id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03620v1 | Self-Discover: Large Language Models Self-Compose Reasoning Structures | 2024-02-06T01:13:53 | 2024-02-06T01:13:53 | Pei Zhou, Jay Pujara, Xiang Ren, Xinyun Chen, Heng-Tze Cheng, Quoc V. Le, Ed H. Chi, Denny Zhou, Swaroop Mishra, Huaixiu Steven Zheng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce SELF-DISCOVER, a general framework for LLMs to self-discover the
task-intrinsic reasoning structures to tackle complex reasoning problems that
are challenging for typical prompting methods. Core to the framework is a
self-discovery process where LLMs select multiple atomic reasoning modules such
as critical thinking and step-by-step thinking, and compose them into an
explicit reasoning structure for LLMs to follow during decoding. SELF-DISCOVER
substantially improves GPT-4 and PaLM 2's performance on challenging reasoning
benchmarks such as BigBench-Hard, grounded agent reasoning, and MATH, by as
much as 32% compared to Chain of Thought (CoT). Furthermore, SELF-DISCOVER
outperforms inference-intensive methods such as CoT-Self-Consistency by more
than 20%, while requiring 10-40x fewer inference compute. Finally, we show that
the self-discovered reasoning structures are universally applicable across
model families: from PaLM 2-L to GPT-4, and from GPT-4 to Llama2, and share
commonalities with human reasoning patterns. | [
-0.2515711486339569,
-0.7112934589385986,
1.0288468599319458,
0.16889867186546326,
0.2612172067165375,
0.024996446445584297,
-0.02254154160618782,
-0.5053995847702026,
0.09249899536371231,
0.48016321659088135,
-0.6483194828033447,
-0.4602765142917633,
-0.28092554211616516,
0.10100440680980682,
-0.1798313707113266,
0.4817943274974823,
-0.13123291730880737,
-0.16368630528450012,
-0.00654700119048357,
0.13120853900909424,
-0.21169382333755493,
-0.7227522730827332,
-0.38162192702293396,
-0.48133450746536255,
0.45052269101142883,
0.5525956153869629,
0.3699841797351837,
0.7590641975402832,
0.12892477214336395,
0.3348172605037689,
-0.011958122253417969,
0.18246592581272125,
-0.23721903562545776,
0.5519486665725708,
-0.7281757593154907,
-0.5661727786064148,
-0.541422963142395,
-0.22010833024978638,
0.44373819231987,
0.5355079770088196,
-0.07865741848945618,
0.10984507948160172,
-0.15735289454460144,
0.9420409798622131,
-0.4513479173183441,
0.2888469099998474,
-0.6055847406387329,
0.09045931696891785,
-0.2472604662179947,
-0.16833460330963135,
-0.4198090136051178,
0.101982481777668,
0.19558921456336975,
-0.41751864552497864,
0.5260835289955139,
0.17814630270004272,
0.17832393944263458,
0.1839962601661682,
-0.6342801451683044,
-0.4097411036491394,
-0.6854392886161804,
0.6164531111717224,
-0.46790093183517456,
0.3214503228664398,
0.39614900946617126,
0.40979069471359253,
-0.3394186198711395,
-0.5240318179130554,
-0.46242547035217285,
-0.3329436779022217,
0.12930980324745178,
-0.010699806734919548,
-0.005869049113243818,
0.17511853575706482,
0.32574087381362915,
0.5081105828285217,
-0.7422879338264465,
0.11841167509555817,
-0.18718338012695312,
-0.47925475239753723,
0.7071551084518433,
0.19704565405845642,
0.2025366872549057,
-0.14739613234996796,
-0.3104780316352844,
0.1612766832113266,
-1.2585173845291138,
-0.30169644951820374,
0.1710672378540039,
0.12255845963954926,
0.12541013956069946,
0.5111256837844849,
-0.45203647017478943,
0.45680859684944153,
0.14029759168624878,
-0.05960190296173096,
0.20577649772167206,
-0.38166266679763794,
-0.14194148778915405,
0.0873313620686531,
0.6846567988395691,
-0.13987982273101807,
0.18662770092487335,
0.06396270543336868,
-0.3711206614971161,
-0.1591801941394806,
-0.036170028150081635,
-0.6784206032752991,
-0.6787872314453125,
0.18572811782360077,
-0.46398141980171204,
0.12230949848890305,
-0.20102298259735107,
-0.16105374693870544,
-0.3970750570297241,
-0.3846220374107361,
0.545219361782074,
-0.294737845659256,
-0.5019961595535278,
0.24862831830978394,
-0.13833947479724884,
0.26297619938850403,
0.6918195486068726,
-1.2190855741500854,
0.22490942478179932,
0.574173092842102,
0.6525594592094421,
-0.08134882152080536,
-0.3317486047744751,
-0.20205891132354736,
0.4384039044380188,
-0.5111768245697021,
1.150929570198059,
-0.3137608766555786,
-0.34053292870521545,
-0.2361644208431244,
-0.15352998673915863,
0.13830316066741943,
-0.6331356763839722,
0.48660534620285034,
-0.30525070428848267,
0.028418274596333504,
-0.7822365164756775,
-0.834416925907135,
-0.1777370721101761,
0.5015034675598145,
-0.6017913818359375,
1.1022645235061646,
0.17052699625492096,
-0.5683218836784363,
-0.09241029620170593,
-0.7774049639701843,
-0.46011030673980713,
0.2023833692073822,
-0.3200647830963135,
-0.1300419718027115,
0.10580918192863464,
0.3403748869895935,
0.641607940196991,
-0.5058106780052185,
0.147917240858078,
-0.40533745288848877,
-0.1872473657131195,
0.050615258514881134,
-0.3618895709514618,
0.46865832805633545,
0.3534916639328003,
-0.7864734530448914,
0.21587786078453064,
-0.514443039894104,
0.06513461470603943,
0.3990934193134308,
-0.15161055326461792,
-0.04369252547621727,
0.09917187690734863,
-0.5994884967803955,
0.19876673817634583,
0.40595242381095886,
-0.4315926134586334,
0.6134798526763916,
-0.40166041254997253,
0.7488909363746643,
0.870924711227417,
-0.014134754426777363,
0.5135625600814819,
-0.17032209038734436,
0.4211367964744568,
0.21210475265979767,
0.06594130396842957,
-0.4743191599845886,
-0.21324773132801056,
-0.8820340633392334,
-0.029784496873617172,
-0.027608538046479225,
0.3290286660194397,
-0.4142666161060333,
0.39222413301467896,
0.043190840631723404,
-0.4894619286060333,
-0.3185810148715973,
0.3177536129951477,
0.4260485768318176,
0.482700377702713,
0.4474422335624695,
0.06879132986068726,
-0.3177110552787781,
-1.077252745628357,
-0.25538480281829834,
-0.1976684182882309,
0.17042626440525055,
0.267844557762146,
0.6191450357437134,
-0.5846569538116455,
0.6575540900230408,
-0.5346013903617859,
-0.1503412276506424,
-0.40687769651412964,
0.041823919862508774,
0.07675912231206894,
0.4756244719028473,
0.23114965856075287,
-0.5456594228744507,
-0.465198814868927,
-0.12126404792070389,
-0.8654094338417053,
0.016097109764814377,
0.018967926502227783,
-0.07110635936260223,
0.2959364652633667,
0.6217961311340332,
-0.6660614609718323,
0.19714698195457458,
0.1844005584716797,
-0.30201786756515503,
0.7995027303695679,
-0.26902031898498535,
-0.11324251443147659,
-0.6890785098075867,
-0.15372446179389954,
-0.3189036548137665,
-0.26934292912483215,
-0.3341951072216034,
0.07172136753797531,
0.14551204442977905,
0.3226056396961212,
-0.09630535542964935,
0.7904567718505859,
-1.0561890602111816,
-0.3793434798717499,
-0.39122700691223145,
0.12081422656774521,
-0.05099577456712723,
0.4239248037338257,
0.009294419549405575,
0.918117880821228,
0.8997172713279724,
-0.7096747756004333,
0.24083024263381958,
0.10162399709224701,
-0.401572585105896,
0.31408601999282837,
-0.6576929688453674,
0.35616204142570496,
-0.12389752268791199,
0.5019746422767639,
-0.8684629201889038,
-0.25373539328575134,
0.15326105058193207,
-0.32123538851737976,
0.11649781465530396,
-0.06725572794675827,
-0.5705021619796753,
-0.5337560772895813,
-0.2147371619939804,
0.45099398493766785,
0.132854625582695,
-0.862033486366272,
0.8568406701087952,
0.39704009890556335,
-0.10478899627923965,
-0.5662347674369812,
-0.40679287910461426,
-0.030419982969760895,
0.044293563812971115,
-0.527611494064331,
0.2693668305873871,
-0.4561706483364105,
-0.024843407794833183,
-0.22788365185260773,
-0.46500536799430847,
0.1286185085773468,
0.2563597559928894,
0.45025914907455444,
-0.07340690493583679,
-0.2813006639480591,
0.47535011172294617,
0.12246136367321014,
-0.12427391856908798,
0.24702022969722748,
-0.5597650408744812,
0.5814887881278992,
-0.5678468346595764,
-0.5939518213272095,
-0.30983760952949524,
0.3968918025493622,
0.3938673138618469,
-0.31118252873420715,
0.18033181130886078,
0.3978725075721741,
-0.3015057146549225,
-0.529726505279541,
-0.8511486053466797,
-0.26808878779411316,
-0.5097444653511047,
0.02954551950097084,
-0.9484096169471741,
-1.2878546714782715,
0.5623899102210999,
-0.24393166601657867,
-0.17967380583286285,
0.8116220235824585,
0.8329412937164307,
-0.08726859092712402,
1.250057578086853,
0.426273375749588,
-0.23903323709964752,
0.12940852344036102,
-0.2762707471847534,
0.13926804065704346,
-0.9057719707489014,
-0.33466359972953796,
-0.3098286986351013,
-0.04347408190369606,
-0.38503021001815796,
-0.4755970537662506,
0.4401489496231079,
0.15135636925697327,
-0.5435968637466431,
0.2451448142528534,
-0.6689162850379944,
0.7293892502784729,
0.7860161066055298,
0.0668754130601883,
0.46295586228370667,
-0.26190176606178284,
-0.4657124876976013,
0.39876678586006165,
-0.6968626379966736,
-0.42487800121307373,
1.2363488674163818,
0.4009692072868347,
0.8585628867149353,
0.3230920135974884,
1.1131666898727417,
0.3308241367340088,
0.3680802285671234,
-0.6611825823783875,
0.6094670295715332,
0.38456985354423523,
-1.0010454654693604,
-0.43768563866615295,
-0.5284767746925354,
-1.040720820426941,
0.22362007200717926,
0.11227516829967499,
-0.7031699419021606,
-0.23022377490997314,
0.4077586233615875,
-0.3466874957084656,
0.18112972378730774,
-0.6492787003517151,
0.7608448266983032,
-0.45954567193984985,
-0.23111259937286377,
-0.5835652351379395,
-0.7118057608604431,
0.48533669114112854,
0.15988212823867798,
0.08058033138513565,
-0.2871447801589966,
0.16957159340381622,
0.495322048664093,
-0.2271631509065628,
0.857529878616333,
-0.09658724069595337,
-0.42375773191452026,
0.7350972890853882,
0.5801949501037598,
0.5101592540740967,
0.08881010860204697,
0.013072139583528042,
-0.14525745809078217,
0.026972796767950058,
-0.29101502895355225,
-0.8463213443756104,
0.8666913509368896,
-0.7657930254936218,
-1.045502781867981,
-0.5861926078796387,
-0.4215506911277771,
-0.11502817273139954,
0.38074368238449097,
0.20937417447566986,
0.410424143075943,
-0.14876335859298706,
-0.0043683238327503204,
0.8507598638534546,
0.24429915845394135,
0.2387259155511856,
0.810630202293396,
-0.24716641008853912,
-0.20786726474761963,
0.6719231605529785,
0.10520486533641815,
0.21833562850952148,
0.6302796602249146,
0.4209710359573364,
-0.6589951515197754,
-0.5330936312675476,
-0.356639564037323,
0.4069206416606903,
-0.9650193452835083,
-0.31290721893310547,
-0.6935819387435913,
-0.23360981047153473,
-0.4508696496486664,
0.013386912643909454,
-0.5303119421005249,
-0.550064742565155,
-0.1315649151802063,
-0.42631909251213074,
-0.011028137989342213,
1.0738098621368408,
-0.4124119281768799,
0.12111463397741318,
-0.6647293567657471,
0.3566233217716217,
0.5506412386894226,
0.24308788776397705,
0.21552737057209015,
-0.26152095198631287,
-0.044477786868810654,
-0.08912868052721024,
-0.4833615720272064,
-0.7916445732116699,
0.16028448939323425,
-0.06580059975385666,
0.7669930458068848,
0.44406405091285706,
0.03553212434053421,
0.4886631667613983,
-0.48047980666160583,
0.6135726571083069,
0.13521966338157654,
-1.3061496019363403,
0.7249809503555298,
-0.4757023751735687,
0.2905847728252411,
0.2505473792552948,
0.404471755027771,
-0.20099671185016632,
0.020494256168603897,
-0.8590324521064758,
-0.55268394947052,
0.251323938369751,
0.08178986608982086,
-0.2053450047969818,
-0.1771223396062851,
0.5601016879081726,
0.015583938919007778,
0.050832636654376984,
-0.9123085737228394,
-0.19648277759552002,
-0.09818150848150253,
-0.07105810195207596,
-0.030452368780970573,
-0.491136372089386,
-0.24527622759342194,
-0.3104654550552368,
0.5496653318405151,
-0.5187112092971802,
0.3675484359264374,
0.7373563647270203,
-0.21251854300498962,
-0.12516385316848755,
0.36276334524154663,
0.4586802124977112,
0.6625365018844604,
0.014196671545505524,
0.6315668821334839,
0.12041617929935455,
0.145573228597641,
0.28232675790786743,
-0.23308436572551727,
0.13480204343795776,
-0.4472360610961914,
0.510286808013916,
0.5317997336387634,
0.2718527317047119,
-0.7067970633506775,
0.3414662480354309,
0.14917296171188354,
-0.2637186646461487,
-0.5765558481216431,
0.4302234351634979,
0.26094678044319153,
0.5603750944137573,
0.33226338028907776,
-0.2801380157470703,
0.4631733298301697,
-0.9168846011161804,
0.11598047614097595,
0.557090163230896,
-0.03879917785525322,
-0.4036225974559784,
0.5304103493690491,
0.16772590577602386,
-0.08292300999164581,
0.5665041208267212,
-0.45090776681900024,
-0.9313790798187256,
0.4173847734928131,
0.8658109307289124,
0.7819865942001343,
-0.4653744399547577,
0.23533564805984497,
0.3711884915828705,
0.2614537179470062,
-0.5071364045143127,
0.414976567029953,
-0.6536146402359009,
-0.9761016368865967,
-0.39265093207359314,
-0.2463027685880661,
-0.5937327742576599,
-0.06983093917369843,
-0.4074699878692627,
-0.17158077657222748,
-0.6495689153671265,
0.07765421271324158,
0.052155617624521255,
0.20144619047641754,
-0.49609681963920593,
0.1521671712398529,
0.21139682829380035,
0.8221856355667114,
-0.4686564803123474,
0.8378818035125732,
0.33001190423965454,
-0.11005796492099762,
-1.0848925113677979,
-0.33968883752822876,
0.2693265676498413,
-0.9313467144966125,
0.7109375,
0.4565282464027405,
-0.3966054320335388,
0.1321231722831726,
-0.7733283042907715,
-1.1663347482681274,
1.265480875968933,
0.24690809845924377,
-0.7348729372024536,
-0.09775976836681366,
-0.25466880202293396,
0.40093377232551575,
-0.46456271409988403,
0.4018794298171997,
0.5662326216697693,
0.47759079933166504,
0.3039257228374481,
-0.941863477230072,
0.24234411120414734,
-0.07265909761190414,
-0.3806459605693817,
0.34987130761146545,
-0.6608105897903442,
0.9770583510398865,
-0.6093499660491943,
-0.26480334997177124,
0.028838220983743668,
0.8071754574775696,
0.5306124687194824,
0.2551339268684387,
0.39279454946517944,
0.47395560145378113,
1.0438710451126099,
0.10784085094928741,
0.8517383337020874,
-0.2512759268283844,
0.34661558270454407,
1.156893253326416,
-0.4601503014564514,
0.7367368340492249,
-0.08998340368270874,
-0.14993208646774292,
0.8206395506858826,
0.5634579658508301,
0.037004537880420685,
0.09949135780334473,
0.3067459464073181,
-0.21389225125312805,
-0.6959923505783081,
0.34305182099342346,
-0.4590147137641907,
0.3755660653114319,
0.6435682773590088,
-0.17123475670814514,
-0.18153239786624908,
-0.32264742255210876,
0.037749312818050385,
-0.02834697812795639,
-0.4460699260234833,
0.6495947241783142,
0.22960682213306427,
-0.8873095512390137,
0.5635126233100891,
0.04131060466170311,
0.272376149892807,
-0.491624653339386,
-0.005075383000075817,
-0.17218397557735443,
0.26399022340774536,
-0.2290806621313095,
-0.9832345843315125,
0.08434461057186127,
-0.5223493576049805,
-0.2744036018848419,
-0.2533136010169983,
0.9376358985900879,
-0.33349621295928955,
-0.20298604667186737,
0.4914104640483856,
0.873780369758606,
0.18595948815345764,
-0.5514687299728394,
-0.7355976700782776,
-0.18527492880821228,
0.06241226941347122,
-0.33056575059890747,
0.3502514362335205,
0.6447731256484985,
-0.10547473281621933,
1.2104021310806274,
0.6754498481750488,
-0.2377490997314453,
-0.0706910565495491,
0.1225183755159378,
0.9394384026527405,
-1.1862339973449707,
-0.46357637643814087,
-0.8841122984886169,
0.0856596902012825,
0.011443127878010273,
-0.0793672651052475,
0.8973167538642883,
0.6964325904846191,
0.5980762839317322,
-0.06393207609653473,
0.9008225798606873,
0.24059055745601654,
0.6886597275733948,
-0.669222354888916,
0.3177083134651184,
-0.27432945370674133,
0.2664066553115845,
-0.07928328216075897,
-0.8925355076789856,
-0.11217043548822403,
0.7535598278045654,
-0.3013644814491272,
-0.030846459791064262,
0.783295750617981,
0.7722465395927429,
0.11267448961734772,
0.11062487959861755,
0.22022230923175812,
0.43346062302589417,
0.5915669202804565,
0.7978556156158447,
1.0224782228469849,
-0.08624248951673508,
0.16521427035331726,
0.03672241419553757,
-0.2532525658607483,
-0.07632376253604889,
-0.7743057012557983,
-1.1639176607131958,
-0.7131028175354004,
-0.16974025964736938,
-0.2105829268693924,
-0.15756767988204956,
1.0115493535995483,
0.7764403223991394,
-0.6946951150894165,
-0.3194480240345001,
-0.37346145510673523,
0.5021824240684509,
-0.05841542035341263,
-0.19971956312656403,
0.3562721014022827,
-0.41116946935653687,
-0.3776257038116455,
0.9704442024230957,
0.5270063877105713,
0.17762158811092377,
-0.5840911269187927,
-0.13511167466640472,
0.028839875012636185,
-0.002112270100042224,
0.7781500220298767,
0.5873888731002808,
-0.8792930841445923,
-0.3099479675292969,
0.04121928662061691,
0.06336159259080887,
0.05791488289833069,
1.0604424476623535,
-0.8757004141807556,
0.3272753655910492,
0.30727240443229675,
0.40235236287117004,
0.7938650250434875,
-0.028172990307211876,
0.6117769479751587,
-0.2544562518596649,
-0.1497879922389984,
0.3699926435947418,
0.6013275384902954,
0.2493075728416443,
-0.3819909989833832,
0.6914522051811218,
0.23844760656356812,
-0.8676016330718994,
-0.5834356546401978,
0.7778897285461426,
-1.034352421760559,
-0.48802828788757324,
1.1133159399032593,
-0.03855019435286522,
-0.17480303347110748,
-0.13630272448062897,
-0.23923806846141815,
-0.20089294016361237,
-0.26961541175842285,
0.7362086772918701,
0.51212078332901,
-0.5245290398597717,
-0.34018775820732117,
-0.15155217051506042,
0.6339527368545532,
0.4208199679851532,
-0.8870823979377747,
0.17212213575839996,
0.5793634057044983,
0.628912627696991,
0.2416238784790039,
0.9957779049873352,
-0.05304114520549774,
0.1286540925502777,
-0.16802027821540833,
0.0021219681948423386,
-0.06354211270809174,
-0.7668827176094055,
0.00934521108865738,
0.1978275179862976,
0.21542014181613922,
0.38535478711128235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03618v1 | Comparing Abstraction in Humans and Large Language Models Using Multimodal Serial Reproduction | 2024-02-06T01:07:56 | 2024-02-06T01:07:56 | Sreejan Kumar, Raja Marjieh, Byron Zhang, Declan Campbell, Michael Y. Hu, Umang Bhatt, Brenden Lake, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Humans extract useful abstractions of the world from noisy sensory data.
Serial reproduction allows us to study how people construe the world through a
paradigm similar to the game of telephone, where one person observes a stimulus
and reproduces it for the next to form a chain of reproductions. Past serial
reproduction experiments typically employ a single sensory modality, but humans
often communicate abstractions of the world to each other through language. To
investigate the effect language on the formation of abstractions, we implement
a novel multimodal serial reproduction framework by asking people who receive a
visual stimulus to reproduce it in a linguistic format, and vice versa. We ran
unimodal and multimodal chains with both humans and GPT-4 and find that adding
language as a modality has a larger effect on human reproductions than GPT-4's.
This suggests human visual and linguistic representations are more dissociable
than those of GPT-4. | [
-0.44317004084587097,
-0.6095250248908997,
0.5701568126678467,
0.5043150186538696,
-0.3166990280151367,
0.30587542057037354,
-0.20811139047145844,
-0.8852255344390869,
-0.018564272671937943,
0.053143177181482315,
-0.07074257731437683,
-0.07105977833271027,
-0.40823471546173096,
0.23000724613666534,
-0.3760264217853546,
0.6241171360015869,
0.27793973684310913,
0.18736359477043152,
-0.4369381368160248,
0.045399267226457596,
-0.128212109208107,
-0.8940197825431824,
-0.6893469095230103,
-0.4942421317100525,
0.605151355266571,
-0.13955087959766388,
0.7019370794296265,
0.6592738628387451,
0.34961557388305664,
0.5010070204734802,
-0.0359640046954155,
0.06107203662395477,
-0.2598220109939575,
0.05923554673790932,
-0.09279203414916992,
-0.3720461428165436,
-0.3184618651866913,
0.0771334171295166,
0.6774162650108337,
0.8615652918815613,
0.011453153565526009,
-0.11738093197345734,
0.11527001112699509,
0.4730827510356903,
-0.4063808023929596,
0.35305702686309814,
-0.13596680760383606,
0.10310535877943039,
-0.27155351638793945,
-0.31289297342300415,
-0.3556049168109894,
-0.15380719304084778,
0.07983513921499252,
-0.5083854794502258,
0.05968617647886276,
-0.1141933724284172,
0.5059410929679871,
-0.0037826241459697485,
-0.6111806631088257,
-0.26069462299346924,
-1.0721242427825928,
0.5285391211509705,
-0.6642962694168091,
0.7692765593528748,
0.3810593783855438,
-0.29164227843284607,
-0.1248486191034317,
-0.6901306509971619,
-0.8414517641067505,
-0.5962533354759216,
-0.29132959246635437,
0.19781586527824402,
-0.10195808112621307,
0.2665748596191406,
0.5205916166305542,
0.12402525544166565,
-0.47830575704574585,
-0.2555716931819916,
-0.7510102391242981,
-0.22298838198184967,
0.3622036576271057,
-0.011133497580885887,
0.5331583619117737,
-0.19882196187973022,
-0.49662289023399353,
0.0349946953356266,
-0.2444484531879425,
-0.09696277976036072,
0.6697801351547241,
-0.044503286480903625,
0.012229247950017452,
0.16489320993423462,
0.010507294908165932,
0.7438640594482422,
0.05698511376976967,
-0.22782188653945923,
0.5539035201072693,
-0.5071767568588257,
0.07662121951580048,
-0.2771089971065521,
0.9253571629524231,
0.6018105149269104,
0.12646807730197906,
-0.38404738903045654,
-0.20449897646903992,
0.47447916865348816,
0.19070489704608917,
-0.8036597371101379,
-0.06123415380716324,
-0.08658546954393387,
-0.6241264939308167,
-0.23414768278598785,
0.06497158855199814,
-0.689122200012207,
-0.3866441547870636,
-0.4354526698589325,
0.43907973170280457,
-0.32967662811279297,
-0.47226354479789734,
0.22628282010555267,
-0.44057732820510864,
0.047846533358097076,
0.12176310271024704,
-1.1535166501998901,
0.6868315935134888,
0.5563586950302124,
0.9417383670806885,
-0.14739061892032623,
-0.6690617799758911,
-0.08896654099225998,
-0.10174699127674103,
-0.5053278207778931,
0.8343914747238159,
-0.43232250213623047,
-0.3419056534767151,
-0.5373309850692749,
-0.1982959657907486,
0.18278004229068756,
-0.8431104421615601,
0.2260037213563919,
-0.5418095588684082,
0.30988770723342896,
-0.2752215564250946,
-0.2619210481643677,
-0.16919200122356415,
0.07489840686321259,
-0.7990756630897522,
0.5802301168441772,
0.18966534733772278,
-0.5156792402267456,
0.46624481678009033,
-0.7028162479400635,
-0.36765143275260925,
0.09426284581422806,
-0.4430975914001465,
-0.2556891441345215,
0.15273135900497437,
-0.16477155685424805,
0.2636182904243469,
-0.24144108593463898,
0.00967385247349739,
-0.17512932419776917,
-0.29986372590065,
0.5268681049346924,
-0.4797878563404083,
0.5159701704978943,
0.21576102077960968,
-0.42230895161628723,
-0.005839288700371981,
-0.5488185286521912,
-0.10755627602338791,
0.018948739394545555,
-0.5482150316238403,
-0.4622422754764557,
0.2389727234840393,
0.0835806131362915,
0.6097243428230286,
0.041019778698682785,
-0.5611898899078369,
0.13311654329299927,
-0.24538984894752502,
0.7399876713752747,
0.47892871499061584,
0.2413090616464615,
0.5683864951133728,
-0.5072226524353027,
0.3451428711414337,
0.6813239455223083,
0.201104074716568,
-0.2283642441034317,
-0.62998366355896,
-0.38609009981155396,
-0.23381544649600983,
0.10488799959421158,
0.2226942926645279,
-0.5323081016540527,
-0.18655091524124146,
-0.264392226934433,
-0.19786013662815094,
-0.18293645977973938,
0.3206416964530945,
0.5285321474075317,
0.041374001652002335,
0.03056100383400917,
-0.7288398742675781,
-0.511206328868866,
-1.0035675764083862,
0.08131710439920425,
-0.23682595789432526,
-0.03653246536850929,
0.2647268772125244,
0.39958077669143677,
-0.2697902023792267,
0.8581157326698303,
-0.27043911814689636,
-0.14879263937473297,
0.01116272620856762,
0.5070928931236267,
-0.22230297327041626,
0.4229625463485718,
0.7522441148757935,
-0.8262853026390076,
-0.16369089484214783,
0.13102833926677704,
-1.0231879949569702,
0.2809169590473175,
-0.12301305681467056,
0.043762173503637314,
0.25499412417411804,
0.36296555399894714,
-0.6399732232093811,
0.46844035387039185,
0.5460208654403687,
-0.47158071398735046,
0.539771318435669,
-0.3880155384540558,
0.4887130856513977,
-0.9743346571922302,
-0.13600268959999084,
-0.193699449300766,
-0.2945082485675812,
-0.6100383400917053,
-0.0700555294752121,
0.010865364223718643,
-0.09167464822530746,
-0.39762094616889954,
0.27094462513923645,
-0.8165601491928101,
-0.5417235493659973,
-0.1468130201101303,
0.07380039989948273,
-0.11024610698223114,
0.6192147135734558,
0.07646796107292175,
0.7773259282112122,
0.41554325819015503,
-0.5792202353477478,
0.45405977964401245,
0.0877784863114357,
-0.5010353326797485,
0.2684462070465088,
-0.6955464482307434,
0.29909437894821167,
-0.29625317454338074,
0.21562154591083527,
-1.0204683542251587,
-0.32691559195518494,
0.1881219446659088,
-0.3832876980304718,
-0.07835391163825989,
0.1469532698392868,
-0.4101659059524536,
-0.34583568572998047,
-0.3260265588760376,
0.844377875328064,
0.6359872221946716,
-0.26415061950683594,
0.4925547242164612,
0.19217464327812195,
-0.2525898814201355,
-0.42467573285102844,
-0.7474364042282104,
0.14221462607383728,
-0.1801896095275879,
-0.579993486404419,
0.07870232313871384,
-0.1514718383550644,
-0.5511268973350525,
-0.09730213135480881,
0.007165113463997841,
-0.20272548496723175,
0.01831556297838688,
0.345786988735199,
0.18091638386249542,
-0.04370198771357536,
0.2265201210975647,
-0.10820766538381577,
0.01835104636847973,
0.23448117077350616,
-0.11741498112678528,
0.6691508889198303,
-0.21368630230426788,
-0.42268064618110657,
-0.5611647367477417,
0.6373147964477539,
0.9207969903945923,
-0.21856610476970673,
0.4496409296989441,
0.2312670797109604,
-0.25842076539993286,
0.19914491474628448,
-0.39550843834877014,
-0.36156517267227173,
-0.47739824652671814,
0.5993742346763611,
-0.4824163019657135,
-0.41316622495651245,
0.5671973824501038,
-0.14993155002593994,
-0.09104526787996292,
-0.16572925448417664,
0.6399485468864441,
0.05267053097486496,
1.044363260269165,
0.317825049161911,
0.08394976705312729,
0.5334176421165466,
-0.3559624254703522,
0.04101113975048065,
-0.7074139714241028,
-0.18230439722537994,
-0.13234609365463257,
-0.5322032570838928,
-0.2829797863960266,
-0.5823068022727966,
0.1441042572259903,
0.34157177805900574,
-0.43792757391929626,
0.03787125647068024,
-0.39092761278152466,
0.5679931044578552,
0.4366995692253113,
0.3604917824268341,
0.7770294547080994,
0.12447113543748856,
-0.04137296974658966,
-0.18664011359214783,
-0.31056350469589233,
-0.6537074446678162,
0.9695442914962769,
0.07268919050693512,
0.6880065202713013,
0.42960265278816223,
0.6674810647964478,
0.24495412409305573,
0.3956444561481476,
-0.7682256102561951,
0.43890517950057983,
-0.12782686948776245,
-0.4992915689945221,
-0.10655435919761658,
-0.43802517652511597,
-1.1214768886566162,
0.279233455657959,
-0.09573166817426682,
-0.7671037912368774,
0.544683575630188,
0.1931181699037552,
-0.26793116331100464,
0.18684443831443787,
-0.788832426071167,
0.7315266728401184,
-0.3930630385875702,
-0.3896137475967407,
-0.09969336539506912,
-0.5613001585006714,
0.4410534203052521,
-0.17355290055274963,
0.5745590329170227,
0.1681477278470993,
-0.4517609775066376,
0.639595091342926,
-0.18345597386360168,
0.8794794082641602,
-0.040699541568756104,
-0.3249448239803314,
0.15254944562911987,
0.1578378975391388,
-0.00978446938097477,
-0.07434730976819992,
0.1816561073064804,
0.2052818387746811,
-0.14136198163032532,
-0.2474488914012909,
-0.8238123655319214,
0.6260117888450623,
-1.1679325103759766,
-0.45919010043144226,
-0.3966001272201538,
-0.6332153081893921,
-0.05686837062239647,
0.21930958330631256,
0.3425116240978241,
0.8467031717300415,
-0.18384139239788055,
-0.09131273627281189,
0.1282218098640442,
-0.04110107943415642,
0.8006101250648499,
0.26674893498420715,
-0.6978954672813416,
-0.3410584032535553,
0.9335347414016724,
0.037949271500110626,
0.8122950792312622,
0.11718969792127609,
0.19995781779289246,
-0.2862775921821594,
-0.35867029428482056,
-0.40252363681793213,
0.3131618797779083,
-0.5254076719284058,
0.059094540774822235,
-0.6928727626800537,
-0.022728988900780678,
-0.10590909421443939,
0.2290067970752716,
-0.28106051683425903,
-0.1969950795173645,
-0.025096412748098373,
0.030248533934354782,
0.2934926152229309,
1.2077760696411133,
-0.4612942934036255,
0.04055532440543175,
-0.743855357170105,
0.4632880985736847,
0.7122825384140015,
0.40411993861198425,
0.19288405776023865,
-0.3157564401626587,
-0.04765363782644272,
0.3621830940246582,
-0.3664342164993286,
-0.9062162637710571,
0.2318069040775299,
0.3452453315258026,
0.2494584619998932,
0.4923977851867676,
-0.37641778588294983,
0.9827535152435303,
-0.6125924587249756,
0.8450603485107422,
0.43896424770355225,
-1.0343201160430908,
-0.07551368325948715,
-0.6135384440422058,
0.23462221026420593,
0.01266922615468502,
0.40456727147102356,
-0.7416165471076965,
-0.29826071858406067,
-0.5089294910430908,
-0.7463906407356262,
0.6592325568199158,
0.08908693492412567,
0.35884907841682434,
-0.348823606967926,
0.2443634420633316,
0.0362740121781826,
0.292904794216156,
-0.9078950881958008,
-0.39893466234207153,
-0.18870480358600616,
0.2702489197254181,
-0.21785829961299896,
-0.30519339442253113,
-0.0777396410703659,
-0.2912442088127136,
-0.08099294453859329,
0.2400878518819809,
0.614447832107544,
0.1347779631614685,
0.005641281604766846,
-0.20246396958827972,
0.32199209928512573,
0.7811133861541748,
0.8603330254554749,
-0.057559993118047714,
0.3749297261238098,
-0.27893659472465515,
-0.6480188965797424,
0.563966691493988,
-0.2913752794265747,
-0.10242035984992981,
0.0335499607026577,
0.5085973143577576,
0.7051553726196289,
0.33070608973503113,
-0.6600769758224487,
0.6685644388198853,
-0.19542182981967926,
-0.590660810470581,
-0.23649978637695312,
-0.24675194919109344,
0.4959481954574585,
0.3251131772994995,
0.3818860650062561,
0.482206791639328,
0.28419652581214905,
-0.9152206182479858,
0.21303947269916534,
0.22226418554782867,
-0.006429965607821941,
-0.5803937911987305,
0.709064245223999,
0.21607519686222076,
-0.5131626725196838,
0.7218868732452393,
-0.5211564898490906,
-0.4514843225479126,
0.298420250415802,
0.8555643558502197,
0.5485588312149048,
-0.2521318197250366,
0.2257823348045349,
0.2665713429450989,
0.09406138956546783,
-0.33290085196495056,
0.39168819785118103,
-0.10117821395397186,
-0.9727926254272461,
-0.7777901887893677,
-0.4736865758895874,
-0.06018110737204552,
0.14677946269512177,
-0.7001181244850159,
-0.2647416591644287,
-0.37765008211135864,
-0.24474170804023743,
0.2335628867149353,
-0.5537221431732178,
-0.4756857752799988,
-0.2598187029361725,
0.30301567912101746,
0.14561158418655396,
-1.014583706855774,
0.5031601786613464,
0.9513916373252869,
-0.6751134395599365,
-0.7782703638076782,
-0.050775621086359024,
-0.15401791036128998,
-0.22779688239097595,
1.260609745979309,
0.05919254571199417,
-0.2729348838329315,
0.19979694485664368,
-0.3440069854259491,
-0.7817983627319336,
0.8863139748573303,
0.6300525069236755,
-0.5083642601966858,
-0.0038706958293914795,
0.1327890008687973,
0.6749790906906128,
0.015565709210932255,
0.34302520751953125,
0.6341940760612488,
0.41839727759361267,
0.07620739936828613,
-1.1950631141662598,
-0.023385802283883095,
-0.3016698658466339,
0.285704106092453,
0.39807647466659546,
-0.5012540817260742,
1.160627841949463,
-0.3054056763648987,
-0.5575131773948669,
0.1858421266078949,
0.3779766857624054,
0.05374535173177719,
-0.008236655965447426,
0.6011372804641724,
0.5001705288887024,
0.5682413578033447,
0.004866237752139568,
0.9764105081558228,
-0.17944183945655823,
0.2968822121620178,
0.9610861539840698,
-0.15549015998840332,
0.8577243089675903,
0.5181834697723389,
-0.45709675550460815,
0.689347505569458,
0.24714024364948273,
0.4323781728744507,
0.29834896326065063,
0.3491830825805664,
-0.5801541805267334,
-0.1545475423336029,
0.11245524883270264,
-0.29571759700775146,
0.7359905242919922,
0.19063237309455872,
-0.22672007977962494,
-0.19014893472194672,
0.5202494859695435,
-0.0857824832201004,
0.20672200620174408,
-0.12627603113651276,
0.9704415798187256,
0.014660228975117207,
-0.4188520014286041,
0.7103469371795654,
-0.3258223235607147,
0.8479634523391724,
-0.36761343479156494,
-0.10973233729600906,
-0.3355139493942261,
0.31447193026542664,
-0.35536906123161316,
-0.3862490952014923,
0.25706860423088074,
-0.22047322988510132,
-0.34104588627815247,
-0.21452262997627258,
0.26994794607162476,
-0.575410783290863,
-0.25122368335723877,
0.4921964406967163,
0.7205619215965271,
0.46359503269195557,
-0.051503319293260574,
-0.6194382309913635,
0.23040972650051117,
-0.05233333259820938,
-0.1556338220834732,
0.36254194378852844,
0.4635002315044403,
-0.12843281030654907,
0.6754880547523499,
0.7508987188339233,
0.14702476561069489,
0.2800717055797577,
0.17995744943618774,
0.7718172669410706,
-0.8595139384269714,
-0.32608529925346375,
-1.045883297920227,
0.42689016461372375,
-0.09196066856384277,
-0.22514468431472778,
0.6321284770965576,
0.7914047837257385,
0.7099571824073792,
-0.35244324803352356,
0.7468500733375549,
-0.20544171333312988,
0.14564107358455658,
-0.07549315690994263,
0.5214834809303284,
-0.4357766807079315,
0.08875498175621033,
-0.5960621237754822,
-0.9476344585418701,
-0.20415474474430084,
0.6856598258018494,
-0.11065617203712463,
0.22189299762248993,
0.9752490520477295,
0.8206226825714111,
-0.17045587301254272,
-0.10249902307987213,
0.5505409836769104,
0.41181281208992004,
0.2327796071767807,
0.31668293476104736,
1.2936087846755981,
-0.16293857991695404,
0.41873425245285034,
-0.3109586834907532,
-0.39986956119537354,
0.32486045360565186,
-0.7513819336891174,
-0.6655491590499878,
-0.8721320033073425,
-0.07513591647148132,
-0.06383638083934784,
-0.11201202124357224,
0.9786602854728699,
0.6423302292823792,
-0.29801374673843384,
-0.6053234934806824,
-0.062226034700870514,
-0.2839953303337097,
-0.4475472867488861,
-0.25651368498802185,
0.11636439710855484,
-0.2635546028614044,
-0.998409628868103,
0.1450403332710266,
0.47147834300994873,
0.2632337808609009,
-0.46814122796058655,
0.05213767662644386,
-0.158945694565773,
-0.28562262654304504,
0.9709358811378479,
0.16659051179885864,
-0.7435389161109924,
-0.21032819151878357,
-0.07078877836465836,
-0.04566061869263649,
0.15172703564167023,
0.9778782725334167,
-0.8912336826324463,
0.6183252334594727,
0.40319716930389404,
0.3218010663986206,
0.33842504024505615,
0.07525131106376648,
0.8385922312736511,
-0.6485264301300049,
0.5061464905738831,
0.18730732798576355,
0.31568655371665955,
0.3796622157096863,
-0.13356973230838776,
0.22876521944999695,
0.49405351281166077,
-0.6282915472984314,
-0.4714869260787964,
0.3186526894569397,
-1.1114840507507324,
-0.2851002514362335,
1.0582196712493896,
0.039656903594732285,
-0.08035020530223846,
-0.548305094242096,
-0.47513505816459656,
0.07526380568742752,
-0.5186895728111267,
0.6640803813934326,
0.6828054785728455,
-0.2852131426334381,
-0.1412411779165268,
-0.541166365146637,
0.5020879507064819,
-0.00017349206609651446,
-0.7618502378463745,
0.06857277452945709,
0.7118971347808838,
0.37889543175697327,
0.4624767303466797,
0.8690314888954163,
-0.2714909315109253,
0.35946324467658997,
0.2689847946166992,
0.20369555056095123,
-0.15163396298885345,
0.1898665577173233,
-0.1444711536169052,
0.025463402271270752,
0.20065681636333466,
-0.25709423422813416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03616v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Hybrid Workplace Decision Support | 2024-02-06T01:05:14 | 2024-02-06T01:05:14 | Yujin Kim, Chin-Chia Hsu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR | Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to perform a variety of text
processing tasks and provide textual explanations for proposed actions or
decisions. In the era of hybrid work, LLMs can provide intelligent decision
support for workers who are designing their hybrid work plans. In particular,
they can offer suggestions and explanations to workers balancing numerous
decision factors, thereby enhancing their work experience. In this paper, we
present a decision support model for workspaces in hybrid work environments,
leveraging the reasoning skill of LLMs. We first examine LLM's capability of
making suitable workspace suggestions. We find that its reasoning extends
beyond the guidelines in the prompt and the LLM can manage the trade-off among
the available resources in the workspaces. We conduct an extensive user study
to understand workers' decision process for workspace choices and evaluate the
effectiveness of the system. We observe that a worker's decision could be
influenced by the LLM's suggestions and explanations. The participants in our
study find the system to be convenient, regardless of whether reasons are
provided or not. Our results show that employees can benefit from the
LLM-empowered system for their workspace selection in hybrid workplace. | [
-0.2835110127925873,
-0.5720826983451843,
1.0533056259155273,
0.357753723859787,
-0.2812938690185547,
0.09807297587394714,
-0.4293389618396759,
-0.6960009932518005,
0.19076883792877197,
0.6634675860404968,
-0.6018582582473755,
-0.34183934330940247,
-0.1583782434463501,
0.3184926211833954,
-0.1622723489999771,
0.627288281917572,
-0.31651565432548523,
0.0662330836057663,
-0.5803626775741577,
-0.06202716752886772,
-0.9106751084327698,
-0.4331100583076477,
-0.5792654156684875,
-0.7060286998748779,
0.5883781313896179,
0.460498183965683,
0.9684162139892578,
0.17117321491241455,
0.022736066952347755,
0.36579811573028564,
-0.22635309398174286,
0.3315195143222809,
-0.18005312979221344,
0.041652530431747437,
-0.4707719087600708,
-0.5795868635177612,
-0.46533477306365967,
-0.3482905328273773,
0.4179253876209259,
0.8009542226791382,
-0.29951128363609314,
-0.13343137502670288,
-0.012134673073887825,
0.39074015617370605,
-0.259766548871994,
-0.014764565043151379,
-0.3910605311393738,
0.3614404797554016,
-0.15498089790344238,
0.07837497442960739,
-0.5631112456321716,
-0.0883135050535202,
-0.06881589442491531,
-0.44528132677078247,
-0.2800230383872986,
0.3093363642692566,
0.1677265763282776,
0.1849556267261505,
-0.4448573887348175,
0.16948871314525604,
-1.066366195678711,
0.6912027597427368,
-0.712302029132843,
0.49176928400993347,
0.24963825941085815,
0.18131865561008453,
-0.2457403689622879,
-0.3185766935348511,
-0.7658771276473999,
-0.29306647181510925,
-0.3099859654903412,
0.10042382031679153,
-0.029000980779528618,
0.31579750776290894,
0.3286076486110687,
0.4407494366168976,
-0.49494364857673645,
0.657375693321228,
-0.24572288990020752,
-0.11330325156450272,
0.506818950176239,
0.31142252683639526,
0.3922177255153656,
0.04397256672382355,
-0.38321542739868164,
0.19856734573841095,
-0.42033326625823975,
-0.2569705843925476,
-0.000936828029807657,
0.040190380066633224,
0.1075698509812355,
0.8855032920837402,
-0.21247181296348572,
0.9715524315834045,
-0.2882654070854187,
-0.35854464769363403,
0.05349888652563095,
-0.26879701018333435,
-0.34022513031959534,
-0.31738772988319397,
0.7621334791183472,
0.09925645589828491,
-0.039539411664009094,
-0.4871964156627655,
-0.29434865713119507,
0.25252261757850647,
0.17700593173503876,
-0.2462538629770279,
0.21143768727779388,
0.28341829776763916,
-0.7211511135101318,
-0.057509370148181915,
-0.28669029474258423,
-0.44448819756507874,
-0.7826907634735107,
-0.7568922638893127,
0.17465701699256897,
-0.2559387683868408,
-0.5975050926208496,
0.29315829277038574,
-0.37693703174591064,
-0.10440967977046967,
0.8447638154029846,
-0.5292593240737915,
0.23259854316711426,
0.3378773331642151,
0.8554832339286804,
-0.5220901966094971,
-0.36351248621940613,
-0.27219340205192566,
0.2693101167678833,
-0.2083425670862198,
0.6788933873176575,
-0.6990014910697937,
-0.5949403643608093,
0.14977875351905823,
-0.2834196984767914,
-0.23610755801200867,
-0.7981242537498474,
0.5506478548049927,
-0.49637115001678467,
0.31244194507598877,
-0.21628108620643616,
-0.3950720727443695,
-0.20313332974910736,
0.1722065508365631,
-0.7716387510299683,
0.9932489395141602,
0.005861423444002867,
-0.7746208906173706,
0.48304426670074463,
-1.0558425188064575,
-0.5087870955467224,
0.5625572800636292,
-0.37483060359954834,
-0.13090477883815765,
0.08412396162748337,
-0.16729485988616943,
0.5520399808883667,
0.032074443995952606,
0.29822707176208496,
-0.48619988560676575,
-0.09568849205970764,
0.2946954369544983,
0.06777908653020859,
0.7185640931129456,
0.21780963242053986,
-0.16337443888187408,
0.40424755215644836,
-0.3639209568500519,
-0.1934576779603958,
0.07938914000988007,
-0.6958109140396118,
-0.3082249164581299,
0.2603951692581177,
0.051289357244968414,
0.40255483984947205,
0.44354987144470215,
-0.5193850994110107,
0.1691371500492096,
0.15350349247455597,
0.14403431117534637,
0.7167138457298279,
-0.4076736271381378,
0.4757901728153229,
-0.5113958120346069,
0.7361490726470947,
-0.16578319668769836,
0.029347533360123634,
0.3720000088214874,
-0.5456928610801697,
-0.44869810342788696,
-0.4730003774166107,
-0.1009945198893547,
0.7170507311820984,
-1.1494468450546265,
0.4937630295753479,
0.08218526095151901,
-0.30848395824432373,
-0.03252595290541649,
0.2948770225048065,
0.1909528374671936,
0.2745608985424042,
0.12415285408496857,
0.26547765731811523,
-0.6932173371315002,
-0.9667792916297913,
-0.3750348687171936,
-0.030904218554496765,
-0.0021260676439851522,
0.4016197621822357,
0.5015443563461304,
-0.5311261415481567,
1.1860467195510864,
-0.3382461369037628,
-0.05925457552075386,
-0.7710230350494385,
-0.20042940974235535,
0.39876508712768555,
0.14982357621192932,
0.3262574374675751,
-1.0522183179855347,
-0.41704121232032776,
0.13180238008499146,
-0.7200467586517334,
-0.2355506420135498,
-0.4308260977268219,
-0.41882583498954773,
0.05768517404794693,
0.5603393912315369,
-0.9452673196792603,
0.35505804419517517,
0.5992379188537598,
-0.4130416214466095,
0.9593213200569153,
-0.30390504002571106,
-0.4413260519504547,
-1.1804537773132324,
0.09184037894010544,
0.216545969247818,
-0.6451523303985596,
-0.4060877561569214,
-0.24029462039470673,
-0.16835854947566986,
-0.1537621170282364,
-0.11451686173677444,
0.5480145215988159,
-0.31083962321281433,
-0.32225650548934937,
-0.4317859411239624,
0.061774399131536484,
-0.03804619982838631,
0.4086529016494751,
0.6810658574104309,
0.647985577583313,
0.34400948882102966,
-0.6006351709365845,
0.49216097593307495,
0.47004181146621704,
-0.4835048317909241,
0.5483839511871338,
-0.522335946559906,
0.13654081523418427,
0.0978340283036232,
0.915747344493866,
-0.842041015625,
-0.0766262635588646,
-0.11853017657995224,
0.053946029394865036,
-0.2112649530172348,
0.09847351908683777,
-1.1525486707687378,
-0.7081840634346008,
0.00634719617664814,
-0.009717782028019428,
0.09682668745517731,
-0.8509383797645569,
1.0821948051452637,
0.4888443648815155,
-0.30904126167297363,
-0.11865395307540894,
-0.6826884746551514,
0.21367639303207397,
-0.3041641414165497,
-0.7909196019172668,
0.6669062972068787,
-0.13929811120033264,
-0.6328492164611816,
-0.12042610347270966,
-0.032929811626672745,
-0.03711205720901489,
0.06643834710121155,
0.46827059984207153,
0.8022281527519226,
0.2397252470254898,
0.005657213274389505,
-0.21364839375019073,
-0.09822624921798706,
0.13076399266719818,
-0.3972824513912201,
0.2982037663459778,
-0.057596608996391296,
-0.26030999422073364,
-0.10971489548683167,
0.5484228730201721,
0.9314706921577454,
-0.13120153546333313,
1.065240740776062,
0.5384164452552795,
-0.6612111926078796,
-0.5252636671066284,
-0.7144705653190613,
-0.04353967308998108,
-0.5094807744026184,
0.24415908753871918,
0.049081262201070786,
-0.9741559624671936,
0.5158374905586243,
-0.4069063663482666,
0.3913741111755371,
0.05627976730465889,
1.0805567502975464,
-0.10816282033920288,
1.163740873336792,
0.6952171325683594,
0.057502761483192444,
0.7094730734825134,
0.07594361156225204,
0.3780016303062439,
-0.7814946174621582,
-0.5843011140823364,
-0.31712543964385986,
-0.31135445833206177,
-0.1388857215642929,
-0.5102819204330444,
0.5420969128608704,
-0.3242161273956299,
0.2149793654680252,
0.35716864466667175,
-0.16921620070934296,
0.43060627579689026,
0.5317018032073975,
0.26119861006736755,
0.27239397168159485,
-0.28727245330810547,
-0.6500775218009949,
0.04322805628180504,
-0.7289988994598389,
-0.532153308391571,
0.10852846503257751,
0.4393734931945801,
0.7108563184738159,
0.1889694482088089,
0.37658068537712097,
0.4726828336715698,
0.07328898459672928,
-0.6067655682563782,
0.7441553473472595,
-0.025115782395005226,
-0.6633657217025757,
-0.31713804602622986,
-0.4690897762775421,
-0.5957202315330505,
0.7094615697860718,
-0.5498839020729065,
-0.9839293360710144,
-0.09253386408090591,
-0.03113410994410515,
-0.49034616351127625,
0.5620443224906921,
-0.8661089539527893,
0.65032958984375,
-0.4698773920536041,
-0.5010902881622314,
-0.6229694485664368,
-0.06553483009338379,
0.32810845971107483,
-0.10600113123655319,
0.4692418873310089,
0.07426785677671432,
0.1261165738105774,
0.8671320676803589,
-0.5868948698043823,
1.2332696914672852,
-0.09374802559614182,
-0.16730020940303802,
0.025119367986917496,
0.30977970361709595,
0.5700811743736267,
-0.03486642241477966,
-0.536619246006012,
-0.1351645588874817,
-0.1335870623588562,
-0.018105462193489075,
-0.3686342239379883,
0.6922881007194519,
-0.48252803087234497,
-0.5318548679351807,
-0.10870981961488724,
-0.7573621273040771,
-0.7365636229515076,
0.3515043556690216,
0.15135075151920319,
0.15392687916755676,
0.1781734973192215,
0.2231907695531845,
0.4791841506958008,
-0.43666505813598633,
0.42880743741989136,
0.5624046325683594,
-0.49013012647628784,
-0.03870764747262001,
0.3769674599170685,
0.1638190895318985,
-0.02762667089700699,
0.3148312568664551,
0.4320964813232422,
-0.7726311087608337,
-0.5478693842887878,
-0.3146466910839081,
0.22883374989032745,
-0.788331151008606,
-0.11122515052556992,
-0.4129214882850647,
0.15790194272994995,
0.1538173258304596,
-0.5033395290374756,
-0.057852353900671005,
-0.16385392844676971,
-0.10549803823232651,
-0.5031108260154724,
0.27695292234420776,
0.8307950496673584,
-0.0016426099464297295,
-0.043670475482940674,
-0.7504677176475525,
0.2454209178686142,
0.4330810308456421,
0.5632261037826538,
0.08560223877429962,
-0.1826775074005127,
-0.5856978297233582,
-0.2673373818397522,
-0.05495847389101982,
-0.9028741121292114,
0.28595834970474243,
-0.3014615476131439,
1.010119080543518,
0.1389276087284088,
0.11415411531925201,
0.13719382882118225,
-0.33323270082473755,
0.7074759006500244,
0.34036943316459656,
-0.7585899233818054,
0.4374595284461975,
-0.6570209264755249,
0.1790877729654312,
0.48465320467948914,
0.10813497751951218,
-0.5695076584815979,
-0.17569273710250854,
-0.44337648153305054,
-0.6041378378868103,
0.732384204864502,
0.1263183206319809,
-0.06253693997859955,
0.31114745140075684,
0.030910801142454147,
0.3164229691028595,
0.12636594474315643,
-1.1057219505310059,
0.024162907153367996,
0.2697886526584625,
0.15234288573265076,
0.23165559768676758,
-0.03572366014122963,
-0.311945378780365,
-0.28466036915779114,
0.39548468589782715,
-0.21161265671253204,
0.14858336746692657,
-0.20128284394741058,
0.043280839920043945,
-0.4202077388763428,
0.27945366501808167,
0.23101793229579926,
0.9180100560188293,
0.19559648633003235,
-0.010272859595716,
0.7841329574584961,
0.3210345208644867,
-0.2658390402793884,
0.015904603525996208,
0.22143039107322693,
0.11796373873949051,
0.2151758223772049,
0.9926699995994568,
0.029800958931446075,
-0.8254990577697754,
0.44698190689086914,
-0.018422283232212067,
-0.3588496148586273,
-0.31391292810440063,
0.3856809437274933,
0.3979490399360657,
0.48254430294036865,
0.21494421362876892,
0.10626605153083801,
-0.02543448656797409,
-0.43786904215812683,
-0.24175713956356049,
0.5636926293373108,
0.16672207415103912,
0.03284316882491112,
0.42682507634162903,
0.3315475583076477,
-0.45276516675949097,
0.40883612632751465,
0.03296493738889694,
-0.6952313780784607,
0.3870062530040741,
0.8217374682426453,
0.6705784797668457,
0.30117183923721313,
0.4073534309864044,
-0.0499521866440773,
-0.08655668050050735,
-0.09951930493116379,
0.31472551822662354,
-0.09725102037191391,
-0.859440267086029,
-0.7536787986755371,
-0.4492926597595215,
-0.8980901837348938,
0.13686978816986084,
-0.21492084860801697,
0.07531231641769409,
-0.6357123851776123,
-0.18226031959056854,
0.053331974893808365,
-0.21663442254066467,
-0.7407318949699402,
0.229667529463768,
0.8321517109870911,
1.1893882751464844,
-0.747326135635376,
0.6716404557228088,
1.1524990797042847,
0.05904768407344818,
-0.7601655125617981,
-0.23470476269721985,
0.036753974854946136,
-0.7713055610656738,
0.4791813790798187,
-0.10969844460487366,
-0.344421923160553,
-0.5940582752227783,
-0.45333132147789,
-0.5006399154663086,
1.120993733406067,
0.3865828514099121,
-0.8097564578056335,
0.021123113110661507,
0.04576161503791809,
0.6717700362205505,
-0.3089134395122528,
0.17067188024520874,
0.33451420068740845,
0.7923054099082947,
-0.03192059323191643,
-1.166883945465088,
0.2091563642024994,
-0.15805955231189728,
0.2170422226190567,
-0.001117223291657865,
-0.6272808313369751,
0.5974296927452087,
-0.2127951979637146,
0.10232730954885483,
-0.2908211052417755,
0.39602696895599365,
0.5554403066635132,
0.09525560587644577,
0.9995552897453308,
0.4102884531021118,
0.954914927482605,
0.2142389416694641,
1.1383684873580933,
-0.0989018976688385,
-0.07429734617471695,
0.8287411332130432,
-0.4804050326347351,
0.8813946843147278,
0.42753303050994873,
-0.2123076170682907,
1.0694236755371094,
0.5741299986839294,
0.2494543343782425,
0.2825470566749573,
-0.11426433175802231,
-0.4386754035949707,
-0.6410959959030151,
-0.4309060573577881,
-0.11052846163511276,
0.20937396585941315,
0.44210296869277954,
-0.17400456964969635,
-0.1389455497264862,
0.0847918838262558,
-0.05205501988530159,
0.025455191731452942,
-0.16088104248046875,
0.8824139833450317,
0.27108272910118103,
-0.8301189541816711,
0.2501542270183563,
0.30681881308555603,
0.6012331247329712,
-0.5549448132514954,
0.06369255483150482,
0.16733108460903168,
0.23052766919136047,
-0.8058044910430908,
-1.1056978702545166,
0.34244757890701294,
0.058518923819065094,
-0.292279452085495,
-0.6694316864013672,
0.9326879978179932,
-0.3219996988773346,
-0.24116331338882446,
0.5452478528022766,
0.6650505661964417,
-0.47529786825180054,
-0.12337563931941986,
-0.6842663884162903,
0.016915205866098404,
0.03059682436287403,
0.11633971333503723,
0.3464684784412384,
0.37352022528648376,
-0.21653489768505096,
0.53984135389328,
0.8547975420951843,
0.1358756572008133,
-0.2441847324371338,
0.16322678327560425,
0.9672691822052002,
-0.34342387318611145,
-0.9515599608421326,
-0.8227528929710388,
0.4778558909893036,
-0.27796709537506104,
-0.15749390423297882,
0.5511967539787292,
0.3674546480178833,
0.500376284122467,
-0.16209715604782104,
1.2532726526260376,
-0.12844231724739075,
0.5307867527008057,
-0.7279064059257507,
0.19217443466186523,
-0.48861128091812134,
0.3119337260723114,
-0.2690306007862091,
-0.8599560260772705,
-0.11256790906190872,
0.6570451259613037,
-0.9373994469642639,
-0.04747454449534416,
0.5211727023124695,
0.6221827268600464,
-0.13181860744953156,
0.3102951645851135,
0.21929337084293365,
0.05026031658053398,
0.39443230628967285,
0.45795586705207825,
1.154984951019287,
0.6330512762069702,
0.45529070496559143,
-0.10004564374685287,
-0.28625351190567017,
-0.471507728099823,
-1.1038132905960083,
-0.8558551669120789,
-0.38619574904441833,
-0.23943394422531128,
-0.36439889669418335,
-0.4359056055545807,
1.0842194557189941,
1.050652027130127,
-0.38983970880508423,
-0.31312376260757446,
-0.11391376703977585,
0.2780134975910187,
-0.13463422656059265,
-0.24214591085910797,
-0.13056588172912598,
0.03022954612970352,
-0.18147391080856323,
0.6447033882141113,
0.31738609075546265,
-0.16166456043720245,
-0.3709455728530884,
-0.4352010488510132,
-0.055140089243650436,
0.04028266295790672,
0.7005192637443542,
0.2242116630077362,
-0.6044175028800964,
0.07111115753650665,
-0.15639032423496246,
-0.15822969377040863,
-0.14365744590759277,
0.9236486554145813,
-0.5740830302238464,
0.35223230719566345,
0.672934353351593,
0.6793692708015442,
0.40652361512184143,
-0.26744288206100464,
0.9077683091163635,
-0.5613808035850525,
-0.0006193867884576321,
0.3727248013019562,
0.9683356285095215,
0.5111041069030762,
-0.4973340332508087,
0.37059083580970764,
0.12043164670467377,
-0.38819798827171326,
-0.4088406562805176,
0.12189149111509323,
-0.8150232434272766,
-0.5595700144767761,
1.5297082662582397,
0.25431910157203674,
-0.06462831050157547,
-0.30889925360679626,
-0.6659265160560608,
-0.07711277902126312,
-0.3186326324939728,
0.7529454231262207,
0.7649381160736084,
-0.47456133365631104,
-0.18864047527313232,
-0.4599158763885498,
0.3031749725341797,
0.6803269982337952,
-1.0874347686767578,
0.11628424376249313,
0.6538928747177124,
0.13170191645622253,
0.17419084906578064,
0.8574812412261963,
0.20355486869812012,
0.3755950331687927,
-0.254822701215744,
-0.38534414768218994,
-0.03730139508843422,
-0.20278894901275635,
0.0652444139122963,
-0.14922180771827698,
0.3421255350112915,
-0.13711363077163696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03610v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03610v1 | RAP: Retrieval-Augmented Planning with Contextual Memory for Multimodal LLM Agents | 2024-02-06T00:53:27 | 2024-02-06T00:53:27 | Tomoyuki Kagaya, Thong Jing Yuan, Yuxuan Lou, Jayashree Karlekar, Sugiri Pranata, Akira Kinose, Koki Oguri, Felix Wick, Yang You | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Owing to recent advancements, Large Language Models (LLMs) can now be
deployed as agents for increasingly complex decision-making applications in
areas including robotics, gaming, and API integration. However, reflecting past
experiences in current decision-making processes, an innate human behavior,
continues to pose significant challenges. Addressing this, we propose
Retrieval-Augmented Planning (RAP) framework, designed to dynamically leverage
past experiences corresponding to the current situation and context, thereby
enhancing agents' planning capabilities. RAP distinguishes itself by being
versatile: it excels in both text-only and multimodal environments, making it
suitable for a wide range of tasks. Empirical evaluations demonstrate RAP's
effectiveness, where it achieves SOTA performance in textual scenarios and
notably enhances multimodal LLM agents' performance for embodied tasks. These
results highlight RAP's potential in advancing the functionality and
applicability of LLM agents in complex, real-world applications. | [
-0.3739464282989502,
-0.8086612224578857,
0.8184298872947693,
0.5064413547515869,
0.23294302821159363,
0.4078332781791687,
-0.08834336698055267,
-0.37181782722473145,
0.5617074966430664,
0.41665858030319214,
-0.6192062497138977,
-0.44399043917655945,
-0.38380539417266846,
-0.1575450748205185,
-0.3290020525455475,
0.6399760246276855,
-0.2975451350212097,
-0.2049873024225235,
-0.19514568150043488,
-0.012573899701237679,
-0.590915322303772,
-0.7143564820289612,
-0.7031939029693604,
-0.2776573896408081,
0.6528995037078857,
0.474710613489151,
0.715894341468811,
0.27303487062454224,
0.37309831380844116,
0.24899327754974365,
0.021249298006296158,
0.46423614025115967,
-0.5640530586242676,
0.5048588514328003,
-0.3747223913669586,
-0.2320145070552826,
-0.6856420040130615,
-0.12919442355632782,
0.7867862582206726,
0.3692620098590851,
-0.0815463438630104,
-0.20591889321804047,
-0.5315828919410706,
0.4259470999240875,
-0.9944226741790771,
0.017546357586979866,
-0.5338955521583557,
0.27503180503845215,
0.22951412200927734,
-0.7135442495346069,
-0.5777015089988708,
0.08784031867980957,
0.2507442235946655,
-0.7562047839164734,
-0.3408209979534149,
0.11858490854501724,
0.35444602370262146,
0.2689817249774933,
-0.42998555302619934,
-0.433236688375473,
-1.0989793539047241,
0.7343490123748779,
-0.2015700489282608,
0.5879956483840942,
0.36449670791625977,
0.3865506052970886,
-0.4606141746044159,
-1.0587272644042969,
-0.6193469762802124,
-0.24371570348739624,
0.13302083313465118,
0.27199193835258484,
-0.13066431879997253,
-0.07124266773462296,
0.30241698026657104,
-0.11901704967021942,
-0.21605731546878815,
-0.19073347747325897,
-0.14812275767326355,
-0.19409632682800293,
0.3750264644622803,
0.17838487029075623,
0.5970067977905273,
-0.003956797067075968,
-0.9233313798904419,
-0.11689714342355728,
-0.7719056606292725,
0.11636947840452194,
-0.033479928970336914,
0.48041078448295593,
0.10103143751621246,
0.6611963510513306,
-0.07549232989549637,
0.5023735165596008,
-0.4146583080291748,
-0.39810508489608765,
0.18962055444717407,
-0.42937958240509033,
0.028714168816804886,
0.09813949465751648,
0.4064086377620697,
0.3185877501964569,
0.005154126789420843,
-0.333347886800766,
-0.3530139923095703,
-0.07683189958333969,
0.49455150961875916,
-0.5720882415771484,
0.055081527680158615,
-0.12888771295547485,
-0.19010914862155914,
0.22503915429115295,
-0.22848185896873474,
-0.724605917930603,
-0.28682613372802734,
-0.21949078142642975,
0.5839509963989258,
-0.7959682941436768,
-0.2950664758682251,
0.15943820774555206,
-0.36288920044898987,
0.10784762352705002,
0.40756359696388245,
-0.5863836407661438,
0.36727455258369446,
0.4263034462928772,
0.8701006174087524,
-0.22665178775787354,
-0.700730562210083,
-0.8772929310798645,
0.6120471954345703,
-0.3814419209957123,
0.923861563205719,
-0.8952268958091736,
-0.65705406665802,
-0.007296726573258638,
-0.30061861872673035,
0.021143432706594467,
-0.41351816058158875,
0.6740766167640686,
-0.8003759980201721,
-0.37986108660697937,
-0.32178395986557007,
-0.08685393631458282,
-0.004218294285237789,
0.6182331442832947,
-0.6809244155883789,
0.9882920384407043,
0.06344716250896454,
-0.36681079864501953,
0.5394148826599121,
-0.6988025903701782,
-0.44734033942222595,
-0.09345986694097519,
-0.26859399676322937,
-0.038702093064785004,
-0.23688821494579315,
0.12753431499004364,
0.25652074813842773,
0.17918865382671356,
0.09035556763410568,
0.034138359129428864,
-0.5725273489952087,
0.21125146746635437,
-0.20015496015548706,
0.269136905670166,
0.3318796157836914,
0.09319377690553665,
0.3523422181606293,
-0.510707676410675,
0.0051814960315823555,
-0.013958590105175972,
-0.5567097067832947,
-0.4791407883167267,
0.27027377486228943,
-0.07849621027708054,
0.5058768391609192,
0.22229644656181335,
-0.3583241403102875,
0.5161909461021423,
-0.19838039577007294,
0.25750434398651123,
0.48068588972091675,
-0.12793207168579102,
0.7645522356033325,
-0.5270224809646606,
0.6985824108123779,
-0.04049723222851753,
-0.05976896360516548,
-0.35142916440963745,
-0.2251754254102707,
-0.3344116806983948,
-0.383064866065979,
-0.05243392288684845,
0.44592323899269104,
-1.2176756858825684,
-0.27246853709220886,
-0.32977133989334106,
-0.22104793787002563,
0.19162262976169586,
-0.13185399770736694,
0.204635351896286,
0.3531056344509125,
0.3954488933086395,
-0.08949019759893417,
-0.8707560896873474,
-0.6076620221138,
-0.1269369125366211,
-0.21189254522323608,
0.3044549822807312,
0.611143171787262,
0.4519287943840027,
-0.6394385099411011,
1.2395304441452026,
-0.3171840012073517,
-0.4508362412452698,
-0.6136022210121155,
0.2578815221786499,
-0.1404995620250702,
0.2574485242366791,
0.6516475677490234,
-1.1237317323684692,
-0.13571768999099731,
-0.3143330514431,
-0.49424856901168823,
0.037927161902189255,
-0.4236345887184143,
-0.37634745240211487,
0.015427347272634506,
0.5733711123466492,
-0.7963897585868835,
0.4979301393032074,
0.4099366366863251,
-0.40966978669166565,
0.7718213200569153,
-0.5021817684173584,
0.08192979544401169,
-0.9500536322593689,
-0.0058551509864628315,
-0.31923550367355347,
-0.33011752367019653,
-0.5905587077140808,
0.17827565968036652,
0.041385386139154434,
0.029494136571884155,
-0.646370530128479,
0.882249653339386,
-0.5519286394119263,
-0.5377234816551208,
-0.2328409105539322,
0.4598546028137207,
-0.08516082912683487,
0.4688962697982788,
0.23145121335983276,
1.2663968801498413,
0.230751633644104,
-0.8761842846870422,
0.14288261532783508,
0.5377909541130066,
-0.18330469727516174,
0.40088802576065063,
-0.15416620671749115,
0.08502884209156036,
-0.1368400603532791,
0.48978427052497864,
-0.6931859850883484,
-0.10954537242650986,
0.11746212840080261,
-0.412648469209671,
0.3941260576248169,
-0.10958781093358994,
-0.51029372215271,
-0.06326805800199509,
-0.3258821666240692,
0.6640411615371704,
0.015490098856389523,
-0.41766050457954407,
1.3374770879745483,
0.5878968834877014,
-0.24475184082984924,
-0.7577345371246338,
-0.573563814163208,
0.3290337026119232,
0.10956837236881256,
-0.21445505321025848,
0.7467972636222839,
-0.22918923199176788,
-0.34017235040664673,
-0.031474120914936066,
-0.13357989490032196,
-0.04106224700808525,
-0.14575770497322083,
0.3361113369464874,
0.29655325412750244,
0.052035555243492126,
0.16146361827850342,
-0.032902542501688004,
-0.18625681102275848,
-0.11848769336938858,
0.05818263068795204,
0.9107198715209961,
-0.0236139427870512,
-0.26084014773368835,
0.10935614258050919,
0.36555641889572144,
0.5646757483482361,
-0.3470996022224426,
0.5514244437217712,
0.3136061131954193,
-0.2646360695362091,
-0.21158820390701294,
-0.36655503511428833,
0.1341935098171234,
-0.4251873195171356,
0.4590863585472107,
-0.6531410217285156,
-0.7718541026115417,
0.47069382667541504,
-0.586817741394043,
-0.0611540824174881,
-0.09034775197505951,
0.5051988959312439,
-0.18034787476062775,
0.9475916624069214,
0.5627479553222656,
0.13898082077503204,
0.7204400300979614,
-0.4966624081134796,
0.1119755208492279,
-1.1078050136566162,
-0.3584437668323517,
-0.10943745076656342,
-0.6528027057647705,
-0.27921849489212036,
-0.6558417081832886,
0.46328234672546387,
-0.059648338705301285,
-0.3034364879131317,
0.08023277670145035,
-0.00610888609662652,
0.4862348139286041,
0.5927246809005737,
-0.0031053400598466396,
0.37766551971435547,
-0.1926300972700119,
-0.3713330626487732,
0.057236142456531525,
-0.49149489402770996,
-0.6489678621292114,
0.8917500376701355,
0.09817788004875183,
0.7490792274475098,
0.17958161234855652,
0.5557356476783752,
0.3027627170085907,
0.06316899508237839,
-0.9653562903404236,
0.7677453756332397,
0.06918825209140778,
-0.5105304718017578,
-0.31862208247184753,
-0.3662307858467102,
-1.0292503833770752,
0.16921848058700562,
-0.4300757646560669,
-0.8149518370628357,
0.2384791374206543,
-0.0589311346411705,
-0.5467075109481812,
0.5003450512886047,
-0.5557072162628174,
0.5416343808174133,
-0.4479086101055145,
-0.37409573793411255,
-0.32490816712379456,
-0.5373314619064331,
0.10552845895290375,
0.0698513463139534,
0.10592878609895706,
-0.1043330654501915,
-0.45333680510520935,
0.5454158782958984,
0.05845090374350548,
0.38301360607147217,
-0.24501393735408783,
0.181277334690094,
0.28549379110336304,
0.47180095314979553,
0.6303505301475525,
-0.07438111305236816,
-0.1285087764263153,
-0.28854623436927795,
0.15009213984012604,
-0.1037299856543541,
-0.6767024993896484,
0.8117384910583496,
-0.7682783603668213,
-0.3480146527290344,
-0.4936974048614502,
-1.087550163269043,
-0.4422021806240082,
0.4190148413181305,
-0.21456508338451385,
0.5934322476387024,
-0.3728238642215729,
0.21727676689624786,
0.4005352854728699,
-0.5708382725715637,
0.536597490310669,
0.6388952732086182,
-0.7190059423446655,
-0.1206396073102951,
0.7190590500831604,
0.23099082708358765,
0.1349540650844574,
0.5837581753730774,
-0.0917946994304657,
-0.36846598982810974,
-0.6903508305549622,
-0.10449576377868652,
0.023356689140200615,
-0.5734623670578003,
-0.16115139424800873,
-0.9052267074584961,
-0.2127363234758377,
-0.17433322966098785,
-0.20943504571914673,
-0.44748544692993164,
-0.46711990237236023,
-0.001258576987311244,
-0.2707696557044983,
0.22423842549324036,
0.5460551381111145,
-0.21734488010406494,
0.25734516978263855,
-0.5108667612075806,
0.6950596570968628,
0.24931316077709198,
0.3479568660259247,
-0.1780991554260254,
-0.053047917783260345,
-0.013607229106128216,
0.24054262042045593,
-0.3410094380378723,
-0.6918346881866455,
0.7008851766586304,
0.18997791409492493,
0.6623415350914001,
-0.030736787244677544,
0.2879253327846527,
0.8237457871437073,
-0.5437312722206116,
0.49247437715530396,
-0.2213171422481537,
-0.47199973464012146,
0.7292737364768982,
-0.269852876663208,
0.23506610095500946,
0.5522331595420837,
0.33013439178466797,
-0.43696367740631104,
-0.008433428592979908,
-0.3056546449661255,
-1.1062694787979126,
0.8904572129249573,
0.09684984385967255,
0.30359509587287903,
-0.10328689217567444,
0.43591243028640747,
0.027164489030838013,
0.10873726010322571,
-0.43496692180633545,
-0.13783490657806396,
-0.007691380102187395,
0.27090930938720703,
0.034579548984766006,
-0.663384735584259,
-0.0821426510810852,
-0.15323525667190552,
0.36007818579673767,
-0.08814471960067749,
0.6385734677314758,
0.24489490687847137,
-0.3503625988960266,
0.015912706032395363,
0.2932383716106415,
0.883249819278717,
0.9932828545570374,
-0.44886505603790283,
0.3901813328266144,
0.2104140967130661,
-0.4864417016506195,
0.1092299073934555,
-0.06187842786312103,
-0.17918945848941803,
-0.32175934314727783,
0.18933041393756866,
0.4813660979270935,
0.6644380688667297,
-1.2214338779449463,
0.3870224356651306,
-0.20831389725208282,
0.05187808349728584,
-0.6838085651397705,
0.12760761380195618,
-0.09361062943935394,
0.5297709107398987,
0.6538505554199219,
0.2799411118030548,
0.1980089247226715,
-1.0088727474212646,
0.4578684866428375,
0.32520729303359985,
-0.36621806025505066,
-0.08785156905651093,
0.4003526568412781,
-0.1285547912120819,
-0.5753081440925598,
0.5111060738563538,
-0.3158661425113678,
-0.5444388389587402,
0.2601330280303955,
1.004623532295227,
0.5181636810302734,
-0.054293226450681686,
0.23175282776355743,
0.19116589426994324,
-0.08777870982885361,
-0.05460596829652786,
0.5949850678443909,
-0.12445603311061859,
-1.0643311738967896,
-0.4613868296146393,
-0.4988904297351837,
-0.44226154685020447,
-0.438068687915802,
-0.3502501845359802,
0.09099603444337845,
-0.6341370344161987,
-0.480440616607666,
-0.6282006502151489,
-0.010610421188175678,
-0.5068866014480591,
0.14127816259860992,
-0.025128547102212906,
1.0996266603469849,
-0.23482351005077362,
0.8124852776527405,
0.9612689018249512,
-0.49584633111953735,
-0.7106865644454956,
0.004305063746869564,
-0.04241744056344032,
-0.9686832427978516,
1.0629934072494507,
-0.06668125838041306,
-0.7258586287498474,
0.031020725145936012,
-0.4574809968471527,
-0.9273353219032288,
1.3941009044647217,
0.4243963956832886,
-0.2220454066991806,
-0.42886075377464294,
-0.23077796399593353,
0.43235456943511963,
-0.43724387884140015,
0.41117891669273376,
0.5912824273109436,
0.379298597574234,
0.7459600567817688,
-0.8444424867630005,
-0.2671811878681183,
-0.2881666123867035,
-0.041833169758319855,
0.2512708604335785,
-0.545213520526886,
0.8848626017570496,
-0.3259267508983612,
-0.4411780834197998,
0.08422373980283737,
0.6202830076217651,
0.7618788480758667,
0.48018988966941833,
0.4299061596393585,
0.3914933204650879,
0.5666866898536682,
-0.06523530185222626,
1.120177984237671,
-0.2575760781764984,
-0.1806187629699707,
1.347324013710022,
-0.5404092669487,
1.2164713144302368,
0.515289843082428,
0.12170220166444778,
0.6133037209510803,
0.22547504305839539,
0.6618284583091736,
0.7515327334403992,
-0.36991187930107117,
-0.24380354583263397,
-0.30269932746887207,
-0.4538446366786957,
-0.22688643634319305,
0.7312979102134705,
0.49560168385505676,
-0.11353614926338196,
-0.2027042657136917,
0.07344243675470352,
0.01242087222635746,
0.22220216691493988,
-0.36221498250961304,
0.6614982485771179,
-0.02423950843513012,
-0.5477126240730286,
0.06025009602308273,
-0.1785019487142563,
0.6231040358543396,
-0.6938217878341675,
-0.28411364555358887,
-0.06145058944821358,
0.1681974083185196,
0.010254595428705215,
-0.9815759062767029,
0.41837653517723083,
-0.19780083000659943,
-0.13900770246982574,
-0.7650147676467896,
0.8505733609199524,
-0.19548402726650238,
-0.12457495927810669,
0.6349184513092041,
0.7118120789527893,
-0.06078103557229042,
-0.1061372458934784,
-0.39713093638420105,
0.2642595171928406,
-0.5410146713256836,
-0.048033710569143295,
0.3681473135948181,
0.4752756953239441,
-0.07827742397785187,
1.2529406547546387,
0.6068177223205566,
0.34848734736442566,
-0.042815200984478,
0.06865771859884262,
1.0002014636993408,
-0.8916304707527161,
-0.5247901678085327,
-0.698957622051239,
0.34583863615989685,
0.07364743947982788,
-0.017571859061717987,
0.530937135219574,
0.8116188049316406,
0.79945969581604,
0.17192620038986206,
0.46167898178100586,
-0.04244930297136307,
0.5951256155967712,
-0.6221140623092651,
0.5340709090232849,
-0.5466679334640503,
0.40859004855155945,
-0.3813197910785675,
-0.8283385634422302,
-0.3247765600681305,
0.7766410708427429,
-0.604644238948822,
0.24233593046665192,
0.45284274220466614,
0.6153714656829834,
0.03541306033730507,
-0.26904594898223877,
0.46280407905578613,
0.09438852220773697,
0.5001223683357239,
0.6910104751586914,
1.357068419456482,
-0.03090357966721058,
0.5761759877204895,
0.11162366718053818,
-0.09615454822778702,
-0.19752459228038788,
-0.8396011590957642,
-0.5703400373458862,
-0.6436196565628052,
0.2813490927219391,
0.14482511579990387,
0.03074181079864502,
1.3144347667694092,
0.5937000513076782,
-0.3434373140335083,
-0.24052467942237854,
0.34193068742752075,
0.13982366025447845,
-0.14087419211864471,
-0.17279179394245148,
0.08567395061254501,
-0.308093398809433,
-0.5372118353843689,
0.8916342854499817,
0.6790035367012024,
0.07800084352493286,
-0.13953714072704315,
-0.46522581577301025,
-0.7489711046218872,
-0.007003734353929758,
1.0384775400161743,
0.35912904143333435,
-0.629999041557312,
-0.3499096632003784,
0.20568574965000153,
-0.14395233988761902,
0.10714884847402573,
1.0491859912872314,
-1.296172857284546,
0.7370961308479309,
0.35313600301742554,
0.5260953903198242,
0.6761317849159241,
-0.02187998779118061,
0.8308631777763367,
-0.8469342589378357,
0.3257291615009308,
0.5187278389930725,
0.4314557611942291,
-0.04013105481863022,
-0.06297262758016586,
0.5745369791984558,
-0.19373217225074768,
-0.4453226625919342,
-0.6644290685653687,
0.22571393847465515,
-1.1431000232696533,
-0.2813716530799866,
1.143671989440918,
0.06178490072488785,
0.020140618085861206,
-0.15829183161258698,
-0.7573502063751221,
0.20657867193222046,
-0.46811816096305847,
0.6265897154808044,
0.47896313667297363,
-0.3454407751560211,
-0.42078152298927307,
-0.556532621383667,
0.4193730652332306,
-0.01763894408941269,
-0.6020342111587524,
-0.21972139179706573,
0.7033671736717224,
-0.2128182351589203,
0.3732861280441284,
1.1265746355056763,
0.07214120030403137,
0.3609924912452698,
-0.07531005144119263,
-0.007243293337523937,
-0.3390750288963318,
-0.8615712523460388,
0.3776426911354065,
0.24698330461978912,
0.22739970684051514,
0.09005250036716461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03607v1 | Improving Contextual Congruence Across Modalities for Effective Multimodal Marketing using Knowledge-infused Learning | 2024-02-06T00:51:27 | 2024-02-06T00:51:27 | Trilok Padhi, Ugur Kursuncu, Yaman Kumar, Valerie L. Shalin, Lane Peterson Fronczek | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.HC, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.4; I.2.1 | The prevalence of smart devices with the ability to capture moments in
multiple modalities has enabled users to experience multimodal information
online. However, large Language (LLMs) and Vision models (LVMs) are still
limited in capturing holistic meaning with cross-modal semantic relationships.
Without explicit, common sense knowledge (e.g., as a knowledge graph), Visual
Language Models (VLMs) only learn implicit representations by capturing
high-level patterns in vast corpora, missing essential contextual cross-modal
cues. In this work, we design a framework to couple explicit commonsense
knowledge in the form of knowledge graphs with large VLMs to improve the
performance of a downstream task, predicting the effectiveness of multi-modal
marketing campaigns. While the marketing application provides a compelling
metric for assessing our methods, our approach enables the early detection of
likely persuasive multi-modal campaigns and the assessment and augmentation of
marketing theory. | [
-0.24144472181797028,
-0.6859884262084961,
0.38836756348609924,
0.16126170754432678,
-0.3861062824726105,
-0.005601552315056324,
-0.4662829339504242,
-0.5221995115280151,
0.11878500878810883,
0.24991266429424286,
-0.47541359066963196,
-0.568494975566864,
-0.3561524450778961,
-0.16253766417503357,
0.20124614238739014,
0.7045327425003052,
0.08828869462013245,
0.23826590180397034,
-0.4775988459587097,
-0.2685185372829437,
-0.6057777404785156,
-0.2954948842525482,
-0.3080705404281616,
-0.16217996180057526,
0.7575819492340088,
0.44930246472358704,
0.321198970079422,
0.22653599083423615,
0.2112739086151123,
0.33869650959968567,
0.16440656781196594,
0.6526791453361511,
-0.6436437368392944,
0.3233168423175812,
-0.16026705503463745,
-0.18251505494117737,
-0.37314480543136597,
-0.005614783614873886,
0.4264829754829407,
0.5938209295272827,
0.10529546439647675,
0.12153861671686172,
0.07628246396780014,
0.3192172646522522,
-0.7986608147621155,
0.5937703847885132,
-0.7042661309242249,
-0.17451730370521545,
-0.012096760794520378,
-0.4861586093902588,
-0.4895728826522827,
0.07545237988233566,
0.3963741660118103,
-0.9066857099533081,
-0.06883992999792099,
0.21157096326351166,
0.6616488099098206,
0.1297072321176529,
-0.8514324426651001,
-0.26870882511138916,
-0.5494565963745117,
0.8898122906684875,
-0.416669636964798,
0.8103586435317993,
0.3040233254432678,
0.27367037534713745,
0.08880016207695007,
-0.7032497525215149,
-0.49980461597442627,
-0.22682219743728638,
-0.17837543785572052,
0.26362940669059753,
-0.013383294455707073,
0.05970459803938866,
0.18411216139793396,
0.12666203081607819,
-0.28339457511901855,
-0.1582229733467102,
-0.4149453341960907,
-0.35657474398612976,
0.39707043766975403,
0.12325616180896759,
0.214027538895607,
-0.4314189851284027,
-0.9184426665306091,
0.12085994333028793,
-0.23139463365077972,
0.3168559670448303,
0.023360971361398697,
0.3467070162296295,
-0.2958664000034332,
0.6582459211349487,
-0.3971898555755615,
0.8460279107093811,
0.18864871561527252,
-0.4091743528842926,
0.3296372890472412,
-0.8752524852752686,
-0.3556564748287201,
-0.12253983318805695,
0.5109905004501343,
0.5698762536048889,
0.03560233861207962,
-0.022910844534635544,
-0.22577862441539764,
-0.05295456200838089,
0.031534478068351746,
-0.8136783838272095,
-0.12346139550209045,
-0.019979247823357582,
-0.33289894461631775,
-0.052996959537267685,
-0.04488563910126686,
-0.6256353259086609,
-0.3889283835887909,
-0.6825235486030579,
0.5908458828926086,
-0.5365696549415588,
-0.3830288350582123,
0.00545878428965807,
-0.36419785022735596,
0.16297297179698944,
0.38882747292518616,
-0.632449746131897,
-0.2835383415222168,
0.5458531975746155,
0.6074592471122742,
0.06456457823514938,
-0.14271292090415955,
-0.44025692343711853,
0.6418947577476501,
0.03742938116192818,
0.6370202302932739,
-0.7623676061630249,
-0.1485847532749176,
-0.039904795587062836,
0.01822093315422535,
-0.45004013180732727,
-0.31094616651535034,
0.16110844910144806,
-0.8310331702232361,
0.31325748562812805,
-0.5270829796791077,
-0.5168700218200684,
-0.6333075165748596,
0.6639000177383423,
-0.7087630033493042,
0.7270622849464417,
0.055299412459135056,
-0.5405028462409973,
0.8397398591041565,
-0.6693606972694397,
-0.5557297468185425,
0.1391657441854477,
-0.1216808632016182,
-0.36182084679603577,
0.15755949914455414,
0.2328750193119049,
0.7352175712585449,
0.1385105699300766,
0.18127231299877167,
-0.4224724769592285,
0.0038959290832281113,
0.2628667950630188,
-0.6576403379440308,
0.5092471837997437,
0.2735915780067444,
-0.3406110107898712,
0.3585069477558136,
-0.7445419430732727,
-0.2110612988471985,
-0.10389254987239838,
-0.46614792943000793,
-0.5751823782920837,
-0.24259892106056213,
0.24309101700782776,
0.34349220991134644,
0.3411085307598114,
-0.21328379213809967,
0.05919323489069939,
0.02631106786429882,
0.2307494580745697,
0.8077613115310669,
0.06722655147314072,
0.4752834439277649,
-0.23762090504169464,
0.26680436730384827,
0.2786250114440918,
0.27762195467948914,
-0.39164018630981445,
-0.5935664176940918,
-0.5725162029266357,
-0.5789094567298889,
-0.07755496352910995,
0.1308475136756897,
-1.0207220315933228,
0.07941213995218277,
-0.4848727881908417,
-0.3604470193386078,
0.050866495817899704,
0.5566060543060303,
0.1839735358953476,
0.5610905289649963,
0.25809022784233093,
-0.4682547152042389,
-0.3984268307685852,
-0.6030688881874084,
-0.3153832256793976,
0.051209188997745514,
0.2523120045661926,
0.496185302734375,
0.37738826870918274,
-0.2170739769935608,
0.9021942019462585,
-0.31001362204551697,
-0.4365176558494568,
-0.34684768319129944,
0.1288817971944809,
-0.24399001896381378,
0.1541619449853897,
0.22647379338741302,
-1.2138627767562866,
-0.3576337695121765,
0.241787388920784,
-0.6857887506484985,
0.19583362340927124,
0.02506800927221775,
0.19203926622867584,
0.19276075065135956,
0.37835562229156494,
-0.4527668356895447,
0.1845511645078659,
0.5794552564620972,
-0.6345264911651611,
0.3938142955303192,
-0.123365119099617,
0.4807571470737457,
-0.9947195649147034,
0.01575782336294651,
0.45909279584884644,
-0.24978381395339966,
-0.521641194820404,
-0.32310354709625244,
0.06046811491250992,
-0.14939013123512268,
-0.7354771494865417,
0.49665966629981995,
-0.4214412569999695,
-0.14606401324272156,
0.04936300590634346,
0.1634490042924881,
0.4579259753227234,
0.744972288608551,
-0.027996165677905083,
0.7227430939674377,
0.2890706956386566,
-0.6921728849411011,
0.27304375171661377,
-0.007422801107168198,
-0.5786824822425842,
0.9377807378768921,
-0.31967806816101074,
-0.39143189787864685,
-0.2763887643814087,
0.20008765161037445,
-1.2411493062973022,
-0.5742599368095398,
0.24009262025356293,
-0.2494152933359146,
0.08997403830289841,
-0.04939788579940796,
-0.3391578793525696,
-0.06888848543167114,
-0.10585180670022964,
0.7613550424575806,
0.13192805647850037,
-0.5103750228881836,
0.9803359508514404,
0.1377410590648651,
0.10543079674243927,
-0.43521156907081604,
-0.39741286635398865,
-0.13509801030158997,
-0.3479311764240265,
-0.9268571734428406,
0.042884062975645065,
0.1500438004732132,
-0.17307186126708984,
-0.08430717140436172,
0.0647750273346901,
-0.007306459825485945,
-0.022694850340485573,
0.1894904524087906,
0.21777166426181793,
-0.20849250257015228,
0.44687893986701965,
-0.23875874280929565,
-0.058536842465400696,
-0.041049033403396606,
-0.46471211314201355,
0.4773329198360443,
-0.16487234830856323,
-0.6413016319274902,
-0.5619598627090454,
0.14577189087867737,
1.0348364114761353,
-0.5103625655174255,
0.5573491454124451,
1.0837416648864746,
-0.13255783915519714,
-0.07993552833795547,
-0.6366773843765259,
-0.2617778480052948,
-0.46714547276496887,
0.3868831396102905,
-0.34408438205718994,
-0.7548903226852417,
0.3950854539871216,
-0.281200647354126,
-0.23731690645217896,
0.1451404094696045,
0.5967354774475098,
0.018524641171097755,
1.2492783069610596,
0.544912576675415,
0.3568898141384125,
0.8277878761291504,
-0.3713319003582001,
0.335681676864624,
-0.6168606281280518,
-0.8653654456138611,
0.2169998735189438,
-0.3487996459007263,
-0.19106236100196838,
-0.7512971758842468,
0.5717880129814148,
0.04304395988583565,
-0.12810225784778595,
0.09332148730754852,
-0.1321220099925995,
0.34690800309181213,
0.7206004858016968,
0.4619726836681366,
0.6344888806343079,
0.2994820475578308,
0.03603050857782364,
-0.10201099514961243,
-0.8139776587486267,
-0.18994030356407166,
1.0074087381362915,
0.24304640293121338,
0.6780543923377991,
0.18306177854537964,
0.07403790205717087,
0.19379635155200958,
0.3411392271518707,
-0.862223207950592,
0.42894497513771057,
0.05646316334605217,
-0.661105215549469,
-0.05860922485589981,
-0.4525931477546692,
-0.7271314859390259,
0.40032443404197693,
-0.5049431324005127,
-0.35226309299468994,
0.4083341360092163,
0.20460760593414307,
-0.25005725026130676,
0.2860998809337616,
-0.9234827160835266,
1.0810112953186035,
-0.6574859023094177,
-0.762374758720398,
-0.35083261132240295,
-0.38010725378990173,
0.5275648236274719,
0.09587538987398148,
0.4010869860649109,
-0.13958871364593506,
-0.09617574512958527,
0.6251887679100037,
-0.24195924401283264,
1.1361199617385864,
-0.10910043865442276,
-0.20820562541484833,
0.1879146695137024,
-0.2358023226261139,
0.4250747263431549,
-0.12121549993753433,
0.28470200300216675,
-0.10675092041492462,
-0.34355270862579346,
-0.6638269424438477,
-0.6239432692527771,
0.661491870880127,
-0.40872451663017273,
-0.230298712849617,
0.00709577277302742,
-0.7894701957702637,
-0.36500832438468933,
0.3022582232952118,
-0.05280720070004463,
0.8638453483581543,
-0.09455528110265732,
0.34900087118148804,
0.7365905046463013,
0.09354092180728912,
0.3694698214530945,
0.24828702211380005,
-0.011230546981096268,
-0.7027349472045898,
1.1884902715682983,
0.0010311517398804426,
0.6438707113265991,
0.18569618463516235,
0.2531420886516571,
-0.6772143244743347,
-0.3409477472305298,
-0.30471327900886536,
0.03350275382399559,
-0.9462001919746399,
-0.07349396497011185,
-0.6127697825431824,
0.4356047511100769,
-0.5875915288925171,
-0.10552413761615753,
-0.0883982926607132,
-0.12360981851816177,
-0.22341476380825043,
0.01810319907963276,
0.30842751264572144,
0.588200569152832,
-0.14682498574256897,
0.2852579951286316,
-0.5931438207626343,
0.2585136294364929,
0.835571825504303,
0.20368361473083496,
0.15885049104690552,
-0.13567350804805756,
-0.38603490591049194,
0.2736700177192688,
-0.2442288100719452,
-0.6208383440971375,
0.27085617184638977,
0.024515070021152496,
0.7007938027381897,
0.8083341717720032,
-0.10363951325416565,
0.7724529504776001,
0.08463932573795319,
0.6589512228965759,
0.6931512951850891,
-0.7863524556159973,
0.35547909140586853,
-0.6390323042869568,
0.1646718531847,
0.5356975793838501,
0.5435983538627625,
-0.3697333037853241,
0.06691068410873413,
-0.47148576378822327,
-0.7990990877151489,
0.19218021631240845,
-0.23554180562496185,
0.09624320268630981,
0.011327490210533142,
-0.3496011197566986,
0.10727613419294357,
0.5114245414733887,
-0.9212737083435059,
-0.014288334175944328,
-0.45253556966781616,
-0.3734942376613617,
-0.07782204449176788,
-0.08234606683254242,
-0.36499544978141785,
-0.3791331946849823,
0.4573768973350525,
-0.3903679847717285,
-0.2904401421546936,
0.12403308600187302,
-0.37646588683128357,
0.15804129838943481,
0.220376655459404,
0.808077871799469,
0.9362872242927551,
-0.07460048049688339,
0.3718494176864624,
-0.07796256244182587,
-0.24375933408737183,
-0.14735719561576843,
0.07552731037139893,
0.07104038447141647,
-0.20311971008777618,
0.28596341609954834,
0.7257746458053589,
0.7099180817604065,
-0.8246016502380371,
0.7733246088027954,
0.2388114184141159,
-0.002866662573069334,
-0.07641325891017914,
-0.22839272022247314,
-0.050016164779663086,
0.5041471719741821,
0.3651055693626404,
0.20401331782341003,
0.013096080161631107,
-0.7995744943618774,
0.30363979935646057,
0.7064180970191956,
-0.7075598239898682,
-0.23700959980487823,
0.5939857363700867,
0.5921412110328674,
0.035389311611652374,
0.10423703491687775,
0.03847181051969528,
-0.6797818541526794,
0.2860695719718933,
0.3973553776741028,
0.47256189584732056,
0.07683254778385162,
0.1925208419561386,
0.13773591816425323,
0.1805858463048935,
0.07357049733400345,
-0.031077083200216293,
-0.39885395765304565,
-0.6092817783355713,
-0.5743078589439392,
-0.3670462965965271,
-0.13884709775447845,
-0.06467746198177338,
-0.3628431558609009,
0.39173272252082825,
-0.25399866700172424,
-0.24438580870628357,
-0.009105130098760128,
-0.023108525201678276,
-0.8407975435256958,
0.20924516022205353,
0.30913296341896057,
0.6401864290237427,
-0.8732786774635315,
0.48727354407310486,
0.6520973443984985,
-0.6673997640609741,
-0.7556664943695068,
-0.3439718782901764,
-0.093776173889637,
-0.9015342593193054,
0.881144106388092,
0.29394692182540894,
-0.1830245852470398,
-0.01272104773670435,
-0.4816339910030365,
-0.6931908130645752,
1.296155333518982,
0.04215603694319725,
-0.40679019689559937,
0.15907350182533264,
0.13720183074474335,
0.02766135148704052,
-0.5041179060935974,
0.1384739726781845,
0.10247176140546799,
0.7996286153793335,
0.34088507294654846,
-0.7124642133712769,
0.0020739955361932516,
-0.0045912740752100945,
-0.18949298560619354,
0.057589512318372726,
-0.43092915415763855,
0.6206626892089844,
-0.26511186361312866,
-0.34103384613990784,
-0.3638008236885071,
0.6820427775382996,
0.2433823049068451,
0.9431479573249817,
0.6497220993041992,
0.6523255109786987,
0.7520880103111267,
0.17523884773254395,
0.8617828488349915,
-0.2974843680858612,
0.2284899652004242,
0.7341622710227966,
-0.07273383438587189,
0.7806225419044495,
0.6107901930809021,
0.4414781332015991,
0.7309902310371399,
0.41966545581817627,
0.12177784740924835,
0.5738916993141174,
-0.09302061051130295,
-0.5418679118156433,
-0.8095055818557739,
-0.4976465106010437,
-0.33226895332336426,
0.49538183212280273,
0.46079280972480774,
-0.3698161840438843,
-0.3931783139705658,
0.4450805187225342,
-0.11049363762140274,
0.14462028443813324,
-0.42404621839523315,
0.7597981691360474,
-0.1182960495352745,
-0.5278173685073853,
0.4746088683605194,
-0.37348508834838867,
0.8201418519020081,
-0.5647268295288086,
-0.08656962960958481,
0.06968425959348679,
0.20814545452594757,
-0.2113603800535202,
-0.5461639761924744,
-0.1248532086610794,
-0.5885072946548462,
-0.2524524927139282,
-0.262645423412323,
0.8955195546150208,
-0.7492320537567139,
-0.42202022671699524,
0.1584356129169464,
0.7345220446586609,
-0.3124222457408905,
-0.03241346403956413,
-0.6076304912567139,
0.1863558143377304,
-0.200694277882576,
-0.12466089427471161,
0.03293634206056595,
0.544653594493866,
0.1099151074886322,
0.6119527220726013,
1.0041080713272095,
-0.2574414908885956,
0.1953446865081787,
0.05027947574853897,
0.8622864484786987,
-0.45341411232948303,
-0.37930482625961304,
-0.6439264416694641,
0.7028018832206726,
-0.4073020815849304,
-0.21386198699474335,
1.127941608428955,
0.6012430191040039,
0.98233962059021,
-0.03421200439333916,
0.715486466884613,
0.1283116191625595,
-0.12359802424907684,
-0.48183751106262207,
0.481999933719635,
-0.9305720329284668,
0.2289862185716629,
-0.13776154816150665,
-0.8090912699699402,
-0.1693984419107437,
0.1779354065656662,
-0.5001715421676636,
-0.04326905682682991,
0.4193043112754822,
0.708200216293335,
-0.37682971358299255,
-0.016004612669348717,
0.4796679615974426,
0.052468135952949524,
0.21215404570102692,
0.5914686918258667,
1.0859475135803223,
-0.2615482807159424,
0.6448351144790649,
-0.267304390668869,
-0.31147193908691406,
-0.3842768669128418,
-0.8517970442771912,
-0.9115056395530701,
-0.6868526339530945,
-0.24024872481822968,
-0.4245653450489044,
-0.0575033463537693,
0.8998054265975952,
0.8882576823234558,
-0.3207021951675415,
-0.10843217372894287,
0.2317809909582138,
0.33701828122138977,
-0.4114570915699005,
-0.2540111839771271,
0.19265663623809814,
-0.434101939201355,
-0.688489556312561,
0.3825172483921051,
0.39569875597953796,
0.07312536984682083,
-0.4388405978679657,
-0.05642605200409889,
-0.23088940978050232,
-0.016713669523596764,
1.057640790939331,
0.11651623249053955,
-0.6672595143318176,
-0.27848494052886963,
0.2248341292142868,
-0.13435213267803192,
-0.08124082535505295,
1.1615245342254639,
-0.7552231550216675,
0.5806999206542969,
0.6890792846679688,
0.39780908823013306,
0.2904343903064728,
0.11658494174480438,
0.5503178834915161,
-0.5836001038551331,
0.11371584981679916,
0.11724603176116943,
0.32290560007095337,
0.44371092319488525,
0.0274161659181118,
0.06862523406744003,
0.704609215259552,
-0.13929197192192078,
-0.47217580676078796,
0.4965660870075226,
-1.3948196172714233,
-0.5250287652015686,
1.3042103052139282,
0.19602446258068085,
-0.35694971680641174,
-0.6182379722595215,
-0.08131275326013565,
-0.05647783353924751,
-0.34839287400245667,
0.499345600605011,
0.2169876992702484,
0.22256679832935333,
0.09623178839683533,
-0.3101009428501129,
0.37683477997779846,
0.399026095867157,
-0.5758060216903687,
-0.04232276603579521,
0.8124343752861023,
0.353311687707901,
0.28593045473098755,
0.5654789805412292,
0.21777771413326263,
0.1653316617012024,
-0.06764519959688187,
-0.25386983156204224,
-0.5414797067642212,
-0.39952802658081055,
0.07729117572307587,
0.5293150544166565,
-0.2611999809741974,
-0.15917904675006866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05969v2 | Breaking Symmetry When Training Transformers | 2024-02-06T00:32:28 | 2024-06-16T22:18:36 | Chunsheng Zuo, Michael Guerzhoy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | As we show in this paper, the prediction for output token $n+1$ of
Transformer architectures without one of the mechanisms of positional encodings
and causal attention is invariant to permutations of input tokens $1, 2, ...,
n-1$. Usually, both mechanisms are employed and the symmetry with respect to
the input tokens is broken. Recently, it has been shown that one can train
Transformers without positional encodings. This must be enabled by the causal
attention mechanism. In this paper, we elaborate on the argument that the
causal connection mechanism must be responsible for the fact that Transformers
are able to model input sequences where the order is important. Vertical
"slices" of Transformers are all encouraged to represent the same location $k$
in the input sequence. We hypothesize that residual connections contribute to
this phenomenon, and demonstrate evidence for this. | [
-0.36382320523262024,
-0.16709579527378082,
0.6493488550186157,
0.1548517644405365,
-0.29973021149635315,
-0.22428938746452332,
0.49326634407043457,
-0.24269139766693115,
0.22297607362270355,
0.3476928174495697,
-0.9924446940422058,
0.007819144055247307,
-0.8817868232727051,
0.18495264649391174,
-0.8022864460945129,
0.9488077163696289,
-0.05885619297623634,
0.443034291267395,
-0.2760486602783203,
-0.3154909908771515,
-0.8860011696815491,
-0.5561274290084839,
-0.6706756949424744,
-0.5209822058677673,
0.9420480728149414,
0.1407383382320404,
0.7416843771934509,
0.9878487586975098,
0.5919755697250366,
0.3888171911239624,
0.10186493396759033,
-0.3997688889503479,
-0.6976587772369385,
0.252858430147171,
-0.22004260122776031,
-0.9478930234909058,
-0.11009039729833603,
0.0676070898771286,
0.7484697103500366,
0.755687415599823,
0.0013738902052864432,
0.1789526343345642,
0.1313197761774063,
0.48491623997688293,
-0.42076927423477173,
0.0669974759221077,
-0.6410009860992432,
0.3624855875968933,
-0.07025784999132156,
-0.30699387192726135,
-0.4947478175163269,
-0.10374901443719864,
-0.17914767563343048,
-0.4954400956630707,
0.5051741003990173,
-0.30482807755470276,
1.2433120012283325,
0.5658129453659058,
-0.36467334628105164,
0.45538145303726196,
-1.0761104822158813,
0.4691852927207947,
-0.25111642479896545,
0.7715834379196167,
0.37111881375312805,
0.5473141670227051,
-0.029452510178089142,
-0.681536853313446,
-0.41307997703552246,
0.2886950373649597,
-0.33932366967201233,
0.45796382427215576,
0.023769278079271317,
-0.01601097732782364,
0.6255006194114685,
0.17326951026916504,
-0.2740039825439453,
0.17447759211063385,
-0.6042965054512024,
0.1849069893360138,
0.13675886392593384,
0.37738871574401855,
0.2131803184747696,
-0.07396138459444046,
-0.572056770324707,
-0.2310347855091095,
-0.6360393166542053,
0.18522831797599792,
0.40380439162254333,
-0.07917050272226334,
-0.36278465390205383,
0.5523213744163513,
0.21759966015815735,
0.6132513880729675,
0.6621200442314148,
-0.015100632794201374,
0.055562250316143036,
-0.14539214968681335,
-0.2642226815223694,
0.2736912965774536,
0.76173335313797,
0.0545496866106987,
0.095607690513134,
-0.4166214168071747,
-0.02140963077545166,
0.24638065695762634,
0.6909626126289368,
-0.44591453671455383,
0.060052499175071716,
0.020556675270199776,
-0.48055028915405273,
-0.43365907669067383,
0.5901619791984558,
-0.5909519791603088,
-0.10325691103935242,
-0.5640024542808533,
0.38569849729537964,
-0.3415570855140686,
0.020425787195563316,
-0.02511070854961872,
-0.37173086404800415,
0.5252438187599182,
-0.03506040200591087,
-1.3327100276947021,
0.21075966954231262,
0.8000631332397461,
0.5267359614372253,
0.05178944393992424,
-0.7322039604187012,
-0.47350767254829407,
0.2680152356624603,
-0.16839289665222168,
0.7917150855064392,
-0.3819415867328644,
-0.06760182231664658,
0.05649242177605629,
0.33099138736724854,
-0.24239304661750793,
-0.41382089257240295,
0.3948880136013031,
-0.6382468938827515,
0.3712998628616333,
-0.44401538372039795,
-0.30064353346824646,
0.06845889985561371,
-0.11232684552669525,
-0.7819881439208984,
0.45336511731147766,
0.13120079040527344,
-0.7939624190330505,
0.6840837001800537,
-0.19983308017253876,
-0.5889200568199158,
-0.28618761897087097,
-0.3972036838531494,
-0.5440733432769775,
0.29814720153808594,
0.1460365206003189,
0.02540481835603714,
-0.11935387551784515,
0.3606726825237274,
-0.7132925987243652,
-0.6074571013450623,
0.37694495916366577,
-0.7100402116775513,
1.0671825408935547,
-0.09285872429609299,
-0.5272413492202759,
0.1467171311378479,
-0.7268849015235901,
-0.6433378458023071,
0.39511188864707947,
-0.021220441907644272,
0.0464230477809906,
0.2134224772453308,
-0.2991165816783905,
0.5179898738861084,
-0.09475059062242508,
-0.5655859708786011,
0.0955360159277916,
-0.5797178745269775,
0.315994530916214,
1.1137045621871948,
-0.02052759751677513,
0.6979196667671204,
-0.12968023121356964,
0.3933945596218109,
0.38352251052856445,
0.418623149394989,
-0.12496108561754227,
-0.30213242769241333,
-1.0364758968353271,
-0.1389678716659546,
0.19642174243927002,
0.29877999424934387,
-0.5365905165672302,
0.4706958532333374,
-0.21709062159061432,
-0.3630830943584442,
-0.18498162925243378,
-0.2540779411792755,
0.16211318969726562,
0.6530452966690063,
0.2153186947107315,
-0.1717936247587204,
-0.6836597323417664,
-0.8133729100227356,
-0.44679689407348633,
-0.2523373067378998,
-0.1408710926771164,
-0.030133573338389397,
0.23678527772426605,
0.027442634105682373,
0.9735110402107239,
-0.438372403383255,
-0.21560607850551605,
-0.16370868682861328,
-0.0010204012505710125,
0.5941002368927002,
0.50436931848526,
0.5490069389343262,
-0.5914497375488281,
-0.19406433403491974,
-0.23055289685726166,
-1.0451221466064453,
0.21318934857845306,
-0.25913766026496887,
-0.34775814414024353,
-0.057501066476106644,
0.6731646656990051,
-0.8869870901107788,
0.5848736763000488,
0.38097089529037476,
-0.3322694003582001,
0.27560558915138245,
0.3254943788051605,
-0.22404108941555023,
-1.014472484588623,
-0.013340719975531101,
0.046913228929042816,
0.07510077208280563,
-0.6659208536148071,
-0.22286835312843323,
-0.004564702045172453,
-0.4462428390979767,
-0.4413248598575592,
0.31699422001838684,
-0.163230761885643,
-0.1703067123889923,
-0.08347364515066147,
-0.27476537227630615,
-0.10027115792036057,
0.7447985410690308,
-0.14304521679878235,
0.17259396612644196,
0.5080851316452026,
-0.40591657161712646,
0.20484714210033417,
0.49284636974334717,
0.16006308794021606,
0.4916476309299469,
-0.9102318286895752,
-0.13339826464653015,
-0.2430141121149063,
0.23500728607177734,
-1.0488324165344238,
-0.15725520253181458,
0.4881048798561096,
-0.443837970495224,
0.47985678911209106,
-0.10680021345615387,
-0.3477526605129242,
-0.3104526996612549,
-0.04317395016551018,
0.704014778137207,
0.5771517753601074,
-0.9214043021202087,
0.609237015247345,
-0.009953908622264862,
0.5735227465629578,
-0.8088530898094177,
-0.55821293592453,
-0.3959692418575287,
-0.2773769795894623,
-0.6111751198768616,
0.10491090267896652,
0.5746251940727234,
0.040540486574172974,
0.05837225541472435,
-0.7200106382369995,
0.014671009965240955,
0.22483591735363007,
0.4924273192882538,
0.2916654050350189,
-0.27741146087646484,
-0.12861722707748413,
0.2565467953681946,
-0.4938017725944519,
0.46268942952156067,
-0.2505984306335449,
0.6822639107704163,
0.46684330701828003,
-0.6773529052734375,
-0.7608726024627686,
0.22854939103126526,
1.0538511276245117,
-0.2578108012676239,
0.9654582142829895,
0.6779056191444397,
-0.38716739416122437,
0.0998288244009018,
-0.36847132444381714,
-0.548896849155426,
-0.5855759382247925,
0.22539348900318146,
-0.38079676032066345,
-0.5958436131477356,
0.5579140782356262,
0.1727084070444107,
-0.11506647616624832,
0.5486716628074646,
0.17708107829093933,
-0.3385738730430603,
1.3008216619491577,
0.6838458180427551,
-0.1723751276731491,
0.8446924686431885,
-0.06842296570539474,
0.531394362449646,
-0.5474978089332581,
-0.14702945947647095,
-0.6317432522773743,
-0.6547417044639587,
-0.5894198417663574,
0.23098117113113403,
0.21712307631969452,
0.18798556923866272,
-0.6376110911369324,
0.40550947189331055,
-0.4063393473625183,
0.5381945371627808,
0.5727984309196472,
0.17069390416145325,
-0.008474772796034813,
0.38397207856178284,
-0.07139376550912857,
-0.099056176841259,
-0.92659592628479,
0.083409383893013,
0.7309243083000183,
0.44083163142204285,
0.799731969833374,
-0.14853712916374207,
0.7579579949378967,
-0.3617981970310211,
0.2490912526845932,
-0.7056736350059509,
0.38616225123405457,
-0.13480950891971588,
-0.41257476806640625,
-0.2189246118068695,
-0.2929530143737793,
-1.2107089757919312,
0.10164511948823929,
0.03488416224718094,
-0.7604952454566956,
0.6134595274925232,
0.10372498631477356,
0.18251994252204895,
0.30930402874946594,
-0.4855245053768158,
1.0564390420913696,
-0.14921221137046814,
-0.2390526682138443,
0.03127427026629448,
-0.8666101098060608,
0.512572705745697,
0.21571128070354462,
-0.3817342519760132,
0.3729073703289032,
0.6509601473808289,
0.6150959730148315,
-0.6357424855232239,
0.903664231300354,
-0.18240024149417877,
0.05504370480775833,
-0.06611200422048569,
0.01453175488859415,
0.4829299747943878,
0.15444612503051758,
0.45725178718566895,
0.5380110740661621,
-0.39395609498023987,
-0.41931629180908203,
-0.8077865839004517,
0.31079190969467163,
-1.1751328706741333,
-0.878048300743103,
-0.49467864632606506,
-0.45086029171943665,
-0.25001657009124756,
0.16596457362174988,
0.8522903323173523,
0.5471910834312439,
0.19649291038513184,
0.125025674700737,
0.4467717707157135,
0.09621775895357132,
0.4439854323863983,
-0.07949276268482208,
-0.04083196446299553,
-0.29517117142677307,
0.7167485356330872,
0.14534668624401093,
0.38500186800956726,
0.3611578941345215,
0.010382410138845444,
-0.148612841963768,
0.006229587364941835,
-0.22177213430404663,
0.49953824281692505,
-0.6849043369293213,
-0.16690531373023987,
-0.5070730447769165,
-0.39945483207702637,
-0.25594136118888855,
-0.21817997097969055,
-0.3551380932331085,
-0.40008217096328735,
-0.4274192750453949,
-0.2977786064147949,
-0.18455253541469574,
0.6784951090812683,
0.0998682975769043,
0.215293750166893,
-0.8734431862831116,
0.5548484921455383,
0.513958215713501,
0.5210393071174622,
0.23635528981685638,
-0.6435931324958801,
-0.3829406797885895,
-0.03817001357674599,
-0.495259165763855,
-0.8401715159416199,
0.15548670291900635,
-0.31881117820739746,
0.578041136264801,
0.9327784180641174,
-0.3716413676738739,
0.8807703852653503,
-0.9765408635139465,
0.5794445276260376,
0.6365277767181396,
-0.9451093673706055,
0.2755972146987915,
-0.4869544208049774,
0.448208749294281,
0.27014726400375366,
0.3399381637573242,
-0.5794034004211426,
-0.7468587160110474,
-0.6511218547821045,
-0.6530697345733643,
1.16912841796875,
0.03910103440284729,
0.04945046454668045,
-0.09596168994903564,
0.2731608748435974,
0.24491430819034576,
-0.107823945581913,
-0.6675757169723511,
-0.6016395688056946,
-0.6988146901130676,
-0.2586635947227478,
-0.03230834752321243,
-0.2550652027130127,
-0.4201849400997162,
-0.42915183305740356,
0.2667568027973175,
0.3245197832584381,
0.8194932341575623,
0.008713353425264359,
0.04505585879087448,
-0.3502073884010315,
-0.3529250919818878,
0.7399367690086365,
0.7553342580795288,
0.13180601596832275,
0.12882530689239502,
-0.18160566687583923,
-0.49071377515792847,
0.5602448582649231,
-0.18396268784999847,
-0.22698082029819489,
0.1394544392824173,
0.2501154839992523,
1.0021768808364868,
0.335463285446167,
0.10752837359905243,
0.2430892437696457,
-0.3584742546081543,
-0.34120675921440125,
-0.1746608316898346,
0.08341044932603836,
0.006386368535459042,
0.2667112946510315,
0.2955380380153656,
0.5977075695991516,
-0.12466001510620117,
-0.22948960959911346,
0.3385492265224457,
0.3018997311592102,
-0.7832174301147461,
-0.5408663153648376,
1.0129050016403198,
-0.10985490679740906,
-0.5151851773262024,
0.8554319143295288,
0.3459528684616089,
-0.4361235201358795,
0.7801946997642517,
0.8978888392448425,
1.2577834129333496,
-0.33838242292404175,
0.08801711350679398,
0.4482247531414032,
0.45701396465301514,
-0.17826338112354279,
-0.2390400767326355,
0.11161427944898605,
-0.8325846791267395,
-0.41276082396507263,
-0.41976937651634216,
-0.067690409719944,
-0.08397037535905838,
-0.9445598125457764,
0.6406680941581726,
-0.5287874937057495,
-0.03529147431254387,
-0.21148668229579926,
-1.1196515560150146,
-0.710692286491394,
-0.01775890402495861,
0.21139906346797943,
0.44900137186050415,
-1.0762383937835693,
0.6516156196594238,
0.5612919330596924,
-0.4656989276409149,
-0.9215897917747498,
0.1871165931224823,
-0.16020046174526215,
-0.6984738707542419,
0.9743133783340454,
0.26392173767089844,
-0.049580175429582596,
-0.270633727312088,
-0.5765718221664429,
-1.2603267431259155,
1.0307867527008057,
0.7933240532875061,
-0.33509236574172974,
-0.08558717370033264,
0.5006064176559448,
0.3983548581600189,
0.06828688830137253,
-0.01809941604733467,
0.30798327922821045,
0.2949248254299164,
-0.09160898625850677,
-0.4721696674823761,
0.01001389604061842,
-0.16170255839824677,
-0.02747492864727974,
0.5797243714332581,
-0.7916708588600159,
0.9857714772224426,
0.26458942890167236,
-0.5557234287261963,
-0.09861022979021072,
0.5996718406677246,
0.21594391763210297,
0.029919682070612907,
0.3515283763408661,
0.8828188180923462,
0.1464361995458603,
-0.2995854616165161,
1.0367170572280884,
-0.2582467794418335,
0.5805644392967224,
1.0198272466659546,
-0.18600422143936157,
0.2597699463367462,
0.7834010720252991,
-0.20358480513095856,
0.5570352077484131,
0.4026716947555542,
-0.36974528431892395,
0.6542128920555115,
-0.24550418555736542,
0.24084465205669403,
-0.1821131855249405,
0.21075358986854553,
-0.40474337339401245,
0.5492681264877319,
0.0396675206720829,
-0.5616682767868042,
-0.36645716428756714,
-0.07689012587070465,
-0.08745625615119934,
-0.26423513889312744,
-0.18111808598041534,
0.6025518178939819,
0.08277687430381775,
-0.6162306070327759,
0.6808858513832092,
-0.19020581245422363,
0.06149325147271156,
-0.5656974911689758,
-0.14460940659046173,
-0.4571046233177185,
0.2622928321361542,
-0.28061312437057495,
-0.2883620858192444,
0.3613494038581848,
-0.3671380877494812,
-0.4511708915233612,
-0.3183809816837311,
0.6302977800369263,
-0.07784879952669144,
-0.5793096423149109,
0.3045637607574463,
0.05037284642457962,
-0.34866777062416077,
0.3328140676021576,
-0.4232889413833618,
-0.16727082431316376,
-0.11020328104496002,
-0.32397863268852234,
0.6010256409645081,
0.5417384505271912,
0.1555444896221161,
0.3575626015663147,
0.5343389511108398,
-0.34029048681259155,
0.3850322961807251,
0.12719078361988068,
0.7974203824996948,
-0.6531065106391907,
-0.47414910793304443,
-1.0935378074645996,
0.7453473806381226,
0.11952749639749527,
-0.30177661776542664,
0.6857641935348511,
0.20251229405403137,
1.0085768699645996,
-0.3318819999694824,
0.37837278842926025,
0.43671131134033203,
-0.21736964583396912,
-0.41431891918182373,
0.7030996680259705,
-0.31094270944595337,
0.06863253563642502,
-0.23124992847442627,
-1.3753407001495361,
-0.41009819507598877,
0.5179721713066101,
-0.26921597123146057,
-0.12848831713199615,
1.270050287246704,
0.23268942534923553,
-0.40128472447395325,
0.16807204484939575,
0.357616126537323,
0.22387558221817017,
0.2999011278152466,
0.31105273962020874,
0.8657097220420837,
-0.7057148218154907,
0.43890663981437683,
-0.28412190079689026,
0.1575535535812378,
0.07726586610078812,
-0.3795299530029297,
-0.8307085037231445,
-0.41524097323417664,
-0.018164856359362602,
-0.5000854730606079,
-0.22788985073566437,
0.2515503168106079,
0.4249642491340637,
-0.6267752051353455,
-0.35207706689834595,
-0.6067153215408325,
0.4115269184112549,
-0.6056639552116394,
-0.21960745751857758,
0.27831414341926575,
-0.6097060441970825,
-0.5690889358520508,
0.028034798800945282,
0.57277512550354,
-0.1550811231136322,
-0.24549594521522522,
0.23069553077220917,
-0.07226212322711945,
-0.18444928526878357,
0.43840470910072327,
0.3361845016479492,
-0.6719276309013367,
-0.5434278249740601,
0.2376275658607483,
-0.04267179220914841,
0.47145190834999084,
0.8905723094940186,
-0.7996231317520142,
0.11063111573457718,
0.4783650040626526,
0.705299437046051,
0.530614972114563,
0.07092032581567764,
0.787138819694519,
-0.6304810047149658,
0.37415534257888794,
-0.01352174486964941,
0.6814604997634888,
-0.15087570250034332,
-0.4125046133995056,
0.26952388882637024,
0.540540874004364,
-0.43285679817199707,
-0.8331422209739685,
0.5083513855934143,
-0.9057751297950745,
-0.005180760752409697,
0.8775267601013184,
-0.018968598917126656,
-0.4591915011405945,
0.0010282028233632445,
0.060932572931051254,
0.5624182820320129,
-0.08582131564617157,
0.9255897998809814,
0.5647920370101929,
-0.07661615312099457,
-0.13001582026481628,
-0.10587523877620697,
0.0921836867928505,
0.7091187834739685,
-0.2604437470436096,
-0.2264757752418518,
0.18281766772270203,
0.13614848256111145,
0.32637083530426025,
-0.14882385730743408,
-0.40642794966697693,
0.5076497197151184,
0.2104584276676178,
-0.052661411464214325,
0.14493311941623688,
-0.4781430661678314,
-0.6977167725563049,
0.29862654209136963,
-0.07660827040672302,
-0.42094114422798157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03597v1 | Identifying Reasons for Contraceptive Switching from Real-World Data Using Large Language Models | 2024-02-06T00:14:53 | 2024-02-06T00:14:53 | Brenda Y. Miao, Christopher YK Williams, Ebenezer Chinedu-Eneh, Travis Zack, Emily Alsentzer, Atul J. Butte, Irene Y. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Prescription contraceptives play a critical role in supporting women's
reproductive health. With nearly 50 million women in the United States using
contraceptives, understanding the factors that drive contraceptives selection
and switching is of significant interest. However, many factors related to
medication switching are often only captured in unstructured clinical notes and
can be difficult to extract. Here, we evaluate the zero-shot abilities of a
recently developed large language model, GPT-4 (via HIPAA-compliant Microsoft
Azure API), to identify reasons for switching between classes of contraceptives
from the UCSF Information Commons clinical notes dataset. We demonstrate that
GPT-4 can accurately extract reasons for contraceptive switching, outperforming
baseline BERT-based models with microF1 scores of 0.849 and 0.881 for
contraceptive start and stop extraction, respectively. Human evaluation of
GPT-4-extracted reasons for switching showed 91.4% accuracy, with minimal
hallucinations. Using extracted reasons, we identified patient preference,
adverse events, and insurance as key reasons for switching using unsupervised
topic modeling approaches. Notably, we also showed using our approach that
"weight gain/mood change" and "insurance coverage" are disproportionately found
as reasons for contraceptive switching in specific demographic populations. Our
code and supplemental data are available at
https://github.com/BMiao10/contraceptive-switching. | [
-0.1270952671766281,
-0.7327818274497986,
0.8551616072654724,
0.21679645776748657,
-0.18267042934894562,
-0.4083794951438904,
0.045486196875572205,
-0.49114492535591125,
-0.2595088481903076,
0.6283031702041626,
-0.6315368413925171,
-0.5069010257720947,
-0.5327029824256897,
-0.10493411123752594,
-0.5681938529014587,
1.2120989561080933,
-0.17766264081001282,
0.15356823801994324,
-0.05862707644701004,
0.30494678020477295,
-0.5576943755149841,
-0.5227139592170715,
-0.24989740550518036,
-0.5330756306648254,
0.8998051881790161,
0.49122923612594604,
0.503186047077179,
0.2644909918308258,
0.5039406418800354,
0.03777305781841278,
0.08250182121992111,
-0.2998073399066925,
-0.20007456839084625,
-0.0689549446105957,
-0.14770451188087463,
-0.6937378644943237,
-0.5146026611328125,
0.17791269719600677,
0.23819419741630554,
0.6982524991035461,
-0.3362274169921875,
0.4324027895927429,
-0.08461577445268631,
0.559283435344696,
-0.6696420311927795,
0.1992923617362976,
-0.6297981142997742,
0.15329432487487793,
-0.6035850644111633,
0.06584877520799637,
-0.3979759216308594,
0.05512489378452301,
0.4722661077976227,
-0.34937819838523865,
0.3869648873806,
-0.3824212849140167,
1.0894207954406738,
0.0057691484689712524,
-0.8127077221870422,
-0.15620897710323334,
-1.0135217905044556,
0.6515251994132996,
-0.659666895866394,
0.7773228287696838,
0.3916842043399811,
-0.0006432427326217294,
-0.11332865059375763,
-0.43652451038360596,
-0.518664538860321,
-0.24743056297302246,
0.11338341236114502,
0.11623864620923996,
-0.4454265236854553,
-0.0703040137887001,
0.4136551022529602,
-0.036016013473272324,
-0.5392211079597473,
0.03460900858044624,
-0.5005065202713013,
-0.15093328058719635,
0.38009172677993774,
0.0712209939956665,
0.4759313762187958,
0.027191834524273872,
-0.14696495234966278,
-0.0672081932425499,
-0.7807140350341797,
0.10062415152788162,
0.4274175763130188,
0.3409915864467621,
-0.33491796255111694,
0.699906051158905,
0.3628242015838623,
0.5582007765769958,
0.05467977374792099,
0.16900557279586792,
0.08832987397909164,
-0.11085913330316544,
-0.27987152338027954,
-0.007599431090056896,
0.5750882029533386,
0.31270748376846313,
-0.14423280954360962,
-0.12446644902229309,
0.25099098682403564,
-0.07797340303659439,
0.3588436245918274,
-0.8729057312011719,
-0.23840898275375366,
0.371652752161026,
-0.7430097460746765,
-0.06918856501579285,
-0.09691286087036133,
-0.8572384715080261,
-0.19849316775798798,
-0.47343575954437256,
0.16684529185295105,
-0.5386271476745605,
-0.16506467759609222,
0.16641727089881897,
-0.2463981956243515,
0.3337308466434479,
0.44497206807136536,
-1.007702112197876,
0.3481318950653076,
0.7277217507362366,
1.0007811784744263,
-0.5667904019355774,
-0.1564294546842575,
-0.20693296194076538,
-0.12293445318937302,
-0.3791528642177582,
0.8564918041229248,
-0.1410611867904663,
-0.4132791757583618,
0.22888199985027313,
-0.0008991907234303653,
-0.36706727743148804,
-0.58195960521698,
0.5084283947944641,
-0.2552240788936615,
0.6416573524475098,
-0.6597131490707397,
-0.574984610080719,
-0.07205478101968765,
0.21514984965324402,
-0.6583148241043091,
0.3648708760738373,
-0.034233689308166504,
-0.5686951875686646,
0.559829831123352,
-0.4803606867790222,
-0.46878430247306824,
0.04834982380270958,
-0.12631553411483765,
-0.613361120223999,
0.13130372762680054,
-0.19602295756340027,
0.16785430908203125,
-0.3787842392921448,
0.29292070865631104,
-0.28798428177833557,
-0.1437482386827469,
0.5893306136131287,
-0.6542263031005859,
0.7531828284263611,
0.08537574857473373,
-0.11043709516525269,
0.09813983738422394,
-0.5013909339904785,
-0.419283390045166,
0.11322218924760818,
-0.2551156282424927,
-0.4492626488208771,
0.015385104343295097,
0.39380085468292236,
0.273713082075119,
0.10687977820634842,
-0.7086681723594666,
0.30378955602645874,
0.052804261445999146,
0.3210146129131317,
0.543351411819458,
0.4068485200405121,
0.16917753219604492,
-0.2417982816696167,
0.6384198069572449,
0.06907084584236145,
0.4062459170818329,
0.1644047200679779,
-0.9585555791854858,
-0.21809275448322296,
-0.16801267862319946,
0.4459308087825775,
0.46318796277046204,
-0.41389861702919006,
-0.08339492976665497,
0.029957540333271027,
-0.1395682990550995,
-0.21712535619735718,
0.10144953429698944,
0.27310898900032043,
0.6534332036972046,
0.4638434052467346,
0.02696666494011879,
-0.18189646303653717,
-0.7158584594726562,
-0.3418249785900116,
-0.30548885464668274,
0.0461592823266983,
0.13474801182746887,
0.5525948405265808,
-0.31420382857322693,
1.0643771886825562,
-0.8479956388473511,
-0.08855139464139938,
-0.4102020263671875,
0.22638854384422302,
0.40932539105415344,
0.31808215379714966,
0.3472597301006317,
-0.7700813412666321,
-0.21689382195472717,
-0.1591103971004486,
-0.25351545214653015,
-0.35886886715888977,
-0.6424742341041565,
-0.4102586507797241,
-0.14293602108955383,
0.3800050914287567,
-0.7719481587409973,
0.5232656598091125,
0.3658316433429718,
-0.340609610080719,
0.8231096267700195,
-0.39846405386924744,
-0.2515961527824402,
-0.789291501045227,
0.22825683653354645,
0.19139863550662994,
0.20606057345867157,
-0.7613591551780701,
-0.16854740679264069,
0.37362560629844666,
-0.08301883935928345,
-0.5681830048561096,
0.472709059715271,
-0.2871323823928833,
0.11685781180858612,
0.1613290160894394,
-0.3531249165534973,
-0.25228098034858704,
0.134254589676857,
-0.1787407249212265,
0.3627236485481262,
-0.10675796121358871,
-0.5280680656433105,
0.15517252683639526,
0.5596258044242859,
0.06360393762588501,
0.43842288851737976,
-0.47364428639411926,
-0.1553419977426529,
0.12267313152551651,
0.19039681553840637,
-0.9805751442909241,
-0.19730454683303833,
0.3546915352344513,
-0.1388561874628067,
0.2918443977832794,
-0.6149854063987732,
-0.05643684044480324,
-0.40910863876342773,
0.004925225395709276,
-0.014825704507529736,
0.3467589318752289,
-0.3147256076335907,
0.4232082664966583,
0.23626796901226044,
-0.2980162501335144,
-0.29564687609672546,
-0.8031328320503235,
0.3939741551876068,
-0.16458185017108917,
0.10812447965145111,
0.5099312663078308,
0.13132865726947784,
-0.1729058027267456,
0.13052701950073242,
-0.2731023132801056,
-0.055941130965948105,
-0.3960517942905426,
0.3085661828517914,
0.7114762663841248,
0.22262856364250183,
0.44304218888282776,
0.33127355575561523,
-0.25347259640693665,
0.31968989968299866,
-0.42120158672332764,
0.5548725724220276,
0.30600255727767944,
-0.23435498774051666,
-0.32845842838287354,
0.49901121854782104,
0.4466172456741333,
-0.2188996821641922,
0.505483865737915,
0.24287089705467224,
-0.3543820381164551,
-0.20237748324871063,
-0.4103493392467499,
-0.03834119066596031,
-0.30076301097869873,
0.24016238749027252,
0.013279871083796024,
-0.3647952079772949,
0.6137389540672302,
0.07384887337684631,
0.07771072536706924,
0.3609217703342438,
0.630806565284729,
0.0006017019040882587,
0.7133898735046387,
0.32268425822257996,
0.16669276356697083,
0.7620573043823242,
-0.13209164142608643,
0.22822733223438263,
-0.5601523518562317,
-0.25913602113723755,
-0.20522141456604004,
-0.18801911175251007,
-0.4540272057056427,
-0.33854636549949646,
0.2849900722503662,
-0.2920343279838562,
-0.21300382912158966,
0.23325476050376892,
-0.3687306344509125,
0.035643674433231354,
0.06653192639350891,
0.24834027886390686,
0.23191338777542114,
-0.016836123540997505,
-0.16793988645076752,
-0.11030086874961853,
-0.38603734970092773,
-0.0658889040350914,
1.3748559951782227,
0.30262601375579834,
0.7959520220756531,
0.2878054082393646,
0.4554656445980072,
0.3573039472103119,
0.44935768842697144,
-0.5732744336128235,
0.6455124616622925,
-0.6865331530570984,
-0.7522431015968323,
-0.15814101696014404,
-0.7575158476829529,
-1.1709864139556885,
0.3958010971546173,
-0.37164416909217834,
-0.5896371006965637,
0.32521718740463257,
0.19136708974838257,
-0.4335479140281677,
0.20070935785770416,
-0.9336881041526794,
1.1203923225402832,
-0.5792148113250732,
-0.49763023853302,
0.08538342267274857,
-0.4663494825363159,
0.4281446039676666,
-0.025799626484513283,
-0.11688066273927689,
-0.35876038670539856,
0.09724830836057663,
0.39955082535743713,
-0.48720118403434753,
0.8069008588790894,
-0.18842865526676178,
-0.32746097445487976,
-0.09436408430337906,
-0.05856332927942276,
-0.10836638510227203,
-0.040703848004341125,
0.2579233944416046,
0.5976884365081787,
0.04551367461681366,
0.019137198105454445,
-0.4602089524269104,
0.7450827956199646,
-0.6462472081184387,
-0.38897672295570374,
-0.5894590616226196,
-0.4905087351799011,
-0.2520284950733185,
0.2980867922306061,
0.33601438999176025,
0.3096911907196045,
-0.16960346698760986,
-0.20267897844314575,
0.37514135241508484,
-0.4422800838947296,
0.3427852690219879,
0.8025472164154053,
-0.4167560935020447,
-0.08210224658250809,
0.46247655153274536,
0.6730448603630066,
0.2671796977519989,
0.5035174489021301,
0.5584681034088135,
-0.631942868232727,
-0.3053341507911682,
-0.5473152995109558,
0.3628750145435333,
-0.20019443333148956,
0.09943103045225143,
-0.6667590737342834,
-0.05210400000214577,
-0.5139062404632568,
0.18914319574832916,
-0.2327742874622345,
-0.13374802470207214,
-0.4386667311191559,
-0.2058929204940796,
0.2987866699695587,
0.404824435710907,
0.19393372535705566,
-0.0011354415910318494,
-0.9002037644386292,
0.34785160422325134,
0.5111455321311951,
0.3351966142654419,
-0.12765811383724213,
-0.2581982910633087,
0.17184975743293762,
-0.3612816333770752,
-0.3253071904182434,
-1.5345395803451538,
0.37341657280921936,
-0.10626646131277084,
0.5543487668037415,
0.5674024224281311,
0.04055316373705864,
0.8492261171340942,
-0.37375926971435547,
0.579443097114563,
0.13462543487548828,
-0.9251773953437805,
0.313973993062973,
-0.6952037215232849,
0.5868951082229614,
0.4221900701522827,
0.3754139840602875,
-0.8209124803543091,
0.16932819783687592,
-0.4289495050907135,
-0.9110550284385681,
0.5311378836631775,
0.3715674579143524,
-0.12735046446323395,
0.02080676332116127,
0.5983091592788696,
0.0905076190829277,
0.30479592084884644,
-0.6764642596244812,
-0.16103844344615936,
0.022669080644845963,
-0.009761654771864414,
0.16296055912971497,
0.017443832010030746,
-0.1076301783323288,
-0.1206742525100708,
0.3584420382976532,
-0.07585525512695312,
0.3269377648830414,
0.2439454346895218,
0.0700734332203865,
-0.08209428191184998,
0.680824339389801,
0.680829644203186,
0.7305752635002136,
-0.481932133436203,
0.18567456305027008,
0.03133907541632652,
-0.8477137684822083,
0.1094122976064682,
0.7523151636123657,
-0.7140457630157471,
0.06749750673770905,
0.526678740978241,
0.727254331111908,
0.3648310899734497,
-0.5929659605026245,
0.46269309520721436,
0.02650076523423195,
-0.2199430614709854,
-0.34815090894699097,
-0.07453170418739319,
0.005467700771987438,
-0.20023992657661438,
0.20343303680419922,
-0.005443065892904997,
0.20653827488422394,
-0.7935878038406372,
-0.0017380911158397794,
0.3228132724761963,
-0.4346923828125,
-0.3166855573654175,
0.6014426946640015,
0.07173822820186615,
-0.11911388486623764,
0.5698851943016052,
-0.07438506931066513,
-0.24782954156398773,
0.6027774214744568,
0.865515410900116,
0.7690079212188721,
-0.406667560338974,
0.5556696057319641,
0.19718359410762787,
0.15613077580928802,
-0.1676279455423355,
0.12616023421287537,
0.3509771525859833,
-0.7385746240615845,
-0.11163163930177689,
-0.05504937097430229,
-0.6544697880744934,
0.16525427997112274,
-0.937976062297821,
0.3337261378765106,
-0.3353557884693146,
-0.4330978989601135,
0.09049282968044281,
-0.3486456871032715,
-0.7271349430084229,
0.021019387990236282,
0.481384813785553,
0.7075992822647095,
-0.9775159358978271,
0.6144406795501709,
0.7608930468559265,
-0.5748152732849121,
-0.6092879176139832,
0.28866398334503174,
0.24547100067138672,
-0.41740721464157104,
0.1402653455734253,
-0.05289769172668457,
0.1746797412633896,
-0.49667349457740784,
-0.44724324345588684,
-0.5222262144088745,
0.9547114968299866,
0.39536941051483154,
-0.9116920232772827,
-0.28529632091522217,
0.4260996878147125,
0.5021620988845825,
-0.3442199230194092,
0.3673805296421051,
0.6472368240356445,
0.23449207842350006,
0.14938677847385406,
-0.6042291522026062,
-0.06891530007123947,
-0.0579802505671978,
-0.07193608582019806,
0.587266206741333,
-0.3538452982902527,
1.3798692226409912,
-0.3676318824291229,
0.012285735458135605,
-0.20858962833881378,
-0.19303245842456818,
0.2788752615451813,
0.5506564378738403,
0.5950809717178345,
0.49026378989219666,
0.6197813749313354,
0.04138194024562836,
0.8714334964752197,
-0.017222676426172256,
0.45123979449272156,
1.165724515914917,
-0.8170562386512756,
1.233710527420044,
0.45287588238716125,
-0.32519444823265076,
0.7005257606506348,
0.20778435468673706,
-0.10416770726442337,
0.22532813251018524,
-0.11571153998374939,
-0.17156797647476196,
-0.32463064789772034,
0.38794559240341187,
-0.4423081576824188,
0.5972991585731506,
0.3599992096424103,
-0.35817965865135193,
-0.4696009159088135,
0.10150232166051865,
0.33386918902397156,
-0.5681777000427246,
-0.06752374768257141,
0.5958291888237,
0.0457300990819931,
-0.724420964717865,
0.11559905856847763,
-0.14203965663909912,
0.021628189831972122,
-1.1076066493988037,
-0.3859270513057709,
-0.171615868806839,
0.40882283449172974,
-0.24961264431476593,
-0.6570287346839905,
-0.03511748090386391,
0.2815247178077698,
-0.13859011232852936,
-0.5753355026245117,
0.7749731540679932,
-0.42761677503585815,
-0.493387907743454,
0.2792360782623291,
0.5646408796310425,
-0.049925073981285095,
-0.05717794597148895,
-0.9082739353179932,
-0.2474903166294098,
0.10232965648174286,
-0.048145513981580734,
0.5827218294143677,
0.4104462265968323,
-0.42270299792289734,
0.34823670983314514,
1.3310332298278809,
0.3837176561355591,
-0.3037453293800354,
0.27970224618911743,
0.6601355075836182,
-0.835101306438446,
-0.6120728254318237,
-0.9592260718345642,
0.44549670815467834,
-0.17261768877506256,
-0.722406268119812,
0.9750751852989197,
0.5787018537521362,
0.22653929889202118,
-0.2970542013645172,
0.6341750621795654,
0.19577163457870483,
0.7070639729499817,
-0.4759357273578644,
1.0636532306671143,
-0.27781787514686584,
0.4178706705570221,
-0.28459641337394714,
-0.6738619208335876,
-0.49423426389694214,
0.34305933117866516,
-0.6381247043609619,
-0.1779167354106903,
0.5968897938728333,
0.2584773898124695,
-0.06041417643427849,
0.030762678012251854,
0.21419981122016907,
0.507502555847168,
0.8370678424835205,
0.2521832287311554,
0.5885941982269287,
-0.22768379747867584,
0.6621480584144592,
0.23498237133026123,
-0.32243043184280396,
-0.21649298071861267,
-1.070252537727356,
-0.5119946002960205,
-0.31471747159957886,
-0.45915696024894714,
-0.39473071694374084,
0.056627992540597916,
0.7829219698905945,
0.5521435737609863,
-0.6819438934326172,
-0.17396987974643707,
-0.23323528468608856,
0.10403512418270111,
-0.41177892684936523,
-0.18079525232315063,
0.0453110970556736,
-0.11364029347896576,
-0.047665782272815704,
-0.05576053634285927,
0.2422959804534912,
-0.05165359377861023,
-0.1387016475200653,
0.5786775350570679,
-0.4113902151584625,
0.13472318649291992,
0.3792824447154999,
0.644742488861084,
-0.6396944522857666,
0.13028398156166077,
0.12497209757566452,
-0.19951483607292175,
-0.3656086027622223,
1.0587025880813599,
-0.4819381535053253,
0.5079058408737183,
0.5199779868125916,
0.2294495552778244,
0.597331702709198,
-0.002345616463571787,
0.622065007686615,
-0.12221118062734604,
-0.09901577234268188,
-0.09165356308221817,
0.4498577415943146,
0.1576509326696396,
-0.3984754681587219,
0.18504194915294647,
0.3952658474445343,
-0.6797530651092529,
-0.5455365777015686,
0.06007823720574379,
-1.0111706256866455,
-0.2285481095314026,
1.3419450521469116,
-0.2469736933708191,
-0.1285378783941269,
-0.464896023273468,
-0.3390071392059326,
0.02154633402824402,
-0.49705860018730164,
0.9224825501441956,
0.8580068349838257,
-0.5484845638275146,
-0.46112895011901855,
-0.9618489742279053,
0.3604735732078552,
0.29275140166282654,
-1.1906572580337524,
0.12383539974689484,
0.4555075466632843,
0.48389893770217896,
0.14134445786476135,
0.7545487880706787,
-0.32153478264808655,
0.21073445677757263,
-0.22004547715187073,
0.17637187242507935,
0.2896064817905426,
-0.13668619096279144,
-0.2745867669582367,
0.03631873056292534,
-0.4064939320087433,
-0.4035279154777527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05132v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05132v2 | TexShape: Information Theoretic Sentence Embedding for Language Models | 2024-02-05T22:48:28 | 2024-05-11T20:03:26 | Kaan Kale, Homa Esfahanizadeh, Noel Elias, Oguzhan Baser, Muriel Medard, Sriram Vishwanath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | With the exponential growth in data volume and the emergence of
data-intensive applications, particularly in the field of machine learning,
concerns related to resource utilization, privacy, and fairness have become
paramount. This paper focuses on the textual domain of data and addresses
challenges regarding encoding sentences to their optimized representations
through the lens of information-theory. In particular, we use empirical
estimates of mutual information, using the Donsker-Varadhan definition of
Kullback-Leibler divergence. Our approach leverages this estimation to train an
information-theoretic sentence embedding, called TexShape, for (task-based)
data compression or for filtering out sensitive information, enhancing privacy
and fairness. In this study, we employ a benchmark language model for initial
text representation, complemented by neural networks for information-theoretic
compression and mutual information estimations. Our experiments demonstrate
significant advancements in preserving maximal targeted information and minimal
sensitive information over adverse compression ratios, in terms of predictive
accuracy of downstream models that are trained using the compressed data. | [
-0.18786810338497162,
-0.8297628164291382,
0.6448435187339783,
0.10692516714334488,
-0.051741987466812134,
-0.08358784765005112,
-0.24807852506637573,
-0.3000277876853943,
-0.1366608738899231,
0.3896559774875641,
-0.2905845046043396,
-0.4879074692726135,
-0.9525373578071594,
-0.15566325187683105,
-0.48083800077438354,
0.7836220860481262,
0.003963543102145195,
-0.030521737411618233,
-0.2527501583099365,
-0.1659337729215622,
-0.422150582075119,
-0.7533705830574036,
-0.2631864547729492,
-0.03787624463438988,
0.4297485053539276,
0.15799519419670105,
0.7045733332633972,
0.7948644757270813,
0.19807754456996918,
0.23670682311058044,
0.1274033486843109,
0.004220529925078154,
-0.39460083842277527,
0.38903680443763733,
0.08819055557250977,
-0.5536530017852783,
0.061122868210077286,
0.03646286204457283,
0.6170936822891235,
0.8373289108276367,
-0.4262441396713257,
-0.18147271871566772,
0.16730205714702606,
0.4736887514591217,
-0.8831414580345154,
0.4084100127220154,
-0.4363022744655609,
0.4805624485015869,
0.016616247594356537,
-0.2555304765701294,
-0.5814013481140137,
-0.7116615176200867,
0.0382610484957695,
-0.42678096890449524,
0.02757977321743965,
0.31514599919319153,
0.799322783946991,
0.3018890917301178,
-0.47197121381759644,
-0.06982320547103882,
-0.5620645880699158,
1.0085172653198242,
-0.4133985638618469,
0.6153407096862793,
0.8036198019981384,
0.16153523325920105,
-0.019072508439421654,
-0.639575183391571,
-0.5142456293106079,
-0.10712061822414398,
-0.17144683003425598,
-0.03986865282058716,
-0.6246162056922913,
0.24302002787590027,
0.30209097266197205,
0.13039657473564148,
-0.4044785499572754,
0.08890905976295471,
-0.05888533219695091,
-0.24012163281440735,
0.5777018666267395,
0.1682872623205185,
0.11019236594438553,
-0.03814477473497391,
-0.28104910254478455,
-0.3842550218105316,
-0.3553226590156555,
0.009749120101332664,
0.4783462882041931,
0.25686147809028625,
-0.16050627827644348,
0.4956754744052887,
-0.12437186390161514,
0.5324012041091919,
-0.1790471374988556,
0.39976081252098083,
0.1707034707069397,
-0.34591206908226013,
-0.4405139088630676,
0.01418102253228426,
0.886650025844574,
0.07667332142591476,
0.21532593667507172,
-0.3335614502429962,
-0.07360051572322845,
0.16518186032772064,
0.2878682613372803,
-0.9656996726989746,
0.14705008268356323,
0.27821922302246094,
-0.5499635934829712,
-0.5622293949127197,
0.3175049424171448,
-0.6652129292488098,
-0.36326220631599426,
-0.2425680011510849,
0.193123921751976,
-0.5060075521469116,
-0.11006905138492584,
0.3745003342628479,
-0.15907014906406403,
-0.0830005630850792,
-0.02543174847960472,
-0.9045554399490356,
0.6348761916160583,
0.6181927919387817,
0.7330780625343323,
0.3216716945171356,
-0.10149095952510834,
-0.6582865715026855,
0.16452962160110474,
-0.14370782673358917,
0.477893590927124,
-0.8059625029563904,
-0.1707388311624527,
0.27221375703811646,
-0.20041753351688385,
0.05650249868631363,
-0.09935412555932999,
0.8868453502655029,
-0.3150237500667572,
0.39803996682167053,
-0.05414750427007675,
-0.9718085527420044,
-0.2494497150182724,
-0.03582081198692322,
-0.6893911361694336,
0.796868622303009,
0.19851960241794586,
-1.017789602279663,
0.2249208688735962,
-0.5839923620223999,
-0.15627272427082062,
-0.04210416600108147,
-0.3977241814136505,
-0.40525898337364197,
0.2609185576438904,
0.056038353592157364,
0.8169699907302856,
-0.4249110817909241,
0.4132382273674011,
-0.38519519567489624,
-0.27991360425949097,
0.3836643099784851,
-0.3501858413219452,
0.6287767887115479,
0.2704613208770752,
0.04236428439617157,
-0.3761995732784271,
-0.3743690252304077,
0.3366883397102356,
0.12328048050403595,
-0.19808141887187958,
-0.6055644750595093,
-0.06537064164876938,
0.4809374511241913,
-0.2081284075975418,
0.06032288447022438,
-0.7586102485656738,
0.12527717649936676,
-0.1347450464963913,
0.44579172134399414,
0.8994253873825073,
-0.3328125774860382,
0.4791749119758606,
-0.3543701767921448,
0.4418959617614746,
0.18054835498332977,
0.19321002066135406,
-0.13276545703411102,
-0.2656102180480957,
-0.35663360357284546,
0.17368264496326447,
0.6367030739784241,
0.4305851459503174,
-0.3797993063926697,
0.447137713432312,
-0.40459808707237244,
-0.1798681765794754,
-0.3485719859600067,
-0.21280725300312042,
0.24434305727481842,
0.2808433175086975,
0.22474358975887299,
-0.14139144122600555,
-0.5736827850341797,
-0.9698709845542908,
-0.3994705379009247,
-0.04400712624192238,
0.07308052480220795,
0.4123781621456146,
0.1106579527258873,
-0.21931852400302887,
1.0318933725357056,
-0.600164532661438,
-0.1050107553601265,
-0.14874789118766785,
0.22601500153541565,
0.1203405112028122,
0.4371492862701416,
0.6326069235801697,
-1.0511659383773804,
-0.5169144868850708,
-0.14712215960025787,
-0.7660869359970093,
-0.2051485925912857,
0.2817618250846863,
-0.08019370585680008,
-0.015003830194473267,
0.21384096145629883,
-0.5080158114433289,
0.4764454960823059,
0.7764739990234375,
-0.7064430117607117,
0.10982057452201843,
-0.2526847720146179,
0.18437901139259338,
-1.2852790355682373,
-0.07287150621414185,
0.0926566943526268,
-0.6071481704711914,
-0.6815916895866394,
-0.12649434804916382,
0.1977061927318573,
-0.0556836761534214,
-0.007768027018755674,
0.43433627486228943,
-0.3467242419719696,
0.19853579998016357,
-0.2720853388309479,
-0.025549165904521942,
0.023530391976237297,
0.46076908707618713,
-0.0734616369009018,
0.5134614706039429,
0.46184125542640686,
-0.6370126008987427,
0.02012215182185173,
0.40006765723228455,
-0.3298163115978241,
0.46987390518188477,
-0.48493391275405884,
0.22072839736938477,
-0.44694632291793823,
0.23275090754032135,
-0.09126977622509003,
-0.16705697774887085,
0.07079233974218369,
-0.4068524241447449,
0.2633456289768219,
-0.11364500224590302,
-0.6102737784385681,
0.1016981452703476,
-0.5165756344795227,
0.4911080002784729,
0.729131817817688,
-0.29551103711128235,
0.5357971787452698,
0.6084609627723694,
-0.12866978347301483,
-1.0274302959442139,
-0.9963581562042236,
0.04528957977890968,
-0.16952896118164062,
-0.5261139273643494,
0.6554124355316162,
0.017200976610183716,
-0.30061236023902893,
0.32627174258232117,
-0.06548762321472168,
-0.5527253746986389,
-0.03252827748656273,
0.4108505845069885,
-0.04733993858098984,
-0.040109336376190186,
0.47052302956581116,
0.30790749192237854,
-0.16724619269371033,
-0.07512951642274857,
-0.46353718638420105,
0.5913205742835999,
0.04050018638372421,
0.042405422776937485,
-0.30504485964775085,
0.747455894947052,
-0.11186683923006058,
0.21904458105564117,
0.8555177450180054,
0.4191240668296814,
-0.4710371792316437,
-0.4228653907775879,
-0.40298932790756226,
-0.1935214251279831,
-0.41764453053474426,
0.380998432636261,
-0.0816730260848999,
-1.0763510465621948,
0.07744389772415161,
-0.0246057640761137,
-0.1573408544063568,
0.15892471373081207,
-0.00866855401545763,
-0.14834944903850555,
0.7625892758369446,
1.219735026359558,
-0.14120829105377197,
0.6029365062713623,
-0.2449423223733902,
0.12053702026605606,
-0.43845170736312866,
-0.10274439305067062,
-0.7023431658744812,
-0.07664772123098373,
-0.5724384188652039,
-0.364082396030426,
0.17508959770202637,
0.10871805250644684,
-0.3186092674732208,
0.3827987015247345,
-0.20770278573036194,
0.5915616750717163,
0.6419817209243774,
0.24666765332221985,
0.12680058181285858,
0.2070336937904358,
-0.11248384416103363,
-0.14257502555847168,
-0.8656812906265259,
-0.48332589864730835,
1.1586668491363525,
0.21766427159309387,
0.8239720463752747,
0.12950974702835083,
0.5964051485061646,
0.7338106036186218,
-0.3459119200706482,
-0.5892233848571777,
0.2949149012565613,
-0.40635937452316284,
-0.04852181300520897,
0.019814839586615562,
-0.6689271330833435,
-1.0797733068466187,
-0.12192784249782562,
-0.40179070830345154,
-0.8180033564567566,
0.32959601283073425,
-0.05013901740312576,
-0.04254639148712158,
0.1967945694923401,
-0.6630745530128479,
0.7021369934082031,
0.12500138580799103,
-0.4673823118209839,
-0.4191421866416931,
-0.43518999218940735,
-0.00559509452432394,
-0.16589602828025818,
0.15516629815101624,
-0.07272142916917801,
-0.263938307762146,
0.7378444075584412,
-0.5864161252975464,
0.6575078964233398,
-0.24591676890850067,
0.24071083962917328,
-0.10588141530752182,
0.014079886488616467,
0.48214972019195557,
-0.008421194739639759,
-0.1387469321489334,
0.25916221737861633,
0.1606527417898178,
-0.5366899967193604,
-0.842523455619812,
0.39207008481025696,
-0.6323214173316956,
-0.30899158120155334,
-0.47006505727767944,
-0.6343476176261902,
-0.32050955295562744,
-0.05070655420422554,
0.09256467968225479,
0.4946975111961365,
-0.2748776078224182,
0.46282508969306946,
0.6345520615577698,
-0.29964321851730347,
0.7060751914978027,
0.2516683042049408,
0.04768875986337662,
-0.24539430439472198,
0.4042253792285919,
-0.08172494173049927,
-0.023914430290460587,
0.7294822931289673,
0.34359362721443176,
-0.3484656512737274,
-0.33903768658638,
0.07652290910482407,
-0.045623764395713806,
-0.7826146483421326,
-0.37860795855522156,
-0.8874676823616028,
-0.3380211889743805,
-0.14392299950122833,
0.011503142304718494,
-0.11181864887475967,
-0.6043422222137451,
0.16671112179756165,
-0.0702977254986763,
0.5797327160835266,
0.8776898384094238,
-0.2010677605867386,
0.26642099022865295,
-0.8393685221672058,
-0.08084327727556229,
-0.09256474673748016,
0.3924151062965393,
-0.16305148601531982,
-0.1179739385843277,
-0.5020759105682373,
0.1517842710018158,
-0.049980465322732925,
-0.8021062612533569,
0.24102337658405304,
0.20063477754592896,
0.4943450093269348,
0.05920398235321045,
0.2449818104505539,
0.22088362276554108,
-0.3617938458919525,
0.5513577461242676,
0.07812261581420898,
-0.9906159043312073,
0.586021363735199,
-0.11448142677545547,
0.1198803260922432,
0.43530282378196716,
0.4295284152030945,
-0.7556713223457336,
-0.3208538293838501,
-0.570629894733429,
-0.5019031763076782,
0.757831871509552,
0.486917644739151,
0.5912321209907532,
0.2134828269481659,
0.2790957987308502,
0.45632436871528625,
0.42152920365333557,
-0.8428592681884766,
-0.13571056723594666,
-0.041840746998786926,
-0.7358203530311584,
0.2619946002960205,
-0.4250473976135254,
0.05159103870391846,
0.1088627353310585,
0.40345147252082825,
-0.00319307972677052,
0.6099110245704651,
0.0605165958404541,
-0.22729629278182983,
0.4249739944934845,
0.47366002202033997,
0.13194765150547028,
0.23283813893795013,
-0.12117674946784973,
0.12338906526565552,
-0.19299229979515076,
-0.8413780927658081,
0.3527858257293701,
0.34644508361816406,
-0.31909605860710144,
0.07171140611171722,
0.3900037407875061,
0.8628464341163635,
0.012688686139881611,
-0.5480983257293701,
0.8847849369049072,
-0.3553414046764374,
0.013194018974900246,
-0.13632351160049438,
0.11144984513521194,
-0.39101168513298035,
0.30109092593193054,
0.3444105088710785,
0.09498358517885208,
0.19367508590221405,
-0.33374735713005066,
0.3027406930923462,
0.3028002381324768,
-0.47414010763168335,
-0.08201112598180771,
0.7260528206825256,
-0.0034436776768416166,
-0.10481103509664536,
0.3951205313205719,
0.17798113822937012,
-0.3615982234477997,
0.5295379161834717,
0.16197100281715393,
1.1046723127365112,
-0.28920379281044006,
0.2998468577861786,
0.27402186393737793,
0.13622622191905975,
-0.06486603617668152,
0.26040422916412354,
-0.46851643919944763,
-0.803248405456543,
-0.26733148097991943,
-0.534518837928772,
-0.3329954147338867,
-0.21303589642047882,
-0.4835483729839325,
0.2721136808395386,
-0.4537118971347809,
-0.26832935214042664,
-0.11482078582048416,
-0.10982850193977356,
-0.790310800075531,
0.08383149653673172,
-0.05709884315729141,
0.7140843868255615,
-0.6007400155067444,
0.9446911215782166,
0.13593682646751404,
-0.5208141207695007,
-0.7379933595657349,
0.24289539456367493,
-0.3314637243747711,
-0.5221109986305237,
0.7458298802375793,
0.29764971137046814,
-0.0026842819061130285,
-0.1250298172235489,
-0.5708903074264526,
-0.6485975980758667,
1.1009258031845093,
0.827339231967926,
-0.6512529850006104,
0.005856303032487631,
0.34753572940826416,
0.16080307960510254,
-0.41970154643058777,
0.37952280044555664,
0.13740374147891998,
0.35097262263298035,
-0.4996704161167145,
-0.7327995300292969,
0.2018568366765976,
-0.3633965253829956,
0.1708221137523651,
0.11961725354194641,
-0.4347209930419922,
0.822279155254364,
0.1033770814538002,
-0.36558789014816284,
-0.22221750020980835,
0.2435796707868576,
-0.1644405573606491,
-0.0007906947284936905,
0.4739483594894409,
0.4392736852169037,
0.9043853878974915,
-0.14784175157546997,
1.4240256547927856,
-0.36698633432388306,
0.29143792390823364,
0.9717796444892883,
0.10684370994567871,
0.8049132227897644,
0.2975148856639862,
-0.24258387088775635,
0.6726725101470947,
0.48782187700271606,
0.0738745853304863,
0.646376371383667,
0.0905546247959137,
-0.42073190212249756,
0.14406846463680267,
-0.507408082485199,
-0.41956841945648193,
0.47479692101478577,
0.0346614345908165,
-0.7311275601387024,
-0.04263601824641228,
0.15064944326877594,
0.21185316145420074,
0.2386542707681656,
-0.046058014035224915,
0.6233436465263367,
0.11491808295249939,
-0.207444429397583,
0.32403308153152466,
0.32087308168411255,
0.7243053317070007,
-0.6763401031494141,
-0.032499972730875015,
-0.33087798953056335,
0.0038894186727702618,
-0.12135986983776093,
-0.7511076927185059,
0.2782900929450989,
0.12705948948860168,
-0.2285085916519165,
-0.4013775587081909,
0.676821768283844,
-0.5913822054862976,
-0.29646584391593933,
0.4233362674713135,
0.3927978575229645,
-0.0401582196354866,
-0.065843865275383,
-0.5268495678901672,
0.1168045923113823,
-0.20275869965553284,
-0.1331699639558792,
0.13259683549404144,
0.3812991678714752,
0.18982625007629395,
0.5621588826179504,
0.2124129831790924,
0.022232577204704285,
-0.11166805773973465,
0.174874946475029,
0.7135971784591675,
-0.8834763169288635,
-0.8374931812286377,
-0.9686335325241089,
0.33382904529571533,
-0.48115962743759155,
0.13196851313114166,
0.4677959978580475,
0.5748337507247925,
0.6218928694725037,
0.11044395714998245,
1.198287010192871,
-0.16514840722084045,
0.17578314244747162,
-0.9057868719100952,
0.8503576517105103,
-0.2966402471065521,
0.08069773018360138,
-0.18390919268131256,
-1.0770975351333618,
-0.09760333597660065,
0.5894257426261902,
0.07543186843395233,
0.16371916234493256,
0.9783856272697449,
0.5618110299110413,
-0.4153626561164856,
0.3465098738670349,
0.2916196882724762,
0.28038349747657776,
-0.004267258569598198,
0.9396713972091675,
0.58395916223526,
-0.664646565914154,
0.4702531695365906,
-0.45828041434288025,
-0.06282167136669159,
0.019000817090272903,
-0.9926298260688782,
-0.6752557754516602,
-0.9663887023925781,
-0.26783323287963867,
-0.2344360500574112,
0.039666999131441116,
0.8530492186546326,
0.9389788508415222,
-0.5245329141616821,
-0.2379540055990219,
-0.4984527826309204,
-0.014280290342867374,
0.09828129410743713,
-0.20027047395706177,
0.4322032630443573,
-0.2051069438457489,
-0.7824310660362244,
0.27023109793663025,
0.3048732876777649,
0.3002535402774811,
-0.17982134222984314,
-0.15543605387210846,
-0.008313294500112534,
0.27287450432777405,
0.526874840259552,
-0.12694557011127472,
-0.3576134145259857,
-0.3412656784057617,
-0.2473440319299698,
-0.21863779425621033,
0.05918125435709953,
0.886309802532196,
-0.8858831524848938,
0.43217021226882935,
0.3334653079509735,
0.9098265171051025,
0.5844241976737976,
-0.11653222888708115,
0.9625945687294006,
-0.9781262278556824,
0.4865962564945221,
0.340657114982605,
0.4656931161880493,
0.44516026973724365,
-0.4647767245769501,
0.7876631021499634,
0.020433293655514717,
-0.32432931661605835,
-0.9426175951957703,
0.2562621533870697,
-0.7807541489601135,
-0.2539293169975281,
0.8687921166419983,
-0.23977439105510712,
-0.2147357165813446,
-0.03069339506328106,
-0.05800286680459976,
0.2697918117046356,
-0.4913056194782257,
0.6628142595291138,
0.8881279230117798,
0.12942297756671906,
-0.43518272042274475,
-0.5407028794288635,
0.6462160348892212,
0.4178984761238098,
-0.9494216442108154,
0.21811532974243164,
0.5444405674934387,
-0.08574564009904861,
-0.2162512242794037,
0.5725952386856079,
0.1604185253381729,
0.07631009817123413,
0.35041746497154236,
-0.1512446403503418,
-0.22633393108844757,
0.0920010656118393,
-0.3639318346977234,
0.3712866008281708,
-0.30300265550613403,
-0.17826834321022034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05131v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05131v3 | Financial Report Chunking for Effective Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T22:35:42 | 2024-03-16T09:08:26 | Antonio Jimeno Yepes, Yao You, Jan Milczek, Sebastian Laverde, Renyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chunking information is a key step in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG).
Current research primarily centers on paragraph-level chunking. This approach
treats all texts as equal and neglects the information contained in the
structure of documents. We propose an expanded approach to chunk documents by
moving beyond mere paragraph-level chunking to chunk primary by structural
element components of documents. Dissecting documents into these constituent
elements creates a new way to chunk documents that yields the best chunk size
without tuning. We introduce a novel framework that evaluates how chunking
based on element types annotated by document understanding models contributes
to the overall context and accuracy of the information retrieved. We also
demonstrate how this approach impacts RAG assisted Question & Answer task
performance. Our research includes a comprehensive analysis of various element
types, their role in effective information retrieval, and the impact they have
on the quality of RAG outputs. Findings support that element type based
chunking largely improve RAG results on financial reporting. Through this
research, we are also able to answer how to uncover highly accurate RAG. | [
-0.2274423986673355,
-0.7977693676948547,
0.30375418066978455,
0.37504106760025024,
-0.3879840075969696,
0.6471184492111206,
0.2610776722431183,
-0.8558779358863831,
0.49781230092048645,
0.523569643497467,
0.00792799610644579,
0.052724990993738174,
-0.6643959879875183,
-0.025859329849481583,
-0.7172985672950745,
1.1733115911483765,
0.15804429352283478,
-0.04482920467853546,
-0.3649068772792816,
0.12585075199604034,
-0.3602066934108734,
-0.10858548432588577,
-0.960015594959259,
-0.3983405828475952,
0.5025150179862976,
0.4905306398868561,
0.5693332552909851,
0.9591820240020752,
0.7973375916481018,
0.3366788327693939,
-0.1989804208278656,
0.3855537176132202,
-0.34263086318969727,
0.06959321349859238,
-0.1973133087158203,
-0.42831069231033325,
-0.6545495390892029,
0.07632161676883698,
0.5833856463432312,
0.5620090365409851,
-0.13268738985061646,
0.37292614579200745,
0.023200811818242073,
0.9875378012657166,
-0.8334032893180847,
0.10343974083662033,
-0.551848292350769,
-0.09721655398607254,
-0.41594022512435913,
-0.6658711433410645,
-0.5770615339279175,
-0.2922005355358124,
0.28454291820526123,
-0.7132293581962585,
0.4546389877796173,
0.49788448214530945,
0.8501432538032532,
0.12722091376781464,
-0.5408182740211487,
-0.7857797145843506,
-0.7037637233734131,
0.49500763416290283,
-0.4547857344150543,
0.16986094415187836,
0.7177993059158325,
0.030587121844291687,
0.2279215306043625,
-0.7275576591491699,
-0.1796775460243225,
0.03828192502260208,
-0.23968495428562164,
0.15547512471675873,
-0.007164376322180033,
-0.00799525622278452,
0.01640787161886692,
0.9705766439437866,
-0.37890565395355225,
-0.19345258176326752,
-0.4960234761238098,
-0.18197587132453918,
0.6094668507575989,
0.05438941344618797,
0.16161461174488068,
-0.3290710747241974,
-0.5490756034851074,
-0.4139469861984253,
-0.42610469460487366,
-0.07863666862249374,
0.5057147741317749,
0.35507020354270935,
0.09621334820985794,
0.7517910599708557,
0.1667492538690567,
0.6438208222389221,
0.548006534576416,
-0.46317043900489807,
0.02998320199549198,
-0.5323577523231506,
-0.1597461700439453,
0.3369464874267578,
-0.09871797263622284,
0.2715595066547394,
-0.21579430997371674,
-0.17428694665431976,
-0.3160129189491272,
-0.5160337090492249,
0.6300350427627563,
-0.6186825037002563,
-0.043596938252449036,
0.287955641746521,
-0.5560060739517212,
-0.43700888752937317,
0.42486515641212463,
-0.7794824242591858,
-0.6291857361793518,
-0.29130271077156067,
0.3503672182559967,
-0.7162523865699768,
-0.21000884473323822,
-0.1660575568675995,
-0.7309244275093079,
0.4461565613746643,
0.36355888843536377,
-1.001442313194275,
0.4382046163082123,
1.003932237625122,
0.621726930141449,
-0.012362215667963028,
0.03600296750664711,
-0.9838785529136658,
0.38632825016975403,
-0.3989052474498749,
1.1293052434921265,
-0.585157573223114,
-0.5537706017494202,
-0.18574965000152588,
-0.4936820864677429,
0.06344545632600784,
-0.9135408997535706,
0.2618796229362488,
-0.7396254539489746,
0.053912341594696045,
-0.3670654892921448,
-0.7306167483329773,
-0.25233128666877747,
0.18035751581192017,
-0.7669358253479004,
1.041225790977478,
0.6079889535903931,
-0.9652776718139648,
0.6988661885261536,
-0.3986096680164337,
-0.6894620656967163,
0.18795911967754364,
-0.04491621255874634,
-0.19937580823898315,
0.31062784790992737,
0.13359469175338745,
0.03464469313621521,
-0.350612610578537,
-0.10863465070724487,
0.07347571849822998,
-0.17406079173088074,
0.3256826102733612,
-0.14755424857139587,
0.07785715907812119,
0.2973783016204834,
-0.12814950942993164,
0.06651684641838074,
-0.9644283056259155,
-0.06875590980052948,
0.13684497773647308,
-0.4736984968185425,
-0.8909072279930115,
-0.014553818851709366,
0.22710217535495758,
-0.23980669677257538,
0.46536552906036377,
-0.5056208372116089,
-0.05515170469880104,
-0.47833794355392456,
-0.05698244273662567,
0.8357068300247192,
0.1778378188610077,
0.715659499168396,
-0.6070908904075623,
0.4360910654067993,
0.1164976954460144,
-0.14761239290237427,
-0.37762901186943054,
0.02764369361102581,
-0.6324938535690308,
-0.4061850607395172,
0.7687592506408691,
0.4659293293952942,
-0.7646384239196777,
0.1797519475221634,
0.060146257281303406,
-0.3995295464992523,
-0.5111057162284851,
-0.10721205174922943,
0.4141794443130493,
0.6897299289703369,
0.33420559763908386,
-0.4248080849647522,
-0.6668990254402161,
-0.8609482049942017,
-0.34699374437332153,
-0.17214752733707428,
-0.12254569679498672,
0.10160715132951736,
0.29999664425849915,
0.3136979937553406,
0.8693808913230896,
-0.7744736671447754,
0.026103276759386063,
-0.4017317295074463,
0.6687747836112976,
-0.10767605155706406,
0.5325846076011658,
0.45961055159568787,
-1.1911876201629639,
-0.42853012681007385,
0.023766379803419113,
-0.13814933598041534,
0.22024105489253998,
-0.42382538318634033,
-0.026771800592541695,
0.17903593182563782,
0.18441151082515717,
-0.20165786147117615,
0.5825915336608887,
0.08027362823486328,
-0.787340521812439,
0.3366379141807556,
-0.2696433365345001,
0.11804531514644623,
-1.0115857124328613,
0.11872860044240952,
0.08428363502025604,
-0.5070628523826599,
-0.5035656094551086,
0.10193496942520142,
0.20130762457847595,
0.18569789826869965,
0.05028730630874634,
0.5741175413131714,
-0.48166027665138245,
-0.5984141230583191,
-0.6241047382354736,
0.07651542872190475,
0.36063486337661743,
0.011535216122865677,
-0.2863352298736572,
0.8352568745613098,
-0.06059664860367775,
-0.5011224150657654,
-0.091614730656147,
0.2807711660861969,
-0.3740297853946686,
0.882716178894043,
-0.5058133602142334,
0.011326654814183712,
-0.41457054018974304,
0.12659336626529694,
-0.922973096370697,
-0.20698480308055878,
-0.029657429084181786,
-0.4714764356613159,
0.8897539973258972,
0.14877575635910034,
-0.3738469183444977,
-0.05360913649201393,
-0.5180209279060364,
0.30518364906311035,
0.19457757472991943,
-0.3635290563106537,
0.8622644543647766,
0.46807393431663513,
-0.5040158629417419,
-0.6597343683242798,
-0.4871368110179901,
-0.09245987981557846,
-0.24248120188713074,
-0.6624187231063843,
0.6654226183891296,
-0.08330070972442627,
-0.4784908890724182,
0.2141627073287964,
-0.8022564053535461,
-0.34104615449905396,
0.07584917545318604,
-0.048780739307403564,
0.5963180065155029,
-0.15756863355636597,
-0.1386476457118988,
-0.0645342767238617,
-0.15595431625843048,
-0.29214736819267273,
0.06879784166812897,
0.5501838326454163,
0.07262811064720154,
-0.10975106060504913,
0.1557232290506363,
0.5454186201095581,
0.3593248426914215,
-0.5889147520065308,
0.690135657787323,
0.6008478999137878,
-0.09907699376344681,
-0.16714699566364288,
-0.8074570894241333,
0.08665559440851212,
-0.509533703327179,
0.1515212506055832,
-0.2336074411869049,
-0.9616162180900574,
0.635195255279541,
0.10465957969427109,
0.23810464143753052,
0.7968441843986511,
0.14836695790290833,
-0.14890217781066895,
0.5443893671035767,
0.8632367253303528,
-0.016341954469680786,
0.48193660378456116,
-0.1523141860961914,
0.10334799438714981,
-1.0154885053634644,
-0.35000357031822205,
-0.6763131618499756,
-0.23221004009246826,
-0.09375062584877014,
-0.6575055122375488,
0.3455078601837158,
0.25266629457473755,
0.013465920463204384,
0.08821456879377365,
-0.49378156661987305,
0.5154604315757751,
0.41114580631256104,
-0.11143005639314651,
0.42382287979125977,
-0.017363661900162697,
0.052556250244379044,
0.23986317217350006,
-0.4136059880256653,
-0.08897630870342255,
0.8821870684623718,
0.35310307145118713,
0.6607107520103455,
-0.2303253710269928,
0.7412484884262085,
0.4886524975299835,
0.27039191126823425,
-0.6942026019096375,
0.2036476582288742,
-0.18131065368652344,
-0.7103126049041748,
-0.40160638093948364,
-0.7344750165939331,
-0.8041594624519348,
0.30805468559265137,
-0.03276987373828888,
-0.4379866123199463,
0.20694346725940704,
-0.10302639752626419,
-0.42679837346076965,
0.22999301552772522,
-0.5322309732437134,
0.309082955121994,
-0.07698880136013031,
0.03227580711245537,
-0.2277923971414566,
-0.4529876410961151,
0.37994295358657837,
-0.28632625937461853,
0.4587491750717163,
0.09107494354248047,
-0.19465532898902893,
0.7462072372436523,
-0.3601602613925934,
0.5663752555847168,
0.0036636011209338903,
-0.18130402266979218,
0.5933270454406738,
0.07004334032535553,
0.5334354639053345,
0.017546167597174644,
-0.0994834452867508,
-0.44800645112991333,
0.1537187248468399,
-0.4897025227546692,
-0.6565452814102173,
0.25195685029029846,
-0.3138180673122406,
-0.3488568663597107,
-0.6399146318435669,
-0.9541647434234619,
0.0292957853525877,
0.11286668479442596,
0.027674894779920578,
0.6499642133712769,
0.004377597942948341,
0.28514647483825684,
0.6451724171638489,
-0.010910404846072197,
0.3690601587295532,
0.6282025575637817,
-0.21082870662212372,
-0.5725605487823486,
1.1563057899475098,
0.29728397727012634,
0.12862111628055573,
0.6271257400512695,
0.130860835313797,
-0.34139254689216614,
-0.6222299933433533,
-0.19830702245235443,
0.28511667251586914,
-0.5369166135787964,
-0.3887709677219391,
-0.39730873703956604,
-0.2835620641708374,
-0.5556548833847046,
-0.3240046799182892,
-0.472189724445343,
-0.6197870373725891,
-0.2405206263065338,
-0.4236678183078766,
0.2097810059785843,
0.9487313628196716,
-0.23023255169391632,
0.06481841206550598,
-1.0876977443695068,
0.45489123463630676,
0.25142621994018555,
0.38099515438079834,
0.308115690946579,
-0.2999328672885895,
-0.49539077281951904,
-0.2941638231277466,
-0.39502447843551636,
-0.588599443435669,
0.21371428668498993,
-0.060675762593746185,
0.3960479497909546,
0.4680923521518707,
0.11915679275989532,
1.0254631042480469,
-0.3179715573787689,
0.6735817790031433,
0.14923542737960815,
-0.9268895983695984,
0.24738246202468872,
-0.27259182929992676,
0.16027991473674774,
0.7464638948440552,
0.2026900053024292,
-0.49409377574920654,
-0.44294920563697815,
-0.7450857162475586,
-1.3574745655059814,
0.6320170164108276,
0.15064823627471924,
-0.3277333974838257,
-0.1525842845439911,
0.4441389739513397,
0.1936391294002533,
0.2196505218744278,
-0.1657247543334961,
-0.22685322165489197,
0.055601924657821655,
0.05702124536037445,
0.0623602494597435,
-0.5174574851989746,
-0.03700992465019226,
-0.08808744698762894,
0.5853867530822754,
0.062204621732234955,
-0.07100830227136612,
0.4975112974643707,
0.14174054563045502,
-0.30585306882858276,
0.1400929093360901,
0.4809637665748596,
0.9971639513969421,
-0.41190388798713684,
-0.006081955041736364,
-0.10228664427995682,
-0.6072149872779846,
-0.09367036074399948,
0.23571059107780457,
-0.14680542051792145,
0.05057059973478317,
0.40944749116897583,
0.4075358211994171,
0.4437541365623474,
-0.5941640734672546,
0.17781472206115723,
0.04462737962603569,
-0.17642240226268768,
-0.38962382078170776,
-0.1872669756412506,
0.025785520672798157,
0.2858981788158417,
0.8891322612762451,
0.002046706387773156,
0.30597150325775146,
-0.7330679893493652,
0.4454280436038971,
0.2501069903373718,
-0.14852792024612427,
-0.0351034440100193,
0.5453317761421204,
0.1010875329375267,
-0.010992640629410744,
0.6126965880393982,
-0.18629536032676697,
-0.13368283212184906,
0.8260076642036438,
0.6851902604103088,
0.7591651082038879,
-0.25739017128944397,
0.4525577425956726,
0.11830148100852966,
0.31840795278549194,
-0.20140084624290466,
0.28676676750183105,
-0.13484196364879608,
-0.38224324584007263,
-0.7895686030387878,
-0.8923069834709167,
-0.6089404225349426,
-0.15947560966014862,
-0.9717692732810974,
-0.3160632848739624,
-0.41367778182029724,
0.028348367661237717,
0.11153478920459747,
0.04320661723613739,
-0.1702364981174469,
0.37855809926986694,
0.1549915075302124,
1.2062089443206787,
-0.28590694069862366,
0.333322674036026,
0.6544659733772278,
-0.4968632757663727,
-0.9059587717056274,
-0.05350813269615173,
-0.0295486468821764,
-0.5976199507713318,
0.5380984544754028,
-0.09827621281147003,
0.056697286665439606,
-0.2694680094718933,
-0.23076516389846802,
-1.2381168603897095,
1.086915135383606,
-0.1512874811887741,
0.023167071864008904,
-0.4218788743019104,
0.14027632772922516,
0.1262616515159607,
-0.34535154700279236,
0.09246324002742767,
0.5892238020896912,
0.6573626399040222,
0.6742162704467773,
-0.788068950176239,
-0.034386202692985535,
-0.2375059425830841,
0.03519461676478386,
0.5399797558784485,
-0.639913022518158,
0.9563930034637451,
0.17230536043643951,
-0.11453454941511154,
0.013880632817745209,
0.9084100127220154,
0.2355882078409195,
0.7916640639305115,
0.607760488986969,
0.6710700392723083,
0.9418560862541199,
0.13970914483070374,
1.276859998703003,
-0.2194703221321106,
-0.003964041359722614,
1.3637336492538452,
-0.35026460886001587,
0.7942970991134644,
0.3948787748813629,
-0.08460541814565659,
0.4332364499568939,
0.43241629004478455,
0.01825256086885929,
0.3538646697998047,
0.21742357313632965,
-0.06603085994720459,
0.1475912630558014,
-0.23873357474803925,
-0.3337581157684326,
0.5383585095405579,
0.35116830468177795,
-0.333126425743103,
-0.24584929645061493,
-0.2094351202249527,
0.005983554292470217,
0.038841988891363144,
-0.5502709150314331,
0.9330659508705139,
0.1107058972120285,
-0.5352274179458618,
-0.02385859563946724,
0.20672425627708435,
0.5550832152366638,
-0.7984749674797058,
-0.09758493304252625,
-0.16643090546131134,
-0.2347235530614853,
-0.31355196237564087,
-0.4591156840324402,
0.8171963095664978,
0.2233845740556717,
-0.4491584002971649,
-0.3224506974220276,
1.06073796749115,
-0.2537955343723297,
-0.4766639769077301,
-0.17240236699581146,
0.37815266847610474,
-0.10092465579509735,
-0.17013150453567505,
-0.18480747938156128,
-0.16759642958641052,
-0.007839368656277657,
-0.35898807644844055,
0.7545923590660095,
0.45860540866851807,
0.3204934298992157,
0.36837393045425415,
0.6945101022720337,
-0.006568076554685831,
-0.14219661056995392,
-0.3364320993423462,
1.0350263118743896,
-0.8652733564376831,
-0.6826853156089783,
-0.5481785535812378,
0.7704288959503174,
-0.3620874881744385,
-0.20384660363197327,
0.8753675222396851,
1.1221431493759155,
0.6955869793891907,
0.18709507584571838,
0.5413281321525574,
-0.16002823412418365,
0.8369118571281433,
-0.4270518124103546,
0.6567714214324951,
-0.6672477126121521,
0.1676006317138672,
-0.446620911359787,
-0.9232235550880432,
0.03452926501631737,
0.3000020682811737,
-0.20755968987941742,
-0.31281718611717224,
0.7849828004837036,
0.11596547812223434,
0.016200514510273933,
0.28035712242126465,
0.0852898582816124,
0.1430397480726242,
0.1960967630147934,
-0.29304054379463196,
0.5025929808616638,
-0.2069147676229477,
0.659669816493988,
-0.29152441024780273,
-0.15533491969108582,
-0.1368659883737564,
-0.6149424314498901,
-0.46367940306663513,
-0.564120352268219,
-0.3011029362678528,
-0.3377317190170288,
-0.31871503591537476,
0.5068968534469604,
0.3196847140789032,
-0.4315437972545624,
-0.2708262503147125,
0.2268284410238266,
0.258382111787796,
-0.11193114519119263,
-0.33530980348587036,
0.34965643286705017,
-0.6029503345489502,
-0.45708611607551575,
0.6139770746231079,
0.6385148763656616,
0.0881766602396965,
0.026117220520973206,
0.4165714681148529,
-0.23519466817378998,
0.5072191953659058,
0.713412880897522,
0.2183753401041031,
-0.15706133842468262,
-0.2901425063610077,
-0.08918476104736328,
0.027201663702726364,
0.20132175087928772,
0.9917518496513367,
-0.34801870584487915,
0.16160954535007477,
0.5385277271270752,
0.9141238927841187,
0.7753665447235107,
0.5839773416519165,
0.5162780284881592,
-0.8131404519081116,
0.1024264544248581,
0.38882699608802795,
0.046328358352184296,
0.20224575698375702,
-0.5747404098510742,
0.7061914205551147,
-0.11219371110200882,
-0.623288631439209,
-0.6484236121177673,
-0.005159430205821991,
-1.0989693403244019,
-0.5527097582817078,
0.7151463031768799,
0.043201446533203125,
-0.5584255456924438,
-0.06291366368532181,
-0.23445507884025574,
0.18251650035381317,
-0.6260289549827576,
0.7083593010902405,
0.7585545182228088,
-0.13625064492225647,
0.04382525756955147,
-0.2866690158843994,
0.31805163621902466,
0.36663487553596497,
-0.6710268259048462,
-0.012588071636855602,
0.5914759039878845,
0.12265836447477341,
0.5185444355010986,
0.8761367797851562,
-0.3119179904460907,
0.15458868443965912,
0.30902430415153503,
-0.268868088722229,
-0.07319954037666321,
-0.31408706307411194,
-0.014308827929198742,
0.52093106508255,
-0.020149946212768555,
0.033389605581760406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03563v2 | Distinguishing the Knowable from the Unknowable with Language Models | 2024-02-05T22:22:49 | 2024-02-27T07:37:08 | Gustaf Ahdritz, Tian Qin, Nikhil Vyas, Boaz Barak, Benjamin L. Edelman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We study the feasibility of identifying epistemic uncertainty (reflecting a
lack of knowledge), as opposed to aleatoric uncertainty (reflecting entropy in
the underlying distribution), in the outputs of large language models (LLMs)
over free-form text. In the absence of ground-truth probabilities, we explore a
setting where, in order to (approximately) disentangle a given LLM's
uncertainty, a significantly larger model stands in as a proxy for the ground
truth. We show that small linear probes trained on the embeddings of frozen,
pretrained models accurately predict when larger models will be more confident
at the token level and that probes trained on one text domain generalize to
others. Going further, we propose a fully unsupervised method that achieves
non-trivial accuracy on the same task. Taken together, we interpret these
results as evidence that LLMs naturally contain internal representations of
different types of uncertainty that could potentially be leveraged to devise
more informative indicators of model confidence in diverse practical settings. | [
-0.009072396904230118,
-0.5865316390991211,
1.1370583772659302,
-0.1234406977891922,
-0.019857479259371758,
0.13735292851924896,
-0.49925515055656433,
-0.3034075200557709,
0.11456797271966934,
0.1460440307855606,
-0.18724583089351654,
-0.45409631729125977,
-0.972621500492096,
-0.27501922845840454,
-0.638434648513794,
0.46762019395828247,
-0.1364555060863495,
-0.04386743903160095,
-0.4393590986728668,
-0.01717555895447731,
0.04708418622612953,
-0.5168421268463135,
-0.2682463824748993,
-0.571491003036499,
0.34926339983940125,
0.08822187036275864,
0.7263898253440857,
0.6703969836235046,
0.17075733840465546,
0.21526025235652924,
-0.22286558151245117,
0.006902248132973909,
-0.20777538418769836,
0.12528029084205627,
-0.2517487704753876,
-0.8537942171096802,
0.10604449361562729,
0.1601799726486206,
0.737709641456604,
0.9192366003990173,
-0.0787709578871727,
0.03385670483112335,
0.10250582545995712,
0.4606235921382904,
-0.8348900079727173,
0.2565549910068512,
-0.8404117822647095,
0.03603384643793106,
-0.21834735572338104,
0.001959466841071844,
-0.5389514565467834,
-0.07541246712207794,
0.12968428432941437,
-0.5872237682342529,
0.0624922513961792,
0.05764157697558403,
1.0264472961425781,
0.4321663975715637,
-0.4913151264190674,
-0.42178547382354736,
-1.1115883588790894,
0.8202093243598938,
-0.7180574536323547,
0.7001092433929443,
0.6967851519584656,
0.13287709653377533,
-0.0492696687579155,
-0.47687748074531555,
-0.6692119836807251,
-0.046450983732938766,
0.035992007702589035,
0.05660875514149666,
-0.34535709023475647,
-0.009493269957602024,
-0.05565952509641647,
0.3590565025806427,
-0.14124234020709991,
0.250394344329834,
-0.014683528803288937,
-0.3177785873413086,
0.2162420004606247,
-0.22268520295619965,
0.2907046973705292,
0.24783311784267426,
-0.10165084898471832,
0.06630507856607437,
-0.8065403699874878,
0.12294168025255203,
0.2752282917499542,
0.25745081901550293,
-0.15919572114944458,
0.80459064245224,
-0.0928177610039711,
0.5782113075256348,
-0.0028707494493573904,
-0.17942139506340027,
-0.0016059699701145291,
0.3076896667480469,
-0.27753740549087524,
-0.13549691438674927,
0.6485396027565002,
-0.08426441252231598,
0.20927506685256958,
-0.395027220249176,
-0.29453951120376587,
-0.09042317420244217,
-0.10787487030029297,
-0.3598201274871826,
-0.29792287945747375,
0.3085351884365082,
-0.15282423794269562,
-0.2175387293100357,
0.2515401542186737,
-0.34036073088645935,
-0.6649180054664612,
-0.18666808307170868,
0.593018651008606,
-0.3137117922306061,
-0.4972284734249115,
0.0719224289059639,
-0.1539672464132309,
0.1142270565032959,
0.4765188694000244,
-0.7827426791191101,
0.312487930059433,
0.6395755410194397,
0.8301277756690979,
0.13426540791988373,
-0.22300592064857483,
-0.18151690065860748,
0.25895488262176514,
-0.8260409235954285,
0.6188021302223206,
-0.6189956665039062,
0.050819773226976395,
-0.012137405574321747,
-0.09639497846364975,
0.03455301746726036,
-0.3285161256790161,
0.19741900265216827,
-0.5717825293540955,
0.1630764901638031,
-0.10217392444610596,
-0.8968344926834106,
-0.2284628003835678,
0.2542690336704254,
-0.7509009838104248,
0.8420286774635315,
0.07710443437099457,
-0.9492684006690979,
0.33176955580711365,
0.0047897277399897575,
0.0733758807182312,
-0.18387196958065033,
-0.42953401803970337,
-0.1424855887889862,
0.6250052452087402,
0.021924136206507683,
0.5716333389282227,
-0.4852742850780487,
0.2911891043186188,
-0.4532034695148468,
-0.11858797818422318,
0.7034420967102051,
-0.7388208508491516,
0.4840993583202362,
-0.0021338362712413073,
-0.21621055901050568,
-0.20116600394248962,
-0.7811092734336853,
0.17160382866859436,
0.13315923511981964,
-0.5188787579536438,
-0.6922781467437744,
0.10899832099676132,
-0.44396016001701355,
-0.03343413770198822,
0.3214793801307678,
-0.6023283004760742,
-0.09326262027025223,
-0.46946901082992554,
0.265481173992157,
0.6965579390525818,
-0.26055845618247986,
0.6628319025039673,
-0.13963989913463593,
0.24622194468975067,
0.2586132287979126,
-0.26627427339553833,
0.17194902896881104,
-0.6461711525917053,
-0.9707251787185669,
-0.3067578077316284,
0.6059271097183228,
0.5166010856628418,
-0.5884605646133423,
0.31299707293510437,
-0.1321553736925125,
-0.666704535484314,
-0.583041787147522,
0.20068535208702087,
0.3854285776615143,
0.26891016960144043,
0.0034309697803109884,
0.009867007844150066,
-0.33524268865585327,
-0.6843338012695312,
-0.4562648832798004,
-0.44638463854789734,
-0.30190157890319824,
0.03732046112418175,
0.47691282629966736,
-0.1335950493812561,
0.9584188461303711,
-0.44608360528945923,
0.1164356917142868,
-0.051480911672115326,
0.3038836419582367,
0.2019389271736145,
0.24277788400650024,
0.18452763557434082,
-0.6616904735565186,
-0.2804342806339264,
0.2132428139448166,
-0.8938065767288208,
0.154430091381073,
-0.04316907003521919,
0.24740388989448547,
0.12770338356494904,
0.5443832278251648,
-0.7030528783798218,
0.5657745599746704,
0.5803955793380737,
-0.2714890241622925,
0.2794262170791626,
-0.5159722566604614,
-0.15204709768295288,
-0.8776319026947021,
-0.10749312490224838,
-0.0010690329363569617,
-0.13709665834903717,
-0.7756534814834595,
-0.06201065704226494,
0.30162402987480164,
0.2809138000011444,
-0.1285705715417862,
0.6858706474304199,
-0.6687500476837158,
0.019084660336375237,
-0.04512607306241989,
0.009516214951872826,
-0.03850392624735832,
0.16851408779621124,
0.2718004882335663,
0.4841315448284149,
0.684613823890686,
-0.6423763632774353,
-0.0020221618469804525,
-0.20717425644397736,
-0.6611745953559875,
0.08585959672927856,
-0.5460243821144104,
0.03770819306373596,
-0.3738596737384796,
-0.09727615863084793,
-1.182900309562683,
-0.4955028295516968,
0.019538013264536858,
-0.7217980027198792,
0.3446972668170929,
-0.2651561498641968,
-0.32552775740623474,
-0.12073971331119537,
0.09639246016740799,
0.29825907945632935,
0.5194107890129089,
-0.39279666543006897,
0.4716520607471466,
0.43290987610816956,
-0.11236398667097092,
-0.6182828545570374,
-0.8899075984954834,
-0.1073651984333992,
-0.2707953453063965,
-0.24150018393993378,
0.026161838322877884,
0.13468913733959198,
-0.8056013584136963,
-0.016405753791332245,
-0.1903027445077896,
-0.6472078561782837,
0.4156458377838135,
0.4542890787124634,
0.05643843859434128,
-0.2492336928844452,
0.5251380801200867,
0.03550983592867851,
0.04503731429576874,
0.028996208682656288,
-0.5104570388793945,
0.295247346162796,
-0.1682645082473755,
-0.738336443901062,
-0.20562142133712769,
0.1573314070701599,
0.636319637298584,
0.016823217272758484,
1.0146898031234741,
0.2290612906217575,
-0.9279772639274597,
-0.2925388216972351,
-0.48632675409317017,
0.009910515509545803,
-0.4060576260089874,
0.13528938591480255,
-0.2652856707572937,
-0.8958680629730225,
0.7016389966011047,
0.0006042149034328759,
-0.2731882333755493,
0.5536884069442749,
0.4422847032546997,
-0.07252413779497147,
0.8207467794418335,
0.8689618706703186,
0.09052253514528275,
0.10204492509365082,
0.12985795736312866,
0.35950589179992676,
-0.40469276905059814,
-0.2720179557800293,
-0.6811087727546692,
0.15036821365356445,
-0.4853028953075409,
-0.7613188624382019,
0.24582643806934357,
0.42962363362312317,
-0.3928763270378113,
-0.11945662647485733,
-0.15569183230400085,
0.6956884264945984,
0.6476129293441772,
0.10288991779088974,
0.36922526359558105,
-0.11503007262945175,
-0.3096637427806854,
-0.10997964441776276,
-0.5434843301773071,
-0.7184839844703674,
1.1902391910552979,
0.7050636410713196,
0.7951571941375732,
0.2863132059574127,
0.5681653022766113,
0.012218931689858437,
0.27379345893859863,
-0.7352969646453857,
0.06999223679304123,
0.11642836034297943,
-0.7489280104637146,
-0.5641821026802063,
-0.5212103128433228,
-0.7406114935874939,
0.16443605720996857,
-0.3423592150211334,
-0.9773412942886353,
0.274406373500824,
0.0780453234910965,
-0.42048147320747375,
0.7354944348335266,
-0.5940961837768555,
0.4251304864883423,
-0.13835853338241577,
-0.036548372358083725,
0.2982828915119171,
-0.5266537666320801,
0.3888305723667145,
-0.4044223427772522,
0.46288684010505676,
-0.08242835104465485,
-0.15824849903583527,
0.6275264024734497,
-0.3624752163887024,
1.0566476583480835,
-0.05609516426920891,
-0.4087175130844116,
0.38584259152412415,
0.34040120244026184,
0.4897507131099701,
-0.0542760007083416,
-0.06463830173015594,
0.2472093403339386,
-0.04426828399300575,
-0.26149672269821167,
-0.6019608378410339,
0.3311332166194916,
-0.8296029567718506,
-0.4852403700351715,
-0.35210779309272766,
-0.38051605224609375,
-0.4281271994113922,
0.24753756821155548,
0.5379924178123474,
0.20280969142913818,
-0.23936820030212402,
0.20296351611614227,
1.0645554065704346,
-0.295427143573761,
0.24125778675079346,
0.5816650986671448,
-0.18822261691093445,
-0.08029128611087799,
0.7121347784996033,
0.251163125038147,
0.3729100227355957,
0.760083019733429,
0.3718854486942291,
-0.4353826642036438,
-0.6949793100357056,
-0.0554802231490612,
0.1417284607887268,
-0.8597061038017273,
-0.10776109993457794,
-0.4328267574310303,
-0.3199232220649719,
-0.3947848081588745,
0.01121353730559349,
-0.6373677849769592,
-0.5813947319984436,
-0.4943573772907257,
-0.36485233902931213,
0.260187029838562,
1.124872088432312,
-0.3014814257621765,
0.44707733392715454,
-0.6231133937835693,
-0.13725429773330688,
0.46485644578933716,
0.44136831164360046,
-0.016846926882863045,
-0.7262486815452576,
-0.23117288947105408,
0.34239399433135986,
0.06783830374479294,
-0.948760986328125,
0.4219723641872406,
0.23325768113136292,
0.7259243726730347,
0.7431578636169434,
0.20474377274513245,
0.2625923752784729,
-0.3224222958087921,
0.6714484691619873,
0.29673805832862854,
-1.1915349960327148,
0.4016597867012024,
-0.3605975806713104,
-0.013903099112212658,
0.32108932733535767,
0.6500142812728882,
-0.3434115946292877,
-0.7002303600311279,
-0.7048072218894958,
-0.7170274257659912,
0.25459927320480347,
0.02667684480547905,
0.01342769619077444,
-0.1292741596698761,
0.3682282269001007,
0.0945449247956276,
0.28718096017837524,
-0.7713844180107117,
-0.15468065440654755,
-0.01161274779587984,
-0.2689964175224304,
-0.2319735586643219,
-0.3591248691082001,
-0.259853720664978,
-0.015541739761829376,
0.44271397590637207,
-0.12100382894277573,
0.516366183757782,
0.1843622475862503,
-0.21642464399337769,
-0.107951819896698,
0.45194950699806213,
0.5723523497581482,
0.693541407585144,
-0.26023069024086,
0.7894726395606995,
0.10513667017221451,
-0.24275337159633636,
0.2841669023036957,
-0.31275516748428345,
-0.06324733048677444,
0.08234935998916626,
0.8018681406974792,
0.6269305944442749,
0.08105596154928207,
-0.6008599996566772,
0.7030938863754272,
-0.019952600821852684,
-0.11384345591068268,
-0.513182520866394,
-0.2590254545211792,
0.3696218430995941,
0.3076390326023102,
0.4208362102508545,
0.02077452652156353,
-0.22458423674106598,
-0.6009458899497986,
0.1550997495651245,
0.3317805826663971,
-0.6282146573066711,
-0.5221226811408997,
0.5153605341911316,
-0.20550575852394104,
-0.13749347627162933,
0.4284753203392029,
-0.2708524763584137,
-0.4234095513820648,
0.462240606546402,
0.5611109733581543,
0.6532802581787109,
-0.3073806166648865,
0.28756794333457947,
0.10524677485227585,
0.5001578330993652,
-0.499675452709198,
0.07129637897014618,
0.4036737084388733,
-1.2040116786956787,
-0.34577232599258423,
-0.6582943201065063,
-0.43082302808761597,
0.1924714297056198,
-0.8273106217384338,
-0.23121722042560577,
-0.6608487367630005,
0.024623166769742966,
-0.08729440718889236,
-0.390791654586792,
-0.6915217638015747,
0.3393179774284363,
0.20862318575382233,
0.7842491865158081,
-1.1586451530456543,
0.8488805890083313,
0.6487305760383606,
-0.19494283199310303,
-0.9823312759399414,
0.24831241369247437,
0.232463538646698,
-0.9346432685852051,
0.5640196800231934,
-0.0012245136313140392,
-0.0776156336069107,
-0.24963805079460144,
-0.6440726518630981,
-1.0338165760040283,
0.9220919013023376,
0.574639081954956,
-0.42830100655555725,
-0.05699741467833519,
0.2128080278635025,
0.5251740217208862,
-0.35621166229248047,
0.2742644250392914,
0.460791677236557,
0.38871580362319946,
0.034046683460474014,
-0.9106866717338562,
0.05220622569322586,
0.031833842396736145,
-0.1799694299697876,
0.22262920439243317,
-0.3263041079044342,
1.2279503345489502,
-0.3050290048122406,
-0.49563899636268616,
-0.010538714937865734,
0.6372726559638977,
-0.04021342843770981,
0.2423805594444275,
0.4214727580547333,
0.5836751461029053,
1.3779089450836182,
-0.255720317363739,
0.8876913189888,
-0.22105231881141663,
0.4430297613143921,
1.1785744428634644,
-0.07507898658514023,
1.0031572580337524,
0.6137621402740479,
-0.12952566146850586,
0.3074667453765869,
0.6020147204399109,
0.5379825234413147,
0.6024144887924194,
0.2541021406650543,
-0.2891588509082794,
-0.6941501498222351,
-0.09348103404045105,
-0.1851508766412735,
0.4864950478076935,
0.7206929922103882,
-0.37735486030578613,
-0.18860699236392975,
-0.10477688908576965,
0.13484807312488556,
0.1730164736509323,
-0.30301883816719055,
0.6778239607810974,
0.16086426377296448,
-0.43260401487350464,
0.4876317083835602,
0.006215487141162157,
0.5305311679840088,
-0.4768064618110657,
0.19067823886871338,
-0.009768161922693253,
0.3341846764087677,
0.026811951771378517,
-1.0182477235794067,
0.2633386552333832,
-0.17409305274486542,
-0.1799960732460022,
0.013268095441162586,
0.8141747117042542,
-0.4824325144290924,
-0.5743461847305298,
0.29788029193878174,
0.9828545451164246,
0.3202299475669861,
-0.3358849883079529,
-0.2344970852136612,
0.00045509065967053175,
0.10521350800991058,
-0.30763253569602966,
0.28624364733695984,
0.950926661491394,
0.0583619698882103,
0.8967304825782776,
0.2310762107372284,
0.269020676612854,
0.12399660795927048,
-0.3144132196903229,
0.5762645602226257,
-0.5908131003379822,
-0.09145037829875946,
-0.7839756608009338,
0.3857889175415039,
0.07948912680149078,
-0.32973068952560425,
0.7361022233963013,
0.1799759566783905,
0.913070797920227,
-0.15740202367305756,
1.0902247428894043,
0.10260546952486038,
0.6391097903251648,
-0.71319979429245,
0.7258968949317932,
-0.5436473488807678,
0.3516058623790741,
-0.12455127388238907,
-0.427691787481308,
-0.3911675214767456,
0.8482788801193237,
-0.2565617561340332,
-0.187725231051445,
0.6500763893127441,
0.6020905375480652,
-0.06263931840658188,
-0.16983243823051453,
0.7005963921546936,
0.2570911645889282,
0.03578273206949234,
0.5510191917419434,
1.0758775472640991,
-0.22274023294448853,
0.2614290416240692,
-0.14157070219516754,
-0.3490488827228546,
0.05289800092577934,
-0.8915846347808838,
-1.0003056526184082,
-0.8653926253318787,
-0.14677584171295166,
-0.34261682629585266,
-0.14943793416023254,
0.7388375401496887,
0.5422990918159485,
-0.7177630066871643,
0.02155849151313305,
-0.027067039161920547,
0.30974245071411133,
0.0007552504539489746,
-0.10575495660305023,
0.19160988926887512,
-0.08752432465553284,
-0.48795390129089355,
0.44994503259658813,
0.07786136865615845,
0.5908054113388062,
-0.19590288400650024,
-0.13908228278160095,
-0.007841956801712513,
0.5787222385406494,
0.2715833783149719,
0.2371223270893097,
-0.809518039226532,
-0.6450664401054382,
-0.1660834550857544,
-0.04694958031177521,
-0.19097688794136047,
0.5527893900871277,
-0.3722321689128876,
0.30923599004745483,
0.3181588351726532,
0.6079676747322083,
0.18318165838718414,
-0.3082190155982971,
0.6882777214050293,
-1.0063765048980713,
0.14047083258628845,
0.08842777460813522,
0.5222567915916443,
0.35759615898132324,
-0.3633241355419159,
0.3984328806400299,
0.040189679712057114,
-0.3341386914253235,
-0.9776034355163574,
0.3884950280189514,
-0.5663673281669617,
-0.5466328263282776,
1.1972784996032715,
-0.5352381467819214,
-0.19636298716068268,
-0.24308468401432037,
0.42450442910194397,
0.2790469527244568,
-0.06244472786784172,
0.7009174227714539,
1.182483196258545,
0.34022027254104614,
-0.09518095850944519,
-0.6107704639434814,
0.43497133255004883,
0.1866488754749298,
-0.6829790472984314,
0.32113274931907654,
0.3266720771789551,
0.4576588273048401,
0.4616391360759735,
0.5451810359954834,
0.01880839467048645,
-0.21202421188354492,
0.3104805052280426,
0.004128239583224058,
0.14052577316761017,
-0.5714685916900635,
-0.3033654987812042,
0.27653348445892334,
0.5266954302787781,
0.09357750415802002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03561v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03561v2 | VLN-Video: Utilizing Driving Videos for Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2024-02-05T22:20:19 | 2024-02-07T18:02:51 | Jialu Li, Aishwarya Padmakumar, Gaurav Sukhatme, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) requires an agent to navigate
through realistic 3D outdoor environments based on natural language
instructions. The performance of existing VLN methods is limited by
insufficient diversity in navigation environments and limited training data. To
address these issues, we propose VLN-Video, which utilizes the diverse outdoor
environments present in driving videos in multiple cities in the U.S. augmented
with automatically generated navigation instructions and actions to improve
outdoor VLN performance. VLN-Video combines the best of intuitive classical
approaches and modern deep learning techniques, using template infilling to
generate grounded navigation instructions, combined with an image rotation
similarity-based navigation action predictor to obtain VLN style data from
driving videos for pretraining deep learning VLN models. We pre-train the model
on the Touchdown dataset and our video-augmented dataset created from driving
videos with three proxy tasks: Masked Language Modeling, Instruction and
Trajectory Matching, and Next Action Prediction, so as to learn
temporally-aware and visually-aligned instruction representations. The learned
instruction representation is adapted to the state-of-the-art navigator when
fine-tuning on the Touchdown dataset. Empirical results demonstrate that
VLN-Video significantly outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by 2.1% in
task completion rate, achieving a new state-of-the-art on the Touchdown
dataset. | [
-0.34119367599487305,
-0.5380858182907104,
0.6162235736846924,
0.10696510225534439,
-0.4097254276275635,
0.04588767886161804,
-0.1989683210849762,
-0.49896788597106934,
0.01299180556088686,
0.45698973536491394,
-0.6993176937103271,
-0.6090813279151917,
-0.24879589676856995,
-0.2808193564414978,
-0.20798611640930176,
0.5464586019515991,
0.021793024614453316,
0.22402317821979523,
-0.19191399216651917,
-0.19635595381259918,
-0.42228302359580994,
-0.36088061332702637,
-0.4173632562160492,
-0.24156369268894196,
0.22514192759990692,
0.2233150452375412,
0.8141396045684814,
0.5914096236228943,
0.4797626733779907,
0.3336246609687805,
0.25126805901527405,
0.4176807999610901,
-0.45242008566856384,
-0.22495447099208832,
-0.208846315741539,
0.08686509728431702,
-0.08993944525718689,
-0.4116154611110687,
0.5974244475364685,
0.24519816040992737,
0.020895633846521378,
-0.12435733526945114,
-0.19629089534282684,
0.7518268823623657,
-0.8995952606201172,
0.3813208341598511,
-0.23986035585403442,
0.08305933326482773,
-0.12962229549884796,
-0.31814539432525635,
-0.025209719315171242,
-0.307190477848053,
0.36496466398239136,
-0.8973862528800964,
0.2068966031074524,
0.0866428092122078,
0.7357990741729736,
0.4111383855342865,
-0.6355544924736023,
0.020277537405490875,
-0.9961034059524536,
0.4290708899497986,
-0.547407329082489,
0.9614328145980835,
0.4303814768791199,
0.5746890306472778,
0.1344909816980362,
-0.360743910074234,
-0.6237728595733643,
-0.30689433217048645,
0.1420646458864212,
0.3692007064819336,
0.2569515109062195,
0.25718939304351807,
0.07755732536315918,
0.32784250378608704,
-0.750630795955658,
0.2700130343437195,
-0.5407736897468567,
0.03494015336036682,
0.6933435201644897,
0.3474678099155426,
0.0035904478281736374,
0.07867134362459183,
-0.47282674908638,
-0.4746249318122864,
-0.7671524882316589,
0.6414207220077515,
0.04675496742129326,
0.3927701711654663,
-0.2353089451789856,
0.524314284324646,
-0.6378988027572632,
0.8513206839561462,
-0.28113144636154175,
-0.23033380508422852,
0.3866161108016968,
-0.4461510181427002,
-0.5283143520355225,
0.17038913071155548,
0.6563929319381714,
0.8921212553977966,
0.14597421884536743,
-0.033199768513441086,
-0.35844895243644714,
-0.2984665632247925,
0.4295295774936676,
-0.48765888810157776,
-0.4296756982803345,
-0.22811314463615417,
-0.0224147979170084,
-0.022214127704501152,
0.20564405620098114,
-0.6933688521385193,
-0.5318452715873718,
-0.7262272834777832,
0.5848495364189148,
-0.46897515654563904,
-0.3685001730918884,
0.25998613238334656,
-0.18933363258838654,
0.5994402766227722,
0.492416650056839,
-0.7494286894798279,
0.11631409823894501,
0.4063417613506317,
0.732632040977478,
0.021759137511253357,
-0.3669607937335968,
-0.7691138982772827,
0.3493432104587555,
-0.293333500623703,
0.35730794072151184,
-0.3191971480846405,
-0.35760995745658875,
0.35838407278060913,
0.1361774206161499,
0.0767846405506134,
-0.31014999747276306,
-0.09526672214269638,
-0.5571226477622986,
-0.011346815153956413,
-0.22605381906032562,
-0.15197840332984924,
-0.677643895149231,
0.47331827878952026,
-0.6794920563697815,
1.1634336709976196,
0.08477339148521423,
0.03970350697636604,
0.5860002636909485,
-0.6232826709747314,
-0.7667154669761658,
0.330171138048172,
-0.1651296466588974,
-0.350801020860672,
0.13831722736358643,
0.4055333733558655,
0.2009296864271164,
-0.05436430126428604,
0.007515710312873125,
0.22742818295955658,
-0.5001853108406067,
-0.1292952001094818,
-0.49317455291748047,
0.46654102206230164,
-0.29990559816360474,
-0.8289344310760498,
-0.02201915718615055,
-0.5902949571609497,
-0.04825519397854805,
-0.0724320188164711,
-0.3492019772529602,
-0.27953553199768066,
0.10672392696142197,
-0.10698866844177246,
0.04523788020014763,
0.12196235358715057,
-0.467913419008255,
-0.022430362179875374,
-0.6105908751487732,
-0.2150869220495224,
0.816034734249115,
-0.1569020003080368,
0.597464382648468,
0.07635615020990372,
0.4846935570240021,
-0.008416770026087761,
0.3141615688800812,
-0.11583646386861801,
-0.7139187455177307,
-0.8233450651168823,
0.21361909806728363,
-0.4881661534309387,
0.615242600440979,
-1.1167694330215454,
-0.14961518347263336,
-0.6052542924880981,
-0.5197811722755432,
-0.510585606098175,
0.26371732354164124,
0.7631523013114929,
0.4727974832057953,
0.7488352656364441,
-0.26574042439460754,
-0.5016025304794312,
-0.3719913363456726,
0.21752779185771942,
-0.23370018601417542,
0.19635212421417236,
0.5979627966880798,
0.4049969017505646,
-0.31880804896354675,
0.9783610105514526,
-0.3450450599193573,
-0.49249836802482605,
-0.12931108474731445,
-0.09549472481012344,
-0.07165341824293137,
0.22780197858810425,
0.5334581732749939,
-1.0500668287277222,
-0.5227486491203308,
0.39783918857574463,
-0.8864132761955261,
0.3557400405406952,
-0.07083871960639954,
0.12933693826198578,
0.1116424947977066,
0.6186864972114563,
-0.32029470801353455,
0.8021904230117798,
0.4716973900794983,
-0.037264395505189896,
0.45654281973838806,
-0.39126574993133545,
0.3069921135902405,
-0.4208114743232727,
-0.5572260022163391,
0.15105070173740387,
-0.3758052885532379,
-0.6105313301086426,
0.1777818351984024,
-0.26698002219200134,
0.003102492541074753,
-0.8821483254432678,
0.4374070167541504,
-0.4580691456794739,
-0.24890434741973877,
-0.26994338631629944,
0.07977857440710068,
-0.051096923649311066,
0.5052860975265503,
0.4436309337615967,
0.7611693143844604,
0.9054503440856934,
-1.0932637453079224,
0.7822520732879639,
0.20495474338531494,
-0.4981582760810852,
0.1982472836971283,
-0.2658497989177704,
-0.0665210485458374,
-0.650669276714325,
-0.055104877799749374,
-0.7619366645812988,
-0.301979660987854,
0.058089446276426315,
-0.07757631689310074,
-0.07176850736141205,
-0.3698141872882843,
-0.3104007840156555,
-0.11946818977594376,
0.03242023289203644,
0.3165231943130493,
0.6678895950317383,
-0.7588598728179932,
0.8380624651908875,
0.03413066640496254,
0.45157918334007263,
-0.27225738763809204,
-0.6737599968910217,
0.10156483948230743,
-0.19666920602321625,
-0.5374888777732849,
0.5581572651863098,
0.06671678274869919,
-0.13417088985443115,
-0.14676138758659363,
0.048144422471523285,
-0.0949166864156723,
-0.08469263464212418,
0.6691832542419434,
0.2162650227546692,
-0.39830994606018066,
-0.02859744429588318,
-0.3330689072608948,
0.014466225169599056,
0.09935946762561798,
-0.24631312489509583,
0.3495158553123474,
-0.17885230481624603,
-0.3529466390609741,
-0.4396473169326782,
0.2315712720155716,
0.35750725865364075,
-0.3066929280757904,
0.6161090731620789,
0.7004956603050232,
-0.11577604711055756,
0.13200922310352325,
-0.35384663939476013,
-0.2270308881998062,
-0.6342611908912659,
0.3802507519721985,
-0.3771485984325409,
-0.6591386795043945,
-0.2989242374897003,
-0.0789206326007843,
0.17884154617786407,
-0.0027134339325129986,
0.25471484661102295,
-0.6299412250518799,
0.6930647492408752,
0.6891595721244812,
0.1605367213487625,
0.7732893824577332,
-0.5123842358589172,
0.2674494981765747,
-0.46749675273895264,
-0.6789284348487854,
0.21624168753623962,
-0.2079533189535141,
-0.4812825620174408,
-0.713880181312561,
0.6529725193977356,
-0.25563278794288635,
-0.527955949306488,
0.4738255441188812,
-0.15662813186645508,
0.5931919813156128,
0.8532956838607788,
0.25053170323371887,
0.15101003646850586,
0.09404301643371582,
0.05759112164378166,
-0.31038710474967957,
-0.5951128602027893,
-0.19197838008403778,
0.8197342157363892,
0.113255575299263,
0.5760914087295532,
0.4920317530632019,
0.5369590520858765,
0.2936236560344696,
0.09139227867126465,
-0.5573612451553345,
0.8532207012176514,
-0.1946672648191452,
-0.36489078402519226,
-0.2623082399368286,
-0.3158920705318451,
-0.6625732779502869,
-0.038868606090545654,
-0.2364547699689865,
-0.600895881652832,
-0.21970456838607788,
0.3492331802845001,
-0.44931483268737793,
0.21924440562725067,
-0.524834156036377,
0.9089279174804688,
-0.8524667620658875,
-0.4729599952697754,
-0.06569264829158783,
-0.7824777960777283,
0.2456124871969223,
0.41464006900787354,
0.2306136041879654,
0.12001609802246094,
0.16718460619449615,
0.27230432629585266,
-0.31836065649986267,
0.8618274927139282,
-0.548812985420227,
0.0785927027463913,
0.24546734988689423,
0.04861920699477196,
0.4346517026424408,
0.05850541591644287,
0.39153239130973816,
-0.11617190390825272,
-0.5706723928451538,
-0.024110160768032074,
-0.7450849413871765,
0.49397948384284973,
-0.7023910284042358,
-0.5901238918304443,
-0.3300027549266815,
-0.015398257412016392,
-0.14739680290222168,
0.003952152095735073,
0.2922179698944092,
0.6168927550315857,
-0.17284627258777618,
0.20378750562667847,
0.5862473845481873,
-0.27433979511260986,
0.7983396053314209,
0.5673509836196899,
-0.40632978081703186,
-0.4232025742530823,
1.4196221828460693,
-0.03317475691437721,
0.2186288982629776,
0.6210518479347229,
0.001122274436056614,
-0.5489203929901123,
-0.6653971076011658,
-0.630445122718811,
-0.21853001415729523,
-0.6392397284507751,
0.006918754428625107,
-0.3086487948894501,
-0.41943034529685974,
-0.33967819809913635,
-0.4223337769508362,
-0.6298143267631531,
0.14697369933128357,
-0.2933681011199951,
-0.4639880359172821,
0.4715571701526642,
0.7405537366867065,
-0.04565076157450676,
0.7235404849052429,
-0.6243575811386108,
0.45093509554862976,
0.666782557964325,
0.0692421942949295,
-0.32059651613235474,
-0.26166245341300964,
-0.48486027121543884,
0.20659804344177246,
-0.16501541435718536,
-0.6681973934173584,
0.3646508753299713,
0.43060973286628723,
0.4855427145957947,
0.3339473605155945,
-0.11729372292757034,
1.097166895866394,
-0.5295844078063965,
1.0072849988937378,
0.2743939161300659,
-0.5756950378417969,
0.6549935340881348,
-0.20139342546463013,
0.5601330399513245,
0.7125603556632996,
0.4043620824813843,
-0.10046987235546112,
-0.11485648900270462,
-0.2558566629886627,
-1.0561432838439941,
0.2535187900066376,
0.3157085180282593,
0.13201239705085754,
0.42498281598091125,
-0.03950027748942375,
-0.21983464062213898,
0.15852823853492737,
-0.9225377440452576,
-0.14623866975307465,
-0.7961313128471375,
0.011278335005044937,
-0.5344491004943848,
0.19337895512580872,
0.07467389106750488,
-0.4964652955532074,
0.6679118871688843,
-0.30712950229644775,
-0.007504256442189217,
0.3336164653301239,
-0.3859226405620575,
0.3584130108356476,
-0.1553984135389328,
0.7024447917938232,
0.20820678770542145,
-0.27795732021331787,
0.1980283111333847,
0.24347999691963196,
-0.47965261340141296,
0.3210473656654358,
-0.008215106092393398,
-0.3769482970237732,
0.21569183468818665,
0.23393724858760834,
1.0573383569717407,
0.28405556082725525,
-0.9509775638580322,
0.7009046077728271,
0.28713899850845337,
0.011465945281088352,
-0.7556397318840027,
0.2739589810371399,
-0.34728389978408813,
0.43193501234054565,
0.22901944816112518,
-0.06436317414045334,
0.33904969692230225,
-0.5090722441673279,
0.06939490884542465,
0.3887459337711334,
-0.8369776606559753,
-0.2599216103553772,
0.7457702159881592,
0.39605405926704407,
-0.502073347568512,
0.7165420055389404,
-0.49912771582603455,
-0.5132567882537842,
0.4465314745903015,
0.20643950998783112,
0.8305736184120178,
-0.09552889317274094,
0.4362567067146301,
0.5676814913749695,
0.49781009554862976,
-0.1819770336151123,
0.32759901881217957,
-0.15604129433631897,
-0.5035586357116699,
-0.40683481097221375,
-0.49960774183273315,
-0.2627001702785492,
0.1646440178155899,
-0.48467615246772766,
0.17092576622962952,
-0.5230307579040527,
-0.09456942230463028,
-0.5972403287887573,
-0.4112887382507324,
-0.9929401874542236,
0.8293628692626953,
0.4327974319458008,
0.6158098578453064,
-0.6618658304214478,
0.6568539142608643,
0.6425737738609314,
-0.27506551146507263,
-0.4633992612361908,
-0.09950648248195648,
0.2705232501029968,
-0.5667486786842346,
0.7641880512237549,
0.5914393067359924,
-0.5515883564949036,
-0.13052992522716522,
-0.2811869978904724,
-0.7877662181854248,
1.2093887329101562,
0.14322857558727264,
-0.5616007447242737,
-0.24944305419921875,
0.4641639292240143,
0.2577051818370819,
-0.3317953944206238,
0.14535804092884064,
0.4280828833580017,
0.36180469393730164,
0.1144583523273468,
-0.8308351039886475,
-0.33907657861709595,
-0.1868620365858078,
0.04238075762987137,
0.023514967411756516,
-0.6455436944961548,
0.3397465944290161,
-0.18335705995559692,
0.08915530890226364,
-0.13872364163398743,
0.8382207155227661,
0.30455490946769714,
0.5172991752624512,
0.6469972729682922,
0.5787926912307739,
0.3260091245174408,
-0.12692143023014069,
0.7896019220352173,
0.13903243839740753,
-0.16879840195178986,
1.5193281173706055,
-0.2792826294898987,
0.7492249608039856,
0.4965384006500244,
0.2413739264011383,
0.6810846328735352,
0.26470592617988586,
0.014283956028521061,
1.147649884223938,
-0.11477763205766678,
-0.5796968340873718,
-0.49081817269325256,
-0.21409837901592255,
-0.2072065770626068,
0.8237904906272888,
0.11764992773532867,
-0.2670125663280487,
-0.11030242592096329,
0.4741400182247162,
-0.3908196985721588,
0.0883074626326561,
-0.48424673080444336,
0.892071545124054,
-0.2769384980201721,
-0.6261802315711975,
0.21516761183738708,
-0.06919614970684052,
0.44241979718208313,
-0.6572886109352112,
-0.25819671154022217,
-0.15091978013515472,
0.09672733396291733,
-0.05638076737523079,
-0.9240724444389343,
0.06669197976589203,
0.061287153512239456,
0.20657148957252502,
-0.5370963215827942,
0.16368459165096283,
-0.34039661288261414,
-0.42517104744911194,
0.3003298044204712,
0.14608563482761383,
0.11441553384065628,
-0.14435729384422302,
-0.2078535407781601,
0.023169012740254402,
0.22238613665103912,
-0.0363985113799572,
0.09012487530708313,
0.1739671379327774,
0.11685322970151901,
0.8548077344894409,
0.5608683824539185,
-0.19637034833431244,
0.5104479789733887,
0.08078108727931976,
0.951082170009613,
-0.9068018794059753,
-0.4799190163612366,
-0.8889119625091553,
1.0615366697311401,
-0.2695161998271942,
-0.4940112233161926,
0.8280907273292542,
0.9421091675758362,
1.0041687488555908,
-0.18856239318847656,
0.6955674886703491,
0.11081136018037796,
-0.22136475145816803,
-1.1076641082763672,
0.1118677407503128,
-0.6663102507591248,
-0.08245102316141129,
-0.12953363358974457,
-0.7670921087265015,
0.08961634337902069,
0.6621772050857544,
-0.2077120691537857,
0.04612259939312935,
0.359449177980423,
1.0263177156448364,
-0.5127159953117371,
-0.14475008845329285,
0.3685978949069977,
-0.21407799422740936,
0.5240124464035034,
0.7620283961296082,
0.8414707183837891,
-0.6431682705879211,
0.6303899884223938,
-0.49337148666381836,
-0.0016411987598985434,
-0.43032073974609375,
-0.9517003297805786,
-0.8840312957763672,
-0.6256240606307983,
-0.5311585664749146,
-0.14423395693302155,
0.26693782210350037,
0.7374529838562012,
1.0560601949691772,
-0.1788606196641922,
-0.3123317062854767,
-0.4479404091835022,
-0.1808168590068817,
-0.44514700770378113,
-0.25406667590141296,
-0.15321244299411774,
0.06681372225284576,
-0.5074651837348938,
1.210424542427063,
0.5004981756210327,
0.5418063998222351,
-0.46423497796058655,
-0.47667673230171204,
0.0006329218740575016,
-0.22033558785915375,
0.5967353582382202,
0.45975378155708313,
-0.6874107122421265,
-0.27468445897102356,
0.16941311955451965,
-0.018085870891809464,
0.2400578260421753,
0.7503093481063843,
-1.0477689504623413,
0.7601519823074341,
0.18551410734653473,
0.48556187748908997,
1.0408759117126465,
0.03667275607585907,
0.7377103567123413,
-0.777525782585144,
0.2608242332935333,
0.17578141391277313,
0.20747405290603638,
0.6376670598983765,
0.008417138829827309,
0.5387252569198608,
0.13342435657978058,
-0.20484791696071625,
-0.5210595726966858,
0.3927168548107147,
-0.9565664529800415,
0.031244322657585144,
1.2295939922332764,
-0.007812860421836376,
-0.2983846962451935,
-0.09810034930706024,
-0.24958962202072144,
-0.03737283870577812,
-0.24173489212989807,
0.5296844244003296,
0.14869244396686554,
0.17266346514225006,
-0.6999605298042297,
-0.8927059769630432,
0.6590673327445984,
0.14968061447143555,
-0.6360557675361633,
-0.2188786268234253,
0.5677480697631836,
-0.0675714984536171,
0.0716920718550682,
0.47900375723838806,
0.4866762161254883,
0.6414129137992859,
-0.11255435645580292,
-0.2901242673397064,
-0.34373417496681213,
-0.6792905926704407,
-0.19453446567058563,
0.1415865570306778,
-0.32996076345443726,
-0.4370908737182617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03519v1 | Resolving Transcription Ambiguity in Spanish: A Hybrid Acoustic-Lexical System for Punctuation Restoration | 2024-02-05T21:05:35 | 2024-02-05T21:05:35 | Xiliang Zhu, Chia-Tien Chang, Shayna Gardiner, David Rossouw, Jonas Robertson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Punctuation restoration is a crucial step after Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) systems to enhance transcript readability and facilitate subsequent NLP
tasks. Nevertheless, conventional lexical-based approaches are inadequate for
solving the punctuation restoration task in Spanish, where ambiguity can be
often found between unpunctuated declaratives and questions. In this study, we
propose a novel hybrid acoustic-lexical punctuation restoration system for
Spanish transcription, which consolidates acoustic and lexical signals through
a modular process. Our experiment results show that the proposed system can
effectively improve F1 score of question marks and overall punctuation
restoration on both public and internal Spanish conversational datasets.
Additionally, benchmark comparison against LLMs (Large Language Model)
indicates the superiority of our approach in accuracy, reliability and latency.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that the Word Error Rate (WER) of the ASR module
also benefits from our proposed system. | [
-0.17108529806137085,
-0.7696368098258972,
0.439845472574234,
0.6317866444587708,
-0.487081915140152,
0.7377874255180359,
-0.3672800064086914,
-0.5962310433387756,
0.6828404068946838,
0.2902538478374481,
-0.4342785179615021,
-0.36912691593170166,
-0.38863304257392883,
0.6867024898529053,
-0.46928122639656067,
0.6130475401878357,
0.14428241550922394,
0.3128316402435303,
-0.10284072905778885,
-0.049490127712488174,
-0.4239983856678009,
-0.347677618265152,
-0.627694308757782,
-0.341010719537735,
0.3541029095649719,
0.020838772878050804,
0.7881482839584351,
0.5135912299156189,
0.6438312530517578,
0.3543343245983124,
-0.47515302896499634,
0.4183966815471649,
-0.08791431039571762,
-0.15951040387153625,
-0.24703270196914673,
-0.28761205077171326,
-0.3001045286655426,
-0.5927274227142334,
0.7537198066711426,
1.0197900533676147,
-0.3015376329421997,
-0.31671538949012756,
0.13613997399806976,
0.4497475028038025,
-0.42563748359680176,
0.0023834772873669863,
-0.4433617889881134,
0.08987262099981308,
-0.0724361464381218,
-0.4124264717102051,
-0.1458839625120163,
-0.7115115523338318,
-0.08475881814956665,
-0.5028266906738281,
-0.061781689524650574,
-0.05847049131989479,
0.3968100845813751,
0.547721266746521,
-0.3187958002090454,
-0.0758361890912056,
-1.0025869607925415,
0.49521660804748535,
-0.6135187149047852,
0.47846177220344543,
0.19754590094089508,
-0.03239234909415245,
-0.2439279407262802,
-0.5217969417572021,
-0.552635133266449,
0.17377206683158875,
-0.18803781270980835,
0.3738640546798706,
-0.16055218875408173,
0.2664441764354706,
-0.12961696088314056,
0.8523398041725159,
-0.4009592533111572,
0.15166057646274567,
-0.43229278922080994,
-0.6951798796653748,
0.1322726607322693,
0.009499313309788704,
0.27975964546203613,
-0.14863668382167816,
-0.531349778175354,
-0.024003418162465096,
-0.6974754929542542,
0.19696401059627533,
0.6658142805099487,
0.44603464007377625,
0.18773610889911652,
0.3110595941543579,
-0.13103780150413513,
0.7027305364608765,
-0.30063942074775696,
-0.3324536979198456,
0.4578897953033447,
-0.3845216929912567,
-0.12079209834337234,
0.4161984324455261,
0.8845319747924805,
0.07149962335824966,
0.0198652446269989,
-0.3348298966884613,
-0.2753419280052185,
0.18914006650447845,
-0.09141545742750168,
-0.095360167324543,
0.18224512040615082,
0.18857479095458984,
0.18245753645896912,
-0.08531353622674942,
0.5649104714393616,
-0.40012574195861816,
-0.31325656175613403,
-0.3151649236679077,
0.586652934551239,
-0.3633521497249603,
-0.31240352988243103,
0.8690890073776245,
-0.14495179057121277,
0.13403508067131042,
0.4392179548740387,
-0.4697916805744171,
0.5580334067344666,
0.6181182861328125,
0.8065822124481201,
-0.14555011689662933,
0.0015967692015692592,
-0.19619561731815338,
0.08448964357376099,
-0.14259915053844452,
0.8026013374328613,
-0.34347569942474365,
-0.8762131333351135,
0.025065144523978233,
-0.05755574256181717,
-0.5352995991706848,
-0.9991100430488586,
0.8156057000160217,
-0.40481486916542053,
0.5441185235977173,
-0.3025995194911957,
-0.3485395014286041,
-0.21017685532569885,
0.11593581736087799,
-0.8036194443702698,
1.2508031129837036,
-0.24604929983615875,
-0.5761627554893494,
-0.18286359310150146,
-0.3948740065097809,
-0.6534338593482971,
0.04181627929210663,
-0.0656660869717598,
-0.4232712984085083,
-0.16206006705760956,
0.23576074838638306,
-0.15417997539043427,
-0.22095456719398499,
0.3332684338092804,
-0.004269761964678764,
-0.5629034042358398,
0.28147977590560913,
-0.22718945145606995,
0.82989102602005,
-0.18674276769161224,
-0.32221609354019165,
-0.11289262026548386,
-0.6657877564430237,
-0.046207983046770096,
-0.3409627079963684,
-0.7321600914001465,
-0.3214515447616577,
-0.3053905665874481,
-0.0194388534873724,
0.2463577836751938,
0.5432640314102173,
-0.9416069984436035,
-0.18703486025333405,
-0.679233193397522,
0.3535076379776001,
0.4832688868045807,
0.26285412907600403,
0.24777941405773163,
-0.6424638628959656,
0.6416200995445251,
-0.16536931693553925,
0.048715606331825256,
-0.18358640372753143,
-0.5811005234718323,
-0.8079674243927002,
-0.4635285437107086,
0.4030233323574066,
0.9858644604682922,
-0.6461762189865112,
0.8758999109268188,
-0.2730759382247925,
-0.14128129184246063,
-0.6411851644515991,
-0.15553860366344452,
0.8079535961151123,
0.7921605110168457,
0.5626444816589355,
-0.36538252234458923,
-0.9520951509475708,
-0.7905236482620239,
-0.11811105161905289,
-0.2960539758205414,
-0.1362273246049881,
0.2685847282409668,
0.2439456284046173,
0.13604611158370972,
1.09396493434906,
-0.06636977195739746,
-0.448912113904953,
0.05779426917433739,
0.0796283707022667,
0.3653448820114136,
0.5360076427459717,
-0.1283680945634842,
-0.6577369570732117,
-0.23346708714962006,
0.18307612836360931,
-0.3082405626773834,
-0.5090149641036987,
0.08941171318292618,
0.10473743081092834,
-0.1215486228466034,
0.7062276601791382,
-0.23643316328525543,
0.263203501701355,
0.42524453997612,
-0.36251676082611084,
0.6979883313179016,
-0.18491700291633606,
0.3823910653591156,
-0.8840135931968689,
0.27659502625465393,
-0.4484083652496338,
-0.5511346459388733,
-0.5652264952659607,
-0.17551428079605103,
0.1367024928331375,
0.04836291819810867,
-0.666607677936554,
0.23433753848075867,
-0.27534887194633484,
-0.07812713086605072,
-0.04998995363712311,
-0.055793825536966324,
0.259257972240448,
0.3288940191268921,
0.10046429932117462,
1.0544533729553223,
0.28034311532974243,
-0.3669041693210602,
0.07195483148097992,
0.6117924451828003,
-0.09512603282928467,
0.46263906359672546,
-0.7644002437591553,
0.2742916941642761,
0.007123521529138088,
0.3087890148162842,
-0.9327760934829712,
0.15268531441688538,
0.14350663125514984,
-0.27123451232910156,
-0.0029863305389881134,
0.14721669256687164,
-0.7477311491966248,
-0.48344865441322327,
-0.32421451807022095,
0.4477207064628601,
0.29982247948646545,
-0.44738736748695374,
0.4570963978767395,
0.16460223495960236,
-0.4518750011920929,
-0.3983387053012848,
-0.5234377384185791,
0.14527533948421478,
0.035963211208581924,
-0.7509332299232483,
0.5776073336601257,
-0.08501149713993073,
-0.26351720094680786,
-0.2430354654788971,
-0.44210684299468994,
0.06867208331823349,
-0.08222697675228119,
0.01851283386349678,
0.22590559720993042,
-0.3538518249988556,
0.15017861127853394,
0.27404624223709106,
0.11365781724452972,
-0.0792497768998146,
-0.32622796297073364,
0.7724628448486328,
-0.14307813346385956,
-0.44735509157180786,
-0.6443381905555725,
0.3641241490840912,
0.5955789685249329,
-0.4403552711009979,
0.4070983827114105,
0.1493101418018341,
-0.41104161739349365,
0.06843342632055283,
-0.9453535676002502,
-0.11972834169864655,
-0.46728453040122986,
-0.06293195486068726,
-0.3065543472766876,
-0.7938947677612305,
0.9747575521469116,
-0.15900392830371857,
-0.43503469228744507,
0.3626217246055603,
0.5715756416320801,
-0.18428948521614075,
0.41119781136512756,
0.4838652014732361,
-0.061691030859947205,
0.5553406476974487,
-0.07830033451318741,
0.11244244873523712,
-0.6847677230834961,
-0.6815401315689087,
-0.6405324935913086,
-0.09886614978313446,
0.15520285069942474,
-0.46990758180618286,
0.5373913645744324,
-0.13628661632537842,
0.3186165690422058,
0.4632680118083954,
-0.22787906229496002,
0.6159594655036926,
0.6431246399879456,
0.5151795148849487,
0.959792971611023,
-0.15230828523635864,
-0.4271439015865326,
0.006179227493703365,
-0.4078015983104706,
-0.5332496166229248,
0.4956628978252411,
0.01375792920589447,
0.302355021238327,
0.103480264544487,
0.7674869298934937,
0.3081156015396118,
-0.3860708773136139,
-0.5984155535697937,
0.3976725935935974,
-0.1703992336988449,
-0.3604203462600708,
-0.31537574529647827,
-0.3104330897331238,
-0.7193106412887573,
0.5183363556861877,
-0.31293192505836487,
-0.5740100741386414,
0.4739502966403961,
0.06461867690086365,
-0.9503249526023865,
0.2513716518878937,
-0.5945927500724792,
0.5251925587654114,
0.14434123039245605,
-0.2194634974002838,
-0.0481594055891037,
-0.7171865105628967,
0.05374517664313316,
-0.2590448260307312,
0.35167577862739563,
0.06612002849578857,
-0.250573992729187,
0.8058550357818604,
-0.8130735158920288,
0.6820575594902039,
0.007411505561321974,
-0.18528735637664795,
0.06438631564378738,
0.0484674796462059,
0.492443710565567,
-0.15752634406089783,
-0.14929234981536865,
-0.003676914842799306,
-0.06708107888698578,
0.03578753396868706,
-0.6466765999794006,
0.3185340166091919,
-0.5141416192054749,
-0.4193475842475891,
-0.11215846985578537,
-0.6503660082817078,
-0.4487582743167877,
0.07486756145954132,
0.1756114363670349,
0.3721945285797119,
-0.3933772146701813,
0.0727686658501625,
0.819179892539978,
-0.11167995631694794,
0.5868085622787476,
0.6632347106933594,
0.013755305670201778,
-0.6875054836273193,
0.6968207955360413,
-0.3258872330188751,
0.20263105630874634,
0.4454800486564636,
0.06449436396360397,
-0.3917413055896759,
-0.585938572883606,
-0.33479899168014526,
0.4971071183681488,
-0.3730027675628662,
-0.31895145773887634,
-0.7174739837646484,
0.028468623757362366,
-0.30793526768684387,
-0.1795007437467575,
-0.3579811453819275,
-0.7822736501693726,
-0.6564615964889526,
-0.07064212113618851,
0.3150479197502136,
0.39657077193260193,
0.03588429093360901,
0.4573635756969452,
-0.6890838742256165,
0.13051101565361023,
0.06690361350774765,
0.10432248562574387,
-0.47874701023101807,
-0.9160082340240479,
0.03287935256958008,
-0.13485635817050934,
0.020624104887247086,
-0.8387170433998108,
0.3123582601547241,
0.4300953149795532,
0.19147880375385284,
0.40140098333358765,
-0.04936527833342552,
0.9483355283737183,
-0.7085180282592773,
0.3239895701408386,
0.32082200050354004,
-1.0550094842910767,
0.41000065207481384,
-0.5536771416664124,
0.32223424315452576,
0.794730544090271,
-0.07925242185592651,
-0.8810559511184692,
-0.9061365127563477,
-0.5333746075630188,
-0.9730823636054993,
0.4887765049934387,
0.285983681678772,
-0.23647722601890564,
0.03293882682919502,
0.18983517587184906,
0.1911875307559967,
0.3322960138320923,
-0.4679943025112152,
0.03567710146307945,
-0.002569114789366722,
-0.3042766749858856,
0.05150356516242027,
-0.02173890359699726,
-0.2953556478023529,
-0.4091220796108246,
0.730731189250946,
0.2106926143169403,
0.07662934809923172,
0.39621543884277344,
-0.47562041878700256,
-0.10068334639072418,
0.3735071122646332,
0.6315246224403381,
0.3565467298030853,
-0.05453013628721237,
0.10219038277864456,
0.16771067678928375,
-0.5407470464706421,
0.22346927225589752,
0.424679696559906,
-0.14816510677337646,
0.17961539328098297,
0.2839799225330353,
0.4120142459869385,
0.777470588684082,
-0.5944628715515137,
0.6693581938743591,
0.2749263644218445,
-0.0708887055516243,
-0.42291519045829773,
-0.22668671607971191,
0.12627267837524414,
0.23402056097984314,
0.46089041233062744,
0.40929391980171204,
0.3640308082103729,
-0.4487035572528839,
0.16860300302505493,
0.27414557337760925,
-0.19307462871074677,
-0.29019075632095337,
0.6273193359375,
0.41950881481170654,
-0.5698732733726501,
0.14282910525798798,
-0.010635128244757652,
-0.7257910370826721,
0.6168327331542969,
0.6848883628845215,
0.4811406433582306,
-0.38356176018714905,
0.19041623175144196,
0.1867893934249878,
0.2565092146396637,
-0.4054221510887146,
0.6631768941879272,
-0.133505180478096,
-0.6287376284599304,
-0.3649699091911316,
-0.7076218724250793,
-0.6301816701889038,
-0.34438151121139526,
-0.8129984140396118,
0.08915666490793228,
-0.48081618547439575,
-0.01946982927620411,
-0.24537873268127441,
-0.2566078305244446,
-0.2888355851173401,
0.07063975185155869,
0.19518890976905823,
0.8961784839630127,
-1.0059419870376587,
0.7948400378227234,
0.5652185082435608,
-0.3600938618183136,
-0.628050684928894,
-0.41024962067604065,
-0.06556396931409836,
-0.8112704753875732,
0.08509418368339539,
-0.14698606729507446,
-0.6588636040687561,
0.053384967148303986,
0.13224519789218903,
-0.9693707823753357,
0.947517454624176,
0.7104961276054382,
-0.7666031718254089,
-0.03862696886062622,
0.5002569556236267,
0.7893971800804138,
0.15472827851772308,
0.010176609270274639,
0.771433413028717,
0.6034259796142578,
0.11635575443506241,
-1.5840445756912231,
0.01989305391907692,
-0.2600981593132019,
-0.09921564906835556,
0.42794302105903625,
-0.428457647562027,
0.5398868918418884,
0.04035722836852074,
-0.457156240940094,
0.3373381495475769,
0.4743252396583557,
-0.1913982629776001,
-0.09144303947687149,
0.5613163113594055,
0.6429337859153748,
1.027138352394104,
-0.3825642764568329,
0.7568332552909851,
-0.18908105790615082,
0.2618599236011505,
0.9837546944618225,
-0.00469953054562211,
0.7728906273841858,
0.9883368015289307,
-0.36358290910720825,
0.673973798751831,
0.4733000099658966,
0.21089918911457062,
0.37940046191215515,
0.007766479626297951,
-0.6307540535926819,
-0.22028495371341705,
-0.29224008321762085,
-0.39196139574050903,
0.437274307012558,
0.316029816865921,
-0.26279279589653015,
-0.045438073575496674,
0.08591002970933914,
0.03710435703396797,
0.46601176261901855,
-0.27104780077934265,
0.887079656124115,
-0.03525222837924957,
-0.5638797879219055,
0.33092638850212097,
-0.12761643528938293,
0.6857568025588989,
-0.4947045147418976,
0.2862362563610077,
-0.38546279072761536,
0.09726285934448242,
-0.41885799169540405,
-0.19154538214206696,
0.4177605211734772,
-0.3899799585342407,
-0.17905572056770325,
-0.3580354154109955,
0.3049010634422302,
-0.7051954865455627,
-0.4514220058917999,
0.19809645414352417,
0.6576247215270996,
0.09045404195785522,
-0.17530551552772522,
-0.4001480042934418,
0.21904797852039337,
-0.028034484013915062,
0.23209437727928162,
-0.3145102262496948,
0.09756709635257721,
0.14792005717754364,
0.3352981507778168,
0.6601892709732056,
0.2853550612926483,
0.41109055280685425,
0.46272262930870056,
0.824189305305481,
-0.606070876121521,
-0.7728118896484375,
-0.7279219627380371,
0.5761119723320007,
-0.00425297487527132,
-0.28853291273117065,
0.5919577479362488,
0.7882804870605469,
0.5848847031593323,
-0.09777934849262238,
0.48199859261512756,
0.21359820663928986,
0.827053964138031,
-0.6262290477752686,
0.26720237731933594,
-0.17569203674793243,
0.5181779861450195,
-0.4908077120780945,
-0.80433189868927,
-0.8956511616706848,
0.4574146866798401,
-0.23617279529571533,
-0.3407231867313385,
1.097895860671997,
1.0951253175735474,
-0.15515314042568207,
0.21944479644298553,
0.4487435817718506,
0.057564180344343185,
-0.08862423151731491,
0.31377968192100525,
0.882309079170227,
-0.3922766447067261,
0.8462083339691162,
-0.27670401334762573,
-0.22211939096450806,
-0.07719680666923523,
-0.42577123641967773,
-0.28247857093811035,
-0.5029857754707336,
-0.31134048104286194,
-0.1471194475889206,
0.42396053671836853,
0.9608904123306274,
0.22744761407375336,
-0.8588769435882568,
-0.34972190856933594,
-0.10940916836261749,
0.05200548470020294,
-0.20001254975795746,
-0.17994371056556702,
0.3826516568660736,
-0.1759169101715088,
-0.761860728263855,
0.8865624070167542,
0.5245851874351501,
0.07951048761606216,
-0.15206462144851685,
0.038573961704969406,
-0.15647143125534058,
-0.06571050733327866,
0.21481680870056152,
0.679855465888977,
-0.8170531392097473,
-0.3596343696117401,
0.29483580589294434,
0.0548931360244751,
0.4301299750804901,
1.1212211847305298,
-1.0515861511230469,
0.5735961198806763,
0.27956271171569824,
0.5610420107841492,
0.29934534430503845,
-0.024595821276307106,
0.7435007691383362,
-0.8080096244812012,
0.31852972507476807,
0.5186963677406311,
0.8464481234550476,
0.5961269736289978,
-0.32370874285697937,
0.28430140018463135,
0.568691074848175,
-0.20159445703029633,
-0.7063906192779541,
0.22642655670642853,
-1.1475979089736938,
0.06800501048564911,
1.0725970268249512,
0.02674705721437931,
0.009186121635138988,
-0.4619283378124237,
-0.5094639658927917,
0.23850524425506592,
-0.5612624287605286,
0.817829966545105,
0.5250812768936157,
0.08389876037836075,
0.1963135004043579,
0.22662410140037537,
0.3439416289329529,
0.6220958828926086,
-0.5744738578796387,
-0.2161656767129898,
0.5073003768920898,
0.2126792073249817,
0.3939478099346161,
0.594342827796936,
-0.4548923075199127,
0.5524747967720032,
-0.3230051100254059,
0.2618609368801117,
-0.024275999516248703,
-0.2986457645893097,
-0.7269493341445923,
0.12110692262649536,
-0.1333494335412979,
-0.3283238708972931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03509v1 | Evaluating the Factuality of Zero-shot Summarizers Across Varied Domains | 2024-02-05T20:51:11 | 2024-02-05T20:51:11 | Sanjana Ramprasad, Kundan Krishna, Zachary C Lipton, Byron C Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work has shown that large language models (LLMs) are capable of
generating summaries zero-shot (i.e., without explicit supervision) that, under
human assessment, are often comparable or even preferred to manually composed
reference summaries. However, this prior work has focussed almost exclusively
on evaluating news article summarization. How do zero-shot summarizers perform
in other (potentially more specialized) domains? In this work we evaluate
zero-shot generated summaries across specialized domains including biomedical
articles, and legal bills (in addition to standard news benchmarks for
reference). We focus especially on the factuality of outputs. We acquire
annotations from domain experts to identify inconsistencies in summaries and
systematically categorize these errors. We analyze whether the prevalence of a
given domain in the pretraining corpus affects extractiveness and faithfulness
of generated summaries of articles in this domain. We release all collected
annotations to facilitate additional research toward measuring and realizing
factually accurate summarization, beyond news articles. The dataset can be
downloaded from https://github.com/sanjanaramprasad/zero_shot_faceval_domains | [
-0.04733092337846756,
-0.8309326767921448,
0.7560135126113892,
0.15150415897369385,
-0.33121979236602783,
0.14768698811531067,
-0.17521429061889648,
-0.5313557386398315,
0.3317548930644989,
0.3402005732059479,
-0.24597099423408508,
-0.6929293870925903,
-0.7952409386634827,
0.4005798101425171,
-0.36876991391181946,
1.454028606414795,
-0.04320210963487625,
-0.21677987277507782,
-0.6113206744194031,
-0.38237157464027405,
-0.30466601252555847,
-0.5306452512741089,
0.06911920011043549,
-0.28539368510246277,
0.656022846698761,
0.27396225929260254,
0.4073870778083801,
0.44603487849235535,
0.6095973253250122,
0.17493751645088196,
-0.0016555704642087221,
0.12744203209877014,
-0.6457525491714478,
-0.002769020851701498,
-0.26831620931625366,
-0.21164920926094055,
-0.5582678318023682,
0.20663107931613922,
0.6026533842086792,
0.6946773529052734,
0.08332138508558273,
0.4287319481372833,
-0.20963309705257416,
0.5517994165420532,
-0.8751933574676514,
0.006587716285139322,
-0.667573869228363,
0.12041632831096649,
-0.20827420055866241,
-0.3938254117965698,
-0.3517094850540161,
-0.5043290257453918,
0.2508986294269562,
-0.33634641766548157,
0.49570178985595703,
-0.19229237735271454,
1.123718500137329,
0.17071712017059326,
-0.653409481048584,
-0.19189788401126862,
-0.7810961008071899,
0.6640098094940186,
-0.7907214164733887,
0.11134174466133118,
0.011871160939335823,
0.2399989515542984,
0.22736209630966187,
-0.5706908702850342,
-0.42740917205810547,
-0.188301220536232,
-0.13986870646476746,
0.46832796931266785,
-0.3146438002586365,
-0.15600138902664185,
0.22189004719257355,
0.3685257136821747,
-0.700486421585083,
-0.1552375704050064,
-0.4707784950733185,
-0.16341723501682281,
0.7679920792579651,
0.11904727667570114,
0.3869466781616211,
-0.028263062238693237,
-0.09584509581327438,
0.4779408574104309,
-0.9305110573768616,
-0.2762335240840912,
0.38658010959625244,
0.18634790182113647,
-0.22494494915008545,
0.8257441520690918,
-0.5226348042488098,
0.6863119602203369,
0.03394961729645729,
-0.27289775013923645,
0.23831439018249512,
-0.5589988231658936,
-0.23678340017795563,
0.18399962782859802,
0.600537896156311,
0.5789291262626648,
0.25019314885139465,
-0.32827162742614746,
0.00411806209012866,
-0.13481184840202332,
0.4989730417728424,
-0.8546687960624695,
-0.05383650213479996,
0.40410253405570984,
-0.15710628032684326,
-0.4085315763950348,
-0.013469378463923931,
-0.26334819197654724,
-0.18201665580272675,
-0.24579088389873505,
0.5630570650100708,
-0.23455475270748138,
-0.18764536082744598,
0.1306687593460083,
-0.2904280126094818,
0.09810150414705276,
0.4791916310787201,
-0.5912585258483887,
0.14890196919441223,
0.5420427918434143,
0.827298104763031,
-0.4002467095851898,
-0.2109278291463852,
-0.3350783586502075,
0.1446315199136734,
-0.3283407986164093,
1.093454360961914,
-0.028280675411224365,
-0.23629166185855865,
0.07654313743114471,
-0.22315427660942078,
-0.24122704565525055,
-0.5549066662788391,
0.4372257590293884,
-0.6202526688575745,
-0.010060752741992474,
-0.3274538815021515,
-0.7637456059455872,
-0.1087845116853714,
0.4058140814304352,
-0.4088767468929291,
0.3623253405094147,
0.0865958109498024,
-0.8305338621139526,
0.5305501818656921,
-0.44927507638931274,
-0.7244938015937805,
0.026143593713641167,
-0.24940058588981628,
-0.5123223066329956,
0.2608407735824585,
-0.034323401749134064,
0.5114773511886597,
0.1659560203552246,
0.42387160658836365,
-0.16912508010864258,
-0.3284669518470764,
0.36302581429481506,
-0.372604638338089,
0.7431673407554626,
-0.08373856544494629,
-0.19938071072101593,
-0.010239209979772568,
-0.7321362495422363,
-0.3640115559101105,
0.20321273803710938,
-0.21638739109039307,
-0.3362499475479126,
-0.19257047772407532,
-0.15708918869495392,
0.053187914192676544,
0.07628557831048965,
-0.7201549410820007,
0.07130223512649536,
-0.32770997285842896,
-0.0560583621263504,
0.1391468644142151,
0.5345008969306946,
0.14214348793029785,
-0.4444220960140228,
0.3139636218547821,
0.13358913362026215,
-0.14994600415229797,
-0.4894098937511444,
-0.375762403011322,
-0.5083602666854858,
-0.4602207839488983,
0.5537970662117004,
0.4597824513912201,
-0.640630841255188,
0.32246148586273193,
-0.45182645320892334,
-0.5264844298362732,
-0.26208215951919556,
-0.09698919206857681,
0.5326008200645447,
0.8039049506187439,
0.2586919069290161,
-0.42513370513916016,
-0.3953193724155426,
-0.8542218804359436,
-0.5616874098777771,
-0.03358793258666992,
0.05861324444413185,
0.1725112944841385,
0.7932440638542175,
-0.09465282410383224,
1.1246545314788818,
-0.5366820096969604,
-0.09736297279596329,
-0.2351674735546112,
0.5695970058441162,
0.16066403687000275,
0.17091290652751923,
0.7530927062034607,
-0.3598187565803528,
-0.419028639793396,
-0.07255037873983383,
-1.1623708009719849,
-0.32729002833366394,
-0.36716631054878235,
0.13177475333213806,
0.2569872736930847,
0.011936097405850887,
-0.9648337364196777,
0.6704383492469788,
0.17542526125907898,
-0.1241445541381836,
1.0311204195022583,
-0.1056036576628685,
0.23807477951049805,
-0.6163123250007629,
0.3514215052127838,
0.0868246853351593,
-0.4757947027683258,
-0.644345223903656,
0.06582006812095642,
-0.0497092641890049,
0.00878225453197956,
-0.5908967852592468,
0.42654770612716675,
-0.4405023455619812,
-0.3128091096878052,
-0.31114858388900757,
0.40451446175575256,
0.22429248690605164,
0.2945307791233063,
0.11036744713783264,
0.77159184217453,
0.32755720615386963,
-0.6183984279632568,
0.1431531459093094,
0.29548704624176025,
-0.2853792607784271,
0.6043854355812073,
-0.9150057435035706,
-0.14344820380210876,
-0.2396267056465149,
0.3711341321468353,
-0.6789661645889282,
-0.4108956754207611,
0.1503453254699707,
-0.600487232208252,
0.2226419895887375,
-0.00973964761942625,
-0.35570046305656433,
-0.0024091913364827633,
-0.5420359373092651,
0.17375724017620087,
0.33293479681015015,
-0.06417535245418549,
0.24612204730510712,
0.43690991401672363,
-0.24702541530132294,
-0.7603453397750854,
-0.54349684715271,
0.3555874526500702,
0.14340677857398987,
-0.2038322538137436,
0.20264321565628052,
-0.024331487715244293,
-0.4606296420097351,
0.30907371640205383,
-0.37908315658569336,
-0.10279345512390137,
0.1103062704205513,
0.21604250371456146,
0.33569058775901794,
-0.31824401021003723,
-0.16718529164791107,
0.2814517319202423,
0.08366619050502777,
0.09527291357517242,
0.014281640760600567,
-0.017263727262616158,
0.08633123338222504,
-0.4415779411792755,
-0.3634600043296814,
0.2419208139181137,
0.4939360022544861,
-0.15978801250457764,
0.6572178602218628,
0.35900431871414185,
-0.29304060339927673,
-0.029770147055387497,
-0.6016150712966919,
0.04547961428761482,
-0.28986284136772156,
0.2750934362411499,
-0.0830933004617691,
-0.7882903218269348,
0.4955176115036011,
0.16933013498783112,
0.3687935471534729,
0.6925704479217529,
0.7396095395088196,
-0.09410832822322845,
0.3744527995586395,
0.5474003553390503,
0.23475691676139832,
-0.12365156412124634,
-0.19301152229309082,
0.2458750307559967,
-0.612914502620697,
-0.06154472380876541,
-0.3086748719215393,
0.14385472238063812,
-0.2750221788883209,
-0.1944044977426529,
0.4818945825099945,
-0.11093530058860779,
0.15669211745262146,
0.3736973702907562,
-0.06531806290149689,
0.7042621970176697,
0.29389292001724243,
-0.08470801264047623,
0.4753457307815552,
0.13364148139953613,
0.021447235718369484,
0.10823312401771545,
-0.6331609487533569,
-0.7338629961013794,
1.178528904914856,
0.21502113342285156,
0.2515997886657715,
0.04239318519830704,
0.7098661661148071,
0.5965042114257812,
0.6780411005020142,
-0.9558901190757751,
0.28945088386535645,
-0.0852142870426178,
-0.732410192489624,
-0.018055306747555733,
-0.41073957085609436,
-0.7082418203353882,
0.26346221566200256,
-0.32647958397865295,
-0.42412954568862915,
0.21912600100040436,
0.004860592540353537,
-0.7870320677757263,
0.12258681654930115,
-0.36392542719841003,
0.711944043636322,
0.006060573738068342,
-0.2291060984134674,
-0.18622079491615295,
-0.7107646465301514,
0.6998465657234192,
-0.3854808807373047,
0.08616781234741211,
-0.337348610162735,
0.02986794523894787,
0.5119827389717102,
-0.25670909881591797,
0.8949111104011536,
0.03322707116603851,
-0.2057458907365799,
0.4207752048969269,
0.042652834206819534,
-0.27184027433395386,
0.14657849073410034,
0.09129535406827927,
0.7089799046516418,
0.06547977775335312,
-0.48707643151283264,
-0.33835092186927795,
0.39500582218170166,
-0.7663974761962891,
-0.5763752460479736,
-0.6778972744941711,
-0.5430461764335632,
-0.3989943861961365,
0.35890504717826843,
0.3372993767261505,
0.6528258919715881,
-0.5034691691398621,
0.1822499781847,
0.6186148524284363,
-0.34785202145576477,
0.2275814265012741,
1.0405707359313965,
-0.01062774658203125,
-0.32160672545433044,
0.876842200756073,
0.5296482443809509,
0.01671852543950081,
0.3790288269519806,
-0.1610262542963028,
-0.0672912523150444,
-0.6471843719482422,
-0.6500898599624634,
0.4216378331184387,
-0.5957338809967041,
-0.42469024658203125,
-0.8485636711120605,
-0.4296458065509796,
-0.6353422403335571,
-0.07129083573818207,
-0.23934808373451233,
-0.6341769695281982,
-0.1571504771709442,
-0.4009058475494385,
0.0022154049947857857,
0.7327105402946472,
-0.11670968681573868,
0.20808014273643494,
-1.1486432552337646,
0.41777220368385315,
0.21617905795574188,
0.09095774590969086,
-0.2930815517902374,
-0.6666405200958252,
-0.4707198739051819,
-0.09521549940109253,
-0.285114586353302,
-0.7777184844017029,
0.19867749512195587,
0.14350777864456177,
0.5449191331863403,
0.24443751573562622,
0.09300587326288223,
0.48757535219192505,
-0.7702105641365051,
1.0068106651306152,
0.23355939984321594,
-0.9207135438919067,
0.4131997227668762,
-0.46373510360717773,
0.33292290568351746,
0.6904534101486206,
0.471149206161499,
-0.3209517300128937,
-0.5735987424850464,
-0.5755770802497864,
-0.8439873456954956,
0.4733162522315979,
0.4545000195503235,
0.2571849524974823,
-0.09187006950378418,
0.6017525792121887,
0.3433953523635864,
0.4282398521900177,
-0.31056731939315796,
-0.38288113474845886,
-0.11535544693470001,
-0.07363913953304291,
0.029235146939754486,
-0.44885656237602234,
-0.30487316846847534,
0.06760414689779282,
0.7061055898666382,
0.031473491340875626,
0.16793422400951385,
0.4349828362464905,
-0.487130343914032,
-0.22295670211315155,
0.15425263345241547,
1.0257651805877686,
1.0344233512878418,
-0.3128986060619354,
0.2515577971935272,
0.01451906282454729,
-0.5379442572593689,
0.05585097521543503,
-0.054284319281578064,
-0.528342604637146,
0.587874710559845,
0.8826398253440857,
0.6873921155929565,
0.17084312438964844,
-0.7687857747077942,
0.850482165813446,
-0.13003751635551453,
-0.3316513001918793,
-0.09679917991161346,
-0.00547436997294426,
-0.24206753075122833,
-0.01502513512969017,
0.41805729269981384,
0.28969287872314453,
0.32361850142478943,
-0.47076037526130676,
0.40157341957092285,
0.30207207798957825,
-0.10981229692697525,
-0.8094542622566223,
0.6978811621665955,
0.2704242169857025,
0.15495677292346954,
0.1526862531900406,
-0.163168266415596,
-0.1956646889448166,
0.6444429159164429,
0.46317633986473083,
0.9950430393218994,
0.14913985133171082,
0.41002291440963745,
0.35618022084236145,
0.33154916763305664,
0.14673945307731628,
-0.06339201331138611,
-0.0009534714627079666,
-0.8286144733428955,
-0.8629370331764221,
-0.5502090454101562,
-0.7278707027435303,
-0.0059127770364284515,
-0.5707995295524597,
-0.03690081089735031,
-0.20259059965610504,
-0.27320265769958496,
0.29767054319381714,
-0.08350954204797745,
-0.2902234196662903,
0.36315420269966125,
0.24009251594543457,
0.7690454721450806,
-1.1023526191711426,
0.543727457523346,
0.7609860301017761,
-0.6887254118919373,
-0.31861603260040283,
0.298458069562912,
0.06001468375325203,
-0.6513791680335999,
0.59803706407547,
0.02717910148203373,
-0.2737334668636322,
-0.26454803347587585,
-0.653063952922821,
-0.5209352374076843,
0.9454168677330017,
0.6411756277084351,
-0.35743510723114014,
0.2016734480857849,
0.37673747539520264,
0.6159479022026062,
-0.28291746973991394,
0.24157945811748505,
0.4664037525653839,
0.19575510919094086,
0.02201877348124981,
-0.9328261017799377,
-0.18589036166667938,
-0.1573268622159958,
-0.3162524700164795,
-0.2970556318759918,
-0.5412604212760925,
0.6143375635147095,
-0.2276180535554886,
-0.2284488081932068,
-0.2709689736366272,
0.7010272741317749,
0.32125893235206604,
0.6648513674736023,
-0.05368555337190628,
0.5178439617156982,
0.44848307967185974,
0.12019345164299011,
1.1151463985443115,
-0.4110488295555115,
0.4122728407382965,
1.21278715133667,
-0.662794828414917,
0.5535048842430115,
0.2643704116344452,
-0.053690988570451736,
0.4110505282878876,
0.3193778395652771,
0.00792766734957695,
0.3941856026649475,
-0.15376067161560059,
-0.39360952377319336,
-0.010968555696308613,
-0.3273935317993164,
-0.15694023668766022,
0.387862890958786,
0.07492971420288086,
-0.09913553297519684,
-0.5664774179458618,
-0.24084410071372986,
0.25161656737327576,
0.013847057707607746,
-0.17334991693496704,
0.8126427531242371,
0.1811825931072235,
-0.4881473481655121,
0.41841214895248413,
0.15724585950374603,
0.3565984070301056,
-0.46746182441711426,
-0.03979834169149399,
-0.3780783712863922,
-0.12900246679782867,
-0.4081657826900482,
-0.637031078338623,
0.7463394999504089,
0.56710284948349,
-0.15239255130290985,
-0.05389415845274925,
0.9751918315887451,
-0.33131155371665955,
-0.25730425119400024,
-0.1774733066558838,
0.9535049796104431,
0.3351869583129883,
-0.049894191324710846,
-0.4075767993927002,
0.045607663691043854,
-0.2918691635131836,
-0.2724810838699341,
0.3280927538871765,
0.44015106558799744,
0.13594986498355865,
0.14363844692707062,
0.4784126281738281,
0.32207053899765015,
-0.10538593679666519,
0.02256767451763153,
0.6068019866943359,
-0.4717799723148346,
-0.01489370595663786,
-1.019131064414978,
0.5108402371406555,
-0.20782232284545898,
-0.368306964635849,
1.1117963790893555,
0.7636703252792358,
0.6667996644973755,
-0.36854279041290283,
0.8969065546989441,
0.024221619591116905,
0.46609824895858765,
-0.32497790455818176,
0.8366076946258545,
-0.3851144313812256,
0.02155441790819168,
-0.05104327201843262,
-0.8596062064170837,
-0.7303516268730164,
0.2993467152118683,
-0.3935558795928955,
-0.19222117960453033,
0.5697384476661682,
0.342593252658844,
-0.10083653777837753,
-0.21675704419612885,
0.5243879556655884,
0.2386818677186966,
0.04754600301384926,
-0.04373571649193764,
0.6533950567245483,
-0.37964165210723877,
0.15786507725715637,
-0.19645456969738007,
-0.09436221420764923,
-0.37250953912734985,
-1.1000356674194336,
-0.8423421382904053,
-0.054493628442287445,
-0.7382804155349731,
-0.10625013709068298,
0.25512170791625977,
0.7092105746269226,
0.5272889137268066,
-0.9594552516937256,
-0.09459728747606277,
0.25242334604263306,
0.13765747845172882,
-0.11643677949905396,
-0.23869895935058594,
0.37523505091667175,
-0.3595127761363983,
-0.5154232978820801,
0.23337480425834656,
0.6783674955368042,
-0.10455824434757233,
-0.16670463979244232,
0.33933064341545105,
-0.018222259357571602,
0.5133330821990967,
0.8952509164810181,
0.3116382360458374,
-0.48973584175109863,
-0.33091670274734497,
-0.04737508296966553,
-0.3216515779495239,
0.10965811461210251,
0.6924818754196167,
-0.6240789890289307,
0.19197599589824677,
0.3562864363193512,
0.7306655645370483,
0.30592218041419983,
0.21326865255832672,
0.3664608299732208,
-1.025178074836731,
-0.1798110455274582,
0.06810778379440308,
0.27361196279525757,
0.37823328375816345,
-0.33527594804763794,
0.5517735481262207,
0.6567740440368652,
-0.4921489655971527,
-0.8113733530044556,
-0.0466381274163723,
-0.9753729701042175,
-0.20399250090122223,
1.1754881143569946,
-0.4971635043621063,
-0.39385613799095154,
-0.19926345348358154,
0.02889653667807579,
0.4072573781013489,
-0.12323762476444244,
0.8820032477378845,
0.5462732911109924,
-0.23427988588809967,
0.15535522997379303,
-0.6916458606719971,
0.30744099617004395,
0.10845484584569931,
-0.9107692837715149,
0.08347102254629135,
0.7440619468688965,
0.5959080457687378,
0.3062364161014557,
0.8482259511947632,
-0.21597592532634735,
0.3476521372795105,
-0.12775291502475739,
0.15818960964679718,
-0.10164637863636017,
-0.25453418493270874,
-0.4291530251502991,
0.22229142487049103,
-0.2599358558654785,
0.0583929717540741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03507v1 | Neural networks for abstraction and reasoning: Towards broad generalization in machines | 2024-02-05T20:48:57 | 2024-02-05T20:48:57 | Mikel Bober-Irizar, Soumya Banerjee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | For half a century, artificial intelligence research has attempted to
reproduce the human qualities of abstraction and reasoning - creating computer
systems that can learn new concepts from a minimal set of examples, in settings
where humans find this easy. While specific neural networks are able to solve
an impressive range of problems, broad generalisation to situations outside
their training data has proved elusive.In this work, we look at several novel
approaches for solving the Abstraction & Reasoning Corpus (ARC), a dataset of
abstract visual reasoning tasks introduced to test algorithms on broad
generalization. Despite three international competitions with $100,000 in
prizes, the best algorithms still fail to solve a majority of ARC tasks and
rely on complex hand-crafted rules, without using machine learning at all. We
revisit whether recent advances in neural networks allow progress on this task.
First, we adapt the DreamCoder neurosymbolic reasoning solver to ARC.
DreamCoder automatically writes programs in a bespoke domain-specific language
to perform reasoning, using a neural network to mimic human intuition. We
present the Perceptual Abstraction and Reasoning Language (PeARL) language,
which allows DreamCoder to solve ARC tasks, and propose a new recognition model
that allows us to significantly improve on the previous best implementation.We
also propose a new encoding and augmentation scheme that allows large language
models (LLMs) to solve ARC tasks, and find that the largest models can solve
some ARC tasks. LLMs are able to solve a different group of problems to
state-of-the-art solvers, and provide an interesting way to complement other
approaches. We perform an ensemble analysis, combining models to achieve better
results than any system alone. Finally, we publish the arckit Python library to
make future research on ARC easier. | [
-0.2763972580432892,
-0.6625387668609619,
0.6172573566436768,
0.1940932720899582,
0.17047399282455444,
0.23259446024894714,
-0.3360818326473236,
-0.6091008186340332,
0.18397705256938934,
0.43479397892951965,
-0.32736578583717346,
-0.4677306115627289,
-0.6197695732116699,
0.08471734076738358,
-0.6238786578178406,
0.3062126040458679,
-0.26614996790885925,
-0.02428743988275528,
-0.29649439454078674,
-0.15177427232265472,
-0.26709434390068054,
-0.6505936980247498,
-0.7830222845077515,
-0.5499086380004883,
0.38368985056877136,
0.23835666477680206,
0.5228528380393982,
0.4017738401889801,
0.6218761205673218,
0.3436741232872009,
-0.14454346895217896,
0.2852870225906372,
0.00632953317835927,
0.05115485191345215,
-0.23206230998039246,
-0.6515464186668396,
-0.2960270643234253,
-0.5880540013313293,
0.23559381067752838,
1.1625511646270752,
0.2102600485086441,
-0.06536994874477386,
-0.11273960024118423,
0.8448869585990906,
-0.8514872789382935,
0.35608184337615967,
-0.4566957950592041,
0.36316007375717163,
0.15923431515693665,
0.258300244808197,
-0.37142911553382874,
-0.2187182605266571,
0.08136463910341263,
-0.6488288640975952,
0.07683787494897842,
-0.00008889060700312257,
0.6748329401016235,
0.2144150286912918,
-0.07592178881168365,
-0.24691727757453918,
-1.0821127891540527,
0.8314223885536194,
-0.3663055896759033,
0.05696070194244385,
0.186722531914711,
0.2760731875896454,
-0.026281973347067833,
-0.9280145168304443,
-0.4186897575855255,
-0.07669481635093689,
0.16361302137374878,
-0.07338321208953857,
-0.7488789558410645,
0.3320840299129486,
0.213308185338974,
0.2336135357618332,
-0.4854968786239624,
0.08375532925128937,
-0.28747573494911194,
-0.26714372634887695,
0.8082556128501892,
0.3387773334980011,
0.5142483115196228,
0.2589006721973419,
0.12533210217952728,
0.12130662053823471,
-0.5045154690742493,
0.12089706212282181,
0.198715940117836,
-0.02214532531797886,
0.15231317281723022,
0.47257718443870544,
-0.47345349192619324,
0.7156760692596436,
-0.16328290104866028,
0.5166406631469727,
0.1579229235649109,
-0.14664293825626373,
-0.20269791781902313,
-0.02388846129179001,
0.7025800943374634,
0.07112937420606613,
0.78936368227005,
-0.37268075346946716,
-0.2996246814727783,
0.5092617869377136,
0.06146137788891792,
-0.30803051590919495,
-0.45014089345932007,
0.38377946615219116,
-0.6395967602729797,
-0.12418163567781448,
-0.30254697799682617,
-0.24703636765480042,
-0.2901008725166321,
-0.8579537272453308,
0.3176892399787903,
-0.48955923318862915,
-0.48828762769699097,
0.45594653487205505,
-0.24503692984580994,
0.17237518727779388,
0.4198816418647766,
-0.91563481092453,
0.407230019569397,
0.72508704662323,
0.6672788262367249,
-0.2750285565853119,
-0.31133776903152466,
0.23076578974723816,
-0.08072035014629364,
-0.7112820148468018,
0.7313935160636902,
-0.6656737923622131,
0.07764710485935211,
-0.20059330761432648,
-0.46542081236839294,
-0.0932503342628479,
-0.6939173340797424,
0.2852114737033844,
-0.3992132544517517,
-0.21425527334213257,
0.05028850585222244,
-0.49370965361595154,
-0.3531554639339447,
0.2906239926815033,
-0.5802369117736816,
0.36338716745376587,
-0.20341995358467102,
-0.5039283037185669,
-0.17447873950004578,
-0.9491033554077148,
-0.5130073428153992,
-0.2459288239479065,
-0.18940263986587524,
-0.06592828035354614,
0.2640526592731476,
0.3832608759403229,
0.40184128284454346,
-0.14482098817825317,
0.28124260902404785,
-0.16941070556640625,
-0.5686509013175964,
0.12617792189121246,
-0.3399771749973297,
0.7607222199440002,
0.3621228039264679,
-0.33698225021362305,
0.2528011202812195,
-0.46084073185920715,
0.20785373449325562,
0.23370704054832458,
0.04649829491972923,
-0.15962472558021545,
-0.04845070838928223,
-0.2744331657886505,
-0.09766203165054321,
0.14278516173362732,
-0.3922673463821411,
0.13167722523212433,
-0.4330815076828003,
0.7983617186546326,
0.6078138947486877,
-0.19714577496051788,
0.5930679440498352,
-0.08886422216892242,
0.2213107794523239,
0.16237105429172516,
0.061375394463539124,
-0.1698191910982132,
-0.6621181964874268,
-1.0228159427642822,
0.16253899037837982,
0.3938952386379242,
0.5125325918197632,
-0.6181811690330505,
0.3967733085155487,
-0.16356751322746277,
-0.10299495607614517,
-0.30708906054496765,
-0.14865346252918243,
0.17882274091243744,
0.2788639962673187,
0.4064662456512451,
-0.19144076108932495,
-0.8310217261314392,
-1.0022238492965698,
-0.29856711626052856,
-0.14684054255485535,
-0.17155231535434723,
0.3454362154006958,
0.5195983052253723,
-0.24139834940433502,
1.081633448600769,
-0.3538447916507721,
-0.04608885571360588,
-0.4374285638332367,
0.15755772590637207,
0.34801778197288513,
0.49536827206611633,
0.044989701360464096,
-0.9446918964385986,
-0.016702238470315933,
0.2510296106338501,
-1.3442184925079346,
0.28980737924575806,
-0.07015331834554672,
0.07543089240789413,
-0.08662068843841553,
0.5190130472183228,
-0.4993954300880432,
0.585758626461029,
0.2988486588001251,
-0.10426919162273407,
0.764519214630127,
-0.11539319157600403,
-0.18191760778427124,
-0.47106534242630005,
0.06772452592849731,
0.027393817901611328,
0.03843529522418976,
-0.6772662401199341,
0.09451824426651001,
-0.1912558227777481,
-0.23533691465854645,
-0.3159770667552948,
0.5015523433685303,
-0.4492128789424896,
-0.13586242496967316,
-0.43431854248046875,
-0.18595637381076813,
-0.049890708178281784,
0.7422026991844177,
0.32978081703186035,
0.3630543351173401,
1.0597095489501953,
-0.7594555616378784,
0.7638662457466125,
0.09083276987075806,
-0.1628560721874237,
0.14296463131904602,
-0.7831826210021973,
0.19040238857269287,
-0.46822863817214966,
0.2452826201915741,
-0.7805435061454773,
-0.1447317749261856,
0.30316418409347534,
-0.4421238899230957,
0.008186682127416134,
-0.09717841446399689,
-0.016910512000322342,
-0.5682869553565979,
0.18240006268024445,
0.6492180824279785,
0.5649339556694031,
-0.3813228905200958,
1.0128021240234375,
0.10804980993270874,
-0.021068954840302467,
-0.8126285076141357,
-0.9391775131225586,
0.5268422365188599,
0.09746196866035461,
-0.7231000065803528,
0.24836260080337524,
0.09658819437026978,
-0.6611887216567993,
0.1480918526649475,
-0.17760500311851501,
-0.4027106463909149,
0.0937284305691719,
0.07356711477041245,
0.04755297675728798,
-0.5016986727714539,
0.08691521733999252,
0.19365781545639038,
-0.18374009430408478,
0.2541542649269104,
-0.700663685798645,
0.5077772736549377,
-0.6309312582015991,
-0.5716871023178101,
-0.5620347857475281,
0.3717736601829529,
0.23476295173168182,
-0.3526057004928589,
0.32023680210113525,
0.24024024605751038,
-0.5037092566490173,
-0.331758588552475,
-0.43931588530540466,
-0.25960156321525574,
-0.4011741578578949,
0.45918095111846924,
-0.6642332673072815,
-0.530288815498352,
0.43879806995391846,
-0.46898168325424194,
-0.07524491101503372,
0.3761483132839203,
0.49287933111190796,
-0.26717522740364075,
0.9674658179283142,
0.5135163068771362,
-0.0708598867058754,
0.2194390594959259,
-0.869030773639679,
0.10163741558790207,
-0.732438862323761,
-0.3396146297454834,
-0.18768461048603058,
-0.9962827563285828,
0.14463253319263458,
-0.2153182476758957,
0.010833349078893661,
0.33938169479370117,
-0.33838531374931335,
0.24345137178897858,
-0.8074094653129578,
0.9035394191741943,
0.5854429602622986,
0.2065306305885315,
0.4760337173938751,
-0.039183344691991806,
-0.2793167531490326,
0.49897465109825134,
-0.6942963004112244,
-0.3829647898674011,
1.3021223545074463,
0.10289620608091354,
0.6529213786125183,
-0.30724841356277466,
0.622586727142334,
0.31383052468299866,
0.13559959828853607,
-0.6461002826690674,
0.6864655017852783,
-0.16372150182724,
-0.4149804711341858,
-0.27005207538604736,
-0.36154845356941223,
-1.1322753429412842,
0.25824928283691406,
0.025391260161995888,
-0.8823570013046265,
0.4245666563510895,
0.028570333495736122,
-0.22214722633361816,
0.6644193530082703,
-0.8780867457389832,
0.6438244581222534,
-0.24333789944648743,
-0.11950088292360306,
-0.2545411288738251,
-0.7326831221580505,
0.45719003677368164,
0.33540230989456177,
0.03876165300607681,
-0.17333491146564484,
-0.05869774520397186,
0.41367825865745544,
-0.16122221946716309,
0.923707902431488,
-0.10803645104169846,
0.34731292724609375,
0.505150556564331,
0.05667145550251007,
0.20565453171730042,
-0.22088639438152313,
-0.15749071538448334,
0.39550235867500305,
-0.45001664757728577,
-0.4913504421710968,
-0.6671533584594727,
0.4991660714149475,
-0.7487308382987976,
-0.5385029911994934,
-0.19384843111038208,
-0.7129772901535034,
-0.1756054311990738,
0.13862495124340057,
0.2884458303451538,
0.40942102670669556,
-0.12302732467651367,
-0.11788901686668396,
0.8989623188972473,
0.14452411234378815,
0.6950482726097107,
-0.2497597336769104,
-0.24600142240524292,
-0.04375810548663139,
0.9918813705444336,
-0.2602642774581909,
0.027802832424640656,
0.3127728998661041,
0.13561886548995972,
-0.1668016016483307,
-0.854829728603363,
-0.5185332298278809,
0.04221322014927864,
-0.7804458737373352,
-0.05397701635956764,
-0.5564633011817932,
-0.5761541724205017,
-0.004223502241075039,
-0.13965186476707458,
-0.23675793409347534,
-0.8253167271614075,
-0.21096038818359375,
0.10126019269227982,
0.007279707118868828,
0.8160001635551453,
-0.07182157784700394,
-0.12617966532707214,
-0.31301257014274597,
0.448462575674057,
0.3258819580078125,
0.18457014858722687,
0.3636264503002167,
-0.08113548159599304,
-0.014891164377331734,
0.18011486530303955,
-0.24042250216007233,
-0.3321860134601593,
0.059739675372838974,
0.026813331991434097,
0.6012210845947266,
0.33695918321609497,
-0.2191902995109558,
0.32253608107566833,
-0.41816088557243347,
0.6757272481918335,
0.3765198290348053,
-0.8851388692855835,
0.5969041585922241,
0.019624246284365654,
0.14782975614070892,
0.2138521522283554,
0.4276946485042572,
-0.49905288219451904,
-0.2587289810180664,
-0.546319305896759,
-0.6561304330825806,
0.36734095215797424,
0.43115442991256714,
0.1794380396604538,
0.30346328020095825,
0.5117226839065552,
-0.10172330588102341,
-0.008618789725005627,
-0.43922752141952515,
-0.3349159061908722,
-0.3118569254875183,
-0.45693227648735046,
0.21855518221855164,
0.44499364495277405,
-0.05976305529475212,
-0.4459347724914551,
0.26606130599975586,
-0.25527122616767883,
0.42533180117607117,
0.2639125883579254,
-0.17589887976646423,
0.24783022701740265,
0.23320382833480835,
0.3375367820262909,
0.7193632125854492,
0.31164270639419556,
0.07112681865692139,
0.18167081475257874,
-0.24040712416172028,
0.3020312190055847,
-0.12578965723514557,
-0.23959678411483765,
-0.03496227040886879,
0.4618092179298401,
0.8089325428009033,
-0.2291262000799179,
-0.8146094679832458,
0.4044325351715088,
-0.11276400089263916,
-0.5270178914070129,
-0.3983858525753021,
0.34771472215652466,
0.2712863087654114,
0.31799212098121643,
0.3643737733364105,
0.8177899718284607,
0.2718380391597748,
-0.35571539402008057,
-0.08375753462314606,
0.4815572500228882,
-0.30176258087158203,
-0.2677749991416931,
0.6955235004425049,
0.19949716329574585,
-0.4337629973888397,
0.8148460984230042,
0.023051684722304344,
-0.35714492201805115,
1.0822259187698364,
0.408810019493103,
0.9246672987937927,
0.15575526654720306,
-0.007245086599141359,
0.16434352099895477,
0.1802077740430832,
-0.2619284987449646,
0.3218192756175995,
-0.057645440101623535,
-1.0993939638137817,
-0.6360679268836975,
-0.43934643268585205,
-0.5867738127708435,
-0.03990897908806801,
-0.1499883234500885,
-0.07229531556367874,
-0.6928941607475281,
-0.02272149920463562,
0.06624551117420197,
-0.486346036195755,
-0.6283257007598877,
0.2376977503299713,
0.630237340927124,
0.9126730561256409,
-0.6080911159515381,
0.6197814345359802,
0.7311050295829773,
-0.5168656706809998,
-0.8403734564781189,
-0.34667113423347473,
-0.28817862272262573,
-0.8160272240638733,
0.7390291690826416,
0.1180458664894104,
-0.048439912497997284,
-0.052612025290727615,
-0.7729412317276001,
-0.7297720909118652,
0.8175468444824219,
0.6174631714820862,
-0.5820929408073425,
-0.5071468353271484,
0.1884623020887375,
0.5061907172203064,
-0.4588809907436371,
0.39398249983787537,
0.7817710638046265,
0.4858621656894684,
0.21879462897777557,
-0.7728155851364136,
-0.32648080587387085,
-0.47458019852638245,
0.09005770087242126,
0.02972337231040001,
-0.36930960416793823,
0.8597530722618103,
-0.4577632546424866,
0.12265145033597946,
0.4231293201446533,
0.8199974298477173,
0.14771214127540588,
0.4369928240776062,
0.26487210392951965,
0.7453108429908752,
0.8550816774368286,
-0.3892759382724762,
1.1602494716644287,
0.046817321330308914,
0.03215000778436661,
0.7279012799263,
-0.08383399248123169,
0.6204426288604736,
0.30208101868629456,
-0.2335263043642044,
0.9202242493629456,
0.3184686005115509,
0.05908665060997009,
0.07796546816825867,
0.6486610174179077,
-0.3943600654602051,
-0.4676361083984375,
0.12280263006687164,
-0.21426089107990265,
0.40655407309532166,
0.5566439032554626,
-0.3699319064617157,
-0.06801173090934753,
0.4774801433086395,
-0.48447152972221375,
0.12194503843784332,
-0.9219143390655518,
0.750389814376831,
0.3490869104862213,
-0.48109403252601624,
0.6066629886627197,
-0.19309382140636444,
0.7489737272262573,
-0.5553608536720276,
-0.03239811584353447,
-0.23421306908130646,
0.5103606581687927,
-0.554292619228363,
-0.7787377834320068,
0.5049898028373718,
-0.21023163199424744,
-0.14357778429985046,
-0.06854557245969772,
0.9356333613395691,
-0.07892822474241257,
-0.6278376579284668,
0.0421023815870285,
0.6227355003356934,
0.31558334827423096,
-0.3044872581958771,
-0.6670327186584473,
0.025529326871037483,
-0.15784041583538055,
0.000600869650952518,
0.12464821338653564,
0.38395124673843384,
-0.21964256465435028,
1.068724274635315,
0.5647290945053101,
0.22584745287895203,
0.07178696990013123,
0.12806017696857452,
0.9008532762527466,
-0.738618016242981,
-0.316333144903183,
-0.7576701045036316,
0.3435565233230591,
-0.09678487479686737,
-0.18958429992198944,
0.2836012542247772,
0.48556607961654663,
0.7140771150588989,
-0.07795581966638565,
0.9857264161109924,
0.04931727796792984,
0.07963883876800537,
-0.44774019718170166,
0.5581446290016174,
-0.3451424241065979,
0.20443791151046753,
-0.1910782903432846,
-0.7976255416870117,
-0.8467110395431519,
0.663998544216156,
-0.4576202929019928,
-0.05806313827633858,
0.6570560336112976,
0.548565685749054,
-0.3007948696613312,
0.5151808857917786,
0.2250543236732483,
0.052673712372779846,
0.10452732443809509,
1.0910799503326416,
1.2194933891296387,
-0.2615779936313629,
0.7745690941810608,
-0.18345311284065247,
-0.08404280245304108,
0.0889052301645279,
-0.5569652915000916,
-0.6922463774681091,
-0.35843318700790405,
-0.2788686156272888,
-0.14099843800067902,
0.35363927483558655,
0.7144138216972351,
0.843823254108429,
-0.9663953185081482,
-0.4014660716056824,
-0.692017674446106,
0.40862685441970825,
-0.6452834010124207,
-0.17776426672935486,
0.3894451856613159,
-0.575311005115509,
-0.6577372550964355,
0.46496036648750305,
0.32487303018569946,
-0.20813727378845215,
-0.14654317498207092,
-0.1945992261171341,
0.11601883918046951,
-0.1030530333518982,
0.4861947000026703,
0.5972582101821899,
-0.8379998207092285,
-0.057510435581207275,
0.09106187522411346,
0.11272955685853958,
0.30274736881256104,
0.9191678166389465,
-1.0900933742523193,
0.28254395723342896,
0.4116671681404114,
0.9410446286201477,
0.6279541850090027,
-0.2278364598751068,
0.48689979314804077,
-0.4543580710887909,
0.12737569212913513,
0.8504579663276672,
0.6249431371688843,
0.1050320714712143,
-0.13831692934036255,
0.5025733709335327,
0.29311293363571167,
-0.26290011405944824,
-0.3304949998855591,
0.39089542627334595,
-0.6847368478775024,
-0.6187489628791809,
0.880433976650238,
-0.011214504018425941,
-0.4540722966194153,
-0.43243208527565,
-0.1694108545780182,
-0.13546870648860931,
-0.24388961493968964,
0.535618782043457,
0.5596538782119751,
-0.8892236351966858,
-0.3039715886116028,
0.052893344312906265,
0.15284158289432526,
0.5802132487297058,
-0.8286662101745605,
-0.12220045924186707,
0.25551918148994446,
0.16051016747951508,
0.4795348644256592,
0.48702195286750793,
0.02140820026397705,
0.5345567464828491,
0.06859799474477768,
0.14792415499687195,
-0.4142879843711853,
-0.5708510279655457,
-0.4705466330051422,
0.43128159642219543,
-0.051943376660346985,
-0.22582045197486877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03501v1 | An Inpainting-Infused Pipeline for Attire and Background Replacement | 2024-02-05T20:34:32 | 2024-02-05T20:34:32 | Felipe Rodrigues Perche-Mahlow, André Felipe-Zanella, William Alberto Cruz-Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in Generative Artificial
Intelligence (GenAI) have triggered a transformative paradigm shift,
significantly influencing various domains. In this work, we specifically
explore an integrated approach, leveraging advanced techniques in GenAI and
computer vision emphasizing image manipulation. The methodology unfolds through
several stages, including depth estimation, the creation of inpaint masks based
on depth information, the generation and replacement of backgrounds utilizing
Stable Diffusion in conjunction with Latent Consistency Models (LCMs), and the
subsequent replacement of clothes and application of aesthetic changes through
an inpainting pipeline. Experiments conducted in this study underscore the
methodology's efficacy, highlighting its potential to produce visually
captivating content. The convergence of these advanced techniques allows users
to input photographs of individuals and manipulate them to modify clothing and
background based on specific prompts without manually input inpainting masks,
effectively placing the subjects within the vast landscape of creative
imagination. | [
-0.32881900668144226,
-0.48572230339050293,
0.5850116014480591,
0.059157293289899826,
-0.40146464109420776,
0.7344338297843933,
0.0011728712124750018,
-0.6979852318763733,
0.28524187207221985,
0.6378232836723328,
-0.8903403878211975,
-0.3459201455116272,
-0.494706392288208,
-0.16881881654262543,
-0.46827611327171326,
0.5917201638221741,
-0.13229522109031677,
-0.3049886226654053,
-0.2535141110420227,
-0.15237030386924744,
-0.7719952464103699,
-0.1887780874967575,
-0.370579332113266,
-0.4369139075279236,
0.18699423968791962,
0.5201454758644104,
0.7651748657226562,
0.23185783624649048,
0.44212108850479126,
0.29934388399124146,
0.11455287784337997,
0.4993686079978943,
-0.40703293681144714,
0.34483033418655396,
-0.3200163245201111,
-0.38497722148895264,
0.036524079740047455,
0.22836890816688538,
0.2906718850135803,
0.44553685188293457,
0.05866442248225212,
0.07638894021511078,
0.4464802145957947,
0.9035089612007141,
-0.9899075627326965,
-0.2577846944332123,
-0.39639464020729065,
0.28105831146240234,
-0.4912012815475464,
-0.5463405251502991,
0.0725923404097557,
0.24140089750289917,
-0.24287772178649902,
-0.7817902565002441,
0.3532986044883728,
-0.31359025835990906,
0.5810962319374084,
0.5663373470306396,
0.07040926814079285,
-0.11362433433532715,
-1.0682121515274048,
0.4335736036300659,
-0.4817235767841339,
0.44118455052375793,
0.3402308225631714,
0.3895566761493683,
0.1534891277551651,
-0.9700934886932373,
-0.5376472473144531,
0.2578568458557129,
-0.28662896156311035,
0.45585864782333374,
0.17200793325901031,
-0.12283115088939667,
0.3486645221710205,
0.6339160203933716,
-0.48387399315834045,
0.0009334423230029643,
-0.24421003460884094,
0.170149564743042,
0.6231321096420288,
0.20288245379924774,
0.856222927570343,
0.054153554141521454,
-0.4273471236228943,
-0.10896942019462585,
-0.4915141761302948,
-0.11412730813026428,
0.38126087188720703,
-0.21557001769542694,
-0.039818789809942245,
0.5560188293457031,
-0.45295462012290955,
0.8000539541244507,
0.1726730465888977,
-0.26102522015571594,
-0.015464488416910172,
-0.2960584759712219,
-0.6189133524894714,
-0.10492239892482758,
0.36383575201034546,
0.6730203628540039,
-0.18714219331741333,
-0.4578178822994232,
-0.10651306062936783,
0.11070606857538223,
0.35607844591140747,
-0.6234816908836365,
-0.3060697615146637,
0.34941914677619934,
-0.4001478850841522,
-0.3320337235927582,
0.4193461537361145,
-0.8737075328826904,
-0.6116489768028259,
-0.7771045565605164,
0.35257479548454285,
-0.33340778946876526,
-0.06882105767726898,
-0.17444473505020142,
-0.6727200746536255,
0.590817928314209,
0.6761412620544434,
-0.7761034369468689,
-0.22195614874362946,
0.5991710424423218,
1.0016893148422241,
-0.10339248925447464,
0.10633544623851776,
-0.1443321704864502,
0.47781386971473694,
-0.7056976556777954,
0.5031259655952454,
-0.6666485667228699,
-0.3426336646080017,
-0.09168815612792969,
0.0011159373680129647,
0.3611922264099121,
-0.606533408164978,
0.14902529120445251,
-0.6776788830757141,
0.15570379793643951,
0.07139571011066437,
-0.2528194189071655,
-0.09557026624679565,
0.09607835114002228,
-0.7082561254501343,
0.6468816995620728,
0.27936309576034546,
-0.4553590714931488,
0.3914077877998352,
-0.791007936000824,
-0.34180331230163574,
0.5961017608642578,
0.000047235811507562175,
-0.5708301067352295,
-0.0801469013094902,
0.35914453864097595,
0.11132892966270447,
0.2026687115430832,
-0.04046877101063728,
-0.08951493352651596,
-0.8806220293045044,
0.17842726409435272,
-0.029476314783096313,
0.9048149585723877,
0.23247091472148895,
-0.3447408676147461,
0.12640932202339172,
-0.6217984557151794,
-0.3611343204975128,
-0.16768640279769897,
0.06098470464348793,
-0.2105199545621872,
-0.3350728154182434,
0.26903507113456726,
0.11616095155477524,
0.43151265382766724,
-0.6137081980705261,
0.11032616347074509,
-0.2556688189506531,
0.45101794600486755,
0.8318967819213867,
0.18852946162223816,
1.0632416009902954,
-0.5791228413581848,
0.5697017908096313,
-0.40417221188545227,
0.32462865114212036,
-0.43245717883110046,
-0.700808048248291,
-0.7079867720603943,
-0.4901060461997986,
-0.19470703601837158,
0.6503168344497681,
-1.1619513034820557,
0.09564492106437683,
0.21065619587898254,
-0.5991142392158508,
-0.1870567947626114,
0.06646658480167389,
0.0819249227643013,
0.4707486033439636,
0.3541052043437958,
-0.4801444709300995,
-0.7181708216667175,
-0.4845049977302551,
-0.2981690466403961,
0.22291097044944763,
-0.5936093926429749,
-0.018990781158208847,
0.14588001370429993,
-0.5224563479423523,
0.9056158661842346,
-0.2108580619096756,
-0.4527705907821655,
0.22999703884124756,
0.13189782202243805,
0.40768247842788696,
1.0703365802764893,
0.44948485493659973,
-0.8549457788467407,
-0.6127225756645203,
0.11484581977128983,
-1.0308698415756226,
0.04617847502231598,
-0.43548548221588135,
-0.36115384101867676,
-0.04285123199224472,
0.7311114072799683,
-0.22566582262516022,
0.9028056859970093,
0.30561935901641846,
-0.010816212743520737,
0.47535595297813416,
-0.1319943517446518,
0.5888599753379822,
-0.7686092257499695,
-0.03847586363554001,
0.09865162521600723,
-0.24636957049369812,
-0.8867928385734558,
0.7584601640701294,
-0.1038319319486618,
-0.6781399250030518,
-0.3919491171836853,
0.5698263049125671,
-0.6305191516876221,
0.03397670015692711,
-0.3781248927116394,
-0.5421486496925354,
0.31598880887031555,
0.6037533283233643,
-0.27921879291534424,
0.754628598690033,
0.562152624130249,
-0.5477399230003357,
0.7155890464782715,
0.405971884727478,
-0.6249922513961792,
0.8341421484947205,
-0.557934582233429,
0.9370336532592773,
-0.35011518001556396,
0.28857511281967163,
-1.1590603590011597,
-0.6869731545448303,
0.9987044930458069,
-0.08124958723783493,
0.4229818880558014,
-0.5883945226669312,
-0.6807745695114136,
-0.035310301929712296,
-0.3148391842842102,
0.7617911100387573,
0.8073495626449585,
-0.8177318572998047,
1.042220950126648,
0.23618920147418976,
-0.15851469337940216,
-0.2240026593208313,
-0.9497659802436829,
0.6050395965576172,
-0.7799710035324097,
-0.633537232875824,
1.0484416484832764,
-0.152875155210495,
-0.34034717082977295,
-0.2920873463153839,
0.14766846597194672,
-0.12454453110694885,
-0.03045991249382496,
0.07043186575174332,
0.6450368165969849,
0.2310715615749359,
-0.2277166098356247,
0.09137637168169022,
0.23905296623706818,
-0.28711608052253723,
-0.30579203367233276,
0.42732104659080505,
0.42464253306388855,
-0.5041549801826477,
-0.6461665034294128,
0.5663796663284302,
0.6513180136680603,
-0.22445321083068848,
0.3442881405353546,
0.5191747546195984,
-0.47816789150238037,
0.19476564228534698,
-0.5594228506088257,
-0.02245926856994629,
-0.49304917454719543,
0.00304132211022079,
-0.17275571823120117,
-0.4421321153640747,
0.6400676369667053,
-0.12793715298175812,
0.15292680263519287,
0.27525538206100464,
0.31425032019615173,
-0.607616126537323,
0.8328662514686584,
0.5587816834449768,
0.3498774766921997,
1.0124123096466064,
-0.6458914875984192,
-0.02296432852745056,
-1.189370036125183,
-0.38188689947128296,
-0.008186315186321735,
-0.9399267435073853,
-0.576558530330658,
-0.7535443902015686,
1.0054973363876343,
-0.02471659518778324,
-0.29033342003822327,
0.24566428363323212,
-0.6071590185165405,
0.7421836256980896,
0.6658931374549866,
1.1111901998519897,
0.31623733043670654,
0.14031225442886353,
0.7184197902679443,
-0.011916762217879295,
-0.2854878008365631,
-0.19968238472938538,
1.0596789121627808,
-0.03383259102702141,
0.8158777952194214,
0.09229335188865662,
0.4731665551662445,
0.3417529761791229,
0.4147421419620514,
-0.6131258010864258,
0.32501140236854553,
-0.45015060901641846,
-0.04701180011034012,
-0.4861659109592438,
0.19642052054405212,
-0.5351306796073914,
-0.013429171405732632,
-0.3336295485496521,
-0.5193973779678345,
0.7740767598152161,
0.2193935364484787,
-0.16226837038993835,
0.5453252196311951,
-0.3780270516872406,
0.15486550331115723,
0.019205331802368164,
-0.6862918138504028,
-0.3933543562889099,
-0.7359651923179626,
0.43248993158340454,
-0.030878106132149696,
-0.07633895426988602,
0.16491667926311493,
-0.09378503262996674,
0.5205597281455994,
-0.41683313250541687,
0.799842894077301,
-0.00341564929112792,
-0.07513777166604996,
0.05727900192141533,
-0.11142441630363464,
0.4191742241382599,
-0.12673085927963257,
-0.07160168141126633,
0.42225465178489685,
-0.6546172499656677,
-0.4756510555744171,
-0.8883782029151917,
0.4209217429161072,
-0.37155818939208984,
-0.5627517700195312,
-0.0770077109336853,
-0.7184547781944275,
-0.2746463418006897,
-0.14292454719543457,
0.4310421645641327,
0.6563835740089417,
-0.24306343495845795,
0.09195923060178757,
0.5437195301055908,
-0.3130766749382019,
0.5486661195755005,
-0.30443882942199707,
0.017115725204348564,
-0.34954285621643066,
0.7733937501907349,
0.1612878292798996,
0.1589273363351822,
0.3234487771987915,
0.1419001966714859,
-0.13772636651992798,
-0.11607580631971359,
-1.0881305932998657,
-0.21175511181354523,
-0.8237997889518738,
-0.09019256383180618,
-0.30941519141197205,
-0.27571234107017517,
-0.24619553983211517,
-0.6265937089920044,
0.24318547546863556,
-0.18766283988952637,
-0.5973408222198486,
0.4285733103752136,
0.17435674369335175,
0.6791176199913025,
0.09329619258642197,
0.14548879861831665,
-0.3045971393585205,
0.3414497375488281,
1.1239439249038696,
0.1957632452249527,
-0.16231173276901245,
-0.5455873608589172,
-0.40565916895866394,
0.10801276564598083,
-0.310249388217926,
-0.7888107895851135,
0.3708515465259552,
0.2944290339946747,
0.4412742257118225,
0.17580921947956085,
-0.34348514676094055,
0.8570337891578674,
-0.18905127048492432,
0.7294481992721558,
0.19091521203517914,
-0.7003195881843567,
0.6332570910453796,
-0.42925211787223816,
0.422412246465683,
0.18752393126487732,
-0.033044859766960144,
-0.5747518539428711,
-0.4485808312892914,
-0.742631733417511,
-0.7208743095397949,
0.18122385442256927,
0.07552443444728851,
0.26783278584480286,
0.5450682044029236,
0.32577070593833923,
0.04580434039235115,
0.38641539216041565,
0.14376631379127502,
0.09896697849035263,
-0.6125296950340271,
0.08563225716352463,
0.04637378826737404,
0.17481684684753418,
-0.28352388739585876,
-0.29779937863349915,
0.5565167665481567,
-0.22669671475887299,
0.17781077325344086,
0.06892242282629013,
-0.09656640142202377,
-0.08202790468931198,
-0.01751553826034069,
0.38060322403907776,
0.9927829504013062,
0.00690821697935462,
-0.32654982805252075,
-0.0091397138312459,
-0.12412981688976288,
0.09359253197908401,
0.01315992046147585,
-0.3415362536907196,
-0.03551923856139183,
0.22355546057224274,
0.8068683743476868,
-0.05480007827281952,
-0.4700739085674286,
0.27565979957580566,
0.3589631915092468,
0.19480545818805695,
-0.374541312456131,
0.06766402721405029,
-0.35172611474990845,
0.22503706812858582,
0.6269775629043579,
0.6901944279670715,
0.5497222542762756,
-1.130063533782959,
0.12562032043933868,
0.5302072167396545,
-0.24025075137615204,
-0.10728064924478531,
0.7746766209602356,
0.07458140701055527,
-0.47093120217323303,
0.6489120125770569,
0.2611144781112671,
-0.2518230676651001,
0.7041087746620178,
0.1872950792312622,
0.9943610429763794,
-0.19843198359012604,
0.3222276568412781,
0.3020555377006531,
-0.16803748905658722,
0.11448778957128525,
-0.16569086909294128,
-0.12980704009532928,
-0.8712520599365234,
-0.44730037450790405,
-0.3085234761238098,
-0.6585479974746704,
0.09196785092353821,
-0.26000577211380005,
0.2981621325016022,
-0.6225482225418091,
0.4202558398246765,
-0.31085100769996643,
-0.6809879541397095,
-0.6865682601928711,
0.4197165369987488,
0.27535152435302734,
0.43266069889068604,
-0.8955036401748657,
0.2806270718574524,
0.801264226436615,
-0.5987767577171326,
-0.4006350338459015,
0.44993770122528076,
-0.11470240354537964,
-0.7707512378692627,
0.4516509473323822,
0.08200110495090485,
-0.12352517247200012,
-0.0640583485364914,
-1.0425137281417847,
-0.5502305030822754,
1.0219072103500366,
0.37742528319358826,
-0.4274817109107971,
-0.12940965592861176,
-0.16231466829776764,
0.4132647216320038,
-0.3696828782558441,
-0.037619590759277344,
0.702214241027832,
0.4557899832725525,
0.5680472254753113,
-0.3833046555519104,
-0.3781883716583252,
-0.4805167019367218,
0.3987353444099426,
0.019038384780287743,
-0.5274872779846191,
0.8078988194465637,
0.09959637373685837,
-0.5380432605743408,
0.48740047216415405,
0.5181363821029663,
0.3675047755241394,
0.5141115784645081,
0.8425129055976868,
0.8340402841567993,
0.5352038145065308,
-0.15351714193820953,
0.8420444130897522,
-0.10394883155822754,
0.06912070512771606,
0.8293805718421936,
0.2655077576637268,
0.28008654713630676,
0.2906070053577423,
-0.0673922523856163,
1.0551598072052002,
0.5066046714782715,
0.03762781247496605,
0.7663666605949402,
0.051670461893081665,
-0.6963401436805725,
0.00023860608052928,
-0.17587950825691223,
-0.17888185381889343,
0.6807205080986023,
0.22527533769607544,
-0.1811889111995697,
0.10196687281131744,
0.3770855665206909,
-0.11781033128499985,
0.18704359233379364,
-0.515924334526062,
1.0274536609649658,
-0.4446299374103546,
-0.5458155274391174,
0.4272710978984833,
-0.209106907248497,
0.7760040163993835,
-0.40778639912605286,
-0.7777363061904907,
-0.3635927140712738,
-0.30495837330818176,
-0.3607993721961975,
-1.0799787044525146,
0.5036330819129944,
-0.13030418753623962,
0.07871589809656143,
-0.665329098701477,
1.0759913921356201,
-0.3958587050437927,
-0.5461281538009644,
-0.27821025252342224,
0.17887349426746368,
0.06637625396251678,
-0.4350952208042145,
-0.34355947375297546,
0.04512685909867287,
-0.24641937017440796,
0.3925658166408539,
0.20034345984458923,
0.20058275759220123,
-0.02086980640888214,
0.3062528669834137,
0.8917291760444641,
-0.18116751313209534,
-0.3841685950756073,
0.22173482179641724,
0.9372892379760742,
-0.18713630735874176,
-0.8229025602340698,
-0.6628100275993347,
0.7977312803268433,
-0.274254709482193,
0.013595479540526867,
0.3204873204231262,
0.37365448474884033,
0.8544890284538269,
-0.42037203907966614,
0.849105715751648,
-0.0858992412686348,
-0.02442225255072117,
-0.7320737838745117,
0.6569584012031555,
-0.593669056892395,
0.12540900707244873,
-0.7383283376693726,
-0.9174714088439941,
-0.23438504338264465,
0.5451174378395081,
0.20648233592510223,
-0.05593724921345711,
0.07874274998903275,
0.905314028263092,
-0.2909351885318756,
-0.22921675443649292,
0.43862786889076233,
-0.36744970083236694,
0.26086848974227905,
0.1442430019378662,
0.9571458101272583,
-0.3309173583984375,
-0.060053106397390366,
-0.6255157589912415,
-0.7074979543685913,
-0.06263682246208191,
-0.8431127667427063,
-0.26505428552627563,
-0.6762420535087585,
-0.3499297499656677,
-0.18817326426506042,
0.15715530514717102,
0.3575505018234253,
0.9831862449645996,
-0.5474438071250916,
-0.14518693089485168,
-0.19365228712558746,
-0.1684761792421341,
-0.5897938013076782,
-0.28458645939826965,
-0.045042283833026886,
-0.17462579905986786,
-1.050873875617981,
0.82692950963974,
0.8916616439819336,
0.00774384057149291,
-0.7664684653282166,
0.20868238806724548,
0.021246669813990593,
-0.17899161577224731,
0.7184051275253296,
0.2922469675540924,
-0.6982840299606323,
-0.30415409803390503,
-0.3614768385887146,
0.2500620484352112,
0.30577734112739563,
0.9467301368713379,
-1.0863933563232422,
0.8051868677139282,
0.7816838622093201,
0.7469469308853149,
0.6038734912872314,
0.3480902314186096,
0.6366618871688843,
-1.0094459056854248,
0.29123446345329285,
0.07003983110189438,
0.35434916615486145,
0.8028204441070557,
-0.7420072555541992,
0.809628963470459,
0.4944739043712616,
-0.40763700008392334,
-0.34094157814979553,
0.43785688281059265,
-0.8655074834823608,
-0.1813238561153412,
0.5467087626457214,
0.08403103053569794,
0.11274195462465286,
-0.25776898860931396,
-0.3461703360080719,
0.22900259494781494,
0.12777963280677795,
0.8114258050918579,
0.4120519757270813,
-0.2428283840417862,
-0.4917183220386505,
-0.04548335447907448,
0.230073943734169,
-0.013749312609434128,
-0.8654694557189941,
-0.4720522463321686,
0.39450588822364807,
0.19899660348892212,
0.3420845568180084,
0.5344362258911133,
-0.10510644316673279,
0.4016813337802887,
-0.44176626205444336,
-0.04743683338165283,
0.05174233764410019,
-0.3807041347026825,
-0.08259128779172897,
0.06992582231760025,
-0.5647943615913391,
-0.4872814416885376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03485v2 | Attention Meets Post-hoc Interpretability: A Mathematical Perspective | 2024-02-05T19:56:56 | 2024-06-17T13:18:30 | Gianluigi Lopardo, Frederic Precioso, Damien Garreau | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG | Attention-based architectures, in particular transformers, are at the heart
of a technological revolution. Interestingly, in addition to helping obtain
state-of-the-art results on a wide range of applications, the attention
mechanism intrinsically provides meaningful insights on the internal behavior
of the model. Can these insights be used as explanations? Debate rages on. In
this paper, we mathematically study a simple attention-based architecture and
pinpoint the differences between post-hoc and attention-based explanations. We
show that they provide quite different results, and that, despite their
limitations, post-hoc methods are capable of capturing more useful insights
than merely examining the attention weights. | [
-0.6142030954360962,
-0.7789575457572937,
0.8421661853790283,
0.3237011134624481,
-0.1151125505566597,
-0.39629870653152466,
0.0653853565454483,
-0.5511692762374878,
-0.0973300114274025,
0.1894368678331375,
-0.7926572561264038,
0.14916419982910156,
-0.6100484132766724,
0.006307210773229599,
-0.575164258480072,
0.9541929960250854,
-0.1947237253189087,
-0.18325841426849365,
-0.5837664604187012,
-0.12753045558929443,
-0.4572286307811737,
-0.182032972574234,
-0.41090139746665955,
-0.5098928213119507,
0.6697583198547363,
0.1768151819705963,
0.8582723736763,
0.8135830760002136,
0.8444417715072632,
0.3167338967323303,
-0.053183771669864655,
-0.06600144505500793,
-0.41044872999191284,
-0.2947268486022949,
-0.2927117347717285,
-0.5275640487670898,
-0.3438647985458374,
0.02250799536705017,
0.26265662908554077,
1.0001881122589111,
0.12230473756790161,
0.5390673279762268,
0.2796383798122406,
0.7825075387954712,
-0.5215533375740051,
0.3183068633079529,
-0.31802815198898315,
0.12458568066358566,
-0.10493245720863342,
-0.5681876540184021,
-0.4684070348739624,
-0.23293353617191315,
0.483111709356308,
-0.7397724986076355,
0.35827866196632385,
0.036431536078453064,
0.7015344500541687,
0.7011725902557373,
-0.23225091397762299,
-0.2396879941225052,
-1.1262273788452148,
1.0257481336593628,
-0.12272129952907562,
0.6588127613067627,
0.2125219851732254,
0.654035747051239,
0.39068421721458435,
-0.8554197549819946,
-0.14520318806171417,
0.21599406003952026,
-0.29338183999061584,
0.23610153794288635,
-0.2479618489742279,
-0.16380789875984192,
0.6150897145271301,
0.5452889800071716,
-0.5290555357933044,
-0.3595612049102783,
-0.4320864677429199,
-0.19323095679283142,
0.31848713755607605,
0.07983780652284622,
0.0020633265376091003,
-0.002624250715598464,
-0.5108619928359985,
0.20784801244735718,
-0.6960760354995728,
0.34291771054267883,
0.007062634918838739,
-0.2094925045967102,
-0.3284594416618347,
0.5171716213226318,
-0.16184525191783905,
0.6216109991073608,
0.2999231815338135,
0.6031838059425354,
-0.2657433748245239,
0.022328538820147514,
-0.359906941652298,
0.15155565738677979,
0.32009196281433105,
0.18050065636634827,
0.3748840391635895,
-0.2706697881221771,
0.004400753416121006,
0.4598775804042816,
0.8542486429214478,
-0.5275375843048096,
-0.35213881731033325,
0.2681331932544708,
-0.8341981768608093,
-0.246469646692276,
0.07360105216503143,
-0.9869036078453064,
-0.0539572648704052,
-0.5775635242462158,
0.48149392008781433,
-0.026739606633782387,
-0.25486472249031067,
0.2831352949142456,
-0.10555607825517654,
0.6591023802757263,
0.4075055420398712,
-1.013089895248413,
0.21164493262767792,
1.014621376991272,
0.899667501449585,
0.17009423673152924,
-0.03629111126065254,
-0.6562798023223877,
-0.12748979032039642,
-0.29377561807632446,
1.206923484802246,
-0.4523649513721466,
-0.31578436493873596,
-0.013028752990067005,
-0.2523132264614105,
0.07235568761825562,
-0.4832949638366699,
0.5646803975105286,
-0.938786506652832,
0.33160412311553955,
-0.43812355399131775,
-0.1626688688993454,
-0.31505897641181946,
-0.04008495807647705,
-0.5946492552757263,
1.0390048027038574,
0.16573980450630188,
-1.0321792364120483,
0.26773178577423096,
-1.0996952056884766,
-0.6247392892837524,
0.05827099084854126,
-0.056053295731544495,
-0.2048584222793579,
0.7620908617973328,
0.11667513102293015,
-0.03982909768819809,
-0.3736693263053894,
-0.012670797295868397,
-0.35167524218559265,
-0.44527095556259155,
0.4781794548034668,
-0.3525271713733673,
0.7292793989181519,
0.29846927523612976,
-0.4757848083972931,
0.2176743894815445,
-0.6531076431274414,
-0.38127613067626953,
0.20372377336025238,
0.22975477576255798,
-0.04850084334611893,
0.3366871476173401,
-0.4194430708885193,
0.35197553038597107,
0.28351181745529175,
-0.3816199004650116,
-0.34802934527397156,
-0.6851327419281006,
0.7053658962249756,
0.808141827583313,
-0.26327791810035706,
0.8162598013877869,
-0.601086437702179,
0.5755624771118164,
-0.22131620347499847,
0.44295260310173035,
-0.4679647982120514,
-0.5179868340492249,
-0.5796709656715393,
-0.010258401744067669,
-0.18554043769836426,
0.22475026547908783,
-0.7542946934700012,
-0.15556734800338745,
-0.26236844062805176,
-0.4584922194480896,
-0.7443919777870178,
-0.3963278830051422,
0.2008107304573059,
0.9083303213119507,
0.4151315689086914,
-0.16705869138240814,
-0.5337676405906677,
-0.8282570838928223,
-0.8207330107688904,
0.01778385043144226,
-0.4046555459499359,
0.6271874308586121,
0.0927865281701088,
-0.02729378454387188,
0.8834829330444336,
-0.5240522623062134,
0.2280479371547699,
-0.07536166161298752,
0.11109256744384766,
0.34794431924819946,
0.024561172351241112,
0.24454949796199799,
-0.7731359004974365,
-0.2872438132762909,
0.280153751373291,
-0.9581790566444397,
-0.17680443823337555,
-0.31638747453689575,
-0.2866690754890442,
-0.3609013557434082,
0.5972442626953125,
-0.8163636922836304,
0.6054518818855286,
0.08881589770317078,
-0.03808198496699333,
0.7990787625312805,
0.1235923022031784,
0.07162367552518845,
-0.4676670432090759,
0.20881865918636322,
0.07530151307582855,
-0.12396945059299469,
-0.6611154675483704,
-0.022541027516126633,
-0.03774763643741608,
-0.24209202826023102,
-0.7587254643440247,
0.65802401304245,
-0.4353374242782593,
-0.6001620292663574,
-0.37234747409820557,
0.27166011929512024,
0.16365577280521393,
0.546198844909668,
-0.02845671772956848,
0.3253256678581238,
0.7390567660331726,
-0.8556451797485352,
0.48857229948043823,
0.5604383945465088,
-0.3779757618904114,
0.6163257360458374,
-1.193228006362915,
0.19507111608982086,
-0.36034002900123596,
0.010122379288077354,
-1.3728691339492798,
-0.3992486000061035,
0.2983640730381012,
-0.7718173265457153,
-0.07597324997186661,
0.06576866656541824,
-0.09254191070795059,
-0.5431547164916992,
-0.36584049463272095,
0.6127534508705139,
0.5501821637153625,
-0.693291962146759,
0.8809728026390076,
-0.01695755124092102,
-0.13131307065486908,
-0.3839922547340393,
-0.7043612003326416,
-0.43047651648521423,
-0.33409616351127625,
-0.8742312788963318,
0.127864807844162,
-0.028295939788222313,
-0.7793980240821838,
0.1349629908800125,
-0.3807365298271179,
0.029817819595336914,
0.37350526452064514,
0.3090455234050751,
0.35380983352661133,
-0.6221614480018616,
0.26591023802757263,
-0.13147124648094177,
-0.7016161680221558,
0.49070173501968384,
-0.42029064893722534,
0.5150354504585266,
0.0016388250514864922,
-0.3960379660129547,
-1.131102204322815,
0.39975202083587646,
0.8531257510185242,
-0.40469151735305786,
0.5416567325592041,
0.28642821311950684,
-0.31739285588264465,
-0.10935933142900467,
-0.22231251001358032,
-0.5707105994224548,
-0.5572550892829895,
-0.10985653847455978,
-0.49057090282440186,
-0.6514633297920227,
0.4696670174598694,
-0.20221532881259918,
0.3633915185928345,
0.874173641204834,
0.6662588119506836,
-0.35329216718673706,
1.3189105987548828,
0.6251816749572754,
0.44285839796066284,
0.7685533761978149,
0.2263742983341217,
0.38035276532173157,
-0.9414476752281189,
-0.10545867681503296,
-0.8094402551651001,
-0.5933238863945007,
-0.3759189248085022,
0.001692718593403697,
0.24694280326366425,
-0.3552430272102356,
-0.236541286110878,
0.3301084339618683,
-0.855658233165741,
0.33238518238067627,
0.4120560586452484,
-0.050853095948696136,
0.2007896900177002,
-0.06351335346698761,
0.6247743368148804,
-0.14077572524547577,
-0.7632940411567688,
-0.5329208374023438,
0.8500998020172119,
0.367549866437912,
0.6093981266021729,
-0.19848227500915527,
0.1135215237736702,
0.10778986662626266,
0.8781594038009644,
-1.1441339254379272,
0.21980451047420502,
0.24276871979236603,
-0.630562961101532,
-0.26323944330215454,
-0.5302217602729797,
-0.9685739278793335,
0.2679281532764435,
0.2313299924135208,
-0.6272791028022766,
0.25578296184539795,
0.4542092978954315,
-0.4573480188846588,
-0.04572613164782524,
-0.9308331608772278,
1.2277024984359741,
-0.29203787446022034,
-0.29289481043815613,
-0.4277590215206146,
-0.7488568425178528,
0.4301775395870209,
-0.0064476351253688335,
0.6907671093940735,
0.21921075880527496,
0.16988283395767212,
0.5856394171714783,
-0.2186843305826187,
0.536487340927124,
0.030046552419662476,
-0.15111714601516724,
0.27216944098472595,
0.10683333873748779,
0.3807372450828552,
-0.08431008458137512,
-0.12692323327064514,
0.24306544661521912,
-0.25436705350875854,
-0.5000160336494446,
-0.7982586026191711,
0.510658323764801,
-0.6556112170219421,
-0.8531177639961243,
-0.08339770883321762,
-0.6129722595214844,
-0.0663963109254837,
0.12406797707080841,
0.5620867609977722,
0.9309142827987671,
-0.029093829914927483,
0.23303522169589996,
0.7991535663604736,
-0.15768201649188995,
0.45036783814430237,
0.2455044537782669,
-0.07606577128171921,
0.16974203288555145,
0.7546780705451965,
-0.16151900589466095,
0.08915774524211884,
0.6733472347259521,
0.4079882502555847,
-0.629439115524292,
-0.21087679266929626,
-0.4573781192302704,
0.32069915533065796,
-0.624366819858551,
0.29527953267097473,
-0.6946304440498352,
0.13721252977848053,
-0.1408766359090805,
-0.5102454423904419,
-0.3042083978652954,
-0.33561089634895325,
-0.40616554021835327,
0.013769608922302723,
0.040287841111421585,
0.9287464022636414,
0.09419698268175125,
0.5257271528244019,
-0.8161386251449585,
0.5474637746810913,
0.4020029306411743,
0.5640310645103455,
0.3830384314060211,
-0.7344297766685486,
-0.5243892669677734,
0.05094223469495773,
-0.2662227153778076,
-0.8864294290542603,
-0.08671161532402039,
-0.07946640998125076,
0.47823864221572876,
0.8415420055389404,
-0.0014862667303532362,
0.49280428886413574,
-0.4856700897216797,
0.6351374387741089,
0.09202665835618973,
-1.1723911762237549,
0.6181433200836182,
-0.29169759154319763,
0.5845250487327576,
0.018572110682725906,
0.35261619091033936,
-0.4803290069103241,
-0.13864630460739136,
-0.8464089035987854,
-0.43583860993385315,
1.1145328283309937,
0.10746735334396362,
0.06660821288824081,
0.2730799913406372,
0.499931275844574,
0.2534371316432953,
0.16043215990066528,
-0.4120471179485321,
-0.1411571353673935,
-0.3557378351688385,
-0.17435738444328308,
0.005023415666073561,
-0.22210049629211426,
-0.26440125703811646,
0.12035377323627472,
0.3251378536224365,
0.23521369695663452,
0.5481977462768555,
0.33035770058631897,
-0.4265839755535126,
-0.4469112753868103,
0.003007891122251749,
0.6836970448493958,
0.9046152234077454,
0.2553471028804779,
0.5200034976005554,
-0.11314751952886581,
-0.18028457462787628,
-0.17562046647071838,
0.027206050232052803,
0.021762270480394363,
-0.014040708541870117,
0.6567858457565308,
0.8331649899482727,
0.30914151668548584,
-0.4187788963317871,
0.26393669843673706,
-0.1268298476934433,
-0.2923894226551056,
0.2281210571527481,
-0.22473126649856567,
-0.0498349703848362,
0.3527171015739441,
0.31079941987991333,
0.3712637722492218,
0.3208112120628357,
-0.6573069095611572,
0.39111170172691345,
0.33227357268333435,
-0.758229672908783,
-0.8558186292648315,
1.189571738243103,
0.1356176733970642,
-0.749405562877655,
0.1829763501882553,
0.3868384063243866,
-0.32329946756362915,
0.8783080577850342,
0.06683316826820374,
1.020349383354187,
-0.49834567308425903,
0.22429193556308746,
0.0778028666973114,
0.3542686998844147,
0.1620841771364212,
0.08073554933071136,
-0.7120316624641418,
-0.42486435174942017,
-0.6794121861457825,
-0.4394697844982147,
-0.385467529296875,
-0.23725180327892303,
-0.9870311617851257,
0.04348228499293327,
-0.416959673166275,
0.034617435187101364,
0.7113252878189087,
-0.602152407169342,
-0.8669645190238953,
0.1367087960243225,
-0.17094269394874573,
0.5787380933761597,
-0.5538672804832458,
0.14322324097156525,
1.017368197441101,
0.0694078654050827,
-0.383846253156662,
0.16078199446201324,
-0.012746010906994343,
-1.0016651153564453,
0.3898751139640808,
0.47094669938087463,
-0.33405956625938416,
0.0072334841825068,
-0.2903781533241272,
-0.9280760288238525,
0.5272470116615295,
0.268749475479126,
-0.4256545901298523,
0.19712728261947632,
0.024047771468758583,
0.7440395355224609,
0.1847403198480606,
0.31240853667259216,
0.5168328285217285,
0.49172908067703247,
0.06845267117023468,
-0.6084107756614685,
-0.2075074166059494,
-0.09468552470207214,
-0.2811930775642395,
0.4574044346809387,
-0.5427675247192383,
0.7101156115531921,
-0.15078790485858917,
-0.571262538433075,
-0.4137057960033417,
0.7114570736885071,
-0.23886613547801971,
0.8893890380859375,
0.4276174008846283,
0.20224794745445251,
0.21470609307289124,
-0.2760617136955261,
1.4119096994400024,
-0.4183327555656433,
0.5735504627227783,
0.7583342790603638,
-0.026526588946580887,
0.3547098934650421,
0.44131574034690857,
-0.4355010390281677,
0.4262809455394745,
0.8426477313041687,
0.452534019947052,
0.5250704288482666,
-0.1517489105463028,
0.014774898998439312,
-0.22848980128765106,
-0.13131462037563324,
-0.4520878791809082,
0.30871838331222534,
0.2980180084705353,
-0.26635923981666565,
-0.4023407995700836,
-0.0077510313130915165,
-0.40641069412231445,
-0.11446444690227509,
-0.553633987903595,
0.9203194379806519,
0.388721764087677,
-0.7893762588500977,
0.26425454020500183,
-0.48823222517967224,
-0.0850185975432396,
-0.22918809950351715,
0.16888120770454407,
-0.05312132090330124,
0.4969724714756012,
-0.27356767654418945,
-0.685452938079834,
0.917366623878479,
-0.06511399149894714,
-0.42806607484817505,
-0.5921692252159119,
0.6031437516212463,
0.14399603009223938,
-0.24771030247211456,
0.10914204269647598,
0.5746870636940002,
0.13108615577220917,
-0.374469518661499,
-0.33106744289398193,
0.26193782687187195,
-0.19845232367515564,
-0.259270042181015,
-0.015517828054726124,
0.7297046184539795,
0.035268109291791916,
0.5231525897979736,
0.5715965628623962,
-0.553069531917572,
-0.10084123909473419,
-0.20495694875717163,
0.6509616374969482,
-0.5180066227912903,
-0.7010616660118103,
-1.0797725915908813,
0.6719098091125488,
0.25038179755210876,
-0.3435521423816681,
0.802979052066803,
0.2709895074367523,
0.606663703918457,
-0.20559486746788025,
0.628639280796051,
0.30697935819625854,
0.4866234064102173,
-0.2861092686653137,
0.29660043120384216,
-0.8161321878433228,
0.14504922926425934,
-0.06391214579343796,
-1.189239740371704,
-0.38204139471054077,
0.6817855834960938,
-0.794431209564209,
-0.09503939747810364,
0.8590260148048401,
0.2852810323238373,
-0.22292861342430115,
0.42432311177253723,
0.22240783274173737,
0.4352239668369293,
0.17788299918174744,
0.487471342086792,
1.3240056037902832,
-0.08511009067296982,
0.6974947452545166,
0.064457468688488,
-0.43245038390159607,
-0.6153784394264221,
-0.4628859758377075,
-0.5974286198616028,
-0.3195548951625824,
-0.1859048306941986,
-0.14125913381576538,
-0.4737212657928467,
0.1559295803308487,
0.5498993396759033,
-0.6554204821586609,
0.18081097304821014,
-0.34417253732681274,
0.4050128161907196,
-0.5037210583686829,
-0.21874840557575226,
0.510638952255249,
-0.24929675459861755,
-0.5722663402557373,
0.12678422033786774,
0.7550839781761169,
-0.2638256847858429,
-0.16929128766059875,
0.32429707050323486,
0.5080069899559021,
0.45916154980659485,
0.9845777750015259,
0.29599300026893616,
-0.7031839489936829,
-0.46164631843566895,
0.3982481360435486,
0.1160338893532753,
0.3573928475379944,
1.2329864501953125,
-0.6580049991607666,
0.6632025837898254,
0.670356035232544,
0.7632826566696167,
0.5979525446891785,
0.3173057734966278,
0.5609607100486755,
-0.31130582094192505,
0.24477602541446686,
0.16256596148014069,
0.36854076385498047,
0.2446981966495514,
-0.46310678124427795,
0.20626571774482727,
0.26882821321487427,
-0.6317431926727295,
-0.7392882704734802,
0.6371539831161499,
-0.9871533513069153,
-0.04875408858060837,
0.6976377367973328,
0.05844804272055626,
-0.4250761568546295,
-0.44454890489578247,
-0.23727653920650482,
0.4554840326309204,
-0.11954709887504578,
1.1692410707473755,
0.8982400894165039,
-0.2884845733642578,
-0.4475202262401581,
-0.7013031244277954,
0.604423463344574,
0.7566458582878113,
-0.9575005769729614,
0.12562346458435059,
0.19572895765304565,
-0.1504712551832199,
0.32923343777656555,
0.35808223485946655,
-0.2722886800765991,
0.6732107400894165,
0.02916511707007885,
-0.47518378496170044,
0.27130886912345886,
-0.519472599029541,
-0.5196243524551392,
0.1657126545906067,
-0.2334793657064438,
-0.4703836739063263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03484v1 | Harnessing PubMed User Query Logs for Post Hoc Explanations of Recommended Similar Articles | 2024-02-05T19:56:27 | 2024-02-05T19:56:27 | Ashley Shin, Qiao Jin, James Anibal, Zhiyong Lu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Searching for a related article based on a reference article is an integral
part of scientific research. PubMed, like many academic search engines, has a
"similar articles" feature that recommends articles relevant to the current
article viewed by a user. Explaining recommended items can be of great utility
to users, particularly in the literature search process. With more than a
million biomedical papers being published each year, explaining the recommended
similar articles would facilitate researchers and clinicians in searching for
related articles. Nonetheless, the majority of current literature
recommendation systems lack explanations for their suggestions. We employ a
post hoc approach to explaining recommendations by identifying relevant tokens
in the titles of similar articles. Our major contribution is building PubCLogs
by repurposing 5.6 million pairs of coclicked articles from PubMed's user query
logs. Using our PubCLogs dataset, we train the Highlight Similar Article Title
(HSAT), a transformer-based model designed to select the most relevant parts of
the title of a similar article, based on the title and abstract of a seed
article. HSAT demonstrates strong performance in our empirical evaluations,
achieving an F1 score of 91.72 percent on the PubCLogs test set, considerably
outperforming several baselines including BM25 (70.62), MPNet (67.11), MedCPT
(62.22), GPT-3.5 (46.00), and GPT-4 (64.89). Additional evaluations on a
separate, manually annotated test set further verifies HSAT's performance.
Moreover, participants of our user study indicate a preference for HSAT, due to
its superior balance between conciseness and comprehensiveness. Our study
suggests that repurposing user query logs of academic search engines can be a
promising way to train state-of-the-art models for explaining literature
recommendation. | [
-0.30926185846328735,
-0.24983416497707367,
0.9095867872238159,
-0.17332744598388672,
-0.755556583404541,
-0.19408099353313446,
0.02019590325653553,
-0.5348989367485046,
0.4288337230682373,
0.7108532190322876,
-0.5356869697570801,
-0.5557015538215637,
-0.2221357673406601,
0.2904788553714752,
-0.20160456001758575,
1.4116970300674438,
0.10900627076625824,
0.07653208076953888,
-0.3733910918235779,
-0.22075530886650085,
-0.45324739813804626,
-0.20168595016002655,
-0.4741877019405365,
-0.6628990173339844,
0.7455666065216064,
0.10371214896440506,
0.39210695028305054,
0.29659348726272583,
0.7422038316726685,
0.13566428422927856,
-0.2758174538612366,
0.17061178386211395,
-0.6656830906867981,
0.2018120288848877,
-0.5099716186523438,
-0.4944736957550049,
-0.30301153659820557,
-0.16022373735904694,
0.22996923327445984,
0.7302652597427368,
0.015216141007840633,
0.23833906650543213,
0.28634893894195557,
0.8157284259796143,
-0.1717761754989624,
-0.22240416705608368,
-0.6008508205413818,
-0.017897695302963257,
-0.25644978880882263,
-0.5912343859672546,
-0.34519895911216736,
-0.5054880380630493,
0.5437435507774353,
-0.7416936755180359,
0.4476613700389862,
0.4454667866230011,
1.0143455266952515,
-0.10270693153142929,
-0.24940958619117737,
-0.1815866231918335,
-0.6076387166976929,
0.7035168409347534,
-0.6869052648544312,
0.47731366753578186,
0.49058160185813904,
0.27573442459106445,
0.0338585302233696,
-0.9289629459381104,
0.07868964225053787,
-0.08741378784179688,
-0.6146755814552307,
0.11677828431129456,
-0.12116960436105728,
0.02491135708987713,
0.33344534039497375,
0.25657352805137634,
-1.0661875009536743,
-0.22100825607776642,
-0.5641406178474426,
-0.17631062865257263,
0.5626670718193054,
0.25786641240119934,
-0.13039909303188324,
-0.2640480697154999,
-0.5045363306999207,
0.10457613319158554,
-0.9995964765548706,
0.10688254237174988,
0.05659287050366402,
0.1310669481754303,
0.41298437118530273,
0.4200689196586609,
-0.48641151189804077,
0.7591278553009033,
0.2444269061088562,
-0.017133094370365143,
0.3428192436695099,
-0.6913050413131714,
0.025335611775517464,
0.2758374810218811,
0.716093897819519,
0.7407817244529724,
0.035353612154722214,
-0.17552663385868073,
0.11301390081644058,
-0.3253073990345001,
0.4181394577026367,
-0.9219251871109009,
-0.3585699200630188,
0.24038831889629364,
-0.8920137286186218,
-0.09616822749376297,
0.12661640346050262,
-0.7539469003677368,
-0.5208059549331665,
-0.009450544603168964,
0.4152580499649048,
-0.3012257516384125,
-0.02604694478213787,
0.2612151503562927,
-0.18739798665046692,
-0.029506299644708633,
0.20585469901561737,
-0.5750665664672852,
-0.015723945572972298,
0.6198709011077881,
0.6461734771728516,
-0.2502695918083191,
-0.25549209117889404,
-0.3344658315181732,
0.25427278876304626,
-0.0666256994009018,
1.1496676206588745,
-0.5599703192710876,
-0.49013134837150574,
-0.08215523511171341,
0.28217971324920654,
-0.06143004819750786,
-0.46388930082321167,
0.5060786008834839,
-0.6519847512245178,
0.34928804636001587,
-0.5256856679916382,
-0.6243419647216797,
-0.2634463608264923,
0.21840478479862213,
-0.5020112991333008,
0.848164975643158,
-0.3397825360298157,
-1.0990349054336548,
0.3916158080101013,
-0.4686903953552246,
-0.2942298948764801,
-0.025312336161732674,
-0.009039806202054024,
-0.6189736127853394,
0.18922926485538483,
0.23388788104057312,
0.28131672739982605,
-0.35630002617836,
0.3037489354610443,
-0.2376030832529068,
-0.5235580801963806,
0.11049959808588028,
0.19714020192623138,
0.7388731837272644,
0.224762424826622,
-0.038390424102544785,
0.22853456437587738,
-0.16048620641231537,
-0.19230766594409943,
0.0760621502995491,
0.14727316796779633,
-0.8404107093811035,
-0.09666740894317627,
-0.3166749179363251,
-0.13999983668327332,
0.3227062225341797,
-0.47556614875793457,
0.016697069630026817,
-0.44887232780456543,
0.2690523862838745,
0.22582028806209564,
0.5846619606018066,
0.22709999978542328,
-0.7066007256507874,
0.5304901599884033,
-0.33782708644866943,
0.11682316660881042,
-0.5043218731880188,
-0.7212556004524231,
-0.058955613523721695,
-0.017383020371198654,
0.2575884163379669,
0.19002190232276917,
-0.4483925700187683,
0.11070474237203598,
-0.1940656155347824,
-0.6744686961174011,
-0.6914085745811462,
-0.05653096362948418,
0.3739263117313385,
0.6167038083076477,
0.3630789518356323,
-0.3150542676448822,
-0.7341939806938171,
-0.9255815148353577,
-0.7097817063331604,
-0.43468788266181946,
-0.16239884495735168,
0.7171410918235779,
0.14497195184230804,
-0.3247160315513611,
0.8789551854133606,
-0.7890602350234985,
-0.30218225717544556,
0.09695747494697571,
0.3398171365261078,
0.4710571765899658,
0.10650216788053513,
0.3484051823616028,
-0.7945452332496643,
-0.374088853597641,
0.1596294492483139,
-0.6565407514572144,
-0.4877396821975708,
-0.15365678071975708,
-0.14661212265491486,
-0.31104764342308044,
0.6424334049224854,
-0.3465724587440491,
0.3169315755367279,
0.2535381019115448,
-0.48372888565063477,
0.8151744604110718,
-0.2306932508945465,
0.5161616802215576,
-0.8317098617553711,
0.37915512919425964,
-0.07176890224218369,
-0.27110084891319275,
-0.19864119589328766,
-0.020213011652231216,
-0.2472992092370987,
-0.08934392780065536,
-0.1898193508386612,
0.4028332233428955,
-0.23225778341293335,
-0.02859785221517086,
-0.14109818637371063,
-0.05416474491357803,
0.19082248210906982,
0.1626724749803543,
-0.05350739136338234,
0.6509698033332825,
0.2813199460506439,
-0.2503880262374878,
0.09254899621009827,
0.2039179503917694,
-0.21668128669261932,
0.5519859194755554,
-0.8705856800079346,
-0.1622142493724823,
-0.07046043127775192,
0.12615478038787842,
-1.3983700275421143,
0.10620492696762085,
-0.09919282048940659,
-0.3408050835132599,
-0.12133727967739105,
-0.15247862040996552,
-0.3177229166030884,
-0.49421629309654236,
-0.5153880715370178,
0.34888288378715515,
0.5263526439666748,
-0.36643970012664795,
0.22591646015644073,
0.18017882108688354,
-0.47709885239601135,
-0.24684321880340576,
-0.11545392870903015,
-0.19404877722263336,
-0.4311668276786804,
-0.17561247944831848,
0.5644862055778503,
-0.16992487013339996,
0.0021205744706094265,
0.3976821303367615,
-0.24558034539222717,
0.008351966738700867,
-0.021871641278266907,
0.39139893651008606,
0.15991368889808655,
-0.2349753975868225,
0.3877270817756653,
-0.0015469698701053858,
-0.2656029760837555,
0.07644645124673843,
-0.2496040165424347,
0.4813208281993866,
-0.23693442344665527,
-0.4524300694465637,
-0.5102635622024536,
0.23665140569210052,
0.4618220627307892,
-0.3604077696800232,
0.404499351978302,
0.8232110142707825,
-0.08499225229024887,
0.33970919251441956,
-0.4457416832447052,
-0.8220946788787842,
-0.3816531300544739,
0.1475706398487091,
-0.14859060943126678,
-1.0104275941848755,
0.5729530453681946,
-0.2584677040576935,
0.07851477712392807,
0.6338413953781128,
0.4294353127479553,
-0.6182236075401306,
0.8637545108795166,
0.3094184994697571,
0.21367695927619934,
0.4928467273712158,
-0.04656008630990982,
0.31715479493141174,
-0.7120786309242249,
-0.38495659828186035,
-0.6103376746177673,
-0.2462725043296814,
-0.5961218476295471,
-0.26332080364227295,
0.425008624792099,
-0.03603089228272438,
0.10861897468566895,
0.5352317690849304,
-0.702563464641571,
0.3849901556968689,
0.6756033301353455,
0.2698267102241516,
0.65468829870224,
0.3387290835380554,
-0.18141095340251923,
-0.23444703221321106,
-0.49483245611190796,
-0.24206194281578064,
1.3483433723449707,
0.10457763075828552,
0.7676168084144592,
-0.2916349768638611,
0.9624896049499512,
0.333675742149353,
0.3789616525173187,
-0.6738266944885254,
0.2780951261520386,
-0.06367728114128113,
-0.7719948291778564,
-0.280622661113739,
-0.1586390733718872,
-1.3888812065124512,
0.20965316891670227,
-0.3566285967826843,
-0.6183473467826843,
0.09602313488721848,
0.12916186451911926,
-0.5405884385108948,
0.08894234150648117,
-0.3444194793701172,
0.7752428650856018,
-0.03831156715750694,
-0.5069118142127991,
-0.38821449875831604,
-0.5590654015541077,
0.22209812700748444,
-0.26285049319267273,
0.12235407531261444,
0.04451741278171539,
0.08325255662202835,
1.0136284828186035,
-0.308175265789032,
0.5083557367324829,
-0.06617974489927292,
0.2501841187477112,
0.2759362757205963,
-0.14144401252269745,
0.3171679973602295,
0.18482792377471924,
-0.2276364415884018,
0.1568729728460312,
0.336110919713974,
-0.24939380586147308,
-0.5373736023902893,
0.7828827500343323,
-0.3143421411514282,
-0.8269674181938171,
-0.3095785975456238,
-0.2227897346019745,
-0.01752132549881935,
0.3848511874675751,
0.4535622298717499,
0.3742729127407074,
-0.10001754015684128,
0.4825815260410309,
0.793952465057373,
0.013290301896631718,
0.10438966006040573,
0.5556318163871765,
-0.46149536967277527,
-0.38841453194618225,
0.635394811630249,
0.002208804478868842,
-0.45999956130981445,
0.30646461248397827,
0.39392217993736267,
-0.48255568742752075,
-0.8048281669616699,
-0.16799883544445038,
0.6506240367889404,
-0.07995156198740005,
-0.40101200342178345,
-0.711768388748169,
0.1201348751783371,
-0.15013186633586884,
-0.24030908942222595,
-0.07419386506080627,
-0.06755389273166656,
-0.2505601644515991,
-0.07851246744394302,
0.5230738520622253,
0.6844741106033325,
0.18233342468738556,
0.38786348700523376,
-0.7619441747665405,
0.23903778195381165,
0.5102457404136658,
0.6020525097846985,
-0.05420628562569618,
-0.6221269965171814,
-0.5676632523536682,
-0.27024024724960327,
-0.2362600862979889,
-1.1320737600326538,
0.26391342282295227,
0.16205017268657684,
0.6846338510513306,
0.6313726902008057,
0.26007553935050964,
0.6773861050605774,
-0.7232447266578674,
0.6936928033828735,
0.22924071550369263,
-0.32289719581604004,
0.6676667332649231,
-0.5423707962036133,
0.3423759937286377,
0.8926848769187927,
0.6671538352966309,
-0.3762979209423065,
-0.32704615592956543,
-0.7371731400489807,
-0.7287479639053345,
0.5274029970169067,
0.2859257161617279,
-0.2673705220222473,
0.22790531814098358,
0.42808055877685547,
0.3752717077732086,
0.22126203775405884,
-0.38549548387527466,
-0.23561249673366547,
0.13116464018821716,
0.005247191525995731,
-0.17923709750175476,
-0.5072686076164246,
-0.378408282995224,
-0.23926962912082672,
0.6365968585014343,
-0.00315704382956028,
0.3029823899269104,
0.5569188594818115,
-0.015080008655786514,
-0.20428146421909332,
0.07008451223373413,
0.33191487193107605,
0.8273480534553528,
-0.7211318612098694,
0.24203592538833618,
-0.036291174590587616,
-0.437752902507782,
-0.10894820094108582,
0.43733370304107666,
0.02263246476650238,
0.44501376152038574,
0.5038267970085144,
0.4907081127166748,
0.41505327820777893,
-0.760469377040863,
0.4089220464229584,
-0.07236737757921219,
-0.045221053063869476,
0.059705693274736404,
-0.22551144659519196,
0.3574441373348236,
0.33866262435913086,
0.5931155681610107,
0.05237746238708496,
0.7061839699745178,
-0.3256499767303467,
0.6339066624641418,
0.25733599066734314,
-0.6658127903938293,
-0.5383189916610718,
0.5565978288650513,
0.13603085279464722,
-0.27470657229423523,
0.05948692932724953,
0.0037674775812774897,
-0.28950953483581543,
0.41237735748291016,
0.5741266012191772,
0.7290827035903931,
-0.2627854645252228,
0.298347532749176,
0.5568386316299438,
0.29189333319664,
-0.21402709186077118,
0.18004558980464935,
0.038004931062459946,
-0.21925736963748932,
-0.34607523679733276,
-0.6668405532836914,
-0.2912980020046234,
0.04176761209964752,
-0.8845700621604919,
0.12489009648561478,
-0.07333500683307648,
-0.35545435547828674,
0.3748062551021576,
0.08449579775333405,
-0.7486011981964111,
-0.026874443516135216,
-0.1713971048593521,
0.664161205291748,
-1.1280763149261475,
0.6197088956832886,
1.3095966577529907,
-0.22502218186855316,
-0.41444092988967896,
-0.029109075665473938,
-0.030789947137236595,
-0.671990692615509,
0.1345520317554474,
0.11442065984010696,
0.16054564714431763,
-0.2390688806772232,
-0.2840847373008728,
-0.5474295020103455,
1.1935123205184937,
0.07496465742588043,
-0.5739143490791321,
-0.024408550933003426,
-0.31999653577804565,
1.0265655517578125,
-0.5284529328346252,
0.31899651885032654,
0.42132195830345154,
0.21685056388378143,
0.14098003506660461,
-1.0788289308547974,
0.21354930102825165,
-0.008472491055727005,
-0.09736108779907227,
0.08448226004838943,
-0.28546059131622314,
0.6107702851295471,
-0.2410246878862381,
0.23181204497814178,
-0.008454844355583191,
0.3114112615585327,
0.6426923871040344,
1.0607609748840332,
0.4986729323863983,
0.48851409554481506,
0.7426671385765076,
0.20816725492477417,
0.9180384874343872,
-0.13473162055015564,
0.5716915130615234,
0.9849675297737122,
-0.07221914082765579,
0.8390746712684631,
0.6866734027862549,
-0.346849262714386,
0.7572466731071472,
0.9176630973815918,
0.1070309728384018,
0.8086445331573486,
-0.15398094058036804,
0.08364711701869965,
-0.4428286552429199,
-0.405081182718277,
-0.7408796548843384,
0.23955848813056946,
0.3155575692653656,
-0.8322921395301819,
-0.4043373763561249,
0.11323714256286621,
-0.03403878211975098,
0.018612787127494812,
-0.14956165850162506,
1.1743743419647217,
0.15855881571769714,
-0.6684930920600891,
0.6735056042671204,
-0.5600325465202332,
0.3132946491241455,
-0.5672191977500916,
-0.06039850786328316,
-0.41370096802711487,
-0.15827453136444092,
-0.35656532645225525,
-0.7895792722702026,
0.4361072778701782,
-0.08189860731363297,
-0.4168213903903961,
-0.15623711049556732,
0.7653918862342834,
-0.5177621841430664,
-0.2601384222507477,
0.16383221745491028,
0.585086464881897,
0.5018654465675354,
-0.08355777710676193,
-0.746634840965271,
0.06775011867284775,
0.3615705370903015,
-0.10008736699819565,
0.22329968214035034,
0.39356911182403564,
-0.05375901982188225,
0.3433492183685303,
0.5505337119102478,
0.19572043418884277,
-0.5025105476379395,
-0.3172420263290405,
0.8053563237190247,
-0.6290283203125,
-0.5674138069152832,
-0.6191351413726807,
0.2756507694721222,
-0.17765215039253235,
-0.13833807408809662,
0.8653334975242615,
0.6628906726837158,
0.5532141923904419,
-0.14198575913906097,
0.38681694865226746,
0.48854556679725647,
0.6806172728538513,
-0.25440287590026855,
0.8135401606559753,
-0.9180631041526794,
0.42196542024612427,
-0.24616722762584686,
-1.011397123336792,
-0.3268026113510132,
0.38041990995407104,
-0.5576547384262085,
-0.26922306418418884,
0.861587643623352,
0.7272449731826782,
-0.22276350855827332,
0.05730639770627022,
0.1703815907239914,
0.2810998260974884,
0.015979111194610596,
0.2031683325767517,
0.44430580735206604,
-0.2518143057823181,
0.6546375155448914,
0.04967927560210228,
-0.21342723071575165,
-1.0051759481430054,
-0.7904640436172485,
-0.9870959520339966,
-0.5573269128799438,
-0.4053930342197418,
-0.3794505298137665,
0.42588385939598083,
0.6136875152587891,
0.8115532994270325,
-1.0022292137145996,
-0.18641790747642517,
0.2726000249385834,
0.3920125365257263,
-0.5212261080741882,
-0.18121743202209473,
0.6085176467895508,
-0.12820427119731903,
-0.2899269163608551,
0.12631277740001678,
0.2026374340057373,
-0.38802680373191833,
0.10870644450187683,
0.04578692466020584,
-0.2861849367618561,
-0.13327011466026306,
0.550808310508728,
0.3411145806312561,
-0.7955818772315979,
-0.09423995018005371,
0.0826764702796936,
-0.11940877884626389,
0.01946125738322735,
1.0523335933685303,
-1.0405564308166504,
0.9684203863143921,
0.8258885741233826,
0.5984740257263184,
0.8656579256057739,
0.1714107096195221,
0.42014285922050476,
-0.4768279790878296,
-0.18220362067222595,
0.1647510975599289,
0.2660427391529083,
0.2722231447696686,
-0.42513197660446167,
0.5116447806358337,
0.40629082918167114,
-0.6494942903518677,
-0.9219772219657898,
-0.0665505975484848,
-1.0239239931106567,
-0.3466101288795471,
1.0377405881881714,
-0.23855501413345337,
-0.15179315209388733,
-0.285360187292099,
-0.5104588866233826,
0.14434795081615448,
-0.6841009259223938,
0.859567403793335,
0.37982311844825745,
-0.40790051221847534,
-0.22075879573822021,
-0.37797194719314575,
0.6860828399658203,
0.6055488586425781,
-0.5797317028045654,
-0.028373176231980324,
0.2509336471557617,
0.3030741810798645,
0.25730034708976746,
0.5514551997184753,
-0.1393611878156662,
0.35143420100212097,
-0.33123478293418884,
-0.19828474521636963,
-0.147282674908638,
-0.16642741858959198,
-0.4275795519351959,
0.298499196767807,
0.09103203564882278,
-0.09955114871263504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03483v1 | SWAG: Storytelling With Action Guidance | 2024-02-05T19:55:06 | 2024-02-05T19:55:06 | Zeeshan Patel, Karim El-Refai, Jonathan Pei, Tianle Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automated long-form story generation typically employs long-context large
language models (LLMs) for one-shot creation, which can produce cohesive but
not necessarily engaging content. We introduce Storytelling With Action
Guidance (SWAG), a novel approach to storytelling with LLMs. Our approach
reduces story writing to a search problem through a two-model feedback loop:
one LLM generates story content, and another auxiliary LLM is used to choose
the next best "action" to steer the story's future direction. Our results show
that SWAG can substantially outperform previous end-to-end story generation
techniques when evaluated by GPT-4 and through human evaluation, and our SWAG
pipeline using only open-source models surpasses GPT-3.5-Turbo. | [
-0.12130973488092422,
-0.8516116142272949,
0.49260011315345764,
0.35377973318099976,
-0.44140034914016724,
0.27372270822525024,
-0.0825624093413353,
-0.490448534488678,
0.2844923436641693,
0.4573272466659546,
-1.033164620399475,
-0.7015987038612366,
-0.26579776406288147,
-0.11726225167512894,
-0.3920574188232422,
1.3778150081634521,
-0.2023741602897644,
0.06024393066763878,
-0.21445074677467346,
-0.10374066978693008,
-0.6123043894767761,
-0.37873220443725586,
-0.56844562292099,
-0.3593638241291046,
0.888739287853241,
0.2637064456939697,
0.6991339325904846,
0.36607733368873596,
0.4658891260623932,
0.15248341858386993,
-0.053863197565078735,
0.17816321551799774,
-0.5904985666275024,
0.4394775629043579,
-0.25269371271133423,
-0.23682360351085663,
-0.48740318417549133,
-0.1708083301782608,
0.24145500361919403,
0.3798324167728424,
-0.34995371103286743,
0.4558553695678711,
-0.1569979190826416,
0.5622550249099731,
-0.37860390543937683,
-0.592974841594696,
-0.1623622179031372,
-0.05449448898434639,
-0.027706455439329147,
-0.31626808643341064,
-0.2620280385017395,
-0.4127749502658844,
0.24163636565208435,
-0.3699833154678345,
0.4212782382965088,
0.42935049533843994,
0.622257649898529,
-0.0858561173081398,
-0.3827165365219116,
-0.7753099799156189,
-0.941434383392334,
0.6780673861503601,
-0.6269963383674622,
-0.19355514645576477,
0.24102738499641418,
0.3074479401111603,
-0.3922930657863617,
-0.8483425378799438,
-0.4774438738822937,
0.07266295701265335,
0.14985321462154388,
0.07119444012641907,
0.013467496261000633,
0.033454529941082,
-0.06637103110551834,
0.16210484504699707,
-0.7559140920639038,
0.2682323753833771,
-0.6490185260772705,
0.21236565709114075,
1.003161072731018,
0.3557484745979309,
0.07861661911010742,
-0.13392184674739838,
-0.907927930355072,
-0.005400198511779308,
-0.8716312646865845,
0.16524168848991394,
0.502578854560852,
0.14073717594146729,
0.04498828202486038,
0.5937826037406921,
0.25356680154800415,
0.44285351037979126,
0.004553633276373148,
-0.40164437890052795,
-0.19771839678287506,
-0.35703951120376587,
-0.24347032606601715,
0.18460580706596375,
0.6053944826126099,
0.6559813022613525,
0.05784944072365761,
0.08067530393600464,
-0.33520010113716125,
-0.22735878825187683,
0.39646902680397034,
-0.775499165058136,
0.152051642537117,
0.3018633723258972,
-0.5343384146690369,
-0.6294366121292114,
-0.08881305158138275,
-0.47555747628211975,
-0.6909877061843872,
-0.3077723979949951,
0.4481154978275299,
-0.44393599033355713,
-0.17472001910209656,
-0.05492473766207695,
-0.6603039503097534,
0.5965833067893982,
0.4679497182369232,
-0.8354183435440063,
-0.18431280553340912,
0.7557331323623657,
1.0588469505310059,
-0.5111122727394104,
-0.37436118721961975,
-0.4186759293079376,
0.5932455658912659,
-0.6392984390258789,
1.0582081079483032,
-0.5145599842071533,
-0.6467497944831848,
0.17873911559581757,
-0.42818084359169006,
0.5233750343322754,
-0.11078396439552307,
0.4755442142486572,
-0.19997552037239075,
0.306560754776001,
-0.23250259459018707,
-0.5682247281074524,
-0.2249322384595871,
0.08994504809379578,
-0.2537868320941925,
0.9180058836936951,
0.21625973284244537,
-0.3218846321105957,
0.9110330939292908,
-0.7442082166671753,
-0.7410345673561096,
0.422951340675354,
-0.27333760261535645,
-0.22648845613002777,
0.36812978982925415,
0.16116400063037872,
0.32795149087905884,
-0.2940821051597595,
0.7277300953865051,
-0.13428671658039093,
-0.5422768592834473,
-0.14313514530658722,
-0.304548442363739,
0.47937601804733276,
0.10476759821176529,
-0.2865428328514099,
0.4299826920032501,
-0.6045413017272949,
-0.16736599802970886,
0.35783663392066956,
-0.4247935116291046,
-0.11182373017072678,
0.05747433379292488,
0.0022735525853931904,
0.2271328866481781,
0.02638939954340458,
-0.2841207981109619,
0.5607314109802246,
-0.18561089038848877,
0.27710282802581787,
0.8546988368034363,
0.11119703948497772,
0.46301278471946716,
-0.41977259516716003,
0.9979439973831177,
-0.18935035169124603,
0.07733137160539627,
-0.6852381229400635,
-0.573462724685669,
-0.6973832249641418,
0.03652583807706833,
-0.006123348139226437,
0.1830209344625473,
-0.6390605568885803,
0.3304727077484131,
0.04027868062257767,
-0.6034333109855652,
-0.37862372398376465,
0.2295982539653778,
0.25021106004714966,
0.3516980707645416,
0.1187610849738121,
-0.21361494064331055,
-0.5509482026100159,
-0.4756038784980774,
-0.200355663895607,
-0.25280746817588806,
-0.05387314036488533,
0.07468800991773605,
0.38707929849624634,
-0.14522245526313782,
0.9278297424316406,
-0.5248686075210571,
-0.26575180888175964,
-0.8503660559654236,
0.7427010536193848,
0.2059611827135086,
0.1923971176147461,
0.60783851146698,
-0.5340441465377808,
-0.32352137565612793,
-0.09848527610301971,
-0.610284686088562,
-0.07018669694662094,
-0.31889358162879944,
-0.06050953269004822,
0.5215342044830322,
0.2750824987888336,
-0.6264496445655823,
0.8987067937850952,
0.5041521787643433,
-0.7318574786186218,
0.6901018023490906,
-0.17209485173225403,
0.09828106313943863,
-0.8695599436759949,
0.13363240659236908,
-0.1469510942697525,
-0.13008348643779755,
-0.7257774472236633,
-0.017018308863043785,
-0.262864351272583,
-0.4020962417125702,
-0.5526963472366333,
0.9269402623176575,
-0.41880694031715393,
-0.2235436886548996,
-0.4286813735961914,
0.19057953357696533,
0.16509857773780823,
0.6084272861480713,
0.14590127766132355,
0.5323585271835327,
0.4544396996498108,
-0.7095755338668823,
0.533348798751831,
0.3642004430294037,
-0.21675561368465424,
0.6772452592849731,
-0.5177550911903381,
0.07604870200157166,
-0.36165252327919006,
0.6488531827926636,
-0.9940558075904846,
-0.3782249987125397,
-0.2003970444202423,
-0.41034969687461853,
0.20266428589820862,
-0.09711777418851852,
-0.48559337854385376,
-0.6950477361679077,
-0.4779547154903412,
0.002749493345618248,
0.6477885842323303,
-0.830017626285553,
0.5905315279960632,
-0.037819430232048035,
-0.4684036374092102,
-0.35505974292755127,
-0.6917297840118408,
0.08743256330490112,
-0.4150974154472351,
-0.7830500602722168,
0.17342931032180786,
-0.22440265119075775,
-0.09800183027982712,
-0.43587279319763184,
-0.16335366666316986,
-0.027840008959174156,
-0.18346665799617767,
0.27317190170288086,
0.3185083270072937,
-0.23352766036987305,
0.3150061070919037,
0.24939152598381042,
0.1353415995836258,
-0.10007615387439728,
0.18344862759113312,
0.4843136966228485,
0.04418059065937996,
-0.3613054156303406,
-0.02190113067626953,
0.8067150115966797,
0.377786785364151,
-0.0010435361182317138,
0.38853299617767334,
0.8949812054634094,
0.09376825392246246,
-0.5609539151191711,
-0.29414114356040955,
0.08052834123373032,
-0.5507627725601196,
0.1352178305387497,
0.04242117702960968,
-0.5938741564750671,
0.23615925014019012,
-0.1527528464794159,
0.5918644666671753,
0.14893710613250732,
0.5080704689025879,
-0.30522698163986206,
1.2681840658187866,
0.8171244859695435,
0.3418639004230499,
0.5659270286560059,
-0.017838725820183754,
0.3887442648410797,
-0.4335549771785736,
-0.3747362494468689,
-0.11809923499822617,
-0.7140341997146606,
-0.002057271311059594,
-0.35356512665748596,
0.27836862206459045,
0.7808877229690552,
-0.19044049084186554,
0.2854951322078705,
-0.6309859156608582,
0.6202850341796875,
0.6780909299850464,
-0.36672282218933105,
0.4382132887840271,
-0.18457449972629547,
0.041966456919908524,
0.19415581226348877,
-0.8172082304954529,
-0.6147753000259399,
0.9546841382980347,
0.4608253240585327,
0.9742728471755981,
0.2618778645992279,
0.8802425861358643,
0.2749795615673065,
0.3060520887374878,
-0.878383994102478,
0.6466109752655029,
-0.02070182003080845,
-0.5131808519363403,
-0.3057941496372223,
0.2966559827327728,
-0.9127140045166016,
0.11988373100757599,
-0.21996815502643585,
-0.497016966342926,
-0.04006439074873924,
0.15335553884506226,
-0.3997078835964203,
0.09643133729696274,
-0.8764657378196716,
0.274966835975647,
-0.6624255180358887,
-0.23913037776947021,
-0.12955768406391144,
-0.6515125036239624,
0.2603718340396881,
0.1709078997373581,
0.012077596969902515,
-0.12999984622001648,
-0.0775388702750206,
0.619236409664154,
-0.39260849356651306,
0.8433988690376282,
-0.2944813072681427,
-0.27798017859458923,
0.7752359509468079,
0.19491499662399292,
0.7568740248680115,
-0.00764091731980443,
0.10541246086359024,
0.006614737678319216,
-0.3960990309715271,
-0.17581894993782043,
-0.49817490577697754,
0.585256040096283,
-0.14439837634563446,
-0.7615666389465332,
-0.37861162424087524,
-0.6064738035202026,
0.04929108917713165,
0.28170153498649597,
0.43337932229042053,
0.4424668252468109,
-0.49811726808547974,
-0.055182479321956635,
0.2271416336297989,
-0.31505295634269714,
1.1185697317123413,
0.49145227670669556,
-0.5602491497993469,
-0.3647436499595642,
0.5704708099365234,
-0.05469120666384697,
0.12818384170532227,
-0.23054786026477814,
0.3491131663322449,
-0.19536425173282623,
-0.7317242622375488,
-0.789262592792511,
0.17979316413402557,
-0.7629533410072327,
-0.45320484042167664,
-0.3132832944393158,
-0.12067679315805435,
-0.4023834764957428,
-0.9584708213806152,
-0.0393349751830101,
-0.26867279410362244,
-0.23828229308128357,
-0.4085879623889923,
0.464089572429657,
1.2557213306427002,
0.13811439275741577,
0.26192528009414673,
-0.7180776596069336,
0.18341845273971558,
0.25419020652770996,
0.2567042112350464,
-0.2291625291109085,
-0.16599798202514648,
-0.03333071246743202,
-0.28321850299835205,
-0.7182458639144897,
-0.634189784526825,
0.4707227349281311,
0.2231481373310089,
0.3983252942562103,
0.37588411569595337,
-0.09010601788759232,
0.9989910125732422,
-0.6121197938919067,
1.3297473192214966,
0.6773889064788818,
-0.773848831653595,
0.9429317712783813,
-0.6962496638298035,
0.6703764200210571,
0.18604648113250732,
0.33220982551574707,
-0.32583481073379517,
-0.4064619541168213,
-0.7339609861373901,
-1.0281684398651123,
0.6533621549606323,
0.010430688969790936,
0.13605758547782898,
-0.15490588545799255,
0.10633070021867752,
0.38576799631118774,
0.4855481684207916,
-0.5252928733825684,
0.06678442656993866,
-0.20182691514492035,
-0.015849532559514046,
-0.0065984101966023445,
-0.1103811115026474,
-0.3561877906322479,
-0.10886909067630768,
0.3786882758140564,
-0.2580724358558655,
0.28618761897087097,
0.1663835197687149,
0.023272525519132614,
-0.4606413245201111,
0.24389132857322693,
0.9918622374534607,
0.9906662702560425,
-0.009410994127392769,
-0.23911626636981964,
0.19721446931362152,
-0.3099476099014282,
-0.0875428318977356,
-0.47221946716308594,
0.03409057855606079,
0.30827316641807556,
0.542256772518158,
1.0532634258270264,
0.1555417776107788,
-0.9082577228546143,
0.8640996217727661,
0.14529865980148315,
-0.5599745512008667,
-0.30048128962516785,
0.2580409348011017,
0.11819128692150116,
0.4651370346546173,
0.5947849750518799,
-0.1179724633693695,
-0.07205536961555481,
-0.6543665528297424,
0.10173043608665466,
0.3372972905635834,
-0.20196299254894257,
-0.29425176978111267,
0.4750252366065979,
0.6277449727058411,
-0.6146359443664551,
0.11751504242420197,
-0.1103605329990387,
-0.15328995883464813,
0.5305655002593994,
0.9882898926734924,
0.9728060960769653,
-0.1868414580821991,
0.5243316888809204,
0.25675198435783386,
-0.0003089078236371279,
-0.22413183748722076,
0.15085949003696442,
-0.062456902116537094,
-0.07722283899784088,
-0.5316805839538574,
-0.840813398361206,
-0.5248941779136658,
0.1372128576040268,
-0.6442335844039917,
0.8265935182571411,
-0.3849133551120758,
0.1513078808784485,
-0.29458481073379517,
-0.24119694530963898,
-0.4342745244503021,
0.17507489025592804,
0.24463337659835815,
0.8884499073028564,
-0.4791167974472046,
0.5728419423103333,
0.6200736165046692,
-0.299248069524765,
-0.668678879737854,
-0.08562055230140686,
0.033607643097639084,
-0.7148200869560242,
0.4366057813167572,
0.25229087471961975,
-0.31228214502334595,
-0.26241233944892883,
-0.8153126835823059,
-0.7095828056335449,
1.630189299583435,
0.08961273729801178,
-0.6531846523284912,
-0.6096403002738953,
-0.2925301194190979,
0.7436713576316833,
-0.7123785614967346,
-0.18261484801769257,
0.49575674533843994,
0.3033033609390259,
0.7199873924255371,
-0.6296052932739258,
-0.14915882050991058,
0.04942120984196663,
0.09568683058023453,
0.34157294034957886,
-0.5194828510284424,
0.5432893633842468,
-0.6337259411811829,
-0.4073790907859802,
0.11623935401439667,
0.6639785170555115,
0.6326956748962402,
0.6588954925537109,
0.1778506487607956,
0.17637242376804352,
0.6903600096702576,
0.21548040211200714,
1.0892229080200195,
0.08688897639513016,
0.07722683995962143,
1.1736952066421509,
-0.3257521092891693,
0.8572800755500793,
0.45180803537368774,
0.2505018413066864,
0.7907638549804688,
0.3897518515586853,
-0.026627102866768837,
0.5585795640945435,
0.1927599161863327,
-0.17529630661010742,
-0.027877498418092728,
0.03267863392829895,
-0.16561520099639893,
0.4668717086315155,
0.178831085562706,
-0.4823338985443115,
-0.2930688261985779,
0.12571093440055847,
0.1427580565214157,
-0.009253975935280323,
-0.6266146898269653,
0.9361363649368286,
0.024384602904319763,
-0.9859914183616638,
0.5138732194900513,
-0.2258545160293579,
0.8178426623344421,
-0.8448992967605591,
-0.2236419916152954,
-0.20222589373588562,
-0.3536418676376343,
-0.19538071751594543,
-0.9091435670852661,
0.2124878317117691,
0.3141357898712158,
-0.006685661617666483,
-0.5103992819786072,
1.0008795261383057,
-0.6126163601875305,
-0.4352242946624756,
0.08465888351202011,
0.3303351402282715,
-0.09345398843288422,
0.433106005191803,
-0.6117326021194458,
-0.13624994456768036,
-0.14919614791870117,
-0.5714942216873169,
0.2649078965187073,
0.3845509886741638,
-0.1614110767841339,
0.6900190711021423,
0.5771893262863159,
0.07108204066753387,
-0.09502676874399185,
0.14527331292629242,
0.732534646987915,
-1.0276387929916382,
-0.7616415619850159,
-0.6208693385124207,
0.846734344959259,
-0.12979939579963684,
-0.695866584777832,
0.571894109249115,
0.17549514770507812,
0.3720210790634155,
0.02550271525979042,
0.904119610786438,
-0.22261551022529602,
0.3301340937614441,
-0.43752169609069824,
0.5609478950500488,
-0.28147974610328674,
0.15051551163196564,
-0.19403289258480072,
-0.9235196113586426,
-0.32005393505096436,
0.3581606447696686,
0.06972677260637283,
0.05045536532998085,
0.846184253692627,
0.5861582159996033,
0.25775399804115295,
0.1102890595793724,
0.34764692187309265,
-0.305777907371521,
0.4594999849796295,
0.22082337737083435,
0.862702488899231,
-0.07193611562252045,
0.799272894859314,
0.2940542697906494,
-0.15639740228652954,
-0.27214184403419495,
-1.1267210245132446,
-1.2427235841751099,
-0.48183494806289673,
-0.1049548089504242,
-0.164261132478714,
-0.024592800065875053,
0.705643892288208,
0.7257258296012878,
-0.2821771204471588,
-0.1820821613073349,
-0.3075892925262451,
0.061153870075941086,
-0.23847874999046326,
-0.22369788587093353,
-0.07268599420785904,
-0.39951157569885254,
-0.4647711217403412,
0.7957248687744141,
0.5099097490310669,
0.12637421488761902,
-0.5816227197647095,
-0.29473575949668884,
-0.0687548816204071,
0.47609660029411316,
0.8648286461830139,
0.09844674170017242,
-0.7825672626495361,
-0.29552409052848816,
-0.3440113663673401,
0.07974191755056381,
0.03500087186694145,
1.2612806558609009,
-0.6410786509513855,
0.17050686478614807,
0.5215544104576111,
0.20761074125766754,
0.5432392358779907,
0.31844279170036316,
1.0760644674301147,
-1.0747849941253662,
-0.0179565642029047,
0.4000297784805298,
0.02021903172135353,
0.12865152955055237,
-0.5361528992652893,
0.6552990078926086,
-0.13779273629188538,
-0.7485403418540955,
-0.8309543132781982,
0.5000883936882019,
-0.9679851531982422,
-0.4816160202026367,
1.677201747894287,
0.11063722521066666,
-0.3339453339576721,
-0.028742097318172455,
-0.5663455128669739,
-0.03746665269136429,
-0.5253113508224487,
0.3357246518135071,
0.7864920496940613,
-0.5408328771591187,
-0.10609780251979828,
-0.3207128047943115,
0.5595589876174927,
0.14191992580890656,
-0.7627975940704346,
0.1354135423898697,
0.6757907867431641,
0.14880268275737762,
0.07682802528142929,
0.5961357951164246,
0.0879502147436142,
0.43840521574020386,
0.09080667048692703,
0.11326400190591812,
-0.30775123834609985,
-0.5801153182983398,
-0.42293238639831543,
0.19731469452381134,
0.07472109794616699,
0.268226683139801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07927v1 | A Systematic Survey of Prompt Engineering in Large Language Models: Techniques and Applications | 2024-02-05T19:49:13 | 2024-02-05T19:49:13 | Pranab Sahoo, Ayush Kumar Singh, Sriparna Saha, Vinija Jain, Samrat Mondal, Aman Chadha | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Prompt engineering has emerged as an indispensable technique for extending
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) and vision-language models
(VLMs). This approach leverages task-specific instructions, known as prompts,
to enhance model efficacy without modifying the core model parameters. Rather
than updating the model parameters, prompts allow seamless integration of
pre-trained models into downstream tasks by eliciting desired model behaviors
solely based on the given prompt. Prompts can be natural language instructions
that provide context to guide the model or learned vector representations that
activate relevant knowledge. This burgeoning field has enabled success across
various applications, from question-answering to commonsense reasoning.
However, there remains a lack of systematic organization and understanding of
the diverse prompt engineering methods and techniques. This survey paper
addresses the gap by providing a structured overview of recent advancements in
prompt engineering, categorized by application area. For each prompting
approach, we provide a summary detailing the prompting methodology, its
applications, the models involved, and the datasets utilized. We also delve
into the strengths and limitations of each approach and include a taxonomy
diagram and table summarizing datasets, models, and critical points of each
prompting technique. This systematic analysis enables a better understanding of
this rapidly developing field and facilitates future research by illuminating
open challenges and opportunities for prompt engineering. | [
-0.49646568298339844,
-0.9991864562034607,
0.948806643486023,
0.5573418140411377,
0.20016855001449585,
0.013730737380683422,
-0.16408823430538177,
-0.15914900600910187,
-0.18667908012866974,
0.25674158334732056,
-1.019650936126709,
-0.40806373953819275,
-0.06611062586307526,
0.33193060755729675,
-0.16165871918201447,
0.49523288011550903,
-0.20527057349681854,
0.2363022118806839,
-0.09615396708250046,
0.2966304421424866,
-1.0791020393371582,
-0.43081825971603394,
-0.5593181252479553,
0.13434258103370667,
0.7940750122070312,
0.43903863430023193,
0.18723060190677643,
0.3315233290195465,
0.24904443323612213,
0.29967933893203735,
-0.4165251553058624,
0.08109403401613235,
-0.04393881931900978,
0.3965286910533905,
-0.0897754430770874,
-0.20215679705142975,
-0.18531760573387146,
0.14200496673583984,
0.6089709401130676,
0.9894457459449768,
0.18054510653018951,
0.3257495164871216,
0.26563647389411926,
0.42052510380744934,
-0.8195464611053467,
0.19482944905757904,
-0.3636806011199951,
-0.030710864812135696,
-0.1913571059703827,
-0.4180053770542145,
-0.7022669911384583,
-0.4952797293663025,
0.1714298576116562,
-0.3826678693294525,
0.0389484167098999,
0.33954718708992004,
0.4461815655231476,
0.06767433881759644,
-0.3315370976924896,
-0.49042820930480957,
-0.491992712020874,
1.1046648025512695,
-0.5743730664253235,
0.19185654819011688,
-0.00036242089117877185,
0.5645798444747925,
-0.386312872171402,
-0.5835968852043152,
-0.26033610105514526,
-0.5266023278236389,
-0.11859158426523209,
-0.00047544611152261496,
-0.052268531173467636,
0.42417964339256287,
0.5668216943740845,
0.030115140601992607,
-0.7889645099639893,
0.5885941982269287,
-0.15348996222019196,
-0.2907424867153168,
0.3867030739784241,
0.3333492875099182,
0.6578027606010437,
-0.2943700850009918,
-0.47662943601608276,
0.06417737156152725,
-0.72737056016922,
0.4252046048641205,
0.0726562887430191,
0.545502245426178,
-0.033717770129442215,
0.5306187272071838,
-0.4657440185546875,
1.0002222061157227,
-0.1915677785873413,
0.05086340382695198,
-0.06025249883532524,
-0.5456495881080627,
-0.12849485874176025,
0.07828793674707413,
0.7844488620758057,
0.33195024728775024,
0.1252293437719345,
0.17385877668857574,
-0.5027241110801697,
-0.23860539495944977,
0.004491458646953106,
-0.479330450296402,
0.20875492691993713,
0.1913391351699829,
-0.5147839784622192,
-0.2417447865009308,
-0.34198638796806335,
-0.6805064082145691,
-0.6516201496124268,
-0.5664423704147339,
0.132817804813385,
-0.10962455719709396,
-0.11264502257108688,
0.02113357186317444,
-0.21140246093273163,
0.5706455707550049,
0.502395510673523,
-0.8300621509552002,
-0.17147311568260193,
0.8172829747200012,
0.9293308854103088,
-0.0932130515575409,
-0.3029315173625946,
-0.6612410545349121,
-0.3417859375476837,
-0.47498342394828796,
0.8000273108482361,
-0.5896775722503662,
-0.6139726042747498,
0.3269226551055908,
-0.08830976486206055,
-0.035546913743019104,
-0.2652376890182495,
0.7500553727149963,
-0.688838541507721,
0.19233933091163635,
-0.5641143918037415,
-0.3777475953102112,
-0.2668958604335785,
0.2718828320503235,
-0.4837968349456787,
0.8281780481338501,
-0.13391786813735962,
-0.5176133513450623,
0.08301305770874023,
-0.8175776600837708,
-0.11154215782880783,
0.10801289975643158,
-0.1343538612127304,
0.24880142509937286,
0.29846978187561035,
0.455883264541626,
0.679729700088501,
-0.6027472019195557,
0.39988523721694946,
-0.08336742222309113,
-0.14800654351711273,
0.2040942907333374,
-0.41615575551986694,
1.0383741855621338,
0.2877640128135681,
0.05131000280380249,
0.48042818903923035,
-0.4916064143180847,
-0.08219817280769348,
-0.01930336095392704,
0.2005329132080078,
-0.32610759139060974,
-0.2722834646701813,
-0.012553672306239605,
0.16988135874271393,
0.37716785073280334,
-0.24664203822612762,
0.4755873680114746,
-0.29907703399658203,
0.44401124119758606,
0.8811062574386597,
0.2680474519729614,
0.6370391249656677,
-0.19992470741271973,
0.8418980836868286,
-0.4272049069404602,
0.3470681309700012,
-0.8805205821990967,
-0.6316911578178406,
-0.407111257314682,
-0.26824966073036194,
-0.017899295315146446,
0.6948192715644836,
-0.8024475574493408,
0.14246685802936554,
0.09627055376768112,
-0.5219953060150146,
-0.3353470265865326,
-0.04716072604060173,
0.0997798964381218,
0.798800528049469,
0.290518194437027,
0.25461238622665405,
-0.4786747395992279,
-0.9118054509162903,
-0.20913220942020416,
-0.22313188016414642,
-0.11456907540559769,
0.13195018470287323,
0.02890719659626484,
0.0008085982408374548,
1.187829852104187,
-0.3821145296096802,
0.2689957916736603,
-0.4324130415916443,
0.2249983698129654,
0.5672245621681213,
0.39587199687957764,
0.7326662540435791,
-0.593402087688446,
-0.4259335994720459,
-0.11415945738554001,
-0.8790895938873291,
-0.6115744113922119,
-0.3623119592666626,
-0.1012251004576683,
-0.13487765192985535,
0.6800866723060608,
-0.7431287169456482,
0.0446753092110157,
0.3904660940170288,
-0.18708433210849762,
0.9360134601593018,
0.21069571375846863,
0.4473855793476105,
-0.8516080379486084,
0.08176843076944351,
0.1321297287940979,
0.12339481711387634,
-0.9046206474304199,
0.2810351550579071,
0.11570658534765244,
-0.34165817499160767,
-0.5916358828544617,
0.9468323588371277,
-0.9089274406433105,
0.20596148073673248,
-0.5009703636169434,
0.05707055330276489,
-0.12873044610023499,
0.23540335893630981,
-0.06265521794557571,
0.9727233648300171,
1.0515302419662476,
-0.8854551315307617,
0.6150930523872375,
0.2521218955516815,
-0.243928924202919,
0.49849674105644226,
-0.8508046269416809,
0.030850999057292938,
-0.2633259892463684,
-0.05048118159174919,
-1.2069724798202515,
-0.19071951508522034,
0.44090035557746887,
-0.37928640842437744,
0.26530468463897705,
-0.15017981827259064,
-0.36428844928741455,
-0.509857714176178,
-0.3246295750141144,
0.2849489450454712,
0.7955248355865479,
-0.5265399217605591,
0.5522714853286743,
-0.060709744691848755,
-0.8120620250701904,
-0.40782806277275085,
-0.282530814409256,
0.2891036570072174,
-0.18149390816688538,
-0.8038904666900635,
-0.02434980683028698,
-0.2048940807580948,
-0.4468018114566803,
-0.38645845651626587,
-0.013099380768835545,
-0.06030534580349922,
0.2705821990966797,
0.015044554136693478,
0.6106801629066467,
-0.3123154938220978,
0.06641972064971924,
0.13168536126613617,
-0.25965312123298645,
0.3059280514717102,
-0.049597784876823425,
0.5056437253952026,
0.20336219668388367,
-0.41306740045547485,
-0.5697154402732849,
0.46508756279945374,
0.3665277063846588,
-0.4311313331127167,
0.42349973320961,
0.16800588369369507,
-0.19714438915252686,
-0.2938309609889984,
-0.587116539478302,
-0.4218119978904724,
-0.5673537254333496,
0.18353229761123657,
-0.3933875560760498,
-0.8940339088439941,
0.42384523153305054,
-0.36695152521133423,
0.5337284207344055,
0.15595707297325134,
0.3506550192832947,
-0.12305187433958054,
1.0049171447753906,
0.7657963037490845,
0.04210921376943588,
0.7081412672996521,
0.23664924502372742,
0.17764759063720703,
-0.6177610158920288,
-0.15458807349205017,
-0.9063736200332642,
-0.1308216154575348,
-0.21845057606697083,
-0.3738788366317749,
0.34897011518478394,
0.15131430327892303,
-0.013077666983008385,
0.04201021417975426,
-0.4793699085712433,
0.31250426173210144,
0.36726418137550354,
-0.3720940351486206,
0.05119152367115021,
-0.10348683595657349,
0.00033305102260783315,
-0.0024757040664553642,
-0.7352887392044067,
-0.6811951994895935,
0.5290543437004089,
0.38276299834251404,
0.7643826603889465,
-0.29150497913360596,
0.5327478051185608,
0.30773118138313293,
0.1759507954120636,
-1.0706892013549805,
0.8794674873352051,
0.49837109446525574,
-0.3113866150379181,
-0.4737759232521057,
-0.3528611958026886,
-0.891636073589325,
-0.046777863055467606,
0.08519706130027771,
-0.6876375675201416,
0.2846594750881195,
0.21448425948619843,
-0.4853484034538269,
-0.1657659262418747,
-0.8328191637992859,
0.8720636367797852,
-0.23786771297454834,
-0.024726299569010735,
0.09633593261241913,
-0.602214515209198,
0.4900132715702057,
-0.007397481705993414,
0.28207531571388245,
0.028734318912029266,
-0.16261880099773407,
0.4967799186706543,
-0.39186328649520874,
0.9266111254692078,
-0.3843582272529602,
-0.5080918669700623,
0.5530997514724731,
0.037228599190711975,
0.8022257089614868,
-0.21480779349803925,
-0.10935984551906586,
-0.14857584238052368,
-0.33192965388298035,
-0.2841152250766754,
-0.7854467630386353,
0.6408764719963074,
-0.13899526000022888,
-0.7807867527008057,
-0.2100878357887268,
-0.443645179271698,
-0.5198196768760681,
0.2082156538963318,
0.07148852199316025,
0.4554564356803894,
-0.02796962670981884,
-0.23554426431655884,
0.8654060363769531,
-0.522843062877655,
0.7993435859680176,
0.37629497051239014,
-0.28622573614120483,
-0.15687640011310577,
0.7268131971359253,
-0.0010799226583912969,
0.2663005292415619,
0.37058785557746887,
0.09643787145614624,
-0.34797027707099915,
-0.718399703502655,
-0.5520923137664795,
0.18510664999485016,
-0.6984778642654419,
-0.01697188802063465,
-0.693198025226593,
-0.14376795291900635,
-0.5635261535644531,
-0.4993046224117279,
-0.023035641759634018,
-0.13481715321540833,
-0.21532008051872253,
-0.13067951798439026,
0.4181116819381714,
0.7477412819862366,
0.40069451928138733,
0.3677104413509369,
-1.0031872987747192,
0.17673949897289276,
0.35187020897865295,
0.06937127560377121,
0.2104797214269638,
-0.35133302211761475,
0.10577009618282318,
-0.018375173211097717,
0.10914169996976852,
-1.176996111869812,
0.1361166536808014,
-0.24431826174259186,
0.9266425967216492,
0.21870943903923035,
0.2131039947271347,
0.5066080689430237,
-0.6745876669883728,
1.0998468399047852,
0.2790374159812927,
-0.9029673337936401,
0.7866759896278381,
-0.36338144540786743,
0.4021095037460327,
0.30518391728401184,
0.5148153901100159,
-0.8102526664733887,
-0.06646210700273514,
-0.03691887855529785,
-0.9061868786811829,
0.5654358863830566,
-0.224895641207695,
0.22242413461208344,
0.1689026802778244,
0.34934625029563904,
0.10059724003076553,
0.09623709321022034,
-0.13443079590797424,
-0.14955274760723114,
0.17893965542316437,
-0.2772635221481323,
0.15681573748588562,
-0.3386823832988739,
0.07991804927587509,
0.2092832773923874,
0.6325881481170654,
-0.1877964287996292,
-0.00047416359302587807,
0.09371083974838257,
-0.19331946969032288,
0.34664231538772583,
0.5031020641326904,
0.6396932601928711,
0.5875895023345947,
0.24947546422481537,
-0.25647521018981934,
0.22481901943683624,
-0.32629668712615967,
0.2605167627334595,
0.09170228242874146,
-0.6126497983932495,
0.1425393670797348,
0.33189889788627625,
0.7906729578971863,
0.045941874384880066,
-0.6891670823097229,
0.4401904046535492,
-0.026189403608441353,
0.12558096647262573,
0.05718354880809784,
-0.0361952967941761,
-0.14742645621299744,
0.15292760729789734,
0.5302348136901855,
0.0017847373383119702,
0.4218454658985138,
-0.3146168887615204,
-0.19854722917079926,
0.4373043179512024,
-0.5950552225112915,
-0.3718622624874115,
0.4604717791080475,
0.4165441393852234,
-0.21270275115966797,
0.4608845114707947,
-0.0018763764528557658,
-0.015226729214191437,
0.5142410397529602,
0.23476320505142212,
1.1423953771591187,
-0.29246947169303894,
0.308280885219574,
0.41189420223236084,
0.4221228063106537,
-0.15738072991371155,
0.3232632279396057,
-0.1089441105723381,
-0.2842857539653778,
-0.8281644582748413,
-0.5505838394165039,
-0.46464312076568604,
-0.08227769285440445,
-0.3367462754249573,
0.4225137531757355,
-0.42062053084373474,
-0.12561190128326416,
-0.18828435242176056,
-0.5091682076454163,
-0.508263111114502,
-0.14503611624240875,
0.276498407125473,
1.3914265632629395,
-0.7756882309913635,
0.09324421733617783,
1.0314065217971802,
-0.24605339765548706,
-0.9688549041748047,
-0.09687294065952301,
0.29157567024230957,
-0.6344940662384033,
0.65462726354599,
0.35657885670661926,
0.05620076507329941,
0.1299929916858673,
-0.8170832395553589,
-0.6790513396263123,
0.7720650434494019,
0.1776762753725052,
-0.7232738137245178,
-0.31383445858955383,
-0.13600608706474304,
0.18879233300685883,
-0.14641524851322174,
0.43369701504707336,
0.23985211551189423,
0.586334764957428,
0.05387924611568451,
-0.9018619060516357,
0.2667445242404938,
-0.2699540853500366,
0.29086998105049133,
0.03873513266444206,
-0.3447785973548889,
0.5126255750656128,
-0.23734672367572784,
-0.5212836265563965,
0.453706294298172,
0.7206858396530151,
0.6209914088249207,
0.37462329864501953,
0.45461368560791016,
-0.2874194383621216,
0.7264968156814575,
-0.12337339669466019,
0.9443033933639526,
-0.33366504311561584,
-0.03767624497413635,
0.7229859232902527,
-0.46838194131851196,
0.34554389119148254,
0.563576877117157,
0.014281199313700199,
0.12424328178167343,
0.8495433330535889,
0.1522943675518036,
0.21598421037197113,
0.18663635849952698,
-0.27091526985168457,
-0.31404566764831543,
-0.6291180849075317,
-0.41698893904685974,
-0.03497893363237381,
0.2671511173248291,
-0.2559342086315155,
-0.37556594610214233,
0.428706556558609,
-0.23779860138893127,
-0.12478490173816681,
-0.6714361906051636,
0.6931477785110474,
0.24122942984104156,
-0.6369814872741699,
0.328278511762619,
-0.1906973421573639,
0.70976722240448,
-0.7661397457122803,
-0.08855246007442474,
-0.16835089027881622,
-0.5956627130508423,
0.06390899419784546,
-0.8658799529075623,
-0.09059526771306992,
0.19632644951343536,
-0.1980063021183014,
-0.8487465381622314,
0.7508320808410645,
0.038572508841753006,
-0.1868869811296463,
-0.13464392721652985,
0.5978370308876038,
0.010790755040943623,
-0.11740235984325409,
-0.5482585430145264,
0.13874273002147675,
-0.19649791717529297,
-0.438588947057724,
-0.17669522762298584,
0.7022805213928223,
-0.25819408893585205,
0.797457754611969,
0.7845602631568909,
0.0984637588262558,
0.19829890131950378,
0.2925378382205963,
0.8728691339492798,
-0.8342031836509705,
-0.4635395407676697,
-0.9205366373062134,
0.8264546394348145,
-0.0008085415465757251,
-0.2556004524230957,
1.0237973928451538,
0.30927804112434387,
0.3630085289478302,
-0.32600098848342896,
0.963316798210144,
-0.028026383370161057,
0.517531156539917,
-0.791080117225647,
0.3859662413597107,
-0.28335854411125183,
0.2191963791847229,
-0.301362544298172,
-0.9835827946662903,
-0.3346100151538849,
0.06779973953962326,
-0.36516502499580383,
0.00590016832575202,
0.3924218714237213,
0.9780914187431335,
0.2537561357021332,
0.004733374807983637,
0.25588569045066833,
0.22752521932125092,
0.33811646699905396,
0.26676008105278015,
1.4200142621994019,
0.1270718276500702,
0.2771190106868744,
0.1699700504541397,
-0.5244879126548767,
-0.20707643032073975,
-0.7465487122535706,
-0.9319555759429932,
-0.4768814742565155,
-0.24280127882957458,
0.04248899966478348,
-0.016467098146677017,
1.0283290147781372,
0.5126777291297913,
-0.66408771276474,
-0.059897877275943756,
-0.15829508006572723,
0.24430502951145172,
-0.2392788529396057,
-0.2260848730802536,
0.005783789791166782,
-0.8328336477279663,
-0.7349474430084229,
0.7322444319725037,
0.3959393799304962,
0.152257040143013,
-0.44714391231536865,
0.14949822425842285,
0.03114437870681286,
0.03891119360923767,
0.6670469045639038,
0.4828673303127289,
-0.5797921419143677,
0.05407280847430229,
0.679954469203949,
-0.18227091431617737,
-0.35479551553726196,
1.1097476482391357,
-0.6637857556343079,
0.33635425567626953,
0.987716794013977,
0.8292813301086426,
-0.34821322560310364,
-0.13382744789123535,
0.7908489108085632,
-0.5887008905410767,
-0.03999548777937889,
0.30221259593963623,
0.4141036570072174,
0.30137503147125244,
-0.29850029945373535,
0.12865746021270752,
0.09715454280376434,
-0.5012859106063843,
-0.9333662390708923,
0.5087740421295166,
-1.0639954805374146,
-0.3260454535484314,
1.2011104822158813,
0.1565769910812378,
-0.28916800022125244,
-0.21163980662822723,
-0.7479804158210754,
-0.05355364829301834,
-0.41870126128196716,
0.42179057002067566,
0.6805638670921326,
0.008667008951306343,
-0.4650292694568634,
-0.8043747544288635,
0.3451198637485504,
0.40537020564079285,
-0.8108776211738586,
0.1901216208934784,
0.8142433762550354,
-0.08242470026016235,
0.11483889818191528,
0.43193355202674866,
0.18553054332733154,
0.30268633365631104,
-0.31153231859207153,
0.12994951009750366,
0.0004601305990945548,
-0.37166041135787964,
-0.5617220401763916,
0.3407779037952423,
0.2370394468307495,
-0.01115870475769043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03477v1 | Arabic Synonym BERT-based Adversarial Examples for Text Classification | 2024-02-05T19:39:07 | 2024-02-05T19:39:07 | Norah Alshahrani, Saied Alshahrani, Esma Wali, Jeanna Matthews | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text classification systems have been proven vulnerable to adversarial text
examples, modified versions of the original text examples that are often
unnoticed by human eyes, yet can force text classification models to alter
their classification. Often, research works quantifying the impact of
adversarial text attacks have been applied only to models trained in English.
In this paper, we introduce the first word-level study of adversarial attacks
in Arabic. Specifically, we use a synonym (word-level) attack using a Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) task with a BERT model in a black-box setting to assess
the robustness of the state-of-the-art text classification models to
adversarial attacks in Arabic. To evaluate the grammatical and semantic
similarities of the newly produced adversarial examples using our synonym
BERT-based attack, we invite four human evaluators to assess and compare the
produced adversarial examples with their original examples. We also study the
transferability of these newly produced Arabic adversarial examples to various
models and investigate the effectiveness of defense mechanisms against these
adversarial examples on the BERT models. We find that fine-tuned BERT models
were more susceptible to our synonym attacks than the other Deep Neural
Networks (DNN) models like WordCNN and WordLSTM we trained. We also find that
fine-tuned BERT models were more susceptible to transferred attacks. We,
lastly, find that fine-tuned BERT models successfully regain at least 2% in
accuracy after applying adversarial training as an initial defense mechanism. | [
-0.3644883632659912,
-1.0495312213897705,
0.0991465225815773,
-0.12972649931907654,
-0.2603238523006439,
0.011053523048758507,
0.10104596614837646,
-0.49154749512672424,
-0.08472117781639099,
0.4975152909755707,
-0.40220025181770325,
-0.42551660537719727,
-1.0390510559082031,
-0.036598894745111465,
-0.8680585622787476,
1.181828498840332,
-0.047387029975652695,
0.18518027663230896,
0.2512420117855072,
-0.1349579244852066,
-0.4093821048736572,
-0.8472825884819031,
-0.6589645147323608,
-0.12833471596240997,
0.5874171853065491,
-0.14954045414924622,
1.0845820903778076,
0.19324250519275665,
0.6124829649925232,
0.38146868348121643,
-0.1441241055727005,
-0.20608198642730713,
-0.3933807611465454,
0.010217346251010895,
-0.06791099905967712,
-0.33044397830963135,
-0.08502010256052017,
0.05614277347922325,
0.4736398458480835,
0.5355154871940613,
0.014817002229392529,
-0.040705543011426926,
0.03677361086010933,
0.7029812335968018,
-0.5632826089859009,
-0.3168608546257019,
-1.2680448293685913,
0.06910130381584167,
-0.061103589832782745,
0.23111757636070251,
-0.2591473162174225,
-0.4080299139022827,
0.2687872350215912,
-0.04491839185357094,
0.17524245381355286,
-0.11052637547254562,
1.080842137336731,
0.1673182249069214,
-0.429572194814682,
-0.7366804480552673,
-0.4652434289455414,
0.7235904335975647,
-0.8618248701095581,
-0.0028084057848900557,
0.1407134085893631,
0.5289679765701294,
-0.48023197054862976,
-0.7558426260948181,
-0.9097642302513123,
-0.5168060660362244,
0.08420384675264359,
-0.07357568293809891,
-0.6998924612998962,
0.056312285363674164,
-0.050834208726882935,
0.16665036976337433,
-0.49160170555114746,
0.07405266910791397,
-0.05974720045924187,
-0.382698118686676,
0.5640510320663452,
-0.03896499425172806,
0.5756033658981323,
0.005936176050454378,
-0.7251644134521484,
-0.2766930162906647,
-0.7358773946762085,
-0.08319065719842911,
0.5653265714645386,
0.19353607296943665,
0.15807025134563446,
0.4155685603618622,
0.07944845408201218,
0.7624898552894592,
-0.3269074261188507,
-0.025072218850255013,
-0.35609352588653564,
-0.11293043941259384,
-0.13563242554664612,
0.23702815175056458,
0.5636820197105408,
0.31607693433761597,
0.25851044058799744,
-0.4155805706977844,
-0.3719307482242584,
0.3167567849159241,
0.676889181137085,
-0.8536953926086426,
-0.34437304735183716,
-0.054253365844488144,
-0.5721465349197388,
-0.6126673817634583,
0.16486512124538422,
-0.42511799931526184,
-0.4875691533088684,
0.15605215728282928,
1.0248888731002808,
-0.6284172534942627,
0.15989816188812256,
-0.0034873951226472855,
-0.24171829223632812,
0.23745901882648468,
0.2969953715801239,
-0.49867314100265503,
0.48949870467185974,
0.8285625576972961,
0.6552383899688721,
-0.08921638876199722,
-0.3513939380645752,
-0.1345168948173523,
-0.19930194318294525,
-0.4734680950641632,
0.3328956961631775,
0.024701876565814018,
-0.4154229164123535,
0.30724209547042847,
-0.2878539562225342,
0.15659885108470917,
-0.5019381642341614,
0.7299520969390869,
-0.872279703617096,
0.27959537506103516,
0.0027850077021867037,
-0.7828298211097717,
-0.6416589021682739,
0.49711552262306213,
-0.578914999961853,
0.7208726406097412,
0.007854100316762924,
-0.8702684640884399,
0.0958949625492096,
-0.486531138420105,
-0.6525195837020874,
0.09977665543556213,
0.03330809995532036,
-0.5832328200340271,
0.05211130902171135,
-0.06402020156383514,
0.4939191937446594,
-0.011319557204842567,
-0.1973043978214264,
-0.3022436201572418,
-0.3766356110572815,
0.6641077995300293,
-0.6319153308868408,
0.977395236492157,
0.2179069221019745,
-0.604249119758606,
0.04892348125576973,
-0.49728408455848694,
0.13748344779014587,
0.269796758890152,
-0.02570641227066517,
-0.5197397470474243,
0.024464452639222145,
0.13285960257053375,
0.29723823070526123,
0.39099428057670593,
-0.6652238965034485,
0.22016410529613495,
-0.6474120020866394,
0.26295313239097595,
0.767915666103363,
0.026634572073817253,
-0.11188485473394394,
-0.5948489904403687,
0.38758593797683716,
-0.032528530806303024,
0.02666478231549263,
0.19900843501091003,
-0.40165936946868896,
-0.7475695013999939,
-0.30374521017074585,
0.49442365765571594,
0.5389713644981384,
-0.9010689854621887,
0.5687037110328674,
-0.1715497225522995,
-0.750251293182373,
-0.6029800176620483,
0.08472325652837753,
0.4593396484851837,
0.29581597447395325,
0.29507386684417725,
-0.19274045526981354,
-0.33745065331459045,
-1.0538629293441772,
-0.5159857869148254,
-0.22435519099235535,
0.043319668620824814,
0.29168927669525146,
0.7985404133796692,
-0.3076933026313782,
0.7619168162345886,
-0.3292583227157593,
-0.24173375964164734,
-0.3444349467754364,
0.3751920759677887,
-0.03192098066210747,
0.25056779384613037,
0.9037554860115051,
-0.8668711185455322,
-0.5261277556419373,
-0.211852565407753,
-0.46685323119163513,
0.10874146223068237,
-0.11061598360538483,
-0.22442758083343506,
0.22180640697479248,
0.21779470145702362,
-0.34233400225639343,
0.632415771484375,
0.5886817574501038,
-0.49473080039024353,
0.5638197064399719,
-0.12076267600059509,
0.04128105565905571,
-1.1681251525878906,
-0.12700629234313965,
-0.34008482098579407,
-0.2020133137702942,
-0.9904242753982544,
0.5397877097129822,
-0.010846887715160847,
-0.1724005937576294,
-0.6194901466369629,
0.646907389163971,
0.06307926028966904,
0.14329580962657928,
-0.5352747440338135,
-0.1504303365945816,
-0.12817957997322083,
0.24639222025871277,
-0.37526005506515503,
0.8717848062515259,
0.5483487844467163,
-0.5234829187393188,
0.5125489234924316,
0.2931489050388336,
-0.5699436068534851,
0.2033660113811493,
-0.8190969228744507,
0.151927188038826,
0.08628226816654205,
0.10264882445335388,
-1.063237190246582,
0.30639350414276123,
0.38029107451438904,
-0.5191479921340942,
0.5868954658508301,
0.1792130172252655,
-0.533765971660614,
-0.17510831356048584,
-0.48210039734840393,
0.05151981860399246,
0.649313747882843,
-0.7650510668754578,
0.3146114647388458,
0.06921632587909698,
-0.24051016569137573,
-0.6877437829971313,
-0.5748228430747986,
0.5123983025550842,
-0.27774956822395325,
-0.38331809639930725,
0.5281317830085754,
0.12578509747982025,
-0.17303119599819183,
-0.018302656710147858,
-0.10059219598770142,
-0.21944110095500946,
0.6396155953407288,
0.3076021075248718,
0.23277494311332703,
-0.007992981933057308,
-0.19880689680576324,
-0.10815875232219696,
0.3881271481513977,
0.284618616104126,
-0.08875501155853271,
0.511147677898407,
-0.1027209535241127,
-0.38498926162719727,
-0.5486310124397278,
0.45539751648902893,
0.5497214794158936,
0.011700696311891079,
1.2262884378433228,
0.7231045365333557,
-0.6648302674293518,
-0.1036195158958435,
-0.415535569190979,
-0.25528451800346375,
-0.47039633989334106,
0.7448869347572327,
-0.304206907749176,
-0.6443656086921692,
0.3621237277984619,
0.1576642543077469,
0.0014205294428393245,
0.5184118151664734,
0.5601145625114441,
-0.12166284024715424,
1.049543857574463,
0.49855539202690125,
-0.6085559725761414,
0.24747170507907867,
-0.16253697872161865,
0.14275918900966644,
-0.37154439091682434,
0.07094601541757584,
-0.5262079238891602,
-0.3923778831958771,
-0.6276541352272034,
-0.010605507530272007,
0.24384503066539764,
0.2178155779838562,
-0.26506131887435913,
0.46704286336898804,
-0.1650659143924713,
0.04449346661567688,
0.5563941597938538,
0.2036593109369278,
-0.20933812856674194,
0.35200053453445435,
-0.19347983598709106,
-0.045458920300006866,
-0.6986315846443176,
-0.6405009031295776,
0.9691689610481262,
0.445626825094223,
0.6590663194656372,
0.5536941885948181,
0.7668394446372986,
0.8571205735206604,
0.599639892578125,
-0.7440091967582703,
0.6765754818916321,
-0.42492198944091797,
-0.616571307182312,
-0.03812238946557045,
-0.35575416684150696,
-1.0651336908340454,
0.08837653696537018,
-0.3258683681488037,
-0.649925708770752,
-0.22368624806404114,
-0.1311604082584381,
-0.049415864050388336,
0.4623379111289978,
-0.4862571656703949,
0.8761720657348633,
-0.42231515049934387,
0.05872580409049988,
-0.23783819377422333,
-0.5282531380653381,
0.1844925880432129,
-0.2470598965883255,
0.07625393569469452,
0.29784393310546875,
-0.013998879119753838,
0.8253353834152222,
-0.5142562985420227,
0.7165506482124329,
-0.12149495631456375,
-0.22888536751270294,
0.20967766642570496,
0.2693134546279907,
0.4302794635295868,
-0.3822111189365387,
0.01739536225795746,
0.5601145625114441,
-0.09067483246326447,
-0.6848227977752686,
-0.6537213325500488,
0.7060165405273438,
-0.9197486042976379,
-0.6544083952903748,
-0.6703272461891174,
-0.47683581709861755,
0.1083439365029335,
0.13836489617824554,
0.23449528217315674,
0.38389262557029724,
-0.47828397154808044,
0.029779864475131035,
0.24896790087223053,
-0.39780697226524353,
0.4116513431072235,
0.6244951486587524,
0.007572823204100132,
-0.3925566077232361,
1.108649730682373,
-0.16472510993480682,
0.23142890632152557,
0.4550952613353729,
-0.04164303094148636,
-0.3587725758552551,
-0.8048771023750305,
-0.5735936760902405,
-0.1970852017402649,
-0.6017956733703613,
-0.33725816011428833,
-0.33010050654411316,
-0.4414993226528168,
-0.37493768334388733,
-0.20968766510486603,
-0.08094613999128342,
-0.37340229749679565,
0.003571539418771863,
0.3769334852695465,
0.31817811727523804,
0.8417409062385559,
0.35371413826942444,
0.4346647560596466,
-0.691024661064148,
0.13639354705810547,
0.5927271842956543,
-0.10868289321660995,
0.12357521057128906,
-0.6223088502883911,
-0.2992916405200958,
0.3449903428554535,
-0.6327093243598938,
-1.2505455017089844,
0.4435020685195923,
0.25237953662872314,
0.4127172529697418,
0.5440690517425537,
0.19719071686267853,
0.326622873544693,
-0.6271184682846069,
0.9096157550811768,
0.12089721113443375,
-0.9426385164260864,
0.3819669187068939,
-0.004890402313321829,
0.1057814434170723,
0.39281344413757324,
0.4780295491218567,
-0.3229176700115204,
-0.3929157853126526,
-0.6158029437065125,
-0.576036274433136,
0.44995972514152527,
0.6082203984260559,
0.2062206268310547,
-0.05479910224676132,
0.3288772702217102,
0.06273175776004791,
0.4305371642112732,
-0.6617569327354431,
-0.669877827167511,
-0.3308907747268677,
-0.20718112587928772,
-0.0627298429608345,
-0.31006869673728943,
-0.1850120574235916,
-0.08404073119163513,
0.847844660282135,
0.321922242641449,
0.3100247085094452,
0.05752101540565491,
-0.2924211025238037,
0.3996725380420685,
0.4391689896583557,
0.5797672271728516,
0.14619757235050201,
-0.12256284803152084,
0.17978700995445251,
0.37512633204460144,
-0.622063159942627,
0.3725493848323822,
0.5568642616271973,
-0.3591899275779724,
0.16696003079414368,
0.5569379925727844,
0.5425037741661072,
0.15131688117980957,
-0.6864888668060303,
0.5596067309379578,
-0.1832113265991211,
-0.21472278237342834,
-0.264367014169693,
-0.08445210009813309,
-0.22341838479042053,
0.08578751236200333,
0.33613741397857666,
0.019573168829083443,
0.24341022968292236,
-0.6218395829200745,
0.2721329927444458,
1.0771290063858032,
-0.453290730714798,
0.13396431505680084,
0.3269472122192383,
-0.023939963430166245,
-0.5107343196868896,
0.400945782661438,
-0.25891730189323425,
-1.3671538829803467,
0.6831698417663574,
0.46413397789001465,
0.7191202640533447,
-0.35580161213874817,
0.0067872554063797,
-0.13700824975967407,
0.43380483984947205,
0.31408125162124634,
0.17919889092445374,
-0.02389962412416935,
-0.7328912615776062,
0.20360513031482697,
-0.6488710641860962,
-0.34966689348220825,
0.3260881006717682,
-0.7238829731941223,
-0.1166570708155632,
-0.5426825284957886,
-0.1846941113471985,
0.10909716784954071,
0.24322861433029175,
-0.4917747378349304,
0.2220230996608734,
0.18893685936927795,
0.9462042450904846,
-0.5677012205123901,
0.8953501582145691,
0.9320561289787292,
-0.05462507903575897,
-0.4419170022010803,
0.21667535603046417,
-0.20226342976093292,
-0.7700642347335815,
0.7957112193107605,
0.24396175146102905,
-0.235403910279274,
-0.10876878350973129,
-0.30803442001342773,
-0.4784739017486572,
0.7230075001716614,
0.11620784550905228,
-0.18393918871879578,
0.27643734216690063,
0.27216219902038574,
0.5569133758544922,
-0.12846411764621735,
0.06816594302654266,
0.31682050228118896,
0.16158492863178253,
-0.2839038074016571,
-0.5851556658744812,
0.08169153332710266,
-0.1604362577199936,
0.057056255638599396,
0.3724428713321686,
-0.2729564607143402,
0.780336320400238,
-0.009802163578569889,
-0.20100240409374237,
0.6949921250343323,
0.7217917442321777,
-0.2631782293319702,
0.18292631208896637,
0.6004838943481445,
0.8495683073997498,
0.1884605884552002,
-0.004532826133072376,
1.0438838005065918,
-0.5491246581077576,
0.21162723004817963,
0.8457462191581726,
-0.19473956525325775,
0.9578114748001099,
0.1742209494113922,
-0.3371678590774536,
0.6023883819580078,
0.36022886633872986,
-0.15994253754615784,
0.7151386141777039,
0.5310802459716797,
-0.6011109948158264,
0.15062887966632843,
-0.10933104157447815,
-0.6267709136009216,
0.46642598509788513,
0.30557888746261597,
-0.3941420912742615,
-0.4078187048435211,
0.23076298832893372,
0.20982728898525238,
0.3044203519821167,
-0.41641390323638916,
0.866517961025238,
-0.16130892932415009,
-0.38493478298187256,
0.8424223065376282,
0.48673027753829956,
0.7504574060440063,
-0.7882266044616699,
0.034896302968263626,
0.043001044541597366,
0.35743647813796997,
0.2957642376422882,
-0.4135136008262634,
0.12436584383249283,
0.21334344148635864,
-0.0004382076149340719,
0.05333197861909866,
0.7195932269096375,
-0.3806360363960266,
-0.6974030137062073,
0.1515142321586609,
0.2097284197807312,
0.13658586144447327,
-0.22266420722007751,
-1.016922950744629,
-0.23581843078136444,
-0.093806691467762,
0.12581601738929749,
0.6163531541824341,
0.13082046806812286,
0.1941865235567093,
0.6200279593467712,
0.47222474217414856,
0.34286192059516907,
-0.029991241171956062,
-0.137775257229805,
0.8207231163978577,
-0.5567389726638794,
-0.3759397864341736,
-1.146750807762146,
-0.149482861161232,
-0.09553646296262741,
-0.04218022897839546,
1.0164883136749268,
0.3985005021095276,
0.7343922257423401,
-0.10480259358882904,
0.6968175172805786,
0.1467396765947342,
0.5058610439300537,
-0.36833488941192627,
1.1695560216903687,
-0.5964370369911194,
0.1507304161787033,
-0.38131994009017944,
-0.58559250831604,
-0.009450836107134819,
0.5791622400283813,
-0.02902446687221527,
0.01032009907066822,
0.4804511070251465,
0.7367530465126038,
0.25263720750808716,
0.005805133376270533,
0.36597001552581787,
0.3520191013813019,
0.2633819580078125,
0.5472711324691772,
0.9039871096611023,
-0.7684527039527893,
0.6317387819290161,
-0.33364081382751465,
-0.16189351677894592,
-0.2923654615879059,
-0.8080037236213684,
-1.2005665302276611,
-0.42132270336151123,
-0.27128881216049194,
-0.5631051659584045,
0.6539777517318726,
0.8246883749961853,
0.4453568160533905,
-0.9843475818634033,
-0.010782882571220398,
-0.04445579648017883,
0.205779567360878,
-0.16320912539958954,
-0.2530796229839325,
0.6348978281021118,
-0.08478552848100662,
-0.380281925201416,
0.2095915526151657,
-0.23981131613254547,
0.45900478959083557,
-0.28107327222824097,
0.13859321177005768,
-0.2553503215312958,
0.19597795605659485,
0.5231432914733887,
0.11801834404468536,
-0.953191339969635,
-0.43717852234840393,
-0.3103513717651367,
-0.3268667161464691,
-0.6036829352378845,
0.4853133261203766,
-0.8127970099449158,
0.3451286256313324,
0.0027899383567273617,
1.0505720376968384,
-0.2685464322566986,
-0.05286196619272232,
0.40329301357269287,
-0.7506168484687805,
0.25277820229530334,
0.2637660503387451,
0.38541048765182495,
0.30880746245384216,
-0.18298408389091492,
-0.010047380812466145,
0.005050771404057741,
-0.29233017563819885,
-0.7780691981315613,
0.5159112215042114,
-0.7110175490379333,
-0.5739482045173645,
0.8405014276504517,
-0.5491253733634949,
0.07254606485366821,
-0.014831654727458954,
-0.46076700091362,
0.29070860147476196,
-0.14395974576473236,
1.3768442869186401,
0.9519967436790466,
0.47659385204315186,
0.3739394545555115,
-0.33916720747947693,
0.5011257529258728,
0.7920881509780884,
-0.5614961385726929,
-0.34929877519607544,
0.0025384328328073025,
-0.041148845106363297,
0.023385832086205482,
-0.27762478590011597,
0.25621506571769714,
0.3345740735530853,
-0.0009759014355950058,
-0.07852672785520554,
-0.16603775322437286,
-0.11749424040317535,
-0.5567300915718079,
0.2027670443058014,
0.1292080581188202,
-0.476898193359375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03435v1 | Psychological Assessments with Large Language Models: A Privacy-Focused and Cost-Effective Approach | 2024-02-05T19:00:02 | 2024-02-05T19:00:02 | Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This study explores the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) to analyze text
comments from Reddit users, aiming to achieve two primary objectives: firstly,
to pinpoint critical excerpts that support a predefined psychological
assessment of suicidal risk; and secondly, to summarize the material to
substantiate the preassigned suicidal risk level. The work is circumscribed to
the use of "open-source" LLMs that can be run locally, thereby enhancing data
privacy. Furthermore, it prioritizes models with low computational
requirements, making it accessible to both individuals and institutions
operating on limited computing budgets. The implemented strategy only relies on
a carefully crafted prompt and a grammar to guide the LLM's text completion.
Despite its simplicity, the evaluation metrics show outstanding results, making
it a valuable privacy-focused and cost-effective approach. This work is part of
the Computational Linguistics and Clinical Psychology (CLPsych) 2024 shared
task. | [
-0.3145984709262848,
-0.677340030670166,
0.9692511558532715,
0.725702166557312,
-0.10122408717870712,
-0.21090541779994965,
-0.5927774906158447,
-0.5432186722755432,
0.0843248963356018,
0.4613621234893799,
-0.7448776960372925,
-0.630554735660553,
-0.7591708898544312,
0.39066430926322937,
-0.3987180292606354,
0.9235468506813049,
-0.14546911418437958,
0.10423444956541061,
-0.07295720279216766,
0.29727622866630554,
-0.06291484832763672,
-0.5924437046051025,
-0.7232099175453186,
0.013149481266736984,
0.9872492551803589,
0.13471992313861847,
0.6289997696876526,
0.3262149691581726,
0.821436882019043,
0.25503307580947876,
-0.09535306692123413,
-0.3165915608406067,
-0.5617477297782898,
0.19516238570213318,
-0.1798195242881775,
-0.15958158671855927,
-0.4949396252632141,
0.11996422708034515,
0.4310930371284485,
0.5849887728691101,
-0.1990453153848648,
0.5050821900367737,
0.13343964517116547,
0.7401992678642273,
-0.972891092300415,
0.17600536346435547,
-0.2169622927904129,
0.13520990312099457,
-0.012517256662249565,
0.1394646018743515,
-0.534026563167572,
-0.7986955642700195,
0.19889813661575317,
-0.2341855764389038,
-0.26110556721687317,
-0.47322264313697815,
0.3292118310928345,
0.2264944314956665,
-0.30415570735931396,
-0.2409071922302246,
-0.5786798596382141,
0.8863221406936646,
-0.7240114212036133,
0.4066786766052246,
0.5467292070388794,
-0.012226346880197525,
-0.08110659569501877,
-0.5493537187576294,
-0.22733965516090393,
-0.2018939107656479,
-0.3146350085735321,
0.10008438676595688,
-0.42835482954978943,
0.21979929506778717,
0.3452041447162628,
0.3075076639652252,
-0.536477267742157,
0.12281382828950882,
-0.32419905066490173,
-0.28147092461586,
1.0207544565200806,
0.3383472263813019,
0.2280295342206955,
-0.14923150837421417,
-0.1388731151819229,
0.2393742799758911,
-0.44671356678009033,
-0.10463717579841614,
0.4835277497768402,
0.2934001386165619,
-0.29907047748565674,
0.7406433820724487,
-0.23245924711227417,
0.4566802978515625,
-0.2607203423976898,
-0.22002309560775757,
0.1807999461889267,
-0.28468865156173706,
-0.09089253097772598,
-0.2411060631275177,
1.264923334121704,
0.7163618803024292,
0.523335874080658,
-0.12937825918197632,
0.09205496311187744,
0.06411208212375641,
0.3686085641384125,
-0.8773614764213562,
-0.1531197875738144,
0.5827946066856384,
-0.6625745296478271,
-0.291538804769516,
-0.3430232107639313,
-1.275948405265808,
-0.7039684057235718,
-0.2557370364665985,
0.24047838151454926,
-0.11151430010795593,
-0.2387007772922516,
0.1370561420917511,
0.16600897908210754,
-0.25248265266418457,
0.20449846982955933,
-0.6544509530067444,
0.4864274859428406,
0.6505675315856934,
1.1017988920211792,
-0.3233487606048584,
-0.16270002722740173,
-0.19396398961544037,
-0.016235046088695526,
-0.1587703675031662,
0.5144854187965393,
-0.3830687999725342,
-0.467849463224411,
0.3384738266468048,
0.016218826174736023,
0.11239248514175415,
-0.09728387743234634,
0.7270286083221436,
-0.3292689025402069,
0.5325457453727722,
-0.18603754043579102,
-0.4162765145301819,
-0.13765820860862732,
0.23775434494018555,
-0.65995192527771,
0.8627499938011169,
-0.08944930881261826,
-1.0477931499481201,
-0.14126703143119812,
-0.8541725277900696,
-0.3116415739059448,
0.05150241777300835,
-0.1304851472377777,
-0.3576008677482605,
0.2264867126941681,
-0.047399573028087616,
0.7603582143783569,
-0.228663831949234,
0.2855394184589386,
-0.4484463930130005,
-0.11662667989730835,
0.718407392501831,
-0.3279913067817688,
0.7495131492614746,
0.21894775331020355,
-0.28639891743659973,
0.026091743260622025,
-0.667566180229187,
0.15803645551204681,
0.04505940154194832,
-0.4819194972515106,
-0.41768190264701843,
0.09696436673402786,
0.18642713129520416,
0.05623974651098251,
0.8139849305152893,
-0.7365792989730835,
-0.241707444190979,
-0.4219212830066681,
0.4132908880710602,
0.6177868247032166,
0.18191535770893097,
0.30935028195381165,
-0.11221782863140106,
0.7030184268951416,
-0.5991591215133667,
0.6575208902359009,
0.17175322771072388,
-0.3358909487724304,
-0.06751208007335663,
-0.7600880265235901,
-0.001115553081035614,
0.5118462443351746,
0.17664369940757751,
0.4339970648288727,
0.13605186343193054,
-0.6560558080673218,
-0.23559769988059998,
0.09912058711051941,
0.4171821177005768,
0.19053499400615692,
0.061247579753398895,
-0.14048011600971222,
-0.6613410711288452,
-0.9936291575431824,
-0.5012688636779785,
-0.11372670531272888,
-0.14314429461956024,
0.32566243410110474,
0.397398978471756,
-0.37756818532943726,
0.7294186949729919,
-0.8706343770027161,
-0.40220218896865845,
-0.11214783787727356,
0.04584971070289612,
0.14627493917942047,
0.1745181679725647,
0.2680193781852722,
-0.7174466252326965,
-0.7674775123596191,
-0.16168642044067383,
-0.8096524477005005,
-0.351657897233963,
0.11670044809579849,
-0.1301114708185196,
-0.08984227478504181,
0.4141693115234375,
-0.7245898246765137,
0.5390962362289429,
0.7515735626220703,
-0.08164940774440765,
0.5453575253486633,
-0.15153127908706665,
-0.05196163430809975,
-0.898316502571106,
0.20315924286842346,
0.16516418755054474,
-0.15663717687129974,
-0.6183999180793762,
0.06600180268287659,
-0.11975252628326416,
-0.23436160385608673,
-0.3114638924598694,
0.32215583324432373,
-0.396714448928833,
0.2533784806728363,
-0.3421785533428192,
0.31291934847831726,
-0.42507830262184143,
0.3389096260070801,
0.02008049003779888,
0.7175236940383911,
0.34934133291244507,
-0.1997031271457672,
-0.07620995491743088,
0.1656084507703781,
-0.26434019207954407,
0.2746697664260864,
-0.5558518171310425,
0.14641305804252625,
-0.12414728105068207,
0.025626324117183685,
-0.9977421760559082,
-0.514319658279419,
0.11779610067605972,
-0.5749233365058899,
-0.22445538640022278,
0.359935462474823,
-0.3819340765476227,
-0.10291044414043427,
-0.6736860871315002,
0.307537317276001,
0.467903196811676,
-0.008863652125000954,
0.7317352294921875,
0.868127167224884,
-0.6535612940788269,
-0.4644286334514618,
-0.6891424059867859,
0.27630990743637085,
-0.39347827434539795,
-0.28134188055992126,
0.0034522560890764,
-0.352688193321228,
-0.5645057559013367,
-0.1234433725476265,
0.31048583984375,
-0.2833613455295563,
0.37640079855918884,
0.609653890132904,
0.11516179144382477,
0.12016358226537704,
0.09817490726709366,
-0.1514805257320404,
-0.0449180081486702,
0.545935332775116,
0.1831083446741104,
0.6496760845184326,
-0.08071458339691162,
0.12116235494613647,
-0.7764089703559875,
0.8000136017799377,
0.5346227884292603,
-0.1197768971323967,
0.9278311729431152,
0.13977590203285217,
-0.5386820435523987,
-0.26368850469589233,
-0.5081556439399719,
-0.061834752559661865,
-0.4545399248600006,
0.3726493716239929,
0.20743407309055328,
-1.1982109546661377,
0.4582202136516571,
-0.17266961932182312,
0.1636698991060257,
0.08985977619886398,
0.9804292321205139,
-0.2547822892665863,
1.0011296272277832,
0.8300554752349854,
0.018527351319789886,
0.4935753345489502,
0.27306240797042847,
0.5755417346954346,
-0.6322437524795532,
-0.024577828124165535,
-0.6001227498054504,
-0.10388075560331345,
-0.6067049503326416,
-0.1467578411102295,
0.5031545162200928,
-0.2363905906677246,
-0.5030092597007751,
0.21076205372810364,
-0.5298450589179993,
0.5887106657028198,
0.26198095083236694,
0.3337343633174896,
0.3808814287185669,
0.04767483100295067,
0.3546604514122009,
-0.4685058295726776,
-0.009522541426122189,
-0.7972413301467896,
1.292267084121704,
0.6504254341125488,
0.739806592464447,
0.24463103711605072,
0.7355321645736694,
0.3139781951904297,
0.6989431977272034,
-0.7097976207733154,
0.7373851537704468,
-0.15202738344669342,
-0.7382226586341858,
-0.4190608859062195,
-0.460151731967926,
-0.7046719193458557,
0.12205188721418381,
-0.0592820905148983,
-1.3417751789093018,
-0.02396552637219429,
-0.05855756253004074,
-0.39107513427734375,
-0.16372190415859222,
-0.6481781005859375,
0.7620129585266113,
-0.2829640805721283,
-0.2899780571460724,
-0.2734997272491455,
-0.6162117719650269,
0.6305820345878601,
-0.7126629948616028,
0.41767629981040955,
-0.16686202585697174,
-0.24530354142189026,
1.124204397201538,
-0.17334353923797607,
1.046199083328247,
-0.14118310809135437,
-0.230423241853714,
0.04261291027069092,
0.07912874966859818,
0.35703858733177185,
-0.005772013682872057,
-0.18902158737182617,
0.1833185851573944,
0.1066359430551529,
-0.022898782044649124,
-0.5274239182472229,
0.7674560546875,
-0.8214654922485352,
-0.5764369368553162,
-0.34652066230773926,
-0.6430484056472778,
-0.3627258837223053,
0.3893219232559204,
0.007448859978467226,
-0.08044537156820297,
-0.29571157693862915,
0.21469256281852722,
0.5328183174133301,
-0.3188367784023285,
0.18666137754917145,
0.778641402721405,
-0.35341107845306396,
-0.7778880596160889,
0.4003526568412781,
-0.014138107188045979,
0.28060102462768555,
0.13389265537261963,
0.6034964919090271,
-0.33667317032814026,
-0.4834471642971039,
0.3950081169605255,
0.7422472834587097,
-0.8016929030418396,
0.017073340713977814,
-0.7348418831825256,
-0.19084452092647552,
-0.37768274545669556,
-0.17743979394435883,
-0.35051417350769043,
-0.10939974337816238,
-0.22400552034378052,
-0.3609646260738373,
0.4547273516654968,
0.7054559588432312,
-0.20584973692893982,
0.5463192462921143,
-0.7102257013320923,
0.03487741947174072,
0.022782377898693085,
0.42438507080078125,
0.13423174619674683,
-0.1250046193599701,
-0.15710175037384033,
-0.22589662671089172,
-0.18793870508670807,
-1.136975646018982,
0.2984919846057892,
-0.09477628767490387,
0.1722787767648697,
0.33892160654067993,
0.2667936682701111,
0.47000959515571594,
-0.4696027636528015,
0.8398552536964417,
0.48130008578300476,
-0.9713642001152039,
0.3321491479873657,
-0.5963660478591919,
-0.08649034053087234,
1.0354939699172974,
0.8672622442245483,
-0.6395474076271057,
-0.5030176043510437,
-0.24420206248760223,
-0.6227424144744873,
0.4884975552558899,
0.19685667753219604,
0.3605990409851074,
-0.07184155285358429,
0.41091105341911316,
-0.10506497323513031,
0.25565382838249207,
-1.0588538646697998,
0.0015680976212024689,
0.42671480774879456,
-0.7336403727531433,
-0.13058573007583618,
-0.5308791399002075,
-0.5112589001655579,
-0.16367053985595703,
0.5208644866943359,
0.04039967805147171,
0.40004774928092957,
0.21008244156837463,
0.3108638525009155,
-0.28085389733314514,
0.21035952866077423,
0.4871502220630646,
0.7329270243644714,
-0.24499261379241943,
0.07325748354196548,
0.05916064605116844,
-0.7559517621994019,
0.17898404598236084,
0.004335514735430479,
-0.2590203285217285,
-0.14557887613773346,
0.30786290764808655,
0.2238037884235382,
0.20337341725826263,
-1.0531853437423706,
0.8727107048034668,
-0.33279743790626526,
-0.35445067286491394,
-0.6256101131439209,
-0.17466913163661957,
0.4480549991130829,
0.4009769856929779,
-0.0702066719532013,
-0.3747955858707428,
0.08612525463104248,
-0.31337109208106995,
0.09011368453502655,
0.33185553550720215,
-0.4298296570777893,
-0.3542565405368805,
0.44277694821357727,
0.02477024868130684,
-0.6165497899055481,
0.2064153254032135,
0.23208539187908173,
-0.43697911500930786,
0.14776986837387085,
0.2940143048763275,
1.1784156560897827,
-0.20419016480445862,
0.48559993505477905,
0.3293883204460144,
0.33201760053634644,
-0.2439524382352829,
0.5865229368209839,
-0.003963619936257601,
-0.33260998129844666,
-0.38030150532722473,
-0.7722246646881104,
-0.5394213795661926,
0.24696248769760132,
-0.6986615657806396,
0.23990562558174133,
-0.7496657371520996,
-0.3671285808086395,
-0.24432218074798584,
-0.08116203546524048,
-0.2565634846687317,
0.1747053861618042,
0.15528233349323273,
0.8826190829277039,
-0.754342794418335,
0.3987720310688019,
0.40378817915916443,
-0.34079793095588684,
-0.7911909818649292,
0.11264796555042267,
0.0837734267115593,
-0.5620756149291992,
0.5845992565155029,
0.14473380148410797,
-0.15859463810920715,
-0.3961038291454315,
-0.6169028282165527,
-0.9214649200439453,
0.6349091529846191,
0.5338701009750366,
-0.6885759830474854,
-0.15404778718948364,
0.46989598870277405,
0.8636980056762695,
-0.16154012084007263,
0.11888117343187332,
0.5379931330680847,
0.6110837459564209,
-0.42196255922317505,
-0.8756398558616638,
0.17086991667747498,
-0.024731697514653206,
-0.3587804138660431,
0.3396492898464203,
-0.6559549570083618,
0.870850682258606,
0.10336332023143768,
-0.36655452847480774,
0.1546207070350647,
0.4424055814743042,
0.11486027389764786,
0.14099101722240448,
0.34414196014404297,
0.36473286151885986,
0.8359091877937317,
0.455197274684906,
0.8788405656814575,
-0.45426347851753235,
0.7409077882766724,
1.1651374101638794,
-0.48722001910209656,
1.1616737842559814,
0.42162907123565674,
-0.3418149948120117,
0.3273608684539795,
0.4109894037246704,
0.15645453333854675,
0.5424550771713257,
0.30127793550491333,
-0.5218068957328796,
-0.10934792459011078,
-0.20219814777374268,
0.03752849996089935,
0.2253810465335846,
0.33492088317871094,
-0.7036061882972717,
-0.30185264348983765,
0.09609797596931458,
0.36371657252311707,
0.423618346452713,
-0.08878479897975922,
0.8597891926765442,
0.38195833563804626,
-0.5978914499282837,
0.15042829513549805,
-0.03404425084590912,
0.5157363414764404,
-0.7810763716697693,
0.3681178390979767,
-0.05480017513036728,
0.4895974397659302,
-0.32359132170677185,
-0.8064984679222107,
0.5228196382522583,
0.695473313331604,
-0.07539217919111252,
-0.2746693789958954,
0.613419771194458,
-0.33445754647254944,
-0.7058790326118469,
0.6010639071464539,
0.3019897937774658,
0.2627667486667633,
-0.282696396112442,
-0.6843589544296265,
0.224691241979599,
-0.04338984191417694,
-0.50820392370224,
0.4988068640232086,
0.1390819102525711,
0.06595811247825623,
0.5127054452896118,
0.4726160764694214,
0.39454710483551025,
-0.1589542031288147,
-0.069129079580307,
0.6945345997810364,
-0.7157875895500183,
-0.5715054869651794,
-1.1405030488967896,
0.30551671981811523,
-0.06604168564081192,
-0.43225300312042236,
0.9375301599502563,
0.42857596278190613,
0.5659857988357544,
0.05880611762404442,
0.898184597492218,
0.14416944980621338,
0.7667593955993652,
-0.25194650888442993,
0.9567895531654358,
-0.43251001834869385,
-0.1297508031129837,
-0.4716850519180298,
-0.7131145596504211,
-0.6566355228424072,
0.6449573636054993,
-0.6996162533760071,
-0.26937025785446167,
0.8520586490631104,
0.7958874702453613,
0.3767642676830292,
0.16991934180259705,
0.24819152057170868,
0.28944864869117737,
0.41902852058410645,
0.6653969883918762,
0.981738269329071,
-0.17981459200382233,
0.18300510942935944,
-0.3408586084842682,
-0.41870683431625366,
0.1818470060825348,
-0.9320623278617859,
-1.1032105684280396,
-0.3433026671409607,
-0.43087038397789,
-0.19225162267684937,
-0.2305709570646286,
0.8541381359100342,
0.1401343196630478,
-0.4709480404853821,
-0.45580682158470154,
0.1308784782886505,
-0.278283953666687,
0.17164330184459686,
-0.19054029881954193,
0.35669612884521484,
0.01882541924715042,
-0.4654218256473541,
0.07838034629821777,
0.28698351979255676,
-0.41097867488861084,
-0.6987910866737366,
0.10555684566497803,
-0.1422789990901947,
0.29362738132476807,
0.6050125956535339,
0.02046077884733677,
-0.6667397022247314,
-0.2696094214916229,
-0.027270521968603134,
-0.2506280243396759,
-0.24251660704612732,
0.7396871447563171,
-0.1502363085746765,
0.15843012928962708,
0.5704157948493958,
0.7316679954528809,
0.12078393250703812,
0.11609697341918945,
0.5453376770019531,
-0.3025803565979004,
-0.11304017901420593,
0.2550511062145233,
0.2457827925682068,
0.21607258915901184,
-0.7816647887229919,
0.3744150996208191,
-0.12000856548547745,
-0.6959108710289001,
-1.1124157905578613,
0.031095968559384346,
-0.9195980429649353,
-0.37381425499916077,
1.1036322116851807,
-0.30700552463531494,
-0.38014495372772217,
0.0456143356859684,
-0.3892614543437958,
-0.12507863342761993,
-0.41623127460479736,
0.9735023975372314,
0.9155007600784302,
-0.13183023035526276,
-0.04187944903969765,
-0.6604849100112915,
0.5779627561569214,
0.17024175822734833,
-0.8708961606025696,
0.6336668729782104,
0.4699907898902893,
0.41246476769447327,
0.28859198093414307,
0.752887487411499,
-0.2917811870574951,
0.1614057868719101,
-0.5223227739334106,
0.04293170943856239,
0.2141038328409195,
-0.21104955673217773,
-0.556185245513916,
0.618594765663147,
-0.17578165233135223,
0.19457104802131653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03303v1 | Nevermind: Instruction Override and Moderation in Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:58:19 | 2024-02-05T18:58:19 | Edward Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Given the impressive capabilities of recent Large Language Models (LLMs), we
investigate and benchmark the most popular proprietary and different sized open
source models on the task of explicit instruction following in conflicting
situations, e.g. overrides. These include the ability of the model to override
the knowledge within the weights of the model, the ability to override (or
moderate) extracted knowledge in the prompt, and lastly the ability to perform
a full jailbreak. Experimentation performed suggest several key findings to
improve instruction following - larger models perform the best in following
instructions that override internal and contextual instructions, and are
obedient, even to a fault. When scaling to longer contexts via rope scaling, a
significant buffer needs to be maintained from the edge of the perplexity cliff
in order to maintain instruction following capabilities. Finally, we observe
improving instruction following, and subsequently instruction
overrides/jailbreaks, is fundamentally at odds with the ability of a language
model to follow given safety filters or guidelines. Thus, we postulate the most
effective approach for safe, trustworthy AI should be dealt external to the LLM
itself. | [
-0.05718512460589409,
-0.7973315119743347,
0.7239700555801392,
0.012194612063467503,
0.01881449855864048,
0.056135863065719604,
-0.21280673146247864,
-0.5170145630836487,
-0.23528914153575897,
0.7835149168968201,
-0.37768808007240295,
-0.45150741934776306,
-0.6714352369308472,
-0.29041871428489685,
-0.4775347113609314,
1.0748871564865112,
-0.3369669020175934,
-0.03851617872714996,
-0.17727933824062347,
-0.13919875025749207,
-0.6320587396621704,
-0.5259668231010437,
-0.38095784187316895,
-0.5567726492881775,
0.5575677156448364,
0.30981695652008057,
0.7273286581039429,
0.9991202354431152,
0.20314791798591614,
0.3332594335079193,
-0.09811876714229584,
0.03720435872673988,
-0.705659806728363,
0.30659234523773193,
-0.3046964704990387,
-0.5575127005577087,
-0.5564983487129211,
-0.0298254806548357,
0.6594864726066589,
0.48978665471076965,
-0.28190866112709045,
-0.08007341623306274,
-0.05596667900681496,
0.6015504598617554,
-0.8277304172515869,
0.22587893903255463,
-0.6375399827957153,
-0.11842191219329834,
0.04356996342539787,
0.045459795743227005,
-0.3693482577800751,
-0.5874276161193848,
-0.05740206316113472,
-0.41254061460494995,
-0.31941354274749756,
0.11535628885030746,
0.37741151452064514,
0.5993351936340332,
-0.4224739670753479,
-0.38524243235588074,
-0.5183393359184265,
0.8750746846199036,
-0.6522088050842285,
0.44900432229042053,
0.6754223108291626,
0.053985822945833206,
-0.275585412979126,
-0.563545286655426,
-0.2794073820114136,
-0.5317584872245789,
0.10974609851837158,
-0.18185392022132874,
-0.26659613847732544,
0.21886232495307922,
0.5258165597915649,
0.21782943606376648,
-0.18971599638462067,
0.4430158734321594,
-0.39155837893486023,
0.11095909774303436,
0.4189586639404297,
0.19351401925086975,
0.5260483026504517,
0.09387202560901642,
-0.2396416962146759,
0.09204181283712387,
-1.2895591259002686,
0.018202457576990128,
0.24568913877010345,
-0.03857304900884628,
-0.12002445012331009,
0.5012342929840088,
-0.25799259543418884,
0.7261089086532593,
-0.009741883724927902,
0.1545652598142624,
0.1259702444076538,
-0.07949379086494446,
-0.2967858910560608,
0.2888592481613159,
0.6671454906463623,
0.3826676905155182,
0.21521006524562836,
-0.37022271752357483,
-0.4639279246330261,
-0.37420743703842163,
0.5181431770324707,
-0.9266677498817444,
-0.29382389783859253,
0.20786984264850616,
-0.17603325843811035,
-0.12124651670455933,
-0.18486462533473969,
-0.4584934115409851,
-0.8011206388473511,
-0.3413715064525604,
0.5529969930648804,
-0.5231121182441711,
-0.016368640586733818,
-0.03116043284535408,
0.2220756709575653,
0.3170137107372284,
0.36583617329597473,
-0.9437570571899414,
0.17759354412555695,
1.0717657804489136,
0.7367427945137024,
0.029139766469597816,
-0.2539960443973541,
-0.6285544633865356,
0.26803210377693176,
-0.4940550923347473,
0.43136316537857056,
-0.49670958518981934,
-0.43309834599494934,
-0.047649070620536804,
-0.046230580657720566,
-0.25016647577285767,
-0.4152412712574005,
0.4610600471496582,
-0.6020197868347168,
0.06728048622608185,
-0.2974730134010315,
-1.0782362222671509,
-0.44266030192375183,
0.15881766378879547,
-0.5171523094177246,
0.3378961682319641,
-0.10338114202022552,
-0.44137585163116455,
0.04270829260349274,
-0.625399112701416,
-0.5281401872634888,
-0.11647859960794449,
-0.13412146270275116,
-0.1510268747806549,
0.23251716792583466,
-0.04695744067430496,
0.1727861911058426,
-0.05896677076816559,
0.25042295455932617,
-0.4406968653202057,
-0.5368136763572693,
0.05467994138598442,
-0.6378089189529419,
1.0037635564804077,
-0.09769095480442047,
-0.6896522045135498,
0.38295549154281616,
-0.42198479175567627,
0.10107066482305527,
0.01770593598484993,
-0.05199623852968216,
-0.5051382184028625,
0.2213367521762848,
-0.4490008056163788,
-0.06374738365411758,
0.3327347934246063,
-0.6460198163986206,
0.34529465436935425,
-0.18275241553783417,
0.8845711946487427,
1.0129272937774658,
-0.08996839821338654,
0.44597679376602173,
-0.4840139150619507,
0.4296087622642517,
-0.5404412150382996,
0.350035697221756,
-0.6004106402397156,
-0.463058739900589,
-0.5217755436897278,
-0.11241836100816727,
0.05851137265563011,
0.7156987190246582,
-0.39531567692756653,
0.2956385314464569,
-0.013812834396958351,
-0.5045570135116577,
-0.6000280380249023,
0.3942786753177643,
0.7462478280067444,
0.5092172026634216,
0.3961668610572815,
-0.2741171717643738,
-0.31661123037338257,
-0.5617539882659912,
-0.1958148032426834,
-0.3493804335594177,
0.052249304950237274,
0.2909791171550751,
0.30543053150177,
-0.21892555058002472,
0.6129138469696045,
-0.49091222882270813,
-0.15995539724826813,
-0.05948557332158089,
0.04733094200491905,
0.14174877107143402,
0.6575785875320435,
0.5113325119018555,
-0.6181446313858032,
-0.37247899174690247,
-0.016377782449126244,
-0.8196713924407959,
-0.17085357010364532,
0.07044905424118042,
0.07562949508428574,
0.5861489176750183,
1.0116385221481323,
-0.6624097228050232,
0.2725341320037842,
0.38112789392471313,
-0.09692072123289108,
0.5888702273368835,
-0.5066583156585693,
0.15961384773254395,
-0.6417586803436279,
0.08908256143331528,
-0.28141748905181885,
-0.2106737494468689,
-0.5697824358940125,
0.6887861490249634,
0.354707807302475,
0.36725860834121704,
-0.34965091943740845,
0.5872448682785034,
-0.34562599658966064,
0.2134220451116562,
-0.28290823101997375,
0.13662715256214142,
-0.13825468719005585,
0.42685312032699585,
-0.14279590547084808,
0.8330070376396179,
0.5565978288650513,
-0.1653479039669037,
0.3956408202648163,
0.008195260539650917,
-0.42961689829826355,
0.297066330909729,
-0.8538433909416199,
0.4597916007041931,
-0.12928174436092377,
0.19452530145645142,
-1.0653551816940308,
-0.17162646353244781,
0.26309263706207275,
-0.1626162976026535,
0.6017637252807617,
-0.4376361668109894,
-0.6756829023361206,
-0.23762796819210052,
-0.40972161293029785,
0.055128518491983414,
0.7261877655982971,
-0.36537814140319824,
0.4579997658729553,
0.2994902431964874,
-0.048060979694128036,
-0.6710909008979797,
-0.6455169916152954,
0.04629413038492203,
-0.12038656324148178,
-0.07101286947727203,
0.13786160945892334,
-0.37680625915527344,
-0.29033270478248596,
-0.10712821781635284,
-0.37120598554611206,
-0.2928987741470337,
0.20798622071743011,
0.7063161134719849,
0.2853340208530426,
-0.29275771975517273,
-0.019826719537377357,
0.1402648538351059,
0.18874937295913696,
0.3717373013496399,
-0.24615909159183502,
0.3671494424343109,
-0.05678961053490639,
-0.5480713248252869,
-0.5027526617050171,
0.12815259397029877,
0.7775804996490479,
-0.10293194651603699,
0.940171480178833,
0.3318812847137451,
-0.07748637348413467,
0.00613373052328825,
-0.635704755783081,
-0.18944336473941803,
-0.5167039632797241,
0.32940369844436646,
-0.014545552432537079,
-0.9941797852516174,
0.4561850130558014,
0.21389015018939972,
0.471936970949173,
-0.018174897879362106,
0.30101683735847473,
-0.1710483431816101,
0.9959462285041809,
0.8330750465393066,
-0.5638289451599121,
0.721540093421936,
-0.02670593373477459,
0.3558027744293213,
-0.7070165276527405,
-0.18352483212947845,
-0.5680164098739624,
-0.14780284464359283,
-0.647922933101654,
-0.4220794439315796,
0.07362721115350723,
0.27394264936447144,
-0.4749842584133148,
0.39031246304512024,
-0.03302996978163719,
0.7420852780342102,
0.4901497960090637,
0.18354755640029907,
0.22773467004299164,
-0.13230247795581818,
-0.05317606404423714,
0.249799907207489,
-0.7963423728942871,
-0.320068359375,
1.1648287773132324,
0.32343789935112,
0.9147941470146179,
0.09993376582860947,
0.6118638515472412,
0.3057684898376465,
0.5990038514137268,
-0.7184534072875977,
0.510181188583374,
-0.2799069881439209,
-0.6658539175987244,
-0.18050143122673035,
-0.63603675365448,
-0.6088315844535828,
-0.06154170632362366,
0.02487494982779026,
-0.9928969740867615,
-0.33668309450149536,
0.3196806311607361,
-0.5319435596466064,
0.6832458972930908,
-0.9583039879798889,
0.7764012217521667,
-0.14083577692508698,
-0.44587257504463196,
-0.4177156984806061,
-0.7580811381340027,
0.46324723958969116,
-0.2653016149997711,
0.23407131433486938,
0.2936263680458069,
-0.17527174949645996,
0.3133859932422638,
-0.18727156519889832,
1.0899251699447632,
0.00322726764716208,
-0.34802281856536865,
0.18358029425144196,
0.31857335567474365,
0.4792018532752991,
-0.340472549200058,
-0.08923661708831787,
0.23689186573028564,
-0.24749712646007538,
-0.3279980421066284,
-0.6839361190795898,
1.0703603029251099,
-1.0233590602874756,
-1.1016755104064941,
0.10455066710710526,
-0.6303824782371521,
-0.1316503882408142,
0.46277105808258057,
0.13997678458690643,
0.6393832564353943,
0.05848792940378189,
0.3429994285106659,
1.0299006700515747,
-0.3092074692249298,
0.5200510025024414,
0.5590494871139526,
-0.3324248790740967,
-0.24919159710407257,
0.8404187560081482,
0.3379741907119751,
0.5185959339141846,
0.38212665915489197,
0.12120140343904495,
-0.3682771921157837,
-0.49039357900619507,
-0.6515341401100159,
0.07978023588657379,
-0.6690676212310791,
-0.13055069744586945,
-0.7296004891395569,
-0.44219523668289185,
-0.30346226692199707,
-0.25674378871917725,
-0.45426103472709656,
-0.3292522132396698,
-0.17191284894943237,
-0.08187457919120789,
0.4112727642059326,
1.1289827823638916,
0.033043861389160156,
0.2746581733226776,
-0.8347082138061523,
0.0725594013929367,
0.2972525656223297,
0.5683483481407166,
0.23522253334522247,
-0.7173080444335938,
0.014314387924969196,
0.014693626202642918,
-0.45386818051338196,
-0.691504716873169,
-0.18683327734470367,
-0.07111486792564392,
0.8088260889053345,
0.6864935159683228,
0.2857816219329834,
0.5072547793388367,
-0.6783791184425354,
0.5345436334609985,
0.1576918065547943,
-1.0607924461364746,
0.22742776572704315,
-0.39489105343818665,
0.33943960070610046,
0.2822341322898865,
0.5584495067596436,
-0.5658900737762451,
-0.6057875752449036,
-0.3980582356452942,
-1.0007929801940918,
0.6866501569747925,
0.12280722707509995,
0.4261128902435303,
0.2391437143087387,
0.39641255140304565,
0.06687866896390915,
0.4861000180244446,
-0.5165801048278809,
-0.3016212284564972,
-0.10213790088891983,
-0.03821611404418945,
-0.15818870067596436,
-0.2910776734352112,
-0.15376324951648712,
-0.054514650255441666,
0.6318551898002625,
0.25349530577659607,
-0.017332643270492554,
-0.19098667800426483,
-0.07687105238437653,
-0.4380641579627991,
0.20736613869667053,
0.8567420244216919,
0.8740217089653015,
-0.17358267307281494,
-0.000058142377383774146,
0.19573841989040375,
-0.2802635431289673,
-0.013421214185655117,
-0.020195461809635162,
-0.47013431787490845,
-0.45850974321365356,
0.6221508979797363,
0.8105095624923706,
0.26458218693733215,
-0.8060164451599121,
0.24183279275894165,
0.11132603883743286,
0.05525984615087509,
-0.1287413239479065,
0.7042756676673889,
-0.0075070904567837715,
0.26515066623687744,
0.2025671899318695,
0.04210522025823593,
-0.06739994883537292,
-0.6345889568328857,
0.2886325418949127,
0.3919517397880554,
-0.6952602863311768,
-0.18515048921108246,
0.6141226887702942,
-0.049963679164648056,
-0.5270185470581055,
0.7226511240005493,
0.09942983835935593,
-0.599622905254364,
0.689030110836029,
0.38494059443473816,
0.7433695793151855,
-0.3966595530509949,
0.11569839715957642,
0.10949479788541794,
0.5720829367637634,
-0.19561614096164703,
-0.09298659861087799,
-0.20765572786331177,
-0.5807746052742004,
-0.6136592626571655,
-0.028474003076553345,
-0.6130130887031555,
0.22816401720046997,
-0.5377630591392517,
-0.10106165707111359,
-0.901052713394165,
0.15544337034225464,
-0.12980608642101288,
-0.12812116742134094,
-0.05076819658279419,
-0.0381753072142601,
0.2390209138393402,
1.055073857307434,
-0.5312120318412781,
1.0425562858581543,
0.7420870661735535,
-0.20774798095226288,
-0.8258011341094971,
0.18681474030017853,
0.3647618889808655,
-0.764958381652832,
0.2525983452796936,
0.3944163918495178,
-0.19765028357505798,
-0.10356726497411728,
-0.8322497010231018,
-0.6437158584594727,
0.788274347782135,
0.3916004002094269,
-0.7319797873497009,
0.038324985653162,
-0.4660419523715973,
0.48897841572761536,
-0.15286105871200562,
0.2701244652271271,
0.4858144223690033,
0.3147355020046234,
0.24543122947216034,
-0.8679264187812805,
-0.0014285518554970622,
0.012684818357229233,
-0.3611011803150177,
0.4587140381336212,
-0.6573574542999268,
0.795052707195282,
-0.47178536653518677,
0.09480895102024078,
0.4249024987220764,
0.3646869361400604,
0.2528780996799469,
0.15357184410095215,
0.43436479568481445,
0.5506852865219116,
0.6014134883880615,
0.2410174459218979,
1.0280213356018066,
-0.3531027138233185,
0.13421235978603363,
1.610267996788025,
-0.3991568088531494,
0.8919868469238281,
0.3148011267185211,
0.1728413850069046,
0.4826832711696625,
0.2984946370124817,
0.1328541785478592,
0.4356062412261963,
0.16974769532680511,
0.009349091909825802,
-0.08802274614572525,
-0.1280488818883896,
-0.3604815602302551,
0.24566936492919922,
0.27398499846458435,
-0.3498494029045105,
-0.3790631890296936,
-0.21340928971767426,
0.4974414110183716,
0.11511041969060898,
-0.566653311252594,
0.700706422328949,
0.1317628026008606,
-0.7567840814590454,
0.7097533941268921,
0.0025859528686851263,
0.3356042206287384,
-0.5172054767608643,
-0.11801149696111679,
-0.40830063819885254,
0.16943658888339996,
-0.07231967896223068,
-1.0347651243209839,
0.16668428480625153,
0.2521669268608093,
-0.13576386868953705,
-0.47215691208839417,
0.3941092789173126,
-0.3225700855255127,
-0.0718764215707779,
0.5996120572090149,
0.17942722141742706,
0.11002408713102341,
-0.12590450048446655,
-0.7165124416351318,
0.26450783014297485,
0.12693731486797333,
-0.26947909593582153,
0.3656020760536194,
0.4622499346733093,
-0.18704141676425934,
1.0131876468658447,
0.376264750957489,
-0.0976032167673111,
0.1691449135541916,
-0.08302737772464752,
0.9895741939544678,
-0.48147115111351013,
-0.3215472996234894,
-0.9416393637657166,
0.2268468290567398,
0.04538293927907944,
-0.12237239629030228,
0.8781430721282959,
0.1399516612291336,
0.9778399467468262,
0.28161850571632385,
0.5024588108062744,
-0.09476630389690399,
0.08214947581291199,
-0.49987536668777466,
1.0516630411148071,
-0.6331428289413452,
0.25925809144973755,
-0.26943954825401306,
-0.8299831748008728,
-0.23387795686721802,
0.46840476989746094,
-0.5932241678237915,
0.09181711822748184,
0.4572020471096039,
0.7673251032829285,
-0.07194662094116211,
0.2244538962841034,
0.505524754524231,
0.695363461971283,
0.2098907232284546,
0.6298297047615051,
0.7515882849693298,
-0.09715143591165543,
0.40258267521858215,
-0.014659219421446323,
-0.22713717818260193,
-0.16926996409893036,
-0.8286051154136658,
-0.9161655902862549,
-0.19567333161830902,
-0.3393957018852234,
-0.19338756799697876,
0.35955774784088135,
1.0869317054748535,
0.7522007822990417,
-0.9786846041679382,
-0.3195023834705353,
-0.22385574877262115,
0.62333083152771,
-0.1224241778254509,
-0.07429856806993484,
0.04638725146651268,
-0.3532503545284271,
-0.5839176774024963,
0.5921099781990051,
0.3762168288230896,
-0.060553520917892456,
-0.40288254618644714,
-0.022474072873592377,
-0.06672833114862442,
0.16578532755374908,
0.5388699769973755,
0.4390907883644104,
-0.7519745230674744,
-0.39419233798980713,
-0.05839253216981888,
-0.41873300075531006,
-0.1298711746931076,
0.7595484852790833,
-0.41617709398269653,
0.44594767689704895,
0.3664759397506714,
0.6507023572921753,
-0.00875141192227602,
-0.14880958199501038,
0.7187185287475586,
-0.4473041594028473,
-0.03569939360022545,
-0.12539221346378326,
0.1769598424434662,
0.2179718166589737,
-0.3132011294364929,
0.295580118894577,
-0.057662781327962875,
-0.7322059869766235,
-0.8020719885826111,
0.25103703141212463,
-0.4290330410003662,
-0.5994901657104492,
0.9577676653862,
-0.7162340879440308,
-0.3379477560520172,
-0.05565936490893364,
-0.13675576448440552,
0.07091254740953445,
-0.6179013252258301,
0.9747109413146973,
0.6633343696594238,
0.04490533098578453,
-0.466874361038208,
-0.7888047695159912,
0.3890080153942108,
0.363595187664032,
-0.47895801067352295,
0.2937920093536377,
0.5685517191886902,
0.3930779993534088,
-0.06540396809577942,
0.3028184771537781,
0.07660030573606491,
0.0590875968337059,
-0.25538504123687744,
-0.1205747202038765,
-0.2037155032157898,
-0.6051161885261536,
-0.520673930644989,
0.25372785329818726,
0.0507725365459919,
0.027572069317102432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03300v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03300v3 | DeepSeekMath: Pushing the Limits of Mathematical Reasoning in Open Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:55:32 | 2024-04-27T15:25:53 | Zhihong Shao, Peiyi Wang, Qihao Zhu, Runxin Xu, Junxiao Song, Xiao Bi, Haowei Zhang, Mingchuan Zhang, Y. K. Li, Y. Wu, Daya Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning poses a significant challenge for language models due
to its complex and structured nature. In this paper, we introduce DeepSeekMath
7B, which continues pre-training DeepSeek-Coder-Base-v1.5 7B with 120B
math-related tokens sourced from Common Crawl, together with natural language
and code data. DeepSeekMath 7B has achieved an impressive score of 51.7% on the
competition-level MATH benchmark without relying on external toolkits and
voting techniques, approaching the performance level of Gemini-Ultra and GPT-4.
Self-consistency over 64 samples from DeepSeekMath 7B achieves 60.9% on MATH.
The mathematical reasoning capability of DeepSeekMath is attributed to two key
factors: First, we harness the significant potential of publicly available web
data through a meticulously engineered data selection pipeline. Second, we
introduce Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO), a variant of Proximal
Policy Optimization (PPO), that enhances mathematical reasoning abilities while
concurrently optimizing the memory usage of PPO. | [
-0.4776722192764282,
-0.49621209502220154,
0.6639270782470703,
0.2836390435695648,
-0.20750465989112854,
0.04365940019488335,
-0.3351396918296814,
-0.18851926922798157,
-0.5499173998832703,
0.504562258720398,
-0.6081172227859497,
-0.5128661394119263,
-0.5496914386749268,
-0.2781742811203003,
0.08084483444690704,
0.787796139717102,
-0.15624646842479706,
0.011915956623852253,
-0.24757803976535797,
0.05268412455916405,
-0.2987329661846161,
-0.6431486010551453,
-0.4524227976799011,
-0.4201658070087433,
0.24548698961734772,
0.39444437623023987,
0.9835854172706604,
0.3072820007801056,
0.7936545610427856,
0.2524662911891937,
0.1434696912765503,
0.08780095726251602,
-0.48473694920539856,
0.13250483572483063,
-0.5051299929618835,
-0.4374317228794098,
-0.5096150636672974,
-0.05094951018691063,
0.3604225516319275,
0.5997331142425537,
-0.3155139684677124,
-0.010917636565864086,
-0.26828810572624207,
0.8290532231330872,
-0.8196565508842468,
0.25864508748054504,
-0.6657335162162781,
0.03534147888422012,
-0.3414818048477173,
0.42474353313446045,
-0.06687997281551361,
-0.6068936586380005,
0.25449004769325256,
-0.6220143437385559,
0.035904597491025925,
-0.3887995481491089,
0.6897199749946594,
0.24866043031215668,
-0.0408950075507164,
-0.41244104504585266,
-0.563783586025238,
0.9233895540237427,
-0.8152213096618652,
0.5035451054573059,
0.6868689656257629,
0.744594931602478,
-0.13790978491306305,
-0.7401598691940308,
-0.5421979427337646,
-0.2825073003768921,
0.3202746510505676,
0.011414462700486183,
-0.19276218116283417,
-0.08008038252592087,
0.24977770447731018,
0.5083627700805664,
-0.4620949625968933,
-0.07307998090982437,
-0.5087729096412659,
-0.22422410547733307,
0.6353042125701904,
0.06087842211127281,
0.1233353316783905,
0.1797388195991516,
0.07141220569610596,
-0.1242842972278595,
-0.5590671896934509,
-0.04395032674074173,
0.5153136849403381,
0.11111766844987869,
0.026676874607801437,
0.5790756940841675,
-0.37770432233810425,
0.43628981709480286,
-0.4027467668056488,
0.19084161520004272,
0.3149227499961853,
-0.19895251095294952,
-0.3332342207431793,
0.012854411266744137,
0.6771612763404846,
0.02839258313179016,
0.669806718826294,
0.04890304431319237,
-0.11477309465408325,
0.538112223148346,
0.09648226946592331,
-0.8875865936279297,
-0.4950683116912842,
-0.03261154517531395,
-0.17232370376586914,
-0.2268042266368866,
-0.026411250233650208,
-0.9797623157501221,
-0.274537056684494,
-0.6099464297294617,
0.21927717328071594,
-0.5898329019546509,
-0.3322361409664154,
0.6594280004501343,
0.1357133537530899,
-0.10945703834295273,
0.6052030324935913,
-0.7381682991981506,
0.31101754307746887,
1.0866198539733887,
0.5515506267547607,
0.22500889003276825,
-0.26167136430740356,
-0.4303836524486542,
0.0229684729129076,
-0.44970011711120605,
0.6278021335601807,
-0.9934402108192444,
-0.25215622782707214,
-0.16653025150299072,
-0.5776592493057251,
-0.0700237900018692,
-0.5818074345588684,
0.7655847072601318,
-0.2815263271331787,
0.5085052847862244,
-0.05992773547768593,
-0.5960118770599365,
-0.21586163341999054,
0.27980563044548035,
-0.34259435534477234,
0.8194010257720947,
0.23591160774230957,
-0.4015354812145233,
0.24820636212825775,
-0.8247038722038269,
-0.2549220323562622,
-0.09158763289451599,
-0.2821923792362213,
-0.2244536280632019,
0.4859204888343811,
0.4559408128261566,
0.24569597840309143,
-0.48822221159935,
0.3125878572463989,
-0.6553076505661011,
-0.15278145670890808,
0.0019422632176429033,
-0.4477384686470032,
0.5142663717269897,
0.4455763101577759,
-0.2889982759952545,
0.050666313618421555,
-0.7623298168182373,
0.15866023302078247,
0.32832977175712585,
0.13433194160461426,
-0.4106651842594147,
-0.04390580952167511,
-0.6281180381774902,
0.3651900589466095,
0.141251340508461,
-0.3955240845680237,
0.4176889657974243,
-0.5109199285507202,
0.4716448485851288,
1.1017755270004272,
-0.374386727809906,
0.3944959342479706,
0.10889744758605957,
0.6490123271942139,
-0.14696519076824188,
0.4757572114467621,
0.14994387328624725,
-0.5499522089958191,
-0.4641711115837097,
-0.23612003028392792,
0.3272020220756531,
0.3862706422805786,
-0.38990432024002075,
0.23529033362865448,
-0.19941294193267822,
-0.6297709345817566,
-0.708042562007904,
0.21163992583751678,
0.425326943397522,
0.67659592628479,
0.34451937675476074,
0.04949289187788963,
-0.24370235204696655,
-0.8581151962280273,
-0.318258136510849,
0.15186606347560883,
-0.05057739093899727,
0.40507203340530396,
0.37874239683151245,
-0.4342772960662842,
0.6889054775238037,
-0.8522522449493408,
-0.29708775877952576,
-0.17129187285900116,
-0.19462822377681732,
0.7183214426040649,
0.4009915292263031,
0.43700671195983887,
-0.6259575486183167,
-0.4445442855358124,
0.032694198191165924,
-0.6827189922332764,
-0.26324474811553955,
0.30838608741760254,
-0.45873671770095825,
0.02984626218676567,
0.3092767596244812,
-0.7460607290267944,
0.4112647771835327,
0.6209513545036316,
-0.3846522271633148,
0.6113328337669373,
-0.16230998933315277,
-0.16696885228157043,
-0.7173980474472046,
-0.1253732293844223,
-0.2446807324886322,
0.14543034136295319,
-0.1813598871231079,
0.3056776225566864,
-0.1525963395833969,
-0.38878878951072693,
-0.2284574657678604,
0.6195356249809265,
-0.16590073704719543,
0.14175733923912048,
-0.04267243295907974,
-0.12666399776935577,
-0.09168651700019836,
0.3787553012371063,
-0.31634005904197693,
0.8944156765937805,
0.8645616769790649,
-0.679709792137146,
0.5017979145050049,
0.06007228419184685,
-0.3735939860343933,
0.2821616530418396,
-0.6652804017066956,
0.30288293957710266,
0.037236325442790985,
0.07228872925043106,
-0.5514718890190125,
-0.11553607136011124,
0.20439413189888,
-0.51878422498703,
0.11077151447534561,
-0.2447977364063263,
-0.5556885004043579,
-0.40007951855659485,
-0.12402870506048203,
0.5079039335250854,
0.7777279019355774,
-0.4499376118183136,
0.6405863761901855,
0.29769769310951233,
-0.09174444526433945,
-0.3409087359905243,
-0.3415316343307495,
-0.2445589154958725,
-0.12040434777736664,
-0.7725636959075928,
-0.027428194880485535,
-0.05364936217665672,
-0.4945911169052124,
0.20834222435951233,
-0.4790004789829254,
0.020414192229509354,
-0.030504466965794563,
-0.015029237605631351,
0.1564006805419922,
-0.36688321828842163,
0.10136190056800842,
0.14612038433551788,
-0.5469785332679749,
0.1829788237810135,
-0.6450896263122559,
0.8842157125473022,
-0.3375576436519623,
-0.5020207762718201,
-0.1616307497024536,
0.17742261290550232,
0.35159480571746826,
-0.4341350495815277,
0.46358832716941833,
0.31325599551200867,
-0.44862961769104004,
0.003517393721267581,
-0.34889909625053406,
0.04493432492017746,
-0.49636825919151306,
0.19664786756038666,
-0.8781790733337402,
-0.8103736042976379,
0.32078737020492554,
-0.30785420536994934,
0.07540743798017502,
0.8334962725639343,
0.5928505659103394,
0.27453097701072693,
1.2069095373153687,
0.23019078373908997,
-0.09760583937168121,
0.03565295413136482,
-0.17869427800178528,
0.24089135229587555,
-0.5714773535728455,
-0.2888864278793335,
-0.6226316094398499,
-0.05775828659534454,
-0.4130009114742279,
-0.5240960121154785,
0.09802517294883728,
0.4668833911418915,
-0.573520839214325,
0.1511792540550232,
-0.5892608761787415,
0.7293210625648499,
0.6943380832672119,
0.018754711374640465,
0.03311484307050705,
0.17078357934951782,
-0.4512559175491333,
-0.24991735816001892,
-0.37674111127853394,
-0.3037720024585724,
1.151023507118225,
0.3040813207626343,
0.9737939834594727,
0.326323539018631,
0.5934770107269287,
0.08619972318410873,
0.15970851480960846,
-0.4407099485397339,
0.6286386251449585,
-0.39468228816986084,
-0.5790818929672241,
-0.2901317775249481,
-0.9004073739051819,
-0.8521518707275391,
0.23741412162780762,
0.1410096287727356,
-0.7354187965393066,
-0.11082221567630768,
0.2479124367237091,
-0.16658401489257812,
0.22056441009044647,
-0.7816211581230164,
0.9847663640975952,
-0.36765575408935547,
-0.33594459295272827,
-0.6390107274055481,
-0.2816065549850464,
0.3777879476547241,
-0.038073018193244934,
0.38906624913215637,
-0.5702672004699707,
0.03428652137517929,
0.2156287282705307,
-0.4978610575199127,
0.4008159339427948,
-0.2573096752166748,
-0.2102203071117401,
0.20311705768108368,
0.47169381380081177,
0.396949827671051,
0.1516992151737213,
-0.03646166995167732,
0.42133596539497375,
-0.37325164675712585,
-0.6138670444488525,
-0.7569664120674133,
0.8671122193336487,
-0.7925133109092712,
-0.6578297019004822,
-0.43563148379325867,
-0.27828532457351685,
-0.519200325012207,
0.3434087038040161,
0.05089479312300682,
0.4940689206123352,
0.3500213027000427,
0.28646430373191833,
0.6234999895095825,
-0.30900639295578003,
0.14450812339782715,
-0.014935728162527084,
-0.42631739377975464,
-0.7466112375259399,
1.1317247152328491,
-0.17815515398979187,
0.236500546336174,
0.5340490937232971,
0.9115725159645081,
-0.6115712523460388,
-0.4294328987598419,
-0.2418123334646225,
0.1458664834499359,
-0.6550257205963135,
-0.1968940794467926,
-0.4315546452999115,
-0.26875776052474976,
-0.7483410835266113,
-0.08418218046426773,
-0.5360007882118225,
-0.5760778784751892,
0.031841784715652466,
0.08181348443031311,
0.16714689135551453,
0.326569139957428,
-0.2590595483779907,
0.11623363941907883,
-0.8010185360908508,
0.3658469617366791,
0.43350446224212646,
0.7236233353614807,
-0.080720916390419,
-0.26429370045661926,
0.14918512105941772,
0.06466342508792877,
-0.13884234428405762,
-0.4575718641281128,
0.12888900935649872,
0.033755555748939514,
0.6793595552444458,
0.43536847829818726,
-0.02526969462633133,
0.8082433938980103,
-0.4915047883987427,
0.2709631621837616,
0.3820415735244751,
-0.8982972502708435,
0.8589994311332703,
-0.345571368932724,
0.4319809079170227,
0.5726149082183838,
0.309520959854126,
-0.10519815236330032,
-0.0005708642420358956,
-0.6635124683380127,
-0.634519636631012,
0.3361506462097168,
0.622088611125946,
0.2942924499511719,
0.18209801614284515,
0.20611953735351562,
0.15855123102664948,
0.32954683899879456,
-0.11016951501369476,
0.21555635333061218,
-0.40746793150901794,
-0.3915339410305023,
-0.09602082520723343,
-0.17710942029953003,
-0.07233039289712906,
-0.5766830444335938,
0.5420060157775879,
-0.0971670001745224,
0.040475886315107346,
0.05625268071889877,
0.04759423807263374,
0.21637263894081116,
0.2365664392709732,
0.9674283862113953,
1.1823195219039917,
-0.18662716448307037,
0.08653214573860168,
-0.1767401099205017,
-0.7316767573356628,
-0.1854202002286911,
0.5615270733833313,
0.03653385862708092,
-0.2254166454076767,
0.3537423610687256,
0.803290843963623,
0.048283569514751434,
-0.8136447668075562,
0.1385827511548996,
-0.045785367488861084,
-0.27216920256614685,
-0.18267032504081726,
0.3149280250072479,
-0.2081596851348877,
0.2675044536590576,
0.2712162137031555,
-0.13254763185977936,
0.05797259882092476,
-0.39606383442878723,
0.18655644357204437,
0.22053876519203186,
-0.23066401481628418,
-0.28007972240448,
0.6715611219406128,
0.14179830253124237,
-0.23467455804347992,
0.6817889213562012,
-0.0944337248802185,
-0.7708297371864319,
0.37907251715660095,
0.31602051854133606,
0.907925009727478,
-0.2920131981372833,
-0.08120624721050262,
0.19023628532886505,
0.32557252049446106,
0.09461389482021332,
0.43209174275398254,
0.022883642464876175,
-0.6172077655792236,
-0.6825080513954163,
-0.7968074679374695,
-0.46519702672958374,
0.13227497041225433,
-0.29978781938552856,
0.1579657644033432,
-0.6653477549552917,
0.016195878386497498,
-0.0014074539067223668,
0.28721126914024353,
-0.6077256202697754,
0.23851561546325684,
0.07862496376037598,
1.0287591218948364,
-0.18704938888549805,
0.7071902751922607,
0.6772135496139526,
-0.22243285179138184,
-0.6053706407546997,
-0.24225571751594543,
-0.09971508383750916,
-1.1296383142471313,
0.4815281331539154,
0.1769438087940216,
0.09654619544744492,
-0.08659166842699051,
-0.6333871483802795,
-0.6944127082824707,
0.5207520127296448,
0.7242054343223572,
-0.8175888061523438,
0.021389292553067207,
0.22347769141197205,
0.3655921220779419,
-0.06984203308820724,
0.01013275422155857,
0.3862040638923645,
0.43075382709503174,
0.40948206186294556,
-0.9042704105377197,
-0.15478073060512543,
-0.2335463911294937,
-0.21186111867427826,
0.6163384318351746,
-0.38521143794059753,
1.0023561716079712,
-0.2243395745754242,
0.29787299036979675,
-0.21177901327610016,
0.6139222383499146,
0.7325923442840576,
0.37256237864494324,
0.4878333508968353,
1.0995960235595703,
0.6663591861724854,
-0.06672819703817368,
1.2495144605636597,
0.002290438860654831,
0.3999391496181488,
1.2301723957061768,
-0.3908332288265228,
0.492148220539093,
0.1278190016746521,
-0.3701860010623932,
0.46446898579597473,
0.4508047103881836,
0.034024398773908615,
0.5821256041526794,
0.4171905517578125,
-0.3209981322288513,
-0.5888676047325134,
0.09901769459247589,
-0.7860413193702698,
0.38614213466644287,
0.4003637135028839,
-0.024043820798397064,
-0.6219033002853394,
-0.25512850284576416,
0.22443179786205292,
0.2832055985927582,
-0.4877445101737976,
0.3863048851490021,
0.2661210298538208,
-0.3917330503463745,
0.17758849263191223,
-0.13614672422409058,
0.21176272630691528,
-0.8364462852478027,
-0.15090779960155487,
-0.3788597881793976,
0.922435998916626,
0.14345356822013855,
-0.94320148229599,
0.3246270716190338,
-0.061744753271341324,
0.048594653606414795,
-0.06360597163438797,
0.8512893915176392,
-0.020514555275440216,
-0.7970066070556641,
0.0795823261141777,
0.3189491331577301,
0.09100953489542007,
-0.6572422981262207,
-0.8813337683677673,
0.07210765033960342,
-0.23234286904335022,
-0.1613357663154602,
0.40475791692733765,
0.9186848998069763,
-0.12264358252286911,
0.8362141251564026,
1.1880935430526733,
0.09515807777643204,
0.13366740942001343,
0.4020533561706543,
1.0526337623596191,
-0.7159807085990906,
-0.5419670343399048,
-1.1538459062576294,
0.11759360134601593,
-0.3011036217212677,
-0.6103811264038086,
0.8500211834907532,
0.738146185874939,
1.0363212823867798,
0.07531760632991791,
0.49419453740119934,
0.1774713397026062,
0.392127126455307,
-0.6447370052337646,
0.47015371918678284,
-0.3746933043003082,
-0.059146612882614136,
-0.38202524185180664,
-0.9332816004753113,
-0.4070882499217987,
0.8030412793159485,
-0.46633633971214294,
-0.06692381948232651,
0.39694541692733765,
0.178717240691185,
-0.32404857873916626,
-0.005787829402834177,
0.2541474997997284,
-0.0020359663758426905,
0.6143977046012878,
0.9453035593032837,
0.9475293755531311,
-0.08770430833101273,
0.6417545080184937,
-0.3716026544570923,
-0.22568774223327637,
0.10801933705806732,
-0.7656559944152832,
-1.0411245822906494,
0.05017830803990364,
-0.19948381185531616,
-0.39528921246528625,
-0.11860726028680801,
0.7125155925750732,
0.6419892907142639,
-0.7930289506912231,
-0.02651815302670002,
-0.6009913682937622,
0.1932888627052307,
-0.04767881706357002,
-0.2777705490589142,
0.3551925718784332,
-0.5537263751029968,
-0.5328992605209351,
0.1641918420791626,
0.3494934141635895,
-0.05444268137216568,
-0.27469077706336975,
-0.28146445751190186,
0.07899060845375061,
0.03962771221995354,
0.6343285441398621,
0.1788480281829834,
-0.5078899264335632,
0.10842117667198181,
0.013128981925547123,
0.12550842761993408,
-0.18059736490249634,
0.9728487730026245,
-0.7847675085067749,
0.40301382541656494,
0.5593170523643494,
0.9094092845916748,
0.3976728618144989,
-0.11361254751682281,
0.6731094717979431,
-0.15280558168888092,
0.2172366976737976,
0.6089814305305481,
0.25112253427505493,
-0.06118045002222061,
-0.04420958459377289,
0.8540548086166382,
0.5477234125137329,
-0.3549584448337555,
-1.0392967462539673,
0.2787873446941376,
-0.5999857187271118,
-0.4068618416786194,
1.053958535194397,
-0.07159128040075302,
-0.10835543274879456,
0.25976794958114624,
-0.1880040168762207,
-0.3036755919456482,
-0.40857142210006714,
0.6385751962661743,
0.6875155568122864,
-0.10765432566404343,
-0.3690485954284668,
-0.5527617335319519,
0.38851797580718994,
0.2933538258075714,
-0.8786865472793579,
-0.05823774263262749,
0.4520108997821808,
-0.004119553603231907,
0.09957529604434967,
0.6036607027053833,
-0.16731137037277222,
0.12236671894788742,
-0.00444590300321579,
-0.2841505706310272,
-0.32051533460617065,
-0.4718075096607208,
-0.027053218334913254,
0.26057371497154236,
-0.3798215687274933,
-0.23554779589176178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03299v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03299v4 | GUARD: Role-playing to Generate Natural-language Jailbreakings to Test Guideline Adherence of Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:54:43 | 2024-05-30T21:14:26 | Haibo Jin, Ruoxi Chen, Andy Zhou, Yang Zhang, Haohan Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | The discovery of "jailbreaks" to bypass safety filters of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and harmful responses have encouraged the community to implement
safety measures. One major safety measure is to proactively test the LLMs with
jailbreaks prior to the release. Therefore, such testing will require a method
that can generate jailbreaks massively and efficiently. In this paper, we
follow a novel yet intuitive strategy to generate jailbreaks in the style of
the human generation. We propose a role-playing system that assigns four
different roles to the user LLMs to collaborate on new jailbreaks. Furthermore,
we collect existing jailbreaks and split them into different independent
characteristics using clustering frequency and semantic patterns sentence by
sentence. We organize these characteristics into a knowledge graph, making them
more accessible and easier to retrieve. Our system of different roles will
leverage this knowledge graph to generate new jailbreaks, which have proved
effective in inducing LLMs to generate unethical or guideline-violating
responses. In addition, we also pioneer a setting in our system that will
automatically follow the government-issued guidelines to generate jailbreaks to
test whether LLMs follow the guidelines accordingly. We refer to our system as
GUARD (Guideline Upholding through Adaptive Role-play Diagnostics). We have
empirically validated the effectiveness of GUARD on three cutting-edge
open-sourced LLMs (Vicuna-13B, LongChat-7B, and Llama-2-7B), as well as a
widely-utilized commercial LLM (ChatGPT). Moreover, our work extends to the
realm of vision language models (MiniGPT-v2 and Gemini Vision Pro), showcasing
GUARD's versatility and contributing valuable insights for the development of
safer, more reliable LLM-based applications across diverse modalities. | [
-0.3644983172416687,
-0.8647075891494751,
0.463657021522522,
0.3347872197628021,
-0.27084019780158997,
0.12956202030181885,
-0.03036642260849476,
-0.4462459683418274,
0.2150225043296814,
1.0383092164993286,
-0.5617866516113281,
-0.6036520600318909,
-0.2995317280292511,
0.07148328423500061,
-0.16266117990016937,
0.9604251384735107,
-0.0548420324921608,
-0.09649199992418289,
0.11850744485855103,
0.23853743076324463,
-0.827953040599823,
-0.49926406145095825,
-0.6346921920776367,
-0.25132742524147034,
0.38242489099502563,
0.5174276828765869,
0.4915963113307953,
0.6918359398841858,
0.472497820854187,
0.17367520928382874,
-0.0951918512582779,
0.3142182528972626,
-0.21535661816596985,
0.2579091191291809,
-0.1262817084789276,
-0.30132994055747986,
-0.4213016927242279,
0.0015092726098373532,
0.07401413470506668,
0.09485294669866562,
-0.2371654212474823,
-0.014914210885763168,
0.09383305162191391,
0.47538280487060547,
-0.518947184085846,
0.27738773822784424,
-0.4971366822719574,
0.02653503231704235,
-0.3390117585659027,
-0.24470913410186768,
-0.46441981196403503,
-0.37902167439460754,
0.018648741766810417,
-0.45596790313720703,
-0.047122370451688766,
0.08926840126514435,
0.5246215462684631,
-0.03484060615301132,
-0.26556381583213806,
-0.22994539141654968,
-0.6264844536781311,
0.33321720361709595,
-0.705257773399353,
0.09081026911735535,
0.5766175389289856,
0.44732704758644104,
-0.4164298474788666,
-0.31820353865623474,
-0.374054491519928,
-0.5095196962356567,
0.08437304198741913,
-0.003856122260913253,
0.1841413825750351,
0.09524378180503845,
0.13916170597076416,
-0.13691546022891998,
-0.3284558653831482,
0.1970927119255066,
-0.4063486158847809,
-0.3626030385494232,
0.8069233298301697,
0.04904833808541298,
0.4809129536151886,
-0.35027262568473816,
-0.39290642738342285,
-0.050453003495931625,
-1.063419222831726,
0.26866430044174194,
0.5470110774040222,
0.366281121969223,
-0.14180488884449005,
0.5349224805831909,
-0.020105289295315742,
0.6039915084838867,
-0.03902633860707283,
-0.2481764554977417,
-0.07207424193620682,
-0.19763578474521637,
0.03947744891047478,
0.42902493476867676,
0.765159547328949,
0.675360381603241,
0.5652734637260437,
-0.1380263715982437,
-0.16224607825279236,
0.06409986317157745,
0.375518262386322,
-0.6560719609260559,
-0.21187055110931396,
-0.2284470796585083,
-0.2924433648586273,
-0.868628740310669,
-0.09089744836091995,
-0.9392416477203369,
-0.9527621865272522,
-0.01321246474981308,
0.4547651410102844,
-0.6369766592979431,
-0.2668531537055969,
0.10482220351696014,
-0.03485148027539253,
0.26544228196144104,
0.02645145170390606,
-1.077712893486023,
0.5767284631729126,
0.5556355118751526,
0.8365023136138916,
-0.039922792464494705,
-0.29524150490760803,
-0.7133427262306213,
0.30347999930381775,
-0.34185531735420227,
0.5237696766853333,
-0.32602760195732117,
-0.49144333600997925,
-0.057988490909338,
-0.10566597431898117,
-0.08159273117780685,
-0.5171838402748108,
0.47747454047203064,
-0.4933287799358368,
-0.20249755680561066,
-0.05052059888839722,
-0.3914334774017334,
0.24430827796459198,
0.4411078989505768,
-0.5839503407478333,
0.7884828448295593,
-0.22756364941596985,
-0.5611268877983093,
0.4606011211872101,
-0.8950117230415344,
-0.4159502685070038,
-0.0053475587628781796,
0.007650203071534634,
-0.3041277527809143,
-0.24118462204933167,
0.3057616651058197,
0.23835471272468567,
-0.1711900234222412,
0.380956768989563,
-0.37358975410461426,
-0.37194111943244934,
0.2279936820268631,
-0.24031348526477814,
0.6903576850891113,
0.2498120218515396,
-0.42899027466773987,
0.112334243953228,
-0.3592599928379059,
-0.06834568828344345,
0.2050763964653015,
-0.2661815285682678,
-0.45448651909828186,
0.4016394317150116,
-0.1089554950594902,
0.17180943489074707,
0.008817858062684536,
-0.5437467694282532,
0.13771718740463257,
-0.27516937255859375,
0.6423229575157166,
0.9812892079353333,
0.25090491771698,
0.2550047039985657,
-0.21094433963298798,
0.612001895904541,
-0.11824453622102737,
0.49729281663894653,
-0.17190563678741455,
-0.36967357993125916,
-0.4588541090488434,
-0.14283190667629242,
0.05906578153371811,
0.87324059009552,
-0.5918819904327393,
0.7380574941635132,
0.005959079600870609,
-0.4222770929336548,
-0.26463595032691956,
0.41732364892959595,
0.472913533449173,
0.44003599882125854,
0.37115970253944397,
-0.5645977258682251,
-0.6609379649162292,
-0.7691249847412109,
-0.369456946849823,
-0.5696991682052612,
0.25461551547050476,
0.15083268284797668,
0.36108824610710144,
-0.2638832628726959,
1.0245215892791748,
-0.4754869043827057,
-0.3372030556201935,
-0.5856202840805054,
-0.3054865300655365,
0.06711483746767044,
0.4241845905780792,
0.5311620235443115,
-0.571815013885498,
-0.18183402717113495,
-0.28536456823349,
-0.6466507911682129,
-0.2949841022491455,
0.05630114674568176,
-0.2734289765357971,
0.03963687643408775,
0.7477065920829773,
-0.4711451828479767,
0.3987014591693878,
0.604514479637146,
-0.7360051870346069,
0.7406259179115295,
-0.14824099838733673,
-0.13029766082763672,
-1.1012965440750122,
0.03604752942919731,
0.09984569251537323,
-0.3512365520000458,
-0.71258145570755,
0.17448852956295013,
-0.09754351526498795,
0.03764255717396736,
-0.20857280492782593,
0.4942418336868286,
-0.25091442465782166,
0.07421448826789856,
-0.17237041890621185,
0.22016505897045135,
-0.19760259985923767,
0.08685994893312454,
-0.15271934866905212,
0.7125974893569946,
0.5070107579231262,
-0.5543314814567566,
0.4726680517196655,
0.29687631130218506,
-0.39285117387771606,
0.27145588397979736,
-0.6082261204719543,
0.0601222924888134,
0.08057500422000885,
0.22002887725830078,
-0.562526524066925,
-0.28059154748916626,
0.31860417127609253,
-0.014470054768025875,
0.012335765175521374,
-0.7274159789085388,
-0.6077923774719238,
-0.41039061546325684,
-0.2934011220932007,
-0.06917537748813629,
0.6745904684066772,
-0.41107767820358276,
0.2053142935037613,
0.7371793389320374,
-0.2444796860218048,
-0.5063613653182983,
-0.5498239398002625,
0.37582358717918396,
-0.576931893825531,
-0.8394247889518738,
0.3153645396232605,
-0.10033460706472397,
-0.35683175921440125,
-0.21148911118507385,
-0.24945856630802155,
-0.014019851572811604,
0.46985575556755066,
0.3014308214187622,
0.5427248477935791,
0.04002547636628151,
-0.04709106683731079,
-0.1073182001709938,
0.08887354284524918,
0.24137026071548462,
-0.22659289836883545,
0.7046654224395752,
-0.2613087594509125,
-0.236101895570755,
0.05372423678636551,
0.0572228729724884,
0.4405209720134735,
-0.5307531952857971,
0.5684535503387451,
0.21566437184810638,
-0.04630511626601219,
-0.3501266837120056,
-0.47263309359550476,
-0.288128137588501,
-0.5374650955200195,
0.02469981461763382,
-0.16958361864089966,
-1.0620276927947998,
0.46659183502197266,
-0.03881620615720749,
0.1324988305568695,
-0.130902498960495,
0.23556183278560638,
0.1127152368426323,
0.9131975769996643,
0.8273703455924988,
-0.06859709322452545,
0.6651225090026855,
0.1168675646185875,
0.36876118183135986,
-0.6796669363975525,
-0.22066235542297363,
-0.11236904561519623,
-0.17517469823360443,
-0.6393402814865112,
-0.3528355062007904,
0.4440845847129822,
0.4460376501083374,
-0.18293894827365875,
0.583794355392456,
-0.3384171426296234,
0.6374319791793823,
0.49740317463874817,
0.2258969396352768,
0.2839531898498535,
-0.17505310475826263,
-0.39921560883522034,
0.14644233882427216,
-0.36977750062942505,
-0.8720777630805969,
1.0458955764770508,
0.3128319978713989,
0.9462404251098633,
0.35426515340805054,
1.177414059638977,
0.46079084277153015,
0.2977698743343353,
-0.6252710223197937,
0.7957514524459839,
-0.046296220272779465,
-0.6135510206222534,
-0.2717772424221039,
-0.3490391969680786,
-0.7909852862358093,
0.057674847543239594,
-0.219620019197464,
-1.028304100036621,
-0.16176727414131165,
0.48230046033859253,
-0.369369775056839,
0.2046564370393753,
-0.8878728747367859,
1.0717228651046753,
-0.41363993287086487,
-0.5059768557548523,
-0.09498810023069382,
-0.6901763677597046,
0.7155908942222595,
0.0120660699903965,
0.3106807470321655,
-0.13298137485980988,
0.3224468529224396,
0.599772036075592,
-0.47960686683654785,
1.150337815284729,
-0.5315870046615601,
-0.0916992649435997,
0.4847583770751953,
0.3788239061832428,
0.5505433082580566,
0.34089207649230957,
0.1543937772512436,
-0.4627160429954529,
0.014942900277674198,
-0.04898525029420853,
-0.327489972114563,
0.6831730008125305,
-0.6063289046287537,
-0.8930454850196838,
-0.25732421875,
-0.36157146096229553,
-0.2957925796508789,
0.4084005057811737,
-0.00768376374617219,
0.2153172343969345,
-0.44541922211647034,
-0.12056592851877213,
0.8019163012504578,
-0.3054024875164032,
0.3898880183696747,
0.3818742632865906,
-0.5552486777305603,
-0.11263380944728851,
0.5595454573631287,
-0.016305752098560333,
0.21232977509498596,
-0.08278010040521622,
0.33244144916534424,
-0.17015966773033142,
-0.632073700428009,
-0.501192033290863,
0.018959544599056244,
-0.2318045198917389,
-0.16562038660049438,
-0.314750999212265,
-0.4871314764022827,
-0.531164288520813,
-0.09466943144798279,
-0.018048079684376717,
-0.2103368043899536,
0.2602657675743103,
-0.3412642776966095,
0.734332799911499,
0.6085476875305176,
-0.19676055014133453,
0.28958868980407715,
-0.775332510471344,
0.3510238826274872,
0.4275132715702057,
0.5114659070968628,
-0.44986164569854736,
-0.19818708300590515,
-0.06334233283996582,
-0.031187033280730247,
-0.3946911692619324,
-1.0658495426177979,
0.3285028636455536,
0.04985077679157257,
0.6924898028373718,
0.26469871401786804,
0.11490705609321594,
0.5380868315696716,
-0.681526780128479,
0.6117688417434692,
0.16748104989528656,
-1.0075693130493164,
0.752919614315033,
-0.6494113802909851,
-0.27500119805336,
0.6014700531959534,
-0.3745628595352173,
-0.8641613721847534,
-0.5183013677597046,
-0.4221414625644684,
-0.8806613683700562,
0.7305397391319275,
0.14771947264671326,
0.1810842603445053,
-0.062200479209423065,
0.27347636222839355,
-0.229161337018013,
0.06771630793809891,
-0.6741052269935608,
0.2155846506357193,
-0.2930258810520172,
-0.17199653387069702,
-0.05374017730355263,
-0.04459204152226448,
-0.3505316376686096,
0.14041990041732788,
0.44923630356788635,
-0.19221799075603485,
0.005878879688680172,
0.17377425730228424,
-0.2323095202445984,
0.11166372895240784,
0.4856312572956085,
0.4914032518863678,
0.3801862299442291,
-0.28523436188697815,
0.2977403700351715,
0.003370807506144047,
-0.7199174165725708,
0.223358154296875,
0.18579702079296112,
-0.45836493372917175,
-0.4095573127269745,
0.173855721950531,
0.7388763427734375,
-0.021673796698451042,
-0.8399253487586975,
0.486142635345459,
0.07319723814725876,
-0.08547317981719971,
-0.5486064553260803,
0.5760855078697205,
0.08700621873140335,
0.20429548621177673,
0.00055561593035236,
0.2594144344329834,
-0.11319084465503693,
-0.8087695240974426,
0.4368969202041626,
0.2252179980278015,
-0.4890234172344208,
-0.2338264435529709,
0.6695302128791809,
0.3881170451641083,
-0.4409772455692291,
0.45226988196372986,
-0.22554823756217957,
-0.5162790417671204,
0.6446822881698608,
0.6165329813957214,
0.8207414150238037,
-0.2347251921892166,
0.4526645541191101,
0.039969656616449356,
0.6782968044281006,
-0.4792947471141815,
0.19161005318164825,
0.2227819263935089,
-0.9822139143943787,
-0.5505414605140686,
-0.4420677721500397,
-0.19376158714294434,
0.06236916780471802,
-0.4122295677661896,
0.31965622305870056,
-0.7062381505966187,
-0.22266241908073425,
-0.2502327859401703,
-0.07394462823867798,
-0.3762713372707367,
-0.10078730434179306,
0.2959928810596466,
1.1868555545806885,
-0.8287877440452576,
0.9558096528053284,
0.5054470896720886,
-0.3511055111885071,
-0.8046020269393921,
0.08854340016841888,
0.2873140275478363,
-0.6766287088394165,
0.4384409785270691,
0.3767363727092743,
-0.20990340411663055,
-0.1626567393541336,
-0.6478325128555298,
-0.5814194083213806,
1.1582614183425903,
0.27289193868637085,
-0.41103994846343994,
-0.22809883952140808,
-0.03439286723732948,
0.5836459398269653,
-0.4677981734275818,
-0.2135377675294876,
0.8289353847503662,
0.5609471797943115,
-0.25718483328819275,
-0.7828155755996704,
0.2546634078025818,
-0.3802489936351776,
-0.17569878697395325,
0.336283802986145,
-0.5037305951118469,
0.30438297986984253,
-0.3986908495426178,
0.03555157408118248,
0.14225582778453827,
0.04771334305405617,
0.7712447643280029,
0.2026834785938263,
0.7346932888031006,
0.4137875437736511,
0.4323181211948395,
-0.03137502446770668,
0.8906418681144714,
-0.3398655354976654,
-0.10902602970600128,
1.047118902206421,
-0.5696339011192322,
0.6199121475219727,
0.5304883122444153,
0.405496209859848,
0.5960540175437927,
0.30747559666633606,
-0.2531358003616333,
0.656922459602356,
0.5266005396842957,
-0.2439415007829666,
-0.40689608454704285,
-0.07806937396526337,
0.07171052694320679,
0.4366685748100281,
0.36002907156944275,
-0.39109349250793457,
-0.1666295975446701,
-0.16318188607692719,
0.2989330589771271,
0.145920068025589,
-0.2352258563041687,
0.6504214406013489,
0.14455780386924744,
-0.82879638671875,
0.09629034250974655,
0.31860435009002686,
0.6530081629753113,
-0.8289870023727417,
-0.014578086324036121,
-0.2611164152622223,
0.21424531936645508,
-0.11539823561906815,
-0.9137022495269775,
0.1523454487323761,
0.6149436235427856,
0.1292697638273239,
-0.3984294533729553,
0.8116580843925476,
-0.21257804334163666,
-0.28122615814208984,
0.6283451318740845,
0.4046972692012787,
-0.06285686790943146,
0.25957903265953064,
-0.465117484331131,
-0.11512813717126846,
-0.09633712470531464,
-0.11893666535615921,
0.30497831106185913,
0.16556569933891296,
-0.5245087146759033,
0.7467110753059387,
0.7503589987754822,
0.28220170736312866,
0.3252251148223877,
0.11785411089658737,
0.9133356213569641,
-0.6123807430267334,
-0.5863170027732849,
-0.9991564154624939,
0.42279455065727234,
-0.360989511013031,
-0.31605982780456543,
0.7581990957260132,
0.44730332493782043,
0.6110590100288391,
0.18152210116386414,
0.9583643674850464,
-0.32738953828811646,
0.10994097590446472,
-0.7118546366691589,
0.8363975882530212,
0.00859870109707117,
0.5748009085655212,
-0.4961552321910858,
-0.6920369267463684,
-0.2910742461681366,
0.5364468693733215,
-0.3622152507305145,
-0.1619570553302765,
0.30799928307533264,
1.0189884901046753,
-0.09678451716899872,
-0.13142423331737518,
0.14297738671302795,
0.038400501012802124,
0.691723108291626,
0.5085195899009705,
0.8886651396751404,
-0.09433867037296295,
0.8354383111000061,
-0.08194481581449509,
-0.24690961837768555,
-0.206787109375,
-0.7998802065849304,
-0.9974560737609863,
-0.012435922399163246,
0.012036433443427086,
-0.4037627875804901,
0.33828771114349365,
0.9906161427497864,
0.7598893046379089,
-0.556679368019104,
-0.42325708270072937,
-0.4477710723876953,
0.011257252655923367,
-0.3684440553188324,
-0.23811447620391846,
-0.025235267356038094,
-0.21083557605743408,
-0.03581567853689194,
0.8121426701545715,
0.09783102571964264,
-0.019988663494586945,
-0.22540254890918732,
-0.20436057448387146,
0.0029613168444484472,
0.1545443832874298,
0.5401154160499573,
0.32083508372306824,
-0.5013374090194702,
-0.4735911786556244,
0.15829820930957794,
-0.07791876047849655,
-0.21431225538253784,
0.9293855428695679,
-0.6558864116668701,
0.43411123752593994,
0.35086947679519653,
0.40017884969711304,
0.45706313848495483,
-0.13286656141281128,
0.8175105452537537,
-0.7593306303024292,
0.00685040932148695,
0.058137375861406326,
0.3729957342147827,
0.18032068014144897,
-0.2697656452655792,
0.6017515659332275,
0.028539614751935005,
-0.45305415987968445,
-0.7157248258590698,
0.703976571559906,
-0.7025163173675537,
-0.15117090940475464,
1.091467261314392,
-0.1385304033756256,
-0.1954088658094406,
-0.26138734817504883,
-0.3385624587535858,
0.0656176432967186,
-0.5424337983131409,
1.0477917194366455,
0.4834696650505066,
-0.02626902051270008,
-0.28802210092544556,
-0.6016934514045715,
0.718666136264801,
-0.03305676579475403,
-0.9211940765380859,
0.35406970977783203,
0.4647601842880249,
0.641805112361908,
0.13403144478797913,
0.5429811477661133,
-0.32113203406333923,
0.20269882678985596,
-0.35757455229759216,
0.1197601705789566,
-0.28195643424987793,
-0.3325803875923157,
-0.0955752581357956,
-0.13368453085422516,
0.24650828540325165,
0.10437512397766113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03284v1 | Deal, or no deal (or who knows)? Forecasting Uncertainty in Conversations using Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:39:47 | 2024-02-05T18:39:47 | Anthony Sicilia, Hyunwoo Kim, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Malihe Alikhani, Jack Hessel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Effective interlocutors account for the uncertain goals, beliefs, and
emotions of others. But even the best human conversationalist cannot perfectly
anticipate the trajectory of a dialogue. How well can language models represent
inherent uncertainty in conversations? We propose FortUne Dial, an expansion of
the long-standing "conversation forecasting" task: instead of just accuracy,
evaluation is conducted with uncertainty-aware metrics, effectively enabling
abstention on individual instances. We study two ways in which language models
potentially represent outcome uncertainty (internally, using scores and
directly, using tokens) and propose fine-tuning strategies to improve
calibration of both representations. Experiments on eight difficult negotiation
corpora demonstrate that our proposed fine-tuning strategies (a traditional
supervision strategy and an off-policy reinforcement learning strategy) can
calibrate smaller open-source models to compete with pre-trained models 10x
their size. | [
-0.2244330495595932,
-0.6613673567771912,
0.7811700105667114,
0.009920508600771427,
-0.28331586718559265,
0.3098684847354889,
-0.2858354449272156,
-0.6249820590019226,
0.33301272988319397,
0.5987161993980408,
-0.5871734023094177,
-0.10766120254993439,
-0.7301597595214844,
-0.3307865262031555,
-0.0955667719244957,
0.8757710456848145,
0.32838305830955505,
0.20257049798965454,
0.11934095621109009,
0.09631231427192688,
-0.6408159732818604,
-0.2442164123058319,
-0.7522132992744446,
-0.44767889380455017,
0.26418694853782654,
0.6159072518348694,
1.2812713384628296,
0.38025444746017456,
0.5195913910865784,
0.2796310484409332,
-0.06474027037620544,
0.1258639395236969,
-0.5491447448730469,
-0.0029439525678753853,
-0.20954707264900208,
-0.689723789691925,
-0.24500161409378052,
0.19403082132339478,
0.08306194096803665,
1.0269914865493774,
-0.2910332977771759,
-0.1687297523021698,
-0.2776956558227539,
0.3689767122268677,
-0.45354709029197693,
0.3017923831939697,
-1.1891489028930664,
0.0738886147737503,
0.12704624235630035,
-0.26146256923675537,
-0.34129899740219116,
-0.33268582820892334,
0.4445708692073822,
-0.5258083343505859,
-0.27297285199165344,
0.38775739073753357,
0.7155208587646484,
0.3436751365661621,
-0.39961889386177063,
-0.5264890789985657,
-0.7278193831443787,
0.8996866345405579,
-0.8180150389671326,
0.21932923793792725,
0.6369471549987793,
0.17402222752571106,
-0.449187695980072,
-0.2817680537700653,
-0.34375816583633423,
-0.1671280860900879,
0.16901572048664093,
0.1715220808982849,
-0.17513403296470642,
0.24232764542102814,
-0.019644560292363167,
0.1832861304283142,
-0.06047981232404709,
0.2026541829109192,
-0.43695294857025146,
-0.1660534292459488,
0.629469633102417,
0.06545616686344147,
-0.26426827907562256,
-0.08672074228525162,
-0.31709372997283936,
-0.06868430227041245,
-0.574330747127533,
-0.017454667016863823,
0.5541883707046509,
0.4664404094219208,
-0.10482056438922882,
0.5383365154266357,
-0.3344481289386749,
0.6986050009727478,
0.29877546429634094,
0.01826123148202896,
-0.2528194487094879,
-0.04654213413596153,
-0.24734076857566833,
0.09405229985713959,
0.669454038143158,
0.5567930936813354,
0.32025575637817383,
-0.29466718435287476,
-0.05571860820055008,
-0.10036507248878479,
0.20005033910274506,
-0.56334388256073,
-0.25301384925842285,
0.3937370479106903,
-0.09038083255290985,
-0.4120244085788727,
0.020581595599651337,
-0.9247644543647766,
-0.5536108016967773,
-0.18526791036128998,
0.5469805598258972,
-0.38620439171791077,
0.026717301458120346,
0.4283908009529114,
-0.08644164353609085,
0.12419568747282028,
0.5321376919746399,
-0.7686328887939453,
0.2853486239910126,
0.6273533701896667,
0.49032142758369446,
0.09935086220502853,
-0.09790527820587158,
-0.6892046332359314,
-0.06587060540914536,
-0.9757940173149109,
0.6306077241897583,
-0.5721350312232971,
-0.7044641375541687,
-0.022410472854971886,
-0.4907168745994568,
0.12045710533857346,
-0.2701265513896942,
0.4787929654121399,
-0.3168342709541321,
0.2572007477283478,
-0.0806671604514122,
-0.6397595405578613,
0.0698389783501625,
0.27130159735679626,
-0.3103785514831543,
0.5017665028572083,
0.14766806364059448,
-0.46235963702201843,
0.42375296354293823,
-0.36212989687919617,
-0.1830378770828247,
0.22098584473133087,
-0.10914415121078491,
-0.24248750507831573,
0.3456563651561737,
0.012795213609933853,
0.2276540845632553,
-0.493197500705719,
0.5652568340301514,
-0.3535718023777008,
-0.40696778893470764,
0.6313920617103577,
-0.6378383040428162,
0.2607956826686859,
0.2680174708366394,
-0.06338878720998764,
0.040118250995874405,
-0.23243078589439392,
0.3028806746006012,
-0.08209222555160522,
-0.036970630288124084,
-0.25732678174972534,
0.04630148038268089,
-0.21205586194992065,
0.11395101249217987,
0.3946628272533417,
-0.3180260956287384,
0.18603076040744781,
-0.6441990733146667,
0.5241770148277283,
0.624352753162384,
0.04628458246588707,
0.5971255898475647,
-0.5340951681137085,
0.5497311949729919,
-0.03622380644083023,
0.31833186745643616,
-0.1023762971162796,
-0.5027679204940796,
-0.9475616216659546,
0.4138573408126831,
0.6132659912109375,
0.48581618070602417,
-0.7499986290931702,
0.3356429934501648,
-0.3083212971687317,
-0.7898557186126709,
-0.5158998370170593,
-0.180768221616745,
0.4886970818042755,
0.04437090829014778,
0.1096908375620842,
-0.25260648131370544,
-0.2213582545518875,
-0.6199962496757507,
-0.6688851118087769,
-0.44476601481437683,
-0.040623292326927185,
0.23703061044216156,
0.24489031732082367,
0.2939257323741913,
1.0697742700576782,
-0.6565157175064087,
-0.2846161425113678,
-0.11176387220621109,
0.5400599837303162,
0.16295422613620758,
0.3276466429233551,
0.24166519939899445,
-0.9494274258613586,
-0.4193127751350403,
-0.022870557382702827,
-0.0892690122127533,
0.40786507725715637,
-0.3863077759742737,
0.003089663339778781,
0.13882292807102203,
0.5230057239532471,
-0.5506725311279297,
0.42662081122398376,
0.6118783354759216,
-0.3899920880794525,
0.5907081365585327,
-0.3358941972255707,
0.17666929960250854,
-0.8038926124572754,
-0.40689054131507874,
-0.04172969609498978,
-0.37862804532051086,
-0.5639281868934631,
-0.2878789007663727,
-0.05118713155388832,
-0.19354116916656494,
-0.3137624263763428,
0.6238799095153809,
-0.28859376907348633,
0.19446173310279846,
-0.1454019546508789,
0.26705315709114075,
-0.04553798958659172,
0.43072280287742615,
0.2915600538253784,
0.7586001753807068,
0.3194326162338257,
-0.3927758038043976,
-0.06542146950960159,
0.34244322776794434,
-0.7696317434310913,
0.5093231201171875,
-0.5237268805503845,
0.20791621506214142,
0.08015292137861252,
0.06417795270681381,
-0.7775086760520935,
-0.3295958936214447,
0.17898936569690704,
-0.6176657676696777,
0.21814307570457458,
-0.14642180502414703,
-0.07523629069328308,
-0.4059683382511139,
-0.13746456801891327,
0.020768681541085243,
0.46119633316993713,
-0.023349151015281677,
0.3531525731086731,
0.330426961183548,
-0.3700145184993744,
-0.4773603677749634,
-0.6224059462547302,
0.3427480459213257,
-0.314444899559021,
-0.25924238562583923,
0.4919215738773346,
-0.34576526284217834,
-0.5039676427841187,
-0.2505009174346924,
-0.2782841920852661,
-0.269741028547287,
0.17811402678489685,
0.1868894249200821,
0.07296290248632431,
0.18424157798290253,
0.2223322093486786,
-0.019248496741056442,
-0.301405668258667,
-0.08705966174602509,
-0.2371516078710556,
0.5994199514389038,
0.017325835302472115,
-0.5639311075210571,
0.045679721981287,
0.24020040035247803,
0.6780338287353516,
-0.016225246712565422,
0.6502601504325867,
0.10114303231239319,
-0.35359153151512146,
0.026069724932312965,
-0.706952691078186,
-0.19881142675876617,
-0.48533394932746887,
0.31350934505462646,
-0.3623999357223511,
-0.6651515364646912,
0.5426619052886963,
-0.30913618206977844,
-0.12286804616451263,
0.19597011804580688,
0.21528123319149017,
0.08413095772266388,
1.0727895498275757,
0.7982749938964844,
-0.1079452782869339,
0.42087844014167786,
0.09991084039211273,
0.6495585441589355,
-0.35287240147590637,
-0.030683141201734543,
-0.5314305424690247,
-0.010245421901345253,
-0.4675890803337097,
-0.5943988561630249,
0.39515018463134766,
0.2484320104122162,
-0.03872007504105568,
0.29681485891342163,
-0.3485645651817322,
0.5514984726905823,
0.8351802229881287,
-0.007583902217447758,
0.36055701971054077,
-0.33982840180397034,
0.3158796727657318,
-0.24248795211315155,
-0.5520493984222412,
-0.4654408395290375,
0.8302720785140991,
0.27127692103385925,
0.8413951992988586,
-0.1648399978876114,
0.48148661851882935,
0.061628613620996475,
-0.06037261709570885,
-0.9400864839553833,
0.26418015360832214,
0.1746927797794342,
-0.6039977073669434,
-0.6926888227462769,
-0.6700876951217651,
-0.8164811730384827,
0.019834067672491074,
-0.32255858182907104,
-1.0498446226119995,
0.3553825616836548,
-0.06304829567670822,
-0.6816601753234863,
0.21955247223377228,
-0.7114636898040771,
0.8995783925056458,
-0.45330145955085754,
0.09347684681415558,
-0.24135532975196838,
-0.5726690888404846,
0.04373563081026077,
-0.38924914598464966,
0.5232080221176147,
-0.3041812777519226,
0.1917913258075714,
0.5528707504272461,
-0.31867846846580505,
0.7123141884803772,
0.16120558977127075,
-0.08196931332349777,
0.338937908411026,
0.5068877935409546,
0.7029821276664734,
0.10226117819547653,
-0.42489853501319885,
0.21646681427955627,
0.2857212722301483,
-0.2294066995382309,
-0.5121832489967346,
0.36601972579956055,
-0.5213693976402283,
-0.5405104160308838,
-0.30560973286628723,
-0.765442430973053,
-0.5385898351669312,
-0.0035433860030025244,
0.5907408595085144,
0.07033905386924744,
-0.4111979901790619,
-0.03763531893491745,
0.19173644483089447,
-0.18027949333190918,
0.1551133394241333,
0.5142054557800293,
-0.15460196137428284,
-0.26740363240242004,
0.892792284488678,
0.16341905295848846,
0.5634558200836182,
0.3317462205886841,
0.21150356531143188,
-0.12674561142921448,
-0.5849495530128479,
-0.0966024324297905,
-0.06713102012872696,
-0.5570806264877319,
-0.5201318264007568,
-0.19032667577266693,
-0.1647317111492157,
-0.3017060160636902,
-0.3603772819042206,
-0.4792080223560333,
-0.330196738243103,
-0.2560696303844452,
-0.1354788988828659,
0.5364173054695129,
0.6460437774658203,
-0.038406211882829666,
0.6844203472137451,
-0.5884401202201843,
-0.11948713660240173,
0.2456481009721756,
0.5316426157951355,
-0.30127403140068054,
-0.4324922561645508,
-0.32220521569252014,
0.6220298409461975,
-0.34777531027793884,
-0.7910458445549011,
0.7010908722877502,
0.13450847566127777,
-0.020553473383188248,
0.4119454622268677,
0.5917094349861145,
0.8031293749809265,
-0.25326210260391235,
0.7329550385475159,
0.46739497780799866,
-1.240435242652893,
0.3825472891330719,
-0.40460848808288574,
0.27337533235549927,
0.676410973072052,
-0.06463263928890228,
-0.8433777689933777,
-0.5798332691192627,
-0.6673856377601624,
-0.7308492660522461,
0.7887841463088989,
0.14476098120212555,
0.45194029808044434,
-0.11649738997220993,
0.09986630082130432,
0.1293734908103943,
0.6266891956329346,
-0.4716229736804962,
-0.053446464240550995,
0.1272902488708496,
-0.13456177711486816,
-0.22554881870746613,
-0.375061571598053,
-0.14121229946613312,
-0.026707548648118973,
0.5105507969856262,
-0.2600797414779663,
0.1784915328025818,
-0.1353681981563568,
0.2390507161617279,
-0.4593571126461029,
0.36335986852645874,
0.3074755072593689,
0.8767452836036682,
-0.2956102192401886,
-0.2117299735546112,
0.19717039167881012,
0.008250747807323933,
-0.23523977398872375,
0.09397469460964203,
0.010309110395610332,
-0.06593015789985657,
0.17738476395606995,
1.006617784500122,
0.6862314939498901,
-0.8789759874343872,
0.5321206450462341,
-0.18327032029628754,
-0.3354436159133911,
-0.4686545431613922,
-0.055985402315855026,
0.028900543227791786,
0.3146420419216156,
0.3427915871143341,
0.14215046167373657,
0.11084523797035217,
-0.6363208293914795,
-0.06646308302879333,
0.6377795934677124,
-0.7968801259994507,
0.021489646285772324,
0.530211329460144,
0.1781042069196701,
-0.6264814138412476,
0.517095685005188,
-0.25373679399490356,
-0.6925278306007385,
0.6465252041816711,
0.27630355954170227,
0.4031769633293152,
-0.17682459950447083,
0.5235205888748169,
-0.20971707999706268,
0.34377795457839966,
-0.20792484283447266,
0.12811532616615295,
0.27363595366477966,
-0.8984668850898743,
-0.5605723857879639,
-0.4944760799407959,
-1.0108038187026978,
-0.00878551322966814,
-0.6202829480171204,
0.3448140621185303,
-0.17195844650268555,
-0.17314594984054565,
0.024870285764336586,
0.242536723613739,
-0.8819524645805359,
0.11109751462936401,
-0.059380628168582916,
0.9107547402381897,
-0.6173558235168457,
0.5356003046035767,
0.22898295521736145,
-0.3256504535675049,
-0.882921040058136,
0.1761361062526703,
-0.13598419725894928,
-0.580924391746521,
0.19466838240623474,
0.023007899522781372,
0.08806037902832031,
-0.058648645877838135,
-0.5676687955856323,
-0.9918022751808167,
0.5926001667976379,
0.694733738899231,
-0.6426969766616821,
-0.21747028827667236,
0.12049226462841034,
0.30406075716018677,
-0.1344487965106964,
0.3762269914150238,
0.5540112853050232,
0.7004104256629944,
0.30698254704475403,
-1.2974112033843994,
-0.5027616620063782,
0.21696314215660095,
-0.3301324248313904,
0.45924004912376404,
-0.6492792367935181,
0.6994476914405823,
-0.3354620635509491,
-0.06162737309932709,
0.4387304484844208,
0.49489057064056396,
-0.26027533411979675,
0.30717456340789795,
0.4727934002876282,
0.23313315212726593,
0.8025293946266174,
-0.43429800868034363,
0.9971373081207275,
-0.3844405710697174,
0.28304868936538696,
1.1495215892791748,
-0.29670220613479614,
0.8036095499992371,
0.5027401447296143,
-0.2417324036359787,
0.2551819086074829,
0.837469220161438,
0.23929151892662048,
0.50907301902771,
0.22314120829105377,
0.06185709312558174,
-0.7042036652565002,
-0.14981509745121002,
-0.05533604696393013,
0.7483399510383606,
0.7497162222862244,
-0.009490027092397213,
-0.05717526376247406,
-0.05112471431493759,
0.06685728579759598,
0.12557204067707062,
-0.14733636379241943,
0.8661223649978638,
0.2745053172111511,
-1.0463978052139282,
0.05062419921159744,
0.05678809806704521,
0.5255037546157837,
-0.6490795016288757,
0.06169545650482178,
-0.09154807776212692,
0.1415567249059677,
0.33380037546157837,
-0.6805091500282288,
0.22342625260353088,
-0.5512716174125671,
0.15056997537612915,
-0.11801392585039139,
0.3874760568141937,
-0.8198046684265137,
-0.5429588556289673,
0.2636563777923584,
0.5840543508529663,
0.31033623218536377,
-0.36001574993133545,
-0.7364982962608337,
0.035566117614507675,
-0.0019337910925969481,
-0.02236359193921089,
0.3340334892272949,
0.5933741927146912,
0.05205314978957176,
0.7844614386558533,
0.2684602737426758,
0.19977892935276031,
-0.3007737398147583,
-0.24947203695774078,
0.3758590519428253,
-0.46464380621910095,
-0.4145251214504242,
-0.4947473704814911,
0.38339123129844666,
-0.08030690252780914,
-0.5641550421714783,
0.4732953608036041,
0.22116923332214355,
0.6895133256912231,
0.12595710158348083,
0.5640653371810913,
0.2523880898952484,
0.3781520426273346,
-0.5185970067977905,
0.47276049852371216,
-0.43460386991500854,
0.22493626177310944,
-0.3437138497829437,
-0.7535226941108704,
-0.1372409462928772,
0.7582919597625732,
-0.6273930072784424,
0.05938175693154335,
0.5378742218017578,
0.441280335187912,
0.06311103701591492,
0.22001218795776367,
0.6759948134422302,
0.10600906610488892,
0.07996746897697449,
0.4607398509979248,
0.6114224195480347,
-0.3039635419845581,
0.8168728351593018,
-0.24399122595787048,
-0.01072688214480877,
-0.38987013697624207,
-0.9402713179588318,
-0.5311239957809448,
-0.658941924571991,
-0.40673184394836426,
-0.11991473287343979,
0.18961498141288757,
0.9159137606620789,
0.9456117153167725,
-0.5357258319854736,
-0.2802610993385315,
-0.19315196573734283,
0.30035707354545593,
-0.10867032408714294,
-0.1618998497724533,
0.1354469507932663,
-0.44825342297554016,
-0.8092566132545471,
0.42399120330810547,
0.2665177285671234,
0.18962998688220978,
-0.18255147337913513,
-0.0449979230761528,
0.2590818405151367,
0.6414353847503662,
0.18120568990707397,
0.0874965637922287,
-0.7652989029884338,
-0.5005106329917908,
-0.159429669380188,
0.10553157329559326,
-0.031911250203847885,
0.623782217502594,
-0.5749548673629761,
0.6697260141372681,
-0.1661081314086914,
0.25292396545410156,
0.4235696792602539,
0.006225847639143467,
0.953058123588562,
-0.6942701935768127,
0.30542346835136414,
0.39718785881996155,
0.3055104911327362,
0.30917930603027344,
-0.47259408235549927,
0.613487720489502,
-0.5065925717353821,
-0.6428326368331909,
-0.6726879477500916,
0.36510133743286133,
-0.5915265679359436,
-0.5887595415115356,
0.7490674257278442,
0.05309182032942772,
0.09780178219079971,
-0.18399235606193542,
-0.25690385699272156,
-0.04235675930976868,
-0.6065805554389954,
1.0224648714065552,
1.052396297454834,
0.28016197681427,
-0.022136176005005836,
-0.594001293182373,
0.48984652757644653,
0.5515252351760864,
-0.5486273765563965,
0.2433980107307434,
0.4184293746948242,
-0.19630016386508942,
0.3491609990596771,
0.6409116387367249,
0.30841171741485596,
0.0472429059445858,
0.07605740427970886,
-0.19183063507080078,
0.4755401313304901,
-0.37283122539520264,
-0.05378042906522751,
-0.1930617094039917,
0.5475836396217346,
0.04943607747554779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03271v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03271v2 | Uncertainty of Thoughts: Uncertainty-Aware Planning Enhances Information Seeking in Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T18:28:44 | 2024-05-30T14:03:35 | Zhiyuan Hu, Chumin Liu, Xidong Feng, Yilun Zhao, See-Kiong Ng, Anh Tuan Luu, Junxian He, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the face of uncertainty, the ability to *seek information* is of
fundamental importance. In many practical applications, such as medical
diagnosis and troubleshooting, the information needed to solve the task is not
initially given and has to be actively sought by asking follow-up questions
(for example, a doctor asking a patient for more details about their symptoms).
In this work, we introduce Uncertainty of Thoughts (UoT), an algorithm to
augment large language models with the ability to actively seek information by
asking effective questions. UoT combines 1) an *uncertainty-aware simulation
approach* which enables the model to simulate possible future scenarios and how
likely they are to occur, 2) *uncertainty-based rewards* motivated by
information gain which incentivizes the model to seek information, and 3) a
*reward propagation scheme* to select the optimal question to ask in a way that
maximizes the expected reward. In experiments on medical diagnosis,
troubleshooting, and the `20 Questions` game, UoT achieves an average
performance improvement of 38.1% in the rate of successful task completion
across multiple LLMs compared with direct prompting and also improves
efficiency (i.e., the number of questions needed to complete the task). Our
code has been released [here](https://github.com/zhiyuanhubj/UoT) | [
-0.22442345321178436,
-0.8628653883934021,
1.0092390775680542,
0.255860298871994,
-0.16184449195861816,
-0.16345812380313873,
-0.2252061516046524,
-0.5183286070823669,
0.2656339406967163,
0.4214528501033783,
-0.6799219846725464,
-0.15030726790428162,
-0.541849672794342,
-0.41769179701805115,
-0.14237289130687714,
0.5027661323547363,
-0.06702948361635208,
0.013028628192842007,
0.00004128138243686408,
0.42439568042755127,
-0.3464682102203369,
-0.3530619740486145,
-1.0007506608963013,
-0.284316748380661,
0.6711159944534302,
0.6166514158248901,
0.8479986786842346,
0.3336069881916046,
0.6611871123313904,
0.24554674327373505,
0.000891095376573503,
0.056045882403850555,
-0.36435234546661377,
0.5800134539604187,
-0.19505275785923004,
-0.5870707631111145,
-0.13276037573814392,
-0.41001471877098083,
0.5061130523681641,
0.6950445771217346,
-0.5108540058135986,
-0.07284010201692581,
-0.1935974806547165,
0.7301372289657593,
-0.6881569027900696,
-0.016017472371459007,
-0.5421327948570251,
0.19611229002475739,
-0.08618724346160889,
-0.3861671984195709,
-0.10311425477266312,
-0.044483356177806854,
0.29216116666793823,
-0.6958786249160767,
-0.23166722059249878,
-0.010393941774964333,
0.5173407196998596,
0.45632731914520264,
-0.08806948363780975,
-0.3664686679840088,
-1.0274137258529663,
0.6465148329734802,
-0.3487851619720459,
0.5535925030708313,
0.3581068217754364,
0.07509233057498932,
-0.5834372043609619,
-0.5862830281257629,
-0.477804958820343,
0.21505482494831085,
0.3184342682361603,
0.28044766187667847,
-0.47604694962501526,
0.30395177006721497,
0.26651737093925476,
0.21220171451568604,
-0.42180678248405457,
-0.15407654643058777,
-0.13681049644947052,
-0.2020369917154312,
0.5382298231124878,
-0.03102482110261917,
0.03168009594082832,
-0.03628033772110939,
-0.3633846640586853,
-0.21501368284225464,
-0.4221613109111786,
0.23655852675437927,
0.22862887382507324,
-0.2453911304473877,
0.20701301097869873,
0.564725399017334,
-0.5547205805778503,
0.7377536296844482,
-0.12371203303337097,
0.10153642296791077,
-0.1261833757162094,
-0.19797655940055847,
-0.16194310784339905,
-0.10755875706672668,
0.6631554961204529,
0.28194019198417664,
0.08528919517993927,
0.15371668338775635,
-0.29868367314338684,
-0.11084061861038208,
0.45533478260040283,
-0.5248208045959473,
-0.4867525100708008,
0.7004474401473999,
-0.1682453602552414,
-0.09695389121770859,
-0.27910447120666504,
-0.838182270526886,
-0.4686072766780853,
-0.043540552258491516,
0.5525985956192017,
-0.6607656478881836,
-0.5018625259399414,
0.5632520318031311,
-0.023266926407814026,
-0.12812590599060059,
0.5271104574203491,
-0.666159451007843,
0.13684658706188202,
0.33270198106765747,
0.31233516335487366,
-0.08026662468910217,
-0.19096435606479645,
-0.31522810459136963,
0.17339468002319336,
-0.4428485035896301,
1.0186896324157715,
-0.4652569591999054,
-0.40373700857162476,
-0.18275685608386993,
-0.6049267649650574,
0.016388114541769028,
-0.336264044046402,
0.6648094654083252,
-0.47994592785835266,
0.06121634319424629,
-0.5177201628684998,
-0.5275940299034119,
-0.14201851189136505,
0.4070613980293274,
-0.5324155688285828,
1.0472604036331177,
0.18828114867210388,
-0.6839700937271118,
0.39700379967689514,
-0.9679909348487854,
-0.2095501869916916,
0.2782510221004486,
-0.23759783804416656,
-0.00858831126242876,
0.2311829924583435,
0.35354918241500854,
0.48552659153938293,
-0.40659043192863464,
0.3028619885444641,
0.07835068553686142,
-0.23840932548046112,
0.35264965891838074,
-0.5220175385475159,
0.3843161463737488,
0.47428858280181885,
-0.2625557482242584,
0.24259956181049347,
-0.35979798436164856,
0.466545969247818,
0.3821936547756195,
-0.18015097081661224,
-0.4244213402271271,
0.2981555461883545,
-0.08904773741960526,
0.032478298991918564,
0.32621774077415466,
-0.36304759979248047,
0.44749996066093445,
-0.3996202051639557,
0.0624166801571846,
0.5581026077270508,
0.38779789209365845,
0.2617606222629547,
-0.3915037512779236,
0.6487595438957214,
-0.04140940308570862,
0.5597870945930481,
-0.0026218644343316555,
-0.7645208835601807,
-0.5703252553939819,
0.04665014147758484,
0.25212377309799194,
0.6135212779045105,
-0.91458660364151,
-0.05605126544833183,
0.07723472267389297,
-0.5823975801467896,
-0.5106372237205505,
-0.23183438181877136,
0.23399950563907623,
0.4339885413646698,
0.2249774932861328,
-0.25567078590393066,
-0.5668913722038269,
-0.450794517993927,
-0.17601750791072845,
-0.565169095993042,
0.006895103491842747,
0.2509741485118866,
0.3095601797103882,
-0.2013208121061325,
0.7049109935760498,
-0.8082138895988464,
0.08295504003763199,
-0.5063371658325195,
0.3062620162963867,
0.12126754969358444,
0.46448802947998047,
0.023876411840319633,
-1.1333085298538208,
-0.1466217339038849,
-0.09570679068565369,
-0.5278273224830627,
0.17921625077724457,
-0.329950749874115,
-0.30202606320381165,
-0.19617587327957153,
0.18335965275764465,
-0.7728613018989563,
0.4382975399494171,
0.3974858224391937,
-0.13817758858203888,
0.4286899268627167,
-0.48174306750297546,
0.31122541427612305,
-1.0336112976074219,
0.10256551206111908,
-0.2506882846355438,
-0.04729779437184334,
-0.5846105217933655,
0.18351879715919495,
-0.00872066617012024,
0.130965456366539,
-0.3654598593711853,
0.5515623688697815,
-0.5214817523956299,
0.13229195773601532,
-0.20638452470302582,
0.029716821387410164,
-0.20158663392066956,
0.26416173577308655,
0.0830921158194542,
0.7237325310707092,
0.7598641514778137,
-0.6972777843475342,
0.38799813389778137,
-0.04631240665912628,
-0.45915544033050537,
0.6645967364311218,
-0.4466405212879181,
0.19445520639419556,
-0.14573107659816742,
-0.20654037594795227,
-0.8741018772125244,
-0.6015901565551758,
0.30395233631134033,
-0.5708491206169128,
0.3020681142807007,
0.2353898137807846,
-0.4272916615009308,
-0.68117356300354,
-0.08896841108798981,
0.49670344591140747,
0.3355398178100586,
-0.14488007128238678,
0.504540741443634,
0.5937057137489319,
-0.37474900484085083,
-0.7491809725761414,
-0.45151859521865845,
-0.05300815403461456,
0.0493863970041275,
-0.25425025820732117,
0.1373090296983719,
-0.22149863839149475,
-0.40475818514823914,
0.245259091258049,
-0.2206508070230484,
-0.211069256067276,
0.31809625029563904,
0.15592718124389648,
0.09677571803331375,
0.15488818287849426,
0.5302743315696716,
0.1674415022134781,
-0.131769061088562,
0.1238180547952652,
-0.6694295406341553,
0.8192370533943176,
0.05707065761089325,
-0.639743983745575,
-0.2170305699110031,
0.4867314100265503,
0.10255854576826096,
-0.1432923823595047,
0.2824397087097168,
0.26966503262519836,
-0.7343034148216248,
-0.1574891209602356,
-0.6204863786697388,
-0.34373047947883606,
-0.4542980492115021,
0.533475935459137,
-0.3613910973072052,
-0.7462167739868164,
0.48639464378356934,
-0.322172611951828,
-0.12823699414730072,
0.4681815505027771,
0.3671785891056061,
-0.5679649114608765,
1.1717429161071777,
0.9816820025444031,
-0.14947456121444702,
0.4449111819267273,
-0.10465048998594284,
-0.007105551660060883,
-0.6321901679039001,
-0.170879527926445,
-0.29247385263442993,
-0.23470163345336914,
-0.2071407288312912,
-0.8129760026931763,
0.5903805494308472,
0.0798349380493164,
0.19352127611637115,
-0.029446538537740707,
-0.7519509792327881,
0.4275568127632141,
0.7224312424659729,
0.06363622099161148,
0.2752830386161804,
-0.09195616096258163,
-0.27821314334869385,
0.025049259886145592,
-1.003230333328247,
-0.08589762449264526,
1.0009632110595703,
0.18929168581962585,
0.8960793018341064,
-0.2232801616191864,
0.7908790707588196,
0.030117152258753777,
-0.04007624462246895,
-0.8648441433906555,
0.40582236647605896,
0.6911191344261169,
-0.7923887968063354,
-0.7604181170463562,
-0.6190999150276184,
-1.1971216201782227,
-0.09917652606964111,
-0.18789292871952057,
-0.9676270484924316,
0.2781079411506653,
0.2572263479232788,
-0.8692576289176941,
0.5639880895614624,
-0.38784652948379517,
0.5076056122779846,
-0.5818287134170532,
-0.14706052839756012,
-0.40937539935112,
-0.6308789849281311,
-0.046880003064870834,
-0.2510891854763031,
0.10457727313041687,
0.13077618181705475,
-0.005723281763494015,
0.7052305936813354,
0.24008610844612122,
0.4322047829627991,
-0.019087746739387512,
0.05322084575891495,
0.45727014541625977,
0.1055721566081047,
0.6372740268707275,
0.08806528151035309,
-0.06026432663202286,
-0.09206747263669968,
0.005817953031510115,
-0.3220454156398773,
-0.6490858197212219,
0.38642418384552,
-0.3683357238769531,
-0.5496898889541626,
-0.572189450263977,
-1.0636028051376343,
-0.44329431653022766,
0.33032071590423584,
0.42537325620651245,
0.1565398871898651,
-0.030440401285886765,
-0.1917061060667038,
1.0555460453033447,
-0.2952437698841095,
0.16498972475528717,
0.24141031503677368,
-0.3677489161491394,
-0.08340553194284439,
0.4375438988208771,
0.17167365550994873,
0.26562801003456116,
0.598190426826477,
0.19204415380954742,
-0.36831966042518616,
-0.744604766368866,
-0.36539241671562195,
0.17525334656238556,
-0.5621458888053894,
-0.20885924994945526,
-0.6893477439880371,
-0.23452603816986084,
-0.1562034636735916,
0.03415892273187637,
-0.6376128196716309,
-0.43296101689338684,
0.0627143606543541,
-0.12592589855194092,
0.5011532306671143,
0.9540291428565979,
-0.20569570362567902,
0.4198819100856781,
-0.5166100859642029,
0.023927688598632812,
0.26263630390167236,
0.5172103643417358,
-0.24163630604743958,
-0.1978783905506134,
-0.34203413128852844,
0.29359322786331177,
-0.22781674563884735,
-0.9765200018882751,
0.2505660951137543,
-0.3412926197052002,
0.7228844165802002,
0.40001118183135986,
0.3393353223800659,
0.750758945941925,
-0.1334952563047409,
0.4762187600135803,
0.052201494574546814,
-0.6327413320541382,
0.761618435382843,
-0.3485354483127594,
0.4781794250011444,
0.6817629933357239,
0.5747619867324829,
-0.6473639011383057,
-0.3773987889289856,
-0.7444892525672913,
-0.9748896360397339,
0.536017656326294,
0.13818034529685974,
-0.2369600385427475,
0.06228259578347206,
0.6110125780105591,
-0.3890737295150757,
0.41636285185813904,
-0.3265193700790405,
-0.14759773015975952,
0.514980137348175,
-0.2840110957622528,
0.15538205206394196,
-0.5288674831390381,
-0.16770978271961212,
-0.13977566361427307,
0.5625839829444885,
-0.011005970649421215,
0.9133462309837341,
0.5685286521911621,
0.2610672414302826,
-0.5721593499183655,
0.2436647266149521,
0.5488018989562988,
0.48466813564300537,
-0.35096266865730286,
0.13753126561641693,
0.16493405401706696,
-0.699842095375061,
-0.08398894220590591,
0.2535034120082855,
-0.246412992477417,
-0.16381250321865082,
-0.05588487163186073,
0.6126287579536438,
0.15976206958293915,
-0.8566310405731201,
0.1284092664718628,
-0.10787662863731384,
-0.13784584403038025,
-0.24159599840641022,
0.11020012199878693,
0.16902008652687073,
0.5037254095077515,
0.32210665941238403,
0.20321114361286163,
0.4251551926136017,
-0.5571274161338806,
0.22350479662418365,
0.30701059103012085,
-0.7334242463111877,
-0.034818053245544434,
0.5851156115531921,
-0.3162102997303009,
-0.2649533152580261,
0.5351240038871765,
-0.374490350484848,
-0.6096201539039612,
0.4093998074531555,
0.4427180886268616,
0.4991507828235626,
-0.5636902451515198,
0.34178921580314636,
0.0960923433303833,
0.5251603126525879,
-0.4419771432876587,
1.101707935333252,
0.06059225648641586,
-0.662712812423706,
-0.49699991941452026,
-0.25235792994499207,
-0.7822490334510803,
0.04145132005214691,
-0.3862975239753723,
-0.1220586895942688,
-0.14091521501541138,
-0.4079550802707672,
-0.47807514667510986,
0.008866535499691963,
-0.5465589761734009,
0.4383394420146942,
0.05552216246724129,
0.8616639971733093,
-0.1843511015176773,
0.8681952953338623,
0.8087015748023987,
-0.18585409224033356,
-1.2456128597259521,
0.15607935190200806,
-0.04773557931184769,
-0.5418753623962402,
0.13343574106693268,
-0.03289104998111725,
-0.12461993843317032,
-0.036590710282325745,
-0.36996322870254517,
-1.3709088563919067,
0.9487062692642212,
0.27403852343559265,
-0.5756098628044128,
-0.11949427425861359,
0.12100286036729813,
0.29539480805397034,
-0.18473950028419495,
0.17891767621040344,
0.28925350308418274,
0.5853555202484131,
0.30625244975090027,
-0.842328667640686,
-0.16132237017154694,
-0.2526851296424866,
-0.3987887501716614,
0.5465289354324341,
-0.2949422597885132,
0.9035709500312805,
-0.6593241095542908,
-0.23687253892421722,
-0.013440633192658424,
0.4976469874382019,
0.10318423807621002,
0.37286698818206787,
0.6449862122535706,
0.4503280222415924,
1.4273873567581177,
-0.2519693374633789,
1.2082709074020386,
-0.3675106167793274,
0.13770802319049835,
1.0193603038787842,
-0.1733534336090088,
0.9450470209121704,
0.4848967492580414,
0.017154932022094727,
0.10630405694246292,
0.7172054052352905,
0.37749114632606506,
0.4488079249858856,
0.11667934060096741,
-0.1562136560678482,
-0.3317147493362427,
-0.1234067901968956,
-0.3783974349498749,
0.29817861318588257,
0.6090209484100342,
-0.025302361696958542,
0.12770318984985352,
-0.009600170888006687,
-0.08076122403144836,
-0.05832059681415558,
-0.29955124855041504,
0.5555819272994995,
-0.11515097320079803,
-0.8545109033584595,
0.18030206859111786,
-0.17841778695583344,
0.2788035571575165,
-0.7963049411773682,
0.06297048926353455,
0.06569556146860123,
0.20607715845108032,
0.1822504848241806,
-1.1071579456329346,
0.20129980146884918,
-0.2529025375843048,
-0.013284633867442608,
-0.08988538384437561,
0.8986256718635559,
-0.3983291983604431,
-0.48637425899505615,
0.23844636976718903,
0.7190099358558655,
0.27184078097343445,
-0.6147018074989319,
-0.8224871754646301,
-0.01726491004228592,
0.05662918835878372,
-0.5313829779624939,
0.09585161507129669,
0.8079343438148499,
-0.19911254942417145,
1.034426212310791,
0.5132028460502625,
0.4322448670864105,
-0.14993973076343536,
-0.2713398337364197,
0.9846952557563782,
-0.5549783110618591,
-0.3531913161277771,
-0.5877135396003723,
0.5324742197990417,
-0.14782562851905823,
-0.4192779064178467,
0.44259780645370483,
0.4078846871852875,
0.7940382957458496,
0.1540284901857376,
0.6222141981124878,
-0.016487836837768555,
0.5339647531509399,
-0.44059401750564575,
0.6419962644577026,
-0.6202765703201294,
0.2815718352794647,
-0.3648252487182617,
-0.6884806156158447,
-0.3346334397792816,
0.8914233446121216,
-0.46386510133743286,
-0.04293946549296379,
0.7138881087303162,
0.43387094140052795,
0.2541615962982178,
0.07184398919343948,
0.48069727420806885,
0.011387990787625313,
0.10311883687973022,
0.8424059152603149,
0.9116241335868835,
-0.13898250460624695,
0.3711497485637665,
-0.5385013818740845,
-0.2545936107635498,
-0.1533006727695465,
-0.5668166875839233,
-0.3568416237831116,
-0.6099575757980347,
0.030620470643043518,
0.09492545574903488,
0.11786520481109619,
1.2079601287841797,
0.6821087598800659,
-0.47805917263031006,
-0.29369691014289856,
-0.16853715479373932,
0.3265671730041504,
-0.37023743987083435,
-0.1093546450138092,
0.055267333984375,
-0.33810222148895264,
-0.4899911880493164,
0.3600272238254547,
0.44797414541244507,
0.08323167264461517,
-0.11599277704954147,
0.07047906517982483,
-0.3395625352859497,
0.4102799594402313,
0.2811793088912964,
0.1910858303308487,
-0.3711325526237488,
-0.18056079745292664,
0.3075895309448242,
-0.09717477113008499,
-0.04372628778219223,
0.5581022500991821,
-0.623592734336853,
0.761735200881958,
0.2538243532180786,
0.6574681401252747,
0.47600066661834717,
0.016895506531000137,
0.6397687196731567,
-0.33668336272239685,
0.15472260117530823,
0.6212586760520935,
0.3410017490386963,
0.1174187883734703,
-0.8196582794189453,
0.6151582598686218,
-0.08101281523704529,
-0.6410836577415466,
-0.517412543296814,
0.5229358673095703,
-0.9086610078811646,
-0.34896376729011536,
1.0777535438537598,
0.07866747677326202,
-0.2236396074295044,
-0.19502630829811096,
-0.5159845948219299,
0.23155435919761658,
-0.5657449960708618,
0.8769197463989258,
0.7201293706893921,
-0.33736759424209595,
-0.22208218276500702,
-0.7440747618675232,
0.6030524373054504,
0.7316705584526062,
-0.7908478379249573,
-0.006714525166898966,
0.26385432481765747,
-0.09946347028017044,
0.2811858057975769,
0.943004846572876,
0.1269470453262329,
0.44416025280952454,
-0.09564049541950226,
0.30803725123405457,
0.21173301339149475,
-0.5657544732093811,
0.033321723341941833,
0.15482810139656067,
0.3211555778980255,
0.007118892855942249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03269v1 | ISPA: Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet for Transcribing Animal Sounds | 2024-02-05T18:27:27 | 2024-02-05T18:27:27 | Masato Hagiwara, Marius Miron, Jen-Yu Liu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Traditionally, bioacoustics has relied on spectrograms and continuous,
per-frame audio representations for the analysis of animal sounds, also serving
as input to machine learning models. Meanwhile, the International Phonetic
Alphabet (IPA) system has provided an interpretable, language-independent
method for transcribing human speech sounds. In this paper, we introduce ISPA
(Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet), a precise, concise, and interpretable system
designed for transcribing animal sounds into text. We compare acoustics-based
and feature-based methods for transcribing and classifying animal sounds,
demonstrating their comparable performance with baseline methods utilizing
continuous, dense audio representations. By representing animal sounds with
text, we effectively treat them as a "foreign language," and we show that
established human language ML paradigms and models, such as language models,
can be successfully applied to improve performance. | [
-0.3364708125591278,
-0.39406725764274597,
-0.03558550775051117,
0.7830113172531128,
-0.5053884983062744,
0.3094402849674225,
-0.32654640078544617,
-1.0381786823272705,
0.6493614315986633,
0.3546866178512573,
-0.3865889310836792,
-0.38160693645477295,
-0.561040461063385,
0.4884297847747803,
-0.42515701055526733,
0.6548997163772583,
0.5365442633628845,
0.30319586396217346,
0.14340783655643463,
-0.5527328848838806,
-0.12799465656280518,
-0.6842957139015198,
-0.301068514585495,
-0.5016551613807678,
0.45534762740135193,
-0.12410116195678711,
0.5589563846588135,
0.8335310220718384,
0.5746434330940247,
0.30425965785980225,
-0.3904673159122467,
0.23547224700450897,
0.2601664960384369,
-0.012190615758299828,
-0.11079508066177368,
-0.2721094489097595,
-0.23280222713947296,
0.058532122522592545,
0.6191263794898987,
0.8774083256721497,
-0.13262684643268585,
0.0989035964012146,
0.10208063572645187,
0.6510367393493652,
-0.4279593527317047,
0.5926114916801453,
-0.4860629439353943,
0.22084730863571167,
-0.3044588267803192,
-0.6980881690979004,
-0.48965591192245483,
-0.2651965320110321,
0.34637436270713806,
-0.9476240873336792,
-0.2639317810535431,
-0.13387684524059296,
0.5838842988014221,
0.31185010075569153,
-0.18956007063388824,
-0.8435015082359314,
-0.7828977108001709,
0.6557347774505615,
-0.497231125831604,
0.528670072555542,
0.40469348430633545,
0.14792968332767487,
-0.20929355919361115,
-0.715394914150238,
-0.45530813932418823,
-0.4208601415157318,
0.11004514992237091,
-0.039392098784446716,
-0.23898185789585114,
0.3540797829627991,
0.1125684529542923,
0.452816903591156,
-0.5150423049926758,
0.2822110652923584,
-0.38502126932144165,
-0.38723477721214294,
0.725398600101471,
-0.3293774724006653,
0.6471045017242432,
0.4147171974182129,
-0.16693775355815887,
-0.38666191697120667,
-0.607489824295044,
0.2774680554866791,
0.4344221353530884,
0.8279311656951904,
0.07941273599863052,
0.41127514839172363,
-0.09386735409498215,
0.4541824162006378,
-0.378377228975296,
-0.4793218970298767,
0.2928122580051422,
-0.06532059609889984,
0.1419152319431305,
0.6033841967582703,
0.5838239789009094,
0.027194758877158165,
0.22307917475700378,
-0.3507838845252991,
-0.18868601322174072,
0.353847473859787,
0.23423653841018677,
-0.6548936367034912,
-0.04316079616546631,
0.15894487500190735,
-0.7098137140274048,
-0.2970600426197052,
-0.31626707315444946,
-0.49419406056404114,
-0.08870775997638702,
-0.23637397587299347,
0.6086565852165222,
-0.4322633445262909,
-0.14733022451400757,
0.26984187960624695,
-0.3706320524215698,
0.22821781039237976,
0.08000505715608597,
-1.1723449230194092,
0.7105934619903564,
0.6228220462799072,
0.875336766242981,
-0.05639158934354782,
-0.49474239349365234,
-0.7934595942497253,
0.1550949513912201,
-0.38038402795791626,
0.932262122631073,
-0.7799224853515625,
-0.8045119643211365,
-0.01263287290930748,
0.06824558973312378,
0.28354594111442566,
-0.823935866355896,
0.16259177029132843,
-0.28722497820854187,
-0.04140326380729675,
-0.4326220750808716,
-0.5242441892623901,
-0.6558820605278015,
-0.12491694837808609,
-0.5416808128356934,
0.9884384870529175,
-0.12794707715511322,
-0.503075122833252,
0.25675198435783386,
-0.9836026430130005,
-0.7053757905960083,
0.317224383354187,
-0.06979488581418991,
-0.3530157208442688,
-0.35061100125312805,
-0.06921709328889847,
0.2153419405221939,
-0.18253576755523682,
0.03801782801747322,
-0.33511286973953247,
-0.6823416352272034,
0.2353653758764267,
-0.16366799175739288,
0.7626098990440369,
0.3092619776725769,
-0.2428363412618637,
-0.10763155668973923,
-1.090956449508667,
0.09682480990886688,
-0.08243988454341888,
-0.7765769958496094,
-0.5536725521087646,
0.15049612522125244,
0.1437472254037857,
-0.3655565083026886,
0.18847836554050446,
-0.7941218614578247,
0.41255807876586914,
-0.1934017539024353,
0.7450064420700073,
0.3209501802921295,
-0.2952324450016022,
0.37989360094070435,
-0.3220093846321106,
0.23106853663921356,
-0.26908713579177856,
-0.1504504680633545,
0.04041425138711929,
-0.7413512468338013,
-0.18370269238948822,
-0.4949992597103119,
0.5696792602539062,
0.7749270796775818,
-0.278850793838501,
0.6597650051116943,
-0.07515546679496765,
-0.5773062109947205,
-0.6630116701126099,
-0.2036052942276001,
0.3214360475540161,
0.4848770201206207,
0.49881911277770996,
-0.8508565425872803,
-0.502185583114624,
-0.7807084321975708,
-0.26684311032295227,
-0.8581485748291016,
-0.10777366906404495,
0.019616276025772095,
0.07148058712482452,
-0.2591511011123657,
0.47521042823791504,
0.13583791255950928,
-0.12712916731834412,
0.05323292315006256,
0.4209335744380951,
0.11044564843177795,
0.5388432145118713,
0.6278288960456848,
-0.5344120264053345,
-0.24219106137752533,
0.1291506439447403,
-0.7526841163635254,
-0.23592855036258698,
0.14495928585529327,
0.15458053350448608,
0.0009663947275839746,
0.4797130227088928,
-0.39945411682128906,
0.365493506193161,
0.4717258810997009,
0.005172605626285076,
0.27371537685394287,
-0.16312026977539062,
0.2578237056732178,
-0.47625038027763367,
0.30402690172195435,
0.0015265585388988256,
-0.03942158818244934,
-0.7148849964141846,
-0.30458101630210876,
-0.09519730508327484,
-0.15676884353160858,
-0.34366875886917114,
0.552056074142456,
-0.36801815032958984,
-0.8162336945533752,
-0.24143537878990173,
-0.21356633305549622,
0.03502536565065384,
0.457072913646698,
0.6514540314674377,
0.8842662572860718,
0.5789167284965515,
-0.6995180249214172,
0.19422945380210876,
0.5427100658416748,
-0.5341633558273315,
0.5199875831604004,
-0.22611449658870697,
0.128122478723526,
0.02113458514213562,
0.42695891857147217,
-0.5034940242767334,
0.1277327686548233,
0.1968335509300232,
-0.39155372977256775,
0.3242025077342987,
-0.08870228379964828,
-0.35324516892433167,
-0.1797584742307663,
-0.15258751809597015,
0.219684436917305,
0.46939265727996826,
-0.5675466060638428,
0.4147081971168518,
0.6660822033882141,
-0.44474872946739197,
-0.8735881447792053,
-0.7786670923233032,
0.17995478212833405,
-0.22874101996421814,
-0.4418063163757324,
0.5639658570289612,
-0.2574499845504761,
-0.35991886258125305,
0.13025431334972382,
0.11532454937696457,
-0.13369157910346985,
0.15413103997707367,
0.03407254070043564,
-0.10426538437604904,
-0.42735618352890015,
0.30087992548942566,
0.0033473006915301085,
-0.009974880144000053,
-0.19762207567691803,
-0.19963546097278595,
0.28938809037208557,
0.006137085612863302,
-0.16092856228351593,
-0.7288166880607605,
0.49146080017089844,
0.8871096968650818,
-0.3415204584598541,
0.2178524285554886,
0.25981980562210083,
-0.3097217381000519,
-0.3120775818824768,
-0.054535724222660065,
-0.2542797029018402,
-0.4276200532913208,
0.380469411611557,
-0.4245868921279907,
-0.1874016374349594,
0.49625977873802185,
-0.4005572199821472,
0.1374669373035431,
0.0574205219745636,
0.39913126826286316,
-0.38325124979019165,
0.7197892069816589,
0.9168002009391785,
-0.21643030643463135,
0.6999861598014832,
-0.08448397368192673,
-0.24046389758586884,
-0.7100858688354492,
-0.40224993228912354,
-0.7446646690368652,
-0.29707109928131104,
-0.563988208770752,
-0.04951947182416916,
0.2490457445383072,
-0.39345720410346985,
-0.1201496347784996,
0.29321786761283875,
-0.7473016381263733,
0.39889049530029297,
0.7018898725509644,
-0.10788585245609283,
0.35038119554519653,
0.34643155336380005,
0.0009385021403431892,
0.15537172555923462,
-0.483807772397995,
-0.6307352781295776,
0.8478670120239258,
0.534576416015625,
0.6318221688270569,
-0.06590326130390167,
0.46966418623924255,
0.6591746211051941,
0.2770788073539734,
-1.109593152999878,
0.3998829424381256,
-0.6259615421295166,
-0.5209377408027649,
-0.5824304223060608,
0.15088294446468353,
-0.8948419690132141,
0.6546076536178589,
-0.12478603422641754,
-0.8425775766372681,
0.3785967230796814,
-0.20150959491729736,
-0.2356913983821869,
0.4807538092136383,
-0.30025169253349304,
0.32623860239982605,
-0.22048060595989227,
0.3874667286872864,
-0.01796507090330124,
-0.734387218952179,
0.06576211750507355,
-0.1131414845585823,
0.10453171283006668,
-0.3113969564437866,
-0.18828950822353363,
0.9109575152397156,
-0.9942196607589722,
0.7003123760223389,
0.01144395675510168,
-0.05654146149754524,
0.5080540776252747,
-0.09672456979751587,
0.3363305926322937,
-0.40170714259147644,
-0.602247416973114,
0.5517460703849792,
0.46072107553482056,
-0.15114910900592804,
-0.30948054790496826,
0.054798610508441925,
-0.9655746817588806,
-0.19775281846523285,
-0.26767659187316895,
-0.462211936712265,
-0.43011459708213806,
-0.004609374795109034,
0.5435072183609009,
0.5647894144058228,
-0.3880966007709503,
0.23854249715805054,
0.6626830101013184,
-0.39481449127197266,
0.45351794362068176,
0.8652932047843933,
-0.1362312138080597,
-0.4630891680717468,
1.0445226430892944,
0.4480653703212738,
-0.1991734355688095,
0.6223088502883911,
0.24825003743171692,
-0.7387645244598389,
-0.5302867293357849,
-0.6672160029411316,
0.19891171157360077,
-0.834697961807251,
0.058055222034454346,
-0.8200418949127197,
-0.2918927073478699,
-0.14388757944107056,
-0.052537448704242706,
-0.3124781548976898,
-0.1961323320865631,
-0.33993014693260193,
0.16697274148464203,
0.5568738579750061,
0.9323694705963135,
-0.6523805856704712,
0.5791575312614441,
-0.8726798892021179,
0.49051791429519653,
0.4517326056957245,
0.18995153903961182,
-0.4160377085208893,
-0.47800830006599426,
-0.014279590919613838,
-0.10358182340860367,
0.06237517669796944,
-0.9905834794044495,
0.4284859597682953,
0.6372641921043396,
0.620222270488739,
0.08017577975988388,
-0.11641450971364975,
0.5128886103630066,
-0.34641844034194946,
0.4618515074253082,
0.01422308199107647,
-1.1186996698379517,
0.4622479975223541,
-0.16181562840938568,
-0.009868664667010307,
0.5562614798545837,
0.155694380402565,
-0.9303256273269653,
-0.45673200488090515,
-0.20538052916526794,
-0.44232940673828125,
0.8980692625045776,
0.026249036192893982,
-0.17518815398216248,
0.31504130363464355,
0.08397982269525528,
0.43458792567253113,
0.2314688116312027,
-0.5903685688972473,
-0.20360903441905975,
-0.3045797348022461,
-0.21201810240745544,
-0.21590526401996613,
0.0359334796667099,
-0.06014494597911835,
-0.09503259509801865,
0.7547892332077026,
-0.23086795210838318,
0.04808410629630089,
0.23329879343509674,
-0.2602040767669678,
-0.37989291548728943,
0.1406288743019104,
0.4804154634475708,
0.08204514533281326,
-0.3837299942970276,
-0.04065699502825737,
0.06916190683841705,
-0.9262091517448425,
0.5325085520744324,
0.10641724616289139,
-0.18983834981918335,
0.2616325616836548,
0.5880722403526306,
0.5751290917396545,
0.026835711672902107,
-0.5556153059005737,
0.48013198375701904,
-0.1509217768907547,
-0.23063938319683075,
0.04711480438709259,
-0.16836880147457123,
0.0979844182729721,
0.23948149383068085,
0.2904251515865326,
0.05305549129843712,
0.5234041213989258,
-0.8906278610229492,
0.11307016760110855,
0.14507581293582916,
-0.4824029803276062,
-0.3982090353965759,
0.5953927040100098,
0.31488946080207825,
-0.4508855938911438,
0.6815989017486572,
0.24326592683792114,
-0.2343074381351471,
0.9732293486595154,
0.6833077073097229,
0.8846937417984009,
-0.3901360332965851,
0.28113046288490295,
0.048124682158231735,
0.4140288233757019,
-0.08531861752271652,
0.6336137056350708,
-0.3469528555870056,
-0.49196112155914307,
-0.25362324714660645,
-0.9876499176025391,
-0.9270145297050476,
0.34632813930511475,
-0.71696537733078,
0.11547136306762695,
-0.4887899160385132,
-0.03631839156150818,
0.5147196650505066,
-0.2008359283208847,
-0.3276991844177246,
0.1591716855764389,
0.5558682680130005,
1.087335228919983,
-0.9806876182556152,
1.019972562789917,
0.8670892119407654,
-0.4940802752971649,
-0.6484324932098389,
0.01574242301285267,
-0.034422192722558975,
-0.9106919169425964,
0.821610689163208,
0.2097553014755249,
-0.4117361009120941,
-0.20941999554634094,
-0.6245970726013184,
-0.9200025796890259,
0.7400063276290894,
0.44779083132743835,
-0.6533071994781494,
0.3598534166812897,
0.44891053438186646,
0.7234218716621399,
-0.34733349084854126,
-0.04206807166337967,
0.3689497113227844,
0.5163360238075256,
-0.0998881608247757,
-1.164322853088379,
-0.26152727007865906,
-0.4159182012081146,
0.005116382613778114,
-0.2425372153520584,
-0.9012465476989746,
0.6445411443710327,
0.22094261646270752,
-0.30534520745277405,
0.17007341980934143,
0.7777984738349915,
0.38004106283187866,
0.27949613332748413,
0.691344678401947,
0.11103009432554245,
1.2008742094039917,
0.0799022912979126,
0.5385874509811401,
-0.504237174987793,
-0.20425185561180115,
0.6115996837615967,
-0.34749215841293335,
1.0374565124511719,
0.21456249058246613,
-0.46561887860298157,
0.5988382697105408,
1.0775080919265747,
0.08436563611030579,
0.6238031983375549,
0.4227788746356964,
-0.595411479473114,
-0.1720312535762787,
-0.26865941286087036,
-0.49961280822753906,
0.9603749513626099,
0.7122932076454163,
-0.0232828501611948,
0.12016218900680542,
0.2848680019378662,
-0.5560975074768066,
-0.07310313731431961,
-0.2287314087152481,
0.9872459769248962,
0.050537895411252975,
-0.515993058681488,
0.4577925205230713,
-0.25366684794425964,
0.8932149410247803,
-0.6721097230911255,
-0.3142877221107483,
-0.09538774937391281,
-0.2713376581668854,
-0.07768552750349045,
-0.6793318390846252,
0.2330116182565689,
-0.12632746994495392,
-0.15114063024520874,
0.1054675430059433,
0.5131081938743591,
-0.5893614888191223,
-0.07182782888412476,
0.49172282218933105,
0.013824685476720333,
0.6857455372810364,
-0.023697184398770332,
-0.7131592631340027,
0.22936977446079254,
-0.27209892868995667,
-0.03402278572320938,
-0.012852066196501255,
0.3637051582336426,
-0.31860625743865967,
0.8693581819534302,
0.4884949028491974,
0.4074108898639679,
0.03953656926751137,
-0.10537365078926086,
0.41086551547050476,
-0.6241562366485596,
-0.9475749731063843,
-0.5098202228546143,
0.013289456255733967,
0.34205830097198486,
0.01790068857371807,
0.11642348766326904,
0.41514626145362854,
0.5998785495758057,
-0.10541801899671555,
1.1293470859527588,
0.32593291997909546,
0.6700616478919983,
-0.5485898852348328,
0.7199705243110657,
-0.5787767171859741,
0.2661817669868469,
-0.14747896790504456,
-0.9513296484947205,
-0.348758339881897,
0.2391396313905716,
0.1722387671470642,
-0.29102107882499695,
0.5541220903396606,
0.8209021091461182,
-0.06524109095335007,
0.21742132306098938,
0.5844011306762695,
-0.11339614540338516,
0.06557410210371017,
0.03455427289009094,
1.0777896642684937,
-0.2058054804801941,
0.7274746298789978,
-0.3207712471485138,
-0.103447824716568,
-0.37937429547309875,
-0.5439422130584717,
-0.31115612387657166,
-0.737865149974823,
-0.30325204133987427,
-0.21052557229995728,
0.24805299937725067,
0.9896250367164612,
0.8815358281135559,
-0.701444685459137,
-0.48738721013069153,
0.42755696177482605,
0.05754000321030617,
-0.3763858675956726,
-0.05971742421388626,
0.3928191661834717,
-0.27017417550086975,
-0.9467770457267761,
0.8514717221260071,
0.7756015658378601,
0.346159964799881,
-0.3913828134536743,
-0.17319634556770325,
0.11489958316087723,
0.5923051834106445,
0.6110062599182129,
1.1496976613998413,
-0.9116721749305725,
-0.30852556228637695,
-0.2727137804031372,
-0.3122479021549225,
0.4948124587535858,
0.5040785074234009,
-0.610517144203186,
0.719624936580658,
0.5150713920593262,
0.44514232873916626,
0.3613932728767395,
-0.2147846817970276,
0.5335358381271362,
-0.4533592462539673,
0.46443867683410645,
0.11231600493192673,
0.3752833902835846,
0.35680803656578064,
-0.25706711411476135,
0.6789986491203308,
0.23302337527275085,
-0.31310537457466125,
-0.8745049834251404,
-0.019134970381855965,
-1.1498018503189087,
-0.44717398285865784,
0.947135865688324,
-0.28660163283348083,
-0.5642601251602173,
-0.26619696617126465,
-0.23816357553005219,
0.4230167269706726,
-0.3802371323108673,
0.6613857746124268,
0.47918713092803955,
-0.25448042154312134,
0.2955206036567688,
-0.04181433096528053,
0.7105390429496765,
0.14355246722698212,
-0.7976260185241699,
-0.1482364535331726,
0.16253691911697388,
0.2916087806224823,
0.36055687069892883,
1.0215548276901245,
-0.2614404857158661,
0.29439613223075867,
0.3564341068267822,
0.48721230030059814,
0.4123407006263733,
-0.38449203968048096,
-0.48149555921554565,
-0.13038213551044464,
0.30020672082901,
-0.5676345229148865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03268v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03268v3 | Understanding Reasoning Ability of Language Models From the Perspective of Reasoning Paths Aggregation | 2024-02-05T18:25:51 | 2024-06-20T18:46:06 | Xinyi Wang, Alfonso Amayuelas, Kexun Zhang, Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) are able to perform complex reasoning
without explicit fine-tuning. To understand how pre-training with a next-token
prediction objective contributes to the emergence of such reasoning capability,
we propose that we can view an LM as deriving new conclusions by aggregating
indirect reasoning paths seen at pre-training time. We found this perspective
effective in two important cases of reasoning: logic reasoning with knowledge
graphs (KGs) and chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. More specifically, we
formalize the reasoning paths as random walk paths on the knowledge/reasoning
graphs. Analyses of learned LM distributions suggest that a weighted sum of
relevant random walk path probabilities is a reasonable way to explain how LMs
reason. Experiments and analysis on multiple KG and CoT datasets reveal the
effect of training on random walk paths and suggest that augmenting unlabeled
random walk reasoning paths can improve real-world multi-step reasoning
performance. code: https://github.com/WANGXinyiLinda/LM_random_walk | [
-0.21643370389938354,
-0.8218469619750977,
1.1562703847885132,
-0.2697376608848572,
-0.27711862325668335,
0.090423084795475,
0.037588801234960556,
-0.6177331805229187,
-0.029887763783335686,
0.6399978995323181,
-0.4583887755870819,
-0.31137725710868835,
-0.655957818031311,
-0.17257370054721832,
-0.5360698699951172,
0.7535141110420227,
-0.07439631968736649,
0.17031557857990265,
-0.3470345139503479,
-0.17749424278736115,
-0.3870407044887543,
-0.45499566197395325,
-0.7612093091011047,
-0.5232268571853638,
0.6790812015533447,
0.1687687486410141,
0.871948778629303,
0.5580438375473022,
0.280428409576416,
0.292574405670166,
0.0006053638062439859,
0.13064134120941162,
-0.21862030029296875,
0.15429748594760895,
-0.25669360160827637,
-0.6592796444892883,
-0.43032723665237427,
0.049768585711717606,
0.6475130319595337,
0.9615114331245422,
0.07155115902423859,
-0.028463497757911682,
-0.30981510877609253,
0.6688687205314636,
-0.4591248631477356,
-0.29040423035621643,
-0.6054719686508179,
0.05213769152760506,
-0.3733227252960205,
-0.2972293794155121,
-0.5833346843719482,
-0.2815057635307312,
0.29070010781288147,
-0.42900803685188293,
-0.07448453456163406,
0.2651330530643463,
0.5988535284996033,
0.07381341606378555,
-0.5456356406211853,
-0.32124170660972595,
-0.7511111497879028,
0.5782843828201294,
-0.46444517374038696,
0.5255115628242493,
0.39183309674263,
0.6291910409927368,
-0.20853453874588013,
-0.9821493029594421,
-0.3980656862258911,
-0.21249274909496307,
-0.3190833032131195,
-0.3112145662307739,
-0.007097980473190546,
0.10001868009567261,
0.24347393214702606,
0.15056198835372925,
-0.40501174330711365,
-0.006610495503991842,
-0.3015076220035553,
-0.2128753513097763,
0.579616904258728,
0.02942880243062973,
0.2780245542526245,
0.2463688850402832,
-0.1658891886472702,
-0.04077466204762459,
-0.7560062408447266,
0.2524748146533966,
0.40851151943206787,
0.15543296933174133,
0.02777700312435627,
0.4674200713634491,
-0.17213447391986847,
1.1897644996643066,
-0.31195327639579773,
-0.025709757581353188,
0.28318771719932556,
-0.4569118916988373,
-0.07710408419370651,
0.08554799109697342,
0.708747386932373,
-0.1844743937253952,
0.6987075209617615,
-0.4156281352043152,
-0.16017261147499084,
-0.3158641755580902,
0.21207953989505768,
-0.4691210091114044,
-0.3977118730545044,
0.1967584639787674,
-0.5104754567146301,
-0.19907018542289734,
-0.0562349371612072,
-0.13587981462478638,
-0.49445560574531555,
-0.4225420355796814,
0.45631489157676697,
-0.5835922360420227,
-0.4135743975639343,
0.25350821018218994,
-0.2379968911409378,
0.17556273937225342,
0.531520664691925,
-0.558310329914093,
0.325405478477478,
0.5306811928749084,
0.6940610408782959,
0.10489685833454132,
-0.52540522813797,
-0.6358041167259216,
0.12623117864131927,
-0.4276662766933441,
1.0654916763305664,
-0.5976023077964783,
-0.12828995287418365,
-0.285489022731781,
-0.2724960744380951,
-0.26419657468795776,
-0.3281950056552887,
0.47039639949798584,
-0.5218743681907654,
-0.07865647971630096,
-0.3016151189804077,
-0.5117895007133484,
-0.20747439563274384,
0.1863831728696823,
-0.3367508053779602,
0.8281275033950806,
0.05414283648133278,
-0.6828537583351135,
0.5396504998207092,
-0.4539049565792084,
-0.7386489510536194,
-0.10535804182291031,
-0.13415086269378662,
0.2173565924167633,
0.0010841353796422482,
0.21570318937301636,
0.49161189794540405,
-0.1961677074432373,
0.25749123096466064,
-0.3399987816810608,
-0.23390212655067444,
0.3345213830471039,
-0.4376271367073059,
0.9561529755592346,
0.34634315967559814,
-0.1277763992547989,
0.318254679441452,
-0.8303945064544678,
0.18276724219322205,
0.12061449140310287,
-0.046347588300704956,
-0.6037577986717224,
0.44173717498779297,
-0.6318145394325256,
0.5486627817153931,
0.007313855923712254,
0.01186537928879261,
0.18747109174728394,
-0.2979690730571747,
0.07713828980922699,
1.0069730281829834,
-0.10133767127990723,
0.5301046371459961,
-0.07066644728183746,
0.5020126104354858,
0.23767638206481934,
0.26852157711982727,
-0.1091226115822792,
-0.58724045753479,
-0.6797318458557129,
0.115635946393013,
0.08598903566598892,
0.26948636770248413,
-0.45355790853500366,
0.1934630572795868,
-0.15442651510238647,
-0.6263968348503113,
-0.3552619218826294,
0.08462558686733246,
0.3523409366607666,
0.5698207020759583,
0.33332520723342896,
-0.20386168360710144,
-0.4991738796234131,
-0.37569233775138855,
-0.6821399927139282,
-0.3331153392791748,
0.19706599414348602,
0.3276878893375397,
0.423781156539917,
-0.07474658638238907,
0.9393154978752136,
-0.5019478797912598,
0.2753988206386566,
-0.4768013656139374,
0.04878135770559311,
0.3105681240558624,
0.3833586871623993,
0.3665103018283844,
-0.7739424109458923,
-0.26384174823760986,
-0.12508954107761383,
-0.5636892914772034,
-0.11056511104106903,
-0.1400340050458908,
-0.6072192788124084,
-0.18392960727214813,
0.7714589834213257,
-0.7756588459014893,
0.40837571024894714,
0.25981029868125916,
-0.7424432039260864,
0.8166214227676392,
-0.2664971649646759,
-0.028856433928012848,
-0.6930921673774719,
-0.33898109197616577,
-0.2507477402687073,
-0.4089765250682831,
-0.5321611166000366,
-0.19898225367069244,
-0.5714350342750549,
0.2718844711780548,
-0.26602834463119507,
0.5178313255310059,
-0.4077026844024658,
-0.5230176448822021,
-0.07020732015371323,
0.3696557879447937,
-0.0736367255449295,
0.3532293736934662,
0.0295500960201025,
0.3408656120300293,
0.8313562273979187,
-0.9338853359222412,
0.32135578989982605,
-0.23999130725860596,
-0.46727073192596436,
0.2879222333431244,
-0.4412021040916443,
0.3104425072669983,
-0.09274055063724518,
0.45428401231765747,
-0.8770520687103271,
-0.03173872455954552,
0.2053479105234146,
-0.5134558081626892,
0.06388906389474869,
-0.05319206789135933,
-0.5184605121612549,
-0.4474097788333893,
0.1527310609817505,
0.6161829233169556,
0.38081008195877075,
-0.4713090658187866,
0.9685788154602051,
0.3243931829929352,
0.46856850385665894,
-0.4946347177028656,
-0.5228419899940491,
-0.2674161493778229,
-0.11659154295921326,
-0.6581997871398926,
-0.06681155413389206,
-0.09814032912254333,
-0.6268162727355957,
0.06853354722261429,
-0.11523254215717316,
-0.04024507850408554,
0.3559739291667938,
0.2554444968700409,
-0.08069970458745956,
-0.13765759766101837,
0.3007654845714569,
-0.0913940966129303,
-0.0755225121974945,
0.3853515684604645,
-0.5764774084091187,
0.801036536693573,
-0.12503938376903534,
-0.7754015922546387,
-0.0418848991394043,
-0.06543789803981781,
0.42104852199554443,
-0.19742567837238312,
0.9743395447731018,
0.5905642509460449,
-0.270284503698349,
-0.04498261585831642,
-0.1957787275314331,
-0.024782132357358932,
-0.401673287153244,
0.21157406270503998,
-0.5920959115028381,
-0.6762069463729858,
0.39272040128707886,
-0.18337413668632507,
-0.04234511777758598,
0.4539586901664734,
0.34615233540534973,
-0.11603040248155594,
1.274452567100525,
0.36771515011787415,
0.13433873653411865,
0.23029860854148865,
-0.15523022413253784,
0.5520076155662537,
-0.6040833592414856,
-0.46864649653434753,
-0.5071428418159485,
-0.03758249804377556,
-0.37880730628967285,
-0.585258424282074,
0.07306680828332901,
0.6755001544952393,
-0.5220513343811035,
0.1535780280828476,
-0.1395026445388794,
0.49588149785995483,
0.5437328815460205,
0.06498263031244278,
0.3267086148262024,
-0.27826622128486633,
-0.45814064145088196,
0.5159315466880798,
-0.9066278338432312,
-0.4216047525405884,
0.9465889930725098,
0.32360365986824036,
0.5992894172668457,
-0.043925411999225616,
0.6611954569816589,
0.13463380932807922,
0.21806849539279938,
-0.6842787265777588,
0.7388935685157776,
0.1142783910036087,
-0.5219924449920654,
-0.45607468485832214,
-0.480991929769516,
-0.6670024394989014,
0.226081982254982,
-0.2113114595413208,
-0.9833669066429138,
-0.1219249740242958,
0.5487877130508423,
-0.2083217352628708,
0.5143657922744751,
-0.7896592020988464,
0.8011357188224792,
-0.5736045241355896,
-0.26731839776039124,
-0.3208148181438446,
-0.8863925337791443,
0.4386775493621826,
0.06105346977710724,
0.4903755486011505,
0.02056329883635044,
0.4403395652770996,
0.8644551634788513,
-0.627632200717926,
0.41706383228302,
-0.2115347534418106,
0.03474554419517517,
0.6708800196647644,
0.13855060935020447,
0.5591233372688293,
-0.3269173204898834,
0.1324293166399002,
0.048315275460481644,
-0.23957549035549164,
-0.3124222755432129,
-0.7107246518135071,
0.25490307807922363,
-0.5762152671813965,
-0.7676798701286316,
-0.3906456530094147,
-0.5200353264808655,
-0.6093273758888245,
0.3029562830924988,
0.24221907556056976,
0.2912968099117279,
0.11197493970394135,
-0.00964860338717699,
0.47443845868110657,
-0.04568399116396904,
0.20069195330142975,
0.2712475061416626,
-0.5598570108413696,
0.01102393213659525,
0.5569971799850464,
0.1286342889070511,
0.5321809649467468,
0.5041442513465881,
0.4103406071662903,
-0.42512354254722595,
-0.6939777135848999,
-0.12425494939088821,
0.055002279579639435,
-1.0097192525863647,
0.33303579688072205,
-0.6828466057777405,
-0.29664358496665955,
-0.5054811835289001,
-0.13544581830501556,
-0.10933085530996323,
-0.5312069654464722,
0.03009052574634552,
-0.5646558403968811,
0.39038342237472534,
0.7691784501075745,
-0.10076862573623657,
0.3726995885372162,
-0.7550842761993408,
0.12310004234313965,
0.4029947817325592,
0.22691316902637482,
0.3989350497722626,
-0.4379144608974457,
-0.46246039867401123,
0.048700422048568726,
-0.05616287514567375,
-0.7149991989135742,
0.007031820248812437,
-0.19482527673244476,
0.749913215637207,
0.6707595586776733,
-0.30093899369239807,
0.8939899206161499,
-0.5548911690711975,
0.7468321323394775,
0.30970218777656555,
-0.7136423587799072,
0.6889783143997192,
-0.31967490911483765,
0.310893177986145,
0.38169437646865845,
0.3963793218135834,
-0.22875835001468658,
-0.4121277630329132,
-0.7589903473854065,
-0.7406420707702637,
0.7841967940330505,
0.20682194828987122,
-0.2417782098054886,
0.08244825154542923,
0.1904246062040329,
-0.1007041335105896,
-0.011575622484087944,
-0.7773293852806091,
-0.26999759674072266,
-0.12068729102611542,
-0.016655022278428078,
-0.29118138551712036,
-0.20204097032546997,
-0.0444207563996315,
-0.6383755207061768,
0.6058767437934875,
0.03545084595680237,
0.03547035530209541,
-0.03222529590129852,
-0.22847552597522736,
-0.05978520214557648,
0.06238497421145439,
0.295789897441864,
0.8327070474624634,
-0.15293993055820465,
0.5199593901634216,
0.053884945809841156,
-0.3159298896789551,
0.10680586844682693,
-0.07177992910146713,
0.263426274061203,
-0.16169019043445587,
0.7529191374778748,
1.0843485593795776,
-0.06380131840705872,
-0.7302069664001465,
0.3051649332046509,
-0.009057432413101196,
-0.09849685430526733,
-0.2415827512741089,
0.3722957968711853,
0.2533178925514221,
0.23500743508338928,
0.2264254242181778,
0.398834228515625,
0.04022497683763504,
-0.6816322207450867,
0.09203241020441055,
0.2638891637325287,
-0.3954712450504303,
-0.33542969822883606,
0.4682738482952118,
0.023302963003516197,
-0.2937832772731781,
0.6343364715576172,
-0.15458030998706818,
-0.5205681324005127,
0.5757250189781189,
0.45735833048820496,
0.8099173307418823,
-0.14782404899597168,
0.12623071670532227,
0.2183864563703537,
0.4356950521469116,
-0.22991500794887543,
-0.12092864513397217,
-0.29062584042549133,
-1.156550645828247,
-0.4261619448661804,
-0.7005329132080078,
-0.08277954161167145,
-0.05205386504530907,
-0.3309730589389801,
0.2626189589500427,
-0.2213393598794937,
0.03279371187090874,
-0.2439388483762741,
-0.34536343812942505,
-0.6528017520904541,
0.5339035391807556,
0.03387569263577461,
1.0206118822097778,
-0.9664071202278137,
0.8023667335510254,
0.6916384100914001,
-0.3618124723434448,
-1.319914698600769,
0.07516861706972122,
-0.3455297648906708,
-0.8712655901908875,
0.6509157419204712,
0.21603980660438538,
-0.40518319606781006,
-0.08885114639997482,
-0.4857825040817261,
-0.9701810479164124,
1.0434560775756836,
0.3267747461795807,
-0.4430832862854004,
-0.02772725559771061,
0.15344108641147614,
0.5027465224266052,
-0.47869983315467834,
0.4671128988265991,
0.756635844707489,
0.27009090781211853,
0.24056215584278107,
-0.578325092792511,
0.01335950754582882,
0.024884402751922607,
-0.2672334909439087,
0.2078934609889984,
-0.33753064274787903,
0.9551872611045837,
-0.505877673625946,
0.1243663802742958,
-0.20093418657779694,
0.4472009539604187,
0.7142961621284485,
0.49337953329086304,
0.803996741771698,
0.7100502848625183,
0.9241013526916504,
0.03843450918793678,
1.3943802118301392,
-0.23649419844150543,
-0.1437244564294815,
1.2086678743362427,
-0.24508881568908691,
0.3662969470024109,
0.45530304312705994,
-0.20484115183353424,
0.9806909561157227,
0.7944343686103821,
0.6605583429336548,
0.5634423494338989,
0.2638589143753052,
-0.15645182132720947,
-0.6405627727508545,
0.0766996368765831,
-0.2009023129940033,
0.3840692639350891,
0.324053019285202,
-0.49036863446235657,
-0.02355724200606346,
-0.24153520166873932,
0.025742916390299797,
-0.10758410394191742,
-0.6488938331604004,
0.3675200939178467,
0.287652850151062,
-0.8438517451286316,
0.18761003017425537,
-0.3371288478374481,
-0.07008238881826401,
-0.8145325779914856,
-0.13238021731376648,
0.1609049141407013,
0.041432809084653854,
-0.3145383894443512,
-0.8792322874069214,
0.2224770337343216,
-0.10025777667760849,
0.013829883188009262,
-0.31125274300575256,
1.021485447883606,
-0.11858291178941727,
-0.33488595485687256,
0.5149001479148865,
0.7503029704093933,
0.43344414234161377,
0.1530703753232956,
-0.5518236756324768,
-0.37866923213005066,
-0.044194385409355164,
-0.5286258459091187,
0.4038471579551697,
0.9010788798332214,
-0.35361558198928833,
0.8615000247955322,
0.8134463429450989,
0.17638926208019257,
0.19058990478515625,
0.5615371465682983,
0.7874580025672913,
-0.5635952949523926,
-0.48486992716789246,
-1.0442630052566528,
0.5626468658447266,
-0.1174270361661911,
-0.23416712880134583,
0.6387885808944702,
0.3579312860965729,
0.8302281498908997,
0.10797282308340073,
0.6959879994392395,
-0.012553902342915535,
0.3111405372619629,
-0.8936956524848938,
0.5049282312393188,
-0.49094417691230774,
0.4059091806411743,
-0.24638549983501434,
-0.6325212121009827,
-0.046923402696847916,
0.7611215710639954,
-0.6062641739845276,
0.32612231373786926,
1.0302609205245972,
0.43595415353775024,
0.011640764772891998,
-0.17442932724952698,
0.16356338560581207,
0.2786256670951843,
0.19818106293678284,
0.48115113377571106,
0.9267808794975281,
0.0635756105184555,
0.5742928385734558,
-0.09352850914001465,
-0.08407541364431381,
0.3056578040122986,
-0.9443849921226501,
-0.7929741144180298,
-0.3765861392021179,
-0.12514916062355042,
-0.408562034368515,
-0.04589257016777992,
0.5877801775932312,
0.716854453086853,
-0.5885614156723022,
-0.26830509305000305,
-0.9243106245994568,
0.5991745591163635,
-0.31401559710502625,
-0.27500078082084656,
0.3249700665473938,
-0.4384751319885254,
-0.15917624533176422,
0.23226884007453918,
0.2114083617925644,
-0.04977404698729515,
-0.15965121984481812,
-0.41744688153266907,
-0.5281833410263062,
0.07877819240093231,
0.5871080160140991,
0.05922134965658188,
-0.5103492736816406,
-0.3378603756427765,
-0.16452907025814056,
0.15462034940719604,
-0.07462425529956818,
1.073058009147644,
-0.9858278632164001,
0.43190667033195496,
0.587314248085022,
0.2355712503194809,
0.41146671772003174,
-0.0954418033361435,
0.7626076340675354,
-0.5409904718399048,
0.22055521607398987,
0.23489034175872803,
0.7065900564193726,
0.09514780342578888,
-0.24940961599349976,
0.663522481918335,
0.41379299759864807,
-0.4781252443790436,
-0.8284371495246887,
0.5394254326820374,
-0.7257176041603088,
-0.45959585905075073,
1.2283439636230469,
-0.18878713250160217,
-0.22439278662204742,
-0.17167827486991882,
-0.05312914028763771,
0.4862903654575348,
0.03807013854384422,
0.3810957670211792,
0.818954348564148,
-0.7331992983818054,
-0.20470401644706726,
-0.4601385295391083,
0.5637209415435791,
0.245738223195076,
-0.8156307339668274,
-0.11241941154003143,
0.44277769327163696,
0.052621662616729736,
0.25857222080230713,
1.152492642402649,
-0.06690613925457001,
0.07293947786092758,
0.016475893557071686,
-0.4511520266532898,
0.012329446151852608,
-0.5062932968139648,
0.03196240961551666,
-0.1377575844526291,
0.35059452056884766,
-0.023160161450505257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03244v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03244v2 | Skill Set Optimization: Reinforcing Language Model Behavior via Transferable Skills | 2024-02-05T17:59:00 | 2024-06-22T18:58:09 | Kolby Nottingham, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Sameer Singh, Peter Clark, Roy Fox | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently been used for sequential decision
making in interactive environments. However, leveraging environment reward
signals for continual LLM actor improvement is not straightforward. We propose
Skill Set Optimization (SSO) for improving LLM actor performance through
constructing and refining sets of transferable skills. SSO constructs skills by
extracting common subtrajectories with high rewards and generating subgoals and
instructions to represent each skill. These skills are provided to the LLM
actor in-context to reinforce behaviors with high rewards. Then, SSO further
refines the skill set by pruning skills that do not continue to result in high
rewards. We evaluate our method in the classic videogame NetHack and the text
environment ScienceWorld to demonstrate SSO's ability to optimize a set of
skills and perform in-context policy improvement. SSO outperforms baselines by
40% in our custom NetHack task and outperforms the previous state-of-the-art in
ScienceWorld by 35%. | [
-0.0592757873237133,
-0.5058218240737915,
0.3942386507987976,
0.3245663642883301,
-0.03263296186923981,
0.45038214325904846,
-0.47997966408729553,
-0.19862239062786102,
0.006540984380990267,
0.5698264241218567,
-0.9356846213340759,
-0.05931442975997925,
-0.5533793568611145,
0.04819965362548828,
0.2317807823419571,
0.8931986093521118,
-0.017466245219111443,
-0.3033662438392639,
-0.4600854516029358,
0.03175733983516693,
-0.5179048776626587,
-0.21547169983386993,
-1.0082563161849976,
-0.6190176010131836,
0.4110608994960785,
0.829702615737915,
0.3259909749031067,
0.7735493183135986,
0.5104044079780579,
0.424409419298172,
-0.147154301404953,
0.4850633442401886,
-1.0712496042251587,
0.20120392739772797,
-0.35340094566345215,
-0.29380127787590027,
-0.14024928212165833,
-0.14694422483444214,
0.7296271920204163,
0.34697866439819336,
-0.2243949919939041,
0.10168412327766418,
-0.024054666981101036,
0.4623212218284607,
-0.6421215534210205,
0.28849467635154724,
-0.6211332082748413,
0.19907981157302856,
0.31306275725364685,
-0.4334726929664612,
-0.35045209527015686,
-0.2910505533218384,
-0.1106482669711113,
-1.113481879234314,
-0.2108883112668991,
0.043682221323251724,
0.8621185421943665,
0.4824320375919342,
-0.10356791317462921,
0.033214833587408066,
-0.6789184808731079,
1.0973992347717285,
-0.7607064247131348,
0.06508851796388626,
0.35269367694854736,
0.05509030073881149,
-0.44232335686683655,
-0.35891127586364746,
-0.5460152626037598,
-0.25797563791275024,
0.2061241865158081,
0.20459714531898499,
0.12321678549051285,
0.06446266919374466,
0.326907217502594,
-0.12665919959545135,
-0.1014299988746643,
0.4496802091598511,
-0.3619726002216339,
-0.08383770287036896,
0.7719767093658447,
0.2379280924797058,
0.2534908354282379,
0.2509363293647766,
-0.03045842982828617,
-0.4115711450576782,
-0.5061160922050476,
0.4331485629081726,
0.22576452791690826,
0.22826185822486877,
0.1014038473367691,
0.28424736857414246,
-0.17469817399978638,
0.5818586945533752,
-0.057913888245821,
-0.6734886765480042,
-0.0958818718791008,
-0.46304163336753845,
0.2017837017774582,
-0.13551144301891327,
0.13321425020694733,
0.32235604524612427,
0.5562229752540588,
-0.02364436350762844,
-0.23135650157928467,
-0.1944098025560379,
0.63437819480896,
-0.5950949192047119,
0.08528189361095428,
0.08292720466852188,
-0.23359951376914978,
-0.6522467732429504,
-0.25214654207229614,
-0.40765097737312317,
-0.39548978209495544,
-0.5308736562728882,
0.34836989641189575,
-0.44215425848960876,
-0.1782306432723999,
-0.16091759502887726,
-0.2901461124420166,
0.1334248036146164,
0.3550399839878082,
-1.0632752180099487,
0.25110381841659546,
0.8461530804634094,
0.7531545758247375,
-0.1940210461616516,
-0.3896898627281189,
-0.8124409317970276,
0.5458040833473206,
-0.47450217604637146,
0.7814545035362244,
-0.8202964663505554,
-0.4305524528026581,
-0.013085921294987202,
-0.050976432859897614,
-0.04322749748826027,
-0.523801863193512,
0.36255404353141785,
-0.3616160452365875,
-0.07510623335838318,
-0.17363087832927704,
-0.47942936420440674,
0.2029968798160553,
0.23945467174053192,
-0.5169373154640198,
0.8909097909927368,
0.20148813724517822,
-0.06758269667625427,
0.496769517660141,
-0.8651690483093262,
-0.6235423684120178,
0.029604710638523102,
0.054572220891714096,
-0.19983604550361633,
0.1758088618516922,
0.35610806941986084,
0.24864086508750916,
0.15659548342227936,
-0.015613402239978313,
-0.29314154386520386,
-0.7731224298477173,
0.042476411908864975,
0.2223118096590042,
0.3510934114456177,
0.12102290242910385,
-0.22341766953468323,
0.3166824281215668,
-0.38509729504585266,
0.35356342792510986,
-0.015756092965602875,
-0.5571922659873962,
-0.24742165207862854,
0.26903989911079407,
-0.2300180196762085,
0.23241488635540009,
0.11603669822216034,
-0.2770620286464691,
0.28836551308631897,
-0.4471892714500427,
0.4129370450973511,
1.1452523469924927,
0.15674610435962677,
0.39174216985702515,
-0.36104509234428406,
0.6928489804267883,
-0.16390810906887054,
0.24895510077476501,
0.24543671309947968,
-0.06233782693743706,
-0.7315089702606201,
-0.32430848479270935,
-0.21734417974948883,
0.5888648629188538,
-0.9588863253593445,
0.5329801440238953,
-0.29728949069976807,
-0.342068076133728,
-0.3964154124259949,
0.08690616488456726,
0.4076884090900421,
0.41584038734436035,
0.10570082813501358,
-0.15615995228290558,
-0.32884132862091064,
-0.8541843891143799,
-0.26456329226493835,
-0.17060622572898865,
0.26019421219825745,
0.3707709014415741,
0.3943052589893341,
0.1667088270187378,
0.6648455858230591,
-0.3519395887851715,
0.017112785950303078,
-0.32058992981910706,
-0.2115856111049652,
0.31326255202293396,
0.4636167883872986,
0.004338135477155447,
-0.5896224975585938,
-0.38068684935569763,
0.34489959478378296,
-0.8204656839370728,
-0.18113532662391663,
-0.21565194427967072,
-0.05745091289281845,
0.26005545258522034,
0.7104921340942383,
-0.11758460849523544,
0.20265835523605347,
0.5318964719772339,
-0.2245706021785736,
0.5253809690475464,
-0.27425241470336914,
0.2652417719364166,
-0.7436132431030273,
0.3113247752189636,
-0.32416996359825134,
-0.2409714013338089,
-0.566837728023529,
0.2918379306793213,
-0.38234174251556396,
-0.30614182353019714,
-0.36148878931999207,
0.8677462935447693,
-0.3872115910053253,
-0.12035062164068222,
-0.43350499868392944,
0.20621377229690552,
-0.2412310093641281,
0.7466137409210205,
0.17652353644371033,
0.9228105545043945,
0.46504858136177063,
-0.8526337146759033,
0.3088946044445038,
0.3831256926059723,
-0.4550131559371948,
0.7228143811225891,
-0.52845299243927,
0.2686094343662262,
-0.16941946744918823,
0.19728516042232513,
-0.39303484559059143,
-0.041458696126937866,
-0.1524430215358734,
-0.0800878033041954,
0.11229772120714188,
-0.22150947153568268,
-0.20564748346805573,
-0.12470919638872147,
-0.24989084899425507,
0.03751571476459503,
0.6868751049041748,
-0.4553031921386719,
0.3467434346675873,
0.30854925513267517,
-0.16639502346515656,
-0.8704935312271118,
-0.2653255760669708,
-0.09211704134941101,
-0.2712899446487427,
-0.5806835889816284,
0.4663563072681427,
-0.11373040080070496,
-0.28369221091270447,
-0.14548276364803314,
-0.41425320506095886,
0.1857742816209793,
0.14349818229675293,
-0.02285408414900303,
-0.006939741782844067,
0.1346847265958786,
0.20521126687526703,
0.110533706843853,
-0.2035120278596878,
-0.14516369998455048,
-0.19773700833320618,
0.2342986911535263,
-0.0241635050624609,
-0.09291532635688782,
-0.04176627844572067,
0.14388792216777802,
0.14115473628044128,
-0.04746824502944946,
0.8094444870948792,
0.4337989389896393,
-0.13779406249523163,
-0.6049527525901794,
-0.4494037628173828,
-0.4035837948322296,
-0.546074390411377,
0.7516140937805176,
-0.4373449385166168,
-1.23727285861969,
0.34400632977485657,
-0.4143424332141876,
0.36510297656059265,
-0.11534010618925095,
0.23100149631500244,
-0.23211300373077393,
0.7240062355995178,
0.6486687660217285,
0.004351318813860416,
0.8524828553199768,
-0.1779492199420929,
0.15445494651794434,
-0.9273437261581421,
-0.1417287141084671,
-0.16618815064430237,
-0.4951428771018982,
-0.3249908685684204,
-0.4505404829978943,
0.4900779724121094,
0.265656441450119,
-0.519209623336792,
0.3337552547454834,
-0.3355482816696167,
0.9064198136329651,
0.5542312860488892,
0.28361600637435913,
0.18715445697307587,
0.2911263108253479,
-0.003319251351058483,
-0.042332593351602554,
-0.9627641439437866,
-0.5282920598983765,
0.8713912963867188,
0.25202667713165283,
0.5141061544418335,
0.24799750745296478,
0.8029382824897766,
0.19362880289554596,
0.26366305351257324,
-0.6457676887512207,
0.7636823654174805,
-0.306511253118515,
-0.2283530980348587,
-0.7388159036636353,
-0.5652191638946533,
-0.847602903842926,
0.17232897877693176,
-0.34265872836112976,
-1.0339467525482178,
0.07219837605953217,
0.23049530386924744,
-0.03414110466837883,
0.08870669454336166,
-0.548484742641449,
0.7748024463653564,
-0.01588490977883339,
-0.6523935794830322,
-0.778992772102356,
-0.4616616368293762,
0.23017330467700958,
-0.021021666005253792,
0.10233236104249954,
-0.18707546591758728,
-0.2691192030906677,
0.3320213854312897,
-0.29616788029670715,
0.648648202419281,
-0.08671537786722183,
0.10493238270282745,
0.027646195143461227,
0.118714340031147,
0.8398314118385315,
-0.0534977912902832,
-0.34806308150291443,
-0.16251349449157715,
0.13111495971679688,
-0.531632125377655,
-0.7648947238922119,
0.7369133830070496,
-0.8140197396278381,
-0.5937122702598572,
-0.1791294515132904,
-0.4853936433792114,
-0.49421393871307373,
-0.018859272822737694,
-0.05657530203461647,
0.23721614480018616,
-0.3526793122291565,
0.18955844640731812,
0.8076238632202148,
-0.2886330485343933,
0.586108386516571,
0.3534470796585083,
0.181412011384964,
-0.24067270755767822,
0.9983794689178467,
-0.34716716408729553,
0.5490947961807251,
0.3623661994934082,
0.2796330749988556,
-0.04441902041435242,
-0.45268288254737854,
-0.09436296671628952,
0.133310467004776,
-0.7658798098564148,
-0.08856140077114105,
-0.13788384199142456,
-0.261243611574173,
-0.3392496705055237,
-0.47640204429626465,
-0.04968408867716789,
-0.2785911560058594,
-0.1542997509241104,
-0.05662861093878746,
0.374443918466568,
0.4837547540664673,
-0.3197402358055115,
0.4212699830532074,
-0.5707831978797913,
-0.009225754998624325,
0.2800685167312622,
0.3682865798473358,
0.019318165257573128,
-0.7209331393241882,
-0.5731079578399658,
-0.21282190084457397,
-0.14168982207775116,
-0.34869280457496643,
0.3479640781879425,
0.458883672952652,
0.7902214527130127,
0.28329354524612427,
-0.26958146691322327,
0.8173948526382446,
-0.46469396352767944,
0.386371374130249,
-0.006703745573759079,
-0.8397296667098999,
0.6764423847198486,
-0.36215925216674805,
0.5931358337402344,
0.8027741312980652,
0.13365378975868225,
-0.7813698053359985,
-0.32558247447013855,
-0.5804794430732727,
-0.6875203847885132,
1.1097517013549805,
0.29670438170433044,
0.2653493583202362,
0.221333310008049,
0.5224876403808594,
-0.1343299299478531,
0.2715509533882141,
-0.6898607611656189,
0.22003254294395447,
0.017568185925483704,
-0.08826399594545364,
-0.11020011454820633,
0.12290892004966736,
-0.4657239317893982,
-0.25311365723609924,
0.9795132279396057,
-0.5473547577857971,
0.2144971787929535,
-0.05819164961576462,
-0.029104385524988174,
-0.21050089597702026,
0.0759631097316742,
0.8594716787338257,
0.7976911664009094,
-0.06297776848077774,
-0.19223003089427948,
0.33957627415657043,
-0.4253670275211334,
0.2693229615688324,
-0.25342434644699097,
0.11492068320512772,
-0.6201122999191284,
0.6627724766731262,
0.8234438896179199,
0.3291739523410797,
-0.9772550463676453,
0.16601695120334625,
0.41271886229515076,
-0.08943808078765869,
-0.44242560863494873,
0.6616482734680176,
0.044448062777519226,
0.3317109942436218,
0.11445799469947815,
-0.3077612817287445,
-0.017737427726387978,
-0.6801862716674805,
0.19452454149723053,
0.3303948640823364,
-0.08773833513259888,
0.0828743502497673,
0.06710509955883026,
0.4153086245059967,
-0.519946813583374,
0.9042258858680725,
-0.030156023800373077,
-0.41543641686439514,
0.8605232834815979,
0.7390934228897095,
0.5929884910583496,
-0.2070825845003128,
0.3033376932144165,
0.4627774953842163,
0.4409084618091583,
-0.2663235664367676,
0.17442995309829712,
0.11487628519535065,
-1.081050157546997,
-0.6640908122062683,
-0.4576922357082367,
-0.4882238209247589,
0.09674214571714401,
-0.27613791823387146,
0.4092920422554016,
-0.816555917263031,
0.03969520702958107,
-0.3159308135509491,
0.06822460889816284,
-0.6287440061569214,
0.16105207800865173,
-0.09562446922063828,
0.5869296789169312,
-0.6080969572067261,
0.5193855166435242,
0.7183803915977478,
-0.4370850622653961,
-0.7629178166389465,
-0.20606710016727448,
-0.031038112938404083,
-1.0334179401397705,
0.7332766056060791,
-0.12475220113992691,
-0.13380466401576996,
0.26299533247947693,
-0.6961938738822937,
-1.1361908912658691,
1.0711039304733276,
0.24689561128616333,
-0.5769681930541992,
0.03824189677834511,
-0.14181700348854065,
0.6228917241096497,
-0.5942133665084839,
0.26268669962882996,
0.4314157962799072,
0.6625480055809021,
0.15506939589977264,
-0.8947344422340393,
0.1534910649061203,
-0.23261210322380066,
0.22892659902572632,
0.1715378612279892,
-0.8103697896003723,
0.022364718839526176,
-0.3485260009765625,
-0.12936267256736755,
-0.31812211871147156,
0.5399474501609802,
0.7682505249977112,
0.12190264463424683,
0.7438657283782959,
0.5052740573883057,
0.5299881100654602,
0.10796137899160385,
0.9127780795097351,
-0.0705997422337532,
-0.12771181762218475,
0.9932256937026978,
-0.34166061878204346,
0.8509722948074341,
0.7731785178184509,
0.020281925797462463,
0.8379265666007996,
0.6312155723571777,
-0.13966365158557892,
0.6534484624862671,
0.6912165880203247,
-0.3876795768737793,
-0.444541335105896,
-0.21773192286491394,
0.20816588401794434,
0.41674208641052246,
0.3264540731906891,
-0.13045351207256317,
0.2077132612466812,
-0.01706375740468502,
-0.016708113253116608,
0.3019948899745941,
-0.2675047218799591,
0.939683198928833,
0.05168642848730087,
-0.9512041807174683,
0.26165351271629333,
-0.10013142973184586,
0.4628061354160309,
-0.8375075459480286,
-0.34114134311676025,
-0.4466310739517212,
0.17812557518482208,
-0.15622484683990479,
-0.4697286784648895,
0.29071107506752014,
-0.23187926411628723,
0.03985339030623436,
-0.4311523735523224,
0.696214497089386,
-0.38239723443984985,
-0.34813791513442993,
0.10434656590223312,
0.25078195333480835,
0.33426982164382935,
0.2610243856906891,
-0.6887026429176331,
0.1045217216014862,
-0.02327350713312626,
-0.22908362746238708,
0.318606972694397,
0.24338354170322418,
-0.3330056369304657,
1.0319392681121826,
0.7860730886459351,
0.2839641869068146,
-0.4008304178714752,
0.09680651873350143,
0.726534366607666,
-0.6237223148345947,
-0.622887909412384,
-0.4130144417285919,
0.4539123773574829,
-0.5448682904243469,
-0.5637599229812622,
0.3759627640247345,
0.28652575612068176,
0.8679885268211365,
-0.20387443900108337,
0.5935220718383789,
-0.08814448118209839,
0.13089002668857574,
-0.7253730893135071,
0.4235393702983856,
-0.5718611478805542,
0.2108597457408905,
-0.21577246487140656,
-1.1589202880859375,
0.242530956864357,
0.7553716897964478,
-0.1078961044549942,
0.3855825662612915,
0.821793258190155,
0.7928414344787598,
0.0344303622841835,
-0.3658706545829773,
0.4170942008495331,
-0.2343919426202774,
0.23411720991134644,
0.6703850030899048,
0.7100101113319397,
0.07469692081212997,
0.4031740128993988,
-0.09997564554214478,
-0.39770227670669556,
-0.10284706950187683,
-1.151097059249878,
-0.8715164661407471,
-0.4869055449962616,
-0.4407706558704376,
-0.19728370010852814,
0.3942212164402008,
0.8085952401161194,
1.0042715072631836,
-0.5022282004356384,
-0.6828709840774536,
0.012983261607587337,
0.1629905104637146,
-0.7215436100959778,
-0.28783127665519714,
-0.003937964327633381,
-0.559316098690033,
-0.6776723265647888,
0.8774309754371643,
0.24910104274749756,
-0.27382516860961914,
-0.24875202775001526,
-0.22127942740917206,
-0.25932663679122925,
0.2863406240940094,
0.6944445967674255,
0.5152855515480042,
-0.6164391040802002,
-0.5803758502006531,
0.06502597779035568,
0.11895225942134857,
-0.29771241545677185,
0.9426023960113525,
-0.6022794246673584,
0.2755391001701355,
0.4568353593349457,
0.7549530267715454,
0.6720860004425049,
0.015144544653594494,
0.9532711505889893,
-1.1252129077911377,
0.03453077748417854,
0.3273506760597229,
0.008838861249387264,
0.2717793583869934,
-0.5278384685516357,
0.965864360332489,
0.09693126380443573,
-0.5658820271492004,
-0.7413881421089172,
0.2821124792098999,
-0.8855465054512024,
-0.4700702130794525,
1.238973617553711,
-0.14146973192691803,
-0.23657095432281494,
0.03762172535061836,
0.08887714892625809,
-0.023236630484461784,
-0.46688276529312134,
0.788266658782959,
0.9501985311508179,
-0.3793874680995941,
-0.5573356747627258,
-0.22714665532112122,
0.7374001741409302,
0.6540027260780334,
-1.2627686262130737,
-0.01360334176570177,
0.4952200651168823,
0.25217053294181824,
-0.03143315017223358,
0.6166216731071472,
0.0388578362762928,
0.11606479436159134,
-0.01345114316791296,
0.34620630741119385,
-0.40824487805366516,
-0.34931209683418274,
-0.30026572942733765,
-0.3206247389316559,
0.06500159949064255,
0.16045279800891876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03242v1 | JOBSKAPE: A Framework for Generating Synthetic Job Postings to Enhance Skill Matching | 2024-02-05T17:57:26 | 2024-02-05T17:57:26 | Antoine Magron, Anna Dai, Mike Zhang, Syrielle Montariol, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent approaches in skill matching, employing synthetic training data for
classification or similarity model training, have shown promising results,
reducing the need for time-consuming and expensive annotations. However,
previous synthetic datasets have limitations, such as featuring only one skill
per sentence and generally comprising short sentences. In this paper, we
introduce JobSkape, a framework to generate synthetic data that tackles these
limitations, specifically designed to enhance skill-to-taxonomy matching.
Within this framework, we create SkillSkape, a comprehensive open-source
synthetic dataset of job postings tailored for skill-matching tasks. We
introduce several offline metrics that show that our dataset resembles
real-world data. Additionally, we present a multi-step pipeline for skill
extraction and matching tasks using large language models (LLMs), benchmarking
against known supervised methodologies. We outline that the downstream
evaluation results on real-world data can beat baselines, underscoring its
efficacy and adaptability. | [
-0.09242293983697891,
-0.31623002886772156,
0.4942921996116638,
0.2544311583042145,
-0.18300357460975647,
0.21065248548984528,
-0.23663190007209778,
-0.7695534825325012,
0.49540475010871887,
0.5371955633163452,
-0.7311921119689941,
-0.5267282128334045,
-0.3634868562221527,
0.29038748145103455,
-0.5818753838539124,
0.6316508054733276,
0.42029324173927307,
-0.13037408888339996,
-0.6386069655418396,
0.13215164840221405,
-0.6078649163246155,
-0.2571457326412201,
-0.6436696648597717,
-0.15051676332950592,
0.4581885039806366,
0.7800034284591675,
0.545752227306366,
0.7748623490333557,
0.31325674057006836,
0.2672906816005707,
0.3009521961212158,
0.4118017852306366,
-0.28037896752357483,
0.3935636579990387,
-0.4012303650379181,
-0.6552534103393555,
-0.332247257232666,
0.06502221524715424,
0.5547399520874023,
0.7178040146827698,
-0.12638217210769653,
0.4401802122592926,
-0.140735924243927,
0.2350485473871231,
-0.46645987033843994,
0.2796880304813385,
-1.1615172624588013,
0.0924714207649231,
-0.3139059841632843,
-0.21737714111804962,
-0.139337420463562,
-0.3028671443462372,
-0.06980207562446594,
-0.9021204710006714,
0.5614945888519287,
0.002445521531626582,
0.9031603336334229,
0.09953341633081436,
-0.2699907720088959,
-0.23304085433483124,
-0.627998411655426,
0.5593951940536499,
-0.8526641130447388,
0.27826181054115295,
0.5660803914070129,
0.795315146446228,
-0.23074109852313995,
-0.7326616644859314,
-0.6508915424346924,
-0.009584288112819195,
-0.25745752453804016,
0.12485014647245407,
0.4159560203552246,
-0.03476007655262947,
0.22627170383930206,
0.4600455164909363,
-0.6084100604057312,
0.27719753980636597,
-0.5177261233329773,
-0.029028257355093956,
0.7137071490287781,
0.20252153277397156,
0.2611246407032013,
-0.11332258582115173,
0.003219293663278222,
-0.41556039452552795,
-0.6071956753730774,
-0.04720284789800644,
0.9284392595291138,
0.6486762762069702,
0.208794504404068,
0.9746204614639282,
-0.7595992684364319,
0.9282175898551941,
-0.2010040134191513,
-0.4235585331916809,
0.06431428343057632,
-0.35029223561286926,
0.0551295168697834,
-0.011572599411010742,
0.5974825620651245,
0.4819337725639343,
0.18863315880298615,
-0.33700311183929443,
-0.11217086762189865,
0.19934532046318054,
0.7566871643066406,
-0.47908642888069153,
-0.23591651022434235,
0.06333618611097336,
-0.13027678430080414,
-0.6588159799575806,
0.05355098843574524,
-0.782137393951416,
-0.327501118183136,
-0.3270283341407776,
0.47620561718940735,
-0.19880187511444092,
-0.13848339021205902,
0.017106739804148674,
-0.36894795298576355,
0.3513825833797455,
0.00585682038217783,
-1.102454662322998,
0.46746644377708435,
1.0702298879623413,
0.9208694696426392,
-0.20441851019859314,
-0.2514406442642212,
-0.3863409459590912,
-0.13658037781715393,
-0.30599454045295715,
0.8726050853729248,
-0.6691842675209045,
0.0722057893872261,
0.08101513981819153,
0.18398432433605194,
0.000841696688439697,
-0.5906729102134705,
0.4595886766910553,
-0.568078339099884,
0.16586732864379883,
0.12604939937591553,
-0.5231661796569824,
0.02238984778523445,
0.4486953318119049,
-0.6730011701583862,
1.5109755992889404,
0.5914612412452698,
-0.3258872628211975,
0.7223600745201111,
-0.7150412797927856,
-0.4674846827983856,
0.2532813847064972,
-0.14644643664360046,
-0.4558304250240326,
0.01700892299413681,
-0.1026250571012497,
0.5707617998123169,
-0.414937287569046,
-0.04006025940179825,
-0.2618955373764038,
-0.4829411208629608,
0.007939456030726433,
0.14514845609664917,
0.4126119911670685,
0.01913944073021412,
-0.08758655935525894,
-0.09818863123655319,
-0.9240490794181824,
0.19706425070762634,
0.12972399592399597,
-0.31918346881866455,
-0.32436123490333557,
-0.07891169935464859,
0.1017618328332901,
0.6415742039680481,
0.005552135873585939,
-0.676511824131012,
0.36123642325401306,
-0.6594617962837219,
0.28846117854118347,
0.463902086019516,
-0.3230833411216736,
0.4189494848251343,
-0.4484683573246002,
0.8432214260101318,
-0.331049382686615,
0.05183078348636627,
0.2809116542339325,
-0.4201071560382843,
-0.3227943181991577,
-0.23154808580875397,
0.34468117356300354,
0.532502293586731,
-0.7884286642074585,
0.7707708477973938,
-0.5394847393035889,
-1.131459355354309,
-0.9148144721984863,
0.30758634209632874,
0.221713125705719,
0.5991077423095703,
0.4934457540512085,
-0.6284878849983215,
-0.8206648826599121,
-1.181616187095642,
-0.3500097692012787,
0.16176550090312958,
-0.3272894024848938,
0.15940484404563904,
0.2008158415555954,
0.07047002017498016,
1.0892750024795532,
-0.4433722496032715,
-0.5804601907730103,
-0.03103041835129261,
-0.1206110417842865,
0.31166842579841614,
0.5312000513076782,
0.5353063941001892,
-0.6500141024589539,
-0.6336954832077026,
-0.036887526512145996,
-0.6820043325424194,
-0.09089258313179016,
-0.22905544936656952,
-0.33485880494117737,
-0.1092410609126091,
0.44675537943840027,
-0.8709093332290649,
-0.06701517850160599,
0.7930632829666138,
-0.3938179314136505,
0.6630680561065674,
0.07060503959655762,
0.2183852195739746,
-1.3254444599151611,
0.45732995867729187,
-0.03646354377269745,
-0.4482117295265198,
-0.4549597203731537,
0.1374497413635254,
-0.17731796205043793,
-0.4843789339065552,
-0.6025553345680237,
0.6850551962852478,
-0.26180729269981384,
-0.50495445728302,
-0.26923510432243347,
0.33844679594039917,
0.01045276504009962,
0.28792476654052734,
0.20038515329360962,
0.59845370054245,
0.7281266450881958,
-0.2989882230758667,
0.7256380915641785,
0.7151339650154114,
-0.5747654438018799,
0.8079395890235901,
-0.40537261962890625,
0.1870402991771698,
0.16922733187675476,
0.22407075762748718,
-0.6832578182220459,
-0.5665119886398315,
0.09117966890335083,
-0.2817964255809784,
-0.12346161156892776,
-0.728905439376831,
-0.8548721075057983,
-0.43226343393325806,
-0.2938748002052307,
0.28129449486732483,
0.7446077466011047,
-0.4650714099407196,
0.4790603816509247,
0.10691706091165543,
-0.28362107276916504,
-0.6223792433738708,
-0.6016682982444763,
0.1434752345085144,
-0.2108612209558487,
-0.45041075348854065,
0.8264055252075195,
0.23876994848251343,
0.29789745807647705,
-0.12457150220870972,
-0.046144600957632065,
-0.3012203872203827,
0.20219135284423828,
0.034684404730796814,
0.15116433799266815,
-0.0818723514676094,
0.013634524308145046,
-0.04194953292608261,
0.02164178341627121,
-0.05915074795484543,
-0.312528133392334,
0.47990354895591736,
0.4833967089653015,
-0.296809583902359,
-0.2538498342037201,
0.002001522807404399,
0.5833805799484253,
0.065975122153759,
0.9397718906402588,
0.7876201868057251,
-0.36847221851348877,
-0.415505588054657,
-0.4396659731864929,
-0.3954452872276306,
-0.5169312953948975,
0.2470722496509552,
-0.34698113799095154,
-0.5950388312339783,
0.06988160312175751,
-0.10256568342447281,
0.12449964135885239,
0.28124573826789856,
0.3484099507331848,
-0.3407030701637268,
0.7462961673736572,
0.548105776309967,
0.2681151330471039,
0.3651658594608307,
-0.0016896043671295047,
0.188824862241745,
-0.6089801788330078,
-0.4652169346809387,
-0.23807092010974884,
-0.5399665832519531,
-0.6363787651062012,
-0.386638343334198,
0.04834200069308281,
-0.083989217877388,
0.2683703601360321,
0.8679112195968628,
-0.784056544303894,
0.4179648160934448,
0.8485319018363953,
0.07273146510124207,
0.14407560229301453,
-0.09420802444219589,
0.24020355939865112,
-0.07401860505342484,
-0.8992917537689209,
-0.4483717381954193,
1.1515370607376099,
-0.11089187860488892,
0.23539654910564423,
-0.08360745012760162,
0.43409550189971924,
0.3626939654350281,
0.020877711474895477,
-0.7786099314689636,
0.7027238607406616,
-0.27907246351242065,
-0.5255311131477356,
-0.3212890923023224,
-0.3139532208442688,
-1.0712507963180542,
0.05013115331530571,
-0.9516589045524597,
-0.21131731569766998,
-0.2103419452905655,
0.3870875835418701,
-0.19984857738018036,
0.2725942134857178,
-0.5112226009368896,
1.0244756937026978,
-0.13180416822433472,
-0.09982069581747055,
-0.21511338651180267,
-0.5411071181297302,
0.3259492814540863,
-0.4698639214038849,
0.040516532957553864,
-0.4340778589248657,
-0.0024324594996869564,
0.6113601326942444,
-0.4942170977592468,
0.7814252376556396,
-0.10307643562555313,
0.04834515228867531,
-0.010332056321203709,
0.113561250269413,
0.3243725597858429,
-0.035698045045137405,
-0.34386253356933594,
-0.006542724557220936,
0.4741181433200836,
-0.6913268566131592,
-0.5548686981201172,
0.7465052008628845,
-0.4201095402240753,
-0.24499693512916565,
-0.30676668882369995,
-0.7413256168365479,
-0.44721266627311707,
0.1471496969461441,
0.09702853113412857,
0.052131082862615585,
-0.06993353366851807,
0.32732000946998596,
-0.02349039353430271,
-0.13154031336307526,
-0.10592985898256302,
0.1717771738767624,
-0.02990475669503212,
0.05509379133582115,
0.9311782121658325,
-0.02036367356777191,
0.23565573990345,
0.14809447526931763,
-0.1209678202867508,
-0.32328659296035767,
-0.12371475994586945,
-0.1829909086227417,
0.07055183500051498,
-0.5935718417167664,
-0.44695809483528137,
-0.33555811643600464,
-0.09080025553703308,
-0.5915603041648865,
-0.23152942955493927,
-0.4357176125049591,
-0.5508344769477844,
0.0798908993601799,
0.06515859067440033,
0.7466825246810913,
0.5643942952156067,
-0.12369454652070999,
0.20337767899036407,
-0.6909348368644714,
0.4476967751979828,
0.46767038106918335,
0.8015769124031067,
-0.3270123302936554,
-0.29727330803871155,
-0.3087015450000763,
0.12336506694555283,
-0.038623370230197906,
-0.6353906989097595,
0.3722960352897644,
0.5704434514045715,
0.45353928208351135,
-0.1778150051832199,
-0.07057654112577438,
0.537422239780426,
-0.3509649932384491,
0.6933097839355469,
-0.11018118262290955,
-0.6085200905799866,
0.6617125272750854,
-0.42339688539505005,
0.1629238724708557,
0.775749146938324,
0.6731237769126892,
-0.7533735036849976,
-0.37414154410362244,
-0.7484394311904907,
-0.8830463290214539,
0.7623111009597778,
0.5125208497047424,
0.29045727849006653,
-0.17128482460975647,
0.566046416759491,
0.3746376633644104,
0.1976357102394104,
-0.5348790884017944,
0.28112906217575073,
-0.143146350979805,
-0.6894204020500183,
0.10751395672559738,
0.13674937188625336,
-0.022426363080739975,
-0.2867138981819153,
0.6161932349205017,
-0.2677856981754303,
0.3650461435317993,
-0.19799962639808655,
-0.23962558805942535,
0.11942189186811447,
-0.014653099700808525,
0.24693048000335693,
0.5379575490951538,
-0.0708506628870964,
0.055613256990909576,
0.42489612102508545,
-0.35108521580696106,
0.0456337034702301,
0.025404920801520348,
0.015391873195767403,
0.04971180856227875,
0.31432968378067017,
0.2942383289337158,
0.2938869893550873,
-1.196106195449829,
0.6065908670425415,
0.29642412066459656,
-0.285076767206192,
-0.5607036352157593,
0.3885827362537384,
0.15493252873420715,
0.2027812898159027,
0.26031339168548584,
0.02905299887061119,
-0.12756788730621338,
-0.8777303099632263,
0.2635292708873749,
0.4420803189277649,
-0.03699147701263428,
-0.3371000289916992,
0.6457327008247375,
0.15516416728496552,
-0.6974121928215027,
0.8474949598312378,
-0.24727898836135864,
-0.2819843590259552,
0.5970513820648193,
0.4960549771785736,
0.23861059546470642,
-0.09058236330747604,
0.19823302328586578,
0.5151413083076477,
-0.09991093724966049,
-0.5112634301185608,
0.375271201133728,
0.03401220217347145,
-0.6031447052955627,
-0.590686559677124,
-0.7354839444160461,
-0.5149503946304321,
0.10874157398939133,
-0.6333441138267517,
0.7663397192955017,
-0.5266803503036499,
0.01092086173593998,
-0.07614726573228836,
-0.27211588621139526,
-0.9173055291175842,
0.47194671630859375,
0.11069195717573166,
0.6954696178436279,
-1.2469120025634766,
0.7457700371742249,
0.6446903944015503,
-0.3998628854751587,
-0.33026283979415894,
-0.29056090116500854,
-0.21296054124832153,
-0.7254301309585571,
0.3563874363899231,
0.2288106381893158,
0.23361937701702118,
0.22715413570404053,
-0.25976046919822693,
-0.7211815118789673,
1.3371222019195557,
0.42424121499061584,
-0.30786600708961487,
-0.5165548920631409,
0.5753205418586731,
0.740403413772583,
-0.39616355299949646,
-0.05133863165974617,
0.6265861392021179,
0.2581643760204315,
-0.225160613656044,
-1.1578071117401123,
0.06136920675635338,
-0.23797567188739777,
-0.15240687131881714,
0.00771698635071516,
-0.27188944816589355,
0.27765029668807983,
0.39917266368865967,
-0.06026550009846687,
0.06531714648008347,
0.261960506439209,
0.2754964530467987,
-0.16372650861740112,
0.655244767665863,
0.38888102769851685,
0.5054406523704529,
-0.06091955676674843,
0.6748054623603821,
-0.3676851689815521,
0.13411356508731842,
1.038393497467041,
-0.16426993906497955,
1.016789197921753,
0.31349214911460876,
-0.13164356350898743,
0.7815402746200562,
0.6417133808135986,
-0.5886303186416626,
0.42051246762275696,
0.2765245735645294,
-0.013736167922616005,
-0.413482666015625,
-0.220520481467247,
0.08732165396213531,
0.7662410736083984,
0.13808254897594452,
-0.2608206272125244,
-0.19193655252456665,
0.11840984970331192,
-0.45697498321533203,
0.5452004671096802,
-0.01720556989312172,
0.7292458415031433,
-0.04523788020014763,
-0.7083545327186584,
0.37802237272262573,
-0.04160182550549507,
0.9486764073371887,
-0.6574097275733948,
-0.47268760204315186,
0.07475440204143524,
-0.14220455288887024,
-0.4534261226654053,
-1.0278801918029785,
0.8208776116371155,
-0.24260108172893524,
0.1078190952539444,
-0.46107912063598633,
0.8686277270317078,
-0.6126078963279724,
-0.5797170400619507,
0.27124860882759094,
0.3202284276485443,
0.16761913895606995,
-0.019720211625099182,
-0.6668877005577087,
-0.4216143488883972,
-0.6680215001106262,
0.2367962896823883,
0.417819082736969,
0.13579420745372772,
0.06324977427721024,
0.6093733906745911,
0.8668162822723389,
0.33217182755470276,
-0.03782803192734718,
-0.24372433125972748,
0.3937709331512451,
-0.4514818787574768,
-0.48123693466186523,
-0.4097953140735626,
0.4079953730106354,
-0.44716551899909973,
-0.4512784481048584,
0.36177948117256165,
0.7429285049438477,
1.171268105506897,
-0.3578799068927765,
0.7503436207771301,
-0.3063700199127197,
0.7488589882850647,
-0.4393363893032074,
0.625619649887085,
-0.6261932849884033,
-0.09100151062011719,
-0.11499015241861343,
-1.2388676404953003,
-0.09588345140218735,
0.4788294732570648,
0.0024667654652148485,
0.040766872465610504,
0.36639225482940674,
1.148195743560791,
-0.6955344080924988,
-0.5656057000160217,
0.4900277853012085,
-0.16817104816436768,
-0.12372535467147827,
0.41139253973960876,
0.47971317172050476,
-0.5265491008758545,
0.7185637950897217,
-0.42844879627227783,
0.2860034704208374,
-0.4893297553062439,
-0.8558603525161743,
-0.7238927483558655,
-0.9077781438827515,
-0.41106703877449036,
-0.39779505133628845,
0.014846044592559338,
1.0727730989456177,
0.8985228538513184,
-0.4915273189544678,
-0.1916200816631317,
-0.12513791024684906,
-0.3375556766986847,
-0.6897278428077698,
-0.26280173659324646,
0.0993206650018692,
-0.21837672591209412,
-0.6474946141242981,
0.8553577065467834,
-0.005293968599289656,
-0.13202498853206635,
-0.15646353363990784,
0.28473490476608276,
-0.3648061156272888,
0.13849705457687378,
0.7436767220497131,
0.5145812034606934,
-0.5158097743988037,
-0.44129201769828796,
0.07467246055603027,
-0.15549792349338531,
-0.1070328876376152,
0.5882583260536194,
-0.771050214767456,
0.41623473167419434,
0.5344545841217041,
0.733985424041748,
0.535999059677124,
0.010256338864564896,
0.8906996846199036,
-1.3646636009216309,
0.268311470746994,
0.3381991386413574,
0.09813488274812698,
0.5561327338218689,
-0.40809857845306396,
0.8375202417373657,
0.32760608196258545,
-0.09886298328638077,
-0.8688533902168274,
0.22405454516410828,
-0.923309326171875,
-0.1523320972919464,
1.0445575714111328,
0.14418722689151764,
0.15016242861747742,
-0.31172770261764526,
0.05878550931811333,
0.35799819231033325,
0.31170299649238586,
1.2564830780029297,
0.5172671675682068,
0.11282608658075333,
0.002484348602592945,
-0.6964882612228394,
0.7115424275398254,
0.38795241713523865,
-1.0408140420913696,
-0.14551420509815216,
0.11151275783777237,
0.49381306767463684,
-0.030532578006386757,
0.4119877219200134,
0.19506751000881195,
0.6610910892486572,
0.12168076634407043,
0.323349267244339,
-0.1268208920955658,
-0.11229093372821808,
0.13423682749271393,
0.031699445098638535,
0.35830292105674744,
0.06948862969875336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03223v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03223v4 | English Prompts are Better for NLI-based Zero-Shot Emotion Classification than Target-Language Prompts | 2024-02-05T17:36:19 | 2024-03-07T17:18:18 | Patrick Bareiß, Roman Klinger, Jeremy Barnes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion classification in text is a challenging task due to the processes
involved when interpreting a textual description of a potential emotion
stimulus. In addition, the set of emotion categories is highly domain-specific.
For instance, literature analysis might require the use of aesthetic emotions
(e.g., finding something beautiful), and social media analysis could benefit
from fine-grained sets (e.g., separating anger from annoyance) than only those
that represent basic categories as they have been proposed by Paul Ekman
(anger, disgust, fear, joy, surprise, sadness). This renders the task an
interesting field for zero-shot classifications, in which the label set is not
known at model development time. Unfortunately, most resources for emotion
analysis are English, and therefore, most studies on emotion analysis have been
performed in English, including those that involve prompting language models
for text labels. This leaves us with a research gap that we address in this
paper: In which language should we prompt for emotion labels on non-English
texts? This is particularly of interest when we have access to a multilingual
large language model, because we could request labels with English prompts even
for non-English data. Our experiments with natural language inference-based
language models show that it is consistently better to use English prompts even
if the data is in a different language. | [
-0.2647591233253479,
-0.4448282718658447,
0.5475563406944275,
0.42512017488479614,
-0.1365847885608673,
-0.008858597837388515,
-0.241439089179039,
-0.7029533386230469,
0.17877966165542603,
-0.1644357293844223,
-0.5659303665161133,
-0.5325034260749817,
-0.5275347828865051,
0.7822713255882263,
-0.03298214450478554,
0.998466432094574,
-0.289726585149765,
0.10052490234375,
-0.2216181606054306,
-0.3760877549648285,
-0.46363726258277893,
-0.619432270526886,
-1.0946425199508667,
-0.3065890073776245,
1.2535357475280762,
0.30393972992897034,
0.18386594951152802,
-0.05241949483752251,
0.19412218034267426,
0.21905763447284698,
-0.0807146206498146,
-0.1557767391204834,
-0.1445450484752655,
0.41125670075416565,
-0.11539191752672195,
-0.4777074158191681,
-0.015727104619145393,
0.23199602961540222,
-0.06085484102368355,
0.6033785343170166,
0.3047437369823456,
-0.10351662337779999,
-0.14598380029201508,
0.6232390403747559,
-0.846651017665863,
0.034300219267606735,
-0.07622156292200089,
0.51198410987854,
0.012198777869343758,
-0.45934757590293884,
-0.6525278687477112,
-0.24626803398132324,
0.26466986536979675,
-0.3658507764339447,
0.10140062868595123,
0.06263419985771179,
1.1167229413986206,
0.13319344818592072,
-0.7094941735267639,
-0.43989673256874084,
-0.6272392272949219,
1.013627290725708,
-0.4068361520767212,
0.4151025712490082,
0.2935963571071625,
0.03760574012994766,
0.3057226538658142,
-0.095489501953125,
-0.4685015380382538,
-0.23764614760875702,
-0.02675520069897175,
0.4680492877960205,
-0.5267682671546936,
0.11170060187578201,
0.2848677635192871,
-0.0025518417824059725,
-0.8134301900863647,
0.46057963371276855,
-0.11518074572086334,
-0.15894781053066254,
0.737404465675354,
0.10219339281320572,
0.5953801274299622,
-0.4487103223800659,
-0.10971686989068985,
0.10732495784759521,
-0.6295488476753235,
0.29626011848449707,
0.24693350493907928,
0.5510282516479492,
-0.1804743856191635,
0.49512991309165955,
-0.05819100886583328,
0.6333445906639099,
0.018213775008916855,
-0.07408937811851501,
0.16399075090885162,
0.06992968916893005,
-0.01868049055337906,
0.26185429096221924,
1.026017427444458,
0.8016487956047058,
0.41889506578445435,
-0.040301259607076645,
-0.07134760916233063,
0.4697891175746918,
0.0035334639251232147,
-0.9188485741615295,
0.100450798869133,
0.6995329856872559,
-0.36606472730636597,
0.014589001424610615,
-0.2710399627685547,
-0.8924630880355835,
-0.49696803092956543,
-0.15939588844776154,
0.20582160353660583,
-0.40719276666641235,
-0.032852668315172195,
0.04437801614403725,
-0.2559478282928467,
0.31838205456733704,
0.4035165011882782,
-0.7038207650184631,
-0.23856769502162933,
0.44405534863471985,
0.7861146330833435,
-0.28424128890037537,
-0.013529257848858833,
-0.16746647655963898,
-0.4020147919654846,
-0.4678390324115753,
1.0273809432983398,
-0.6031431555747986,
-0.40773460268974304,
0.31693243980407715,
0.19451016187667847,
-0.062285132706165314,
-0.07615477591753006,
0.786934494972229,
-0.27775245904922485,
0.8551195859909058,
-0.4077857732772827,
-0.5597575902938843,
-0.2678880989551544,
0.45391032099723816,
-0.4529215097427368,
1.1000759601593018,
-0.24028071761131287,
-0.6542182564735413,
0.33603277802467346,
-0.7833841443061829,
-0.4626028835773468,
0.20671840012073517,
-0.030677100643515587,
0.011859817430377007,
0.1438308209180832,
0.14324533939361572,
0.6915478706359863,
-0.310261070728302,
0.23567692935466766,
-0.2129467874765396,
-0.3239171802997589,
0.15643292665481567,
-0.49078893661499023,
0.564806342124939,
0.4367663860321045,
-0.43953731656074524,
-0.08629915863275528,
-0.6025472283363342,
-0.08895309269428253,
0.12696930766105652,
-0.03642517700791359,
-0.7885830998420715,
0.03488064929842949,
-0.002420579083263874,
0.15849821269512177,
0.16396145522594452,
-0.7301055788993835,
-0.03616528958082199,
-0.317310631275177,
-0.08876997977495193,
0.4996742606163025,
0.07249727100133896,
0.4373246133327484,
-0.008310969918966293,
0.922455370426178,
-0.04197639971971512,
-0.0785955935716629,
-0.5053620934486389,
-0.5986937880516052,
-0.6526086330413818,
-0.17332394421100616,
0.20494918525218964,
0.841814398765564,
-0.7575686573982239,
0.23686981201171875,
0.3808337152004242,
-0.5672922730445862,
-0.5528976321220398,
-0.48754364252090454,
0.35390743613243103,
0.6353967189788818,
0.19632163643836975,
0.1955128312110901,
-0.4620113670825958,
-0.6049395799636841,
-0.23138085007667542,
-0.23433475196361542,
-0.008241956122219563,
0.49741441011428833,
0.12457306683063507,
0.04634520411491394,
0.7831982374191284,
-0.4151275157928467,
0.1618078351020813,
-0.371805876493454,
0.5354257225990295,
0.1574700027704239,
-0.019902337342500687,
0.823463499546051,
-0.7661709189414978,
-1.0150995254516602,
0.19959191977977753,
-1.0994362831115723,
-0.6184312701225281,
-0.30298566818237305,
-0.15213485062122345,
0.5909469723701477,
0.09671784192323685,
-0.4454666078090668,
0.31923311948776245,
0.40298157930374146,
-0.44528645277023315,
0.43737170100212097,
0.17750927805900574,
0.556638240814209,
-1.0167547464370728,
0.13441751897335052,
0.40189164876937866,
0.09041670709848404,
-0.9240403175354004,
-0.12496108561754227,
0.1408727467060089,
-0.32641372084617615,
-0.7557599544525146,
1.0533472299575806,
-0.4470403790473938,
0.425768107175827,
-0.2810736298561096,
0.01087114866822958,
0.3565908670425415,
0.2717951238155365,
0.46085819602012634,
0.7057223916053772,
0.8489266633987427,
-0.7247389554977417,
0.2196877896785736,
0.22241897881031036,
0.055920012295246124,
1.1824198961257935,
-0.5114027261734009,
-0.0735420510172844,
-0.5674548745155334,
0.031140698119997978,
-0.8744373917579651,
-0.20863080024719238,
0.3200608193874359,
-0.6548829078674316,
0.46292585134506226,
0.18505018949508667,
0.1349005401134491,
-0.34949976205825806,
-0.47082337737083435,
0.12588676810264587,
0.7079429626464844,
-0.5607701539993286,
0.4282090663909912,
-0.048342715948820114,
-0.2501757740974426,
-0.8558704853057861,
-0.5992012023925781,
0.1939675658941269,
-0.42260271310806274,
-0.13800199329853058,
0.0030609990935772657,
-0.3018115162849426,
-0.3003098964691162,
0.05793469771742821,
-0.012257833033800125,
-0.13699373602867126,
0.03686754032969475,
0.3149614632129669,
0.2872821092605591,
-0.15444745123386383,
0.3142487108707428,
0.03131048381328583,
-0.1722044050693512,
0.12831245362758636,
0.1457487940788269,
0.18913455307483673,
0.18963272869586945,
-0.14542165398597717,
-0.6241989731788635,
0.8676519393920898,
0.5043270587921143,
-0.16193123161792755,
0.7786346077919006,
0.5272877812385559,
-0.4752855896949768,
-0.2333841323852539,
-0.31733474135398865,
-0.031772710382938385,
-0.37800702452659607,
0.1559988409280777,
-0.2852899432182312,
-0.9072094559669495,
0.35182350873947144,
0.2517862021923065,
-0.049616165459156036,
0.5005077123641968,
0.4158213138580322,
-0.5541190505027771,
1.2357761859893799,
0.7330683469772339,
-0.23877859115600586,
0.4954482614994049,
0.14111986756324768,
0.47251641750335693,
-0.4576318562030792,
-0.08917355537414551,
-1.0743495225906372,
-0.33235594630241394,
-0.33405232429504395,
0.05516374111175537,
0.21617981791496277,
-0.1605890542268753,
0.14528700709342957,
0.14217127859592438,
-0.5338284969329834,
0.6477681994438171,
0.30517250299453735,
-0.40561509132385254,
-0.15686079859733582,
0.07530531287193298,
0.08796396851539612,
-0.4598023295402527,
-0.7509561777114868,
-0.48942551016807556,
0.6127107739448547,
0.22778907418251038,
0.5523115396499634,
-0.19083300232887268,
0.78943932056427,
0.09319096803665161,
0.4022764563560486,
-1.267574429512024,
0.4385266900062561,
-0.2276989221572876,
-0.4463650584220886,
-0.002932610223069787,
-0.33593446016311646,
-1.4863793849945068,
-0.08855229616165161,
-0.20881082117557526,
-0.7753522396087646,
0.3771800994873047,
0.0695880874991417,
-0.36947357654571533,
0.20861615240573883,
-0.7754048705101013,
0.9103941917419434,
-0.19486407935619354,
-0.13891389966011047,
0.3072943091392517,
-0.3939909040927887,
0.12575805187225342,
-0.01516291219741106,
0.3548862636089325,
-0.22943156957626343,
-0.030365655198693275,
0.6525503396987915,
-0.35723087191581726,
0.8963448405265808,
-0.27498310804367065,
-0.3622397780418396,
0.4667539596557617,
0.08123880624771118,
0.29014793038368225,
-0.3051629066467285,
-0.21868188679218292,
0.1525985449552536,
-0.14385591447353363,
-0.18069998919963837,
-0.792913019657135,
0.4468725919723511,
-0.6150435209274292,
-0.3214379549026489,
-0.5391353964805603,
-0.37539783120155334,
-0.31075215339660645,
-0.17946209013462067,
0.584869384765625,
0.41783595085144043,
0.027203893288969994,
-0.07693568617105484,
0.6797266006469727,
-0.6511926651000977,
0.6538995504379272,
0.8417657613754272,
0.007815977558493614,
0.06962014734745026,
1.0286771059036255,
0.23657652735710144,
0.020136041566729546,
0.5667698383331299,
0.33359038829803467,
-0.39387065172195435,
-0.18790721893310547,
-0.3715873658657074,
0.16123171150684357,
-0.6944597959518433,
-0.4418393671512604,
-0.8143072724342346,
0.02548684924840927,
-0.2448345422744751,
-0.5439121723175049,
0.008627538569271564,
-0.2613658308982849,
-0.4547714293003082,
-0.24630820751190186,
0.7681077718734741,
0.5704675912857056,
-0.08101627975702286,
0.0648856908082962,
-1.0938210487365723,
0.20209382474422455,
0.16327641904354095,
0.3560328781604767,
-0.11781638115644455,
-0.46626168489456177,
-0.09623552113771439,
-0.418071985244751,
0.007697922643274069,
-1.521256923675537,
0.6177759766578674,
0.20747560262680054,
0.2592720091342926,
0.43400001525878906,
0.4867940843105316,
0.5910137295722961,
-0.61373370885849,
1.1181676387786865,
0.18292780220508575,
-0.7773169875144958,
0.642227292060852,
-0.28984227776527405,
0.4473429024219513,
0.3789069354534149,
1.181265950202942,
-1.2132577896118164,
-0.598125159740448,
-0.4567312002182007,
-1.08284330368042,
0.7663792967796326,
-0.2294377237558365,
0.4409498870372772,
-0.5631763935089111,
0.21957512199878693,
0.2937033474445343,
0.14401347935199738,
-0.8559454083442688,
-0.3311011791229248,
0.14713892340660095,
-0.637779176235199,
-0.0023514479398727417,
-0.3861686885356903,
0.22235527634620667,
0.08279282599687576,
0.633272111415863,
-0.13304604589939117,
0.34785255789756775,
0.34820809960365295,
0.013262149877846241,
-0.32998231053352356,
0.46414050459861755,
0.22175906598567963,
-0.03961421176791191,
-0.18333350121974945,
0.1470981389284134,
0.22942562401294708,
-0.13171100616455078,
0.5109544396400452,
-0.16045507788658142,
-0.5131543874740601,
0.40716323256492615,
0.44534483551979065,
1.2213242053985596,
0.13181094825267792,
-0.8059865832328796,
0.6107831597328186,
-0.14418940246105194,
-0.20053090155124664,
0.044562987983226776,
-0.24255461990833282,
-0.23928189277648926,
0.2073109745979309,
0.18851882219314575,
-0.2153274565935135,
0.391317218542099,
-0.48993590474128723,
-0.08880368620157242,
0.3636297583580017,
-0.6114122271537781,
-0.3816760182380676,
0.5083139538764954,
0.3910575807094574,
-0.41420674324035645,
0.2582491338253021,
-0.6605255007743835,
-0.5631424784660339,
0.5569097399711609,
0.5236200094223022,
1.071636438369751,
-0.46313533186912537,
0.5871822834014893,
0.6290601491928101,
0.1711900383234024,
0.18594267964363098,
0.6397725939750671,
0.12696270644664764,
-0.7114111185073853,
-0.692709743976593,
-0.5675745606422424,
-0.6930503845214844,
-0.00885749515146017,
-0.6164271831512451,
0.23964691162109375,
-0.2954508066177368,
-0.023423977196216583,
-0.08948207646608353,
-0.3451646864414215,
-0.6365628242492676,
0.43775689601898193,
0.5280004143714905,
0.9856641888618469,
-1.144278883934021,
0.30055710673332214,
1.0321531295776367,
-0.13754068315029144,
-1.0458300113677979,
-0.24562086164951324,
0.20717185735702515,
-0.31800511479377747,
0.5899072885513306,
0.5425501465797424,
0.16410093009471893,
-0.22385556995868683,
-0.7064028382301331,
-0.5567324757575989,
0.524853527545929,
0.05043177306652069,
-0.4569956958293915,
0.32496699690818787,
-0.11701023578643799,
0.8304837346076965,
-0.18399669229984283,
0.7592135071754456,
0.13580107688903809,
0.4962979257106781,
0.23502132296562195,
-0.5320456624031067,
-0.19741399586200714,
-0.4126981794834137,
-0.21368135511875153,
0.3834822177886963,
-0.33235281705856323,
0.6137812733650208,
0.03835374489426613,
-0.5281756520271301,
-0.2964484691619873,
0.6211469769477844,
0.016326745972037315,
0.5672542452812195,
0.428428590297699,
0.2697771489620209,
0.8677745461463928,
-0.34795472025871277,
1.335645079612732,
-0.20622746646404266,
0.13292744755744934,
0.670735776424408,
-0.6908925771713257,
1.017127513885498,
0.30182501673698425,
-0.28403180837631226,
0.569357693195343,
1.009462594985962,
0.055345647037029266,
0.198441743850708,
-0.16867513954639435,
-0.46630367636680603,
-0.0014814502792432904,
-0.730976939201355,
-0.0850503146648407,
0.17083688080310822,
0.19018591940402985,
0.1270434558391571,
-0.29240888357162476,
0.4466080367565155,
0.33731594681739807,
0.06953974813222885,
-0.4367659091949463,
0.846094012260437,
0.004651536233723164,
-0.5439487099647522,
0.4292477071285248,
-0.09700388461351395,
1.0155961513519287,
-0.7019209861755371,
0.1899849772453308,
-0.5735289454460144,
-0.571155309677124,
-0.28511640429496765,
-0.8045427203178406,
0.28194576501846313,
0.8071534633636475,
-0.20206616818904877,
-0.3522021174430847,
0.6038727164268494,
-0.642082154750824,
-0.3805338442325592,
0.3508840799331665,
0.4202692210674286,
0.4613260328769684,
-0.041732463985681534,
-0.7459015250205994,
-0.10039423406124115,
-0.06642403453588486,
-0.6065516471862793,
0.23612548410892487,
0.827113687992096,
-0.18302132189273834,
0.28648948669433594,
0.39952602982521057,
-0.037663478404283524,
-0.1601373255252838,
0.3152526617050171,
0.21937620639801025,
-0.8098927140235901,
-0.2631641924381256,
-0.814271867275238,
0.9349186420440674,
0.06390553712844849,
-0.21650956571102142,
0.7687671780586243,
0.11786510050296783,
0.4436149299144745,
-0.3144223093986511,
0.8518896102905273,
-0.19895321130752563,
0.4985141456127167,
-0.3184196352958679,
0.4657512903213501,
-0.9060895442962646,
-0.3883941173553467,
-0.41687431931495667,
-0.8721306324005127,
-0.6055597066879272,
0.5431122779846191,
-0.20627744495868683,
-0.07256817072629929,
0.9501243233680725,
0.5506223440170288,
0.4635038375854492,
-0.026469308882951736,
0.4705861806869507,
0.07846157252788544,
0.037801168859004974,
0.6588263511657715,
1.023397445678711,
-0.2823352515697479,
0.15364030003547668,
-0.16096842288970947,
-0.27653783559799194,
-0.005116803105920553,
-1.0901854038238525,
-0.9660710692405701,
-0.3283868134021759,
-0.6658259630203247,
-0.2263888716697693,
-0.2280171662569046,
1.1759884357452393,
0.2185150682926178,
-1.0583187341690063,
-0.0020448723807930946,
0.37100833654403687,
0.12829314172267914,
0.06424463540315628,
-0.278328537940979,
0.1235925480723381,
-0.5856614112854004,
-1.126907467842102,
0.4331042170524597,
0.5236709713935852,
0.27081993222236633,
0.16334211826324463,
-0.16704684495925903,
-0.028124406933784485,
0.4022618532180786,
0.7496606707572937,
0.5362342000007629,
-0.5111966133117676,
-0.43948498368263245,
0.30049213767051697,
-0.10595766454935074,
0.009222978726029396,
0.4033844769001007,
-0.477466344833374,
0.4537670612335205,
0.401851087808609,
0.7288804650306702,
-0.18438781797885895,
-0.30630970001220703,
0.4613090455532074,
-0.9653437733650208,
0.37341880798339844,
0.219252809882164,
0.5672613978385925,
0.5393322110176086,
-0.6664952039718628,
0.4957023561000824,
0.1121886745095253,
-0.49676743149757385,
-0.890738844871521,
0.2321774810552597,
-0.9087555408477783,
-0.34441739320755005,
1.1827421188354492,
-0.2777969241142273,
-0.40842774510383606,
0.0997379943728447,
-0.6493948101997375,
0.17835606634616852,
-0.48713091015815735,
0.5402005314826965,
1.0177483558654785,
-0.151113823056221,
-0.4845973551273346,
-0.43190035223960876,
0.48884135484695435,
0.8713840842247009,
-1.0870248079299927,
-0.03424336761236191,
0.5240052938461304,
-0.26411086320877075,
0.15246492624282837,
0.5835962891578674,
0.20201721787452698,
0.11030545830726624,
-0.3620922863483429,
0.48517581820487976,
0.38211095333099365,
-0.4452238082885742,
-0.7925927042961121,
0.16450968384742737,
-0.009806313551962376,
0.032282546162605286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03221v1 | "Define Your Terms" : Enhancing Efficient Offensive Speech Classification with Definition | 2024-02-05T17:33:22 | 2024-02-05T17:33:22 | Huy Nghiem, Umang Gupta, Fred Morstatter | cs.CL | cs.CL | The propagation of offensive content through social media channels has
garnered attention of the research community. Multiple works have proposed
various semantically related yet subtle distinct categories of offensive
speech. In this work, we explore meta-earning approaches to leverage the
diversity of offensive speech corpora to enhance their reliable and efficient
detection. We propose a joint embedding architecture that incorporates the
input's label and definition for classification via Prototypical Network. Our
model achieves at least 75% of the maximal F1-score while using less than 10%
of the available training data across 4 datasets. Our experimental findings
also provide a case study of training strategies valuable to combat resource
scarcity. | [
-0.5339470505714417,
-0.9656744599342346,
-0.19618338346481323,
0.2062155157327652,
-0.2791394591331482,
0.518470048904419,
-0.40071940422058105,
-0.5020611882209778,
0.5529834628105164,
0.2829590439796448,
-0.11885832250118256,
-0.559332549571991,
-0.9515203833580017,
0.29778486490249634,
-0.6689576506614685,
0.9905005097389221,
0.36092156171798706,
-0.30092477798461914,
0.25776514410972595,
-0.5842330455780029,
-0.15672430396080017,
-0.4037071764469147,
-0.7177853584289551,
0.2165888398885727,
0.5716040730476379,
0.3810311257839203,
0.8319646716117859,
0.8597995638847351,
0.38065600395202637,
0.45166388154029846,
-0.11186924576759338,
0.2680288255214691,
-0.47526785731315613,
0.2727566063404083,
-0.47205886244773865,
-0.015773318707942963,
-0.36912134289741516,
0.016567450016736984,
0.4561408758163452,
0.3067287802696228,
-0.2348141223192215,
0.2521125078201294,
0.005245681386440992,
0.054185424000024796,
-1.1851577758789062,
-0.06346967071294785,
-0.8330490589141846,
0.08034004271030426,
-0.33505940437316895,
-0.0635732114315033,
-0.3913077414035797,
-0.13222986459732056,
0.1707204282283783,
-0.5425864458084106,
0.11470113694667816,
-0.4219060242176056,
0.6304118633270264,
-0.2245139330625534,
-0.15412558615207672,
-0.5330996513366699,
-0.5047944784164429,
0.36177322268486023,
-0.25322598218917847,
0.4610621929168701,
0.3123602867126465,
0.33895424008369446,
0.5600908398628235,
-0.9609881639480591,
-0.5149000883102417,
0.22600483894348145,
-0.08345892280340195,
-0.06354633718729019,
-0.7430170774459839,
0.31745994091033936,
0.027861086651682854,
0.12397073209285736,
-0.2732914388179779,
0.17730338871479034,
-0.37225577235221863,
-0.2705840766429901,
0.68385249376297,
0.09215427935123444,
0.26427310705184937,
-0.07355309277772903,
-0.2028057873249054,
0.028709977865219116,
-0.2006734013557434,
-0.23316413164138794,
0.5276644825935364,
0.6539972424507141,
-0.06838253140449524,
0.27204763889312744,
-0.21066534519195557,
0.5217054486274719,
0.11608503013849258,
0.004518622532486916,
0.47138679027557373,
-0.2476235181093216,
-0.3818846046924591,
0.0025295522063970566,
0.843572199344635,
0.3196778893470764,
-0.0029062277171760798,
-0.2780190408229828,
-0.26388445496559143,
0.17179353535175323,
0.43488502502441406,
-0.6889025568962097,
-0.10428962856531143,
-0.14720353484153748,
-0.1678859293460846,
-0.5384271740913391,
-0.11867432296276093,
-0.9616726636886597,
-0.4044426381587982,
-0.043311361223459244,
0.4842647612094879,
-0.4488067030906677,
-0.45286574959754944,
-0.19598227739334106,
-0.5801898241043091,
0.2328978180885315,
-0.0635310560464859,
-0.9967811107635498,
0.46321889758110046,
0.668953001499176,
0.8614965677261353,
0.28319263458251953,
0.4005912244319916,
-0.47372329235076904,
0.07391577959060669,
-0.3992500901222229,
0.31851765513420105,
-0.8328216075897217,
-0.298507958650589,
0.2944020628929138,
-0.20188209414482117,
0.07916847616434097,
-0.6461738348007202,
0.6843264698982239,
-0.7134915590286255,
-0.021640578284859657,
0.00718044675886631,
-0.24283087253570557,
-0.2712101638317108,
0.24232707917690277,
-0.4091264009475708,
0.6270977854728699,
0.13022492825984955,
-0.7639536261558533,
0.5090276598930359,
-0.7258813381195068,
-0.7244647741317749,
0.49537596106529236,
-0.0041238730773329735,
-0.3571181893348694,
-0.021387139335274696,
0.03277428075671196,
0.4142501652240753,
0.11556657403707504,
0.34893664717674255,
-0.3952403664588928,
-0.13210657238960266,
0.17818091809749603,
-0.38547760248184204,
0.7658033967018127,
0.5565041899681091,
-0.6759380102157593,
-0.06385572254657745,
-0.682153046131134,
-0.16837258636951447,
0.057625263929367065,
-0.27577346563339233,
-0.7165257334709167,
0.040746454149484634,
0.046172987669706345,
-0.015564227476716042,
-0.13441191613674164,
-0.6405113339424133,
-0.3897913694381714,
-0.46939051151275635,
0.39297157526016235,
0.7960205078125,
-0.3782244622707367,
0.39283743500709534,
-0.023297498002648354,
0.5064884424209595,
-0.21246224641799927,
0.09612935781478882,
0.15928338468074799,
-0.2855141758918762,
-0.6728722453117371,
-0.43742021918296814,
0.28146106004714966,
0.8416727781295776,
-0.8823270797729492,
0.5713990926742554,
-0.2759716808795929,
-0.4070338308811188,
-0.6675184369087219,
0.2804581820964813,
0.6029342412948608,
0.37076613306999207,
0.47212210297584534,
-0.02527584880590439,
-0.8973358869552612,
-0.9723629355430603,
-0.36084356904029846,
-0.07114192843437195,
0.008763172663748264,
0.27249228954315186,
0.33877402544021606,
-0.17361417412757874,
0.9096336364746094,
-0.23619863390922546,
-0.3492819368839264,
-0.3476734161376953,
0.36508116126060486,
-0.1938319355249405,
0.14686915278434753,
0.5924060344696045,
-1.0848503112792969,
-0.5732312798500061,
-0.23279161751270294,
-0.5038077235221863,
-0.3360520303249359,
0.2565464973449707,
0.21531029045581818,
-0.1345605105161667,
0.45181283354759216,
0.07342928647994995,
0.1413649320602417,
0.5367816686630249,
-0.41703668236732483,
0.17279133200645447,
0.3595280051231384,
0.04171231389045715,
-0.9770362377166748,
-0.2510259747505188,
0.15503641963005066,
-0.4667648673057556,
-0.8955029845237732,
0.4695388078689575,
-0.36365681886672974,
-0.0832521989941597,
-0.5765872001647949,
0.15961021184921265,
-0.04230610653758049,
0.31599417328834534,
-0.22334767878055573,
0.5206989645957947,
-0.2456742376089096,
0.1566961109638214,
0.08961594104766846,
0.5210116505622864,
0.47198301553726196,
-0.711245059967041,
0.4828268885612488,
0.20103316009044647,
-0.11427398025989532,
0.6593745946884155,
-0.5611529350280762,
0.24811093509197235,
-0.11801104992628098,
0.015420566312968731,
-1.159281849861145,
-0.14936433732509613,
0.5885801315307617,
-0.49461641907691956,
0.3571648597717285,
0.005680907517671585,
-0.4104713201522827,
-0.33111128211021423,
-0.3706013858318329,
0.34822145104408264,
0.2531841993331909,
-0.6702715754508972,
0.6136285662651062,
0.8545470237731934,
-0.038237810134887695,
-0.841453492641449,
-0.6416057348251343,
0.23594112694263458,
-0.5662035942077637,
-0.49873965978622437,
0.6566137075424194,
0.2743999660015106,
-0.30817732214927673,
0.0753541812300682,
0.2130243182182312,
-0.06865229457616806,
0.2735903859138489,
0.13246433436870575,
-0.27837827801704407,
-0.19339649379253387,
0.5379501581192017,
-0.0502048060297966,
0.4637036919593811,
0.1974913775920868,
0.07358971238136292,
0.3897714614868164,
-0.06374316662549973,
0.35967200994491577,
-0.3681271970272064,
0.3704056143760681,
0.32587140798568726,
-0.062319543212652206,
0.6581003069877625,
1.0174345970153809,
-0.25551849603652954,
-0.3453541100025177,
-0.4046458303928375,
-0.025833113119006157,
-0.5483611226081848,
0.6058263182640076,
-0.3048291802406311,
-1.032720923423767,
0.22568878531455994,
0.05408391356468201,
0.18624909222126007,
0.4195334017276764,
0.3778652250766754,
0.0681270956993103,
0.878921627998352,
0.5484534502029419,
-0.08542360365390778,
0.5201777219772339,
-0.18778865039348602,
0.11682291328907013,
-0.6111236214637756,
-0.15689654648303986,
-0.4778707027435303,
-0.29989224672317505,
-0.8032292723655701,
-0.6276600956916809,
0.13913455605506897,
-0.24451878666877747,
-0.19547821581363678,
0.5806374549865723,
-0.45913082361221313,
0.3612186312675476,
0.047571878880262375,
0.27697741985321045,
-0.2915918827056885,
-0.01772746630012989,
0.006930267438292503,
0.15049293637275696,
-0.6158209443092346,
-0.36137253046035767,
1.1677594184875488,
0.7282487750053406,
0.2577049732208252,
0.5707017779350281,
0.7284546494483948,
0.6246407628059387,
0.5970705151557922,
-0.7593935132026672,
0.47516852617263794,
-0.6303228139877319,
-0.8777971863746643,
-0.34274283051490784,
-0.6104715466499329,
-0.6726406812667847,
0.41128259897232056,
-0.5369678735733032,
-0.723548948764801,
0.2036018818616867,
0.14634640514850616,
-0.5340955853462219,
0.4363727569580078,
-0.3777945935726166,
0.5960226058959961,
-0.052946239709854126,
-0.3881556987762451,
-0.36126840114593506,
-0.43238481879234314,
0.5089555382728577,
-0.16783110797405243,
0.6783087849617004,
-0.10456325858831406,
-0.504978358745575,
1.2109873294830322,
-0.23183494806289673,
1.1690263748168945,
-0.30209192633628845,
-0.017157169058918953,
0.5718506574630737,
-0.31834498047828674,
0.09513093531131744,
0.02426311932504177,
-0.10603351891040802,
-0.0365205742418766,
-0.45829159021377563,
-0.18988904356956482,
-0.44784247875213623,
0.10803297907114029,
-0.5029831528663635,
-0.3959709107875824,
-0.07060976326465607,
-0.19515720009803772,
-0.14310777187347412,
-0.01724032498896122,
0.30440405011177063,
0.5724301934242249,
-0.6515740752220154,
0.3410143256187439,
0.7807865738868713,
-0.3584510087966919,
0.4479981064796448,
0.42522841691970825,
-0.002362214494496584,
-0.5808582901954651,
0.9370660185813904,
0.02370147965848446,
0.23214736580848694,
0.419060081243515,
0.3948000371456146,
-0.5085083246231079,
-0.3909275233745575,
-0.03759241849184036,
-0.11158230155706406,
-0.8231286406517029,
-0.5284981727600098,
-0.9908920526504517,
-0.15194380283355713,
-0.6482109427452087,
-0.04899381473660469,
-0.2744719088077545,
-0.17764157056808472,
-0.18213927745819092,
-0.23140770196914673,
0.23996292054653168,
0.7308561205863953,
-0.5459985136985779,
0.9469782710075378,
-0.48464828729629517,
0.4017024636268616,
0.5324004888534546,
0.28310203552246094,
-0.26518476009368896,
-0.9086678624153137,
-0.09050852060317993,
0.11209473758935928,
-0.4581620991230011,
-1.0976366996765137,
0.3113836646080017,
0.6422073841094971,
0.5903514623641968,
0.8639088869094849,
0.09643356502056122,
0.6160276532173157,
-0.2849399447441101,
0.49144232273101807,
0.32010549306869507,
-1.179093360900879,
0.4233050048351288,
-0.11145108193159103,
-0.13129529356956482,
0.5598574876785278,
0.7785981297492981,
-0.35421717166900635,
-0.6074451208114624,
-0.7950544953346252,
-0.9440337419509888,
0.38828667998313904,
0.054608337581157684,
0.7873574495315552,
-0.5769152641296387,
-0.0728958398103714,
-0.2988281548023224,
0.15500853955745697,
-0.7005279064178467,
-0.35611242055892944,
-0.12985014915466309,
-0.02770925685763359,
-0.049180831760168076,
-0.39417073130607605,
-0.36104050278663635,
-0.4148145616054535,
0.4834786355495453,
0.029206475242972374,
0.38741883635520935,
-0.1605404019355774,
-0.189026340842247,
0.20815792679786682,
0.2829018533229828,
0.675958514213562,
0.5184766054153442,
-0.1515674591064453,
0.2212040275335312,
0.4129987955093384,
-0.5802211165428162,
0.10203812271356583,
-0.21197399497032166,
0.15864047408103943,
0.4745609760284424,
0.3722275495529175,
0.7392896413803101,
0.4661441743373871,
-0.4699523150920868,
0.8215010762214661,
0.05312725529074669,
-0.43570443987846375,
-0.15352676808834076,
0.016238044947385788,
-0.033998455852270126,
0.23349729180335999,
0.16685469448566437,
0.01805630512535572,
0.4656257927417755,
-0.6810422539710999,
0.6432033777236938,
0.46937552094459534,
-0.4232930541038513,
-0.08629418164491653,
0.32555049657821655,
0.6302953362464905,
-0.33222463726997375,
0.4773001968860626,
-0.6315200328826904,
-1.0139950513839722,
0.3854288160800934,
0.5565915703773499,
0.9317988157272339,
-0.48421868681907654,
0.5748012065887451,
0.4092826545238495,
0.32457759976387024,
0.42991986870765686,
0.07204682379961014,
-0.10912147909402847,
-1.0147444009780884,
-0.14968055486679077,
-0.8048593997955322,
-0.023099346086382866,
0.27486807107925415,
-0.5482260584831238,
0.36863332986831665,
-0.9482912421226501,
-0.45902881026268005,
0.40173059701919556,
-0.4140927791595459,
-0.48864316940307617,
0.18736959993839264,
0.6264871954917908,
0.9291977882385254,
-1.1312395334243774,
0.5330740809440613,
0.41396886110305786,
-0.21253478527069092,
-0.7132545113563538,
-0.3249719440937042,
0.1794905662536621,
-0.9002382159233093,
0.996399462223053,
0.09706339985132217,
-0.1666308492422104,
-0.1611475646495819,
-0.3513179123401642,
-0.5416925549507141,
0.6132985949516296,
-0.10269182920455933,
-0.4871252179145813,
-0.08173512667417526,
0.0964910164475441,
0.49791911244392395,
-0.7176165580749512,
0.23138947784900665,
0.665564239025116,
0.24387164413928986,
0.0859585553407669,
-0.7631136178970337,
0.02309935912489891,
0.027691666036844254,
-0.13390427827835083,
0.24017523229122162,
-0.3315330147743225,
0.5873813629150391,
-0.009641052223742008,
-0.6030598878860474,
-0.24249103665351868,
0.6689019799232483,
-0.3885568082332611,
0.3406496047973633,
0.7361936569213867,
0.7299840450286865,
0.7436890006065369,
-0.08265749365091324,
0.5384700894355774,
0.10449808835983276,
0.0320514477789402,
1.0174572467803955,
0.30604270100593567,
0.881650984287262,
-0.018130546435713768,
-0.17834632098674774,
0.6187928915023804,
0.45153066515922546,
-0.07106463611125946,
0.6091930866241455,
0.49295827746391296,
-0.5258963704109192,
-0.07473915815353394,
-0.3677302896976471,
-0.1578562706708908,
1.0957645177841187,
0.874377965927124,
-0.8277591466903687,
-0.27039599418640137,
0.3479256331920624,
0.15135538578033447,
0.3658045530319214,
-0.5582559108734131,
1.0280808210372925,
-0.08525721728801727,
-0.04050825908780098,
0.5585370063781738,
0.23884379863739014,
1.0446510314941406,
-0.4245254397392273,
0.18919619917869568,
-0.006867776624858379,
-0.09335421025753021,
-0.32448282837867737,
-0.5701591968536377,
0.6229051947593689,
0.09061247855424881,
0.12963330745697021,
-0.1052059605717659,
0.4366207718849182,
-0.4676162898540497,
-0.2191040962934494,
0.5021308660507202,
0.18215501308441162,
0.06294757127761841,
0.019891882315278053,
-0.8711581826210022,
0.16472451388835907,
-0.25285637378692627,
0.37594905495643616,
0.03853164240717888,
0.4403868317604065,
0.18860352039337158,
0.28020501136779785,
0.41898807883262634,
0.20940859615802765,
0.28421738743782043,
-0.03054698184132576,
0.8306562304496765,
-0.23032768070697784,
-0.5439751744270325,
-1.1333707571029663,
0.29560863971710205,
-0.38920801877975464,
-0.3740214407444,
0.3538900911808014,
0.47679004073143005,
0.943115770816803,
0.1404939591884613,
0.7880404591560364,
-0.423678994178772,
0.4813031554222107,
-0.13925819098949432,
0.47906050086021423,
-0.2902355194091797,
0.14327481389045715,
-0.647320568561554,
-0.6667119860649109,
-0.18574398756027222,
0.5193962454795837,
-0.1806195080280304,
-0.13255801796913147,
0.2336934506893158,
0.6860819458961487,
-0.13591787219047546,
0.13233843445777893,
0.5098100900650024,
-0.08002312481403351,
0.18199780583381653,
0.3439893126487732,
0.6616356372833252,
-0.39016756415367126,
0.6957665681838989,
-0.4142911732196808,
-0.5135798454284668,
-0.33836057782173157,
-0.69065922498703,
-0.843149721622467,
-0.5592184662818909,
-0.5354996919631958,
-0.3784342408180237,
0.41672396659851074,
0.8227326273918152,
0.8440308570861816,
-0.7150542736053467,
-0.32994815707206726,
0.22692888975143433,
0.19416369497776031,
-0.20702804625034332,
-0.2787184417247772,
0.07491936534643173,
-0.5973305702209473,
-0.5539424419403076,
0.30820655822753906,
0.04127713292837143,
-0.19083532691001892,
0.05465495213866234,
0.037198781967163086,
-0.6395314931869507,
0.26161399483680725,
0.9505810737609863,
0.25668761134147644,
-0.4601956605911255,
-0.3871273398399353,
-0.2460673600435257,
-0.042024802416563034,
-0.2293909341096878,
0.614011287689209,
-0.4518844187259674,
0.5764214992523193,
0.3827258348464966,
0.9844145178794861,
-0.18328958749771118,
0.30324363708496094,
0.5490445494651794,
-1.1281064748764038,
0.062181372195482254,
0.39020437002182007,
0.08546436578035355,
0.39822378754615784,
-0.3425714671611786,
0.43284472823143005,
0.4530124068260193,
-0.07941596955060959,
-0.6265024542808533,
0.11056146025657654,
-0.5109300017356873,
-0.4683346748352051,
1.0470175743103027,
-0.26713240146636963,
-0.05397818237543106,
-0.23621425032615662,
0.28854110836982727,
0.5519239902496338,
-0.3999992907047272,
0.6599664092063904,
0.41027870774269104,
0.2339373081922531,
-0.1560511291027069,
-0.3277967870235443,
0.8562255501747131,
0.10932100564241409,
-0.4905030429363251,
0.10110387206077576,
0.20644070208072662,
0.37904107570648193,
0.6079090237617493,
0.5034976005554199,
-0.03132999315857887,
0.31848105788230896,
0.12534068524837494,
-0.3038729429244995,
-0.007236186880618334,
-0.48168838024139404,
-0.31470897793769836,
0.5526569485664368,
-0.32960671186447144,
-0.7094489932060242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03216v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03216v4 | BGE M3-Embedding: Multi-Lingual, Multi-Functionality, Multi-Granularity Text Embeddings Through Self-Knowledge Distillation | 2024-02-05T17:26:49 | 2024-06-28T09:55:49 | Jianlv Chen, Shitao Xiao, Peitian Zhang, Kun Luo, Defu Lian, Zheng Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we present a new embedding model, called M3-Embedding, which
is distinguished for its versatility in Multi-Linguality, Multi-Functionality,
and Multi-Granularity. It can support more than 100 working languages, leading
to new state-of-the-art performances on multi-lingual and cross-lingual
retrieval tasks. It can simultaneously perform the three common retrieval
functionalities of embedding model: dense retrieval, multi-vector retrieval,
and sparse retrieval, which provides a unified model foundation for real-world
IR applications. It is able to process inputs of different granularities,
spanning from short sentences to long documents of up to 8192 tokens. The
effective training of M3-Embedding involves the following technical
contributions. We propose a novel self-knowledge distillation approach, where
the relevance scores from different retrieval functionalities can be integrated
as the teacher signal to enhance the training quality. We also optimize the
batching strategy, enabling a large batch size and high training throughput to
ensure the discriminativeness of embeddings. To the best of our knowledge,
M3-Embedding is the first embedding model which realizes such a strong
versatility. The model and code will be publicly available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding. | [
-0.6480177640914917,
-0.6492094993591309,
0.5860168933868408,
0.04059365391731262,
-0.22024044394493103,
-0.012956843711435795,
0.018297454342246056,
-0.1630203127861023,
0.12200025469064713,
0.29684698581695557,
-0.11651366204023361,
-0.5009006261825562,
-0.8840847015380859,
-0.05331384763121605,
-0.2662001848220825,
0.8786956667900085,
-0.13074181973934174,
0.3478890657424927,
-0.32294127345085144,
-0.3461637794971466,
-0.29898932576179504,
-0.5786837339401245,
-0.06446962058544159,
-0.40746062994003296,
0.3707011938095093,
0.43218547105789185,
0.4866202771663666,
0.5043894648551941,
0.4715544879436493,
0.2508213222026825,
0.07622606307268143,
0.12876537442207336,
-0.4685269594192505,
-0.19978049397468567,
-0.30440422892570496,
-0.2125365287065506,
-0.29724204540252686,
-0.021652670577168465,
0.7896267771720886,
0.5174546837806702,
-0.31920552253723145,
0.13010403513908386,
0.3299257159233093,
0.7516220211982727,
-0.7547183632850647,
0.19329707324504852,
-0.5684348344802856,
0.195032998919487,
0.1815171092748642,
0.18593436479568481,
-0.38463422656059265,
-0.02651864103972912,
0.25762811303138733,
-0.2371395081281662,
-0.08387523889541626,
0.0886683464050293,
0.6647877097129822,
0.10565859079360962,
-0.5297427773475647,
-0.45218756794929504,
-0.5282397866249084,
0.8819916844367981,
-0.6067039370536804,
0.5786275267601013,
0.4176388084888458,
0.43950366973876953,
0.2717798054218292,
-0.8033234477043152,
-0.3916349709033966,
-0.0978727638721466,
-0.1288328617811203,
0.034646712243556976,
-0.04194757714867592,
-0.004539621062576771,
-0.08181510865688324,
0.576170802116394,
-0.3746514618396759,
-0.2037651538848877,
-0.11659221351146698,
-0.025672204792499542,
0.26146116852760315,
-0.19641678035259247,
0.010276197455823421,
-0.02807631529867649,
-0.6325504779815674,
0.11905945837497711,
-0.5041473507881165,
-0.39231789112091064,
0.24937258660793304,
0.14480428397655487,
0.012999014928936958,
0.4752657413482666,
-0.22875052690505981,
0.6081091165542603,
0.1167398989200592,
-0.28331702947616577,
0.2998802363872528,
-0.21504530310630798,
-0.1933719366788864,
-0.11629438400268555,
0.8286933302879333,
-0.017815645784139633,
-0.10230860114097595,
-0.11178990453481674,
-0.3920133709907532,
-0.4862593412399292,
0.14972615242004395,
-1.030039668083191,
-0.08803337067365646,
-0.08334233611822128,
-0.5468225479125977,
-0.28012633323669434,
0.18554449081420898,
-0.5116854906082153,
-0.09890789538621902,
-0.19706356525421143,
0.9437757730484009,
-0.5876929759979248,
-0.42500072717666626,
0.40605810284614563,
-0.19817543029785156,
0.02807389385998249,
0.10273077338933945,
-1.1069470643997192,
0.144566610455513,
0.5350688099861145,
0.9463905692100525,
0.24411462247371674,
-0.4945114552974701,
-0.1977124959230423,
0.3638480603694916,
0.11953933537006378,
0.4614185690879822,
-0.6069424152374268,
-0.537826657295227,
0.025942888110876083,
-0.2698844075202942,
0.03345685452222824,
-0.5071958899497986,
0.07150933891534805,
-0.6084293127059937,
0.2876424491405487,
-0.09514742344617844,
-0.7730442881584167,
-0.5468189716339111,
0.47491270303726196,
-0.6892625689506531,
1.0092790126800537,
0.11347610503435135,
-0.7810282707214355,
0.2657874524593353,
-0.5694515705108643,
-0.16089566051959991,
-0.14178456366062164,
-0.19620415568351746,
-0.6058597564697266,
0.03896666318178177,
0.22944636642932892,
0.7543292045593262,
-0.2664133310317993,
0.4338223934173584,
-0.41302651166915894,
-0.3288929760456085,
0.020902488380670547,
-0.4785667657852173,
0.5692858099937439,
0.31824472546577454,
-0.18130989372730255,
-0.4300738573074341,
-0.42085641622543335,
-0.185033917427063,
-0.17748084664344788,
-0.394391268491745,
-0.4299505949020386,
-0.18663600087165833,
-0.06890944391489029,
0.25411441922187805,
0.6146246790885925,
-0.5826689004898071,
0.37968647480010986,
0.15323406457901,
0.16678743064403534,
0.4262959659099579,
-0.06518068164587021,
0.5424671173095703,
-0.37472397089004517,
0.2820214331150055,
0.30095550417900085,
0.17475838959217072,
-0.3281867206096649,
-0.3344917595386505,
-0.42304331064224243,
-0.6241127252578735,
0.49086183309555054,
0.4923519194126129,
-0.6582674384117126,
0.4962523281574249,
-0.2754802703857422,
-0.6162360310554504,
-0.6557521224021912,
0.38634541630744934,
0.5300840139389038,
0.31446346640586853,
0.5677151679992676,
-0.09416114538908005,
-0.39176589250564575,
-0.9689130187034607,
0.022331172600388527,
0.06825535744428635,
0.1738520711660385,
0.22253286838531494,
0.7087459564208984,
-0.5775692462921143,
0.937324047088623,
-0.7175148725509644,
-0.5885255932807922,
-0.42082667350769043,
0.32876449823379517,
0.1190769299864769,
0.5989155173301697,
0.5905846357345581,
-0.6710479855537415,
-0.6510134935379028,
0.032756153494119644,
-0.9699870347976685,
0.3297067880630493,
0.14323031902313232,
-0.1899474859237671,
0.12075532227754593,
0.610523521900177,
-0.22156508266925812,
0.0995568111538887,
0.7546080350875854,
-0.11390162259340286,
0.34284457564353943,
-0.3818252980709076,
0.09686229377985,
-1.4347816705703735,
0.01244810875505209,
-0.05324231833219528,
-0.38349515199661255,
-0.45030349493026733,
0.12030259519815445,
0.3974587619304657,
-0.0766364112496376,
-0.48966163396835327,
0.5356427431106567,
-0.689265251159668,
0.08488040417432785,
-0.2919635772705078,
0.21742309629917145,
0.2742767035961151,
0.4613843858242035,
-0.09673510491847992,
0.6068596839904785,
0.7357943058013916,
-0.7035439014434814,
0.09854831546545029,
0.2632642090320587,
-0.49392035603523254,
0.5051338076591492,
-0.41100218892097473,
-0.04467857629060745,
-0.2547796070575714,
0.11946973204612732,
-0.7919473648071289,
0.2339629828929901,
-0.12884379923343658,
-0.3570525050163269,
0.5720910429954529,
-0.7567590475082397,
-0.550743818283081,
-0.16746339201927185,
-0.38190674781799316,
0.3355199694633484,
0.4696841537952423,
-0.6622562408447266,
0.779464840888977,
0.6015803217887878,
0.041784852743148804,
-0.8371394872665405,
-0.7571278214454651,
-0.07545579969882965,
-0.1716047078371048,
-0.4899170398712158,
0.48411279916763306,
-0.03829203546047211,
0.20402906835079193,
0.18207447230815887,
-0.03011946566402912,
-0.04592237249016762,
0.1682361364364624,
-0.13636168837547302,
0.08527591824531555,
-0.010017961263656616,
0.2539703845977783,
0.32559406757354736,
-0.23178279399871826,
-0.20433105528354645,
-0.6064097881317139,
0.3674975633621216,
-0.20541462302207947,
-0.6313468217849731,
-0.29514890909194946,
0.5424347519874573,
0.5190051198005676,
-0.3369970917701721,
0.8867043256759644,
0.9858309030532837,
-0.3361704349517822,
-0.15402939915657043,
-0.722396969795227,
-0.16370896995067596,
-0.5480650663375854,
0.4723360538482666,
-0.5307745337486267,
-1.2232065200805664,
0.36170175671577454,
-0.33051812648773193,
0.10091172903776169,
0.19433118402957916,
0.42152196168899536,
-0.22078193724155426,
1.050687551498413,
0.8039957880973816,
-0.30872809886932373,
0.6115802526473999,
-0.6402167677879333,
0.19130322337150574,
-0.953718900680542,
-0.36073410511016846,
-0.2874755859375,
-0.2477053999900818,
-0.6784914135932922,
-0.5593647956848145,
0.4690115749835968,
0.11337422579526901,
-0.22392545640468597,
-0.028716186061501503,
-0.34697073698043823,
0.4275975227355957,
0.4894832670688629,
-0.09591306746006012,
0.13667891919612885,
0.07801242917776108,
-0.5063022971153259,
0.1541105955839157,
-0.6667514443397522,
-0.5340567827224731,
1.0942304134368896,
0.41976097226142883,
0.9418722987174988,
0.45364442467689514,
1.2012882232666016,
0.32092294096946716,
0.12125135213136673,
-0.8754655718803406,
0.3918744921684265,
-0.3493626117706299,
-0.7787036299705505,
-0.25701960921287537,
-0.3465960621833801,
-0.7476548552513123,
0.6544103026390076,
-0.23372922837734222,
-0.5960559248924255,
0.0243857279419899,
0.07505618780851364,
-0.09297891706228256,
0.6019492745399475,
-0.8267560005187988,
0.9572675824165344,
-0.022700130939483643,
-0.28152763843536377,
-0.22541294991970062,
-0.2546202540397644,
0.197465717792511,
-0.013888605870306492,
0.2877718508243561,
-0.19431616365909576,
0.04583489149808884,
0.5371567010879517,
-0.18103928864002228,
0.7565136551856995,
-0.5769931077957153,
-0.013192740269005299,
0.4379056990146637,
0.1879129707813263,
0.3239947557449341,
0.2904909551143646,
-0.1979118287563324,
0.23097625374794006,
0.12907256186008453,
-0.417756587266922,
-0.7589737772941589,
0.7213378548622131,
-0.741239070892334,
-0.8035176396369934,
-0.46088311076164246,
-0.07791011035442352,
-0.1407884657382965,
0.4286389648914337,
0.0017000655643641949,
0.6565303802490234,
-0.34947240352630615,
0.5030279159545898,
0.897803008556366,
0.17932799458503723,
0.5931682586669922,
0.5790817141532898,
-0.6441158652305603,
-0.5466822981834412,
1.1133326292037964,
0.11216141283512115,
0.12748649716377258,
0.6378301978111267,
0.33334222435951233,
-0.3617084324359894,
-0.5914800763130188,
-0.5379593372344971,
0.24624407291412354,
-0.6714292168617249,
-0.4247979521751404,
-0.8487148284912109,
-0.2549189031124115,
-0.28033140301704407,
-0.2227863371372223,
-0.6385819315910339,
-0.2547461986541748,
-0.43891701102256775,
-0.1475045531988144,
0.2511414885520935,
0.9993172883987427,
-0.2939563989639282,
0.30151379108428955,
-1.1645379066467285,
0.174137145280838,
0.5234792232513428,
0.677937924861908,
0.0660504475235939,
-0.6076117157936096,
-0.9524774551391602,
0.07993344962596893,
-0.3821025490760803,
-0.7806722521781921,
0.3797544538974762,
0.24834007024765015,
0.7953356504440308,
0.43019336462020874,
-0.23014762997627258,
0.5962410569190979,
-0.5530617237091064,
0.6028106808662415,
0.08335711061954498,
-1.1536691188812256,
0.40763822197914124,
-0.2975998520851135,
0.3968406915664673,
0.9157227277755737,
0.7647903561592102,
-0.3780125379562378,
-0.14425331354141235,
-0.29293808341026306,
-0.7696878910064697,
0.5564932823181152,
-0.14109817147254944,
0.3412884771823883,
-0.016343509778380394,
0.22865687310695648,
0.3535299301147461,
0.18618972599506378,
-0.728994607925415,
-0.33425986766815186,
-0.3922717273235321,
-0.35265007615089417,
0.07147525995969772,
-0.5240771770477295,
-0.07141324877738953,
-0.29579824209213257,
0.8166657090187073,
-0.24246583878993988,
0.41666513681411743,
0.16249968111515045,
-0.46708783507347107,
0.5359951853752136,
0.1741400510072708,
0.160814568400383,
0.4613734483718872,
-0.3591427206993103,
0.3228965103626251,
0.2268122285604477,
-0.6104415655136108,
0.24913032352924347,
0.1020580530166626,
-0.07312705367803574,
-0.004062413237988949,
0.08525418490171432,
0.6299222111701965,
0.37045496702194214,
-0.14666393399238586,
0.5532159209251404,
-0.09934932738542557,
-0.25478246808052063,
-0.34911081194877625,
-0.019680548459291458,
0.13651378452777863,
0.2289300113916397,
0.4642181396484375,
-0.3215036690235138,
0.5340572595596313,
-0.5701693892478943,
0.3756127655506134,
0.5658748745918274,
-0.3050672113895416,
-0.051770973950624466,
0.19131271541118622,
0.20169757306575775,
0.1434473842382431,
0.40054991841316223,
-0.6248364448547363,
-0.4734778106212616,
0.15861359238624573,
0.5350343585014343,
0.8259504437446594,
-0.25492167472839355,
0.35251331329345703,
0.5386803150177002,
0.12432625889778137,
-0.24449019134044647,
0.34971883893013,
-0.1491718292236328,
-0.7374311089515686,
-0.07066387683153152,
-0.6390507221221924,
-0.46020230650901794,
-0.27616187930107117,
-0.7020273804664612,
0.40198856592178345,
-0.32153356075286865,
-0.25762704014778137,
-0.19685696065425873,
0.07778524607419968,
-0.6366052627563477,
0.08674014359712601,
0.13812078535556793,
0.7775138020515442,
-0.6580978035926819,
1.0080188512802124,
0.7728899717330933,
-0.4250785708427429,
-0.5381420254707336,
0.010811196640133858,
-0.14738760888576508,
-0.6064572334289551,
0.48025423288345337,
0.35708460211753845,
-0.33904191851615906,
0.212247833609581,
-0.19058243930339813,
-1.2238335609436035,
1.6612485647201538,
0.21510446071624756,
-0.4829644560813904,
0.14817538857460022,
0.016039280220866203,
0.23764365911483765,
-0.5422791838645935,
0.4043736457824707,
0.24325776100158691,
0.3509061932563782,
0.1259414255619049,
-0.7305787205696106,
-0.06914477795362473,
0.013567918911576271,
0.16667644679546356,
0.11396133899688721,
-0.7991164922714233,
0.5734236836433411,
-0.04844599962234497,
-0.10058919340372086,
-0.3300457298755646,
0.8405090570449829,
0.11811330914497375,
0.15853089094161987,
0.21245786547660828,
0.8508632779121399,
0.7431775331497192,
0.02694561891257763,
0.8837903141975403,
-0.5320747494697571,
0.6197758913040161,
1.0127171277999878,
-0.14390839636325836,
0.9008370637893677,
0.37703511118888855,
-0.10941428691148758,
0.8175938725471497,
0.08687000721693039,
-0.10988866537809372,
0.8901944160461426,
0.03470922261476517,
-0.48931294679641724,
-0.07412683963775635,
0.1689847856760025,
-0.3508535623550415,
0.6102985739707947,
0.3810070753097534,
-0.320965051651001,
-0.256433367729187,
0.16459327936172485,
0.186243936419487,
-0.21722260117530823,
-0.1816096305847168,
0.9375578165054321,
0.11630342900753021,
-0.6166998147964478,
0.49436894059181213,
0.3077123165130615,
1.0160987377166748,
-0.7547118663787842,
0.01538456417620182,
-0.27632153034210205,
0.040823355317115784,
-0.16047148406505585,
-0.8310315012931824,
0.28542932868003845,
-0.2792022228240967,
-0.15416298806667328,
-0.35627907514572144,
0.6558791399002075,
-0.6094894409179688,
-0.4604114890098572,
0.4643082618713379,
0.8443349003791809,
-0.08233126997947693,
0.02161007560789585,
-0.6683773994445801,
-0.08371969312429428,
-0.01145006250590086,
-0.28787606954574585,
0.5647754669189453,
0.7501851916313171,
0.482490599155426,
0.7701126337051392,
0.4239138662815094,
-0.30749309062957764,
-0.008285727351903915,
0.16713400185108185,
0.8987451195716858,
-0.6185291409492493,
-0.41236647963523865,
-0.9927524328231812,
0.5279157161712646,
0.10465903580188751,
0.05250782147049904,
0.6785244941711426,
0.7237676382064819,
0.7552914023399353,
-0.1990584135055542,
0.9062050580978394,
0.053861699998378754,
0.06612175703048706,
-0.5559401512145996,
0.8625672459602356,
-0.6702705025672913,
0.1900472491979599,
-0.18930941820144653,
-0.8227914571762085,
-0.153391033411026,
0.6962394714355469,
-0.036649253219366074,
0.3915247321128845,
0.7502486109733582,
0.8041899800300598,
-0.30506619811058044,
-0.17747750878334045,
0.6386942863464355,
-0.1130974069237709,
0.2605694532394409,
0.2669237554073334,
0.6007766723632812,
-0.40134987235069275,
0.531301736831665,
-0.18820950388908386,
-0.21659132838249207,
-0.46228620409965515,
-0.9513046741485596,
-0.9797881245613098,
-0.9074568152427673,
-0.322873592376709,
-0.0003041396557819098,
-0.09051699936389923,
0.8587513566017151,
0.8241515159606934,
-0.47861284017562866,
-0.16872426867485046,
0.19816744327545166,
0.32202836871147156,
0.0068191769532859325,
-0.19631855189800262,
0.18557488918304443,
-0.439868301153183,
-0.7224299907684326,
0.3034486770629883,
0.29555976390838623,
0.38256341218948364,
-0.7029321193695068,
-0.017238397151231766,
-0.6134145259857178,
0.12140653282403946,
0.7074872851371765,
-0.0741940289735794,
-0.32654669880867004,
-0.2072535902261734,
-0.20594875514507294,
-0.2599383592605591,
-0.013823656365275383,
0.6357247829437256,
-0.7724049687385559,
0.4908784329891205,
0.3801821768283844,
0.6671737432479858,
0.772541344165802,
-0.3583306670188904,
0.39638063311576843,
-0.9392820000648499,
-0.0032456256449222565,
0.06251257658004761,
0.6826258897781372,
0.45575782656669617,
-0.24530161917209625,
0.39741891622543335,
-0.011070191860198975,
-0.5194616317749023,
-0.5718787908554077,
0.2559562027454376,
-0.702785849571228,
-0.3446536660194397,
1.134645700454712,
-0.5440800189971924,
0.003389854682609439,
-0.08787621557712555,
-0.12173092365264893,
0.3358863890171051,
-0.3779865503311157,
0.9214496612548828,
0.9030673503875732,
0.11221091449260712,
-0.06308554112911224,
-0.35670143365859985,
0.3218618631362915,
0.3861124813556671,
-0.5250827670097351,
-0.23115858435630798,
0.3640265464782715,
0.4559484124183655,
0.18151238560676575,
0.5759636163711548,
-0.3122000992298126,
0.031931422650814056,
0.12531228363513947,
0.14898337423801422,
-0.5163949131965637,
-0.4123305082321167,
-0.34963610768318176,
0.2063259482383728,
0.318442702293396,
-0.21998047828674316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03191v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03191v3 | Isotropy, Clusters, and Classifiers | 2024-02-05T16:57:24 | 2024-05-27T10:21:08 | Timothee Mickus, Stig-Arne Grönroos, Joseph Attieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Whether embedding spaces use all their dimensions equally, i.e., whether they
are isotropic, has been a recent subject of discussion. Evidence has been
accrued both for and against enforcing isotropy in embedding spaces. In the
present paper, we stress that isotropy imposes requirements on the embedding
space that are not compatible with the presence of clusters -- which also
negatively impacts linear classification objectives. We demonstrate this fact
both mathematically and empirically and use it to shed light on previous
results from the literature. | [
-0.3454984724521637,
-0.25714704394340515,
0.7779690623283386,
0.42977145314216614,
-0.08422552794218063,
-0.17475007474422455,
-0.2483532577753067,
-0.5920335650444031,
0.4000300168991089,
-0.032677799463272095,
0.23553019762039185,
-0.7882562279701233,
-0.6475083231925964,
0.13892368972301483,
-0.6125451326370239,
0.7421010732650757,
-0.33744049072265625,
-0.207839697599411,
-0.9815678000450134,
-0.6197757124900818,
-0.18098941445350647,
-0.5861685276031494,
0.09536577761173248,
0.1059931218624115,
0.506859302520752,
0.4663637578487396,
1.0245329141616821,
0.9762669801712036,
0.45944520831108093,
0.23743309080600739,
-0.017115458846092224,
-0.28260529041290283,
-0.08266424387693405,
0.26920896768569946,
0.3638004958629608,
-0.5081364512443542,
-0.10485123097896576,
0.14021937549114227,
0.9617962837219238,
0.7722750902175903,
-0.40391483902931213,
-0.12675943970680237,
0.27742865681648254,
0.34519296884536743,
-1.04658842086792,
-0.10283608734607697,
-0.4396075904369354,
0.39802876114845276,
0.25818929076194763,
0.03803889825940132,
-0.00855933502316475,
-0.7784283757209778,
-0.16311924159526825,
-0.7068212628364563,
0.5087907314300537,
0.010197769850492477,
0.6976060271263123,
0.5523933172225952,
-0.5761899352073669,
-0.45203712582588196,
-0.9177378416061401,
0.6031534671783447,
-0.2806982696056366,
0.441328227519989,
0.28192058205604553,
0.21721072494983673,
0.21071194112300873,
-0.6544679403305054,
-0.3450474143028259,
-0.1576961725950241,
-0.2951433062553406,
-0.07606156915426254,
-0.368301659822464,
0.3200581669807434,
0.44992804527282715,
0.17562030255794525,
-0.3676595985889435,
0.6057970523834229,
-0.9714164733886719,
0.2036285102367401,
0.5096883177757263,
0.17414513230323792,
0.23914982378482819,
0.11449626088142395,
-0.836965799331665,
-0.03799596056342125,
-0.631633996963501,
0.3059098720550537,
0.31922346353530884,
0.29908204078674316,
-0.12098516523838043,
0.7565928101539612,
0.3804425597190857,
0.7208369374275208,
0.010478728450834751,
0.0044534532353281975,
0.11649004369974136,
0.038017965853214264,
0.059653449803590775,
0.4820334315299988,
0.4501332938671112,
0.6339840888977051,
-0.10363338887691498,
-0.05291663855314255,
0.1117316335439682,
0.41560643911361694,
0.449872761964798,
-0.7661001086235046,
-0.049818214029073715,
0.49689623713493347,
-0.27749210596084595,
-0.38955211639404297,
0.43468815088272095,
-0.5233322978019714,
-0.42343199253082275,
-0.09585946798324585,
0.20887981355190277,
-0.19356726109981537,
0.14483922719955444,
0.04905030131340027,
-0.5418633818626404,
0.06337428092956543,
0.3756491243839264,
-0.6844251751899719,
0.2639199197292328,
0.7021834850311279,
0.6542789936065674,
-0.07886457443237305,
-0.5172284841537476,
0.24368402361869812,
0.15855497121810913,
-0.3220648169517517,
0.8942624926567078,
-1.078565239906311,
-0.5311011672019958,
-0.0007781136664561927,
-0.13915692269802094,
-0.15842217206954956,
-0.6674802303314209,
0.31066182255744934,
0.19695070385932922,
-0.012702155858278275,
-0.35494494438171387,
-0.5496025085449219,
-0.09491238743066788,
0.04274645075201988,
-0.4383898973464966,
0.39393287897109985,
0.1561737060546875,
-0.4134555459022522,
0.7931493520736694,
-0.0648636743426323,
-0.3372402787208557,
-0.11355344951152802,
-0.5922539830207825,
-0.6634733080863953,
0.4828575551509857,
-0.3173814117908478,
0.1349339634180069,
0.11087103933095932,
0.14600984752178192,
-0.8839561343193054,
-0.28748008608818054,
0.4142668545246124,
0.025942588225007057,
0.5480177402496338,
0.4613863229751587,
-0.06614666432142258,
-0.307311475276947,
-0.9844586253166199,
0.2569650113582611,
-0.3717115521430969,
-0.5460085272789001,
-0.39010924100875854,
0.34658727049827576,
0.29832592606544495,
0.2928396761417389,
0.11750374734401703,
-0.7444920539855957,
0.3175003230571747,
0.5754837393760681,
0.5290072560310364,
0.6999451518058777,
-0.42936185002326965,
0.680342972278595,
-0.35116735100746155,
0.7213050127029419,
0.10294368118047714,
0.040397096425294876,
0.5705086588859558,
-0.3901790976524353,
-0.1554594188928604,
-0.5912160277366638,
0.11549429595470428,
0.33694881200790405,
-0.09183375537395477,
0.6758013367652893,
0.18069447576999664,
-0.5601525902748108,
-0.24136020243167877,
0.285391241312027,
0.2815495431423187,
-0.22342269122600555,
0.21228699386119843,
-0.059656232595443726,
-0.7376498579978943,
-0.9078945517539978,
-0.18615402281284332,
-0.21290791034698486,
0.1702943593263626,
0.3888383209705353,
0.28703752160072327,
-0.34181538224220276,
0.955637514591217,
-0.4684738516807556,
-0.4652535617351532,
0.30403220653533936,
-0.28202691674232483,
-0.16137883067131042,
0.6149005889892578,
1.0621296167373657,
-0.5418640971183777,
-0.4469311237335205,
-0.2578903138637543,
-0.9903302192687988,
-0.18103455007076263,
0.08482424914836884,
0.3662465214729309,
-0.0006043881876394153,
1.072113037109375,
-0.7336928248405457,
0.8069016933441162,
0.6008277535438538,
-0.6219750642776489,
0.316531777381897,
-0.3464583456516266,
-0.46769049763679504,
-0.6079084873199463,
-0.19057421386241913,
0.3035772442817688,
-0.08938679844141006,
-0.5518863201141357,
0.1231289729475975,
0.12527324259281158,
-0.25667741894721985,
-0.2993831932544708,
0.19775836169719696,
-0.12123261392116547,
-0.1004003956913948,
-0.26538076996803284,
0.1352549046278,
0.19164258241653442,
-0.17977724969387054,
-0.022435978055000305,
0.1739087998867035,
0.4516015946865082,
-0.6724447011947632,
0.227616086602211,
0.4487527906894684,
-0.1648874580860138,
0.9581763744354248,
-0.6338447332382202,
-0.40817490220069885,
-0.5100752115249634,
0.6371283531188965,
-1.1017969846725464,
0.1701444536447525,
-0.29514315724372864,
-0.47612684965133667,
0.21202510595321655,
0.22700318694114685,
-0.26940104365348816,
-0.19299811124801636,
-0.5716515183448792,
0.6786017417907715,
0.41119372844696045,
-0.6344743967056274,
0.4717009663581848,
0.16949422657489777,
0.6035248637199402,
-0.6491565704345703,
-0.7054913640022278,
-0.46927517652511597,
-0.6880364418029785,
-0.12213961780071259,
0.25720903277397156,
0.4650970995426178,
-0.6172468662261963,
0.6211544275283813,
-0.4560706615447998,
-0.055463261902332306,
0.11740262806415558,
0.6564618349075317,
-0.11789766699075699,
-0.0025585717521607876,
0.06294632703065872,
-0.06350158900022507,
-0.24605655670166016,
0.2764999568462372,
-0.5314846038818359,
0.27753856778144836,
-0.07982400059700012,
-0.399140864610672,
-0.3194098174571991,
0.24287116527557373,
0.8247243165969849,
0.41207438707351685,
0.8368568420410156,
0.8329143524169922,
-0.24980029463768005,
-0.29195111989974976,
-0.45812472701072693,
0.1596008688211441,
-0.5017794370651245,
0.4322061836719513,
-0.28089725971221924,
-1.240889310836792,
0.6972790360450745,
0.43306729197502136,
0.02811172790825367,
0.5002116560935974,
0.1489439606666565,
-0.6283687353134155,
0.9238969087600708,
0.6597458124160767,
0.009736530482769012,
0.2665214538574219,
-0.08481642603874207,
0.533933699131012,
-1.0627182722091675,
-0.41873714327812195,
-1.085129737854004,
-0.9457356929779053,
-1.2319190502166748,
-0.04301019757986069,
0.5783151984214783,
0.14141571521759033,
-0.3086101710796356,
0.5049046874046326,
-0.5324546098709106,
0.3277479410171509,
0.37693819403648376,
0.08014338463544846,
-0.15560084581375122,
0.13185684382915497,
0.045016027987003326,
0.04718044772744179,
-0.9801366329193115,
-0.0906575471162796,
0.8527909517288208,
0.21402397751808167,
1.2058871984481812,
0.3336903750896454,
0.6226795315742493,
0.05828351899981499,
-0.06176811084151268,
-0.620151162147522,
0.15919837355613708,
-0.35753101110458374,
-0.7963656187057495,
-0.17789480090141296,
-0.37862661480903625,
-1.4674729108810425,
0.2637304365634918,
-0.16609157621860504,
-0.7033047676086426,
1.1260874271392822,
0.09924773871898651,
-0.40684619545936584,
0.7106519341468811,
-0.49876075983047485,
0.6793701648712158,
-0.29276126623153687,
-0.15964056551456451,
-0.3379373550415039,
-0.3345366418361664,
0.08160044252872467,
0.08522308617830276,
0.3510662615299225,
-0.09239764511585236,
-0.13099347054958344,
0.4021894931793213,
-0.684398889541626,
1.1830188035964966,
-0.6371326446533203,
0.16039343178272247,
0.4434105157852173,
0.2964158356189728,
-0.19648411870002747,
-0.14438259601593018,
0.5304269194602966,
0.047290727496147156,
0.5703556537628174,
-0.7376816272735596,
-0.5847370028495789,
0.7773415446281433,
-1.3465042114257812,
-0.6609846949577332,
-0.570787787437439,
-0.5676379799842834,
0.01084160152822733,
-0.4329392910003662,
0.5057294368743896,
0.253187358379364,
-0.36178597807884216,
0.7555848360061646,
0.41898998618125916,
-0.3824547231197357,
0.25354093313217163,
0.08688588440418243,
-0.5143563747406006,
0.0016290276544168591,
1.0028114318847656,
0.5868099927902222,
0.5248481035232544,
-0.03626009449362755,
0.21368438005447388,
-0.17311106622219086,
-0.19558678567409515,
0.05408545583486557,
-0.15790151059627533,
-0.6969095468521118,
-0.21574924886226654,
-0.5333698391914368,
-0.40462544560432434,
-0.5120712518692017,
-0.6420290470123291,
-0.11842552572488785,
-1.123199701309204,
-0.19626331329345703,
-0.38380444049835205,
0.2145901769399643,
0.809293806552887,
-0.6744112372398376,
0.2556622326374054,
-0.8688334822654724,
0.027477776631712914,
0.6205732822418213,
0.21840327978134155,
-0.15798261761665344,
-0.402678519487381,
-0.22249174118041992,
-0.4504072666168213,
-0.32597967982292175,
-0.4580875039100647,
-0.2731107473373413,
0.324384480714798,
0.961062490940094,
1.0171656608581543,
-0.09330127388238907,
0.25436002016067505,
-0.30614832043647766,
0.3986402750015259,
0.27574101090431213,
-0.6962507963180542,
0.3273344039916992,
-0.19484971463680267,
-0.02867407537996769,
0.7044842839241028,
0.7732911109924316,
-0.43681180477142334,
-0.1611628383398056,
-0.9315006136894226,
-0.8298683762550354,
0.14352786540985107,
-0.006914546247571707,
0.04512418434023857,
0.09156487137079239,
0.39748871326446533,
0.1357458382844925,
0.33822813630104065,
-0.6978910565376282,
-0.10362642258405685,
-0.036540284752845764,
-0.06239938735961914,
-0.12088895589113235,
-0.40390217304229736,
-0.21329547464847565,
-0.6101226806640625,
-0.0753895714879036,
0.2212618738412857,
0.42530345916748047,
0.07058434933423996,
-0.005433832295238972,
-0.17892010509967804,
0.049739252775907516,
0.37300652265548706,
0.85479336977005,
-0.2088329941034317,
0.4017743468284607,
0.15201157331466675,
-0.4625910222530365,
0.6850331425666809,
-0.1285698562860489,
-0.23546303808689117,
-0.039560310542583466,
0.34192898869514465,
0.5163649320602417,
0.014745663851499557,
-0.11344508081674576,
0.429465651512146,
0.20542269945144653,
-0.6360494494438171,
-0.42480215430259705,
0.22264878451824188,
-0.44418418407440186,
0.056562382727861404,
-0.2725295126438141,
0.41466522216796875,
-0.17835472524166107,
-0.5708922147750854,
0.037274979054927826,
0.5395376086235046,
-0.8066571354866028,
-0.2977880537509918,
0.4545620083808899,
-0.04565971717238426,
-0.16412821412086487,
0.8044207096099854,
0.021931568160653114,
-0.7982890605926514,
0.9560161828994751,
0.6222761869430542,
0.970713198184967,
-0.47295907139778137,
0.20274771749973297,
0.5149674415588379,
0.5626422166824341,
0.03965143859386444,
0.008889547549188137,
-0.3881990611553192,
-1.184859275817871,
0.24309861660003662,
-0.48760053515434265,
-0.47849053144454956,
-0.560390830039978,
-0.9249765872955322,
0.04867395758628845,
-1.1333571672439575,
-0.012546933256089687,
-0.056713610887527466,
-0.8072784543037415,
-0.5174106359481812,
0.0296943336725235,
0.21452336013317108,
0.6928955316543579,
-1.4709012508392334,
0.5766512751579285,
0.9527080655097961,
-0.11524741351604462,
-0.334247350692749,
-0.23428025841712952,
0.35496294498443604,
-0.8909688591957092,
0.41557034850120544,
0.2632378041744232,
0.01937389187514782,
-0.4321231245994568,
-0.6516414284706116,
-0.9948354363441467,
0.939842939376831,
-0.396698921918869,
-0.39470162987709045,
-0.0761871188879013,
0.5713762044906616,
0.6383336782455444,
-0.30610191822052,
-0.26573923230171204,
0.5262552499771118,
0.7607789635658264,
-0.22375094890594482,
-0.6332683563232422,
0.08342915028333664,
-0.19926348328590393,
0.09118065983057022,
0.099557064473629,
-0.9299136400222778,
0.933673620223999,
-0.13189715147018433,
-0.22257927060127258,
-0.10799304395914078,
0.2356860190629959,
0.4265018701553345,
0.3317927122116089,
0.8051460981369019,
1.5140154361724854,
0.49269068241119385,
-0.2677944302558899,
1.0381358861923218,
-0.23186682164669037,
0.21409587562084198,
0.5203078389167786,
-0.33415740728378296,
0.6318143010139465,
0.4694168269634247,
-0.6746342778205872,
0.5501050353050232,
0.4403340816497803,
-0.3266964852809906,
0.48717445135116577,
0.5106701254844666,
-0.11590547114610672,
-0.20972976088523865,
0.020569633692502975,
-0.6209478974342346,
0.7361506819725037,
0.8179484009742737,
-0.14543253183364868,
-0.44730809330940247,
0.09148125350475311,
-0.21943198144435883,
0.35106122493743896,
0.06962527334690094,
0.4145011007785797,
0.21469075977802277,
-0.012690972536802292,
0.3232530355453491,
-0.029460014775395393,
0.5599682927131653,
-0.1709711253643036,
0.2877333462238312,
0.005546329542994499,
0.503135085105896,
-0.9026551842689514,
-0.6223614811897278,
0.516705334186554,
-0.18300892412662506,
0.15502244234085083,
-0.06318029761314392,
0.3768775761127472,
-0.13013628125190735,
-0.5085299015045166,
0.49011266231536865,
0.5113092064857483,
0.05070391297340393,
0.09885909408330917,
-0.24684830009937286,
0.11955010145902634,
-0.018885169178247452,
0.22139005362987518,
0.47159209847450256,
0.6254278421401978,
0.10338140279054642,
0.19671766459941864,
0.42340001463890076,
-0.027028489857912064,
0.05225204676389694,
-0.2719287872314453,
0.876068115234375,
-0.5057238936424255,
-0.3601160943508148,
-0.8178693056106567,
0.27048394083976746,
0.17266163229942322,
-0.3789414167404175,
0.9364804029464722,
0.9365973472595215,
0.9800937175750732,
0.4702812135219574,
0.7626222372055054,
-0.5045276880264282,
0.11500466614961624,
-0.3055849075317383,
0.27096012234687805,
-0.6919803023338318,
0.28866010904312134,
-0.004937855526804924,
-1.5351256132125854,
-0.4830361008644104,
0.8875834941864014,
-0.2825064957141876,
0.34410133957862854,
1.050136685371399,
0.4893591105937958,
-0.14526678621768951,
0.1309959441423416,
0.329537957906723,
0.21686996519565582,
0.34259578585624695,
0.4988187849521637,
1.4735482931137085,
-0.12199830263853073,
0.24717317521572113,
-0.2721112370491028,
-0.301453560590744,
-0.11908584833145142,
-0.41856807470321655,
-0.847314178943634,
-0.758564293384552,
-0.4628560245037079,
-0.8886958956718445,
-0.2695734202861786,
0.8262696862220764,
0.3280284106731415,
-0.741987943649292,
-0.43673402070999146,
0.020612046122550964,
0.18762116134166718,
-0.11828765273094177,
-0.17657212913036346,
0.28254234790802,
-0.34273096919059753,
-0.33505067229270935,
-0.022323204204440117,
0.17644518613815308,
0.1373664289712906,
-0.25785166025161743,
0.16445668041706085,
0.16264182329177856,
-0.36062559485435486,
0.30667969584465027,
0.5197526216506958,
-0.4484214186668396,
-0.5579756498336792,
-0.176125168800354,
-0.23269911110401154,
0.38319334387779236,
1.0347955226898193,
-0.4680149555206299,
-0.06809891760349274,
0.6473208665847778,
0.3008085787296295,
0.6050116419792175,
0.06483223289251328,
0.2690018117427826,
-0.7294632792472839,
0.54412442445755,
0.1327929049730301,
0.44256651401519775,
-0.11793336272239685,
-0.37657561898231506,
0.42967545986175537,
0.2822871506214142,
-0.7562146186828613,
-0.7303496599197388,
0.21391050517559052,
-0.8158231973648071,
-0.644553542137146,
1.1405948400497437,
0.049358222633600235,
-0.2677212357521057,
0.1409989595413208,
0.24475041031837463,
-0.3637351393699646,
0.036573536694049835,
1.0656386613845825,
0.6162900328636169,
-0.22664174437522888,
-0.027949290350079536,
-0.3340255320072174,
0.277808278799057,
0.2399623990058899,
-0.4602012634277344,
-0.33725103735923767,
0.5147602558135986,
0.10874488949775696,
0.5415707230567932,
0.2011464387178421,
-0.27468639612197876,
0.21223735809326172,
0.3040302097797394,
0.27659907937049866,
-0.040186211466789246,
-0.6857917308807373,
-0.652070939540863,
0.15506987273693085,
0.25573524832725525,
-0.24205288290977478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03190v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03190v4 | Unified Hallucination Detection for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:56:11 | 2024-05-27T11:52:56 | Xiang Chen, Chenxi Wang, Yida Xue, Ningyu Zhang, Xiaoyan Yang, Qiang Li, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM | Despite significant strides in multimodal tasks, Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) are plagued by the critical issue of hallucination. The reliable
detection of such hallucinations in MLLMs has, therefore, become a vital aspect
of model evaluation and the safeguarding of practical application deployment.
Prior research in this domain has been constrained by a narrow focus on
singular tasks, an inadequate range of hallucination categories addressed, and
a lack of detailed granularity. In response to these challenges, our work
expands the investigative horizons of hallucination detection. We present a
novel meta-evaluation benchmark, MHaluBench, meticulously crafted to facilitate
the evaluation of advancements in hallucination detection methods.
Additionally, we unveil a novel unified multimodal hallucination detection
framework, UNIHD, which leverages a suite of auxiliary tools to validate the
occurrence of hallucinations robustly. We demonstrate the effectiveness of
UNIHD through meticulous evaluation and comprehensive analysis. We also provide
strategic insights on the application of specific tools for addressing various
categories of hallucinations. | [
-0.4431028664112091,
-0.8020274043083191,
0.5552740097045898,
0.4921957552433014,
-0.23120947182178497,
-0.014785954728722572,
-0.4369851052761078,
-0.35627496242523193,
0.22124041616916656,
0.5843915939331055,
-0.6946868896484375,
-0.7779600620269775,
-0.30784305930137634,
0.18024326860904694,
-0.33783143758773804,
0.5807302594184875,
0.14236995577812195,
0.19043231010437012,
-0.4185071587562561,
-0.3500880002975464,
-0.5815206170082092,
-0.7285326719284058,
-0.0809723362326622,
-0.3841404318809509,
0.5792546272277832,
0.3206211030483246,
0.6505278944969177,
0.03432435914874077,
0.4594549536705017,
0.27941951155662537,
0.20615245401859283,
0.35986942052841187,
-0.1977829784154892,
0.4676741361618042,
0.08998975157737732,
0.18903206288814545,
-0.37991732358932495,
-0.4669709801673889,
0.7211264371871948,
0.9513504505157471,
-0.36742010712623596,
0.10543328523635864,
0.2242632657289505,
0.6234008073806763,
-0.949500322341919,
-0.053224753588438034,
-0.6119722127914429,
0.20502983033657074,
-0.29539182782173157,
-0.22244171798229218,
-0.76555335521698,
0.09611255675554276,
-0.20200595259666443,
-0.17399585247039795,
0.07178138941526413,
-0.07572345435619354,
0.26432281732559204,
0.4023550748825073,
-0.5660762190818787,
-0.27624452114105225,
-0.755659818649292,
0.7685705423355103,
-0.5325122475624084,
1.1319700479507446,
0.15674658119678497,
0.3451160788536072,
-0.24396660923957825,
-0.7041655778884888,
-0.538682222366333,
-0.5733451247215271,
-0.10335247218608856,
-0.14231544733047485,
-0.38710474967956543,
0.07815759629011154,
0.178054079413414,
0.18913307785987854,
-1.0050987005233765,
0.06023067235946655,
-0.050185542553663254,
-0.5464291572570801,
0.22295476496219635,
0.30012640357017517,
0.17306973040103912,
-0.39399608969688416,
-0.2947996258735657,
-0.10882017016410828,
-0.2411440908908844,
-0.35115623474121094,
0.25128763914108276,
0.17802022397518158,
0.18803006410598755,
0.5346052050590515,
-0.34493106603622437,
0.511851966381073,
-0.42724156379699707,
-0.05651867017149925,
0.5272406339645386,
-0.20460233092308044,
-0.1859365701675415,
-0.07330112904310226,
0.8195969462394714,
0.4550004303455353,
0.135511115193367,
-0.4866502583026886,
-0.2106999009847641,
0.22033068537712097,
0.4890311360359192,
-0.7312250137329102,
-0.4244731068611145,
0.3184843957424164,
-0.6308485269546509,
-0.1626552939414978,
0.007176182232797146,
-1.1234064102172852,
-0.49579477310180664,
-0.2070493996143341,
0.2922619581222534,
-0.30349647998809814,
-0.6209211349487305,
0.13421979546546936,
-0.02867846004664898,
0.05874810740351677,
0.0278374794870615,
-0.8921924829483032,
0.1022232249379158,
0.4898492693901062,
0.730888307094574,
-0.4396176040172577,
-0.5675512552261353,
-0.46271970868110657,
0.09400922060012817,
-0.27696284651756287,
1.0812681913375854,
-0.6115682125091553,
-0.2679614722728729,
0.21967695653438568,
0.16258303821086884,
-0.026966271921992302,
-0.6225357055664062,
0.8062983155250549,
-0.09627771377563477,
-0.13452456891536713,
-0.2482028603553772,
-0.2112380415201187,
-0.3610793650150299,
0.21563158929347992,
-0.7209011316299438,
0.9841087460517883,
0.07571940869092941,
-0.6147168278694153,
0.5207780003547668,
-0.7645214200019836,
-0.4169524908065796,
0.0332215279340744,
-0.21885165572166443,
-0.4794038236141205,
0.4164687395095825,
0.20328176021575928,
0.5724804401397705,
0.0017342811916023493,
0.4874410033226013,
-0.7202042937278748,
-0.32809823751449585,
0.3666606545448303,
-0.7308859825134277,
0.628908097743988,
0.1653929352760315,
-0.42886996269226074,
0.502540647983551,
-0.7174476981163025,
0.10475801676511765,
0.004197686444967985,
-0.033723458647727966,
-0.2790258228778839,
-0.07822588831186295,
0.6750510931015015,
0.08665183186531067,
-0.07152710855007172,
-0.2924584746360779,
0.14834019541740417,
0.19630073010921478,
0.030201902613043785,
0.7615354657173157,
-0.15004077553749084,
0.07507381588220596,
0.06950541585683823,
0.3301974833011627,
-0.014271298423409462,
0.41027185320854187,
-0.11448907107114792,
-0.19246040284633636,
-0.6883128881454468,
-0.453461229801178,
0.18057823181152344,
0.22650128602981567,
-0.5951753854751587,
0.6512466073036194,
-0.12776538729667664,
-0.31159353256225586,
-0.5176904797554016,
0.16062748432159424,
0.4053346812725067,
0.12753136456012726,
0.5263456702232361,
-0.17841753363609314,
-0.7064886093139648,
-1.0626981258392334,
-0.162075012922287,
0.16172127425670624,
-0.0984167605638504,
0.12098778784275055,
0.7333300113677979,
-0.9183238744735718,
0.4689291715621948,
-0.3638540804386139,
-0.6668460369110107,
-0.2675054371356964,
0.384952574968338,
-0.2076631635427475,
0.4372217655181885,
0.4331170320510864,
-0.8157477378845215,
-0.19633664190769196,
-0.013591395691037178,
-1.1133396625518799,
-0.24069459736347198,
-0.2123684138059616,
-0.0150469820946455,
0.4374704658985138,
0.6573849320411682,
-0.648488461971283,
0.37969309091567993,
0.6635606288909912,
-0.44745343923568726,
0.9617308378219604,
-0.1524336189031601,
0.39177846908569336,
-0.7295279502868652,
0.2846669852733612,
-0.5098339915275574,
-0.077287457883358,
-0.6141444444656372,
0.06993642449378967,
0.13221095502376556,
0.11941563338041306,
-0.2351396530866623,
0.2810070812702179,
-0.5710344314575195,
-0.38006681203842163,
-0.20910093188285828,
0.0621497705578804,
-0.14935268461704254,
0.5402511954307556,
-0.0442541129887104,
0.4129754602909088,
0.5595958828926086,
-0.4283425509929657,
0.44366776943206787,
0.09526222199201584,
-0.4102288484573364,
0.4350910484790802,
-0.3548993170261383,
0.16092771291732788,
0.0924815759062767,
0.13586731255054474,
-1.0179789066314697,
-0.360657662153244,
0.3043592870235443,
-0.32503822445869446,
0.1982847899198532,
0.19279703497886658,
-0.8786267638206482,
-0.32754793763160706,
-0.44217848777770996,
0.5110135674476624,
0.23487772047519684,
-0.5790775418281555,
0.9000035524368286,
0.28430992364883423,
0.28805869817733765,
-0.5534672141075134,
-0.431959331035614,
0.2673279643058777,
-0.08266197144985199,
-0.5632908344268799,
0.060980089008808136,
-0.360189825296402,
-0.15933749079704285,
-0.13634590804576874,
-0.18762601912021637,
0.015351500362157822,
0.178450345993042,
0.38579171895980835,
0.027577972039580345,
-0.2366635799407959,
0.1256319284439087,
0.13881906867027283,
-0.2407321333885193,
0.08106177300214767,
0.08267907053232193,
0.9254276156425476,
-0.07563954591751099,
-0.7769970893859863,
-0.5610147714614868,
0.4068329632282257,
0.9723737835884094,
-0.1425718367099762,
0.5890356302261353,
1.1044416427612305,
-0.6243215799331665,
-0.12022574245929718,
-0.9083102941513062,
-0.4605322778224945,
-0.39674556255340576,
0.5528314709663391,
-0.5146377682685852,
-0.5993314981460571,
0.5494913458824158,
-0.011759730987250805,
-0.1581166386604309,
0.3575589060783386,
0.6211726069450378,
0.07095629721879959,
1.2933270931243896,
0.565050482749939,
0.006232034880667925,
0.10939659923315048,
0.04868712276220322,
0.13851375877857208,
-1.0184946060180664,
-0.5054762363433838,
-0.40936633944511414,
0.0021225938107818365,
-0.49796196818351746,
-0.2308073192834854,
0.34918633103370667,
-0.14638479053974152,
0.2518388032913208,
0.04260283708572388,
-0.520022988319397,
0.5253515839576721,
0.2876702845096588,
-0.022241147235035896,
0.5016512274742126,
0.08573248982429504,
-0.2714209258556366,
-0.3052779734134674,
-0.3258766829967499,
-0.5186330676078796,
1.2030421495437622,
0.1637878715991974,
0.6561835408210754,
0.11739015579223633,
0.5599949955940247,
0.6621097922325134,
0.3275241553783417,
-0.5025712251663208,
0.5894119143486023,
-0.11660174280405045,
-0.6315082311630249,
-0.4485681354999542,
-0.3263051211833954,
-0.8569991588592529,
0.8947558999061584,
-0.3275757431983948,
-0.982700526714325,
0.06421255320310593,
-0.004135237541049719,
-0.23183323442935944,
0.35424575209617615,
-0.5363491177558899,
1.322764277458191,
-0.2536260783672333,
-0.2782841920852661,
-0.39262181520462036,
-0.4294827878475189,
0.6258825659751892,
-0.060801152139902115,
0.23265281319618225,
-0.1418989598751068,
0.24957512319087982,
0.7125064730644226,
0.16286413371562958,
0.729179322719574,
-0.11925115436315536,
-0.20589101314544678,
-0.1708814948797226,
0.29601651430130005,
0.11343109607696533,
0.03784990683197975,
0.1526513248682022,
0.4295734465122223,
-0.04389013350009918,
-0.23580943048000336,
-0.5644944906234741,
0.842542290687561,
-0.2086179107427597,
-0.25599926710128784,
-0.49752941727638245,
-0.7614892721176147,
-0.15060152113437653,
0.3073151409626007,
0.17030467092990875,
0.5392748117446899,
-0.5469680428504944,
0.5815365314483643,
0.5099985599517822,
-0.05607031658291817,
0.3748718202114105,
0.4027935266494751,
-0.7360972166061401,
-0.501799464225769,
0.8840205669403076,
-0.1752186268568039,
0.08293624222278595,
0.18429884314537048,
0.04237682372331619,
-0.5717317461967468,
-0.58867347240448,
-0.5215821266174316,
0.2133653610944748,
-0.8809207677841187,
-0.06163680925965309,
-0.9771619439125061,
0.10927700251340866,
-0.6174351572990417,
0.050119392573833466,
-0.4419408440589905,
0.0747213289141655,
-0.10176312923431396,
0.08821028470993042,
-0.16718165576457977,
0.6950985789299011,
-0.28962135314941406,
0.008284509181976318,
-0.7573090195655823,
0.7029476761817932,
0.24970586597919464,
0.2575352191925049,
0.014068600721657276,
-0.29538050293922424,
0.0473143570125103,
0.08626542240381241,
-0.33963093161582947,
-0.7355141639709473,
0.22751034796237946,
-0.022430753335356712,
0.7832140326499939,
0.9152056574821472,
0.15959016978740692,
0.6722228527069092,
-0.4138633608818054,
0.5291849970817566,
0.21850784122943878,
-0.9343830347061157,
0.2386280596256256,
-0.052698951214551926,
0.19818557798862457,
0.6504526138305664,
0.2856948673725128,
-0.5729881525039673,
-0.4220737814903259,
-0.3824399709701538,
-0.5805991888046265,
0.28848305344581604,
0.3272285759449005,
0.012816481292247772,
0.16578538715839386,
-0.16097158193588257,
0.3403051197528839,
0.3421670198440552,
-1.0810741186141968,
-0.11470906436443329,
-0.017139658331871033,
-0.010707248002290726,
-0.2587691843509674,
-0.49767187237739563,
0.03141668066382408,
-0.4141729176044464,
0.3656322658061981,
-0.1020287424325943,
0.2515309154987335,
-0.043840352445840836,
-0.6520423889160156,
-0.1472114622592926,
0.209992453455925,
0.8940843343734741,
0.7998375296592712,
-0.4581390619277954,
0.3711080253124237,
0.1548975706100464,
-0.46318939328193665,
-0.05541616305708885,
-0.12112390249967575,
0.10733002424240112,
0.4173624515533447,
0.7182218432426453,
0.5762293338775635,
0.641473650932312,
-0.9077064394950867,
0.5778352618217468,
-0.027933187782764435,
-0.22318245470523834,
-0.4060001075267792,
-0.17563886940479279,
-0.19117842614650726,
0.3942295014858246,
0.4246154725551605,
0.05654783546924591,
0.59479159116745,
-0.668667733669281,
0.6208128333091736,
0.7347060441970825,
-0.43255719542503357,
-0.4021447002887726,
0.4715777635574341,
-0.057556889951229095,
-0.2876718044281006,
0.7836730480194092,
-0.38251858949661255,
-0.7773573994636536,
0.2588142454624176,
0.5272700190544128,
1.254672884941101,
-0.5500968098640442,
0.2473166137933731,
0.10283024609088898,
0.6493595242500305,
0.12902776896953583,
0.29511022567749023,
-0.2798491418361664,
-0.6017876267433167,
-0.08561451733112335,
-0.7919449210166931,
-0.22462518513202667,
0.3498057425022125,
-0.8217485547065735,
0.1327434480190277,
-0.0031597730703651905,
-0.030263131484389305,
0.05937206372618675,
-0.4463272988796234,
-0.3892531096935272,
-0.1775134950876236,
0.258615106344223,
0.3290528953075409,
-0.9874698519706726,
0.610706627368927,
0.32426151633262634,
-0.228302463889122,
0.09861456602811813,
0.2556043565273285,
0.04647447168827057,
-0.5345884561538696,
0.4047498404979706,
0.6736665964126587,
-0.35006484389305115,
-0.18738912045955658,
-0.28216809034347534,
-0.37813064455986023,
0.8827040791511536,
0.1759909987449646,
-0.349459707736969,
0.11663023382425308,
0.14222770929336548,
0.5464738607406616,
-0.3644731938838959,
0.2203168123960495,
0.7166385054588318,
0.8731037974357605,
0.057148970663547516,
-0.7526701092720032,
0.1663103699684143,
-0.09627830237150192,
-0.2256104201078415,
0.34378957748413086,
-0.2060946226119995,
0.6957949995994568,
-0.43091240525245667,
-0.34620192646980286,
0.0321233905851841,
0.6029697060585022,
0.18612803518772125,
0.5611099600791931,
0.7222448587417603,
0.6203698515892029,
0.6807900667190552,
0.003153895726427436,
0.6554390788078308,
-0.009615962393581867,
0.3137221336364746,
1.0164669752120972,
-0.5189404487609863,
0.812406063079834,
0.6062220931053162,
-0.01678522862493992,
0.5306254625320435,
0.4965166449546814,
-0.24650120735168457,
0.5763473510742188,
0.021811848506331444,
-0.19010064005851746,
-0.5557427406311035,
-0.19749130308628082,
-0.5362150073051453,
0.6104637384414673,
0.29754725098609924,
-0.03771824389696121,
-0.3514157831668854,
0.5729967951774597,
-0.1895034909248352,
-0.174621120095253,
-0.0028015864081680775,
0.7870857119560242,
-0.16926105320453644,
-0.4946953058242798,
0.6716235876083374,
-0.332689493894577,
0.6208728551864624,
-0.45015764236450195,
-0.2613169550895691,
-0.13578657805919647,
0.37121081352233887,
-0.19113728404045105,
-0.3273089528083801,
0.2774359881877899,
-0.23275987803936005,
-0.055647097527980804,
0.02584381401538849,
0.5839677453041077,
-0.4942041337490082,
-0.4780697524547577,
0.8481619954109192,
0.4154484272003174,
0.25737112760543823,
-0.693980872631073,
-0.5874783396720886,
0.49291470646858215,
0.06784646213054657,
-0.10203119367361069,
0.2398231476545334,
0.4905969500541687,
-0.0019857033621519804,
0.8454366326332092,
0.9104917049407959,
-0.3266746699810028,
0.018161749467253685,
0.5256337523460388,
0.8304639458656311,
-0.7112762928009033,
-0.2173820436000824,
-1.0696334838867188,
0.6230970025062561,
-0.10513792932033539,
-0.26976481080055237,
0.8921377062797546,
0.7119028568267822,
0.7008542418479919,
-0.3900890052318573,
0.5154726505279541,
0.17122779786586761,
0.132230743765831,
-0.6402287483215332,
0.9132835268974304,
-0.8887129426002502,
-0.03904680162668228,
-0.5824249982833862,
-1.2248485088348389,
-0.5504611134529114,
0.579093337059021,
0.23362897336483002,
0.02263779565691948,
1.1011784076690674,
0.8255389928817749,
-0.19161789119243622,
-0.06892679631710052,
0.760100781917572,
0.218295156955719,
0.10564878582954407,
0.28263846039772034,
1.1324447393417358,
-0.337129682302475,
0.5979084372520447,
-0.4034556448459625,
-0.17805685102939606,
-0.6510332822799683,
-0.7537188529968262,
-1.233837366104126,
-0.9537879228591919,
-0.20105628669261932,
-0.22148635983467102,
-0.13009130954742432,
0.7724642157554626,
0.6076352596282959,
-0.9947630167007446,
-0.34564727544784546,
0.28089073300361633,
0.19005116820335388,
-0.2842247784137726,
-0.236930251121521,
0.3545023500919342,
-0.4062440097332001,
-0.4512141942977905,
0.3913682699203491,
0.4880951941013336,
0.016482967883348465,
-0.6609373092651367,
-0.13197745382785797,
-0.20598861575126648,
-0.2798877954483032,
0.9105212092399597,
-0.1108030378818512,
-1.0804482698440552,
-0.14990036189556122,
0.13310572504997253,
0.08939439058303833,
-0.10779403895139694,
1.0220316648483276,
-0.32199645042419434,
0.47885218262672424,
0.29756033420562744,
0.40180230140686035,
0.27621182799339294,
-0.3095359206199646,
0.09422969818115234,
-0.514617383480072,
0.29418861865997314,
0.2394333928823471,
0.40856611728668213,
0.3555808961391449,
-0.09813717007637024,
0.4016338586807251,
0.26092085242271423,
-0.46892231702804565,
-1.5365983247756958,
0.06953943520784378,
-1.0121062994003296,
-0.46288400888442993,
1.004135251045227,
0.38194990158081055,
-0.03304049372673035,
-0.39385101199150085,
-0.25929245352745056,
0.02081672102212906,
-0.3226816654205322,
0.951927125453949,
0.7697926163673401,
-0.14345358312129974,
-0.15103694796562195,
-0.663123607635498,
0.41485998034477234,
0.4074925184249878,
-0.8605006337165833,
0.5249465107917786,
0.717648446559906,
-0.13226304948329926,
0.43083691596984863,
0.4517921507358551,
0.10633614659309387,
0.36191824078559875,
0.014439591206610203,
0.4674096703529358,
0.03267481550574303,
-0.9513794183731079,
-0.44966673851013184,
0.26674526929855347,
-0.20080599188804626,
-0.25164949893951416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05130v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05130v2 | LB-KBQA: Large-language-model and BERT based Knowledge-Based Question and Answering System | 2024-02-05T16:47:17 | 2024-02-09T02:45:51 | Yan Zhao, Zhongyun Li, Yushan Pan, Jiaxing Wang, Yihong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), because of its emergent abilities,
has empowered various fields, one typical of which is large language models
(LLMs). One of the typical application fields of Generative AI is large
language models (LLMs), and the natural language understanding capability of
LLM is dramatically improved when compared with conventional AI-based methods.
The natural language understanding capability has always been a barrier to the
intent recognition performance of the Knowledge-Based-Question-and-Answer
(KBQA) system, which arises from linguistic diversity and the newly appeared
intent. Conventional AI-based methods for intent recognition can be divided
into semantic parsing-based and model-based approaches. However, both of the
methods suffer from limited resources in intent recognition. To address this
issue, we propose a novel KBQA system based on a Large Language Model(LLM) and
BERT (LB-KBQA). With the help of generative AI, our proposed method could
detect newly appeared intent and acquire new knowledge. In experiments on
financial domain question answering, our model has demonstrated superior
effectiveness. | [
-0.18630962073802948,
-1.190054178237915,
0.7323600649833679,
0.2834451496601105,
-0.2984534502029419,
0.10097204148769379,
-0.12852536141872406,
-0.4795570969581604,
0.056544847786426544,
0.5097771883010864,
-0.4217129051685333,
-0.32524967193603516,
-0.6339190006256104,
0.00794295221567154,
-0.16277629137039185,
0.6877774596214294,
0.1433456838130951,
0.2877044975757599,
-0.28792983293533325,
0.06020888313651085,
-0.4741417169570923,
-0.30173957347869873,
-0.8875910043716431,
-0.2791736125946045,
0.20137876272201538,
0.17795272171497345,
0.6269324421882629,
-0.0030494118109345436,
0.38969695568084717,
0.3781633973121643,
-0.213131844997406,
0.12989257276058197,
-0.1581256240606308,
0.08882379531860352,
0.04178750142455101,
-0.5000529885292053,
-0.3162206709384918,
-0.36462870240211487,
0.6806962490081787,
0.5638297200202942,
-0.0798601508140564,
-0.05715133249759674,
-0.2841133773326874,
0.630513072013855,
-0.518256425857544,
0.4414452612400055,
-0.7612491846084595,
-0.26035380363464355,
0.3551475703716278,
-0.03505174443125725,
-0.6919882297515869,
-0.5022962093353271,
0.45463433861732483,
-0.6400837898254395,
-0.10545755177736282,
-0.1696927696466446,
0.7542758584022522,
0.04728470742702484,
-0.43310806155204773,
-0.5778363347053528,
-0.5716407299041748,
0.7507780194282532,
-0.9147027134895325,
0.5790979862213135,
0.24577677249908447,
0.5600754618644714,
-0.12594854831695557,
-0.5034914016723633,
-0.7888672947883606,
-0.4089776277542114,
0.0917363166809082,
-0.019710510969161987,
-0.008065943606197834,
-0.002724716439843178,
-0.1366921067237854,
0.07008721679449081,
-0.4855966866016388,
0.05878221243619919,
-0.35494643449783325,
-0.2828037738800049,
0.5166252255439758,
0.02603255771100521,
0.10350582003593445,
-0.4542869031429291,
-0.47514164447784424,
0.12150278687477112,
-0.5693008303642273,
0.357776403427124,
-0.07511677592992783,
0.3265770673751831,
0.04786231368780136,
0.513587236404419,
-0.34236660599708557,
0.7091230750083923,
0.13162368535995483,
-0.3086363673210144,
-0.028013719245791435,
0.06932254135608673,
-0.5990161895751953,
0.14084529876708984,
0.5285085439682007,
-0.057856276631355286,
0.1406482756137848,
-0.30188271403312683,
-0.04887929931282997,
-0.39477458596229553,
0.14031793177127838,
-0.5846003293991089,
-0.006891319993883371,
0.29956501722335815,
-0.5668507218360901,
-0.21155843138694763,
-0.2978785037994385,
-0.3791358768939972,
-0.3541727662086487,
-0.2926827669143677,
0.8136186003684998,
-0.799161434173584,
-0.13556599617004395,
0.20250821113586426,
-0.04307153820991516,
0.9365544319152832,
0.6594304442405701,
-0.7137024402618408,
-0.0677841380238533,
0.8099460601806641,
0.32078519463539124,
0.23319421708583832,
0.09092656522989273,
-0.42266321182250977,
0.3067677319049835,
-0.22935520112514496,
0.6290731430053711,
-0.44201335310935974,
-0.15532372891902924,
-0.03939996659755707,
-0.34201738238334656,
0.028886785730719566,
-0.36737415194511414,
0.3475397229194641,
-1.4446417093276978,
0.2465604990720749,
-0.3355899453163147,
-0.904423177242279,
-0.5883374810218811,
0.5305918455123901,
-0.6011994481086731,
0.584684431552887,
0.08958116918802261,
-0.45990076661109924,
0.3998890519142151,
-0.9107359051704407,
-0.3857888877391815,
0.5865068435668945,
-0.18050040304660797,
-0.07723327726125717,
-0.08994750678539276,
0.3809531033039093,
0.4866718053817749,
-0.3826327621936798,
0.5549119114875793,
-0.05127371847629547,
-0.19714170694351196,
0.6031634211540222,
-0.7963609099388123,
0.8689014911651611,
0.10608069598674774,
-0.25020694732666016,
-0.05613983795046806,
-0.6473833322525024,
0.22324147820472717,
0.11347750574350357,
-0.6995665431022644,
-0.352005273103714,
-0.004612709861248732,
-0.21375682950019836,
0.06449786573648453,
0.7812477350234985,
-0.6262977719306946,
0.1817023605108261,
-0.40869665145874023,
0.2987300157546997,
0.8518037796020508,
-0.11507615447044373,
0.46971970796585083,
-0.11463112384080887,
0.47929805517196655,
0.07267734408378601,
0.1096859946846962,
0.11677885055541992,
-0.6252378821372986,
-0.7239318490028381,
-0.26617178320884705,
0.48510968685150146,
0.6875327825546265,
-0.8758744597434998,
0.6009635329246521,
-0.20164576172828674,
-0.31472352147102356,
-0.4631783366203308,
0.0026730233803391457,
0.20510680973529816,
0.37047040462493896,
0.23905499279499054,
0.03366367891430855,
-0.23894177377223969,
-0.9558250904083252,
0.02266807295382023,
-0.48744213581085205,
-0.06661821156740189,
0.7276647686958313,
0.16478696465492249,
-0.1379278153181076,
1.1060670614242554,
-0.6972504258155823,
-0.04807116836309433,
-0.5860834717750549,
0.26666057109832764,
0.342487633228302,
0.06420549750328064,
0.4787573218345642,
-1.0488824844360352,
-0.5029966235160828,
-0.07496106624603271,
-0.7322908639907837,
0.15428271889686584,
-0.136911541223526,
-0.3556353449821472,
0.38938191533088684,
0.47778570652008057,
-0.763735294342041,
0.312531054019928,
0.3266703188419342,
-0.3725559115409851,
0.6093270182609558,
-0.17012715339660645,
0.12651364505290985,
-1.1401841640472412,
0.0960206463932991,
-0.3520994186401367,
-0.11137688159942627,
-0.6697028279304504,
-0.1201430931687355,
0.2992483079433441,
0.10615193843841553,
-0.3800823390483856,
0.6238871812820435,
-0.18675029277801514,
-0.021071897819638252,
-0.2934391498565674,
0.030007826164364815,
0.0578768327832222,
0.651420533657074,
0.22827266156673431,
0.6933929920196533,
0.4965249300003052,
-0.8387646079063416,
0.42324432730674744,
0.6383815407752991,
-0.6195059418678284,
0.402935653924942,
-0.5473411083221436,
0.013441036455333233,
-0.4287053048610687,
0.17142745852470398,
-1.103234887123108,
-0.2210998237133026,
0.12192244827747345,
-0.7214457392692566,
0.23771245777606964,
0.00008753346628509462,
-0.2890196442604065,
-0.37741219997406006,
0.029282834380865097,
0.5610156655311584,
0.6303348541259766,
-0.4684012532234192,
1.0101851224899292,
0.026193581521511078,
-0.7554171681404114,
-0.7511166334152222,
-0.3669339120388031,
-0.013375519774854183,
0.1263495236635208,
-0.7664391398429871,
0.09066541492938995,
-0.07959822565317154,
-0.012381626293063164,
-0.05806984007358551,
0.12402565777301788,
-0.441940575838089,
0.015895532444119453,
-0.1578121781349182,
0.7001451849937439,
-0.46728092432022095,
0.4101933538913727,
0.2676442563533783,
0.22920726239681244,
0.3169737458229065,
-0.24532315135002136,
0.7094226479530334,
0.03284416347742081,
-0.1932400017976761,
-0.3671647310256958,
0.4105963110923767,
0.8409342169761658,
-0.38944077491760254,
1.0429871082305908,
0.3369230628013611,
-0.11642201989889145,
-0.12374571710824966,
-0.8100454211235046,
-0.015892619267106056,
-0.5441052317619324,
0.5113639831542969,
-0.26375070214271545,
-1.2792127132415771,
0.3923880457878113,
0.017326273024082184,
0.05305305868387222,
0.3908901810646057,
0.7532011270523071,
-0.14894072711467743,
0.7120193243026733,
0.5635839104652405,
-0.35840243101119995,
0.26978254318237305,
0.006679314188659191,
0.5548684000968933,
-0.7423030138015747,
-0.3600943982601166,
-0.3339596390724182,
-0.2549401521682739,
-0.1765073984861374,
-0.3411664366722107,
0.5457099080085754,
0.1674453318119049,
-0.2979159951210022,
0.16253428161144257,
-0.2637217342853546,
0.1693686842918396,
0.6722323298454285,
0.13610799610614777,
0.3233978748321533,
-0.20732173323631287,
-0.2366894632577896,
0.29076358675956726,
-0.5298516750335693,
-0.41528940200805664,
1.2890264987945557,
0.44967126846313477,
0.7975924611091614,
0.38248786330223083,
0.44878628849983215,
0.27885785698890686,
0.3812556564807892,
-0.9094350337982178,
0.737356424331665,
-0.04095111042261124,
-0.8185766339302063,
-0.8065774440765381,
-0.661584198474884,
-0.6967878341674805,
0.04799528419971466,
-0.026664892211556435,
-0.6699570417404175,
0.19382016360759735,
0.008686058223247528,
-0.5463410019874573,
0.3405511975288391,
-0.8042389154434204,
0.7013983130455017,
-0.4415675699710846,
0.08002964407205582,
-0.05036480352282524,
-0.6090390682220459,
0.41244950890541077,
-0.14867724478244781,
0.08872631937265396,
-0.06499969214200974,
0.19287997484207153,
0.7050912976264954,
-0.1820562481880188,
0.6337893009185791,
-0.4916555881500244,
-0.5675346255302429,
0.450917512178421,
-0.13944348692893982,
0.6343002915382385,
0.1912899911403656,
-0.042862001806497574,
-0.2462691217660904,
-0.28804659843444824,
-0.3138854205608368,
-0.6193176507949829,
0.45193204283714294,
-0.709597110748291,
-0.587411105632782,
-0.06142904609441757,
-0.9255325198173523,
-0.4843284785747528,
0.20564809441566467,
-0.07661717385053635,
0.25890791416168213,
-0.3575075566768646,
0.3303946256637573,
0.7734759449958801,
-0.6324624419212341,
0.2797972559928894,
0.9166598916053772,
-0.2347448617219925,
-0.42673563957214355,
0.7021871209144592,
-0.31417402625083923,
0.35674652457237244,
0.8609956502914429,
0.052790962159633636,
-0.6875038743019104,
-0.48111751675605774,
-0.3290348947048187,
0.202969491481781,
-0.5979242324829102,
-0.44370970129966736,
-0.7503791451454163,
-0.5151805877685547,
-0.7764648795127869,
-0.2294190376996994,
0.105080746114254,
-0.3003041446208954,
0.009065638296306133,
0.1445314884185791,
0.550674557685852,
0.4817103445529938,
0.19260889291763306,
0.18687577545642853,
-0.9574585556983948,
0.5783194899559021,
0.9184009432792664,
0.38365644216537476,
0.14678853750228882,
-0.47671517729759216,
-0.07056593149900436,
0.18554288148880005,
-0.17029941082000732,
-0.7288011908531189,
0.25540244579315186,
0.06431986391544342,
0.5264567136764526,
0.5196986198425293,
0.09945522248744965,
0.0811588317155838,
-0.1891556978225708,
0.48267388343811035,
0.06772199273109436,
-0.9041560888290405,
0.3457324504852295,
-0.32118889689445496,
0.5002673864364624,
0.578797459602356,
0.3702029585838318,
-0.5362180471420288,
-0.4042266309261322,
-0.373060405254364,
-0.7251356840133667,
0.8043879270553589,
0.20776039361953735,
0.05627797544002533,
0.0649162083864212,
0.3907237946987152,
0.09458530694246292,
0.520158052444458,
-0.9533538818359375,
-0.08604422211647034,
0.025758344680070877,
-0.35899627208709717,
0.15201205015182495,
-0.37458905577659607,
0.3005475401878357,
-0.31787779927253723,
0.8771937489509583,
-0.08118101954460144,
0.5830762982368469,
0.09022584557533264,
-0.12163466215133667,
0.06257014721632004,
0.7240892648696899,
0.24894434213638306,
0.4697153866291046,
-0.28994590044021606,
-0.28357622027397156,
0.22828741371631622,
-0.5699107050895691,
0.19124682247638702,
0.3682776689529419,
-0.5486697554588318,
-0.0722106546163559,
0.15693983435630798,
0.6275086998939514,
0.03191642463207245,
-1.045409917831421,
0.6006736159324646,
0.0573459155857563,
-0.43349117040634155,
-0.5456092953681946,
0.08307202905416489,
0.4870307743549347,
0.49457022547721863,
0.5006533861160278,
-0.22793611884117126,
0.12087510526180267,
-0.5332381725311279,
0.008538657799363136,
0.7508558630943298,
-0.1800324022769928,
0.21277353167533875,
0.3347519338130951,
0.2309354841709137,
-0.12295446544885635,
0.8137906193733215,
-0.44247129559516907,
-0.7992319464683533,
0.9148346781730652,
0.45060068368911743,
0.6700409650802612,
-0.3378986716270447,
0.5393650531768799,
0.17408348619937897,
0.11212921887636185,
0.35881033539772034,
0.7805081605911255,
-0.21103881299495697,
-1.0576809644699097,
-0.6175452470779419,
-0.9451223015785217,
-0.30222490429878235,
0.4942238926887512,
-0.5569106936454773,
-0.04885568469762802,
-0.345696359872818,
0.23639418184757233,
0.2704271674156189,
-0.16348326206207275,
-0.5168319940567017,
0.3357045352458954,
0.04974415525794029,
1.0522968769073486,
-0.4645918607711792,
0.8091345429420471,
0.8154916167259216,
-0.1041732057929039,
-0.977462112903595,
0.005499331746250391,
-0.48669517040252686,
-0.9816745519638062,
0.9992401003837585,
0.11093837022781372,
0.11049788445234299,
0.03823385387659073,
-0.5525228977203369,
-0.8386467695236206,
1.1667978763580322,
0.09146681427955627,
-0.41492199897766113,
-0.26025137305259705,
0.3234712779521942,
0.2971169054508209,
-0.15701758861541748,
-0.16591514647006989,
0.4997189939022064,
0.6952763199806213,
0.38477134704589844,
-0.6946279406547546,
-0.2482212632894516,
-0.14465636014938354,
-0.25199076533317566,
0.597285270690918,
-0.45216265320777893,
0.7085120677947998,
-0.19099056720733643,
0.0554584339261055,
0.332031786441803,
0.7288785576820374,
0.41767773032188416,
0.21186208724975586,
0.6140388250350952,
0.5504307150840759,
0.5299178957939148,
-0.03544851019978523,
0.6105794310569763,
-0.06906238943338394,
0.35442599654197693,
0.8394836187362671,
-0.4271792471408844,
1.0135071277618408,
0.16978362202644348,
-0.39391523599624634,
0.6211097836494446,
0.05494430661201477,
0.004443580284714699,
0.5839102864265442,
0.21283990144729614,
-0.7271999716758728,
-0.4922565817832947,
0.13194569945335388,
-0.17260748147964478,
0.6139390468597412,
0.5367072820663452,
-0.368385910987854,
-0.17687243223190308,
0.1458757519721985,
-0.23734427988529205,
-0.2566644847393036,
-0.3697774112224579,
0.9841700792312622,
-0.07661868631839752,
-0.7505573630332947,
0.31304556131362915,
0.15943492949008942,
0.6925892233848572,
-0.9351086020469666,
0.0424150712788105,
0.12386426329612732,
-0.03138991445302963,
0.3150961399078369,
-0.6365477442741394,
-0.12207794934511185,
0.06421757489442825,
-0.40591591596603394,
0.14408200979232788,
0.8470603823661804,
-0.5142220258712769,
-0.696033239364624,
0.1512790471315384,
0.5664625763893127,
-0.07528387010097504,
-0.1693769246339798,
-0.5279857516288757,
-0.42465800046920776,
-0.016515526920557022,
0.019931605085730553,
0.07075227797031403,
0.6899673938751221,
0.06862816214561462,
0.7441600561141968,
0.5564407110214233,
-0.2776191830635071,
0.05390758439898491,
0.025604702532291412,
0.7704269289970398,
-0.7201012969017029,
-0.7787689566612244,
-0.4649490714073181,
0.13176549971103668,
0.015889983624219894,
0.008319377899169922,
0.4015152156352997,
0.525745153427124,
0.3416839838027954,
-0.18521231412887573,
0.9584828019142151,
-0.34652841091156006,
0.6899437308311462,
-0.6626683473587036,
0.8197482228279114,
-0.538012683391571,
0.13538482785224915,
-0.2225215882062912,
-0.6100240349769592,
0.11570780724287033,
0.5376673936843872,
-0.4905538558959961,
0.3703906238079071,
0.49024075269699097,
0.5490992665290833,
0.11565539240837097,
0.23480172455310822,
0.39712515473365784,
0.48152977228164673,
0.1696089804172516,
0.9241011738777161,
0.8976325988769531,
-0.16996131837368011,
0.6817218661308289,
0.13077692687511444,
-0.23590326309204102,
-0.45224428176879883,
-0.5978994965553284,
-0.6958898305892944,
-0.5999940037727356,
0.015065598301589489,
-0.018609043210744858,
-0.056131020188331604,
0.7848654985427856,
0.36602792143821716,
-0.8762776851654053,
0.04268711060285568,
-0.2020406574010849,
-0.09961631894111633,
-0.09723256528377533,
-0.32883456349372864,
0.6274424195289612,
-0.4102800786495209,
-0.45745623111724854,
0.3265477418899536,
0.40745478868484497,
0.07791358232498169,
-0.34965386986732483,
-0.19193978607654572,
-0.5239371657371521,
0.42702847719192505,
0.9186521768569946,
0.2027716040611267,
-0.7566817998886108,
-0.22136190533638,
0.20403118431568146,
-0.06772013008594513,
-0.15176190435886383,
0.6060630083084106,
-0.8381702303886414,
0.2567400634288788,
0.48065242171287537,
1.0721744298934937,
0.12908782064914703,
0.02400924451649189,
0.5762125849723816,
-0.46020105481147766,
-0.13460715115070343,
0.4487101435661316,
0.26959228515625,
0.00847437884658575,
-0.6628075838088989,
-0.10344839841127396,
-0.2506066858768463,
-0.5710469484329224,
-0.16953334212303162,
0.3104482889175415,
-1.1742920875549316,
-0.6808115839958191,
0.9422057867050171,
-0.07064300775527954,
-0.11640646308660507,
-0.38536593317985535,
-0.4098113775253296,
0.17844654619693756,
-0.5356336236000061,
0.9558238983154297,
0.7966873049736023,
-0.10602039098739624,
-0.0634283572435379,
-0.4698227345943451,
0.3318743407726288,
0.6215189695358276,
-0.9884950518608093,
0.06766422837972641,
0.5886683464050293,
0.1505802422761917,
0.19150854647159576,
0.7607830762863159,
-0.06498030573129654,
0.7087502479553223,
-0.43130865693092346,
-0.013959388248622417,
0.012190954759716988,
-0.26201048493385315,
0.07299580425024033,
0.4124399423599243,
0.27837109565734863,
-0.12130945175886154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03181v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03181v4 | C-RAG: Certified Generation Risks for Retrieval-Augmented Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:46:16 | 2024-06-04T04:51:08 | Mintong Kang, Nezihe Merve Gürel, Ning Yu, Dawn Song, Bo Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs) across
diverse applications, they still suffer from trustworthiness issues, such as
hallucinations and misalignments. Retrieval-augmented language models (RAG)
have been proposed to enhance the credibility of generations by grounding
external knowledge, but the theoretical understandings of their generation
risks remains unexplored. In this paper, we answer: 1) whether RAG can indeed
lead to low generation risks, 2) how to provide provable guarantees on the
generation risks of RAG and vanilla LLMs, and 3) what sufficient conditions
enable RAG models to reduce generation risks. We propose C-RAG, the first
framework to certify generation risks for RAG models. Specifically, we provide
conformal risk analysis for RAG models and certify an upper confidence bound of
generation risks, which we refer to as conformal generation risk. We also
provide theoretical guarantees on conformal generation risks for general
bounded risk functions under test distribution shifts. We prove that RAG
achieves a lower conformal generation risk than that of a single LLM when the
quality of the retrieval model and transformer is non-trivial. Our intensive
empirical results demonstrate the soundness and tightness of our conformal
generation risk guarantees across four widely-used NLP datasets on four
state-of-the-art retrieval models. | [
-0.2880583703517914,
-0.46742767095565796,
0.4955991208553314,
-0.09028680622577667,
0.18523037433624268,
0.08871554583311081,
-0.0693698301911354,
-0.8381850123405457,
-0.10935714840888977,
0.6923830509185791,
-0.18719322979450226,
-0.14993637800216675,
-0.8329818248748779,
-0.2404521107673645,
-0.5111426115036011,
0.7871479392051697,
0.20976980030536652,
-0.3069007396697998,
-0.2549269199371338,
0.3645695149898529,
-0.13598281145095825,
-0.3731117844581604,
-0.5694440603256226,
-0.11061617732048035,
0.5390384197235107,
0.3503373861312866,
0.9199153184890747,
0.3080559968948364,
0.44088417291641235,
0.19374865293502808,
-0.5869617462158203,
-0.056488003581762314,
-0.6650575399398804,
0.36939823627471924,
-0.15054473280906677,
-0.6286289691925049,
-0.4346001148223877,
0.134965717792511,
0.613810122013092,
0.8628383278846741,
-0.3150002956390381,
0.3929316997528076,
0.19876044988632202,
0.916550874710083,
-0.861143946647644,
-0.1892372965812683,
-1.1360481977462769,
-0.24904417991638184,
-0.2731723487377167,
-0.05792113021016121,
-1.081538200378418,
-0.5721170902252197,
0.024998534470796585,
-0.3707910180091858,
0.4072929620742798,
0.24049633741378784,
0.9237143993377686,
0.23923304677009583,
-0.6047371029853821,
-0.155161052942276,
-1.0275336503982544,
0.8091210126876831,
-0.4057466983795166,
0.5443291664123535,
0.5491480231285095,
0.4453008472919464,
-0.3310152590274811,
-0.6455820202827454,
-0.467870831489563,
-0.5188431739807129,
-0.13782255351543427,
-0.028001658618450165,
0.041695304214954376,
0.2099982649087906,
0.2857244908809662,
0.573234498500824,
-0.39381158351898193,
0.06776641309261322,
-0.6226344704627991,
-0.2502685785293579,
0.482258677482605,
0.003527952590957284,
0.15207834541797638,
-0.1619577556848526,
-0.6165874004364014,
-0.27592262625694275,
-1.3108747005462646,
-0.03737311065196991,
0.7341212630271912,
0.1740020215511322,
-0.1381267011165619,
0.6269981861114502,
-0.023776892572641373,
0.472427099943161,
0.08262884616851807,
-0.14050666987895966,
0.001952716032974422,
-0.14838971197605133,
0.00864486861974001,
-0.04702254384756088,
0.33998462557792664,
0.17898736894130707,
0.3893500566482544,
-0.43098634481430054,
0.0005120295681990683,
-0.09833496809005737,
0.35892409086227417,
-0.553983211517334,
0.1388707160949707,
0.11713407933712006,
-0.4476795792579651,
-0.5605960488319397,
0.21462108194828033,
-0.8937011361122131,
-0.6953102946281433,
0.058910369873046875,
0.16313692927360535,
-0.23447754979133606,
-0.37985098361968994,
0.06363973021507263,
0.02342856675386429,
0.5382798314094543,
0.08625321835279465,
-0.7101384997367859,
0.17366421222686768,
0.7793799638748169,
0.38955503702163696,
-0.23849600553512573,
0.22899948060512543,
-0.23222702741622925,
0.3682461977005005,
-0.4733530580997467,
0.8828022480010986,
-0.3224652409553528,
-0.7561952471733093,
0.15555985271930695,
-0.15801219642162323,
-0.132703959941864,
-0.5780942440032959,
0.6402631402015686,
-0.5880081653594971,
-0.12837746739387512,
0.08902974426746368,
-0.5602446794509888,
-0.030770130455493927,
0.1369318962097168,
-0.5830164551734924,
0.6574466824531555,
0.20648853480815887,
-0.867350161075592,
0.27739521861076355,
0.3608684539794922,
-0.3023039698600769,
-0.009349877014756203,
0.013260354287922382,
-0.46310287714004517,
0.25125157833099365,
-0.36684125661849976,
0.127155601978302,
-0.5944021940231323,
0.125310480594635,
-0.4872039258480072,
0.022438036277890205,
0.3978468179702759,
-0.7389342784881592,
0.7929801940917969,
0.35335928201675415,
-0.10484185069799423,
-0.19407084584236145,
-0.6279613971710205,
0.2585800588130951,
-0.08709055185317993,
-0.3019500970840454,
-0.3948955535888672,
-0.060592327266931534,
-0.03023369051516056,
0.28909629583358765,
0.12486709654331207,
-0.4201997220516205,
-0.03849509358406067,
-0.5075849294662476,
-0.12472539395093918,
0.6162720322608948,
0.3260784149169922,
0.567436933517456,
-0.6426666975021362,
0.7637637853622437,
-0.06273993849754333,
0.36082085967063904,
-0.06600768119096756,
-0.6305734515190125,
-0.7956617474555969,
0.006688513793051243,
0.4796481728553772,
0.6517364978790283,
-0.781257688999176,
0.13958993554115295,
-0.19639764726161957,
-0.6438481211662292,
-0.42877399921417236,
-0.0898611769080162,
0.6403839588165283,
0.43023988604545593,
0.19255457818508148,
0.1488926112651825,
-0.4762096405029297,
-0.7131013870239258,
-0.41981828212738037,
-0.4860736131668091,
-0.00956543255597353,
0.22147448360919952,
0.024816764518618584,
-0.3566509783267975,
0.7798874378204346,
-0.5382382273674011,
-0.05685963109135628,
-0.22068572044372559,
0.08983935415744781,
0.09596911072731018,
0.6336566209793091,
0.5089586973190308,
-0.842296838760376,
-0.6176138520240784,
-0.0821102038025856,
-0.22676563262939453,
-0.08602270483970642,
-0.1968294382095337,
0.09690013527870178,
0.4162963628768921,
0.6003921031951904,
-0.7124772071838379,
0.5620144009590149,
0.9368472695350647,
-0.2316976636648178,
0.6636044979095459,
-0.2583071291446686,
0.000878258841112256,
-0.9558809995651245,
-0.01446332223713398,
-0.04328273981809616,
-0.43942004442214966,
-0.823904812335968,
0.17693912982940674,
0.03616224229335785,
0.0676356628537178,
-0.47374507784843445,
0.6593210101127625,
-0.2635657489299774,
0.09672348201274872,
-0.18686991930007935,
0.01085849292576313,
0.008583154529333115,
-0.06744713336229324,
-0.20074208080768585,
0.6963192820549011,
0.36171257495880127,
-0.9220476150512695,
-0.4437420666217804,
0.26666948199272156,
-0.09192296862602234,
0.5261974334716797,
-0.5112988352775574,
0.10412539541721344,
-0.16140754520893097,
0.16227589547634125,
-0.6973110437393188,
0.10591742396354675,
-0.016117598861455917,
-0.6272796988487244,
0.6704881191253662,
-0.21817535161972046,
-0.22011902928352356,
-0.17076195776462555,
-0.2541484236717224,
0.2770498991012573,
0.9317575097084045,
-0.56273353099823,
0.5382155179977417,
0.6182012557983398,
-0.2055848389863968,
-0.7056714296340942,
-0.5461794137954712,
0.06563115119934082,
-0.21400904655456543,
-0.6180219650268555,
0.4090745449066162,
-0.1584886908531189,
-0.3854304552078247,
-0.038601379841566086,
-0.22389227151870728,
-0.11007668077945709,
0.23906663060188293,
0.6016359925270081,
0.32045799493789673,
0.0627371072769165,
-0.19523385167121887,
0.024255119264125824,
-0.4865468740463257,
-0.07073058933019638,
-0.11267399787902832,
0.2661866247653961,
-0.11794713139533997,
-0.2764500379562378,
0.2636822462081909,
0.10252756625413895,
0.23621225357055664,
-0.054184690117836,
0.9086510539054871,
0.30948418378829956,
-0.4861435294151306,
-0.26672741770744324,
-0.7542374134063721,
0.0326797217130661,
-0.5135694146156311,
-0.16247893869876862,
-0.1775667369365692,
-0.9248536229133606,
0.5368180274963379,
-0.12681013345718384,
-0.1564316600561142,
0.7666890621185303,
0.5308514833450317,
-0.1851748526096344,
0.7967453002929688,
0.6448804140090942,
0.2741140127182007,
0.19136248528957367,
-0.2080676257610321,
0.0537743903696537,
-0.9013118743896484,
-0.2625011205673218,
-0.8630853295326233,
0.294198602437973,
-1.074880838394165,
-0.5896924734115601,
0.48545190691947937,
0.27882906794548035,
-0.3326756954193115,
0.2662040889263153,
-0.3999846279621124,
0.4278425872325897,
0.4787822365760803,
-0.10741952061653137,
0.525244951248169,
-0.3531581163406372,
0.0265756044536829,
0.09848067909479141,
-0.5668294429779053,
-0.6447665095329285,
1.0650423765182495,
0.6450369358062744,
1.0974034070968628,
0.33859893679618835,
0.8699448108673096,
0.18598870933055878,
0.6676278114318848,
-0.5823161005973816,
0.45728906989097595,
-0.39442166686058044,
-1.1207679510116577,
-0.10118570923805237,
-0.6100225448608398,
-1.0809770822525024,
0.0173124298453331,
-0.5194784998893738,
-0.6854465007781982,
0.6032016277313232,
0.38613754510879517,
-0.040446411818265915,
0.2131277620792389,
-0.34397393465042114,
0.311922550201416,
-0.022231575101614,
-0.2216629534959793,
-0.16849744319915771,
-0.5534520745277405,
0.9221858978271484,
-0.15488068759441376,
0.39704135060310364,
-0.028372453525662422,
0.18119964003562927,
0.1495058238506317,
-0.19994090497493744,
0.6163943409919739,
-0.21602800488471985,
-0.18301187455654144,
0.5439779758453369,
0.45667579770088196,
0.700900137424469,
0.1414111703634262,
-0.15939171612262726,
0.04231107607483864,
0.247370183467865,
-0.033429160714149475,
-0.17964375019073486,
0.6350874900817871,
-0.41030436754226685,
-0.8085694313049316,
-0.5604879260063171,
-0.3203258216381073,
-0.34974125027656555,
0.2841794788837433,
0.2812209725379944,
-0.062109582126140594,
-0.2897319197654724,
0.5483896136283875,
1.002959132194519,
-0.5289989113807678,
0.003986596129834652,
0.33805957436561584,
-0.32770591974258423,
-0.5268756151199341,
0.6926904320716858,
-0.14423201978206635,
0.9094407558441162,
0.0631512701511383,
0.3005208373069763,
-0.26321354508399963,
-0.5980929136276245,
-0.011220455169677734,
0.13419084250926971,
-0.8356379270553589,
-0.3036217987537384,
-0.37750914692878723,
-0.3782980144023895,
-0.5068204402923584,
-0.0784405767917633,
-0.40203115344047546,
-0.5496800541877747,
-0.025120269507169724,
-0.1215895265340805,
0.15692675113677979,
0.5298886299133301,
-0.06180029362440109,
0.1403896063566208,
-0.9369456171989441,
0.7209363579750061,
0.31749364733695984,
0.40766748785972595,
-0.16671167314052582,
-0.6377961039543152,
-0.15130940079689026,
0.02167636714875698,
-0.38692760467529297,
-0.8151525259017944,
0.21766257286071777,
0.21190808713436127,
0.7588727474212646,
0.1916438341140747,
0.3045257329940796,
0.35053908824920654,
-0.8337246775627136,
0.7152094841003418,
0.14597579836845398,
-0.7160094380378723,
0.06683725863695145,
-0.47495195269584656,
-0.26758572459220886,
0.670106053352356,
0.15723659098148346,
-0.46744978427886963,
-0.620007336139679,
-1.0921194553375244,
-0.8208367824554443,
0.26287686824798584,
0.09675048291683197,
0.13922066986560822,
-0.171881765127182,
0.6184657216072083,
-0.05352775752544403,
-0.08713629841804504,
-0.6087912917137146,
-0.437155157327652,
-0.03520835191011429,
-0.10501069575548172,
0.031551163643598557,
-0.5618330240249634,
-0.033585891127586365,
0.16970208287239075,
0.9441412687301636,
0.04799223691225052,
0.04937729239463806,
0.21539485454559326,
-0.07919386029243469,
-0.4376833736896515,
0.47861427068710327,
0.6346733570098877,
0.34699830412864685,
-0.14163322746753693,
0.27526775002479553,
0.26529160141944885,
-0.5309011936187744,
0.43830442428588867,
0.06745361536741257,
-0.468902051448822,
-0.1647120863199234,
0.1272345781326294,
0.40886953473091125,
0.22023418545722961,
-0.5366659760475159,
0.44438114762306213,
0.01781199872493744,
-0.11052651703357697,
-0.7098223567008972,
0.035748060792684555,
0.2813763916492462,
0.02125290036201477,
0.31212323904037476,
0.0691070705652237,
0.12499219924211502,
-0.3245624005794525,
0.4461534917354584,
0.619701087474823,
-0.3302701413631439,
-0.16447985172271729,
0.9191259741783142,
-0.013282458297908306,
-0.12852419912815094,
0.127542644739151,
-0.25644224882125854,
-0.24836844205856323,
0.5862866044044495,
0.6150142550468445,
1.1398371458053589,
-0.44117870926856995,
0.3994711637496948,
0.3835586905479431,
0.7180081009864807,
-0.41027069091796875,
-0.013977687805891037,
0.6247949004173279,
-0.6564573049545288,
-0.2941753566265106,
-0.7661761045455933,
-0.8605296611785889,
-0.07894212752580643,
-0.752192497253418,
0.19937950372695923,
-0.24116402864456177,
-0.304485946893692,
-0.3498450815677643,
-0.2811512053012848,
-0.5137016773223877,
0.13315095007419586,
0.36942678689956665,
0.9227654933929443,
-0.47418302297592163,
0.7232938408851624,
0.10797205567359924,
-0.2911701500415802,
-0.6903182864189148,
0.25001266598701477,
-0.1799272894859314,
-0.5241188406944275,
0.7240321636199951,
0.019168207421898842,
-0.34798339009284973,
0.037292446941137314,
-0.36491307616233826,
-1.035478115081787,
1.0714107751846313,
0.6629921793937683,
-0.5722521543502808,
-0.0923612043261528,
0.4052722454071045,
0.4802176058292389,
-0.13333456218242645,
-0.17577528953552246,
0.3744972050189972,
0.5672054290771484,
0.38830164074897766,
-0.8154311776161194,
-0.01786896213889122,
0.41795942187309265,
0.3242146968841553,
0.20798246562480927,
-0.28031936287879944,
0.8111470341682434,
-0.3699820041656494,
-0.4017869234085083,
0.1564529538154602,
0.6086203455924988,
0.5884932279586792,
0.4497474133968353,
0.6016553044319153,
0.5651695728302002,
0.43611153960227966,
-0.03327815234661102,
1.3938219547271729,
-0.49607595801353455,
0.4852794110774994,
1.038986086845398,
-0.2544349730014801,
0.8552770614624023,
0.3475187420845032,
-0.31657329201698303,
0.3998412489891052,
0.342512309551239,
0.376269668340683,
0.3555845320224762,
0.3441256880760193,
-0.13180746138095856,
-0.12571728229522705,
-0.07637149095535278,
-0.1743973195552826,
0.05001213401556015,
0.5517592430114746,
-0.42945125699043274,
-0.07158306241035461,
-0.13124331831932068,
0.03271761164069176,
0.3926989734172821,
-0.3442525565624237,
0.6087526082992554,
0.549717903137207,
-0.5349236726760864,
0.6233071684837341,
-0.21180826425552368,
0.54576176404953,
-0.43455150723457336,
0.11221269518136978,
-0.06093249097466469,
0.3030339479446411,
-0.2889954149723053,
-0.5103830695152283,
0.6114926934242249,
-0.14520171284675598,
-0.12024962902069092,
-0.1803485006093979,
1.0099327564239502,
-0.4926541745662689,
-0.6183230876922607,
0.13839387893676758,
0.3464454710483551,
-0.24575498700141907,
0.1634044051170349,
-0.4180818796157837,
-0.1623394936323166,
-0.2966870069503784,
-0.47729572653770447,
0.421318382024765,
0.20401597023010254,
0.014369387179613113,
0.7668436765670776,
0.6184365749359131,
0.41273677349090576,
0.3639988601207733,
-0.11967497318983078,
0.547320544719696,
-0.5343348979949951,
-0.12114887684583664,
-0.43807247281074524,
0.6026826500892639,
0.17166776955127716,
0.10061641782522202,
0.6959325075149536,
0.3724290132522583,
0.6391356587409973,
-0.1258709579706192,
0.6480839252471924,
-0.044578295201063156,
0.7091912031173706,
-0.5766743421554565,
0.8288905620574951,
-0.2536461651325226,
0.3889737129211426,
-0.12119877338409424,
-0.983905553817749,
-0.4399605095386505,
0.22010904550552368,
-0.16659106314182281,
0.07193681597709656,
0.6800197958946228,
0.764492928981781,
0.24309873580932617,
-0.36129307746887207,
0.500324010848999,
0.20954975485801697,
0.5443263649940491,
0.319050133228302,
0.7637867331504822,
-0.4246889352798462,
0.6158979535102844,
-0.26937973499298096,
-0.06413158029317856,
-0.03849891200661659,
-1.1538512706756592,
-0.6005207300186157,
-0.637746274471283,
-0.1567303091287613,
-0.8835623264312744,
-0.06684152036905289,
0.5401972532272339,
0.3122892677783966,
-0.813101053237915,
0.040151115506887436,
-0.12397437542676926,
0.2386089414358139,
-0.15435951948165894,
-0.2148529589176178,
0.0825430154800415,
-0.3969750702381134,
-0.5286095142364502,
0.33395370841026306,
-0.062601238489151,
0.2699548006057739,
-0.361722856760025,
-0.18750597536563873,
-0.011425158940255642,
0.32950982451438904,
0.2680622935295105,
0.48704466223716736,
-0.6632886528968811,
-0.6546332240104675,
-0.12428011000156403,
-0.339192658662796,
-0.1567973792552948,
0.7052211761474609,
-0.6416658759117126,
0.24616092443466187,
0.5749528408050537,
0.6695928573608398,
0.5086361765861511,
-0.03045983426272869,
0.4128572344779968,
-0.7417033314704895,
0.15986375510692596,
0.3498553931713104,
0.32832980155944824,
0.24191123247146606,
-0.6234124302864075,
0.4309392273426056,
-0.11084026843309402,
-0.8333099484443665,
-1.0258324146270752,
0.6825350522994995,
-0.9461889266967773,
0.04015590250492096,
1.4247063398361206,
-0.12973828613758087,
0.009671441279351711,
-0.09255355596542358,
0.12257325649261475,
0.2487902045249939,
0.20887823402881622,
0.9125531315803528,
0.40403351187705994,
0.27178049087524414,
-0.06880446523427963,
-0.8080806732177734,
0.8101595044136047,
0.17847196757793427,
-0.7828141450881958,
0.34751656651496887,
0.3481081426143646,
0.28163400292396545,
0.4254695475101471,
0.3095663785934448,
-0.4302101731300354,
0.24177415668964386,
-0.01929585076868534,
0.09745407849550247,
-0.03348083421587944,
-0.33007267117500305,
-0.34026119112968445,
0.08628346771001816,
0.5346779823303223,
0.28202030062675476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03177v1 | CIDAR: Culturally Relevant Instruction Dataset For Arabic | 2024-02-05T16:44:17 | 2024-02-05T16:44:17 | Zaid Alyafeai, Khalid Almubarak, Ahmed Ashraf, Deema Alnuhait, Saied Alshahrani, Gubran A. Q. Abdulrahman, Gamil Ahmed, Qais Gawah, Zead Saleh, Mustafa Ghaleb, Yousef Ali, Maged S. Al-Shaibani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Instruction tuning has emerged as a prominent methodology for teaching Large
Language Models (LLMs) to follow instructions. However, current instruction
datasets predominantly cater to English or are derived from English-dominated
LLMs, resulting in inherent biases toward Western culture. This bias
significantly impacts the linguistic structures of non-English languages such
as Arabic, which has a distinct grammar reflective of the diverse cultures
across the Arab region. This paper addresses this limitation by introducing
CIDAR: https://hf.co/datasets/arbml/CIDAR, the first open Arabic
instruction-tuning dataset culturally-aligned by human reviewers. CIDAR
contains 10,000 instruction and output pairs that represent the Arab region. We
discuss the cultural relevance of CIDAR via the analysis and comparison to
other models fine-tuned on other datasets. Our experiments show that CIDAR can
help enrich research efforts in aligning LLMs with the Arabic culture. All the
code is available at https://github.com/ARBML/CIDAR. | [
-0.2767072916030884,
-0.45605549216270447,
0.05002923682332039,
0.2558983564376831,
-0.008984377607703209,
0.3552129566669464,
-0.405709445476532,
-0.1638917326927185,
-0.15607357025146484,
0.3681826889514923,
-0.25293007493019104,
-0.8623071908950806,
-0.4917016327381134,
-0.18944120407104492,
-0.38210374116897583,
1.136587142944336,
-0.1940174698829651,
0.30207356810569763,
-0.0414416566491127,
-0.40706178545951843,
-0.6626327633857727,
-0.4929673373699188,
-0.49835002422332764,
-0.3594683110713959,
0.274600625038147,
0.9171454310417175,
0.5795286893844604,
0.9895756244659424,
0.6726722717285156,
0.1809874176979065,
0.06266910582780838,
0.31694090366363525,
-0.4788152277469635,
0.05507712438702583,
-0.22480538487434387,
-0.40108466148376465,
-0.15900728106498718,
-0.28564825654029846,
0.512362539768219,
0.643538236618042,
-0.2940628230571747,
0.6175600290298462,
-0.10968855768442154,
0.9593226909637451,
-0.6515960097312927,
0.0943855568766594,
-0.4378332197666168,
-0.19444863498210907,
-0.29102373123168945,
-0.03883282467722893,
-0.3360217213630676,
-0.7090647220611572,
0.036726292222738266,
0.08723444491624832,
0.20445787906646729,
0.23166148364543915,
0.40450969338417053,
0.4360582232475281,
-0.7149094343185425,
-0.3782094419002533,
-0.7590026259422302,
0.75181645154953,
-0.3612324297428131,
0.5346832871437073,
0.4121744632720947,
0.3303690552711487,
-0.2496262788772583,
-0.43507251143455505,
-0.36418360471725464,
0.0028016313444823027,
0.08988359570503235,
-0.24619585275650024,
-0.0492398701608181,
-0.13116583228111267,
-0.0009969309903681278,
0.3877405822277069,
-0.3903293013572693,
0.33737653493881226,
-0.47608253359794617,
-0.1768662929534912,
0.5528845191001892,
0.24074505269527435,
0.43210288882255554,
0.5432286262512207,
-0.13184542953968048,
-0.2465706765651703,
-1.027726173400879,
0.4834410846233368,
0.467745840549469,
0.23589780926704407,
-0.7166047692298889,
0.366167277097702,
-0.09388478845357895,
0.8947240114212036,
0.27427399158477783,
-0.2971973121166229,
-0.02250814251601696,
0.08604499697685242,
0.021114714443683624,
0.4942042827606201,
0.34226298332214355,
0.33358335494995117,
0.4206116795539856,
0.004257814958691597,
0.02032567746937275,
0.22877243161201477,
0.17569714784622192,
-0.9462717771530151,
-0.3926927149295807,
-0.033654384315013885,
-0.44525083899497986,
-0.13737012445926666,
0.05429239571094513,
-0.7007624506950378,
-0.4553646147251129,
-0.31574106216430664,
-0.14966003596782684,
0.01662638410925865,
0.13507121801376343,
-0.10929615795612335,
0.35614609718322754,
0.6951909065246582,
0.040625158697366714,
-1.1080571413040161,
0.33125436305999756,
0.664655864238739,
0.7156909108161926,
-0.14915357530117035,
-0.2582036256790161,
-0.5148922204971313,
0.03678671270608902,
-0.6480957865715027,
0.695853590965271,
-1.0205953121185303,
-0.40147390961647034,
-0.0013863680651411414,
-0.04816330224275589,
0.23436301946640015,
-0.4813854992389679,
0.7222840785980225,
-0.794490396976471,
0.021014537662267685,
-0.4152725040912628,
-0.21331436932086945,
-0.4661861062049866,
0.07536191493272781,
-0.4991907477378845,
0.833439826965332,
0.07565773278474808,
-0.5312134623527527,
0.2609245181083679,
-0.6614354848861694,
-0.7323394417762756,
-0.20253309607505798,
-0.2859702706336975,
-0.3511233329772949,
0.06649365276098251,
0.585614025592804,
0.10796266794204712,
-0.4637742042541504,
0.2100098431110382,
0.18344035744667053,
-0.7180372476577759,
0.02144545502960682,
-0.4373009204864502,
0.6967486143112183,
0.4345519542694092,
-0.416288286447525,
0.2058166116476059,
-0.5664514303207397,
-0.0861792042851448,
-0.07806029170751572,
-0.3461078107357025,
-0.2540874481201172,
0.05684874206781387,
-0.00836795475333929,
0.10942471027374268,
0.16962513327598572,
-0.4407513737678528,
0.20229484140872955,
-0.20764905214309692,
0.0693865641951561,
0.8523815870285034,
-0.0962003618478775,
0.5382057428359985,
-0.47519367933273315,
0.8260939717292786,
0.19771964848041534,
-0.12614744901657104,
-0.23212358355522156,
-0.14692193269729614,
-0.763719916343689,
-0.36416172981262207,
0.2279605120420456,
0.5160303115844727,
-0.2989380657672882,
0.08991779386997223,
-0.10782726109027863,
-0.7029010653495789,
-0.8740680813789368,
0.3997967541217804,
0.3168012201786041,
0.5270166397094727,
0.11123429238796234,
-0.34781646728515625,
-0.6417383551597595,
-0.8087034225463867,
-0.030994541943073273,
-0.05517035722732544,
0.3819369375705719,
0.22256630659103394,
0.2631964385509491,
-0.1930990219116211,
0.7549228668212891,
-0.27690696716308594,
-0.3201552629470825,
-0.137424498796463,
-0.1113249734044075,
0.3963707685470581,
0.4688231647014618,
0.6264761090278625,
-0.3117222487926483,
-0.8149905204772949,
0.2591029405593872,
-0.49806320667266846,
-0.19553972780704498,
0.016035402193665504,
-0.46613699197769165,
0.40849828720092773,
0.5007727146148682,
0.03587992861866951,
0.45749565958976746,
0.8388304114341736,
-0.29641205072402954,
0.19412603974342346,
-0.039406780153512955,
0.3063148558139801,
-1.0315470695495605,
-0.060175273567438126,
-0.1844005137681961,
0.015904344618320465,
-0.4809384346008301,
-0.0005596749833784997,
0.07824764400720596,
-0.047335878014564514,
-0.3888782262802124,
0.6636971235275269,
-0.5132563710212708,
0.21034173667430878,
-0.46915486454963684,
-0.6793898940086365,
-0.11326174437999725,
0.279529333114624,
0.27618640661239624,
1.374754786491394,
0.6195664405822754,
-0.4742474853992462,
0.06007491052150726,
0.4759999215602875,
-0.7847903966903687,
0.44001516699790955,
-0.7151426076889038,
0.4812474846839905,
-0.37092259526252747,
0.19650845229625702,
-0.5901205539703369,
-0.12127890437841415,
0.235261932015419,
-0.08649972826242447,
0.3756343424320221,
-0.30661535263061523,
-0.05963250994682312,
0.0570996031165123,
-0.0536821112036705,
0.736717164516449,
0.631629228591919,
-0.8655949831008911,
0.4807610511779785,
0.3124932646751404,
-0.10843749344348907,
-0.864130437374115,
-0.3130830228328705,
-0.0510428212583065,
-0.37545275688171387,
-0.38785994052886963,
0.09418755024671555,
0.05031868442893028,
-0.5066003203392029,
-0.334079384803772,
-0.21897442638874054,
0.11723091453313828,
0.14464938640594482,
0.519317090511322,
0.23563939332962036,
-0.3370826542377472,
0.08274275809526443,
0.20792031288146973,
0.3429284989833832,
0.14620868861675262,
-0.10275989770889282,
0.7204869389533997,
-0.31521663069725037,
-0.502297043800354,
-0.5043225884437561,
0.32778415083885193,
0.6498200297355652,
-0.7204601168632507,
1.011643886566162,
0.6299464702606201,
-0.13921275734901428,
-0.21475812792778015,
-0.5348076224327087,
-0.18964338302612305,
-0.49181056022644043,
0.4118734896183014,
-0.16876330971717834,
-0.60289067029953,
0.4111557900905609,
0.016121044754981995,
0.1419452428817749,
-0.052098874002695084,
0.7324308753013611,
-0.18758603930473328,
1.0230084657669067,
0.8151536583900452,
-0.6000548601150513,
0.4461125135421753,
-0.10088459402322769,
0.23410412669181824,
-0.631341278553009,
-0.3847595453262329,
-0.7054232358932495,
-0.7293117642402649,
-0.7443636655807495,
-0.2199031114578247,
0.45424702763557434,
-0.22148497402668,
-0.8480724692344666,
-0.3141535222530365,
-0.293010950088501,
0.8930056691169739,
0.7966443300247192,
-0.13370202481746674,
-0.0252233799546957,
0.3408359885215759,
-0.20888403058052063,
-0.011358555406332016,
-0.6255776882171631,
-0.7357472777366638,
1.0882306098937988,
0.2182016372680664,
1.3510122299194336,
0.4293294847011566,
0.5845180153846741,
0.6502050161361694,
0.31363645195961,
-0.6475188136100769,
0.16968774795532227,
-0.15642142295837402,
-0.45849835872650146,
0.27332064509391785,
-0.05745485797524452,
-0.8625762462615967,
-0.32959669828414917,
0.058554407209157944,
-0.5822474360466003,
0.20774734020233154,
0.029234709218144417,
-0.10716117918491364,
0.23783285915851593,
-0.7893643975257874,
0.6062036156654358,
-0.5824881792068481,
-0.4582301378250122,
-0.008155995979905128,
-0.76373690366745,
0.13802269101142883,
-0.04958794265985489,
0.21004165709018707,
-0.020857833325862885,
0.15715423226356506,
0.8133496642112732,
-0.12389729171991348,
1.0343116521835327,
-0.11374245584011078,
-0.2231157273054123,
0.39125603437423706,
0.316537082195282,
0.3551706075668335,
-0.16939759254455566,
-0.14143605530261993,
0.2828513979911804,
0.14428740739822388,
-0.4888201951980591,
-0.46120843291282654,
0.8693062663078308,
-1.2418817281723022,
-0.7557056546211243,
-0.6351991295814514,
-1.0034401416778564,
-0.17912112176418304,
-0.08653123676776886,
-0.24134127795696259,
0.4237555265426636,
0.057907380163669586,
0.17630499601364136,
0.4618070721626282,
-0.3344385623931885,
0.23129498958587646,
0.6222013235092163,
-0.1547843962907791,
-0.1574568897485733,
0.8953477740287781,
-0.1936711072921753,
0.05046037584543228,
0.22678528726100922,
-0.025742286816239357,
-0.17833256721496582,
-0.5098593235015869,
-0.575962245464325,
0.18380939960479736,
-0.8119922876358032,
-0.2334844321012497,
-0.22737041115760803,
-0.13487012684345245,
-0.2999587059020996,
-0.3431720435619354,
-0.060692109167575836,
-0.02758016437292099,
-0.40470877289772034,
-0.05691120773553848,
0.5600481629371643,
0.8236225843429565,
-0.008941891603171825,
0.48292261362075806,
-0.746355414390564,
0.020575307309627533,
0.06920477747917175,
0.2766840159893036,
0.01948070339858532,
-0.716049313545227,
-0.35203805565834045,
0.29597705602645874,
-0.27863505482673645,
-0.7269036769866943,
0.38749057054519653,
0.511397123336792,
0.5055381655693054,
0.5557416677474976,
0.18542137742042542,
0.7629861831665039,
-0.5945354700088501,
0.5256059169769287,
-0.316659539937973,
-0.74869704246521,
0.6353040933609009,
-0.06947383284568787,
0.6474516987800598,
0.6468316316604614,
0.5514562726020813,
-0.8131476044654846,
-0.06316036731004715,
0.014548738487064838,
-0.5234053134918213,
0.7839543223381042,
-0.3854288160800934,
0.4302293658256531,
-0.18885187804698944,
0.25499624013900757,
0.44766688346862793,
0.08967079967260361,
-0.1477922797203064,
-0.571614146232605,
-0.13245613873004913,
-0.6317843794822693,
0.0361892469227314,
-0.3426504135131836,
-0.19235001504421234,
-0.3174743950366974,
0.8007403016090393,
-0.12850786745548248,
0.08387419581413269,
-0.28628507256507874,
-0.29332464933395386,
-0.18491928279399872,
0.3662535548210144,
0.5709153413772583,
0.7697395086288452,
-0.18073438107967377,
0.08225748687982559,
0.10464838892221451,
-0.7702469825744629,
0.4248664677143097,
-0.19956892728805542,
-0.3224230110645294,
-0.5512617826461792,
0.3995114266872406,
0.6085009574890137,
-0.3208696246147156,
-0.8708556294441223,
0.03245834633708,
-0.15885166823863983,
0.3111492991447449,
-0.2287740856409073,
0.2336793690919876,
-0.24601125717163086,
0.3618311583995819,
0.23833438754081726,
0.09620851278305054,
-0.2002379447221756,
-0.5300512313842773,
0.07180249691009521,
0.363156795501709,
-0.6326877474784851,
-0.24576276540756226,
0.5615209937095642,
0.31341552734375,
-0.34556901454925537,
0.9909287691116333,
0.08908496797084808,
-0.685219943523407,
0.6663236021995544,
0.7735550403594971,
0.3317999541759491,
-0.17051459848880768,
0.2814197838306427,
0.2558842897415161,
0.43068909645080566,
0.2893677353858948,
0.5108181238174438,
-0.12892138957977295,
-0.7411845922470093,
-0.36247333884239197,
-0.7515765428543091,
-0.5541330575942993,
-0.22193458676338196,
-0.7325455546379089,
0.2766653299331665,
-0.4204384982585907,
0.17352280020713806,
-0.5961575508117676,
0.07469543069601059,
-0.8175556063652039,
0.060096919536590576,
0.2142287790775299,
0.810830295085907,
-0.9876694679260254,
0.9083330631256104,
1.1477570533752441,
-0.1737831085920334,
-0.7049753069877625,
-0.012264896184206009,
0.08915822207927704,
-1.0499927997589111,
0.8536316752433777,
0.008402915671467781,
-0.351822167634964,
0.13352616131305695,
-0.6805723905563354,
-0.7818781137466431,
0.8247856497764587,
0.40967556834220886,
-0.516990065574646,
0.27711087465286255,
0.22208066284656525,
0.48350176215171814,
-0.46469846367836,
0.20196911692619324,
0.7780213356018066,
0.23377065360546112,
0.19728723168373108,
-0.49981969594955444,
-0.21310074627399445,
-0.14611268043518066,
-0.236252099275589,
0.3018755614757538,
-0.7500953674316406,
0.4236201345920563,
-0.5447199940681458,
-0.06042163819074631,
0.08836853504180908,
0.9430474638938904,
0.15040533244609833,
0.09149710088968277,
0.12122655659914017,
0.42998719215393066,
0.8597524762153625,
-0.03296741470694542,
0.8396700620651245,
-0.5020191669464111,
-0.22938792407512665,
1.3056291341781616,
-0.4793393909931183,
0.69698166847229,
0.4834537208080292,
-0.1322462558746338,
0.6804041862487793,
0.7044122219085693,
0.05976756662130356,
0.6588373184204102,
0.22914238274097443,
-0.4133114218711853,
0.03992201387882233,
-0.7560949921607971,
-0.6726242303848267,
1.035292625427246,
0.27487266063690186,
-0.38075363636016846,
-0.13664810359477997,
-0.2357345074415207,
0.23050425946712494,
0.4110548496246338,
-0.4582679271697998,
0.6860273480415344,
-0.27065515518188477,
-0.549795389175415,
0.6130332946777344,
0.10188552737236023,
0.5234447121620178,
-0.48770973086357117,
-0.30814310908317566,
-0.6207566261291504,
0.04850494861602783,
-0.16844739019870758,
-0.39046502113342285,
0.17411178350448608,
0.3239614963531494,
-0.2742379307746887,
0.041989535093307495,
0.3752102851867676,
-0.5656188130378723,
-0.8306140899658203,
-0.20123524963855743,
0.5212381482124329,
-0.007429652381688356,
0.551738977432251,
-0.12619805335998535,
0.2794000208377838,
0.1662605106830597,
0.3026238679885864,
0.23135802149772644,
0.09805861115455627,
-0.4870774745941162,
0.5511225461959839,
0.604075014591217,
0.18029053509235382,
0.010112927295267582,
0.09887788444757462,
0.5057974457740784,
-0.591390073299408,
-0.1559777408838272,
-0.8733210563659668,
0.15390557050704956,
0.4137769043445587,
-0.23754911124706268,
0.5840070843696594,
0.4555700123310089,
1.0472593307495117,
-0.07871083170175552,
0.6454936265945435,
0.0592995248734951,
0.20394419133663177,
-0.3392334282398224,
1.0593311786651611,
-0.22136647999286652,
0.3527955412864685,
0.24697232246398926,
-1.0178629159927368,
-0.21696507930755615,
0.5473883152008057,
-0.41687607765197754,
0.21578389406204224,
0.4838588833808899,
1.0048408508300781,
-0.1283862143754959,
0.1733911633491516,
0.06874054670333862,
0.09935490041971207,
0.26588645577430725,
0.337520956993103,
0.8737537264823914,
-0.0712515339255333,
0.2843897342681885,
-0.5158171057701111,
-0.1488601118326187,
0.133627250790596,
-0.8946627974510193,
-1.1393810510635376,
-0.4248587191104889,
-0.28076115250587463,
0.07182023674249649,
0.13274124264717102,
1.6027790307998657,
0.6308388710021973,
-1.1910576820373535,
-0.5890302658081055,
0.4284813702106476,
0.17961545288562775,
-0.42045044898986816,
-0.13794049620628357,
0.603018045425415,
-0.12499813735485077,
-0.78191739320755,
0.3551056683063507,
-0.14406856894493103,
0.07511582225561142,
-0.018353259190917015,
-0.1516740769147873,
-0.34948065876960754,
-0.045514561235904694,
0.38787269592285156,
0.29676833748817444,
-0.5343298316001892,
-0.3792860805988312,
0.10998885333538055,
0.04445488378405571,
0.1139431893825531,
0.5738393664360046,
-0.772087574005127,
0.504414975643158,
0.1511995792388916,
1.0978634357452393,
0.12580132484436035,
0.03532570227980614,
0.6632709503173828,
-0.8229873180389404,
0.13096824288368225,
0.028696253895759583,
0.16879433393478394,
0.43773478269577026,
-0.24335506558418274,
0.5781169533729553,
-0.45427632331848145,
-0.6325863003730774,
-0.5965679287910461,
0.16613340377807617,
-0.6568477749824524,
0.3268609642982483,
1.038278341293335,
0.0315096341073513,
-0.11861193925142288,
-0.04184902831912041,
-0.4780367612838745,
0.23884455859661102,
-0.4946367144584656,
1.0394784212112427,
0.78794926404953,
0.04682862013578415,
-0.29931244254112244,
-0.17142395675182343,
0.18261806666851044,
0.47018948197364807,
-0.7244182825088501,
-0.24825243651866913,
0.5653182864189148,
0.15567946434020996,
-0.5224515795707703,
0.010619191452860832,
0.1650453507900238,
0.46262431144714355,
-0.415044367313385,
0.19171005487442017,
-0.24977454543113708,
-0.39508500695228577,
-0.3881070017814636,
-0.16901133954524994,
0.5784552693367004,
-0.22950156033039093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03173v2 | MULTI: Multimodal Understanding Leaderboard with Text and Images | 2024-02-05T16:41:02 | 2024-02-20T07:55:52 | Zichen Zhu, Yang Xu, Lu Chen, Jingkai Yang, Yichuan Ma, Yiming Sun, Hailin Wen, Jiaqi Liu, Jinyu Cai, Yingzi Ma, Situo Zhang, Zihan Zhao, Liangtai Sun, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Rapid progress in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) highlights the
need to introduce challenging yet realistic benchmarks to the academic
community, while existing benchmarks primarily focus on understanding simple
natural images and short context. In this paper, we present MULTI as a
cutting-edge benchmark for evaluating MLLMs on understanding complex tables and
images, and reasoning with long context. MULTI provides multimodal inputs and
requires responses that are either precise or open-ended, reflecting real-life
examination styles. MULTI includes over 18,000 questions and challenges MLLMs
with a variety of tasks, ranging from formula derivation to image detail
analysis and cross-modality reasoning. We also introduce MULTI-Elite, a
500-question selected hard subset, and MULTI-Extend, with more than 4,500
external knowledge context pieces. Our evaluation indicates significant
potential for MLLM advancement, with GPT-4V achieving a 63.7% accuracy rate on
MULTI, in contrast to other MLLMs scoring between 28.5% and 55.3%. MULTI serves
not only as a robust evaluation platform but also paves the way for the
development of expert-level AI. | [
-0.5495849847793579,
-0.8822202682495117,
0.5935118794441223,
0.321713387966156,
-0.11549296230077744,
0.1916768103837967,
-0.43808576464653015,
-0.46910417079925537,
-0.41488131880760193,
0.12340842187404633,
-0.6059584021568298,
-0.49744847416877747,
-0.7348417639732361,
0.058937519788742065,
-0.04243135824799538,
0.8320997953414917,
-0.17956745624542236,
0.18580706417560577,
-0.521131157875061,
-0.49524492025375366,
-0.5640507936477661,
-0.5771178603172302,
-0.44923684000968933,
-0.244927316904068,
0.7670371532440186,
0.29051268100738525,
0.6558437347412109,
0.26655471324920654,
0.7135481834411621,
0.3879580795764923,
0.07325844466686249,
0.38608670234680176,
-0.3017371594905853,
0.1624450832605362,
-0.06169850006699562,
-0.08783869445323944,
-0.668602466583252,
-0.030391674488782883,
0.6999912261962891,
0.5619370937347412,
0.14816255867481232,
0.4336739182472229,
0.10381064563989639,
0.8483992218971252,
-0.7296398878097534,
0.49963587522506714,
-0.48189613223075867,
0.1603042334318161,
-0.0814993754029274,
-0.061178985983133316,
-0.4708460867404938,
0.079816535115242,
0.10766810923814774,
-0.583851158618927,
-0.18910975754261017,
-0.009344728663563728,
0.5216447710990906,
0.12970802187919617,
-0.9311926364898682,
-0.21641574800014496,
-0.4248690903186798,
0.9029492735862732,
-0.1313457489013672,
0.8693485260009766,
0.2836165130138397,
0.8438071608543396,
-0.059063103049993515,
-0.989783763885498,
-0.5351061820983887,
-0.3185098469257355,
0.07909507304430008,
0.282199501991272,
0.03729771450161934,
-0.1116919219493866,
0.10125446319580078,
0.1801777333021164,
-0.7419782876968384,
-0.10348642617464066,
-0.24330322444438934,
-0.17790445685386658,
0.5502423644065857,
0.23988178372383118,
0.045239709317684174,
-0.010737482458353043,
-0.6058365106582642,
-0.17406919598579407,
-0.42941081523895264,
0.19141703844070435,
-0.03232116624712944,
0.03644487261772156,
-0.12446817010641098,
0.3741261661052704,
0.008102738298475742,
0.9638445377349854,
-0.5800188779830933,
-0.25422924757003784,
0.40697741508483887,
-0.79242342710495,
-0.3446286916732788,
-0.4681057333946228,
0.6917988657951355,
0.7154547572135925,
0.2961142957210541,
-0.006379415281116962,
-0.09879106283187866,
-0.04179034009575844,
0.009676957502961159,
-0.8149896860122681,
-0.1438637524843216,
0.06522337347269058,
-0.6375597715377808,
0.18288010358810425,
-0.17237789928913116,
-0.9192407131195068,
-0.3162607252597809,
-0.5440390706062317,
0.5089349746704102,
-0.28100502490997314,
-0.16204428672790527,
-0.1201154813170433,
-0.11487934738397598,
0.2843483090400696,
0.8845159411430359,
-0.6076919436454773,
0.05559375882148743,
0.609236478805542,
0.8231277465820312,
-0.2583467364311218,
-0.5653551816940308,
-0.6233475208282471,
-0.026692280545830727,
-0.2604561448097229,
0.8142130374908447,
-0.6704694032669067,
-0.277885764837265,
-0.29438135027885437,
-0.12142098695039749,
-0.3174798786640167,
-0.5397807359695435,
0.721360981464386,
-0.3391912579536438,
0.24072767794132233,
-0.10837403684854507,
-0.31325003504753113,
-0.22327978909015656,
0.8234961628913879,
-0.6483762860298157,
0.892930805683136,
-0.17161546647548676,
-0.42185837030410767,
0.5291584730148315,
-0.8892367482185364,
-0.26230525970458984,
-0.05337424576282501,
-0.37374088168144226,
-0.18107879161834717,
-0.15575744211673737,
0.44084101915359497,
0.5338624119758606,
-0.34178799390792847,
0.4027484357357025,
-0.3816373348236084,
-0.2388727366924286,
0.24778833985328674,
-0.7480996251106262,
0.39333489537239075,
0.29962143301963806,
-0.11398398131132126,
0.4292961657047272,
-0.6876683831214905,
0.3523234724998474,
-0.06710439175367355,
-0.46878665685653687,
-0.02420886792242527,
-0.08327972888946533,
0.4045158922672272,
0.6066709756851196,
0.21140794456005096,
-0.28941646218299866,
0.1977759450674057,
0.4948437213897705,
0.5162880420684814,
0.8548462390899658,
-0.15470220148563385,
-0.000692482921294868,
-0.1221616268157959,
0.2573627233505249,
0.14982642233371735,
0.47937044501304626,
-0.4280451834201813,
-0.8429712057113647,
-0.42773720622062683,
-0.5339159369468689,
0.2815312445163727,
0.39421358704566956,
-0.7749522924423218,
0.07399710267782211,
-0.3366250693798065,
-0.5618413686752319,
-0.7427927851676941,
0.29343360662460327,
0.49766266345977783,
0.43209508061408997,
0.7764933705329895,
-0.07562363147735596,
-0.28438684344291687,
-1.1185967922210693,
-0.37984180450439453,
0.13033701479434967,
-0.04271985590457916,
0.46790727972984314,
0.684789776802063,
-0.4091981053352356,
0.5301414728164673,
-0.18976224958896637,
-0.42652350664138794,
-0.06627315282821655,
0.34492751955986023,
0.20207472145557404,
0.5250065326690674,
0.18841949105262756,
-1.0469611883163452,
-0.6032624244689941,
0.1742752194404602,
-0.9219165444374084,
0.43075844645500183,
-0.19748936593532562,
-0.011697649024426937,
-0.14143986999988556,
0.4714052677154541,
-0.6235108375549316,
0.16838856041431427,
0.6639638543128967,
-0.42225390672683716,
0.59943687915802,
-0.321512371301651,
0.5747895240783691,
-0.7885453701019287,
0.27620986104011536,
0.14496499300003052,
-0.3062811493873596,
-0.604644238948822,
0.1790185123682022,
0.3852589428424835,
-0.049911193549633026,
-0.31677117943763733,
0.5292738676071167,
-0.635596513748169,
-0.19205857813358307,
0.14006705582141876,
0.340457022190094,
0.14110411703586578,
0.5337563753128052,
-0.23034192621707916,
0.7587867379188538,
0.49080219864845276,
-0.2508656084537506,
0.42446285486221313,
0.07453883439302444,
-0.7654049396514893,
0.7073717713356018,
-0.41172757744789124,
0.11835260689258575,
-0.2394142597913742,
0.3111553490161896,
-1.0209742784500122,
0.05381196737289429,
-0.20463860034942627,
-0.22986073791980743,
0.23321278393268585,
-0.01148198638111353,
-0.5629504919052124,
-0.3475131690502167,
-0.3319554626941681,
0.3944458067417145,
0.16096335649490356,
-0.4363006353378296,
0.8374546766281128,
0.222831130027771,
0.002785264980047941,
-0.9250255823135376,
-0.44536301493644714,
0.39834848046302795,
0.010941811837255955,
-0.705367922782898,
0.25170478224754333,
-0.5220385193824768,
-0.37786951661109924,
-0.1855745166540146,
-0.07510628551244736,
-0.1765684187412262,
0.20418187975883484,
0.2013421356678009,
0.11029718816280365,
-0.48248767852783203,
0.24683329463005066,
-0.11737188696861267,
-0.062158387154340744,
-0.09849029779434204,
0.18075580894947052,
0.3811641335487366,
-0.5466353893280029,
-0.5436577200889587,
-0.43513476848602295,
0.4398247301578522,
1.101865530014038,
-0.406574010848999,
0.46054956316947937,
0.8686573505401611,
-0.2204355150461197,
0.010152342729270458,
-0.45457765460014343,
0.008559318259358406,
-0.40914252400398254,
0.6788050532341003,
-0.8881436586380005,
-0.6626591682434082,
0.37641918659210205,
-0.02795056626200676,
0.3040459156036377,
0.5201417803764343,
0.6798650026321411,
-0.11402013897895813,
1.2548822164535522,
0.35400301218032837,
0.17433881759643555,
0.15786471962928772,
0.010116513818502426,
-0.0017545213922858238,
-0.7582421898841858,
-0.5271073579788208,
-0.3217126727104187,
-0.4551800787448883,
-0.3376179039478302,
-0.7018842697143555,
0.4622032046318054,
0.180418461561203,
-0.1341971755027771,
-0.05614045634865761,
-0.25694921612739563,
0.5119467973709106,
0.3706827759742737,
0.2115086019039154,
0.6483844518661499,
-0.35950231552124023,
-0.11701565980911255,
-0.16016033291816711,
-0.45818814635276794,
-0.4411688446998596,
1.0888751745224,
0.5245439410209656,
0.7656270265579224,
0.3074835538864136,
0.06567161530256271,
0.4717874825000763,
0.7192103862762451,
-0.7141281366348267,
0.42863887548446655,
-0.06197402998805046,
-0.7843812108039856,
-0.236932173371315,
-0.3940626084804535,
-0.7005248069763184,
0.904754638671875,
-0.33189529180526733,
-0.4877344071865082,
-0.1564762145280838,
0.037371546030044556,
-0.082684725522995,
0.11089546978473663,
-1.062585473060608,
1.3573732376098633,
-0.5058645009994507,
-0.41340094804763794,
-0.16281943023204803,
-0.7880719900131226,
0.4538988173007965,
-0.100361168384552,
0.5422699451446533,
-0.24595169723033905,
-0.18087796866893768,
0.5620242953300476,
0.15555453300476074,
0.5087325572967529,
-0.2789216935634613,
0.12466350197792053,
-0.09231789410114288,
-0.15445023775100708,
0.035200335085392,
0.059306416660547256,
-0.18038593232631683,
-0.013627972453832626,
0.08394712954759598,
-0.37975940108299255,
-0.8479622602462769,
0.7396261692047119,
-0.7043721079826355,
-0.4449741542339325,
-0.18201051652431488,
-0.6935029029846191,
-0.46130239963531494,
0.11644089967012405,
-0.20358701050281525,
0.6171265840530396,
-0.1881134957075119,
0.5674527883529663,
0.2718844711780548,
-0.09227897226810455,
0.3820977509021759,
0.16915318369865417,
-0.31678536534309387,
-0.434896320104599,
0.8569800853729248,
-0.008436429314315319,
0.25881054997444153,
0.3808661997318268,
0.18731904029846191,
-0.607303261756897,
-0.5189361572265625,
-1.0263950824737549,
-0.13822263479232788,
-1.0926412343978882,
-0.18301601707935333,
-0.8075142502784729,
0.0656299963593483,
-0.16058337688446045,
0.11652901768684387,
-0.3254217505455017,
-0.18916630744934082,
0.10703263431787491,
-0.0009214692399837077,
-0.013573475182056427,
0.7231402397155762,
0.2571641206741333,
-0.12505513429641724,
-0.8406772017478943,
0.19105610251426697,
0.5654370188713074,
0.48211759328842163,
0.1121942326426506,
-0.4134315252304077,
-0.17020680010318756,
-0.14297400414943695,
-0.38407307863235474,
-0.6248332858085632,
-0.03067971020936966,
0.46115991473197937,
1.0777862071990967,
0.3457014262676239,
-0.31265807151794434,
1.0307456254959106,
-0.6217715740203857,
0.7354352474212646,
0.26855194568634033,
-1.0013216733932495,
0.2788381278514862,
-0.05101843550801277,
0.5465031266212463,
0.7406389117240906,
0.5208343267440796,
-0.4694214463233948,
-0.11417204141616821,
-0.2162383645772934,
-0.5752142071723938,
0.19328205287456512,
0.14492523670196533,
-0.07131892442703247,
0.31419992446899414,
-0.11050491780042648,
0.22620384395122528,
0.3040723502635956,
-0.9807676672935486,
-0.24635854363441467,
-0.2537325918674469,
-0.22623786330223083,
-0.38424235582351685,
-0.07595191895961761,
-0.15884524583816528,
-0.38787642121315,
0.2765497863292694,
-0.33254337310791016,
0.15382440388202667,
0.12591403722763062,
-0.5197462439537048,
0.24851959943771362,
0.4898727536201477,
1.0945849418640137,
1.0427848100662231,
-0.3268558979034424,
0.4600059986114502,
0.2013932466506958,
-0.3109821677207947,
-0.1389399766921997,
0.06477771699428558,
0.5513632297515869,
-0.09952050447463989,
0.6983445882797241,
0.6589415669441223,
0.21861973404884338,
-0.871285080909729,
0.6165676712989807,
-0.23062798380851746,
-0.2008759081363678,
0.06873910874128342,
-0.3053539991378784,
0.11726942658424377,
0.33277255296707153,
0.5436272025108337,
0.15477941930294037,
0.17634961009025574,
-0.8370007276535034,
0.5039529204368591,
0.48257434368133545,
-0.5666403770446777,
-0.19818611443042755,
0.4842548668384552,
0.261552631855011,
-0.0744534581899643,
0.4289673864841461,
0.00007633971836185083,
-0.481905996799469,
0.5382541418075562,
0.4298047721385956,
0.35294246673583984,
-0.16490207612514496,
-0.06886900216341019,
0.4245278537273407,
0.49270099401474,
0.20460520684719086,
0.3528752028942108,
-0.3625311255455017,
-0.5868264436721802,
-0.42963707447052,
-0.4154473543167114,
-0.6291354894638062,
0.05625660717487335,
-0.5493166446685791,
0.07531645894050598,
-0.43826010823249817,
-0.2331666499376297,
0.3292878270149231,
-0.20372292399406433,
-0.7368308305740356,
0.1959981620311737,
0.12470785528421402,
0.9410406351089478,
-0.6266745924949646,
0.8556561470031738,
0.6344287395477295,
-0.2593689262866974,
-0.22599533200263977,
-0.3622804880142212,
0.0036582504399120808,
-0.8407365679740906,
0.8878694772720337,
0.6401985883712769,
-0.11176204681396484,
-0.23398619890213013,
-0.3114132285118103,
-0.4638017416000366,
1.1163338422775269,
0.058479733765125275,
-0.416009783744812,
0.12465915828943253,
-0.24231503903865814,
0.48200392723083496,
-0.43590080738067627,
0.7316878437995911,
0.35756248235702515,
0.8803775906562805,
-0.1134120374917984,
-1.1192350387573242,
-0.13359859585762024,
-0.47714412212371826,
-0.3396059572696686,
0.15198317170143127,
-0.5008495450019836,
1.2027980089187622,
-0.22223728895187378,
-0.059860870242118835,
-0.1633652299642563,
0.42694804072380066,
0.23884229362010956,
0.5408810973167419,
0.6007175445556641,
0.3772203326225281,
0.5808890461921692,
-0.12775562703609467,
0.8377710580825806,
-0.05983424559235573,
0.392530620098114,
1.1241997480392456,
-0.3677367568016052,
1.0240422487258911,
0.5877133011817932,
-0.15786150097846985,
0.6480884552001953,
0.5350766181945801,
-0.12120825052261353,
0.3506965935230255,
0.16509418189525604,
-0.21167664229869843,
-0.46554234623908997,
-0.06089112162590027,
-0.6319587230682373,
0.6973995566368103,
0.5526477694511414,
-0.33491721749305725,
-0.48200950026512146,
0.26604899764060974,
-0.23112817108631134,
0.06375222653150558,
-0.35975274443626404,
0.7395131587982178,
-0.0006900358130224049,
-0.7012591361999512,
0.46245697140693665,
-0.054062217473983765,
0.5972025990486145,
-0.5589354634284973,
-0.16268175840377808,
-0.04587825760245323,
0.37481948733329773,
-0.0355449803173542,
-1.1166077852249146,
0.044943615794181824,
-0.13015903532505035,
-0.11460811644792557,
-0.44470712542533875,
0.4578735828399658,
-0.5180105566978455,
-0.34140723943710327,
0.4577843248844147,
0.8257734179496765,
0.13055957853794098,
-0.252323716878891,
-1.0192023515701294,
0.191860169172287,
-0.2112005054950714,
-0.28935736417770386,
0.3486287295818329,
0.3718368411064148,
-0.11599510163068771,
0.8226566314697266,
0.6383272409439087,
-0.6296643614768982,
0.04830949008464813,
0.18386657536029816,
0.817245364189148,
-0.6457862257957458,
-0.3072858452796936,
-0.9402421116828918,
0.6121166944503784,
-0.334648460149765,
-0.548175573348999,
0.7620102167129517,
0.7467127442359924,
0.6438973546028137,
-0.09310097992420197,
0.45601093769073486,
0.23613733053207397,
0.16922186315059662,
-0.5225543975830078,
0.8565059900283813,
-0.8858626484870911,
-0.3090369701385498,
-0.2617540955543518,
-0.7805680632591248,
-0.5169696807861328,
0.5474259853363037,
-0.14975623786449432,
0.0944671705365181,
0.7262774109840393,
0.48818445205688477,
-0.10136944055557251,
0.04497693479061127,
0.6605693697929382,
-0.04891239106655121,
0.4321057200431824,
0.6627485156059265,
1.1018167734146118,
-0.40657761693000793,
0.6550253033638,
-0.024717381224036217,
-0.4646050035953522,
-0.011149071156978607,
-0.9024667739868164,
-0.9777578115463257,
-0.7055174112319946,
0.00537890987470746,
-0.06715788692235947,
-0.08836354315280914,
1.009770154953003,
0.905825138092041,
-0.7448611259460449,
-0.2902779281139374,
0.4696968197822571,
0.2571258842945099,
-0.3208625614643097,
-0.17616528272628784,
0.3492397665977478,
-0.10792401432991028,
-0.6109253168106079,
0.5159124732017517,
0.5592895150184631,
-0.10271652787923813,
-0.38240745663642883,
-0.20195956528186798,
-0.580263078212738,
-0.3410699963569641,
1.1962898969650269,
-0.07767853140830994,
-0.8035273551940918,
-0.15069478750228882,
0.06629545241594315,
-0.20084506273269653,
0.2646760046482086,
0.7821115255355835,
-0.47379615902900696,
0.7801252603530884,
0.4186916649341583,
0.7563043832778931,
0.5597094297409058,
-0.020808342844247818,
0.3467979431152344,
-0.5488789081573486,
0.07567168772220612,
0.26673227548599243,
0.5167678594589233,
0.35442331433296204,
0.016926223412156105,
0.44450390338897705,
0.30650290846824646,
-0.5325284600257874,
-0.8522874116897583,
0.131663516163826,
-1.0825281143188477,
-0.43682241439819336,
0.6662739515304565,
-0.2141667604446411,
-0.1377059817314148,
-0.26641520857810974,
-0.13521920144557953,
-0.10238327085971832,
-0.3122170567512512,
0.39929264783859253,
0.8109790086746216,
-0.2732336223125458,
-0.5319130420684814,
-0.9096323847770691,
0.2310146689414978,
0.4190009832382202,
-1.1409778594970703,
-0.02834613248705864,
0.5816149115562439,
-0.0030678368639200926,
0.30059438943862915,
0.622774600982666,
-0.14194227755069733,
0.3153684139251709,
-0.02677352912724018,
-0.04631462320685387,
-0.18956969678401947,
-0.6839218735694885,
-0.14126121997833252,
0.48939409852027893,
0.003979516215622425,
-0.2254127711057663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03172v1 | Accurate and Well-Calibrated ICD Code Assignment Through Attention Over Diverse Label Embeddings | 2024-02-05T16:40:23 | 2024-02-05T16:40:23 | Gonçalo Gomes, Isabel Coutinho, Bruno Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) has been adopted
worldwide, manually assigning ICD codes to clinical text is time-consuming,
error-prone, and expensive, motivating the development of automated approaches.
This paper describes a novel approach for automated ICD coding, combining
several ideas from previous related work. We specifically employ a strong
Transformer-based model as a text encoder and, to handle lengthy clinical
narratives, we explored either (a) adapting the base encoder model into a
Longformer, or (b) dividing the text into chunks and processing each chunk
independently. The representations produced by the encoder are combined with a
label embedding mechanism that explores diverse ICD code synonyms. Experiments
with different splits of the MIMIC-III dataset show that the proposed approach
outperforms the current state-of-the-art models in ICD coding, with the label
embeddings significantly contributing to the good performance. Our approach
also leads to properly calibrated classification results, which can effectively
inform downstream tasks such as quantification. | [
-0.08933739364147186,
-0.02980799227952957,
0.6148748993873596,
0.28563669323921204,
-0.5146984457969666,
0.31559592485427856,
-0.02234046347439289,
-0.49731820821762085,
0.3375466465950012,
0.3544631004333496,
-0.09467364847660065,
-0.527273952960968,
-0.6771032214164734,
0.3014492988586426,
-0.23176415264606476,
1.1210981607437134,
-0.6910492777824402,
0.3801632523536682,
-0.197435200214386,
-0.3140503168106079,
-0.451705664396286,
-0.6490743160247803,
-0.19211098551750183,
-0.3646467626094818,
0.43782636523246765,
0.2181701809167862,
0.6822760701179504,
1.0499593019485474,
0.7920129895210266,
0.09433259069919586,
0.26137328147888184,
0.1168283149600029,
-0.049092359840869904,
-0.16080929338932037,
-0.08332797139883041,
-0.3650668263435364,
-0.6521654725074768,
-0.33458855748176575,
0.11947722733020782,
0.585791289806366,
-0.22258111834526062,
0.18284063041210175,
0.0022120391950011253,
0.27716347575187683,
-0.5222970247268677,
0.002019235398620367,
-0.035332970321178436,
0.14028075337409973,
0.10837479680776596,
-0.34095707535743713,
-0.6020735502243042,
-0.4755591154098511,
0.042490970343351364,
-0.5682122707366943,
0.15511079132556915,
-0.11549245566129684,
0.4863392114639282,
0.41417473554611206,
-0.580511212348938,
-0.7067619562149048,
-0.7442092895507812,
0.4311498701572418,
-0.38302093744277954,
0.424823522567749,
0.2220182716846466,
0.48880693316459656,
0.35855937004089355,
-0.8660293221473694,
-0.30733996629714966,
0.07742451131343842,
-0.10855431854724884,
0.28975874185562134,
-0.15513825416564941,
0.052332762628793716,
0.12459202110767365,
0.3954564034938812,
-0.39738401770591736,
0.13385802507400513,
-0.5356746912002563,
-0.19455663859844208,
0.35967862606048584,
0.14966723322868347,
0.6307654976844788,
0.2714610993862152,
-0.2943519651889801,
0.07741506397724152,
-0.34929704666137695,
-0.3422331213951111,
-0.08825599402189255,
-0.023221921175718307,
-0.4849194288253784,
0.6789606809616089,
0.024175450205802917,
0.5312423706054688,
0.4388251304626465,
-0.37290558218955994,
0.5854400992393494,
-0.06748755276203156,
-0.02649538777768612,
0.6004883646965027,
0.5163334012031555,
0.7021750807762146,
0.16449838876724243,
-0.4393727481365204,
-0.24386270344257355,
0.194025456905365,
0.7500549554824829,
-0.801214337348938,
-0.1908450722694397,
0.30208244919776917,
-0.741168200969696,
-0.2559479773044586,
-0.10623518377542496,
-0.7261545062065125,
-0.12882208824157715,
-0.4048750698566437,
0.43645527958869934,
-0.26114383339881897,
0.34893086552619934,
0.24477842450141907,
0.0928880125284195,
-0.0030406343284994364,
0.30707377195358276,
-0.8481782674789429,
0.6157455444335938,
0.4498291611671448,
0.7568402886390686,
-0.41481634974479675,
0.06817501038312912,
-0.5448158979415894,
0.545876145362854,
-0.3542955815792084,
0.5431081056594849,
-0.5322620272636414,
-0.2618899643421173,
-0.1333252638578415,
-0.07833724468946457,
0.10847558081150055,
-0.5588335394859314,
0.5537971258163452,
-0.4004956781864166,
-0.2339211106300354,
0.3923344314098358,
-0.4474574625492096,
0.07401415705680847,
0.27474045753479004,
-0.9687479138374329,
0.4744199812412262,
0.247579425573349,
-0.720759928226471,
0.1456678956747055,
-0.3596510887145996,
-0.649320662021637,
0.00028613160247914493,
-0.1684383898973465,
-0.44779834151268005,
0.09632112085819244,
0.7412227988243103,
0.3609704375267029,
-0.4449426531791687,
0.2932957708835602,
0.1340222805738449,
-0.2564717233181,
0.2711776793003082,
-0.3043075203895569,
0.4451405704021454,
0.24368202686309814,
-0.25602781772613525,
0.03028382547199726,
-0.7328037023544312,
-0.017560169100761414,
-0.16326816380023956,
-0.16811835765838623,
-0.2789941430091858,
-0.20341452956199646,
0.1979956328868866,
-0.012228487059473991,
-0.05912245437502861,
-0.5941941738128662,
0.49265727400779724,
-0.29908642172813416,
0.3920389413833618,
0.38928624987602234,
0.19733066856861115,
0.45048052072525024,
-0.6328979730606079,
0.7650247812271118,
0.11143303662538528,
0.2739849388599396,
-0.3955737352371216,
-0.28443971276283264,
-0.4205010235309601,
-0.3726186454296112,
0.499607115983963,
0.6398167014122009,
-0.6964089870452881,
0.40928199887275696,
-0.6394189596176147,
-0.5612635016441345,
-0.769402027130127,
-0.17862170934677124,
0.25881192088127136,
0.420792818069458,
0.5384953022003174,
-0.5689222812652588,
-0.028580965474247932,
-0.7288994193077087,
0.19210898876190186,
0.08172597736120224,
-0.2782094180583954,
0.2517654001712799,
0.4617880582809448,
-0.5821471214294434,
0.80902099609375,
-0.615790843963623,
-0.3972526490688324,
-0.14124231040477753,
0.160935640335083,
0.17475742101669312,
0.7432581782341003,
0.39538660645484924,
-0.700744092464447,
-0.5826401114463806,
0.2772427201271057,
-0.4153033494949341,
-0.12207016348838806,
-0.48748326301574707,
0.1546781212091446,
-0.16523733735084534,
0.3511771261692047,
-0.2785806357860565,
0.6584814190864563,
0.44025635719299316,
0.09807318449020386,
0.3043758273124695,
-0.770311176776886,
0.23097223043441772,
-0.9326012134552002,
0.002640903927385807,
-0.024381157010793686,
-0.26780569553375244,
-0.521960437297821,
0.1093657985329628,
0.6864221096038818,
0.05711179971694946,
-0.37018486857414246,
0.4854044020175934,
-0.36463475227355957,
0.3324558436870575,
-0.030659984797239304,
-0.35970696806907654,
0.07872157543897629,
0.32765135169029236,
0.004891879856586456,
0.28340980410575867,
0.4542046785354614,
-0.40993475914001465,
0.7109324932098389,
0.19460800290107727,
-0.24318543076515198,
0.6304915547370911,
-0.6673055291175842,
0.312071830034256,
-0.17093205451965332,
0.7523499131202698,
-0.5534590482711792,
-0.2980734705924988,
0.2494441121816635,
-0.18739528954029083,
0.35221216082572937,
-0.2969408631324768,
-0.6492267847061157,
-0.7124163508415222,
-0.036309562623500824,
1.3176528215408325,
0.5993700623512268,
-0.7454711198806763,
0.6978914737701416,
0.34431102871894836,
-0.08967271447181702,
0.07025725394487381,
-0.7840448617935181,
0.0804101899266243,
-0.1973666548728943,
-0.13348010182380676,
0.8485551476478577,
-0.14736568927764893,
0.08928196132183075,
-0.22562028467655182,
-0.0945713147521019,
-0.2782067358493805,
-0.3675488233566284,
0.40722134709358215,
0.0034000473096966743,
-0.25130707025527954,
0.24463295936584473,
0.1570666879415512,
-0.38439542055130005,
-0.1029665619134903,
-0.29686465859413147,
0.38107314705848694,
0.4214918911457062,
-0.7780390977859497,
-0.814082682132721,
0.5683369636535645,
0.990872323513031,
-0.5256118774414062,
0.19258777797222137,
0.31550833582878113,
-0.9264412522315979,
-0.28646689653396606,
-0.47347012162208557,
0.0244074035435915,
-0.36171776056289673,
0.2923215329647064,
-0.2256821244955063,
-0.3165772259235382,
0.5432018637657166,
-0.12599724531173706,
-0.1868446320295334,
0.24416029453277588,
0.5228967666625977,
0.13252772390842438,
1.4013258218765259,
0.6581322550773621,
-0.2014947235584259,
-0.2652318775653839,
-0.02619578316807747,
0.4074653387069702,
-0.9376344680786133,
-0.42587316036224365,
-0.6085436940193176,
-0.26106053590774536,
-0.33209893107414246,
-0.6887898445129395,
0.4434822201728821,
-0.0714099332690239,
-0.21793894469738007,
-0.11210395395755768,
-0.8966928124427795,
0.3613165020942688,
0.1515340805053711,
0.4099560081958771,
0.1951749622821808,
-0.10089240223169327,
-0.05088524892926216,
-0.20328021049499512,
-0.6755041480064392,
-0.44023656845092773,
1.210518479347229,
0.5254312753677368,
1.2518469095230103,
-0.05207345634698868,
0.7275422811508179,
0.27089545130729675,
0.6915162801742554,
-0.7648768424987793,
-0.2243582159280777,
-0.2390574961900711,
-0.04207024723291397,
0.32443705201148987,
0.05233088880777359,
-0.7919475436210632,
-0.4204912781715393,
0.25732892751693726,
-0.6798608899116516,
0.27948758006095886,
0.15034621953964233,
-0.6845229268074036,
0.28926634788513184,
-0.5933122038841248,
0.851242184638977,
-0.5812127590179443,
0.18335653841495514,
-0.08216972649097443,
-0.543514609336853,
-0.034625131636857986,
-0.5026839971542358,
0.35295501351356506,
0.31346219778060913,
-0.08921470493078232,
0.7872098684310913,
-0.6779413223266602,
0.792988657951355,
0.1753530204296112,
-0.30496594309806824,
0.01590675301849842,
-0.013430333696305752,
0.5821239352226257,
0.18235717713832855,
0.12540669739246368,
-0.1826993077993393,
0.17332056164741516,
-0.3576470613479614,
-0.7464613914489746,
0.48099929094314575,
-0.7531030178070068,
-0.0030262565705925226,
-0.3947984278202057,
-0.43620720505714417,
-0.10309156030416489,
0.12822766602039337,
0.35163456201553345,
1.0946098566055298,
-0.04993801563978195,
-0.16950136423110962,
0.4651183784008026,
-0.48194003105163574,
0.011040239594876766,
-0.039577826857566833,
-0.028783170506358147,
-0.6693480014801025,
0.9544796347618103,
-0.03614858537912369,
0.3268062174320221,
0.6262043714523315,
-0.05572502315044403,
0.05488376319408417,
-0.5265851616859436,
-0.6435703635215759,
0.25674548745155334,
-0.8503227233886719,
-0.457085520029068,
-0.6961873173713684,
-0.19451794028282166,
-0.3264929950237274,
-0.7560083866119385,
-0.41275936365127563,
0.10449929535388947,
-0.44245773553848267,
-0.020782925188541412,
0.2023572474718094,
0.8197977542877197,
0.16906967759132385,
0.3045540452003479,
-0.9423174858093262,
0.7249652147293091,
0.20084692537784576,
0.6335293054580688,
-0.015208764933049679,
-0.27652353048324585,
-0.36313408613204956,
0.15916061401367188,
-0.11200399696826935,
-1.0630615949630737,
0.4582558274269104,
-0.005828761495649815,
0.5354027152061462,
0.33828967809677124,
0.3877566158771515,
0.8390575647354126,
-0.7442100644111633,
0.6043855547904968,
0.42375648021698,
-0.9071406126022339,
0.5854767560958862,
0.02588523179292679,
0.6153384447097778,
0.2708189785480499,
0.4216424822807312,
-0.6078575849533081,
-0.3817801773548126,
-0.5025306940078735,
-0.8165640830993652,
0.5074925422668457,
-0.0715731605887413,
0.2208050638437271,
-0.15288139879703522,
0.4308338463306427,
0.34916484355926514,
-0.23190343379974365,
-0.42757388949394226,
-0.2914150059223175,
-0.14515122771263123,
-0.9043315052986145,
-0.07257930934429169,
-0.15295177698135376,
-0.2658798098564148,
-0.39456331729888916,
0.2900647222995758,
-0.34752485156059265,
0.7150718569755554,
0.4586300253868103,
-0.4309230446815491,
-0.15476788580417633,
0.07513818889856339,
0.3935486674308777,
0.7946330904960632,
0.006607025396078825,
0.3213101327419281,
0.08736774325370789,
-0.6658154129981995,
0.29664304852485657,
0.3151453733444214,
-0.00862844754010439,
0.023199276998639107,
0.3779313862323761,
0.5215896964073181,
0.04834071174263954,
-0.7772237062454224,
0.7594258189201355,
-0.18744274973869324,
-0.09038729965686798,
0.02005903422832489,
-0.20682206749916077,
-0.153791144490242,
0.06268543750047684,
0.4930656850337982,
0.19311979413032532,
-0.02344418503344059,
-0.18706920742988586,
0.609333872795105,
-0.07287482172250748,
-0.6503114104270935,
-0.35588276386260986,
0.7900584936141968,
0.3870502710342407,
-0.5000202059745789,
0.5642425417900085,
0.01907174289226532,
-0.6566635370254517,
1.0592306852340698,
0.966792643070221,
0.7330411076545715,
-0.2234710454940796,
0.23656973242759705,
0.16887669265270233,
0.21802067756652832,
-0.13039585947990417,
-0.02165156416594982,
-0.036676254123449326,
-0.5082646012306213,
-0.5912650227546692,
-0.38696563243865967,
-0.2129533886909485,
-0.02322390489280224,
-1.1182893514633179,
0.36524373292922974,
-0.5012787580490112,
0.07499711215496063,
0.10754606872797012,
-0.4944089651107788,
-0.8104867339134216,
0.47423315048217773,
0.43668967485427856,
0.9970370531082153,
-0.5522291660308838,
0.6965747475624084,
0.7187235951423645,
0.04220511019229889,
-0.7363718748092651,
0.16220369935035706,
-0.10223742574453354,
-0.4816450774669647,
0.4071996510028839,
0.4262286126613617,
0.15256839990615845,
0.15419429540634155,
-0.1710829883813858,
-0.7965048551559448,
0.9146245121955872,
0.23192784190177917,
-0.6516149640083313,
-0.05040948837995529,
0.10501381009817123,
0.6206624507904053,
-0.5675475597381592,
0.31157317757606506,
0.3670480251312256,
0.1352221667766571,
-0.025853218510746956,
-1.482263445854187,
0.24104228615760803,
-0.45869436860084534,
-0.3289712965488434,
0.16854237020015717,
-0.32142308354377747,
0.22409561276435852,
-0.45078667998313904,
-0.15504230558872223,
0.1365414559841156,
0.3041093945503235,
-0.09808885306119919,
0.2982179522514343,
0.24197323620319366,
0.4244171380996704,
0.6374647617340088,
-0.00005163618698134087,
1.0948225259780884,
-0.551973283290863,
0.2900180220603943,
0.886978268623352,
-0.22237472236156464,
0.3448338508605957,
0.22205905616283417,
-0.22574256360530853,
0.25501590967178345,
0.49735745787620544,
-0.1514427810907364,
0.7478926777839661,
0.27868708968162537,
-0.21007558703422546,
-0.170888751745224,
-0.030840005725622177,
-0.4353087246417999,
0.21227297186851501,
0.3184172809123993,
-0.5643423795700073,
-0.2581952214241028,
0.5780720710754395,
-0.263744056224823,
-0.08284389972686768,
-0.368511825799942,
0.6969448328018188,
-0.021244946867227554,
-0.7328546047210693,
0.5145403146743774,
0.24820667505264282,
0.42788755893707275,
-0.24434728920459747,
-0.2070450484752655,
0.04289180412888527,
0.38203495740890503,
-0.1459142565727234,
-0.40656957030296326,
0.1061076819896698,
0.05138659477233887,
-0.0925404354929924,
-0.5029380917549133,
0.2004566788673401,
-0.3953765630722046,
-0.7463868856430054,
-0.04876747727394104,
0.02632381208240986,
-0.12580959498882294,
0.29568731784820557,
-0.2440701723098755,
0.08284346759319305,
0.05563611909747124,
0.275508850812912,
0.16671748459339142,
0.5778117775917053,
-0.16403669118881226,
0.6035383939743042,
0.24745023250579834,
0.10243827849626541,
-0.0371750071644783,
0.3259167969226837,
0.9016062021255493,
-0.5607189536094666,
-0.9571250677108765,
-0.5375300645828247,
0.5435515642166138,
0.26433905959129333,
-0.34826427698135376,
0.168228417634964,
0.7204669713973999,
0.612704873085022,
-0.010169888846576214,
0.7621751427650452,
0.2226932942867279,
0.334547221660614,
-0.36083629727363586,
0.6287926435470581,
-0.3539975881576538,
0.15844009816646576,
-0.220115065574646,
-0.5406548976898193,
-0.9508593082427979,
0.574667751789093,
-0.02695564366877079,
-0.18697768449783325,
0.7075452208518982,
0.5238097310066223,
-0.31834256649017334,
-0.06957735866308212,
-0.2553921341896057,
0.08660126477479935,
0.5479239821434021,
0.6066690683364868,
0.37499430775642395,
-0.37290599942207336,
0.38472655415534973,
-0.6059935688972473,
-0.32440146803855896,
-0.32313182950019836,
-0.6772722601890564,
-0.6394065022468567,
-0.4648773968219757,
-0.7606732249259949,
-0.27074992656707764,
0.12761427462100983,
0.9563829302787781,
0.6437425017356873,
-0.8170618414878845,
0.2305297553539276,
0.22767430543899536,
-0.025704966858029366,
-0.39839938282966614,
-0.06744346767663956,
0.7692246437072754,
0.03781644254922867,
-0.6544316411018372,
-0.08420863002538681,
0.3341812491416931,
0.34522372484207153,
0.2227432131767273,
-0.206598162651062,
0.4809879958629608,
-0.338074266910553,
0.326968252658844,
0.06551946699619293,
-0.6656274199485779,
-0.36134228110313416,
-0.07504945993423462,
-0.4512665271759033,
0.252956360578537,
0.8597564101219177,
-0.966849148273468,
0.7623392343521118,
0.11993653327226639,
0.845176637172699,
0.5496333241462708,
0.18022185564041138,
0.576356053352356,
-0.33896929025650024,
-0.09315090626478195,
0.5628701448440552,
0.012131181545555592,
0.15775160491466522,
-0.38801324367523193,
0.05030328035354614,
-0.06057518720626831,
-0.43534350395202637,
-0.9713907837867737,
-0.05664507672190666,
-1.1788960695266724,
-0.022587960585951805,
1.1240447759628296,
0.009755385108292103,
-0.1839609593153,
-0.34430748224258423,
-0.42629921436309814,
0.3012012243270874,
-0.05096842348575592,
0.889310896396637,
0.31709498167037964,
-0.18849916756153107,
-0.010437055490911007,
-0.2692597508430481,
0.3487096130847931,
0.03927388787269592,
-0.7301815748214722,
-0.173699289560318,
0.4250732362270355,
0.16875895857810974,
0.33292344212532043,
0.5830798745155334,
-0.20204229652881622,
0.5318063497543335,
-0.32202616333961487,
0.18075062334537506,
0.14444643259048462,
-0.2733353078365326,
-0.3915901780128479,
0.155669704079628,
-0.22554077208042145,
-0.22867876291275024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03171v1 | Homograph Attacks on Maghreb Sentiment Analyzers | 2024-02-05T16:39:15 | 2024-02-05T16:39:15 | Fatima Zahra Qachfar, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | We examine the impact of homograph attacks on the Sentiment Analysis (SA)
task of different Arabic dialects from the Maghreb North-African countries.
Homograph attacks result in a 65.3% decrease in transformer classification from
an F1-score of 0.95 to 0.33 when data is written in "Arabizi". The goal of this
study is to highlight LLMs weaknesses' and to prioritize ethical and
responsible Machine Learning. | [
-0.7248587012290955,
-0.4520949721336365,
0.1514776647090912,
0.22163282334804535,
-0.1025724858045578,
0.07451723515987396,
0.26021116971969604,
-0.7242807149887085,
0.38778939843177795,
0.28961631655693054,
-0.7380606532096863,
-0.5570973753929138,
-0.802872896194458,
0.28359872102737427,
-0.3395727872848511,
1.0641684532165527,
0.1807755082845688,
0.3918438255786896,
0.1291007399559021,
-0.15968984365463257,
0.05660473555326462,
-0.7709091901779175,
-0.4747013747692108,
-0.31814372539520264,
0.45754024386405945,
0.3893255293369293,
1.1089917421340942,
0.020271124318242073,
0.7825738787651062,
0.25242772698402405,
-0.27499526739120483,
-0.23113270103931427,
-0.3878016173839569,
-0.021225739270448685,
0.10596946626901627,
-0.5442383289337158,
-0.45889002084732056,
0.15604615211486816,
0.4516901671886444,
0.6677309274673462,
0.29152992367744446,
0.3060190975666046,
-0.1449233591556549,
1.0115087032318115,
-0.47960928082466125,
0.06833241879940033,
-0.4019472002983093,
0.15091851353645325,
-0.31958284974098206,
0.11496837437152863,
-0.35691913962364197,
-0.5361155867576599,
0.12422863394021988,
0.19786860048770905,
0.6080464124679565,
0.04490424692630768,
1.0036898851394653,
0.13032512366771698,
-0.47601622343063354,
-0.47884273529052734,
-0.46402740478515625,
0.9146355986595154,
-0.5851903557777405,
0.40428823232650757,
0.3220096826553345,
0.29390349984169006,
-0.07532212138175964,
-0.37884798645973206,
-0.3762395977973938,
0.14497001469135284,
-0.2585930824279785,
0.005045454949140549,
-0.17953380942344666,
-0.1044263169169426,
0.14014901220798492,
0.6216751933097839,
-0.0769348219037056,
-0.14710800349712372,
-0.4738297164440155,
-0.4466589093208313,
1.0498168468475342,
0.18579339981079102,
0.11522869020700455,
-0.4536781907081604,
-0.30697083473205566,
-0.007553497329354286,
-0.7987133264541626,
0.2230134904384613,
0.6389850974082947,
0.33093199133872986,
0.12435437738895416,
0.5533024668693542,
0.10354581475257874,
0.5701732635498047,
0.13436052203178406,
-0.31032195687294006,
0.4680420756340027,
-0.09701338410377502,
-0.23438072204589844,
0.08039188385009766,
0.7231131196022034,
0.6415234804153442,
0.33514609932899475,
-0.1490487903356552,
-0.2784269154071808,
0.1643441915512085,
0.3341960608959198,
-0.8958775997161865,
0.059438131749629974,
-0.009604359045624733,
-0.34319111704826355,
-0.47263267636299133,
0.48555025458335876,
-0.9131379127502441,
-0.691328763961792,
0.4351077377796173,
-0.016679711639881134,
-0.3178316056728363,
0.24891197681427002,
-0.3016826808452606,
-0.18987350165843964,
0.8774473071098328,
0.2741874158382416,
-0.48762598633766174,
0.24522963166236877,
0.3665388524532318,
0.8803303837776184,
-0.09809207171201706,
-0.0028366895858198404,
-0.1670011729001999,
-0.06870090216398239,
-0.2703944742679596,
0.6991249322891235,
-0.42470085620880127,
-1.0471653938293457,
0.04372787848114967,
0.08607442677021027,
-0.12693627178668976,
-0.45723989605903625,
0.7682494521141052,
-0.6926547884941101,
0.07232814282178879,
-0.49652138352394104,
-0.3418081998825073,
-0.6013144254684448,
0.132536381483078,
-0.8135287761688232,
1.0792919397354126,
0.452796995639801,
-0.978974461555481,
0.2315736711025238,
-0.6018562316894531,
-0.9210379719734192,
-0.220070481300354,
-0.12124118208885193,
-0.5903208255767822,
-0.027600694447755814,
0.2551780343055725,
0.5009976029396057,
-0.5286138653755188,
-0.19752785563468933,
-0.10027328133583069,
-0.606879472732544,
0.43281686305999756,
-0.19557976722717285,
0.8647822141647339,
0.25764578580856323,
-0.7164779901504517,
0.10141296684741974,
-0.6069615483283997,
-0.025514578446745872,
0.14632028341293335,
-0.08119155466556549,
0.0871446505188942,
0.1335519552230835,
0.3489042818546295,
0.46126943826675415,
-0.06656361371278763,
-0.9205098748207092,
0.12449939548969269,
-0.715884268283844,
0.27171385288238525,
0.8102842569351196,
0.23409923911094666,
0.20098964869976044,
-0.6392316818237305,
0.7352443337440491,
0.05797363817691803,
0.245082825422287,
0.4497075378894806,
-0.7219315767288208,
-0.8315727710723877,
-0.2829192280769348,
-0.035309452563524246,
0.720154345035553,
-0.5530166625976562,
0.3945472836494446,
-0.2518171966075897,
-0.9353058338165283,
-0.7089231014251709,
-0.007423532661050558,
0.24021178483963013,
0.41289079189300537,
0.21540868282318115,
-0.026762649416923523,
-0.3859370946884155,
-1.0708353519439697,
-0.5845491886138916,
-0.20043715834617615,
0.12401546537876129,
0.13926170766353607,
0.6226952075958252,
-0.894067108631134,
0.9630768299102783,
-0.47613653540611267,
-0.8022411465644836,
-0.3206298053264618,
-0.02888435870409012,
0.31539568305015564,
0.04499455541372299,
0.9680739641189575,
-0.9640082716941833,
-0.7410433888435364,
-0.2559433877468109,
-0.4451790153980255,
-0.1875254511833191,
0.1360735148191452,
0.1183556616306305,
0.6257692575454712,
0.49548399448394775,
-0.18850386142730713,
0.8841633200645447,
0.5438150763511658,
-0.5713883638381958,
0.30532658100128174,
0.6099305748939514,
0.29036960005760193,
-0.891449511051178,
-0.26091599464416504,
0.1039118692278862,
-0.23837979137897491,
-0.6770968437194824,
-0.12648339569568634,
-0.22479215264320374,
0.044700413942337036,
-0.63236403465271,
0.27417948842048645,
-0.15986794233322144,
0.004109151195734739,
0.024952253326773643,
-0.3159388303756714,
0.015157099813222885,
0.16948731243610382,
-0.2972814738750458,
1.0689910650253296,
0.523544430732727,
-0.09703817218542099,
0.11657129228115082,
0.3261389136314392,
-0.2557808756828308,
0.21731752157211304,
-0.6808013916015625,
0.34931114315986633,
-0.11804695427417755,
0.07325790822505951,
-1.3773728609085083,
-0.31965798139572144,
0.32301878929138184,
-0.4609854221343994,
0.15036845207214355,
0.18639902770519257,
-0.26424869894981384,
-0.252186119556427,
-0.9400306344032288,
0.06815697252750397,
0.46267595887184143,
-0.41445133090019226,
0.9353784322738647,
0.3987976312637329,
0.15194013714790344,
-0.8096480369567871,
-1.0867652893066406,
-0.17028184235095978,
-0.12261808663606644,
-0.7983988523483276,
0.10609034448862076,
0.19216643273830414,
-0.44581133127212524,
-0.07343064993619919,
-0.3241040110588074,
-0.044537752866744995,
0.1895507276058197,
0.854121744632721,
0.20663651823997498,
0.04995333403348923,
-0.29990148544311523,
-0.023088162764906883,
0.11830368638038635,
0.6040729284286499,
0.3674325942993164,
0.9061411619186401,
-0.7042223215103149,
-0.49077439308166504,
-0.7526902556419373,
0.46291688084602356,
0.7775483131408691,
0.03512349724769592,
1.2327078580856323,
0.5079126358032227,
-0.06133647635579109,
0.25132590532302856,
-0.3403526544570923,
-0.03084670566022396,
-0.5900633335113525,
0.26466619968414307,
-0.44135579466819763,
-0.8951714634895325,
0.5681919455528259,
-0.17577853798866272,
-0.012969213537871838,
1.0884945392608643,
0.5171797275543213,
-0.5078546404838562,
1.005449652671814,
0.6006152629852295,
-0.6345618367195129,
0.21992027759552002,
-0.3518346846103668,
0.31699448823928833,
-0.5298507809638977,
-0.4583394229412079,
-0.5042259693145752,
-0.4696689546108246,
-0.8011265397071838,
-0.07379327714443207,
0.5841023325920105,
-0.09603162854909897,
-0.09432186931371689,
-0.12806588411331177,
-0.26888400316238403,
0.4224727153778076,
0.37430787086486816,
0.15285179018974304,
-0.027222435921430588,
0.1462889462709427,
0.11177889257669449,
-0.06183435767889023,
-0.6286191940307617,
-0.7091729044914246,
0.9669012427330017,
0.3505810797214508,
0.7410970330238342,
0.24058778584003448,
1.0074269771575928,
0.8051509857177734,
0.826033353805542,
-1.0133179426193237,
0.5367797613143921,
0.15148335695266724,
-0.6620122790336609,
-0.3898681700229645,
-0.16420018672943115,
-0.6667518019676208,
-0.10000232607126236,
-0.11361084878444672,
-0.5027533173561096,
0.3590586483478546,
-0.13807839155197144,
0.11523513495922089,
0.3847498297691345,
-0.32283949851989746,
0.5938326120376587,
0.04761003330349922,
0.07359793782234192,
0.1787131428718567,
-0.9086593389511108,
0.17683790624141693,
-0.2989880442619324,
0.7610507011413574,
-0.09828656166791916,
0.2906002402305603,
0.9592046737670898,
-0.5717135071754456,
1.0195350646972656,
-0.36361539363861084,
-0.1685195416212082,
0.42612430453300476,
0.14486630260944366,
0.2527771294116974,
-0.048211898654699326,
-0.6185024976730347,
0.6594915390014648,
-0.20352022349834442,
-0.47273749113082886,
-0.31436559557914734,
0.3253258168697357,
-1.1465966701507568,
-0.7857390642166138,
-0.8633959293365479,
-0.5712570548057556,
-0.3082142174243927,
-0.18122605979442596,
0.7186279892921448,
0.09865719079971313,
-0.37354210019111633,
-0.07823943346738815,
0.2594625651836395,
-0.014263780787587166,
0.45514196157455444,
0.007518846541643143,
-0.39987707138061523,
-0.5064671039581299,
0.6885957717895508,
0.048816241323947906,
0.30109524726867676,
-0.2432587444782257,
-0.025948984548449516,
-0.08654772490262985,
-0.3690277338027954,
-0.3060053586959839,
0.4408373236656189,
-1.0989325046539307,
-0.4630233347415924,
-0.2518855631351471,
-0.3083716034889221,
-0.6333343386650085,
-0.5202111601829529,
-0.01947454735636711,
-0.3235582113265991,
-0.08831554651260376,
-0.04763241857290268,
0.43492037057876587,
0.8739620447158813,
0.19805701076984406,
0.9926504492759705,
-0.8585935831069946,
-0.01650429144501686,
0.16133658587932587,
0.032914578914642334,
-0.41472917795181274,
-0.805517852306366,
-0.13015227019786835,
-0.10489185899496078,
-0.23410123586654663,
-1.4080240726470947,
0.47122058272361755,
0.3915562927722931,
0.21635498106479645,
0.6644684076309204,
-0.004081811290234327,
0.44715431332588196,
-0.4375031590461731,
0.9268208742141724,
0.08931420743465424,
-1.3279095888137817,
0.5886074900627136,
0.03702516481280327,
0.11073319613933563,
0.6221269965171814,
0.9461638927459717,
-0.4616509675979614,
-0.46022501587867737,
-0.5524460673332214,
-0.6651090979576111,
0.7169086933135986,
0.2692568004131317,
-0.0050167967565357685,
-0.20971465110778809,
0.6957476139068604,
-0.06667664647102356,
0.06800819933414459,
-0.5979836583137512,
-0.9186384081840515,
-0.2748040556907654,
-0.11121749877929688,
-0.05775095894932747,
-0.6324560046195984,
-0.23858200013637543,
-0.7520326375961304,
0.8520617485046387,
0.07028613239526749,
0.4215644598007202,
0.41828805208206177,
-0.2904443144798279,
-0.215157613158226,
0.18899869918823242,
0.4077588617801666,
0.5248353481292725,
-0.11272643506526947,
0.04041416570544243,
0.318348228931427,
-0.8027442693710327,
0.3916202783584595,
-0.18192008137702942,
-0.29216721653938293,
0.20398013293743134,
0.6122176647186279,
0.5722222328186035,
-0.3696465492248535,
-0.5408042669296265,
0.6622664928436279,
-0.03548285365104675,
-0.32803550362586975,
-0.3719938397407532,
0.06542555242776871,
-0.04412798210978508,
0.11856414377689362,
0.4628389775753021,
0.18924351036548615,
0.4038271903991699,
-0.5854040384292603,
0.27445948123931885,
0.6223843693733215,
-0.7473447322845459,
-0.22834908962249756,
0.32440415024757385,
0.05595416575670242,
-0.46122556924819946,
0.6860179901123047,
-0.1356043666601181,
-1.2154475450515747,
0.6451482772827148,
0.7606127858161926,
0.6913052797317505,
-0.8141656517982483,
0.2843180298805237,
-0.12276240438222885,
0.7775387763977051,
0.44281768798828125,
0.791126012802124,
0.4107359051704407,
-0.8606153130531311,
-0.15199759602546692,
-0.7554722428321838,
-0.5593410730361938,
-0.3485928475856781,
-0.9750496745109558,
0.14635752141475677,
-0.6530866622924805,
-0.431615948677063,
0.11542695015668869,
-0.05380445346236229,
-0.48101791739463806,
0.6331505179405212,
0.07005868852138519,
0.7383924722671509,
-1.1066757440567017,
0.8201668858528137,
1.0659871101379395,
-0.1534961760044098,
-0.6141396164894104,
0.1300404667854309,
0.1166142076253891,
-0.7542343139648438,
0.9392321705818176,
0.3602322041988373,
-0.7007617950439453,
-0.1617744415998459,
-0.6558351516723633,
-0.8520519733428955,
0.8156970739364624,
0.2571978271007538,
-0.3597392737865448,
0.2724727690219879,
0.7489252090454102,
0.46277540922164917,
-0.08185408264398575,
-0.020633524283766747,
0.7851415872573853,
0.6160338521003723,
-0.06110767275094986,
-0.6285825371742249,
-0.05426999554038048,
-0.26975610852241516,
-0.3813319206237793,
0.5967947840690613,
-0.9169208407402039,
1.0419772863388062,
0.022943146526813507,
-0.2371344119310379,
-0.5507103204727173,
0.6619253754615784,
-0.3024340271949768,
0.301820307970047,
0.7191432118415833,
0.34442421793937683,
0.7892764210700989,
-0.13278374075889587,
1.2447651624679565,
-0.35651201009750366,
0.36164405941963196,
0.48295968770980835,
-0.3090493381023407,
0.5624935626983643,
0.6204968690872192,
-0.3760225474834442,
0.8753181099891663,
0.5077297687530518,
-0.09396833926439285,
0.3764903247356415,
0.11243915557861328,
-0.34377822279930115,
0.01588900201022625,
-0.013295827433466911,
-0.3695564568042755,
0.7758809328079224,
0.4932001829147339,
-0.2896258234977722,
-0.0577823743224144,
0.15379458665847778,
0.33042773604393005,
-0.09485401958227158,
-0.4260401129722595,
0.5122626423835754,
0.01154680922627449,
0.2007371485233307,
0.5729172825813293,
0.18292374908924103,
0.7348929047584534,
-0.3544130325317383,
0.3301149606704712,
-0.25572264194488525,
0.07785817235708237,
-0.6284645199775696,
-0.6348263025283813,
0.8896998763084412,
0.025092288851737976,
-0.3719308078289032,
0.2297595590353012,
0.7639886736869812,
0.05628468468785286,
-0.795689582824707,
0.44534850120544434,
0.44590139389038086,
0.14046716690063477,
-0.12971942126750946,
-0.6490345597267151,
0.17129428684711456,
0.2622597813606262,
-0.514102041721344,
0.27117952704429626,
-0.036432597786188126,
-0.14421206712722778,
0.6168131232261658,
0.49151742458343506,
-0.12922072410583496,
0.06374125182628632,
-0.040213748812675476,
1.1397268772125244,
-0.9484586715698242,
-0.24355392158031464,
-1.1563400030136108,
-0.15029019117355347,
-0.2122693806886673,
0.02754388004541397,
1.2653878927230835,
0.5009939074516296,
0.6798774600028992,
-0.013751863501966,
0.7474597692489624,
-0.07720361649990082,
0.5019146800041199,
-0.16257627308368683,
1.0657331943511963,
-0.3122488558292389,
0.2365720123052597,
-0.45207881927490234,
-1.0510807037353516,
-0.4940076172351837,
0.808392345905304,
-0.4016934335231781,
-0.10122134536504745,
0.6536586880683899,
0.7160959839820862,
0.48442840576171875,
0.4232126474380493,
-0.009374273009598255,
0.10122987627983093,
0.34269869327545166,
0.1427064687013626,
0.8743502497673035,
-0.7111133933067322,
0.12229570746421814,
-0.5726084113121033,
-0.13271453976631165,
0.07257995754480362,
-0.7351047992706299,
-1.2883813381195068,
-0.17461368441581726,
-0.29882651567459106,
-0.5960558652877808,
-0.16168220341205597,
0.8310928344726562,
0.11080744862556458,
-1.1245503425598145,
-0.4207133948802948,
0.42337682843208313,
0.15485471487045288,
0.13830937445163727,
-0.3145415186882019,
0.7021637558937073,
-0.27762293815612793,
-0.5482226610183716,
0.3138045072555542,
-0.07662765681743622,
-0.01786772720515728,
-0.07032954692840576,
0.0443657785654068,
-0.34636521339416504,
0.28015878796577454,
0.6609044671058655,
-0.19307158887386322,
-0.5367317795753479,
-0.4753323793411255,
0.1767139732837677,
-0.20419469475746155,
0.28724589943885803,
0.6117787957191467,
-0.7072532176971436,
-0.08717446029186249,
0.17936095595359802,
0.5371508002281189,
0.13691237568855286,
0.02819623425602913,
0.1935727596282959,
-0.8436636924743652,
0.40205180644989014,
0.4262648820877075,
0.3484865427017212,
0.22278326749801636,
-0.6578713655471802,
0.657433271408081,
0.4148516058921814,
-0.537009596824646,
-0.7617636322975159,
0.11488177627325058,
-0.7822176814079285,
-0.24212536215782166,
1.14434814453125,
-0.09050553292036057,
-0.45752012729644775,
-0.13577809929847717,
-0.4175359010696411,
0.15336211025714874,
-0.2837522327899933,
0.6875227689743042,
0.729710042476654,
-0.34940969944000244,
0.39099323749542236,
-0.18874575197696686,
0.6457346081733704,
0.5094318389892578,
-0.7412480115890503,
-0.43180933594703674,
0.5324700474739075,
0.2139129638671875,
0.2981319725513458,
0.2850154638290405,
-0.0848359614610672,
0.09110831469297409,
-0.21665434539318085,
0.033528219908475876,
0.19426479935646057,
-0.4082367420196533,
-0.5358121395111084,
0.4972689747810364,
0.003326474456116557,
-0.08387771248817444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03163v1 | Linguistic features for sentence difficulty prediction in ABSA | 2024-02-05T16:31:03 | 2024-02-05T16:31:03 | Adrian-Gabriel Chifu, Sébastien Fournier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | One of the challenges of natural language understanding is to deal with the
subjectivity of sentences, which may express opinions and emotions that add
layers of complexity and nuance. Sentiment analysis is a field that aims to
extract and analyze these subjective elements from text, and it can be applied
at different levels of granularity, such as document, paragraph, sentence, or
aspect. Aspect-based sentiment analysis is a well-studied topic with many
available data sets and models. However, there is no clear definition of what
makes a sentence difficult for aspect-based sentiment analysis. In this paper,
we explore this question by conducting an experiment with three data sets:
"Laptops", "Restaurants", and "MTSC" (Multi-Target-dependent Sentiment
Classification), and a merged version of these three datasets. We study the
impact of domain diversity and syntactic diversity on difficulty. We use a
combination of classifiers to identify the most difficult sentences and analyze
their characteristics. We employ two ways of defining sentence difficulty. The
first one is binary and labels a sentence as difficult if the classifiers fail
to correctly predict the sentiment polarity. The second one is a six-level
scale based on how many of the top five best-performing classifiers can
correctly predict the sentiment polarity. We also define 9 linguistic features
that, combined, aim at estimating the difficulty at sentence level. | [
-0.48847514390945435,
-1.0064719915390015,
0.6288660764694214,
0.4967958629131317,
-0.3471498191356659,
0.12227217853069305,
-0.2495669424533844,
-0.4003692865371704,
0.0908212661743164,
0.3782571256160736,
-0.6169910430908203,
-0.6324977874755859,
-0.8187066912651062,
0.6353896856307983,
0.06882814317941666,
1.3717238903045654,
-0.0976245105266571,
0.09323407709598541,
-0.27859964966773987,
-0.46183064579963684,
-0.9382580518722534,
-0.776006281375885,
-0.04813380539417267,
-0.1325572282075882,
0.39358216524124146,
0.5119187831878662,
0.8357224464416504,
-0.03737577795982361,
0.8356788158416748,
0.36070001125335693,
-0.36915722489356995,
-0.11735616624355316,
0.07249518483877182,
0.26681214570999146,
-0.25942397117614746,
-0.7368777394294739,
-0.10057252645492554,
-0.16451536118984222,
0.03353044018149376,
1.04696524143219,
0.10804106295108795,
-0.3689267039299011,
0.12453223764896393,
0.9517074227333069,
-0.23174181580543518,
0.36363187432289124,
-0.5569370985031128,
0.12064886093139648,
-0.4689629077911377,
0.21995672583580017,
-0.031467244029045105,
-0.39558637142181396,
0.22670412063598633,
-0.1323988139629364,
0.34407466650009155,
0.1913032978773117,
0.8175990581512451,
0.22702695429325104,
-0.6798120141029358,
-0.5635623931884766,
-0.6248680353164673,
0.857370913028717,
-0.495261013507843,
0.07240600138902664,
0.35434210300445557,
0.02096174843609333,
-0.008214203640818596,
-0.05259038135409355,
-0.6063293218612671,
-0.17943687736988068,
-0.18389266729354858,
0.0013298516860231757,
-0.31049975752830505,
0.10230351984500885,
0.028389809653162956,
0.5295633673667908,
-0.46215689182281494,
-0.03959515690803528,
-0.4409008324146271,
0.13108156621456146,
0.5640237927436829,
0.28744229674339294,
0.2695857286453247,
-0.9006218314170837,
-0.07547633349895477,
-0.033964723348617554,
-0.36760082840919495,
0.4330054521560669,
0.48412954807281494,
0.5499650239944458,
-0.06823991984128952,
0.7557072043418884,
-0.3231216371059418,
0.5785505175590515,
-0.2047913521528244,
-0.01827918365597725,
0.6546509265899658,
-0.31321242451667786,
-0.05153343081474304,
-0.12673991918563843,
0.8647844791412354,
0.1803358495235443,
0.06175968050956726,
0.18486323952674866,
-0.34177109599113464,
0.21364004909992218,
0.4003112316131592,
-0.3480776846408844,
-0.0983683317899704,
0.4254944920539856,
-0.45392102003097534,
-0.39115244150161743,
0.1781684309244156,
-0.9208212494850159,
-0.48539572954177856,
-0.11906396597623825,
0.13046389818191528,
-0.7450025081634521,
-0.005794723518192768,
-0.1742638796567917,
0.02948884665966034,
0.09939047694206238,
0.14340974390506744,
-0.6166300773620605,
0.2998976707458496,
0.8452462553977966,
0.9135491251945496,
-0.2210402488708496,
-0.28352028131484985,
-0.11727001518011093,
-0.5532599687576294,
-0.008633146062493324,
0.8493479490280151,
-0.6563004851341248,
-0.4697994291782379,
-0.11379674077033997,
-0.2241935282945633,
-0.17690257728099823,
-0.4035896360874176,
0.9728670716285706,
-0.06044543534517288,
0.3447272777557373,
-0.23239800333976746,
-0.44988420605659485,
-0.5348942875862122,
0.1702907383441925,
-0.64944988489151,
0.7900639176368713,
0.5971832871437073,
-0.9175441265106201,
0.30326101183891296,
-0.6309123039245605,
-1.045669436454773,
0.07820123434066772,
-0.08895912021398544,
-0.522047758102417,
0.5855509042739868,
0.15432436764240265,
0.543458878993988,
-0.10303959995508194,
0.25268426537513733,
-0.21718120574951172,
0.0807855948805809,
0.6964403986930847,
-0.1289825290441513,
0.48727676272392273,
0.08689487725496292,
-0.44580620527267456,
0.041848793625831604,
-0.5227002501487732,
-0.22385135293006897,
-0.06627114117145538,
-0.24940936267375946,
-0.6194196343421936,
0.08549424260854721,
0.1096925288438797,
0.14118942618370056,
0.009475315921008587,
-0.4497074484825134,
0.21627210080623627,
-0.7520627379417419,
0.34119483828544617,
0.6025040745735168,
0.21152439713478088,
0.26085364818573,
-0.11115345358848572,
0.8031958937644958,
0.35747018456459045,
0.17388519644737244,
0.09305296838283539,
-0.8261608481407166,
-0.5726054310798645,
0.03274508938193321,
0.18545374274253845,
0.8237304091453552,
-0.7990233898162842,
0.6045999526977539,
-0.0695115402340889,
-0.45736995339393616,
-0.721200704574585,
0.4127459228038788,
0.49670639634132385,
0.18037909269332886,
0.34844839572906494,
-0.38828232884407043,
-0.3190537393093109,
-0.9231202602386475,
-0.2537122666835785,
-0.12704353034496307,
0.27595674991607666,
0.38615983724594116,
0.526324987411499,
-0.0486765019595623,
0.8284043669700623,
-0.6580764651298523,
-0.744935929775238,
-0.8685654401779175,
0.4818885028362274,
0.3681277632713318,
0.22276800870895386,
0.43926313519477844,
-1.0126405954360962,
-0.3901819586753845,
-0.0423424206674099,
-0.5907624363899231,
-0.12425287812948227,
0.11002819985151291,
0.30429235100746155,
0.5561270713806152,
0.10125495493412018,
-0.6546768546104431,
0.35258761048316956,
0.572932779788971,
-0.4587153494358063,
0.4044468104839325,
0.013055041432380676,
0.2069585770368576,
-1.0661433935165405,
-0.356332391500473,
0.3288915753364563,
0.30883437395095825,
-0.650088369846344,
-0.04954426735639572,
-0.19770368933677673,
-0.13835927844047546,
-0.3817838728427887,
-0.15524598956108093,
-0.26209211349487305,
0.08099159598350525,
-0.29781702160835266,
-0.14643284678459167,
0.20655249059200287,
0.6073557734489441,
-0.0362231619656086,
0.500609278678894,
0.5232458710670471,
-0.3764537572860718,
0.32430505752563477,
0.13448573648929596,
-0.3892681300640106,
0.6743213534355164,
-0.5781846046447754,
-0.08234748989343643,
-0.23535911738872528,
-0.14305634796619415,
-1.0402880907058716,
-0.23757658898830414,
0.12739405035972595,
-0.3439640402793884,
0.060478854924440384,
0.18733328580856323,
-0.10060923546552658,
-0.3015235960483551,
-0.33839911222457886,
0.4051920771598816,
0.13339950144290924,
0.19981540739536285,
0.7752305269241333,
0.26818737387657166,
-0.5813407897949219,
-0.5157986283302307,
-0.6983494162559509,
0.11070774495601654,
-0.35873275995254517,
-0.5018230676651001,
0.2662850022315979,
0.017551835626363754,
-0.640303373336792,
0.0664677545428276,
0.188521146774292,
-0.17356567084789276,
0.2784968614578247,
0.7178442478179932,
0.22420717775821686,
-0.08344406634569168,
0.18951930105686188,
0.23176166415214539,
0.13131295144557953,
0.10281448066234589,
0.33840376138687134,
0.5839435458183289,
-0.634046733379364,
-0.040677957236766815,
-0.3920062482357025,
0.4796539545059204,
0.4378145635128021,
-0.20677617192268372,
0.6960039138793945,
0.2355959415435791,
-0.2789466679096222,
-0.1642281711101532,
-0.2787192761898041,
0.16099920868873596,
-0.40145647525787354,
0.4328244924545288,
-0.5032603740692139,
-0.7061981558799744,
0.4830819070339203,
0.3559264838695526,
-0.20654554665088654,
0.5523976683616638,
0.24528054893016815,
-0.131015807390213,
0.6574669480323792,
0.606619656085968,
-0.14256642758846283,
0.22564077377319336,
-0.0197589211165905,
0.3692038655281067,
-0.5138412714004517,
-0.445151150226593,
-0.8032328486442566,
-0.3802388310432434,
-0.7108184099197388,
-0.1993410587310791,
0.3158104419708252,
-0.06854250282049179,
0.27887481451034546,
0.25604280829429626,
-0.27197811007499695,
0.21352259814739227,
0.4859444797039032,
0.135310560464859,
0.0993000790476799,
-0.07188840955495834,
0.027282927185297012,
-0.3497390151023865,
-0.2939958870410919,
-0.30290448665618896,
0.8179844617843628,
0.25473159551620483,
0.6194177865982056,
0.3504868745803833,
0.7290820479393005,
0.3932403028011322,
0.1298702508211136,
-1.233188509941101,
0.48207342624664307,
-0.6708706021308899,
-0.32885080575942993,
-0.24660083651542664,
-0.7293872237205505,
-0.9901639819145203,
0.0030071011278778315,
-0.4148328900337219,
-0.5109774470329285,
0.2751288115978241,
-0.27674421668052673,
-0.30391472578048706,
0.017445938661694527,
-0.7633021473884583,
0.8539206385612488,
-0.3845442831516266,
-0.027416538447141647,
0.045022230595350266,
-0.7046384811401367,
0.30876803398132324,
-0.048289719969034195,
0.7651339173316956,
-0.10397743433713913,
0.18539495766162872,
0.7046673893928528,
-0.294647216796875,
0.886518120765686,
-0.062274087220430374,
0.17025168240070343,
0.2414117306470871,
0.3319033086299896,
0.04934428259730339,
-0.11600982397794724,
-0.15589168667793274,
0.28469061851501465,
-0.3103714883327484,
-0.11821097135543823,
-0.5991967916488647,
0.6330888271331787,
-0.8774129748344421,
-0.5199761390686035,
-0.5548553466796875,
-0.5055708885192871,
-0.40859562158584595,
0.010864210315048695,
0.27928775548934937,
0.39168864488601685,
-0.2379719614982605,
0.30866578221321106,
0.333074688911438,
-0.3093734681606293,
0.45721548795700073,
0.23318631947040558,
0.01975303515791893,
-0.48417699337005615,
1.0655611753463745,
0.19548992812633514,
-0.012709427624940872,
0.4136025905609131,
0.41804906725883484,
-0.16492898762226105,
-0.8139215111732483,
-0.13840404152870178,
0.03235034644603729,
-0.580237865447998,
-0.4259529113769531,
-0.7737979888916016,
-0.0874304249882698,
-0.4043036997318268,
-0.16205857694149017,
-0.21773630380630493,
-0.5247206687927246,
-0.4131503105163574,
-0.2807040810585022,
0.3710441291332245,
0.9020576477050781,
0.2954671382904053,
0.48462533950805664,
-0.8272836804389954,
0.3075445294380188,
-0.0267539843916893,
0.19462940096855164,
-0.4540550708770752,
-0.43146032094955444,
0.043924957513809204,
-0.33231887221336365,
-0.471920907497406,
-1.0679864883422852,
0.703586220741272,
0.31786561012268066,
0.20722104609012604,
0.26465892791748047,
0.22095607221126556,
0.12287218123674393,
-0.12019677460193634,
0.954990029335022,
0.22904790937900543,
-1.2746986150741577,
0.9401389956474304,
0.03084789402782917,
0.14856861531734467,
0.8843711018562317,
0.39842164516448975,
-0.3037576675415039,
-0.86790531873703,
-0.5999384522438049,
-1.1876392364501953,
0.6531302332878113,
0.36784154176712036,
0.2805052101612091,
-0.06244694069027901,
0.5172178149223328,
0.47566765546798706,
0.3549231290817261,
-1.013514757156372,
-0.24733351171016693,
-0.4960345923900604,
-0.6728605031967163,
-0.16471856832504272,
-0.23226743936538696,
0.0994618758559227,
-0.09686332195997238,
0.4238895773887634,
0.060131411999464035,
-0.06650153547525406,
0.09152043610811234,
-0.11448070406913757,
-0.1016916036605835,
0.7711620926856995,
0.2544057369232178,
0.5277846455574036,
-0.42982593178749084,
0.06163373962044716,
0.027427133172750473,
-0.3993966579437256,
0.022279886528849602,
0.23509731888771057,
-0.1841319352388382,
0.12833595275878906,
0.6108402609825134,
0.95406174659729,
0.03554445877671242,
-0.6183918714523315,
0.6477704644203186,
-0.07274752110242844,
-0.16765984892845154,
-0.20467719435691833,
0.146419957280159,
-0.3984418213367462,
0.08557426929473877,
0.4301559031009674,
0.1423603594303131,
0.46060097217559814,
-0.9048997163772583,
0.023059243336319923,
0.26586347818374634,
-0.5943916440010071,
-0.31906428933143616,
0.10708893090486526,
0.3602255880832672,
-0.35195836424827576,
0.6291841864585876,
-0.4147833585739136,
-0.8749910593032837,
0.6588405966758728,
0.12379880249500275,
0.9597258567810059,
-0.22630023956298828,
0.4289894998073578,
-0.010519128292798996,
0.456627756357193,
0.09791797399520874,
0.4509989619255066,
0.48270076513290405,
-0.765507698059082,
-0.23052598536014557,
-0.9176846146583557,
-0.5807579755783081,
-0.1020272970199585,
-0.747309684753418,
0.12420818209648132,
-0.5070974230766296,
-0.25457486510276794,
0.17814335227012634,
0.17610806226730347,
-0.6273084282875061,
0.4939083456993103,
-0.04589712992310524,
0.37318697571754456,
-1.1572797298431396,
0.4347083568572998,
1.009771466255188,
-0.5315335392951965,
-0.6761751770973206,
0.17390070855617523,
-0.08144433051347733,
-0.295404314994812,
0.5576786398887634,
0.5959452390670776,
0.11154957115650177,
-0.6720556020736694,
-0.24438783526420593,
-0.24806538224220276,
0.6067928671836853,
-0.02401949279010296,
-0.39949142932891846,
0.2236230969429016,
0.3444634675979614,
0.8627467155456543,
-0.6047317981719971,
0.020171474665403366,
0.5298359990119934,
0.36692801117897034,
-0.17541159689426422,
-0.8537243008613586,
0.1096886619925499,
-0.19864948093891144,
-0.015281068161129951,
0.20732946693897247,
-0.47078806161880493,
1.1668459177017212,
-0.16657744348049164,
-0.04039749875664711,
-0.24943406879901886,
0.9062037467956543,
-0.12078885734081268,
0.6673436164855957,
0.7961528301239014,
0.3971739411354065,
0.6756328344345093,
-0.3052264153957367,
1.0411463975906372,
-0.1398920863866806,
0.3238499164581299,
0.886590301990509,
-0.35934194922447205,
0.9671525955200195,
0.3770464360713959,
-0.29645588994026184,
1.1058757305145264,
0.47852787375450134,
0.09286370128393173,
0.5161466598510742,
0.28777915239334106,
-0.11401359736919403,
0.03416617959737778,
-0.1756696105003357,
-0.17414310574531555,
0.8533855080604553,
0.5052546262741089,
-0.2774057984352112,
0.10327310860157013,
0.4755931794643402,
-0.10033275187015533,
0.2738095223903656,
-0.30253341794013977,
0.8351889252662659,
0.07548036426305771,
-0.7113404870033264,
-0.05871229246258736,
0.36903873085975647,
0.6868995428085327,
-0.4866867959499359,
0.1242125853896141,
-0.4828443229198456,
-0.07297927886247635,
-0.2942924499511719,
-1.3187065124511719,
0.6576412320137024,
0.03682895749807358,
-0.191407710313797,
0.16144773364067078,
0.6417489051818848,
-0.12579534947872162,
-0.7191815376281738,
0.34700918197631836,
0.7177135348320007,
0.09321705251932144,
-0.43567150831222534,
-0.742348849773407,
0.19310396909713745,
0.13105785846710205,
-0.35490691661834717,
0.250307559967041,
0.8365955948829651,
0.09958404302597046,
0.5683156251907349,
0.1863039880990982,
-0.08096934109926224,
-0.3726733326911926,
0.19634424149990082,
0.8638718724250793,
-1.0815614461898804,
-0.5259240865707397,
-0.8660833835601807,
0.33594852685928345,
0.1094026118516922,
-0.60304856300354,
0.4184668958187103,
0.36180388927459717,
0.3491196632385254,
0.024979636073112488,
0.9323456287384033,
-0.404297411441803,
0.4758499264717102,
-0.548923134803772,
0.20717397332191467,
-0.48911380767822266,
0.5338581800460815,
-0.36036601662635803,
-0.8930278420448303,
-0.3150641620159149,
0.5242498517036438,
-0.4173169434070587,
0.07708199322223663,
0.9304436445236206,
0.6229519844055176,
0.08622433245182037,
0.1660662740468979,
0.003593632485717535,
0.30113348364830017,
0.068475641310215,
0.6708211302757263,
0.745807945728302,
-0.0905069038271904,
0.7442523837089539,
-0.8191419839859009,
-0.3169924318790436,
-0.16808952391147614,
-0.5946203470230103,
-0.9210751056671143,
-0.610223114490509,
-0.37180909514427185,
-0.5527862906455994,
-0.08364415168762207,
0.8274081945419312,
0.05843108519911766,
-1.0453953742980957,
-0.15190701186656952,
-0.17708872258663177,
0.46508654952049255,
-0.36260443925857544,
-0.39098846912384033,
0.41613221168518066,
-0.4553077816963196,
-0.7123540639877319,
0.22900494933128357,
0.22584804892539978,
-0.024979520589113235,
-0.22074970602989197,
0.25835105776786804,
-0.010277642868459225,
0.09711165726184845,
0.6047207117080688,
-0.08585499227046967,
-0.5698820352554321,
-0.43738776445388794,
-0.11104883253574371,
-0.09206852316856384,
0.14347177743911743,
0.8694138526916504,
-0.4123179018497467,
0.28008028864860535,
0.32098522782325745,
0.29210156202316284,
-0.07847539335489273,
0.3005627691745758,
0.49821507930755615,
-0.9842456579208374,
-0.10602536797523499,
0.29490405321121216,
0.4538742005825043,
0.6605189442634583,
-0.47013354301452637,
0.33023062348365784,
0.42678409814834595,
-0.24904288351535797,
-0.5361053943634033,
0.244948610663414,
-1.4087449312210083,
-0.6343566179275513,
1.202439308166504,
-0.27237269282341003,
-0.27375125885009766,
-0.4976119101047516,
-0.2562211751937866,
-0.05274698883295059,
-0.5547935366630554,
1.0551137924194336,
0.9426212310791016,
-0.49218541383743286,
-0.18806491792201996,
-0.3771370053291321,
0.41873252391815186,
0.6623937487602234,
-0.8719372153282166,
-0.03393326699733734,
0.6212729215621948,
0.11422454565763474,
0.3683944642543793,
0.13208013772964478,
0.21171164512634277,
0.019998572766780853,
-0.19540545344352722,
-0.0325070321559906,
0.06526044756174088,
-0.30230650305747986,
-0.5431429743766785,
0.8216964602470398,
0.15102185308933258,
0.13607631623744965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03161v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03161v3 | Video-LaVIT: Unified Video-Language Pre-training with Decoupled Visual-Motional Tokenization | 2024-02-05T16:30:49 | 2024-06-03T08:09:09 | Yang Jin, Zhicheng Sun, Kun Xu, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Hao Jiang, Quzhe Huang, Chengru Song, Yuliang Liu, Di Zhang, Yang Song, Kun Gai, Yadong Mu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In light of recent advances in multimodal Large Language Models (LLMs), there
is increasing attention to scaling them from image-text data to more
informative real-world videos. Compared to static images, video poses unique
challenges for effective large-scale pre-training due to the modeling of its
spatiotemporal dynamics. In this paper, we address such limitations in
video-language pre-training with an efficient video decomposition that
represents each video as keyframes and temporal motions. These are then adapted
to an LLM using well-designed tokenizers that discretize visual and temporal
information as a few tokens, thus enabling unified generative pre-training of
videos, images, and text. At inference, the generated tokens from the LLM are
carefully recovered to the original continuous pixel space to create various
video content. Our proposed framework is both capable of comprehending and
generating image and video content, as demonstrated by its competitive
performance across 13 multimodal benchmarks in image and video understanding
and generation. Our code and models are available at
https://video-lavit.github.io. | [
-0.20526166260242462,
-0.6774501800537109,
0.3502340018749237,
0.16230252385139465,
-0.8488378524780273,
0.11230173707008362,
-0.4397636651992798,
0.22840414941310883,
0.2825741469860077,
0.27792179584503174,
-0.4714142978191376,
-0.4029662013053894,
-0.6161136627197266,
-0.4334259331226349,
-0.6052322387695312,
0.8685458302497864,
-0.19088362157344818,
0.1515074372291565,
-0.032539792358875275,
-0.15487074851989746,
-0.17625001072883606,
-0.5694804191589355,
-0.36212754249572754,
0.04405563697218895,
0.2517624497413635,
0.017581112682819366,
0.4474712908267975,
0.5889002680778503,
0.5042552947998047,
0.3842036724090576,
0.11111544072628021,
0.09480234235525131,
-0.4950904846191406,
0.055262595415115356,
0.15792213380336761,
-0.02628333680331707,
-0.38178473711013794,
-0.3586830794811249,
0.9488677382469177,
0.4917960464954376,
-0.13192012906074524,
0.4311315417289734,
-0.08124629408121109,
0.38509172201156616,
-0.707116961479187,
0.16041718423366547,
-0.58147132396698,
0.1485644429922104,
-0.3658442199230194,
-0.3822573125362396,
-0.11757437884807587,
-0.06748274713754654,
-0.09489962458610535,
-0.7310259342193604,
0.3663591146469116,
-0.4225570261478424,
0.7607502341270447,
0.5293525457382202,
-0.2726805508136749,
0.25219208002090454,
-0.7851916551589966,
0.3403775691986084,
-0.20292429625988007,
0.6423944234848022,
0.01792743243277073,
0.38847464323043823,
0.15863369405269623,
-1.0849097967147827,
-0.6735759973526001,
0.2441873848438263,
0.26633480191230774,
0.034566525369882584,
-0.033344220370054245,
0.22221267223358154,
0.08753819763660431,
0.29486608505249023,
-0.6989844441413879,
0.09044831246137619,
-0.23217865824699402,
-0.0522320419549942,
0.2324279397726059,
0.19775933027267456,
0.49440011382102966,
-0.018455317243933678,
-0.39290347695350647,
-0.3033210337162018,
-0.6239420771598816,
0.06963258981704712,
0.08664052188396454,
0.0720643624663353,
-0.3548029363155365,
0.5043646693229675,
0.16984575986862183,
0.49183890223503113,
-0.031412310898303986,
-0.3288765847682953,
0.25128278136253357,
-0.45294564962387085,
-0.5179899334907532,
-0.09551768004894257,
0.934205174446106,
0.43028780817985535,
0.20527124404907227,
-0.10056613385677338,
0.05694827437400818,
0.28849512338638306,
0.11978324502706528,
-1.164984941482544,
-0.1889352649450302,
-0.12862877547740936,
-0.30884209275245667,
0.08064813166856766,
0.28470274806022644,
-0.817424476146698,
-0.11388656497001648,
-0.2937842607498169,
0.5198634266853333,
-0.07701894640922546,
-0.35223913192749023,
0.1836821585893631,
0.2379923313856125,
0.20955593883991241,
0.40880587697029114,
-0.9728404879570007,
-0.08658275008201599,
0.3690602481365204,
0.7310975193977356,
-0.30162787437438965,
-0.3974566161632538,
-0.9855874180793762,
0.3794512152671814,
-0.2673906981945038,
0.4947870373725891,
-0.33827322721481323,
-0.1885790228843689,
0.46672406792640686,
0.04506254196166992,
0.01081536803394556,
-0.20507392287254333,
0.08070818334817886,
-0.6100776195526123,
-0.00023858208442106843,
-0.10230712592601776,
-0.18719539046287537,
0.17873331904411316,
0.3044934868812561,
-0.6281775236129761,
0.7142253518104553,
-0.25529253482818604,
-0.7645495533943176,
0.6128673553466797,
-0.7835606932640076,
-0.3939589560031891,
0.1039801761507988,
-0.3465343415737152,
-0.4208541810512543,
0.08472506701946259,
0.4213128387928009,
0.6000616550445557,
0.016285860911011696,
0.5932527184486389,
-0.17006337642669678,
-0.3218149244785309,
0.13466596603393555,
-0.8774062991142273,
0.11327364295721054,
0.24597038328647614,
-0.18063949048519135,
0.19241352379322052,
-0.8802635669708252,
-0.09369772672653198,
-0.04989808425307274,
-0.3553100824356079,
0.2875860631465912,
-0.047446537762880325,
0.12377502024173737,
0.02097315341234207,
0.05356841906905174,
-0.20066896080970764,
0.05028288811445236,
-0.14492809772491455,
0.4486117362976074,
0.8598793745040894,
-0.1850980818271637,
0.6417261958122253,
0.45919176936149597,
0.679794430732727,
0.07066082954406738,
0.08413545787334442,
-0.8307453393936157,
0.11228138208389282,
-0.7972209453582764,
-0.44253402948379517,
-0.06990784406661987,
0.15598233044147491,
-1.054439663887024,
0.06507721543312073,
-0.8944194912910461,
-0.04201525077223778,
-0.21501901745796204,
0.23656173050403595,
0.3296937942504883,
0.2290390133857727,
0.3370583951473236,
-0.44422197341918945,
-0.5112975239753723,
-0.257152259349823,
0.019583024084568024,
-0.1255655586719513,
-0.11637833714485168,
-0.14505210518836975,
0.404629111289978,
-0.2380629926919937,
0.7821667194366455,
-0.5605884194374084,
-0.18740056455135345,
-0.09902767837047577,
0.293413370847702,
-0.0770348533987999,
0.20418575406074524,
0.5585137009620667,
-0.8844725489616394,
-0.31895485520362854,
0.09161578118801117,
-0.7338112592697144,
0.21563518047332764,
-0.1343139410018921,
0.13035912811756134,
-0.08259454369544983,
0.8811134696006775,
-0.6025372743606567,
0.6121443510055542,
0.5948540568351746,
-0.14107848703861237,
0.2840675115585327,
-0.41315141320228577,
0.2234591841697693,
-1.1746282577514648,
0.08620826154947281,
-0.3596472442150116,
-0.3053903877735138,
-0.5146844983100891,
0.08529956638813019,
-0.34431955218315125,
-0.4509173035621643,
-0.9031447768211365,
0.4864200949668884,
-0.46437570452690125,
-0.2542513608932495,
-0.10234473645687103,
0.13755296170711517,
-0.21884538233280182,
0.5393195152282715,
0.35519832372665405,
0.8131095767021179,
0.7140095233917236,
-0.6411277651786804,
0.4050790071487427,
0.08090950548648834,
-0.5084500312805176,
0.3625701069831848,
-0.4283079504966736,
-0.10432210564613342,
-0.36828380823135376,
0.1978410929441452,
-0.757506251335144,
-0.6539334654808044,
-0.08400499820709229,
-0.21812009811401367,
0.19883136451244354,
-0.27547407150268555,
-0.42155835032463074,
-0.2006101757287979,
-0.24475377798080444,
0.8376820683479309,
0.438920795917511,
-0.7681986093521118,
0.7765777111053467,
0.3543550968170166,
-0.1267586499452591,
-0.7878475189208984,
-0.6499058604240417,
0.03375548496842384,
-0.2873067259788513,
-0.39889246225357056,
0.35769450664520264,
-0.26666802167892456,
-0.008969416841864586,
-0.03851858526468277,
-0.18993070721626282,
-0.2480497509241104,
-0.2751941978931427,
0.4153505265712738,
-0.0769357979297638,
-0.16567976772785187,
0.2092452198266983,
-0.1831691861152649,
-0.0769374743103981,
-0.10679975152015686,
-0.14215585589408875,
0.7468893527984619,
-0.21306389570236206,
-0.4891916513442993,
-0.4078567922115326,
0.2593625783920288,
0.7696675658226013,
-0.40355193614959717,
0.4302072525024414,
1.276602864265442,
-0.059848200529813766,
0.16324080526828766,
-0.37750962376594543,
0.09868830442428589,
-0.48723599314689636,
0.7689081430435181,
-0.13518519699573517,
-1.021990418434143,
0.26758241653442383,
-0.1675555408000946,
-0.07110540568828583,
-0.11263757944107056,
0.8053492903709412,
-0.16524314880371094,
0.6372779607772827,
0.6572481989860535,
0.1432839035987854,
1.028115153312683,
-0.4684135913848877,
0.1546984612941742,
-0.2771666347980499,
-0.27143773436546326,
-0.03848112002015114,
-0.031176399439573288,
-0.3380957543849945,
-0.710059404373169,
0.3928213119506836,
0.17920611798763275,
-0.4309084415435791,
0.12147179245948792,
-0.012288954108953476,
0.7874065041542053,
0.08725501596927643,
-0.09543431550264359,
-0.010073680430650711,
0.3724929392337799,
-0.10247249901294708,
-0.07417707145214081,
-0.5515002608299255,
-0.2129097282886505,
0.9094608426094055,
0.15099868178367615,
0.7824556231498718,
0.24637432396411896,
0.607536256313324,
0.16257090866565704,
0.18502989411354065,
-0.5991389751434326,
0.8133572936058044,
-0.4305097162723541,
-0.1962081789970398,
-0.10565520077943802,
-0.24043987691402435,
-0.9290404915809631,
0.33477917313575745,
-0.3833375573158264,
-0.5509932041168213,
-0.3362973630428314,
0.43351924419403076,
-0.42305082082748413,
0.5536007881164551,
-0.5228379368782043,
0.9979949593544006,
-0.5118905305862427,
-0.574742317199707,
-0.15303029119968414,
-0.6443629264831543,
0.15682858228683472,
-0.08005405962467194,
0.5182531476020813,
0.19646546244621277,
0.06492948532104492,
0.5193877220153809,
-0.5737931132316589,
0.9024904370307922,
-0.26203790307044983,
-0.04356638714671135,
0.44916096329689026,
0.06243179738521576,
0.19411185383796692,
0.28988218307495117,
0.8143165111541748,
-0.017316700890660286,
-0.08292979747056961,
-0.19641779363155365,
-0.6281386613845825,
0.2886938154697418,
-0.6478897333145142,
-0.34480005502700806,
-0.11362051963806152,
-0.14370784163475037,
0.10044177621603012,
0.23053108155727386,
0.2834503650665283,
0.5968093276023865,
-0.5083763003349304,
0.44982805848121643,
0.5468878746032715,
-0.16695594787597656,
0.8950572609901428,
0.24190112948417664,
-0.6439095735549927,
-0.7683966755867004,
0.9537956118583679,
-0.3981497883796692,
0.12666165828704834,
0.6858644485473633,
-0.2885156273841858,
-0.258364737033844,
-0.5152108669281006,
-0.2692215144634247,
-0.06269394606351852,
-0.859110951423645,
-0.09553928673267365,
-0.352433979511261,
0.022905925288796425,
-0.29933756589889526,
-0.3070192039012909,
-0.5875189900398254,
-0.12581075727939606,
-0.49507105350494385,
-0.3439944386482239,
-0.10578067600727081,
0.33870646357536316,
-0.0784798413515091,
0.8117375373840332,
-0.9951526522636414,
0.6576076745986938,
0.7191989421844482,
0.24410824477672577,
-0.36607062816619873,
-0.4332057237625122,
-0.4073348641395569,
-0.23554004728794098,
-0.205756276845932,
-0.36529916524887085,
0.4277254343032837,
0.42210593819618225,
0.2847002148628235,
0.880316436290741,
-0.5642678141593933,
1.1656831502914429,
-0.6627841591835022,
1.2336708307266235,
0.8335258960723877,
-0.918119490146637,
0.29207509756088257,
-0.38029056787490845,
0.3492712676525116,
0.24755410850048065,
0.18907329440116882,
-0.317218154668808,
0.24513956904411316,
-0.40383484959602356,
-1.0004123449325562,
0.31544914841651917,
0.1470867544412613,
0.41183170676231384,
-0.04305993393063545,
0.18121054768562317,
-0.07726138085126877,
0.1757299154996872,
-1.0884246826171875,
0.05937972292304039,
-0.6873395442962646,
-0.09228809177875519,
-0.3392241597175598,
-0.17707958817481995,
-0.026949642226099968,
-0.37700626254081726,
0.0818224847316742,
-0.40338370203971863,
0.145722433924675,
-0.20320014655590057,
-0.6961602568626404,
0.11521174758672714,
0.29190918803215027,
0.7699587941169739,
0.45700690150260925,
-0.03372492268681526,
0.30690452456474304,
0.06014816835522652,
-0.6919008493423462,
0.5042796730995178,
-0.17209097743034363,
-0.005809749010950327,
-0.011129485443234444,
0.6456143856048584,
1.127536416053772,
0.46535518765449524,
-0.8079351186752319,
0.82082200050354,
-0.1718158721923828,
-0.16664515435695648,
-0.3985092043876648,
-0.24789880216121674,
-0.2839483320713043,
0.2848771810531616,
0.2413521707057953,
0.15795272588729858,
-0.3717910647392273,
-0.5003458261489868,
0.1613837331533432,
0.45369061827659607,
-0.15696118772029877,
-0.9750100374221802,
0.9263184070587158,
0.33973023295402527,
-0.23472866415977478,
0.31780916452407837,
-0.20251038670539856,
-0.48085257411003113,
0.10623472929000854,
0.3191329538822174,
0.9773837924003601,
0.056533750146627426,
0.443291574716568,
0.37575796246528625,
0.0002592426317278296,
-0.2144727110862732,
0.1948145627975464,
-0.4275110960006714,
-0.7516708374023438,
-0.8022208213806152,
-0.7060831189155579,
0.16429565846920013,
0.24260684847831726,
-0.5714025497436523,
0.22477461397647858,
-0.3334985077381134,
-0.39029476046562195,
-0.34368929266929626,
-0.5476914644241333,
-0.9036117196083069,
0.16381768882274628,
0.3483058214187622,
0.2629280686378479,
-0.736001193523407,
0.8695838451385498,
0.7780943512916565,
-0.4533195197582245,
-0.519548237323761,
0.009857199154794216,
-0.2793145775794983,
-0.6605623364448547,
1.0585353374481201,
0.12238195538520813,
-0.26519259810447693,
-0.1987961381673813,
-0.44082438945770264,
-0.6775579452514648,
1.0785164833068848,
0.8235788941383362,
-0.4932365417480469,
-0.3338242471218109,
0.458211749792099,
0.38745054602622986,
-0.2364177703857422,
0.07421361654996872,
0.22129778563976288,
0.20089936256408691,
0.2713620364665985,
-0.8008463382720947,
-0.6086137294769287,
-0.09305532276630402,
0.05140224099159241,
0.255869060754776,
-0.5400923490524292,
0.8472327589988708,
-0.23930269479751587,
-0.298728346824646,
0.004842492286115885,
0.7540252804756165,
-0.20342642068862915,
0.15494133532047272,
0.4474901556968689,
0.7034564018249512,
0.3747960031032562,
-0.10214118659496307,
0.5476918816566467,
-0.1814168393611908,
0.19379229843616486,
1.2163922786712646,
0.1151617094874382,
0.8388352990150452,
0.7488333582878113,
-0.1090339943766594,
0.32398611307144165,
0.3344751298427582,
0.26375770568847656,
0.6529151201248169,
-0.07287238538265228,
-0.4250338673591614,
-0.587736189365387,
-0.002662196522578597,
-0.31458625197410583,
0.8899956345558167,
0.2576085329055786,
-0.25518012046813965,
-0.38265329599380493,
0.19794932007789612,
-0.11486655473709106,
0.058997683227062225,
-0.6277928352355957,
0.6564264297485352,
-0.14025971293449402,
-0.44548940658569336,
0.4526940882205963,
-0.32967057824134827,
0.5343470573425293,
-0.7684471011161804,
0.10710671544075012,
-0.23513750731945038,
0.2551761567592621,
0.006603233516216278,
-0.5413051843643188,
0.03730132803320885,
0.3185807168483734,
0.05267513543367386,
-0.44404682517051697,
0.33006590604782104,
-0.6663640737533569,
-0.23960210382938385,
0.1064065471291542,
0.3409370481967926,
0.15138375759124756,
-0.030380401760339737,
-0.31562280654907227,
0.4840604066848755,
-0.08547811955213547,
-0.20455345511436462,
0.4179365038871765,
0.37649211287498474,
-0.07449958473443985,
0.5115677118301392,
0.5297979116439819,
-0.05503424257040024,
0.16806484758853912,
0.3398972153663635,
0.9119465947151184,
-0.4679183065891266,
-0.4359736144542694,
-1.0008697509765625,
0.7367520928382874,
0.24278780817985535,
0.07932771742343903,
0.41873863339424133,
0.4543159604072571,
0.8660427927970886,
-0.2566052973270416,
0.48311978578567505,
0.15029631555080414,
-0.34818539023399353,
-0.9752604961395264,
0.49830177426338196,
-0.6382240056991577,
-0.018323101103305817,
-0.4197387099266052,
-0.9474250078201294,
-0.4716893434524536,
0.3516189157962799,
0.14310353994369507,
-0.09774114191532135,
0.5972207188606262,
0.586030900478363,
-0.12625570595264435,
-0.43211159110069275,
0.4283237159252167,
0.16355891525745392,
0.6475787162780762,
0.3376973271369934,
0.7835685014724731,
-0.35211482644081116,
0.9219915866851807,
0.18741430342197418,
0.1435919851064682,
-0.0869886577129364,
-1.180219054222107,
-1.0338808298110962,
-0.7399358749389648,
-0.2262933999300003,
0.20881260931491852,
-0.042994361370801926,
0.8324815034866333,
0.8611270785331726,
-0.3117818236351013,
-0.18562625348567963,
-0.05982964485883713,
-0.364464670419693,
0.16105417907238007,
-0.10779798030853271,
0.5141032338142395,
-0.029333829879760742,
-0.5854426026344299,
0.4762478470802307,
0.42777490615844727,
0.32427769899368286,
-0.28579697012901306,
-0.32404226064682007,
0.2077307552099228,
-0.17410387098789215,
0.9906743168830872,
0.43481767177581787,
-0.5986987352371216,
-0.3605298697948456,
-0.16921775043010712,
0.4578937888145447,
0.17685049772262573,
1.256239414215088,
-0.6128595471382141,
0.6639618873596191,
0.4121842384338379,
0.5714706182479858,
1.0813982486724854,
0.09608741104602814,
0.3329693377017975,
-1.0601719617843628,
0.7761024236679077,
-0.08889881521463394,
0.564914345741272,
0.3035344183444977,
0.27484285831451416,
0.2785082161426544,
0.2667902410030365,
-0.24402371048927307,
-0.9632206559181213,
0.3748556971549988,
-1.054723858833313,
-0.1330718845129013,
0.8850340843200684,
-0.2507552206516266,
-0.1882942020893097,
0.4344812035560608,
-0.05725574865937233,
0.310472309589386,
-0.09421088546514511,
0.4059200882911682,
0.35262250900268555,
0.24919825792312622,
-0.5098069310188293,
-0.13149312138557434,
0.41376793384552,
0.15105587244033813,
-0.7445248365402222,
0.08802071213722229,
0.5675288438796997,
0.1458115428686142,
0.13330700993537903,
0.8618855476379395,
-0.1419258564710617,
0.3241153657436371,
0.03224143758416176,
0.11766967177391052,
-0.1701454520225525,
-0.602851152420044,
-0.31564733386039734,
0.3880399465560913,
-0.16918161511421204,
-0.3337578773498535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03142v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03142v2 | Less is KEN: a Universal and Simple Non-Parametric Pruning Algorithm for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T16:11:43 | 2024-06-09T10:32:03 | Michele Mastromattei, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Neural network pruning has become increasingly crucial due to the complexity
of these models and their widespread use in various fields. Existing pruning
algorithms often suffer from limitations such as architecture specificity,
excessive complexity and reliance on demanding calculations, rendering them
impractical for real-world applications. This paper introduces KEN: a
straightforward, universal and unstructured pruning algorithm based on Kernel
Density Estimation (KDE). KEN aims to construct optimized transformers by
selectively preserving the most significant parameters while restoring others
to their pre-training state. This strategy preserves model performance while
enabling storage of only the optimized subnetwork, leading to substantial
memory savings. Extensive evaluations across seven different LLMs demonstrate
that KEN achieves equal or better performance than their original unpruned
versions, with a minimum parameter reduction of 25%. Furthermore, in-depth
comparisons with established pruning and PEFT algorithms confirm KEN
effectiveness. We further introduce KEN$_{viz}$, an explainable tool that
visualizes the optimized model composition achieved by KEN from different
points of view. | [
-0.531602144241333,
-0.8067396879196167,
0.6259188652038574,
0.08296482264995575,
-0.4674709737300873,
-0.25636786222457886,
-0.5457243919372559,
-0.03811994940042496,
0.6035370230674744,
0.41067567467689514,
-0.7610751986503601,
-0.6279016733169556,
-0.32586604356765747,
-0.27490636706352234,
-0.5116685032844543,
0.6425462365150452,
0.231089785695076,
-0.35024315118789673,
-0.3316648602485657,
-0.22799646854400635,
-0.3062928318977356,
-0.11435108631849289,
-0.5311479568481445,
-0.3781750798225403,
0.6842634081840515,
0.7328712344169617,
0.2836698293685913,
0.4797671139240265,
0.31254562735557556,
0.3203064501285553,
-0.24692970514297485,
-0.08648224174976349,
-0.6337876915931702,
0.25589436292648315,
0.45621851086616516,
-0.4698862135410309,
-0.12585186958312988,
-0.23262882232666016,
0.7838980555534363,
0.9291636943817139,
-0.41420790553092957,
0.17868748307228088,
0.003449207404628396,
1.0415468215942383,
-0.9437312483787537,
0.000050807910156436265,
-0.7031605839729309,
0.1687726080417633,
-0.021238991990685463,
0.11030665040016174,
-0.361092746257782,
-0.09154809266328812,
0.06895172595977783,
-0.7452433109283447,
0.1556439995765686,
-0.38960352540016174,
0.907792329788208,
0.28628265857696533,
-0.29682374000549316,
0.4624437391757965,
-0.9087692499160767,
1.2589035034179688,
-0.7844823002815247,
0.7673314809799194,
0.16676545143127441,
0.4489165246486664,
0.0547664612531662,
-0.7043807506561279,
-0.5460442900657654,
-0.25249361991882324,
0.10653141885995865,
0.30924996733665466,
-0.18566292524337769,
0.30573078989982605,
0.08204621076583862,
0.051947567611932755,
-0.2544861435890198,
0.15776431560516357,
-0.45868194103240967,
-0.20261980593204498,
0.5830527544021606,
-0.017231235280632973,
-0.0798996239900589,
-0.22998309135437012,
-0.2197788655757904,
-0.43934765458106995,
-0.6292440891265869,
0.09535084664821625,
0.4363950788974762,
-0.025604337453842163,
-0.02790205366909504,
0.4155885875225067,
-0.18781201541423798,
0.627549409866333,
-0.21256287395954132,
-0.33603644371032715,
-0.24137239158153534,
0.061693303287029266,
-0.46293601393699646,
-0.00723994430154562,
0.8425659537315369,
0.5538106560707092,
0.46480220556259155,
-0.20951275527477264,
-0.0007929125567898154,
0.18462145328521729,
0.5053059458732605,
-0.5667796730995178,
-0.7125293612480164,
-0.1072193905711174,
-0.7420135736465454,
-0.5009145736694336,
-0.10802286863327026,
-0.8540326356887817,
-0.14539022743701935,
-0.40295082330703735,
0.029808437451720238,
-0.3211817145347595,
-0.36491817235946655,
-0.10803055018186569,
0.009736938402056694,
0.15817053616046906,
0.5009490251541138,
-0.6486769318580627,
0.29846298694610596,
0.7519203424453735,
0.757172167301178,
0.1677805781364441,
-0.008640569634735584,
-0.33760228753089905,
0.03288775682449341,
-0.6206175088882446,
0.32067328691482544,
-0.6048551797866821,
-0.359211266040802,
-0.3836618661880493,
-0.060665808618068695,
0.12671220302581787,
-0.37917762994766235,
0.7737141251564026,
-0.4128556549549103,
-0.37630587816238403,
-0.3616728186607361,
-0.4536155164241791,
-0.634775698184967,
0.20600618422031403,
-0.7626705169677734,
0.89597088098526,
0.15055176615715027,
-0.6365396976470947,
0.2389131784439087,
-0.40887534618377686,
-0.36618030071258545,
0.030847836285829544,
-0.07932548969984055,
-0.6507018804550171,
0.6710512042045593,
0.1451444774866104,
0.5752694010734558,
-0.2538440227508545,
0.4481324851512909,
-0.3901601731777191,
-0.16170500218868256,
-0.36770981550216675,
-0.4207986891269684,
0.5839705467224121,
0.22236138582229614,
0.04444783926010132,
0.14894692599773407,
-0.8610104918479919,
0.11912654340267181,
0.27426645159721375,
-0.5109198093414307,
-0.6434441208839417,
0.2082781195640564,
0.1020694151520729,
-0.07534875720739365,
0.06272105872631073,
-1.066692590713501,
0.02278813160955906,
-0.5547057390213013,
0.7742305994033813,
0.7369128465652466,
-0.07170112431049347,
0.7845581769943237,
-0.2200535088777542,
0.5713412165641785,
0.05342629924416542,
0.32909658551216125,
0.11635243147611618,
-0.46616214513778687,
-1.1526011228561401,
0.06138359755277634,
0.5940582156181335,
0.24724316596984863,
-0.45628541707992554,
0.43226978182792664,
-0.5433880090713501,
-0.6447388529777527,
-0.5288191437721252,
0.480594664812088,
0.15219596028327942,
0.8857949376106262,
0.11344847083091736,
-0.37028270959854126,
-0.6709020137786865,
-1.5040873289108276,
0.17941570281982422,
-0.2923261821269989,
0.07757803052663803,
0.35151734948158264,
0.16934438049793243,
-0.054917093366384506,
0.9669697880744934,
-0.3200593590736389,
-0.166193887591362,
-0.4590356647968292,
-0.14860326051712036,
0.22895213961601257,
0.5638805627822876,
0.17531119287014008,
-0.6047762632369995,
-0.8046936988830566,
0.2067296802997589,
-0.5742266774177551,
0.26794126629829407,
-0.1964181363582611,
-0.0024099242873489857,
-0.06433884054422379,
0.5646304488182068,
-0.6021966338157654,
0.2721163034439087,
0.5065708756446838,
0.34292617440223694,
0.5274161100387573,
-0.30037349462509155,
-0.6520383358001709,
-0.6937282681465149,
0.19926616549491882,
0.2982345223426819,
-0.37466496229171753,
-0.6678581833839417,
0.05774267390370369,
0.34107327461242676,
-0.27174636721611023,
-0.2958712577819824,
0.2943710684776306,
-0.3178008198738098,
-0.0509796068072319,
0.03357047587633133,
-0.30293190479278564,
0.1893898844718933,
0.7105638980865479,
-0.020632151514291763,
0.5597715377807617,
0.38200074434280396,
-0.6684985160827637,
0.1866127848625183,
0.2505433261394501,
-0.7912828922271729,
0.4492943584918976,
-0.6584575772285461,
-0.021401019766926765,
-0.46760979294776917,
0.14397935569286346,
-0.7589346170425415,
0.057436972856521606,
0.01916773058474064,
-0.12788403034210205,
0.4089865982532501,
-0.36773011088371277,
-0.26625877618789673,
-0.2508851885795593,
-0.38346385955810547,
0.005507725290954113,
0.9130808711051941,
-0.42148083448410034,
0.5882395505905151,
0.4573286175727844,
-0.21627506613731384,
-0.2710716724395752,
-0.5733223557472229,
0.15928050875663757,
-0.3428349792957306,
-0.8256096839904785,
0.4430799186229706,
-0.11623485386371613,
-0.20157429575920105,
0.06426942348480225,
-0.4146275222301483,
-0.30936551094055176,
0.33013954758644104,
0.06416743248701096,
0.06702416390180588,
-0.4061190187931061,
-0.023001737892627716,
0.27038344740867615,
-0.30400583148002625,
-0.07551360130310059,
-0.10720431059598923,
0.4039233326911926,
0.16604584455490112,
-0.23984664678573608,
-0.6745357513427734,
0.4388573467731476,
0.5458848476409912,
0.036248959600925446,
0.4962030351161957,
0.4500008225440979,
-0.022636929526925087,
-0.5276374220848083,
-0.5379207134246826,
-0.33421021699905396,
-0.5523809194564819,
0.49383285641670227,
-0.3286002576351166,
-0.6317874193191528,
0.3332473933696747,
-0.23971663415431976,
0.2894997298717499,
0.34811845421791077,
0.08622951060533524,
-0.41544580459594727,
1.1592001914978027,
0.7142403721809387,
-0.16032561659812927,
0.3810514211654663,
-0.5190091729164124,
0.36619219183921814,
-1.0825939178466797,
-0.11517191678285599,
-0.2486724704504013,
-1.0896642208099365,
-0.2719326615333557,
-0.06494691967964172,
0.4193764925003052,
0.3087407648563385,
0.057910289615392685,
0.39951077103614807,
-0.8970959186553955,
0.7698534727096558,
0.8988932967185974,
-0.15833377838134766,
-0.04303247109055519,
0.2630620002746582,
-0.2596789598464966,
-0.30362629890441895,
-1.0336823463439941,
-0.16328762471675873,
1.20159912109375,
0.3827633559703827,
0.7153401970863342,
-0.27590733766555786,
0.7628002762794495,
-0.08819771558046341,
0.21877111494541168,
-0.9567263722419739,
0.7386177182197571,
-0.24117065966129303,
-0.40190064907073975,
-0.3778584599494934,
-0.5902394652366638,
-0.9627480506896973,
0.05667298287153244,
-0.010105053894221783,
-0.7399678230285645,
0.41927531361579895,
0.161025732755661,
-0.4778361916542053,
0.5377054214477539,
-0.8949511647224426,
0.511204183101654,
0.025557417422533035,
0.052787698805332184,
-0.09574553370475769,
-0.6409786939620972,
0.5671347975730896,
-0.20157626271247864,
-0.12742280960083008,
-0.14922644197940826,
0.097439706325531,
0.9169324040412903,
-0.7237796187400818,
0.6616005897521973,
-0.47399869561195374,
-0.01853223703801632,
0.1570434272289276,
0.3457213342189789,
0.8195510506629944,
-0.07424131035804749,
0.1645727902650833,
0.20402246713638306,
0.12815415859222412,
-0.15184266865253448,
-0.72048020362854,
1.1606189012527466,
-0.7685916423797607,
-0.4106787145137787,
0.35109642148017883,
-0.5617055892944336,
-0.20715543627738953,
-0.0792509987950325,
0.10470809042453766,
0.27798992395401,
-0.07768670469522476,
0.614424467086792,
0.6547025442123413,
-0.46138864755630493,
0.6496577858924866,
0.35598281025886536,
0.23124480247497559,
-0.45597395300865173,
1.388104796409607,
0.43904373049736023,
-0.030521368607878685,
0.5222513675689697,
0.31976261734962463,
-0.24323676526546478,
-0.5874505043029785,
-0.11363724619150162,
0.3324087858200073,
-0.7526547908782959,
-0.1888219118118286,
-0.7266281247138977,
-0.237730473279953,
-0.11990930140018463,
-0.41870981454849243,
-0.5581628680229187,
-0.7289940714836121,
0.1718979775905609,
-0.051592033356428146,
0.30357858538627625,
0.5081512928009033,
-0.1060752123594284,
0.8819057941436768,
-0.6459174156188965,
0.2365630865097046,
0.6329030990600586,
0.4718383550643921,
0.29803499579429626,
0.12378185987472534,
0.0223722942173481,
-0.017967751249670982,
-0.3355235159397125,
-0.5565088391304016,
0.5720486044883728,
0.45664525032043457,
0.2979702055454254,
0.6385274529457092,
0.2228745073080063,
0.7239227294921875,
-0.4449107348918915,
0.42231711745262146,
0.5652495622634888,
-0.5996547341346741,
0.2869264781475067,
-0.16351287066936493,
0.2969733476638794,
0.9716383814811707,
-0.1381087601184845,
-0.7590756416320801,
-0.027791891247034073,
-0.9040257334709167,
-0.9831769466400146,
0.8336834907531738,
0.27304187417030334,
0.23602990806102753,
0.11179559677839279,
0.15160655975341797,
0.11952820420265198,
0.19308306276798248,
-0.5797221064567566,
-0.45780640840530396,
-0.0765327587723732,
-0.48484885692596436,
-0.1700962483882904,
-0.5475386381149292,
-0.0681939572095871,
-0.6062378883361816,
0.8571821451187134,
0.23295941948890686,
0.47871389985084534,
0.06872742623090744,
-0.2739414870738983,
-0.04224921762943268,
0.11522475630044937,
0.5703045129776001,
0.4914328455924988,
-0.3284679353237152,
0.135995551943779,
0.10346189886331558,
-0.5174047350883484,
0.1281803399324417,
-0.1848500669002533,
-0.5839779376983643,
0.4174036979675293,
0.07107415050268173,
0.8598776459693909,
0.31993839144706726,
-0.4791349768638611,
0.497329980134964,
-0.17188911139965057,
-0.6687563061714172,
-0.3832670748233795,
0.07384134083986282,
0.20750753581523895,
-0.07632289081811905,
0.02259024977684021,
0.05240092799067497,
-0.18853439390659332,
0.20917187631130219,
0.04865860939025879,
0.509551465511322,
-0.5999625325202942,
-0.4488370716571808,
0.5687370300292969,
0.4579198658466339,
-0.3538462519645691,
0.844338595867157,
0.13340641558170319,
-0.2073039561510086,
0.7609715461730957,
0.1514660120010376,
0.899052619934082,
-0.0007780459709465504,
0.42144089937210083,
0.353371262550354,
0.5642820596694946,
0.09974616020917892,
0.20100921392440796,
-0.5438404083251953,
-0.679658055305481,
-0.7850586175918579,
-0.977448582649231,
0.07722391933202744,
0.6756349802017212,
-0.45514965057373047,
0.05950305238366127,
-0.9768546223640442,
-0.07791555672883987,
0.18224479258060455,
0.02843637205660343,
-0.6129066944122314,
0.007244899403303862,
-0.15998360514640808,
1.0521107912063599,
-0.8130194544792175,
0.998944878578186,
0.5795571208000183,
-0.03440718352794647,
-0.7901275753974915,
-0.537801206111908,
-0.1778385490179062,
-0.6922309994697571,
0.6235501170158386,
0.1704460233449936,
0.5444014668464661,
0.5228779315948486,
-0.559832751750946,
-0.7956973910331726,
0.9066675305366516,
0.6927149295806885,
-1.1638883352279663,
-0.08724252134561539,
-0.061254970729351044,
-0.1509120911359787,
0.17246611416339874,
-0.11056048423051834,
0.501843273639679,
0.8462867140769958,
-0.07488417625427246,
-0.6104872822761536,
-0.30644282698631287,
-0.44661664962768555,
0.09907183796167374,
0.9650249481201172,
-0.3748341202735901,
0.6235196590423584,
0.29923713207244873,
-0.30527520179748535,
0.058991771191358566,
0.3214402198791504,
-0.03066464327275753,
-0.0003161212080158293,
0.8399388194084167,
1.1548219919204712,
0.45255202054977417,
0.03265762701630592,
1.1000336408615112,
-0.3566346764564514,
0.17733733355998993,
0.8344326615333557,
-0.11281481385231018,
0.4343456029891968,
0.7913366556167603,
-0.3157537281513214,
0.29775097966194153,
0.3551984131336212,
0.008841194212436676,
0.7523996233940125,
0.07192141562700272,
-0.264978289604187,
-0.606764018535614,
-0.1133328303694725,
-0.09730719774961472,
0.3619925081729889,
0.12200788408517838,
-0.267183780670166,
-0.7188101410865784,
-0.07057345658540726,
0.05350128188729286,
-0.09944760799407959,
-0.13167335093021393,
0.7647132277488708,
0.29664546251296997,
-0.5685396790504456,
0.6632969975471497,
0.46192067861557007,
0.5658072233200073,
-0.8292595744132996,
0.0911203920841217,
-0.28752627968788147,
0.12234475463628769,
0.1305713802576065,
-0.12828046083450317,
0.3536771833896637,
-0.28753748536109924,
-0.31614622473716736,
-0.44568607211112976,
0.8712978959083557,
-0.1857171505689621,
-0.815657377243042,
0.10134723782539368,
0.22886109352111816,
0.06224382668733597,
-0.1752627193927765,
-0.7829965353012085,
0.046116989105939865,
0.08242826163768768,
-0.18088671565055847,
0.425732284784317,
0.15082912147045135,
-0.05973628908395767,
0.7000570297241211,
0.9097622036933899,
0.2915692627429962,
0.03609583154320717,
-0.08441581577062607,
0.7924230694770813,
-0.42385217547416687,
-0.5186521410942078,
-0.7143973708152771,
0.5217717289924622,
-0.13323314487934113,
-0.26589885354042053,
0.6293165683746338,
0.4086807370185852,
0.594496488571167,
0.09596647322177887,
0.6170060038566589,
0.19353744387626648,
0.32915377616882324,
-0.30583953857421875,
0.844879150390625,
-0.6266554594039917,
0.08706191927194595,
-0.11503022909164429,
-1.2775901556015015,
-0.023808471858501434,
0.8923292756080627,
-0.20485538244247437,
-0.18810251355171204,
0.4496610760688782,
0.6804252862930298,
-0.5821272134780884,
-0.09028524905443192,
0.6571663618087769,
0.2028827965259552,
0.14551293849945068,
0.4929440915584564,
0.5484602451324463,
-0.15045814216136932,
0.519515872001648,
-0.8679875731468201,
0.22599424421787262,
0.02954249642789364,
-0.7362825870513916,
-0.5195654034614563,
-0.5230355262756348,
-0.3820599317550659,
0.22548434138298035,
-0.24422107636928558,
0.4298000931739807,
1.2110639810562134,
-0.6405422687530518,
-0.0845043882727623,
-0.6733798384666443,
0.10801373422145844,
-0.14182785153388977,
-0.2086532562971115,
0.2227145880460739,
-0.1570320576429367,
-0.49596133828163147,
0.8954662084579468,
0.3507351577281952,
-0.24583043158054352,
-0.4095665514469147,
-0.3026905357837677,
-0.1906801462173462,
0.01590782403945923,
0.48239192366600037,
0.37152475118637085,
-0.6176824569702148,
-0.04101923853158951,
-0.15355385839939117,
0.37631475925445557,
0.1205584928393364,
0.6653676629066467,
-1.00911283493042,
0.5763747096061707,
0.497690349817276,
0.7876455783843994,
0.6040185689926147,
-0.04602552577853203,
0.7207414507865906,
-1.2649223804473877,
0.2840169370174408,
0.38825929164886475,
0.37734749913215637,
0.19909097254276276,
0.025760704651474953,
0.2312229424715042,
0.22152823209762573,
-0.2836189866065979,
-1.0527890920639038,
0.3888646960258484,
-0.857352077960968,
-0.40913838148117065,
1.009526014328003,
0.1505313217639923,
-0.5991556644439697,
-0.017231304198503494,
0.060683537274599075,
0.01504223421216011,
-0.4629164934158325,
0.5918623805046082,
0.6477599143981934,
0.5819608569145203,
-0.48863619565963745,
-0.853740394115448,
0.3035784661769867,
0.7802481651306152,
-0.3308786451816559,
-0.14424842596054077,
0.3078896105289459,
0.244953915476799,
0.008689358830451965,
0.3969281315803528,
0.25856295228004456,
-0.06569130718708038,
-0.2562634348869324,
0.05459652468562126,
-0.34455519914627075,
-0.5890584588050842,
-0.3177487552165985,
0.2986299693584442,
0.006900324020534754,
-0.20924967527389526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03137v1 | Sociolinguistically Informed Interpretability: A Case Study on Hinglish Emotion Classification | 2024-02-05T16:05:32 | 2024-02-05T16:05:32 | Kushal Tatariya, Heather Lent, Johannes Bjerva, Miryam de Lhoneux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Emotion classification is a challenging task in NLP due to the inherent
idiosyncratic and subjective nature of linguistic expression, especially with
code-mixed data. Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have achieved high
performance for many tasks and languages, but it remains to be seen whether
these models learn and are robust to the differences in emotional expression
across languages. Sociolinguistic studies have shown that Hinglish speakers
switch to Hindi when expressing negative emotions and to English when
expressing positive emotions. To understand if language models can learn these
associations, we study the effect of language on emotion prediction across 3
PLMs on a Hinglish emotion classification dataset. Using LIME and token level
language ID, we find that models do learn these associations between language
choice and emotional expression. Moreover, having code-mixed data present in
the pre-training can augment that learning when task-specific data is scarce.
We also conclude from the misclassifications that the models may overgeneralise
this heuristic to other infrequent examples where this sociolinguistic
phenomenon does not apply. | [
-0.11802847683429718,
-0.45009538531303406,
0.3225724399089813,
0.5769752264022827,
-0.08411332964897156,
0.3798788785934448,
-0.3813284933567047,
-0.8437849283218384,
0.13725414872169495,
0.34035947918891907,
-0.16150452196598053,
-0.42047223448753357,
-0.7289189100265503,
0.11074452102184296,
0.08808793872594833,
0.8565186262130737,
0.024073036387562752,
0.09945090860128403,
0.05645088478922844,
-0.4544367790222168,
-0.3820238411426544,
-0.9028469324111938,
-0.5347614288330078,
-0.5927127599716187,
0.531738817691803,
0.41879504919052124,
0.7208480834960938,
0.1734735518693924,
0.3218129277229309,
0.21216310560703278,
-0.2662038505077362,
-0.2470589280128479,
-0.5544442534446716,
0.041056327521800995,
-0.16968269646167755,
-0.7311480641365051,
-0.24209243059158325,
0.20165911316871643,
0.16789071261882782,
0.575133204460144,
-0.2749646008014679,
0.13092371821403503,
0.179690420627594,
0.8362765908241272,
-0.7192670702934265,
0.5195705890655518,
-0.4805431365966797,
0.267465204000473,
-0.2286517322063446,
-0.26773181557655334,
-0.5074118375778198,
-0.2933160364627838,
0.35314688086509705,
-0.3424831032752991,
-0.23988699913024902,
0.10645128041505814,
0.8870633244514465,
0.25708454847335815,
-0.492116779088974,
-0.3890094757080078,
-0.6734863519668579,
0.6725829839706421,
-0.7324651479721069,
0.4030960500240326,
0.5098283886909485,
0.31555330753326416,
0.4177352786064148,
-0.2591438889503479,
-0.5321571230888367,
-0.05942405387759209,
-0.3151683807373047,
0.3744099736213684,
-0.020066028460860252,
0.2450595498085022,
0.2194187343120575,
0.22205276787281036,
-0.5957445502281189,
0.16504187881946564,
-0.24219629168510437,
-0.05843951180577278,
0.6747770309448242,
-0.03467675298452377,
0.33403512835502625,
-0.8415831923484802,
-0.18839587271213531,
0.30145952105522156,
-0.7708442807197571,
0.14901641011238098,
0.5061408281326294,
0.29950112104415894,
-0.5066121220588684,
0.5112012624740601,
-0.025754040107131004,
0.45959508419036865,
0.14472654461860657,
-0.05799631029367447,
0.4714711904525757,
0.17934085428714752,
-0.17006410658359528,
0.2770337164402008,
0.5451491475105286,
0.30628910660743713,
0.7412379384040833,
0.034124381840229034,
-0.014471620321273804,
0.4497222900390625,
0.05583859607577324,
-0.6110740900039673,
-0.1875283420085907,
0.32539132237434387,
-0.6210049390792847,
-0.2804652452468872,
-0.23299159109592438,
-1.0241105556488037,
-0.6146461367607117,
-0.23680463433265686,
0.3196963369846344,
-0.30677032470703125,
-0.650701105594635,
0.3391382098197937,
0.10693974047899246,
0.13942588865756989,
0.015524080954492092,
-0.7878307104110718,
0.040985092520713806,
0.4437108039855957,
0.5605365037918091,
0.016048841178417206,
-0.41211366653442383,
-0.16319289803504944,
-0.10830090939998627,
-0.24873043596744537,
0.5178699493408203,
-0.6802527904510498,
-0.23715859651565552,
0.20942579209804535,
0.030426595360040665,
-0.32090309262275696,
-0.6284294724464417,
0.28968390822410583,
-0.4558987617492676,
0.19742842018604279,
0.013181118294596672,
-0.42991921305656433,
-0.24641117453575134,
0.01217668130993843,
-0.49707654118537903,
1.0396606922149658,
0.21110862493515015,
-0.7788117527961731,
0.4674428701400757,
-0.44484609365463257,
-0.759373664855957,
0.1691032499074936,
0.01660483330488205,
-0.23967303335666656,
0.22089791297912598,
-0.2753579020500183,
0.6349220871925354,
0.016678432002663612,
0.42620566487312317,
-0.42389458417892456,
-0.2630106508731842,
0.13172771036624908,
0.019131192937493324,
0.5858008861541748,
0.37892529368400574,
-0.4937939941883087,
0.012720038183033466,
-0.8140429258346558,
-0.050421494990587234,
0.09275630861520767,
-0.43188777565956116,
-0.5017809271812439,
0.13328517973423004,
-0.0861932784318924,
0.5785030722618103,
0.20675088465213776,
-0.3349977731704712,
-0.1990959495306015,
-0.6407841444015503,
0.15597869455814362,
0.6625634431838989,
-0.03147413954138756,
0.42620915174484253,
-0.032341647893190384,
0.9270431399345398,
0.09880182892084122,
0.05790301039814949,
0.20123307406902313,
-0.5206770300865173,
-0.6544268131256104,
0.04682181030511856,
0.16049864888191223,
0.6955283284187317,
-0.8059118986129761,
0.2805050313472748,
0.11250211298465729,
-0.43521201610565186,
-0.8929728269577026,
-0.03004264272749424,
0.4199548661708832,
0.34265169501304626,
0.22236180305480957,
-0.11489164084196091,
-0.796508252620697,
-0.598761260509491,
-0.5541951060295105,
-0.43161913752555847,
0.24322988092899323,
0.556780219078064,
0.15841837227344513,
-0.24897810816764832,
0.6890879273414612,
-0.28387588262557983,
0.1022525206208229,
-0.6652427315711975,
0.5996052622795105,
0.08886393159627914,
0.14837409555912018,
0.6410942673683167,
-0.8684221506118774,
-0.8514115810394287,
0.18462635576725006,
-0.7571485638618469,
-0.3865583539009094,
-0.16521908342838287,
-0.09203937649726868,
0.4426560401916504,
0.22367875277996063,
-0.58535236120224,
0.6055733561515808,
0.6806753873825073,
-0.3582966923713684,
0.6571685075759888,
-0.09566592425107956,
0.15387949347496033,
-1.0697672367095947,
-0.24794024229049683,
0.12757036089897156,
0.08719952404499054,
-0.6467440128326416,
-0.05209188535809517,
0.10436464846134186,
-0.14166156947612762,
-0.5488578081130981,
0.5939218997955322,
-0.552004873752594,
-0.14223918318748474,
-0.24650093913078308,
-0.0869501605629921,
-0.11612268537282944,
0.5183623433113098,
0.4367736279964447,
0.37949371337890625,
0.7773816585540771,
-0.47962242364883423,
0.10433997213840485,
0.1131744459271431,
-0.4456430673599243,
0.45961910486221313,
-0.4550583064556122,
-0.0981733500957489,
-0.3787495791912079,
-0.22454284131526947,
-0.7828378677368164,
-0.43224257230758667,
0.06267274916172028,
-0.4234327971935272,
0.39010047912597656,
-0.3180462121963501,
-0.2573202848434448,
-0.06196759641170502,
0.12026873230934143,
0.15696945786476135,
0.7420443296432495,
-0.6564841866493225,
0.6560238599777222,
0.42983123660087585,
-0.3977113962173462,
-0.5271701216697693,
-0.6042687296867371,
0.07775215059518814,
-0.49899810552597046,
-0.2939893305301666,
-0.15149854123592377,
-0.090456023812294,
-0.4315476715564728,
-0.18388819694519043,
0.013483408838510513,
-0.18678800761699677,
0.27366673946380615,
0.47007524967193604,
0.17816513776779175,
-0.1319475919008255,
0.3966527283191681,
-0.24196229875087738,
-0.008677969686686993,
0.26363351941108704,
0.2868990898132324,
0.6550732851028442,
-0.16300253570079803,
-0.2550608515739441,
-0.06788339465856552,
0.3107233941555023,
0.5055006742477417,
-0.41989806294441223,
0.8572071194648743,
0.565182626247406,
-0.4165024757385254,
-0.18628063797950745,
-0.2291851043701172,
0.25563865900039673,
-0.4177580773830414,
0.42667001485824585,
-0.38744327425956726,
-0.7104100584983826,
0.5165688395500183,
-0.04847246780991554,
-0.4218885004520416,
0.4396454393863678,
0.5357336401939392,
-0.2825746238231659,
1.2878003120422363,
0.7567468285560608,
-0.21815969049930573,
0.6108769774436951,
0.17849813401699066,
0.5949167609214783,
-0.3088635802268982,
0.021268868818879128,
-0.593847393989563,
-0.14334742724895477,
-0.9217764735221863,
0.07834363728761673,
0.22170495986938477,
0.11259804666042328,
0.05172952264547348,
0.05362588167190552,
-0.2661493122577667,
0.47961685061454773,
0.03233547881245613,
0.16554899513721466,
-0.11021117866039276,
-0.16779743134975433,
0.26729708909988403,
-0.1858985871076584,
-0.6889604926109314,
-0.42403167486190796,
0.8229964971542358,
0.4129679799079895,
0.8523730635643005,
0.1971636414527893,
0.8797856569290161,
0.00575780076906085,
0.6221497058868408,
-0.9142681956291199,
0.33721476793289185,
-0.004629909992218018,
-0.5870367288589478,
-0.05377431586384773,
-0.4752160608768463,
-0.8605791926383972,
0.036663684993982315,
-0.3324020206928253,
-0.7866978049278259,
0.30885350704193115,
0.13631181418895721,
-0.25580310821533203,
-0.0686647817492485,
-1.0432487726211548,
0.9490239024162292,
-0.3894599378108978,
-0.30769234895706177,
-0.3701581358909607,
-0.8490341305732727,
0.1582941710948944,
-0.26474013924598694,
0.5130714774131775,
-0.13618029654026031,
0.4988514482975006,
0.7352883815765381,
-0.0911615863442421,
1.0582880973815918,
-0.3461413085460663,
-0.0075880433432757854,
0.25091853737831116,
0.021955063566565514,
0.23177318274974823,
-0.16251255571842194,
-0.38522255420684814,
0.1219094842672348,
0.029648490250110626,
-0.45726102590560913,
-0.7513982653617859,
0.2554517984390259,
-0.6779350638389587,
-0.5630807876586914,
-0.4254266917705536,
-0.3768962323665619,
-0.37480753660202026,
-0.002785073360428214,
0.2549951672554016,
0.18216080963611603,
-0.02821141481399536,
0.05607886612415314,
0.36560019850730896,
-0.32969558238983154,
0.17181845009326935,
0.5759894251823425,
-0.2808443605899811,
0.15247321128845215,
0.9162374138832092,
0.21181747317314148,
0.3703747093677521,
0.19325639307498932,
0.5089727640151978,
-0.15879803895950317,
-0.4015171229839325,
-0.06293531507253647,
0.15055878460407257,
-0.8708385229110718,
0.17352157831192017,
-0.4549773037433624,
-0.10126685351133347,
-0.42995917797088623,
-0.23907622694969177,
-0.15616045892238617,
-0.3408089578151703,
-0.3330344557762146,
-0.36459705233573914,
0.2679170072078705,
1.097643256187439,
-0.12269827723503113,
0.3124368488788605,
-0.8474389314651489,
0.2042362242937088,
0.1301468163728714,
0.44784805178642273,
0.011357615701854229,
-0.5551249384880066,
-0.48385727405548096,
-0.06323399394750595,
0.13334637880325317,
-1.307083010673523,
0.7474029064178467,
0.34131383895874023,
0.42791280150413513,
0.4097990095615387,
0.07690457999706268,
0.564235270023346,
-0.18923503160476685,
0.6685164570808411,
0.03397072106599808,
-0.9614747166633606,
0.5476035475730896,
-0.16548290848731995,
0.2819127142429352,
0.42554154992103577,
0.7804738879203796,
-0.6931101679801941,
-0.28387895226478577,
-0.6616522073745728,
-0.7749863862991333,
0.449678510427475,
-0.31974565982818604,
0.00010559832298895344,
-0.1468845009803772,
0.41564318537712097,
0.268181711435318,
0.31348398327827454,
-1.007776141166687,
-0.0790327787399292,
-0.21453912556171417,
-0.5796945691108704,
-0.45581430196762085,
-0.4671383500099182,
0.2226167768239975,
-0.2808602452278137,
0.48726457357406616,
-0.1814134418964386,
0.016757385805249214,
-0.10048802196979523,
-0.4517723619937897,
-0.23721566796302795,
0.5539674162864685,
0.09626657515764236,
0.42791005969047546,
-0.3613947629928589,
0.3354963958263397,
-0.08531911671161652,
-0.2128104567527771,
0.06207604333758354,
-0.016416477039456367,
0.29407161474227905,
-0.046957120299339294,
0.4885598421096802,
0.9476335048675537,
0.361608624458313,
-0.7039022445678711,
0.4486747682094574,
0.17083008587360382,
0.05245336517691612,
-0.021410347893834114,
-0.2552536427974701,
0.14512649178504944,
0.2085498869419098,
-0.05257994309067726,
0.15740923583507538,
0.22884204983711243,
-0.9070428013801575,
-0.04471588134765625,
0.046164870262145996,
-0.43139034509658813,
-0.5752815008163452,
0.3302684426307678,
0.1388946920633316,
-0.34748682379722595,
0.29714077711105347,
-0.3324645459651947,
-0.9523699283599854,
0.5220708250999451,
0.38682788610458374,
0.9361769556999207,
-0.5746389627456665,
0.33996644616127014,
0.1606406420469284,
0.20876768231391907,
0.08234275877475739,
0.6452957987785339,
0.02240953966975212,
-0.9351614713668823,
-0.41174042224884033,
-0.6540642380714417,
-0.4818080961704254,
-0.2513340413570404,
-1.0066756010055542,
0.031431060284376144,
-0.22605904936790466,
0.0009098947048187256,
-0.030882565304636955,
-0.23253005743026733,
-0.8081781268119812,
0.47869160771369934,
0.1443852037191391,
0.6125752329826355,
-1.2884422540664673,
0.8198463916778564,
0.8178926706314087,
-0.24965263903141022,
-0.9622613787651062,
-0.013993836008012295,
-0.01833992823958397,
-0.7174492478370667,
0.8991798758506775,
0.2847679555416107,
-0.027322376146912575,
-0.2592476010322571,
-0.5178307294845581,
-0.5966718792915344,
0.3745812475681305,
0.1091926097869873,
-0.2052784264087677,
0.09395858645439148,
0.1517161726951599,
1.029377818107605,
-0.38710054755210876,
0.17742480337619781,
0.595634400844574,
0.3976745903491974,
-0.10298920422792435,
-0.8691675662994385,
-0.3243005573749542,
-0.3672432601451874,
-0.39935189485549927,
-0.0019818178843706846,
-0.43210628628730774,
0.7995894551277161,
-0.16971054673194885,
-0.45969676971435547,
-0.32803240418434143,
0.4491095542907715,
-0.017719119787216187,
0.4856793284416199,
0.5932042598724365,
0.2726956605911255,
0.7171596884727478,
0.0035573462955653667,
1.0512930154800415,
-0.4534333348274231,
0.3714081645011902,
1.0089470148086548,
-0.8131797313690186,
1.0611941814422607,
0.5118443965911865,
-0.21019667387008667,
0.47529956698417664,
1.0960029363632202,
0.5078577995300293,
0.5854261517524719,
0.0593695230782032,
-0.2015611231327057,
-0.3206241726875305,
-0.22581109404563904,
-0.04307689517736435,
0.5795052647590637,
0.433862566947937,
-0.11901836842298508,
0.04168016463518143,
0.1188020333647728,
-0.0814066231250763,
0.09841296076774597,
-0.24138760566711426,
0.757197380065918,
0.08841034770011902,
-0.5331743955612183,
0.5650690793991089,
-0.37260550260543823,
0.7914513349533081,
-0.47529104351997375,
-0.09117969125509262,
-0.05863442271947861,
-0.04639342799782753,
-0.6019218564033508,
-0.8592720627784729,
0.44157838821411133,
-0.054807793349027634,
-0.04075418785214424,
-0.4114888608455658,
0.9431959390640259,
-0.6323385834693909,
-0.1412467062473297,
0.6210651397705078,
0.6900666952133179,
0.26079654693603516,
-0.01023969054222107,
-0.5294935703277588,
-0.18178674578666687,
0.04838673397898674,
-0.45119985938072205,
0.394398957490921,
0.5283294916152954,
0.04624079912900925,
0.6738525032997131,
0.19796784222126007,
0.336004376411438,
0.0011455175699666142,
0.21304483711719513,
0.39881834387779236,
-0.5779361724853516,
-0.6273911595344543,
-0.6515880227088928,
0.5155459046363831,
0.14676086604595184,
-0.18730328977108002,
0.6793756484985352,
0.2174673229455948,
0.7586010694503784,
-0.1671167016029358,
1.0362603664398193,
0.012076673097908497,
0.6531861424446106,
-0.5865195989608765,
0.6088677644729614,
-0.6352938413619995,
0.04410065338015556,
-0.35120657086372375,
-0.5664359927177429,
-0.052214913070201874,
0.7070710062980652,
-0.6543999910354614,
0.09394355118274689,
0.6625638604164124,
0.5700110793113708,
0.2795799672603607,
0.2848270535469055,
0.4569486975669861,
0.5033161044120789,
-0.13863082230091095,
0.39548712968826294,
1.0731209516525269,
0.19293241202831268,
0.11582624912261963,
-0.3205640912055969,
-0.3264627456665039,
-0.14045517146587372,
-0.805995762348175,
-0.7895494103431702,
-0.4027443826198578,
-0.3087022602558136,
-0.4242193400859833,
0.09222082793712616,
0.9205309152603149,
0.5841835141181946,
-0.6916893124580383,
-0.3490142822265625,
0.2634955942630768,
0.29430246353149414,
0.001036492525599897,
-0.33704042434692383,
0.030177287757396698,
-0.258262038230896,
-0.4903274178504944,
0.18035775423049927,
0.39017876982688904,
0.16699862480163574,
-0.09717440605163574,
-0.2757187485694885,
-0.15860062837600708,
0.2414546012878418,
0.726746141910553,
0.33369675278663635,
-0.4455936551094055,
-0.5231981873512268,
-0.12783417105674744,
-0.09757786244153976,
0.30242449045181274,
0.5811567902565002,
-0.4490222632884979,
0.46477261185646057,
0.4385472536087036,
0.5093647241592407,
0.3706928789615631,
-0.15937811136245728,
0.5818159580230713,
-0.7267852425575256,
0.24467557668685913,
0.15564003586769104,
0.657748281955719,
0.37599459290504456,
-0.6060822010040283,
0.4658247232437134,
0.18845219910144806,
-0.43989309668540955,
-0.7189419865608215,
0.3567771315574646,
-0.7890723347663879,
-0.25562453269958496,
1.2250293493270874,
-0.3633103668689728,
-0.24721811711788177,
-0.17131097614765167,
-0.28432074189186096,
0.3106936812400818,
-0.06503281742334366,
0.9101470112800598,
0.9299277663230896,
-0.20144249498844147,
-0.41469889879226685,
-0.5075395703315735,
0.651687741279602,
0.7526369094848633,
-0.9107463955879211,
0.25662150979042053,
0.4031360447406769,
0.07771995663642883,
0.08627782762050629,
0.4487367570400238,
0.09090548008680344,
0.27787917852401733,
-0.26113203167915344,
0.5117475390434265,
0.6229254007339478,
-0.3416700065135956,
-0.7124773859977722,
0.13737381994724274,
0.31204432249069214,
0.25451740622520447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03131v1 | Constrained Decoding for Cross-lingual Label Projection | 2024-02-05T15:57:32 | 2024-02-05T15:57:32 | Duong Minh Le, Yang Chen, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer utilizing multilingual LLMs has become a
popular learning paradigm for low-resource languages with no labeled training
data. However, for NLP tasks that involve fine-grained predictions on words and
phrases, the performance of zero-shot cross-lingual transfer learning lags far
behind supervised fine-tuning methods. Therefore, it is common to exploit
translation and label projection to further improve the performance by (1)
translating training data that is available in a high-resource language (e.g.,
English) together with the gold labels into low-resource languages, and/or (2)
translating test data in low-resource languages to a high-source language to
run inference on, then projecting the predicted span-level labels back onto the
original test data. However, state-of-the-art marker-based label projection
methods suffer from translation quality degradation due to the extra label
markers injected in the input to the translation model. In this work, we
explore a new direction that leverages constrained decoding for label
projection to overcome the aforementioned issues. Our new method not only can
preserve the quality of translated texts but also has the versatility of being
applicable to both translating training and translating test data strategies.
This versatility is crucial as our experiments reveal that translating test
data can lead to a considerable boost in performance compared to translating
only training data. We evaluate on two cross-lingual transfer tasks, namely
Named Entity Recognition and Event Argument Extraction, spanning 20 languages.
The results demonstrate that our approach outperforms the state-of-the-art
marker-based method by a large margin and also shows better performance than
other label projection methods that rely on external word alignment. | [
-0.23774589598178864,
-0.1762624979019165,
0.2880305051803589,
0.2140878587961197,
-0.4239778220653534,
0.12000710517168045,
-0.25125160813331604,
-0.7429974675178528,
0.26181498169898987,
0.4934093654155731,
-0.41847777366638184,
-0.6642705202102661,
-0.6444299221038818,
0.32228511571884155,
-0.06844353675842285,
1.1280969381332397,
-0.3606491684913635,
0.06229553744196892,
0.0012294150656089187,
-0.16913561522960663,
-0.34831133484840393,
-0.538037896156311,
-0.21533790230751038,
-0.44882524013519287,
0.415515273809433,
0.5191555619239807,
0.4339085817337036,
0.7628383040428162,
0.016831740736961365,
0.09669095277786255,
-0.0544499009847641,
0.4873824715614319,
-0.5359752774238586,
-0.16742761433124542,
-0.2944807708263397,
-0.3576773703098297,
-0.3156368136405945,
-0.07001251727342606,
0.6070369482040405,
0.8234189748764038,
0.3257894814014435,
0.042907241731882095,
0.23911890387535095,
0.2552013099193573,
-0.8710074424743652,
0.3608008325099945,
-0.5476772785186768,
0.39244988560676575,
-0.10821328312158585,
-0.4103700518608093,
-0.7097116708755493,
-0.003222016617655754,
-0.15580329298973083,
-0.8370499014854431,
0.09504599124193192,
0.02187187969684601,
1.0220500230789185,
0.16160637140274048,
-0.5565398335456848,
-0.3064550459384918,
-0.6935572028160095,
0.9432151317596436,
-0.4809390604496002,
0.6041534543037415,
0.3592558205127716,
0.0806904137134552,
0.13323231041431427,
-0.4785585403442383,
-0.22705495357513428,
0.03573758900165558,
-0.20674124360084534,
0.1659853607416153,
-0.0654699057340622,
0.0012361770495772362,
0.11784105747938156,
0.16730748116970062,
-0.46245262026786804,
0.2987143397331238,
-0.20160840451717377,
-0.5491586923599243,
0.5642207264900208,
-0.05592425912618637,
0.18614187836647034,
-0.24351637065410614,
-0.6567922830581665,
-0.24355711042881012,
-0.6973920464515686,
-0.13339975476264954,
0.04127541184425354,
0.6252997517585754,
-0.058941297233104706,
0.5210567712783813,
-0.24041110277175903,
0.8029171228408813,
-0.007698381785303354,
-0.33660995960235596,
0.2236255407333374,
-0.5106931328773499,
-0.13328491151332855,
0.4070751667022705,
0.707057774066925,
0.42284470796585083,
0.2206166684627533,
-0.39109423756599426,
-0.03707924112677574,
0.004740735050290823,
-0.29130688309669495,
-0.7265965938568115,
-0.006282662972807884,
-0.27438512444496155,
-0.0708925724029541,
0.2348356693983078,
-0.3628414273262024,
-0.8729696273803711,
-0.1912732571363449,
-0.021486502140760422,
0.18048052489757538,
-0.421882301568985,
0.13637685775756836,
0.287557989358902,
0.17359374463558197,
0.1441350132226944,
0.16954421997070312,
-0.9405332207679749,
-0.04663435369729996,
0.38641902804374695,
0.6854738593101501,
-0.3723461627960205,
-0.11491076648235321,
-0.8387146592140198,
0.5862468481063843,
-0.44018852710723877,
0.6219651699066162,
-0.4289427399635315,
-0.39032891392707825,
0.23875267803668976,
-0.004749210551381111,
-0.20653748512268066,
-0.439785897731781,
0.6553370952606201,
-0.4852869510650635,
0.024765020236372948,
-0.12856918573379517,
-0.42263805866241455,
-0.10959503799676895,
0.4079801142215729,
-0.39189550280570984,
0.7757119536399841,
0.1107456311583519,
-0.39068084955215454,
0.4174703061580658,
-0.05858522653579712,
-0.5911301374435425,
0.18369773030281067,
-0.08040362596511841,
-0.147800475358963,
-0.14482474327087402,
0.6299425959587097,
0.5738982558250427,
-0.39174914360046387,
0.09972558170557022,
-0.09328041970729828,
-0.12961068749427795,
0.17950677871704102,
-0.3812435269355774,
0.5368668437004089,
0.2279118448495865,
-0.1928943693637848,
-0.23469874262809753,
-0.8673129081726074,
0.22409547865390778,
-0.1939026117324829,
-0.5795539617538452,
-0.39999788999557495,
-0.38095641136169434,
-0.064335398375988,
0.2853582799434662,
0.0951874628663063,
-0.6309742331504822,
0.32412484288215637,
-0.33050110936164856,
0.03466760739684105,
0.37656643986701965,
-0.08299919217824936,
0.6758134961128235,
-0.012743198312819004,
0.7598827481269836,
-0.05480126664042473,
-0.18421241641044617,
-0.05553251504898071,
-0.44818606972694397,
-0.7063541412353516,
-0.3127373456954956,
0.5270037055015564,
0.8644468784332275,
-1.2488924264907837,
0.11121349036693573,
-0.45690518617630005,
-0.12508711218833923,
-0.7265768647193909,
0.3489907383918762,
0.6897791028022766,
0.7120712995529175,
0.7252297401428223,
-0.27211976051330566,
-0.5716882348060608,
-0.8480081558227539,
-0.19817277789115906,
-0.1969721019268036,
-0.08879829198122025,
0.20865875482559204,
0.16169732809066772,
-0.14422966539859772,
0.45280155539512634,
-0.42935287952423096,
-0.567657470703125,
-0.5014739632606506,
0.1727055311203003,
0.08709536492824554,
0.5575827956199646,
0.44572415947914124,
-0.6830481886863708,
-0.7895570993423462,
0.3434980511665344,
-0.5196380019187927,
-0.40433040261268616,
-0.46152248978614807,
-0.2244926542043686,
0.4440820515155792,
0.48241668939590454,
-0.3461100161075592,
0.26157933473587036,
0.9005994200706482,
-0.3516605794429779,
0.46724894642829895,
-0.09296038746833801,
0.034317176789045334,
-0.8868248462677002,
-0.16739706695079803,
-0.00853513553738594,
-0.32049399614334106,
-0.6043473482131958,
-0.17876015603542328,
0.12488909810781479,
0.09526017308235168,
-0.6668091416358948,
0.6029155850410461,
-0.7665776610374451,
0.03648239001631737,
-0.13464650511741638,
0.2686539888381958,
0.3679668605327606,
0.459788978099823,
0.2615821957588196,
0.5047787427902222,
0.4138006865978241,
-0.45245540142059326,
0.17212823033332825,
0.40092170238494873,
-0.40459567308425903,
0.7174948453903198,
-0.12437351047992706,
-0.04555090516805649,
0.026583142578601837,
0.21961116790771484,
-0.7434940338134766,
0.08557071536779404,
0.5926656723022461,
-0.2747128903865814,
0.8303743600845337,
-0.2639097273349762,
-0.24506868422031403,
0.10025615990161896,
0.07246999442577362,
0.6067087650299072,
0.35635170340538025,
-0.6791446805000305,
0.397158682346344,
0.2376142144203186,
0.09219279885292053,
-0.7540729641914368,
-1.1931562423706055,
0.1782289743423462,
-0.11769847571849823,
-0.3320270776748657,
0.6616187691688538,
0.17516614496707916,
0.29782894253730774,
0.14494197070598602,
-0.23702789843082428,
-0.039668548852205276,
-0.2538463771343231,
-0.07253789901733398,
0.2233462929725647,
-0.1809334009885788,
-0.1434154212474823,
0.09357524663209915,
-0.2822936475276947,
-0.1964714229106903,
-0.42866748571395874,
0.14715476334095,
0.1243056207895279,
-0.29341939091682434,
-0.2595987319946289,
0.5416417717933655,
0.274443656206131,
-0.17540588974952698,
0.7026568055152893,
0.6748064756393433,
-0.1795218586921692,
-0.36926397681236267,
-0.2767474949359894,
0.18232931196689606,
-0.40166717767715454,
0.4056644141674042,
-0.6741344928741455,
-0.7191983461380005,
0.3584093749523163,
-0.18586397171020508,
-0.2541157305240631,
0.28379911184310913,
0.385848730802536,
0.13756778836250305,
0.9076256155967712,
0.7520127892494202,
-0.044473446905612946,
0.2530606687068939,
-0.3342597484588623,
0.22993843257427216,
-0.9266766905784607,
-0.3714541792869568,
-0.306443452835083,
-0.3367273211479187,
-0.4591243863105774,
-0.8221590518951416,
0.20343062281608582,
0.3385903537273407,
0.3507704436779022,
0.42783358693122864,
-0.48696908354759216,
0.2956925332546234,
0.37463781237602234,
-0.06566523015499115,
0.40209969878196716,
0.1338338553905487,
-0.35867810249328613,
-0.39633747935295105,
-1.0827829837799072,
-0.25318479537963867,
0.7563328742980957,
0.0713689923286438,
0.6509583592414856,
-0.1508457213640213,
0.7468241453170776,
0.00825116503983736,
0.37248292565345764,
-0.8238608837127686,
0.643231987953186,
-0.2870180010795593,
-0.44612985849380493,
-0.1433219313621521,
-0.5212908387184143,
-1.054099440574646,
0.5002442002296448,
-0.296051025390625,
-0.8689205646514893,
0.521360456943512,
0.046522051095962524,
0.003775200806558132,
0.5755847096443176,
-0.5699386596679688,
0.8571252226829529,
-0.369455486536026,
-0.42922744154930115,
0.20893442630767822,
-0.5301464200019836,
0.24443423748016357,
-0.1245817020535469,
0.23214104771614075,
-0.19832761585712433,
-0.10917557030916214,
0.6828052997589111,
-0.06898844987154007,
0.936732292175293,
-0.04471580684185028,
-0.4398937523365021,
0.23683080077171326,
0.24140162765979767,
0.5718190670013428,
-0.10001672804355621,
-0.13616782426834106,
0.12678547203540802,
0.15518932044506073,
-0.4110628664493561,
-0.5145371556282043,
0.5914519429206848,
-0.615585446357727,
-0.4451376795768738,
-0.37601473927497864,
-0.9935476183891296,
-0.4314025342464447,
0.10425988584756851,
0.39072132110595703,
0.07129505276679993,
-0.07116685807704926,
-0.015687506645917892,
0.38314110040664673,
-0.4241343140602112,
0.23135949671268463,
0.5863677263259888,
-0.12322646379470825,
-0.4065292775630951,
1.2145437002182007,
0.286695659160614,
0.41453734040260315,
0.7862945795059204,
-0.06245679035782814,
-0.34302350878715515,
-0.6371062397956848,
-0.7124922275543213,
0.4096463620662689,
-0.7938776612281799,
-0.4759880304336548,
-0.31636250019073486,
0.019838955253362656,
-0.4858241677284241,
-0.38421738147735596,
-0.6043305993080139,
-0.6559290885925293,
-0.45398229360580444,
-0.16012701392173767,
-0.10465215891599655,
0.12914404273033142,
-0.5071990489959717,
0.14161765575408936,
-0.9527239203453064,
0.40138763189315796,
-0.08906988054513931,
0.0837748721241951,
-0.4218320846557617,
-0.5825074315071106,
-0.4851061999797821,
0.01801319792866707,
-0.13374502956867218,
-1.1269659996032715,
0.7353118062019348,
0.36975863575935364,
0.45548194646835327,
0.23606863617897034,
0.5264354348182678,
0.8012389540672302,
-0.35753995180130005,
0.39785563945770264,
0.19497278332710266,
-0.9053996801376343,
0.37931662797927856,
0.07027601450681686,
0.3889337480068207,
0.3947063684463501,
0.6264270544052124,
-0.6092904210090637,
-0.33986321091651917,
-0.1459999829530716,
-0.9788680672645569,
0.7582303881645203,
-0.038218799978494644,
-0.0926351547241211,
0.1489448845386505,
0.2684057056903839,
0.2580871880054474,
-0.16343820095062256,
-0.7997937798500061,
-0.28717178106307983,
-0.047106772661209106,
0.08014275878667831,
-0.39891937375068665,
-0.3637957274913788,
-0.20509208738803864,
-0.27544206380844116,
0.6960441470146179,
-0.40137335658073425,
0.06843886524438858,
0.26541945338249207,
-0.25095266103744507,
-0.03567255288362503,
0.48293209075927734,
0.3446618616580963,
0.2071262001991272,
-0.06878883391618729,
0.3328644931316376,
0.4073704779148102,
-0.09518926590681076,
0.39613160490989685,
0.401406466960907,
-0.5070866942405701,
0.25524914264678955,
0.40524372458457947,
1.0509381294250488,
0.19509075582027435,
-0.5148628950119019,
0.15812644362449646,
0.35253772139549255,
-0.2994767427444458,
0.26246291399002075,
-0.33070504665374756,
-0.19022150337696075,
0.26491421461105347,
0.2819090485572815,
-0.2955991327762604,
0.04738568142056465,
-0.4534907042980194,
0.22182992100715637,
0.3709321916103363,
-0.4414825141429901,
-0.347890704870224,
0.7146333456039429,
0.07051806896924973,
0.0563630536198616,
0.48450392484664917,
-0.3318219482898712,
-0.5749111175537109,
0.29550403356552124,
0.9641745090484619,
0.6652233004570007,
-0.1589365303516388,
0.6212503910064697,
0.3929384648799896,
0.42784029245376587,
0.06066690385341644,
0.07877402752637863,
-0.33779895305633545,
-0.8722392916679382,
-0.9223207831382751,
-0.6424344778060913,
-0.4577861428260803,
-0.04023332521319389,
-0.817142128944397,
0.003890005638822913,
0.05927788093686104,
-0.0036611713003367186,
-0.32094547152519226,
-0.139129176735878,
-0.6403290033340454,
0.17418846487998962,
0.6814196705818176,
0.7793615460395813,
-0.9054098129272461,
1.0709129571914673,
0.657952070236206,
-0.03074786812067032,
-0.720969021320343,
-0.31044602394104004,
-0.1354338824748993,
-0.8333063721656799,
0.8186215162277222,
0.11800941079854965,
-0.16633537411689758,
-0.07261497527360916,
-0.06892753392457962,
-1.0039222240447998,
0.7696291208267212,
0.7776089906692505,
-0.45602354407310486,
-0.1362762153148651,
0.6621543169021606,
0.48189759254455566,
-0.3423347473144531,
-0.19736546277999878,
0.5956228971481323,
0.5785356163978577,
0.27020302414894104,
-0.9923564791679382,
0.29020175337791443,
-0.09548775851726532,
-0.009773341938853264,
0.18893957138061523,
-0.36774030327796936,
0.3365592062473297,
-0.24306902289390564,
-0.5872992277145386,
0.025769703090190887,
0.7084150910377502,
0.13428446650505066,
0.3960864841938019,
0.2061864286661148,
0.4825127422809601,
0.4948303699493408,
-0.18609458208084106,
1.0874159336090088,
-0.33405372500419617,
0.35254961252212524,
0.9538218975067139,
-0.2002432942390442,
0.6767579913139343,
0.8597232699394226,
0.1552400141954422,
0.2658187747001648,
0.46908262372016907,
0.056073784828186035,
0.8059531450271606,
0.09996771067380905,
-0.10414569824934006,
-0.39033275842666626,
-0.7219701409339905,
-0.29152655601501465,
0.5007373690605164,
0.5924040675163269,
-0.20075342059135437,
-0.4292024075984955,
0.2819836139678955,
-0.06273891031742096,
0.11295866966247559,
-0.23092785477638245,
0.31924280524253845,
0.17501063644886017,
-0.7308757901191711,
1.1466962099075317,
0.04674912616610527,
0.6880801320075989,
-0.5729450583457947,
-0.009248998947441578,
-0.2224111258983612,
0.2972056567668915,
-0.1412891000509262,
-0.6607269644737244,
0.3755398690700531,
-0.2115764617919922,
0.2061372697353363,
-0.8427993059158325,
0.6225087642669678,
-0.8293471336364746,
-0.4465717673301697,
0.6754393577575684,
0.5243193507194519,
0.3396095037460327,
0.3899020850658417,
-0.5200139880180359,
0.1582113802433014,
0.33251112699508667,
-0.22610682249069214,
0.5226578116416931,
0.5848398804664612,
0.07148768752813339,
0.5683925747871399,
0.2817941904067993,
0.43080389499664307,
0.3323488235473633,
-0.2249833196401596,
0.5744619369506836,
-0.4381476640701294,
-0.23787446320056915,
-0.551240861415863,
0.33589068055152893,
0.2640764117240906,
-0.29689136147499084,
0.8228398561477661,
0.5088347792625427,
1.285366415977478,
-0.12087413668632507,
0.5953624248504639,
0.11646300554275513,
0.1825052797794342,
-0.7399324178695679,
0.2419886440038681,
-0.6181712746620178,
0.21615125238895416,
-0.1692616492509842,
-0.7025675177574158,
-0.757202684879303,
0.41143152117729187,
-0.3115617036819458,
-0.4051130414009094,
0.5041921138763428,
0.6545665860176086,
0.021500108763575554,
-0.5306721925735474,
0.6471637487411499,
-0.135393887758255,
0.2779267430305481,
1.1521363258361816,
0.6980136632919312,
-0.4479300081729889,
1.1973137855529785,
-0.5849233269691467,
0.0076609402894973755,
-0.26776495575904846,
-0.7999374866485596,
-0.7534151673316956,
-0.4689730703830719,
-0.6354041695594788,
-0.2983626127243042,
0.0953962504863739,
0.3431681990623474,
0.7391114234924316,
-0.8847861289978027,
-0.17309823632240295,
0.3047391474246979,
0.1762819141149521,
-0.3752180337905884,
-0.18387342989444733,
0.3168909251689911,
-0.32089993357658386,
-1.0572229623794556,
0.6590859293937683,
0.19872726500034332,
0.22210794687271118,
0.04362281784415245,
-0.31260356307029724,
-0.39583250880241394,
-0.1572790890932083,
0.6186416149139404,
0.7447929978370667,
-0.540645182132721,
-0.3279522657394409,
-0.08140780031681061,
-0.21767716109752655,
0.1492491513490677,
0.6181163787841797,
-0.7627214789390564,
0.6015480756759644,
0.49905794858932495,
0.9273124933242798,
0.9712925553321838,
-0.09323102980852127,
0.6804695725440979,
-1.0243104696273804,
0.3671588599681854,
0.2678995728492737,
0.2600945830345154,
0.4419778287410736,
-0.23110823333263397,
0.5971750617027283,
0.14133045077323914,
-0.217019721865654,
-0.951019287109375,
0.4163699746131897,
-0.9286855459213257,
-0.31127244234085083,
1.2690668106079102,
-0.35109737515449524,
-0.09353592991828918,
0.002051373478025198,
-0.09427821636199951,
0.5549429655075073,
-0.11609764397144318,
0.4766850769519806,
0.5223897695541382,
-0.32808348536491394,
-0.32224786281585693,
-0.4476804733276367,
0.39387235045433044,
0.6683952808380127,
-0.45397260785102844,
-0.10904254019260406,
0.4873969256877899,
-0.056394513696432114,
0.43343019485473633,
0.39593306183815,
0.00342644564807415,
-0.04200855270028114,
-0.02789527364075184,
0.07904934883117676,
-0.0715750977396965,
-0.336353600025177,
-0.20117589831352234,
0.30619585514068604,
-0.1505296379327774,
-0.5995245575904846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05129v1 | Best Practices for Text Annotation with Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T15:43:50 | 2024-02-05T15:43:50 | Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a new era of text annotation, as
their ease-of-use, high accuracy, and relatively low costs have meant that
their use has exploded in recent months. However, the rapid growth of the field
has meant that LLM-based annotation has become something of an academic Wild
West: the lack of established practices and standards has led to concerns about
the quality and validity of research. Researchers have warned that the
ostensible simplicity of LLMs can be misleading, as they are prone to bias,
misunderstandings, and unreliable results. Recognizing the transformative
potential of LLMs, this paper proposes a comprehensive set of standards and
best practices for their reliable, reproducible, and ethical use. These
guidelines span critical areas such as model selection, prompt engineering,
structured prompting, prompt stability analysis, rigorous model validation, and
the consideration of ethical and legal implications. The paper emphasizes the
need for a structured, directed, and formalized approach to using LLMs, aiming
to ensure the integrity and robustness of text annotation practices, and
advocates for a nuanced and critical engagement with LLMs in social scientific
research. | [
-0.049685776233673096,
-0.7110497951507568,
0.8457317352294922,
0.3703804910182953,
-0.463100790977478,
-0.025102416053414345,
-0.5122166872024536,
-0.6893776655197144,
0.10167402774095535,
0.819605827331543,
-0.10303894430398941,
-0.684718132019043,
-0.749252200126648,
0.43883100152015686,
-0.4418199062347412,
1.0744765996932983,
-0.26198437809944153,
0.16632840037345886,
-0.2559965252876282,
-0.340299516916275,
-0.10751021653413773,
-0.7203165888786316,
-0.405368834733963,
-0.49104106426239014,
0.7782934308052063,
0.04348801076412201,
0.7960249185562134,
0.8259777426719666,
0.6065952181816101,
0.16165949404239655,
-0.561764657497406,
0.29747873544692993,
-0.48219311237335205,
0.3752239942550659,
0.04162698984146118,
-0.13922475278377533,
-0.5558584332466125,
0.26825955510139465,
0.5872960090637207,
0.7090243101119995,
-0.07865121960639954,
0.3908863365650177,
0.006169447209686041,
0.26707035303115845,
-0.4496917128562927,
0.2277461439371109,
-0.5725517272949219,
0.022177401930093765,
-0.3142267167568207,
-0.2817135453224182,
-0.5289345383644104,
-0.732510507106781,
-0.028325999155640602,
-0.576919436454773,
-0.33162572979927063,
0.0641392320394516,
0.6925886869430542,
0.06204240769147873,
-0.40513888001441956,
-0.29408344626426697,
-0.7018249034881592,
0.8190438747406006,
-0.8324054479598999,
0.25463396310806274,
0.510193407535553,
0.16773636639118195,
-0.23540426790714264,
-0.6332162618637085,
-0.3533594310283661,
-0.35788044333457947,
0.022896308451890945,
-0.40031591057777405,
0.334770530462265,
0.1455080658197403,
0.5090296864509583,
0.21733255684375763,
-0.10114241391420364,
0.4824737012386322,
-0.21653829514980316,
-0.20109058916568756,
0.8472642302513123,
0.09410267323255539,
0.13790497183799744,
-0.11692051589488983,
-0.38000980019569397,
0.14391642808914185,
-1.1714409589767456,
-0.24380488693714142,
0.3796735405921936,
0.497345507144928,
0.023183615878224373,
0.6750788688659668,
0.028981897979974747,
0.41378355026245117,
-0.4973849058151245,
-0.31267955899238586,
0.23849345743656158,
-0.29587653279304504,
-0.16679874062538147,
-0.12762196362018585,
0.9083774089813232,
0.60511714220047,
0.7189064025878906,
-0.2805691063404083,
-0.5045967102050781,
-0.2187851369380951,
0.11178823560476303,
-0.6808128356933594,
0.12796103954315186,
0.11354701220989227,
-0.482982873916626,
-0.41627588868141174,
-0.217773899435997,
-0.7686622738838196,
-0.56069016456604,
-0.6385962963104248,
0.17570728063583374,
-0.1835441142320633,
-0.22731414437294006,
-0.10167235136032104,
0.154237300157547,
0.30759939551353455,
0.535254180431366,
-0.9196383953094482,
0.3566596508026123,
0.749306321144104,
0.935126006603241,
-0.008748363703489304,
-0.14915812015533447,
-0.3788885176181793,
0.3362818956375122,
-0.6508021354675293,
0.5172825455665588,
-0.5561249256134033,
-0.517902672290802,
0.46341750025749207,
-0.13389965891838074,
0.5100058317184448,
-0.22774669528007507,
0.7622504830360413,
-0.4723929762840271,
-0.09336354583501816,
-0.45759084820747375,
-0.6592540740966797,
-0.16884000599384308,
0.15547789633274078,
-0.6123960614204407,
1.193008542060852,
-0.34360408782958984,
-0.6966865658760071,
0.16720736026763916,
-0.6821396350860596,
-0.3639601767063141,
0.20392857491970062,
-0.2830427289009094,
-0.3293910026550293,
0.22857609391212463,
-0.03020257130265236,
0.7930405735969543,
-0.2458040565252304,
0.5712604522705078,
-0.38856884837150574,
-0.3377465605735779,
0.35321393609046936,
-0.3637285828590393,
0.6628895998001099,
0.22286036610603333,
-0.2254806011915207,
0.14626401662826538,
-0.6737508773803711,
-0.07988549023866653,
0.2763892114162445,
-0.37084609270095825,
-0.4881783127784729,
0.1490541696548462,
0.433042973279953,
-0.16763600707054138,
0.248153418302536,
-0.5005389451980591,
0.08520926535129547,
-0.18177589774131775,
0.5942525267601013,
0.818105936050415,
-0.10522263497114182,
0.28874748945236206,
-0.2904700040817261,
0.2986791431903839,
-0.6142252087593079,
0.12282245606184006,
-0.372210830450058,
-0.27540478110313416,
-0.37951338291168213,
-0.2047160118818283,
0.36411887407302856,
0.3517889380455017,
-0.3563251495361328,
0.4716312885284424,
-0.1708831787109375,
-0.653049647808075,
-0.41478613018989563,
0.17811721563339233,
0.12611861526966095,
0.2258521467447281,
0.37837228178977966,
0.13237978518009186,
-0.4945300221443176,
-0.8552667498588562,
-0.2735133767127991,
-0.32665756344795227,
0.19163230061531067,
0.13108062744140625,
0.6789746284484863,
-0.3024064600467682,
0.8413890600204468,
-0.1596578061580658,
-0.0782104879617691,
-0.15435189008712769,
0.28459906578063965,
-0.13453859090805054,
0.3281707465648651,
0.34188467264175415,
-0.8045824766159058,
-0.206046000123024,
-0.07077200710773468,
-0.8541982769966125,
-0.3617536127567291,
-0.024792885407805443,
-0.06387268006801605,
0.39316725730895996,
0.6661866307258606,
-0.5225932002067566,
0.22093616425991058,
0.7252323627471924,
0.019628610461950302,
0.48719245195388794,
-0.10725580900907516,
0.09540154039859772,
-0.9403852224349976,
0.29054948687553406,
0.2865423858165741,
-0.5174123644828796,
-0.5652704238891602,
0.15889546275138855,
0.10392758995294571,
0.25166112184524536,
-0.2282484769821167,
0.6307843923568726,
-0.41476017236709595,
0.2756550908088684,
-0.41809242963790894,
0.20286698639392853,
-0.05184577777981758,
-0.2595765292644501,
0.04655389115214348,
0.7120398283004761,
0.2746870815753937,
-0.34174150228500366,
0.33409664034843445,
0.1623566448688507,
-0.21506313979625702,
0.31515270471572876,
-0.8165671825408936,
0.1603010892868042,
-0.26099225878715515,
0.29114511609077454,
-0.6164583563804626,
-0.14972557127475739,
0.2052869349718094,
-0.285911500453949,
0.3899783790111542,
-0.14055044949054718,
-1.0303781032562256,
0.13416045904159546,
-0.44291460514068604,
0.3040790855884552,
0.6324191689491272,
-0.4337350130081177,
0.6344178318977356,
0.6729341149330139,
-0.27911630272865295,
-0.6407527923583984,
-0.7722901701927185,
0.4655841588973999,
-0.2954230308532715,
-0.4320984184741974,
0.25371718406677246,
0.08554410189390182,
-0.6107933521270752,
-0.20617564022541046,
0.25717300176620483,
-0.009383478201925755,
0.33492961525917053,
0.31445255875587463,
0.31271159648895264,
0.00634112348780036,
0.18671603500843048,
-0.031684838235378265,
-0.009023980237543583,
0.06830053776502609,
0.21832895278930664,
0.29068422317504883,
0.14827115833759308,
-0.16121706366539001,
-0.18306270241737366,
0.5474207997322083,
0.6014700531959534,
-0.26524871587753296,
0.61454176902771,
0.3750186264514923,
-0.7072364687919617,
-0.1419292688369751,
-0.8501540422439575,
-0.3376308083534241,
-0.39362576603889465,
0.29673463106155396,
0.10037995129823685,
-1.1123542785644531,
0.44774192571640015,
-0.31389373540878296,
0.3597034215927124,
0.33455580472946167,
0.5435262322425842,
-0.20624184608459473,
0.6762053966522217,
0.9782525300979614,
0.12129226326942444,
0.33652690052986145,
0.22036509215831757,
0.29160743951797485,
-0.9682984352111816,
-0.2974589467048645,
-0.7662485241889954,
0.22967614233493805,
-0.6730253100395203,
-0.5705522894859314,
0.17654316127300262,
0.06987964361906052,
-0.2117341011762619,
0.023849356919527054,
-0.3155226707458496,
0.5635940432548523,
0.1909995973110199,
-0.3687324821949005,
0.4418354630470276,
-0.04127345606684685,
-0.1275245100259781,
-0.2877970039844513,
-0.2887445092201233,
-1.4620821475982666,
0.9468883872032166,
0.7885558605194092,
1.0139251947402954,
-0.12469909340143204,
0.6601457595825195,
0.06308122724294662,
0.6013567447662354,
-0.6250070929527283,
0.7218612432479858,
-0.07156402617692947,
-0.7631411552429199,
-0.40858474373817444,
-0.3508777916431427,
-0.7077706456184387,
0.3190647065639496,
-0.272834450006485,
-0.8886463642120361,
-0.19707146286964417,
0.13831865787506104,
-0.19635410606861115,
0.28916144371032715,
-0.2851896584033966,
0.5378806591033936,
-0.19592639803886414,
-0.23467257618904114,
0.09341608732938766,
-0.6457569003105164,
0.36347758769989014,
-0.2795761227607727,
0.49251678586006165,
-0.324963241815567,
-0.23240700364112854,
0.7811611890792847,
-0.10209333896636963,
1.1958732604980469,
0.13097944855690002,
-0.24257148802280426,
0.2895776331424713,
0.06882639229297638,
0.8067097663879395,
0.0034296729136258364,
-0.05496012419462204,
0.41785693168640137,
0.1520131379365921,
-0.11760862916707993,
-0.10784339159727097,
0.5963535308837891,
-0.5921974182128906,
-0.5601861476898193,
-0.6213172674179077,
-0.5896942615509033,
-0.06439394503831863,
0.09761080890893936,
-0.13728900253772736,
0.2501625120639801,
-0.26111099123954773,
0.27908259630203247,
0.8976707458496094,
-0.18501196801662445,
0.3796757161617279,
0.2619003355503082,
-0.43357202410697937,
-0.456306517124176,
0.5487521886825562,
0.3302001953125,
0.2635425627231598,
0.09280887246131897,
0.1943434327840805,
-0.337130606174469,
-0.8512471318244934,
-0.22348521649837494,
0.6031898856163025,
-1.0912808179855347,
-0.054179538041353226,
-0.609521210193634,
-0.16373108327388763,
-0.4675087034702301,
-0.231024831533432,
-0.2944403886795044,
-0.12194055318832397,
-0.4787898063659668,
-0.2262994945049286,
0.6362802386283875,
0.7344253063201904,
0.16549792885780334,
0.10459131747484207,
-0.7090121507644653,
-0.07337740808725357,
-0.09419222176074982,
0.25688695907592773,
-0.22686989605426788,
-0.4036560654640198,
-0.10811109840869904,
-0.20528662204742432,
-0.005510194227099419,
-0.7505947947502136,
0.17922617495059967,
-0.0404515378177166,
0.7627086639404297,
0.11782734096050262,
0.13156358897686005,
0.35680827498435974,
-0.8361756801605225,
0.8448368310928345,
0.13874010741710663,
-0.9473378658294678,
0.30554884672164917,
-0.5720946192741394,
-0.14022044837474823,
0.5637102723121643,
0.6218680739402771,
-0.9212812185287476,
-0.6313260197639465,
-0.25893357396125793,
-1.0174248218536377,
0.12791608273983002,
0.04835426062345505,
0.5848368406295776,
0.08620613068342209,
0.5410987734794617,
0.334869384765625,
0.24049679934978485,
-1.1906400918960571,
-0.15234453976154327,
0.12297199666500092,
-0.48089563846588135,
0.013956292532384396,
-0.5372329950332642,
-0.3427952527999878,
0.07800094038248062,
0.6057534217834473,
-0.322571337223053,
-0.23621204495429993,
0.17437081038951874,
-0.06582190096378326,
-0.22743922472000122,
0.27130618691444397,
0.557087779045105,
1.0640017986297607,
0.020914340391755104,
0.26218181848526,
0.21236540377140045,
-0.38483721017837524,
0.07237062603235245,
0.07537632435560226,
-0.4662174880504608,
0.0007163455593399704,
0.4365408718585968,
0.3692776560783386,
0.15756434202194214,
-0.7466060519218445,
0.4014468193054199,
0.11725255101919174,
-0.14348824322223663,
-0.5280756950378418,
-0.1825941801071167,
0.2994835078716278,
0.13436196744441986,
0.3239170014858246,
-0.3934163749217987,
-0.0684070810675621,
-0.314825177192688,
-0.33013758063316345,
0.44119352102279663,
-0.19528323411941528,
-0.14679911732673645,
0.4769064784049988,
0.31719180941581726,
-0.3010079562664032,
0.14519941806793213,
0.08727265894412994,
-0.3611588776111603,
0.2367865890264511,
0.32789355516433716,
0.7223708033561707,
-0.09736327826976776,
0.2310994565486908,
0.1362318992614746,
0.7890961766242981,
-0.5582892894744873,
0.23475919663906097,
0.22789990901947021,
-0.4209311902523041,
-0.831055223941803,
-0.6785579323768616,
-0.5411514639854431,
0.15327712893486023,
-0.3783479332923889,
0.4462902843952179,
-0.5569800138473511,
-0.17650821805000305,
-0.023728612810373306,
0.020274752750992775,
-0.18660631775856018,
0.09905578941106796,
0.3910858929157257,
1.0518217086791992,
-0.9242356419563293,
0.7596218585968018,
0.7299099564552307,
-0.39021480083465576,
-0.5878852605819702,
-0.16014240682125092,
0.16230879724025726,
-0.5962554812431335,
0.6262515783309937,
0.17742523550987244,
-0.09446261078119278,
-0.29983335733413696,
-0.9189491868019104,
-0.7610249519348145,
0.9988608360290527,
0.2887732684612274,
-0.7744834423065186,
0.12813135981559753,
0.12911926209926605,
0.6023434400558472,
-0.39430898427963257,
0.12833945453166962,
0.2727803885936737,
0.5618003010749817,
0.12364431470632553,
-0.8816038966178894,
0.33013466000556946,
0.15638887882232666,
0.3428727388381958,
0.12807001173496246,
-0.5305050015449524,
0.6921607255935669,
-0.12077690660953522,
-0.06730829179286957,
0.22995932400226593,
0.5294464826583862,
0.33402588963508606,
0.37009087204933167,
0.25540855526924133,
0.23796196281909943,
0.8558998703956604,
-0.10810275375843048,
0.8776314854621887,
-0.07198955118656158,
0.3234376907348633,
0.8625996708869934,
-0.5011874437332153,
0.938353955745697,
0.7882551550865173,
0.03935357555747032,
0.10888439416885376,
0.799734890460968,
-0.09299885481595993,
0.04346949979662895,
0.43669238686561584,
-0.13044103980064392,
-0.30864280462265015,
-0.4273262321949005,
-0.2058299481868744,
0.1680186688899994,
0.4219728112220764,
-0.6346287131309509,
-0.09655336290597916,
-0.269718736410141,
0.558052122592926,
0.3819102346897125,
-0.23438842594623566,
0.6968700289726257,
0.34666526317596436,
-0.2838926911354065,
0.11418670415878296,
0.11782374978065491,
0.7552415132522583,
-0.5324651002883911,
-0.12958572804927826,
-0.043655987828969955,
-0.3540709614753723,
-0.19787263870239258,
-0.8398393392562866,
0.1893574446439743,
0.39020371437072754,
-0.06871501356363297,
-0.38038909435272217,
0.7297298908233643,
-0.4373272657394409,
-0.5994320511817932,
0.32247933745384216,
0.32826900482177734,
0.12283272296190262,
0.19043727219104767,
-0.27018603682518005,
0.6114964485168457,
-0.36153391003608704,
-0.3701300024986267,
0.254970908164978,
0.5473564267158508,
-0.13869324326515198,
0.6639511585235596,
0.6074020266532898,
0.47847288846969604,
-0.07805383950471878,
0.12637938559055328,
0.7047044634819031,
-0.7077686190605164,
-0.024740226566791534,
-1.082588791847229,
0.5113701820373535,
-0.3266332745552063,
-0.44781264662742615,
0.6830247640609741,
0.18853504955768585,
0.655040442943573,
0.4767317473888397,
0.807354211807251,
0.33688023686408997,
0.3557640016078949,
-0.6100781559944153,
0.7633933424949646,
-0.3188045918941498,
0.25835496187210083,
-0.27052927017211914,
-1.0306167602539062,
-0.7592865228652954,
0.875356912612915,
-0.3116392195224762,
0.21081794798374176,
0.649967610836029,
0.5251601934432983,
0.3946806788444519,
0.13168835639953613,
0.3688787519931793,
0.2524891495704651,
0.6702643632888794,
-0.12048447132110596,
0.8668330907821655,
-0.1886831521987915,
0.34103620052337646,
-0.08736557513475418,
-0.24593089520931244,
-0.3761800527572632,
-1.3197457790374756,
-0.9521393179893494,
-0.4384779930114746,
-0.6250271201133728,
-0.23169729113578796,
0.015693120658397675,
1.363646388053894,
0.6612336039543152,
-0.408735066652298,
-0.3494335412979126,
0.2918676435947418,
-0.0694073885679245,
0.20355124771595,
-0.13438592851161957,
0.061172980815172195,
-0.481746643781662,
-0.6890876293182373,
0.006098227109760046,
0.5530470013618469,
0.3254905045032501,
-0.6581525802612305,
0.004901665262877941,
-0.06831580400466919,
0.31751132011413574,
0.6665619611740112,
0.16953915357589722,
-0.9339470863342285,
-0.5226733684539795,
-0.22869379818439484,
-0.4769737124443054,
-0.23878654837608337,
0.6757956147193909,
-0.19238388538360596,
0.23334434628486633,
0.1957961916923523,
0.7798845767974854,
-0.010971123352646828,
-0.2837507426738739,
0.5642756819725037,
-0.3581346571445465,
-0.14519169926643372,
0.679179310798645,
0.4830666482448578,
0.7611151337623596,
-0.2523084878921509,
0.4638718068599701,
-0.04076434299349785,
-0.9273958206176758,
-1.3173563480377197,
0.007829966023564339,
-0.8659358024597168,
-0.12038532644510269,
1.539859414100647,
-0.2875692546367645,
-0.29722166061401367,
-0.08444121479988098,
-0.26007598638534546,
0.0625547543168068,
-0.2894775867462158,
0.8761735558509827,
0.9278542399406433,
0.15565019845962524,
-0.21650898456573486,
-0.7436209321022034,
0.49295574426651,
0.12335240095853806,
-0.821416974067688,
0.50710129737854,
0.46726059913635254,
0.20104749500751495,
0.15543368458747864,
0.31632736325263977,
-0.41845399141311646,
-0.1833968460559845,
-0.3429376780986786,
0.13590683043003082,
0.05508958548307419,
-0.16011300683021545,
-0.39709505438804626,
0.031155159696936607,
0.5126283764839172,
0.3089580535888672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03099v1 | Intent-based Prompt Calibration: Enhancing prompt optimization with synthetic boundary cases | 2024-02-05T15:28:43 | 2024-02-05T15:28:43 | Elad Levi, Eli Brosh, Matan Friedmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompt engineering is a challenging and important task due to the high
sensitivity of Large Language Models (LLMs) to the given prompt and the
inherent ambiguity of a textual task instruction. Automatic prompt engineering
is essential to achieve optimized performance from LLMs. Recent studies have
demonstrated the capabilities of LLMs to automatically conduct prompt
engineering by employing a meta-prompt that incorporates the outcomes of the
last trials and proposes an improved prompt. However, this requires a
high-quality benchmark to compare different prompts, which is difficult and
expensive to acquire in many real-world use cases. In this work, we introduce a
new method for automatic prompt engineering, using a calibration process that
iteratively refines the prompt to the user intent. During the optimization
process, the system jointly generates synthetic data of boundary use cases and
optimizes the prompt according to the generated dataset. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method with respect to strong proprietary models on
real-world tasks such as moderation and generation. Our method outperforms
state-of-the-art methods with a limited number of annotated samples.
Furthermore, we validate the advantages of each one of the system's key
components. Our system is built in a modular way, facilitating easy adaptation
to other tasks. The code is available
$\href{https://github.com/Eladlev/AutoPrompt}{here}$. | [
-0.4044455885887146,
-0.772501528263092,
0.8917970657348633,
0.4133435785770416,
-0.07603082060813904,
-0.2523671090602875,
-0.3281969726085663,
-0.0062781269662082195,
-0.05904741957783699,
0.47917988896369934,
-1.1170885562896729,
-0.6521414518356323,
-0.025085778906941414,
0.3659493327140808,
0.36314940452575684,
0.6623060703277588,
-0.4533754885196686,
-0.0031033584382385015,
-0.23736587166786194,
0.07386836409568787,
-1.068535566329956,
-0.10097295045852661,
-0.5302422046661377,
-0.16093219816684723,
0.3893827497959137,
0.48923999071121216,
0.2792351543903351,
0.4849669337272644,
0.08935849368572235,
0.3021160364151001,
0.19556283950805664,
0.5449044108390808,
-0.2700570821762085,
0.5634127259254456,
-0.10160279273986816,
-0.09553608298301697,
-0.2942894399166107,
0.07291202247142792,
0.42835482954978943,
0.4801923632621765,
0.09543976932764053,
0.36985722184181213,
0.3012132942676544,
0.5236073732376099,
-0.8940433859825134,
0.18194322288036346,
-0.45096319913864136,
-0.08215504139661789,
0.2093137502670288,
-0.5700291991233826,
-0.7499376535415649,
-0.5984389781951904,
0.09957531094551086,
-0.8231502175331116,
-0.04833222180604935,
0.3184027373790741,
0.4228626489639282,
0.6299441456794739,
-0.474714070558548,
-0.27310460805892944,
-0.48215192556381226,
0.9004812836647034,
-0.6246427893638611,
0.39455437660217285,
0.1678536832332611,
0.551740825176239,
-0.4310835897922516,
-0.5384067893028259,
-0.3762989044189453,
-0.39140555262565613,
0.010882147587835789,
0.14692066609859467,
0.1623672991991043,
0.2765054702758789,
0.40505197644233704,
-0.0945567861199379,
-0.800693154335022,
0.08955748379230499,
-0.04760979861021042,
-0.6165875792503357,
0.5791443586349487,
0.3700902462005615,
0.4364832639694214,
-0.2101278007030487,
-0.4152604341506958,
-0.14156588912010193,
-0.574257493019104,
0.4132479727268219,
0.5025154948234558,
0.5725170373916626,
0.14790739119052887,
0.4947112798690796,
-0.3318992853164673,
0.8573570847511292,
0.250078946352005,
0.11149115115404129,
0.3429052531719208,
-0.2687479853630066,
-0.040975429117679596,
0.0767042487859726,
0.7732705473899841,
0.6370161771774292,
0.05507677420973778,
0.14251962304115295,
-0.32771944999694824,
-0.09702122211456299,
0.27792617678642273,
-0.8017403483390808,
-0.0006524494965560734,
0.2683773636817932,
-0.08006949722766876,
0.00029130105394870043,
-0.07670444995164871,
-0.5086200833320618,
-0.27051860094070435,
-0.7183664441108704,
0.5568477511405945,
-0.1714220494031906,
0.1691172569990158,
0.16195040941238403,
0.01672567054629326,
0.14172367751598358,
0.5114229321479797,
-0.6034606099128723,
-0.02208620496094227,
0.5318238735198975,
0.6041020750999451,
-0.2693404257297516,
-0.11474210768938065,
-0.9368578195571899,
-0.13962610065937042,
-0.22776417434215546,
0.8183594942092896,
-0.4411846399307251,
-0.6035770773887634,
-0.15883803367614746,
0.03694763407111168,
-0.14882230758666992,
-0.4175281822681427,
0.9715562462806702,
-0.5372232794761658,
0.30654382705688477,
-0.32907402515411377,
-0.317664235830307,
-0.2169889509677887,
0.3248356282711029,
-0.6009424328804016,
0.959875226020813,
0.07437082380056381,
-0.23302152752876282,
0.1256660670042038,
-0.7158312201499939,
-0.1979074478149414,
0.1960180550813675,
-0.14311887323856354,
-0.15244925022125244,
-0.04919029772281647,
0.271602988243103,
0.13295413553714752,
-0.3640020489692688,
0.5977379679679871,
-0.073857881128788,
-0.17960216104984283,
0.0287379939109087,
-0.4257434606552124,
0.7877897024154663,
0.2542385458946228,
-0.3081568479537964,
0.34304890036582947,
-0.4690682590007782,
0.32898861169815063,
-0.26397138833999634,
-0.08571942895650864,
-0.22743478417396545,
-0.24712663888931274,
-0.15755769610404968,
0.09551853686571121,
0.4191054403781891,
-0.7738138437271118,
0.17609398066997528,
-0.43027809262275696,
0.12244078516960144,
0.764927327632904,
0.29831835627555847,
0.40815576910972595,
-0.4442332983016968,
0.6991258263587952,
-0.30119335651397705,
0.4629237651824951,
-0.4442341923713684,
-0.4466240108013153,
-0.35686707496643066,
-0.3067271113395691,
0.22866114974021912,
0.8127025961875916,
-0.7157570719718933,
0.6742703914642334,
0.128697007894516,
-0.38004976511001587,
-0.3033342957496643,
0.0024076683912426233,
0.14995503425598145,
0.9366884827613831,
0.34689071774482727,
-0.05726232752203941,
-0.39098989963531494,
-0.7792190909385681,
-0.32561439275741577,
-0.1532043218612671,
-0.09400416165590286,
0.7253291606903076,
0.027774352580308914,
-0.19720099866390228,
1.4073536396026611,
-0.6474059820175171,
-0.1498531550168991,
0.04274230822920799,
0.22290277481079102,
0.401104599237442,
0.46759602427482605,
0.5501015782356262,
-0.6549742221832275,
-0.6231475472450256,
-0.25586602091789246,
-0.5123962163925171,
-1.0085740089416504,
-0.30615222454071045,
-0.47152581810951233,
-0.03968246281147003,
0.36769726872444153,
-0.39760005474090576,
0.30533871054649353,
0.3557978570461273,
-0.31907758116722107,
0.8717626333236694,
-0.23652619123458862,
0.4110037684440613,
-0.7884302139282227,
0.15475043654441833,
0.1907266080379486,
-0.2498970776796341,
-0.49085909128189087,
-0.021579615771770477,
0.28897610306739807,
-0.18415895104408264,
-0.5525345206260681,
0.9300345182418823,
-0.3865680694580078,
0.4452279806137085,
-0.49979010224342346,
0.06450218707323074,
0.31102466583251953,
0.49623578786849976,
-0.03433512896299362,
0.8984460234642029,
0.4724700152873993,
-0.7099202871322632,
0.5428908467292786,
0.1375519186258316,
0.022454462945461273,
0.6658304333686829,
-0.6460282802581787,
0.014219429343938828,
-0.053428471088409424,
0.4353693723678589,
-1.1059088706970215,
-0.1853415071964264,
0.3811999261379242,
-0.23143233358860016,
0.05162075161933899,
-0.04710453376173973,
-0.34251073002815247,
-0.2814779281616211,
-0.4774653911590576,
0.6793457865715027,
0.5697811245918274,
-0.5324694514274597,
0.8725613951683044,
0.12705104053020477,
-0.4910220801830292,
-0.29242345690727234,
-0.19146974384784698,
-0.005965852178633213,
-0.15623904764652252,
-0.6367992758750916,
0.48184630274772644,
-0.5251509547233582,
0.06595383584499359,
-0.4029708504676819,
-0.11886550486087799,
0.12832358479499817,
0.021151147782802582,
0.327576220035553,
0.34987133741378784,
-0.05490276962518692,
0.12905572354793549,
0.5148981809616089,
-0.3344731032848358,
0.25836268067359924,
-0.2426384836435318,
0.5003772377967834,
0.15461288392543793,
-0.48009660840034485,
-0.7614187598228455,
0.29076772928237915,
0.38520312309265137,
-0.14633946120738983,
0.09971340745687485,
0.23203277587890625,
-0.3701048791408539,
-0.6656692028045654,
-0.6336181163787842,
-0.3921736776828766,
-0.6386047005653381,
-0.07132357358932495,
-0.4883292615413666,
-0.5005089044570923,
0.5604982376098633,
-0.4882872998714447,
0.36734631657600403,
0.377000629901886,
0.34480616450309753,
0.1992470622062683,
1.1223727464675903,
0.39010509848594666,
0.34441864490509033,
0.48577192425727844,
-0.04116274043917656,
0.07921074330806732,
-1.0031747817993164,
-0.2244943380355835,
-0.5605969429016113,
-0.2273821085691452,
-0.2792382836341858,
-0.2636995315551758,
0.6812214255332947,
-0.3803156018257141,
-0.26098063588142395,
0.30378201603889465,
-0.6398465037345886,
0.5110384225845337,
0.5985994338989258,
0.19446714222431183,
0.2658216655254364,
-0.19201859831809998,
-0.44451284408569336,
-0.21964940428733826,
-0.47218188643455505,
-0.7899118661880493,
0.8450599908828735,
0.19859644770622253,
0.8195109963417053,
-0.3082772493362427,
0.6081722378730774,
0.4222068190574646,
0.24280555546283722,
-0.7610027194023132,
0.7049130201339722,
0.23027318716049194,
-0.25929948687553406,
-0.2609575390815735,
-0.511245608329773,
-0.6964566707611084,
0.000019325838366057724,
0.0129814762622118,
-0.6059447526931763,
0.38139793276786804,
0.347344309091568,
-0.7819153666496277,
-0.19642022252082825,
-0.944926381111145,
0.9023570418357849,
-0.3120535910129547,
-0.45798635482788086,
0.2739226222038269,
-0.5341708660125732,
0.021983912214636803,
-0.22280439734458923,
0.08430380374193192,
-0.23247495293617249,
-0.14119940996170044,
0.44727692008018494,
-0.43112465739250183,
0.912015438079834,
-0.5223827958106995,
-0.4935693144798279,
0.4089711010456085,
0.12446653842926025,
0.6820783019065857,
0.23991750180721283,
-0.5494052767753601,
-0.34793853759765625,
-0.12024790048599243,
-0.024692190811038017,
-0.773980975151062,
0.788853108882904,
-0.3424839377403259,
-0.6787554025650024,
-0.11887860298156738,
-0.6080019474029541,
-0.30577996373176575,
0.2992545962333679,
0.1963559091091156,
0.644003689289093,
-0.13475185632705688,
-0.24254915118217468,
0.4966503977775574,
-0.32939064502716064,
0.44652581214904785,
0.511058509349823,
-0.004141443874686956,
-0.342563271522522,
0.7810376882553101,
-0.16028855741024017,
0.057399943470954895,
0.14305022358894348,
0.21699680387973785,
-0.5169203877449036,
-0.36105212569236755,
-0.6829774975776672,
0.027006668969988823,
-0.680921733379364,
-0.41649073362350464,
-0.6451108455657959,
-0.10096769034862518,
-0.39338764548301697,
-0.38924720883369446,
-0.13309942185878754,
-0.28770002722740173,
-0.4669031798839569,
0.26357120275497437,
0.23912638425827026,
0.1683812141418457,
0.1420772224664688,
0.43843159079551697,
-0.7400130033493042,
0.18910302221775055,
0.23526827991008759,
0.2495850920677185,
-0.37079861760139465,
-0.6148423552513123,
0.1524471491575241,
0.2288210690021515,
-0.48036158084869385,
-0.9062643647193909,
0.266379714012146,
0.12993749976158142,
0.7674255967140198,
0.06292656809091568,
0.6386474370956421,
0.33110108971595764,
-0.6347684264183044,
0.6851770281791687,
-0.17466886341571808,
-0.9295413494110107,
0.7767913341522217,
-0.24043188989162445,
0.46655797958374023,
0.928756594657898,
0.24881583452224731,
-0.3767237365245819,
-0.2195650339126587,
-0.28142815828323364,
-0.9813735485076904,
0.6259907484054565,
0.03231997787952423,
0.13512645661830902,
0.19955983757972717,
0.7538555264472961,
0.3836369812488556,
0.12098827958106995,
-0.4572218358516693,
-0.2232551872730255,
0.056764740496873856,
-0.6682190299034119,
0.24037334322929382,
-0.025383519008755684,
-0.0840211734175682,
-0.01654919795691967,
0.891627311706543,
-0.4404045343399048,
0.0314544141292572,
0.30501362681388855,
-0.33562156558036804,
-0.18409781157970428,
0.11873140186071396,
0.6371943354606628,
0.4665236175060272,
-0.06900675594806671,
-0.13897596299648285,
0.3998548984527588,
-0.5376342535018921,
0.4467340409755707,
0.2271634191274643,
-0.4976883828639984,
0.03221762180328369,
-0.06134166941046715,
0.8890736699104309,
-0.13659848272800446,
-0.7642751932144165,
0.5101447105407715,
-0.18000175058841705,
-0.08496886491775513,
-0.07005342841148376,
0.3345637619495392,
-0.5663380026817322,
0.2831643223762512,
0.4661405384540558,
-0.04872621223330498,
0.5691280961036682,
-0.06412266939878464,
0.19541025161743164,
0.4392029345035553,
-0.21691235899925232,
-0.3122653365135193,
0.4953504204750061,
0.5742203593254089,
-0.48650306463241577,
0.22343650460243225,
-0.37267178297042847,
-0.47287848591804504,
0.5820615887641907,
0.4909575283527374,
1.2053617238998413,
-0.40420955419540405,
0.28131404519081116,
0.5132408738136292,
0.2609507739543915,
0.1715441644191742,
0.40802398324012756,
-0.2299027144908905,
-0.4209739863872528,
-0.6236168146133423,
-0.5185526013374329,
-0.6626057028770447,
-0.10884905606508255,
-0.28972765803337097,
0.5411463379859924,
-0.26980993151664734,
-0.4832640290260315,
-0.3795478045940399,
-0.011506311595439911,
-0.5180023908615112,
0.2810579836368561,
-0.014027277007699013,
0.9616526961326599,
-0.8574895262718201,
0.016699692234396935,
0.8396384716033936,
0.24532082676887512,
-0.6665846109390259,
0.06453938037157059,
-0.08715490251779556,
-0.5287284851074219,
0.5608211159706116,
0.4687274098396301,
-0.2800702452659607,
0.27661463618278503,
-0.2912728190422058,
-0.6912783980369568,
0.9576653838157654,
0.5074769854545593,
-0.5796340107917786,
-0.0793265700340271,
0.06550673395395279,
0.23412872850894928,
-0.5385560989379883,
0.5609132051467896,
0.24591247737407684,
0.6793795228004456,
0.09364369511604309,
-0.9221982955932617,
0.45126500725746155,
-0.2438134253025055,
0.019440753385424614,
0.16809393465518951,
-0.3701491355895996,
0.2710244953632355,
-0.1506742388010025,
-0.38456499576568604,
0.05745171755552292,
0.5611653327941895,
0.5747221112251282,
0.4185810387134552,
0.7674722075462341,
0.1525559425354004,
0.5901907682418823,
-0.19345587491989136,
0.5280622243881226,
-0.5868903994560242,
0.24291348457336426,
1.0010558366775513,
-0.5441023707389832,
0.2753516733646393,
0.5019787549972534,
0.28644654154777527,
0.44389116764068604,
0.8655554056167603,
0.18995103240013123,
0.5702442526817322,
0.3470832407474518,
-0.4196898341178894,
-0.3204253911972046,
-0.31637340784072876,
-0.13515199720859528,
0.006928130518645048,
0.33125537633895874,
-0.17125080525875092,
-0.4193878769874573,
0.36273133754730225,
-0.41600897908210754,
0.026405110955238342,
-0.17295275628566742,
0.7078198194503784,
-0.14946770668029785,
-0.9662864804267883,
0.38162723183631897,
-0.05105412006378174,
0.507084846496582,
-0.43829092383384705,
0.00620871689170599,
-0.0538066066801548,
-0.1533822864294052,
-0.10461646318435669,
-0.6309685707092285,
-0.045796092599630356,
0.003483295440673828,
0.06457627564668655,
-0.4881909489631653,
0.6881667375564575,
-0.2667228579521179,
-0.2226879745721817,
-0.09992890805006027,
0.3975887894630432,
-0.1470654159784317,
-0.21331752836704254,
-0.5353611707687378,
0.18170325458049774,
-0.020372629165649414,
-0.5493602156639099,
-0.37415894865989685,
0.5495685935020447,
-0.0623563788831234,
0.5592530965805054,
0.6374838948249817,
0.027172677218914032,
-0.13845038414001465,
0.1342085897922516,
0.8672294020652771,
-0.48201653361320496,
-0.6447358727455139,
-0.8459487557411194,
0.7439590096473694,
-0.038275595754384995,
-0.3385108411312103,
0.46489641070365906,
0.6776765584945679,
0.4342708885669708,
0.07172609120607376,
0.7529237270355225,
0.21617460250854492,
0.3383568525314331,
-0.6087921857833862,
0.2451028972864151,
-0.4056384563446045,
0.3293493390083313,
-0.08946747332811356,
-1.1502493619918823,
-0.3460324704647064,
0.546090304851532,
-0.5330968499183655,
0.24509553611278534,
0.6051202416419983,
0.940822184085846,
-0.11911410838365555,
0.05526411533355713,
-0.026016563177108765,
-0.25402429699897766,
0.42696866393089294,
0.44995275139808655,
0.729762613773346,
-0.3125886917114258,
0.263153076171875,
-0.14329443871974945,
-0.6306591629981995,
-0.33032166957855225,
-1.1473912000656128,
-0.5936083793640137,
-0.6296582221984863,
-0.49972108006477356,
-0.08128133416175842,
-0.021563945338129997,
1.3085782527923584,
0.6805891394615173,
-0.6193298697471619,
-0.09715107828378677,
-0.10358470678329468,
-0.0919480249285698,
0.04977262392640114,
-0.2696235477924347,
0.16644129157066345,
-0.6231213808059692,
-0.7936540842056274,
0.5016257762908936,
0.2897527515888214,
0.2513464689254761,
-0.2102506011724472,
-0.04096866399049759,
0.2311021387577057,
0.3203153610229492,
0.47602829337120056,
0.23233500123023987,
-0.47902798652648926,
-0.18030084669589996,
0.41191503405570984,
-0.19766107201576233,
-0.1089259460568428,
0.7352247834205627,
-0.9349938631057739,
0.5095415115356445,
0.750266969203949,
0.6662662029266357,
0.08058622479438782,
0.23520687222480774,
0.824154257774353,
-0.8172231912612915,
-0.25270798802375793,
0.4066295921802521,
0.2648814022541046,
0.2867596447467804,
-0.6466663479804993,
0.23041406273841858,
-0.07152808457612991,
-0.7408818602561951,
-0.980067253112793,
0.27768415212631226,
-0.9506687521934509,
0.0043670362792909145,
1.2129528522491455,
0.05321134254336357,
-0.30101343989372253,
-0.0066430941224098206,
-0.8513023853302002,
0.3486972153186798,
-0.6403716206550598,
0.7592088580131531,
0.470151424407959,
-0.21344797313213348,
0.041060250252485275,
-0.5428785681724548,
0.4923720061779022,
0.49696874618530273,
-0.9779247641563416,
0.17213432490825653,
0.7046881914138794,
0.02076021023094654,
0.0684628039598465,
0.3241420090198517,
0.2340402752161026,
0.49464529752731323,
-0.7358037829399109,
0.1588502675294876,
-0.18608668446540833,
-0.3820321261882782,
-0.2878580391407013,
0.04663803428411484,
-0.12543486058712006,
-0.22835375368595123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03407v1 | Enhancing the Stability of LLM-based Speech Generation Systems through Self-Supervised Representations | 2024-02-05T15:08:19 | 2024-02-05T15:08:19 | Álvaro Martín-Cortinas, Daniel Sáez-Trigueros, Iván Vallés-Pérez, Biel Tura-Vecino, Piotr Biliński, Mateusz Lajszczak, Grzegorz Beringer, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are one of the most promising technologies for
the next era of speech generation systems, due to their scalability and
in-context learning capabilities. Nevertheless, they suffer from multiple
stability issues at inference time, such as hallucinations, content skipping or
speech repetitions. In this work, we introduce a new self-supervised Voice
Conversion (VC) architecture which can be used to learn to encode transitory
features, such as content, separately from stationary ones, such as speaker ID
or recording conditions, creating speaker-disentangled representations. Using
speaker-disentangled codes to train LLMs for text-to-speech (TTS) allows the
LLM to generate the content and the style of the speech only from the text,
similarly to humans, while the speaker identity is provided by the decoder of
the VC model. Results show that LLMs trained over speaker-disentangled
self-supervised representations provide an improvement of 4.7pp in speaker
similarity over SOTA entangled representations, and a word error rate (WER)
5.4pp lower. Furthermore, they achieve higher naturalness than human recordings
of the LibriTTS test-other dataset. Finally, we show that using explicit
reference embedding negatively impacts intelligibility (stability), with WER
increasing by 14pp compared to the model that only uses text to infer the
style. | [
-0.3220446705818176,
-0.4850107431411743,
0.3515872359275818,
0.3198237121105194,
-0.2706112265586853,
0.05941758677363396,
-0.45115548372268677,
-0.08088111877441406,
0.1592569351196289,
0.5848482847213745,
-0.3927415907382965,
-0.38763323426246643,
-0.4740915596485138,
0.3113838732242584,
-0.5483766198158264,
0.6390036940574646,
0.4408424198627472,
0.21200431883335114,
-0.44624292850494385,
0.12035462260246277,
-0.19346611201763153,
-0.7314265370368958,
-0.46881741285324097,
-0.2649083733558655,
0.17146846652030945,
0.1856660097837448,
0.4212261438369751,
0.5211532711982727,
0.05426530912518501,
0.4384114742279053,
-0.009904338046908379,
0.326788991689682,
-0.6280028820037842,
0.4720478951931,
0.0426265150308609,
-0.13768045604228973,
-0.2956644594669342,
-0.12442681938409805,
0.7319422960281372,
0.32471907138824463,
-0.4582587480545044,
0.031620532274246216,
0.4626235365867615,
0.4453376233577728,
-0.3899381160736084,
0.290554940700531,
-0.8234275579452515,
-0.1335468292236328,
-0.1950976550579071,
-0.4063068628311157,
-0.8673315048217773,
-0.15363362431526184,
0.057626549154520035,
-0.3075082004070282,
0.024218663573265076,
-0.23641757667064667,
0.49993467330932617,
0.6889913082122803,
-0.2651812434196472,
-0.1455310434103012,
-0.8293362259864807,
0.40148231387138367,
-0.7541963458061218,
0.6426013708114624,
0.3859140872955322,
0.28487181663513184,
-0.36918511986732483,
-0.471250057220459,
-0.5281939506530762,
-0.16156862676143646,
0.06907392293214798,
0.34813758730888367,
-0.029254894703626633,
0.10997427999973297,
-0.0033476960379630327,
0.04608668386936188,
-0.278687983751297,
0.3254929780960083,
-0.24828460812568665,
-0.3085908591747284,
0.6627877950668335,
-0.10844995081424713,
-0.10094231367111206,
-0.3619881570339203,
-0.2853708863258362,
-0.24577032029628754,
-0.7724716067314148,
-0.1402529925107956,
0.3664427697658539,
0.5671725869178772,
-0.12410728633403778,
0.32023683190345764,
0.1118483692407608,
0.37626203894615173,
0.680989682674408,
-0.2935319244861603,
0.3691047430038452,
0.049666889011859894,
-0.10262030363082886,
0.650085985660553,
0.96761155128479,
0.2741594910621643,
0.12004686146974564,
-0.21623125672340393,
0.028674686327576637,
-0.1404157131910324,
0.1814320832490921,
-0.9050925970077515,
-0.027165671810507774,
0.09381777048110962,
-0.38590705394744873,
-0.08310721814632416,
0.12029416114091873,
-0.5194563269615173,
-0.2738170325756073,
-0.1896733194589615,
0.2887520492076874,
-0.4517498016357422,
-0.3377995193004608,
0.14502139389514923,
0.28870245814323425,
0.0638989806175232,
0.18045710027217865,
-1.21732497215271,
0.1958509236574173,
0.2805453836917877,
0.6162209510803223,
-0.13383162021636963,
-0.23317451775074005,
-0.6815947890281677,
0.550180196762085,
-0.4574786424636841,
0.2235027402639389,
-0.1950618326663971,
-0.47961676120758057,
0.0918428972363472,
0.005105435848236084,
0.07240121811628342,
-0.5920683145523071,
0.1927252560853958,
-0.4494525194168091,
0.03512610122561455,
0.03835270553827286,
-0.6389262676239014,
0.2154344618320465,
-0.1553260087966919,
-0.4890355169773102,
0.7634855508804321,
-0.2244049310684204,
-0.5564931035041809,
0.10572975873947144,
-0.12204835563898087,
-0.21222876012325287,
-0.12184000015258789,
-0.546676516532898,
-0.5437623858451843,
0.2857798933982849,
0.2169361710548401,
0.7333284616470337,
0.04423762857913971,
0.4744436740875244,
-0.2602579593658447,
-0.3553670048713684,
0.18358640372753143,
-0.6149029731750488,
0.4567900598049164,
0.21436887979507446,
-0.43655475974082947,
-0.2574954628944397,
-0.8801851868629456,
-0.15133793652057648,
0.0802660584449768,
-0.5065187215805054,
-0.1954132467508316,
0.24228134751319885,
-0.25229743123054504,
0.15258190035820007,
0.2151591032743454,
-0.5618327260017395,
0.04926253482699394,
-0.3847278356552124,
0.5392125248908997,
0.7510867118835449,
-0.023432429879903793,
0.3170432150363922,
-0.03531990945339203,
0.25525030493736267,
0.2267187535762787,
-0.20221784710884094,
-0.2427232265472412,
-0.3411009907722473,
-0.8373527526855469,
-0.05137602984905243,
0.29111447930336,
0.2780655324459076,
-0.7707193493843079,
0.7147735357284546,
-0.48924463987350464,
-0.2993422746658325,
-0.7024210095405579,
0.15373335778713226,
0.2880663275718689,
0.46096283197402954,
0.28279799222946167,
-0.09572280198335648,
-0.5244489312171936,
-0.7342995405197144,
0.18204282224178314,
-0.46057283878326416,
-0.009571600705385208,
-0.06465215235948563,
0.05761159583926201,
-0.382535845041275,
0.9874542951583862,
0.12411924451589584,
-0.28864216804504395,
0.060582734644412994,
0.049767620861530304,
0.045545998960733414,
0.5521650910377502,
0.5006164312362671,
-0.637667715549469,
-0.28414177894592285,
-0.12118565291166306,
-0.5133546590805054,
-0.16012728214263916,
-0.17676793038845062,
0.17263343930244446,
0.35728904604911804,
0.6855902075767517,
-0.42635688185691833,
0.25110241770744324,
0.9777845144271851,
-0.04218399524688721,
0.14216136932373047,
-0.28179481625556946,
-0.023739583790302277,
-1.1458607912063599,
-0.31795233488082886,
-0.08896782994270325,
-0.43014776706695557,
-0.4721795320510864,
-0.5314032435417175,
0.053430937230587006,
-0.07257416099309921,
-0.4427608847618103,
-0.004517694003880024,
-0.4342834949493408,
0.00874218251556158,
-0.19734470546245575,
0.3258972764015198,
0.014232903718948364,
0.24070769548416138,
0.1595889776945114,
0.9465674161911011,
0.5990458130836487,
-0.6608151793479919,
0.3264630138874054,
0.34651851654052734,
0.08755568414926529,
0.32434985041618347,
-0.4330644905567169,
0.4234992265701294,
-0.2920193076133728,
0.18078619241714478,
-0.7876789569854736,
-0.07006389647722244,
-0.08623642474412918,
-0.6620469689369202,
0.7138884663581848,
-0.15203645825386047,
-0.6056836247444153,
-0.050512902438640594,
-0.11690115183591843,
0.03870757296681404,
0.6210213303565979,
-0.8779920935630798,
0.622380256652832,
0.4115988612174988,
0.10712572187185287,
-0.3079635500907898,
-0.975385308265686,
0.14628075063228607,
-0.15897855162620544,
-0.5700215101242065,
0.5700432062149048,
-0.10259721428155899,
-0.0018844386795535684,
-0.024574363604187965,
-0.10431070625782013,
0.25574979186058044,
-0.05621897056698799,
0.4585874378681183,
-0.015923870727419853,
-0.06042923033237457,
0.4598138928413391,
0.17350567877292633,
-0.2020135521888733,
0.08206871151924133,
-0.28963813185691833,
0.49576303362846375,
-0.10940790921449661,
-0.36767977476119995,
-0.47953224182128906,
0.23904329538345337,
0.5653507709503174,
-0.2096087634563446,
0.6723188161849976,
0.5233444571495056,
-0.1318994164466858,
-0.4192346930503845,
-0.5815677046775818,
-0.1919260174036026,
-0.5961834192276001,
0.379186749458313,
-0.41045644879341125,
-1.251805067062378,
0.4252552092075348,
-0.16642238199710846,
-0.19814327359199524,
0.3946188986301422,
0.8129720091819763,
-0.30356931686401367,
0.8281921744346619,
0.45001429319381714,
-0.17450734972953796,
0.3663387596607208,
-0.2160438597202301,
0.028469154611229897,
-0.7532049417495728,
-0.3546026945114136,
-0.26295337080955505,
0.10172850638628006,
-0.9040948152542114,
-0.5600483417510986,
0.21959523856639862,
-0.0700099915266037,
-0.29276955127716064,
0.23531635105609894,
-0.7594611048698425,
0.0017811021534726024,
0.4128870368003845,
0.019766848534345627,
0.22766467928886414,
0.18598222732543945,
0.10727426409721375,
-0.20999200642108917,
-0.6306741833686829,
-0.6264703273773193,
0.898897647857666,
0.542998731136322,
1.0524578094482422,
0.09505259990692139,
1.1197608709335327,
0.2839290499687195,
-0.1842726469039917,
-0.432077556848526,
0.6035043001174927,
-0.5039058923721313,
-0.334879070520401,
-0.4081619083881378,
-0.5228343605995178,
-0.8027894496917725,
0.127640038728714,
-0.2887543737888336,
-0.6768574714660645,
0.24627645313739777,
0.2049005776643753,
-0.3591565787792206,
0.14322230219841003,
-0.5815476775169373,
0.27804312109947205,
-0.4732564389705658,
-0.468382328748703,
-0.054514698684215546,
-0.45837321877479553,
0.019971057772636414,
-0.04358454421162605,
0.07954569160938263,
0.008793615736067295,
0.17343682050704956,
0.7380329966545105,
-0.23023687303066254,
1.0130717754364014,
-0.17502908408641815,
-0.463797390460968,
0.46151483058929443,
0.04638102650642395,
0.3153798580169678,
0.20793594419956207,
-0.3281216323375702,
0.25858160853385925,
-0.1332118660211563,
0.13549388945102692,
-0.6670165657997131,
0.951832115650177,
-1.0827959775924683,
-0.8773179650306702,
-0.1804136335849762,
-0.16737021505832672,
-0.33485928177833557,
0.04416108876466751,
0.2197064906358719,
0.48229143023490906,
-0.08326661586761475,
0.6314882040023804,
0.8636012673377991,
0.08762338757514954,
0.5117254257202148,
0.3182089030742645,
-0.3126119375228882,
-0.627879798412323,
0.8241112232208252,
0.3012148439884186,
0.47782060503959656,
0.27095943689346313,
0.07971721887588501,
-0.6428530216217041,
-0.6985552906990051,
-0.46294477581977844,
0.13201215863227844,
-0.6857175827026367,
-0.13876113295555115,
-0.3368966281414032,
-0.5334317088127136,
-0.5686752200126648,
0.31892839074134827,
-0.701974093914032,
-0.25388917326927185,
-0.7687142491340637,
-0.26413801312446594,
0.2731465697288513,
0.6808317303657532,
-0.18764430284500122,
0.40320470929145813,
-0.7792505025863647,
0.25509029626846313,
0.6091166734695435,
0.2013716846704483,
-0.3203718066215515,
-0.758728563785553,
-0.36696094274520874,
-0.09145446121692657,
-0.3212800621986389,
-0.918968677520752,
0.3011222779750824,
0.434072345495224,
0.5387202501296997,
0.4451931118965149,
0.19107352197170258,
0.8971904516220093,
-0.6464288234710693,
0.6798062920570374,
0.29682284593582153,
-1.088521122932434,
0.5473498106002808,
-0.43516066670417786,
0.09288724511861801,
0.653895378112793,
-0.05370058864355087,
-0.2375004142522812,
-0.3675196170806885,
-0.4414029121398926,
-0.5267223119735718,
0.6554898619651794,
0.2755628824234009,
0.4595474898815155,
-0.06636672466993332,
0.46702131628990173,
-0.041445836424827576,
0.16615772247314453,
-0.7986094355583191,
-0.34817972779273987,
-0.7303516864776611,
-0.2750447988510132,
-0.10365447402000427,
-0.4322682321071625,
0.06530997902154922,
-0.1279609501361847,
0.6269285678863525,
-0.2839090824127197,
0.1730085015296936,
0.34641700983047485,
0.2711602747440338,
-0.12900570034980774,
0.21152321994304657,
0.42183831334114075,
0.30679038166999817,
-0.31161195039749146,
0.4679461121559143,
0.17861437797546387,
-0.3060614764690399,
0.4346935749053955,
0.05830051749944687,
-0.05694964528083801,
0.11631893366575241,
0.1600533425807953,
0.8885723352432251,
0.19422867894172668,
-0.41224610805511475,
0.3866112232208252,
-0.16963070631027222,
-0.09271471947431564,
-0.449499249458313,
0.06593793630599976,
0.43739357590675354,
0.1977231204509735,
0.370747447013855,
-0.20223239064216614,
-0.03952997550368309,
-0.37697485089302063,
0.22727636992931366,
0.34941568970680237,
-0.22377637028694153,
-0.2718459367752075,
0.7717076539993286,
0.49972978234291077,
-0.2903707027435303,
0.4657956659793854,
-0.15902280807495117,
-0.11195638030767441,
0.11548130959272385,
0.9406422972679138,
0.9934697151184082,
-0.6155845522880554,
0.18455564975738525,
0.24048180878162384,
0.2652161717414856,
-0.05390934646129608,
-0.06911402940750122,
-0.1955525428056717,
-0.6738386154174805,
-0.27579465508461,
-0.6309741735458374,
-0.2871769070625305,
0.07225354015827179,
-0.6016568541526794,
0.2487230747938156,
-0.3908737599849701,
-0.5904152989387512,
-0.6413334608078003,
-0.38030925393104553,
-0.2480686902999878,
0.1530325561761856,
0.6140779256820679,
0.3988451063632965,
-0.6862548589706421,
1.0803500413894653,
0.3604065775871277,
0.023697305470705032,
-0.8494941592216492,
0.09411369264125824,
-0.20709969103336334,
-0.5388590693473816,
0.6573586463928223,
0.26314833760261536,
-0.6545867919921875,
0.11995793133974075,
-0.43063852190971375,
-1.1196341514587402,
1.2731335163116455,
0.9817416071891785,
-1.106083869934082,
0.04677984490990639,
0.3076978623867035,
0.4894264042377472,
-0.4805554747581482,
-0.05071413144469261,
0.39988765120506287,
0.06266213953495026,
0.2946890890598297,
-1.0187201499938965,
-0.07945463061332703,
-0.15256264805793762,
0.26773276925086975,
-0.209732785820961,
-0.7961664199829102,
0.6460613012313843,
0.1448359340429306,
-0.3751722276210785,
-0.13476505875587463,
0.985127866268158,
0.6126267910003662,
0.023333823308348656,
0.4490691125392914,
0.5735337138175964,
0.6241317987442017,
-0.0804678350687027,
0.48178011178970337,
-0.5127492547035217,
0.41620349884033203,
1.2138453722000122,
-0.11219239234924316,
0.9046235084533691,
0.6997327208518982,
-0.043829545378685,
0.5500715374946594,
0.35242459177970886,
0.015735691413283348,
0.7493617534637451,
0.19747920334339142,
-0.03963245823979378,
-0.6507672667503357,
0.06399542838335037,
-0.5335096120834351,
0.798596978187561,
0.3296956419944763,
-0.5165067911148071,
-0.04277295246720314,
0.0576884001493454,
-0.126379132270813,
0.41293203830718994,
-0.06867945194244385,
0.6993400454521179,
0.26141899824142456,
-0.22767439484596252,
0.7954796552658081,
-0.38855573534965515,
0.7142379879951477,
-0.6773205995559692,
-0.054197996854782104,
0.17232809960842133,
0.12715989351272583,
-0.2490977793931961,
-0.5186300277709961,
0.1420789361000061,
-0.059531137347221375,
-0.22129939496517181,
-0.3383817672729492,
0.5938313603401184,
-0.5013716220855713,
-0.5266480445861816,
0.6600867509841919,
0.3950626850128174,
0.025716863572597504,
0.37322792410850525,
-0.37388136982917786,
0.44636815786361694,
-0.00134404341224581,
-0.29417091608047485,
0.2918570935726166,
0.6189458966255188,
0.2812388837337494,
0.6272595524787903,
0.3511471748352051,
0.17179569602012634,
0.31098470091819763,
0.21817921102046967,
0.9402713179588318,
-0.4046188294887543,
-0.4747580289840698,
-1.0627353191375732,
0.40680572390556335,
-0.0344303622841835,
0.09016596525907516,
0.9818847179412842,
0.39233389496803284,
0.6982544660568237,
0.10247449576854706,
0.721635103225708,
0.09738347679376602,
0.20247361063957214,
-0.7533036470413208,
0.9010013937950134,
-0.4137955605983734,
0.4193269908428192,
-0.2947230637073517,
-0.7084417939186096,
-0.05680723860859871,
0.5755820870399475,
0.009545008651912212,
0.13015742599964142,
0.1668606996536255,
0.6303354501724243,
0.3591928780078888,
-0.24402037262916565,
0.6572812795639038,
0.31197285652160645,
0.5861437320709229,
0.20904111862182617,
0.9070459604263306,
-0.3093665838241577,
0.5915807485580444,
-0.28019416332244873,
0.030086379498243332,
-0.13762398064136505,
-0.8332775831222534,
-1.0967333316802979,
-0.7495753765106201,
-0.37610432505607605,
-0.3082454204559326,
0.1443113386631012,
0.8809657096862793,
0.9278663396835327,
-0.6020990014076233,
-0.269481897354126,
-0.03934751823544502,
-0.3468317985534668,
0.2241084724664688,
-0.11299055814743042,
0.31724411249160767,
-0.2819373905658722,
-0.7106092572212219,
0.7168295383453369,
0.4798089861869812,
0.3157200813293457,
-0.6745308041572571,
-0.46106621623039246,
0.22090497612953186,
0.02314513735473156,
0.44511348009109497,
-0.03941217064857483,
-0.8458729386329651,
-0.43837302923202515,
-0.07710906118154526,
-0.044442396610975266,
0.2505247890949249,
0.3187047243118286,
-0.869123101234436,
0.8014883399009705,
0.14144794642925262,
0.6863462924957275,
0.6897947192192078,
0.23068781197071075,
0.35215693712234497,
-0.8109940886497498,
0.23641987144947052,
0.2918022871017456,
0.39914020895957947,
0.5577650666236877,
-0.3899563252925873,
-0.03590012714266777,
0.0320369154214859,
-0.6926771402359009,
-0.5860564112663269,
0.10519805550575256,
-1.0240567922592163,
0.10231700539588928,
1.0497329235076904,
-0.1695360243320465,
-0.3891240060329437,
0.10269998759031296,
-0.06447573751211166,
0.42034995555877686,
-0.642579197883606,
0.8305878639221191,
0.28860190510749817,
-0.2289385348558426,
-0.3902001678943634,
-0.09323263168334961,
0.4467964470386505,
0.2961159646511078,
-0.4962541162967682,
0.25786155462265015,
0.43932273983955383,
0.09692088514566422,
0.611369788646698,
0.6714461445808411,
-0.1325877457857132,
0.031481169164180756,
-0.08955644816160202,
0.07604765892028809,
-0.3506523072719574,
-0.3016435503959656,
-0.40584081411361694,
0.09089254587888718,
0.21612463891506195,
-0.479694128036499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03067v1 | Multilingual transformer and BERTopic for short text topic modeling: The case of Serbian | 2024-02-05T14:59:29 | 2024-02-05T14:59:29 | Darija Medvecki, Bojana Bašaragin, Adela Ljajić, Nikola Milošević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents the results of the first application of BERTopic, a
state-of-the-art topic modeling technique, to short text written in a
morphologi-cally rich language. We applied BERTopic with three multilingual
embed-ding models on two levels of text preprocessing (partial and full) to
evalu-ate its performance on partially preprocessed short text in Serbian. We
also compared it to LDA and NMF on fully preprocessed text. The experiments
were conducted on a dataset of tweets expressing hesitancy toward COVID-19
vaccination. Our results show that with adequate parameter setting, BERTopic
can yield informative topics even when applied to partially pre-processed short
text. When the same parameters are applied in both prepro-cessing scenarios,
the performance drop on partially preprocessed text is minimal. Compared to LDA
and NMF, judging by the keywords, BERTopic offers more informative topics and
gives novel insights when the number of topics is not limited. The findings of
this paper can be significant for re-searchers working with other
morphologically rich low-resource languages and short text. | [
-0.5376806259155273,
-0.8717684149742126,
0.4520385265350342,
0.33078569173812866,
-0.6185502409934998,
-0.048971474170684814,
-0.40664297342300415,
-0.4359354078769684,
0.7103541493415833,
0.27585989236831665,
-0.5609579086303711,
-0.47359561920166016,
-0.6056602001190186,
0.15328504145145416,
-0.34540390968322754,
1.1616599559783936,
0.05282524600625038,
-0.044178519397974014,
-0.09932515025138855,
0.14588730037212372,
-0.18157422542572021,
-0.6438484191894531,
-0.14638665318489075,
-0.1460292786359787,
0.5313763618469238,
0.5879095196723938,
0.6882898807525635,
-0.030359050258994102,
0.44916412234306335,
0.15214446187019348,
-0.1959838718175888,
-0.35511690378189087,
-0.2972947061061859,
0.3689296245574951,
-0.38367554545402527,
-0.3291674852371216,
-0.30936306715011597,
-0.12144830822944641,
0.5567103028297424,
0.47597846388816833,
0.054598383605480194,
0.09432120621204376,
-0.23647308349609375,
0.4340781271457672,
-0.37295204401016235,
0.03867814689874649,
-0.6060656905174255,
0.11046530306339264,
-0.49411919713020325,
-0.24686333537101746,
-0.42585670948028564,
-0.13689441978931427,
0.5957083702087402,
-0.3318589925765991,
0.21524301171302795,
-0.1631467491388321,
0.8153753876686096,
0.09410195052623749,
-0.269777774810791,
-0.4022110104560852,
-0.4685766398906708,
0.932757556438446,
-0.8535154461860657,
0.13864204287528992,
0.271345317363739,
0.12213670462369919,
0.10284502059221268,
-0.6802058815956116,
-0.3554842472076416,
-0.09324926137924194,
0.04466160759329796,
0.16110625863075256,
-0.48929563164711,
0.05743774399161339,
0.007986600510776043,
0.05470508337020874,
-0.6380487084388733,
0.07403504103422165,
-0.5258255004882812,
-0.23708680272102356,
0.4642846882343292,
-0.10438890010118484,
0.36344417929649353,
-0.5164206027984619,
-0.1008610874414444,
0.10194680094718933,
-0.4887513518333435,
-0.13677728176116943,
0.4129900336265564,
0.5347648859024048,
-0.07537582516670227,
0.6786583662033081,
-0.128198504447937,
0.70191890001297,
-0.17995360493659973,
-0.3422636091709137,
0.32730722427368164,
-0.5323861837387085,
0.04765557125210762,
-0.004672119859606028,
0.49075037240982056,
-0.0984577015042305,
0.16024191677570343,
-0.15104757249355316,
0.1572679728269577,
-0.19038093090057373,
0.43759211897850037,
-1.0168135166168213,
-0.3960113525390625,
0.003456713631749153,
-0.7745355367660522,
-0.13717021048069,
0.021551530808210373,
-1.184309720993042,
0.10058973729610443,
0.06715427339076996,
0.3345949947834015,
-0.36351341009140015,
0.15609578788280487,
0.0013469633413478732,
0.0583740696310997,
-0.023273516446352005,
0.25956615805625916,
-1.0065228939056396,
0.10733945667743683,
0.5958876609802246,
0.950751006603241,
-0.22093498706817627,
-0.12070878595113754,
-0.18024656176567078,
0.009650825522840023,
-0.1954421103000641,
0.9126508235931396,
-0.7197425365447998,
-0.17879438400268555,
0.20342876017093658,
-0.03537581115961075,
0.02755291759967804,
-0.2152121514081955,
0.9409474730491638,
-0.5087450742721558,
0.5245360732078552,
-0.1051831990480423,
-0.27874141931533813,
-0.1659121960401535,
0.32674640417099,
-0.7967972755432129,
0.9429267644882202,
-0.05156523361802101,
-1.2256609201431274,
0.4380357265472412,
-0.7304174900054932,
-0.5443381667137146,
-0.00031541375210508704,
-0.05599866434931755,
-0.4788295030593872,
-0.02243313565850258,
0.3015645444393158,
0.6301376223564148,
-0.23748569190502167,
0.4260108470916748,
-0.1876363903284073,
-0.2294710874557495,
-0.08146483451128006,
-0.3970790207386017,
0.37762439250946045,
0.13194774091243744,
-0.20802222192287445,
0.28095096349716187,
-0.4277295172214508,
-0.01728261075913906,
-0.07833720743656158,
-0.36516404151916504,
-0.5876599550247192,
0.21736888587474823,
0.3482264280319214,
0.4781157076358795,
0.39201825857162476,
-0.5625647902488708,
0.31914806365966797,
-0.6167146563529968,
0.40578722953796387,
0.26334479451179504,
0.0829700231552124,
0.4565746784210205,
-0.16455502808094025,
0.6191985011100769,
0.024196360260248184,
0.13657470047473907,
-0.23531214892864227,
-1.0181198120117188,
-0.47299402952194214,
-0.39167550206184387,
0.5429505705833435,
0.5776097774505615,
-1.1057560443878174,
0.14059798419475555,
-0.05474146828055382,
-0.5777235627174377,
-0.4623189866542816,
-0.2689730226993561,
0.19613759219646454,
0.25168734788894653,
0.17219646275043488,
-0.1965743899345398,
-0.6388030052185059,
-1.1284070014953613,
0.041824646294116974,
-0.24798326194286346,
0.2047479897737503,
0.24799925088882446,
0.6553142666816711,
-0.377246618270874,
0.8576943278312683,
-0.4207651913166046,
-0.03819895163178444,
-0.5900810956954956,
0.5597279667854309,
0.43392765522003174,
0.34493711590766907,
1.1000858545303345,
-1.0935025215148926,
-0.7062615156173706,
-0.21596704423427582,
-0.06995128095149994,
-0.22418834269046783,
0.07381331920623779,
-0.0992867574095726,
0.5180466771125793,
-0.08111920207738876,
-0.46336978673934937,
0.4257930517196655,
0.7893524169921875,
-0.3066633343696594,
0.5664829611778259,
-0.3809104859828949,
0.1258918195962906,
-1.408556342124939,
0.1235489696264267,
0.03099403716623783,
-0.2202213704586029,
-0.9759778380393982,
-0.05408233776688576,
-0.09031584858894348,
-0.5020913481712341,
-0.5688554644584656,
0.515566349029541,
-0.08357954770326614,
-0.08795209974050522,
-0.3915185332298279,
0.07139310240745544,
-0.12156619876623154,
0.18741822242736816,
0.13297736644744873,
0.9854776859283447,
0.5032979249954224,
-0.37790191173553467,
0.1919563114643097,
0.43447592854499817,
-0.4008793532848358,
-0.08541195839643478,
-0.574558675289154,
-0.30138951539993286,
-0.09793391823768616,
0.12484463304281235,
-0.8956581354141235,
-0.27414488792419434,
0.5967976450920105,
-0.22262004017829895,
0.13233019411563873,
-0.28552764654159546,
-0.6907360553741455,
-0.3528542220592499,
-0.41823476552963257,
0.5047694444656372,
0.4249446988105774,
-0.2613492012023926,
0.27721214294433594,
0.33285409212112427,
-0.8747138977050781,
-0.5191680788993835,
-0.6507177352905273,
0.12512177228927612,
-0.2297356277704239,
-0.8032040596008301,
0.7122983932495117,
-0.20821721851825714,
-0.16847646236419678,
0.03189008682966232,
0.1344449520111084,
-0.6195088624954224,
0.18270567059516907,
-0.15079151093959808,
0.16600975394248962,
-0.11724187433719635,
0.2781471908092499,
0.2719595730304718,
-0.06256607919931412,
-0.178168386220932,
-0.12652432918548584,
0.712119996547699,
-0.14337396621704102,
-0.09094168990850449,
-0.269944429397583,
0.803462028503418,
0.35815250873565674,
-0.12108391523361206,
0.911557137966156,
0.6288118958473206,
-0.31091272830963135,
0.1085861325263977,
-0.32537323236465454,
-0.07006862759590149,
-0.26437249779701233,
0.37919020652770996,
-0.2530626952648163,
-0.7778906226158142,
0.6560720801353455,
0.08589178323745728,
-0.1904309093952179,
0.6411908268928528,
0.761803150177002,
-0.041086792945861816,
0.5653813481330872,
1.0979570150375366,
-0.16483666002750397,
0.6376269459724426,
-0.0026964738499373198,
0.5170010328292847,
-0.21889628469944,
-0.24219992756843567,
-0.6904043555259705,
-0.06306874006986618,
-0.8841919898986816,
-0.5113097429275513,
0.34938883781433105,
-0.036106426268815994,
0.39696845412254333,
0.3874299228191376,
-0.29180407524108887,
0.12713873386383057,
0.5847821831703186,
0.004629100207239389,
-0.10753615945577621,
-0.004844835493713617,
0.054321885108947754,
-0.38970547914505005,
-0.9409643411636353,
-0.6885724067687988,
0.7324666380882263,
0.19740381836891174,
0.7224006652832031,
-0.03245426341891289,
0.8287944793701172,
0.3355702757835388,
0.15184496343135834,
-0.8849270939826965,
0.2812228500843048,
-0.5184297561645508,
-0.8239756226539612,
-0.4757908582687378,
-0.07799074053764343,
-0.6088362336158752,
0.4332750737667084,
-0.2827904522418976,
-0.7448796033859253,
0.3796069622039795,
0.05915103107690811,
-0.22608625888824463,
0.27118563652038574,
-0.5300446152687073,
1.014865517616272,
-0.24601002037525177,
-0.01888250932097435,
-0.26095518469810486,
-0.6953068971633911,
0.1239352896809578,
-0.30496901273727417,
0.10913688689470291,
-0.3187350630760193,
-0.11901992559432983,
0.9624239802360535,
0.04226278141140938,
0.7124223113059998,
-0.048281967639923096,
-0.0697857066988945,
0.1141800656914711,
-0.2968975007534027,
0.09753517806529999,
0.31380942463874817,
-0.2502693831920624,
0.1995226889848709,
0.1547337770462036,
-0.4785570800304413,
-0.36703649163246155,
0.43255794048309326,
-0.42908424139022827,
-0.6511079668998718,
-0.6305863261222839,
-0.4368349015712738,
0.09390982985496521,
0.3908345699310303,
0.36006805300712585,
0.2598370313644409,
-0.4162377715110779,
0.25144872069358826,
0.6947316527366638,
-0.4475937783718109,
0.5150160789489746,
0.3365189731121063,
-0.0581497997045517,
-0.20344474911689758,
0.691940426826477,
0.04539306461811066,
-0.03113637864589691,
0.6470863819122314,
0.31846001744270325,
0.2129490077495575,
-0.5531325340270996,
-0.23563076555728912,
0.24040062725543976,
-0.5520607829093933,
-0.28255555033683777,
-0.671775758266449,
-0.11495129764080048,
-0.46380433440208435,
-0.28642866015434265,
-0.3868906795978546,
-0.5052434802055359,
-0.6231824159622192,
0.20001237094402313,
0.12278018146753311,
0.4635050296783447,
-0.21900859475135803,
0.26873189210891724,
-0.7070423364639282,
0.5094602108001709,
0.006429015658795834,
0.14051838219165802,
-0.31976789236068726,
-0.4133853614330292,
-0.4260365068912506,
0.13905441761016846,
-0.3113841414451599,
-1.0161337852478027,
0.8480632305145264,
0.40249869227409363,
0.6435836553573608,
0.2998928427696228,
0.11013579368591309,
0.3758830428123474,
-0.6322193741798401,
0.8868528008460999,
0.002723365556448698,
-1.0754565000534058,
0.811290442943573,
-0.3033943176269531,
0.1710604429244995,
0.5654601454734802,
0.7147142887115479,
-0.5415135025978088,
-0.3092070519924164,
-0.460508793592453,
-1.1067148447036743,
0.8372313976287842,
0.3785203993320465,
0.29133841395378113,
-0.0872359350323677,
0.18956194818019867,
0.5211407542228699,
0.25741925835609436,
-0.7023587226867676,
-0.26224589347839355,
-0.37929508090019226,
-0.06349054723978043,
-0.1303333342075348,
-1.0840867757797241,
0.05644216015934944,
-0.19346390664577484,
0.8072346448898315,
-0.11065540462732315,
0.5685539841651917,
0.012186473235487938,
-0.15819688141345978,
0.23349250853061676,
0.7590063810348511,
0.9709895849227905,
0.8950799107551575,
-0.3817801773548126,
-0.004829883575439453,
-0.07912780344486237,
-0.3369256258010864,
-0.0680462196469307,
0.36377623677253723,
-0.24023421108722687,
0.6023243069648743,
0.4235631823539734,
0.5920516848564148,
0.5765810608863831,
-0.6417601704597473,
0.66026371717453,
-0.06447430700063705,
-0.1825527399778366,
-0.26876726746559143,
-0.49512895941734314,
-0.11811232566833496,
0.24098265171051025,
0.46434569358825684,
-0.11842064559459686,
0.35721448063850403,
-0.7805464267730713,
0.34399980306625366,
0.19686101377010345,
-0.046772394329309464,
-0.5898699164390564,
0.35189324617385864,
0.3427944481372833,
-0.04657430201768875,
0.3468281924724579,
-0.021273331716656685,
-0.8902032375335693,
0.5853926539421082,
0.5822675228118896,
0.6211047768592834,
-0.018314704298973083,
0.6803012490272522,
0.08387809991836548,
0.2056025117635727,
-0.0125538669526577,
0.5005933046340942,
-0.19940583407878876,
-0.5429851412773132,
-0.5143055319786072,
-0.36104393005371094,
-0.5462026596069336,
-0.14044271409511566,
-0.8608870506286621,
0.050117310136556625,
0.1718585342168808,
-0.3091559112071991,
0.27433010935783386,
0.2491534948348999,
-0.28379786014556885,
0.023463603109121323,
0.08976650983095169,
1.0896804332733154,
-1.0550832748413086,
1.0263382196426392,
0.8319902420043945,
-0.3069651126861572,
-0.07742756605148315,
0.529796302318573,
-0.574961245059967,
-0.3815937042236328,
0.8997559547424316,
0.020858798176050186,
0.2204073667526245,
-0.48918119072914124,
-0.21682649850845337,
-1.03591787815094,
0.8639677166938782,
0.40380361676216125,
-0.28002285957336426,
-0.2774202823638916,
0.0438205860555172,
0.7648592591285706,
-0.13357171416282654,
-0.0286067146807909,
0.3283170163631439,
0.5488936305046082,
0.010664083063602448,
-1.0294965505599976,
-0.3753582537174225,
-0.27325496077537537,
-0.056359175592660904,
0.31193456053733826,
-0.458839476108551,
0.8662536144256592,
-0.11871412396430969,
-0.09325966984033585,
0.42289507389068604,
0.5519996881484985,
-0.04019848257303238,
0.42785465717315674,
-0.0607617124915123,
0.2190641164779663,
0.479974627494812,
-0.17684215307235718,
1.016158103942871,
-0.46428245306015015,
0.520711362361908,
0.7157111167907715,
-0.18208210170269012,
0.8070101737976074,
0.7444780468940735,
0.19354364275932312,
0.3341345489025116,
0.6625061631202698,
0.1503220498561859,
1.047986626625061,
-0.00463135028257966,
-0.1700037270784378,
-0.12901082634925842,
-0.0211363323032856,
-0.31223711371421814,
0.48241284489631653,
0.31762707233428955,
-0.34142759442329407,
-0.4220429062843323,
0.6187776327133179,
0.05429527908563614,
-0.019836170598864555,
-0.22557376325130463,
0.6298775672912598,
-0.1534009575843811,
-0.3892871141433716,
0.0743621289730072,
0.42934346199035645,
0.914055347442627,
-0.5929713249206543,
0.01640024594962597,
-0.09535245597362518,
-0.0521068312227726,
0.14691221714019775,
-0.7792320251464844,
0.7045391201972961,
0.18156155943870544,
-0.6088944673538208,
-0.4803890883922577,
1.0755858421325684,
-0.5010900497436523,
-0.5444731712341309,
0.24812829494476318,
0.4631221890449524,
0.22869952023029327,
0.050985146313905716,
-0.7383440136909485,
-0.036407873034477234,
-0.059969887137413025,
-0.20878492295742035,
0.10969626158475876,
0.48974665999412537,
-0.18542170524597168,
0.7383154034614563,
0.04298081994056702,
0.15159621834754944,
0.13832613825798035,
0.08563897758722305,
0.8712533116340637,
-0.5969677567481995,
-0.6813257932662964,
-0.6148667335510254,
0.20959311723709106,
0.14146210253238678,
-0.1764286905527115,
0.8049226999282837,
0.5016257166862488,
0.7971047759056091,
-0.3610875606536865,
0.7611185312271118,
-0.20065279304981232,
0.5997232794761658,
-0.54476398229599,
0.8209023475646973,
-0.37293216586112976,
-0.22437065839767456,
-0.4310237169265747,
-0.815657377243042,
-0.40960493683815,
0.604428231716156,
-0.48526719212532043,
-0.1821509152650833,
0.5794469118118286,
0.21251724660396576,
0.008247622288763523,
-0.25703442096710205,
0.5589668154716492,
-0.04823365807533264,
0.33284077048301697,
0.38545656204223633,
0.6660138964653015,
-0.302438348531723,
0.4924471378326416,
-0.6412145495414734,
0.03232412785291672,
-0.5501673221588135,
-0.8142265677452087,
-1.0121732950210571,
-0.7768122553825378,
-0.12696388363838196,
0.2450251579284668,
0.3468720614910126,
0.8461297154426575,
0.7348510026931763,
-0.9061340689659119,
0.14689961075782776,
0.2978183329105377,
0.1672038584947586,
0.18613672256469727,
-0.21090760827064514,
0.34398066997528076,
-0.2542790174484253,
-0.6306183338165283,
0.22981694340705872,
0.3146151006221771,
0.06774604320526123,
-0.22320783138275146,
0.2696588635444641,
-0.43540632724761963,
0.19181521236896515,
0.7189794778823853,
0.1889546811580658,
-0.8821006417274475,
-0.2592363655567169,
-0.18773320317268372,
-0.10504020750522614,
0.20136843621730804,
1.070165753364563,
-0.7139714956283569,
0.3594391644001007,
0.6477301716804504,
0.41707393527030945,
0.5255980491638184,
0.03671018034219742,
0.3926345109939575,
-0.7869736552238464,
0.519396185874939,
0.5386824011802673,
0.42600104212760925,
0.15083113312721252,
-0.2722921371459961,
0.17766501009464264,
-0.00798459816724062,
-0.3165821135044098,
-0.6554021835327148,
0.20614606142044067,
-1.031079888343811,
-0.4017307758331299,
0.8959890007972717,
-0.21277175843715668,
-0.029495934024453163,
-0.0194106362760067,
-0.40241366624832153,
0.1952378749847412,
-0.4728965759277344,
0.9834187626838684,
0.9393516778945923,
-0.03893755003809929,
-0.1349790394306183,
-0.40594252943992615,
0.2734614610671997,
0.27918362617492676,
-0.9751518368721008,
-0.37416955828666687,
0.17774875462055206,
0.12275910377502441,
0.28954651951789856,
0.5000602602958679,
0.032799750566482544,
0.3535017669200897,
-0.2774438261985779,
0.014006383717060089,
0.10650068521499634,
-0.8539106845855713,
-0.2890387773513794,
0.28461766242980957,
-0.14877410233020782,
-0.03648247942328453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03053v1 | Multi-Lingual Malaysian Embedding: Leveraging Large Language Models for Semantic Representations | 2024-02-05T14:36:51 | 2024-02-05T14:36:51 | Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we present a comprehensive exploration of finetuning Malaysian
language models, specifically Llama2 and Mistral, on embedding tasks involving
negative and positive pairs. We release two distinct models tailored for
Semantic Similarity and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG).
For Semantic Similarity, our 600 million parameter Llama2 model outperforms
OpenAI text-embedding-ada-002 across all recall@k metrics for b.cari.com.my,
c.cari.com.my, Malay news, and Malaysian Twitter test sets.
In the realm of RAG models, our approach proves competitive with OpenAI
text-embedding-ada-002 in the Malaysian context. Notably, our 2 billion
parameter Llama2 model achieves superior Recall@5, Recall@10 for the "Melayu"
keyword research papers dataset and excels in Recall@3, Recall@5, and Recall@10
for the lom.agc.gov.my dataset.
These findings underscore the effectiveness of our finetuning strategy and
highlight the performance gains in both Semantic Similarity and RAG tasks.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/malaysian-embedding-6523612bfe5881ad35f81b99 | [
-0.39080071449279785,
-0.611926257610321,
0.26765480637550354,
0.4546113610267639,
-0.41528812050819397,
-0.19641828536987305,
-0.25755396485328674,
-0.5899820327758789,
0.40511348843574524,
0.6901368498802185,
-0.13296188414096832,
-0.5316866040229797,
-0.6300087571144104,
0.24306343495845795,
-0.3977123200893402,
0.704201340675354,
-0.3184720575809479,
0.19085155427455902,
-0.21986974775791168,
-0.44107604026794434,
-0.5984541177749634,
-0.5813546180725098,
-0.445809930562973,
-0.33681780099868774,
0.5899220705032349,
0.495342880487442,
0.6280631422996521,
0.693069338798523,
0.47596853971481323,
0.23071078956127167,
0.005866135936230421,
0.02442226931452751,
-0.6181261539459229,
0.26969510316848755,
-0.25487998127937317,
-0.4649096727371216,
-0.17145439982414246,
0.034031376242637634,
0.6822490096092224,
0.5704583525657654,
-0.27815917134284973,
0.17201091349124908,
0.06201484799385071,
0.3667026460170746,
-0.5840744972229004,
0.364313542842865,
-0.6446483731269836,
-0.06021828576922417,
-0.3152918517589569,
-0.08970757573843002,
-0.2957843542098999,
-0.3191862404346466,
-0.17483115196228027,
-0.7190095782279968,
-0.197468101978302,
0.006569931283593178,
0.974461019039154,
0.45991578698158264,
-0.750890851020813,
-0.730029821395874,
-0.43999171257019043,
0.9539393186569214,
-0.8239362239837646,
0.46176111698150635,
0.6984310746192932,
0.29034966230392456,
0.11388399451971054,
-0.49457836151123047,
-0.4901117980480194,
-0.3650108277797699,
-0.012192679569125175,
0.18013520538806915,
0.16859464347362518,
-0.010520926676690578,
0.12350840121507645,
0.44082483649253845,
-0.31254643201828003,
0.32881489396095276,
-0.10027870535850525,
-0.11518987268209457,
0.47293856739997864,
0.1270313560962677,
0.01437753438949585,
-0.46738487482070923,
-0.2933329939842224,
-0.276167094707489,
-1.0567436218261719,
-0.26681649684906006,
0.43400225043296814,
0.4004165232181549,
-0.14191724359989166,
1.0898088216781616,
-0.19545535743236542,
0.3645610809326172,
-0.20925073325634003,
-0.3423086702823639,
0.2747943103313446,
-0.46048590540885925,
-0.008824064396321774,
0.1454048752784729,
0.3993690609931946,
0.34207069873809814,
0.2088702768087387,
-0.05495138093829155,
-0.36672070622444153,
0.36377301812171936,
-0.07536948472261429,
-0.8951528072357178,
-0.034137021750211716,
-0.13818635046482086,
-0.46000829339027405,
-0.24337886273860931,
0.26265570521354675,
-0.5284082889556885,
-0.5260629057884216,
-0.5745872855186462,
0.7283498644828796,
-0.1759684979915619,
-0.534061849117279,
0.3563895523548126,
-0.004570092540234327,
0.6920760869979858,
0.11582581698894501,
-0.8098238110542297,
0.30912482738494873,
1.0098456144332886,
0.6782050728797913,
0.15166498720645905,
-0.16999170184135437,
-0.22984886169433594,
0.3756762146949768,
-0.4278925061225891,
0.515051543712616,
-0.6355315446853638,
-0.34100469946861267,
0.2509307861328125,
0.0179666206240654,
-0.013827163726091385,
-0.9003702998161316,
0.5118438601493835,
-0.5860426425933838,
0.25463879108428955,
-0.31172439455986023,
-0.6626282930374146,
-0.49134740233421326,
0.364617258310318,
-0.9684898257255554,
1.100487470626831,
0.12035165727138519,
-0.7237246036529541,
0.26981377601623535,
-0.43944135308265686,
-0.3521042764186859,
-0.3644843101501465,
-0.12850898504257202,
-0.41804391145706177,
0.035040512681007385,
0.07904369384050369,
0.88776695728302,
-0.4626186490058899,
0.1960715502500534,
-0.36093640327453613,
-0.3228553831577301,
-0.023125596344470978,
-0.32565292716026306,
0.5865052342414856,
0.17011217772960663,
-0.1271456629037857,
-0.020083852112293243,
-0.5524513721466064,
-0.5456334352493286,
0.3936537802219391,
-0.4894852042198181,
-0.732654869556427,
-0.34874075651168823,
0.30940189957618713,
0.4331814646720886,
0.5084903836250305,
-0.7828214168548584,
0.20526395738124847,
-0.3310682475566864,
0.2002493292093277,
0.564238965511322,
0.005265772342681885,
0.35369163751602173,
-0.3876435458660126,
0.40381595492362976,
0.34265241026878357,
-0.348781943321228,
-0.2922026216983795,
-0.4572311043739319,
-0.8197894096374512,
-0.11143440753221512,
0.4670715928077698,
0.6293497085571289,
-0.6147845983505249,
-0.1374201625585556,
-0.245126873254776,
-0.4546842873096466,
-0.8718041777610779,
0.3531683683395386,
0.4600803852081299,
0.16141994297504425,
0.28750118613243103,
-0.18560771644115448,
-0.6103999018669128,
-0.8751609921455383,
0.0017010362353175879,
-0.015618346631526947,
0.05840872973203659,
0.5231423377990723,
0.4551725685596466,
-0.563273549079895,
0.6154600977897644,
-0.3065774738788605,
-0.5440502762794495,
-0.18588002026081085,
0.024407649412751198,
0.214686319231987,
0.36259934306144714,
0.6098678708076477,
-0.8996939659118652,
-0.6656491756439209,
0.10167066007852554,
-0.745958685874939,
-0.04539479315280914,
-0.054261114448308945,
0.09070808440446854,
0.6419192552566528,
0.7283812761306763,
-0.6650193929672241,
0.19235025346279144,
0.763950765132904,
-0.4750465452671051,
0.5643253922462463,
-0.20050811767578125,
0.04594173654913902,
-1.559906005859375,
0.08222512155771255,
-0.02286645770072937,
-0.28098684549331665,
-0.33355170488357544,
0.326151579618454,
0.11784925311803818,
-0.013289880007505417,
-0.3467969596385956,
0.7523189187049866,
-0.3085942268371582,
0.053088169544935226,
-0.11168942600488663,
0.146925151348114,
-0.09561709314584732,
0.4296225905418396,
-0.10008545219898224,
0.790671169757843,
0.3455258309841156,
-0.5830384492874146,
0.2293773591518402,
0.23660139739513397,
-0.5820218920707703,
0.2754758596420288,
-0.7397705912590027,
-0.12375319749116898,
-0.18482637405395508,
0.1575968861579895,
-1.0470504760742188,
-0.3606342077255249,
0.2400069385766983,
-0.12546496093273163,
0.4219798743724823,
-0.06675141304731369,
-0.8214575052261353,
0.044823333621025085,
-0.5621210336685181,
0.6215418577194214,
0.3606078028678894,
-0.5579480528831482,
0.4388016164302826,
0.6794931292533875,
-0.4285566508769989,
-0.6020904183387756,
-0.7298650741577148,
0.17202717065811157,
-0.5411199927330017,
-0.3007824122905731,
0.543391764163971,
0.47795650362968445,
-0.19331873953342438,
0.26547595858573914,
0.19295834004878998,
0.1409526914358139,
0.11332761496305466,
0.2716556191444397,
0.03935523331165314,
-0.4719943702220917,
0.06953433901071548,
0.14925648272037506,
-0.37202247977256775,
-0.005501751787960529,
-0.04213286191225052,
0.7128127217292786,
-0.024309145286679268,
-0.5547398328781128,
-0.4180055856704712,
0.47769415378570557,
0.43023407459259033,
-0.35137665271759033,
0.7806939482688904,
0.9947988390922546,
-0.5862112641334534,
0.3716655969619751,
-0.743589460849762,
-0.15945671498775482,
-0.4309450387954712,
0.5479527711868286,
-0.5402947068214417,
-1.169999599456787,
0.5545514225959778,
-0.2832828462123871,
0.1017356663942337,
0.6250303983688354,
0.6812060475349426,
0.05793360248208046,
1.1192221641540527,
0.8047659993171692,
-0.4000304639339447,
0.31877732276916504,
-0.4773269295692444,
0.08587886393070221,
-0.7840585708618164,
-0.24410754442214966,
-0.419997900724411,
-0.1274564117193222,
-0.9916407465934753,
-0.6760540008544922,
0.0780099406838417,
0.40173667669296265,
-0.3665061891078949,
0.4834202229976654,
0.04131174460053444,
0.290196031332016,
0.6392266154289246,
-0.238280788064003,
0.2578226327896118,
0.003570742905139923,
-0.33763644099235535,
-0.13914528489112854,
-0.5919422507286072,
-0.6603580117225647,
1.097676396369934,
0.5258876085281372,
1.011999487876892,
0.4983370900154114,
1.00058913230896,
0.020356884226202965,
0.19355922937393188,
-0.8443436622619629,
0.41520243883132935,
-0.26814067363739014,
-0.40237554907798767,
-0.14572250843048096,
-0.3362380862236023,
-1.1191664934158325,
0.29997915029525757,
-0.21521231532096863,
-0.3697313368320465,
-0.20460648834705353,
-0.16335570812225342,
-0.045598406344652176,
0.319728285074234,
-0.5318382978439331,
0.7875304818153381,
0.22552809119224548,
-0.03206656873226166,
-0.745887041091919,
-0.34996551275253296,
0.3306751847267151,
-0.029684195294976234,
0.05337364971637726,
-0.225656196475029,
-0.4326585531234741,
0.8281319737434387,
0.09382902830839157,
0.8996410369873047,
-0.2918737530708313,
-0.396007239818573,
0.33244678378105164,
0.11766084283590317,
0.2684505879878998,
0.06987829506397247,
-0.1625795215368271,
0.22262874245643616,
0.18713979423046112,
-0.42848360538482666,
-0.3772873878479004,
0.8440061807632446,
-0.8101280927658081,
-0.6270804405212402,
-0.2071564793586731,
-0.3371769189834595,
-0.009259740822017193,
0.10773298889398575,
-0.2741873264312744,
0.5818562507629395,
-0.16654956340789795,
0.31188490986824036,
0.46189630031585693,
-0.3507809638977051,
0.28420141339302063,
0.21478666365146637,
-0.5104621648788452,
-0.37969303131103516,
1.3528794050216675,
0.028234440833330154,
0.1005263552069664,
0.6002529859542847,
0.18582302331924438,
-0.49037405848503113,
-0.10448582470417023,
-0.4227304756641388,
0.7278384566307068,
-0.7812326550483704,
-0.33642813563346863,
-0.5489950180053711,
-0.13392093777656555,
-0.41367703676223755,
0.05753865838050842,
-0.4055952727794647,
-0.6997860670089722,
-0.3662773668766022,
0.048468902707099915,
0.31576594710350037,
1.48007333278656,
-0.2753458321094513,
0.2084299474954605,
-0.6129167675971985,
0.3829353153705597,
0.2849285304546356,
0.42357540130615234,
0.2889297306537628,
-0.4317605495452881,
-0.4624684154987335,
0.01393087301403284,
-0.34899866580963135,
-0.7084679007530212,
0.3810561001300812,
0.21594731509685516,
0.5515279173851013,
0.4926278591156006,
-0.25840991735458374,
0.6673623323440552,
-0.5181918144226074,
0.6585444808006287,
-0.16625118255615234,
-0.6756668090820312,
0.17467878758907318,
-0.3543412387371063,
0.26704370975494385,
0.35649335384368896,
0.7355489134788513,
-0.8483458161354065,
-0.2752513885498047,
-0.32049909234046936,
-0.8806566596031189,
0.46444055438041687,
-0.13256408274173737,
0.4480777978897095,
-0.10979396104812622,
0.3313601315021515,
0.25558868050575256,
-0.018088465556502342,
-0.6330110430717468,
-0.30025714635849,
-0.0823921337723732,
-0.34820231795310974,
-0.16507965326309204,
-0.7728179693222046,
0.244264617562294,
-0.14734023809432983,
0.6499704718589783,
0.0454498752951622,
0.4604978859424591,
-0.04908743128180504,
-0.3075267970561981,
0.20128405094146729,
0.13814522325992584,
0.6264575123786926,
0.25749829411506653,
-0.15630429983139038,
0.11823679506778717,
0.18347781896591187,
-0.49544569849967957,
0.05749811604619026,
0.19695083796977997,
0.223409503698349,
0.09272503852844238,
0.35889220237731934,
0.4574217200279236,
0.4985940456390381,
-0.6391274333000183,
0.4903692305088043,
0.044668812304735184,
-0.07199832797050476,
-0.2831994891166687,
-0.35356855392456055,
0.38379907608032227,
0.10364879667758942,
0.18541309237480164,
-0.2028198540210724,
0.0016166786663234234,
-0.36901846528053284,
0.2645168602466583,
0.338206946849823,
-0.40078920125961304,
-0.29182592034339905,
0.5745142102241516,
0.021457761526107788,
0.02353164553642273,
0.5270012617111206,
-0.3360220193862915,
-0.6387017369270325,
0.3809921145439148,
0.7992733716964722,
0.4375119209289551,
-0.32682040333747864,
0.11728081107139587,
0.6796512603759766,
0.03194054961204529,
-0.09819335490465164,
0.40407153964042664,
-0.042976949363946915,
-0.6447637677192688,
-0.6346037983894348,
-0.6293152570724487,
-0.4722929298877716,
-0.004075256641954184,
-0.6640385985374451,
0.4334644377231598,
-0.23589618504047394,
0.14546413719654083,
-0.33403444290161133,
0.2597210705280304,
-0.7841511964797974,
-0.22469539940357208,
0.3124963343143463,
0.892403781414032,
-0.8733180165290833,
0.9089682102203369,
0.8275196552276611,
-0.41997867822647095,
-0.6979771852493286,
-0.17207369208335876,
-0.002073958981782198,
-0.8565670847892761,
0.4824483394622803,
0.5583929419517517,
0.0430944599211216,
0.04481493681669235,
-0.08426682651042938,
-1.1461846828460693,
1.280277132987976,
0.3239251673221588,
-0.416206032037735,
0.13540101051330566,
0.40031832456588745,
0.3087487518787384,
-0.20956499874591827,
0.038535501807928085,
0.46545183658599854,
0.3161311745643616,
-0.11062199622392654,
-1.0975773334503174,
0.10455788671970367,
-0.11253467202186584,
0.03290877118706703,
0.20982171595096588,
-0.511275589466095,
0.8149256110191345,
-0.21959863603115082,
-0.38075974583625793,
0.3829640746116638,
0.7110862135887146,
0.3141913414001465,
0.059759095311164856,
0.27994993329048157,
1.0612437725067139,
0.7052502632141113,
0.16867808997631073,
1.21575129032135,
-0.25949251651763916,
0.246908038854599,
0.9451634883880615,
-0.05601871386170387,
1.3258682489395142,
0.509806752204895,
0.05345865339040756,
0.5640383958816528,
0.6053531765937805,
0.31100186705589294,
0.7735811471939087,
0.04605397954583168,
-0.23257924616336823,
-0.11125500500202179,
-0.5855957865715027,
-0.4200625717639923,
0.6753643751144409,
0.6556810736656189,
-0.22739194333553314,
-0.4547499418258667,
0.06242432817816734,
0.15105494856834412,
0.07522129267454147,
-0.26989346742630005,
0.945782482624054,
0.34051328897476196,
-0.48765286803245544,
0.5857139229774475,
0.5007884502410889,
1.0507925748825073,
-0.37950170040130615,
-0.34491869807243347,
-0.2095547616481781,
0.2703453600406647,
0.03981529176235199,
-0.8453962206840515,
0.3007378876209259,
-0.20912589132785797,
0.11524634808301926,
-0.22258417308330536,
0.7616062164306641,
-0.8161559104919434,
-0.40528079867362976,
0.4230089485645294,
0.4847857654094696,
0.13664864003658295,
0.012617785483598709,
-0.7163623571395874,
0.1361747831106186,
-0.12239842861890793,
-0.1824575811624527,
0.2769625782966614,
0.40270867943763733,
-0.3024252951145172,
0.61302649974823,
0.45335593819618225,
-0.07180164754390717,
0.08255523443222046,
0.4204036593437195,
0.7742500901222229,
-0.8151540756225586,
-0.27772560715675354,
-0.8167847990989685,
0.11663137376308441,
0.19351370632648468,
-0.3853802978992462,
0.8281627893447876,
0.6576330065727234,
1.156346321105957,
-0.10763513296842575,
0.3928118944168091,
0.12164035439491272,
0.5545485615730286,
-0.4580293297767639,
0.6865432262420654,
-0.6016969680786133,
-0.0676882416009903,
-0.2622714042663574,
-1.207897424697876,
-0.44488370418548584,
0.6518052816390991,
-0.06530299037694931,
-0.0813373252749443,
0.24255327880382538,
1.1354150772094727,
-0.3761809170246124,
-0.12449890375137329,
0.24543574452400208,
0.3241879940032959,
0.2968445420265198,
0.6091779470443726,
0.9119476675987244,
-0.6115511059761047,
0.32873550057411194,
-0.43481898307800293,
0.03195296227931976,
-0.31161656975746155,
-0.8215867280960083,
-0.8853799700737,
-0.9334244132041931,
-0.10389837622642517,
-0.12241358309984207,
-0.2841765880584717,
1.1089547872543335,
0.4521714448928833,
-0.9480778574943542,
-0.4219339191913605,
0.24431930482387543,
0.16175273060798645,
0.18050406873226166,
-0.1919824331998825,
0.44533514976501465,
-0.34093883633613586,
-0.5396515130996704,
0.09781605750322342,
0.16576175391674042,
0.21626725792884827,
-0.5620420575141907,
-0.2905533015727997,
-0.4618086516857147,
-0.07427568733692169,
0.9209745526313782,
0.02770252712070942,
-1.0241562128067017,
-0.11644098907709122,
-0.0883944183588028,
-0.49249833822250366,
-0.19058330357074738,
0.4812754690647125,
-0.8160152435302734,
0.044753268361091614,
0.2938315272331238,
1.0242186784744263,
0.4904046356678009,
-0.14042358100414276,
0.3911287486553192,
-0.605506956577301,
0.28568530082702637,
0.10240352898836136,
0.44447049498558044,
0.7310811281204224,
0.029794510453939438,
0.5800450444221497,
-0.0038037733174860477,
-0.4493100047111511,
-0.6898979544639587,
0.08064272999763489,
-0.8471589088439941,
-0.08834674209356308,
1.4063472747802734,
-0.021262867376208305,
-0.01422432903200388,
-0.13547082245349884,
-0.42335397005081177,
0.292359858751297,
-0.14017269015312195,
0.7378073930740356,
0.6771334409713745,
0.2751125693321228,
0.07415328919887543,
-0.6716572642326355,
0.35772669315338135,
0.6794299483299255,
-0.34748849272727966,
-0.16992293298244476,
0.15495331585407257,
0.2064114660024643,
0.17428891360759735,
0.2700935900211334,
-0.1918553113937378,
0.17283934354782104,
0.042146652936935425,
-0.2589499056339264,
-0.03559884428977966,
-0.2737044394016266,
-0.4287054240703583,
-0.09965895116329193,
0.2851128578186035,
-0.10282804071903229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03050v1 | A Comprehensive Study of the Current State-of-the-Art in Nepali Automatic Speech Recognition Systems | 2024-02-05T14:34:14 | 2024-02-05T14:34:14 | Rupak Raj Ghimire, Bal Krishna Bal, Prakash Poudyal | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In this paper, we examine the research conducted in the field of Nepali
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). The primary objective of this survey is to
conduct a comprehensive review of the works on Nepali Automatic Speech
Recognition Systems completed to date, explore the different datasets used,
examine the technology utilized, and take account of the obstacles encountered
in implementing the Nepali ASR system. In tandem with the global trends of
ever-increasing research on speech recognition based research, the number of
Nepalese ASR-related projects are also growing. Nevertheless, the investigation
of language and acoustic models of the Nepali language has not received
adequate attention compared to languages that possess ample resources. In this
context, we provide a framework as well as directions for future
investigations. | [
-0.011791725642979145,
-0.546237051486969,
-0.2049310803413391,
0.579565167427063,
-0.22881591320037842,
0.30634602904319763,
-0.011746418662369251,
-0.5369472503662109,
0.08608503639698029,
0.5492239594459534,
0.11654094606637955,
0.010030917823314667,
-0.663684606552124,
0.3877089023590088,
-1.046066403388977,
0.4749424159526825,
-0.18598832190036774,
0.22502073645591736,
0.22897320985794067,
-0.28894734382629395,
-0.5504634380340576,
-0.6689028143882751,
-0.7615543007850647,
-0.2984769344329834,
0.04825339466333389,
0.10845015197992325,
0.03290100768208504,
0.08385491371154785,
0.6081627607345581,
0.5183237195014954,
-0.6016198992729187,
-0.05833135545253754,
-0.07743261754512787,
0.2489289939403534,
0.22384901344776154,
-0.15962988138198853,
-0.484491765499115,
-0.244906947016716,
1.300744891166687,
0.5322240591049194,
-0.5963578224182129,
0.2699960172176361,
0.08751603215932846,
0.5331820845603943,
-0.4464429020881653,
-0.022257598116993904,
-0.35662028193473816,
0.12022022902965546,
-0.3818388879299164,
-0.3044085204601288,
-0.06130042299628258,
-0.39348745346069336,
0.29381445050239563,
-0.26776444911956787,
0.048552077263593674,
-0.03799177706241608,
0.49041417241096497,
0.19466933608055115,
-0.4803338348865509,
-0.46880218386650085,
-1.0103963613510132,
0.7265864610671997,
-0.4407821297645569,
0.45447343587875366,
0.5388787984848022,
0.6341628432273865,
0.1344364583492279,
-0.4558432996273041,
-0.477374404668808,
-0.1565287858247757,
0.05776679515838623,
-0.25539249181747437,
-0.36620262265205383,
-0.34639325737953186,
-0.03473963215947151,
0.6466243863105774,
-0.6710339188575745,
0.09491104632616043,
-0.8601588606834412,
-0.15976731479167938,
0.6036432385444641,
0.21953457593917847,
0.32701796293258667,
-0.1720690280199051,
-0.04911693185567856,
0.27782005071640015,
-0.7579069137573242,
0.19940651953220367,
0.19306808710098267,
0.218583345413208,
-0.19519208371639252,
0.6429848670959473,
-0.5253644585609436,
1.1415777206420898,
-0.13480187952518463,
0.08504026383161545,
0.29473456740379333,
-0.6282289028167725,
-0.4384293556213379,
0.5858482122421265,
0.7740250825881958,
-0.2164967954158783,
0.22103221714496613,
-0.06349769979715347,
-0.27275508642196655,
0.06546483933925629,
0.147844597697258,
-0.3309057354927063,
0.06553283333778381,
0.07283629477024078,
-0.19397637248039246,
-0.21973565220832825,
-0.2793612778186798,
-0.34317630529403687,
-0.2746390700340271,
-0.6005681157112122,
0.15434058010578156,
-0.3947000801563263,
-0.860163688659668,
0.25956112146377563,
-0.2273714691400528,
0.3385208249092102,
0.38510462641716003,
-0.4565883278846741,
0.5359487533569336,
0.551825225353241,
0.8623543977737427,
-0.025654876604676247,
-0.24863815307617188,
-0.2832251489162445,
0.15655644237995148,
-0.24667300283908844,
1.13540518283844,
-0.6516886949539185,
-0.68172287940979,
0.08631008118391037,
0.044461339712142944,
-0.04079156368970871,
-0.8275775909423828,
0.15192751586437225,
-0.6841394305229187,
-0.14333994686603546,
-0.11354891955852509,
-0.19010613858699799,
-0.16340786218643188,
0.44873443245887756,
-0.5393116474151611,
0.7165899872779846,
-0.1402921974658966,
-0.8510843515396118,
0.23307621479034424,
-0.6853346824645996,
-0.6247062683105469,
0.10862612724304199,
-0.19073738157749176,
-0.198533833026886,
-0.029014458879828453,
-0.11342749744653702,
0.25622618198394775,
-0.4627569615840912,
0.4438982903957367,
0.33532074093818665,
-0.6397873163223267,
0.42081186175346375,
-0.28642457723617554,
1.2171317338943481,
0.315695583820343,
-0.30882787704467773,
0.30925822257995605,
-1.0638072490692139,
-0.2044193297624588,
-0.06705588847398758,
-0.7110923528671265,
-0.1310194432735443,
0.13033583760261536,
0.39711540937423706,
-0.04676763340830803,
0.24637839198112488,
-0.7862435579299927,
-0.2493640035390854,
-0.3098698556423187,
0.6630088686943054,
0.4696001708507538,
-0.2716177999973297,
0.5022705793380737,
-0.08271150290966034,
0.5465051531791687,
-0.13430947065353394,
0.03177332878112793,
0.07532823830842972,
-0.27997851371765137,
-0.7788474559783936,
-0.153629869222641,
0.7453385591506958,
0.6527888178825378,
-0.30636245012283325,
0.5236982703208923,
-0.2547335922718048,
-0.2859242558479309,
-0.5772994160652161,
-0.27829509973526,
0.4563590884208679,
0.3331276476383209,
0.11634539067745209,
-0.41778290271759033,
-0.8633142709732056,
-0.8384812474250793,
0.024739641696214676,
-0.416855126619339,
0.04239914193749428,
0.027617737650871277,
0.23919323086738586,
0.13211140036582947,
0.8110615611076355,
-0.2548074722290039,
-0.20119965076446533,
-0.22622795403003693,
0.061147481203079224,
-0.13377852737903595,
0.7539957165718079,
0.19697155058383942,
-1.120702862739563,
-0.803052544593811,
0.21072357892990112,
-0.696487545967102,
0.20472095906734467,
0.6662238836288452,
0.4256168603897095,
0.29430869221687317,
0.4618479013442993,
-0.3105708062648773,
0.6006750464439392,
0.3577374517917633,
-0.13646432757377625,
0.5664367079734802,
-0.004119514022022486,
0.3197920024394989,
-0.5813644528388977,
0.5875235795974731,
-0.1371309906244278,
0.034619320183992386,
-0.8207834362983704,
-0.18621812760829926,
-0.1045922189950943,
-0.3305234909057617,
-0.1386493742465973,
0.5514998435974121,
-0.5208947062492371,
-0.06603728979825974,
-0.49069806933403015,
-0.19913996756076813,
-0.39277052879333496,
-0.1367940455675125,
0.35377493500709534,
0.6291308403015137,
1.0437853336334229,
-0.7179754972457886,
0.38623934984207153,
0.41506728529930115,
-0.5724290013313293,
0.867761492729187,
-0.8291233777999878,
-0.07386733591556549,
0.0581134669482708,
0.3445155918598175,
-0.8034639358520508,
-0.04703538119792938,
0.18733333051204681,
-0.7136273384094238,
0.6826642155647278,
0.15857307612895966,
-0.5882071256637573,
-0.30177944898605347,
0.2602548897266388,
0.5523171424865723,
0.6819092035293579,
-0.14855605363845825,
0.39547908306121826,
0.9561428427696228,
-0.5516189336776733,
-0.5987802743911743,
-0.5149536728858948,
0.36804643273353577,
-0.2342270165681839,
-0.28248265385627747,
-0.18256685137748718,
0.12332834303379059,
-0.5024908781051636,
-0.2794851064682007,
-0.08666461706161499,
-0.37719377875328064,
-0.20321477949619293,
-0.08541128784418106,
-0.33515551686286926,
-0.1195325255393982,
-0.20420792698860168,
-0.25482288002967834,
-0.12770476937294006,
-0.0676414743065834,
0.1257690042257309,
0.6156374216079712,
-0.09065721929073334,
-0.21118003129959106,
-0.9513124227523804,
0.6582491993904114,
0.2870205044746399,
-0.5271919965744019,
0.039149314165115356,
0.3279147446155548,
-0.4768044948577881,
0.07788407057523727,
-0.870554506778717,
0.260858952999115,
-0.4711715281009674,
0.32575029134750366,
-0.2864081859588623,
-0.74446702003479,
0.39627569913864136,
-0.007631994783878326,
-0.30977243185043335,
0.20089755952358246,
0.3415168225765228,
-0.05528586730360985,
0.8219035267829895,
0.7449545860290527,
-0.2128198891878128,
0.4466497600078583,
-0.193928524851799,
0.20121033489704132,
-1.2462451457977295,
-0.5786618590354919,
-1.0950957536697388,
-0.03345710039138794,
-0.384320467710495,
-0.2450743019580841,
0.20964474976062775,
-0.356618732213974,
-0.35096731781959534,
0.3257407546043396,
-1.010509967803955,
-0.20437610149383545,
0.4524485766887665,
-0.13843069970607758,
0.4282374978065491,
-0.034760937094688416,
0.2931728959083557,
0.3132645785808563,
-0.5817357897758484,
-0.34717097878456116,
0.8134781122207642,
-0.05945487692952156,
0.6364938020706177,
-0.1266588717699051,
0.2324923723936081,
0.1271461397409439,
0.053070686757564545,
-0.4376108646392822,
0.46325090527534485,
-0.0829821228981018,
-0.8332667350769043,
-0.6630758047103882,
-0.2867984175682068,
-1.145133376121521,
0.2359006255865097,
0.4893643856048584,
-0.5344438552856445,
0.4702766537666321,
0.16150936484336853,
-0.10792818665504456,
0.2178833931684494,
-0.07641171663999557,
0.30349886417388916,
-0.15250565111637115,
0.30975401401519775,
-0.41080448031425476,
-0.8963552117347717,
0.1559327393770218,
-0.10094155371189117,
0.16797944903373718,
0.0694214329123497,
0.20943206548690796,
1.0404564142227173,
-0.17166997492313385,
0.7627540230751038,
-0.30120790004730225,
-0.13994605839252472,
0.5998578667640686,
-0.22438843548297882,
0.14671911299228668,
-0.38978034257888794,
-0.48496583104133606,
0.18712159991264343,
0.11087477207183838,
-0.362691730260849,
-0.11022496968507767,
0.6285682916641235,
-0.39608559012413025,
-0.2541261911392212,
-0.8181423544883728,
-0.33658358454704285,
-0.18488311767578125,
0.13390107452869415,
0.08343254774808884,
0.5223631262779236,
-0.687605082988739,
0.13653461635112762,
0.394234299659729,
-0.2601926624774933,
0.24517720937728882,
0.7696892023086548,
0.013225123286247253,
-0.5879350304603577,
0.9589937925338745,
0.7046246528625488,
-0.19576238095760345,
0.2493085265159607,
-0.015355131588876247,
-0.385904461145401,
-0.8041711449623108,
-0.5944792628288269,
0.015764597803354263,
-0.3955267369747162,
-0.06831752508878708,
-0.5604698061943054,
-0.4178526997566223,
-0.4406060576438904,
0.11568623781204224,
-0.09673105925321579,
-0.4914489686489105,
-0.38097578287124634,
0.26313987374305725,
0.32297956943511963,
1.119849681854248,
-0.04848223924636841,
0.4198390245437622,
-0.4300958216190338,
0.31783390045166016,
0.20897531509399414,
0.3312804698944092,
0.31580865383148193,
-0.526084840297699,
-0.21612025797367096,
-0.011441727168858051,
-0.27149060368537903,
-0.4509028196334839,
0.3037220239639282,
0.15228530764579773,
0.47214475274086,
0.0798901617527008,
-0.100278839468956,
0.7375006079673767,
-0.8748940825462341,
0.838097870349884,
0.30960798263549805,
-0.8850472569465637,
0.7558744549751282,
-0.25309792160987854,
0.33990538120269775,
0.4937555193901062,
0.15388962626457214,
-0.4893893897533417,
-0.10933448374271393,
-0.6122958660125732,
-0.6417410969734192,
0.6165563464164734,
0.1022181436419487,
-0.13917872309684753,
0.4744679033756256,
0.12042216956615448,
-0.06749087572097778,
0.6904749870300293,
-0.11484687030315399,
0.08350959420204163,
-0.1513885110616684,
0.031117528676986694,
-0.23441389203071594,
0.02575775794684887,
-0.0612509548664093,
-0.5203408598899841,
0.4411469101905823,
0.1632758378982544,
0.24935828149318695,
0.04103931412100792,
0.033664096146821976,
-0.17937272787094116,
0.3199025094509125,
0.4579310715198517,
0.6429789662361145,
0.03605903312563896,
-0.029738925397396088,
0.2716307044029236,
-0.42713281512260437,
0.408285528421402,
0.16519451141357422,
-0.34059321880340576,
0.062285635620355606,
0.09583073854446411,
0.7001947164535522,
0.1470726579427719,
-0.5780537128448486,
0.5113617777824402,
0.10455546528100967,
-0.022654283791780472,
-0.7070499062538147,
-0.15955568850040436,
-0.01817140355706215,
0.08172822743654251,
0.3341878354549408,
0.33036696910858154,
0.5308243036270142,
-0.613050639629364,
-0.11878703534603119,
0.6159875988960266,
-0.7486151456832886,
-0.6204073429107666,
0.2981460690498352,
0.2443762868642807,
-0.7077144980430603,
0.707364559173584,
0.171092227101326,
-0.7031311392784119,
0.6717191338539124,
0.7644068002700806,
0.6215721368789673,
-0.8004502058029175,
-0.020729202777147293,
0.33583855628967285,
0.18505863845348358,
-0.3002103865146637,
0.8715113997459412,
-0.3656156659126282,
-0.17093659937381744,
-0.3366391360759735,
-0.9356893301010132,
-0.41093772649765015,
-0.07177265733480453,
-0.676745593547821,
0.3043360412120819,
-0.25667640566825867,
-0.20621320605278015,
-0.31008464097976685,
-0.09910549968481064,
-0.4975934624671936,
0.4497085511684418,
-0.313474178314209,
0.9011731147766113,
-0.5101996660232544,
0.7951993346214294,
0.802784264087677,
-0.24555064737796783,
-0.35392457246780396,
-0.30526673793792725,
0.03463156521320343,
-0.8380246162414551,
0.8588705658912659,
-0.16749021410942078,
-0.5710776448249817,
0.060448482632637024,
-0.452907919883728,
-0.9389364719390869,
0.8754240870475769,
0.07007811218500137,
-0.3614632189273834,
-0.08217541128396988,
0.030832991003990173,
0.6043509840965271,
-0.0004383451887406409,
-0.2598998248577118,
0.5444790124893188,
0.7729403972625732,
0.13872575759887695,
-1.5750722885131836,
-0.051537733525037766,
-0.6926895976066589,
-0.19007807970046997,
0.2217705398797989,
-0.8672276139259338,
0.5149391889572144,
0.09271472692489624,
-0.26390889286994934,
0.42070770263671875,
0.5995068550109863,
0.40195560455322266,
0.3404756188392639,
0.5038619637489319,
0.3510625958442688,
0.5197478532791138,
0.16105103492736816,
0.6908217668533325,
-0.015178683213889599,
-0.1496436446905136,
0.6466906070709229,
-0.49352777004241943,
1.2197545766830444,
0.4332068860530853,
-0.5137208104133606,
0.2265397012233734,
0.6032660603523254,
-0.12375060468912125,
0.4514923095703125,
0.7800424098968506,
-0.28886890411376953,
-0.08642920106649399,
-0.4139074981212616,
-0.6355447769165039,
0.5827407836914062,
0.5530047416687012,
0.09522811323404312,
0.054707009345293045,
0.035274259746074677,
-0.46093836426734924,
-0.19641061127185822,
-0.2137170433998108,
0.9519009590148926,
0.2398359626531601,
-0.43595167994499207,
0.7675805687904358,
-0.3087386190891266,
0.879485547542572,
-0.7826713919639587,
-0.08923622220754623,
0.5028278827667236,
-0.0823410153388977,
-0.2941676378250122,
-0.3890666365623474,
0.5770965814590454,
0.2403702288866043,
-0.058510102331638336,
-0.07945244759321213,
0.677078366279602,
-0.24047328531742096,
-0.5489557385444641,
0.15571168065071106,
0.2920803129673004,
0.4573158621788025,
-0.11529815942049026,
-0.28320106863975525,
0.5369865894317627,
-0.20183363556861877,
0.14707547426223755,
0.31641024351119995,
0.3035079836845398,
0.09416943788528442,
0.632966935634613,
0.3285004496574402,
0.626969039440155,
0.08975586295127869,
-0.059767331928014755,
0.7487999796867371,
-0.7312712073326111,
-0.6877940893173218,
-0.31673958897590637,
0.71873539686203,
-0.0996217131614685,
-0.40158843994140625,
0.6434621810913086,
0.6705471873283386,
0.5978436470031738,
0.24230168759822845,
1.0733109712600708,
-0.2027312070131302,
0.8775482177734375,
0.004850135184824467,
1.0076444149017334,
-0.7262839078903198,
0.04605300724506378,
-0.14878986775875092,
-0.6265560984611511,
-0.47051453590393066,
0.7669981122016907,
-0.07217167317867279,
-0.015734203159809113,
0.49561089277267456,
0.4547868072986603,
-0.15181879699230194,
0.511928915977478,
0.044959016144275665,
0.17444591224193573,
0.10137016326189041,
-0.21979106962680817,
1.2025443315505981,
-0.45838814973831177,
0.380355566740036,
0.03390521928668022,
-0.3333718776702881,
-0.2157459259033203,
-0.39585575461387634,
-0.33670774102211,
-1.009175181388855,
-0.2666659653186798,
0.03423469141125679,
0.274636834859848,
0.3779977560043335,
0.7353147864341736,
-1.034578800201416,
-0.8855946063995361,
0.026163335889577866,
-0.2739216387271881,
-0.16564781963825226,
-0.07777462899684906,
0.6112619042396545,
0.056120775640010834,
-0.6987046003341675,
0.755588948726654,
0.1700989156961441,
-0.12217309325933456,
-0.3168274462223053,
-0.13231691718101501,
-0.3420494496822357,
-0.1838921308517456,
0.6309340596199036,
0.5877928137779236,
-0.7370859980583191,
0.003073349827900529,
0.0953214094042778,
0.21488921344280243,
0.2649647295475006,
0.9887146949768066,
-0.7258822321891785,
0.4273362457752228,
0.7691575884819031,
0.30062276124954224,
0.5252005457878113,
-0.20144426822662354,
0.7210597991943359,
-0.2893301546573639,
-0.1628877818584442,
0.4662210941314697,
0.2669861614704132,
0.8566960096359253,
-0.0224395003169775,
0.43005165457725525,
-0.12351330369710922,
-0.8623411059379578,
-1.4078847169876099,
0.18242508172988892,
-0.9864451885223389,
0.04732758179306984,
0.9554013609886169,
0.19317302107810974,
0.12434887886047363,
-0.7498321533203125,
-0.40241774916648865,
0.44983866810798645,
-0.25793513655662537,
0.5098258852958679,
0.488649845123291,
-0.5614508986473083,
0.13857078552246094,
-0.30226102471351624,
0.4049087166786194,
-0.0107200276106596,
-0.3376856744289398,
0.04956389591097832,
0.2959076762199402,
0.4789198935031891,
0.3593398630619049,
1.005722165107727,
-0.4071957767009735,
0.09245778620243073,
0.12942518293857574,
-0.019153261557221413,
0.2591804563999176,
-0.4445361793041229,
-0.9083959460258484,
0.40287071466445923,
0.3128327429294586,
-0.025789877399802208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03049v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03049v4 | EasyInstruct: An Easy-to-use Instruction Processing Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T14:33:56 | 2024-06-24T02:10:23 | Yixin Ou, Ningyu Zhang, Honghao Gui, Ziwen Xu, Shuofei Qiao, Yida Xue, Runnan Fang, Kangwei Liu, Lei Li, Zhen Bi, Guozhou Zheng, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG | In recent years, instruction tuning has gained increasing attention and
emerged as a crucial technique to enhance the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To construct high-quality instruction datasets, many instruction
processing approaches have been proposed, aiming to achieve a delicate balance
between data quantity and data quality. Nevertheless, due to inconsistencies
that persist among various instruction processing methods, there is no standard
open-source instruction processing implementation framework available for the
community, which hinders practitioners from further developing and advancing.
To facilitate instruction processing research and development, we present
EasyInstruct, an easy-to-use instruction processing framework for LLMs, which
modularizes instruction generation, selection, and prompting, while also
considering their combination and interaction. EasyInstruct is publicly
released and actively maintained at https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyInstruct,
along with an online demo app and a demo video for quick-start, calling for
broader research centered on instruction data and synthetic data. | [
-0.29472973942756653,
-0.7926539182662964,
0.5555037260055542,
0.15036049485206604,
0.09795556962490082,
-0.13621626794338226,
-0.3244816064834595,
-0.12443212419748306,
-0.13269229233264923,
0.5534915924072266,
-0.6791404485702515,
-0.7770497798919678,
-0.3496759533882141,
-0.27459385991096497,
-0.618668794631958,
0.9086728096008301,
0.021930031478405,
0.21635346114635468,
-0.38829267024993896,
0.12277595698833466,
-0.17610709369182587,
-0.07087906450033188,
-0.6578393578529358,
-0.24291403591632843,
0.0727100819349289,
0.8954539895057678,
0.5377642512321472,
1.2480074167251587,
0.2273283749818802,
0.2869599759578705,
-0.12225167453289032,
0.3911780118942261,
-0.3082539141178131,
0.13085366785526276,
-0.2100285142660141,
-0.28417202830314636,
-0.6410132050514221,
-0.18238677084445953,
0.7864029407501221,
0.9794643521308899,
-0.5490885972976685,
0.37031620740890503,
0.2892744839191437,
0.7649206519126892,
-0.5837221145629883,
0.31961867213249207,
-0.41874435544013977,
-0.07187546044588089,
-0.20584143698215485,
0.059219177812337875,
-0.8218051195144653,
-0.5432066917419434,
-0.20668376982212067,
-0.367370069026947,
0.4619022011756897,
-0.013825342059135437,
0.20760585367679596,
0.2305489033460617,
-0.4357147514820099,
-0.4889853298664093,
-0.4412296414375305,
0.6011424660682678,
-0.6593879461288452,
0.40500321984291077,
0.3629668653011322,
0.2190437614917755,
-0.4467836320400238,
-0.7947317361831665,
-0.14728961884975433,
-0.0031927700620144606,
0.060314055532217026,
-0.24104683101177216,
0.19489654898643494,
0.38250961899757385,
0.2926315367221832,
0.536881685256958,
-0.6076670289039612,
0.45917028188705444,
-0.22885911166667938,
-0.17848120629787445,
0.38560399413108826,
0.36644530296325684,
0.28965356945991516,
-0.11769630759954453,
-0.21615301072597504,
0.0029529284220188856,
-1.119730830192566,
0.29308363795280457,
0.44687414169311523,
0.573671281337738,
-0.18106739223003387,
0.5095227360725403,
-0.49374476075172424,
1.0579978227615356,
0.2801615595817566,
-0.12861430644989014,
0.1392267793416977,
-0.07031838595867157,
-0.2784586548805237,
0.30672159790992737,
0.4908032715320587,
0.10180331021547318,
-0.1347895711660385,
0.10508549958467484,
-0.33356502652168274,
-0.34452351927757263,
0.015092871151864529,
-1.1639138460159302,
-0.45892858505249023,
0.15657158195972443,
-0.3889557123184204,
0.045181065797805786,
0.09164252877235413,
-0.7240983843803406,
-0.3519160747528076,
-0.5552468299865723,
0.2695149779319763,
-0.28498122096061707,
0.24427039921283722,
0.40422502160072327,
0.35268619656562805,
0.3971659541130066,
0.4977562427520752,
-0.9629403948783875,
0.4875553846359253,
0.943171501159668,
0.6076420545578003,
-0.1406887322664261,
-0.1659972220659256,
-0.9897366762161255,
0.2816494107246399,
-0.13226532936096191,
0.7899379134178162,
-0.6158215403556824,
-0.3426523506641388,
0.09782622754573822,
0.31415197253227234,
-0.05967766419053078,
-0.41763535141944885,
0.5712854862213135,
-0.3443002998828888,
0.13645228743553162,
0.3087552785873413,
-1.0371813774108887,
-0.053529102355241776,
0.05658332630991936,
-0.8314996361732483,
0.852297842502594,
0.0759722888469696,
-0.31397199630737305,
-0.19202156364917755,
-0.5707562565803528,
-0.8289252519607544,
0.08801546692848206,
-0.20922666788101196,
-0.5451655387878418,
0.14999982714653015,
0.3356335461139679,
0.5614407658576965,
-0.3257494270801544,
0.049004729837179184,
-0.11003168672323227,
-0.5852588415145874,
-0.22156871855258942,
-0.551796019077301,
0.9202916622161865,
0.10384608060121536,
-0.3615033030509949,
0.09705518186092377,
-0.9464975595474243,
0.44541630148887634,
-0.11359777301549911,
-0.5695686340332031,
-0.16873541474342346,
0.1964968591928482,
-0.29183733463287354,
-0.25814566016197205,
0.29819512367248535,
-0.40648943185806274,
0.6302379965782166,
-0.6086633801460266,
0.2579113245010376,
0.846152663230896,
-0.14043521881103516,
0.7132550477981567,
0.17495322227478027,
0.43680596351623535,
-0.20288881659507751,
0.32924240827560425,
-0.4370921552181244,
-0.20305190980434418,
-0.8867620229721069,
-0.37878042459487915,
0.31260064244270325,
0.457859069108963,
-0.9470848441123962,
0.13820314407348633,
-0.21502751111984253,
-0.4653172194957733,
-0.8246477246284485,
0.6477826833724976,
0.5676078796386719,
0.30177098512649536,
0.24467109143733978,
-0.13827642798423767,
-0.3792375326156616,
-0.9819356203079224,
-0.012188350781798363,
0.3530677855014801,
-0.0812157616019249,
-0.06122487783432007,
0.12323235720396042,
-0.08524923026561737,
0.6085140705108643,
-0.922429084777832,
-0.08118587732315063,
-0.18563514947891235,
0.11804579943418503,
0.2736315429210663,
0.5593627095222473,
0.3411492705345154,
-0.39373978972435,
-0.6129106879234314,
-0.10977930575609207,
-0.3611868917942047,
0.19516712427139282,
0.4132481813430786,
-0.145541250705719,
0.006091632880270481,
0.7202093601226807,
-0.5952277183532715,
0.23301337659358978,
0.5789396166801453,
-0.1846136450767517,
0.4456668496131897,
-0.10662425309419632,
0.15837892889976501,
-0.9306380748748779,
-0.2869752049446106,
-0.15330414474010468,
-0.27089449763298035,
-0.567488431930542,
0.36294060945510864,
0.23538616299629211,
-0.25824978947639465,
-0.6240269541740417,
0.2624470889568329,
-0.6153786778450012,
0.24083875119686127,
-0.09706428647041321,
-0.3222366273403168,
-0.06321988254785538,
0.3135928213596344,
-0.10326260328292847,
0.7767781615257263,
0.6536743640899658,
-0.6206035017967224,
0.3000774681568146,
0.16873370110988617,
-1.0335350036621094,
0.5203614234924316,
-0.6943058967590332,
0.4128163158893585,
-0.1972542256116867,
0.15727727115154266,
-0.8624179363250732,
-0.7962890863418579,
0.40423622727394104,
0.031977470964193344,
0.5321618914604187,
-0.6467266082763672,
-0.6066652536392212,
0.0652972161769867,
-0.3932109773159027,
0.3377065658569336,
0.17688114941120148,
-0.8204626441001892,
0.4708459973335266,
0.2589799761772156,
-0.3448844850063324,
-0.45325779914855957,
-0.574234127998352,
-0.1494595855474472,
0.14231836795806885,
-0.3159524202346802,
0.34514519572257996,
-0.4604637026786804,
-0.048742737621068954,
0.06279277056455612,
0.023920131847262383,
-0.36841312050819397,
-0.005676266271620989,
0.26951295137405396,
0.1745341420173645,
-0.4143216013908386,
0.16916903853416443,
0.5540961623191833,
-0.13893574476242065,
-0.08103140443563461,
0.0742158591747284,
0.3574889004230499,
0.07176227122545242,
-0.6319993138313293,
-0.42565077543258667,
0.35062071681022644,
0.4973265528678894,
-0.22080500423908234,
0.543595016002655,
0.3051401674747467,
-0.24240930378437042,
-0.8259923458099365,
-0.3536113500595093,
-0.1681184321641922,
-0.5400494933128357,
0.39173683524131775,
-0.06122271344065666,
-0.9233158230781555,
-0.17346732318401337,
-0.14141809940338135,
0.36507290601730347,
-0.04550419747829437,
0.2781059741973877,
-0.2695283591747284,
1.3612573146820068,
0.390807181596756,
0.13592588901519775,
0.4573322832584381,
-0.13999879360198975,
-0.031463880091905594,
-0.589021623134613,
-0.06836660206317902,
-0.5027329325675964,
-0.06694933027029037,
-0.36287951469421387,
-0.4578254222869873,
0.09792924672365189,
-0.2321183830499649,
-0.4638635218143463,
0.20007579028606415,
-0.7765769958496094,
0.8760533928871155,
0.4963172674179077,
0.2775506377220154,
0.2192133367061615,
0.21551388502120972,
0.6188228130340576,
0.04505793750286102,
-0.7466933131217957,
-0.46115222573280334,
0.9013217091560364,
0.17792364954948425,
1.0212233066558838,
0.1598421037197113,
0.8276830911636353,
0.2704055607318878,
0.346529096364975,
-1.0395585298538208,
0.7586617469787598,
-0.5394893884658813,
-0.5358656048774719,
-0.21014168858528137,
-0.48145219683647156,
-0.8687034845352173,
-0.14609721302986145,
-0.07385371625423431,
-0.46686387062072754,
-0.10596557706594467,
0.39631858468055725,
-0.562376856803894,
0.2650167942047119,
-1.059809684753418,
0.8730443716049194,
-0.3305477797985077,
-0.3728941082954407,
-0.15067937970161438,
-0.37210607528686523,
0.5154796838760376,
0.32545873522758484,
0.37334010004997253,
0.019219819456338882,
-0.014150272123515606,
0.531929075717926,
-0.5375662446022034,
1.1035133600234985,
-0.24105150997638702,
-0.27404844760894775,
0.5083478689193726,
0.40426525473594666,
0.665946364402771,
-0.11585833132266998,
-0.23752109706401825,
-0.32622671127319336,
0.014372340403497219,
-0.2208741307258606,
-0.7593033313751221,
0.9955348968505859,
-0.4905115067958832,
-0.5908101797103882,
-0.04085702821612358,
-0.42496153712272644,
-0.09872224181890488,
0.12601961195468903,
0.09264771640300751,
0.6897187232971191,
-0.1457296907901764,
0.4276658892631531,
1.0195029973983765,
-0.11227059364318848,
0.4108760952949524,
0.44877439737319946,
-0.13876605033874512,
-0.44501471519470215,
1.1281538009643555,
0.22851812839508057,
0.16770268976688385,
0.3673557639122009,
0.006511695217341185,
0.05581315606832504,
-0.4932551085948944,
-0.6028047800064087,
-0.19896404445171356,
-0.6941454410552979,
-0.30199486017227173,
-0.01681464910507202,
-0.25639545917510986,
-0.1590343862771988,
-0.1849210262298584,
-0.8341391682624817,
-0.32265540957450867,
-0.13188710808753967,
-0.14247071743011475,
0.2200407236814499,
0.9007173776626587,
0.22400611639022827,
0.4114611744880676,
-0.7485078573226929,
0.23671771585941315,
0.5016332268714905,
0.615700900554657,
0.1353299766778946,
-0.37384745478630066,
-0.6407037973403931,
0.17186497151851654,
-0.20656412839889526,
-0.34460005164146423,
-0.13439908623695374,
0.48793238401412964,
0.48161277174949646,
0.38393306732177734,
0.1189090758562088,
0.564356803894043,
-0.7147257328033447,
0.5424213409423828,
0.10202731192111969,
-1.0120455026626587,
0.5777794122695923,
0.039229921996593475,
0.5554871559143066,
0.7075399160385132,
0.2475198358297348,
-0.10436290502548218,
0.024020971730351448,
-0.2688004970550537,
-1.0695747137069702,
0.9114848375320435,
-0.120052270591259,
0.17318545281887054,
0.05590440705418587,
0.31733307242393494,
0.5450735092163086,
0.11941495537757874,
-0.6024450063705444,
-0.4635254740715027,
0.051840346306562424,
-0.526686429977417,
0.09051842242479324,
-0.3586300015449524,
-0.10433999449014664,
-0.32809513807296753,
0.5631328821182251,
-0.09331672638654709,
0.11762520670890808,
-0.4075164198875427,
-0.31511062383651733,
-0.003631817176938057,
0.2918858528137207,
0.39085257053375244,
0.47237589955329895,
-0.09956562519073486,
0.24490457773208618,
-0.08646972477436066,
-0.297195166349411,
0.3684035837650299,
0.04648853465914726,
-0.4432840645313263,
-0.15769252181053162,
0.4074072241783142,
0.6562228202819824,
0.7039710879325867,
-0.5770793557167053,
0.40338796377182007,
0.00503940973430872,
-0.014846141450107098,
-0.16515901684761047,
0.44500109553337097,
0.14171245694160461,
0.11746595054864883,
-0.008577186614274979,
-0.07471707463264465,
0.3503733277320862,
-0.43453434109687805,
0.082480788230896,
0.04701871797442436,
-0.3226906359195709,
-0.2720738649368286,
0.4555774927139282,
0.5532956719398499,
-0.5865201950073242,
0.9125587344169617,
-0.49141794443130493,
-0.0564335361123085,
0.565247654914856,
0.37873539328575134,
0.8114599585533142,
-0.31043505668640137,
0.2833738327026367,
0.44649532437324524,
0.1951838582754135,
-0.29705390334129333,
0.14148317277431488,
-0.10326032340526581,
-0.30798816680908203,
-0.8985637426376343,
-0.4942159354686737,
-0.4327464699745178,
0.1256132274866104,
-0.8055709600448608,
0.28773030638694763,
-0.6336822509765625,
0.28098568320274353,
-0.1097375899553299,
-0.5319210886955261,
-0.6890143156051636,
0.12191540002822876,
0.10903099179267883,
0.9540001749992371,
-0.5846225619316101,
0.8606594204902649,
0.7634809017181396,
-0.07638128846883774,
-0.6593520045280457,
-0.04253823682665825,
0.3382263481616974,
-0.3806621730327606,
0.47341156005859375,
0.24893732368946075,
-0.37927573919296265,
0.19206832349300385,
-1.0210574865341187,
-0.5609577894210815,
0.7032719850540161,
0.7379481792449951,
-0.7233363389968872,
-0.016969852149486542,
0.036812931299209595,
0.23652519285678864,
-0.26149675250053406,
-0.10430515557527542,
0.3872326910495758,
0.3900512456893921,
-0.07245035469532013,
-0.4546387195587158,
-0.03178664669394493,
-0.14962579309940338,
-0.3877536654472351,
0.35750484466552734,
-0.6540354490280151,
0.6029015779495239,
-0.10634218156337738,
-0.21873833239078522,
0.2764745056629181,
0.7090367674827576,
0.04088462516665459,
0.3119536340236664,
0.4419603943824768,
0.4417807161808014,
0.5601123571395874,
-0.047319233417510986,
0.7485395073890686,
-0.4334467053413391,
0.3031974732875824,
1.6502779722213745,
0.08849552273750305,
0.9248802065849304,
0.21568287909030914,
-0.2387332022190094,
0.4413679242134094,
0.6108640432357788,
0.16513951122760773,
0.45869213342666626,
0.08554644137620926,
-0.2741541266441345,
-0.4635361433029175,
0.029145309701561928,
-0.2698359191417694,
0.6351248621940613,
0.4288307726383209,
-0.1677914261817932,
-0.19822047650814056,
-0.20913399755954742,
0.05282166227698326,
0.11048722267150879,
-0.6108670234680176,
0.6049006581306458,
0.030602827668190002,
-0.526394784450531,
0.21381093561649323,
0.04952297359704971,
0.49191346764564514,
-0.7512858510017395,
-0.46744969487190247,
-0.1528952568769455,
0.09108191728591919,
-0.5420651435852051,
-1.0118597745895386,
0.051348283886909485,
-0.09635403007268906,
-0.35835158824920654,
-0.2650606334209442,
0.45316439867019653,
-0.6679413914680481,
-0.46724143624305725,
-0.04789403825998306,
0.385044664144516,
0.012023433111608028,
0.23379570245742798,
-0.4916718602180481,
0.1730068027973175,
0.2234427034854889,
-0.4491278827190399,
0.4035220742225647,
0.3214176893234253,
0.24396438896656036,
0.6769097447395325,
0.42699185013771057,
-0.0010465651284903288,
-0.1379537731409073,
0.0816807746887207,
0.5355815887451172,
-0.5017092227935791,
-0.11847183853387833,
-0.6807525157928467,
0.7405738234519958,
-0.1229213997721672,
-0.2335899919271469,
0.7264805436134338,
0.7398352026939392,
0.9978066086769104,
-0.376401424407959,
0.6216325163841248,
-0.12568072974681854,
0.4623573422431946,
-0.8294341564178467,
0.6011545062065125,
-0.39569735527038574,
0.3765963912010193,
-0.11570137739181519,
-1.015794038772583,
-0.2439688742160797,
0.468780517578125,
-0.14901548624038696,
-0.17492511868476868,
0.2707122564315796,
1.0246635675430298,
-0.47583863139152527,
-0.1417081505060196,
0.011902909725904465,
0.1403217762708664,
0.24406856298446655,
0.39014190435409546,
0.5616816878318787,
-0.20301438868045807,
0.6251511573791504,
-0.4260084927082062,
-0.15738177299499512,
-0.19832384586334229,
-0.8913791179656982,
-0.752242922782898,
-0.37510186433792114,
-0.5159763097763062,
-0.08656936883926392,
0.07736269384622574,
1.4518976211547852,
0.640552282333374,
-0.9583996534347534,
-0.47835901379585266,
0.08238659799098969,
0.3268949091434479,
-0.33452901244163513,
-0.20705899596214294,
0.7203139662742615,
-0.20498913526535034,
-1.1032137870788574,
0.8824105858802795,
0.3025410771369934,
-0.08174087107181549,
-0.15300512313842773,
-0.0951421856880188,
0.01606070250272751,
-0.028961237519979477,
0.829343318939209,
0.506763219833374,
-0.24929119646549225,
-0.2674972712993622,
-0.241008460521698,
-0.29935869574546814,
-0.08399716764688492,
0.6978047490119934,
-0.23047436773777008,
0.7124657034873962,
0.3690696954727173,
0.8167584538459778,
0.3733784854412079,
-0.250610888004303,
0.5604456067085266,
-0.744393527507782,
0.17452506721019745,
-0.09700164943933487,
0.32912659645080566,
0.405999094247818,
-0.20781144499778748,
0.5632217526435852,
-0.07146502286195755,
-0.44381511211395264,
-0.9146187901496887,
0.4186916649341583,
-0.6008461117744446,
-0.2764705419540405,
0.9459268450737,
-0.12206994742155075,
-0.30150946974754333,
0.06281767785549164,
-0.40028396248817444,
0.05032190680503845,
-0.41185635328292847,
0.7754318118095398,
0.6457889080047607,
-0.25778308510780334,
-0.17173349857330322,
-0.5873610973358154,
0.3917787969112396,
0.08521562069654465,
-0.7595964670181274,
0.1392318308353424,
0.6428396701812744,
0.29438358545303345,
-0.3230327367782593,
0.04467295482754707,
0.20286878943443298,
0.4363635182380676,
0.019681284204125404,
0.37188977003097534,
-0.4183632433414459,
-0.3440251648426056,
-0.1267022043466568,
0.4401521682739258,
0.2694181203842163,
-0.20464900135993958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03043v1 | SIDU-TXT: An XAI Algorithm for NLP with a Holistic Assessment Approach | 2024-02-05T14:29:54 | 2024-02-05T14:29:54 | Mohammad N. S. Jahromi, Satya. M. Muddamsetty, Asta Sofie Stage Jarlner, Anna Murphy Høgenhaug, Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen, Thomas B. Moeslund | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Explainable AI (XAI) aids in deciphering 'black-box' models. While several
methods have been proposed and evaluated primarily in the image domain, the
exploration of explainability in the text domain remains a growing research
area. In this paper, we delve into the applicability of XAI methods for the
text domain. In this context, the 'Similarity Difference and Uniqueness' (SIDU)
XAI method, recognized for its superior capability in localizing entire salient
regions in image-based classification is extended to textual data. The extended
method, SIDU-TXT, utilizes feature activation maps from 'black-box' models to
generate heatmaps at a granular, word-based level, thereby providing
explanations that highlight contextually significant textual elements crucial
for model predictions. Given the absence of a unified standard for assessing
XAI methods, this study applies a holistic three-tiered comprehensive
evaluation framework: Functionally-Grounded, Human-Grounded and
Application-Grounded, to assess the effectiveness of the proposed SIDU-TXT
across various experiments. We find that, in sentiment analysis task of a movie
review dataset, SIDU-TXT excels in both functionally and human-grounded
evaluations, demonstrating superior performance through quantitative and
qualitative analyses compared to benchmarks like Grad-CAM and LIME. In the
application-grounded evaluation within the sensitive and complex legal domain
of asylum decision-making, SIDU-TXT and Grad-CAM demonstrate comparable
performances, each with its own set of strengths and weaknesses. However, both
methods fall short of entirely fulfilling the sophisticated criteria of expert
expectations, highlighting the imperative need for additional research in XAI
methods suitable for such domains. | [
-0.4385910630226135,
-0.6340680718421936,
0.5240586996078491,
0.01220595184713602,
-0.48321861028671265,
0.22828546166419983,
-0.22380563616752625,
-0.34959203004837036,
0.14742882549762726,
-0.01783245988190174,
-0.48910272121429443,
-0.47292593121528625,
-0.5832025408744812,
-0.003605964593589306,
-0.4972667396068573,
1.0699801445007324,
-0.07518575340509415,
-0.23702138662338257,
-0.2783884108066559,
-0.4401991069316864,
-0.6219497323036194,
-0.40058624744415283,
-0.5549439787864685,
-0.2849154472351074,
0.4280856251716614,
0.06824135035276413,
1.0040022134780884,
0.6396059393882751,
0.7332131862640381,
0.22217051684856415,
-0.025758538395166397,
-0.22874829173088074,
-0.178480327129364,
-0.03479546681046486,
-0.5423716306686401,
-0.511768102645874,
-0.4069509506225586,
-0.05421580374240875,
0.38077694177627563,
0.3566480278968811,
-0.06511503458023071,
0.002325482200831175,
-0.08331399410963058,
0.5546866059303284,
-0.552051305770874,
0.17242318391799927,
-0.6663342118263245,
0.1614539474248886,
-0.040611643344163895,
-0.4433300197124481,
-0.1351233571767807,
0.0682782381772995,
0.4532241225242615,
-0.5214025974273682,
0.49314984679222107,
0.16561003029346466,
0.8662127256393433,
0.4106462895870209,
-0.23214901983737946,
-0.3293576240539551,
-0.6600782871246338,
0.8578316569328308,
-0.6311606764793396,
0.040609996765851974,
0.2886737585067749,
0.24892941117286682,
0.23269934952259064,
-0.2942046523094177,
-0.8673296570777893,
-0.1325283795595169,
-0.1631176620721817,
0.357276976108551,
-0.17865638434886932,
0.02922743931412697,
0.2032655030488968,
0.5236067175865173,
-0.7301304936408997,
0.0727250799536705,
0.06430307030677795,
0.2640576958656311,
0.7154732942581177,
-0.035433486104011536,
0.5190656185150146,
-0.5371742844581604,
-0.4275940954685211,
-0.0877416655421257,
-0.3173946142196655,
0.22062449157238007,
0.054797954857349396,
0.09156212955713272,
-0.18127906322479248,
0.2696174085140228,
0.09467078000307083,
0.2614486813545227,
-0.39181411266326904,
-0.14803113043308258,
0.13180649280548096,
-0.08754318207502365,
-0.30746227502822876,
0.15648314356803894,
0.6453113555908203,
0.5627683401107788,
-0.02719852142035961,
-0.2113466113805771,
-0.24944539368152618,
0.5267729759216309,
0.46068212389945984,
-0.43317052721977234,
0.11737839132547379,
0.4273378252983093,
-0.659660816192627,
-0.5520564317703247,
-0.050264570862054825,
-0.8751042485237122,
-0.4698677062988281,
-0.2563273012638092,
0.3810757100582123,
-0.40843474864959717,
-0.5031747817993164,
-0.1766095906496048,
-0.27509647607803345,
0.6648478507995605,
0.34501731395721436,
-0.6832508444786072,
0.26317936182022095,
0.7952169179916382,
1.0450984239578247,
-0.5882351398468018,
-0.19272936880588531,
-0.2712111175060272,
-0.0810023844242096,
-0.18342247605323792,
0.7553877234458923,
-0.6999171376228333,
-0.2567062973976135,
-0.09172596782445908,
-0.22415323555469513,
-0.04294935613870621,
-0.2538089454174042,
0.9084903597831726,
-0.36910000443458557,
0.20462749898433685,
-0.17261721193790436,
-0.2913479804992676,
-0.47301000356674194,
0.38339927792549133,
-0.5472605228424072,
0.7764708995819092,
0.3013981878757477,
-0.8510774970054626,
0.4883214831352234,
-1.102170705795288,
-0.4439519941806793,
0.23800890147686005,
-0.36818236112594604,
-0.4056445062160492,
0.16902026534080505,
0.2599720358848572,
0.5714405179023743,
-0.5011808276176453,
0.6280754208564758,
-0.12857672572135925,
-0.5046057105064392,
0.29132309556007385,
-0.6639456152915955,
0.7833181023597717,
0.10821494460105896,
-0.91597580909729,
0.20307937264442444,
-0.7336153388023376,
-0.14677414298057556,
0.2508051097393036,
0.08172129839658737,
-0.5734793543815613,
0.05058453604578972,
0.1850094497203827,
0.23708301782608032,
-0.4583510756492615,
-0.5039452314376831,
0.01874459721148014,
-0.35942378640174866,
0.5732923746109009,
0.5950706601142883,
-0.25944432616233826,
0.3125649690628052,
-0.5248176455497742,
0.7686648964881897,
-0.03773820400238037,
-0.21820004284381866,
-0.6707112193107605,
-0.6836073398590088,
-0.39924517273902893,
-0.24963237345218658,
0.1672724187374115,
0.6274502277374268,
-0.8352347612380981,
0.3964378237724304,
-0.48819881677627563,
-0.3967176675796509,
-0.7703170776367188,
-0.15665610134601593,
0.3925679326057434,
0.6372776627540588,
0.28316959738731384,
-0.2889689803123474,
-0.2876232862472534,
-0.5333348512649536,
-0.23448830842971802,
-0.4473112225532532,
0.04317346215248108,
0.39585280418395996,
0.5702602863311768,
-0.48921632766723633,
0.9278921484947205,
-0.16859139502048492,
-0.31576356291770935,
-0.19556951522827148,
0.3097308874130249,
0.05529303103685379,
0.32008570432662964,
0.5639417767524719,
-1.1097631454467773,
-0.19181519746780396,
0.2851198613643646,
-1.12649405002594,
0.2045532763004303,
-0.5098294615745544,
-0.00781842228025198,
0.2319369614124298,
0.022058818489313126,
-0.4850997030735016,
0.8242732882499695,
0.2478606402873993,
-0.3353480100631714,
0.33593255281448364,
-0.1890137642621994,
0.3874218165874481,
-0.8593170642852783,
0.17555005848407745,
0.24958570301532745,
-0.2966744899749756,
-0.5296436548233032,
0.4944482743740082,
-0.13299278914928436,
-0.20865648984909058,
-0.25012052059173584,
0.6476877927780151,
-0.17874079942703247,
0.030125247314572334,
-0.22614525258541107,
0.4793214201927185,
0.119576096534729,
0.7152158617973328,
0.18365299701690674,
0.39811643958091736,
0.6893469095230103,
-0.2068661004304886,
0.23085545003414154,
0.2569181025028229,
-0.3329477608203888,
0.6668686270713806,
-0.7722852230072021,
0.04828883334994316,
-0.3045579493045807,
0.017455799505114555,
-1.08807373046875,
0.03170129284262657,
0.21015363931655884,
-0.3790615499019623,
0.10857688635587692,
-0.05269626900553703,
-0.04191690683364868,
-0.1360410898923874,
-0.48214972019195557,
0.47122353315353394,
0.5908666253089905,
-0.5895920991897583,
0.5806653499603271,
0.23337852954864502,
-0.3272342383861542,
-0.6340550184249878,
-0.5789788961410522,
0.306945264339447,
-0.5783613324165344,
-0.5264397263526917,
0.6135429739952087,
-0.07247235625982285,
-0.42933937907218933,
-0.008589078672230244,
-0.06605791300535202,
-0.10594481229782104,
0.33665722608566284,
0.5449725985527039,
0.3126024603843689,
-0.378678560256958,
-0.18527847528457642,
0.2915830910205841,
-0.3265153765678406,
0.2457764446735382,
-0.04829881340265274,
0.10765527933835983,
-0.28190720081329346,
-0.14946451783180237,
-0.5890311002731323,
0.5266720652580261,
0.5649325847625732,
-0.13663987815380096,
0.46062034368515015,
0.7519699335098267,
-0.3747985064983368,
-0.011156431399285793,
-0.13191436231136322,
0.21527373790740967,
-0.3381951153278351,
0.113541379570961,
-0.42454755306243896,
-0.5352144837379456,
0.38840189576148987,
0.11523111909627914,
0.1167275533080101,
0.485171377658844,
0.607677698135376,
-0.08403504639863968,
0.7940660715103149,
0.6668741106987,
0.004850148689001799,
0.19768139719963074,
-0.44090208411216736,
0.48774242401123047,
-0.6734863519668579,
-0.0207145344465971,
-0.40767285227775574,
-0.2970372438430786,
-0.6567702889442444,
-0.16434285044670105,
0.1362963616847992,
-0.2017616182565689,
0.40859857201576233,
0.15564629435539246,
-0.6464969515800476,
0.3899238705635071,
0.5191377997398376,
-0.0011045514838770032,
0.3343737721443176,
0.1070651262998581,
0.031874023377895355,
-0.014932082034647465,
-0.5675531029701233,
-0.6868063807487488,
0.7965330481529236,
0.43222859501838684,
0.4848974943161011,
0.02029125951230526,
0.5308687686920166,
0.7677924633026123,
0.49076008796691895,
-0.9571067094802856,
0.3113899230957031,
0.04575527831912041,
-0.41512149572372437,
-0.40187373757362366,
-0.19805723428726196,
-0.980816125869751,
0.38143107295036316,
-0.22229641675949097,
-0.6161291599273682,
0.2497623711824417,
-0.1829155832529068,
-0.4415266811847687,
0.4002269208431244,
-0.8644772171974182,
0.6580565571784973,
-0.23594193160533905,
-0.28924205899238586,
-0.1865876019001007,
-0.7639163732528687,
0.2863104045391083,
-0.3276788294315338,
0.3487323820590973,
-0.13985903561115265,
0.03643321618437767,
0.9513366222381592,
-0.2733064889907837,
0.4765191376209259,
-0.2554919421672821,
-0.15820851922035217,
0.1935630440711975,
-0.06981785595417023,
-0.1332453042268753,
0.29590046405792236,
-0.37974539399147034,
0.5064023733139038,
0.41094139218330383,
-0.46913179755210876,
-0.9732753038406372,
0.7024703025817871,
-0.8591731190681458,
-0.7165988683700562,
-0.48741424083709717,
-0.49704793095588684,
0.20758359134197235,
0.25184640288352966,
0.25565874576568604,
0.612563967704773,
-0.2092386782169342,
0.1208871379494667,
0.3957783877849579,
-0.4036768078804016,
0.5216867327690125,
0.09253427386283875,
-0.07433030009269714,
-0.1542433351278305,
1.0716216564178467,
0.1196618378162384,
-0.3322610855102539,
0.618075966835022,
0.3382817506790161,
-0.1608840674161911,
-0.6416943669319153,
-0.3817175328731537,
-0.02388954348862171,
-0.6380621194839478,
-0.16922320425510406,
-0.7042052745819092,
-0.09827279299497604,
-0.29773664474487305,
-0.4831632077693939,
0.0662672370672226,
-0.36627671122550964,
0.18236877024173737,
-0.10002206265926361,
0.06766974925994873,
0.6593255400657654,
0.2471417933702469,
0.4248931407928467,
-0.4226163327693939,
0.8619336485862732,
0.011914574541151524,
0.44739601016044617,
0.0337037667632103,
-0.45930081605911255,
-0.14440615475177765,
0.09236686676740646,
-0.16934873163700104,
-0.7526135444641113,
0.352384090423584,
0.1726338118314743,
0.5247688889503479,
0.6029061079025269,
0.2873079478740692,
0.46942567825317383,
-0.08231908082962036,
0.8427351117134094,
-0.08029158413410187,
-1.003373146057129,
0.8778541684150696,
-0.3240317702293396,
0.09861687570810318,
0.3568626940250397,
0.6333372592926025,
-0.34867265820503235,
-0.10713884979486465,
-0.8844098448753357,
-0.8648630380630493,
0.721725344657898,
0.6662241220474243,
0.2355722188949585,
0.09108449518680573,
0.6239520907402039,
0.47923633456230164,
0.13280758261680603,
-0.6202892661094666,
-0.4156462848186493,
-0.16965121030807495,
-0.11491167545318604,
-0.13209199905395508,
-0.21106113493442535,
-0.05103841796517372,
-0.1307440847158432,
0.6276595592498779,
-0.1734541356563568,
0.5673559904098511,
0.3447725772857666,
-0.245854914188385,
0.08308237791061401,
0.4325217306613922,
0.37315550446510315,
0.728601336479187,
-0.42627471685409546,
0.11017332971096039,
-0.1919535994529724,
-0.41720396280288696,
0.3221367597579956,
0.13968928158283234,
-0.23630079627037048,
0.19823437929153442,
0.7430452108383179,
0.7573519945144653,
-0.23242002725601196,
-0.5817515850067139,
0.6423754692077637,
-0.5326691269874573,
-0.093956857919693,
-0.0817849263548851,
0.13161267340183258,
-0.6229112148284912,
-0.1057320237159729,
0.27251917123794556,
0.38630253076553345,
0.2549647092819214,
-0.6803062558174133,
0.11800773441791534,
0.2855101227760315,
-0.5946229100227356,
-0.3095097541809082,
0.5547181963920593,
0.20690160989761353,
-0.5095206499099731,
0.49860745668411255,
-0.2569975256919861,
-0.253536194562912,
0.563878059387207,
0.2568756341934204,
1.0636513233184814,
-0.11526143550872803,
0.5049154758453369,
0.010553563944995403,
0.2987765073776245,
0.20884549617767334,
0.1656903177499771,
-0.4694395363330841,
-0.7963709235191345,
-0.13030953705310822,
-0.29050275683403015,
-0.4473872780799866,
-0.02566865086555481,
-1.0492537021636963,
0.1950024664402008,
-0.47260400652885437,
-0.039572812616825104,
0.29462018609046936,
-0.004337984137237072,
-0.6969332098960876,
0.4400089681148529,
0.0527784563601017,
0.7524216771125793,
-0.8117045760154724,
0.6970834136009216,
0.8055748343467712,
-0.4107469320297241,
-0.2946924567222595,
0.21665996313095093,
0.01869179494678974,
-0.6847409009933472,
0.029398275539278984,
0.3126050531864166,
-0.06327083706855774,
-0.22223250567913055,
-0.366685152053833,
-0.3613402247428894,
1.0525643825531006,
0.2585938572883606,
-0.25889843702316284,
-0.12979288399219513,
-0.07335003465414047,
0.7652100324630737,
-0.49507755041122437,
0.5747541785240173,
0.9360488057136536,
0.23990115523338318,
0.0028788188938051462,
-0.3675440549850464,
0.1705121099948883,
-0.7585623860359192,
0.19822528958320618,
-0.2614539563655853,
-0.3411911725997925,
-0.031503837555646896,
-0.4423517882823944,
-0.2207234799861908,
-0.06544392555952072,
0.6336754560470581,
0.18306401371955872,
0.8074390888214111,
0.5831974744796753,
0.33134108781814575,
0.9035822153091431,
-0.19465026259422302,
1.3063656091690063,
-0.09263170510530472,
0.19790740311145782,
1.0230822563171387,
-0.3325318396091461,
0.7678017020225525,
0.4200100600719452,
-0.01594340056180954,
0.6911341547966003,
0.4330713748931885,
-0.038884878158569336,
0.37218132615089417,
0.05488423630595207,
-0.08482852578163147,
0.19877338409423828,
-0.2829592227935791,
-0.057671502232551575,
0.3855975866317749,
0.44188281893730164,
-0.2683520019054413,
-0.13435162603855133,
0.4520776867866516,
-0.000014898912013450172,
0.11602523177862167,
-0.14106376469135284,
0.7905055284500122,
0.0323156900703907,
-0.7219158411026001,
0.5568209886550903,
0.2373478263616562,
0.6139995455741882,
-0.3074285387992859,
-0.16073556244373322,
-0.28259605169296265,
0.02499345876276493,
-0.33582115173339844,
-1.0026534795761108,
0.5131389498710632,
0.19471944868564606,
-0.3085381090641022,
-0.42175421118736267,
0.6810865998268127,
-0.07185345143079758,
-0.31841620802879333,
0.321496844291687,
0.3381510376930237,
0.3172438144683838,
-0.14525337517261505,
-0.9763578176498413,
0.16987083852291107,
-0.041200533509254456,
-0.05713943392038345,
0.02104036696255207,
0.5718284845352173,
-0.3987882137298584,
0.7386983633041382,
0.44264358282089233,
-0.08014906942844391,
-0.3303165137767792,
0.12416611611843109,
0.5792519450187683,
-0.7943517565727234,
-0.6507596373558044,
-0.8730199933052063,
0.6347898244857788,
0.0977073609828949,
-0.36784154176712036,
0.45379117131233215,
0.3007637560367584,
0.5810927152633667,
0.09295587241649628,
1.1992518901824951,
-0.2384711652994156,
0.1742735058069229,
-0.4583468735218048,
0.6393049955368042,
-0.4750744700431824,
0.4374149441719055,
-0.7556975483894348,
-0.9938705563545227,
-0.47606509923934937,
0.636929988861084,
-0.257971853017807,
0.20381715893745422,
0.8754140734672546,
0.7129361033439636,
-0.06343655288219452,
0.22870226204395294,
0.6207112669944763,
0.2568937838077545,
0.4239594042301178,
0.1844928115606308,
0.9056850671768188,
-0.6972264647483826,
0.21834824979305267,
-0.3079758584499359,
-0.6406968235969543,
0.04918939992785454,
-0.8312633633613586,
-0.8872804045677185,
-0.8342974185943604,
-0.7815508842468262,
-0.16955597698688507,
-0.04940570890903473,
0.8180661797523499,
0.7708222270011902,
-0.7547024488449097,
-0.023804225027561188,
0.16982540488243103,
0.5240902304649353,
-0.5176162719726562,
-0.2802531123161316,
0.5580076575279236,
-0.09158744663000107,
-0.45809611678123474,
0.1461174488067627,
0.5760884284973145,
-0.0687335655093193,
-0.37030893564224243,
-0.03530481085181236,
-0.09750598669052124,
0.14546804130077362,
0.7610929608345032,
0.019749362021684647,
-0.9266349077224731,
0.04384111613035202,
-0.19083833694458008,
0.2258109599351883,
0.2893159091472626,
1.1253806352615356,
-0.8737845420837402,
0.5449232459068298,
0.4917755424976349,
0.8092174530029297,
0.07950503379106522,
0.049712538719177246,
0.6211686730384827,
-0.5287312865257263,
-0.0459369532763958,
-0.0939558669924736,
0.4935199022293091,
0.4456849694252014,
-0.7255058884620667,
0.6777217984199524,
0.17552007734775543,
-0.352614164352417,
-0.7278579473495483,
-0.2413923591375351,
-1.3227680921554565,
-0.2095259726047516,
0.9178134202957153,
-0.44752028584480286,
-0.3755311369895935,
-0.27032655477523804,
-0.5149474143981934,
-0.024523794651031494,
-0.3475116789340973,
1.0360974073410034,
0.5994074940681458,
-0.024135835468769073,
-0.4422803521156311,
-0.3151964545249939,
0.4188763499259949,
0.42094722390174866,
-0.9023597836494446,
0.03319113701581955,
-0.1243729367852211,
-0.12142941355705261,
0.3132864236831665,
0.468176007270813,
-0.25295087695121765,
0.22314101457595825,
-0.23627609014511108,
-0.15871509909629822,
0.3089452385902405,
-0.3995152413845062,
-0.7917472124099731,
0.19248336553573608,
-0.022484751418232918,
0.08724642544984818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03038v1 | Automatic Combination of Sample Selection Strategies for Few-Shot Learning | 2024-02-05T14:23:43 | 2024-02-05T14:23:43 | Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova, Joaquin Vanschoren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In few-shot learning, such as meta-learning, few-shot fine-tuning or
in-context learning, the limited number of samples used to train a model have a
significant impact on the overall success. Although a large number of sample
selection strategies exist, their impact on the performance of few-shot
learning is not extensively known, as most of them have been so far evaluated
in typical supervised settings only. In this paper, we thoroughly investigate
the impact of 20 sample selection strategies on the performance of 5 few-shot
learning approaches over 8 image and 6 text datasets. In addition, we propose a
new method for automatic combination of sample selection strategies (ACSESS)
that leverages the strengths and complementary information of the individual
strategies. The experimental results show that our method consistently
outperforms the individual selection strategies, as well as the recently
proposed method for selecting support examples for in-context learning. We also
show a strong modality, dataset and approach dependence for the majority of
strategies as well as their dependence on the number of shots - demonstrating
that the sample selection strategies play a significant role for lower number
of shots, but regresses to random selection at higher number of shots. | [
-0.7615134119987488,
-0.477172315120697,
0.4044092297554016,
-0.28435105085372925,
-0.4741678535938263,
-0.1344885379076004,
-0.17964637279510498,
-0.46108564734458923,
0.11820323765277863,
0.05989797040820122,
-0.5494167804718018,
-0.5289837121963501,
-0.6346930861473083,
0.6064954996109009,
-0.04426015168428421,
0.8411988615989685,
0.09967481344938278,
0.45763739943504333,
-0.08383449912071228,
-0.36526989936828613,
-0.5566532611846924,
-0.0006415377138182521,
-0.6692900061607361,
-0.2791367471218109,
0.30263879895210266,
0.7872830033302307,
-0.09314817935228348,
0.4816419184207916,
0.850243330001831,
0.2945738732814789,
0.0020720718894153833,
0.2728487253189087,
-0.3762426972389221,
0.05319172143936157,
0.08015640825033188,
-0.6725317239761353,
0.13927902281284332,
0.08288204669952393,
0.710229218006134,
0.3523286283016205,
0.28170520067214966,
0.266839861869812,
0.32697030901908875,
0.39299288392066956,
-1.1480956077575684,
-0.25052255392074585,
-0.6450665593147278,
0.3490118682384491,
-0.38128024339675903,
-0.23980224132537842,
-0.437643826007843,
-0.041799817234277725,
0.1978769153356552,
-0.4486668109893799,
0.3060206174850464,
-0.06242071092128754,
0.3130926787853241,
0.2450622022151947,
-0.31328457593917847,
-0.19043377041816711,
-0.5972817540168762,
0.9837855696678162,
-0.5335164666175842,
-0.16211532056331635,
0.5216310024261475,
0.8052902221679688,
0.09188801795244217,
-0.41738608479499817,
-0.24589642882347107,
0.003308223094791174,
-0.12443889677524567,
0.2927260100841522,
-0.03271857649087906,
0.14804382622241974,
0.38532137870788574,
-0.1880704164505005,
-0.28673499822616577,
0.2815898358821869,
-0.4031113386154175,
-0.10231569409370422,
0.6645607948303223,
0.15442438423633575,
-0.11255188286304474,
-0.29300591349601746,
-0.26183971762657166,
-0.4732608199119568,
-0.5448240041732788,
0.2702268064022064,
0.33229196071624756,
0.5391108989715576,
-0.036126211285591125,
0.4169172942638397,
-0.3952561616897583,
0.9508495330810547,
0.28649264574050903,
-0.5404462814331055,
0.1607825756072998,
-0.3193444311618805,
-0.26226991415023804,
-0.15841755270957947,
0.8479028940200806,
0.000022552145310328342,
-0.0882849171757698,
0.14803700149059296,
-0.2984757721424103,
-0.24226370453834534,
-0.04536399617791176,
-0.67792147397995,
-0.1570085883140564,
-0.13478682935237885,
-0.5833094716072083,
-0.5140907764434814,
0.25539863109588623,
-0.771257758140564,
-0.012551646679639816,
-0.07787945121526718,
0.5907233357429504,
-0.5571802258491516,
0.4387742280960083,
-0.3982577621936798,
-0.538366973400116,
0.2645253837108612,
0.5092583894729614,
-0.7801194787025452,
0.6127765774726868,
0.07911748439073563,
0.9165329337120056,
-0.5475531220436096,
-0.43163278698921204,
-0.9377306699752808,
-0.02828471176326275,
-0.3312961459159851,
1.262532114982605,
-0.8353816866874695,
-0.6326414346694946,
-0.2599286437034607,
-0.45630979537963867,
0.05217767506837845,
-0.574929416179657,
0.20077115297317505,
-0.33795303106307983,
0.08517346531152725,
-0.3102160096168518,
-0.6356338858604431,
-0.3874336779117584,
0.26599985361099243,
-0.9140446782112122,
0.7792348265647888,
-0.0919640064239502,
-0.5238803625106812,
0.7562133073806763,
-0.5231760144233704,
-0.5628867745399475,
0.04717966541647911,
-0.4260506331920624,
-0.7146634459495544,
0.04763984680175781,
0.2868073880672455,
0.6532991528511047,
0.06365306675434113,
-0.6765656471252441,
-0.6137149333953857,
-0.7327228784561157,
0.14225979149341583,
-0.4426490068435669,
0.6689884066581726,
0.06774765253067017,
-0.3443552851676941,
-0.31925827264785767,
-0.7768389582633972,
0.1322770118713379,
0.066543810069561,
-0.3289770185947418,
-0.29220351576805115,
-0.3037298321723938,
-0.10971541702747345,
0.19258907437324524,
-0.5216344594955444,
-0.1412048488855362,
0.3137851655483246,
-0.24570459127426147,
-0.0036091250367462635,
0.4183029532432556,
0.5597312450408936,
0.7462105751037598,
-0.4883379340171814,
0.6678422093391418,
-0.0221481304615736,
-0.0070531838573515415,
-0.44588202238082886,
-0.2526446580886841,
-0.32475781440734863,
-0.5989198684692383,
0.5039300918579102,
0.41957083344459534,
-0.7441536784172058,
0.2251623272895813,
0.15734955668449402,
-0.34579020738601685,
-0.3278858959674835,
0.7284343242645264,
0.5079421401023865,
0.35964688658714294,
0.6254196166992188,
-0.5880701541900635,
-0.561979353427887,
-0.560325562953949,
-0.0634574219584465,
0.08911971002817154,
0.19833876192569733,
0.5124924778938293,
0.7715741991996765,
0.25854209065437317,
1.3206511735916138,
-0.5173138380050659,
-0.6968725919723511,
-0.44087573885917664,
0.24424947798252106,
-0.1682010442018509,
0.20268280804157257,
1.1008154153823853,
-0.36151835322380066,
-0.5811226963996887,
-0.5009084343910217,
-0.5306539535522461,
0.12960845232009888,
-0.23123799264431,
0.09671938419342041,
0.14389392733573914,
0.2708304524421692,
-0.14158006012439728,
0.506953239440918,
0.17664563655853271,
0.3993408679962158,
0.33752238750457764,
0.0923205316066742,
0.06306785345077515,
-0.7262216806411743,
-0.3199135363101959,
0.5742201805114746,
-0.27328574657440186,
-0.19447579979896545,
-0.17246633768081665,
0.06747180223464966,
0.224116250872612,
-1.052842140197754,
0.6259093880653381,
-0.49828794598579407,
-0.07603518664836884,
-0.424376517534256,
-0.14615663886070251,
0.004461232107132673,
0.46987658739089966,
0.16068081557750702,
0.3953378200531006,
0.7557395100593567,
-0.6203302145004272,
0.3224315941333771,
0.4466901123523712,
-0.1967461109161377,
0.6102516651153564,
-0.3394545614719391,
0.25909459590911865,
-0.19610072672367096,
0.9003524780273438,
-0.9590367674827576,
-0.31523728370666504,
0.03819306567311287,
-0.17993009090423584,
0.43579381704330444,
-0.37133267521858215,
-0.4510529935359955,
-0.2793036103248596,
-0.5460935831069946,
0.3680092692375183,
0.13646994531154633,
-0.3996621370315552,
0.3466447591781616,
0.07139749825000763,
0.26610153913497925,
-0.5515584349632263,
-0.8281413316726685,
-0.1584058701992035,
-0.3706483244895935,
-0.04533957690000534,
0.2446838617324829,
0.1705915480852127,
-0.15837620198726654,
-0.16294753551483154,
-0.036452509462833405,
0.09183170646429062,
0.06976909935474396,
-0.020166825503110886,
0.3997495770454407,
0.05365132912993431,
0.1415501981973648,
0.19271314144134521,
-0.17722013592720032,
-0.6660064458847046,
-0.157739520072937,
0.31652265787124634,
0.0397014245390892,
-0.5011960864067078,
-0.4256110191345215,
0.40768963098526,
-0.09137467294931412,
-0.2215053141117096,
0.5446270108222961,
0.7279326915740967,
-0.15844514966011047,
-0.5166699886322021,
-0.4445738196372986,
-0.796888530254364,
-0.3788919150829315,
0.19032225012779236,
-0.3104773163795471,
-0.4844150245189667,
0.2700214684009552,
-0.20060600340366364,
-0.052313100546598434,
0.3750317692756653,
0.3949691951274872,
-0.6755287051200867,
0.7517940998077393,
0.4302009046077728,
-0.28133031725883484,
0.7207004427909851,
-0.808464765548706,
-0.3485710918903351,
-0.5550694465637207,
0.05411405488848686,
-0.27410903573036194,
-0.9772833585739136,
-0.5012189745903015,
-0.13162386417388916,
0.7888900637626648,
-0.10933053493499756,
0.009686390869319439,
0.34026679396629333,
-0.2123599350452423,
0.8656092286109924,
0.9214757084846497,
0.6311214566230774,
0.3958395719528198,
-0.010350308381021023,
-0.3363957405090332,
0.15033142268657684,
-0.905482292175293,
-0.21978335082530975,
1.3942482471466064,
-0.016309911385178566,
0.8292355537414551,
-0.12359986454248428,
1.2935359477996826,
0.0961267352104187,
-0.10841970145702362,
-1.0018205642700195,
0.49614232778549194,
-0.33592191338539124,
-0.6534960269927979,
-0.4274604618549347,
-0.2023477852344513,
-0.8500905632972717,
0.17773599922657013,
-0.925287127494812,
-0.3730233907699585,
0.3873852789402008,
0.12925611436367035,
-1.0139209032058716,
0.03022153675556183,
-0.7922475934028625,
0.476784884929657,
-0.42838144302368164,
-0.3944564759731293,
-0.23688320815563202,
-0.9086695909500122,
0.16806766390800476,
-0.021545177325606346,
-0.17598506808280945,
0.25746411085128784,
-0.015196124091744423,
0.6704913973808289,
-0.053825512528419495,
1.2262681722640991,
-0.07181164622306824,
0.6845284700393677,
0.6137794852256775,
-0.07232639193534851,
0.4449503421783447,
-0.19948072731494904,
0.13389374315738678,
0.07156559079885483,
0.09202330559492111,
-0.3649091422557831,
-0.411641925573349,
0.24064379930496216,
-0.6983450055122375,
-0.11477898061275482,
-0.3319450914859772,
-0.1786315143108368,
-0.42381390929222107,
0.2508089244365692,
0.9193329811096191,
0.5076615214347839,
-0.3270781338214874,
0.39767906069755554,
0.47346609830856323,
0.05229716747999191,
0.9582281112670898,
0.2520310580730438,
0.39293935894966125,
-0.6036174893379211,
0.5639709830284119,
0.34403377771377563,
0.34188225865364075,
0.2714952230453491,
0.2653878629207611,
0.0353102870285511,
-0.6653071045875549,
-0.10822135955095291,
0.05935581028461456,
-0.8223106265068054,
-0.7463846802711487,
-0.2580064535140991,
0.04352639243006706,
-0.38878291845321655,
-0.20876173675060272,
-0.21178625524044037,
-0.3074324429035187,
-0.4325621724128723,
-0.10771650075912476,
0.08546518534421921,
0.28811296820640564,
-0.0027065712492913008,
0.5962746739387512,
-0.8564147353172302,
0.5189091563224792,
0.5298559069633484,
0.1171082928776741,
-0.16060619056224823,
-0.3270547688007355,
-0.31300848722457886,
-0.18905450403690338,
-0.7848087549209595,
-1.0890127420425415,
0.12107393890619278,
0.5144792795181274,
0.7229982614517212,
0.6221317052841187,
-0.06657100468873978,
0.6350030899047852,
-0.3726728558540344,
0.30078479647636414,
0.2309591919183731,
-0.4514990448951721,
0.7210994958877563,
-0.09861885011196136,
0.3668138086795807,
1.2555148601531982,
0.4451511800289154,
0.07719318568706512,
-0.1471557468175888,
-0.7532273530960083,
-0.3447166979312897,
0.8052764534950256,
0.22685930132865906,
-0.13082052767276764,
0.2634774446487427,
0.01087648794054985,
0.20687538385391235,
-0.031279634684324265,
-0.4194425940513611,
-0.24930863082408905,
0.11465348303318024,
-0.2205306589603424,
0.22391945123672485,
0.32550114393234253,
-0.43870192766189575,
-0.2928411662578583,
0.4214504361152649,
-0.5953760743141174,
0.031226756051182747,
0.03748295083642006,
-0.2425462007522583,
-0.32470643520355225,
0.09404149651527405,
0.3004932701587677,
0.14964179694652557,
-0.15910205245018005,
-0.22609366476535797,
0.5312891602516174,
-0.293382853269577,
0.1982886642217636,
-0.07596653699874878,
-0.39339521527290344,
-0.07910790294408798,
0.7029508352279663,
0.8780834078788757,
0.3192952573299408,
-0.4024790823459625,
0.46293333172798157,
0.2705032229423523,
-0.3310948312282562,
-0.09326667338609695,
0.526149332523346,
-0.7680379152297974,
0.5065773725509644,
0.7413948774337769,
0.40759116411209106,
0.34906530380249023,
-0.5859829783439636,
0.48979660868644714,
0.8105689883232117,
-0.10451097786426544,
0.0372285433113575,
0.1074938029050827,
0.1309082806110382,
0.005543229635804892,
0.15228389203548431,
-0.2880237102508545,
-0.24298380315303802,
0.7269290089607239,
0.40240412950515747,
0.8698042631149292,
0.037102583795785904,
0.4447353184223175,
0.3903069794178009,
0.09119214117527008,
-0.6309822201728821,
-0.2915697693824768,
-0.22464391589164734,
-0.8212639093399048,
-0.1742229461669922,
-0.1805516630411148,
-0.6030822396278381,
0.00603033322840929,
-0.49775785207748413,
0.9437921643257141,
-0.4132261574268341,
-0.30226001143455505,
-0.1463777869939804,
0.4797569811344147,
-0.9767642021179199,
0.2846228778362274,
0.38685324788093567,
0.8767915964126587,
-1.1131302118301392,
0.7073662877082825,
0.8005132675170898,
-0.5553193092346191,
-0.6282916069030762,
0.20681235194206238,
0.564769446849823,
-0.5175350904464722,
0.5937760472297668,
-0.011847599409520626,
-0.14415496587753296,
0.0455404557287693,
-0.8380074501037598,
-0.671740710735321,
1.2580440044403076,
0.11432118713855743,
-0.45329466462135315,
-0.06036800518631935,
-0.24843154847621918,
0.3616551458835602,
-0.5886059999465942,
0.54554283618927,
0.645479142665863,
0.31403928995132446,
0.7423359155654907,
-0.6585308909416199,
-0.37118878960609436,
0.12868262827396393,
-0.07584177702665329,
-0.18906009197235107,
-0.8399659395217896,
0.17303268611431122,
-0.2914294898509979,
-0.060707055032253265,
-0.11913155019283295,
0.5792974829673767,
0.600963830947876,
0.5518243312835693,
0.6156155467033386,
0.5254653096199036,
0.435602068901062,
0.31432339549064636,
0.7845559120178223,
0.10101591795682907,
0.2876472771167755,
1.0501748323440552,
-0.1440972536802292,
0.9297743439674377,
0.327425479888916,
-0.30991819500923157,
0.1112603023648262,
0.6776331663131714,
-0.3677869737148285,
0.9240425825119019,
-0.3118036389350891,
-0.10147181898355484,
-0.23836620151996613,
0.352220743894577,
0.09603848308324814,
1.0201404094696045,
0.16287140548229218,
-0.2150842398405075,
-0.5455731749534607,
0.45240113139152527,
-0.31585896015167236,
-0.326172798871994,
-0.10327214002609253,
1.2700382471084595,
0.1606215238571167,
-0.5666683912277222,
0.2069614678621292,
-0.25050562620162964,
0.9165199995040894,
-0.5284889340400696,
-0.2056736946105957,
-0.07721634954214096,
-0.07246706634759903,
-0.46442100405693054,
-0.5693625807762146,
0.0004675707605201751,
-0.04868098348379135,
0.10480744391679764,
0.07820011675357819,
0.9622106552124023,
-0.1936097890138626,
-0.6200454831123352,
-0.096722811460495,
0.45414164662361145,
-0.2624858617782593,
0.11663863807916641,
-0.5829488039016724,
-0.15973235666751862,
-0.2879020571708679,
-0.06474687904119492,
0.6189165711402893,
0.2263367474079132,
0.06513027846813202,
0.3574985861778259,
0.509817898273468,
0.3263107240200043,
-0.1956215500831604,
-0.26167425513267517,
0.6947137713432312,
-0.4350275993347168,
-0.38020363450050354,
-0.957499086856842,
0.3473345935344696,
-0.06108996644616127,
-0.328800767660141,
0.5808013677597046,
0.48433998227119446,
0.8461519479751587,
0.061982739716768265,
1.09467613697052,
0.16600154340267181,
0.45255225896835327,
-0.6494895219802856,
0.2365759015083313,
-0.38381919264793396,
0.3848685920238495,
-0.5222024321556091,
-0.9729235172271729,
-0.5427423715591431,
0.6939260363578796,
-0.48250526189804077,
0.21374082565307617,
0.7553069591522217,
0.3912588655948639,
-0.12839755415916443,
-0.17043161392211914,
0.207021102309227,
-0.3666015565395355,
0.08987662196159363,
0.4661080241203308,
0.33357924222946167,
-0.4179379940032959,
0.6581119298934937,
-0.692014753818512,
-0.3528057932853699,
-0.5030631422996521,
-0.8853381872177124,
-0.944698691368103,
-0.5262152552604675,
-0.16973327100276947,
0.02965940721333027,
-0.2248150259256363,
1.2369892597198486,
0.8891995549201965,
-0.7750483155250549,
-0.11343880742788315,
0.22387845814228058,
-0.07242054492235184,
-0.5241305828094482,
-0.14666999876499176,
0.13784873485565186,
-0.6627147793769836,
-0.7453752756118774,
0.4068742096424103,
0.2698785364627838,
0.19769611954689026,
0.03320091590285301,
0.10235816985368729,
-0.170643612742424,
-0.18307004868984222,
0.47266581654548645,
0.42302635312080383,
-0.20613151788711548,
0.14126676321029663,
0.15835770964622498,
-0.23644980788230896,
0.2032889574766159,
0.8773488998413086,
-1.2105679512023926,
0.4391244351863861,
0.790202796459198,
0.6247662305831909,
0.7389010787010193,
0.1360023021697998,
0.3375871479511261,
-0.9651703238487244,
0.30089178681373596,
0.449026882648468,
0.3279328942298889,
0.024911558255553246,
-0.14447732269763947,
0.5090738534927368,
0.46922507882118225,
-0.21451233327388763,
-0.48169732093811035,
0.03938603773713112,
-0.871202826499939,
-0.4312267601490021,
1.3554966449737549,
0.22106264531612396,
-0.08025159686803818,
0.26859569549560547,
-0.14869321882724762,
0.22368204593658447,
-0.46763911843299866,
0.8322319984436035,
0.6394962668418884,
-0.5085632801055908,
-0.48322904109954834,
-0.4318488836288452,
0.5161216259002686,
0.18379303812980652,
-0.6478520035743713,
-0.8215115070343018,
0.6870558857917786,
0.08199106901884079,
-0.1769244223833084,
0.486113041639328,
0.22879092395305634,
0.32221493124961853,
-0.27891266345977783,
-0.4619346559047699,
0.04174097999930382,
-0.5324153900146484,
-0.4218676686286926,
0.16528867185115814,
-0.14537672698497772,
-0.5258529186248779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03009v1 | UniMem: Towards a Unified View of Long-Context Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T13:47:53 | 2024-02-05T13:47:53 | Junjie Fang, Likai Tang, Hongzhe Bi, Yujia Qin, Si Sun, Zhenyu Li, Haolun Li, Yongjian Li, Xin Cong, Yukun Yan, Xiaodong Shi, Sen Song, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context processing is a critical ability that constrains the
applicability of large language models. Although there exist various methods
devoted to enhancing the long-context processing ability of large language
models (LLMs), they are developed in an isolated manner and lack systematic
analysis and integration of their strengths, hindering further developments. In
this paper, we introduce UniMem, a unified framework that reformulates existing
long-context methods from the view of memory augmentation of LLMs. UniMem is
characterized by four key dimensions: Memory Management, Memory Writing, Memory
Reading, and Memory Injection, providing a systematic theory for understanding
various long-context methods. We reformulate 16 existing methods based on
UniMem and analyze four representative methods: Transformer-XL, Memorizing
Transformer, RMT, and Longformer into equivalent UniMem forms to reveal their
design principles and strengths. Based on these analyses, we propose UniMix, an
innovative approach that integrates the strengths of these algorithms.
Experimental results show that UniMix achieves superior performance in handling
long contexts with significantly lower perplexity than baselines. | [
-0.5012435913085938,
-0.578665554523468,
0.7486363053321838,
0.3419608175754547,
-0.39644864201545715,
0.10552812367677689,
-0.7366645336151123,
-0.3701136112213135,
-0.034691959619522095,
0.9046107530593872,
-0.31724151968955994,
-0.5139166712760925,
-0.1663838028907776,
-0.07034042477607727,
-0.21658113598823547,
0.694012463092804,
-0.22159935534000397,
-0.06392370909452438,
-0.374444842338562,
-0.4215385317802429,
-0.5405306816101074,
-0.6645246744155884,
-0.12663646042346954,
-0.811348557472229,
0.12509894371032715,
0.35724297165870667,
0.4853459596633911,
0.5237265825271606,
0.27253520488739014,
0.35046935081481934,
-0.27147555351257324,
0.07155296206474304,
-0.11792243272066116,
-0.15793006122112274,
-0.3652620315551758,
-0.4066424071788788,
-0.7836645245552063,
-0.21069040894508362,
0.9846911430358887,
1.145628809928894,
0.011897546239197254,
-0.02339870110154152,
0.4649105370044708,
0.7139483690261841,
-0.6384037137031555,
-0.066135935485363,
-0.3153228461742401,
-0.0656229704618454,
-0.3187272846698761,
-0.22778090834617615,
-0.3417179584503174,
0.28879764676094055,
0.017254315316677094,
-0.34577760100364685,
-0.08505845814943314,
-0.18672791123390198,
-0.029379315674304962,
0.06919202208518982,
-0.6523023247718811,
0.08735408633947372,
-1.071244716644287,
1.1025505065917969,
-0.8735129833221436,
0.2723383903503418,
-0.07675141841173172,
0.1564650684595108,
-0.4640829861164093,
-0.5737255811691284,
-0.326105535030365,
0.16051611304283142,
0.013271808624267578,
-0.05634845420718193,
-0.30325838923454285,
0.31442463397979736,
0.09114772081375122,
0.41071388125419617,
-0.2728431522846222,
0.37567830085754395,
-0.2474684864282608,
-0.0753917247056961,
0.45793211460113525,
0.2035374939441681,
0.08604320883750916,
0.04378770664334297,
-0.8326323628425598,
0.3057391047477722,
-0.7418605089187622,
0.09867777675390244,
0.01805717870593071,
0.09661228209733963,
0.18731921911239624,
0.350791335105896,
-0.2734183371067047,
0.5572008490562439,
-0.3323362469673157,
-0.07319028675556183,
0.12013278156518936,
-0.1719420701265335,
-0.38055747747421265,
-0.13938719034194946,
0.7970709800720215,
0.3054650127887726,
0.1490621566772461,
-0.42144763469696045,
-0.4102976620197296,
-0.2043941169977188,
0.06085315719246864,
-0.851094663143158,
0.07222344726324081,
0.17450955510139465,
-0.2808105945587158,
0.09548252820968628,
0.09046352654695511,
-0.9490633010864258,
-0.04139084368944168,
-0.5928927063941956,
0.3095216155052185,
-0.5496217608451843,
-0.11250390112400055,
0.3554302453994751,
0.1716114580631256,
0.014294655062258244,
0.2855352461338043,
-0.5102426409721375,
0.5124496221542358,
0.7259950041770935,
0.4513525664806366,
-0.5326654314994812,
-0.4564994275569916,
-0.30853164196014404,
0.3800611197948456,
-0.1406470090150833,
0.9305909276008606,
-0.6900840401649475,
-0.36973807215690613,
-0.003949744626879692,
0.052509553730487823,
0.1503189355134964,
-0.5786191821098328,
0.48411795496940613,
-0.5367627143859863,
0.370509535074234,
-0.04866468533873558,
-0.7104128003120422,
-0.5120928287506104,
-0.09075547754764557,
-0.5521107912063599,
0.892777144908905,
0.1489369124174118,
-0.49742695689201355,
0.1460908204317093,
-1.172650933265686,
-0.3823345899581909,
0.12622007727622986,
-0.06122779846191406,
-0.064967080950737,
0.5807517170906067,
0.41452065110206604,
0.5186018347740173,
-0.533962070941925,
0.49791595339775085,
-0.11186344176530838,
-0.5232843160629272,
0.453088641166687,
-0.689028263092041,
0.7349084615707397,
0.19153326749801636,
-0.29097384214401245,
0.1787962019443512,
-0.7365086078643799,
0.29630210995674133,
-0.08700795471668243,
-0.5971347093582153,
-0.4689778685569763,
-0.12943579256534576,
0.23502305150032043,
-0.026279393583536148,
0.33507221937179565,
-0.5300100445747375,
0.24869771301746368,
-0.1661141812801361,
0.5491204857826233,
0.6182456612586975,
-0.23873409628868103,
0.82232266664505,
0.01680372655391693,
0.24281533062458038,
0.22081851959228516,
0.16729861497879028,
-0.6195902228355408,
0.17680704593658447,
-0.7434519529342651,
-0.33902207016944885,
0.19557200372219086,
0.433224081993103,
-0.23677107691764832,
0.5092431306838989,
-0.3426077365875244,
0.18609684705734253,
-0.12649093568325043,
0.7060734629631042,
0.5306531190872192,
0.15501531958580017,
0.5026240944862366,
-0.5677462816238403,
-0.5873352885246277,
-0.8138413429260254,
-0.3158232867717743,
0.12313677370548248,
-0.28393757343292236,
0.07320763915777206,
0.32986411452293396,
-0.7649174332618713,
1.043015480041504,
-0.2433994859457016,
-0.22821785509586334,
-0.33744117617607117,
0.2060278207063675,
0.2592921555042267,
0.4233822226524353,
0.2669961154460907,
-0.5472407937049866,
-0.10112392157316208,
-0.14075128734111786,
-0.801857590675354,
-0.17514483630657196,
-0.028822684660553932,
0.2125522792339325,
0.4142235219478607,
0.7103955149650574,
-0.42132219672203064,
0.4134066104888916,
0.2925074100494385,
-0.24272610247135162,
0.32046422362327576,
-0.4932399094104767,
-0.04474368691444397,
-1.2409734725952148,
0.1090705469250679,
-0.0888330489397049,
-0.2665848135948181,
-0.6144883036613464,
0.2604493498802185,
0.31566449999809265,
-0.01682664081454277,
-0.4523318111896515,
0.5931072235107422,
-0.8849966526031494,
-0.031399205327034,
-0.6505457162857056,
-0.01833276078104973,
0.15665777027606964,
0.46251043677330017,
-0.07350520044565201,
0.6692597270011902,
0.44521117210388184,
-0.526496946811676,
0.49995458126068115,
-0.23346367478370667,
-0.26515325903892517,
0.7128881812095642,
-0.5521464347839355,
0.25582703948020935,
-0.30883845686912537,
0.299170583486557,
-0.9257739782333374,
-0.012335984036326408,
-0.47705501317977905,
-0.10842204838991165,
0.5542213916778564,
-0.027892954647541046,
-0.5374451875686646,
-0.4278525710105896,
-0.3105258345603943,
0.6906949877738953,
0.39309796690940857,
-0.7805633544921875,
0.7178018093109131,
0.3650418817996979,
0.02828359790146351,
-0.48113763332366943,
-0.4317319095134735,
0.33909299969673157,
-0.6036137342453003,
-0.6170675158500671,
0.5255609750747681,
-0.25373533368110657,
-0.40357881784439087,
-0.18966536223888397,
-0.03764902427792549,
-0.08134405314922333,
0.03864393010735512,
0.28661394119262695,
0.1444479376077652,
-0.3449089229106903,
0.09777623414993286,
-0.16110265254974365,
-0.48206907510757446,
0.030747007578611374,
-0.46843597292900085,
0.6002817749977112,
-0.28954246640205383,
-0.218967467546463,
-0.46992895007133484,
0.7228754162788391,
0.7157318592071533,
-0.24782763421535492,
0.28863146901130676,
0.5500501990318298,
-0.3504025340080261,
-0.26127293705940247,
-0.803728461265564,
-0.11962133646011353,
-0.471454918384552,
0.33733931183815,
-0.273291677236557,
-1.1732203960418701,
0.6076631546020508,
-0.7311453819274902,
0.2149762064218521,
0.19177022576332092,
0.34656763076782227,
-0.037653643637895584,
0.946565568447113,
1.0407036542892456,
-0.5292861461639404,
0.2821989357471466,
-0.06081599369645119,
-0.017358554527163506,
-1.3758167028427124,
-0.2577572166919708,
-0.14295177161693573,
-0.3256378471851349,
-0.11890505254268646,
-0.6697505116462708,
0.23626190423965454,
0.4841614365577698,
-0.31157973408699036,
0.3444575369358063,
-0.13921420276165009,
0.7865920066833496,
0.33679068088531494,
-0.3907400369644165,
0.5648509860038757,
0.17653197050094604,
-0.48512816429138184,
-0.047407642006874084,
-0.4672955572605133,
-0.5985041260719299,
1.0665966272354126,
0.3940422832965851,
1.0227755308151245,
0.056680288165807724,
0.4184744358062744,
-0.08846380561590195,
0.305260568857193,
-0.6291812658309937,
0.6311728954315186,
-0.16973450779914856,
-0.48997020721435547,
-0.4135689437389374,
-0.3044683635234833,
-1.0145260095596313,
0.2504190504550934,
0.08472692966461182,
-1.105172872543335,
-0.0862017571926117,
-0.24490705132484436,
-0.5277653336524963,
0.5772929191589355,
-0.4331985116004944,
0.5878880620002747,
-0.38717004656791687,
-0.3111979365348816,
-0.1700815111398697,
-0.44336211681365967,
0.3220468759536743,
-0.20947985351085663,
0.24241292476654053,
-0.011722113005816936,
-0.09064926207065582,
0.6752738356590271,
-0.19305875897407532,
0.8665483593940735,
0.17923137545585632,
-0.24246108531951904,
0.3098197877407074,
0.10382045060396194,
0.19905804097652435,
0.3700946271419525,
0.07226696610450745,
0.35079461336135864,
0.07563412189483643,
-0.2939354479312897,
-0.5840916037559509,
0.9103137850761414,
-0.5763009190559387,
-0.5776844620704651,
-0.20388692617416382,
-0.9691556096076965,
-0.2899055778980255,
0.3723125457763672,
0.10483888536691666,
0.5389422178268433,
-0.5243638753890991,
0.3882262408733368,
0.6688203811645508,
-0.14499254524707794,
0.8795206546783447,
0.8756960034370422,
-0.5051230788230896,
-0.4652896225452423,
0.34479033946990967,
-0.09296345710754395,
0.0554303303360939,
0.5407701730728149,
0.1320970058441162,
-0.4469216763973236,
-0.49463579058647156,
-0.24053530395030975,
0.17909455299377441,
-0.5105457901954651,
-0.11045803874731064,
-0.395008385181427,
-0.12510907649993896,
-0.3716990351676941,
-0.029738763347268105,
-0.5842819809913635,
-0.11714111268520355,
-0.16164176166057587,
0.24152399599552155,
0.23372381925582886,
0.5310240983963013,
-0.27122926712036133,
0.5969967246055603,
-0.8146987557411194,
0.1652020812034607,
0.3409882187843323,
0.5612961053848267,
-0.14185185730457306,
-0.47583839297294617,
-0.12238730490207672,
0.06689802557229996,
-0.4133092761039734,
-0.3933872878551483,
0.3344113826751709,
0.018747199326753616,
0.4855685532093048,
0.7094570398330688,
-0.10803543031215668,
0.8809924721717834,
-0.5623464584350586,
0.35309988260269165,
0.3118033707141876,
-0.9818934202194214,
0.2129582315683365,
-0.18730489909648895,
0.556305468082428,
0.47349750995635986,
0.001012813183479011,
-0.6494836211204529,
0.051859572529792786,
-0.4557027518749237,
-0.9089055061340332,
0.3530654311180115,
0.012436500750482082,
0.3344418704509735,
0.2027430683374405,
0.5028547644615173,
0.06685955822467804,
0.030182041227817535,
-0.5196759104728699,
-0.09807096421718597,
0.2763233184814453,
0.12572607398033142,
-0.46119940280914307,
-0.5018811225891113,
-0.19953203201293945,
-0.4028201103210449,
0.1482585072517395,
-0.2327808141708374,
0.2368459701538086,
-0.06839966773986816,
-0.23482611775398254,
-0.19124826788902283,
0.7293376326560974,
0.3496078550815582,
1.030728816986084,
-0.22525353729724884,
0.4244024157524109,
0.40484461188316345,
-0.15115986764431,
-0.045298442244529724,
0.030002368614077568,
-0.01691662333905697,
-0.18187345564365387,
0.291296124458313,
0.4971216917037964,
0.6311338543891907,
-0.6237519979476929,
0.3204942047595978,
-0.08475899696350098,
0.08368219435214996,
-0.5545759797096252,
0.0664604976773262,
0.2240872085094452,
0.37357887625694275,
0.46967583894729614,
-0.34640762209892273,
0.0020177143160253763,
-0.8910185694694519,
0.33398497104644775,
0.6495522260665894,
-0.46327438950538635,
-0.5507320165634155,
0.48328495025634766,
0.034464236348867416,
-0.26622623205184937,
0.6329270601272583,
0.10125862061977386,
-0.45942893624305725,
0.24408909678459167,
0.9979027509689331,
0.7335274815559387,
-0.51130211353302,
-0.031005293130874634,
0.004438112489879131,
0.12606020271778107,
-0.11326625198125839,
0.18366317451000214,
-0.18426840007305145,
-0.5988554358482361,
-0.7357437610626221,
-0.6683177947998047,
-0.03746563196182251,
0.5907568335533142,
-0.6905109286308289,
-0.09309834241867065,
-0.23969487845897675,
-0.018577758222818375,
-0.09253775328397751,
0.2725616991519928,
-0.5830878019332886,
0.03406117856502533,
-0.0434245690703392,
0.8519220948219299,
-0.4484536945819855,
0.9115728735923767,
0.8558277487754822,
0.13123241066932678,
-0.36635351181030273,
-0.03804134950041771,
0.1751248985528946,
-0.6745725870132446,
0.2641427218914032,
0.3392826318740845,
-0.012957576662302017,
-0.12185793370008469,
-0.42676249146461487,
-0.7717618346214294,
1.1161774396896362,
0.267405241727829,
-0.5553451776504517,
0.08848520368337631,
0.44752535223960876,
0.4389267563819885,
-0.614447832107544,
0.07920591533184052,
0.7887738347053528,
0.452115535736084,
-0.03463234007358551,
-0.7635208964347839,
0.14015652239322662,
-0.10958021134138107,
0.2525045573711395,
0.6116944551467896,
-0.49121204018592834,
0.7078620791435242,
-0.45094528794288635,
-0.35117316246032715,
0.36245113611221313,
0.8656170964241028,
-0.030401861295104027,
0.3170328736305237,
0.32939431071281433,
0.7107135653495789,
0.5067931413650513,
0.22583481669425964,
0.670265793800354,
-0.32110151648521423,
0.23735573887825012,
1.0256776809692383,
-0.20260639488697052,
0.7179536819458008,
0.6623362898826599,
-0.19995808601379395,
0.35347074270248413,
0.017034558579325676,
0.35088786482810974,
0.10576685518026352,
0.18785861134529114,
-0.4669247567653656,
-0.4634890556335449,
0.02096431888639927,
-0.10876653343439102,
0.6411297917366028,
0.36426204442977905,
-0.14373041689395905,
-0.6317929625511169,
0.023765549063682556,
0.3106114864349365,
0.16028304398059845,
-0.3659549355506897,
0.7578645348548889,
0.4051226079463959,
-0.6033475995063782,
0.4430287182331085,
0.3819226920604706,
0.8171809911727905,
-0.21146883070468903,
0.12909018993377686,
-0.37070372700691223,
0.6146052479743958,
0.0714750587940216,
-0.965967059135437,
0.27475154399871826,
-0.05209408327937126,
-0.19242431223392487,
-0.036061301827430725,
0.5961765646934509,
-0.4176028072834015,
-0.5156960487365723,
0.6054167747497559,
0.6166535019874573,
0.065321184694767,
-0.4409750699996948,
-0.4701092839241028,
-0.02449222095310688,
-0.18084365129470825,
-0.11035895347595215,
0.6623749732971191,
0.6815336346626282,
-0.29998454451560974,
0.5378387570381165,
0.7364583015441895,
-0.16272078454494476,
-0.3149053156375885,
0.06071627885103226,
0.8318830132484436,
-0.9935958385467529,
-0.14305029809474945,
-1.0438458919525146,
0.42010366916656494,
-0.008034801110625267,
-0.22908514738082886,
0.7200170755386353,
0.6388733386993408,
0.6939589977264404,
0.27557891607284546,
0.46362847089767456,
0.48888638615608215,
0.36303776502609253,
-0.4439152181148529,
0.5993994474411011,
-0.5344900488853455,
0.4769199788570404,
-0.1053222194314003,
-1.2925972938537598,
-0.46707668900489807,
0.2519761025905609,
-0.08618395030498505,
-0.04586578533053398,
0.6773988008499146,
0.5140659809112549,
-0.3739009201526642,
-0.09281796962022781,
0.4725877642631531,
0.12481677532196045,
0.3138667345046997,
0.9230867624282837,
0.6449764370918274,
-0.17738954722881317,
0.29822632670402527,
-0.3672337830066681,
-0.40946391224861145,
-0.08715534955263138,
-1.0568548440933228,
-1.1210201978683472,
-0.5828511714935303,
0.04909843951463699,
0.04679259657859802,
-0.223781555891037,
0.6622488498687744,
0.6274023652076721,
-0.49813392758369446,
-0.4722326397895813,
0.11959987878799438,
0.014141648076474667,
0.007111504208296537,
-0.17010819911956787,
0.37054315209388733,
-0.26609623432159424,
-0.6584933996200562,
0.6115902066230774,
0.7756764888763428,
-0.07244937121868134,
-0.40036246180534363,
-0.09044882655143738,
0.35598790645599365,
0.29622092843055725,
0.8861952424049377,
0.4816228151321411,
-0.5436645746231079,
-0.11999712139368057,
-0.08326572924852371,
0.19547757506370544,
0.24868541955947876,
1.0413798093795776,
-0.788668155670166,
0.39546486735343933,
0.2949385344982147,
0.4132704734802246,
0.23335187137126923,
-0.011931754648685455,
0.5886394381523132,
-0.5199674963951111,
0.21003662049770355,
0.08690785616636276,
0.6754172444343567,
0.2697426378726959,
-0.10329041630029678,
0.259920597076416,
-0.003045442048460245,
-0.5168951153755188,
-0.7970441579818726,
0.32978832721710205,
-1.046385645866394,
-0.5996148586273193,
1.3229143619537354,
-0.026994533836841583,
-0.3935811519622803,
-0.13331174850463867,
0.03349164128303528,
0.09543705731630325,
-0.23175252974033356,
0.848526656627655,
0.4329439401626587,
-0.04702058807015419,
-0.08689897507429123,
-0.4896116256713867,
0.0641438439488411,
0.378983736038208,
-0.777418851852417,
0.2830051779747009,
0.45047080516815186,
0.5778622031211853,
0.21966876089572906,
0.5235007405281067,
-0.5804707407951355,
0.008632251992821693,
-0.6535353660583496,
0.12872594594955444,
-0.2070751041173935,
-0.6339618563652039,
-0.5305332541465759,
0.07674507051706314,
-0.0976991131901741,
0.26525235176086426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02992v2 | Decoding-time Realignment of Language Models | 2024-02-05T13:31:28 | 2024-05-24T08:39:07 | Tianlin Liu, Shangmin Guo, Leonardo Bianco, Daniele Calandriello, Quentin Berthet, Felipe Llinares, Jessica Hoffmann, Lucas Dixon, Michal Valko, Mathieu Blondel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Aligning language models with human preferences is crucial for reducing
errors and biases in these models. Alignment techniques, such as reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF), are typically cast as optimizing a
tradeoff between human preference rewards and a proximity regularization term
that encourages staying close to the unaligned model. Selecting an appropriate
level of regularization is critical: insufficient regularization can lead to
reduced model capabilities due to reward hacking, whereas excessive
regularization hinders alignment. Traditional methods for finding the optimal
regularization level require retraining multiple models with varying
regularization strengths. This process, however, is resource-intensive,
especially for large models. To address this challenge, we propose
decoding-time realignment (DeRa), a simple method to explore and evaluate
different regularization strengths in aligned models without retraining. DeRa
enables control over the degree of alignment, allowing users to smoothly
transition between unaligned and aligned models. It also enhances the
efficiency of hyperparameter tuning by enabling the identification of effective
regularization strengths using a validation dataset. | [
-0.2408508062362671,
-0.6125558614730835,
0.44776347279548645,
0.20414787530899048,
-0.2362360805273056,
0.4212002456188202,
-0.38539132475852966,
-0.41693681478500366,
0.1383868008852005,
0.2026214450597763,
-0.7832400798797607,
-0.27387624979019165,
-0.41216742992401123,
0.07564443349838257,
-0.10276435315608978,
0.9154413938522339,
-0.19214515388011932,
-0.07328556478023529,
-0.01687934249639511,
-0.2179490476846695,
-0.6404016017913818,
-0.5400575995445251,
-0.5098091959953308,
-0.34520792961120605,
0.6421830058097839,
0.3565816879272461,
1.0363469123840332,
1.2353928089141846,
0.4505954384803772,
0.2601095139980316,
-0.04382764548063278,
0.07720325887203217,
-0.49710819125175476,
0.06791254878044128,
-0.1423567235469818,
-0.4188603460788727,
-0.518952488899231,
-0.01586299203336239,
0.8013195395469666,
0.7823779582977295,
-0.4422968924045563,
0.35796743631362915,
-0.12814122438430786,
0.8110635876655579,
-0.783096194267273,
0.006122330203652382,
-0.45677149295806885,
0.2390335351228714,
-0.0868261456489563,
-0.1705140918493271,
-0.35573652386665344,
-0.5468604564666748,
0.09876986593008041,
-0.6750086545944214,
0.20264272391796112,
0.13691207766532898,
1.5385286808013916,
0.5616692304611206,
-0.22556985914707184,
0.49846306443214417,
-1.088698148727417,
1.2045421600341797,
-0.8732107281684875,
0.6949833631515503,
0.29854875802993774,
0.540230393409729,
-0.010718376375734806,
-0.13943509757518768,
-0.581219494342804,
0.1524207442998886,
-0.1387801319360733,
-0.11360900849103928,
0.04833068326115608,
0.15768638253211975,
0.2684994339942932,
0.10935483127832413,
-0.5941681861877441,
0.2865757346153259,
-0.12444747984409332,
-0.23604467511177063,
0.5082231163978577,
0.23209241032600403,
0.38183486461639404,
0.20287324488162994,
-0.14201708137989044,
-0.38162457942962646,
-0.4200516939163208,
0.11140413582324982,
0.6494709253311157,
0.49796342849731445,
-0.09927845746278763,
0.3643066883087158,
-0.20851179957389832,
1.0798956155776978,
0.37170156836509705,
-0.37979257106781006,
0.23783570528030396,
-0.37517648935317993,
-0.2026507556438446,
0.25020238757133484,
0.5378537774085999,
0.4147481322288513,
0.2437445968389511,
-0.2189851552248001,
-0.40973374247550964,
0.0798933133482933,
0.4600425362586975,
-0.6701136231422424,
0.1765882521867752,
0.17215068638324738,
-0.6708952784538269,
-0.5736598968505859,
-0.10089774429798126,
-0.9003370404243469,
0.049209024757146835,
-0.4818466603755951,
0.11326157301664352,
0.10286257416009903,
-0.34493282437324524,
0.20859019458293915,
0.11091741174459457,
0.28469085693359375,
-0.05543231591582298,
-1.3541918992996216,
0.27584102749824524,
0.731952428817749,
0.7153871655464172,
0.09136392921209335,
-0.37008628249168396,
-0.5482364296913147,
0.1649884283542633,
-0.4362075924873352,
0.4718078374862671,
-0.7560492753982544,
0.007184240501374006,
-0.09076228737831116,
0.034611187875270844,
-0.1923789381980896,
-0.42660197615623474,
0.4827994704246521,
-0.8417780995368958,
0.2649592161178589,
-0.1667865514755249,
-0.3402295708656311,
-0.09449557214975357,
0.27458345890045166,
-0.6826275587081909,
0.7968615889549255,
0.4051536023616791,
-0.5761444568634033,
0.46214747428894043,
-0.35624000430107117,
-0.13579176366329193,
-0.41493093967437744,
-0.039560478180646896,
-0.7990896105766296,
-0.007608239538967609,
0.43958115577697754,
0.0728958249092102,
0.012527665123343468,
0.42574572563171387,
-0.1547739952802658,
-0.4309787452220917,
0.18287073075771332,
-0.3164718747138977,
0.40898919105529785,
0.4440736770629883,
-0.3599381148815155,
0.3957558572292328,
-0.7672504782676697,
0.028348611667752266,
0.2001240849494934,
-0.5087664127349854,
-0.358058363199234,
0.09992921352386475,
-0.10601650923490524,
0.2355043739080429,
0.3234226107597351,
-0.5595922470092773,
0.4273761212825775,
-0.8398924469947815,
0.3559931218624115,
0.9292392730712891,
-0.11961846798658371,
0.6071359515190125,
-0.33099135756492615,
0.8276975750923157,
-0.006398205645382404,
0.3080275058746338,
0.4271303117275238,
-0.15629951655864716,
-0.6372872591018677,
-0.1848745197057724,
0.803436815738678,
0.5552906394004822,
-0.20561477541923523,
0.6693000197410583,
-0.5058767795562744,
-0.15838609635829926,
-1.109018325805664,
0.048452749848365784,
0.6470534205436707,
0.5110535621643066,
0.39062264561653137,
-0.23207378387451172,
-0.49266451597213745,
-0.9944165945053101,
-0.19469912350177765,
0.12022291123867035,
0.05143992230296135,
0.17972314357757568,
-0.10718583315610886,
-0.28315919637680054,
1.000815749168396,
-0.48514777421951294,
-0.20026803016662598,
-0.17571121454238892,
0.08164648711681366,
0.08759116381406784,
0.420242577791214,
0.4214393198490143,
-0.6556359529495239,
-0.37361907958984375,
0.010890834033489227,
-0.42131030559539795,
-0.12149021774530411,
-0.36614444851875305,
-0.21445010602474213,
0.29300493001937866,
0.2674398124217987,
-0.05023539066314697,
0.23955607414245605,
0.8383873105049133,
-0.4112926423549652,
0.40820199251174927,
-0.15374617278575897,
0.2952723801136017,
-0.8656477928161621,
0.11767884343862534,
-0.18538953363895416,
-0.31629809737205505,
-0.5739189982414246,
-0.11130852997303009,
0.18752016127109528,
-0.1485908180475235,
-0.1956830471754074,
0.7396565675735474,
-0.5141720175743103,
-0.27955523133277893,
-0.1281464397907257,
0.19681617617607117,
0.07152711600065231,
0.690295934677124,
0.14765019714832306,
0.7468863725662231,
0.07948573678731918,
-0.5325959920883179,
0.2633383870124817,
0.24337968230247498,
-0.1859900951385498,
0.2276235818862915,
-0.46368318796157837,
0.164450541138649,
-0.1618410050868988,
0.11472364515066147,
-0.7585428953170776,
-0.15271064639091492,
0.2222890406847,
-0.317899614572525,
0.35290905833244324,
-0.3264198899269104,
-0.1383827179670334,
-0.0018157390877604485,
-0.16603554785251617,
1.0170350074768066,
0.3957561254501343,
-0.7303421497344971,
0.5851374864578247,
0.337461918592453,
0.043290507048368454,
-1.1091866493225098,
-0.3194763660430908,
-0.05998896062374115,
-0.23806677758693695,
-0.5237784385681152,
0.43977785110473633,
0.11688713729381561,
-0.325175017118454,
-0.04347384721040726,
-0.11749975383281708,
0.10007917881011963,
0.2159499078989029,
0.1513378918170929,
0.4411698877811432,
-0.08760566264390945,
-0.1856023073196411,
0.1153288334608078,
-0.4001314640045166,
-0.32902246713638306,
-0.18893353641033173,
0.5334900617599487,
0.06714747101068497,
-0.3548603653907776,
-0.7516543865203857,
0.07904080301523209,
0.4802820086479187,
-0.5484192967414856,
0.7762553691864014,
0.591204047203064,
-0.34703630208969116,
0.09211759269237518,
-0.5278518795967102,
-0.4463677704334259,
-0.4188164174556732,
0.2165837287902832,
-0.3377235233783722,
-0.7307265996932983,
0.5564631223678589,
0.2608794569969177,
0.25790202617645264,
0.12010452896356583,
0.437038779258728,
0.21439658105373383,
1.6603647470474243,
0.6938532590866089,
-0.26401299238204956,
0.6988005042076111,
0.011096757836639881,
0.5245143175125122,
-0.717679500579834,
-0.18804076313972473,
-0.6189663410186768,
-0.7454354166984558,
-0.2971368432044983,
-0.040947798639535904,
0.015278371050953865,
0.03863878548145294,
-0.14462728798389435,
0.3171290457248688,
-0.6169776916503906,
0.6380425691604614,
0.41437289118766785,
0.002172473119571805,
0.19584250450134277,
0.09502213448286057,
-0.015683120116591454,
-0.3320498764514923,
-0.6513392925262451,
-0.4780944883823395,
0.934548020362854,
0.5931342840194702,
0.8472037315368652,
0.1900579333305359,
0.7497636675834656,
0.0063338144682347775,
0.05051217973232269,
-0.8547804951667786,
0.2866871953010559,
0.011070480570197105,
-0.3434734344482422,
-0.6236345171928406,
-0.5652981400489807,
-0.9793612360954285,
0.1828395575284958,
-0.31528910994529724,
-0.43245866894721985,
0.47178757190704346,
0.27887025475502014,
-0.8660879731178284,
0.3873589038848877,
-0.6125908493995667,
1.0353835821151733,
-0.17967478930950165,
-0.1923574060201645,
-0.32843008637428284,
-0.7957731485366821,
0.21997545659542084,
0.11638890206813812,
0.2936430275440216,
-0.21703611314296722,
0.12315356731414795,
0.9171164035797119,
-0.2634994685649872,
0.6916380524635315,
-0.17354488372802734,
-0.37756210565567017,
-0.3078344464302063,
0.38510027527809143,
0.5258686542510986,
-0.20972692966461182,
0.08615623414516449,
-0.12931199371814728,
0.2410575896501541,
-0.5574692487716675,
-0.8315969109535217,
0.6875649690628052,
-0.9248207807540894,
-0.44492799043655396,
-0.33813729882240295,
-0.6925902366638184,
-0.32192525267601013,
0.12845106422901154,
-0.1937226951122284,
0.46232783794403076,
-0.16257773339748383,
-0.2745896279811859,
0.6813040375709534,
0.007603618782013655,
0.20530486106872559,
0.46096542477607727,
-0.24269452691078186,
-0.18810558319091797,
1.237667202949524,
-0.06536503881216049,
0.45940664410591125,
0.6431235074996948,
0.12325336039066315,
-0.32628166675567627,
-0.4318515956401825,
-0.5599654912948608,
0.40124398469924927,
-0.2879610061645508,
-0.09725120663642883,
-0.3742322325706482,
-0.10166103392839432,
-0.41567933559417725,
-0.40049463510513306,
-0.5684912204742432,
-0.5858110785484314,
-0.3411768078804016,
-0.08583708852529526,
-0.13289643824100494,
0.41695746779441833,
-0.0743483304977417,
0.2784520387649536,
-0.9898175001144409,
0.31582584977149963,
0.44309401512145996,
0.5798309445381165,
-0.06889136135578156,
-0.6600287556648254,
-0.45081955194473267,
0.001215102500282228,
0.06379808485507965,
-0.6767138242721558,
0.4827021658420563,
-0.12422637641429901,
0.35587331652641296,
0.6243770718574524,
-0.17619813978672028,
0.7377439737319946,
-0.287321537733078,
0.581145167350769,
-0.003745777066797018,
-0.7288729548454285,
0.2964388430118561,
-0.1639242321252823,
0.27775806188583374,
0.5227457880973816,
0.14327655732631683,
-0.8312989473342896,
-0.2072625458240509,
-0.5636510252952576,
-0.611332356929779,
0.8155691027641296,
-0.1878868043422699,
-0.04204903170466423,
0.22450344264507294,
0.4811909794807434,
-0.17216576635837555,
-0.07103287428617477,
-0.3948523700237274,
-0.15100476145744324,
-0.2425883561372757,
-0.4216657876968384,
0.10400918126106262,
-0.43346527218818665,
-0.5147687196731567,
-0.0661313459277153,
0.7223163843154907,
-0.17998740077018738,
0.07102949917316437,
-0.10481695085763931,
-0.1193271204829216,
-0.6057406067848206,
0.41787153482437134,
0.8656193017959595,
0.9691605567932129,
-0.5947964191436768,
0.07351978123188019,
0.014344035647809505,
-0.12561769783496857,
0.4720662236213684,
-0.10987317562103271,
-0.19317908585071564,
-0.22981679439544678,
0.27507585287094116,
0.8899221420288086,
0.269849956035614,
-0.6798104643821716,
0.45579323172569275,
-0.3384844958782196,
-0.12141553312540054,
0.320278137922287,
0.1467941403388977,
-0.260049045085907,
0.13628172874450684,
-0.11440669000148773,
-0.09049540758132935,
-0.27123361825942993,
-0.24446433782577515,
0.04304566606879234,
0.4167582392692566,
-0.4849259853363037,
-0.4044061005115509,
0.7363434433937073,
0.19554728269577026,
-0.29018712043762207,
0.7601617574691772,
-0.05702367052435875,
-0.41357824206352234,
0.6047421097755432,
0.5455527305603027,
0.9002149105072021,
-0.37831559777259827,
0.07400210946798325,
0.67934650182724,
0.179473415017128,
-0.2407854199409485,
0.0044333371333777905,
0.06568042933940887,
-1.0037909746170044,
-0.5077072978019714,
-0.7350558042526245,
-0.13017484545707703,
0.0028857863508164883,
-0.8267024755477905,
0.06470826268196106,
-0.59839928150177,
-0.3470870554447174,
-0.20860356092453003,
-0.12055252492427826,
-0.2909598648548126,
0.12306685000658035,
-0.054344017058610916,
0.6694541573524475,
-0.9420015811920166,
0.7398786544799805,
0.453871488571167,
-0.40459808707237244,
-0.8998373746871948,
0.10878274589776993,
0.11403033882379532,
-0.6631354093551636,
0.6320686340332031,
-0.24530333280563354,
-0.21149387955665588,
0.22012315690517426,
-0.4352848529815674,
-0.8135408163070679,
0.9888626337051392,
0.437318354845047,
-0.9258589148521423,
-0.39435920119285583,
-0.24152471125125885,
0.5034090876579285,
-0.3423827588558197,
-0.0485774502158165,
0.8757513761520386,
0.5976266264915466,
-0.3665426969528198,
-1.015903115272522,
0.16958850622177124,
0.16902804374694824,
0.16068463027477264,
0.4540560245513916,
-0.7656674385070801,
0.39860546588897705,
-0.3271902799606323,
-0.4934659004211426,
-0.15265540778636932,
0.7668253183364868,
0.11098650842905045,
-0.3038604259490967,
0.6967092752456665,
0.8747187852859497,
0.48187458515167236,
-0.046359799802303314,
0.7346727252006531,
-0.3883204758167267,
0.42245978116989136,
1.002942681312561,
-0.015966080129146576,
0.6228799819946289,
0.616008996963501,
-0.17854629456996918,
0.40670230984687805,
0.7052176594734192,
0.1015450656414032,
0.5684475898742676,
0.1166834756731987,
-0.1244102418422699,
-0.5680039525032043,
-0.1522367000579834,
-0.3149334788322449,
0.19650568068027496,
0.02712649293243885,
-0.024250440299510956,
-0.3351784348487854,
-0.1585259735584259,
0.041846394538879395,
0.413004994392395,
0.07917953282594681,
0.8625499606132507,
-0.345010906457901,
-0.8125061988830566,
0.963712751865387,
0.36508581042289734,
0.5415434241294861,
-0.5651305913925171,
-0.1515875607728958,
-0.38875722885131836,
0.19447539746761322,
-0.30709129571914673,
-0.5631001591682434,
0.2582302987575531,
-0.2842511534690857,
-0.5093845725059509,
-0.26463648676872253,
0.22753725945949554,
-0.7079265117645264,
-0.1829347461462021,
0.30696964263916016,
0.09203541278839111,
-0.1493239402770996,
0.31922590732574463,
-0.7699012756347656,
0.2798804044723511,
0.1822943091392517,
-0.1666562706232071,
0.5223115682601929,
-0.13143987953662872,
-0.22620640695095062,
0.7829740643501282,
0.6695103645324707,
0.2350260615348816,
-0.042343273758888245,
0.39506763219833374,
0.6653872728347778,
-0.7309916615486145,
-0.4638373851776123,
-0.8196220397949219,
0.06421759724617004,
0.2596017122268677,
-0.03118046373128891,
0.5093159675598145,
0.45897066593170166,
0.9051326513290405,
0.017874184995889664,
0.4513028860092163,
0.27027520537376404,
0.5473427772521973,
-0.5278499126434326,
0.5464498400688171,
-0.5733147859573364,
0.19495858252048492,
0.044906530529260635,
-0.8955828547477722,
-0.44667091965675354,
0.5402057766914368,
-0.2660837173461914,
-0.17529705166816711,
0.43077385425567627,
1.134611964225769,
-0.23480570316314697,
-0.5334162712097168,
0.23154987394809723,
-0.13376671075820923,
0.4925476908683777,
0.5088565945625305,
0.5895897746086121,
-0.1216910183429718,
0.4233936071395874,
-0.3134671747684479,
-0.3740178346633911,
-0.30866867303848267,
-0.749267041683197,
-0.6052330732345581,
-0.5261133909225464,
-0.2532535791397095,
-0.4952163100242615,
0.08026285469532013,
1.146363377571106,
0.891962468624115,
-0.9383333921432495,
-0.2566690444946289,
0.3786104619503021,
0.4283648729324341,
-0.6721813678741455,
-0.2696591317653656,
0.45932072401046753,
-0.5595983266830444,
-0.968405544757843,
0.5077654123306274,
0.24447055160999298,
0.13578084111213684,
-0.3703996241092682,
-0.30347582697868347,
-0.41052576899528503,
0.11828238517045975,
0.061060693114995956,
0.6656163334846497,
-0.6183685660362244,
-0.4182821214199066,
-0.09173019975423813,
-0.2792205512523651,
0.09608623385429382,
0.8400658369064331,
-0.6570168733596802,
0.6456524133682251,
0.6766417622566223,
0.862575113773346,
0.10498151183128357,
0.5069090127944946,
0.8686339855194092,
-0.9153779149055481,
0.28995051980018616,
0.01013462245464325,
0.1114267036318779,
0.15376725792884827,
-0.38994288444519043,
0.3363436162471771,
0.18658100068569183,
-0.6287436485290527,
-1.0640610456466675,
0.32515114545822144,
-0.7192740440368652,
-0.15686139464378357,
0.9276136755943298,
0.16774000227451324,
-0.40950798988342285,
-0.10566601902246475,
-0.281830370426178,
0.488579124212265,
-0.49811211228370667,
1.0824415683746338,
0.7917290329933167,
-0.05107664316892624,
-0.06403598189353943,
-0.2668812572956085,
0.9216196537017822,
0.640596866607666,
-0.6256338357925415,
0.33899545669555664,
0.4213024973869324,
0.2842848598957062,
0.11153237521648407,
0.5194581747055054,
-0.17080871760845184,
0.10002748668193817,
-0.45204925537109375,
0.16056326031684875,
-0.11175746470689774,
-0.44827771186828613,
-0.6208449602127075,
-0.1335093080997467,
0.3159351050853729,
-0.26209330558776855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02987v1 | Conversation Reconstruction Attack Against GPT Models | 2024-02-05T13:18:42 | 2024-02-05T13:18:42 | Junjie Chu, Zeyang Sha, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent times, significant advancements have been made in the field of
large language models (LLMs), represented by GPT series models. To optimize
task execution, users often engage in multi-round conversations with GPT models
hosted in cloud environments. These multi-round conversations, potentially
replete with private information, require transmission and storage within the
cloud. However, this operational paradigm introduces additional attack
surfaces. In this paper, we first introduce a specific Conversation
Reconstruction Attack targeting GPT models. Our introduced Conversation
Reconstruction Attack is composed of two steps: hijacking a session and
reconstructing the conversations. Subsequently, we offer an exhaustive
evaluation of the privacy risks inherent in conversations when GPT models are
subjected to the proposed attack. However, GPT-4 demonstrates certain
robustness to the proposed attacks. We then introduce two advanced attacks
aimed at better reconstructing previous conversations, specifically the UNR
attack and the PBU attack. Our experimental findings indicate that the PBU
attack yields substantial performance across all models, achieving semantic
similarity scores exceeding 0.60, while the UNR attack is effective solely on
GPT-3.5. Our results reveal the concern about privacy risks associated with
conversations involving GPT models and aim to draw the community's attention to
prevent the potential misuse of these models' remarkable capabilities. We will
responsibly disclose our findings to the suppliers of related large language
models. | [
-0.3969496786594391,
-1.1382545232772827,
0.5794868469238281,
-0.17961768805980682,
-0.19157932698726654,
0.16777312755584717,
0.07624539732933044,
-0.6167965531349182,
-0.0665326789021492,
1.0790557861328125,
-0.5685215592384338,
-0.31838458776474,
-0.6363449096679688,
-0.242116317152977,
-0.8437654376029968,
1.0654244422912598,
0.48617759346961975,
-0.330056369304657,
0.058051131665706635,
0.17892494797706604,
-0.4864737391471863,
-0.9598532319068909,
-0.741867184638977,
0.196060910820961,
0.23793108761310577,
-0.023763787001371384,
0.8740633130073547,
0.22996240854263306,
0.5685354471206665,
0.4504588842391968,
-0.0857454165816307,
-0.29803934693336487,
-0.8929285407066345,
0.41985857486724854,
0.1294739544391632,
-0.19765816628932953,
-0.6885790824890137,
-0.2601366639137268,
0.6260594725608826,
0.3697441816329956,
-0.3502289354801178,
-0.14206242561340332,
0.13602015376091003,
0.5358669757843018,
-0.3422546982765198,
-0.02144251950085163,
-1.2751847505569458,
-0.15581946074962616,
-0.14179056882858276,
-0.04792266711592674,
-0.5180720090866089,
-0.018968185409903526,
0.21975210309028625,
-0.20371484756469727,
0.5224535465240479,
-0.023037245497107506,
0.8737527132034302,
0.016015639528632164,
-0.2341238409280777,
-0.15839315950870514,
-0.6474255919456482,
0.5145285725593567,
-0.8122706413269043,
0.19923192262649536,
0.3713790774345398,
0.36875295639038086,
-0.6414827108383179,
-0.7080734968185425,
-0.5494839549064636,
-0.16501733660697937,
-0.19234241545200348,
0.08538369834423065,
-0.6727342009544373,
0.23998311161994934,
0.40466853976249695,
0.5287298560142517,
-0.6558412909507751,
0.1852179914712906,
-0.394223153591156,
-0.3703487813472748,
0.5461211800575256,
0.40350550413131714,
0.0528070293366909,
-0.3609623908996582,
-0.526067316532135,
0.09142031520605087,
-0.7820737957954407,
-0.292117714881897,
0.5284687876701355,
0.22678598761558533,
-0.20682473480701447,
0.31050071120262146,
-0.227231964468956,
0.7793173789978027,
-0.10797116905450821,
-0.05508621409535408,
-0.2897051274776459,
-0.5623085498809814,
-0.41841572523117065,
-0.18408891558647156,
1.0590895414352417,
0.2595137655735016,
0.060126014053821564,
-0.27558189630508423,
-0.015555384568870068,
-0.3552406430244446,
0.5717216730117798,
-0.9497395157814026,
-0.4210352897644043,
0.35375118255615234,
-0.12555651366710663,
-0.23448045551776886,
0.1656700223684311,
-1.103942632675171,
-0.5536428689956665,
0.1677653044462204,
0.07227546721696854,
-0.2208264023065567,
-0.2274954468011856,
0.23816488683223724,
0.3938870429992676,
0.3100702166557312,
0.34830060601234436,
-0.8655394315719604,
0.4823459982872009,
1.107869267463684,
0.734497606754303,
0.037412144243717194,
-0.11484523862600327,
-0.3280433416366577,
0.27157047390937805,
-0.1829093098640442,
0.5827726125717163,
-0.24581564962863922,
-0.8876075744628906,
-0.03787444159388542,
0.0403643399477005,
-0.04713229462504387,
-0.2211684137582779,
0.34934201836586,
-0.7626258730888367,
0.4621232748031616,
-0.2417449951171875,
-0.5816770195960999,
-0.2840859293937683,
0.6267561316490173,
-0.6728459596633911,
0.5771235227584839,
-0.12277917563915253,
-0.9194853901863098,
-0.1396886706352234,
-0.567782461643219,
-0.2278629094362259,
0.06415972113609314,
-0.18482454121112823,
-0.5726332068443298,
0.07381576299667358,
0.317683607339859,
0.6589983701705933,
-0.32117143273353577,
-0.024821823462843895,
-0.4987959563732147,
-0.06815017014741898,
0.44666317105293274,
-0.6346500515937805,
0.6164154410362244,
0.14872540533542633,
-0.2996617257595062,
0.06762111186981201,
-0.5513584613800049,
0.007728673052042723,
0.2527880370616913,
0.14144267141819,
-0.17457935214042664,
-0.10228544473648071,
-0.3240779638290405,
-0.1144663393497467,
0.18354910612106323,
-0.6088579297065735,
0.21239876747131348,
-0.2814495861530304,
0.6601094603538513,
0.8303889632225037,
0.5240913033485413,
0.17027011513710022,
-0.23990505933761597,
0.5944036841392517,
-0.19434168934822083,
0.2695220410823822,
-0.21501630544662476,
-0.6039218306541443,
-0.3714213967323303,
-0.38915255665779114,
0.01719910278916359,
0.4226759970188141,
-0.4628942310810089,
0.18242396414279938,
-0.4818153381347656,
-0.620111882686615,
-0.40467751026153564,
-0.25240156054496765,
0.3715972900390625,
0.3871256113052368,
0.011124164797365665,
-0.2316984236240387,
-0.26100462675094604,
-0.9264740347862244,
-0.445724219083786,
-0.18476946651935577,
-0.19115354120731354,
0.48450666666030884,
0.30748504400253296,
-0.10593900084495544,
0.9395121932029724,
-0.6846415996551514,
-0.2132713496685028,
0.018130585551261902,
-0.06927495449781418,
0.028059756383299828,
0.4763845205307007,
0.6857442855834961,
-0.7361049652099609,
-0.49582433700561523,
-0.0869639590382576,
-0.5233744978904724,
0.2958134412765503,
-0.2848063111305237,
-0.17263975739479065,
0.2728414535522461,
0.35332396626472473,
-0.8537041544914246,
0.5374758839607239,
0.6712101101875305,
-0.2780304551124573,
0.2594231069087982,
-0.16627590358257294,
0.26294150948524475,
-1.1753982305526733,
-0.1704004406929016,
-0.42033204436302185,
-0.34555768966674805,
-0.9060817956924438,
0.09006860107183456,
-0.2350454032421112,
-0.46091151237487793,
-0.5521397590637207,
0.2373751699924469,
-0.5858967304229736,
-0.3045198917388916,
-0.3302324712276459,
-0.06506824493408203,
-0.09719865024089813,
0.4416452944278717,
-0.04430589824914932,
0.9157121181488037,
0.5408197045326233,
-0.41912075877189636,
0.3320247530937195,
0.4658270478248596,
-0.31494665145874023,
0.4019160568714142,
-0.6737321615219116,
1.0326600074768066,
0.08508037775754929,
0.23096096515655518,
-1.0558428764343262,
-0.17440158128738403,
0.33284837007522583,
-0.6728397011756897,
0.329568088054657,
-0.2613295614719391,
-0.4652141332626343,
0.004933055490255356,
-0.3644278943538666,
0.040422458201646805,
0.41227760910987854,
-0.3600828945636749,
0.6858466267585754,
0.7325569987297058,
-0.435063898563385,
-0.4855693578720093,
-0.5351088047027588,
0.48791277408599854,
-0.4586969316005707,
-0.7067350149154663,
0.18313893675804138,
0.16418345272541046,
-0.09642349928617477,
-0.14350616931915283,
-0.0643208920955658,
-0.03618145361542702,
0.3017135560512543,
0.3953500986099243,
0.16529116034507751,
0.015691686421632767,
-0.6180006861686707,
-0.4810411334037781,
-0.09169183671474457,
0.20234906673431396,
-0.047497693449258804,
0.7124942541122437,
-0.25634440779685974,
-0.5356815457344055,
-0.49853742122650146,
0.5960690975189209,
0.6336880326271057,
-0.019674712792038918,
0.7550836205482483,
0.45578351616859436,
-0.43347403407096863,
0.3335045576095581,
-0.8009912967681885,
-0.36551016569137573,
-0.5208949446678162,
0.7581119537353516,
-0.3990747034549713,
-1.1295305490493774,
0.5464854836463928,
0.3897261321544647,
0.21559813618659973,
0.040274616330862045,
0.552116334438324,
-0.052596524357795715,
0.867213785648346,
0.603938639163971,
-0.3973942995071411,
0.5180759429931641,
-0.07624363154172897,
0.23535184562206268,
-0.8028386235237122,
-0.1142972856760025,
-0.6311256289482117,
0.05634148046374321,
-0.7121495008468628,
-0.08495168387889862,
0.18701370060443878,
-0.1867360770702362,
-0.28871169686317444,
0.46391305327415466,
-0.2476077377796173,
0.5021135807037354,
0.36558282375335693,
0.09568420052528381,
0.353393018245697,
0.22313566505908966,
0.588782787322998,
-0.09642277657985687,
-0.5523728728294373,
-0.48886287212371826,
1.2058638334274292,
0.4697466492652893,
0.6876140832901001,
0.42069685459136963,
0.6636461019515991,
0.05942633002996445,
0.24482698738574982,
-0.5666666626930237,
0.8329998254776001,
0.11728686094284058,
-0.5990383625030518,
-0.32032662630081177,
-0.638023316860199,
-1.1702665090560913,
0.5913255214691162,
-0.06246303394436836,
-1.1063028573989868,
-0.18275615572929382,
0.01467489916831255,
-0.4042493402957916,
0.5399534106254578,
-0.6415114402770996,
0.9014759063720703,
-0.14693887531757355,
-0.23808656632900238,
-0.30968642234802246,
-0.5728296041488647,
0.5668089985847473,
-0.3127301335334778,
0.252166748046875,
0.03458774834871292,
0.2724758982658386,
0.5152359008789062,
-0.3797794580459595,
1.0003639459609985,
-0.13925713300704956,
-0.09551288187503815,
0.2517263889312744,
0.2698422074317932,
0.7357204556465149,
0.15641765296459198,
0.3353484272956848,
0.4125854969024658,
0.11938151717185974,
-0.42418885231018066,
-0.4821876585483551,
0.7084779739379883,
-0.6131073236465454,
-1.1222307682037354,
-0.5346113443374634,
-0.45386287569999695,
-0.20466655492782593,
0.0822017714381218,
0.07647719979286194,
0.2989636957645416,
-0.46733179688453674,
0.27539360523223877,
0.4106208086013794,
-0.24078400433063507,
0.35050827264785767,
0.6545642614364624,
-0.10561446100473404,
-0.4699814021587372,
0.6022276282310486,
-0.27263766527175903,
0.7416164875030518,
0.17728029191493988,
-0.11087733507156372,
-0.2727998197078705,
-0.8645673990249634,
-0.027761392295360565,
0.2558095455169678,
-0.5189006328582764,
-0.2671685218811035,
-0.7359771132469177,
-0.09749779105186462,
-0.5093919038772583,
0.27154144644737244,
-0.3901212811470032,
-0.20103667676448822,
0.005824233405292034,
-0.1659465730190277,
0.3759910464286804,
0.5523894429206848,
0.28383731842041016,
0.592595636844635,
-1.0411485433578491,
0.2510661780834198,
0.26369360089302063,
0.023216336965560913,
-0.09020669758319855,
-0.5404831767082214,
0.25015923380851746,
0.15651795268058777,
-0.5172559022903442,
-0.9507005214691162,
0.45394161343574524,
-0.030299413949251175,
0.36872997879981995,
0.16672492027282715,
0.016496969386935234,
0.7610657811164856,
-0.543105959892273,
0.8510379195213318,
0.02182769775390625,
-0.7029459476470947,
0.15572737157344818,
-0.420014351606369,
0.18758276104927063,
0.5478553771972656,
0.13495053350925446,
-0.49145421385765076,
-0.5081827044487,
-1.1065186262130737,
-0.6908950805664062,
0.6552720665931702,
0.3933368921279907,
0.43325188755989075,
0.09546805173158646,
0.2882579565048218,
-0.029081247746944427,
0.3207712769508362,
-0.6080340147018433,
0.006088841240853071,
-0.15422092378139496,
0.17649142444133759,
0.1444937288761139,
-0.33102285861968994,
-0.1555742770433426,
0.1349368691444397,
0.6933133006095886,
0.18909144401550293,
0.3956180810928345,
0.012558677233755589,
0.017424607649445534,
0.3663466274738312,
0.39806365966796875,
0.33924412727355957,
0.34567514061927795,
-0.009907357394695282,
-0.15971489250659943,
0.08036936074495316,
-0.7074442505836487,
-0.12995854020118713,
0.32823190093040466,
-0.2607237696647644,
-0.11697426438331604,
0.173528790473938,
0.8596312403678894,
0.37328609824180603,
-0.3372912108898163,
0.4597083628177643,
-0.3061041533946991,
-0.1263849139213562,
-0.478075236082077,
-0.24102875590324402,
0.2198391854763031,
0.11486837267875671,
0.003391572507098317,
-0.14565621316432953,
0.024011341854929924,
-0.5362494587898254,
0.09586318582296371,
0.7815623879432678,
-0.285595566034317,
-0.33579492568969727,
0.4514244496822357,
0.01883719302713871,
-0.3502388298511505,
0.8978086709976196,
0.10791461169719696,
-0.6965512037277222,
0.38932734727859497,
0.5090131163597107,
0.8617591857910156,
-0.37467828392982483,
-0.13014169037342072,
0.07889088243246078,
0.34378865361213684,
0.03219691663980484,
-0.03513346612453461,
0.0434018112719059,
-0.6708822846412659,
-0.23907899856567383,
-0.31865087151527405,
-0.6353670358657837,
0.6010921597480774,
-0.6975876688957214,
-0.07210710644721985,
-0.4805171489715576,
-0.21898160874843597,
-0.11781678348779678,
-0.28111833333969116,
-0.5237761735916138,
-0.23840247094631195,
0.04046258702874184,
0.30671024322509766,
-0.3343314826488495,
0.8927954435348511,
0.18478618562221527,
-0.12361845374107361,
-0.5515300035476685,
-0.00820141565054655,
0.1948980689048767,
-0.6997442245483398,
0.12015867233276367,
0.06872851401567459,
-0.1436539888381958,
0.04363133758306503,
-0.300681471824646,
-0.7632178068161011,
0.9947050213813782,
0.5560510158538818,
-0.78369140625,
-0.06608422100543976,
0.3982366621494293,
0.31041741371154785,
0.06325487047433853,
-0.010927017778158188,
0.6038419008255005,
0.16662435233592987,
0.03836407512426376,
-1.0299161672592163,
0.1254291534423828,
0.18032024800777435,
-0.12251108139753342,
0.3189358711242676,
-0.5083752870559692,
0.6338949203491211,
-0.03223034739494324,
-0.4940764009952545,
0.23976224660873413,
0.6467639207839966,
0.19615551829338074,
-0.15992574393749237,
0.44782814383506775,
0.2987286150455475,
0.6896167993545532,
-0.14210696518421173,
1.273964285850525,
-0.1969624012708664,
0.47988855838775635,
1.1266852617263794,
-0.33078619837760925,
0.8222334980964661,
0.3940315544605255,
-0.296173632144928,
-0.0858045220375061,
0.5458126664161682,
-0.03362899646162987,
0.5089224576950073,
0.14200790226459503,
-0.2675749957561493,
0.013756446540355682,
0.39794477820396423,
-0.5490633845329285,
0.42529985308647156,
0.400080144405365,
-0.030066538602113724,
-0.13745340704917908,
-0.17222413420677185,
0.5363447666168213,
0.010619604960083961,
-0.1311674267053604,
1.101657509803772,
0.1694074273109436,
-0.5413781404495239,
0.5986039042472839,
0.013712880201637745,
0.5620753169059753,
-0.7105878591537476,
0.17043793201446533,
-0.2153731882572174,
0.2804756164550781,
-0.08064253628253937,
-0.471962571144104,
0.4504832327365875,
-0.017067408189177513,
0.2507879137992859,
0.037165965884923935,
0.700360894203186,
-0.3929118812084198,
-0.17916882038116455,
0.07262223213911057,
0.33646872639656067,
0.30130988359451294,
-0.5309867858886719,
-0.7655425071716309,
0.14315909147262573,
0.18384425342082977,
-0.45095404982566833,
0.6910287141799927,
0.16612644493579865,
-0.009090076200664043,
0.6475621461868286,
0.6874133944511414,
0.05157557129859924,
-0.032629791647195816,
0.003153637982904911,
0.7108580470085144,
-0.6091399788856506,
-0.60100919008255,
-1.092238187789917,
0.18558147549629211,
-0.29338526725769043,
0.10554474592208862,
0.7977306842803955,
0.527626633644104,
0.8475790023803711,
0.012010496109724045,
0.8119112253189087,
0.3468047082424164,
0.5854528546333313,
-0.759054958820343,
0.7939718961715698,
0.13371655344963074,
0.6178359985351562,
-0.45230036973953247,
-0.8412004113197327,
-0.15154775977134705,
0.2723711431026459,
-0.41569244861602783,
0.03452764078974724,
0.711456835269928,
0.9906941652297974,
-0.02573557011783123,
0.6042880415916443,
0.22286319732666016,
0.4248778522014618,
0.8734897375106812,
0.6732305884361267,
0.9635506272315979,
-0.3559580147266388,
0.7338223457336426,
-0.11480533331632614,
-0.15447260439395905,
0.14929664134979248,
-0.967438280582428,
-0.8552008867263794,
-0.3726028800010681,
-0.2677120566368103,
-0.5014327764511108,
0.21488165855407715,
0.30421197414398193,
0.503792405128479,
-0.6549405455589294,
-0.14336447417736053,
-0.02677628956735134,
-0.3916175663471222,
0.07858633995056152,
-0.1614174097776413,
0.5653136968612671,
0.13205811381340027,
-0.6693299412727356,
0.4501366913318634,
-0.03376549482345581,
0.289666086435318,
-0.23013567924499512,
0.22531597316265106,
0.13009734451770782,
-0.1444525271654129,
0.2429959625005722,
0.4207612872123718,
-0.8122416734695435,
-0.5045197010040283,
-0.21459543704986572,
-0.01530351210385561,
0.12024832516908646,
0.940901517868042,
-0.6428300738334656,
0.08036551624536514,
0.12833163142204285,
1.067061424255371,
0.848742663860321,
0.28429684042930603,
0.6082330346107483,
-0.5932255387306213,
0.2849714457988739,
0.19496522843837738,
0.48172757029533386,
0.6463884115219116,
-0.585991621017456,
0.24687500298023224,
0.13794201612472534,
-0.5195574164390564,
-0.97418212890625,
0.5075321793556213,
-0.9854255318641663,
-0.31793469190597534,
1.1169377565383911,
-0.30321356654167175,
-0.05921211093664169,
-0.19107861816883087,
-0.407162070274353,
-0.10754121094942093,
-0.30453574657440186,
0.8924949169158936,
0.7025966644287109,
0.045022983103990555,
0.03367401659488678,
-0.8742716908454895,
0.451183944940567,
0.271602988243103,
-0.891524076461792,
0.5718207359313965,
0.5162928104400635,
0.4307843744754791,
-0.07152455300092697,
0.7404753565788269,
-0.6141006946563721,
-0.02008720673620701,
-0.07919681817293167,
-0.35015466809272766,
-0.2415107935667038,
0.021738242357969284,
-0.42160603404045105,
0.5867270231246948,
-0.04702209681272507,
-0.36535337567329407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02975v1 | Putting Context in Context: the Impact of Discussion Structure on Text Classification | 2024-02-05T12:56:22 | 2024-02-05T12:56:22 | Nicolò Penzo, Antonio Longa, Bruno Lepri, Sara Tonelli, Marco Guerini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current text classification approaches usually focus on the content to be
classified. Contextual aspects (both linguistic and extra-linguistic) are
usually neglected, even in tasks based on online discussions. Still in many
cases the multi-party and multi-turn nature of the context from which these
elements are selected can be fruitfully exploited. In this work, we propose a
series of experiments on a large dataset for stance detection in English, in
which we evaluate the contribution of different types of contextual
information, i.e. linguistic, structural and temporal, by feeding them as
natural language input into a transformer-based model. We also experiment with
different amounts of training data and analyse the topology of local discussion
networks in a privacy-compliant way. Results show that structural information
can be highly beneficial to text classification but only under certain
circumstances (e.g. depending on the amount of training data and on discussion
chain complexity). Indeed, we show that contextual information on smaller
datasets from other classification tasks does not yield significant
improvements. Our framework, based on local discussion networks, allows the
integration of structural information, while minimising user profiling, thus
preserving their privacy. | [
-0.5372629165649414,
-0.8129467964172363,
0.4361626207828522,
0.15201254189014435,
-0.2684430778026581,
-0.3832021951675415,
-0.21177345514297485,
-0.5343469381332397,
0.3579068183898926,
0.3954678177833557,
-0.031456392258405685,
-0.4265314042568207,
-0.6384223699569702,
0.12394512444734573,
-0.4263307452201843,
1.3942406177520752,
-0.014415809884667397,
0.03680872917175293,
-0.20690545439720154,
-0.49329444766044617,
-0.40837904810905457,
-0.7983678579330444,
-0.6247809529304504,
-0.1278982311487198,
0.7087005376815796,
0.23459936678409576,
0.5959802865982056,
0.5969803929328918,
0.15666350722312927,
0.41982969641685486,
-0.5847906470298767,
-0.24815575778484344,
-0.15633223950862885,
0.46799609065055847,
-0.3738706111907959,
-0.6441470384597778,
-0.2964695692062378,
0.07318118959665298,
0.7010173797607422,
0.6315329670906067,
-0.008790625259280205,
-0.20500142872333527,
0.3537594676017761,
0.37439030408859253,
-0.4543064832687378,
0.1913956254720688,
-0.22314809262752533,
0.31182411313056946,
-0.31087419390678406,
-0.2908942699432373,
-0.5610765218734741,
-0.1043042317032814,
0.32122567296028137,
-0.0037928626406937838,
0.258315771818161,
0.0026381760835647583,
0.7630977034568787,
0.0011037422809749842,
-0.8400177955627441,
-0.35974475741386414,
-0.4604671001434326,
0.6780754327774048,
-0.5465179085731506,
0.3795998692512512,
0.41379010677337646,
0.017620233818888664,
-0.03325120732188225,
-0.5532102584838867,
-0.6475778222084045,
0.09239412099123001,
-0.5965034365653992,
0.08997225016355515,
-0.120320163667202,
0.01159808412194252,
0.08376602828502655,
0.32408368587493896,
-0.325932115316391,
0.01668519899249077,
-0.24387319386005402,
-0.04140007868409157,
0.4593762755393982,
-0.0361441969871521,
0.229220449924469,
-0.8805481791496277,
-0.32679811120033264,
-0.11829591542482376,
-0.3946417272090912,
0.4314924478530884,
0.30321475863456726,
0.43921682238578796,
-0.166020467877388,
0.4131925404071808,
-0.1963495910167694,
0.48854610323905945,
0.252204954624176,
-0.1018141657114029,
0.21879497170448303,
-0.34568721055984497,
-0.17614050209522247,
0.00927921012043953,
0.8394343852996826,
0.4132803976535797,
-0.26926547288894653,
0.011855363845825195,
0.09405772387981415,
0.08833487331867218,
0.22644586861133575,
-0.8561239838600159,
-0.11247771233320236,
0.15494127571582794,
-0.537781298160553,
-0.4663396179676056,
0.27598506212234497,
-0.6624433994293213,
-0.5806124210357666,
-0.281615674495697,
-0.07147035002708435,
-0.06117737665772438,
-0.18327325582504272,
-0.05962752550840378,
-0.20440523326396942,
0.5075612664222717,
0.362283319234848,
-0.6806468367576599,
0.2597285807132721,
0.7389548420906067,
0.8086124062538147,
-0.30795714259147644,
-0.06666591018438339,
-0.24528780579566956,
0.1754785031080246,
-0.02043241634964943,
0.8487318158149719,
-0.6019266247749329,
-0.4324805438518524,
-0.042149242013692856,
0.27678295969963074,
0.007449336815625429,
-0.18826748430728912,
0.7267100214958191,
-0.29478347301483154,
0.9341358542442322,
-0.09956976026296616,
-0.5230598449707031,
-0.12959663569927216,
0.8127787113189697,
-0.7864765524864197,
1.0259106159210205,
-0.3651377260684967,
-1.3196778297424316,
0.573859453201294,
-0.6799809336662292,
-0.8359954953193665,
0.00384694361127913,
-0.49568644165992737,
-0.4165548086166382,
-0.04974048584699631,
0.007817517966032028,
0.703245222568512,
0.24932746589183807,
0.4025152623653412,
-0.061954349279403687,
-0.08734466880559921,
0.4230051040649414,
-0.37672922015190125,
0.677229642868042,
0.056954238563776016,
-0.7554425001144409,
0.2031303495168686,
-0.37816864252090454,
-0.26455649733543396,
-0.23824399709701538,
-0.5148128867149353,
-0.7491155862808228,
0.3641286790370941,
-0.024494674056768417,
0.3766038417816162,
-0.09644027054309845,
-0.4626687467098236,
0.11255522072315216,
-0.7559130191802979,
0.4349859952926636,
0.5340736508369446,
0.25687190890312195,
0.7048905491828918,
-0.20483604073524475,
0.4173169732093811,
0.21636848151683807,
0.18936468660831451,
-0.12387331575155258,
-0.6668555736541748,
-0.7439821362495422,
0.16189908981323242,
0.17322587966918945,
0.3743174970149994,
-0.5419573187828064,
0.5267588496208191,
-0.30859991908073425,
-0.18958161771297455,
0.061615217477083206,
-0.1119321882724762,
0.4774334132671356,
0.3090360164642334,
0.10219307988882065,
-0.2487955093383789,
-0.40666815638542175,
-0.8919922113418579,
-0.3160633146762848,
-0.3944711685180664,
0.08776430040597916,
0.3764755129814148,
0.3355410099029541,
-0.08536434918642044,
1.0662705898284912,
-0.25716498494148254,
-0.3807598650455475,
-0.4030449688434601,
0.24945896863937378,
-0.13194367289543152,
0.21218213438987732,
0.5045198202133179,
-1.1942460536956787,
-0.5438113808631897,
0.13001275062561035,
-0.619770884513855,
0.232929527759552,
-0.0373721569776535,
-0.1137094646692276,
0.2866280972957611,
0.5357486605644226,
-0.48418980836868286,
0.45781567692756653,
0.5231863260269165,
-0.4189888834953308,
-0.12538214027881622,
0.2111598253250122,
0.06079467386007309,
-1.5889031887054443,
-0.18613986670970917,
0.13749654591083527,
-0.48238372802734375,
-0.8130127787590027,
0.00023056112695485353,
-0.2387991100549698,
0.03071799874305725,
-0.46996018290519714,
0.6005812883377075,
-0.08386638760566711,
0.31285834312438965,
-0.2685889005661011,
0.42186450958251953,
0.15846329927444458,
0.5130778551101685,
0.4190627634525299,
0.45281097292900085,
0.25614961981773376,
-0.6679970622062683,
-0.18561305105686188,
0.46075475215911865,
-0.18521571159362793,
0.813010036945343,
-0.306090772151947,
0.27410122752189636,
-0.263927698135376,
0.5588414669036865,
-0.9937072396278381,
-0.41866591572761536,
0.32165127992630005,
-0.5094952583312988,
0.269184947013855,
-0.32991859316825867,
-0.22026695311069489,
0.10921777039766312,
-0.6994951367378235,
0.22368168830871582,
-0.05577860772609711,
-0.5180289149284363,
0.6062594056129456,
0.8895286917686462,
-0.2166561484336853,
-0.6398217082023621,
-0.7270061373710632,
0.11350304633378983,
-0.4949047565460205,
-0.4151901602745056,
0.2745821177959442,
0.20347386598587036,
-0.33942103385925293,
-0.12108153104782104,
-0.18803125619888306,
-0.2482992261648178,
0.09028632193803787,
0.5270913243293762,
-0.13197191059589386,
0.0043614087626338005,
0.28480997681617737,
0.06639628857374191,
0.0015859132399782538,
0.06257738918066025,
-0.16251255571842194,
0.3418239951133728,
-0.41558900475502014,
-0.04854940250515938,
-0.45994797348976135,
0.48374152183532715,
0.4673313796520233,
0.10843871533870697,
0.8219475746154785,
0.23442509770393372,
-0.155196875333786,
-0.5066449046134949,
-0.15249665081501007,
-0.0823197141289711,
-0.47773417830467224,
0.2886820137500763,
-0.02200181409716606,
-1.2169913053512573,
0.24135306477546692,
-0.0023318917956203222,
0.18468038737773895,
0.26218315958976746,
0.6133528351783752,
-0.45642510056495667,
1.0810729265213013,
0.7476006746292114,
-0.1633106917142868,
0.7093772292137146,
0.06659823656082153,
0.42863261699676514,
-0.47855618596076965,
-0.2577866315841675,
-0.7277830243110657,
-0.5965503454208374,
-0.7420520186424255,
-0.3243699371814728,
0.2505531907081604,
-0.09344109147787094,
0.17292505502700806,
0.5195980668067932,
-0.6174601316452026,
0.5122482776641846,
-0.049970854073762894,
0.09158641844987869,
0.18525072932243347,
-0.07521336525678635,
0.1748930811882019,
-0.1576606035232544,
-0.5475133657455444,
-0.7233788371086121,
0.5359807014465332,
0.4285466969013214,
0.40586742758750916,
0.14003433287143707,
0.5071126222610474,
0.27420663833618164,
0.6148831844329834,
-1.2431410551071167,
0.630364716053009,
-0.034262608736753464,
-0.6462833881378174,
-0.2902573049068451,
-0.4127698540687561,
-1.1087919473648071,
0.4179236590862274,
0.09502109885215759,
-0.6670445203781128,
0.47748681902885437,
0.19863992929458618,
0.11257867515087128,
0.31785306334495544,
-0.5105472803115845,
0.8864883780479431,
-0.020916420966386795,
-0.35861319303512573,
0.020945165306329727,
-0.7246976494789124,
0.041326574981212616,
0.2835518717765808,
0.5192712545394897,
0.38159850239753723,
0.28147897124290466,
0.9965661764144897,
-0.25523051619529724,
1.328138828277588,
-0.34794917702674866,
-0.33640679717063904,
0.3152134418487549,
-0.06971485912799835,
0.44592538475990295,
0.0994747132062912,
0.15463344752788544,
0.08533560484647751,
-0.20846854150295258,
0.022351998835802078,
-0.6580148935317993,
0.4720512330532074,
-0.571872889995575,
-0.6197551488876343,
-0.3330869972705841,
-0.11333087086677551,
-0.35443639755249023,
0.07936397194862366,
0.39208483695983887,
0.5147165656089783,
-0.20655988156795502,
0.7952454090118408,
0.7069306373596191,
0.11234038323163986,
0.39009588956832886,
0.32021796703338623,
-0.05018928647041321,
-0.04532329738140106,
0.6727790832519531,
-0.026526840403676033,
-0.21194131672382355,
0.6905680298805237,
0.5709469318389893,
-0.37273290753364563,
-0.3070840537548065,
0.033117953687906265,
-0.04790050908923149,
-1.1386250257492065,
-0.2621116042137146,
-0.6902235150337219,
-0.05604884773492813,
-0.19386672973632812,
-0.31865379214286804,
-0.21588538587093353,
-0.6048291921615601,
0.12363987416028976,
-0.4775087833404541,
0.006576485466212034,
0.8365124464035034,
0.4977359175682068,
0.6072476506233215,
-0.46626439690589905,
-0.17456208169460297,
0.20428001880645752,
0.36224356293678284,
-0.27864930033683777,
-0.39339688420295715,
-0.1519080102443695,
-0.3981172740459442,
-0.36727532744407654,
-1.0820858478546143,
0.08060120791196823,
0.0450000986456871,
0.5138505697250366,
0.544321596622467,
0.09961101412773132,
0.22147658467292786,
-0.285165011882782,
0.8924915194511414,
-0.03784574195742607,
-0.9391000270843506,
0.7176390290260315,
-0.2630174160003662,
-0.003283222671598196,
0.7381496429443359,
0.5683780312538147,
-0.6237932443618774,
-0.7248387336730957,
-0.62080317735672,
-0.7880101203918457,
0.7669210433959961,
0.2357717752456665,
0.4848272204399109,
-0.17158780992031097,
0.42287248373031616,
-0.09372095763683319,
0.25236156582832336,
-1.3306255340576172,
-0.11824049800634384,
-0.2749894857406616,
-0.09373942762613297,
0.24417835474014282,
-0.15662413835525513,
-0.3373599052429199,
-0.42257794737815857,
0.4435758888721466,
-0.24266384541988373,
0.11943873763084412,
0.22373326122760773,
-0.14511549472808838,
0.3171865940093994,
0.7358756065368652,
0.42853784561157227,
0.31683385372161865,
0.28420740365982056,
0.3977988660335541,
0.3068670332431793,
-0.45193755626678467,
0.08235114067792892,
-0.42158243060112,
-0.30901944637298584,
0.2330922931432724,
0.27747753262519836,
0.8460312485694885,
0.6536204218864441,
0.012583800591528416,
0.7609696984291077,
-0.2569589614868164,
-0.2969534695148468,
-0.020001105964183807,
0.11924120783805847,
-0.07780585438013077,
0.11226949840784073,
-0.25478044152259827,
0.059816088527441025,
0.32543057203292847,
-0.6827994585037231,
0.30572348833084106,
0.33535462617874146,
-0.6010334491729736,
-0.518177330493927,
0.23536866903305054,
0.23775692284107208,
-0.3488863408565521,
0.0640435665845871,
-0.15042100846767426,
-0.8612374067306519,
0.35347357392311096,
0.37607520818710327,
0.8454732298851013,
-0.4089076817035675,
0.3840886354446411,
0.14351247251033783,
0.011432640254497528,
-0.012446551583707333,
0.003955549094825983,
-0.5006219148635864,
-0.9506738781929016,
-0.16385839879512787,
-0.5891261696815491,
-0.5768529772758484,
0.0037455493584275246,
-0.71056067943573,
0.32620012760162354,
-0.627974271774292,
-0.43894273042678833,
0.1025518923997879,
-0.10982968658208847,
-0.2565242648124695,
0.047790080308914185,
0.11390068382024765,
0.6436534523963928,
-0.9056742191314697,
0.796920120716095,
1.0457642078399658,
-0.0056230854243040085,
-0.5922359228134155,
0.333111435174942,
0.039543092250823975,
0.13580556213855743,
0.5287542343139648,
0.5250104069709778,
-0.5351904630661011,
-0.48289114236831665,
-0.6873200535774231,
-0.36167043447494507,
0.7172402739524841,
0.07908095419406891,
-0.2507801353931427,
0.05877289921045303,
0.039398275315761566,
0.8261138796806335,
-0.10778460651636124,
-0.013658085837960243,
0.13133345544338226,
0.48781800270080566,
0.12711787223815918,
-0.7560782432556152,
-0.040909115225076675,
-0.44720134139060974,
-0.19304336607456207,
0.28052040934562683,
-0.7193993330001831,
0.7285991907119751,
0.5372536778450012,
-0.5475415587425232,
-0.4938463270664215,
0.6385853886604309,
-0.15708215534687042,
0.2446569800376892,
0.7326414585113525,
0.0664193257689476,
0.8231244683265686,
-0.10407744348049164,
1.2100114822387695,
-0.29404395818710327,
0.30971208214759827,
0.964451789855957,
-0.3239484131336212,
1.0368627309799194,
0.4405510127544403,
0.08128063380718231,
0.8900584578514099,
0.3739420473575592,
0.24967575073242188,
0.3557864725589752,
-0.04982854798436165,
-0.2519824206829071,
0.057753559201955795,
-0.09904175996780396,
-0.11110495775938034,
0.5311399698257446,
0.3377007246017456,
-0.20996251702308655,
-0.1454983800649643,
0.04590161517262459,
0.421898752450943,
0.2198287397623062,
-0.11077257990837097,
0.9935572147369385,
0.07472498714923859,
-0.6920792460441589,
-0.1583951860666275,
0.36064472794532776,
0.7624565362930298,
-0.4475758373737335,
0.2134845107793808,
-0.26964566111564636,
0.20217545330524445,
-0.5029462575912476,
-0.9000137448310852,
0.6032856106758118,
0.04052763804793358,
-0.22796379029750824,
-0.49983322620391846,
0.7815607190132141,
-0.2536613643169403,
-0.059191636741161346,
0.3331679105758667,
0.26484403014183044,
0.008368898183107376,
0.14079175889492035,
-0.29860731959342957,
-0.26520201563835144,
-0.2615920901298523,
-0.6031481623649597,
0.5746762156486511,
0.5810607075691223,
-0.4231376349925995,
0.09632569551467896,
0.42638683319091797,
-0.45840492844581604,
-0.24406199157238007,
0.03188763186335564,
1.0101444721221924,
-0.6148887872695923,
-1.0667449235916138,
-0.8683709502220154,
0.4123382270336151,
-0.3512924611568451,
-0.3907412886619568,
1.0626431703567505,
0.47064685821533203,
0.8905728459358215,
0.4376758337020874,
0.5678526759147644,
-0.05743370205163956,
0.15605109930038452,
-0.37712523341178894,
0.7742597460746765,
-0.3317634165287018,
0.18152697384357452,
-0.2536149322986603,
-0.7305469512939453,
-0.3754023015499115,
0.9230871200561523,
-0.425833523273468,
-0.024847354739904404,
0.7581535577774048,
0.3831767141819,
-0.10002292692661285,
0.5459891557693481,
0.06361948698759079,
0.21406885981559753,
0.38286086916923523,
0.09412412345409393,
0.9115626811981201,
-0.18951067328453064,
0.38135960698127747,
-0.1595873087644577,
-0.19735966622829437,
0.07446049898862839,
-0.8711757659912109,
-1.1894421577453613,
-0.6956270337104797,
-0.46551358699798584,
-0.39752528071403503,
-0.3290863335132599,
0.7111334800720215,
0.7733657956123352,
-0.9968077540397644,
-0.23904959857463837,
-0.09682602435350418,
0.2546004354953766,
0.15903668105602264,
-0.32968610525131226,
0.30019447207450867,
-0.266458660364151,
-0.6891022324562073,
0.5891606211662292,
0.34428051114082336,
-0.21935869753360748,
-0.17201915383338928,
0.022231590002775192,
-0.193449005484581,
0.04783279448747635,
0.8490852117538452,
0.23449492454528809,
-0.4423089921474457,
-0.5387477278709412,
-0.07010955363512039,
-0.20076556503772736,
0.3545229434967041,
1.1569199562072754,
-0.6648802161216736,
0.2219921499490738,
0.5850547552108765,
0.6441651582717896,
0.4853736460208893,
0.21608451008796692,
0.4199076294898987,
-1.4104114770889282,
0.3652394115924835,
0.14480765163898468,
0.4584004580974579,
0.30206990242004395,
-0.588287889957428,
0.2524077594280243,
0.17267750203609467,
-0.3138682544231415,
-0.7895783185958862,
0.24367719888687134,
-0.8279547095298767,
-0.4724976420402527,
1.0490977764129639,
-0.004838894587010145,
-0.28198108077049255,
-0.5065056681632996,
-0.24947506189346313,
0.08394064754247665,
-0.18934743106365204,
0.6083183884620667,
0.8646745085716248,
-0.24504004418849945,
-0.03895222395658493,
-0.36266082525253296,
0.6210013628005981,
0.46294647455215454,
-1.0045750141143799,
0.196916863322258,
0.3658244013786316,
0.15634307265281677,
0.5520161986351013,
0.6163201928138733,
-0.2537556290626526,
-0.2205360382795334,
-0.3901495039463043,
-0.36474165320396423,
0.291816383600235,
-0.649322509765625,
-0.5940044522285461,
0.6966317296028137,
-0.2564071714878082,
0.13458380103111267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02969v2 | Towards Understanding the Word Sensitivity of Attention Layers: A Study via Random Features | 2024-02-05T12:47:19 | 2024-05-17T15:31:34 | Simone Bombari, Marco Mondelli | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding the reasons behind the exceptional success of transformers
requires a better analysis of why attention layers are suitable for NLP tasks.
In particular, such tasks require predictive models to capture contextual
meaning which often depends on one or few words, even if the sentence is long.
Our work studies this key property, dubbed word sensitivity (WS), in the
prototypical setting of random features. We show that attention layers enjoy
high WS, namely, there exists a vector in the space of embeddings that largely
perturbs the random attention features map. The argument critically exploits
the role of the softmax in the attention layer, highlighting its benefit
compared to other activations (e.g., ReLU). In contrast, the WS of standard
random features is of order $1/\sqrt{n}$, $n$ being the number of words in the
textual sample, and thus it decays with the length of the context. We then
translate these results on the word sensitivity into generalization bounds: due
to their low WS, random features provably cannot learn to distinguish between
two sentences that differ only in a single word; in contrast, due to their high
WS, random attention features have higher generalization capabilities. We
validate our theoretical results with experimental evidence over the BERT-Base
word embeddings of the imdb review dataset. | [
-0.6579481363296509,
-0.7966130375862122,
0.34070703387260437,
0.0909046083688736,
-0.06369592994451523,
-0.44752803444862366,
-0.39297473430633545,
-0.33995720744132996,
0.14162121713161469,
0.3832426071166992,
-0.5284371972084045,
-0.3245624601840973,
-0.8554816246032715,
0.05993090942502022,
-0.5493725538253784,
1.1559576988220215,
0.24889631569385529,
-0.5315458178520203,
-0.02027001604437828,
-0.5159482359886169,
-0.13319067656993866,
-0.5259053707122803,
-0.22854070365428925,
-0.041633594781160355,
1.0273044109344482,
0.14939777553081512,
1.015527606010437,
0.5165566802024841,
0.7056892514228821,
0.31433168053627014,
-0.1642749011516571,
-0.3049684166908264,
-0.43622562289237976,
0.22778154909610748,
-0.1820714920759201,
-0.6217387318611145,
-0.06682828068733215,
-0.10396920144557953,
0.5104840397834778,
0.7416055798530579,
0.11356255412101746,
0.26682308316230774,
0.3685532212257385,
0.5925854444503784,
-0.6779444813728333,
-0.1828341782093048,
-0.8831639885902405,
0.48903945088386536,
-0.23074284195899963,
-0.24451124668121338,
-0.20482268929481506,
0.23947609961032867,
0.6915282607078552,
-0.501780092716217,
0.8350886702537537,
0.17107920348644257,
0.9063364267349243,
0.3041827976703644,
-0.2883163094520569,
0.02711649239063263,
-0.7177409529685974,
0.9815146923065186,
-0.2780466079711914,
0.1940932720899582,
0.10501381754875183,
-0.05053103715181351,
0.0955551415681839,
-0.6509404182434082,
-0.6189403533935547,
-0.2310144156217575,
0.0706101506948471,
-0.02954874001443386,
-0.16163955628871918,
0.0383005291223526,
0.6133543848991394,
0.43369248509407043,
-0.26486682891845703,
0.01416407898068428,
-0.06978356093168259,
-0.40196892619132996,
0.31924641132354736,
0.050615280866622925,
0.052324507385492325,
-0.10345032811164856,
-0.5865966081619263,
-0.35404694080352783,
-0.27679750323295593,
0.3530144691467285,
0.2498915046453476,
0.28991711139678955,
0.03516553342342377,
0.7292879223823547,
0.06628413498401642,
0.5373157262802124,
-0.0954163447022438,
0.008074154146015644,
0.21191871166229248,
-0.0279388427734375,
-0.2717287242412567,
-0.06502426415681839,
0.5829426646232605,
0.39748144149780273,
0.6511712074279785,
-0.21933194994926453,
-0.20147950947284698,
0.13148149847984314,
0.4934341311454773,
-0.4974035620689392,
0.14830899238586426,
0.20426087081432343,
-0.42775484919548035,
-0.35207420587539673,
-0.016935374587774277,
-0.554008960723877,
-0.370512455701828,
-0.048346273601055145,
0.4052037298679352,
-0.3239823579788208,
-0.09372986108064651,
0.13774532079696655,
-0.46011781692504883,
0.36110588908195496,
0.02751380391418934,
-0.8404265642166138,
0.10008454322814941,
0.5481948852539062,
0.6181229948997498,
-0.23588521778583527,
-0.37410688400268555,
-0.354733407497406,
0.18718191981315613,
-0.09560446441173553,
0.8794588446617126,
-0.4612419605255127,
-0.0965089425444603,
0.13853007555007935,
-0.1475009322166443,
-0.2878502309322357,
-0.2579600214958191,
0.7972010970115662,
-0.38280144333839417,
0.13592784106731415,
-0.1783658266067505,
-0.3168771266937256,
-0.0857333242893219,
0.05621998757123947,
-0.5395488142967224,
0.8128156065940857,
0.349808007478714,
-1.2081074714660645,
0.5575286746025085,
-0.2981490194797516,
-0.6257440447807312,
-0.032597701996564865,
-0.016010239720344543,
-0.27899160981178284,
0.6324393153190613,
0.14214208722114563,
0.47106239199638367,
0.09751428663730621,
-0.22127898037433624,
-0.49222806096076965,
-0.327883780002594,
0.7527040243148804,
-0.4500226080417633,
0.3177001476287842,
0.17559072375297546,
-0.2687132954597473,
0.043053705245256424,
-0.5451028347015381,
0.12398717552423477,
0.11350467056035995,
-0.38903146982192993,
-0.4509621858596802,
0.17197781801223755,
0.12299437820911407,
0.32276755571365356,
-0.06306767463684082,
-0.48606857657432556,
-0.13035188615322113,
-0.45828577876091003,
0.4592381715774536,
0.7361953258514404,
-0.013065313920378685,
0.46051454544067383,
-0.2176928073167801,
0.6158396005630493,
0.337272047996521,
0.1558266133069992,
-0.04696374759078026,
-0.5435558557510376,
-0.6407680511474609,
-0.16910101473331451,
0.3913736641407013,
0.6735495924949646,
-0.3744736909866333,
0.5779203176498413,
-0.3336586356163025,
0.13505280017852783,
-0.7334784865379333,
0.39667272567749023,
0.367195725440979,
0.3685688078403473,
0.32284221053123474,
-0.6641818284988403,
-0.18385447561740875,
-1.2522268295288086,
-0.4483901858329773,
0.1945563405752182,
-0.5397182106971741,
0.5615386366844177,
0.075327068567276,
-0.025372030213475227,
1.0454201698303223,
-0.5573066473007202,
-0.7480689287185669,
-0.4948335587978363,
-0.10122621804475784,
0.06116408482193947,
0.050063032656908035,
0.5186396837234497,
-0.8221389055252075,
-0.12579789757728577,
-0.27961865067481995,
-0.3757973611354828,
0.06350865215063095,
-0.02054433897137642,
-0.129886656999588,
-0.09728293120861053,
0.5972650051116943,
-0.7341299653053284,
0.4030550718307495,
0.37769418954849243,
-0.1866506040096283,
0.14992180466651917,
-0.13076236844062805,
-0.3829522132873535,
-0.8890892267227173,
0.1347869336605072,
0.42132920026779175,
-0.07458287477493286,
-0.5834805965423584,
0.08165224641561508,
-0.22519218921661377,
-0.031054388731718063,
-0.5915676355361938,
0.14773690700531006,
-0.2940995395183563,
-0.15911094844341278,
-0.1260005533695221,
0.5243768095970154,
0.06379737704992294,
0.7648379802703857,
-0.20301257073879242,
0.43613702058792114,
0.2976866364479065,
-0.647853672504425,
0.15094812214374542,
0.19276027381420135,
-0.4343089759349823,
0.3987901508808136,
-0.8314700722694397,
0.1346224993467331,
-0.3259439468383789,
0.13677211105823517,
-1.2033591270446777,
-0.10872513800859451,
-0.15589293837547302,
-0.5466510057449341,
0.39317500591278076,
0.05742865428328514,
-0.4500025510787964,
-0.57500821352005,
-0.587397038936615,
0.052207861095666885,
0.30901038646698,
0.036515019834041595,
0.34073153138160706,
0.6080917716026306,
0.041869454085826874,
-0.7261013388633728,
-0.9039028286933899,
0.0053367773070931435,
-0.2756621837615967,
-0.6843752264976501,
0.3474809527397156,
0.006467712111771107,
-0.1840784102678299,
0.13864921033382416,
-0.0644344612956047,
0.11834392696619034,
0.3570362329483032,
0.30053699016571045,
-0.24316395819187164,
-0.2898155748844147,
0.18564236164093018,
-0.06401168555021286,
-0.18300864100456238,
0.06501225382089615,
-0.14865393936634064,
0.42483821511268616,
-0.048260509967803955,
0.07773756980895996,
-0.001225420506671071,
0.36773407459259033,
0.40417373180389404,
-0.22525809705257416,
0.726942241191864,
0.9198694229125977,
-0.23230238258838654,
-0.4188553988933563,
-0.4230348765850067,
-0.22181715071201324,
-0.4708561599254608,
0.5712479948997498,
-0.5792255401611328,
-1.0885331630706787,
0.5851762294769287,
0.3906223475933075,
-0.09125065803527832,
0.6952111721038818,
0.4162112772464752,
-0.1604633629322052,
1.2414385080337524,
0.9473004341125488,
-0.18877646327018738,
0.47695401310920715,
-0.16758868098258972,
0.2716054320335388,
-1.156406283378601,
0.12193424999713898,
-0.6100250482559204,
-0.7897300720214844,
-0.7656021118164062,
-0.05458290874958038,
0.09673439711332321,
-0.17908072471618652,
0.18262477219104767,
0.2178027331829071,
-0.680553138256073,
0.3308936655521393,
0.435924768447876,
0.14333787560462952,
-0.1562810093164444,
0.21957887709140778,
-0.29941582679748535,
-0.272803395986557,
-0.7560774087905884,
-0.3047429621219635,
0.8249428868293762,
0.6393882632255554,
0.8519748449325562,
-0.07833923399448395,
0.09173489362001419,
0.37970760464668274,
0.16567730903625488,
-0.7837989926338196,
0.5919891595840454,
-0.3239137828350067,
-0.7545634508132935,
-0.4521632492542267,
-0.08937977254390717,
-0.9554415941238403,
0.2353893220424652,
-0.2746477723121643,
-0.6459364891052246,
0.3208872675895691,
0.014503814280033112,
-0.5735712647438049,
0.1283297836780548,
-0.9789714217185974,
0.670995831489563,
0.19262540340423584,
-0.4968068301677704,
-0.06657689064741135,
-0.929530918598175,
0.11014775186777115,
0.20635634660720825,
0.13860875368118286,
-0.3160591125488281,
-0.28718507289886475,
0.6543357968330383,
0.11663861572742462,
0.8527017831802368,
-0.09099435061216354,
-0.1029154509305954,
0.23166538774967194,
-0.024146756157279015,
0.15535469353199005,
-0.0482809878885746,
0.18621623516082764,
-0.10135037451982498,
-0.46102574467658997,
-0.2957735061645508,
-0.40550222992897034,
0.7470918297767639,
-0.6703471541404724,
-0.6995157599449158,
-0.32658651471138,
-0.7014473676681519,
-0.334609717130661,
0.03891172260046005,
0.5340873599052429,
0.4047796428203583,
-0.006615165155380964,
0.5286455154418945,
1.015333652496338,
-0.39415499567985535,
0.4633004069328308,
0.11229555308818817,
0.06010906398296356,
-0.014558377675712109,
0.7534971833229065,
0.37152186036109924,
0.223249152302742,
0.6247975826263428,
0.2816523015499115,
-0.2471935749053955,
-0.5392675995826721,
0.008471880108118057,
0.0056013073772192,
-0.5643372535705566,
-0.007918749004602432,
-1.0506770610809326,
-0.4132728576660156,
-0.3918302655220032,
-0.09662375599145889,
0.09007497876882553,
-0.6744447350502014,
-0.21496431529521942,
-0.3318183720111847,
0.2744872272014618,
0.3590191602706909,
0.23562310636043549,
0.0016600264934822917,
-0.6092933416366577,
0.5557477474212646,
0.497041791677475,
0.37061136960983276,
-0.044374700635671616,
-0.9765288233757019,
-0.262843519449234,
-0.4308154881000519,
-0.40532124042510986,
-0.5738978981971741,
0.36921414732933044,
0.530012845993042,
0.5686125159263611,
0.5157000422477722,
0.04163416102528572,
0.13811169564723969,
-0.3131709098815918,
0.7083909511566162,
-0.20112724602222443,
-0.733215868473053,
0.6214057207107544,
-0.35792744159698486,
0.5753034949302673,
0.5544715523719788,
0.22968259453773499,
-0.47533178329467773,
-0.9853252172470093,
-0.8110861778259277,
-1.1645547151565552,
0.4335622489452362,
0.1753494292497635,
0.6774142384529114,
-0.09617184847593307,
0.29775384068489075,
0.017622312530875206,
0.28646114468574524,
-0.7286048531532288,
-0.3047068417072296,
-0.11167807877063751,
-0.23731841146945953,
-0.16434668004512787,
-0.7158304452896118,
-0.15524418652057648,
0.009245848283171654,
0.3168972432613373,
-0.16013921797275543,
0.5005157589912415,
0.49423491954803467,
-0.39904865622520447,
-0.18739427626132965,
0.5273462533950806,
0.7867588400840759,
0.2924373745918274,
-0.42266955971717834,
0.3740340769290924,
0.251270592212677,
-0.7496855854988098,
-0.29334965348243713,
0.013581889681518078,
-0.19951102137565613,
0.016133753582835197,
0.5417155623435974,
0.8387749791145325,
0.37047451734542847,
-0.3148316740989685,
0.7007742524147034,
-0.1163448840379715,
-0.09640763700008392,
-0.056056682020425797,
0.2371343970298767,
-0.06046333536505699,
-0.13262145221233368,
0.5833421945571899,
0.13504521548748016,
0.3342917859554291,
-0.38700366020202637,
0.4275776445865631,
0.4578629732131958,
-0.6432737112045288,
-0.2634909451007843,
0.6843465566635132,
0.2718227505683899,
-0.18937107920646667,
0.461467981338501,
0.14265789091587067,
-0.6485626101493835,
0.8146653771400452,
0.43834465742111206,
1.0507116317749023,
-0.1191602349281311,
-0.09965091943740845,
0.18720418214797974,
0.545492947101593,
0.41798970103263855,
0.07774098217487335,
-0.023641562089323997,
-0.9454064965248108,
-0.3449389338493347,
-0.6870592832565308,
-0.22785817086696625,
0.12722036242485046,
-0.6145057678222656,
0.07162877172231674,
-0.6544500589370728,
-0.5161792039871216,
0.12115981429815292,
-0.22734993696212769,
-0.8600595593452454,
0.34541967511177063,
0.31725066900253296,
0.921027421951294,
-0.775592029094696,
0.5574924349784851,
0.4733729958534241,
-0.06080588698387146,
-0.6852176189422607,
0.212829127907753,
-0.2804502546787262,
-0.8685698509216309,
0.35781559348106384,
0.6975357532501221,
0.05693609267473221,
0.1629093736410141,
-0.45544490218162537,
-0.6973463296890259,
0.7777985334396362,
0.2655387222766876,
-0.5913991928100586,
0.060264140367507935,
0.23335309326648712,
0.8181845545768738,
-0.3261536955833435,
0.153120756149292,
0.43278253078460693,
0.26833096146583557,
-0.4104912281036377,
-0.41406211256980896,
-0.03099459409713745,
-0.11956008523702621,
0.3428065776824951,
0.10847815126180649,
-0.5491241812705994,
0.48305070400238037,
-0.4931705892086029,
-0.15259955823421478,
-0.3363596498966217,
0.7700771689414978,
-0.23870155215263367,
0.15465635061264038,
0.6729596853256226,
0.7083564400672913,
0.18449418246746063,
-0.10771625488996506,
1.6078473329544067,
-0.38351404666900635,
0.30128028988838196,
0.7780724167823792,
-0.20184439420700073,
0.7652415037155151,
0.5623128414154053,
-0.2406178116798401,
0.42034462094306946,
0.33471590280532837,
0.007045680657029152,
0.6145281791687012,
0.5265383124351501,
-0.23557977378368378,
-0.031767040491104126,
-0.4777333438396454,
-0.26207682490348816,
0.37005940079689026,
0.4382832646369934,
-0.609296441078186,
0.09605596214532852,
0.37258192896842957,
-0.3113194704055786,
-0.004039671737700701,
-0.25353240966796875,
0.7000530362129211,
0.3704789876937866,
-0.44707679748535156,
0.12759746611118317,
-0.16927289962768555,
0.8511504530906677,
-0.7525110244750977,
0.4605259299278259,
-0.21770811080932617,
0.47142767906188965,
-0.18510554730892181,
-1.1155778169631958,
0.16651862859725952,
-0.24442853033542633,
-0.4421616494655609,
-0.1613062024116516,
0.9018736481666565,
-0.30523353815078735,
-0.39299196004867554,
0.4568954110145569,
0.14680705964565277,
-0.24083638191223145,
-0.14461326599121094,
-0.7961945533752441,
-0.0112690394744277,
-0.14339061081409454,
-0.7442221641540527,
0.489715576171875,
0.8430220484733582,
0.11547260731458664,
0.7124045491218567,
0.4337083101272583,
-0.029257366433739662,
0.31847548484802246,
0.36966410279273987,
0.6344300508499146,
-0.5158277750015259,
-0.5215996503829956,
-0.5907168388366699,
0.5210587978363037,
0.048391059041023254,
-0.6326467394828796,
0.7056893706321716,
0.2618783712387085,
0.7019314169883728,
-0.26787757873535156,
0.7109013199806213,
0.029656682163476944,
0.5622097849845886,
-0.33669012784957886,
0.47678184509277344,
-0.3242098093032837,
0.15572397410869598,
-0.2549187242984772,
-1.194347620010376,
-0.44825127720832825,
0.5090038776397705,
-0.19080482423305511,
0.1118260994553566,
0.8300506472587585,
0.7811156511306763,
-0.03131943568587303,
-0.4674488604068756,
0.4847911596298218,
0.25655195116996765,
0.05300271138548851,
0.590471088886261,
0.6409947872161865,
-0.16417160630226135,
0.6617245078086853,
-0.4380280375480652,
-0.0697399452328682,
-0.2600925862789154,
-0.770014762878418,
-0.6448453068733215,
-0.5098670721054077,
-0.3009447455406189,
-0.4700115919113159,
-0.1502685397863388,
0.4341883957386017,
0.28228065371513367,
-0.8397927284240723,
0.3338724970817566,
0.0861695259809494,
0.1853066086769104,
-0.24338498711585999,
-0.3406723439693451,
0.41118350625038147,
-0.4428509771823883,
-0.4189680814743042,
-0.12127116322517395,
0.4565395414829254,
0.018193958327174187,
-0.26487013697624207,
0.4180118143558502,
-0.06750988215208054,
0.34774884581565857,
0.5995780229568481,
0.16499708592891693,
-0.4276423156261444,
-0.6836627721786499,
-0.009701508097350597,
-0.6511185765266418,
-0.06772556900978088,
1.0159084796905518,
-0.6127650737762451,
0.10971087217330933,
0.5883591175079346,
0.4643653631210327,
0.2655293941497803,
-0.17810304462909698,
0.47555485367774963,
-1.1354176998138428,
0.41591891646385193,
0.1839708834886551,
0.2859751284122467,
0.4279785752296448,
-0.523216962814331,
0.43738389015197754,
0.31244078278541565,
-0.41308796405792236,
-0.665431022644043,
0.2640467584133148,
-1.2101867198944092,
-0.06529770791530609,
1.1580910682678223,
0.008021526038646698,
-0.3070957362651825,
-0.1783919781446457,
-0.1704409271478653,
-0.02049148641526699,
-0.24503298103809357,
0.8521527647972107,
0.8559419512748718,
0.13574659824371338,
-0.10862051695585251,
-0.646027147769928,
0.6447315812110901,
0.7463651299476624,
-0.26493915915489197,
0.03347036987543106,
0.02154109813272953,
0.17282633483409882,
0.49086809158325195,
0.18943670392036438,
-0.1232580617070198,
0.16450342535972595,
-0.21763356029987335,
-0.03753888979554176,
0.14871083199977875,
-0.22181440889835358,
-0.4779299795627594,
0.6062949895858765,
0.12228171527385712,
-0.17007459700107574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05964v2 | A Survey on Transformer Compression | 2024-02-05T12:16:28 | 2024-04-07T13:03:58 | Yehui Tang, Yunhe Wang, Jianyuan Guo, Zhijun Tu, Kai Han, Hailin Hu, Dacheng Tao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Transformer plays a vital role in the realms of natural language processing
(NLP) and computer vision (CV), specially for constructing large language
models (LLM) and large vision models (LVM). Model compression methods reduce
the memory and computational cost of Transformer, which is a necessary step to
implement large language/vision models on practical devices. Given the unique
architecture of Transformer, featuring alternative attention and feedforward
neural network (FFN) modules, specific compression techniques are usually
required. The efficiency of these compression methods is also paramount, as
retraining large models on the entire training dataset is usually impractical.
This survey provides a comprehensive review of recent compression methods, with
a specific focus on their application to Transformer-based models. The
compression methods are primarily categorized into pruning, quantization,
knowledge distillation, and efficient architecture design (Mamba, RetNet, RWKV,
etc.). In each category, we discuss compression methods for both language and
vision tasks, highlighting common underlying principles. Finally, we delve into
the relation between various compression methods, and discuss further
directions in this domain. | [
-0.6604203581809998,
-0.3306572437286377,
0.17936380207538605,
0.10815167427062988,
-0.04085329547524452,
-0.11620023846626282,
-0.23895302414894104,
-0.47771650552749634,
0.06630725413560867,
0.5011677145957947,
-0.5030983686447144,
-0.10266606509685516,
-0.6373683214187622,
0.1511276215314865,
-0.631158709526062,
0.38865864276885986,
0.07415752112865448,
-0.03912215679883957,
-0.24928602576255798,
0.10312134772539139,
-0.7072980403900146,
-0.6347596645355225,
-0.6275478005409241,
-0.2751326262950897,
0.3028774857521057,
-0.08568373322486877,
0.4294484555721283,
0.38449323177337646,
0.9002913236618042,
0.3826627731323242,
-0.38619786500930786,
0.05538005754351616,
-0.40725961327552795,
0.1389714628458023,
-0.011709005571901798,
-0.5712962746620178,
-0.008879432454705238,
-0.24786771833896637,
0.5508270859718323,
0.5688796043395996,
-0.16606420278549194,
0.32138144969940186,
0.07162097841501236,
0.7205575704574585,
-0.911001443862915,
0.26955556869506836,
-0.325065016746521,
0.3883383572101593,
-0.05512974411249161,
-0.14529162645339966,
-0.6483917832374573,
-0.3369229733943939,
-0.10617285966873169,
-0.13815081119537354,
0.6925069689750671,
0.12422427535057068,
0.7529280185699463,
0.8586539626121521,
-0.33426687121391296,
0.22381676733493805,
-0.9850318431854248,
0.8268865346908569,
-0.5058212876319885,
0.6689034700393677,
0.024843940511345863,
0.5141618847846985,
0.22578664124011993,
-0.7695180177688599,
-0.529395341873169,
0.10646402835845947,
-0.21169985830783844,
0.15140868723392487,
-0.458586186170578,
0.22172801196575165,
0.4343567490577698,
0.7918791770935059,
-0.37964966893196106,
0.18974420428276062,
-0.558907687664032,
-0.26337572932243347,
0.41842588782310486,
0.03766429424285889,
0.15966542065143585,
-0.15208299458026886,
-0.24158428609371185,
-0.7147940397262573,
-0.7857502698898315,
0.06215716898441315,
0.35373151302337646,
-0.13486216962337494,
0.24863122403621674,
0.5122469067573547,
-0.20890329778194427,
1.270652174949646,
-0.10998450219631195,
-0.2953419089317322,
0.013091472908854485,
-0.20467734336853027,
-0.4758914113044739,
-0.22606773674488068,
0.6330575346946716,
0.4363701641559601,
0.24226973950862885,
-0.29180529713630676,
-0.28121599555015564,
0.24063029885292053,
0.6653585433959961,
-0.6680688858032227,
-0.22581340372562408,
0.023070018738508224,
-0.599281370639801,
-0.4718968868255615,
0.12464196979999542,
-0.891067385673523,
-0.29786789417266846,
-0.3545704782009125,
0.2972486913204193,
-0.093461774289608,
-0.04351062327623367,
0.33554646372795105,
-0.31922367215156555,
0.6101647615432739,
0.17372652888298035,
-0.9346188306808472,
0.2533506453037262,
0.6509196162223816,
0.6692708730697632,
0.06775427609682083,
-0.0029420130886137486,
-0.4137135446071625,
-0.22081983089447021,
-0.06346695870161057,
0.885860800743103,
-0.15110863745212555,
-0.2779642641544342,
0.2706843316555023,
0.11907749623060226,
0.10789315402507782,
-0.5624816417694092,
0.9778408408164978,
-0.45340830087661743,
0.020411964505910873,
0.1524718552827835,
-0.36078155040740967,
-0.4895144999027252,
0.25091156363487244,
-1.0725163221359253,
0.7043429017066956,
0.18179842829704285,
-0.6020068526268005,
-0.006237156689167023,
-0.27229467034339905,
-0.4481348991394043,
-0.03877674415707588,
-0.07173188030719757,
-0.34488746523857117,
0.4801749289035797,
0.5770390629768372,
0.7903696894645691,
-0.7354703545570374,
0.1834491342306137,
0.2333446741104126,
-0.3429300785064697,
0.013770266436040401,
-0.5260898470878601,
0.4503221809864044,
0.06088314950466156,
0.0721832886338234,
-0.02004551701247692,
-0.5796461701393127,
-0.14366240799427032,
0.21887582540512085,
-0.23494194447994232,
0.018559059128165245,
-0.08931136131286621,
0.1352950632572174,
0.1740867793560028,
-0.008211889304220676,
-0.539043128490448,
0.4071466028690338,
-0.682780921459198,
0.6951178908348083,
0.5053164958953857,
-0.017811933532357216,
0.47286972403526306,
-0.1656111180782318,
0.5449147820472717,
-0.3245641589164734,
0.4878872334957123,
-0.3164842128753662,
-0.29349783062934875,
-1.0694366693496704,
0.17442995309829712,
0.43788984417915344,
0.665410578250885,
-0.8840650916099548,
0.5336544513702393,
-0.5571131706237793,
-0.7340151071548462,
-0.6151283979415894,
-0.2744409441947937,
0.11246981471776962,
0.3227483928203583,
0.4600144326686859,
-0.15411542356014252,
-0.48775428533554077,
-1.0504037141799927,
-0.1775698959827423,
0.02156931720674038,
-0.28924015164375305,
0.17212912440299988,
0.21166741847991943,
0.028318161144852638,
0.9295427203178406,
-0.8748025298118591,
-0.22772905230522156,
-0.3625797629356384,
0.1805768758058548,
0.25297945737838745,
0.4148336946964264,
0.6047223806381226,
-1.0562019348144531,
-0.169460728764534,
-0.2972956597805023,
-0.28257089853286743,
-0.10751619935035706,
-0.13263720273971558,
0.52359938621521,
0.006687772460281849,
0.3014535903930664,
-0.6476492881774902,
0.6120510697364807,
0.8709176778793335,
0.08918015658855438,
0.44093456864356995,
-0.05925286188721657,
0.20604169368743896,
-0.8058624863624573,
-0.09867838770151138,
0.055340953171253204,
-0.2619803547859192,
-0.8543148040771484,
0.2494688332080841,
0.14316940307617188,
-0.24750515818595886,
-0.6757137179374695,
0.19359809160232544,
-0.5373146533966064,
0.06261646747589111,
-0.4133050739765167,
-0.2885500192642212,
0.009494406171143055,
0.6543418169021606,
0.2159423679113388,
0.6153655648231506,
0.5746812224388123,
-0.5905057191848755,
0.7501841187477112,
0.3166860342025757,
-0.41490229964256287,
0.24956180155277252,
-0.9246170520782471,
0.2289905846118927,
-0.43727198243141174,
0.29239779710769653,
-0.6833601593971252,
-0.027242891490459442,
0.22662381827831268,
-0.11044145375490189,
0.6093579530715942,
-0.07469211518764496,
-0.5048873424530029,
-0.7230745553970337,
-0.2910372018814087,
0.6319180727005005,
0.7697997689247131,
-0.7489205002784729,
0.7573732733726501,
0.23097936809062958,
0.22148250043392181,
-0.7675116658210754,
-1.0343561172485352,
0.24491383135318756,
-0.2323913425207138,
-0.6246265172958374,
0.7200270891189575,
-0.08932561427354813,
-0.02115517109632492,
-0.19680102169513702,
-0.23695328831672668,
-0.06070011854171753,
-0.2877972722053528,
0.3063346743583679,
0.27378973364830017,
-0.020583132281899452,
-0.05480639636516571,
-0.37817302346229553,
-0.23584502935409546,
-0.10804092884063721,
-0.21197812259197235,
0.631220817565918,
0.02463906817138195,
-0.22007416188716888,
-0.3088535964488983,
0.36354097723960876,
0.25659996271133423,
-0.20464104413986206,
0.8183677196502686,
0.5793871879577637,
-0.21866144239902496,
-0.09053056687116623,
-0.7985944747924805,
-0.24365665018558502,
-0.43396681547164917,
0.09702982008457184,
-0.17191331088542938,
-1.124525547027588,
0.216457337141037,
-0.2936149537563324,
0.022313550114631653,
0.6228403449058533,
0.4488854706287384,
0.324882447719574,
0.6268605589866638,
0.9994460344314575,
-0.12169602513313293,
0.5463640093803406,
-0.34278616309165955,
0.589199960231781,
-0.761344313621521,
-0.04893907532095909,
-0.7164162397384644,
-0.5190980434417725,
-0.34916824102401733,
-0.7715314030647278,
0.18801052868366241,
-0.19439774751663208,
0.2265533059835434,
0.7375099658966064,
-1.0652716159820557,
0.6514729261398315,
0.4437868893146515,
-0.0991734191775322,
0.08976966142654419,
-0.11753882467746735,
0.5261350870132446,
0.13367845118045807,
-0.842332124710083,
-0.08064085990190506,
0.7796242237091064,
0.4292350709438324,
0.8775637745857239,
-0.056217536330223083,
0.3779810667037964,
0.0722125768661499,
0.018399711698293686,
-1.1725101470947266,
0.43039560317993164,
-0.22772760689258575,
-0.23825959861278534,
-0.09683610498905182,
-0.43361443281173706,
-0.859693706035614,
-0.016719890758395195,
-0.19851987063884735,
-0.589466392993927,
0.4551296830177307,
0.07154358923435211,
-0.32741254568099976,
0.46418657898902893,
-0.565670371055603,
0.48523885011672974,
0.061565522104501724,
0.08837118744850159,
0.012586614117026329,
-0.8339677453041077,
0.42339351773262024,
-0.05142974853515625,
-0.14115850627422333,
0.37582898139953613,
0.16623637080192566,
0.8656391501426697,
-0.3228462338447571,
0.730733335018158,
0.08377016335725784,
-0.042474620044231415,
0.3016950786113739,
-0.2519742250442505,
0.3995108902454376,
-0.37787705659866333,
0.399600088596344,
0.47490233182907104,
0.0240293238312006,
-0.04752322658896446,
-0.7812411189079285,
0.24965018033981323,
-0.40193259716033936,
-0.5039475560188293,
-0.201276496052742,
-0.4243122637271881,
-0.02399487979710102,
-0.13493680953979492,
0.5859898328781128,
0.6743388772010803,
-0.0735822468996048,
0.4137740731239319,
0.8419012427330017,
-0.33355772495269775,
0.5257569551467896,
0.04803461208939552,
0.016301864758133888,
-0.38892862200737,
0.6473418474197388,
0.008237216621637344,
0.1422601193189621,
0.9078661203384399,
0.006536101922392845,
-0.09550175815820694,
-0.5752127766609192,
0.008145730011165142,
0.1787068396806717,
-0.7807549834251404,
-0.8116600513458252,
-0.39384621381759644,
-0.5888670682907104,
-0.683370053768158,
-0.1676998883485794,
-0.5272916555404663,
-0.6267107129096985,
0.1623530089855194,
0.1677982360124588,
0.21024462580680847,
0.7663161158561707,
0.25066787004470825,
0.6484853029251099,
-0.9334559440612793,
0.4728357791900635,
0.4536409378051758,
0.20624472200870514,
0.018982546404004097,
-0.31014329195022583,
-0.2452034056186676,
-0.35160142183303833,
-0.29753321409225464,
-0.8911645412445068,
0.5631226301193237,
0.2272333949804306,
0.3867235779762268,
0.4238932728767395,
0.20688074827194214,
0.48472580313682556,
-0.7254653573036194,
1.0598522424697876,
0.36683303117752075,
-0.6728877425193787,
0.5588873624801636,
0.4094264507293701,
0.3807342052459717,
0.17259171605110168,
0.3120613396167755,
-0.7456322312355042,
-0.07565024495124817,
-0.5809429287910461,
-0.8766863346099854,
0.3715192973613739,
0.18638475239276886,
0.1403154730796814,
0.3096216320991516,
0.5142806768417358,
-0.21535643935203552,
0.01511293463408947,
-0.6972290277481079,
-0.26337361335754395,
-0.1550481617450714,
-0.38254639506340027,
-0.055797893553972244,
-0.25208887457847595,
-0.12341998517513275,
-0.22154870629310608,
0.34070107340812683,
-0.08770068734884262,
0.6320093274116516,
0.27789542078971863,
-0.16921015083789825,
0.30973586440086365,
0.26131734251976013,
0.3851501941680908,
-0.019639886915683746,
0.102857805788517,
0.22277574241161346,
0.19261038303375244,
-0.6001242399215698,
0.2608645260334015,
-0.1911253184080124,
-0.05797277390956879,
-0.143825501203537,
0.32262536883354187,
0.8904582262039185,
0.23304052650928497,
-0.5330154895782471,
0.6508603692054749,
-0.5094828605651855,
-0.284666508436203,
-0.153656467795372,
0.1846873164176941,
-0.2261728048324585,
0.26746872067451477,
0.12041084468364716,
0.35768771171569824,
0.2437799870967865,
-0.07201177626848221,
-0.2826363444328308,
0.24306102097034454,
-0.24831834435462952,
-0.15988869965076447,
0.42438286542892456,
0.06963682919740677,
-0.45999208092689514,
0.7529783844947815,
0.35748550295829773,
-0.4757339358329773,
0.35542914271354675,
0.45271989703178406,
0.9892382621765137,
-0.3506390452384949,
-0.27747729420661926,
0.5130650997161865,
0.46849653124809265,
-0.45056596398353577,
-0.23790587484836578,
-0.34973829984664917,
-0.7304623126983643,
-0.914844810962677,
-0.7475561499595642,
-0.3702084720134735,
0.055785730481147766,
-0.5662078857421875,
0.3997790217399597,
-0.04389386624097824,
-0.21147848665714264,
-0.0630621388554573,
-0.28528907895088196,
-0.7632642388343811,
0.2269141972064972,
0.3412305414676666,
1.2500239610671997,
-0.6566488742828369,
0.5917489528656006,
0.3992690443992615,
-0.30028262734413147,
-0.8802189826965332,
-0.14290224015712738,
-0.042085397988557816,
-0.44001325964927673,
0.5776187181472778,
0.21845459938049316,
-0.25482887029647827,
0.06037873774766922,
-0.5024117231369019,
-0.6501648426055908,
0.9296106696128845,
0.3344787657260895,
-0.5984205007553101,
-0.3057628273963928,
0.22265738248825073,
0.36534279584884644,
-0.026014739647507668,
-0.03328663855791092,
0.5470827221870422,
0.4656565189361572,
0.25245213508605957,
-0.6915719509124756,
-0.13247065246105194,
-0.26607227325439453,
0.2754814624786377,
0.4370499849319458,
-0.6405211687088013,
0.38926321268081665,
0.3890422284603119,
-0.2890598773956299,
-0.00489891367033124,
0.622456431388855,
-0.2994179427623749,
-0.20044724643230438,
0.6030940413475037,
0.5956537127494812,
0.3697231113910675,
-0.2804145812988281,
1.0302008390426636,
-0.47911447286605835,
0.4335368871688843,
0.628127932548523,
0.1721343845129013,
0.8164280652999878,
0.6757095456123352,
-0.25421273708343506,
0.0978790670633316,
0.34633663296699524,
-0.4238293170928955,
0.32935044169425964,
0.20352253317832947,
0.004764571785926819,
-0.09412693977355957,
-0.07129460573196411,
-0.15400345623493195,
0.5965184569358826,
0.010455912910401821,
-0.24958612024784088,
0.03266645967960358,
0.11014929413795471,
-0.2833375632762909,
-0.2212478071451187,
-0.31619545817375183,
0.6088529825210571,
0.06885287910699844,
-0.6975894570350647,
0.46290042996406555,
0.018144262954592705,
0.9207078814506531,
-0.5254898071289062,
0.15105408430099487,
0.13498808443546295,
-0.021004384383559227,
-0.10862933844327927,
-0.8519046306610107,
0.8054352402687073,
0.006499628070741892,
-0.25023531913757324,
-0.6736202239990234,
1.1251120567321777,
-0.12877951562404633,
-0.3115098178386688,
-0.11394016444683075,
0.24957776069641113,
0.10101883858442307,
-0.3211604654788971,
-0.22049731016159058,
0.11116031557321548,
-0.06622213870286942,
-0.33723556995391846,
-0.027852267026901245,
-0.04096691682934761,
0.4339177906513214,
0.6311970353126526,
0.4585520923137665,
0.19429293274879456,
0.029836537316441536,
0.19838137924671173,
0.9729278683662415,
-0.7302088737487793,
-0.24534212052822113,
-0.5669749975204468,
0.43456336855888367,
-0.09471378475427628,
0.016917798668146133,
0.47813594341278076,
0.264129638671875,
0.6106966733932495,
-0.3387284278869629,
0.32669976353645325,
0.005782605614513159,
0.10300350934267044,
-0.7051205039024353,
0.5530241131782532,
-0.37266644835472107,
-0.04913884773850441,
-0.10132400691509247,
-1.1456929445266724,
-0.7578417658805847,
0.736365556716919,
-0.16772893071174622,
-0.2764867842197418,
0.6305434107780457,
0.6184301972389221,
-0.06696755439043045,
0.11465909332036972,
0.3694111108779907,
-0.17696048319339752,
0.321874737739563,
0.6484653353691101,
0.7646622061729431,
-0.6968929171562195,
0.6845771074295044,
-0.45244935154914856,
0.015384701080620289,
-0.13907776772975922,
-1.0182455778121948,
-0.558842122554779,
-0.7791771292686462,
-0.44128987193107605,
0.11005401611328125,
-0.5542510747909546,
0.4770413637161255,
0.9972525238990784,
-0.4728621244430542,
0.08031368255615234,
-0.18652810156345367,
-0.1046447604894638,
-0.411609947681427,
-0.19109003245830536,
0.3119734227657318,
-0.10435322672128677,
-0.8244772553443909,
0.3591917157173157,
0.41003936529159546,
0.07039997726678848,
-0.49708521366119385,
0.22331158816814423,
0.2026320993900299,
-0.0032259090803563595,
0.5919076204299927,
0.259896844625473,
-0.5804768800735474,
-0.22659926116466522,
0.11793964356184006,
0.22335763275623322,
0.19189971685409546,
1.0563335418701172,
-1.1470520496368408,
0.20387229323387146,
0.8332279324531555,
0.7031369209289551,
0.5314814448356628,
-0.07012679427862167,
0.557752788066864,
-0.9273599982261658,
0.4210019111633301,
0.32639625668525696,
0.6272475719451904,
0.4700796902179718,
-0.3482034504413605,
0.6426466107368469,
0.17198510468006134,
-0.8658657670021057,
-0.655073344707489,
0.5448519587516785,
-1.1989065408706665,
-0.175709530711174,
0.9433670043945312,
0.040032368153333664,
-0.6441309452056885,
0.22379623353481293,
-0.40456250309944153,
0.3987197279930115,
0.15100693702697754,
0.63716059923172,
0.7246166467666626,
-0.10297954082489014,
-0.6125711798667908,
-0.506180465221405,
0.43436771631240845,
0.07012863457202911,
-0.7208287715911865,
0.032851990312337875,
0.3584509491920471,
-0.25897151231765747,
0.5443834066390991,
-0.13757944107055664,
0.08958200365304947,
-0.04300079122185707,
0.04035656154155731,
0.31974563002586365,
0.05939602106809616,
-0.40431949496269226,
-0.8347486257553101,
0.45490097999572754,
-0.23391039669513702,
0.03690168634057045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05128v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05128v2 | Enhancing Textbook Question Answering Task with Large Language Models and Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T11:58:56 | 2024-02-14T10:06:54 | Hessa Abdulrahman Alawwad, Areej Alhothali, Usman Naseem, Ali Alkhathlan, Amani Jamal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Textbook question answering (TQA) is a challenging task in artificial
intelligence due to the complex nature of context and multimodal data. Although
previous research has significantly improved the task, there are still some
limitations including the models' weak reasoning and inability to capture
contextual information in the lengthy context. The introduction of large
language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field of AI, however, directly
applying LLMs often leads to inaccurate answers. This paper proposes a
methodology that handle the out-of-domain scenario in TQA where concepts are
spread across different lessons by incorporating the retrieval augmented
generation (RAG) technique and utilize transfer learning to handle the long
context and enhance reasoning abilities. Through supervised fine-tuning of the
LLM model Llama-2 and the incorporation of RAG, our architecture outperforms
the baseline, achieving a 4.12% accuracy improvement on validation set and
9.84% on test set for non-diagram multiple-choice questions. | [
-0.4061765670776367,
-1.0424271821975708,
0.7221577763557434,
-0.2558446228504181,
-0.31119540333747864,
0.3224198520183563,
-0.0554315447807312,
-0.4056828022003174,
-0.1120520755648613,
0.5378687977790833,
-0.24401409924030304,
-0.07934476435184479,
-0.43226075172424316,
0.06794648617506027,
-0.18092259764671326,
0.9686785936355591,
-0.27273544669151306,
-0.01776045374572277,
-0.5724146366119385,
-0.09578036516904831,
-0.8367382287979126,
-0.4483649730682373,
-0.6916089057922363,
-0.336724191904068,
0.19413092732429504,
0.5873985290527344,
0.5685224533081055,
0.25291144847869873,
0.4761367440223694,
0.20041674375534058,
-0.27323678135871887,
0.697626531124115,
-0.42601847648620605,
0.10185080766677856,
-0.6253359913825989,
-0.43186116218566895,
-0.5547515153884888,
-0.4546499252319336,
0.7904230356216431,
0.45739248394966125,
-0.1131657138466835,
0.4925564229488373,
0.000018211643691756763,
0.6648448705673218,
-0.628455638885498,
0.08858742564916611,
-0.7804036736488342,
-0.3928408920764923,
-0.02451261691749096,
-0.26152780652046204,
-0.6155616044998169,
-0.20092709362506866,
0.04175661504268646,
-0.8123583197593689,
-0.0379633754491806,
-0.0669642984867096,
0.8222107291221619,
0.26806947588920593,
-0.694025456905365,
-0.3806954324245453,
-0.6934242844581604,
0.7775313854217529,
-0.5402831435203552,
0.2800661027431488,
0.4695960283279419,
0.408372700214386,
-0.3461346924304962,
-0.7139779329299927,
-0.708148717880249,
-0.108815498650074,
-0.08166434615850449,
0.059425096958875656,
0.16543292999267578,
-0.26065197587013245,
0.10668338090181351,
0.11878614872694016,
-0.290439248085022,
-0.056847404688596725,
-0.3723725378513336,
0.16127696633338928,
0.674109160900116,
0.09778420627117157,
0.2634267210960388,
-0.3889302909374237,
-0.4343031346797943,
-0.14609883725643158,
-0.5083586573600769,
0.08999503403902054,
-0.12575320899486542,
0.41062280535697937,
0.17265182733535767,
0.6008288860321045,
-0.07319562137126923,
0.8277980089187622,
0.08427875488996506,
-0.32962697744369507,
0.11426816135644913,
-0.23707939684391022,
-0.22305233776569366,
-0.13608233630657196,
0.16483096778392792,
0.19427470862865448,
0.14651824533939362,
-0.08263204991817474,
-0.24608521163463593,
-0.5009596347808838,
0.4154012203216553,
-0.610363781452179,
0.18531006574630737,
0.09621527791023254,
-0.12223925441503525,
-0.0027284848038107157,
-0.19651347398757935,
-0.8651842474937439,
-0.35094836354255676,
-0.6775836944580078,
0.7244116067886353,
-0.4172511398792267,
-0.07240935415029526,
-0.09937825053930283,
0.11558402329683304,
0.46703794598579407,
0.5907413363456726,
-0.6495003700256348,
0.27977749705314636,
0.7369878888130188,
0.5930414199829102,
-0.2883983552455902,
-0.0241490937769413,
-0.763158917427063,
0.5124213695526123,
-0.5651992559432983,
0.8937920928001404,
-0.6114206910133362,
-0.37118110060691833,
0.03392374515533447,
-0.039478790014982224,
0.0013055384624749422,
-0.5756303071975708,
0.4350973665714264,
-1.0431174039840698,
0.3226691484451294,
-0.05610978975892067,
-0.669978678226471,
-0.5243425369262695,
0.46141910552978516,
-0.39063242077827454,
1.2950043678283691,
0.4423507750034332,
-0.36701318621635437,
-0.15613630414009094,
-0.47845587134361267,
-0.3664534389972687,
-0.018759148195385933,
0.12437795847654343,
-0.36520397663116455,
-0.07038614898920059,
0.5147860050201416,
0.37629860639572144,
-0.5635479092597961,
0.5765840411186218,
0.12848708033561707,
-0.4614522159099579,
0.22085626423358917,
-0.1653796285390854,
0.5287620425224304,
0.19080330431461334,
-0.08489572256803513,
-0.13106349110603333,
-0.759994626045227,
0.1553817093372345,
0.09827666729688644,
-0.41357654333114624,
-0.6223079562187195,
-0.4049922525882721,
-0.18250586092472076,
0.15364181995391846,
0.3471774160861969,
-0.27267321944236755,
0.47822049260139465,
-0.2225167155265808,
0.030833430588245392,
0.700461745262146,
0.28873300552368164,
0.6618697047233582,
-0.6150895357131958,
0.622681200504303,
0.055406633764505386,
-0.0693330243229866,
0.029860053211450577,
-0.5450279116630554,
-0.7951822876930237,
-0.15401045978069305,
0.30364087224006653,
0.5789275169372559,
-1.372464656829834,
-0.030047986656427383,
-0.3252354562282562,
-0.5717791318893433,
-0.294344425201416,
0.3289406895637512,
0.4873327612876892,
0.7515222430229187,
0.6919094920158386,
-0.09626470506191254,
-0.30139926075935364,
-0.7137167453765869,
-0.08945665508508682,
-0.2568330466747284,
-0.008725177496671677,
0.5692574977874756,
0.42345741391181946,
-0.2806774079799652,
0.9258673787117004,
-0.6634994745254517,
-0.3919484317302704,
-0.36281222105026245,
-0.09355007857084274,
0.23238505423069,
0.42363348603248596,
0.3132117986679077,
-0.8348605036735535,
-0.43963852524757385,
0.13225184381008148,
-0.6637354493141174,
0.09784194082021713,
-0.28443026542663574,
-0.4871164858341217,
0.4638131260871887,
0.4513469934463501,
-0.6095349192619324,
0.12499366700649261,
0.2786876857280731,
-0.11870428174734116,
0.4218297600746155,
-0.24780401587486267,
0.1786152571439743,
-1.5822869539260864,
0.056143395602703094,
-0.1361619085073471,
-0.06373241543769836,
-0.5622939467430115,
0.34354302287101746,
0.20691511034965515,
-0.13435934484004974,
-0.5060391426086426,
0.9255349636077881,
-0.35764214396476746,
-0.07858674973249435,
-0.2905484139919281,
0.30226218700408936,
0.2383926808834076,
0.5453380942344666,
-0.09258022904396057,
1.1224548816680908,
0.24033088982105255,
-0.7103106379508972,
0.26744645833969116,
0.5410857200622559,
-0.14684626460075378,
0.3794403672218323,
-0.2956145107746124,
0.328655481338501,
-0.2976473271846771,
0.5144006609916687,
-0.8791753053665161,
-0.1864769011735916,
0.15468713641166687,
-0.34854015707969666,
0.5339783430099487,
-0.08879799395799637,
-0.42655763030052185,
-0.05031408742070198,
-0.1590893417596817,
0.61864173412323,
0.5819016098976135,
-0.7946195602416992,
1.0257328748703003,
0.2315562665462494,
-0.29928869009017944,
-0.7229164242744446,
-0.182706817984581,
-0.035549502819776535,
-0.17848140001296997,
-0.41362252831459045,
0.26456043124198914,
-0.05365514010190964,
-0.3720034658908844,
-0.22184410691261292,
-0.011297724209725857,
-0.33931654691696167,
-0.009407871402800083,
-0.1638772338628769,
0.4704979956150055,
-0.3182918131351471,
0.7303670644760132,
0.33003538846969604,
0.19025404751300812,
-0.06675135344266891,
-0.05907052382826805,
0.3944209814071655,
0.041342593729496,
0.015119517222046852,
-0.35283562541007996,
0.14472559094429016,
0.45658889412879944,
-0.25763919949531555,
0.6364238858222961,
0.2356707751750946,
-0.3053337335586548,
-0.4155627489089966,
-0.47479119896888733,
-0.13239562511444092,
-0.45280149579048157,
0.43331393599510193,
-0.5570884346961975,
-0.6623013019561768,
0.2912225127220154,
-0.2537381052970886,
0.04800168797373772,
0.3393303155899048,
0.43417149782180786,
-0.08496329933404922,
0.4957145154476166,
0.4846843481063843,
0.08416245877742767,
0.2966028153896332,
-0.2794974148273468,
0.0005192167009226978,
-1.1231781244277954,
-0.3148263394832611,
-0.5073590278625488,
-0.007890853099524975,
-0.39174094796180725,
-0.8403159976005554,
0.4628770351409912,
0.4507623314857483,
-0.4937073290348053,
0.07828696072101593,
-0.36942335963249207,
0.4889025092124939,
0.6355412602424622,
0.29059505462646484,
0.5347573757171631,
0.07695572078227997,
0.18117853999137878,
0.35282233357429504,
-0.5855069756507874,
-0.6063997745513916,
1.2049980163574219,
0.24443992972373962,
0.5517585277557373,
0.4662303924560547,
0.5063226819038391,
0.2068508118391037,
0.5532669425010681,
-0.835931122303009,
0.622032880783081,
-0.12546950578689575,
-0.6505112648010254,
-0.5321499705314636,
-0.24116399884223938,
-0.675909698009491,
0.33200883865356445,
-0.23246745765209198,
-0.4301541745662689,
-0.0034085523802787066,
-0.018191494047641754,
-0.17814649641513824,
0.338035523891449,
-0.6207101345062256,
0.4302915632724762,
-0.059255678206682205,
-0.4015920162200928,
0.07370682805776596,
-0.5256364345550537,
0.5061582326889038,
-0.48434287309646606,
0.3351972997188568,
0.1955343782901764,
-0.17087040841579437,
0.6471944451332092,
-0.19428133964538574,
0.6458137631416321,
0.0697556734085083,
-0.539574921131134,
0.6464139223098755,
0.23728448152542114,
0.728702187538147,
0.24363912642002106,
-0.3139912486076355,
-0.093843974173069,
-0.01699562557041645,
-0.40174180269241333,
-0.9200466275215149,
0.5178134441375732,
-0.8654195070266724,
-0.9510293006896973,
-0.36816367506980896,
-0.9282256364822388,
-0.7325217723846436,
0.01819998398423195,
-0.2296663075685501,
0.5697048902511597,
0.15527817606925964,
-0.09209433943033218,
0.637229859828949,
-0.3464442789554596,
0.25396448373794556,
0.459454745054245,
-0.18260933458805084,
-0.44591623544692993,
1.000615119934082,
-0.058340251445770264,
0.4604959487915039,
0.5870141386985779,
0.20639848709106445,
-0.5040477514266968,
-0.48069241642951965,
-0.981153666973114,
0.41554421186447144,
-0.9394518136978149,
-0.4687170088291168,
-0.49361705780029297,
-0.2349863201379776,
-0.5254575610160828,
-0.17142054438591003,
-0.04938714578747749,
-0.45329493284225464,
-0.5277132391929626,
0.11871791630983353,
0.4298021197319031,
0.7718970775604248,
0.24419079720973969,
0.1599324494600296,
-1.1019002199172974,
0.5491503477096558,
0.5713918805122375,
0.11562364548444748,
0.22230839729309082,
-1.0666385889053345,
-0.025132659822702408,
0.019457900896668434,
-0.47088292241096497,
-0.5542826652526855,
0.2597944438457489,
0.2780674695968628,
0.23840834200382233,
-0.08659707754850388,
0.3482900857925415,
0.7399353981018066,
-0.5924891233444214,
0.7356061935424805,
-0.08410336077213287,
-0.9117869138717651,
0.46938320994377136,
-0.3500007092952728,
0.24998338520526886,
0.3632628619670868,
0.4057864248752594,
-0.246127188205719,
-0.28881028294563293,
-0.48624187707901,
-0.658455491065979,
0.625511646270752,
-0.006745954509824514,
0.36924758553504944,
0.16138315200805664,
0.7828772664070129,
0.1869376003742218,
-0.03466500714421272,
-0.3902954161167145,
-0.1546190083026886,
0.02399718388915062,
-0.1803845316171646,
-0.2932594120502472,
-0.4008685052394867,
0.008205675520002842,
-0.2740379571914673,
1.1013987064361572,
-0.330049604177475,
-0.1870540827512741,
0.2292836755514145,
-0.054712217301130295,
-0.1203911080956459,
0.46093669533729553,
0.6622223854064941,
1.0181559324264526,
-0.08315257728099823,
0.021359344944357872,
0.5662713050842285,
-0.4837966561317444,
0.3406813442707062,
0.10562305152416229,
-0.23755453526973724,
-0.12667147815227509,
0.3160848319530487,
0.3547215163707733,
-0.16348272562026978,
-0.8740863800048828,
0.22265753149986267,
0.11784319579601288,
0.024769876152276993,
-0.4016806483268738,
-0.04875332862138748,
0.13043853640556335,
0.3864940404891968,
0.5788905024528503,
-0.32878702878952026,
0.07343190908432007,
-0.5465593338012695,
0.22426217794418335,
0.3588341772556305,
-0.08468598127365112,
0.1914670467376709,
0.4183286130428314,
0.12345615774393082,
-0.3266848623752594,
0.6324189901351929,
-0.01643371395766735,
-0.47560080885887146,
0.816926896572113,
0.7603157162666321,
0.3157268762588501,
-0.18396621942520142,
0.3994238078594208,
0.4983377158641815,
0.10700904577970505,
0.038457367569208145,
0.11861412227153778,
-0.009910516440868378,
-0.6202982664108276,
-0.5968014001846313,
-0.7423012256622314,
-0.6500363349914551,
0.029875341802835464,
-0.6668234467506409,
0.27960333228111267,
-0.22046853601932526,
0.14084932208061218,
-0.22898174822330475,
0.089240163564682,
-0.2499406486749649,
0.47768765687942505,
0.0020793115254491568,
0.7965548634529114,
-0.415814608335495,
0.8723359107971191,
0.9912086129188538,
-0.3437259793281555,
-1.0029093027114868,
0.09797753393650055,
-0.5178348422050476,
-0.6353932023048401,
0.9805293679237366,
-0.1554216593503952,
-0.07604362815618515,
0.1868167519569397,
-0.4112740457057953,
-1.024255394935608,
1.0035433769226074,
0.3009188175201416,
-0.39187300205230713,
-0.016113366931676865,
0.1614435762166977,
0.6176727414131165,
-0.10238561034202576,
0.10335028171539307,
0.5332518219947815,
0.24064823985099792,
0.4960639178752899,
-0.9222992062568665,
0.1641007512807846,
0.007112530525773764,
0.0938602089881897,
0.2514231503009796,
-0.6087243556976318,
0.8201106786727905,
-0.38123467564582825,
0.03904082253575325,
0.30872634053230286,
0.7595925331115723,
0.521048903465271,
0.5631060004234314,
0.38091355562210083,
0.4643072783946991,
0.6867402195930481,
0.20494429767131805,
1.168606162071228,
0.039780184626579285,
0.3798348009586334,
1.3497767448425293,
-0.2986757159233093,
1.0663518905639648,
0.5300102233886719,
-0.010403788648545742,
0.5590015649795532,
0.5568186044692993,
0.34980887174606323,
0.35468533635139465,
0.237590029835701,
-0.3647170066833496,
-0.4849875271320343,
-0.3380795121192932,
-0.46466925740242004,
0.561521589756012,
0.33056849241256714,
-0.10667574405670166,
-0.26144924759864807,
0.12172509729862213,
-0.09672833234071732,
0.3068506121635437,
-0.566177487373352,
0.956820011138916,
0.09431315213441849,
-0.8584842085838318,
0.9693388938903809,
-0.02301119826734066,
0.35994523763656616,
-0.3434700071811676,
-0.47001615166664124,
-0.4986395537853241,
0.22157792747020721,
0.07133409380912781,
-0.7763996720314026,
0.07573945075273514,
-0.06669747829437256,
-0.2110481560230255,
0.05718250945210457,
0.6097801327705383,
-0.39250755310058594,
-0.7133932113647461,
-0.006852565798908472,
0.7691225409507751,
0.06415342539548874,
0.23686382174491882,
-0.4377363324165344,
-0.282245934009552,
-0.1916758269071579,
-0.10254353284835815,
0.38325047492980957,
0.5861815810203552,
-0.3841024935245514,
0.8159539103507996,
0.6614760160446167,
-0.17376460134983063,
-0.21237269043922424,
-0.1283845156431198,
1.0538907051086426,
-0.48809003829956055,
-0.287560373544693,
-0.5042238235473633,
0.2008577436208725,
0.04514698311686516,
-0.22118927538394928,
0.627740204334259,
0.42653027176856995,
0.8611183762550354,
-0.13061130046844482,
0.42184221744537354,
0.19253718852996826,
0.7707065939903259,
-0.6563884019851685,
0.5982755422592163,
-0.9044612646102905,
0.23170340061187744,
-0.3751755952835083,
-0.9943121075630188,
-0.2656328082084656,
0.2652251720428467,
-0.1950874924659729,
0.028970319777727127,
0.652692973613739,
0.5819061994552612,
0.07834699749946594,
-0.0892508327960968,
0.34894299507141113,
0.09604418277740479,
0.4283128082752228,
0.6729989647865295,
0.8818453550338745,
-0.6062180995941162,
0.5183863043785095,
-0.2771854102611542,
-0.14847750961780548,
-0.08332318067550659,
-0.6719538569450378,
-0.9897427558898926,
-0.6372522711753845,
-0.2078244388103485,
-0.47266536951065063,
0.15316152572631836,
0.789030134677887,
0.2949703335762024,
-0.7559570074081421,
-0.11490140110254288,
0.28627046942710876,
0.29320383071899414,
-0.09724210202693939,
-0.245347797870636,
0.8081009387969971,
-0.5685948133468628,
-0.9086998701095581,
0.31355416774749756,
-0.18929508328437805,
0.07149452716112137,
-0.005568490829318762,
0.054450660943984985,
-0.4690353572368622,
0.33169668912887573,
0.905480682849884,
0.060861118137836456,
-0.5114784836769104,
-0.41924187541007996,
0.02426004223525524,
-0.015599747188389301,
0.0074881925247609615,
0.577006459236145,
-0.9297977685928345,
0.367250919342041,
0.3682660162448883,
1.1535875797271729,
0.26733866333961487,
0.503122866153717,
0.3785381317138672,
-0.7051573395729065,
-0.08089722692966461,
0.27326834201812744,
0.11134670674800873,
0.3514944612979889,
-0.5029939413070679,
0.6284316182136536,
-0.013871163129806519,
-0.5411475896835327,
-0.9268626570701599,
0.023265104740858078,
-0.947838306427002,
-0.7076796293258667,
1.3706666231155396,
0.05475617200136185,
-0.25958251953125,
-0.26227107644081116,
-0.5497857928276062,
0.3701874613761902,
-0.21087557077407837,
0.9158974289894104,
0.5678682327270508,
-0.12737607955932617,
-0.04191982373595238,
-0.539527952671051,
0.3893451690673828,
0.47106271982192993,
-1.1925078630447388,
-0.025835903361439705,
0.5677754878997803,
0.20976956188678741,
0.29649022221565247,
0.38858649134635925,
0.12237817049026489,
0.41572892665863037,
-0.49280866980552673,
-0.129865825176239,
-0.22812633216381073,
-0.34993860125541687,
-0.23217755556106567,
0.25215885043144226,
0.08616313338279724,
-0.1709587424993515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02926v1 | Automated Cognate Detection as a Supervised Link Prediction Task with Cognate Transformer | 2024-02-05T11:47:36 | 2024-02-05T11:47:36 | V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7 | Identification of cognates across related languages is one of the primary
problems in historical linguistics. Automated cognate identification is helpful
for several downstream tasks including identifying sound correspondences,
proto-language reconstruction, phylogenetic classification, etc. Previous
state-of-the-art methods for cognate identification are mostly based on
distributions of phonemes computed across multilingual wordlists and make
little use of the cognacy labels that define links among cognate clusters. In
this paper, we present a transformer-based architecture inspired by
computational biology for the task of automated cognate detection. Beyond a
certain amount of supervision, this method performs better than the existing
methods, and shows steady improvement with further increase in supervision,
thereby proving the efficacy of utilizing the labeled information. We also
demonstrate that accepting multiple sequence alignments as input and having an
end-to-end architecture with link prediction head saves much computation time
while simultaneously yielding superior performance. | [
-0.5665766596794128,
-0.672056257724762,
0.2919018268585205,
0.14153985679149628,
-0.1956787109375,
0.008496290072798729,
-0.27830132842063904,
-0.8483794927597046,
0.48965179920196533,
-0.007045193109661341,
-0.8466243743896484,
-0.382118284702301,
-0.5541648268699646,
0.48328977823257446,
-0.5412320494651794,
0.6900718212127686,
0.47005173563957214,
0.022600308060646057,
-0.2611079812049866,
0.061197828501462936,
-0.31891611218452454,
-0.23895493149757385,
-0.7553020119667053,
-0.33381348848342896,
0.5922921895980835,
0.29935938119888306,
0.6394078135490417,
1.1004010438919067,
0.7441249489784241,
0.3810970187187195,
-0.2924738824367523,
0.18286913633346558,
-0.38756808638572693,
0.24964472651481628,
-0.02290981449186802,
-0.5004913210868835,
-0.41214266419410706,
-0.16838853061199188,
0.21267089247703552,
0.6861010193824768,
0.10086580365896225,
0.18981000781059265,
-0.10174663364887238,
0.3119012713432312,
-0.5069624781608582,
0.4232206642627716,
-0.6215065121650696,
0.1032809391617775,
-0.5769670605659485,
-0.327126145362854,
-0.6986340880393982,
-0.1906096190214157,
0.2713869512081146,
-0.6399935483932495,
0.31521227955818176,
0.33364352583885193,
0.832709014415741,
0.4650389850139618,
-0.08960928022861481,
-0.6546455025672913,
-0.567931056022644,
0.5431360602378845,
-0.20318564772605896,
0.662865161895752,
0.258889764547348,
0.4665098488330841,
-0.47313761711120605,
-0.4043886959552765,
-0.3521686792373657,
-0.12107402086257935,
-0.5023001432418823,
0.13368262350559235,
-0.22629906237125397,
-0.13287033140659332,
-0.07210954278707504,
0.4273392856121063,
-0.7084057927131653,
0.09356409311294556,
-0.2634819447994232,
-0.518610954284668,
0.4318729341030121,
-0.2185494750738144,
0.4342030882835388,
0.07035388797521591,
-0.20129628479480743,
-0.30033570528030396,
-0.5397577285766602,
-0.051136843860149384,
0.3590664267539978,
0.29033228754997253,
-0.14055298268795013,
0.1078001856803894,
-0.013397247530519962,
0.6967331767082214,
0.4911637008190155,
-0.07596022635698318,
0.38464057445526123,
-0.10072945058345795,
0.13388288021087646,
0.38945233821868896,
0.9282821416854858,
-0.31615060567855835,
0.20959559082984924,
-0.31672582030296326,
0.32687416672706604,
0.2940630316734314,
0.1124352291226387,
-0.5269109010696411,
-0.49546051025390625,
0.09225504100322723,
-0.2597062289714813,
-0.20600779354572296,
-0.1587740033864975,
-0.8614976406097412,
0.0889752209186554,
-0.08112923055887222,
0.12375650554895401,
-0.546493411064148,
-0.03327682986855507,
-0.061238180845975876,
-0.22578981518745422,
0.42948803305625916,
0.15525949001312256,
-1.0665061473846436,
0.3184402287006378,
0.7236983776092529,
0.784128725528717,
-0.5229393243789673,
-0.07982218265533447,
-0.7215057611465454,
0.21046261489391327,
-0.1494750827550888,
0.8236833810806274,
-0.6966630220413208,
-0.3169987201690674,
-0.32405123114585876,
0.31582462787628174,
-0.08014728873968124,
-0.5092069506645203,
0.5390238761901855,
-0.6200582981109619,
0.1341993659734726,
-0.05985833704471588,
-0.611026406288147,
-0.16216649115085602,
0.07157202810049057,
-0.9322612881660461,
0.8031435608863831,
-0.10386017709970474,
-0.7149233222007751,
0.16986848413944244,
-0.5625908374786377,
-0.5158233046531677,
0.447325736284256,
-0.15218542516231537,
-0.8386357426643372,
-0.32896408438682556,
0.260517418384552,
0.32989954948425293,
-0.17574220895767212,
0.6630496382713318,
-0.28790345788002014,
-0.38031330704689026,
-0.04423622414469719,
-0.22963444888591766,
1.0570976734161377,
-0.04303079843521118,
-0.38039544224739075,
0.11362354457378387,
-0.9856119155883789,
-0.2959752082824707,
-0.10533353686332703,
-0.1535443812608719,
-0.40570536255836487,
0.10052332282066345,
-0.1679447442293167,
-0.08659732341766357,
0.1322193443775177,
-0.6871450543403625,
0.1283922642469406,
-0.3658348023891449,
0.14128482341766357,
0.2634306848049164,
-0.15405097603797913,
0.4731462001800537,
-0.057992734014987946,
0.3964107036590576,
-0.08713448792695999,
0.07609652727842331,
-0.33648115396499634,
-0.8651466965675354,
-0.8399206399917603,
-0.46782997250556946,
0.11614079773426056,
0.6213597059249878,
-0.46302124857902527,
0.8173065781593323,
-0.3522431552410126,
-0.72459477186203,
-0.2979373037815094,
-0.10686396807432175,
0.5207778811454773,
0.5704625844955444,
0.9459440112113953,
-0.15106458961963654,
-0.768622636795044,
-0.8749244809150696,
-0.23900936543941498,
-0.16425618529319763,
-0.05635451897978783,
0.22627626359462738,
0.5012593865394592,
-0.26928266882896423,
1.0251729488372803,
-0.489265501499176,
-0.3008401095867157,
0.14434783160686493,
0.08638273924589157,
0.2327134907245636,
0.6176661252975464,
0.46883776783943176,
-0.7766177654266357,
-0.4872785210609436,
0.2879476845264435,
-0.7369799017906189,
-0.4318578243255615,
0.03024379350244999,
-0.22565414011478424,
-0.39048197865486145,
0.684802770614624,
-0.1215415820479393,
0.12086713314056396,
0.7545354962348938,
-0.10673900693655014,
0.4458158314228058,
0.04216792434453964,
-0.24871544539928436,
-1.089980125427246,
0.1295056790113449,
0.11669983714818954,
-0.09712065756320953,
-0.7303985357284546,
-0.10376139730215073,
0.11469003558158875,
0.11959628760814667,
-0.2342434525489807,
0.203432098031044,
-0.45185622572898865,
0.023603307083249092,
0.08220218867063522,
-0.27500325441360474,
-0.2961079180240631,
0.5033780932426453,
0.3324773609638214,
0.697018563747406,
0.48447030782699585,
-0.34097564220428467,
0.6009997129440308,
0.5847112536430359,
0.1660948246717453,
0.39255085587501526,
-0.5251808762550354,
0.2903869152069092,
0.005451332312077284,
0.4632241725921631,
-1.0200440883636475,
-0.21148331463336945,
0.20664487779140472,
-0.5232006311416626,
0.21006369590759277,
-0.22025901079177856,
0.07636088132858276,
-0.40993204712867737,
-0.01129110623151064,
0.6344947814941406,
0.3668960630893707,
-0.934329092502594,
0.510362446308136,
0.3796056807041168,
-0.208029106259346,
-0.40373682975769043,
-0.46180832386016846,
0.18774797022342682,
-0.2413344532251358,
-0.710261881351471,
0.5503222346305847,
0.13338473439216614,
0.09264655411243439,
-0.3046185076236725,
0.13521189987659454,
-0.43210452795028687,
-0.11226284503936768,
0.4288540482521057,
0.5090034008026123,
-0.15633085370063782,
0.29810070991516113,
0.16091810166835785,
-0.4161699414253235,
-0.007032997906208038,
-0.43629100918769836,
0.557841420173645,
-0.0949731096625328,
-0.3600592613220215,
-0.6022380590438843,
0.4005372226238251,
0.585059404373169,
-0.46483615040779114,
0.3563084900379181,
0.7461289167404175,
-0.20092730224132538,
-0.1264810413122177,
-0.45320260524749756,
-0.11268426477909088,
-0.5376352071762085,
0.1744098961353302,
-0.3079514801502228,
-0.6891853213310242,
0.3037431538105011,
-0.4303620159626007,
-0.46294382214546204,
0.4714921712875366,
0.3903195261955261,
-0.13905099034309387,
0.44489797949790955,
0.6911060214042664,
-0.2971811890602112,
0.38863569498062134,
-0.23106853663921356,
0.25364813208580017,
-0.5430943369865417,
-0.45460036396980286,
-0.8195667266845703,
-0.3052839934825897,
-0.7112361192703247,
-0.5196092128753662,
0.5652890205383301,
-0.17851395905017853,
0.20484861731529236,
1.0484564304351807,
-0.6069663166999817,
0.19920526444911957,
0.6665729880332947,
0.11930190771818161,
0.5437758564949036,
-0.1428527683019638,
-0.3356096148490906,
0.17560140788555145,
-0.626328706741333,
-0.3057108223438263,
0.6660269498825073,
0.1477171927690506,
0.7509973049163818,
-0.15199577808380127,
0.9189742207527161,
0.13978710770606995,
0.12044354528188705,
-1.04901921749115,
0.5142398476600647,
-0.11321080476045609,
-0.26013967394828796,
-0.29894545674324036,
-0.17110370099544525,
-0.983659029006958,
0.06564869731664658,
-0.3573254346847534,
-0.6189624071121216,
0.5940019488334656,
0.3469557762145996,
-0.057978078722953796,
-0.037312451750040054,
-0.41060930490493774,
0.6551079154014587,
-0.13272063434123993,
-0.3896658420562744,
-0.04704313725233078,
-0.816200315952301,
0.06765931099653244,
-0.33558979630470276,
0.16896595060825348,
0.20678295195102692,
0.17510131001472473,
0.8092352747917175,
-0.5190680027008057,
0.6668223142623901,
0.14594075083732605,
-0.21790778636932373,
0.28319108486175537,
-0.15921026468276978,
0.5567454099655151,
-0.2886248230934143,
-0.09636981785297394,
0.4221303164958954,
0.06693603843450546,
-0.17825326323509216,
-0.051392022520303726,
0.4636428952217102,
-0.3493262529373169,
-0.28395459055900574,
-0.04795003682374954,
-0.748712956905365,
-0.1352839320898056,
0.2492658793926239,
0.42336177825927734,
0.3337344229221344,
-0.23884674906730652,
0.27516651153564453,
0.498465895652771,
-0.22640864551067352,
0.823743462562561,
0.23641017079353333,
0.08026215434074402,
-0.2946079969406128,
0.7612376809120178,
-0.2736338973045349,
0.011431372724473476,
0.4914894998073578,
0.3601735234260559,
-0.32052698731422424,
-0.25173553824424744,
-0.6612149477005005,
-0.019882507622241974,
-0.3175915777683258,
-0.1867171972990036,
-0.6192360520362854,
-0.03046981431543827,
-0.06988020241260529,
-0.22703689336776733,
-0.2953987717628479,
-0.06544710695743561,
-0.07831350713968277,
0.3415316939353943,
0.34057387709617615,
0.5593772530555725,
0.1200018972158432,
0.4609869122505188,
-0.8135545253753662,
0.33005523681640625,
0.307253897190094,
0.227376788854599,
-0.1972557008266449,
-0.022500954568386078,
-0.12416969239711761,
-0.1014290302991867,
-0.09636042267084122,
-1.124541997909546,
0.36202096939086914,
0.6387147903442383,
0.35605454444885254,
0.435459166765213,
-0.1897137612104416,
0.8301751613616943,
-0.7487897872924805,
0.21997997164726257,
0.23930449783802032,
-0.8942000865936279,
0.4433062672615051,
-0.36235445737838745,
0.23931168019771576,
0.31175071001052856,
0.6237697601318359,
-0.351498544216156,
-0.4837784469127655,
-0.3783031702041626,
-0.5528151392936707,
0.2825443148612976,
0.22923703491687775,
-0.3438488245010376,
-0.18446822464466095,
0.16456422209739685,
0.3285631537437439,
-0.15018746256828308,
-0.32429006695747375,
0.012848666869103909,
0.27588188648223877,
-0.3353906571865082,
0.09479294717311859,
0.18023599684238434,
0.21305665373802185,
-0.43234142661094666,
0.6282490491867065,
-0.357185959815979,
0.2751740515232086,
0.2386549562215805,
-0.3571898937225342,
-0.24877327680587769,
0.3043805956840515,
0.1974896490573883,
0.1783033013343811,
0.02922886237502098,
0.06571294367313385,
0.14838771522045135,
-0.6848583817481995,
0.22989332675933838,
0.09794402122497559,
-0.22658281028270721,
0.30214208364486694,
0.610925018787384,
0.5383710861206055,
0.10410104691982269,
-0.3978373110294342,
0.5011786222457886,
0.18140895664691925,
0.1080973744392395,
-0.3382717967033386,
0.0755210742354393,
0.42188307642936707,
0.3248286545276642,
0.4007585644721985,
0.3727496564388275,
0.3028119206428528,
-0.4529218077659607,
0.5839146375656128,
0.5402572154998779,
-0.4993709921836853,
-0.35718509554862976,
0.6887719631195068,
0.3199164867401123,
-0.5867659449577332,
0.4688170552253723,
-0.1407705694437027,
-0.674787163734436,
0.8452779054641724,
0.6852553486824036,
0.7866648435592651,
-0.6345295310020447,
-0.1751154661178589,
0.4162748456001282,
-0.10589281469583511,
-0.04645184054970741,
-0.06676346808671951,
-0.23732982575893402,
-0.7048367857933044,
-0.5393587946891785,
-0.9543914794921875,
-0.36076220870018005,
-0.16934487223625183,
-0.8424055576324463,
0.5684935450553894,
0.06370794773101807,
0.057939574122428894,
0.3775443732738495,
-0.5635700225830078,
-0.37364956736564636,
0.18310695886611938,
0.4065912663936615,
0.8250365853309631,
-1.1230264902114868,
1.1033743619918823,
0.4025002121925354,
-0.06463378667831421,
-0.6207987070083618,
-0.21000120043754578,
0.29600197076797485,
-0.7482464909553528,
0.773115336894989,
0.3301023542881012,
-0.6838815212249756,
0.26252490282058716,
-0.236211895942688,
-0.8481858372688293,
1.074256181716919,
0.36067286133766174,
-0.9480428695678711,
-0.21999725699424744,
0.06375262141227722,
0.7615925073623657,
-0.26544463634490967,
0.3782261610031128,
0.5689302682876587,
0.4132751524448395,
0.473548948764801,
-1.099565863609314,
-0.029381342232227325,
-0.3449247479438782,
-0.29001888632774353,
0.34523892402648926,
-0.2910500168800354,
0.7275446653366089,
-0.07004261761903763,
-0.19074685871601105,
0.08203701674938202,
0.5481264591217041,
-0.08188612759113312,
0.08832172304391861,
0.5913779735565186,
0.5479033589363098,
0.720393717288971,
-0.20284545421600342,
0.5149673223495483,
-0.5346812605857849,
0.5460538268089294,
1.1886487007141113,
0.13160862028598785,
0.9109532833099365,
0.5370231866836548,
-0.30788710713386536,
0.7432126998901367,
0.5652576684951782,
-0.43546128273010254,
0.3090469539165497,
0.25622498989105225,
-0.17861907184123993,
-0.1357453614473343,
-0.22880084812641144,
-0.348523885011673,
0.7648799419403076,
0.48164868354797363,
-0.4299198389053345,
-0.23628534376621246,
-0.32102644443511963,
-0.1263197362422943,
-0.06951841711997986,
-0.09209524095058441,
0.8371196985244751,
-0.2586832344532013,
-0.6954335570335388,
0.6345453858375549,
-0.4795821011066437,
0.9137536883354187,
-0.4599964916706085,
-0.27054667472839355,
0.1947268843650818,
0.26003116369247437,
-0.4667315185070038,
-0.300886869430542,
0.509887158870697,
-0.2982674539089203,
0.015013364143669605,
-0.10578823834657669,
0.9070020318031311,
-0.8478626608848572,
-0.3742096424102783,
0.7115371227264404,
0.5572458505630493,
0.08395133167505264,
0.11534439027309418,
-0.20896682143211365,
-0.002552303019911051,
-0.3123616874217987,
0.17104403674602509,
-0.14843343198299408,
-0.05448018014431,
-0.26221519708633423,
0.7215265035629272,
0.7032860517501831,
0.025868240743875504,
0.2548361122608185,
-0.26266252994537354,
0.584101676940918,
-0.482023149728775,
-0.6717149615287781,
-1.0266355276107788,
0.0036554383113980293,
-0.12860487401485443,
0.07024157047271729,
0.5148020386695862,
0.7252752184867859,
0.9078789949417114,
-0.28566625714302063,
0.5774801969528198,
-0.12747447192668915,
0.23886190354824066,
-0.02423730492591858,
0.5995702147483826,
-0.1792016625404358,
0.09515023231506348,
-0.35210731625556946,
-0.7514395713806152,
-0.4046652019023895,
0.5440908074378967,
-0.20225875079631805,
-0.408052921295166,
0.8900012969970703,
0.9275643825531006,
-0.37673208117485046,
0.40790507197380066,
0.12570707499980927,
-0.037445321679115295,
0.19950950145721436,
0.6492722034454346,
0.47808560729026794,
-0.3275667726993561,
0.6373963356018066,
-0.3282402455806732,
-0.15579786896705627,
-0.23654800653457642,
-0.8567368984222412,
-0.7696635127067566,
-0.6484443545341492,
-0.17072775959968567,
0.009076066315174103,
0.20442023873329163,
0.9451947212219238,
0.7233582139015198,
-1.089472770690918,
-0.446542352437973,
-0.33161938190460205,
-0.3982630968093872,
-0.4049457013607025,
-0.1241312175989151,
0.4410684406757355,
-0.3315763473510742,
-0.8152049779891968,
0.6166783571243286,
0.6702597737312317,
-0.21212689578533173,
-0.09890791773796082,
-0.01247622724622488,
-0.658195436000824,
-0.4254603683948517,
0.4206376075744629,
0.27525797486305237,
-0.6624609231948853,
-0.3186221420764923,
0.04217908903956413,
-0.08759765326976776,
0.4232776165008545,
0.519092857837677,
-0.8522099256515503,
0.5408496856689453,
0.646125853061676,
0.8858003616333008,
0.5026840567588806,
0.044410496950149536,
0.7058581709861755,
-0.5257494449615479,
0.18119563162326813,
0.0935373455286026,
0.46708425879478455,
0.2812674045562744,
-0.5424230098724365,
0.5390525460243225,
0.47239211201667786,
-0.2404506653547287,
-0.13185587525367737,
0.24474017322063446,
-1.2321665287017822,
0.1466953009366989,
0.8230297565460205,
-0.2938068211078644,
-0.5273033976554871,
-0.5147300362586975,
-0.12222801148891449,
0.6704390048980713,
-0.21166019141674042,
0.6216772794723511,
0.29709091782569885,
-0.1839834302663803,
0.06631093472242355,
-0.129936084151268,
0.4568684697151184,
0.36420613527297974,
-0.8899038434028625,
-0.4060050845146179,
0.31519815325737,
0.1926141232252121,
0.6604554653167725,
0.18217705190181732,
-0.03467753902077675,
0.1831810176372528,
-0.13808444142341614,
0.024143679067492485,
-0.002129365922883153,
-0.30985337495803833,
-0.1923268586397171,
0.2101142704486847,
-0.38468727469444275,
-0.43318939208984375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02915v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02915v1 | A Computational Model for the Assessment of Mutual Intelligibility Among Closely Related Languages | 2024-02-05T11:32:13 | 2024-02-05T11:32:13 | Jessica Nieder, Johann-Mattis List | cs.CL | cs.CL | Closely related languages show linguistic similarities that allow speakers of
one language to understand speakers of another language without having actively
learned it. Mutual intelligibility varies in degree and is typically tested in
psycholinguistic experiments. To study mutual intelligibility computationally,
we propose a computer-assisted method using the Linear Discriminative Learner,
a computational model developed to approximate the cognitive processes by which
humans learn languages, which we expand with multilingual semantic vectors and
multilingual sound classes. We test the model on cognate data from German,
Dutch, and English, three closely related Germanic languages. We find that our
model's comprehension accuracy depends on 1) the automatic trimming of
inflections and 2) the language pair for which comprehension is tested. Our
multilingual modelling approach does not only offer new methodological findings
for automatic testing of mutual intelligibility across languages but also
extends the use of Linear Discriminative Learning to multilingual settings. | [
-0.7617843151092529,
-0.8924793004989624,
0.40537795424461365,
0.22591061890125275,
-0.058198343962430954,
0.01061373669654131,
-0.6342933773994446,
-0.906771719455719,
0.11957693845033646,
-0.10514982789754868,
-0.6388049125671387,
-0.19669941067695618,
-0.3066268265247345,
0.2089034765958786,
-0.16488145291805267,
0.508311927318573,
-0.004554727114737034,
0.37200233340263367,
-0.5976916551589966,
-0.5525225400924683,
-0.425881028175354,
-0.5760118961334229,
-0.36815354228019714,
-0.6807535886764526,
0.5627717971801758,
0.3457774817943573,
0.6105560660362244,
0.2053833305835724,
0.6316326856613159,
0.3327972888946533,
0.05443888157606125,
-0.20897753536701202,
-0.49327346682548523,
0.14622721076011658,
-0.15309575200080872,
-0.5528878569602966,
-0.17998673021793365,
-0.13755156099796295,
0.4190312922000885,
1.0911591053009033,
0.020006272941827774,
0.21736827492713928,
0.12393245846033096,
0.5798502564430237,
-0.27900242805480957,
0.46226584911346436,
-0.505096435546875,
0.20878827571868896,
0.025767013430595398,
0.028807643800973892,
-0.3819805383682251,
-0.6181004047393799,
0.177510067820549,
-0.7454838156700134,
0.2750544846057892,
-0.16507874429225922,
0.7299041152000427,
0.2492971569299698,
-0.16854025423526764,
-0.2945641875267029,
-0.7542316317558289,
0.5761816501617432,
-0.4704097509384155,
0.8015006184577942,
0.6658304333686829,
0.3680800795555115,
0.1530928611755371,
-0.4389026463031769,
-0.7900710701942444,
-0.4400375485420227,
-0.22854721546173096,
-0.021580854430794716,
-0.1877865046262741,
0.25429093837738037,
0.31824856996536255,
0.24272312223911285,
-0.9589802026748657,
-0.18560092151165009,
-0.6249783039093018,
-0.1844913363456726,
0.461275190114975,
-0.15545736253261566,
0.5452623963356018,
0.25838059186935425,
-0.20306600630283356,
-0.31361329555511475,
-0.2555568516254425,
0.06857788562774658,
0.4718281924724579,
0.17927701771259308,
-0.22109469771385193,
0.3694734573364258,
0.28922155499458313,
0.8961531519889832,
-0.004474582150578499,
-0.2669895589351654,
0.49919429421424866,
-0.2732735872268677,
0.1892271488904953,
-0.03868885710835457,
0.43717125058174133,
0.20348770916461945,
0.7676032781600952,
-0.3439510464668274,
-0.051236409693956375,
0.4974641501903534,
-0.23886893689632416,
-0.308447003364563,
-0.2795717716217041,
-0.026072151958942413,
-0.4629459083080292,
0.17970925569534302,
-0.2222837656736374,
-0.41496923565864563,
0.26063746213912964,
-0.5487071871757507,
0.48036259412765503,
-0.8653719425201416,
-0.5366930961608887,
0.17834554612636566,
-0.22672529518604279,
0.0805547758936882,
-0.2087860107421875,
-0.7911756038665771,
0.4439581334590912,
0.8906189799308777,
0.6273500919342041,
-0.16153091192245483,
-0.7530459761619568,
-0.3674841523170471,
0.16751420497894287,
-0.010029636323451996,
0.587066113948822,
-0.8363809585571289,
-0.24374976754188538,
0.05864635109901428,
-0.2334386259317398,
-0.2637368440628052,
-0.406330406665802,
0.3378002643585205,
-0.792239248752594,
0.13800019025802612,
-0.34022146463394165,
-0.8689762353897095,
-0.5334482192993164,
0.17043879628181458,
-0.8948323130607605,
0.7799097299575806,
0.005786492954939604,
-0.9881349802017212,
0.4116644561290741,
-0.4776695668697357,
-0.36872759461402893,
0.14672330021858215,
-0.3877417743206024,
-0.23979230225086212,
-0.03418414667248726,
-0.2044505774974823,
0.22223250567913055,
-0.054053522646427155,
0.42490193247795105,
-0.6565693616867065,
-0.7272216081619263,
-0.048550885170698166,
-0.3762037754058838,
0.8078843951225281,
-0.04264119267463684,
-0.08512867987155914,
-0.2081848680973053,
-0.7363954782485962,
-0.09743062406778336,
-0.08429429680109024,
-0.1643761694431305,
-0.5895305871963501,
-0.044851843267679214,
-0.0011395096080377698,
0.30419689416885376,
0.3324042856693268,
-0.6007088422775269,
-0.08336687833070755,
-0.5509516596794128,
0.1106991097331047,
0.5197708010673523,
0.03146122395992279,
0.42367616295814514,
-0.4764356017112732,
0.741547167301178,
-0.1881111115217209,
-0.025491954758763313,
0.10780175030231476,
-0.26769372820854187,
-0.7283921837806702,
-0.13614673912525177,
0.2962576746940613,
0.6929912567138672,
-0.7036589980125427,
0.23201918601989746,
-0.27320611476898193,
-0.3563551902770996,
-0.32284530997276306,
0.19537299871444702,
0.6420886516571045,
0.29773107171058655,
0.0834394246339798,
-0.2782979905605316,
-0.3858549892902374,
-0.8342459797859192,
-0.20085905492305756,
-0.5278040766716003,
0.09394464641809464,
0.2987658679485321,
0.3126973509788513,
-0.1783488243818283,
0.6366692781448364,
-0.36330702900886536,
0.19952262938022614,
-0.0037532560527324677,
0.1055610403418541,
0.16571953892707825,
0.25406211614608765,
0.7303275465965271,
-0.6800448894500732,
-0.5774112939834595,
0.19374366104602814,
-0.9822477102279663,
0.05771183967590332,
0.33976784348487854,
0.18167032301425934,
0.036351509392261505,
0.7727162837982178,
-0.07988253235816956,
0.15053971111774445,
0.7409144639968872,
-0.2433495670557022,
0.4330039918422699,
-0.5619527101516724,
0.026440657675266266,
-0.6452462077140808,
0.1120103970170021,
-0.13209913671016693,
-0.020099475979804993,
-0.6608676314353943,
0.12240977585315704,
-0.021741069853305817,
-0.04668193683028221,
-0.24571073055267334,
0.45642319321632385,
-0.475087434053421,
-0.23659288883209229,
-0.09113029390573502,
0.1601397544145584,
-0.19947020709514618,
0.5582807064056396,
-0.007600438315421343,
0.6839085221290588,
0.6110787391662598,
-0.7806046605110168,
0.43296292424201965,
-0.02897169254720211,
-0.10956508666276932,
0.7783219814300537,
-0.6901669502258301,
0.14264224469661713,
-0.3986286520957947,
-0.1187053844332695,
-0.9417065978050232,
-0.153920978307724,
-0.22090977430343628,
-0.510750949382782,
0.09132880717515945,
0.1417117565870285,
-0.38073667883872986,
-0.34100252389907837,
0.030240317806601524,
0.9073968529701233,
0.2064015418291092,
-0.6356907486915588,
0.6500669121742249,
0.4312469959259033,
-0.15701325237751007,
-0.41258499026298523,
-0.5299525856971741,
-0.41410335898399353,
-0.39620789885520935,
-1.1644110679626465,
-0.035305723547935486,
-0.4394512474536896,
-0.6226712465286255,
-0.1294330358505249,
0.34643304347991943,
-0.4801083207130432,
0.06981781125068665,
0.29939886927604675,
0.2589704990386963,
-0.18250301480293274,
0.5526171326637268,
0.006900876760482788,
-0.09414470195770264,
0.1706472635269165,
-0.13154610991477966,
0.6740618348121643,
-0.27418604493141174,
-0.6429446935653687,
-0.0867362767457962,
0.4484424889087677,
0.4126059114933014,
-0.5099855661392212,
0.560835063457489,
0.6775403022766113,
-0.3548654615879059,
-0.1452893763780594,
-0.5691043138504028,
-0.4580807685852051,
-0.47176647186279297,
0.2772350013256073,
-0.9293797612190247,
-1.019554615020752,
0.8075312376022339,
-0.07055956870317459,
-0.15227004885673523,
0.1421627551317215,
0.3729739487171173,
-0.03487987071275711,
0.5791019201278687,
0.8900238275527954,
-0.1955423206090927,
0.3292805254459381,
0.03204234316945076,
0.10257793962955475,
-0.08493015915155411,
-0.07971108704805374,
-0.5676126480102539,
-0.1359781175851822,
-0.5276033878326416,
-0.31683096289634705,
0.5592967867851257,
0.077574223279953,
0.14372199773788452,
0.38780272006988525,
-0.11599510163068771,
0.6311883330345154,
0.5036055445671082,
0.0663895308971405,
0.4169894754886627,
0.16181638836860657,
-0.6152065992355347,
-0.20324265956878662,
-0.41125866770744324,
-0.032685596495866776,
0.5662744045257568,
0.23845063149929047,
0.4236963391304016,
0.1809109002351761,
0.544615626335144,
0.17422595620155334,
-0.356731653213501,
-0.42874082922935486,
0.2602880001068115,
-0.16312627494335175,
-0.4707440137863159,
-0.3436216115951538,
-0.35285571217536926,
-0.80003422498703,
0.15217027068138123,
-0.09060338139533997,
-0.6421278715133667,
0.2641170024871826,
0.03753679245710373,
-0.02450791373848915,
0.12420056760311127,
-0.7045037746429443,
0.5586200952529907,
0.07007138431072235,
-0.3331426680088043,
-0.7271541357040405,
-0.6418887376785278,
0.4197940230369568,
-0.34223830699920654,
0.4243827164173126,
-0.11349067836999893,
0.39013904333114624,
0.6664025187492371,
-0.16365578770637512,
0.626761794090271,
-0.16444921493530273,
-0.12330665439367294,
-0.0022445775102823973,
0.33210399746894836,
0.14855696260929108,
-0.12706223130226135,
-0.40083903074264526,
0.3683858811855316,
0.18762066960334778,
-0.5409943461418152,
-0.5516353845596313,
0.7075068950653076,
-0.7406787872314453,
-0.2765628397464752,
-0.3949490785598755,
-0.8112717270851135,
-0.3770993649959564,
0.022401796653866768,
0.06331285834312439,
0.2171623259782791,
-0.711471438407898,
-0.4077853560447693,
0.7112719416618347,
-0.22555314004421234,
0.5573891997337341,
0.7904421091079712,
-0.2870308756828308,
-0.2575235962867737,
1.0790071487426758,
-0.05094142258167267,
0.46314164996147156,
0.29457712173461914,
0.0833803042769432,
-0.1503496766090393,
-0.1832810491323471,
-0.14105388522148132,
0.5125131607055664,
-0.6157167553901672,
0.32504555583000183,
-0.3374359905719757,
-0.0917837917804718,
0.01625054143369198,
-0.29961124062538147,
0.16197800636291504,
-0.5575937032699585,
-0.01875297725200653,
-0.14058400690555573,
0.452675461769104,
1.0734961032867432,
-0.439953088760376,
-0.040913138538599014,
-0.579941987991333,
0.2889995574951172,
0.40005698800086975,
0.27482035756111145,
0.0530792698264122,
-0.36589351296424866,
-0.10286553204059601,
0.009831561706960201,
0.2237606942653656,
-0.750537633895874,
0.10627347975969315,
0.5824617147445679,
0.5067636370658875,
0.4404137432575226,
-0.07060030847787857,
0.7302901744842529,
-0.582982063293457,
0.43376410007476807,
0.29025235772132874,
-1.0797221660614014,
0.2004409283399582,
-0.3167082667350769,
0.23848122358322144,
0.8877645134925842,
0.48928582668304443,
-0.7092515826225281,
-0.44733577966690063,
-0.3827373683452606,
-0.34567883610725403,
0.5222882032394409,
-0.056435998529195786,
-0.16151633858680725,
0.023615427315235138,
0.369058758020401,
0.2145712822675705,
-0.36398935317993164,
-0.5335654616355896,
-0.2756345570087433,
0.2648806571960449,
-0.18356992304325104,
-0.36258095502853394,
-0.0886135920882225,
0.046052854508161545,
-0.43757161498069763,
0.5649382472038269,
-0.08154142647981644,
0.11452991515398026,
0.010999104008078575,
-0.27636510133743286,
-0.26241493225097656,
-0.016885772347450256,
0.38301584124565125,
0.8070600032806396,
-0.284659206867218,
0.3184908926486969,
0.4233139157295227,
-0.5492452383041382,
0.4139392375946045,
0.265015184879303,
-0.10546740889549255,
0.2542601525783539,
0.6411813497543335,
0.5514690279960632,
0.14243264496326447,
-0.5400668978691101,
0.5797210931777954,
-0.6354448199272156,
-0.12856803834438324,
-0.45719772577285767,
-0.045778628438711166,
0.48839524388313293,
0.16407625377178192,
-0.02791183814406395,
0.08999355882406235,
0.14448508620262146,
-0.24755904078483582,
0.6735268235206604,
0.45349088311195374,
-0.5911310911178589,
-0.4082023501396179,
0.4368070960044861,
0.2199583649635315,
-0.27562543749809265,
0.42159223556518555,
-0.3586096167564392,
-0.5212489366531372,
0.5675336718559265,
0.6100098490715027,
0.4880050718784332,
-0.5308005213737488,
-0.002705850638449192,
0.6330258250236511,
0.18511167168617249,
0.1508166640996933,
0.40366363525390625,
-0.23047080636024475,
-0.6002534627914429,
-0.496362566947937,
-0.5877030491828918,
-0.18621376156806946,
-0.42460793256759644,
-0.7549422383308411,
0.2293875366449356,
0.007155285216867924,
0.018706737086176872,
0.299851655960083,
0.045513395220041275,
-0.6785920858383179,
-0.054695017635822296,
0.11065884679555893,
0.8778823614120483,
-1.1671175956726074,
1.219988226890564,
0.4574921131134033,
-0.45143505930900574,
-0.8027323484420776,
0.026213692501187325,
-0.17340205609798431,
-0.8842910528182983,
0.8399733901023865,
0.031247220933437347,
-0.37609031796455383,
-0.2267010509967804,
-0.09845069795846939,
-0.7089184522628784,
0.8051127791404724,
0.8741475939750671,
-0.8119311332702637,
-0.06335987895727158,
0.46613290905952454,
0.6691653728485107,
0.13333091139793396,
0.5936167240142822,
0.5586916208267212,
0.43685609102249146,
-0.07065588980913162,
-1.3258147239685059,
-0.32593828439712524,
-0.3802222013473511,
-0.16814154386520386,
0.1871880143880844,
-0.5237583518028259,
0.8325732946395874,
0.037454839795827866,
-0.1275591105222702,
-0.3183964192867279,
0.931628406047821,
0.10085988789796829,
0.3581741750240326,
0.8911566138267517,
0.5748680233955383,
1.046197772026062,
0.18270008265972137,
0.7198264002799988,
-0.8135970830917358,
0.44605642557144165,
1.0143332481384277,
-0.22387954592704773,
0.7815642356872559,
0.2899155914783478,
-0.2874673902988434,
0.5139658451080322,
0.1736019253730774,
0.18136301636695862,
0.24375426769256592,
0.37913239002227783,
-0.7924487590789795,
-0.12275293469429016,
-0.2734200060367584,
-0.44619280099868774,
0.4157676100730896,
0.2544310688972473,
-0.16888925433158875,
-0.10688789933919907,
0.3251393139362335,
0.0023021502420306206,
0.5154147744178772,
0.04326091334223747,
0.8511580228805542,
0.11686103790998459,
-0.8145346641540527,
0.8430494070053101,
-0.20253600180149078,
0.7030892968177795,
-0.5322965979576111,
-0.19142797589302063,
-0.1573626846075058,
0.3846616744995117,
-0.09723535925149918,
-0.5655169486999512,
0.5229672789573669,
-0.17738166451454163,
-0.3769057095050812,
0.3109711706638336,
0.6421288847923279,
-0.7575262784957886,
-0.7202616930007935,
1.1494077444076538,
0.5561050176620483,
0.28586453199386597,
0.283672571182251,
-0.6229130029678345,
0.3161795735359192,
0.13929225504398346,
0.479040265083313,
0.11412036418914795,
0.3151775598526001,
0.049022164195775986,
0.5885132551193237,
0.3768990635871887,
0.07579710334539413,
0.35520854592323303,
0.27082642912864685,
0.7677412629127502,
-0.37165096402168274,
-0.37294095754623413,
-0.8571588397026062,
-0.2073514610528946,
0.19686973094940186,
0.032378293573856354,
0.7956052422523499,
0.6136643290519714,
1.1258609294891357,
-0.08452461659908295,
0.7720355987548828,
0.11345931142568588,
0.5852482914924622,
-0.17584384977817535,
0.6158226132392883,
-0.31714051961898804,
0.0023462276440113783,
-0.4274904429912567,
-0.9067345857620239,
-0.16115638613700867,
0.6427504420280457,
-0.2540460526943207,
-0.09416554868221283,
0.7256035804748535,
0.9204583764076233,
-0.5151745080947876,
0.28866133093833923,
0.6332458853721619,
0.16999086737632751,
0.026595886796712875,
0.9172238111495972,
0.6484057903289795,
-0.1842508465051651,
0.3777413070201874,
-0.6049528121948242,
-0.41206109523773193,
0.17689888179302216,
-0.4290662407875061,
-1.1861361265182495,
-0.8947719931602478,
-0.0694660097360611,
-0.36542412638664246,
0.3293415307998657,
0.7964922785758972,
0.6440165638923645,
-0.6486853361129761,
-0.6221876740455627,
-0.05525586009025574,
-0.007082258816808462,
-0.2290468066930771,
-0.19555674493312836,
0.4192558825016022,
-0.21065208315849304,
-0.7470055222511292,
0.46063166856765747,
0.11123307049274445,
-0.16783814132213593,
-0.5009568929672241,
-0.43912604451179504,
-0.34577134251594543,
0.13453063368797302,
0.37106460332870483,
0.426554411649704,
-0.5673942565917969,
-0.07761036604642868,
-0.11768276244401932,
-0.010481514967978,
0.0020554191432893276,
0.6114980578422546,
-0.6771752834320068,
0.8270816206932068,
0.7631736397743225,
0.42594730854034424,
0.480416864156723,
-0.12272710353136063,
0.6932823657989502,
-0.5966012477874756,
0.5253925919532776,
0.10179753601551056,
0.33731308579444885,
0.25209420919418335,
-0.1616351455450058,
0.2988857924938202,
0.11285659670829773,
-0.620018720626831,
-0.47431355714797974,
0.4208472669124603,
-0.8864179849624634,
-0.2557627558708191,
0.7854291200637817,
-0.4122592508792877,
-0.2550327777862549,
-0.3884068727493286,
0.0033523733727633953,
0.2838408350944519,
-0.1877097338438034,
0.3490641713142395,
0.8302756547927856,
0.011812527664005756,
0.07209862023591995,
-0.2851729989051819,
0.48069292306900024,
0.44316449761390686,
-0.5851696133613586,
-0.050138574093580246,
0.3950761556625366,
0.22095166146755219,
0.2762926518917084,
0.49271735548973083,
0.13018792867660522,
0.4366509020328522,
0.10113153606653214,
0.3455018401145935,
0.1987302601337433,
-0.1949942260980606,
-0.7167777419090271,
0.15303069353103638,
0.2674778699874878,
-0.007775256410241127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02896v1 | LLM Agents in Interaction: Measuring Personality Consistency and Linguistic Alignment in Interacting Populations of Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T11:05:20 | 2024-02-05T11:05:20 | Ivar Frisch, Mario Giulianelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.MA | While both agent interaction and personalisation are vibrant topics in
research on large language models (LLMs), there has been limited focus on the
effect of language interaction on the behaviour of persona-conditioned LLM
agents. Such an endeavour is important to ensure that agents remain consistent
to their assigned traits yet are able to engage in open, naturalistic
dialogues. In our experiments, we condition GPT-3.5 on personality profiles
through prompting and create a two-group population of LLM agents using a
simple variability-inducing sampling algorithm. We then administer personality
tests and submit the agents to a collaborative writing task, finding that
different profiles exhibit different degrees of personality consistency and
linguistic alignment to their conversational partners. Our study seeks to lay
the groundwork for better understanding of dialogue-based interaction between
LLMs and highlights the need for new approaches to crafting robust, more
human-like LLM personas for interactive environments. | [
-0.4937886595726013,
-0.7200743556022644,
0.8358429074287415,
0.3854774832725525,
0.14921656250953674,
0.12179772555828094,
-0.4256822168827057,
-0.6646828651428223,
0.45454710721969604,
0.6487246155738831,
-0.7008345723152161,
-0.38283273577690125,
-0.2600863575935364,
0.21015894412994385,
0.0002963675942737609,
0.8205445408821106,
-0.09630073606967926,
0.17628814280033112,
-0.4385448098182678,
-0.35822269320487976,
-0.3899923264980316,
-0.8246769309043884,
-0.7819753289222717,
-0.5202474594116211,
0.7331154942512512,
0.25476619601249695,
0.8709096312522888,
0.2967669665813446,
0.4494994878768921,
0.42471301555633545,
-0.01497950404882431,
0.12458564341068268,
-0.5797048807144165,
0.5398644804954529,
-0.34398090839385986,
-0.30051833391189575,
-0.7011975646018982,
0.21181350946426392,
0.5779213309288025,
0.8046255707740784,
-0.06046126037836075,
-0.27062395215034485,
0.16106119751930237,
0.5280566811561584,
-0.17737378180027008,
0.2577155530452728,
-0.27774250507354736,
-0.1679379791021347,
-0.19295331835746765,
-0.08213869482278824,
-0.4296268820762634,
-0.41907134652137756,
0.15964241325855255,
-0.4340539872646332,
0.010016590356826782,
0.1196000725030899,
0.5830400586128235,
0.15748825669288635,
-0.47953322529792786,
-0.10479819774627686,
-0.8555315732955933,
0.5469518303871155,
-0.7146105766296387,
0.20091891288757324,
0.4137292504310608,
0.012979048304259777,
-0.4217631220817566,
-0.21462249755859375,
-0.800378143787384,
-0.5359795689582825,
-0.13518816232681274,
0.16528289020061493,
0.17780885100364685,
0.3146091103553772,
0.10446654260158539,
0.16297899186611176,
-0.5510430335998535,
0.387412428855896,
0.10760238766670227,
-0.1593087911605835,
0.8013136982917786,
0.3750416338443756,
0.3359425663948059,
0.12002258002758026,
-0.01885743997991085,
-0.005765895359218121,
-0.668444812297821,
-0.08119536191225052,
0.8132777810096741,
0.2393607497215271,
-0.10594486445188522,
0.723117470741272,
-0.13727912306785583,
0.43381068110466003,
0.32701510190963745,
-0.1245318278670311,
0.01913543790578842,
-0.5152908563613892,
0.04111381620168686,
-0.18682749569416046,
0.8846603631973267,
0.5285314321517944,
0.5316479802131653,
-0.12621143460273743,
-0.19286170601844788,
-0.10159618407487869,
0.16467973589897156,
-0.4689801335334778,
-0.15281462669372559,
0.2682664394378662,
-0.1690254509449005,
-0.2161414623260498,
0.13053977489471436,
-0.5638373494148254,
-0.6592514514923096,
-0.4245711863040924,
0.18719947338104248,
-0.25514963269233704,
-0.3930606544017792,
-0.06782715022563934,
0.16809122264385223,
0.5388547778129578,
0.4036175310611725,
-1.2863175868988037,
0.4872135519981384,
0.6543756127357483,
0.530768632888794,
-0.365339457988739,
-0.7156295776367188,
-0.4992106854915619,
0.27164000272750854,
-0.20148985087871552,
0.7601728439331055,
-0.5355516672134399,
-0.49552232027053833,
0.08487380295991898,
-0.08438672125339508,
-0.13981156051158905,
-0.5625919699668884,
0.05704130604863167,
-0.26290249824523926,
0.3133499026298523,
-0.4764927327632904,
-0.5811427235603333,
0.29350951313972473,
0.34397435188293457,
-0.488156259059906,
0.8038672804832458,
0.3630428910255432,
-0.4947809875011444,
0.2095230668783188,
-0.541312575340271,
-0.15545187890529633,
0.1168188527226448,
-0.3887109160423279,
-0.2284916788339615,
0.005629530176520348,
-0.1841801404953003,
0.37779298424720764,
0.050931982696056366,
0.18749025464057922,
-0.5228706002235413,
-0.35179707407951355,
0.8258440494537354,
-0.1529960334300995,
0.4302597641944885,
-0.08634166419506073,
-0.14856389164924622,
0.31390002369880676,
-0.32730814814567566,
-0.05896758660674095,
0.0261703971773386,
-0.3775179982185364,
0.038950540125370026,
0.07355378568172455,
0.10744408518075943,
0.06041362136602402,
0.5069556832313538,
-0.5522168278694153,
0.7054598927497864,
-0.30355924367904663,
0.2563030421733856,
0.6986504197120667,
0.07509902864694595,
0.4719659090042114,
-0.6755033135414124,
0.40461963415145874,
-0.14028100669384003,
-0.05778113752603531,
0.1309727281332016,
-0.5166195034980774,
-0.6629311442375183,
-0.31537532806396484,
-0.05043617635965347,
0.49998345971107483,
-0.3175992965698242,
0.6435258984565735,
-0.14469492435455322,
-0.24848096072673798,
-0.4134348928928375,
0.34267789125442505,
0.49995481967926025,
0.19315625727176666,
-0.16547249257564545,
-0.5971626043319702,
-0.6131455898284912,
-0.8515811562538147,
-0.20997528731822968,
-0.42348146438598633,
-0.08026643097400665,
0.40886321663856506,
0.35743775963783264,
-0.45967456698417664,
1.2082860469818115,
-0.30084627866744995,
0.11277610808610916,
-0.5688748359680176,
0.04567892476916313,
-0.032752711325883865,
0.4224335849285126,
0.5209860801696777,
-0.5016234517097473,
-0.8258639574050903,
0.02671164460480213,
-0.5974070429801941,
-0.3888940215110779,
0.03979502245783806,
-0.07016482204198837,
0.3846387267112732,
0.5702095627784729,
-0.6689034700393677,
0.20070719718933105,
0.4779256284236908,
-0.27993708848953247,
0.6026149392127991,
-0.1914016455411911,
0.07272690534591675,
-0.9464300870895386,
-0.06679504364728928,
0.04414012283086777,
-0.44906872510910034,
-1.0085957050323486,
-0.2038722187280655,
-0.37753570079803467,
0.20435841381549835,
-0.3494526743888855,
0.7546992897987366,
-0.34400495886802673,
-0.06700844317674637,
-0.3271234631538391,
0.3849926292896271,
-0.0741284117102623,
0.5019290447235107,
0.2218855768442154,
0.8949657678604126,
0.3300302028656006,
-0.2984646260738373,
0.3087516725063324,
0.5646246075630188,
0.03417053446173668,
1.0363770723342896,
-0.5324564576148987,
0.5900977253913879,
-0.0653715580701828,
0.3307434022426605,
-1.0317273139953613,
-0.6413360238075256,
0.3543122708797455,
-0.2777808904647827,
0.2492268979549408,
0.13277797400951385,
-0.4679034352302551,
0.11493279039859772,
-0.33555009961128235,
0.1702948808670044,
0.4369361400604248,
-0.2576274573802948,
0.7295745015144348,
0.3159443140029907,
-0.5525408387184143,
-0.06623988598585129,
-0.48479321599006653,
0.07787571847438812,
-0.3346877992153168,
-0.7490554451942444,
0.12306404858827591,
-0.45444589853286743,
-0.6902915239334106,
-0.2881217896938324,
0.06017075851559639,
-0.1602303385734558,
0.037844836711883545,
0.22472289204597473,
0.21667516231536865,
-0.0696178451180458,
-0.11870269477367401,
-0.2977793216705322,
0.04908960685133934,
0.011974283494055271,
0.01373861450701952,
0.7941476106643677,
-0.30396854877471924,
-0.5324499607086182,
-0.6602776646614075,
0.42348402738571167,
0.5226699709892273,
0.007935872301459312,
1.033761739730835,
0.32167354226112366,
-0.10229688137769699,
0.26443320512771606,
-0.6597611308097839,
-0.06953313201665878,
-0.512397825717926,
0.10932429879903793,
-0.39569514989852905,
-1.0034202337265015,
0.7777213454246521,
0.09977669268846512,
-0.08543156087398529,
0.22833704948425293,
0.823874831199646,
-0.39793941378593445,
0.9424863457679749,
0.7153494954109192,
-0.1545221358537674,
0.4537878930568695,
0.2711506187915802,
0.1475568413734436,
-0.9543994069099426,
-0.2343667894601822,
-0.30625587701797485,
-0.28406471014022827,
-0.7407366037368774,
0.02177106775343418,
0.06306286156177521,
-0.21618032455444336,
-0.33340173959732056,
0.09633946418762207,
-0.21856413781642914,
0.6074950098991394,
0.37693890929222107,
0.06895702332258224,
0.25844064354896545,
-0.531338632106781,
0.03243069350719452,
-0.138060063123703,
-0.0265351589769125,
-0.7334649562835693,
0.8424018025398254,
0.2322387844324112,
0.7703276872634888,
0.5202392935752869,
0.781501829624176,
-0.07385819405317307,
0.46150150895118713,
-0.6948140263557434,
0.6782639622688293,
0.2981630861759186,
-0.45161861181259155,
-0.45476022362709045,
-0.1997680962085724,
-0.9786221981048584,
-0.05692722648382187,
-0.04987361282110214,
-1.3818180561065674,
0.0518701896071434,
0.11919858306646347,
-0.2179766148328781,
-0.13730189204216003,
-0.664280891418457,
0.7040020227432251,
-0.12447390705347061,
-0.3483222723007202,
0.05617491528391838,
-0.7582414746284485,
0.22898724675178528,
-0.21401168406009674,
-0.23444724082946777,
-0.1973252147436142,
-0.04041675478219986,
0.3503737449645996,
-0.36642134189605713,
1.104284405708313,
0.015010303817689419,
-0.38172438740730286,
0.057081494480371475,
0.1232326477766037,
0.5432519316673279,
-0.004348675720393658,
-0.05817433074116707,
-0.1032136008143425,
0.049386486411094666,
-0.3257644772529602,
-0.708129346370697,
0.7242370843887329,
-1.0215243101119995,
-0.9189525842666626,
-0.4333154559135437,
-0.8956975340843201,
-0.5317361354827881,
0.051420100033283234,
-0.02177944779396057,
0.11909008771181107,
-0.5757840275764465,
0.1077481210231781,
0.8169891238212585,
-0.03611712157726288,
0.2577416002750397,
0.6992037296295166,
-0.40283727645874023,
-0.28784123063087463,
0.7346076369285583,
-0.12853170931339264,
0.6658757328987122,
0.25302791595458984,
0.10737978667020798,
-0.2848268151283264,
-0.4791051745414734,
0.09558121860027313,
0.3516154885292053,
-0.512061357498169,
0.43870648741722107,
-0.3737562894821167,
-0.2528640031814575,
-0.49986329674720764,
-0.2776816785335541,
-0.11781015992164612,
-0.1253870278596878,
-0.09660709649324417,
0.2536894679069519,
0.203559011220932,
0.9728469848632812,
0.1186021938920021,
0.5811325311660767,
-0.5569468140602112,
0.0127338832244277,
0.3130139708518982,
0.3329441547393799,
-0.41037899255752563,
-0.31422799825668335,
-0.023437878116965294,
0.011524166911840439,
-0.4203554689884186,
-1.0168148279190063,
0.1739993542432785,
0.21777498722076416,
0.641457736492157,
0.5009900331497192,
-0.31967005133628845,
0.32456865906715393,
-0.2558956742286682,
0.8642804026603699,
-0.04223299026489258,
-0.8773529529571533,
0.32249417901039124,
-0.7327325344085693,
0.3705979585647583,
0.6337817907333374,
0.17896540462970734,
-1.0147756338119507,
-0.660406231880188,
-0.5194064974784851,
-0.4630717933177948,
0.6380995512008667,
0.2947273254394531,
0.11660800129175186,
0.05765256658196449,
0.5537868738174438,
0.03700803965330124,
0.3643113672733307,
-0.7656039595603943,
-0.18371208012104034,
0.06729034334421158,
-0.4367133677005768,
-0.3187568485736847,
-0.24461157619953156,
-0.41958242654800415,
-0.17667526006698608,
0.30331531167030334,
-0.20845358073711395,
0.3176423907279968,
0.11936500668525696,
0.043746285140514374,
-0.11499851942062378,
0.2997398376464844,
0.7947872877120972,
0.5777264833450317,
-0.1728586107492447,
0.07479872554540634,
0.15827323496341705,
-0.49632659554481506,
0.2488686591386795,
0.02873258665204048,
0.054873861372470856,
-0.34751445055007935,
0.2904979884624481,
0.5420367121696472,
0.06826245784759521,
-0.6559572219848633,
0.4755711853504181,
-0.2513673007488251,
-0.30701884627342224,
-0.3448234498500824,
0.29261088371276855,
0.3609071373939514,
0.34004536271095276,
-0.14086073637008667,
-0.22551757097244263,
-0.24705755710601807,
-0.6987123489379883,
0.03631329908967018,
0.6482945680618286,
-0.1479577124118805,
-0.4166695177555084,
0.43135830760002136,
0.25876304507255554,
-0.702457070350647,
0.7177960872650146,
-0.2505982518196106,
-0.3716091811656952,
0.42854613065719604,
0.4441136419773102,
0.9660674929618835,
-0.3536848723888397,
0.11926113814115524,
-0.2072822004556656,
0.09210877120494843,
-0.04054636135697365,
0.39012423157691956,
0.13306871056556702,
-1.038030982017517,
-0.345139741897583,
-0.3591517508029938,
-1.0963646173477173,
0.22870077192783356,
-0.4825834333896637,
0.04563422501087189,
-0.31036970019340515,
0.0440591461956501,
-0.03729164972901344,
0.21963348984718323,
-0.5492758750915527,
-0.17921210825443268,
0.16953669488430023,
0.3768812119960785,
-0.7611024975776672,
0.9151556491851807,
0.7739840745925903,
-0.3935578465461731,
-0.7146154046058655,
0.17145006358623505,
0.3343580961227417,
-0.5889043211936951,
0.3908732831478119,
0.275322824716568,
-0.10846125334501266,
-0.015094048343598843,
-0.6145132184028625,
-0.7547798752784729,
0.9561202526092529,
0.462147980928421,
-0.44638630747795105,
0.24894286692142487,
0.503557026386261,
0.790820300579071,
-0.5106618404388428,
0.2968692481517792,
0.742279589176178,
0.6845577359199524,
0.08783917129039764,
-1.1147165298461914,
-0.1273455023765564,
-0.3094136714935303,
0.020857373252511024,
0.19504384696483612,
-0.9729495048522949,
0.4978041350841522,
0.12545077502727509,
0.11224060505628586,
0.4785423278808594,
0.8176981210708618,
0.37684160470962524,
0.15343336760997772,
0.40167155861854553,
0.3424926996231079,
1.0112115144729614,
-0.18289177119731903,
0.8560724854469299,
-0.3058825135231018,
0.13005205988883972,
1.2516132593154907,
-0.9133800268173218,
0.6848462224006653,
0.5539982914924622,
-0.17223326861858368,
0.48050323128700256,
0.5938944220542908,
-0.016759157180786133,
0.254104882478714,
0.2983725070953369,
-0.6354175209999084,
-0.02984013594686985,
-0.1956370323896408,
0.07034127414226532,
0.3777713179588318,
0.19023816287517548,
0.06536539644002914,
0.3225906491279602,
-0.04489171877503395,
0.1369313895702362,
0.26305893063545227,
-0.02742532081902027,
0.8433974981307983,
-0.11194373667240143,
-0.9053232073783875,
-0.02028569206595421,
-0.2595716416835785,
0.5148414969444275,
-0.5308190584182739,
0.23312155902385712,
-0.3925239145755768,
0.11872905492782593,
-0.23841407895088196,
-1.0220649242401123,
0.29333409667015076,
-0.18137575685977936,
-0.1361950784921646,
-0.44417843222618103,
0.5323709845542908,
-0.7161136269569397,
0.02086503803730011,
0.04451529309153557,
0.7478348016738892,
0.43973177671432495,
0.09557627141475677,
-0.2423800677061081,
0.18284215033054352,
-0.21686431765556335,
-0.4423799216747284,
0.7310494780540466,
0.20549744367599487,
0.08184703439474106,
0.7033414244651794,
0.3910118341445923,
-0.009724617935717106,
-0.2696734368801117,
0.3181397020816803,
0.7351773977279663,
-0.5207880139350891,
-0.11654987186193466,
-0.9428973197937012,
0.44298139214515686,
-0.07371469587087631,
-0.37356138229370117,
0.8451952338218689,
0.4574568569660187,
0.637257993221283,
0.011412438936531544,
0.7025961875915527,
0.01760260947048664,
0.24498717486858368,
-0.4320242404937744,
0.4880223572254181,
0.006912656128406525,
0.15059535205364227,
-0.09564001858234406,
-1.0765907764434814,
-0.023304063826799393,
0.4815279543399811,
-0.3571658134460449,
0.2957473695278168,
0.6911048293113708,
0.9578850865364075,
0.21743477880954742,
-0.028175698593258858,
0.3233935534954071,
0.29290369153022766,
0.5195562243461609,
0.4232421815395355,
0.9690049290657043,
0.2840907573699951,
0.10980015993118286,
-0.004279407672584057,
-0.20248810946941376,
0.020906999707221985,
-0.9025272130966187,
-1.0516306161880493,
-0.6256905794143677,
-0.3605651259422302,
-0.37516993284225464,
-0.025277383625507355,
1.1086875200271606,
0.2904735803604126,
-0.46571141481399536,
-0.43498319387435913,
-0.07027439028024673,
-0.0641140341758728,
-0.05322027578949928,
-0.20910193026065826,
-0.105005644261837,
-0.24612855911254883,
-1.004721999168396,
0.41714051365852356,
0.4565967321395874,
0.31620579957962036,
-0.8265175819396973,
-0.3601739704608917,
-0.051548123359680176,
0.3425273597240448,
0.2431776374578476,
0.44929006695747375,
-0.7792590856552124,
-0.5892179012298584,
0.052673835307359695,
-0.3681023120880127,
0.28811416029930115,
0.6963157057762146,
-0.4407240152359009,
0.2774927318096161,
0.24136026203632355,
0.3740799129009247,
0.3032715320587158,
0.15151293575763702,
0.8438822031021118,
-0.8759892582893372,
0.006816543638706207,
0.08870644122362137,
0.28717169165611267,
0.5056142807006836,
-0.5968381762504578,
0.3023116886615753,
0.09844176471233368,
-1.019544243812561,
-0.5445029139518738,
0.5322737693786621,
-1.2477654218673706,
0.29656004905700684,
1.341225028038025,
-0.05985943228006363,
-0.0415370911359787,
-0.24657776951789856,
-0.518229603767395,
-0.033112768083810806,
-0.3418548107147217,
0.615516722202301,
1.098296880722046,
-0.6331329345703125,
-0.18345138430595398,
-0.4542310833930969,
0.4996134638786316,
0.27571406960487366,
-0.9953115582466125,
-0.03338565677404404,
0.4869219660758972,
0.27172544598579407,
0.06527533382177353,
1.0113366842269897,
0.26486748456954956,
-0.029301712289452553,
-0.29264160990715027,
0.10800978541374207,
0.2874537408351898,
-0.012948182411491871,
-0.38062527775764465,
-0.18350332975387573,
0.4719926118850708,
0.3172915577888489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02883v1 | Approximate Attributions for Off-the-Shelf Siamese Transformers | 2024-02-05T10:49:05 | 2024-02-05T10:49:05 | Lucas Möller, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Siamese encoders such as sentence transformers are among the least understood
deep models. Established attribution methods cannot tackle this model class
since it compares two inputs rather than processing a single one. To address
this gap, we have recently proposed an attribution method specifically for
Siamese encoders (M\"oller et al., 2023). However, it requires models to be
adjusted and fine-tuned and therefore cannot be directly applied to
off-the-shelf models. In this work, we reassess these restrictions and propose
(i) a model with exact attribution ability that retains the original model's
predictive performance and (ii) a way to compute approximate attributions for
off-the-shelf models. We extensively compare approximate and exact attributions
and use them to analyze the models' attendance to different linguistic aspects.
We gain insights into which syntactic roles Siamese transformers attend to,
confirm that they mostly ignore negation, explore how they judge semantically
opposite adjectives, and find that they exhibit lexical bias. | [
-0.36668524146080017,
-0.2775050699710846,
0.706728994846344,
0.029122935608029366,
-0.11141704022884369,
-0.24918344616889954,
-0.23308902978897095,
-0.31805744767189026,
0.3366785943508148,
0.5861320495605469,
-0.7004250288009644,
0.1293213665485382,
-0.3995412290096283,
0.14363901317119598,
-0.4758610129356384,
0.9561966061592102,
-0.12412115931510925,
-0.1941983848810196,
-0.22579728066921234,
-0.11887115240097046,
-0.13548295199871063,
-0.4915545880794525,
-0.23729529976844788,
-0.36148837208747864,
0.5187863707542419,
0.41386678814888,
0.764689028263092,
0.4093005359172821,
0.6334481835365295,
0.23392373323440552,
-0.0535750538110733,
-0.20628075301647186,
-0.1222783774137497,
-0.14154033362865448,
-0.39514559507369995,
-0.9401856660842896,
-0.47841885685920715,
0.011596948839724064,
0.6191717982292175,
0.5581728219985962,
-0.16695788502693176,
0.31934770941734314,
-0.07892999798059464,
0.4169425368309021,
-0.8983928561210632,
0.12290804088115692,
-0.9422460794448853,
0.1482202410697937,
0.13649913668632507,
-0.12591779232025146,
-0.6001161932945251,
-0.6171296238899231,
0.15987858176231384,
-0.5804734826087952,
0.24700990319252014,
-0.12203647941350937,
0.8943830132484436,
0.558976948261261,
-0.4771767854690552,
-0.4643566608428955,
-0.7463034391403198,
0.9711477756500244,
-0.6384363770484924,
0.3106591999530792,
0.4295932352542877,
0.37062060832977295,
0.06890009343624115,
-0.7592850923538208,
-0.5063230395317078,
-0.3573310971260071,
-0.25866225361824036,
0.1538216769695282,
-0.34873804450035095,
0.03066183626651764,
0.13781234622001648,
0.46628662943840027,
-0.31859904527664185,
0.2586260437965393,
-0.33707958459854126,
0.15608754754066467,
0.36572760343551636,
0.09440530091524124,
-0.049749139696359634,
-0.6002910137176514,
-0.5343068838119507,
-0.11428944021463394,
-0.7059534192085266,
-0.05781951919198036,
0.4597391188144684,
0.042237065732479095,
-0.06763498485088348,
0.9084354639053345,
0.0039102318696677685,
0.35477644205093384,
0.145111083984375,
0.46587204933166504,
-0.08579283207654953,
-0.55107581615448,
0.023516705259680748,
0.3466920852661133,
0.7069640159606934,
0.3500954806804657,
0.741414487361908,
-0.3377683162689209,
-0.5356249809265137,
0.21800938248634338,
0.7816062569618225,
-0.49289801716804504,
-0.349785178899765,
-0.4539032578468323,
-0.2889077961444855,
-0.6732891201972961,
0.03372306376695633,
-0.806344211101532,
-0.21100157499313354,
-0.09431012719869614,
0.6420334577560425,
0.037368811666965485,
-0.07460277527570724,
-0.14850153028964996,
-0.11185315251350403,
0.31529027223587036,
-0.056342121213674545,
-0.6440512537956238,
0.6209906935691833,
0.32894280552864075,
0.9559870362281799,
-0.009585510939359665,
0.0739789828658104,
-0.23337972164154053,
0.17603027820587158,
-0.3450123965740204,
0.6362916231155396,
-0.6581354141235352,
-0.1947428435087204,
-0.07368765771389008,
0.06912652403116226,
-0.09796907007694244,
-0.5803747773170471,
0.7141836285591125,
-0.43687254190444946,
0.3219495713710785,
-0.03524557128548622,
-0.6959393620491028,
-0.07555638253688812,
0.07912270724773407,
-0.8779201507568359,
0.36376672983169556,
0.21611492335796356,
-0.6688306927680969,
0.3653181493282318,
-0.8908030986785889,
-0.1738494485616684,
-0.33865442872047424,
0.03342290595173836,
-0.5079226493835449,
0.5331639051437378,
0.5102869272232056,
0.42254072427749634,
-0.2983916699886322,
0.3580596148967743,
-0.3368408977985382,
-0.3322278559207916,
0.6857132911682129,
-0.7014162540435791,
0.9964597225189209,
0.13441653549671173,
-0.13296614587306976,
-0.056406937539577484,
-0.6832908391952515,
-0.178812175989151,
0.23286308348178864,
0.1195368692278862,
-0.19886888563632965,
0.035338807851076126,
-0.08032787591218948,
0.027219729498028755,
0.01844681426882744,
-0.6975195407867432,
0.26635754108428955,
-0.6508030891418457,
0.6908982396125793,
0.6693561673164368,
0.07413741946220398,
0.8631013035774231,
-0.24613994359970093,
0.929664671421051,
-0.13383331894874573,
0.10211716592311859,
-0.14970344305038452,
-0.2595670819282532,
-0.9422623515129089,
-0.21059562265872955,
0.42961814999580383,
0.450224906206131,
-0.7812337875366211,
0.5159033536911011,
-0.6906652450561523,
-0.7911205887794495,
-0.7939797043800354,
-0.14733943343162537,
0.31978777050971985,
0.25784406065940857,
0.2973691523075104,
-0.5111778974533081,
-0.6923705339431763,
-1.0909147262573242,
-0.6445322632789612,
-0.410269170999527,
-0.21062515676021576,
-0.010640800930559635,
0.472141832113266,
0.12707410752773285,
1.3021594285964966,
-0.7581521272659302,
-0.5882412791252136,
-0.1486297994852066,
0.04961501434445381,
0.15475572645664215,
0.4345772862434387,
0.6794487833976746,
-0.6048437356948853,
-0.3253355324268341,
-0.2702057957649231,
-0.5761977434158325,
-0.15091371536254883,
-0.08193080872297287,
0.3496261239051819,
-0.03713969141244888,
0.6425438523292542,
-0.9064533114433289,
0.4156624376773834,
0.34631481766700745,
-0.000683046062476933,
0.6400941610336304,
-0.00605848990380764,
-0.05481339246034622,
-0.9425886273384094,
-0.0015719379298388958,
0.13897700607776642,
-0.3882959485054016,
-0.5901504158973694,
0.17265328764915466,
0.10311131179332733,
-0.10161031782627106,
-0.5398673415184021,
0.4851153492927551,
-0.23931436240673065,
-0.1064242497086525,
0.04671742022037506,
-0.030965648591518402,
0.17371520400047302,
0.5850090384483337,
0.024242626503109932,
0.623080849647522,
0.1989237368106842,
-0.3753061592578888,
0.5996553301811218,
0.19701822102069855,
-0.7023307681083679,
0.5487378239631653,
-0.8299873471260071,
-0.027350474148988724,
-0.004241001792252064,
0.504641592502594,
-1.1015113592147827,
-0.09037161618471146,
0.3877466917037964,
-0.6665665507316589,
0.29542943835258484,
-0.3349006175994873,
-0.5295882225036621,
-0.2252548485994339,
-0.28253740072250366,
0.6155336499214172,
0.8284145593643188,
-0.6498177647590637,
0.6405545473098755,
0.040181007236242294,
-0.22898750007152557,
-0.14267385005950928,
-1.0045968294143677,
-0.07682152092456818,
-0.735078752040863,
-0.25774019956588745,
0.3666214346885681,
0.36754339933395386,
-0.3032047152519226,
0.2476450502872467,
0.08907908946275711,
-0.27911803126335144,
-0.12371394783258438,
-0.03330402448773384,
0.039495956152677536,
-0.6591953039169312,
0.007516607642173767,
-0.12199972569942474,
-0.3118414580821991,
0.33108028769493103,
-0.04696044698357582,
0.07191947102546692,
0.015197274275124073,
-0.38489505648612976,
-0.39170408248901367,
0.012613123282790184,
0.4936748147010803,
-0.12595590949058533,
0.6900700926780701,
0.3927110731601715,
-0.4420726001262665,
0.15673969686031342,
-0.6157935261726379,
-0.4800330400466919,
-0.5353080034255981,
0.5496937036514282,
-0.35537534952163696,
-0.1795692890882492,
0.5482597351074219,
0.5303954482078552,
-0.04476138576865196,
0.5302333235740662,
0.482713520526886,
0.16818611323833466,
1.1700464487075806,
0.5650416612625122,
0.1504596769809723,
0.4180278182029724,
0.01056063361465931,
0.5702107548713684,
-0.8217005729675293,
0.0048673637211322784,
-0.6384404897689819,
-0.11691732704639435,
-0.6085614562034607,
-0.21409370005130768,
0.11066661030054092,
-0.03631026670336723,
-0.18358761072158813,
0.8029046058654785,
-0.36552542448043823,
0.3875463604927063,
0.3701569437980652,
-0.007934640161693096,
0.29435819387435913,
0.23839814960956573,
0.3738163113594055,
-0.4269285202026367,
-0.794984757900238,
-0.5158488750457764,
0.8187608122825623,
0.47916701436042786,
0.9608004689216614,
0.32098957896232605,
0.16905167698860168,
0.1943354606628418,
0.06801538169384003,
-0.9063452482223511,
0.3417423963546753,
-0.3280400037765503,
-0.6102749705314636,
0.050176892429590225,
-0.46209585666656494,
-0.6564038395881653,
0.0036862289998680353,
0.23470182716846466,
-0.9178733825683594,
0.16488169133663177,
0.12209262698888779,
-0.2785375714302063,
0.394010990858078,
-1.0567076206207275,
0.9672946929931641,
0.002514719031751156,
0.04376670718193054,
0.007869948633015156,
-0.5347903966903687,
0.3391183316707611,
-0.30698785185813904,
0.03228381276130676,
0.14594805240631104,
-0.1599782258272171,
0.935912549495697,
-0.30665963888168335,
0.8283145427703857,
-0.14530515670776367,
-0.2597886025905609,
0.28556498885154724,
0.1883917897939682,
0.500049352645874,
-0.3327527940273285,
-0.0992927998304367,
-0.11156924068927765,
0.029360175132751465,
-0.2083752155303955,
-1.1014280319213867,
0.5933947563171387,
-0.6943389773368835,
-0.41531819105148315,
-0.239698588848114,
-0.12341556698083878,
-0.17645716667175293,
-0.09749961644411087,
0.6681622862815857,
0.5516189932823181,
-0.060803309082984924,
0.17684206366539001,
0.11795258522033691,
-0.1302940547466278,
0.2360425889492035,
0.24217288196086884,
-0.11541738361120224,
-0.12851235270500183,
1.0955476760864258,
0.1688975691795349,
0.6239648461341858,
0.4611125588417053,
0.11831872165203094,
-0.6807066798210144,
0.09498848766088486,
-0.5761943459510803,
0.18473072350025177,
-1.0390554666519165,
-0.25375089049339294,
-0.7731484770774841,
-0.24446001648902893,
-0.27771586179733276,
-0.6136642694473267,
-0.8469933867454529,
-0.7956939339637756,
-0.5422065854072571,
0.054042939096689224,
0.38395923376083374,
0.8673608303070068,
0.27023711800575256,
0.5721229314804077,
-0.5473823547363281,
0.1677246242761612,
0.12024859338998795,
0.4108518958091736,
0.2781902849674225,
-0.9563419818878174,
-0.10092765092849731,
0.3653238117694855,
-0.4229501783847809,
-0.8045148253440857,
0.18649230897426605,
0.5519831776618958,
0.39859700202941895,
0.38714489340782166,
0.3407532572746277,
0.9232391715049744,
-0.4172447621822357,
0.9432043433189392,
0.4045640230178833,
-0.994986355304718,
0.34517741203308105,
0.17308950424194336,
0.26497766375541687,
0.3346417248249054,
0.344144344329834,
-0.19145508110523224,
-0.552430272102356,
-0.822494626045227,
-0.738717257976532,
0.9347783327102661,
0.6033141016960144,
0.2513028085231781,
0.20895035564899445,
0.19280703365802765,
0.11032421141862869,
0.0411091074347496,
-0.7293967008590698,
-0.07125270366668701,
-0.3245224356651306,
-0.3966716229915619,
-0.5186159610748291,
-0.17829731106758118,
0.4964519739151001,
-0.23355410993099213,
0.632041335105896,
0.07191701233386993,
0.514416515827179,
-0.07522209733724594,
-0.35958340764045715,
-0.0852324590086937,
0.3970927596092224,
0.418170690536499,
0.4489065110683441,
-0.28492048382759094,
0.41703325510025024,
0.34141385555267334,
-0.22687660157680511,
0.4156520664691925,
-0.09453004598617554,
0.016037918627262115,
0.3449450433254242,
0.34088465571403503,
0.7979171872138977,
0.39333638548851013,
-0.5790786147117615,
0.7743071913719177,
0.057967834174633026,
0.19305717945098877,
-0.7669022679328918,
-0.06931295245885849,
-0.14648793637752533,
0.11966896802186966,
0.031515032052993774,
0.3614223301410675,
0.15409903228282928,
-0.5066290497779846,
0.3266350030899048,
0.12272102385759354,
-1.1181033849716187,
-0.4767599403858185,
0.782202422618866,
-0.011260458268225193,
-0.25154587626457214,
0.6350794434547424,
-0.15569888055324554,
-0.9602827429771423,
0.7849512696266174,
0.38775554299354553,
1.035893201828003,
-0.14304840564727783,
0.05741741135716438,
0.29256054759025574,
0.4251304566860199,
-0.03653036057949066,
-0.539423942565918,
0.0840606838464737,
-0.751436173915863,
-0.4626142084598541,
-0.5179607272148132,
-0.06430255621671677,
-0.2611813247203827,
-0.9572190642356873,
0.5539527535438538,
-0.0005642210599035025,
-0.19136661291122437,
0.27004095911979675,
-0.2549797296524048,
-0.7009683847427368,
-0.06293296068906784,
-0.08042017370462418,
0.7018004059791565,
-0.9075217843055725,
0.6009556651115417,
0.6991000771522522,
-0.5481562614440918,
-0.5281258821487427,
-0.027820060029625893,
-0.17934547364711761,
-0.7368363738059998,
0.48994559049606323,
0.1723555028438568,
-0.04346335306763649,
0.1239694356918335,
-0.3496876060962677,
-0.6670981049537659,
0.5456823706626892,
0.5110129117965698,
-0.2938151955604553,
-0.3439973294734955,
0.10616013407707214,
0.4160858690738678,
-0.41695570945739746,
0.522107720375061,
0.6236382722854614,
0.27641719579696655,
0.11943904310464859,
-1.1268844604492188,
0.017129210755228996,
-0.13251855969429016,
-0.027159642428159714,
0.1890254020690918,
-0.0999273955821991,
0.44458436965942383,
-0.23165090382099152,
-0.049007583409547806,
0.30071884393692017,
0.535167396068573,
-0.16120947897434235,
-0.0395328626036644,
0.670843243598938,
0.28215286135673523,
0.01037933211773634,
0.13725680112838745,
1.1063534021377563,
0.22923430800437927,
0.6450589299201965,
1.133288025856018,
-0.17037555575370789,
0.7552796006202698,
0.58380126953125,
-0.32962414622306824,
0.32231831550598145,
0.46405041217803955,
-0.33298459649086,
0.7909090518951416,
0.0945415124297142,
0.05253524333238602,
-0.0450909286737442,
-0.5423827171325684,
-0.15450844168663025,
0.6150763630867004,
0.377813458442688,
-0.7046955227851868,
-0.09335219860076904,
0.08096762746572495,
-0.044908307492733,
-0.13740654289722443,
-0.2759650647640228,
0.8396005034446716,
0.3678743839263916,
-0.6934862732887268,
0.6561124920845032,
0.0287419855594635,
0.6598437428474426,
-0.5593575239181519,
0.14968077838420868,
0.2254556566476822,
0.5649043917655945,
-0.16784702241420746,
-0.8625748157501221,
0.5501936078071594,
0.1735755354166031,
-0.17062808573246002,
-0.13750791549682617,
0.6451597809791565,
-0.5582373142242432,
-0.7208006381988525,
0.08263232558965683,
-0.01881534792482853,
0.22938044369220734,
-0.2954181432723999,
-0.3619362413883209,
-0.3345465064048767,
0.22309915721416473,
-0.2510780692100525,
-0.12479206919670105,
0.3522226810455322,
0.04279753193259239,
0.7809185981750488,
0.10308507084846497,
0.097629614174366,
0.3418232798576355,
-0.1845806986093521,
0.5691474080085754,
-0.557553768157959,
-0.504696249961853,
-0.8063556551933289,
0.4413161873817444,
0.1536639928817749,
-0.3044115900993347,
0.5975936651229858,
0.43545278906822205,
0.8630979061126709,
-0.2814250588417053,
0.6356465816497803,
0.024127062410116196,
0.22154274582862854,
-0.5590479373931885,
0.6303841471672058,
-1.1197972297668457,
0.10878685861825943,
-0.43513718247413635,
-1.4158623218536377,
-0.16593022644519806,
0.7562858462333679,
-0.2485896497964859,
0.08063279837369919,
0.5861683487892151,
0.8760112524032593,
-0.5202004313468933,
0.38570934534072876,
0.26983872056007385,
0.29784315824508667,
0.4185456931591034,
0.5410255193710327,
1.0971837043762207,
-0.545667827129364,
0.53423011302948,
-0.43444880843162537,
0.15790629386901855,
-0.35394424200057983,
-0.8604934811592102,
-0.5664811134338379,
-0.5558683276176453,
-0.47396931052207947,
-0.022064801305532455,
-0.20811721682548523,
0.9099584817886353,
0.3914788067340851,
-0.7846409678459167,
0.038740821182727814,
-0.16529418528079987,
-0.06876862794160843,
-0.004851485136896372,
-0.2544817626476288,
0.3032660484313965,
-0.05348064377903938,
-0.5148065686225891,
-0.06572026759386063,
-0.08707237243652344,
0.09949491918087006,
-0.5689268708229065,
0.042737819254398346,
0.04418397322297096,
0.08711322396993637,
0.511947751045227,
-0.11813630163669586,
-0.980181097984314,
-0.451956570148468,
0.08152735233306885,
-0.1388188749551773,
0.028486240655183792,
0.9898679852485657,
-0.7249854803085327,
0.5036245584487915,
0.28554368019104004,
0.3453920781612396,
0.3118400275707245,
-0.048122864216566086,
0.8189154863357544,
-0.8414776921272278,
0.2450287640094757,
0.4401879906654358,
0.23761442303657532,
0.5007303357124329,
-0.05293835699558258,
0.36183369159698486,
-0.010582821443676949,
-0.4715406000614166,
-0.8333913683891296,
0.3573121130466461,
-0.7160764336585999,
-0.08962441235780716,
1.06148362159729,
-0.2460964471101761,
-0.13761869072914124,
-0.12542030215263367,
0.14201237261295319,
0.36838260293006897,
-0.22301363945007324,
0.4209744334220886,
0.7063716650009155,
0.43272778391838074,
-0.21380873024463654,
-0.5037915706634521,
0.3119957149028778,
0.7760487198829651,
-0.1562570035457611,
0.05932311713695526,
0.08502701669931412,
0.01495850458741188,
0.21932679414749146,
0.17427591979503632,
-0.026968518272042274,
-0.005791868548840284,
0.07375721633434296,
-0.04451534524559975,
0.3454301953315735,
-0.2621169686317444,
-0.3894955813884735,
-0.1406068503856659,
0.20710329711437225,
-0.24705617129802704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02872v2 | How do Large Language Models Learn In-Context? Query and Key Matrices of In-Context Heads are Two Towers for Metric Learning | 2024-02-05T10:39:32 | 2024-06-11T12:58:51 | Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We investigate the mechanism of in-context learning (ICL) on sentence
classification tasks with semantically-unrelated labels ("foo"/"bar"). We find
intervening in only 1\% heads (named "in-context heads") significantly affects
ICL accuracy from 87.6\% to 24.4\%. To understand this phenomenon, we analyze
the value-output vectors in these heads and discover that the vectors at each
label position contain substantial information about the corresponding labels.
Furthermore, we observe that the prediction shift from "foo" to "bar" is due to
the respective reduction and increase in these heads' attention scores at "foo"
and "bar" positions. Therefore, we propose a hypothesis for ICL: in in-context
heads, the value-output matrices extract label features, while the query-key
matrices compute the similarity between the features at the last position and
those at each label position. The query and key matrices can be considered as
two towers that learn the similarity metric between the last position's
features and each demonstration at label positions. Using this hypothesis, we
explain the majority label bias and recency bias in ICL and propose two methods
to reduce these biases by 22\% and 17\%, respectively. | [
-0.45193228125572205,
-0.7153669595718384,
0.46778804063796997,
-0.1698475182056427,
-0.11106308549642563,
-0.036309290677309036,
-0.2953716516494751,
-0.42076894640922546,
-0.29913821816444397,
0.47242918610572815,
-0.3715609014034271,
-0.7491359710693359,
-0.5090569257736206,
-0.11968744546175003,
-0.3157796561717987,
1.27840256690979,
0.27978911995887756,
0.08332300186157227,
-0.3718624413013458,
-0.3694992661476135,
-0.7187782526016235,
-0.7298291325569153,
-0.5675333738327026,
-0.25551801919937134,
0.45899781584739685,
0.649398922920227,
0.4338808059692383,
0.589332640171051,
0.47489017248153687,
0.14840397238731384,
-0.22686874866485596,
-0.15688548982143402,
-0.7714635133743286,
0.15274296700954437,
-0.3098292052745819,
-0.7628488540649414,
-0.14684927463531494,
-0.05672132596373558,
0.8266728520393372,
0.9372528791427612,
0.31559574604034424,
0.3300395607948303,
0.4513588547706604,
0.9381652474403381,
-0.6980924606323242,
0.413839727640152,
-1.0582271814346313,
0.05203861743211746,
-0.3787469267845154,
-0.34238097071647644,
-0.740723192691803,
-0.050099149346351624,
0.369760662317276,
-0.3323221802711487,
0.04101250320672989,
0.29695942997932434,
0.7676135301589966,
0.3323627710342407,
-0.6263729929924011,
-0.3521997034549713,
-0.41512879729270935,
0.9343315362930298,
-0.43729811906814575,
0.5521813035011292,
0.4933675229549408,
0.1486060470342636,
-0.3066188097000122,
-0.5748735666275024,
-0.4155239760875702,
-0.3524560034275055,
-0.15618497133255005,
-0.09616655856370926,
-0.16399459540843964,
0.095049187541008,
0.5361223816871643,
-0.10928606986999512,
-0.36760109663009644,
0.2522219121456146,
-0.400977224111557,
0.19988088309764862,
0.33574819564819336,
0.030144711956381798,
0.14272616803646088,
0.09225247800350189,
-0.47127866744995117,
-0.24452504515647888,
-1.2230567932128906,
0.3807402551174164,
-0.16125892102718353,
0.4563533067703247,
0.1414523422718048,
0.3895556926727295,
-0.020322460681200027,
0.9213275909423828,
0.3245965540409088,
-0.46379637718200684,
0.2683242857456207,
-0.030361192300915718,
-0.4076419174671173,
0.27444717288017273,
0.5483811497688293,
0.24081754684448242,
0.3668750524520874,
-0.21789607405662537,
-0.16945046186447144,
-0.08059749752283096,
0.16568170487880707,
-0.7347425222396851,
-0.04929324984550476,
-0.053137943148612976,
-0.4716360569000244,
0.006898539140820503,
0.06264112889766693,
-0.2191062718629837,
-0.027835743501782417,
-0.553019106388092,
0.48650139570236206,
-0.38444164395332336,
0.24092857539653778,
-0.15539272129535675,
0.1053163930773735,
0.21549023687839508,
0.18523713946342468,
-0.6656516194343567,
0.32387566566467285,
0.6648908257484436,
0.7361087203025818,
-0.35227611660957336,
-0.32697606086730957,
-0.7224748730659485,
0.14763101935386658,
-0.3365636467933655,
0.6423947215080261,
-0.6079826951026917,
-0.14079056680202484,
-0.06664519757032394,
-0.05277223140001297,
-0.10499367117881775,
-0.7747274041175842,
0.3235324025154114,
-0.6575228571891785,
0.08730243891477585,
-0.4409944713115692,
-0.7291221022605896,
-0.48881465196609497,
0.15352283418178558,
-0.4465738832950592,
0.8145639300346375,
0.03913525119423866,
-0.9637650847434998,
0.6847293972969055,
-0.5873639583587646,
-0.4599088132381439,
-0.06417878717184067,
-0.24664343893527985,
-0.26729217171669006,
0.08883904665708542,
0.021424531936645508,
0.7492522597312927,
-0.2730034589767456,
0.20092548429965973,
-0.3401123881340027,
-0.5921940207481384,
0.6912517547607422,
-0.17490257322788239,
0.9158470034599304,
0.09251179546117783,
-0.46160808205604553,
-0.04737935960292816,
-0.579159140586853,
-0.1109587624669075,
-0.2542504668235779,
-0.34854650497436523,
-0.6450711488723755,
0.2132769227027893,
0.07410485297441483,
0.5047039985656738,
-0.23984098434448242,
-0.5078956484794617,
0.05534562095999718,
-0.4455757141113281,
0.4198959171772003,
0.5006136894226074,
0.002907856134697795,
0.4483245015144348,
-0.2101634442806244,
0.32181671261787415,
0.22525982558727264,
-0.3723854124546051,
-0.018923291936516762,
-0.2614031434059143,
-0.6226640343666077,
-0.13926748931407928,
0.21798208355903625,
0.31562554836273193,
-0.5184678435325623,
0.26833921670913696,
-0.3373543918132782,
-0.32335832715034485,
-0.3747720718383789,
-0.027915937826037407,
0.6972305774688721,
0.9344741106033325,
0.31320396065711975,
-0.2578984498977661,
-0.2532995939254761,
-1.0549795627593994,
-0.22418302297592163,
-0.25249043107032776,
-0.04324674978852272,
0.25957974791526794,
0.6074113845825195,
0.076649010181427,
1.1868382692337036,
-0.442229688167572,
-0.5474060773849487,
-0.11619942635297775,
-0.03105928935110569,
0.14016297459602356,
0.537055492401123,
0.6809878349304199,
-0.8350680470466614,
-0.7586244940757751,
-0.033817216753959656,
-0.6250777840614319,
-0.06430995464324951,
0.09445904940366745,
-0.048434264957904816,
0.33276909589767456,
1.026761531829834,
-0.43020838499069214,
0.3502601683139801,
0.1530616581439972,
-0.17731796205043793,
0.3427937924861908,
0.042723193764686584,
-0.2120482176542282,
-0.9989297389984131,
0.031733375042676926,
0.25354471802711487,
-0.18494382500648499,
-0.5724886655807495,
0.17535929381847382,
0.20346854627132416,
0.13867275416851044,
-0.49044713377952576,
0.48895010352134705,
-0.43417370319366455,
-0.28440728783607483,
-0.33341333270072937,
0.40570083260536194,
-0.08307231962680817,
0.7787968516349792,
-0.04343390092253685,
0.7928212285041809,
0.5448945760726929,
-0.8388469815254211,
-0.2703530192375183,
0.16107608377933502,
-0.7025798559188843,
0.7267504930496216,
-0.4078296720981598,
0.021494071930646896,
-0.3697153925895691,
0.5637088418006897,
-1.3838266134262085,
0.053273048251867294,
0.05436411872506142,
-0.5250061750411987,
0.42854630947113037,
-0.08298441022634506,
-0.43025869131088257,
0.020451530814170837,
-0.0008796705515123904,
0.520962655544281,
0.31474438309669495,
-0.6217209696769714,
-0.013055207207798958,
0.7669425010681152,
0.13039441406726837,
-0.7372928857803345,
-0.9008726477622986,
-0.17521603405475616,
-0.4679945707321167,
-0.15106970071792603,
0.4643247425556183,
-0.010147173888981342,
-0.4186805188655853,
0.04655730724334717,
0.12241092324256897,
-0.09646337479352951,
0.13002218306064606,
0.23578211665153503,
0.05432996153831482,
-0.26114940643310547,
0.7196641564369202,
-0.12484554201364517,
0.014945406466722488,
0.19785486161708832,
-0.6131048202514648,
0.3118166923522949,
-0.2058236002922058,
-0.18609830737113953,
-0.481050044298172,
0.09939476102590561,
0.8417961001396179,
-0.19911684095859528,
0.7792326807975769,
0.35706910490989685,
-0.41194096207618713,
-0.21619637310504913,
-0.27751779556274414,
-0.2565373182296753,
-0.3509380519390106,
0.7807788848876953,
-0.6480593681335449,
-0.9607481360435486,
0.4140608310699463,
0.10517355799674988,
0.044060975313186646,
0.4707591235637665,
0.5971110463142395,
-0.12231818586587906,
1.1368664503097534,
0.6692845821380615,
-0.3068375885486603,
0.4349260926246643,
-0.2744465172290802,
0.28406789898872375,
-1.2070705890655518,
-0.14273487031459808,
-0.5652379393577576,
-0.6073524355888367,
-0.7467131614685059,
-0.14729206264019012,
0.657390832901001,
0.15579773485660553,
-0.3643423616886139,
0.3029822111129761,
-0.39387086033821106,
0.49949732422828674,
0.5612902641296387,
0.1595063954591751,
0.11456797271966934,
0.027266545221209526,
-0.2845921814441681,
-0.1963227242231369,
-0.7599064707756042,
-0.12580537796020508,
1.083701729774475,
0.2790015637874603,
0.6308289766311646,
0.006602031644433737,
0.2600565552711487,
0.0998838022351265,
0.30475494265556335,
-0.9792096018791199,
0.33750003576278687,
-0.10410462319850922,
-0.5649617314338684,
-0.24026983976364136,
-0.15104052424430847,
-0.9509943723678589,
0.5468884110450745,
-0.13771258294582367,
-0.9440351724624634,
0.09303266555070877,
0.10617285966873169,
-0.28854936361312866,
0.26900336146354675,
-0.5309453010559082,
0.8663772940635681,
-0.10249000042676926,
-0.31018146872520447,
-0.3062722980976105,
-0.9003157615661621,
0.3131594657897949,
-0.0777592733502388,
0.13991238176822662,
0.09009021520614624,
0.11404303461313248,
0.6998628973960876,
-0.06592947244644165,
0.8879663944244385,
-0.07765918970108032,
0.0796184167265892,
0.18836252391338348,
0.1004767045378685,
0.3596345782279968,
-0.0238067414611578,
0.16139724850654602,
0.048168230801820755,
-0.20195432007312775,
-0.2130490094423294,
-0.6109449863433838,
0.5372166037559509,
-0.6538412570953369,
-0.43794524669647217,
-0.28180980682373047,
-0.7173135280609131,
-0.37515950202941895,
-0.059762872755527496,
0.4515995979309082,
0.7593259215354919,
-0.06457503139972687,
0.7863010764122009,
0.8767653107643127,
-0.1763506829738617,
0.3381386995315552,
0.5074418187141418,
-0.1832132339477539,
0.02590716816484928,
0.649153470993042,
0.4125281274318695,
0.49639517068862915,
0.882290244102478,
0.10614140331745148,
-0.2980493903160095,
-0.44479548931121826,
-0.1256563365459442,
0.19043521583080292,
-0.927571177482605,
-0.30474305152893066,
-0.7905847430229187,
-0.16563239693641663,
-0.14578314125537872,
-0.20019613206386566,
-0.0801951214671135,
-0.34102514386177063,
-0.20753349363803864,
-0.12687192857265472,
0.13651323318481445,
0.6658015847206116,
0.3514938950538635,
0.4338747560977936,
-0.43560704588890076,
-0.1787262111902237,
0.07036737352609634,
0.04196161404252052,
0.33525633811950684,
-0.7920446991920471,
-0.5077154636383057,
-0.017835689708590508,
-0.291615754365921,
-0.6805776953697205,
0.4201214611530304,
0.3435627222061157,
0.35056591033935547,
0.5836575031280518,
0.002502004848793149,
0.7082091569900513,
-0.5758119225502014,
0.509871780872345,
-0.11773775517940521,
-0.9189924597740173,
0.23440100252628326,
-0.15817119181156158,
0.6071418523788452,
0.6138043403625488,
0.4672839343547821,
-0.8251160979270935,
-0.6038069128990173,
-0.5100137591362,
-0.6514008045196533,
0.9011173248291016,
-0.08934143930673599,
-0.1150188148021698,
-0.08252506703138351,
0.33963754773139954,
0.22093088924884796,
0.22614271938800812,
-0.8191654682159424,
-0.282645583152771,
0.2792547643184662,
-0.1813138872385025,
-0.20055176317691803,
-0.2540135681629181,
0.11237132549285889,
-0.36694470047950745,
0.5824503898620605,
-0.28566473722457886,
0.21509288251399994,
0.04781027510762215,
-0.4546900987625122,
0.05939562991261482,
0.13244809210300446,
0.7311866879463196,
1.0227108001708984,
-0.33910733461380005,
0.2197241336107254,
0.3374086618423462,
-0.22974801063537598,
-0.12592755258083344,
-0.40743646025657654,
-0.31972289085388184,
-0.05872543901205063,
0.4162636399269104,
1.0677263736724854,
0.5721229910850525,
-0.6198863983154297,
0.5060091614723206,
0.09867627918720245,
0.07566402107477188,
-0.3278161287307739,
-0.1903427541255951,
0.01230717170983553,
0.13077962398529053,
0.45877134799957275,
0.0219084732234478,
0.2397148460149765,
-0.7531027793884277,
0.3653230667114258,
0.6297818422317505,
-0.7634953260421753,
-0.3715437054634094,
0.6419804692268372,
-0.2181369960308075,
-0.05650252848863602,
0.5829143524169922,
-0.046094443649053574,
-0.6917712092399597,
0.6293381452560425,
0.8988544344902039,
0.828165590763092,
0.035379935055971146,
0.014902313239872456,
0.4710637629032135,
0.07773735374212265,
0.15783943235874176,
-0.2318073809146881,
-0.30195415019989014,
-0.7599837183952332,
-0.25269386172294617,
-0.47234028577804565,
-0.27593088150024414,
0.19157324731349945,
-0.7781397104263306,
0.16547004878520966,
-0.2505340576171875,
0.010801748372614384,
0.06599117070436478,
-0.052504200488328934,
-0.6788737177848816,
0.301401287317276,
0.13364911079406738,
0.7415754199028015,
-0.7759789228439331,
1.0589419603347778,
0.6564079523086548,
-0.31472164392471313,
-0.6856350302696228,
0.3328821063041687,
0.020646773278713226,
-0.7242259979248047,
1.3061407804489136,
0.44937559962272644,
-0.16788993775844574,
0.003976976498961449,
-0.6547027230262756,
-1.208558440208435,
0.8609606027603149,
0.30519241094589233,
-0.39850127696990967,
0.013469927944242954,
0.03433515131473541,
0.5346732139587402,
-0.7580400109291077,
0.27009788155555725,
0.48013052344322205,
0.19873642921447754,
-0.1443169265985489,
-0.9331928491592407,
-0.07835762202739716,
0.1198311373591423,
0.09213104844093323,
0.1116715669631958,
-0.6979138255119324,
0.972456693649292,
0.009866091422736645,
-0.2359127253293991,
-0.3996656835079193,
0.685785174369812,
0.23841291666030884,
0.17341944575309753,
0.5185315012931824,
0.35002899169921875,
0.7449836730957031,
0.03294019401073456,
1.0315165519714355,
-0.35260143876075745,
0.3502064347267151,
1.0782196521759033,
-0.30969175696372986,
1.0994371175765991,
0.44687578082084656,
-0.04866105690598488,
0.669930100440979,
0.7158403992652893,
0.35298699140548706,
0.6387832760810852,
0.21918940544128418,
0.05111188441514969,
0.04865847900509834,
-0.14482995867729187,
-0.11027644574642181,
0.7613896131515503,
0.6820517778396606,
-0.393999308347702,
-0.13057561218738556,
0.38833510875701904,
0.31082683801651,
-0.05105048418045044,
-0.4399750530719757,
0.7967104911804199,
0.22787411510944366,
-1.0280449390411377,
0.7619614005088806,
-0.08925115317106247,
0.44206392765045166,
-0.38902077078819275,
0.11496797949075699,
-0.09410504996776581,
0.531385600566864,
-0.031085675582289696,
-0.7614903450012207,
0.12209425866603851,
-0.30514851212501526,
-0.4073316156864166,
-0.024793699383735657,
0.49056491255760193,
-0.6858096122741699,
-0.1785728633403778,
0.24064669013023376,
0.1745578944683075,
0.23247919976711273,
-0.16769513487815857,
-0.6230201721191406,
-0.19516833126544952,
0.00039441819535568357,
-0.04764566943049431,
0.5961459875106812,
0.432176798582077,
-0.35121679306030273,
0.6912676095962524,
0.2225184589624405,
-0.028050053864717484,
-0.03340044245123863,
-0.22020933032035828,
0.6424497365951538,
-0.5127516984939575,
-0.6679572463035583,
-0.9072818756103516,
0.17839227616786957,
0.08069100975990295,
-0.44265618920326233,
0.6735913157463074,
0.45542412996292114,
1.4408081769943237,
-0.07479007542133331,
0.6137036085128784,
0.14644519984722137,
0.585440456867218,
-0.7127317190170288,
0.6844549179077148,
-0.7537292838096619,
-0.07701383531093597,
-0.2270570695400238,
-1.1395243406295776,
-0.4642973840236664,
0.5715879201889038,
-0.29388830065727234,
-0.09759256988763809,
1.0170276165008545,
0.7365802526473999,
-0.0920717716217041,
-0.31471961736679077,
0.3455307185649872,
0.3960845172405243,
0.21658508479595184,
0.7785307168960571,
0.4714325964450836,
-0.2812504768371582,
0.335683673620224,
-0.09647127240896225,
-0.15283869206905365,
-0.3948163092136383,
-0.5926764607429504,
-0.9727677702903748,
-0.9553871750831604,
-0.20104537904262543,
-0.315386563539505,
0.08706306666135788,
1.0528348684310913,
0.7996150255203247,
-0.8957241773605347,
-0.5727021098136902,
0.009016244672238827,
0.09868212044239044,
-0.2710402011871338,
-0.27727454900741577,
0.7608947157859802,
-0.5832520127296448,
-0.7620980143547058,
0.23803041875362396,
0.4315548539161682,
-0.43389901518821716,
-0.17896097898483276,
0.09891115128993988,
-0.34455230832099915,
-0.2575322687625885,
0.8236616253852844,
0.2753368020057678,
-0.9166501760482788,
-0.3866759240627289,
-0.10842110961675644,
-0.40395140647888184,
0.3613605201244354,
0.6829839944839478,
-1.0771985054016113,
0.4087546467781067,
0.4974357783794403,
0.7596665024757385,
0.3795962929725647,
0.08190613240003586,
0.45110803842544556,
-0.9336665868759155,
0.26410815119743347,
0.04860280454158783,
0.2752230167388916,
0.3241524398326874,
-0.34007588028907776,
0.3627477288246155,
0.19500869512557983,
-0.7370532155036926,
-0.707696259021759,
0.33403506875038147,
-0.769032895565033,
-0.4516025185585022,
1.0562807321548462,
-0.029264336451888084,
-0.4283338785171509,
-0.04999307915568352,
-0.2615868151187897,
0.27189937233924866,
-0.19684579968452454,
0.8530463576316833,
0.7563980221748352,
-0.19774027168750763,
0.06947510689496994,
-0.67255038022995,
0.6785444617271423,
0.4754166007041931,
-0.39041438698768616,
-0.060397032648324966,
0.3897520899772644,
0.22226561605930328,
0.12344931066036224,
0.4206749200820923,
-0.03702700510621071,
0.20813536643981934,
-0.3894004225730896,
-0.08117461949586868,
0.33154457807540894,
-0.4711964428424835,
-0.3335769474506378,
0.3626157343387604,
0.1634293645620346,
-0.3118245005607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02864v1 | EEVEE: An Easy Annotation Tool for Natural Language Processing | 2024-02-05T10:24:40 | 2024-02-05T10:24:40 | Axel Sorensen, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank, Rob van der Goot | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Annotation tools are the starting point for creating Natural Language
Processing (NLP) datasets. There is a wide variety of tools available; setting
up these tools is however a hindrance. We propose EEVEE, an annotation tool
focused on simplicity, efficiency, and ease of use. It can run directly in the
browser (no setup required) and uses tab-separated files (as opposed to
character offsets or task-specific formats) for annotation. It allows for
annotation of multiple tasks on a single dataset and supports four task-types:
sequence labeling, span labeling, text classification and seq2seq. | [
-0.7368868589401245,
-0.7674071192741394,
0.30882006883621216,
0.5689475536346436,
-0.18306615948677063,
-0.14817796647548676,
-0.3782272934913635,
-0.7387459874153137,
0.45959872007369995,
0.6128904819488525,
-0.7014099955558777,
-0.5674787163734436,
-0.47525838017463684,
0.4175432324409485,
-0.41455546021461487,
0.8134949803352356,
0.3155807852745056,
-0.2645642161369324,
0.009794987738132477,
-0.1858784705400467,
-0.7275024652481079,
-0.11813725531101227,
-0.9618749618530273,
-0.24722003936767578,
0.629311203956604,
0.4488866925239563,
0.35118475556373596,
0.4322129786014557,
0.4652806520462036,
0.314008891582489,
0.23592780530452728,
0.1575792282819748,
-0.1824844628572464,
0.5322535634040833,
0.019022155553102493,
-0.5440553426742554,
-0.31665563583374023,
0.13969624042510986,
0.08594413101673126,
0.924934446811676,
0.05428706482052803,
0.29241588711738586,
0.15981896221637726,
0.5494096279144287,
-0.5946032404899597,
-0.007895623333752155,
-0.24605879187583923,
0.08553361892700195,
-0.4992961883544922,
-0.019990362226963043,
-0.32336023449897766,
-0.6865829229354858,
0.3131997883319855,
-1.0160387754440308,
0.03691262751817703,
0.1365044265985489,
0.6422246098518372,
0.4592370092868805,
-0.35049182176589966,
-0.2129364013671875,
-0.5799255967140198,
0.54549241065979,
-0.32120993733406067,
0.44557031989097595,
0.2989116907119751,
0.3997734785079956,
-0.10671749711036682,
-1.0002509355545044,
-0.6012033820152283,
0.014619282446801662,
-0.1001184731721878,
-0.13739052414894104,
0.15569967031478882,
0.1912662237882614,
0.42915308475494385,
0.19137689471244812,
-0.5099343061447144,
0.1394267976284027,
0.03417729213833809,
-0.24338427186012268,
0.44593140482902527,
-0.05828588828444481,
0.44507938623428345,
-0.23205505311489105,
-0.27791252732276917,
-0.11751803755760193,
-0.15793739259243011,
0.0007340465672314167,
0.034984931349754333,
0.4202636778354645,
0.34757915139198303,
0.7285033464431763,
-0.13638091087341309,
0.6545230746269226,
-0.17127381265163422,
-0.0037481579929590225,
0.3719123601913452,
0.15876664221286774,
-0.5931375026702881,
0.1553262621164322,
0.5599437952041626,
0.35797300934791565,
0.18932291865348816,
-0.2835959494113922,
0.0011709841201081872,
0.23770952224731445,
0.2613891363143921,
-0.6095713376998901,
-0.2760763168334961,
0.46542125940322876,
-0.20885667204856873,
-0.18678569793701172,
-0.06203746050596237,
-0.991970956325531,
-0.6784297823905945,
-0.6467461585998535,
0.3265707790851593,
-0.6504021883010864,
0.1756616234779358,
0.19899770617485046,
-0.44602227210998535,
0.24692818522453308,
0.6165484189987183,
-0.6871787309646606,
0.7172858119010925,
0.549140453338623,
0.7612103819847107,
-0.06856120377779007,
-0.2527082562446594,
-0.7824337482452393,
-0.007745535112917423,
0.08113591372966766,
1.1054680347442627,
-0.5941352844238281,
-0.3751833140850067,
-0.03952972963452339,
0.06227411702275276,
-0.0708499401807785,
-0.07651589810848236,
0.8877905011177063,
-0.16746467351913452,
0.2155655324459076,
-0.23864193260669708,
-0.9401807188987732,
-0.6317519545555115,
0.02844010852277279,
-1.0330010652542114,
1.528731346130371,
-0.21765631437301636,
-0.8086745142936707,
0.6807819604873657,
-1.0466972589492798,
-0.47351664304733276,
0.6149669289588928,
-0.14983229339122772,
0.14773951470851898,
0.0381302535533905,
0.3054662048816681,
0.5572023391723633,
-0.17641718685626984,
-0.17168740928173065,
-0.013673461973667145,
-0.1100258007645607,
-0.26708242297172546,
-0.16707168519496918,
0.8932175636291504,
0.19078321754932404,
-0.5026383399963379,
-0.207665354013443,
-1.0709301233291626,
0.198144793510437,
0.07650502771139145,
-0.3758811950683594,
-0.6721758842468262,
0.08398336172103882,
0.603827178478241,
0.04857450723648071,
0.19968844950199127,
-0.713654637336731,
0.5355921983718872,
-0.45436879992485046,
0.08518947660923004,
0.3797855079174042,
0.035707026720047,
0.3306090235710144,
0.12926286458969116,
0.33024609088897705,
-0.49163222312927246,
-0.01922796666622162,
-0.2531092166900635,
-0.881729006767273,
-0.7543671727180481,
-0.4538763761520386,
0.3994201123714447,
1.0178536176681519,
-0.5179373621940613,
0.592848002910614,
-0.0909879058599472,
-0.6680941581726074,
-0.6929745078086853,
0.07586418837308884,
0.019419968128204346,
0.23028427362442017,
0.40311217308044434,
-0.05143887177109718,
-0.6778270602226257,
-1.1006816625595093,
-0.36041754484176636,
0.19997620582580566,
-0.1522500365972519,
-0.11725004017353058,
0.4686051905155182,
-0.1880410611629486,
1.2008191347122192,
-0.5671553611755371,
-0.34491240978240967,
-0.05770578980445862,
0.7498601675033569,
-0.10126213729381561,
0.2945406138896942,
0.43243545293807983,
-0.9542047381401062,
-0.47311875224113464,
0.18199004232883453,
-0.5732261538505554,
-0.5678065419197083,
-0.13810278475284576,
-0.13044318556785583,
0.05236626788973808,
0.3421482443809509,
-0.4422697424888611,
0.4537033140659332,
0.31447526812553406,
-0.40629953145980835,
0.10213325917720795,
0.05822455883026123,
0.3057660162448883,
-0.8267066478729248,
0.1981886625289917,
0.21905572712421417,
-0.5067752003669739,
-0.7785317897796631,
-0.17193618416786194,
0.022352194413542747,
-0.028307434171438217,
-0.33170589804649353,
0.509704053401947,
-0.3167378604412079,
0.25962573289871216,
-0.083792544901371,
0.3935420513153076,
0.22674939036369324,
0.2149399220943451,
0.2050842046737671,
0.523093581199646,
0.5291218161582947,
-0.5804083943367004,
0.3640943467617035,
0.3290621340274811,
0.04544951766729355,
0.5756170153617859,
-0.3376055955886841,
0.4101238250732422,
-0.25263530015945435,
-0.38478973507881165,
-0.7230561375617981,
-0.3571268916130066,
0.09162366390228271,
-0.2669237554073334,
0.2837403118610382,
0.02544979937374592,
-0.3144442141056061,
-0.23073850572109222,
-0.6227657198905945,
-0.14113961160182953,
0.23808234930038452,
-0.6235362887382507,
0.7479830980300903,
0.5213668942451477,
-0.29673343896865845,
-0.3426576256752014,
-0.7831531763076782,
0.2846326231956482,
-0.30303701758384705,
-0.7897602319717407,
0.30359598994255066,
-0.059513021260499954,
-0.15269100666046143,
0.09724356979131699,
0.10124053061008453,
-0.2567046880722046,
0.0403343103826046,
0.41534897685050964,
0.0159742571413517,
-0.025235557928681374,
0.29914095997810364,
-0.0912894681096077,
-0.11648223549127579,
-0.3290250301361084,
0.0028900185134261847,
0.2901837229728699,
-0.1377425491809845,
-0.2040930986404419,
-0.15205056965351105,
0.6892072558403015,
0.1836777925491333,
-0.24434196949005127,
0.3583827614784241,
0.5986810922622681,
-1.006374478340149,
-0.4936003088951111,
-0.8589345216751099,
0.050115395337343216,
-0.4311676621437073,
0.25487852096557617,
-0.36452141404151917,
-0.8050200343132019,
0.3134399950504303,
-0.24943716824054718,
0.423104852437973,
0.44844958186149597,
0.2509617209434509,
-0.1982143670320511,
0.6450161337852478,
0.748855471611023,
0.23161202669143677,
0.2583034634590149,
0.14822044968605042,
0.3207274377346039,
-0.6579198837280273,
-0.3839869201183319,
-0.7611709237098694,
-0.2637098729610443,
-0.39083757996559143,
-0.32449576258659363,
-0.014436599798500538,
0.14346152544021606,
0.03449461609125137,
0.46326714754104614,
-0.9109092950820923,
0.6612223982810974,
0.7136877775192261,
-0.34259510040283203,
0.03226619213819504,
-0.09557375311851501,
0.24755364656448364,
-0.2582622170448303,
-0.39953505992889404,
-1.051706314086914,
0.8245333433151245,
0.2318085879087448,
0.5545941591262817,
-0.23313184082508087,
0.9943055510520935,
0.3904295265674591,
0.09856563806533813,
-0.7023255228996277,
0.7800818681716919,
-0.13048957288265228,
-0.5180220603942871,
-0.510519802570343,
0.237184077501297,
-0.9556164145469666,
0.13018439710140228,
-0.5908756852149963,
-1.2418864965438843,
0.2975933849811554,
0.11055228859186172,
-0.5045466423034668,
0.14059078693389893,
-1.1943236589431763,
1.059998631477356,
-0.012268483638763428,
-0.23773637413978577,
0.23261116445064545,
-0.377085417509079,
0.16056779026985168,
0.003054609289392829,
0.2530367374420166,
-0.31226488947868347,
-0.10334201902151108,
0.9637048244476318,
-0.272892564535141,
0.8813155293464661,
-0.3402855396270752,
0.38969308137893677,
0.3901190161705017,
0.29691198468208313,
0.5044037103652954,
0.18897029757499695,
0.18971680104732513,
-0.026326950639486313,
0.11078253388404846,
-0.12301317602396011,
-0.3406355679035187,
0.5335691571235657,
-0.3063282072544098,
-0.38323500752449036,
-0.46494996547698975,
-0.10040697455406189,
-0.04394932836294174,
0.2550187408924103,
0.11259480565786362,
0.290733277797699,
-0.34714919328689575,
0.06719499826431274,
0.6896625757217407,
-0.15121427178382874,
0.6239722967147827,
0.06110689789056778,
-0.44721463322639465,
-0.19671647250652313,
0.5538190007209778,
0.21905314922332764,
-0.3210104703903198,
0.2348291575908661,
-0.0740794762969017,
-0.23189719021320343,
-0.2519778311252594,
-0.1481669843196869,
-0.19975507259368896,
-0.9321062564849854,
-0.06530072540044785,
-0.6242467761039734,
0.15642772614955902,
-0.12414174526929855,
-0.4735923409461975,
-0.5265819430351257,
-0.6347677707672119,
0.09005008637905121,
-0.15200287103652954,
0.6597069501876831,
0.865389883518219,
0.05502016842365265,
0.08095616847276688,
-0.7163456678390503,
0.4965340793132782,
0.7374138832092285,
0.3135814070701599,
-0.5590811371803284,
0.3347097337245941,
-0.17045672237873077,
-0.3134467899799347,
-0.08496295660734177,
-1.2542781829833984,
0.24095655977725983,
0.49979329109191895,
0.45893606543540955,
0.029095636680722237,
-0.26000648736953735,
0.38328611850738525,
-0.6084712147712708,
1.0753957033157349,
0.11974947154521942,
-1.005086898803711,
0.9792457222938538,
0.0226425901055336,
-0.10955982655286789,
0.7308071851730347,
0.21634434163570404,
-0.7086809277534485,
-0.30725497007369995,
-0.29524919390678406,
-1.060557246208191,
0.49514082074165344,
0.41687244176864624,
-0.4493163228034973,
-0.33628901839256287,
0.35451287031173706,
0.5706509351730347,
0.09362445026636124,
-0.6295424103736877,
-0.5359739065170288,
-0.27575093507766724,
-0.15802334249019623,
0.232958123087883,
-0.10364307463169098,
0.01885710097849369,
-0.1725427806377411,
0.7673624753952026,
-0.22193603217601776,
0.3053245544433594,
0.5379853844642639,
-0.25340649485588074,
0.12435472011566162,
0.3180526793003082,
-0.048363491892814636,
0.22276081144809723,
-0.4077345132827759,
0.11801657825708389,
0.3552633225917816,
-0.7231019139289856,
-0.02774779498577118,
0.327082097530365,
-0.12495308369398117,
0.14399832487106323,
0.3089907169342041,
0.7608389258384705,
0.0007409386453218758,
-0.5280945301055908,
0.470472514629364,
-0.13564200699329376,
-0.06772071123123169,
-0.44396907091140747,
0.039983589202165604,
0.31827735900878906,
0.14686058461666107,
0.12999168038368225,
0.2061442881822586,
0.6503907442092896,
-0.10982012003660202,
0.15110985934734344,
0.006574728060513735,
-0.1892404407262802,
-0.1339414119720459,
0.8808695673942566,
0.5058478116989136,
-0.4707525372505188,
0.41681209206581116,
-0.610313892364502,
-0.09978213906288147,
0.4190593361854553,
0.2687751352787018,
1.3536146879196167,
-0.15825337171554565,
0.21304500102996826,
0.2963758707046509,
0.5540344715118408,
-0.01063484512269497,
0.49542665481567383,
0.3606034815311432,
-0.5404743552207947,
-0.982001006603241,
-0.630770206451416,
-0.24314753711223602,
0.04526883363723755,
-0.750074565410614,
0.5810550451278687,
-0.11451592296361923,
-0.24078354239463806,
0.6392703056335449,
-0.18151000142097473,
-1.326784610748291,
0.41399648785591125,
0.5940846800804138,
1.132463812828064,
-0.9973724484443665,
0.8231967091560364,
1.2699087858200073,
-0.43536436557769775,
-0.5289556980133057,
-0.34336793422698975,
0.19285398721694946,
-0.5153449177742004,
0.6690061688423157,
0.5519374012947083,
-0.12027053534984589,
-0.08875449001789093,
-0.3325682580471039,
-0.545129120349884,
1.0685584545135498,
0.1977539360523224,
-0.7544543743133545,
0.07467593252658844,
0.05537235364317894,
0.2912840247154236,
-0.27550050616264343,
0.21466293931007385,
0.9509892463684082,
0.9471260905265808,
-0.6189607381820679,
-0.8879824876785278,
0.03267528489232063,
-0.4381971061229706,
-0.004919322207570076,
0.4025091528892517,
-0.049425121396780014,
0.45645788311958313,
0.297270804643631,
-0.28713515400886536,
-0.5331462025642395,
0.3700520992279053,
-0.3775613307952881,
0.19877910614013672,
0.7578021883964539,
0.7399206757545471,
1.1367374658584595,
-0.3388496935367584,
1.025671124458313,
0.02363014407455921,
0.20630508661270142,
1.0277695655822754,
-0.3129613399505615,
0.7135451436042786,
0.5866259932518005,
-0.3054760694503784,
0.2758171558380127,
0.4884023666381836,
0.08684388548135757,
0.22606681287288666,
-0.05949278548359871,
-0.28463172912597656,
-0.3115079402923584,
-0.010814005509018898,
0.10095711797475815,
0.2791214883327484,
0.4253879189491272,
0.38540181517601013,
-0.2634581923484802,
0.31309762597084045,
-0.012552667409181595,
0.19993358850479126,
-0.28096410632133484,
0.6976637244224548,
-0.0658271536231041,
-0.35095903277397156,
-0.0997881218791008,
-0.2259785681962967,
0.6378874778747559,
-0.6010902523994446,
-0.3436039686203003,
0.24899767339229584,
-0.39638739824295044,
-0.4698230028152466,
-0.9751697778701782,
0.3793383836746216,
-0.012901585549116135,
-0.10945083945989609,
0.018035681918263435,
0.9869283437728882,
-0.1974828541278839,
-0.28915631771087646,
0.3403158187866211,
0.5439609289169312,
0.07476285099983215,
-0.24159076809883118,
-0.5612779855728149,
-0.06286806613206863,
0.19955825805664062,
-1.065669059753418,
-0.15102753043174744,
0.6481167078018188,
0.004714498296380043,
0.6337996125221252,
0.41682106256484985,
0.15246334671974182,
0.507593035697937,
0.13217346370220184,
0.6061018109321594,
-0.9660577774047852,
-0.4101255238056183,
-0.6892030239105225,
0.8875144124031067,
-0.5262163281440735,
-0.5147930383682251,
0.5602009296417236,
0.5500857830047607,
0.41875767707824707,
-0.01978265307843685,
1.2017110586166382,
-0.6452568769454956,
0.8369858860969543,
-0.4305197596549988,
0.056996043771505356,
-0.32891643047332764,
0.1389976590871811,
-0.10965261608362198,
-1.2151914834976196,
-0.7165305018424988,
0.8329273462295532,
-0.0327787846326828,
-0.21706125140190125,
1.0518467426300049,
0.4737716615200043,
0.09828631579875946,
0.5209370851516724,
0.13859166204929352,
0.021940330043435097,
0.2812943458557129,
0.3699696660041809,
0.37039220333099365,
-0.22016184031963348,
0.24602645635604858,
-0.6392971873283386,
-0.23766519129276276,
-0.05580009147524834,
-1.1258411407470703,
-1.0244522094726562,
-0.6026981472969055,
-0.5757778882980347,
0.17029863595962524,
-0.15975405275821686,
1.4602882862091064,
0.6190471053123474,
-0.775641679763794,
0.18306246399879456,
-0.10966141521930695,
-0.37166473269462585,
-0.2833913266658783,
-0.22287830710411072,
0.4189983606338501,
-0.6696706414222717,
-1.0292731523513794,
0.5723749399185181,
0.6091349124908447,
-0.11980817466974258,
-0.02298353798687458,
0.1618138551712036,
-0.37791964411735535,
0.03903231769800186,
0.5886706709861755,
0.3549198806285858,
-0.5406992435455322,
-0.5731330513954163,
-0.32495638728141785,
0.002454818459227681,
0.045634686946868896,
0.571071982383728,
-0.7551180124282837,
0.8416299819946289,
0.38402995467185974,
0.77159184217453,
0.5386084914207458,
-0.40465879440307617,
0.4308784008026123,
-1.0412659645080566,
0.36192750930786133,
0.36109739542007446,
0.5392451286315918,
0.2685299813747406,
-0.3404824733734131,
0.8152072429656982,
0.017273180186748505,
-0.7525566816329956,
-0.6121689677238464,
-0.12806275486946106,
-1.2180089950561523,
-0.19611971080303192,
0.8685050010681152,
0.025089068338274956,
-0.2753966152667999,
-0.45647576451301575,
-0.8384038805961609,
0.1761154979467392,
-0.42384687066078186,
0.27273640036582947,
0.8976354598999023,
-0.26957330107688904,
0.14448916912078857,
-1.1213226318359375,
0.7348806262016296,
0.1358887404203415,
-0.9626713395118713,
-0.06197194382548332,
0.4320744276046753,
0.0806172788143158,
0.4337867200374603,
0.45788145065307617,
0.400064617395401,
0.07561412453651428,
0.18321654200553894,
0.919736921787262,
-0.05998075753450394,
-0.07085088640451431,
-0.08592773973941803,
0.35482338070869446,
0.3023431897163391,
-0.39597228169441223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02844v1 | Comparing Knowledge Sources for Open-Domain Scientific Claim Verification | 2024-02-05T09:57:15 | 2024-02-05T09:57:15 | Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The increasing rate at which scientific knowledge is discovered and health
claims shared online has highlighted the importance of developing efficient
fact-checking systems for scientific claims. The usual setting for this task in
the literature assumes that the documents containing the evidence for claims
are already provided and annotated or contained in a limited corpus. This
renders the systems unrealistic for real-world settings where knowledge sources
with potentially millions of documents need to be queried to find relevant
evidence. In this paper, we perform an array of experiments to test the
performance of open-domain claim verification systems. We test the final
verdict prediction of systems on four datasets of biomedical and health claims
in different settings. While keeping the pipeline's evidence selection and
verdict prediction parts constant, document retrieval is performed over three
common knowledge sources (PubMed, Wikipedia, Google) and using two different
information retrieval techniques. We show that PubMed works better with
specialized biomedical claims, while Wikipedia is more suited for everyday
health concerns. Likewise, BM25 excels in retrieval precision, while semantic
search in recall of relevant evidence. We discuss the results, outline frequent
retrieval patterns and challenges, and provide promising future directions. | [
-0.0022591601591557264,
-0.5327590107917786,
0.8920878171920776,
0.07529378682374954,
-0.01433558203279972,
-0.150735542178154,
-0.25449055433273315,
-0.7619301080703735,
0.11930513381958008,
0.19496336579322815,
0.21788480877876282,
-0.4861122965812683,
-0.7114278078079224,
0.43833863735198975,
-0.1885834038257599,
0.7823275327682495,
-0.2613255977630615,
0.2392268180847168,
-0.6938225626945496,
-0.11544238030910492,
-0.1433451920747757,
-0.2194949835538864,
-0.19243241846561432,
-0.4526945650577545,
0.5057905912399292,
0.1463092863559723,
0.5950332283973694,
0.1868400126695633,
0.8004103302955627,
0.2001638263463974,
0.0028271442279219627,
0.5451095104217529,
-0.2578047811985016,
0.18768908083438873,
-0.5390917658805847,
-0.29582467675209045,
-0.13189689815044403,
-0.0046600583009421825,
0.3945438265800476,
0.5254606008529663,
0.09170150756835938,
0.21023134887218475,
-0.2527584433555603,
0.39703434705734253,
-1.0275299549102783,
0.18560785055160522,
-0.5628608465194702,
0.12449604272842407,
-0.2559797465801239,
-0.23321367800235748,
-0.6174999475479126,
-0.7407694458961487,
0.3288280665874481,
-0.5980561375617981,
0.3565877676010132,
0.2786089777946472,
1.128480076789856,
0.0403040312230587,
-0.6217280626296997,
-0.4444452226161957,
-0.6563664674758911,
0.503243625164032,
-0.6109426021575928,
0.6429557204246521,
0.4355631172657013,
0.35686150193214417,
-0.051858264952898026,
-0.9055291414260864,
-0.48849183320999146,
-0.3204837739467621,
-0.33639734983444214,
0.280746728181839,
-0.34976786375045776,
-0.05843797326087952,
0.3935534358024597,
0.30673596262931824,
-0.9818553328514099,
-0.10517913848161697,
-0.6188464760780334,
-0.5680067539215088,
0.423437237739563,
-0.42072242498397827,
0.1513049155473709,
-0.24528659880161285,
-0.26327618956565857,
-0.18594327569007874,
-1.0352758169174194,
-0.08634123206138611,
0.021151119843125343,
0.08599374443292618,
0.266934335231781,
0.7918235063552856,
-0.566312313079834,
0.7778598070144653,
-0.1824827939271927,
-0.14313971996307373,
0.40362703800201416,
-0.385087251663208,
-0.18676607310771942,
0.3264657258987427,
0.6084384322166443,
0.5936347842216492,
-0.050407081842422485,
-0.2914574444293976,
0.10946428030729294,
-0.009344657883048058,
0.322516530752182,
-0.836525022983551,
-0.09979929029941559,
0.4032396674156189,
-0.5836367011070251,
0.19981513917446136,
-0.001115336548537016,
-0.552712619304657,
-0.4764745533466339,
-0.021346110850572586,
0.6234192252159119,
-0.6175193190574646,
0.05912335216999054,
0.27233174443244934,
-0.5072919726371765,
-0.2192779779434204,
0.39971837401390076,
-0.29456454515457153,
0.1999681144952774,
0.5282313823699951,
0.8335700035095215,
-0.2519581615924835,
0.06448886543512344,
-0.649836003780365,
0.14373049139976501,
-0.3680568337440491,
1.0778465270996094,
-0.28077301383018494,
-0.10798341035842896,
0.17656192183494568,
-0.008290115743875504,
-0.0037218716461211443,
-0.8025516867637634,
1.009101390838623,
-0.7656773924827576,
0.11106131970882416,
-0.593803882598877,
-0.6386910676956177,
0.04375341162085533,
0.17761068046092987,
-0.5588667392730713,
0.6527439951896667,
0.02018432877957821,
-0.9171547293663025,
0.6942200064659119,
-0.60528564453125,
-0.3508991301059723,
0.22013695538043976,
-0.2792704403400421,
-0.3599698841571808,
0.12839746475219727,
-0.14234206080436707,
0.34699004888534546,
-0.34938204288482666,
-0.06047310307621956,
-0.3948766589164734,
-0.16117694973945618,
0.294411301612854,
0.03938208520412445,
0.6072179079055786,
0.4479420781135559,
-0.35477760434150696,
-0.44856956601142883,
-0.6814975738525391,
0.04171287268400192,
0.2547239363193512,
-0.5173375606536865,
-0.8502770662307739,
0.05925743281841278,
-0.38320985436439514,
-0.21226008236408234,
0.14102958142757416,
-1.3858906030654907,
0.1134384348988533,
-0.17867021262645721,
0.30125752091407776,
0.2272462099790573,
0.01827634871006012,
-0.10485776513814926,
-0.5189319252967834,
-0.10451218485832214,
0.1268056482076645,
0.16676491498947144,
-0.05861200392246246,
-0.6772471070289612,
-0.08626975119113922,
-0.2556500732898712,
0.7478837370872498,
0.42473098635673523,
-0.6215953826904297,
0.19328363239765167,
-0.38180533051490784,
-0.1891271471977234,
-0.6332308053970337,
-0.3397149443626404,
0.3378807306289673,
0.6558260321617126,
0.6667231321334839,
-0.31768113374710083,
-0.4204089343547821,
-0.8346794843673706,
-0.5079898238182068,
-0.3466194272041321,
-0.40409138798713684,
0.5033778548240662,
0.5635719895362854,
-0.08321110159158707,
0.9973611235618591,
-0.7421907782554626,
-0.06666921079158783,
0.6050415635108948,
-0.04211195558309555,
0.05141185224056244,
0.08694053441286087,
0.49363940954208374,
-0.918778121471405,
-0.4233110547065735,
0.26840323209762573,
-0.9282934069633484,
-0.13411816954612732,
0.4726313054561615,
0.08641187101602554,
0.11102347820997238,
0.21392206847667694,
-0.803463876247406,
0.5199172496795654,
0.29156872630119324,
-0.48455971479415894,
0.6825281381607056,
-0.34612610936164856,
0.5324015617370605,
-0.37820982933044434,
0.31547924876213074,
-0.1175236627459526,
-0.25159746408462524,
-0.2511172890663147,
0.042499199509620667,
0.44140851497650146,
0.150340273976326,
-0.276822954416275,
0.3775079548358917,
-0.4199036657810211,
-0.06287719309329987,
0.07501455396413803,
0.027105078101158142,
0.17215648293495178,
-0.21368685364723206,
-0.1593143194913864,
0.6242581009864807,
0.11554225534200668,
-0.5545405745506287,
0.1994953602552414,
0.3294285535812378,
-0.7408114075660706,
0.7500603199005127,
-0.6965944170951843,
-0.0356719009578228,
-0.16329050064086914,
0.4087647795677185,
-0.8383448123931885,
-0.4619957506656647,
-0.05319909378886223,
-0.5022065043449402,
0.016847288236021996,
0.21668417751789093,
-0.6804221272468567,
-0.6821890473365784,
-0.14532560110092163,
0.0328030101954937,
0.3340175151824951,
-0.7597137093544006,
0.27414894104003906,
0.35258322954177856,
-0.33938950300216675,
-0.743334174156189,
-0.3666958212852478,
0.07826609909534454,
0.009501570835709572,
-0.45864608883857727,
0.6000136733055115,
-0.011999228037893772,
-0.59218829870224,
0.25280287861824036,
-0.4157043993473053,
0.09553946554660797,
-0.028757106512784958,
0.2360237091779709,
0.13415110111236572,
-0.1768912374973297,
0.16674242913722992,
0.2029494196176529,
0.28605917096138,
0.10139274597167969,
-0.48954707384109497,
-0.04414554312825203,
-0.011528038419783115,
-0.7794735431671143,
0.15908585488796234,
0.45275527238845825,
0.46089690923690796,
-0.2295135259628296,
0.5525401830673218,
0.13234278559684753,
-0.6085570454597473,
0.036204319447278976,
-0.8219365477561951,
-0.05837284028530121,
-0.34712550044059753,
-0.018343552947044373,
-0.17685307562351227,
-0.8371061682701111,
0.3916950523853302,
-0.360691100358963,
0.3523466885089874,
0.6489719152450562,
0.45833560824394226,
-0.116251640021801,
0.6659548282623291,
0.004020812921226025,
0.5887758731842041,
-0.0713479071855545,
-0.12234717607498169,
0.25004157423973083,
-0.4643017053604126,
-0.5309447646141052,
-0.9460998177528381,
0.09259219467639923,
-0.19854430854320526,
-0.5563205480575562,
0.7318277955055237,
0.03809163719415665,
-0.2962230443954468,
0.46941128373146057,
-0.44340381026268005,
0.4918521046638489,
0.6178014874458313,
0.6190171241760254,
0.9518448114395142,
0.08124548941850662,
-0.7334383726119995,
0.17070074379444122,
-0.5752559900283813,
-0.4209763705730438,
1.233548879623413,
0.27249178290367126,
0.4269263744354248,
0.2899039089679718,
0.5420822501182556,
0.5066192150115967,
0.6931597590446472,
-0.44617387652397156,
0.19201944768428802,
-0.2860721945762634,
-0.8513165712356567,
-0.12393687665462494,
-0.4982196092605591,
-1.1452245712280273,
0.28578048944473267,
-0.4345439672470093,
-0.4243369996547699,
0.3697143495082855,
-0.18625204265117645,
-0.5509162545204163,
0.11903795599937439,
-0.6488407254219055,
0.3915106952190399,
-0.200829416513443,
-0.32301464676856995,
-0.2680075168609619,
-0.6432337164878845,
0.2651348114013672,
-0.16361552476882935,
0.10032887756824493,
0.12735028564929962,
0.25829577445983887,
0.552302896976471,
-0.36402416229248047,
0.41003379225730896,
-0.10734441876411438,
-0.026842806488275528,
0.32092636823654175,
-0.12571698427200317,
0.3125151991844177,
0.17770199477672577,
-0.3384808897972107,
0.2776234447956085,
0.33641085028648376,
-0.3981320559978485,
-0.4277406334877014,
0.5286194086074829,
-0.7367971539497375,
-0.5151085257530212,
-0.5699381232261658,
-0.16349509358406067,
-0.32159316539764404,
0.5010634660720825,
0.3430594205856323,
0.23812268674373627,
-0.4898242652416229,
0.502124011516571,
0.9707244634628296,
-0.28354552388191223,
0.006213872693479061,
1.0473307371139526,
0.0024065712932497263,
-0.3855592906475067,
0.6440455317497253,
0.31252607703208923,
0.07120057195425034,
0.35878828167915344,
0.3192456364631653,
-0.30062565207481384,
-0.6503264307975769,
-0.4298889636993408,
0.2688460052013397,
-0.5569983720779419,
-0.6599926948547363,
-0.8779287934303284,
-0.07176326960325241,
-0.709021806716919,
0.26040250062942505,
-0.19450780749320984,
-0.27114132046699524,
0.265438437461853,
-0.1685837060213089,
0.3926599323749542,
0.7862515449523926,
-0.20809990167617798,
-0.3820367157459259,
-0.7814350128173828,
0.4434525966644287,
0.2914384603500366,
0.6628504991531372,
-0.44202110171318054,
0.016967415809631348,
-0.3901219666004181,
0.1395018845796585,
-0.45168572664260864,
-0.8236059546470642,
-0.06702104210853577,
0.06233464553952217,
0.8830190300941467,
0.4002823531627655,
0.3625401556491852,
0.1736011654138565,
-0.7655889987945557,
0.6089951992034912,
0.13323384523391724,
-0.3455387055873871,
0.5011594891548157,
-0.16764484345912933,
-0.1194935142993927,
0.658645510673523,
0.9358933568000793,
-0.3495481014251709,
-0.16862615942955017,
-0.6782127022743225,
-0.5047159790992737,
0.1654459685087204,
0.1631515771150589,
-0.5205764174461365,
-0.21187151968479156,
0.42285552620887756,
0.3701135814189911,
-0.12480885535478592,
0.020290803164243698,
-0.09289948642253876,
-0.05223356559872627,
-0.03880496695637703,
0.0848909392952919,
0.16244909167289734,
-0.6635358929634094,
0.10871686786413193,
0.5114836096763611,
-0.19672325253486633,
0.5189278721809387,
0.8466300964355469,
-0.03138561546802521,
-0.32738813757896423,
0.15933454036712646,
0.4360159933567047,
0.5655762553215027,
-0.45541107654571533,
0.41164326667785645,
-0.0032749571837484837,
-0.6874421238899231,
0.10212007164955139,
0.24082784354686737,
-0.4407092332839966,
0.5420563220977783,
0.24981853365898132,
0.5739108920097351,
0.25389331579208374,
-0.8348284959793091,
0.5290610790252686,
-0.154185488820076,
-0.45185837149620056,
0.0348949134349823,
0.0030076580587774515,
0.1200122982263565,
0.25340327620506287,
0.6015271544456482,
0.23463782668113708,
0.30480048060417175,
-0.575324296951294,
0.35969236493110657,
0.3128882348537445,
0.027235161513090134,
-0.023301253095269203,
0.6350016593933105,
0.055819232016801834,
-0.17173834145069122,
0.3379782438278198,
-0.021306557580828667,
-0.08898188173770905,
0.5123056769371033,
0.3511267304420471,
0.25116318464279175,
0.0032002199441194534,
0.18035107851028442,
0.34139174222946167,
0.012777021154761314,
-0.4334474503993988,
0.11237706243991852,
0.03333640471100807,
-0.5843542218208313,
-0.49221354722976685,
-0.4930519461631775,
-0.9807986617088318,
0.06668055802583694,
-0.45573610067367554,
0.16636629402637482,
-0.06858447939157486,
-0.4126920998096466,
0.38321825861930847,
0.24150794744491577,
-0.6560070514678955,
0.05538367107510567,
-0.08357434719800949,
1.2971805334091187,
-0.8645653128623962,
0.5237758755683899,
0.7408810257911682,
-0.37345632910728455,
-0.33253028988838196,
0.07714393734931946,
0.0818687230348587,
-0.5983839631080627,
0.7667416334152222,
-0.13113175332546234,
0.12238249182701111,
-0.374260812997818,
-0.766101598739624,
-0.7626798152923584,
1.143112063407898,
0.4983905851840973,
-0.21506251394748688,
-0.04228423908352852,
-0.09594540297985077,
0.6527174711227417,
-0.20177927613258362,
0.2818859815597534,
0.15839403867721558,
0.515411376953125,
0.26732876896858215,
-1.2377489805221558,
0.13462969660758972,
0.007426380645483732,
-0.4508281946182251,
-0.20239537954330444,
-0.5980814695358276,
0.7591456174850464,
-0.3220793604850769,
-0.07904557138681412,
-0.08745081722736359,
0.813971221446991,
0.6306684017181396,
0.9361298680305481,
0.45014241337776184,
0.6128709316253662,
1.1414755582809448,
-0.01871003769338131,
0.97263503074646,
-0.24337664246559143,
0.4561034142971039,
0.8200908899307251,
-0.6004625558853149,
0.8707742094993591,
0.19350485503673553,
-0.435215562582016,
0.6075626015663147,
0.7696178555488586,
0.05873337388038635,
0.5902985334396362,
0.4218081533908844,
-0.31532931327819824,
0.059535812586545944,
-0.38376277685165405,
-0.5896618366241455,
0.086208276450634,
0.5036957263946533,
-0.38924798369407654,
-0.3858645260334015,
0.08597017079591751,
0.05978919565677643,
-0.04658474773168564,
-0.07910867035388947,
0.5872941017150879,
-0.02699732780456543,
-1.0462543964385986,
0.5459437966346741,
-0.06310916692018509,
0.44068965315818787,
-0.5079691410064697,
-0.07414696365594864,
-0.04323817417025566,
0.21313947439193726,
-0.386352002620697,
-0.6837372779846191,
0.2287326455116272,
0.019160309806466103,
-0.1332029402256012,
-0.0710388794541359,
1.2311733961105347,
-0.2900491952896118,
0.1526966691017151,
0.17624181509017944,
0.5213295221328735,
0.30454882979393005,
-0.08846762776374817,
-0.3472866714000702,
-0.20276565849781036,
-0.340945303440094,
-0.14369213581085205,
0.43736976385116577,
0.4298023581504822,
-0.08671552687883377,
0.37426963448524475,
0.6802331209182739,
0.3594329059123993,
-0.04336566850543022,
-0.2783457040786743,
0.8167494535446167,
-0.07803352177143097,
-0.07605079561471939,
-0.2773536443710327,
-0.12999999523162842,
-0.38242441415786743,
-0.03489409387111664,
0.806526243686676,
0.708429753780365,
0.9234950542449951,
-0.20262391865253448,
0.9386760592460632,
-0.23504532873630524,
0.7889264225959778,
-0.41129109263420105,
0.7920696139335632,
-0.34107282757759094,
-0.32192814350128174,
-0.01829664595425129,
-0.46258699893951416,
-0.3636656403541565,
0.5581368803977966,
-0.1650998890399933,
-0.256244033575058,
1.0478770732879639,
0.4267691671848297,
-0.059277426451444626,
0.26603466272354126,
0.09463084489107132,
0.37487566471099854,
0.17265097796916962,
0.4048709273338318,
0.55795818567276,
-0.41963881254196167,
0.1867249459028244,
-0.06409160047769547,
-0.42322421073913574,
-0.47306397557258606,
-0.8794568777084351,
-0.4933381676673889,
-0.4121156632900238,
-0.41589486598968506,
-0.9890307784080505,
0.39606234431266785,
0.7654116749763489,
0.662228524684906,
-1.0180364847183228,
0.37339767813682556,
0.2892933785915375,
0.047929082065820694,
-0.3766845464706421,
-0.09758417308330536,
0.3548811078071594,
-0.11333039402961731,
-0.3515017628669739,
0.5443608164787292,
0.12280391901731491,
-0.22472237050533295,
0.01768355816602707,
0.04268627613782883,
-0.4117906987667084,
0.18969520926475525,
0.5596912503242493,
0.5636021494865417,
-0.40363749861717224,
-0.4056244492530823,
0.31741863489151,
-0.4579943120479584,
-0.026682956144213676,
0.923190712928772,
-0.806401789188385,
0.3555343747138977,
0.8123637437820435,
0.8054597973823547,
0.5650442838668823,
-0.07499070465564728,
0.29625412821769714,
-0.38118183612823486,
-0.6339429020881653,
0.1799723356962204,
0.5444657206535339,
0.12092103809118271,
-0.3028206527233124,
0.7178311944007874,
0.603706419467926,
-0.7519497275352478,
-0.853131115436554,
-0.12963096797466278,
-0.8785375952720642,
-0.38066235184669495,
0.9578192830085754,
-0.49011650681495667,
-0.11043257266283035,
-0.3552812337875366,
0.05054476112127304,
0.254485547542572,
-0.28026464581489563,
1.059906005859375,
0.7496522665023804,
-0.1542859822511673,
0.695620059967041,
-0.7486013770103455,
0.3958898186683655,
0.3138458728790283,
-0.6726753115653992,
0.08175797015428543,
0.4801753759384155,
0.40886422991752625,
0.7176902294158936,
0.6186841726303101,
-0.3978390395641327,
0.435418963432312,
-0.22506804764270782,
0.011195618659257889,
-0.0329652838408947,
-0.2464490383863449,
-0.0160830095410347,
0.46052566170692444,
-0.21011409163475037,
0.03511619567871094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02837v1 | With a Little Help from my (Linguistic) Friends: Topic Segmentation of Multi-party Casual Conversations | 2024-02-05T09:48:07 | 2024-02-05T09:48:07 | Amandine Decker, Maxime Amblard | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topics play an important role in the global organisation of a conversation as
what is currently discussed constrains the possible contributions of the
participant. Understanding the way topics are organised in interaction would
provide insight on the structure of dialogue beyond the sequence of utterances.
However, studying this high-level structure is a complex task that we try to
approach by first segmenting dialogues into smaller topically coherent sets of
utterances. Understanding the interactions between these segments would then
enable us to propose a model of topic organisation at a dialogue level. In this
paper we work with open-domain conversations and try to reach a comparable
level of accuracy as recent machine learning based topic segmentation models
but with a formal approach. The features we identify as meaningful for this
task help us understand better the topical structure of a conversation. | [
-0.7097721099853516,
-1.152787208557129,
0.499695748090744,
0.1348079890012741,
-0.31644901633262634,
0.21646350622177124,
-0.11151814460754395,
-0.45780330896377563,
0.41845762729644775,
0.4975627660751343,
-0.6548806428909302,
-0.4441428780555725,
-0.35565224289894104,
-0.2511094808578491,
-0.26960283517837524,
0.8877150416374207,
0.3577149212360382,
0.07821821421384811,
-0.23732832074165344,
-0.48184099793434143,
-0.4128452241420746,
-0.7863233089447021,
-0.8628436326980591,
-0.1037890687584877,
0.5038412809371948,
0.631489098072052,
0.3876875638961792,
0.3035134971141815,
0.341083288192749,
0.37707194685935974,
-0.6230522990226746,
0.28157275915145874,
-0.6598641276359558,
0.3537885248661041,
-0.33301371335983276,
-0.6351356506347656,
-0.35226213932037354,
0.0012248504208400846,
0.4366862177848816,
1.0229641199111938,
-0.23032207787036896,
-0.2138247787952423,
0.026328125968575478,
0.4401446580886841,
-0.22799351811408997,
0.3107680082321167,
-0.6760544776916504,
-0.04826938733458519,
-0.4892832636833191,
-0.1981370598077774,
-0.30380260944366455,
0.16233710944652557,
0.3611927628517151,
0.12313330918550491,
0.4582717716693878,
-0.07601845264434814,
0.8528656363487244,
-0.18459120392799377,
-0.4297385513782501,
-0.2609608471393585,
-0.839744508266449,
0.5160062313079834,
-0.26327982544898987,
0.10170156508684158,
0.15814486145973206,
0.16325144469738007,
-0.1717858612537384,
-0.5058169364929199,
-0.14952802658081055,
0.17632435262203217,
-0.10886044055223465,
-0.23334406316280365,
0.13246414065361023,
0.12654638290405273,
-0.21674132347106934,
0.44072863459587097,
-0.176126167178154,
-0.09644655883312225,
-0.3823959231376648,
0.23552346229553223,
0.5534347295761108,
0.3046165406703949,
0.3408918082714081,
-0.19725123047828674,
-0.15309517085552216,
0.5045409798622131,
-0.40274283289909363,
0.06294261664152145,
0.17675679922103882,
0.275481641292572,
-0.03435781970620155,
0.42874258756637573,
-0.5211009383201599,
0.5948290824890137,
0.21915678679943085,
-0.25339779257774353,
-0.24395456910133362,
-0.6586775183677673,
0.1643311232328415,
0.0004342856991570443,
0.41059184074401855,
0.3205079138278961,
0.3338468670845032,
-0.03435273468494415,
0.26733288168907166,
-0.30081403255462646,
0.044878531247377396,
-0.6875028014183044,
-0.3892503082752228,
0.30715084075927734,
-0.6769278645515442,
-0.20311732590198517,
0.37383097410202026,
-0.6179836392402649,
0.010782246477901936,
-0.35263413190841675,
-0.24046620726585388,
-0.23515254259109497,
-0.08790089190006256,
-0.05738624930381775,
-0.10173797607421875,
0.195914164185524,
0.6045839190483093,
-0.695793092250824,
0.6517058610916138,
0.9121124148368835,
0.9663368463516235,
-0.1946420818567276,
-0.0036149986553937197,
-0.5112322568893433,
0.5083117485046387,
-0.06382100284099579,
1.0022828578948975,
-0.669056236743927,
-0.46051648259162903,
-0.38549506664276123,
0.23111464083194733,
-0.04152970388531685,
-0.2281908094882965,
0.44361865520477295,
-0.38192179799079895,
0.49349313974380493,
-0.007218521554023027,
-0.5151544809341431,
-0.10401793569326401,
0.3423583209514618,
-0.2501963973045349,
0.4729298949241638,
-0.3819974660873413,
-0.9041216969490051,
0.38848236203193665,
-0.913364827632904,
-0.3822767436504364,
0.0795980915427208,
-0.3421453535556793,
-0.20536884665489197,
0.1990961879491806,
0.2457498162984848,
0.5520351529121399,
-0.15182079374790192,
0.42703187465667725,
-0.4214393198490143,
-0.02573959343135357,
0.5238986611366272,
-0.3068563938140869,
0.3865123689174652,
0.23644675314426422,
-0.04643979296088219,
0.5544270873069763,
-0.6525880694389343,
-0.2051590532064438,
-0.15795695781707764,
0.19861634075641632,
-0.7389706969261169,
0.3956151604652405,
-0.11315251141786575,
0.19412219524383545,
0.06147154048085213,
-0.35403719544410706,
0.19173966348171234,
-0.40814584493637085,
0.6562127470970154,
0.5221042037010193,
0.7118871808052063,
0.5862035751342773,
-0.08586464822292328,
0.1373041570186615,
0.17800414562225342,
0.2544400990009308,
-0.30266475677490234,
-0.8767873644828796,
-0.8339752554893494,
-0.5015168190002441,
0.4240700602531433,
0.45623454451560974,
-0.5161079168319702,
0.40204840898513794,
0.06948603689670563,
-0.464328408241272,
-0.09031694382429123,
-0.35253190994262695,
0.24760738015174866,
0.21179983019828796,
-0.031093481928110123,
-0.47871124744415283,
-0.18439431488513947,
-0.7213321924209595,
-0.12769833207130432,
-0.13836342096328735,
0.02228061482310295,
0.7516823410987854,
0.22992214560508728,
-0.04612206667661667,
1.242301344871521,
-0.9000964164733887,
-0.07346314936876297,
-0.34114688634872437,
0.4906232953071594,
0.09845232218503952,
0.45941683650016785,
0.22200307250022888,
-1.0675073862075806,
-0.6893017292022705,
0.09889356046915054,
-0.4118626117706299,
0.2984715700149536,
-0.03314002603292465,
-0.3868468403816223,
0.07185345888137817,
0.46808454394340515,
-0.6054194569587708,
0.4870959222316742,
-0.18037685751914978,
-0.35622528195381165,
0.002309180796146393,
-0.28846728801727295,
0.1858121156692505,
-1.043258547782898,
-0.33700984716415405,
-0.01828720048069954,
-0.10302697122097015,
-0.9460439085960388,
-0.07721563428640366,
-0.4007910490036011,
-0.5053684115409851,
-0.417296826839447,
0.5630417466163635,
-0.30847322940826416,
-0.024106336757540703,
-0.10278500616550446,
0.18291734158992767,
-0.137934610247612,
0.589878499507904,
0.4198625385761261,
0.5132117867469788,
0.5655040144920349,
-0.7013320922851562,
-0.08816859871149063,
0.539361834526062,
-0.35634106397628784,
0.6758422255516052,
-0.676071047782898,
0.4254131019115448,
-0.02056141011416912,
0.11844983696937561,
-1.2577375173568726,
-0.5039745569229126,
0.511154294013977,
-0.34309104084968567,
0.3151814937591553,
-0.41853147745132446,
-0.14859402179718018,
0.14362645149230957,
-0.034174904227256775,
0.3854324519634247,
0.027730854228138924,
-0.231979638338089,
0.15665476024150848,
0.952122151851654,
-0.5828074216842651,
-0.20343495905399323,
-0.1338568478822708,
0.11923526227474213,
-0.452422171831131,
-1.162022590637207,
0.537617564201355,
0.11325295269489288,
-0.7693126797676086,
-0.17790000140666962,
-0.06745526939630508,
-0.6572434306144714,
0.034764036536216736,
0.4156181812286377,
-0.13557399809360504,
-0.2166932076215744,
-0.012111196294426918,
-0.07487168163061142,
-0.18813802301883698,
-0.23293323814868927,
-0.1409856528043747,
0.7946199774742126,
-0.16537776589393616,
-0.2618786692619324,
-0.39591026306152344,
0.7637746334075928,
0.39257189631462097,
-0.44034522771835327,
0.9689505696296692,
0.3883395195007324,
-0.07849349081516266,
-0.24087083339691162,
-0.3648504912853241,
-0.1262344866991043,
-0.48488566279411316,
0.21968042850494385,
-0.7514743804931641,
-0.9608075022697449,
0.6690923571586609,
-0.18194346129894257,
-0.24527201056480408,
0.32381725311279297,
0.4360072910785675,
-0.316826194524765,
0.8731521964073181,
0.7456905245780945,
0.1702478677034378,
0.45538678765296936,
0.10522535443305969,
0.3574954569339752,
-0.3325679302215576,
-0.4986426830291748,
-0.7222229242324829,
-0.24683023989200592,
-0.5618967413902283,
-0.6652541160583496,
0.05293918773531914,
0.21443909406661987,
0.41408711671829224,
0.07555406540632248,
-0.2856391668319702,
0.5663399696350098,
0.3091716766357422,
0.12794229388237,
0.06863643229007721,
0.021476255729794502,
0.45040163397789,
0.06528909504413605,
-0.6709567904472351,
-0.5635786652565002,
0.4074768126010895,
0.4814559817314148,
0.8247334957122803,
-0.13292278349399567,
0.7945263981819153,
0.09780103713274002,
-0.09764259308576584,
-0.8614296317100525,
0.767355740070343,
-0.1346743106842041,
-0.5879051089286804,
-0.5501817464828491,
-0.4322444498538971,
-0.8520723581314087,
0.25867339968681335,
0.2318628877401352,
-1.0270683765411377,
0.5136894583702087,
-0.4062589406967163,
-0.09921852499246597,
0.14949533343315125,
-0.5324209928512573,
0.9534491300582886,
0.10348338633775711,
-0.08496971428394318,
-0.19943606853485107,
-0.7531237602233887,
0.36646318435668945,
0.24558274447917938,
0.33044883608818054,
-0.45552143454551697,
0.06486872583627701,
0.8777648210525513,
-0.44398751854896545,
0.7983368635177612,
-0.05940409377217293,
-0.013187983073294163,
0.6324450373649597,
-0.17903314530849457,
-0.09775776416063309,
0.43274006247520447,
0.25086766481399536,
0.3663052022457123,
0.10497336834669113,
-0.48086991906166077,
-0.4577028453350067,
0.32637450098991394,
-0.7334421873092651,
-0.71151202917099,
-0.1844315528869629,
-0.47175464034080505,
-0.14314153790473938,
-0.20173870027065277,
-0.007466185837984085,
0.7647430896759033,
-0.730676531791687,
0.33045387268066406,
0.7851094603538513,
0.012157886289060116,
0.4294520318508148,
0.4577232003211975,
0.06147181615233421,
-0.22773484885692596,
0.9454383850097656,
-0.06576711684465408,
0.19965414702892303,
0.58439040184021,
0.15976206958293915,
-0.08171446621417999,
-0.6128765940666199,
-0.1218726634979248,
0.11565020680427551,
-0.8716484904289246,
0.2598015367984772,
-0.9477250576019287,
-0.03042750060558319,
-0.23820027709007263,
0.08168897032737732,
-0.21338197588920593,
-0.6498897671699524,
-0.2276686131954193,
0.10524369031190872,
0.06364795565605164,
0.699306070804596,
0.19882725179195404,
0.43089547753334045,
-0.9095696806907654,
0.3947790563106537,
0.35775744915008545,
-0.08612361550331116,
-0.38776150345802307,
-0.3197541832923889,
0.04169851541519165,
-0.2403431087732315,
-0.21215122938156128,
-0.8680570721626282,
0.2729937434196472,
0.519783079624176,
0.6364471912384033,
0.6817574501037598,
-0.03800438344478607,
0.6640273332595825,
-0.714343249797821,
0.9827284216880798,
-0.03278258815407753,
-0.9554949998855591,
0.8910249471664429,
-0.39217609167099,
0.04396481066942215,
0.7967555522918701,
0.5389910340309143,
-0.6631208658218384,
-0.4484364986419678,
-0.9305020570755005,
-0.8290289044380188,
0.9934458136558533,
0.37125617265701294,
0.15486855804920197,
-0.1779508888721466,
0.5551995038986206,
0.09486951678991318,
0.18916279077529907,
-0.44871553778648376,
-0.4008261263370514,
0.4599798321723938,
0.13737045228481293,
-0.08251778036355972,
-0.5819507837295532,
-0.4746110141277313,
-0.12026271224021912,
0.33444613218307495,
-0.03606700897216797,
0.41259315609931946,
-0.13687343895435333,
0.1295909732580185,
-0.032081082463264465,
0.49223268032073975,
0.7003870010375977,
0.9369728565216064,
-0.3389693796634674,
-0.0650070309638977,
-0.13718463480472565,
-0.23880474269390106,
0.25903430581092834,
-0.15719282627105713,
0.198114275932312,
0.2681034207344055,
0.35960206389427185,
0.6680930256843567,
0.18521124124526978,
-0.08192900568246841,
0.3534899055957794,
-0.4886116683483124,
-0.12607011198997498,
0.2839341163635254,
0.25858426094055176,
0.10762201249599457,
0.16758212447166443,
0.01335055660456419,
0.26050257682800293,
0.15197554230690002,
-1.1950711011886597,
0.6898894906044006,
0.3225111663341522,
-0.6138351559638977,
-0.20128457248210907,
0.022743212059140205,
0.7888558506965637,
-0.744638204574585,
0.40721821784973145,
-0.2767101228237152,
-0.7018970847129822,
0.7349447011947632,
0.20872682332992554,
0.8982721567153931,
-0.2690806984901428,
0.293450266122818,
0.037135593593120575,
-0.15916204452514648,
0.28076544404029846,
0.3484173119068146,
-0.41379424929618835,
-0.5259208679199219,
-0.6012656688690186,
-0.41006460785865784,
-0.8280279040336609,
-0.2729054093360901,
-0.6342618465423584,
0.20954462885856628,
-0.03538796305656433,
0.15423272550106049,
0.25052329897880554,
-0.050729308277368546,
-0.17443755269050598,
0.05179629847407341,
0.15941855311393738,
0.6085808873176575,
-0.5884211659431458,
1.0258179903030396,
0.6156908273696899,
-0.07996479421854019,
-0.3150504529476166,
0.4361177682876587,
-0.36244437098503113,
-0.2815980315208435,
0.6654053926467896,
0.28602275252342224,
-0.04535737261176109,
-0.45123422145843506,
-0.5247503519058228,
-0.624970018863678,
0.5383254289627075,
-0.2518359422683716,
-0.48835837841033936,
-0.228567436337471,
0.08614187687635422,
0.3044546842575073,
-0.48087748885154724,
0.1303544044494629,
0.26484236121177673,
0.23933283984661102,
0.4533912241458893,
-0.7851431965827942,
-0.2516913115978241,
-0.06982331722974777,
-0.2579735517501831,
0.6205105185508728,
-0.7323653697967529,
0.8280380964279175,
0.16058073937892914,
-0.052983153611421585,
0.029128093272447586,
0.887738823890686,
0.0005717563326470554,
0.757667601108551,
0.6246520280838013,
-0.08406095951795578,
0.8407715559005737,
-0.332219660282135,
0.7222681045532227,
-0.4231998920440674,
0.27296990156173706,
1.202759027481079,
-0.19951777160167694,
0.533747136592865,
0.2814050316810608,
-0.15939649939537048,
0.30421608686447144,
0.9204638600349426,
0.3140946626663208,
0.7554839849472046,
0.33408084511756897,
-0.2201983630657196,
-0.11433067172765732,
-0.09605871140956879,
-0.4805137813091278,
0.5946133136749268,
0.7756685018539429,
0.09612096101045609,
-0.026751507073640823,
0.11277201026678085,
-0.22497625648975372,
-0.24731449782848358,
-0.39241456985473633,
1.2115106582641602,
0.20319199562072754,
-0.7058274745941162,
0.037389401346445084,
0.3710498809814453,
0.3513800799846649,
-0.5161681771278381,
-0.05860963091254234,
-0.25339627265930176,
0.05311613529920578,
-0.1886933445930481,
-0.7732366323471069,
0.5754997134208679,
-0.19459280371665955,
-0.0141320014372468,
-0.10501685738563538,
1.137698769569397,
-0.6446217894554138,
-0.0879136323928833,
-0.13062867522239685,
0.7097899913787842,
0.36864563822746277,
-0.37634462118148804,
-0.6790264248847961,
0.049105629324913025,
-0.04070734977722168,
0.12226415425539017,
0.37935391068458557,
1.1201671361923218,
-0.11457409709692001,
0.31618809700012207,
0.24748413264751434,
-0.3885628581047058,
-0.1580926924943924,
0.14392653107643127,
0.7788864970207214,
-0.6945282816886902,
-0.9611256718635559,
-0.788873016834259,
0.5527157187461853,
-0.2923992872238159,
-0.3864787518978119,
0.7151491045951843,
0.3241543471813202,
0.5262336730957031,
0.08736447244882584,
0.06296087056398392,
-0.019072582945227623,
0.26983922719955444,
-0.5081920623779297,
0.5682822465896606,
-0.34868091344833374,
0.14914056658744812,
-0.40310895442962646,
-0.850225567817688,
-0.01538922917097807,
0.6383057832717896,
-0.4123918414115906,
-0.3674876093864441,
0.6109105944633484,
0.4538431763648987,
-0.30242154002189636,
0.5322313904762268,
0.23662114143371582,
-0.2042916715145111,
0.4081401526927948,
0.08717161417007446,
1.401050090789795,
0.23477335274219513,
0.43918412923812866,
-0.4848295748233795,
-0.2900804579257965,
-0.204130619764328,
-0.46799540519714355,
-1.174176573753357,
-0.6392961144447327,
-0.6996289491653442,
0.050399649888277054,
0.14606624841690063,
0.6660136580467224,
1.1001758575439453,
-0.8804044127464294,
-0.49162912368774414,
-0.22807374596595764,
0.3659839630126953,
0.10250698775053024,
-0.26630261540412903,
0.30796515941619873,
-0.6314027905464172,
-0.8147644400596619,
0.6048121452331543,
0.6218457221984863,
-0.30594301223754883,
-0.04940912500023842,
0.2598884403705597,
-0.5059984922409058,
0.20161080360412598,
0.6210575699806213,
0.06261647492647171,
-0.6504080891609192,
-0.24598641693592072,
-0.21464331448078156,
0.10357371717691422,
0.4815269112586975,
1.3202669620513916,
-0.15697667002677917,
0.18539026379585266,
0.43661022186279297,
0.45974230766296387,
0.8752750158309937,
0.22394801676273346,
0.6292614340782166,
-1.1479467153549194,
0.3738371431827545,
0.252636581659317,
0.1472940742969513,
0.04819737374782562,
-0.3811922073364258,
0.717345118522644,
0.3139387369155884,
-0.5547127723693848,
-0.8332493305206299,
0.26764586567878723,
-1.0079089403152466,
-0.7062625288963318,
0.8753069639205933,
-0.20203344523906708,
-0.2822231352329254,
-0.5544313192367554,
-0.6568495035171509,
0.008865751326084137,
-0.47549930214881897,
0.37697461247444153,
0.8118451237678528,
-0.5736503601074219,
-0.16194899380207062,
-0.24871288239955902,
0.5437625646591187,
0.24125972390174866,
-1.130051851272583,
-0.11711815744638443,
0.24029143154621124,
-0.012183653190732002,
0.4675002694129944,
0.8976147770881653,
0.0073164100758731365,
-0.14061297476291656,
-0.07256975024938583,
-0.5933026671409607,
0.5415759682655334,
-0.9667714238166809,
-0.13851048052310944,
0.8682804703712463,
-0.06700525432825089,
-0.4769769310951233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02834v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02834v2 | Shortened LLaMA: Depth Pruning for Large Language Models with Comparison of Retraining Methods | 2024-02-05T09:44:49 | 2024-06-23T08:45:33 | Bo-Kyeong Kim, Geonmin Kim, Tae-Ho Kim, Thibault Castells, Shinkook Choi, Junho Shin, Hyoung-Kyu Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Structured pruning of modern large language models (LLMs) has emerged as a
way of decreasing their high computational needs. Width pruning reduces the
size of projection weight matrices (e.g., by removing attention heads) while
maintaining the number of layers. Depth pruning, in contrast, removes entire
layers or blocks, while keeping the size of the remaining weights unchanged.
Most current research focuses on either width-only or a blend of width and
depth pruning, with little comparative analysis between the two units (width
vs. depth) concerning their impact on LLM inference efficiency. In this work,
we show that simple depth pruning can effectively compress LLMs while achieving
comparable or superior performance to recent width pruning studies. Our pruning
method boosts inference speeds, especially under memory-constrained conditions
that require limited batch sizes for running LLMs, where width pruning is
ineffective. In retraining pruned models for quality recovery, continued
pretraining on a large corpus markedly outperforms LoRA-based tuning,
particularly at severe pruning ratios. We hope this work can help build compact
yet capable LLMs. Code and models can be found at:
https://github.com/Nota-NetsPresso/shortened-llm | [
-0.2553420960903168,
-0.6923204660415649,
0.584935188293457,
0.34028804302215576,
-0.6520165801048279,
0.09697961807250977,
-0.4773941934108734,
-0.3697488605976105,
0.5518090128898621,
0.5242746472358704,
-0.4216998815536499,
-0.516886293888092,
-0.6103978753089905,
0.1434803009033203,
-0.6676161885261536,
0.6082035303115845,
0.05821404233574867,
-0.1092723086476326,
-0.1652076542377472,
0.08421313017606735,
-0.31550049781799316,
-0.3224047124385834,
-0.722046971321106,
-0.16900329291820526,
0.6653423309326172,
0.6305847764015198,
0.639735221862793,
0.8612562417984009,
0.42827096581459045,
0.36132076382637024,
-0.4550764262676239,
0.1895734816789627,
-0.6757674217224121,
0.2679503560066223,
0.3262808322906494,
-0.5017585158348083,
-0.4613076150417328,
-0.1744230091571808,
0.8467865586280823,
1.0333739519119263,
-0.3631502687931061,
0.07471881806850433,
0.001107872580178082,
0.89963299036026,
-0.8398534655570984,
-0.2824832797050476,
-0.5546762347221375,
0.2038547545671463,
-0.11759506911039352,
-0.038030955940485,
-0.3125535845756531,
-0.4257785379886627,
-0.01086729858070612,
-0.6085616946220398,
0.2411152422428131,
-0.004225537646561861,
0.7908026576042175,
0.46399766206741333,
-0.33565500378608704,
0.17059031128883362,
-0.8097175359725952,
0.9398022294044495,
-0.8699591755867004,
0.5920496582984924,
0.2989751398563385,
0.16983555257320404,
0.05126839503645897,
-0.7835761308670044,
-0.3193882703781128,
-0.1585170179605484,
0.00908456090837717,
-0.0611463226377964,
0.00361237651668489,
0.198013037443161,
0.38912323117256165,
0.6494868397712708,
-0.48160961270332336,
0.30128687620162964,
-0.6248314380645752,
-0.20014825463294983,
0.7022138833999634,
-0.10802000761032104,
0.014029310084879398,
0.06560122966766357,
-0.3095453083515167,
-0.1478998064994812,
-1.2177886962890625,
-0.18577395379543304,
0.4248224198818207,
-0.07943986356258392,
0.09299027919769287,
0.5332117080688477,
-0.3075844645500183,
0.7177895903587341,
-0.3279969096183777,
-0.7482014298439026,
0.23444582521915436,
0.014762574806809425,
-0.5127540826797485,
0.0000069991115196899045,
0.5678373575210571,
0.30398330092430115,
0.512260377407074,
-0.20490127801895142,
-0.31001201272010803,
-0.017412563785910606,
0.09180053323507309,
-0.8925473093986511,
-0.13756363093852997,
0.037890899926424026,
-0.5605902671813965,
0.013221021741628647,
-0.09698816388845444,
-0.579758882522583,
-0.24048839509487152,
-0.2354278266429901,
0.13850387930870056,
-0.3587534427642822,
-0.2567066252231598,
0.3460364043712616,
-0.06827624887228012,
0.39637529850006104,
0.4003645181655884,
-0.6710081696510315,
0.49472135305404663,
0.797612190246582,
1.038198471069336,
-0.24984197318553925,
-0.026560774073004723,
-0.5637912154197693,
0.0065729799680411816,
-0.32934802770614624,
0.5857749581336975,
-0.43839821219444275,
-0.5599759221076965,
-0.10232321172952652,
-0.21293644607067108,
0.22679051756858826,
-0.7340809106826782,
0.5862873196601868,
-0.47148001194000244,
0.057178035378456116,
-0.12806974351406097,
-0.4727165400981903,
-0.24341300129890442,
0.3574240803718567,
-0.7216143608093262,
0.8167144060134888,
-0.045993298292160034,
-0.535671055316925,
0.13327337801456451,
0.030662331730127335,
-0.6866233944892883,
-0.31666597723960876,
0.06594042479991913,
-0.57322758436203,
0.5658028721809387,
0.20610378682613373,
0.22392967343330383,
-0.3972974717617035,
0.17156554758548737,
-0.4380439817905426,
-0.5924178957939148,
-0.08272571861743927,
-0.4015263617038727,
0.5604692101478577,
0.218035489320755,
0.05641363561153412,
0.2053385078907013,
-0.8587422370910645,
0.10780198127031326,
0.2613060772418976,
-0.708980917930603,
-0.21503761410713196,
0.03787465766072273,
-0.29067450761795044,
0.0020563940051943064,
0.08163982629776001,
-0.532631516456604,
0.2809738516807556,
-0.6630252003669739,
0.6292792558670044,
0.5456990599632263,
-0.0417809784412384,
0.47532427310943604,
-0.1575848013162613,
0.5906245112419128,
-0.2574949562549591,
0.1098526269197464,
0.03549124300479889,
-0.052407100796699524,
-1.0897811651229858,
-0.4810108244419098,
0.5170120596885681,
0.4126855731010437,
-0.5956634283065796,
0.3843369483947754,
-0.4359457790851593,
-0.3599202632904053,
-0.477028489112854,
0.2582184970378876,
0.46710315346717834,
0.3812299072742462,
0.3423023223876953,
-0.7181288003921509,
-0.7123501896858215,
-1.0858080387115479,
-0.3077645003795624,
-0.08010595291852951,
-0.30339595675468445,
0.16772052645683289,
0.2187143862247467,
0.027304504066705704,
0.7875556349754333,
-0.6209375858306885,
-0.16521090269088745,
-0.4656025171279907,
-0.332699716091156,
0.1250038594007492,
0.44413167238235474,
0.2010210007429123,
-0.4517015516757965,
-0.2779579758644104,
-0.5129304528236389,
-0.4221945106983185,
-0.12893298268318176,
0.15991297364234924,
0.059904348105192184,
0.13410229980945587,
0.5704609155654907,
-0.7839020490646362,
0.48195043206214905,
0.5614786148071289,
-0.04935344308614731,
0.5959720611572266,
-0.17963512241840363,
-0.46797263622283936,
-0.7285200357437134,
-0.09255561232566833,
-0.12929052114486694,
-0.43856409192085266,
-0.5555837154388428,
-0.266345739364624,
0.004873379599303007,
-0.04313673451542854,
-0.5512003898620605,
0.33730214834213257,
-0.7608191967010498,
-0.5623591542243958,
-0.3645884394645691,
0.25092294812202454,
0.36813122034072876,
0.4577128291130066,
0.22250229120254517,
0.611321747303009,
0.3897308111190796,
-0.6909560561180115,
0.1461220383644104,
0.10771258920431137,
-0.6520785093307495,
0.0009638644405640662,
-0.7704339623451233,
0.33383607864379883,
0.049286942929029465,
0.4090856611728668,
-0.7608839273452759,
-0.01896531507372856,
0.10420569032430649,
-0.08118226379156113,
0.44645363092422485,
-0.04282491281628609,
-0.42227858304977417,
-0.12406805157661438,
-0.5497713685035706,
0.48375430703163147,
0.7061867713928223,
-0.5230804681777954,
0.36109888553619385,
0.3629519045352936,
-0.1572641283273697,
-0.5991300940513611,
-0.9400789141654968,
0.19307094812393188,
-0.5704458951950073,
-0.6515733003616333,
0.6107813119888306,
0.047152746468782425,
-0.33861038088798523,
-0.19135327637195587,
-0.44615137577056885,
-0.08568837493658066,
0.4299394190311432,
0.08882554620504379,
-0.08332332223653793,
-0.26218539476394653,
0.17951898276805878,
0.12909433245658875,
-0.08242084085941315,
0.06424908339977264,
-0.11941606551408768,
0.6176860928535461,
-0.022968780249357224,
-0.5698694586753845,
-0.35676711797714233,
0.27755704522132874,
0.17443084716796875,
-0.3389925956726074,
0.8425614237785339,
0.3460076153278351,
-0.15570011734962463,
-0.29534876346588135,
-0.7344011068344116,
-0.4281954765319824,
-0.4138961136341095,
0.22938497364521027,
-0.21247424185276031,
-1.0815645456314087,
0.2259666472673416,
-0.24124868214130402,
0.0443863719701767,
0.1522408127784729,
0.2869235873222351,
0.1676858812570572,
0.7326964139938354,
0.8362976312637329,
-0.3136359751224518,
0.5976782441139221,
-0.38931217789649963,
0.2705494165420532,
-0.8635071516036987,
-0.021156415343284607,
-0.4720540940761566,
-0.6250283122062683,
-0.31432676315307617,
-0.3083382248878479,
0.08088251948356628,
0.3058330714702606,
-0.06550345569849014,
0.02975289337337017,
-0.30198153853416443,
0.6439797282218933,
0.518459677696228,
0.01453449297696352,
0.4524478614330292,
0.19815626740455627,
0.40606868267059326,
0.19726711511611938,
-0.7801024913787842,
-0.45011985301971436,
0.8932024240493774,
0.4383273124694824,
0.7364553809165955,
0.14849525690078735,
0.8910799026489258,
-0.1659986972808838,
0.33576977252960205,
-1.0180697441101074,
0.6131108999252319,
0.12811270356178284,
-0.21424420177936554,
-0.46883052587509155,
-0.5597743391990662,
-0.9276579022407532,
0.5534063577651978,
0.03872904181480408,
-0.4804745018482208,
0.14171148836612701,
0.18137295544147491,
-0.5380083322525024,
0.29088613390922546,
-0.8057368993759155,
0.5114877820014954,
-0.21418868005275726,
-0.26387158036231995,
-0.38676464557647705,
-0.6933773159980774,
0.4931820034980774,
0.031007492914795876,
0.0216665156185627,
-0.24203543365001678,
-0.3152167797088623,
0.837211012840271,
-0.7541952729225159,
0.8077151775360107,
-0.1441032737493515,
-0.15417154133319855,
0.327488511800766,
0.21357901394367218,
0.40920159220695496,
0.047735545784235,
0.029150955379009247,
0.16099117696285248,
-0.11937003582715988,
-0.2860548198223114,
-0.5611991286277771,
0.629972517490387,
-0.6233276724815369,
-0.9144406318664551,
0.031093280762434006,
-0.6079227924346924,
-0.305280864238739,
0.1519732028245926,
0.023914404213428497,
0.2563752830028534,
-0.16791583597660065,
0.4958021342754364,
0.6141193509101868,
-0.39712896943092346,
0.5061423778533936,
0.41647207736968994,
-0.21014726161956787,
-0.26911357045173645,
0.7938258647918701,
0.13680621981620789,
0.20262449979782104,
0.3641431927680969,
0.1297268122434616,
-0.18730522692203522,
-0.8624325394630432,
-0.021342674270272255,
0.4332071542739868,
-0.5531541109085083,
-0.4244900047779083,
-0.2790100574493408,
-0.2701481282711029,
-0.35579994320869446,
0.12404133379459381,
-0.44853347539901733,
-0.8390105366706848,
-0.10649146884679794,
-0.30348172783851624,
0.158206507563591,
0.6340182423591614,
-0.014514593407511711,
0.7013177275657654,
-0.6406816244125366,
0.22374719381332397,
0.08410747349262238,
0.30019789934158325,
-0.07008892297744751,
-0.6796995997428894,
-0.18321916460990906,
-0.31482791900634766,
-0.3151102066040039,
-0.7751930356025696,
0.7489187121391296,
0.4967903792858124,
0.1902034878730774,
0.5183183550834656,
-0.06399314850568771,
0.7995725274085999,
-0.4285030961036682,
0.48775121569633484,
0.15077130496501923,
-0.8291781544685364,
0.2555899918079376,
0.18875163793563843,
0.3356795907020569,
0.40944772958755493,
0.05563681200146675,
-0.6859230399131775,
-0.16076578199863434,
-0.5044026374816895,
-1.0248924493789673,
0.4261702299118042,
0.06119868531823158,
-0.07907144725322723,
-0.010964122600853443,
0.4717021882534027,
0.13023893535137177,
0.34520480036735535,
-0.6211184859275818,
-0.07183143496513367,
0.06322794407606125,
-0.0736093819141388,
-0.2926108241081238,
-0.7377740144729614,
-0.11936779320240021,
-0.21225765347480774,
0.6390281915664673,
-0.02433914877474308,
0.07399241626262665,
0.3222094774246216,
-0.48416993021965027,
0.20813708007335663,
0.26514965295791626,
0.5260960459709167,
0.8138922452926636,
-0.01564324088394642,
0.3036413788795471,
0.4304746687412262,
-0.2695002853870392,
0.04708345606923103,
-0.22994446754455566,
-0.07718852162361145,
-0.14384151995182037,
0.6416075825691223,
0.7983564734458923,
0.3457663655281067,
-0.6504831910133362,
0.33253371715545654,
-0.11390016973018646,
-0.366131991147995,
-0.3027118742465973,
0.07032223790884018,
0.30174946784973145,
0.2129814624786377,
0.005362417548894882,
-0.38444745540618896,
0.06374841183423996,
-0.1806008666753769,
-0.17097339034080505,
0.3837254047393799,
-0.08467328548431396,
-0.18793225288391113,
0.1894543468952179,
0.28113770484924316,
-0.3953895568847656,
0.8915651440620422,
0.17323440313339233,
-0.2944577634334564,
0.5831897854804993,
0.4462915360927582,
0.7251834273338318,
-0.14538022875785828,
-0.09363408386707306,
0.2557252049446106,
0.36703404784202576,
-0.3540099561214447,
0.08425284177064896,
-0.3382600247859955,
-0.6278060078620911,
-0.9048256874084473,
-0.7631701231002808,
-0.2133791446685791,
0.26412272453308105,
-0.5960891246795654,
-0.131985604763031,
-0.6799377799034119,
0.08720558881759644,
-0.5276147127151489,
0.21818487346172333,
-0.38923174142837524,
0.21828612685203552,
0.2343260794878006,
1.3472342491149902,
-0.7748040556907654,
1.1223214864730835,
0.237583726644516,
-0.060534242540597916,
-0.8674624562263489,
-0.13446781039237976,
-0.031234240159392357,
-0.68250972032547,
0.33615127205848694,
0.45392003655433655,
-0.3026452660560608,
-0.003753971541300416,
-0.5845915675163269,
-1.071236491203308,
1.1830291748046875,
0.8024886250495911,
-0.9161317944526672,
0.0790441557765007,
0.09096453338861465,
0.5365464091300964,
-0.24084126949310303,
-0.09046092629432678,
0.8911249041557312,
0.4561130404472351,
0.06814979761838913,
-0.7495090365409851,
-0.0006369109032675624,
-0.011146491393446922,
0.16204600036144257,
0.22409780323505402,
-0.6504331827163696,
0.6127102375030518,
-0.10504964739084244,
-0.44238442182540894,
0.20553527772426605,
0.9530125260353088,
0.3037511706352234,
0.06835268437862396,
0.8231531381607056,
0.914424479007721,
0.8107735514640808,
-0.023245973512530327,
1.0241950750350952,
-0.3404151499271393,
0.07536760717630386,
0.936936616897583,
-0.24633857607841492,
0.7699791789054871,
0.7652934193611145,
-0.07651026546955109,
0.4894474744796753,
0.7574337720870972,
0.3703148066997528,
0.35825347900390625,
0.3802802562713623,
-0.02711356431245804,
-0.3548129200935364,
-0.050374265760183334,
-0.39187467098236084,
0.353848934173584,
0.2568265199661255,
-0.13966354727745056,
-0.03160101920366287,
-0.23799817264080048,
0.1099415123462677,
-0.04005205258727074,
-0.2760798931121826,
0.6490904688835144,
0.5798253417015076,
-0.7485527396202087,
0.7088320255279541,
0.12878955900669098,
0.6330023407936096,
-0.5562926530838013,
0.22693224251270294,
-0.6048632264137268,
0.2333742082118988,
-0.23979710042476654,
-0.46936488151550293,
0.5358157753944397,
-0.016553156077861786,
-0.015603257343173027,
-0.4529978632926941,
0.8705498576164246,
-0.41299116611480713,
-0.20183566212654114,
0.310740202665329,
0.6426376700401306,
0.38917598128318787,
-0.25256696343421936,
-0.47855132818222046,
0.3586806058883667,
0.04171738773584366,
-0.7408612966537476,
0.37154364585876465,
0.1959504932165146,
-0.15418584644794464,
0.9407507181167603,
0.5379453301429749,
0.25768208503723145,
0.00924154557287693,
0.3215106725692749,
0.8977662324905396,
-0.6866833567619324,
-0.2050647735595703,
-0.9226598739624023,
0.1763891875743866,
-0.0796099305152893,
-0.09943976998329163,
0.7869927287101746,
0.6827369928359985,
0.8405195474624634,
0.048085328191518784,
0.26232922077178955,
0.19162647426128387,
0.4591720700263977,
-0.6506516337394714,
0.32357257604599,
-0.7548854351043701,
0.3977213501930237,
0.2925548851490021,
-1.1565234661102295,
-0.33042585849761963,
0.5672692656517029,
-0.48679137229919434,
0.17258943617343903,
0.56582111120224,
0.7862876057624817,
-0.16609729826450348,
-0.35543176531791687,
0.32073819637298584,
0.22632339596748352,
0.1868930608034134,
0.5214361548423767,
0.8167064189910889,
0.0358305387198925,
0.763613224029541,
-0.38084864616394043,
0.008097721263766289,
-0.21787042915821075,
-0.8551567792892456,
-0.5499330759048462,
-0.1381024718284607,
-0.19990922510623932,
-0.030537990853190422,
-0.04611068591475487,
0.5085638761520386,
0.8571485877037048,
-0.4336305558681488,
-0.38782763481140137,
0.0228048674762249,
0.3815310299396515,
-0.056636665016412735,
-0.1554170697927475,
0.3350539207458496,
-0.0027677377220243216,
-0.5885871052742004,
0.8107122778892517,
0.21103914082050323,
-0.15882103145122528,
-0.3358832597732544,
-0.22125780582427979,
-0.09012844413518906,
-0.039964091032743454,
0.638878583908081,
0.4505244195461273,
-0.681894063949585,
-0.2504999041557312,
-0.32835572957992554,
0.02086404711008072,
0.1409311443567276,
0.7870352268218994,
-0.9767486453056335,
-0.139705628156662,
0.6509614586830139,
0.5421341061592102,
0.8201857805252075,
0.07030121237039566,
0.5501563549041748,
-1.1237980127334595,
0.4421003460884094,
0.157660573720932,
0.5176917910575867,
0.5449983477592468,
0.0948580950498581,
0.6513003706932068,
0.18864545226097107,
-0.40946027636528015,
-1.0453485250473022,
0.4598899185657501,
-0.7460629940032959,
-0.48884719610214233,
1.2585701942443848,
-0.07930180430412292,
-0.586007833480835,
0.33499228954315186,
-0.15400464832782745,
0.26879337430000305,
-0.13548223674297333,
0.7030499577522278,
0.4473371207714081,
0.0761152058839798,
-0.26825517416000366,
-0.33488887548446655,
0.42615267634391785,
0.7410339713096619,
-0.7185301184654236,
-0.036706335842609406,
0.4818502366542816,
0.3540229797363281,
0.01246134378015995,
0.517073929309845,
0.16494520008563995,
-0.06738635152578354,
-0.20973075926303864,
0.20059950649738312,
-0.21132032573223114,
-0.5775465369224548,
-0.43965113162994385,
0.2537839114665985,
0.2751554250717163,
-0.013084005564451218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02823v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02823v2 | Evading Data Contamination Detection for Language Models is (too) Easy | 2024-02-05T09:10:32 | 2024-02-12T17:50:07 | Jasper Dekoninck, Mark Niklas Müller, Maximilian Baader, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large language models are widespread, with their performance on benchmarks
frequently guiding user preferences for one model over another. However, the
vast amount of data these models are trained on can inadvertently lead to
contamination with public benchmarks, thus compromising performance
measurements. While recently developed contamination detection methods try to
address this issue, they overlook the possibility of deliberate contamination
by malicious model providers aiming to evade detection. We argue that this
setting is of crucial importance as it casts doubt on the reliability of public
benchmarks. To more rigorously study this issue, we propose a categorization of
both model providers and contamination detection methods. This reveals
vulnerabilities in existing methods that we exploit with EAL, a simple yet
effective contamination technique that significantly inflates benchmark
performance while completely evading current detection methods. | [
-0.4956648051738739,
-0.9300675988197327,
0.9143227934837341,
-0.1509440839290619,
0.2111128270626068,
0.07641404867172241,
0.06500449031591415,
-0.886660635471344,
-0.5292548537254333,
1.0292962789535522,
-0.13289280235767365,
-0.26051682233810425,
-0.6423659920692444,
-0.24614442884922028,
-0.8787885308265686,
1.0341312885284424,
0.01869310811161995,
-0.5067573189735413,
-0.291424959897995,
-0.13881617784500122,
-0.06781186908483505,
-0.7432034015655518,
-0.48022031784057617,
-0.24117088317871094,
0.3851410150527954,
0.2037089467048645,
0.7382708191871643,
0.8840094208717346,
0.2817525565624237,
0.3152424991130829,
-0.12795233726501465,
0.31461408734321594,
-0.37965071201324463,
0.0593428872525692,
-0.3410226106643677,
-0.6456866264343262,
-0.25810912251472473,
-0.19562014937400818,
0.3053719103336334,
0.6256954669952393,
-0.18751786649227142,
0.11964650452136993,
0.1250876933336258,
0.6221330165863037,
-1.2089911699295044,
-0.03456347808241844,
-0.9641901254653931,
-0.32471784949302673,
-0.6251876950263977,
-0.023730283603072166,
-0.9678028225898743,
0.028095383197069168,
-0.14450116455554962,
-0.5028790235519409,
0.17318810522556305,
0.08820405602455139,
1.0234630107879639,
0.22769127786159515,
-0.4315069019794464,
-0.001082578208297491,
-1.0597816705703735,
0.7951951622962952,
-0.4969932734966278,
0.30123451352119446,
0.8643276691436768,
0.41647815704345703,
-0.06468717753887177,
-0.8540704846382141,
-0.3905578851699829,
-0.2310960739850998,
0.0028577407356351614,
-0.42240533232688904,
-0.8106857538223267,
0.0011829313589259982,
0.25805556774139404,
-0.0536968931555748,
-0.40936553478240967,
0.18650008738040924,
-0.3247600495815277,
-0.26718294620513916,
0.7053580284118652,
0.07023706287145615,
0.6818051934242249,
-0.10091472417116165,
-0.7157660126686096,
-0.1642283797264099,
-1.0844534635543823,
0.06634189933538437,
0.5425978302955627,
0.19853200018405914,
0.1609107106924057,
0.022881925106048584,
-0.017143042758107185,
0.6726361513137817,
-0.3684508204460144,
0.3582724332809448,
0.07880055904388428,
-0.2796277403831482,
-0.3442397117614746,
-0.1289260983467102,
0.6818719506263733,
-0.08426504582166672,
0.2306392341852188,
-0.2305736094713211,
-0.48192426562309265,
-0.05847592651844025,
0.47247517108917236,
-0.3586384356021881,
-0.42010974884033203,
0.581689178943634,
0.01675974577665329,
-0.48049992322921753,
0.20765328407287598,
-0.7612119913101196,
-0.41621696949005127,
0.013632148504257202,
0.667109489440918,
-0.10424943268299103,
-0.3631341755390167,
0.15625785291194916,
0.06918246299028397,
-0.2662297189235687,
0.29598215222358704,
-0.7404012680053711,
0.510624349117279,
1.1386563777923584,
0.3794110119342804,
0.23909497261047363,
-0.3235470950603485,
-0.8469701409339905,
0.1751856654882431,
-0.33467647433280945,
0.8883630633354187,
-0.5397351384162903,
-0.46294090151786804,
0.1490575224161148,
-0.10559482872486115,
0.23612356185913086,
-0.7677791714668274,
0.6729626655578613,
-0.5273422598838806,
-0.1365119069814682,
-0.2673887610435486,
-0.5323641896247864,
-0.1570664495229721,
-0.0834929421544075,
-0.8576562404632568,
1.0006446838378906,
-0.14607183635234833,
-0.9045803546905518,
0.419656366109848,
-0.2942329943180084,
-0.33186134696006775,
0.20702648162841797,
-0.09849388897418976,
-0.47231772541999817,
0.0646061822772026,
0.3083168864250183,
0.2699087858200073,
0.06564874947071075,
0.4530593752861023,
-0.7265799045562744,
-0.46536505222320557,
0.32836201786994934,
-0.888439953327179,
0.8880851864814758,
0.5048577785491943,
-0.4347093403339386,
-0.25765615701675415,
-0.8133347034454346,
0.13568304479122162,
0.003696025814861059,
-0.09503307193517685,
-0.7628490924835205,
0.14329558610916138,
0.43244078755378723,
0.24707560241222382,
-0.04252025857567787,
-0.40698865056037903,
-0.24787305295467377,
-0.2435482144355774,
0.2240481972694397,
1.0142689943313599,
0.13997219502925873,
0.03417778015136719,
-0.5086017847061157,
0.44523242115974426,
0.07573440670967102,
0.3684366047382355,
-0.26946502923965454,
-0.34767696261405945,
-0.7552679181098938,
-0.2982498109340668,
0.2133036106824875,
0.3202818036079407,
-0.8069962859153748,
0.3921796679496765,
-0.21060360968112946,
-0.780927300453186,
-0.5740540623664856,
0.1769355684518814,
0.7161635756492615,
0.2828983664512634,
0.4374423027038574,
0.19918547570705414,
-0.28608715534210205,
-1.04096519947052,
-0.8932058215141296,
-0.28575801849365234,
-0.14948537945747375,
0.4570073187351227,
0.5237163305282593,
-0.04522037133574486,
0.8498464822769165,
-0.5084671378135681,
0.03376087173819542,
-0.06037424877285957,
0.09181272238492966,
-0.1732596755027771,
0.5053985714912415,
0.5954403877258301,
-0.7202890515327454,
-0.40175989270210266,
-0.07826323062181473,
-0.6157483458518982,
-0.390288382768631,
0.03628622740507126,
-0.012784009799361229,
0.021857015788555145,
0.6679331660270691,
-0.27046480774879456,
0.4617423117160797,
0.5411311388015747,
-0.37225303053855896,
0.5791392922401428,
-0.2263917475938797,
0.05593551695346832,
-0.6320984363555908,
0.40191248059272766,
0.11346469074487686,
-0.44344356656074524,
-1.102123737335205,
0.4766893684864044,
0.3371443748474121,
0.004287615418434143,
-0.9388048052787781,
0.6507163047790527,
-0.2012890875339508,
0.27337560057640076,
-0.21295499801635742,
0.06249401345849037,
0.5114737153053284,
-0.11105389147996902,
-0.1649705022573471,
0.6241760849952698,
0.5954315662384033,
-0.4127347767353058,
-0.17046041786670685,
0.15996317565441132,
-0.5336933135986328,
0.31005704402923584,
-0.7069056630134583,
0.3032764494419098,
0.061163559556007385,
0.19809657335281372,
-0.9679189920425415,
-0.07711266726255417,
-0.0013760364381596446,
-0.07863286882638931,
0.3810567855834961,
-0.3009278476238251,
-0.6299983859062195,
-0.062334299087524414,
-0.29745960235595703,
0.4120977222919464,
0.3271883726119995,
-1.0591397285461426,
0.1514073759317398,
0.36931994557380676,
0.24239061772823334,
-0.7389156222343445,
-0.9933025240898132,
-0.08623497188091278,
-0.4767261743545532,
-0.635394811630249,
0.1294783502817154,
0.21252226829528809,
-0.6162804961204529,
0.02454392984509468,
-0.1903461366891861,
-0.4205365478992462,
0.6889750957489014,
0.20968842506408691,
0.22058525681495667,
-0.13131870329380035,
0.03620577231049538,
-0.17974556982517242,
-0.042388565838336945,
0.18116283416748047,
0.38704565167427063,
0.38491785526275635,
0.08966075628995895,
-0.903286874294281,
-0.4415630102157593,
0.26202407479286194,
0.7092007994651794,
-0.4599287807941437,
0.7102385759353638,
0.03200724348425865,
-0.6506050229072571,
-0.4903614819049835,
-0.6789838671684265,
-0.05647134780883789,
-0.6081087589263916,
0.45433223247528076,
-0.33476507663726807,
-0.13256493210792542,
0.5041843056678772,
0.0715741217136383,
-0.11147084087133408,
0.28293338418006897,
-0.22250208258628845,
0.08256513625383377,
1.0671976804733276,
0.568916380405426,
-0.26735708117485046,
0.173411563038826,
0.0973980724811554,
0.19709903001785278,
-0.6349700093269348,
-0.013820580206811428,
-0.943812906742096,
0.1858236938714981,
-0.46012088656425476,
-0.28952866792678833,
0.1705644726753235,
0.16927142441272736,
-0.1456325501203537,
0.4114937484264374,
-0.21883998811244965,
0.9138689041137695,
0.18301810324192047,
0.21467424929141998,
0.49378785490989685,
-0.17337864637374878,
0.044953327625989914,
0.022906573489308357,
-0.3671969175338745,
-0.589496374130249,
1.2032002210617065,
0.577886700630188,
0.747914731502533,
0.07579763978719711,
0.9520397186279297,
0.4052169620990753,
0.3355603814125061,
0.015784472227096558,
0.2817519009113312,
-0.25811144709587097,
-0.835720956325531,
-0.05842825397849083,
-0.37142688035964966,
-0.8722568154335022,
0.36401888728141785,
0.1952201873064041,
-1.2191400527954102,
0.5334815382957458,
0.06760469824075699,
-0.2482728362083435,
0.5904344916343689,
-0.7490799427032471,
0.8122844099998474,
-0.23354196548461914,
-0.5963364243507385,
0.026181232184171677,
-0.2760144770145416,
0.7637338638305664,
-0.5720857381820679,
0.6589248776435852,
-0.14628714323043823,
0.14741083979606628,
0.3762425482273102,
-0.6304178833961487,
0.6232802867889404,
-0.1726786196231842,
-0.10188271850347519,
0.050728656351566315,
0.5592548251152039,
0.6858950853347778,
-0.0728316679596901,
0.07526441663503647,
0.19359678030014038,
0.009690134786069393,
-0.5840392708778381,
-0.39481133222579956,
0.6185290217399597,
-0.5001340508460999,
-0.7073246836662292,
-0.40136319398880005,
-0.049632132053375244,
-0.453064888715744,
0.1177280843257904,
0.33822858333587646,
0.37214088439941406,
0.1349795013666153,
0.2113427221775055,
0.6022223234176636,
-0.4165390729904175,
0.3958542048931122,
0.7302494049072266,
-0.4046758711338043,
0.17006592452526093,
0.9349996447563171,
-0.06001763045787811,
0.7283254861831665,
0.11954545974731445,
0.19478660821914673,
-0.27332139015197754,
-0.5572731494903564,
-0.2575415074825287,
-0.017811352387070656,
-0.7054381966590881,
-0.24076804518699646,
-0.6783255934715271,
-0.2979467213153839,
0.0948570966720581,
-0.08306751400232315,
-0.776552140712738,
-0.01534173171967268,
-0.15560223162174225,
-0.13160698115825653,
0.12672147154808044,
0.7848646640777588,
0.14485250413417816,
-0.030703067779541016,
-0.8410297632217407,
-0.0231309961527586,
0.02161887288093567,
0.2692524194717407,
0.0777084082365036,
-0.4684550166130066,
0.03974737226963043,
0.05976010859012604,
-0.27630841732025146,
-0.8574500679969788,
0.3597870171070099,
0.101606585085392,
0.7851945757865906,
0.8507314324378967,
0.23934587836265564,
0.45832374691963196,
-0.4484937787055969,
0.7651326656341553,
-0.19824877381324768,
-1.3682880401611328,
0.6902164816856384,
-0.2859911620616913,
-0.022981274873018265,
0.6534880995750427,
0.39588209986686707,
-0.5084938406944275,
-1.0219573974609375,
-0.8609991073608398,
-1.0923727750778198,
0.6732539534568787,
0.10005208849906921,
0.05793651565909386,
-0.01155050192028284,
-0.064365454018116,
0.07449162006378174,
0.060899171978235245,
-0.5540211796760559,
-0.3828558623790741,
0.05407081916928291,
0.310140460729599,
-0.05330972373485565,
-0.29213687777519226,
-0.18217381834983826,
0.16368180513381958,
0.6070484519004822,
0.31475865840911865,
-0.29763415455818176,
-0.1772344708442688,
-0.26696348190307617,
-0.09339120984077454,
0.2599398195743561,
0.49119436740875244,
0.7205541133880615,
0.05999936908483505,
0.3193415403366089,
-0.2031799703836441,
-0.23018711805343628,
0.222457155585289,
-0.015416688285768032,
-0.23116940259933472,
-0.037058450281620026,
0.4912901222705841,
0.4285309612751007,
0.44511309266090393,
-0.9326038956642151,
0.6846833229064941,
0.1548396795988083,
0.10319094359874725,
-0.06165864318609238,
0.1964280754327774,
0.10513819009065628,
-0.0836663544178009,
0.4572044312953949,
0.20796851813793182,
0.3973676562309265,
-0.5854886174201965,
0.89882892370224,
0.26876121759414673,
-0.35632702708244324,
-0.2547513246536255,
0.8427755832672119,
0.1065211072564125,
-0.12131540477275848,
0.44776055216789246,
0.01877545565366745,
-0.582205593585968,
0.8326374292373657,
0.3873462378978729,
0.8326123952865601,
-0.5183625221252441,
0.15978500247001648,
-0.07762255519628525,
0.481899619102478,
-0.12992291152477264,
-0.06886587291955948,
0.2726067006587982,
-0.8606809973716736,
-0.22713471949100494,
-0.3920237720012665,
-0.23134049773216248,
0.7182820439338684,
-0.9837622046470642,
0.2763795554637909,
-0.35915613174438477,
0.12005462497472763,
0.5002636313438416,
-0.42171862721443176,
-0.6749387383460999,
-0.14499105513095856,
0.3675941526889801,
1.1341075897216797,
-1.2843966484069824,
0.8854579329490662,
0.18758654594421387,
-0.294997900724411,
-0.8326500058174133,
0.3012375831604004,
0.33666154742240906,
-0.6100584268569946,
0.6474974751472473,
0.21222923696041107,
0.11805100739002228,
-0.5067614316940308,
-0.1550840586423874,
-0.6962596774101257,
0.5330293774604797,
0.3487469255924225,
-0.42528602480888367,
0.34077584743499756,
0.2391490489244461,
0.5546289086341858,
0.27023670077323914,
0.1916363388299942,
0.8413640856742859,
0.7007235884666443,
-0.5896046757698059,
-0.9840328097343445,
0.21378402411937714,
-0.2282613217830658,
-0.08580968528985977,
0.361767441034317,
-0.5644225478172302,
0.7724232077598572,
0.11396133154630661,
-0.363043874502182,
-0.07105862349271774,
-0.12597419321537018,
0.1736343950033188,
0.500399649143219,
0.49539992213249207,
0.5047247409820557,
0.8026943206787109,
-0.17792390286922455,
1.254822850227356,
-0.19347752630710602,
0.522413969039917,
1.2701458930969238,
-0.6017464399337769,
1.08457612991333,
0.3229753375053406,
-0.4861060082912445,
0.142528235912323,
0.31709396839141846,
-0.1893840879201889,
0.5327159762382507,
0.14137676358222961,
-0.5189629793167114,
-0.18780027329921722,
-0.08151368051767349,
-0.26786985993385315,
0.8392502069473267,
0.31729716062545776,
-0.37475118041038513,
-0.5488064885139465,
0.12163624167442322,
0.29083606600761414,
0.3885924518108368,
-0.06583976000547409,
0.5118106007575989,
-0.2541743516921997,
-0.5822457671165466,
0.6651372909545898,
-0.0400683619081974,
0.33442452549934387,
-0.4229564964771271,
-0.013307904824614525,
-0.29597729444503784,
0.2790549397468567,
-0.28416708111763,
-0.7130250930786133,
0.2746318578720093,
-0.09372961521148682,
0.1979653388261795,
-0.18212415277957916,
0.7821757793426514,
-0.287335067987442,
-0.17127852141857147,
0.5733984112739563,
0.6090866923332214,
0.14446485042572021,
-0.39596331119537354,
-0.46524298191070557,
0.28448447585105896,
0.00305712828412652,
-0.31579121947288513,
0.532744824886322,
0.04949764162302017,
-0.009766578674316406,
0.9942653179168701,
0.8529972434043884,
0.22402840852737427,
0.020045116543769836,
-0.08778322488069534,
0.7628636956214905,
-0.16779612004756927,
-0.4695785641670227,
-1.129624605178833,
0.4887874722480774,
0.02514764480292797,
0.046585842967033386,
0.7482388019561768,
0.6490932106971741,
0.8728582859039307,
0.1410137265920639,
0.7407594323158264,
0.41805294156074524,
0.33238521218299866,
-0.4352383613586426,
1.1491323709487915,
-0.46826106309890747,
0.8177804946899414,
-0.27403077483177185,
-0.588768720626831,
-0.058819808065891266,
-0.02574392594397068,
-0.1788024753332138,
0.1440887153148651,
0.694762647151947,
0.6883756518363953,
-0.33189213275909424,
0.10968714207410812,
0.6063060164451599,
0.2333350032567978,
0.7398419976234436,
0.4741024672985077,
0.8679258823394775,
-0.24236367642879486,
0.6149961352348328,
-0.5794017314910889,
-0.1805880069732666,
-0.24827919900417328,
-0.8124608397483826,
-0.5541414618492126,
-0.39777424931526184,
-0.23412522673606873,
-0.4624817967414856,
0.2726263701915741,
0.30018535256385803,
0.7462257742881775,
-0.8886697888374329,
0.18499065935611725,
-0.19415976107120514,
0.10229310393333435,
-0.3793144226074219,
-0.28152719140052795,
0.38062235713005066,
-0.24138760566711426,
-0.8260442614555359,
0.5623787641525269,
-0.031366027891635895,
-0.11320691555738449,
-0.5038958191871643,
0.44661903381347656,
0.042615022510290146,
0.23819266259670258,
0.04696723073720932,
0.5434108972549438,
-0.8281257748603821,
-0.541588306427002,
-0.45887526869773865,
-0.29290488362312317,
-0.171854168176651,
0.631339430809021,
-0.6502566933631897,
0.525478720664978,
0.26883184909820557,
0.849377453327179,
0.3055262565612793,
0.07705897092819214,
0.5241521596908569,
-0.9877421855926514,
0.07923871278762817,
0.1759180724620819,
0.4512723684310913,
0.2306000292301178,
-0.764475405216217,
0.36895751953125,
-0.0341227762401104,
-0.45181989669799805,
-1.461969256401062,
0.31279489398002625,
-0.4444698989391327,
-0.5297641158103943,
1.1525931358337402,
-0.5679746270179749,
-0.26567739248275757,
-0.38814878463745117,
0.37469682097435,
-0.3478125333786011,
-0.1549978107213974,
0.8628764748573303,
1.0399123430252075,
-0.0008773471927270293,
0.16315588355064392,
-1.0299952030181885,
0.6171870827674866,
0.22847610712051392,
-1.031124234199524,
0.5362604856491089,
0.10511401295661926,
0.6839986443519592,
0.20520435273647308,
0.3069119155406952,
-0.4342435896396637,
0.3934214413166046,
0.2657867670059204,
-0.1710912138223648,
-0.17220553755760193,
-0.41605424880981445,
-0.48999497294425964,
0.03641777113080025,
0.1937790811061859,
-0.16755197942256927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02807v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02807v3 | Are Sounds Sound for Phylogenetic Reconstruction? | 2024-02-05T08:35:33 | 2024-05-14T07:38:26 | Luise Häuser, Gerhard Jäger, Taraka Rama, Johann-Mattis List, Alexandros Stamatakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In traditional studies on language evolution, scholars often emphasize the
importance of sound laws and sound correspondences for phylogenetic inference
of language family trees. However, to date, computational approaches have
typically not taken this potential into account. Most computational studies
still rely on lexical cognates as major data source for phylogenetic
reconstruction in linguistics, although there do exist a few studies in which
authors praise the benefits of comparing words at the level of sound sequences.
Building on (a) ten diverse datasets from different language families, and (b)
state-of-the-art methods for automated cognate and sound correspondence
detection, we test, for the first time, the performance of sound-based versus
cognate-based approaches to phylogenetic reconstruction. Our results show that
phylogenies reconstructed from lexical cognates are topologically closer, by
approximately one third with respect to the generalized quartet distance on
average, to the gold standard phylogenies than phylogenies reconstructed from
sound correspondences. | [
-0.35910627245903015,
-0.41587865352630615,
0.2396163046360016,
-0.1977328062057495,
-0.34778109192848206,
0.21207751333713531,
-0.4382234215736389,
-0.750559389591217,
0.6389260292053223,
0.10169392824172974,
-0.7101061344146729,
-0.19219903647899628,
-0.1673753261566162,
0.3925161063671112,
-0.6759611368179321,
0.6489382982254028,
0.7997621297836304,
-0.2694871127605438,
0.17724178731441498,
-0.0104745514690876,
0.03898920118808746,
-0.529609203338623,
-0.556775689125061,
0.0023734767455607653,
0.34434232115745544,
-0.048349980264902115,
0.8477137088775635,
0.8998584151268005,
0.4622114896774292,
0.2257269024848938,
-0.524067223072052,
0.046687133610248566,
-0.3704202175140381,
0.13485482335090637,
-0.028491947799921036,
-0.3031300902366638,
-0.19240258634090424,
-0.22654522955417633,
0.3782237470149994,
1.1279572248458862,
-0.06700821965932846,
0.004766268655657768,
-0.009103755466639996,
0.6187294721603394,
-0.39209839701652527,
0.10856948047876358,
-0.6648465394973755,
0.31907448172569275,
-0.4608614146709442,
-0.5733348727226257,
-0.43587860465049744,
-0.3583489954471588,
0.6711134314537048,
-0.8050265908241272,
0.4360332190990448,
0.3137330710887909,
0.8425344228744507,
0.24547265470027924,
-0.11507584899663925,
-0.5909072160720825,
-0.9653369784355164,
0.5953963398933411,
-0.776809573173523,
0.8250604271888733,
0.06805124133825302,
0.09561283886432648,
-0.5890182256698608,
-0.5159094929695129,
-0.3084249794483185,
-0.28965646028518677,
-0.04681602492928505,
0.046039432287216187,
-0.46095967292785645,
0.1141996681690216,
0.28209802508354187,
0.972524106502533,
-0.7767190933227539,
0.02445562370121479,
-0.4073675572872162,
-0.5448521375656128,
0.5511126518249512,
-0.29480522871017456,
0.6771832704544067,
-0.22537674009799957,
-0.1038263812661171,
-0.6295136213302612,
-0.6934065222740173,
-0.08148232847452164,
0.6721617579460144,
0.6864541172981262,
-0.21682539582252502,
0.26456353068351746,
0.070744588971138,
0.8405712842941284,
0.09557057172060013,
-0.6951489448547363,
0.1426595002412796,
-0.7967696785926819,
0.2234814316034317,
0.503675639629364,
0.6317718625068665,
0.11377117037773132,
0.59098219871521,
-0.3349792957305908,
0.10750604420900345,
0.09220701456069946,
-0.3255079686641693,
-0.33230727910995483,
-0.6865521669387817,
-0.14775486290454865,
-0.3564935624599457,
0.10012326389551163,
-0.24981065094470978,
-0.7763479948043823,
-0.3744457960128784,
-0.30747362971305847,
0.08956347405910492,
-0.5352299809455872,
-0.5888972282409668,
0.24728401005268097,
-0.4605795741081238,
0.4134680926799774,
0.2501904368400574,
-1.3018474578857422,
0.7948237657546997,
0.912657618522644,
0.8738802075386047,
-0.1538773775100708,
-0.16833364963531494,
-0.38438117504119873,
-0.211276113986969,
-0.4359991252422333,
0.9846177697181702,
-0.3986364006996155,
-0.5406948328018188,
-0.18342436850070953,
-0.3027459383010864,
-0.026860205456614494,
-0.8713527321815491,
0.5038593411445618,
-0.05111490935087204,
0.08848251402378082,
-0.4076699912548065,
-0.5550139546394348,
-0.36226075887680054,
-0.24788697063922882,
-0.6462907791137695,
0.8238148093223572,
0.29374316334724426,
-0.7958297729492188,
0.6840157508850098,
-0.05190229043364525,
-0.4612685441970825,
0.001058543915860355,
-0.20595651865005493,
-0.3200226426124573,
0.1488800346851349,
-0.005253089126199484,
-0.010627632960677147,
-0.22060538828372955,
0.10164134949445724,
-0.4580070972442627,
-0.39819997549057007,
-0.2740273177623749,
-0.08076883107423782,
0.95014888048172,
0.26349323987960815,
-0.46728917956352234,
-0.2725302577018738,
-0.7538816332817078,
-0.2728763520717621,
-0.1370929479598999,
-0.2272169142961502,
-0.4560324251651764,
0.12349119782447815,
-0.36790913343429565,
-0.24770024418830872,
-0.11683478206396103,
-0.6089439988136292,
0.27298828959465027,
-0.7051781415939331,
0.3842023015022278,
0.24234843254089355,
-0.048610247671604156,
0.24046123027801514,
-0.43108242750167847,
0.3872120976448059,
-0.21464110910892487,
-0.443831205368042,
-0.16124257445335388,
-0.5170714259147644,
-0.43537071347236633,
-0.5379299521446228,
0.5569922924041748,
0.24307292699813843,
0.006324344780296087,
0.4678446352481842,
-0.41861391067504883,
-0.4907766878604889,
-0.26032450795173645,
-0.4641590416431427,
0.17291979491710663,
0.2713269889354706,
0.29082581400871277,
-0.7558310627937317,
-1.0073567628860474,
-0.6549941301345825,
-0.3309186100959778,
-0.753945529460907,
0.08304551243782043,
0.43544816970825195,
0.31933388113975525,
0.42816823720932007,
0.8554591536521912,
-0.17185981571674347,
-0.0002510868071112782,
0.1701871007680893,
-0.09513552486896515,
0.189382404088974,
0.25721877813339233,
0.7971622347831726,
-0.28445160388946533,
-0.23405008018016815,
0.24566520750522614,
-0.6173560619354248,
-0.3182222247123718,
0.20908838510513306,
0.3590273857116699,
-0.06285055726766586,
0.4524304270744324,
-0.22781121730804443,
0.2587096691131592,
0.6689949631690979,
-0.34568703174591064,
0.49470776319503784,
0.2003672868013382,
0.14759202301502228,
-0.7928885817527771,
0.2218654751777649,
-0.3406030237674713,
-0.15642865002155304,
-0.7211493253707886,
-0.04866906255483627,
-0.5916054844856262,
-0.08272049576044083,
-0.2582649290561676,
0.3888185918331146,
-0.5404263138771057,
-0.8015473484992981,
0.03511224687099457,
0.04908290132880211,
-0.40842506289482117,
0.25440260767936707,
0.19611112773418427,
0.6861143112182617,
0.5643481016159058,
-0.47632911801338196,
0.34594979882240295,
0.20341016352176666,
-0.24638597667217255,
0.4254315197467804,
-0.3982885777950287,
0.21027930080890656,
0.27043840289115906,
0.5922666192054749,
-0.9915636777877808,
-0.15486811101436615,
0.15915097296237946,
-0.436137318611145,
0.24915674328804016,
-0.0987258329987526,
-0.16404764354228973,
-0.19251136481761932,
-0.23148560523986816,
0.7317709922790527,
0.6463899612426758,
-0.7104564905166626,
0.026899470016360283,
0.45298659801483154,
-0.3879793882369995,
-0.109231136739254,
-0.377387136220932,
0.13672897219657898,
-0.48012131452560425,
-0.746987521648407,
0.006188973318785429,
0.1739654690027237,
-0.7217465043067932,
-0.2950266897678375,
-0.3383633494377136,
-0.16983376443386078,
0.2982603907585144,
0.0070500923320651054,
-0.03193071112036705,
-0.5988818407058716,
0.14993321895599365,
-0.32510772347450256,
0.24124735593795776,
-0.22864507138729095,
-0.6230306029319763,
0.47183623909950256,
0.0059999870136380196,
-0.23464958369731903,
-0.36073678731918335,
-0.0025528259575366974,
0.501060962677002,
-0.16909238696098328,
-0.09698798507452011,
0.05668361112475395,
-0.49190181493759155,
0.0435744933784008,
-0.43940961360931396,
-0.43459251523017883,
-0.37580886483192444,
-0.04293074831366539,
-0.2880580425262451,
-0.8493956923484802,
0.2812139391899109,
-0.3864026665687561,
-0.1505369246006012,
0.4838855266571045,
0.2777361273765564,
-0.07777886092662811,
0.30089277029037476,
0.1916012018918991,
-0.20020955801010132,
0.20409558713436127,
0.006183146499097347,
0.0742957666516304,
-0.45635294914245605,
-0.031077373772859573,
-1.100110650062561,
-0.23599791526794434,
-0.6599749326705933,
-0.017591658979654312,
0.24097940325737,
-0.16487304866313934,
0.21959376335144043,
0.6114214062690735,
-0.3926575481891632,
0.07149036228656769,
0.5328380465507507,
-0.13974061608314514,
0.557165801525116,
0.32412204146385193,
-0.1537097841501236,
-0.13444870710372925,
-0.6851927638053894,
-0.15712183713912964,
0.6167021989822388,
0.05232180282473564,
0.49148157238960266,
0.04102655500173569,
1.0460872650146484,
0.04970437288284302,
-0.5271605253219604,
-0.8928991556167603,
0.5014005899429321,
-0.2949760854244232,
-0.42802897095680237,
-0.38956204056739807,
-0.3919519782066345,
-1.4158843755722046,
0.28725677728652954,
-0.2361205518245697,
-0.9449567198753357,
0.7148319482803345,
0.1523544043302536,
-0.5425539612770081,
0.3420576751232147,
-0.19071371853351593,
0.31501859426498413,
0.011552196927368641,
0.028760066255927086,
-0.23973976075649261,
-0.6884852647781372,
0.34355291724205017,
-0.1743452250957489,
0.2758221924304962,
-0.2483503818511963,
0.23437190055847168,
0.9121785163879395,
-0.7134717702865601,
0.3181009888648987,
0.0909121185541153,
-0.41878077387809753,
0.42789947986602783,
0.5038173198699951,
0.15154297649860382,
-0.6653993129730225,
-0.16160011291503906,
0.0754576325416565,
0.465154230594635,
-0.07833434641361237,
-0.3617650270462036,
0.5143151879310608,
-0.36138755083084106,
-0.39485013484954834,
-0.4810323417186737,
-0.7265092134475708,
-0.20870435237884521,
0.1548084020614624,
0.12348447740077972,
0.6850870847702026,
-0.36094850301742554,
0.33318838477134705,
0.3963403105735779,
-0.01600436493754387,
0.6024607419967651,
0.26313289999961853,
-0.12418273091316223,
-0.21229293942451477,
0.9513586759567261,
-0.003616717178374529,
0.13063202798366547,
0.2854577600955963,
0.4417194426059723,
-0.26123756170272827,
-0.7383950352668762,
-0.4116699993610382,
0.09331447631120682,
-0.11246109008789062,
0.29228633642196655,
-0.3428114354610443,
0.20018480718135834,
-0.19521436095237732,
0.02251538075506687,
-0.22442014515399933,
-0.7331604957580566,
0.10999666899442673,
0.12077085673809052,
0.4941501319408417,
0.7906373143196106,
-0.47514885663986206,
-0.09213541448116302,
-0.6606529355049133,
0.334587961435318,
0.11050328612327576,
-0.009578780271112919,
-0.1801469922065735,
-0.30365610122680664,
0.08930543065071106,
0.13907746970653534,
0.1626393347978592,
-0.885118305683136,
0.3563196063041687,
0.844830334186554,
0.15710508823394775,
0.125327467918396,
-0.09227591007947922,
0.8016500473022461,
-0.5398059487342834,
0.8320925235748291,
0.09546397626399994,
-0.7230117321014404,
0.3267003893852234,
-0.5778263807296753,
0.30649763345718384,
0.614212155342102,
0.13657107949256897,
-0.5433200001716614,
-0.49827465415000916,
-0.8254792094230652,
-0.4924314320087433,
0.4202902317047119,
0.3966577351093292,
-0.3986099660396576,
0.031159838661551476,
0.32923176884651184,
0.20548629760742188,
0.1670071929693222,
0.05754087492823601,
0.06350787729024887,
0.14179617166519165,
-0.1357857882976532,
-0.15748746693134308,
0.4592653810977936,
0.1055031418800354,
-0.2820911109447479,
0.24046365916728973,
-0.15433256328105927,
0.16995421051979065,
0.33935895562171936,
-0.06461048871278763,
-0.295082151889801,
0.1144537404179573,
0.6380258798599243,
0.48579874634742737,
-0.03210430592298508,
0.308876097202301,
0.2837556302547455,
-0.6678997874259949,
0.3119770586490631,
-0.09454190731048584,
-0.11595596373081207,
0.4689524173736572,
0.86974036693573,
0.6617878675460815,
0.5507941246032715,
-0.3850972652435303,
0.45004796981811523,
0.1772274374961853,
-0.2679156959056854,
0.006898378022015095,
0.09294076263904572,
0.24184584617614746,
0.22131122648715973,
0.17974448204040527,
0.2154628485441208,
0.5477986931800842,
-1.080580472946167,
0.4508310854434967,
0.33991843461990356,
-0.1322088986635208,
-0.671846330165863,
0.4212682247161865,
0.008581523783504963,
-0.3672119677066803,
0.5819553732872009,
0.12499280273914337,
-0.4729028046131134,
0.6381339430809021,
0.4774930477142334,
0.6551580429077148,
-0.36952996253967285,
-0.2328193187713623,
0.6652302145957947,
-0.03482022508978844,
-0.0404454804956913,
0.3790900409221649,
-0.34863540530204773,
-0.27661073207855225,
-0.29092735052108765,
-0.7693957090377808,
-0.6135868430137634,
-0.250705748796463,
-0.6595632433891296,
0.28324592113494873,
-0.3207619786262512,
0.11496740579605103,
0.3121705651283264,
-0.23529669642448425,
-0.07713533937931061,
0.32598283886909485,
0.44530385732650757,
0.9808397889137268,
-0.600291907787323,
0.48583829402923584,
0.1841408759355545,
0.08860035985708237,
-0.9443116784095764,
0.10892199724912643,
0.4009009897708893,
-0.498570054769516,
0.5652895569801331,
-0.29400473833084106,
-0.5221219062805176,
0.0676112100481987,
-0.2868220806121826,
-0.8431037068367004,
0.7255792617797852,
0.9153760671615601,
-0.6818311214447021,
-0.18316878378391266,
0.23581837117671967,
0.8886528015136719,
-0.03480648249387741,
0.2082033008337021,
0.6324372291564941,
0.47105690836906433,
0.15951219201087952,
-1.4673173427581787,
-0.12918388843536377,
0.0985327810049057,
-0.387332946062088,
0.4911699593067169,
-0.47854751348495483,
0.7409797310829163,
-0.08814151585102081,
-0.5164228677749634,
0.3585314154624939,
0.7013936042785645,
0.21539759635925293,
0.012868406251072884,
0.7866839170455933,
0.6652306318283081,
1.101792335510254,
-0.3601563274860382,
0.8693459033966064,
-0.6179550290107727,
0.36863553524017334,
0.9456745386123657,
-0.11129657924175262,
0.8225870728492737,
0.4212903678417206,
-0.5715621113777161,
0.503046989440918,
1.001344919204712,
-0.1281370371580124,
0.2846734821796417,
0.697593092918396,
-0.20580020546913147,
-0.009938289411365986,
-0.5683802962303162,
-0.6582194566726685,
0.595298707485199,
0.31213048100471497,
0.00499915424734354,
-0.2623254954814911,
-0.6452242732048035,
0.000993346213363111,
-0.13236728310585022,
-0.16522595286369324,
0.9891622066497803,
0.21465249359607697,
-0.7960777878761292,
0.8197762370109558,
-0.7485638856887817,
0.4877648651599884,
-0.4731220304965973,
-0.26470935344696045,
-0.07614326477050781,
-0.12573987245559692,
-0.49163898825645447,
-0.45737749338150024,
0.36134031414985657,
-0.5465604662895203,
0.30064359307289124,
0.23011188209056854,
0.8624731302261353,
-0.4715922474861145,
0.21056553721427917,
0.36875441670417786,
0.5052220821380615,
0.6115261912345886,
0.3008171319961548,
-0.002878232393413782,
0.06974530965089798,
-0.13643455505371094,
0.1996639519929886,
-0.08406271785497665,
0.03139444440603256,
0.10948587954044342,
0.35760849714279175,
0.6136701107025146,
0.42879828810691833,
0.4167795777320862,
-0.25166019797325134,
0.24410831928253174,
-0.4225999712944031,
-0.462863028049469,
-0.8457109928131104,
-0.036403585225343704,
0.3685658574104309,
-0.2806021273136139,
0.6730858683586121,
0.7914911508560181,
1.0636063814163208,
-0.10762752592563629,
0.568951427936554,
0.2225988805294037,
0.4873824715614319,
-0.44793766736984253,
0.21556514501571655,
-0.5134533047676086,
-0.22504545748233795,
-0.6110678911209106,
-0.9554010033607483,
-0.2607952058315277,
0.374810129404068,
0.102007657289505,
-0.22424359619617462,
0.9401561617851257,
0.6370034217834473,
-0.38858070969581604,
0.5860968828201294,
0.2176944613456726,
0.17170201241970062,
-0.1555945873260498,
0.45223256945610046,
0.8271489143371582,
-0.1492113471031189,
0.39868631958961487,
-0.18849435448646545,
0.06976883113384247,
-0.1461700201034546,
-0.48010119795799255,
-0.30132856965065,
-0.6499752402305603,
-0.32050076127052307,
-0.29250913858413696,
0.48115116357803345,
1.065128207206726,
0.5881963968276978,
-0.9774221777915955,
-0.724937379360199,
-0.10963604599237442,
-0.2898864150047302,
-0.4301902949810028,
-0.06078298017382622,
0.3831610381603241,
0.19272074103355408,
-0.695310652256012,
0.9713714718818665,
0.35383567214012146,
0.14686529338359833,
0.062347717583179474,
-0.08170746266841888,
-0.29362329840660095,
0.1417732983827591,
0.2103409469127655,
0.8023051619529724,
-0.7444135546684265,
-0.6078206896781921,
-0.08759132772684097,
-0.010586577467620373,
0.4186558127403259,
0.8312042355537415,
-0.6766014099121094,
0.47728273272514343,
0.9500719904899597,
0.4604937732219696,
0.34351488947868347,
-0.18201085925102234,
0.7681673169136047,
-0.42978161573410034,
0.024213692173361778,
0.1598907709121704,
0.645392656326294,
0.3502599895000458,
-0.04669148474931717,
0.7613112330436707,
0.5676700472831726,
-0.22913707792758942,
-0.8506943583488464,
0.35373976826667786,
-1.2150774002075195,
0.1254861205816269,
1.2038863897323608,
-0.0930900052189827,
-0.22251169383525848,
-0.3157366216182709,
-0.3856774568557739,
0.45448651909828186,
-0.2128669023513794,
0.4717492461204529,
0.650775671005249,
-0.16955406963825226,
0.08922117948532104,
-0.059619586914777756,
0.7581688761711121,
0.38701358437538147,
-0.6272648572921753,
-0.24941837787628174,
0.3668823838233948,
0.09150777757167816,
0.5401766896247864,
0.38542142510414124,
0.010558112524449825,
0.5313461422920227,
0.20252756774425507,
-0.18030868470668793,
0.3936656713485718,
-0.3954276740550995,
-0.5075854063034058,
0.08011817932128906,
0.3740560710430145,
0.17668482661247253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02805v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02805v2 | Graph-enhanced Large Language Models in Asynchronous Plan Reasoning | 2024-02-05T08:26:33 | 2024-06-03T13:07:06 | Fangru Lin, Emanuele La Malfa, Valentin Hofmann, Elle Michelle Yang, Anthony Cohn, Janet B. Pierrehumbert | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Planning is a fundamental property of human intelligence. Reasoning about
asynchronous plans is challenging since it requires sequential and parallel
planning to optimize time costs. Can large language models (LLMs) succeed at
this task? Here, we present the first large-scale study investigating this
question. We find that a representative set of closed and open-source LLMs,
including GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, behave poorly when not supplied with illustrations
about the task-solving process in our benchmark AsyncHow. We propose a novel
technique called Plan Like a Graph (PLaG) that combines graphs with natural
language prompts and achieves state-of-the-art results. We show that although
PLaG can boost model performance, LLMs still suffer from drastic degradation
when task complexity increases, highlighting the limits of utilizing LLMs for
simulating digital devices. We see our study as an exciting step towards using
LLMs as efficient autonomous agents. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/fangru-lin/graph-llm-asynchow-plan. | [
-0.24441514909267426,
-0.8460454940795898,
0.8305819034576416,
0.3359309136867523,
-0.1330697238445282,
0.3912643492221832,
-0.35127881169319153,
-0.6145229339599609,
0.31078046560287476,
0.6772153973579407,
-0.7097762823104858,
-0.4993699789047241,
-0.3970116078853607,
-0.00509799737483263,
-0.3412977159023285,
0.36277005076408386,
-0.43619340658187866,
-0.09036442637443542,
-0.33830657601356506,
0.024049920961260796,
-0.28347229957580566,
-0.3778236508369446,
-0.7345117926597595,
-0.7131303548812866,
0.4096764028072357,
0.4731573462486267,
0.7469622492790222,
0.5090327262878418,
0.2356574386358261,
0.3001464307308197,
-0.015724970027804375,
0.4425123333930969,
-0.3860239088535309,
0.11646079272031784,
0.17613445222377777,
-0.18461643159389496,
-0.7056121230125427,
-0.1437888890504837,
0.5691083669662476,
1.0190205574035645,
0.09906712919473648,
0.04651638865470886,
0.03870826214551926,
0.4660874605178833,
-0.28916096687316895,
0.7543671131134033,
-0.5079776048660278,
-0.12002024799585342,
-0.1045764833688736,
-0.0027913174126297235,
-0.4859548807144165,
-0.1959352195262909,
-0.06662099808454514,
-0.7177318334579468,
-0.27514562010765076,
0.037942759692668915,
0.5638815760612488,
0.20227405428886414,
-0.32847097516059875,
-0.4680083394050598,
-0.8231369853019714,
0.3446459174156189,
-0.5636485815048218,
0.21660390496253967,
0.4134097397327423,
0.3200865089893341,
-0.5301914811134338,
-0.9780943989753723,
-0.6295716166496277,
-0.3958413302898407,
-0.0029330856632441282,
-0.03801259025931358,
-0.2054961770772934,
0.3021863102912903,
0.6006743311882019,
-0.05709189921617508,
-0.605376124382019,
0.38342490792274475,
0.031594425439834595,
-0.2399856448173523,
0.7562441825866699,
0.27047255635261536,
0.25235599279403687,
0.013574972748756409,
-0.2589779496192932,
0.030997032299637794,
-0.7092075943946838,
0.15871071815490723,
0.4494999349117279,
0.1950041651725769,
-0.08179550617933273,
0.8165292143821716,
-0.43377262353897095,
0.6700129508972168,
-0.334724485874176,
0.07884813845157623,
0.10846570134162903,
-0.3264691233634949,
-0.11835716664791107,
-0.07451946288347244,
0.795089840888977,
0.3483135998249054,
0.6140379905700684,
-0.17023612558841705,
-0.234908789396286,
0.35693788528442383,
-0.20095865428447723,
-0.7831522822380066,
-0.43399176001548767,
0.37982258200645447,
-0.09361080825328827,
0.14487187564373016,
-0.5200425982475281,
-0.552727460861206,
-0.4685763120651245,
-0.18156005442142487,
0.18034756183624268,
-0.4273854196071625,
-0.16942474246025085,
0.18414191901683807,
0.13770148158073425,
0.018369847908616066,
0.5577940344810486,
-0.5413385033607483,
0.45203545689582825,
0.7416109442710876,
0.767329752445221,
0.10099340975284576,
-0.5541720986366272,
-0.649185299873352,
0.07746931165456772,
-0.5790786743164062,
1.1046628952026367,
-0.5011085867881775,
-0.5815533995628357,
0.053170811384916306,
-0.16798187792301178,
0.04985105246305466,
-0.39587268233299255,
0.4264473021030426,
-0.4693734645843506,
-0.07860875129699707,
-0.35442915558815,
-0.5475113987922668,
-0.14032502472400665,
0.29200103878974915,
-0.6885405778884888,
0.6173776984214783,
-0.23782217502593994,
-0.45153987407684326,
0.1422833800315857,
-0.8102890253067017,
-0.7227770686149597,
0.24344363808631897,
-0.2868495583534241,
-0.21546921133995056,
-0.3493645489215851,
0.24982976913452148,
0.46910911798477173,
-0.42997464537620544,
0.3353293240070343,
-0.31350189447402954,
-0.28957873582839966,
0.1967383623123169,
-0.16390849649906158,
0.8657707571983337,
0.04996009171009064,
-0.25333136320114136,
0.5555247068405151,
-0.4929015636444092,
0.2647388279438019,
0.41127854585647583,
-0.26881468296051025,
0.10679913312196732,
0.4440135061740875,
-0.27913811802864075,
0.09314192831516266,
0.3981911540031433,
-0.42286384105682373,
0.37420982122421265,
-0.3287545442581177,
0.6678768396377563,
0.6796523332595825,
-0.3076816201210022,
0.4852708578109741,
-0.35302263498306274,
0.4727511405944824,
-0.6241873502731323,
-0.013279475271701813,
-0.341058611869812,
-0.6757796406745911,
-0.6311534643173218,
-0.3065105676651001,
-0.07242655754089355,
0.4114310145378113,
-0.8311144709587097,
0.1355101317167282,
-0.3273260295391083,
-0.29601460695266724,
0.07817545533180237,
-0.08489762246608734,
0.2666986286640167,
0.3828701972961426,
0.31620705127716064,
-0.06554378569126129,
-0.30981960892677307,
-0.5415475964546204,
-0.11237240582704544,
-0.32320716977119446,
-0.10116931051015854,
0.45389533042907715,
0.3347388803958893,
-0.41651853919029236,
0.8208689093589783,
-0.6427236795425415,
-0.059057049453258514,
-0.4921949803829193,
0.25968021154403687,
0.0074683427810668945,
-0.0009576067677699029,
0.31083405017852783,
-0.49352237582206726,
-0.4348546862602234,
0.028936173766851425,
-0.6213421821594238,
-0.4710480570793152,
-0.08087707310914993,
-0.03137518838047981,
0.3732767701148987,
0.5680832266807556,
-0.9864630699157715,
0.284686803817749,
0.6231058835983276,
-0.5444638133049011,
0.7125595211982727,
-0.2898949086666107,
-0.2557930648326874,
-0.6982751488685608,
0.10860435664653778,
-0.22788065671920776,
-0.48040148615837097,
-0.6625126004219055,
0.11402854323387146,
-0.013687757775187492,
-0.3661450147628784,
-0.03449057787656784,
0.7072570323944092,
-0.6280288100242615,
-0.5316388607025146,
-0.5858945250511169,
0.1532934457063675,
-0.08447819203138351,
0.4488521218299866,
-0.01756870560348034,
0.6334867477416992,
0.5014055371284485,
-0.36597615480422974,
0.3864899277687073,
0.2945890426635742,
-0.21787314116954803,
-0.07495152950286865,
-0.6448999047279358,
0.3014581501483917,
-0.10320305079221725,
0.7075838446617126,
-0.8143302202224731,
-0.3885907530784607,
0.27379685640335083,
-0.26131078600883484,
0.22571249306201935,
0.09217418730258942,
-0.9059808254241943,
-0.6830506324768066,
-0.08631418645381927,
0.14123187959194183,
0.4354907274246216,
-0.6553545594215393,
0.7379481792449951,
0.5077564120292664,
-0.23689095675945282,
-0.23214343190193176,
-0.4306846857070923,
0.1289682686328888,
0.09209277480840683,
-0.834024965763092,
0.4012051224708557,
-0.14533893764019012,
-0.40035557746887207,
0.0271266121417284,
-0.06742331385612488,
-0.0005008321604691446,
0.00660190312191844,
0.43134191632270813,
0.20269712805747986,
0.061497170478105545,
-0.02009008266031742,
-0.19019955396652222,
-0.2250746488571167,
0.193368598818779,
-0.3803844153881073,
1.0904837846755981,
-0.0757981464266777,
-0.45600730180740356,
-0.43972381949424744,
0.41971707344055176,
0.5623841285705566,
-0.41624754667282104,
0.2189103364944458,
0.12136519700288773,
-0.38526591658592224,
-0.3993070423603058,
-0.29562821984291077,
-0.047778986394405365,
-0.4751743972301483,
0.2116345763206482,
-0.4144003391265869,
-0.7569235563278198,
0.6754069924354553,
-0.41127848625183105,
0.16006000339984894,
0.09206140786409378,
0.4359515309333801,
-0.08750606328248978,
1.108181118965149,
0.46222350001335144,
0.08238217979669571,
0.3761647045612335,
-0.3837706446647644,
0.0347878523170948,
-0.4355345368385315,
-0.2561197578907013,
-0.32640141248703003,
-0.4008149206638336,
-0.4347851574420929,
-0.8196409940719604,
0.17146869003772736,
0.103455550968647,
-0.41172683238983154,
0.13907617330551147,
-0.22608572244644165,
0.44756150245666504,
0.40512803196907043,
-0.12225662171840668,
0.5110007524490356,
-0.03560797870159149,
-0.02136101946234703,
0.4310286343097687,
-0.6736335158348083,
-0.5752321481704712,
0.9046513438224792,
0.29097774624824524,
0.7063965201377869,
-0.2954144775867462,
0.5403655171394348,
-0.08941586315631866,
0.18089640140533447,
-0.8757110238075256,
1.0717140436172485,
-0.1274137645959854,
-0.23069335520267487,
-0.5742535591125488,
-0.5214539766311646,
-1.0664268732070923,
-0.0007202247506938875,
-0.020192844793200493,
-0.9007353782653809,
-0.05309838056564331,
0.12468716502189636,
-0.14937138557434082,
0.24696770310401917,
-0.7312987446784973,
0.7552491426467896,
-0.5493156909942627,
-0.1623382568359375,
-0.33074891567230225,
-0.4299585819244385,
0.11536412686109543,
-0.06506913155317307,
0.16186107695102692,
-0.5529360771179199,
0.12936565279960632,
0.5968632102012634,
-0.5601276159286499,
0.7432937622070312,
-0.30227524042129517,
0.10787305235862732,
0.55657958984375,
0.20576748251914978,
0.9559458494186401,
-0.18397079408168793,
-0.003445834619924426,
0.26867783069610596,
-0.4610782265663147,
-0.43009600043296814,
-0.4961431324481964,
0.7491264939308167,
-0.61848384141922,
-0.5787649154663086,
-0.16336224973201752,
-0.9894446730613708,
-0.2652614414691925,
0.37728333473205566,
0.06266777217388153,
0.5392069816589355,
0.11317192018032074,
-0.268513560295105,
0.09503103792667389,
-0.3053821325302124,
0.7194104790687561,
0.3927512466907501,
-0.6537961959838867,
-0.04316072538495064,
0.7187134623527527,
0.42115238308906555,
0.4150233566761017,
0.0719539225101471,
0.23829346895217896,
-0.3440089225769043,
-0.739554226398468,
-0.3381110429763794,
0.3261853754520416,
-0.6972544193267822,
-0.008302928879857063,
-0.6968321204185486,
-0.20588399469852448,
-0.2754642963409424,
-0.350458562374115,
-0.4366905391216278,
-0.424511194229126,
-0.03430497646331787,
0.012346439994871616,
0.366693913936615,
0.899064302444458,
0.1141398549079895,
0.12631087005138397,
-0.3192947506904602,
0.3349571228027344,
0.322397917509079,
0.3622027635574341,
-0.03589053452014923,
0.17679540812969208,
0.24377430975437164,
0.09352031350135803,
-0.13080592453479767,
-0.7927209138870239,
0.4500441253185272,
-0.0950460210442543,
0.6223751306533813,
0.13741649687290192,
0.14972370862960815,
0.7360778450965881,
-0.6399363279342651,
0.41103434562683105,
0.12272778153419495,
-0.8535755276679993,
0.3815978467464447,
-0.566896378993988,
0.3842124938964844,
0.18764932453632355,
0.33063554763793945,
-0.21408207714557648,
-0.3125419020652771,
-0.4626825749874115,
-1.0339007377624512,
0.6434371471405029,
0.14037300646305084,
-0.08640242367982864,
0.06346327066421509,
0.13886658847332,
-0.168744295835495,
0.17324796319007874,
-0.6193854212760925,
-0.11549912393093109,
-0.11259108781814575,
0.05407140403985977,
-0.21264085173606873,
-0.2332322895526886,
-0.0665319636464119,
-0.11943797767162323,
0.26139581203460693,
-0.4120585024356842,
0.5001794099807739,
0.057541169226169586,
0.033143531531095505,
-0.16258978843688965,
0.02923133783042431,
0.5223216414451599,
0.7105451822280884,
0.009945414029061794,
0.18394629657268524,
0.13912425935268402,
-0.21826758980751038,
0.028424806892871857,
0.5018871426582336,
-0.05063645914196968,
-0.22344160079956055,
0.39252567291259766,
0.7516089081764221,
0.18785636126995087,
-0.9669771194458008,
0.3384210169315338,
0.023482970893383026,
-0.2408100664615631,
-0.44677817821502686,
-0.18219059705734253,
0.33716174960136414,
0.579241931438446,
0.25998032093048096,
-0.26356786489486694,
-0.11313969641923904,
-0.6997166275978088,
0.007257995195686817,
0.5094995498657227,
-0.061186496168375015,
-0.19803985953330994,
0.7105443477630615,
0.17643508315086365,
-0.7016443014144897,
0.6567671298980713,
-0.7133219242095947,
-0.5285956263542175,
0.8118581771850586,
0.7583633065223694,
0.6626623272895813,
0.014684375375509262,
0.38798651099205017,
0.0001436766324331984,
0.31314149498939514,
-0.16394463181495667,
0.47719746828079224,
-0.026779863983392715,
-0.7551271915435791,
-0.900216817855835,
-0.3621949851512909,
-0.48575225472450256,
-0.06644027680158615,
-0.04281345009803772,
0.27240657806396484,
-0.5745940208435059,
0.011838935315608978,
-0.09204229712486267,
0.17444588243961334,
-0.49401718378067017,
-0.17714664340019226,
0.2698500454425812,
0.8458314538002014,
-0.5108845233917236,
0.8609910607337952,
0.868842601776123,
-0.04532282054424286,
-1.1034083366394043,
0.25599995255470276,
-0.06434701383113861,
-0.8559463024139404,
0.6374359130859375,
0.42526233196258545,
-0.2662724554538727,
0.193244069814682,
-0.3294372856616974,
-0.8637659549713135,
1.2507413625717163,
0.6274339556694031,
-0.6286013722419739,
-0.36444202065467834,
0.0858936607837677,
0.4813104271888733,
-0.28060397505760193,
0.05892395228147507,
0.4399532079696655,
0.4451408088207245,
0.438186377286911,
-1.0884277820587158,
0.1635432094335556,
-0.05817282199859619,
-0.42282772064208984,
0.39092159271240234,
-0.548031747341156,
0.9618093371391296,
-0.39600130915641785,
-0.5061943531036377,
0.021044859662652016,
0.33602339029312134,
0.40979284048080444,
0.6504747867584229,
0.5531934499740601,
0.3474763035774231,
0.9739238619804382,
0.03666999191045761,
1.2540606260299683,
-0.297325998544693,
0.1659630835056305,
1.1184762716293335,
-0.7430375218391418,
0.7385532855987549,
-0.035874877125024796,
-0.04598284140229225,
0.4204939901828766,
0.4241945445537567,
0.34982889890670776,
0.24854417145252228,
0.16927450895309448,
-0.13856260478496552,
-0.3389997184276581,
-0.1920861303806305,
-0.02563418075442314,
0.6038503646850586,
0.4895947575569153,
0.03650421276688576,
-0.3325442373752594,
-0.06143588200211525,
0.2102266401052475,
0.16966982185840607,
-0.60784912109375,
0.5710116028785706,
0.13247992098331451,
-0.6833671927452087,
0.49847307801246643,
-0.21301394701004028,
0.30404138565063477,
-0.472019225358963,
0.11046724766492844,
0.05873608961701393,
0.020168274641036987,
-0.05764861777424812,
-0.9663071036338806,
0.3143768012523651,
0.020228084176778793,
0.13400530815124512,
-0.3962025046348572,
0.9196828603744507,
-0.2226838767528534,
-0.41382884979248047,
0.7288148999214172,
0.4899604618549347,
0.005560033489018679,
-0.2028254121541977,
-0.4326237738132477,
0.08259214460849762,
-0.1601049304008484,
-0.16581301391124725,
0.1710638403892517,
0.21796084940433502,
-0.2933652102947235,
1.0294556617736816,
0.6875889897346497,
0.15943117439746857,
-0.022603007033467293,
0.04636688530445099,
1.1086796522140503,
-0.5049494504928589,
-0.6140848994255066,
-0.8273310661315918,
0.35121849179267883,
-0.270884245634079,
0.1743108481168747,
0.6852547526359558,
0.45170265436172485,
0.7042190432548523,
0.3962412178516388,
0.5891335010528564,
0.250388503074646,
0.33108222484588623,
-0.5515347719192505,
0.5798126459121704,
-0.2503811717033386,
0.2221975177526474,
-0.1218472421169281,
-0.6943269371986389,
-0.27363812923431396,
0.5659403800964355,
-0.6679081916809082,
-0.21258176863193512,
0.6727713942527771,
0.584712564945221,
0.25628146529197693,
-0.028981463983654976,
0.3527642786502838,
0.23015791177749634,
0.5483332872390747,
0.709999144077301,
0.981044352054596,
0.30400094389915466,
0.6702454686164856,
-0.10396535694599152,
-0.1870492696762085,
-0.1566779911518097,
-0.7400467991828918,
-1.0838218927383423,
-0.4282197654247284,
-0.2509234845638275,
-0.16266818344593048,
0.01944568380713463,
0.974634051322937,
0.5214440226554871,
-0.29259732365608215,
-0.41332539916038513,
-0.4815623462200165,
0.19968952238559723,
0.033925168216228485,
-0.11658412218093872,
0.20543430745601654,
-0.22320975363254547,
-0.5132768154144287,
0.6284409761428833,
0.3472574055194855,
0.03806491196155548,
-0.2693201005458832,
-0.26226869225502014,
0.004253621678799391,
0.06357143819332123,
0.7709352970123291,
0.4616813659667969,
-0.6382918357849121,
-0.3079911470413208,
0.011327710933983326,
-0.04192183539271355,
-0.012380260042846203,
0.9504980444908142,
-0.6856753826141357,
0.5900425910949707,
0.4547187387943268,
0.5195788741111755,
0.7503331303596497,
-0.05460513010621071,
0.5395371317863464,
-0.5013259053230286,
0.2569979131221771,
0.4615057110786438,
0.5209488272666931,
0.13856005668640137,
-0.14512163400650024,
0.4347124993801117,
0.0063591389916837215,
-0.8532302379608154,
-0.7582131028175354,
0.5805219411849976,
-0.9566622376441956,
-0.46311551332473755,
1.4494893550872803,
-0.048731833696365356,
-0.18960809707641602,
-0.16019898653030396,
-0.27658483386039734,
0.17099031805992126,
-0.3811855614185333,
0.48952069878578186,
0.4276115894317627,
-0.499098539352417,
-0.044349588453769684,
-0.6405025720596313,
0.34116145968437195,
-0.016802912577986717,
-1.0907365083694458,
0.29309916496276855,
0.7207382917404175,
-0.08720427006483078,
0.22598719596862793,
1.1611043214797974,
0.22917293012142181,
0.07981077581644058,
0.22869764268398285,
-0.0622844398021698,
-0.351654052734375,
-0.48490676283836365,
-0.041860319674015045,
0.15651026368141174,
0.3413918912410736,
-0.08408566564321518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02801v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02801v2 | KS-Lottery: Finding Certified Lottery Tickets for Multilingual Language Models | 2024-02-05T08:19:56 | 2024-06-03T07:35:25 | Fei Yuan, Chang Ma, Shuai Yuan, Qiushi Sun, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The lottery ticket hypothesis posits the existence of ``winning tickets''
within a randomly initialized neural network. Do winning tickets exist for LLMs
in fine-tuning scenarios? How can we find such winning tickets? In this paper,
we propose KS-Lottery, a method to identify a small subset of LLM parameters
highly effective in multilingual fine-tuning. Our key idea is to use
Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test to analyze the distribution shift of parameters before
and after fine-tuning. We further theoretically prove that KS-Lottery can find
the certified winning tickets in the embedding layer, fine-tuning on the found
parameters is guaranteed to perform as well as full fine-tuning. Comparing
KS-Lottery with other parameter-efficient tuning algorithms on translation
tasks, the experimental results show that KS-Lottery finds a much smaller set
of parameters for fine-tuning while achieving the comparable performance as
full fine-tuning LLM. Surprisingly, we find that fine-tuning 18 tokens'
embedding of LLaMA suffices to reach the fine-tuning translation
performance~\footnote{https://github.com/CONE-MT/KS-Lottery.}. | [
-0.32519659399986267,
-0.5187822580337524,
0.5002328157424927,
0.20933561027050018,
-0.7846418023109436,
-0.11110762506723404,
-0.6688515543937683,
-0.2204059660434723,
0.32279714941978455,
0.5353475213050842,
-0.4547431766986847,
-0.5806270837783813,
-0.706663966178894,
0.09960593283176422,
-0.44625434279441833,
0.7049937844276428,
0.0005046590813435614,
0.4694672226905823,
-0.07664826512336731,
-0.02266465313732624,
0.04664188623428345,
-0.13561320304870605,
-0.5700280070304871,
-0.39840009808540344,
0.9544852375984192,
0.5747031569480896,
0.49514254927635193,
0.6829937696456909,
0.3068510591983795,
0.2672683000564575,
-0.1886131763458252,
0.22300775349140167,
-0.35122424364089966,
0.07847671955823898,
0.10251983255147934,
-1.1575289964675903,
0.23935562372207642,
0.1073961853981018,
0.6875149011611938,
0.5050152540206909,
-0.31896713376045227,
0.22576315701007843,
0.039093151688575745,
0.5572534799575806,
-0.6443438529968262,
0.16115206480026245,
-0.9086496829986572,
0.4969380795955658,
-0.4440723955631256,
-0.605968713760376,
-0.44798120856285095,
-0.4773871898651123,
-0.39654210209846497,
-0.4764227271080017,
0.2274438589811325,
0.10893648862838745,
0.9416240453720093,
0.22130870819091797,
-0.5236215591430664,
-0.44837236404418945,
-0.5632348656654358,
0.7547792196273804,
-0.6311509609222412,
0.5818136930465698,
0.2763029932975769,
0.3264351487159729,
-0.3752266764640808,
-0.3418451249599457,
-0.5555459856987,
-0.7368850111961365,
0.21342508494853973,
0.043502528220415115,
0.3938876688480377,
0.16976574063301086,
-0.010804036632180214,
0.22361184656620026,
-0.22649630904197693,
0.18337365984916687,
-0.15279963612556458,
-0.411104291677475,
0.5462614893913269,
0.12082402408123016,
0.15692730247974396,
0.04927154257893562,
0.034178365021944046,
-0.12119393795728683,
-0.7165787220001221,
0.10659557580947876,
0.8925551772117615,
0.6352194547653198,
-0.04291898384690285,
0.7287346124649048,
-0.5530680418014526,
0.7950791716575623,
0.1508176028728485,
-0.4703441262245178,
0.005618429742753506,
-0.6481518745422363,
0.022842448204755783,
0.05112195760011673,
0.5997452139854431,
0.1175684854388237,
0.6510566473007202,
-0.4817031919956207,
-0.2917199432849884,
-0.27444493770599365,
-0.09542077779769897,
-0.5353351831436157,
-0.20024457573890686,
-0.047385696321725845,
-0.6608622670173645,
-0.7492713928222656,
-0.3104734420776367,
-0.576829195022583,
-0.48802676796913147,
-0.43838560581207275,
0.5190075039863586,
-0.08138163387775421,
-0.2699616849422455,
0.11595316231250763,
-0.11193857342004776,
0.3423226773738861,
0.007245594635605812,
-1.0404776334762573,
-0.03041796013712883,
0.6626859903335571,
0.6659687757492065,
-0.04585414379835129,
-0.5898590087890625,
-0.5626258850097656,
-0.3120720386505127,
-0.7215909957885742,
0.9477255940437317,
-0.33002978563308716,
-0.02939426898956299,
0.16698101162910461,
-0.04413383826613426,
-0.08428533375263214,
-0.7641022205352783,
0.312152624130249,
-0.7576461434364319,
-0.4432583749294281,
-0.19320760667324066,
-0.5264867544174194,
0.3318977653980255,
0.2657914161682129,
-0.462004691362381,
0.7285998463630676,
-0.23046651482582092,
-0.1920621544122696,
0.749452531337738,
-0.11865290999412537,
-0.593180239200592,
-0.06531523168087006,
-0.17928709089756012,
-0.3277781009674072,
0.5522257685661316,
-0.09548263996839523,
0.48326194286346436,
-0.23369364440441132,
-0.03569049760699272,
-0.5194178223609924,
-0.4309448003768921,
0.44589173793792725,
-0.47760477662086487,
0.6763066649436951,
0.2811742424964905,
-0.33536675572395325,
-0.18307489156723022,
-0.9446617960929871,
0.10387855768203735,
0.03510481119155884,
-0.7524737119674683,
-0.1308010369539261,
0.031444087624549866,
0.09379962831735611,
0.27401936054229736,
0.3800390064716339,
-0.5727372765541077,
0.15443530678749084,
-0.5966548919677734,
0.03775079548358917,
0.808590292930603,
-0.08153582364320755,
0.778437614440918,
0.11766549199819565,
0.6232078075408936,
0.5135433077812195,
0.2558269202709198,
0.14560312032699585,
-0.5683409571647644,
-1.0508054494857788,
0.09008681029081345,
0.7379160523414612,
0.34866324067115784,
-0.583652138710022,
0.15501391887664795,
0.0457543283700943,
-0.5351884365081787,
-0.8719995021820068,
0.3603253662586212,
0.171200692653656,
0.0926896259188652,
-0.14615829288959503,
0.1694045215845108,
-0.3417647182941437,
-1.2619022130966187,
-0.4942878186702728,
0.2784583270549774,
0.2764472961425781,
0.39759552478790283,
0.3601752817630768,
0.11294709891080856,
0.5740938186645508,
-0.26050183176994324,
-0.40250664949417114,
-0.008889312855899334,
-0.13951706886291504,
0.33627352118492126,
0.33036720752716064,
0.4756120443344116,
-0.8021669983863831,
-0.719973623752594,
0.5523457527160645,
-0.4092831611633301,
0.01076775323599577,
-0.08195029199123383,
0.10878098756074905,
0.3403090536594391,
0.4219374358654022,
-0.3857327699661255,
0.29017508029937744,
0.5411860942840576,
-0.513837993144989,
0.4694507420063019,
-0.479830801486969,
0.27220410108566284,
-1.1006510257720947,
-0.2744862735271454,
-0.194046750664711,
-0.17603816092014313,
-0.3948822021484375,
0.3202812075614929,
0.4053248465061188,
0.15097448229789734,
-0.37986695766448975,
0.25968167185783386,
-0.3618124723434448,
-0.014773276634514332,
-0.4034384489059448,
0.23481377959251404,
-0.665794312953949,
0.45013442635536194,
-0.34710562229156494,
0.5659772157669067,
0.5049350261688232,
-0.666649580001831,
0.44790583848953247,
-0.23633641004562378,
-0.8580037951469421,
0.5328904390335083,
-0.1260979324579239,
-0.0453852042555809,
-0.2543770372867584,
-0.22866705060005188,
-1.0004843473434448,
-0.14587007462978363,
0.37611880898475647,
-0.3664621114730835,
0.14402593672275543,
-0.40360257029533386,
-0.8026682734489441,
-0.031087860465049744,
0.21368901431560516,
0.051816899329423904,
0.47598376870155334,
-0.5140355229377747,
0.3878898620605469,
0.2507987916469574,
0.045751847326755524,
-0.5697789192199707,
-0.521350622177124,
0.18035994470119476,
-0.26189202070236206,
-0.31425973773002625,
-0.010108673945069313,
-0.15039101243019104,
0.010633488185703754,
-0.1680300384759903,
0.03304174169898033,
-0.02398831769824028,
0.4740234613418579,
-0.05794966220855713,
-0.304206520318985,
-0.20533733069896698,
-0.004827861674129963,
0.4534010589122772,
-0.43081533908843994,
-0.1654215306043625,
-0.5443714261054993,
0.470771849155426,
0.10992177575826645,
-0.332684189081192,
-0.16368572413921356,
0.21321244537830353,
0.5586990118026733,
-0.07324022054672241,
0.7079391479492188,
0.5244830846786499,
-0.38187000155448914,
-0.3182736039161682,
-0.616064190864563,
-0.2671220004558563,
-0.4702882468700409,
0.5420823693275452,
-0.7123838067054749,
-0.8698275089263916,
0.8338363170623779,
-0.2303047776222229,
-0.3152797520160675,
0.393255352973938,
0.732857346534729,
-0.01792377233505249,
1.3947092294692993,
0.4638879597187042,
-0.08868720382452011,
0.31297069787979126,
-0.017522960901260376,
0.2495172917842865,
-0.32110100984573364,
-0.34285295009613037,
-0.7646637558937073,
-0.6655553579330444,
-0.8078941702842712,
-0.16914916038513184,
0.3563920259475708,
0.37374117970466614,
0.16481970250606537,
0.12107052654027939,
-0.2355763167142868,
0.9681645035743713,
0.8723266124725342,
-0.09976177662611008,
0.2802238464355469,
-0.007957070134580135,
-0.7467851638793945,
-0.11248528957366943,
-0.6418299674987793,
-0.16198988258838654,
1.1270740032196045,
-0.015616409480571747,
0.43514975905418396,
-0.012426839210093021,
1.0608326196670532,
-0.14024072885513306,
0.10810210555791855,
-0.6960592865943909,
0.6667228937149048,
-0.1667722910642624,
-0.5471177101135254,
-0.4261831045150757,
-0.3075026273727417,
-0.8689143061637878,
0.20821411907672882,
-0.3230483829975128,
-0.7672325968742371,
0.2377035766839981,
0.07246103137731552,
-0.2796747386455536,
0.1721477508544922,
-0.4496976435184479,
0.8260378241539001,
-0.2463420033454895,
-0.037489935755729675,
-0.5336896181106567,
-0.42500606179237366,
0.10383699834346771,
-0.3854716122150421,
0.09357716143131256,
-0.28208500146865845,
-0.09996061027050018,
0.35930562019348145,
-0.08786754310131073,
0.6997236609458923,
-0.2804493010044098,
-0.3648154139518738,
-0.014494750648736954,
0.15048524737358093,
0.8544185161590576,
0.31363821029663086,
-0.2734939157962799,
0.04303313419222832,
0.10971404612064362,
-0.27277496457099915,
-0.7479298710823059,
1.0899063348770142,
-0.781833827495575,
-0.3701014518737793,
-0.08066181093454361,
-0.42181530594825745,
0.03430011868476868,
0.31767916679382324,
0.40733757615089417,
0.0919303372502327,
0.260957270860672,
0.4280502498149872,
0.45326584577560425,
-0.004001222085207701,
0.3873533606529236,
0.708091139793396,
-0.049257777631282806,
-0.5220715999603271,
1.129279613494873,
0.4212498366832733,
0.040727999061346054,
0.4041908085346222,
0.4287627339363098,
-0.2506900429725647,
-0.9919168949127197,
-0.6409231424331665,
0.1495455950498581,
-0.7275570034980774,
-0.12567180395126343,
-0.1588829755783081,
-0.0008185417391359806,
-0.12771093845367432,
0.021225959062576294,
-0.7064629793167114,
-0.39210736751556396,
-0.43191903829574585,
-0.05288021266460419,
0.1567278802394867,
0.5574597716331482,
-0.15870225429534912,
0.09279801696538925,
-0.5145982503890991,
0.1158037930727005,
0.19439737498760223,
0.7496256232261658,
0.06459105759859085,
-0.3901863694190979,
-0.743870198726654,
0.1483583003282547,
-0.14473845064640045,
-0.8019400238990784,
0.1655254364013672,
0.2179621458053589,
0.6033596396446228,
0.5079406499862671,
-0.2836405336856842,
0.755802571773529,
-0.7137577533721924,
0.8006564378738403,
0.003965066745877266,
-0.6035553812980652,
0.4111286401748657,
-0.31457850337028503,
0.09118311107158661,
0.6931579113006592,
0.03457096591591835,
-0.5704783797264099,
-0.684548556804657,
-0.4369882047176361,
-0.5746066570281982,
0.742240309715271,
0.10354205220937729,
0.33314210176467896,
-0.08793982118368149,
0.7282798290252686,
0.18441781401634216,
0.32661575078964233,
-0.754593014717102,
-0.7851639986038208,
0.22658196091651917,
-0.31146979331970215,
-0.45305055379867554,
-0.3185322880744934,
0.11108983308076859,
-0.3174040615558624,
0.5578130483627319,
-0.2093990594148636,
0.1158256083726883,
-0.19621141254901886,
0.038879770785570145,
-0.2855336666107178,
0.17450246214866638,
1.071997046470642,
0.4330761134624481,
0.006014899350702763,
0.19636058807373047,
0.35863083600997925,
-0.2961380183696747,
0.27589330077171326,
0.20521777868270874,
-0.35755789279937744,
0.025646992027759552,
-0.04994510859251022,
0.6488543748855591,
0.6966915130615234,
-0.5609440803527832,
0.3047872483730316,
0.09702783077955246,
-0.5305073261260986,
-0.3835412263870239,
0.2283780574798584,
0.31354373693466187,
0.4641098380088806,
0.495890736579895,
-0.07315093278884888,
0.11992533504962921,
-0.24770434200763702,
0.15158309042453766,
0.5259743332862854,
-0.42557576298713684,
-0.19152075052261353,
0.7119287848472595,
0.031587839126586914,
-0.7013116478919983,
0.4731205403804779,
-0.5271559357643127,
-0.2382662296295166,
0.7178782224655151,
0.6340709924697876,
0.8212684988975525,
-0.0544840432703495,
0.3133339583873749,
0.23912055790424347,
0.25864094495773315,
-0.14247021079063416,
0.38491591811180115,
-0.1683243215084076,
-0.9144113659858704,
-0.36479872465133667,
-0.7277206182479858,
-0.11857812851667404,
-0.023941682651638985,
-0.39216405153274536,
0.3569294214248657,
0.16453181207180023,
0.08534862846136093,
0.11091944575309753,
0.08502265065908432,
-0.7114706635475159,
0.01887807995080948,
0.2186538279056549,
0.9404269456863403,
-0.7167393565177917,
0.9455860257148743,
0.5939700603485107,
-0.1708206832408905,
-0.7725472450256348,
-0.16704867780208588,
-0.3136293590068817,
-0.7878319621086121,
0.7883206605911255,
-0.2865659296512604,
0.29120463132858276,
0.3138658106327057,
-0.4755959212779999,
-1.1844801902770996,
0.9855173826217651,
0.5517026782035828,
-0.7483028173446655,
0.22921591997146606,
0.7278817892074585,
0.44195109605789185,
-0.16911198198795319,
0.06806348264217377,
0.5923561453819275,
0.4880034029483795,
-0.018851008266210556,
-0.9284010529518127,
-0.3974294066429138,
-0.09258443862199783,
-0.11688274145126343,
0.5175502896308899,
-0.5243387222290039,
0.5616322755813599,
-0.09540534764528275,
0.1973700374364853,
0.3707164227962494,
0.36575090885162354,
0.3382413685321808,
0.30409303307533264,
0.5880882740020752,
0.5366025567054749,
0.8284347057342529,
-0.19243650138378143,
1.0308655500411987,
-0.6391292810440063,
0.5698007345199585,
0.5809551477432251,
0.05873474106192589,
0.9385756850242615,
0.7998755574226379,
-0.060954686254262924,
0.17353340983390808,
0.7668293714523315,
0.07122687250375748,
0.954600989818573,
0.6242192983627319,
-0.2103230506181717,
-0.7176167368888855,
0.13418525457382202,
-0.07712298631668091,
0.534188985824585,
-0.06053898483514786,
-0.35805580019950867,
-0.22751115262508392,
0.44116634130477905,
-0.37222400307655334,
-0.1826292723417282,
-0.2846617102622986,
0.7102983593940735,
0.3071132302284241,
-0.7749308347702026,
0.3601064085960388,
0.23540860414505005,
0.5676920413970947,
-0.6380465030670166,
0.18052814900875092,
-0.4778774380683899,
0.5090210437774658,
0.18595916032791138,
-0.45973408222198486,
-0.01277807168662548,
-0.40190261602401733,
-0.027971012517809868,
0.02536364458501339,
0.7797439694404602,
-0.7432100176811218,
-0.6723960638046265,
0.14477425813674927,
0.24083387851715088,
0.18533790111541748,
0.012439929880201817,
-0.7040503621101379,
-0.07656877487897873,
0.06396593898534775,
-0.4674256443977356,
0.6831192374229431,
0.5018514394760132,
0.28414350748062134,
0.7350871562957764,
0.662311851978302,
0.5330987572669983,
0.12229709327220917,
0.2770130932331085,
0.24660415947437286,
-0.591468870639801,
-0.717650830745697,
-0.9297752976417542,
0.4646797180175781,
0.09731854498386383,
-0.5793926119804382,
0.8266437649726868,
0.7081732153892517,
0.9093335270881653,
-0.47393661737442017,
0.5071137547492981,
0.47187161445617676,
0.07888370752334595,
-0.5378067493438721,
0.8786263465881348,
-0.8777750730514526,
-0.03225197643041611,
-0.015670539811253548,
-0.7712823152542114,
-0.4755454957485199,
0.5095329880714417,
0.1362859606742859,
-0.13140557706356049,
0.45732641220092773,
0.9801337718963623,
-0.09977499395608902,
-0.18223653733730316,
0.5816013216972351,
0.08518359810113907,
0.06985659152269363,
0.48314398527145386,
0.8924373388290405,
-0.6080348491668701,
0.8256403207778931,
-0.4550075829029083,
0.03751759976148605,
-0.4268896281719208,
-0.9021975994110107,
-0.8284387588500977,
-0.7464298009872437,
-0.3969007432460785,
-0.32924845814704895,
0.10117816925048828,
0.9121147394180298,
0.5931764841079712,
-0.8849705457687378,
-0.27931034564971924,
-0.2170545756816864,
0.4992520809173584,
-0.39955613017082214,
-0.12593384087085724,
0.026623409241437912,
-0.5711840391159058,
-0.8818179965019226,
0.38459253311157227,
0.299039751291275,
0.1388646811246872,
-0.2933409810066223,
-0.27625295519828796,
0.06550479680299759,
0.07157314568758011,
0.33679255843162537,
-0.035851020365953445,
-0.8526175618171692,
-0.34600406885147095,
0.26122164726257324,
-0.03024212270975113,
-0.3078135848045349,
0.754691481590271,
-0.3746371269226074,
0.5667045712471008,
0.28415486216545105,
0.4780188798904419,
0.5294476747512817,
-0.6132763624191284,
0.4902339577674866,
-0.7845609188079834,
0.3531205356121063,
0.07758591324090958,
0.26210400462150574,
-0.2518034875392914,
-0.3228357434272766,
0.297639399766922,
0.20363233983516693,
-0.5759545564651489,
-0.8930478692054749,
-0.015307336114346981,
-0.8501250147819519,
-0.012401031330227852,
1.420290231704712,
0.4222727119922638,
-0.11956392973661423,
0.12480227649211884,
-0.1257960945367813,
0.11772928386926651,
0.04974345862865448,
1.0455540418624878,
1.0299893617630005,
0.3514220118522644,
-0.295166552066803,
-0.6129873991012573,
0.7003609538078308,
0.48765575885772705,
-0.36418235301971436,
-0.28693217039108276,
-0.06533091515302658,
0.44969335198402405,
0.1562797725200653,
0.416983962059021,
0.08740000426769257,
0.5110802054405212,
-0.07911185175180435,
-0.23212891817092896,
-0.01519816555082798,
-0.27714043855667114,
-0.3053343594074249,
0.19430752098560333,
0.356501042842865,
-0.4573209285736084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02791v2 | Rethinking Optimization and Architecture for Tiny Language Models | 2024-02-05T07:59:38 | 2024-02-06T05:38:26 | Yehui Tang, Fangcheng Liu, Yunsheng Ni, Yuchuan Tian, Zheyuan Bai, Yi-Qi Hu, Sichao Liu, Shangling Jui, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The power of large language models (LLMs) has been demonstrated through
numerous data and computing resources. However, the application of language
models on mobile devices is facing huge challenge on the computation and memory
costs, that is, tiny language models with high performance are urgently
required. Limited by the highly complex training process, there are many
details for optimizing language models that are seldom studied carefully. In
this study, based on a tiny language model with 1B parameters, we carefully
design a series of empirical study to analyze the effect of each component.
Three perspectives are mainly discussed, \ie, neural architecture, parameter
initialization, and optimization strategy. Several design formulas are
empirically proved especially effective for tiny language models, including
tokenizer compression, architecture tweaking, parameter inheritance and
multiple-round training. Then we train PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro and PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B
Pro on 1.6T multilingual corpora, following the established formulas.
Experimental results demonstrate the improved optimization and architecture
yield a notable average improvement of 8.87 on benchmark evaluation sets for
PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro. Besides, PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B Pro surpasses a range of SOTA
models with larger model sizes, validating its superior performance. The code
is available at https://github.com/YuchuanTian/RethinkTinyLM. | [
-0.35714009404182434,
-0.9050787091255188,
0.43135958909988403,
0.2190149873495102,
-0.5825962424278259,
-0.22486639022827148,
-0.5068304538726807,
-0.4440383315086365,
0.3078705966472626,
0.2282826453447342,
-0.4507833421230316,
-0.10422159731388092,
-0.2784412205219269,
0.07912173122167587,
0.18561764061450958,
0.5322081446647644,
0.24076257646083832,
0.2420075386762619,
0.10645131766796112,
-0.2887428104877472,
-0.37626710534095764,
-0.18525177240371704,
-0.9690853953361511,
-0.17839469015598297,
0.5524089932441711,
0.7768482565879822,
0.634170413017273,
1.0656815767288208,
0.3312089443206787,
0.23865264654159546,
-0.24968868494033813,
0.005796161480247974,
-0.4582480490207672,
-0.2717299461364746,
0.32020437717437744,
-0.6520483493804932,
-0.51938396692276,
-0.24788126349449158,
0.7267170548439026,
0.5961599349975586,
0.04699769616127014,
0.49947184324264526,
-0.07029838114976883,
0.5690698623657227,
-0.2966153919696808,
0.07571141421794891,
-0.6592652201652527,
-0.1948390007019043,
-0.22585393488407135,
-0.028406867757439613,
-0.48403677344322205,
-0.46438276767730713,
0.003848597640171647,
-0.31991639733314514,
0.20296889543533325,
0.4390414357185364,
0.7034244537353516,
0.2297815978527069,
-0.06878456473350525,
-0.2723327875137329,
-0.5091383457183838,
0.7684375643730164,
-0.8927941918373108,
0.5699541568756104,
0.1295395791530609,
0.0674705058336258,
-0.13525404036045074,
-0.5447433590888977,
-0.48233866691589355,
-0.5753762722015381,
0.12495483458042145,
-0.431632936000824,
-0.08224688470363617,
-0.027961600571870804,
0.03766145184636116,
0.21332915127277374,
-0.5448555946350098,
0.5348070859909058,
-0.4702751040458679,
-0.03751663118600845,
0.6724987030029297,
0.21535006165504456,
0.38505077362060547,
-0.20723390579223633,
-0.1611385941505432,
0.11559859663248062,
-1.0867520570755005,
-0.0026758303865790367,
0.359276682138443,
0.6183375716209412,
-0.2483830600976944,
0.3041468560695648,
-0.026972338557243347,
0.6132209897041321,
0.07722451537847519,
-0.29054346680641174,
0.21772095561027527,
-0.4620974063873291,
-0.12822586297988892,
0.10903133451938629,
0.8654265403747559,
0.04316532239317894,
0.13525508344173431,
-0.3250576853752136,
-0.23651084303855896,
-0.19489634037017822,
0.3540650010108948,
-1.1381720304489136,
-0.18230687081813812,
0.28484052419662476,
-0.667227566242218,
-0.46701347827911377,
-0.5548840165138245,
-0.5828253626823425,
-0.10410797595977783,
-0.4639679193496704,
0.3076232373714447,
-0.5631701946258545,
-0.3312852084636688,
0.05154592543840408,
0.545443594455719,
-0.001278930576518178,
-0.03305653855204582,
-1.3093352317810059,
0.2649349570274353,
0.7623100280761719,
0.9140385985374451,
0.0935707688331604,
-0.25317320227622986,
-0.21776480972766876,
-0.3243301808834076,
-0.31941714882850647,
0.7588757872581482,
-0.3875058591365814,
-0.42732253670692444,
-0.26954230666160583,
-0.24986043572425842,
-0.2964388132095337,
-0.6052422523498535,
0.6927392482757568,
-0.5565205812454224,
-0.25072863698005676,
0.02683638222515583,
-0.5189009308815002,
-0.11268600821495056,
0.1972828358411789,
-0.8662649393081665,
0.8200876712799072,
-0.20415088534355164,
-0.6617633104324341,
0.2399887889623642,
-0.6474677920341492,
-0.45476242899894714,
0.010686416178941727,
-0.18796902894973755,
-0.567899763584137,
0.6073669791221619,
0.04193711280822754,
0.30301403999328613,
-0.5839904546737671,
0.11035044491291046,
-0.15958952903747559,
-0.4091133773326874,
0.07230620086193085,
-0.09349694848060608,
0.7207409739494324,
0.3900543749332428,
-0.16302944719791412,
0.17948505282402039,
-0.9117040634155273,
0.27435505390167236,
0.1393546611070633,
-0.5860358476638794,
-0.39947178959846497,
-0.014732887968420982,
0.010624762624502182,
0.06455110758543015,
0.19363364577293396,
-0.5876210331916809,
0.22323819994926453,
-0.6886317729949951,
0.6575247049331665,
0.5592579245567322,
-0.1157941222190857,
0.8065963387489319,
-0.07305794954299927,
0.48532795906066895,
-0.2434392273426056,
0.24188800156116486,
-0.03897939249873161,
-0.3479631245136261,
-0.7751268744468689,
-0.40894079208374023,
0.6929192543029785,
0.276480495929718,
-0.44118237495422363,
0.09236789494752884,
-0.45220327377319336,
-0.60875004529953,
-0.8550220727920532,
0.2123340517282486,
0.4864761233329773,
0.10935793817043304,
-0.02776055410504341,
0.03836328908801079,
-0.7620548009872437,
-1.1124897003173828,
-0.2757812738418579,
-0.2944972813129425,
0.0856202095746994,
0.28384461998939514,
0.43461501598358154,
-0.23363782465457916,
0.961212158203125,
-0.20618784427642822,
0.08053706586360931,
-0.6098334193229675,
-0.11830426752567291,
0.1948317587375641,
0.5007566213607788,
0.5614715218544006,
-0.682564377784729,
-0.4013831317424774,
0.06259511411190033,
-0.39255428314208984,
-0.09216481447219849,
-0.08884910494089127,
0.19370271265506744,
0.24496690928936005,
0.4630557894706726,
-0.6862339973449707,
0.0631665363907814,
0.4483585059642792,
0.1353745311498642,
0.8165420889854431,
-0.3013826310634613,
-0.4183211028575897,
-0.9763123393058777,
0.07553202658891678,
0.04173489660024643,
0.07095798850059509,
-0.7365968823432922,
0.5182791948318481,
0.27700239419937134,
-0.16846877336502075,
-0.6725260615348816,
0.8325339555740356,
-0.534839928150177,
0.04130656272172928,
-0.49073049426078796,
0.32138437032699585,
-0.285005122423172,
0.6556596159934998,
-0.21383817493915558,
0.7786518931388855,
0.4168547987937927,
-0.6419862508773804,
0.12554605305194855,
-0.12515556812286377,
-0.4690576493740082,
-0.06263670325279236,
-0.8031684160232544,
0.1850656419992447,
-0.08668367564678192,
-0.1275828629732132,
-0.9986788034439087,
0.022786274552345276,
0.11481166630983353,
-0.2976650893688202,
0.31309396028518677,
-0.15739217400550842,
-0.8681874871253967,
-0.24697905778884888,
-0.44201719760894775,
0.6215329766273499,
0.29602324962615967,
-0.5358134508132935,
0.5940415859222412,
0.3947533965110779,
-0.12603826820850372,
0.04419558867812157,
-0.5012402534484863,
-0.03719353303313255,
-0.5154649615287781,
-0.8816137313842773,
0.21410438418388367,
0.07542165368795395,
-0.2900604009628296,
-0.28221017122268677,
-0.1643311083316803,
0.16804485023021698,
0.05483463406562805,
0.014723037369549274,
0.1541546732187271,
-0.6249741315841675,
0.20941473543643951,
0.00994089711457491,
-0.32890236377716064,
-0.07218731939792633,
-0.292239785194397,
0.8015968203544617,
-0.5247809290885925,
0.16205698251724243,
-0.5148891806602478,
0.04898485168814659,
0.3789653480052948,
-0.16014499962329865,
0.7749560475349426,
0.4477468430995941,
-0.32820042967796326,
-0.1143159344792366,
-0.49011269211769104,
-0.2450118362903595,
-0.4964723289012909,
0.511762261390686,
-0.7826831340789795,
-0.9016897082328796,
0.676181972026825,
-0.13629086315631866,
0.09270945191383362,
0.24671480059623718,
0.9223408699035645,
0.1886187195777893,
0.67931067943573,
0.695788562297821,
-0.15124450623989105,
0.502484142780304,
-0.2669426202774048,
0.4283931255340576,
-0.9433190822601318,
-0.19312670826911926,
-0.534511387348175,
-0.4127545952796936,
-0.8404999375343323,
-0.46719998121261597,
0.09198174625635147,
0.29034435749053955,
-0.2182970643043518,
0.5937837958335876,
-0.1588888019323349,
0.4901981055736542,
0.41750746965408325,
0.12114366143941879,
0.2195262461900711,
0.06266804039478302,
-0.34826749563217163,
-0.10775641351938248,
-1.0720027685165405,
-0.9258294105529785,
1.100345492362976,
0.651414692401886,
0.9360151886940002,
0.2981700599193573,
0.6293655633926392,
-0.1739596128463745,
0.17239148914813995,
-0.9484197497367859,
0.716015100479126,
-0.2934776544570923,
-0.5353614091873169,
-0.19621381163597107,
-0.39949044585227966,
-0.8513375520706177,
0.6755990982055664,
0.09527783840894699,
-0.9069333672523499,
0.21001039445400238,
0.2677561044692993,
-0.5688744783401489,
0.1196526512503624,
-1.1008881330490112,
1.084004282951355,
-0.47844862937927246,
-0.46725142002105713,
-0.18741478025913239,
-0.5712987780570984,
0.35862308740615845,
-0.28032082319259644,
0.271232932806015,
0.030033934861421585,
-0.19448532164096832,
0.6711336374282837,
-0.3635716438293457,
0.8227106928825378,
-0.02027701400220394,
-0.08568832278251648,
0.25228768587112427,
0.14675940573215485,
0.4952871799468994,
0.1867724508047104,
-0.3136782944202423,
0.052564628422260284,
-0.1243395209312439,
-0.3283059000968933,
-0.41262418031692505,
0.740139901638031,
-0.8113433122634888,
-0.5118467807769775,
0.16283828020095825,
-0.26631960272789,
-0.0864894762635231,
0.323783278465271,
0.30074477195739746,
0.4828106462955475,
-0.22562584280967712,
0.22824089229106903,
0.6757587194442749,
-0.16417168080806732,
0.572585940361023,
0.49514028429985046,
-0.3038484454154968,
-0.12808813154697418,
0.9781517386436462,
0.014816951006650925,
0.3493679165840149,
0.3917757570743561,
0.5260445475578308,
-0.30379465222358704,
-0.7194539308547974,
-0.883712649345398,
0.5126394033432007,
-0.31261691451072693,
-0.008602770045399666,
-0.5681595206260681,
0.11522071063518524,
-0.3814829885959625,
0.2886768877506256,
-0.7496690154075623,
-0.41038161516189575,
-0.3735312521457672,
-0.02205037698149681,
-0.006146446336060762,
0.1627570390701294,
0.067292220890522,
0.7411543726921082,
-0.5560970902442932,
0.2451753169298172,
-0.014746002852916718,
0.29213234782218933,
0.3572896122932434,
-0.7059752941131592,
-0.6142864227294922,
0.050115857273340225,
-0.18954575061798096,
-0.489744633436203,
0.26185327768325806,
0.23221802711486816,
0.46291878819465637,
0.5948492884635925,
-0.3019954264163971,
0.6357297897338867,
-0.9055693745613098,
0.40758514404296875,
-0.012091904878616333,
-0.6499703526496887,
0.3527403473854065,
-0.24333788454532623,
0.18316438794136047,
0.6283395886421204,
0.04813707247376442,
-0.2928667664527893,
-0.05688861757516861,
-0.7483612895011902,
-0.6984982490539551,
0.793006956577301,
0.241008922457695,
0.20205681025981903,
0.13000187277793884,
0.591917097568512,
0.0007721334113739431,
0.06741925328969955,
-0.6363069415092468,
-0.2274250090122223,
0.030355367809534073,
-0.06215183809399605,
0.1566758006811142,
-0.5995063185691833,
0.20233027637004852,
-0.21075507998466492,
0.5581344962120056,
0.05189850553870201,
0.30134469270706177,
-0.35347694158554077,
-0.18646559119224548,
0.048779793083667755,
0.2334194928407669,
0.9583250880241394,
0.5424813032150269,
-0.14542755484580994,
0.12509220838546753,
0.15757004916667938,
-0.5220413208007812,
0.11604930460453033,
-0.2887380123138428,
-0.1670200675725937,
0.06374059617519379,
0.19823236763477325,
1.0240408182144165,
0.3713264465332031,
-0.6538997888565063,
0.09598326683044434,
-0.10086201876401901,
0.10143711417913437,
-0.13603198528289795,
0.0030796825885772705,
0.396731972694397,
0.21748757362365723,
0.10069674253463745,
-0.037278153002262115,
-0.04516875371336937,
-0.6413958072662354,
0.03141903132200241,
0.2671670913696289,
0.06927236914634705,
-0.5983456373214722,
0.6352736353874207,
0.2698875367641449,
-0.7463551759719849,
0.5123085975646973,
-0.24312622845172882,
-0.507540762424469,
0.5667369961738586,
0.8379226326942444,
0.6816709637641907,
-0.18995578587055206,
0.04116833582520485,
0.3104069232940674,
0.6573793292045593,
-0.18894051015377045,
0.059359773993492126,
0.13607539236545563,
-0.7660563588142395,
-0.30685096979141235,
-0.7560292482376099,
-0.155901700258255,
0.08459357172250748,
-0.2153986692428589,
0.29003939032554626,
-0.5843924283981323,
-0.12860852479934692,
0.06600041687488556,
0.4330960214138031,
-0.39380601048469543,
0.3558726906776428,
0.00114940304774791,
1.0350255966186523,
-0.6844668984413147,
1.1213555335998535,
0.6177589297294617,
-0.3758228123188019,
-1.0545909404754639,
-0.14364513754844666,
-0.04871422052383423,
-0.9521262049674988,
0.7582808136940002,
0.12643636763095856,
-0.21265660226345062,
0.058508679270744324,
-0.26058056950569153,
-0.7925432324409485,
0.6631842255592346,
0.3993532359600067,
-0.693925678730011,
-0.012479070574045181,
0.21385818719863892,
0.7830750942230225,
-0.6556156277656555,
-0.024372929707169533,
0.8218061923980713,
0.20651596784591675,
-0.030331118032336235,
-0.8430442214012146,
0.063198983669281,
-0.3352251350879669,
0.4738151729106903,
0.20325186848640442,
-0.8718860149383545,
0.9206011295318604,
-0.49683865904808044,
-0.2452351152896881,
0.49277031421661377,
0.5109824538230896,
0.5875898599624634,
0.09621962904930115,
0.29729050397872925,
0.4891655743122101,
0.5259937047958374,
0.08491344004869461,
1.0629044771194458,
-0.4054047763347626,
0.4653996527194977,
1.0603125095367432,
0.018718332052230835,
1.0242441892623901,
0.7104964256286621,
-0.11165864020586014,
0.20328009128570557,
0.8792462348937988,
0.11042612791061401,
0.4659099280834198,
0.43071192502975464,
-0.2329602688550949,
-0.04470457136631012,
0.19767828285694122,
-0.19671742618083954,
0.4218921959400177,
0.23156066238880157,
-0.2969001233577728,
0.011796354316174984,
0.04699353873729706,
0.23761577904224396,
-0.20935456454753876,
-0.307524710893631,
0.5687341690063477,
0.20757481455802917,
-0.25372955203056335,
0.5852941274642944,
0.7041313052177429,
0.6405303478240967,
-0.24708104133605957,
0.6294390559196472,
-0.6477648615837097,
0.31694477796554565,
-0.09477904438972473,
-0.03873441740870476,
0.2090815305709839,
0.03175618499517441,
-0.19657249748706818,
0.007811019197106361,
0.7446447014808655,
-0.21764527261257172,
-0.7270255088806152,
-0.08552512526512146,
0.37765219807624817,
0.33572572469711304,
-0.12394476681947708,
-0.6231674551963806,
0.43520376086235046,
0.024152571335434914,
-0.2349824756383896,
0.21000076830387115,
0.551673173904419,
-0.0833236575126648,
0.8333036303520203,
0.515560507774353,
0.2396405190229416,
0.275718092918396,
0.2097543329000473,
0.7438620924949646,
-0.6380756497383118,
-0.7448593378067017,
-1.1658402681350708,
0.1626528650522232,
0.17296047508716583,
-0.19888336956501007,
0.7973836064338684,
0.9315810799598694,
0.7670013904571533,
-0.2015238106250763,
0.3216198682785034,
-0.09634166955947876,
0.33582431077957153,
-0.560755729675293,
0.6785191893577576,
-0.6723600625991821,
0.6510628461837769,
-0.07230141013860703,
-1.0011234283447266,
-0.3547481596469879,
0.681571364402771,
-0.39309820532798767,
0.13225406408309937,
0.5943026542663574,
0.9890694618225098,
-0.1038677841424942,
0.23688066005706787,
0.19427955150604248,
0.2907232642173767,
0.22224082052707672,
0.46629318594932556,
0.5669291615486145,
-0.7117809057235718,
0.4793035387992859,
-0.12392109632492065,
-0.0891069695353508,
-0.5931292772293091,
-0.5912805199623108,
-0.8221657872200012,
-0.21010029315948486,
-0.21504779160022736,
0.017082389444112778,
-0.0676935687661171,
0.9520736336708069,
0.7707239985466003,
-0.5112485885620117,
-0.4565468728542328,
-0.03512800112366676,
0.13134171068668365,
0.056985434144735336,
-0.13783341646194458,
0.5367490649223328,
-0.37571272253990173,
-0.7060700058937073,
0.3035402297973633,
0.21858011186122894,
-0.07455416023731232,
-0.28599169850349426,
-0.21592256426811218,
-0.07938650995492935,
0.027466045692563057,
0.8020291328430176,
0.41112691164016724,
-0.8197327852249146,
-0.2253495305776596,
0.03986680507659912,
-0.2679973244667053,
0.09895119816064835,
1.0790964365005493,
-0.623053789138794,
0.28879550099372864,
0.28632277250289917,
0.7125066518783569,
0.36267998814582825,
-0.08664114028215408,
0.3672509491443634,
-0.8774436712265015,
0.3742702603340149,
-0.0203611571341753,
0.3771001100540161,
0.185578390955925,
-0.05120691657066345,
0.4683106541633606,
0.04176763445138931,
-0.33133164048194885,
-0.9855639338493347,
0.1751914769411087,
-0.8490885496139526,
-0.27626466751098633,
1.1597048044204712,
0.19052234292030334,
-0.40351808071136475,
0.1784764975309372,
-0.29767540097236633,
0.09331024438142776,
-0.26583418250083923,
0.95744389295578,
0.5145009160041809,
-0.20613469183444977,
-0.5101177096366882,
-0.483064740896225,
0.32532817125320435,
0.5055935978889465,
-0.57880038022995,
0.06677482277154922,
0.18800295889377594,
0.3566475212574005,
0.18779295682907104,
0.6579743027687073,
-0.0689389705657959,
0.17648334801197052,
0.32522711157798767,
-0.1195586547255516,
-0.16672538220882416,
-0.3535565733909607,
-0.3292088210582733,
0.10382996499538422,
0.22060804069042206,
-0.3872661590576172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02782v1 | From Partial to Strictly Incremental Constituent Parsing | 2024-02-05T07:33:25 | 2024-02-05T07:33:25 | Ana Ezquerro, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study incremental constituent parsers to assess their capacity to output
trees based on prefix representations alone. Guided by strictly left-to-right
generative language models and tree-decoding modules, we build parsers that
adhere to a strong definition of incrementality across languages. This builds
upon work that asserted incrementality, but that mostly only enforced it on
either the encoder or the decoder. Finally, we conduct an analysis against
non-incremental and partially incremental models. | [
-0.16211038827896118,
-0.6774356365203857,
0.5807415246963501,
0.5423738360404968,
-0.21228256821632385,
0.004836533684283495,
-0.06431886553764343,
-0.375665545463562,
0.21825505793094635,
0.4911090135574341,
-0.6485562920570374,
-0.30126479268074036,
-0.3797091245651245,
0.6429484486579895,
-0.7508876323699951,
0.6002910733222961,
0.20029157400131226,
0.019539810717105865,
-0.4038008749485016,
-0.18884462118148804,
-0.7661349177360535,
-0.7804645895957947,
-0.7450979351997375,
-0.11029159277677536,
0.18457666039466858,
0.4914776384830475,
0.6254269480705261,
0.9371045827865601,
0.15221484005451202,
0.3085011839866638,
-0.1618090271949768,
-0.5701949000358582,
-0.10635963827371597,
0.26940810680389404,
-0.18793794512748718,
-0.3987693786621094,
-0.29613834619522095,
-0.3427070677280426,
1.1025078296661377,
0.8230829834938049,
0.025399526581168175,
-0.14356353878974915,
0.1274556815624237,
0.6520023345947266,
-0.1633402705192566,
0.11757172644138336,
-0.783636748790741,
0.33446067571640015,
-0.5628712177276611,
-0.23884747922420502,
-0.713866651058197,
-0.3718481659889221,
-0.3339120149612427,
-0.16890430450439453,
0.3869486451148987,
-0.40480417013168335,
0.8529080748558044,
0.09322382509708405,
-0.38774874806404114,
-0.3216148018836975,
-0.4254930913448334,
0.5773584246635437,
-0.8223139643669128,
0.669557511806488,
0.42692553997039795,
0.2617083191871643,
-0.14509621262550354,
-1.0037511587142944,
-0.22176189720630646,
-0.5878113508224487,
-0.18843592703342438,
0.08849208801984787,
-0.040919993072748184,
0.19628308713436127,
0.4148912727832794,
1.0143440961837769,
-0.5556710362434387,
-0.1543288677930832,
0.08500764518976212,
-0.052962567657232285,
0.2905033528804779,
0.1946423053741455,
0.48560845851898193,
-0.25943902134895325,
-0.15565167367458344,
0.045031849294900894,
-0.7634448409080505,
0.1386299729347229,
0.39842918515205383,
0.4379952847957611,
-0.010633301921188831,
0.8167998194694519,
-0.14921993017196655,
0.9336698651313782,
0.31592968106269836,
0.07891232520341873,
-0.32183951139450073,
-0.8016685247421265,
-0.4500357210636139,
0.12565304338932037,
0.30904340744018555,
-0.560547947883606,
-0.12271138280630112,
-0.3085590898990631,
-0.22447891533374786,
-0.011909705586731434,
0.18205715715885162,
-0.6295737028121948,
-0.4218369424343109,
0.06683491170406342,
-0.26128700375556946,
-0.11620308458805084,
0.0024757387582212687,
-0.5914304852485657,
-0.1992495059967041,
-0.5789822936058044,
0.07281707972288132,
-0.5934061408042908,
-0.35411348938941956,
0.044977881014347076,
-0.026543118059635162,
0.04621174558997154,
0.16847072541713715,
-0.8469000458717346,
0.447332501411438,
0.988383412361145,
0.8150141835212708,
0.0733407586812973,
-0.28135454654693604,
-0.617303729057312,
-0.08342666178941727,
-0.5045422911643982,
0.7172302007675171,
-0.9498684406280518,
-0.25411859154701233,
0.18299600481987,
0.38852396607398987,
0.04084246978163719,
-0.6019441485404968,
0.5948148369789124,
-0.43040454387664795,
-0.05575943738222122,
-0.4659426510334015,
-0.7222586274147034,
-0.3273370862007141,
0.25471407175064087,
-0.5132983922958374,
0.9306722283363342,
0.5955711603164673,
-0.716425895690918,
0.5074781179428101,
-0.4662516713142395,
-0.3909660279750824,
0.2533242106437683,
-0.3146160840988159,
-0.24189403653144836,
0.47013208270072937,
-0.20958642661571503,
-0.0455787368118763,
-0.02890668250620365,
0.5460928678512573,
-0.11216425895690918,
0.14261075854301453,
-0.06374900043010712,
-0.6067668795585632,
1.0422847270965576,
-0.01546088419854641,
-0.17527058720588684,
0.4831148684024811,
-0.6993811130523682,
-0.06606090813875198,
-0.13430525362491608,
-0.398006409406662,
-0.1455741673707962,
0.1463070511817932,
-0.4097270667552948,
0.17795149981975555,
0.2101576328277588,
-0.5793063044548035,
0.2560463547706604,
-0.3376339077949524,
0.5159262418746948,
0.7982750535011292,
0.09048505127429962,
0.24473193287849426,
-0.002727848244830966,
0.5013765096664429,
0.3052051365375519,
0.08744163811206818,
-0.6519227623939514,
-0.4292711913585663,
-1.2837709188461304,
-0.35390621423721313,
0.8339162468910217,
0.07724189758300781,
-0.7228229641914368,
0.7050473093986511,
-0.42672425508499146,
0.02529747411608696,
-0.3442222774028778,
-0.0056633492931723595,
0.15489079058170319,
0.41751179099082947,
0.12412742525339127,
-0.7186519503593445,
-0.5131211876869202,
-0.9970303773880005,
0.014714445918798447,
-0.393548846244812,
0.22073563933372498,
-0.44790494441986084,
0.3564152717590332,
0.0009058772120624781,
0.9912796020507812,
-0.032992638647556305,
0.044116225093603134,
-0.2505285143852234,
0.009635508991777897,
0.2676648199558258,
0.563251256942749,
0.205900639295578,
-0.5259740948677063,
-0.6493096947669983,
0.2783450186252594,
-0.726263165473938,
-0.15536779165267944,
-0.2798823416233063,
0.04205656796693802,
0.09819991141557693,
0.42248907685279846,
-0.5954344868659973,
0.6934050917625427,
0.3730415999889374,
-0.6438551545143127,
0.3046749532222748,
-0.05199568346142769,
-0.16028642654418945,
-0.806730329990387,
-0.0384339839220047,
-0.05764172598719597,
-0.964552640914917,
-0.5406638979911804,
0.5658966302871704,
0.16211168467998505,
-0.19178298115730286,
-0.09953852742910385,
0.10779549181461334,
-0.5661419034004211,
-0.5201810002326965,
-0.058634884655475616,
-0.64168381690979,
0.03539123013615608,
0.33493757247924805,
0.22965294122695923,
0.9408453702926636,
0.5794304013252258,
-0.630581259727478,
0.16215528547763824,
-0.13398116827011108,
-0.22753214836120605,
0.44617822766304016,
-0.44550371170043945,
0.08468671143054962,
-0.273844450712204,
0.1437665969133377,
-0.9181120991706848,
-0.3755868971347809,
0.1465332806110382,
-0.26613226532936096,
0.48435842990875244,
-0.5658935308456421,
-0.7249133586883545,
-0.2247101366519928,
-0.4596690535545349,
0.529317319393158,
0.3213844299316406,
-0.6337381601333618,
0.5283529162406921,
0.2432197630405426,
-0.24802707135677338,
0.06142521649599075,
-0.6601921319961548,
0.24728713929653168,
-0.10202168673276901,
-0.6038632988929749,
0.058709390461444855,
0.12855210900306702,
-0.08368358016014099,
0.17794273793697357,
-0.07340921461582184,
-0.1410672813653946,
-0.04817314073443413,
0.2837545573711395,
-0.28524050116539,
-0.47512251138687134,
0.029835857450962067,
0.03240591660141945,
-0.16617518663406372,
-0.03642257675528526,
-0.3177247941493988,
0.8452631831169128,
-0.06152950972318649,
-0.748539388179779,
-0.740436315536499,
0.7689168453216553,
0.47266361117362976,
-0.14939412474632263,
0.31147053837776184,
-0.1557408720254898,
-0.2976328432559967,
0.10001228749752045,
-0.3533759117126465,
0.07888612896203995,
-0.49594199657440186,
0.3420118987560272,
-0.9325248003005981,
-0.6705514192581177,
0.48636406660079956,
0.10124772042036057,
0.06372543424367905,
0.5447567701339722,
0.5257623791694641,
0.4110032320022583,
1.0679110288619995,
0.8354618549346924,
0.09280383586883545,
0.2999233901500702,
-0.06729935109615326,
0.16485513746738434,
-0.6361507177352905,
-0.19072072207927704,
-0.6236369609832764,
0.20677685737609863,
-0.4196482300758362,
-0.3787234127521515,
0.022251727059483528,
0.33837804198265076,
-0.29992595314979553,
0.5455760359764099,
-0.6615868210792542,
0.565528154373169,
0.44891512393951416,
-0.44024622440338135,
0.4341326951980591,
0.17682988941669464,
0.02689877524971962,
-0.06512255221605301,
-0.6505749225616455,
-0.43987101316452026,
0.27377042174339294,
0.6251030564308167,
0.4601963758468628,
0.2327413260936737,
0.5584832429885864,
0.3892548382282257,
0.4259975254535675,
-1.3513888120651245,
0.6155956387519836,
-0.13681550323963165,
-0.3417374789714813,
-0.0025969601701945066,
-0.36036401987075806,
-0.9712606072425842,
0.28476986289024353,
0.608672022819519,
-0.4848518967628479,
0.5440828800201416,
-0.07975487411022186,
0.07154706865549088,
0.3637446165084839,
-0.5636423826217651,
1.0103285312652588,
-0.019122092053294182,
-0.028862979263067245,
0.18450452387332916,
-0.42710837721824646,
0.4583491384983063,
0.019651837646961212,
-0.28802523016929626,
0.14635546505451202,
-0.1311129778623581,
0.3167310059070587,
-0.6205035448074341,
0.7895509600639343,
-0.14218099415302277,
-0.14383918046951294,
0.5847651362419128,
0.5220742225646973,
0.3944016695022583,
0.1064603328704834,
-0.1444355696439743,
0.27514412999153137,
0.1346486210823059,
-0.5444966554641724,
-0.21072109043598175,
0.7326527833938599,
-0.5730770230293274,
-0.7140379548072815,
-0.750324010848999,
-0.17970238626003265,
-0.19545407593250275,
0.12293915450572968,
0.15739592909812927,
0.44726258516311646,
-0.19100575149059296,
0.018245892599225044,
0.25986403226852417,
0.15330538153648376,
0.7267791628837585,
0.3972850441932678,
-0.5241045951843262,
-0.37048572301864624,
0.9229220747947693,
0.20548169314861298,
0.299315482378006,
0.46277013421058655,
0.17462125420570374,
-0.49152225255966187,
-0.5269614458084106,
-0.7179696559906006,
0.1666124314069748,
-0.9026815891265869,
-0.37282127141952515,
-0.6299991011619568,
-0.503616452217102,
-0.2748156785964966,
0.2837962210178375,
-0.35482215881347656,
-0.5921660661697388,
-0.2355048507452011,
-0.1738397777080536,
0.09853823482990265,
1.0631771087646484,
-0.056548524647951126,
0.04297240823507309,
-0.8350012302398682,
0.03504733368754387,
0.6535956263542175,
0.04262058809399605,
0.10089948773384094,
-0.564421534538269,
0.09830863773822784,
-0.02115875668823719,
-0.4962117373943329,
-1.0361956357955933,
0.23114266991615295,
0.16818328201770782,
-0.1168912723660469,
0.43999406695365906,
-0.25007617473602295,
1.1321839094161987,
-0.6838585734367371,
1.0807591676712036,
0.36812010407447815,
-1.3521517515182495,
0.3994135558605194,
-0.16413021087646484,
0.22563336789608002,
0.7527082562446594,
0.04029514640569687,
-0.6365349888801575,
-0.34682944416999817,
-0.4920252561569214,
-0.5892900824546814,
0.7827240824699402,
0.2544327676296234,
0.33031079173088074,
-0.14621324837207794,
0.23579008877277374,
0.594689667224884,
-0.11987165361642838,
-0.8699095845222473,
0.1340893805027008,
-0.5599463582038879,
-0.08430825173854828,
0.44032490253448486,
-0.5250183343887329,
0.09949581325054169,
-0.44514667987823486,
0.533721923828125,
0.12303318828344345,
0.15673592686653137,
0.2155999392271042,
0.01242993213236332,
-0.06101153418421745,
0.3617524206638336,
0.44253647327423096,
0.9477198719978333,
-0.14792899787425995,
0.5752977132797241,
-0.2713891267776489,
-0.1618797928094864,
0.608479380607605,
-0.23616959154605865,
-0.43136176466941833,
0.4828875660896301,
0.5476080775260925,
0.677505373954773,
-0.45555737614631653,
-0.2529233992099762,
0.6197639107704163,
-0.03837085887789726,
0.2469121366739273,
-0.3825395703315735,
-0.3737095296382904,
0.04714417830109596,
-0.3524908125400543,
0.2184392809867859,
0.07269299775362015,
0.12527064979076385,
-0.8552766442298889,
0.2525686025619507,
0.26935723423957825,
-0.6841552257537842,
-1.081147313117981,
0.1473522037267685,
0.10831031948328018,
-0.2724553048610687,
0.545581042766571,
-0.384470134973526,
-0.30387595295906067,
0.6392484307289124,
0.7653995156288147,
1.2038090229034424,
-0.28316354751586914,
0.21434630453586578,
0.45960086584091187,
0.3085055947303772,
-0.013776936568319798,
0.2641264796257019,
-0.5022355318069458,
-0.29018744826316833,
-0.7660612463951111,
-0.7092210650444031,
-0.1626562774181366,
0.2582811713218689,
-0.6811486482620239,
0.21893323957920074,
-0.33575209975242615,
-0.15569257736206055,
0.1851162314414978,
-0.4583221673965454,
-0.25402265787124634,
0.06691744923591614,
-0.2439032644033432,
1.0628877878189087,
-0.6511874794960022,
1.1820266246795654,
0.7413299679756165,
-0.5474367141723633,
-0.5709234476089478,
0.4891339838504791,
-0.38750165700912476,
-0.6229038834571838,
0.7717792987823486,
0.2084224373102188,
0.0965762659907341,
0.0048152729868888855,
-0.28930094838142395,
-0.677184522151947,
0.5234650373458862,
0.578636109828949,
-0.45186522603034973,
0.024768244475126266,
0.5035354495048523,
0.3330528140068054,
-0.14586524665355682,
0.1585429161787033,
0.5262426137924194,
0.5636666417121887,
0.23739105463027954,
-0.697126567363739,
0.0479426383972168,
-0.02714604139328003,
0.4214092195034027,
0.44981467723846436,
-0.43016326427459717,
1.067870855331421,
0.5572752356529236,
-0.9283133149147034,
0.40585196018218994,
0.7795248031616211,
-0.13309979438781738,
0.121641144156456,
0.27502763271331787,
1.1123192310333252,
0.29339849948883057,
-0.08845814317464828,
1.292567491531372,
-0.24175649881362915,
0.33240780234336853,
1.2183674573898315,
-0.19673170149326324,
0.6846762895584106,
0.4944058060646057,
-0.5195412039756775,
0.3419440984725952,
0.9333741068840027,
0.4362066090106964,
0.6118388772010803,
0.23363201320171356,
-0.7160150408744812,
-0.4334810674190521,
-0.47430577874183655,
-0.6271781325340271,
0.25130242109298706,
0.14949610829353333,
-0.3396196663379669,
-0.565983235836029,
-0.25898489356040955,
-0.03036215901374817,
0.037862446159124374,
-0.3314026892185211,
0.9555263519287109,
0.03799985721707344,
-0.9024500250816345,
0.6796438694000244,
0.32664966583251953,
0.2303580641746521,
-0.8182374835014343,
-0.31434565782546997,
-0.5486488342285156,
0.05849064514040947,
-0.33441856503486633,
-0.7485949397087097,
0.6431464552879333,
0.08751842379570007,
-0.18519988656044006,
-0.16638141870498657,
0.5230168700218201,
-0.40263831615448,
-0.7094385027885437,
0.19246864318847656,
0.34860655665397644,
0.1313980221748352,
0.00898695271462202,
-0.4432946443557739,
0.2774706780910492,
0.1838364452123642,
0.142616406083107,
0.3146543502807617,
0.8079183101654053,
-0.07663988322019577,
0.16269251704216003,
0.4180300831794739,
0.10522548854351044,
0.4339936673641205,
0.04918643459677696,
1.0513666868209839,
-0.9142312407493591,
-0.30359968543052673,
-1.2480276823043823,
0.5673643350601196,
0.01022119540721178,
0.09490504115819931,
1.0167906284332275,
0.9460015892982483,
0.7768132090568542,
-0.16705136001110077,
0.524109423160553,
-0.19859442114830017,
0.012181637808680534,
-0.5418596863746643,
-0.04482574388384819,
-0.48398730158805847,
0.1420842558145523,
0.3320734202861786,
-1.1317393779754639,
-0.2182569056749344,
0.38960376381874084,
-0.013373001478612423,
-0.2931095361709595,
0.6703217029571533,
0.6800326108932495,
-0.5175402760505676,
0.24903462827205658,
0.5570361018180847,
0.2255403995513916,
0.4063516855239868,
0.3712104558944702,
1.4014822244644165,
-0.17849449813365936,
-0.07668895274400711,
-0.27153417468070984,
-0.10243826359510422,
0.2750888168811798,
-0.9063454866409302,
-0.6046358346939087,
-0.6424573659896851,
-0.41632887721061707,
-0.39810284972190857,
-0.296359658241272,
0.6659427881240845,
0.8016690015792847,
-1.0376667976379395,
-0.49028345942497253,
-0.9453191757202148,
0.20868268609046936,
0.0638275220990181,
-0.3367353677749634,
0.3481358587741852,
-0.7556912899017334,
-0.6877883672714233,
0.4829363524913788,
0.8370476365089417,
0.03618507832288742,
-0.44319093227386475,
0.13220559060573578,
-0.1513776183128357,
0.26139211654663086,
0.7327324151992798,
0.39727306365966797,
-0.8652654886245728,
-0.23828762769699097,
-0.49117550253868103,
0.06821393966674805,
0.6621044278144836,
1.2505648136138916,
-0.6896799206733704,
0.6795750260353088,
0.8220996856689453,
0.7204888463020325,
0.40441593527793884,
0.3740459978580475,
0.18748816847801208,
-1.074913501739502,
0.22391381859779358,
0.5321942567825317,
0.3500537574291229,
0.5069813132286072,
-0.018682707101106644,
0.5127107501029968,
0.27550822496414185,
-0.2354595810174942,
-0.8784205317497253,
0.6318520903587341,
-0.7300414443016052,
-0.2142833024263382,
0.8435773253440857,
-0.3792315721511841,
-0.2765349745750427,
-0.34764692187309265,
-0.20298436284065247,
0.06707621365785599,
-0.28737279772758484,
0.13256268203258514,
0.6990616321563721,
-0.277778685092926,
-0.19503642618656158,
-0.15024162828922272,
0.5138591527938843,
0.41029468178749084,
-0.8499108552932739,
0.31174805760383606,
0.5465133190155029,
0.1067737564444542,
0.4987538754940033,
0.8626455664634705,
-0.46848347783088684,
-0.0932023897767067,
0.13199977576732635,
-0.28509828448295593,
0.09570804983377457,
-0.3862451910972595,
-0.6795221567153931,
0.4818800389766693,
0.4449324607849121,
-0.17830705642700195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02781v1 | Dual Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Sound Event Detection | 2024-02-05T07:30:32 | 2024-02-05T07:30:32 | Yang Xiao, Rohan Kumar Das | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Sound event detection (SED) is essential for recognizing specific sounds and
their temporal locations within acoustic signals. This becomes challenging
particularly for on-device applications, where computational resources are
limited. To address this issue, we introduce a novel framework referred to as
dual knowledge distillation for developing efficient SED systems in this work.
Our proposed dual knowledge distillation commences with temporal-averaging
knowledge distillation (TAKD), utilizing a mean student model derived from the
temporal averaging of the student model's parameters. This allows the student
model to indirectly learn from a pre-trained teacher model, ensuring a stable
knowledge distillation. Subsequently, we introduce embedding-enhanced feature
distillation (EEFD), which involves incorporating an embedding distillation
layer within the student model to bolster contextual learning. On DCASE 2023
Task 4A public evaluation dataset, our proposed SED system with dual knowledge
distillation having merely one-third of the baseline model's parameters,
demonstrates superior performance in terms of PSDS1 and PSDS2. This highlights
the importance of proposed dual knowledge distillation for compact SED systems,
which can be ideal for edge devices. | [
-0.36398324370384216,
-0.6362991333007812,
0.905381977558136,
0.0059227957390248775,
-0.5462131500244141,
0.08371809124946594,
-0.16797253489494324,
-0.3514757454395294,
0.05778023600578308,
-0.08904224634170532,
-0.44666698575019836,
-0.43816477060317993,
-0.541753888130188,
-0.47705310583114624,
-0.3221014738082886,
0.7417207956314087,
0.0769633948802948,
0.04163311421871185,
-0.019468072801828384,
-0.18213103711605072,
-0.27454712986946106,
-0.5066415071487427,
-0.9100035429000854,
-0.4260872006416321,
0.15984702110290527,
0.13351789116859436,
0.04988185688853264,
0.3261887729167938,
0.2568777799606323,
0.15065744519233704,
-0.34663712978363037,
0.061948057264089584,
0.03475233539938927,
0.26710984110832214,
0.02068428508937359,
-0.08945021778345108,
-0.234480082988739,
-0.07557927817106247,
0.22182027995586395,
0.630230188369751,
-0.4037592113018036,
0.22693830728530884,
0.30030742287635803,
0.345623254776001,
-0.6087486147880554,
0.05585462599992752,
-0.4421428143978119,
0.4335223138332367,
-0.17411983013153076,
-0.3652741312980652,
-0.0607151985168457,
-0.10261256247758865,
0.3497064709663391,
-0.6887766122817993,
0.12144137918949127,
-0.6516648530960083,
0.2773817181587219,
0.6347391605377197,
-0.5811719298362732,
-0.36644837260246277,
-0.8987861275672913,
0.4067048728466034,
-0.4844379723072052,
0.7081567645072937,
0.19552594423294067,
0.595180094242096,
0.1011362299323082,
-0.9951609373092651,
-0.6290069818496704,
0.3296779990196228,
0.37855008244514465,
0.20746849477291107,
-0.035551588982343674,
0.1328830122947693,
0.3383311331272125,
0.2027214914560318,
-0.42449918389320374,
0.026469066739082336,
-0.15116170048713684,
-0.17851431667804718,
0.44873303174972534,
-0.2036668360233307,
0.13624881207942963,
0.05195219814777374,
-0.5531430840492249,
-0.20157575607299805,
-0.3080260455608368,
0.03845973312854767,
0.41163718700408936,
0.15815934538841248,
-0.1426098495721817,
-0.05725472792983055,
-0.08929932117462158,
0.22891733050346375,
0.24552369117736816,
-0.5341838598251343,
0.2166150063276291,
-0.5045015811920166,
0.019757024943828583,
0.6178950667381287,
0.4020650088787079,
0.15596066415309906,
-0.2626051604747772,
0.08243610709905624,
-0.36026400327682495,
0.1608744114637375,
-0.2143549770116806,
-0.8188477754592896,
-0.5099489092826843,
0.21110810339450836,
-0.37655964493751526,
-0.24808602035045624,
-0.07236390560865402,
-0.713985025882721,
-0.5785175561904907,
-0.48683008551597595,
0.7655168175697327,
-0.297504186630249,
-0.7260401248931885,
0.26842349767684937,
-0.8307409286499023,
-0.1461029052734375,
0.10069338232278824,
-0.7386264801025391,
0.26762714982032776,
0.6515079736709595,
0.9242624640464783,
0.01716017536818981,
0.06523293256759644,
-0.521311342716217,
0.44676610827445984,
0.04970049858093262,
0.6888970732688904,
-0.3411738872528076,
-0.8230781555175781,
-0.4512450695037842,
-0.4747821092605591,
0.11668632179498672,
-0.6205037832260132,
0.7673216462135315,
-0.2271658182144165,
-0.20082701742649078,
-0.3265521228313446,
-0.44543078541755676,
-0.08532463014125824,
-0.4686603844165802,
-0.45879095792770386,
0.9792112112045288,
-0.21785013377666473,
-0.6910574436187744,
0.9917163848876953,
-0.7282083630561829,
-0.5738575458526611,
-0.06749878078699112,
-0.2820335924625397,
-0.48630619049072266,
0.3365691304206848,
0.4233667552471161,
0.319861501455307,
-0.04133306443691254,
0.6395145654678345,
-0.46191149950027466,
-0.2750670909881592,
-0.18127696216106415,
-0.7383798956871033,
0.7249205112457275,
0.5048326849937439,
-0.48296359181404114,
-0.3651394248008728,
-0.7489367127418518,
-0.30533072352409363,
-0.07145574688911438,
-0.31744781136512756,
-0.7145226001739502,
0.15901723504066467,
0.19433185458183289,
0.09095722436904907,
0.1916084885597229,
-0.7685315012931824,
-0.08130355924367905,
0.24954797327518463,
0.4662349224090576,
0.7231174111366272,
0.3220316767692566,
0.23605340719223022,
-0.12841041386127472,
0.09823784977197647,
0.38115987181663513,
-0.015989096835255623,
-0.1045604720711708,
-0.2454463690519333,
-0.20552349090576172,
-0.37533026933670044,
0.11893855780363083,
0.35877037048339844,
-0.43367984890937805,
0.42570605874061584,
0.1559772491455078,
-0.24613326787948608,
-0.2273818701505661,
0.04517214372754097,
0.23565427958965302,
0.5566815137863159,
0.37578102946281433,
0.06208016723394394,
-0.8635319471359253,
-0.5443869233131409,
-0.1957719624042511,
-0.3323398232460022,
-0.24178990721702576,
0.23985224962234497,
0.10487058013677597,
0.09976156800985336,
0.8691901564598083,
-0.8044307827949524,
-0.5701800584793091,
0.05190618708729744,
0.37181326746940613,
0.22420634329319,
0.35222864151000977,
0.7980169653892517,
-0.8911781311035156,
-0.24266602098941803,
0.11902021616697311,
-0.7291024327278137,
-0.490840882062912,
-0.10998539626598358,
0.2880440354347229,
0.0355520136654377,
0.5879271030426025,
-0.057443346828222275,
0.4072309732437134,
0.3178296685218811,
-0.5592904090881348,
0.3078869879245758,
-0.14496609568595886,
0.3199971914291382,
-1.0512874126434326,
-0.04010460898280144,
0.18826213479042053,
-0.08747141808271408,
-0.595618724822998,
-0.4190111756324768,
0.06839828938245773,
-0.19313573837280273,
-0.3856624960899353,
0.2328953742980957,
-0.28705382347106934,
-0.23513656854629517,
-0.40674373507499695,
0.17844048142433167,
0.31214267015457153,
0.32926470041275024,
0.4800443947315216,
0.4049082398414612,
0.4478444755077362,
-0.493195116519928,
0.39606547355651855,
-0.23687848448753357,
-0.3257291615009308,
0.8503022789955139,
-0.62466961145401,
0.18111464381217957,
0.18327808380126953,
0.1337222009897232,
-0.8183485269546509,
0.14375534653663635,
-0.45434948801994324,
-0.2912854254245758,
0.4159137010574341,
-0.5291218757629395,
-0.28732043504714966,
-0.5013901591300964,
-0.08314421027898788,
0.49708232283592224,
0.6118781566619873,
-1.1531314849853516,
0.5313146710395813,
0.8338389992713928,
-0.19548840820789337,
-0.12704190611839294,
-0.6257651448249817,
-0.23769842088222504,
-0.643474817276001,
-0.7786754369735718,
0.3552447259426117,
0.05192909762263298,
-0.22343730926513672,
0.07154066860675812,
-0.7018454074859619,
-0.29693713784217834,
0.2993658185005188,
0.23354090750217438,
-0.03571775555610657,
-0.29845163226127625,
0.27287670969963074,
0.49250754714012146,
-0.1133689284324646,
-0.052299678325653076,
-0.7385129928588867,
0.1676650196313858,
0.27256500720977783,
-0.6518523693084717,
-0.7837638854980469,
0.22738805413246155,
0.6451284885406494,
0.12538041174411774,
0.18216484785079956,
0.7575411200523376,
-0.5726919174194336,
-0.3943801820278168,
-0.7366757392883301,
-0.4984520673751831,
-0.5041844844818115,
0.3759858012199402,
-0.7173205614089966,
-0.6153336763381958,
0.7067607641220093,
-0.3228651285171509,
0.011934446170926094,
0.20373648405075073,
0.19101063907146454,
-0.31503355503082275,
0.943317174911499,
0.22567465901374817,
0.045421719551086426,
0.4896734356880188,
-0.21533794701099396,
-0.061604928225278854,
-0.9153594970703125,
-0.3070138096809387,
-0.5431874394416809,
-0.6140043139457703,
0.18932472169399261,
-0.2902638018131256,
0.7719120979309082,
0.16362223029136658,
0.002553089987486601,
0.12313823401927948,
-0.5742269158363342,
0.44807887077331543,
0.6237568855285645,
0.2689305543899536,
0.42512595653533936,
-0.08393852412700653,
-0.22859716415405273,
-0.0930495411157608,
-0.4239077866077423,
-0.10776861011981964,
1.193809151649475,
0.3401281535625458,
0.5668684840202332,
-0.02939748391509056,
1.0903910398483276,
0.372713178396225,
-0.7880589365959167,
-0.36576929688453674,
0.21704384684562683,
-0.1703745573759079,
-0.47852906584739685,
-0.4927150011062622,
-0.21478873491287231,
-0.4173378646373749,
0.5018962025642395,
0.1106213852763176,
-0.5902377963066101,
0.6825680732727051,
0.01709662936627865,
-0.6934013366699219,
0.6220844388008118,
-0.979108452796936,
0.6191723346710205,
-0.24238498508930206,
-0.23643456399440765,
-0.5239976048469543,
-0.05148954689502716,
0.25066903233528137,
-0.36040887236595154,
0.24857591092586517,
-0.23067089915275574,
0.18936973810195923,
1.132748007774353,
-0.4566667079925537,
0.6632779240608215,
-1.01287043094635,
-0.11412429064512253,
0.5870595574378967,
-0.07970437407493591,
0.45454132556915283,
0.5206112265586853,
-0.0834108516573906,
0.007043940015137196,
0.4127528667449951,
0.03873852640390396,
-0.49153411388397217,
0.8071549534797668,
-0.7872505784034729,
-0.6256272792816162,
-0.2068902552127838,
-0.34866026043891907,
-0.08929365873336792,
-0.04178265482187271,
0.003460453823208809,
0.7775933146476746,
-0.26738110184669495,
0.2738490700721741,
0.7880738377571106,
0.004597892984747887,
0.7867663502693176,
0.6818704009056091,
0.013169114477932453,
-0.08139797300100327,
0.7314755916595459,
0.34825655817985535,
-0.05595748499035835,
0.17776277661323547,
0.2949364483356476,
-0.5218964219093323,
-0.6991615295410156,
-0.40436840057373047,
-0.2568216919898987,
-0.4681757390499115,
-0.10256600379943848,
-0.9067646861076355,
0.02031685598194599,
-0.5708459615707397,
-0.10657897591590881,
-0.7008197903633118,
-0.6991003155708313,
-0.5782093405723572,
-0.37324750423431396,
0.3667198717594147,
0.5106323957443237,
-0.6806649565696716,
-0.023864667862653732,
-0.5566003322601318,
0.7581740617752075,
0.6137282252311707,
0.117589071393013,
-0.28622081875801086,
-0.7175413370132446,
-0.06875558197498322,
0.2273857146501541,
-0.36002352833747864,
-0.8220324516296387,
0.07707691937685013,
0.5295328497886658,
0.804832398891449,
0.8012323379516602,
0.5346868634223938,
0.674056887626648,
-0.11994664371013641,
0.6111547946929932,
0.2751346230506897,
-0.9785370826721191,
0.9405689835548401,
-0.10616409778594971,
0.3533921241760254,
0.5539761781692505,
0.029093865305185318,
-0.5280229449272156,
-0.1144181415438652,
-0.4128107726573944,
-0.7641808390617371,
0.852863609790802,
-0.27693578600883484,
-0.26468217372894287,
0.21216191351413727,
0.05063774809241295,
0.27866771817207336,
0.006662691943347454,
-0.24615880846977234,
-0.11087051033973694,
-0.24363772571086884,
-0.17742155492305756,
0.12517480552196503,
-0.2681886851787567,
-0.17841850221157074,
-0.23974618315696716,
0.5519554018974304,
0.08188822865486145,
-0.010003187693655491,
0.19131247699260712,
-0.11790309846401215,
0.09616724401712418,
0.20611853897571564,
0.34641793370246887,
0.4295845329761505,
-0.22355177998542786,
0.3499739170074463,
0.38131219148635864,
-0.7111182808876038,
0.34030666947364807,
0.1360781341791153,
0.03646450489759445,
0.058859847486019135,
-0.022344397380948067,
0.7344812154769897,
0.46093428134918213,
-0.22622719407081604,
0.5805575251579285,
-0.04347831383347511,
-0.25922027230262756,
-0.3832685649394989,
0.05283401161432266,
0.35344019532203674,
0.6954385042190552,
0.7583625912666321,
-0.08796411007642746,
0.5711522102355957,
-0.4757091701030731,
0.5395318269729614,
0.17565803229808807,
-0.44049960374832153,
-0.41555508971214294,
0.8270211815834045,
0.4811968207359314,
0.1049034520983696,
0.42233794927597046,
-0.2526320815086365,
-0.3940947949886322,
0.8945851922035217,
0.48815885186195374,
1.1107815504074097,
-0.446530282497406,
0.04013435170054436,
0.2642431855201721,
-0.08819811046123505,
0.1635609120130539,
0.47439295053482056,
-0.6644189953804016,
-0.5302807092666626,
0.008456991985440254,
-0.9192737340927124,
-0.24156519770622253,
0.06866882741451263,
-0.7806251645088196,
0.41368916630744934,
-0.3989468216896057,
-0.41515180468559265,
0.10541412234306335,
0.051612526178359985,
-0.5069982409477234,
-0.10236618667840958,
0.4206966161727905,
0.6530826091766357,
-1.0620074272155762,
0.9731389284133911,
0.5945609211921692,
0.019738709554076195,
-0.7931880950927734,
-0.14750537276268005,
0.534060001373291,
-0.2621719241142273,
0.6042661070823669,
-0.23485340178012848,
-0.04025569558143616,
-0.012692178599536419,
0.38997116684913635,
-0.4191768765449524,
1.453762412071228,
0.35811278223991394,
-0.9077709913253784,
0.10531380772590637,
-0.16586677730083466,
0.25964662432670593,
-0.12234465777873993,
0.21726267039775848,
0.7792452573776245,
0.6134522557258606,
0.5037017464637756,
-1.1383864879608154,
-0.31154143810272217,
-0.09186355024576187,
-0.19244001805782318,
0.2965347468852997,
-0.23454587161540985,
0.3310384750366211,
-0.45195257663726807,
-0.5415354371070862,
-0.6273754835128784,
0.6460636854171753,
0.2707615792751312,
1.0351849794387817,
0.581432580947876,
0.842271089553833,
0.9726445078849792,
-0.44271746277809143,
0.40554529428482056,
-0.17789490520954132,
0.1565992385149002,
1.2212042808532715,
-0.2856035530567169,
0.5787118077278137,
0.552924633026123,
-0.4886682331562042,
0.17542105913162231,
0.5495417714118958,
0.28782162070274353,
1.0861761569976807,
-0.032034732401371,
-0.7866869568824768,
-0.16287113726139069,
-0.06274917721748352,
-0.7709709405899048,
0.4670554995536804,
0.36998409032821655,
0.05001850053668022,
-0.16497811675071716,
0.6059617400169373,
-0.35145026445388794,
-0.08605027198791504,
-0.25625988841056824,
1.1442269086837769,
0.20243248343467712,
-0.20680470764636993,
-0.02000962756574154,
-0.33106639981269836,
0.7904931902885437,
-0.30800190567970276,
0.0032910641748458147,
-0.13613583147525787,
0.22174449265003204,
-0.16797344386577606,
-0.7211881279945374,
0.4709687829017639,
-0.17347562313079834,
-0.31109169125556946,
-0.18950344622135162,
0.7693443894386292,
-0.49401283264160156,
-0.21483418345451355,
0.5365591645240784,
0.22944746911525726,
-0.05529041960835457,
-0.18811877071857452,
-0.109994076192379,
0.35375967621803284,
-0.06862807273864746,
-0.14572028815746307,
0.3194018602371216,
0.7418104410171509,
0.31331783533096313,
0.230568990111351,
0.5462427735328674,
0.12680990993976593,
0.15346433222293854,
0.27166759967803955,
0.7312557101249695,
-0.2469950169324875,
-0.9646868705749512,
-0.6122822165489197,
0.3361886441707611,
-0.12345394492149353,
-0.019256211817264557,
0.3951402008533478,
0.6439114809036255,
0.8537981510162354,
0.0345948301255703,
0.9676475524902344,
0.0667065903544426,
0.5910754799842834,
-0.45075035095214844,
0.7483332753181458,
-0.4514218270778656,
0.6667459607124329,
-0.303682804107666,
-0.734494686126709,
0.10183121263980865,
0.3024633228778839,
-0.0942750871181488,
-0.08564095944166183,
0.5198302865028381,
0.48773688077926636,
-0.38630107045173645,
0.6300026178359985,
0.5188284516334534,
-0.009112711064517498,
0.32378676533699036,
0.7775114178657532,
0.7888278961181641,
-0.2269359976053238,
0.3892938196659088,
-0.5411452651023865,
-0.2508315443992615,
-0.20548638701438904,
-0.6667821407318115,
-0.5983217358589172,
-0.965576708316803,
-0.7878832817077637,
0.19505392014980316,
0.35436704754829407,
0.6616843342781067,
0.8106197714805603,
-0.8194024562835693,
-0.12135665863752365,
0.020347770303487778,
0.21213530004024506,
-0.2587062418460846,
-0.20072610676288605,
0.48668092489242554,
-0.09842725843191147,
-0.7422541975975037,
0.9071663022041321,
0.40572938323020935,
0.11917713284492493,
0.1347101926803589,
-0.13369283080101013,
-0.11362937837839127,
-0.1617119014263153,
0.3693174123764038,
0.20768190920352936,
-0.3571191430091858,
-0.5372348427772522,
-0.3876606523990631,
0.07110710442066193,
-0.27463507652282715,
0.8452399373054504,
-0.9161375761032104,
0.6449809074401855,
0.717616081237793,
0.2716332674026489,
0.8545519113540649,
-0.27620813250541687,
0.44606658816337585,
-0.7975074648857117,
0.4048548936843872,
0.15519872307777405,
0.38962364196777344,
-0.10345284640789032,
-0.36357590556144714,
0.4592137336730957,
0.48351263999938965,
-0.49065303802490234,
-1.0308763980865479,
0.014698577113449574,
-0.8524207472801208,
-0.4470485746860504,
0.8946542143821716,
-0.23329266905784607,
0.2622573673725128,
-0.44991713762283325,
-0.04309261962771416,
0.5499812960624695,
-0.4972810447216034,
0.5435177087783813,
0.2828115224838257,
-0.19969213008880615,
-0.010413660667836666,
-0.20075108110904694,
0.5366575121879578,
-0.10509815812110901,
-0.32702192664146423,
-0.14272159337997437,
0.5610272884368896,
0.24825100600719452,
0.12704779207706451,
0.5958155989646912,
-0.21657441556453705,
0.6486716270446777,
0.45857352018356323,
0.04177818074822426,
-0.606013834476471,
-0.6059060096740723,
-0.22484976053237915,
0.3528425395488739,
-0.18252582848072052,
-0.383522629737854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02764v1 | List-aware Reranking-Truncation Joint Model for Search and Retrieval-augmented Generation | 2024-02-05T06:52:53 | 2024-02-05T06:52:53 | Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Jun Xu, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The results of information retrieval (IR) are usually presented in the form
of a ranked list of candidate documents, such as web search for humans and
retrieval-augmented generation for large language models (LLMs). List-aware
retrieval aims to capture the list-level contextual features to return a better
list, mainly including reranking and truncation. Reranking finely re-scores the
documents in the list. Truncation dynamically determines the cut-off point of
the ranked list to achieve the trade-off between overall relevance and avoiding
misinformation from irrelevant documents. Previous studies treat them as two
separate tasks and model them separately. However, the separation is not
optimal. First, it is hard to share the contextual information of the ranking
list between the two tasks. Second, the separate pipeline usually meets the
error accumulation problem, where the small error from the reranking stage can
largely affect the truncation stage. To solve these problems, we propose a
Reranking-Truncation joint model (GenRT) that can perform the two tasks
concurrently. GenRT integrates reranking and truncation via generative paradigm
based on encoder-decoder architecture. We also design the novel loss functions
for joint optimization to make the model learn both tasks. Sharing parameters
by the joint model is conducive to making full use of the common modeling
information of the two tasks. Besides, the two tasks are performed concurrently
and co-optimized to solve the error accumulation problem between separate
stages. Experiments on public learning-to-rank benchmarks and open-domain Q\&A
tasks show that our method achieves SOTA performance on both reranking and
truncation tasks for web search and retrieval-augmented LLMs. | [
-0.428320974111557,
-0.8202807307243347,
0.20113416016101837,
-0.01051340438425541,
-0.2433491051197052,
0.4088689088821411,
-0.26122552156448364,
-0.534254252910614,
0.31819576025009155,
0.4145698845386505,
-0.5496866106987,
-0.3343362808227539,
-0.5476963520050049,
-0.015301773324608803,
-0.4941088557243347,
0.920993983745575,
0.0003850397770293057,
-0.39403635263442993,
-0.5423262715339661,
-0.034774329513311386,
-0.6027360558509827,
-0.4906105399131775,
-0.5663612484931946,
-0.10432814806699753,
0.4297599196434021,
0.6066333651542664,
0.6875007152557373,
0.603965699672699,
0.6986724734306335,
0.1908617913722992,
-0.10425503551959991,
0.38368287682533264,
-0.7908383011817932,
0.5240386128425598,
-0.11112474650144577,
-0.3147640824317932,
-0.4460020959377289,
0.05948009341955185,
0.8651958703994751,
0.6534485220909119,
-0.2685949504375458,
0.43312495946884155,
0.37913185358047485,
0.6199902296066284,
-0.8061325550079346,
-0.18613098561763763,
-0.4614114463329315,
-0.028714701533317566,
-0.26899614930152893,
-0.4165414571762085,
-0.4287455677986145,
-0.3592633008956909,
0.1464821845293045,
-0.7013430595397949,
0.34726306796073914,
0.04849168285727501,
0.9197248816490173,
0.20227406919002533,
-0.24129176139831543,
0.16237159073352814,
-0.8597111701965332,
0.603322446346283,
-0.37809011340141296,
0.6784736514091492,
0.34357088804244995,
0.11525354534387589,
-0.07706982642412186,
-0.6738936901092529,
-0.2533223330974579,
-0.08189507573843002,
0.04952075704932213,
0.16585317254066467,
0.1259201169013977,
-0.08733652532100677,
0.28143829107284546,
0.3573187291622162,
-0.6652771830558777,
-0.06255851686000824,
-0.37840718030929565,
0.03321295231580734,
0.45191535353660583,
-0.19257523119449615,
0.3355165123939514,
-0.1960904598236084,
-0.48810917139053345,
-0.2142174243927002,
-0.8877720236778259,
-0.01841627061367035,
0.2624794840812683,
0.3068162202835083,
0.17378240823745728,
0.5438998937606812,
-0.20964539051055908,
0.5791844129562378,
0.039428479969501495,
-0.017028549686074257,
0.02808244898915291,
-0.1851932406425476,
-0.16006948053836823,
-0.15626956522464752,
0.5062571167945862,
0.3057420253753662,
0.04826488345861435,
-0.33821117877960205,
-0.25880569219589233,
-0.08004800975322723,
0.27601802349090576,
-0.5469297766685486,
-0.022882860153913498,
0.003220464801415801,
-0.4288468360900879,
-0.24883386492729187,
0.08518988639116287,
-0.7041364908218384,
-0.008431030437350273,
-0.013965481892228127,
0.8850616812705994,
-0.29006344079971313,
-0.251796692609787,
-0.11148136854171753,
-0.10303935408592224,
-0.17695888876914978,
0.13487307727336884,
-0.5941934585571289,
0.3483624756336212,
0.6327515244483948,
0.7030548453330994,
-0.06944230198860168,
-0.239779531955719,
-0.8207108378410339,
0.4626398980617523,
-0.04447014257311821,
0.6151804327964783,
-0.7209944725036621,
-0.44417211413383484,
-0.04993818700313568,
-0.33366161584854126,
-0.25678643584251404,
-0.5643797516822815,
0.4021081030368805,
-0.8423581719398499,
0.2795778810977936,
-0.17596499621868134,
-0.6959467530250549,
-0.17193114757537842,
0.3907056450843811,
-0.8670517802238464,
1.0575041770935059,
0.1256742775440216,
-0.8138149976730347,
0.44681963324546814,
-0.5957404375076294,
-0.3314080238342285,
0.22960862517356873,
0.031251706182956696,
-0.6321305632591248,
-0.1309836506843567,
0.1019122526049614,
0.19982169568538666,
-0.39310383796691895,
0.30051085352897644,
-0.06171255558729172,
-0.5714560151100159,
-0.21079735457897186,
-0.23601140081882477,
0.4132029712200165,
0.1977829486131668,
-0.17577038705348969,
0.09125527739524841,
-0.4248214662075043,
0.14897115528583527,
0.13389615714550018,
-0.6852262020111084,
-0.48304396867752075,
0.004370847716927528,
-0.10583093762397766,
0.13877998292446136,
0.3660385012626648,
-0.36032500863075256,
0.467217355966568,
-0.3242155611515045,
0.2179410457611084,
0.4819909930229187,
0.2108834683895111,
0.3738914728164673,
-0.5047026872634888,
0.6175762414932251,
-0.194642573595047,
0.30218255519866943,
0.34390825033187866,
-0.27491387724876404,
-0.8025270104408264,
-0.0656382218003273,
0.701948881149292,
0.5292463302612305,
-0.7476717233657837,
0.3826431632041931,
-0.5289631485939026,
-0.43178534507751465,
-0.5994074940681458,
0.07894410192966461,
0.48497575521469116,
0.14850884675979614,
0.2389761209487915,
-0.37293311953544617,
-0.694232702255249,
-0.5734544992446899,
-0.40690603852272034,
-0.01673690602183342,
0.22129078209400177,
0.055729132145643234,
0.19978389143943787,
-0.0116435457020998,
0.7733805179595947,
-0.3024948537349701,
-0.35142332315444946,
-0.4596541225910187,
0.18619190156459808,
-0.06204658001661301,
0.5247689485549927,
0.013077633455395699,
-1.0419590473175049,
-0.43413838744163513,
-0.2540290355682373,
-0.6351810693740845,
0.20057766139507294,
0.10993897914886475,
-0.1931215524673462,
0.10155113786458969,
0.30608630180358887,
-0.573922336101532,
0.5399882197380066,
0.23003315925598145,
-0.0943773165345192,
0.40565022826194763,
-0.29882386326789856,
0.34957557916641235,
-0.9437438249588013,
0.2092834860086441,
-0.1345190852880478,
-0.5279849171638489,
-0.6572956442832947,
0.42006468772888184,
-0.06699033826589584,
-0.09270220994949341,
-0.21516989171504974,
0.2093585878610611,
-0.514410138130188,
-0.31197237968444824,
-0.11852674186229706,
0.36289358139038086,
0.2622879445552826,
0.38911035656929016,
-0.07170463353395462,
0.7605482339859009,
0.13791252672672272,
-0.7345095276832581,
-0.08708957582712173,
0.35113444924354553,
-0.2652565538883209,
-0.12505066394805908,
-0.37326717376708984,
0.0262241642922163,
-0.08495623618364334,
0.06689094007015228,
-0.6294704079627991,
0.058917608112096786,
0.2540390193462372,
-0.41310256719589233,
0.4197227954864502,
-0.16369175910949707,
-0.5628548860549927,
-0.378073513507843,
-0.37497350573539734,
0.7632396221160889,
0.23919758200645447,
-0.4960309565067291,
0.28692421317100525,
0.4911179840564728,
-0.12938587367534637,
-0.7862139940261841,
-0.2511386275291443,
-0.12221615016460419,
-0.16043512523174286,
-0.5542718172073364,
0.6460379958152771,
-0.00641325069591403,
0.058382514864206314,
0.14505736529827118,
-0.15954318642616272,
0.11371222138404846,
-0.02529231831431389,
0.18314151465892792,
0.29507166147232056,
0.2711593508720398,
0.2626516819000244,
-0.06637806445360184,
0.0024847802706062794,
-0.3109012544155121,
-0.12763577699661255,
0.6582810878753662,
0.11104650795459747,
-0.3587457835674286,
-0.20193716883659363,
0.555363118648529,
0.4655347168445587,
-0.5663238763809204,
0.7861948013305664,
0.47814127802848816,
-0.39676329493522644,
0.009643212892115116,
-0.7014623284339905,
-0.20624470710754395,
-0.4275658130645752,
0.2458599954843521,
-0.6220740079879761,
-1.0300601720809937,
0.4855630397796631,
-0.07561678439378738,
0.2153811901807785,
0.48254114389419556,
0.28026360273361206,
-0.06294061988592148,
0.9492484927177429,
0.7126624584197998,
0.054234448820352554,
0.5849649906158447,
-0.6636064648628235,
0.3524048924446106,
-0.9198617935180664,
-0.2173241227865219,
-0.3816840350627899,
-0.523407518863678,
-0.7307921648025513,
-0.42829227447509766,
0.43795543909072876,
0.36424756050109863,
-0.1834808737039566,
0.12045075744390488,
-0.7529376149177551,
0.3307484984397888,
0.9067978858947754,
0.2863728702068329,
0.2979658544063568,
0.27765363454818726,
-0.26177212595939636,
-0.0180470272898674,
-0.8354071974754333,
-0.15492050349712372,
1.123093843460083,
0.05278205871582031,
0.5394484400749207,
0.3160751163959503,
0.9076938033103943,
0.45362934470176697,
-0.006406294647604227,
-0.511193573474884,
0.6381326913833618,
-0.3463703691959381,
-0.48243799805641174,
-0.4092961251735687,
-0.5328426957130432,
-0.899021327495575,
0.2052648663520813,
-0.23883748054504395,
-0.6110644936561584,
0.22459498047828674,
0.008403899148106575,
-0.34380587935447693,
0.5131184458732605,
-0.42661723494529724,
0.735072135925293,
0.1904323250055313,
-0.5585154294967651,
-0.4535628855228424,
-0.7036177515983582,
0.4657684564590454,
0.2543462812900543,
0.10595162212848663,
0.09785593301057816,
0.13998040556907654,
1.1319042444229126,
-0.3357216417789459,
0.4363151788711548,
-0.2586398720741272,
0.28336474299430847,
0.32868441939353943,
0.27123650908470154,
0.7361489534378052,
-0.1233656108379364,
-0.029822679236531258,
-0.2252708375453949,
0.012933257035911083,
-0.17762792110443115,
-0.626851499080658,
0.6077457666397095,
-0.8465155959129333,
-0.8874619007110596,
-0.36551299691200256,
-0.5514875650405884,
-0.0345291830599308,
0.1956503838300705,
0.32794883847236633,
0.41712114214897156,
-0.06733698397874832,
0.05268795043230057,
0.6148375868797302,
-0.08344843238592148,
0.21749965846538544,
0.3688247501850128,
-0.25555670261383057,
-0.18151085078716278,
1.1029964685440063,
0.3453042507171631,
0.3547346591949463,
0.7655718922615051,
-0.009241058491170406,
-0.3041952848434448,
-0.435146301984787,
-0.049284808337688446,
0.3143279254436493,
-0.5286885499954224,
-0.2850095331668854,
-0.508173942565918,
-0.6000356674194336,
-0.5126987099647522,
0.10957705229520798,
-0.27021560072898865,
-0.6874927878379822,
-0.015035603195428848,
-0.09945306181907654,
0.16348084807395935,
0.680330753326416,
-0.2929793894290924,
0.06000712141394615,
-0.8023803234100342,
0.3822399377822876,
0.2055847942829132,
0.4166075885295868,
0.20292827486991882,
-0.37270790338516235,
-0.39346450567245483,
-0.035208992660045624,
-0.37703168392181396,
-0.7402009963989258,
0.48806729912757874,
0.22232690453529358,
0.5380175113677979,
0.2535158395767212,
0.20301954448223114,
0.8853067755699158,
-0.24990685284137726,
0.4378341734409332,
0.01278830599039793,
-0.7413227558135986,
0.6966747045516968,
-0.1512327641248703,
0.04353050887584686,
0.6087563037872314,
0.15926741063594818,
-0.6618034243583679,
-0.5552507042884827,
-0.5710468292236328,
-1.0534032583236694,
0.6646513342857361,
0.20443518459796906,
-0.48288577795028687,
-0.013390530832111835,
0.4116889238357544,
0.15005309879779816,
0.10761938244104385,
-0.694366455078125,
-0.21390202641487122,
0.05707811564207077,
-0.06886552274227142,
0.15387454628944397,
-0.6884101033210754,
-0.10483682155609131,
-0.19858884811401367,
0.8201372027397156,
0.3470776677131653,
0.3966224491596222,
0.23960740864276886,
-0.4130975306034088,
-0.402150422334671,
0.43334832787513733,
0.4925366938114166,
0.5878872871398926,
-0.5650728940963745,
0.07293210178613663,
-0.18662989139556885,
-0.4562252461910248,
0.3375704288482666,
0.12764592468738556,
-0.3411444127559662,
-0.06499581784009933,
0.1247604563832283,
0.5904874205589294,
0.24229305982589722,
-0.5550904273986816,
0.3612431287765503,
-0.0908435806632042,
-0.21274307370185852,
-0.14617152512073517,
0.004297296516597271,
-0.04608886316418648,
0.1848604679107666,
0.46918347477912903,
0.10665508359670639,
0.25922292470932007,
-0.2799522578716278,
0.4824877083301544,
0.48551225662231445,
-0.09196742624044418,
-0.03380178287625313,
0.7213412523269653,
0.30884867906570435,
-0.31451416015625,
0.7137892246246338,
-0.2594766914844513,
-0.5773153901100159,
0.34020182490348816,
0.4823911190032959,
0.6800094246864319,
-0.2501908242702484,
0.20684407651424408,
0.3774612545967102,
0.16157978773117065,
-0.1640309989452362,
0.2831907570362091,
-0.14526037871837616,
-0.5868255496025085,
-0.47827020287513733,
-0.5234325528144836,
-0.2846587002277374,
0.017785726115107536,
-0.8829371929168701,
0.07511817663908005,
-0.26666826009750366,
-0.2746855616569519,
-0.3335300087928772,
0.4176797866821289,
-0.7090348601341248,
0.14568501710891724,
-0.17318414151668549,
0.6652585864067078,
-0.5035676956176758,
0.7070782780647278,
0.5497080087661743,
-0.5573241710662842,
-0.8331679701805115,
0.147561714053154,
-0.3238566219806671,
-0.5797836780548096,
0.7739705443382263,
0.20831717550754547,
-0.06897126138210297,
0.3359796702861786,
0.009156362153589725,
-1.0984450578689575,
1.1766397953033447,
0.2859111726284027,
-0.8183198571205139,
-0.34616273641586304,
-0.03377411514520645,
-0.006129674147814512,
-0.2640949487686157,
0.20271039009094238,
0.33133453130722046,
0.4109375774860382,
0.03849894553422928,
-0.9619231820106506,
0.1594838798046112,
-0.2085069715976715,
-0.05284281447529793,
0.4246201515197754,
-0.782360315322876,
0.7011966109275818,
-0.2058531939983368,
-0.5167590975761414,
0.08279255032539368,
0.5460721254348755,
0.41177988052368164,
0.2693415880203247,
0.7407461404800415,
0.8339661359786987,
0.6780620217323303,
0.07513150572776794,
0.8936514854431152,
-0.305605947971344,
0.4017646312713623,
1.095528483390808,
-0.185556560754776,
1.1174615621566772,
0.32990527153015137,
-0.11943726986646652,
0.40392985939979553,
0.7237804532051086,
0.2451498955488205,
0.6241886615753174,
0.04659971594810486,
-0.43741610646247864,
-0.4142639935016632,
-0.2007371187210083,
-0.48118826746940613,
0.41366034746170044,
0.3457675278186798,
-0.2823130488395691,
-0.2464277297258377,
0.12974339723587036,
-0.2502553164958954,
0.04408860206604004,
-0.130801722407341,
0.712321400642395,
-0.19553329050540924,
-0.7331530451774597,
0.5654661059379578,
0.12968172132968903,
0.5606566667556763,
-0.27613556385040283,
-0.1268804967403412,
-0.12201488018035889,
-0.003404803341254592,
-0.04712235555052757,
-0.5429701805114746,
0.1537190079689026,
-0.08423374593257904,
-0.5557679533958435,
-0.25921639800071716,
0.8383493423461914,
-0.6431604623794556,
-0.5083463788032532,
0.38496750593185425,
0.7607817053794861,
0.21606414020061493,
0.06246788427233696,
-0.5367525219917297,
0.1961124688386917,
0.0916329100728035,
-0.23516468703746796,
0.428171843290329,
0.05453496053814888,
-0.2237473875284195,
0.9080905318260193,
0.5259379148483276,
0.19070015847682953,
0.12101604044437408,
0.423601359128952,
0.8454383015632629,
-0.6144424080848694,
-0.6025156378746033,
-0.506681501865387,
0.24684622883796692,
-0.03774028271436691,
0.3134378492832184,
0.39710167050361633,
0.6548058986663818,
0.7146635055541992,
0.2402368187904358,
0.7147018909454346,
-0.10216100513935089,
0.9182752966880798,
-0.29528188705444336,
0.7656301856040955,
-0.8409058451652527,
0.47988516092300415,
-0.05356181412935257,
-0.9655860662460327,
-0.29899662733078003,
0.3408907651901245,
-0.17681953310966492,
0.22387100756168365,
0.44500231742858887,
0.6436820030212402,
0.1161208525300026,
-0.3130579888820648,
0.3843976855278015,
0.0036668777465820312,
0.3336545526981354,
0.6586149334907532,
0.6387094259262085,
-0.6154587268829346,
0.8641642332077026,
-0.2342696636915207,
0.011861331760883331,
-0.5006688833236694,
-0.3003195822238922,
-0.44854727387428284,
-0.5786207318305969,
-0.4184575080871582,
-0.1934153437614441,
0.5245862007141113,
0.6885479092597961,
0.677929699420929,
-0.40703901648521423,
-0.1397629827260971,
-0.021329939365386963,
0.4474770128726959,
-0.5364683866500854,
-0.31822696328163147,
0.5371330380439758,
-0.1880611777305603,
-0.6713712811470032,
0.3216550648212433,
0.22452625632286072,
-0.131343275308609,
-0.17303065955638885,
-0.09694820642471313,
-0.6765596866607666,
-0.33238208293914795,
0.4003435969352722,
0.2874393165111542,
-0.7573967576026917,
-0.4476063847541809,
-0.1888577789068222,
-0.07635000348091125,
-0.006491211708635092,
0.7297945618629456,
-1.0783443450927734,
0.5637650489807129,
0.5342559814453125,
0.4707794189453125,
0.4713038206100464,
0.3394681513309479,
0.6744657754898071,
-1.1198384761810303,
0.006522435694932938,
0.1347731500864029,
0.089647576212883,
0.3639349341392517,
-0.569673478603363,
0.5668960809707642,
0.21561239659786224,
-0.6400800347328186,
-0.9128416180610657,
0.06756829470396042,
-0.8875173330307007,
-0.15758013725280762,
0.7830752730369568,
-0.06797628849744797,
-0.034129440784454346,
0.051465462893247604,
0.2346067726612091,
0.7222970128059387,
-0.3482178747653961,
0.6887397766113281,
0.4188488721847534,
-0.008917637169361115,
-0.5427544713020325,
-0.43876034021377563,
0.4713186025619507,
0.44850897789001465,
-0.4533408582210541,
0.0020629549399018288,
0.22036215662956238,
0.2627812325954437,
0.14190228283405304,
0.5253683924674988,
0.15637214481830597,
0.3962608575820923,
-0.1474766582250595,
0.22545118629932404,
-0.22935666143894196,
-0.39633122086524963,
0.18888501822948456,
0.4943419396877289,
0.35913264751434326,
-0.5340656638145447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06147v2 | DeAL: Decoding-time Alignment for Large Language Models | 2024-02-05T06:12:29 | 2024-02-21T02:25:32 | James Y. Huang, Sailik Sengupta, Daniele Bonadiman, Yi-an Lai, Arshit Gupta, Nikolaos Pappas, Saab Mansour, Katrin Kirchhoff, Dan Roth | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are nowadays expected to generate content
aligned with human preferences. Current work focuses on alignment at model
training time, through techniques such as Reinforcement Learning with Human
Feedback (RLHF). However, it is unclear if such methods are an effective choice
to teach alignment objectives to the model. First, the inability to incorporate
multiple, custom rewards and reliance on a model developer's view of universal
and static principles are key limitations. Second, the residual gaps in model
training and the reliability of such approaches are also questionable (e.g.
susceptibility to jail-breaking even after safety training). To address these,
we propose DeAL, a framework that allows the user to customize reward functions
and enables Decoding-time Alignment of LLMs (DeAL). At its core, we view
decoding as a heuristic-guided search process and facilitate the use of a wide
variety of alignment objectives. Our experiments with programmatic constraints
such as keyword and length constraints (studied widely in the pre-LLM era) and
abstract objectives such as harmlessness and helpfulness (proposed in the
post-LLM era) show that we can DeAL with fine-grained trade-offs, improve
adherence to alignment objectives, and address residual gaps in LLMs. Lastly,
while DeAL can be effectively paired with RLHF and prompting techniques, its
generality makes decoding slower, an optimization we leave for future work. | [
-0.002445189980790019,
-0.37356463074684143,
0.6266688108444214,
0.2446310818195343,
-0.3026670515537262,
0.2747795879840851,
-0.5307548642158508,
-0.33438509702682495,
0.1913800984621048,
0.35633572936058044,
-0.578758716583252,
-0.523409903049469,
-0.5687595009803772,
-0.10564174503087997,
-0.26028910279273987,
0.8808870315551758,
-0.20957589149475098,
-0.08401954919099808,
0.009439428336918354,
-0.031819917261600494,
-0.44504010677337646,
-0.5639970302581787,
-0.6328344941139221,
-0.5417832136154175,
0.7791861891746521,
0.35858649015426636,
0.8681647777557373,
1.1621559858322144,
0.537101686000824,
0.20803096890449524,
-0.14190642535686493,
0.13292641937732697,
-0.5852790474891663,
0.005262702237814665,
-0.29261037707328796,
-0.3334422707557678,
-0.38475117087364197,
-0.07219712436199188,
0.4805198013782501,
0.6751824617385864,
-0.6006020307540894,
-0.11450133472681046,
-0.0437873974442482,
0.5334410667419434,
-0.8018440008163452,
0.20280472934246063,
-0.5313411355018616,
0.1868455857038498,
-0.05620395764708519,
-0.4063130021095276,
-0.6215027570724487,
-0.24514305591583252,
-0.0726524218916893,
-0.7268918752670288,
-0.19243605434894562,
0.1502213031053543,
1.0991922616958618,
0.3431536555290222,
-0.4078906774520874,
-0.39048945903778076,
-0.572282612323761,
1.0204843282699585,
-0.9505764245986938,
0.39883309602737427,
0.3604028522968292,
0.2565288841724396,
-0.37794846296310425,
-0.2633975148200989,
-0.43099868297576904,
-0.05109948664903641,
-0.13484059274196625,
-0.0572088360786438,
0.19769860804080963,
0.20214307308197021,
0.20055897533893585,
0.32613059878349304,
-0.4736558198928833,
0.3925415873527527,
-0.00605758186429739,
-0.3664129078388214,
0.703465461730957,
0.40486109256744385,
0.2588392198085785,
-0.0025605831760913134,
-0.4267026484012604,
-0.14729242026805878,
-0.7005261778831482,
0.1876308172941208,
0.609800398349762,
0.3948541581630707,
-0.249714657664299,
0.6416164040565491,
-0.25200214982032776,
0.9022783637046814,
0.07378892600536346,
-0.29212796688079834,
-0.05974783003330231,
-0.27434173226356506,
0.0047484454698860645,
0.28823238611221313,
0.6602359414100647,
0.3841433823108673,
0.19864147901535034,
-0.4138089418411255,
-0.36286842823028564,
0.08250731974840164,
0.25450727343559265,
-0.6832223534584045,
0.04851231351494789,
0.20235575735569,
-0.38897356390953064,
-0.24822215735912323,
-0.02881798893213272,
-0.3328550159931183,
-0.15116533637046814,
-0.5617472529411316,
0.2435687929391861,
-0.2876652479171753,
-0.08043952286243439,
0.6090272068977356,
-0.023272553458809853,
0.6422722339630127,
0.23618173599243164,
-1.288083553314209,
0.14934773743152618,
0.9504206776618958,
0.6896830201148987,
-0.19025294482707977,
-0.43649834394454956,
-0.7956954836845398,
0.5858275294303894,
-0.30041050910949707,
0.5757436752319336,
-0.6039917469024658,
-0.29439598321914673,
0.043396130204200745,
-0.14322368800640106,
-0.007404637522995472,
-0.1368713229894638,
0.4188491106033325,
-0.6909090876579285,
0.09679990261793137,
-0.15585777163505554,
-0.759756326675415,
0.2490984946489334,
0.45003414154052734,
-0.495602011680603,
0.514643669128418,
0.15900476276874542,
-0.5012461543083191,
0.23551735281944275,
-0.30830398201942444,
-0.5817499756813049,
-0.07279854267835617,
-0.22665661573410034,
-0.38909912109375,
-0.024508001282811165,
0.309011846780777,
0.3137767016887665,
-0.18648570775985718,
0.6013749241828918,
-0.24144287407398224,
-0.6490878462791443,
0.591717541217804,
-0.3696703612804413,
0.5205042362213135,
0.419098824262619,
-0.35567864775657654,
0.14471298456192017,
-0.36791539192199707,
-0.0014266697689890862,
0.04564860463142395,
-0.7103476524353027,
-0.20359285175800323,
0.12203928828239441,
-0.06441543251276016,
-0.0031774083618074656,
0.41276490688323975,
-0.2998404800891876,
0.5537897348403931,
-0.5063199996948242,
0.5200494527816772,
0.7832311987876892,
-0.18814148008823395,
0.6315089464187622,
-0.4149475693702698,
0.7553914785385132,
-0.10817360132932663,
0.1226540207862854,
-0.21154627203941345,
-0.02025248482823372,
-0.5849547982215881,
-0.22631700336933136,
0.5730172991752625,
0.5136308670043945,
-0.48859596252441406,
0.5872185230255127,
-0.38085299730300903,
-0.07811205089092255,
-0.7797315716743469,
0.19482320547103882,
0.6806201934814453,
0.22417713701725006,
0.1772635579109192,
-0.14244796335697174,
-0.5436998605728149,
-0.8561918139457703,
-0.35813358426094055,
-0.05244677886366844,
0.03415866196155548,
0.11510942876338959,
0.10982771217823029,
-0.0846703052520752,
0.8570461869239807,
-0.4765734076499939,
-0.20315062999725342,
-0.2632482051849365,
0.07758523523807526,
0.24440337717533112,
0.34004995226860046,
0.1295129954814911,
-0.7399413585662842,
-0.4010315239429474,
0.09317266941070557,
-0.5625060796737671,
-0.04123310744762421,
-0.25471940636634827,
-0.14899632334709167,
0.46158361434936523,
0.61740642786026,
-0.5410756468772888,
0.2178201526403427,
0.7048852443695068,
-0.482930451631546,
0.2870030701160431,
-0.2301904410123825,
0.3227792978286743,
-1.1011698246002197,
0.0065747820772230625,
-0.32144254446029663,
-0.31294822692871094,
-0.28172755241394043,
0.05766788870096207,
0.13446184992790222,
0.018871527165174484,
-0.42092016339302063,
0.7408087253570557,
-0.4543868899345398,
-0.14811566472053528,
-0.3619193732738495,
0.1816226691007614,
0.07355763763189316,
0.5976433157920837,
0.36450594663619995,
0.5822479128837585,
-0.029980672523379326,
-0.5317525267601013,
0.145473450422287,
0.38474878668785095,
-0.49358463287353516,
0.646812379360199,
-0.5289413928985596,
0.20335377752780914,
0.02088966593146324,
0.23817305266857147,
-0.5660465359687805,
-0.29387611150741577,
0.3188629150390625,
-0.4507291316986084,
0.3811708986759186,
-0.24260132014751434,
-0.3128710389137268,
0.05771001800894737,
-0.22622038424015045,
0.6620004177093506,
0.4724941849708557,
-0.6102127432823181,
0.3969665467739105,
0.2800312340259552,
0.07110968232154846,
-1.0466179847717285,
-0.48834481835365295,
0.32504308223724365,
-0.34363242983818054,
-0.48422685265541077,
0.6707504391670227,
-0.115492083132267,
-0.16377389430999756,
0.19561952352523804,
-0.02088109776377678,
0.30098116397857666,
0.20949529111385345,
0.020472070202231407,
0.24994613230228424,
-0.0019249907927587628,
-0.10274980217218399,
-0.045981984585523605,
-0.42281481623649597,
-0.2237616777420044,
-0.2845475673675537,
0.5438933968544006,
0.04389846697449684,
-0.5107749104499817,
-0.24309678375720978,
0.3367975354194641,
0.3837094306945801,
-0.3504040539264679,
0.7383522987365723,
0.48955321311950684,
-0.26226454973220825,
-0.130360946059227,
-0.40543174743652344,
-0.16518886387348175,
-0.4360908567905426,
0.24330203235149384,
-0.3566933572292328,
-1.065646767616272,
0.4290616512298584,
0.16354922950267792,
0.1344064325094223,
-0.01043394673615694,
0.5625951290130615,
-0.13708387315273285,
1.1337368488311768,
0.6414816379547119,
-0.19273467361927032,
0.5644340515136719,
0.020649336278438568,
0.4867385923862457,
-0.8749011158943176,
-0.3906487226486206,
-0.43863147497177124,
-0.5478143095970154,
-0.20987798273563385,
-0.13288262486457825,
0.017592288553714752,
0.5155744552612305,
-0.2650471031665802,
0.4390452802181244,
-0.4012884199619293,
0.6068429350852966,
0.4611436724662781,
0.022274626418948174,
0.2833353579044342,
-0.08903557062149048,
0.27742695808410645,
-0.19568009674549103,
-0.7489935159683228,
-0.40231090784072876,
0.8081392645835876,
0.3937636613845825,
1.1724776029586792,
0.33803340792655945,
0.8917185068130493,
0.20600448548793793,
0.08899084478616714,
-0.9659671783447266,
0.3932359218597412,
-0.041047826409339905,
-0.2331470102071762,
-0.4249069094657898,
-0.4632851779460907,
-1.188328504562378,
0.005001663230359554,
-0.16411708295345306,
-0.7646107077598572,
0.09435345232486725,
0.40420180559158325,
-0.34375524520874023,
0.16767597198486328,
-0.4387798011302948,
1.0867946147918701,
-0.5192839503288269,
-0.2420697957277298,
-0.21563321352005005,
-0.6655892729759216,
0.3040267825126648,
0.1498442441225052,
0.3460243046283722,
-0.15614408254623413,
-0.10140622407197952,
0.6193547248840332,
-0.2691226303577423,
0.8131647706031799,
0.10149635374546051,
-0.331298828125,
-0.11763567477464676,
0.26763737201690674,
0.7276250123977661,
-0.09441959857940674,
0.04949723556637764,
-0.09686296433210373,
0.1201104074716568,
-0.46930399537086487,
-0.611855685710907,
0.5924723148345947,
-0.5989135503768921,
-0.5972064137458801,
-0.41398581862449646,
-1.0629961490631104,
-0.035841915756464005,
0.06544120609760284,
0.19264443218708038,
0.2835763394832611,
-0.010881787165999413,
0.0687515065073967,
0.7447117567062378,
-0.2350674718618393,
0.45674261450767517,
0.5462988018989563,
-0.21599502861499786,
-0.4234248399734497,
1.0397742986679077,
-0.42779433727264404,
0.4779494106769562,
0.7437910437583923,
0.18946805596351624,
-0.3831174075603485,
-0.6908118724822998,
-0.2564529478549957,
0.18262794613838196,
-0.7569214105606079,
-0.36156782507896423,
-0.3717905282974243,
-0.1323128044605255,
-0.4123137593269348,
-0.5888950228691101,
-0.37213224172592163,
-0.1971764713525772,
-0.3240416347980499,
0.13320493698120117,
0.2282177358865738,
0.38789719343185425,
-0.08269626647233963,
0.41912803053855896,
-1.0201349258422852,
0.2964269518852234,
0.04219980165362358,
0.4618198871612549,
-0.21677041053771973,
-0.594935417175293,
-0.5878384709358215,
-0.005677998531609774,
0.015067276544868946,
-0.6931732892990112,
0.3697942793369293,
-0.07004373520612717,
0.4572805166244507,
0.31301018595695496,
0.16000039875507355,
0.6278443336486816,
-0.341706246137619,
0.5536471605300903,
0.25565317273139954,
-1.1204564571380615,
0.20440413057804108,
-0.4233918786048889,
0.4187006652355194,
0.4103427231311798,
-0.025005551055073738,
-0.9707142114639282,
-0.2991167902946472,
-0.3575969636440277,
-0.882680356502533,
0.892482340335846,
-0.04463521018624306,
0.06931746751070023,
0.012539217248558998,
0.404611200094223,
-0.012586894445121288,
0.2770628333091736,
-0.8174247741699219,
0.10369089990854263,
0.20177917182445526,
-0.6193209886550903,
-0.055855248123407364,
-0.3488030731678009,
-0.29089799523353577,
0.11020500957965851,
0.632365882396698,
-0.2864646911621094,
0.012607311829924583,
-0.23959989845752716,
-0.3384994864463806,
-0.18504402041435242,
0.5930212140083313,
0.7144266366958618,
0.6628523468971252,
-0.1708289384841919,
0.0789560005068779,
-0.19131648540496826,
0.15117903053760529,
0.42962774634361267,
-0.015745244920253754,
-0.05872400477528572,
-0.4045749008655548,
0.5723770260810852,
0.8969396948814392,
0.5452949404716492,
-0.8762441277503967,
0.5188961029052734,
-0.030481375753879547,
-0.22129134833812714,
-0.20542386174201965,
0.15535303950309753,
0.3773786425590515,
0.5450464487075806,
-0.1351618766784668,
-0.5687180757522583,
-0.09455753117799759,
-0.46105876564979553,
0.03167275711894035,
0.5889668464660645,
-0.1892116814851761,
-0.0020365638192743063,
0.6373451352119446,
0.020734397694468498,
-0.6700401306152344,
0.8724431395530701,
-0.2413330078125,
-0.5758169293403625,
0.6220613121986389,
0.6017037034034729,
0.7122617959976196,
-0.1466764211654663,
0.22442162036895752,
0.11207395046949387,
0.23912130296230316,
-0.4092170298099518,
0.17106400430202484,
-0.1024351716041565,
-0.8181735277175903,
-0.7455533742904663,
-0.7407482862472534,
-0.39817360043525696,
-0.04905395582318306,
-0.8185853362083435,
0.3868894577026367,
-0.19454362988471985,
0.08743196725845337,
-0.29474541544914246,
-0.29078251123428345,
-0.4290553629398346,
-0.11007094383239746,
0.14668413996696472,
0.7915709614753723,
-0.5383670330047607,
0.8147889375686646,
0.4686112403869629,
-0.28496697545051575,
-0.8835724592208862,
-0.1326671540737152,
-0.029330337420105934,
-0.8139134049415588,
0.6040742993354797,
0.14337655901908875,
-0.1212906539440155,
0.0014792387373745441,
-0.46195530891418457,
-0.8281852602958679,
1.0091654062271118,
0.6881610751152039,
-1.010240912437439,
-0.39926019310951233,
0.07456403225660324,
0.26115748286247253,
-0.45606279373168945,
-0.23697808384895325,
0.7193045020103455,
0.6111328601837158,
0.11591625213623047,
-0.8810853362083435,
0.01066023949533701,
0.11541560292243958,
0.049965668469667435,
0.5901553630828857,
-0.44506579637527466,
0.5774787068367004,
-0.3964982032775879,
-0.17429418861865997,
0.15746137499809265,
0.4344377815723419,
0.2697899043560028,
0.11299286037683487,
0.48656466603279114,
0.8581638932228088,
0.3761180341243744,
-0.09251193702220917,
1.1563889980316162,
-0.1893261820077896,
0.48300838470458984,
1.2103843688964844,
-0.1891065388917923,
0.7854530215263367,
0.777976393699646,
-0.1284172534942627,
0.23628605902194977,
0.8829519748687744,
0.09732110053300858,
0.7016959190368652,
0.42236778140068054,
-0.09719423949718475,
-0.5792073607444763,
-0.12425724416971207,
-0.14722654223442078,
0.23042508959770203,
0.396879106760025,
-0.03362283483147621,
-0.20076042413711548,
-0.14718055725097656,
-0.0825507640838623,
0.2793421149253845,
-0.10467668622732162,
0.8498977422714233,
0.18588007986545563,
-0.8649201393127441,
0.4818803668022156,
0.15494544804096222,
0.6353083252906799,
-0.7304158210754395,
-0.10749955475330353,
-0.22565557062625885,
0.2966883182525635,
-0.24392388761043549,
-0.7821128368377686,
0.1670103669166565,
-0.4111415445804596,
-0.185831218957901,
-0.319142609834671,
0.2370295375585556,
-0.9833585619926453,
-0.12762583792209625,
0.3392815589904785,
0.027864621952176094,
-0.009316176176071167,
0.23426224291324615,
-0.6837487816810608,
0.5560835003852844,
0.04071226343512535,
-0.24373392760753632,
0.39717915654182434,
0.12187429517507553,
0.048500653356313705,
0.6393473744392395,
0.42072194814682007,
0.13551612198352814,
-0.19706948101520538,
0.05022100731730461,
0.43119144439697266,
-0.9372197985649109,
-0.5738232731819153,
-0.9153153896331787,
0.4575331211090088,
0.2123643159866333,
-0.05959990993142128,
0.33396798372268677,
0.33982694149017334,
1.0212583541870117,
0.14262604713439941,
0.603635847568512,
0.14430604875087738,
0.08987656235694885,
-1.0723377466201782,
0.2805313169956207,
-0.6064763069152832,
0.6566808819770813,
0.08929555118083954,
-0.9754202961921692,
-0.3062790036201477,
0.4893827438354492,
-0.18840153515338898,
-0.007665348704904318,
0.6348551511764526,
0.761401355266571,
-0.136557936668396,
-0.33950480818748474,
0.30134448409080505,
-0.32467880845069885,
0.5580629110336304,
0.9715158343315125,
0.9770053625106812,
-0.03517947718501091,
0.6887795925140381,
-0.18764334917068481,
-0.02499065361917019,
-0.38911008834838867,
-1.0737104415893555,
-0.7878401875495911,
-0.457027792930603,
-0.42792177200317383,
-0.5284030437469482,
0.2164943665266037,
1.1589007377624512,
0.5532146692276001,
-0.6031221747398376,
-0.42414000630378723,
0.06876274943351746,
0.30387744307518005,
-0.2522379457950592,
-0.16425786912441254,
0.45255380868911743,
-0.6059237718582153,
-0.8053287267684937,
0.39638805389404297,
0.37615254521369934,
0.08638254553079605,
-0.1879587173461914,
-0.6686102151870728,
-0.13452446460723877,
-0.0532107874751091,
0.2930763363838196,
0.5137591361999512,
-0.9126337766647339,
-0.425234854221344,
0.0734873041510582,
-0.37872782349586487,
0.025302957743406296,
1.2058756351470947,
-0.40402016043663025,
0.2533980906009674,
0.2786933183670044,
1.1818230152130127,
0.4172675907611847,
-0.04073695093393326,
0.9165740013122559,
-0.628420352935791,
0.1540360450744629,
0.1352728009223938,
0.46384546160697937,
0.34634706377983093,
-0.5291351079940796,
0.33231040835380554,
-0.12884455919265747,
-0.5189536809921265,
-0.8483170866966248,
0.545659065246582,
-0.9268337488174438,
-0.41956549882888794,
1.1376127004623413,
-0.16067306697368622,
-0.2582613229751587,
0.08003227412700653,
-0.19516144692897797,
0.2591797709465027,
-0.545703113079071,
0.9543589353561401,
0.8618210554122925,
-0.055041488260030746,
-0.20168782770633698,
-0.0653214082121849,
0.46212995052337646,
0.6446232199668884,
-0.8255022168159485,
0.24662438035011292,
0.6244060397148132,
0.16011811792850494,
-0.13528653979301453,
0.5265026688575745,
-0.17825542390346527,
0.3463112413883209,
-0.42139288783073425,
0.25322192907333374,
-0.17182818055152893,
-0.30980661511421204,
-0.6418329477310181,
-0.13765498995780945,
0.47097048163414,
-0.15802782773971558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05127v1 | Illuminate: A novel approach for depression detection with explainable analysis and proactive therapy using prompt engineering | 2024-02-05T06:08:06 | 2024-02-05T06:08:06 | Aryan Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces a novel paradigm for depression detection and treatment
using advanced Large Language Models (LLMs): Generative Pre-trained Transformer
4 (GPT-4), Llama 2 chat, and Gemini. These LLMs are fine-tuned with specialized
prompts to diagnose, explain, and suggest therapeutic interventions for
depression. A unique few-shot prompting method enhances the models' ability to
analyze and explain depressive symptoms based on the DSM-5 criteria. In the
interaction phase, the models engage in empathetic dialogue management, drawing
from resources like PsychDB and a Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) Guide,
fostering supportive interactions with individuals experiencing major
depressive disorders. Additionally, the research introduces the Illuminate
Database, enriched with various CBT modules, aiding in personalized therapy
recommendations. The study evaluates LLM performance using metrics such as F1
scores, Precision, Recall, Cosine similarity, and Recall-Oriented Understudy
for Gisting Evaluation (ROUGE) across different test sets, demonstrating their
effectiveness. This comprehensive approach blends cutting-edge AI with
established psychological methods, offering new possibilities in mental health
care and showcasing the potential of LLMs in revolutionizing depression
diagnosis and treatment strategies. | [
-0.29668936133384705,
-1.0883897542953491,
0.9726414680480957,
0.440766304731369,
-0.16344547271728516,
0.06401358544826508,
-0.1733558028936386,
-0.14471760392189026,
0.22467364370822906,
0.11462534219026566,
-0.913245677947998,
-0.6425406336784363,
-0.40628573298454285,
0.32252779603004456,
-0.3939632475376129,
0.4904307425022125,
-0.01312191504985094,
0.27193185687065125,
0.15892334282398224,
0.2257859706878662,
-0.8545737862586975,
-0.04801606386899948,
-0.9798061847686768,
-0.24870501458644867,
0.18428818881511688,
0.5022686123847961,
0.8103561401367188,
-0.327973872423172,
0.5723212957382202,
0.26486170291900635,
-0.04768437519669533,
-0.03822289779782295,
-0.3864425718784332,
0.10039451718330383,
0.06726493686437607,
-0.6288794279098511,
-0.5545657277107239,
-0.23968619108200073,
0.0331127792596817,
0.5314370393753052,
0.028035234659910202,
-0.2386322319507599,
0.29250654578208923,
0.2317575365304947,
-0.6986712217330933,
0.05411414057016373,
-0.27518516778945923,
0.3493078351020813,
-0.057734739035367966,
-0.08394897729158401,
-0.35864442586898804,
-0.19621889293193817,
-0.40607643127441406,
-0.4965269863605499,
0.12237992137670517,
-0.25840994715690613,
0.4410124123096466,
0.4338979721069336,
-0.32293185591697693,
-0.3388483226299286,
-0.6590098142623901,
0.603893518447876,
-0.811461329460144,
-0.27434393763542175,
0.5200299620628357,
0.5786305665969849,
-0.07372641563415527,
-0.7149032354354858,
-0.2652927339076996,
-0.12243963778018951,
-0.22511325776576996,
0.39817166328430176,
-0.3631012439727783,
0.2951851785182953,
0.23605236411094666,
0.6996245980262756,
-0.6491467952728271,
0.41542625427246094,
0.08383244276046753,
-0.14444810152053833,
0.5239062905311584,
0.534214973449707,
0.5323128700256348,
-0.17472738027572632,
-0.26464107632637024,
0.46949663758277893,
-0.3320341408252716,
-0.11693866550922394,
-0.1984429806470871,
-0.001891301479190588,
-0.06270507723093033,
0.45109063386917114,
-0.059369586408138275,
0.44840550422668457,
0.19173532724380493,
-0.0021371222101151943,
-0.13954831659793854,
-0.2317906767129898,
-0.39968404173851013,
0.11414038389921188,
0.8659756183624268,
0.48449382185935974,
-0.1259918212890625,
0.03783022612333298,
-0.1863703578710556,
0.22365176677703857,
0.048993341624736786,
-0.8360186815261841,
-0.6051769852638245,
0.4597867429256439,
-0.7593121528625488,
-0.28154700994491577,
-0.5096346139907837,
-1.0646814107894897,
-0.8487988710403442,
-0.2856592535972595,
0.6163203716278076,
-0.7517575621604919,
-0.6467995047569275,
0.3788596987724304,
0.09482469409704208,
0.075894296169281,
0.3372642397880554,
-0.8510079979896545,
0.0053471107967197895,
0.4543409049510956,
1.2304319143295288,
-0.10725343972444534,
0.33612701296806335,
-0.3971865475177765,
-0.07003428786993027,
-0.19632191956043243,
0.7707010507583618,
-0.5673923492431641,
-0.4399259686470032,
0.2182590216398239,
-0.11225248873233795,
0.007566129323095083,
-0.37578055262565613,
0.6986632347106934,
-0.11844771355390549,
0.10249810665845871,
-0.11718769371509552,
-0.5749481916427612,
-0.05776200816035271,
0.3406687080860138,
-0.713868260383606,
0.589719295501709,
0.3219321668148041,
-0.7386420965194702,
0.010890056379139423,
-0.8784764409065247,
-0.023992186412215233,
0.47625115513801575,
-0.060782402753829956,
-0.21416452527046204,
0.27826252579689026,
0.47057896852493286,
0.5652744174003601,
-0.2696859538555145,
0.3012889325618744,
-0.32220980525016785,
-0.3694628179073334,
0.276166170835495,
-0.39062821865081787,
0.7929360270500183,
0.485809326171875,
-0.24284759163856506,
0.1745748519897461,
-0.8377931714057922,
-0.06578082591295242,
0.2557556629180908,
0.03647242486476898,
-0.3626108169555664,
-0.37856003642082214,
0.07426176965236664,
0.06799469143152237,
0.2605073153972626,
-0.2480260729789734,
0.11635547131299973,
-0.3872031271457672,
0.5291866660118103,
0.5895300507545471,
0.15226790308952332,
0.16584104299545288,
0.08184128254652023,
1.1669187545776367,
-0.03196495398879051,
0.46644139289855957,
-0.7291094064712524,
-0.2942894995212555,
-0.497962087392807,
-0.8207361698150635,
-0.060717564076185226,
0.6258329153060913,
-0.396308571100235,
0.5174139142036438,
0.2683587372303009,
-0.29962319135665894,
-0.5834392309188843,
-0.2764149308204651,
0.07920727133750916,
0.3173724114894867,
0.6213917136192322,
-0.1442657709121704,
-0.4829154312610626,
-0.7329809665679932,
-0.2840415835380554,
0.3768264055252075,
-0.003225399646908045,
-0.08146248757839203,
0.1872766613960266,
-0.45899251103401184,
0.9107698798179626,
-0.6587129831314087,
-0.41360414028167725,
-0.6499611735343933,
0.35376328229904175,
0.49196895956993103,
0.20704618096351624,
0.5093258023262024,
-0.5337172150611877,
-0.553500771522522,
-0.2513574957847595,
-0.9423076510429382,
-0.19211825728416443,
-0.36085107922554016,
-0.04990869015455246,
-0.47543367743492126,
0.4891616404056549,
-0.677803099155426,
0.7590746879577637,
0.13708485662937164,
-0.494228720664978,
0.3608322739601135,
-0.0034596859477460384,
0.12741152942180634,
-0.9330220818519592,
-0.09867390990257263,
-0.09861055016517639,
-0.12375663965940475,
-0.5741952657699585,
-0.525122880935669,
-0.07681123912334442,
-0.4255201816558838,
-0.14234010875225067,
0.3718002140522003,
-0.5105290412902832,
0.08500203490257263,
-0.48311343789100647,
0.10982853919267654,
-0.08084982633590698,
0.18055199086666107,
-0.4390357434749603,
0.47164008021354675,
0.8955883383750916,
-0.35052427649497986,
0.560967206954956,
0.3903244137763977,
-0.37435218691825867,
0.9408887624740601,
-0.5378337502479553,
-0.10913928598165512,
-0.2160380482673645,
0.014768799766898155,
-1.4326250553131104,
-0.24348047375679016,
0.42384085059165955,
-0.15710501372814178,
0.3461518883705139,
0.27728471159935,
-0.43440061807632446,
-0.32960203289985657,
-0.1058213859796524,
0.6516346335411072,
0.38029229640960693,
-0.425601601600647,
0.4499976634979248,
-0.25043734908103943,
-0.4811904728412628,
-0.1121983602643013,
-0.5951117277145386,
0.42609062790870667,
-0.6546982526779175,
-0.6071570515632629,
0.6774112582206726,
-0.2588672339916229,
-0.3744613826274872,
-0.17721369862556458,
0.2210407704114914,
0.07209581881761551,
0.49121132493019104,
0.019960155710577965,
0.1297384798526764,
0.03077717311680317,
0.4767105281352997,
0.039588019251823425,
-0.4509035050868988,
0.21355777978897095,
0.3205283284187317,
0.7096285820007324,
0.04199400171637535,
-0.5772539377212524,
-0.9246078133583069,
0.5489462614059448,
0.34977614879608154,
-0.1929107904434204,
0.5537598729133606,
0.6722518801689148,
-0.34703880548477173,
-0.13519306480884552,
-0.07204968482255936,
-0.4703972339630127,
-0.4323063790798187,
0.3749845325946808,
-0.34304943680763245,
-0.4658660888671875,
0.42902684211730957,
-0.5117858648300171,
-0.21670638024806976,
-0.002423468977212906,
0.5917220115661621,
0.19413448870182037,
1.6398895978927612,
0.8086515069007874,
0.029026178643107414,
0.675847589969635,
-0.2734036147594452,
0.7700805068016052,
-0.5711615681648254,
0.033582720905542374,
-0.1046474277973175,
-0.46230143308639526,
-0.14648373425006866,
0.08908329904079437,
0.5092372298240662,
0.5203394889831543,
-0.3522866368293762,
-0.08293908089399338,
-0.6787614226341248,
0.17522265017032623,
0.09882606565952301,
0.20363014936447144,
0.5649560689926147,
-0.41143980622291565,
0.04000937193632126,
-0.47177577018737793,
-0.3464319705963135,
-0.4776518642902374,
0.887982964515686,
0.24370889365673065,
1.0099445581436157,
-0.01523477490991354,
0.600609540939331,
0.3739672005176544,
0.47737613320350647,
-0.9912475347518921,
0.33764907717704773,
0.34456008672714233,
-0.3887102007865906,
0.006963666994124651,
0.09731671214103699,
-0.9910987615585327,
0.25514495372772217,
0.015178629197180271,
-0.7217297554016113,
0.18517136573791504,
0.03249117732048035,
-0.6423497200012207,
-0.13619790971279144,
-0.7717859745025635,
1.0455372333526611,
-0.7025520205497742,
-0.01613234356045723,
-0.3546864688396454,
-0.4338878095149994,
0.8168214559555054,
-0.087303027510643,
0.3546646535396576,
-0.16654643416404724,
0.1347099393606186,
0.25107142329216003,
-0.14149783551692963,
0.8961115479469299,
-0.25325965881347656,
-0.20773781836032867,
-0.12063901871442795,
0.1759752333164215,
0.36846432089805603,
0.34374475479125977,
-0.06429217010736465,
-0.28739073872566223,
-0.1642804890871048,
-0.20962080359458923,
-0.9070152044296265,
0.5159450173377991,
-0.3999575078487396,
-0.5491447448730469,
-0.2769613265991211,
-0.4028981924057007,
-0.18647333979606628,
0.294727623462677,
0.49885961413383484,
0.1751319319009781,
-0.3546901047229767,
-0.1383822113275528,
0.6271518468856812,
-0.5077885389328003,
0.35395723581314087,
0.4562525153160095,
-0.43493884801864624,
-0.4456818401813507,
0.35068514943122864,
-0.11606457084417343,
0.028475496917963028,
0.23920778930187225,
0.037862859666347504,
0.01851595751941204,
-0.525216281414032,
0.4460926055908203,
0.34599992632865906,
-0.8398080468177795,
-0.5953971147537231,
-0.6509540677070618,
0.043460384011268616,
-0.3449695110321045,
-0.13651293516159058,
-0.32088902592658997,
-0.21505849063396454,
-0.6447165608406067,
-0.39560022950172424,
0.4899214804172516,
0.5070382952690125,
-0.1029706597328186,
0.4513612389564514,
-0.5839207172393799,
0.583914041519165,
-0.008870849385857582,
0.16904285550117493,
0.13829293847084045,
-0.14372913539409637,
-0.35563746094703674,
0.01211151760071516,
-0.6898448467254639,
-1.3561066389083862,
0.73661869764328,
0.1875312328338623,
0.548603892326355,
0.764928936958313,
0.2824583947658539,
0.5276213884353638,
0.017210572957992554,
0.7797728180885315,
0.6126937866210938,
-1.019304633140564,
1.0719720125198364,
0.08570383489131927,
0.09917296469211578,
0.27413490414619446,
0.5354160666465759,
-0.5074321031570435,
-0.28304222226142883,
-0.45947226881980896,
-1.0173205137252808,
0.694044291973114,
0.18700359761714935,
-0.13859392702579498,
-0.18238094449043274,
0.4925447404384613,
0.12100419402122498,
-0.12307310849428177,
-0.7143692374229431,
-0.1421499252319336,
-0.46687278151512146,
-0.7346781492233276,
-0.10164079070091248,
-0.25124844908714294,
-0.36590442061424255,
-0.0409497432410717,
0.3170156478881836,
-0.3621065020561218,
0.6730862855911255,
0.22356024384498596,
-0.13334999978542328,
-0.06376241892576218,
0.3519098460674286,
0.033374715596437454,
0.6303240656852722,
-0.06187652423977852,
0.16578368842601776,
-0.1422022432088852,
-0.03844885528087616,
0.033441390842199326,
0.30901822447776794,
0.03272669017314911,
0.17805898189544678,
0.37248191237449646,
0.8371539115905762,
0.07752837240695953,
-0.6554068922996521,
0.633837878704071,
-0.2567734718322754,
0.018629157915711403,
-0.5484398603439331,
0.14520680904388428,
0.12938471138477325,
0.6697512269020081,
0.3112720847129822,
-0.29124730825424194,
0.4275551438331604,
-0.48684602975845337,
-0.2789182662963867,
0.6610749959945679,
-0.4685588479042053,
-0.661867618560791,
0.6734490990638733,
0.03217693045735359,
-0.40271973609924316,
0.6778261661529541,
-0.03474397957324982,
-0.25450843572616577,
0.5026999711990356,
0.5385380387306213,
1.0325803756713867,
-0.3554774522781372,
0.5171259045600891,
0.4086807370185852,
-0.03853916749358177,
-0.05868065357208252,
0.34039971232414246,
-0.20297740399837494,
-0.5952081680297852,
-0.25180158019065857,
-0.3233549892902374,
-0.06828512996435165,
0.47718051075935364,
-0.7117869853973389,
0.4203212261199951,
-0.4678785502910614,
-0.28007203340530396,
-0.04277190566062927,
-0.22826305031776428,
-0.5420796275138855,
-0.009625954553484917,
0.22631321847438812,
0.765933632850647,
-0.923559844493866,
0.33170703053474426,
0.6162708401679993,
-0.729859471321106,
-0.3180900514125824,
0.07418856769800186,
0.12758868932724,
-0.7521426677703857,
0.49354708194732666,
0.5613036155700684,
0.24008168280124664,
0.33977770805358887,
-0.6926235556602478,
-0.6856624484062195,
1.3929420709609985,
0.5195985436439514,
-0.3840342164039612,
0.029066458344459534,
-0.08422238379716873,
0.5229597091674805,
-0.33850717544555664,
0.6288708448410034,
0.9036022424697876,
0.7401901483535767,
-0.09640441834926605,
-0.5616785883903503,
0.164675772190094,
-0.2540305554866791,
0.10472603887319565,
0.04412492364645004,
-0.5889741778373718,
0.6994988918304443,
-0.22659824788570404,
-0.5860356092453003,
0.4552184045314789,
0.36098480224609375,
0.2131231129169464,
0.3903405964374542,
0.28073421120643616,
0.513867199420929,
0.898888885974884,
-0.05848708376288414,
0.7948219180107117,
-0.2747687101364136,
0.3380142152309418,
0.5029789209365845,
-0.33659157156944275,
0.14823615550994873,
0.34662604331970215,
-0.1525285392999649,
0.3887024521827698,
0.7781080603599548,
-0.01950441300868988,
0.7607830166816711,
0.018569091334939003,
-0.5824028849601746,
-0.5091406106948853,
-0.24229183793067932,
-0.3380892276763916,
0.09734611958265305,
0.6570011973381042,
-0.3982678949832916,
-0.41763192415237427,
0.6873419880867004,
0.048530738800764084,
0.07381734251976013,
-0.2629997432231903,
0.7223756909370422,
0.48890113830566406,
-0.4578450620174408,
0.627705454826355,
-0.13188602030277252,
0.5175856351852417,
-0.4840681850910187,
-0.00600441126152873,
-0.5828337669372559,
0.5195072293281555,
-0.388790488243103,
-0.6562881469726562,
0.11587303876876831,
-0.05453005060553551,
-0.03953856602311134,
-0.2510664761066437,
0.6487760543823242,
-0.18219561874866486,
-0.4169142246246338,
0.46970683336257935,
0.41617855429649353,
-0.010134972631931305,
-0.2889975309371948,
-0.8112339973449707,
-0.03897847607731819,
-0.08032835274934769,
-0.2981609106063843,
0.348100870847702,
0.7694371342658997,
0.06540002673864365,
0.7138014435768127,
0.1305229365825653,
-0.298350065946579,
-0.26709669828414917,
0.28300055861473083,
0.7641224265098572,
-0.9716451168060303,
-0.46087050437927246,
-0.7984390258789062,
0.6803187727928162,
-0.04318813979625702,
-0.08368179947137833,
0.7017908096313477,
0.0617414191365242,
0.06525687873363495,
-0.03650708124041557,
0.8586617708206177,
0.059979166835546494,
0.5189923048019409,
-0.4839988648891449,
0.038385551422834396,
-0.5236065983772278,
0.307790070772171,
-0.20940779149532318,
-0.8986799716949463,
-0.6185688376426697,
0.7160994410514832,
-0.4050941467285156,
0.13955718278884888,
0.8365599513053894,
0.7895767092704773,
0.017031783238053322,
0.15826986730098724,
0.2760140895843506,
0.6568743586540222,
0.8049111366271973,
0.7555374503135681,
1.356680989265442,
-0.21857602894306183,
0.4781447947025299,
0.02399883233010769,
-0.5652880668640137,
-0.4226456880569458,
-0.5406686067581177,
-0.7770037651062012,
-0.2186475247144699,
-0.42781031131744385,
0.12891371548175812,
-0.13920827209949493,
0.5233373045921326,
0.2064734548330307,
-0.49013379216194153,
0.30102819204330444,
-0.5368803143501282,
-0.03386252373456955,
-0.5442747473716736,
-0.33699822425842285,
0.38402125239372253,
-0.7008017897605896,
-0.4948457181453705,
0.5778922438621521,
0.47238361835479736,
0.02761588804423809,
-0.4729992151260376,
-0.003480839543044567,
0.1296262890100479,
-0.34010061621665955,
0.47375616431236267,
-0.13108550012111664,
-0.5428216457366943,
0.3329763412475586,
-0.0876827985048294,
0.11554981023073196,
0.2418363243341446,
0.8192770481109619,
-0.8190921545028687,
0.42158636450767517,
0.4705936014652252,
0.3165362477302551,
0.3153018057346344,
0.1012343317270279,
0.5771778225898743,
-0.10131382197141647,
0.020160004496574402,
0.5120797753334045,
0.4262465238571167,
0.4629272520542145,
-0.7821993827819824,
0.24611501395702362,
0.024280862882733345,
-0.6567375063896179,
-0.7091207504272461,
0.4692261219024658,
-0.6523768305778503,
-0.7355438470840454,
0.8350287079811096,
-0.34814614057540894,
0.1376708447933197,
-0.49533340334892273,
-0.658341646194458,
0.16547206044197083,
-0.17764708399772644,
1.0131011009216309,
0.5011643767356873,
-0.5934851169586182,
-0.5250391364097595,
-0.39813485741615295,
0.5914321541786194,
0.46613848209381104,
-0.7662544846534729,
0.034264396876096725,
0.5510188937187195,
-0.129919171333313,
0.045170124620199203,
0.74756920337677,
-0.15881861746311188,
0.1725771725177765,
-0.41687923669815063,
0.029632961377501488,
0.10853532701730728,
0.11464060097932816,
-0.5590722560882568,
0.11419110000133514,
0.0458628386259079,
-0.0015977831790223718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02750v1 | KIVI: A Tuning-Free Asymmetric 2bit Quantization for KV Cache | 2024-02-05T06:06:47 | 2024-02-05T06:06:47 | Zirui Liu, Jiayi Yuan, Hongye Jin, Shaochen Zhong, Zhaozhuo Xu, Vladimir Braverman, Beidi Chen, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PF | Efficiently serving large language models (LLMs) requires batching many
requests together to reduce the cost per request. Yet, the key-value (KV)
cache, which stores attention keys and values to avoid re-computations,
significantly increases memory demands and becomes the new bottleneck in speed
and memory usage. This memory demand increases with larger batch sizes and
longer context lengths. Additionally, the inference speed is limited by the
size of KV cache, as the GPU's SRAM must load the entire KV cache from the main
GPU memory for each token generated, causing the computational core to be idle
during this process. A straightforward and effective solution to reduce KV
cache size is quantization, which decreases the total bytes taken by KV cache.
However, there is a lack of in-depth studies that explore the element
distribution of KV cache to understand the hardness and limitation of KV cache
quantization. To fill the gap, we conducted a comprehensive study on the
element distribution in KV cache of popular LLMs. Our findings indicate that
the key cache should be quantized per-channel, i.e., group elements along the
channel dimension and quantize them together. In contrast, the value cache
should be quantized per-token. From this analysis, we developed a tuning-free
2bit KV cache quantization algorithm, named KIVI. With the hardware-friendly
implementation, KIVI can enable Llama (Llama-2), Falcon, and Mistral models to
maintain almost the same quality while using $\mathbf{2.6\times}$ less peak
memory usage (including the model weight). This reduction in memory usage
enables up to $\mathbf{4\times}$ larger batch size, bringing
$\mathbf{2.35\times \sim 3.47\times}$ throughput on real LLM inference
workload. The source code is available at https://github.com/jy-yuan/KIVI. | [
-0.31397581100463867,
-0.4159635603427887,
0.45544174313545227,
0.4487690031528473,
-0.8317003846168518,
-0.11929517239332199,
-0.22828122973442078,
-0.2229432761669159,
0.1775152087211609,
0.34957998991012573,
-0.46005746722221375,
-0.3893418312072754,
-0.3420265316963196,
-0.503174901008606,
-0.009069429710507393,
0.6160382628440857,
0.09920745342969894,
0.26337406039237976,
-0.5152068138122559,
-0.30530187487602234,
-0.7464751601219177,
-0.10951973497867584,
-0.6080392003059387,
-0.1486051380634308,
0.3110544681549072,
0.5872281789779663,
0.4746805429458618,
0.8346491456031799,
0.6078760027885437,
0.15765145421028137,
-0.1631307154893875,
-0.14828310906887054,
-0.34670424461364746,
0.5035371780395508,
0.1691415011882782,
-1.0291378498077393,
-0.4905540645122528,
-0.1766401082277298,
0.6418910622596741,
-0.040039267390966415,
-0.13077601790428162,
0.285125732421875,
-0.36632952094078064,
0.7706819176673889,
-1.1194332838058472,
0.14597290754318237,
-0.7078834176063538,
-0.0744129866361618,
-0.4397558867931366,
-0.20862552523612976,
-0.3521377742290497,
-0.17653797566890717,
-0.20344282686710358,
-0.8584390878677368,
0.28329983353614807,
0.012275265529751778,
0.8896110653877258,
0.6844946146011353,
-0.5107697248458862,
0.024579908698797226,
-0.5516714453697205,
0.7637783885002136,
-0.5021505355834961,
0.49187004566192627,
0.5201027989387512,
0.3824133574962616,
0.06524664163589478,
-0.7385478019714355,
-0.49237746000289917,
0.07081668823957443,
0.45373305678367615,
0.18197666108608246,
-0.10490451008081436,
0.20384706556797028,
0.1027183011174202,
0.4817589819431305,
-0.6042752265930176,
0.052720483392477036,
-0.20496438443660736,
-0.2422046810388565,
0.4029514491558075,
0.21369719505310059,
0.08677366375923157,
0.07339994609355927,
-0.31871137022972107,
-0.42329177260398865,
-1.0615171194076538,
0.2027464509010315,
0.4393167793750763,
-0.05172234773635864,
-0.16942091286182404,
0.28669098019599915,
-0.5354073643684387,
0.18447957932949066,
-0.14247392117977142,
0.030922558158636093,
0.04407351464033127,
-0.27221354842185974,
-0.3869319558143616,
-0.032201722264289856,
0.6303481459617615,
0.4468247592449188,
0.3445913791656494,
0.04184335470199585,
-0.08690163493156433,
0.3981587886810303,
0.2770126461982727,
-1.2786695957183838,
-0.46800702810287476,
0.054790183901786804,
-0.3719232976436615,
-0.4154592752456665,
-0.3144684135913849,
-0.7158973813056946,
-0.027274224907159805,
0.08530986309051514,
0.49711620807647705,
-0.07573599368333817,
-0.18339157104492188,
-0.005044077057391405,
-0.2127295732498169,
0.3494839668273926,
0.12061040848493576,
-0.9993186593055725,
0.15761999785900116,
0.5968019962310791,
0.8326655626296997,
0.020643198862671852,
0.3817688822746277,
-0.6314539909362793,
0.0698864683508873,
-0.3715580403804779,
0.5580253601074219,
-0.6721183657646179,
-0.7532162070274353,
-0.3203095495700836,
-0.16734449565410614,
0.5009514689445496,
-0.4236452579498291,
0.11584746092557907,
-1.0003540515899658,
-0.6248917579650879,
-0.859092652797699,
-0.1456071138381958,
0.0701252743601799,
-0.0407005175948143,
-0.6652756333351135,
1.017855167388916,
-0.12799951434135437,
-0.33781638741493225,
0.5137841701507568,
-0.23727606236934662,
-0.2578098177909851,
0.10835964232683182,
-0.14897312223911285,
-0.5286861062049866,
0.5371776819229126,
0.3285522758960724,
0.013244297355413437,
-0.5815508365631104,
0.17449481785297394,
-0.3250710964202881,
-0.43850815296173096,
0.15775084495544434,
-0.6254438757896423,
0.4429255723953247,
0.4019468128681183,
-0.3835959732532501,
0.03404843807220459,
-0.6727567315101624,
0.3712153136730194,
-0.05153243616223335,
-0.2615146338939667,
-0.3887649178504944,
0.12213525176048279,
-0.01251829881221056,
-0.03065941296517849,
0.19413451850414276,
-0.39063596725463867,
0.43565163016319275,
-0.41509997844696045,
0.624613344669342,
0.8292839527130127,
0.019341520965099335,
0.5516544580459595,
0.09064887464046478,
0.5629592537879944,
0.13721448183059692,
0.521364688873291,
-0.046820227056741714,
-0.6993919610977173,
-1.3767105340957642,
-0.3178249001502991,
0.4127783477306366,
0.2604930102825165,
-0.7240647077560425,
-0.1085188090801239,
-0.4885760247707367,
-0.26634541153907776,
-0.9281551837921143,
0.03804374858736992,
0.701662003993988,
-0.04886702820658684,
0.17633618414402008,
-0.44631072878837585,
-0.17093080282211304,
-1.01602041721344,
-0.029496503993868828,
-0.3126026690006256,
0.0917438194155693,
0.39333075284957886,
0.48507800698280334,
-0.018457937985658646,
0.9408402442932129,
-0.534920871257782,
0.003693197388201952,
0.4671737849712372,
0.21202223002910614,
-0.37715187668800354,
0.49802178144454956,
0.05597097799181938,
-0.8214065432548523,
-0.548552930355072,
0.07722451537847519,
-0.33373934030532837,
-0.2579054832458496,
0.38052788376808167,
-0.25321921706199646,
0.2960699796676636,
0.3876757025718689,
-0.6962891221046448,
0.7932819128036499,
0.3923124074935913,
-0.2034982293844223,
0.33605316281318665,
-0.19462887942790985,
-0.06459332257509232,
-1.0883597135543823,
0.10024826228618622,
-0.27737802267074585,
-0.3329409658908844,
-0.26651695370674133,
0.49226462841033936,
0.47055795788764954,
0.10288891196250916,
-0.2957764267921448,
0.5065850019454956,
-0.3267894685268402,
-0.14859990775585175,
-0.3686680793762207,
-0.13902848958969116,
0.05968276038765907,
0.4555014371871948,
-0.22245097160339355,
1.1539435386657715,
0.1835174560546875,
-0.5333638191223145,
0.2343004196882248,
0.050838105380535126,
-0.3672145903110504,
0.45644721388816833,
-0.738029956817627,
0.09446503221988678,
-0.1761023849248886,
0.23919878900051117,
-1.0865029096603394,
0.036093004047870636,
0.012533595785498619,
-0.7128654718399048,
0.25859159231185913,
-0.37632638216018677,
-0.6221416592597961,
0.04329870641231537,
-0.37608012557029724,
0.8084888458251953,
0.6549214124679565,
-0.38710010051727295,
0.2672824561595917,
0.20106905698776245,
0.0731363445520401,
-0.5217422842979431,
-0.7746221423149109,
-0.08303442597389221,
-0.17899012565612793,
-0.5687836408615112,
0.3118681013584137,
-0.3132916986942291,
-0.19819851219654083,
0.09315339475870132,
-0.4865415692329407,
-0.0643281564116478,
0.10813016444444656,
0.4283948540687561,
0.18062764406204224,
-0.3907850384712219,
0.48451149463653564,
0.22667483985424042,
-0.3996274769306183,
-0.09635249525308609,
-0.5861942768096924,
0.6427555084228516,
-0.27335700392723083,
-0.37545540928840637,
-0.4512321352958679,
0.1451953947544098,
0.8121635317802429,
-0.4247100055217743,
0.4980618357658386,
0.7677578330039978,
-0.13235154747962952,
-0.09219173341989517,
-0.7305330038070679,
-0.08185546100139618,
-0.536922037601471,
0.16158141195774078,
-0.5173296928405762,
-0.9998136162757874,
0.6287975311279297,
0.16250549256801605,
-0.14694906771183014,
0.5069482326507568,
0.7685956954956055,
0.09185318648815155,
1.088117003440857,
0.4882870316505432,
-0.4705770015716553,
0.33136796951293945,
-0.45298469066619873,
0.23470495641231537,
-0.8753360509872437,
-0.3331969678401947,
-0.3274797797203064,
-0.5941573977470398,
-0.7697879672050476,
-0.7492173910140991,
0.5368674993515015,
0.19592200219631195,
-0.2538089156150818,
-0.1629611700773239,
-0.5486561059951782,
0.5820645689964294,
0.6801510453224182,
-0.06581699848175049,
0.16226421296596527,
0.11851423978805542,
-0.20009498298168182,
-0.063904769718647,
-0.3791017532348633,
0.056058891117572784,
1.1110820770263672,
0.04288022220134735,
0.9403666853904724,
0.15016864240169525,
0.19955769181251526,
0.23186807334423065,
0.13272027671337128,
-0.8666864037513733,
0.47805458307266235,
0.050101589411497116,
-0.6808249950408936,
-0.1556013971567154,
-0.3741162121295929,
-0.6321916580200195,
0.27288150787353516,
0.15510013699531555,
-0.7837584018707275,
0.2160913646221161,
0.23815923929214478,
-0.3403441309928894,
0.20970264077186584,
-0.39656323194503784,
0.4677538275718689,
0.03553074598312378,
-0.33568716049194336,
-0.5216502547264099,
-0.7963224053382874,
0.33497145771980286,
0.11852465569972992,
-0.27322420477867126,
-0.21838699281215668,
-0.23078210651874542,
0.5061412453651428,
-0.7102872133255005,
0.6479318141937256,
-0.25560253858566284,
0.08169727772474289,
0.39994552731513977,
0.11794919520616531,
0.8467695713043213,
0.5068767070770264,
0.2964155375957489,
-0.07046228647232056,
0.09881649166345596,
-0.48330190777778625,
-0.6425617337226868,
1.0064116716384888,
-1.1412042379379272,
-0.5853708386421204,
-0.008947254158556461,
-0.6925262212753296,
-0.09621621668338776,
-0.135518416762352,
0.42642509937286377,
0.324832558631897,
0.36089059710502625,
0.4470095634460449,
0.9398927688598633,
-0.030425628647208214,
0.4481337368488312,
0.6087461113929749,
0.1630205363035202,
-0.6688001155853271,
1.2262450456619263,
0.0404820442199707,
0.5031362771987915,
0.5894863605499268,
0.079039566218853,
-0.2629907429218292,
-0.33090856671333313,
-0.48647528886795044,
0.23307763040065765,
-0.751820981502533,
-0.4832688868045807,
-0.5043825507164001,
-0.2192920744419098,
-0.28803205490112305,
-0.18985696136951447,
-0.7104124426841736,
-0.6704546213150024,
-0.5444942116737366,
0.16668444871902466,
0.6548863053321838,
0.16613003611564636,
0.20374441146850586,
0.9835779666900635,
-0.44759392738342285,
0.18581826984882355,
0.43898138403892517,
0.5155588388442993,
0.20593883097171783,
-0.33213290572166443,
-0.2888151705265045,
0.11481375247240067,
-0.45814746618270874,
-0.5263116955757141,
0.4543113112449646,
0.1504693180322647,
0.01958341896533966,
0.7338351607322693,
-0.214422345161438,
1.2245557308197021,
-0.12724675238132477,
0.857494056224823,
0.015046462416648865,
-1.0362635850906372,
0.4910198152065277,
-0.21232230961322784,
0.39993467926979065,
0.7963584661483765,
0.049751393496990204,
-0.5898878574371338,
-0.09110315889120102,
-0.4482235908508301,
-1.0392322540283203,
0.5107048153877258,
0.3030282258987427,
-0.02290215902030468,
0.06479193270206451,
0.5265229940414429,
-0.19644354283809662,
0.3967728614807129,
-0.42529547214508057,
-0.4030587077140808,
-0.02700909972190857,
-0.1231120303273201,
-0.04673260077834129,
-0.48195335268974304,
0.3229411840438843,
-0.3369884192943573,
0.7721906304359436,
-0.15604229271411896,
0.572490394115448,
0.029944486916065216,
-0.21826432645320892,
-0.26925602555274963,
-0.0068678054958581924,
0.6658792495727539,
0.28155994415283203,
-0.12586699426174164,
0.20139750838279724,
0.20662100613117218,
-0.6085616946220398,
0.3023316562175751,
-0.32790014147758484,
-0.17391015589237213,
-0.12090664356946945,
-0.3125469386577606,
0.9956051707267761,
0.18839555978775024,
-0.593231201171875,
0.6790054440498352,
-0.27493593096733093,
-0.1312204748392105,
-0.15693584084510803,
0.08448610454797745,
0.15367059409618378,
0.49738216400146484,
0.09758544713258743,
-0.29528987407684326,
-0.01293808501213789,
-0.10595889389514923,
-0.16566821932792664,
0.8674283027648926,
-0.3691326975822449,
-0.49047815799713135,
1.0149061679840088,
0.13028696179389954,
-0.15403686463832855,
1.0691567659378052,
-0.2973356246948242,
-0.2663639783859253,
0.7558149099349976,
0.5092243552207947,
1.0228079557418823,
-0.2208935022354126,
-0.08038529753684998,
0.04756906256079674,
0.2502324879169464,
-0.09422273933887482,
0.5016270279884338,
-0.6726037263870239,
-0.517835795879364,
-0.4473956823348999,
-0.8908065557479858,
-0.008078914135694504,
0.2871887981891632,
-0.9331355094909668,
0.20340365171432495,
-0.39843207597732544,
-0.27129870653152466,
-0.18635256588459015,
0.2602522671222687,
-0.7266506552696228,
0.15101315081119537,
0.0673416331410408,
0.9005584716796875,
-0.7841132879257202,
1.1117113828659058,
0.29622846841812134,
-0.1409444361925125,
-0.46030446887016296,
-0.31417733430862427,
0.04162720590829849,
-1.1465373039245605,
0.625129222869873,
-0.0004535055486485362,
0.17177705466747284,
0.2597808241844177,
-0.5535025000572205,
-1.1068307161331177,
1.4334462881088257,
0.14416787028312683,
-0.6506057381629944,
-0.034129440784454346,
0.1985449343919754,
0.27580028772354126,
0.05583838000893593,
0.12489333003759384,
0.5229605436325073,
0.4310908913612366,
0.2747419476509094,
-0.6480603218078613,
0.019505420699715614,
-0.48644599318504333,
0.5569748878479004,
0.8341540098190308,
-1.1434941291809082,
0.6380684971809387,
-0.003053460270166397,
-0.10805649310350418,
0.4535837471485138,
0.6248278617858887,
0.25575384497642517,
0.19982761144638062,
0.3390675485134125,
1.1051342487335205,
0.6373809576034546,
-0.09979016333818436,
0.8350990414619446,
-0.5602896809577942,
0.31675803661346436,
0.6052980422973633,
0.06922867149114609,
0.8416914939880371,
0.8215300440788269,
-0.08412909507751465,
0.15504230558872223,
0.604161262512207,
0.05124392360448837,
0.9131001830101013,
0.281520277261734,
-0.6120336055755615,
-0.41028472781181335,
-0.04777810722589493,
-0.3353232145309448,
0.3496149778366089,
0.5576154589653015,
-0.2482183277606964,
-0.020749615505337715,
-0.16462305188179016,
-0.13068296015262604,
-0.9174727201461792,
-0.2853803336620331,
0.5413632988929749,
0.20435041189193726,
-0.5890548229217529,
0.5206286907196045,
0.19303201138973236,
0.4617895781993866,
-0.6471442580223083,
0.11336229741573334,
-0.30234819650650024,
0.06249339506030083,
0.15642204880714417,
-0.20164327323436737,
-0.08615314960479736,
-0.07947821915149689,
-0.4353930652141571,
-0.03199900686740875,
0.6936531662940979,
-0.30440542101860046,
-0.4340157210826874,
-0.22986342012882233,
0.1738296002149582,
0.20986703038215637,
-0.19737666845321655,
-0.021155141294002533,
0.3884100615978241,
0.023800289258360863,
-0.36163172125816345,
0.6177003383636475,
0.25031745433807373,
-0.5047652125358582,
0.9246023297309875,
0.7320079207420349,
0.1841052770614624,
0.18499822914600372,
-0.073662169277668,
0.9902629256248474,
-0.5298730731010437,
-0.7067819237709045,
-0.93528151512146,
0.5515698790550232,
0.3339320123195648,
-0.39654654264450073,
0.5444138646125793,
0.57542884349823,
0.5952456593513489,
0.22803133726119995,
0.6351245045661926,
0.2811890244483948,
-0.6696656942367554,
-0.518053412437439,
0.7332790493965149,
-0.8219525814056396,
0.13299518823623657,
0.23424537479877472,
-0.7552537322044373,
-0.17524243891239166,
0.45615866780281067,
0.0022904204670339823,
-0.11685766279697418,
0.4656517803668976,
1.0726630687713623,
-0.03538639470934868,
-0.06904812157154083,
0.4123673439025879,
-0.05232887342572212,
0.4691421687602997,
0.6101959943771362,
0.5621487498283386,
-0.5075623989105225,
0.653435230255127,
-0.09349031746387482,
0.032929904758930206,
-0.6149865388870239,
-0.6077219247817993,
-0.5732061266899109,
-0.6445621848106384,
-0.15538880228996277,
-0.12832440435886383,
0.2954084873199463,
0.5634007453918457,
0.9127378463745117,
-0.4406801164150238,
0.11403705924749374,
-0.42690718173980713,
-0.11466338485479355,
0.11800879240036011,
-0.2706148624420166,
0.26120254397392273,
-0.4321507215499878,
-0.44652214646339417,
0.23570379614830017,
0.5608183145523071,
0.012259858660399914,
-0.31508079171180725,
-0.12799781560897827,
0.4083400368690491,
0.1717383861541748,
0.46648135781288147,
0.0264402087777853,
-0.9295960068702698,
-0.23069176077842712,
0.0916842520236969,
-0.027142483741044998,
0.1496712863445282,
1.0361254215240479,
-0.8726597428321838,
0.9325616955757141,
0.5392329096794128,
0.5689992904663086,
1.1453620195388794,
-0.14714403450489044,
0.31106942892074585,
-0.9853935837745667,
0.24536047875881195,
0.014367598108947277,
0.10568751394748688,
-0.1274891197681427,
-0.27913209795951843,
0.1584138572216034,
0.3998695909976959,
-0.7916688919067383,
-0.8151216506958008,
0.14345361292362213,
-1.1109715700149536,
-0.0982038676738739,
1.2331231832504272,
0.19265462458133698,
-0.39786770939826965,
0.33606991171836853,
0.16919682919979095,
0.4705238342285156,
-0.5223052501678467,
0.6421442031860352,
0.6384789943695068,
0.3542413115501404,
-0.10363317281007767,
-0.8917360305786133,
0.49438226222991943,
0.470194548368454,
-0.3444458544254303,
-0.08016786724328995,
0.21089079976081848,
0.5077070593833923,
-0.1852712482213974,
0.7206247448921204,
-0.03295419365167618,
0.40885719656944275,
0.15218260884284973,
0.2524622082710266,
0.008838893845677376,
-0.41378554701805115,
-0.40514442324638367,
-0.15736018121242523,
0.22361664474010468,
-0.5021247267723083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02716v1 | Understanding the planning of LLM agents: A survey | 2024-02-05T04:25:24 | 2024-02-05T04:25:24 | Xu Huang, Weiwen Liu, Xiaolong Chen, Xingmei Wang, Hao Wang, Defu Lian, Yasheng Wang, Ruiming Tang, Enhong Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown significant intelligence, the
progress to leverage LLMs as planning modules of autonomous agents has
attracted more attention. This survey provides the first systematic view of
LLM-based agents planning, covering recent works aiming to improve planning
ability. We provide a taxonomy of existing works on LLM-Agent planning, which
can be categorized into Task Decomposition, Plan Selection, External Module,
Reflection and Memory. Comprehensive analyses are conducted for each direction,
and further challenges for the field of research are discussed. | [
-0.6005399823188782,
-0.5889627933502197,
0.8024758696556091,
-0.04012180492281914,
0.28648295998573303,
0.028255844488739967,
-0.23491516709327698,
-0.5088279247283936,
0.5291574001312256,
0.8926167488098145,
-0.8403482437133789,
-0.43379494547843933,
-0.48878684639930725,
0.11736400425434113,
-0.30675008893013,
0.441016286611557,
-0.07361462712287903,
0.10815542191267014,
-0.23298965394496918,
-0.038613419979810715,
-0.3557456433773041,
-0.3313129246234894,
-0.9207648634910583,
-0.49852651357650757,
0.7987833619117737,
0.6041684746742249,
0.559558093547821,
0.5081333518028259,
0.5922301411628723,
0.40717199444770813,
-0.2176554799079895,
0.23406614363193512,
-0.3974418640136719,
0.2676106095314026,
-0.3230976462364197,
-0.5280985236167908,
-0.9257628917694092,
-0.04875455051660538,
0.7053804993629456,
0.7238359451293945,
-0.08744259923696518,
0.049037665128707886,
-0.3892975449562073,
0.5106457471847534,
-0.4646128714084625,
0.38794127106666565,
-0.6047540903091431,
0.07298856973648071,
0.12796588242053986,
-0.11851978302001953,
-0.49374186992645264,
0.07197906821966171,
0.039423923939466476,
-0.14645789563655853,
-0.01496055256575346,
-0.11673644185066223,
0.051324497908353806,
0.2853853404521942,
-0.6554074883460999,
-0.4150976538658142,
-1.0693507194519043,
0.8299149870872498,
-0.4762043058872223,
0.09159428626298904,
0.40205830335617065,
0.4963569641113281,
-0.5161910057067871,
-0.6040844321250916,
-0.2659902572631836,
-0.3307096064090729,
0.03281620144844055,
0.06734316051006317,
-0.13651607930660248,
0.39913466572761536,
0.14146363735198975,
0.13610680401325226,
-0.6038105487823486,
0.5112475752830505,
-0.28536728024482727,
-0.07645409554243088,
1.098630666732788,
0.4482738673686981,
0.20511184632778168,
0.20808695256710052,
-0.2401631772518158,
0.10720278322696686,
-0.7399148344993591,
-0.1982824057340622,
0.2062838077545166,
0.1249835193157196,
0.23460829257965088,
0.8657659888267517,
-0.6634202599525452,
0.7579432129859924,
-0.4636151194572449,
-0.38902968168258667,
-0.5409337282180786,
-0.5261953473091125,
-0.33196717500686646,
-0.2902816832065582,
0.40109992027282715,
0.33579322695732117,
0.31505662202835083,
-0.2726660668849945,
-0.6051207780838013,
-0.20625002682209015,
0.24247050285339355,
-0.575332522392273,
-0.022881824523210526,
0.3749678432941437,
-0.365662544965744,
0.08808039873838425,
-0.368521511554718,
-0.10426409542560577,
-0.43576982617378235,
-0.43214431405067444,
0.022801797837018967,
-0.17283432185649872,
-0.29816359281539917,
0.0998622477054596,
0.030046654865145683,
0.5047866106033325,
0.47526952624320984,
-0.6701189875602722,
0.5656094551086426,
0.8572783470153809,
0.34064576029777527,
-0.016695531085133553,
-0.5177432894706726,
-0.11352463066577911,
0.2610260844230652,
-0.3978195786476135,
1.3082624673843384,
-0.2672562599182129,
-0.5226747393608093,
0.40744930505752563,
-0.06115526705980301,
0.13341709971427917,
-0.4543774724006653,
0.15315932035446167,
-0.6406639218330383,
-0.20427951216697693,
-0.4997505247592926,
-0.5140550136566162,
-0.3894372582435608,
0.7778190970420837,
-0.6860559582710266,
0.3883224129676819,
0.02855200693011284,
-0.23027710616588593,
0.49883779883384705,
-0.6207467913627625,
-0.28444966673851013,
0.11786410957574844,
-0.25668865442276,
0.24755842983722687,
-0.24711933732032776,
-0.07678277790546417,
0.7355930805206299,
-0.3902055323123932,
0.14772658050060272,
0.11332746595144272,
-0.03587773069739342,
0.5181195735931396,
0.08473874628543854,
0.5421584248542786,
0.2674882113933563,
0.13325728476047516,
0.6398065686225891,
-0.628322422504425,
0.031030496582388878,
-0.055714480578899384,
-0.22826066613197327,
0.08770635724067688,
0.43082764744758606,
-0.1436883807182312,
0.24790813028812408,
0.4730258882045746,
-0.2763875126838684,
0.7655388116836548,
-0.2402999997138977,
0.2606891095638275,
0.682541012763977,
-0.09736844152212143,
0.8732893466949463,
-0.5301944017410278,
0.787302553653717,
-0.4886387884616852,
0.3557467758655548,
-0.15255947411060333,
-0.4290832281112671,
-0.642530083656311,
-0.18393930792808533,
-0.16679701209068298,
0.3486210107803345,
-0.7641378045082092,
0.05269216373562813,
-0.20301680266857147,
-0.5938448309898376,
0.2642991244792938,
0.0688481405377388,
0.18149767816066742,
-0.22547461092472076,
0.09485145658254623,
-0.07482849806547165,
-0.2524348199367523,
-0.8955419659614563,
0.09445317089557648,
-0.4212716817855835,
0.2297540307044983,
0.209043949842453,
0.5351876616477966,
-0.43572306632995605,
0.893230140209198,
-0.5137352347373962,
-0.26425448060035706,
-0.9859883189201355,
-0.16229376196861267,
-0.1056215837597847,
-0.07482601702213287,
0.48242974281311035,
-0.5628284811973572,
-0.34429579973220825,
-0.11327530443668365,
-0.26513031125068665,
-0.07842662185430527,
-0.011574586853384972,
-0.13624250888824463,
0.06583759933710098,
0.6209362745285034,
-0.9657149910926819,
0.34459415078163147,
0.19210369884967804,
-0.3949776887893677,
0.581993579864502,
-0.09161289036273956,
-0.4329250454902649,
-0.7790917158126831,
-0.26414093375205994,
-0.14525045454502106,
-0.12434914708137512,
-0.7542659044265747,
0.2743850648403168,
-0.18970559537410736,
0.37685665488243103,
-0.5426745414733887,
0.8242880702018738,
-0.9715888500213623,
-0.4921227693557739,
-0.8151857852935791,
0.05537950247526169,
-0.5186124444007874,
0.38773515820503235,
0.08029045164585114,
0.5567952990531921,
0.4960600733757019,
-0.7280336022377014,
0.5833837985992432,
0.31352511048316956,
0.06558511406183243,
0.1629219502210617,
-0.20424573123455048,
0.26830020546913147,
-0.3140169680118561,
0.4183589220046997,
-0.9195345044136047,
-0.326947420835495,
0.31667980551719666,
-0.16623693704605103,
0.461088091135025,
-0.14524713158607483,
-0.48399272561073303,
-0.31939780712127686,
-0.27977558970451355,
0.37370163202285767,
0.2850760221481323,
-0.09450962394475937,
0.8533504009246826,
0.5512385964393616,
-0.26737457513809204,
-0.5368004441261292,
-0.486324667930603,
0.08963620662689209,
-0.056028012186288834,
-0.5748291015625,
0.09464523196220398,
-0.02240641601383686,
-1.0053261518478394,
0.05155681073665619,
0.2310902327299118,
-0.07688803225755692,
-0.19195614755153656,
0.11112402379512787,
-0.024286866188049316,
-0.16381442546844482,
0.024380359798669815,
-0.5359212160110474,
-0.09645530581474304,
0.2884725034236908,
0.007276022806763649,
0.7658262848854065,
0.37577563524246216,
-0.24549904465675354,
-0.007369220722466707,
0.33496153354644775,
0.3438436686992645,
-0.3193049430847168,
0.6658605933189392,
0.0401621013879776,
-0.20643799006938934,
-0.5174534916877747,
-0.5091891288757324,
-0.07212869822978973,
-0.433107852935791,
0.38291627168655396,
-0.17455115914344788,
-0.6182931661605835,
0.6167516112327576,
-0.10163377970457077,
0.2575128376483917,
0.3941899538040161,
0.6394696831703186,
0.14017990231513977,
0.7532929182052612,
1.0513818264007568,
-0.20103169977664948,
0.28136739134788513,
-0.5294842720031738,
-0.07220219075679779,
-0.6094958782196045,
-0.3736603558063507,
-0.4809311330318451,
-0.4938574433326721,
-0.42407047748565674,
-0.714006781578064,
-0.07244355231523514,
-0.583746075630188,
0.05283002182841301,
0.32145047187805176,
-0.2611246705055237,
0.41110584139823914,
0.17943091690540314,
-0.40516236424446106,
0.29441672563552856,
-0.44358476996421814,
0.3931606113910675,
0.6112484335899353,
-0.44582879543304443,
-0.7152366042137146,
1.0957521200180054,
0.4836910665035248,
0.9043612480163574,
0.101023830473423,
0.6117275953292847,
0.006883672904223204,
0.3294545114040375,
-1.1285412311553955,
1.1600443124771118,
0.2996632754802704,
-0.793298602104187,
-0.6363793015480042,
-0.13885824382305145,
-1.076634407043457,
0.20180507004261017,
0.16890504956245422,
-0.6700731515884399,
-0.02458144724369049,
-0.29140231013298035,
-0.11702041327953339,
0.3609426021575928,
-0.40202367305755615,
0.34649401903152466,
-0.4713931679725647,
0.13907964527606964,
-0.5457411408424377,
-0.31686413288116455,
0.2886877655982971,
0.07712776958942413,
-0.03167485073208809,
-0.4843341112136841,
-0.37085840106010437,
0.6489244699478149,
-0.21356624364852905,
0.477130264043808,
-0.2705298066139221,
-0.36427339911460876,
0.5931373238563538,
-0.07686441391706467,
0.47341322898864746,
-0.31194499135017395,
-0.10255879163742065,
-0.2748762369155884,
-0.16627418994903564,
-0.4208925664424896,
-0.4255569279193878,
0.47063446044921875,
-0.5116385221481323,
-0.6114073991775513,
-0.41680440306663513,
-1.032179832458496,
-0.2770482301712036,
0.07122267782688141,
-0.052041903138160706,
0.4222765266895294,
-0.6101227402687073,
-0.22752489149570465,
0.42011240124702454,
-0.09569168090820312,
0.8579117655754089,
0.815538227558136,
-0.765902578830719,
-0.035747501999139786,
0.4089518189430237,
0.6133152842521667,
0.30205148458480835,
0.5139309167861938,
-0.21960222721099854,
-0.30442461371421814,
-1.3001123666763306,
0.0635455772280693,
0.3716021478176117,
-0.829100489616394,
0.009228063747286797,
-0.4444911479949951,
-0.3517235219478607,
-0.5241442918777466,
-0.09808683395385742,
-0.348545104265213,
-0.3895639181137085,
0.18797554075717926,
-0.13731497526168823,
0.13479764759540558,
1.5227636098861694,
0.1259239763021469,
0.6324378252029419,
-0.30387017130851746,
0.20497377216815948,
0.2429044246673584,
0.10708398371934891,
-0.12704217433929443,
0.10068998485803604,
-0.3563351631164551,
-0.29779964685440063,
-0.16120237112045288,
-0.8199735879898071,
0.5667611956596375,
-0.18394359946250916,
0.8863040208816528,
0.5651935935020447,
0.06806560605764389,
0.24935737252235413,
-0.3681904077529907,
0.7990679144859314,
-0.25924935936927795,
-0.08848276734352112,
0.5501129627227783,
-0.33411097526550293,
0.3654704689979553,
0.299029678106308,
0.4521389305591583,
-0.2672692835330963,
-0.3357451260089874,
-0.6218383312225342,
-0.8248105049133301,
0.6347290277481079,
0.1774117350578308,
-0.0258509311825037,
0.13105709850788116,
0.36102691292762756,
0.034832898527383804,
0.05738907307386398,
-0.6333436965942383,
-0.3156077265739441,
0.6654331684112549,
0.23014546930789948,
-0.5488362312316895,
-0.6090664863586426,
-0.09243380278348923,
-0.2355644255876541,
0.4518744945526123,
-0.06905031949281693,
0.5858466029167175,
0.040572069585323334,
-0.21777789294719696,
-0.11874239146709442,
0.2570616900920868,
0.7543947100639343,
1.00406813621521,
-0.021281395107507706,
0.20064781606197357,
0.32135432958602905,
-0.4606527090072632,
0.17294949293136597,
0.03977121785283089,
-0.003386031836271286,
-0.292686402797699,
0.5859016180038452,
0.2499743551015854,
-0.1499105989933014,
-0.727375328540802,
0.1997309774160385,
-0.18812911212444305,
-0.3255952000617981,
-0.7582473754882812,
0.23437097668647766,
0.05193907395005226,
0.5532575249671936,
0.3376350700855255,
-0.33777695894241333,
0.13218361139297485,
-0.9612581729888916,
-0.11510570347309113,
0.6488105654716492,
-0.3065212070941925,
-0.3259589970111847,
0.02936583012342453,
0.10277549922466278,
-0.503203272819519,
0.267977237701416,
-0.4335300922393799,
-0.4384114742279053,
0.8159863352775574,
0.4573255181312561,
0.9727960824966431,
-0.2194465696811676,
0.08980943262577057,
0.021841319277882576,
0.5044723153114319,
0.028922947123646736,
0.683337390422821,
-0.04133734852075577,
-0.8764333128929138,
-0.3778790235519409,
-0.4159679114818573,
-0.52705317735672,
0.07839858531951904,
-0.07363592088222504,
0.14201393723487854,
-0.5333311557769775,
-0.17408306896686554,
-0.303473562002182,
0.3521418869495392,
-0.6128790378570557,
0.16426651179790497,
0.26665055751800537,
1.2105712890625,
-0.3561939299106598,
0.8872466087341309,
1.292773723602295,
-0.2968844771385193,
-0.8189505338668823,
-0.00003932896288461052,
-0.05994947999715805,
-0.9619974493980408,
0.6075299382209778,
-0.047252994030714035,
-0.5132563710212708,
-0.15262562036514282,
-0.6489713788032532,
-0.8776648640632629,
1.2404475212097168,
0.021143317222595215,
-0.23172824084758759,
-0.32868918776512146,
0.47621315717697144,
0.32348138093948364,
-0.39496660232543945,
0.4180096983909607,
0.6812112331390381,
0.6005798578262329,
0.10974475741386414,
-0.8285552859306335,
-0.14948917925357819,
-0.07156344503164291,
-0.31810063123703003,
0.3921387493610382,
-0.8100363612174988,
0.9151349067687988,
-0.030661098659038544,
-0.0948982834815979,
0.3070448338985443,
0.6888534426689148,
-0.11356428265571594,
0.5918329358100891,
0.31640997529029846,
0.2201060950756073,
0.4534348249435425,
0.13695965707302094,
0.959856390953064,
-0.2879808247089386,
-0.019299237057566643,
0.7207741737365723,
-0.37989068031311035,
0.7172508239746094,
0.21582671999931335,
-0.1844070553779602,
0.2801162600517273,
0.5040831565856934,
0.3572215437889099,
0.35369980335235596,
0.32670414447784424,
-0.4086895287036896,
-0.1055910661816597,
-0.1720883995294571,
-0.061809785664081573,
0.7604705691337585,
0.4680321216583252,
-0.04176415875554085,
-0.20094631612300873,
-0.04653938114643097,
-0.07047206908464432,
-0.11480503529310226,
-0.7756657004356384,
0.9433874487876892,
0.10074453800916672,
-0.858106791973114,
-0.03000923991203308,
0.024066783487796783,
0.43938833475112915,
-0.5687322020530701,
0.21261419355869293,
-0.1975845843553543,
0.19045411050319672,
-0.16119593381881714,
-1.1099584102630615,
0.34280160069465637,
-0.2138841152191162,
-0.038540106266736984,
-0.6596871018409729,
1.2396024465560913,
-0.18312467634677887,
-0.033159464597702026,
0.48845863342285156,
0.8318518400192261,
0.23439794778823853,
-0.23996104300022125,
-0.23379085958003998,
-0.13974615931510925,
-0.2597264051437378,
-0.2701786458492279,
0.2946063280105591,
0.5726637244224548,
0.0037286144215613604,
0.9579203724861145,
0.19172047078609467,
0.167649507522583,
0.24591825902462006,
-0.1363212913274765,
0.8055785298347473,
-1.2039774656295776,
-0.19055785238742828,
-0.6737458109855652,
0.4102962613105774,
0.041769836097955704,
-0.059570301324129105,
0.7417478561401367,
0.5182013511657715,
0.6401843428611755,
-0.059378381818532944,
0.3509332239627838,
0.2034267634153366,
0.37307533621788025,
-0.6155039668083191,
0.7364731431007385,
-0.389471173286438,
0.1297139823436737,
0.13647142052650452,
-0.9677537679672241,
0.03308054804801941,
0.37630677223205566,
-0.5851938724517822,
-0.1075255274772644,
0.5176392793655396,
0.8077725172042847,
0.3432765007019043,
-0.23158283531665802,
0.549013078212738,
0.06010597571730614,
0.3617750406265259,
0.5511042475700378,
1.6061879396438599,
0.2907983958721161,
0.201024129986763,
-0.2167808562517166,
-0.045794256031513214,
-0.19691771268844604,
-0.48144713044166565,
-0.9518798589706421,
-0.5608566999435425,
-0.1278296709060669,
0.46238210797309875,
-0.2985098958015442,
0.8837981820106506,
0.6522617936134338,
-0.28267624974250793,
-0.6886759400367737,
0.05932626500725746,
0.28666073083877563,
0.19584845006465912,
-0.05215596780180931,
-0.08743073046207428,
-0.39583608508110046,
-0.5084437727928162,
0.6219114661216736,
0.2630595266819,
-0.010272587649524212,
-0.7139634490013123,
-0.2876996397972107,
-0.29065847396850586,
0.3205593228340149,
0.9015340805053711,
0.48538902401924133,
-0.7293857932090759,
-0.01690136082470417,
0.1656818389892578,
-0.2522880434989929,
-0.1959787905216217,
0.8606123328208923,
-0.4979501962661743,
0.025605246424674988,
0.5031737685203552,
0.25972244143486023,
0.47553643584251404,
-0.30637258291244507,
0.4387386441230774,
-0.39414751529693604,
0.2129749208688736,
0.509558916091919,
0.4403170645236969,
-0.1683167964220047,
-0.3560797870159149,
0.642745316028595,
-0.3457878828048706,
-1.0047601461410522,
-0.5349243879318237,
0.5362271666526794,
-1.2275630235671997,
-0.3449092209339142,
1.4439650774002075,
0.3821386694908142,
-0.3815511465072632,
-0.19134904444217682,
-0.620938777923584,
0.17576509714126587,
-0.08721240609884262,
0.36806365847587585,
0.7017840147018433,
-0.7323246598243713,
-0.17388850450515747,
-0.6413238048553467,
0.40684306621551514,
-0.09964486211538315,
-0.8344771862030029,
-0.004417488817125559,
0.7988554835319519,
-0.08348902314901352,
0.1772589534521103,
1.395127773284912,
0.30142179131507874,
0.02325752191245556,
-0.06742401421070099,
0.15094377100467682,
0.11560966819524765,
-0.7343038320541382,
-0.1499345898628235,
0.2224791944026947,
0.8577948808670044,
0.11998205631971359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02695v2 | Exploiting Class Probabilities for Black-box Sentence-level Attacks | 2024-02-05T03:15:26 | 2024-02-21T00:09:00 | Raha Moraffah, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Sentence-level attacks craft adversarial sentences that are synonymous with
correctly-classified sentences but are misclassified by the text classifiers.
Under the black-box setting, classifiers are only accessible through their
feedback to queried inputs, which is predominately available in the form of
class probabilities. Even though utilizing class probabilities results in
stronger attacks, due to the challenges of using them for sentence-level
attacks, existing attacks use either no feedback or only the class labels.
Overcoming the challenges, we develop a novel algorithm that uses class
probabilities for black-box sentence-level attacks, investigate the
effectiveness of using class probabilities on the attack's success, and examine
the question if it is worthy or practical to use class probabilities by
black-box sentence-level attacks. We conduct extensive evaluations of our
attack comparing with the baselines across various classifiers and benchmark
datasets. | [
-0.16482025384902954,
-1.1909995079040527,
0.3947499394416809,
-0.0651761069893837,
0.12493649125099182,
0.23117461800575256,
-0.02356916479766369,
-0.6081389784812927,
-0.07455210387706757,
0.26669493317604065,
-0.27998507022857666,
-0.44809484481811523,
-0.6056782007217407,
-0.2494429051876068,
-0.6164541244506836,
1.1394826173782349,
0.5147642493247986,
-0.1524129956960678,
-0.03677419573068619,
0.30602842569351196,
-0.5595635771751404,
-0.9050120115280151,
-0.6377881765365601,
0.0938941165804863,
0.5626698732376099,
0.23341482877731323,
0.7970608472824097,
0.1142461821436882,
0.41864559054374695,
0.2654133141040802,
-0.00901569239795208,
-0.26735255122184753,
-0.4572286307811737,
-0.014287430793046951,
0.04627109318971634,
-0.6944987177848816,
-0.2912641167640686,
0.07951508462429047,
0.5385996103286743,
0.5963183641433716,
-0.053690310567617416,
-0.040963590145111084,
-0.007531692739576101,
0.4843493700027466,
-1.1139655113220215,
-0.044952504336833954,
-0.8533433675765991,
0.5489982962608337,
-0.29206788539886475,
-0.5484181642532349,
-1.0812139511108398,
-0.34553322196006775,
0.1738976538181305,
-0.2955698072910309,
0.29684171080589294,
-0.07365109026432037,
0.49524417519569397,
-0.06200413405895233,
-0.13010966777801514,
-0.2760951817035675,
-0.5524294376373291,
0.48977646231651306,
-0.5056654810905457,
-0.1390695422887802,
0.259699285030365,
0.4956912696361542,
-0.39257097244262695,
-0.4110763967037201,
-0.37826329469680786,
-0.30404654145240784,
-0.17971430718898773,
0.14465555548667908,
-0.41975805163383484,
0.2814083397388458,
0.16963528096675873,
0.4399454891681671,
-0.5242844820022583,
-0.048118121922016144,
-0.3901340067386627,
-0.003310068277642131,
0.7228116989135742,
-0.021585805341601372,
0.29355451464653015,
-0.24181440472602844,
-0.49132686853408813,
-0.13915786147117615,
-0.23433470726013184,
0.3276219367980957,
0.8209348320960999,
0.2356557697057724,
0.13868016004562378,
0.7680487036705017,
-0.08974839746952057,
1.0109599828720093,
-0.07679254561662674,
0.03948040306568146,
0.0448116660118103,
-0.133529394865036,
-0.24926233291625977,
0.3238881528377533,
0.9129742980003357,
0.35448405146598816,
0.2350424975156784,
-0.6751283407211304,
-0.18776394426822662,
0.4366167187690735,
0.8404222726821899,
-0.5800328850746155,
-0.4133707582950592,
0.31015744805336,
-0.22455188632011414,
-1.1006299257278442,
0.16940723359584808,
-1.1959896087646484,
-0.4894528090953827,
0.5974658131599426,
0.7739994525909424,
-0.1502530574798584,
-0.055245451629161835,
0.36863869428634644,
-0.6321457624435425,
0.007096758112311363,
-0.03906835988163948,
-0.5493465065956116,
0.12980452179908752,
0.6108327507972717,
0.6280505061149597,
0.10505083948373795,
-0.2832033038139343,
-0.8044564723968506,
0.15857325494289398,
-0.32594504952430725,
0.5488405823707581,
-0.9313932657241821,
-0.39070925116539,
0.16818730533123016,
-0.286236435174942,
0.016789857298135757,
-0.20462264120578766,
0.48805925250053406,
-0.6383336782455444,
0.32304346561431885,
0.4791162312030792,
-0.7574927806854248,
-0.05164974182844162,
0.37461644411087036,
-0.47948795557022095,
0.6806715726852417,
-0.08126142621040344,
-0.9503412246704102,
0.2694711685180664,
-0.6204675436019897,
-0.6508557200431824,
0.3156174123287201,
0.06854604929685593,
-0.6197524666786194,
0.3355269134044647,
0.0807042047381401,
0.6112924814224243,
0.35339513421058655,
-0.031506456434726715,
-0.5789615511894226,
-0.46252647042274475,
0.529437243938446,
-0.549635112285614,
0.836837887763977,
-0.019701270386576653,
-0.4836280643939972,
-0.02896421030163765,
-0.8791903257369995,
0.14450648427009583,
0.3735902011394501,
-0.029647456482052803,
-0.4189336597919464,
0.18027406930923462,
-0.09504620730876923,
-0.10168393701314926,
0.25047409534454346,
-0.6380871534347534,
0.6243220567703247,
-0.559058427810669,
0.466457337141037,
0.5660774111747742,
0.38164573907852173,
0.4620143473148346,
-0.24479223787784576,
0.6854878664016724,
-0.23176315426826477,
0.3894454538822174,
0.16313496232032776,
-0.39503973722457886,
-0.38957804441452026,
-0.0523681603372097,
0.384525328874588,
0.8104418516159058,
-0.9556881785392761,
0.46863889694213867,
0.3230136036872864,
-0.7667726278305054,
-0.5876045227050781,
-0.23605908453464508,
0.48433825373649597,
0.26756173372268677,
0.4719710350036621,
-0.2516382932662964,
-0.28933900594711304,
-0.5311328768730164,
-0.49997222423553467,
-0.348958283662796,
0.14876991510391235,
-0.264408677816391,
0.3287281394004822,
0.010240716859698296,
0.6584060192108154,
-1.0764480829238892,
-0.40337541699409485,
-0.32287806272506714,
0.1276254504919052,
-0.23874296247959137,
0.4473173916339874,
0.6487113237380981,
-0.5689423084259033,
-0.02601591870188713,
-0.35467636585235596,
-0.8584057688713074,
0.21990296244621277,
-0.32575511932373047,
-0.18933552503585815,
0.22241677343845367,
0.49937328696250916,
-0.2599111497402191,
0.6833060383796692,
0.31123825907707214,
-0.5753217935562134,
0.5449815988540649,
-0.1262620985507965,
0.05152132734656334,
-0.7724955081939697,
-0.4083237946033478,
0.3664269745349884,
-0.010952923446893692,
-0.9058364629745483,
0.40037795901298523,
0.08071427047252655,
-0.30600446462631226,
-0.46180108189582825,
0.15951275825500488,
-0.24570752680301666,
0.06859306246042252,
-0.2708422839641571,
-0.005622610449790955,
-0.17294317483901978,
0.6745185852050781,
-0.20463800430297852,
0.4754510223865509,
0.5906034111976624,
-0.3767787218093872,
0.322649210691452,
-0.009407439269125462,
-0.2906167805194855,
0.7762434482574463,
-0.5690711736679077,
0.017258204519748688,
-0.11737431585788727,
0.24271467328071594,
-0.765388548374176,
0.03800256922841072,
0.37345245480537415,
-0.7134278416633606,
0.41066864132881165,
-0.06553474813699722,
-0.5567388534545898,
-0.39112597703933716,
-0.5193501114845276,
0.10896921902894974,
0.24799636006355286,
-0.49436697363853455,
0.2443595975637436,
0.5908652544021606,
0.18163402378559113,
-1.094664454460144,
-0.6498885750770569,
0.36111071705818176,
-0.1534947007894516,
-0.29064318537712097,
0.09375964105129242,
-0.09810269623994827,
-0.029572831466794014,
-0.01700695976614952,
-0.24766303598880768,
0.09189628064632416,
0.6146434545516968,
0.1390550434589386,
0.27549290657043457,
0.12150713801383972,
-0.29265305399894714,
-0.21398869156837463,
0.059307828545570374,
0.436296671628952,
-0.49331921339035034,
0.6389009952545166,
-0.06648683547973633,
-0.23909161984920502,
-0.7628163695335388,
0.21670573949813843,
0.23736725747585297,
-0.2320016771554947,
0.7671687602996826,
0.41191771626472473,
-0.4956175684928894,
-0.4858706295490265,
-0.40341460704803467,
-0.19724145531654358,
-0.4990033507347107,
0.6663397550582886,
-0.5590900778770447,
-0.7641363739967346,
0.09829957038164139,
0.5123290419578552,
0.23632661998271942,
0.14723454415798187,
0.19493824243545532,
-0.16847862303256989,
0.9049076437950134,
0.30114105343818665,
-0.11637434363365173,
0.596560537815094,
-0.38524067401885986,
0.3873378336429596,
-0.4502415657043457,
-0.34683138132095337,
-0.5555254817008972,
-0.27222973108291626,
-0.6814009547233582,
0.08646935969591141,
0.16458524763584137,
0.12371514737606049,
-0.014906446449458599,
0.6118371486663818,
-0.8516638875007629,
0.5389901399612427,
0.8616992235183716,
0.4317490756511688,
0.09700325131416321,
0.06503453850746155,
0.27582085132598877,
0.2532752454280853,
-0.7504540681838989,
-0.20542672276496887,
1.30567467212677,
0.27176013588905334,
0.5477956533432007,
0.18580415844917297,
0.9342976808547974,
0.5548979640007019,
-0.0020842268131673336,
-0.6501502990722656,
0.862545371055603,
-0.36781781911849976,
-0.47389551997184753,
-0.3769543766975403,
-0.7267621159553528,
-1.1428356170654297,
0.24811282753944397,
-0.5220801830291748,
-0.7010303735733032,
0.11679088324308395,
-0.06472243368625641,
-0.08000263571739197,
0.6498933434486389,
-0.905497133731842,
1.2150728702545166,
-0.06932184845209122,
-0.2886546552181244,
-0.030126644298434258,
-0.6268516778945923,
0.2137656807899475,
-0.036734454333782196,
0.2563469111919403,
0.439015656709671,
0.29467153549194336,
0.693424642086029,
-0.44780585169792175,
0.9060137867927551,
-0.5493559837341309,
-0.12978044152259827,
0.21366223692893982,
0.1959700882434845,
0.3142814338207245,
0.10981254279613495,
0.10984180867671967,
0.08149535953998566,
-0.0514313206076622,
-0.7302342653274536,
-0.7276157736778259,
0.3314533531665802,
-0.8885748386383057,
-0.742155134677887,
-0.7246625423431396,
-0.3798055946826935,
-0.30188503861427307,
-0.13285496830940247,
0.2209513783454895,
0.6748682260513306,
-0.12434640526771545,
0.102959044277668,
0.5131198763847351,
-0.2638980746269226,
0.5825214982032776,
0.4048549234867096,
0.14711220562458038,
-0.57847660779953,
1.4668980836868286,
0.2164507508277893,
0.4526357054710388,
0.7962702512741089,
0.08207503706216812,
-0.12446510046720505,
-0.703816831111908,
-0.3991732895374298,
-0.237465962767601,
-0.46780914068222046,
-0.44007569551467896,
-0.7171756029129028,
-0.45480889081954956,
-0.3745778203010559,
-0.41339051723480225,
0.31009066104888916,
-0.6128864288330078,
0.016213221475481987,
-0.28345292806625366,
0.047417785972356796,
0.5643853545188904,
0.35998469591140747,
0.39049243927001953,
-0.4890066683292389,
0.20238222181797028,
0.5880447030067444,
0.12458578497171402,
0.10007601231336594,
-0.21803928911685944,
0.02541714534163475,
-0.09041953831911087,
-0.5692233443260193,
-1.352696180343628,
0.2915196120738983,
-0.11493109166622162,
0.4236094057559967,
0.11426829546689987,
0.3380119204521179,
0.44499319791793823,
-0.4607114791870117,
0.7820250988006592,
0.2242465317249298,
-0.9081164002418518,
0.8220566511154175,
0.054652776569128036,
0.09271415323019028,
0.5450143218040466,
0.19885650277137756,
-0.12994599342346191,
-1.2274515628814697,
-1.0364556312561035,
-0.6323429346084595,
0.8129069805145264,
0.4015481770038605,
-0.10094943642616272,
-0.036491625010967255,
0.5126867294311523,
-0.17895010113716125,
0.37044602632522583,
-0.9840067625045776,
-0.6294773817062378,
-0.4194748103618622,
-0.34569665789604187,
-0.21757882833480835,
-0.23157593607902527,
-0.055046118795871735,
0.24606651067733765,
0.6218454837799072,
0.23921720683574677,
0.11487603932619095,
0.0035171485505998135,
-0.1850670874118805,
0.12363918125629425,
0.6849227547645569,
0.2979995608329773,
0.14597684144973755,
-0.31608137488365173,
0.32421743869781494,
0.11485835164785385,
-0.7635377049446106,
0.3599863350391388,
0.4508029520511627,
-0.5448459982872009,
-0.16536220908164978,
0.43798670172691345,
0.5436848998069763,
0.334714412689209,
-0.47764772176742554,
0.7454944252967834,
-0.35275033116340637,
-0.2025839388370514,
-0.35538774728775024,
0.34871718287467957,
-0.5179648995399475,
0.28436797857284546,
0.4387884736061096,
0.23872727155685425,
0.391812801361084,
-0.6515007615089417,
0.3240646719932556,
0.7423486113548279,
-0.5095938444137573,
-0.030508236959576607,
0.7676268815994263,
0.0424555204808712,
-0.5070039629936218,
0.10678405314683914,
-0.22839003801345825,
-0.7057662606239319,
0.6657705903053284,
0.549613356590271,
0.8126776814460754,
-0.09785689413547516,
0.5847043395042419,
0.1417282521724701,
0.5282207727432251,
-0.21552711725234985,
-0.06586329638957977,
0.07566358149051666,
-0.45061686635017395,
-0.1571861207485199,
-0.6401811838150024,
-0.6889182329177856,
0.0657191351056099,
-0.8083372712135315,
0.19677138328552246,
-0.6082459092140198,
-0.10846652090549469,
0.3049182593822479,
0.3637339770793915,
-0.20197217166423798,
0.2279486060142517,
0.00582905812188983,
0.7623080611228943,
-0.5481044054031372,
0.5298731923103333,
0.7893154621124268,
-0.5923498868942261,
-0.37112823128700256,
0.20581454038619995,
-0.05342483147978783,
-0.6802338361740112,
0.42550376057624817,
0.29196473956108093,
0.19629260897636414,
-0.10689126700162888,
-0.43863528966903687,
-0.1856350153684616,
0.610424280166626,
0.2003505378961563,
-0.5589028596878052,
-0.2816087603569031,
0.20512349903583527,
0.4834636151790619,
-0.014782854355871677,
0.006387574132531881,
0.43020302057266235,
0.30156266689300537,
-0.1754872053861618,
-0.3883403241634369,
-0.01683161035180092,
-0.30242520570755005,
-0.19138020277023315,
0.39372095465660095,
-0.48233047127723694,
0.3946117162704468,
-0.04202008247375488,
-0.14837802946567535,
-0.42641496658325195,
0.9845120906829834,
0.1968042105436325,
0.5755496621131897,
0.630255401134491,
0.9088535308837891,
0.6045722365379333,
-0.132904052734375,
1.0933791399002075,
-0.2432190626859665,
0.18232062458992004,
0.9495493173599243,
0.061099570244550705,
1.1091340780258179,
-0.06577343493700027,
-0.18812808394432068,
0.3996785581111908,
0.2662084996700287,
-0.3054654002189636,
0.5388278365135193,
0.5649785399436951,
-0.4142332077026367,
0.016605166718363762,
0.3507566452026367,
-0.3424868881702423,
0.14389067888259888,
0.2658747136592865,
0.16556842625141144,
-0.011135129258036613,
0.27965813875198364,
0.3129672706127167,
0.17335081100463867,
-0.5274441242218018,
0.97678542137146,
-0.21422022581100464,
-0.6120243668556213,
0.48183757066726685,
0.022418834269046783,
0.9525448679924011,
-0.41766855120658875,
0.2991580665111542,
0.048355039209127426,
0.2546647787094116,
-0.3692633807659149,
-1.0061020851135254,
0.1602601706981659,
0.1748490333557129,
-0.13174358010292053,
0.049665119498968124,
0.4772528409957886,
-0.5030876398086548,
-0.556241512298584,
0.11927906423807144,
-0.031232217326760292,
-0.14481016993522644,
-0.01829647086560726,
-0.45586761832237244,
-0.16946156322956085,
-0.08298960328102112,
0.057393256574869156,
0.5812810063362122,
0.48812028765678406,
0.4066082537174225,
0.535876452922821,
0.4808866083621979,
0.39988142251968384,
0.1568009853363037,
-0.03314843028783798,
0.5959938764572144,
-0.7106005549430847,
-0.48013195395469666,
-0.966328501701355,
0.12310770153999329,
-0.3723158836364746,
-0.11692619323730469,
0.736007571220398,
0.6734367609024048,
1.1970546245574951,
0.11984038352966309,
0.9759179353713989,
0.17200511693954468,
0.22788113355636597,
-0.46402931213378906,
0.6072142124176025,
-0.5137174725532532,
0.4280225336551666,
-0.5578089952468872,
-0.607980489730835,
-0.4276852309703827,
0.5426331162452698,
-0.4593692421913147,
-0.383938193321228,
0.703464925289154,
0.6457821726799011,
0.44040629267692566,
0.3175703287124634,
0.18553151190280914,
0.11946045607328415,
0.5921518802642822,
0.8314772844314575,
0.8958883881568909,
-0.5451183319091797,
0.9992495179176331,
-0.4009140133857727,
-0.5155329704284668,
-0.30363595485687256,
-0.48665758967399597,
-1.3267171382904053,
-0.26295167207717896,
-0.5824905037879944,
-0.7220316529273987,
0.535677969455719,
0.3865554630756378,
0.38481223583221436,
-0.672505259513855,
-0.012215245515108109,
-0.03997039049863815,
0.17934481799602509,
-0.39330828189849854,
-0.4137841761112213,
0.43677380681037903,
-0.7912008762359619,
-0.5166275501251221,
0.39303091168403625,
0.13636073470115662,
0.0994897410273552,
-0.2594023644924164,
0.4967133104801178,
-0.05881979316473007,
0.06600187718868256,
0.6006417274475098,
0.1437978446483612,
-0.3333224058151245,
-0.3256031274795532,
-0.13767193257808685,
-0.18109792470932007,
-0.1912178248167038,
0.6834090352058411,
-0.7115048766136169,
0.2932389974594116,
0.3145056962966919,
0.9019877314567566,
0.1882587969303131,
-0.1168239638209343,
0.4902796447277069,
-0.9865834712982178,
0.21763627231121063,
0.3185805082321167,
0.2637220025062561,
0.12908591330051422,
-0.47478392720222473,
0.5335015654563904,
0.3695770800113678,
-0.40389350056648254,
-1.2510603666305542,
0.25712230801582336,
-1.0789062976837158,
-0.797157883644104,
0.8749943375587463,
-0.0003770784824155271,
-0.2071612924337387,
0.02679910510778427,
-0.2079622745513916,
0.030002253130078316,
-0.4050813317298889,
0.9789773225784302,
0.6597943902015686,
0.329632431268692,
-0.06741106510162354,
-0.7173543572425842,
0.5666776895523071,
0.29813963174819946,
-0.9965390563011169,
-0.11121411621570587,
0.3125905394554138,
-0.07094103842973709,
0.24827736616134644,
0.24191038310527802,
-0.13684582710266113,
0.2803082764148712,
-0.007251631934195757,
-0.17122937738895416,
0.03693539649248123,
-0.5334940552711487,
-0.34481751918792725,
1.2456815242767334,
-0.29140999913215637,
-0.3554595410823822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05126v1 | Graph Neural Network and NER-Based Text Summarization | 2024-02-05T03:00:44 | 2024-02-05T03:00:44 | Imaad Zaffar Khan, Amaan Aijaz Sheikh, Utkarsh Sinha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the abundance of data and information in todays time, it is nearly
impossible for man, or, even machine, to go through all of the data line by
line. What one usually does is to try to skim through the lines and retain the
absolutely important information, that in a more formal term is called
summarization. Text summarization is an important task that aims to compress
lengthy documents or articles into shorter, coherent representations while
preserving the core information and meaning. This project introduces an
innovative approach to text summarization, leveraging the capabilities of Graph
Neural Networks (GNNs) and Named Entity Recognition (NER) systems. GNNs, with
their exceptional ability to capture and process the relational data inherent
in textual information, are adept at understanding the complex structures
within large documents. Meanwhile, NER systems contribute by identifying and
emphasizing key entities, ensuring that the summarization process maintains a
focus on the most critical aspects of the text. By integrating these two
technologies, our method aims to enhances the efficiency of summarization and
also tries to ensures a high degree relevance in the condensed content. This
project, therefore, offers a promising direction for handling the ever
increasing volume of textual data in an information-saturated world. | [
-0.3132084012031555,
-0.8308779001235962,
0.40535396337509155,
0.10409831255674362,
-0.3707124888896942,
0.341765433549881,
0.04170164838433266,
-0.5091211199760437,
0.680712878704071,
0.49386465549468994,
-0.11912637948989868,
-0.5808225274085999,
-0.6390671133995056,
0.2397450953722,
-0.7068047523498535,
1.3443206548690796,
0.049814723432064056,
-0.12962576746940613,
-0.23659969866275787,
-0.05012945085763931,
-0.339592307806015,
-0.6252805590629578,
-0.9953711628913879,
-0.7671394944190979,
0.8494792580604553,
0.2309546023607254,
0.4900176227092743,
0.6027438044548035,
0.5631134510040283,
0.3605573773384094,
-0.3982093334197998,
0.27662619948387146,
-0.623124897480011,
0.19313466548919678,
0.09857210516929626,
-0.10258786380290985,
-0.5934052467346191,
-0.3849111497402191,
0.8036664724349976,
0.7293340563774109,
0.26408714056015015,
0.033473581075668335,
0.2518107295036316,
0.9285848140716553,
-0.3229052722454071,
0.42512601613998413,
-0.1696772426366806,
0.2128886580467224,
0.12623269855976105,
-0.16653864085674286,
-0.18618528544902802,
-0.549490749835968,
0.2207091897726059,
-0.6840725541114807,
0.04913642257452011,
0.0025225221179425716,
0.9827550649642944,
-0.04109781235456467,
-0.592851996421814,
-0.2483455091714859,
-0.6438791155815125,
0.2342316061258316,
-0.7551048398017883,
0.1295638233423233,
0.012491434812545776,
0.027417128905653954,
-0.03635489568114281,
-1.056904673576355,
-0.36668041348457336,
0.12010219693183899,
-0.28361406922340393,
0.33724766969680786,
-0.17184622585773468,
0.07208339124917984,
0.0392458476126194,
0.24160043895244598,
-0.6100243330001831,
0.04515118896961212,
-0.23656444251537323,
-0.23476119339466095,
0.5290058255195618,
0.3356069326400757,
0.5436578989028931,
-0.3512153625488281,
-0.18781577050685883,
0.16067750751972198,
-0.3381456434726715,
-0.22348754107952118,
0.521756112575531,
0.3279195725917816,
0.07449125498533249,
0.5572501420974731,
-0.44235971570014954,
0.6289055347442627,
-0.2563322186470032,
0.014830638654530048,
0.11345759779214859,
-0.5066927671432495,
-0.3251483142375946,
0.5003286004066467,
1.056788444519043,
0.6630010008811951,
0.37180468440055847,
-0.4277137815952301,
-0.10289771854877472,
-0.09878652542829514,
-0.04443000257015228,
-1.0747824907302856,
-0.319953978061676,
-0.08128932118415833,
-0.6782202124595642,
-0.4276929199695587,
-0.09698931127786636,
-0.85440593957901,
-0.43862849473953247,
-0.5354006290435791,
0.21816998720169067,
-0.4336600601673126,
-0.27690067887306213,
-0.2137337476015091,
-0.5777660608291626,
-0.07712246477603912,
0.5403284430503845,
-0.9689672589302063,
0.5705280303955078,
0.7298586368560791,
1.3676173686981201,
0.02123071439564228,
-0.11628617346286774,
-0.35806599259376526,
0.3684130311012268,
-0.18808820843696594,
0.8053256869316101,
-0.15442310273647308,
-0.38977205753326416,
-0.35144272446632385,
-0.17506790161132812,
-0.21755772829055786,
-0.3355315029621124,
0.14344526827335358,
-0.6917673349380493,
-0.029119135811924934,
-0.08849715441465378,
-0.6473757028579712,
-0.5255816578865051,
0.4166082739830017,
-0.7723119854927063,
0.9159733653068542,
0.07720198482275009,
-1.070880651473999,
-0.005241189152002335,
-0.5709319710731506,
-0.7127824425697327,
0.09785565733909607,
-0.1196378841996193,
-0.5402483344078064,
0.03840816393494606,
0.2637283504009247,
0.48536670207977295,
-0.09842807054519653,
0.16155403852462769,
0.018567141145467758,
-0.49829748272895813,
0.1317930519580841,
-0.0840286836028099,
0.6080467700958252,
-0.14023424685001373,
-0.04578162357211113,
0.1941409707069397,
-0.6030803918838501,
0.06245970353484154,
0.16984739899635315,
-0.3745565712451935,
-0.48976585268974304,
-0.12753356993198395,
0.23881085216999054,
-0.04422224685549736,
0.2724706828594208,
-0.25070464611053467,
0.2019200474023819,
-0.505547285079956,
0.7023051381111145,
0.39394208788871765,
0.3560951352119446,
0.5379230976104736,
-0.1694038212299347,
0.41409507393836975,
-0.24626122415065765,
-0.1978588104248047,
-0.2833822965621948,
-0.5616822838783264,
-0.5584151744842529,
0.08896811306476593,
0.7220475077629089,
0.9813517928123474,
-0.8543552756309509,
0.3463345468044281,
-0.5189434289932251,
-0.5158978700637817,
0.2337063103914261,
-0.049960535019636154,
0.3146935999393463,
0.9362152218818665,
0.2586629092693329,
-0.3061835765838623,
-0.6286313533782959,
-0.6483608484268188,
-0.19196142256259918,
-0.15349431335926056,
0.08190198987722397,
0.4061789810657501,
0.5985691547393799,
0.03457199037075043,
0.8031145930290222,
-0.6320317387580872,
-0.4306541979312897,
-0.5796465873718262,
0.14942656457424164,
0.3155333697795868,
0.44258347153663635,
0.3547336757183075,
-1.0678589344024658,
-0.4812794029712677,
0.20445646345615387,
-1.1216251850128174,
0.19886071979999542,
-0.01123812235891819,
0.015939636155962944,
-0.13259756565093994,
0.9442922472953796,
-0.43720579147338867,
0.630732536315918,
0.1852681040763855,
-0.2882894277572632,
0.4072510302066803,
-0.46924328804016113,
0.024342838674783707,
-1.0892056226730347,
0.21478809416294098,
-0.1672276258468628,
-0.3370388448238373,
-0.6226580739021301,
-0.3221155107021332,
-0.04908979684114456,
-0.39948150515556335,
-0.02918015420436859,
0.35554608702659607,
-0.7018155455589294,
-0.14967069029808044,
-0.3694549798965454,
0.472406804561615,
0.26541054248809814,
0.3968355059623718,
-0.20100924372673035,
0.5875808596611023,
0.23792505264282227,
-0.7709043025970459,
0.588607668876648,
0.5592486262321472,
-0.01386238168925047,
0.3438529968261719,
-0.8245230913162231,
-0.0487496517598629,
-0.4109381139278412,
0.2960854470729828,
-0.7465959787368774,
-0.2169458568096161,
0.4380600154399872,
-0.6543939113616943,
0.4309273660182953,
-0.12126459926366806,
-0.5764105916023254,
-0.1301136314868927,
-0.07919357717037201,
0.2918410301208496,
0.10160047560930252,
0.040732719004154205,
0.939102292060852,
0.5165067315101624,
-0.554911196231842,
-0.6504111289978027,
-0.8320227265357971,
0.7834798097610474,
-0.07798610627651215,
-0.42284494638442993,
0.5250071883201599,
0.23323896527290344,
-0.006579732988029718,
0.4711648225784302,
-0.01373718585819006,
-0.11254917085170746,
0.19967222213745117,
0.2528685927391052,
0.2692948579788208,
-0.22160376608371735,
0.2959665060043335,
0.14667938649654388,
-0.4695824086666107,
-0.03922353312373161,
-0.5595057010650635,
0.5657287836074829,
-0.15970519185066223,
0.1626005321741104,
-0.4622565507888794,
0.5802837014198303,
0.3203127682209015,
-0.32759878039360046,
0.7516310214996338,
0.42748409509658813,
-0.6016852855682373,
0.13254030048847198,
-0.08196457475423813,
0.0852118730545044,
-0.3677231967449188,
0.6005758047103882,
-0.06573443114757538,
-0.7951198220252991,
0.7418266534805298,
-0.34533971548080444,
-0.45390045642852783,
0.5140548348426819,
0.14782476425170898,
-0.1035386249423027,
0.75333571434021,
0.6198168396949768,
-0.3265524208545685,
0.6955572962760925,
-0.5185494422912598,
0.3272632360458374,
-1.0811198949813843,
-0.37480491399765015,
-0.46942558884620667,
-0.6713220477104187,
-0.38043907284736633,
0.1380009949207306,
0.19586020708084106,
0.21994648873806,
-0.043358128517866135,
0.39211395382881165,
-0.8456431031227112,
0.6714978814125061,
0.49032050371170044,
0.21850153803825378,
0.3226422965526581,
-0.13959191739559174,
-0.21244356036186218,
0.25252217054367065,
-0.6458970904350281,
-0.4059734642505646,
0.9529590010643005,
0.03916424512863159,
0.39128851890563965,
-0.04981409013271332,
0.8491485714912415,
0.2844199240207672,
0.2430613934993744,
-0.9120034575462341,
0.8101277351379395,
-0.24170507490634918,
-0.19932012259960175,
-0.6038344502449036,
-0.6164659857749939,
-1.0279104709625244,
0.14013205468654633,
-0.21692897379398346,
-0.8288247585296631,
0.1708647459745407,
-0.04605572298169136,
-0.22142940759658813,
0.4245046079158783,
-0.6463514566421509,
0.8275099992752075,
-0.12576159834861755,
0.06394103169441223,
0.08072831481695175,
-0.889835774898529,
0.05183861777186394,
0.20702004432678223,
-0.038023386150598526,
-0.0005321435746736825,
-0.1832512468099594,
0.8864947557449341,
-0.4047403633594513,
0.6132780909538269,
0.014638316817581654,
0.35021036863327026,
0.31027349829673767,
-0.18848976492881775,
0.5293793678283691,
0.1910405457019806,
0.0624152347445488,
0.11114656180143356,
-0.5089666843414307,
-0.16062043607234955,
-0.7031261920928955,
0.7085254788398743,
-0.5223773717880249,
-0.010428537614643574,
-0.4549817740917206,
-0.5906558632850647,
0.1908973753452301,
0.8894449472427368,
0.44295722246170044,
0.8024775385856628,
-0.36043456196784973,
0.026741115376353264,
0.7590724229812622,
0.03685816749930382,
0.7244797945022583,
-0.13384035229682922,
-0.4965997338294983,
-1.0856894254684448,
1.150471568107605,
0.556853711605072,
-0.04880714789032936,
0.6648030281066895,
-0.037355318665504456,
-0.14438194036483765,
-1.0073142051696777,
-0.5599536299705505,
0.2354041486978531,
-0.7905613780021667,
-0.35215479135513306,
-0.9831163287162781,
-0.538232684135437,
-0.45176637172698975,
-0.25178492069244385,
0.21317845582962036,
-0.6384190320968628,
-0.5533365607261658,
-0.21481123566627502,
0.29339686036109924,
0.9048652052879333,
0.274111270904541,
0.3619239032268524,
-0.9308369159698486,
0.48897674679756165,
0.0928536206483841,
0.3519256114959717,
0.21648897230625153,
-0.0014121108688414097,
-0.3737529218196869,
-0.3471766412258148,
-0.1481722593307495,
-1.0605653524398804,
0.5663580894470215,
0.1658114492893219,
0.393454372882843,
0.2111511379480362,
-0.2614656686782837,
0.36090362071990967,
-0.45899027585983276,
0.4436296820640564,
0.3066202700138092,
-0.9506246447563171,
0.4401792883872986,
-0.5455948114395142,
0.3744280934333801,
0.5531874299049377,
0.18258629739284515,
-0.8336114883422852,
-0.22863352298736572,
-0.5545214414596558,
-1.268872618675232,
0.5554593801498413,
0.3729060888290405,
-0.05277009308338165,
0.17670036852359772,
0.6020147800445557,
-0.2512805163860321,
0.4888950288295746,
-0.4149578809738159,
-0.37706607580184937,
-0.4380796253681183,
-0.5357692241668701,
-0.2200954258441925,
-0.06997166574001312,
0.13220715522766113,
-0.03453018143773079,
0.8481652736663818,
-0.3146841824054718,
0.31827929615974426,
0.4483988285064697,
-0.2957276701927185,
0.5233693718910217,
0.11721533536911011,
0.7266693711280823,
0.5363650321960449,
-0.10553673654794693,
0.06859549134969711,
0.24788540601730347,
-0.849341869354248,
0.0832330510020256,
0.3812890648841858,
-0.698074221611023,
0.29720765352249146,
0.2670329213142395,
0.7945313453674316,
0.19733747839927673,
-0.1473560482263565,
0.3316044807434082,
-0.28800535202026367,
-0.16893304884433746,
-0.26232001185417175,
-0.12372077256441116,
0.41153356432914734,
0.12689267098903656,
0.37334442138671875,
0.2805681824684143,
0.41995275020599365,
-0.23839029669761658,
0.17201903462409973,
0.12757597863674164,
-0.6222519278526306,
-0.0651993602514267,
0.5652470588684082,
0.19242914021015167,
-0.49716490507125854,
0.7930242419242859,
-0.1669628620147705,
-0.546969473361969,
1.1267313957214355,
0.6067733764648438,
0.9127944111824036,
0.2080867886543274,
0.36022284626960754,
0.3571861982345581,
0.237528458237648,
0.06196499988436699,
0.20658718049526215,
0.10092992335557938,
-0.580621063709259,
-0.38113877177238464,
-0.21274183690547943,
-0.46586713194847107,
-0.20934052765369415,
-0.4210263788700104,
0.10847016423940659,
-0.6098853349685669,
-0.3521451950073242,
0.2113429605960846,
-0.1541730910539627,
-0.20588469505310059,
0.33755046129226685,
0.01548384502530098,
0.816402018070221,
-0.5819960832595825,
0.3144717514514923,
0.7131487131118774,
-0.571240246295929,
-0.7346639633178711,
-0.20978036522865295,
-0.12749940156936646,
-0.36090755462646484,
0.6344122886657715,
0.390200674533844,
-0.041161421686410904,
0.42924219369888306,
-0.10220802575349808,
-0.7621362209320068,
1.3008203506469727,
0.3249238133430481,
-0.23497061431407928,
-0.555541455745697,
-0.13098055124282837,
0.5593537092208862,
-0.3559275269508362,
0.30615437030792236,
0.270724892616272,
0.46197715401649475,
-0.1007053330540657,
-0.6325643658638,
0.06742140650749207,
-0.5164871215820312,
0.12164165079593658,
0.8033719658851624,
-0.6821484565734863,
0.8247326016426086,
-0.26636338233947754,
-0.1823461651802063,
-0.10363198071718216,
0.7873302698135376,
-0.3140209913253784,
0.735517680644989,
0.17511093616485596,
0.6423220634460449,
0.9892708659172058,
-0.31630173325538635,
0.9151086807250977,
-0.1694408506155014,
0.31785401701927185,
1.2435847520828247,
-0.06169092655181885,
0.44562041759490967,
0.15080901980400085,
0.21898820996284485,
0.6829692125320435,
0.47697773575782776,
-0.050609759986400604,
0.28178226947784424,
0.2206391543149948,
-0.2697640359401703,
0.1660173386335373,
-0.4388320744037628,
-0.34829768538475037,
0.30320194363594055,
0.42340412735939026,
-0.47920843958854675,
-0.33571577072143555,
0.025904620066285133,
0.1357092410326004,
0.11486396193504333,
-0.6269758343696594,
1.1436153650283813,
0.19020745158195496,
-0.33845168352127075,
-0.10595757514238358,
-0.15677909553050995,
0.16957803070545197,
-0.551220178604126,
-0.09813957661390305,
0.0967727079987526,
0.05713105574250221,
-0.387428343296051,
-0.6665334701538086,
0.3316691517829895,
-0.30104103684425354,
-0.40781229734420776,
-0.2524413466453552,
1.2872503995895386,
-0.23778574168682098,
-0.42190638184547424,
0.40566304326057434,
0.37673288583755493,
0.064342200756073,
-0.16412848234176636,
-0.4401782155036926,
-0.32173240184783936,
-0.23155800998210907,
-0.09179897606372833,
0.25065407156944275,
0.5837680697441101,
-0.031189946457743645,
0.5853796005249023,
0.5526772737503052,
0.2888285219669342,
-0.2010357826948166,
0.24296912550926208,
0.98295658826828,
-0.8310372233390808,
-0.9484645128250122,
-0.9171012043952942,
0.351946085691452,
-0.6043686270713806,
-0.235159769654274,
0.7136895060539246,
0.9613890051841736,
0.44260284304618835,
0.14696045219898224,
0.8209244608879089,
0.15136124193668365,
0.33246320486068726,
-0.46169060468673706,
1.1602762937545776,
-0.12831556797027588,
-0.15330295264720917,
-0.4203251302242279,
-0.9160367250442505,
-0.555873692035675,
0.2631397843360901,
-0.10993874818086624,
-0.04136219248175621,
0.7736513018608093,
0.2448832243680954,
0.20570017397403717,
0.24002303183078766,
-0.014310118742287159,
-0.025529593229293823,
0.25953343510627747,
0.4642842411994934,
0.5726562738418579,
-0.678398609161377,
0.8282630443572998,
0.10266665369272232,
-0.12250538915395737,
-0.4017148017883301,
-1.0157333612442017,
-0.8141736388206482,
-0.32776954770088196,
-0.36728474497795105,
-0.3413211405277252,
0.05867689475417137,
0.3074440658092499,
0.3534218370914459,
-0.7893924117088318,
-0.05922869220376015,
-0.44176459312438965,
0.5090984106063843,
-0.28982800245285034,
-0.21974334120750427,
0.539986252784729,
-0.041634753346443176,
-0.4545506536960602,
0.19640235602855682,
0.6155644655227661,
0.5082758665084839,
0.14661546051502228,
0.02349579520523548,
-0.28658315539360046,
-0.032909002155065536,
0.4654829502105713,
0.31909897923469543,
-0.09972486644983292,
-0.10466621071100235,
0.1065468117594719,
-0.17389144003391266,
0.16499866545200348,
0.9205176830291748,
-0.8922010064125061,
0.2925110459327698,
0.8999351859092712,
0.862967848777771,
0.5545528531074524,
-0.022264733910560608,
0.42274010181427,
-0.48079708218574524,
-0.17217160761356354,
0.25269097089767456,
0.3436526358127594,
0.4876320958137512,
-0.6555890440940857,
0.5723153948783875,
0.2582606375217438,
-0.6834144592285156,
-0.6210421323776245,
0.031162019819021225,
-1.0407367944717407,
-0.12580010294914246,
0.5813858509063721,
-0.05554744973778725,
-0.18598797917366028,
-0.36054089665412903,
-0.4356228709220886,
0.7549596428871155,
-0.48086443543434143,
0.39561936259269714,
0.6338529586791992,
-0.30960825085639954,
0.011373039335012436,
-0.41395679116249084,
0.15433605015277863,
-0.028352536261081696,
-1.0644081830978394,
-0.1592179536819458,
0.34357428550720215,
0.03358763828873634,
0.4834500551223755,
0.7194958925247192,
0.04830768331885338,
0.09913886338472366,
0.14582204818725586,
-0.1539703756570816,
-0.4809996783733368,
-0.39715075492858887,
-0.4027787148952484,
0.5430014729499817,
-0.5965067148208618,
-0.16798976063728333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06655v1 | Adversarial Text Purification: A Large Language Model Approach for Defense | 2024-02-05T02:36:41 | 2024-02-05T02:36:41 | Raha Moraffah, Shubh Khandelwal, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Huan Liu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Adversarial purification is a defense mechanism for safeguarding classifiers
against adversarial attacks without knowing the type of attacks or training of
the classifier. These techniques characterize and eliminate adversarial
perturbations from the attacked inputs, aiming to restore purified samples that
retain similarity to the initially attacked ones and are correctly classified
by the classifier. Due to the inherent challenges associated with
characterizing noise perturbations for discrete inputs, adversarial text
purification has been relatively unexplored. In this paper, we investigate the
effectiveness of adversarial purification methods in defending text
classifiers. We propose a novel adversarial text purification that harnesses
the generative capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to purify
adversarial text without the need to explicitly characterize the discrete noise
perturbations. We utilize prompt engineering to exploit LLMs for recovering the
purified examples for given adversarial examples such that they are
semantically similar and correctly classified. Our proposed method demonstrates
remarkable performance over various classifiers, improving their accuracy under
the attack by over 65% on average. | [
-0.3998337388038635,
-1.2708348035812378,
0.3776666522026062,
-0.23264040052890778,
-0.2322188764810562,
0.23955343663692474,
-0.3385481834411621,
-0.22198519110679626,
-0.2537112236022949,
0.7286930084228516,
-0.30090922117233276,
-0.4896593391895294,
-0.7495951056480408,
0.11874789744615555,
-0.9429647326469421,
1.2185173034667969,
0.2663383483886719,
-0.030588390305638313,
-0.00721744354814291,
0.3179576098918915,
-0.048056963831186295,
-0.7359328269958496,
-0.7873628735542297,
-0.27312424778938293,
0.42147237062454224,
-0.12799949944019318,
0.738516092300415,
0.6082579493522644,
0.473823219537735,
0.44455525279045105,
-0.6364622712135315,
0.12726391851902008,
-0.48878756165504456,
0.4482397139072418,
0.029761044308543205,
-0.4636116027832031,
-0.1577150523662567,
0.19714801013469696,
0.5360255837440491,
0.3728482723236084,
0.007923067547380924,
-0.415701687335968,
0.23327778279781342,
0.46445396542549133,
-0.6799997091293335,
-0.31308647990226746,
-0.9628754258155823,
0.11907584220170975,
-0.38175636529922485,
-0.16460129618644714,
-0.7567389011383057,
-0.19518673419952393,
-0.10921032726764679,
-0.4965871274471283,
0.3979344367980957,
-0.2799101769924164,
0.9730785489082336,
0.3456161618232727,
-0.28501924872398376,
-0.21632741391658783,
-0.8888283371925354,
0.7379469275474548,
-0.6691038012504578,
-0.10571130365133286,
0.28228989243507385,
0.25745686888694763,
-0.48387566208839417,
-0.6726717352867126,
-0.551487147808075,
-0.2863449156284332,
-0.03307138383388519,
-0.009050422348082066,
-0.4305029809474945,
0.423166424036026,
0.3343856930732727,
0.4791804850101471,
-0.6798259019851685,
0.12545128166675568,
-0.25587818026542664,
-0.36385464668273926,
0.5581461787223816,
-0.21703389286994934,
0.6565127372741699,
-0.09646955877542496,
-0.5905951261520386,
-0.2202068418264389,
-0.805009126663208,
-0.17949533462524414,
0.6382681727409363,
0.23266398906707764,
0.5075799226760864,
0.3579169809818268,
0.018807685002684593,
0.6576783657073975,
-0.0592975877225399,
-0.2190893143415451,
-0.24279911816120148,
-0.12337443232536316,
-0.24854306876659393,
0.1402384340763092,
0.9749928712844849,
-0.3185289204120636,
0.2721967399120331,
-0.3020223081111908,
-0.4200838804244995,
0.22117988765239716,
0.6320751905441284,
-0.8646422028541565,
-0.42150652408599854,
0.14030267298221588,
-0.4769428074359894,
-0.7694405913352966,
-0.06488999724388123,
-0.9090668559074402,
-0.8668326139450073,
0.07658494263887405,
0.43912273645401,
-0.4187857508659363,
-0.017738429829478264,
0.10536906868219376,
-0.17904409766197205,
-0.02863667719066143,
0.17364415526390076,
-0.8351114392280579,
0.20782427489757538,
0.8648928999900818,
0.5086324214935303,
0.00016378736472688615,
-0.07575008273124695,
-0.6431622505187988,
-0.2438959926366806,
-0.24484345316886902,
0.8230147957801819,
-0.29787829518318176,
-0.48469069600105286,
0.10187404602766037,
-0.2628464698791504,
0.02433256059885025,
-0.6620218753814697,
0.8681510090827942,
-0.9872179627418518,
0.17888322472572327,
0.2725330889225006,
-0.5178966522216797,
-0.35982730984687805,
0.4189824163913727,
-0.865157425403595,
0.47750619053840637,
-0.3411999046802521,
-0.7493191957473755,
-0.1638413965702057,
-0.3338264226913452,
-0.6354598999023438,
0.08982446044683456,
0.10101082175970078,
-0.5920721888542175,
0.10081269592046738,
0.37710756063461304,
0.3013105094432831,
-0.3241569995880127,
0.3452450633049011,
-0.6162614822387695,
-0.2268363982439041,
0.4852079749107361,
-1.0128564834594727,
1.0625348091125488,
0.40295466780662537,
-0.11966968327760696,
0.2725793719291687,
-0.8857072591781616,
-0.02997010573744774,
0.13796725869178772,
-0.36848339438438416,
-0.44341662526130676,
0.07056742161512375,
-0.11839306354522705,
0.13797971606254578,
0.180264413356781,
-0.556861937046051,
0.23541322350502014,
-0.7668012976646423,
0.6882880330085754,
0.7790247797966003,
0.06502123177051544,
0.2662774920463562,
-0.16579031944274902,
0.5691941380500793,
-0.26098015904426575,
0.14183767139911652,
-0.1091654822230339,
-0.3555881381034851,
-0.6495420336723328,
-0.6097655296325684,
0.30342790484428406,
0.4762856662273407,
-0.9749371409416199,
0.4148360788822174,
-0.14821870625019073,
-0.42745959758758545,
-0.37219369411468506,
0.2308100014925003,
0.4865722060203552,
0.35809168219566345,
0.3348587453365326,
0.28095492720603943,
-0.547261655330658,
-0.7363300323486328,
-0.21773965656757355,
-0.2763545513153076,
-0.18309801816940308,
-0.18056559562683105,
0.4559706449508667,
-0.2335260510444641,
0.7022237181663513,
-0.5269102454185486,
-0.20184071362018585,
-0.2145492285490036,
0.04139312356710434,
-0.1025092601776123,
0.1759408861398697,
0.4474688768386841,
-1.0568344593048096,
-0.22411078214645386,
-0.12943069636821747,
-0.6912111639976501,
-0.2593493163585663,
-0.01727096550166607,
-0.10954254865646362,
-0.03936678171157837,
0.7637077569961548,
-0.6521224975585938,
0.3193747401237488,
0.42227548360824585,
-0.38979214429855347,
0.5324434638023376,
-0.03932781517505646,
0.17472419142723083,
-1.014819622039795,
0.07434666901826859,
-0.0728975310921669,
-0.39004820585250854,
-0.8719814419746399,
0.4228573739528656,
-0.09949088841676712,
-0.5505012273788452,
-0.4544927477836609,
0.40721601247787476,
-0.07348959892988205,
0.4684440791606903,
-0.646697998046875,
0.17416664958000183,
0.27877816557884216,
0.20141173899173737,
-0.12629789113998413,
0.614896833896637,
0.3961181044578552,
-0.6462118029594421,
0.6008653044700623,
0.29526349902153015,
-0.07549848407506943,
0.5102778673171997,
-0.6976563334465027,
0.06100068241357803,
-0.03045894205570221,
0.3466046452522278,
-1.0988044738769531,
0.12655186653137207,
0.28571370244026184,
-0.5317050814628601,
0.5423597097396851,
-0.15201209485530853,
-0.5042340159416199,
-0.2063932567834854,
-0.25221648812294006,
0.169484481215477,
0.4421752989292145,
-0.9505783319473267,
0.5240088105201721,
0.2672409415245056,
-0.14004799723625183,
-0.6320467591285706,
-0.552757978439331,
0.3565208911895752,
-0.4608354866504669,
-0.49232181906700134,
0.4137972295284271,
-0.06255654990673065,
-0.24139221012592316,
-0.013868395239114761,
-0.027608375996351242,
-0.12667249143123627,
0.6256777048110962,
0.16533547639846802,
0.39624691009521484,
-0.05495896562933922,
0.06486465781927109,
-0.20587687194347382,
-0.12161802500486374,
0.20013433694839478,
-0.28895846009254456,
0.5070301294326782,
0.2862303853034973,
-0.18595601618289948,
-0.40976107120513916,
0.4210539162158966,
0.6698154211044312,
-0.1623126119375229,
0.7413082718849182,
0.5210621356964111,
-0.5466108918190002,
-0.3512286841869354,
-0.5359878540039062,
-0.1633853167295456,
-0.5517487525939941,
0.5539948344230652,
-0.40605929493904114,
-0.5820856094360352,
0.28108805418014526,
0.041527021676301956,
-0.043684836477041245,
0.5625794529914856,
0.07877930998802185,
0.14617708325386047,
1.1763821840286255,
0.24001756310462952,
-0.3290722370147705,
0.5938787460327148,
-0.18392814695835114,
0.17105406522750854,
-0.6277408599853516,
-0.06585802137851715,
-0.8588930368423462,
0.004779062233865261,
-0.28936368227005005,
0.09848914295434952,
0.037489861249923706,
0.2617220878601074,
-0.3092954754829407,
0.2094791829586029,
-0.5147219896316528,
0.4771825671195984,
0.643081545829773,
0.2487230896949768,
0.16931189596652985,
0.2737194895744324,
-0.12682634592056274,
-0.03178717568516731,
-0.41450631618499756,
-0.7056577205657959,
0.8190394639968872,
0.37570083141326904,
0.7111158967018127,
0.10947492718696594,
0.788997232913971,
0.317579984664917,
0.321115106344223,
-0.7883420586585999,
0.8230077028274536,
-0.7237971425056458,
-0.5795637965202332,
-0.1722835898399353,
-0.6527000665664673,
-1.0004711151123047,
0.38257429003715515,
-0.32002124190330505,
-0.644040584564209,
-0.0702766701579094,
-0.148381769657135,
-0.2963844835758209,
0.653297483921051,
-0.4186599552631378,
0.6474304795265198,
0.01606113277375698,
-0.07382865995168686,
-0.16210946440696716,
-0.18937668204307556,
0.535560667514801,
-0.29360681772232056,
0.15731769800186157,
0.4185331165790558,
0.191749706864357,
0.7717477083206177,
-0.5219079852104187,
0.8035282492637634,
-0.031351473182439804,
-0.5065619945526123,
0.2695356011390686,
0.13074705004692078,
0.6359447836875916,
-0.2955673933029175,
0.04537977650761604,
-0.07302802801132202,
-0.34621745347976685,
-0.20671243965625763,
-0.8326852917671204,
0.7642910480499268,
-0.7376652956008911,
-1.0781360864639282,
-0.351938933134079,
-0.17154569923877716,
0.08612377196550369,
0.30727720260620117,
0.4725642502307892,
0.47857949137687683,
-0.23000405728816986,
0.3442087173461914,
1.113921046257019,
-0.49190688133239746,
0.617866575717926,
0.4765227138996124,
0.21768055856227875,
-0.7843062877655029,
1.0550237894058228,
-0.10655345022678375,
0.31164097785949707,
0.5859614610671997,
0.16315504908561707,
-0.3937563896179199,
-0.742769181728363,
-0.34221744537353516,
-0.014871257357299328,
-0.7748261094093323,
-0.4020078778266907,
-0.7721416354179382,
-0.4629833996295929,
-0.4891490638256073,
0.00845253374427557,
-0.22583554685115814,
-0.2443544566631317,
-0.41244474053382874,
0.13371522724628448,
0.14606375992298126,
0.638779878616333,
0.285089373588562,
0.26765623688697815,
-0.8446123600006104,
0.5360192656517029,
0.4630484879016876,
-0.07898712158203125,
-0.053548820316791534,
-0.7781949639320374,
-0.0411139577627182,
0.10732053220272064,
-0.5547152757644653,
-1.0160243511199951,
0.5465160608291626,
0.06815876066684723,
0.4657086730003357,
0.484466552734375,
0.4497201442718506,
0.37318935990333557,
-0.5477534532546997,
0.8448941707611084,
0.0784473568201065,
-0.9667390584945679,
0.6564362049102783,
-0.17075999081134796,
0.20268769562244415,
0.2975839376449585,
0.13429392874240875,
-0.1560545712709427,
-0.7284347414970398,
-0.6948448419570923,
-0.9009062051773071,
0.47394827008247375,
0.22674894332885742,
-0.12250512838363647,
-0.006277925334870815,
0.38874197006225586,
-0.3635033071041107,
0.07426447421312332,
-0.6189578771591187,
-0.16303929686546326,
-0.1176576092839241,
-0.3287375569343567,
-0.29615116119384766,
-0.4915773272514343,
-0.35171738266944885,
0.5340609550476074,
1.0098555088043213,
0.4377439618110657,
-0.10912329703569412,
0.1242167055606842,
-0.24946627020835876,
0.37882179021835327,
0.49121472239494324,
0.496956467628479,
-0.29048341512680054,
0.2821403443813324,
0.3128109276294708,
-0.1249217838048935,
-0.6835537552833557,
0.6730051040649414,
0.5283612012863159,
-0.48182761669158936,
-0.286631315946579,
0.4085412919521332,
0.46393802762031555,
-0.0773589164018631,
-0.49471691250801086,
0.6115149259567261,
-0.33611375093460083,
-0.03367917612195015,
-0.10425995290279388,
0.09690854698419571,
-0.31606540083885193,
0.2243194878101349,
0.35805124044418335,
0.16689756512641907,
0.4225606620311737,
-0.21623189747333527,
0.2694091498851776,
0.6438581347465515,
-0.4120026230812073,
-0.1299225240945816,
0.7222273945808411,
0.2568729519844055,
-0.26560965180397034,
0.43065106868743896,
-0.11638715118169785,
-0.8433657288551331,
0.553693950176239,
0.6195912957191467,
1.0544360876083374,
-0.3444831073284149,
0.10213001817464828,
0.19307845830917358,
0.27459588646888733,
-0.21090200543403625,
-0.3227718472480774,
0.010068950243294239,
-0.6534721255302429,
-0.38493120670318604,
-0.6872048377990723,
-0.09271308034658432,
0.5233379602432251,
-0.5210465788841248,
0.008356839418411255,
-0.5290924906730652,
-0.20204710960388184,
0.20723888278007507,
0.17981041967868805,
-0.0630996972322464,
0.3264017105102539,
0.2883840799331665,
0.5651856064796448,
-0.7270451784133911,
0.5815287828445435,
0.6716068387031555,
-0.19125431776046753,
-0.4771534502506256,
0.10443244874477386,
0.22058351337909698,
-0.27669668197631836,
0.665743887424469,
0.14207081496715546,
-0.20268221199512482,
-0.2352794110774994,
-0.3881525993347168,
-0.5316839218139648,
0.4013073742389679,
0.5225226879119873,
-0.314509779214859,
0.17574511468410492,
-0.1722683310508728,
0.6412091851234436,
0.22351692616939545,
-0.004625978879630566,
0.27265381813049316,
0.26358917355537415,
-0.10501508414745331,
-0.42649492621421814,
0.30633071064949036,
-0.5957865715026855,
0.1394938826560974,
0.18246512115001678,
-0.464435338973999,
0.6370922923088074,
0.007915513589978218,
-0.5372755527496338,
0.4676070511341095,
0.7619261145591736,
0.1911315768957138,
0.011830423027276993,
0.5911049246788025,
0.6119076013565063,
0.7351890802383423,
-0.1303880363702774,
0.9900845885276794,
-0.2018241137266159,
0.14719273149967194,
0.900976300239563,
-0.11522552371025085,
0.7431543469429016,
0.1028214618563652,
-0.09363143891096115,
0.17964130640029907,
0.3875528573989868,
-0.08027195930480957,
0.43627187609672546,
0.5233175754547119,
-0.6618794202804565,
-0.17775806784629822,
-0.10002076625823975,
-0.2618304491043091,
0.46804115176200867,
0.3277110755443573,
-0.45454496145248413,
-0.16525352001190186,
0.48595643043518066,
0.09001854062080383,
0.46549177169799805,
-0.2345244586467743,
0.9752294421195984,
-0.13732574880123138,
-0.746741533279419,
0.8538358211517334,
0.033432647585868835,
0.6874105930328369,
-0.5488402247428894,
0.12523256242275238,
0.04292258620262146,
0.5073235034942627,
-0.0883377194404602,
-0.4697524309158325,
0.1827710121870041,
0.1119673028588295,
-0.39304301142692566,
-0.19858528673648834,
0.8848108053207397,
-0.45022982358932495,
-0.1623249500989914,
0.2915778160095215,
-0.20500925183296204,
-0.035234931856393814,
-0.36147573590278625,
-0.3223113417625427,
0.009551674127578735,
0.0941367894411087,
-0.33961179852485657,
0.343507319688797,
0.31448131799697876,
0.45753830671310425,
0.8546069264411926,
0.6735321283340454,
0.44369587302207947,
-0.2391882687807083,
0.21114976704120636,
0.8754734992980957,
-0.4267255961894989,
-0.37274235486984253,
-1.2649391889572144,
0.20367088913917542,
-0.13727226853370667,
-0.008111316710710526,
0.8314952850341797,
0.3775998055934906,
0.469235360622406,
0.087789386510849,
0.8992294669151306,
0.45408502221107483,
0.335056334733963,
-0.585736095905304,
0.878420889377594,
-0.25310659408569336,
0.6392038464546204,
-0.13972915709018707,
-0.6275911927223206,
-0.5006049871444702,
0.4381747245788574,
-0.16074246168136597,
-0.1645418107509613,
0.5793176889419556,
0.8218696117401123,
0.2064594328403473,
0.2504224181175232,
0.445048063993454,
0.4488416314125061,
0.8186345100402832,
0.45291849970817566,
0.9783631563186646,
-0.5739241242408752,
1.1572617292404175,
-0.1177544966340065,
-0.29995712637901306,
0.0528816357254982,
-0.595554769039154,
-1.0884013175964355,
-0.27746596932411194,
-0.4678668677806854,
-0.7901508808135986,
0.41800183057785034,
0.46985921263694763,
0.5129290819168091,
-0.7699623703956604,
0.321076899766922,
-0.1801077127456665,
0.20150819420814514,
-0.08363822847604752,
-0.29837051033973694,
0.4037392735481262,
-0.383269727230072,
-0.9453716278076172,
0.604203999042511,
-0.023635026067495346,
0.2663387954235077,
-0.5096962451934814,
0.4072440266609192,
0.03105098381638527,
0.05708654969930649,
0.44578656554222107,
0.2716677784919739,
-0.7250822186470032,
-0.04326589033007622,
-0.2624136805534363,
-0.4170714020729065,
-0.3668552339076996,
0.5741671323776245,
-0.6819611191749573,
0.3811749219894409,
0.6901773810386658,
1.0203477144241333,
0.0003251633606851101,
0.016030993312597275,
0.5357217788696289,
-0.744820237159729,
0.11669804155826569,
0.29845115542411804,
0.4291726052761078,
0.3354989290237427,
-0.609969973564148,
0.1376938670873642,
0.30709558725357056,
-0.5411320924758911,
-0.9301100969314575,
0.4962502419948578,
-0.5444393754005432,
-0.6554290652275085,
1.476034164428711,
-0.5547387003898621,
-0.2188071310520172,
-0.12468846887350082,
-0.3469407558441162,
0.3351295590400696,
-0.23814931511878967,
0.9197243452072144,
0.7851284146308899,
0.7017413377761841,
0.15478911995887756,
-0.21000266075134277,
0.5638437867164612,
0.20307375490665436,
-0.7247815728187561,
0.15510967373847961,
0.2824895679950714,
0.03164457529783249,
0.29334914684295654,
0.1441067010164261,
-0.3437351584434509,
0.02680170349776745,
0.1504395455121994,
-0.1803635060787201,
0.02242927998304367,
-0.32483699917793274,
-0.6389431357383728,
0.6287007927894592,
-0.08734983950853348,
-0.32776740193367004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02680v1 | Large Language Models are Geographically Biased | 2024-02-05T02:32:09 | 2024-02-05T02:32:09 | Rohin Manvi, Samar Khanna, Marshall Burke, David Lobell, Stefano Ermon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently carry the biases contained in their
training corpora, which can lead to the perpetuation of societal harm. As the
impact of these foundation models grows, understanding and evaluating their
biases becomes crucial to achieving fairness and accuracy. We propose to study
what LLMs know about the world we live in through the lens of geography. This
approach is particularly powerful as there is ground truth for the numerous
aspects of human life that are meaningfully projected onto geographic space
such as culture, race, language, politics, and religion. We show various
problematic geographic biases, which we define as systemic errors in geospatial
predictions. Initially, we demonstrate that LLMs are capable of making accurate
zero-shot geospatial predictions in the form of ratings that show strong
monotonic correlation with ground truth (Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.89). We
then show that LLMs exhibit common biases across a range of objective and
subjective topics. In particular, LLMs are clearly biased against locations
with lower socioeconomic conditions (e.g. most of Africa) on a variety of
sensitive subjective topics such as attractiveness, morality, and intelligence
(Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.70). Finally, we introduce a bias score to
quantify this and find that there is significant variation in the magnitude of
bias across existing LLMs. | [
-0.5708909034729004,
-0.7099459767341614,
0.9150979518890381,
0.03437761589884758,
0.07383302599191666,
-0.193661168217659,
-0.7216242551803589,
-0.47596853971481323,
0.2518540620803833,
0.7392114996910095,
-0.29554444551467896,
-0.8360742926597595,
-0.9251511096954346,
-0.37803915143013,
-0.17184332013130188,
0.9359129071235657,
0.07022885978221893,
0.2289891093969345,
-0.1122201532125473,
-0.2708880305290222,
-0.263051837682724,
-0.8033036589622498,
-0.01918911002576351,
-0.4751090407371521,
0.4393896460533142,
0.36215609312057495,
1.0409470796585083,
0.37940534949302673,
0.49338585138320923,
0.26214146614074707,
-0.4044881761074066,
-0.0678832083940506,
-0.6967551708221436,
0.08617863059043884,
-0.49809256196022034,
-0.45762205123901367,
-0.1372283697128296,
0.13577252626419067,
0.6252375841140747,
1.0761531591415405,
-0.030556151643395424,
0.38844525814056396,
-0.020207326859235764,
0.5062355399131775,
-0.4881344735622406,
0.03742268681526184,
-0.6852905750274658,
0.09889212250709534,
-0.1985745131969452,
-0.010891853831708431,
-0.10379136353731155,
-0.50847989320755,
0.47150322794914246,
-0.3311176300048828,
0.44621700048446655,
0.2064221054315567,
0.7639979124069214,
0.29180246591567993,
-0.6965745091438293,
-0.3533586859703064,
-0.7603338360786438,
0.9356569051742554,
-0.4203161299228668,
0.2693231999874115,
0.45605921745300293,
0.300741046667099,
-0.29274672269821167,
0.000938209006562829,
-0.3322981595993042,
-0.23631858825683594,
-0.009628226049244404,
-0.15417687594890594,
0.06035284325480461,
-0.11668948084115982,
0.4077639579772949,
0.1425771266222,
-0.48497265577316284,
0.10991928726434708,
-0.41195887327194214,
-0.04842996597290039,
0.5976496338844299,
0.06846010684967041,
0.4666651487350464,
-0.26675549149513245,
-0.059692077338695526,
0.180526003241539,
-1.11343252658844,
-0.07262156903743744,
0.5359224677085876,
0.39043062925338745,
-0.3112293481826782,
0.5328190922737122,
0.0001345478231087327,
0.7999972701072693,
-0.09112951904535294,
-0.3151910603046417,
0.06592628359794617,
0.1604337841272354,
-0.13034093379974365,
-0.04254463315010071,
0.5709627866744995,
0.5072177648544312,
0.6561880707740784,
-0.10629789531230927,
0.09577232599258423,
0.041933927685022354,
0.13443881273269653,
-0.5107825994491577,
0.193992480635643,
-0.028032751753926277,
-0.2571302354335785,
-0.1032073050737381,
0.07340185344219208,
-0.8698840737342834,
-0.6213813424110413,
-0.44687849283218384,
-0.13475848734378815,
-0.0557442344725132,
-0.09017810970544815,
-0.008127346634864807,
0.1779540777206421,
0.1975945383310318,
0.2779909372329712,
-0.8478001356124878,
0.014252342283725739,
0.9067643284797668,
0.8310062289237976,
0.07865792512893677,
-0.5211711525917053,
0.028408953920006752,
0.031108364462852478,
-0.41512346267700195,
0.8092974424362183,
-0.4515121579170227,
-0.3837902247905731,
0.07236120849847794,
0.008969651535153389,
0.45333409309387207,
-0.48615869879722595,
0.5833688974380493,
-0.5659525394439697,
0.10641954094171524,
-0.8369151949882507,
-0.04654931649565697,
-0.2672072649002075,
0.36968299746513367,
-0.5828375220298767,
0.9245563745498657,
0.02907532826066017,
-0.7025465965270996,
0.5731603503227234,
-0.37040063738822937,
-0.3669142425060272,
-0.23211655020713806,
-0.23594339191913605,
-0.07925787568092346,
0.319841593503952,
0.305266410112381,
0.3445628881454468,
-0.4357438087463379,
0.8092342615127563,
-0.6448855996131897,
-0.4988444745540619,
0.22692570090293884,
-0.49539944529533386,
0.8393219709396362,
0.03124360553920269,
-0.6617227792739868,
-0.27992773056030273,
-0.5870577096939087,
-0.18256092071533203,
0.04080893471837044,
-0.10921864956617355,
-0.5285972952842712,
0.14461858570575714,
-0.15573012828826904,
0.30546295642852783,
0.1597737967967987,
-0.5168599486351013,
0.1051686629652977,
-0.3620899021625519,
0.27866360545158386,
0.930098831653595,
-0.3346330225467682,
0.8626230359077454,
-0.11804305016994476,
0.34520286321640015,
-0.10578764230012894,
0.13503287732601166,
0.29692432284355164,
-0.34622201323509216,
-0.589709997177124,
-0.17535188794136047,
0.047984201461076736,
0.38937118649482727,
-0.22540704905986786,
0.41711628437042236,
-0.65187668800354,
-0.5762878656387329,
-0.16086138784885406,
0.0413249135017395,
0.06810551136732101,
0.4219743013381958,
0.013302777893841267,
-0.19982409477233887,
-0.5156487822532654,
-0.7729549407958984,
-0.4392539858818054,
-0.07968707382678986,
-0.09713906794786453,
0.6131742596626282,
0.6561220288276672,
-0.12085390836000443,
1.1199779510498047,
-0.507708728313446,
-0.14791609346866608,
0.08654063194990158,
-0.2289409339427948,
0.25655806064605713,
0.07360927760601044,
0.712457537651062,
-0.6904722452163696,
-0.21352490782737732,
-0.09359534829854965,
-1.0502158403396606,
-0.34231266379356384,
0.3904312551021576,
-0.17938794195652008,
0.003875753143802285,
-0.00708326231688261,
-0.7104703187942505,
0.3537430465221405,
0.8154698014259338,
-0.5702897310256958,
0.3786611258983612,
-0.032327864319086075,
0.021946879103779793,
-0.6055983901023865,
-0.05996117740869522,
0.30291101336479187,
-0.11411624401807785,
-0.26004135608673096,
0.13841190934181213,
-0.34804439544677734,
-0.09961283206939697,
-0.32994183897972107,
0.7314903140068054,
-0.5165326595306396,
-0.6113624572753906,
-0.13995419442653656,
0.427115797996521,
-0.04849894717335701,
0.06750941276550293,
0.09539277106523514,
0.5927421450614929,
0.48548316955566406,
-0.25172364711761475,
0.34141185879707336,
0.006854096427559853,
-0.6784223914146423,
0.6826680302619934,
-0.44804173707962036,
-0.1056932806968689,
-0.596929669380188,
0.7107452750205994,
-0.648510217666626,
-0.3409310281276703,
-0.11123331636190414,
-0.3145654499530792,
-0.10945852845907211,
-0.2641948163509369,
-0.2810637950897217,
-0.4043000340461731,
0.056334465742111206,
0.19996418058872223,
0.4881937801837921,
-0.6615467667579651,
0.4553525745868683,
0.7907298803329468,
-0.14487381279468536,
-0.807088315486908,
-0.8909491896629333,
0.1558009833097458,
-0.3449264466762543,
-0.5787366032600403,
-0.26496610045433044,
0.16856245696544647,
-0.8413413763046265,
-0.0071885595098137856,
0.042724475264549255,
-0.01966749131679535,
0.03649343550205231,
0.703594982624054,
0.21148335933685303,
-0.12264316529035568,
-0.03526633232831955,
-0.42119020223617554,
0.04677757993340492,
0.3250972330570221,
-0.5588420629501343,
0.4212387204170227,
-0.10669848322868347,
-0.4495674669742584,
0.1783459633588791,
0.25837841629981995,
0.6314947009086609,
0.027525484561920166,
0.8429898619651794,
0.2829990088939667,
-0.4605187177658081,
-0.14312830567359924,
-0.628070056438446,
-0.04181740805506706,
-0.3701055347919464,
0.48227575421333313,
-0.15559551119804382,
-1.1817268133163452,
0.6075308918952942,
-0.045998819172382355,
-0.09801539778709412,
0.255280464887619,
0.7656905651092529,
0.022246044129133224,
0.6704537868499756,
0.676365852355957,
-0.5004515647888184,
0.21152223646640778,
-0.1667531430721283,
0.5366082191467285,
-0.6045913696289062,
-0.24356244504451752,
-0.6521004438400269,
-0.31217148900032043,
-0.873784601688385,
-0.5879302024841309,
0.5268422961235046,
0.008295613341033459,
-0.8239898681640625,
-0.1955992579460144,
-0.32048654556274414,
0.8401380777359009,
0.4917793273925781,
-0.0397447794675827,
-0.06163192540407181,
0.37261858582496643,
-0.2035534828901291,
-0.3867311477661133,
-0.6378562450408936,
-0.804572582244873,
1.1755695343017578,
0.4314118027687073,
0.9734786748886108,
0.12538708746433258,
0.30007684230804443,
0.1736123114824295,
0.8323472738265991,
-0.5625942349433899,
0.31413036584854126,
-0.1715238243341446,
-0.8539912700653076,
-0.34134042263031006,
-0.4054691791534424,
-0.564756453037262,
0.4454413950443268,
-0.11170469224452972,
-0.6778150796890259,
0.15924566984176636,
-0.03380206227302551,
-0.24145175516605377,
0.5541988015174866,
-0.3612522780895233,
0.4976709187030792,
-0.4748305082321167,
-0.48621484637260437,
0.03948729485273361,
-0.765312135219574,
0.5375217795372009,
0.040104132145643234,
0.730187714099884,
-0.49519863724708557,
0.2023618221282959,
0.2761847972869873,
-0.1009148433804512,
0.9761189222335815,
-0.2933078706264496,
-0.3536761701107025,
0.19924189150333405,
0.09556986391544342,
0.1763571798801422,
0.2096714824438095,
-0.3017566204071045,
0.7737244963645935,
-0.3606010377407074,
-0.621610701084137,
-0.557183027267456,
0.9898993968963623,
-1.254393219947815,
-0.5622539520263672,
-0.5327337384223938,
-0.6084433197975159,
-0.0357656255364418,
0.09346205741167068,
0.25294211506843567,
0.3156612813472748,
-0.4946552515029907,
-0.18842753767967224,
0.802036464214325,
-0.5341323614120483,
-0.05079730600118637,
0.5928241610527039,
-0.3213157653808594,
-0.34558752179145813,
0.45421531796455383,
0.20572035014629364,
0.20848599076271057,
0.14444267749786377,
0.22997623682022095,
-0.36032527685165405,
-0.18719740211963654,
-0.14350268244743347,
0.4184240996837616,
-0.8952344655990601,
-0.08396033942699432,
-0.3896079361438751,
-0.062208015471696854,
-0.3415224850177765,
-0.5447694659233093,
-0.19277293980121613,
0.010957126505672932,
-0.00885582435876131,
-0.2279519885778427,
0.10471004992723465,
1.010405421257019,
-0.2713194787502289,
0.467961847782135,
-0.40934503078460693,
0.10247163474559784,
0.022734811529517174,
0.2925264537334442,
-0.1309557557106018,
-0.6397043466567993,
-0.14223574101924896,
0.1959763914346695,
-0.13987167179584503,
-0.6532400846481323,
0.3882744610309601,
-0.2015848010778427,
0.31686604022979736,
0.3696643114089966,
-0.16420523822307587,
0.7679932117462158,
-0.8910172581672668,
0.9778550863265991,
-0.006906723137944937,
-0.9107406735420227,
0.458435982465744,
-0.3617788851261139,
0.24862949550151825,
0.3165709674358368,
0.6324007511138916,
-0.6261875033378601,
-0.6013708114624023,
-0.5023972988128662,
-0.6742541790008545,
0.33064165711402893,
-0.5080525279045105,
0.3977530002593994,
-0.09991712868213654,
0.553526759147644,
-0.035660237073898315,
0.11315283924341202,
-1.020223617553711,
-0.3240269422531128,
-0.0336378812789917,
0.012117992155253887,
-0.44743481278419495,
-0.5644124150276184,
-0.44075772166252136,
-0.06999527662992477,
0.4292643964290619,
-0.08160030841827393,
-0.005115460138767958,
0.2831070125102997,
-0.13118022680282593,
-0.3610784113407135,
0.4571695923805237,
0.6595182418823242,
1.170607566833496,
-0.1388346403837204,
0.5304778814315796,
0.324645459651947,
-0.35157865285873413,
0.4619220197200775,
-0.20059847831726074,
-0.4043166935443878,
0.16102835536003113,
0.5011767148971558,
0.671860933303833,
0.2361183762550354,
-0.5279189348220825,
0.6308881640434265,
0.14227552711963654,
0.02371317334473133,
-0.5173565745353699,
-0.4243125915527344,
0.1496243178844452,
0.36665138602256775,
0.3118371069431305,
0.04933895543217659,
-0.025435920804739,
-0.6648188829421997,
-0.07999802380800247,
0.6722347736358643,
-0.3491412401199341,
-0.37817344069480896,
0.49268415570259094,
0.24380046129226685,
-0.08169892430305481,
0.5056971311569214,
-0.13328811526298523,
-0.8563269972801208,
0.49951574206352234,
0.4614019989967346,
0.41179391741752625,
-0.2085290402173996,
0.10345759987831116,
0.4353101849555969,
0.7799797058105469,
-0.21833357214927673,
0.012656239792704582,
0.319347083568573,
-0.9050635695457458,
-0.48990699648857117,
-0.8617902994155884,
-0.2367689162492752,
0.07812273502349854,
-0.41905614733695984,
0.2311500906944275,
-0.4602331519126892,
-0.263334184885025,
-0.3378400504589081,
0.1977596879005432,
-0.6911805868148804,
0.31567463278770447,
0.44532856345176697,
0.7966800332069397,
-1.1750692129135132,
0.45555824041366577,
0.6358050107955933,
0.13094474375247955,
-0.5431293249130249,
0.04832211509346962,
0.22745288908481598,
-0.8921818137168884,
1.0959848165512085,
0.18364782631397247,
-0.09425393491983414,
-0.5758061408996582,
-0.7955239415168762,
-1.1971821784973145,
0.7790262699127197,
0.5564521551132202,
-0.7269480228424072,
-0.05383062735199928,
0.3239455223083496,
0.6554032564163208,
-0.2841356098651886,
0.45821619033813477,
0.6013490557670593,
0.5032538771629333,
-0.14588743448257446,
-0.9401453137397766,
0.04333657771348953,
0.40352684259414673,
0.29829370975494385,
0.20974873006343842,
-0.8164142370223999,
0.8725902438163757,
-0.3761078119277954,
0.011624014005064964,
-0.28570523858070374,
0.5056843161582947,
0.4392040967941284,
0.1768733561038971,
0.2728556990623474,
0.6053123474121094,
0.7376596927642822,
-0.3059314787387848,
1.1187503337860107,
-0.49198585748672485,
0.68598872423172,
1.0405795574188232,
-0.6935303807258606,
0.5538787841796875,
0.2985316812992096,
-0.3041803538799286,
0.5576347708702087,
0.6878654956817627,
0.16937704384326935,
0.4256228804588318,
0.5924056768417358,
-0.3392771780490875,
-0.12397781759500504,
-0.18875162303447723,
-0.21544170379638672,
0.7459210753440857,
0.3725384771823883,
-0.3175159692764282,
-0.4126729369163513,
-0.05579392984509468,
0.36102432012557983,
0.15868385136127472,
-0.41675713658332825,
0.2181086391210556,
0.20014789700508118,
-0.6133466362953186,
0.29234641790390015,
0.060077399015426636,
0.7458201050758362,
-0.5202817320823669,
0.1785511076450348,
-0.2424846589565277,
0.07996664196252823,
-0.23512707650661469,
-0.9004924893379211,
0.39508554339408875,
0.12176573276519775,
-0.3334729075431824,
-0.11314105242490768,
0.6973508596420288,
-0.4022068381309509,
-0.499178409576416,
0.4326974153518677,
0.4262504577636719,
0.2874966859817505,
0.0026852216105908155,
-0.46517136693000793,
0.3403215706348419,
-0.13610611855983734,
-0.30949029326438904,
0.2524859607219696,
0.597370445728302,
-0.12939272820949554,
0.7513500452041626,
0.5700830817222595,
0.4762694835662842,
0.022824030369520187,
-0.12992800772190094,
0.5119069814682007,
-0.7716390490531921,
-0.42150425910949707,
-1.105365514755249,
-0.05918484926223755,
-0.07974918186664581,
-0.1616222858428955,
0.8903017640113831,
0.4534939229488373,
0.7697358727455139,
0.25803112983703613,
0.9313546419143677,
0.09090131521224976,
0.4176400303840637,
-0.40531885623931885,
0.6857581734657288,
-0.22798600792884827,
0.24944914877414703,
-0.03744419291615486,
-1.054025650024414,
-0.32003021240234375,
0.8858699798583984,
-0.9769441485404968,
0.19281832873821259,
0.48509523272514343,
0.6299018859863281,
0.04677301272749901,
-0.0895894318819046,
0.24589309096336365,
0.30532515048980713,
0.19395607709884644,
0.5402886271476746,
0.9675536155700684,
-0.08806709945201874,
0.02107301726937294,
-0.049665577709674835,
-0.4399930536746979,
0.01295931451022625,
-0.884699285030365,
-0.9370355010032654,
-0.11118917912244797,
0.21014586091041565,
-0.5777289867401123,
0.11630356311798096,
0.7021480202674866,
0.8706344366073608,
-0.576155424118042,
-0.46309924125671387,
0.3374880254268646,
0.5164884924888611,
0.4426063895225525,
-0.29988130927085876,
0.2021908015012741,
0.05773795768618584,
-0.6586742401123047,
-0.14282892644405365,
0.4565519392490387,
-0.06769634783267975,
-0.7891045212745667,
0.05155574530363083,
0.15257613360881805,
-0.06446995586156845,
0.7646092176437378,
0.024507561698555946,
-0.9889701008796692,
-0.503642737865448,
-0.25826215744018555,
-0.32755520939826965,
-0.09458912163972855,
0.8737890720367432,
-0.5584144592285156,
0.020971376448869705,
0.11379741877317429,
0.39657098054885864,
0.17550654709339142,
-0.06729526817798615,
0.4766874313354492,
-0.692491352558136,
0.4288017749786377,
0.0610344372689724,
0.34792932868003845,
0.7285434603691101,
-0.42352789640426636,
0.4113794267177582,
0.27211621403694153,
-1.0308359861373901,
-0.6691520810127258,
0.2534571886062622,
-0.45778316259384155,
-0.22190329432487488,
1.417700171470642,
-0.12441230565309525,
-0.45378759503364563,
0.11379446089267731,
0.06589727848768234,
-0.12215407192707062,
-0.12136181443929672,
0.834999680519104,
1.061303973197937,
0.2463761866092682,
0.07538663595914841,
-0.9817542433738708,
0.27117255330085754,
0.280010461807251,
-0.6237993240356445,
-0.03030533343553543,
0.9280217885971069,
0.8356807827949524,
0.29470470547676086,
0.6700547337532043,
-0.04630911722779274,
-0.14096783101558685,
-0.1674095094203949,
0.11202520877122879,
0.546043872833252,
-0.25118547677993774,
-0.4804386496543884,
0.18194587528705597,
0.13648545742034912,
0.4788239598274231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02662v1 | Image-Caption Encoding for Improving Zero-Shot Generalization | 2024-02-05T01:14:07 | 2024-02-05T01:14:07 | Eric Yang Yu, Christopher Liao, Sathvik Ravi, Theodoros Tsiligkaridis, Brian Kulis | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in vision-language models have combined contrastive
approaches with generative methods to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA) on
downstream inference tasks like zero-shot image classification. However, a
persistent issue of these models for image classification is their
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization capabilities. We first show that when
an OOD data point is misclassified, the correct class can be typically found in
the Top-K predicted classes. In order to steer the model prediction toward the
correct class within the top predicted classes, we propose the Image-Caption
Encoding (ICE) method, a straightforward approach that directly enforces
consistency between the image-conditioned and caption-conditioned predictions
at evaluation time only. Intuitively, we take advantage of unique properties of
the generated captions to guide our local search for the correct class label
within the Top-K predicted classes. We show that our method can be easily
combined with other SOTA methods to enhance Top-1 OOD accuracies by 0.5% on
average and up to 3% on challenging datasets. Our code:
https://github.com/Chris210634/ice | [
-0.24856425821781158,
-0.19420363008975983,
0.43322688341140747,
-0.1817326843738556,
-0.6016316413879395,
0.011089243926107883,
0.03381836786866188,
-0.3645506203174591,
0.030651606619358063,
0.486946165561676,
-0.24997590482234955,
-0.6975634694099426,
-0.6789222359657288,
-0.04417421296238899,
-0.2644702196121216,
0.877328634262085,
-0.19564737379550934,
0.20034825801849365,
-0.39233821630477905,
-0.34294551610946655,
-0.39380204677581787,
-0.43253087997436523,
-0.3744942843914032,
-0.2657180428504944,
0.12142950296401978,
0.7897602319717407,
0.7322027087211609,
0.880395770072937,
0.6746439337730408,
0.08572610467672348,
0.2654562294483185,
0.05895156040787697,
-0.5302771329879761,
0.0031286661978811026,
-0.05149437487125397,
-0.6227927803993225,
-0.2410920411348343,
-0.27675727009773254,
0.6061814427375793,
0.45298588275909424,
-0.37109512090682983,
0.07906344532966614,
-0.3584628999233246,
0.7171867489814758,
-1.0913968086242676,
0.3985387980937958,
-0.7037428617477417,
0.2262638658285141,
-0.07870961725711823,
-0.448520302772522,
-0.5880811810493469,
0.021186623722314835,
-0.012725642882287502,
-0.8116708397865295,
0.4827646017074585,
0.3210045397281647,
1.1115617752075195,
0.3757537007331848,
0.0020115734077990055,
0.23817597329616547,
-0.706413209438324,
0.9466067552566528,
-0.5074552297592163,
0.3049464225769043,
0.3922490179538727,
0.5590115785598755,
0.07635566592216492,
-0.31611937284469604,
-0.6469247341156006,
-0.03944285213947296,
0.08969292789697647,
0.4154956042766571,
-0.3255171775817871,
0.21788714826107025,
0.0007073982851579785,
0.4992278218269348,
-0.4988028109073639,
0.22620554268360138,
-0.46099454164505005,
0.08554979413747787,
0.7052488923072815,
0.010939298197627068,
0.35237041115760803,
0.306801438331604,
-0.39728784561157227,
-0.29910871386528015,
-0.7521141171455383,
-0.2781873941421509,
0.13775239884853363,
0.20744073390960693,
-0.38402459025382996,
0.6051592826843262,
-0.24321533739566803,
0.6169115900993347,
0.27859264612197876,
0.1489265114068985,
0.4002835154533386,
0.0055281613022089005,
-0.36892253160476685,
0.16102570295333862,
0.5091558694839478,
0.7318249344825745,
0.11740480363368988,
-0.28655362129211426,
-0.13368657231330872,
0.20286157727241516,
-0.009289387613534927,
-0.9421069622039795,
-0.2642236351966858,
0.25953754782676697,
-0.31695517897605896,
-0.3857695162296295,
0.1358529031276703,
-0.8198711276054382,
-0.49948981404304504,
-0.08938036859035492,
0.5062507390975952,
-0.24679997563362122,
-0.14788666367530823,
0.3551143407821655,
-0.43602100014686584,
0.4026113748550415,
0.3373655378818512,
-1.0167479515075684,
0.35247737169265747,
0.0469539649784565,
0.8165367245674133,
-0.09696181118488312,
-0.13218626379966736,
-0.7136151790618896,
0.41477328538894653,
-0.6327471733093262,
0.9398409724235535,
-0.6398677229881287,
0.17194567620754242,
0.08015330880880356,
-0.44376569986343384,
0.03693342208862305,
-0.7044605612754822,
0.1292664259672165,
-0.6370917558670044,
0.14270570874214172,
0.13440588116645813,
-0.598164439201355,
-0.176496684551239,
0.11534541100263596,
-0.5031353831291199,
0.6641107201576233,
0.24002082645893097,
-0.7785837650299072,
0.5859227776527405,
-0.7303479313850403,
-0.1782727837562561,
0.34388265013694763,
-0.5297088623046875,
-0.7397035956382751,
0.30198073387145996,
0.5704209804534912,
0.49684908986091614,
-0.3070642352104187,
-0.01993756927549839,
-0.37053927779197693,
-0.5575301647186279,
-0.003739091334864497,
-0.08108452707529068,
0.3590523898601532,
0.29502174258232117,
-0.3710046708583832,
-0.016976628452539444,
-0.6387209892272949,
-0.13402576744556427,
0.37866201996803284,
0.035874225199222565,
-0.26135626435279846,
-0.250999391078949,
-0.23588736355304718,
-0.1775553971529007,
-0.07931330054998398,
-0.7523419260978699,
0.3213491439819336,
-0.144285187125206,
0.4377642273902893,
0.5314727425575256,
0.08221456408500671,
0.8684768676757812,
-0.11295140534639359,
0.6062257289886475,
0.4728679060935974,
0.17418928444385529,
-0.5303059220314026,
-0.5568863749504089,
-0.6819793581962585,
-0.2872830629348755,
0.25885728001594543,
0.659601628780365,
-1.330505132675171,
0.24797703325748444,
-0.27936798334121704,
-0.40691208839416504,
-0.47999662160873413,
-0.03636062890291214,
0.5388914346694946,
0.45214831829071045,
0.4744933247566223,
-0.6391834020614624,
-0.3695550262928009,
-0.5755478739738464,
0.1945362091064453,
0.09022332727909088,
0.003595832735300064,
0.2695307433605194,
0.48727837204933167,
-0.07045956701040268,
0.9848152995109558,
-0.9756655693054199,
-0.5323117971420288,
-0.4175460934638977,
0.22075510025024414,
0.13350459933280945,
0.6919643878936768,
0.8400865197181702,
-0.7918477654457092,
-0.7107771635055542,
0.09229462593793869,
-0.9298578500747681,
0.22017385065555573,
-0.03446905314922333,
-0.23784518241882324,
0.35539501905441284,
0.5352922081947327,
-0.5434775948524475,
0.6155869960784912,
0.4617805480957031,
-0.04863820597529411,
0.44419559836387634,
-0.34756213426589966,
0.2177731841802597,
-0.663623034954071,
-0.09615600854158401,
0.08065294474363327,
0.02032463811337948,
-0.9520120620727539,
0.31767168641090393,
0.10208437591791153,
-0.46218976378440857,
-0.48625752329826355,
0.4908934235572815,
-0.5847686529159546,
0.07147104293107986,
-0.0231921523809433,
-0.07141515612602234,
0.020687386393547058,
0.4805893003940582,
0.39206749200820923,
0.6510788202285767,
1.273070216178894,
-0.45681068301200867,
0.1976102888584137,
0.1864750236272812,
-0.3415036201477051,
0.7631898522377014,
-0.43683674931526184,
0.29318946599960327,
-0.8826134204864502,
0.23178721964359283,
-1.0673822164535522,
-0.5598434805870056,
0.43826454877853394,
-0.45000526309013367,
0.7000161409378052,
-0.3905324935913086,
-0.4175124168395996,
-0.11922600865364075,
-0.35843268036842346,
0.6541656255722046,
0.7357770800590515,
-0.6299778819084167,
0.42871418595314026,
0.050694458186626434,
0.1371467411518097,
-0.714852511882782,
-0.9830350875854492,
0.02720070257782936,
-0.17446717619895935,
-0.29592010378837585,
0.37915709614753723,
-0.21232543885707855,
0.08520878106355667,
0.09336758404970169,
-0.3042432367801666,
-0.3853524923324585,
-0.370947003364563,
0.16906104981899261,
0.4285820722579956,
-0.2199806421995163,
0.11115024983882904,
0.0903933048248291,
-0.04521692916750908,
-0.4728833734989166,
-0.5428519248962402,
0.35372111201286316,
-0.025487342849373817,
-0.2365289330482483,
-0.5234820246696472,
0.2867414951324463,
0.4686114490032196,
-0.15225519239902496,
0.9042655825614929,
0.37840044498443604,
-0.33032602071762085,
-0.15012091398239136,
-0.4204461872577667,
-0.32466161251068115,
-0.4294762909412384,
0.1958020180463791,
-0.20492881536483765,
-0.5586675405502319,
0.495286226272583,
0.24865713715553284,
-0.1509920358657837,
0.23727339506149292,
-0.16046369075775146,
-0.4402138590812683,
1.0044833421707153,
0.7333997488021851,
-0.009997320361435413,
0.6736432909965515,
-0.6614153981208801,
0.11652278900146484,
-0.44172242283821106,
-0.2012234926223755,
-0.23568178713321686,
-0.11697638034820557,
-0.35688871145248413,
-0.27832886576652527,
0.40167129039764404,
0.10427889227867126,
-0.0875079333782196,
0.3234081268310547,
-0.42266926169395447,
0.7462239265441895,
0.6644318699836731,
0.349124014377594,
0.029192058369517326,
0.7171134948730469,
0.202157124876976,
-0.006866327486932278,
-0.9206191301345825,
0.04769621416926384,
1.1473960876464844,
0.18026675283908844,
0.872268795967102,
-0.15050864219665527,
0.9546263217926025,
0.472249299287796,
0.3412340581417084,
-0.6025117635726929,
0.3998839557170868,
-0.603699803352356,
-0.697963297367096,
-0.3445601165294647,
-0.51307213306427,
-0.8053054809570312,
0.04191405698657036,
-0.25796329975128174,
-0.5442724823951721,
0.38603001832962036,
0.5468685626983643,
-0.3770746886730194,
0.485850989818573,
-0.733262836933136,
0.9174844622612,
0.006917305290699005,
-0.12446193397045135,
0.050064779818058014,
-0.7201998233795166,
0.2442856729030609,
0.25896042585372925,
0.2801457345485687,
-0.024743637070059776,
0.11428973078727722,
0.31415656208992004,
-0.4142959713935852,
0.9911398887634277,
-0.5203611254692078,
0.1841931939125061,
0.45785003900527954,
-0.10471241921186447,
0.2524690330028534,
-0.5314184427261353,
0.2744429111480713,
0.5596571564674377,
-0.13670484721660614,
-0.7083187103271484,
-0.8131051659584045,
0.10821917653083801,
-0.8482247591018677,
-0.319113165140152,
-0.5179632902145386,
-0.4157957434654236,
0.025149352848529816,
0.12983667850494385,
0.6718857288360596,
0.6538739800453186,
0.42163750529289246,
0.1681140959262848,
0.8024383783340454,
-0.1909196525812149,
0.2862848937511444,
0.3756975531578064,
-0.09014085680246353,
-0.754509449005127,
1.1583211421966553,
0.19979839026927948,
0.4951505959033966,
0.7153072953224182,
0.2092742770910263,
-0.13022224605083466,
-0.8882041573524475,
-0.8626157641410828,
0.18977072834968567,
-0.9746723771095276,
-0.5783044695854187,
-0.05534711852669716,
-0.16176171600818634,
-0.5254480242729187,
-0.5106102228164673,
-0.22452135384082794,
-0.294929563999176,
-0.35157501697540283,
-0.10477939248085022,
0.21203555166721344,
0.46292316913604736,
-0.10663086920976639,
0.6703269481658936,
-0.7032634615898132,
0.43385857343673706,
0.16492857038974762,
0.5477049946784973,
-0.110540971159935,
-0.8622195720672607,
-0.19607168436050415,
-0.24509313702583313,
-0.20863448083400726,
-0.7812123894691467,
0.38252514600753784,
0.548437237739563,
0.563942015171051,
0.6664707660675049,
0.38309043645858765,
0.7172400951385498,
-0.3461451530456543,
0.6862512826919556,
0.7166796326637268,
-0.7574126720428467,
0.594481885433197,
-0.11507616192102432,
0.4740966558456421,
0.44422632455825806,
0.43829840421676636,
-0.2789853811264038,
-0.5085843205451965,
-0.5774858593940735,
-0.8556755781173706,
0.9189750552177429,
0.35201558470726013,
0.36677661538124084,
0.08287779241800308,
0.40942344069480896,
0.32459622621536255,
0.2727862596511841,
-0.7660401463508606,
-0.40146404504776,
-0.5235904455184937,
-0.290024071931839,
-0.027798963710665703,
-0.3051895797252655,
0.00835474207997322,
-0.030588194727897644,
0.5893028974533081,
-0.2247074395418167,
0.24292737245559692,
0.22543194890022278,
-0.090394027531147,
-0.4240362346172333,
0.30732712149620056,
0.708322286605835,
0.4770830273628235,
-0.48011311888694763,
0.26610493659973145,
0.03400183841586113,
-0.5694560408592224,
0.11431729048490524,
-0.02410794235765934,
-0.7145503759384155,
0.0033931764774024487,
0.30235910415649414,
0.9489051103591919,
-0.11201586574316025,
-0.6121721267700195,
0.6270717978477478,
0.03983531519770622,
-0.30986323952674866,
-0.16579586267471313,
0.1044003814458847,
-0.6568765640258789,
0.0007372514810413122,
0.5679542422294617,
0.38408172130584717,
0.18897272646427155,
-0.6509371995925903,
-0.03165891766548157,
0.20564672350883484,
-0.4210869073867798,
-0.20360420644283295,
0.6740342974662781,
0.09780716896057129,
0.19106729328632355,
0.6611304879188538,
-0.5288905501365662,
-0.24769406020641327,
0.6348565816879272,
0.5730701684951782,
0.9703329801559448,
-0.04523400962352753,
0.3383601903915405,
0.5053174495697021,
0.24264976382255554,
-0.10875758528709412,
0.5410639643669128,
-0.11868293583393097,
-0.9810746312141418,
-0.30333468317985535,
-0.31269189715385437,
-0.5737593770027161,
0.011222383007407188,
-0.7702417373657227,
0.22942779958248138,
-0.4738505482673645,
-0.0016180925304070115,
-0.07150814682245255,
-0.5044891834259033,
-0.610217273235321,
0.45911821722984314,
0.43774309754371643,
0.7653876543045044,
-0.9748486876487732,
0.6268570423126221,
0.8945499062538147,
-0.7200284600257874,
-0.4416200816631317,
-0.0913446769118309,
-0.2927156984806061,
-0.796264111995697,
0.5544863343238831,
0.2385120391845703,
-0.10523857176303864,
-0.00151708850171417,
-1.1177334785461426,
-0.790890634059906,
1.1575160026550293,
0.7392964363098145,
-0.5829558968544006,
0.23883004486560822,
0.255183607339859,
0.358480304479599,
-0.5969491004943848,
0.05798213183879852,
0.3365546464920044,
0.20364205539226532,
0.6609111428260803,
-0.6236764788627625,
-0.14992065727710724,
-0.02378261648118496,
0.13130654394626617,
0.03341410309076309,
-0.36338943243026733,
0.35376694798469543,
-0.6777985095977783,
-0.3956857919692993,
0.17785906791687012,
0.6155031323432922,
0.22603026032447815,
0.7733332514762878,
0.3913652300834656,
0.700831949710846,
0.4120866656303406,
-0.0862831249833107,
1.0825378894805908,
-0.01992056332528591,
0.35315296053886414,
1.2027407884597778,
-0.22955849766731262,
0.8771106004714966,
0.4414454400539398,
0.06832640618085861,
0.4703928530216217,
0.43462568521499634,
-0.3223355710506439,
1.10060453414917,
0.07225058972835541,
-0.06152428314089775,
-0.2618037164211273,
-0.2695254683494568,
-0.15913556516170502,
0.37983962893486023,
0.09985509514808655,
-0.32840538024902344,
-0.20511016249656677,
0.12722259759902954,
-0.054218389093875885,
0.09899449348449707,
-0.6773760318756104,
0.6242362260818481,
-0.17556695640087128,
-0.46012789011001587,
0.8356515169143677,
-0.26037755608558655,
0.5363037586212158,
-0.29777756333351135,
-0.2957504987716675,
-0.55436110496521,
0.06742240488529205,
-0.41633492708206177,
-0.8787872195243835,
0.042935069650411606,
-0.07118896394968033,
-0.16577839851379395,
-0.03713836520910263,
0.5205667614936829,
-0.5714016556739807,
-0.41812819242477417,
-0.07665988802909851,
-0.04031209275126457,
0.5415675044059753,
-0.10921928286552429,
-0.28291642665863037,
0.10773581266403198,
-0.22191131114959717,
0.30044806003570557,
0.14723818004131317,
0.14989392459392548,
-0.03725367784500122,
0.5363216996192932,
0.36854541301727295,
0.006315446458756924,
0.12575672566890717,
0.3192998766899109,
0.672767698764801,
-0.47451797127723694,
-0.3406411111354828,
-0.6956303715705872,
0.6073299050331116,
-0.11576350033283234,
-0.0209138635545969,
0.19351458549499512,
0.48335835337638855,
1.0414166450500488,
-0.7373611927032471,
0.8387758731842041,
-0.06724346429109573,
-0.08436591178178787,
-0.5875069499015808,
0.5843930244445801,
-0.5893344879150391,
-0.14078198373317719,
-0.07994935661554337,
-0.8995014429092407,
-0.8934032320976257,
0.3857559859752655,
-0.2617039084434509,
-0.007553065661340952,
0.4844938814640045,
0.5604140758514404,
-0.27560362219810486,
-0.4905587434768677,
0.7289071083068848,
-0.03687585890293121,
0.08569452166557312,
0.4318309724330902,
0.6570609211921692,
-0.6838169693946838,
0.7801682949066162,
-0.4557206332683563,
-0.3926776051521301,
-0.29319098591804504,
-1.067461371421814,
-0.8312069773674011,
-0.29280799627304077,
-0.9300495386123657,
0.12024800479412079,
0.26364925503730774,
0.5821334719657898,
1.0839650630950928,
-1.1373732089996338,
-0.09784384071826935,
-0.31545379757881165,
-0.18354499340057373,
-0.4796428084373474,
-0.165487602353096,
0.2766542434692383,
-0.3611278235912323,
-0.6419199109077454,
-0.01655052788555622,
0.5417713522911072,
0.3021533489227295,
-0.027609599754214287,
-0.2845481038093567,
0.2893354892730713,
0.14784154295921326,
0.5115334987640381,
0.44784116744995117,
-0.5883550047874451,
-0.31903576850891113,
-0.015201796777546406,
0.15781930088996887,
0.47848543524742126,
0.46148693561553955,
-0.3524298369884491,
0.7597066760063171,
0.317994087934494,
0.28858068585395813,
0.5986599922180176,
0.11364491283893585,
0.31912705302238464,
-0.9134879112243652,
0.022242482751607895,
-0.050700705498456955,
0.38094261288642883,
0.5008305907249451,
-0.19848835468292236,
0.6593770980834961,
0.3057718575000763,
-0.18013618886470795,
-0.9166709780693054,
0.3038654327392578,
-0.923085629940033,
-0.025129221379756927,
0.8578481078147888,
-0.46818915009498596,
-0.16071976721286774,
0.16477590799331665,
-0.2156851440668106,
0.1066063717007637,
-0.5558255910873413,
1.0023515224456787,
0.3395737111568451,
-0.16202843189239502,
-0.6790410876274109,
-0.2564263939857483,
0.20751473307609558,
0.1957465410232544,
-0.7671748995780945,
-0.043884050101041794,
0.4888699948787689,
0.3081168532371521,
0.364852637052536,
0.547743558883667,
-0.015215883031487465,
0.5352569222450256,
0.30890142917633057,
0.45957228541374207,
-0.1866341382265091,
-0.5320724248886108,
-0.5568111538887024,
0.1105072870850563,
0.17362159490585327,
-0.6698963046073914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02658v1 | Multi-step Problem Solving Through a Verifier: An Empirical Analysis on Model-induced Process Supervision | 2024-02-05T00:57:51 | 2024-02-05T00:57:51 | Zihan Wang, Yunxuan Li, Yuexin Wu, Liangchen Luo, Le Hou, Hongkun Yu, Jingbo Shang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Process supervision, using a trained verifier to evaluate the intermediate
steps generated by reasoner, has demonstrated significant improvements in
multi-step problem solving. In this paper, to avoid expensive human annotation
effort on the verifier training data, we introduce Model-induced Process
Supervision (MiPS), a novel method for automating data curation. MiPS annotates
an intermediate step by sampling completions of this solution through the
reasoning model, and obtaining an accuracy defined as the proportion of correct
completions. Errors in the reasoner would cause MiPS to underestimate the
accuracy of intermediate steps, therefore, we suggest and empirically show that
verification focusing on high predicted scores of the verifier shall be
preferred over that of low predicted scores, contrary to prior work. Our
approach significantly improves the performance of PaLM 2 on math and coding
tasks (accuracy +0.67% on GSM8K, +4.16% on MATH, +0.92% on MBPP compared with
an output supervision trained verifier). Additionally, our study demonstrates
that the verifier exhibits strong generalization ability across different
reasoning models. | [
-0.3768457770347595,
-0.7189634442329407,
0.7359977960586548,
0.185317724943161,
-0.0760687068104744,
0.11334526538848877,
0.31107065081596375,
-0.46422407031059265,
-0.32925963401794434,
0.5413619875907898,
-0.37855032086372375,
-0.052187953144311905,
-0.929387629032135,
-0.01889779418706894,
-0.26307985186576843,
0.9533840417861938,
-0.4916619658470154,
0.2864922881126404,
-0.2840223014354706,
0.34608781337738037,
-0.27124711871147156,
-0.5810419321060181,
-0.6467617750167847,
-0.6224392056465149,
0.1969996988773346,
0.6102237701416016,
0.5356345772743225,
0.6688703894615173,
0.7092887163162231,
0.3255882263183594,
0.10077860206365585,
0.4537391662597656,
-0.05669477954506874,
0.1188613772392273,
0.019715052098035812,
-0.7680188417434692,
-0.47342321276664734,
0.21052852272987366,
0.19219745695590973,
0.41397154331207275,
-0.22531655430793762,
0.4183402359485626,
0.11531423777341843,
0.6684353351593018,
-0.8857073783874512,
0.08915539085865021,
-0.42078983783721924,
0.04887473210692406,
-0.040840212255716324,
-0.474405437707901,
-0.5809990763664246,
-0.203565314412117,
-0.21679799258708954,
-0.4506233036518097,
0.5395402908325195,
0.027880892157554626,
0.790079653263092,
0.42245954275131226,
-0.48991522192955017,
-0.2415093332529068,
-1.1808751821517944,
0.5926628708839417,
-0.5423606038093567,
-0.0032336122822016478,
0.47769778966903687,
0.753667950630188,
-0.20939068496227264,
-0.6063881516456604,
-0.6522688269615173,
0.004119035787880421,
-0.13192158937454224,
0.04133285954594612,
0.1459963321685791,
0.08608706295490265,
0.9329410791397095,
0.3245339095592499,
-0.19027192890644073,
-0.26545602083206177,
-0.6036636233329773,
-0.24121646583080292,
0.718237042427063,
0.09115927666425705,
0.19750387966632843,
0.0994429811835289,
-0.4900248646736145,
0.01494616735726595,
-0.5775131583213806,
0.41531145572662354,
0.34137633442878723,
0.007076677400618792,
0.06841964274644852,
0.637302815914154,
-0.39188718795776367,
0.5882672071456909,
0.1715981662273407,
-0.2970482409000397,
0.4283827841281891,
-0.4442444145679474,
-0.3250451385974884,
-0.17688879370689392,
0.51973557472229,
0.29798656702041626,
0.3209339380264282,
0.07943099737167358,
-0.2762707769870758,
0.17003759741783142,
0.43496638536453247,
-0.886640727519989,
-0.21015483140945435,
0.3852825164794922,
-0.21133750677108765,
-0.16030441224575043,
0.11416152119636536,
-0.47467005252838135,
-0.43030452728271484,
-0.57558673620224,
0.4308255612850189,
-0.32811009883880615,
-0.14627918601036072,
0.00850688386708498,
-0.11833915114402771,
0.24442662298679352,
0.719749927520752,
-0.7323147654533386,
0.3274652063846588,
0.8542069792747498,
0.9821897745132446,
0.2944408357143402,
-0.2317044585943222,
-0.7371548414230347,
0.18663236498832703,
-0.5490301251411438,
0.7390371561050415,
-0.40717270970344543,
-0.3656591475009918,
-0.17117421329021454,
-0.13982079923152924,
-0.11534411460161209,
-0.4160325229167938,
0.9337387084960938,
-0.3211773633956909,
-0.019910825416445732,
-0.32147544622421265,
-0.5406794548034668,
-0.1277233213186264,
0.2950529456138611,
-0.3538440763950348,
1.2949037551879883,
-0.21649524569511414,
-0.7469355463981628,
0.5273251533508301,
-0.73538738489151,
-0.12277477234601974,
-0.1713891327381134,
-0.35768356919288635,
-0.5574467778205872,
0.04497893527150154,
0.44833633303642273,
0.5968131422996521,
-0.21379686892032623,
0.2115224450826645,
-0.44221678376197815,
-0.3993385434150696,
0.10593091696500778,
-0.2872582674026489,
0.6874735355377197,
0.08496781438589096,
-0.2567918598651886,
0.11787842214107513,
-0.7786173820495605,
0.127940371632576,
0.026216939091682434,
-0.301212877035141,
-0.19272403419017792,
-0.024127721786499023,
-0.29649266600608826,
0.6549632549285889,
0.05089877173304558,
-0.8225457072257996,
0.36543986201286316,
-0.2338457703590393,
0.1861502230167389,
0.5426883101463318,
0.19299927353858948,
0.22283776104450226,
-0.4247044026851654,
0.3629775047302246,
0.2622559070587158,
0.32261693477630615,
-0.39728254079818726,
-0.6409380435943604,
-0.8596703410148621,
-0.04713809862732887,
0.1567852646112442,
0.7432032823562622,
-0.6916022896766663,
0.17684563994407654,
-0.04738641902804375,
-0.8353357911109924,
-0.3147999346256256,
0.4117586016654968,
0.5843366980552673,
0.7485750317573547,
0.44355252385139465,
-0.1721973568201065,
-0.3204821050167084,
-0.8745088577270508,
-0.18468569219112396,
-0.091407410800457,
-0.2685719132423401,
0.03798862174153328,
0.6028167009353638,
-0.03843221068382263,
0.7751729488372803,
-0.3716883957386017,
-0.22983740270137787,
0.026354879140853882,
0.44648465514183044,
0.43596822023391724,
0.7771081924438477,
0.29980793595314026,
-0.8482998609542847,
-0.5162100195884705,
-0.03632974997162819,
-0.8445590138435364,
-0.05188371241092682,
-0.19696682691574097,
-0.12323448807001114,
0.20878362655639648,
0.4475362300872803,
-0.35559895634651184,
0.6801615357398987,
0.31682977080345154,
-0.2565973103046417,
0.7417694926261902,
-0.7696555256843567,
0.39849376678466797,
-0.6700690388679504,
0.18123751878738403,
0.3835964500904083,
-0.24311797320842743,
-0.7106824517250061,
-0.09764392673969269,
0.2806159257888794,
0.03583681955933571,
-0.07167750597000122,
-0.06892623752355576,
-0.47971341013908386,
0.0743989571928978,
-0.5222367644309998,
-0.3121285140514374,
-0.03744333237409592,
0.43308934569358826,
0.035765036940574646,
0.8324826955795288,
0.6230068206787109,
-0.6424587965011597,
0.3609771430492401,
0.0028088917024433613,
-0.2502764165401459,
0.4410257339477539,
-0.8524389863014221,
0.24213643372058868,
-0.10191592574119568,
0.23324938118457794,
-1.1962920427322388,
-0.08234827220439911,
0.44512394070625305,
-0.430715948343277,
0.31821408867836,
-0.4637870192527771,
-0.8073069453239441,
-0.5673034191131592,
-0.13655489683151245,
0.04954928904771805,
0.33064544200897217,
-0.47912564873695374,
0.8304387331008911,
0.11375360190868378,
-0.14768041670322418,
-0.6037642955780029,
-0.5784666538238525,
-0.10503750294446945,
-0.18614152073860168,
-0.6093630790710449,
0.22305747866630554,
-0.015756290405988693,
-0.09154725819826126,
-0.5868784785270691,
-0.4183518588542938,
-0.28941982984542847,
0.23735152184963226,
0.709755539894104,
0.4474175274372101,
0.18096822500228882,
-0.2666807770729065,
0.3514530658721924,
-0.5825980305671692,
0.5236572623252869,
0.21246473491191864,
0.1424369215965271,
0.13058336079120636,
-0.8104773759841919,
-0.7123928070068359,
0.28882426023483276,
0.6621415019035339,
-0.26668116450309753,
0.4511263072490692,
0.3996782600879669,
-0.5030719637870789,
0.034580156207084656,
-0.6006432771682739,
-0.1710808128118515,
-0.46302440762519836,
-0.2621230185031891,
-0.843061625957489,
-0.3804522752761841,
0.4789019227027893,
-0.5414514541625977,
0.3263651132583618,
0.12119486182928085,
0.3545597195625305,
-0.2002611756324768,
1.440332293510437,
0.6114577651023865,
-0.0828859880566597,
0.2152785360813141,
-0.25083133578300476,
0.3259872496128082,
-0.7403714656829834,
-0.23743310570716858,
-0.6247439980506897,
-0.12985838949680328,
-0.26792478561401367,
-0.4111725986003876,
0.5168958902359009,
0.5335307717323303,
-0.2396266907453537,
0.2954905331134796,
-0.578732430934906,
0.3337511122226715,
0.6758953928947449,
0.27113771438598633,
0.397360235452652,
-0.1784873902797699,
-0.13273048400878906,
0.011670079082250595,
-0.5066387057304382,
-0.7570812702178955,
1.3407741785049438,
0.49548932909965515,
0.274502158164978,
0.09696175903081894,
0.7915313243865967,
0.34770476818084717,
0.38702231645584106,
-0.3534358739852905,
0.16723565757274628,
0.4089770019054413,
-0.6961408257484436,
-0.2816365957260132,
-0.1344907134771347,
-0.24594557285308838,
0.4494743049144745,
-0.10013435781002045,
-1.0551021099090576,
0.1999950259923935,
0.7085615992546082,
-0.44030502438545227,
-0.012842521071434021,
-0.7020681500434875,
0.7649289965629578,
-0.15413914620876312,
-0.7302894592285156,
-0.3040769696235657,
-0.5866797566413879,
0.6365769505500793,
-0.1459585726261139,
0.446697860956192,
-0.10755567997694016,
0.16604463756084442,
0.6931543946266174,
-1.0042173862457275,
0.737716019153595,
-0.7416584491729736,
-0.28867271542549133,
0.27007269859313965,
-0.04546569660305977,
0.8983544707298279,
0.12625251710414886,
-0.14804407954216003,
-0.12502336502075195,
0.1867285966873169,
-0.3933570683002472,
-0.8253138661384583,
0.3718228042125702,
-0.4223777651786804,
-0.7792266607284546,
-0.5713642239570618,
-0.15163160860538483,
-0.2666151225566864,
0.00961638055741787,
0.18419331312179565,
-0.021001407876610756,
0.507564127445221,
-0.2499033361673355,
0.5924524068832397,
0.44997623562812805,
0.32124119997024536,
0.3661123216152191,
-0.4049370586872101,
-0.135703906416893,
0.5496779084205627,
0.22479602694511414,
0.13093383610248566,
0.0336061492562294,
0.05206843838095665,
0.11483396589756012,
-0.5477061867713928,
-0.7731119394302368,
-0.024263860657811165,
-0.591590166091919,
-0.16670487821102142,
-0.5103208422660828,
-0.09114253520965576,
-0.27875280380249023,
-0.08188427239656448,
-0.41530030965805054,
-0.2176257222890854,
0.14098303020000458,
-0.10036935657262802,
0.17155387997627258,
0.3767470419406891,
-0.21851246058940887,
0.5082627534866333,
-0.609652042388916,
0.49587589502334595,
0.0749586820602417,
0.14437326788902283,
-0.20968204736709595,
-0.5439432263374329,
-0.2939372658729553,
0.146558940410614,
-0.461505264043808,
-0.8683861494064331,
0.05937100946903229,
-0.04884470999240875,
0.5150647163391113,
0.69208824634552,
-0.07285609096288681,
0.7805587649345398,
-0.43113279342651367,
0.42752936482429504,
0.1206418052315712,
-1.088482141494751,
0.8766103386878967,
-0.10967081040143967,
-0.017727749422192574,
0.512934148311615,
0.506372332572937,
-0.18645721673965454,
-0.34001782536506653,
-0.5625438690185547,
-0.6965116262435913,
0.7396737933158875,
0.20774585008621216,
-0.08275114744901657,
0.4970000386238098,
0.5646526217460632,
-0.024099424481391907,
-0.0661306381225586,
-0.31900453567504883,
-0.4086668789386749,
-0.05669943243265152,
0.4555947780609131,
0.021025313064455986,
-0.49905768036842346,
-0.12004221230745316,
-0.3239143490791321,
1.0456395149230957,
-0.1509145051240921,
0.05518363043665886,
0.34276288747787476,
-0.025767724961042404,
-0.24744905531406403,
0.21381844580173492,
0.34669995307922363,
0.6696078181266785,
-0.08714452385902405,
0.01549579668790102,
0.06645523756742477,
-0.27072635293006897,
0.33273255825042725,
0.21835719048976898,
-0.37625136971473694,
-0.009214219637215137,
0.2859354317188263,
0.42590010166168213,
-0.1033690795302391,
-0.20920775830745697,
0.5105077624320984,
0.06928927451372147,
-0.3247518241405487,
-0.39675337076187134,
0.4344223141670227,
-0.0983428955078125,
0.2841534912586212,
0.5380091071128845,
0.23411233723163605,
0.5055065751075745,
-0.08021150529384613,
0.13781490921974182,
0.19391369819641113,
-0.12038812041282654,
-0.06549130380153656,
0.6737497448921204,
0.044431380927562714,
-0.24736887216567993,
0.5155297517776489,
-0.1032319888472557,
-0.4156489968299866,
0.6879433989524841,
0.5349993705749512,
0.3182174563407898,
-0.5064669847488403,
0.027752194553613663,
0.7076647877693176,
0.3052034378051758,
-0.26524561643600464,
0.6536946296691895,
-0.536196768283844,
-0.7409936785697937,
-0.7319309711456299,
-0.3831378221511841,
-0.7984556555747986,
-0.1449759304523468,
-0.8208869695663452,
0.23457132279872894,
-0.6580994725227356,
-0.22868667542934418,
0.33935344219207764,
-0.1433836817741394,
-0.5178412199020386,
0.4071626365184784,
0.18382862210273743,
1.0484373569488525,
-1.095516324043274,
1.0527862310409546,
0.579750120639801,
-0.4408363401889801,
-0.8557534217834473,
-0.20598885416984558,
0.1727532595396042,
-0.5062638521194458,
0.6252747178077698,
0.42248526215553284,
-0.19210146367549896,
-0.10794268548488617,
-0.398780882358551,
-0.7713196277618408,
1.1139590740203857,
0.2281905710697174,
-0.7778761982917786,
0.22227995097637177,
0.15572354197502136,
0.3842123746871948,
-0.07247098535299301,
0.5390095114707947,
0.5671166181564331,
0.5296074748039246,
0.12375748157501221,
-0.9291322827339172,
0.010502738878130913,
-0.6061947345733643,
-0.04069092497229576,
0.27938494086265564,
-0.11383450031280518,
0.5534119009971619,
-0.5303018093109131,
-0.036935605108737946,
-0.08637577295303345,
0.7505747675895691,
0.5576143264770508,
0.6004881262779236,
0.5048123598098755,
0.411277711391449,
0.7803886532783508,
-0.008684626780450344,
0.8675376772880554,
-0.523431122303009,
0.34043145179748535,
1.439730167388916,
-0.42035993933677673,
0.724341630935669,
0.7620833516120911,
-0.4497666358947754,
0.631004810333252,
0.4609622657299042,
-0.006230887491255999,
0.11633338779211044,
0.3837079107761383,
-0.3008958399295807,
-0.4519352614879608,
0.16164518892765045,
-0.1135241836309433,
0.45911598205566406,
0.29118841886520386,
-0.5875099897384644,
-0.26801928877830505,
0.036902401596307755,
0.059038739651441574,
0.1654386669397354,
-0.19939373433589935,
0.459288626909256,
-0.19373208284378052,
-0.7210522890090942,
0.11694613844156265,
0.22725291550159454,
0.47645148634910583,
-0.4895239472389221,
-0.2160436511039734,
0.10562431812286377,
0.33220717310905457,
-0.37593862414360046,
-0.6140023469924927,
0.4603154957294464,
0.10293729603290558,
-0.25905874371528625,
-0.4209764897823334,
0.8433462381362915,
0.03599623218178749,
-0.5874974131584167,
0.14171625673770905,
0.6112940311431885,
0.15829798579216003,
-0.30990853905677795,
-0.5283511281013489,
-0.16560764610767365,
-0.2202884405851364,
-0.4692850112915039,
0.03042946569621563,
0.28100183606147766,
-0.11108488589525223,
0.8473063707351685,
0.8086018562316895,
-0.0839972272515297,
0.12113012373447418,
-0.06677393615245819,
0.695317804813385,
-0.37656137347221375,
-0.35931864380836487,
-1.0863900184631348,
0.6865721940994263,
-0.44988322257995605,
-0.3019174337387085,
0.8335242867469788,
0.8328125476837158,
0.9355483651161194,
0.028539979830384254,
1.0392882823944092,
-0.046774230897426605,
0.5833640098571777,
-0.4368095397949219,
0.3473255932331085,
-0.08517603576183319,
0.2411724478006363,
-0.21996045112609863,
-0.5790130496025085,
-0.27580493688583374,
0.5965247750282288,
-0.6996253132820129,
-0.11309389770030975,
0.4308733642101288,
0.8723888397216797,
-0.23324230313301086,
0.14696945250034332,
0.19033877551555634,
-0.2685190439224243,
0.3988429605960846,
0.5867102146148682,
0.6139784455299377,
-0.5629376769065857,
0.09813503175973892,
-0.8049959540367126,
-0.555717408657074,
-0.05748739838600159,
-0.8350568413734436,
-0.6210815906524658,
-0.4544603228569031,
-0.5338833928108215,
-0.3136100172996521,
-0.09440595656633377,
0.7189649343490601,
0.6885397434234619,
-0.7846029996871948,
-0.16865374147891998,
-0.3768499195575714,
-0.10325630754232407,
-0.515532374382019,
-0.1208338513970375,
0.1126287579536438,
-0.42614465951919556,
-0.56770259141922,
0.3056838810443878,
0.1883625090122223,
-0.008413223549723625,
-0.2258797585964203,
-0.1479879915714264,
-0.08015275001525879,
-0.07126369327306747,
0.35675397515296936,
0.27160805463790894,
-0.6600606441497803,
-0.15719012916088104,
-0.5091904401779175,
-0.059612762182950974,
0.20542646944522858,
1.028059959411621,
-0.7310522198677063,
0.44800275564193726,
0.4556630551815033,
0.37765219807624817,
0.6603375673294067,
0.05219373479485512,
0.5815437436103821,
-0.20590625703334808,
-0.34076517820358276,
-0.2274954915046692,
0.7778828144073486,
-0.009863041341304779,
-0.557212233543396,
0.6199564337730408,
0.1394319385290146,
-0.6288806796073914,
-0.7631332278251648,
0.2274700105190277,
-0.7647342681884766,
0.14966942369937897,
0.724471390247345,
-0.6238035559654236,
-0.19678063690662384,
-0.19117321074008942,
-0.4343195855617523,
0.4729297161102295,
-0.2917279601097107,
0.927626371383667,
0.5967002511024475,
-0.6109016537666321,
-0.2681150734424591,
-0.5625688433647156,
0.32067298889160156,
0.42020270228385925,
-1.010280728340149,
0.2828570008277893,
0.5170350670814514,
0.282987505197525,
0.5403391718864441,
0.5964288115501404,
-0.03949018195271492,
0.4758189022541046,
0.08398032933473587,
0.07535857707262039,
-0.4918074905872345,
-0.3969310522079468,
-0.23098129034042358,
0.5271399617195129,
0.14009542763233185,
-0.4930919408798218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02656v1 | RACER: An LLM-powered Methodology for Scalable Analysis of Semi-structured Mental Health Interviews | 2024-02-05T00:56:30 | 2024-02-05T00:56:30 | Satpreet Harcharan Singh, Kevin Jiang, Kanchan Bhasin, Ashutosh Sabharwal, Nidal Moukaddam, Ankit B Patel | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.QM | Semi-structured interviews (SSIs) are a commonly employed data-collection
method in healthcare research, offering in-depth qualitative insights into
subject experiences. Despite their value, the manual analysis of SSIs is
notoriously time-consuming and labor-intensive, in part due to the difficulty
of extracting and categorizing emotional responses, and challenges in scaling
human evaluation for large populations. In this study, we develop RACER, a
Large Language Model (LLM) based expert-guided automated pipeline that
efficiently converts raw interview transcripts into insightful domain-relevant
themes and sub-themes. We used RACER to analyze SSIs conducted with 93
healthcare professionals and trainees to assess the broad personal and
professional mental health impacts of the COVID-19 crisis. RACER achieves
moderately high agreement with two human evaluators (72%), which approaches the
human inter-rater agreement (77%). Interestingly, LLMs and humans struggle with
similar content involving nuanced emotional, ambivalent/dialectical, and
psychological statements. Our study highlights the opportunities and challenges
in using LLMs to improve research efficiency and opens new avenues for scalable
analysis of SSIs in healthcare research. | [
-0.32425615191459656,
-0.823974072933197,
0.7397763133049011,
0.2629704773426056,
-0.03346037119626999,
0.49191007018089294,
-0.3212108314037323,
-0.4368469715118408,
0.3311883211135864,
-0.05683362856507301,
-0.9269834756851196,
-0.42552369832992554,
-0.46926143765449524,
0.26823708415031433,
-0.16393227875232697,
1.178268313407898,
0.10785876214504242,
0.2945387065410614,
-0.24011555314064026,
-0.006297308020293713,
-0.18613144755363464,
-0.5503906011581421,
-0.8691295385360718,
-0.1680910438299179,
0.5788066387176514,
0.29269659519195557,
0.5608375072479248,
0.1365649551153183,
0.643328845500946,
0.21742181479930878,
-0.06320676952600479,
-0.039495743811130524,
-0.8791866302490234,
0.39000624418258667,
-0.05838058516383171,
-0.09900668263435364,
-0.6231858134269714,
0.09337668865919113,
0.2807316780090332,
0.6299523115158081,
-0.5765154957771301,
0.6738196611404419,
-0.23999536037445068,
0.14657030999660492,
-0.6872523427009583,
0.13236939907073975,
-0.3604459762573242,
0.1373792290687561,
-0.40592268109321594,
-0.43693098425865173,
-0.34101662039756775,
-0.005842178128659725,
-0.34755510091781616,
-0.32869040966033936,
0.22828303277492523,
-0.022573864087462425,
0.4013483226299286,
0.5962240695953369,
-0.3761550188064575,
0.060028523206710815,
-0.9133077263832092,
0.5879087448120117,
-0.7650832533836365,
0.02689925767481327,
-0.018937956541776657,
0.4532560706138611,
-0.2539155185222626,
-0.5837780833244324,
-0.5120575428009033,
0.21957077085971832,
0.13683170080184937,
0.24447007477283478,
-0.25611814856529236,
0.20339606702327728,
0.42926469445228577,
0.2665085792541504,
-0.5606458783149719,
0.4417648911476135,
-0.3779691159725189,
-0.058271851390600204,
1.239861011505127,
1.1478415727615356,
0.5814018249511719,
0.008052730932831764,
0.05554347485303879,
0.2533322274684906,
-0.24402865767478943,
0.13499613106250763,
-0.2821125090122223,
0.17545799911022186,
-0.3114204406738281,
0.6460846066474915,
-0.19446556270122528,
0.5661192536354065,
0.09843714535236359,
-0.4383719265460968,
-0.030513791367411613,
-0.16914309561252594,
-0.12320562452077866,
0.06774856895208359,
1.0393879413604736,
0.5799495577812195,
-0.07319444417953491,
-0.4266008138656616,
0.0006783152348361909,
0.09423436969518661,
0.5735366344451904,
-0.8667377233505249,
-0.04638448730111122,
0.49638471007347107,
-0.27508068084716797,
-0.14164762198925018,
-0.22462382912635803,
-1.1711879968643188,
-0.6338356733322144,
-0.20166629552841187,
-0.00788048468530178,
-0.12717421352863312,
-0.23166808485984802,
0.25966158509254456,
-0.1340932548046112,
0.3172360956668854,
0.22681160271167755,
-0.4662383198738098,
0.1811738908290863,
0.7429797649383545,
0.8069383502006531,
-0.2812953591346741,
0.21592697501182556,
-0.8194994330406189,
0.2597194314002991,
-0.1883390098810196,
0.6813185214996338,
-0.711979329586029,
-0.5575826168060303,
-0.06017126142978668,
-0.29091885685920715,
-0.2755964398384094,
-0.3578490614891052,
0.38618040084838867,
-0.2782460153102875,
0.1438182294368744,
-0.1815132051706314,
-0.45984795689582825,
0.34057071805000305,
0.26430168747901917,
-0.16756649315357208,
1.1413249969482422,
0.2026919722557068,
-0.9766398668289185,
0.1745654046535492,
-0.4556090533733368,
-0.6198760867118835,
0.3671090006828308,
-0.6914036870002747,
-0.5077940225601196,
0.46105316281318665,
0.15260206162929535,
0.6159124970436096,
-0.5871514678001404,
0.6482239961624146,
-0.7374380230903625,
-0.43366679549217224,
0.06197889894247055,
0.21727800369262695,
0.7833356857299805,
0.04524398595094681,
-0.3532901108264923,
0.14231352508068085,
-0.8430584073066711,
0.07667933404445648,
-0.02911633811891079,
-0.11780495941638947,
-0.4263421297073364,
0.04096534475684166,
0.2023838311433792,
0.4654638171195984,
-0.15404370427131653,
-0.6951737999916077,
-0.04870344325900078,
-0.17229442298412323,
0.4730985760688782,
0.5122938752174377,
0.17807026207447052,
-0.0059556555934250355,
-0.11015377938747406,
1.142172932624817,
-0.2707952558994293,
0.22396419942378998,
0.2713107168674469,
-0.48402145504951477,
-0.2887660264968872,
-0.8058733940124512,
-0.3537273406982422,
0.6146491765975952,
-0.6276203989982605,
0.31163308024406433,
-0.3766796588897705,
-0.5962197184562683,
-0.6737446188926697,
-0.17290431261062622,
0.24696125090122223,
0.7297302484512329,
0.17209552228450775,
-0.2690518796443939,
-0.5791799426078796,
-0.8156033754348755,
-0.432348370552063,
-0.150108203291893,
-0.08388251811265945,
0.2590954005718231,
0.5130653977394104,
-0.3417302370071411,
0.9933937788009644,
-0.5478574633598328,
-0.006147413048893213,
-0.45898357033729553,
0.47221559286117554,
0.015029381029307842,
0.15593522787094116,
0.30582016706466675,
-0.1357485055923462,
-0.41598203778266907,
-0.2111683487892151,
-0.9528636336326599,
-0.2986212968826294,
-0.04512209817767143,
-0.13251210749149323,
-0.4251602292060852,
0.3640791177749634,
-0.6568762063980103,
0.4297250509262085,
0.3094410300254822,
-0.38089871406555176,
0.5430788397789001,
0.017633037641644478,
0.055480871349573135,
-1.0528645515441895,
0.24477225542068481,
0.215584859251976,
-0.09694726020097733,
-0.6102003455162048,
0.013677244074642658,
-0.36410966515541077,
-0.30969953536987305,
-0.1384812742471695,
0.41320523619651794,
-0.30001258850097656,
0.08455663174390793,
0.011709733866155148,
-0.18283917009830475,
-0.21223360300064087,
0.17793193459510803,
-0.06238725036382675,
1.0534741878509521,
0.2691318690776825,
-0.1455874741077423,
0.3559111952781677,
0.2838309705257416,
-0.37180355191230774,
0.8549814224243164,
-0.6139113306999207,
0.502433717250824,
-0.37917110323905945,
0.3233812749385834,
-0.7744652032852173,
-0.3021931052207947,
-0.07891907542943954,
-0.24601727724075317,
0.3087172210216522,
0.2698870599269867,
-0.21069206297397614,
-0.4088651239871979,
-0.25656116008758545,
0.4080694317817688,
0.32885614037513733,
0.23433421552181244,
0.40103602409362793,
0.9431578516960144,
-0.6247677206993103,
-0.17011211812496185,
-0.40309998393058777,
0.4625384509563446,
-0.5010767579078674,
-0.5980504751205444,
0.15314213931560516,
-0.19075864553451538,
-0.7201680541038513,
-0.4098365306854248,
-0.14969033002853394,
-0.29684609174728394,
0.22422091662883759,
0.1698167771100998,
0.42534956336021423,
-0.14221951365470886,
-0.04221651703119278,
0.10711802542209625,
-0.0764247253537178,
0.48219117522239685,
0.2058693766593933,
0.15793025493621826,
-0.13023337721824646,
-0.03189070522785187,
-0.6486205458641052,
0.7066541910171509,
0.7510119080543518,
-0.28551825881004333,
0.8262513875961304,
0.6532025933265686,
-0.26652470231056213,
-0.08559457212686539,
-0.48747000098228455,
-0.14829117059707642,
-0.3205447494983673,
0.5988474488258362,
-0.17825083434581757,
-1.0747103691101074,
0.34198668599128723,
-0.09804336726665497,
-0.14154447615146637,
0.31973129510879517,
0.9000338315963745,
-0.45601287484169006,
1.1021368503570557,
0.6141065359115601,
-0.3782345652580261,
0.08111049979925156,
-0.18340563774108887,
0.3350578546524048,
-0.6797173023223877,
-0.589330792427063,
-0.7407336235046387,
-0.44641372561454773,
-0.35382696986198425,
-0.5030253529548645,
1.0627479553222656,
-0.5503408908843994,
-0.362633615732193,
-0.37168967723846436,
-0.39610886573791504,
-0.0162587258964777,
0.02225577086210251,
0.36705270409584045,
0.25631752610206604,
-0.3817431330680847,
0.21757397055625916,
-0.3792669475078583,
-0.837901771068573,
-0.21226242184638977,
0.759774386882782,
0.33908548951148987,
0.8754702210426331,
-0.021504852920770645,
0.47710120677948,
0.4243130683898926,
0.48271432518959045,
-0.8050426244735718,
0.5233214497566223,
0.21008460223674774,
-0.860264241695404,
-0.2885909676551819,
-0.43801814317703247,
-0.5600422620773315,
-0.08553028851747513,
-0.26729485392570496,
-0.776393473148346,
0.11774078756570816,
-0.2568739950656891,
-0.9117797613143921,
0.13832345604896545,
-0.24705344438552856,
0.6914588809013367,
-0.3566437363624573,
-0.5071707963943481,
-0.2497127652168274,
-0.8044739961624146,
0.5153796076774597,
-0.29128527641296387,
0.3803563416004181,
-0.37784111499786377,
-0.055626142770051956,
0.9465156197547913,
-0.5946904420852661,
0.7866036295890808,
-0.09704388678073883,
0.08019275218248367,
-0.06358950585126877,
-0.09608417749404907,
0.3704158365726471,
0.32353708148002625,
-0.19655168056488037,
0.102961964905262,
0.2863929569721222,
-0.4294731616973877,
-0.8542571663856506,
0.1729525625705719,
-0.7610883116722107,
-0.6206991076469421,
-0.5593427419662476,
-0.7509632706642151,
-0.6900806427001953,
-0.09136083722114563,
0.10569814592599869,
0.33507928252220154,
-0.22432662546634674,
-0.17272064089775085,
0.6272934675216675,
-0.2917627990245819,
0.054881878197193146,
0.7320391535758972,
0.20107460021972656,
-0.26578289270401,
0.3714834451675415,
-0.14605993032455444,
-0.19393093883991241,
0.1521175503730774,
0.13665913045406342,
0.0640011876821518,
-0.5657616257667542,
-0.2540973126888275,
0.5126131176948547,
-0.05814091116189957,
-0.1083335354924202,
-0.6170243620872498,
-0.20135661959648132,
-0.2986229658126831,
0.0015899374848231673,
-0.540217936038971,
-0.21310684084892273,
-0.09344609081745148,
-0.14577379822731018,
0.3362753987312317,
0.725810170173645,
0.19987447559833527,
0.2219357043504715,
-0.6598833799362183,
0.1756593883037567,
0.20510907471179962,
0.18525183200836182,
-0.12090002000331879,
-0.4361071288585663,
-0.6009369492530823,
-0.2089838832616806,
-0.05940984934568405,
-1.0213245153427124,
0.5667018890380859,
0.2070200890302658,
0.38628238439559937,
0.48612844944000244,
0.48999813199043274,
1.22968327999115,
-0.4589787721633911,
0.65177321434021,
0.3192638158798218,
-0.6049604415893555,
0.5223853588104248,
-0.5136229991912842,
-0.02895902842283249,
1.0852099657058716,
0.3973050117492676,
-0.50346440076828,
-0.6176706552505493,
-0.4432864487171173,
-0.678247332572937,
0.5976626873016357,
0.17097266018390656,
-0.15944576263427734,
-0.07721665501594543,
0.6015034914016724,
-0.11763310432434082,
0.22484692931175232,
0.10311903804540634,
-0.10525573045015335,
0.4113313555717468,
-0.5339956283569336,
-0.4569689631462097,
-0.3795672655105591,
-0.5205328464508057,
-0.6086134314537048,
0.4153045117855072,
0.0053032864816486835,
0.31435438990592957,
0.18153926730155945,
0.20400777459144592,
-0.1488385945558548,
0.43066641688346863,
0.2906875014305115,
0.4575601816177368,
-0.3980865180492401,
0.24999678134918213,
0.132241889834404,
-0.55168616771698,
0.29704728722572327,
0.21338823437690735,
-0.022283222526311874,
-0.035397596657276154,
0.503589928150177,
0.5902965068817139,
0.2614383101463318,
-1.0627307891845703,
0.43485426902770996,
-0.16674774885177612,
0.3159716725349426,
-0.28181540966033936,
0.045904818922281265,
0.0516253225505352,
0.40105438232421875,
-0.0012557955924421549,
-0.28991588950157166,
0.4259180724620819,
-0.582493782043457,
0.13054479658603668,
0.5295912623405457,
-0.5136700868606567,
-0.6273855566978455,
0.9006447792053223,
0.307612806558609,
-0.37617290019989014,
0.9377215504646301,
0.06000693514943123,
-0.1485615223646164,
0.2869308292865753,
0.29111090302467346,
0.9336331486701965,
-0.2243427336215973,
0.3342263102531433,
0.1827082633972168,
0.16537730395793915,
0.022594310343265533,
0.420139342546463,
0.05941858887672424,
-0.38807106018066406,
-0.5586016178131104,
-0.4454508125782013,
-0.5102589130401611,
0.14936743676662445,
-1.3603118658065796,
-0.019921904429793358,
-0.32623401284217834,
-0.6633386611938477,
0.0018701755907386541,
-0.053603142499923706,
-0.7671839594841003,
0.2690017521381378,
0.35497424006462097,
0.9593130350112915,
-1.1084730625152588,
0.641627848148346,
1.0463536977767944,
-0.3484724164009094,
-0.9367586970329285,
-0.029877595603466034,
0.3702174723148346,
-0.7849331498146057,
0.27416741847991943,
-0.10898346453905106,
-0.059318266808986664,
-0.05239485204219818,
-0.47153908014297485,
-0.3779127299785614,
1.1494601964950562,
0.6904971599578857,
-0.46513837575912476,
-0.3922097682952881,
0.20982463657855988,
0.8594174385070801,
-0.49129271507263184,
0.6409544348716736,
0.7385907769203186,
0.26360946893692017,
0.14078888297080994,
-0.9694060683250427,
0.04220049828290939,
-0.6421681642532349,
0.03601427748799324,
-0.2166270762681961,
-0.7850004434585571,
0.32712551951408386,
-0.33819833397865295,
-0.06901107728481293,
-0.23533004522323608,
0.44451096653938293,
0.5025507807731628,
0.8061907887458801,
0.23812328279018402,
0.6191812753677368,
1.2013146877288818,
0.32012027502059937,
1.1490085124969482,
-0.3020268678665161,
0.5266691446304321,
1.3020490407943726,
-0.49173492193222046,
0.6978954672813416,
0.4749387502670288,
-0.5261252522468567,
0.5947482585906982,
0.7686918377876282,
0.3068273663520813,
0.06215842068195343,
0.22997987270355225,
-0.5803813934326172,
-0.6800342202186584,
-0.21155758202075958,
-0.25165876746177673,
0.5016416311264038,
0.22880366444587708,
-0.11871083825826645,
-0.21643337607383728,
0.09258395433425903,
0.3577841520309448,
-0.15913274884223938,
-0.163286030292511,
0.6069515943527222,
0.2689094543457031,
-0.392477422952652,
0.33249983191490173,
0.022545861080288887,
0.26064422726631165,
-0.4004099667072296,
0.41721248626708984,
-0.44226011633872986,
-0.04032949358224869,
-0.22327359020709991,
-0.4199715554714203,
0.5393237471580505,
0.4535309076309204,
-0.2950376272201538,
-0.2687460780143738,
0.4244258999824524,
-0.1414472609758377,
-0.756284236907959,
0.18965214490890503,
0.7542600631713867,
0.3341033160686493,
-0.09479302912950516,
-0.6581836938858032,
0.25417205691337585,
-0.3509784936904907,
-0.28359660506248474,
0.4225653409957886,
0.36788055300712585,
0.03525073826313019,
0.6593979001045227,
0.08483441919088364,
0.39461928606033325,
0.025211604312062263,
0.11890510469675064,
0.8181479573249817,
-0.8618839979171753,
-0.46142998337745667,
-0.9147056937217712,
0.6643010973930359,
-0.22100089490413666,
-0.10163915157318115,
0.7185645699501038,
0.9179966449737549,
0.20797395706176758,
0.062211040407419205,
0.942195475101471,
-0.043261073529720306,
0.5056949853897095,
-0.14900103211402893,
0.6739987134933472,
-0.5877739191055298,
0.17313678562641144,
-0.28187260031700134,
-0.06120571494102478,
-0.219862163066864,
0.33265602588653564,
-0.4910542666912079,
-0.12208478152751923,
0.5346400737762451,
0.7077557444572449,
0.27191975712776184,
0.05134136602282524,
0.0911446362733841,
0.5330628156661987,
0.42206037044525146,
0.742273211479187,
0.8680224418640137,
0.07791829854249954,
-0.012709463015198708,
0.12029554694890976,
-0.49226731061935425,
0.14542512595653534,
-0.5377729535102844,
-0.9022107720375061,
-0.22301512956619263,
-0.6199179291725159,
-0.3542171120643616,
0.2819920480251312,
0.7943877577781677,
0.7334924936294556,
-0.5872839689254761,
-0.33531126379966736,
0.4098398983478546,
-0.08348938822746277,
-0.21276645362377167,
-0.20150376856327057,
0.13379141688346863,
-0.20107057690620422,
-0.5726249814033508,
0.48366376757621765,
0.7364426851272583,
-0.5839160680770874,
-0.3944670259952545,
-0.022540975362062454,
0.10130900144577026,
0.07964818924665451,
0.41801539063453674,
0.17056944966316223,
-0.36069273948669434,
-0.028162991628050804,
0.005700156558305025,
-0.15717916190624237,
0.09980626404285431,
1.0710536241531372,
-0.7429504990577698,
0.6216853260993958,
0.15079781413078308,
0.7781851291656494,
0.4926513135433197,
0.103196881711483,
0.6445014476776123,
-0.33258241415023804,
-0.06415877491235733,
0.3125373125076294,
0.016623834148049355,
0.06304780393838882,
-0.5650147795677185,
0.43879979848861694,
0.6322073936462402,
-0.40895509719848633,
-1.0992846488952637,
-0.14550112187862396,
-1.121264934539795,
0.03800320625305176,
1.1888763904571533,
-0.14182385802268982,
-0.12097473442554474,
-0.3496300280094147,
0.13603579998016357,
0.36801114678382874,
-0.18509048223495483,
1.0707145929336548,
0.45905908942222595,
-0.6733913421630859,
-0.22730235755443573,
-0.7764155268669128,
0.3418407440185547,
0.10231208801269531,
-0.9858229160308838,
-0.23174676299095154,
0.3738078474998474,
0.4591243863105774,
-0.42343419790267944,
1.1390893459320068,
-0.009082801640033722,
0.04911156743764877,
-0.2321568727493286,
0.08911573141813278,
-0.12390206009149551,
-0.07140380144119263,
-0.34430280327796936,
0.2723686397075653,
-0.24603386223316193,
0.19751086831092834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02655v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02655v2 | VlogQA: Task, Dataset, and Baseline Models for Vietnamese Spoken-Based Machine Reading Comprehension | 2024-02-05T00:54:40 | 2024-04-06T04:29:58 | Thinh Phuoc Ngo, Khoa Tran Anh Dang, Son T. Luu, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the development process of a Vietnamese spoken language
corpus for machine reading comprehension (MRC) tasks and provides insights into
the challenges and opportunities associated with using real-world data for
machine reading comprehension tasks. The existing MRC corpora in Vietnamese
mainly focus on formal written documents such as Wikipedia articles, online
newspapers, or textbooks. In contrast, the VlogQA consists of 10,076
question-answer pairs based on 1,230 transcript documents sourced from YouTube
-- an extensive source of user-uploaded content, covering the topics of food
and travel. By capturing the spoken language of native Vietnamese speakers in
natural settings, an obscure corner overlooked in Vietnamese research, the
corpus provides a valuable resource for future research in reading
comprehension tasks for the Vietnamese language. Regarding performance
evaluation, our deep-learning models achieved the highest F1 score of 75.34% on
the test set, indicating significant progress in machine reading comprehension
for Vietnamese spoken language data. In terms of EM, the highest score we
accomplished is 53.97%, which reflects the challenge in processing spoken-based
content and highlights the need for further improvement. | [
-0.32882553339004517,
-0.9035417437553406,
0.4486887753009796,
-0.2740779519081116,
-0.2713756263256073,
0.19286859035491943,
0.06461962312459946,
-0.2567014694213867,
-0.12177423387765884,
0.9676167964935303,
-0.587027370929718,
-0.7777788639068604,
-0.3867347538471222,
0.24376079440116882,
-0.4137313961982727,
0.7855551242828369,
-0.09382976591587067,
-0.16615653038024902,
-0.36679595708847046,
-0.19408667087554932,
-0.6243528723716736,
-0.6514741778373718,
-0.3861408829689026,
0.008468110114336014,
0.5292222499847412,
0.8064752817153931,
0.4895218312740326,
0.7227802276611328,
0.31998300552368164,
0.22387798130512238,
-0.038374122232198715,
0.343196302652359,
-0.6708143353462219,
0.20679570734500885,
0.0227312371134758,
-0.5400782823562622,
-0.2708348333835602,
-0.09875617176294327,
0.7125223278999329,
0.4760611355304718,
-0.105307437479496,
0.4283156096935272,
0.052987925708293915,
0.6809551119804382,
-0.49079757928848267,
0.1557765156030655,
-0.6098834872245789,
-0.06808322668075562,
0.19409213960170746,
-0.17015832662582397,
-0.551242470741272,
0.0231013186275959,
0.14756828546524048,
-0.685464084148407,
0.19611942768096924,
-0.2123095840215683,
1.0406454801559448,
0.5478626489639282,
-0.7649344205856323,
-0.28779473900794983,
-0.5059442520141602,
0.8459542989730835,
-0.46771061420440674,
0.4683980643749237,
0.9332051277160645,
0.3161795735359192,
0.5159246325492859,
-0.7603570222854614,
-0.672961413860321,
-0.46813395619392395,
-0.11878164857625961,
0.3005366027355194,
-0.09885041415691376,
-0.18103092908859253,
0.1789916306734085,
0.23008954524993896,
-1.147971510887146,
-0.02203020453453064,
-0.8013365268707275,
0.00280354218557477,
0.44905635714530945,
0.24780800938606262,
-0.08595994114875793,
-0.5575376152992249,
-0.4093194007873535,
-0.05767003446817398,
-0.4128154218196869,
-0.03742027282714844,
0.14736101031303406,
0.19744522869586945,
-0.03065536543726921,
0.8380663394927979,
-0.5625802278518677,
1.1149263381958008,
-0.5776805877685547,
-0.20865370333194733,
0.41452428698539734,
-0.6764379739761353,
-0.5595483183860779,
-0.16648806631565094,
0.2951233983039856,
0.37049081921577454,
0.5129877328872681,
0.34733158349990845,
-0.20011670887470245,
-0.19774867594242096,
0.5707019567489624,
-0.34989669919013977,
-0.1503814458847046,
0.5353929400444031,
-0.450145423412323,
-0.12989991903305054,
0.07553280889987946,
-0.47930195927619934,
0.029269490391016006,
-0.8161864876747131,
0.4033735394477844,
-0.4224046468734741,
-0.2661658823490143,
0.1380079686641693,
-0.24856466054916382,
0.5056349635124207,
0.1879701018333435,
-0.5219125151634216,
0.15571558475494385,
0.8617242574691772,
0.9622991681098938,
-0.12772898375988007,
-0.19917109608650208,
-0.7464141845703125,
0.045539263635873795,
-0.028289463371038437,
0.8498749136924744,
-0.34538599848747253,
-0.4823465645313263,
0.32592111825942993,
0.13941174745559692,
-0.338818222284317,
-0.7051560282707214,
0.6868634819984436,
-0.5022459626197815,
0.27195531129837036,
0.03963371738791466,
-0.5985212922096252,
-0.34614846110343933,
0.37630704045295715,
-0.766819417476654,
1.0962116718292236,
0.38526585698127747,
-0.6549449563026428,
0.1563078761100769,
-0.11730717122554779,
-0.4095534682273865,
0.15914402902126312,
0.2096986472606659,
-0.16079804301261902,
-0.2625633180141449,
0.40490972995758057,
0.5307389497756958,
-0.001685085124336183,
0.061221178621053696,
0.07280726730823517,
-0.3861175775527954,
0.27878713607788086,
-0.4643988013267517,
1.0001899003982544,
0.62529456615448,
-0.1381632387638092,
0.21878913044929504,
-0.7252483367919922,
0.37997594475746155,
-0.19710281491279602,
-0.3032101094722748,
-0.2570619583129883,
-0.29196518659591675,
0.1533229649066925,
0.14519578218460083,
0.15677881240844727,
-0.024033907800912857,
0.03694179281592369,
-0.010896964929997921,
0.3627574145793915,
0.39801573753356934,
0.05813620612025261,
0.13582497835159302,
-0.2246093451976776,
0.763089656829834,
-0.05267871916294098,
-0.0009565261425450444,
-0.6308314800262451,
-0.633704423904419,
-0.8299586772918701,
-0.4673403799533844,
0.4845573604106903,
1.238179326057434,
-0.8616024851799011,
0.35661712288856506,
-0.09885496646165848,
-0.6339238882064819,
-1.0662733316421509,
0.1406036615371704,
0.48549291491508484,
0.9954434633255005,
0.47055530548095703,
-0.008771463297307491,
-0.5224305391311646,
-0.7956932783126831,
-0.059813156723976135,
-0.47224703431129456,
-0.40625202655792236,
0.35940611362457275,
0.5471516847610474,
-0.40841081738471985,
0.4953638017177582,
-0.6642653942108154,
-0.234610915184021,
-0.34503284096717834,
-0.013877062126994133,
0.275199830532074,
0.26042577624320984,
0.15072640776634216,
-1.0012835264205933,
-0.5128389000892639,
0.08741670846939087,
-0.9354093670845032,
-0.1163577139377594,
-0.012770590372383595,
-0.13749916851520538,
0.3282083570957184,
0.8534604907035828,
-0.5230294466018677,
0.309408038854599,
0.6952605247497559,
-0.42803314328193665,
0.7082298994064331,
-0.11373666673898697,
0.2873622179031372,
-0.9660730957984924,
0.17224723100662231,
0.036899883300065994,
-0.47620755434036255,
-0.5737839341163635,
0.2908872067928314,
0.038638100028038025,
0.010873248800635338,
-0.6306917071342468,
0.48770442605018616,
-0.1424262523651123,
0.18671250343322754,
-0.12280062586069107,
0.3343695104122162,
0.009916090406477451,
0.2477836012840271,
0.2819657325744629,
0.6447515487670898,
0.47322967648506165,
-0.7790255546569824,
0.38805055618286133,
0.27305009961128235,
-0.35166269540786743,
0.7798335552215576,
-0.8031110167503357,
0.08469462394714355,
-0.1417446881532669,
0.0631459653377533,
-1.0585567951202393,
-0.10160022228956223,
0.34846848249435425,
-0.7607555389404297,
0.13836538791656494,
-0.08983097970485687,
-0.20981504023075104,
-0.3142469823360443,
0.20184697210788727,
0.12838199734687805,
0.5089648365974426,
-0.2429511398077011,
0.19180943071842194,
0.49034014344215393,
-0.2177807092666626,
-0.6234686970710754,
-0.6994260549545288,
0.08026852458715439,
-0.24318267405033112,
-0.6152065396308899,
0.002895892132073641,
0.01092902198433876,
-0.4235474169254303,
0.06185277923941612,
0.14661799371242523,
-0.3784593641757965,
-0.20491111278533936,
0.11182224750518799,
0.20843368768692017,
-0.643639087677002,
0.19267882406711578,
-0.16001123189926147,
-0.3605140149593353,
-0.21936798095703125,
-0.5906820297241211,
0.29764246940612793,
-0.09124185889959335,
0.0029113355558365583,
-0.48480287194252014,
0.5097581148147583,
0.1747114062309265,
-0.4186685383319855,
0.8142295479774475,
0.8881123065948486,
-0.35677459836006165,
-0.0010301594156771898,
-0.33445408940315247,
0.05925419554114342,
-0.4101722240447998,
0.38347959518432617,
-0.67657470703125,
-1.214303731918335,
0.15915001928806305,
0.46244633197784424,
0.07135054469108582,
0.5781943798065186,
0.6984627842903137,
-0.4003589451313019,
0.6146175861358643,
0.5045377612113953,
-0.1347869634628296,
0.31981220841407776,
-0.26979345083236694,
-0.3245548605918884,
-0.407929003238678,
-0.13509951531887054,
-0.6997557282447815,
0.11393822729587555,
-0.694529116153717,
-0.8782878518104553,
0.021785572171211243,
-0.20544786751270294,
-0.22290253639221191,
0.5280368328094482,
-0.4149533808231354,
0.21703237295150757,
0.9436099529266357,
-0.054269734770059586,
0.6377082467079163,
-0.046423666179180145,
-0.19632397592067719,
-0.049845945090055466,
-0.4795690178871155,
-0.9325193166732788,
1.0769413709640503,
0.3097611367702484,
0.29534196853637695,
-0.15740320086479187,
0.465514212846756,
0.6008339524269104,
-0.1137763187289238,
-0.8074181079864502,
0.404563307762146,
0.12032749503850937,
-0.6969278454780579,
-0.5709130167961121,
-0.6157825589179993,
-0.9960403442382812,
0.371413916349411,
0.25789254903793335,
-0.502166748046875,
-0.1896650493144989,
0.0025098260957747698,
-0.13303427398204803,
-0.08889110386371613,
-0.8793100714683533,
1.2852948904037476,
-0.07206066697835922,
0.011256490834057331,
-0.2271561324596405,
-0.812890350818634,
0.4830179214477539,
-0.00027144295745529234,
0.14871704578399658,
0.16772577166557312,
-0.2056283801794052,
0.5266684889793396,
-0.15788458287715912,
0.585820198059082,
-0.021843111142516136,
-0.10150108486413956,
0.8790721893310547,
-0.10731763392686844,
0.079548679292202,
0.5860772132873535,
-0.2236834168434143,
0.0754016637802124,
0.3495825529098511,
-0.8733099699020386,
-0.2915385663509369,
0.38370996713638306,
-0.6239057779312134,
-0.49082517623901367,
-0.4804123342037201,
-0.12357509881258011,
-0.18830741941928864,
0.2688226103782654,
0.09651023894548416,
0.03345899656414986,
-0.40408551692962646,
0.21570447087287903,
0.8906291723251343,
-0.185061514377594,
-0.028283949941396713,
0.5668371319770813,
-0.10832098871469498,
-0.5783301591873169,
1.0529944896697998,
-0.009400635026395321,
0.42907625436782837,
0.866155207157135,
-0.3646721839904785,
-0.165260449051857,
-0.423345148563385,
-0.5161135792732239,
0.35065189003944397,
-0.5811967849731445,
0.01563367247581482,
-0.7565814256668091,
-0.43323245644569397,
-0.4801250696182251,
0.11275041103363037,
-0.1563170850276947,
-0.26491451263427734,
-0.5471022129058838,
-0.5306867361068726,
0.10929329693317413,
0.7688570618629456,
0.014791159890592098,
0.40405723452568054,
-0.8518519997596741,
0.7002557516098022,
0.2943955063819885,
-0.10806606709957123,
-0.39699986577033997,
-0.8682593703269958,
-0.5931162238121033,
0.051565930247306824,
-0.2371455878019333,
-0.7040150761604309,
0.573740541934967,
-0.017886212095618248,
0.40903258323669434,
0.2792036533355713,
0.02500106394290924,
0.6577062606811523,
-0.34049952030181885,
0.7638851404190063,
-0.42683151364326477,
-0.7413594722747803,
0.3163251280784607,
-0.3984892666339874,
0.7707507610321045,
0.6433320641517639,
0.562706708908081,
-0.8745607733726501,
-0.3435204029083252,
-0.4585508704185486,
-0.6587674617767334,
0.36200350522994995,
0.299915075302124,
-0.013125400990247726,
0.31278344988822937,
0.2305404394865036,
0.22214429080486298,
0.3382444977760315,
-0.31234192848205566,
-0.13787741959095,
-0.40071991086006165,
-0.13413237035274506,
-0.5687001347541809,
-0.3733801543712616,
0.13106243312358856,
-0.44905370473861694,
0.46041786670684814,
-0.236596018075943,
0.27475255727767944,
0.3024117350578308,
-0.2583114504814148,
0.10770437866449356,
-0.13759540021419525,
0.8773861527442932,
0.6838452219963074,
-0.2477341741323471,
0.14682777225971222,
0.11275603622198105,
-0.6654443144798279,
-0.11055651307106018,
-0.0546112023293972,
-0.19226010143756866,
0.195497065782547,
0.7135764360427856,
0.7431265711784363,
-0.1336635947227478,
-1.127279281616211,
0.0003394295636098832,
-0.2305659055709839,
-0.43574362993240356,
-0.5108028054237366,
0.01414575707167387,
0.26514410972595215,
0.16452042758464813,
0.45901474356651306,
-0.35356035828590393,
0.09538304805755615,
-0.31898191571235657,
0.7731872200965881,
0.015435602515935898,
-0.7942197322845459,
-0.09058719128370285,
0.4312953054904938,
-0.0015332286711782217,
-0.2490128129720688,
1.1102744340896606,
-0.07198082655668259,
-0.45333003997802734,
0.6325734853744507,
0.1310833990573883,
0.6073681116104126,
-0.24444909393787384,
0.6908233761787415,
0.6378062963485718,
0.6090037226676941,
0.28713473677635193,
0.5137270092964172,
-0.10682433098554611,
-0.23282474279403687,
-0.40224170684814453,
-0.5380731821060181,
-0.4939520061016083,
0.13912104070186615,
-0.6667677164077759,
0.34311115741729736,
0.12155336141586304,
0.021639594808220863,
-0.26957422494888306,
0.14019742608070374,
-0.7883820533752441,
0.5789505243301392,
0.24654968082904816,
0.9418236613273621,
-0.4670679271221161,
0.8807704448699951,
0.488023042678833,
-0.3947625756263733,
-0.45039454102516174,
-0.007362960837781429,
0.06027267128229141,
-0.7895379066467285,
0.34110453724861145,
0.16593536734580994,
0.2460753619670868,
0.05815848335623741,
-0.40471112728118896,
-0.8113439679145813,
0.8054413795471191,
0.15558455884456635,
-0.3845466077327728,
-0.10389900207519531,
0.3242323696613312,
0.6609921455383301,
-0.3281361162662506,
0.23806703090667725,
0.7024518847465515,
0.6252094507217407,
-0.04576777294278145,
-0.926527202129364,
-0.3209686279296875,
-0.1267623007297516,
-0.3972339332103729,
-0.28882744908332825,
-0.5813113451004028,
0.7091616988182068,
-0.17169231176376343,
-0.0635349377989769,
0.0706794261932373,
1.089798092842102,
0.26550936698913574,
0.6351088881492615,
0.3407282531261444,
0.5174027681350708,
0.9927764534950256,
0.23226289451122284,
0.920744001865387,
0.195321187376976,
0.1286875158548355,
1.150228500366211,
-0.010408259928226471,
1.2135157585144043,
0.47768834233283997,
-0.10081873834133148,
0.4112105667591095,
0.9705343842506409,
0.08029589802026749,
0.42937254905700684,
0.22893942892551422,
-0.1812797486782074,
-0.38166090846061707,
-0.15436069667339325,
-0.20610010623931885,
0.5627634525299072,
0.39245888590812683,
-0.3123967945575714,
0.27805304527282715,
0.05731811746954918,
-0.13544738292694092,
0.16912902891635895,
-0.10970527678728104,
0.7394479513168335,
0.40624162554740906,
-0.8601961135864258,
0.9549086093902588,
-0.1361081749200821,
0.118547223508358,
-0.31893429160118103,
-0.09536921977996826,
-0.12994706630706787,
0.08581820130348206,
-0.09883931279182434,
-1.0830811262130737,
0.42535266280174255,
0.1209006980061531,
-0.15521597862243652,
-0.1920909434556961,
0.3999250531196594,
-0.42550721764564514,
-0.5209750533103943,
0.11473234742879868,
0.8701605200767517,
0.31268906593322754,
-0.3076938986778259,
-0.7200803160667419,
0.08182962983846664,
0.20310308039188385,
-0.3260746896266937,
0.12068179249763489,
0.5999080538749695,
0.17486214637756348,
0.6269463300704956,
0.3666161298751831,
-0.28746774792671204,
0.174353688955307,
-0.06512648612260818,
0.4662243127822876,
-0.9148569703102112,
-0.38984414935112,
-0.5423467755317688,
0.8561475872993469,
0.07700280100107193,
-0.6322174072265625,
0.7420526742935181,
0.689812421798706,
1.248769998550415,
-0.36056843400001526,
0.946987509727478,
0.15087556838989258,
0.7564736604690552,
-0.6309953331947327,
0.6284535527229309,
-0.5993480086326599,
-0.10319533944129944,
-0.12547561526298523,
-0.7531116008758545,
-0.15656179189682007,
0.3110372722148895,
0.06305790692567825,
-0.1127030998468399,
0.8377142548561096,
0.7063273191452026,
0.08592869341373444,
-0.15054775774478912,
0.6265137791633606,
-0.028484588488936424,
0.06412717700004578,
0.5199583172798157,
0.7309178113937378,
-0.5280565023422241,
0.8238781094551086,
-0.04836323484778404,
-0.058499183505773544,
-0.37440723180770874,
-0.3728434443473816,
-1.0469892024993896,
-1.1215081214904785,
-0.3032376766204834,
-0.37907692790031433,
0.2745223939418793,
0.3744501769542694,
0.5616744756698608,
-0.8596247434616089,
-0.5180054903030396,
0.22493427991867065,
0.44256073236465454,
-0.4749642312526703,
-0.2611065208911896,
0.19227491319179535,
-0.2378903031349182,
-0.8839269280433655,
0.43842414021492004,
-0.007686307188123465,
-0.21832580864429474,
-0.3467688262462616,
-0.2172532081604004,
-0.43178096413612366,
-0.08630611002445221,
0.7662970423698425,
0.4210340678691864,
-0.5315045714378357,
-0.025904295966029167,
0.46395447850227356,
-0.4284573197364807,
0.0101671377196908,
0.7396460771560669,
-1.0662211179733276,
0.5005128979682922,
0.6235057711601257,
0.6448602676391602,
0.6402785778045654,
0.2544151246547699,
0.5987982153892517,
-0.3722294569015503,
0.04329468309879303,
0.40121206641197205,
0.032126378268003464,
0.3438699543476105,
-0.10857486724853516,
0.6546620726585388,
0.2839849591255188,
-0.6418805122375488,
-1.017983078956604,
0.1436339020729065,
-1.1554417610168457,
-0.2352120578289032,
1.1297482252120972,
-0.04831157997250557,
-0.4476945102214813,
-0.43647706508636475,
-0.5775067210197449,
0.44240057468414307,
-0.2925886809825897,
0.45975181460380554,
0.5953100323677063,
0.2157701849937439,
-0.3746985197067261,
-1.3333264589309692,
0.4045511782169342,
0.3962680399417877,
-0.6892610788345337,
0.021766452118754387,
0.43118199706077576,
-0.05125412344932556,
-0.2203805297613144,
0.4787413775920868,
0.2963807284832001,
0.25241854786872864,
0.20464357733726501,
-0.3277304172515869,
0.15488538146018982,
-0.45178869366645813,
-0.2879762351512909,
0.2984160780906677,
-0.10326764732599258,
-0.20069994032382965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02648v2 | Recursive Chain-of-Feedback Prevents Performance Degradation from Redundant Prompting | 2024-02-05T00:44:28 | 2024-03-01T10:46:01 | Jinwoo Ahn, Kyuseung Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently struggle with complex reasoning
tasks, failing to construct logically sound steps towards the solution. In
response to this behavior, users often try prompting the LLMs repeatedly in
hopes of reaching a better response. This paper studies such repetitive
behavior and its effect by defining a novel setting, Chain-of-Feedback (CoF).
The setting takes questions that require multi-step reasoning as an input. Upon
response, we repetitively prompt meaningless feedback (e.g. 'make another
attempt') requesting additional trials. Surprisingly, our preliminary results
show that repeated meaningless feedback gradually decreases the quality of the
responses, eventually leading to a larger deviation from the intended outcome.
To alleviate these troubles, we propose a novel method, Recursive
Chain-of-Feedback (R-CoF). Following the logic of recursion in computer
science, R-CoF recursively revises the initially incorrect response by breaking
down each incorrect reasoning step into smaller individual problems. Our
preliminary results show that majority of questions that LLMs fail to respond
correctly can be answered using R-CoF without any sample data outlining the
logical process. | [
-0.6161413788795471,
-1.1159785985946655,
0.46278730034828186,
0.24853244423866272,
-0.12120817601680756,
0.4274108409881592,
-0.05649751052260399,
-0.25057029724121094,
0.169901505112648,
0.5608254075050354,
-1.088681936264038,
-0.12950779497623444,
-0.3313106298446655,
0.36751464009284973,
-0.5786870718002319,
1.0786991119384766,
-0.040297478437423706,
-0.08770930767059326,
-0.3913497030735016,
-0.2504960596561432,
-0.7994263768196106,
-0.5694944858551025,
-0.896099865436554,
-0.6234157085418701,
0.8292704820632935,
0.5771874189376831,
0.4249521791934967,
0.17750799655914307,
0.3848610520362854,
0.25560706853866577,
0.1836196780204773,
0.3883054256439209,
-0.6560170650482178,
0.40080538392066956,
-0.14456810057163239,
-0.5261318683624268,
-0.1937474012374878,
-0.1334042102098465,
0.651215672492981,
0.866901695728302,
-0.5319936275482178,
0.22464622557163239,
0.2696177661418915,
1.1333870887756348,
-0.6472563743591309,
-0.059961386024951935,
-0.2718011736869812,
0.04992975294589996,
0.26289641857147217,
-0.5948570966720581,
-0.6710260510444641,
-0.4482291638851166,
-0.023878416046500206,
-0.5563288927078247,
0.09268105030059814,
0.10254792124032974,
0.4057466685771942,
0.3491160571575165,
0.1764068752527237,
-0.44661468267440796,
-1.082034945487976,
0.6533729434013367,
-0.4246554672718048,
0.2577905058860779,
0.15393273532390594,
0.07914234697818756,
-0.6782630681991577,
-0.4379318356513977,
-0.690804660320282,
-0.4238191545009613,
-0.10715199261903763,
0.1039203330874443,
-0.12846027314662933,
-0.010983678512275219,
0.4234602749347687,
0.2360295057296753,
-0.2928282618522644,
-0.29517796635627747,
-0.32179760932922363,
0.05245178937911987,
0.34057652950286865,
0.3921634554862976,
0.19019730389118195,
0.19953584671020508,
-0.18586179614067078,
-0.16993150115013123,
-0.8226761221885681,
0.18556223809719086,
0.20012538135051727,
0.3161822259426117,
0.28939732909202576,
0.2923019528388977,
-0.1994480937719345,
0.915728747844696,
0.49414339661598206,
-0.28551772236824036,
0.18644003570079803,
-0.2634350061416626,
-0.13192492723464966,
-0.2410171777009964,
0.608443021774292,
0.19562509655952454,
0.37217098474502563,
-0.23409214615821838,
-0.26751676201820374,
0.023893436416983604,
0.29755717515945435,
-0.5026377439498901,
-0.04753943905234337,
0.36442887783050537,
-0.17490507662296295,
-0.25047922134399414,
0.13855192065238953,
-0.5452160835266113,
-0.03310278803110123,
-0.21207775175571442,
0.2574812173843384,
-0.24091804027557373,
-0.08948399871587753,
0.1991415023803711,
-0.10245709121227264,
-0.2801416218280792,
0.3922947645187378,
-0.4565802216529846,
0.708406925201416,
0.5625017881393433,
0.7086710929870605,
-0.17623284459114075,
-0.46789583563804626,
-1.0424275398254395,
0.01740712858736515,
-0.29964569211006165,
0.7442149519920349,
-0.5098024606704712,
-0.44601157307624817,
-0.18241198360919952,
0.02992752380669117,
0.08460504561662674,
-0.8778331279754639,
0.11858820915222168,
-0.6690518260002136,
0.19296802580356598,
-0.4545034170150757,
-0.15385830402374268,
-0.1614796668291092,
0.4615210294723511,
-0.9085278511047363,
0.9517500996589661,
-0.2478969395160675,
-0.7289406061172485,
0.1667962372303009,
-0.3625764846801758,
-0.5634867548942566,
-0.18658098578453064,
-0.053521957248449326,
-0.28593263030052185,
0.016698798164725304,
0.13525964319705963,
0.022367332130670547,
-0.15354903042316437,
0.20147396624088287,
-0.5485863089561462,
-0.42932215332984924,
0.3260554075241089,
-0.3679915964603424,
0.32048583030700684,
0.15134114027023315,
-0.35265490412712097,
-0.08811653405427933,
-0.8438843488693237,
0.15812470018863678,
0.040601857006549835,
-0.47835537791252136,
-0.17670495808124542,
0.3037165403366089,
-0.44942706823349,
0.42939865589141846,
-0.17018944025039673,
-0.43676790595054626,
0.1704004853963852,
-0.311552494764328,
0.4071562886238098,
0.7295288443565369,
0.22915881872177124,
0.08692094683647156,
-0.8690305948257446,
0.7407450079917908,
-0.027126453816890717,
-0.0291206706315279,
-0.26011842489242554,
-0.25233015418052673,
-0.7643057703971863,
0.26725757122039795,
-0.031900595873594284,
0.5153206586837769,
-0.8111625909805298,
0.20708037912845612,
-0.1416313648223877,
-0.008316104300320148,
-0.2294786125421524,
0.24026677012443542,
0.4964219033718109,
0.4059293568134308,
0.25887003540992737,
-0.43487709760665894,
-0.6050344705581665,
-0.5170589089393616,
-0.17967934906482697,
-0.3023556172847748,
0.06344617903232574,
0.19981805980205536,
0.5036361217498779,
0.038033612072467804,
0.7058359384536743,
-0.3025510609149933,
0.03921157121658325,
-0.22716324031352997,
0.2468375861644745,
0.19375810027122498,
0.23281541466712952,
-0.2724345922470093,
-0.28186526894569397,
0.006062488537281752,
-0.21816277503967285,
-0.44701316952705383,
-0.13457009196281433,
-0.38186535239219666,
0.08121384680271149,
0.42561623454093933,
0.39256104826927185,
-0.3899517357349396,
0.23992820084095,
0.5353276133537292,
0.1135832890868187,
0.599698007106781,
-0.23171494901180267,
0.2677423357963562,
-0.4173119068145752,
0.334923654794693,
-0.3152785301208496,
-0.35664376616477966,
-0.0592983216047287,
0.05570470914244652,
-0.41742703318595886,
0.037596963346004486,
-0.051012519747018814,
0.32785195112228394,
-0.32032230496406555,
0.03877480328083038,
-0.3629090189933777,
0.3397626578807831,
0.08247368782758713,
0.6176754832267761,
-0.037868279963731766,
0.6148632168769836,
-0.049114592373371124,
-0.9641313552856445,
0.41216984391212463,
0.09745482355356216,
-0.12197629362344742,
0.5234397649765015,
-0.7602766156196594,
0.3986251950263977,
-0.10872452706098557,
0.6269694566726685,
-1.2477892637252808,
-0.1051265075802803,
0.47192972898483276,
-0.3826550245285034,
0.008852245286107063,
0.17157253623008728,
-0.6066594123840332,
-0.797555148601532,
-0.3879968822002411,
0.3701905608177185,
0.15714505314826965,
-0.6587068438529968,
0.15354077517986298,
0.05815752595663071,
-0.13183452188968658,
-0.6648136973381042,
-0.7870458960533142,
-0.20154504477977753,
0.3788973093032837,
-0.6119785904884338,
0.034133557230234146,
-0.31962060928344727,
-0.15765616297721863,
-0.01623833179473877,
-0.35150671005249023,
0.0701783150434494,
-0.036795735359191895,
0.18762154877185822,
0.13344338536262512,
0.1785339117050171,
0.36719056963920593,
-0.20203299820423126,
-0.06671614944934845,
0.3271404802799225,
-0.3272087574005127,
0.6222302913665771,
-0.08486759662628174,
-0.49880877137184143,
-0.6090027093887329,
0.5221607685089111,
0.7861195802688599,
0.05758167803287506,
0.4302757978439331,
-0.13879510760307312,
-0.06390166282653809,
-0.5195450186729431,
-0.5597397685050964,
-0.43040207028388977,
-0.4232005178928375,
0.16156266629695892,
-0.3512144684791565,
-1.0576176643371582,
0.319794625043869,
-0.22212335467338562,
0.11523369699716568,
-0.011944804340600967,
0.5075311064720154,
-0.23294129967689514,
0.9506326913833618,
0.2263588160276413,
0.0729350596666336,
0.3163723647594452,
-0.21534602344036102,
0.30326247215270996,
-0.585102915763855,
-0.45396167039871216,
-0.3487863838672638,
-0.31318992376327515,
-0.36784613132476807,
-0.2193530797958374,
0.34758907556533813,
0.14267979562282562,
-0.3963897228240967,
-0.01960957609117031,
-0.6952456831932068,
0.43099403381347656,
0.2882928252220154,
0.25187695026397705,
0.5927832722663879,
0.1979212611913681,
-0.30102360248565674,
0.3090667724609375,
-0.9615378379821777,
-0.21415121853351593,
0.5635151267051697,
0.2707774043083191,
1.0620746612548828,
-0.07725772261619568,
0.8005746603012085,
0.2302749752998352,
0.340188592672348,
-0.7755035758018494,
0.5311087369918823,
0.08738809823989868,
-0.379915714263916,
-0.27115902304649353,
-0.5590884685516357,
-0.9257423877716064,
0.0526641421020031,
0.1900632381439209,
-0.5353713631629944,
0.10266122221946716,
0.5935494303703308,
-0.7316005229949951,
0.29609501361846924,
-0.4848569631576538,
0.1830846220254898,
-0.10377343744039536,
-0.5065058469772339,
-0.34328338503837585,
-0.420221745967865,
0.466132789850235,
0.18080618977546692,
0.47213277220726013,
0.3780573010444641,
0.2613389790058136,
0.6205617189407349,
-0.7850369215011597,
1.0385652780532837,
-0.15485693514347076,
-0.09911007434129715,
0.5457170009613037,
0.4147234559059143,
0.971358597278595,
0.034037183970212936,
0.26175814867019653,
-0.2933933734893799,
0.003538473742082715,
-0.07225124537944794,
-0.9514680504798889,
0.8220627903938293,
-0.5012264847755432,
-0.8890796303749084,
-0.47714272141456604,
-0.4092593491077423,
-0.32891032099723816,
-0.04240491986274719,
0.18866899609565735,
0.4631046950817108,
0.09821710735559464,
-0.006199688650667667,
0.5417261123657227,
-0.14704547822475433,
0.3036702871322632,
0.2556983232498169,
-0.5617137551307678,
-0.6273251175880432,
0.665153443813324,
0.1662871390581131,
0.7083242535591125,
0.22122745215892792,
0.033497508615255356,
-0.24698509275913239,
-0.20854362845420837,
-0.1303846836090088,
0.2523815631866455,
-0.5799320936203003,
-0.16880930960178375,
-0.4745062291622162,
-0.0061351521871984005,
-0.008860217407345772,
0.1290081888437271,
-0.32236430048942566,
-0.45853859186172485,
0.058086100965738297,
-0.02843298390507698,
0.26604747772216797,
1.0453790426254272,
-0.11598736047744751,
-0.13208818435668945,
-0.7429702281951904,
0.34511569142341614,
0.43579864501953125,
0.5864765644073486,
0.5918890833854675,
-0.3765435814857483,
0.006207492668181658,
0.08300133794546127,
-0.5095219016075134,
-0.5941503047943115,
0.11159086227416992,
-0.09056330472230911,
0.4642389714717865,
-0.052590202540159225,
0.042326826602220535,
0.969683051109314,
-0.5562689900398254,
0.5635968446731567,
0.4411015510559082,
-0.8555338978767395,
0.5445542335510254,
-0.2432590276002884,
0.6437860131263733,
0.49358102679252625,
0.27198317646980286,
-0.7454596161842346,
-0.4434206485748291,
-0.31602537631988525,
-0.9398916959762573,
0.7277222275733948,
0.0022832260001450777,
-0.11043644696474075,
-0.3526110053062439,
0.5343640446662903,
0.07123970240354538,
0.2476860135793686,
-0.7300773859024048,
-0.4397200047969818,
-0.054434046149253845,
0.5149788856506348,
0.48449093103408813,
-0.27146589756011963,
-0.2128220498561859,
-0.30856120586395264,
0.5815418362617493,
0.052749428898096085,
0.30470263957977295,
0.5864149332046509,
0.05933813005685806,
-0.594318151473999,
0.36974361538887024,
0.7079423069953918,
0.7875412702560425,
-0.1850605458021164,
0.10941086709499359,
0.22347597777843475,
-0.21921010315418243,
0.4001424312591553,
-0.5466486811637878,
-0.07462700456380844,
-0.1129605695605278,
0.37276628613471985,
0.4206722378730774,
0.21393975615501404,
-0.5831260085105896,
0.037220943719148636,
0.009943580254912376,
-0.28244078159332275,
-0.4041918218135834,
0.25533682107925415,
0.035270415246486664,
-0.09394455701112747,
0.36651068925857544,
0.3078015148639679,
0.03837862238287926,
-0.741718053817749,
0.6303501129150391,
0.18044798076152802,
-0.3294431269168854,
-0.0648248940706253,
0.27930742502212524,
0.3096081018447876,
-0.6209983229637146,
0.7387217879295349,
-0.16607871651649475,
-0.3869918882846832,
0.492902010679245,
0.71113520860672,
0.629515528678894,
-0.056303057819604874,
0.36631888151168823,
0.7581140995025635,
0.10381926596164703,
-0.4349079430103302,
0.3128919303417206,
-0.0888262391090393,
-0.5299807190895081,
-0.7891003489494324,
-0.36836162209510803,
-0.4072093665599823,
0.3028338551521301,
-0.9160120487213135,
-0.05357782915234566,
-1.0120482444763184,
-0.17921963334083557,
-0.296676903963089,
-0.2264675498008728,
-0.3054354786872864,
0.15291957557201385,
-0.0873531922698021,
0.6949029564857483,
-0.18786782026290894,
0.6318254470825195,
0.29147303104400635,
-0.476082980632782,
-0.8049509525299072,
0.17695128917694092,
0.004687096457928419,
-0.646386444568634,
0.8326594829559326,
0.11878184229135513,
-0.8884779810905457,
-0.19433662295341492,
-0.6980481147766113,
-0.8466442823410034,
0.793152928352356,
0.16428576409816742,
-1.1581671237945557,
0.20705853402614594,
0.07120505720376968,
0.514471173286438,
-0.32191139459609985,
0.07136545330286026,
0.617056667804718,
0.49722182750701904,
0.38491082191467285,
-0.7988442778587341,
0.311077356338501,
-0.28156477212905884,
-0.029918933287262917,
0.2932600677013397,
-0.6791914701461792,
0.7762728929519653,
-0.6738002300262451,
-0.5072594285011292,
0.3337508738040924,
0.21046046912670135,
0.7236774563789368,
0.19727833569049835,
0.7495653629302979,
0.6385296583175659,
0.8856547474861145,
-0.022492730990052223,
1.325773000717163,
-0.2167002409696579,
0.37765923142433167,
1.5498073101043701,
-0.206643208861351,
0.9235156178474426,
0.6983230113983154,
-0.290486216545105,
0.9592905640602112,
0.2703966200351715,
-0.004902360960841179,
0.5271779894828796,
0.8272966146469116,
-0.284536212682724,
-0.39121702313423157,
0.05597693473100662,
-0.32642418146133423,
-0.08754991739988327,
0.15785439312458038,
0.002819567685946822,
-0.2226344794034958,
-0.05087331309914589,
-0.08606415241956711,
0.16141937673091888,
-0.1843787133693695,
0.49557963013648987,
0.18139153718948364,
-1.2768454551696777,
0.9407928586006165,
-0.33624815940856934,
0.5459423065185547,
-0.3180066645145416,
-0.3779130280017853,
-0.20354516804218292,
0.3136231601238251,
-0.3708968758583069,
-0.7121365070343018,
0.5222182273864746,
-0.1696619689464569,
-0.6712626218795776,
-0.08536053448915482,
0.2878211736679077,
-0.30128714442253113,
-0.2641138732433319,
0.6551926136016846,
0.298450767993927,
-0.1837228387594223,
0.15774498879909515,
-0.7591407895088196,
0.23468424379825592,
-0.05858459696173668,
-0.16436021029949188,
0.06978936493396759,
0.36199045181274414,
0.03018411248922348,
1.04296875,
0.7541522979736328,
-0.0990108773112297,
-0.2151401787996292,
0.2485070526599884,
0.8757525086402893,
-0.7784230709075928,
-0.2386484295129776,
-0.8308138251304626,
0.26549261808395386,
0.1051526665687561,
-0.043527498841285706,
0.45325133204460144,
0.10418074578046799,
1.0652453899383545,
0.004275570157915354,
1.005855917930603,
0.0893147811293602,
0.642223060131073,
-0.4215189516544342,
0.2960696220397949,
-0.5533612966537476,
0.6715947389602661,
-0.23293501138687134,
-0.431914359331131,
-0.4407484233379364,
0.5253339409828186,
-0.2805682420730591,
0.27061882615089417,
1.1272990703582764,
0.833949089050293,
0.44968381524086,
-0.015311979688704014,
0.23074615001678467,
0.3947053849697113,
0.27123671770095825,
0.7089310884475708,
1.1392284631729126,
-0.17590701580047607,
0.8060849905014038,
-0.15451757609844208,
-0.06218435987830162,
-0.004124870058149099,
-0.5723939538002014,
-0.7856355905532837,
-0.319970041513443,
-0.2127210795879364,
-0.6850214004516602,
0.29288506507873535,
0.9575711488723755,
0.5297656059265137,
-1.0325320959091187,
-0.47070446610450745,
-0.5436198711395264,
0.40977418422698975,
-0.5040850043296814,
-0.21661636233329773,
0.030381426215171814,
-0.755619466304779,
-0.26742279529571533,
0.1472000777721405,
0.48708781599998474,
-0.4306566119194031,
-0.42939993739128113,
-0.23644305765628815,
-0.3346879482269287,
-0.0002857120707631111,
0.5738790035247803,
0.5085777640342712,
-0.92325758934021,
-0.4963778257369995,
0.039854563772678375,
0.08882450312376022,
0.1885235458612442,
1.070682406425476,
-1.0050336122512817,
0.5393709540367126,
0.605128824710846,
0.4276004135608673,
0.20667079091072083,
-0.06497898697853088,
0.7686663866043091,
-0.6081632971763611,
-0.2270086109638214,
0.1776367723941803,
0.10754615813493729,
0.09039492905139923,
-0.46444928646087646,
0.2996983230113983,
0.5172082185745239,
-0.5263267159461975,
-0.6194928288459778,
0.34941497445106506,
-0.8663034439086914,
-0.36583417654037476,
1.0717500448226929,
-0.11707979440689087,
-0.31495174765586853,
-0.2900899052619934,
-0.16678982973098755,
-0.08947374671697617,
-0.6291263699531555,
1.0238819122314453,
1.0445388555526733,
-0.5037997364997864,
-0.25087738037109375,
-0.28748929500579834,
0.2964794933795929,
0.5643742084503174,
-0.6374836564064026,
0.2892414629459381,
0.5313088893890381,
0.4946790337562561,
0.3385430574417114,
0.7663906216621399,
-0.26319262385368347,
0.6216979622840881,
-0.1447398066520691,
-0.16973906755447388,
-0.19696639478206635,
-0.6309353113174438,
-0.3333825170993805,
0.480625718832016,
0.2011733204126358,
-0.12010230123996735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05125v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05125v3 | Zero-Shot Clinical Trial Patient Matching with LLMs | 2024-02-05T00:06:08 | 2024-04-10T05:37:26 | Michael Wornow, Alejandro Lozano, Dev Dash, Jenelle Jindal, Kenneth W. Mahaffey, Nigam H. Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Matching patients to clinical trials is a key unsolved challenge in bringing
new drugs to market. Today, identifying patients who meet a trial's eligibility
criteria is highly manual, taking up to 1 hour per patient. Automated screening
is challenging, however, as it requires understanding unstructured clinical
text. Large language models (LLMs) offer a promising solution. In this work, we
explore their application to trial matching. First, we design an LLM-based
system which, given a patient's medical history as unstructured clinical text,
evaluates whether that patient meets a set of inclusion criteria (also
specified as free text). Our zero-shot system achieves state-of-the-art scores
on the n2c2 2018 cohort selection benchmark. Second, we improve the data and
cost efficiency of our method by identifying a prompting strategy which matches
patients an order of magnitude faster and more cheaply than the status quo, and
develop a two-stage retrieval pipeline that reduces the number of tokens
processed by up to a third while retaining high performance. Third, we evaluate
the interpretability of our system by having clinicians evaluate the natural
language justifications generated by the LLM for each eligibility decision, and
show that it can output coherent explanations for 97% of its correct decisions
and 75% of its incorrect ones. Our results establish the feasibility of using
LLMs to accelerate clinical trial operations. | [
0.30929264426231384,
-0.4694201648235321,
1.2653321027755737,
0.1951054036617279,
-0.4236137568950653,
-0.0567345954477787,
-0.06811497360467911,
-0.5616492033004761,
0.1499406099319458,
0.8148547410964966,
-0.3221016824245453,
-0.5325408577919006,
-0.5548829436302185,
0.2097131907939911,
-0.47545126080513,
0.9396577477455139,
-0.4019728899002075,
0.2301819622516632,
-0.1992272436618805,
-0.2403847873210907,
-0.6185029149055481,
-0.3073717951774597,
-0.6538124084472656,
-0.6600416302680969,
0.6001471281051636,
0.6202659606933594,
0.4502827823162079,
0.7862086892127991,
0.5437254309654236,
0.1542820930480957,
-0.028462320566177368,
-0.2410508245229721,
-0.6263242959976196,
0.4652791917324066,
0.01820819079875946,
-0.5390419363975525,
-0.3090203106403351,
-0.029386961832642555,
0.1894282102584839,
0.8137375712394714,
-0.3102661669254303,
0.0020963905844837427,
-0.15020275115966797,
0.3309338092803955,
-0.6195581555366516,
-0.12771031260490417,
-0.7116044759750366,
0.3378673791885376,
-0.17743197083473206,
-0.49132582545280457,
-0.49099159240722656,
-0.3400956094264984,
0.1366962194442749,
-0.6481673717498779,
0.42976221442222595,
0.03708261996507645,
0.8829827308654785,
0.03648337721824646,
-0.47884055972099304,
-0.5223543047904968,
-0.5178203582763672,
0.5561737418174744,
-0.7713664174079895,
-0.019148273393511772,
0.42250362038612366,
0.405121773481369,
-0.47621604800224304,
-0.4319196939468384,
-0.4489196240901947,
-0.48488643765449524,
-0.1960439682006836,
0.25559860467910767,
-0.010970626957714558,
0.32786276936531067,
0.24529707431793213,
0.42923927307128906,
-0.8875306248664856,
0.542184591293335,
-0.23204660415649414,
-0.41813814640045166,
0.4720980226993561,
0.3742419481277466,
0.3803887963294983,
-0.008193761110305786,
-0.5356290936470032,
0.23517398536205292,
-0.7186620831489563,
-0.3092498481273651,
-0.19727787375450134,
0.5349478721618652,
-0.09947111457586288,
1.0108259916305542,
-0.46083760261535645,
0.6780386567115784,
-0.020827578380703926,
0.09321273863315582,
-0.03772972896695137,
-0.30428338050842285,
-0.34925955533981323,
0.4402431547641754,
0.7878060340881348,
0.6455836296081543,
0.43920648097991943,
-0.16827210783958435,
-0.022860946133732796,
0.15928004682064056,
0.09900680184364319,
-0.9912536144256592,
0.19706028699874878,
0.6383563876152039,
-0.4920676350593567,
-0.35960352420806885,
-0.31336912512779236,
-0.6499237418174744,
-0.5970918536186218,
-0.13507986068725586,
0.7112345099449158,
-0.3575473129749298,
0.13325421512126923,
0.5280255675315857,
-0.33701345324516296,
0.5708535313606262,
0.4943322241306305,
-0.7116634845733643,
0.15656034648418427,
0.6611670255661011,
1.0984609127044678,
-0.1162361279129982,
0.17309637367725372,
-0.9480196833610535,
0.15711870789527893,
-0.559310257434845,
0.8467965126037598,
-0.20565946400165558,
-0.39815250039100647,
0.23010824620723724,
-0.0322246178984642,
-0.1931537389755249,
-0.4326699376106262,
0.651509165763855,
-0.5263262391090393,
0.45318326354026794,
-0.12895281612873077,
-0.9694086909294128,
0.24563638865947723,
0.26913684606552124,
-0.32625964283943176,
0.43050727248191833,
0.18061207234859467,
-0.2859267294406891,
0.5665334463119507,
-0.49982643127441406,
-0.34129732847213745,
0.6920008063316345,
-0.32994529604911804,
-0.48872917890548706,
0.28853753209114075,
0.1047678291797638,
0.42008545994758606,
-0.31245702505111694,
0.10354063659906387,
-0.5452877283096313,
-0.6482390761375427,
0.19124485552310944,
0.023402376100420952,
0.5329359769821167,
0.3861950933933258,
-0.3216499090194702,
-0.011166070587933064,
-0.460827499628067,
0.0051828292198479176,
0.23207560181617737,
-0.2768717408180237,
-0.14635002613067627,
-0.22036118805408478,
0.22315950691699982,
0.1466110348701477,
0.02881006896495819,
-0.8514103889465332,
0.25174978375434875,
-0.4021550416946411,
0.39785081148147583,
0.5610601902008057,
-0.0006443990278057754,
0.16436654329299927,
-0.19421343505382538,
0.5207984447479248,
-0.17576970160007477,
0.25290602445602417,
-0.2833966016769409,
-0.4375044107437134,
-0.5453096628189087,
-0.36636632680892944,
0.45772209763526917,
0.6342875957489014,
-0.5975130796432495,
0.3555062413215637,
-0.16340117156505585,
-0.1359027922153473,
-0.4778750538825989,
-0.08079184591770172,
0.37807509303092957,
0.5785509943962097,
0.2201932817697525,
-0.4525604248046875,
-0.41880178451538086,
-0.907016932964325,
-0.17355887591838837,
-0.07988923043012619,
-0.43769222497940063,
0.4599558711051941,
0.5015084147453308,
-0.1927989274263382,
0.8888682723045349,
-0.7174506187438965,
-0.7958332300186157,
-0.3988693356513977,
-0.0859793946146965,
0.46178245544433594,
0.10041660815477371,
0.37436556816101074,
-0.3862772583961487,
-0.6341142654418945,
0.1699911206960678,
-0.9907985329627991,
-0.41742679476737976,
-0.3030044734477997,
-0.07018779218196869,
0.015500652603805065,
0.5778955817222595,
-0.49993225932121277,
0.6017951965332031,
0.43749067187309265,
-0.46690961718559265,
0.04864407703280449,
-0.6865900158882141,
0.216582253575325,
-0.8647795915603638,
0.29085102677345276,
0.14134155213832855,
-0.43938153982162476,
-0.6715300679206848,
-0.048649486154317856,
0.10000108182430267,
-0.32268378138542175,
-0.441147118806839,
0.7567154765129089,
-0.4381559193134308,
0.1504623293876648,
-0.4934392273426056,
0.3995601534843445,
-0.03974631801247597,
0.06925803422927856,
-0.07626736909151077,
0.4742037355899811,
0.3278827667236328,
-0.3193487524986267,
0.084595687687397,
0.39074093103408813,
-0.4149405062198639,
0.8241887092590332,
-0.8631063103675842,
-0.00965789519250393,
-0.2554055452346802,
0.480791836977005,
-1.0240986347198486,
-0.48023250699043274,
0.15994518995285034,
-0.37804317474365234,
0.021160626783967018,
-0.24972334504127502,
-0.2264670878648758,
-0.3611399531364441,
-0.24549289047718048,
0.3704204857349396,
0.4030527174472809,
-0.11687827855348587,
0.3429652452468872,
0.044805269688367844,
-0.22144410014152527,
-0.3661530613899231,
-0.7155532836914062,
0.4599721133708954,
0.07798383384943008,
-0.1417204886674881,
0.24651497602462769,
-0.011093233712017536,
0.13962240517139435,
-0.08439502120018005,
0.1398262232542038,
-0.0842137336730957,
-0.1018267348408699,
0.27545759081840515,
0.34286195039749146,
-0.1250474452972412,
0.006678982172161341,
-0.03612210601568222,
-0.2152900993824005,
-0.3474290370941162,
-0.17432844638824463,
0.427433043718338,
0.48354119062423706,
-0.45844119787216187,
-0.7247771620750427,
0.6608785390853882,
0.7333753705024719,
0.16708660125732422,
0.6395454406738281,
0.17073923349380493,
-0.4194704592227936,
-0.04225574806332588,
-0.7174878120422363,
-0.058149900287389755,
-0.4046834707260132,
0.15102604031562805,
-0.05617891252040863,
-0.9459369778633118,
0.29012882709503174,
0.16017818450927734,
-0.06635642796754837,
0.38476327061653137,
0.8989335894584656,
-0.026636216789484024,
0.9989513158798218,
0.5443328022956848,
0.03498169407248497,
0.3348427712917328,
0.2932891547679901,
0.2440558522939682,
-0.6787213087081909,
-0.3773405849933624,
-0.5729321241378784,
-0.28296998143196106,
-0.2846091687679291,
-0.41851750016212463,
0.47182250022888184,
-0.1353384554386139,
-0.1665179282426834,
0.2928042709827423,
-0.5060334205627441,
0.5725987553596497,
0.2931773066520691,
0.1273084580898285,
0.43096914887428284,
-0.05300242453813553,
-0.26954561471939087,
-0.06392879039049149,
-0.5288180112838745,
-0.4464173913002014,
1.4106824398040771,
0.21274688839912415,
0.4280211627483368,
-0.003025240497663617,
0.5594716668128967,
0.4111005663871765,
0.5295606851577759,
-0.8362947106361389,
0.4960409104824066,
-0.26773643493652344,
-0.7139692902565002,
0.0003080496098846197,
-0.458649605512619,
-1.250194787979126,
0.14481079578399658,
-0.3983340561389923,
-0.6602620482444763,
0.14102135598659515,
-0.08795461058616638,
-0.9312346577644348,
0.007578280288726091,
-0.6529672145843506,
0.7128750681877136,
-0.4006531238555908,
-0.06320638209581375,
0.02948378212749958,
-0.6102045774459839,
0.2906375229358673,
-0.29660916328430176,
0.011866915039718151,
-0.3478403687477112,
0.0033076321706175804,
0.4392995238304138,
-0.37129902839660645,
0.4809429943561554,
-0.17407211661338806,
0.06511016190052032,
-0.10659968852996826,
0.060399189591407776,
0.23015715181827545,
-0.0458492748439312,
-0.19469085335731506,
0.19456256926059723,
0.2841002643108368,
-0.5584067702293396,
-0.4853067994117737,
0.790296196937561,
-0.35612568259239197,
-0.20122532546520233,
-0.6802055239677429,
-0.554731547832489,
-0.001368517056107521,
0.348068505525589,
0.09657708555459976,
0.20496432483196259,
-0.3232327103614807,
0.2737775146961212,
0.38851407170295715,
-0.48943591117858887,
0.056388624012470245,
1.202309250831604,
-0.2756613790988922,
-0.3645935654640198,
0.4431881606578827,
-0.04112379997968674,
0.3358747363090515,
0.5527679920196533,
0.2159571796655655,
-0.47861936688423157,
-0.9379470944404602,
-0.4726404845714569,
0.3429544270038605,
-0.27729716897010803,
-0.18088944256305695,
-0.6969109177589417,
-0.024070467799901962,
-0.43245717883110046,
-0.17726737260818481,
0.047677986323833466,
-0.005485697649419308,
-0.15204863250255585,
0.23815041780471802,
0.14970770478248596,
0.6171019673347473,
0.2092030793428421,
0.44581538438796997,
-0.7080165147781372,
0.619515061378479,
0.053234346210956573,
0.6535760164260864,
-0.3645886778831482,
-0.6889169216156006,
-0.1568680852651596,
-0.10146301239728928,
-0.14370061457157135,
-0.8591857552528381,
0.21457608044147491,
0.15235275030136108,
0.5859885215759277,
0.3973602056503296,
0.06229143962264061,
0.6839143633842468,
-0.6436713337898254,
0.5022836923599243,
0.2598258852958679,
-0.8208310604095459,
0.6633825898170471,
-0.3831077814102173,
0.10673823207616806,
0.8100142478942871,
0.2670300006866455,
-0.9530273079872131,
-0.14489129185676575,
-0.19813288748264313,
-0.8096479773521423,
0.7931135892868042,
0.32793647050857544,
-0.0729280337691307,
0.08921298384666443,
0.806904673576355,
-0.20280176401138306,
0.1418488323688507,
-0.4408538043498993,
0.12248428165912628,
0.3826783001422882,
-0.6087852716445923,
-0.3353011906147003,
-0.24476787447929382,
-0.35929396748542786,
0.11518479883670807,
0.41725489497184753,
-0.4009786546230316,
0.32985788583755493,
0.5338249206542969,
-0.16206693649291992,
-0.3408251106739044,
0.31328681111335754,
0.6725047826766968,
0.3339770436286926,
-0.4916158616542816,
-0.25776952505111694,
0.05476705729961395,
-0.42439278960227966,
0.14377592504024506,
0.2170434296131134,
-0.30739691853523254,
0.017144648358225822,
0.39169418811798096,
0.7189001441001892,
0.17366841435432434,
-1.0284771919250488,
0.7665265202522278,
-0.4829774498939514,
-0.6155697703361511,
-0.038560424000024796,
-0.10727004706859589,
-0.15617124736309052,
0.329254150390625,
0.3196612000465393,
-0.42676615715026855,
0.11868052929639816,
-0.6044877767562866,
0.3556941747665405,
0.7955024242401123,
-0.773598313331604,
0.0829034298658371,
0.7745381593704224,
0.03678179904818535,
-0.42958417534828186,
0.5675293803215027,
0.1646117866039276,
-0.06427950412034988,
0.5070132613182068,
0.5610920190811157,
0.7588400840759277,
0.13597805798053741,
0.34749194979667664,
0.0719853937625885,
0.09404931962490082,
-0.2956119775772095,
0.08148189634084702,
0.27413707971572876,
-0.520465612411499,
-0.5401458740234375,
-0.5965341925621033,
-0.7999676465988159,
0.1801033765077591,
-0.3766043782234192,
0.5513516068458557,
-0.4752095937728882,
0.008358047343790531,
0.22138555347919464,
0.1240641176700592,
-0.43619516491889954,
0.08575303852558136,
0.38084936141967773,
0.9199850559234619,
-0.9323611855506897,
0.6101622581481934,
0.2771322727203369,
-0.2892720699310303,
-0.6649426817893982,
-0.32899588346481323,
0.13313032686710358,
-0.933992326259613,
0.0979095995426178,
0.39175137877464294,
0.2576083838939667,
-0.32943180203437805,
-0.2826979458332062,
-0.5515109300613403,
1.2931859493255615,
0.5769126415252686,
-0.7664475440979004,
-0.03615745157003403,
0.34611669182777405,
0.8675072193145752,
-0.4261949062347412,
0.5079548358917236,
0.5714256763458252,
0.1746080368757248,
0.5880134105682373,
-0.9684157371520996,
0.19451603293418884,
0.036567572504282,
-0.17698079347610474,
0.25865960121154785,
-0.23940718173980713,
0.5656163096427917,
-0.31904423236846924,
-0.3188968002796173,
0.4933648407459259,
0.13778111338615417,
0.24679601192474365,
0.7756996750831604,
0.39798709750175476,
0.6043512225151062,
0.6125082969665527,
-0.15704602003097534,
0.9328818321228027,
-0.3178718090057373,
0.5818831920623779,
0.8741034269332886,
-1.0495907068252563,
0.8124423623085022,
0.38641056418418884,
-0.15808144211769104,
0.45089277625083923,
0.4309772253036499,
-0.03694033622741699,
0.27584025263786316,
0.248877614736557,
-0.36794987320899963,
-0.4268726408481598,
-0.449273943901062,
-0.10758649557828903,
0.3058144748210907,
0.20653894543647766,
-0.42722705006599426,
-0.5333260893821716,
0.048971597105264664,
-0.0033248981926590204,
0.01871856302022934,
0.017578471451997757,
0.866868793964386,
0.1804099678993225,
-0.6958383917808533,
0.41689351201057434,
-0.03995800018310547,
0.4140375256538391,
-0.8508473634719849,
0.05636981874704361,
-0.28751322627067566,
0.5471643805503845,
-0.24909980595111847,
-0.7077394723892212,
0.022742625325918198,
0.09125557541847229,
0.036438364535570145,
-0.13407641649246216,
0.5217584371566772,
-0.4805981516838074,
-0.6297279000282288,
0.4791709780693054,
0.3490145802497864,
0.19799110293388367,
-0.20028933882713318,
-0.7166876196861267,
0.00405924255028367,
-0.11613421887159348,
0.04745258763432503,
0.48423486948013306,
0.32100850343704224,
-0.09650366008281708,
0.5642737746238708,
0.828096866607666,
0.4338167905807495,
-0.49980369210243225,
0.17899835109710693,
0.519126296043396,
-0.78426593542099,
-0.13597291707992554,
-0.9275974631309509,
0.12650036811828613,
-0.13322332501411438,
-0.2537093758583069,
0.42824587225914,
0.632706344127655,
0.12464740872383118,
0.28079190850257874,
0.5910204648971558,
0.32665345072746277,
0.5669954419136047,
-0.36943483352661133,
0.7293201088905334,
-0.6562244296073914,
0.11467749625444412,
0.031838130205869675,
-0.5620030760765076,
-0.8190955519676208,
0.17273163795471191,
-0.21405945718288422,
-0.2156781256198883,
0.5383044481277466,
0.8594419956207275,
0.14657796919345856,
-0.1595504879951477,
0.4789407253265381,
0.13601355254650116,
0.6855908036231995,
0.9503529071807861,
0.45070499181747437,
-0.6426203846931458,
0.5290687680244446,
0.3473272919654846,
-0.6366738080978394,
-0.6379185914993286,
-0.9358691573143005,
-0.7618048787117004,
0.07477911561727524,
-0.16013525426387787,
-0.450579971075058,
0.17849618196487427,
1.0633032321929932,
0.535240650177002,
-0.7063885927200317,
-0.2586097717285156,
0.08185694366693497,
-0.12570162117481232,
0.010177436284720898,
-0.14458394050598145,
0.18633422255516052,
-0.1102033257484436,
-0.5213226079940796,
0.38358333706855774,
0.7161401510238647,
-0.03892000392079353,
-0.04033905640244484,
-0.0994911938905716,
-0.24488870799541473,
0.3828449249267578,
0.5116006135940552,
0.4285082519054413,
-0.4610428810119629,
-0.10843382030725479,
0.2593117654323578,
-0.3917750418186188,
-0.006367702968418598,
1.0176265239715576,
-0.8163995742797852,
0.6501761078834534,
0.2939688563346863,
0.5180962085723877,
0.6700520515441895,
-0.10863946378231049,
0.6586352586746216,
-0.11666276305913925,
0.013687770813703537,
0.4130394160747528,
0.35356199741363525,
0.22819268703460693,
-0.3362025320529938,
0.2537166178226471,
0.15171058475971222,
-0.822225034236908,
-0.8820076584815979,
0.1308237761259079,
-1.183619499206543,
-0.21374619007110596,
1.1974849700927734,
0.0238064993172884,
-0.05862869694828987,
-0.5685073137283325,
-0.2341078668832779,
0.13755929470062256,
-0.32730793952941895,
0.8789699673652649,
0.5338683128356934,
-0.18300612270832062,
0.1863560527563095,
-0.7403700947761536,
0.2982397973537445,
0.6185596585273743,
-0.5829150080680847,
-0.07612473517656326,
0.45536860823631287,
0.4170435070991516,
-0.1360677182674408,
1.2468458414077759,
-0.20496271550655365,
0.20634736120700836,
-0.563424825668335,
0.03679174929857254,
0.17836232483386993,
0.10636357963085175,
-0.7216177582740784,
0.05175020918250084,
-0.11569590121507645,
-0.1388021856546402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02643v1 | LLM-Enhanced Data Management | 2024-02-04T23:42:02 | 2024-02-04T23:42:02 | Xuanhe Zhou, Xinyang Zhao, Guoliang Li | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Machine learning (ML) techniques for optimizing data management problems have
been extensively studied and widely deployed in recent five years. However
traditional ML methods have limitations on generalizability (adapting to
different scenarios) and inference ability (understanding the context).
Fortunately, large language models (LLMs) have shown high generalizability and
human-competitive abilities in understanding context, which are promising for
data management tasks (e.g., database diagnosis, database tuning). However,
existing LLMs have several limitations: hallucination, high cost, and low
accuracy for complicated tasks. To address these challenges, we design LLMDB,
an LLM-enhanced data management paradigm which has generalizability and high
inference ability while avoiding hallucination, reducing LLM cost, and
achieving high accuracy. LLMDB embeds domain-specific knowledge to avoid
hallucination by LLM fine-tuning and prompt engineering. LLMDB reduces the high
cost of LLMs by vector databases which provide semantic search and caching
abilities. LLMDB improves the task accuracy by LLM agent which provides
multiple-round inference and pipeline executions. We showcase three real-world
scenarios that LLMDB can well support, including query rewrite, database
diagnosis and data analytics. We also summarize the open research challenges of
LLMDB. | [
-0.42370954155921936,
-1.146884560585022,
0.6291444301605225,
0.10016632080078125,
-0.1376311480998993,
0.14319054782390594,
-0.18452754616737366,
-0.4397297203540802,
0.21696077287197113,
0.8055336475372314,
-0.6405754685401917,
-0.7054155468940735,
-0.378329336643219,
0.15354207158088684,
-0.34632715582847595,
0.5391326546669006,
-0.12621431052684784,
-0.031141895800828934,
-0.5624313950538635,
-0.027735047042369843,
-0.7380165457725525,
-0.8118085265159607,
-0.5109067559242249,
-0.35284993052482605,
0.4930777847766876,
0.4247016906738281,
0.8535031676292419,
0.9624060988426208,
0.6297372579574585,
0.27529752254486084,
0.10397687554359436,
0.7678616046905518,
-0.6504868268966675,
0.4158167541027069,
-0.05369161069393158,
-0.4889116883277893,
-0.7866824269294739,
-0.2696703374385834,
0.4098435342311859,
0.9493060111999512,
-0.19461724162101746,
-0.13856399059295654,
0.011606048792600632,
0.9295810461044312,
-0.5166306495666504,
0.29331591725349426,
-0.7348923683166504,
0.17364178597927094,
-0.009545466862618923,
-0.31040024757385254,
-0.2203182727098465,
-0.16468781232833862,
-0.033357154577970505,
-0.5893697142601013,
0.07526286691427231,
0.08060763776302338,
0.6022990345954895,
0.7619625329971313,
-0.333185613155365,
-0.3470621407032013,
-0.6905791759490967,
0.7532908916473389,
-0.24145551025867462,
0.40456026792526245,
0.3834613859653473,
0.4018358886241913,
-0.4631376266479492,
-0.49559104442596436,
-0.3157607614994049,
0.10188151150941849,
0.08790917694568634,
-0.033219434320926666,
-0.17811685800552368,
0.10987655073404312,
0.18399038910865784,
0.24045468866825104,
-0.5577904582023621,
0.49651363492012024,
-0.040237460285425186,
-0.11325763911008835,
0.529741644859314,
0.49947866797447205,
-0.08590003848075867,
0.045812323689460754,
-0.3412472903728485,
0.18091937899589539,
-0.752332329750061,
-0.4257293939590454,
0.07480879127979279,
0.3222668766975403,
0.3958108723163605,
0.6140877604484558,
-0.4375816881656647,
0.7762030363082886,
-0.2643606960773468,
0.0673767477273941,
0.09135778993368149,
-0.16336669027805328,
-0.4675569534301758,
-0.04398137331008911,
0.3183736503124237,
0.3544577658176422,
0.09990598261356354,
-0.6251973509788513,
-0.421601265668869,
0.0797024667263031,
0.3679518699645996,
-0.8857202529907227,
-0.14091773331165314,
0.4841242730617523,
-0.4436081647872925,
-0.36050882935523987,
-0.22304584085941315,
-0.7285935878753662,
-0.6824985146522522,
-0.5787995457649231,
0.49317631125450134,
-0.3884041905403137,
-0.2827226519584656,
0.13924884796142578,
0.15967565774917603,
0.22722981870174408,
0.5325653553009033,
-0.5749956369400024,
0.31189408898353577,
0.8240483403205872,
0.7506974339485168,
-0.6965381503105164,
0.036941323429346085,
-0.5840494632720947,
0.38324061036109924,
-0.3596581518650055,
0.6834874749183655,
-0.6163998246192932,
-0.4111223518848419,
-0.09866302460432053,
0.0366002656519413,
0.04985272139310837,
-0.9964801669120789,
0.3782702088356018,
-0.5229263305664062,
-0.10059144347906113,
-0.045041799545288086,
-0.7648499011993408,
-0.3415490984916687,
0.2170877903699875,
-0.6591030359268188,
0.9229684472084045,
0.21687820553779602,
-0.31983062624931335,
0.3828984498977661,
-0.46337056159973145,
-0.23379607498645782,
0.060588665306568146,
-0.2873654365539551,
-0.5899205207824707,
0.1333625465631485,
0.3127126395702362,
0.8151170611381531,
-0.4366786479949951,
0.5019081830978394,
-0.31198009848594666,
-0.5125951766967773,
0.04534885287284851,
-0.19515903294086456,
0.4585275948047638,
0.3050139844417572,
0.026635238900780678,
0.1586340069770813,
-0.8565821051597595,
-0.1210893839597702,
0.2435646951198578,
-0.46546468138694763,
-0.20999272167682648,
0.04415502771735191,
-0.1759737730026245,
-0.10315218567848206,
0.1174408346414566,
-0.037818826735019684,
0.4666888117790222,
-0.11233555525541306,
0.18905217945575714,
0.8260648250579834,
-0.12099047750234604,
0.3650471270084381,
-0.5572922229766846,
0.526763916015625,
0.175191730260849,
-0.06960595399141312,
0.03487255424261093,
-0.3500688374042511,
-0.7006956338882446,
-0.6258437633514404,
0.21106931567192078,
0.8066384196281433,
-0.7421993613243103,
0.5830351710319519,
-0.2244604229927063,
-0.2406320422887802,
-0.7162607312202454,
0.4164341688156128,
-0.0832296833395958,
0.6253900527954102,
0.6359140276908875,
-0.2357366532087326,
-0.6388493180274963,
-0.7828493118286133,
-0.21155770123004913,
0.3074360191822052,
-0.13755013048648834,
0.6328250169754028,
0.1948927342891693,
-0.8512421250343323,
0.9553332328796387,
-0.5167149901390076,
-0.4595157206058502,
-0.3379686176776886,
-0.30240070819854736,
0.4393908977508545,
0.35073474049568176,
0.05274252966046333,
-0.7396493554115295,
-0.06430864334106445,
-0.05682029202580452,
-1.0403763055801392,
-0.30584684014320374,
-0.28509509563446045,
-0.22991928458213806,
0.344425767660141,
0.3655664920806885,
-0.8416450619697571,
0.22389215230941772,
0.17547939717769623,
-0.16085654497146606,
0.43488749861717224,
-0.2596225440502167,
-0.0333138182759285,
-0.8852697610855103,
-0.21960608661174774,
-0.139961376786232,
-0.28968545794487,
-0.6967915892601013,
-0.16040797531604767,
0.23552697896957397,
-0.12492580711841583,
-0.2947174906730652,
0.44581732153892517,
-0.4514952600002289,
-0.1661074310541153,
-0.36258208751678467,
0.18839900195598602,
-0.18686966598033905,
0.3343339264392853,
0.08321071416139603,
0.6108434796333313,
0.7081411480903625,
-1.1873483657836914,
0.6625334620475769,
0.2547387182712555,
-0.20832858979701996,
0.6134232878684998,
-0.36526554822921753,
0.18083398044109344,
-0.3584762215614319,
0.07573924213647842,
-0.6064295172691345,
-0.27306273579597473,
0.18402458727359772,
-0.27154165506362915,
0.476176917552948,
0.012149970978498459,
-0.6468648314476013,
-0.26874467730522156,
-0.21565058827400208,
-0.12316460907459259,
0.45408961176872253,
-0.8421978950500488,
0.6907476782798767,
0.2307555377483368,
0.041334621608257294,
-0.7063352465629578,
-0.6887755990028381,
0.3362511992454529,
-0.5199220776557922,
-0.6802466511726379,
0.48954859375953674,
0.005886406172066927,
-0.33590027689933777,
-0.022527698427438736,
-0.3476775884628296,
-0.08662932366132736,
0.43477293848991394,
0.10558412224054337,
0.3162524402141571,
-0.07317081838846207,
0.3339582681655884,
0.12506608664989471,
-0.22837308049201965,
0.11727400124073029,
-0.17004042863845825,
0.44271206855773926,
0.3538164496421814,
-0.28541257977485657,
-0.31168225407600403,
0.21425054967403412,
0.26478874683380127,
0.08878139406442642,
0.75382399559021,
0.5675902366638184,
-0.44352665543556213,
-0.45112714171409607,
-0.6173846125602722,
-0.38793009519577026,
-0.4858161211013794,
0.5544753074645996,
-0.6575877666473389,
-0.7182824015617371,
0.34737077355384827,
-0.4750520884990692,
-0.022586338222026825,
0.16952690482139587,
0.6393370032310486,
-0.1794532686471939,
0.8507034778594971,
0.4643233120441437,
-0.20760495960712433,
0.19674928486347198,
-0.24346917867660522,
0.1209413930773735,
-0.705637514591217,
-0.27717968821525574,
-0.3795682191848755,
-0.25673454999923706,
-0.5930410623550415,
-0.5968974232673645,
0.14109955728054047,
0.21961183845996857,
-0.2536982297897339,
0.10168341547250748,
-0.49326401948928833,
0.4213731586933136,
0.3404206335544586,
0.27945375442504883,
0.5621691346168518,
0.14718204736709595,
0.13593223690986633,
0.10817930102348328,
-0.6752780675888062,
-0.576704204082489,
1.3224178552627563,
0.4569871723651886,
1.0243874788284302,
0.1286805272102356,
0.6592370867729187,
0.36804667115211487,
0.05068879574537277,
-0.6682468056678772,
0.5892795324325562,
0.04994705691933632,
-0.33136922121047974,
-0.18707579374313354,
-0.7904497981071472,
-0.9254534840583801,
0.46666908264160156,
-0.2035994678735733,
-0.52094566822052,
-0.05147257447242737,
0.10638603568077087,
0.09326734393835068,
0.314816951751709,
-0.5194604396820068,
0.5696573257446289,
-0.23827971518039703,
-0.4322836399078369,
-0.2765668034553528,
-0.2944628894329071,
0.2230149209499359,
-0.35044360160827637,
0.1946621537208557,
-0.12574632465839386,
-0.37998539209365845,
0.4572829306125641,
-0.25517815351486206,
0.7080003023147583,
-0.31394699215888977,
-0.09796537458896637,
-0.03006802685558796,
0.23288488388061523,
0.9281776547431946,
0.03712649643421173,
-0.2980528175830841,
0.10176775604486465,
-0.3333568572998047,
-0.40919816493988037,
-0.5291290879249573,
0.7342309355735779,
-0.6005616188049316,
-0.7514708638191223,
-0.1417795568704605,
-0.7338127493858337,
-0.3688858449459076,
0.037451330572366714,
-0.21161897480487823,
0.04863426089286804,
-0.029219379648566246,
0.40591761469841003,
0.9797415137290955,
-0.5471170544624329,
0.15755099058151245,
0.5441067814826965,
-0.27426350116729736,
-0.20025479793548584,
1.0338494777679443,
0.09956900775432587,
0.10003447532653809,
0.5062239766120911,
0.07181331515312195,
-0.2710648775100708,
-0.6761507391929626,
-0.32334381341934204,
0.13468249142169952,
-0.6267537474632263,
-0.3788812756538391,
-0.9234645366668701,
0.025934729725122452,
-0.3003062307834625,
-0.10785961896181107,
-0.14115971326828003,
-0.41917112469673157,
-0.5891112685203552,
-0.21971848607063293,
0.6014761328697205,
0.4523504674434662,
-0.0685887485742569,
0.10233205556869507,
-0.3801010847091675,
0.4951842129230499,
0.10299364477396011,
0.306711882352829,
-0.12457932531833649,
-0.28816697001457214,
-0.2220626175403595,
-0.21527805924415588,
-0.2128576934337616,
-0.6662367582321167,
0.4877850115299225,
0.09150933474302292,
0.6501296758651733,
0.18626776337623596,
0.037668291479349136,
0.633741557598114,
-0.22950701415538788,
0.35270121693611145,
-0.19143478572368622,
-0.6115136742591858,
0.5150089263916016,
-0.18431566655635834,
-0.03938950225710869,
0.16288699209690094,
0.44844144582748413,
-0.25558966398239136,
-0.29166826605796814,
-0.08892670273780823,
-0.8934570550918579,
0.48041990399360657,
0.11461860686540604,
0.014689113013446331,
0.19507330656051636,
0.5491785407066345,
0.3883335590362549,
0.3497343957424164,
-0.35575369000434875,
-0.4615570306777954,
0.07437672466039658,
-0.2707129716873169,
-0.039867039769887924,
-0.15361297130584717,
0.06133996322751045,
-0.3408132493495941,
0.6031496524810791,
-0.20460475981235504,
0.3177734613418579,
0.029116356745362282,
-0.44047361612319946,
0.12850911915302277,
0.13470375537872314,
0.23197200894355774,
0.6798120141029358,
-0.34855037927627563,
0.02062561735510826,
0.4139672517776489,
-0.3362259268760681,
-0.057199738919734955,
0.037756308913230896,
-0.08589550852775574,
-0.11593088507652283,
0.059314776211977005,
0.6911444067955017,
-0.09607639163732529,
-0.7748181223869324,
-0.04395096004009247,
0.08581887930631638,
-0.25562724471092224,
-0.16649718582630157,
0.3518736958503723,
0.2717718482017517,
0.4002765119075775,
0.393358051776886,
-0.34153178334236145,
0.09028829634189606,
-0.3403313159942627,
0.19187720119953156,
0.5408427715301514,
-0.12334152311086655,
0.2735068202018738,
0.6641005277633667,
0.015345039777457714,
-0.15605150163173676,
0.6762632727622986,
-0.04739394411444664,
-0.23752231895923615,
0.7014460563659668,
0.4911828935146332,
0.6102047562599182,
-0.17028599977493286,
-0.061221376061439514,
-0.057683080434799194,
0.2777514159679413,
0.12669983506202698,
0.5026768445968628,
-0.06843354552984238,
-0.7402415871620178,
-0.23673681914806366,
-0.5650895833969116,
-0.6825428605079651,
0.16943666338920593,
-0.4106372892856598,
0.3170938193798065,
-0.32299357652664185,
0.03287283703684807,
-0.19677135348320007,
0.37533286213874817,
-0.7822774052619934,
0.1595541089773178,
-0.14638778567314148,
0.8793277144432068,
-0.2962234616279602,
1.0277540683746338,
0.24395187199115753,
-0.19056694209575653,
-0.1415378302335739,
-0.5611298084259033,
0.050293635576963425,
-0.9638736844062805,
0.5953088402748108,
0.3278268575668335,
0.09402830898761749,
0.04669329524040222,
-0.36458995938301086,
-0.5133194327354431,
1.361322283744812,
0.4547595977783203,
-0.6284248232841492,
0.1278291940689087,
0.2867773771286011,
0.33180925250053406,
-0.48632729053497314,
-0.1012033075094223,
0.8254764676094055,
0.6175341010093689,
-0.047890663146972656,
-0.5637332201004028,
0.09998064488172531,
0.2769756019115448,
0.008191448636353016,
0.10329624265432358,
-0.34026628732681274,
0.7227890491485596,
-0.21884767711162567,
-0.11484919488430023,
-0.17609292268753052,
0.6079824566841125,
0.2545386552810669,
0.42109718918800354,
0.21561354398727417,
0.6624165773391724,
1.1567047834396362,
-0.11945191770792007,
0.9975231289863586,
-0.13800537586212158,
0.16745483875274658,
1.0408941507339478,
-0.46454867720603943,
0.4785972535610199,
0.3866480886936188,
-0.13438710570335388,
0.12446364015340805,
0.7915683388710022,
-0.15930776298046112,
0.3698175549507141,
0.39742663502693176,
-0.3712752163410187,
-0.28970086574554443,
-0.16115617752075195,
-0.3221876919269562,
0.3200705945491791,
0.5218831300735474,
-0.2580415606498718,
0.040355291217565536,
0.04887016490101814,
-0.06435703486204147,
-0.028841210529208183,
-0.35595008730888367,
0.8247766494750977,
0.06160733476281166,
-0.026410290971398354,
0.6347312927246094,
-0.04590864107012749,
0.7433694005012512,
-0.29336994886398315,
-0.05697965621948242,
-0.38090792298316956,
0.305934876203537,
-0.4146786034107208,
-0.6861323118209839,
0.38993844389915466,
-0.07255680859088898,
-0.19465892016887665,
-0.20092205703258514,
0.8899309039115906,
-0.3576190173625946,
-0.21396662294864655,
0.44351986050605774,
0.7702139616012573,
0.38764792680740356,
-0.3170570135116577,
-0.5932058691978455,
0.296051949262619,
-0.17363715171813965,
-0.31068336963653564,
0.44069957733154297,
0.6146883964538574,
0.09953561425209045,
1.1116594076156616,
0.5145902633666992,
0.2786514163017273,
-0.029612183570861816,
0.09965068101882935,
0.8349243998527527,
-0.8173651695251465,
-0.19469475746154785,
-0.8392287492752075,
0.055478379130363464,
-0.16160456836223602,
0.36062881350517273,
0.5383927226066589,
0.6654821038246155,
0.6156915426254272,
-0.011133993975818157,
0.7150701880455017,
0.2828079164028168,
0.6366193890571594,
-0.7159929871559143,
0.5226014852523804,
-0.6111835241317749,
0.5378220081329346,
-0.050021108239889145,
-1.170688271522522,
-0.48052024841308594,
0.5110223889350891,
-0.036919571459293365,
0.018850000575184822,
0.49007919430732727,
1.026046872138977,
0.07505969703197479,
-0.10657431930303574,
0.5416125655174255,
0.2229098081588745,
0.3969435691833496,
0.6137781143188477,
0.6185824871063232,
-0.08513357490301132,
0.41209667921066284,
-0.06057746708393097,
-0.13830684125423431,
-0.31526249647140503,
-0.7067172527313232,
-1.015924096107483,
-0.22170919179916382,
-0.24498289823532104,
-0.20601920783519745,
0.1368960589170456,
0.9289693236351013,
0.6385106444358826,
-0.6700108647346497,
-0.18053153157234192,
-0.15521621704101562,
0.5196593403816223,
-0.10805448889732361,
-0.2532128691673279,
0.3308137059211731,
-0.5076138973236084,
-0.6183238625526428,
0.6095748543739319,
0.23773415386676788,
0.05484432354569435,
-0.31350088119506836,
-0.19718512892723083,
0.17946363985538483,
-0.11337874084711075,
0.758319616317749,
-0.03681908920407295,
-0.3994166851043701,
-0.0018346995348110795,
0.006918264087289572,
-0.10036757588386536,
0.024841483682394028,
0.5721369385719299,
-0.9685520529747009,
0.3528350591659546,
0.2713567316532135,
1.2211462259292603,
0.5566387176513672,
-0.02416227012872696,
0.5968625545501709,
-0.47612717747688293,
0.001790150417946279,
0.2387627214193344,
0.2259349226951599,
0.29938653111457825,
-0.6845268607139587,
0.7958602905273438,
0.3203122913837433,
-0.5374507904052734,
-0.9344709515571594,
0.137451171875,
-0.8534573912620544,
-0.5963252782821655,
1.0915988683700562,
0.2893209159374237,
-0.02037818357348442,
-0.29981347918510437,
-0.09577187895774841,
0.19349713623523712,
-0.33686602115631104,
0.8048810362815857,
0.5360023975372314,
-0.4222036898136139,
-0.14768196642398834,
-0.9426283836364746,
0.47595351934432983,
0.30716899037361145,
-1.0545276403427124,
0.28617340326309204,
0.5001117587089539,
0.021157803013920784,
-0.49079379439353943,
0.30256229639053345,
0.0857330784201622,
-0.07617437094449997,
-0.2204241007566452,
-0.026125840842723846,
-0.3270856440067291,
-0.4137476980686188,
-0.3621255159378052,
0.1994459629058838,
-0.12201814353466034,
-0.15656721591949463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02639v2 | "It's how you do things that matters": Attending to Process to Better Serve Indigenous Communities with Language Technologies | 2024-02-04T23:23:51 | 2024-02-06T02:50:48 | Ned Cooper, Courtney Heldreth, Ben Hutchinson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Indigenous languages are historically under-served by Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technologies, but this is changing for some languages with the
recent scaling of large multilingual models and an increased focus by the NLP
community on endangered languages. This position paper explores ethical
considerations in building NLP technologies for Indigenous languages, based on
the premise that such projects should primarily serve Indigenous communities.
We report on interviews with 17 researchers working in or with Aboriginal
and/or Torres Strait Islander communities on language technology projects in
Australia. Drawing on insights from the interviews, we recommend practices for
NLP researchers to increase attention to the process of engagements with
Indigenous communities, rather than focusing only on decontextualised
artefacts. | [
-0.34472015500068665,
-0.5836108326911926,
0.4171033501625061,
0.3197711408138275,
-0.08424808084964752,
0.2976764738559723,
-0.27243295311927795,
-0.8008842468261719,
0.46919286251068115,
0.6431694030761719,
-0.18104085326194763,
-0.07870326936244965,
-0.8098017573356628,
0.34303268790245056,
-0.07628481835126877,
0.6124469637870789,
0.08443864434957504,
-0.17112791538238525,
0.2236488163471222,
-0.39369142055511475,
-0.6272705793380737,
-0.4266398549079895,
-0.8880828022956848,
-0.2400633543729782,
0.43739303946495056,
0.2744804918766022,
1.2726962566375732,
0.8242362141609192,
0.5813024640083313,
0.256550133228302,
-0.5982150435447693,
0.017213456332683563,
-0.08681902289390564,
0.1057676151394844,
-0.6461284756660461,
-0.5095537900924683,
0.12145210057497025,
0.04588541388511658,
0.13150985538959503,
0.6383697986602783,
-0.27743053436279297,
0.7367264628410339,
-0.29785582423210144,
0.3770485520362854,
-0.6867030262947083,
0.13446320593357086,
-0.19194863736629486,
0.4733355939388275,
-0.32281506061553955,
-0.39546865224838257,
-0.37815529108047485,
-0.7648778557777405,
-0.2553849518299103,
-0.43933457136154175,
-0.1765785962343216,
0.1463920623064041,
0.2934280335903168,
0.2013358175754547,
-0.33820053935050964,
-0.06356248259544373,
-0.8496639132499695,
1.0397531986236572,
-1.0855735540390015,
-0.058635272085666656,
0.8191639184951782,
-0.09834038466215134,
-0.09261102229356766,
-0.7784655094146729,
-0.4800271689891815,
0.29897797107696533,
-0.4651232957839966,
-0.2572799324989319,
-0.10814562439918518,
0.19780932366847992,
0.44877633452415466,
0.3383535146713257,
-0.39503204822540283,
0.16085384786128998,
-0.726460874080658,
-0.14128170907497406,
0.5480237603187561,
-0.0952080562710762,
0.5753458738327026,
-0.23022973537445068,
0.1825024038553238,
0.05728738382458687,
-0.662935733795166,
0.12273524701595306,
0.3601697087287903,
0.5084574222564697,
0.3727198541164398,
0.8490942716598511,
-0.00815145019441843,
0.8301291465759277,
-0.14981353282928467,
-0.10863929241895676,
0.03614451736211777,
-0.34840676188468933,
-0.10052083432674408,
0.2448975294828415,
0.25246840715408325,
0.5659236311912537,
0.1787053495645523,
-0.07328783720731735,
0.1167912557721138,
0.09293054044246674,
0.4411028325557709,
-0.4587107002735138,
0.07864495366811752,
0.4877464473247528,
-0.5356720685958862,
0.051655758172273636,
-0.27423301339149475,
0.041166726499795914,
-0.22701536118984222,
-0.7202360033988953,
0.25870481133461,
-0.15632188320159912,
-1.012542486190796,
0.47475045919418335,
-0.49204471707344055,
0.26584288477897644,
-0.08872395008802414,
-1.3041870594024658,
0.3222716450691223,
0.8870898485183716,
0.5369192957878113,
0.3762434124946594,
-0.2562825381755829,
-0.5813857316970825,
0.14756354689598083,
-0.4748738706111908,
0.6395324468612671,
-0.6279038190841675,
-0.42874038219451904,
0.271875262260437,
-0.10616494715213776,
-0.056531600654125214,
-0.4741503596305847,
0.7277163863182068,
-0.42742207646369934,
0.03301990404725075,
-0.5659230351448059,
-0.17528168857097626,
-0.24677129089832306,
-0.12037733942270279,
-0.46251609921455383,
1.2028909921646118,
-0.06664593517780304,
-0.671464741230011,
0.49401772022247314,
-0.9561614990234375,
-0.7573152780532837,
0.49108627438545227,
0.16035296022891998,
-0.12487421929836273,
0.3830176293849945,
-0.026040028780698776,
0.3992997705936432,
0.16965541243553162,
0.43221381306648254,
0.09702581912279129,
-0.45493441820144653,
0.2109815925359726,
-0.04159685969352722,
1.1866594552993774,
0.41654446721076965,
-0.6390134692192078,
-0.28786641359329224,
-0.3315100371837616,
0.37009382247924805,
-0.39063194394111633,
-0.41215112805366516,
-0.5572370290756226,
0.15810179710388184,
0.32564792037010193,
0.1962541788816452,
-0.07296593487262726,
-0.5449339747428894,
0.15733560919761658,
-0.38802653551101685,
0.9126482605934143,
0.3296472728252411,
-0.05838993564248085,
0.6394676566123962,
-0.33902373909950256,
0.4778123199939728,
-0.6119264364242554,
0.5305556654930115,
0.04242035374045372,
-0.9311283230781555,
-0.5188708305358887,
0.4638085663318634,
0.09674467891454697,
0.22459790110588074,
-0.690407395362854,
0.24979330599308014,
0.09266764670610428,
-0.25777143239974976,
-0.9703564047813416,
-0.10966894775629044,
-0.016659565269947052,
0.22944855690002441,
0.21022042632102966,
-0.4321838915348053,
-0.4943358302116394,
-0.9103637933731079,
-0.3754050135612488,
-0.8101186156272888,
0.07594119757413864,
0.056011103093624115,
0.1367238163948059,
-0.1152665838599205,
1.280333399772644,
-0.24499297142028809,
-0.14762164652347565,
-0.07087048888206482,
0.4262518286705017,
0.08320940285921097,
0.38960498571395874,
0.40335026383399963,
-1.189846396446228,
-0.34414395689964294,
0.27462688088417053,
-0.7025764584541321,
-0.20274484157562256,
-0.04526760056614876,
0.12748171389102936,
0.01607414148747921,
0.31539076566696167,
-0.5629549622535706,
0.3229048252105713,
0.45701542496681213,
-0.5362147688865662,
-0.07982707768678665,
-0.2666657567024231,
0.3314337730407715,
-0.7016392350196838,
0.1382557600736618,
-0.23287652432918549,
-0.13753290474414825,
-0.6060366034507751,
0.5201811194419861,
-0.09688258916139603,
-0.13759486377239227,
-0.6894956827163696,
0.38193419575691223,
-0.297383189201355,
-0.09490738809108734,
-0.29814064502716064,
-0.1562504768371582,
0.11403416842222214,
0.06766120344400406,
0.5475611090660095,
0.547788679599762,
0.3860214650630951,
-0.5430678129196167,
0.06642349064350128,
0.49929079413414,
-0.19809457659721375,
0.7265893816947937,
-0.41233953833580017,
0.39608925580978394,
-0.0404936820268631,
-0.2607070803642273,
-0.4631968140602112,
0.27062347531318665,
0.18561628460884094,
-0.4785822033882141,
0.032414257526397705,
-0.25582486391067505,
-0.66559898853302,
-0.3921964168548584,
-0.15526346862316132,
0.26303911209106445,
0.24816298484802246,
-0.18401861190795898,
0.8077082633972168,
1.0199253559112549,
-0.5738199949264526,
-0.8718595504760742,
-1.4891753196716309,
0.6147076487541199,
-0.45880213379859924,
-0.6771937608718872,
-0.11093445867300034,
-0.014531324617564678,
-0.7840906977653503,
0.08601131290197372,
0.15641511976718903,
-0.4016963541507721,
0.5728509426116943,
0.20415011048316956,
-0.48166990280151367,
-0.4278337359428406,
0.07412297278642654,
0.17944373190402985,
-0.19477300345897675,
0.19628579914569855,
-0.2234085500240326,
0.35687628388404846,
-0.05587633699178696,
-0.18733760714530945,
-0.34252262115478516,
0.8981058597564697,
0.08569486439228058,
-0.3032127320766449,
0.7513163685798645,
0.7572091221809387,
-0.31873154640197754,
0.11785364151000977,
-0.7854071259498596,
-0.09836188703775406,
-0.5168962478637695,
-0.021732425317168236,
0.1967986822128296,
-0.9832260608673096,
0.21881002187728882,
0.15110182762145996,
0.5467098355293274,
0.257267028093338,
0.32189661264419556,
-0.1899157017469406,
0.17624981701374054,
1.0749709606170654,
-0.018536187708377838,
0.366569459438324,
-0.059851109981536865,
0.6962223649024963,
-0.7082159519195557,
0.14566029608249664,
-0.6419144868850708,
-0.28656381368637085,
-0.6472769379615784,
-0.516541063785553,
-0.051276471465826035,
-0.04296300560235977,
-0.1995936781167984,
0.9604282379150391,
-0.8956817388534546,
0.5672466158866882,
0.5845762491226196,
-0.11930648237466812,
0.8218201398849487,
-0.2630162835121155,
0.6055989861488342,
-0.150961235165596,
-0.6551328897476196,
-0.9353376030921936,
0.7524154782295227,
0.18140409886837006,
0.6005973815917969,
0.41912370920181274,
0.8100252151489258,
0.5991824865341187,
0.3206866979598999,
-0.7033271193504333,
0.2277352511882782,
0.26322346925735474,
-0.8278389573097229,
-0.509639322757721,
-0.09770304709672928,
-1.1954963207244873,
0.06393697112798691,
0.09599713981151581,
-0.5535535216331482,
0.4652518928050995,
-0.11730040609836578,
-0.5099658966064453,
0.471393883228302,
-0.9032971858978271,
0.3514619469642639,
0.08310005068778992,
-0.06296378374099731,
-0.46596065163612366,
-0.6374346017837524,
-0.18008622527122498,
0.23078393936157227,
0.5398096442222595,
0.09043359756469727,
-0.014276129193603992,
0.6412013173103333,
-0.11100766807794571,
0.963493287563324,
0.07646854966878891,
-0.20170801877975464,
0.7365105748176575,
0.07868709415197372,
-0.002386751351878047,
0.23489786684513092,
-0.4254313111305237,
0.16877852380275726,
0.047858063131570816,
-0.4076269865036011,
-0.11140068620443344,
0.5446769595146179,
-0.5300199389457703,
-0.7704742550849915,
-0.41498076915740967,
-0.0927114337682724,
0.11281266808509827,
-0.020005101338028908,
-0.05135668069124222,
0.14637434482574463,
-0.02715037576854229,
0.01924184150993824,
0.6682822704315186,
-0.0979638621211052,
0.9026333689689636,
0.29522648453712463,
0.1102341040968895,
0.21340535581111908,
0.6041361689567566,
0.3925130069255829,
0.3907649517059326,
0.4353196918964386,
0.17874287068843842,
-0.24620287120342255,
-0.43921995162963867,
-0.6331356167793274,
0.05579940229654312,
-0.8680951595306396,
0.007629790343344212,
-0.7112367153167725,
-0.01445157639682293,
-0.3154376447200775,
-0.45071133971214294,
-0.2992568612098694,
-0.6235300898551941,
-0.19588591158390045,
-0.4786585867404938,
0.5521754622459412,
0.8588565587997437,
-0.5092186331748962,
0.09840759634971619,
-0.6969735622406006,
0.2496330440044403,
0.3980887532234192,
0.11572615057229996,
-0.20088250935077667,
-0.15638163685798645,
-0.07932571321725845,
-0.16192229092121124,
-0.1349487602710724,
-0.14066588878631592,
0.4735034704208374,
-0.003540968056768179,
0.6402195692062378,
-0.21310369670391083,
0.24438945949077606,
0.4783456027507782,
-0.26345381140708923,
0.9747360944747925,
0.03022966906428337,
-0.73708176612854,
0.5906925797462463,
-0.34206801652908325,
0.27081283926963806,
0.672191858291626,
0.30133965611457825,
-1.179736852645874,
-0.5414419174194336,
-0.7303595542907715,
-1.058876395225525,
0.7132473587989807,
0.4766657054424286,
0.6426070332527161,
-0.11839227378368378,
0.1932060867547989,
0.005601507145911455,
0.36657553911209106,
-1.1169975996017456,
-0.40429091453552246,
-0.040409233421087265,
0.31908315420150757,
0.2786826491355896,
-0.03359658271074295,
-0.42258355021476746,
0.2861657738685608,
0.19541776180267334,
-0.24151979386806488,
0.20695361495018005,
0.17987759411334991,
-0.09305490553379059,
-0.2993147671222687,
0.4346407949924469,
0.10767288506031036,
0.9334049224853516,
0.17134502530097961,
0.16980107128620148,
0.08875041455030441,
-0.5092488527297974,
0.15694904327392578,
-0.2449144572019577,
-0.16549701988697052,
-0.025750882923603058,
0.1523863524198532,
0.38160377740859985,
0.006670344155281782,
-0.3562217652797699,
0.16502609848976135,
-0.3154710829257965,
0.23089449107646942,
-0.1651248186826706,
0.05061296373605728,
0.39562663435935974,
0.08149649202823639,
0.4761851131916046,
0.4976237118244171,
0.32559144496917725,
-0.8447193503379822,
-0.2079876810312271,
0.03770847246050835,
-0.13152563571929932,
-0.04289183020591736,
0.3938680589199066,
0.3919317424297333,
-0.8443894982337952,
0.3718881905078888,
0.24559947848320007,
-0.023802053183317184,
0.5192509293556213,
0.19904541969299316,
0.6703777313232422,
-0.1846865862607956,
0.6180013418197632,
0.24135391414165497,
0.6199929714202881,
-0.49282240867614746,
0.2161037027835846,
-0.37940341234207153,
-0.6447582840919495,
-0.9723367691040039,
-0.46172770857810974,
-0.7273873686790466,
-0.22966653108596802,
-0.8095372915267944,
0.09252514690160751,
-0.3419974744319916,
-0.5195218920707703,
-0.19850125908851624,
-0.025158468633890152,
-0.28295984864234924,
0.1085474044084549,
0.3504279851913452,
0.7178823947906494,
-1.1159300804138184,
0.35494866967201233,
0.36622172594070435,
-0.31902623176574707,
-0.47043558955192566,
-0.27804452180862427,
-0.1469372659921646,
-0.41583704948425293,
0.5850721001625061,
-0.3104802966117859,
-0.18885336816310883,
-0.11181771010160446,
-0.3834410011768341,
-1.055804967880249,
0.7815075516700745,
0.32857048511505127,
-0.14595960080623627,
0.20410121977329254,
0.4377860426902771,
0.5515321493148804,
0.3103378713130951,
0.40601733326911926,
0.4167012870311737,
0.770143985748291,
-0.4124356210231781,
-1.1450092792510986,
-0.24953900277614594,
-0.19707337021827698,
0.15982341766357422,
0.22548411786556244,
-0.7494170069694519,
0.25945302844047546,
-0.03423366695642471,
-0.38480934500694275,
0.0015355529030784965,
0.42579248547554016,
-0.011484145186841488,
0.1110754981637001,
0.021710749715566635,
0.15756769478321075,
0.7242363095283508,
-0.056355033069849014,
1.2043784856796265,
0.1720128059387207,
0.06462782621383667,
0.7445154190063477,
-0.011277702637016773,
0.689461886882782,
0.9151117205619812,
-0.3321221172809601,
-0.002868299838155508,
0.7519536018371582,
0.38222241401672363,
0.1459030658006668,
0.3253667950630188,
-0.1938028782606125,
-0.01785370521247387,
-0.409053236246109,
-0.3128089904785156,
0.32770946621894836,
0.44456395506858826,
-0.03176385536789894,
-0.08375097066164017,
0.13703277707099915,
-0.14243973791599274,
0.580659806728363,
-0.329080730676651,
0.6823174953460693,
0.29604464769363403,
-0.5504879951477051,
0.08040212839841843,
0.14129871129989624,
0.8495951294898987,
-0.4929567873477936,
0.0622609406709671,
0.017769165337085724,
-0.3729632794857025,
-0.5942330956459045,
-1.1785131692886353,
0.9796354174613953,
-0.25216320157051086,
-0.07793360948562622,
-0.6938602924346924,
0.5006667375564575,
0.06279055029153824,
-0.35647526383399963,
0.30664825439453125,
0.38553088903427124,
0.08044880628585815,
0.10427577048540115,
-0.40576037764549255,
0.11438434571027756,
-0.02382928691804409,
-0.22122369706630707,
0.38854125142097473,
0.4528280198574066,
-0.2906872034072876,
0.6600180268287659,
0.5885318517684937,
0.3805912137031555,
0.06458582729101181,
0.22572845220565796,
0.6082370281219482,
-0.7737236022949219,
-0.14446039497852325,
-0.63616544008255,
0.5773314237594604,
-0.04404071345925331,
-0.7960245609283447,
0.5938323736190796,
0.30888500809669495,
0.841424286365509,
0.14763030409812927,
0.5534578561782837,
-0.450865775346756,
0.1920456439256668,
-0.4717147946357727,
0.518995463848114,
0.15583230555057526,
0.14230675995349884,
-0.2804581820964813,
-0.7242138385772705,
-0.6002101302146912,
0.916520357131958,
-0.275027871131897,
-0.19390588998794556,
0.35026854276657104,
0.489432692527771,
0.28977012634277344,
0.5256479978561401,
0.4307049810886383,
-0.10680177807807922,
0.31101685762405396,
-0.00852794386446476,
0.8435113430023193,
-0.511093020439148,
0.25302183628082275,
-0.4502343237400055,
-0.010771770030260086,
0.14259763062000275,
-0.9846796989440918,
-0.2453773468732834,
-0.5937013030052185,
-0.5754472613334656,
0.026224583387374878,
-0.2341611236333847,
0.9290810227394104,
0.8993580341339111,
-0.6624614596366882,
-0.49871551990509033,
0.2282683402299881,
0.0707859918475151,
-0.6169564723968506,
-0.24752174317836761,
0.11469274759292603,
-0.22056297957897186,
-0.8619545698165894,
0.3136832118034363,
0.6690912246704102,
-0.4492422938346863,
-0.29648131132125854,
0.2954850494861603,
-0.4827418923377991,
-0.31050628423690796,
0.7840034365653992,
0.685025691986084,
-0.6561053395271301,
-0.2815577983856201,
-0.008880739100277424,
-0.12854477763175964,
0.3040561378002167,
1.0504223108291626,
-0.6054614782333374,
0.3938208818435669,
0.20748348534107208,
0.8985667824745178,
0.522972822189331,
-0.09256704896688461,
0.838289201259613,
-0.42234519124031067,
0.11423728615045547,
0.7084555625915527,
0.3268187642097473,
0.7499996423721313,
-0.9105105400085449,
0.7711848616600037,
-0.18301834166049957,
-0.8523581624031067,
-0.45064571499824524,
0.09885130077600479,
-0.8092946410179138,
-0.19831721484661102,
1.1841931343078613,
0.019538141787052155,
-0.23400668799877167,
-0.9439888000488281,
-0.5525282025337219,
-0.11145754903554916,
-0.30695202946662903,
0.7651643753051758,
0.41272619366645813,
-0.22876931726932526,
-0.10881784558296204,
-0.5465509295463562,
0.44045549631118774,
0.4684840440750122,
-0.36091306805610657,
0.16836586594581604,
-0.12927469611167908,
0.1483025848865509,
0.6147896647453308,
0.8571353554725647,
-0.19631414115428925,
0.1741810292005539,
-0.11049968749284744,
-0.049178916960954666,
0.37376171350479126,
0.24817951023578644,
-0.14139729738235474,
0.11780422180891037,
0.45435017347335815,
0.32505184412002563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02636v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02636v1 | Can Large Language Models Learn Independent Causal Mechanisms? | 2024-02-04T23:04:02 | 2024-02-04T23:04:02 | Gaël Gendron, Bao Trung Nguyen, Alex Yuxuan Peng, Michael Witbrock, Gillian Dobbie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT, I.2.3; I.2.6; I.2.7; G.3 | Despite impressive performance on language modelling and complex reasoning
tasks, Large Language Models (LLMs) fall short on the same tasks in uncommon
settings or with distribution shifts, exhibiting some lack of generalisation
ability. This issue has usually been alleviated by feeding more training data
into the LLM. However, this method is brittle, as the scope of tasks may not be
readily predictable or may evolve, and updating the model with new data
generally requires extensive additional training. By contrast, systems, such as
causal models, that learn abstract variables and causal relationships can
demonstrate increased robustness against changes in the distribution. One
reason for this success is the existence and use of Independent Causal
Mechanisms (ICMs) representing high-level concepts that only sparsely interact.
In this work, we apply two concepts from causality to learn ICMs within LLMs.
We develop a new LLM architecture composed of multiple sparsely interacting
language modelling modules. We introduce a routing scheme to induce
specialisation of the network into domain-specific modules. We also present a
Mutual Information minimisation objective that trains a separate module to
learn abstraction and domain-invariant mechanisms. We show that such causal
constraints can improve out-of-distribution performance on abstract and causal
reasoning tasks. | [
-0.1639915555715561,
-0.6875195503234863,
0.7361102104187012,
0.22860370576381683,
-0.03384978324174881,
-0.3801186978816986,
-0.29972943663597107,
-0.39562347531318665,
0.0763845145702362,
0.46002650260925293,
-0.5037679076194763,
-0.19647817313671112,
-0.6563459634780884,
0.11772345006465912,
-0.2336108237504959,
0.7803559303283691,
0.0011566614266484976,
0.26386943459510803,
-0.16631917655467987,
-0.23716969788074493,
-0.3646407127380371,
-0.38131067156791687,
-0.7681543827056885,
-0.5859098434448242,
0.8026413917541504,
0.1985340416431427,
0.4266274571418762,
0.6715867519378662,
0.39851969480514526,
0.3736500144004822,
0.09146495908498764,
0.21235789358615875,
-0.3490377962589264,
0.008640201762318611,
-0.6493822336196899,
-0.4996616542339325,
0.06611272692680359,
-0.30095991492271423,
0.6655188202857971,
0.9236528873443604,
-0.04841341823339462,
-0.1811385601758957,
0.20136426389217377,
0.4294646382331848,
-0.6581385135650635,
0.6646693348884583,
-0.6541250348091125,
-0.2814251482486725,
-0.0766933262348175,
-0.2583077549934387,
-0.6154776811599731,
0.10780825465917587,
0.07198093086481094,
-0.555478572845459,
0.09663068503141403,
0.015220713801681995,
0.42126789689064026,
0.2560305893421173,
-0.7464040517807007,
-0.21216048300266266,
-0.7502549886703491,
0.626410722732544,
-0.5768946409225464,
0.15087246894836426,
0.21730588376522064,
0.2473791241645813,
-0.31308260560035706,
-0.40187835693359375,
-0.2771323621273041,
-0.199861541390419,
-0.27142247557640076,
-0.051880959421396255,
-0.19892849028110504,
0.060471028089523315,
0.14430096745491028,
-0.2571248412132263,
-0.12974543869495392,
0.49792414903640747,
-0.36646589636802673,
-0.05894920229911804,
0.5879931449890137,
0.4008770287036896,
0.2320857048034668,
-0.13440777361392975,
-0.47602784633636475,
0.08520281314849854,
-1.0406111478805542,
-0.10495688766241074,
0.5140585899353027,
0.4734833538532257,
-0.3544157147407532,
0.23507803678512573,
-0.05802048370242119,
0.5850222706794739,
-0.03655432537198067,
-0.07979649305343628,
-0.21239590644836426,
0.1202082484960556,
-0.13128772377967834,
-0.11217660456895828,
0.714734673500061,
-0.4962024688720703,
-0.0584222786128521,
-0.3174750804901123,
-0.3127322196960449,
0.05146782100200653,
0.01977476105093956,
-0.2895413041114807,
-0.2222883105278015,
-0.011039553210139275,
-0.15859225392341614,
0.0042923735454678535,
-0.16165724396705627,
-0.21166622638702393,
-0.3487433195114136,
-0.5816660523414612,
0.6999458074569702,
-0.2786098122596741,
-0.24858802556991577,
0.269700825214386,
0.1277923732995987,
0.021993262693285942,
0.5267494320869446,
-1.050897240638733,
0.5048547387123108,
0.5714191198348999,
0.6233307719230652,
-0.25556978583335876,
-0.6100218296051025,
-0.6847720742225647,
0.5644237399101257,
-0.24381090700626373,
0.7020905017852783,
-0.4698939025402069,
0.11677858233451843,
0.07785482704639435,
0.14379353821277618,
-0.36002933979034424,
-0.44566768407821655,
0.2762967646121979,
-0.7678714394569397,
-0.1743737906217575,
-0.056145086884498596,
-0.4890010356903076,
-0.364279568195343,
-0.1551925092935562,
-0.6686686873435974,
0.45773056149482727,
-0.17015814781188965,
-1.0186322927474976,
0.17983923852443695,
-0.2693325877189636,
-0.6389529705047607,
-0.17632833123207092,
-0.3973153829574585,
-0.2436361312866211,
0.169902965426445,
-0.015768632292747498,
0.693143367767334,
-0.6380746960639954,
0.705522358417511,
-0.7468002438545227,
-0.1452733278274536,
0.11880283057689667,
-0.6299774050712585,
0.7443706393241882,
-0.06369598954916,
-0.5591747760772705,
0.1441350281238556,
-0.938174843788147,
-0.4429253041744232,
-0.06433281302452087,
-0.38613811135292053,
-0.5778332948684692,
0.3146374821662903,
-0.3004004955291748,
0.4337000250816345,
-0.06029780954122543,
-0.11032575368881226,
0.09654927253723145,
-0.2744394838809967,
0.21951480209827423,
1.082915186882019,
0.12222073972225189,
0.5975437164306641,
-0.21003028750419617,
0.1484447568655014,
0.45294538140296936,
0.07271669805049896,
0.0886419266462326,
-0.33124664425849915,
-0.9191356897354126,
-0.2982522249221802,
-0.2108060121536255,
0.3818471133708954,
-0.7953512668609619,
0.37552034854888916,
-0.036330707371234894,
-0.11590326577425003,
-0.02525644563138485,
0.29653188586235046,
0.408738911151886,
0.24486100673675537,
0.2559371292591095,
-0.29853522777557373,
-0.24740047752857208,
-0.7597230672836304,
-0.10561083257198334,
-0.26123371720314026,
0.2983671724796295,
0.20270417630672455,
0.5727046132087708,
-0.17508138716220856,
0.5703374743461609,
-0.41454795002937317,
-0.15977594256401062,
-0.29827648401260376,
0.07738063484430313,
0.1297987550497055,
0.5141590237617493,
0.14970451593399048,
-0.5594058632850647,
-0.17277969419956207,
0.17663191258907318,
-0.9723487496376038,
-0.17026683688163757,
-0.22335144877433777,
-0.1184588074684143,
-0.07297333329916,
0.729013204574585,
-0.8040264248847961,
0.13158240914344788,
0.3301919996738434,
-0.25020650029182434,
0.46874362230300903,
-0.46301019191741943,
-0.3854184150695801,
-0.6111693382263184,
-0.06965496391057968,
0.031818658113479614,
-0.023606793954968452,
-0.6152607202529907,
0.06712331622838974,
-0.04722020775079727,
0.09198302775621414,
-0.6058807969093323,
0.9415819048881531,
-0.7204375267028809,
-0.01928890123963356,
-0.3655725419521332,
0.26394763588905334,
-0.18011769652366638,
0.7776529788970947,
0.053914960473775864,
0.06988345831632614,
1.0662164688110352,
-0.9376845955848694,
0.008151724934577942,
0.00991090852767229,
-0.38677388429641724,
0.2650068402290344,
-0.4583999514579773,
-0.26583823561668396,
-0.43683522939682007,
0.09748947620391846,
-0.7390161156654358,
-0.33846092224121094,
0.2545018494129181,
0.059180185198783875,
0.48580071330070496,
-0.07335711270570755,
-0.5000793933868408,
0.07662846893072128,
0.30123960971832275,
0.2489544153213501,
0.2928962707519531,
-0.6838871240615845,
0.6063221096992493,
0.3963974118232727,
0.1156245693564415,
-0.6542242169380188,
-0.5339938998222351,
-0.22967010736465454,
-0.2951645255088806,
-0.5218878388404846,
-0.25529614090919495,
0.13220776617527008,
-0.4484765827655792,
0.04487144947052002,
0.07641585171222687,
-0.06610983610153198,
0.21575912833213806,
0.25124573707580566,
-0.11671443283557892,
-0.12000016868114471,
0.5226471424102783,
0.2498856782913208,
-0.2251410186290741,
0.21286757290363312,
-0.5967282652854919,
0.3202178478240967,
0.36493149399757385,
-0.6931841373443604,
-0.38764333724975586,
0.44753438234329224,
0.5111121535301208,
-0.03885388746857643,
0.9329211711883545,
0.5580241680145264,
-0.2084677666425705,
-0.4260343015193939,
-0.544820249080658,
-0.39954450726509094,
-0.4529966413974762,
0.3444472551345825,
-0.38067999482154846,
-1.0886790752410889,
0.5613778829574585,
-0.2368169128894806,
-0.25083884596824646,
0.48642176389694214,
0.6176275610923767,
0.41352707147598267,
1.0373950004577637,
0.9589400887489319,
-0.22793230414390564,
0.35845768451690674,
0.019195428118109703,
0.12932436168193817,
-0.5856747627258301,
-0.16976557672023773,
-0.44097164273262024,
0.012705420143902302,
-0.4241941273212433,
-0.45676136016845703,
0.3964141309261322,
0.34994208812713623,
-0.5100807547569275,
0.06459154188632965,
0.15482909977436066,
0.2972531020641327,
0.5567692518234253,
0.29304295778274536,
0.3509480059146881,
0.0722498744726181,
-0.38824817538261414,
0.3051500618457794,
-1.0839425325393677,
-0.1629457175731659,
0.6968836784362793,
0.15973001718521118,
1.1563844680786133,
0.2929878234863281,
0.563136100769043,
0.044657543301582336,
0.4991098940372467,
-0.27790141105651855,
0.5619970560073853,
-0.03935445472598076,
-0.45800483226776123,
-0.2437954545021057,
-0.7536652088165283,
-0.8964396119117737,
0.4219527840614319,
-0.15213751792907715,
-0.7896028161048889,
0.5694527626037598,
0.07559407502412796,
0.050237707793712616,
0.49526652693748474,
-0.7471826076507568,
0.5852728486061096,
-0.07046233117580414,
-0.6622557640075684,
-0.33773162961006165,
-0.7228278517723083,
0.5779559016227722,
-0.21565689146518707,
0.40913328528404236,
-0.17286540567874908,
-0.030120518058538437,
0.4462663233280182,
-0.32528650760650635,
1.629246711730957,
-0.10820060223340988,
-0.19620859622955322,
0.30402278900146484,
0.18848200142383575,
0.8368598222732544,
0.2163151651620865,
0.02800443023443222,
0.06124217435717583,
-0.6149181723594666,
-0.4583759605884552,
-0.6044839024543762,
0.8165773153305054,
-1.0034263134002686,
-0.9330441355705261,
-0.20608317852020264,
-0.5648095607757568,
-0.2925209701061249,
0.30375170707702637,
0.029786448925733566,
0.5653857588768005,
0.03775341063737869,
-0.04117027297616005,
0.7442978024482727,
-0.2649568021297455,
0.4746462106704712,
0.7604983448982239,
0.18777024745941162,
-0.32756006717681885,
0.5401347875595093,
-0.12741903960704803,
0.6674333810806274,
0.7757471203804016,
0.3476448059082031,
-0.14182701706886292,
-0.40499183535575867,
-0.1789739727973938,
0.4101913273334503,
-1.0128132104873657,
-0.18035878241062164,
-0.8740689754486084,
-0.13920141756534576,
-0.34311774373054504,
-0.06805381178855896,
-0.03915754705667496,
-0.35981616377830505,
-0.28777775168418884,
-0.18027682602405548,
0.3040200471878052,
0.9575485587120056,
-0.48189231753349304,
0.36224550008773804,
-0.6186450719833374,
-0.024556690827012062,
0.46947696805000305,
0.14456382393836975,
0.5348432660102844,
-0.47208869457244873,
-0.537022054195404,
-0.3369544446468353,
-0.15067094564437866,
-0.6152859330177307,
0.2511124908924103,
0.15535283088684082,
0.6040678024291992,
0.6265753507614136,
-0.05694233998656273,
0.5905817151069641,
-0.8001109957695007,
0.2743700444698334,
0.4008151590824127,
-0.8600198030471802,
0.1349194049835205,
-0.5069669485092163,
0.2789899706840515,
0.07853210717439651,
0.6698172092437744,
-0.26143720746040344,
-0.6405982971191406,
-0.5263011455535889,
-0.5960891246795654,
0.7901650667190552,
-0.0668041780591011,
0.07412736862897873,
-0.19531579315662384,
0.4484988749027252,
0.14024022221565247,
-0.021186668425798416,
-1.064462661743164,
-0.16710388660430908,
0.5216422080993652,
-0.0690637081861496,
-0.23033244907855988,
-0.16178807616233826,
-0.199210062623024,
-0.10280227661132812,
0.747140109539032,
-0.3272322714328766,
0.11503569781780243,
0.08017224073410034,
-0.13794414699077606,
-0.17390526831150055,
0.13584640622138977,
0.4363449215888977,
0.736391007900238,
0.3588283956050873,
0.49061015248298645,
0.09152799099683762,
-0.05809818208217621,
0.4290713965892792,
-0.11217030137777328,
-0.17462196946144104,
-0.16246993839740753,
0.666427731513977,
1.1110771894454956,
0.579687237739563,
-0.48712289333343506,
0.5529499650001526,
0.11329249292612076,
0.02932826429605484,
0.018348190933465958,
0.1898791342973709,
0.223906472325325,
0.5654821991920471,
0.06662029772996902,
0.2454887330532074,
-0.016544250771403313,
-0.5010545253753662,
0.2554439604282379,
0.2644953429698944,
-0.4936659336090088,
-0.4145040810108185,
0.7818238139152527,
-0.06355472654104233,
0.059986747801303864,
0.19192029535770416,
-0.20799751579761505,
-0.16487811505794525,
0.418636679649353,
0.6984825134277344,
0.8785114288330078,
-0.33027058839797974,
0.2037828117609024,
0.14629989862442017,
0.48645713925361633,
-0.42556652426719666,
-0.05407951772212982,
-0.07210606336593628,
-0.717819094657898,
-0.5884203910827637,
-0.4158022701740265,
-0.19427822530269623,
-0.08537591993808746,
-0.31746986508369446,
0.42902329564094543,
-0.3442869782447815,
0.1760168820619583,
-0.2760895788669586,
-0.47465378046035767,
-0.5989418029785156,
0.1267050802707672,
-0.3067256808280945,
0.5843783617019653,
-1.1439573764801025,
0.7831275463104248,
0.41322627663612366,
-0.46138784289360046,
-0.9996155500411987,
-0.2712991237640381,
-0.08670904487371445,
-0.6831822991371155,
1.1021054983139038,
-0.1352761685848236,
-0.16890834271907806,
-0.1752842366695404,
-0.3326782286167145,
-0.9751659631729126,
0.7273977398872375,
0.5925698280334473,
-0.5302735567092896,
0.0109045235440135,
0.09558342397212982,
0.37059205770492554,
-0.289788156747818,
0.12658046185970306,
0.10725106298923492,
0.22464151680469513,
-0.08819562196731567,
-0.5444729328155518,
0.19892124831676483,
0.09423018991947174,
-0.22961941361427307,
0.2721211612224579,
-0.9350074529647827,
1.0085004568099976,
-0.22438809275627136,
-0.16347253322601318,
-0.08793845027685165,
0.596581220626831,
0.016154495999217033,
0.09789186716079712,
0.31827905774116516,
0.4414374828338623,
0.6054772138595581,
0.12801873683929443,
0.9743788838386536,
-0.27263790369033813,
0.36184918880462646,
1.1560347080230713,
-0.4372973144054413,
0.635103166103363,
0.27441132068634033,
0.19910135865211487,
0.43609097599983215,
0.2961558401584625,
0.5937793254852295,
0.6533750295639038,
0.4689094126224518,
-0.6262942552566528,
-0.4761044383049011,
0.12407512962818146,
0.05337244272232056,
0.225316122174263,
0.3541654348373413,
-0.20886828005313873,
-0.5186303853988647,
0.19498290121555328,
0.07059980928897858,
-0.13032840192317963,
-0.47032681107521057,
0.8325737714767456,
0.49438712000846863,
-0.5623258352279663,
0.43571555614471436,
0.10421402007341385,
0.33631905913352966,
-0.9206979274749756,
0.1245405524969101,
-0.2567603886127472,
0.5470249652862549,
-0.012411164119839668,
-0.12112119048833847,
0.20102271437644958,
-0.42727547883987427,
-0.13112132251262665,
0.002957666525617242,
0.7651692628860474,
-0.5634845495223999,
-0.338685542345047,
0.6164833307266235,
0.6658245921134949,
-0.10822825133800507,
0.34542316198349,
-0.3916870653629303,
0.03742818161845207,
-0.32023319602012634,
-0.039621978998184204,
0.6077620387077332,
0.9927592873573303,
-0.3735657334327698,
0.8130135536193848,
0.4538448750972748,
0.3525215685367584,
0.2623456120491028,
0.25145605206489563,
0.8546878695487976,
-0.5840079188346863,
-0.5689389109611511,
-0.9844037890434265,
0.1465153992176056,
0.1459323763847351,
-0.14282162487506866,
0.8581428527832031,
0.11881715804338455,
0.889243483543396,
-0.22897286713123322,
0.5679177641868591,
0.3315686583518982,
0.07710818201303482,
-0.8476715683937073,
0.44815686345100403,
-0.4512023627758026,
0.3965652287006378,
-0.27315494418144226,
-0.6476746201515198,
-0.6037494540214539,
0.24481768906116486,
-0.4292130470275879,
-0.08971738815307617,
0.8991778492927551,
0.8370251655578613,
-0.2723732590675354,
-0.18173126876354218,
0.3884575366973877,
0.4619760513305664,
0.38907575607299805,
0.5964733958244324,
0.8831033110618591,
-0.03839758038520813,
0.18864896893501282,
-0.016930151730775833,
-0.22091399133205414,
0.006354528479278088,
-0.7509472370147705,
-1.108604907989502,
-0.5615085959434509,
-0.37411078810691833,
-0.0873866155743599,
0.163211852312088,
0.7272372841835022,
0.7853356599807739,
-0.5216629505157471,
-0.4966767132282257,
-0.3943323493003845,
0.5140165090560913,
-0.2349725216627121,
-0.19181649386882782,
0.5204390287399292,
-0.7930617928504944,
-0.3161144256591797,
0.3401773273944855,
0.7371927499771118,
-0.1844502091407776,
-0.44305071234703064,
-0.003610119689255953,
-0.27437299489974976,
0.26659318804740906,
0.6075473427772522,
0.27068233489990234,
-0.3701978027820587,
-0.48555988073349,
-0.44435030221939087,
0.036064524203538895,
-0.2434840202331543,
1.245327353477478,
-0.42120370268821716,
0.11118453741073608,
0.46253451704978943,
0.8196330666542053,
0.299864798784256,
-0.5884357690811157,
0.4555262327194214,
-0.667192280292511,
0.4101428985595703,
-0.042923904955387115,
0.6252914071083069,
0.15645791590213776,
-0.3325076103210449,
0.16744524240493774,
0.4702342748641968,
-0.5159013271331787,
-0.5483334064483643,
0.5259936451911926,
-0.5650995969772339,
-0.3817553222179413,
1.194596290588379,
-0.2165396511554718,
-0.5629264116287231,
-0.3879510164260864,
0.15890423953533173,
0.11127875000238419,
0.004534413572400808,
0.7496063113212585,
0.49071499705314636,
-0.1859574317932129,
0.01521007064729929,
-0.3261670172214508,
0.34002089500427246,
0.298666387796402,
-0.8865676522254944,
0.10835441201925278,
0.48417380452156067,
0.3474515676498413,
-0.06575880199670792,
0.7333671450614929,
-0.05973745882511139,
0.07182972133159637,
0.0454665869474411,
-0.0858415737748146,
0.31104516983032227,
-0.7065675258636475,
-0.4286261200904846,
0.09082233905792236,
0.022107908502221107,
0.30319908261299133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02633v1 | Predicting Machine Translation Performance on Low-Resource Languages: The Role of Domain Similarity | 2024-02-04T22:56:56 | 2024-02-04T22:56:56 | Eric Khiu, Hasti Toossi, David Anugraha, Jinyu Liu, Jiaxu Li, Juan Armando Parra Flores, Leandro Acros Roman, A. Seza Doğruöz, En-Shiun Annie Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning and testing a multilingual large language model is expensive and
challenging for low-resource languages (LRLs). While previous studies have
predicted the performance of natural language processing (NLP) tasks using
machine learning methods, they primarily focus on high-resource languages,
overlooking LRLs and shifts across domains. Focusing on LRLs, we investigate
three factors: the size of the fine-tuning corpus, the domain similarity
between fine-tuning and testing corpora, and the language similarity between
source and target languages. We employ classical regression models to assess
how these factors impact the model's performance. Our results indicate that
domain similarity has the most critical impact on predicting the performance of
Machine Translation models. | [
-0.5631403923034668,
-0.6985737681388855,
0.3843871057033539,
-0.014243010431528091,
-0.07212702929973602,
0.167960986495018,
-0.4536167085170746,
-0.75006502866745,
-0.35236504673957825,
0.7500811815261841,
-0.5776501297950745,
-0.0435343012213707,
-0.6941226124763489,
0.5862041711807251,
-0.24555808305740356,
0.8871809840202332,
-0.1300489604473114,
0.017499225214123726,
-0.163834348320961,
-0.2717236578464508,
-0.49613386392593384,
-0.6013553142547607,
-0.6288211941719055,
-0.5261331796646118,
0.5600061416625977,
0.1627478450536728,
1.084726333618164,
0.7530148029327393,
0.9148662686347961,
0.2547454237937927,
-0.09523338824510574,
0.2793298363685608,
-0.4584955871105194,
0.1079016625881195,
-0.2297522872686386,
-0.46432027220726013,
-0.2194645255804062,
-0.03822990879416466,
0.6389684677124023,
0.8452373147010803,
0.3676016330718994,
0.4311302900314331,
0.4260711669921875,
0.7010242342948914,
-0.5010536313056946,
0.1441812515258789,
-0.7384825348854065,
-0.1776057928800583,
-0.1972007006406784,
-0.18988604843616486,
-0.38591521978378296,
-0.312503457069397,
0.09096308052539825,
-0.4327518045902252,
0.5255886912345886,
0.42746463418006897,
0.810316801071167,
0.5084903240203857,
-0.18422555923461914,
-0.10871276259422302,
-0.8184046745300293,
1.1111594438552856,
-0.6138296127319336,
0.5381181836128235,
0.6211439967155457,
0.0062601566314697266,
-0.0380847305059433,
-0.2167886644601822,
-0.2838442027568817,
-0.2776608169078827,
-0.37934550642967224,
-0.3930632770061493,
-0.16097579896450043,
-0.07042963057756424,
0.4205104112625122,
0.3018154501914978,
-0.8504772782325745,
0.22649511694908142,
-0.617331862449646,
-0.054585110396146774,
0.42043033242225647,
0.18833254277706146,
0.16637353599071503,
-0.03003864921629429,
-0.1549685001373291,
-0.08662797510623932,
-0.6699150204658508,
-0.03611786291003227,
0.10032347589731216,
0.9603434205055237,
0.011341067962348461,
0.4573978781700134,
-0.028043141588568687,
0.8682435154914856,
-0.1372528076171875,
-0.28538835048675537,
0.18941403925418854,
-0.48200029134750366,
-0.41318798065185547,
-0.02455008402466774,
0.5939650535583496,
0.20256248116493225,
0.5019109845161438,
-0.2753262519836426,
-0.2559884786605835,
0.003600041614845395,
0.32784223556518555,
-0.7032092809677124,
0.21253849565982819,
-0.09296669065952301,
-0.5676778554916382,
-0.07587119936943054,
-0.4297443628311157,
-0.5415899753570557,
-0.19291837513446808,
-0.5133705139160156,
0.21404977142810822,
-0.677367627620697,
-0.041553106158971786,
-0.09944423288106918,
0.21229757368564606,
-0.07312463223934174,
0.14976242184638977,
-0.7307046055793762,
0.5610693693161011,
0.8205367922782898,
1.042850375175476,
-0.6034096479415894,
-0.5010708570480347,
-0.5917801260948181,
-0.21352297067642212,
-0.3433283567428589,
0.504747748374939,
-0.4056122601032257,
-0.20863009989261627,
0.17989958822727203,
0.17895764112472534,
-0.32445210218429565,
-0.7985764741897583,
0.4702804684638977,
-0.6573516130447388,
-0.0917213186621666,
-0.21929360926151276,
-0.5401561260223389,
-0.13461804389953613,
0.02429535798728466,
-0.9236242175102234,
1.0171847343444824,
0.3663071095943451,
-0.5958386063575745,
0.333613783121109,
-0.5059467554092407,
-0.6825947761535645,
-0.05101904273033142,
0.2854540944099426,
-0.4567174017429352,
0.3402681052684784,
-0.08579280227422714,
0.5556644201278687,
-0.6169078350067139,
-0.004434780217707157,
-0.20355339348316193,
-0.436893492937088,
0.3465927243232727,
-0.3024231791496277,
0.5138042569160461,
0.5835329294204712,
-0.11230242997407913,
-0.03455907478928566,
-0.5973824262619019,
0.20543892681598663,
-0.10452651977539062,
-0.3254677355289459,
-0.48518091440200806,
-0.09390237927436829,
0.3391992449760437,
0.32649824023246765,
0.20556223392486572,
-0.21816405653953552,
0.04008481279015541,
-0.39777183532714844,
0.22137032449245453,
0.39620527625083923,
-0.23773977160453796,
0.6143456697463989,
-0.20207616686820984,
0.8274020552635193,
-0.12549234926700592,
0.0711216852068901,
0.16688132286071777,
-0.6411976218223572,
-0.5090283155441284,
-0.030176958069205284,
0.6372033953666687,
0.4691990613937378,
-0.5292178988456726,
-0.21336792409420013,
-0.2992226183414459,
-0.4266343414783478,
-1.0080149173736572,
0.5090823769569397,
0.642941415309906,
0.048330679535865784,
0.5439509749412537,
-0.29341331124305725,
-0.45666933059692383,
-1.068006992340088,
-0.4547105133533478,
0.012660326436161995,
0.08737971633672714,
0.16307204961776733,
0.4235280156135559,
-0.24988998472690582,
0.39969602227211,
-0.4065215587615967,
-0.3264814019203186,
-0.3603964149951935,
0.2664521038532257,
0.21539711952209473,
0.37602460384368896,
0.6176578998565674,
-0.8115834593772888,
-0.8043296933174133,
0.38998931646347046,
-0.2788839042186737,
-0.12229742854833603,
0.24542482197284698,
0.19635732471942902,
0.5642138719558716,
0.5873123407363892,
-0.3598182499408722,
0.04964558035135269,
0.998594343662262,
-0.13810841739177704,
0.3568601906299591,
-0.3405348062515259,
0.18618573248386383,
-0.8360631465911865,
0.21530570089817047,
0.16743390262126923,
-0.16047264635562897,
-0.5186393857002258,
0.20555154979228973,
0.1091737449169159,
-0.17004017531871796,
-0.4645138680934906,
0.4632980227470398,
-0.3301842212677002,
-0.30585750937461853,
-0.33267083764076233,
-0.03131847828626633,
-0.1922110617160797,
0.23527440428733826,
-0.08098717033863068,
1.167657732963562,
0.1286957561969757,
-0.6911694407463074,
-0.04979338496923447,
-0.05632169544696808,
-0.5451855659484863,
0.2325417697429657,
-0.5170547962188721,
-0.14334718883037567,
0.23379074037075043,
-0.3683928847312927,
-0.6050311326980591,
0.04267057776451111,
-0.35768431425094604,
-0.3787263035774231,
0.2863267958164215,
-0.21229466795921326,
-0.5642991065979004,
-0.27830055356025696,
0.2781517207622528,
0.43667423725128174,
0.5345848202705383,
-0.014367545023560524,
0.2889486253261566,
0.10893776267766953,
-0.21868503093719482,
-0.5423651933670044,
-0.6263526082038879,
-0.2019260823726654,
-0.24107299745082855,
-0.3576769530773163,
0.4900816082954407,
-0.0002003571717068553,
-0.29742568731307983,
0.019291803240776062,
0.17538882791996002,
-0.28381025791168213,
0.45871850848197937,
0.3278346061706543,
0.13956142961978912,
-0.4783209264278412,
0.12138654291629791,
-0.3049016296863556,
-0.09523391723632812,
-0.07188821583986282,
-0.2612181007862091,
0.5126157402992249,
-0.28912433981895447,
-0.14174117147922516,
-0.14093154668807983,
0.3168677091598511,
0.6778056025505066,
-0.4167036712169647,
0.8891009092330933,
0.7348026633262634,
-0.30788490176200867,
-0.17983928322792053,
-0.3591533601284027,
-0.05945971980690956,
-0.384742796421051,
0.5467408299446106,
-0.6264744997024536,
-0.8427190780639648,
0.44457754492759705,
-0.1347225159406662,
-0.213334321975708,
0.5690211653709412,
0.7444875240325928,
0.03360604867339134,
1.0886633396148682,
0.993821382522583,
-0.32754626870155334,
0.3791157901287079,
-0.19365127384662628,
0.29891327023506165,
-0.5917044281959534,
0.27697134017944336,
-0.8157241940498352,
-0.3510589003562927,
-1.164724349975586,
-0.5895620584487915,
0.11635329574346542,
0.15369702875614166,
-0.13622720539569855,
0.774010419845581,
-0.11043232679367065,
0.4641185402870178,
0.8642321825027466,
-0.49929434061050415,
0.5104756951332092,
0.14047843217849731,
-0.19366909563541412,
-0.1501583606004715,
-0.6423114538192749,
-0.6574657559394836,
0.9638005495071411,
0.2449074238538742,
0.5466340184211731,
0.037279434502124786,
0.4480244815349579,
0.33649301528930664,
0.045527949929237366,
-0.5735980272293091,
0.20499522984027863,
-0.505509078502655,
-0.6143388748168945,
-0.2953263521194458,
-0.40657004714012146,
-1.0544016361236572,
0.21071180701255798,
-0.3114995062351227,
-0.2833167314529419,
-0.15431368350982666,
0.0015853599179536104,
-0.31798428297042847,
0.24965976178646088,
-0.5470356345176697,
0.9314284324645996,
-0.2812155485153198,
-0.34512630105018616,
-0.5706812143325806,
-0.38731658458709717,
-0.041212063282728195,
-0.4424019157886505,
0.3336934745311737,
-0.11045683920383453,
0.12481150031089783,
0.4724879860877991,
0.1915103793144226,
0.57122403383255,
0.25416484475135803,
0.023751497268676758,
0.025252418592572212,
0.557776153087616,
0.22937798500061035,
-0.2553250789642334,
-0.4085126519203186,
0.3187943696975708,
0.2001871019601822,
-0.41130125522613525,
-0.2956176698207855,
0.9177866578102112,
-0.9078242778778076,
-0.35786283016204834,
-0.19152161478996277,
-0.5909010767936707,
-0.30204811692237854,
0.18899331986904144,
0.3422294855117798,
-0.10969839245080948,
-0.33410221338272095,
0.18127930164337158,
0.5860475301742554,
-0.23268964886665344,
0.29342082142829895,
0.54579758644104,
-0.23823830485343933,
0.1076882854104042,
0.8670024275779724,
0.16331997513771057,
0.5094307065010071,
0.42158448696136475,
0.09999658167362213,
-0.05346141383051872,
-0.6440386176109314,
-0.544434666633606,
0.17776916921138763,
-0.2200963795185089,
-0.3351496756076813,
-0.4332720935344696,
-0.03967829793691635,
-0.2646244168281555,
-0.15739308297634125,
-0.5864217281341553,
-0.3686043918132782,
-0.3885706961154938,
0.10619325190782547,
0.2930034101009369,
0.742404043674469,
0.0067751482129096985,
0.18495894968509674,
-0.8670641183853149,
0.26119405031204224,
-0.01622217334806919,
0.4513454735279083,
-0.09302844852209091,
-0.7759038805961609,
-0.8322811722755432,
-0.08496313542127609,
-0.4147339463233948,
-0.45157310366630554,
0.6255962252616882,
0.2534736096858978,
0.3631860017776489,
0.14537313580513,
-0.08359426259994507,
0.5605570673942566,
-0.757996141910553,
0.7846775054931641,
-0.019855815917253494,
-0.764503002166748,
0.4737803339958191,
-0.12591609358787537,
0.02993302047252655,
0.40704673528671265,
0.6309426426887512,
-0.4869369864463806,
-0.37998896837234497,
-0.4164056181907654,
-0.496299684047699,
0.6209536790847778,
0.10673176497220993,
-0.022967470809817314,
0.1245424821972847,
0.22143866121768951,
0.2989204227924347,
-0.009938491508364677,
-0.517040491104126,
-0.2161381095647812,
0.4209703207015991,
0.03201720118522644,
-0.5846964120864868,
-0.12221258133649826,
0.1434561312198639,
-0.09327518939971924,
0.549787163734436,
-0.23700901865959167,
0.11996709555387497,
-0.21746280789375305,
-0.15371809899806976,
-0.5958283543586731,
0.3122551143169403,
0.7421156764030457,
0.5011954307556152,
-0.36951491236686707,
0.0442185215651989,
0.37316232919692993,
-0.146658793091774,
0.013510599732398987,
-0.057329270988702774,
-0.12120125442743301,
0.1292930692434311,
0.6193989515304565,
0.8990362286567688,
0.14172622561454773,
-0.5657483339309692,
0.09796739369630814,
0.12138216942548752,
-0.0642806887626648,
-0.001865697093307972,
0.03973520174622536,
0.02025752142071724,
0.1331087350845337,
0.04911040514707565,
0.33127734065055847,
0.03742958605289459,
-0.6358251571655273,
0.05671660974621773,
0.3024095594882965,
-0.6220459938049316,
-0.37833893299102783,
0.5722876191139221,
0.02332877740263939,
-0.491289347410202,
0.566473126411438,
-0.04425780102610588,
-0.6799299716949463,
0.5622810125350952,
0.4963862895965576,
0.7045692801475525,
-0.3524491786956787,
0.012968222610652447,
0.42740321159362793,
0.43932947516441345,
-0.3116799592971802,
0.008306014351546764,
0.4865173101425171,
-0.38281726837158203,
-0.7242223620414734,
-0.8636123538017273,
-0.3364966809749603,
0.24641409516334534,
-0.7289564609527588,
0.209988534450531,
-0.028036465868353844,
-0.4721519947052002,
0.013989555649459362,
0.33358389139175415,
-1.0980066061019897,
0.17220965027809143,
0.3044791519641876,
0.9143209457397461,
-0.9431352019309998,
1.0096434354782104,
0.5021741390228271,
-0.3809601664543152,
-0.3852691650390625,
-0.14854851365089417,
-0.1713087558746338,
-0.6852750778198242,
1.172463297843933,
-0.0956001952290535,
-0.28252846002578735,
-0.27153635025024414,
-0.07708690315485,
-1.0353033542633057,
0.62088543176651,
0.4082721173763275,
-0.4942653179168701,
-0.05811955779790878,
0.4903000295162201,
0.798254668712616,
-0.43624362349510193,
-0.13728511333465576,
0.6380934119224548,
0.33144956827163696,
-0.6005121469497681,
-1.517795443534851,
-0.08561135083436966,
0.137535959482193,
0.2873843014240265,
0.30107662081718445,
-0.4881298243999481,
0.9684018492698669,
-0.30725204944610596,
-0.10430684685707092,
0.04448578134179115,
0.36263611912727356,
-0.13107651472091675,
0.16094166040420532,
0.3256933391094208,
0.28021103143692017,
0.6134998202323914,
-0.024573806673288345,
1.300728678703308,
-0.5974112153053284,
0.3755969703197479,
1.0068168640136719,
-0.37750300765037537,
1.2271268367767334,
0.6329631805419922,
-0.27123913168907166,
0.27450913190841675,
0.5703863501548767,
-0.02591642737388611,
0.6786101460456848,
0.2833866477012634,
0.24482767283916473,
-0.24411769211292267,
-0.21859411895275116,
-0.4120412766933441,
0.49422693252563477,
0.2928663194179535,
-0.7015832662582397,
0.19536836445331573,
0.030258890241384506,
-0.3155991733074188,
0.2602890133857727,
-0.2924349009990692,
0.7285361886024475,
0.09438708424568176,
-0.8153463006019592,
0.9491748213768005,
0.294796347618103,
0.5793687701225281,
-0.2852439284324646,
0.16856110095977783,
-0.1470813751220703,
0.47873353958129883,
0.1194787323474884,
-0.6141559481620789,
0.5335423946380615,
-0.03878052532672882,
-0.57098788022995,
-0.42350295186042786,
0.5703364014625549,
-0.29626157879829407,
-0.5678097605705261,
0.853299081325531,
0.9072381854057312,
0.002213873667642474,
-0.15445934236049652,
-0.8448331952095032,
0.2237510234117508,
0.016737595200538635,
-0.19056375324726105,
0.7525850534439087,
0.4955400228500366,
-0.08373352140188217,
0.7847921252250671,
0.5207313299179077,
0.37816277146339417,
-0.07191216200590134,
-0.15032410621643066,
0.43023592233657837,
-0.6840123534202576,
-0.1028989925980568,
-0.8274046778678894,
-0.10508904606103897,
0.2478230893611908,
-0.260979562997818,
0.5640449523925781,
0.6465508937835693,
1.0780088901519775,
-0.38852792978286743,
0.7160961627960205,
0.37776947021484375,
0.8191584348678589,
-0.4409101605415344,
0.6155076622962952,
-0.7536490559577942,
-0.028521887958049774,
-0.23579034209251404,
-0.9260138869285583,
-0.19724339246749878,
0.4584507942199707,
-0.16680927574634552,
-0.1839410811662674,
0.8260865211486816,
0.7798078656196594,
-0.1633538454771042,
-0.16271308064460754,
0.6229616403579712,
0.17437447607517242,
-0.09596265852451324,
0.5670720338821411,
0.5155834555625916,
-0.5420734286308289,
0.6196996569633484,
-0.3464895188808441,
0.1350087821483612,
-0.5323405265808105,
-0.8383613228797913,
-0.7812535762786865,
-0.735757052898407,
-0.2895079255104065,
-0.44151291251182556,
0.044747792184352875,
0.8929605484008789,
0.6149150133132935,
-1.1650761365890503,
-0.4638878405094147,
0.2593216896057129,
0.14733649790287018,
-0.5760746598243713,
-0.1815473586320877,
0.3873225450515747,
-0.5205352902412415,
-0.9023619294166565,
0.29927220940589905,
0.07770387083292007,
0.02125832810997963,
-0.20566697418689728,
-0.12865233421325684,
-0.013247420080006123,
-0.187019482254982,
0.7582189440727234,
0.11559373885393143,
-1.032238245010376,
-0.04503418505191803,
0.2698129415512085,
-0.53770911693573,
-0.12529157102108002,
0.844338059425354,
-0.6050940752029419,
0.042358722537755966,
0.3295828402042389,
0.7829189896583557,
0.2954677641391754,
-0.16053998470306396,
0.7706475853919983,
-0.6243281364440918,
0.007890801876783371,
0.10091960430145264,
0.2445712834596634,
0.4060631990432739,
-0.2932884991168976,
0.7715861201286316,
0.07124916464090347,
-0.7092761397361755,
-0.6781612634658813,
0.16533558070659637,
-0.6509367823600769,
-0.41445183753967285,
1.1532124280929565,
-0.02087721787393093,
-0.11039078235626221,
-0.19896036386489868,
-0.0467853844165802,
0.20839720964431763,
-0.1507708728313446,
0.679344117641449,
0.7867435216903687,
-0.08608750998973846,
-0.04321007803082466,
-1.1005308628082275,
0.9592949151992798,
0.4868060052394867,
-0.21055833995342255,
0.35319972038269043,
0.23407183587551117,
0.20946571230888367,
0.39836397767066956,
0.18815667927265167,
0.16684487462043762,
0.0011541430139914155,
-0.20880335569381714,
-0.10454139113426208,
0.2898416817188263,
-0.15757039189338684,
-0.24522265791893005,
0.13879427313804626,
0.3855125904083252,
0.12769056856632233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02632v2 | GIRT-Model: Automated Generation of Issue Report Templates | 2024-02-04T22:53:38 | 2024-02-08T14:24:40 | Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Abbas Heydarnoori | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Platforms such as GitHub and GitLab introduce Issue Report Templates (IRTs)
to enable more effective issue management and better alignment with developer
expectations. However, these templates are not widely adopted in most
repositories, and there is currently no tool available to aid developers in
generating them. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Model, an assistant language
model that automatically generates IRTs based on the developer's instructions
regarding the structure and necessary fields. We create GIRT-Instruct, a
dataset comprising pairs of instructions and IRTs, with the IRTs sourced from
GitHub repositories. We use GIRT-Instruct to instruction-tune a T5-base model
to create the GIRT-Model. In our experiments, GIRT-Model outperforms general
language models (T5 and Flan-T5 with different parameter sizes) in IRT
generation by achieving significantly higher scores in ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR, and
human evaluation. Additionally, we analyze the effectiveness of GIRT-Model in a
user study in which participants wrote short IRTs with GIRT-Model. Our results
show that the participants find GIRT-Model useful in the automated generation
of templates. We hope that through the use of GIRT-Model, we can encourage more
developers to adopt IRTs in their repositories. We publicly release our code,
dataset, and model at https://github.com/ISE-Research/girt-model. | [
-0.27724775671958923,
-0.5463941693305969,
0.24800236523151398,
-0.00821403693407774,
-0.2128169685602188,
0.15845851600170135,
-0.015631448477506638,
-0.3537778854370117,
0.36252284049987793,
0.4403901696205139,
-0.22222355008125305,
-0.6106715798377991,
-0.38724610209465027,
0.022400103509426117,
-0.6881553530693054,
1.4474748373031616,
-0.06087955832481384,
0.011067970655858517,
0.07093750685453415,
0.032437678426504135,
-0.7734535932540894,
-0.18739581108093262,
-0.13721230626106262,
-0.042674921452999115,
0.32361942529678345,
0.923256516456604,
0.4988984763622284,
0.7302107214927673,
0.908278226852417,
0.2437775433063507,
0.30460265278816223,
-0.14669713377952576,
-0.25507065653800964,
0.1867823749780655,
-0.04146179184317589,
-0.1679360568523407,
-0.7003412246704102,
0.047847189009189606,
0.008905937895178795,
0.2083047330379486,
-0.38696199655532837,
0.4497069716453552,
-0.05185128003358841,
0.6775224208831787,
-0.4888778030872345,
0.18739397823810577,
-0.48784691095352173,
-0.2341344952583313,
-0.06779278814792633,
-0.1912582963705063,
-0.5520753860473633,
-0.5269582867622375,
0.231601744890213,
-0.4022883474826813,
0.37951064109802246,
-0.11392076313495636,
0.8439710140228271,
-0.2554079294204712,
-0.3248005509376526,
-0.7898291945457458,
-0.6840940117835999,
0.1202486976981163,
-0.519668698310852,
0.17712275683879852,
0.14785204827785492,
0.4179239571094513,
-0.1256113052368164,
-0.7586275339126587,
-0.17089378833770752,
-0.5889925956726074,
-0.24295583367347717,
0.12617561221122742,
-0.2660852372646332,
-0.14266343414783478,
-0.019818799570202827,
0.17165923118591309,
-0.8745520114898682,
-0.2428475171327591,
-0.6344291567802429,
0.21920554339885712,
0.5704517960548401,
0.3045414984226227,
0.3542364537715912,
-0.5950661301612854,
-0.29952502250671387,
-0.10215067863464355,
-0.5989567637443542,
-0.29304543137550354,
0.33537712693214417,
0.20122739672660828,
-0.23078835010528564,
0.6565085053443909,
0.01322183944284916,
0.48602575063705444,
0.21634908020496368,
0.0950361043214798,
-0.03223266452550888,
-0.24916982650756836,
-0.02413560077548027,
-0.18424734473228455,
0.5730624198913574,
0.17835380136966705,
0.3318990170955658,
-0.2268683761358261,
-0.5525103807449341,
0.0188590195029974,
0.5754213333129883,
-0.641518771648407,
-0.7720783352851868,
0.15910959243774414,
-0.18188215792179108,
-0.5192963480949402,
0.4046535789966583,
-0.6981077790260315,
-0.4520065486431122,
-0.2674291729927063,
0.20660696923732758,
-0.6038875579833984,
-0.5897183418273926,
-0.25836658477783203,
-0.09006519615650177,
0.017461156472563744,
0.3905463218688965,
-0.5357208847999573,
0.24553167819976807,
0.4427415430545807,
0.721394419670105,
0.09257511794567108,
-0.24156852066516876,
-0.6492699384689331,
0.28925275802612305,
-0.3649919927120209,
1.014505386352539,
-0.5216522216796875,
-0.525788426399231,
-0.1576969176530838,
-0.23028427362442017,
0.061315812170505524,
-0.3615074157714844,
-0.07497257739305496,
-0.3752810060977936,
0.24232082068920135,
0.1733800321817398,
-0.5432286858558655,
0.030876874923706055,
0.29359355568885803,
-0.5343397855758667,
0.6855168342590332,
0.5662606954574585,
-0.7864303588867188,
0.07154640555381775,
-1.2092266082763672,
-0.17795564234256744,
0.3587130308151245,
-0.13885515928268433,
-0.6043989062309265,
0.06336333602666855,
0.018427930772304535,
0.08520093560218811,
-0.5765186548233032,
0.5028529763221741,
0.0214214026927948,
-0.0689900666475296,
0.25886768102645874,
0.12900196015834808,
0.5345249772071838,
0.2832668721675873,
-0.47235146164894104,
0.1470562219619751,
-0.46573948860168457,
0.07283864170312881,
0.3237176835536957,
-0.09879612177610397,
-0.2514289915561676,
-0.16265615820884705,
0.09239056706428528,
-0.11164665967226028,
0.06214500591158867,
-0.06891268491744995,
0.4420977532863617,
0.08183926343917847,
0.4260818660259247,
0.5990816950798035,
0.12631148099899292,
0.5405985116958618,
-0.2769743502140045,
1.015942931175232,
0.04870835691690445,
0.22360393404960632,
-0.5301594138145447,
-0.3017899990081787,
-0.7695448398590088,
-0.24332313239574432,
0.7922207713127136,
0.7137873768806458,
-0.3568888008594513,
0.23093917965888977,
-0.4145476222038269,
-0.7847410440444946,
-0.3829399049282074,
0.06831635534763336,
0.4609779119491577,
0.5625032782554626,
0.09151359647512436,
-0.4014005959033966,
-0.5238577723503113,
-0.829172670841217,
-0.19062913954257965,
-0.5002461671829224,
0.016863545402884483,
0.0426245741546154,
0.7117375135421753,
-0.2250189632177353,
1.0757193565368652,
-0.6145841479301453,
-0.028402384370565414,
-0.2069505900144577,
0.7551206946372986,
-0.34727710485458374,
0.43685203790664673,
0.6805413365364075,
-0.6973798871040344,
-0.6224831938743591,
0.0243074893951416,
-0.5981008410453796,
-0.3598769009113312,
0.15941563248634338,
-0.06472285836935043,
0.2652171850204468,
0.2575390636920929,
-0.4781491756439209,
0.4696744978427887,
0.33981478214263916,
-0.5297667980194092,
0.5025548338890076,
-0.18987664580345154,
0.3382848799228668,
-1.1775165796279907,
0.31624293327331543,
0.24432158470153809,
-0.3200685381889343,
-0.5841134786605835,
0.2682654559612274,
0.3187117278575897,
-0.45437827706336975,
-0.16416248679161072,
0.4258406162261963,
-0.6329702138900757,
-0.11468083411455154,
-0.035689227283000946,
0.034968841820955276,
0.26056715846061707,
0.24071456491947174,
-0.2567215859889984,
0.7789129614830017,
0.16282010078430176,
-0.29171547293663025,
0.1374024748802185,
0.018219374120235443,
-0.13082654774188995,
0.35283994674682617,
-0.7177926898002625,
0.4615822434425354,
0.02350773476064205,
-0.011353778652846813,
-0.9617226719856262,
-0.5134359002113342,
0.4475691318511963,
-0.48769012093544006,
0.35997164249420166,
-0.6306069493293762,
-0.5866166949272156,
-0.3997765779495239,
-0.13528798520565033,
-0.13442185521125793,
0.5735131502151489,
-0.04536249116063118,
0.5601310133934021,
0.5508171916007996,
-0.46951019763946533,
-0.11662699282169342,
-0.5290125012397766,
0.03606628626585007,
-0.4928966760635376,
-0.6618761420249939,
-0.0967293381690979,
-0.0860588327050209,
-0.31003814935684204,
0.14355748891830444,
0.30403465032577515,
-0.23825395107269287,
0.026174871250987053,
0.24375487864017487,
0.29735371470451355,
-0.42042428255081177,
0.2724599838256836,
-0.2717529237270355,
-0.2044774740934372,
-0.0524747297167778,
-0.25690680742263794,
0.24101796746253967,
-0.4090650975704193,
-0.5978676676750183,
-0.09566083550453186,
0.6350312232971191,
0.7287953495979309,
-0.5551213622093201,
0.39003461599349976,
0.09420759230852127,
-0.09962537884712219,
0.034091975539922714,
-0.5540290474891663,
-0.11641576141119003,
-0.44084852933883667,
0.3202645182609558,
-0.2267361581325531,
-0.32296088337898254,
0.6422117948532104,
-0.07109512388706207,
0.07051608711481094,
0.3064514100551605,
0.4772593080997467,
-0.1131073385477066,
0.8839683532714844,
0.6918061375617981,
0.03716593235731125,
0.7464320063591003,
-0.3796718120574951,
0.15561042726039886,
-0.3083844780921936,
0.16173911094665527,
-0.7154667973518372,
0.06761091202497482,
-0.5177940130233765,
-0.20803268253803253,
0.6533569693565369,
0.2198285162448883,
-0.33259129524230957,
0.3085795044898987,
-0.9024462103843689,
0.5587596893310547,
0.43700799345970154,
-0.1605222523212433,
0.253017783164978,
-0.025792952626943588,
0.29315224289894104,
0.030986012890934944,
-0.6734742522239685,
-0.7906878590583801,
0.9468075633049011,
0.2621593773365021,
0.8313054442405701,
0.20116053521633148,
0.8244253993034363,
0.5324091911315918,
0.7822498679161072,
-0.39647433161735535,
0.22054079174995422,
0.024738987907767296,
-0.4606926739215851,
-0.23457929491996765,
-0.1616262048482895,
-0.7919533848762512,
-0.10543382167816162,
0.2244863063097,
-0.5026946663856506,
-0.14382503926753998,
0.5124285817146301,
0.01015809178352356,
-0.1402631253004074,
-1.4550474882125854,
0.9297409653663635,
-0.2200440615415573,
0.13845893740653992,
0.061735112220048904,
-0.3736472427845001,
0.31630775332450867,
0.01472411584109068,
0.20500418543815613,
0.06021701917052269,
0.2367040365934372,
0.576729953289032,
-0.4620647728443146,
0.7326509356498718,
-0.3030130863189697,
0.04967698082327843,
0.6985150575637817,
0.3733898401260376,
0.8904628157615662,
0.27753278613090515,
-0.09225209057331085,
-0.23242099583148956,
-0.20905166864395142,
-0.1335151642560959,
-0.6201257705688477,
0.3632607161998749,
-0.6191482543945312,
-0.6865633726119995,
-0.22617368400096893,
-0.5001288652420044,
0.26190027594566345,
0.20803949236869812,
0.36422884464263916,
0.46457338333129883,
-0.27234020829200745,
-0.0846048966050148,
0.2523212432861328,
0.011722492054104805,
0.07648678123950958,
0.9710043668746948,
-0.3139774799346924,
-0.35171085596084595,
0.8108728528022766,
0.4423885643482208,
0.1867765635251999,
-0.0017800141358748078,
0.23801648616790771,
0.17190682888031006,
-0.5592336654663086,
-0.6015112400054932,
-0.013476141728460789,
-0.7150751948356628,
-0.6966921091079712,
-0.5060164332389832,
-0.39925485849380493,
-0.3655412793159485,
-0.3033892810344696,
-0.3908526599407196,
-0.4101387560367584,
-0.09089832007884979,
-0.06926529854536057,
0.9342421889305115,
1.1047438383102417,
-0.01687885820865631,
0.27076393365859985,
-0.9324906468391418,
0.3983086049556732,
0.04614473506808281,
0.22216255962848663,
-0.13067607581615448,
-0.38604557514190674,
-0.5378477573394775,
0.14374372363090515,
-0.6219576001167297,
-1.0657514333724976,
0.5412150621414185,
-0.23496274650096893,
0.2039112001657486,
-0.08754577487707138,
0.1691698580980301,
0.6096790432929993,
-0.47284650802612305,
0.4880468249320984,
0.14054496586322784,
-1.037927269935608,
0.9885582327842712,
-0.8307788968086243,
0.42147552967071533,
0.420798659324646,
-0.10015778988599777,
-0.4093317985534668,
-1.1836339235305786,
-0.8097651600837708,
-0.8348832130432129,
0.6870062351226807,
0.3035481870174408,
-0.020305026322603226,
-0.1360122561454773,
0.1718132346868515,
0.07915376126766205,
0.11461436748504639,
-0.6963682174682617,
-0.023666413500905037,
-0.3105512857437134,
-0.2422250211238861,
0.4719352126121521,
-0.27407991886138916,
-0.23880265653133392,
-0.03261670097708702,
0.40998825430870056,
-0.19059769809246063,
0.4505678713321686,
0.07711870968341827,
-0.29444724321365356,
-0.46896806359291077,
0.3843487799167633,
0.7631192803382874,
0.9208381772041321,
-0.26340338587760925,
-0.18786026537418365,
-0.24417534470558167,
-0.5155677199363708,
0.05271531268954277,
0.20224498212337494,
-0.12103502452373505,
0.26928749680519104,
0.3455369472503662,
0.5010364651679993,
-0.06737973541021347,
-0.43241050839424133,
0.5913441777229309,
-0.21676813066005707,
-0.10505323112010956,
-0.5850450992584229,
0.1338275969028473,
0.33636724948883057,
0.23060761392116547,
0.41704025864601135,
-0.16705046594142914,
0.12201564759016037,
-0.19669675827026367,
0.19365555047988892,
0.135297030210495,
-0.1429230272769928,
-0.4197884202003479,
0.5088294744491577,
0.3974933624267578,
-0.6666714549064636,
0.7000389695167542,
-0.3572596311569214,
-0.3184424936771393,
1.0038188695907593,
0.4339478611946106,
0.9311622381210327,
-0.32364651560783386,
0.39493829011917114,
0.09124461561441422,
0.3599260747432709,
0.15720729529857635,
0.3313271999359131,
0.4112395644187927,
-0.16608089208602905,
-0.07247281819581985,
-0.057820335030555725,
-0.46295076608657837,
0.12952619791030884,
-0.7754132747650146,
0.5846142172813416,
-0.1183813139796257,
-0.08868193626403809,
0.05386127531528473,
-0.07775966078042984,
-0.6404238939285278,
-0.06468242406845093,
-0.18536846339702606,
0.8125399351119995,
-0.7745823264122009,
0.8618201613426208,
0.9579120874404907,
-0.6904057860374451,
-1.0853736400604248,
-0.010082988999783993,
-0.09234532713890076,
-0.27644991874694824,
0.6449491381645203,
-0.034078069031238556,
0.08436071872711182,
-0.12486075609922409,
-0.6515372395515442,
-0.6308897733688354,
1.243155598640442,
0.7084375023841858,
-0.46803218126296997,
-0.11310530453920364,
0.06488197296857834,
0.5804266929626465,
-0.7061450481414795,
0.4884757399559021,
0.24680176377296448,
0.5071688890457153,
-0.23556005954742432,
-0.8686146140098572,
-0.26905688643455505,
-0.5656331777572632,
0.04668877273797989,
0.4671613574028015,
-0.44145649671554565,
0.8223246335983276,
-0.27815452218055725,
0.003275878494605422,
-0.02510140836238861,
0.5284359455108643,
0.3722052276134491,
0.2840690612792969,
0.47103914618492126,
0.018119320273399353,
0.6575002670288086,
0.1591993123292923,
1.13800847530365,
-0.5774739384651184,
0.4533837139606476,
1.2260935306549072,
-0.12574513256549835,
0.40787097811698914,
0.3167452812194824,
0.26518043875694275,
0.6520147323608398,
0.331928014755249,
-0.14952942728996277,
0.483949214220047,
0.1474849283695221,
0.33709293603897095,
0.11932624131441116,
-0.04290779307484627,
-0.5768953561782837,
0.4142093062400818,
0.32363590598106384,
-0.5401833653450012,
-0.20350795984268188,
-0.05652638152241707,
0.06478308141231537,
0.0038935840129852295,
0.07878768444061279,
0.7756461501121521,
-0.10572996735572815,
-0.6242997050285339,
0.4929373860359192,
0.10998320579528809,
0.029185116291046143,
-0.7454294562339783,
-0.26972198486328125,
-0.4762575626373291,
0.004253416787832975,
0.1079716831445694,
-0.6090368628501892,
0.3601093590259552,
0.5546175837516785,
-0.4092003107070923,
-0.05921923741698265,
0.6172270178794861,
-0.3213447332382202,
-0.6149924993515015,
0.19677762687206268,
0.6752007603645325,
-0.07839784771203995,
0.35624808073043823,
-0.6490862965583801,
-0.20202215015888214,
-0.010035298764705658,
-0.6417731642723083,
0.319167822599411,
0.7535451054573059,
-0.27314960956573486,
0.6591870784759521,
0.0921623632311821,
-0.01850610040128231,
-0.05775939300656319,
0.03258686140179634,
0.9707074165344238,
-0.5907795429229736,
-0.6971835494041443,
-0.562639594078064,
1.0220986604690552,
0.046538788825273514,
-0.3027624785900116,
0.4582728147506714,
0.5177009105682373,
0.38259512186050415,
-0.25623369216918945,
0.9418590664863586,
-0.3322596549987793,
0.6684154868125916,
-0.37509992718696594,
0.7018001675605774,
-0.4477258026599884,
0.4504581689834595,
-0.4279068410396576,
-0.5460853576660156,
-0.19159966707229614,
0.2456853985786438,
-0.3522520363330841,
0.05534887686371803,
0.562410295009613,
0.9347832798957825,
-0.2990231215953827,
-0.02940976433455944,
-0.06572748720645905,
-0.05939305201172829,
0.49106189608573914,
0.23528093099594116,
0.7873157858848572,
-0.4211867153644562,
0.8204566836357117,
-0.09856697916984558,
0.05734945461153984,
-0.37134575843811035,
-0.8775746822357178,
-0.7027730345726013,
-0.6864505410194397,
-0.5013967752456665,
-0.355421245098114,
0.4195268154144287,
0.7983531951904297,
0.6556650996208191,
-0.8059362769126892,
-0.35325631499290466,
-0.31456324458122253,
0.14815354347229004,
0.17541781067848206,
-0.3214638829231262,
0.2891818583011627,
-0.24157512187957764,
-0.46803373098373413,
-0.024362964555621147,
0.15746788680553436,
0.30373650789260864,
-0.17623966932296753,
-0.0691903755068779,
-0.1295015513896942,
-0.1980941742658615,
0.0838879719376564,
0.20798975229263306,
-0.47250896692276,
-0.4535350203514099,
0.11835223436355591,
-0.6385661363601685,
0.36228522658348083,
1.0682214498519897,
-0.4871053099632263,
0.33487188816070557,
0.4253822863101959,
0.15839329361915588,
0.09439779072999954,
0.03521453216671944,
1.074025273323059,
-0.6397224068641663,
0.1145281195640564,
0.234097421169281,
0.22025048732757568,
0.34288638830184937,
-0.5213783383369446,
0.9557115435600281,
-0.26020434498786926,
-0.5243460536003113,
-1.022836446762085,
0.07756452262401581,
-0.37059369683265686,
-0.2104014754295349,
0.9546403288841248,
-0.19516156613826752,
0.04416653886437416,
-0.009347205050289631,
-0.09340518712997437,
0.44569817185401917,
-0.6823226809501648,
0.9575615525245667,
0.45392099022865295,
0.022649003192782402,
-0.4207317531108856,
-0.5804544687271118,
0.19679108262062073,
0.08361183851957321,
-0.9560357332229614,
0.2324056327342987,
0.4810565114021301,
0.3728630840778351,
0.2758832573890686,
0.7451407313346863,
0.05479728803038597,
0.579579770565033,
0.09318863600492477,
0.3816778361797333,
-0.15776607394218445,
-0.43341949582099915,
-0.06895817816257477,
0.19746097922325134,
0.4070330858230591,
-0.02543417550623417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03396v1 | UniTSyn: A Large-Scale Dataset Capable of Enhancing the Prowess of Large Language Models for Program Testing | 2024-02-04T22:48:05 | 2024-02-04T22:48:05 | Yifeng He, Jiabo Huang, Yuyang Rong, Yiwen Guo, Ethan Wang, Hao Chen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | The remarkable capability of large language models (LLMs) in generating
high-quality code has drawn increasing attention in the software testing
community. However, existing code LLMs often demonstrate unsatisfactory
capabilities in generating accurate and complete tests since they were trained
on code snippets collected without differentiating between code for testing
purposes and other code. In this paper, we present a large-scale dataset
UniTSyn, which is capable of enhancing the prowess of LLMs for Unit Test
Synthesis. Associating tests with the tested functions is crucial for LLMs to
infer the expected behavior and the logic paths to be verified. By leveraging
Language Server Protocol, UniTSyn achieves the challenging goal of collecting
focal-test pairs without per-project execution setups or per-language
heuristics that tend to be fragile and difficult to scale. It contains 2.7
million focal-test pairs across five mainstream programming languages, making
it possible to be utilized for enhancing the test generation ability of LLMs.
The details of UniTSyn can be found in Table 1. Our experiments demonstrate
that, by building an autoregressive model based on UniTSyn, we can achieve
significant benefits in learning and understanding unit test representations,
resulting in improved generation accuracy and code coverage across all
evaluated programming languages. Code and data will be publicly available. | [
-0.28988972306251526,
-0.44597697257995605,
0.382201611995697,
0.20499001443386078,
0.1604497879743576,
0.0626760721206665,
-0.2894440293312073,
-0.008635244332253933,
0.2094084918498993,
0.5156127214431763,
-0.31370460987091064,
-0.319703608751297,
0.027102896943688393,
-0.046815626323223114,
-0.4895511269569397,
0.8457432389259338,
-0.18035347759723663,
-0.012767888605594635,
-0.33998745679855347,
0.025679247453808784,
-0.14171677827835083,
-0.4148869812488556,
-0.06081265211105347,
-0.15100957453250885,
0.31200647354125977,
0.7574167847633362,
0.42007699608802795,
0.45091506838798523,
0.5464150309562683,
0.255720853805542,
0.4851152300834656,
0.09858689457178116,
-0.4936034381389618,
0.5834274888038635,
0.03020576201379299,
-0.3215883672237396,
-0.5492596626281738,
-0.06666222214698792,
0.9621530771255493,
0.8049888014793396,
-0.09735365957021713,
0.56141197681427,
-0.0832124575972557,
0.5117279887199402,
-0.4043378233909607,
0.08377029746770859,
-0.8638678789138794,
-0.036635175347328186,
-0.04378635808825493,
-0.026058828458189964,
-0.6084670424461365,
-0.23407326638698578,
-0.4748900830745697,
-0.321338415145874,
0.20205344259738922,
-0.025112798437476158,
0.7948260307312012,
0.13122978806495667,
-0.3881431221961975,
-0.025282172486186028,
-0.4663461446762085,
0.6746585965156555,
-0.6019064784049988,
0.7217139005661011,
0.19619208574295044,
0.26570412516593933,
-0.21000562608242035,
-0.49622640013694763,
-0.3642289340496063,
-0.5155163407325745,
0.1424940824508667,
-0.16293811798095703,
0.21496839821338654,
-0.018300671130418777,
0.6058118939399719,
0.22173194587230682,
-0.7427113652229309,
0.027972465381026268,
-0.2050795704126358,
-0.1235668882727623,
0.9931608438491821,
0.2042447179555893,
0.24044044315814972,
-0.36250293254852295,
-0.28242045640945435,
0.04351871833205223,
-1.02518892288208,
-0.05229119583964348,
0.12777963280677795,
0.3309682309627533,
0.19695396721363068,
0.6597526669502258,
-0.40893301367759705,
0.5813629627227783,
-0.48115700483322144,
-0.26232972741127014,
0.17151564359664917,
-0.10876655578613281,
-0.5748066306114197,
-0.22879429161548615,
0.7230255603790283,
0.32434120774269104,
-0.009360047988593578,
-0.15763063728809357,
-0.3232330083847046,
0.25584062933921814,
0.19263237714767456,
-1.2151377201080322,
-0.49915456771850586,
0.15029148757457733,
-0.2600246071815491,
-0.5127451419830322,
-0.08757573366165161,
-0.651579737663269,
-0.1988290250301361,
-0.5397958755493164,
0.1424950361251831,
-0.35544198751449585,
-0.325412780046463,
-0.1331249475479126,
0.34688878059387207,
0.04004606232047081,
-0.0758465901017189,
-0.7665547132492065,
0.2172444462776184,
0.6834442019462585,
0.42177554965019226,
-0.18869879841804504,
-0.5877909064292908,
-0.6933760643005371,
-0.19645990431308746,
-0.7117812633514404,
0.245025634765625,
-0.18738622963428497,
-0.33130699396133423,
-0.36902526021003723,
0.13506734371185303,
0.02749638259410858,
-0.2571676969528198,
-0.3129597306251526,
-0.5112361311912537,
-0.37759023904800415,
-0.2568972110748291,
-0.7502215504646301,
0.5108700394630432,
0.23171468079090118,
-0.15917257964611053,
1.1835544109344482,
0.23823171854019165,
-0.25975027680397034,
0.02922196500003338,
-0.34459277987480164,
-0.4029245376586914,
0.38679325580596924,
-0.7596226334571838,
-0.3597402274608612,
0.11682751029729843,
-0.1941993683576584,
0.5852627754211426,
-0.32961609959602356,
0.47440019249916077,
-0.3028396964073181,
-0.28548502922058105,
0.48725229501724243,
-0.3241649866104126,
0.5150877833366394,
0.24219658970832825,
-0.43158096075057983,
-0.03145113214850426,
-0.7932428121566772,
0.40431493520736694,
0.10182151943445206,
-0.23692965507507324,
-0.24253998696804047,
-0.22049099206924438,
-0.08255723118782043,
-0.015864798799157143,
-0.000004557619377010269,
-0.5634946823120117,
0.4412207007408142,
-0.02319488674402237,
0.3695180118083954,
0.6839113235473633,
-0.1059226468205452,
0.473280131816864,
0.0011214225087314844,
0.6457653641700745,
-0.504199206829071,
0.3545092046260834,
-0.35260072350502014,
-0.4287736713886261,
-0.8078957200050354,
-0.13964274525642395,
0.23159852623939514,
0.2073393613100052,
-0.6206161379814148,
0.446968674659729,
-0.32850542664527893,
-0.6268782615661621,
-0.35061201453208923,
0.32540637254714966,
0.5172795057296753,
0.4848768711090088,
-0.03880228102207184,
-0.23933985829353333,
-0.6584969758987427,
-0.6006894111633301,
0.27175819873809814,
-0.414562851190567,
-0.09808570891618729,
0.26434311270713806,
0.5931475758552551,
-0.3073459565639496,
0.6924047470092773,
-0.7192438840866089,
0.18711020052433014,
-0.19015242159366608,
-0.22850583493709564,
0.051369890570640564,
0.4552750885486603,
0.22146888077259064,
-0.3751601278781891,
-0.3333805799484253,
-0.09685683995485306,
-0.580463707447052,
-0.3318389654159546,
-0.1386268138885498,
-0.300413578748703,
0.3189930319786072,
0.8343026041984558,
-0.35453104972839355,
0.08143479377031326,
0.8430435657501221,
-0.4567510187625885,
0.7976949214935303,
-0.12974750995635986,
0.12159542739391327,
-1.056016445159912,
0.18249589204788208,
-0.5068243741989136,
-0.3222757875919342,
-0.37477755546569824,
0.6067966222763062,
0.49357953667640686,
-0.4492590129375458,
-0.08823122829198837,
0.28225505352020264,
-0.3984948992729187,
-0.5066487789154053,
-0.17445649206638336,
-0.13410766422748566,
0.2948320806026459,
0.04889987036585808,
-0.16777363419532776,
0.9400244951248169,
0.44388362765312195,
-0.3715628385543823,
0.33342087268829346,
-0.00860671978443861,
-0.24226246774196625,
0.41534560918807983,
-0.503056526184082,
0.015384027734398842,
0.1410738229751587,
0.0011435499181970954,
-1.0349644422531128,
-0.4554559886455536,
-0.4511584937572479,
-0.41885876655578613,
0.1150677502155304,
-0.2708727717399597,
-0.3152901828289032,
-0.40527281165122986,
-0.08145751804113388,
0.27610403299331665,
0.7021848559379578,
-0.6038081645965576,
0.2886364459991455,
0.35427597165107727,
-0.12262696027755737,
-0.3765556812286377,
-0.7438415884971619,
-0.01386886928230524,
0.033721134066581726,
-0.4387384057044983,
-0.053361646831035614,
-0.23580586910247803,
-0.35390937328338623,
-0.2738979756832123,
0.06459115445613861,
0.09081658720970154,
0.27644798159599304,
0.793153703212738,
0.6366241574287415,
-0.30895546078681946,
0.5796970725059509,
-0.3337821662425995,
-0.13073678314685822,
0.09448937326669693,
-0.26789650321006775,
0.7225459218025208,
-0.30149784684181213,
-0.8211849331855774,
-0.14362399280071259,
0.37775278091430664,
0.7584925889968872,
-0.1702025830745697,
0.13943977653980255,
0.29268935322761536,
-0.1942261904478073,
-0.5601431131362915,
-0.5029703974723816,
-0.26671871542930603,
-0.4681668281555176,
0.42670053243637085,
-0.6236935257911682,
-0.773840606212616,
0.21294422447681427,
0.017658863216638565,
-0.008746286854147911,
0.16140390932559967,
0.19270765781402588,
0.09065112471580505,
0.8272918462753296,
0.3106169104576111,
-0.5534644722938538,
0.17955709993839264,
-0.3207532465457916,
0.13914772868156433,
-0.7933464050292969,
0.10151436924934387,
-0.3697339594364166,
0.15218056738376617,
-0.42212456464767456,
-0.5452538132667542,
0.27626460790634155,
0.0948706865310669,
-0.7132946848869324,
0.4448195695877075,
-0.5871652960777283,
0.6825409531593323,
0.38284608721733093,
-0.0006713834591209888,
0.3638743758201599,
0.1260041445493698,
-0.07318424433469772,
-0.1676834225654602,
-0.4369591772556305,
-0.17854323983192444,
1.4274570941925049,
0.4017031192779541,
0.7982233166694641,
0.15974122285842896,
0.7930487394332886,
0.18790046870708466,
0.563092052936554,
-0.7865903973579407,
0.7357456088066101,
-0.009000509046018124,
-0.16718734800815582,
-0.4238314926624298,
-0.795372724533081,
-0.6130487322807312,
-0.04518929868936539,
0.2329958826303482,
-0.420091837644577,
-0.2106543332338333,
-0.08913052082061768,
-0.5398595333099365,
0.21031436324119568,
-0.5957089066505432,
0.6593127846717834,
-0.2942138612270355,
-0.20648321509361267,
0.1673143357038498,
-0.19102859497070312,
0.405338317155838,
0.011915817856788635,
0.10495894402265549,
-0.21503570675849915,
0.1887492686510086,
0.49851131439208984,
-0.5886979103088379,
0.5634625554084778,
-0.04050441086292267,
-0.12256145477294922,
0.05662134289741516,
0.6588031649589539,
0.5120217204093933,
0.4589628577232361,
-0.10888651013374329,
-0.22928114235401154,
-0.17879703640937805,
-0.44870880246162415,
-0.28250768780708313,
1.0761662721633911,
-0.704938530921936,
-0.33386579155921936,
-0.18216055631637573,
-0.9546638131141663,
-0.20806024968624115,
0.2080850899219513,
-0.15210621058940887,
0.7192454934120178,
-0.1930921971797943,
-0.04538644477725029,
0.6298009753227234,
-0.03650074452161789,
0.47740495204925537,
0.6778152585029602,
-0.8430421948432922,
-0.3211469054222107,
0.9281377792358398,
-0.13565048575401306,
0.6805934309959412,
-0.24567319452762604,
-0.09672176837921143,
-0.017103441059589386,
-0.45579227805137634,
-0.532499372959137,
0.2233988493680954,
-0.6221361756324768,
-0.6149706840515137,
-0.32390737533569336,
-0.30737268924713135,
-0.6577058434486389,
-0.2954886257648468,
-0.6869567036628723,
-0.35678836703300476,
0.1443585902452469,
-0.0673157125711441,
0.5535051822662354,
0.7838375568389893,
0.002329972805455327,
0.059591006487607956,
-0.4563334584236145,
0.24985434114933014,
0.5620996952056885,
0.19691641628742218,
-0.18237771093845367,
-0.3001773953437805,
0.09509970992803574,
-0.1329580843448639,
-0.04048214852809906,
-0.5894491076469421,
0.5433635115623474,
0.05809544399380684,
0.056840669363737106,
0.21942883729934692,
-0.08624561876058578,
0.8199679851531982,
-0.485554039478302,
0.8289747834205627,
0.17634105682373047,
-1.0255345106124878,
0.6161975264549255,
-0.2635009288787842,
0.15650023519992828,
0.7389968037605286,
0.2119220644235611,
-0.6318154335021973,
-0.1478426605463028,
-0.6276540160179138,
-0.6795722246170044,
0.3734056353569031,
0.1362546682357788,
-0.11600957810878754,
0.12326671928167343,
0.4541032314300537,
-0.17477698624134064,
0.16394110023975372,
-0.3666011691093445,
-0.10204972326755524,
0.10171405225992203,
-0.1185918003320694,
-0.24036382138729095,
-0.13144153356552124,
-0.26911282539367676,
-0.4042510986328125,
0.7499856352806091,
-0.39683645963668823,
0.13392402231693268,
0.3201298713684082,
-0.19365090131759644,
-0.1455266773700714,
0.1100570484995842,
0.21525341272354126,
0.5618857145309448,
-0.24257273972034454,
0.4068416953086853,
0.1680542230606079,
-0.5763860940933228,
0.29283201694488525,
0.28146469593048096,
-0.3754262924194336,
0.016567399725317955,
0.21049343049526215,
0.4571857750415802,
0.006274119485169649,
-0.8241992592811584,
0.4218612313270569,
-0.07217250764369965,
-0.1446409970521927,
-0.3939792811870575,
0.05016085132956505,
0.230083167552948,
0.25240811705589294,
0.2527681887149811,
-0.05367853865027428,
0.00377009273506701,
-0.6009853482246399,
0.667273223400116,
0.2507678270339966,
-0.29499751329421997,
-0.22462520003318787,
0.3813190460205078,
0.13151058554649353,
-0.22401152551174164,
0.7787860035896301,
-0.6400618553161621,
-0.5006066560745239,
0.9011995792388916,
0.583117663860321,
0.30061936378479004,
-0.5736209750175476,
0.4019470512866974,
0.32311776280403137,
0.13263079524040222,
-0.14016753435134888,
0.5857512950897217,
0.011163998395204544,
-0.6601110696792603,
-0.36972400546073914,
-0.7074840068817139,
-0.4118126928806305,
0.30699166655540466,
-0.5145282745361328,
0.04562073200941086,
-0.3422093689441681,
0.19833166897296906,
-0.19132229685783386,
0.22850771248340607,
-0.5082919001579285,
0.06345251202583313,
0.3799944818019867,
0.8349836468696594,
-0.9707620739936829,
1.1438231468200684,
0.4542221128940582,
-0.40186527371406555,
-1.104651689529419,
-0.19131578505039215,
-0.16397462785243988,
-0.719752848148346,
0.6029290556907654,
0.20365828275680542,
0.3054869472980499,
0.030550912022590637,
-0.18137741088867188,
-0.9985039234161377,
1.3094080686569214,
0.29096299409866333,
-0.9529042840003967,
0.21993388235569,
0.5922445058822632,
0.4018165171146393,
-0.6630995273590088,
0.42736244201660156,
0.5907464623451233,
0.07021845877170563,
-0.040981534868478775,
-0.7925012111663818,
0.43272095918655396,
-0.13555078208446503,
0.4009717106819153,
0.3172594904899597,
-0.539483368396759,
1.137622356414795,
-0.20071935653686523,
0.20291978120803833,
0.28960517048835754,
0.40275219082832336,
0.6850208640098572,
0.0835193321108818,
0.5526702404022217,
0.3979741036891937,
0.9271584153175354,
0.023547593504190445,
0.8935344815254211,
-0.3824841380119324,
0.49384236335754395,
1.354434847831726,
-0.7730587124824524,
1.123902440071106,
0.5263714790344238,
-0.2929283678531647,
0.35276684165000916,
0.3126293122768402,
-0.04248835891485214,
0.12303966283798218,
0.5237758159637451,
-0.3343698978424072,
-0.484150230884552,
-0.18925780057907104,
-0.347628116607666,
0.2421584129333496,
0.29000619053840637,
-0.6315125226974487,
-0.0983918234705925,
-0.08213389664888382,
0.011835861951112747,
0.06930673122406006,
-0.15621189773082733,
0.18909794092178345,
0.027104657143354416,
-0.7456398606300354,
0.684740424156189,
-0.4422668218612671,
0.3064401149749756,
-0.49350106716156006,
0.04004887491464615,
-0.44985124468803406,
0.4676133096218109,
-0.12936437129974365,
-0.6327016949653625,
0.1498340666294098,
-0.0920124426484108,
0.152124285697937,
-0.3009495139122009,
0.7477715611457825,
-0.49094897508621216,
-0.591951310634613,
0.29762792587280273,
0.3734513521194458,
0.3074583113193512,
-0.18671762943267822,
-0.5190364718437195,
0.3607912063598633,
0.11930857598781586,
-0.213797464966774,
0.33858680725097656,
0.1613669991493225,
0.0816178023815155,
0.47427111864089966,
0.6871072053909302,
0.35193008184432983,
-0.16354170441627502,
0.4429459869861603,
0.9264615774154663,
-0.523238480091095,
-0.05335671454668045,
-0.676211953163147,
0.4294739067554474,
-0.27304357290267944,
-0.31429609656333923,
0.9039928317070007,
0.742496132850647,
0.6761980056762695,
-0.006447481922805309,
0.8551939725875854,
-0.12127579748630524,
0.21538184583187103,
-0.24346923828125,
0.7687625885009766,
-0.281014084815979,
0.3108178973197937,
0.07260720431804657,
-0.5856329202651978,
-0.2571153938770294,
0.26650363206863403,
0.009285848587751389,
-0.4082731306552887,
0.5463230013847351,
1.228633165359497,
-0.16078431904315948,
-0.045555904507637024,
0.5405013561248779,
0.33626773953437805,
0.36513611674308777,
0.6409936547279358,
0.7389423251152039,
-0.8677315711975098,
0.4116997718811035,
-0.32111895084381104,
-0.36358940601348877,
-0.15862783789634705,
-0.5811172723770142,
-0.8881155848503113,
-0.6000627875328064,
-0.20986014604568481,
-0.673821747303009,
0.0449724942445755,
0.9872568845748901,
0.8288061022758484,
-0.8408446311950684,
-0.45743104815483093,
-0.5052739977836609,
-0.08935315161943436,
0.07048777490854263,
-0.2369215488433838,
0.22970180213451385,
-0.6468518972396851,
-0.2796079218387604,
0.6299751400947571,
-0.00190234265755862,
-0.04713978245854378,
-0.6864647269248962,
-0.30181390047073364,
0.10438323020935059,
-0.19129294157028198,
0.6527159214019775,
0.14485430717468262,
-0.2805710732936859,
-0.1545160710811615,
0.3570437431335449,
-0.2505762577056885,
-0.23139378428459167,
0.704872727394104,
-0.49892622232437134,
0.3258199095726013,
0.6195520162582397,
0.5541279911994934,
0.24524518847465515,
-0.2392800748348236,
0.6230708360671997,
-0.8514524698257446,
0.12953774631023407,
0.021087124943733215,
0.5779442191123962,
0.31707853078842163,
-0.4231605529785156,
0.7239630818367004,
0.21153606474399567,
-0.9259597659111023,
-1.1231881380081177,
0.4385209381580353,
-0.6904461979866028,
-0.18660669028759003,
1.6591498851776123,
-0.3629920780658722,
-0.2828662395477295,
0.12383265048265457,
0.04599061235785484,
0.10602792352437973,
-0.24629755318164825,
0.7798274159431458,
0.23977278172969818,
-0.11364053189754486,
0.21772518754005432,
-0.5203235149383545,
0.6116970181465149,
0.4763011634349823,
-1.1060045957565308,
0.40769025683403015,
0.45641252398490906,
0.5987657904624939,
0.2677231729030609,
0.635899543762207,
-0.015313954092562199,
0.26373860239982605,
0.11959241330623627,
0.47850051522254944,
-0.044880129396915436,
-0.4367403984069824,
-0.2267892211675644,
0.05045870319008827,
0.26319190859794617,
-0.17088274657726288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02625v1 | Enhancing Transformer RNNs with Multiple Temporal Perspectives | 2024-02-04T22:12:29 | 2024-02-04T22:12:29 | Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Darius Peteleaza, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.7 | We introduce the concept of multiple temporal perspectives, a novel approach
applicable to Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) architectures for enhancing their
understanding of sequential data. This method involves maintaining diverse
temporal views of previously encountered text, significantly enriching the
language models' capacity to interpret context. To show the efficacy of this
approach, we incorporate it into the Receptance Weighted Key Value (RWKV)
architecture, addressing its inherent challenge of retaining all historical
information within a single hidden state. Notably, this improvement is achieved
with a minimal increase in the number of parameters --even as little as
$0.04\%$ of the original number of parameters. Further, the additional
parameters necessary for the multiple temporal perspectives are fine-tuned with
minimal computational overhead, avoiding the need for a full pre-training. The
resulting model maintains linear computational complexity during prompt
inference, ensuring consistent efficiency across various sequence lengths. The
empirical results and ablation studies included in our research validate the
effectiveness of our approach, showcasing improved performance across multiple
benchmarks. The code, model weights and datasets are open-sourced at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/TemporalRNNs. | [
-0.20444859564304352,
-0.4023367464542389,
0.4521982669830322,
0.5613203644752502,
-0.3399105370044708,
0.14994357526302338,
-0.04631700739264488,
-0.2781641185283661,
-0.07991944998502731,
0.33121803402900696,
-0.7399159669876099,
-0.30936431884765625,
-0.5591235160827637,
0.04578903689980507,
-0.3118351697921753,
0.9574824571609497,
0.22364208102226257,
-0.042270366102457047,
0.23761729896068573,
-0.44200456142425537,
-0.45107364654541016,
-0.18614692986011505,
-0.7175050973892212,
-0.835076630115509,
1.0540192127227783,
0.29383108019828796,
0.5537346005439758,
0.597722589969635,
0.3667425215244293,
0.24190346896648407,
-0.17783856391906738,
0.042078014463186264,
-0.269612193107605,
0.5062814354896545,
-0.02911573275923729,
-0.2848787009716034,
-0.2518804669380188,
-0.2624551057815552,
0.9897040128707886,
0.6283221244812012,
-0.511108934879303,
0.21207015216350555,
0.010760616511106491,
0.8469063639640808,
-0.542582631111145,
0.07972194999456406,
-0.5172029733657837,
0.5570653676986694,
-0.159932479262352,
-0.41705426573753357,
-0.7248801589012146,
-0.23570619523525238,
0.5058058500289917,
-0.5478453636169434,
0.4261915683746338,
-0.15917040407657623,
0.6883974671363831,
0.49658292531967163,
-0.6136419773101807,
0.5251652002334595,
-0.9819533824920654,
0.79473876953125,
-0.7329801917076111,
0.7377884984016418,
-0.43035390973091125,
0.31591692566871643,
-0.007533756550401449,
-1.0178533792495728,
-0.5053182244300842,
-0.010142394341528416,
-0.251869261264801,
0.37098827958106995,
-0.0680803433060646,
-0.17094896733760834,
0.5440196394920349,
0.33664706349372864,
-0.6744077205657959,
-0.153486967086792,
-0.2942318320274353,
-0.14857566356658936,
0.13914573192596436,
0.38073983788490295,
-0.22247955203056335,
-0.36926892399787903,
-0.48400309681892395,
-0.25232115387916565,
-0.28322282433509827,
0.001565666520036757,
0.2949000895023346,
0.2749178409576416,
-0.199366956949234,
0.32720044255256653,
-0.2687702476978302,
0.7808005809783936,
0.05780370533466339,
0.06408477574586868,
0.5575184226036072,
-0.47192710638046265,
-0.20739677548408508,
-0.08635697513818741,
0.605086624622345,
0.033894166350364685,
-0.08874860405921936,
-0.1183900311589241,
0.2883307635784149,
-0.26190099120140076,
0.9513511657714844,
-0.8524095416069031,
-0.20005187392234802,
0.17647190392017365,
-0.7411695122718811,
-0.5892446637153625,
0.2111237496137619,
-0.9006815552711487,
-0.41486939787864685,
-0.3400474786758423,
0.1491197645664215,
-0.5151746869087219,
-0.4345509707927704,
-0.02726815454661846,
-0.5183979868888855,
0.5345614552497864,
0.36380767822265625,
-0.6676182150840759,
-0.04081301391124725,
0.7344792485237122,
0.987914502620697,
-0.06501127034425735,
-0.4362258315086365,
-0.13030102849006653,
0.09918441623449326,
-0.09608139097690582,
0.6911185383796692,
-0.5479811429977417,
-0.2854519784450531,
-0.3361818492412567,
-0.01942032016813755,
0.06938239932060242,
-0.09596367925405502,
0.314572811126709,
-0.8530794382095337,
0.33943432569503784,
0.07077949494123459,
0.023744776844978333,
-0.28427237272262573,
0.20219992101192474,
-0.9274905920028687,
1.1043529510498047,
0.13931725919246674,
-0.7071020603179932,
0.4412015974521637,
-0.48051488399505615,
-0.6663349866867065,
-0.11501903086900711,
-0.2728952169418335,
-0.6215038299560547,
0.4267076551914215,
0.40383461117744446,
0.14652274549007416,
-0.009424393065273762,
0.2848215699195862,
-0.0003407085605431348,
0.041241373866796494,
0.3481731414794922,
-0.9340814352035522,
0.3635140359401703,
0.3432022035121918,
-0.17100170254707336,
0.39141446352005005,
-0.9987235069274902,
0.0787045806646347,
-0.051631659269332886,
-0.470621794462204,
-0.1270134150981903,
-0.018703904002904892,
0.011532899923622608,
0.32109805941581726,
0.11730511486530304,
-0.5748279094696045,
0.2920299768447876,
-0.6109431982040405,
0.5791471004486084,
0.8150877952575684,
0.3448466956615448,
0.5355765223503113,
-0.38608506321907043,
0.4908870756626129,
0.320326030254364,
0.40280213952064514,
-0.6256118416786194,
-0.5395664572715759,
-0.577041745185852,
0.13930867612361908,
0.09165816754102707,
0.5813160538673401,
-0.7335718274116516,
0.08289401233196259,
-0.6814458966255188,
-0.38648149371147156,
-0.3777672350406647,
-0.4158509373664856,
0.21902815997600555,
0.9841046929359436,
0.4850180149078369,
-0.28222742676734924,
-0.7763115763664246,
-1.0454792976379395,
-0.4045637249946594,
0.015811927616596222,
-0.20841197669506073,
0.31077203154563904,
0.24583931267261505,
0.10701224952936172,
0.9306168556213379,
-0.3686443269252777,
-0.10710139572620392,
-0.14282293617725372,
0.4036799967288971,
0.6607222557067871,
0.4600332975387573,
0.03175469860434532,
-0.9859957695007324,
-0.21131570637226105,
0.1598065048456192,
-0.6710042357444763,
0.24968041479587555,
-0.5507318377494812,
0.10598146915435791,
0.12093690782785416,
0.2240212857723236,
-0.24832235276699066,
0.606256365776062,
0.417453795671463,
-0.2580140233039856,
0.28269001841545105,
-0.11026301980018616,
0.30287304520606995,
-1.1369881629943848,
0.1320536732673645,
-0.10847628861665726,
-0.25570106506347656,
-0.7643647789955139,
-0.15825673937797546,
0.17061269283294678,
-0.11045590043067932,
-0.5749614238739014,
0.5241244435310364,
-0.22248220443725586,
0.0004775524139404297,
-0.2190830409526825,
-0.1622142344713211,
0.3179347515106201,
0.7338224053382874,
0.26300835609436035,
0.6136122345924377,
0.021842362359166145,
-0.23848968744277954,
0.23942522704601288,
0.3077335059642792,
-0.21701404452323914,
0.31397703289985657,
-0.8246173858642578,
0.2112862765789032,
-0.4340093433856964,
0.5488489866256714,
-0.7625590562820435,
0.11498553305864334,
0.4116685092449188,
-0.7439045310020447,
0.3677434027194977,
-0.4313071668148041,
-0.06637023389339447,
-0.20784740149974823,
-0.07633496075868607,
0.7078381776809692,
0.2670060992240906,
-0.47198250889778137,
1.3205852508544922,
-0.18492555618286133,
-0.04448952153325081,
-1.1190519332885742,
-0.9354687333106995,
0.11225367337465286,
-0.18075761198997498,
-0.5947157740592957,
0.6010305881500244,
0.32833680510520935,
0.07219143211841583,
0.048703815788030624,
-0.4110037088394165,
0.15811926126480103,
-0.20463722944259644,
0.2834458649158478,
0.2674236595630646,
-0.2612842321395874,
0.22285054624080658,
-0.08938520401716232,
-0.5198198556900024,
-0.07006518542766571,
-0.9016002416610718,
0.5243343710899353,
-0.10626520216464996,
-0.14496609568595886,
-0.5232529640197754,
0.5588459968566895,
0.4856494069099426,
-0.36167100071907043,
1.0714502334594727,
0.8525015711784363,
-0.3591611385345459,
-0.2272898554801941,
-0.6332451701164246,
-0.1922353208065033,
-0.433521568775177,
0.37707364559173584,
-0.36223822832107544,
-0.8494593501091003,
0.6699264049530029,
0.09875573217868805,
0.2270345687866211,
0.4178697168827057,
0.5539632439613342,
0.08784687519073486,
0.6923826336860657,
0.47241029143333435,
-0.04151428863406181,
0.924589991569519,
-0.18279089033603668,
0.2149556279182434,
-1.0498552322387695,
-0.5915920734405518,
-0.3140280544757843,
-0.48030805587768555,
-0.4568982422351837,
-0.38769039511680603,
0.502544105052948,
-0.3186061382293701,
-0.6288195848464966,
0.1432788372039795,
-0.605742871761322,
0.16759857535362244,
0.45875757932662964,
0.4934564232826233,
0.38267043232917786,
-0.009001537226140499,
-0.17870184779167175,
-0.112894207239151,
-0.926207959651947,
-0.10511616617441177,
1.1986806392669678,
0.6161350607872009,
0.682251513004303,
0.08595674484968185,
0.5947176814079285,
0.14070914685726166,
0.2850249409675598,
-0.8064481019973755,
0.09475406259298325,
-0.057350944727659225,
-0.3706192970275879,
-0.499411404132843,
-0.6491113305091858,
-0.7955965995788574,
0.6034939885139465,
-0.19341322779655457,
-0.3781574070453644,
0.3828408420085907,
0.0906464084982872,
-0.7912822961807251,
0.23497407138347626,
-0.3752117455005646,
0.8750685453414917,
-0.07925032079219818,
-0.5085902214050293,
-0.3964386284351349,
-1.0330599546432495,
0.06471696496009827,
0.23203684389591217,
-0.04826847091317177,
0.16650904715061188,
-0.21367694437503815,
0.525989830493927,
-0.3642779290676117,
0.8061831593513489,
-0.19033339619636536,
0.08031445741653442,
-0.06235232949256897,
-0.19402341544628143,
0.4929540455341339,
0.41973039507865906,
-0.016134656965732574,
0.33497869968414307,
-0.19464297592639923,
-0.34675416350364685,
-0.9567897915840149,
0.49686694145202637,
-0.6854024529457092,
-0.32690638303756714,
-0.6171723008155823,
-0.7111374735832214,
-0.06180614233016968,
0.32658323645591736,
0.11865010112524033,
0.9283947944641113,
0.017257073894143105,
0.4469324052333832,
0.9000098705291748,
-0.36195847392082214,
0.39444875717163086,
0.48111629486083984,
0.06584100425243378,
-0.7400932312011719,
0.2570771872997284,
-0.339130163192749,
0.4028586149215698,
0.8115350008010864,
0.3709643483161926,
-0.26471230387687683,
-0.6269049048423767,
-0.21332675218582153,
0.08178716152906418,
-0.7118238210678101,
-0.21014246344566345,
-0.7863407135009766,
-0.4362305998802185,
-0.5546575784683228,
0.327136754989624,
-0.5227502584457397,
-0.6505762338638306,
-0.06658343970775604,
-0.07322423905134201,
0.5544524192810059,
0.5647439360618591,
0.007200897671282291,
0.5916896462440491,
-1.027287483215332,
0.6776593327522278,
0.12097971886396408,
0.46090981364250183,
0.4174712300300598,
-0.7382568120956421,
-0.2590746283531189,
-0.154181569814682,
-0.22887985408306122,
-0.6542835235595703,
0.26953837275505066,
0.13076011836528778,
0.6566963195800781,
0.15260696411132812,
-0.2744452655315399,
0.8036800026893616,
-1.0011327266693115,
0.7474770545959473,
0.05135957896709442,
-0.6830651760101318,
0.5622307658195496,
-0.264387309551239,
0.7907752394676208,
0.3323846161365509,
0.09247470647096634,
-0.9602454304695129,
-0.28553903102874756,
-0.5193119049072266,
-1.0438876152038574,
0.6708724498748779,
0.12801282107830048,
0.021960005164146423,
0.17370165884494781,
0.6176536679267883,
0.1459898054599762,
0.11766690015792847,
-0.7040748596191406,
-0.5934308171272278,
-0.6828673481941223,
-0.15987807512283325,
0.16571378707885742,
-0.13870540261268616,
-0.129774808883667,
-0.10143117606639862,
0.4361807107925415,
-0.03452906757593155,
0.28883275389671326,
0.41533729434013367,
0.0014556031674146652,
0.19017063081264496,
0.4632025361061096,
0.8179360628128052,
0.7791488766670227,
-0.031889934092760086,
-0.09933538734912872,
0.29749056696891785,
-0.7549154162406921,
0.030314302071928978,
0.13610047101974487,
-0.022079315036535263,
-0.10830400139093399,
0.5658754706382751,
0.9035982489585876,
0.43598008155822754,
0.11189466714859009,
0.21874864399433136,
-0.34127098321914673,
0.005727918352931738,
-0.6732417345046997,
-0.24823899567127228,
-0.13023324310779572,
0.5970584750175476,
0.6288095712661743,
0.5755529403686523,
-0.20213666558265686,
-0.1681249588727951,
0.49633923172950745,
0.040563277900218964,
-0.28527823090553284,
-0.0982002466917038,
0.646902322769165,
0.11334551125764847,
-0.2522346079349518,
0.9755582213401794,
0.35328441858291626,
-0.48479509353637695,
0.5268032550811768,
0.28901398181915283,
0.9946325421333313,
-0.3272475004196167,
0.009026470594108105,
0.48812779784202576,
0.3698013424873352,
-0.03304700553417206,
0.2606944441795349,
-0.23657792806625366,
-0.9699604511260986,
-0.660001277923584,
-0.5085428953170776,
-0.13097092509269714,
-0.02615268900990486,
-0.9516894817352295,
0.08628600090742111,
-0.39994925260543823,
-0.2115759551525116,
-0.08175869286060333,
-0.2666088342666626,
-0.7117374539375305,
-0.05912567675113678,
0.09652937948703766,
1.0568572282791138,
-0.641919732093811,
1.0036367177963257,
0.2966623902320862,
-0.3506470322608948,
-0.7320850491523743,
-0.03702827915549278,
0.13866101205348969,
-0.7704763412475586,
0.6430361866950989,
-0.009386015124619007,
-0.3211483359336853,
0.01438868511468172,
0.09659803658723831,
-0.819156289100647,
1.3526535034179688,
-0.333863765001297,
-0.6437180638313293,
-0.3868195712566376,
0.10521285980939865,
0.534741997718811,
-0.3178706169128418,
0.24353833496570587,
0.6376439929008484,
0.4920032024383545,
0.23981089890003204,
-0.6445422768592834,
-0.01956356316804886,
-0.20919933915138245,
0.37063995003700256,
0.5333814024925232,
-0.42973166704177856,
0.6247739791870117,
-0.2473609447479248,
-0.3115972876548767,
0.14427143335342407,
0.9391656517982483,
0.12787334620952606,
0.1748785674571991,
0.518535852432251,
0.6960068345069885,
0.3869178891181946,
-0.17874129116535187,
1.0065778493881226,
-0.2515186369419098,
0.14496813714504242,
1.397468090057373,
-0.002025529509410262,
0.6611860990524292,
0.8027216196060181,
-0.14109177887439728,
0.6470147967338562,
0.33363035321235657,
-0.05053738132119179,
0.6361455917358398,
-0.0056860195472836494,
-0.25169360637664795,
-0.19363072514533997,
0.030026374384760857,
-0.5135189890861511,
0.1979345679283142,
0.2684098780155182,
-0.3830408453941345,
-0.23195873200893402,
0.2614559233188629,
-0.25162097811698914,
0.020954756066203117,
-0.09921790659427643,
0.7329713702201843,
0.21263356506824493,
-0.5075136423110962,
0.056815870106220245,
-0.26447755098342896,
0.5594483017921448,
-0.8929448127746582,
-0.2119266539812088,
-0.09264731407165527,
0.3138454258441925,
-0.37601739168167114,
-0.788297176361084,
0.5951091647148132,
-0.3218630254268646,
-0.5639534592628479,
-0.7681970000267029,
0.5064945220947266,
-0.36829712986946106,
-0.5022118091583252,
0.037575770169496536,
0.4838555157184601,
-0.42667850852012634,
0.11846923828125,
-0.6230106353759766,
0.15484248101711273,
-0.21474044024944305,
-0.4036504030227661,
-0.026027023792266846,
0.4863450527191162,
0.19889600574970245,
0.6642583608627319,
0.46483463048934937,
0.27873316407203674,
0.09620076417922974,
0.7335933446884155,
0.7433598041534424,
-0.9428104162216187,
-0.5358307361602783,
-0.7950654625892639,
0.7788169980049133,
0.058840710669755936,
-0.3608244061470032,
0.6558442115783691,
0.4986715316772461,
0.8382395505905151,
0.019903933629393578,
0.6257246136665344,
0.06423662602901459,
0.6915704011917114,
-0.4735492169857025,
0.6626009345054626,
-0.35098305344581604,
0.40504586696624756,
-0.05165543779730797,
-0.6911804676055908,
-0.4404039978981018,
0.4905247986316681,
-0.08109460771083832,
0.09612727165222168,
0.8488763570785522,
0.6445371508598328,
0.20062807202339172,
0.30362987518310547,
-0.06246395409107208,
0.017262505367398262,
0.4481455087661743,
0.6598762273788452,
1.2010353803634644,
-0.6281605362892151,
0.664506733417511,
-0.5280082821846008,
-0.21054911613464355,
0.3456098139286041,
-1.2314475774765015,
-0.5606057643890381,
-0.573701024055481,
-0.18489140272140503,
-0.2889823019504547,
0.006823391187936068,
0.6652734875679016,
0.670849621295929,
-0.7073994278907776,
0.022722363471984863,
0.02384003810584545,
0.13757479190826416,
-0.4341612458229065,
-0.30096808075904846,
0.01490737497806549,
-0.4040181338787079,
-0.34202811121940613,
0.4543190896511078,
0.38992011547088623,
-0.2551507353782654,
-0.2289150506258011,
0.2582833468914032,
-0.0430503711104393,
-0.429942786693573,
0.6973694562911987,
0.17550721764564514,
-0.7784085273742676,
-0.6298748850822449,
0.23998132348060608,
0.1846713125705719,
0.4440663754940033,
1.4359290599822998,
-1.2913469076156616,
0.4455202519893646,
0.6023475527763367,
0.6957209706306458,
0.6967366337776184,
0.17398574948310852,
0.8053930401802063,
-0.882698118686676,
0.3348817825317383,
0.48526880145072937,
0.228492870926857,
0.12087079882621765,
-0.49537912011146545,
0.3282984793186188,
0.04543784260749817,
-0.5971149802207947,
-0.4890401363372803,
0.49920329451560974,
-0.9601047039031982,
-0.2601505517959595,
0.7997539043426514,
0.04714994505047798,
0.04597249627113342,
-0.19360828399658203,
0.3209019601345062,
0.4810894727706909,
-0.5016579627990723,
0.5805827379226685,
0.5369507670402527,
-0.33112525939941406,
-0.4783253073692322,
-0.7024672627449036,
0.2089352160692215,
0.34232214093208313,
-0.43000560998916626,
0.0015657349722459912,
0.3341245651245117,
0.3101159334182739,
0.13059794902801514,
0.30419617891311646,
-0.4882067143917084,
0.3159162402153015,
-0.08308962732553482,
-0.2653041481971741,
-0.39304107427597046,
-0.7301788330078125,
-0.9690639972686768,
0.11278007179498672,
-0.27669283747673035,
-0.13820628821849823
] |
Subsets and Splits