id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06126v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06126v3 | Learn To be Efficient: Build Structured Sparsity in Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T01:18:16 | 2024-06-03T18:28:58 | Haizhong Zheng, Xiaoyan Bai, Xueshen Liu, Z. Morley Mao, Beidi Chen, Fan Lai, Atul Prakash | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success with their
billion-level parameters, yet they incur high inference overheads. The
emergence of activation sparsity in LLMs provides a natural approach to reduce
this cost by involving only parts of the parameters for inference. However,
existing methods only focus on utilizing this naturally formed activation
sparsity in a post-training setting, overlooking the potential for further
amplifying this inherent sparsity. In this paper, we hypothesize that LLMs can
learn to be efficient by achieving more structured activation sparsity. To
achieve this, we introduce a novel training algorithm, Learn-To-be-Efficient
(LTE), designed to train efficiency-aware LLMs to learn to activate fewer
neurons and achieve a better trade-off between sparsity and performance.
Furthermore, unlike SOTA MoEfication methods, which mainly focus on ReLU-based
models, LTE can also be applied to LLMs like LLaMA using non-ReLU activations.
Extensive evaluation on language understanding, language generation, and
instruction tuning tasks show that LTE consistently outperforms SOTA baselines.
Along with our hardware-aware custom kernel implementation, LTE reduces
LLaMA2-7B inference latency by 25% at 50% sparsity. | [
-0.08876725286245346,
-0.9678640365600586,
0.42305272817611694,
0.30652743577957153,
-0.37578457593917847,
-0.08189232647418976,
-0.36423033475875854,
-0.33281365036964417,
0.21809104084968567,
0.21893276274204254,
-0.3956458866596222,
-0.29932987689971924,
-0.8247789740562439,
0.07178805768489838,
-0.19614703953266144,
0.6586505770683289,
0.12273645401000977,
-0.09456659108400345,
0.1423824280500412,
-0.19277241826057434,
-0.21438509225845337,
-0.23609161376953125,
-0.9408538937568665,
-0.5884514451026917,
0.6603436470031738,
0.276325523853302,
0.3177051842212677,
0.5869717001914978,
0.05377859249711037,
0.3083076477050781,
-0.23477502167224884,
0.31705451011657715,
-0.9145116209983826,
-0.034678973257541656,
0.30173173546791077,
-0.4385853409767151,
-0.3678341507911682,
-0.22870586812496185,
0.6578301787376404,
0.8238126635551453,
-0.3965455889701843,
0.09507426619529724,
0.1332348734140396,
0.5840786695480347,
-0.7013758420944214,
0.03433329984545708,
-1.0099183320999146,
-0.009977792389690876,
0.006323979701846838,
-0.3972591459751129,
-0.7670474052429199,
-0.13336274027824402,
-0.24719524383544922,
-0.7616989016532898,
-0.18668565154075623,
-0.1078220084309578,
0.8426703810691833,
0.4516885578632355,
-0.25356170535087585,
-0.00001317283749813214,
-0.539423942565918,
0.7492272257804871,
-0.5706686973571777,
0.8076316118240356,
0.21933187544345856,
0.08291047811508179,
-0.3081475496292114,
-0.6831603050231934,
-0.407713919878006,
-0.39054685831069946,
0.11017793416976929,
0.03612817823886871,
-0.11055568605661392,
0.09485536068677902,
0.41684162616729736,
0.010723561979830265,
-0.4087257385253906,
0.3908410966396332,
-0.14679621160030365,
0.0903589203953743,
0.452633798122406,
-0.28652578592300415,
0.10486511886119843,
0.33114945888519287,
-0.5205705761909485,
0.27535679936408997,
-0.9332451224327087,
0.08074799925088882,
0.3534179925918579,
0.2069801241159439,
0.018292086198925972,
0.5259965658187866,
0.05904950574040413,
0.5327073931694031,
0.003049669321626425,
0.004235380329191685,
0.17241205275058746,
0.11563657969236374,
-0.30490759015083313,
0.08484291285276413,
0.5133240818977356,
-0.08946098387241364,
0.22563014924526215,
-0.5265306234359741,
-0.6560767889022827,
-0.021248366683721542,
0.39546748995780945,
-0.9267839193344116,
0.044482141733169556,
0.014160949736833572,
-0.39116793870925903,
-0.1545296162366867,
-0.4935321509838104,
-0.3293563723564148,
0.08549881726503372,
-0.06398435682058334,
0.6625134944915771,
-0.4362347722053528,
-0.25747182965278625,
0.2616109549999237,
0.09813076257705688,
0.2204533964395523,
0.2443496435880661,
-1.138460397720337,
0.44142165780067444,
0.6641183495521545,
0.8314986824989319,
0.08700855821371078,
-0.22543808817863464,
-0.8310079574584961,
0.18839214742183685,
-0.4689039885997772,
0.8322271704673767,
-0.47262418270111084,
-0.2291582226753235,
-0.20253394544124603,
-0.23821185529232025,
-0.28914809226989746,
-0.4351072907447815,
0.4113099277019501,
-0.9566407799720764,
-0.13342240452766418,
0.020105566829442978,
-0.5817516446113586,
-0.20861028134822845,
0.030816074460744858,
-0.6462444067001343,
1.222792625427246,
0.11787296086549759,
-0.4532979726791382,
0.42940759658813477,
-0.7427929043769836,
-0.697472333908081,
0.1601548045873642,
0.09032003581523895,
-0.5244547128677368,
0.4757942855358124,
-0.0482347272336483,
0.5416686534881592,
0.032924361526966095,
0.3291865289211273,
-0.10885714739561081,
-0.5894201397895813,
0.018019285053014755,
-0.29148802161216736,
0.5125985741615295,
0.2609159052371979,
-0.43295595049858093,
0.05108685791492462,
-0.7383747696876526,
0.03715561702847481,
0.045735061168670654,
-0.7267695665359497,
-0.41208887100219727,
0.14264898002147675,
-0.05146530643105507,
-0.2420472800731659,
0.14222145080566406,
-0.32562267780303955,
0.1093273013830185,
-0.7134899497032166,
0.47483572363853455,
0.6712706685066223,
-0.36479082703590393,
0.6866511106491089,
-0.09318142384290695,
0.14439664781093597,
-0.2883542776107788,
-0.10685762017965317,
0.125574991106987,
-0.29527416825294495,
-0.747894823551178,
-0.5798906087875366,
0.29581403732299805,
0.4138803482055664,
-0.7455611228942871,
0.5948501229286194,
-0.3369871973991394,
-0.41049325466156006,
-0.3359256088733673,
0.5838434100151062,
0.4529955983161926,
0.4851214289665222,
0.4025105834007263,
-0.2640972137451172,
-0.4822041690349579,
-0.7278891205787659,
-0.4094755947589874,
0.23490722477436066,
0.1393241137266159,
0.2540186941623688,
0.3840840756893158,
-0.13767695426940918,
0.6834596991539001,
-0.16426272690296173,
0.04280219227075577,
-0.6147243976593018,
-0.024233432486653328,
0.3334735631942749,
0.48423707485198975,
0.15315017104148865,
-0.683201014995575,
-0.2500605881214142,
0.08020411431789398,
-0.4531073570251465,
-0.2855338454246521,
-0.1734984964132309,
0.03782274201512337,
0.22972489893436432,
0.6445564031600952,
-0.6592506170272827,
0.031801749020814896,
0.4678761959075928,
-0.05028007552027702,
0.1976911574602127,
-0.3063164949417114,
-0.2532568573951721,
-1.0039206743240356,
0.10913841426372528,
0.16148482263088226,
-0.29884353280067444,
-0.8446558117866516,
-0.3130216598510742,
0.03572198748588562,
0.010253406129777431,
-0.31145569682121277,
0.6385639905929565,
-0.5555561184883118,
-0.2606963515281677,
-0.1843138337135315,
-0.1304118037223816,
-0.14464952051639557,
0.7711899280548096,
0.034909892827272415,
0.8986935019493103,
0.2761400640010834,
-0.686578631401062,
-0.3247394263744354,
-0.023897184059023857,
-0.5121462345123291,
-0.18271878361701965,
-0.8412868976593018,
-0.054767265915870667,
-0.1691911816596985,
0.2089138925075531,
-0.8341385126113892,
-0.1616588681936264,
-0.047683872282505035,
-0.233148992061615,
0.5127524733543396,
-0.09155893325805664,
-0.3896650969982147,
0.26790449023246765,
-0.17801883816719055,
0.5110567212104797,
0.7178485989570618,
-0.8593262434005737,
0.644839882850647,
0.33420324325561523,
0.002136500785127282,
-0.9236693978309631,
-0.5884440541267395,
-0.036404259502887726,
-0.12925300002098083,
-0.5709384083747864,
0.4258847236633301,
0.3050784170627594,
0.22479644417762756,
-0.12879648804664612,
-0.16974763572216034,
-0.09014756232500076,
0.6231852173805237,
0.018647484481334686,
-0.05402861908078194,
-0.2422705590724945,
0.3412250578403473,
0.2530561685562134,
-0.2310672402381897,
-0.0762563943862915,
-0.3128296732902527,
0.7409563064575195,
-0.05160200968384743,
-0.2464146912097931,
-0.5070475339889526,
0.21797099709510803,
0.27695930004119873,
-0.1554735153913498,
0.7256926894187927,
0.45234599709510803,
-0.30149132013320923,
-0.47881367802619934,
-0.7314612865447998,
-0.3774658739566803,
-0.49146780371665955,
0.6739206314086914,
-0.3663293123245239,
-1.0342494249343872,
0.23147957026958466,
-0.45832329988479614,
0.2957994043827057,
0.061232563108205795,
0.47074615955352783,
0.03729446977376938,
0.8608882427215576,
0.7035640478134155,
0.13117027282714844,
0.8990493416786194,
-0.4475618898868561,
0.28709301352500916,
-0.7799157500267029,
-0.24639873206615448,
-0.2525276243686676,
-0.37965983152389526,
-0.37215912342071533,
-0.5108989477157593,
0.2684025466442108,
0.26377904415130615,
-0.3434749245643616,
0.32951709628105164,
-0.15039116144180298,
0.6165830492973328,
0.28713634610176086,
0.3695414364337921,
0.13783803582191467,
0.448397159576416,
0.05026322603225708,
0.2814626693725586,
-1.1752023696899414,
-0.6280849575996399,
0.8944726586341858,
0.5595435500144958,
0.769293487071991,
-0.04273805022239685,
0.8077831864356995,
0.02420859783887863,
0.5345017313957214,
-0.8613585233688354,
0.6093482971191406,
-0.16823707520961761,
-0.13267609477043152,
-0.24263256788253784,
-0.7450470924377441,
-1.090346336364746,
0.18234491348266602,
-0.3392748534679413,
-0.6207498908042908,
0.09236133098602295,
0.2864595949649811,
-0.22389468550682068,
0.2605888843536377,
-0.9014295339584351,
0.7879870533943176,
-0.16961154341697693,
-0.6833989024162292,
-0.44130954146385193,
-0.41363051533699036,
0.2999277710914612,
0.03330903500318527,
0.15409617125988007,
0.006574725266546011,
-0.4617510139942169,
0.6732796430587769,
-0.3043455481529236,
0.9187710285186768,
-0.3239174783229828,
-0.0624745637178421,
0.13158787786960602,
-0.16675297915935516,
0.6737725138664246,
-0.03777247294783592,
-0.3485821485519409,
0.27965545654296875,
-0.7771218419075012,
-0.6204617023468018,
-0.6340599060058594,
0.5283448696136475,
-0.7859524488449097,
-0.3956705927848816,
0.06236870214343071,
-0.4231688976287842,
-0.2583734393119812,
0.12157979607582092,
0.3118686079978943,
0.5451666116714478,
-0.17472460865974426,
0.16945642232894897,
0.8871633410453796,
-0.09637624025344849,
0.4444926381111145,
0.16713637113571167,
0.25352829694747925,
-0.4173843264579773,
0.8762956261634827,
0.25809988379478455,
0.3122754991054535,
0.5469447374343872,
0.14887358248233795,
-0.4521694779396057,
-0.8539621829986572,
-0.4301355183124542,
0.2492227405309677,
-0.5026473999023438,
-0.14864222705364227,
-0.8375315070152283,
-0.23387138545513153,
-0.052956219762563705,
-0.4511999785900116,
-0.5016838908195496,
-0.3931906223297119,
-0.34356504678726196,
-0.1883379966020584,
0.27484825253486633,
0.43324363231658936,
0.0024093317333608866,
0.9076229929924011,
-0.5502643585205078,
0.1486017107963562,
0.27264559268951416,
0.46139487624168396,
0.004248877055943012,
-0.6769949793815613,
-0.3243343234062195,
-0.17605918645858765,
-0.21422994136810303,
-0.6135051846504211,
0.4647327959537506,
0.5187697410583496,
0.6677601933479309,
0.23946547508239746,
-0.31895288825035095,
0.6627694964408875,
-0.5936898589134216,
0.46122249960899353,
0.37940794229507446,
-0.9634034633636475,
0.08917004615068436,
-0.04523663595318794,
-0.02356533706188202,
0.43986016511917114,
0.32734182476997375,
0.01621568389236927,
-0.16103793680667877,
-0.6138520836830139,
-0.960576057434082,
0.39547842741012573,
0.04087537154555321,
0.48701056838035583,
-0.08174347132444382,
0.5853561162948608,
0.1679232120513916,
0.09269332140684128,
-1.044752597808838,
0.02092391438782215,
-0.03183254227042198,
-0.22768791019916534,
-0.0987217128276825,
-0.6236066222190857,
0.08870065212249756,
-0.0405617281794548,
0.7866815328598022,
-0.15597966313362122,
0.16782090067863464,
0.10922682285308838,
-0.485347181558609,
0.016280101612210274,
0.4237920045852661,
0.48366737365722656,
0.45740512013435364,
0.06860770285129547,
0.2656736671924591,
0.6189446449279785,
-0.28449946641921997,
0.24509446322917938,
-0.06689238548278809,
-0.08000103384256363,
-0.06373050063848495,
0.3371502459049225,
0.9664286375045776,
0.5569028258323669,
-0.5723584890365601,
0.41192305088043213,
-0.010195918381214142,
-0.3400621712207794,
-0.1311466544866562,
0.2165052592754364,
0.29498645663261414,
0.29168418049812317,
0.2467787265777588,
0.012381089851260185,
0.06071095913648605,
-0.16895532608032227,
0.12814012169837952,
0.6555654406547546,
-0.12519046664237976,
-0.20908363163471222,
0.5277242064476013,
0.45544472336769104,
-0.3731203079223633,
0.43415820598602295,
-0.2440747618675232,
-0.4343126118183136,
0.5400046706199646,
0.695229709148407,
0.9128528833389282,
-0.28527936339378357,
-0.12048498541116714,
0.29065918922424316,
0.3761095404624939,
-0.2927873730659485,
0.3424430191516876,
-0.33843493461608887,
-0.777467668056488,
-0.9220969080924988,
-0.7425305247306824,
-0.020273592323064804,
0.10022544860839844,
-0.28763601183891296,
0.2703857421875,
-0.4418391287326813,
-0.11802125722169876,
-0.15636740624904633,
-0.0077190641313791275,
-0.27607810497283936,
0.10030276328325272,
-0.05847550928592682,
1.1295965909957886,
-0.8413180708885193,
0.9091147780418396,
0.520250141620636,
0.17092148959636688,
-0.8938807845115662,
-0.3144029676914215,
-0.6352071762084961,
-0.9699940085411072,
0.9679672122001648,
0.6127371788024902,
-0.38365495204925537,
0.44530171155929565,
-0.560154378414154,
-0.520564615726471,
0.9743792414665222,
0.6315611004829407,
-0.7126849889755249,
0.12875600159168243,
-0.2953399121761322,
0.2594080865383148,
-0.3820475935935974,
0.3784189522266388,
0.37238645553588867,
0.2917082905769348,
0.04598342627286911,
-0.560300886631012,
-0.003915633540600538,
-0.31843695044517517,
0.09290488064289093,
0.35332784056663513,
-0.513288140296936,
0.5287690162658691,
-0.39063936471939087,
-0.3470814824104309,
-0.08250757306814194,
0.7362462282180786,
0.1541508585214615,
0.3900688886642456,
0.7865232229232788,
0.8329482078552246,
0.5997128486633301,
0.06880372762680054,
0.9437731504440308,
-0.319017618894577,
0.16207517683506012,
0.7694855332374573,
-0.21324071288108826,
0.9630594849586487,
0.5797559022903442,
0.20628345012664795,
0.3978408873081207,
0.5640625357627869,
0.22212348878383636,
0.6277697086334229,
0.2540781795978546,
-0.6153847575187683,
-0.5651569962501526,
0.04768669977784157,
-0.08804802596569061,
0.33310458064079285,
0.5121075510978699,
-0.22141502797603607,
-0.27703726291656494,
-0.09614696353673935,
0.07515726238489151,
0.02775784395635128,
-0.23155371844768524,
0.9385597109794617,
0.1848776936531067,
-0.5574706792831421,
0.9749457240104675,
-0.12508559226989746,
0.7551190853118896,
-0.8800084590911865,
-0.06299968808889389,
-0.17970480024814606,
0.07791543006896973,
-0.2822951078414917,
-0.16775590181350708,
0.28096839785575867,
0.047667305916547775,
-0.11023375391960144,
-0.3815882205963135,
0.6267837882041931,
-0.4486089050769806,
-0.25753387808799744,
0.38388359546661377,
0.48901835083961487,
0.16054324805736542,
0.10382331162691116,
-0.6127527952194214,
0.11302949488162994,
-0.1332872062921524,
-0.70893394947052,
0.48284685611724854,
0.32407206296920776,
0.14936035871505737,
0.8553638458251953,
0.7983465790748596,
0.27302396297454834,
0.20007823407649994,
0.004288799595087767,
1.0535355806350708,
-0.39962059259414673,
-0.3048814535140991,
-0.8588141798973083,
0.44060418009757996,
-0.16390244662761688,
-0.1597410887479782,
0.35251060128211975,
0.6592072248458862,
0.7186402678489685,
0.059473469853401184,
0.6607223749160767,
0.098532535135746,
0.0580277182161808,
-0.8341628313064575,
0.6170589327812195,
-0.8119655251502991,
0.6138471364974976,
0.2098183035850525,
-0.8056862950325012,
-0.21400752663612366,
0.8520569205284119,
-0.4345926344394684,
0.18723174929618835,
0.4712211787700653,
1.2873167991638184,
-0.1411837786436081,
-0.14313742518424988,
0.5380927324295044,
0.20019467175006866,
0.2061208188533783,
0.6823624968528748,
0.7853140234947205,
-0.2749162018299103,
0.43339240550994873,
-0.1320039927959442,
-0.5217717289924622,
-0.3438934087753296,
-1.0154162645339966,
-0.7988660335540771,
-0.24477267265319824,
-0.2131613940000534,
-0.25984710454940796,
0.44732972979545593,
1.1062473058700562,
0.880442202091217,
-0.3671964108943939,
-0.41247478127479553,
-0.38573774695396423,
0.2818886339664459,
-0.24794436991214752,
-0.12185554206371307,
0.3601545989513397,
-0.9605277180671692,
-0.6822177767753601,
0.6453877091407776,
0.4348579943180084,
-0.11072909086942673,
0.1796017438173294,
-0.06671468168497086,
-0.16380879282951355,
0.11346828937530518,
0.8697965145111084,
0.34927013516426086,
-0.34062087535858154,
-0.05081766098737717,
-0.04716429114341736,
-0.1772732436656952,
0.07687342911958694,
0.8403903841972351,
-0.7322270274162292,
0.030556540936231613,
0.3038267195224762,
1.0307295322418213,
0.45854371786117554,
-0.08865584433078766,
0.4706958532333374,
-0.7502673268318176,
0.26446598768234253,
0.22518809139728546,
0.3899555802345276,
0.12496670335531235,
-0.2823209762573242,
0.3378884196281433,
0.16455671191215515,
-0.6469485759735107,
-0.9036500453948975,
0.2696973979473114,
-1.0321048498153687,
-0.2680613100528717,
1.3744765520095825,
-0.09949704259634018,
-0.6112063527107239,
-0.20708821713924408,
-0.038138944655656815,
0.29392993450164795,
-0.5476434230804443,
0.7589727640151978,
0.08325985819101334,
-0.010743612423539162,
-0.16695022583007812,
-0.5930960774421692,
0.4616623818874359,
0.901968240737915,
-0.8723435997962952,
0.09372969716787338,
0.19125723838806152,
0.38883814215660095,
-0.23741403222084045,
0.7437913417816162,
0.1860199272632599,
0.24901194870471954,
0.03641374781727791,
0.17115749418735504,
-0.2692492604255676,
-0.2336876541376114,
-0.2611372470855713,
0.2461014837026596,
0.1658228039741516,
-0.14040178060531616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06125v1 | Language Model Sentence Completion with a Parser-Driven Rhetorical Control Method | 2024-02-09T01:15:42 | 2024-02-09T01:15:42 | Joshua Zingale, Jugal Kalita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controlled text generation (CTG) seeks to guide large language model (LLM)
output to produce text that conforms to desired criteria. The current study
presents a novel CTG algorithm that enforces adherence toward specific
rhetorical relations in an LLM sentence-completion context by a parser-driven
decoding scheme that requires no model fine-tuning. The method is validated
both with automatic and human evaluation. The code is accessible on GitHub. | [
-0.14219291508197784,
-1.0405333042144775,
0.6756335496902466,
0.22083573043346405,
-0.5162621736526489,
0.14711010456085205,
-0.28096041083335876,
-0.06140686199069023,
-0.11849690228700638,
0.9005471467971802,
-0.6843349933624268,
-0.7790891528129578,
-0.6962360143661499,
0.35020971298217773,
-0.38371577858924866,
0.9329363703727722,
0.08557125180959702,
0.040096282958984375,
0.11035015434026718,
0.23823288083076477,
-0.5115416049957275,
-0.47692182660102844,
-0.786188542842865,
-0.8558852672576904,
0.30217820405960083,
0.08072483539581299,
0.9420986771583557,
1.0606359243392944,
0.30126604437828064,
0.19807864725589752,
-0.23133742809295654,
0.16054655611515045,
-0.40711790323257446,
0.1545751690864563,
-0.20107024908065796,
-0.5745091438293457,
-0.4429076910018921,
-0.02738032117486,
0.4630488455295563,
0.5672640204429626,
-0.29666340351104736,
-0.3207656145095825,
0.2263862043619156,
0.3090904951095581,
-0.4718247056007385,
0.03444439172744751,
-0.7799037098884583,
0.07196291536092758,
-0.05910563841462135,
-0.7033475041389465,
-0.9854740500450134,
-0.6407519578933716,
0.04422552511096001,
-0.4556899666786194,
0.002104058163240552,
0.1680915206670761,
0.7835609912872314,
0.18081283569335938,
-0.9004908800125122,
-0.5145212411880493,
-0.4621979594230652,
0.7589612603187561,
-0.7871531844139099,
-0.06531226634979248,
0.496962308883667,
-0.04348240792751312,
-0.4757072329521179,
-0.6689476370811462,
-0.2867705523967743,
-0.5897840857505798,
-0.2728140354156494,
0.1536676287651062,
-0.15272018313407898,
0.7912303805351257,
0.37605589628219604,
0.45716121792793274,
-0.6541165709495544,
-0.201703280210495,
-0.27457234263420105,
-0.1409139782190323,
0.2859141230583191,
0.1857830137014389,
0.4897509515285492,
-0.6882247924804688,
-0.44229772686958313,
0.21942031383514404,
-0.9638065695762634,
-0.05651092901825905,
0.28869205713272095,
0.22899675369262695,
-0.07502158731222153,
0.8865051865577698,
-0.05255720764398575,
0.9228715300559998,
0.3786293566226959,
0.1790236532688141,
-0.13829953968524933,
-0.2860735356807709,
-0.48682621121406555,
0.35809069871902466,
0.8204911351203918,
0.4610499143600464,
0.6711612939834595,
0.07428690791130066,
-0.21985913813114166,
0.017224261537194252,
0.4159558117389679,
-0.4972057640552521,
0.05628259852528572,
0.12365467101335526,
-0.38098907470703125,
-0.5001529455184937,
-0.17457915842533112,
-0.40835410356521606,
-0.23510117828845978,
-0.5763115286827087,
-0.0022782497107982635,
-0.4750445783138275,
-0.0032904809340834618,
0.15786409378051758,
-0.06967562437057495,
0.23141518235206604,
0.14456674456596375,
-0.690548837184906,
0.22311347723007202,
0.6387529373168945,
0.9248555898666382,
-0.23199857771396637,
-0.16091014444828033,
-0.7520627379417419,
0.5174941420555115,
-0.43715736269950867,
0.6616054177284241,
-0.6733771562576294,
-0.6283622980117798,
0.3308779299259186,
-0.11551541835069656,
-0.27973783016204834,
-0.3372971713542938,
0.6956433057785034,
-0.6894361972808838,
0.41310548782348633,
-0.17116887867450714,
-0.9889465570449829,
-0.09511931240558624,
0.41765037178993225,
-0.5105555653572083,
0.9329785108566284,
0.20478034019470215,
-0.8203708529472351,
0.17504876852035522,
-0.4363217353820801,
-0.41766074299812317,
0.27875635027885437,
-0.35834482312202454,
-0.18999077379703522,
0.18349775671958923,
-0.020202159881591797,
0.45329734683036804,
-0.2921530306339264,
0.8270813226699829,
-0.14119763672351837,
-0.3762105405330658,
0.07895829528570175,
-0.13376113772392273,
0.9514606595039368,
0.4096411466598511,
-0.28522375226020813,
0.48891180753707886,
-1.0019103288650513,
0.30873557925224304,
0.004263836424797773,
-0.8643149733543396,
-0.17539362609386444,
0.002205426571890712,
0.22943022847175598,
0.06669007241725922,
0.43689414858818054,
-0.2351895421743393,
0.4472000300884247,
-0.4035125970840454,
0.6778221726417542,
0.6238000988960266,
0.22170235216617584,
0.5237837433815002,
-0.6312433481216431,
0.8608853220939636,
-0.4586733281612396,
-0.3262953758239746,
-0.41044536232948303,
-0.22816012799739838,
-0.7791661024093628,
0.07747741043567657,
0.17611795663833618,
0.7913104295730591,
-0.6678831577301025,
0.8450073599815369,
-0.012999474070966244,
-0.15719002485275269,
-0.012722641229629517,
0.12922066450119019,
0.6003357768058777,
0.39815059304237366,
-0.06460508704185486,
0.21797482669353485,
-0.7391902804374695,
-0.8223274350166321,
-0.18792863190174103,
-0.021325984969735146,
-0.23397374153137207,
0.09362342953681946,
0.18617679178714752,
0.0705818384885788,
0.7548776268959045,
-0.47650912404060364,
-0.1409667581319809,
-0.7067847847938538,
0.4205741584300995,
0.03783058747649193,
0.4843907356262207,
0.5440039038658142,
-0.3857101798057556,
-0.5370521545410156,
0.10267668217420578,
-0.6016376614570618,
-0.6592655181884766,
-0.23457565903663635,
-0.1263522505760193,
0.20052006840705872,
0.9205251336097717,
-0.504050612449646,
0.4939550757408142,
0.7796236872673035,
-0.43684613704681396,
0.5094304084777832,
-0.3554902970790863,
0.294132262468338,
-1.272316336631775,
0.025713060051202774,
-0.06360851228237152,
-0.68589186668396,
-0.7741873264312744,
0.19212575256824493,
0.08374274522066116,
-0.12439271807670593,
-0.37479308247566223,
0.2740830183029175,
-0.3255755603313446,
0.446640282869339,
-0.692136287689209,
0.22403177618980408,
-0.018049990758299828,
0.5157558917999268,
0.18441489338874817,
0.8990206122398376,
0.247345432639122,
-0.561955988407135,
0.09161649644374847,
0.17618273198604584,
-0.029924314469099045,
0.4978998303413391,
-1.0291802883148193,
0.11387713253498077,
-0.04100368916988373,
0.22186002135276794,
-1.037522554397583,
-0.3978680968284607,
0.14225445687770844,
-0.18913571536540985,
-0.0005598746356554329,
-0.13893286883831024,
-0.5661647319793701,
-0.07815397530794144,
0.029789211228489876,
0.35353872179985046,
0.5096009373664856,
-0.19088011980056763,
0.6779283285140991,
-0.030141590163111687,
-0.2448897510766983,
-0.05242776498198509,
-0.8465516567230225,
0.1286199390888214,
-0.17528848350048065,
-0.41800832748413086,
0.30301612615585327,
-0.1297731101512909,
-0.2193252146244049,
-0.32542818784713745,
0.3043918311595917,
0.07137027382850647,
-0.23696453869342804,
0.1895863562822342,
0.04779331758618355,
-0.1029641330242157,
0.12114633619785309,
0.3130243420600891,
0.055401068180799484,
0.10584679245948792,
0.06435666978359222,
1.0321059226989746,
0.18202531337738037,
-0.2503200173377991,
-0.5194126963615417,
0.5286256074905396,
0.49090132117271423,
-0.012638870626688004,
0.31293585896492004,
0.221533864736557,
-0.33138561248779297,
-0.3721666932106018,
-0.4036443531513214,
-0.042267363518476486,
-0.5366222262382507,
0.14115101099014282,
-0.4184556007385254,
-1.1485167741775513,
0.5425704121589661,
-0.022298309952020645,
-0.17133374512195587,
0.2523593306541443,
0.6013074517250061,
0.2577355206012726,
1.0720674991607666,
0.7987508773803711,
0.24180950224399567,
0.43454834818840027,
0.2621435225009918,
0.08824822306632996,
-0.5147010684013367,
0.04469095170497894,
-0.6121246814727783,
-0.1094776913523674,
-0.7630060911178589,
0.1533062756061554,
0.1506962776184082,
0.3373972475528717,
-0.19007514417171478,
0.3482706844806671,
-0.6711363196372986,
0.5671349167823792,
0.6946077346801758,
0.08743114769458771,
0.5221484303474426,
-0.13629977405071259,
-0.3875589668750763,
-0.06507302820682526,
-0.5950403213500977,
-0.7587667107582092,
0.8770205974578857,
0.08218632638454437,
0.5999603867530823,
-0.18146494030952454,
0.6818318367004395,
0.5076654553413391,
0.07697758823633194,
-0.6687926650047302,
0.6637350916862488,
-0.12473739683628082,
-0.515415370464325,
0.12598036229610443,
-0.3401564061641693,
-0.9686400890350342,
0.0538424514234066,
0.10271553695201874,
-0.8217018842697144,
-0.3016493320465088,
0.28740760684013367,
-0.23778551816940308,
-0.029852066189050674,
-0.5181094408035278,
0.5374487638473511,
-0.01862005703151226,
-0.04113265499472618,
-0.33164313435554504,
-0.34735310077667236,
0.5110654830932617,
0.17377084493637085,
-0.23267912864685059,
0.010008196346461773,
0.05350572615861893,
0.662137508392334,
-0.48645785450935364,
0.846777617931366,
0.03545984998345375,
-0.1456996351480484,
0.5096244215965271,
0.4925219416618347,
0.7107878923416138,
-0.16806648671627045,
0.03281799331307411,
-0.2654483914375305,
0.0399596132338047,
-0.42714357376098633,
-0.36235544085502625,
0.7865198850631714,
-0.5121696591377258,
-0.8784566521644592,
-0.4060038924217224,
-0.8286104202270508,
-0.04082318767905235,
0.5236250758171082,
0.5505660772323608,
0.06826998293399811,
-0.1760873943567276,
0.3723635673522949,
0.6937088370323181,
-0.3763352036476135,
0.5419407486915588,
0.15331140160560608,
-0.5321019291877747,
-0.7055564522743225,
0.22196301817893982,
-0.11662572622299194,
0.5004185438156128,
0.40234997868537903,
0.19327996671199799,
-0.12580467760562897,
-0.6987297534942627,
-0.1549059897661209,
0.12300015985965729,
-0.6028690338134766,
-0.10711735486984253,
-0.6025517582893372,
-0.565183162689209,
-0.40227416157722473,
-0.5354803800582886,
0.050727300345897675,
-0.26315924525260925,
-0.5323929190635681,
-0.1862660050392151,
0.2811233699321747,
1.0787408351898193,
0.38934463262557983,
1.0090960264205933,
-0.7611111998558044,
0.06236876919865608,
0.031884677708148956,
0.1366967260837555,
-0.4063495397567749,
-0.3863942325115204,
0.14365041255950928,
-0.026317868381738663,
-0.5573724508285522,
-1.1127899885177612,
0.3613726794719696,
-0.06191530078649521,
0.22342266142368317,
0.5767216682434082,
-0.09928461164236069,
0.3710017800331116,
-0.4089389741420746,
0.9082702398300171,
0.33137306571006775,
-1.2929222583770752,
0.9856768846511841,
-1.1014702320098877,
0.8623178601264954,
0.31394994258880615,
-0.0997186154127121,
-0.4788977801799774,
-0.7146417498588562,
-0.40679672360420227,
-0.5155743360519409,
0.6455010771751404,
0.26486119627952576,
0.1139017790555954,
-0.26908600330352783,
0.5398043394088745,
-0.1606188714504242,
0.35977309942245483,
-1.0235995054244995,
0.05832355469465256,
-0.04325824975967407,
-0.3033216595649719,
0.2495352327823639,
-0.5195257663726807,
-0.22675299644470215,
0.23948007822036743,
0.5325782895088196,
-0.19319719076156616,
-0.1614307463169098,
0.11571894586086273,
-0.0012030776124447584,
-0.20342013239860535,
0.6446281671524048,
0.9171704649925232,
0.7244415283203125,
-0.16815976798534393,
0.07712807506322861,
-0.15314744412899017,
-0.29965025186538696,
0.20115120708942413,
-0.01869218423962593,
-0.7096866965293884,
0.0036155465058982372,
0.24406158924102783,
0.46727409958839417,
0.11594142019748688,
-0.6829520463943481,
0.570330023765564,
0.06013468652963638,
-0.592255175113678,
-0.2882285714149475,
0.24201099574565887,
-0.019476402550935745,
0.0875563994050026,
0.3305452764034271,
-0.20705866813659668,
0.0020675002597272396,
-0.16945256292819977,
0.3247518837451935,
0.4032297730445862,
-0.35188862681388855,
-0.10007666796445847,
0.8382039666175842,
0.02509636990725994,
-0.4146207869052887,
0.3618799149990082,
-0.20593230426311493,
-0.49646255373954773,
0.6344044804573059,
0.7110317945480347,
0.9265132546424866,
-0.09441415220499039,
0.27159583568573,
0.37008899450302124,
0.3323785364627838,
-0.22753728926181793,
0.6124380230903625,
0.14904621243476868,
-0.5547342300415039,
-0.7799851298332214,
-0.5237935185432434,
-0.2386574149131775,
0.3902202546596527,
-0.6515224575996399,
0.50255286693573,
-0.8853186964988708,
-0.24889783561229706,
-0.38355550169944763,
-0.08208811283111572,
-0.27943524718284607,
0.2569558322429657,
0.04173123836517334,
1.018554925918579,
-0.6021562218666077,
1.0268642902374268,
0.3485625386238098,
-0.21483471989631653,
-0.8548845052719116,
-0.1700260490179062,
0.09879548847675323,
-0.6077530980110168,
0.5754692554473877,
-0.04247453808784485,
-0.1992163062095642,
-0.01141345128417015,
-0.5383036732673645,
-0.6211896538734436,
0.9849600195884705,
0.43988195061683655,
-0.7970985770225525,
-0.2891870439052582,
0.3445459008216858,
0.5484501719474792,
-0.621309220790863,
-0.07549049705266953,
0.5776888132095337,
0.6092277765274048,
0.2180367261171341,
-0.9225620627403259,
0.21570679545402527,
-0.10440519452095032,
0.3900180459022522,
0.2390330284833908,
-0.5000879764556885,
0.5809666514396667,
0.1520255208015442,
-0.1618659347295761,
0.3652613162994385,
0.6440354585647583,
0.5473719835281372,
0.10909492522478104,
0.2336827963590622,
0.6165376901626587,
0.6628064513206482,
-0.23143470287322998,
0.9369029402732849,
-0.5944209098815918,
0.2768104374408722,
1.4622725248336792,
-0.25269004702568054,
0.6323749423027039,
0.4824192225933075,
0.10658092796802521,
0.27670934796333313,
0.5158069729804993,
-0.07837486267089844,
0.45762500166893005,
0.28965097665786743,
-0.2691236436367035,
-0.2765781879425049,
-0.3289507031440735,
-0.15136897563934326,
0.5539059638977051,
0.20207582414150238,
-0.9936134219169617,
-0.40524500608444214,
-0.03459213674068451,
0.30129575729370117,
0.5704609155654907,
-0.3657594323158264,
0.7330747246742249,
-0.07251905649900436,
-0.9861341714859009,
0.7618218660354614,
0.1023968830704689,
0.48198598623275757,
-0.7314614057540894,
0.04912518709897995,
0.07661867886781693,
0.06287139654159546,
-0.09824739396572113,
-0.5265547037124634,
0.5432198643684387,
-0.09652829170227051,
-0.23194563388824463,
-0.521824300289154,
0.6432122588157654,
-0.7214384078979492,
-0.4231218695640564,
0.2563031315803528,
0.5688695907592773,
-0.25004392862319946,
0.16006319224834442,
-0.5002117156982422,
0.14505791664123535,
0.35968151688575745,
-0.49486473202705383,
-0.021158579736948013,
0.3388527035713196,
0.12288330495357513,
0.5941120386123657,
0.24436409771442413,
0.1723129004240036,
0.2906929552555084,
0.20024877786636353,
0.6944255828857422,
-0.7510752081871033,
-0.5033366084098816,
-0.9459171295166016,
0.29195600748062134,
0.11426590383052826,
-0.35117343068122864,
0.6211563348770142,
0.639850914478302,
0.7855058312416077,
-0.04324443265795708,
1.1044926643371582,
-0.19173291325569153,
0.226450577378273,
-0.8430208563804626,
0.6440645456314087,
-0.17247973382472992,
0.17992836236953735,
0.12009350955486298,
-0.8263958096504211,
-0.5284567475318909,
0.4813469350337982,
-0.42298996448516846,
0.021654078736901283,
1.08443021774292,
0.9364129304885864,
0.005102740600705147,
0.041668735444545746,
0.5682989954948425,
0.045457832515239716,
0.4634658694267273,
0.7328967452049255,
0.6972689032554626,
-0.17066241800785065,
0.6321681141853333,
0.049099426716566086,
-0.18595321476459503,
0.14227774739265442,
-1.1582386493682861,
-1.2471680641174316,
-0.3993188142776489,
-0.41617169976234436,
-0.5447086095809937,
0.015884535387158394,
1.1681784391403198,
0.5026953220367432,
-0.7467831969261169,
-0.3769160509109497,
-0.7914822101593018,
-0.09128950536251068,
0.11525414139032364,
-0.29844680428504944,
0.2025952935218811,
-0.44938474893569946,
-0.9169194102287292,
0.18782752752304077,
0.3689800798892975,
0.053212396800518036,
-0.18355149030685425,
-0.06257741898298264,
-0.4112758934497833,
0.4386133551597595,
0.39886248111724854,
-0.15224824845790863,
-1.0173497200012207,
-0.2319975197315216,
-0.15272068977355957,
-0.4092680811882019,
0.1899295598268509,
1.3937017917633057,
-0.4314666986465454,
0.2305610030889511,
0.6648185849189758,
0.3936285078525543,
0.10956377536058426,
0.08063887804746628,
0.9148313999176025,
-0.7569290399551392,
0.04934293404221535,
0.17809757590293884,
0.5292935371398926,
0.039379775524139404,
-0.5372821092605591,
0.17656494677066803,
-0.07944124191999435,
-0.7834177017211914,
-0.37714579701423645,
0.5417453050613403,
-1.0880932807922363,
-0.32106515765190125,
1.4469413757324219,
-0.1953236311674118,
-0.3132575750350952,
0.15385566651821136,
-0.7011730074882507,
0.385736882686615,
-0.4956236183643341,
0.7032567262649536,
0.9785805940628052,
-0.08025010675191879,
-0.6329378485679626,
-0.27780184149742126,
0.7005631923675537,
0.3090464770793915,
-0.8338192701339722,
0.11420977860689163,
0.8097172379493713,
0.22665302455425262,
-0.00843678880482912,
0.6578658819198608,
-0.043194591999053955,
0.2625909745693207,
-0.3577541708946228,
0.0048881759867072105,
0.01786067709326744,
0.007066395133733749,
-0.4612221419811249,
0.7127737402915955,
0.048158299177885056,
0.2247621715068817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06120v1 | Exploring Group and Symmetry Principles in Large Language Models | 2024-02-09T01:10:25 | 2024-02-09T01:10:25 | Shima Imani, Hamid Palangi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance across
a wide range of applications; however, assessing their reasoning capabilities
remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we introduce a framework
grounded in group and symmetry principles, which have played a crucial role in
fields such as physics and mathematics, and offer another way to evaluate their
capabilities. While the proposed framework is general, to showcase the benefits
of employing these properties, we focus on arithmetic reasoning and investigate
the performance of these models on four group properties: closure, identity,
inverse, and associativity. Our findings reveal that LLMs studied in this work
struggle to preserve group properties across different test regimes. In the
closure test, we observe biases towards specific outputs and an abrupt
degradation in their performance from 100% to 0% after a specific sequence
length. They also perform poorly in the identity test, which represents adding
irrelevant information in the context, and show sensitivity when subjected to
inverse test, which examines the robustness of the model with respect to
negation. In addition, we demonstrate that breaking down problems into smaller
steps helps LLMs in the associativity test that we have conducted. To support
these tests we have developed a synthetic dataset which will be released. | [
-0.3564833402633667,
-0.4627820551395416,
0.7401206493377686,
0.11282544583082199,
-0.14173920452594757,
0.06446806341409683,
-0.16034869849681854,
-0.19349193572998047,
-0.032789215445518494,
0.43714046478271484,
-0.25480005145072937,
-0.5367773771286011,
-0.4868135452270508,
0.3784945011138916,
-0.4822121560573578,
0.612011730670929,
-0.09335064888000488,
0.4141739010810852,
-0.26675036549568176,
-0.6123893857002258,
-0.012755143456161022,
-0.8415299654006958,
-0.46785402297973633,
-0.5199264883995056,
0.09511856734752655,
0.1127472072839737,
0.9902177453041077,
0.8150392770767212,
0.5362622737884521,
0.27859124541282654,
-0.1368323564529419,
-0.055706121027469635,
-0.4554416835308075,
-0.02179238758981228,
-0.17419618368148804,
-0.6917339563369751,
-0.3876175880432129,
0.034286100417375565,
0.9430931210517883,
1.241369366645813,
-0.35724613070487976,
-0.0032181786373257637,
-0.11780343949794769,
0.6486232876777649,
-0.34022435545921326,
0.44927722215652466,
-0.7331991195678711,
-0.04264307767152786,
-0.026388654485344887,
0.4943980872631073,
-0.3336840569972992,
-0.4242766499519348,
-0.26143720746040344,
-0.6357026696205139,
0.28135502338409424,
0.2156834751367569,
0.7114441990852356,
-0.029456622898578644,
-0.4864068329334259,
-0.14790450036525726,
-0.4137694239616394,
0.788480818271637,
-0.9641781449317932,
0.6404873728752136,
0.5646189451217651,
0.21944014728069305,
-0.271451860666275,
-0.289543092250824,
-0.6250302791595459,
-0.06960812956094742,
-0.08715023845434189,
-0.06274950504302979,
0.15638329088687897,
0.2237900197505951,
0.4859566390514374,
0.7484778761863708,
-0.628362774848938,
0.16979125142097473,
-0.18529611825942993,
-0.09972092509269714,
0.6480106711387634,
0.22539681196212769,
0.3690589368343353,
0.08891642838716507,
0.03927742317318916,
-0.008815580978989601,
-0.9608492255210876,
0.08530556410551071,
0.48766952753067017,
0.2223711460828781,
-0.14754849672317505,
0.8193050622940063,
-0.031639546155929565,
0.6841629147529602,
-0.1394682377576828,
-0.38034817576408386,
0.2271163910627365,
-0.35766127705574036,
-0.1728270798921585,
-0.24633561074733734,
0.6341865658760071,
0.14170075953006744,
0.2678469717502594,
-0.2539305090904236,
-0.4077190160751343,
0.4530559480190277,
-0.4807947874069214,
-0.8063180446624756,
-0.04447280243039131,
-0.09243239462375641,
-0.5949610471725464,
-0.078606016933918,
0.2046431005001068,
-0.3792373836040497,
-0.23648977279663086,
-0.6231794357299805,
0.33085158467292786,
-0.5922726392745972,
-0.2788262963294983,
0.5016791224479675,
-0.11076828092336655,
0.2743005156517029,
0.3192187547683716,
-1.237420678138733,
0.7632794380187988,
1.1776336431503296,
0.644986629486084,
-0.1936275064945221,
-0.30495330691337585,
-0.5450034141540527,
0.16005615890026093,
-0.4192739427089691,
0.34711402654647827,
-0.7752261161804199,
-0.25129950046539307,
-0.16459940373897552,
-0.197771817445755,
-0.10530762374401093,
-0.5109944939613342,
0.32962584495544434,
-0.36392971873283386,
0.3605445921421051,
-0.3711927831172943,
-0.6817396879196167,
-0.17593489587306976,
0.2811787724494934,
-0.6902594566345215,
0.444519579410553,
-0.05414346978068352,
-0.42060187458992004,
0.12209727615118027,
-0.3840574622154236,
-0.3810930848121643,
-0.29327136278152466,
-0.6020656228065491,
-0.22617098689079285,
0.5065780878067017,
0.08472438901662827,
0.19287550449371338,
-0.5708193778991699,
0.19315172731876373,
-0.7302237153053284,
-0.4110586941242218,
0.26282280683517456,
-0.2457062005996704,
0.9074475765228271,
0.05799460411071777,
0.004763627890497446,
-0.12338379770517349,
-0.7902999520301819,
0.15860112011432648,
0.05001252517104149,
-0.10034438222646713,
-0.4870541989803314,
0.09385759383440018,
-0.8110871911048889,
0.13239401578903198,
-0.04983915016055107,
-0.27813300490379333,
0.4871310889720917,
-0.5637863278388977,
0.537993311882019,
0.9865763783454895,
-0.17543324828147888,
0.5085738897323608,
-0.23170040547847748,
0.4725722670555115,
-0.09497330337762833,
0.06723605841398239,
-0.23737621307373047,
-0.5046559572219849,
-0.6108296513557434,
-0.36056700348854065,
0.060768526047468185,
0.32610902190208435,
-0.4749087989330292,
0.5095314979553223,
-0.29570186138153076,
-0.18076913058757782,
-0.1759653389453888,
0.4733898341655731,
0.49778541922569275,
0.3368397057056427,
0.11354531347751617,
-0.21805378794670105,
-0.07160734385251999,
-0.9240203499794006,
-0.3716607391834259,
-0.48105424642562866,
-0.108071468770504,
0.03921215608716011,
0.37076616287231445,
-0.04732165113091469,
0.6711703538894653,
-0.4841589331626892,
0.1354883909225464,
-0.07448915392160416,
-0.12064014375209808,
0.7199409008026123,
-0.034945011138916016,
0.3585909605026245,
-0.7805308699607849,
-0.09452097117900848,
-0.08565037697553635,
-1.0307470560073853,
-0.40889206528663635,
0.34263595938682556,
-0.025503087788820267,
0.2781819999217987,
0.29677802324295044,
-0.9025618433952332,
0.4449428915977478,
0.8076333403587341,
-0.5472946166992188,
0.5484673380851746,
0.28524303436279297,
0.06001533940434456,
-0.9738566875457764,
-0.23636402189731598,
-0.03478660061955452,
-0.11295704543590546,
-0.4767179787158966,
0.2791885733604431,
-0.13212618231773376,
-0.23863811790943146,
-0.1484101265668869,
0.5579627156257629,
-0.6790770292282104,
-0.3432128429412842,
-0.020112888887524605,
-0.11776922643184662,
0.38168469071388245,
0.1649327278137207,
-0.1873096227645874,
0.5970554947853088,
0.618718147277832,
-0.6949996948242188,
0.333543598651886,
0.19531354308128357,
-0.20972010493278503,
0.3874832093715668,
-0.7405202388763428,
0.03539547696709633,
-0.2592046558856964,
0.017898783087730408,
-1.0363234281539917,
-0.20075587928295135,
0.003745785215869546,
-0.3645890951156616,
0.23345041275024414,
-0.184493750333786,
-0.8044622540473938,
-0.09118909388780594,
-0.23210953176021576,
0.7095750570297241,
0.6612240672111511,
-0.4086102247238159,
0.8987849950790405,
0.31174424290657043,
-0.017609456554055214,
-0.369834840297699,
-0.3978043496608734,
-0.2311418503522873,
-0.6073535680770874,
-0.9360001087188721,
0.1400332897901535,
-0.11368262767791748,
-1.0526907444000244,
-0.11156930029392242,
-0.15483985841274261,
0.08095462620258331,
0.17030154168605804,
0.1590930074453354,
0.21783824265003204,
-0.31114959716796875,
0.4253447651863098,
-0.17520885169506073,
-0.03158547356724739,
0.1888425350189209,
-0.19423584640026093,
0.7102421522140503,
-0.45255354046821594,
-0.6780551075935364,
-0.0062719169072806835,
0.3341132402420044,
0.7873974442481995,
-0.3476337492465973,
0.8762146234512329,
-0.03410862758755684,
-0.4586292803287506,
-0.061090245842933655,
-0.5949246883392334,
-0.3348879814147949,
-0.5027763843536377,
0.3048642873764038,
-0.39802786707878113,
-0.8309983015060425,
1.0238521099090576,
0.13479599356651306,
-0.028403548523783684,
0.33729973435401917,
0.5786241292953491,
0.24558860063552856,
1.120850920677185,
0.35781633853912354,
-0.15350309014320374,
0.0630679503083229,
-0.06694705784320831,
0.4647861123085022,
-0.7292816638946533,
0.013217386789619923,
-0.3206392228603363,
0.09824330359697342,
-0.34266167879104614,
-0.33143725991249084,
0.4657123386859894,
0.6061752438545227,
-0.4739012122154236,
-0.019372913986444473,
-0.005966225638985634,
0.6089239716529846,
0.04489175230264664,
-0.1481793075799942,
0.5660278797149658,
-0.002780199283733964,
-0.2266020029783249,
-0.10965635627508163,
-0.26039057970046997,
-0.6393643617630005,
0.9786243438720703,
0.42728739976882935,
1.121852993965149,
0.5394251346588135,
0.6211327314376831,
-0.16877900063991547,
0.42004120349884033,
-0.7911542654037476,
0.8184843063354492,
-0.18601027131080627,
-0.40728628635406494,
-0.4895158112049103,
-0.7498114109039307,
-0.648917019367218,
0.6346811652183533,
0.016362814232707024,
-0.7779081463813782,
-0.030566222965717316,
0.19076427817344666,
0.1873297393321991,
0.3737790584564209,
-0.687162458896637,
0.5507068634033203,
-0.35783588886260986,
-0.34182167053222656,
0.013042911887168884,
-0.41930973529815674,
0.7824589610099792,
-0.25917375087738037,
0.4334384799003601,
-0.277282178401947,
0.05384119600057602,
0.3808196485042572,
-0.48679086565971375,
0.6294124126434326,
0.1622132509946823,
-0.37375205755233765,
0.049958325922489166,
0.40424439311027527,
0.4605821967124939,
0.15972085297107697,
-0.5322490334510803,
0.5361723899841309,
-0.17463645339012146,
-0.14966042339801788,
-1.0297842025756836,
0.6615667939186096,
-0.6466754078865051,
-0.9746429324150085,
-0.27018508315086365,
-0.682253897190094,
-0.32664933800697327,
0.43770018219947815,
0.0317559652030468,
0.4161185324192047,
0.013381468132138252,
0.3170710802078247,
0.6524596214294434,
-0.02079237625002861,
0.3234122097492218,
0.49769872426986694,
-0.966253936290741,
-0.49936047196388245,
0.6634470224380493,
0.09969636052846909,
0.889644205570221,
0.16086523234844208,
0.4374869465827942,
-0.3984781503677368,
-0.4489760398864746,
-0.19079652428627014,
0.5839637517929077,
-0.841535747051239,
-0.015625298023223877,
-0.3248620629310608,
-0.06376311182975769,
-0.7655972838401794,
0.2676909863948822,
-0.2798374891281128,
-0.8060004711151123,
-0.10563268512487411,
-0.11680252104997635,
0.02693825401365757,
0.5353124737739563,
0.0263995248824358,
-0.08223288506269455,
-0.545606255531311,
0.6472060084342957,
0.242079958319664,
0.25090911984443665,
-0.1431063860654831,
-0.5258132815361023,
0.10887551307678223,
0.0826893150806427,
-0.2935221791267395,
-0.7532312273979187,
0.18810227513313293,
0.20676450431346893,
0.7660214304924011,
0.5581400394439697,
-0.10172748565673828,
0.5094765424728394,
-0.5987451076507568,
0.5893138647079468,
0.3108048737049103,
-1.256232738494873,
0.12331444770097733,
-0.5093811750411987,
-0.040038179606199265,
0.34265628457069397,
0.22035619616508484,
-0.31367772817611694,
-0.33380571007728577,
-0.38889580965042114,
-0.5856742262840271,
0.1654018759727478,
0.45059528946876526,
-0.015297388657927513,
0.1839045137166977,
0.4844932556152344,
-0.02328832820057869,
0.3833863437175751,
-0.9065694808959961,
-0.33339723944664,
-0.2979344129562378,
-0.3148622214794159,
-0.10367792099714279,
0.030453763902187347,
-0.2921657860279083,
-0.38602975010871887,
0.34543925523757935,
-0.2539062201976776,
-0.01986577920615673,
-0.14107857644557953,
0.18870021402835846,
0.005191045813262463,
0.2502804696559906,
0.5333566069602966,
1.1068209409713745,
0.12096162885427475,
0.16890981793403625,
0.18093444406986237,
-0.16767370700836182,
0.5278182029724121,
0.030438527464866638,
0.01462126336991787,
-0.3450259566307068,
0.6184024810791016,
0.42502182722091675,
-0.03754619508981705,
-0.37017014622688293,
0.4249153733253479,
-0.08895580470561981,
-0.26109442114830017,
-0.26064446568489075,
0.16460123658180237,
0.12818774580955505,
-0.05723077431321144,
0.3940035402774811,
-0.33059409260749817,
0.03325168415904045,
-0.901290237903595,
0.08053655922412872,
0.6476922631263733,
0.19631347060203552,
-0.512190043926239,
0.24356038868427277,
-0.24200858175754547,
-0.34820669889450073,
0.4798314869403839,
-0.2220015525817871,
-0.7493496537208557,
0.6018376350402832,
0.7576963305473328,
0.5474466681480408,
-0.456053227186203,
-0.14920537173748016,
0.0077026356011629105,
0.4469904899597168,
-0.3978547751903534,
0.2547098398208618,
0.22802580893039703,
-1.0138075351715088,
-0.3998938202857971,
-0.5529277324676514,
-0.3930792808532715,
0.10134398937225342,
-0.733073353767395,
0.23099590837955475,
-0.5651455521583557,
-0.009729769080877304,
-0.21986614167690277,
-0.32762548327445984,
-0.2963365614414215,
0.07509756088256836,
0.08077986538410187,
0.5922252535820007,
-1.0121020078659058,
0.4130525588989258,
0.5706254839897156,
-0.16367512941360474,
-0.8908402919769287,
-0.02401065267622471,
0.2024364322423935,
-1.1097190380096436,
0.7576466798782349,
0.4084920585155487,
-0.10073547065258026,
-0.2385583370923996,
-0.6018856167793274,
-1.2292325496673584,
0.8133476376533508,
0.7870463728904724,
-0.5188723206520081,
-0.1769283264875412,
0.323793888092041,
0.6332871913909912,
-0.4290250837802887,
0.02692514657974243,
0.37558528780937195,
0.5223907828330994,
0.2520238757133484,
-1.0010242462158203,
0.07582351565361023,
-0.26996690034866333,
-0.09036949276924133,
0.3695753812789917,
-0.8662634491920471,
1.271089792251587,
-0.1603168249130249,
-0.21536527574062347,
0.02177281677722931,
0.4851641356945038,
0.7771467566490173,
0.21781347692012787,
0.5689324736595154,
1.0166304111480713,
0.7638577818870544,
-0.14993064105510712,
1.0404771566390991,
-0.28370940685272217,
0.3622806966304779,
0.7818346619606018,
-0.7172443866729736,
0.44890812039375305,
0.44763392210006714,
-0.12920089066028595,
0.48025810718536377,
0.1298896223306656,
0.04661214351654053,
0.3353402614593506,
0.6421934962272644,
-0.24350717663764954,
-0.404440313577652,
-0.046412356197834015,
-0.4985118806362152,
0.46941107511520386,
0.5732976198196411,
-0.45270413160324097,
-0.2166520059108734,
-0.21224446594715118,
0.08018498122692108,
0.20615911483764648,
-0.43707937002182007,
0.5152037143707275,
0.5255419015884399,
-0.568345308303833,
0.46238401532173157,
0.04766951873898506,
0.06005958467721939,
-0.49357593059539795,
-0.35792356729507446,
-0.21108423173427582,
0.4178917407989502,
-0.1161177009344101,
-0.6290153861045837,
0.17413319647312164,
-0.3960433006286621,
-0.2922680675983429,
0.11643887311220169,
0.4228630065917969,
-0.3603760302066803,
-0.890626847743988,
0.16397127509117126,
0.20291858911514282,
0.10391730815172195,
0.20075784623622894,
-0.44797906279563904,
0.41533344984054565,
-0.1602916717529297,
-0.05133727937936783,
0.17305949330329895,
0.7148333191871643,
-0.12472136318683624,
0.860602855682373,
0.7069647312164307,
0.23394565284252167,
-0.025446094572544098,
0.1636265218257904,
1.0212002992630005,
-0.8093313574790955,
-0.3889573812484741,
-1.3066917657852173,
0.20035023987293243,
-0.052919380366802216,
-0.1261688619852066,
1.0527021884918213,
0.7112284302711487,
0.5786476135253906,
0.3721878230571747,
0.5686293840408325,
0.4724166691303253,
0.33780500292778015,
-0.9946709871292114,
0.4228264391422272,
-0.28286635875701904,
0.5683996677398682,
-0.34652766585350037,
-1.0482909679412842,
-0.47127270698547363,
0.860653817653656,
-0.27734896540641785,
0.2682186961174011,
0.8585567474365234,
0.5967523455619812,
-0.1870754361152649,
0.10778720676898956,
0.44809287786483765,
0.3012254238128662,
0.8759428262710571,
0.7228935360908508,
0.8814687728881836,
-0.3909200429916382,
0.21796172857284546,
0.08750452101230621,
-0.21263018250465393,
0.2794898450374603,
-0.9369632601737976,
-1.304347038269043,
-0.21034860610961914,
-0.07675551623106003,
-0.5394112467765808,
-0.2266848236322403,
0.6774637699127197,
0.5160120129585266,
-0.4537620544433594,
-0.3496832251548767,
-0.16647933423519135,
0.18653210997581482,
0.17572124302387238,
-0.25149446725845337,
0.30535566806793213,
-0.042887330055236816,
-0.33302244544029236,
0.13528437912464142,
0.36357381939888,
0.1726108342409134,
-0.49785271286964417,
-0.21956001222133636,
0.22146989405155182,
0.07146051526069641,
0.5092604756355286,
0.19362220168113708,
-0.8822762370109558,
-0.23553788661956787,
0.03642397001385689,
0.04826099053025246,
-0.1266455352306366,
0.8214197158813477,
-0.4020715355873108,
0.176642507314682,
0.3255126178264618,
0.5246420502662659,
0.08982271701097488,
0.410083144903183,
0.8448552489280701,
-0.29334840178489685,
0.10241948813199997,
0.23117023706436157,
0.81736159324646,
0.36783841252326965,
-0.14440099895000458,
0.6020201444625854,
0.37662068009376526,
-0.48831936717033386,
-1.0464977025985718,
0.5267916917800903,
-0.5046943426132202,
0.040108393877744675,
1.3681623935699463,
-0.2630097568035126,
-0.1757083684206009,
0.062287334352731705,
0.2514856457710266,
-0.24725914001464844,
-0.21050626039505005,
0.8246434926986694,
1.0880311727523804,
-0.2433827966451645,
-0.1273784339427948,
0.0031205967534333467,
0.10613494366407394,
0.528847873210907,
-0.7828183174133301,
0.20629562437534332,
0.7011234164237976,
0.3153265714645386,
0.3078347444534302,
0.4870893955230713,
-0.4008781313896179,
-0.05789484456181526,
-0.3942275643348694,
-0.2182997763156891,
-0.1298064887523651,
-0.2763086259365082,
-0.4496174454689026,
0.1541174352169037,
0.03750618174672127,
0.2041352242231369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06094v1 | Rethinking Data Selection for Supervised Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-08T23:02:04 | 2024-02-08T23:02:04 | Ming Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although supervised finetuning (SFT) has emerged as an essential technique to
align large language models with humans, it is considered superficial, with
style learning being its nature. At the same time, recent works indicate the
importance of data selection for SFT, showing that finetuning with high-quality
and diverse subsets of the original dataset leads to superior downstream
performance. In this work, we rethink the intuition behind data selection for
SFT. Considering SFT is superficial, we propose that essential demonstrations
for SFT should focus on reflecting human-like interactions instead of data
quality or diversity. However, it is not straightforward to directly assess to
what extent a demonstration reflects human styles. Towards an initial attempt
in this direction, we find selecting instances with long responses is
surprisingly more effective for SFT than utilizing full datasets or instances
selected based on quality and diversity. We hypothesize that such a simple
heuristic implicitly mimics a crucial aspect of human-style conversation:
detailed responses are usually more helpful. | [
-0.8023005723953247,
-1.0924605131149292,
0.5015279054641724,
0.23604440689086914,
-0.3345472514629364,
0.011888914741575718,
-0.6785324215888977,
-0.42899826169013977,
0.19095756113529205,
0.307810515165329,
-0.7626370191574097,
-0.409258633852005,
-0.188720703125,
0.14989742636680603,
-0.6870924234390259,
1.246842622756958,
0.12386710196733475,
-0.2020808309316635,
-0.26143133640289307,
-0.055220603942871094,
-0.45542293787002563,
-0.18863371014595032,
-0.9317222833633423,
-0.426917165517807,
0.5259751081466675,
0.8825445771217346,
0.9081082940101624,
0.9495106339454651,
0.3917403221130371,
0.19797246158123016,
0.09673646837472916,
0.28763267397880554,
-0.8749098777770996,
0.13901513814926147,
-0.21794329583644867,
-0.5017882585525513,
0.046457190066576004,
0.24885861575603485,
0.1514483392238617,
1.0220755338668823,
0.14049015939235687,
0.14762020111083984,
0.38396599888801575,
1.0886154174804688,
-0.34377172589302063,
-0.027228251099586487,
-0.5516521334648132,
0.06550159305334091,
-0.2926831841468811,
0.0019022146007046103,
-0.2188362181186676,
-0.11491736024618149,
0.36284929513931274,
-0.671296238899231,
0.7140735983848572,
0.06171179935336113,
0.8761182427406311,
0.5548504590988159,
-0.3409602642059326,
0.07010383903980255,
-0.8625686764717102,
0.7237917184829712,
-0.41104191541671753,
0.5616775751113892,
0.6376754641532898,
0.5235925316810608,
-0.024470612406730652,
-0.5074280500411987,
-0.2922130525112152,
-0.40119749307632446,
-0.21675889194011688,
0.11182747036218643,
0.13840819895267487,
-0.0017249754164367914,
0.4619845449924469,
0.5360816121101379,
-0.4278427064418793,
0.4330730736255646,
-0.46957889199256897,
-0.04901066794991493,
0.8870371580123901,
0.11066143959760666,
-0.271712064743042,
-0.04389486089348793,
-0.11663844436407089,
-0.23905836045742035,
-0.5944571495056152,
0.3393624424934387,
0.41466477513313293,
0.5375750660896301,
-0.1512984186410904,
0.3553240895271301,
-0.8550986647605896,
0.673486053943634,
0.48764997720718384,
0.10960973054170609,
0.09040533006191254,
-0.3576790988445282,
-0.2327026128768921,
-0.21549390256404877,
0.9212689995765686,
0.5700803995132446,
0.7156214118003845,
-0.20106469094753265,
-0.17921435832977295,
-0.16177721321582794,
0.5473055243492126,
-0.8381933569908142,
-0.4784793555736542,
0.11519281566143036,
-0.4043247401714325,
-0.38040223717689514,
0.3253442645072937,
-0.9142204523086548,
-0.04165342077612877,
-0.9051241874694824,
0.057500772178173065,
-0.30335623025894165,
-0.19463658332824707,
0.1255960762500763,
-0.05120968073606491,
-0.1208416223526001,
0.2548123300075531,
-1.1080472469329834,
0.39695292711257935,
0.781830906867981,
0.49242275953292847,
-0.27828824520111084,
-0.27899959683418274,
-0.5780996084213257,
-0.19940806925296783,
-0.6836905479431152,
0.7169427871704102,
-0.5456565022468567,
-0.4792347550392151,
-0.3125167191028595,
0.06878097355365753,
0.3186579644680023,
-0.4160284698009491,
0.6773434281349182,
-0.10926695913076401,
0.21872273087501526,
-0.42707347869873047,
-0.28402701020240784,
0.0050643314607441425,
-0.163599893450737,
-0.7029961943626404,
0.9808416962623596,
0.3474093973636627,
-0.6991270780563354,
1.1233307123184204,
-0.3519160747528076,
-0.6767691373825073,
-0.14125044643878937,
-0.3358570635318756,
-0.6363252401351929,
0.07099194079637527,
0.396404504776001,
0.9381128549575806,
-0.055397190153598785,
0.3257017731666565,
-0.7034021615982056,
-0.7898934483528137,
0.2299271821975708,
-0.45354804396629333,
0.18763379752635956,
0.5363022685050964,
-0.5026089549064636,
0.1518884003162384,
-0.7047308087348938,
0.07014674693346024,
-0.021247681230306625,
-0.3441314399242401,
-0.47512346506118774,
0.08682896941900253,
0.11154007166624069,
0.12190268188714981,
-0.31428951025009155,
-0.44046086072921753,
0.15721391141414642,
-0.38315725326538086,
0.4852724075317383,
0.7917307019233704,
-0.20828525722026825,
0.5454750657081604,
-0.48413893580436707,
0.25144127011299133,
-0.36429136991500854,
0.15916787087917328,
0.27097025513648987,
-0.023336214944720268,
-0.4471573233604431,
-0.33098527789115906,
0.40931472182273865,
0.2719591557979584,
-0.693040668964386,
0.26232072710990906,
-0.29632458090782166,
-0.46950170397758484,
-0.7706617712974548,
0.42750629782676697,
0.3892010748386383,
0.39102599024772644,
0.3653649389743805,
-0.31347963213920593,
-0.42221978306770325,
-1.2341406345367432,
-0.19768843054771423,
0.1788347214460373,
-0.18127773702144623,
0.476457417011261,
0.05849317088723183,
-0.16706658899784088,
1.2833764553070068,
-0.6024149656295776,
0.006356424652040005,
-0.20519223809242249,
-0.019371842965483665,
0.022213000804185867,
0.5851874351501465,
1.0839704275131226,
-0.7657685279846191,
-0.45991650223731995,
0.035978998988866806,
-0.472184956073761,
-0.09807222336530685,
-0.4348472058773041,
-0.28365233540534973,
0.007526564411818981,
0.5831140279769897,
-0.27796822786331177,
0.4493248164653778,
0.27606478333473206,
-0.10456354171037674,
0.5370418429374695,
0.030290963128209114,
0.28202417492866516,
-0.9080426096916199,
-0.2299104630947113,
0.40631532669067383,
-0.38362616300582886,
-0.3485102951526642,
-0.09800411015748978,
0.029951022937893867,
0.10172542184591293,
-0.17385511100292206,
0.3847354054450989,
-0.23094360530376434,
0.018437394872307777,
-0.18870232999324799,
-0.1732030063867569,
-0.15788017213344574,
0.5266662836074829,
-0.03751015663146973,
0.854954183101654,
0.49594640731811523,
-0.6561464667320251,
0.1889774054288864,
0.20404283702373505,
-0.32353559136390686,
0.798708975315094,
-0.7955968976020813,
0.16419954597949982,
-0.009028258733451366,
0.17936542630195618,
-1.1038061380386353,
-0.6205393075942993,
-0.2608156204223633,
-0.2809523344039917,
0.4130622446537018,
-0.3476523756980896,
-0.5432154536247253,
-0.49130091071128845,
-0.36890602111816406,
0.1830676645040512,
0.4745379090309143,
-0.68952476978302,
-0.09094437211751938,
0.060563910752534866,
-0.13117463886737823,
-0.176808699965477,
-0.5103365778923035,
-0.06821350008249283,
-0.5631214380264282,
-0.6164320111274719,
0.1657686084508896,
-0.09526079893112183,
-0.29006385803222656,
-0.5101762413978577,
-0.2551741302013397,
-0.04833025857806206,
0.5316798090934753,
0.24461500346660614,
0.021650712937116623,
-0.18644823133945465,
-0.011007668450474739,
0.3772432804107666,
0.029741376638412476,
-0.13305909931659698,
-0.009492033161222935,
0.3233281075954437,
-0.11292111873626709,
-0.41605082154273987,
-0.735740065574646,
0.36188364028930664,
0.34866923093795776,
-0.10973693430423737,
0.33481284976005554,
0.9230815172195435,
0.14071735739707947,
-0.2273857444524765,
-0.6103517413139343,
-0.6289902329444885,
-0.4778133034706116,
0.3065625727176666,
-0.48026156425476074,
-1.060509443283081,
0.21924139559268951,
-0.013486295938491821,
0.0986473485827446,
0.2126377820968628,
0.1434258073568344,
-0.3887767195701599,
1.0867029428482056,
0.5757021307945251,
-0.030424680560827255,
0.9248458743095398,
-0.28410467505455017,
-0.07295127958059311,
-0.5985880494117737,
0.16889892518520355,
-0.4971407353878021,
-0.5781829953193665,
-0.8930109739303589,
0.23143529891967773,
0.03744358569383621,
0.12407545000314713,
-0.2685956358909607,
0.29563742876052856,
-0.6048154234886169,
0.6056776642799377,
0.6645531058311462,
0.4579874873161316,
0.0671035498380661,
0.11968974024057388,
0.25265830755233765,
-0.20203649997711182,
-0.3405730128288269,
-0.46300598978996277,
1.0938910245895386,
0.267269104719162,
0.9692630767822266,
-0.20803460478782654,
0.7477299571037292,
-0.07873499393463135,
0.0034695619251579046,
-0.9316892623901367,
0.2763559818267822,
-0.5399855375289917,
-0.31422361731529236,
-0.5084364414215088,
-0.3571479022502899,
-1.1053065061569214,
0.04268139600753784,
-0.1927739828824997,
-0.43004491925239563,
0.03089158609509468,
0.36441025137901306,
-0.6052772402763367,
-0.22414977848529816,
-0.8949996829032898,
0.7283565402030945,
-0.02077639475464821,
-0.5786648988723755,
-0.18069182336330414,
-0.7892599105834961,
0.2008049488067627,
-0.14138510823249817,
0.17289753258228302,
0.06530078500509262,
0.5160606503486633,
0.9302223920822144,
-0.26216885447502136,
0.951082706451416,
-0.027559874579310417,
-0.0914422869682312,
0.09921137243509293,
0.24974505603313446,
0.19105872511863708,
0.2799917161464691,
0.07348614186048508,
-0.16765451431274414,
0.027593566104769707,
-0.4056989550590515,
-0.615280270576477,
0.7311672568321228,
-0.6415751576423645,
-0.6601845026016235,
0.5042330622673035,
-0.34929290413856506,
-0.49857816100120544,
0.0468791164457798,
0.17005881667137146,
0.44133874773979187,
-0.01910644769668579,
0.7338994145393372,
0.589887261390686,
0.220253124833107,
0.14124615490436554,
0.2272712141275406,
-0.11323167383670807,
-0.08525264263153076,
0.9361480474472046,
0.22478142380714417,
0.7190395593643188,
0.01833820343017578,
0.3194105625152588,
0.14458458125591278,
-0.5583310723304749,
-0.40531420707702637,
0.11106385290622711,
-0.3657532334327698,
0.04717963933944702,
-0.4606867730617523,
0.16729484498500824,
-0.30084294080734253,
-0.45025402307510376,
-0.4382705092430115,
-0.6235082745552063,
-0.47574225068092346,
-0.4702816307544708,
0.6104755401611328,
0.5450977087020874,
-0.06288610398769379,
0.4132118821144104,
-0.35462555289268494,
0.5126965045928955,
0.6383282542228699,
0.5464196801185608,
-0.1650080680847168,
-0.355285108089447,
-0.16623225808143616,
0.4055856168270111,
-0.38506999611854553,
-0.3733232021331787,
0.04395955801010132,
0.26953908801078796,
0.6575616598129272,
0.6271718144416809,
-0.0265305545181036,
0.9551751017570496,
-0.3954094350337982,
0.6880773305892944,
-0.4058046340942383,
-0.5284563899040222,
0.7322596907615662,
-0.5215617418289185,
-0.023224713280797005,
1.1200586557388306,
0.36222603917121887,
-0.5699326992034912,
-0.5860859155654907,
-0.7331718802452087,
-0.8816186785697937,
0.6540781855583191,
-0.015613135881721973,
0.195999413728714,
0.038636211305856705,
0.4554879665374756,
0.6128136515617371,
0.20685778558254242,
-0.18702730536460876,
-0.0539267398416996,
-0.47568508982658386,
-0.10768105834722519,
-0.11309206485748291,
0.038082726299762726,
-0.14210160076618195,
-0.47453388571739197,
0.25581714510917664,
-0.47290197014808655,
0.14033262431621552,
0.02041100151836872,
0.07798627763986588,
-0.1639285534620285,
0.35419178009033203,
0.43878641724586487,
0.5734630823135376,
-0.14933167397975922,
-0.17197231948375702,
-0.0048284465447068214,
-0.34243181347846985,
-0.3700341582298279,
0.01927848719060421,
-0.023760100826621056,
-0.08398742973804474,
0.3872458338737488,
1.0368905067443848,
0.4211962819099426,
-0.3445075452327728,
0.39020511507987976,
0.07306760549545288,
-0.3870600163936615,
0.1343822330236435,
0.5049602389335632,
-0.22666683793067932,
0.14867983758449554,
0.3004343807697296,
0.04254240542650223,
0.21571311354637146,
-0.5695738196372986,
0.43768104910850525,
0.5522632598876953,
-0.5891227126121521,
-0.2053547203540802,
0.6178587079048157,
0.08771044760942459,
-0.22426848113536835,
0.8187833428382874,
-0.05519790202379227,
-0.30522266030311584,
0.6202212572097778,
0.1655159443616867,
0.6424660682678223,
0.18369725346565247,
0.09443987160921097,
0.33761173486709595,
-0.09036815166473389,
-0.38673141598701477,
0.06985299289226532,
-0.4055982530117035,
-0.47975245118141174,
-0.47763967514038086,
-0.5358996391296387,
-0.1557222455739975,
0.04322686046361923,
-1.1329485177993774,
0.39944177865982056,
-0.3950805068016052,
-0.024587681517004967,
-0.044212281703948975,
-0.07126469910144806,
-0.8204764723777771,
0.27561748027801514,
-0.0027669977862387896,
0.8596711754798889,
-1.0975178480148315,
0.602042019367218,
0.31856510043144226,
-0.3723617494106293,
-1.0454919338226318,
0.25026965141296387,
-0.02246136963367462,
-0.7122877836227417,
0.6803440451622009,
0.10986411571502686,
0.1546928733587265,
0.060063522309064865,
-1.0035430192947388,
-0.580820620059967,
0.9926379323005676,
0.27650585770606995,
-0.5115240812301636,
0.03826746717095375,
-0.24625122547149658,
0.7403120398521423,
-0.1724109947681427,
0.025346878916025162,
0.8931161165237427,
0.21255341172218323,
0.2790515124797821,
-1.434621810913086,
-0.013522448018193245,
0.05581459403038025,
0.01689239777624607,
0.1193779781460762,
-0.8434081673622131,
0.6390067338943481,
-0.34567901492118835,
-0.14009849727153778,
0.042910993099212646,
0.7645366787910461,
0.12072266638278961,
0.2094915360212326,
0.5334299206733704,
0.2404586225748062,
0.5089857578277588,
-0.3067609965801239,
1.0360426902770996,
0.18969573080539703,
0.41321447491645813,
1.0070478916168213,
0.09625296294689178,
0.7161887288093567,
0.6301712989807129,
-0.3711216151714325,
0.2482413947582245,
1.0327521562576294,
-0.04732871800661087,
0.7980837821960449,
0.17379912734031677,
0.2569935619831085,
-0.46944594383239746,
0.12820233404636383,
-0.23661160469055176,
0.5748912692070007,
0.32701948285102844,
-0.1602904498577118,
-0.053289495408535004,
0.10572659969329834,
0.036555610597133636,
0.21429510414600372,
-0.15571902692317963,
1.0687286853790283,
-0.07957689464092255,
-0.7347375154495239,
0.8348692655563354,
-0.456797331571579,
0.9556601643562317,
-0.1748882681131363,
0.02084212191402912,
-0.3334197998046875,
-0.08071248978376389,
-0.4931008815765381,
-1.0886266231536865,
0.1899711787700653,
-0.22979041934013367,
-0.21392928063869476,
-0.41340121626853943,
0.20342902839183807,
-0.4907682538032532,
-0.1981988102197647,
-0.08064258098602295,
0.2654312551021576,
0.2327936440706253,
-0.15419189631938934,
-0.40206220746040344,
-0.27512413263320923,
0.1347484588623047,
-0.2912346422672272,
0.511872410774231,
0.582617461681366,
-0.41540998220443726,
0.6910028457641602,
0.8865488767623901,
-0.12042995542287827,
-0.3513130843639374,
0.362152099609375,
0.8309561014175415,
-0.35322147607803345,
-0.5714946389198303,
-0.9338484406471252,
0.5027064085006714,
-0.2115044742822647,
-0.28570476174354553,
0.5661281943321228,
0.4010782539844513,
1.17758047580719,
-0.12202241271734238,
0.762173593044281,
0.23866666853427887,
0.5795375108718872,
-0.697991669178009,
0.7210661172866821,
-0.45942798256874084,
0.039956651628017426,
-0.7147645950317383,
-0.6542069315910339,
-0.07332505285739899,
0.8651371598243713,
-0.3578158915042877,
0.1751052439212799,
0.6442805528640747,
0.6338185667991638,
-0.40482035279273987,
0.33450156450271606,
0.2804467976093292,
-0.07334832102060318,
0.4664155840873718,
0.3307538628578186,
0.6336337327957153,
0.039868660271167755,
0.3954647481441498,
-0.6349221467971802,
-0.27856507897377014,
-0.34962350130081177,
-0.6596964001655579,
-1.012276530265808,
-0.7267321348190308,
-0.12418162822723389,
-0.11281155794858932,
-0.20483490824699402,
1.1740771532058716,
1.0031849145889282,
-0.5681413412094116,
-0.06540482491254807,
0.09784185141324997,
-0.1846061497926712,
-0.43947193026542664,
-0.2922368347644806,
0.17762593924999237,
-0.37549087405204773,
-0.634162962436676,
0.3350693881511688,
-0.1742406189441681,
0.3717457950115204,
-0.10117983818054199,
0.14743289351463318,
0.3191060721874237,
-0.4200874865055084,
0.5910307168960571,
0.1440076380968094,
-0.688758373260498,
-0.4855225086212158,
-0.08473239094018936,
-0.13683663308620453,
-0.019717620685696602,
0.7689836621284485,
-0.9863153696060181,
0.10757146030664444,
0.20352017879486084,
0.923988938331604,
0.5551506876945496,
0.1948767453432083,
0.6209861040115356,
-1.04074227809906,
0.08606326580047607,
-0.117131806910038,
0.22693908214569092,
0.43862491846084595,
-0.5730515122413635,
0.6446978449821472,
0.09349000453948975,
-0.5981411337852478,
-0.7675065398216248,
0.28176379203796387,
-1.0193802118301392,
-0.23452679812908173,
1.3389055728912354,
0.2182788997888565,
-0.10130853950977325,
-0.132277250289917,
-0.7367458343505859,
-0.008960793726146221,
-0.6000784635543823,
1.0619226694107056,
0.7310490608215332,
-0.2935405671596527,
-0.017170581966638565,
-0.8279116749763489,
0.7619749307632446,
0.38179105520248413,
-0.7181199193000793,
0.3534854054450989,
0.5509613156318665,
0.4253024756908417,
-0.055902380496263504,
0.3714147210121155,
0.4754752516746521,
0.40869051218032837,
-0.5475253462791443,
-0.5498794317245483,
-0.21618123352527618,
-0.34379440546035767,
-0.07792309671640396,
0.0027922268491238356,
0.16799959540367126,
-0.030489925295114517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06073v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06073v2 | LightCAM: A Fast and Light Implementation of Context-Aware Masking based D-TDNN for Speaker Verification | 2024-02-08T21:47:16 | 2024-02-12T15:28:38 | Di Cao, Xianchen Wang, Junfeng Zhou, Jiakai Zhang, Yanjing Lei, Wenpeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Traditional Time Delay Neural Networks (TDNN) have achieved state-of-the-art
performance at the cost of high computational complexity and slower inference
speed, making them difficult to implement in an industrial environment. The
Densely Connected Time Delay Neural Network (D-TDNN) with Context Aware Masking
(CAM) module has proven to be an efficient structure to reduce complexity while
maintaining system performance. In this paper, we propose a fast and
lightweight model, LightCAM, which further adopts a depthwise separable
convolution module (DSM) and uses multi-scale feature aggregation (MFA) for
feature fusion at different levels. Extensive experiments are conducted on
VoxCeleb dataset, the comparative results show that it has achieved an EER of
0.83 and MinDCF of 0.0891 in VoxCeleb1-O, which outperforms the other
mainstream speaker verification methods. In addition, complexity analysis
further demonstrates that the proposed architecture has lower computational
cost and faster inference speed. | [
-0.5311632752418518,
-0.8151726722717285,
0.4450559914112091,
0.18320997059345245,
-0.45881757140159607,
0.10895846039056778,
-0.04183153435587883,
-0.6349799633026123,
0.077012799680233,
0.07771015167236328,
-0.26595133543014526,
-0.2968711853027344,
-0.46121716499328613,
-0.1218961775302887,
-0.5927572846412659,
-0.045670606195926666,
0.5433853268623352,
-0.0902090072631836,
0.13187865912914276,
-0.17453789710998535,
-0.4273921847343445,
0.050926048308610916,
-0.5250130891799927,
-0.28531527519226074,
0.6437084078788757,
0.3882402777671814,
0.5723701119422913,
0.5586308836936951,
0.1686239093542099,
0.48081734776496887,
-0.42473122477531433,
0.3029720187187195,
-0.06976334750652313,
-0.14247427880764008,
-0.03256772831082344,
0.32706183195114136,
-0.7513976693153381,
-0.24995821714401245,
0.6102648973464966,
0.7885829210281372,
0.15373595058918,
0.14762529730796814,
-0.28412649035453796,
0.23602458834648132,
-0.6410656571388245,
-0.05287111923098564,
-0.8687393069267273,
-0.03805837407708168,
-0.15948174893856049,
-0.2846071124076843,
-0.4211452007293701,
-0.026329346001148224,
0.1224125325679779,
-0.08892011642456055,
0.2903931140899658,
0.12004036456346512,
0.4467596709728241,
0.2750031352043152,
-0.5274630188941956,
0.567604124546051,
-1.0289604663848877,
0.6194822788238525,
-0.580839991569519,
0.4611995220184326,
-0.11132898181676865,
0.8242056965827942,
-0.12018795311450958,
-0.4948939383029938,
-0.8666045665740967,
0.21774637699127197,
-0.09784307330846786,
-0.1680207997560501,
0.15721429884433746,
0.10130224376916885,
0.2914227843284607,
0.47916314005851746,
-0.6059888005256653,
0.13447457551956177,
-0.3208119869232178,
-0.3040916323661804,
0.6043775677680969,
-0.03383106365799904,
0.15823803842067719,
-0.18479961156845093,
-0.5308328866958618,
0.019736947491765022,
-0.16167311370372772,
-0.044850800186395645,
-0.04902774095535278,
0.2874203622341156,
-0.16443699598312378,
0.0376783087849617,
-0.468331903219223,
0.9899849891662598,
-0.37751713395118713,
-0.5265138149261475,
0.016444554552435875,
-0.2809734046459198,
-0.20186957716941833,
0.6285954713821411,
0.5504832863807678,
0.23249274492263794,
-0.16800852119922638,
-0.1831972450017929,
-0.18568174540996552,
0.4366989731788635,
-0.22426344454288483,
-0.8895045518875122,
0.0639968067407608,
0.45639073848724365,
-0.5629918575286865,
-0.005307183135300875,
0.014026344753801823,
-0.8708353638648987,
-0.21145842969417572,
-0.20047913491725922,
0.7408897876739502,
-0.21486832201480865,
-0.6942281126976013,
0.3812452256679535,
0.23351554572582245,
0.42340368032455444,
0.703933596611023,
-0.6035661697387695,
0.21567265689373016,
0.7113404273986816,
0.9935800433158875,
-0.21720637381076813,
-0.09478766471147537,
-0.7171677947044373,
0.09049158543348312,
-0.3180178701877594,
0.3884475529193878,
-0.08234058320522308,
-0.07200273126363754,
-0.25299072265625,
-0.035062238574028015,
0.12027128785848618,
-0.3161850869655609,
0.16057667136192322,
-0.5635946393013,
-0.09950857609510422,
0.17254240810871124,
-0.5220198631286621,
-0.16665855050086975,
0.13394320011138916,
-0.5282824039459229,
0.7224269509315491,
0.25536754727363586,
-0.7040652632713318,
0.5966724753379822,
-0.1972482055425644,
-0.43136054277420044,
0.619310736656189,
-0.4547220766544342,
-0.3981088399887085,
-0.13334223628044128,
0.24189704656600952,
0.6048213243484497,
-0.0830223336815834,
0.5436156392097473,
-0.3478306531906128,
-0.956121563911438,
0.09448635578155518,
-0.4002331495285034,
0.8082922697067261,
0.4130055904388428,
-0.8078144788742065,
-0.06845752894878387,
-1.2536556720733643,
0.0007472576689906418,
-0.11601152271032333,
-0.17080694437026978,
-0.06767259538173676,
-0.19029326736927032,
0.23847022652626038,
0.149867981672287,
-0.3252451717853546,
-0.9782223105430603,
-0.10213489085435867,
-0.12938810884952545,
0.48048070073127747,
0.33641260862350464,
-0.06813431531190872,
0.026422956958413124,
0.023260926827788353,
0.1735825389623642,
0.352412611246109,
0.11440172046422958,
-0.4384058713912964,
-0.5321367979049683,
-0.549183189868927,
-0.584749162197113,
0.3198116719722748,
0.37408116459846497,
-1.0507378578186035,
0.5926645994186401,
-0.39110010862350464,
-0.6880899667739868,
-0.29146435856819153,
-0.19028180837631226,
0.41245532035827637,
0.9329810738563538,
0.1541244387626648,
-0.16183777153491974,
-0.3787727952003479,
-0.9414767622947693,
0.09475474059581757,
-0.05803075432777405,
-0.2323581725358963,
0.5404551029205322,
0.3367161750793457,
-0.05592988803982735,
0.9547582864761353,
-0.29452791810035706,
-0.19091743230819702,
-0.12017204612493515,
-0.06794368475675583,
0.24972781538963318,
0.7048987746238708,
0.7937658429145813,
-1.0336748361587524,
-0.08147513121366501,
-0.06517262011766434,
-0.5444900989532471,
-0.04541706666350365,
0.05462966486811638,
0.2969363033771515,
0.14412596821784973,
0.33529675006866455,
-0.3466155529022217,
0.9701198935508728,
0.45329469442367554,
-0.49287015199661255,
-0.001931609003804624,
-0.09638592600822449,
0.48512303829193115,
-0.8082370162010193,
0.029911059886217117,
-0.16522575914859772,
-0.5646779537200928,
-0.7529918551445007,
-0.6628250479698181,
0.2922276556491852,
-0.3959416449069977,
-1.0190590620040894,
0.6553438305854797,
-0.36666813492774963,
-0.5145244002342224,
-0.27114343643188477,
0.34994667768478394,
0.2977447211742401,
0.6521053910255432,
0.0972076877951622,
0.7069921493530273,
0.6444035768508911,
-1.032283902168274,
0.5606326460838318,
-0.16553443670272827,
-0.8988373279571533,
0.4256030321121216,
-0.6161438822746277,
0.04682859778404236,
0.15937329828739166,
0.39392536878585815,
-1.181213617324829,
0.030520059168338776,
-0.13426455855369568,
-0.0736585408449173,
0.24611130356788635,
-0.259957492351532,
-0.38862845301628113,
-0.3606977164745331,
0.18735545873641968,
1.2583038806915283,
0.4532108008861542,
-0.9625625014305115,
0.4919520318508148,
0.1738734394311905,
0.03298008814454079,
-0.40574368834495544,
-0.773871660232544,
0.2615480422973633,
-0.042542923241853714,
-0.9099843502044678,
0.8813268542289734,
0.03159523010253906,
-0.35969674587249756,
-0.5264483094215393,
-0.1090770736336708,
0.0026963402051478624,
0.07982026785612106,
-0.2023797333240509,
0.07450247555971146,
-0.24203822016716003,
0.12992747128009796,
-0.3043482005596161,
-0.17007744312286377,
-0.49436306953430176,
-0.16413646936416626,
0.1857031285762787,
-0.044765472412109375,
-0.509255588054657,
-0.6133686304092407,
0.5639576315879822,
0.45930927991867065,
0.014136750251054764,
0.37147337198257446,
0.9046490788459778,
-0.4645323157310486,
-0.33981266617774963,
-1.070412516593933,
-0.4151564836502075,
-0.5030665993690491,
0.3592683970928192,
-0.1607714742422104,
-0.9692943096160889,
0.5436071753501892,
-0.02229919843375683,
-0.4328862130641937,
0.06906197220087051,
0.3456078767776489,
0.38039693236351013,
0.8354082703590393,
0.4731994569301605,
0.14344683289527893,
0.5000605583190918,
-0.1775035560131073,
0.23722200095653534,
-0.5248365998268127,
-0.4237769544124603,
-0.537958562374115,
-0.591397225856781,
-0.4611518979072571,
-0.5441546440124512,
0.3157576322555542,
-0.3406984806060791,
0.16529227793216705,
0.3896809220314026,
-0.6239600777626038,
0.3733671009540558,
0.339031457901001,
0.478805273771286,
0.3022960424423218,
-0.2964978516101837,
0.07925941795110703,
0.05059218779206276,
-0.7428889870643616,
-0.1661732792854309,
0.3376271426677704,
0.19852498173713684,
0.5235646367073059,
0.045050110667943954,
0.21699590981006622,
0.296303391456604,
-0.3122391700744629,
-0.6786739826202393,
0.9791742563247681,
0.09536097198724747,
-0.47422125935554504,
-0.39826786518096924,
-0.6857039332389832,
-0.4376210868358612,
0.41239455342292786,
0.12718014419078827,
-0.8837845921516418,
0.6729516386985779,
0.17791293561458588,
-0.3602104187011719,
0.646075963973999,
-0.8174296021461487,
0.5969043970108032,
-0.4083591401576996,
-0.7138239145278931,
-0.15136578679084778,
-0.6862972378730774,
0.4463251233100891,
0.2689553499221802,
0.1915932595729828,
-0.4001300632953644,
0.1217336654663086,
0.7046397924423218,
-0.5310766696929932,
0.45213210582733154,
-0.5885417461395264,
-0.0151064433157444,
0.28799667954444885,
0.040725093334913254,
0.08645464479923248,
0.49755972623825073,
-0.08598526567220688,
0.15734362602233887,
-0.3004402220249176,
-0.49524417519569397,
-0.5021238923072815,
0.5948439240455627,
-0.446906715631485,
-0.6421439051628113,
-0.11833450198173523,
-0.5068105459213257,
-0.23538674414157867,
0.18728995323181152,
0.05199422314763069,
0.9856663942337036,
-0.1441696584224701,
0.6528279781341553,
0.9798128604888916,
-0.31335920095443726,
1.089863657951355,
0.40675705671310425,
-0.16224239766597748,
-0.42659324407577515,
0.5142858624458313,
0.08109403401613235,
0.06158934161067009,
0.44840186834335327,
0.0856531485915184,
0.008382159285247326,
-0.5975476503372192,
-0.37240058183670044,
-0.22568850219249725,
-0.4657772481441498,
-0.3254954218864441,
-0.6785367131233215,
-0.368704229593277,
-0.504595935344696,
-0.06076112017035484,
-0.5758154988288879,
-0.6145041584968567,
0.06565268337726593,
0.19080118834972382,
0.5162578821182251,
0.27142876386642456,
0.2735660970211029,
0.5497990846633911,
-0.32042157649993896,
0.575469434261322,
0.9323348999023438,
0.7316140532493591,
0.10351502150297165,
-0.42596563696861267,
-0.28754130005836487,
-0.18497003614902496,
-0.05322525277733803,
-0.5317403674125671,
-0.04772135987877846,
0.3250621259212494,
0.5897559523582458,
0.6070056557655334,
0.13747096061706543,
0.6439952254295349,
-0.16468843817710876,
0.8450060486793518,
-0.019526910036802292,
-1.1232191324234009,
0.576675534248352,
-0.32080820202827454,
0.5626818537712097,
0.32866182923316956,
-0.36382409930229187,
-0.4408791959285736,
0.07186304032802582,
-0.572508692741394,
-0.7932988405227661,
1.0436396598815918,
0.2671873867511749,
-0.29594993591308594,
0.299862802028656,
0.39452695846557617,
0.13070546090602875,
0.1883498579263687,
-0.4006396234035492,
-0.20678524672985077,
-0.590918242931366,
0.23283357918262482,
-0.22551533579826355,
-0.5252364873886108,
0.03829146921634674,
-0.4394817650318146,
0.40088120102882385,
-0.18272584676742554,
0.2441866248846054,
0.5392354130744934,
-0.18365877866744995,
0.15236695110797882,
0.4769365191459656,
1.0827432870864868,
0.890953004360199,
-0.47747811675071716,
0.36530232429504395,
0.3395923376083374,
-0.202484592795372,
0.3586943447589874,
0.009932405315339565,
0.12150514870882034,
0.4565897583961487,
0.434476763010025,
0.7438650727272034,
0.5409405827522278,
-0.20573465526103973,
0.9749407768249512,
-0.3226708769798279,
-0.2033592313528061,
-0.014421625062823296,
0.09745103120803833,
-0.0007976204506121576,
0.2511489987373352,
0.5264947414398193,
-0.14348097145557404,
0.1786094307899475,
-0.18245556950569153,
0.34516823291778564,
0.1982487440109253,
-0.15452279150485992,
-0.18011817336082458,
0.7955649495124817,
0.3703143000602722,
-0.5873973369598389,
0.3212512135505676,
-0.21258644759655,
-0.4143633544445038,
0.8289615511894226,
0.2382989227771759,
0.9789509177207947,
-0.4355488419532776,
-0.014132567681372166,
0.13956956565380096,
0.17806829512119293,
0.2110542505979538,
0.4425630271434784,
-0.5332637429237366,
-0.37202852964401245,
-0.25440534949302673,
-0.47716012597084045,
-0.44619521498680115,
0.11207380890846252,
-0.07400989532470703,
0.39275723695755005,
-0.4355843961238861,
-0.12062841653823853,
-0.06588049978017807,
0.047607630491256714,
-0.7762414216995239,
0.5239351391792297,
0.2971722483634949,
1.0517914295196533,
-0.734779417514801,
0.962716817855835,
0.15893198549747467,
0.17042407393455505,
-0.8597267270088196,
-0.5596009492874146,
0.01340574026107788,
-0.4371941089630127,
0.5524694323539734,
0.47753939032554626,
-0.4091469645500183,
-0.2983333170413971,
-0.2724916934967041,
-0.4156002104282379,
1.5775564908981323,
0.4631916284561157,
-0.7459527850151062,
0.4452103078365326,
0.13842134177684784,
0.26771730184555054,
-0.8228752017021179,
0.4584507942199707,
0.2544427812099457,
0.4482652544975281,
0.4771795868873596,
-0.7800444960594177,
0.0195396076887846,
-0.13971318304538727,
0.5302513241767883,
-0.4069223701953888,
-0.9295020699501038,
0.841769278049469,
0.10331105440855026,
0.06424518674612045,
-0.24588461220264435,
0.7447029948234558,
-0.014468385837972164,
0.5088852047920227,
1.028926134109497,
0.18028925359249115,
0.3793236017227173,
-0.242294579744339,
0.2605297565460205,
-0.2852281630039215,
0.04756966233253479,
0.8939366936683655,
-0.31748196482658386,
0.3492106795310974,
0.4182739853858948,
0.06536251306533813,
0.16942672431468964,
0.5979140996932983,
-0.08726008236408234,
0.5176382660865784,
-0.03272859752178192,
-0.3449794054031372,
-0.43055152893066406,
-0.19936610758304596,
-0.6090598106384277,
0.8864780068397522,
0.10706398636102676,
-0.22471663355827332,
0.023867201060056686,
0.100625179708004,
-0.3003259599208832,
-0.19241103529930115,
-0.39633944630622864,
0.7959625720977783,
0.059035688638687134,
-0.43267229199409485,
0.5172169804573059,
-0.2947937250137329,
0.7052982449531555,
-0.42755571007728577,
-0.04231348633766174,
-0.35919514298439026,
0.4575134813785553,
-0.40055081248283386,
-0.2177847921848297,
0.056396789848804474,
-0.2922649681568146,
-0.0040796054527163506,
-0.3940639793872833,
0.9550211429595947,
-0.5412392616271973,
-0.37630125880241394,
0.5219659805297852,
0.4518585801124573,
-0.03418752923607826,
0.17254452407360077,
-0.05485605448484421,
0.4076264500617981,
-0.4151027798652649,
-0.3019362986087799,
0.13569867610931396,
0.6081987619400024,
0.23437856137752533,
0.5703967809677124,
0.16195464134216309,
0.11192527413368225,
-0.007929015904664993,
0.4250369369983673,
0.7860018610954285,
-0.6538915038108826,
-0.6380451321601868,
-0.7560337781906128,
0.4297887086868286,
-0.2746707499027252,
-0.026531094685196877,
0.5203499794006348,
0.5652189254760742,
0.7434353232383728,
0.09371553361415863,
0.22444456815719604,
0.14808154106140137,
0.5138359665870667,
-0.3568513095378876,
1.0101374387741089,
-0.6032168865203857,
0.5231362581253052,
-0.75472092628479,
-0.956853985786438,
-0.3738946318626404,
0.12019389867782593,
0.22383883595466614,
0.42303159832954407,
0.5961591005325317,
0.9783264994621277,
-0.505638599395752,
0.06867444515228271,
0.8590976595878601,
-0.06929470598697662,
0.5144163370132446,
0.5014362931251526,
0.5933426022529602,
-0.7424948215484619,
0.793847918510437,
-0.6015483736991882,
-0.5062935948371887,
-0.62764972448349,
-1.3018580675125122,
-0.754010021686554,
-0.4632435739040375,
-0.7487530708312988,
-0.004042422864586115,
-0.36556968092918396,
0.4978219270706177,
1.1817547082901,
-0.6910272836685181,
-0.20896129310131073,
0.20950639247894287,
0.4389573335647583,
-0.5428833365440369,
-0.20495657622814178,
0.40107420086860657,
0.23704220354557037,
-0.4251238703727722,
0.6022970676422119,
0.5131589770317078,
0.09120591729879379,
-0.36812734603881836,
0.2116730660200119,
-0.4547242224216461,
-0.0685693696141243,
0.4160752594470978,
0.05050920695066452,
-0.777773380279541,
-0.7270278334617615,
-0.4183962643146515,
-0.04705043509602547,
0.2236810177564621,
0.9372684359550476,
-0.9657214879989624,
0.713232159614563,
0.6788237690925598,
0.4513857662677765,
0.4786168038845062,
-0.28462639451026917,
0.37593066692352295,
-0.9456660747528076,
0.7553000450134277,
0.16522759199142456,
0.7958046197891235,
0.5201172828674316,
-0.29213541746139526,
0.3898039758205414,
0.39953359961509705,
-0.6162194609642029,
-0.9143502116203308,
0.16927705705165863,
-1.1934665441513062,
-0.08841939270496368,
0.6647326946258545,
-0.22964856028556824,
-0.4434163570404053,
-0.35951703786849976,
-0.06412018090486526,
0.44042661786079407,
-0.28389105200767517,
0.912215530872345,
0.267618328332901,
0.09907838702201843,
-0.507469654083252,
-0.18121503293514252,
0.5267199277877808,
0.26731276512145996,
-0.5458962917327881,
-0.00031866395147517323,
0.21241405606269836,
-0.020141690969467163,
0.165998637676239,
0.5431851744651794,
-0.01853659749031067,
0.5749103426933289,
0.15743732452392578,
0.012482142075896263,
-0.5910624861717224,
-0.5287755131721497,
-0.33838918805122375,
0.3324783742427826,
-0.32353872060775757,
-0.26482251286506653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16877v1 | Large Language Model Augmented Exercise Retrieval for Personalized Language Learning | 2024-02-08T20:35:31 | 2024-02-08T20:35:31 | Austin Xu, Will Monroe, Klinton Bicknell | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We study the problem of zero-shot exercise retrieval in the context of online
language learning, to give learners the ability to explicitly request
personalized exercises via natural language. Using real-world data collected
from language learners, we observe that vector similarity approaches poorly
capture the relationship between exercise content and the language that
learners use to express what they want to learn. This semantic gap between
queries and content dramatically reduces the effectiveness of general-purpose
retrieval models pretrained on large scale information retrieval datasets like
MS MARCO. We leverage the generative capabilities of large language models to
bridge the gap by synthesizing hypothetical exercises based on the learner's
input, which are then used to search for relevant exercises. Our approach,
which we call mHyER, overcomes three challenges: (1) lack of relevance labels
for training, (2) unrestricted learner input content, and (3) low semantic
similarity between input and retrieval candidates. mHyER outperforms several
strong baselines on two novel benchmarks created from crowdsourced data and
publicly available data. | [
-0.2593500018119812,
-0.8453919887542725,
0.5408689379692078,
-0.2540592849254608,
0.2204144150018692,
0.17111726105213165,
-0.383038192987442,
-0.2795748710632324,
0.45350614190101624,
0.31271713972091675,
-0.46959009766578674,
-0.3788842260837555,
-0.555109441280365,
0.048172663897275925,
-0.36943086981773376,
0.7971479892730713,
-0.3002793788909912,
0.13088321685791016,
-0.13986681401729584,
-0.31319865584373474,
-0.2420956939458847,
-0.6319577693939209,
-0.36518311500549316,
-0.46775442361831665,
0.780367910861969,
0.4913710653781891,
0.41388076543807983,
0.4634363651275635,
0.4019736349582672,
0.2980022728443146,
0.05194462090730667,
-0.15539653599262238,
-0.6399890184402466,
0.38266924023628235,
-0.05181582644581795,
-0.5081757307052612,
0.029435059055685997,
-0.11761124432086945,
0.8275684118270874,
0.850540816783905,
-0.03244739770889282,
0.23695510625839233,
-0.17654135823249817,
0.6401192545890808,
-0.8298974633216858,
-0.13037726283073425,
-0.6884349584579468,
0.05017855763435364,
-0.2702173590660095,
-0.06891081482172012,
-0.14492543041706085,
-0.3049222230911255,
0.24767601490020752,
-0.5375301241874695,
0.44615763425827026,
-0.05930054187774658,
0.8652434349060059,
0.088097482919693,
-0.267353892326355,
-0.35046300292015076,
-0.6769073009490967,
0.8610950708389282,
-0.38166919350624084,
0.7343744039535522,
0.612855851650238,
0.5063098669052124,
-0.03878315910696983,
-0.3995319604873657,
-0.7394835352897644,
-0.6411862373352051,
0.28317177295684814,
-0.09762382507324219,
0.05083983764052391,
0.06216586008667946,
0.4137805998325348,
0.5436897873878479,
-0.7402292490005493,
-0.04444090649485588,
-0.3414807617664337,
-0.02271309867501259,
0.5147465467453003,
0.10571750998497009,
0.41334041953086853,
-0.2091735452413559,
-0.20320527255535126,
-0.27860555052757263,
-0.7829118371009827,
0.06891526281833649,
0.5331873297691345,
0.2051924467086792,
0.05703001469373703,
0.8968216180801392,
-0.48959484696388245,
0.8740976452827454,
-0.19860412180423737,
-0.11082773655653,
0.5267233848571777,
0.0801704078912735,
-0.06737928092479706,
-0.14351429045200348,
0.7072682976722717,
-0.08439169079065323,
0.23223285377025604,
-0.4141075909137726,
-0.2153010368347168,
-0.39418521523475647,
0.061473097652196884,
-0.9127124547958374,
-0.3350413739681244,
0.21555384993553162,
-0.12300563603639603,
0.016396645456552505,
0.3748711943626404,
-0.5553491711616516,
-0.10489162057638168,
-0.6306562423706055,
0.786065399646759,
-0.4974413812160492,
-0.09412216395139694,
0.09417962282896042,
-0.26795297861099243,
0.3262179493904114,
0.13564074039459229,
-0.7972361445426941,
0.138544499874115,
0.6278181076049805,
0.8112382292747498,
0.0016530189896002412,
-0.2767455577850342,
-0.685126781463623,
0.130588561296463,
-0.15517063438892365,
0.5666243433952332,
-0.7961846590042114,
-0.07538506388664246,
0.2543991506099701,
-0.15430158376693726,
-0.24378183484077454,
-0.7517560720443726,
0.11901387572288513,
-0.8271343111991882,
0.4914219081401825,
-0.26282399892807007,
-0.9042099714279175,
-0.0030051609501242638,
0.47542697191238403,
-0.6390952467918396,
1.0422078371047974,
0.2543908953666687,
-0.7378736138343811,
0.2729008197784424,
-0.5496680736541748,
-0.2633706033229828,
0.022757356986403465,
-0.31252434849739075,
-0.46295255422592163,
0.18133455514907837,
-0.035984836518764496,
0.4489533007144928,
-0.15602436661720276,
0.05453719571232796,
-0.5510738492012024,
-0.46982964873313904,
0.2106425017118454,
-0.05591749772429466,
0.3977093994617462,
0.17297066748142242,
-0.2998949885368347,
0.1518644392490387,
-0.9195961356163025,
0.09731347113847733,
0.3052125573158264,
-0.5411372780799866,
-0.6468881964683533,
-0.09517604112625122,
0.2708114683628082,
0.425226628780365,
0.23821000754833221,
-0.927814245223999,
0.3168388903141022,
-0.5466073155403137,
0.20907245576381683,
0.5606722831726074,
-0.11063624173402786,
0.3427673280239105,
-0.22873470187187195,
0.5984402298927307,
-0.3963891267776489,
-0.20235499739646912,
-0.1455746740102768,
-0.21961627900600433,
-0.7020784616470337,
-0.15109917521476746,
0.5673168301582336,
0.543332576751709,
-0.959244430065155,
0.41344159841537476,
-0.5990958213806152,
-0.4835149943828583,
-0.7333819270133972,
0.5886396765708923,
0.41291436553001404,
0.3394227623939514,
0.4899291694164276,
-0.28598669171333313,
-0.3382555842399597,
-0.6786913871765137,
-0.25276413559913635,
0.12694646418094635,
-0.5028365850448608,
0.36226868629455566,
0.4788256585597992,
-0.28282105922698975,
0.7185244560241699,
-0.7677121162414551,
-0.3949502110481262,
-0.3593900501728058,
0.09267999231815338,
0.02669922448694706,
0.26961949467658997,
0.5240442752838135,
-0.8211944103240967,
-0.6739767789840698,
-0.0032550895120948553,
-0.6118226051330566,
0.13211067020893097,
0.06979243457317352,
-0.00490602059289813,
-0.16210786998271942,
0.5459367036819458,
-0.501294732093811,
0.16989129781723022,
0.519119918346405,
-0.04426945745944977,
0.30022430419921875,
-0.32676267623901367,
0.16842779517173767,
-1.1974424123764038,
0.2764821946620941,
-0.08891851454973221,
-0.05796057730913162,
-0.573880672454834,
0.21643365919589996,
0.1519361287355423,
-0.3792448937892914,
-0.39988771080970764,
0.811182975769043,
-0.27752530574798584,
0.0922824889421463,
-0.4386494755744934,
0.1364554911851883,
-0.22687162458896637,
0.3405136168003082,
0.0481768436729908,
0.677757203578949,
0.5339844226837158,
-0.7029449343681335,
0.18236778676509857,
0.45816177129745483,
-0.2958308458328247,
0.388823539018631,
-0.8127951622009277,
0.313531756401062,
-0.43215978145599365,
0.04120364785194397,
-0.9265655279159546,
-0.6270157694816589,
0.08084625750780106,
-0.5708438754081726,
0.4394766390323639,
0.0132441446185112,
-0.3236095905303955,
-0.3037225008010864,
-0.49763306975364685,
0.534340500831604,
0.30002546310424805,
-0.6279623508453369,
0.28729623556137085,
0.27529770135879517,
-0.01763523742556572,
-0.6241447925567627,
-0.48198202252388,
-0.04394938796758652,
-0.12062253057956696,
-0.3788394331932068,
0.323352575302124,
-0.21810291707515717,
-0.023815471678972244,
-0.06512419879436493,
-0.10996642708778381,
-0.2452244758605957,
-0.010901699773967266,
0.15423619747161865,
-0.02638915367424488,
-0.14833256602287292,
0.40468630194664,
-0.3258896768093109,
0.031719617545604706,
-0.10369457304477692,
-0.14074544608592987,
0.6233152747154236,
0.19736509025096893,
-0.5687221884727478,
-0.3067542016506195,
0.4158002734184265,
0.40333133935928345,
-0.4061322808265686,
0.941838264465332,
0.7653976678848267,
-0.4085242450237274,
0.0394599623978138,
-0.7581140995025635,
-0.10848362743854523,
-0.44641342759132385,
0.49563419818878174,
-0.5088090896606445,
-1.197666883468628,
0.14290574193000793,
0.13692131638526917,
-0.01317435409873724,
0.16595031321048737,
0.5510665774345398,
-0.19845737516880035,
0.9227353930473328,
0.5348444581031799,
-0.2950259745121002,
0.8901975750923157,
-0.4791357219219208,
0.15350888669490814,
-0.8694826364517212,
-0.3089165687561035,
-0.5231938362121582,
-0.45717963576316833,
-0.552319347858429,
-0.4554058611392975,
0.22477705776691437,
-0.14741159975528717,
-0.4058981239795685,
0.4601005017757416,
-0.14634430408477783,
0.37012073397636414,
0.7943033576011658,
0.21906553208827972,
0.0272227693349123,
0.2917810082435608,
-0.17651982605457306,
-0.2890428900718689,
-0.605043888092041,
-0.17295955121517181,
1.188686490058899,
0.0037928130477666855,
0.6917881965637207,
0.27594444155693054,
0.9111552834510803,
0.04135863855481148,
0.3828359842300415,
-0.950221836566925,
0.21623070538043976,
0.15908300876617432,
-0.7875593304634094,
-0.3337228000164032,
-0.6742186546325684,
-1.4247363805770874,
0.3928990364074707,
-0.33635276556015015,
-0.5233101844787598,
-0.12450408935546875,
0.028050001710653305,
-0.025917910039424896,
0.4294087290763855,
-0.5197317004203796,
0.8577796816825867,
-0.2551043629646301,
-0.5094272494316101,
-0.28609728813171387,
-0.644445538520813,
0.30263668298721313,
-0.15193846821784973,
0.3083707392215729,
-0.1446484923362732,
-0.007222829852253199,
0.557878315448761,
-0.4660244882106781,
0.49270570278167725,
-0.21308064460754395,
0.10993729531764984,
0.1965319663286209,
0.13975068926811218,
0.24183733761310577,
-0.3543262779712677,
-0.15160034596920013,
-0.28132766485214233,
-0.1863008588552475,
-0.8522018194198608,
-0.6304143071174622,
0.8752529621124268,
-0.7577561140060425,
-0.4916728436946869,
-0.41447508335113525,
-0.28914108872413635,
-0.22798773646354675,
0.17279505729675293,
0.15763315558433533,
0.2986283600330353,
-0.37249043583869934,
0.4229010343551636,
0.6795125603675842,
-0.3101668059825897,
0.21364085376262665,
0.4950438141822815,
0.021157165989279747,
-0.48824459314346313,
1.28481924533844,
0.09899838268756866,
0.23373271524906158,
0.9382116198539734,
0.05790013447403908,
-0.3617769777774811,
-0.47079288959503174,
-0.244034081697464,
0.3873632252216339,
-0.5094265341758728,
-0.11412104219198227,
-0.5730434656143188,
0.0914393961429596,
-0.2669617831707001,
0.01814228855073452,
-0.33196941018104553,
-0.2658640742301941,
-0.10090348869562149,
0.07686915993690491,
0.1255776733160019,
0.6499775648117065,
0.14505019783973694,
0.3627740740776062,
-0.7948456406593323,
0.5828462839126587,
0.399008572101593,
0.485015332698822,
-0.16401758790016174,
-0.5821089148521423,
-0.28001827001571655,
0.00820030178874731,
-0.4862184226512909,
-0.8003042936325073,
0.2865777611732483,
0.3855339288711548,
0.610438883304596,
0.3745190501213074,
-0.016169194132089615,
0.734792172908783,
-0.7867180109024048,
0.5235539078712463,
0.34808051586151123,
-0.779344379901886,
0.6556354761123657,
-0.1976025253534317,
0.13371437788009644,
0.8130075931549072,
0.7934158444404602,
-0.5076705813407898,
-0.14641913771629333,
-0.5942219495773315,
-0.9664672017097473,
0.28000974655151367,
0.05127132683992386,
0.5636543035507202,
-0.15843617916107178,
0.5420125126838684,
-0.014197585172951221,
0.15282434225082397,
-0.7950689196586609,
-0.06401843577623367,
0.11613240092992783,
-0.3063153922557831,
-0.18026988208293915,
-0.02976040355861187,
0.21537181735038757,
-0.3830794394016266,
0.6156171560287476,
-0.18889617919921875,
0.03502760827541351,
0.24354016780853271,
-0.34206703305244446,
-0.2134493887424469,
0.24367544054985046,
0.13181644678115845,
0.5029711723327637,
-0.23884978890419006,
-0.041372913867235184,
0.20431655645370483,
-0.25151491165161133,
0.2717123031616211,
0.1145995706319809,
-0.20945148169994354,
0.15194353461265564,
0.3304404020309448,
0.5780093669891357,
0.5871313214302063,
-1.2147111892700195,
0.8519039750099182,
-0.027068087831139565,
-0.2876173257827759,
-0.5793504118919373,
0.17747771739959717,
-0.026343030855059624,
0.08307231962680817,
0.19247925281524658,
-0.16015836596488953,
0.2077663689851761,
-0.35455891489982605,
0.316439688205719,
0.6561402678489685,
-0.600344717502594,
-0.44123348593711853,
0.9810366034507751,
-0.1498018354177475,
-0.3810252249240875,
0.6677011847496033,
-0.20091620087623596,
-0.35994160175323486,
0.11731741577386856,
0.24514949321746826,
0.621109664440155,
-0.36879611015319824,
0.13085156679153442,
0.6465889811515808,
0.055844228714704514,
-0.1464281678199768,
0.20764456689357758,
-0.21039541065692902,
-0.43392348289489746,
-0.6342648267745972,
-0.5696835517883301,
-0.5299281477928162,
0.39013490080833435,
-0.5993992686271667,
0.4662249982357025,
-0.25319793820381165,
0.08226294815540314,
-0.06893713772296906,
0.06582725048065186,
-0.9250431656837463,
0.12009463459253311,
0.1430920660495758,
0.7084788680076599,
-0.7236880660057068,
0.954837441444397,
0.902325451374054,
-0.5901224613189697,
-0.5672599077224731,
0.14671702682971954,
-0.31252703070640564,
-0.7909197807312012,
0.6759175658226013,
0.17783746123313904,
0.23270782828330994,
-0.18253059685230255,
-0.3886163830757141,
-0.8109868764877319,
0.9487428665161133,
0.5678961277008057,
-0.4354514181613922,
-0.10044755041599274,
0.19566065073013306,
0.44860389828681946,
-0.017467688769102097,
0.1648494154214859,
0.16578976809978485,
0.16457974910736084,
0.2929920554161072,
-0.72103351354599,
-0.2389099895954132,
-0.19029079377651215,
-0.029261771589517593,
0.2789989709854126,
-0.5778955221176147,
0.7045104503631592,
-0.2396763563156128,
0.10697704553604126,
0.17176088690757751,
0.6936890482902527,
0.24176698923110962,
0.31285056471824646,
0.3276033401489258,
0.7288808822631836,
0.7203566431999207,
0.2643570601940155,
1.428912878036499,
-0.2030748873949051,
0.545117974281311,
1.0255374908447266,
-0.20572885870933533,
1.3105583190917969,
0.44403547048568726,
-0.1750364750623703,
0.3746320307254791,
0.472550630569458,
0.17040474712848663,
0.42048290371894836,
0.5165764689445496,
-0.5217140913009644,
-0.30150550603866577,
0.06830766797065735,
-0.2903614640235901,
0.4166867136955261,
0.1625659316778183,
-0.34091952443122864,
-0.2714919447898865,
0.16356012225151062,
-0.1312839835882187,
0.35603901743888855,
-0.07158830016851425,
0.6403256058692932,
-0.06883883476257324,
-0.5386288166046143,
0.7671902775764465,
0.051540885120630264,
0.6789805293083191,
-0.7067769169807434,
-0.06808620691299438,
-0.01797342486679554,
0.20456841588020325,
-0.04555998370051384,
-0.3653889000415802,
0.1781330704689026,
-0.03184954449534416,
0.0517335906624794,
-0.14734123647212982,
0.5915058851242065,
-0.7110788226127625,
-0.4920254051685333,
0.2985193431377411,
0.8220855593681335,
0.34105488657951355,
-0.35268375277519226,
-0.6652045249938965,
-0.11248025298118591,
-0.047879450023174286,
-0.38612934947013855,
0.595676064491272,
0.34766244888305664,
0.22660265862941742,
0.7245965600013733,
0.5780083537101746,
0.047027427703142166,
0.1535300314426422,
0.11741580814123154,
0.836169421672821,
-0.7091190218925476,
-0.18775632977485657,
-0.6634132862091064,
0.08262317627668381,
0.05846697837114334,
-0.30324238538742065,
0.7184061408042908,
0.9259164333343506,
1.1576792001724243,
-0.21598099172115326,
0.7689934968948364,
-0.09407317638397217,
0.7230924963951111,
-0.4674879014492035,
0.5541977882385254,
-0.8074739575386047,
0.06132632866501808,
-0.11713510751724243,
-1.0611463785171509,
-0.31106534600257874,
0.7156769037246704,
-0.3814488649368286,
0.003918841946870089,
0.33138298988342285,
0.7472994327545166,
-0.46022456884384155,
-0.3831561505794525,
0.4348059594631195,
-0.11871273070573807,
0.37934643030166626,
0.6862068772315979,
0.8474799990653992,
-0.6007232666015625,
0.4872416853904724,
-0.19521084427833557,
-0.14673425257205963,
-0.38949790596961975,
-0.6022874116897583,
-1.1630269289016724,
-0.7153856754302979,
-0.3149389624595642,
-0.1827639937400818,
-0.057375822216272354,
1.481331706047058,
0.688544511795044,
-0.9667311906814575,
-0.217592254281044,
-0.041754692792892456,
0.08622665703296661,
0.19567759335041046,
-0.24523510038852692,
0.39421314001083374,
-0.6140291690826416,
-0.9930952787399292,
0.31404373049736023,
-0.11642196774482727,
0.0353817418217659,
-0.145247682929039,
-0.22934968769550323,
-0.26616981625556946,
-0.22485125064849854,
0.660485565662384,
0.6316133737564087,
-0.7209782004356384,
-0.4241737425327301,
0.25794708728790283,
-0.013875839300453663,
0.1159197986125946,
1.0324839353561401,
-0.6634415984153748,
0.6089664101600647,
0.55422443151474,
1.1902186870574951,
0.7744240760803223,
-0.15475217998027802,
0.334023118019104,
-0.9610967040061951,
0.23479774594306946,
0.23646864295005798,
0.2175273597240448,
0.47665396332740784,
0.0003501168976072222,
0.3413357138633728,
0.20676377415657043,
-0.39533254504203796,
-0.593719482421875,
0.11725243926048279,
-0.7973877787590027,
-0.1446804255247116,
1.1712149381637573,
-0.12030453979969025,
-0.12940336763858795,
-0.11820022016763687,
-0.2615004777908325,
0.20351442694664001,
-0.1268361210823059,
1.0254991054534912,
0.7922681570053101,
-0.22430844604969025,
0.07907330989837646,
-1.1002618074417114,
0.30158713459968567,
0.4764692187309265,
-0.47701355814933777,
-0.16632455587387085,
0.4258713126182556,
0.6521443128585815,
0.011596698313951492,
0.5394344925880432,
0.16411103308200836,
0.11451730132102966,
-0.37193968892097473,
0.20901206135749817,
0.07085622847080231,
-0.18995502591133118,
-0.27373746037483215,
0.3015342354774475,
0.29345405101776123,
-0.22445471584796906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06044v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06044v3 | OpenToM: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Theory-of-Mind Reasoning Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T20:35:06 | 2024-06-03T10:48:16 | Hainiu Xu, Runcong Zhao, Lixing Zhu, Jinhua Du, Yulan He | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural Theory-of-Mind (N-ToM), machine's ability to understand and keep track
of the mental states of others, is pivotal in developing socially intelligent
agents. However, prevalent N-ToM benchmarks have several shortcomings,
including the presence of ambiguous and artificial narratives, absence of
personality traits and preferences, a lack of questions addressing characters'
psychological mental states, and limited diversity in the questions posed. In
response to these issues, we construct OpenToM, a new benchmark for assessing
N-ToM with (1) longer and clearer narrative stories, (2) characters with
explicit personality traits, (3) actions that are triggered by character
intentions, and (4) questions designed to challenge LLMs' capabilities of
modeling characters' mental states of both the physical and psychological
world. Using OpenToM, we reveal that state-of-the-art LLMs thrive at modeling
certain aspects of mental states in the physical world but fall short when
tracking characters' mental states in the psychological world. | [
-0.6599397659301758,
-0.6399549841880798,
1.0350297689437866,
-0.07699722796678543,
-0.09347628057003021,
-0.10777443647384644,
-0.6951285600662231,
-0.3891953229904175,
0.16118283569812775,
0.26243531703948975,
-0.7434828281402588,
-0.3177158534526825,
-0.43014708161354065,
0.257264107465744,
-0.08345136046409607,
0.7880304455757141,
-0.12530627846717834,
-0.05011274665594101,
-0.5200459957122803,
-0.2945558428764343,
-0.10376584529876709,
-0.4279818832874298,
-0.6670408844947815,
-0.5111355781555176,
0.7077956199645996,
-0.11471733450889587,
0.7249258160591125,
0.39278748631477356,
0.6449838876724243,
0.2737853527069092,
-0.06240091472864151,
0.4240218997001648,
-0.3932029604911804,
0.3779093027114868,
-0.5203118920326233,
-0.7343574166297913,
-0.7237036824226379,
0.10226865857839584,
0.7080142498016357,
0.5803826451301575,
0.13523106276988983,
0.1123262271285057,
0.012914115563035011,
0.46424517035484314,
-0.799305260181427,
0.19145353138446808,
-0.45119354128837585,
0.02967642806470394,
-0.058012429624795914,
-0.07374307513237,
-0.2860502004623413,
-0.5947508215904236,
0.2998277544975281,
-0.6194345355033875,
-0.0379997193813324,
-0.034031450748443604,
0.7715705037117004,
0.264198899269104,
-0.47531378269195557,
-0.060098178684711456,
-0.6891389489173889,
0.8726891875267029,
-0.6724950075149536,
0.21449577808380127,
0.3809070289134979,
0.6495965719223022,
-0.23171518743038177,
-0.35825785994529724,
-0.8090456128120422,
-0.4542084336280823,
0.03112952411174774,
0.07142791897058487,
-0.2220776081085205,
-0.019950300455093384,
0.30547595024108887,
0.2751789689064026,
-0.4008438289165497,
-0.1124320849776268,
0.11401040852069855,
-0.013353846967220306,
0.7040505409240723,
0.5166186094284058,
0.12921050190925598,
0.09000299125909805,
-0.37204715609550476,
-0.2926158010959625,
-0.4247235357761383,
-0.30588433146476746,
0.2414928674697876,
0.2043328583240509,
0.02653740532696247,
0.483686625957489,
-0.14760474860668182,
0.4573822319507599,
-0.2467741221189499,
-0.10895347595214844,
0.07129213958978653,
-0.15317222476005554,
-0.2399703860282898,
-0.13482651114463806,
0.752145528793335,
0.599760115146637,
0.5674017071723938,
-0.09728609025478363,
-0.2819545269012451,
0.23492954671382904,
0.38304996490478516,
-0.6292577981948853,
-0.03928201273083687,
0.2701854407787323,
-0.40999549627304077,
0.060254134237766266,
0.02810858190059662,
-1.0290510654449463,
-0.8282853364944458,
-0.11492683738470078,
0.3480599522590637,
-0.6936658620834351,
-0.5279402732849121,
0.08153119683265686,
-0.1359708458185196,
0.3385220170021057,
0.5100582838058472,
-0.5897192358970642,
0.47276389598846436,
0.7757331132888794,
1.0708965063095093,
-0.12252672016620636,
-0.4415476620197296,
0.10705152153968811,
0.06610904633998871,
-0.45948851108551025,
0.9040833115577698,
-0.588119387626648,
-0.0450889952480793,
-0.16680538654327393,
-0.2651180028915405,
-0.06119541823863983,
-0.2959023118019104,
0.2981205880641937,
-0.1130095049738884,
0.221200093626976,
-0.5787276029586792,
-0.6239337921142578,
-0.2902822196483612,
0.6649638414382935,
-0.4427514672279358,
0.4915125072002411,
0.2508755922317505,
-0.2670765817165375,
0.32052576541900635,
-0.7793071866035461,
-0.2415323555469513,
-0.03875843808054924,
-0.4311986267566681,
0.16403427720069885,
0.3571874499320984,
0.06231633201241493,
0.4307500123977661,
-0.898300051689148,
0.3199450671672821,
-0.5354376435279846,
-0.30726349353790283,
0.673629641532898,
-0.4864012598991394,
0.780180037021637,
0.1631920039653778,
-0.21614262461662292,
0.049206044524908066,
-0.6787527203559875,
0.28561851382255554,
0.449354887008667,
-0.028203008696436882,
-0.38053086400032043,
0.15367281436920166,
-0.31739726662635803,
0.11286367475986481,
0.31890860199928284,
-0.5763211250305176,
0.19783909618854523,
-0.22823747992515564,
0.5925674438476562,
0.6945512294769287,
-0.17952032387256622,
0.09594379365444183,
-0.6580855846405029,
0.4485268294811249,
-0.2095712572336197,
0.05493222549557686,
-0.16105540096759796,
-0.6139936447143555,
-0.7130978107452393,
-0.617580235004425,
-0.019542837515473366,
0.16887180507183075,
-0.5544753670692444,
0.7584913372993469,
-0.23186439275741577,
-0.9052531123161316,
-0.5020779967308044,
-0.35647740960121155,
0.6353026032447815,
0.29370856285095215,
0.26810944080352783,
-0.38280847668647766,
-0.2760274410247803,
-0.6821783185005188,
-0.4382317066192627,
-0.37870532274246216,
-0.25943613052368164,
0.35025373101234436,
0.5772944688796997,
-0.031845271587371826,
0.9259079098701477,
-0.47148382663726807,
-0.19579949975013733,
-0.2330622524023056,
-0.040920764207839966,
0.15869280695915222,
0.348622590303421,
0.45358094573020935,
-0.30427125096321106,
0.0027535140980035067,
-0.030904963612556458,
-0.9956535696983337,
0.10549765080213547,
0.16709992289543152,
-0.20537114143371582,
0.11255975812673569,
0.13345952332019806,
-0.9934854507446289,
0.4249613583087921,
0.15026485919952393,
-0.5343436002731323,
0.3907158076763153,
-0.3016636371612549,
0.2846900224685669,
-0.7516120076179504,
0.2640085816383362,
0.12295620143413544,
0.10753925144672394,
-0.5918194651603699,
0.34422510862350464,
0.07661057263612747,
0.05039498955011368,
-0.2370765209197998,
0.7681353688240051,
-0.3362690210342407,
-0.34386563301086426,
0.0014230788219720125,
0.5516627430915833,
0.06632835417985916,
0.71470707654953,
-0.13290074467658997,
0.5562705397605896,
0.27173542976379395,
-0.8251671195030212,
0.4227867126464844,
0.1547505259513855,
-0.4810020327568054,
1.1170008182525635,
-0.5056122541427612,
0.44580528140068054,
-0.08742652088403702,
0.24737010896205902,
-1.1720541715621948,
-0.19292108714580536,
0.014599309302866459,
-0.5933403372764587,
0.06800875812768936,
0.2081526666879654,
-0.7611222863197327,
-0.2501246929168701,
-0.11221075803041458,
0.38285398483276367,
0.5896745920181274,
-0.39672577381134033,
0.8050634264945984,
0.26328906416893005,
0.298435240983963,
0.011178518645465374,
-0.6089984774589539,
-0.10907179117202759,
-0.23433834314346313,
-0.5979484915733337,
0.32980072498321533,
-0.16949209570884705,
-0.5573534369468689,
-0.045527100563049316,
-0.2051188200712204,
-0.2432129979133606,
0.18283702433109283,
-0.17888951301574707,
0.10324445366859436,
-0.44611984491348267,
0.17914627492427826,
-0.12992613017559052,
-0.06829815357923508,
0.43590161204338074,
-0.20599661767482758,
0.6901669502258301,
-0.3414347469806671,
-0.3934715688228607,
-0.2705058157444,
-0.05984477326273918,
0.942242443561554,
-0.40443137288093567,
0.4886684715747833,
0.16571855545043945,
-0.642932653427124,
-0.1946564018726349,
-0.3040708899497986,
-0.17893265187740326,
-0.4051542282104492,
0.4405214786529541,
-0.38292166590690613,
-0.6453579664230347,
0.5432050228118896,
-0.035485923290252686,
0.060491956770420074,
0.38042837381362915,
0.5160138607025146,
-0.046995602548122406,
1.1222164630889893,
0.2003604769706726,
0.12445806711912155,
0.06552596390247345,
0.05618630349636078,
0.17423300445079803,
-1.05460786819458,
-0.2783944010734558,
-0.5429942011833191,
-0.6342834234237671,
-0.35971981287002563,
-0.552267849445343,
0.3260684013366699,
-0.22516940534114838,
-0.47871822118759155,
0.37324678897857666,
-0.4590403437614441,
0.5003665089607239,
0.484492689371109,
0.17148974537849426,
0.29346179962158203,
-0.3046187460422516,
-0.28492027521133423,
0.003139824140816927,
-0.30107277631759644,
-0.7837461233139038,
1.2871862649917603,
0.47888681292533875,
0.5891125202178955,
0.4553380310535431,
0.3330087959766388,
0.04214826226234436,
0.12360969185829163,
-0.5949249267578125,
1.0560874938964844,
-0.02687649242579937,
-0.9505656957626343,
-0.35548606514930725,
-0.3625662326812744,
-0.8715587854385376,
0.38524502515792847,
-0.16723020374774933,
-1.028641939163208,
0.039044056087732315,
0.0010836475994437933,
-0.4797864854335785,
0.4566348195075989,
-0.3366054892539978,
0.6064732670783997,
-0.41287368535995483,
-0.4023997485637665,
-0.3777598738670349,
-0.4452306926250458,
0.4300193786621094,
0.09221427142620087,
-0.3099576532840729,
-0.5758183002471924,
-0.39982056617736816,
0.6383076906204224,
-0.24053435027599335,
0.5639714002609253,
-0.20017027854919434,
-0.19293543696403503,
0.23304489254951477,
0.2220575213432312,
0.07874244451522827,
-0.02459670603275299,
-0.17827165126800537,
0.3330422043800354,
0.1943419873714447,
-0.2655988037586212,
-1.0133696794509888,
0.5805904269218445,
-0.8725619912147522,
-0.4446640610694885,
-0.5690938830375671,
-0.6498810052871704,
-0.7113510966300964,
0.2101273536682129,
-0.0615263357758522,
0.22865748405456543,
-0.3715613782405853,
0.27317914366722107,
0.8073570728302002,
-0.2699110805988312,
0.20704500377178192,
0.49270570278167725,
-0.44391563534736633,
-0.5855107307434082,
0.7931855320930481,
-0.016957050189375877,
0.2710876762866974,
0.35038405656814575,
0.2714860439300537,
-0.2816540002822876,
-0.4274258315563202,
-0.21196436882019043,
0.24579325318336487,
-0.7432346940040588,
-0.0018655307358130813,
-0.3735755383968353,
-0.16001242399215698,
-0.13258427381515503,
0.03855171427130699,
-0.3110918402671814,
-0.17235971987247467,
0.01965273916721344,
0.1520920991897583,
0.28411781787872314,
0.7910627722740173,
0.4119550883769989,
0.03708517923951149,
-0.34233418107032776,
0.18212351202964783,
0.18723832070827484,
0.73927903175354,
0.2551022171974182,
-0.3419477045536041,
0.024365559220314026,
-0.023163551464676857,
-0.32900577783584595,
-0.821053147315979,
0.005793172866106033,
-0.0734301432967186,
0.827143132686615,
0.5998027920722961,
0.040490563958883286,
0.6507759690284729,
-0.18274420499801636,
0.6811133027076721,
0.09865140169858932,
-0.8423017859458923,
0.5554124116897583,
-0.5763297080993652,
0.46879035234451294,
0.604312539100647,
0.4070053696632385,
-0.43306970596313477,
-0.3168783485889435,
-0.38181808590888977,
-0.41833654046058655,
0.5341607928276062,
0.27680978178977966,
-0.09933420270681381,
-0.3289435803890228,
0.26282167434692383,
0.15316621959209442,
0.362436980009079,
-0.4259020984172821,
0.006295135244727135,
-0.03752174973487854,
-0.3481307327747345,
-0.23697902262210846,
0.03040333278477192,
-0.1586131602525711,
-0.3318042457103729,
0.4378819763660431,
-0.37499773502349854,
0.6510879993438721,
0.331842303276062,
-0.006012185476720333,
-0.09166039526462555,
0.0348743200302124,
0.7097184062004089,
0.6954703330993652,
-0.4266233444213867,
0.10923202335834503,
0.08157341927289963,
-0.32219699025154114,
0.15519140660762787,
-0.19045071303844452,
0.014852238819003105,
-0.2908613383769989,
0.44037625193595886,
0.6664849519729614,
0.2865016460418701,
-0.9497309327125549,
0.3236372172832489,
-0.106209896504879,
-0.35011035203933716,
-0.2215871661901474,
0.37111160159111023,
-0.06424065679311752,
0.6404915452003479,
0.10886989533901215,
0.0019934545271098614,
-0.2628248929977417,
-0.8538223505020142,
0.007730310317128897,
0.3735065758228302,
-0.5419506430625916,
-0.3274132311344147,
0.4146103262901306,
0.2174573391675949,
-0.5172314643859863,
0.6993809938430786,
-0.11264470219612122,
-0.20221200585365295,
0.7444176077842712,
0.4591193199157715,
1.231031060218811,
0.002579031977802515,
-0.14970636367797852,
0.27568694949150085,
0.6586050987243652,
-0.006237870082259178,
0.53727126121521,
0.0019062565406784415,
-0.8483419418334961,
0.05063226819038391,
-0.39143532514572144,
-0.5769400000572205,
0.23185688257217407,
-0.8196526765823364,
0.17440272867679596,
-0.9847898483276367,
-0.3898097276687622,
-0.2425564080476761,
0.15816083550453186,
-0.723301112651825,
0.2709881365299225,
0.32844239473342896,
1.1238019466400146,
-0.2698468565940857,
0.7806267738342285,
0.8934957385063171,
-0.41017091274261475,
-0.3074660301208496,
0.26288706064224243,
0.14819487929344177,
-0.7648909687995911,
0.18225234746932983,
0.4176683723926544,
-0.08717148751020432,
-0.15616574883460999,
-0.2676195502281189,
-0.9582854509353638,
1.3747249841690063,
0.6534799337387085,
-0.4554932415485382,
-0.14157050848007202,
-0.08925984054803848,
0.7784453630447388,
-0.5028819441795349,
0.6636534333229065,
0.6496255993843079,
0.6540426015853882,
-0.3121388554573059,
-0.7430186867713928,
0.25863873958587646,
-0.3324261009693146,
0.03734315559267998,
0.314330518245697,
-0.951299250125885,
1.1461442708969116,
-0.12656137347221375,
-0.17340978980064392,
0.3425149619579315,
0.6939073204994202,
0.5115979909896851,
0.5526241064071655,
0.564814567565918,
0.5794909596443176,
0.9348739385604858,
-0.2965378761291504,
1.0356271266937256,
-0.251392662525177,
0.14989174902439117,
1.1000957489013672,
-0.7404808402061462,
0.802887499332428,
0.2396083027124405,
-0.31646057963371277,
0.5751140713691711,
0.3964660167694092,
-0.0439518578350544,
0.4938737452030182,
0.41101038455963135,
-0.07969975471496582,
-0.2455878108739853,
0.07376860082149506,
-0.2543700635433197,
0.5855926275253296,
0.40505412220954895,
-0.2101249396800995,
-0.14169302582740784,
-0.1408856213092804,
0.019182613119482994,
0.3773527145385742,
-0.3552388548851013,
0.5198237895965576,
0.04617031663656235,
-0.894543468952179,
0.2819119989871979,
-0.1774657815694809,
0.529204249382019,
-0.7199370265007019,
0.19129936397075653,
-0.33071932196617126,
0.4927334785461426,
0.2928149104118347,
-0.8799189925193787,
0.11936251819133759,
0.08455249667167664,
0.04177221655845642,
-0.083871029317379,
0.6018901467323303,
-0.07951813191175461,
-0.09660574048757553,
0.48738715052604675,
0.45488473773002625,
0.3078765869140625,
-0.15230302512645721,
-0.5404325723648071,
0.09992028772830963,
-0.3729069232940674,
-0.3105662763118744,
0.4773962199687958,
0.5733534693717957,
0.03965252637863159,
0.8082747459411621,
0.3606579005718231,
-0.01944579742848873,
-0.3057147264480591,
-0.15435273945331573,
0.5734742879867554,
-1.0605741739273071,
-0.35043179988861084,
-1.0968657732009888,
0.26037153601646423,
-0.22369983792304993,
-0.942760169506073,
0.7699559926986694,
0.1897224634885788,
0.9035622477531433,
0.26195231080055237,
0.7226190567016602,
-0.10722827166318893,
0.3007756173610687,
-0.4888446629047394,
0.9314006567001343,
-0.7427196502685547,
0.04365374147891998,
-0.3767813742160797,
-1.071778416633606,
-0.04697215184569359,
0.8022361397743225,
-0.23447950184345245,
0.35711342096328735,
1.0695396661758423,
0.4419982135295868,
0.24942465126514435,
0.4314539134502411,
0.579765796661377,
0.2046952247619629,
0.25616922974586487,
0.9520928263664246,
1.1107678413391113,
-0.14789573848247528,
0.20045028626918793,
-0.07658575475215912,
-0.3328583538532257,
-0.07365752756595612,
-0.8772558569908142,
-1.4124902486801147,
-0.5333322882652283,
-0.16196765005588531,
-0.18600131571292877,
0.09567011892795563,
1.1053423881530762,
0.5941436886787415,
-0.42955711483955383,
-0.36093300580978394,
-0.04379265755414963,
0.014729805290699005,
-0.49207600951194763,
-0.16129647195339203,
-0.22389821708202362,
-0.14706750214099884,
-0.5485279560089111,
0.475693941116333,
0.5686924457550049,
-0.1647247076034546,
-0.851105809211731,
-0.15883687138557434,
-0.20182470977306366,
0.5968997478485107,
0.48378986120224,
0.046517159789800644,
-1.0090675354003906,
-0.3973596394062042,
-0.043620847165584564,
-0.1464231163263321,
0.014148615300655365,
0.849983811378479,
-0.6801292896270752,
0.331264853477478,
0.42059358954429626,
0.6403276324272156,
-0.039142269641160965,
-0.40542393922805786,
0.8148592114448547,
-0.3230397701263428,
-0.17218154668807983,
0.535137414932251,
0.45269232988357544,
0.03868721053004265,
-0.1764763742685318,
0.6319948434829712,
0.22952143847942352,
-0.43459075689315796,
-0.9835408926010132,
0.32495787739753723,
-0.8354802131652832,
-0.25506091117858887,
0.8499290943145752,
-0.3438664376735687,
-0.5442375540733337,
0.13269245624542236,
-0.01997327245771885,
0.14727534353733063,
-0.28119030594825745,
0.6714620590209961,
0.873611330986023,
-0.069587841629982,
-0.1422901302576065,
-0.5100386142730713,
0.15614862740039825,
0.521755576133728,
-1.0284292697906494,
0.15332245826721191,
0.37624916434288025,
-0.10353459417819977,
0.32555627822875977,
0.6497841477394104,
-0.16956903040409088,
0.20986463129520416,
0.06530343741178513,
0.07368582487106323,
-0.10230209678411484,
-0.6576223373413086,
-0.24700702726840973,
0.16194763779640198,
-0.020104287192225456,
-0.09425049275159836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06041v1 | A Prompt Response to the Demand for Automatic Gender-Neutral Translation | 2024-02-08T20:24:44 | 2024-02-08T20:24:44 | Beatrice Savoldi, Andrea Piergentili, Dennis Fucci, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gender-neutral translation (GNT) that avoids biased and undue binary
assumptions is a pivotal challenge for the creation of more inclusive
translation technologies. Advancements for this task in Machine Translation
(MT), however, are hindered by the lack of dedicated parallel data, which are
necessary to adapt MT systems to satisfy neutral constraints. For such a
scenario, large language models offer hitherto unforeseen possibilities, as
they come with the distinct advantage of being versatile in various (sub)tasks
when provided with explicit instructions. In this paper, we explore this
potential to automate GNT by comparing MT with the popular GPT-4 model. Through
extensive manual analyses, our study empirically reveals the inherent
limitations of current MT systems in generating GNTs and provides valuable
insights into the potential and challenges associated with prompting for
neutrality. | [
-0.29744723439216614,
-0.41200026869773865,
0.6343832612037659,
0.07533084601163864,
-0.23670609295368195,
0.10172183811664581,
-0.12637819349765778,
-0.19337742030620575,
-0.26244786381721497,
0.35899701714515686,
-0.8112700581550598,
-0.3173401355743408,
-0.6963973045349121,
0.9369640946388245,
-0.6204845309257507,
1.1754207611083984,
-0.45619457960128784,
0.0388428159058094,
0.21919792890548706,
-0.28868353366851807,
-1.2339638471603394,
-0.44578373432159424,
-0.4301173985004425,
-0.21053247153759003,
0.5144649744033813,
0.3665686249732971,
0.9088473320007324,
0.6181195974349976,
0.4089375138282776,
0.45526719093322754,
0.38357633352279663,
-0.11918845772743225,
-0.21072742342948914,
0.3485671579837799,
-0.3033100962638855,
-0.2513215243816376,
-0.5269567966461182,
0.3057636022567749,
0.7124588489532471,
0.7855812311172485,
0.21106597781181335,
0.1987740695476532,
0.2928374707698822,
0.5788021683692932,
-0.0717025101184845,
0.1892707496881485,
-0.6496132016181946,
0.050612807273864746,
0.0030298884958028793,
0.1934325248003006,
-0.11469237506389618,
-0.5325364470481873,
0.2621086537837982,
-0.46452072262763977,
0.6482863426208496,
-0.10423606634140015,
0.8881767392158508,
0.3495866060256958,
-0.5737490653991699,
-0.35271134972572327,
-0.8354774117469788,
0.9000394940376282,
-0.3966338634490967,
0.3443353474140167,
0.15795430541038513,
0.4063398241996765,
-0.09190382063388824,
-0.2965204417705536,
-0.35704320669174194,
-0.32015565037727356,
-0.018533868715167046,
0.021239137277007103,
-0.5260674357414246,
-0.06045813113451004,
0.31659814715385437,
0.24986974895000458,
-0.6432114839553833,
0.03522876277565956,
-0.27076637744903564,
0.01748257502913475,
0.014471227303147316,
0.2876572608947754,
0.5338343977928162,
-0.25032323598861694,
-0.26807230710983276,
0.2915434241294861,
-0.43406224250793457,
-0.16123640537261963,
0.7984054088592529,
0.45151713490486145,
-0.32600924372673035,
0.7232356071472168,
-0.21399475634098053,
0.535849928855896,
0.25195518136024475,
0.5114670395851135,
0.2839888632297516,
-0.48654624819755554,
-0.20354945957660675,
-0.2172849029302597,
1.0057510137557983,
0.20011602342128754,
0.26447081565856934,
-0.407559335231781,
-0.33888745307922363,
0.2250090390443802,
0.17552420496940613,
-0.9156672954559326,
0.11656555533409119,
0.16717776656150818,
-0.2651560306549072,
-0.1506948471069336,
-0.2379026710987091,
-0.629247784614563,
-0.09106989204883575,
-0.7198238372802734,
0.44551724195480347,
-0.2193623185157776,
-0.1280241757631302,
-0.04653666168451309,
-0.3884383738040924,
0.06589735299348831,
0.549627959728241,
-0.9843184351921082,
0.2057938426733017,
0.4588232636451721,
0.9634964466094971,
-0.160704106092453,
-0.19832248985767365,
-0.5204405188560486,
-0.116700679063797,
-0.35347118973731995,
0.19787856936454773,
-0.3466869294643402,
-0.3959991931915283,
-0.49056026339530945,
0.18810875713825226,
-0.0902639850974083,
-0.18409758806228638,
0.4302997887134552,
-0.20759154856204987,
0.5616505742073059,
-0.8796196579933167,
-0.06554265320301056,
-0.22390444576740265,
0.2467595785856247,
-0.5804817080497742,
0.28591930866241455,
0.31499865651130676,
-0.8625898361206055,
0.3130117952823639,
-0.5056262016296387,
-0.17302338778972626,
-0.0502265989780426,
-0.46976885199546814,
-0.2655180096626282,
0.1203220933675766,
0.206812784075737,
0.17486721277236938,
-0.812921941280365,
0.7624357342720032,
-0.4375176429748535,
-0.27222034335136414,
0.23782280087471008,
-0.8048059940338135,
0.8120610117912292,
0.03702206909656525,
-0.7456048130989075,
0.13658535480499268,
-0.12961165606975555,
-0.3713928461074829,
0.14520633220672607,
-0.09067580103874207,
0.00021560178720392287,
-0.1669158637523651,
-0.5434408783912659,
0.3793069124221802,
0.15688304603099823,
-0.49311065673828125,
0.14808215200901031,
-0.24598558247089386,
0.501829981803894,
1.0003749132156372,
-0.5763850212097168,
0.5490980744361877,
-0.04875040054321289,
0.7879402041435242,
-0.4019085466861725,
0.07676874101161957,
0.08188634365797043,
-0.9197506904602051,
-0.5476348996162415,
-0.32516276836395264,
0.5564256310462952,
0.8278142213821411,
-0.9118157625198364,
0.1500771939754486,
-0.24753639101982117,
0.0879993885755539,
-0.7636401653289795,
0.23802892863750458,
0.4316612184047699,
0.8838489055633545,
0.35567957162857056,
-0.3238897919654846,
-0.43302229046821594,
-1.085243582725525,
-0.4003940224647522,
0.12424874305725098,
-0.11865916848182678,
0.08333012461662292,
0.5274814963340759,
-0.2625957727432251,
0.9412270188331604,
0.15885019302368164,
-0.04288949444890022,
-0.3553445339202881,
0.5557730793952942,
0.6123890280723572,
0.5795483589172363,
0.4776122570037842,
-0.6024125218391418,
-0.43125757575035095,
0.2709062099456787,
-1.2826571464538574,
-0.46017366647720337,
-0.046183742582798004,
-0.10144087672233582,
0.14655694365501404,
0.3015664517879486,
-0.8156924247741699,
0.543667733669281,
0.7276757955551147,
-0.16940534114837646,
0.48213085532188416,
-0.4161665439605713,
0.39418184757232666,
-0.679261326789856,
0.44780173897743225,
-0.43018513917922974,
-0.3471407890319824,
-0.8413593769073486,
-0.062405843287706375,
0.17877867817878723,
-0.3708347678184509,
-0.2827163636684418,
0.5277905464172363,
-0.7157931327819824,
-0.3528716564178467,
-0.36873501539230347,
-0.14577987790107727,
-0.09786011278629303,
0.30532628297805786,
-0.1891026794910431,
0.9426830410957336,
0.17187297344207764,
-0.40778669714927673,
-0.07346248626708984,
0.3887019455432892,
0.46434667706489563,
0.2556518614292145,
-0.8855920433998108,
0.2141607254743576,
-0.25313252210617065,
0.280507355928421,
-0.8318679332733154,
-0.3168675899505615,
0.7251215577125549,
-0.4348295331001282,
0.4140143394470215,
-0.3604629337787628,
-0.22444814443588257,
-0.5130234360694885,
-0.2082415223121643,
0.6458091735839844,
0.6563300490379333,
-0.2937726378440857,
0.4455239474773407,
-0.0440434031188488,
-0.5348680019378662,
-0.679558277130127,
-0.7565391659736633,
0.49019065499305725,
-0.2172326296567917,
-0.38378608226776123,
0.09757673740386963,
-0.01954166777431965,
-0.02767672948539257,
0.01229636836796999,
0.04916048049926758,
0.29284700751304626,
0.07904098182916641,
0.07627623528242111,
0.4659809470176697,
-0.13567687571048737,
-0.18278637528419495,
0.31174564361572266,
-0.5833116173744202,
-0.11109873652458191,
-0.639185905456543,
0.4280354380607605,
-0.4328464865684509,
-0.46282488107681274,
-0.732859194278717,
0.6904535293579102,
0.5825507044792175,
-0.12209278345108032,
0.4950958490371704,
0.6083767414093018,
-0.2156716287136078,
0.2560516595840454,
-0.2337951511144638,
-0.010830085724592209,
-0.515518069267273,
0.06472333520650864,
-0.32638588547706604,
-0.8121482729911804,
0.4043818414211273,
0.36310145258903503,
0.18591879308223724,
0.5596696734428406,
0.6242774128913879,
0.2648009955883026,
1.4627232551574707,
0.38217979669570923,
0.09792480617761612,
0.07652958482503891,
0.2876286804676056,
0.19334518909454346,
-0.582697868347168,
0.20646658539772034,
-0.8122218251228333,
-0.5727859139442444,
-0.943608283996582,
-0.4083225429058075,
0.3411857783794403,
-0.12312322109937668,
-0.5227633714675903,
0.4343820810317993,
-0.6343373656272888,
0.1815148890018463,
0.5454981327056885,
-0.28280049562454224,
0.3116439878940582,
-0.018273206427693367,
-0.07863356173038483,
-0.28700655698776245,
-0.5545342564582825,
-0.5642374753952026,
1.1029142141342163,
0.3577008843421936,
0.4043956696987152,
0.26042455434799194,
0.5650784969329834,
0.2762788236141205,
0.5840394496917725,
-0.36683788895606995,
0.5643821358680725,
-0.6650977730751038,
-0.7677181363105774,
-0.040855772793293,
-0.8663455843925476,
-1.1299513578414917,
0.30090582370758057,
0.07534344494342804,
-0.401027649641037,
0.26412299275398254,
0.26192066073417664,
-0.023655645549297333,
0.14763957262039185,
-0.9595730304718018,
0.8956941962242126,
-0.3599078059196472,
-0.29375821352005005,
0.363905131816864,
-0.6702388525009155,
0.4871206283569336,
-0.2842632234096527,
0.16982869803905487,
-0.16630323231220245,
-0.13978144526481628,
0.20664478838443756,
-0.3627617061138153,
0.9035341143608093,
-0.31158390641212463,
-0.07499981671571732,
-0.029032384976744652,
0.338868647813797,
0.48818886280059814,
-0.1260160505771637,
-0.23053626716136932,
0.377702534198761,
-0.7137106657028198,
-0.4465305209159851,
-0.18071962893009186,
0.6165950298309326,
-0.826129674911499,
-0.8765718936920166,
-0.4694724977016449,
-0.8639858961105347,
-0.09737180173397064,
0.4632304310798645,
0.370523601770401,
0.21922188997268677,
0.018708061426877975,
-0.11683076620101929,
0.36273884773254395,
-0.5849069356918335,
0.4187985956668854,
0.3455319106578827,
-0.3940139710903168,
-0.4958327114582062,
0.9145439267158508,
0.19326138496398926,
0.43024060130119324,
0.17515075206756592,
0.3717237114906311,
-0.5781921148300171,
-0.5609904527664185,
-1.0580745935440063,
0.19319847226142883,
-0.5779966115951538,
-0.05786927044391632,
-1.0462557077407837,
0.2669233977794647,
-0.3806004226207733,
-0.31405317783355713,
-0.15272261202335358,
-0.4755329191684723,
-0.256574422121048,
0.013704421930015087,
0.2012253701686859,
0.8268132209777832,
-0.03716297447681427,
-0.020643046125769615,
-0.6363574862480164,
0.6777592897415161,
0.5267729163169861,
-0.026291729882359505,
-0.31980666518211365,
-0.6849327087402344,
0.39656761288642883,
0.003405450377613306,
-0.2656934857368469,
-1.139877438545227,
0.5149157643318176,
-0.23926390707492828,
0.36477622389793396,
-0.018009068444371223,
-0.09332535415887833,
0.4097103774547577,
-0.7667688131332397,
0.5893449783325195,
0.42087894678115845,
-1.1552681922912598,
0.23652349412441254,
-1.1327546834945679,
0.5799105763435364,
0.47410818934440613,
0.3338939845561981,
-0.2009258270263672,
-0.5388116240501404,
-0.43233078718185425,
-0.8487678170204163,
0.7743979692459106,
0.7475239634513855,
0.2756524682044983,
0.06708677858114243,
0.1939253807067871,
0.7149633169174194,
0.8056357502937317,
-0.7857983708381653,
0.20467062294483185,
-0.5696383714675903,
-0.25932449102401733,
-0.07416996359825134,
0.40428081154823303,
0.14191702008247375,
-0.13555942475795746,
0.5247694849967957,
-0.14586985111236572,
0.5177250504493713,
0.13434357941150665,
-0.0538615956902504,
0.012063086964190006,
0.4868217706680298,
0.5733821392059326,
0.09570271521806717,
-0.16212640702724457,
0.13414981961250305,
0.3248195946216583,
-0.11265365779399872,
0.3920381963253021,
0.24625597894191742,
-0.7048214673995972,
0.3124784231185913,
-0.05696253851056099,
0.9520758390426636,
-0.1549861878156662,
-0.07069062441587448,
0.32821232080459595,
-0.19140775501728058,
-0.48107799887657166,
0.21921317279338837,
-0.2845284342765808,
0.009265214204788208,
-0.10773967206478119,
-0.03201394900679588,
0.39263585209846497,
0.13110344111919403,
-0.3984034061431885,
-0.08145492523908615,
0.450104296207428,
-0.5112619400024414,
-0.5784120559692383,
1.0803953409194946,
0.30703726410865784,
-0.1835644543170929,
0.5941212177276611,
-0.5482146143913269,
-0.46845778822898865,
0.42763954401016235,
0.45649397373199463,
1.363226294517517,
-0.41878238320350647,
0.29466208815574646,
0.2712905704975128,
0.7941692471504211,
-0.22069492936134338,
0.21617260575294495,
0.1893097162246704,
-0.2522255480289459,
-0.43794938921928406,
-0.36188870668411255,
-0.3428267240524292,
-0.04187386855483055,
-0.2458648830652237,
0.4116167426109314,
-0.5184314846992493,
-0.3696447014808655,
-0.258539080619812,
-0.6367847919464111,
-1.0409268140792847,
-0.08071693032979965,
0.0486619658768177,
0.28774046897888184,
-0.5994158387184143,
0.4888899624347687,
0.39489635825157166,
-0.5294830203056335,
-0.7101171016693115,
-0.021037520840764046,
0.19007867574691772,
-0.5771443843841553,
0.5468403100967407,
0.4488202929496765,
-0.39357754588127136,
-0.009137675166130066,
-0.08563094586133957,
-0.4658743143081665,
0.8105524182319641,
1.0997177362442017,
-0.5575065016746521,
-0.24770554900169373,
0.6495450139045715,
0.3200596868991852,
-0.13242599368095398,
0.3761198818683624,
0.3602712154388428,
0.7606331706047058,
-0.4477052092552185,
-0.9837108254432678,
0.3706808388233185,
-0.17483094334602356,
0.04392930492758751,
0.29605042934417725,
-0.3798460066318512,
1.3917155265808105,
0.1944672018289566,
-0.17092059552669525,
0.19252736866474152,
0.37026211619377136,
-0.15949077904224396,
0.18949146568775177,
0.5984106659889221,
0.2013072818517685,
0.47560983896255493,
-0.152017280459404,
1.138596773147583,
0.25853824615478516,
0.1281890720129013,
0.9187401533126831,
-0.5804798007011414,
0.11817274242639542,
0.2771099805831909,
0.08368559926748276,
0.34156534075737,
0.20986604690551758,
0.0520312562584877,
0.050559524446725845,
-0.07962333410978317,
-0.3302147686481476,
-0.29705700278282166,
-0.05751337856054306,
-0.6151639223098755,
0.3236337900161743,
0.192169189453125,
-0.3665646016597748,
-0.6463256478309631,
-0.060020074248313904,
0.06360646337270737,
-0.09514904022216797,
-0.1497015506029129,
0.35949811339378357,
0.2147827297449112,
-0.9159731864929199,
0.7426916360855103,
0.26667967438697815,
0.4973616898059845,
-0.5833263397216797,
0.050669413059949875,
-0.1843073070049286,
0.05223884806036949,
0.08381849527359009,
-0.45907771587371826,
0.4044983685016632,
0.559144914150238,
-0.30375969409942627,
-0.7805547118186951,
0.7204937934875488,
-0.20704588294029236,
-0.4787498414516449,
0.37541764974594116,
0.7649176716804504,
0.047499749809503555,
-0.05759231373667717,
-0.9370448589324951,
-0.07613568007946014,
0.28367358446121216,
0.03126506134867668,
0.3413752019405365,
0.7220572233200073,
-0.4454268217086792,
0.47553545236587524,
0.7405185103416443,
-0.31278499960899353,
0.0017280378378927708,
-0.03773994371294975,
0.6026608347892761,
-0.6822199821472168,
-0.6076348423957825,
-0.8652366995811462,
0.5546826720237732,
0.17655879259109497,
-0.2882383167743683,
0.8921236395835876,
0.10761812329292297,
0.2804130017757416,
-0.20237472653388977,
1.137039065361023,
-0.10405068844556808,
0.43052878975868225,
-0.23854009807109833,
0.5394465327262878,
-0.3810451626777649,
0.28742489218711853,
-0.39523014426231384,
-0.7160349488258362,
-0.25336843729019165,
-0.050344888120889664,
-0.506556510925293,
0.24381966888904572,
0.6227415204048157,
0.6366456747055054,
-0.4140476584434509,
0.31096354126930237,
0.15436354279518127,
0.062068331986665726,
0.3876674473285675,
0.3992465138435364,
0.9184926748275757,
-0.22824859619140625,
0.7321758270263672,
0.4029190242290497,
-0.31314167380332947,
0.0394030325114727,
-1.1033380031585693,
-0.990128219127655,
-0.09849470108747482,
-0.14890971779823303,
-0.23785409331321716,
0.27586355805397034,
0.8256252408027649,
0.322406530380249,
-0.8170980215072632,
-0.1515374630689621,
-0.7000987529754639,
0.050306130200624466,
0.04028267413377762,
-0.011455905623733997,
-0.0407349057495594,
-0.3883186876773834,
-0.9047651290893555,
0.39338240027427673,
0.15317046642303467,
0.22087493538856506,
-0.11536552011966705,
-0.23810304701328278,
0.1022644117474556,
-0.12951180338859558,
0.20529113709926605,
0.34675899147987366,
-0.5842999219894409,
-0.18134605884552002,
0.2408968061208725,
0.002532277023419738,
-0.09232140332460403,
0.8423763513565063,
-0.6012793779373169,
0.5098596215248108,
0.535632848739624,
0.8356795907020569,
0.031047236174345016,
-0.01793733239173889,
1.1539158821105957,
-0.6764021515846252,
0.04567372053861618,
0.1716604381799698,
0.13044582307338715,
0.5039646029472351,
-0.18642395734786987,
0.190841943025589,
0.49802306294441223,
-0.5102760195732117,
-0.7351663708686829,
0.4990397095680237,
-0.618123471736908,
-0.19193679094314575,
1.0859113931655884,
-0.09436588734388351,
0.030035793781280518,
-0.5333515405654907,
-0.33172371983528137,
0.4919819235801697,
-0.586317241191864,
0.3844454288482666,
0.5055081844329834,
0.16227886080741882,
0.25219765305519104,
-1.1917756795883179,
0.15341778099536896,
0.778847336769104,
-0.5026692152023315,
0.009567641653120518,
0.3508327901363373,
0.2701001465320587,
-0.1459902822971344,
0.7131786942481995,
-0.12788556516170502,
0.22467346489429474,
-0.1927807629108429,
0.06537028402090073,
-0.025563865900039673,
-0.15485341846942902,
-0.544056236743927,
0.21851271390914917,
-0.10084578394889832,
-0.2705978751182556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06025v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06025v6 | Doing Experiments and Revising Rules with Natural Language and Probabilistic Reasoning | 2024-02-08T19:57:29 | 2024-05-22T21:24:19 | Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Cassidy Langenfeld, Tuan Anh Le, Kevin Ellis | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We give a model of how to infer natural language rules by doing experiments.
The model integrates Large Language Models (LLMs) with Monte Carlo algorithms
for probabilistic inference, interleaving online belief updates with experiment
design under information-theoretic criteria. We conduct a human-model
comparison on a Zendo-style task, finding that a critical ingredient for
modeling the human data is to assume that humans also consider fuzzy,
probabilistic rules, in addition to assuming that humans perform
approximately-Bayesian belief updates. We also compare with recent algorithms
for using LLMs to generate and revise hypotheses, finding that our online
inference method yields higher accuracy at recovering the true underlying rule,
and provides better support for designing optimal experiments. | [
-0.2514423429965973,
-1.0524325370788574,
0.9460474848747253,
0.1218816488981247,
-0.07966972887516022,
-0.1443469077348709,
-0.5025262832641602,
-0.36406034231185913,
0.07938925921916962,
0.7982280850410461,
-0.6650232076644897,
-0.4382838010787964,
-0.20312003791332245,
0.13509833812713623,
-0.41869500279426575,
0.655695378780365,
0.03977064788341522,
0.22074632346630096,
-0.16219158470630646,
0.6197707653045654,
0.02628662995994091,
-0.24495548009872437,
-0.741977870464325,
-0.5775988698005676,
0.35593175888061523,
0.5287876725196838,
0.8607682585716248,
0.311360627412796,
0.5925495028495789,
0.3527378737926483,
0.06075114384293556,
0.18389226496219635,
-0.26384514570236206,
-0.022089140489697456,
-0.39062273502349854,
-0.7952573895454407,
-0.20448404550552368,
0.1365932822227478,
0.4686826169490814,
0.7672640085220337,
-0.5463634729385376,
-0.26955461502075195,
-0.23763802647590637,
0.354898065328598,
-0.3548591136932373,
0.23057059943675995,
-0.5674354434013367,
-0.036482132971286774,
0.18256177008152008,
-0.3318365514278412,
-0.5670068264007568,
-0.7149314880371094,
0.07080342620611191,
-0.6912502646446228,
0.6171033978462219,
0.11794964224100113,
0.7497184872627258,
-0.12961755692958832,
-0.2984701693058014,
-0.2910956144332886,
-0.9043250679969788,
0.8942980170249939,
-1.2994716167449951,
0.42798277735710144,
0.7145490646362305,
0.26506516337394714,
-0.8433899879455566,
-0.6972875595092773,
-0.9964314699172974,
-0.7579233646392822,
-0.1457226276397705,
-0.13062834739685059,
0.058598145842552185,
0.4488513767719269,
0.47549840807914734,
0.31085044145584106,
-0.26690852642059326,
-0.04027470201253891,
-0.22663307189941406,
0.113240085542202,
1.0298441648483276,
-0.12076845020055771,
0.315258264541626,
-0.08800286799669266,
-0.08461973071098328,
-0.34725847840309143,
-0.6744748950004578,
-0.19822843372821808,
0.42814400792121887,
0.25844383239746094,
0.16783100366592407,
0.7042360305786133,
-0.7511175274848938,
0.6899078488349915,
-0.0243915393948555,
-0.3656390607357025,
0.3082343339920044,
-0.3054342567920685,
-0.3384571373462677,
0.017018504440784454,
0.7956539392471313,
0.5213772654533386,
0.5727826952934265,
-0.3845461905002594,
-0.27915647625923157,
0.04069630056619644,
0.3602825999259949,
-0.4528960883617401,
-0.30275607109069824,
0.06468145549297333,
-0.2839113175868988,
-0.23816944658756256,
0.18693561851978302,
-0.6297844648361206,
-0.5052617192268372,
-0.5812375545501709,
0.8482811450958252,
-0.4906533360481262,
-0.1796916127204895,
0.5909852981567383,
-0.34184661507606506,
-0.028392711654305458,
0.5519465804100037,
-0.8707019090652466,
0.7480748295783997,
0.8155682682991028,
0.5278624296188354,
0.24345257878303528,
-0.41291630268096924,
-0.35264042019844055,
0.1086294949054718,
-0.6481707096099854,
0.9009079337120056,
-0.5681794881820679,
-0.3204396963119507,
-0.13497567176818848,
-0.06241130828857422,
0.01889765076339245,
-0.3791685402393341,
0.7912845015525818,
-0.5047947764396667,
0.3404524624347687,
-0.33815398812294006,
-0.9200472235679626,
-0.48004329204559326,
0.02440257929265499,
-0.535122275352478,
0.8850346207618713,
-0.05188016593456268,
-0.8450735211372375,
0.3301241993904114,
-0.8016698956489563,
-0.4693320095539093,
-0.16233152151107788,
-0.01100056990981102,
-0.2847994267940521,
0.20563147962093353,
-0.08408956229686737,
0.43166616559028625,
-0.40476709604263306,
0.428145170211792,
-0.5034217238426208,
-0.42337992787361145,
0.7398577928543091,
-0.20148532092571259,
0.6858193278312683,
0.2880726754665375,
-0.38495224714279175,
0.21044830977916718,
-0.6801466345787048,
-0.0024781697429716587,
0.15600934624671936,
-0.26654431223869324,
-0.2349693328142166,
0.796814501285553,
-0.06229903921484947,
-0.012645348906517029,
-0.28589969873428345,
-0.791046679019928,
0.4482252299785614,
-0.583455502986908,
0.6085453629493713,
0.49729228019714355,
0.26977282762527466,
0.44150054454803467,
-0.5220668911933899,
0.060942184180021286,
-0.32099437713623047,
0.11300640553236008,
0.16500908136367798,
-0.7049790620803833,
-0.6832834482192993,
-0.10221803933382034,
0.26094216108322144,
0.539695680141449,
-0.6166861653327942,
0.2983980178833008,
-0.12854495644569397,
-0.5037904381752014,
-0.4574373960494995,
0.19903695583343506,
0.0508476197719574,
0.3989724814891815,
0.3394578695297241,
-0.16175392270088196,
-0.5742690563201904,
-1.0065574645996094,
-0.44174593687057495,
-0.1671067327260971,
-0.31156402826309204,
-0.13284045457839966,
0.5683485865592957,
-0.30989134311676025,
1.0341092348098755,
-0.49326130747795105,
0.04211985692381859,
-0.39849045872688293,
0.5924456119537354,
0.3589150905609131,
0.4451840817928314,
0.2916523218154907,
-0.8180565237998962,
-0.1623409390449524,
-0.12227015197277069,
-0.5077775716781616,
-0.18698793649673462,
-0.2680536210536957,
0.003153847996145487,
-0.06773938238620758,
0.5968344807624817,
-0.7921998500823975,
0.6107944846153259,
0.1441548764705658,
-0.3465271294116974,
0.3755117356777191,
-0.44701194763183594,
0.6190972924232483,
-0.9282391667366028,
-0.4842648506164551,
0.2951158583164215,
-0.24836945533752441,
-1.038562297821045,
0.18980476260185242,
0.015593034215271473,
0.4335644841194153,
-0.3457675874233246,
0.34198522567749023,
-0.3858715295791626,
-0.0843873992562294,
-0.4409755766391754,
0.08536818623542786,
-0.08147644251585007,
0.18173956871032715,
0.4001259505748749,
0.5696165561676025,
0.4274745285511017,
-0.7053934931755066,
0.4581999182701111,
-0.1612536907196045,
-0.6987294554710388,
0.2474398910999298,
-0.6578500270843506,
-0.04278845712542534,
-0.30394163727760315,
0.15187500417232513,
-1.1480709314346313,
-0.4486483335494995,
0.35060280561447144,
-0.5181801319122314,
0.10842741280794144,
0.19057346880435944,
-1.129281759262085,
-0.21324048936367035,
-0.32777416706085205,
-0.1008189246058464,
0.6614748239517212,
-0.4144825041294098,
0.6907890439033508,
0.1328127384185791,
-0.11048559844493866,
-0.057857248932123184,
-0.6214241981506348,
0.3131139576435089,
-0.2399473786354065,
-0.4235036075115204,
0.4923064708709717,
-0.09037156403064728,
-1.0094091892242432,
0.007996775209903717,
0.37285131216049194,
-0.12987348437309265,
0.34794124960899353,
0.12890197336673737,
0.09147123992443085,
-0.10483723878860474,
0.14769496023654938,
-0.10907900333404541,
0.13267171382904053,
0.35274848341941833,
0.11992622166872025,
0.3916020393371582,
0.12186086177825928,
-0.45639437437057495,
-0.6519453525543213,
0.2832183539867401,
0.20199652016162872,
0.1856323778629303,
0.6622781753540039,
0.2827002704143524,
-0.7018176913261414,
-0.23486508429050446,
-0.8380885720252991,
-0.5157188773155212,
-0.4925578832626343,
0.19872264564037323,
-0.3800660967826843,
-0.5429760813713074,
0.151598259806633,
-0.018584299832582474,
0.12633031606674194,
0.34912458062171936,
0.5895479321479797,
-0.5173680186271667,
1.2508811950683594,
0.542828381061554,
0.3426204025745392,
0.4639246165752411,
0.09949717670679092,
0.278107613325119,
-0.636600136756897,
0.048553429543972015,
-0.5100888609886169,
-0.0767548531293869,
-0.5951294302940369,
-0.6869091987609863,
0.019730815663933754,
0.30327656865119934,
-0.19979578256607056,
0.25442662835121155,
-0.053694069385528564,
0.49648478627204895,
0.925619900226593,
0.31997400522232056,
0.33549362421035767,
-0.05940277501940727,
-0.001946658594533801,
0.09637276828289032,
-0.5242828130722046,
-0.6118229031562805,
1.002234935760498,
0.15176139771938324,
1.1201388835906982,
0.1827227622270584,
0.7029028534889221,
0.3796178102493286,
0.6311721205711365,
-0.6670928597450256,
0.5582696795463562,
0.341645210981369,
-0.711662232875824,
-0.1822039633989334,
-0.5693480968475342,
-0.8073030710220337,
0.17119243741035461,
-0.5599578619003296,
-0.9943166971206665,
-0.0793672651052475,
0.10453931987285614,
-0.132307767868042,
0.4812413156032562,
-0.8363892436027527,
0.5141564011573792,
-0.14901116490364075,
-0.33313220739364624,
-0.5640308260917664,
-0.4746069312095642,
0.4118373692035675,
0.043821677565574646,
0.5657371282577515,
-0.15683922171592712,
0.1201484277844429,
0.7187297940254211,
-0.2671716511249542,
1.1519123315811157,
0.11147033423185349,
-0.07564818859100342,
0.5917935371398926,
0.3335881531238556,
0.4727666676044464,
0.12464414536952972,
-0.14049892127513885,
-0.11063896119594574,
0.06070864573121071,
-0.2548500895500183,
-0.7277530431747437,
0.5538862943649292,
-0.7446224093437195,
-0.8493975400924683,
-0.47613635659217834,
-0.5218075513839722,
-0.29674002528190613,
0.037903815507888794,
0.009001432918012142,
0.027208073064684868,
-0.19797278940677643,
0.05572490766644478,
0.8411145806312561,
-0.21582385897636414,
0.23370324075222015,
0.6912939548492432,
-0.3831923305988312,
-0.23594646155834198,
0.5351564884185791,
0.01146053709089756,
0.546827495098114,
0.6461650133132935,
0.43739020824432373,
-0.2176436483860016,
-0.4999907612800598,
-0.08426716923713684,
0.3865234851837158,
-0.6941860318183899,
0.16151636838912964,
-0.5291346311569214,
-0.11906376481056213,
-0.5786100625991821,
-0.17094430327415466,
-0.11806729435920715,
-0.2905369997024536,
-0.2085941880941391,
-0.1910778135061264,
0.5888493657112122,
0.9112395644187927,
-0.29891273379325867,
0.3679516315460205,
-0.6832874417304993,
0.6075611710548401,
0.4279446303844452,
0.27384310960769653,
-0.12434723228216171,
-0.4993789494037628,
0.06330662220716476,
0.47512200474739075,
-0.12137968838214874,
-1.2940682172775269,
0.3485082983970642,
0.20928172767162323,
0.7825904488563538,
0.4304753243923187,
-0.031205859035253525,
0.4930252134799957,
-0.5994680523872375,
0.5517995357513428,
0.052563682198524475,
-0.8261734843254089,
0.6432957649230957,
-0.3965538740158081,
-0.1574011892080307,
0.3553762137889862,
0.4748675227165222,
-0.758757472038269,
-0.395123153924942,
-0.8128658533096313,
-0.3364051878452301,
0.45378294587135315,
0.20296981930732727,
-0.005585466977208853,
-0.286289244890213,
0.6206905841827393,
0.027756547555327415,
0.29303497076034546,
-0.3952137231826782,
0.17071208357810974,
0.11216409504413605,
-0.32291379570961,
-0.38671794533729553,
-0.13960886001586914,
-0.1373109519481659,
-0.33257338404655457,
0.7226266860961914,
-0.17879532277584076,
0.2120833545923233,
0.3363191783428192,
-0.01283296849578619,
-0.2170330286026001,
0.3972325921058655,
0.7326745390892029,
0.8176674842834473,
-0.45806238055229187,
0.2546902596950531,
0.43767839670181274,
-0.167809396982193,
-0.02558118849992752,
-0.009691252373158932,
-0.26401087641716003,
-0.15700949728488922,
0.5386988520622253,
0.6012009978294373,
0.4872129559516907,
-0.9539926052093506,
0.15267716348171234,
-0.30775249004364014,
-0.5474728941917419,
-0.3020007312297821,
0.5553622245788574,
0.5115553140640259,
0.3062526285648346,
0.3310525119304657,
-0.029863370582461357,
0.3488667905330658,
-0.933253288269043,
0.24868206679821014,
0.26482170820236206,
0.037793055176734924,
-0.43656685948371887,
0.5593929886817932,
-0.23998668789863586,
-0.7182934284210205,
0.5113562345504761,
-0.40802955627441406,
-0.5205141305923462,
0.5366573929786682,
0.6689453721046448,
0.5857557654380798,
-0.07866158336400986,
0.2879420518875122,
0.3816395699977875,
0.3136751055717468,
-0.6731675863265991,
0.5979171395301819,
0.024147160351276398,
-0.9061692953109741,
-0.5938006043434143,
-0.534656286239624,
-0.6773646473884583,
-0.18781758844852448,
-0.4534730613231659,
0.2993852198123932,
-0.40921467542648315,
-0.1080167219042778,
0.11086958646774292,
0.006731230299919844,
-0.5534814596176147,
0.47690829634666443,
0.2310762256383896,
0.9488240480422974,
-0.8854168057441711,
0.9189760684967041,
0.671771228313446,
-0.33479827642440796,
-0.5432214140892029,
0.03165917098522186,
0.1281045377254486,
-0.6275899410247803,
0.653401255607605,
-0.12795390188694,
-0.042610183358192444,
-0.04567195475101471,
-0.8651813268661499,
-1.0758037567138672,
0.8276966214179993,
0.1347607970237732,
-0.6274019479751587,
0.11283162236213684,
-0.016017641872167587,
0.5860441327095032,
-0.273309588432312,
0.29861706495285034,
0.5784397721290588,
0.4443747401237488,
0.21159476041793823,
-0.8076719045639038,
-0.13361050188541412,
-0.05367927625775337,
-0.09658441692590714,
0.20822367072105408,
-0.2144448310136795,
1.0723686218261719,
-0.6343669891357422,
-0.24841268360614777,
-0.017540615051984787,
0.8865876197814941,
0.21769918501377106,
0.14749358594417572,
0.6476974487304688,
0.7770556211471558,
0.746360719203949,
-0.04306725412607193,
1.2142155170440674,
0.031896717846393585,
0.4601254165172577,
1.3002269268035889,
-0.44082996249198914,
1.0902072191238403,
0.4894866645336151,
-0.45205309987068176,
0.5841194987297058,
0.9012045860290527,
0.17245112359523773,
0.5510599613189697,
0.5229164958000183,
-0.29024121165275574,
-0.49117276072502136,
0.04049014672636986,
-0.09957649558782578,
0.1805392950773239,
0.4415867328643799,
-0.2303600162267685,
-0.16620230674743652,
-0.20778857171535492,
0.17050743103027344,
0.16691675782203674,
-0.25912052392959595,
0.8197055459022522,
-0.015352175571024418,
-0.8431774377822876,
0.09419913589954376,
0.5125784277915955,
0.5745819211006165,
-0.44518235325813293,
-0.30836471915245056,
0.05011618509888649,
0.3750499486923218,
-0.14271582663059235,
-0.9717115163803101,
0.1580812931060791,
-0.13355691730976105,
0.07946700602769852,
-0.009382623247802258,
0.7164843082427979,
-0.3129012882709503,
-0.767865002155304,
0.08206026256084442,
0.17788229882717133,
0.15690450370311737,
0.03620557859539986,
-0.5822038650512695,
-0.22429879009723663,
-0.11334944516420364,
-0.5232594609260559,
0.22463075816631317,
0.3180612027645111,
-0.12637144327163696,
0.8495491147041321,
0.82045978307724,
0.3446836769580841,
0.19271765649318695,
0.2580128312110901,
0.6607940793037415,
-0.8861766457557678,
-0.40966978669166565,
-0.9424425363540649,
0.2534129023551941,
-0.2629457414150238,
-0.017910098657011986,
0.7474183440208435,
0.26621800661087036,
0.9279701709747314,
-0.01072858739644289,
0.86086505651474,
0.04920361191034317,
0.6102798581123352,
-0.7575129270553589,
0.34707748889923096,
-0.36491236090660095,
0.06964708119630814,
-0.1397029310464859,
-0.6744039058685303,
-0.3251638114452362,
1.0527591705322266,
-0.44525429606437683,
-0.022406186908483505,
0.5798078775405884,
0.9071993231773376,
-0.012566635385155678,
0.3566727936267853,
0.08289357274770737,
0.4134722054004669,
0.4191931486129761,
0.4718822240829468,
0.9066576361656189,
-0.28836989402770996,
-0.3087330162525177,
-0.5584798455238342,
-0.2561233639717102,
-0.31791794300079346,
-1.0117322206497192,
-0.9695819616317749,
-0.4945656955242157,
-0.4366458058357239,
-0.322444349527359,
-0.00026542815612629056,
1.3955912590026855,
0.4584893584251404,
-0.7610583901405334,
-0.5078510642051697,
-0.2826823890209198,
0.17279167473316193,
-0.39652854204177856,
-0.2800769507884979,
-0.04469398036599159,
-0.4086432456970215,
-0.544861376285553,
0.49116697907447815,
-0.027281636372208595,
0.014502635225653648,
-0.21532386541366577,
-0.12318193167448044,
-0.6587849855422974,
0.5706824660301208,
0.41718408465385437,
-0.009660397656261921,
-0.8460168242454529,
-0.5168749094009399,
-0.10604381561279297,
-0.15000811219215393,
0.03985900804400444,
0.7461528182029724,
-0.7506867051124573,
0.5059554576873779,
0.8331518769264221,
0.3353882133960724,
0.44947943091392517,
-0.023227782920002937,
0.6875640749931335,
-0.17941342294216156,
-0.2235456258058548,
0.08624819666147232,
0.45339837670326233,
0.3238244652748108,
-0.07784505188465118,
0.5987528562545776,
0.30641475319862366,
-0.4868525266647339,
-0.9177002906799316,
0.18315823376178741,
-0.7833273410797119,
-0.42584770917892456,
1.255900502204895,
-0.0443686805665493,
-0.44206753373146057,
0.009874922223389149,
-0.30381128191947937,
0.24795104563236237,
-0.1728971153497696,
0.9731534719467163,
0.7836750149726868,
-0.3172844350337982,
-0.22055454552173615,
-0.9998313784599304,
0.5735271573066711,
-0.0020155850797891617,
-0.9594020247459412,
0.014165299944579601,
0.27396512031555176,
0.5605987906455994,
0.07080324739217758,
0.5751202702522278,
0.2104232758283615,
0.28716930747032166,
0.0178129430860281,
0.30128756165504456,
0.3567456007003784,
-0.12718433141708374,
0.09728575497865677,
-0.06642505526542664,
0.2676629424095154,
0.2929171919822693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06015v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06015v2 | Exploring Visual Culture Awareness in GPT-4V: A Comprehensive Probing | 2024-02-08T19:25:40 | 2024-02-15T10:39:19 | Yong Cao, Wenyan Li, Jiaang Li, Yifei Yuan, Antonia Karamolegkou, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Pretrained large Vision-Language models have drawn considerable interest in
recent years due to their remarkable performance. Despite considerable efforts
to assess these models from diverse perspectives, the extent of visual cultural
awareness in the state-of-the-art GPT-4V model remains unexplored. To tackle
this gap, we extensively probed GPT-4V using the MaRVL benchmark dataset,
aiming to investigate its capabilities and limitations in visual understanding
with a focus on cultural aspects. Specifically, we introduced three visual
related tasks, i.e. caption classification, pairwise captioning, and culture
tag selection, to systematically delve into fine-grained visual cultural
evaluation. Experimental results indicate that GPT-4V excels at identifying
cultural concepts but still exhibits weaker performance in low-resource
languages, such as Tamil and Swahili. Notably, through human evaluation, GPT-4V
proves to be more culturally relevant in image captioning tasks than the
original MaRVL human annotations, suggesting a promising solution for future
visual cultural benchmark construction. | [
-0.6938039064407349,
-0.24706587195396423,
0.3623785674571991,
0.07589639723300934,
-0.3971906006336212,
0.011633400805294514,
-0.35039767622947693,
-0.6346963047981262,
-0.3552229404449463,
0.42673835158348083,
-0.46250468492507935,
-0.5714406967163086,
-0.3987976610660553,
0.21661163866519928,
0.1654861867427826,
0.8870071172714233,
-0.49065712094306946,
0.05434652045369148,
-0.24271829426288605,
-0.4287518560886383,
-0.7359734177589417,
-0.4714716672897339,
-0.24284271895885468,
-0.029609907418489456,
0.30508294701576233,
0.2555144727230072,
0.24863839149475098,
0.4720092713832855,
0.8012593388557434,
0.21963518857955933,
0.2161865383386612,
0.06293971091508865,
-0.6484139561653137,
-0.07332306355237961,
0.0065386053174734116,
-0.47403600811958313,
-0.25581130385398865,
0.4607662856578827,
0.5877973437309265,
0.15835237503051758,
0.08665668964385986,
0.500389814376831,
-0.1178799420595169,
0.6695248484611511,
-0.7332250475883484,
0.6477898359298706,
-0.4805225729942322,
0.2921347916126251,
-0.4816407859325409,
-0.13602682948112488,
-0.10788874328136444,
-0.04550032317638397,
0.33247822523117065,
-0.6182587742805481,
0.17309115827083588,
-0.04532357305288315,
0.7805994153022766,
0.5190373659133911,
-0.5795134902000427,
0.1961280256509781,
-0.6660831570625305,
0.7021307349205017,
-0.033296555280685425,
0.6274099349975586,
0.44401440024375916,
0.5910507440567017,
0.4499457776546478,
-0.8525186777114868,
-0.5446233153343201,
-0.04269769787788391,
0.17070822417736053,
0.5342274308204651,
-0.24099500477313995,
-0.1585879921913147,
0.4319974482059479,
0.2919481098651886,
-0.7252699732780457,
-0.14622336626052856,
-0.4903410077095032,
-0.4628826975822449,
0.41721752285957336,
0.04412847012281418,
0.33956006169319153,
-0.12349162995815277,
-0.5362737774848938,
-0.03157972916960716,
-0.8205094337463379,
0.2588963210582733,
0.019525619223713875,
-0.12539124488830566,
-0.3096964657306671,
0.2752743363380432,
-0.3797517716884613,
0.6716147065162659,
-0.529263973236084,
0.08106033504009247,
0.3615845739841461,
-0.7472624778747559,
-0.25855937600135803,
-0.4244190454483032,
0.6449466347694397,
0.882817804813385,
0.7258095145225525,
0.3184265196323395,
-0.11537274718284607,
0.12084819376468658,
0.3193542957305908,
-0.9035892486572266,
-0.5291551947593689,
-0.3433787226676941,
-0.44153308868408203,
-0.18850857019424438,
-0.11746621876955032,
-0.5658175945281982,
-0.5385748744010925,
-0.09443790465593338,
0.3694590628147125,
-0.34822389483451843,
-0.3306122422218323,
-0.2500157654285431,
-0.1653517484664917,
0.7575531601905823,
0.6660041213035583,
-0.9012108445167542,
-0.120649054646492,
0.41044485569000244,
0.7093176245689392,
-0.21633128821849823,
-0.28072425723075867,
-0.2597045600414276,
0.09460852295160294,
-0.5506089329719543,
0.506737470626831,
-0.5532000660896301,
-0.2834053337574005,
-0.1573583483695984,
-0.12054132670164108,
0.1494438201189041,
-0.286472886800766,
0.5960033535957336,
-0.5934290289878845,
0.05503440648317337,
-0.780512273311615,
0.011491821147501469,
-0.4142703711986542,
0.7450250387191772,
-0.6197806000709534,
0.6196491718292236,
0.17134447395801544,
-0.9165692925453186,
0.8170391917228699,
-0.4715158939361572,
-0.08218465000391006,
0.5988242626190186,
-0.7061402797698975,
-0.34580403566360474,
-0.061196018010377884,
0.5039359927177429,
0.4981536865234375,
-0.16069014370441437,
-0.23665623366832733,
-0.1528228372335434,
-0.6364749670028687,
0.016868963837623596,
-0.5941805839538574,
0.3194054961204529,
0.3917020261287689,
-0.3549097776412964,
0.17515142261981964,
-0.29108038544654846,
-0.2659311294555664,
0.25878363847732544,
-0.020661164075136185,
-0.4241337478160858,
-0.30198433995246887,
-0.13095726072788239,
0.17236080765724182,
0.33118873834609985,
-0.3229013979434967,
0.21526563167572021,
0.06507433205842972,
0.42974939942359924,
0.6827886700630188,
0.05221153795719147,
0.45067331194877625,
0.08461060374975204,
0.7895317673683167,
0.14223383367061615,
0.4797033369541168,
-0.26212820410728455,
-0.6642128229141235,
-0.43056783080101013,
-0.2544287145137787,
-0.08134280145168304,
0.37372317910194397,
-1.201125979423523,
-0.5087676644325256,
-0.2994386553764343,
-0.38494056463241577,
-0.32085999846458435,
0.1461717188358307,
0.3759750425815582,
0.6060921549797058,
0.22431747615337372,
-0.646353542804718,
-0.3135377764701843,
-1.107151746749878,
-0.05602550134062767,
-0.24977415800094604,
0.19619058072566986,
0.4884788393974304,
0.4889749586582184,
-0.07402346283197403,
0.6803723573684692,
-0.3868236839771271,
-0.46323779225349426,
-0.18898136913776398,
0.12642215192317963,
-0.02904270961880684,
0.200008362531662,
0.6908764839172363,
-1.0468400716781616,
-0.4743940234184265,
0.29860392212867737,
-0.8251070380210876,
0.09891791641712189,
0.2694838047027588,
0.019959906116127968,
0.3414563834667206,
0.43943697214126587,
-0.12592150270938873,
0.4919643700122833,
0.6345357298851013,
-0.08407007157802582,
0.4995540678501129,
-0.19115960597991943,
0.46964767575263977,
-0.7153545618057251,
-0.11570484191179276,
0.16666921973228455,
-0.136112242937088,
-0.5867984890937805,
-0.023487726226449013,
0.5113914012908936,
-0.1418221890926361,
-0.46115192770957947,
0.23590382933616638,
-0.683069109916687,
-0.40049248933792114,
-0.05731517821550369,
-0.13349305093288422,
-0.13380715250968933,
0.3967529237270355,
0.4474518299102783,
0.9823277592658997,
0.7469225525856018,
-0.02738148532807827,
0.3279610872268677,
0.1655997484922409,
-0.49492907524108887,
0.7029913067817688,
-0.3546496033668518,
-0.06945796310901642,
-0.0927511528134346,
0.3390033543109894,
-0.8678144216537476,
-0.28214168548583984,
0.36114978790283203,
-0.2590327262878418,
0.19794915616512299,
-0.7398968935012817,
-0.2568899095058441,
-0.5250556468963623,
-0.24612432718276978,
0.8192946314811707,
0.7863617539405823,
-0.26693007349967957,
0.46239063143730164,
0.2335173487663269,
-0.017265351489186287,
-0.62498539686203,
-0.6084337830543518,
0.16419744491577148,
-0.5845464468002319,
-0.6431657075881958,
-0.22018562257289886,
0.1162450984120369,
-0.12626278400421143,
-0.5351986885070801,
-0.3255106806755066,
0.03601108863949776,
0.05908447876572609,
0.2853310704231262,
0.36056461930274963,
-0.2719411849975586,
-0.08201729506254196,
-0.6533561944961548,
0.12888501584529877,
0.10623002797365189,
-0.31364870071411133,
0.3468160927295685,
-0.9207972884178162,
-0.43430545926094055,
-0.45790213346481323,
-0.12339859455823898,
0.5596381425857544,
-1.020885944366455,
0.051447708159685135,
1.129831314086914,
-0.1829017847776413,
0.16030524671077728,
-0.7593623399734497,
0.00003263028702349402,
-0.44814684987068176,
0.46593236923217773,
-0.6495922803878784,
-0.9923315048217773,
0.47634246945381165,
0.04817243665456772,
-0.466762900352478,
0.2791373133659363,
0.5716468095779419,
-0.20803983509540558,
0.6194285154342651,
0.6374791860580444,
0.09827959537506104,
0.3745734691619873,
-0.2739584147930145,
-0.06753136217594147,
-0.7528883218765259,
-0.2739197313785553,
-0.06275422871112823,
-0.11195709556341171,
-1.0429333448410034,
-0.9275215268135071,
0.585461437702179,
-0.2601330578327179,
-0.18735642731189728,
-0.0347134992480278,
-0.39955493807792664,
0.7013276219367981,
0.3422003388404846,
-0.13983426988124847,
0.2428404986858368,
-0.11999993026256561,
0.0725497156381607,
-0.2891010642051697,
-0.4018324017524719,
-0.42123648524284363,
0.9476745128631592,
0.47925034165382385,
0.6644970774650574,
0.17900796234607697,
0.5274787545204163,
0.05918774753808975,
0.3206748962402344,
-0.5425173044204712,
0.33838966488838196,
-0.03922198340296745,
-0.4226513206958771,
-0.1853664666414261,
-0.3339157700538635,
-0.5674363374710083,
0.3567105233669281,
-0.07033979892730713,
-0.681979238986969,
0.1791960895061493,
0.35513052344322205,
-0.23407334089279175,
0.14694830775260925,
-0.8719480037689209,
1.3311296701431274,
-0.3171580731868744,
-0.4989594519138336,
0.05027925223112106,
-0.9206122756004333,
0.6366736888885498,
-0.3068138360977173,
0.283505380153656,
-0.17016960680484772,
0.016726702451705933,
0.4728926718235016,
0.0552556999027729,
0.7579165101051331,
-0.19894878566265106,
-0.09561219811439514,
0.13427434861660004,
0.0699731633067131,
0.3522079288959503,
0.03488483279943466,
0.5362518429756165,
0.34397944808006287,
-0.10404430329799652,
-0.4272158145904541,
-0.3864547312259674,
0.6671634316444397,
-0.8982608914375305,
-0.6144940853118896,
-0.556550145149231,
-0.5974882245063782,
-0.3149383068084717,
0.20943583548069,
0.017615532502532005,
0.34269922971725464,
-0.17694668471813202,
0.10691916197538376,
0.5854192972183228,
-0.26154187321662903,
0.45094695687294006,
0.4909970462322235,
-0.23355746269226074,
-0.06777742505073547,
0.9042425155639648,
0.09402641654014587,
0.17995047569274902,
0.14893151819705963,
0.13148589432239532,
-0.24021492898464203,
-0.8701643943786621,
-0.7456486821174622,
0.034876223653554916,
-0.7945446968078613,
0.22588670253753662,
-0.32750803232192993,
0.09723634272813797,
-0.17278560996055603,
-0.04043800011277199,
-0.45079106092453003,
-0.02866111882030964,
0.0367160364985466,
0.08234211802482605,
0.2971474230289459,
0.8980224132537842,
0.20941482484340668,
-0.05983223766088486,
-0.5734347105026245,
0.1412809193134308,
0.5535213947296143,
0.5647895336151123,
-0.33563631772994995,
-0.47541648149490356,
-0.24362286925315857,
-0.2659100592136383,
-0.07728536427021027,
-0.6543563604354858,
0.3226979672908783,
-0.10880102962255478,
0.4480878710746765,
0.56952303647995,
-0.06897759437561035,
0.6766486763954163,
-0.6464011669158936,
0.992483913898468,
0.022421661764383316,
-0.6827331781387329,
0.49259570240974426,
-0.6919130682945251,
0.47646835446357727,
0.43444639444351196,
0.48438555002212524,
-0.5656754970550537,
-0.16805529594421387,
-0.3516688346862793,
-0.5956966876983643,
0.4298074245452881,
0.3308526277542114,
0.020767424255609512,
0.18537737429141998,
0.05575959011912346,
0.006676610559225082,
0.15623973309993744,
-0.6905043721199036,
0.15767328441143036,
-0.7199822068214417,
0.30513811111450195,
-0.18742920458316803,
-0.033521849662065506,
-0.23333582282066345,
-0.24008619785308838,
0.15614134073257446,
-0.22415080666542053,
-0.08186861127614975,
0.09916900098323822,
-0.31031814217567444,
0.14172224700450897,
0.0652768462896347,
0.7932322025299072,
0.8222829699516296,
-0.3404010832309723,
0.24240002036094666,
0.4167095124721527,
-0.7551383376121521,
-0.08038369566202164,
0.07544250041246414,
0.07786847651004791,
-0.5764725208282471,
0.3538965880870819,
0.9379924535751343,
-0.21128186583518982,
-0.4568484127521515,
0.8257201313972473,
-0.5085415840148926,
-0.022583765909075737,
-0.5700774788856506,
-0.1476115882396698,
0.022588714957237244,
0.311669260263443,
0.24831770360469818,
0.09157383441925049,
0.134007528424263,
-0.3943544626235962,
0.08434583246707916,
0.4721739888191223,
-0.6740351915359497,
-0.32369571924209595,
0.804995059967041,
0.4181920886039734,
0.3507806062698364,
0.730228841304779,
-0.17464596033096313,
-0.7407403588294983,
0.4622449576854706,
0.15117612481117249,
0.49633315205574036,
-0.03838907554745674,
0.14603444933891296,
0.1829608529806137,
0.6644244194030762,
0.07428082078695297,
0.385407954454422,
-0.2946607172489166,
-0.9237146973609924,
-0.6936261653900146,
-0.5709602236747742,
-0.40950608253479004,
-0.11341123282909393,
-0.6559358835220337,
0.2633771300315857,
-0.2522297203540802,
0.05197971314191818,
-0.2538208067417145,
-0.06796485930681229,
-1.0107063055038452,
0.3672689199447632,
0.6895858645439148,
0.5965330004692078,
-1.2019286155700684,
0.9475617408752441,
0.892570972442627,
-0.7245155572891235,
-0.8109548687934875,
0.08682827651500702,
0.23348698019981384,
-1.0457582473754883,
0.9824696183204651,
0.5103776454925537,
-0.10017117112874985,
0.019478116184473038,
-0.4115040600299835,
-0.7114887237548828,
1.3323577642440796,
-0.04852530360221863,
-0.3291853666305542,
0.4598856568336487,
0.06498786062002182,
0.6437206268310547,
-0.2633008360862732,
0.31858837604522705,
0.6861351728439331,
0.6008214950561523,
0.2552063763141632,
-0.8980523347854614,
0.018626045435667038,
-0.33183714747428894,
0.244353786110878,
0.1326204240322113,
-0.8476823568344116,
0.6057283282279968,
-0.3226713538169861,
0.0161991436034441,
-0.29560548067092896,
0.7096124887466431,
0.14062339067459106,
0.3253513276576996,
0.5797821283340454,
0.3714066445827484,
0.5972329378128052,
-0.39219188690185547,
1.3419482707977295,
0.06518793851137161,
0.09698651731014252,
0.7893510460853577,
-0.44874149560928345,
0.6318275332450867,
0.4495662450790405,
-0.13350683450698853,
0.088758185505867,
0.8413775563240051,
-0.30442580580711365,
0.47154271602630615,
0.37112581729888916,
-0.2802262306213379,
-0.35060298442840576,
-0.1852066069841385,
-0.4233541488647461,
1.0049113035202026,
0.17436374723911285,
-0.07985454052686691,
0.019299956038594246,
0.09695091843605042,
-0.16381864249706268,
-0.21309340000152588,
-0.5238871574401855,
0.6643082499504089,
-0.19099654257297516,
-0.5868338942527771,
0.6272079348564148,
-0.3913253843784332,
0.5851625800132751,
-0.4980238676071167,
-0.09126009047031403,
-0.3083101511001587,
-0.08401986211538315,
0.09591378271579742,
-0.9061539769172668,
0.05708509311079979,
0.08362210541963577,
0.08957123756408691,
-0.4475300908088684,
0.6751807928085327,
-0.35159358382225037,
-0.17968173325061798,
-0.09674569219350815,
0.4483417868614197,
0.4417232275009155,
-0.29733049869537354,
-0.2746809720993042,
0.38512659072875977,
0.2967323362827301,
-0.15983490645885468,
0.33021244406700134,
0.46921005845069885,
-0.7162964344024658,
0.5482679605484009,
0.3873034417629242,
-0.11315962672233582,
-0.043438903987407684,
0.4145214259624481,
0.6196967959403992,
-0.5438082218170166,
-0.3837506175041199,
-0.7916731834411621,
0.3990783095359802,
-0.10287840664386749,
-0.1827666014432907,
0.7675923109054565,
0.4914242625236511,
1.0411511659622192,
-0.2946791350841522,
0.9871741533279419,
0.20302163064479828,
-0.2788332402706146,
-0.35039985179901123,
0.9844833612442017,
-0.5093160271644592,
0.06909699738025665,
-0.4019474387168884,
-0.8288373351097107,
-0.36003074049949646,
0.5191419124603271,
-0.5962424874305725,
0.12493444234132767,
0.6764964461326599,
0.49979671835899353,
0.03626732528209686,
0.28687185049057007,
0.6331379413604736,
0.28467419743537903,
0.3979615867137909,
0.35245782136917114,
1.1904833316802979,
0.1454392969608307,
0.7577826976776123,
-0.3531261384487152,
-0.3788638412952423,
0.12775468826293945,
-1.1917670965194702,
-0.8718118667602539,
-0.7157948017120361,
-0.25625383853912354,
0.16686616837978363,
-0.019434183835983276,
0.5458227396011353,
0.5778209567070007,
-0.4614405930042267,
-0.04288690909743309,
0.35040512681007385,
-0.34177541732788086,
-0.09855929762125015,
-0.11349857598543167,
0.36468350887298584,
-0.028654713183641434,
-0.6719426512718201,
0.24193672835826874,
0.4927629232406616,
0.23482617735862732,
-0.3168865442276001,
-0.013315411284565926,
0.17703719437122345,
-0.4460768401622772,
0.6633342504501343,
0.2523992955684662,
-0.8096350431442261,
-0.42518219351768494,
-0.09850259870290756,
0.10844353586435318,
-0.012192848138511181,
0.6476544141769409,
-0.6353411078453064,
0.8875610828399658,
0.47746512293815613,
0.5824984312057495,
0.949602484703064,
0.24204757809638977,
0.7561393976211548,
-0.8383839726448059,
0.12444932758808136,
0.12014276534318924,
0.5139700770378113,
0.7173343896865845,
0.021908659487962723,
0.630002498626709,
0.37633970379829407,
-0.7000742554664612,
-0.4529932737350464,
0.39841532707214355,
-1.1992197036743164,
0.16247744858264923,
1.022871732711792,
-0.20731164515018463,
-0.058610450476408005,
0.010376927442848682,
-0.3287169635295868,
0.15389640629291534,
-0.17307646572589874,
0.3205541968345642,
0.7310466766357422,
-0.09704615920782089,
-0.4675474464893341,
-1.0810558795928955,
0.5761876106262207,
0.18523958325386047,
-0.5759732723236084,
0.07163316756486893,
0.735836923122406,
0.5202779769897461,
-0.06452326476573944,
0.6358795166015625,
-0.1998518705368042,
0.4859350323677063,
-0.28174394369125366,
0.4137018918991089,
-0.23715399205684662,
-0.05987558886408806,
-0.3183460831642151,
0.021967781707644463,
0.17357470095157623,
-0.3607967495918274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05935v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05935v2 | SPHINX-X: Scaling Data and Parameters for a Family of Multi-modal Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T18:59:48 | 2024-06-26T07:59:03 | Dongyang Liu, Renrui Zhang, Longtian Qiu, Siyuan Huang, Weifeng Lin, Shitian Zhao, Shijie Geng, Ziyi Lin, Peng Jin, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Chao Xu, Conghui He, Junjun He, Hao Shao, Pan Lu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao, Peng Gao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose SPHINX-X, an extensive Multimodality Large Language Model (MLLM)
series developed upon SPHINX. To improve the architecture and training
efficiency, we modify the SPHINX framework by removing redundant visual
encoders, bypassing fully-padded sub-images with skip tokens, and simplifying
multi-stage training into a one-stage all-in-one paradigm. To fully unleash the
potential of MLLMs, we assemble a comprehensive multi-domain and multimodal
dataset covering publicly available resources in language, vision, and
vision-language tasks. We further enrich this collection with our curated OCR
intensive and Set-of-Mark datasets, extending the diversity and generality. By
training over different base LLMs including TinyLlama1.1B, InternLM2-7B,
LLaMA2-13B, and Mixtral8x7B, we obtain a spectrum of MLLMs that vary in
parameter size and multilingual capabilities. Comprehensive benchmarking
reveals a strong correlation between the multi-modal performance with the data
and parameter scales. Code and models are released at
https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory | [
-0.5387022495269775,
-0.36810585856437683,
0.23107314109802246,
0.0751739963889122,
-0.2472066730260849,
-0.2365351766347885,
-0.4931459128856659,
-0.5412800312042236,
0.25754299759864807,
0.5267969369888306,
-0.5757682919502258,
-0.34629398584365845,
-0.6428883671760559,
0.18590949475765228,
-0.5830650329589844,
1.0219767093658447,
0.0579751580953598,
0.3974533677101135,
0.17079997062683105,
-0.5387501120567322,
0.29820817708969116,
-0.524718701839447,
-0.495935320854187,
0.16857950389385223,
1.03762948513031,
0.337885320186615,
0.9385801553726196,
0.9131243824958801,
0.45826196670532227,
0.2803257703781128,
-0.007477139122784138,
0.1722046285867691,
-0.3061901926994324,
0.2542282044887543,
0.054841987788677216,
-0.3390995264053345,
-0.5360368490219116,
-0.1029553934931755,
1.0578488111495972,
0.7806950807571411,
-0.07548267394304276,
0.4076935648918152,
-0.1713164895772934,
0.3940899670124054,
-0.6381461024284363,
0.23248133063316345,
-0.514937162399292,
-0.17895004153251648,
-0.3601961135864258,
0.11771559715270996,
-0.3725442886352539,
0.04102399945259094,
0.1649285852909088,
-0.7676042914390564,
-0.1394324004650116,
0.2701243758201599,
0.48952457308769226,
0.22143784165382385,
-0.6321342587471008,
-0.34635528922080994,
-0.4470631778240204,
1.024759292602539,
-0.4921864867210388,
0.6811897158622742,
0.23927977681159973,
0.24880391359329224,
0.20450423657894135,
-1.0744798183441162,
-0.4555976688861847,
-0.5521821975708008,
0.010261575691401958,
-0.342955082654953,
-0.06677266210317612,
-0.10017426311969757,
0.37610119581222534,
0.4397757053375244,
-0.5848743915557861,
0.1170240268111229,
-0.2884554862976074,
-0.14742043614387512,
0.4414994716644287,
0.44016915559768677,
0.30829328298568726,
-0.02864588238298893,
-0.3005674481391907,
-0.2873365581035614,
-0.695612370967865,
-0.05649949237704277,
0.2601092755794525,
0.3604469299316406,
-0.19357211887836456,
0.7019964456558228,
-0.13471698760986328,
0.79609614610672,
-0.06977831572294235,
-0.3283850848674774,
0.2501600384712219,
-0.5755054354667664,
-0.0633825734257698,
-0.07524625211954117,
0.7523209452629089,
0.24284128844738007,
0.042930178344249725,
-0.085854172706604,
-0.31700655817985535,
-0.3112526834011078,
0.17599785327911377,
-1.0206791162490845,
-0.14754682779312134,
0.04900272935628891,
-0.5914950966835022,
-0.14395253360271454,
-0.22382210195064545,
-0.6654785871505737,
-0.7144806981086731,
-0.5364223122596741,
0.6809101104736328,
-0.4214988648891449,
-0.3768589496612549,
0.2596004903316498,
-0.14538002014160156,
0.17757399380207062,
0.609524667263031,
-1.0665574073791504,
0.27035900950431824,
0.35477396845817566,
0.7483308911323547,
-0.10469941794872284,
-0.5840054750442505,
-0.6646713018417358,
0.11165960878133774,
-0.1740504652261734,
0.37063148617744446,
-0.7664089202880859,
-0.21935631334781647,
0.11114492267370224,
0.02351575717329979,
0.05598966032266617,
-0.33114004135131836,
0.6226905584335327,
-0.5069846510887146,
0.13234926760196686,
-0.184661403298378,
-0.2074216902256012,
-0.16654597222805023,
0.3736807703971863,
-1.135629415512085,
0.9786797761917114,
0.2817859351634979,
-0.7577734589576721,
0.4719698131084442,
-0.600756049156189,
-0.38679659366607666,
-0.14384044706821442,
-0.13536183536052704,
-0.30740320682525635,
0.2191421091556549,
0.229728102684021,
0.3975065052509308,
-0.6014977693557739,
-0.2461886703968048,
-0.5308871269226074,
-0.1183781623840332,
0.38374707102775574,
-0.5059338212013245,
0.7336140275001526,
0.01852080225944519,
-0.320922315120697,
0.47718092799186707,
-1.1165887117385864,
0.14147143065929413,
-0.059969548135995865,
-0.503248393535614,
-0.3514072597026825,
-0.01121664047241211,
0.6865712404251099,
0.4424600899219513,
0.477649062871933,
-0.5061586499214172,
0.33242267370224,
-0.1380843222141266,
0.5708808898925781,
0.5372095704078674,
-0.6193866729736328,
0.5260125398635864,
-0.17043177783489227,
0.34609952569007874,
-0.0662466362118721,
0.5210978984832764,
-0.45128631591796875,
-0.36813685297966003,
-0.9813596606254578,
-0.7276062965393066,
0.29548323154449463,
0.12638966739177704,
-0.7840689420700073,
0.20592549443244934,
-0.5595503449440002,
-0.6611781120300293,
-0.3942597806453705,
0.15456020832061768,
0.1926400512456894,
0.12441721558570862,
0.31631311774253845,
-0.25725057721138,
-0.45904192328453064,
-0.9550658464431763,
0.05840186029672623,
-0.05304946005344391,
-0.18122078478336334,
0.18450644612312317,
0.6023985743522644,
-0.1928897500038147,
0.6130686402320862,
-0.21742558479309082,
-0.39154890179634094,
-0.23364652693271637,
0.0367862842977047,
-0.03417336568236351,
0.2556638717651367,
0.665024995803833,
-0.8938332200050354,
-0.49109047651290894,
0.12672346830368042,
-0.44689539074897766,
0.263886034488678,
0.04966283217072487,
0.25925302505493164,
0.4189673662185669,
0.268791526556015,
-0.6460381150245667,
0.051437363028526306,
0.8384494185447693,
-0.2845965623855591,
0.6518742442131042,
-0.4169299304485321,
0.20043395459651947,
-1.0346877574920654,
0.14283078908920288,
0.19320043921470642,
-0.08133787661790848,
-0.8045170307159424,
0.39378753304481506,
0.5099571943283081,
0.09817668050527573,
-0.5031996965408325,
0.6056579947471619,
-0.584560751914978,
-0.1470523178577423,
-0.014755912125110626,
0.03509914129972458,
-0.0749804675579071,
0.5145063996315002,
0.16270211338996887,
0.8152725696563721,
0.8623538017272949,
-0.29525619745254517,
0.43281060457229614,
-0.012491594068706036,
-0.564789354801178,
0.48286572098731995,
-0.5799728035926819,
-0.1908024549484253,
0.09405616670846939,
0.2773318290710449,
-0.9469976425170898,
-0.24995839595794678,
0.13937872648239136,
-0.18051405251026154,
0.4241018295288086,
-0.07665650546550751,
-0.9378490447998047,
0.016589591279625893,
-0.674271285533905,
0.5596005916595459,
0.30865636467933655,
-0.6378306150436401,
0.9586745500564575,
0.30715230107307434,
-0.1988389790058136,
-0.4346930682659149,
-0.35702773928642273,
0.39704716205596924,
-0.2655692994594574,
-0.7481154203414917,
0.18518389761447906,
-0.1650867462158203,
-0.3297879993915558,
-0.23546689748764038,
0.11457749456167221,
-0.24898019433021545,
-0.06809107959270477,
0.27634546160697937,
0.3016155958175659,
-0.4239938259124756,
0.1413619965314865,
-0.1170395091176033,
-0.04766663908958435,
0.04091746732592583,
-0.42871659994125366,
0.634151816368103,
-0.042928244918584824,
-0.28909429907798767,
-0.2620612680912018,
0.38356778025627136,
1.0539989471435547,
-0.5526601672172546,
0.7009067535400391,
0.886415421962738,
-0.2577926218509674,
0.06032320857048035,
-0.3593800365924835,
-0.04520491883158684,
-0.4467097520828247,
0.5682693719863892,
-0.4428713917732239,
-0.8744523525238037,
0.4202152192592621,
0.1135939359664917,
0.2757420539855957,
0.43609851598739624,
0.8975422382354736,
0.19122324883937836,
1.2973607778549194,
0.6378354430198669,
-0.29186421632766724,
0.612036943435669,
-0.2369629293680191,
-0.2314416766166687,
-0.903340220451355,
-0.1555248647928238,
-0.6230140328407288,
-0.26621460914611816,
-0.48371565341949463,
-0.617009699344635,
0.4698350429534912,
-0.1692885309457779,
-0.30096226930618286,
0.2427031546831131,
-0.16074278950691223,
0.13891726732254028,
0.6485542058944702,
0.005310876294970512,
0.4407026171684265,
0.2455960363149643,
0.10643509030342102,
-0.11190814524888992,
-0.4943609833717346,
-0.36087268590927124,
1.5471440553665161,
0.15679208934307098,
1.2266935110092163,
0.3266468346118927,
0.26336362957954407,
0.16894753277301788,
0.23362328112125397,
-0.8697941303253174,
0.3758116364479065,
-0.19168265163898468,
-0.7053005695343018,
-0.6368061900138855,
-0.25911450386047363,
-0.856652021408081,
0.5571607947349548,
-0.21544930338859558,
-0.5773596167564392,
0.06526613235473633,
-0.15700331330299377,
-0.18060655891895294,
0.40015628933906555,
-0.38827085494995117,
0.6608180403709412,
-0.26720452308654785,
-0.2501542568206787,
-0.525734543800354,
-0.8192397952079773,
0.3710359036922455,
-0.4095573425292969,
0.11969761550426483,
0.13641634583473206,
-0.7183258533477783,
0.49629274010658264,
-0.37648895382881165,
0.9162236452102661,
0.10548626631498337,
-0.5111706852912903,
-0.1527276635169983,
-0.029340948909521103,
0.46465522050857544,
0.11720779538154602,
-0.21669070422649384,
0.31037941575050354,
0.1390220671892166,
-0.29075780510902405,
-0.6318002939224243,
0.8067956566810608,
-0.9462577700614929,
-0.3860526978969574,
-0.27448463439941406,
-0.7305254936218262,
-0.07000444084405899,
0.14199042320251465,
0.015470064245164394,
0.9965462684631348,
-0.02102857455611229,
0.44050055742263794,
0.7006577253341675,
0.07746940106153488,
0.42402952909469604,
0.6525323987007141,
-0.3207884430885315,
-0.7197373509407043,
0.9826202392578125,
0.28947553038597107,
0.43199825286865234,
0.5238407850265503,
-0.14707666635513306,
-0.4686608910560608,
-0.6107726693153381,
-1.0561550855636597,
0.15611161291599274,
-0.7335000038146973,
0.12622159719467163,
-0.57961505651474,
0.03051483817398548,
-0.30543577671051025,
0.12405030429363251,
-0.2239682823419571,
-0.7178871631622314,
-0.4373622536659241,
0.5111203193664551,
0.3025457561016083,
0.7202984690666199,
0.0658884197473526,
0.22051739692687988,
-0.8593079447746277,
0.331763356924057,
0.20342421531677246,
0.30586349964141846,
0.01745767518877983,
-0.7707873582839966,
-0.5184559226036072,
-0.0349615141749382,
-0.04425252974033356,
-0.3886331617832184,
0.2800552546977997,
0.3970462679862976,
0.5048747658729553,
0.4921582043170929,
-0.0024729131255298853,
0.4874959886074066,
-0.7009949088096619,
1.0001742839813232,
0.4353339970111847,
-0.8263341188430786,
0.13799265027046204,
-0.3432263135910034,
0.24748755991458893,
0.04829055070877075,
0.523221492767334,
-0.7347319722175598,
-0.31088772416114807,
-0.2581996023654938,
-0.5957925319671631,
0.8524219989776611,
0.08807455748319626,
0.21894656121730804,
0.2523912489414215,
0.23349212110042572,
0.3148747682571411,
0.06133889779448509,
-0.6330543160438538,
-0.48715198040008545,
-0.3454737365245819,
-0.30802562832832336,
-0.32829955220222473,
-0.3594394624233246,
-0.30108216404914856,
-0.32709938287734985,
0.43982088565826416,
-0.3757156729698181,
-0.21520163118839264,
-0.1189841777086258,
-0.5081512331962585,
0.03540338575839996,
0.17555515468120575,
1.0177186727523804,
0.7405605316162109,
0.06456415355205536,
0.15979036688804626,
0.1149529442191124,
-0.6570306420326233,
0.12009662389755249,
0.2752276659011841,
0.17207452654838562,
-0.06853818148374557,
0.45915687084198,
0.7596516013145447,
0.2766993045806885,
-0.9232707619667053,
0.4694564640522003,
-0.21037855744361877,
-0.20870345830917358,
-0.27833229303359985,
0.0555521622300148,
-0.08570258319377899,
0.4145628809928894,
0.5032954216003418,
-0.08968979120254517,
0.23930682241916656,
-0.42557603120803833,
0.04152696207165718,
0.43083932995796204,
-0.378943532705307,
-0.5099807381629944,
0.5994235277175903,
0.14146047830581665,
0.010511325672268867,
0.4424455761909485,
0.235068216919899,
-0.15587082505226135,
0.3619680404663086,
0.3418440818786621,
0.5641396045684814,
-0.025514677166938782,
0.09376868605613708,
0.28994855284690857,
0.5175430178642273,
-0.0144563103094697,
0.1781052052974701,
-0.21386408805847168,
-0.4280168414115906,
-0.4069710969924927,
-0.6634219288825989,
-0.4899401068687439,
0.08846031129360199,
-0.7006043195724487,
0.36493000388145447,
-0.5408132076263428,
-0.10510793328285217,
0.11235751211643219,
0.14422476291656494,
-0.4111917316913605,
0.19795942306518555,
0.22528190910816193,
1.2056570053100586,
-0.3966922461986542,
1.233005166053772,
0.8014248609542847,
-0.6158303618431091,
-0.505859375,
-0.18635202944278717,
0.16722293198108673,
-0.8711954951286316,
0.925001323223114,
0.009926963597536087,
-0.20470309257507324,
0.057200364768505096,
-0.34754422307014465,
-1.2513706684112549,
1.091199278831482,
0.3406998813152313,
-0.49125349521636963,
-0.11751455068588257,
0.27261707186698914,
0.435025155544281,
-0.38942772150039673,
0.2886756658554077,
0.45909616351127625,
0.5967943668365479,
-0.06708797812461853,
-1.1229907274246216,
0.02336104027926922,
-0.12506569921970367,
0.10962865501642227,
0.4241006076335907,
-0.5246828198432922,
1.1640349626541138,
-0.2111029177904129,
0.00669500045478344,
0.7233695387840271,
0.513645589351654,
-0.06701049953699112,
-0.2823288142681122,
0.6076002717018127,
0.49102064967155457,
0.49617281556129456,
0.029437445104122162,
0.9874083995819092,
-0.566366970539093,
0.256746768951416,
1.0032010078430176,
-0.3069114685058594,
0.97394198179245,
0.5555286407470703,
-0.03577600419521332,
0.31787142157554626,
0.621276319026947,
0.01515287160873413,
0.36840084195137024,
0.082926906645298,
-0.4591667950153351,
-0.39509260654449463,
-0.11533959209918976,
-0.45583000779151917,
0.3978883922100067,
0.5616661906242371,
-0.5785190463066101,
-0.41349178552627563,
0.25087684392929077,
-0.2061011642217636,
-0.44752687215805054,
-0.472971111536026,
0.5691245198249817,
-0.20326118171215057,
-0.1748710721731186,
0.7714022397994995,
0.09024105966091156,
0.7695127129554749,
-0.94764643907547,
0.14252686500549316,
-0.11848676949739456,
0.1486198902130127,
-0.07785653322935104,
-0.8786861896514893,
-0.1817319244146347,
-0.22022280097007751,
-0.3560376465320587,
-0.10301992297172546,
0.4881640672683716,
-0.5756849050521851,
-0.5252630710601807,
0.21501615643501282,
0.3825991749763489,
0.12497910112142563,
-0.2429429441690445,
-0.5816237926483154,
0.40978896617889404,
-0.14331459999084473,
-0.333243191242218,
0.6256694197654724,
0.5369879603385925,
-0.2215125858783722,
0.7760760188102722,
0.5907045006752014,
0.02610253542661667,
0.35034918785095215,
0.30535247921943665,
1.108601450920105,
-0.6343411207199097,
0.006336977705359459,
-0.7068904042243958,
0.5450179576873779,
-0.12116077542304993,
-0.5290979146957397,
0.8378055095672607,
0.690301775932312,
0.7672582268714905,
-0.18206191062927246,
0.5675904750823975,
0.028122682124376297,
0.1082463264465332,
-0.4714624881744385,
0.7257830500602722,
-0.9929115772247314,
-0.0926850438117981,
0.034387070685625076,
-0.7538628578186035,
-0.5920134782791138,
0.23263759911060333,
0.06365669518709183,
-0.008016878738999367,
0.5731121897697449,
0.990268349647522,
0.002387787215411663,
-0.0736527070403099,
0.6138497591018677,
0.04043801873922348,
0.2811136245727539,
0.2917880415916443,
0.9774818420410156,
-0.3042827844619751,
0.9167566895484924,
-0.028586097061634064,
-0.30427223443984985,
-0.450620174407959,
-0.40926578640937805,
-0.9653986096382141,
-0.8943464756011963,
-0.13424676656723022,
-0.09050992131233215,
-0.34587934613227844,
0.9559007883071899,
0.7940521836280823,
-0.4293762445449829,
-0.3445681631565094,
0.5330103039741516,
-0.18634968996047974,
-0.15908293426036835,
-0.09160204976797104,
0.2511305809020996,
-0.5034074187278748,
-0.8967952132225037,
0.19211988151073456,
0.6011786460876465,
-0.03307337686419487,
-0.9925135970115662,
-0.2574518620967865,
0.1381796896457672,
0.029452072456479073,
1.025164246559143,
0.04958244040608406,
-1.0787521600723267,
-0.2787433862686157,
0.0870702713727951,
-0.4328145682811737,
0.12437582015991211,
0.9456471800804138,
-0.5680148005485535,
0.23347583413124084,
0.295863538980484,
0.428411066532135,
0.3576178550720215,
-0.7265827059745789,
0.3579205274581909,
-0.4292891323566437,
0.13957524299621582,
-0.1427881419658661,
0.6369985342025757,
0.17520876228809357,
0.12403739988803864,
0.3026328682899475,
-0.0757175087928772,
-0.2947574555873871,
-0.7304584383964539,
0.26853305101394653,
-1.1783356666564941,
-0.2818182706832886,
1.204093098640442,
-0.09369577467441559,
-0.1764991134405136,
-0.08771877735853195,
-0.5611335635185242,
-0.22524146735668182,
-0.3299882113933563,
0.6263620257377625,
0.655169665813446,
0.08917848020792007,
-0.4162042737007141,
-0.286222904920578,
0.33723363280296326,
0.13536927103996277,
-0.7777888178825378,
0.22591474652290344,
0.7862840890884399,
0.36860719323158264,
0.38900238275527954,
0.33601051568984985,
-0.16068238019943237,
0.40644118189811707,
0.1793777495622635,
0.11398320645093918,
0.052984196692705154,
-0.4407213032245636,
-0.5149828791618347,
0.43914860486984253,
0.2953330874443054,
-0.007397898938506842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05932v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05932v2 | Driving Everywhere with Large Language Model Policy Adaptation | 2024-02-08T18:59:03 | 2024-04-10T23:29:18 | Boyi Li, Yue Wang, Jiageng Mao, Boris Ivanovic, Sushant Veer, Karen Leung, Marco Pavone | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Adapting driving behavior to new environments, customs, and laws is a
long-standing problem in autonomous driving, precluding the widespread
deployment of autonomous vehicles (AVs). In this paper, we present LLaDA, a
simple yet powerful tool that enables human drivers and autonomous vehicles
alike to drive everywhere by adapting their tasks and motion plans to traffic
rules in new locations. LLaDA achieves this by leveraging the impressive
zero-shot generalizability of large language models (LLMs) in interpreting the
traffic rules in the local driver handbook. Through an extensive user study, we
show that LLaDA's instructions are useful in disambiguating in-the-wild
unexpected situations. We also demonstrate LLaDA's ability to adapt AV motion
planning policies in real-world datasets; LLaDA outperforms baseline planning
approaches on all our metrics. Please check our website for more details:
https://boyiliee.github.io/llada. | [
-0.294124960899353,
-0.8125942349433899,
1.099045991897583,
0.3542312681674957,
-0.2811247706413269,
-0.23362798988819122,
-0.16458114981651306,
-0.5302811861038208,
0.23174948990345,
0.46258363127708435,
-0.5997985005378723,
-0.4090965688228607,
-0.12369678914546967,
-0.17538927495479584,
-0.5298371315002441,
0.7294397354125977,
-0.27024534344673157,
-0.1916724443435669,
-0.05430622026324272,
-0.24188628792762756,
-0.48537662625312805,
-0.05814439430832863,
-0.3147624135017395,
0.024240175262093544,
0.6673142910003662,
0.5424983501434326,
0.7705696225166321,
0.5818184614181519,
0.4430214464664459,
0.28271573781967163,
0.14556308090686798,
0.21564248204231262,
-0.27055007219314575,
0.2797428369522095,
-0.5819892287254333,
-0.07511773705482483,
-0.48334091901779175,
-0.6371819972991943,
0.8573743104934692,
0.508686363697052,
-0.42064157128334045,
-0.3302195370197296,
-0.3801044225692749,
0.3100379705429077,
-0.6412256360054016,
-0.03741411864757538,
-0.6715681552886963,
-0.17236894369125366,
-0.15199485421180725,
-0.2173662632703781,
0.26186835765838623,
-0.5283382534980774,
0.01761009730398655,
-0.9069789052009583,
-0.247471421957016,
0.06679573655128479,
0.6024495959281921,
0.4818279445171356,
-0.8110448718070984,
-0.31227755546569824,
-1.259680151939392,
0.5691990852355957,
-0.34476062655448914,
0.38493892550468445,
-0.17220155894756317,
0.6962053179740906,
-0.49651381373405457,
-0.23150798678398132,
-0.9763062596321106,
-0.010697640478610992,
0.4346727728843689,
0.10364729166030884,
-0.3260718882083893,
0.19242018461227417,
-0.10894670337438583,
0.04500662907958031,
-0.32375454902648926,
0.46513423323631287,
-0.31521570682525635,
-0.011489279568195343,
0.8934211134910583,
0.39565324783325195,
0.14316675066947937,
0.4041499197483063,
-0.11970573663711548,
-0.2516820728778839,
-0.8518865704536438,
-0.01387820579111576,
0.1508152335882187,
0.25776585936546326,
-0.21678993105888367,
0.30424222350120544,
-0.48346805572509766,
0.7576939463615417,
-0.39954161643981934,
-0.1743076592683792,
0.370595782995224,
-0.16298706829547882,
-0.5460476279258728,
-0.1093883365392685,
0.6872256398200989,
0.5511147379875183,
0.3378126323223114,
-0.18208089470863342,
-0.2038075476884842,
-0.2809123396873474,
0.16160330176353455,
-0.44597986340522766,
0.10925664752721786,
0.23564167320728302,
0.08385684341192245,
-0.07083279639482498,
-0.0677734911441803,
-0.6889634728431702,
-0.608316957950592,
-0.4556044936180115,
0.361528217792511,
0.037533823400735855,
-0.3440053462982178,
0.32128849625587463,
0.3192805051803589,
0.8316898941993713,
0.7534499764442444,
-0.9050763845443726,
0.262167751789093,
0.6613802313804626,
0.890550971031189,
-0.16954271495342255,
-0.637609601020813,
-0.5771769285202026,
0.3390022814273834,
-0.570254921913147,
1.1227171421051025,
-0.195693701505661,
-0.491396963596344,
0.1654186099767685,
0.34791243076324463,
0.08056200295686722,
-0.35295626521110535,
0.3733077645301819,
-0.20984873175621033,
-0.32128071784973145,
-0.11397949606180191,
-0.10488186776638031,
-0.45469358563423157,
0.14313335716724396,
-0.5581684708595276,
0.5890390872955322,
0.05751660466194153,
0.31922730803489685,
0.38526973128318787,
-1.1267070770263672,
-1.0141499042510986,
-0.03790073096752167,
-0.04630725085735321,
-0.3324938118457794,
0.33631715178489685,
0.1378868967294693,
0.48826852440834045,
-0.25802773237228394,
0.4033946990966797,
-0.158338263630867,
-0.22585295140743256,
-0.026075536385178566,
-0.46449556946754456,
0.7484477162361145,
0.07296793162822723,
0.01265497412532568,
0.6598318219184875,
-0.5526975393295288,
-0.38111650943756104,
0.17700503766536713,
-0.3468257784843445,
-0.028416434302926064,
0.10272505134344101,
0.237323597073555,
0.06965626031160355,
0.05274687334895134,
-0.4601269066333771,
0.5077611804008484,
-0.39779341220855713,
0.3048148453235626,
1.0107041597366333,
0.20165817439556122,
0.6357781291007996,
-0.4046644866466522,
0.6700520515441895,
-0.01838967204093933,
0.2232910394668579,
-0.11444805562496185,
-0.5837475657463074,
-0.6676501035690308,
0.1359727531671524,
-0.1434340626001358,
0.6960899829864502,
-0.5596129894256592,
0.15607281029224396,
-0.4427068531513214,
-0.5875476598739624,
-0.584219217300415,
0.15705381333827972,
-0.033198561519384384,
0.10680430382490158,
0.11909233778715134,
-0.2202325314283371,
-0.510291576385498,
-0.48534220457077026,
0.008114969357848167,
-0.02661934122443199,
-0.08468881249427795,
0.4224478304386139,
0.6547567248344421,
-0.5131547451019287,
0.8884806036949158,
-0.34390363097190857,
-0.4328973889350891,
-0.28848573565483093,
-0.2060684859752655,
-0.06864302605390549,
0.2852315306663513,
0.6885403990745544,
-0.5370318293571472,
-0.46524155139923096,
0.3634020984172821,
-0.5698217153549194,
0.0034826446790248156,
-0.7096956968307495,
-0.27286913990974426,
0.049629442393779755,
0.582269012928009,
-0.28003883361816406,
0.35523390769958496,
0.5492739081382751,
-0.3595665395259857,
0.4456460177898407,
-0.6045750379562378,
-0.28594985604286194,
-0.8141007423400879,
-0.21758152544498444,
0.05405851826071739,
-0.8086032867431641,
-0.5525235533714294,
0.32310688495635986,
-0.19816355407238007,
0.1706138700246811,
-0.8537542819976807,
0.5916911363601685,
-0.16883856058120728,
-0.4993405342102051,
-0.3283284306526184,
0.09252867847681046,
-0.25330832600593567,
0.17879104614257812,
-0.009383048862218857,
0.9703403115272522,
0.9776374101638794,
-0.942895770072937,
0.5678249001502991,
0.3029942512512207,
-0.690636932849884,
0.6272514462471008,
-0.5095300674438477,
-0.16185344755649567,
-0.4192509651184082,
0.3661102056503296,
-0.6439061164855957,
-0.6665546894073486,
0.1444254219532013,
0.1545039564371109,
-0.16655541956424713,
-0.03253896161913872,
-0.40227794647216797,
0.26878783106803894,
0.07228688895702362,
0.13273712992668152,
0.5632568001747131,
-0.5623940229415894,
0.8563474416732788,
0.8458821177482605,
0.0732097253203392,
0.0530022531747818,
-0.5096108317375183,
0.3887091279029846,
-0.3176123797893524,
-0.23211471736431122,
0.40465936064720154,
-0.300010621547699,
-0.6572138071060181,
-0.2877943515777588,
0.12973280251026154,
-0.1760774403810501,
0.5177208185195923,
0.4866819381713867,
0.09178175777196884,
-0.12149105966091156,
-0.001308675855398178,
0.01413316372781992,
0.03134945407509804,
0.02492818981409073,
-0.060874320566654205,
0.4646679759025574,
-0.09405966848134995,
-0.1185852512717247,
-0.5895598530769348,
0.1928911954164505,
0.7950575947761536,
0.08190598338842392,
0.4222312569618225,
0.13446669280529022,
0.023040136322379112,
-0.13825729489326477,
0.07466193288564682,
0.2811351716518402,
-0.542883038520813,
0.6137789487838745,
-0.4187175929546356,
-0.39011701941490173,
0.2127152532339096,
-0.4713187515735626,
0.39335891604423523,
0.25479137897491455,
0.7484161257743835,
-0.5209423303604126,
0.731546938419342,
0.9632928967475891,
-0.061152052134275436,
0.6654812097549438,
0.10975535959005356,
0.03222459927201271,
-0.6003750562667847,
-0.3179575204849243,
-0.08662790805101395,
-0.2876954972743988,
-0.7967898845672607,
-0.44899603724479675,
0.45850518345832825,
-0.4857129156589508,
-0.40609100461006165,
0.12377656996250153,
-0.14444608986377716,
0.9602897763252258,
0.4826897084712982,
0.0028278229292482138,
0.28650590777397156,
-0.18940818309783936,
0.3935377597808838,
0.33486586809158325,
-0.4625435173511505,
-0.09562800824642181,
1.0596938133239746,
0.16556085646152496,
0.6070077419281006,
0.35223835706710815,
0.5240626335144043,
0.3120136857032776,
0.2367568463087082,
-1.0079931020736694,
0.6519001722335815,
0.09274892508983612,
-0.4366875886917114,
-0.40804600715637207,
-0.42226171493530273,
-1.10091233253479,
0.2443118691444397,
-0.29746735095977783,
-0.5482416152954102,
0.24334044754505157,
-0.06719779223203659,
-0.6331021785736084,
0.40664589405059814,
-0.24870193004608154,
0.730605959892273,
-0.6831154227256775,
-0.11116981506347656,
-0.10567236691713333,
-0.41627928614616394,
0.14400508999824524,
-0.22575853765010834,
0.6084266304969788,
-0.5336856842041016,
-0.08868861943483353,
0.451448917388916,
-0.09541917592287064,
0.7773703336715698,
-0.3335115313529968,
-0.5028519034385681,
0.09673221409320831,
0.3762257993221283,
0.5001216530799866,
-0.30386483669281006,
0.10899706184864044,
0.2644062340259552,
-0.27200716733932495,
-0.25299662351608276,
-0.4814358651638031,
0.8369565010070801,
-0.6970849633216858,
-0.4735998213291168,
-0.5551542043685913,
-0.9560645222663879,
-0.012124787084758282,
0.1962064951658249,
-0.2501387894153595,
0.039420634508132935,
-0.4054785966873169,
-0.10279364138841629,
0.5067088603973389,
-0.339273065328598,
0.5947312116622925,
0.6898254752159119,
-0.5946812033653259,
0.06875048577785492,
1.1526317596435547,
0.02212858386337757,
0.3307119309902191,
0.2751612067222595,
0.1171114519238472,
-0.3651188910007477,
-0.658219039440155,
-0.5725719928741455,
-0.0021151225082576275,
-0.9164344668388367,
0.0640435591340065,
-0.1533302515745163,
0.07526375353336334,
-0.2912367284297943,
-0.5797654390335083,
-0.39390820264816284,
-0.6355788111686707,
-0.09878730773925781,
-0.14752115309238434,
0.4617944657802582,
0.9786779284477234,
-0.38898026943206787,
0.8015144467353821,
-0.052529606968164444,
0.2918643355369568,
0.5244444608688354,
0.12277606874704361,
-0.24691618978977203,
-0.49673545360565186,
0.05035463348031044,
-0.16247491538524628,
-0.3142378032207489,
-0.5559390187263489,
0.5190022587776184,
0.37411588430404663,
0.3708203434944153,
0.2709219455718994,
0.020626546815037727,
0.8925410509109497,
-0.6082301139831543,
0.44423946738243103,
0.03336872160434723,
-0.6941080689430237,
0.4154411852359772,
-0.3583948314189911,
0.472445011138916,
0.5858949422836304,
0.07209188491106033,
-0.5859235525131226,
-0.12825098633766174,
0.009412730112671852,
-1.0725297927856445,
0.13962411880493164,
-0.0037161626387387514,
0.41093671321868896,
0.32557785511016846,
0.26290106773376465,
-0.0034975982271134853,
0.02292024716734886,
-0.7780038118362427,
-0.0161724966019392,
-0.028996363282203674,
-0.19548992812633514,
-0.11298917233943939,
0.12327779829502106,
-0.1327514797449112,
-0.43577536940574646,
0.6129213571548462,
-0.17660698294639587,
0.13913565874099731,
0.047086019068956375,
-0.21386407315731049,
-0.0083699906244874,
0.28974825143814087,
0.8972935676574707,
0.705349862575531,
-0.09655611962080002,
-0.14260219037532806,
0.35882943868637085,
-0.32556650042533875,
0.3103012144565582,
-0.25917547941207886,
-0.41702207922935486,
-0.15341681241989136,
-0.03040027618408203,
0.6941710114479065,
0.3211926221847534,
-0.9365071058273315,
0.3629535734653473,
-0.012537655420601368,
-0.3047473430633545,
-0.651522159576416,
0.4978477656841278,
-0.346131831407547,
0.21713808178901672,
0.1542205512523651,
0.21209965646266937,
-0.09334173798561096,
-0.8556710481643677,
-0.0636298730969429,
0.17769019305706024,
-0.5284451842308044,
-0.28362926840782166,
0.9610288143157959,
0.390285849571228,
-0.34655365347862244,
0.324911892414093,
-0.3749108612537384,
-0.2659393548965454,
0.5689123868942261,
0.5054149031639099,
0.8768191337585449,
-0.13211436569690704,
0.14802470803260803,
0.10461485385894775,
0.25568822026252747,
-0.16582508385181427,
0.46076399087905884,
-0.025353852659463882,
-0.7603020071983337,
-0.7064432501792908,
-0.39647188782691956,
-0.703707754611969,
-0.29631367325782776,
-0.3967910408973694,
0.03161618486046791,
-0.7474677562713623,
0.44838014245033264,
0.007485734764486551,
-0.41065457463264465,
-0.728039562702179,
0.14047031104564667,
0.09850990772247314,
0.8642723560333252,
-0.860632061958313,
1.041825532913208,
0.7922054529190063,
-0.21207010746002197,
-0.1676533967256546,
0.24072898924350739,
0.3084801733493805,
-1.1148605346679688,
0.1615251898765564,
0.011874031275510788,
-0.22435034811496735,
0.02000238001346588,
-0.673899233341217,
-0.8902971148490906,
1.2074470520019531,
0.3263934850692749,
-0.9746510982513428,
0.014819239266216755,
0.2782766819000244,
0.19976498186588287,
-0.35090047121047974,
-0.12474995851516724,
1.0120407342910767,
0.5186525583267212,
0.24930329620838165,
-1.0125222206115723,
-0.011977930553257465,
0.36478525400161743,
-0.1493280827999115,
0.09925219416618347,
-0.4539569318294525,
0.45550215244293213,
-0.3704536259174347,
0.027389612048864365,
0.1379828304052353,
0.5349815487861633,
0.20933213829994202,
0.1818259060382843,
0.6322434544563293,
0.36639028787612915,
0.9653034806251526,
-0.09021028876304626,
1.3211299180984497,
0.011859115213155746,
-0.023963168263435364,
1.2169333696365356,
-0.6961345672607422,
0.7250552773475647,
0.37897786498069763,
-0.0329584926366806,
0.6913185119628906,
0.3144729733467102,
0.022971244528889656,
0.9584919810295105,
-0.0954439640045166,
-0.3856964707374573,
-0.4379274547100067,
-0.3224634826183319,
0.07494257390499115,
0.7688215970993042,
0.2737150192260742,
0.2186683565378189,
-0.337848424911499,
0.3087802231311798,
0.07289819419384003,
-0.06984005123376846,
-0.7192695140838623,
0.9327166080474854,
-0.22210073471069336,
-0.43400150537490845,
0.26613494753837585,
0.1067890077829361,
0.4504379630088806,
-0.4682323634624481,
-0.042692139744758606,
-0.22378437221050262,
0.25496527552604675,
-0.08026590198278427,
-1.0145031213760376,
0.4774625301361084,
-0.07583445310592651,
0.05832541361451149,
-0.2557407319545746,
0.19127245247364044,
-0.061121128499507904,
-0.5641705989837646,
0.04190964624285698,
0.25160011649131775,
0.43345436453819275,
-0.06142190471291542,
-0.41006994247436523,
0.2612283229827881,
0.22146061062812805,
0.13478602468967438,
0.36233165860176086,
0.3832838535308838,
-0.1950986087322235,
0.9388633966445923,
0.7176131010055542,
0.2614597678184509,
-0.04887102171778679,
-0.15447160601615906,
0.8146227598190308,
-0.9777595400810242,
-0.6320569515228271,
-0.8255102634429932,
0.5672379732131958,
0.1709868609905243,
-0.5304654836654663,
0.7616381645202637,
0.34984758496284485,
0.6976929903030396,
0.37759581208229065,
1.001314401626587,
0.04384227097034454,
0.024868357926607132,
-0.5590898990631104,
0.29241183400154114,
-0.8040690422058105,
0.29057008028030396,
0.04821903631091118,
-0.8762736320495605,
-0.5829380750656128,
1.051338791847229,
-0.43149325251579285,
-0.44321200251579285,
-0.023397717624902725,
0.7099214792251587,
-0.3511268198490143,
-0.36132290959358215,
0.5315673351287842,
0.47862789034843445,
0.6282422542572021,
0.565185010433197,
0.6034039855003357,
-0.34860917925834656,
0.5587758421897888,
-0.04129541665315628,
-0.03084498457610607,
-0.28000736236572266,
-1.0087918043136597,
-0.36545971035957336,
-0.35415416955947876,
-0.28373995423316956,
-0.05515922233462334,
0.1706455498933792,
0.9144971370697021,
0.8764379620552063,
-0.7366864085197449,
-0.310534805059433,
-0.45139437913894653,
0.34342432022094727,
-0.14492279291152954,
-0.11874683201313019,
-0.028410274535417557,
0.08483652770519257,
-0.7583766579627991,
1.0810593366622925,
0.26850324869155884,
0.4686400294303894,
-0.38069260120391846,
-0.4484744071960449,
0.08867762237787247,
0.14038300514221191,
0.42900198698043823,
0.6321584582328796,
-0.46968066692352295,
-0.12302983552217484,
-0.443695068359375,
0.28128790855407715,
0.1844145804643631,
0.6471251845359802,
-0.680414080619812,
0.5357831716537476,
0.06605309247970581,
0.24562276899814606,
0.40308788418769836,
-0.13352659344673157,
0.8876563906669617,
-0.564570963382721,
0.5331701040267944,
0.08877528458833694,
0.46771591901779175,
0.2327035814523697,
-0.05534343793988228,
0.4788474440574646,
-0.23545438051223755,
-0.8609120845794678,
-0.7528042793273926,
0.4937340319156647,
-0.9263027906417847,
-0.4461304843425751,
1.2735387086868286,
0.22541876137256622,
-0.5215661525726318,
-0.4040526747703552,
-0.2595747411251068,
-0.2565123736858368,
-0.49125635623931885,
0.8194758892059326,
-0.031652286648750305,
0.12314067780971527,
-0.22535602748394012,
-1.0303982496261597,
0.25268086791038513,
-0.01853177137672901,
-1.0439777374267578,
0.16281622648239136,
0.5997296571731567,
0.3088788092136383,
-0.2574728727340698,
0.5525985360145569,
0.4021086096763611,
0.4325541853904724,
-0.23781944811344147,
0.05079898610711098,
0.04080543667078018,
-0.5407028198242188,
-0.669929027557373,
-0.2709296941757202,
0.003174453042447567,
-0.14484012126922607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05930v1 | WebLINX: Real-World Website Navigation with Multi-Turn Dialogue | 2024-02-08T18:58:02 | 2024-02-08T18:58:02 | Xing Han Lù, Zdeněk Kasner, Siva Reddy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose the problem of conversational web navigation, where a digital
agent controls a web browser and follows user instructions to solve real-world
tasks in a multi-turn dialogue fashion. To support this problem, we introduce
WEBLINX - a large-scale benchmark of 100K interactions across 2300 expert
demonstrations of conversational web navigation. Our benchmark covers a broad
range of patterns on over 150 real-world websites and can be used to train and
evaluate agents in diverse scenarios. Due to the magnitude of information
present, Large Language Models (LLMs) cannot process entire web pages in
real-time. To solve this bottleneck, we design a retrieval-inspired model that
efficiently prunes HTML pages by ranking relevant elements. We use the selected
elements, along with screenshots and action history, to assess a variety of
models for their ability to replicate human behavior when navigating the web.
Our experiments span from small text-only to proprietary multimodal LLMs. We
find that smaller finetuned decoders surpass the best zero-shot LLMs (including
GPT-4V), but also larger finetuned multimodal models which were explicitly
pretrained on screenshots. However, all finetuned models struggle to generalize
to unseen websites. Our findings highlight the need for large multimodal models
that can generalize to novel settings. Our code, data and models are available
for research: https://mcgill-nlp.github.io/weblinx | [
-0.514523446559906,
-0.7279606461524963,
0.6757484674453735,
0.09261023253202438,
-0.1237732321023941,
0.0769253522157669,
-0.2914300560951233,
-0.5490569472312927,
-0.043725743889808655,
0.17032499611377716,
-0.7439491748809814,
-0.4415833055973053,
-0.21268704533576965,
-0.03595030680298805,
-0.6423358917236328,
0.6107522249221802,
0.33929750323295593,
0.12714336812496185,
-0.2539019286632538,
0.06583478301763535,
0.1103183701634407,
-0.5161016583442688,
-0.7256138324737549,
-0.26458242535591125,
0.6858335733413696,
0.2744388282299042,
0.6989986300468445,
0.33781734108924866,
0.48927780985832214,
0.31353759765625,
0.04778412729501724,
0.2511466443538666,
-0.7009583711624146,
0.12152352929115295,
-0.20632991194725037,
-0.3929343819618225,
-0.43609780073165894,
0.029240567237138748,
0.43152400851249695,
0.6276292204856873,
-0.2841930687427521,
-0.03898902237415314,
-0.034396108239889145,
0.2763151526451111,
-0.6283941268920898,
-0.05417976528406143,
-0.3124934136867523,
-0.06722637265920639,
0.22999663650989532,
-0.11987251788377762,
-0.5831493139266968,
-0.43969953060150146,
0.3656754791736603,
-0.9217565059661865,
0.1809478998184204,
0.018999818712472916,
0.7498577237129211,
-0.015339917503297329,
-0.6311730742454529,
-0.037795305252075195,
-0.8074500560760498,
0.8541603684425354,
-0.748988687992096,
0.9050890207290649,
0.32277587056159973,
0.324598103761673,
-0.13332931697368622,
-0.909500002861023,
-0.7553709745407104,
-0.20794858038425446,
0.18441715836524963,
0.09646119177341461,
-0.38044974207878113,
0.10573989897966385,
0.2057395577430725,
-0.17686417698860168,
-0.8127038478851318,
0.06800780445337296,
-0.04947575554251671,
-0.3158254623413086,
0.39024442434310913,
0.1460466980934143,
0.31040307879447937,
0.1236797645688057,
-0.33382225036621094,
-0.5168969631195068,
-0.4467392563819885,
0.0909513309597969,
0.17322956025600433,
0.3658204674720764,
-0.034162238240242004,
0.1252981573343277,
-0.41990238428115845,
0.832444965839386,
-0.010644219815731049,
-0.2967948615550995,
0.11959031224250793,
-0.44986552000045776,
0.14138707518577576,
-0.3039018511772156,
0.5522032976150513,
0.9434382319450378,
0.433276891708374,
-0.20904402434825897,
-0.27468058466911316,
0.1645122766494751,
0.5682733058929443,
-0.7659660577774048,
-0.18647202849388123,
0.28756237030029297,
-0.44840914011001587,
0.0008995716343633831,
0.22669073939323425,
-0.8207639455795288,
-0.3497219979763031,
-0.34986013174057007,
0.3957606852054596,
-0.32692939043045044,
-0.37366610765457153,
0.1310497671365738,
-0.27706941962242126,
0.48972976207733154,
0.5724730491638184,
-0.5236158967018127,
0.39960429072380066,
0.7108383178710938,
0.647226870059967,
-0.29914388060569763,
-0.2731100916862488,
-0.747664213180542,
-0.05231134966015816,
-0.16189737617969513,
0.7430295348167419,
-0.772156298160553,
-0.28625306487083435,
0.3987416923046112,
-0.014750687405467033,
0.11996153742074966,
-0.37939175963401794,
0.34940847754478455,
-0.5497983694076538,
-0.09330141544342041,
0.04556068405508995,
-0.2593865394592285,
-0.3204326331615448,
0.6808068156242371,
-0.6511194109916687,
0.4019721448421478,
-0.40180015563964844,
-0.1841822862625122,
0.011265701614320278,
-0.42930537462234497,
-0.4333322048187256,
-0.07843484729528427,
0.14627724885940552,
-0.15587368607521057,
-0.038496073335409164,
0.0514117032289505,
0.3402949571609497,
-0.2053167074918747,
-0.06558073312044144,
-0.3211592435836792,
-0.264686644077301,
0.43914324045181274,
-0.5754311680793762,
0.17916154861450195,
0.2264484167098999,
-0.22946418821811676,
-0.067180335521698,
-0.7090813517570496,
0.304657906293869,
0.02951788157224655,
-0.5428626537322998,
-0.30551260709762573,
0.09015082567930222,
0.4007219076156616,
0.28816428780555725,
0.1963580995798111,
-0.5121549963951111,
0.40575236082077026,
0.03744981065392494,
0.38347122073173523,
0.5225715637207031,
-0.035803064703941345,
0.3913087546825409,
-0.377346932888031,
0.5576657056808472,
-0.10332568734884262,
0.4660276472568512,
-0.32828009128570557,
-0.47535109519958496,
-1.0584173202514648,
0.22055727243423462,
0.24043701589107513,
0.4357052743434906,
-0.7614061832427979,
-0.3102308213710785,
-0.5251020789146423,
-0.3879408538341522,
-0.1913629025220871,
-0.05719345062971115,
0.7068296074867249,
-0.0018607900710776448,
0.5596761107444763,
-0.299172967672348,
-0.1825469434261322,
-0.7772352695465088,
-0.23793865740299225,
-0.08011292666196823,
-0.16654080152511597,
0.3477792739868164,
0.20820894837379456,
-0.5576680302619934,
0.7297220230102539,
-0.5720128417015076,
-0.0576326809823513,
-0.19810615479946136,
0.501754879951477,
-0.23551496863365173,
0.3123132586479187,
0.00010620117245707661,
-1.0885554552078247,
-0.4983617663383484,
-0.007155087776482105,
-0.6308017373085022,
0.04281112551689148,
-0.3427998721599579,
0.06783672422170639,
0.0282934308052063,
0.47302448749542236,
-0.6299497485160828,
0.22421953082084656,
0.461972177028656,
-0.13619749248027802,
0.39729779958724976,
-0.04949948191642761,
0.2125261276960373,
-0.7322209477424622,
-0.03540750965476036,
0.5513374209403992,
-0.5741456151008606,
-0.8132131695747375,
0.5874856114387512,
0.2201196253299713,
-0.1901586502790451,
-0.5916826725006104,
0.5816252827644348,
-0.4602263569831848,
-0.1006719246506691,
-0.04829341545701027,
0.5140023231506348,
0.08845803141593933,
0.7664568424224854,
-0.044442277401685715,
0.7901466488838196,
0.044638946652412415,
-0.9121901988983154,
0.47113561630249023,
0.26516756415367126,
0.03366703540086746,
0.6272894740104675,
-0.281767874956131,
0.22848747670650482,
0.12564216554164886,
0.3849254846572876,
-0.8785924315452576,
-0.08430119603872299,
-0.24855175614356995,
-0.4184245765209198,
0.028365924954414368,
-0.21707002818584442,
-0.3311339318752289,
-0.2619059085845947,
-0.3731057643890381,
0.19436819851398468,
0.3579420745372772,
-0.4063647389411926,
0.6328610777854919,
0.2797711193561554,
-0.21598376333713531,
-0.2545757591724396,
-0.4174003303050995,
0.4305606782436371,
0.058572348207235336,
-0.5861195921897888,
0.4322841763496399,
-0.36055243015289307,
-0.5742177367210388,
-0.385591596364975,
-0.09845069795846939,
-0.2814171016216278,
-0.013225756585597992,
0.043237194418907166,
0.014465509913861752,
-0.0861813947558403,
0.09751821309328079,
-0.29913994669914246,
-0.09579005092382431,
-0.04833103343844414,
-0.47506168484687805,
0.6914663314819336,
-0.21439509093761444,
-0.5451714396476746,
-0.7687849402427673,
0.4515351355075836,
0.61604243516922,
-0.11905300617218018,
0.08178828656673431,
0.48678186535835266,
-0.22203265130519867,
0.033981628715991974,
-0.7836461663246155,
-0.48211392760276794,
-0.4899538457393646,
0.18242135643959045,
-0.3587956428527832,
-0.6124944686889648,
0.4313291907310486,
-0.43109336495399475,
0.20870929956436157,
0.06096480041742325,
0.17592640221118927,
-0.386942058801651,
1.224490761756897,
0.6331508159637451,
0.1569918692111969,
0.491972416639328,
-0.36712101101875305,
-0.016013819724321365,
-0.5063366889953613,
-0.18871796131134033,
-0.3558042645454407,
-0.4801376461982727,
-0.6409083008766174,
-0.3694727122783661,
0.4882587492465973,
-0.16391077637672424,
0.030662596225738525,
0.3285215497016907,
-0.17424827814102173,
0.30710363388061523,
0.8113515973091125,
0.26582223176956177,
0.5508063435554504,
-0.014518268406391144,
-0.4385150969028473,
0.1420377492904663,
-0.6356934905052185,
-0.4172651469707489,
1.028764009475708,
0.058913469314575195,
1.088096022605896,
0.5020340085029602,
0.47166964411735535,
0.5432754755020142,
-0.11469881236553192,
-0.7923439145088196,
0.8235331177711487,
-0.06121411919593811,
-0.4922303259372711,
-0.40331539511680603,
-0.2395125925540924,
-1.187491774559021,
0.27708670496940613,
-0.3190780282020569,
-0.5373107194900513,
0.06937766820192337,
0.236882284283638,
-0.5469825863838196,
0.1445091813802719,
-0.6954419612884521,
0.7717291116714478,
-0.26782453060150146,
-0.8501293659210205,
-0.7275471091270447,
-0.6186220645904541,
-0.06468793749809265,
0.30484244227409363,
0.33253058791160583,
0.23379629850387573,
0.115389883518219,
0.27323833107948303,
-0.19252388179302216,
0.9336315989494324,
-0.07580383867025375,
-0.07886134088039398,
0.10386631637811661,
0.3146900236606598,
0.6563763618469238,
-0.19062688946723938,
0.32046613097190857,
-0.010118232108652592,
-0.018995363265275955,
-0.2879675030708313,
-0.5726664662361145,
0.8465781807899475,
-0.732005774974823,
-0.5599697828292847,
-0.4579884707927704,
0.0035241171717643738,
-0.5058239102363586,
0.057699017226696014,
-0.0993252545595169,
0.993465006351471,
-0.3615632653236389,
0.27285274863243103,
0.7985672950744629,
-0.11422056704759598,
0.8284246325492859,
0.7434977889060974,
-0.3611276149749756,
-0.06107509136199951,
1.1775656938552856,
-0.13412539660930634,
0.36812230944633484,
0.6294258236885071,
-0.00829603523015976,
-0.40447548031806946,
-0.5013729333877563,
-0.5461761951446533,
0.09114543348550797,
-0.7403507232666016,
-0.1418437957763672,
-0.5148894786834717,
-0.16050972044467926,
-0.2277284413576126,
-0.05242801457643509,
-0.3431645631790161,
-0.5100838541984558,
-0.2866440415382385,
0.08072826266288757,
0.013078601099550724,
0.8313425779342651,
0.014184367842972279,
0.3550776541233063,
-0.9661754369735718,
0.3829084634780884,
0.8384456038475037,
0.3383675813674927,
0.21053647994995117,
-0.2668267786502838,
-0.2338486909866333,
0.18308863043785095,
-0.529999315738678,
-0.5982291102409363,
0.43228647112846375,
0.10009526461362839,
0.7570533156394958,
0.5737572908401489,
0.04654855653643608,
0.6929754018783569,
-0.4861033260822296,
0.734185516834259,
0.3301050662994385,
-0.6320606470108032,
0.2651525139808655,
-0.5877746343612671,
0.7219805121421814,
0.38855549693107605,
0.6542330384254456,
-0.8963577151298523,
-0.1222144365310669,
-0.3464948236942291,
-0.6312552690505981,
0.41845232248306274,
0.0477135069668293,
0.10703303664922714,
0.08223321288824081,
0.21351170539855957,
-0.1277027130126953,
0.10882633924484253,
-0.6963091492652893,
0.09615056216716766,
-0.3053676187992096,
-0.08112865686416626,
0.020081887021660805,
-0.2558545470237732,
-0.1259920746088028,
0.07058841735124588,
0.5241593718528748,
-0.4357679486274719,
0.25783056020736694,
0.1628866344690323,
-0.6465137004852295,
0.05858558788895607,
0.3202855885028839,
0.8767217397689819,
0.9532157182693481,
-0.15984591841697693,
0.3234012722969055,
0.05445946753025055,
-0.4907948672771454,
0.11809279024600983,
0.09537879377603531,
-0.09995802491903305,
-0.24443338811397552,
0.2837957739830017,
0.5455323457717896,
0.5047635436058044,
-0.8959481120109558,
0.4582139253616333,
-0.3232463598251343,
0.06668166816234589,
-0.3889329433441162,
0.07604413479566574,
0.0754900798201561,
0.40637266635894775,
0.7834919095039368,
-0.2399047613143921,
0.34015771746635437,
-0.7182617783546448,
0.29036945104599,
0.4957456588745117,
-0.5439507365226746,
-0.4477609097957611,
0.519946813583374,
0.8347514271736145,
-0.7212620377540588,
0.6877555847167969,
-0.29701051115989685,
-0.4139186441898346,
0.24974830448627472,
0.3254898190498352,
0.780722975730896,
-0.08914751559495926,
0.32398107647895813,
0.3916924297809601,
0.07649493217468262,
-0.15144330263137817,
0.0836433619260788,
0.010444781742990017,
-0.6202929615974426,
-0.35269060730934143,
-0.5648161172866821,
-0.7254245281219482,
0.04171741008758545,
-0.5757917761802673,
-0.07303042709827423,
-0.41157835721969604,
-0.4715808928012848,
-0.041988059878349304,
-0.09553348273038864,
-0.5497252345085144,
0.25491970777511597,
0.34145587682724,
0.7066782116889954,
-0.3673045039176941,
0.6792753338813782,
0.5623652338981628,
-0.3266112208366394,
-0.17732849717140198,
0.24417118728160858,
0.35939180850982666,
-0.4834921061992645,
0.3461422920227051,
0.25733712315559387,
-0.4687441289424896,
0.30041468143463135,
-0.584375262260437,
-0.5628260374069214,
0.9673186540603638,
-0.10992774367332458,
-0.9184297919273376,
-0.1722036451101303,
0.1277843713760376,
0.38101261854171753,
-0.0791575238108635,
0.3845372498035431,
0.24831798672676086,
0.4532615840435028,
-0.08221495151519775,
-1.2106544971466064,
-0.1684735119342804,
-0.2526242733001709,
-0.133619025349617,
0.022051379084587097,
-0.9046975374221802,
0.8161637783050537,
0.012946845032274723,
-0.09308762103319168,
0.016804557293653488,
0.14620669186115265,
-0.020849671214818954,
0.16914530098438263,
0.6895728707313538,
0.5424133539199829,
0.4907515347003937,
-0.05582364648580551,
0.918160617351532,
-0.2843552231788635,
0.1496906876564026,
0.7998963594436646,
-0.1747129261493683,
1.1112825870513916,
0.41884395480155945,
-0.11962305009365082,
0.5785278081893921,
0.3688710927963257,
0.328068345785141,
0.460593581199646,
0.038083236664533615,
-0.4590420424938202,
-0.7845072150230408,
-0.1492520570755005,
-0.022505879402160645,
0.5904937982559204,
0.3015785813331604,
0.1100291758775711,
-0.32915234565734863,
0.1723872721195221,
-0.0009030298097059131,
0.27654895186424255,
-0.2765451967716217,
1.0399110317230225,
0.03479813039302826,
-0.8640472888946533,
0.6195194125175476,
0.12813152372837067,
0.6883600354194641,
-0.8656905293464661,
-0.2840557098388672,
-0.45687639713287354,
0.32779279351234436,
0.08226172626018524,
-0.5720540881156921,
-0.29432207345962524,
-0.0646248385310173,
-0.08984723687171936,
-0.46099308133125305,
0.5418257117271423,
-0.2168707698583603,
-0.300735205411911,
0.38620448112487793,
0.5686593651771545,
0.16032589972019196,
-0.26805374026298523,
-0.5118516087532043,
0.26850223541259766,
0.1948380321264267,
-0.24629651010036469,
0.6020129919052124,
0.025642771273851395,
-0.16722604632377625,
1.2351452112197876,
0.8219638466835022,
-0.4018261730670929,
0.2531287968158722,
0.1330333799123764,
0.9315097332000732,
-0.8873860239982605,
-0.4185383915901184,
-0.5726305246353149,
0.3429678976535797,
-0.24372628331184387,
-0.22223778069019318,
0.6059578657150269,
0.7194701433181763,
0.7263065576553345,
0.10089121758937836,
0.8166465163230896,
0.4615689814090729,
0.3020309805870056,
-0.5890873074531555,
0.5515949726104736,
-0.5594547390937805,
-0.14425252377986908,
-0.11257112771272659,
-0.8996080756187439,
-0.09459458291530609,
0.7553868889808655,
0.1705126315355301,
-0.09576589614152908,
0.49234718084335327,
0.7332494258880615,
-0.2522803843021393,
-0.004570925608277321,
0.5720893740653992,
0.1856367290019989,
0.4624429941177368,
0.4738665223121643,
0.8567513227462769,
-0.16655170917510986,
1.0646928548812866,
-0.007726618088781834,
-0.1823781430721283,
-0.6452344655990601,
-0.7472444772720337,
-0.6080231070518494,
-0.6200853586196899,
-0.1156989336013794,
-0.1774352341890335,
0.32639193534851074,
1.0217857360839844,
1.0641095638275146,
-0.6358603835105896,
-0.5205890536308289,
0.08356645703315735,
-0.059337735176086426,
-0.3048805296421051,
-0.152598574757576,
-0.34255334734916687,
-0.2714810073375702,
-0.9739665985107422,
0.51252281665802,
0.1482185274362564,
0.15851429104804993,
-0.616856038570404,
-0.1332291066646576,
-0.7374735474586487,
0.1458510458469391,
0.687789261341095,
0.30376118421554565,
-0.8813455700874329,
-0.35200151801109314,
0.3104310631752014,
-0.1887815296649933,
0.1118268147110939,
0.7411983013153076,
-0.8579283952713013,
0.6803438663482666,
0.3201483190059662,
0.41944772005081177,
1.0005857944488525,
0.1687152236700058,
0.6452253460884094,
-0.5369080305099487,
-0.004377509001642466,
0.1974135935306549,
0.10533168166875839,
0.45135337114334106,
0.1329619437456131,
0.45532897114753723,
0.20613443851470947,
-0.3033773601055145,
-0.4730418026447296,
0.261756956577301,
-1.0153298377990723,
-0.5007181167602539,
1.322348713874817,
-0.17474456131458282,
0.10646791756153107,
-0.25145137310028076,
-0.023101020604372025,
0.003473650896921754,
-0.5811479091644287,
0.6584284901618958,
0.6828861236572266,
-0.1234307661652565,
-0.34541282057762146,
-0.8199118971824646,
0.3597058951854706,
0.003372752107679844,
-0.6147212386131287,
-0.003303389996290207,
0.7862530946731567,
0.14193007349967957,
0.43553102016448975,
0.41823500394821167,
0.5720614790916443,
0.2682150602340698,
0.05022231489419937,
0.19676922261714935,
0.03845015540719032,
-0.576755166053772,
-0.13871300220489502,
0.12534494698047638,
-0.06354894489049911,
-0.05791445076465607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05926v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05926v3 | On the Convergence of Zeroth-Order Federated Tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T18:56:40 | 2024-06-17T16:00:59 | Zhenqing Ling, Daoyuan Chen, Liuyi Yao, Yaliang Li, Ying Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The confluence of Federated Learning (FL) and Large Language Models (LLMs) is
ushering in a new era in privacy-preserving natural language processing.
However, the intensive memory requirements for fine-tuning LLMs pose
significant challenges, especially when deploying on clients with limited
computational resources. To circumvent this, we explore the novel integration
of Memory-efficient Zeroth-Order Optimization within a federated setting, a
synergy we term as FedMeZO. Our study is the first to examine the theoretical
underpinnings of FedMeZO in the context of LLMs, tackling key questions
regarding the influence of large parameter spaces on optimization behavior, the
establishment of convergence properties, and the identification of critical
parameters for convergence to inform personalized federated strategies. Our
extensive empirical evidence supports the theory, showing that FedMeZO not only
converges faster than traditional first-order methods such as FedAvg but also
significantly reduces GPU memory usage during training to levels comparable to
those during inference. Moreover, the proposed personalized FL strategy that is
built upon the theoretical insights to customize the client-wise learning rate
can effectively accelerate loss reduction. We hope our work can help to bridge
theoretical and practical aspects of federated fine-tuning for LLMs, thereby
stimulating further advancements and research in this area. | [
-0.7232850193977356,
-0.7636549472808838,
0.5985327363014221,
0.15331487357616425,
-0.057141970843076706,
0.024422330781817436,
-0.6947851777076721,
-0.3800208866596222,
0.055301468819379807,
0.6212150454521179,
-0.7924302220344543,
-0.6227298378944397,
-0.28144362568855286,
0.06283668428659439,
-0.10458873212337494,
0.9341461658477783,
0.19409342110157013,
0.07262767851352692,
-0.19353333115577698,
-0.49137818813323975,
-0.20193208754062653,
-0.24570757150650024,
-0.4406890869140625,
-0.41053852438926697,
0.6333681344985962,
0.528497040271759,
0.6467419266700745,
0.8443195223808289,
0.33358466625213623,
0.35355448722839355,
0.2130618542432785,
0.12435246258974075,
-0.8455970883369446,
0.22923161089420319,
-0.37693116068840027,
-0.6067686676979065,
-0.4662809669971466,
0.1036318689584732,
0.7184555530548096,
0.8748575448989868,
-0.534730851650238,
0.15984933078289032,
-0.25054559111595154,
0.5637915730476379,
-0.944367527961731,
0.10769795626401901,
-0.4235914349555969,
0.30845144391059875,
-0.23502930998802185,
-0.45687898993492126,
-0.5637655258178711,
-0.38927987217903137,
0.0914788544178009,
-0.43008390069007874,
0.35748258233070374,
0.08044268935918808,
0.587565541267395,
0.1297132968902588,
0.13341942429542542,
0.1271759569644928,
-0.9478775858879089,
0.8362023234367371,
-0.8559173941612244,
0.5865784287452698,
0.031741946935653687,
0.3525204062461853,
-0.25788408517837524,
-0.423446923494339,
-0.521395206451416,
0.28746524453163147,
0.10438665747642517,
-0.11507180333137512,
-0.32570502161979675,
0.37861377000808716,
0.13428649306297302,
0.6265199780464172,
-0.3304855227470398,
0.536272406578064,
0.024839984253048897,
-0.16821981966495514,
0.6647993922233582,
0.3569774329662323,
0.00597256189212203,
0.6088524460792542,
-0.4568485617637634,
-0.10310699790716171,
-0.5180996060371399,
-0.035238344222307205,
0.35557159781455994,
0.5937860012054443,
-0.03764834627509117,
0.1400543749332428,
-0.586963415145874,
0.6959874033927917,
0.3201039731502533,
-0.3942602276802063,
0.24070443212985992,
-0.09136135131120682,
-0.4013061225414276,
0.10810784250497818,
0.9133787751197815,
0.15215685963630676,
0.1340218186378479,
-0.6264398694038391,
-0.258861243724823,
-0.14747391641139984,
0.17076550424098969,
-1.0521559715270996,
0.13571996986865997,
0.11063983291387558,
-0.11349250376224518,
-0.2708152234554291,
0.04680463671684265,
-0.7673683762550354,
-0.13882064819335938,
-0.22062088549137115,
0.27542126178741455,
-0.2396194189786911,
-0.12081702798604965,
0.2249899059534073,
0.21987801790237427,
0.2327437847852707,
0.3166447877883911,
-1.2761237621307373,
0.6812335252761841,
1.2137115001678467,
0.7908226847648621,
0.20442993938922882,
-0.5297548174858093,
-0.8190175294876099,
-0.00047922300291247666,
-0.1950380802154541,
0.44403231143951416,
-0.5322332382202148,
-0.2303556501865387,
0.08047550171613693,
0.00316617707721889,
-0.1406404823064804,
-0.2555769681930542,
0.20122972130775452,
-0.7773037552833557,
0.46249377727508545,
-0.31649544835090637,
-0.7653616666793823,
-0.33495959639549255,
0.15135186910629272,
-0.31890371441841125,
0.24472153186798096,
0.17210102081298828,
-0.5269781947135925,
0.13337241113185883,
-0.42381182312965393,
-0.5020391941070557,
0.21351908147335052,
-0.23802292346954346,
-0.5297638177871704,
0.3747449815273285,
-0.16049911081790924,
0.6898847222328186,
-0.4564656615257263,
0.061720624566078186,
-0.6976755261421204,
-0.5526053309440613,
-0.09059621393680573,
-0.046326279640197754,
0.6247450709342957,
0.23825734853744507,
-0.5878251194953918,
-0.014744122512638569,
-0.5462386012077332,
0.29151463508605957,
0.2121654897928238,
-0.15217550098896027,
-0.4198036193847656,
-0.04744011163711548,
-0.28849390149116516,
-0.139422208070755,
0.282136470079422,
-0.7377011775970459,
0.10380486398935318,
-0.8208640813827515,
0.5426228046417236,
0.6999183893203735,
-0.13192978501319885,
0.7291432023048401,
-0.12894798815250397,
0.44441038370132446,
-0.3004434108734131,
0.302223265171051,
-0.17805948853492737,
-0.21631060540676117,
-0.5084940791130066,
-0.14923276007175446,
0.09492141008377075,
0.2679656445980072,
-0.2575991451740265,
0.3764282166957855,
-0.4360475242137909,
-0.3059293031692505,
-0.2645801603794098,
0.29200270771980286,
0.5033841133117676,
0.4822998642921448,
0.09134305268526077,
-0.26075661182403564,
-0.03936855122447014,
-0.9325694441795349,
0.07956122606992722,
0.19159218668937683,
0.041011035442352295,
0.5788593292236328,
0.02390695922076702,
-0.20418298244476318,
0.9472010731697083,
-0.5575342178344727,
-0.26013824343681335,
-0.0728193148970604,
-0.13339146971702576,
0.32056862115859985,
0.3573194146156311,
0.8481926918029785,
-0.5062949657440186,
-0.43227019906044006,
0.35040706396102905,
-0.41127318143844604,
-0.10808487236499786,
0.13122761249542236,
-0.14484310150146484,
0.2259625941514969,
0.0034909239038825035,
-0.4982028305530548,
-0.06624077260494232,
0.6370121240615845,
-0.3153477609157562,
0.3278738856315613,
-0.5226948857307434,
-0.12362799048423767,
-0.9917555451393127,
-0.16006730496883392,
-0.207113116979599,
-0.2346019595861435,
-0.7138345241546631,
0.3681773543357849,
-0.08057291060686111,
-0.13955450057983398,
0.032202254980802536,
0.3846278786659241,
-0.496988981962204,
-0.2133946716785431,
-0.4879307746887207,
0.11990739405155182,
-0.07464280724525452,
0.6193447709083557,
-0.4345351457595825,
0.7450602054595947,
0.38253623247146606,
-0.3672076165676117,
0.22492003440856934,
0.2548162639141083,
0.07707613706588745,
0.6095021367073059,
-0.3443598449230194,
0.16916514933109283,
0.06918076425790787,
-0.04783649370074272,
-0.6700063347816467,
-0.19119182229042053,
0.16049812734127045,
-0.2179843634366989,
0.516076922416687,
0.19030654430389404,
-0.6955931782722473,
-0.1696668416261673,
-0.31179988384246826,
0.22447086870670319,
0.36001327633857727,
-0.704954206943512,
0.3908161222934723,
0.29721561074256897,
0.1409553587436676,
-0.6070733070373535,
-0.5462457537651062,
-0.060363367199897766,
-0.12367390096187592,
-0.6383256912231445,
0.3273558020591736,
-0.010050139389932156,
-0.18719527125358582,
-0.07602997124195099,
-0.037722550332546234,
0.03614490106701851,
0.3736984133720398,
0.2000681310892105,
-0.05047788470983505,
-0.6171613335609436,
-0.006728550419211388,
0.20542369782924652,
-0.07950843125581741,
0.008243640884757042,
-0.5280829071998596,
0.6600053310394287,
-0.5356378555297852,
-0.07271554321050644,
-0.3514820337295532,
0.31997430324554443,
0.6101117134094238,
-0.3509214520454407,
1.1171908378601074,
0.7188357710838318,
-0.08615780621767044,
-0.6680888533592224,
-0.8440830111503601,
-0.2679345905780792,
-0.5469226837158203,
0.029751339927315712,
-0.10473629832267761,
-1.4093832969665527,
0.6920321583747864,
-0.07541952282190323,
0.29619866609573364,
0.08204804360866547,
0.7286691069602966,
0.18053539097309113,
0.6235353350639343,
0.9791796207427979,
-0.4974379241466522,
0.5887587070465088,
-0.26405441761016846,
0.3588548004627228,
-0.5023162961006165,
0.007576164323836565,
-0.2821689546108246,
-0.5180339217185974,
-0.8008886575698853,
-0.24173447489738464,
0.05925535410642624,
-0.1767703890800476,
-0.30269262194633484,
0.2820061147212982,
-0.2213011384010315,
0.7259112000465393,
0.4822033941745758,
0.123290054500103,
0.29347866773605347,
0.0848919078707695,
-0.08211628347635269,
0.1953996866941452,
-0.8652178049087524,
0.18973982334136963,
0.7164331674575806,
0.26816001534461975,
0.579316258430481,
0.11049550026655197,
1.0114918947219849,
0.13155174255371094,
0.3376087248325348,
-0.5878109335899353,
0.5987582802772522,
-0.2330237627029419,
-0.4404631555080414,
-0.35540837049484253,
-0.6110775470733643,
-0.7361639738082886,
0.40250536799430847,
-0.13517364859580994,
-0.8182898163795471,
0.34792572259902954,
0.018147803843021393,
-0.6758384108543396,
0.3385271430015564,
-0.6483083963394165,
0.7278679013252258,
-0.08019993454217911,
-0.8048701882362366,
-0.4982965290546417,
-0.7328076958656311,
0.4814401865005493,
0.12120263278484344,
-0.013742025010287762,
-0.27329307794570923,
-0.14059562981128693,
0.33102744817733765,
-0.7665757536888123,
0.7198116779327393,
-0.3760984539985657,
-0.09502637386322021,
-0.1872193068265915,
-0.09560026973485947,
0.38484442234039307,
-0.0036139856092631817,
-0.07585666328668594,
0.3082365393638611,
-0.28755515813827515,
-0.42005443572998047,
-0.6966168284416199,
1.1539478302001953,
-0.7083710432052612,
-0.6619620323181152,
0.008703851141035557,
-0.5242345929145813,
-0.44640135765075684,
0.5200168490409851,
-0.01889234408736229,
0.4193209111690521,
-0.13343419134616852,
0.23512022197246552,
0.850759744644165,
-0.1766076683998108,
0.48231035470962524,
0.9628604054450989,
-0.010823222808539867,
-0.6743100881576538,
0.8853514194488525,
-0.0052725342102348804,
0.2772683799266815,
0.41541680693626404,
0.37182068824768066,
0.05264478921890259,
-0.7020809054374695,
-0.26395323872566223,
0.6520026326179504,
-0.4001363217830658,
-0.36398303508758545,
-0.3964959979057312,
-0.09070201218128204,
-0.18287359178066254,
-0.42870643734931946,
-0.5926811099052429,
-0.036462027579545975,
-0.404540091753006,
0.04272238537669182,
0.36817556619644165,
0.06868517398834229,
0.07243835926055908,
0.5424813032150269,
-0.6883658766746521,
-0.14748172461986542,
-0.018002783879637718,
0.9311314821243286,
0.19619633257389069,
-0.1309971958398819,
-0.46977245807647705,
-0.08305063098669052,
-0.015353141352534294,
-0.5444043874740601,
0.24499741196632385,
0.4508923888206482,
0.6295807361602783,
1.0395194292068481,
0.2417609989643097,
0.7561571598052979,
-0.6988012194633484,
0.20686456561088562,
0.11352600902318954,
-0.6368651986122131,
0.10736488550901413,
-0.6266874074935913,
0.3239838182926178,
0.8695591688156128,
0.14938820898532867,
-0.31115177273750305,
-0.38788750767707825,
-0.5965083837509155,
-0.617311418056488,
0.9338842630386353,
0.09118503332138062,
0.36388760805130005,
0.12415925413370132,
0.6418120861053467,
0.15375617146492004,
0.4716954231262207,
-0.13902898132801056,
-0.36937522888183594,
0.21567663550376892,
-0.013651694171130657,
-0.2991991341114044,
-0.18049141764640808,
-0.34048500657081604,
-0.23655804991722107,
0.36956343054771423,
-0.23099598288536072,
0.22759610414505005,
-0.14835087954998016,
0.2278243452310562,
-0.46017932891845703,
0.28475287556648254,
0.8293005228042603,
0.41081929206848145,
-0.18329750001430511,
-0.24434131383895874,
-0.00030185526702553034,
-0.2635899782180786,
0.019275253638625145,
0.40662381052970886,
-0.39964789152145386,
-0.13601136207580566,
0.1757878065109253,
1.0114893913269043,
0.7522927522659302,
-0.5156919360160828,
0.5383707284927368,
-0.08636932820081711,
-0.3922466039657593,
-0.12561266124248505,
0.4523962140083313,
-0.029730049893260002,
0.6112455725669861,
0.12355950474739075,
-0.055541280657052994,
0.009650250896811485,
-0.39248839020729065,
0.2135045975446701,
0.7785100340843201,
0.0012864110758528113,
-0.5306828618049622,
0.7175772786140442,
0.17063359916210175,
-0.3962896466255188,
0.4525723159313202,
0.06543774157762527,
-0.44438987970352173,
0.17283016443252563,
0.4777323007583618,
1.2428696155548096,
-0.2987259328365326,
0.22249780595302582,
0.14494392275810242,
0.030512221157550812,
-0.21857550740242004,
-0.04306942969560623,
-0.808652400970459,
-0.778190016746521,
-0.2497137188911438,
-0.8875793218612671,
-0.5279781222343445,
-0.09283686429262161,
-0.7383891344070435,
-0.06040654703974724,
-1.1024976968765259,
-0.17626866698265076,
-0.013877431862056255,
0.364181786775589,
-0.3672914206981659,
-0.1935124695301056,
0.3919562101364136,
0.7772805690765381,
-0.473542183637619,
0.7878240942955017,
0.30150264501571655,
0.08605097234249115,
-0.6837268471717834,
-0.020106539130210876,
-0.09738754481077194,
-0.7439127564430237,
0.09396125376224518,
0.20563027262687683,
-0.23264029622077942,
0.1781773567199707,
-0.3784209191799164,
-0.7359545230865479,
1.3386294841766357,
0.5414121150970459,
-0.8210498690605164,
-0.09331189095973969,
0.19305036962032318,
0.8192384839057922,
-0.5370299816131592,
-0.12097339332103729,
0.5713829398155212,
0.1995312124490738,
0.15743696689605713,
-0.8366235494613647,
0.08954298496246338,
0.029370564967393875,
0.058664895594120026,
0.6199998259544373,
-1.1598905324935913,
0.7368018627166748,
-0.44589200615882874,
-0.36128681898117065,
-0.06643202155828476,
0.6375972628593445,
-0.2028501182794571,
0.4489039182662964,
0.4658268988132477,
0.7501952052116394,
0.6480053067207336,
0.01479558739811182,
0.9474622011184692,
-0.4941287338733673,
0.5995720624923706,
1.1131705045700073,
-0.3686583638191223,
0.738797128200531,
0.4047796130180359,
-0.09925873577594757,
0.3984922170639038,
0.2985709607601166,
-0.043941810727119446,
0.6150399446487427,
-0.10220925509929657,
-0.4287630319595337,
-0.1738409548997879,
0.0024862803984433413,
-0.27039000391960144,
0.36873239278793335,
0.2109007090330124,
-0.4892157316207886,
-0.6070935726165771,
0.11393657326698303,
0.1649836152791977,
0.05049445107579231,
-0.21146845817565918,
0.9076517820358276,
0.07724564522504807,
-0.43800753355026245,
0.7085939645767212,
0.10346277803182602,
0.5390611886978149,
-0.6224464774131775,
0.4534318745136261,
-0.5198533535003662,
0.6197521686553955,
-0.11292926967144012,
-0.25959211587905884,
0.23898328840732574,
-0.191245436668396,
-0.14475801587104797,
-0.3879702389240265,
0.3130592703819275,
-0.5347136855125427,
-0.13460573554039001,
0.4213113486766815,
0.2839030623435974,
-0.30072829127311707,
0.15831442177295685,
-0.397950679063797,
0.007438747677952051,
-0.15223030745983124,
-0.3316158056259155,
0.640866756439209,
0.2998313009738922,
0.2736353576183319,
0.5674903392791748,
0.5456975102424622,
0.005604601930826902,
-0.08846072107553482,
-0.015130124986171722,
0.8975706696510315,
-0.43568405508995056,
-0.8106660842895508,
-0.9846510291099548,
-0.18990834057331085,
0.08074796944856644,
-0.01563265547156334,
1.0660041570663452,
0.4129403829574585,
0.9770573973655701,
-0.029143765568733215,
0.265654057264328,
0.07998392730951309,
0.19735053181648254,
-0.3117803931236267,
0.8677279949188232,
-0.7231460809707642,
0.1908409744501114,
-0.15045587718486786,
-0.7469078898429871,
-0.2502209544181824,
0.22959144413471222,
-0.4246254861354828,
-0.2651192843914032,
0.21059022843837738,
0.6967911720275879,
-0.08284920454025269,
0.261409729719162,
0.5517706871032715,
0.2607521414756775,
0.19673149287700653,
0.6018231511116028,
0.16797098517417908,
-0.1702377051115036,
0.034168489277362823,
-0.8199239373207092,
-0.17755287885665894,
-0.5100585222244263,
-0.5095736980438232,
-0.8693278431892395,
-0.32827508449554443,
-0.13193176686763763,
-0.018373576924204826,
0.12238022685050964,
0.9546242952346802,
0.5786464810371399,
-0.7616758346557617,
-0.17736870050430298,
-0.23603905737400055,
0.03253115713596344,
-0.08047422766685486,
-0.22391420602798462,
-0.06704095005989075,
-0.4174095094203949,
-0.6227245330810547,
0.32639920711517334,
0.6651961803436279,
-0.20287786424160004,
-0.5993310213088989,
-0.16619451344013214,
-0.009093580767512321,
0.04685642197728157,
0.4616166055202484,
0.5373120903968811,
-0.6532143354415894,
-0.06755005568265915,
0.0369650274515152,
-0.0708807185292244,
0.1635701060295105,
0.8935468196868896,
-0.590083122253418,
0.618648111820221,
0.48437198996543884,
0.9087051153182983,
0.2997828722000122,
0.24063946306705475,
0.784331202507019,
-0.6866466999053955,
0.3452802300453186,
0.2600333094596863,
0.1899888962507248,
0.13000057637691498,
-0.5385415554046631,
0.25929388403892517,
0.4117904603481293,
-0.5509461760520935,
-1.0110236406326294,
-0.03049829788506031,
-0.9005952477455139,
-0.0061666714027523994,
0.685011625289917,
-0.2936159372329712,
-0.40764811635017395,
0.5188732147216797,
0.35319918394088745,
-0.04366336017847061,
-0.306257963180542,
0.7766189575195312,
0.5357046723365784,
-0.16347838938236237,
-0.3060839772224426,
-0.35022222995758057,
0.3024030327796936,
0.41424351930618286,
-0.5208606719970703,
0.2666112184524536,
0.644862711429596,
0.3260674476623535,
0.1490725874900818,
0.5327983498573303,
0.24826622009277344,
0.32969021797180176,
-0.14531727135181427,
-0.29672929644584656,
-0.4434240460395813,
-0.2646700143814087,
-0.5541443824768066,
0.4394901394844055,
-0.10177373886108398,
-0.11918525397777557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05913v1 | Efficient Stagewise Pretraining via Progressive Subnetworks | 2024-02-08T18:49:09 | 2024-02-08T18:49:09 | Abhishek Panigrahi, Nikunj Saunshi, Kaifeng Lyu, Sobhan Miryoosefi, Sashank Reddi, Satyen Kale, Sanjiv Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent developments in large language models have sparked interest in
efficient pretraining methods. A recent effective paradigm is to perform
stage-wise training, where the size of the model is gradually increased over
the course of training (e.g. gradual stacking (Reddi et al., 2023)). While the
resource and wall-time savings are appealing, it has limitations, particularly
the inability to evaluate the full model during earlier stages, and degradation
in model quality due to smaller model capacity in the initial stages. In this
work, we propose an alternative framework, progressive subnetwork training,
that maintains the full model throughout training, but only trains subnetworks
within the model in each step. We focus on a simple instantiation of this
framework, Random Path Training (RaPTr) that only trains a sub-path of layers
in each step, progressively increasing the path lengths in stages. RaPTr
achieves better pre-training loss for BERT and UL2 language models while
requiring 20-33% fewer FLOPs compared to standard training, and is competitive
or better than other efficient training methods. Furthermore, RaPTr shows
better downstream performance on UL2, improving QA tasks and SuperGLUE by 1-5%
compared to standard training and stacking. Finally, we provide a theoretical
basis for RaPTr to justify (a) the increasing complexity of subnetworks in
stages, and (b) the stability in loss across stage transitions due to residual
connections and layer norm. | [
-0.0973096415400505,
-0.4133506715297699,
0.21509356796741486,
0.2458992451429367,
-0.272697776556015,
0.1614757925271988,
-0.06918805092573166,
-0.2373933047056198,
-0.010551342740654945,
0.16868798434734344,
-0.770376980304718,
-0.2824091613292694,
-0.4242776334285736,
-0.28725287318229675,
-0.5944865345954895,
1.1367137432098389,
-0.12749715149402618,
0.09051614999771118,
0.01877342350780964,
-0.014069120399653912,
-0.09617414325475693,
-0.392111212015152,
-1.2021156549453735,
-0.7125781178474426,
0.7258653044700623,
0.294560045003891,
0.34932973980903625,
0.30564409494400024,
0.1821429431438446,
0.23824642598628998,
0.0460507795214653,
-0.1964298039674759,
-0.764952540397644,
0.2638283371925354,
0.14155349135398865,
-0.2960270643234253,
-0.1513327807188034,
0.02424086071550846,
0.7650871872901917,
0.7035964727401733,
-0.5041074752807617,
0.12943671643733978,
-0.03392288088798523,
0.7162574529647827,
-0.49913454055786133,
-0.15002571046352386,
-0.49750617146492004,
0.4829649329185486,
-0.3503119647502899,
0.014983145520091057,
-0.5108757615089417,
-0.18248145282268524,
0.06005888804793358,
-0.5770286321640015,
-0.04895687848329544,
-0.21971844136714935,
0.8183249235153198,
-0.0012126931687816978,
-0.08793942630290985,
0.0539122000336647,
-0.7951890826225281,
0.4843490719795227,
-0.7376524209976196,
0.7427414059638977,
0.08475598692893982,
0.33904552459716797,
-0.11140824854373932,
-1.2153539657592773,
-0.3945762813091278,
-0.38803717494010925,
0.0688043162226677,
0.3960763216018677,
-0.31340956687927246,
0.23368920385837555,
0.2224515825510025,
0.0946388766169548,
-0.612629771232605,
0.4582187533378601,
-0.18795622885227203,
-0.26484811305999756,
0.08220146596431732,
-0.16577711701393127,
0.15540289878845215,
0.21443665027618408,
-0.4802783131599426,
-0.2364516407251358,
-0.8105238080024719,
0.24130547046661377,
0.5101838111877441,
0.28636619448661804,
0.08423244208097458,
0.17178967595100403,
-0.04371863603591919,
0.5945712327957153,
0.04421469569206238,
-0.17678207159042358,
0.23185673356056213,
-0.32257866859436035,
0.043545082211494446,
-0.2103264331817627,
0.6580613255500793,
-0.34489625692367554,
0.5272901058197021,
-0.3182785212993622,
-0.2868402302265167,
-0.21084408462047577,
0.3247407376766205,
-0.8507561087608337,
-0.44901320338249207,
0.15440616011619568,
-0.121436707675457,
-0.14252689480781555,
-0.22311225533485413,
0.03172435611486435,
-0.024948107078671455,
-0.08719248324632645,
0.4222280979156494,
-0.8376670479774475,
-0.22354625165462494,
-0.051795389503240585,
0.1547466367483139,
0.08505860716104507,
0.3300594687461853,
-0.6516207456588745,
0.3124040961265564,
0.37978076934814453,
0.9157609939575195,
0.10771499574184418,
-0.30766692757606506,
-0.8018162846565247,
-0.09266407042741776,
-0.5997352600097656,
0.6531335711479187,
-0.4386651813983917,
-0.1941840648651123,
-0.23373650014400482,
-0.328471839427948,
-0.3382207751274109,
-0.25229090452194214,
0.3009655773639679,
-0.844655454158783,
0.17849768698215485,
0.14251834154129028,
-0.19322514533996582,
0.04153487831354141,
0.2736765146255493,
-0.4499198794364929,
1.066184163093567,
0.2871127426624298,
-0.9639815092086792,
0.39336493611335754,
-0.4304860830307007,
-0.7145088911056519,
-0.008229934610426426,
-0.3377573490142822,
-0.47116872668266296,
-0.05504395440220833,
0.07761098444461823,
0.21682628989219666,
0.23541538417339325,
0.020874489098787308,
0.10745231062173843,
-0.527032196521759,
-0.20760829746723175,
-0.1493322104215622,
0.6910033226013184,
0.2069683074951172,
-0.3955625593662262,
0.25756317377090454,
-0.7736802697181702,
0.08909180015325546,
-0.24470128118991852,
-0.5590137839317322,
-0.3773959279060364,
-0.03278972953557968,
-0.3217774033546448,
0.524959146976471,
0.033762745559215546,
-0.5287135243415833,
0.2542707026004791,
-0.4548570215702057,
0.18986889719963074,
0.8776100277900696,
-0.1399456113576889,
0.4133915603160858,
-0.09218551218509674,
0.8813644647598267,
0.3822512626647949,
0.32057443261146545,
-0.012748409993946552,
-0.23530146479606628,
-0.9656972885131836,
-0.12217239290475845,
0.8153592348098755,
0.5736629366874695,
-1.117611050605774,
0.19164660573005676,
-0.27070143818855286,
-0.5168839693069458,
-0.37491193413734436,
0.0524449422955513,
0.6218198537826538,
0.555414080619812,
0.2983698546886444,
-0.6837903261184692,
-0.7796803116798401,
-0.884598970413208,
0.17769932746887207,
-0.22026152908802032,
-0.10174009203910828,
-0.11312174052000046,
0.26252317428588867,
-0.06461863219738007,
0.929146409034729,
-0.027768516913056374,
-0.2254631519317627,
-0.7332241535186768,
0.43458160758018494,
0.41360002756118774,
0.7436233758926392,
0.3698248267173767,
-0.5846230983734131,
-0.5301390290260315,
-0.09937237203121185,
-0.17809362709522247,
-0.04549432173371315,
-0.43613317608833313,
-0.13564978539943695,
0.06975477188825607,
0.5421432256698608,
-0.4174962043762207,
0.12000541388988495,
0.7151160836219788,
0.13326305150985718,
0.4790392518043518,
-0.2536149024963379,
-0.3107222020626068,
-0.858375072479248,
0.011017234064638615,
-0.08210645616054535,
-0.24654297530651093,
-0.7599889039993286,
-0.1301346868276596,
-0.1734822392463684,
-0.031074756756424904,
-0.5339542627334595,
0.2515043020248413,
-0.42397141456604004,
-0.19306336343288422,
-0.000929937930777669,
0.034809138625860214,
-0.19870741665363312,
0.5092218518257141,
0.07019620388746262,
0.883973240852356,
0.5005232691764832,
-0.469207763671875,
-0.21453213691711426,
0.08238586038351059,
-0.43959036469459534,
-0.02006344683468342,
-0.7714638710021973,
0.3139297664165497,
-0.07454792410135269,
0.8112835884094238,
-0.7190520167350769,
0.20114648342132568,
0.19347968697547913,
-0.29989904165267944,
0.3931788504123688,
-0.23668919503688812,
-0.31641149520874023,
-0.4816642105579376,
-0.23725350201129913,
0.35669636726379395,
0.6777375340461731,
-0.30663633346557617,
0.6175342202186584,
0.051974572241306305,
0.15478672087192535,
-0.7734895944595337,
-0.6791161298751831,
-0.10126805305480957,
0.08357356488704681,
-0.6668527722358704,
0.2947310507297516,
0.028058476746082306,
0.18119600415229797,
-0.13458457589149475,
-0.4171850383281708,
0.07048867642879486,
0.07031131535768509,
0.20081955194473267,
-0.3382514715194702,
-0.07938223332166672,
-0.044011421501636505,
-0.01837388426065445,
-0.3456064462661743,
-0.25647100806236267,
-0.833048403263092,
0.8166494965553284,
-0.049357108771800995,
-0.2632416784763336,
-0.22372104227542877,
0.3278387188911438,
0.22432377934455872,
-0.2070688158273697,
0.9653455018997192,
0.9261990189552307,
-0.18227648735046387,
-0.5227365493774414,
-0.20225107669830322,
0.022301655262708664,
-0.4225432574748993,
0.5167507529258728,
-0.4834953844547272,
-1.0054758787155151,
0.5494582056999207,
-0.011729567311704159,
0.1156417652964592,
0.28847837448120117,
0.29151812195777893,
-0.07196775078773499,
0.9517971873283386,
0.9556878805160522,
0.19910074770450592,
0.6972004771232605,
-0.56974858045578,
0.18661271035671234,
-0.840404212474823,
-0.299180805683136,
-0.19783619046211243,
-0.3416319489479065,
-0.36898860335350037,
-0.48496565222740173,
0.5081916451454163,
0.2433656007051468,
-0.5435474514961243,
0.4918685257434845,
-0.039472587406635284,
0.3194149136543274,
0.8177830576896667,
0.2014361172914505,
0.09544934332370758,
0.010293809697031975,
-0.6199482679367065,
0.12938381731510162,
-1.4049991369247437,
-0.180795356631279,
0.593259871006012,
0.6012181043624878,
0.8030434846878052,
-0.19396741688251495,
0.9103743433952332,
0.047180648893117905,
0.4028007686138153,
-0.5219293236732483,
0.5367831587791443,
-0.3643382787704468,
-0.5048076510429382,
-0.47952765226364136,
-0.6903757452964783,
-0.8009411096572876,
0.0877460390329361,
-0.16912947595119476,
-0.6845912337303162,
0.3070056438446045,
0.33904898166656494,
-0.5362851023674011,
0.4827980697154999,
-0.5194038152694702,
0.7348263263702393,
-0.23415637016296387,
-0.18516094982624054,
-0.06968104094266891,
-0.9889861941337585,
0.24478282034397125,
-0.2803492546081543,
0.13064977526664734,
0.1855521947145462,
0.253758043050766,
0.9737962484359741,
-0.5579978823661804,
0.7926344871520996,
-0.413083016872406,
-0.1548946350812912,
0.1799497902393341,
0.12828686833381653,
0.6616013646125793,
-0.12069841474294662,
-0.038422830402851105,
0.04664032161235809,
-0.3092575967311859,
-0.3964177072048187,
-0.5379036068916321,
0.24994158744812012,
-0.860228419303894,
-0.23610667884349823,
-0.34097984433174133,
-0.48513323068618774,
-0.6074046492576599,
0.23231662809848785,
0.44518911838531494,
0.6781628727912903,
0.041478004306554794,
0.19573459029197693,
0.6283820867538452,
-0.226197749376297,
0.4847683906555176,
0.25439155101776123,
-0.17663736641407013,
-0.14344468712806702,
0.7068173289299011,
0.3155840337276459,
0.468161940574646,
0.5562986135482788,
0.1681438535451889,
-0.2409031242132187,
-1.1779450178146362,
-0.18137381970882416,
-0.11764494329690933,
-0.6661499738693237,
-0.03272675350308418,
-0.6772282123565674,
-0.5499277710914612,
-0.273133784532547,
0.08131162822246552,
-0.5165342688560486,
-0.558622419834137,
0.1358972191810608,
-0.2386821061372757,
0.09034470468759537,
0.4918834865093231,
-0.5046238303184509,
0.5330225229263306,
-0.6761350631713867,
0.08063941448926926,
0.4992193579673767,
0.5098886489868164,
0.2756096422672272,
-0.6046715974807739,
-0.568818986415863,
-0.008976965211331844,
-0.09998739510774612,
-0.25603628158569336,
0.14161734282970428,
0.473609983921051,
0.5845277309417725,
0.40815573930740356,
0.025088664144277573,
0.7823759317398071,
-0.872571587562561,
0.6975995898246765,
0.5269504189491272,
-0.7039301991462708,
0.45451873540878296,
-0.3555258512496948,
0.4179304540157318,
0.8754971027374268,
0.6538040041923523,
-0.4998833239078522,
-0.42744317650794983,
-0.6501645445823669,
-1.2367937564849854,
0.6649960279464722,
0.4423782229423523,
0.1585034430027008,
0.07617764919996262,
0.14203296601772308,
0.21323439478874207,
0.10783178359270096,
-0.9559080600738525,
0.057351235300302505,
-0.38640931248664856,
-0.01894502528011799,
-0.02568015456199646,
-0.1671622097492218,
-0.15378880500793457,
-0.3087559640407562,
0.8526716828346252,
0.06421749293804169,
0.2273992896080017,
0.0644260123372078,
-0.18989041447639465,
-0.06920506805181503,
0.18663589656352997,
0.4388114809989929,
0.9418826699256897,
-0.270253986120224,
0.2944582998752594,
0.15344275534152985,
-0.645793616771698,
0.3965221047401428,
-0.01302450243383646,
-0.23153705894947052,
-0.052799493074417114,
0.712123692035675,
0.9230560064315796,
0.24317508935928345,
-0.4463682472705841,
0.3875446915626526,
0.02047642134130001,
-0.24738219380378723,
-0.2657546401023865,
0.09037332236766815,
0.02413998171687126,
0.36908257007598877,
0.4915132224559784,
0.014329984784126282,
-0.21335823833942413,
-0.49962499737739563,
0.611761212348938,
0.03844121843576431,
-0.495216965675354,
-0.23563793301582336,
0.5055617094039917,
0.10492618381977081,
-0.25174638628959656,
0.8788970708847046,
-0.12701939046382904,
-0.5701715350151062,
0.35295137763023376,
0.5429784059524536,
0.8638996481895447,
-0.08117137849330902,
0.48212599754333496,
0.17750772833824158,
0.38507500290870667,
-0.08494309335947037,
-0.04212469980120659,
0.02163161337375641,
-0.7635177373886108,
-0.8759180903434753,
-0.9746902585029602,
-0.3268783390522003,
0.13495299220085144,
-0.3297737240791321,
-0.19883769750595093,
-0.46743711829185486,
-0.1227453425526619,
-0.5364579558372498,
-0.10074348002672195,
-0.39019837975502014,
0.5064048767089844,
0.19464676082134247,
1.270046591758728,
-0.694595992565155,
1.1168973445892334,
0.6076010465621948,
-0.40517759323120117,
-1.2374112606048584,
0.1759115308523178,
-0.42460671067237854,
-0.7917653918266296,
0.9059442281723022,
0.09048057347536087,
-0.2957741320133209,
0.2683258056640625,
-0.32595619559288025,
-0.764409601688385,
1.0785547494888306,
0.35381174087524414,
-0.8782321214675903,
-0.3294870853424072,
-0.12115774303674698,
0.6254450678825378,
-0.40879976749420166,
0.38562482595443726,
0.215907022356987,
0.24667994678020477,
0.5226065516471863,
-0.668566107749939,
-0.025195011869072914,
-0.31621962785720825,
0.384144127368927,
0.12108157575130463,
-0.4343881905078888,
0.9592093229293823,
-0.032925378531217575,
-0.3920058310031891,
0.023827072232961655,
0.8522520065307617,
0.25012367963790894,
-0.16208529472351074,
1.092551827430725,
0.7654520869255066,
0.30143028497695923,
-0.13422183692455292,
0.9999892115592957,
-0.2651609182357788,
0.2619855999946594,
1.099113941192627,
0.03858710452914238,
0.7029088139533997,
0.2945462167263031,
-0.22541183233261108,
0.9508642554283142,
0.908564031124115,
0.4743300676345825,
0.7645854949951172,
0.6105563044548035,
0.02092329040169716,
-0.4981749653816223,
0.05244683101773262,
-0.47817763686180115,
0.289521187543869,
-0.14855681359767914,
0.024007607251405716,
-0.448668509721756,
0.12685532867908478,
0.06353534013032913,
-0.21624159812927246,
-0.2121669054031372,
0.35790759325027466,
0.24368412792682648,
-0.46066397428512573,
0.5998105406761169,
-0.18421980738639832,
0.5615193247795105,
-1.2021476030349731,
0.19984841346740723,
-0.5880259275436401,
0.1330874115228653,
-0.10364478826522827,
-0.3939569592475891,
0.08360353857278824,
-0.044985659420490265,
0.11764663457870483,
-0.576330304145813,
0.43183839321136475,
-0.35810044407844543,
-0.42007699608802795,
0.3491676151752472,
0.5095804333686829,
-0.021893514320254326,
0.3935123383998871,
-0.8001708984375,
-0.0806737095117569,
-0.2989707589149475,
-0.6380495429039001,
0.4967097342014313,
0.4041464030742645,
-0.08620885014533997,
0.6895239353179932,
0.6431793570518494,
0.2549391984939575,
0.12514549493789673,
0.5922595262527466,
1.1012742519378662,
-0.24429379403591156,
-0.6707162261009216,
-0.43777963519096375,
0.6894201636314392,
-0.00546957366168499,
-0.29344236850738525,
0.6156213283538818,
0.37482813000679016,
0.9772769212722778,
0.19871778786182404,
0.5402525663375854,
-0.20075133442878723,
0.3034302294254303,
-0.7911393046379089,
0.5222602486610413,
-0.43929168581962585,
0.3782839775085449,
-0.34439393877983093,
-0.7882900834083557,
-0.09148742258548737,
0.8202963471412659,
-0.25675168633461,
0.4083455502986908,
0.6753075122833252,
0.4270428419113159,
-0.2070169448852539,
-0.42115142941474915,
0.19959549605846405,
0.4537934958934784,
0.32413923740386963,
0.7124247550964355,
0.8970658779144287,
-0.11409980803728104,
0.6220653057098389,
-0.2948288917541504,
-0.4042801558971405,
0.16397322714328766,
-1.0652903318405151,
-0.7070515751838684,
-0.5076020359992981,
-0.15619376301765442,
-0.2218881994485855,
0.5128127932548523,
0.6737985610961914,
0.9795624017715454,
-0.773677408695221,
-0.2432612180709839,
-0.4307369291782379,
-0.1917378455400467,
-0.4095851182937622,
-0.14136968553066254,
0.2725513279438019,
-0.5282727479934692,
-0.18857304751873016,
0.5436115860939026,
0.16757434606552124,
0.03726838529109955,
-0.38023999333381653,
-0.06314776092767715,
-0.6447514295578003,
0.05317556485533714,
0.6383592486381531,
0.40922194719314575,
-0.17884327471256256,
-0.6056909561157227,
-0.13788704574108124,
0.1748029738664627,
-0.03213512524962425,
0.7485937476158142,
-0.8926176428794861,
0.11810596287250519,
0.44576287269592285,
0.472919225692749,
0.8190923929214478,
0.03607752174139023,
0.7973932027816772,
-1.1046451330184937,
0.2698553502559662,
0.4860679507255554,
0.15140016376972198,
0.19362886250019073,
0.03603619709610939,
0.6938334107398987,
0.23546971380710602,
-0.3035869002342224,
-0.687534749507904,
0.5042117834091187,
-0.9147523641586304,
-0.3194730579853058,
0.9762406945228577,
-0.4303450882434845,
0.09266599267721176,
0.0026674913242459297,
0.18876446783542633,
0.36265894770622253,
-0.1727621853351593,
0.6185043454170227,
0.38343939185142517,
-0.4714348614215851,
-0.18996135890483856,
-0.3962728977203369,
0.4543817937374115,
0.3357076942920685,
-0.5411856770515442,
-0.3048592507839203,
0.16830092668533325,
0.0872039943933487,
0.21013890206813812,
1.1008375883102417,
0.024527965113520622,
-0.07481784373521805,
-0.014386762864887714,
-0.07877741008996964,
-0.3372378945350647,
-0.8748341202735901,
0.021740378811955452,
0.2135004848241806,
-0.04479126259684563,
-0.222034752368927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05904v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05904v1 | FACT-GPT: Fact-Checking Augmentation via Claim Matching with LLMs | 2024-02-08T18:43:05 | 2024-02-08T18:43:05 | Eun Cheol Choi, Emilio Ferrara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.SI | Our society is facing rampant misinformation harming public health and trust.
To address the societal challenge, we introduce FACT-GPT, a system leveraging
Large Language Models (LLMs) to automate the claim matching stage of
fact-checking. FACT-GPT, trained on a synthetic dataset, identifies social
media content that aligns with, contradicts, or is irrelevant to previously
debunked claims. Our evaluation shows that our specialized LLMs can match the
accuracy of larger models in identifying related claims, closely mirroring
human judgment. This research provides an automated solution for efficient
claim matching, demonstrates the potential of LLMs in supporting fact-checkers,
and offers valuable resources for further research in the field. | [
0.03789179027080536,
-0.7280861735343933,
1.0647763013839722,
0.002961075631901622,
-0.1884501427412033,
0.2986127734184265,
0.14694571495056152,
-0.6504136919975281,
0.3146565556526184,
0.4263738989830017,
-0.38154923915863037,
-0.3320136070251465,
-0.7861550450325012,
0.10224056988954544,
-0.4684891998767853,
0.947832465171814,
-0.046468786895275116,
0.10698040574789047,
-0.44657960534095764,
0.24016885459423065,
-0.07970206439495087,
-0.5485766530036926,
-0.616935133934021,
-0.4148643910884857,
0.6013700366020203,
0.343354731798172,
0.7154244780540466,
0.5966970324516296,
0.4712602496147156,
0.3369998335838318,
0.23998481035232544,
0.5605785250663757,
-0.34247392416000366,
-0.07458443939685822,
-0.377113938331604,
-0.18081961572170258,
-0.43666672706604004,
0.14499719440937042,
0.33236539363861084,
0.27906766533851624,
-0.0663650706410408,
0.38424837589263916,
0.027980787679553032,
0.4764552414417267,
-0.5127414464950562,
0.20784316956996918,
-0.8213288187980652,
-0.18349269032478333,
0.021259905770421028,
-0.20702840387821198,
-0.14638088643550873,
-0.8613012433052063,
0.1273069828748703,
-0.3737819790840149,
0.5560888648033142,
-0.010019066743552685,
1.0281184911727905,
0.474277526140213,
-0.7150930762290955,
-0.3145987093448639,
-0.560307502746582,
0.19886960089206696,
-0.6657775044441223,
0.4283924400806427,
0.3764484226703644,
0.2303270399570465,
-0.15062738955020905,
-0.6167331337928772,
-0.7407536506652832,
-0.3567785620689392,
-0.4155038595199585,
-0.05047184228897095,
-0.08178780972957611,
0.01914898119866848,
0.45990288257598877,
0.38097846508026123,
-0.9105054140090942,
-0.21674728393554688,
-0.29180532693862915,
-0.637120246887207,
0.6950008869171143,
-0.21669861674308777,
0.6122040152549744,
-0.30012479424476624,
-0.35766130685806274,
0.2081717997789383,
-0.8555005192756653,
-0.49285250902175903,
0.07194612175226212,
0.1816502809524536,
-0.2049744725227356,
0.8647043704986572,
-0.2684744894504547,
0.5566583275794983,
-0.007718957494944334,
-0.38079482316970825,
0.216835156083107,
-0.4407358467578888,
-0.3686566948890686,
0.562120258808136,
0.6730763912200928,
0.5705284476280212,
0.01890229620039463,
-0.059933703392744064,
-0.16943685710430145,
0.4878070652484894,
-0.07520219683647156,
-0.8378804326057434,
-0.06959176808595657,
0.022950736805796623,
-0.17184260487556458,
-0.31525659561157227,
0.19813257455825806,
-0.5012057423591614,
-0.8414400815963745,
-0.35178133845329285,
0.6721860766410828,
-0.10239789634943008,
-0.147105872631073,
0.2860815227031708,
-0.1611769050359726,
0.1652146577835083,
0.4828976094722748,
-0.29928308725357056,
0.07594151794910431,
0.7933069467544556,
1.047615885734558,
0.042221371084451675,
0.2104121595621109,
-0.6749152541160583,
0.19629357755184174,
-0.3368467390537262,
0.9915468096733093,
-0.4125559329986572,
-0.01173828262835741,
0.034791022539138794,
0.16753259301185608,
0.06468799710273743,
-0.45502322912216187,
0.9640989303588867,
-0.6918403506278992,
0.23367823660373688,
-0.7164945006370544,
-0.7111986875534058,
-0.13992425799369812,
0.65240478515625,
-0.7070343494415283,
0.8523338437080383,
-0.020178211852908134,
-0.7739298343658447,
0.37715503573417664,
-0.581569254398346,
-0.5374608039855957,
0.18023191392421722,
-0.185435950756073,
-0.5273559093475342,
-0.09719754010438919,
0.36096689105033875,
0.40994682908058167,
-0.4692777693271637,
0.42756378650665283,
-0.49856358766555786,
-0.06528734415769577,
0.1879691481590271,
-0.43166476488113403,
0.7346394658088684,
0.2910882830619812,
-0.23244380950927734,
0.07877125591039658,
-0.6231777667999268,
-0.36971527338027954,
0.2682259678840637,
-0.5432308912277222,
-0.33901986479759216,
0.1466069221496582,
-0.09691541641950607,
0.22800888121128082,
0.45233023166656494,
-0.8960869312286377,
0.31247642636299133,
-0.08919193595647812,
0.4409165680408478,
0.5316187143325806,
0.03008390963077545,
-0.09483963996171951,
-0.7639288306236267,
0.08962273597717285,
-0.16649095714092255,
0.0733523890376091,
-0.04372241720557213,
-0.32467666268348694,
-0.5421321988105774,
-0.38845503330230713,
0.493338942527771,
0.8992535471916199,
-0.8468095064163208,
0.5256226062774658,
-0.5146797895431519,
-0.4645274579524994,
-0.4360538423061371,
-0.024434326216578484,
-0.08695738762617111,
0.8373384475708008,
0.3602921962738037,
0.005174021702259779,
-0.7655838131904602,
-0.8983071446418762,
-0.5389553904533386,
-0.23576590418815613,
-0.19079910218715668,
0.04755968600511551,
0.3431304693222046,
-0.2987511157989502,
0.9908558130264282,
-0.6151357293128967,
-0.22592584788799286,
0.06477909535169601,
0.0759982094168663,
0.14881835877895355,
0.12964875996112823,
0.4582492411136627,
-0.8612130284309387,
-0.6129535436630249,
-0.05163338780403137,
-0.7998804450035095,
-0.37702134251594543,
-0.021438565105199814,
0.32104572653770447,
0.09447720646858215,
0.3445846736431122,
-0.7754947543144226,
0.17268167436122894,
0.6931508779525757,
-0.46473708748817444,
0.41149795055389404,
-0.15162880718708038,
0.5417078733444214,
-1.0754351615905762,
-0.1752774566411972,
0.3086129128932953,
-0.6810499429702759,
-0.3828488886356354,
-0.22853250801563263,
0.2088124006986618,
0.07579583674669266,
-0.3098830580711365,
0.3849961459636688,
-0.40223228931427,
-0.006536518223583698,
-0.40558964014053345,
0.12530384957790375,
-0.0456022284924984,
-0.18698614835739136,
-0.12070778012275696,
0.8945562839508057,
0.5807704329490662,
-0.48815691471099854,
0.6397331357002258,
0.0005976124084554613,
-0.464058518409729,
0.680456280708313,
-0.6029269099235535,
0.00219379598274827,
-0.04856101796030998,
0.565980851650238,
-0.9344416260719299,
-0.608577311038971,
0.23358465731143951,
-0.4962840676307678,
-0.15664887428283691,
-0.2500300109386444,
-0.8698325157165527,
-0.4075794517993927,
-0.19999514520168304,
0.05661405250430107,
0.4255867302417755,
-0.6825379729270935,
0.8091434240341187,
0.5635724663734436,
-0.43438729643821716,
-0.4924166202545166,
-0.5571548938751221,
0.4878581166267395,
-0.09463264793157578,
-0.539170503616333,
0.31539997458457947,
0.06082843616604805,
-0.28976449370384216,
0.09493772685527802,
-0.2372870296239853,
-0.04235295578837395,
-0.03816724941134453,
0.08349140733480453,
0.38647356629371643,
-0.17356917262077332,
0.2212250828742981,
-0.132715106010437,
0.12025616317987442,
0.07651618868112564,
-0.21649013459682465,
0.2687723636627197,
-0.09091603755950928,
-0.7484639286994934,
-0.27644842863082886,
0.18443429470062256,
0.6513277888298035,
-0.05758296698331833,
0.49188125133514404,
0.49617958068847656,
-0.6597171425819397,
0.2656705975532532,
-1.0868299007415771,
-0.13238951563835144,
-0.4927818775177002,
0.33013901114463806,
0.11188831180334091,
-1.0363410711288452,
0.2202100306749344,
-0.09501742571592331,
-0.019148509949445724,
0.5363833904266357,
0.49940747022628784,
0.08157147467136383,
0.7828453183174133,
0.3865797519683838,
-0.37988173961639404,
0.23338961601257324,
0.3225141763687134,
0.25071054697036743,
-0.20051154494285583,
-0.0560501366853714,
-0.3281148672103882,
-0.008652524091303349,
-0.6158145070075989,
-0.5475673079490662,
0.5716707110404968,
-0.4024724066257477,
-0.18922050297260284,
0.17024372518062592,
-0.43134140968322754,
0.6503806710243225,
0.23913779854774475,
0.3960368037223816,
0.8098910450935364,
-0.09024565666913986,
0.27997663617134094,
0.2033565640449524,
-0.5682246685028076,
-0.5810927152633667,
0.9282600283622742,
0.36420565843582153,
0.8152234554290771,
0.34858807921409607,
0.3971490263938904,
0.7065750956535339,
0.8584824204444885,
-0.705259382724762,
0.5316188335418701,
-0.07361264526844025,
-0.7672587633132935,
-0.17935670912265778,
-0.5484411716461182,
-0.6615088582038879,
0.14967797696590424,
-0.5349035859107971,
-0.3884933888912201,
0.0066020432859659195,
0.37864628434181213,
-0.4470180869102478,
0.4380700886249542,
-0.5609020590782166,
0.39847898483276367,
-0.5438585877418518,
-0.14462579786777496,
-0.4135217070579529,
-0.4291193187236786,
0.5350902676582336,
-0.19729992747306824,
0.27700623869895935,
-0.24871523678302765,
0.09489938616752625,
0.4753867983818054,
-0.36612191796302795,
0.9093669652938843,
-0.01870265044271946,
-0.33438897132873535,
0.13979049026966095,
-0.11835203319787979,
0.6602599024772644,
0.1985405683517456,
0.11082719266414642,
-0.06683965027332306,
-0.008141821250319481,
-0.21228593587875366,
-0.39031973481178284,
0.7027006149291992,
-0.48748886585235596,
-0.6634127497673035,
-0.8669710755348206,
-0.5371250510215759,
-0.12420809268951416,
0.2936503291130066,
-0.10549312829971313,
0.258645236492157,
-0.5373359322547913,
0.026051724329590797,
0.936416745185852,
-0.09546038508415222,
0.02893320843577385,
0.9383397698402405,
-0.2661108076572418,
-0.44340816140174866,
0.886253833770752,
0.1822408139705658,
0.056587185710668564,
0.48660558462142944,
0.387714147567749,
-0.5805231332778931,
-0.3152223825454712,
-0.25055670738220215,
0.40104904770851135,
-0.6293623447418213,
-0.4354127049446106,
-0.8603512644767761,
-0.2889636158943176,
-0.6824418902397156,
0.16562119126319885,
-0.22469471395015717,
-0.27199307084083557,
0.23942089080810547,
-0.3129726052284241,
0.6059591770172119,
0.908706545829773,
-0.460190087556839,
0.2274187058210373,
-0.9107432961463928,
0.7799602150917053,
0.7629641890525818,
0.48184606432914734,
-0.6237558126449585,
-0.2812839448451996,
-0.1142759695649147,
0.24938233196735382,
-0.27981653809547424,
-0.9527671933174133,
-0.07015063613653183,
0.05892235040664673,
0.46090638637542725,
0.24991095066070557,
0.1811414361000061,
0.3945416212081909,
-0.514101505279541,
0.63018399477005,
0.09710798412561417,
-0.8061995506286621,
0.2913559079170227,
-0.34909647703170776,
-0.30423977971076965,
0.31167906522750854,
0.5522793531417847,
-0.6897304654121399,
-0.1559760421514511,
-0.6759611964225769,
-0.5268231630325317,
0.15789924561977386,
-0.11875874549150467,
-0.11178900301456451,
-0.1409061700105667,
0.25854432582855225,
-0.10549497604370117,
-0.0726495236158371,
-0.6902040839195251,
-0.03976976498961449,
-0.11521277576684952,
-0.38059183955192566,
-0.015773562714457512,
-0.3154405355453491,
-0.44267788529396057,
-0.17287026345729828,
0.8195653557777405,
-0.18154272437095642,
0.07066689431667328,
0.5562503933906555,
-0.3345036804676056,
-0.26538506150245667,
0.45252498984336853,
0.7120824456214905,
0.549162745475769,
-0.17126542329788208,
0.39654672145843506,
0.2544086277484894,
-0.45115214586257935,
0.3585702180862427,
0.379784494638443,
-0.4089392125606537,
0.19980990886688232,
0.18017029762268066,
0.5309731960296631,
-0.04168440029025078,
-0.5775834918022156,
0.6490692496299744,
0.04109078645706177,
-0.2546427249908447,
-0.1846182495355606,
-0.005477736704051495,
0.2813180685043335,
0.2290373593568802,
0.5368787050247192,
0.0834229588508606,
0.13353633880615234,
-0.6161660552024841,
0.5915547013282776,
0.6933092474937439,
-0.14168372750282288,
-0.14319221675395966,
0.47037091851234436,
0.2548733651638031,
-0.1743329018354416,
0.2319263219833374,
-0.12837092578411102,
-0.7073194980621338,
0.5027442574501038,
0.442050963640213,
0.6941453218460083,
-0.30413228273391724,
0.32723912596702576,
0.40905413031578064,
0.5756334066390991,
-0.5555069446563721,
0.02221217006444931,
0.4506688714027405,
-0.8286414742469788,
-0.9473299384117126,
-0.33691540360450745,
-0.441602885723114,
0.5242031216621399,
-0.23674248158931732,
0.3112946152687073,
-0.3131992518901825,
-0.12226100265979767,
0.07526438683271408,
-0.0824035108089447,
-0.6573876738548279,
0.2510596513748169,
0.2982357442378998,
0.942840039730072,
-1.3215210437774658,
0.7922955751419067,
0.5530388951301575,
-0.269587904214859,
-0.6790974736213684,
0.357959508895874,
0.394304484128952,
-0.9590743184089661,
0.5072225332260132,
0.04890231788158417,
-0.32266223430633545,
0.035411447286605835,
-0.8599916696548462,
-0.8570684194564819,
0.984999418258667,
0.8714084029197693,
-0.6041474938392639,
0.08747078478336334,
0.27784067392349243,
0.27605605125427246,
-0.2593264579772949,
-0.00627400167286396,
0.4584868848323822,
0.6323813796043396,
0.1676582545042038,
-1.178107500076294,
0.41856735944747925,
0.29326531291007996,
-0.4721784293651581,
-0.06410477310419083,
-0.5676680207252502,
0.5907366871833801,
-0.26504746079444885,
-0.3252975046634674,
-0.2758060395717621,
0.6231673359870911,
0.32867684960365295,
0.3030329942703247,
0.7975181341171265,
0.6584151983261108,
0.8962130546569824,
0.07070619612932205,
0.8537940979003906,
-0.2641432583332062,
0.6226856708526611,
1.1394550800323486,
-0.46920156478881836,
0.41407355666160583,
0.13169704377651215,
-0.26771819591522217,
0.3551165461540222,
0.7931671142578125,
-0.17066265642642975,
0.2729072570800781,
0.12543389201164246,
-0.41181421279907227,
-0.4217223525047302,
-0.38669392466545105,
-0.4197078049182892,
0.13826380670070648,
0.466400682926178,
-0.2697145342826843,
-0.45275816321372986,
-0.367581844329834,
0.1629776656627655,
0.047692012041807175,
-0.2355886548757553,
0.8174822330474854,
-0.13189448416233063,
-0.6586712002754211,
0.34961411356925964,
-0.13250429928302765,
0.7209435105323792,
-0.5195408463478088,
-0.25670525431632996,
0.14082278311252594,
-0.07941808551549911,
-0.3863420784473419,
-0.8520106673240662,
0.38130486011505127,
-0.02310260757803917,
-0.3410211205482483,
0.02624800056219101,
1.2169209718704224,
-0.7382947206497192,
-0.5504385232925415,
0.07235261052846909,
0.6817260384559631,
-0.11100565642118454,
-0.44454458355903625,
-0.7452609539031982,
-0.07388041913509369,
-0.17049261927604675,
0.11251495778560638,
0.13368424773216248,
0.4022851884365082,
-0.0518253929913044,
0.6693643927574158,
0.7350717782974243,
0.2435625046491623,
-0.26782146096229553,
0.05992388725280762,
0.8445450663566589,
-0.2948931157588959,
-0.3906574249267578,
-1.1444905996322632,
0.1226317510008812,
-0.40248793363571167,
0.45352602005004883,
0.7026089429855347,
0.807687520980835,
0.5780036449432373,
-0.03003755211830139,
1.4131344556808472,
-0.16951587796211243,
0.9722170233726501,
-0.4977717697620392,
0.8728121519088745,
-0.3147651255130768,
0.09348060935735703,
-0.12320748716592789,
-0.6406077742576599,
-0.275068461894989,
0.45219001173973083,
-0.4417409896850586,
-0.1568140983581543,
0.5198209881782532,
1.0951262712478638,
-0.28904008865356445,
-0.1638839840888977,
0.15677568316459656,
0.37318548560142517,
0.4265329837799072,
0.2404278814792633,
0.7612658739089966,
-0.258204847574234,
0.4295467436313629,
0.19971264898777008,
-0.39552342891693115,
-0.43218109011650085,
-1.3258823156356812,
-0.7042864561080933,
-0.3463941812515259,
-0.5739045739173889,
-0.6451134085655212,
0.1247800812125206,
1.2838951349258423,
0.5779874920845032,
-0.7694681286811829,
0.2513352036476135,
0.14081348478794098,
0.3310970366001129,
-0.08242665976285934,
-0.20921750366687775,
0.4730534255504608,
0.0505666546523571,
-0.3135434091091156,
0.32854965329170227,
0.1364353746175766,
0.11845847219228745,
-0.17479075491428375,
0.01996256411075592,
-0.2738937735557556,
0.3050350844860077,
0.6406510472297668,
0.2963545620441437,
-0.7029138803482056,
-0.5888468027114868,
-0.19744981825351715,
-0.3087941110134125,
0.07450700551271439,
1.038020133972168,
-0.6338820457458496,
0.13605879247188568,
0.4737948477268219,
0.9993521571159363,
0.26359426975250244,
0.1796567291021347,
0.425459086894989,
-0.6489765048027039,
-0.2791493833065033,
-0.036844462156295776,
0.5175305604934692,
0.7498074173927307,
-0.7168758511543274,
0.5906190276145935,
0.5729073286056519,
-0.5430440902709961,
-0.7852392196655273,
0.34090110659599304,
-1.0732483863830566,
-0.05144030228257179,
1.0586947202682495,
0.10597198456525803,
-0.10084612667560577,
-0.4165422022342682,
-0.18678563833236694,
0.40778738260269165,
-0.3659376800060272,
1.0912361145019531,
0.7340822815895081,
0.1213051825761795,
-0.14061178267002106,
-0.5753217339515686,
0.7450430989265442,
-0.03206261992454529,
-0.891150951385498,
0.1479293704032898,
0.4554716944694519,
0.7474097609519958,
0.18618062138557434,
0.8105273842811584,
-0.06610291451215744,
0.24200791120529175,
-0.35845446586608887,
0.041574541479349136,
-0.033928900957107544,
0.13836446404457092,
0.12968288362026215,
-0.048984672874212265,
-0.08203000575304031,
-0.05320082977414131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05889v2 | CREMA: Generalizable and Efficient Video-Language Reasoning via Multimodal Modular Fusion | 2024-02-08T18:27:22 | 2024-06-12T21:03:33 | Shoubin Yu, Jaehong Yoon, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite impressive advancements in recent multimodal reasoning approaches,
they are still limited in flexibility and efficiency, as these models typically
process only a few fixed modality inputs and require updates to numerous
parameters. This paper tackles these critical challenges and proposes CREMA, a
generalizable, highly efficient, and modular modality-fusion framework that can
incorporate any new modality to enhance video reasoning. We first augment
multiple informative modalities (such as optical flow, 3D point cloud, audio,
thermal heatmap, and touch map) from given videos without extra human
annotation by leveraging sensors or existing pre-trained models. Next, we
introduce a query transformer with multiple parameter-efficient modules
associated with each accessible modality. It projects diverse modality features
to the LLM token embedding space, allowing the model to integrate different
data types for response generation. Furthermore, we propose a novel progressive
multimodal fusion design supported by a lightweight fusion module and
modality-sequential training strategy. It helps compress information across
various assisting modalities, maintaining computational efficiency in the LLM
while improving performance. We validate our method on 7 video-language
reasoning tasks assisted by diverse modalities, including conventional VideoQA
and Video-Audio/3D/Touch/Thermal QA, and achieve better/equivalent performance
against strong multimodal LLMs, including OneLLM, BLIP-2, and SeViLA while
reducing over 90% trainable parameters. We provide extensive analyses of CREMA,
including the impact of each modality on reasoning domains, the design of the
fusion module, and example visualizations. | [
-0.3979001045227051,
-0.7500633001327515,
0.5096299648284912,
-0.011699655093252659,
-0.5186679363250732,
-0.14545029401779175,
-0.37066450715065,
-0.0959378182888031,
0.041984982788562775,
0.4589109420776367,
-0.583700954914093,
-0.6227526068687439,
-0.43303772807121277,
-0.22966346144676208,
-0.337027907371521,
0.4445676803588867,
-0.1139017790555954,
0.2968204915523529,
-0.40802252292633057,
-0.5283240675926208,
-0.37399137020111084,
-0.3858201205730438,
-0.019704364240169525,
-0.23115481436252594,
0.45354995131492615,
0.4076237380504608,
0.6482928991317749,
0.5117443799972534,
0.5680150389671326,
0.4335934519767761,
0.47042205929756165,
0.5369002819061279,
-0.1520548313856125,
0.4264496862888336,
-0.11440444737672806,
-0.2655448913574219,
-0.3831457793712616,
-0.5274789333343506,
0.5603132843971252,
0.39899587631225586,
-0.1514025628566742,
0.1550375372171402,
-0.428305447101593,
0.48040571808815,
-0.8922449350357056,
-0.0754477009177208,
-0.6272522211074829,
-0.09131717681884766,
-0.02447608858346939,
-0.2656088173389435,
-0.40574780106544495,
0.018169423565268517,
0.02299606241285801,
-0.5063697099685669,
0.3454309403896332,
-0.054215967655181885,
0.5301074981689453,
0.7213736772537231,
-0.5721231698989868,
0.15532438457012177,
-0.9073143005371094,
0.8036542534828186,
-0.4423152804374695,
1.0244063138961792,
0.2584112286567688,
0.5962375998497009,
0.23592449724674225,
-0.6023757457733154,
-0.6533075571060181,
-0.14628848433494568,
0.14300794899463654,
0.06755545735359192,
0.03455379977822304,
0.23575173318386078,
0.14897003769874573,
0.18477052450180054,
-0.9763950109481812,
-0.09141375869512558,
-0.10668904334306717,
-0.44097721576690674,
0.4938305616378784,
0.40938958525657654,
0.33291569352149963,
-0.14456671476364136,
-0.5335103273391724,
-0.038366660475730896,
-0.308600515127182,
0.033375296741724014,
0.1511523276567459,
-0.005830090027302504,
-0.19985370337963104,
0.6891607046127319,
-0.4411066770553589,
0.9231560230255127,
-0.22148264944553375,
-0.552933931350708,
0.22201839089393616,
-0.6463407874107361,
-0.6457051634788513,
-0.3105516731739044,
0.6800774931907654,
0.3007446825504303,
-0.24591012299060822,
0.06705262511968613,
0.12852999567985535,
0.41665297746658325,
0.1568196415901184,
-0.7185501456260681,
-0.36889412999153137,
0.3185877501964569,
-0.3846747577190399,
0.11390101909637451,
-0.07708151638507843,
-0.8540732860565186,
-0.11255908012390137,
-0.39610445499420166,
0.3488219976425171,
-0.6024584174156189,
-0.2648179829120636,
0.38737747073173523,
-0.2054852992296219,
0.4143063724040985,
0.6752917170524597,
-0.7882353067398071,
0.0442185252904892,
0.41876915097236633,
0.2586449086666107,
-0.016202522441744804,
-0.18923260271549225,
-0.41038405895233154,
0.5532897710800171,
0.2250509262084961,
0.9868587255477905,
-0.9622762203216553,
-0.24985335767269135,
0.17500032484531403,
-0.11956249922513962,
-0.2673374116420746,
-0.27610334753990173,
0.3592468798160553,
-0.3328808844089508,
0.5295209288597107,
-0.02543848194181919,
-0.16902199387550354,
-0.6877849102020264,
0.5524129271507263,
-0.5830090045928955,
0.7125142812728882,
-0.10920654982328415,
-0.31485989689826965,
0.4400051236152649,
-0.5193901062011719,
-0.450353741645813,
-0.003270588116720319,
-0.42935067415237427,
-0.20195387303829193,
-0.28323280811309814,
0.18736666440963745,
0.2794589698314667,
-0.6313366889953613,
0.22847338020801544,
-0.2689586877822876,
0.03867980092763901,
0.16566002368927002,
-0.5796847939491272,
0.0824662446975708,
0.1609930396080017,
-0.34710341691970825,
0.38302239775657654,
-0.557546079158783,
0.11097481101751328,
-0.3009692430496216,
-0.3287920653820038,
0.1395038515329361,
-0.11811625212430954,
-0.19027119874954224,
0.1917383223772049,
-0.034565918147563934,
-0.2570422887802124,
0.275145024061203,
0.17180468142032623,
0.37325313687324524,
0.370226114988327,
-0.11908125132322311,
0.7519083619117737,
-0.14077362418174744,
0.528779923915863,
0.10590188950300217,
0.44223833084106445,
-0.44336917996406555,
-0.4127967953681946,
-0.7311168313026428,
-0.8397548198699951,
0.01758871227502823,
0.6144257187843323,
-1.0242058038711548,
-0.10046978294849396,
-0.14638157188892365,
-0.5289364457130432,
-0.39252766966819763,
0.42043906450271606,
0.3970799148082733,
0.5430078506469727,
0.48128852248191833,
-0.27070853114128113,
-0.48127028346061707,
-1.2018040418624878,
0.028431177139282227,
-0.22237682342529297,
-0.0235332902520895,
0.3608132004737854,
0.20169495046138763,
-0.23769456148147583,
0.6835542321205139,
-0.4816325902938843,
-0.35107219219207764,
-0.4454628825187683,
-0.014577296562492847,
-0.1834724098443985,
0.40412747859954834,
0.415079802274704,
-1.0695894956588745,
0.07657592743635178,
0.0369863361120224,
-0.8691173195838928,
0.06834950298070908,
-0.3493753671646118,
-0.16118104755878448,
0.2971165180206299,
-0.016196252778172493,
-0.8645513653755188,
0.3506937026977539,
0.4330616295337677,
-0.20481666922569275,
0.55916827917099,
-0.021296439692378044,
0.8224511742591858,
-0.7831102609634399,
-0.07313238084316254,
0.20204463601112366,
-0.15041260421276093,
-0.655823826789856,
0.03594599664211273,
-0.11328227072954178,
-0.1934186965227127,
-0.7755550146102905,
0.4401216208934784,
-0.26717597246170044,
0.152798593044281,
-0.02325998619198799,
0.2305607944726944,
0.2549806237220764,
0.7646378874778748,
0.1256457269191742,
0.44005852937698364,
0.7080686092376709,
-0.6890222430229187,
0.6310272812843323,
0.20036233961582184,
-0.07606019824743271,
0.48886120319366455,
-0.2727651596069336,
-0.08574067801237106,
-0.14481085538864136,
0.42130470275878906,
-1.1378567218780518,
-0.5980029702186584,
0.4012868106365204,
-0.4066045880317688,
0.17394614219665527,
-0.2741432785987854,
-0.2842308580875397,
-0.133330300450325,
-0.20934361219406128,
0.9240666031837463,
0.4501892328262329,
-0.2586230933666229,
1.3656229972839355,
0.26586994528770447,
0.22277311980724335,
-0.47097358107566833,
-0.6519297361373901,
-0.2049591988325119,
-0.2748136818408966,
-1.1716697216033936,
0.35012122988700867,
-0.2560868561267853,
-0.22600048780441284,
-0.044649865478277206,
-0.2152407318353653,
-0.5171444416046143,
-0.2400137484073639,
0.23960742354393005,
0.2783556878566742,
-0.1038467213511467,
0.14048732817173004,
0.08636876940727234,
-0.043086107820272446,
-0.2183607965707779,
-0.1030765026807785,
0.6572772860527039,
-0.07533323764801025,
-0.7510044574737549,
-0.6912433505058289,
0.5545547008514404,
0.646442711353302,
-0.2327692061662674,
0.1352073848247528,
0.9531089663505554,
-0.33579397201538086,
0.019484419375658035,
-0.9965230822563171,
-0.15194453299045563,
-0.4535983204841614,
0.3375810384750366,
-0.35783225297927856,
-0.9206895232200623,
0.4632399380207062,
-0.022270390763878822,
0.015554839745163918,
0.1386788934469223,
1.095566987991333,
0.0944799855351448,
1.1811033487319946,
0.3151650130748749,
0.38873642683029175,
0.45244961977005005,
-0.38925492763519287,
0.042631104588508606,
-0.4632508456707001,
-0.806333601474762,
-0.2755231559276581,
-0.40330231189727783,
-0.05017362907528877,
-1.0014042854309082,
0.5507873892784119,
-0.18213772773742676,
-0.13370944559574127,
0.29230043292045593,
-0.3172168433666229,
0.33110982179641724,
0.2843624949455261,
0.20961004495620728,
0.30638670921325684,
-0.16848689317703247,
0.04198336973786354,
0.045739248394966125,
-0.8403449654579163,
-0.27297067642211914,
0.4616839587688446,
0.1139116957783699,
0.8183393478393555,
0.39111220836639404,
0.2058427482843399,
0.38052159547805786,
0.055719755589962006,
-0.7364626526832581,
0.8935096263885498,
0.13197220861911774,
-0.5438722968101501,
-0.09355432540178299,
-0.30034545063972473,
-0.6033754348754883,
0.5211181640625,
-0.3470659852027893,
-0.41899144649505615,
0.0656004250049591,
0.3019169569015503,
-0.2221977710723877,
0.35382258892059326,
-0.7836707830429077,
0.7496717572212219,
-0.31228816509246826,
-0.6335459351539612,
-0.5853143334388733,
-0.7076190710067749,
0.795973539352417,
0.3554883897304535,
0.36770331859588623,
-0.21547923982143402,
-0.2515365183353424,
0.2926483452320099,
-0.31277960538864136,
0.7133403420448303,
-0.16811178624629974,
0.17993031442165375,
0.4276883900165558,
0.41589927673339844,
-0.0411258228123188,
0.23329435288906097,
0.09427893161773682,
0.16703559458255768,
-0.16128131747245789,
-0.42067041993141174,
-0.8146989941596985,
0.5603383779525757,
-0.3985612094402313,
-0.7145875692367554,
-0.09015198051929474,
-0.6533389687538147,
-0.2728249132633209,
-0.04829051345586777,
-0.013428316451609135,
0.7887921929359436,
0.15957330167293549,
0.1923135668039322,
0.6374530792236328,
-0.08764371275901794,
0.4289887547492981,
0.3245697021484375,
0.01677454449236393,
-0.9119874835014343,
0.8937511444091797,
-0.31911489367485046,
0.39650627970695496,
0.5130866765975952,
-0.0611409991979599,
-0.2504918575286865,
-0.4537276327610016,
-0.84950852394104,
0.13905057311058044,
-0.7635274529457092,
-0.49323463439941406,
-0.6820995211601257,
0.2015029489994049,
-0.40176963806152344,
-0.27220818400382996,
-0.2520523965358734,
-0.5183823108673096,
-0.06696008890867233,
-0.011191575787961483,
0.10883557051420212,
0.11671224236488342,
0.01652630977332592,
0.12040691822767258,
-1.043557047843933,
0.5191650390625,
0.5706806182861328,
0.13341373205184937,
-0.14713674783706665,
-0.2866842448711395,
-0.07121582329273224,
0.0034754506777971983,
-0.39384225010871887,
-0.8222536444664001,
0.1771310567855835,
0.2605719268321991,
0.8024295568466187,
0.4650628864765167,
-0.16336670517921448,
0.8211355805397034,
-0.26941120624542236,
1.1865233182907104,
0.6273664832115173,
-0.8476186394691467,
0.4681347608566284,
-0.3139181435108185,
0.19250522553920746,
0.5117889642715454,
0.3255428969860077,
-0.2491547167301178,
-0.04642464965581894,
-0.47070446610450745,
-0.7400029897689819,
0.07857881486415863,
-0.033789291977882385,
0.06983397901058197,
-0.017874859273433685,
-0.04761171713471413,
0.378452330827713,
0.15583941340446472,
-0.35808423161506653,
-0.00539106409996748,
-0.5204115509986877,
-0.11793582886457443,
0.5059102177619934,
-0.12772423028945923,
-0.33005619049072266,
-0.4751771092414856,
0.506618082523346,
-0.34764528274536133,
0.16913151741027832,
0.3630415201187134,
-0.47972872853279114,
0.05866990238428116,
0.2505556643009186,
1.0644451379776,
0.5923560261726379,
0.14099270105361938,
0.2335420697927475,
0.3069584369659424,
-0.10985303670167923,
0.15688784420490265,
-0.26095613837242126,
0.2421368658542633,
0.046726323664188385,
0.4538162350654602,
0.7410318851470947,
0.43455514311790466,
-1.0262751579284668,
0.45605286955833435,
-0.09323906898498535,
-0.5107620358467102,
-0.22089490294456482,
0.1917150467634201,
-0.11152596771717072,
0.510678231716156,
0.20020097494125366,
0.2062748372554779,
0.2531389892101288,
-0.5579013824462891,
0.3464360237121582,
0.5278693437576294,
-0.25951701402664185,
-0.5213372111320496,
0.708604633808136,
0.40461280941963196,
-0.31658971309661865,
0.3026183843612671,
0.09169729053974152,
-0.6237182021141052,
0.13774512708187103,
0.1058291420340538,
0.7293307781219482,
-0.1530766785144806,
0.41010454297065735,
0.1511302888393402,
0.09532643109560013,
0.09752022475004196,
0.37833908200263977,
-0.4185777008533478,
-0.5917441844940186,
-0.6383195519447327,
-0.3246499001979828,
-0.5138147473335266,
-0.3432901203632355,
-0.32065221667289734,
0.4658645689487457,
-0.3431384861469269,
-0.07489234954118729,
-0.21962784230709076,
-0.45913952589035034,
-0.944510817527771,
0.23559516668319702,
0.3552515506744385,
0.9658870697021484,
-0.6774550676345825,
0.6553947925567627,
0.6516878008842468,
-0.5459365248680115,
-0.4215781092643738,
-0.4799903631210327,
0.07868445664644241,
-0.8328595757484436,
0.5170300006866455,
-0.031856413930654526,
-0.22048000991344452,
-0.4410991966724396,
-0.3692476153373718,
-0.5073171854019165,
1.2404881715774536,
0.5619412660598755,
-0.21330545842647552,
-0.050304532051086426,
0.3527320921421051,
0.23450535535812378,
-0.4694685637950897,
0.4982467591762543,
0.40241333842277527,
0.669802725315094,
0.5333207845687866,
-0.8413585424423218,
-0.07835023105144501,
-0.13365715742111206,
-0.36891448497772217,
0.3106530010700226,
-0.7508326172828674,
0.4993025064468384,
-0.32166558504104614,
-0.007579500786960125,
-0.06958328932523727,
0.5650955438613892,
0.10279642790555954,
0.5021551251411438,
0.5863122940063477,
0.836727499961853,
0.447180837392807,
-0.056331850588321686,
0.900535523891449,
-0.2202172726392746,
0.054568540304899216,
0.7194148898124695,
-0.33002546429634094,
0.44410398602485657,
0.527152955532074,
0.2580716013908386,
0.7713083028793335,
0.3135021924972534,
0.11801431328058243,
0.44636428356170654,
-0.055320437997579575,
-0.6558723449707031,
-1.1197627782821655,
-0.1959763914346695,
-0.23595018684864044,
0.7540004253387451,
0.34344741702079773,
-0.18703442811965942,
-0.5295026302337646,
0.23659533262252808,
-0.2534342110157013,
0.10349330306053162,
-0.19545744359493256,
0.8485776782035828,
-0.1085340678691864,
-0.4598822295665741,
0.4873846769332886,
-0.2604474723339081,
0.414533793926239,
-0.7271922826766968,
-0.15867623686790466,
-0.01848018169403076,
-0.055302564054727554,
-0.4200058877468109,
-0.5085723400115967,
0.20979319512844086,
-0.20319201052188873,
-0.3203337788581848,
-0.19284488260746002,
0.9027033448219299,
-0.7262976169586182,
-0.2156921923160553,
-0.07864081114530563,
0.7562284469604492,
0.018338697031140327,
0.12683051824569702,
-0.6005926132202148,
0.5661369562149048,
-0.010119902901351452,
-0.18059290945529938,
0.46541574597358704,
0.28216448426246643,
0.08283515274524689,
1.0026787519454956,
0.7585992813110352,
-0.2579372227191925,
-0.06419109553098679,
0.20083270967006683,
1.1400078535079956,
-0.6463512182235718,
-0.01793677918612957,
-0.8418064117431641,
0.9142392873764038,
-0.009567624889314175,
-0.1938423067331314,
0.41427117586135864,
0.627136766910553,
0.5870082378387451,
-0.11347859352827072,
0.7288594841957092,
-0.07566482573747635,
-0.026933539658784866,
-0.7120828032493591,
0.025830985978245735,
-0.5737083554267883,
0.16479283571243286,
0.058787520974874496,
-0.8145869970321655,
-0.5707778930664062,
0.3492531180381775,
-0.2105419635772705,
-0.1604221612215042,
0.7062743902206421,
0.8362465500831604,
-0.1172596737742424,
0.14449746906757355,
0.495276540517807,
-0.1860552281141281,
0.6090101003646851,
0.5973138213157654,
0.7687950730323792,
-0.25137388706207275,
0.7819520831108093,
-0.22148491442203522,
-0.1651695817708969,
-0.2624182403087616,
-0.8959382772445679,
-0.7054181098937988,
-0.6583414077758789,
-0.451285183429718,
-0.23628681898117065,
-0.1625216156244278,
1.0697405338287354,
0.9217313528060913,
-0.31220605969429016,
-0.05576488748192787,
0.4745030403137207,
0.27486416697502136,
-0.13214297592639923,
-0.22599460184574127,
-0.013053441420197487,
-0.19765342772006989,
-0.6701964735984802,
0.5612896680831909,
0.5069514513015747,
-0.3596605956554413,
-0.5842059850692749,
-0.06876002997159958,
-0.0601479671895504,
0.08690813928842545,
0.7895973324775696,
0.2646057903766632,
-0.8905398845672607,
-0.6544868350028992,
0.07385315746068954,
0.1611950546503067,
0.07378589361906052,
1.2061759233474731,
-0.9216364026069641,
0.42917710542678833,
0.8644289374351501,
0.6604697108268738,
0.392320841550827,
0.06302745640277863,
0.5921573042869568,
-0.41454562544822693,
0.27842047810554504,
0.5128777027130127,
0.6129494905471802,
0.29678210616111755,
-0.05767324939370155,
0.352567583322525,
0.5852139592170715,
-0.5092599391937256,
-0.9010603427886963,
0.6876925826072693,
-1.717393398284912,
-0.10518726706504822,
1.380507230758667,
0.20597843825817108,
-0.33283212780952454,
-0.1262683868408203,
-0.3488162159919739,
0.08406560122966766,
-0.42709779739379883,
0.5019121170043945,
0.3694594204425812,
-0.49378398060798645,
-0.4855976104736328,
-0.28399062156677246,
0.2837243378162384,
0.5426235198974609,
-0.6299537420272827,
0.021810607984662056,
0.8294155597686768,
0.3294733166694641,
-0.0036749474238604307,
0.5251616835594177,
-0.025984106585383415,
0.5679153203964233,
-0.06842383742332458,
0.08825758099555969,
-0.4612840414047241,
-0.5482082366943359,
0.04884845390915871,
0.5424580574035645,
-0.40158507227897644,
-0.13806556165218353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05880v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05880v2 | Generative Echo Chamber? Effects of LLM-Powered Search Systems on Diverse Information Seeking | 2024-02-08T18:14:33 | 2024-02-10T17:03:58 | Nikhil Sharma, Q. Vera Liao, Ziang Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) powered conversational search systems have
already been used by hundreds of millions of people, and are believed to bring
many benefits over conventional search. However, while decades of research and
public discourse interrogated the risk of search systems in increasing
selective exposure and creating echo chambers -- limiting exposure to diverse
opinions and leading to opinion polarization, little is known about such a risk
of LLM-powered conversational search. We conduct two experiments to
investigate: 1) whether and how LLM-powered conversational search increases
selective exposure compared to conventional search; 2) whether and how LLMs
with opinion biases that either reinforce or challenge the user's view change
the effect. Overall, we found that participants engaged in more biased
information querying with LLM-powered conversational search, and an opinionated
LLM reinforcing their views exacerbated this bias. These results present
critical implications for the development of LLMs and conversational search
systems, and the policy governing these technologies. | [
-0.5107902884483337,
-0.5991183519363403,
0.8938860893249512,
-0.03094835951924324,
-0.2609362006187439,
0.1698511391878128,
-0.10147774964570999,
-0.5062568783760071,
0.3990011513233185,
0.5642725825309753,
-0.46753212809562683,
-0.4210003912448883,
-0.6465813517570496,
0.10381906479597092,
-0.6386162638664246,
0.7449597716331482,
0.3216579556465149,
0.1341477632522583,
-0.018266435712575912,
0.2514090836048126,
-0.3652413785457611,
-0.9292669892311096,
-0.30108436942100525,
-0.14736688137054443,
0.6458458304405212,
0.27014023065567017,
1.0309982299804688,
0.11206931620836258,
0.5230103731155396,
0.18982507288455963,
-0.3526344299316406,
-0.07534365355968475,
-0.8020921945571899,
0.5320390462875366,
-0.20874248445034027,
-0.837415337562561,
-0.1824762523174286,
-0.038956169039011,
0.7066750526428223,
0.5504106879234314,
-0.3037385642528534,
-0.10820672661066055,
0.25955674052238464,
0.7199035882949829,
-0.6362700462341309,
-0.22373951971530914,
-0.9603132009506226,
0.13839684426784515,
-0.3265171945095062,
-0.6479286551475525,
-0.42883238196372986,
-0.24643293023109436,
0.1822892129421234,
-0.5571306943893433,
0.3584982454776764,
0.1951836794614792,
0.448702335357666,
0.1670413315296173,
-0.5293012261390686,
-0.48846864700317383,
-0.9931548833847046,
0.8942014575004578,
-0.3779105842113495,
0.42134347558021545,
0.10752946138381958,
0.004082072991877794,
-0.17170624434947968,
-0.611795961856842,
-0.5093180537223816,
0.003916110377758741,
0.1506265550851822,
0.16761963069438934,
-0.4890252947807312,
0.23135586082935333,
0.22717563807964325,
0.4122002124786377,
-0.4223922789096832,
0.12089575082063675,
-0.4038764536380768,
0.03085208870470524,
0.5473154187202454,
0.2561343312263489,
0.16168347001075745,
-0.21240873634815216,
-0.12228040397167206,
-0.10938505828380585,
-0.9062021970748901,
-0.05804600566625595,
0.6714032888412476,
0.32125571370124817,
0.31222933530807495,
0.685879111289978,
-0.32654857635498047,
0.44522276520729065,
0.07148561626672745,
0.11924870312213898,
0.01999916136264801,
-0.32677531242370605,
-0.0033227354288101196,
0.2620396912097931,
0.49913904070854187,
0.4580517113208771,
0.1048271432518959,
-0.061429642140865326,
-0.21517644822597504,
-0.2469613403081894,
0.4616081416606903,
-0.7764846086502075,
0.3607710897922516,
0.09979657828807831,
-0.7168845534324646,
-0.5080586075782776,
0.43401384353637695,
-0.8375110626220703,
-0.7206059098243713,
-0.014935819432139397,
0.4527454972267151,
0.1825573444366455,
-0.23773539066314697,
0.25515061616897583,
-0.3394469618797302,
0.2657284140586853,
0.20029975473880768,
-0.7860040068626404,
0.5432551503181458,
0.6610454320907593,
0.8321660757064819,
-0.23207680881023407,
0.18208695948123932,
-0.3073246479034424,
-0.24095918238162994,
-0.22873377799987793,
0.7504833340644836,
-0.8164185285568237,
-0.9510990977287292,
0.3386768698692322,
-0.06619510799646378,
0.21194729208946228,
-0.9519258141517639,
0.5170878171920776,
-0.858365535736084,
0.3265742361545563,
-0.4992014765739441,
-0.41266417503356934,
-0.06391213089227676,
0.023234818130731583,
-0.4581625461578369,
0.631047785282135,
-0.2699144780635834,
-0.5494078993797302,
0.2133769541978836,
-0.3267015814781189,
-0.42101773619651794,
0.03247680887579918,
-0.4255363941192627,
-0.3077758252620697,
0.30795174837112427,
0.34321731328964233,
0.15126006305217743,
-0.3046410083770752,
0.07601690292358398,
-0.41041475534439087,
-0.5144680142402649,
0.636387050151825,
-0.6112233400344849,
0.5315098166465759,
0.03728180378675461,
-0.747791588306427,
-0.11264665424823761,
-0.12322044372558594,
-0.1384800523519516,
0.2944052517414093,
-0.39795368909835815,
-0.2061420977115631,
0.2830950617790222,
-0.056212421506643295,
0.1219744011759758,
0.19032494723796844,
-0.575069785118103,
0.06210384517908096,
-0.22555257380008698,
0.07850687950849533,
0.8750090599060059,
0.083245649933815,
0.2679537832736969,
-0.6031246781349182,
0.6909254789352417,
0.02022184617817402,
0.30028554797172546,
-0.16656561195850372,
-0.7188933491706848,
-0.6827767491340637,
0.21146167814731598,
-0.0933375209569931,
0.399436891078949,
-0.3698573708534241,
0.36038827896118164,
0.044844601303339005,
-0.2057933509349823,
-0.6880130171775818,
0.06530731171369553,
0.03285931050777435,
0.15897907316684723,
0.13599354028701782,
-0.2482645958662033,
-0.436462938785553,
-1.0673786401748657,
-0.4283577799797058,
-0.19871442019939423,
-0.32624536752700806,
1.0481404066085815,
0.010848641395568848,
-0.26792341470718384,
0.6434201598167419,
-0.5198317170143127,
-0.5205516219139099,
-0.21555499732494354,
-0.08595693856477737,
0.3796994090080261,
-0.11987223476171494,
0.256118506193161,
-0.9612573385238647,
-0.2001940757036209,
-0.2617916166782379,
-0.6141723990440369,
-0.4395442008972168,
0.1226460412144661,
0.16552817821502686,
-0.14571407437324524,
0.3506040573120117,
-0.6528257727622986,
0.2960638701915741,
0.6581754088401794,
0.21025371551513672,
0.4596419632434845,
0.2674298882484436,
0.30629977583885193,
-0.8577617406845093,
0.019071277230978012,
-0.12782861292362213,
-0.01768704317510128,
-0.5683557391166687,
0.021826433017849922,
-0.309431254863739,
-0.2446717470884323,
-0.34872737526893616,
0.2945336401462555,
-0.4285477101802826,
-0.22314290702342987,
-0.6327309012413025,
0.5151622891426086,
0.0890883207321167,
-0.010412720963358879,
0.031800396740436554,
0.8965297937393188,
0.5842157602310181,
-0.6289058327674866,
0.23069345951080322,
0.06293735653162003,
-0.40862083435058594,
0.1922309696674347,
-0.42569082975387573,
0.44684913754463196,
-0.11319698393344879,
0.4501381516456604,
-0.8088135719299316,
-0.13951559364795685,
-0.18683269619941711,
-0.30215027928352356,
0.0066871135495603085,
0.13873007893562317,
-0.37657469511032104,
-0.24837657809257507,
-0.4688993990421295,
0.5442381501197815,
0.4683842360973358,
-0.7585150599479675,
0.4394359290599823,
0.5585945248603821,
-0.5884770154953003,
-0.5824536085128784,
-0.4929511249065399,
0.48170652985572815,
-0.17545248568058014,
-0.5373426675796509,
0.4394261837005615,
0.05991143733263016,
-0.6129924654960632,
-0.14396430552005768,
-0.05714089795947075,
0.3164224922657013,
0.15043918788433075,
0.3410370349884033,
0.24346624314785004,
0.0311441607773304,
0.46041440963745117,
-0.22400717437267303,
0.1128162294626236,
0.11078780889511108,
-0.16193747520446777,
0.8479558229446411,
-0.28072303533554077,
-0.727915346622467,
-0.2498890459537506,
0.6071451306343079,
0.42213305830955505,
0.15282538533210754,
0.6404137015342712,
0.07061559706926346,
-0.16931548714637756,
-0.08340690284967422,
-0.8909675478935242,
-0.621988832950592,
-0.526124119758606,
0.4037766456604004,
0.10839420557022095,
-1.2279304265975952,
0.38832101225852966,
-0.06242721527814865,
-0.17144380509853363,
0.32937321066856384,
0.9278358817100525,
-0.38659289479255676,
1.324738621711731,
0.51189124584198,
-0.19064901769161224,
0.704581618309021,
0.07037104666233063,
0.38679105043411255,
-0.8986645936965942,
-0.2646818459033966,
-0.6554645299911499,
-0.4885006546974182,
-0.9447697997093201,
-0.08989524096250534,
0.7005242705345154,
-0.25242099165916443,
0.2518201768398285,
-0.4312784671783447,
-0.7122305035591125,
0.2307654470205307,
0.6682836413383484,
0.4763195216655731,
0.5362685322761536,
0.05173647776246071,
0.18961463868618011,
-0.1134357899427414,
-0.6424242854118347,
-0.4506540894508362,
1.4859161376953125,
0.2183166891336441,
1.1210098266601562,
0.21818937361240387,
0.5632641315460205,
0.30622267723083496,
0.23521459102630615,
-0.9346784949302673,
0.49863797426223755,
0.021605180576443672,
-1.0462818145751953,
-0.1950305551290512,
-0.346295565366745,
-1.10454523563385,
0.23191621899604797,
-0.11561335623264313,
-0.645882785320282,
0.34775468707084656,
-0.06687565892934799,
-0.09282634407281876,
0.49886125326156616,
-0.33677878975868225,
0.01620844379067421,
-0.5888919234275818,
-0.37076321244239807,
-0.5919796228408813,
-0.378632515668869,
0.3685908615589142,
-0.21884594857692719,
0.1651071012020111,
0.15994802117347717,
0.149185448884964,
0.7140069007873535,
0.024811463430523872,
0.7787245512008667,
-0.030638670548796654,
0.07956358045339584,
0.2635936141014099,
0.03378668427467346,
0.5416781306266785,
0.001658526947721839,
-0.12962374091148376,
0.23788072168827057,
-0.5004764199256897,
-0.18365836143493652,
-0.5361855626106262,
0.6655849814414978,
-0.6534808278083801,
-1.4423067569732666,
-0.42340087890625,
-0.482683390378952,
0.015310592018067837,
0.18500950932502747,
0.30087071657180786,
0.050783079117536545,
-0.3387131094932556,
0.7244998812675476,
0.8433247804641724,
-0.22883090376853943,
0.026446538046002388,
0.44455739855766296,
-0.46851620078086853,
-0.12277762591838837,
0.4404680132865906,
0.2292863130569458,
0.36783844232559204,
0.2829691171646118,
0.20063284039497375,
-0.15402451157569885,
-0.5221748352050781,
0.08706152439117432,
-0.012222710065543652,
-0.49047499895095825,
0.05295103043317795,
-0.5764340758323669,
-0.29857420921325684,
-0.32973530888557434,
0.06394734233617783,
-0.2659429907798767,
-0.07007114589214325,
-0.4655474126338959,
-0.13570360839366913,
-0.017707010731101036,
0.7701708674430847,
0.14766713976860046,
0.2272779941558838,
-0.3808458745479584,
0.16831877827644348,
0.6894465684890747,
0.3644283711910248,
-0.23048290610313416,
-0.4682439863681793,
-0.11950241029262543,
0.03289986401796341,
-0.624320924282074,
-0.9240695238113403,
0.15607906877994537,
-0.10317260771989822,
0.675757884979248,
0.5088933110237122,
0.10262453556060791,
0.15108053386211395,
-0.12854483723640442,
0.9413222074508667,
0.04173048958182335,
-0.44239190220832825,
0.48235148191452026,
-0.41942861676216125,
0.32091018557548523,
0.37631160020828247,
0.24675071239471436,
-0.6093798279762268,
-0.4172493815422058,
-0.6485161185264587,
-0.7094240188598633,
0.502710223197937,
0.30567464232444763,
0.338937908411026,
0.07126832753419876,
0.12740442156791687,
0.12775807082653046,
0.565726101398468,
-0.7046594023704529,
-0.13976897299289703,
-0.10446540266275406,
0.2525523602962494,
0.14040794968605042,
-0.5177938342094421,
-0.37861958146095276,
0.12373427301645279,
0.6462984085083008,
0.05845371633768082,
0.26291993260383606,
0.48954659700393677,
0.2341870367527008,
-0.2602735161781311,
0.5771046876907349,
0.3722488284111023,
0.209609255194664,
-0.4634493291378021,
0.30290916562080383,
0.04932629317045212,
-0.45298704504966736,
0.21421577036380768,
0.020119983702898026,
-0.3898560106754303,
0.0925484225153923,
0.0016961267683655024,
0.7837415337562561,
-0.016846509650349617,
-0.7501934170722961,
0.4971976578235626,
-0.14697995781898499,
-0.14642766118049622,
-0.2781234085559845,
0.09947983175516129,
0.12121272087097168,
0.29605576395988464,
0.709746778011322,
-0.1373027116060257,
0.43044313788414,
-0.7906211614608765,
-0.0661352202296257,
0.9538742303848267,
-0.36272767186164856,
-0.06642705202102661,
0.45800480246543884,
0.2485998421907425,
-0.6461072564125061,
0.43214231729507446,
0.2224302738904953,
-0.470208078622818,
0.346178263425827,
0.5316973328590393,
1.2450206279754639,
-0.2908962666988373,
-0.04115738719701767,
-0.1974329948425293,
0.5334398150444031,
0.09474173933267593,
0.024820512160658836,
-0.11956868320703506,
-0.8746419548988342,
0.210220068693161,
-0.38456520438194275,
-0.8532621264457703,
0.30931997299194336,
-0.6611647605895996,
0.0026077155489474535,
-0.18715807795524597,
-0.6028656363487244,
-0.2986283004283905,
-0.07559406757354736,
-0.7420264482498169,
-0.15049569308757782,
0.3153018355369568,
0.6117492914199829,
-0.4771879017353058,
0.31769469380378723,
0.4807131886482239,
-0.08904222398996353,
-0.3525601327419281,
0.41698163747787476,
0.28696373105049133,
-0.7824506163597107,
0.5370833277702332,
0.19613900780677795,
-0.5017797350883484,
-0.17370755970478058,
-0.6903948187828064,
-0.9955229163169861,
1.09244704246521,
0.3327082097530365,
-0.8165255188941956,
0.0722552016377449,
0.37911948561668396,
0.4801092743873596,
-0.5010208487510681,
0.337027370929718,
0.5701876282691956,
0.33513492345809937,
-0.16244618594646454,
-1.0100992918014526,
-0.14992213249206543,
-0.18718872964382172,
-0.13693282008171082,
-0.1286599487066269,
-0.8264545798301697,
0.6582403779029846,
-0.027237221598625183,
-0.40281984210014343,
-0.10592038184404373,
0.05249432474374771,
0.5112879872322083,
0.4155696928501129,
0.4651404023170471,
0.3158548176288605,
0.6653314828872681,
0.06675918400287628,
1.2550973892211914,
-0.2727275490760803,
0.16971717774868011,
0.6647729277610779,
-0.6200810670852661,
0.7933001518249512,
0.6089559197425842,
-0.19940686225891113,
0.4071698784828186,
0.41529884934425354,
0.2149890810251236,
0.4863198399543762,
0.1569993644952774,
-0.7305330634117126,
-0.19623732566833496,
-0.5373186469078064,
-0.3948178291320801,
0.235983744263649,
0.4965004324913025,
-0.6758861541748047,
0.00825425423681736,
-0.0718035101890564,
-0.07732387632131577,
-0.011087784543633461,
-0.13235168159008026,
0.812538206577301,
0.3329283893108368,
-0.57215815782547,
0.25810566544532776,
-0.25639551877975464,
0.7279016375541687,
-0.3650946319103241,
0.33666497468948364,
-0.17981316149234772,
-0.10407022386789322,
-0.2969638705253601,
-0.9361807107925415,
-0.12979178130626678,
0.025661572813987732,
-0.20960834622383118,
-0.2068486213684082,
0.9813143610954285,
0.045342497527599335,
-0.4052942395210266,
0.6549206376075745,
0.7518720626831055,
0.19914719462394714,
-0.3279781937599182,
-0.4945339560508728,
0.14587989449501038,
0.11699648201465607,
-0.6576300859451294,
0.4844837486743927,
-0.04091161862015724,
0.2337140589952469,
0.7321903109550476,
0.7826481461524963,
0.23807641863822937,
0.13656647503376007,
0.31358739733695984,
1.2105332612991333,
-0.7356113791465759,
-0.20608286559581757,
-0.6713835597038269,
-0.010514117777347565,
-0.12951457500457764,
0.031834326684474945,
0.5211585164070129,
0.6216521859169006,
0.7734531164169312,
0.31114140152931213,
1.2220369577407837,
0.3090824484825134,
0.39948683977127075,
-0.5379281640052795,
0.5487374067306519,
-0.4681808054447174,
0.5717202425003052,
-0.06324505060911179,
-1.200768232345581,
-0.18127098679542542,
0.21247270703315735,
-0.48088669776916504,
0.32371798157691956,
0.5836413502693176,
1.164483666419983,
0.14766553044319153,
0.12661363184452057,
0.30606403946876526,
0.4130476415157318,
0.6014389395713806,
0.2622681260108948,
1.113404393196106,
-0.13577581942081451,
0.7239586710929871,
0.011224394664168358,
-0.39459842443466187,
-0.5933319330215454,
-0.40536293387413025,
-0.5046061873435974,
-0.30028313398361206,
0.1332985907793045,
-0.21084296703338623,
0.21922501921653748,
0.6882214546203613,
0.4650896489620209,
-0.5292565822601318,
-0.3515355587005615,
-0.10737009346485138,
0.28243136405944824,
0.06207113713026047,
-0.30215898156166077,
-0.026830971240997314,
-0.11607815325260162,
-0.7172441482543945,
0.6128143072128296,
0.5410213470458984,
-0.17778027057647705,
-0.5120576024055481,
0.07366792112588882,
0.010812767781317234,
0.27402812242507935,
0.34703633189201355,
0.1011136919260025,
-0.8768725991249084,
-0.4614051282405853,
0.35183849930763245,
-0.33064696192741394,
0.3106151223182678,
0.896845281124115,
-0.846567690372467,
0.7265539169311523,
0.3532710075378418,
0.4207649827003479,
0.6977282166481018,
0.2745017111301422,
0.5809548497200012,
-0.47409453988075256,
-0.0013081729412078857,
0.5160390734672546,
0.24770231544971466,
0.21584098041057587,
-0.5174924731254578,
0.059055209159851074,
0.14609752595424652,
-0.8806489706039429,
-0.763115406036377,
0.2814052104949951,
-0.8642597794532776,
-0.20543429255485535,
1.3050355911254883,
0.4565865099430084,
0.18862661719322205,
-0.11163146793842316,
-0.409715473651886,
0.09514735639095306,
-0.5332514643669128,
1.2982925176620483,
0.7005948424339294,
-0.45514756441116333,
-0.08873790502548218,
-0.5436336398124695,
0.17315006256103516,
0.6446080803871155,
-0.6463612914085388,
-0.04688917472958565,
0.22752685844898224,
0.05851593241095543,
0.3279995322227478,
0.505220353603363,
-0.3082437217235565,
0.18966200947761536,
-0.06145891547203064,
-0.047716766595840454,
0.25336000323295593,
-0.17728959023952484,
-0.5664108395576477,
0.3513939380645752,
0.11614079028367996,
0.0355704203248024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05868v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05868v2 | EmojiCrypt: Prompt Encryption for Secure Communication with Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T17:57:11 | 2024-02-12T16:26:14 | Guo Lin, Wenyue Hua, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.IR, cs.LG | Cloud-based large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have increasingly
become integral to daily operations, serving as vital tools across various
applications. While these models offer substantial benefits in terms of
accessibility and functionality, they also introduce significant privacy
concerns: the transmission and storage of user data in cloud infrastructures
pose substantial risks of data breaches and unauthorized access to sensitive
information; even if the transmission and storage of data is encrypted, the LLM
service provider itself still knows the real contents of the data, preventing
individuals or entities from confidently using such LLM services. To address
these concerns, this paper proposes a simple yet effective mechanism EmojiCrypt
to protect user privacy. It uses Emoji to encrypt the user inputs before
sending them to LLM, effectively rendering them indecipherable to human or
LLM's examination while retaining the original intent of the prompt, thus
ensuring the model's performance remains unaffected. We conduct experiments on
three tasks, personalized recommendation, sentiment analysis, and tabular data
analysis. Experiment results reveal that EmojiCrypt can encrypt personal
information within prompts in such a manner that not only prevents the
discernment of sensitive data by humans or LLM itself, but also maintains or
even improves the precision without further tuning, achieving comparable or
even better task accuracy than directly prompting the LLM without prompt
encryption. These results highlight the practicality of adopting encryption
measures that safeguard user privacy without compromising the functional
integrity and performance of LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/agiresearch/EmojiCrypt. | [
-0.1982896327972412,
-1.1457369327545166,
0.657023549079895,
0.2412302941083908,
-0.3583463728427887,
0.3573005795478821,
-0.31201377511024475,
-0.35309961438179016,
0.2795127332210541,
0.791208803653717,
-0.7262214422225952,
-0.6692094206809998,
-0.6675283312797546,
0.22204500436782837,
-0.33866778016090393,
0.5519511103630066,
0.237239271402359,
-0.1516227424144745,
-0.04742565378546715,
0.30262231826782227,
-0.33249765634536743,
-0.7832407355308533,
-0.7300528883934021,
-0.007599288132041693,
0.35010671615600586,
0.5155865550041199,
0.9367383718490601,
0.4582800269126892,
0.4775944650173187,
0.24032869935035706,
-0.26718083024024963,
-0.1223018690943718,
-0.22150751948356628,
0.7613168954849243,
0.19260267913341522,
-0.5327286124229431,
0.07496757060289383,
-0.5453559756278992,
0.32894599437713623,
0.1139213889837265,
-0.30168020725250244,
-0.10003861784934998,
0.10936371982097626,
0.5540629029273987,
-0.6692795157432556,
0.20406652987003326,
-0.8423942923545837,
0.12081070244312286,
-0.22927266359329224,
-0.3089587092399597,
-0.35211798548698425,
-0.2700972259044647,
-0.23015780746936798,
-0.25951939821243286,
-0.2818578779697418,
0.3855088949203491,
0.47063660621643066,
0.2839460074901581,
-0.0965765193104744,
-0.401047945022583,
-0.2921406030654907,
0.5638642311096191,
-0.4687943160533905,
0.6038522720336914,
0.7586341500282288,
0.46444761753082275,
-0.20213614404201508,
-0.559575617313385,
-0.46323999762535095,
-0.4405757784843445,
0.19954657554626465,
0.012090901844203472,
-0.0818559005856514,
0.29434865713119507,
0.3763437569141388,
0.10920919477939606,
-0.5547080636024475,
0.3459753096103668,
0.19267341494560242,
-0.30482396483421326,
0.2555253505706787,
0.2078479528427124,
0.6644917726516724,
-0.24114194512367249,
-0.46848636865615845,
0.1264471858739853,
-1.1168760061264038,
0.2400345355272293,
0.2017025351524353,
0.4218263626098633,
-0.2028120905160904,
0.7814757823944092,
-0.2548324167728424,
0.3966614902019501,
-0.029111066833138466,
-0.0043778568506240845,
-0.20161625742912292,
-0.10510914027690887,
-0.08198201656341553,
0.24572394788265228,
0.9730873703956604,
0.1297474056482315,
0.24314649403095245,
-0.25209182500839233,
-0.0967901349067688,
-0.10058292746543884,
-0.06167234852910042,
-0.9531159996986389,
0.1298377960920334,
0.4216541647911072,
-0.19604791700839996,
-0.3894350826740265,
-0.024403681978583336,
-0.71363765001297,
-0.7177547216415405,
-0.057786766439676285,
0.08174443989992142,
-0.3411683440208435,
0.22002631425857544,
-0.1418357491493225,
0.3352162539958954,
-0.05339225381612778,
0.35785672068595886,
-1.3735697269439697,
0.49253034591674805,
1.0899807214736938,
1.0165321826934814,
0.13101792335510254,
-0.19163794815540314,
-0.35580185055732727,
0.12742796540260315,
0.014996427111327648,
0.3131922781467438,
-0.7283284068107605,
-0.40103137493133545,
0.36454999446868896,
-0.03590654209256172,
0.03524814546108246,
-0.011027701199054718,
0.5053980946540833,
-0.5802845358848572,
-0.031919002532958984,
-0.11755232512950897,
-0.7581694722175598,
0.14501069486141205,
0.2962222397327423,
-0.5607565641403198,
0.44793879985809326,
-0.3675113022327423,
-0.8005930185317993,
0.166691854596138,
-0.4727013409137726,
-0.43671756982803345,
0.3784734904766083,
-0.47500520944595337,
-0.3520297706127167,
0.07302527129650116,
0.7746142745018005,
0.6692352294921875,
-0.37146440148353577,
-0.18513748049736023,
-0.46652647852897644,
-0.3452909290790558,
0.9694779515266418,
-0.45724907517433167,
0.7997193932533264,
0.33501505851745605,
-0.0907038077712059,
-0.12017341703176498,
-0.19503936171531677,
-0.011741641908884048,
0.13987420499324799,
-0.10456671565771103,
-0.12590426206588745,
-0.19482627511024475,
0.19981805980205536,
0.05977044627070427,
0.6364173293113708,
-0.7900285720825195,
0.23839755356311798,
-0.44182708859443665,
0.8330798149108887,
0.6413211822509766,
0.05158648639917374,
0.5539004802703857,
-0.08870004117488861,
0.8092213869094849,
-0.3098793029785156,
0.4797012507915497,
-0.577343761920929,
-0.7680667638778687,
-0.13457544147968292,
-0.5477964878082275,
0.3359196186065674,
0.736277163028717,
-0.8575461506843567,
0.6425713896751404,
-0.19999931752681732,
-0.3131406903266907,
-0.5161595344543457,
0.18335463106632233,
0.26571664214134216,
0.19351568818092346,
-0.14365142583847046,
-0.1267470419406891,
-0.29953786730766296,
-0.705804705619812,
-0.478744238615036,
-0.13511325418949127,
-0.15605758130550385,
0.5794971585273743,
0.25216034054756165,
-0.25028473138809204,
0.6529691219329834,
-0.5444523096084595,
-0.2745036482810974,
-0.1963575929403305,
-0.14714886248111725,
0.16011036932468414,
0.46792373061180115,
0.2675740122795105,
-0.808167040348053,
-0.42597508430480957,
-0.21368762850761414,
-0.5427478551864624,
-0.1683487743139267,
-0.2814105451107025,
-0.11732576042413712,
0.26370683312416077,
0.3379587233066559,
-0.961918830871582,
0.4315483570098877,
0.7658498287200928,
-0.6277946829795837,
-0.08992239832878113,
-0.1566094607114792,
0.37786099314689636,
-1.0474562644958496,
-0.05192546546459198,
-0.48329290747642517,
-0.5203564167022705,
-0.6415602564811707,
0.10045532882213593,
0.19735172390937805,
-0.6375693678855896,
-0.5213252305984497,
0.4448590874671936,
-0.45202556252479553,
0.1252911388874054,
-0.16478277742862701,
0.035758405923843384,
-0.2992827594280243,
0.20959845185279846,
-0.11635193228721619,
0.6976770758628845,
0.8140339255332947,
-0.10953391343355179,
0.22737380862236023,
0.7278872132301331,
-0.21555133163928986,
0.380125492811203,
-0.5075581669807434,
0.6406590938568115,
0.2393931746482849,
0.0990748256444931,
-0.8779932260513306,
-0.27545425295829773,
0.5786401033401489,
-0.8262580633163452,
0.1996583342552185,
-0.2804485559463501,
-0.8295568227767944,
0.04363444820046425,
-0.45004239678382874,
-0.012512763030827045,
0.8050336241722107,
-0.7020336389541626,
0.6972559690475464,
0.4111911654472351,
-0.40751785039901733,
-0.540036141872406,
-1.0456939935684204,
0.5932955145835876,
-0.19820654392242432,
-0.8415765762329102,
0.14930123090744019,
-0.25037145614624023,
0.11733163893222809,
-0.34052205085754395,
0.06846454739570618,
-0.37719252705574036,
0.5278717875480652,
0.8000528216362,
0.20053459703922272,
0.5264989733695984,
-0.0528247207403183,
0.20668989419937134,
-0.1402675360441208,
0.1494375318288803,
0.013985950499773026,
0.7530092597007751,
0.08611103147268295,
-0.40936902165412903,
-0.714329719543457,
0.49233123660087585,
0.5469695329666138,
-0.0755419060587883,
0.9903385639190674,
0.25624531507492065,
-0.5093815326690674,
-0.30250757932662964,
-0.5216456651687622,
-0.606884777545929,
-0.5585913062095642,
-0.0013284389860928059,
-0.3558003008365631,
-1.220049500465393,
0.6929384469985962,
0.08210142701864243,
-0.008057612925767899,
-0.30793827772140503,
0.6206366419792175,
-0.13932353258132935,
1.0375255346298218,
0.2846717834472656,
-0.184696227312088,
0.8185304403305054,
0.4364264905452728,
0.3654116690158844,
-0.6502315998077393,
-0.2515067458152771,
-0.49939435720443726,
0.12854133546352386,
-0.5958289504051208,
-0.08620192855596542,
0.13959413766860962,
0.07418423891067505,
-0.21728697419166565,
0.2246115356683731,
-0.4341210126876831,
0.5103791952133179,
0.32755541801452637,
0.3807952105998993,
0.32406851649284363,
0.34315285086631775,
0.2838432788848877,
-0.22319988906383514,
-0.3634546101093292,
-0.4524824619293213,
1.0092955827713013,
0.4288552403450012,
1.1658483743667603,
0.15438765287399292,
1.12374746799469,
0.25271937251091003,
-0.04865836724638939,
-0.6861622929573059,
0.5498634576797485,
0.08217217028141022,
-0.3593667447566986,
-0.3056081533432007,
-0.5154204964637756,
-1.1411317586898804,
0.2650688588619232,
-0.35073524713516235,
-1.1088770627975464,
-0.17491473257541656,
0.2437586635351181,
-0.2408323884010315,
0.11847962439060211,
-0.38518837094306946,
0.5008468627929688,
-0.35647451877593994,
-0.13466891646385193,
-0.05474681407213211,
-0.6826903820037842,
0.23220351338386536,
-0.3079378604888916,
0.2575199604034424,
-0.1314295530319214,
-0.3391098380088806,
0.57520991563797,
-0.4663326144218445,
0.8920004367828369,
-0.07266011834144592,
0.25494638085365295,
0.11536557227373123,
0.3455192446708679,
0.9369432330131531,
0.387108713388443,
0.3021182119846344,
0.32837504148483276,
-0.15425024926662445,
0.027399301528930664,
-0.8401026129722595,
1.0063199996948242,
-0.4815627634525299,
-0.7509982585906982,
-0.32117778062820435,
-0.37733933329582214,
-0.09032218903303146,
0.037455182522535324,
0.17616724967956543,
0.21298174560070038,
0.07866188883781433,
0.357300728559494,
0.45200926065444946,
-0.21963860094547272,
0.4473668336868286,
0.3101572096347809,
-0.3525506854057312,
-0.7434686422348022,
0.5698011517524719,
-0.02411278709769249,
0.14198066294193268,
0.6078557372093201,
0.29124873876571655,
-0.6475452780723572,
-0.40829381346702576,
-0.4970114231109619,
0.08478288352489471,
-0.9385968446731567,
-0.19328227639198303,
-0.6715611815452576,
0.04521864280104637,
-0.5121482014656067,
-0.3821021020412445,
-0.0742226243019104,
-0.7045860886573792,
-0.2505059838294983,
-0.0043686870485544205,
0.574633002281189,
0.25590717792510986,
0.2868793308734894,
0.3783699572086334,
-0.8500948548316956,
0.22843095660209656,
0.059726323932409286,
0.023656265810132027,
-0.2274172008037567,
-0.40514716506004333,
-0.00434530433267355,
-0.05850023031234741,
0.024389684200286865,
-0.9589276313781738,
0.4804714024066925,
0.02937990613281727,
0.3804335296154022,
0.39668676257133484,
0.12417060881853104,
0.33128485083580017,
-0.4683651626110077,
0.7982503175735474,
0.41918736696243286,
-1.2908217906951904,
0.5243571996688843,
-0.21296426653862,
0.3150531053543091,
0.7064525485038757,
-0.024024706333875656,
-0.8219313621520996,
-0.5018115639686584,
-0.5452333092689514,
-0.9373210072517395,
0.46894824504852295,
0.6109772324562073,
0.14769425988197327,
0.10058226436376572,
0.24766358733177185,
0.00610850565135479,
0.4588126242160797,
-0.5983775854110718,
-0.2963641881942749,
-0.12731784582138062,
-0.5079436302185059,
0.16047458350658417,
-0.2818427085876465,
-0.00854442734271288,
0.18265892565250397,
0.2374873161315918,
0.04660981521010399,
0.431813508272171,
0.016016485169529915,
-0.15750683844089508,
0.36159124970436096,
0.6474279165267944,
0.2457977682352066,
0.23553204536437988,
0.03964085504412651,
0.22843316197395325,
0.263516902923584,
-0.7145490646362305,
0.10149740427732468,
0.07574335485696793,
-0.3849075734615326,
-0.2631348967552185,
0.3242676556110382,
0.4269666373729706,
0.2460314780473709,
-0.6731297969818115,
0.7758992314338684,
-0.37700745463371277,
0.21517805755138397,
-0.5724591016769409,
-0.12353234738111496,
0.09040693938732147,
0.0381510928273201,
0.13557304441928864,
-0.2543933689594269,
0.1860864907503128,
-0.3542225658893585,
-0.028305670246481895,
0.38663583993911743,
-0.1818758100271225,
-0.28339684009552,
0.620266854763031,
0.23872002959251404,
-0.4753076434135437,
0.6625248193740845,
0.2898642122745514,
-0.6006571054458618,
0.5300571322441101,
0.6387221813201904,
1.1384950876235962,
-0.4783625602722168,
0.07798919081687927,
-0.09449126571416855,
0.5453203320503235,
-0.09807638078927994,
0.7009970545768738,
-0.23886412382125854,
-0.5080017447471619,
0.04469269514083862,
-0.3140799403190613,
-0.6589416861534119,
-0.26048219203948975,
-0.4604504108428955,
0.010278185829520226,
-0.9437879920005798,
-0.151265487074852,
-0.28399041295051575,
-0.5011444091796875,
-0.7750948667526245,
0.09046212583780289,
0.432284951210022,
0.762641191482544,
-0.7537528872489929,
0.6413739919662476,
0.4478132426738739,
-0.16957460343837738,
-0.4993123710155487,
-0.1622082144021988,
0.10210620611906052,
-1.0485286712646484,
0.42208003997802734,
0.3631123900413513,
0.00040169188287109137,
-0.34686070680618286,
-0.6589146852493286,
-0.8565452694892883,
0.9706887602806091,
0.5100167989730835,
-1.117936611175537,
0.3340364694595337,
0.5641708374023438,
0.19398342072963715,
-0.4256817102432251,
0.27614909410476685,
0.37193557620048523,
0.5112038850784302,
-0.03813621774315834,
-0.6351275444030762,
0.6950632333755493,
0.18538130819797516,
0.033582497388124466,
0.13630233705043793,
-0.3648104667663574,
0.6448965072631836,
-0.1054135262966156,
-0.5953409671783447,
0.08611278235912323,
0.3206078112125397,
0.4355451762676239,
0.12280885875225067,
0.46872439980506897,
0.15823803842067719,
0.9190095067024231,
-0.10845630615949631,
1.1813870668411255,
-0.7356950640678406,
0.2895485460758209,
0.7011692523956299,
-0.21455815434455872,
0.9338366985321045,
0.6438477039337158,
-0.013439715839922428,
-0.07487694174051285,
0.5825803279876709,
-0.002933114767074585,
0.6814201474189758,
0.248937726020813,
-0.46712324023246765,
-0.3895373046398163,
-0.3246106803417206,
-0.1980670988559723,
0.09786243736743927,
0.4487324655056,
-0.5722551941871643,
0.25009453296661377,
0.14954684674739838,
0.2544163167476654,
0.05635455995798111,
-0.30261215567588806,
0.6870517730712891,
0.5051683783531189,
-0.4066419005393982,
0.5554262399673462,
-0.1938343197107315,
0.6076215505599976,
-0.47080883383750916,
0.22279943525791168,
0.10194738954305649,
0.014643536880612373,
-0.3850558400154114,
-0.9539881944656372,
0.0314822681248188,
0.05556941032409668,
0.2578592896461487,
-0.13537992537021637,
0.865218997001648,
-0.4520731568336487,
-0.45896971225738525,
0.18017376959323883,
0.25132256746292114,
0.1950290948152542,
-0.30251121520996094,
-0.9740429520606995,
0.47160497307777405,
-0.025812892243266106,
-0.48361578583717346,
0.2804279327392578,
0.011920720338821411,
0.1153540387749672,
1.10819673538208,
0.7034929394721985,
0.14497826993465424,
-0.14229172468185425,
0.45515313744544983,
0.7132841944694519,
-0.8271417021751404,
-1.0136380195617676,
-1.3055020570755005,
0.1541685163974762,
-0.08572747558355331,
-0.06647256016731262,
1.0040271282196045,
0.18182893097400665,
0.3767087161540985,
-0.033416036516427994,
0.8533215522766113,
0.14542138576507568,
0.21590515971183777,
-0.8082923293113708,
0.8440619111061096,
-0.08209837228059769,
0.3056330680847168,
-0.07041493058204651,
-0.7222172021865845,
-0.4636304974555969,
0.19162485003471375,
-0.1890804022550583,
-0.013275183737277985,
0.5728313326835632,
0.8695403337478638,
0.3328996002674103,
0.1607663929462433,
0.5121414661407471,
0.10633158683776855,
0.494595468044281,
0.5709409713745117,
1.0762747526168823,
-0.1311781257390976,
0.3604256808757782,
-0.2577708065509796,
-0.21741987764835358,
-0.14665529131889343,
-0.7223168611526489,
-1.4345215559005737,
-0.3389151096343994,
-0.17244400084018707,
-0.15122731029987335,
0.2607249617576599,
0.9180346727371216,
0.447689414024353,
-0.5936821103096008,
0.12946046888828278,
-0.22726894915103912,
0.015759291127324104,
-0.03091428242623806,
-0.08975844085216522,
0.42924025654792786,
-0.04393141716718674,
-0.46249210834503174,
0.48229101300239563,
0.19393318891525269,
0.2952737510204315,
-0.17054319381713867,
0.006339332088828087,
0.42806753516197205,
0.2800099849700928,
0.25001996755599976,
0.29491326212882996,
-0.9861698150634766,
-0.14882439374923706,
-0.1588641107082367,
-0.13777123391628265,
0.06682414561510086,
0.6756792664527893,
-0.32607799768447876,
0.4252614676952362,
0.7206113934516907,
0.8386753797531128,
0.46521270275115967,
0.24603907763957977,
0.269010066986084,
-0.6389609575271606,
0.1229734867811203,
0.18649429082870483,
0.6510711312294006,
0.6423635482788086,
-1.0483665466308594,
0.09667827934026718,
-0.24547061324119568,
-0.7875167727470398,
-0.7412416338920593,
0.38043639063835144,
-1.1199586391448975,
-0.12259838730096817,
0.9871522784233093,
-0.33149847388267517,
-0.48152366280555725,
-0.12932151556015015,
-0.38896769285202026,
-0.25965413451194763,
-1.0745068788528442,
0.7570232152938843,
0.4126078188419342,
0.17922039330005646,
-0.5215612053871155,
-0.35993632674217224,
0.6226637363433838,
0.38954293727874756,
-0.923275887966156,
0.4259156286716461,
0.07409895211458206,
0.29372063279151917,
-0.10963352024555206,
0.5034624338150024,
-0.14718489348888397,
0.1924363672733307,
-0.16699129343032837,
0.09376836568117142,
-0.4768470823764801,
-0.30462294816970825,
-0.6844382882118225,
0.31687626242637634,
0.22365061938762665,
-0.2493264079093933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05864v1 | Permute-and-Flip: An optimally robust and watermarkable decoder for LLMs | 2024-02-08T17:54:23 | 2024-02-08T17:54:23 | Xuandong Zhao, Lei Li, Yu-Xiang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose a new decoding method called Permute-and-Flip (PF)
decoder. It enjoys robustness properties similar to the standard sampling
decoder, but is provably up to 2x better in its quality-robustness tradeoff
than sampling and never worse than any other decoder. We also design a
cryptographic watermarking scheme analogous to Aaronson's Gumbel watermark, but
naturally tailored for PF decoder. The watermarking scheme does not change the
distribution to sample, while allowing arbitrarily low false positive rate and
high recall whenever the generated text has high entropy. Our experiments show
that the PF decoder (and its watermarked counterpart) significantly
outperform(s) naive sampling (and it's Gumbel watermarked counterpart) in terms
of perplexity, while retaining the same robustness (and detectability), hence
making it a promising new approach for LLM decoding. The code is available at
https://github.com/XuandongZhao/pf-decoding | [
-0.020796379074454308,
-0.3813556730747223,
0.38120684027671814,
0.3104616105556488,
-0.7028483152389526,
0.20635588467121124,
0.3495117425918579,
-0.28712552785873413,
0.3201257288455963,
0.58990478515625,
-0.4829173982143402,
-0.6105612516403198,
-0.6922886967658997,
0.04388280212879181,
-0.719337522983551,
0.49105849862098694,
0.04210986942052841,
0.14638803899288177,
-0.016631778329610825,
-0.08438313752412796,
0.2862931191921234,
-0.7356454133987427,
-0.4795694947242737,
-0.6597545742988586,
0.13513416051864624,
0.1815796047449112,
0.8031659126281738,
0.8703620433807373,
0.5121021866798401,
0.18758104741573334,
-0.34169918298721313,
0.06886137276887894,
-0.6364332437515259,
0.17734357714653015,
0.15001128613948822,
-0.5189439058303833,
-0.650229275226593,
-0.0689963549375534,
0.6045788526535034,
0.39202046394348145,
-0.04911118373274803,
0.09623974561691284,
0.04142108932137489,
0.8242285847663879,
-0.9854661226272583,
-0.0023988322354853153,
-0.8384115099906921,
0.13804571330547333,
-0.45656245946884155,
-0.7980261445045471,
-0.4026699662208557,
-0.33233126997947693,
-0.5270095467567444,
-0.638147234916687,
-0.07538877427577972,
0.19034463167190552,
0.6927699446678162,
0.15519876778125763,
-0.27820298075675964,
-0.08774099498987198,
-0.7109898924827576,
0.7665218710899353,
-0.721412181854248,
0.35151687264442444,
0.325306236743927,
0.3908553719520569,
-0.22708049416542053,
-0.7139781713485718,
-0.569374680519104,
0.31693345308303833,
0.4900696575641632,
0.41407549381256104,
-0.2884901165962219,
-0.1767764538526535,
0.07315661758184433,
0.739391565322876,
-0.395732045173645,
-0.1822982281446457,
0.3820517361164093,
-0.3263802230358124,
0.573736310005188,
0.5370876789093018,
0.09278061985969543,
0.2867445647716522,
-0.6567792296409607,
-0.46258196234703064,
-1.0468281507492065,
0.1076800599694252,
0.9499063491821289,
-0.17718224227428436,
0.1262960284948349,
0.4131767153739929,
-0.02502809278666973,
0.5038416981697083,
0.08895248174667358,
-0.4280809462070465,
0.28026360273361206,
-0.285264253616333,
-0.23674345016479492,
-0.09926805645227432,
0.5545857548713684,
0.42191293835639954,
0.1262155920267105,
-0.3096892535686493,
-0.5048218369483948,
-0.17391467094421387,
0.07596581429243088,
-0.8193139433860779,
-0.3990253806114197,
0.12286564707756042,
-0.7338229417800903,
-0.5885516405105591,
0.3240734040737152,
-0.7528692483901978,
-0.3768666386604309,
0.12414373457431793,
0.46604791283607483,
-0.566597580909729,
-0.4615767300128937,
0.6970362067222595,
-0.14612525701522827,
0.5790891051292419,
0.20516115427017212,
-0.7796145081520081,
0.4065200388431549,
0.7646281719207764,
0.5513337254524231,
-0.34220945835113525,
-0.2791954576969147,
-0.5287905931472778,
0.30293214321136475,
-0.1947161704301834,
0.9687698483467102,
-0.41161611676216125,
-0.4707026183605194,
0.07708986103534698,
-0.22242584824562073,
0.21661712229251862,
-0.8571751117706299,
0.4875698685646057,
-0.7957546710968018,
-0.31135061383247375,
-0.17103327810764313,
-0.6203691959381104,
-0.014711722731590271,
0.013058215379714966,
-0.9360685348510742,
0.6379397511482239,
-0.0571809858083725,
-1.0166276693344116,
0.1216958537697792,
-0.28368446230888367,
-0.5560824871063232,
-0.028171295300126076,
0.12989887595176697,
-0.706520140171051,
-0.010498763993382454,
0.4148102402687073,
0.28290075063705444,
-0.20940008759498596,
-0.33014732599258423,
-0.28833723068237305,
-0.7121074199676514,
0.7722195982933044,
-0.682006299495697,
0.9786320924758911,
0.24136537313461304,
-0.1920374184846878,
-0.21767476201057434,
-0.9154518842697144,
0.09986847639083862,
0.49059563875198364,
-0.8277127146720886,
-0.005384074989706278,
0.11397004127502441,
0.197383850812912,
-0.45854222774505615,
0.29508140683174133,
-0.35890674591064453,
0.004523823969066143,
-0.3516673147678375,
0.45032545924186707,
0.7343347668647766,
0.059778958559036255,
0.6418190598487854,
-0.4909488260746002,
0.5632333159446716,
0.14875428378582,
0.16122254729270935,
-0.23329247534275055,
-0.37176454067230225,
-0.44449442625045776,
-0.6727990508079529,
0.34534668922424316,
0.8824525475502014,
-0.8949657082557678,
0.453276127576828,
-0.256009966135025,
-0.02544577792286873,
-0.33914533257484436,
0.4306662976741791,
0.1747865080833435,
0.321907639503479,
0.4564545750617981,
-0.3113310635089874,
-0.4374062418937683,
-0.5742496848106384,
-0.48011377453804016,
-0.08052200078964233,
-0.16486281156539917,
0.012463436461985111,
0.35765957832336426,
-0.23660019040107727,
0.7637395858764648,
-0.30403655767440796,
0.041726645082235336,
-0.3037737011909485,
-0.04961824789643288,
0.37724578380584717,
0.43873271346092224,
0.2997596561908722,
-0.7406315803527832,
-0.30976900458335876,
-0.4260868728160858,
-0.48953723907470703,
-0.24372754991054535,
-0.07290098816156387,
-0.43567222356796265,
0.08706780523061752,
0.5773507952690125,
-0.30567872524261475,
0.5392611622810364,
0.5669162273406982,
-0.329249769449234,
0.5902485251426697,
-0.08846108615398407,
-0.1852954626083374,
-0.9909818172454834,
0.0734575167298317,
-0.5523310899734497,
-0.4654185175895691,
-0.4552048444747925,
0.02337600104510784,
0.31181594729423523,
0.1812908947467804,
-0.4195472300052643,
0.36038634181022644,
-0.6469493508338928,
-0.04493003711104393,
-0.5334174633026123,
-0.42887893319129944,
-0.08883614838123322,
0.09871788322925568,
-0.003802628954872489,
0.8586232662200928,
0.5381629467010498,
-0.29802343249320984,
0.4188137352466583,
0.18044033646583557,
-0.36051854491233826,
0.659380316734314,
-0.4071628153324127,
0.4214829206466675,
-0.19402290880680084,
0.2513573467731476,
-0.9931902885437012,
0.13690564036369324,
0.414469838142395,
-0.4461844563484192,
0.5461949110031128,
-0.33360856771469116,
-0.576561450958252,
0.003467164933681488,
-0.8029006123542786,
0.5845837593078613,
0.7305408120155334,
-0.8560045957565308,
0.48364511132240295,
0.2633676528930664,
0.28245627880096436,
-0.5287358164787292,
-0.8540627360343933,
0.23621708154678345,
-0.162361279129982,
-0.4869144558906555,
0.5957263708114624,
-0.12484821677207947,
-0.03940258175134659,
0.024260444566607475,
-0.541282594203949,
0.12300115823745728,
0.10229584574699402,
0.29624325037002563,
0.018076768144965172,
-0.1994280070066452,
-0.6279836297035217,
-0.04177975282073021,
-0.8693549633026123,
-0.037672314792871475,
-0.5480631589889526,
0.6039319038391113,
-0.15162019431591034,
-0.5913848876953125,
-0.3558085858821869,
0.45308399200439453,
0.4400206506252289,
-0.13817612826824188,
0.50955730676651,
0.5194078683853149,
-0.342713862657547,
-0.027727806940674782,
-0.42419081926345825,
-0.15643909573554993,
-0.5431928038597107,
0.040593840181827545,
-0.35791724920272827,
-0.7447246313095093,
0.5367510914802551,
-0.14232492446899414,
-0.018928654491901398,
-0.08833258599042892,
0.5209817290306091,
-0.4341423809528351,
0.7168313264846802,
0.6442551016807556,
-0.24309232831001282,
0.5318710207939148,
-0.4755094647407532,
0.35196399688720703,
-0.8287477493286133,
-0.061405353248119354,
-0.2813568115234375,
-0.3926120400428772,
-0.18593499064445496,
-0.4989340007305145,
0.2616531252861023,
0.5371914505958557,
-0.17105434834957123,
0.2322331815958023,
-0.4381296634674072,
0.6109591126441956,
0.6050634980201721,
0.12179197371006012,
0.6102216243743896,
0.551037609577179,
-0.058746520429849625,
-0.09740111976861954,
-0.6348402500152588,
-0.7551010251045227,
1.3998721837997437,
0.25441989302635193,
1.260264277458191,
0.04105154797434807,
1.118283987045288,
-0.04929182678461075,
0.21148480474948883,
-0.5886170268058777,
0.6679651141166687,
-0.06557990610599518,
-0.32122641801834106,
-0.2362862229347229,
-0.4667498767375946,
-1.2675305604934692,
0.3048287332057953,
-0.265342116355896,
-0.5027188062667847,
0.13583976030349731,
0.09017616510391235,
0.005507756024599075,
0.7332459092140198,
-0.21310551464557648,
0.22902482748031616,
-0.22721177339553833,
-0.18829727172851562,
-0.02701682783663273,
-0.42351993918418884,
0.18019317090511322,
0.24258871376514435,
0.10166752338409424,
-0.11743973195552826,
-0.3346300721168518,
0.5953306555747986,
-0.31791001558303833,
0.48105767369270325,
-0.18036475777626038,
-0.3079250454902649,
0.18046127259731293,
0.41468048095703125,
0.4982626140117645,
0.4467203915119171,
-0.18675075471401215,
0.1061360165476799,
0.1572408825159073,
-0.5815092921257019,
-0.4750284254550934,
0.3672996163368225,
-0.739388644695282,
-0.49507322907447815,
-0.4974059760570526,
-0.41682636737823486,
-0.1161823496222496,
0.10948547720909119,
0.5928682684898376,
0.32976964116096497,
0.12936171889305115,
0.08563696593046188,
0.9077721834182739,
-0.1353335827589035,
0.4847765862941742,
0.5594731569290161,
-0.047261662781238556,
-0.8316782116889954,
1.1009361743927002,
-0.2719325125217438,
0.07013281434774399,
0.8564953207969666,
-0.06743516772985458,
-0.2741377353668213,
-0.9704415202140808,
-0.21220041811466217,
0.17886221408843994,
-0.9075337052345276,
-0.5487844944000244,
-0.301008015871048,
-0.39663034677505493,
-0.24391962587833405,
-0.1517561674118042,
-0.44593513011932373,
-0.18259714543819427,
-0.41578975319862366,
0.037165410816669464,
0.13291068375110626,
0.21906958520412445,
-0.23067286610603333,
0.06332434713840485,
-0.5566217303276062,
0.6330742239952087,
0.48267456889152527,
0.332739919424057,
-0.14341995120048523,
-0.5895152688026428,
0.08874356001615524,
-0.11644835770130157,
-0.35631927847862244,
-1.1459029912948608,
0.3054260313510895,
0.0020226959604769945,
0.7367603182792664,
0.5665681958198547,
0.2557520866394043,
0.3513050973415375,
-0.3007490336894989,
0.5191347002983093,
0.26674193143844604,
-1.0194517374038696,
0.13310347497463226,
-0.09959430992603302,
0.30674487352371216,
0.6000332236289978,
-0.05408264696598053,
-0.23317161202430725,
-0.32519853115081787,
-0.45208555459976196,
-1.2992568016052246,
0.4426831901073456,
0.3487844467163086,
0.3078792095184326,
0.20362980663776398,
0.3982343077659607,
0.24924738705158234,
0.147963747382164,
-0.8343172669410706,
-0.5573078989982605,
-0.7342265844345093,
-0.2984319031238556,
0.16907046735286713,
-0.7830712199211121,
-0.13770294189453125,
-0.13664788007736206,
0.5502122640609741,
-0.22264158725738525,
0.9397823214530945,
0.18737736344337463,
-0.44415050745010376,
-0.08433907479047775,
0.26012757420539856,
0.4946090877056122,
0.36037540435791016,
-0.3140542507171631,
0.6297541856765747,
0.16200275719165802,
-0.825957179069519,
0.3831135630607605,
-0.1602982133626938,
-0.344529390335083,
-0.1025272011756897,
0.6149739027023315,
0.6336074471473694,
-0.044161394238471985,
-0.42111077904701233,
0.6759447455406189,
-0.013189991936087608,
-0.5167848467826843,
-0.09481682628393173,
0.031948573887348175,
0.30599576234817505,
0.44246727228164673,
0.6814823746681213,
-0.23079794645309448,
0.18146945536136627,
-0.2653946280479431,
-0.01649514213204384,
0.5145351886749268,
0.31542056798934937,
-0.322599858045578,
0.7533979415893555,
-0.010567856021225452,
-0.4293873906135559,
0.3606659770011902,
-0.3238733410835266,
-0.610393226146698,
0.323306679725647,
0.848382830619812,
0.8767194747924805,
0.1353839486837387,
-0.059200018644332886,
0.023773273453116417,
0.385247141122818,
-0.17295871675014496,
0.6132712960243225,
-0.28926169872283936,
-0.9656381607055664,
0.043366074562072754,
-0.6772124171257019,
-0.6347740888595581,
0.256308376789093,
-0.7477056384086609,
-0.11055056005716324,
-0.6203622221946716,
-0.05662519112229347,
-0.5747498273849487,
-0.1945422738790512,
-0.43539610505104065,
0.0003618866321630776,
0.2858668863773346,
1.1510592699050903,
-0.43767982721328735,
1.126118779182434,
0.7930493354797363,
0.29260900616645813,
-0.3571164011955261,
0.3457331657409668,
0.009904745034873486,
-1.1573381423950195,
0.11964581906795502,
0.037299562245607376,
-0.49405235052108765,
0.01106670405715704,
-0.7836997509002686,
-0.9539266228675842,
1.5256258249282837,
0.7381793260574341,
-0.398097425699234,
0.4642540514469147,
0.2826727032661438,
0.18737928569316864,
-0.15256379544734955,
-0.04048939421772957,
0.7020868062973022,
0.502067506313324,
0.0634642243385315,
-0.3338949978351593,
0.17569608986377716,
-0.4342091977596283,
0.23107071220874786,
-0.10419182479381561,
-0.4951114356517792,
0.5494661331176758,
0.125287264585495,
-0.4423254728317261,
0.38617661595344543,
0.5116624236106873,
0.3535027503967285,
0.257834255695343,
0.5039277672767639,
0.5710006356239319,
0.6432591080665588,
-0.12311563640832901,
1.0762346982955933,
-0.5668359398841858,
0.34146976470947266,
0.6503602862358093,
-0.3309181034564972,
0.9465006589889526,
0.8868392109870911,
-0.4403138756752014,
0.14316022396087646,
0.2922534644603729,
0.023777863010764122,
0.9368215799331665,
0.4045228362083435,
-0.37438148260116577,
-0.6142160296440125,
0.6710004210472107,
-0.359257310628891,
0.03217369690537453,
0.21465818583965302,
-0.13996382057666779,
-0.26328015327453613,
-0.18719381093978882,
-0.17644453048706055,
0.11810986697673798,
-0.19243958592414856,
0.4959264099597931,
0.2617954909801483,
-0.03789808973670006,
0.733856737613678,
0.3257875442504883,
1.156434178352356,
-0.41282010078430176,
0.3379969894886017,
-0.49366700649261475,
0.2195683866739273,
-0.30719998478889465,
-0.9751942753791809,
0.24028706550598145,
-0.30282798409461975,
-0.08319205790758133,
-0.6399174928665161,
0.9805203676223755,
-0.28209230303764343,
-0.28920915722846985,
0.3522213101387024,
0.2982710599899292,
0.2406953126192093,
-0.13169659674167633,
-0.5480072498321533,
0.31683576107025146,
-0.1111874133348465,
-0.49392029643058777,
0.30812832713127136,
0.19000287353992462,
0.3280014097690582,
0.7843307852745056,
0.7967821359634399,
0.09447271376848221,
0.4135984480381012,
-0.07986398786306381,
0.5675833821296692,
-0.7700294256210327,
-0.4463878273963928,
-0.9628474116325378,
0.2138456106185913,
0.20422567427158356,
-0.027224989607930183,
0.5520851016044617,
0.6227986812591553,
0.6829714179039001,
-0.18111833930015564,
0.7584766149520874,
0.4693019390106201,
0.18622738122940063,
-0.9146319031715393,
0.6238800287246704,
-0.5278891324996948,
0.41093236207962036,
-0.18408432602882385,
-0.9147648215293884,
-0.4465334713459015,
0.8902484774589539,
-0.018411878496408463,
-0.14396990835666656,
0.5709714293479919,
0.9872536063194275,
-0.11543886363506317,
0.0691300630569458,
0.3756505846977234,
-0.16462966799736023,
0.3340182900428772,
0.9707382917404175,
1.0273125171661377,
-0.6108196973800659,
0.8585470914840698,
-0.13038033246994019,
-0.1476064920425415,
-0.478213369846344,
-1.0586978197097778,
-0.8616505265235901,
-0.40043166279792786,
-0.3254720866680145,
-0.46522215008735657,
0.06418780982494354,
0.45748233795166016,
0.61705082654953,
-0.8639703392982483,
-0.15509875118732452,
-0.16097667813301086,
0.4635208547115326,
-0.5004326701164246,
-0.11776275932788849,
0.21152876317501068,
0.012950247153639793,
-0.5843389630317688,
0.37284645438194275,
0.6581557393074036,
0.555722177028656,
0.020200878381729126,
-0.46292638778686523,
0.19342674314975739,
0.29508763551712036,
0.260093092918396,
0.21086321771144867,
-0.303666889667511,
0.18909132480621338,
-0.01734992302954197,
-0.28707367181777954,
0.39582568407058716,
1.1471717357635498,
-0.377035915851593,
0.00625758757814765,
0.5945072174072266,
0.8371536135673523,
0.9626398086547852,
-0.1778848022222519,
0.16343799233436584,
-0.2618614733219147,
0.261200487613678,
0.248567134141922,
0.3778255581855774,
0.30689626932144165,
-0.26166436076164246,
0.28893059492111206,
0.6061581373214722,
-0.09559120982885361,
-0.9751868844032288,
0.24178366363048553,
-1.0708508491516113,
-0.17293784022331238,
1.2663313150405884,
-0.18674111366271973,
-0.3890937566757202,
-0.12794888019561768,
-0.13689745962619781,
0.028557362034916878,
-0.16721871495246887,
0.644044816493988,
0.6989384889602661,
0.016521116718649864,
-0.31642064452171326,
-0.1378304362297058,
0.3374543786048889,
0.6694658398628235,
-0.5345137715339661,
-0.15179744362831116,
-0.08268044888973236,
0.7527790069580078,
-0.12232155352830887,
0.9149885773658752,
-0.6212755441665649,
0.4398117661476135,
0.16880811750888824,
-0.01927071064710617,
-0.5228137969970703,
-0.19014014303684235,
-0.5965023040771484,
0.3143055737018585,
0.16232465207576752,
-0.2967868149280548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05863v1 | How Well Can LLMs Negotiate? NegotiationArena Platform and Analysis | 2024-02-08T17:51:48 | 2024-02-08T17:51:48 | Federico Bianchi, Patrick John Chia, Mert Yuksekgonul, Jacopo Tagliabue, Dan Jurafsky, James Zou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Negotiation is the basis of social interactions; humans negotiate everything
from the price of cars to how to share common resources. With rapidly growing
interest in using large language models (LLMs) to act as agents on behalf of
human users, such LLM agents would also need to be able to negotiate. In this
paper, we study how well LLMs can negotiate with each other. We develop
NegotiationArena: a flexible framework for evaluating and probing the
negotiation abilities of LLM agents. We implemented three types of scenarios in
NegotiationArena to assess LLM's behaviors in allocating shared resources
(ultimatum games), aggregate resources (trading games) and buy/sell goods
(price negotiations). Each scenario allows for multiple turns of flexible
dialogues between LLM agents to allow for more complex negotiations.
Interestingly, LLM agents can significantly boost their negotiation outcomes by
employing certain behavioral tactics. For example, by pretending to be desolate
and desperate, LLMs can improve their payoffs by 20\% when negotiating against
the standard GPT-4. We also quantify irrational negotiation behaviors exhibited
by the LLM agents, many of which also appear in humans. Together,
\NegotiationArena offers a new environment to investigate LLM interactions,
enabling new insights into LLM's theory of mind, irrationality, and reasoning
abilities. | [
-0.6451115608215332,
-0.7184452414512634,
0.7508751153945923,
0.18640820682048798,
-0.2377162128686905,
0.2857738733291626,
-0.421114444732666,
-0.7753766179084778,
0.6474466323852539,
0.3218095898628235,
-0.2890073359012604,
-0.2920183539390564,
-0.6126390099525452,
0.13740749657154083,
0.07677346467971802,
0.44852298498153687,
0.06763021647930145,
0.10142688453197479,
0.14393644034862518,
-0.579437792301178,
-0.47625911235809326,
-0.8752004504203796,
-1.1958626508712769,
-0.5591630339622498,
0.7329854369163513,
0.32617858052253723,
0.8509315252304077,
0.11359750479459763,
0.3958807587623596,
0.5081840753555298,
-0.2873091697692871,
0.008341707289218903,
-0.5504459142684937,
0.5106139183044434,
-0.4744325876235962,
-0.5471429824829102,
-0.6215702891349792,
0.21307939291000366,
0.17767764627933502,
0.3752480447292328,
-0.4205637574195862,
0.11932236701250076,
0.04364785924553871,
0.5057840347290039,
-0.31344732642173767,
0.18690519034862518,
-0.9849380254745483,
0.15147562325000763,
-0.1368701457977295,
-0.13719196617603302,
-0.3008129596710205,
-0.3218420445919037,
-0.022821851074695587,
-0.649888813495636,
-0.3681661784648895,
0.05583813041448593,
0.8612117171287537,
0.21731054782867432,
-0.5078105926513672,
-0.371143639087677,
-0.5409098267555237,
0.48176008462905884,
-0.4852972626686096,
-0.05400095507502556,
0.3285497725009918,
0.48273685574531555,
-0.517381489276886,
-0.8352050185203552,
-0.7111609578132629,
-0.4025425910949707,
0.10061439126729965,
0.3118157684803009,
-0.512002170085907,
0.0031115091405808926,
0.2131498157978058,
0.2290542870759964,
-0.2812862694263458,
0.2996775209903717,
-0.3559238016605377,
-0.044588055461645126,
0.7648895382881165,
0.357080340385437,
0.37895628809928894,
-0.1075952872633934,
-0.5672129988670349,
-0.06623585522174835,
-0.4135560393333435,
0.15311861038208008,
0.5271616578102112,
0.27809473872184753,
0.1201544851064682,
0.6678621768951416,
0.07017087191343307,
0.48750191926956177,
-0.12398430705070496,
0.3157443702220917,
-0.3000611960887909,
-0.13424980640411377,
-0.4327017068862915,
-0.2583170533180237,
0.6995224952697754,
0.6188138127326965,
0.43369999527931213,
-0.20642223954200745,
-0.24813583493232727,
0.291341632604599,
0.3910600543022156,
-0.3623223602771759,
0.09394203126430511,
0.20594337582588196,
-0.8546925187110901,
-0.4075930416584015,
-0.3462907373905182,
-1.0633963346481323,
-0.3061411678791046,
-0.32795751094818115,
0.5537587404251099,
0.02776898443698883,
-0.498073935508728,
0.3202742338180542,
-0.12877675890922546,
0.5617499351501465,
0.28879547119140625,
-0.7039134502410889,
0.8300927877426147,
0.4248797297477722,
0.831917941570282,
-0.15968099236488342,
-0.5953278541564941,
-0.3500194847583771,
-0.01667429693043232,
-0.2307300567626953,
0.8883748054504395,
-0.39709165692329407,
-0.583878755569458,
-0.11457424610853195,
-0.45024970173835754,
-0.2402297854423523,
-0.6583987474441528,
0.4296312928199768,
-0.739467203617096,
-0.34762999415397644,
-0.4118853211402893,
-0.46545183658599854,
-0.022482847794890404,
0.8005809187889099,
-0.9488095045089722,
0.3870554268360138,
-0.16435134410858154,
-0.30271247029304504,
0.11083227396011353,
-0.8371690511703491,
-0.2816142141819,
0.10667632520198822,
-0.1908515840768814,
0.014002733863890171,
0.05073130130767822,
-0.21670596301555634,
0.3850788474082947,
-0.5372006893157959,
0.14217069745063782,
-0.32034438848495483,
-0.2527146637439728,
1.1372262239456177,
-0.3720053732395172,
0.47133126854896545,
0.4228954017162323,
-0.16700120270252228,
0.28259626030921936,
-0.011986943893134594,
-0.10671278834342957,
0.3871615529060364,
-0.46057796478271484,
-0.003657617373391986,
-0.10465020686388016,
0.17525608837604523,
0.3197919726371765,
0.4262634217739105,
-0.2566737234592438,
0.6596239805221558,
-0.20832844078540802,
0.6564913988113403,
0.803428590297699,
-0.046268120408058167,
0.47392737865448,
-0.6020858287811279,
0.8595227599143982,
-0.49466755986213684,
0.3221490681171417,
0.6920349597930908,
-0.4280279278755188,
-0.8139570355415344,
0.04691789671778679,
0.05866336449980736,
0.3726625144481659,
-0.6648833751678467,
-0.17860154807567596,
-0.0277329683303833,
-0.41966989636421204,
-0.3650885224342346,
-0.025289669632911682,
0.3723974823951721,
0.12025511264801025,
0.2234143614768982,
-0.12192961573600769,
-0.4140937328338623,
-0.7547096014022827,
-0.41901931166648865,
-0.21940737962722778,
0.22475233674049377,
0.14476856589317322,
0.34271296858787537,
0.0055965231731534,
0.6818170547485352,
-0.26712191104888916,
-0.40155231952667236,
-0.6166922450065613,
0.3909837603569031,
-0.11444035172462463,
0.16165223717689514,
0.6141775846481323,
-0.8504492044448853,
-0.33272790908813477,
0.18977469205856323,
-0.49136531352996826,
0.3558042347431183,
-0.11614720523357391,
-0.36388954520225525,
0.30222761631011963,
0.544988214969635,
-0.8127187490463257,
0.5569499135017395,
0.591275155544281,
-0.4308374226093292,
0.5118117332458496,
-0.28052642941474915,
0.1596507430076599,
-1.1118134260177612,
-0.01247980073094368,
-0.28632432222366333,
-0.3238769769668579,
-0.47585055232048035,
0.20264752209186554,
-0.5221573114395142,
-0.19199584424495697,
-0.5575056672096252,
0.5650550723075867,
-0.43552255630493164,
-0.3254818916320801,
-0.33475568890571594,
0.3132888376712799,
-0.2896641790866852,
0.6201796531677246,
0.11965245753526688,
0.9680315852165222,
0.3571542203426361,
-0.7469809651374817,
0.24248144030570984,
0.22351863980293274,
-0.31833478808403015,
0.585918664932251,
-0.802178144454956,
0.24600230157375336,
0.22705891728401184,
0.38004669547080994,
-0.6528642773628235,
-0.18569964170455933,
0.3547898232936859,
-0.22971290349960327,
-0.06432943046092987,
-0.13521286845207214,
-0.3845330476760864,
0.04604724049568176,
-0.2215709239244461,
0.39672666788101196,
0.3649020493030548,
-0.3298364281654358,
1.007477879524231,
0.5420041680335999,
-0.15668825805187225,
-0.3463665843009949,
-0.5403209924697876,
0.4906178414821625,
-0.4290527403354645,
-0.5327893495559692,
0.30123573541641235,
-0.3471031188964844,
-0.6138942241668701,
-0.09552805125713348,
0.18130576610565186,
-0.1825193613767624,
0.20514851808547974,
0.039538122713565826,
0.10177762061357498,
0.025741415098309517,
-0.04269784316420555,
-0.06551551073789597,
-0.3777797818183899,
0.11537612229585648,
0.13319428265094757,
0.8227055072784424,
-0.3746364712715149,
-0.40127021074295044,
-0.14390133321285248,
0.27374377846717834,
0.8366172909736633,
-0.231781467795372,
0.796920657157898,
0.13096454739570618,
-0.4343186616897583,
0.2169739305973053,
-0.5238758325576782,
-0.09194789081811905,
-0.47088608145713806,
0.19498027861118317,
-0.6474063396453857,
-0.8630458116531372,
0.9874606132507324,
-0.43331003189086914,
-0.11722534894943237,
0.2634176015853882,
0.6221756935119629,
-0.022250808775424957,
0.9374205470085144,
0.3298055827617645,
-0.0019942813087254763,
0.03955889120697975,
-0.19167335331439972,
0.0638866126537323,
-0.8729504942893982,
-0.40654507279396057,
-0.42951613664627075,
-0.7445107102394104,
-0.4546741843223572,
-0.46504244208335876,
0.3208882808685303,
-0.00002903314816649072,
-0.1498979926109314,
0.2440163493156433,
-0.22963453829288483,
0.917046308517456,
0.18575359880924225,
0.1556779444217682,
0.39371660351753235,
-0.30803149938583374,
0.019303133711218834,
-0.15934902429580688,
-0.41166216135025024,
-0.7421514987945557,
0.6712931990623474,
0.48862922191619873,
0.43216854333877563,
0.7019875645637512,
0.3418884873390198,
0.16730424761772156,
0.31735411286354065,
-1.13755464553833,
0.8930894136428833,
0.1424100548028946,
-0.46290847659111023,
-0.4588944911956787,
-0.49930331110954285,
-1.349183201789856,
0.34850451350212097,
-0.2068326771259308,
-0.885101854801178,
0.3262065351009369,
-0.17714987695217133,
-0.17535799741744995,
0.4837893545627594,
-0.4119771122932434,
0.7095102667808533,
-0.5308248400688171,
-0.33871787786483765,
-0.6260327696800232,
-0.47008103132247925,
0.19524036347866058,
0.07436861842870712,
0.07486628741025925,
-0.25164473056793213,
-0.12186992913484573,
0.6403002738952637,
-0.0024487837217748165,
0.8580435514450073,
0.02213745191693306,
-0.050556618720293045,
0.026173658668994904,
0.6358592510223389,
0.40311697125434875,
0.022437307983636856,
-0.3640836179256439,
0.09534348547458649,
-0.14302639663219452,
-0.4778639078140259,
-0.8792847394943237,
0.5503765940666199,
-0.7474104166030884,
-0.5872223973274231,
-0.5991299748420715,
-0.5320930480957031,
-0.2478381246328354,
0.007945500314235687,
0.3539588153362274,
0.06399670243263245,
-0.5791596174240112,
-0.12500442564487457,
0.3860069513320923,
0.09591761231422424,
0.21890196204185486,
0.5040267109870911,
-0.3051494061946869,
-0.31606778502464294,
0.692783772945404,
0.06731143593788147,
0.2327573001384735,
0.016500499099493027,
0.19825993478298187,
-0.32416611909866333,
-0.5770164728164673,
-0.01289118267595768,
0.12066397070884705,
-0.7502912282943726,
-0.4408433437347412,
-0.21309514343738556,
-0.10407616943120956,
0.11952043324708939,
-0.3965623676776886,
-0.3176417648792267,
-0.4796297252178192,
0.01540434081107378,
-0.30655205249786377,
0.38379597663879395,
1.1599289178848267,
-0.16483627259731293,
0.30630040168762207,
-0.5067521333694458,
0.0210818350315094,
0.6007557511329651,
0.164095938205719,
0.23503659665584564,
-0.20549145340919495,
-0.07622433453798294,
-0.11093375831842422,
-0.13519825041294098,
-1.0314311981201172,
0.3734774589538574,
-0.26159754395484924,
0.6768025755882263,
0.16177847981452942,
0.1545277088880539,
0.6552143692970276,
-0.11979931592941284,
0.8058502078056335,
0.13678674399852753,
-1.2045402526855469,
0.27842333912849426,
-0.2939307689666748,
-0.12457238882780075,
0.577028214931488,
0.12849390506744385,
-0.4250495731830597,
-0.23167303204536438,
-0.5341978073120117,
-0.9754882454872131,
0.4600486755371094,
0.37451767921447754,
0.23658959567546844,
0.11960221827030182,
0.3711853623390198,
-0.07984849065542221,
0.24709506332874298,
-0.9110071659088135,
-0.19778397679328918,
0.17594414949417114,
0.07526373118162155,
0.056446872651576996,
-0.27051106095314026,
-0.5784122943878174,
-0.09682703763246536,
0.36364462971687317,
-0.0004909198614768684,
0.23296356201171875,
-0.027497446164488792,
-0.12020044028759003,
0.01022005919367075,
0.43326297402381897,
0.7166787385940552,
0.7492143511772156,
-0.007533799856901169,
0.18358315527439117,
0.4087262451648712,
-0.1477697491645813,
0.2650296986103058,
0.07410338521003723,
0.607236385345459,
-0.5468441843986511,
0.1970498412847519,
0.6162936091423035,
0.3443247973918915,
-0.8002715706825256,
0.3139156997203827,
-0.769169270992279,
-0.5853955149650574,
-0.3458438515663147,
-0.04037907347083092,
0.23702280223369598,
0.8053885102272034,
0.12602920830249786,
0.0386454313993454,
0.14918586611747742,
-0.5223302245140076,
0.005817226134240627,
0.3818919062614441,
-0.06530892103910446,
-0.2138916403055191,
0.4077586531639099,
0.4480418264865875,
-0.5223283171653748,
0.5740825533866882,
-0.275569885969162,
-0.8047254085540771,
0.5487974882125854,
0.37006422877311707,
0.6876108050346375,
-0.12066265195608139,
0.45615965127944946,
-0.10500647127628326,
0.3162950277328491,
0.01204956229776144,
0.33485254645347595,
-0.13401289284229279,
-0.9708109498023987,
-0.28449520468711853,
-0.24791200459003448,
-0.8645614981651306,
0.08794041723012924,
-0.7828603982925415,
-0.11126208305358887,
-0.38118261098861694,
-0.4239859879016876,
-0.28233057260513306,
0.30534350872039795,
-0.8137211203575134,
-0.36745887994766235,
-0.20976373553276062,
0.9378648996353149,
-0.5819275379180908,
0.6666364073753357,
0.9122734069824219,
-0.7989687323570251,
-1.0019900798797607,
0.1776023954153061,
-0.2422553300857544,
-0.7858680486679077,
0.6743956804275513,
-0.09566571563482285,
-0.553884744644165,
-0.07797154784202576,
-0.7027326822280884,
-0.4893163740634918,
1.0485502481460571,
0.8099549412727356,
-0.38623061776161194,
0.14335456490516663,
0.0958705022931099,
0.45376473665237427,
-0.3115844428539276,
0.08409489691257477,
0.7206076383590698,
0.8171745538711548,
0.2650293707847595,
-0.9606136679649353,
0.1395503282546997,
-0.25148507952690125,
-0.17215436697006226,
-0.08591321110725403,
-1.017342448234558,
0.9030660390853882,
0.07899399101734161,
0.002496632281690836,
0.48997169733047485,
0.5324780941009521,
0.3844749331474304,
0.5274683833122253,
0.6330709457397461,
0.3747140169143677,
0.9385457634925842,
0.12985599040985107,
0.9406029582023621,
-0.07819977402687073,
0.25379663705825806,
0.8173163533210754,
-0.7991140484809875,
1.0089640617370605,
0.5255722999572754,
-0.06130865588784218,
0.4641033411026001,
0.6092992424964905,
0.4777490198612213,
0.037475742399692535,
0.5299657583236694,
-0.4060744643211365,
-0.5383582711219788,
-0.2068086564540863,
-0.0827101618051529,
0.6382601261138916,
0.40136557817459106,
0.21785518527030945,
-0.023186272010207176,
0.017723700031638145,
0.2558557093143463,
0.28026139736175537,
-0.20493124425411224,
0.7597630620002747,
0.250471830368042,
-0.47688278555870056,
0.07986363023519516,
-0.05251593887805939,
0.5185512900352478,
-0.5624327659606934,
0.0014600636204704642,
-0.3254064917564392,
0.02390347607433796,
-0.0004715683462563902,
-0.850365400314331,
0.3042792081832886,
-0.13604027032852173,
0.07945682108402252,
-0.21381326019763947,
0.8625673651695251,
-0.2833493649959564,
-0.15516303479671478,
0.7170642018318176,
0.6409316658973694,
0.37077033519744873,
0.058789242058992386,
-0.8150545358657837,
0.4203903377056122,
-0.3783133327960968,
-0.3583511710166931,
0.6850769519805908,
0.549699068069458,
0.14734326303005219,
0.7843323349952698,
0.5725716352462769,
0.3338708281517029,
-0.4871823489665985,
-0.01858982816338539,
0.9241431951522827,
-0.5515530109405518,
-0.3537466526031494,
-0.6131340861320496,
0.45990410447120667,
-0.2670700252056122,
-0.20288585126399994,
0.5457402467727661,
0.15269942581653595,
0.43859222531318665,
0.30156466364860535,
0.42631205916404724,
0.3578377366065979,
-0.04260329529643059,
-1.0422626733779907,
0.9794090390205383,
-0.5219011902809143,
0.21292631328105927,
0.08502105623483658,
-0.8917250037193298,
0.00963403470814228,
0.9555135369300842,
-0.22017402946949005,
0.11356449127197266,
0.6556475162506104,
0.5178834795951843,
-0.21876126527786255,
0.1725376546382904,
0.427310049533844,
0.22684092819690704,
0.3394160866737366,
0.4703894853591919,
1.187443733215332,
0.007672859355807304,
0.7907918691635132,
0.10985283553600311,
0.00128450826741755,
-0.0004937750054523349,
-0.7477856874465942,
-0.7994850873947144,
-0.5481721758842468,
-0.09711170196533203,
-0.39403313398361206,
0.086640365421772,
1.2065725326538086,
0.6805666089057922,
-0.14257089793682098,
-0.7983501553535461,
0.05250375345349312,
0.29579177498817444,
-0.17103569209575653,
-0.22750870883464813,
0.028868786990642548,
-0.17481215298175812,
-0.7271362543106079,
0.6396080851554871,
0.13047538697719574,
0.17618317902088165,
-0.45586636662483215,
-0.4393163323402405,
-0.07177497446537018,
0.44603148102760315,
0.5174127221107483,
0.40954405069351196,
-0.4563671946525574,
-0.13336624205112457,
-0.03999856859445572,
-0.003895056899636984,
-0.14544148743152618,
1.1862918138504028,
-0.6396756172180176,
0.15266723930835724,
0.048565395176410675,
0.5219281911849976,
0.422756165266037,
-0.17535673081874847,
0.700244665145874,
-0.3699377477169037,
0.36916786432266235,
0.35711970925331116,
0.3502160608768463,
0.06025470793247223,
-0.22889553010463715,
0.4685494303703308,
-0.33332106471061707,
-0.8141038417816162,
-0.5391799211502075,
0.5120607018470764,
-0.889093816280365,
-0.40690845251083374,
0.9319427013397217,
-0.04260255768895149,
-0.10495290160179138,
-0.23406442999839783,
-0.3582521975040436,
0.08647779375314713,
-0.5629150867462158,
0.7818351984024048,
0.8581345081329346,
-0.42812857031822205,
0.04344648867845535,
-0.4109992980957031,
0.38844725489616394,
0.6306426525115967,
-0.700419545173645,
-0.17530597746372223,
0.35409680008888245,
-0.0973605290055275,
0.10437566041946411,
1.026201605796814,
0.2548391819000244,
0.14328420162200928,
-0.35914430022239685,
-0.12860658764839172,
0.1244039237499237,
-0.2314651757478714,
-0.3826306164264679,
0.08948817104101181,
0.5548199415206909,
-0.1281299591064453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06690v1 | Neural Models for Source Code Synthesis and Completion | 2024-02-08T17:10:12 | 2024-02-08T17:10:12 | Mitodru Niyogi | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Natural language (NL) to code suggestion systems assist developers in
Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) by translating NL utterances into
compilable code snippet. The current approaches mainly involve hard-coded,
rule-based systems based on semantic parsing. These systems make heavy use of
hand-crafted rules that map patterns in NL or elements in its syntax parse tree
to various query constructs and can only work on a limited subset of NL with a
restricted NL syntax. These systems are unable to extract semantic information
from the coding intents of the developer, and often fail to infer types, names,
and the context of the source code to get accurate system-level code
suggestions. In this master thesis, we present sequence-to-sequence deep
learning models and training paradigms to map NL to general-purpose programming
languages that can assist users with suggestions of source code snippets, given
a NL intent, and also extend auto-completion functionality of the source code
to users while they are writing source code. The developed architecture
incorporates contextual awareness into neural models which generate source code
tokens directly instead of generating parse trees/abstract meaning
representations from the source code and converting them back to source code.
The proposed pretraining strategy and the data augmentation techniques improve
the performance of the proposed architecture. The proposed architecture has
been found to exceed the performance of a neural semantic parser, TranX, based
on the BLEU-4 metric by 10.82%. Thereafter, a finer analysis for the parsable
code translations from the NL intent for CoNaLA challenge was introduced. The
proposed system is bidirectional as it can be also used to generate NL code
documentation given source code. Lastly, a RoBERTa masked language model for
Python was proposed to extend the developed system for code completion. | [
-0.26876136660575867,
-0.3693191409111023,
0.4875050187110901,
0.3497999906539917,
-0.11625942587852478,
0.268250435590744,
-0.5105485916137695,
-0.4096623957157135,
0.17024967074394226,
0.49799907207489014,
-0.39390772581100464,
-0.581230878829956,
-0.25984442234039307,
0.32647913694381714,
-0.5520225167274475,
0.7403786182403564,
0.07324770838022232,
0.059876859188079834,
-0.014599891379475594,
0.21259506046772003,
-0.8609131574630737,
-0.6060559153556824,
-0.48003536462783813,
-0.08475431799888611,
0.27624303102493286,
0.33122768998146057,
0.4262678325176239,
0.45378613471984863,
0.33535659313201904,
0.29058095812797546,
-0.06561774015426636,
0.1093633770942688,
0.06349699944257736,
0.2129695862531662,
-0.08622622489929199,
-0.344607949256897,
-0.406593918800354,
-0.2606116533279419,
0.2773157060146332,
0.6198259592056274,
0.053861115127801895,
0.3185409605503082,
0.1781826913356781,
0.6200282573699951,
-0.47385361790657043,
0.18404027819633484,
-0.5841130018234253,
0.07694946229457855,
0.2806994915008545,
-0.29073023796081543,
-0.4993785619735718,
-0.5057982802391052,
0.28203195333480835,
-0.3803405463695526,
0.05430569127202034,
-0.18125034868717194,
0.36889293789863586,
0.5017131567001343,
0.028293427079916,
-0.7666155099868774,
-0.6344320178031921,
0.4777103066444397,
-1.131163239479065,
0.22371616959571838,
0.35343149304389954,
0.07699476182460785,
-0.09120432287454605,
-0.6718103885650635,
-0.39014267921447754,
-0.5274817943572998,
-0.1574176400899887,
-0.21407540142536163,
-0.002790365368127823,
0.09756094962358475,
0.3672095537185669,
0.26594415307044983,
-0.7277219891548157,
-0.13044418394565582,
-0.42154884338378906,
-0.16880327463150024,
0.49240007996559143,
-0.07995758205652237,
0.3717350959777832,
-0.5263438820838928,
-0.13297836482524872,
0.24736961722373962,
-0.6316553950309753,
0.0022972929291427135,
0.22682395577430725,
0.4356425404548645,
0.018166810274124146,
0.48366421461105347,
-0.3540049195289612,
1.1796966791152954,
-0.11117006093263626,
0.3345507085323334,
0.16130036115646362,
-0.6115358471870422,
-0.4491736888885498,
0.0015810633776709437,
0.6564904451370239,
0.12485333532094955,
0.33937540650367737,
-0.33272168040275574,
-0.14802168309688568,
0.14099866151809692,
0.4854855537414551,
-0.3782583177089691,
-0.02918785810470581,
0.27005890011787415,
-0.4933708906173706,
-0.3348444104194641,
-0.03703485429286957,
-0.6035155653953552,
-0.23882806301116943,
-0.9284839034080505,
0.13134987652301788,
-0.4900420606136322,
-0.3073153495788574,
0.2956448793411255,
-0.10790007561445236,
0.07507198303937912,
0.2181241512298584,
-0.6467519998550415,
-0.05596382915973663,
0.5731486678123474,
0.6694050431251526,
0.05531294271349907,
-0.2540871500968933,
-0.22660920023918152,
0.19366483390331268,
-0.2980521321296692,
0.3642110526561737,
-0.6041808128356934,
-0.1392345279455185,
0.08310176432132721,
-0.21637144684791565,
0.23984825611114502,
-0.5187225937843323,
0.11523645371198654,
-0.5963704586029053,
-0.09694165736436844,
0.15988801419734955,
-0.49731364846229553,
-0.24688969552516937,
0.17973695695400238,
-0.4972325563430786,
0.6450111865997314,
0.12301208078861237,
-0.4140060245990753,
0.10103173553943634,
-0.5594093203544617,
-0.5187879800796509,
0.06631854921579361,
-0.17954440414905548,
0.04850751906633377,
0.16552796959877014,
-0.04577062651515007,
0.31257370114326477,
-0.21188057959079742,
0.7756973505020142,
0.09280796349048615,
-0.4918658137321472,
0.00677243759855628,
-0.05619282275438309,
0.8265945315361023,
0.4829128682613373,
-0.5140248537063599,
0.42162036895751953,
-0.8628503084182739,
0.21209168434143066,
-0.18129794299602509,
-0.5696532130241394,
-0.295888215303421,
-0.1211489737033844,
-0.10854838788509369,
0.2714070677757263,
0.24365246295928955,
-0.05928319692611694,
0.4115339517593384,
-0.4485277533531189,
0.7385500073432922,
0.5296636819839478,
-0.22143857181072235,
0.6081281304359436,
0.14098820090293884,
0.4259721040725708,
-0.1038580983877182,
0.07416076958179474,
-0.38379836082458496,
-0.47657355666160583,
-0.8031196594238281,
0.23060859739780426,
0.47822749614715576,
0.6763330101966858,
-0.9178464412689209,
0.6434687972068787,
-0.16773971915245056,
-0.08700031787157059,
-0.44464966654777527,
0.3946883976459503,
0.5369250774383545,
0.3742155432701111,
0.33908966183662415,
-0.3571597635746002,
-1.0529735088348389,
-0.7979134917259216,
-0.13179631531238556,
-0.05173003301024437,
-0.2015330195426941,
0.03256332501769066,
0.23470835387706757,
-0.30269625782966614,
1.044310212135315,
-0.24220533668994904,
-0.04162953794002533,
-0.30353429913520813,
-0.20712250471115112,
0.5128627419471741,
0.7725340723991394,
0.24006664752960205,
-0.7272447943687439,
-0.322153776884079,
-0.05491827055811882,
-0.7103762626647949,
0.11565781384706497,
-0.11183317005634308,
-0.015111022628843784,
0.1488116979598999,
0.9354933500289917,
-0.42053109407424927,
0.5189969539642334,
0.4191415011882782,
-0.22981879115104675,
0.4467689096927643,
-0.29678672552108765,
-0.35388579964637756,
-1.2260406017303467,
0.37476691603660583,
-0.1837674081325531,
-0.01705262064933777,
-0.6068069934844971,
0.311452716588974,
0.24866130948066711,
-0.3245195746421814,
-0.3023104667663574,
0.23526965081691742,
-0.539641797542572,
-0.17157107591629028,
-0.32058069109916687,
-0.18752795457839966,
0.03213818371295929,
0.7530849575996399,
0.12726043164730072,
0.8275634050369263,
0.5801477432250977,
-0.7592753767967224,
0.2845013439655304,
0.15698844194412231,
-0.337510883808136,
-0.028084663674235344,
-0.7171621322631836,
0.3621287941932678,
-0.015815572813153267,
-0.007622393313795328,
-0.7144469618797302,
-0.13357824087142944,
0.17415057122707367,
-0.5692798495292664,
0.2512631416320801,
-0.41060248017311096,
-0.39722976088523865,
-0.3951246738433838,
0.010152028873562813,
0.5458894968032837,
0.5074686408042908,
-0.2639404237270355,
0.340863436460495,
0.11748036742210388,
-0.13744314014911652,
-0.5371264219284058,
-0.7419994473457336,
0.40999558568000793,
0.2128489464521408,
-0.41222259402275085,
0.34948328137397766,
-0.184498131275177,
0.03782324492931366,
0.059171345084905624,
0.13337403535842896,
-0.0947885662317276,
0.08511626720428467,
0.31557711958885193,
0.34269949793815613,
-0.1904345452785492,
0.04178428277373314,
-0.13302873075008392,
-0.2401726096868515,
0.08184443414211273,
-0.7494195103645325,
0.5813251733779907,
-0.2682209014892578,
-0.26530858874320984,
-0.09401398152112961,
0.45024293661117554,
0.3511109948158264,
-0.4500758945941925,
0.23050878942012787,
0.2258121371269226,
-0.3511292040348053,
-0.3476003110408783,
-0.45962420105934143,
-0.039231058210134506,
-0.44490355253219604,
0.2226618230342865,
-0.2546294331550598,
-0.7662585973739624,
0.448917418718338,
-0.11733587831258774,
-0.0916096493601799,
0.17791461944580078,
0.5242676734924316,
0.21223166584968567,
0.6378233432769775,
0.6649637222290039,
-0.12673251330852509,
0.6175636649131775,
-0.7459540963172913,
0.21283584833145142,
-0.9322136640548706,
-0.04539814591407776,
-0.4441685676574707,
-0.30889904499053955,
-0.2620835602283478,
-0.35528814792633057,
0.06411557644605637,
0.15048925578594208,
-0.23010596632957458,
0.7744250297546387,
-0.9722992181777954,
0.5665001273155212,
1.006240725517273,
0.0663277879357338,
0.22058194875717163,
0.04138992354273796,
-0.28150036931037903,
0.2916814088821411,
-0.7270002961158752,
-0.32544127106666565,
1.0945217609405518,
0.11889216303825378,
0.43530726432800293,
-0.08497302979230881,
0.7241894006729126,
0.34102922677993774,
0.09022822976112366,
-0.6141533255577087,
0.5040370225906372,
-0.09614142030477524,
-0.423383891582489,
-0.14160311222076416,
-0.2422105073928833,
-0.5990681052207947,
-0.3025692403316498,
0.08954939991235733,
-0.3019571900367737,
0.43894413113594055,
-0.03142247349023819,
-0.7622065544128418,
0.10080241411924362,
-0.8724859356880188,
0.8001846075057983,
-0.09180265665054321,
-0.27130788564682007,
-0.06375668942928314,
-0.7889620065689087,
0.22350984811782837,
0.1482396274805069,
0.012647543102502823,
0.157707080245018,
0.17747268080711365,
0.38189825415611267,
-0.19496534764766693,
0.9883184432983398,
-0.11249328404664993,
-0.1523919254541397,
0.3952898681163788,
0.22351069748401642,
0.26065221428871155,
0.2567492425441742,
-0.43609070777893066,
0.2082626074552536,
-0.2876371741294861,
-0.17123940587043762,
-0.4118090569972992,
0.5951314568519592,
-0.4514346718788147,
-0.46042999625205994,
-0.10617083311080933,
-0.6022506952285767,
-0.009373372420668602,
0.4151388108730316,
0.31705808639526367,
0.5797205567359924,
0.17945155501365662,
-0.09192817658185959,
0.44128724932670593,
-0.36251112818717957,
0.7458670735359192,
0.3116995096206665,
-0.16242507100105286,
-0.5728170275688171,
0.7917851209640503,
-0.09827473759651184,
0.0409751757979393,
0.178388774394989,
-0.33436810970306396,
-0.08837956935167313,
-0.8264456987380981,
-0.6445743441581726,
-0.08453136682510376,
-0.6525843143463135,
-0.6560648679733276,
-0.286160409450531,
-0.5254707932472229,
-0.46393367648124695,
-0.22746756672859192,
-0.0784270167350769,
-0.3933192789554596,
-0.2919660806655884,
-0.043720733374357224,
0.309714674949646,
0.89394211769104,
0.10504443943500519,
0.03546495735645294,
-0.801271378993988,
0.25236108899116516,
0.21531231701374054,
0.7146631479263306,
0.2704874575138092,
-0.24771751463413239,
-0.4790078103542328,
0.0995900109410286,
-0.15305577218532562,
-0.7941479682922363,
0.5616637468338013,
-0.15819823741912842,
0.36291664838790894,
-0.09689676016569138,
-0.07625573128461838,
0.37510615587234497,
-0.6061291694641113,
0.6820573806762695,
0.09013068675994873,
-1.0787725448608398,
0.9701993465423584,
-0.286857008934021,
0.2805524468421936,
0.6933746933937073,
-0.029767783358693123,
-0.4543278217315674,
-0.3979223370552063,
-0.26181522011756897,
-0.750853955745697,
0.6437687277793884,
0.20235835015773773,
0.12842851877212524,
-0.14249245822429657,
0.6556335091590881,
0.05542703717947006,
0.37821298837661743,
-0.5895580053329468,
-0.13033165037631989,
-0.36507168412208557,
-0.356411337852478,
0.12393750250339508,
-0.19281251728534698,
0.15184707939624786,
-0.46822845935821533,
0.29358744621276855,
-0.38856783509254456,
0.344024658203125,
0.41251125931739807,
-0.2793658673763275,
0.10660997033119202,
0.2899288237094879,
0.971813440322876,
0.8722844123840332,
-0.2562881112098694,
-0.04461827501654625,
-0.16804073750972748,
-0.2421271950006485,
0.09245116263628006,
0.03436734899878502,
-0.5752357840538025,
0.15916040539741516,
0.16209855675697327,
0.9359437823295593,
0.23015196621418,
-0.5542609691619873,
0.369619756937027,
-0.06687448173761368,
0.03620936721563339,
-0.5663482546806335,
0.15208610892295837,
0.23875366151332855,
0.19829337298870087,
0.24614748358726501,
0.6105093955993652,
0.38473784923553467,
-0.49576783180236816,
0.2808007001876831,
0.44750866293907166,
-0.19123733043670654,
-0.3530080020427704,
0.5234630107879639,
0.3622652590274811,
-0.5937153100967407,
0.5941305160522461,
-0.2269943207502365,
-0.5544518828392029,
0.9752728343009949,
0.5321254134178162,
1.2263672351837158,
0.05738021060824394,
0.11850950121879578,
0.5104629397392273,
0.11114019900560379,
0.04759664461016655,
0.31821510195732117,
-0.29377907514572144,
-0.35013535618782043,
-0.7730892300605774,
-0.7921047210693359,
-0.09140569716691971,
-0.14908891916275024,
-0.4100434184074402,
0.34192806482315063,
-0.7503751516342163,
-0.16508719325065613,
-0.2501972019672394,
-0.24877400696277618,
-0.6701474189758301,
0.007461337838321924,
0.4010385274887085,
1.2267341613769531,
-0.35350391268730164,
1.1520609855651855,
0.6520867347717285,
-0.7240279316902161,
-0.9333099722862244,
-0.15263889729976654,
-0.40736842155456543,
-0.5587406158447266,
0.8750656247138977,
0.09413731098175049,
0.21282555162906647,
0.023398475721478462,
-0.5487872958183289,
-0.9375240802764893,
0.8731109499931335,
0.5236648321151733,
-0.5573172569274902,
-0.5949563980102539,
0.16344472765922546,
0.5786449909210205,
-0.5427013635635376,
0.27355197072029114,
0.5000867247581482,
0.3604171872138977,
-0.014136253856122494,
-1.0221683979034424,
0.13077419996261597,
-0.5651459097862244,
0.410920649766922,
0.06371604651212692,
-0.2723643481731415,
0.7080075144767761,
-0.33143338561058044,
0.060044050216674805,
0.17669124901294708,
0.5113286972045898,
0.1477242112159729,
0.22755585610866547,
0.15967106819152832,
0.44498056173324585,
0.3308931887149811,
0.1429903507232666,
1.0943377017974854,
-0.6826665997505188,
0.1434015929698944,
1.1749439239501953,
-0.0846157968044281,
0.8925539255142212,
0.4927934408187866,
0.007406060583889484,
0.6622936725616455,
0.45874011516571045,
0.015322109684348106,
0.5515421032905579,
0.33475279808044434,
0.11379304528236389,
0.055272240191698074,
-0.05591099336743355,
-0.542555570602417,
0.12308516353368759,
0.3465610146522522,
-0.5209447145462036,
-0.15816174447536469,
-0.017966005951166153,
-0.47372734546661377,
0.08159390091896057,
-0.2604050934314728,
1.0534831285476685,
0.1930624544620514,
-0.9027723073959351,
0.9015011787414551,
-0.06405613571405411,
0.8531385660171509,
-0.6513417363166809,
-0.21425189077854156,
-0.4531809091567993,
0.050599172711372375,
-0.36380207538604736,
-0.553775429725647,
0.6503418684005737,
-0.09115409106016159,
-0.4326244592666626,
-0.2996457517147064,
0.639245331287384,
-0.6132238507270813,
-0.34021085500717163,
0.4025470018386841,
0.26431187987327576,
-0.28153663873672485,
-0.027080893516540527,
-0.5708486437797546,
0.04010682553052902,
0.2532607913017273,
0.09966839104890823,
0.13566195964813232,
0.22836977243423462,
0.14252717792987823,
0.6152694821357727,
0.7289304137229919,
0.23763036727905273,
0.2964676320552826,
0.12774516642093658,
0.8506708741188049,
-0.7815954089164734,
-0.5109772086143494,
-0.8137331604957581,
0.49167099595069885,
-0.03825864940881729,
-0.10734618455171585,
0.6299818158149719,
0.437701016664505,
1.0139491558074951,
-0.45477041602134705,
0.7817431092262268,
-0.2109595537185669,
0.17393623292446136,
-0.6751281023025513,
0.623461127281189,
-0.2485869824886322,
0.5666899085044861,
-0.2726817727088928,
-1.0989086627960205,
-0.35860955715179443,
0.36643391847610474,
-0.14406216144561768,
-0.07520108669996262,
0.4676811099052429,
0.7485300898551941,
-0.046571359038352966,
-0.013393573462963104,
0.11845458298921585,
-0.15404118597507477,
0.20135462284088135,
0.8678985834121704,
0.7627260088920593,
-0.4562859535217285,
0.4764181971549988,
-0.2479388564825058,
0.08962469547986984,
-0.2429720014333725,
-0.8189494013786316,
-0.585791826248169,
-0.712687075138092,
-0.23972168564796448,
-0.39975088834762573,
-0.08595626801252365,
1.145342469215393,
0.8984103798866272,
-1.0116320848464966,
-0.4142184257507324,
-0.5357415676116943,
0.2293590009212494,
-0.060010913759469986,
-0.21030323207378387,
0.35624778270721436,
-0.744113564491272,
-0.5288777947425842,
0.576425313949585,
0.40487268567085266,
0.018941935151815414,
-0.30400827527046204,
-0.26232820749282837,
-0.2519839107990265,
-0.21805964410305023,
0.631853461265564,
0.37318047881126404,
-0.8805606365203857,
0.10301277041435242,
0.12892048060894012,
-0.29447126388549805,
0.04123346507549286,
1.0915886163711548,
-1.0460119247436523,
0.34680822491645813,
0.6864610910415649,
0.90720134973526,
-0.08411435037851334,
-0.21819354593753815,
0.8117132186889648,
-0.9202682375907898,
0.39282023906707764,
0.373446524143219,
0.3144356310367584,
0.28053194284439087,
-0.5425216555595398,
0.6418958902359009,
-0.04947153851389885,
-0.3745143413543701,
-0.6685315370559692,
0.21361935138702393,
-0.7586829662322998,
-0.4502353072166443,
1.0803687572479248,
0.012074875645339489,
-0.3331648111343384,
-0.18507640063762665,
-0.37316033244132996,
0.17920802533626556,
-0.34789812564849854,
0.5621946454048157,
0.46092817187309265,
0.1213177740573883,
-0.03903883323073387,
-0.5633102655410767,
0.9044632911682129,
0.4404095411300659,
-0.5989604592323303,
0.15687984228134155,
0.5146011114120483,
0.20464326441287994,
0.5854193568229675,
0.6120744347572327,
-0.012584961019456387,
0.433574378490448,
-0.3880758583545685,
0.29499322175979614,
-0.3523489236831665,
-0.4041141867637634,
-0.585304856300354,
0.1809985488653183,
0.15905074775218964,
0.011033875867724419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05827v1 | Is it Possible to Edit Large Language Models Robustly? | 2024-02-08T17:06:45 | 2024-02-08T17:06:45 | Xinbei Ma, Tianjie Ju, Jiyang Qiu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao, Lifeng Liu, Yulong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have played a pivotal role in building
communicative AI to imitate human behaviors but face the challenge of efficient
customization. To tackle this challenge, recent studies have delved into the
realm of model editing, which manipulates specific memories of language models
and changes the related language generation. However, the robustness of model
editing remains an open question. This work seeks to understand the strengths
and limitations of editing methods, thus facilitating robust, realistic
applications of communicative AI. Concretely, we conduct extensive analysis to
address the three key research questions. Q1: Can edited LLMs behave
consistently resembling communicative AI in realistic situations? Q2: To what
extent does the rephrasing of prompts lead LLMs to deviate from the edited
knowledge memory? Q3: Which knowledge features are correlated with the
performance and robustness of editing? Our experimental results uncover a
substantial disparity between existing editing methods and the practical
application of LLMs. On rephrased prompts that are complex and flexible but
common in realistic applications, the performance of editing experiences a
significant decline. Further analysis shows that more popular knowledge is
memorized better, easier to recall, and more challenging to edit effectively. | [
-0.12008719146251678,
-1.18704092502594,
0.6263492703437805,
0.001336508896201849,
0.122266985476017,
0.19272030889987946,
-0.6709513664245605,
-0.6470364332199097,
-0.12959511578083038,
0.31443852186203003,
-0.2026108354330063,
-0.208187073469162,
-0.6274500489234924,
0.21375510096549988,
-0.35116976499557495,
0.5546543598175049,
-0.034542351961135864,
0.12464810162782669,
-0.2246551215648651,
-0.39343780279159546,
-0.6380236744880676,
-0.8182385563850403,
-0.7254371643066406,
-0.19515769183635712,
0.3825812339782715,
0.2570390999317169,
1.1409382820129395,
0.946938693523407,
0.4018198847770691,
0.5049281716346741,
-0.7719127535820007,
0.1803230494260788,
-0.6173182725906372,
0.422393798828125,
-0.14732949435710907,
-0.7583448886871338,
-0.7944380640983582,
0.00016673773643560708,
0.9432094693183899,
0.7571282386779785,
-0.056146278977394104,
-0.2089739888906479,
0.3538666367530823,
0.4454878568649292,
-0.3729284703731537,
0.16891635954380035,
-0.8938624858856201,
-0.33705800771713257,
-0.03572088107466698,
0.06365969032049179,
-0.463847279548645,
-0.06101738661527634,
0.08321351557970047,
-0.633761465549469,
-0.04586951807141304,
-0.11821840703487396,
0.6870574355125427,
0.41068074107170105,
-0.05250219628214836,
-0.44055089354515076,
-0.8247141242027283,
0.7280662655830383,
-0.8904625177383423,
0.3508175313472748,
0.34557783603668213,
0.10908366739749908,
-0.24127236008644104,
-0.6080904603004456,
-0.5561937689781189,
-0.20394620299339294,
-0.006330735515803099,
-0.27840402722358704,
-0.2910555899143219,
0.2501049339771271,
0.6246242523193359,
0.16135111451148987,
-0.33064213395118713,
0.4485883116722107,
-0.15855734050273895,
-0.19127441942691803,
0.5779324173927307,
0.37141111493110657,
0.6302634477615356,
-0.09206202626228333,
0.20901399850845337,
-0.09681396186351776,
-0.6243281364440918,
0.16949795186519623,
0.2742656171321869,
0.15671026706695557,
0.015561788342893124,
0.7041944861412048,
-0.1575421690940857,
0.8156107068061829,
0.005210006609559059,
-0.45303305983543396,
-0.21055088937282562,
-0.24069571495056152,
-0.3531941771507263,
-0.4325958490371704,
0.634560227394104,
0.4719390273094177,
0.4154324531555176,
-0.05681231617927551,
-0.24267785251140594,
-0.1383534073829651,
0.11384084820747375,
-0.5329794883728027,
-0.19034603238105774,
0.23937605321407318,
-0.4841993749141693,
-0.32494091987609863,
-0.34015166759490967,
-0.40017539262771606,
-0.40035480260849,
-0.34890925884246826,
0.20363986492156982,
-0.5986214876174927,
0.16740809381008148,
0.18976856768131256,
-0.09327902644872665,
-0.08884093165397644,
0.8006551861763,
-0.7665271759033203,
0.004190663807094097,
0.8658483624458313,
0.6817508935928345,
-0.05881967395544052,
-0.5692318677902222,
-0.42299094796180725,
0.05941499397158623,
-0.2878251373767853,
0.5367008447647095,
-0.8561156988143921,
-0.4421537220478058,
-0.14215198159217834,
-0.1552509069442749,
-0.12486760318279266,
-0.5450305938720703,
0.32216382026672363,
-0.7227495908737183,
-0.016646847128868103,
-0.3341027796268463,
-0.8236493468284607,
-0.0255796667188406,
0.4009574353694916,
-0.6604019999504089,
0.5556414723396301,
-0.13938851654529572,
-0.7704994082450867,
0.0895741879940033,
-0.29610055685043335,
-0.34023624658584595,
-0.44159576296806335,
0.1178789734840393,
-0.2708335220813751,
0.17255638539791107,
0.3183375298976898,
0.3480580449104309,
-0.04535055533051491,
0.5003501176834106,
-0.41734856367111206,
-0.31549280881881714,
0.7218051552772522,
-0.6983433961868286,
0.7819046974182129,
0.30060094594955444,
0.054776206612586975,
0.2820492386817932,
-0.7179397940635681,
-0.1616280972957611,
-0.1346774697303772,
-0.6163808107376099,
-0.2339031994342804,
-0.08945289999246597,
-0.22512218356132507,
-0.05297735705971718,
0.2292604297399521,
-0.24245603382587433,
0.5541808605194092,
-0.2353864312171936,
0.5338677167892456,
0.9187771081924438,
0.02967301569879055,
0.46323537826538086,
-0.697697103023529,
0.7136479020118713,
-0.22029399871826172,
0.09993202984333038,
-0.3246172368526459,
-0.455914169549942,
-0.7220529913902283,
-0.55096036195755,
0.46155717968940735,
0.6843147873878479,
-0.6665416955947876,
0.1305677890777588,
-0.20535744726657867,
-0.5339184999465942,
-0.40960559248924255,
0.28656578063964844,
0.2966303527355194,
0.4450890123844147,
0.17207391560077667,
0.040632206946611404,
-0.4040466845035553,
-0.7324682474136353,
-0.742601215839386,
-0.2779712378978729,
0.04729350283741951,
0.23912933468818665,
0.23249851167201996,
-0.05980965495109558,
0.7040809392929077,
-0.2587120234966278,
0.3616493046283722,
-0.4251939058303833,
-0.06941714137792587,
0.10016298294067383,
0.4774831235408783,
0.4996553361415863,
-0.4118703603744507,
-0.3705168664455414,
-0.22688016295433044,
-0.7235783934593201,
-0.26410672068595886,
-0.4054540991783142,
0.22822490334510803,
0.17401082813739777,
0.695475161075592,
-0.9792732000350952,
0.4841868579387665,
0.33754459023475647,
-0.13597053289413452,
0.5837084650993347,
-0.5309359431266785,
0.23432563245296478,
-0.9698894619941711,
0.01740160770714283,
-0.2969806492328644,
-0.19573815166950226,
-0.8139841556549072,
0.3795187771320343,
0.013458626344799995,
-0.07296416908502579,
-0.41996413469314575,
0.5287678241729736,
-0.4731218218803406,
0.15390007197856903,
-0.3448573350906372,
0.15404409170150757,
-0.09130261838436127,
0.2452109307050705,
-0.2405853569507599,
0.5634150505065918,
0.5908857583999634,
-0.6668704152107239,
0.3481189012527466,
0.42728859186172485,
-0.6436269283294678,
0.4764740467071533,
-0.8720796704292297,
0.19779279828071594,
-0.21650026738643646,
0.21810291707515717,
-0.7831413745880127,
-0.4088384211063385,
0.0727786123752594,
-0.32973602414131165,
0.3939898610115051,
0.03541065379977226,
-0.5987877249717712,
0.2493128925561905,
-0.21993258595466614,
0.31823620200157166,
0.35055744647979736,
-0.44125840067863464,
0.5730798840522766,
0.30591365694999695,
-0.6045325994491577,
-0.5271069407463074,
-0.6288301944732666,
0.3605893552303314,
-0.28710952401161194,
-0.8282342553138733,
-0.03036409430205822,
-0.28173086047172546,
-0.7629238963127136,
-0.1755242645740509,
0.3194127380847931,
0.0002760406059678644,
0.511654794216156,
0.12328392267227173,
0.3223632872104645,
-0.015622220933437347,
0.07260993868112564,
0.06587700545787811,
-0.0036929550115019083,
-0.14888250827789307,
0.41394081711769104,
0.31169265508651733,
0.19110098481178284,
-0.4198378324508667,
-0.7680194973945618,
0.33988282084465027,
0.9947529435157776,
-0.29954794049263,
0.5794317126274109,
0.10597267001867294,
-0.36040154099464417,
-0.10031305253505707,
-0.4795025587081909,
-0.06389066576957703,
-0.4754849374294281,
0.4506883919239044,
-0.4707117974758148,
-1.2195661067962646,
0.6861015558242798,
0.03924484923481941,
0.19141781330108643,
0.19072775542736053,
0.5188150405883789,
-0.0621633380651474,
1.0424741506576538,
0.5268387794494629,
-0.16988509893417358,
0.4046545624732971,
0.05042349547147751,
0.17473265528678894,
-0.7994615435600281,
0.16962407529354095,
-0.8165568113327026,
-0.40685778856277466,
-0.7168849110603333,
-0.3961818814277649,
0.2702276110649109,
0.1762266457080841,
0.056639038026332855,
0.01903003267943859,
-0.07253269106149673,
0.41004788875579834,
0.5123812556266785,
0.0009804072324186563,
0.5014145970344543,
-0.2999967336654663,
0.19339390099048615,
-0.07816612720489502,
-0.9164334535598755,
-0.7669800519943237,
0.9921163320541382,
0.551781952381134,
0.9769313931465149,
0.22215570509433746,
0.2659601867198944,
0.10154786705970764,
0.21696986258029938,
-0.6544848084449768,
0.6701711416244507,
0.03577328473329544,
-0.6019988656044006,
-0.41175577044487,
-0.2016385793685913,
-0.6629783511161804,
0.053943101316690445,
-0.5143705606460571,
-0.8741719722747803,
0.2511107623577118,
0.4259438216686249,
-0.3789990246295929,
0.606741726398468,
-0.7006251215934753,
0.6236622929573059,
-0.0789896547794342,
-0.2770058810710907,
-0.3262719213962555,
-0.5681836009025574,
0.20019298791885376,
-0.16819390654563904,
0.39654168486595154,
0.19624346494674683,
0.08617445826530457,
0.3776569366455078,
-0.4643382728099823,
0.9888394474983215,
0.1167595162987709,
-0.07658465951681137,
0.2586193084716797,
0.300411581993103,
0.7409347891807556,
0.1995665282011032,
-0.44886884093284607,
-0.03436723351478577,
0.06735830754041672,
-0.3342236578464508,
-0.9605744481086731,
0.5621532797813416,
-0.6637738347053528,
-0.9646952748298645,
-0.2337997406721115,
-1.0262446403503418,
-0.2809489667415619,
0.017691226676106453,
0.06223384663462639,
0.5198714137077332,
-0.2880021333694458,
0.21377524733543396,
0.4919264018535614,
-0.5342305302619934,
0.5044467449188232,
0.24791623651981354,
-0.2716160714626312,
-0.33370646834373474,
0.7826443314552307,
0.3156316876411438,
0.474934846162796,
0.24850554764270782,
0.2735373079776764,
0.10668888688087463,
-0.8705635070800781,
-0.3408098816871643,
0.11024121195077896,
-0.7861220836639404,
0.21136651933193207,
-0.780957043170929,
-0.03780914843082428,
-0.3739009499549866,
-0.42039042711257935,
-0.2708567976951599,
-0.575299859046936,
-0.4167214334011078,
-0.0184920784085989,
0.22563911974430084,
1.0221892595291138,
-0.23592424392700195,
0.32598555088043213,
-0.8256704807281494,
0.2864687144756317,
0.4078165292739868,
0.17497028410434723,
0.07103493064641953,
-0.5449234843254089,
-0.13178390264511108,
0.2542110085487366,
-0.10177482664585114,
-0.7341539859771729,
0.2307402789592743,
0.17798615992069244,
0.48310959339141846,
0.30377885699272156,
-0.018989719450473785,
0.8277400135993958,
-0.24475793540477753,
0.8757779002189636,
-0.3770778775215149,
-1.0651099681854248,
0.24385784566402435,
-0.42163988947868347,
0.39907243847846985,
0.3220177888870239,
0.07653196156024933,
-0.40652212500572205,
-0.80879807472229,
-0.6648728847503662,
-0.3528731167316437,
0.5779085755348206,
0.042258620262145996,
0.247226282954216,
0.17086243629455566,
0.6843400001525879,
0.05319599807262421,
0.03987554460763931,
-0.2920113503932953,
-0.0992508977651596,
0.08762230724096298,
0.01118373405188322,
-0.18669579923152924,
-0.6191878318786621,
0.008171459659934044,
-0.3307057321071625,
0.5284465551376343,
0.19570255279541016,
-0.06390047818422318,
0.1257597655057907,
-0.144597589969635,
-0.004708744119852781,
0.5972375273704529,
0.8866432309150696,
0.7949406504631042,
-0.13936875760555267,
0.0300619974732399,
0.4602613151073456,
-0.3007645308971405,
0.031177887693047523,
-0.2428097128868103,
-0.4967188835144043,
-0.1069696769118309,
0.6934948563575745,
0.8979042172431946,
0.10893944650888443,
-0.7753407955169678,
0.09555058926343918,
-0.23850782215595245,
-0.13171231746673584,
0.1546901911497116,
0.3176313638687134,
0.11735531687736511,
0.3776925504207611,
-0.11717282235622406,
0.32391592860221863,
-0.15619827806949615,
-0.7085539698600769,
-0.0501103401184082,
0.5354440808296204,
-0.06779839098453522,
-0.3330622911453247,
0.6605029702186584,
-0.00187725352589041,
-0.5562937259674072,
0.5730713605880737,
0.06270483136177063,
-0.4912642240524292,
0.35039713978767395,
0.44129228591918945,
0.4953596293926239,
-0.27170005440711975,
-0.13034914433956146,
0.24919122457504272,
0.47851529717445374,
-0.13568460941314697,
0.06911660730838776,
0.22781507670879364,
-0.8438251614570618,
-0.49917566776275635,
-0.09438753128051758,
-0.6731383800506592,
0.2833257019519806,
-0.5603847503662109,
0.25721898674964905,
-0.5576698184013367,
-0.2165355384349823,
0.029139772057533264,
-0.4120643138885498,
-0.5383402705192566,
0.2736825942993164,
-0.3094013035297394,
0.9814648628234863,
-0.5510919094085693,
0.892227292060852,
0.8218556046485901,
0.10622972249984741,
-1.0187084674835205,
-0.04438145086169243,
0.19596551358699799,
-0.5215964913368225,
0.1772434413433075,
-0.09081733226776123,
0.13339745998382568,
-0.17134834825992584,
-0.7904832363128662,
-0.7326393127441406,
0.833648145198822,
0.7057504653930664,
-0.5105229020118713,
-0.1516379863023758,
-0.0015264649409800768,
0.6230252385139465,
-0.17602579295635223,
0.21777880191802979,
0.564927339553833,
0.5684641599655151,
0.0054227677173912525,
-1.1316211223602295,
-0.09297899901866913,
-0.28773078322410583,
-0.002453853143379092,
-0.2860712707042694,
-0.6645169854164124,
0.8341811299324036,
-0.3342093825340271,
-0.13216695189476013,
0.43036937713623047,
0.5187984704971313,
0.12433183193206787,
0.04028069227933884,
0.38705921173095703,
0.5855313539505005,
0.9209017753601074,
0.05213621258735657,
1.0918586254119873,
-0.49811479449272156,
0.10836144536733627,
1.2305089235305786,
-0.21141953766345978,
0.8014266490936279,
0.43661367893218994,
0.08046720176935196,
0.1293792575597763,
0.44142332673072815,
0.1900806725025177,
0.033472940325737,
0.08067245036363602,
-0.19243350625038147,
-0.4234442114830017,
0.04127969220280647,
-0.18786515295505524,
0.7905272245407104,
0.28983473777770996,
-0.25435781478881836,
0.14657501876354218,
-0.056041594594717026,
0.36108851432800293,
0.20954588055610657,
-0.1238030418753624,
0.6899611353874207,
-0.05087373033165932,
-0.8187897801399231,
0.45708167552948,
0.19243302941322327,
0.5289098620414734,
-0.3542207181453705,
-0.04864748567342758,
-0.04292185977101326,
0.02855805680155754,
0.004806633107364178,
-0.7661094069480896,
0.45007407665252686,
0.22512416541576385,
0.0005727114621549845,
-0.2632562518119812,
0.8411508798599243,
-0.30439093708992004,
-0.3617386817932129,
-0.13506174087524414,
0.6730443239212036,
-0.03971165418624878,
0.07081414014101028,
-0.5159422755241394,
0.6171993613243103,
0.02326899580657482,
-0.35016846656799316,
0.2869698405265808,
0.4523310661315918,
0.03294222429394722,
1.038219690322876,
0.6014062166213989,
0.3119027018547058,
-0.053900498896837234,
-0.3496490716934204,
0.8038504719734192,
-0.6080563068389893,
-0.32534661889076233,
-0.9301614165306091,
0.6804272532463074,
0.0011673260014504194,
-0.2661192715167999,
0.7514318227767944,
0.22264206409454346,
0.7435157895088196,
-0.09711522608995438,
1.0068461894989014,
0.07263060659170151,
0.4019436836242676,
-0.6858944296836853,
0.8619055151939392,
-0.2674175500869751,
0.5108862519264221,
-0.44030314683914185,
-0.7441779375076294,
-0.4629189372062683,
0.5225831270217896,
-0.22430889308452606,
0.06838160753250122,
0.39056748151779175,
1.0086525678634644,
0.14536824822425842,
0.10309332609176636,
0.5588301420211792,
0.6780114769935608,
0.45712247490882874,
0.27360472083091736,
1.0324445962905884,
-0.1444445699453354,
0.20709188282489777,
-0.3660762906074524,
-0.1928335577249527,
-0.11721760779619217,
-0.971756100654602,
-1.092220425605774,
-0.4653700292110443,
-0.3028540015220642,
-0.21874362230300903,
0.18972896039485931,
0.9690949320793152,
0.40867897868156433,
-0.5384902358055115,
-0.1825311779975891,
0.2762276828289032,
0.43820902705192566,
-0.13215211033821106,
-0.12742197513580322,
0.31556299328804016,
-0.10495828837156296,
-0.8596931099891663,
0.6139606237411499,
0.2564007341861725,
0.10448693484067917,
-0.048178501427173615,
-0.07980283349752426,
-0.030168388038873672,
0.28102320432662964,
0.5226594805717468,
0.32175883650779724,
-0.6729135513305664,
-0.6460979580879211,
0.11037787795066833,
-0.13535594940185547,
-0.0339263379573822,
0.6761141419410706,
-0.38029593229293823,
0.7116619944572449,
0.6056563258171082,
0.7109081745147705,
-0.14840273559093475,
0.11550253629684448,
0.8052273988723755,
-0.3346290588378906,
0.05977542698383331,
-0.03971044346690178,
0.5093336701393127,
0.4927884638309479,
-0.15317696332931519,
0.04432586207985878,
0.14308100938796997,
-0.8340855240821838,
-0.8528484106063843,
0.11993782222270966,
-1.0834561586380005,
-0.20433834195137024,
1.3047763109207153,
-0.3173457086086273,
-0.14455099403858185,
-0.18773816525936127,
-0.5158683061599731,
0.3360222280025482,
-0.04387792572379112,
0.8146341443061829,
1.0155370235443115,
-0.20842845737934113,
-0.2722782492637634,
-0.4688383638858795,
0.3405310809612274,
0.4542585611343384,
-0.6579751968383789,
0.14556759595870972,
0.7412670850753784,
0.3802545964717865,
-0.1127040758728981,
0.40732309222221375,
0.06922169029712677,
0.4063037037849426,
-0.13108280301094055,
-0.24463263154029846,
-0.1886071413755417,
-0.21457861363887787,
-0.5563675761222839,
0.21163244545459747,
0.7405893206596375,
0.3285270929336548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05819v1 | Integrating Self-supervised Speech Model with Pseudo Word-level Targets from Visually-grounded Speech Model | 2024-02-08T16:55:21 | 2024-02-08T16:55:21 | Hung-Chieh Fang, Nai-Xuan Ye, Yi-Jen Shih, Puyuan Peng, Hsuan-Fu Wang, Layne Berry, Hung-yi Lee, David Harwath | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in self-supervised speech models have shown significant
improvement in many downstream tasks. However, these models predominantly
centered on frame-level training objectives, which can fall short in spoken
language understanding tasks that require semantic comprehension. Existing
works often rely on additional speech-text data as intermediate targets, which
is costly in the real-world setting. To address this challenge, we propose
Pseudo-Word HuBERT (PW-HuBERT), a framework that integrates pseudo word-level
targets into the training process, where the targets are derived from a
visually-ground speech model, notably eliminating the need for speech-text
paired data. Our experimental results on four spoken language understanding
(SLU) benchmarks suggest the superiority of our model in capturing semantic
information. | [
-0.41711100935935974,
-0.7320464253425598,
0.7752901315689087,
0.09218745678663254,
-0.22964885830879211,
-0.3305748999118805,
-0.04247204214334488,
-0.5685967803001404,
0.3226926922798157,
0.42270779609680176,
-0.5291067361831665,
-0.5109300017356873,
-0.48690542578697205,
-0.18155919015407562,
-0.7054625749588013,
0.7940959334373474,
-0.009572910144925117,
-0.1226101666688919,
-0.22100120782852173,
0.13264654576778412,
-0.43918710947036743,
-0.5909487009048462,
-0.1624063402414322,
-0.22738724946975708,
0.5556886792182922,
0.49649766087532043,
0.509876012802124,
0.7216829061508179,
0.21317821741104126,
0.2812022864818573,
0.20765084028244019,
-0.15036384761333466,
-0.6208858489990234,
-0.2954384684562683,
-0.2589256465435028,
-0.34716758131980896,
-0.44748178124427795,
0.507240355014801,
0.8499944806098938,
0.8858904838562012,
-0.2067134976387024,
0.24225810170173645,
0.031447745859622955,
0.29576563835144043,
-0.673550546169281,
0.24323709309101105,
-0.6646724939346313,
0.15468542277812958,
-0.05259041488170624,
-0.07054930925369263,
-0.3638501763343811,
0.28648340702056885,
0.4472000300884247,
-0.771152675151825,
0.10891030728816986,
0.146315336227417,
1.0134334564208984,
0.18524233996868134,
0.08769779652357101,
-0.0016695951344445348,
-0.38115236163139343,
0.8472505807876587,
-0.6139584183692932,
0.5230153799057007,
0.6560959219932556,
0.10784730315208435,
0.05101538076996803,
-0.9133230447769165,
-0.5888220071792603,
-0.3420507311820984,
-0.30013710260391235,
0.36442527174949646,
-0.497877299785614,
0.2754523754119873,
0.2152000069618225,
0.10463658720254898,
-0.6862466931343079,
-0.07390966266393661,
-0.3177124261856079,
-0.23154890537261963,
0.46001479029655457,
-0.07438962161540985,
0.34621208906173706,
-0.4290449023246765,
-0.4196580946445465,
0.008352512493729591,
-0.20898808538913727,
-0.023316640406847,
0.12859612703323364,
0.38949182629585266,
-0.3882072865962982,
0.6260506510734558,
-0.42885228991508484,
1.1150919198989868,
0.20576684176921844,
-0.24561089277267456,
0.1286730319261551,
-0.27691611647605896,
-0.21470889449119568,
0.3894360661506653,
0.5999385714530945,
0.1755073517560959,
0.4365292489528656,
-0.3413920998573303,
-0.24911732971668243,
0.1590207815170288,
0.29565736651420593,
-0.6236938834190369,
-0.7345279455184937,
0.06839899718761444,
-0.4499419927597046,
-0.20918907225131989,
0.029531266540288925,
-0.32251203060150146,
0.3756496012210846,
-0.6198392510414124,
0.8458137512207031,
-0.5112009048461914,
-0.4883054196834564,
-0.09555219858884811,
-0.35460102558135986,
0.3102075159549713,
0.13872405886650085,
-0.8070477843284607,
0.1613466739654541,
0.49411702156066895,
1.0052413940429688,
-0.11563152819871902,
-0.5306218266487122,
-0.8918202519416809,
0.4140392243862152,
-0.6617224812507629,
0.665536105632782,
-0.4418846666812897,
-0.45468670129776,
-0.2635876536369324,
-0.2997867465019226,
-0.11912768334150314,
-0.3896004259586334,
0.18900002539157867,
-0.24675248563289642,
0.48980382084846497,
-0.08963882923126221,
-0.6372323632240295,
-0.18840216100215912,
0.12338310480117798,
-0.08056648820638657,
1.25137197971344,
0.35123956203460693,
-0.8721198439598083,
0.42282232642173767,
-0.3413757383823395,
-0.3439774215221405,
0.20850272476673126,
-0.38394057750701904,
-0.2081688493490219,
0.2744099497795105,
0.29951605200767517,
0.6238226890563965,
0.04236665368080139,
0.622181236743927,
-0.39322036504745483,
-0.5256962180137634,
-0.0061325803399086,
-0.3029627203941345,
0.4005713164806366,
0.06505987048149109,
-0.49551427364349365,
0.24224215745925903,
-0.9649853706359863,
0.0994056686758995,
0.1556629091501236,
0.1835324466228485,
-0.6139004826545715,
-0.13221858441829681,
0.029788848012685776,
0.39413371682167053,
0.4583192765712738,
-0.42378851771354675,
-0.2756475508213043,
-0.41740211844444275,
0.28795474767684937,
0.5564371943473816,
-0.22110547125339508,
0.6172429323196411,
-0.09790707379579544,
0.3511011600494385,
-0.09723230451345444,
0.059944137930870056,
-0.17405110597610474,
-0.5150277614593506,
-0.6836880445480347,
-0.8335233330726624,
0.15507523715496063,
0.6416152119636536,
-0.7667170166969299,
0.5263652801513672,
-0.26209941506385803,
-0.34795668721199036,
-0.5681146383285522,
0.19270168244838715,
0.494671106338501,
1.098495602607727,
0.7110479474067688,
-0.06265195459127426,
-0.30165895819664,
-1.0641074180603027,
-0.2969350516796112,
-0.5234792232513428,
-0.07798007130622864,
0.23594503104686737,
0.3779350817203522,
-0.042633216828107834,
1.4815640449523926,
-0.47855186462402344,
-0.5191991925239563,
-0.5602734684944153,
0.42219895124435425,
0.15905839204788208,
0.4076455235481262,
0.5044127106666565,
-0.7983090877532959,
-0.4634664058685303,
-0.3272196352481842,
-0.8642122149467468,
-0.428149938583374,
0.020527882501482964,
-0.12783434987068176,
-0.5203585624694824,
0.6084656119346619,
-0.29401540756225586,
0.5750596523284912,
0.7004835605621338,
-0.0018213812727481127,
0.3762974739074707,
-0.27897271513938904,
-0.12626774609088898,
-0.8679906129837036,
-0.07967951893806458,
0.14244547486305237,
-0.36520469188690186,
-0.8204222321510315,
-0.37724077701568604,
0.1295740157365799,
-0.4666300415992737,
-0.5507760643959045,
0.5017220377922058,
-0.39574989676475525,
-0.3195294439792633,
-0.5627613663673401,
0.4270554482936859,
0.017819494009017944,
0.4097846448421478,
0.6252806186676025,
0.8105601072311401,
0.7228282690048218,
-0.4963141977787018,
0.3573835492134094,
0.1830603927373886,
-0.30648213624954224,
0.7737622857093811,
-0.8769326210021973,
-0.007830766029655933,
-0.27042725682258606,
0.2211172729730606,
-1.1032772064208984,
-0.36230120062828064,
0.3600873351097107,
-0.3663269579410553,
0.42636165022850037,
-0.2218600958585739,
-0.26089340448379517,
-0.1577928364276886,
-0.1742008775472641,
0.30974575877189636,
0.4124547839164734,
-0.6909560561180115,
0.5808431506156921,
0.5373693704605103,
0.10442960262298584,
-0.3660587668418884,
-1.035020112991333,
0.39223167300224304,
-0.472050279378891,
-0.6704797148704529,
0.7109434008598328,
0.4541052281856537,
-0.1344650387763977,
0.21906380355358124,
-0.07055625319480896,
0.13882233202457428,
-0.24004335701465607,
0.015602647326886654,
0.13608136773109436,
-0.2715238630771637,
0.011988665908575058,
-0.037035051733255386,
-0.5080683827400208,
0.07880859822034836,
-0.597552478313446,
0.13821253180503845,
0.13356544077396393,
-0.12362128496170044,
-1.0003517866134644,
0.6413726210594177,
0.06527961045503616,
-0.33918508887290955,
0.8712849617004395,
0.6780939102172852,
-0.44917693734169006,
-0.3079395592212677,
-0.4686250686645508,
-0.3126155138015747,
-0.4341995418071747,
0.3362308740615845,
-0.7770050168037415,
-0.800833523273468,
0.00034056560252793133,
-0.04632950574159622,
-0.2952382564544678,
0.2651003301143646,
0.22001633048057556,
-0.5700065493583679,
0.9330622553825378,
0.7567567229270935,
-0.17956718802452087,
0.7024223208427429,
-0.3647461235523224,
0.3273661732673645,
-0.6927860975265503,
0.016374217346310616,
-0.2045256346464157,
-0.060281798243522644,
-0.31119558215141296,
-0.46545982360839844,
0.3209964334964752,
0.3851945698261261,
0.3014865815639496,
0.6593500375747681,
-0.33975890278816223,
-0.07127414643764496,
0.733917236328125,
0.09208029508590698,
-0.02547815628349781,
-0.04617130011320114,
-0.057414572685956955,
-0.2003808319568634,
-1.0384427309036255,
-0.3252326548099518,
0.716178834438324,
0.38599151372909546,
0.8355841636657715,
-0.12309035658836365,
0.976260781288147,
0.17973975837230682,
0.21974657475948334,
-0.7896085381507874,
0.5846365690231323,
-0.02525373175740242,
-0.5795179009437561,
-0.4629282057285309,
-0.5506228804588318,
-0.5251991152763367,
0.5597211122512817,
-0.061845339834690094,
-0.823946475982666,
0.35139772295951843,
0.517974853515625,
-0.03052387945353985,
-0.0864398330450058,
-0.8454902172088623,
1.2591313123703003,
-0.24470223486423492,
-0.24483337998390198,
-0.2506020665168762,
-0.727469801902771,
0.33111098408699036,
-0.17455807328224182,
0.4344387352466583,
-0.3016602694988251,
0.0317910835146904,
0.8905791640281677,
-0.45577311515808105,
0.8532323241233826,
-0.48228919506073,
-0.10499720275402069,
0.38907021284103394,
-0.2507610023021698,
0.5173467993736267,
-0.11008540540933609,
0.1507411152124405,
0.3660922050476074,
-0.022375931963324547,
-0.4247951805591583,
-0.4774843156337738,
0.5545883774757385,
-0.5162600874900818,
-0.46392685174942017,
-0.5745106339454651,
-0.29338446259498596,
-0.4427850842475891,
0.0885142832994461,
0.42757242918014526,
0.7470870614051819,
-0.10509159415960312,
0.009886286221444607,
0.5846712589263916,
-0.1282125860452652,
0.2172694057226181,
0.5235674977302551,
-0.2833230197429657,
-0.3848299980163574,
1.1492506265640259,
0.128916397690773,
0.4451977014541626,
0.5198014378547668,
0.35890015959739685,
-0.5821455121040344,
-0.5873903632164001,
-0.2981579005718231,
0.2412930130958557,
-0.7570488452911377,
0.11862372606992722,
-0.7392187118530273,
-0.07417719811201096,
-0.44192245602607727,
-0.19492286443710327,
-0.30976423621177673,
-0.01569732464849949,
-0.5435614585876465,
-0.13526354730129242,
0.17889286577701569,
0.31000974774360657,
-0.5188909769058228,
0.6784350872039795,
-0.5077007412910461,
1.0141085386276245,
0.4825272560119629,
-0.06630111485719681,
-0.2962786555290222,
-1.017060399055481,
-0.13468089699745178,
-0.00044864031951874495,
0.30400872230529785,
-0.9801489114761353,
0.33151975274086,
0.48025253415107727,
0.6941428184509277,
0.3391090929508209,
-0.01369123999029398,
1.2676875591278076,
-0.702064037322998,
0.66949862241745,
0.5252535343170166,
-1.1551353931427002,
0.979381799697876,
-0.3212597072124481,
0.3640647232532501,
0.6349945664405823,
0.3130485713481903,
-0.3700977861881256,
-0.4565519392490387,
-0.5234643816947937,
-0.618954598903656,
1.046477198600769,
0.18208491802215576,
0.2719200849533081,
-0.1674923151731491,
0.2426915019750595,
-0.3130529224872589,
0.027809031307697296,
-0.7515987157821655,
-0.1324300318956375,
-0.4651332199573517,
-0.47439852356910706,
-0.19887995719909668,
-0.3918071985244751,
0.07276778668165207,
-0.4295383393764496,
0.5963906049728394,
-0.17168569564819336,
0.034357476979494095,
0.4011368453502655,
-0.5373367667198181,
0.11767939478158951,
-0.09325263649225235,
0.24424348771572113,
0.6054308414459229,
-0.2552799880504608,
0.23681354522705078,
0.18689224123954773,
-0.4286181926727295,
0.03914046287536621,
0.19055305421352386,
-0.12435350567102432,
0.10048069804906845,
0.6909127235412598,
0.8252706527709961,
0.7364679574966431,
-0.5289591550827026,
0.6657142639160156,
0.12361283600330353,
-0.2713247239589691,
-0.14063411951065063,
-0.032431453466415405,
0.024843866005539894,
-0.05489907041192055,
0.3339107036590576,
-0.4101560413837433,
0.30178314447402954,
-0.5787928104400635,
0.5832529067993164,
0.43981385231018066,
-0.6873699426651001,
-0.09803380817174911,
0.7131950259208679,
0.07032328844070435,
-0.03269893303513527,
0.3866109251976013,
-0.11844056099653244,
-0.5000421404838562,
0.08194965124130249,
0.6606603860855103,
0.7031904458999634,
-0.25832024216651917,
0.33314406871795654,
0.1354668289422989,
0.3234657347202301,
-0.008411062881350517,
0.30314934253692627,
-0.5717219114303589,
-0.5781434774398804,
-0.591705322265625,
-0.7039550542831421,
-0.2715557813644409,
-0.00919465534389019,
-0.6708325743675232,
0.39496028423309326,
-0.24043653905391693,
-0.21359747648239136,
0.025012699887156487,
-0.4075908958911896,
-0.23577305674552917,
0.6482197046279907,
0.3693704307079315,
0.5829027891159058,
-0.6670536398887634,
1.049513339996338,
0.46243616938591003,
-0.24001073837280273,
-0.9043832421302795,
0.09216690808534622,
-0.07933307439088821,
-0.7899402976036072,
0.827099084854126,
0.38999873399734497,
-0.6256574392318726,
0.3076970875263214,
-0.3239806592464447,
-0.916949450969696,
0.6304895281791687,
0.39286428689956665,
-0.6189999580383301,
-0.0675148293375969,
0.14004793763160706,
0.33757278323173523,
-0.28606513142585754,
-0.09274392575025558,
0.4868731200695038,
0.3691868484020233,
0.18519307672977448,
-0.8825942277908325,
-0.47247087955474854,
0.19937428832054138,
0.10099732130765915,
0.12888093292713165,
-0.15416188538074493,
0.5392533540725708,
0.11683252453804016,
-0.17055611312389374,
-0.116848424077034,
1.1700611114501953,
0.04394115135073662,
0.4512284994125366,
0.7309368848800659,
0.7233874201774597,
0.3837229013442993,
-0.01612384431064129,
0.7547249794006348,
-0.31985342502593994,
0.28582558035850525,
1.3212169408798218,
-0.015762172639369965,
0.9193637371063232,
0.3562530279159546,
-0.12723787128925323,
0.25397515296936035,
0.5644663572311401,
0.26990070939064026,
0.8715515732765198,
0.20450206100940704,
-0.1463218331336975,
-0.39095407724380493,
-0.17720912396907806,
-0.3747401237487793,
0.8710948824882507,
0.5144906640052795,
-0.2263675481081009,
-0.20770491659641266,
0.1400623619556427,
-0.2372724711894989,
0.1546790897846222,
-0.3010278046131134,
0.885002613067627,
0.3785977363586426,
-0.4219287931919098,
0.6145171523094177,
0.08754461258649826,
0.6207526922225952,
-0.825276255607605,
0.016439467668533325,
0.12332139164209366,
-0.06407225877046585,
-0.18323910236358643,
-0.6172650456428528,
0.29109975695610046,
0.18444415926933289,
0.07587550580501556,
-0.529955267906189,
0.7907953262329102,
-0.7312244772911072,
-0.48366475105285645,
0.5295363068580627,
0.37930887937545776,
0.272268146276474,
-0.368253618478775,
-0.9390100836753845,
0.010463167913258076,
-0.32357561588287354,
0.0048935734666883945,
0.2342577874660492,
0.45477116107940674,
0.18181167542934418,
0.23109664022922516,
0.6720787286758423,
0.053475264459848404,
0.12002349644899368,
0.21034787595272064,
0.6155014634132385,
-0.6604200005531311,
-0.8707444667816162,
-0.7213294506072998,
0.3169878423213959,
-0.1808493584394455,
-0.27712133526802063,
0.7876321077346802,
0.46376752853393555,
0.7318660616874695,
0.19311514496803284,
0.5224565863609314,
0.14302241802215576,
0.6338569521903992,
-0.6793724894523621,
0.46322813630104065,
-0.7492499947547913,
-0.28587526082992554,
-0.5506672859191895,
-1.0827736854553223,
-0.08225266635417938,
1.0594501495361328,
-0.6174787878990173,
-0.001201303326524794,
0.4665095806121826,
0.4378916323184967,
-0.2941811978816986,
-0.09217019379138947,
0.7498854398727417,
-0.05814318731427193,
0.13386091589927673,
0.20578263700008392,
0.9938124418258667,
-0.005938397720456123,
0.3342573046684265,
-0.5600654482841492,
-0.5993989109992981,
-0.1622607409954071,
-0.7914943695068359,
-0.9499587416648865,
-0.525692343711853,
-0.39643704891204834,
0.008495832793414593,
-0.039553094655275345,
0.565520703792572,
1.1033055782318115,
-0.6921377778053284,
-0.16782288253307343,
-0.1491835117340088,
-0.3754751980304718,
0.005835442338138819,
-0.23663349449634552,
0.38825082778930664,
-0.45138001441955566,
-0.5477432608604431,
0.8419061899185181,
0.7441204190254211,
0.054700516164302826,
-0.2303806096315384,
0.05519920587539673,
-0.241965651512146,
0.01713288016617298,
0.6202085018157959,
0.2371377944946289,
-0.9409772157669067,
-0.29100164771080017,
-0.13023343682289124,
-0.09270981699228287,
-0.10092218965291977,
0.6735363602638245,
-0.9714612364768982,
0.5259246230125427,
0.19291952252388,
0.4815590977668762,
0.7785100936889648,
0.320342481136322,
0.5489637851715088,
-0.6859403252601624,
0.5267409086227417,
0.16070328652858734,
0.3385962247848511,
0.4579658806324005,
-0.12305787205696106,
0.15028223395347595,
0.4208536744117737,
0.08025608956813812,
-0.7845070958137512,
0.15120534598827362,
-0.9160719513893127,
-0.34003645181655884,
0.8896918892860413,
-0.24630926549434662,
-0.2439063936471939,
-0.1750154346227646,
-0.19311325252056122,
0.25247329473495483,
-0.1219978779554367,
0.4065118432044983,
0.6666248440742493,
-0.23717829585075378,
-0.22865842282772064,
-0.5820448398590088,
0.4581207036972046,
0.6393826007843018,
-0.790841281414032,
-0.1765158474445343,
0.48377615213394165,
0.01884353905916214,
0.08846429735422134,
0.7759040594100952,
0.1384887844324112,
0.22602933645248413,
0.07629196345806122,
-0.274842768907547,
0.15238447487354279,
-0.6386481523513794,
-0.17043723165988922,
0.003794650547206402,
-0.1056349128484726,
-0.5080950856208801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05813v1 | Selective Forgetting: Advancing Machine Unlearning Techniques and Evaluation in Language Models | 2024-02-08T16:50:01 | 2024-02-08T16:50:01 | Lingzhi Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Jinsong Guo, Kam-Fai Wong, Georg Gottlob | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The aim of this study is to investigate Machine Unlearning (MU), a burgeoning
field focused on addressing concerns related to neural models inadvertently
retaining personal or sensitive data. Here, a novel approach is introduced to
achieve precise and selective forgetting within language models. Unlike
previous methodologies that adopt completely opposing training objectives, this
approach aims to mitigate adverse effects on language model performance,
particularly in generation tasks. Furthermore, two innovative evaluation
metrics are proposed: Sensitive Information Extraction Likelihood (S-EL) and
Sensitive Information Memory Accuracy (S-MA), designed to gauge the
effectiveness of sensitive information elimination. To reinforce the forgetting
framework, an effective method for annotating sensitive scopes is presented,
involving both online and offline strategies. The online selection mechanism
leverages language probability scores to ensure computational efficiency, while
the offline annotation entails a robust two-stage process based on Large
Language Models (LLMs). | [
-0.3080299198627472,
-0.7386512160301208,
0.18333305418491364,
-0.04248175770044327,
-0.09218651056289673,
0.25661125779151917,
-0.5097490549087524,
-0.011614055372774601,
-0.24904602766036987,
0.4340328574180603,
-0.6419919729232788,
-0.2995266914367676,
-0.37170833349227905,
-0.25303414463996887,
-0.29800230264663696,
1.1466978788375854,
-0.1675061732530594,
-0.0011040312238037586,
-0.2328619360923767,
-0.486287921667099,
-0.5210350751876831,
-0.7623904347419739,
-0.48338189721107483,
-0.3648069202899933,
0.5908985733985901,
0.28842198848724365,
0.17490534484386444,
0.5788021683692932,
0.5685945153236389,
0.17533063888549805,
-0.17789888381958008,
0.2558041512966156,
-0.8290876150131226,
0.2444147914648056,
-0.49521300196647644,
-0.3923390209674835,
-0.2103428989648819,
-0.09766694903373718,
0.9327491521835327,
0.9382930994033813,
-0.19317691028118134,
0.5074825286865234,
0.14187517762184143,
0.797230064868927,
-1.3034234046936035,
-0.2504516541957855,
-1.1978449821472168,
0.25915154814720154,
-0.30883240699768066,
-0.01285872794687748,
-0.6458699703216553,
0.030507966876029968,
0.01643701270222664,
-0.4361802935600281,
0.3791691064834595,
-0.3418060541152954,
0.7941455841064453,
0.2556328773498535,
-0.07122541218996048,
-0.2361789047718048,
-0.8342200517654419,
1.205497145652771,
-0.3381117284297943,
0.3538355827331543,
1.0845153331756592,
0.22674669325351715,
0.23583222925662994,
-0.567415714263916,
0.0633433535695076,
-0.12015166133642197,
0.31465083360671997,
0.29734596610069275,
-0.34115085005760193,
-0.18273258209228516,
0.2506873905658722,
0.279410719871521,
-0.2916291356086731,
0.1255570352077484,
-0.5206148624420166,
-0.40356138348579407,
0.4661010503768921,
-0.021653534844517708,
-0.1083398163318634,
0.37935641407966614,
-0.2536979019641876,
0.39892998337745667,
-0.7576507925987244,
-0.2826217710971832,
0.5091112852096558,
0.22409789264202118,
0.06885192543268204,
0.5397705435752869,
-0.1777084320783615,
0.2607972025871277,
0.07180796563625336,
0.07380005717277527,
0.3226035237312317,
-0.04128390550613403,
-0.09183549880981445,
-0.6832927465438843,
0.7192865610122681,
0.03079189918935299,
0.49002605676651,
-0.44890469312667847,
-0.4030880033969879,
0.07684976607561111,
0.44691234827041626,
-0.36888182163238525,
-0.20597600936889648,
0.046896792948246,
-0.6073265671730042,
-0.1288633942604065,
-0.29546669125556946,
-0.6561279892921448,
-0.3585538864135742,
0.023546678945422173,
0.346882700920105,
-0.6135581135749817,
-0.29492679238319397,
-0.2841801941394806,
-0.16539287567138672,
-0.29352930188179016,
-0.036079615354537964,
-1.100605845451355,
0.25729963183403015,
0.2516539990901947,
0.491196870803833,
-0.25188636779785156,
-0.41823145747184753,
-0.44743263721466064,
0.3144952058792114,
-0.14132611453533173,
0.32992494106292725,
-0.6946219205856323,
-0.3627622425556183,
-0.0347352959215641,
-0.2083979994058609,
-0.35180506110191345,
-0.8898727297782898,
0.5020763874053955,
-0.6054642796516418,
0.2698127329349518,
-0.1334439218044281,
-0.5544593334197998,
-0.46714362502098083,
0.22166617214679718,
-0.6745473742485046,
1.0792261362075806,
0.40857815742492676,
-0.6995541453361511,
0.3059682548046112,
-0.5375800132751465,
-0.21089297533035278,
-0.12020141631364822,
0.11699423938989639,
-0.8193618655204773,
0.28599438071250916,
-0.04210139811038971,
0.4375384449958801,
-0.09417308121919632,
0.45999348163604736,
-0.4256153702735901,
-0.30482012033462524,
0.3578130304813385,
-0.678364634513855,
0.7425299882888794,
0.4242836534976959,
-0.2307083159685135,
0.10115019977092743,
-0.666989266872406,
-0.05241886153817177,
0.3428820073604584,
-0.5062935948371887,
-0.31011709570884705,
-0.03200776129961014,
-0.26232320070266724,
0.034192778170108795,
0.2889292538166046,
-0.3202955424785614,
-0.1691150814294815,
-0.15587112307548523,
0.4917006492614746,
0.7765762209892273,
0.06255292892456055,
0.5377513766288757,
-0.6023235321044922,
0.44762811064720154,
0.12577427923679352,
0.33452460169792175,
-0.39265376329421997,
-0.47414430975914,
-0.9681190252304077,
-0.18807289004325867,
0.3061429262161255,
0.5169506669044495,
-0.3568684756755829,
0.23974475264549255,
0.10357857495546341,
-0.45998916029930115,
-0.5988317131996155,
0.528617262840271,
0.8874853253364563,
0.3569111227989197,
0.3094205856323242,
-0.32584935426712036,
-0.7083183526992798,
-0.8778347969055176,
-0.43467745184898376,
-0.20191815495491028,
-0.042585279792547226,
0.20644539594650269,
0.5041556358337402,
-0.43564897775650024,
0.6373271346092224,
-0.17133161425590515,
-0.3485180735588074,
-0.28946447372436523,
0.03440162539482117,
-0.3330378532409668,
0.36027392745018005,
0.3487321138381958,
-0.6065827012062073,
-0.22733478248119354,
-0.15659353137016296,
-0.7842631936073303,
0.10487430542707443,
-0.010578223504126072,
0.07259644567966461,
0.3182368278503418,
0.27501872181892395,
-0.44531887769699097,
0.3789714276790619,
0.31435996294021606,
0.07837169617414474,
0.43959859013557434,
-0.142396479845047,
-0.012253247201442719,
-0.6551293730735779,
0.47209352254867554,
-0.3120628893375397,
-0.00573265366256237,
-0.7438080310821533,
0.13701647520065308,
0.38102251291275024,
0.021884920075535774,
-0.6990172863006592,
0.6575908660888672,
-0.74979168176651,
0.32204464077949524,
-0.2198476940393448,
-0.010644523426890373,
-0.009875249117612839,
0.7003622055053711,
-0.26006922125816345,
0.40327516198158264,
0.4472980499267578,
-0.740913450717926,
-0.22276701033115387,
-0.0961141288280487,
-0.10184692591428757,
0.00823428388684988,
0.11729133874177933,
0.49144747853279114,
-0.30014875531196594,
-0.46248069405555725,
-0.6862906217575073,
0.02891409955918789,
0.2779925763607025,
-0.4488109052181244,
0.46366456151008606,
-0.13356363773345947,
-0.1467002034187317,
-0.2939537763595581,
-0.2319488376379013,
0.4985317289829254,
0.5075290203094482,
-0.07704854011535645,
0.3412211835384369,
0.8130496740341187,
-0.09521635621786118,
-0.5952695608139038,
-0.6665319800376892,
-0.1093536987900734,
-0.42891427874565125,
0.06310909986495972,
0.24363400042057037,
-0.16993916034698486,
-0.24793723225593567,
-0.036602724343538284,
0.00478651886805892,
-0.4931265413761139,
0.5464980006217957,
0.10133066773414612,
0.0577344074845314,
0.04408308491110802,
0.31207895278930664,
-0.09832347929477692,
-0.2354448288679123,
-0.07698322087526321,
-0.12046866118907928,
0.5292330384254456,
0.14616917073726654,
-0.5041599869728088,
-0.3317456841468811,
0.6320101022720337,
0.31534212827682495,
-0.37703391909599304,
0.5718966126441956,
0.590057373046875,
-0.9163820743560791,
-0.35393238067626953,
-0.7605916857719421,
-0.19244293868541718,
-0.38893237709999084,
0.651229977607727,
-0.30597004294395447,
-0.8811070322990417,
0.7056308388710022,
-0.03303765878081322,
0.16217505931854248,
0.38601207733154297,
0.7056085467338562,
-0.11154843121767044,
1.0507110357284546,
0.9368184208869934,
-0.3072325587272644,
0.6219030022621155,
-0.08775708079338074,
0.05095912516117096,
-0.806126594543457,
-0.2046007663011551,
-0.34128108620643616,
-0.21352054178714752,
-0.1327449232339859,
-0.3157021403312683,
-0.127412810921669,
0.4817356765270233,
-0.3568359911441803,
0.047416966408491135,
-0.385587215423584,
0.43541836738586426,
0.6521220803260803,
0.09555217623710632,
0.09247872978448868,
0.21140789985656738,
-0.42161405086517334,
-0.2301313728094101,
-0.7464108467102051,
-0.5665562748908997,
1.4525285959243774,
0.37219393253326416,
0.4134160876274109,
-0.14794401824474335,
0.3741587698459625,
0.1584140807390213,
0.5979142785072327,
-0.5740687251091003,
0.4035232365131378,
-0.2071315348148346,
-0.9811837077140808,
-0.21186991035938263,
-0.5723505616188049,
-0.8662583827972412,
-0.023303847759962082,
0.07793828845024109,
-0.9857966303825378,
-0.32745030522346497,
0.305082231760025,
-0.5536742806434631,
0.6475008726119995,
-0.8231322765350342,
0.5831731557846069,
-0.17720453441143036,
-0.3983822166919708,
-0.2579166293144226,
-0.382992684841156,
0.45796528458595276,
-0.5777217745780945,
0.020218919962644577,
-0.32033053040504456,
-0.030414218083024025,
0.8652307391166687,
0.16221307218074799,
1.0573135614395142,
-0.2315714955329895,
0.3733566701412201,
0.5512272119522095,
0.2409602701663971,
0.2989456355571747,
-0.34523093700408936,
-0.5844526886940002,
0.3879425823688507,
-0.467233806848526,
-0.30040881037712097,
-0.2836942970752716,
0.501213014125824,
-0.5339494943618774,
-0.4385415017604828,
-0.12557445466518402,
-0.7114280462265015,
-0.38825228810310364,
0.39489296078681946,
0.38566404581069946,
-0.31173089146614075,
-0.37792474031448364,
0.10969655960798264,
0.850456714630127,
-0.2930642366409302,
0.5939816236495972,
0.5836436152458191,
-0.0350881852209568,
-0.5800683498382568,
1.037945032119751,
0.4485167860984802,
0.3551578223705292,
0.5100570321083069,
0.25609123706817627,
-0.08235766738653183,
-0.6097356677055359,
-0.3725399672985077,
0.26420533657073975,
-0.7209156155586243,
-0.1852641999721527,
-0.7286953330039978,
-0.2946871817111969,
-0.17540642619132996,
-0.015250854194164276,
-0.584874153137207,
-0.35691940784454346,
-0.5130786895751953,
-0.19017504155635834,
0.2139735370874405,
0.515775203704834,
0.09153511375188828,
0.3658973276615143,
-0.7640382051467896,
0.25315210223197937,
-0.026897767558693886,
0.4735695421695709,
0.05163636431097984,
-0.7493873834609985,
-0.3563070595264435,
0.1958317756652832,
-0.7883102297782898,
-0.6060866117477417,
0.3370038568973541,
0.44041547179222107,
1.0446833372116089,
0.6786724328994751,
-0.0908554196357727,
0.5228540301322937,
-0.2023918777704239,
0.39103245735168457,
0.16647869348526,
-0.8639401197433472,
0.7909455299377441,
-0.42022770643234253,
0.5373568534851074,
0.7591637372970581,
0.3594241738319397,
-0.46146252751350403,
-0.4650719463825226,
-0.6424612402915955,
-0.9376522302627563,
0.7549604773521423,
0.1507321447134018,
0.11541009694337845,
0.08523543924093246,
0.3884884715080261,
0.40651124715805054,
0.3074316084384918,
-0.8260061144828796,
-0.3198103606700897,
0.23363329470157623,
-0.32972899079322815,
0.021107440814375877,
-0.6175112128257751,
-0.08760566264390945,
0.08265037089586258,
0.7697307467460632,
0.11138036847114563,
0.11518330127000809,
-0.30181875824928284,
-0.3845096826553345,
-0.2362038493156433,
0.09235993772745132,
0.46769481897354126,
0.7247010469436646,
-0.03618200868368149,
-0.0007108444115146995,
0.6912549138069153,
-0.5760331749916077,
0.08878582715988159,
-0.43764030933380127,
-0.6812831163406372,
-0.11983578652143478,
0.09817858040332794,
0.5450770258903503,
0.30950769782066345,
-0.7548201084136963,
0.3307316303253174,
0.18113024532794952,
-0.09557218104600906,
-0.26837852597236633,
0.05431659519672394,
0.15180730819702148,
-0.29792043566703796,
0.1986929327249527,
0.3268057405948639,
-0.030272038653492928,
-0.4710024893283844,
0.4508623480796814,
0.29408663511276245,
-0.8408107161521912,
-0.41843193769454956,
0.6334803700447083,
-0.03678077459335327,
-0.2967163622379303,
0.67803555727005,
-0.29002460837364197,
-0.3936575651168823,
0.4294222891330719,
0.5991535782814026,
1.2060399055480957,
-0.6763716340065002,
-0.05871201306581497,
0.36655035614967346,
0.42801204323768616,
-0.06459135562181473,
0.3413979411125183,
-0.14176735281944275,
-0.6388205289840698,
-0.04260076582431793,
-0.4754694104194641,
-0.16634820401668549,
0.34364306926727295,
-0.6653900146484375,
0.1237633228302002,
-0.8161823153495789,
-0.48341962695121765,
-0.2541659474372864,
-0.13030603528022766,
-0.49979087710380554,
0.18974241614341736,
0.15935298800468445,
0.6214737296104431,
-0.728955090045929,
0.7328544855117798,
0.5365955233573914,
-0.33119896054267883,
-0.3987363278865814,
-0.1581672877073288,
0.3968655467033386,
-0.7885845899581909,
0.19008734822273254,
0.2760621905326843,
-0.00768194580450654,
-0.15115691721439362,
0.09149034321308136,
-0.8057934045791626,
0.758560061454773,
0.6602737307548523,
-0.5960768461227417,
0.32376471161842346,
0.09234386682510376,
0.20992961525917053,
-0.12918239831924438,
0.42056605219841003,
0.5072153210639954,
0.22483696043491364,
-0.2645275592803955,
-0.7979652881622314,
-0.23082910478115082,
-0.44314655661582947,
-0.2713935673236847,
0.37553346157073975,
-0.9176121950149536,
0.8504820466041565,
-0.4229549765586853,
-0.4338032007217407,
0.05395636707544327,
0.3190951943397522,
0.2469996213912964,
0.42403802275657654,
0.34096547961235046,
0.6053212285041809,
1.1277737617492676,
0.008124451152980328,
0.4954470098018646,
0.019321918487548828,
0.18706125020980835,
1.1094944477081299,
-0.3336816728115082,
0.7358136773109436,
0.427896112203598,
0.038780324161052704,
-0.1800803244113922,
0.5533176064491272,
0.05845505744218826,
0.6041690111160278,
0.2687121629714966,
-0.36362260580062866,
-0.17013287544250488,
-0.1893157809972763,
-0.15014950931072235,
0.496792197227478,
0.3654422163963318,
-0.6003971695899963,
-0.18650975823402405,
0.21084801852703094,
0.22790583968162537,
0.23902088403701782,
-0.3273821473121643,
0.8747234344482422,
0.19439011812210083,
-0.7023938298225403,
0.5251275897026062,
0.2375091314315796,
0.3944045305252075,
-0.7699161767959595,
0.3618099093437195,
-0.22723479568958282,
0.6053115129470825,
0.0069551304914057255,
-0.38875332474708557,
0.4953926205635071,
0.3099307417869568,
-0.6752597689628601,
-0.4273439347743988,
0.6806752681732178,
-0.3611912727355957,
-0.5880332589149475,
0.688208818435669,
0.41723620891571045,
0.18471373617649078,
-0.2661430537700653,
-0.8754242062568665,
0.1519078016281128,
0.3406792879104614,
-0.3500290513038635,
0.4236904978752136,
0.3606768250465393,
-0.5623928904533386,
1.1038275957107544,
0.5653007626533508,
0.008792126551270485,
0.0942399799823761,
0.48370516300201416,
0.7020667791366577,
-0.8131490349769592,
-0.24583496153354645,
-0.9578803777694702,
0.4693108797073364,
0.13026665151119232,
-0.715148389339447,
0.7218285799026489,
0.7357472777366638,
1.0163931846618652,
-0.04596959054470062,
1.0385441780090332,
0.4634438455104828,
0.7941619753837585,
-0.3359004557132721,
1.0376861095428467,
-0.19272644817829132,
0.3452623188495636,
-0.07957329601049423,
-0.7154784202575684,
-0.5889574885368347,
0.2737845778465271,
-0.20767661929130554,
0.3625560402870178,
0.6517629027366638,
0.8490793704986572,
0.009321345016360283,
-0.24151663482189178,
0.6295119524002075,
-0.13776911795139313,
0.006836157292127609,
0.8979324102401733,
1.0673054456710815,
-0.3962942659854889,
0.6646137237548828,
-0.4620988667011261,
-0.26021814346313477,
-0.1370597928762436,
-0.5789946913719177,
-0.977528989315033,
-0.5076318383216858,
-0.4609553813934326,
0.15341979265213013,
0.3327837586402893,
0.4267357587814331,
0.7382945418357849,
-1.026456594467163,
-0.18514475226402283,
0.06086868420243263,
0.16648326814174652,
-0.2875710427761078,
-0.12106898427009583,
0.16205835342407227,
-0.3936873972415924,
-0.5555302500724792,
0.44675740599632263,
0.5570451021194458,
0.026797788217663765,
-0.19028225541114807,
-0.038768403232097626,
-0.290237694978714,
-0.11292892694473267,
0.21204201877117157,
0.3237990140914917,
-0.6076661348342896,
-0.03865497186779976,
-0.0032533390913158655,
-0.09635721892118454,
-0.056476376950740814,
0.8496190905570984,
-0.6377438902854919,
0.6066349148750305,
0.315446674823761,
0.5533999800682068,
0.4263803958892822,
-0.13748490810394287,
0.5735978484153748,
-0.7109688520431519,
0.2741299569606781,
0.5548120141029358,
0.4488711655139923,
0.5003572702407837,
-0.2671893239021301,
0.27515512704849243,
0.2510314881801605,
-0.26780053973197937,
-0.9331344962120056,
0.22294171154499054,
-0.3967190384864807,
-0.3392910361289978,
1.010941982269287,
-0.4522426426410675,
-0.18808192014694214,
-0.3848566710948944,
0.02388915978372097,
0.4382399022579193,
-0.048760492354631424,
0.9905140399932861,
0.7081360220909119,
0.38631460070610046,
-0.10515610873699188,
-0.5682441592216492,
0.26933830976486206,
0.6519840359687805,
-0.35702449083328247,
0.3233545422554016,
0.15078023076057434,
0.29174086451530457,
-0.07289014756679535,
0.7385337948799133,
-0.32264649868011475,
0.230180025100708,
0.08260773122310638,
0.2360907644033432,
-0.012227145954966545,
-0.5642856359481812,
-0.4472842812538147,
0.36495906114578247,
-0.002195484936237335,
-0.35142645239830017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05812v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05812v3 | FAQ-Gen: An automated system to generate domain-specific FAQs to aid content comprehension | 2024-02-08T16:49:41 | 2024-05-09T10:29:16 | Sahil Kale, Gautam Khaire, Jay Patankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) refer to the most common inquiries about
specific content. They serve as content comprehension aids by simplifying
topics and enhancing understanding through succinct presentation of
information. In this paper, we address FAQ generation as a well-defined Natural
Language Processing task through the development of an end-to-end system
leveraging text-to-text transformation models. We present a literature review
covering traditional question-answering systems, highlighting their limitations
when applied directly to the FAQ generation task. We propose a system capable
of building FAQs from textual content tailored to specific domains, enhancing
their accuracy and relevance. We utilise self-curated algorithms to obtain an
optimal representation of information to be provided as input and also to rank
the question-answer pairs to maximise human comprehension. Qualitative human
evaluation showcases the generated FAQs as well-constructed and readable while
also utilising domain-specific constructs to highlight domain-based nuances and
jargon in the original content. | [
-0.8179154992103577,
-1.096524953842163,
0.3817232847213745,
-0.20637741684913635,
-0.3065554201602936,
-0.02141108363866806,
0.20627421140670776,
-0.05914687737822533,
-0.006702322047203779,
0.9041805863380432,
-0.850973904132843,
-0.31909364461898804,
-0.16858477890491486,
0.6389095187187195,
-0.6803504824638367,
1.1583783626556396,
0.028124570846557617,
-0.4601823687553406,
-0.6510822176933289,
-0.00492808036506176,
-0.23339907824993134,
-0.4725908935070038,
-0.5015198588371277,
-0.06303246319293976,
0.1266268640756607,
0.41804829239845276,
0.7710555791854858,
0.36664465069770813,
-0.02468661591410637,
0.20974363386631012,
0.18538787961006165,
0.822555661201477,
-0.5382618308067322,
0.502699077129364,
-0.28062206506729126,
-0.06709065288305283,
-0.16103780269622803,
-0.17960627377033234,
-0.08611655980348587,
0.6912578344345093,
0.07242663949728012,
0.383633553981781,
0.09647206217050552,
0.8097726702690125,
-0.28379809856414795,
-0.43776988983154297,
-0.5475041270256042,
-0.0251929871737957,
0.020967593416571617,
-0.5203596353530884,
-0.2688497006893158,
-0.37823376059532166,
0.20500950515270233,
-0.9835973978042603,
0.5871174931526184,
0.16257289052009583,
0.7738590240478516,
0.42651283740997314,
-0.5436745285987854,
-0.7237577438354492,
-0.49315136671066284,
0.36258748173713684,
-0.2600592076778412,
0.4473439157009125,
0.3648846745491028,
0.1987575888633728,
-0.3633909821510315,
-0.5264225602149963,
-0.6459023356437683,
0.2607477307319641,
-0.03310287371277809,
-0.0006154536968097091,
-0.27470076084136963,
-0.2555761933326721,
-0.02574201300740242,
0.551007091999054,
-0.8391307592391968,
-0.611673891544342,
-0.3353683054447174,
-0.19732366502285004,
0.7048117518424988,
0.28981760144233704,
0.5442191362380981,
-0.34478670358657837,
-0.09526047110557556,
0.2692559063434601,
-0.6313421726226807,
0.03721532225608826,
0.34801357984542847,
-0.04535730183124542,
0.36074957251548767,
0.42676571011543274,
-0.5983241200447083,
0.8793906569480896,
0.6530210375785828,
0.015248694457113743,
0.035724423825740814,
-0.5477592945098877,
-0.21467749774456024,
-0.48618853092193604,
0.5451611876487732,
0.33556845784187317,
0.4207908511161804,
-0.39437031745910645,
-0.2305297553539276,
-0.4353877007961273,
0.4468950033187866,
-0.36871230602264404,
-0.02491029165685177,
0.49394842982292175,
-0.17724797129631042,
-0.39018338918685913,
0.048844076693058014,
-0.6608412265777588,
-0.20782296359539032,
-0.40137797594070435,
0.3731944262981415,
-0.31773024797439575,
-0.10097593069076538,
0.11711433529853821,
-0.22952081263065338,
0.4138624966144562,
0.4077570140361786,
-0.7958391904830933,
0.1851852983236313,
0.42293286323547363,
0.5058783888816833,
-0.33529946208000183,
0.09993834048509598,
-0.24755489826202393,
0.46017372608184814,
-0.10507111996412277,
0.9887250661849976,
-0.06637011468410492,
-0.4786778390407562,
0.3389362692832947,
0.11326396465301514,
0.31215178966522217,
-0.41080546379089355,
0.3321601152420044,
-0.7336575984954834,
0.5027086734771729,
-0.01962549239397049,
-0.4600485861301422,
0.09141504764556885,
0.2778641879558563,
-0.7013537883758545,
0.9278156161308289,
0.3442593514919281,
-0.6056309342384338,
0.13432632386684418,
-0.6155385375022888,
-0.787815511226654,
0.3320049047470093,
-0.1778811812400818,
-0.07979534566402435,
-0.1337091326713562,
0.45490047335624695,
0.6294310092926025,
-0.7685750126838684,
0.2705347239971161,
0.4311846196651459,
0.1425866037607193,
0.3149253726005554,
-0.2533070147037506,
0.601201593875885,
0.5444058179855347,
-0.15076692402362823,
-0.13919034600257874,
-0.35531550645828247,
0.23093442618846893,
0.2842826545238495,
-0.2940995693206787,
-0.1554121971130371,
-0.2775346636772156,
-0.2755551338195801,
0.17889489233493805,
0.5137986540794373,
-0.21978971362113953,
-0.04918414354324341,
-0.3343326151371002,
0.3973110318183899,
0.30907300114631653,
0.6467617750167847,
0.6795797348022461,
-0.717624843120575,
0.6484484076499939,
-0.16610375046730042,
0.29384762048721313,
-0.4171472191810608,
-0.6737564206123352,
-0.6348411440849304,
0.2772965431213379,
-0.044804397970438004,
0.5878452658653259,
-1.071315884590149,
0.536658763885498,
-0.14296147227287292,
-0.4882703721523285,
-0.35696035623550415,
0.5863500237464905,
0.09427828341722488,
0.4789999723434448,
0.37661343812942505,
-0.0963333323597908,
-0.26349401473999023,
-0.6050043106079102,
0.06994079053401947,
-0.0549892857670784,
-0.18272177875041962,
0.35493019223213196,
0.2696334719657898,
-0.06911027431488037,
1.170393466949463,
-0.7120025753974915,
0.03862292692065239,
-0.31065085530281067,
0.31426241993904114,
-0.07554128766059875,
0.2559332847595215,
0.4994050860404968,
-1.0914607048034668,
-0.5818385481834412,
-0.12029912322759628,
-0.7333043217658997,
-0.39304468035697937,
-0.16246125102043152,
-0.5553897619247437,
0.22627511620521545,
0.35237395763397217,
-0.542896032333374,
0.25507670640945435,
0.10592707991600037,
-0.3338276445865631,
0.5986725091934204,
0.07548221945762634,
0.37827569246292114,
-1.15628182888031,
0.28294146060943604,
-0.18400989472866058,
-0.19799888134002686,
-0.890879213809967,
0.08886928856372833,
-0.21711325645446777,
-0.4351850748062134,
-0.2125195413827896,
0.7189987897872925,
-0.2996341288089752,
0.11386200785636902,
-0.1803707778453827,
0.11186359077692032,
0.4948378801345825,
0.4974716305732727,
0.01698002591729164,
0.8769330978393555,
0.15261155366897583,
-0.9297806024551392,
0.316203236579895,
0.5994403958320618,
-0.06662728637456894,
0.5843029022216797,
-0.6329780220985413,
0.44633978605270386,
-0.2549273669719696,
0.08343328535556793,
-1.0830637216567993,
-0.51128089427948,
0.37919971346855164,
-0.7836545705795288,
-0.15124580264091492,
-0.08430887013673782,
-0.44955945014953613,
-0.36316126585006714,
-0.04420607164502144,
0.1746644824743271,
0.5537736415863037,
-0.35869190096855164,
0.257003515958786,
0.4330822825431824,
-0.5032914280891418,
-0.394794225692749,
-0.31894761323928833,
-0.14499016106128693,
0.30712127685546875,
-0.9680238962173462,
0.22049874067306519,
-0.37932613492012024,
-0.15018194913864136,
-0.003630019025877118,
-0.15113258361816406,
-0.41954970359802246,
0.18856266140937805,
0.19216375052928925,
-0.05027366429567337,
-0.27410855889320374,
0.34178346395492554,
0.6767385005950928,
0.19278444349765778,
0.07429657876491547,
-0.3056240677833557,
0.6172558069229126,
0.2286282479763031,
-0.057960376143455505,
-0.11289246380329132,
1.0559914112091064,
0.6587546467781067,
-0.36429068446159363,
0.13032636046409607,
0.2975642681121826,
-0.23080570995807648,
-0.4720151126384735,
-0.49441179633140564,
-0.01676418073475361,
-0.4746374189853668,
-0.02443111501634121,
-0.4374687075614929,
-0.9075130820274353,
0.20798222720623016,
-0.07498357445001602,
0.4293057322502136,
0.7355546951293945,
0.5543681383132935,
-0.22896644473075867,
0.8638304471969604,
0.42825087904930115,
0.3847963809967041,
0.08299466967582703,
0.07684493809938431,
-0.10500390082597733,
-0.30401694774627686,
-0.1790759414434433,
-0.43104788661003113,
0.18495209515094757,
0.06116927042603493,
-0.5415366291999817,
0.1442878097295761,
-0.09502086788415909,
-0.22648587822914124,
0.17364004254341125,
-0.663384199142456,
0.31505918502807617,
0.3907758593559265,
-0.029692206531763077,
0.5332142114639282,
0.28764575719833374,
-0.03730451315641403,
0.4052294194698334,
-0.5989342927932739,
-0.7854196429252625,
1.0977133512496948,
0.06480398029088974,
0.4529281258583069,
-0.004111644346266985,
0.639423131942749,
0.7122982144355774,
0.4330935478210449,
-0.5038039684295654,
0.44351983070373535,
-0.1716352105140686,
-0.8835987448692322,
-0.6765584349632263,
-0.28458157181739807,
-0.8611333966255188,
-0.1165504902601242,
-0.1976504623889923,
-0.10508784651756287,
0.06234150752425194,
-0.06952953338623047,
-0.6199295520782471,
-0.12158819288015366,
-0.4526221752166748,
0.5073287487030029,
-0.34594130516052246,
-0.25747036933898926,
0.3162945806980133,
-0.5397434830665588,
0.3103366494178772,
-0.41475027799606323,
0.1424698531627655,
0.11799028515815735,
0.018524590879678726,
0.7214999794960022,
-0.4128515422344208,
0.4742862582206726,
-0.06537137925624847,
-0.43733471632003784,
0.8670449256896973,
0.22312811017036438,
-0.061642829328775406,
0.21210087835788727,
-0.12068998068571091,
-0.1528652012348175,
-0.08689022064208984,
-0.35322606563568115,
-0.6938323378562927,
0.368679016828537,
-0.8798080682754517,
-0.8944883942604065,
0.11488884687423706,
-0.38616153597831726,
-0.3737638294696808,
0.08404151350259781,
0.39302700757980347,
0.2758660912513733,
-0.3809770941734314,
0.00232963589951396,
1.0218415260314941,
-0.34439322352409363,
-0.09695997834205627,
0.45345720648765564,
-0.17176370322704315,
-0.4747202694416046,
0.6630314588546753,
-0.0565771721303463,
0.2396252155303955,
0.4716804623603821,
-0.19357183575630188,
-0.3824585974216461,
-0.4088575839996338,
-0.9021627902984619,
0.11068960279226303,
-0.7256428599357605,
-0.49660736322402954,
-0.7742847800254822,
-0.354434609413147,
-0.864468514919281,
-0.37945184111595154,
0.23853671550750732,
-0.36144372820854187,
-0.5781380534172058,
0.0848793014883995,
0.35690194368362427,
0.7556175589561462,
0.2224891483783722,
0.259905606508255,
-0.8846274614334106,
0.6211087703704834,
0.7345227003097534,
-0.040594469755887985,
-0.21026600897312164,
-0.7012788653373718,
-0.1606348305940628,
0.06470274925231934,
-0.4825613796710968,
-0.9816144704818726,
0.3579060137271881,
0.3233644366264343,
0.6215927004814148,
0.261074036359787,
0.36477842926979065,
0.2852034270763397,
-0.33219215273857117,
0.9138266444206238,
0.13471074402332306,
-0.8549395799636841,
0.7590036988258362,
-0.46903401613235474,
0.38756313920021057,
0.7083718776702881,
0.7031286358833313,
-0.6300908923149109,
-0.4438391327857971,
-0.4636474847793579,
-0.8558856248855591,
0.3581477105617523,
0.19713103771209717,
0.3708510994911194,
-0.24249978363513947,
0.8971759080886841,
0.7685883045196533,
0.2531192898750305,
-0.24401003122329712,
-0.34683459997177124,
-0.5963048934936523,
-0.3997179865837097,
0.370665967464447,
0.04199676960706711,
-0.07667974382638931,
0.09376253187656403,
0.608243465423584,
-0.3293759226799011,
0.3890262842178345,
0.5456017255783081,
-0.3442537486553192,
-0.446085661649704,
0.34603461623191833,
0.29394257068634033,
0.3727521598339081,
0.13146409392356873,
-0.16002891957759857,
-0.09073244035243988,
-0.3917688727378845,
0.23796536028385162,
-0.1713012009859085,
-0.3975665867328644,
0.0180453360080719,
-0.25824686884880066,
0.338457852602005,
-0.17962616682052612,
-0.6972867846488953,
0.47121095657348633,
-0.2310134917497635,
-0.6035187244415283,
-0.23237642645835876,
0.35307350754737854,
-0.040656864643096924,
-0.0962107703089714,
0.931542158126831,
-0.16247649490833282,
0.05189217999577522,
-0.3898194432258606,
0.7261775732040405,
0.14658188819885254,
0.04121822118759155,
-0.14968885481357574,
0.6265730261802673,
0.8340772986412048,
-0.4249306619167328,
0.4044826328754425,
-0.320956826210022,
-0.3694518804550171,
0.4496215879917145,
0.43156948685646057,
0.7718749046325684,
-0.1124332994222641,
0.6037469506263733,
0.29810741543769836,
0.011036824434995651,
0.2051185667514801,
0.45192354917526245,
-0.5009498596191406,
-0.8043971061706543,
-0.3120478093624115,
-0.5175878405570984,
-0.5363741517066956,
0.23907311260700226,
-0.483846515417099,
0.14746709167957306,
-0.5117354989051819,
-0.1228528544306755,
0.023576851934194565,
-0.037491507828235626,
-0.6949992775917053,
0.5351230502128601,
0.1077875867486,
0.8764713406562805,
-0.6682109832763672,
0.32721051573753357,
0.9276992082595825,
-0.6416645646095276,
-0.35088542103767395,
0.1995878517627716,
-0.3729938268661499,
-0.49833980202674866,
0.38833731412887573,
-0.15728768706321716,
-0.1375918835401535,
0.24272942543029785,
-0.8582870364189148,
-0.797369122505188,
1.257910132408142,
-0.06409859657287598,
-0.160101979970932,
-0.2310722917318344,
0.6133163571357727,
0.5143011808395386,
-0.49220314621925354,
-0.14121030271053314,
0.24220727384090424,
0.25236108899116516,
0.05292224511504173,
-0.4992919862270355,
0.2454376220703125,
-0.48114338517189026,
-0.529689610004425,
0.22197934985160828,
-0.3659910261631012,
0.5496276021003723,
-0.07515261322259903,
-0.3668519854545593,
0.35955938696861267,
0.7441158890724182,
0.048272754997015,
0.36197003722190857,
0.6102794408798218,
0.15641935169696808,
0.8552169799804688,
0.14651836454868317,
0.7602059841156006,
-0.6152318120002747,
-0.03763774409890175,
0.7103110551834106,
-0.046752799302339554,
0.4705183804035187,
0.3810300827026367,
0.17908801138401031,
0.3699405789375305,
0.41715380549430847,
0.18132558465003967,
0.34439975023269653,
0.09750188142061234,
-0.2829916775226593,
-0.5165281295776367,
-0.12461350113153458,
-0.24169570207595825,
0.1680167019367218,
0.6440804600715637,
-0.41363948583602905,
-0.21897189319133759,
-0.14799366891384125,
-0.24213677644729614,
0.20315644145011902,
-0.23765991628170013,
0.8560954928398132,
-0.17705555260181427,
-0.9751140475273132,
0.4937961995601654,
-0.09969733655452728,
0.48826709389686584,
-0.4011603593826294,
0.1325567364692688,
-0.5410277843475342,
-0.6949622631072998,
-0.17161895334720612,
-1.0136985778808594,
0.31552207469940186,
0.38675785064697266,
-0.4570423662662506,
-0.4337466061115265,
1.0246645212173462,
-0.3524402976036072,
-0.05590996891260147,
-0.31539294123649597,
1.218079924583435,
-0.02569209784269333,
-0.12743566930294037,
-0.6836866736412048,
-0.446723997592926,
0.32150039076805115,
-0.26502397656440735,
0.14458729326725006,
0.8450865745544434,
0.10418421775102615,
0.6247307658195496,
0.7288923859596252,
-0.5857161283493042,
0.0693138986825943,
-0.15441207587718964,
0.6849856376647949,
-0.6005963087081909,
-0.44257882237434387,
-0.12668491899967194,
0.48566967248916626,
-0.07417865097522736,
-0.690223753452301,
0.2952525317668915,
0.36154916882514954,
0.5633355379104614,
-0.2468857616186142,
1.2621703147888184,
-0.16519741714000702,
0.5318546295166016,
-0.19922390580177307,
0.807956874370575,
-0.7675552368164062,
0.005338490474969149,
-0.012875895015895367,
-0.571088969707489,
-0.11886762827634811,
0.2692355513572693,
-0.1337900459766388,
-0.3055528402328491,
0.3245512545108795,
0.6992512345314026,
0.29333338141441345,
0.15313087403774261,
0.5685115456581116,
-0.2703419029712677,
0.09237062931060791,
0.32604607939720154,
0.9054193496704102,
-0.445395290851593,
0.9232569336891174,
-0.042729444801807404,
0.010825274512171745,
-0.1808493733406067,
-0.19307805597782135,
-0.7716996669769287,
-0.9604707360267639,
-0.2953210175037384,
-0.11469247192144394,
0.18237784504890442,
0.7438061237335205,
0.4021759331226349,
-0.5977185964584351,
0.011763662099838257,
-0.12073445320129395,
0.10089839994907379,
0.10308579355478287,
-0.26326465606689453,
0.09169767796993256,
-0.44037410616874695,
-0.651523232460022,
0.0954815149307251,
0.1284766048192978,
0.1840035617351532,
-0.43319830298423767,
-0.082908034324646,
-0.1131795272231102,
0.44896745681762695,
0.6715567708015442,
0.44069594144821167,
-0.40923017263412476,
-0.1631288081407547,
0.5625043511390686,
-0.30914294719696045,
0.05844825506210327,
0.9161111116409302,
-0.8043981790542603,
0.07142326235771179,
0.578632652759552,
0.9488115906715393,
0.09768042713403702,
0.3465457558631897,
0.8565194010734558,
-0.8300249576568604,
-0.6590425372123718,
0.2091769278049469,
-0.03129163384437561,
0.4497988522052765,
-0.7073482275009155,
0.5484139919281006,
0.13768388330936432,
-0.5352647304534912,
-0.3131917417049408,
0.32972872257232666,
-0.9158469438552856,
-0.3899155259132385,
1.3928422927856445,
0.06447354704141617,
-0.2779035270214081,
-0.9459952116012573,
-0.33023422956466675,
0.41298145055770874,
-0.571911096572876,
0.5260217785835266,
0.4714474678039551,
-0.2829572260379791,
-0.03833939507603645,
-0.31633836030960083,
0.6225656867027283,
0.39830368757247925,
-0.9535010457038879,
0.13995131850242615,
0.4429962933063507,
0.49012747406959534,
0.2381027340888977,
0.5160636305809021,
-0.06363072991371155,
0.6043541431427002,
-0.37441742420196533,
-0.024230707436800003,
0.004757088143378496,
-0.0024407824967056513,
0.011195817962288857,
0.6244765520095825,
-0.1457221806049347,
0.2170839011669159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05808v2 | Training Large Language Models for Reasoning through Reverse Curriculum Reinforcement Learning | 2024-02-08T16:46:26 | 2024-03-17T09:02:02 | Zhiheng Xi, Wenxiang Chen, Boyang Hong, Senjie Jin, Rui Zheng, Wei He, Yiwen Ding, Shichun Liu, Xin Guo, Junzhe Wang, Honglin Guo, Wei Shen, Xiaoran Fan, Yuhao Zhou, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Xinbo Zhang, Peng Sun, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose R$^3$: Learning Reasoning through Reverse
Curriculum Reinforcement Learning (RL), a novel method that employs only
outcome supervision to achieve the benefits of process supervision for large
language models. The core challenge in applying RL to complex reasoning is to
identify a sequence of actions that result in positive rewards and provide
appropriate supervision for optimization. Outcome supervision provides sparse
rewards for final results without identifying error locations, whereas process
supervision offers step-wise rewards but requires extensive manual annotation.
R$^3$ overcomes these limitations by learning from correct demonstrations.
Specifically, R$^3$ progressively slides the start state of reasoning from a
demonstration's end to its beginning, facilitating easier model exploration at
all stages. Thus, R$^3$ establishes a step-wise curriculum, allowing outcome
supervision to offer step-level signals and precisely pinpoint errors. Using
Llama2-7B, our method surpasses RL baseline on eight reasoning tasks by $4.1$
points on average. Notebaly, in program-based reasoning on GSM8K, it exceeds
the baseline by $4.2$ points across three backbone models, and without any
extra data, Codellama-7B + R$^3$ performs comparable to larger models or
closed-source models. | [
-0.20296622812747955,
-0.801317572593689,
0.8832603693008423,
0.24648132920265198,
-0.14375677704811096,
-0.11785446107387543,
-0.26568081974983215,
-0.21565480530261993,
-0.16712653636932373,
0.9428842067718506,
-0.7433856129646301,
-0.6071053147315979,
-0.5408300161361694,
-0.2043015956878662,
-0.1771620213985443,
0.993263304233551,
-0.2705860733985901,
0.20833007991313934,
0.13532690703868866,
0.23642389476299286,
-0.37297341227531433,
-0.428046852350235,
-0.9055412411689758,
-0.6757603883743286,
0.7470155358314514,
0.763796865940094,
0.3928244709968567,
0.5270272493362427,
0.12877784669399261,
0.1600215584039688,
0.1764833629131317,
0.4420211613178253,
-0.6267755627632141,
0.15046426653862,
-0.36809614300727844,
-0.6731931567192078,
-0.32573312520980835,
0.24286483228206635,
0.36606696248054504,
0.5599986910820007,
-0.43063032627105713,
0.06936568021774292,
-0.2364896982908249,
0.7532426714897156,
-0.6747138500213623,
0.4337102770805359,
-0.44135960936546326,
0.14516758918762207,
0.07375147938728333,
-0.27286139130592346,
-0.9626011252403259,
-0.5724707245826721,
-0.26037079095840454,
-0.6086145043373108,
-0.09605098515748978,
0.18164944648742676,
0.6281730532646179,
0.18533001840114594,
-0.2974596619606018,
-0.2221800684928894,
-0.7443737983703613,
1.1078689098358154,
-0.7990301251411438,
0.38469257950782776,
0.6425585150718689,
0.5624340772628784,
-0.3390238583087921,
-0.5149686336517334,
-0.5169997215270996,
-0.2571598291397095,
0.14318722486495972,
0.27607235312461853,
0.3577284514904022,
0.07288532704114914,
0.5384977459907532,
-0.003976644482463598,
-0.4328450560569763,
0.23284998536109924,
-0.4970477521419525,
0.006277270149439573,
0.7151346206665039,
0.2471321076154709,
-0.05782364681363106,
0.18175995349884033,
-0.14765365421772003,
-0.29019036889076233,
-1.0642194747924805,
0.011123117059469223,
0.5067892074584961,
0.3474595844745636,
0.020290624350309372,
0.47066378593444824,
-0.29884275794029236,
0.6345623731613159,
-0.15793916583061218,
-0.27515777945518494,
-0.0656135305762291,
0.22081258893013,
-0.29438158869743347,
0.11701741069555283,
0.5352597832679749,
0.047277092933654785,
0.3193935453891754,
0.10554338246583939,
-0.35202744603157043,
-0.011043774895370007,
0.471338152885437,
-0.5018337368965149,
-0.29027798771858215,
0.16842535138130188,
-0.3731277287006378,
-0.18039341270923615,
0.08618416637182236,
-0.5112301111221313,
-0.2949080467224121,
-0.589909017086029,
0.4664786159992218,
-0.3689548671245575,
-0.2548331916332245,
0.5077909231185913,
0.3032945394515991,
0.44280362129211426,
0.7659887671470642,
-0.8949613571166992,
0.2164420783519745,
1.0709689855575562,
0.49746087193489075,
-0.08916415274143219,
-0.39542844891548157,
-0.7988192439079285,
0.10656151175498962,
-0.540106475353241,
0.6776872277259827,
-0.514938235282898,
-0.2208026796579361,
-0.013286357745528221,
-0.07581524550914764,
-0.10176941007375717,
-0.5594881772994995,
0.6758298873901367,
-0.7628030776977539,
0.1789887249469757,
0.1418885886669159,
-0.4142202138900757,
-0.5938773155212402,
0.2357446402311325,
-0.5055500864982605,
0.9246318340301514,
-0.07888177782297134,
-0.4820682108402252,
0.3249695897102356,
-0.4215354919433594,
-0.48101741075515747,
-0.30637553334236145,
-0.24106073379516602,
-0.6751829385757446,
-0.2286832481622696,
0.25419384241104126,
0.6946303844451904,
-0.13445663452148438,
0.5265306234359741,
-0.5574247241020203,
-0.6591008305549622,
0.0270671509206295,
-0.3186894953250885,
0.713324248790741,
0.2084888219833374,
-0.38487040996551514,
0.36852458119392395,
-0.8285354375839233,
0.03203962743282318,
0.16510289907455444,
-0.4641900062561035,
-0.05842369794845581,
0.03213728964328766,
-0.4468855857849121,
0.26156291365623474,
-0.1189369410276413,
-0.3882859945297241,
0.49133312702178955,
-0.4578286111354828,
0.1285509616136551,
0.726563572883606,
0.10563801229000092,
0.24091285467147827,
-0.22647610306739807,
0.605330765247345,
0.010760823264718056,
0.25016650557518005,
-0.10421796143054962,
-0.5659405589103699,
-1.0163387060165405,
-0.13445764780044556,
-0.08466698229312897,
0.6647020578384399,
-0.7748915553092957,
0.1841239631175995,
0.15511329472064972,
-0.38119298219680786,
-0.3445819914340973,
-0.014913826249539852,
0.6727185249328613,
0.534473717212677,
0.6783294081687927,
0.04863359406590462,
-0.7076534628868103,
-0.948120653629303,
-0.16540272533893585,
-0.3852083384990692,
0.09856941550970078,
0.1087469682097435,
0.6162922978401184,
-0.02487337775528431,
0.5023373961448669,
-0.6707807183265686,
-0.27913162112236023,
-0.637471079826355,
0.41230952739715576,
0.534137487411499,
0.5665499567985535,
-0.0848618745803833,
-0.6333797574043274,
-0.03997556492686272,
-0.04204018414020538,
-0.9520631432533264,
0.02913474291563034,
-0.35720717906951904,
-0.18568941950798035,
0.3346589207649231,
0.5448665022850037,
-0.456800252199173,
0.4365483224391937,
0.32532280683517456,
-0.0125888055190444,
0.8350064158439636,
-0.267672061920166,
0.07239239662885666,
-0.6810622811317444,
-0.21165570616722107,
0.05264502763748169,
-0.23121517896652222,
-0.4054006338119507,
0.14624373614788055,
0.15952998399734497,
0.17301315069198608,
-0.4467364549636841,
0.38728323578834534,
-0.29548683762550354,
-0.24721255898475647,
-0.2950315773487091,
0.14211870729923248,
-0.008482587523758411,
0.7958164811134338,
0.4404463768005371,
0.6442103981971741,
0.3588812053203583,
-0.5912525653839111,
0.5669952630996704,
0.01973923295736313,
-0.46733370423316956,
0.2805284261703491,
-0.3162378668785095,
-0.09684991091489792,
0.06997580081224442,
0.729497492313385,
-0.6876634955406189,
-0.19928161799907684,
0.4664643704891205,
-0.4485182762145996,
0.23037706315517426,
-0.09359006583690643,
-0.2653590738773346,
-0.45790836215019226,
-0.10972584038972855,
0.18519927561283112,
0.4795384109020233,
-0.7490236163139343,
0.6735148429870605,
-0.03628700599074364,
0.17124135792255402,
-0.90269535779953,
-0.6790419816970825,
-0.08989349007606506,
-0.24660472571849823,
-0.277306467294693,
-0.25483131408691406,
0.31760695576667786,
-0.19303837418556213,
-0.19383090734481812,
-0.043199632316827774,
-0.008302286267280579,
0.2009507715702057,
0.3603288233280182,
0.2923402488231659,
-0.19539110362529755,
0.011746915057301521,
0.11962978541851044,
-0.31060558557510376,
0.30073490738868713,
-0.44216564297676086,
0.14067143201828003,
-0.10876986384391785,
-0.787420392036438,
-0.5847244262695312,
0.28036630153656006,
0.14316946268081665,
-0.0902184545993805,
0.625495195388794,
0.34402069449424744,
-0.20187045633792877,
-0.5795436501502991,
-0.5502657890319824,
-0.19235064089298248,
-0.37416958808898926,
0.34945663809776306,
-0.5329739451408386,
-0.8510408401489258,
0.3713606297969818,
-0.13214486837387085,
0.21201948821544647,
-0.013441123068332672,
0.5870391726493835,
0.20620422065258026,
1.2719357013702393,
0.31906750798225403,
0.3072221875190735,
0.20959432423114777,
-0.3942195177078247,
0.3941267728805542,
-0.9102379679679871,
-0.4410513937473297,
-0.24230004847049713,
0.1851688027381897,
-0.12865358591079712,
-0.5849390625953674,
0.09144533425569534,
0.538292646408081,
-0.6108757853507996,
0.3314274847507477,
-0.2410314828157425,
0.3661192059516907,
0.7252752184867859,
0.32491809129714966,
0.4441535770893097,
-0.4505482316017151,
-0.2223067283630371,
0.18003380298614502,
-0.5751962065696716,
-0.7168529033660889,
0.9530622363090515,
0.472848117351532,
1.1528490781784058,
0.19440649449825287,
0.9636197090148926,
0.11076249182224274,
0.6546124219894409,
-0.8920828700065613,
0.7866341471672058,
0.35870522260665894,
-0.24016235768795013,
-0.30396735668182373,
-0.47679370641708374,
-0.49916547536849976,
0.4293452799320221,
-0.07596781849861145,
-0.7779905796051025,
-0.11432100832462311,
0.31561607122421265,
-0.21914944052696228,
0.41343653202056885,
-0.764197051525116,
0.8003566265106201,
-0.08853621780872345,
-0.4982896149158478,
-0.3987686038017273,
-0.7774370908737183,
0.884894609451294,
0.11598590016365051,
0.4001964330673218,
0.12268248945474625,
0.3174494802951813,
0.5628905892372131,
-0.2448713481426239,
1.0011802911758423,
-0.27548202872276306,
-0.4521290361881256,
0.3551631271839142,
0.3923019468784332,
0.7332082986831665,
0.3164662718772888,
0.10184986889362335,
-0.2915195822715759,
-0.24887509644031525,
-0.36757680773735046,
-0.8937521576881409,
0.6925484538078308,
-0.6904942989349365,
-0.9960370659828186,
-0.32409968972206116,
-0.41642048954963684,
-0.41228607296943665,
0.04178055748343468,
-0.3533885180950165,
0.32551297545433044,
0.25561073422431946,
-0.07854267209768295,
0.9695420265197754,
-0.4059256613254547,
0.04337088763713837,
0.5666897296905518,
-0.613501250743866,
-0.2851499319076538,
0.926285445690155,
-0.2839268743991852,
0.46023473143577576,
0.5725852847099304,
0.20947054028511047,
-0.3712911307811737,
-0.5064243078231812,
-0.4964871108531952,
0.3159143924713135,
-1.0943820476531982,
-0.19590306282043457,
-0.774446427822113,
-0.12726235389709473,
-0.31278735399246216,
-0.2373906672000885,
-0.5523988604545593,
-0.4344714283943176,
-0.32632753252983093,
-0.33835962414741516,
-0.02411295473575592,
0.8055204749107361,
-0.271621972322464,
0.19136209785938263,
-0.5761247277259827,
0.3419203460216522,
0.41509726643562317,
0.31031447649002075,
0.3435010313987732,
-0.6563681960105896,
-0.29458293318748474,
-0.09031003713607788,
-0.38207778334617615,
-0.6743340492248535,
0.26238107681274414,
-0.16105405986309052,
0.562508225440979,
0.5140964388847351,
-0.030655885115265846,
0.5343251824378967,
-0.4591328501701355,
0.6948519945144653,
0.10389503091573715,
-0.8204092383384705,
0.6879284381866455,
-0.3824194073677063,
-0.03184731677174568,
0.12417363375425339,
0.33752572536468506,
-0.3891139030456543,
-0.6852185130119324,
-0.6000509858131409,
-0.7264438271522522,
1.0638046264648438,
-0.23459281027317047,
-0.2214558720588684,
-0.13578838109970093,
0.41839519143104553,
0.10469057410955429,
-0.1996893435716629,
-0.8767867684364319,
-0.005411000922322273,
-0.31478020548820496,
-0.1361796110868454,
0.1276012510061264,
-0.2328222244977951,
-0.23369592428207397,
-0.09724502265453339,
1.2901149988174438,
-0.3154127895832062,
-0.040243156254291534,
0.13299207389354706,
-0.03731445223093033,
0.00180356006603688,
0.4372643530368805,
1.0242300033569336,
0.7421079874038696,
-0.3025059103965759,
0.3931538164615631,
0.24138674139976501,
-0.10515914112329483,
0.17409084737300873,
-0.3035914897918701,
0.14124652743339539,
-0.6090669631958008,
0.6857270002365112,
0.8749750256538391,
0.30403608083724976,
-0.8619452714920044,
0.5513913035392761,
0.03493218123912811,
-0.4886825680732727,
-0.40362656116485596,
0.2777847349643707,
0.24615830183029175,
0.6064513325691223,
0.34648793935775757,
-0.31751707196235657,
0.003229887690395117,
-0.4171059727668762,
0.3916907012462616,
0.026626046746969223,
-0.45948007702827454,
-0.08587122708559036,
0.6556993722915649,
-0.14161430299282074,
-0.07635901868343353,
0.6133966445922852,
-0.24407179653644562,
-0.540472149848938,
0.6420587301254272,
0.8574438691139221,
0.553088366985321,
-0.05188806727528572,
0.36579829454421997,
0.5893556475639343,
0.11849215626716614,
-0.801945149898529,
0.21363501250743866,
0.02284354716539383,
-0.7428833246231079,
-0.9943461418151855,
-0.5109289884567261,
-0.8333895802497864,
0.08304299414157867,
-0.8330103158950806,
0.35655033588409424,
-0.5514234900474548,
0.42221495509147644,
-0.2246372252702713,
-0.2639022171497345,
-0.0006170611013658345,
0.376232773065567,
0.08355341106653214,
0.8214667439460754,
-0.9698976278305054,
1.0841469764709473,
0.6243864297866821,
-0.5614736080169678,
-1.240639328956604,
-0.33356499671936035,
-0.020111575722694397,
-0.999538779258728,
1.3410842418670654,
0.24846775829792023,
-0.4930274784564972,
0.03587007150053978,
-0.7621011734008789,
-0.4132412374019623,
0.9064507484436035,
0.09911318868398666,
-0.44770586490631104,
0.09714450687170029,
-0.34801948070526123,
0.41631001234054565,
-0.45757460594177246,
0.33562251925468445,
0.4874359667301178,
0.4342615604400635,
0.4240560531616211,
-0.5419579148292542,
0.11765800416469574,
0.2514778971672058,
-0.119823157787323,
0.19761787354946136,
-0.43232640624046326,
0.8705899119377136,
-0.6765566468238831,
-0.2007208913564682,
0.03752649948000908,
0.8716568350791931,
0.7843807935714722,
0.25734052062034607,
0.35097965598106384,
0.7751604914665222,
0.3445727527141571,
-0.08302284777164459,
1.004776120185852,
0.3129372298717499,
0.6144505739212036,
1.4021416902542114,
-0.4509080946445465,
0.7974033355712891,
0.4878133237361908,
-0.18866480886936188,
0.6371473073959351,
0.601174533367157,
0.1519887000322342,
0.4988957941532135,
0.36864742636680603,
-0.14245815575122833,
-0.850547730922699,
0.14270900189876556,
-0.08461105078458786,
0.26040440797805786,
0.5452533960342407,
-0.14842554926872253,
-0.4144330620765686,
0.1283852458000183,
0.14464275538921356,
0.5171132683753967,
-0.30376508831977844,
0.6159144639968872,
0.2419692724943161,
-0.8929265141487122,
0.561246931552887,
0.03895021975040436,
0.28024038672447205,
-0.4724518358707428,
-0.5678828358650208,
-0.15246735513210297,
0.4117821156978607,
-0.27468064427375793,
-0.9922470450401306,
0.3306587040424347,
-0.27616119384765625,
0.07368239015340805,
-0.2953503131866455,
0.4312444031238556,
-0.34861236810684204,
-0.24090968072414398,
0.3541337251663208,
0.24627678096294403,
0.2006356567144394,
0.25163039565086365,
-0.643696129322052,
0.0071433656848967075,
-0.014210041612386703,
-0.5422007441520691,
0.2489917278289795,
0.5023232102394104,
-0.35436946153640747,
1.1094601154327393,
0.5258132815361023,
0.24644678831100464,
-0.10004791617393494,
0.33302241563796997,
0.8760961890220642,
-0.8313348889350891,
-0.4351712465286255,
-0.7879325151443481,
0.14839114248752594,
0.08168848603963852,
0.01745760440826416,
0.5479788780212402,
0.4704439342021942,
1.0758744478225708,
-0.1461104452610016,
0.7392969727516174,
0.22049307823181152,
0.7677046060562134,
-0.9981698393821716,
0.06179263815283775,
-0.3346266448497772,
0.45687443017959595,
-0.08144702017307281,
-0.7154562473297119,
-0.7112685441970825,
1.0571482181549072,
-0.8148255348205566,
-0.054493874311447144,
0.7801845669746399,
0.9488534331321716,
-0.1602126806974411,
0.2899182140827179,
0.41773682832717896,
0.027889741584658623,
0.593325138092041,
0.9344759583473206,
1.21393883228302,
-0.16874302923679352,
0.42099180817604065,
-0.03151509165763855,
-0.24466374516487122,
-0.34613460302352905,
-0.9744117856025696,
-0.9031789302825928,
-0.2009279578924179,
-0.1307709813117981,
-0.5146328806877136,
0.14412805438041687,
1.0486185550689697,
0.5251775979995728,
-0.8921181559562683,
-0.23863419890403748,
-0.3262999951839447,
0.49852296710014343,
-0.4918406009674072,
-0.2780700623989105,
0.28607192635536194,
-0.47046613693237305,
-0.4301060438156128,
0.41019564867019653,
0.3591057360172272,
-0.3863648474216461,
-0.4827708899974823,
-0.2807266116142273,
-0.44194164872169495,
-0.037277255207300186,
0.5247305631637573,
0.4783213138580322,
-0.9941926598548889,
-0.6196266412734985,
-0.5602367520332336,
-0.12034918367862701,
-0.07827851176261902,
1.0085088014602661,
-0.668085515499115,
0.1888546645641327,
0.27333763241767883,
0.6443603038787842,
0.706915020942688,
0.003827776527032256,
0.46413859724998474,
-0.4408647418022156,
0.10652567446231842,
0.2344563603401184,
0.21085351705551147,
0.19313311576843262,
-0.16768749058246613,
0.646416187286377,
0.11283159255981445,
-0.7210589647293091,
-0.7384807467460632,
0.7494644522666931,
-0.9830469489097595,
-0.32855600118637085,
1.3164490461349487,
-0.5028122663497925,
-0.17931142449378967,
-0.21792566776275635,
-0.4468776285648346,
0.3387417495250702,
-0.3732149302959442,
0.822435736656189,
0.4767966866493225,
-0.5088706612586975,
-0.5216794610023499,
-0.8829052448272705,
0.31002408266067505,
0.3597233295440674,
-0.7798855304718018,
0.3527528643608093,
0.5552715063095093,
0.1274196207523346,
-0.07976913452148438,
0.5593403577804565,
-0.21958667039871216,
0.23845085501670837,
-0.23556651175022125,
0.20050814747810364,
-0.27281373739242554,
-0.49079808592796326,
-0.1631796509027481,
0.16730423271656036,
0.22209502756595612,
0.1832856386899948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05794v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05794v1 | Phonetically rich corpus construction for a low-resourced language | 2024-02-08T16:36:11 | 2024-02-08T16:36:11 | Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Wilmer Lobato, Niasche Aquino | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Speech technologies rely on capturing a speaker's voice variability while
obtaining comprehensive language information. Textual prompts and sentence
selection methods have been proposed in the literature to comprise such
adequate phonetic data, referred to as a phonetically rich \textit{corpus}.
However, they are still insufficient for acoustic modeling, especially critical
for languages with limited resources. Hence, this paper proposes a novel
approach and outlines the methodological aspects required to create a
\textit{corpus} with broad phonetic coverage for a low-resourced language,
Brazilian Portuguese. Our methodology includes text dataset collection up to a
sentence selection algorithm based on triphone distribution. Furthermore, we
propose a new phonemic classification according to acoustic-articulatory speech
features since the absolute number of distinct triphones, or low-probability
triphones, does not guarantee an adequate representation of every possible
combination. Using our algorithm, we achieve a 55.8\% higher percentage of
distinct triphones -- for samples of similar size -- while the currently
available phonetic-rich corpus, CETUC and TTS-Portuguese, 12.6\% and 12.3\% in
comparison to a non-phonetically rich dataset. | [
-0.4783918857574463,
-0.645417332649231,
-0.059775128960609436,
0.3410915434360504,
-0.4631044268608093,
0.36227646470069885,
-0.5320692658424377,
-0.5273610949516296,
0.7194550037384033,
0.5200473070144653,
0.08665414154529572,
-0.437917560338974,
-0.18526574969291687,
0.0711071714758873,
-0.20281168818473816,
0.808439314365387,
0.3792024552822113,
-0.06615376472473145,
0.5088335871696472,
-0.19754166901111603,
-0.4199346899986267,
-0.36711904406547546,
-0.3366093933582306,
0.17116110026836395,
0.40465760231018066,
0.5529119968414307,
0.8938286900520325,
0.7963443398475647,
0.18064838647842407,
0.17554011940956116,
-0.5735544562339783,
0.13645613193511963,
-0.22286434471607208,
0.09827831387519836,
0.05413995310664177,
-0.37528663873672485,
-0.3972671627998352,
-0.14766012132167816,
0.7027774453163147,
1.1976449489593506,
-0.3225151300430298,
-0.10613978654146194,
0.23877540230751038,
0.0033810557797551155,
-0.5668420195579529,
-0.043575890362262726,
-0.582402229309082,
0.15055911242961884,
-0.6590492129325867,
-0.3425813615322113,
-0.3024789094924927,
-0.350066602230072,
0.07109461724758148,
-0.50083988904953,
0.1651497483253479,
-0.23648492991924286,
0.5646827816963196,
0.10188277065753937,
-0.03524479269981384,
-0.3636494278907776,
-0.9340133666992188,
0.7948185205459595,
-0.3536422550678253,
0.5787142515182495,
0.5174888968467712,
0.21842285990715027,
0.23571845889091492,
-0.2083885222673416,
-0.3418002724647522,
-0.3638426959514618,
0.22570107877254486,
0.13689617812633514,
-0.04077095538377762,
-0.0013388075167313218,
0.0018184788059443235,
0.3969714641571045,
-0.5837079286575317,
0.1922610104084015,
-0.5007967948913574,
-0.4034959077835083,
0.4142516553401947,
-0.3421613574028015,
0.22126707434654236,
-0.506174623966217,
-0.250751793384552,
-0.053681280463933945,
-0.5886058807373047,
-0.21259631216526031,
0.7546892166137695,
0.8935738205909729,
-0.319850891828537,
0.6618846654891968,
0.027104241773486137,
0.6798864603042603,
-0.43125659227371216,
-0.4362197816371918,
0.5264444947242737,
-0.3597361743450165,
-0.12664996087551117,
0.3457135260105133,
0.794339120388031,
-0.3875497579574585,
0.48729830980300903,
-0.10765641927719116,
-0.3897739052772522,
-0.01733911782503128,
-0.02630472183227539,
-0.5379138588905334,
-0.06396748125553131,
0.3429124355316162,
-0.41532623767852783,
-0.37260329723358154,
-0.2560617923736572,
-0.6881895065307617,
-0.14490529894828796,
-0.09029212594032288,
-0.23802819848060608,
-0.7464543581008911,
-0.45580023527145386,
-0.1330946385860443,
-0.04582410305738449,
-0.17225731909275055,
-0.013631364330649376,
-0.772845983505249,
0.1243283599615097,
0.09585141390562057,
0.940410315990448,
-0.1031896099448204,
-0.12378184497356415,
-0.7618461847305298,
0.04875576123595238,
-0.5044257640838623,
0.8924883008003235,
-0.7543331384658813,
-0.9007582664489746,
0.24513067305088043,
-0.4119701385498047,
0.0499611534178257,
-0.8693421483039856,
1.05044686794281,
-0.1196926087141037,
0.21204422414302826,
0.010245096869766712,
-0.18120044469833374,
0.18462572991847992,
-0.08976484835147858,
-0.7312852144241333,
1.1223045587539673,
0.36981919407844543,
-0.8162323832511902,
0.34827175736427307,
-0.43206295371055603,
-0.8059350848197937,
0.5894418954849243,
-0.1962754875421524,
-0.04703275114297867,
-0.1646970510482788,
0.10226346552371979,
0.33913883566856384,
-0.09781113266944885,
0.08930018544197083,
-0.27397602796554565,
-0.5636941194534302,
0.36720025539398193,
-0.48437219858169556,
1.0979982614517212,
0.7302849888801575,
-0.16838538646697998,
-0.27593645453453064,
-0.8505383133888245,
0.14843320846557617,
-0.04857729375362396,
-0.715766191482544,
-0.4799332618713379,
-0.381273090839386,
0.5885118842124939,
-0.18766050040721893,
0.08695610612630844,
-0.39214104413986206,
0.27890247106552124,
-0.7583794593811035,
0.5114017724990845,
0.30517980456352234,
-0.08762205392122269,
0.5796665549278259,
-0.35132625699043274,
0.6323462724685669,
-0.1105644628405571,
-0.10054811835289001,
0.04021907597780228,
-0.3693821132183075,
-0.5837183594703674,
-0.8668913841247559,
0.8405384421348572,
0.9266232848167419,
-0.6910403370857239,
0.5903027057647705,
-0.23676146566867828,
-0.5485518574714661,
-0.6618331074714661,
0.10623965412378311,
0.3556380569934845,
0.15429134666919708,
0.31168222427368164,
-0.3434894382953644,
-0.4934539198875427,
-0.7692373394966125,
0.1870511770248413,
-0.3413675129413605,
-0.20929938554763794,
0.47761476039886475,
0.05851568654179573,
0.008684412576258183,
0.5275847911834717,
-0.17787976562976837,
-0.36026301980018616,
-0.4779321849346161,
-0.0639428123831749,
0.33591800928115845,
0.43814337253570557,
0.7295377850532532,
-0.4433286786079407,
-0.12506656348705292,
0.014062629081308842,
-0.3932095468044281,
-0.23080289363861084,
0.09744322299957275,
-0.08232949674129486,
0.15264858305454254,
0.19177615642547607,
-0.542064905166626,
0.007051147986203432,
0.27564364671707153,
0.015119052492082119,
0.2628673315048218,
-0.15578226745128632,
-0.14778099954128265,
-1.0777757167816162,
0.09641167521476746,
-0.07998308539390564,
-0.003671827493235469,
-0.31959858536720276,
-0.19094982743263245,
-0.3167540431022644,
-0.36649417877197266,
-0.5364584922790527,
0.5588294267654419,
-0.5505304932594299,
-0.3434085547924042,
-0.14043886959552765,
0.24938376247882843,
-0.3364056944847107,
0.4611283540725708,
0.27705898880958557,
0.7033900618553162,
0.6000351309776306,
-0.6631008386611938,
0.39057037234306335,
0.33398622274398804,
-0.3540721535682678,
0.7230355143547058,
-0.5604729056358337,
-0.06303010135889053,
0.17742183804512024,
0.24941706657409668,
-0.743117094039917,
-0.21479037404060364,
0.08174366503953934,
-0.29471084475517273,
0.16822366416454315,
-0.38879477977752686,
-0.48671862483024597,
-0.2651110589504242,
0.07638552784919739,
0.5878186821937561,
0.5068459510803223,
-0.39682433009147644,
0.3740462362766266,
0.8510993123054504,
-0.6050825119018555,
-0.39627712965011597,
-0.8237954378128052,
0.26881563663482666,
-0.5557464957237244,
-0.6170592904090881,
0.37958768010139465,
0.04886187985539436,
-0.441782146692276,
-0.21068014204502106,
0.3700793981552124,
-0.29518213868141174,
0.004139684606343508,
-0.08073413372039795,
0.2796195149421692,
-0.20728330314159393,
0.35181543231010437,
0.05318231135606766,
0.1405298113822937,
-0.4261251986026764,
-0.5322896838188171,
0.6718282699584961,
-0.012752755545079708,
0.11759524792432785,
-0.27393367886543274,
0.5746920108795166,
0.21994991600513458,
-0.4508272707462311,
0.03484402224421501,
0.6347136497497559,
-0.31889593601226807,
-0.5439522862434387,
-0.3928435742855072,
-0.07883022725582123,
-0.32776057720184326,
-0.02729816734790802,
-0.46655869483947754,
-0.5507597327232361,
0.5997963547706604,
0.2680562734603882,
-0.143722802400589,
0.18365439772605896,
0.632061243057251,
-0.04277016595005989,
0.3494704067707062,
0.29760047793388367,
-0.1298978626728058,
0.677457869052887,
-0.38872307538986206,
-0.24581573903560638,
-0.3836391270160675,
0.0990847572684288,
-0.7979908585548401,
-0.13022615015506744,
-1.0286073684692383,
-0.4541751742362976,
0.31387391686439514,
-0.07490622997283936,
0.18228955566883087,
0.5797702074050903,
-0.695618212223053,
0.18565933406352997,
0.9935920238494873,
0.05564458668231964,
0.18341487646102905,
0.22680599987506866,
-0.4650942385196686,
0.2973065972328186,
-0.6841225028038025,
-0.686377227306366,
1.0087578296661377,
0.01208149641752243,
0.4943864047527313,
0.18976616859436035,
0.9697692394256592,
0.3966377377510071,
-0.3915269374847412,
-0.8463009595870972,
0.6289466023445129,
-0.0925305113196373,
-0.4542236030101776,
-0.5306820869445801,
-0.42463046312332153,
-1.2933282852172852,
0.24396315217018127,
-0.33127665519714355,
-0.4710022807121277,
0.3854999542236328,
-0.08656579256057739,
-0.7048304677009583,
-0.080391526222229,
-0.8581414818763733,
0.64974045753479,
-0.24602609872817993,
-0.25681114196777344,
-0.10181748867034912,
-0.6263387799263,
-0.06243138760328293,
0.060074806213378906,
0.38946664333343506,
0.04369683191180229,
-0.0002360818034503609,
0.8782687783241272,
-0.5032076239585876,
0.6895961761474609,
-0.2938022315502167,
-0.21987472474575043,
0.8578625321388245,
0.22297295928001404,
0.2717438042163849,
0.09354086220264435,
-0.10181737691164017,
0.21723572909832,
0.011376897804439068,
-0.671380877494812,
-0.0669475644826889,
0.5555329918861389,
-0.7013347744941711,
0.03671663627028465,
-0.33885088562965393,
-0.3564120829105377,
-0.52950119972229,
0.1683027744293213,
0.4505182206630707,
0.3394974172115326,
-0.5911521315574646,
-0.0019447952508926392,
0.5007299184799194,
-0.2634180188179016,
0.717880129814148,
0.21473900973796844,
0.2866179347038269,
-0.49087172746658325,
1.0348800420761108,
0.4242625832557678,
-0.12009405344724655,
0.42723900079727173,
0.2726527154445648,
-0.2607843279838562,
-0.749147355556488,
-0.52977454662323,
0.3283633589744568,
-0.3044019937515259,
0.03860432654619217,
-0.45631253719329834,
-0.02444516494870186,
-0.4226429760456085,
-0.0037017250433564186,
-0.322726845741272,
-0.7114028930664062,
-0.2533003091812134,
-0.15552379190921783,
0.008628872223198414,
0.38114863634109497,
-0.37360864877700806,
0.22782571613788605,
-0.7786275148391724,
0.19725996255874634,
0.0718933567404747,
0.13995516300201416,
-0.43304115533828735,
-0.4297906458377838,
-0.1730467528104782,
0.04982045292854309,
-0.14206188917160034,
-0.9177109003067017,
0.5474398732185364,
0.13090230524539948,
0.5035075545310974,
0.2544654309749603,
0.1473524272441864,
0.2972864806652069,
-0.1899290680885315,
0.5886841416358948,
-0.033215418457984924,
-0.7022686004638672,
0.812282145023346,
-0.708956241607666,
0.1348583996295929,
0.4569069743156433,
-0.0643591433763504,
-0.3675110340118408,
-0.5540076494216919,
-0.9930002689361572,
-0.9442241191864014,
0.33074674010276794,
0.5731915831565857,
0.12829788029193878,
-0.1690511405467987,
-0.13643917441368103,
0.19453027844429016,
0.16693393886089325,
-0.3650705814361572,
0.1918940246105194,
-0.3312254548072815,
-0.1183382123708725,
0.1519143432378769,
-0.15636193752288818,
-0.22416116297245026,
0.1376287043094635,
0.6128156781196594,
-0.1689339131116867,
0.39391589164733887,
0.125209242105484,
0.01695193536579609,
0.20339824259281158,
0.7243964672088623,
0.5044484734535217,
0.18946382403373718,
-0.20222054421901703,
0.2263764590024948,
0.1988583654165268,
-0.6381956934928894,
-0.06311973929405212,
0.48160508275032043,
-0.22320693731307983,
0.35478541254997253,
0.529931366443634,
0.7026222944259644,
0.05299833044409752,
-0.7972079515457153,
0.4975447952747345,
0.2999742329120636,
0.024484409019351006,
-0.3905179798603058,
-0.11652019619941711,
0.06439503282308578,
0.11818338185548782,
0.2739567756652832,
0.0040741609409451485,
0.292788565158844,
-0.5352542400360107,
-0.003113991115242243,
0.3429551124572754,
-0.24300850927829742,
-0.24168427288532257,
0.30803239345550537,
0.615456759929657,
-0.16030023992061615,
0.5179241299629211,
-0.4550885856151581,
-0.0313827209174633,
0.4891777038574219,
0.14285063743591309,
0.7466561794281006,
-0.44125130772590637,
0.28722745180130005,
0.22575834393501282,
0.14313741028308868,
-0.06469575315713882,
0.7249305248260498,
-0.26666125655174255,
-0.7393068671226501,
-0.18909017741680145,
-0.635006844997406,
-0.5230185389518738,
0.08616681396961212,
-0.4092389643192291,
0.4321621060371399,
-0.2289070039987564,
-0.17616742849349976,
0.13604795932769775,
-0.11645768582820892,
-0.5393316745758057,
0.3790381848812103,
0.2864949405193329,
0.5370404124259949,
-0.4549393951892853,
0.8322031497955322,
0.36991554498672485,
-0.4648454487323761,
-0.8892942070960999,
-0.11551743745803833,
-0.37192386388778687,
-1.0314626693725586,
0.5204454660415649,
-0.29376348853111267,
-0.06924059242010117,
-0.30888044834136963,
-0.18149888515472412,
-0.5096592903137207,
0.4967861771583557,
0.796802818775177,
-0.6020811796188354,
-0.24011541903018951,
0.23872923851013184,
0.6364715695381165,
-0.3289244472980499,
0.4657829701900482,
0.38096341490745544,
0.3639838695526123,
0.26577311754226685,
-1.3476296663284302,
-0.2506221830844879,
-0.2488451600074768,
0.0001826263323891908,
0.02722506783902645,
-0.6261053085327148,
0.5385770201683044,
-0.49135762453079224,
-0.4643700122833252,
0.04111127927899361,
0.5708672404289246,
0.17167900502681732,
-0.08028662949800491,
0.7298084497451782,
0.4775354862213135,
1.2341760396957397,
-0.04170865938067436,
0.8393552899360657,
-0.5357743501663208,
0.013953409157693386,
0.9498932361602783,
-0.18493159115314484,
0.9341463446617126,
0.25829723477363586,
-0.11253362894058228,
0.15175937116146088,
0.832852303981781,
-0.007788304705172777,
0.3974148631095886,
0.33647388219833374,
-0.4150477349758148,
-0.3550874888896942,
-0.5878492593765259,
-0.5479995012283325,
1.0893992185592651,
0.26395297050476074,
-0.3330288827419281,
0.08870162814855576,
0.2086213231086731,
0.08488067984580994,
-0.09746867418289185,
-0.13475827872753143,
0.4997042417526245,
0.05808545649051666,
-0.5631301403045654,
0.9329272508621216,
-0.2382432520389557,
0.5903764367103577,
-0.16625191271305084,
0.19257228076457977,
-0.25603991746902466,
-0.03366472199559212,
-0.20011413097381592,
-0.7962234616279602,
0.2195391058921814,
0.07733431458473206,
0.2302916944026947,
-0.2263302505016327,
0.4779549539089203,
-0.537440836429596,
-0.3987128734588623,
0.1890965849161148,
0.9140503406524658,
0.4388423264026642,
0.04706877842545509,
-0.18370622396469116,
0.029980773106217384,
-0.15023532509803772,
-0.04133046045899391,
-0.08461316674947739,
0.6702812314033508,
-0.13725464046001434,
0.35369810461997986,
0.5240079164505005,
0.578916072845459,
-0.2508419156074524,
0.4561171531677246,
0.6490305066108704,
-0.7897537350654602,
-1.0943940877914429,
-0.39250484108924866,
0.13525605201721191,
-0.030719611793756485,
-0.5449904799461365,
0.3188897669315338,
0.8779208064079285,
0.7719194293022156,
0.15007570385932922,
1.2257521152496338,
0.08107379078865051,
0.8966941237449646,
-0.48172062635421753,
0.3781900405883789,
-0.1864074021577835,
0.37480202317237854,
-0.35302475094795227,
-1.1022205352783203,
-0.11266737431287766,
0.7199172377586365,
0.11397955566644669,
0.07483436912298203,
0.5597108006477356,
0.5556855201721191,
-0.10273432731628418,
0.28329190611839294,
0.33579760789871216,
0.22037698328495026,
-0.03966432437300682,
0.5549073219299316,
0.8075321316719055,
-0.0007343209581449628,
1.143776535987854,
-0.07639650255441666,
-0.3422732353210449,
-0.2425820529460907,
-0.5725472569465637,
-0.687850296497345,
-0.5465212464332581,
-0.2343323677778244,
-0.5739924311637878,
0.04880134016275406,
0.9109545946121216,
0.7275327444076538,
-0.5902619361877441,
-0.5341544151306152,
0.03159068897366524,
-0.0022905634250491858,
-0.29879090189933777,
-0.20804202556610107,
0.33823472261428833,
-0.0919186994433403,
-0.9599226713180542,
0.7171323895454407,
0.14390762150287628,
0.3344752788543701,
-0.15597987174987793,
0.20216363668441772,
0.21163411438465118,
0.13069656491279602,
0.4417792856693268,
0.3794519007205963,
-0.41003552079200745,
-0.21255919337272644,
0.2302985042333603,
-0.19238698482513428,
0.21272355318069458,
0.7659993767738342,
-0.8194880485534668,
0.21629047393798828,
0.5134061574935913,
0.3024521768093109,
0.4125860333442688,
-0.4391537010669708,
0.2738436758518219,
-0.8810195922851562,
0.5361350178718567,
0.7130565643310547,
0.6535485982894897,
0.5666192173957825,
-0.11514478176832199,
0.6862866878509521,
0.5555803179740906,
-0.1673947125673294,
-0.8354065418243408,
0.35766544938087463,
-1.759148359298706,
-0.20536233484745026,
1.5952668190002441,
0.33205974102020264,
0.012027841992676258,
-0.2472923845052719,
-0.57662034034729,
0.2858777344226837,
-0.9438285827636719,
0.6089791059494019,
0.560020387172699,
-0.023874111473560333,
0.20085746049880981,
-0.19580532610416412,
0.2986263632774353,
0.21386130154132843,
-0.7037298083305359,
0.11812343448400497,
0.5837586522102356,
0.035036005079746246,
0.4780014753341675,
0.7959455847740173,
0.038599979132413864,
-0.023491213098168373,
0.19334764778614044,
-0.048743151128292084,
0.2041940540075302,
-0.24886910617351532,
0.18664298951625824,
0.6752162575721741,
0.017033224925398827,
-0.27575919032096863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05785v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05785v3 | Limits of Transformer Language Models on Learning to Compose Algorithms | 2024-02-08T16:23:29 | 2024-05-25T11:09:28 | Jonathan Thomm, Aleksandar Terzic, Giacomo Camposampiero, Michael Hersche, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abbas Rahimi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We analyze the capabilities of Transformer language models in learning
compositional discrete tasks. To this end, we evaluate training LLaMA models
and prompting GPT-4 and Gemini on four tasks demanding to learn a composition
of several discrete sub-tasks. On both training LLaMA models from scratch and
prompting on GPT-4 and Gemini, we measure how well these models can reuse
primitives observable in the sub-tasks to learn the composition task. Our
results indicate that compositional learning in state-of-the-art Transformer
language models is highly sample inefficient: LLaMA requires more data samples
than relearning all sub-tasks from scratch to learn the compositional task;
in-context prompting with few samples is unreliable and fails at executing the
sub-tasks or correcting the errors in multi-round code generation. Further, by
leveraging complexity theory, we support these findings with a theoretical
analysis focused on the sample inefficiency of gradient descent in memorizing
feedforward models. | [
-0.1097496822476387,
-0.5493950843811035,
0.606480062007904,
0.30847516655921936,
0.010287321172654629,
0.21584592759609222,
-0.21203140914440155,
-0.3509606719017029,
-0.20878057181835175,
0.4442884624004364,
-0.9119818806648254,
-0.13957567512989044,
-0.6917147040367126,
0.30310148000717163,
-0.5261349081993103,
1.1969817876815796,
-0.14799587428569794,
-0.07955661416053772,
-0.391478568315506,
0.2545281946659088,
-0.7928088307380676,
-0.16390320658683777,
-0.5205698609352112,
-0.4229221045970917,
0.39737173914909363,
0.5939357280731201,
0.16456329822540283,
0.4792804718017578,
0.3770293891429901,
0.3547559082508087,
-0.021680887788534164,
-0.06969333440065384,
-0.631453275680542,
0.23311994969844818,
-0.03509899228811264,
-0.9101139903068542,
0.12945693731307983,
0.10462530702352524,
0.5109604001045227,
0.6197097897529602,
-0.2397441416978836,
0.06936094164848328,
-0.2537820637226105,
0.511992871761322,
-0.3745369017124176,
0.3667030930519104,
-0.9323952794075012,
0.021179819479584694,
-0.009659317322075367,
0.2821388840675354,
-0.4274125397205353,
-0.13444951176643372,
0.26167428493499756,
-0.5995408296585083,
0.3072076439857483,
-0.28362610936164856,
0.3981465697288513,
0.5360364317893982,
-0.24095465242862701,
-0.7208968997001648,
-0.8067803382873535,
0.9422898292541504,
-0.42242908477783203,
0.24335695803165436,
0.4490814805030823,
0.4008379876613617,
0.13552702963352203,
-1.0600318908691406,
-0.6695188283920288,
-0.45436766743659973,
-0.028540166094899178,
0.09994736313819885,
-0.36971065402030945,
-0.17330318689346313,
0.5048897862434387,
0.40329283475875854,
-0.23280370235443115,
0.1971307396888733,
-0.7134342789649963,
-0.015939276665449142,
0.37767285108566284,
0.32398393750190735,
0.2597554624080658,
0.06022549420595169,
-0.2306889146566391,
-0.23151768743991852,
-0.7766793966293335,
0.14689207077026367,
0.47402283549308777,
0.12287338078022003,
-0.36870330572128296,
0.3570965528488159,
0.1070086732506752,
0.5502908825874329,
0.35478535294532776,
-0.3893219530582428,
0.08534007519483566,
-0.15305083990097046,
-0.21288500726222992,
-0.47053980827331543,
0.6024627685546875,
-0.1923828274011612,
0.2529100179672241,
-0.33961448073387146,
-0.45319685339927673,
0.18816587328910828,
0.7707113027572632,
-0.5857152342796326,
-0.4561331272125244,
0.23626282811164856,
-0.10921765863895416,
-0.2189662903547287,
-0.03882142901420593,
-0.3157136142253876,
0.0019812786485999823,
-0.3541366457939148,
0.6672461032867432,
-0.4142136573791504,
0.05412313714623451,
0.022342499345541,
-0.06206107139587402,
0.2650192081928253,
0.04030988737940788,
-1.2553220987319946,
0.37168198823928833,
0.7551196217536926,
0.5510886907577515,
-0.20078855752944946,
-0.6547083258628845,
-0.10165446996688843,
-0.20287325978279114,
-0.18900945782661438,
0.8312652707099915,
-0.6315497756004333,
-0.6672171950340271,
-0.2064862847328186,
-0.018088964745402336,
-0.5826223492622375,
-0.7285528779029846,
0.3897935450077057,
-0.474960058927536,
0.2865477502346039,
-0.36475616693496704,
-0.5655123591423035,
-0.3736255466938019,
0.06322254985570908,
-0.987631618976593,
1.0352414846420288,
0.5091031789779663,
-0.45280224084854126,
0.11529042571783066,
-0.464875727891922,
-0.7071681618690491,
-0.028456661850214005,
-0.24535012245178223,
-0.5813096165657043,
0.3100336492061615,
0.2658443748950958,
0.640197217464447,
-0.3128383755683899,
0.16665509343147278,
0.34510499238967896,
-0.5099673271179199,
0.2948194444179535,
-0.2142006754875183,
0.5081816911697388,
0.08947763592004776,
-0.5860668420791626,
0.09680254757404327,
-0.6309837698936462,
-0.46335601806640625,
0.15177510678768158,
-0.5767426490783691,
0.23642589151859283,
0.18605811893939972,
-0.26955822110176086,
0.2064124196767807,
0.08862283825874329,
-0.39570337533950806,
0.19314531981945038,
-0.2749098241329193,
0.7063952684402466,
0.7277414202690125,
-0.1468605399131775,
0.6362475156784058,
-0.6345497965812683,
0.790971040725708,
0.07621214538812637,
0.0729481652379036,
-0.5675859451293945,
-0.4248714745044708,
-0.9596256613731384,
-0.1998472362756729,
0.007289496250450611,
0.5651984810829163,
-0.8051647543907166,
0.0768563374876976,
-0.29100489616394043,
-0.761620819568634,
-0.33402588963508606,
0.16007475554943085,
0.4527292549610138,
0.6246383190155029,
0.32777273654937744,
-0.20791639387607574,
-0.40056702494621277,
-0.7802702188491821,
0.13907049596309662,
0.09151121973991394,
-0.008248988538980484,
0.11159106343984604,
0.7861732244491577,
-0.2881919741630554,
0.7051071524620056,
-0.15264396369457245,
0.02348550781607628,
-0.4053654670715332,
-0.08483830094337463,
0.2537662982940674,
0.4377700686454773,
0.4139863848686218,
-0.6796143054962158,
-0.4988723695278168,
-0.1441577970981598,
-0.49617552757263184,
0.017382293939590454,
-0.03096707910299301,
0.355760782957077,
0.048856861889362335,
0.5120421648025513,
-0.6686276793479919,
-0.011860535480082035,
0.7481253743171692,
0.1411314159631729,
0.5648015737533569,
-0.0705995038151741,
-0.3842754065990448,
-0.8121873140335083,
-0.13145558536052704,
-0.16683198511600494,
0.1319800615310669,
-0.8892529606819153,
0.15726475417613983,
0.20067718625068665,
-0.06813418865203857,
-0.4310837388038635,
0.17170219123363495,
-0.3163943588733673,
0.135517880320549,
-0.4396066665649414,
-0.36669689416885376,
-0.28376883268356323,
0.7667803168296814,
0.010692841373383999,
0.7336501479148865,
0.5343928933143616,
-0.6578027009963989,
0.14250877499580383,
0.028472580015659332,
-0.31292349100112915,
0.45420047640800476,
-0.8905557990074158,
0.23016908764839172,
-0.3419150412082672,
0.4277741312980652,
-1.1051634550094604,
-0.20077753067016602,
0.13543550670146942,
-0.027472447603940964,
0.321903795003891,
0.11271043866872787,
-0.08039005100727081,
-0.3692379295825958,
-0.02130858600139618,
0.3942452371120453,
0.513587236404419,
-0.42855018377304077,
0.8793503046035767,
0.12207400798797607,
0.1584523618221283,
-0.7064182162284851,
-0.663434624671936,
-0.38980185985565186,
-0.0926022157073021,
-0.33095255494117737,
0.5487410426139832,
-0.04265902563929558,
0.050332531332969666,
-0.1495596021413803,
-0.20979131758213043,
0.18332581222057343,
0.08712582290172577,
0.45574092864990234,
0.03640737757086754,
0.052634578198194504,
0.030311333015561104,
-0.00753843504935503,
-0.19378653168678284,
0.20736920833587646,
-0.37511566281318665,
0.6109694242477417,
-0.07664863020181656,
-0.6280786991119385,
-0.3057955801486969,
0.20935936272144318,
0.6089953184127808,
-0.2581704556941986,
0.573211669921875,
0.4100126326084137,
-0.1655033677816391,
-0.46525058150291443,
-0.6100822687149048,
-0.3073515295982361,
-0.464326947927475,
0.33611685037612915,
-0.5266097784042358,
-1.0401684045791626,
0.727558434009552,
0.14798471331596375,
0.24988950788974762,
0.6389532685279846,
0.6311269998550415,
-0.1072535514831543,
0.4488856792449951,
0.7140985131263733,
-0.3612506091594696,
0.49138253927230835,
-0.6990472078323364,
0.038672368973493576,
-0.6035549640655518,
-0.41059404611587524,
-0.6348248720169067,
-0.4211452901363373,
-0.6628040671348572,
-0.5185331702232361,
0.4799290895462036,
-0.4725939929485321,
-0.45491865277290344,
0.4047220051288605,
-0.4474450349807739,
0.7461933493614197,
0.8357406854629517,
0.259281724691391,
0.20154644548892975,
0.01854153908789158,
-0.009189938195049763,
0.13685491681098938,
-0.7889803647994995,
-0.25094303488731384,
1.2302433252334595,
0.3294374644756317,
0.8293318748474121,
-0.07870068401098251,
0.6344244480133057,
-0.08686526119709015,
0.434817373752594,
-0.8676772117614746,
0.20304366946220398,
-0.18007761240005493,
-0.5517686605453491,
-0.14183641970157623,
-0.2539632022380829,
-0.8066871762275696,
0.09119559079408646,
0.026918107643723488,
-0.45960497856140137,
0.06241700053215027,
-0.027233649045228958,
-0.15889927744865417,
0.33733928203582764,
-0.45055046677589417,
0.573540985584259,
0.039265744388103485,
0.13967154920101166,
-0.06509669870138168,
-0.7840063571929932,
0.4871002733707428,
-0.26118239760398865,
0.15677155554294586,
0.26373547315597534,
-0.01824667677283287,
0.5401676893234253,
-0.1594381481409073,
1.3463943004608154,
-0.08339234441518784,
-0.36011871695518494,
0.3934421241283417,
0.06658725440502167,
0.7278103232383728,
-0.3499343991279602,
0.016433747485280037,
-0.04140697419643402,
-0.2538357675075531,
-0.2643020451068878,
-0.5322595834732056,
0.27275022864341736,
-0.9377336502075195,
-0.45289865136146545,
-0.10283274948596954,
-0.5131335854530334,
-0.035840027034282684,
-0.2085431069135666,
0.6569725275039673,
0.3084430992603302,
0.04407558590173721,
0.05502519756555557,
0.7145856022834778,
0.03899504244327545,
0.5575035214424133,
0.3123164474964142,
0.32868972420692444,
-0.32942861318588257,
0.943452000617981,
0.02502487786114216,
0.42209741473197937,
0.6070996522903442,
0.20060652494430542,
-0.2102055549621582,
-0.667451798915863,
-0.4044705927371979,
0.2885221838951111,
-0.8612085580825806,
-0.11408702284097672,
-0.5832114219665527,
-0.10678493231534958,
0.11726966500282288,
-0.08138401806354523,
-0.41768044233322144,
-0.23661793768405914,
-0.402738094329834,
-0.21154913306236267,
-0.032319724559783936,
1.1500816345214844,
0.2597394585609436,
0.748934805393219,
-0.6454893946647644,
0.06422840803861618,
0.5858824253082275,
0.04931033030152321,
0.26940667629241943,
-0.6250956058502197,
-0.43610823154449463,
-0.18087877333164215,
-0.6625841856002808,
-0.8498364686965942,
-0.007646661251783371,
0.07340642809867859,
0.7635316848754883,
0.20991727709770203,
-0.3871675431728363,
0.38665059208869934,
-0.5504045486450195,
0.9339830875396729,
-0.05812213569879532,
-1.1885422468185425,
0.18451115489006042,
-0.35719332098960876,
0.3835487961769104,
0.47395050525665283,
0.6782416105270386,
-0.5417799949645996,
-0.26653343439102173,
-0.6379580497741699,
-0.5235247015953064,
0.6614841222763062,
-0.06793355196714401,
0.5277256369590759,
0.013979892246425152,
0.6041359901428223,
0.29950377345085144,
0.23436930775642395,
-1.0911332368850708,
-0.15689606964588165,
-0.26574188470840454,
-0.3725486993789673,
-0.07564819604158401,
-0.2807523310184479,
0.03243196755647659,
-0.21811144053936005,
0.5939047932624817,
-0.2510150074958801,
0.372909814119339,
-0.1300014853477478,
-0.060987941920757294,
-0.12298663705587387,
0.07720407843589783,
0.8526355624198914,
0.6184329986572266,
0.3630419075489044,
0.01939036324620247,
0.3341204524040222,
-0.543714702129364,
0.3555073142051697,
-0.1555231511592865,
-0.2687631845474243,
-0.4944288730621338,
0.6519383788108826,
0.9662941694259644,
0.41636568307876587,
-0.6795421242713928,
0.45556193590164185,
-0.006848803721368313,
-0.4399263262748718,
-0.26236966252326965,
0.24241434037685394,
0.28189077973365784,
0.3136619031429291,
0.42489326000213623,
-0.08388414978981018,
-0.1447627991437912,
-0.43099090456962585,
-0.030574990436434746,
0.3734179437160492,
-0.35974588990211487,
-0.5515046715736389,
0.6893388628959656,
-0.04296773299574852,
-0.21485581994056702,
0.8299010396003723,
-0.016352616250514984,
-0.6737831234931946,
0.6587032675743103,
0.7681871652603149,
0.8146884441375732,
-0.40672802925109863,
0.22806665301322937,
0.19396594166755676,
0.46583691239356995,
-0.3772223889827728,
0.15890181064605713,
-0.3626767694950104,
-0.6738331317901611,
-0.7602406740188599,
-0.5168652534484863,
-0.7046735882759094,
0.10997279733419418,
-0.2331649363040924,
-0.09112691134214401,
-0.3939283788204193,
0.18593913316726685,
-0.10685272514820099,
-0.1515064388513565,
-0.5901798605918884,
0.25374796986579895,
-0.12307605892419815,
0.5803610682487488,
-0.981220006942749,
0.4829782247543335,
0.5053933262825012,
-0.3577674329280853,
-1.286001205444336,
-0.22638146579265594,
-0.21159544587135315,
-0.719710648059845,
0.7607754468917847,
0.24155405163764954,
-0.018945984542369843,
0.015943055972456932,
-0.6224753856658936,
-0.8153446912765503,
1.1083307266235352,
0.4333268702030182,
-0.4170096218585968,
-0.24394427239894867,
0.2652779519557953,
0.48547253012657166,
-0.4170207977294922,
0.37770557403564453,
0.6802767515182495,
0.3313915431499481,
0.2680155038833618,
-0.9785290360450745,
0.007295746356248856,
-0.15785270929336548,
0.04537079483270645,
0.05553717166185379,
-0.5967080593109131,
1.424839973449707,
-0.1700325310230255,
-0.287394255399704,
0.03168981149792671,
0.6165276765823364,
0.03074009157717228,
0.022662116214632988,
0.48626190423965454,
0.6653452515602112,
0.6223965883255005,
-0.11698447167873383,
1.1661639213562012,
-0.029620157554745674,
0.2270534634590149,
0.8993577361106873,
-0.050859082490205765,
0.6435593366622925,
0.45824557542800903,
-0.46106889843940735,
0.8478555679321289,
0.41923987865448,
-0.12653149664402008,
0.4397234320640564,
0.4563671052455902,
-0.3690292239189148,
0.02297644317150116,
0.39881691336631775,
0.027302421629428864,
0.7304964065551758,
0.3374398350715637,
-0.4215051531791687,
-0.10384295880794525,
0.20749062299728394,
-0.0898023173213005,
0.0012464950559660792,
-0.04645486921072006,
0.8619397282600403,
0.044836025685071945,
-1.093786358833313,
0.5456293821334839,
0.06561405956745148,
0.7195357084274292,
-0.5904907584190369,
0.1944105327129364,
-0.23009710013866425,
0.04387058690190315,
-0.13268151879310608,
-0.3580787777900696,
0.39369067549705505,
-0.21730883419513702,
-0.22872859239578247,
0.01435998547822237,
0.39298948645591736,
-0.3005610704421997,
-0.46000510454177856,
-0.12331061065196991,
0.6657688617706299,
-0.04926074668765068,
-0.244444340467453,
-0.37200644612312317,
-0.015693265944719315,
0.060007017105817795,
-0.22378738224506378,
0.07309726625680923,
0.12393447756767273,
-0.05852968618273735,
0.7939234375953674,
0.6492868661880493,
-0.20856311917304993,
0.29125797748565674,
0.05139797925949097,
0.9665994644165039,
-0.4889383316040039,
-0.40400511026382446,
-1.0174150466918945,
0.5147944688796997,
0.5359188914299011,
-0.09737356007099152,
0.5902544260025024,
0.24368955194950104,
1.2140508890151978,
-0.5107244253158569,
0.7939004898071289,
-0.02302851527929306,
0.2459355890750885,
-0.6410541534423828,
0.22601664066314697,
-0.16306661069393158,
0.3354964554309845,
-0.11070065200328827,
-0.9967257976531982,
-0.10286572575569153,
0.4944900572299957,
-0.3457014858722687,
0.3341939151287079,
0.7198152542114258,
0.8166383504867554,
-0.1985054463148117,
0.4125031530857086,
0.1475985199213028,
-0.258403480052948,
0.45323750376701355,
0.8884188532829285,
1.0895822048187256,
-0.4334205090999603,
0.38058698177337646,
-0.554745614528656,
0.04211483895778656,
0.006662675645202398,
-0.6894986033439636,
-0.9699379801750183,
-0.8617861866950989,
0.06947163492441177,
0.008813336491584778,
-0.3444286286830902,
0.8140086531639099,
0.7106702923774719,
-0.6325333118438721,
-0.4103470742702484,
-0.34618133306503296,
0.1446818709373474,
-0.382865846157074,
-0.14231136441230774,
0.24212272465229034,
-0.5296390056610107,
-1.0134197473526,
0.5084417462348938,
-0.02363193780183792,
0.2927156090736389,
-0.4506148397922516,
0.014525730162858963,
0.23247338831424713,
-0.06033087894320488,
0.5387283563613892,
0.27291062474250793,
-0.6624126434326172,
-0.011319746263325214,
0.24369651079177856,
0.016576720401644707,
0.033172644674777985,
1.194912314414978,
-0.7664680480957031,
0.20379434525966644,
0.3914787769317627,
0.819284200668335,
0.8179406523704529,
-0.16811512410640717,
0.3730342388153076,
-0.8471211194992065,
-0.06496495753526688,
0.11537538468837738,
0.2117457389831543,
0.34307169914245605,
-0.17564450204372406,
0.36997300386428833,
0.27278661727905273,
-0.6953411102294922,
-0.3185499608516693,
0.42336171865463257,
-0.7975686192512512,
-0.16714268922805786,
0.8565576076507568,
-0.01729677803814411,
-0.2543802261352539,
0.0421682633459568,
-0.1641138345003128,
0.019675876945257187,
-0.09866075217723846,
0.6837906241416931,
0.6109816431999207,
-0.24369896948337555,
-0.21120132505893707,
-0.48050656914711,
0.5820190906524658,
0.3385484516620636,
-0.7473985552787781,
-0.1863812357187271,
0.3348991572856903,
0.5506168007850647,
0.1730717420578003,
0.6474813222885132,
0.05783414468169212,
0.33567893505096436,
0.14820516109466553,
-0.1740320771932602,
-0.24401651322841644,
-0.502280592918396,
-0.4758669137954712,
0.22602178156375885,
-0.15366017818450928,
0.0509406216442585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05783v2 | Text-to-Code Generation with Modality-relative Pre-training | 2024-02-08T16:17:24 | 2024-02-12T10:44:18 | Fenia Christopoulou, Guchun Zhang, Gerasimos Lampouras | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large pre-trained language models have recently been expanded and applied to
programming language tasks with great success, often through further
pre-training of a strictly-natural language model--where training sequences
typically contain both natural and (linearised) programming language. Such
approaches effectively map both modalities of the sequence into the same
embedding space. However, programming language keywords (e.g. "while") often
have very strictly defined semantics. As such, transfer learning from their
natural language usage may not necessarily be beneficial to their code
application and vise versa. Assuming an already pre-trained language model, in
this work we investigate how sequence tokens can be adapted and represented
differently, depending on which modality they belong to, and to the ultimate
benefit of the downstream task. We experiment with separating embedding spaces
between modalities during further model pre-training with modality-relative
training objectives. We focus on text-to-code generation and observe consistent
improvements across two backbone models and two test sets, measuring pass@$k$
and a novel incremental variation. | [
-0.27944257855415344,
-0.3587806224822998,
0.4625290036201477,
0.11937406659126282,
-0.3997284173965454,
0.06663500517606735,
-0.29001563787460327,
-0.4171694815158844,
0.01861029677093029,
0.3009542226791382,
-0.5122610926628113,
-0.30091041326522827,
-0.48868119716644287,
0.396747350692749,
-0.21361301839351654,
1.179007649421692,
-0.1511239856481552,
0.059279561042785645,
-0.14794383943080902,
-0.06082245334982872,
-0.7411030530929565,
-0.9203026294708252,
-0.1249472051858902,
-0.020279424265027046,
0.38743117451667786,
0.23767966032028198,
0.5045236349105835,
0.5449270009994507,
0.43030768632888794,
0.2623344659805298,
0.4284660220146179,
-0.04436559975147247,
-0.23766279220581055,
0.03127070143818855,
-0.1251002997159958,
-0.5737903714179993,
-0.3845047056674957,
0.010962432250380516,
0.7572077512741089,
0.7325347065925598,
0.2892301082611084,
0.16417042911052704,
0.11281553655862808,
0.4364403486251831,
-0.6119399666786194,
-0.03716473653912544,
-0.6426233649253845,
0.0334562212228775,
-0.13636884093284607,
-0.4046560525894165,
-0.4576512277126312,
-0.21829436719417572,
0.12913917005062103,
-0.5545433163642883,
0.10202474892139435,
-0.09828836470842361,
0.790910005569458,
0.1350780427455902,
-0.4817837178707123,
-0.5617787837982178,
-0.4511578679084778,
0.7096907496452332,
-0.8706977367401123,
0.49659502506256104,
0.3768059015274048,
-0.031777918338775635,
0.1753527820110321,
-0.8937214016914368,
-0.6764950752258301,
-0.6429888010025024,
-0.18650084733963013,
-0.11346305161714554,
0.21354292333126068,
0.06002230569720268,
0.3836856782436371,
0.2977931499481201,
-0.503279983997345,
-0.12001443654298782,
-0.31882256269454956,
-0.21761855483055115,
0.36265888810157776,
-0.032742273062467575,
0.16052554547786713,
-0.4238603115081787,
-0.2723401188850403,
-0.131486177444458,
-0.7242469191551208,
0.07906415313482285,
0.44527363777160645,
0.4613552391529083,
-0.2889043986797333,
0.5045634508132935,
0.06861422210931778,
0.7872259020805359,
0.11746246367692947,
-0.1763952374458313,
0.42115893959999084,
-0.970511794090271,
-0.31093496084213257,
-0.23140326142311096,
0.5475189089775085,
-0.22448928654193878,
0.15219788253307343,
-0.344518780708313,
-0.30176299810409546,
0.19524314999580383,
0.5663047432899475,
-0.867190420627594,
-0.3455621004104614,
-0.2048037201166153,
-0.6077690720558167,
-0.43658626079559326,
0.2538317143917084,
-0.16490435600280762,
0.10562852025032043,
-0.5568768382072449,
0.6011361479759216,
-0.4680745303630829,
-0.16925857961177826,
0.07267232984304428,
-0.00591285340487957,
0.27724960446357727,
0.0413033589720726,
-0.6401951313018799,
0.04002678766846657,
0.4710444509983063,
0.6753865480422974,
-0.14749926328659058,
-0.14623743295669556,
-0.5956677198410034,
0.03514337167143822,
-0.22966443002223969,
0.5146374106407166,
-0.8274461030960083,
-0.6463578343391418,
0.07485085725784302,
-0.16978362202644348,
-0.1803237497806549,
-0.3475661277770996,
0.17279163002967834,
-0.5336546301841736,
0.5032625794410706,
-0.3116587996482849,
-0.5398549437522888,
0.04786786064505577,
0.27275174856185913,
-0.3607841730117798,
0.9648370146751404,
0.28073883056640625,
-0.7364283800125122,
0.6810684204101562,
-0.7892486453056335,
-0.6945623755455017,
-0.334904283285141,
-0.5065205693244934,
-0.226415753364563,
0.29870912432670593,
-0.17659389972686768,
0.33438628911972046,
-0.2830974757671356,
0.06260981410741806,
-0.17673039436340332,
-0.2787720561027527,
0.4786533713340759,
-0.37686848640441895,
0.2498020976781845,
0.21277274191379547,
-0.4568924605846405,
0.17093592882156372,
-0.9164925217628479,
0.1844213902950287,
-0.20229598879814148,
-0.6649340987205505,
-0.3808031976222992,
-0.11069986969232559,
0.10112008452415466,
0.4194343388080597,
0.17718954384326935,
-0.20035992562770844,
0.48044243454933167,
-0.3557632267475128,
0.360385537147522,
0.7317676544189453,
-0.07596439123153687,
0.7017480134963989,
-0.41919004917144775,
0.7212250232696533,
0.07377222180366516,
-0.20106226205825806,
-0.5343489050865173,
-0.08444536477327347,
-0.7525582909584045,
-0.2776641845703125,
0.4415561556816101,
0.4105667769908905,
-1.031753420829773,
0.5488535761833191,
-0.3724391460418701,
0.07837213575839996,
-0.06221505254507065,
0.07251276075839996,
0.5645077228546143,
0.40034541487693787,
0.2317950427532196,
-0.7524173855781555,
-0.48041316866874695,
-0.4996342957019806,
-0.07442058622837067,
-0.20436307787895203,
-0.034197766333818436,
0.31066298484802246,
0.3794088363647461,
-0.3120880424976349,
0.8936091661453247,
-0.46130090951919556,
-0.004193311091512442,
-0.2371947169303894,
0.17838901281356812,
0.2080252468585968,
0.7543343901634216,
0.6108685731887817,
-0.7728164792060852,
-0.4693073630332947,
-0.09607048332691193,
-0.23705288767814636,
-0.2146078199148178,
-0.564641535282135,
-0.22941669821739197,
0.2535490393638611,
0.7526902556419373,
-0.18303342163562775,
0.4620884358882904,
0.5343689918518066,
-0.40190181136131287,
0.7023865580558777,
-0.2658003866672516,
0.2397029995918274,
-1.4761723279953003,
0.40438124537467957,
-0.4626506268978119,
-0.4323313236236572,
-0.4775540232658386,
-0.007536340970546007,
0.019457010552287102,
-0.05621024966239929,
-0.35058921575546265,
0.260578989982605,
-0.5410098433494568,
-0.13535283505916595,
-0.2984362244606018,
-0.11167752742767334,
0.09177123755216599,
0.4696100652217865,
0.10017965734004974,
0.9597713947296143,
0.522144615650177,
-0.7190904021263123,
-0.07520879060029984,
0.13425320386886597,
-0.04927799850702286,
0.2569195628166199,
-0.5212017893791199,
0.47129005193710327,
0.16681499779224396,
0.2513214349746704,
-0.9156341552734375,
-0.16194288432598114,
0.2376066893339157,
-0.4066430628299713,
0.6351138949394226,
-0.0765509083867073,
-0.4439418613910675,
-0.12020712345838547,
-0.3361774981021881,
0.9105184674263,
0.5911245346069336,
-0.09349310398101807,
0.36138415336608887,
-0.07014340907335281,
0.0016621671384200454,
-0.36841511726379395,
-0.7728045582771301,
-0.09971530735492706,
-0.17691312730312347,
-0.36488884687423706,
0.5405590534210205,
-0.055056724697351456,
0.148645281791687,
-0.09223970025777817,
-0.220490962266922,
-0.224275141954422,
0.04321073740720749,
0.23907212913036346,
0.32339397072792053,
-0.4206269085407257,
0.2742049992084503,
-0.03156089037656784,
-0.134013831615448,
-0.019344868138432503,
-0.692589282989502,
0.5658308267593384,
0.037030179053545,
-0.6102068424224854,
-0.24062170088291168,
0.3649192750453949,
0.3320169448852539,
-0.32478299736976624,
0.6486343741416931,
0.37042924761772156,
-0.12647847831249237,
-0.1422668844461441,
-0.20985883474349976,
-0.1442105919122696,
-0.5217083096504211,
0.44034114480018616,
-0.625918984413147,
-0.8824381232261658,
0.30906379222869873,
-0.08386025577783585,
0.21554678678512573,
0.11431942135095596,
0.45953428745269775,
0.09702068567276001,
0.7265431880950928,
0.9206383228302002,
0.10555396229028702,
0.8597660064697266,
-0.18610496819019318,
0.30912068486213684,
-0.5269829034805298,
-0.011006621643900871,
-0.6925519704818726,
-0.10911784321069717,
-0.5952383875846863,
-0.7108652591705322,
0.10453929752111435,
0.2977789342403412,
-0.27287352085113525,
0.6163353323936462,
-0.32389694452285767,
0.3112596869468689,
0.39059779047966003,
-0.025394311174750328,
0.11635264754295349,
0.040551405400037766,
-0.14375822246074677,
-0.06840534508228302,
-0.7168289422988892,
-0.4867002069950104,
1.1870299577713013,
0.13067562878131866,
0.548340380191803,
0.11522436887025833,
0.8033114671707153,
0.3448876440525055,
0.5561491847038269,
-0.6122034788131714,
0.3311770260334015,
-0.30321261286735535,
-0.3529050946235657,
0.051151733845472336,
-0.5581746697425842,
-0.709011971950531,
-0.08438409119844437,
-0.14937597513198853,
-0.45868539810180664,
0.09376449882984161,
0.244644895195961,
-0.2602711319923401,
-0.03601321205496788,
-0.5741308331489563,
0.9004522562026978,
-0.19322775304317474,
-0.21309620141983032,
-0.15520992875099182,
-0.7985944151878357,
0.027080737054347992,
-0.42981693148612976,
0.14503377676010132,
0.21804660558700562,
-0.025271430611610413,
0.34447652101516724,
-0.562811017036438,
0.7287510633468628,
0.018111860379576683,
-0.1258154660463333,
0.2691476047039032,
0.20008836686611176,
0.3518247902393341,
0.1050587147474289,
0.013560890220105648,
-0.1540309190750122,
0.013409447856247425,
-0.4288157820701599,
-0.43787360191345215,
0.304984450340271,
-0.6480826735496521,
-0.40196675062179565,
-0.17729926109313965,
-0.596589207649231,
-0.34766116738319397,
0.2157640904188156,
0.5705771446228027,
0.8680424690246582,
0.10703384131193161,
0.11873015761375427,
0.43973276019096375,
-0.4138108491897583,
0.45754924416542053,
0.19286195933818817,
-0.1827470064163208,
-0.22148306667804718,
0.7891150116920471,
-0.15636728703975677,
0.7142899632453918,
0.6438513994216919,
0.05029475316405296,
-0.3949342668056488,
-0.5608291029930115,
-0.4027121961116791,
0.07641297578811646,
-0.7267331480979919,
-0.16597993671894073,
-0.3255404531955719,
-0.10285884886980057,
-0.5348787903785706,
-0.5901409983634949,
-0.23752908408641815,
-0.3680315315723419,
-0.4930031895637512,
0.13942451775074005,
0.08472217619419098,
0.5639629364013672,
0.005440275184810162,
0.15893927216529846,
-1.1586620807647705,
0.24669627845287323,
0.1973886340856552,
0.18302680552005768,
-0.212433323264122,
-0.7576430439949036,
-0.22917859256267548,
0.12594197690486908,
-0.2691863477230072,
-0.9416746497154236,
0.13155913352966309,
0.47700440883636475,
0.31922465562820435,
0.278556227684021,
-0.07317196577787399,
0.8823490142822266,
-0.5759790539741516,
0.9111524820327759,
0.512550950050354,
-1.1496953964233398,
0.4762484133243561,
-0.23728814721107483,
0.41568320989608765,
0.7833089828491211,
0.18132264912128448,
-0.37110650539398193,
-0.3615817725658417,
-0.32990366220474243,
-0.7344786524772644,
0.5843337178230286,
0.27499014139175415,
0.649568498134613,
-0.1179504245519638,
0.45246508717536926,
0.44850218296051025,
0.2941669523715973,
-1.126794457435608,
-0.04066177085042,
-0.41036900877952576,
-0.19023510813713074,
0.20900003612041473,
0.03316473215818405,
0.18645140528678894,
-0.15621674060821533,
0.38278326392173767,
-0.3765096068382263,
0.5613754391670227,
0.17723311483860016,
-0.40333208441734314,
0.31214675307273865,
0.30383357405662537,
0.6230983734130859,
0.7569647431373596,
0.20660656690597534,
0.16213993728160858,
0.03799852356314659,
-0.5639820694923401,
0.18641754984855652,
-0.04119154065847397,
0.09818219393491745,
0.09719878435134888,
0.5459655523300171,
0.7788642644882202,
0.2740868330001831,
-0.6953691840171814,
0.7051838636398315,
0.13188660144805908,
-0.17557206749916077,
0.0178193561732769,
0.11502662301063538,
-0.16003015637397766,
0.033553969115018845,
0.18885691463947296,
0.26589810848236084,
0.07778942584991455,
-0.6870437860488892,
0.4024142026901245,
0.19961270689964294,
-0.2743711769580841,
-0.5428376197814941,
0.5280566215515137,
0.3178611993789673,
-0.2937367856502533,
0.5388630628585815,
-0.33930373191833496,
-0.6319591999053955,
0.544960618019104,
0.6993340849876404,
0.9744643568992615,
0.28473058342933655,
0.04425293207168579,
0.14066478610038757,
0.024123799055814743,
0.21912650763988495,
0.3989607095718384,
-0.6050788164138794,
-0.6612346172332764,
-0.7297268509864807,
-0.6439850330352783,
0.1186765730381012,
-0.15426313877105713,
-0.6232916712760925,
0.4224525988101959,
-0.4186701774597168,
-0.34888291358947754,
-0.3383822739124298,
-0.3016328513622284,
-0.8418290615081787,
0.07987340539693832,
0.33433061838150024,
0.8437129855155945,
-0.6747255325317383,
1.1446776390075684,
0.9762473702430725,
-0.5249847173690796,
-1.168766736984253,
0.5087497234344482,
-0.5211416482925415,
-0.3856315314769745,
0.8415677547454834,
0.37501105666160583,
-0.09973198920488358,
-0.10127869993448257,
-0.26781997084617615,
-0.840480387210846,
0.7827236652374268,
0.296456515789032,
-0.45373183488845825,
-0.30426761507987976,
0.3178269863128662,
0.34136995673179626,
-0.4314661920070648,
0.06358827650547028,
0.3777189254760742,
0.16304443776607513,
0.026712963357567787,
-1.147394061088562,
0.10610955208539963,
-0.1620294451713562,
0.23388104140758514,
0.3388611376285553,
-0.19907091557979584,
0.8248197436332703,
-0.10341279208660126,
-0.31995728611946106,
0.15784673392772675,
0.5641679167747498,
0.21607279777526855,
0.03954363241791725,
0.6115884184837341,
0.19599424302577972,
0.4282817542552948,
0.09561877697706223,
1.1087836027145386,
-0.44429147243499756,
0.20615963637828827,
1.021034836769104,
-0.2111683487892151,
0.7003003358840942,
0.5863383412361145,
-0.23662176728248596,
0.6825608611106873,
0.4860231280326843,
0.3323262333869934,
0.7581810355186462,
0.33944806456565857,
-0.09474751353263855,
-0.22986820340156555,
0.13122591376304626,
-0.6616182923316956,
0.3074497878551483,
0.06849054247140884,
-0.5477275848388672,
-0.00564873730763793,
0.142878919839859,
0.020197849720716476,
0.08505027741193771,
-0.07657839357852936,
0.6251799464225769,
0.09206943213939667,
-0.6754520535469055,
0.593816876411438,
0.09638544172048569,
0.9350441098213196,
-0.8227033019065857,
-0.008704479783773422,
-0.15328937768936157,
-0.037847477942705154,
-0.1017661914229393,
-0.3747881054878235,
0.42807403206825256,
0.06413161754608154,
-0.3240124583244324,
-0.49504587054252625,
0.6193082928657532,
-0.390190064907074,
-0.4305250644683838,
-0.0649944618344307,
0.42777585983276367,
-0.05355212092399597,
0.18768367171287537,
-0.6160582900047302,
-0.048918675631284714,
0.1838226020336151,
-0.1935718059539795,
0.3011794984340668,
0.4173224866390228,
0.00754602300003171,
0.13162454962730408,
0.8318966627120972,
0.036505669355392456,
0.3235766291618347,
0.07074088603258133,
0.9865886569023132,
-0.516768753528595,
-0.8176742196083069,
-0.7721307873725891,
0.5349907875061035,
0.14064966142177582,
-0.6574507355690002,
0.4926376938819885,
0.44071197509765625,
0.9890392422676086,
-0.25105124711990356,
0.6881073117256165,
-0.459259033203125,
0.01954028569161892,
-0.8239235281944275,
0.39815035462379456,
-0.5551208853721619,
0.3928280770778656,
-0.34609296917915344,
-1.0499640703201294,
-0.16245846450328827,
0.7965508699417114,
-0.20377591252326965,
0.15170127153396606,
0.8824964761734009,
0.7083756327629089,
-0.05860770121216774,
-0.22347690165042877,
0.2019520103931427,
-0.1635412871837616,
0.42618972063064575,
0.7219346165657043,
0.8489187359809875,
-0.22683507204055786,
0.3901708722114563,
0.021989930421113968,
-0.10923425853252411,
-0.09754732251167297,
-1.0879188776016235,
-0.6733701825141907,
-0.6491596698760986,
-0.32300055027008057,
-0.39774394035339355,
-0.1296422928571701,
1.103050947189331,
0.8550745248794556,
-0.6755837202072144,
-0.0912650004029274,
-0.38631436228752136,
-0.226645827293396,
0.05933021754026413,
-0.18156833946704865,
0.18943241238594055,
-0.7188304662704468,
-0.4232162535190582,
0.23792590200901031,
0.1271125227212906,
0.134004145860672,
-0.139858216047287,
-0.14450938999652863,
0.08810782432556152,
0.19297607243061066,
0.5368595719337463,
0.190040722489357,
-0.34687143564224243,
-0.550944983959198,
0.20515187084674835,
-0.35731080174446106,
0.1324554830789566,
1.462157130241394,
-0.9701414704322815,
0.3402279019355774,
0.644254744052887,
0.8214265704154968,
0.2467685043811798,
-0.05476047471165657,
0.8020247220993042,
-1.1569324731826782,
0.39709383249282837,
0.23438109457492828,
0.12638916075229645,
0.14897750318050385,
-0.20711418986320496,
0.28064030408859253,
0.32362061738967896,
-0.2935017943382263,
-0.8718758225440979,
0.44833317399024963,
-0.8068108558654785,
-0.44674399495124817,
1.208846092224121,
-0.12374577671289444,
0.217942476272583,
-0.10454189777374268,
-0.23625482618808746,
0.40060293674468994,
-0.054122570902109146,
0.5471751689910889,
0.5351868271827698,
-0.10234872251749039,
0.41417691111564636,
-0.29836201667785645,
0.553726315498352,
0.5894472002983093,
-0.9405028223991394,
-0.19757457077503204,
0.6673586368560791,
0.30504828691482544,
0.20706704258918762,
0.7980822324752808,
-0.221408411860466,
0.39438536763191223,
0.0674581304192543,
-0.08590696007013321,
-0.05340087041258812,
-0.22587506473064423,
-0.2563738524913788,
0.10220982134342194,
0.2500821053981781,
-0.3615499436855316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05779v1 | Examining Gender and Racial Bias in Large Vision-Language Models Using a Novel Dataset of Parallel Images | 2024-02-08T16:11:23 | 2024-02-08T16:11:23 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Svetlana Kiritchenko | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV | Following on recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and subsequent
chat models, a new wave of large vision-language models (LVLMs) has emerged.
Such models can incorporate images as input in addition to text, and perform
tasks such as visual question answering, image captioning, story generation,
etc. Here, we examine potential gender and racial biases in such systems, based
on the perceived characteristics of the people in the input images. To
accomplish this, we present a new dataset PAIRS (PArallel Images for eveRyday
Scenarios). The PAIRS dataset contains sets of AI-generated images of people,
such that the images are highly similar in terms of background and visual
content, but differ along the dimensions of gender (man, woman) and race
(Black, white). By querying the LVLMs with such images, we observe significant
differences in the responses according to the perceived gender or race of the
person depicted. | [
-0.5679526925086975,
-0.5094465613365173,
0.5091089010238647,
0.10501529276371002,
-0.12474668025970459,
0.1677667647600174,
-0.16867470741271973,
-0.6931769251823425,
0.27999138832092285,
0.5814145803451538,
-0.6596248745918274,
-0.40974757075309753,
-0.522078812122345,
0.13864490389823914,
-0.5069569945335388,
0.6558939218521118,
0.027996821328997612,
0.3754819929599762,
-0.4926084578037262,
-0.3123435974121094,
-0.668083667755127,
-0.3926193118095398,
-0.5437527298927307,
-0.01462646760046482,
0.471697598695755,
0.15845565497875214,
0.8210901021957397,
0.38034722208976746,
0.6772399544715881,
0.24645963311195374,
0.12409252673387527,
0.1299717128276825,
-0.5611133575439453,
0.15175820887088776,
-0.19513757526874542,
-0.5734657645225525,
0.03956758975982666,
-0.15304094552993774,
0.7269513607025146,
0.6442005038261414,
0.2596226930618286,
0.5573904514312744,
0.10381011664867401,
0.7572094202041626,
-0.6685898900032043,
0.3221229016780853,
-0.6004975438117981,
0.24826234579086304,
-0.35815441608428955,
0.06305830180644989,
-0.21170812845230103,
-0.17547890543937683,
0.10186371952295303,
-0.4037080705165863,
0.42625847458839417,
0.31240028142929077,
0.7093409895896912,
0.2075977921485901,
-0.491485595703125,
-0.00010735075193224475,
-0.82272869348526,
0.6951872706413269,
-0.393433153629303,
0.48422491550445557,
0.33167752623558044,
0.4671814441680908,
0.05258975550532341,
-0.27268803119659424,
-0.9101545810699463,
-0.29790520668029785,
-0.29769641160964966,
-0.05873973295092583,
-0.07978183776140213,
-0.19946777820587158,
0.44257667660713196,
0.08208632469177246,
-0.5117630362510681,
0.24996396899223328,
-0.48635512590408325,
-0.1262258142232895,
0.8158397078514099,
0.4178678095340729,
0.5287622213363647,
-0.10561802983283997,
-0.1345670074224472,
-0.1546938717365265,
-0.6555985808372498,
0.003870098851621151,
0.5335843563079834,
0.21614080667495728,
-0.43097901344299316,
0.797426164150238,
-0.2694816589355469,
0.7988166213035583,
-0.1747162938117981,
-0.11295465379953384,
0.43013569712638855,
-0.21954508125782013,
-0.13083304464817047,
-0.17189699411392212,
0.8590486645698547,
1.0110526084899902,
0.6243517994880676,
0.11033415794372559,
-0.04005631431937218,
0.2147299200296402,
-0.03158242255449295,
-0.6067360043525696,
-0.04385696351528168,
-0.07625990360975266,
-0.7093019485473633,
-0.37799474596977234,
-0.07623843848705292,
-1.1057403087615967,
-1.0310132503509521,
-0.3980656862258911,
0.04974795877933502,
0.07395144551992416,
-0.2781219780445099,
-0.2765343189239502,
-0.29766085743904114,
0.32586991786956787,
0.36977729201316833,
-0.8994032740592957,
0.21937252581119537,
0.40150028467178345,
0.6267002820968628,
-0.4824182093143463,
-0.36010435223579407,
-0.2540682554244995,
0.03236532583832741,
-0.24419306218624115,
0.556379497051239,
-0.7067947387695312,
-0.11466675251722336,
0.03226393088698387,
-0.11745351552963257,
0.12214316427707672,
-0.6271997690200806,
0.2865455746650696,
-0.5426833629608154,
0.13482913374900818,
-0.5045599341392517,
-0.13931570947170258,
0.16116414964199066,
0.2502407431602478,
-0.7548943758010864,
0.6961517333984375,
-0.22777467966079712,
-1.1250007152557373,
0.4131304621696472,
-0.5462902188301086,
-0.18175014853477478,
0.039203714579343796,
-0.7646492123603821,
-0.36452624201774597,
0.02498127520084381,
0.597556471824646,
0.39751482009887695,
-0.3830738961696625,
0.19859956204891205,
-0.5754579305648804,
-0.4318851828575134,
0.3134118616580963,
-0.32813477516174316,
0.8240115642547607,
0.11111925542354584,
-0.3518487513065338,
0.057822972536087036,
-0.5589157342910767,
-0.5049664974212646,
0.704735517501831,
0.09946856647729874,
-0.5128466486930847,
0.3164210319519043,
0.004566340707242489,
0.15875180065631866,
0.19428178668022156,
-0.8548282384872437,
-0.10635538399219513,
0.1827240139245987,
0.29782983660697937,
0.8452326655387878,
-0.4494328498840332,
0.459155797958374,
-0.11045002192258835,
0.41910025477409363,
0.23413923382759094,
0.30861276388168335,
-0.3596113622188568,
-0.626510500907898,
-0.8632345199584961,
-0.1288621872663498,
0.13860942423343658,
0.5081689357757568,
-0.9074513912200928,
-0.049797043204307556,
-0.29750776290893555,
-0.07208286970853806,
-0.3874329626560211,
-0.04182253032922745,
0.3272539973258972,
0.4273454546928406,
0.001587600912898779,
-0.30556488037109375,
-0.5079845786094666,
-1.3682595491409302,
-0.22161205112934113,
-0.19189928472042084,
-0.1346568912267685,
0.8508980870246887,
0.6315036416053772,
-0.12923605740070343,
0.9299983978271484,
-0.6594724655151367,
-0.12854251265525818,
0.005074627697467804,
-0.2161102443933487,
-0.15220917761325836,
0.3219143748283386,
0.7481311559677124,
-0.9678407311439514,
-0.3574845492839813,
-0.1478872299194336,
-0.9863111972808838,
-0.09324532747268677,
0.04341460019350052,
-0.1632378101348877,
0.21922658383846283,
0.7198280692100525,
-0.23513947427272797,
0.6071215271949768,
0.8365638256072998,
-0.3855215907096863,
0.6520385146141052,
0.17417027056217194,
0.1537366658449173,
-0.874991774559021,
-0.1361723691225052,
0.46081429719924927,
-0.2613944113254547,
-0.4056941568851471,
0.1754421889781952,
-0.041063327342271805,
-0.23306570947170258,
-0.45617568492889404,
0.6910602450370789,
-0.5259376168251038,
-0.7174320816993713,
-0.0322728157043457,
-0.1252378523349762,
-0.17268270254135132,
0.5059099197387695,
0.1745862513780594,
0.7140291333198547,
0.659233570098877,
-0.0727895051240921,
0.4645289480686188,
0.27140358090400696,
-0.680475652217865,
0.6214290261268616,
-0.6708952784538269,
0.328585147857666,
-0.7138445973396301,
0.4099980890750885,
-1.0484853982925415,
-0.347911536693573,
0.2562409043312073,
-0.30284956097602844,
0.011038449592888355,
-0.0886167362332344,
-0.6170253157615662,
-0.6417993307113647,
-0.15317535400390625,
0.8372251391410828,
0.4874173402786255,
-0.5050966143608093,
0.5601832866668701,
0.5163038969039917,
-0.2612720727920532,
-0.5756565928459167,
-0.8112286925315857,
0.18495221436023712,
-0.05565750598907471,
-0.6661400198936462,
0.03698044270277023,
0.15076109766960144,
-0.4595421850681305,
-0.00587717117741704,
0.3692947030067444,
-0.09179210662841797,
-0.243501216173172,
0.5088825225830078,
0.5795722007751465,
-0.0512220598757267,
0.031089307740330696,
-0.23368917405605316,
0.44900092482566833,
0.05952930822968483,
-0.033523887395858765,
0.7423282265663147,
-0.03523840755224228,
-0.6169782876968384,
-0.45601728558540344,
0.5269291400909424,
0.6495329737663269,
-0.455138623714447,
0.7964134812355042,
0.5093244910240173,
-0.22684653103351593,
0.03543640673160553,
-0.5798025131225586,
-0.2215050458908081,
-0.4206591844558716,
0.5042344331741333,
-0.16935034096240997,
-1.1921218633651733,
0.6522663235664368,
0.5797094106674194,
0.08183170855045319,
0.18293537199497223,
0.7898239493370056,
-0.42938899993896484,
1.0101277828216553,
0.5519247055053711,
-0.055496230721473694,
0.7267958521842957,
-0.0017901447135955095,
-0.0968238115310669,
-0.6720730662345886,
-0.37817925214767456,
-0.3610838055610657,
-0.7916768789291382,
-0.7338428497314453,
-0.5018429756164551,
0.38544633984565735,
-0.6336525082588196,
-0.48897311091423035,
-0.24088487029075623,
-0.2114620953798294,
0.7018659114837646,
0.881966233253479,
0.3215927481651306,
0.07808375358581543,
0.33369794487953186,
-0.140835702419281,
-0.2646044194698334,
-0.4094131290912628,
-0.2207392007112503,
1.3797178268432617,
0.36253395676612854,
0.7084649205207825,
-0.19914892315864563,
0.359744131565094,
0.4726273715496063,
0.20263969898223877,
-0.3976368308067322,
0.7081899046897888,
-0.4127686619758606,
-0.8394302129745483,
-0.1981070190668106,
-0.4929811358451843,
-0.8780943155288696,
0.30955770611763,
-0.5635486245155334,
-0.7316052913665771,
0.33432915806770325,
0.2718896269798279,
-0.04150652512907982,
0.500171959400177,
-0.697468101978302,
0.6508156061172485,
-0.34199798107147217,
-0.36207449436187744,
-0.02767474390566349,
-0.6843713521957397,
0.7848030924797058,
-0.09253230690956116,
0.183191180229187,
-0.25824883580207825,
0.17206117510795593,
0.6287369728088379,
-0.17517808079719543,
0.9757784605026245,
-0.151147723197937,
0.0015697467606514692,
0.015927350148558617,
-0.004074526950716972,
0.32168182730674744,
-0.26972296833992004,
0.11988018453121185,
0.6768443584442139,
-0.33672380447387695,
-0.4272724390029907,
-0.5789138078689575,
0.5183911919593811,
-0.9254247546195984,
-0.5691858530044556,
-0.19569511711597443,
-0.8785290122032166,
-0.15359841287136078,
0.05853846296668053,
0.06869678199291229,
0.5534352660179138,
-0.14903110265731812,
-0.013118426315486431,
0.2366168051958084,
-0.7305135726928711,
0.21686455607414246,
0.18246643245220184,
-0.5488097667694092,
-0.11975470185279846,
0.6647723317146301,
-0.09241077303886414,
0.30329665541648865,
0.2274540662765503,
0.046492401510477066,
-0.10689105093479156,
-0.4813326299190521,
-0.4489143192768097,
0.3334856927394867,
-0.38920435309410095,
0.18654941022396088,
-0.5116850137710571,
-0.22320254147052765,
-0.2577069103717804,
0.13245220482349396,
-0.24186870455741882,
-0.251272976398468,
-0.1266176700592041,
0.20407547056674957,
0.09906375408172607,
0.7184755802154541,
0.4743092656135559,
0.20894041657447815,
-0.5505244731903076,
0.6968775391578674,
0.7352277040481567,
0.3677848279476166,
0.0375293493270874,
-0.3405036926269531,
-0.0747421532869339,
0.18974703550338745,
-0.0595538504421711,
-0.8200567960739136,
0.34894925355911255,
-0.03704126924276352,
0.4223451316356659,
0.20022472739219666,
-0.1356155425310135,
0.40000206232070923,
-0.8001766800880432,
0.8150816559791565,
0.41266119480133057,
-0.5154653787612915,
0.4201847016811371,
-0.5126296877861023,
0.1803324669599533,
0.23823386430740356,
0.19533899426460266,
-0.6340778470039368,
-0.44363075494766235,
-0.13237470388412476,
-0.4218108355998993,
0.721617579460144,
0.49988123774528503,
0.19343560934066772,
0.28159233927726746,
0.3026709258556366,
0.024713052436709404,
0.31933754682540894,
-0.7706475853919983,
-0.6149804592132568,
-0.05963737145066261,
-0.35825422406196594,
0.01355269830673933,
-0.3340652287006378,
-0.19803908467292786,
-0.3458281457424164,
-0.02254684828221798,
-0.1917298436164856,
0.520338773727417,
-0.09148748964071274,
-0.12053418159484863,
0.057478874921798706,
-0.0009363455465063453,
0.5424398183822632,
0.5070574879646301,
-0.16832774877548218,
0.07622140645980835,
0.07164422422647476,
-0.4863801896572113,
0.07177216559648514,
-0.028493942692875862,
-0.5148253440856934,
-0.05473747104406357,
0.28249046206474304,
1.256773591041565,
-0.35061007738113403,
-0.8412657380104065,
0.5612872242927551,
-0.3834473490715027,
-0.35427695512771606,
-0.23212185502052307,
-0.08781522512435913,
0.061867669224739075,
0.5530868172645569,
0.375311940908432,
0.1863672286272049,
0.0582607127726078,
-0.7099612355232239,
-0.2539984881877899,
0.592293381690979,
-0.22349415719509125,
-0.2138117104768753,
0.6767851114273071,
0.44059041142463684,
-0.336428701877594,
0.6695387363433838,
-0.01217795629054308,
-0.5935306549072266,
0.8655377626419067,
0.31903931498527527,
0.7455330491065979,
0.2003200203180313,
0.2921256422996521,
0.28934231400489807,
0.521757185459137,
0.07919031381607056,
0.18055762350559235,
0.04104029759764671,
-1.248315453529358,
-0.242746502161026,
-0.6041296720504761,
-0.36620497703552246,
0.14333166182041168,
-0.49397987127304077,
0.3042643964290619,
-0.44796431064605713,
-0.1302599310874939,
0.127207413315773,
-0.5609391331672668,
-0.9192618727684021,
0.1688299924135208,
0.9294053316116333,
0.506690502166748,
-1.0178420543670654,
0.5935115218162537,
0.891741931438446,
-0.007693934720009565,
-0.4801255762577057,
0.1453697681427002,
0.058216534554958344,
-1.1190887689590454,
1.093691349029541,
0.2653302252292633,
0.18671077489852905,
-0.4056394100189209,
-0.6704871654510498,
-0.8711596131324768,
0.8182982206344604,
0.8091424703598022,
-0.9753391146659851,
-0.1340685933828354,
0.553916871547699,
0.46551841497421265,
-0.6076587438583374,
0.2782147526741028,
0.5954307913780212,
0.2588287591934204,
0.013403376564383507,
-1.0728380680084229,
-0.2034766674041748,
-0.29026755690574646,
0.37998199462890625,
0.05460069328546524,
-0.7857881784439087,
1.0000587701797485,
-0.34821248054504395,
-0.08133423328399658,
-0.2945954501628876,
0.5977088809013367,
0.5652647018432617,
0.46907666325569153,
0.9250580072402954,
0.44506025314331055,
0.5774397253990173,
-0.08000674098730087,
1.2074037790298462,
0.0965760126709938,
0.0522356852889061,
1.3439555168151855,
-0.41358453035354614,
0.6490136384963989,
0.3450312316417694,
-0.3247906565666199,
0.583217203617096,
0.38754546642303467,
-0.16090203821659088,
0.24395933747291565,
0.2249063104391098,
-0.06934815645217896,
-0.26071619987487793,
-0.30213499069213867,
-0.24107149243354797,
0.6174562573432922,
0.21854721009731293,
-0.6246788501739502,
0.026102334260940552,
0.1328165978193283,
-0.33507341146469116,
0.08162640035152435,
-0.44604942202568054,
0.5067704916000366,
-0.04645804688334465,
-0.4913608133792877,
0.25304946303367615,
-0.16029208898544312,
0.9822111129760742,
-0.10952634364366531,
0.04931395500898361,
-0.3616209030151367,
-0.0027079666033387184,
-0.17906147241592407,
-1.0263850688934326,
0.05710471048951149,
0.2957713007926941,
-0.32291537523269653,
0.0671861469745636,
0.7617428302764893,
-0.46281835436820984,
-0.9962934255599976,
0.17019125819206238,
0.3166823089122772,
0.15030312538146973,
-0.12623421847820282,
-0.7616870999336243,
0.2829936742782593,
0.18787990510463715,
0.17653979361057281,
0.2847690284252167,
-0.11303335428237915,
-0.476046621799469,
0.6293086409568787,
0.6099963188171387,
0.25048714876174927,
0.39762842655181885,
0.3738757073879242,
0.6934381127357483,
-0.6712396144866943,
-0.46661829948425293,
-0.909679114818573,
0.14257177710533142,
-0.3104451596736908,
-0.052208177745342255,
0.6738776564598083,
0.38704898953437805,
0.8089433908462524,
0.011071261018514633,
0.8558183908462524,
0.18626846373081207,
0.3809551000595093,
-0.3642463982105255,
0.57284015417099,
-0.76250821352005,
-0.0025295638479292393,
-0.4782462418079376,
-1.0063529014587402,
-0.14958101511001587,
0.2633056044578552,
-0.3224736452102661,
0.10624953359365463,
0.412375271320343,
0.8148407340049744,
-0.006082705222070217,
0.1593627780675888,
0.21227572858333588,
0.1414962261915207,
0.30924665927886963,
0.4599928557872772,
1.083709478378296,
-0.15258634090423584,
0.3701448142528534,
-0.13301552832126617,
-0.12497539073228836,
-0.1836985945701599,
-0.8149898648262024,
-1.0527983903884888,
-0.41804689168930054,
-0.20918044447898865,
0.001351466285996139,
0.06448187679052353,
0.6959054470062256,
0.6668028235435486,
-0.6866851449012756,
-0.30816105008125305,
0.2651093900203705,
0.03470970690250397,
0.2555517256259918,
-0.18296903371810913,
0.20192576944828033,
0.2452852874994278,
-0.9065566062927246,
-0.2812020182609558,
0.16811338067054749,
0.08398059755563736,
-0.7004024386405945,
-0.038816336542367935,
0.213449627161026,
-0.1698668897151947,
0.6309651732444763,
0.08815921097993851,
-0.641457200050354,
-0.21544870734214783,
-0.08569781482219696,
-0.07052665203809738,
0.06507664918899536,
0.8203148245811462,
-0.6817384362220764,
0.5354095101356506,
0.5282893776893616,
0.5967097282409668,
0.6188268065452576,
-0.18677067756652832,
0.7413455843925476,
-0.7339357137680054,
0.5589190125465393,
0.024817999452352524,
0.5652273893356323,
0.6636174321174622,
-0.17493171989917755,
0.22546768188476562,
0.48105114698410034,
-0.3539485037326813,
-0.8491424322128296,
0.2493770867586136,
-1.0123538970947266,
-0.27469855546951294,
1.301222801208496,
0.14384318888187408,
-0.29958009719848633,
0.07778511196374893,
-0.354851096868515,
-0.057280924171209335,
-0.450452595949173,
0.5607459545135498,
0.5600897073745728,
0.1846720576286316,
-0.4559941291809082,
-0.7076274752616882,
0.13474711775779724,
0.3823462426662445,
-0.7795198559761047,
-0.07835355401039124,
0.7632789015769958,
0.19886086881160736,
0.04018106311559677,
0.562349259853363,
-0.10621456056833267,
0.232181116938591,
-0.1297164261341095,
0.22717009484767914,
-0.09170197695493698,
-0.16836866736412048,
-0.2532312273979187,
0.1346997618675232,
-0.2395593822002411,
-0.3803302049636841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07939v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07939v5 | UFO: A UI-Focused Agent for Windows OS Interaction | 2024-02-08T15:40:35 | 2024-05-23T05:18:58 | Chaoyun Zhang, Liqun Li, Shilin He, Xu Zhang, Bo Qiao, Si Qin, Minghua Ma, Yu Kang, Qingwei Lin, Saravan Rajmohan, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce UFO, an innovative UI-Focused agent to fulfill user requests
tailored to applications on Windows OS, harnessing the capabilities of
GPT-Vision. UFO employs a dual-agent framework to meticulously observe and
analyze the graphical user interface (GUI) and control information of Windows
applications. This enables the agent to seamlessly navigate and operate within
individual applications and across them to fulfill user requests, even when
spanning multiple applications. The framework incorporates a control
interaction module, facilitating action grounding without human intervention
and enabling fully automated execution. Consequently, UFO transforms arduous
and time-consuming processes into simple tasks achievable solely through
natural language commands. We conducted testing of UFO across 9 popular Windows
applications, encompassing a variety of scenarios reflective of users' daily
usage. The results, derived from both quantitative metrics and real-case
studies, underscore the superior effectiveness of UFO in fulfilling user
requests. To the best of our knowledge, UFO stands as the first UI agent
specifically tailored for task completion within the Windows OS environment.
The open-source code for UFO is available on https://github.com/microsoft/UFO. | [
-0.4088023602962494,
-0.875117301940918,
0.7532788515090942,
0.12985055148601532,
0.2311093956232071,
0.2043105512857437,
0.23378166556358337,
-0.6147862672805786,
0.34954020380973816,
0.36365261673927307,
-0.7370591759681702,
-0.23182685673236847,
-0.006315537262707949,
0.09537044167518616,
-0.12358254939317703,
0.8293771743774414,
0.14569956064224243,
-0.6807070374488831,
-0.43709173798561096,
0.026093630120158195,
-0.43348440527915955,
-0.2250904142856598,
-0.4140084981918335,
-0.10106738656759262,
0.9091119170188904,
0.2931751608848572,
1.1736429929733276,
0.3541184961795807,
0.5157641768455505,
0.39092421531677246,
0.4936683773994446,
0.26534757018089294,
-0.39235439896583557,
0.1625339239835739,
-0.26771315932273865,
-0.2708573341369629,
-0.7323695421218872,
0.2046094536781311,
0.3590567111968994,
0.6339168548583984,
-0.034891340881586075,
-0.039482224732637405,
0.30242711305618286,
0.6272879242897034,
-0.7696323394775391,
-0.13917553424835205,
-0.29700174927711487,
0.2702014446258545,
-0.166458398103714,
-0.1904395967721939,
-0.3376617133617401,
-0.01759849488735199,
-0.05724097043275833,
-1.2730119228363037,
0.044676437973976135,
-0.06608162820339203,
0.6176294088363647,
0.372496098279953,
-0.5127875208854675,
0.26105034351348877,
-0.8131837844848633,
0.6865077614784241,
-0.13075576722621918,
0.36332565546035767,
0.15706762671470642,
0.365116685628891,
-0.5386815071105957,
-0.7273158431053162,
-0.4588991403579712,
-0.8697619438171387,
-0.14411039650440216,
0.06120024994015694,
-0.39378562569618225,
0.4025621712207794,
0.2792210578918457,
0.26546788215637207,
-0.7165853977203369,
-0.23121193051338196,
-0.13456261157989502,
-0.4361572563648224,
0.34059351682662964,
0.36770913004875183,
0.617443323135376,
0.38195252418518066,
-0.6969305872917175,
0.22157788276672363,
-0.4275445342063904,
0.46540212631225586,
0.10612356662750244,
0.24891705811023712,
-0.0532226599752903,
0.7580057382583618,
-0.5971441864967346,
0.9265608191490173,
0.012543418444693089,
0.10428638756275177,
0.20888997614383698,
-0.08560449630022049,
-0.5279909372329712,
-0.6041675806045532,
0.7267484664916992,
0.4211983382701874,
-0.33070236444473267,
-0.5819563269615173,
-0.30727580189704895,
0.16708029806613922,
0.5934116840362549,
-0.4408048987388611,
0.04220248758792877,
0.38218197226524353,
-0.2963697612285614,
-0.344448983669281,
0.4587101638317108,
-0.3109244406223297,
-0.5033783912658691,
-0.5900389552116394,
0.3882113993167877,
-0.14994299411773682,
-0.6775745749473572,
-0.3233400285243988,
-0.43349361419677734,
0.2127920538187027,
0.6995938420295715,
-0.16856922209262848,
0.14701683819293976,
0.7836689352989197,
0.6957702040672302,
-0.5665266513824463,
-0.6529793739318848,
-1.1474353075027466,
0.3056696057319641,
-0.4881076216697693,
0.813659131526947,
-0.5676664710044861,
-0.3983820378780365,
-0.3088725209236145,
0.021429724991321564,
0.030744483694434166,
-0.2478865534067154,
-0.24874603748321533,
-0.32315337657928467,
0.15434029698371887,
-0.2685864269733429,
-0.133159801363945,
-0.27261194586753845,
0.4654618501663208,
-0.5577399134635925,
1.1226392984390259,
0.5255682468414307,
-0.38318100571632385,
0.48332858085632324,
-1.109039545059204,
-0.3889513611793518,
0.7575181722640991,
-0.2594151496887207,
0.10265690088272095,
0.2945282459259033,
-0.5294523239135742,
0.38686174154281616,
0.025792988017201424,
-0.026000680401921272,
-0.380463570356369,
-0.5614893436431885,
-0.0023503981065005064,
-0.2788028120994568,
0.5483222603797913,
0.33968207240104675,
-0.6224592924118042,
0.4165692925453186,
-0.49478939175605774,
0.21769025921821594,
-0.19151142239570618,
-0.24479547142982483,
-0.40788477659225464,
-0.03953411057591438,
0.5630444288253784,
0.008685161359608173,
0.5722382664680481,
-0.8189418911933899,
0.6228329539299011,
0.03320899233222008,
-0.037768203765153885,
0.4975915551185608,
-0.33057376742362976,
0.40247249603271484,
-0.08403262495994568,
0.716976523399353,
-0.1916104108095169,
0.7183192372322083,
0.15222926437854767,
-0.579663097858429,
-0.28299078345298767,
-0.23014110326766968,
-0.4951508045196533,
0.6627010107040405,
-0.9812925457954407,
0.08216601610183716,
0.04258635640144348,
-0.3723004460334778,
-0.0533209852874279,
0.21371951699256897,
0.4629366993904114,
0.3556981682777405,
0.11665555089712143,
-0.21546423435211182,
-0.10611798614263535,
-0.8554321527481079,
-0.3401584029197693,
-0.32519233226776123,
-0.22535566985607147,
0.34217098355293274,
0.18211258947849274,
-0.7441567778587341,
1.6180813312530518,
-0.3048118054866791,
-0.5455439686775208,
-0.2333671897649765,
0.06666618585586548,
0.02046113647520542,
0.24893416464328766,
0.8007633090019226,
-1.2786357402801514,
-0.9207643270492554,
0.8178760409355164,
-1.120468258857727,
-0.1424659639596939,
-0.12124871462583542,
-0.2297554314136505,
0.3905235826969147,
0.4876706898212433,
-0.4944504201412201,
0.8761062622070312,
0.37323546409606934,
-0.6495211720466614,
0.7071791291236877,
-0.3059957027435303,
0.2839932441711426,
-0.6699988842010498,
0.2519029378890991,
-0.1414181888103485,
-0.44280365109443665,
-0.8306791186332703,
0.21648117899894714,
0.1313648819923401,
-0.20520398020744324,
-0.5261437296867371,
0.49127453565597534,
-0.5460996031761169,
-0.08211197704076767,
-0.7249079942703247,
-0.2749072015285492,
0.03653624281287193,
0.55629563331604,
-0.023198800161480904,
1.155261516571045,
0.7623754739761353,
-0.7100615501403809,
0.6846984028816223,
-0.1542305052280426,
0.17303210496902466,
0.834818959236145,
-0.5428498983383179,
0.42445650696754456,
0.02619219198822975,
-0.22692236304283142,
-0.8757961988449097,
-0.2129456102848053,
0.3837045729160309,
-0.31321048736572266,
-0.03225957229733467,
-0.10058141499757767,
0.0366063229739666,
-0.4305652976036072,
-0.3662818372249603,
-0.08782992511987686,
0.20729845762252808,
-0.3421996831893921,
1.1358147859573364,
0.3386732339859009,
0.1136246994137764,
-0.7702452540397644,
-0.5213389992713928,
0.6869524717330933,
-0.09392047673463821,
-0.42343729734420776,
0.06212441995739937,
-0.2202153205871582,
-0.38679251074790955,
0.2517085373401642,
-0.08016446232795715,
-0.02507888525724411,
0.21321439743041992,
0.7070903182029724,
0.3221031427383423,
-0.3481444716453552,
-0.5050009489059448,
-0.08997832983732224,
-0.22144843637943268,
-0.29187411069869995,
-0.31987422704696655,
-0.10753676295280457,
-0.4708237648010254,
-0.3693121373653412,
-0.8097697496414185,
0.6844805479049683,
1.0658475160598755,
-0.07161260396242142,
0.23893791437149048,
0.6735987067222595,
-0.19244398176670074,
-0.12557929754257202,
-0.7245670557022095,
0.06698967516422272,
-0.6307668089866638,
0.6130346655845642,
-0.9123326539993286,
-0.5612809658050537,
0.34552323818206787,
0.05487411469221115,
0.3151111900806427,
0.08316930383443832,
0.17905659973621368,
-0.26032933592796326,
0.984939694404602,
1.2299485206604004,
-0.36272022128105164,
0.6782987117767334,
-0.2099858671426773,
-0.25598910450935364,
-0.6274759769439697,
-0.211610808968544,
-0.06839747726917267,
-0.12940892577171326,
-0.12922969460487366,
-0.15321817994117737,
0.5960545539855957,
-0.26456528902053833,
0.026959259063005447,
0.4267427325248718,
-0.8598943948745728,
0.40827152132987976,
0.8030580282211304,
0.006102048326283693,
0.09092182666063309,
0.10745227336883545,
-0.012320611625909805,
0.16625064611434937,
-0.34003427624702454,
-0.49896880984306335,
0.5856460332870483,
0.2281704992055893,
0.7662038803100586,
-0.016711188480257988,
0.19453977048397064,
1.1148407459259033,
0.6737043857574463,
-0.7125548124313354,
0.7948882579803467,
0.14452746510505676,
-0.35052481293678284,
-0.6492674946784973,
-0.2856596112251282,
-0.9727584719657898,
0.4163249135017395,
0.23473598062992096,
-0.7649092674255371,
0.24555884301662445,
0.2552470564842224,
-0.3482826352119446,
0.37615999579429626,
-0.7431671023368835,
0.9977908730506897,
-0.23838840425014496,
-0.6691162586212158,
-0.2589539587497711,
-0.40026116371154785,
-0.12415716797113419,
0.3759295344352722,
-0.09928130358457565,
-0.3159523010253906,
-0.37543413043022156,
0.1666082888841629,
-0.6815170645713806,
0.8257707953453064,
-0.735747754573822,
-0.18390187621116638,
0.28095707297325134,
0.4528247117996216,
0.5371266007423401,
-0.20999059081077576,
0.08088262379169464,
0.09656612575054169,
-0.06234094873070717,
-0.1984957605600357,
-0.49546849727630615,
0.5856069326400757,
-0.5615847110748291,
-0.6384612917900085,
-0.5546209812164307,
-0.6288623809814453,
0.00963230524212122,
0.35380297899246216,
0.08812869340181351,
0.4813651144504547,
-0.6707939505577087,
-0.03625014051795006,
-0.012255566194653511,
-0.018280968070030212,
0.49849459528923035,
0.9785807132720947,
-0.4392489492893219,
-0.10033319890499115,
1.067021369934082,
-0.18085111677646637,
0.18677784502506256,
0.6066229343414307,
0.0023948773741722107,
-0.13882862031459808,
-0.4832219183444977,
-0.6473942399024963,
-0.206155464053154,
-0.09251195192337036,
-0.11655885726213455,
-0.5155726671218872,
0.05895238369703293,
-0.22624430060386658,
-0.3712453246116638,
-0.4258515238761902,
0.08768898993730545,
-0.13358628749847412,
0.08915699273347855,
0.24610748887062073,
1.1015417575836182,
-0.13721883296966553,
0.27699175477027893,
-0.3866996765136719,
0.8470202088356018,
0.6653666496276855,
0.4143960177898407,
-0.48360109329223633,
0.18887457251548767,
-0.2762991189956665,
0.21047194302082062,
-0.49521878361701965,
-0.7181232571601868,
0.2857801914215088,
0.2773057222366333,
0.7314628958702087,
0.9000440239906311,
0.14014476537704468,
0.5692506432533264,
-0.4129381477832794,
0.9613487720489502,
0.38936007022857666,
-0.7427425980567932,
0.7012218832969666,
-0.44261136651039124,
0.11920630931854248,
0.5948320627212524,
-0.13615953922271729,
-0.6284169554710388,
-0.9003937840461731,
-0.005273585207760334,
-0.45120471715927124,
1.0301220417022705,
0.2388375848531723,
-0.0011553275398910046,
0.30934080481529236,
0.28544875979423523,
0.37818047404289246,
0.17397527396678925,
-0.5037901997566223,
-0.3756069839000702,
-0.18896621465682983,
0.23413673043251038,
-0.07446756958961487,
-0.08097822219133377,
-0.041779983788728714,
-0.046027787029743195,
0.45986634492874146,
-0.3892507255077362,
0.2766615152359009,
0.4311266541481018,
-0.21830680966377258,
-0.26979491114616394,
0.05342821776866913,
0.3963887691497803,
0.855421781539917,
-0.34020623564720154,
0.049112122505903244,
-0.27539193630218506,
-1.1754554510116577,
0.08019141107797623,
0.15775588154792786,
-0.4415469765663147,
-0.054156702011823654,
-0.2079695761203766,
0.48733383417129517,
-0.3202284276485443,
-0.36460012197494507,
0.5080159306526184,
-0.2206001728773117,
-0.11699420213699341,
-0.41653284430503845,
0.45768845081329346,
-0.5082072615623474,
0.2554810345172882,
1.0541212558746338,
0.3298295736312866,
0.572873055934906,
-0.5227175951004028,
0.08508333563804626,
0.7019842267036438,
-0.7319039702415466,
-0.424137681722641,
1.1338807344436646,
0.47833818197250366,
-0.47429895401000977,
0.5299618244171143,
-0.27463144063949585,
-0.30708152055740356,
0.8698808550834656,
0.18566562235355377,
1.202087640762329,
-0.2053832709789276,
0.6126126646995544,
-0.30685529112815857,
0.4869886338710785,
0.1763075441122055,
0.38166964054107666,
-0.5626851916313171,
-0.49931612610816956,
-0.28638529777526855,
-0.3133564293384552,
-0.8298208117485046,
-0.014359582215547562,
-0.6415846347808838,
-0.179460346698761,
-0.17332231998443604,
-0.42145028710365295,
-0.04060034453868866,
0.14314395189285278,
-0.5873827934265137,
0.005941477138549089,
0.1739959567785263,
0.9561750888824463,
-0.44483956694602966,
0.799615204334259,
1.2041319608688354,
-0.2207028716802597,
-0.3354276418685913,
-0.0022726573515683413,
0.11834381520748138,
-0.47702327370643616,
0.23167581856250763,
0.5371248722076416,
-0.6558789610862732,
-0.144952192902565,
-0.5000213980674744,
-0.5460407137870789,
0.9920977354049683,
0.4130094647407532,
-0.4068361818790436,
0.17083299160003662,
0.5081592798233032,
0.3830030560493469,
-0.1567152589559555,
0.2880844175815582,
0.2761574685573578,
0.8025603890419006,
-0.2765932083129883,
-1.1244161128997803,
0.04664308577775955,
-0.75519859790802,
0.059789564460515976,
-0.07528446614742279,
-0.4619505703449249,
0.3726694583892822,
-0.40398848056793213,
-0.19051936268806458,
0.3365820646286011,
0.8152799010276794,
-0.011315546929836273,
0.9676042795181274,
0.8300305604934692,
0.10009881854057312,
0.638322114944458,
-0.1101633682847023,
1.188619613647461,
-0.08996814489364624,
-0.03956504166126251,
0.6593497395515442,
-0.442472904920578,
0.49107691645622253,
0.5028764605522156,
-0.487377792596817,
0.44278720021247864,
0.3809221684932709,
0.16492681205272675,
0.5075758099555969,
-0.4160745441913605,
-0.4224712550640106,
-0.07456034421920776,
-0.07524346560239792,
-0.3966728448867798,
0.12950068712234497,
0.28445255756378174,
0.5117918848991394,
0.08946545422077179,
0.7286596894264221,
-0.28771135210990906,
0.002882562344893813,
-0.5188061594963074,
0.8357524275779724,
-0.20942801237106323,
-0.7607293725013733,
0.28922876715660095,
-0.15263639390468597,
0.9099173545837402,
-0.9516893625259399,
-0.0872112438082695,
-0.330008864402771,
0.1613549143075943,
-0.40041840076446533,
-0.7233587503433228,
0.19328615069389343,
-0.06646321713924408,
-0.31050801277160645,
-0.30110985040664673,
0.6267831921577454,
-0.2090037316083908,
-0.16666163504123688,
0.2737657427787781,
0.25077489018440247,
0.3356156647205353,
-0.9189046621322632,
-0.5822438597679138,
0.05323058366775513,
0.13398030400276184,
-0.5407601594924927,
0.32836300134658813,
0.3773523271083832,
0.0664738118648529,
0.8746309876441956,
0.6751019954681396,
-0.11206717044115067,
-0.09568008035421371,
-0.19746443629264832,
0.9560362696647644,
-0.7173925042152405,
-0.8196470141410828,
-0.49864208698272705,
0.675463855266571,
-0.1013902798295021,
-0.12018617242574692,
0.9322089552879333,
1.023134469985962,
0.29784059524536133,
-0.3012952208518982,
1.0190848112106323,
-0.4000600576400757,
0.3145146667957306,
0.05871429666876793,
0.7649934887886047,
-0.9021730422973633,
-0.11293480545282364,
-0.1279754340648651,
-0.915604829788208,
0.11846993863582611,
0.28293195366859436,
0.062355272471904755,
-0.057744260877370834,
0.44309496879577637,
0.8760200142860413,
-0.34912848472595215,
-0.21850045025348663,
0.7837662696838379,
0.020244693383574486,
0.23858758807182312,
0.5887042880058289,
1.1371430158615112,
-0.02667374350130558,
0.5872730612754822,
-0.09130068868398666,
-0.6948010325431824,
-0.26756641268730164,
-0.6432815790176392,
-0.7457876801490784,
-0.5768513679504395,
-0.39877191185951233,
-0.16406646370887756,
0.09956684708595276,
0.5506601929664612,
0.9061505794525146,
-0.6571597456932068,
-0.23567870259284973,
-0.24057158827781677,
0.20760291814804077,
-0.7806512713432312,
-0.3605225086212158,
0.040044914931058884,
-0.3395828306674957,
-0.7802059650421143,
0.8788424730300903,
0.6725215911865234,
-0.011698560789227486,
-0.23718896508216858,
-0.36093831062316895,
0.5404040813446045,
-0.27617669105529785,
0.5655384063720703,
0.9262750744819641,
-0.6768641471862793,
-0.05508074536919594,
0.06807910650968552,
-0.45119336247444153,
-0.15133310854434967,
0.861463725566864,
-1.0857288837432861,
0.4059933125972748,
0.05733531340956688,
0.20955874025821686,
0.21338452398777008,
0.0529785081744194,
0.7647123336791992,
-0.7718210816383362,
0.3739088773727417,
-0.00938587635755539,
-0.08474616706371307,
-0.037318889051675797,
-1.0278795957565308,
0.46014848351478577,
0.2335319072008133,
-0.22032013535499573,
-0.855751633644104,
0.024127895012497902,
-1.3608567714691162,
-0.4381813406944275,
1.0386853218078613,
-0.014067755080759525,
-0.16088871657848358,
-0.6641795635223389,
-0.5358383059501648,
-0.4438204765319824,
-0.5872852802276611,
0.5174490809440613,
-0.09858270734548569,
-0.30950063467025757,
0.29538705945014954,
-0.6307345628738403,
0.5612002611160278,
0.0053398278541862965,
-0.770424485206604,
0.1537782847881317,
0.726898193359375,
0.276316374540329,
0.24244634807109833,
0.947234570980072,
0.27218887209892273,
0.6394429206848145,
-0.016668016090989113,
0.22576498985290527,
-0.809717059135437,
-0.5499590039253235,
0.09114871174097061,
0.4407387673854828,
-0.31977081298828125,
-0.6871258616447449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05755v1 | SpiRit-LM: Interleaved Spoken and Written Language Model | 2024-02-08T15:39:32 | 2024-02-08T15:39:32 | Tu Anh Nguyen, Benjamin Muller, Bokai Yu, Marta R. Costa-jussa, Maha Elbayad, Sravya Popuri, Paul-Ambroise Duquenne, Robin Algayres, Ruslan Mavlyutov, Itai Gat, Gabriel Synnaeve, Juan Pino, Benoit Sagot, Emmanuel Dupoux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce SPIRIT-LM, a foundation multimodal language model that freely
mixes text and speech. Our model is based on a pretrained text language model
that we extend to the speech modality by continuously training it on text and
speech units. Speech and text sequences are concatenated as a single set of
tokens, and trained with a word-level interleaving method using a small
automatically-curated speech-text parallel corpus. SPIRIT-LM comes in two
versions: a BASE version that uses speech semantic units and an EXPRESSIVE
version that models expressivity using pitch and style units in addition to the
semantic units. For both versions, the text is encoded with subword BPE tokens.
The resulting model displays both the semantic abilities of text models and the
expressive abilities of speech models. Additionally, we demonstrate that
SPIRIT-LM is able to learn new tasks in a few-shot fashion across modalities
(i.e. ASR, TTS, Speech Classification). | [
-0.17895139753818512,
-0.692583441734314,
0.3680568337440491,
0.30726301670074463,
-0.5048531889915466,
0.1960437148809433,
-0.41706588864326477,
-0.5864647626876831,
0.43578001856803894,
0.6292307376861572,
-0.5731929540634155,
-0.29217010736465454,
-0.5461330413818359,
-0.047985877841711044,
-0.49950456619262695,
1.1374696493148804,
0.11851173639297485,
0.7250712513923645,
-0.03848131746053696,
-0.1762584149837494,
-0.48093459010124207,
-0.697951078414917,
-0.3539712429046631,
-0.6104524731636047,
0.418521523475647,
0.104320228099823,
0.4697568714618683,
0.23101025819778442,
0.28304779529571533,
0.2741732597351074,
-0.08521049469709396,
-0.1059265285730362,
-0.3398372530937195,
0.29915422201156616,
-0.1819799393415451,
-0.6418130993843079,
-0.5283955335617065,
0.3016188144683838,
0.7844820618629456,
0.7932763695716858,
-0.04957403242588043,
-0.08515878766775131,
0.055636078119277954,
0.5566142797470093,
-0.37423211336135864,
0.3226916790008545,
-0.9689352512359619,
-0.0960523784160614,
-0.0985729992389679,
-0.19800812005996704,
-0.3296058773994446,
-0.18940868973731995,
0.21929951012134552,
-0.23938383162021637,
-0.07388512790203094,
-0.1443605124950409,
0.48645004630088806,
0.35458457469940186,
-0.5204200148582458,
-0.6415119171142578,
-0.6819417476654053,
0.6863673329353333,
-0.6421173810958862,
0.676985502243042,
0.19818015396595,
0.18010471761226654,
0.08480383455753326,
-0.8886894583702087,
-1.0472041368484497,
-0.3450479209423065,
0.054011065512895584,
0.18287977576255798,
0.16229425370693207,
0.6373611688613892,
-0.11835189163684845,
0.37665852904319763,
-0.3513709604740143,
-0.33252739906311035,
-0.24003057181835175,
-0.0032035112380981445,
0.5193583965301514,
0.0708966925740242,
0.4389970004558563,
-0.1543557196855545,
-0.5275934338569641,
-0.03859466314315796,
-0.35029640793800354,
0.020296433940529823,
0.33191564679145813,
0.6961988806724548,
-0.011928115040063858,
0.7926534414291382,
0.05085618421435356,
0.7060836553573608,
-0.09822675585746765,
-0.6801760196685791,
0.11738215386867523,
-0.3433209955692291,
-0.5019051432609558,
0.345577597618103,
0.6169079542160034,
0.15124398469924927,
0.28570374846458435,
-0.3738867938518524,
-0.35331833362579346,
0.2563225328922272,
0.07899313420057297,
-0.9047263860702515,
0.10395505279302597,
0.14829473197460175,
-0.5652288198471069,
-0.1477898359298706,
0.05952849239110947,
-0.31879568099975586,
-0.387628972530365,
-0.45938795804977417,
0.7467963099479675,
-0.6793782711029053,
-0.6539519429206848,
0.21367618441581726,
-0.01888817548751831,
0.14454230666160583,
0.4378109872341156,
-0.8409909605979919,
0.48216184973716736,
0.735187828540802,
0.7547314763069153,
-0.1617833822965622,
-0.30652734637260437,
-0.6621220707893372,
-0.10701295733451843,
-0.1384701281785965,
0.272768497467041,
-0.614646852016449,
-0.4583398699760437,
-0.010997703298926353,
0.09954002499580383,
-0.18111827969551086,
-0.454496294260025,
0.604465663433075,
-0.4572157859802246,
0.4522993564605713,
-0.06157273054122925,
-0.9322964549064636,
-0.6301551461219788,
-0.059766434133052826,
-0.6044517755508423,
1.0157493352890015,
0.17149174213409424,
-0.5647193193435669,
0.4002022445201874,
-0.38609081506729126,
-0.24674676358699799,
0.19842231273651123,
-0.17996621131896973,
0.014644095674157143,
0.5086588859558105,
-0.4259996712207794,
0.7068325281143188,
-0.29650819301605225,
0.5827646851539612,
0.06823600083589554,
-0.22526617348194122,
0.04812246561050415,
-0.5107744336128235,
0.6318438649177551,
0.28486740589141846,
-0.24745787680149078,
0.45376527309417725,
-0.8965855240821838,
0.14462602138519287,
-0.008054397068917751,
-0.42800676822662354,
-0.38275694847106934,
0.090727299451828,
0.614847719669342,
0.4737323522567749,
0.2337297797203064,
-0.4357835352420807,
0.133117213845253,
-0.48939913511276245,
0.2523682415485382,
0.3596108555793762,
-0.43439045548439026,
0.5556139945983887,
-0.30648425221443176,
0.543898344039917,
0.21161118149757385,
-0.26870328187942505,
-0.6660465598106384,
-0.4459204077720642,
-0.8388805389404297,
-0.500345766544342,
0.049797173589468,
0.7978396415710449,
-0.6374760866165161,
0.37482625246047974,
-0.1571217179298401,
-0.4817144274711609,
-0.6537964344024658,
0.14778219163417816,
0.5573673248291016,
0.5828141570091248,
0.4186670184135437,
-0.32320570945739746,
-0.3464023470878601,
-0.6101635694503784,
-0.5577675700187683,
-0.40808942914009094,
0.32382285594940186,
-0.06010478734970093,
0.34701159596443176,
-0.21455198526382446,
1.2143006324768066,
0.08561109006404877,
-0.2630771994590759,
-0.6270166039466858,
0.10163230448961258,
0.12078306823968887,
0.49999579787254333,
0.6130263805389404,
-0.8901439309120178,
-0.48381417989730835,
-0.2782732844352722,
-0.684415340423584,
-0.3249339461326599,
0.016227584332227707,
0.4146728515625,
0.15798576176166534,
0.5454770922660828,
-0.47167593240737915,
0.45504823327064514,
0.8230093121528625,
-0.48915809392929077,
0.3089491128921509,
0.019580701366066933,
0.12455318123102188,
-1.334469199180603,
-0.20512105524539948,
-0.22664980590343475,
-0.5172532200813293,
-1.0614018440246582,
0.15222537517547607,
0.1450917273759842,
-0.24020269513130188,
-0.7816187739372253,
0.8325579166412354,
-0.5169755220413208,
-0.04033518210053444,
-0.6511054635047913,
0.07923176139593124,
-0.05335082486271858,
0.43837544322013855,
0.2998987138271332,
0.5707743763923645,
0.633106529712677,
-0.516025185585022,
0.48956283926963806,
-0.32742467522621155,
-0.3098815381526947,
0.6260970830917358,
-0.591090202331543,
0.12122635543346405,
-0.6272075772285461,
0.16492639482021332,
-1.1688114404678345,
-0.17614604532718658,
0.15251962840557098,
-0.1188991442322731,
0.5298254489898682,
0.1272566020488739,
-0.4506296217441559,
0.12778478860855103,
-0.02284361980855465,
0.43070048093795776,
0.2516838610172272,
-0.39583921432495117,
1.1341816186904907,
0.18727843463420868,
-0.1118747889995575,
-0.5242966413497925,
-0.6639115810394287,
0.09402626007795334,
-0.12451080232858658,
-0.84317946434021,
0.4214349091053009,
-0.4135790765285492,
-0.5205527544021606,
0.14455680549144745,
0.03816905990242958,
-0.10178466141223907,
0.08392076194286346,
0.4648784399032593,
0.05466821789741516,
-0.1527259647846222,
0.35206225514411926,
0.031090576201677322,
0.14806225895881653,
-0.2835998833179474,
-0.1989387422800064,
0.7873066663742065,
-0.4744893014431,
-0.4117596447467804,
-0.5504809617996216,
0.5661986470222473,
0.5818209648132324,
-0.19497820734977722,
0.9531125426292419,
0.5483564138412476,
-0.6589460968971252,
0.08982495963573456,
-0.5273787379264832,
-0.14629726111888885,
-0.37192055583000183,
0.48150375485420227,
-0.7038838267326355,
-1.006416916847229,
0.4837939739227295,
-0.15962229669094086,
0.05836627259850502,
0.09499587118625641,
0.5246074795722961,
0.057361453771591187,
0.7715361714363098,
0.8591702580451965,
0.07975386083126068,
0.6236339211463928,
0.16031666100025177,
0.0383492186665535,
-0.4671141803264618,
-0.39791756868362427,
-0.26154106855392456,
-0.17798641324043274,
-0.2541351318359375,
-0.5214530229568481,
0.2715759873390198,
0.7815505266189575,
0.12019328773021698,
0.1225600391626358,
-0.2828094959259033,
0.34595128893852234,
0.3853091597557068,
-0.14710429310798645,
0.5217849612236023,
-0.25382116436958313,
-0.24515536427497864,
-0.12084759771823883,
-0.48833706974983215,
-0.6135591268539429,
0.8339483141899109,
0.5165283679962158,
0.8653945326805115,
0.12598639726638794,
0.6955292224884033,
-0.0398179367184639,
0.3694378435611725,
-1.2584623098373413,
0.5689777135848999,
-0.23108431696891785,
-0.7517522573471069,
-0.016166944056749344,
-0.10335257649421692,
-0.42113301157951355,
0.61077880859375,
-0.46267515420913696,
-0.476215124130249,
-0.22286877036094666,
0.07394992560148239,
0.07427511364221573,
0.3973480761051178,
-0.7553004622459412,
0.5267665386199951,
-0.4609186053276062,
-0.09437038749456406,
-0.3085004389286041,
-0.7585537433624268,
0.5491895079612732,
-0.13831059634685516,
0.20264826714992523,
-0.15638136863708496,
-0.09355611354112625,
0.4857707619667053,
-0.559477686882019,
0.7935407161712646,
-0.15504278242588043,
-0.3963063657283783,
0.24711185693740845,
0.07472983747720718,
0.3417908549308777,
-0.05363974720239639,
-0.06942566484212875,
0.1554001420736313,
-0.020590070635080338,
-0.1684311032295227,
-0.4336977005004883,
0.4154071509838104,
-0.6180729866027832,
-0.5008885264396667,
-0.6197408437728882,
-0.425325870513916,
-0.23602789640426636,
0.34040001034736633,
0.22727251052856445,
0.4649897813796997,
-0.38836923241615295,
0.19156719744205475,
0.7373533844947815,
-0.24054986238479614,
0.6618157625198364,
0.5499356389045715,
-0.7128528952598572,
-0.5458282828330994,
0.46623578667640686,
0.03587966784834862,
0.6164944171905518,
0.42504218220710754,
0.1537049561738968,
-0.35432106256484985,
-0.17040616273880005,
-0.24708494544029236,
0.31901291012763977,
-0.8591381907463074,
0.14282475411891937,
-0.9124321937561035,
-0.2772301137447357,
-0.3532496690750122,
0.004096647258847952,
-0.4606545865535736,
-0.4090544879436493,
-0.41274911165237427,
-0.06027979403734207,
0.3368361294269562,
0.6994351744651794,
0.13130046427249908,
0.6758208870887756,
-0.7047403454780579,
0.4785037636756897,
0.43270212411880493,
0.24855861067771912,
-0.234924778342247,
-0.3764118254184723,
-0.11883378773927689,
0.07190965861082077,
0.049841031432151794,
-1.1848701238632202,
0.4339860677719116,
0.47288569808006287,
0.46413809061050415,
0.2394380271434784,
-0.4802614152431488,
0.6178116202354431,
-0.767424464225769,
1.0311529636383057,
0.6564270257949829,
-1.3625460863113403,
0.4183013141155243,
-0.10269671678543091,
0.1190599575638771,
0.4541560411453247,
0.2472948431968689,
-0.890714704990387,
-0.34999921917915344,
-0.31291672587394714,
-0.6009587049484253,
0.7026689648628235,
-0.20117497444152832,
0.2517760097980499,
-0.018790122121572495,
0.401923805475235,
0.27016153931617737,
0.5857433080673218,
-0.9995092153549194,
-0.40933510661125183,
-0.7286626696586609,
-0.5320758819580078,
-0.18853791058063507,
-0.29314032196998596,
-0.11227386444807053,
-0.4102689325809479,
0.6458708643913269,
-0.4058355987071991,
0.1418079286813736,
0.14635424315929413,
-0.3282913863658905,
-0.07357576489448547,
0.30268073081970215,
0.8698825240135193,
0.4069232642650604,
-0.16308505833148956,
0.41221195459365845,
-0.08881574869155884,
-0.7394651770591736,
0.19037233293056488,
0.03528999164700508,
0.07114628702402115,
0.27308088541030884,
0.43344858288764954,
1.2346502542495728,
0.03454858437180519,
-0.8372104167938232,
0.644294261932373,
-0.17154961824417114,
-0.22206656634807587,
-0.37939366698265076,
0.12190879136323929,
0.20614604651927948,
0.4459695518016815,
0.5058386921882629,
0.037115514278411865,
-0.16453817486763,
-0.9345188140869141,
0.05238087847828865,
0.6285156607627869,
-0.7351548075675964,
-0.5349594950675964,
1.0335795879364014,
0.13567441701889038,
-0.2846646308898926,
0.03782695531845093,
-0.06742499768733978,
-0.6533702611923218,
0.17173504829406738,
0.7043539881706238,
1.1849201917648315,
-0.23449648916721344,
0.0000650297588435933,
-0.08534274995326996,
0.44196900725364685,
-0.13576620817184448,
0.7586893439292908,
0.03350570425391197,
-0.9111431837081909,
-0.35615500807762146,
-0.8281269073486328,
-0.17513352632522583,
0.3029187321662903,
-0.3282224237918854,
0.3971483111381531,
-0.3999061584472656,
-0.09895335882902145,
-0.3555827736854553,
0.037244927138090134,
-0.7133392691612244,
0.5167813897132874,
0.20727014541625977,
0.9908539056777954,
-0.8585687279701233,
1.2826075553894043,
0.7315056324005127,
-0.4483816921710968,
-0.9007308483123779,
0.08297554403543472,
0.04833594337105751,
-0.6900445818901062,
1.0356450080871582,
0.1849958449602127,
-0.48506367206573486,
0.14176446199417114,
-0.4626776874065399,
-0.754189670085907,
1.079925537109375,
0.4919646382331848,
-0.551757276058197,
-0.10630930215120316,
0.043422140181064606,
0.4235716760158539,
-0.5976915955543518,
0.32952725887298584,
0.16149242222309113,
0.2382175326347351,
0.022105801850557327,
-1.2834559679031372,
-0.1751626431941986,
-0.13498921692371368,
0.13210426270961761,
-0.013114864937961102,
-0.8494546413421631,
1.2051793336868286,
0.1533726304769516,
-0.3827098608016968,
0.17746855318546295,
1.0304638147354126,
0.13816453516483307,
0.19349640607833862,
0.7935245633125305,
0.574273943901062,
0.8743708729743958,
-0.16978788375854492,
0.6209926009178162,
-0.6237457990646362,
0.13304926455020905,
1.049879550933838,
-0.5650957226753235,
0.6279828548431396,
0.5630446076393127,
0.19832028448581696,
0.45329928398132324,
0.2917659878730774,
0.7485277652740479,
0.5671114325523376,
0.05913551151752472,
-0.8094082474708557,
-0.08481724560260773,
-0.24098488688468933,
-0.44134435057640076,
0.7263728380203247,
0.44331878423690796,
-0.4883095622062683,
-0.030949784442782402,
0.43821436166763306,
0.12663237750530243,
0.17583291232585907,
-0.3468468487262726,
0.7951772809028625,
0.18284323811531067,
-0.5737155675888062,
0.5240469574928284,
0.2289343774318695,
1.1402945518493652,
-0.902286171913147,
0.13113966584205627,
0.07502135634422302,
-0.01949433796107769,
-0.21509794890880585,
-0.5409490466117859,
0.1969044953584671,
-0.09296241402626038,
-0.20717895030975342,
-0.42219746112823486,
1.0197008848190308,
-1.0167752504348755,
-0.26589828729629517,
0.4977555274963379,
0.6463823914527893,
0.17894098162651062,
-0.01513745542615652,
-0.5478188991546631,
0.16708968579769135,
-0.37860822677612305,
-0.2774651348590851,
0.14291982352733612,
0.5511547327041626,
0.02930908277630806,
0.606748104095459,
0.4433501660823822,
0.22805219888687134,
0.39416277408599854,
0.3275929391384125,
0.7181376814842224,
-0.7605186104774475,
-0.5444424748420715,
-0.7717026472091675,
0.48801541328430176,
0.3539235293865204,
-0.2596605718135834,
0.48578065633773804,
0.5435287952423096,
0.7126896977424622,
-0.18418768048286438,
0.8794132471084595,
-0.027679823338985443,
0.5579469203948975,
-0.7258388996124268,
0.5365145802497864,
-0.81170254945755,
-0.10346076637506485,
-0.4559323489665985,
-1.0488355159759521,
-0.03238500654697418,
0.5561226010322571,
0.4649335741996765,
0.11275067180395126,
0.6745702028274536,
0.5345399975776672,
0.00015796652587596327,
0.17317058145999908,
0.3986085057258606,
-0.08448193967342377,
0.223619744181633,
0.2750168442726135,
0.8156699538230896,
-0.30677661299705505,
0.05613337829709053,
-0.09042089432477951,
-0.3253870904445648,
-0.13501782715320587,
-1.1118454933166504,
-0.9981697201728821,
-0.8921921849250793,
0.008335853926837444,
-0.4001900553703308,
-0.21220462024211884,
1.4617606401443481,
0.8427494168281555,
-0.4988623857498169,
-0.45572900772094727,
-0.10306950658559799,
-0.20660483837127686,
-0.136276975274086,
-0.29441866278648376,
-0.1289500594139099,
-0.3811408579349518,
-1.0311322212219238,
0.775297999382019,
0.4578862190246582,
0.298080176115036,
-0.6566093564033508,
-0.2648348808288574,
-0.20933422446250916,
0.37218576669692993,
0.8400661945343018,
-0.06948448717594147,
-1.002043604850769,
-0.24965490400791168,
0.09165897965431213,
-0.2077919989824295,
-0.1114627942442894,
0.9542319178581238,
-0.9221255779266357,
0.730994701385498,
0.658885657787323,
0.6180856823921204,
0.49009692668914795,
-0.2293819785118103,
0.4466090500354767,
-0.9759235978126526,
0.5997692346572876,
0.3131853938102722,
0.4503142237663269,
0.32668042182922363,
-0.06674550473690033,
0.34960201382637024,
0.5523449182510376,
-0.19435109198093414,
-0.7624083757400513,
0.4690644145011902,
-1.182698369026184,
-0.49892017245292664,
1.1140921115875244,
0.12039294838905334,
0.032582033425569534,
0.07232042402029037,
-0.23748745024204254,
0.5897051095962524,
-0.13703379034996033,
0.2082802653312683,
1.018661618232727,
-0.08426979184150696,
-0.2914460599422455,
-0.5121890902519226,
0.6895405650138855,
0.4682973325252533,
-0.655714213848114,
-0.2643517851829529,
0.49009832739830017,
0.39237165451049805,
0.13321617245674133,
1.0489407777786255,
-0.008415515534579754,
-0.1353810876607895,
-0.2407238930463791,
0.24995292723178864,
0.18100383877754211,
-0.5766724348068237,
-0.5955085158348083,
0.22285103797912598,
-0.12485641241073608,
0.05007081478834152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05733v1 | TimeArena: Shaping Efficient Multitasking Language Agents in a Time-Aware Simulation | 2024-02-08T15:08:57 | 2024-02-08T15:08:57 | Yikai Zhang, Siyu Yuan, Caiyu Hu, Kyle Richardson, Yanghua Xiao, Jiangjie Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite remarkable advancements in emulating human-like behavior through
Large Language Models (LLMs), current textual simulations do not adequately
address the notion of time. To this end, we introduce TimeArena, a novel
textual simulated environment that incorporates complex temporal dynamics and
constraints that better reflect real-life planning scenarios. In TimeArena,
agents are asked to complete multiple tasks as soon as possible, allowing for
parallel processing to save time. We implement the dependency between actions,
the time duration for each action, and the occupancy of the agent and the
objects in the environment. TimeArena grounds to 30 real-world tasks in
cooking, household activities, and laboratory work. We conduct extensive
experiments with various state-of-the-art LLMs using TimeArena. Our findings
reveal that even the most powerful models, e.g., GPT-4, still lag behind humans
in effective multitasking, underscoring the need for enhanced temporal
awareness in the development of language agents. | [
0.049137648195028305,
-1.058768630027771,
0.6916528344154358,
0.8411564826965332,
0.11107239872217178,
0.3320853114128113,
-0.0792028158903122,
-0.59375,
0.3964952528476715,
0.3613415062427521,
-0.5173592567443848,
-0.11263077706098557,
-0.2677379548549652,
0.032639969140291214,
-0.19073493778705597,
0.5137603282928467,
-0.22490251064300537,
-0.17760011553764343,
0.11170823872089386,
-0.07482663542032242,
-0.33187106251716614,
-0.7973906397819519,
-0.6534668207168579,
-0.6097063422203064,
0.6499876379966736,
0.21440163254737854,
0.6550477147102356,
0.5062596201896667,
-0.06186458468437195,
0.36398178339004517,
0.129060298204422,
0.2850716710090637,
-0.1685594618320465,
0.47871577739715576,
-0.00960624497383833,
-0.5171636343002319,
-0.6929833292961121,
-0.0476895347237587,
0.45485273003578186,
0.3711587190628052,
-0.2992165684700012,
0.10919417440891266,
-0.021885668858885765,
0.27965399622917175,
-0.5056081414222717,
0.43013444542884827,
-0.262506902217865,
0.2745906114578247,
-0.27754709124565125,
-0.40595564246177673,
-0.16118009388446808,
-0.10532331466674805,
-0.109607994556427,
-0.850310206413269,
0.04273289442062378,
0.09518993645906448,
0.6388733386993408,
0.4070434272289276,
-0.37903618812561035,
0.02687942422926426,
-1.3744806051254272,
0.7816876173019409,
-0.3934677243232727,
0.23139934241771698,
0.2841333746910095,
0.6309798359870911,
-0.22155679762363434,
-0.6260502338409424,
-0.8558081984519958,
-0.11062295734882355,
0.4645252525806427,
0.16084818542003632,
-0.025325234979391098,
-0.10643117129802704,
0.25511878728866577,
-0.2173418402671814,
-0.4337649345397949,
-0.0026455845218151808,
-0.12462269514799118,
0.07637855410575867,
0.04750079661607742,
0.6305854916572571,
0.5695061087608337,
0.08115499466657639,
-0.1392432451248169,
-0.15780949592590332,
-0.4558056890964508,
0.14608584344387054,
0.3515808880329132,
0.1597328931093216,
0.040542226284742355,
0.5413713455200195,
-0.06786485761404037,
0.5083265900611877,
-0.41518011689186096,
-0.05418011173605919,
-0.06237940490245819,
-0.38421308994293213,
-0.2325419783592224,
0.0351034551858902,
0.4622573256492615,
0.402906209230423,
0.2546226382255554,
-0.16930650174617767,
0.11257120221853256,
0.6546469926834106,
0.5065348744392395,
-0.8401215672492981,
0.006377622485160828,
0.4197823107242584,
-0.21643918752670288,
-0.40675970911979675,
-0.5933035016059875,
-1.0372077226638794,
-0.06632925570011139,
-0.2587772607803345,
0.2659050524234772,
-0.3072778582572937,
-0.37676241993904114,
0.31092411279678345,
0.05963428318500519,
0.06849343329668045,
0.4404427707195282,
-0.6984117031097412,
0.5963690876960754,
0.5063714981079102,
0.892397940158844,
0.02390376105904579,
-0.865501344203949,
-0.5709859728813171,
0.6409952640533447,
-0.29259762167930603,
0.8907110095024109,
-0.7755033373832703,
-0.4018120765686035,
-0.15768884122371674,
-0.016268083825707436,
-0.29261380434036255,
-0.205169677734375,
0.15947149693965912,
-0.6151392459869385,
0.0931304320693016,
-0.1288917511701584,
-0.2941468358039856,
-0.09910009056329727,
0.49224820733070374,
-0.9784140586853027,
0.9478074312210083,
-0.04466104879975319,
-0.25821104645729065,
0.3929781913757324,
-1.2218499183654785,
-0.48668569326400757,
-0.13432899117469788,
0.03437402471899986,
-0.26169654726982117,
-0.2107250988483429,
0.3170487880706787,
0.5382845997810364,
-0.0983128547668457,
0.282527357339859,
-0.20411317050457,
-0.1793910712003708,
0.4547707438468933,
-0.46129995584487915,
0.5785802006721497,
0.4634697735309601,
-0.5092568397521973,
0.2703661024570465,
-0.3267521858215332,
0.0453852079808712,
0.20077380537986755,
-0.3881407678127289,
-0.2590596079826355,
0.2027866393327713,
0.2503105700016022,
0.3839032053947449,
0.1827625185251236,
-0.6989845633506775,
0.413281112909317,
-0.029176881536841393,
0.7034960389137268,
0.46407684683799744,
0.08598987758159637,
0.36441415548324585,
-0.8058425784111023,
0.8486580848693848,
-0.165164053440094,
0.535558819770813,
0.004256668966263533,
-0.3797656297683716,
-0.6384069919586182,
-0.016623755916953087,
-0.008673482574522495,
0.7961758375167847,
-0.8839549422264099,
-0.19214552640914917,
-0.3752230703830719,
-0.505876898765564,
-0.1693100482225418,
-0.029632046818733215,
0.43363383412361145,
-0.0859873965382576,
0.24914588034152985,
0.10510148853063583,
-0.3649248480796814,
-0.4783487915992737,
-0.3595755398273468,
-0.048264652490615845,
0.3427458107471466,
0.010402655228972435,
0.5037522315979004,
-0.1771801859140396,
0.7893134951591492,
-0.3626553416252136,
-0.40813499689102173,
-0.48139604926109314,
0.10054882615804672,
-0.21642513573169708,
0.33454474806785583,
0.805332362651825,
-0.6688887476921082,
-0.23608967661857605,
-0.12658561766147614,
-0.8001079559326172,
0.017712993547320366,
-0.3805845379829407,
0.012031316757202148,
0.1286926120519638,
0.6532579660415649,
-0.6308730840682983,
0.35866987705230713,
0.8180976510047913,
-0.5555548071861267,
0.6771856546401978,
-0.4549848139286041,
0.3060711920261383,
-1.3557612895965576,
0.07479245215654373,
-0.31562140583992004,
-0.3383590281009674,
-0.7250272631645203,
-0.0328851193189621,
-0.05942535772919655,
-0.44379013776779175,
-0.5552605390548706,
1.04242742061615,
-0.5893193483352661,
-0.008905448950827122,
-0.251937597990036,
-0.11622007936239243,
0.11598611623048782,
0.7842696309089661,
-0.11303889751434326,
1.00187349319458,
0.08284370601177216,
-0.8146876096725464,
0.1195722445845604,
-0.16094940900802612,
-0.4066673815250397,
0.26808276772499084,
-0.7057097554206848,
0.04461811110377312,
-0.002773930784314871,
0.4518587291240692,
-0.44860151410102844,
-0.3555707037448883,
0.07036178559064865,
-0.05099970102310181,
-0.034928515553474426,
0.06772066652774811,
-0.9062706828117371,
-0.13441362977027893,
-0.2128608524799347,
0.7088572382926941,
0.2754759192466736,
-0.23677128553390503,
1.2318683862686157,
0.4933568239212036,
-0.10333995521068573,
-0.47534888982772827,
-0.6826233863830566,
0.23799051344394684,
-0.24172541499137878,
-0.2155274897813797,
0.40711209177970886,
-0.0710354596376419,
-0.48065218329429626,
0.09458542615175247,
0.15127873420715332,
-0.16317492723464966,
0.3279530107975006,
0.46433407068252563,
-0.06606119871139526,
0.3279646933078766,
0.08237119019031525,
0.19418178498744965,
0.0019528084667399526,
-0.11381310969591141,
-0.3171582818031311,
0.699334442615509,
0.02858208678662777,
-0.36989232897758484,
-0.4587033689022064,
0.5296041965484619,
0.8403494358062744,
-0.30729854106903076,
0.6697697043418884,
0.3935658037662506,
-0.5912341475486755,
-0.29928165674209595,
-0.5494741201400757,
-0.01876981183886528,
-0.4612013101577759,
0.2341230809688568,
-0.4453558921813965,
-0.7494123578071594,
0.7573562264442444,
-0.08192101866006851,
0.48696908354759216,
0.04352443292737007,
0.4248800575733185,
0.05475752800703049,
0.8403392434120178,
0.4105846881866455,
0.169883593916893,
0.9076022505760193,
-0.22001376748085022,
-0.09737161546945572,
-0.799852728843689,
-0.33043915033340454,
-0.522152841091156,
-0.4027327597141266,
-0.06554417312145233,
-0.951870322227478,
0.43637150526046753,
-0.38986900448799133,
-0.09137500077486038,
0.2700482904911041,
-0.1353316605091095,
0.6174766421318054,
0.3946942090988159,
0.0017342172795906663,
0.24893508851528168,
-0.12001916766166687,
-0.2207402139902115,
0.0042991237714886665,
-0.7568168640136719,
-0.6784491539001465,
0.8696165084838867,
0.07544895261526108,
0.7089848518371582,
0.14418822526931763,
0.40337464213371277,
0.3222035765647888,
0.1936900019645691,
-0.42897966504096985,
0.6036777496337891,
-0.11930865794420242,
-0.9084682464599609,
-0.4854172170162201,
-0.344798743724823,
-1.3783230781555176,
0.18729570508003235,
0.09408058226108551,
-0.6009899973869324,
-0.11572399735450745,
0.23642942309379578,
-0.5435460209846497,
0.5387383103370667,
-0.817649245262146,
0.887912392616272,
-0.5571051239967346,
-0.5038829445838928,
-0.5994539856910706,
-0.32432693243026733,
-0.11126738786697388,
0.09295906126499176,
0.39825668931007385,
-0.569477379322052,
-0.2783108651638031,
0.637279748916626,
-0.45543137192726135,
1.2294117212295532,
-0.3006616532802582,
0.014992307871580124,
0.3387005627155304,
0.6626882553100586,
0.5057075023651123,
-0.10032301396131516,
-0.11677567660808563,
-0.1981244683265686,
0.16006523370742798,
-0.6110305190086365,
-0.6821041107177734,
0.8488812446594238,
-0.609770655632019,
-0.2729666531085968,
-0.5809453129768372,
-0.571509063243866,
-0.26739856600761414,
0.15309478342533112,
-0.11932209134101868,
0.7270933985710144,
-0.6463811993598938,
-0.3041805326938629,
0.35694220662117004,
-0.1629188507795334,
0.6795397400856018,
0.5893632173538208,
-0.5270515084266663,
0.047250211238861084,
0.7728897929191589,
0.4046459197998047,
0.04021395742893219,
0.6611786484718323,
0.09380029141902924,
-0.36044588685035706,
-0.09923271834850311,
-0.4189375340938568,
0.03444797173142433,
-0.3701958954334259,
0.15871544182300568,
-1.0636546611785889,
0.10763221979141235,
-0.11043193191289902,
-0.20284493267536163,
-0.6651930809020996,
-0.6265239715576172,
-0.1082344502210617,
-0.05323243886232376,
0.3998956084251404,
0.8686525225639343,
0.19058777391910553,
0.2707526981830597,
-0.8059187531471252,
0.25877055525779724,
0.5984960198402405,
0.36193305253982544,
0.1902453899383545,
0.166741743683815,
-0.17772448062896729,
-0.22804485261440277,
-0.05764329433441162,
-0.5719442367553711,
0.34306085109710693,
0.17797952890396118,
0.49022048711776733,
-0.08033973723649979,
-0.08545230329036713,
0.6501863598823547,
-0.5995885133743286,
0.7763614058494568,
-0.16859318315982819,
-0.7866055369377136,
0.32172176241874695,
-0.4797751307487488,
0.8060395121574402,
0.24820511043071747,
-0.13776518404483795,
-0.7378186583518982,
-0.39755362272262573,
-0.36270952224731445,
-0.8237404227256775,
0.47017303109169006,
0.5144063234329224,
0.09319129586219788,
0.05225750058889389,
0.02697024866938591,
0.09584328532218933,
0.09533191472291946,
-0.43841755390167236,
-0.03295512869954109,
-0.38097015023231506,
0.0653432086110115,
-0.2381199151277542,
-0.32731425762176514,
0.013607234694063663,
0.07652302086353302,
0.41291964054107666,
0.009411962702870369,
0.5449324250221252,
0.1345549374818802,
-0.19362109899520874,
0.08000794798135757,
0.4474414885044098,
1.032669186592102,
0.5338125824928284,
0.06230432540178299,
0.14457224309444427,
0.2722444534301758,
-0.5596919655799866,
0.42867884039878845,
0.07951878756284714,
0.09791753441095352,
-0.1766074299812317,
0.32380399107933044,
0.6361644268035889,
0.5586376190185547,
-0.5019086599349976,
-0.044304486364126205,
-0.6284005641937256,
0.06261153519153595,
-0.7644277215003967,
0.08234108984470367,
0.2384282499551773,
0.41056978702545166,
0.17900577187538147,
0.095018669962883,
-0.0909355953335762,
-0.5371823310852051,
-0.15022991597652435,
-0.139179989695549,
-0.1169511005282402,
-0.548574686050415,
0.991398811340332,
0.4128519594669342,
-0.4369507431983948,
0.22631554305553436,
-0.3780454099178314,
-0.5572645664215088,
0.7562412619590759,
0.4678037166595459,
1.1154459714889526,
-0.5000272989273071,
0.18176120519638062,
0.12330783158540726,
0.3028789460659027,
-0.31567278504371643,
0.8143984079360962,
0.043362442404031754,
-0.6886030435562134,
-0.6492307782173157,
-0.6575343012809753,
-0.44080862402915955,
-0.019106628373265266,
-0.11015591025352478,
-0.2474891096353531,
-0.43516433238983154,
-0.5131329894065857,
-0.04642461612820625,
-0.0755586326122284,
-0.7742330431938171,
-0.2037462741136551,
-0.4317210912704468,
0.6671751141548157,
-0.5414624214172363,
1.0589853525161743,
0.9779410362243652,
-0.025875303894281387,
-0.9023643732070923,
0.16465413570404053,
0.15478995442390442,
-0.53684002161026,
0.41800689697265625,
0.1144934818148613,
-0.7245957255363464,
-0.04604692757129669,
-0.10436674952507019,
-0.6400042772293091,
1.1426860094070435,
0.32482999563217163,
-0.5524689555168152,
-0.4555957317352295,
-0.14383307099342346,
0.6912745237350464,
-0.24618184566497803,
-0.0873776227235794,
0.19793139398097992,
0.4699020981788635,
-0.46626996994018555,
-1.007236361503601,
-0.05788836255669594,
-0.6049679517745972,
0.13336895406246185,
0.36628201603889465,
-0.981365442276001,
0.7096497416496277,
-0.2047649472951889,
-0.2848161458969116,
0.0060478635132312775,
0.4361930191516876,
0.25036540627479553,
0.30485156178474426,
0.6214435696601868,
0.3995665907859802,
0.5447856783866882,
0.012782247737050056,
1.3173151016235352,
-0.4328625202178955,
-0.05227115377783775,
1.1544443368911743,
-0.6472404599189758,
0.5281636118888855,
0.3577333688735962,
-0.06490364670753479,
0.3501412570476532,
0.299381285905838,
0.4926377236843109,
0.23814141750335693,
-0.031207118183374405,
-0.46358153223991394,
-0.4442684054374695,
-0.41232502460479736,
-0.15368963778018951,
0.5947446823120117,
0.5731707215309143,
0.26619821786880493,
-0.17345161736011505,
0.34701886773109436,
0.3680458664894104,
0.23456430435180664,
-0.025451138615608215,
0.41482067108154297,
-0.005812845192849636,
-0.7837451100349426,
0.028335340321063995,
-0.16050906479358673,
0.3797963559627533,
-0.6605461239814758,
-0.20601189136505127,
-0.10432906448841095,
0.42647653818130493,
0.21582694351673126,
-0.6304871439933777,
0.2673581838607788,
0.06479151546955109,
-0.08797379583120346,
-0.4825895130634308,
0.5405959486961365,
-0.4842000901699066,
-0.37117889523506165,
0.6614298224449158,
0.7753235101699829,
0.1504727452993393,
-0.10181402415037155,
-0.537142813205719,
0.24368566274642944,
-0.35883304476737976,
-0.33655548095703125,
0.22545234858989716,
0.5997572541236877,
-0.3277420401573181,
1.0659695863723755,
0.4778117835521698,
0.13366706669330597,
0.12921155989170074,
0.17210735380649567,
0.6518293023109436,
-0.6863992810249329,
-0.8153319358825684,
-0.796791672706604,
-0.06771467626094818,
0.006507062818855047,
-0.2537745535373688,
0.5156844854354858,
0.5251374840736389,
0.6064540147781372,
-0.10718243569135666,
0.6957868933677673,
-0.031342267990112305,
0.4766610264778137,
-0.7647714018821716,
0.9425941705703735,
-0.5411157608032227,
0.17984755337238312,
-0.20608848333358765,
-0.9472736716270447,
-0.10800319164991379,
0.27998295426368713,
-0.13674896955490112,
0.2623958885669708,
0.8337616920471191,
0.6118636727333069,
0.005357980728149414,
-0.15359744429588318,
0.39829114079475403,
-0.0036738701164722443,
0.6851121187210083,
0.7315295338630676,
0.9635336399078369,
0.02963157184422016,
0.7306917905807495,
-0.4631268084049225,
-0.00959886983036995,
-0.2068263739347458,
-0.8672171831130981,
-0.951063871383667,
-0.764481782913208,
-0.00976575631648302,
-0.0715695396065712,
0.34215328097343445,
1.1424494981765747,
0.8453016877174377,
-0.5217390060424805,
-0.47152218222618103,
0.17812485992908478,
-0.303824245929718,
-0.5839090943336487,
-0.17414924502372742,
0.0754317194223404,
-0.12926898896694183,
-0.9187941551208496,
0.6877192258834839,
0.2448931336402893,
0.3281615674495697,
-0.2514803409576416,
-0.10177896171808243,
-0.31589072942733765,
-0.0008565523894503713,
0.7357649207115173,
0.45805877447128296,
-0.49079373478889465,
-0.0981125608086586,
0.13964316248893738,
-0.13858672976493835,
-0.19863077998161316,
1.1959319114685059,
-0.7168450355529785,
0.5030860304832458,
0.15616919100284576,
0.3829847574234009,
0.701971173286438,
-0.1663120836019516,
0.7756069898605347,
-0.6688358783721924,
0.34415388107299805,
0.3915807902812958,
0.18247701227664948,
0.06112886592745781,
-0.2129746824502945,
0.5719618201255798,
-0.06310861557722092,
-0.7294318079948425,
-0.4727621078491211,
0.3541078269481659,
-0.835411787033081,
-0.5059273838996887,
0.9730145335197449,
-0.0025096270255744457,
-0.45797330141067505,
-0.4541880190372467,
-0.16072583198547363,
0.5266926288604736,
-0.8048670291900635,
0.9712602496147156,
0.7360291481018066,
-0.31965991854667664,
0.07603603601455688,
-0.982980489730835,
0.5210260152816772,
0.514434814453125,
-1.1556100845336914,
0.22306974232196808,
0.410897821187973,
0.25959232449531555,
0.257669597864151,
0.8733837008476257,
-0.0394524522125721,
0.2778904438018799,
0.039847489446401596,
0.1529702991247177,
-0.3964211344718933,
-0.7699143290519714,
0.03658562898635864,
0.05916749686002731,
0.0622924268245697,
-0.14511243999004364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05706v1 | Unified Speech-Text Pretraining for Spoken Dialog Modeling | 2024-02-08T14:35:09 | 2024-02-08T14:35:09 | Heeseung Kim, Soonshin Seo, Kyeongseok Jeong, Ohsung Kwon, Jungwhan Kim, Jaehong Lee, Eunwoo Song, Myungwoo Oh, Sungroh Yoon, Kang Min Yoo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | While recent work shows promising results in expanding the capabilities of
large language models (LLM) to directly understand and synthesize speech, an
LLM-based strategy for modeling spoken dialogs remains elusive and calls for
further investigation. This work proposes an extensive speech-text LLM
framework, named the Unified Spoken Dialog Model (USDM), to generate coherent
spoken responses with organic prosodic features relevant to the given input
speech without relying on automatic speech recognition (ASR) or text-to-speech
(TTS) solutions. Our approach employs a multi-step speech-text inference scheme
that leverages chain-of-reasoning capabilities exhibited by the underlying LLM.
We also propose a generalized speech-text pretraining scheme that helps with
capturing cross-modal semantics. Automatic and human evaluations show that the
proposed approach is effective in generating natural-sounding spoken responses,
outperforming both prior and cascaded baselines. Detailed comparative studies
reveal that, despite the cascaded approach being stronger in individual
components, the joint speech-text modeling improves robustness against
recognition errors and speech quality. Demo is available at
https://unifiedsdm.github.io. | [
-0.18152321875095367,
-0.8586379885673523,
0.650295615196228,
-0.0372101366519928,
-0.620803713798523,
0.08348217606544495,
-0.24935609102249146,
-0.2653047442436218,
-0.05855751782655716,
0.7960624694824219,
-0.7234333157539368,
-0.5568860173225403,
-0.1547790914773941,
0.35887402296066284,
-0.2888323962688446,
0.9016651511192322,
0.23781868815422058,
0.6596043109893799,
-0.2521040737628937,
0.14112989604473114,
-0.3791419565677643,
-0.790871262550354,
-0.4261339008808136,
-0.6605547070503235,
0.23389704525470734,
0.15512311458587646,
0.39270541071891785,
0.22867049276828766,
0.19346623122692108,
0.3590727150440216,
-0.027061963453888893,
-0.08866289258003235,
-0.137461856007576,
0.05224373936653137,
0.09959366172552109,
-0.2653467357158661,
-0.5844913721084595,
0.07674932479858398,
0.7265371680259705,
0.8865602612495422,
-0.3499608635902405,
-0.13153763115406036,
0.227028489112854,
0.28561532497406006,
-0.21257486939430237,
0.06399355828762054,
-0.7515742778778076,
-0.07004371285438538,
-0.2227603793144226,
-0.36424368619918823,
-0.5200825929641724,
-0.04853386804461479,
0.4706394672393799,
-0.6227577328681946,
0.16470178961753845,
-0.11360403895378113,
0.4828677177429199,
0.04208523407578468,
-0.5099442601203918,
-0.28273120522499084,
-0.8444552421569824,
0.6418492197990417,
-0.8811494708061218,
0.6271694302558899,
0.2561950087547302,
0.07178636640310287,
-0.20770131051540375,
-0.7195703983306885,
-0.5279099345207214,
-0.4569849669933319,
0.09094960242509842,
0.3021275997161865,
-0.022817252203822136,
0.4705279469490051,
-0.24294869601726532,
0.4018422067165375,
-0.6807300448417664,
0.039827294647693634,
0.141974538564682,
-0.34404367208480835,
0.3138872981071472,
0.20664633810520172,
0.23657146096229553,
-0.1101539209485054,
-0.6215407848358154,
-0.028005322441458702,
-0.6890369653701782,
0.12811769545078278,
0.16821666061878204,
0.6177191138267517,
-0.18160562217235565,
0.5066927075386047,
0.034717053174972534,
0.6967737674713135,
-0.046350132673978806,
-0.24518178403377533,
0.041812166571617126,
-0.5682116150856018,
-0.4695908725261688,
0.05525097995996475,
1.0549639463424683,
-0.0007417231099680066,
0.2040432244539261,
-0.36490151286125183,
-0.2018190175294876,
0.06060203164815903,
0.16525545716285706,
-0.8134124279022217,
-0.04617353901267052,
0.06468526273965836,
-0.05522419884800911,
-0.28645455837249756,
0.16996675729751587,
-0.6389785408973694,
-0.06184723600745201,
-0.6351712942123413,
0.4549707770347595,
-0.31369540095329285,
-0.25434690713882446,
0.01955067738890648,
0.06425821781158447,
-0.038471952080726624,
0.2821634113788605,
-0.7155483365058899,
0.44642215967178345,
0.5042883157730103,
0.6225528120994568,
-0.07384409755468369,
-0.12749426066875458,
-0.7576633095741272,
0.19150668382644653,
-0.2049238532781601,
0.7174466252326965,
-0.7142038345336914,
-0.710087776184082,
-0.07700669765472412,
-0.21748828887939453,
-0.20966388285160065,
-0.5700774788856506,
0.45065584778785706,
-0.4084143042564392,
0.32336902618408203,
0.011178210377693176,
-0.5390231013298035,
0.008268604055047035,
0.003963199444115162,
-0.4865962862968445,
0.9191792011260986,
-0.05069972947239876,
-0.6077558398246765,
0.046030882745981216,
-0.43269532918930054,
-0.46729543805122375,
0.10974328219890594,
-0.39711520075798035,
-0.17568929493427277,
0.24329805374145508,
0.19428834319114685,
0.29093578457832336,
-0.6603567004203796,
0.7433990836143494,
-0.20292213559150696,
-0.15695974230766296,
0.36343154311180115,
-0.6670345664024353,
0.7437395453453064,
0.11321856826543808,
-0.2629326581954956,
0.3984431326389313,
-0.7881699204444885,
0.12146934866905212,
0.04724089056253433,
-0.5634229183197021,
-0.006152976769953966,
-0.10776762664318085,
0.17527160048484802,
0.002389283152297139,
-0.01933051459491253,
-0.47238585352897644,
0.023621100932359695,
-0.3453545868396759,
0.4235084652900696,
0.801929771900177,
-0.1533147543668747,
0.6048458218574524,
-0.06319534778594971,
0.505755603313446,
0.047189559787511826,
-0.1281203031539917,
-0.4450981020927429,
-0.4255484938621521,
-0.5752002000808716,
-0.3328070044517517,
0.3612932562828064,
0.7581605911254883,
-0.6947322487831116,
0.7450765371322632,
-0.09893796592950821,
-0.231705904006958,
-0.18721532821655273,
0.2036043405532837,
0.7355829477310181,
0.7285373210906982,
0.298489511013031,
-0.4437064528465271,
-0.6258677840232849,
-0.4914189875125885,
-0.29435762763023376,
-0.4119715988636017,
-0.3924674391746521,
0.1467476636171341,
0.2503105700016022,
-0.28558745980262756,
1.1987181901931763,
-0.28906697034835815,
-0.34545189142227173,
-0.44511526823043823,
0.3910808861255646,
-0.11051813513040543,
0.2712668478488922,
0.22543920576572418,
-0.7267823219299316,
-0.23274309933185577,
-0.1010279506444931,
-0.39865317940711975,
-0.4077845513820648,
0.021475566551089287,
0.07137786597013474,
0.08796805888414383,
0.4941548705101013,
-0.7481841444969177,
0.17896299064159393,
0.6628897786140442,
-0.15777520835399628,
0.7945809960365295,
-0.07195460796356201,
-0.0984019786119461,
-1.2535213232040405,
0.015125276520848274,
0.009334450587630272,
-0.43365904688835144,
-0.9082863330841064,
-0.35210907459259033,
-0.38152387738227844,
-0.5517661571502686,
-0.40140262246131897,
0.594332754611969,
-0.3569963872432709,
-0.06193351000547409,
-0.2191799432039261,
0.02117125503718853,
0.002620282582938671,
0.5763791799545288,
0.31599053740501404,
0.8694743514060974,
0.5857810974121094,
-0.6353251934051514,
0.16879671812057495,
0.07166053354740143,
-0.0641702264547348,
0.5562019348144531,
-0.7687579989433289,
0.421891987323761,
0.04719901084899902,
0.621393620967865,
-0.9964104890823364,
-0.38083338737487793,
0.1274518519639969,
-0.34174755215644836,
0.3560709059238434,
0.0391353964805603,
-0.3056633770465851,
-0.28286126255989075,
0.033560942858457565,
0.3071856200695038,
0.378131628036499,
-0.37840306758880615,
1.0832569599151611,
0.45936015248298645,
-0.6842876076698303,
-0.06679286807775497,
-0.4118967056274414,
0.05664319917559624,
-0.06240608170628548,
-0.567525327205658,
0.4393756687641144,
-0.1904347836971283,
-0.055783387273550034,
-0.3299318253993988,
-0.3613542318344116,
-0.3048854172229767,
-0.053165119141340256,
0.2066836953163147,
0.18921293318271637,
-0.17395198345184326,
0.07384565472602844,
-0.15852302312850952,
-0.3427516520023346,
0.06615274399518967,
-0.49096331000328064,
0.7229208946228027,
-0.2890208959579468,
-0.3138676583766937,
-0.7849063277244568,
0.5065661072731018,
0.455596387386322,
-0.3330383896827698,
0.14284628629684448,
0.5526272654533386,
-0.22089721262454987,
0.03909643366932869,
-0.3630726635456085,
-0.37580403685569763,
-0.4708271026611328,
0.2609899938106537,
-0.16820429265499115,
-0.9666142463684082,
0.23032580316066742,
-0.4106380343437195,
-0.08272424340248108,
-0.00602888036519289,
0.43464168906211853,
-0.21851614117622375,
1.0978094339370728,
0.47876885533332825,
-0.04963306337594986,
0.60614013671875,
0.020273776724934578,
0.08033192902803421,
-0.5877441167831421,
-0.24837878346443176,
-0.6652613282203674,
0.29163509607315063,
-0.10928471386432648,
-0.49304547905921936,
0.3314379155635834,
0.12859202921390533,
-0.15848414599895477,
0.12639887630939484,
-0.0005482101114466786,
0.3138214349746704,
0.5208353400230408,
0.024092325940728188,
0.3509601950645447,
0.18221034109592438,
-0.5656238198280334,
-0.07892021536827087,
-0.5562494993209839,
-0.6822454333305359,
0.8812387585639954,
0.07473461329936981,
0.8336570858955383,
-0.24257850646972656,
0.66606605052948,
0.049525756388902664,
0.3310990035533905,
-0.5626973509788513,
0.6763247847557068,
-0.1726256161928177,
-0.43352267146110535,
-0.26234158873558044,
-0.6775246858596802,
-0.8041950464248657,
0.29978200793266296,
-0.2315705120563507,
-0.790051281452179,
-0.2730908989906311,
0.2785366177558899,
-0.331501305103302,
0.18017740547657013,
-0.6767054796218872,
0.6767313480377197,
-0.4307936728000641,
0.1633041799068451,
0.035913366824388504,
-0.7335146069526672,
0.09417780488729477,
-0.18768011033535004,
0.20743587613105774,
-0.08134543150663376,
0.2654418647289276,
0.6108152270317078,
-0.604093611240387,
1.1255249977111816,
-0.20492681860923767,
-0.25953081250190735,
0.501071572303772,
-0.09471315890550613,
0.41315749287605286,
0.034315094351768494,
0.01149202510714531,
0.3155282437801361,
-0.3521316647529602,
-0.13626977801322937,
-0.4350985288619995,
0.29075002670288086,
-0.5222323536872864,
-0.6088765859603882,
-0.29436853528022766,
-0.4654339551925659,
-0.5230674743652344,
0.40766480565071106,
0.34358373284339905,
0.8652841448783875,
-0.6757206320762634,
0.27459749579429626,
0.5156036615371704,
0.05214513838291168,
0.2929302453994751,
0.6305230855941772,
-0.265809029340744,
-0.7930296659469604,
0.7411003112792969,
-0.07948978245258331,
0.42676547169685364,
0.46177247166633606,
0.2662144601345062,
-0.5594879984855652,
-0.50407475233078,
-0.5084213614463806,
-0.021637696772813797,
-0.33071210980415344,
-0.18558333814144135,
-0.5554603338241577,
-0.1344829648733139,
-0.4983519911766052,
-0.0710308849811554,
-0.39661335945129395,
-0.04539036750793457,
-0.5632900595664978,
-0.05206901207566261,
-0.016129154711961746,
0.7109516859054565,
0.07380795478820801,
0.6097092032432556,
-1.0034123659133911,
0.7181264162063599,
0.7306389808654785,
0.1954592913389206,
-0.1885802000761032,
-0.5276502370834351,
0.01889517903327942,
0.4750882387161255,
-0.43436571955680847,
-0.8834555149078369,
0.3481191396713257,
0.5139420628547668,
0.4924086332321167,
0.4856535792350769,
-0.018863845616579056,
0.7262383103370667,
-0.7345662713050842,
0.7955130934715271,
0.6045525074005127,
-1.142135739326477,
0.5201795101165771,
-0.4982939064502716,
0.4653988182544708,
0.5648633241653442,
0.17349214851856232,
-0.27326616644859314,
-0.5321140885353088,
-0.35029587149620056,
-0.7951818704605103,
0.5647058486938477,
0.3133231997489929,
0.15622445940971375,
-0.0010644415160641074,
0.057341210544109344,
0.09246731549501419,
0.21753694117069244,
-0.7226812839508057,
0.006206663325428963,
-0.17570911347866058,
-0.2384042590856552,
-0.2090713381767273,
-0.11653956770896912,
-0.19779926538467407,
-0.364632785320282,
0.5721345543861389,
-0.300138920545578,
0.23657214641571045,
0.2580735981464386,
-0.36528217792510986,
-0.1233622133731842,
0.59556645154953,
0.4355895519256592,
0.5032739043235779,
-0.19653016328811646,
0.19063813984394073,
0.09504766017198563,
-0.6238006353378296,
0.4898470938205719,
0.33769622445106506,
-0.10303743183612823,
0.11102592200040817,
0.34723374247550964,
0.8927462100982666,
0.6237438917160034,
-0.666113018989563,
0.43241310119628906,
-0.10827171057462692,
-0.2779833972454071,
-0.137319415807724,
0.005463982000946999,
0.25441110134124756,
0.18287581205368042,
0.5082818865776062,
0.014875826425850391,
-0.016020959243178368,
-0.590194821357727,
0.15416118502616882,
0.4882130026817322,
-0.5219157934188843,
-0.6380995512008667,
0.7438470125198364,
0.5837576389312744,
-0.49239835143089294,
0.5128958225250244,
0.07393393665552139,
-0.5272839069366455,
0.40654435753822327,
0.8755771517753601,
1.1395933628082275,
-0.47260525822639465,
0.2713257372379303,
-0.07625720649957657,
-0.06656597554683685,
0.07690524309873581,
0.32022038102149963,
-0.20645666122436523,
-0.6640593409538269,
-0.38127171993255615,
-0.7860638499259949,
-0.43389201164245605,
0.22439773380756378,
-0.6656715869903564,
0.04637358337640762,
-0.3288205564022064,
-0.36615660786628723,
0.03343585506081581,
-0.2585577666759491,
-0.5826366543769836,
0.3294091820716858,
0.3081566095352173,
0.5906378030776978,
-0.8108279705047607,
0.8274715542793274,
0.6878454089164734,
-0.15162846446037292,
-0.818889319896698,
0.24156895279884338,
0.2736901342868805,
-0.5351777076721191,
0.3069692552089691,
0.5058869123458862,
-0.45054125785827637,
0.20922693610191345,
-0.4319825768470764,
-0.5785163044929504,
1.0630759000778198,
0.7473064064979553,
-0.7926109433174133,
-0.13298043608665466,
0.4885115325450897,
0.4638550281524658,
-0.5593988299369812,
0.06628302484750748,
0.5039882659912109,
0.2111072838306427,
0.2505066394805908,
-1.159509301185608,
-0.2373315989971161,
-0.14460396766662598,
0.16702336072921753,
0.06496375054121017,
-0.3030495345592499,
0.7038423418998718,
-0.17737449705600739,
-0.4684823453426361,
0.2902344763278961,
0.6499584317207336,
0.3116644620895386,
0.2741844952106476,
0.6863313317298889,
0.7560438513755798,
0.820327877998352,
-0.09783963859081268,
0.8670704960823059,
-0.1778331845998764,
0.10153850167989731,
1.314353108406067,
-0.5898110270500183,
0.8569548726081848,
0.3130171298980713,
-0.20720377564430237,
0.4081290066242218,
0.47188666462898254,
0.5999755263328552,
0.5894812941551208,
0.043453458696603775,
-0.6501334309577942,
-0.5730940699577332,
-0.1528911590576172,
-0.40775066614151,
0.7185895442962646,
0.24371784925460815,
-0.07928470522165298,
-0.38775938749313354,
-0.0018718861974775791,
-0.014710893854498863,
-0.13759316504001617,
-0.2477228343486786,
1.1463888883590698,
0.3528856933116913,
-0.5679469108581543,
0.43042829632759094,
-0.3559763431549072,
0.5384377837181091,
-0.8256281018257141,
-0.02261783927679062,
0.06386241316795349,
-0.027318298816680908,
0.1906549483537674,
-0.4229559898376465,
0.04064090549945831,
0.2753424048423767,
-0.17380528151988983,
-0.46495330333709717,
0.7215896844863892,
-0.6825543642044067,
-0.42830249667167664,
0.3352343738079071,
0.43312063813209534,
-0.0021061392035335302,
-0.27206656336784363,
-0.6613304615020752,
-0.16295883059501648,
-0.07179505378007889,
-0.2759072184562683,
0.3235984444618225,
0.40154266357421875,
0.06054633483290672,
0.4031059145927429,
1.0438835620880127,
-0.13747714459896088,
-0.04596230387687683,
0.6053645610809326,
0.936420202255249,
-0.6091427206993103,
-0.6936800479888916,
-0.7130578756332397,
0.646720290184021,
0.16744743287563324,
-0.15457221865653992,
0.4457424581050873,
0.4098827838897705,
0.6350350379943848,
-0.03586249053478241,
0.7578151822090149,
0.3781391978263855,
0.37748345732688904,
-0.7584604620933533,
0.5050560832023621,
-0.3564934730529785,
0.07921036332845688,
-0.42154234647750854,
-0.944491982460022,
-0.1782543808221817,
0.48880699276924133,
0.0803486704826355,
0.1765366643667221,
0.5060420036315918,
0.6430399417877197,
0.11892164498567581,
0.2860338091850281,
0.2595129609107971,
0.19264380633831024,
0.34499284625053406,
0.20390745997428894,
0.7460960745811462,
0.005044036544859409,
0.5798601508140564,
0.10226358473300934,
-0.1252882331609726,
-0.2069082260131836,
-0.871889591217041,
-0.8454110026359558,
-0.4327056407928467,
-0.006316616665571928,
-0.03438375145196915,
-0.03412943705916405,
0.8914421796798706,
0.8821024894714355,
-0.7693726420402527,
-0.33925482630729675,
-0.5255085825920105,
-0.2087784707546234,
0.06375150382518768,
-0.18443523347377777,
-0.04513926059007645,
-0.31942474842071533,
-0.5189866423606873,
0.7267110347747803,
0.4125499427318573,
0.36456531286239624,
-0.17553284764289856,
-0.3296213746070862,
-0.06108098104596138,
0.35994213819503784,
0.5830716490745544,
0.15606403350830078,
-0.8298185467720032,
0.030528992414474487,
0.08722071349620819,
0.03162530064582825,
0.061571862548589706,
1.0482678413391113,
-0.6862962245941162,
0.5794999003410339,
0.3020155727863312,
0.4866592586040497,
0.29259559512138367,
0.08002969622612,
0.9300472140312195,
-0.9245198369026184,
0.28157076239585876,
0.37612077593803406,
0.32697951793670654,
0.35933902859687805,
-0.01500773523002863,
0.1463702917098999,
0.3364499807357788,
-0.4499770998954773,
-0.8261337280273438,
0.4300488829612732,
-1.0713090896606445,
-0.159983828663826,
1.0192935466766357,
-0.17772801220417023,
-0.10748110711574554,
-0.20092174410820007,
-0.39191964268684387,
0.3929424583911896,
-0.43906527757644653,
0.3375914692878723,
0.5557388663291931,
-0.09271226078271866,
-0.025228317826986313,
-0.19948898255825043,
0.4320191442966461,
0.4413617253303528,
-1.0128520727157593,
0.17176392674446106,
0.6093124151229858,
0.2360006421804428,
0.08899155259132385,
0.9702573418617249,
0.0027292920276522636,
0.1871509701013565,
0.040313418954610825,
-0.07216090708971024,
-0.006293238140642643,
-0.6839572787284851,
-0.37359723448753357,
-0.06283951550722122,
-0.19050025939941406,
0.02642144076526165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05699v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05699v3 | Self-Alignment of Large Language Models via Monopolylogue-based Social Scene Simulation | 2024-02-08T14:21:03 | 2024-06-08T06:13:55 | Xianghe Pang, Shuo Tang, Rui Ye, Yuxin Xiong, Bolun Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values is imperative to
mitigate potential adverse effects resulting from their misuse. Drawing from
the sociological insight that acknowledging all parties' concerns is a key
factor in shaping human values, this paper proposes a novel direction to align
LLMs by themselves: social scene simulation. To achieve this, we present
MATRIX, a novel social scene simulator that emulates realistic scenes around a
user's input query, enabling the LLM to take social consequences into account
before responding. MATRIX serves as a virtual rehearsal space, akin to a
Monopolylogue, where the LLM performs diverse roles related to the query and
practice by itself. To inject this alignment, we fine-tune the LLM with
MATRIX-simulated data, ensuring adherence to human values without compromising
inference speed. We theoretically show that the LLM with MATRIX outperforms
Constitutional AI under mild assumptions. Finally, extensive experiments
validate that our method outperforms over 10 baselines across 4 benchmarks. As
evidenced by 875 user ratings, our tuned 13B-size LLM exceeds GPT-4 in aligning
with human values. See our project page at
https://shuotang123.github.io/MATRIX. | [
-0.21247321367263794,
-0.4466882646083832,
0.4951966106891632,
0.3069758415222168,
-0.14496585726737976,
0.3921901285648346,
-0.12924209237098694,
-0.2034144550561905,
0.5382411479949951,
0.6014370322227478,
-0.3731684982776642,
-0.33828839659690857,
-0.14621613919734955,
-0.274200439453125,
-0.28717294335365295,
0.7370105981826782,
0.2083723545074463,
0.17774946987628937,
-0.3400871753692627,
-0.09139057993888855,
-0.27342355251312256,
-0.5940278768539429,
-0.3119035065174103,
-0.3479519784450531,
0.7191024422645569,
0.4750248193740845,
0.8821290731430054,
1.0284724235534668,
0.2620053291320801,
0.39215654134750366,
0.15163086354732513,
0.23425360023975372,
-0.7342225909233093,
-0.08634254336357117,
-0.3560712933540344,
-0.08106862753629684,
-0.6659136414527893,
0.13516974449157715,
0.9451453685760498,
0.4872903823852539,
-0.41023293137550354,
0.5020164847373962,
0.39884278178215027,
0.6545817852020264,
-0.539315938949585,
-0.02704642154276371,
-0.5655089020729065,
0.016397545114159584,
-0.10294844210147858,
0.05087273195385933,
-0.33707934617996216,
-0.5033993124961853,
-0.18326899409294128,
-0.4443572163581848,
-0.22574186325073242,
0.25030985474586487,
1.0921822786331177,
0.23892268538475037,
-0.4985349774360657,
0.15898951888084412,
-0.798052191734314,
0.5606676340103149,
-0.5736960768699646,
-0.042934827506542206,
0.05901129171252251,
0.5374552607536316,
-0.3469405472278595,
-0.37492635846138,
-0.6792185306549072,
0.0387725792825222,
0.20196093618869781,
0.19158980250358582,
-0.08153560757637024,
0.05528263375163078,
0.0902392566204071,
0.021935774013400078,
-0.44535714387893677,
0.2111157923936844,
-0.5688578486442566,
-0.18841779232025146,
0.6863921880722046,
0.6477944254875183,
0.28265419602394104,
-0.35647115111351013,
-0.5155829787254333,
-0.07512152194976807,
-0.7780304551124573,
0.3147267699241638,
0.7504574656486511,
0.32017412781715393,
0.002126965904608369,
0.7388524413108826,
0.10303382575511932,
0.6386380195617676,
0.31631675362586975,
-0.057209935039281845,
0.07023479044437408,
-0.1681157946586609,
-0.13852594792842865,
0.35607534646987915,
0.8700010776519775,
0.7045220136642456,
0.5842910408973694,
0.16847024857997894,
0.030283495783805847,
0.16869887709617615,
0.6216052770614624,
-0.6421159505844116,
0.11366728693246841,
0.037993475794792175,
-0.3052062690258026,
-0.5221738815307617,
-0.3481146991252899,
-0.9007917046546936,
-0.6461670994758606,
-0.6652796864509583,
0.5528571009635925,
-0.11167018860578537,
-0.23879766464233398,
0.03996671363711357,
0.28020167350769043,
0.512065589427948,
0.5510842800140381,
-0.8400142788887024,
0.483462929725647,
0.6958105564117432,
0.7610124945640564,
-0.10021097958087921,
-0.44429001212120056,
-0.3514050245285034,
0.42012909054756165,
-0.5991992354393005,
0.763247549533844,
-0.4824032187461853,
-0.14731870591640472,
-0.126287579536438,
-0.2906567454338074,
0.021933505311608315,
-0.5215315818786621,
0.09646771103143692,
-0.27376770973205566,
-0.12682195007801056,
-0.3655211925506592,
-0.4195635914802551,
0.40874171257019043,
0.3438706398010254,
-0.6033452749252319,
0.8395693898200989,
-0.16163070499897003,
-0.6530361771583557,
0.14993557333946228,
-0.311190128326416,
-0.0708308070898056,
-0.21139231324195862,
-0.5936568379402161,
-0.39723336696624756,
-0.007549773436039686,
-0.092862568795681,
0.2821540832519531,
-0.1289752572774887,
0.5018201470375061,
-0.7539956569671631,
-0.512111485004425,
0.7256625294685364,
-0.2496625781059265,
0.6836407780647278,
0.22277089953422546,
-0.22051003575325012,
0.3340291678905487,
-0.5298389196395874,
0.005657725967466831,
-0.008676829747855663,
-0.1083361804485321,
0.0669001117348671,
0.16494590044021606,
-0.05272993817925453,
0.5635176301002502,
0.2628334164619446,
-0.44261136651039124,
0.2785743176937103,
-0.2756691873073578,
0.35845616459846497,
1.3119733333587646,
-0.4423949122428894,
0.6702103614807129,
-0.5132357478141785,
0.6947389841079712,
-0.16973929107189178,
0.15096063911914825,
0.39764437079429626,
-0.2433539479970932,
-0.5467975735664368,
-0.3797459304332733,
0.43025118112564087,
0.582343339920044,
-0.1566753089427948,
0.3033296763896942,
-0.4335172474384308,
-0.30919232964515686,
-0.9248634576797485,
0.19680717587471008,
0.2566617727279663,
0.2967509627342224,
0.044258441776037216,
-0.15450160205364227,
-0.7359315752983093,
-1.2752206325531006,
-0.2690415680408478,
-0.20830166339874268,
-0.01113023329526186,
0.540849506855011,
0.13956664502620697,
0.03356192633509636,
1.1763266324996948,
-0.4146556258201599,
-0.4527902603149414,
-0.24093613028526306,
-0.050219547003507614,
0.06280868500471115,
0.5077306628227234,
0.09741239994764328,
-0.19770801067352295,
-0.478350430727005,
0.011230865493416786,
-0.6027272343635559,
-0.28477445244789124,
-0.06994836777448654,
-0.3653881549835205,
0.014746399596333504,
0.5990110039710999,
-0.25568199157714844,
0.2625023424625397,
0.7412821054458618,
-0.1392829567193985,
0.5482056140899658,
-0.3621632158756256,
0.00765990698710084,
-1.5132664442062378,
0.12581364810466766,
-0.10138104110956192,
-0.4706597924232483,
-0.37946370244026184,
-0.34790855646133423,
0.10353034734725952,
-0.25415873527526855,
-0.34290874004364014,
0.5508174300193787,
-0.49485692381858826,
-0.39466890692710876,
-0.24205836653709412,
0.32470235228538513,
0.0024179485626518726,
0.3484887182712555,
-0.2896301746368408,
0.9389533996582031,
0.21945539116859436,
-0.10630679875612259,
0.08950909227132797,
0.028873933479189873,
-0.5742210745811462,
0.5103302597999573,
-0.46836310625076294,
0.16503781080245972,
-0.2396441549062729,
0.4054398238658905,
-1.1630408763885498,
-0.3315016031265259,
0.05265790596604347,
-0.319353312253952,
0.21427401900291443,
-0.3104008138179779,
-0.6037386655807495,
-0.05988886207342148,
-0.16310769319534302,
0.4809671938419342,
0.705960214138031,
-0.32694122195243835,
0.7843111753463745,
0.9924343824386597,
-0.04869934543967247,
-0.829955518245697,
-0.39499104022979736,
0.3721648156642914,
-0.4854052662849426,
-0.646806538105011,
0.19264823198318481,
-0.015970710664987564,
-0.2196115255355835,
-0.13839510083198547,
0.11356235295534134,
0.06187544763088226,
-0.07287920266389847,
0.3956766426563263,
0.4097837209701538,
-0.0834169089794159,
-0.11224140971899033,
0.09026120603084564,
0.024797463789582253,
0.06795922666788101,
-0.23755349218845367,
0.47495970129966736,
-0.3117440342903137,
-0.15378960967063904,
-0.3126102089881897,
0.22818027436733246,
0.5417056083679199,
-0.0008500143303535879,
0.46059298515319824,
0.2656514346599579,
-0.22922441363334656,
-0.13245944678783417,
-0.7330816984176636,
0.042630311101675034,
-0.5573660731315613,
0.10135705024003983,
-0.14914846420288086,
-0.9588526487350464,
0.7597041726112366,
-0.1047268658876419,
-0.2362121343612671,
-0.09909852594137192,
0.591975212097168,
-0.3285747170448303,
1.1899837255477905,
0.39979982376098633,
-0.16612789034843445,
0.4186110496520996,
-0.07648720592260361,
0.2707619071006775,
-1.0392603874206543,
-0.09509963542222977,
-0.4207550287246704,
-0.6507411003112793,
-0.48528656363487244,
-0.6946075558662415,
0.3126539885997772,
-0.06309667974710464,
-0.2953640818595886,
0.36740055680274963,
-0.21244646608829498,
0.6953971982002258,
0.12319865822792053,
0.06146201118826866,
0.09871137887239456,
-0.015265140682458878,
-0.4330272376537323,
-0.1621735692024231,
-0.6466783881187439,
-0.8141112327575684,
0.7826980948448181,
0.27712735533714294,
1.1298117637634277,
0.21226900815963745,
0.7648671865463257,
0.023310193791985512,
0.5561913847923279,
-0.4207991063594818,
0.7475488781929016,
0.016460934653878212,
-0.9867974519729614,
-0.39469996094703674,
-0.43692323565483093,
-0.9427058100700378,
0.42578819394111633,
-0.21474584937095642,
-1.005761742591858,
0.3833144009113312,
0.5458817481994629,
-0.5972925424575806,
0.1379915326833725,
-0.5010502338409424,
1.1361788511276245,
-0.12895676493644714,
-0.8459991812705994,
-0.3600963354110718,
-0.6218234300613403,
0.34357041120529175,
0.046845369040966034,
0.44276314973831177,
-0.5869104862213135,
0.05377998203039169,
0.196796715259552,
-0.1444152146577835,
1.2628681659698486,
0.10778488963842392,
-0.07037226855754852,
0.11599383503198624,
0.27843135595321655,
0.3260227143764496,
-0.07381703704595566,
-0.01144509855657816,
0.14085432887077332,
-0.09881232678890228,
-0.4694982171058655,
-0.5092730522155762,
0.8700125813484192,
-0.7973018288612366,
-0.8806053400039673,
-0.4299600124359131,
-0.5974652171134949,
0.02756688930094242,
0.00244730431586504,
-0.029697837308049202,
0.34944432973861694,
-0.6048814654350281,
0.07433326542377472,
0.2644254267215729,
-0.2307707667350769,
0.18029777705669403,
0.40545713901519775,
-0.5484916567802429,
-0.6355804204940796,
0.9469332098960876,
0.38988247513771057,
0.48665547370910645,
0.05591293424367905,
0.3057212829589844,
-0.3793509304523468,
-0.040926478803157806,
-0.6963496208190918,
0.1904863566160202,
-0.5048538446426392,
-0.27043160796165466,
-0.5621637105941772,
-0.2514529526233673,
-0.4503919184207916,
-0.42830485105514526,
-0.557068407535553,
-0.247589111328125,
-0.06739505380392075,
-0.12213533371686935,
-0.16297245025634766,
0.5794370174407959,
-0.3336905539035797,
0.056900665163993835,
-0.407297819852829,
0.0809774398803711,
0.5138171911239624,
0.4725968539714813,
-0.007150859106332064,
-0.5949983596801758,
-0.32057633996009827,
0.09591925889253616,
-0.23992326855659485,
-0.7237083911895752,
0.3929727375507355,
-0.021465567871928215,
0.36628594994544983,
0.4854311943054199,
0.12136168777942657,
1.2097342014312744,
-0.9935628175735474,
0.42178940773010254,
0.08699861913919449,
-1.1477857828140259,
0.21389657258987427,
-0.5020529627799988,
0.0955393835902214,
0.725950300693512,
-0.05967574194073677,
-0.5190509557723999,
-0.5475948452949524,
-0.350006639957428,
-0.6258129477500916,
0.6209713220596313,
0.20747335255146027,
0.45395976305007935,
-0.04581815376877785,
0.3268762528896332,
-0.39104393124580383,
0.05431831628084183,
-0.8977083563804626,
0.0561433807015419,
-0.2683187425136566,
-0.4215043783187866,
-0.06060171127319336,
-0.20904290676116943,
-0.23992426693439484,
-0.3273474872112274,
0.2883831560611725,
-0.1974310278892517,
0.09209611266851425,
0.1888120472431183,
-0.05633549019694328,
-0.43492671847343445,
0.19959260523319244,
0.8144827485084534,
0.8678621649742126,
-0.2815505564212799,
0.21849896013736725,
0.23357664048671722,
-0.09398848563432693,
0.48158809542655945,
-0.22244273126125336,
0.23080965876579285,
-0.47407442331314087,
-0.11409962177276611,
0.5170227289199829,
0.4572738707065582,
-0.6065595149993896,
0.6535439491271973,
-0.1075328066945076,
-0.13801395893096924,
-0.661456286907196,
0.0831327810883522,
0.45889079570770264,
0.442158043384552,
-0.04824148491024971,
-0.17952516674995422,
0.09819197654724121,
-0.6491599678993225,
0.12167248874902725,
0.6560091376304626,
-0.44667407870292664,
-0.2569628953933716,
0.7296423316001892,
0.13646987080574036,
-0.5890619158744812,
0.4153754711151123,
-0.1455642133951187,
-0.3265824019908905,
0.7219296097755432,
0.7538377642631531,
0.7601689100265503,
-0.5116189122200012,
0.24158792197704315,
0.30906668305397034,
0.38226670026779175,
-0.18644462525844574,
-0.020623179152607918,
0.16661971807479858,
-1.100937843322754,
-0.716151237487793,
-0.6973101496696472,
-0.48280617594718933,
-0.02412210963666439,
-0.6317184567451477,
0.29936450719833374,
-0.5665606260299683,
-0.11176036298274994,
0.01224652212113142,
-0.0591183677315712,
-0.16872887313365936,
-0.3149425685405731,
0.295012891292572,
0.5919824838638306,
-0.8641807436943054,
1.3481431007385254,
0.4276001453399658,
-0.05765962228178978,
-0.9785382151603699,
-0.08578462898731232,
0.30592185258865356,
-0.8697771430015564,
0.5971609950065613,
0.371462345123291,
-0.47765040397644043,
0.10242718458175659,
-0.5370769500732422,
-0.9353392124176025,
1.0723819732666016,
0.8329280018806458,
-0.6311241984367371,
-0.07033414393663406,
0.3127208948135376,
0.7079513669013977,
-0.7179951667785645,
-0.1349160075187683,
0.328549325466156,
0.3372615873813629,
0.1579267382621765,
-0.8596665263175964,
0.046805404126644135,
-0.26719343662261963,
0.07066455483436584,
0.18172132968902588,
-0.6983384490013123,
0.6289542317390442,
-0.21390405297279358,
-0.18771375715732574,
-0.019489383324980736,
0.47386160492897034,
0.3269302248954773,
0.186688631772995,
0.689216673374176,
0.5347223877906799,
0.47522324323654175,
0.3673222064971924,
0.7857512831687927,
-0.3759329617023468,
0.19530287384986877,
1.2586495876312256,
-0.8601171970367432,
0.6808420419692993,
0.3308182954788208,
0.014945218339562416,
0.5302110314369202,
0.5216530561447144,
0.04065403714776039,
0.2353460043668747,
0.5718624591827393,
-0.10498163849115372,
-0.5825369358062744,
0.005686876829713583,
-0.11424843966960907,
0.7025601267814636,
0.26814574003219604,
-0.13523884117603302,
-0.11286301165819168,
-0.4858703017234802,
0.02117510885000229,
0.3083501160144806,
-0.17499861121177673,
0.8960750102996826,
0.18883554637432098,
-0.6838138699531555,
0.42961007356643677,
-0.1779201328754425,
0.044926173985004425,
-0.39105284214019775,
-0.07265615463256836,
-0.235809788107872,
0.33925509452819824,
0.019748566672205925,
-0.6465206742286682,
0.21599963307380676,
-0.10778726637363434,
0.027919063344597816,
-0.33076241612434387,
0.4484676718711853,
-0.6541087031364441,
-0.4495159089565277,
0.45989879965782166,
0.14625947177410126,
0.15144164860248566,
0.1382107138633728,
-0.6932349801063538,
0.006143601145595312,
-0.08118116855621338,
0.10517774522304535,
0.730606198310852,
0.5108706951141357,
-0.07595384865999222,
0.58847576379776,
0.6005381345748901,
0.01911383680999279,
-0.15948772430419922,
-0.0438370518386364,
0.9668742418289185,
-0.7788079977035522,
-0.5654456615447998,
-1.0482609272003174,
0.5380189418792725,
-0.42810264229774475,
-0.2647692561149597,
0.5856522917747498,
0.6691756248474121,
0.5762898921966553,
0.2464669644832611,
0.23487205803394318,
0.4690278470516205,
0.17867504060268402,
-0.4238675534725189,
0.7832486033439636,
-0.4518938362598419,
0.28366997838020325,
-0.5369256734848022,
-0.8691153526306152,
-0.09087803214788437,
0.8471822142601013,
-0.2204795479774475,
-0.29309210181236267,
0.3093640208244324,
1.0924439430236816,
-0.10329383611679077,
-0.46992185711860657,
0.6499395370483398,
0.2689334750175476,
0.20641988515853882,
0.19641239941120148,
1.0877898931503296,
0.03854789212346077,
0.6745366454124451,
-0.025781340897083282,
-0.1604074388742447,
-0.3384907841682434,
-1.0202410221099854,
-0.9314946532249451,
-0.463101327419281,
0.03223034366965294,
-0.6017257571220398,
0.16218438744544983,
1.273821234703064,
0.7693634629249573,
-0.3625549376010895,
-1.0201700925827026,
0.2163122147321701,
0.11902853846549988,
-0.0031214153859764338,
-0.17422325909137726,
0.08018798381090164,
-0.27550625801086426,
-0.5171031951904297,
0.2408646047115326,
0.5668977499008179,
-0.051610421389341354,
-0.5432682633399963,
-0.027370981872081757,
-0.22965340316295624,
0.6452297568321228,
0.3827672004699707,
0.06395253539085388,
-0.7495929002761841,
-0.5079120397567749,
-0.028295323252677917,
-0.5618499517440796,
0.3334712088108063,
0.9165608286857605,
-0.5710711479187012,
0.4251399040222168,
0.14424310624599457,
0.47616469860076904,
0.4541158080101013,
0.3173092007637024,
0.9021145701408386,
-0.557205319404602,
-0.0711463987827301,
0.13767792284488678,
0.3269568979740143,
0.2650373578071594,
-0.4436267018318176,
0.1543266773223877,
-0.13164833188056946,
-0.8247026205062866,
-0.8670344948768616,
0.42694589495658875,
-1.059753179550171,
-0.18709473311901093,
1.02743661403656,
0.030585143715143204,
-0.5516538023948669,
-0.09922988712787628,
-0.274370014667511,
0.14983920753002167,
-0.4955231547355652,
1.2578619718551636,
0.6599711775779724,
0.17558814585208893,
-0.11364709585905075,
-0.4996941387653351,
0.4008607566356659,
0.373955100774765,
-0.6631370186805725,
0.3115520775318146,
0.681010365486145,
0.33197444677352905,
0.1147432029247284,
0.7733969688415527,
-0.196901336312294,
0.13249465823173523,
-0.30537670850753784,
0.3580312728881836,
0.11959677189588547,
-0.188380166888237,
-0.533157229423523,
0.09420762211084366,
-0.0009006629697978497,
0.06036879122257233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05672v1 | Multilingual E5 Text Embeddings: A Technical Report | 2024-02-08T13:47:50 | 2024-02-08T13:47:50 | Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Linjun Yang, Rangan Majumder, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This technical report presents the training methodology and evaluation
results of the open-source multilingual E5 text embedding models, released in
mid-2023. Three embedding models of different sizes (small / base / large) are
provided, offering a balance between the inference efficiency and embedding
quality. The training procedure adheres to the English E5 model recipe,
involving contrastive pre-training on 1 billion multilingual text pairs,
followed by fine-tuning on a combination of labeled datasets. Additionally, we
introduce a new instruction-tuned embedding model, whose performance is on par
with state-of-the-art, English-only models of similar sizes. Information
regarding the model release can be found at
https://github.com/microsoft/unilm/tree/master/e5 . | [
-0.3046562075614929,
-0.382513165473938,
0.28276410698890686,
0.316130667924881,
-0.20975176990032196,
-0.07194657623767853,
-0.2194145768880844,
-0.7588783502578735,
0.08246682584285736,
0.38872578740119934,
-0.3019942343235016,
-0.8805812001228333,
-0.4970899224281311,
0.36836642026901245,
-0.49680835008621216,
0.7422207593917847,
-0.24292996525764465,
0.3822343945503235,
-0.2610499858856201,
-0.2203025221824646,
-0.45304879546165466,
-0.6738143563270569,
-0.2530858814716339,
-0.07770741730928421,
0.7121570110321045,
0.5492072105407715,
0.29320916533470154,
0.8046087026596069,
0.623492956161499,
0.24019911885261536,
0.038329266011714935,
-0.05541716516017914,
-0.2611561119556427,
-0.11245687305927277,
0.23862046003341675,
-0.27215149998664856,
-0.6634593605995178,
0.32421135902404785,
0.5665779113769531,
0.5811536908149719,
-0.27326107025146484,
0.1172483041882515,
0.02974656969308853,
0.19754263758659363,
-0.696485161781311,
0.17147186398506165,
-0.207440584897995,
0.23032163083553314,
0.04782469570636749,
0.04153041914105415,
-0.9087942838668823,
-0.21056753396987915,
0.1465010792016983,
-0.5982661843299866,
0.21570703387260437,
0.17867441475391388,
0.7760312557220459,
-0.006095673888921738,
-0.5658052563667297,
-0.3713991343975067,
-0.388200968503952,
0.8391900062561035,
-0.5750707387924194,
0.8262370824813843,
0.4066353440284729,
0.35191160440444946,
0.47922664880752563,
-0.9794492721557617,
-0.19529424607753754,
-0.15951451659202576,
0.027361812070012093,
0.15682941675186157,
0.2719828486442566,
0.12816035747528076,
-0.09981606900691986,
0.2345169633626938,
-0.5389462113380432,
0.2586655616760254,
-0.42033323645591736,
0.0005951711209490895,
0.5280119776725769,
-0.15708766877651215,
0.1989225447177887,
0.4402197301387787,
-0.22092513740062714,
0.07967980206012726,
-0.7660151720046997,
-0.5710793733596802,
0.4082462191581726,
0.2221321314573288,
-0.46315476298332214,
0.350416898727417,
0.12497811764478683,
0.7461111545562744,
-0.20705349743366241,
-0.16247762739658356,
0.5856436491012573,
-0.5283063650131226,
-0.1701096147298813,
0.19557125866413116,
0.3939862549304962,
0.4079573452472687,
0.21356602013111115,
-0.3107486069202423,
-0.3345487415790558,
-0.2225656807422638,
0.24535876512527466,
-1.0101993083953857,
-0.36702409386634827,
0.1705014705657959,
-0.647019624710083,
-0.41141098737716675,
0.16042913496494293,
-0.4174096882343292,
-0.14412446320056915,
-0.1340162307024002,
0.4008547067642212,
-0.5141514539718628,
-0.3296320140361786,
0.23331843316555023,
-0.22394530475139618,
0.13064289093017578,
0.3057996332645416,
-0.9246979355812073,
0.1120300367474556,
0.31202471256256104,
0.7595256567001343,
0.12328506261110306,
-0.5510059595108032,
-0.3235769271850586,
0.39417219161987305,
-0.12635119259357452,
0.7346519231796265,
-0.8794532418251038,
-0.32387661933898926,
0.23165997862815857,
0.2263481169939041,
0.11062254756689072,
-0.2045140564441681,
0.7292834520339966,
-0.5495229363441467,
0.34543681144714355,
-0.13610947132110596,
-0.5956111550331116,
-0.3445377051830292,
0.2501632869243622,
-0.8583036065101624,
0.8330007791519165,
-0.135494202375412,
-0.7344909906387329,
0.46371451020240784,
-0.9125704169273376,
-0.045145537704229355,
-0.17007747292518616,
0.1678386926651001,
-0.5145218968391418,
-0.009087814949452877,
0.1526098996400833,
0.42179563641548157,
-0.3571643531322479,
-0.16510674357414246,
-0.4328121840953827,
-0.32763758301734924,
-0.18129220604896545,
-0.25824931263923645,
0.47074124217033386,
0.39758485555648804,
0.05386895686388016,
0.2286621630191803,
-0.7865650653839111,
0.10887163132429123,
0.15582787990570068,
-0.23897987604141235,
-0.09720765054225922,
-0.016555199399590492,
0.38967522978782654,
0.2099587768316269,
0.4500591456890106,
-0.7737892270088196,
0.022043457254767418,
-0.2272767424583435,
0.6546630263328552,
0.5070469379425049,
-0.2781856060028076,
0.33372044563293457,
-0.09701160341501236,
0.45418116450309753,
0.46023645997047424,
0.13361051678657532,
-0.7227177619934082,
-0.3523326814174652,
-0.6232685446739197,
-0.3577345311641693,
0.9956334829330444,
0.3927907347679138,
-0.4869806468486786,
0.20877419412136078,
-0.16167467832565308,
-0.3978959023952484,
-0.82844078540802,
-0.13200128078460693,
0.5054758787155151,
-0.04663459584116936,
0.4123031198978424,
-0.059108953922986984,
-0.5335608124732971,
-0.9588226079940796,
-0.31393393874168396,
0.39198628067970276,
0.30212804675102234,
-0.15039847791194916,
0.7434708476066589,
-0.1325322687625885,
0.5475895404815674,
-0.2553901672363281,
0.08717220276594162,
-0.21878059208393097,
0.35690826177597046,
-0.2127489596605301,
0.5222233533859253,
0.6893051862716675,
-0.7092693448066711,
-0.8277418613433838,
0.071056067943573,
-0.7227441072463989,
0.06664196401834488,
0.3776681423187256,
0.2880522906780243,
0.4602760076522827,
0.6412454843521118,
-0.01509801670908928,
0.21388743817806244,
0.9046499133110046,
-0.2730885446071625,
0.20909376442432404,
-0.5268775224685669,
0.1301679164171219,
-1.2542632818222046,
-0.052038971334695816,
0.142041876912117,
-0.4085427224636078,
-0.28481897711753845,
0.2838675081729889,
0.4820205271244049,
-0.2589554488658905,
-0.6196081638336182,
0.2892886698246002,
-1.028790831565857,
-0.07430993020534515,
0.11824937164783478,
0.31423619389533997,
0.09780193865299225,
0.07565633952617645,
-0.07840829342603683,
0.6722922325134277,
0.2612179219722748,
-0.5295891165733337,
0.2574099898338318,
0.02334710769355297,
-0.27820760011672974,
0.518110990524292,
-0.833970308303833,
0.4855024814605713,
-0.11720026284456253,
0.15825790166854858,
-0.6958976984024048,
-0.1830717772245407,
-0.07640111446380615,
-0.41343560814857483,
0.48389971256256104,
-0.10519532114267349,
-0.6468951106071472,
-0.2916719913482666,
-0.5364691615104675,
0.2850944697856903,
0.17386162281036377,
-0.5274355411529541,
0.38852575421333313,
0.5065895318984985,
-0.1350940763950348,
-0.41889870166778564,
-0.8860806226730347,
0.01439644768834114,
0.017054427415132523,
-0.5677486062049866,
0.642848789691925,
-0.18191510438919067,
0.11765137314796448,
0.2199503481388092,
0.38317903876304626,
-0.35014843940734863,
0.148118257522583,
-0.16249240934848785,
-0.12114270031452179,
-0.2504596710205078,
0.16567367315292358,
0.07920598983764648,
-0.21027475595474243,
-0.14987944066524506,
-0.3084520101547241,
0.29124653339385986,
-0.2038467824459076,
-0.48596328496932983,
-0.35549435019493103,
0.6201227903366089,
0.35621199011802673,
-0.634849488735199,
1.1237305402755737,
0.7329273223876953,
-0.45239704847335815,
-0.11566806584596634,
-0.3022078275680542,
-0.11515789479017258,
-0.4383712708950043,
0.6622843146324158,
-0.6617828607559204,
-0.7594674825668335,
0.21431691944599152,
-0.13656644523143768,
0.4150301218032837,
0.4517037868499756,
0.41039150953292847,
-0.051154572516679764,
1.5238620042800903,
0.9603433609008789,
0.4279458820819855,
0.33091557025909424,
-0.05439355969429016,
0.2861473858356476,
-0.45216941833496094,
-0.529019832611084,
-0.884006679058075,
-0.19619594514369965,
-0.7637820243835449,
-0.26572397351264954,
0.3258146643638611,
0.1113593727350235,
-0.2798835337162018,
0.036440055817365646,
-0.3886621594429016,
0.6577411890029907,
0.44500696659088135,
-0.10794004797935486,
0.23889166116714478,
0.0702051892876625,
-0.5483349561691284,
-0.19503971934318542,
-0.7372033596038818,
-0.7272549867630005,
1.244815468788147,
0.5297147035598755,
0.43817758560180664,
0.24550381302833557,
0.7233774662017822,
0.1934410184621811,
0.3352976441383362,
-0.5203142762184143,
0.11417309194803238,
-0.31945815682411194,
-0.43153464794158936,
-0.11791836470365524,
-0.1343809962272644,
-0.8715574145317078,
0.13912343978881836,
-0.1292896419763565,
-0.35966992378234863,
-0.330740749835968,
0.10631625354290009,
0.01279022078961134,
0.22666436433792114,
-1.204067349433899,
1.0696061849594116,
-0.1048036739230156,
-0.03973579406738281,
-0.4114179015159607,
-0.5637258887290955,
0.01760966330766678,
0.019854312762618065,
0.29552820324897766,
0.16533197462558746,
-0.2479199916124344,
0.7249871492385864,
-0.10250229388475418,
0.8961413502693176,
-0.32427865266799927,
-0.0837269052863121,
0.007374749053269625,
-0.30281081795692444,
0.47838717699050903,
-0.37966087460517883,
-0.18042108416557312,
0.20488221943378448,
0.3188622295856476,
-0.6353172063827515,
-0.36332643032073975,
0.6598763465881348,
-0.9007295966148376,
-0.1885925978422165,
-0.3506224751472473,
-0.2938644587993622,
-0.19422338902950287,
0.24904678761959076,
0.2032524049282074,
0.5480613708496094,
-0.6633458733558655,
0.5495336055755615,
0.5945219993591309,
-0.4810240864753723,
0.7394956350326538,
0.6904444694519043,
-0.4271990656852722,
-0.6174946427345276,
1.0704196691513062,
0.4339994192123413,
0.13059265911579132,
0.5103253126144409,
-0.10267982631921768,
-0.2715017795562744,
-0.5878236293792725,
-0.39930522441864014,
0.25987717509269714,
-0.6814195513725281,
0.032884564250707626,
-0.5852338075637817,
-0.22697767615318298,
-0.5301626920700073,
-0.0713760033249855,
-0.5062710642814636,
-0.301458477973938,
-0.24118483066558838,
-0.3284774422645569,
0.18478600680828094,
1.4825021028518677,
0.08272680640220642,
0.30947059392929077,
-1.0073189735412598,
-0.10889847576618195,
-0.20003949105739594,
0.5719627737998962,
-0.2218685895204544,
-0.4653932750225067,
-1.080032229423523,
0.16430671513080597,
-0.6701117157936096,
-0.8513096570968628,
0.4192231595516205,
0.30182868242263794,
0.6154665946960449,
0.1324813961982727,
-0.24883344769477844,
0.24462443590164185,
-0.6378220915794373,
0.8877777457237244,
0.34168022871017456,
-0.986088752746582,
0.4765665829181671,
-0.318938285112381,
0.35772716999053955,
0.1712164729833603,
0.6283113360404968,
-0.434477835893631,
-0.0037646694108843803,
-0.5598552227020264,
-0.6785852909088135,
0.7005442380905151,
-0.31192368268966675,
0.08550435304641724,
-0.0804375484585762,
-0.018893469125032425,
0.36413466930389404,
0.33939892053604126,
-0.562116801738739,
-0.3227786719799042,
-0.31320756673812866,
-0.4391937255859375,
-0.1839875876903534,
-0.6434537768363953,
0.0966755747795105,
-0.25667181611061096,
0.5691742300987244,
-0.07699676603078842,
0.6023988723754883,
-0.042120423167943954,
-0.4415041208267212,
0.1698935478925705,
0.22071658074855804,
0.8654210567474365,
0.7278630137443542,
-0.1598615199327469,
0.06641177088022232,
0.13225732743740082,
-0.5274934768676758,
0.04627468064427376,
0.035231247544288635,
0.08033324778079987,
0.07026592642068863,
0.43211856484413147,
0.8193026185035706,
0.47495037317276,
-0.15587027370929718,
0.487555593252182,
-0.06593193858861923,
-0.45059317350387573,
-0.28442081809043884,
-0.4199994206428528,
0.2577723562717438,
-0.06333627551794052,
0.032889142632484436,
-0.28055331110954285,
0.05365600064396858,
-0.412064790725708,
0.14162248373031616,
-0.01401651743799448,
-0.4265719950199127,
-0.6939187049865723,
0.557708203792572,
0.7132218480110168,
-0.26189738512039185,
0.6149472594261169,
-0.05454716831445694,
-0.4006302058696747,
0.45936301350593567,
0.7983523607254028,
0.855187714099884,
-0.48717719316482544,
0.34360596537590027,
0.31003522872924805,
0.628069281578064,
0.15773996710777283,
0.6667757630348206,
0.42383161187171936,
-0.591673731803894,
-0.4188934564590454,
-0.36365509033203125,
-0.45797327160835266,
-0.117819644510746,
-0.635957658290863,
0.48512399196624756,
-0.21551725268363953,
-0.0883089229464531,
-0.07645200192928314,
0.02899172343313694,
-0.8863027095794678,
0.23424188792705536,
0.07627429068088531,
1.2609144449234009,
-0.7200400233268738,
0.9857138395309448,
0.9995394945144653,
-0.5135179758071899,
-0.6212700009346008,
-0.10472261905670166,
-0.08135250955820084,
-0.5870588421821594,
0.5608817934989929,
0.37938112020492554,
-0.154476597905159,
0.36746102571487427,
-0.5945754051208496,
-0.7747781872749329,
1.2185138463974,
0.7329145669937134,
-0.6610589027404785,
-0.006939253304153681,
0.061645038425922394,
0.2631431519985199,
-0.6298640370368958,
0.6303305625915527,
0.3058154284954071,
0.6427084803581238,
-0.2438984364271164,
-1.1279151439666748,
-0.304874449968338,
-0.3421769142150879,
-0.08111587911844254,
0.17339329421520233,
-0.7874217629432678,
0.6787011027336121,
-0.19329914450645447,
-0.007187388371676207,
-0.071010522544384,
0.7435246706008911,
0.020025111734867096,
0.039173077791929245,
0.1811419129371643,
0.7949948906898499,
0.8803638815879822,
-0.1857299953699112,
1.3020485639572144,
-0.873508095741272,
0.294450044631958,
1.0014830827713013,
-0.2405748963356018,
1.0423519611358643,
0.31994906067848206,
0.034542858600616455,
0.48490068316459656,
0.7814502120018005,
0.1534619927406311,
0.6660763621330261,
-0.140035480260849,
-0.10475686937570572,
-0.06684281677007675,
-0.32190608978271484,
-0.7404144406318665,
0.37071263790130615,
0.17753936350345612,
-0.7418097853660583,
-0.1105053722858429,
-0.08906252682209015,
0.06092324107885361,
-0.2522946298122406,
-0.1510426253080368,
0.7159326076507568,
0.11989600211381912,
-0.3842085897922516,
0.5193954110145569,
0.6304288506507874,
0.5082514882087708,
-0.37559014558792114,
-0.23276154696941376,
0.09179044514894485,
0.20168064534664154,
-0.08040179312229156,
-0.6315872669219971,
0.19847290217876434,
-0.08038682490587234,
-0.27470389008522034,
-0.5152134299278259,
0.3096234202384949,
-0.6347625255584717,
-0.46993300318717957,
0.4649343490600586,
0.4416140913963318,
0.14210690557956696,
0.2911525070667267,
-0.6203739643096924,
0.18420767784118652,
-0.14450529217720032,
-0.28210440278053284,
0.3361756503582001,
0.6842811107635498,
0.09438841044902802,
0.39960718154907227,
0.23136061429977417,
-0.10959655046463013,
0.11750621348619461,
0.44771963357925415,
0.5773401856422424,
-0.7705296277999878,
-0.5708752274513245,
-0.583846926689148,
0.7611446976661682,
-0.08494453877210617,
-0.3989834189414978,
0.7090414762496948,
0.6434532403945923,
0.8665971159934998,
-0.25028926134109497,
0.8705887198448181,
0.3942120671272278,
0.40036365389823914,
-0.679853081703186,
0.5932345390319824,
-0.6056718230247498,
0.06944949179887772,
-0.028521545231342316,
-0.7952788472175598,
-0.19582238793373108,
0.38393649458885193,
-0.17077890038490295,
0.42216217517852783,
1.1742936372756958,
0.5912973880767822,
-0.12564608454704285,
0.3142285943031311,
0.5295450687408447,
0.36335235834121704,
0.11791381239891052,
0.30044326186180115,
0.5572870969772339,
-0.45015597343444824,
0.3887348771095276,
-0.15308928489685059,
-0.04382651299238205,
-0.23545826971530914,
-1.0940591096878052,
-0.8121523261070251,
-0.6122227311134338,
-0.2899416387081146,
0.04695058986544609,
0.2527928054332733,
0.8879373669624329,
0.8230294585227966,
-0.8343714475631714,
-0.12728862464427948,
0.011251883581280708,
-0.14099812507629395,
0.014004007913172245,
-0.10987526178359985,
0.06826658546924591,
-0.40277618169784546,
-0.8206536769866943,
0.3886357545852661,
0.22229495644569397,
0.12966737151145935,
-0.49506884813308716,
-0.23343710601329803,
-0.299861878156662,
0.07378432154655457,
0.7014113664627075,
-0.28913986682891846,
-0.5120598673820496,
-0.3645651340484619,
0.06967378407716751,
-0.17827466130256653,
0.006538026034832001,
0.6319936513900757,
-0.2818985879421234,
0.4097474217414856,
0.3541695475578308,
0.3927202820777893,
0.4715786278247833,
-0.5770590901374817,
1.0028340816497803,
-0.9681496620178223,
0.2554152011871338,
-0.020149018615484238,
0.4125703275203705,
0.4266878366470337,
0.07488895207643509,
0.5151311159133911,
0.15463657677173615,
-0.45894014835357666,
-0.8922186493873596,
-0.0036458915565162897,
-0.42332738637924194,
-0.19663003087043762,
0.7745203375816345,
-0.4899344742298126,
-0.0427132286131382,
-0.030947305262088776,
0.008075907826423645,
0.2827298045158386,
-0.3206048011779785,
0.28531771898269653,
1.027793526649475,
0.4372085630893707,
-0.4045114517211914,
-0.6859694719314575,
0.25732144713401794,
0.2520831525325775,
-0.8296311497688293,
-0.362382709980011,
0.4159115254878998,
0.18819375336170197,
-0.042364925146102905,
0.1884949505329132,
-0.2112807035446167,
0.1877741813659668,
0.26545450091362,
0.4797728657722473,
-0.31521669030189514,
-0.8200716376304626,
-0.3113038241863251,
0.38559579849243164,
0.32112476229667664,
-0.27657824754714966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05668v1 | Comprehensive Assessment of Jailbreak Attacks Against LLMs | 2024-02-08T13:42:50 | 2024-02-08T13:42:50 | Junjie Chu, Yugeng Liu, Ziqing Yang, Xinyue Shen, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Misuse of the Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised widespread concern. To
address this issue, safeguards have been taken to ensure that LLMs align with
social ethics. However, recent findings have revealed an unsettling
vulnerability bypassing the safeguards of LLMs, known as jailbreak attacks. By
applying techniques, such as employing role-playing scenarios, adversarial
examples, or subtle subversion of safety objectives as a prompt, LLMs can
produce an inappropriate or even harmful response. While researchers have
studied several categories of jailbreak attacks, they have done so in
isolation. To fill this gap, we present the first large-scale measurement of
various jailbreak attack methods. We concentrate on 13 cutting-edge jailbreak
methods from four categories, 160 questions from 16 violation categories, and
six popular LLMs. Our extensive experimental results demonstrate that the
optimized jailbreak prompts consistently achieve the highest attack success
rates, as well as exhibit robustness across different LLMs. Some jailbreak
prompt datasets, available from the Internet, can also achieve high attack
success rates on many LLMs, such as ChatGLM3, GPT-3.5, and PaLM2. Despite the
claims from many organizations regarding the coverage of violation categories
in their policies, the attack success rates from these categories remain high,
indicating the challenges of effectively aligning LLM policies and the ability
to counter jailbreak attacks. We also discuss the trade-off between the attack
performance and efficiency, as well as show that the transferability of the
jailbreak prompts is still viable, becoming an option for black-box models.
Overall, our research highlights the necessity of evaluating different
jailbreak methods. We hope our study can provide insights for future research
on jailbreak attacks and serve as a benchmark tool for evaluating them for
practitioners. | [
-0.4107342064380646,
-0.9906545281410217,
0.567333996295929,
0.26591575145721436,
-0.16217011213302612,
0.48451393842697144,
-0.13909918069839478,
-0.5045952796936035,
0.38783907890319824,
0.5660165548324585,
-0.37441304326057434,
-0.3110916018486023,
-0.6586407423019409,
0.2210892140865326,
-0.4874708652496338,
0.7335197329521179,
-0.002392957452684641,
-0.015973413363099098,
0.11970909684896469,
-0.0628204271197319,
-0.6711885929107666,
-0.6524586081504822,
-0.3771391212940216,
0.07960519194602966,
0.4797894060611725,
0.2455350011587143,
0.46815481781959534,
0.24160678684711456,
0.7006723284721375,
0.23879782855510712,
-0.40010732412338257,
-0.05077975615859032,
-0.40278568863868713,
0.07352961599826813,
-0.11871103197336197,
-0.37809938192367554,
-0.4317837059497833,
0.07175848633050919,
0.28398653864860535,
0.24815140664577484,
-0.1361047923564911,
0.14454223215579987,
-0.07815658301115036,
0.7474300265312195,
-0.8445587754249573,
-0.5485886335372925,
-0.8731417655944824,
0.059261441230773926,
-0.4276096224784851,
0.11452020704746246,
-0.5821160674095154,
-0.462644100189209,
-0.27253976464271545,
0.14629556238651276,
-0.2813745141029358,
-0.014752986840903759,
0.41614800691604614,
-0.06529084593057632,
-0.34239324927330017,
-0.42249637842178345,
-0.3147208094596863,
0.621351957321167,
-0.8725541234016418,
-0.027743441984057426,
0.4049331247806549,
0.2764509916305542,
-0.3730483651161194,
-0.26426422595977783,
-0.19346436858177185,
-0.62591552734375,
0.15114834904670715,
-0.08417242020368576,
-0.5068650841712952,
0.055651869624853134,
0.4802931249141693,
0.1845708191394806,
-0.34926509857177734,
0.47197145223617554,
-0.51792973279953,
-0.21525469422340393,
0.7040526866912842,
0.34302228689193726,
0.44622042775154114,
-0.3351045250892639,
-0.5477667450904846,
0.11111561954021454,
-1.0912193059921265,
0.12918002903461456,
0.5715280175209045,
-0.024399656802415848,
-0.25759151577949524,
0.665644645690918,
0.139211505651474,
0.8020592927932739,
-0.1654294729232788,
-0.1626853346824646,
-0.12216215580701828,
-0.456428200006485,
-0.14184845983982086,
0.06731226295232773,
0.9791222214698792,
0.5676463842391968,
0.3321439027786255,
-0.3523656725883484,
-0.16000030934810638,
-0.155030757188797,
0.4808618724346161,
-0.8276710510253906,
0.17800463736057281,
0.3458766043186188,
-0.13558049499988556,
-0.7335472106933594,
0.06022658571600914,
-0.8094147443771362,
-1.008110761642456,
0.4534880220890045,
0.07503242790699005,
-0.17318685352802277,
-0.015433997847139835,
0.008754863403737545,
-0.0353006049990654,
0.5334264039993286,
0.17660266160964966,
-0.6948038339614868,
0.3417222201824188,
0.6400101184844971,
0.9830541014671326,
-0.243294358253479,
-0.09655889868736267,
-0.553401529788971,
-0.0278064776211977,
-0.3502987325191498,
0.49113649129867554,
-0.12154901772737503,
-0.5993950963020325,
-0.09964702278375626,
-0.19256995618343353,
-0.04763050377368927,
-0.47815993428230286,
0.3560565412044525,
-0.5372278690338135,
-0.5599038600921631,
-0.17132927477359772,
-0.5539795160293579,
0.03156270831823349,
0.6277629137039185,
-0.6919177174568176,
0.49268296360969543,
-0.09266939014196396,
-0.8148100972175598,
0.08206065744161606,
-0.46050840616226196,
-0.42385539412498474,
-0.23119837045669556,
0.10520046204328537,
-0.3812578618526459,
0.30439478158950806,
0.15413512289524078,
0.44195061922073364,
-0.388039767742157,
0.32733821868896484,
-0.5890718102455139,
-0.46542689204216003,
0.6342723369598389,
-0.4092135727405548,
0.8415565490722656,
0.27458199858665466,
-0.5836371183395386,
-0.05975621938705444,
-0.4889884293079376,
-0.135101780295372,
0.44053909182548523,
-0.06658904254436493,
-0.36555948853492737,
0.1508372575044632,
-0.19198079407215118,
-0.02446257509291172,
0.24591058492660522,
-0.7425837516784668,
0.3321537673473358,
-0.2979579269886017,
0.7777056694030762,
0.8465206027030945,
0.14202666282653809,
0.07875894755125046,
-0.04199624061584473,
0.5628227591514587,
-0.3289691209793091,
0.44893965125083923,
-0.05926842615008354,
-0.15131540596485138,
-0.09859631210565567,
-0.1891651600599289,
0.13240572810173035,
0.8045478463172913,
-0.06842495501041412,
0.39575982093811035,
0.08387234061956406,
-0.8272165060043335,
-0.2416936606168747,
0.30286404490470886,
0.4975578486919403,
0.21700051426887512,
0.2846520245075226,
-0.3534049689769745,
-0.302748441696167,
-0.7154538035392761,
-0.6668007373809814,
-0.22104915976524353,
0.30790314078330994,
0.2964830994606018,
0.409830778837204,
-0.1950218677520752,
0.6050817966461182,
-0.2786828577518463,
0.05695043504238129,
-0.4081350266933441,
-0.25706303119659424,
0.09341950714588165,
0.3325861692428589,
0.6682551503181458,
-0.30554813146591187,
-0.21373766660690308,
-0.35978758335113525,
-0.7559826374053955,
-0.193787083029747,
0.032255224883556366,
0.2597171366214752,
0.026376334950327873,
0.6700544953346252,
-0.5003769397735596,
0.39010000228881836,
0.5059664249420166,
-0.5154117941856384,
0.7730827927589417,
0.09825272858142853,
0.21169619262218475,
-0.7752688527107239,
-0.13437043130397797,
0.03425247594714165,
-0.053766343742609024,
-0.7622898817062378,
0.34923797845840454,
0.22386157512664795,
0.09799578785896301,
-0.8106246590614319,
0.4145641624927521,
-0.3778274655342102,
-0.33531835675239563,
-0.21747387945652008,
0.3120657503604889,
-0.1395222544670105,
-0.20012271404266357,
-0.5834141969680786,
0.890500545501709,
0.29825785756111145,
-0.06500536948442459,
0.5100722312927246,
-0.0060298144817352295,
-0.4065011739730835,
0.3917129337787628,
-0.9187329411506653,
0.5074806213378906,
0.12535671889781952,
0.16328825056552887,
-1.0890198945999146,
-0.07451438158750534,
0.17200957238674164,
-0.3287447690963745,
0.19492414593696594,
-0.255896657705307,
-0.5865998864173889,
-0.2610119581222534,
-0.7716224193572998,
0.05265599489212036,
0.3933395445346832,
-0.44200658798217773,
0.1891012340784073,
0.36649006605148315,
-0.08571924269199371,
-0.8222649693489075,
-0.5163490176200867,
0.615568220615387,
-0.7175920009613037,
-0.7426281571388245,
-0.045553985983133316,
0.051993224769830704,
-0.6431356072425842,
-0.49449142813682556,
-0.257258802652359,
0.2342897206544876,
0.8005739450454712,
0.2530123293399811,
0.5349358320236206,
0.2352779060602188,
-0.6225454211235046,
-0.18682502210140228,
0.2707749307155609,
0.5137540698051453,
0.1261795610189438,
0.6681489944458008,
-0.1258474886417389,
-0.3801543414592743,
-0.2802092134952545,
0.05553468316793442,
0.7611441016197205,
-0.28588879108428955,
0.7080934643745422,
0.2427196055650711,
-0.0830957442522049,
0.15481631457805634,
-0.797464907169342,
-0.07479317486286163,
-0.4546164572238922,
0.34970009326934814,
-0.1916245073080063,
-1.0429508686065674,
0.5306999683380127,
-0.17771843075752258,
0.2374197244644165,
-0.12264861166477203,
0.3359367549419403,
-0.06396171450614929,
0.7571530938148499,
0.3788045644760132,
-0.5062254071235657,
0.46473756432533264,
0.05788550525903702,
0.2686668634414673,
-0.8569912910461426,
-0.19428284466266632,
-0.6053115129470825,
-0.13773252069950104,
-0.5892958045005798,
-0.18833261728286743,
0.1674584448337555,
0.4643309712409973,
-0.32459402084350586,
0.5048310160636902,
-0.1869214028120041,
0.500069260597229,
-0.03939421474933624,
0.116871178150177,
0.2882218062877655,
-0.18682079017162323,
0.018680762499570847,
0.10604970157146454,
-0.23746371269226074,
-0.5440171957015991,
1.283132791519165,
0.5758276581764221,
1.034346342086792,
0.22564847767353058,
0.8831962943077087,
0.4307139813899994,
0.43191367387771606,
-0.7202306389808655,
0.656938910484314,
-0.03728308528661728,
-0.5270276069641113,
-0.09738067537546158,
-0.32891878485679626,
-0.8486194014549255,
0.22717389464378357,
0.037552960216999054,
-1.2397263050079346,
-0.11681737750768661,
0.02897564135491848,
-0.32987144589424133,
0.42509591579437256,
-0.6946749091148376,
0.7875467538833618,
-0.5671996474266052,
-0.4407486915588379,
-0.15419718623161316,
-0.756973922252655,
0.7241004705429077,
-0.37337902188301086,
0.517100989818573,
-0.2521072030067444,
0.12149537354707718,
0.7454991936683655,
-0.5017211437225342,
0.9780129790306091,
-0.3864568769931793,
-0.09791115671396255,
0.22647598385810852,
0.26861006021499634,
0.7416731715202332,
0.21201561391353607,
0.1135113313794136,
0.1124543696641922,
-0.08838192373514175,
-0.32607561349868774,
-0.35542336106300354,
0.6918643116950989,
-0.6581860184669495,
-0.8170334696769714,
-0.3014586567878723,
-0.36525601148605347,
-0.372710257768631,
-0.005928924772888422,
0.08693720400333405,
0.16991648077964783,
-0.23616179823875427,
0.02881665527820587,
0.7186729907989502,
-0.4454089403152466,
0.4043479263782501,
0.47560757398605347,
-0.31402701139450073,
-0.4997243881225586,
0.5021607279777527,
-0.036728572100400925,
0.5373411178588867,
-0.05053126811981201,
0.20466701686382294,
-0.15173311531543732,
-0.8181870579719543,
-0.41628021001815796,
0.15774326026439667,
-0.40828847885131836,
-0.40795913338661194,
-0.3691723048686981,
-0.2861572504043579,
-0.287466436624527,
-0.4089491367340088,
-0.2911987602710724,
-0.11682657897472382,
0.21740993857383728,
-0.44294023513793945,
0.47909730672836304,
0.6596386432647705,
0.09034937620162964,
0.3384610414505005,
-0.7739130854606628,
0.2450316995382309,
0.06912767142057419,
-0.07794128358364105,
-0.045787326991558075,
-0.40332475304603577,
0.10067661106586456,
-0.28647878766059875,
-0.2662542760372162,
-1.27726411819458,
0.1257844716310501,
-0.24186024069786072,
0.41867589950561523,
0.30475324392318726,
0.0710873156785965,
0.6205912828445435,
-0.5225135684013367,
0.7390122413635254,
0.45376166701316833,
-0.9918076992034912,
0.819942831993103,
-0.18903052806854248,
-0.22456640005111694,
0.7473515272140503,
0.1504787653684616,
-0.38056525588035583,
-0.6283808946609497,
-0.5255363583564758,
-0.9578182101249695,
0.3361983895301819,
0.010537966154515743,
0.29916414618492126,
-0.013695911504328251,
0.42060521245002747,
-0.14947231113910675,
0.1485334038734436,
-0.691697359085083,
-0.38908448815345764,
0.11698418110609055,
0.1489723026752472,
0.041098084300756454,
-0.27163130044937134,
-0.23617872595787048,
-0.07934751361608505,
0.11012158542871475,
0.3685375452041626,
-0.08489320427179337,
0.045998312532901764,
-0.34515106678009033,
0.21403510868549347,
0.6651390790939331,
0.5790166258811951,
0.5806205868721008,
-0.26264503598213196,
0.04872306063771248,
0.2573712468147278,
-0.8991284370422363,
0.5910175442695618,
0.005826251115649939,
-0.2512381672859192,
-0.3195045292377472,
0.2929284870624542,
0.5361514091491699,
0.06307400017976761,
-0.9647161960601807,
0.6378929615020752,
0.0014996303943917155,
-0.024888135492801666,
-0.3671601414680481,
0.17369335889816284,
-0.07645765691995621,
0.31269457936286926,
0.076603002846241,
-0.10280334204435349,
0.006729290820658207,
-0.5635062456130981,
0.07886695116758347,
0.7540947794914246,
-0.3872561752796173,
-0.11190993338823318,
0.4833563268184662,
-0.003142482601106167,
-0.2284127026796341,
0.6372344493865967,
-0.07083205133676529,
-0.3999069035053253,
0.7979678511619568,
0.709528923034668,
0.8381352424621582,
-0.23680394887924194,
0.07085152715444565,
0.09230631589889526,
0.9719775319099426,
0.029732035472989082,
0.12603650987148285,
0.10462946444749832,
-0.6605713963508606,
-0.5070756673812866,
-0.39294084906578064,
-0.6033055782318115,
0.292127788066864,
-0.7801594138145447,
0.008256470784544945,
-0.8629387021064758,
-0.2868012487888336,
-0.22191424667835236,
0.029725905507802963,
-0.1921824961900711,
-0.25290560722351074,
0.22757314145565033,
1.4121731519699097,
-0.7329115271568298,
0.6236043572425842,
0.6315537095069885,
-0.03930186480283737,
-0.6794513463973999,
-0.07154913246631622,
0.32777562737464905,
-0.8591193556785583,
0.40880686044692993,
0.38132479786872864,
-0.06802748143672943,
-0.3698279857635498,
-0.8171816468238831,
-0.5193247199058533,
0.9636180996894836,
0.33283281326293945,
-0.8235872983932495,
0.08484160155057907,
0.11737518012523651,
0.0769120529294014,
-0.05230649560689926,
0.058186426758766174,
1.119828701019287,
0.5776748657226562,
-0.2576279640197754,
-0.8112881779670715,
0.26988309621810913,
-0.020098062232136726,
-0.12531931698322296,
0.5130345821380615,
-0.5610059499740601,
0.41008642315864563,
-0.48929089307785034,
0.22825880348682404,
0.17967292666435242,
0.1811889261007309,
0.7634871602058411,
0.4117937684059143,
0.4582870304584503,
0.5257575511932373,
0.4856930077075958,
-0.09723597764968872,
0.9062467813491821,
-0.27752578258514404,
0.1740972250699997,
0.7828855514526367,
-0.47196775674819946,
0.6709946990013123,
0.6860553026199341,
-0.22979843616485596,
0.1160067617893219,
0.4191979467868805,
-0.2874698340892792,
0.47093984484672546,
0.7795494794845581,
-0.1390240490436554,
0.1403418779373169,
0.19347961246967316,
-0.14252616465091705,
0.25926151871681213,
0.526414692401886,
-0.14136317372322083,
-0.24038606882095337,
0.38225042819976807,
0.7700209617614746,
-0.05690159648656845,
-0.4795888066291809,
0.762312114238739,
0.25820958614349365,
-0.38285818696022034,
0.486558735370636,
0.3120408058166504,
0.8470849394798279,
-0.6880528926849365,
0.33487141132354736,
-0.4223830997943878,
-0.10564927756786346,
-0.23630623519420624,
-0.8458584547042847,
0.07875791192054749,
0.6507335901260376,
0.30518150329589844,
0.10563325881958008,
0.8060652613639832,
0.31298455595970154,
-0.06635179370641708,
0.541375994682312,
0.37002116441726685,
0.13552574813365936,
-0.05049341917037964,
-0.6345674991607666,
0.5489984154701233,
-0.0154588483273983,
-0.3898333013057709,
0.7244093418121338,
-0.18241344392299652,
0.017346398904919624,
0.5188339948654175,
0.4898553788661957,
0.33661454916000366,
0.2953643202781677,
-0.07911652326583862,
0.8403101563453674,
-0.8716791868209839,
-0.09700167179107666,
-1.3313343524932861,
0.2933098375797272,
-0.30885565280914307,
-0.15157543122768402,
0.896921694278717,
0.3033464848995209,
0.5926042795181274,
0.39426371455192566,
0.7565292716026306,
-0.2344735860824585,
-0.014932489022612572,
-0.6643512845039368,
0.5534327626228333,
-0.16154278814792633,
0.7224203944206238,
-0.6179792284965515,
-0.6635334491729736,
-0.10152550786733627,
0.36833685636520386,
-0.5281756520271301,
-0.19635111093521118,
0.44461682438850403,
0.6647310853004456,
0.34181955456733704,
-0.0034198809880763292,
0.21381346881389618,
0.18086402118206024,
0.5108668208122253,
0.49230486154556274,
1.2177097797393799,
-0.23551113903522491,
0.39125147461891174,
-0.18767476081848145,
-0.4009886682033539,
-0.06320226192474365,
-0.7966377139091492,
-1.1199017763137817,
0.1766635626554489,
-0.07402022927999496,
-0.5725315809249878,
0.40855926275253296,
0.728389322757721,
0.25428682565689087,
-0.5356558561325073,
-0.38379913568496704,
0.10002017766237259,
0.12122476100921631,
-0.08758171647787094,
-0.18269091844558716,
0.09568546712398529,
-0.2660512328147888,
-0.12545208632946014,
0.7503527998924255,
0.4259066879749298,
-0.16197045147418976,
-0.3207423686981201,
0.18524661660194397,
0.10548624396324158,
0.1540813446044922,
0.6099380254745483,
0.31771066784858704,
-0.5683652758598328,
-0.15258030593395233,
0.10813487321138382,
-0.2881140112876892,
-0.030476927757263184,
0.8493877649307251,
-0.33956173062324524,
0.05206015706062317,
0.19545792043209076,
0.8047187924385071,
0.20649948716163635,
0.07107378542423248,
0.2055264413356781,
-0.5166873335838318,
0.04912326857447624,
0.1588480919599533,
0.5129348635673523,
0.15997152030467987,
-0.30099669098854065,
0.4194572865962982,
0.029018990695476532,
-0.5201343894004822,
-1.118938684463501,
0.26742446422576904,
-0.8008566498756409,
-0.35419636964797974,
1.0512633323669434,
-0.379067599773407,
-0.24291746318340302,
-0.09646708518266678,
-0.1262616217136383,
-0.3712242543697357,
-0.259583443403244,
0.7324702143669128,
0.7036155462265015,
-0.0187116377055645,
-0.031185781583189964,
-0.8653820157051086,
0.08946078270673752,
0.14944158494472504,
-1.018833875656128,
0.26448744535446167,
0.47222334146499634,
0.44834136962890625,
0.056747544556856155,
0.3695785701274872,
-0.6345422863960266,
0.2875045835971832,
-0.32253772020339966,
-0.29416757822036743,
-0.06200443208217621,
-0.27417588233947754,
-0.5036652088165283,
0.27657079696655273,
0.3551727533340454,
0.12186425924301147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14579v1 | Text Role Classification in Scientific Charts Using Multimodal Transformers | 2024-02-08T13:21:44 | 2024-02-08T13:21:44 | Hye Jin Kim, Nicolas Lell, Ansgar Scherp | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text role classification involves classifying the semantic role of textual
elements within scientific charts. For this task, we propose to finetune two
pretrained multimodal document layout analysis models, LayoutLMv3 and UDOP, on
chart datasets. The transformers utilize the three modalities of text, image,
and layout as input. We further investigate whether data augmentation and
balancing methods help the performance of the models. The models are evaluated
on various chart datasets, and results show that LayoutLMv3 outperforms UDOP in
all experiments. LayoutLMv3 achieves the highest F1-macro score of 82.87 on the
ICPR22 test dataset, beating the best-performing model from the ICPR22
CHART-Infographics challenge. Moreover, the robustness of the models is tested
on a synthetic noisy dataset ICPR22-N. Finally, the generalizability of the
models is evaluated on three chart datasets, CHIME-R, DeGruyter, and EconBiz,
for which we added labels for the text roles. Findings indicate that even in
cases where there is limited training data, transformers can be used with the
help of data augmentation and balancing methods. The source code and datasets
are available on GitHub under
https://github.com/hjkimk/text-role-classification | [
-0.16220571100711823,
-0.1596681773662567,
0.4178309440612793,
0.2643393874168396,
-0.27262741327285767,
0.14011870324611664,
-0.058441758155822754,
-0.6895557641983032,
-0.12238658964633942,
0.8220019340515137,
-0.28173086047172546,
-0.7334877848625183,
-0.7154380679130554,
0.47579580545425415,
-0.4106815457344055,
1.1727055311203003,
-0.17849938571453094,
0.22841745615005493,
-0.5886561870574951,
-0.12457763403654099,
-0.4974481761455536,
-0.3801620900630951,
-0.15125510096549988,
-0.2004220336675644,
0.6673434972763062,
0.4922386407852173,
0.7179776430130005,
0.621101975440979,
0.5591520667076111,
0.4365498423576355,
0.25147509574890137,
0.3929150104522705,
-0.22431859374046326,
0.3929094076156616,
0.24252475798130035,
-0.41648057103157043,
-0.5672913193702698,
0.3832142949104309,
0.5601465702056885,
0.5718084573745728,
0.3102070391178131,
-0.11453845351934433,
-0.01596950553357601,
0.23096740245819092,
-0.4063493609428406,
0.9465161561965942,
-0.23030321300029755,
0.10710767656564713,
-0.2284581959247589,
-0.5795968770980835,
-0.9090604782104492,
-0.09186246246099472,
0.2749919891357422,
-1.105313777923584,
0.2859083116054535,
0.2940240502357483,
0.646559476852417,
0.19317373633384705,
-0.9910650253295898,
-0.4935816824436188,
-0.6651328802108765,
0.9685013890266418,
-0.4172808825969696,
0.5153884291648865,
0.3694847822189331,
0.24167995154857635,
0.26611027121543884,
-0.9780074954032898,
-0.40359675884246826,
-0.11928967386484146,
-0.5992282629013062,
0.5348380208015442,
-0.05035603791475296,
0.24735668301582336,
0.3000272810459137,
0.11352114379405975,
-0.6071359515190125,
0.38090527057647705,
-0.7639830708503723,
-0.29958802461624146,
0.6304864883422852,
0.16423343122005463,
0.4316219687461853,
-0.6239946484565735,
-0.4027310609817505,
-0.542212188243866,
-0.037023644894361496,
0.08526749163866043,
0.34341394901275635,
0.261104553937912,
-0.16465820372104645,
0.7630196809768677,
0.32361721992492676,
0.6685871481895447,
-0.21770355105400085,
-0.3514429032802582,
0.19642479717731476,
-0.40438005328178406,
-0.14896070957183838,
0.15892697870731354,
0.7525662183761597,
0.3889298439025879,
0.12241341918706894,
0.17785300314426422,
-0.04104812443256378,
-0.07702413946390152,
0.6514302492141724,
-0.7280953526496887,
-0.2954154312610626,
-0.14067856967449188,
-0.4398763179779053,
-0.4833355247974396,
0.3135490417480469,
-0.6991665959358215,
-0.6118894219398499,
-0.48107489943504333,
0.2008458822965622,
-0.45643094182014465,
0.16116058826446533,
-0.11927551031112671,
-0.29067137837409973,
-0.19397825002670288,
0.5749255418777466,
-0.7828748226165771,
0.16263143718242645,
0.5629962086677551,
0.85929936170578,
-0.18313808739185333,
-0.2740713357925415,
-0.34614723920822144,
0.43003520369529724,
-0.16323032975196838,
0.8201473951339722,
-0.5237011313438416,
-0.5171300172805786,
-0.23432384431362152,
0.10273972898721695,
-0.5198143124580383,
-0.12956978380680084,
0.8167075514793396,
-0.5640126466751099,
0.7066507339477539,
0.14183685183525085,
-0.6103318333625793,
-0.3201864957809448,
0.12764069437980652,
-1.182224988937378,
0.7855310440063477,
0.15682300925254822,
-1.0815637111663818,
0.570953369140625,
-0.832368016242981,
-0.4500402510166168,
0.0625099465250969,
-0.29185205698013306,
-0.5800338983535767,
-0.3316732943058014,
0.24315929412841797,
0.6092354655265808,
-0.00690416106954217,
-0.05609364062547684,
-0.1859932243824005,
-0.08689682930707932,
0.3190484642982483,
-0.36909356713294983,
0.5242396593093872,
0.2551043927669525,
-0.03719848394393921,
0.32695987820625305,
-0.7459822297096252,
-0.10328702628612518,
-0.24682870507240295,
-0.26600292325019836,
-0.6431381106376648,
0.14678554236888885,
0.6604658365249634,
0.17388132214546204,
-0.18191201984882355,
-0.35925665497779846,
0.5358943939208984,
-0.18932293355464935,
0.3441734313964844,
0.569202184677124,
-0.10170530527830124,
0.5015848875045776,
-0.0857057124376297,
0.5774059891700745,
-0.07140310108661652,
0.17648209631443024,
-0.17557813227176666,
-0.6939575672149658,
-0.34928974509239197,
-0.6773595809936523,
0.5677895545959473,
0.5407968759536743,
-0.7311674952507019,
0.45980140566825867,
-0.6134493350982666,
-0.6429030299186707,
-0.044577863067388535,
0.0930611863732338,
0.09388088434934616,
0.666936993598938,
0.5796480178833008,
-0.2534390985965729,
-0.5568585395812988,
-0.7586991190910339,
0.20111270248889923,
-0.1841936856508255,
-0.020833900198340416,
-0.022140350192785263,
0.31080785393714905,
-0.4267039895057678,
0.8013598322868347,
-0.5385689735412598,
-0.5405939221382141,
-0.36462000012397766,
0.5652632713317871,
-0.0897870734333992,
0.2866978347301483,
0.8165988922119141,
-1.098139762878418,
-0.45140987634658813,
0.16346651315689087,
-0.7374582886695862,
-0.3606938421726227,
-0.14493785798549652,
0.06784321367740631,
0.11865121871232986,
0.6268635988235474,
-0.7568939924240112,
0.5491207242012024,
0.689595103263855,
-0.47057268023490906,
0.3692912757396698,
-0.19717735052108765,
0.2193683385848999,
-0.9924277663230896,
0.05715033784508705,
0.18694226443767548,
-0.2758800983428955,
-0.814541757106781,
-0.2698991298675537,
0.23680971562862396,
-0.3036646544933319,
0.05385393276810646,
0.4702867269515991,
-0.35827866196632385,
-0.024887068197131157,
-0.31789782643318176,
-0.002389277331531048,
0.33524754643440247,
0.01744646020233631,
0.14517267048358917,
0.5129438042640686,
0.242075115442276,
-0.42138224840164185,
0.13442541658878326,
0.4350794851779938,
-0.39976343512535095,
0.3580288887023926,
-0.3199675679206848,
-0.27644214034080505,
-0.15513354539871216,
0.7011269330978394,
-1.3697235584259033,
-0.41664114594459534,
0.03018168918788433,
-0.31336063146591187,
0.590438961982727,
-0.040117762982845306,
-0.7646967172622681,
-0.32026833295822144,
-0.3460261821746826,
0.3597151041030884,
0.015251590870320797,
-0.23073387145996094,
0.7139596343040466,
0.17654472589492798,
-0.25688692927360535,
-0.5773235559463501,
-0.49747028946876526,
-0.35013991594314575,
-0.29123029112815857,
-0.7970389723777771,
0.6319951415061951,
0.19111214578151703,
0.02753068320453167,
-0.21080990135669708,
-0.36223676800727844,
-0.08996009081602097,
-0.07294842600822449,
0.4279235005378723,
0.5554492473602295,
0.1643163114786148,
0.2483459711074829,
0.1025281623005867,
-0.4276267886161804,
-0.21700167655944824,
0.009863891638815403,
0.39894887804985046,
0.10956025868654251,
-0.40775468945503235,
-0.3913053274154663,
0.12450937181711197,
0.9824411273002625,
-0.1349623054265976,
0.4835719168186188,
0.8511122465133667,
-0.06613032519817352,
0.22941754758358002,
-0.239586740732193,
-0.0013667333405464888,
-0.4445948898792267,
0.3608715832233429,
0.12325771898031235,
-0.5377709269523621,
0.32464027404785156,
0.2764021158218384,
0.33933383226394653,
0.6526414155960083,
0.1925317496061325,
-0.4269979000091553,
1.2770029306411743,
0.7058199644088745,
0.12927843630313873,
0.4915020167827606,
-0.4284290373325348,
0.14247186481952667,
-0.5543451309204102,
-0.23318716883659363,
-0.5577780604362488,
-0.4242416322231293,
-0.664505660533905,
-0.5142354369163513,
0.7430287003517151,
0.024381710216403008,
-0.08343815803527832,
0.2534560263156891,
-0.5507978200912476,
0.07237163931131363,
0.32398414611816406,
-0.12866653501987457,
0.42900750041007996,
0.14012712240219116,
0.10841567069292068,
-0.3648536801338196,
-0.5092044472694397,
-0.7402927875518799,
1.06657874584198,
0.31547388434410095,
0.9029157757759094,
-0.0699838250875473,
0.3515566885471344,
0.36083298921585083,
0.5274882316589355,
-0.7763546705245972,
0.24174626171588898,
-0.2772977352142334,
-0.4566773474216461,
-0.44549641013145447,
-0.3491896986961365,
-1.0121667385101318,
0.42577430605888367,
-0.3886552155017853,
-0.3433282673358917,
0.17276667058467865,
0.09979846328496933,
-0.04670834168791771,
0.10178449749946594,
-1.0982764959335327,
0.9314191937446594,
-0.5175145268440247,
0.055172041058540344,
-0.09587545692920685,
-0.6157646775245667,
0.08666597306728363,
-0.11468858271837234,
0.5442773103713989,
0.1627042293548584,
0.01657036319375038,
0.8249437808990479,
-0.24135169386863708,
1.0054303407669067,
-0.2302345484495163,
-0.16215699911117554,
0.022653479129076004,
-0.0841057226061821,
0.2525804042816162,
0.1777447611093521,
-0.08966511487960815,
-0.09943719953298569,
0.3966678977012634,
-0.3250894248485565,
-0.6479755640029907,
0.5850337147712708,
-1.0737557411193848,
-0.24946428835391998,
-0.6157753467559814,
-0.6624817252159119,
-0.2140084207057953,
0.4000296890735626,
0.318280965089798,
0.3847748935222626,
0.16683848202228546,
0.699610710144043,
0.2645104229450226,
-0.030100993812084198,
0.2908814251422882,
0.33955150842666626,
-0.24903324246406555,
-0.34604230523109436,
0.6490407586097717,
0.25386855006217957,
0.15865863859653473,
0.44841840863227844,
0.09897584468126297,
-0.5316668748855591,
-0.3815387189388275,
-0.14312484860420227,
-0.04626063257455826,
-0.9426254034042358,
-0.4248952269554138,
-0.7766081094741821,
-0.32306399941444397,
-0.5350527167320251,
-0.084613136947155,
-0.007322071585804224,
-0.537531316280365,
-0.5676089525222778,
-0.2939613461494446,
0.5096826553344727,
0.542688250541687,
0.17344212532043457,
0.4930475056171417,
-0.8187946081161499,
0.25925910472869873,
0.3097743093967438,
0.1811615228652954,
-0.1318100392818451,
-0.21113844215869904,
-0.2634396553039551,
-0.2208583503961563,
-0.9235202074050903,
-0.928443193435669,
0.3954973816871643,
0.08584211021661758,
0.6591625809669495,
0.5080881118774414,
-0.13334636390209198,
0.5204136967658997,
-0.25952133536338806,
0.5148360133171082,
0.2977685332298279,
-0.817459762096405,
0.14032697677612305,
-0.43235597014427185,
0.06890534609556198,
0.38855549693107605,
0.4873301386833191,
-0.5583668351173401,
-0.3962078392505646,
-0.2914324998855591,
-0.8302727937698364,
0.8889769315719604,
0.4740474820137024,
-0.10771719366312027,
0.30822259187698364,
0.021030955016613007,
0.3085859417915344,
0.09625504910945892,
-1.0880181789398193,
0.12135183066129684,
-0.7664418816566467,
-0.547337532043457,
-0.24413661658763885,
0.0632946714758873,
-0.13489902019500732,
-0.6246104836463928,
0.32661014795303345,
-0.4517780840396881,
0.09624703973531723,
0.25885874032974243,
-0.3151920735836029,
-0.11061356961727142,
0.3540734350681305,
0.690927267074585,
0.7565872073173523,
-0.10191532224416733,
0.26717886328697205,
-0.1935793161392212,
-0.7451480627059937,
-0.02424602210521698,
0.46018698811531067,
0.043751560151576996,
-0.08689441531896591,
0.9548018574714661,
0.8155953884124756,
0.5000768303871155,
-0.5410030484199524,
0.38517069816589355,
-0.051366910338401794,
-0.18076449632644653,
-0.11609859764575958,
0.15830078721046448,
-0.09115424752235413,
0.09852419048547745,
0.4754287302494049,
0.12144671380519867,
0.2020149677991867,
-0.33928418159484863,
0.07101322710514069,
0.19324839115142822,
-0.39118751883506775,
-0.4025895297527313,
0.5753181576728821,
0.08165237307548523,
0.13244295120239258,
0.5776490569114685,
0.28654658794403076,
-0.4199891686439514,
0.6732277274131775,
0.43961814045906067,
0.3787163197994232,
-0.1753566414117813,
0.5637206435203552,
0.002564814407378435,
0.3054651916027069,
0.22652554512023926,
-0.05341162905097008,
0.2161291390657425,
-0.5897903442382812,
-0.5781770348548889,
-0.36599233746528625,
-0.47330614924430847,
0.20541228353977203,
-0.5362904071807861,
0.5402729511260986,
-0.20715048909187317,
-0.22414630651474,
0.5630202889442444,
0.012355009093880653,
-0.6735644936561584,
0.16172784566879272,
0.11952757090330124,
0.5172383189201355,
-0.8679744601249695,
0.6179493069648743,
0.9935677647590637,
-0.229710191488266,
-0.3314431607723236,
-0.1188417375087738,
0.11924958974123001,
-0.4113955497741699,
0.7846514582633972,
0.5294190645217896,
0.08769506216049194,
-0.07397254556417465,
-0.6199859976768494,
-0.7008298635482788,
1.4339358806610107,
-0.07830041646957397,
-0.17000773549079895,
-0.2206813246011734,
0.1723865419626236,
0.8592419624328613,
-0.4145124554634094,
0.505944013595581,
-0.024674972519278526,
0.8067643046379089,
-0.06759908050298691,
-0.9336934089660645,
-0.2970590889453888,
-0.2217423915863037,
-0.13261033594608307,
-0.02068968303501606,
-0.438782662153244,
0.8904510140419006,
0.22282445430755615,
-0.21785910427570343,
-0.11531960219144821,
0.5883200168609619,
0.3622535765171051,
0.43329545855522156,
0.7571349143981934,
0.13497662544250488,
0.755495011806488,
-0.14470355212688446,
1.0963945388793945,
-0.12186390161514282,
0.40734580159187317,
0.6660168170928955,
-0.42713820934295654,
0.26594117283821106,
0.35065990686416626,
0.1453176885843277,
0.7108550667762756,
0.5632523894309998,
-0.22143405675888062,
0.5529313683509827,
-0.2211439311504364,
0.2584301233291626,
-0.1972809135913849,
0.20505282282829285,
-0.34945935010910034,
0.6269074082374573,
0.5107971429824829,
-0.46491020917892456,
-0.3088761866092682,
0.31554627418518066,
-0.21708273887634277,
-0.03803698718547821,
-0.015177193097770214,
0.481193870306015,
-0.0546143501996994,
-0.29201722145080566,
0.13656377792358398,
0.20780885219573975,
0.36025601625442505,
-0.6496521830558777,
0.007083257660269737,
0.07705572247505188,
0.18829169869422913,
-0.34709402918815613,
-0.8659958839416504,
0.1602785289287567,
-0.15082834661006927,
-0.44095268845558167,
-0.5519163012504578,
0.7412073612213135,
-0.26883670687675476,
-0.609492838382721,
0.16590675711631775,
0.15494117140769958,
-0.37291938066482544,
0.23369713127613068,
-0.44601866602897644,
-0.024113735184073448,
-0.23775695264339447,
-0.12400396913290024,
0.2604929804801941,
0.3290882408618927,
-0.6311367154121399,
0.6101118326187134,
0.5512409210205078,
-0.35876864194869995,
0.048968639224767685,
0.1702495813369751,
0.7119284868240356,
-0.5291184782981873,
-0.6732975840568542,
-0.3763866722583771,
0.4975418746471405,
-0.3748745918273926,
-0.14449486136436462,
1.0028507709503174,
0.8091565370559692,
0.6599537134170532,
-0.32919594645500183,
0.7498365044593811,
0.08021668344736099,
0.3682078719139099,
-0.564136266708374,
0.8722835183143616,
-0.5151949524879456,
0.103223517537117,
-0.7142889499664307,
-0.7653721570968628,
-0.5659865736961365,
0.4992866814136505,
-0.48324301838874817,
-0.11669043451547623,
0.73764967918396,
0.2926745116710663,
-0.5032390356063843,
0.39273908734321594,
-0.1396671086549759,
0.004455094691365957,
0.6835289001464844,
-0.06711197644472122,
0.8965714573860168,
-0.30305320024490356,
0.6314800977706909,
-0.3343246579170227,
-0.18701866269111633,
-0.30823373794555664,
-0.6956868767738342,
-0.9271253347396851,
-0.7560135722160339,
-0.25972211360931396,
0.017543494701385498,
-0.7882509827613831,
0.6914781332015991,
0.9328364133834839,
-0.6813499927520752,
-0.21495789289474487,
0.19326362013816833,
0.09072789549827576,
-0.1878071278333664,
-0.31635782122612,
0.46658462285995483,
-0.2346152812242508,
-0.6770543456077576,
0.3244541883468628,
0.24322836101055145,
0.34990161657333374,
-0.08285350352525711,
0.11429078876972198,
-0.029712237417697906,
-0.19599254429340363,
0.8658708930015564,
0.08845070004463196,
-0.5983410477638245,
-0.21884989738464355,
0.12192316353321075,
-0.20646139979362488,
0.0562518946826458,
1.1670656204223633,
-0.3181608319282532,
0.6502229571342468,
0.6410697102546692,
0.2295091152191162,
0.5878487825393677,
0.2272794544696808,
0.37846484780311584,
-1.022995948791504,
0.3527679741382599,
0.27397048473358154,
0.3026517629623413,
0.24685755372047424,
-0.4194324016571045,
0.3797569274902344,
0.16923019289970398,
-0.5012778639793396,
-0.9185445308685303,
-0.11461896449327469,
-1.3185863494873047,
-0.2489834427833557,
0.8810767531394958,
0.2535538971424103,
0.11683765053749084,
-0.21481825411319733,
-0.4363834261894226,
0.3737800419330597,
-0.10800494253635406,
0.7303967475891113,
0.9101645350456238,
-0.42973506450653076,
-0.15931682288646698,
-0.6900104284286499,
0.44009652733802795,
0.06019148230552673,
-1.0403913259506226,
-0.03996589779853821,
0.7211363315582275,
0.06275846809148788,
0.7319167852401733,
0.3723198175430298,
-0.26575905084609985,
0.07394314557313919,
-0.49880293011665344,
0.025665000081062317,
-0.13464412093162537,
-0.51258784532547,
0.1912514716386795,
0.15624673664569855,
-0.20020854473114014,
0.1717386394739151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10943v1 | Advances and Limitations in Open Source Arabic-Script OCR: A Case Study | 2024-02-08T12:51:36 | 2024-02-08T12:51:36 | Benjamin Kiessling, Gennady Kurin, Matthew Thomas Miller, Kader Smail | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This work presents an accuracy study of the open source OCR engine, Kraken,
on the leading Arabic scholarly journal, al-Abhath. In contrast with other
commercially available OCR engines, Kraken is shown to be capable of producing
highly accurate Arabic-script OCR. The study also assesses the relative
accuracy of typeface-specific and generalized models on the al-Abhath data and
provides a microanalysis of the ``error instances'' and the contextual features
that may have contributed to OCR misrecognition. Building on this analysis, the
paper argues that Arabic-script OCR can be significantly improved through (1) a
more systematic approach to training data production, and (2) the development
of key technological components, especially multi-language models and improved
line segmentation and layout analysis.
Cet article pr{\'e}sente une {\'e}tude d'exactitude du moteur ROC open
source, Krakan, sur la revue acad{\'e}mique arabe de premier rang, al-Abhath.
Contrairement {\`a} d'autres moteurs ROC disponibles sur le march{\'e}, Kraken
se r{\'e}v{\`e}le {\^e}tre capable de produire de la ROC extr{\^e}mement exacte
de l'{\'e}criture arabe. L'{\'e}tude {\'e}value aussi l'exactitude relative des
mod{\`e}les sp{\'e}cifiquement configur{\'e}s {\`a} des polices et celle des
mod{\`e}les g{\'e}n{\'e}ralis{\'e}s sur les donn{\'e}es d'al-Abhath et fournit
une microanalyse des "occurrences d'erreurs", ainsi qu'une microanalyse des
{\'e}l{\'e}ments contextuels qui pourraient avoir contribu{\'e} {\`a} la
m{\'e}reconnaissance ROC. S'appuyant sur cette analyse, cet article fait valoir
que la ROC de l'{\'e}criture arabe peut {\^e}tre consid{\'e}rablement
am{\'e}lior{\'e}e gr{\^a}ce {\`a} (1) une approche plus syst{\'e}matique
d'entra{\^i}nement de la production de donn{\'e}es et (2) gr{\^a}ce au
d{\'e}veloppement de composants technologiques fondamentaux,
notammentl'am{\'e}lioration des mod{\`e}les multilingues, de la segmentation de
ligne et de l'analyse de la mise en page. | [
-0.3746951222419739,
-0.48434576392173767,
0.5496071577072144,
-0.2410755753517151,
-0.15755346417427063,
0.22385476529598236,
-0.2908538281917572,
-0.8003880381584167,
0.35130539536476135,
0.3714768886566162,
-0.07361096143722534,
-0.8823922276496887,
-0.5090798139572144,
0.12269330769777298,
-0.46006935834884644,
0.9029261469841003,
-0.4802122116088867,
0.10033994168043137,
0.48327144980430603,
-0.7806045413017273,
-0.3139025866985321,
-0.5063915252685547,
-0.5033287405967712,
0.3738548755645752,
0.5984806418418884,
0.5665115118026733,
0.7488923668861389,
0.7618462443351746,
0.6888633966445923,
0.2724008858203888,
0.14056339859962463,
0.17665378749370575,
-0.2057960033416748,
0.11348680406808853,
-0.022140460088849068,
-0.252236932516098,
-0.29876554012298584,
-0.08795584738254547,
0.6375142931938171,
0.4347490966320038,
0.031854383647441864,
0.1936529576778412,
-0.046977829188108444,
0.8697272539138794,
-0.8417173624038696,
0.09554916620254517,
-0.21416330337524414,
-0.22059708833694458,
-0.23295144736766815,
0.22470887005329132,
-0.3132234513759613,
-0.6494457721710205,
-0.011147824116051197,
-0.5735228061676025,
0.30213651061058044,
-0.03522918373346329,
1.1001465320587158,
0.1298125982284546,
-0.16243961453437805,
-0.8869566917419434,
-0.9287517070770264,
0.9963527321815491,
-0.5922331809997559,
0.34922686219215393,
0.3519967198371887,
0.72188800573349,
-0.03629114851355553,
-0.9483943581581116,
-0.7123170495033264,
-0.28261107206344604,
0.12982077896595,
0.21378597617149353,
-0.12046930193901062,
-0.25480222702026367,
0.11339354515075684,
0.48670557141304016,
-0.3340989053249359,
-0.005746164824813604,
-0.4489077925682068,
-0.4023539423942566,
0.4908866882324219,
0.018474938347935677,
0.298622190952301,
0.2830527722835541,
-0.07142137736082077,
-0.43451765179634094,
-0.5280156135559082,
0.22648200392723083,
0.47610124945640564,
0.2065790295600891,
-0.16547822952270508,
0.8994562029838562,
-0.12257760018110275,
0.4599476456642151,
-0.2785833477973938,
-0.12676115334033966,
0.2956646978855133,
-0.34849292039871216,
0.02338799461722374,
0.40332356095314026,
0.721491813659668,
0.46461325883865356,
0.3243418037891388,
0.26919329166412354,
-0.16970592737197876,
0.16380749642848969,
0.4647546112537384,
-0.9030619859695435,
-0.30405357480049133,
0.37471890449523926,
-0.4917130768299103,
-0.2104010432958603,
0.4899064898490906,
-0.8470199704170227,
-0.18505172431468964,
0.05213259160518646,
0.3961992561817169,
-0.5673438906669617,
-0.08511792868375778,
0.11666317284107208,
-0.23787158727645874,
0.27528268098831177,
0.6227177381515503,
-0.5255707502365112,
-0.07793956995010376,
0.31608477234840393,
1.1026989221572876,
0.24152925610542297,
-0.23882807791233063,
-0.32430529594421387,
0.038733433932065964,
-0.5882505178451538,
0.767500102519989,
-0.4835647642612457,
-0.4358193278312683,
0.209329754114151,
-0.021395519375801086,
0.047314271330833435,
-0.2842292785644531,
0.8202276229858398,
-0.6926954388618469,
0.05386200547218323,
-0.14493246376514435,
-0.361386239528656,
-0.6082618832588196,
-0.0622880719602108,
-0.7880121469497681,
0.9893950819969177,
0.07544664293527603,
-0.8779866695404053,
0.38626009225845337,
-0.8345547318458557,
-0.2548484802246094,
-0.03041309118270874,
-0.5696215629577637,
-0.5302318930625916,
-0.13504774868488312,
0.2990734875202179,
-0.04143352806568146,
-0.15736590325832367,
-0.383444607257843,
-0.28457650542259216,
-0.4378219544887543,
0.4351685643196106,
-0.22880251705646515,
0.8630685210227966,
0.4290634095668793,
-0.49717092514038086,
-0.07283170521259308,
-0.9350956082344055,
0.118670754134655,
0.16088934242725372,
-0.4916660189628601,
-0.3760994076728821,
-0.023241201415657997,
0.1276155263185501,
-0.05357363075017929,
0.39124372601509094,
-1.0699833631515503,
0.15805430710315704,
-0.34782204031944275,
0.39674103260040283,
0.5728070139884949,
0.13716793060302734,
0.3682430684566498,
-0.5926362872123718,
0.2891278862953186,
-0.18488703668117523,
0.1152084544301033,
-0.18028946220874786,
-0.5859283804893494,
-0.6485198736190796,
-0.5293954610824585,
0.6062546372413635,
0.6962653994560242,
-0.8124074339866638,
0.4742150604724884,
-0.3231566846370697,
-0.8908330798149109,
-0.7918108105659485,
-0.18413874506950378,
0.39556944370269775,
0.2743414044380188,
0.44083747267723083,
-0.5429403781890869,
-0.4416919946670532,
-0.885107159614563,
-0.5332188606262207,
-0.07956478744745255,
-0.0006334488280117512,
0.32155489921569824,
0.7026562094688416,
-0.15476307272911072,
0.9870873093605042,
-0.4777803421020508,
-0.4391114413738251,
-0.056720081716775894,
0.12396415323019028,
0.3962135910987854,
0.6768422722816467,
0.9203383922576904,
-0.7042182683944702,
-0.940727710723877,
0.39260172843933105,
-0.6965135931968689,
-0.02709978260099888,
0.3897247612476349,
-0.09173870831727982,
0.5652444958686829,
0.3482193052768707,
-0.34216344356536865,
1.0160328149795532,
0.32635778188705444,
-0.14496895670890808,
0.6884304881095886,
-0.40974855422973633,
0.5454851984977722,
-0.9417411088943481,
0.27051106095314026,
-0.05049113929271698,
0.07083889842033386,
-0.6437632441520691,
0.3654688894748688,
0.16991227865219116,
0.050050344318151474,
-0.5136654376983643,
0.4619866609573364,
-0.3075757920742035,
0.1220947653055191,
-0.13879719376564026,
0.011747973039746284,
-0.08181314170360565,
0.37983110547065735,
-0.1268170326948166,
0.8988080024719238,
0.2546708285808563,
-0.35953739285469055,
0.11129703372716904,
0.3404708802700043,
-0.906385600566864,
0.5467373728752136,
-0.5478271245956421,
0.16889920830726624,
-0.21979722380638123,
0.033924371004104614,
-1.2224185466766357,
-0.3721904456615448,
0.7029006481170654,
-0.6399092674255371,
0.04432607814669609,
-0.07657317817211151,
-0.46807870268821716,
-0.17997173964977264,
-0.34231695532798767,
0.6800065040588379,
0.5712745785713196,
-0.3595796525478363,
0.5641383528709412,
0.20230016112327576,
-0.21004502475261688,
-0.8046062588691711,
-0.8619776964187622,
-0.03696304187178612,
0.08132019639015198,
-0.6087494492530823,
-0.04873047024011612,
-0.04660258814692497,
-0.4456121623516083,
0.18352486193180084,
-0.1714325249195099,
-0.40822768211364746,
-0.19195950031280518,
0.16358640789985657,
0.25151047110557556,
-0.4019547402858734,
-0.15968073904514313,
0.17159532010555267,
-0.0012552080443128943,
-0.21166400611400604,
-0.14170396327972412,
0.46744468808174133,
0.10122320055961609,
-0.7274701595306396,
-0.5414309501647949,
0.43027597665786743,
0.8359231948852539,
-0.31304630637168884,
0.7435170412063599,
0.8207542300224304,
-0.25227704644203186,
0.0857260599732399,
-0.7445735931396484,
0.1473352164030075,
-0.49273690581321716,
0.261359304189682,
-0.3133426308631897,
-0.8285862803459167,
0.7494443655014038,
0.3019973039627075,
0.37300896644592285,
1.0448362827301025,
0.3347536623477936,
-0.18923147022724152,
1.1006931066513062,
0.37470975518226624,
-0.07871440052986145,
0.47865068912506104,
-0.4648195803165436,
0.23896610736846924,
-0.5073094367980957,
-0.3400588929653168,
-1.0925930738449097,
-0.328203946352005,
-0.5473811030387878,
-0.3641595244407654,
0.5890612602233887,
-0.08537174761295319,
-0.3424358069896698,
0.06659451872110367,
-0.5006600022315979,
0.6003087162971497,
0.6377357244491577,
0.2478560358285904,
0.260687917470932,
0.35649174451828003,
-0.2913319170475006,
-0.1065860316157341,
-0.7140004634857178,
-0.6794648766517639,
1.2311588525772095,
0.3971058130264282,
0.7141347527503967,
0.35778874158859253,
0.5315266847610474,
0.6354619860649109,
0.13604643940925598,
-0.746980607509613,
0.32054102420806885,
-0.1951621174812317,
-0.621670663356781,
-0.4972885847091675,
-0.23055993020534515,
-1.012912392616272,
0.06455555558204651,
0.023404821753501892,
-0.814141571521759,
0.584172248840332,
-0.1245938315987587,
-0.43710416555404663,
0.4759315252304077,
-0.5193923711776733,
0.8739824891090393,
-0.015389686450362206,
-0.2858183681964874,
-0.3670237362384796,
-0.6218317151069641,
-0.007859193719923496,
-0.1195949986577034,
0.5346369743347168,
-0.024316566064953804,
-0.12395884096622467,
0.8026582598686218,
-0.8431580662727356,
0.7432470321655273,
-0.33659762144088745,
-0.16682778298854828,
0.861219584941864,
0.3049183785915375,
0.5824772119522095,
-0.29421547055244446,
-0.20386676490306854,
0.49626338481903076,
0.10898835957050323,
-0.6582976579666138,
-0.31434598565101624,
0.5662787556648254,
-0.9947117567062378,
-0.18690943717956543,
-0.6638558506965637,
-0.39942389726638794,
0.42476627230644226,
0.4288579523563385,
0.4096519947052002,
0.8555384874343872,
-0.2858717441558838,
0.18120189011096954,
0.23104241490364075,
-0.29800623655319214,
0.45588117837905884,
0.5633261799812317,
-0.24338196218013763,
-0.7229201793670654,
0.9831787943840027,
0.3958815336227417,
0.04463106766343117,
0.25802677869796753,
-0.06706330180168152,
-0.44673171639442444,
-0.733086109161377,
-0.9374459385871887,
0.14108939468860626,
-1.0512869358062744,
-0.019991295412182808,
-0.5870606899261475,
-0.25755253434181213,
-0.27014029026031494,
-0.3102646768093109,
-0.26948752999305725,
-0.4459317922592163,
-0.16833479702472687,
0.1473185420036316,
0.5236233472824097,
1.1015198230743408,
-0.12629976868629456,
0.33863565325737,
-0.8647829294204712,
0.010972618125379086,
0.002848100382834673,
0.23412348330020905,
0.09160726517438889,
-0.5867448449134827,
-0.7917768955230713,
0.42206746339797974,
-0.269241064786911,
-0.8315089344978333,
0.2425452470779419,
-0.04838880896568298,
0.3982123136520386,
0.28297269344329834,
0.10951952636241913,
0.36678192019462585,
-0.3893466591835022,
0.9799947738647461,
0.08486904203891754,
-0.91557776927948,
0.3962981104850769,
-0.37564289569854736,
0.2762390673160553,
0.9136452078819275,
0.6078118085861206,
-0.4702012538909912,
-0.4893430173397064,
-0.47231796383857727,
-0.7625489234924316,
0.8770511150360107,
0.5071207284927368,
-0.42292770743370056,
0.033228550106287,
0.2920534610748291,
0.3124411702156067,
0.16005851328372955,
-0.20244701206684113,
-0.36288347840309143,
-0.2915791869163513,
-0.27606409788131714,
-0.2561655342578888,
-0.2552943825721741,
0.016576921567320824,
-0.25872310996055603,
0.7624375224113464,
0.27796217799186707,
0.26169493794441223,
0.733893871307373,
-0.29795512557029724,
-0.08954627811908722,
0.13352543115615845,
0.8636851906776428,
0.6580687165260315,
-0.5019941329956055,
0.04229697957634926,
0.20437565445899963,
-0.9365745186805725,
0.3256432116031647,
-0.08127868175506592,
-0.28608807921409607,
0.25399792194366455,
0.38942310214042664,
0.44960543513298035,
-0.08472457528114319,
-0.6122291684150696,
0.641635000705719,
0.03822524845600128,
-0.40170252323150635,
-0.6937165856361389,
-0.16735830903053284,
-0.6095626950263977,
0.3470928966999054,
0.5752814412117004,
0.39601370692253113,
0.16928330063819885,
-0.40368929505348206,
-0.058105986565351486,
0.22781310975551605,
-0.4233786463737488,
-0.06356149911880493,
0.6647434830665588,
-0.014811438508331776,
-0.3946766257286072,
0.5255646109580994,
-0.36356595158576965,
-0.4711735248565674,
0.7144916653633118,
0.28042998909950256,
0.7822635173797607,
-0.5018836259841919,
0.08681124448776245,
0.6722002625465393,
0.5192744135856628,
-0.01921870931982994,
0.5750306248664856,
0.04563454911112785,
-0.7124345302581787,
-0.5105419754981995,
-0.5452299118041992,
-0.6269020438194275,
-0.02316736802458763,
-0.6678667664527893,
0.13561823964118958,
-0.5334973335266113,
-0.09389960765838623,
0.04660426080226898,
-0.14645947515964508,
-0.6795918345451355,
0.052546434104442596,
-0.23533856868743896,
1.0582276582717896,
-0.6025092601776123,
0.7043247222900391,
0.9127185344696045,
-0.6103070974349976,
-0.54006028175354,
-0.05112333595752716,
-0.3445792496204376,
-1.0322099924087524,
0.49069204926490784,
0.14757084846496582,
-0.2878565490245819,
0.0059346044436097145,
-0.45748913288116455,
-1.0259038209915161,
0.9797255992889404,
0.07208729535341263,
-0.6263953447341919,
0.24472607672214508,
0.2920018434524536,
0.4700044095516205,
-0.23024871945381165,
0.35753050446510315,
0.43671879172325134,
0.7702069282531738,
-0.01861477643251419,
-1.1321934461593628,
0.2541511654853821,
-0.23386380076408386,
-0.1857323944568634,
0.48896023631095886,
-0.6505630612373352,
0.9438453316688538,
-0.08689484745264053,
-0.4853071868419647,
0.3995542526245117,
0.43538543581962585,
-0.3285856246948242,
0.43954920768737793,
0.34523171186447144,
0.63929283618927,
0.48883578181266785,
0.056260619312524796,
1.0342506170272827,
-0.4493984878063202,
0.3060126304626465,
0.75128173828125,
-0.1790308803319931,
0.9408978819847107,
0.23996207118034363,
-0.3267463445663452,
0.9896625280380249,
0.31217703223228455,
0.06569135189056396,
0.5385549068450928,
-0.07894682884216309,
-0.5070441365242004,
0.09283367544412613,
-0.036512672901153564,
-0.45718708634376526,
0.5249156951904297,
0.3641846179962158,
-0.45130643248558044,
-0.3016495406627655,
-0.070023313164711,
-0.10419672727584839,
0.12108039110898972,
-0.5331027507781982,
0.6105993390083313,
-0.0921834409236908,
-0.4112720489501953,
0.6816269159317017,
0.24185483157634735,
0.16806632280349731,
-0.5833190083503723,
0.03251319378614426,
0.0558784082531929,
0.26232415437698364,
-0.22745396196842194,
-0.6785028576850891,
0.3599683344364166,
0.0029796597082167864,
-0.0007299614953808486,
0.3083557188510895,
0.8304051160812378,
-0.2921035885810852,
-0.545139729976654,
0.15229107439517975,
0.5463648438453674,
0.49385711550712585,
-0.18629205226898193,
-0.41158998012542725,
0.39624640345573425,
0.06358353793621063,
0.026728952303528786,
0.13335543870925903,
0.23957917094230652,
0.07735683768987656,
0.13490037620067596,
0.5573068261146545,
0.09528591483831406,
-0.02238689921796322,
-0.2401772290468216,
0.6854065656661987,
-0.68401700258255,
-0.5337764620780945,
-0.8999606370925903,
0.5767619609832764,
-0.024333350360393524,
-0.08580738306045532,
0.7913179397583008,
0.7916887998580933,
0.9037450551986694,
-0.18362584710121155,
1.1130510568618774,
-0.02090924046933651,
0.5992631912231445,
-0.42048484086990356,
0.7080941200256348,
-0.5089086890220642,
-0.16843044757843018,
-0.17035089433193207,
-1.0772520303726196,
-0.30776891112327576,
0.8239377737045288,
-0.45804563164711,
-0.02410515770316124,
0.8428081274032593,
0.8249852657318115,
-0.14112427830696106,
0.2162616103887558,
0.11288504302501678,
0.2542799115180969,
0.22935597598552704,
0.31157493591308594,
1.0119789838790894,
-0.6028976440429688,
0.7223711013793945,
-0.4089437425136566,
-0.3121374249458313,
-0.5562394857406616,
-0.7419440746307373,
-0.8678921461105347,
-0.5769075751304626,
-0.21656188368797302,
-0.6102249026298523,
0.04836972430348396,
1.0758403539657593,
0.14883887767791748,
-1.094826579093933,
-0.42752256989479065,
-0.02076806128025055,
-0.11071832478046417,
-0.32968220114707947,
-0.24048154056072235,
0.5434055924415588,
-0.023080041632056236,
-0.6511815786361694,
0.2926027476787567,
0.21630114316940308,
0.3509296476840973,
-0.05610676109790802,
0.02484646439552307,
-0.024863220751285553,
0.10754479467868805,
0.4627615213394165,
0.49789199233055115,
-0.5860047340393066,
-0.7104592323303223,
-0.314168244600296,
-0.2568408250808716,
0.19303710758686066,
0.7664322853088379,
-0.3001147508621216,
0.43836596608161926,
0.28235289454460144,
0.6740778088569641,
0.6331908702850342,
-0.2456788718700409,
0.2692011296749115,
-0.4947987198829651,
0.22247357666492462,
0.25698205828666687,
0.2826463282108307,
-0.06784223020076752,
-0.1310967206954956,
0.5084860920906067,
0.18692608177661896,
-0.9350040555000305,
-0.7517902851104736,
0.3270820379257202,
-0.8828718066215515,
-0.2758112847805023,
0.8994148373603821,
-0.2517702877521515,
-0.33905157446861267,
-0.47503164410591125,
-0.6863322257995605,
0.3879474699497223,
-0.8054488301277161,
0.8144558668136597,
0.806046187877655,
0.052980173379182816,
0.3224387466907501,
-0.6404144167900085,
0.34610289335250854,
0.346657395362854,
-0.25602662563323975,
-0.19901441037654877,
0.5838650465011597,
0.14494772255420685,
0.5354412794113159,
0.6691792011260986,
-0.07283191382884979,
0.5640658736228943,
0.3470938503742218,
0.48282888531684875,
-0.035220786929130554,
-0.3077857792377472,
-0.4171275496482849,
0.2113715261220932,
0.296070396900177,
-0.5494744777679443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05629v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05629v4 | Merging Facts, Crafting Fallacies: Evaluating the Contradictory Nature of Aggregated Factual Claims in Long-Form Generations | 2024-02-08T12:36:29 | 2024-06-07T02:28:40 | Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long-form generations from large language models (LLMs) contain a mix of
factual and non-factual claims, making evaluating factuality difficult. Prior
works evaluate the factuality of a long paragraph by decomposing it into
multiple facts, verifying those facts independently, and aggregating the
results. Such methods assume that combining factual claims forms a factual
paragraph. The above assumption can be violated: we show that strong
open-source models like Llama-chat can generate paragraphs that contain
verifiable facts, but the facts are combined into a non-factual paragraph due
to entity ambiguity. We further reveal that existing factuality metrics,
including FActScore and citation recall, cannot properly evaluate these
non-factual paragraphs and overestimate their factuality. To address this, we
introduce an enhanced metric, D-FActScore, specifically designed for content
with ambiguous entities. We evaluate the D-FActScores of people biographies
generated by retrieval-augmented LLMs. We show that D-FActScore can better
assess the factuality of paragraphs with entity ambiguity than FActScore. We
also find that four widely used open-source LLMs tend to mix information of
distinct entities to form non-factual paragraphs, making their D-FActScore much
lower than FActScore by over 10%. | [
-0.38766714930534363,
-0.9334880113601685,
0.9103578925132751,
0.26710447669029236,
-0.22032971680164337,
0.5479514598846436,
-0.23720581829547882,
-0.6557550430297852,
0.09928057342767715,
0.40662795305252075,
-0.45046111941337585,
-0.4328097105026245,
-0.6630215644836426,
0.04347613826394081,
-0.4331946074962616,
1.0763746500015259,
0.07485166937112808,
-0.40424230694770813,
-0.7287062406539917,
-0.30498769879341125,
-0.1929410696029663,
-0.4108009934425354,
-0.15572303533554077,
-0.291545033454895,
0.44681596755981445,
0.4322172999382019,
0.9306966066360474,
0.5276159644126892,
0.34019577503204346,
0.34625211358070374,
-0.2814588248729706,
0.6788665056228638,
-0.7220994830131531,
0.08673836290836334,
-0.2709237337112427,
-0.5038726329803467,
-0.4236551523208618,
0.18221566081047058,
0.6221716403961182,
0.7898647785186768,
-0.14178933203220367,
0.40781518816947937,
-0.028765980154275894,
0.6286596059799194,
-0.6330920457839966,
0.09617598354816437,
-0.5428609251976013,
-0.07517609000205994,
-0.28840741515159607,
-0.18053752183914185,
-0.44151797890663147,
-0.7313883900642395,
0.1941395401954651,
-0.13913480937480927,
0.30078065395355225,
0.20986247062683105,
0.7166199088096619,
0.2218569964170456,
-0.4420322775840759,
-0.4660812020301819,
-0.896899938583374,
0.9734154939651489,
-0.8210893869400024,
0.56473308801651,
0.02986692078411579,
-0.048927146941423416,
-0.30952951312065125,
-0.5500020384788513,
-0.8961427211761475,
-0.46026378870010376,
-0.21030111610889435,
0.047879014164209366,
-0.4417007267475128,
0.02640848606824875,
0.48307105898857117,
0.6443071961402893,
-0.536199152469635,
0.22136643528938293,
-0.6118060350418091,
-0.2417227178812027,
0.7355233430862427,
0.15965156257152557,
0.37288299202919006,
-0.4196789860725403,
-0.7932085394859314,
0.08629259467124939,
-0.8956150412559509,
-0.2006658911705017,
0.598276674747467,
0.05256171524524689,
-0.043305013328790665,
0.9163676500320435,
-0.08109991997480392,
0.4811372756958008,
0.18312403559684753,
-0.6863914132118225,
0.287811815738678,
-0.42557528614997864,
-0.15815705060958862,
0.3589300513267517,
0.7273617386817932,
0.6330191493034363,
-0.2985113859176636,
-0.3614836633205414,
0.08951976895332336,
0.22650977969169617,
0.05632422864437103,
-0.4612518846988678,
0.18279415369033813,
0.41465452313423157,
-0.3473323583602905,
-0.1806296706199646,
-0.005684597417712212,
-1.017121434211731,
-0.4795070290565491,
-0.43463072180747986,
0.10882095992565155,
-0.4238845705986023,
-0.07954240590333939,
0.06291726976633072,
-0.4121215343475342,
0.058177247643470764,
0.4016651511192322,
-0.4901682436466217,
0.18846090137958527,
0.7359894514083862,
0.8416620492935181,
-0.32598578929901123,
-0.38620737195014954,
-0.27770036458969116,
0.1749606728553772,
-0.26719480752944946,
0.9045935869216919,
-0.4116324186325073,
-0.51823890209198,
-0.005970047786831856,
-0.2488587647676468,
0.10464838892221451,
-0.6483544707298279,
0.8751046061515808,
-0.5149703025817871,
0.5780043005943298,
-0.3361724615097046,
-0.6931658387184143,
-0.12465950101613998,
0.2793019413948059,
-0.7207889556884766,
1.329676628112793,
0.2029767632484436,
-0.8872190117835999,
0.5910659432411194,
-0.23469042778015137,
-0.37553179264068604,
-0.0034675640054047108,
-0.2641822099685669,
-0.47087690234184265,
0.1925555318593979,
-0.12468317896127701,
0.19298362731933594,
-0.6061244606971741,
0.5818676352500916,
-0.3728945553302765,
-0.23176643252372742,
0.3175807297229767,
-0.561180055141449,
0.7909954786300659,
0.19904878735542297,
-0.3910723328590393,
-0.27064478397369385,
-0.9063965678215027,
-0.25132763385772705,
0.026560069993138313,
-0.7375222444534302,
-0.3187795579433441,
0.2677019536495209,
-0.3711921274662018,
0.14240820705890656,
0.3599748909473419,
-0.6379554867744446,
0.0915980264544487,
-0.1840817779302597,
0.17005279660224915,
0.5605393648147583,
-0.010663732886314392,
0.253214567899704,
-0.8095301389694214,
0.15360142290592194,
0.3464961051940918,
-0.023470694199204445,
0.04991701617836952,
-0.3998664319515228,
-0.8647682070732117,
-0.14982178807258606,
0.06947863101959229,
0.5529757142066956,
-0.710559606552124,
0.726328432559967,
-0.6316573619842529,
-0.7093331813812256,
-0.19699570536613464,
0.21418717503547668,
0.13824571669101715,
0.8718823194503784,
0.45943111181259155,
-0.09964893013238907,
-0.8004281520843506,
-0.892897367477417,
-0.38622912764549255,
-0.742677628993988,
0.08762583136558533,
0.03153844550251961,
0.403838574886322,
-0.010870277881622314,
1.1165742874145508,
-0.6385774612426758,
0.21312600374221802,
-0.06716157495975494,
0.3520212471485138,
0.13576333224773407,
0.2491866946220398,
0.5022451877593994,
-0.6284986734390259,
-0.17222169041633606,
-0.36209237575531006,
-0.7802926301956177,
0.10639658570289612,
-0.2453010380268097,
0.23170746862888336,
0.2828575670719147,
0.2834039628505707,
-1.027187466621399,
0.13824136555194855,
0.4845513105392456,
-0.23830270767211914,
0.7409481406211853,
-0.06659949570894241,
0.32806622982025146,
-0.7958824634552002,
-0.20467834174633026,
0.23926973342895508,
-0.10511962324380875,
-0.3721352219581604,
0.01912800222635269,
-0.023552250117063522,
0.15841791033744812,
-0.4663337469100952,
0.2773536741733551,
-0.4648530185222626,
0.07138502597808838,
-0.011248358525335789,
0.3556060791015625,
0.18676534295082092,
0.09221518039703369,
-0.2558536231517792,
0.7457637786865234,
0.23265165090560913,
-0.5856664180755615,
0.6366597414016724,
0.16951408982276917,
-0.6484188437461853,
0.7815929055213928,
-0.2898256480693817,
0.029533300548791885,
-0.433679461479187,
0.5123739242553711,
-0.8723012208938599,
-0.12407105416059494,
0.021493108943104744,
-0.3095540404319763,
0.21717709302902222,
0.022579701617360115,
-0.5689938068389893,
-0.4657372832298279,
-0.505427360534668,
0.1244392916560173,
0.6387990713119507,
-0.702135443687439,
0.6380628347396851,
0.308030903339386,
-0.34390580654144287,
-0.7650362253189087,
-0.7719683647155762,
0.37846654653549194,
-0.5138821601867676,
-0.9005258083343506,
0.6052867770195007,
-0.2548986077308655,
-0.49062374234199524,
0.23444904386997223,
-0.1316586136817932,
0.029527340084314346,
-0.14364567399024963,
0.04616131633520126,
0.49060502648353577,
-0.4097076952457428,
0.1810421198606491,
-0.04587676003575325,
0.35298311710357666,
0.15849560499191284,
-0.03175871819257736,
0.2438667118549347,
0.12472981959581375,
-0.531686544418335,
-0.07557126879692078,
0.3252967596054077,
0.655583918094635,
0.07378942519426346,
0.9239372611045837,
0.22339823842048645,
-0.24683792889118195,
-0.29151439666748047,
-1.1060009002685547,
0.3195466697216034,
-0.4134795665740967,
0.17955456674098969,
0.05978015437722206,
-0.991736650466919,
0.47924333810806274,
-0.22914038598537445,
0.24699068069458008,
0.7262989282608032,
0.5278727412223816,
-0.03623301163315773,
0.596132755279541,
0.22443583607673645,
0.02315589413046837,
0.12222245335578918,
-0.005588749423623085,
0.31110167503356934,
-0.6246993541717529,
-0.3871055245399475,
-0.4243592321872711,
-0.08029987663030624,
-0.698944091796875,
-0.6497227549552917,
0.21741729974746704,
-0.013315033167600632,
-0.0437660776078701,
0.07610426098108292,
0.06749144941568375,
0.5352146625518799,
0.4438956677913666,
0.2938632369041443,
0.632880449295044,
0.009265376254916191,
0.2223992943763733,
0.0015303484397009015,
-0.5309415459632874,
-0.6557142734527588,
0.9880304336547852,
0.4427725672721863,
0.7269010543823242,
0.4577695429325104,
0.6701741218566895,
0.5958926677703857,
0.13865742087364197,
-0.8537194728851318,
0.5448396801948547,
-0.2251555621623993,
-0.6580064296722412,
-0.0951535701751709,
-0.6541931629180908,
-0.53553307056427,
0.05666176974773407,
-0.28348541259765625,
-0.5899783372879028,
0.3476146459579468,
0.002555391052737832,
-0.47698795795440674,
0.3712756931781769,
-0.6583473682403564,
0.3058820962905884,
-0.28378376364707947,
-0.388757586479187,
-0.2547352612018585,
-0.3974551856517792,
0.7836453318595886,
-0.1077297180891037,
0.4159625172615051,
-0.19988380372524261,
0.12464503198862076,
0.5820490121841431,
-0.3667432367801666,
0.8907181620597839,
0.14041373133659363,
-0.295668363571167,
0.6283453702926636,
0.08486425131559372,
0.4471297860145569,
0.02740076556801796,
-0.07238063216209412,
0.1386275738477707,
-0.09647821635007858,
-0.30007821321487427,
-0.7444284558296204,
0.7066883444786072,
-0.760373055934906,
-0.963347315788269,
-0.5088037848472595,
-0.23322084546089172,
-0.2966040372848511,
0.0038454432506114244,
0.07283913344144821,
0.4068523645401001,
-0.5913906097412109,
0.26680418848991394,
0.7461184859275818,
-0.06916769593954086,
0.055783774703741074,
0.46206939220428467,
0.1786852777004242,
-0.38598597049713135,
0.7997521162033081,
0.24366815388202667,
0.36520805954933167,
0.13492971658706665,
0.14846983551979065,
-0.49969446659088135,
-0.5574237108230591,
-0.44409194588661194,
0.34761369228363037,
-0.9901087284088135,
-0.17645318806171417,
-0.5604037046432495,
-0.36187466979026794,
-0.364862322807312,
0.2440141886472702,
-0.23281703889369965,
-0.49675437808036804,
-0.21412645280361176,
-0.4266298711299896,
0.10199517756700516,
0.6256282329559326,
-0.21281546354293823,
0.009561223909258842,
-1.0179063081741333,
0.329326868057251,
0.4896469712257385,
0.28081050515174866,
-0.055634159594774246,
-0.44993141293525696,
-0.03280229866504669,
0.047867290675640106,
-0.4446788430213928,
-1.0064650774002075,
-0.24521252512931824,
0.0584721639752388,
0.7887510657310486,
0.2906447947025299,
0.0968046560883522,
0.7147635817527771,
-0.6052896976470947,
1.0894150733947754,
0.410174697637558,
-0.8567278981208801,
0.25958025455474854,
-0.11472602933645248,
-0.23544542491436005,
0.4470107853412628,
0.47939375042915344,
-0.503817617893219,
-0.4133543372154236,
-0.7974296808242798,
-0.7483403086662292,
0.5390063524246216,
0.11187447607517242,
0.18188422918319702,
-0.3231106996536255,
0.15926723182201385,
0.20294369757175446,
0.048521894961595535,
-0.5875217318534851,
-0.3780502378940582,
-0.059013571590185165,
-0.3489963710308075,
0.04389972984790802,
-0.7066167593002319,
-0.54798823595047,
-0.10398878902196884,
0.5680291652679443,
0.11290250718593597,
-0.05943995714187622,
0.28149235248565674,
-0.27422499656677246,
-0.1359419822692871,
0.5822125673294067,
0.6914847493171692,
0.93448406457901,
-0.21961548924446106,
0.47721946239471436,
0.28340381383895874,
-0.19901569187641144,
0.1971501260995865,
0.19598528742790222,
-0.19432221353054047,
0.1338147670030594,
0.5954591035842896,
0.8772995471954346,
0.1960224062204361,
-0.6429327726364136,
0.5137162804603577,
0.11616131663322449,
-0.21363812685012817,
-0.3277908265590668,
0.1109076738357544,
0.18392205238342285,
0.2905382513999939,
0.3367246389389038,
0.06824655830860138,
0.006789452396333218,
-0.9117483496665955,
0.12410925328731537,
0.2364252209663391,
0.032967183738946915,
-0.2716292440891266,
0.3752577602863312,
0.282002717256546,
0.11410509049892426,
0.6595118045806885,
-0.1060229018330574,
-0.43920835852622986,
0.3414500951766968,
0.5690841674804688,
0.5679308772087097,
-0.015064982697367668,
0.4826582372188568,
0.30695873498916626,
0.3394036889076233,
-0.3499167561531067,
-0.0015366789884865284,
0.022154072299599648,
-0.7746118307113647,
-0.6822258830070496,
-0.6519200801849365,
-0.47685369849205017,
0.1800859123468399,
-0.3338722884654999,
0.31991538405418396,
-0.28400978446006775,
-0.26144444942474365,
0.011827483773231506,
-0.060578152537345886,
-0.503142774105072,
0.24138937890529633,
0.24489378929138184,
0.9419646859169006,
-0.9920147657394409,
0.17733657360076904,
0.3955838680267334,
-0.618417501449585,
-0.4315823018550873,
0.0801021158695221,
0.21923492848873138,
-0.65250164270401,
0.6310199499130249,
-0.2125423699617386,
-0.2284003645181656,
-0.34194767475128174,
-0.4084356129169464,
-0.9115565419197083,
1.0582935810089111,
0.5916930437088013,
-0.41724422574043274,
-0.38526269793510437,
0.35826656222343445,
0.40237951278686523,
-0.19357457756996155,
0.1319277584552765,
0.7079834938049316,
0.5627389550209045,
0.4588136076927185,
-0.8072689771652222,
0.34155383706092834,
0.18239089846611023,
-0.25036364793777466,
0.10906508564949036,
-0.8813484907150269,
0.9352965950965881,
-0.18067531287670135,
-0.6070840358734131,
-0.1786559671163559,
0.8744177222251892,
0.4454355239868164,
0.390229731798172,
0.7348400354385376,
0.7673521637916565,
1.0720157623291016,
0.03128598630428314,
0.825775146484375,
-0.2708010971546173,
0.35868895053863525,
1.158685564994812,
-0.266958087682724,
0.6000295281410217,
0.4065920412540436,
-0.6113593578338623,
0.8827252388000488,
0.5725509524345398,
-0.15709641575813293,
-0.0054809534922242165,
0.0041544935666024685,
-0.5177974700927734,
-0.1865871250629425,
-0.10995015501976013,
-0.35521045327186584,
0.5032949447631836,
0.3679159879684448,
-0.3630583882331848,
-0.5039814710617065,
-0.6716635227203369,
0.39955419301986694,
0.18200653791427612,
0.07076027989387512,
0.6435354351997375,
0.031184514984488487,
-0.9189170002937317,
0.40446165204048157,
-0.08269176632165909,
0.5272080898284912,
-0.31950369477272034,
-0.019502751529216766,
-0.2110324203968048,
-0.16493408381938934,
-0.526500940322876,
-0.9351614713668823,
0.38192856311798096,
0.2163505256175995,
-0.2625911831855774,
0.03351356461644173,
0.6473326683044434,
-0.4457434415817261,
-0.5087504386901855,
0.04886356368660927,
0.6843343377113342,
-0.046866416931152344,
0.3074513077735901,
-0.514184296131134,
0.10011538863182068,
-0.01632283814251423,
-0.09082002192735672,
0.1476343274116516,
0.465228408575058,
0.13787683844566345,
0.3547351658344269,
0.7125766277313232,
0.24641770124435425,
0.07834231108427048,
0.01678977720439434,
1.001010775566101,
-0.660712480545044,
-0.3273088335990906,
-1.1455192565917969,
0.5353681445121765,
-0.4793776869773865,
-0.10886102169752121,
0.8970423936843872,
0.7252230048179626,
0.8035090565681458,
0.21678845584392548,
0.9487234950065613,
-0.09789688885211945,
0.6454495191574097,
-0.7052016854286194,
0.35618603229522705,
-0.5149816870689392,
0.25386905670166016,
-0.01073834951967001,
-1.1485315561294556,
0.07706663012504578,
-0.09716285765171051,
-0.2729102075099945,
0.018989959731698036,
0.7718290686607361,
0.5403357148170471,
-0.2182544320821762,
0.19859401881694794,
0.13328899443149567,
0.34951281547546387,
0.38567888736724854,
0.18880708515644073,
1.1764897108078003,
-0.11057691276073456,
0.5083723664283752,
-0.03693627566099167,
-0.20070916414260864,
-0.16887567937374115,
-1.113365650177002,
-0.6230941414833069,
-0.3750564157962799,
-0.4184161126613617,
-0.48461946845054626,
-0.06458112597465515,
0.7581079006195068,
0.2898777723312378,
-0.41096779704093933,
-0.029024431481957436,
0.2802553176879883,
0.35007381439208984,
0.28828513622283936,
-0.26478132605552673,
0.2556340992450714,
-0.2733304798603058,
-0.7521681785583496,
0.5642839670181274,
0.36012178659439087,
0.12138348072767258,
-0.594936728477478,
0.16036701202392578,
-0.11346403509378433,
0.41743847727775574,
0.6357297301292419,
0.23381130397319794,
-0.7312922477722168,
-0.58700031042099,
-0.2007136195898056,
-0.013266844674944878,
0.2808496654033661,
0.7416698932647705,
-0.5482161641120911,
0.3282160460948944,
0.6293296813964844,
0.5548056364059448,
0.2604438066482544,
0.43400847911834717,
0.45290035009384155,
-0.7313464283943176,
-0.03646017983555794,
0.06509944051504135,
0.33510029315948486,
0.641322672367096,
-0.4653265178203583,
0.24608391523361206,
0.42908960580825806,
-0.47069597244262695,
-0.92714923620224,
0.4019613564014435,
-0.9204679131507874,
-0.16644278168678284,
1.0176230669021606,
-0.18482966721057892,
-0.3335975110530853,
-0.02169487252831459,
0.19307948648929596,
0.2079170197248459,
-0.28972306847572327,
0.9834319353103638,
1.0040338039398193,
-0.20841091871261597,
0.19898957014083862,
-0.3493417203426361,
0.380297988653183,
0.08565045893192291,
-0.715285062789917,
0.05322384834289551,
0.8638325333595276,
0.3875284492969513,
0.5270233750343323,
0.5676124691963196,
-0.14067155122756958,
0.030580898746848106,
0.20167285203933716,
-0.3556985855102539,
-0.007667750120162964,
-0.1420951634645462,
0.1590399295091629,
0.11735396832227707,
0.21368755400180817,
0.24723927676677704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05624v1 | Efficient Models for the Detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity | 2024-02-08T12:28:18 | 2024-02-08T12:28:18 | Christoph Tillmann, Aashka Trivedi, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs) are the cornerstone for many Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks like sentiment analysis, document classification, named
entity recognition, question answering, summarization, etc. LLMs are often
trained on data which originates from the web. This data is prone to having
content with Hate, Abuse and Profanity (HAP). For a detailed definition of HAP,
please refer to the Appendix. Due to the LLMs being exposed to HAP content
during training, the models learn it and may then generate hateful or profane
content. For example, when the open-source RoBERTa model (specifically, the
RoBERTA base model) from the HuggingFace (HF) Transformers library is prompted
to replace the mask token in `I do not know that Persian people are that MASK`
it returns the word `stupid` with the highest score. This is unacceptable in
civil discourse.The detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity in text is a vital
component of creating civil and unbiased LLMs, which is needed not only for
English, but for all languages. In this article, we briefly describe the
creation of HAP detectors and various ways of using them to make models civil
and acceptable in the output they generate. | [
-0.38028258085250854,
-0.7949545383453369,
0.4522484242916107,
0.10855388641357422,
-0.14793387055397034,
0.015415009111166,
-0.23266437649726868,
-0.5678321123123169,
-0.0896831825375557,
0.5439868569374084,
-0.1675003468990326,
-0.5975714921951294,
-0.8092429637908936,
-0.017168687656521797,
-0.7750967144966125,
1.029741644859314,
0.11090035736560822,
0.020624656230211258,
0.11503829807043076,
-0.0801209881901741,
0.05317268520593643,
-1.0249221324920654,
-0.7756498456001282,
-0.2881777882575989,
0.4935745894908905,
0.23535092175006866,
0.691373348236084,
0.5341806411743164,
0.6795684099197388,
0.31388047337532043,
-0.23674407601356506,
0.0787297710776329,
-0.5116990208625793,
0.3270648121833801,
-0.3464493155479431,
-0.3484291732311249,
-0.3355776071548462,
0.09199441969394684,
0.5440893173217773,
0.32663798332214355,
-0.10548913478851318,
0.07715874910354614,
-0.1593748927116394,
0.43407702445983887,
-0.529472291469574,
-0.17519856989383698,
-0.799964427947998,
0.10973811149597168,
-0.5481737852096558,
-0.10014300048351288,
-0.4814561903476715,
-0.17460398375988007,
-0.22521112859249115,
-0.22579559683799744,
0.10933481156826019,
0.21856367588043213,
0.7830538153648376,
0.052011530846357346,
-0.31220659613609314,
-0.5909768342971802,
-0.88876873254776,
0.9211964011192322,
-0.8467099070549011,
0.48759737610816956,
0.3259200155735016,
0.27544426918029785,
-0.48422327637672424,
-0.42932456731796265,
-0.8657370209693909,
-0.34746071696281433,
-0.009944824501872063,
-0.09342047572135925,
-0.4690020680427551,
0.14837107062339783,
0.32394272089004517,
0.5118720531463623,
-0.5371710062026978,
0.4672163128852844,
-0.19928863644599915,
-0.26422011852264404,
0.819067656993866,
0.17928612232208252,
0.5609669089317322,
-0.48524731397628784,
-0.40518733859062195,
0.2801293730735779,
-0.63714599609375,
-0.41186636686325073,
0.6904137134552002,
0.21030357480049133,
-0.1769259124994278,
0.5687193274497986,
0.017285335808992386,
0.6365184187889099,
-0.24745722115039825,
-0.6337166428565979,
0.04671064764261246,
-0.0035318867303431034,
-0.24427472054958344,
-0.4533419907093048,
0.7626578211784363,
0.18164843320846558,
0.7667371034622192,
-0.0533403716981411,
-0.41299524903297424,
0.4518633782863617,
0.38487508893013,
-0.7207878232002258,
-0.13847406208515167,
0.05031611770391464,
-0.46687644720077515,
-0.600618839263916,
-0.41906335949897766,
-0.797884464263916,
-0.6753013730049133,
-0.2223254293203354,
0.2871122658252716,
-0.4331270456314087,
-0.2484767585992813,
0.15768173336982727,
-0.19193315505981445,
0.043000444769859314,
0.3690379559993744,
-0.6889833807945251,
0.41462141275405884,
0.5500952005386353,
0.6871243715286255,
-0.39946848154067993,
0.10271230340003967,
-0.5092918872833252,
0.1372484266757965,
-0.10881384462118149,
0.6964091062545776,
-0.5313959717750549,
-0.14462226629257202,
0.2075750231742859,
-0.20977862179279327,
0.16111116111278534,
-0.6807258725166321,
0.9744208455085754,
-0.6814471483230591,
0.23076438903808594,
0.3673328757286072,
-0.6394477486610413,
-0.41636601090431213,
0.33648473024368286,
-0.5002182722091675,
0.9916262626647949,
0.2301829755306244,
-0.8287138342857361,
0.07852287590503693,
-0.6711459159851074,
-0.4085013270378113,
0.23967118561267853,
0.022563334554433823,
-0.7032241821289062,
0.07743779569864273,
-0.024005021899938583,
0.6101667284965515,
-0.1722133606672287,
0.14915424585342407,
-0.4824610650539398,
-0.20920835435390472,
0.22829627990722656,
-0.22128291428089142,
0.7275276184082031,
0.4993647038936615,
-0.27840110659599304,
0.320846289396286,
-0.7531638741493225,
-0.3761140704154968,
0.4225288927555084,
-0.5460951924324036,
-0.5776535868644714,
0.3654395639896393,
0.3300473988056183,
0.2647453546524048,
-0.12234019488096237,
-0.5831815600395203,
-0.3513532876968384,
-0.4100598394870758,
0.18109992146492004,
0.7878893613815308,
-0.09830591827630997,
0.04689868167042732,
-0.48745042085647583,
0.6736722588539124,
0.11560112982988358,
0.1680806279182434,
0.05355645716190338,
-0.6041170358657837,
-0.8305790424346924,
-0.46977466344833374,
-0.061894483864307404,
0.6044261455535889,
-0.4538027048110962,
0.37650319933891296,
0.02342131733894348,
-0.5292351245880127,
-0.1610153317451477,
0.3719021677970886,
0.41682636737823486,
0.41372209787368774,
0.12124795466661453,
-0.2635093927383423,
-0.8933377265930176,
-0.885050892829895,
-0.42589473724365234,
-0.2653890550136566,
-0.056161269545555115,
0.09502606093883514,
0.6237034201622009,
-0.06850854307413101,
0.5783488750457764,
-0.38201430439949036,
-0.3959330916404724,
-0.3316669762134552,
0.05039997026324272,
0.0555935762822628,
0.25553590059280396,
0.7769387364387512,
-0.9200571775436401,
-0.5240257382392883,
-0.17200514674186707,
-0.758586585521698,
-0.2930692732334137,
0.34422948956489563,
-0.04650747776031494,
0.29051339626312256,
0.4977234899997711,
-0.2686147093772888,
0.45907118916511536,
0.583638072013855,
-0.30655229091644287,
0.8264025449752808,
0.3392148017883301,
0.14410129189491272,
-1.042083978652954,
-0.006227873731404543,
0.16426116228103638,
-0.7079801559448242,
-0.9405781626701355,
0.5970734357833862,
-0.29976752400398254,
-0.10799212008714676,
-0.7296782732009888,
0.5320779085159302,
-0.42156168818473816,
0.017888350412249565,
-0.4385346472263336,
0.2465958148241043,
-0.2021298110485077,
0.3702259063720703,
0.05141500011086464,
0.7210381627082825,
0.2037341594696045,
-0.6655462980270386,
0.4941490888595581,
0.03186260536313057,
-0.3983002305030823,
0.7360135912895203,
-0.34901294112205505,
0.11076174676418304,
-0.22860291600227356,
-0.0371122881770134,
-0.7601077556610107,
-0.37612345814704895,
0.34776046872138977,
-0.42674508690834045,
0.12817388772964478,
-0.300162136554718,
-0.7332865595817566,
-0.6543272137641907,
-0.31977713108062744,
0.31668415665626526,
0.6473203897476196,
-0.6412976980209351,
0.5367245674133301,
0.9413000345230103,
0.0485270693898201,
-0.5286396741867065,
-0.4232916235923767,
0.10953996330499649,
-0.6051910519599915,
-0.6385078430175781,
0.1551124006509781,
-0.08860746026039124,
-0.5310197472572327,
-0.21552789211273193,
0.24506306648254395,
-0.2319173961877823,
0.41384169459342957,
0.4458286464214325,
0.24877093732357025,
-0.1638137549161911,
0.2132670283317566,
-0.36776214838027954,
0.20462365448474884,
0.20947688817977905,
0.04041328653693199,
0.8703787326812744,
0.02804669924080372,
-0.2996332049369812,
-0.30036693811416626,
0.5253638625144958,
0.571720540523529,
-0.05241378769278526,
0.8029321432113647,
0.6026584506034851,
-0.7978798151016235,
-0.3451955318450928,
-0.6546417474746704,
0.06288005411624908,
-0.456289142370224,
0.3570369780063629,
-0.11029936373233795,
-1.169916033744812,
0.5258849859237671,
0.18566381931304932,
-0.04297211393713951,
0.40112635493278503,
0.99139404296875,
-0.07831989973783493,
1.0609558820724487,
0.7218862771987915,
-0.2926783561706543,
0.5280879735946655,
0.4051908850669861,
0.3913463056087494,
-0.6046947240829468,
0.0618211030960083,
-0.7221452593803406,
-0.11001694947481155,
-0.4571697413921356,
-0.47335514426231384,
0.4641822576522827,
0.21335908770561218,
-0.2667751610279083,
0.1662868708372116,
-0.49025246500968933,
0.40720847249031067,
0.2950018346309662,
-0.017356690019369125,
0.5105239748954773,
0.3395721912384033,
0.027579868212342262,
-0.19286412000656128,
-0.2923741042613983,
-0.8309572339057922,
1.1394284963607788,
0.7573257684707642,
0.868846595287323,
0.397916704416275,
0.5518057942390442,
0.5250179767608643,
0.6748434901237488,
-0.9357526898384094,
0.5902011394500732,
-0.2919834852218628,
-0.9042559266090393,
-0.023094570264220238,
-0.18703411519527435,
-0.7416656613349915,
0.09131337702274323,
-0.3762792646884918,
-0.8918001055717468,
-0.1679156869649887,
0.21995887160301208,
-0.20971126854419708,
0.670169472694397,
-0.33129265904426575,
0.42030948400497437,
0.05771872401237488,
-0.11400667577981949,
-0.42320218682289124,
-0.08607792854309082,
0.8193053603172302,
-0.20083849132061005,
0.39318177103996277,
-0.2590421140193939,
0.07149607688188553,
1.0085808038711548,
-0.14947375655174255,
0.9587840437889099,
-0.10783648490905762,
-0.32016709446907043,
0.4019514322280884,
0.3411732316017151,
0.31039100885391235,
-0.2766047418117523,
-0.1868915855884552,
0.15803666412830353,
-0.3858758211135864,
-0.1833386868238449,
-0.1905186027288437,
0.4549213647842407,
-0.5768789052963257,
-0.7788720726966858,
-0.431556761264801,
-0.6545644998550415,
0.11043184995651245,
0.20195600390434265,
0.06194218993186951,
0.10453417897224426,
-0.24733175337314606,
-0.07645242661237717,
0.8235825896263123,
-0.3859732747077942,
0.1460944563150406,
0.687283456325531,
-0.7586065530776978,
-0.023481840267777443,
0.5885118842124939,
-0.17909003794193268,
0.2215791791677475,
0.1689547300338745,
0.12591184675693512,
-0.060642044991254807,
-0.8687247633934021,
-0.2670033872127533,
0.4022808074951172,
-0.8435512185096741,
-0.30386480689048767,
-0.9286671280860901,
-0.5357162952423096,
-0.5045085549354553,
-0.03690716251730919,
-0.015299839898943901,
-0.23259760439395905,
-0.2431233674287796,
0.08319979161024094,
0.5177084803581238,
0.9528606534004211,
-0.24645835161209106,
0.6645949482917786,
-0.6740350723266602,
0.5063971877098083,
0.12458828091621399,
0.3044392764568329,
-0.13043974339962006,
-0.9738085269927979,
-0.14186301827430725,
-0.2584604024887085,
-0.36141136288642883,
-1.1570427417755127,
0.5713998079299927,
0.06362511217594147,
0.34776046872138977,
0.5055955052375793,
-0.05726968124508858,
0.25248047709465027,
-0.3786071538925171,
0.5717098712921143,
-0.013255612924695015,
-0.8545526266098022,
0.5363224148750305,
-0.5372768640518188,
-0.2588825523853302,
0.03933311626315117,
0.8023900389671326,
-0.8476735949516296,
-0.6561979055404663,
-0.39988529682159424,
-0.4703381657600403,
0.5519067645072937,
0.022330939769744873,
0.2590143382549286,
-0.2564771771430969,
0.2575182616710663,
-0.13624389469623566,
0.13196228444576263,
-1.0715930461883545,
-0.2159530371427536,
0.15749062597751617,
-0.3047392964363098,
0.21976597607135773,
-0.6015230417251587,
-0.29699188470840454,
-0.07978562265634537,
0.8063969016075134,
0.016030622646212578,
0.2290225476026535,
-0.037387412041425705,
-0.39104264974594116,
-0.20367196202278137,
0.34814146161079407,
0.5682415962219238,
0.26439473032951355,
-0.128020241856575,
0.27907654643058777,
0.09607342630624771,
-0.5229185819625854,
0.20188899338245392,
-0.25597938895225525,
-0.11865875869989395,
0.013098431751132011,
0.3372279703617096,
0.5509099364280701,
0.02126123197376728,
-0.7683547735214233,
0.76702880859375,
0.12242448329925537,
0.007011018693447113,
-0.7165803909301758,
0.2715357840061188,
0.19198942184448242,
0.11109793931245804,
0.04977886751294136,
-0.18005123734474182,
0.2071685791015625,
-0.6255418062210083,
0.3968082070350647,
0.7131496071815491,
-0.1343338042497635,
-0.18967171013355255,
0.6369985342025757,
0.09107138961553574,
-0.47799167037010193,
0.47166305780410767,
-0.3628620505332947,
-1.0583640336990356,
0.3065918982028961,
0.7837355136871338,
0.4166956841945648,
-0.5411801338195801,
0.268148273229599,
0.4525308609008789,
0.34378841519355774,
0.35439085960388184,
0.32853788137435913,
0.24536283314228058,
-1.1437448263168335,
-0.2931171655654907,
-1.1388659477233887,
-0.2502690851688385,
0.5671262145042419,
-0.4284667670726776,
0.36248353123664856,
-0.8083342909812927,
0.004306947346776724,
0.2180091291666031,
-0.24909913539886475,
-0.5880722999572754,
0.2836087644100189,
0.6469516158103943,
0.9613125324249268,
-1.0964577198028564,
0.7466638684272766,
0.46879202127456665,
-0.24114221334457397,
-0.5909209847450256,
-0.3713906705379486,
0.36710530519485474,
-1.1290158033370972,
0.7513884902000427,
0.08230214565992355,
0.040628839284181595,
-0.10696285218000412,
-0.6185567378997803,
-0.7066130638122559,
0.20031040906906128,
0.08640673011541367,
-0.5935084223747253,
-0.08485262095928192,
0.2598133087158203,
0.686011791229248,
-0.4291919469833374,
0.20498260855674744,
0.7629611492156982,
0.5696998238563538,
-0.3198607265949249,
-0.6492689251899719,
0.12191642075777054,
-0.18125757575035095,
-0.07407122850418091,
0.30187687277793884,
-0.2794021666049957,
0.8941465020179749,
0.028998907655477524,
-0.4630581736564636,
0.09151830524206161,
0.6040026545524597,
0.24858595430850983,
0.0714532732963562,
0.6500204801559448,
0.6653514504432678,
0.557981550693512,
-0.0337260477244854,
1.0436689853668213,
0.0008001641253940761,
0.11587537825107574,
0.9844809770584106,
-0.1967984139919281,
0.8104354739189148,
0.2162609100341797,
-0.2217468023300171,
0.62237948179245,
0.42141515016555786,
-0.23139555752277374,
-0.103802889585495,
0.6581770777702332,
-0.5930227637290955,
-0.33000364899635315,
-0.35521432757377625,
0.02188900113105774,
0.7268549203872681,
0.6214476227760315,
-0.42040953040122986,
-0.4015015661716461,
0.11539465934038162,
0.5760247707366943,
0.5437048673629761,
-0.43447810411453247,
0.7005400061607361,
0.1972944736480713,
-0.33111003041267395,
0.5358474850654602,
0.38966822624206543,
1.134413480758667,
-0.4912644922733307,
0.11194078624248505,
0.08915796130895615,
0.13232524693012238,
-0.40907570719718933,
-0.8225827217102051,
0.5427423715591431,
0.34614819288253784,
-0.35344019532203674,
0.09053324908018112,
0.9772627949714661,
-0.39257773756980896,
-0.3447906970977783,
0.5796182155609131,
0.4478100538253784,
0.5315878987312317,
-0.1788635551929474,
-0.7388193011283875,
0.11900795996189117,
-0.10219869017601013,
-0.280511736869812,
0.30315256118774414,
0.04804331436753273,
-0.35677212476730347,
0.7021971344947815,
0.7970883846282959,
0.3412748873233795,
0.2805769443511963,
0.22899335622787476,
0.7577909827232361,
-0.612322211265564,
-0.2387201189994812,
-0.8894308805465698,
0.17055930197238922,
-0.17653772234916687,
-0.061543937772512436,
0.7603746652603149,
0.3770448565483093,
0.7990741729736328,
0.05446544289588928,
0.7701318860054016,
-0.001376189524307847,
0.9445098042488098,
-0.39135652780532837,
0.8910334706306458,
-0.5346732139587402,
0.04491230472922325,
-0.3544914424419403,
-0.8314476609230042,
-0.5441581010818481,
0.5521121025085449,
-0.16507121920585632,
-0.019304601475596428,
0.5549221038818359,
0.9480488896369934,
0.02373586967587471,
0.03969651833176613,
0.6530930995941162,
0.3248763084411621,
0.5652889013290405,
0.38274648785591125,
0.79469233751297,
-0.2842058539390564,
0.3606984615325928,
-0.1655578464269638,
-0.33083081245422363,
-0.193817600607872,
-0.9481512904167175,
-1.0686322450637817,
-0.42505618929862976,
-0.2051832377910614,
-0.45787370204925537,
0.08829009532928467,
0.6856285929679871,
0.7545870542526245,
-0.9531148076057434,
-0.2908006012439728,
0.24670250713825226,
0.3497048616409302,
0.24798992276191711,
-0.29813840985298157,
-0.05814749374985695,
-0.3823105990886688,
-0.8708387613296509,
0.3829318583011627,
0.3753598630428314,
0.1842164844274521,
-0.3658304512500763,
0.012247227132320404,
-0.47265341877937317,
0.2625129222869873,
0.8775514960289001,
0.2589586675167084,
-0.6089861989021301,
-0.5353714823722839,
-0.4626538157463074,
-0.23980163037776947,
-0.020731836557388306,
0.6503886580467224,
-0.5628986358642578,
-0.0006753886700607836,
0.5022326111793518,
0.5444121360778809,
0.13007941842079163,
-0.2330079823732376,
0.5658416152000427,
-0.6277835369110107,
0.24625886976718903,
0.2718009948730469,
0.48012107610702515,
0.6114030480384827,
-0.5037206411361694,
0.5847446322441101,
0.5041040182113647,
-0.6189037561416626,
-1.1182138919830322,
0.6416206359863281,
-0.6736539602279663,
-0.24006301164627075,
1.0802184343338013,
-0.19508962333202362,
-0.3829363286495209,
-0.36770135164260864,
-0.02883950062096119,
0.35906365513801575,
-0.14394211769104004,
0.7227906584739685,
0.8047335743904114,
0.09537206590175629,
-0.1342187076807022,
-0.590221107006073,
0.7845057249069214,
0.4288424849510193,
-0.9118474721908569,
0.030322177335619926,
0.5006443858146667,
0.4879775941371918,
0.28993043303489685,
0.5889053344726562,
-0.3839648365974426,
0.2181679904460907,
-0.28183192014694214,
0.4204402565956116,
0.18809835612773895,
-0.33326637744903564,
-0.30575066804885864,
0.22769808769226074,
0.12914696335792542,
0.18380311131477356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05617v1 | Deep Learning-based Computational Job Market Analysis: A Survey on Skill Extraction and Classification from Job Postings | 2024-02-08T12:20:28 | 2024-02-08T12:20:28 | Elena Senger, Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have brought significant advances to Natural Language Processing
(NLP), which enabled fast progress in the field of computational job market
analysis. Core tasks in this application domain are skill extraction and
classification from job postings. Because of its quick growth and its
interdisciplinary nature, there is no exhaustive assessment of this emerging
field. This survey aims to fill this gap by providing a comprehensive overview
of deep learning methodologies, datasets, and terminologies specific to
NLP-driven skill extraction and classification. Our comprehensive cataloging of
publicly available datasets addresses the lack of consolidated information on
dataset creation and characteristics. Finally, the focus on terminology
addresses the current lack of consistent definitions for important concepts,
such as hard and soft skills, and terms relating to skill extraction and
classification. | [
-0.31040701270103455,
-0.7935560941696167,
0.08610603213310242,
0.039544664323329926,
0.09394609928131104,
0.42536360025405884,
-0.3393354117870331,
-0.7982538342475891,
0.20619581639766693,
0.606002926826477,
-0.7043936252593994,
-0.5634973645210266,
-0.6499642729759216,
-0.02789159305393696,
-0.46990150213241577,
0.9419451951980591,
0.48513704538345337,
-0.0496554933488369,
-0.40572404861450195,
0.1845906525850296,
-0.4527127742767334,
-0.5341659188270569,
-0.8729819655418396,
-0.04052429646253586,
0.4705662131309509,
0.586355447769165,
0.3906100392341614,
0.6076530814170837,
0.6531316637992859,
0.29373952746391296,
0.1398959457874298,
-0.03199010714888573,
-0.2221798598766327,
0.4179735481739044,
-0.18322157859802246,
-0.15264661610126495,
-0.42328184843063354,
0.39381223917007446,
0.49768391251564026,
1.2987372875213623,
-0.24321796000003815,
0.43662017583847046,
0.018980640918016434,
0.673058807849884,
-0.7335758209228516,
0.38628897070884705,
-0.822695255279541,
0.2703973650932312,
-0.2736205756664276,
-0.07458583265542984,
-0.03751784563064575,
-0.35867759585380554,
0.4549122154712677,
-0.394648015499115,
0.6543900966644287,
-0.44770365953445435,
0.6075122952461243,
0.1606469303369522,
-0.40770071744918823,
-0.4946868121623993,
-0.8597536683082581,
0.9264432787895203,
-0.5256352424621582,
0.46523308753967285,
0.3138677179813385,
0.7300751209259033,
0.227897047996521,
-0.9266634583473206,
-0.12532007694244385,
0.02384628914296627,
0.18753962218761444,
0.10827828198671341,
0.17110629379749298,
0.08172309398651123,
0.14517101645469666,
0.6112400889396667,
-0.5685813426971436,
0.6983734965324402,
-0.7010424137115479,
-0.013918536715209484,
0.9944555163383484,
0.40686362981796265,
-0.0339963436126709,
0.1313769370317459,
-0.04773326590657234,
-0.2925400137901306,
-0.4706936776638031,
0.252733439207077,
0.34687477350234985,
0.39414742588996887,
0.09693960100412369,
0.5227041244506836,
-0.5550952553749084,
0.7698509097099304,
-0.1823841780424118,
-0.2275228351354599,
0.3026520013809204,
-0.1341206431388855,
-0.44614607095718384,
-0.06776311248540878,
0.8190543055534363,
0.22023983299732208,
-0.1515718251466751,
-0.2699998915195465,
-0.18396346271038055,
-0.2148936539888382,
0.5986371636390686,
-0.5581353306770325,
-0.04057728871703148,
-0.06673772633075714,
-0.5990145802497864,
-0.6517850160598755,
0.1661141812801361,
-0.9709710478782654,
-0.9458013772964478,
-0.2730785012245178,
-0.38313934206962585,
0.24056677520275116,
-0.4715348482131958,
0.006319623440504074,
-0.26531511545181274,
0.42431315779685974,
0.062392204999923706,
-0.9190441966056824,
0.4840480387210846,
1.03200364112854,
0.518308162689209,
-0.4524662494659424,
-0.05356156826019287,
-0.06216937676072121,
-0.34901800751686096,
-0.2550286650657654,
0.6705420613288879,
-0.6544861793518066,
-0.08977009356021881,
0.26418307423591614,
0.11977483332157135,
-0.10289639234542847,
-0.7224342823028564,
0.5126160979270935,
-0.9618778824806213,
0.14093248546123505,
0.08149515092372894,
-0.4690207242965698,
-0.5444211363792419,
0.5906617045402527,
-0.8689636588096619,
0.9846941828727722,
0.46217048168182373,
-0.4873172342777252,
0.6416118741035461,
-0.6606775522232056,
-0.28960689902305603,
0.25826629996299744,
-0.40464261174201965,
-0.3060207664966583,
0.009241807274520397,
0.03910395875573158,
0.8492688536643982,
-0.4517236649990082,
0.2862775921821594,
-0.3997574746608734,
-0.35202836990356445,
0.5141310095787048,
-0.48976248502731323,
0.9176220297813416,
0.5092973113059998,
-0.22634154558181763,
-0.25208261609077454,
-0.6878405213356018,
0.0015850290656089783,
-0.049747318029403687,
-0.25748348236083984,
-0.01893662102520466,
-0.06443451344966888,
-0.027657736092805862,
0.42826083302497864,
0.2731535732746124,
-0.3996928632259369,
0.3767002522945404,
-0.8665910363197327,
0.23329293727874756,
0.49948304891586304,
-0.06837115436792374,
0.5857089757919312,
0.22546079754829407,
0.8933347463607788,
-0.18175435066223145,
0.09595256298780441,
0.43880876898765564,
-0.42337098717689514,
-0.2557104527950287,
-0.07963193953037262,
0.4902380406856537,
0.7981975674629211,
-0.7031345963478088,
0.5938867926597595,
-0.21290995180606842,
-0.9336835145950317,
-0.459848016500473,
0.17894189059734344,
0.1289239078760147,
0.4480957090854645,
0.14839670062065125,
-0.4162854850292206,
-0.8660852313041687,
-0.9325876832008362,
-0.31940388679504395,
0.3316033184528351,
0.07778269052505493,
0.22167886793613434,
0.07168502360582352,
-0.33060741424560547,
0.9463710784912109,
-0.8394221663475037,
-0.37928110361099243,
-0.3235461711883545,
0.24897430837154388,
0.7280679941177368,
0.25153830647468567,
0.37678050994873047,
-0.9008587002754211,
-0.3732355833053589,
0.1423000693321228,
-0.8873575925827026,
0.217066690325737,
-0.07393122464418411,
0.2271285504102707,
-0.045249879360198975,
0.5981147885322571,
-0.6891793608665466,
0.4171196520328522,
0.2512529790401459,
-0.041883256286382675,
0.5914368033409119,
0.15328699350357056,
-0.09798736870288849,
-0.7409788370132446,
0.396807998418808,
0.1609540730714798,
0.16636915504932404,
-0.7134336829185486,
0.14082418382167816,
-0.4752771258354187,
-0.2968941032886505,
-0.4798262417316437,
0.5577493906021118,
-0.4670332670211792,
-0.5475948452949524,
-0.6013904213905334,
-0.1784367859363556,
-0.3099277913570404,
0.37440672516822815,
0.16170111298561096,
0.6284043788909912,
0.831597089767456,
-0.7381404638290405,
0.7265868782997131,
0.23025298118591309,
-0.4205147624015808,
0.1902977079153061,
-0.35307204723358154,
0.26097261905670166,
-0.025729700922966003,
0.0941743552684784,
-0.705980122089386,
-0.37811970710754395,
0.33251118659973145,
-0.4319482445716858,
0.2563256025314331,
-0.2318059653043747,
-0.2501533031463623,
-0.679105281829834,
-0.17597830295562744,
0.37746551632881165,
0.4711662828922272,
-0.01377257239073515,
0.09585073590278625,
0.597871720790863,
-0.5641539692878723,
-1.253289818763733,
-0.7775906920433044,
-0.05312572047114372,
-0.09026685357093811,
-0.11259514093399048,
0.33740630745887756,
0.33058804273605347,
-0.2060273140668869,
-0.25748971104621887,
-0.047439511865377426,
-0.9426092505455017,
0.5036131143569946,
0.1300722360610962,
0.20122061669826508,
-0.19191913306713104,
0.10282418131828308,
0.0184944998472929,
-0.22199243307113647,
0.38013049960136414,
-0.0862986147403717,
0.33192047476768494,
0.1319132149219513,
-0.13430319726467133,
-0.22809261083602905,
0.0975756123661995,
0.37540575861930847,
-0.09016843140125275,
0.6359120011329651,
1.0117989778518677,
-0.29739558696746826,
-0.21701909601688385,
-0.547278881072998,
-0.14827316999435425,
-0.5054511427879333,
0.35150113701820374,
0.1217975914478302,
-1.0067287683486938,
0.30428972840309143,
-0.3023906648159027,
0.02296743541955948,
0.9427505135536194,
0.2994374632835388,
-0.2461792677640915,
0.8568611145019531,
0.8921524882316589,
-0.11178631335496902,
0.3064756691455841,
-0.6399623155593872,
0.19575311243534088,
-0.42247405648231506,
-0.31362777948379517,
-0.5293084383010864,
-0.5742653012275696,
-0.6680924892425537,
-0.06542101502418518,
0.000642491620965302,
-0.1466951072216034,
-0.14240165054798126,
0.08991757035255432,
-1.061229944229126,
0.34046146273612976,
0.6784888505935669,
-0.07015031576156616,
-0.12347486615180969,
0.09505902975797653,
0.39211493730545044,
-0.13976064324378967,
-0.37871888279914856,
-0.1935756355524063,
1.3117375373840332,
0.26054975390434265,
0.3510442078113556,
-0.3201887309551239,
0.5158310532569885,
0.5280098915100098,
0.08815924823284149,
-0.8614532351493835,
0.5104591846466064,
-0.5263989567756653,
-0.500464916229248,
-0.43315407633781433,
-0.4504355192184448,
-1.1247607469558716,
-0.11732277274131775,
-0.4962182939052582,
-0.3400798738002777,
0.3611690104007721,
-0.16672490537166595,
-0.43722668290138245,
0.27821874618530273,
-0.3467456102371216,
0.965768575668335,
-0.3682926595211029,
0.13968658447265625,
-0.28692787885665894,
-0.6185232996940613,
0.3595917820930481,
-0.31950441002845764,
0.2599501609802246,
-0.21900644898414612,
0.00875159166753292,
0.9368532299995422,
-0.07130897045135498,
1.0248039960861206,
-0.5523638725280762,
0.15056350827217102,
0.33893442153930664,
-0.13394583761692047,
0.18532349169254303,
-0.09585510939359665,
-0.465090811252594,
0.25798434019088745,
0.12191029638051987,
-0.2333066314458847,
-0.4745098948478699,
0.4279576539993286,
-0.6860101819038391,
-0.0029662123415619135,
-0.44070711731910706,
-0.4193764925003052,
-0.2683509886264801,
0.33752647042274475,
0.14923962950706482,
0.022856580093503,
-0.37306174635887146,
0.4146973788738251,
0.5259919762611389,
-0.18795649707317352,
0.26969724893569946,
0.16688400506973267,
0.01256501767784357,
-0.28336015343666077,
1.2384089231491089,
0.3352975845336914,
-0.4956566393375397,
0.3484415113925934,
-0.13705801963806152,
-0.2675726115703583,
-0.7994551062583923,
0.18526345491409302,
-0.03049848973751068,
-0.41785329580307007,
-0.26751887798309326,
-0.4726487398147583,
-0.5908351540565491,
-0.7876098155975342,
-0.21340565383434296,
-0.21963931620121002,
-0.42541301250457764,
-0.40351051092147827,
-0.29730793833732605,
0.18581432104110718,
0.8850902915000916,
-0.04235672205686569,
0.3538002371788025,
-0.7956287264823914,
0.29539579153060913,
0.49678921699523926,
0.6338379383087158,
-0.02916385605931282,
0.02167203091084957,
-0.6086453795433044,
0.21000976860523224,
-0.3305063545703888,
-0.7281920909881592,
0.7007279992103577,
0.18767398595809937,
0.9176188111305237,
0.45503726601600647,
-0.17761051654815674,
0.30761271715164185,
0.17989909648895264,
1.0235458612442017,
0.25641101598739624,
-0.4333289563655853,
0.44638100266456604,
-0.2854624092578888,
0.0012824772857129574,
0.8701968789100647,
0.7011187672615051,
-0.6509923934936523,
0.03293696790933609,
-0.8542329668998718,
-0.9792675971984863,
0.6935954093933105,
0.028435444459319115,
0.13858886063098907,
-0.046518418937921524,
0.5893086194992065,
0.5159768462181091,
0.5546504259109497,
-0.3021915853023529,
-0.07065752148628235,
0.07935703545808792,
-0.24064157903194427,
-0.1079723909497261,
-0.3216472566127777,
0.07919317483901978,
-0.6174535155296326,
0.46525856852531433,
-0.1915121078491211,
0.34667518734931946,
-0.2548724412918091,
-0.3243134915828705,
0.27996790409088135,
0.08857157081365585,
0.38680726289749146,
0.8660974502563477,
-0.19467875361442566,
0.028468409553170204,
0.2771754860877991,
-0.6580031514167786,
-0.15593133866786957,
0.22416310012340546,
0.145512655377388,
-0.1979552060365677,
0.27136659622192383,
0.2820229232311249,
-0.05769416689872742,
-0.9193993806838989,
0.8154484629631042,
0.12790022790431976,
-0.5583849549293518,
-0.7163378596305847,
0.16928182542324066,
-0.25292912125587463,
0.3536093831062317,
0.6611616611480713,
0.014090836979448795,
0.5936470031738281,
-0.3209068477153778,
0.3017815947532654,
0.4542659521102905,
-0.6748347878456116,
-0.19833455979824066,
0.27730101346969604,
0.16638065874576569,
-0.08272245526313782,
1.287865400314331,
-0.2050308883190155,
-0.09008599072694778,
0.9260746836662292,
0.07933028787374496,
1.2258810997009277,
-0.08675641566514969,
0.2979620099067688,
0.2136925905942917,
-0.04979724809527397,
-0.006436552852392197,
0.3198828101158142,
-0.02396753802895546,
-0.7826523184776306,
-0.5424394011497498,
-0.4947376549243927,
-0.5230531096458435,
0.38832366466522217,
-0.7595928907394409,
0.05045541003346443,
-0.7080590724945068,
-0.19907262921333313,
0.16659386456012726,
0.17241407930850983,
-1.0771946907043457,
0.7473580241203308,
0.3226216733455658,
0.7640877366065979,
-0.8297263979911804,
0.6415834426879883,
0.789040744304657,
-0.34473204612731934,
-0.24244673550128937,
-0.6194632053375244,
-0.09665434062480927,
-0.6757479310035706,
0.8306974768638611,
0.30189403891563416,
0.09549540281295776,
-0.14330455660820007,
-0.860249400138855,
-0.7133971452713013,
1.1161235570907593,
0.2337178885936737,
-0.12962199747562408,
-0.3892175555229187,
0.4482702314853668,
0.540509045124054,
-0.45906952023506165,
0.21521905064582825,
0.5066584944725037,
0.3565063178539276,
-0.19915612041950226,
-0.7909594178199768,
-0.3602684438228607,
-0.30582547187805176,
-0.08742539584636688,
-0.11300256848335266,
-0.14458520710468292,
0.6373708248138428,
0.41743966937065125,
-0.22923903167247772,
-0.2595512568950653,
0.663936197757721,
-0.09314993023872375,
0.5676867365837097,
0.5201936364173889,
0.3942231237888336,
0.813666045665741,
0.0323231965303421,
0.566486656665802,
-0.1815917044878006,
0.43346384167671204,
0.9668021202087402,
-0.11365486681461334,
0.676948070526123,
0.021363236010074615,
-0.18844246864318848,
0.6753954887390137,
0.8788675665855408,
-0.4695579707622528,
0.3936867415904999,
0.14636501669883728,
0.06074786186218262,
-0.2574162483215332,
-0.017688991501927376,
-0.4253421127796173,
0.8778475522994995,
0.5245141983032227,
-0.5194430947303772,
-0.23435568809509277,
0.11562303453683853,
-0.5054852962493896,
-0.1362084597349167,
-0.5327762365341187,
1.014214038848877,
0.11482468247413635,
-0.3629211187362671,
0.21192993223667145,
-0.06143670156598091,
0.7937203645706177,
-0.5042513608932495,
-0.3972885310649872,
0.14258968830108643,
-0.026184290647506714,
-0.3837677240371704,
-1.138649344444275,
0.8511120080947876,
-0.2875698506832123,
-0.2801545262336731,
-0.5911456942558289,
1.1654870510101318,
-0.21223080158233643,
-0.40737172961235046,
0.07283531874418259,
0.6752164959907532,
0.46115297079086304,
-0.21910597383975983,
-1.075379490852356,
-0.38349851965904236,
-0.2901343107223511,
-0.03372613713145256,
0.33145540952682495,
0.17646297812461853,
0.10991030186414719,
0.6218805909156799,
0.6927175521850586,
0.023372819647192955,
0.05500474572181702,
-0.16354534029960632,
0.6354570984840393,
-1.0745265483856201,
-0.4354316294193268,
-0.46416452527046204,
0.3573266863822937,
-0.5242434740066528,
-0.4898669421672821,
0.46947771310806274,
0.698861300945282,
0.7954030632972717,
-0.2742776870727539,
0.7380550503730774,
0.040122658014297485,
0.766176164150238,
-0.18454428017139435,
0.7919080257415771,
-0.35884881019592285,
0.060278501361608505,
-0.0851871445775032,
-0.8613513112068176,
-0.22843196988105774,
0.21121059358119965,
-0.4639264643192291,
0.05205236002802849,
0.27385011315345764,
0.623064398765564,
-0.16414500772953033,
-0.12984493374824524,
0.23159261047840118,
-0.062478307634592056,
-0.14219364523887634,
0.049167241901159286,
0.783713161945343,
-0.14431597292423248,
0.34752121567726135,
-0.5118669271469116,
0.09969186782836914,
-0.5559853911399841,
-0.62541264295578,
-0.4191506803035736,
-0.48908814787864685,
-0.5007588267326355,
-0.09465380012989044,
-0.21587754786014557,
0.6212713718414307,
0.7660683393478394,
-0.7500128746032715,
-0.5867146253585815,
-0.07666175067424774,
0.26706135272979736,
-1.062696933746338,
-0.3448854982852936,
0.4045489430427551,
-0.35470306873321533,
-0.3414730429649353,
0.7747362852096558,
-0.059056878089904785,
-0.31998705863952637,
-0.39266157150268555,
0.25836801528930664,
-0.0792989507317543,
-0.29382336139678955,
0.6815356016159058,
0.7211464643478394,
-0.31446775794029236,
0.1610097438097,
0.07147616147994995,
-0.2652338147163391,
-0.1682545691728592,
0.9095872640609741,
-0.8323453068733215,
0.3149358928203583,
0.6370773315429688,
0.9750415086746216,
0.41564515233039856,
-0.2638078033924103,
0.5630987286567688,
-1.0525223016738892,
0.01059269905090332,
0.5079999566078186,
-0.15616807341575623,
0.11312560737133026,
-0.6790199279785156,
0.8598372340202332,
0.39087343215942383,
-0.42466360330581665,
-0.7503390908241272,
0.078494593501091,
-1.140364646911621,
-0.651088297367096,
0.8118074536323547,
0.4178061783313751,
-0.11270838975906372,
-0.37240010499954224,
0.17841920256614685,
0.3393811881542206,
-0.03840778023004532,
0.7429657578468323,
0.4060174226760864,
-0.19503352046012878,
-0.26324716210365295,
-0.8063904047012329,
0.5008051991462708,
-0.14313627779483795,
-0.6794224381446838,
0.041371822357177734,
0.4341290295124054,
0.04980731010437012,
0.14610283076763153,
0.6700934767723083,
0.15324530005455017,
0.4329216778278351,
-0.20980551838874817,
0.38557004928588867,
-0.09511344134807587,
-0.26930859684944153,
-0.502538800239563,
0.6747115254402161,
0.18009378015995026,
-0.013590758666396141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05616v1 | Pretrained Generative Language Models as General Learning Frameworks for Sequence-Based Tasks | 2024-02-08T12:19:32 | 2024-02-08T12:19:32 | Ben Fauber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose that small pretrained foundational generative language models with
millions of parameters can be utilized as a general learning framework for
sequence-based tasks. Our proposal overcomes the computational resource, skill
set, and timeline challenges associated with training neural networks and
language models from scratch. Further, our approach focuses on creating small
and highly specialized models that can accurately execute a challenging task of
which the base model is incapable of performing. We demonstrate that 125M,
350M, and 1.3B parameter pretrained foundational language models can be
instruction fine-tuned with 10,000-to-1,000,000 instruction examples to achieve
near state-of-the-art results on challenging cheminformatics tasks. We also
demonstrate the role of successive language model fine-tuning epochs on
improved outcomes, as well as the importance of both data formatting and
pretrained foundational language model selection for instruction fine-tuning
success. | [
-0.043399080634117126,
-0.730327844619751,
0.5108808875083923,
0.059070270508527756,
-0.2211703509092331,
-0.13561081886291504,
-0.32158318161964417,
-0.07585249096155167,
-0.0913868099451065,
0.4459598958492279,
-0.5789415836334229,
-0.44750773906707764,
-0.43576204776763916,
0.05561257153749466,
-0.4613543152809143,
0.9986820220947266,
0.12709380686283112,
0.21605974435806274,
0.11092187464237213,
0.3574860095977783,
-0.2640809118747711,
-0.4233566224575043,
-0.5730769634246826,
-0.2820483148097992,
0.48809632658958435,
0.46627557277679443,
0.7082719802856445,
0.8392701745033264,
0.21800215542316437,
0.29484203457832336,
0.07215551286935806,
-0.052895352244377136,
-0.541755735874176,
-0.19291505217552185,
-0.24001891911029816,
-0.4355829060077667,
-0.340304434299469,
-0.0010836656438186765,
0.7149519324302673,
1.3373205661773682,
-0.24637646973133087,
-0.05454378202557564,
0.003002825425937772,
0.7432934641838074,
-0.4908658564090729,
0.14232249557971954,
-0.48980632424354553,
0.16234970092773438,
-0.13798175752162933,
0.036084484308958054,
-0.4107893109321594,
-0.3221430778503418,
0.2233365923166275,
-0.7583569288253784,
0.5694332718849182,
-0.13836607336997986,
0.5747222304344177,
0.12196213752031326,
-0.15548263490200043,
-0.2557339370250702,
-0.8136026263237,
0.7373003363609314,
-0.7133726477622986,
0.30531173944473267,
0.3073931038379669,
0.23191674053668976,
-0.08641059696674347,
-0.9943886399269104,
-0.3795703649520874,
-0.3006335496902466,
-0.05182772874832153,
-0.21959730982780457,
0.2153172641992569,
0.4010223150253296,
0.4629703462123871,
0.71803879737854,
-0.7666376829147339,
0.29422229528427124,
-0.36102548241615295,
-0.06950083374977112,
0.39517244696617126,
0.3479171097278595,
0.26787784695625305,
0.03404167294502258,
0.0001814302959246561,
-0.18502074480056763,
-0.9254461526870728,
-0.19749599695205688,
0.2442939579486847,
0.5902997255325317,
-0.12051985412836075,
0.28828510642051697,
-0.6276370286941528,
0.9538800120353699,
0.15856269001960754,
0.34843870997428894,
0.05427657440304756,
-0.22122018039226532,
-0.6396003365516663,
-0.22160424292087555,
0.7930063605308533,
-0.31209269165992737,
0.3119388520717621,
-0.3885357081890106,
-0.06050417199730873,
0.0675259381532669,
0.3953230679035187,
-0.9960561394691467,
-0.5271247029304504,
0.11651274561882019,
-0.15470242500305176,
-0.34587737917900085,
-0.06154240295290947,
-0.7569078803062439,
-0.11965680867433548,
-0.7159101963043213,
0.5238563418388367,
-0.4064881503582001,
0.029591675847768784,
0.39022380113601685,
0.23971812427043915,
0.1517711728811264,
0.37425675988197327,
-1.4034615755081177,
0.19935981929302216,
0.5835442543029785,
0.7019647359848022,
0.04583102464675903,
-0.2606850564479828,
-0.48043107986450195,
-0.08207283169031143,
-0.42059507966041565,
0.37243109941482544,
-0.6516671776771545,
-0.6020522117614746,
-0.04636190086603165,
0.15113238990306854,
-0.2172567993402481,
-0.5394325256347656,
0.01042600441724062,
-0.5479662418365479,
0.1483723670244217,
-0.23650169372558594,
-0.5546605587005615,
0.10315271466970444,
0.06314343959093094,
-0.7517868280410767,
0.6020604968070984,
0.41732674837112427,
-0.2488335818052292,
-0.012755428440868855,
-0.4470587968826294,
-0.7166556119918823,
0.2193702757358551,
-0.24993407726287842,
-0.1918977051973343,
0.18907268345355988,
-0.063055619597435,
0.6629427671432495,
-0.5691387057304382,
0.24261853098869324,
-0.08657639473676682,
-0.42586925625801086,
-0.34270399808883667,
-0.215245321393013,
0.715506911277771,
0.39569002389907837,
-0.4820614755153656,
0.32346075773239136,
-0.816021203994751,
0.40993621945381165,
-0.08432018011808395,
-0.5882097482681274,
0.195980504155159,
-0.1340457648038864,
-0.0748927965760231,
0.23405082523822784,
0.13425740599632263,
-0.12050113826990128,
0.15856023132801056,
-0.6710698008537292,
0.6052442193031311,
0.5364630222320557,
-0.2638322710990906,
0.7048306465148926,
-0.2017374187707901,
0.619698166847229,
-0.019928278401494026,
-0.08820991218090057,
-0.4442994296550751,
-0.26232948899269104,
-0.8671233654022217,
-0.014151022769510746,
0.47905686497688293,
0.6607174277305603,
-0.7559181451797485,
0.4527677595615387,
-0.29505908489227295,
-0.5597754120826721,
-0.3186310827732086,
0.4446938931941986,
0.6819071173667908,
0.4466284513473511,
0.4698753356933594,
-0.4235686957836151,
-0.5682441592216492,
-0.694105863571167,
-0.023015283048152924,
0.15297497808933258,
-0.22831790149211884,
0.0072586932219564915,
0.4353320598602295,
-0.3201025128364563,
0.6722052693367004,
-0.3774217963218689,
0.01343759335577488,
-0.17314717173576355,
0.5218849778175354,
0.029345005750656128,
0.8904081583023071,
0.33401092886924744,
-0.8072516918182373,
-0.42433130741119385,
0.11326730996370316,
-0.6636030673980713,
0.21349340677261353,
0.06598850339651108,
-0.06478091329336166,
-0.020582590252161026,
0.8385136723518372,
-0.5170937180519104,
0.12894423305988312,
0.4032949209213257,
-0.028867870569229126,
0.6256460547447205,
-0.25855085253715515,
0.09206951409578323,
-1.0757704973220825,
0.17580989003181458,
-0.16434481739997864,
-0.1156545877456665,
-0.9403135776519775,
0.17836256325244904,
0.09578083455562592,
-0.43830931186676025,
-0.6545214056968689,
0.4084564447402954,
-0.3401000499725342,
0.10968964546918869,
-0.2926924228668213,
-0.5016169548034668,
-0.1673409342765808,
0.5370981097221375,
0.2977142632007599,
0.6024439930915833,
0.594325065612793,
-0.7720047235488892,
0.25929248332977295,
-0.0070472764782607555,
-0.6474068760871887,
0.09251005947589874,
-0.8316952586174011,
0.2451174110174179,
-0.10086072236299515,
-0.05395543575286865,
-0.5301752686500549,
-0.49032166600227356,
0.0587904192507267,
-0.013634227216243744,
0.5174046158790588,
-0.07580488175153732,
-0.3013549745082855,
-0.1747513711452484,
0.2665582299232483,
0.5318107008934021,
0.6923618316650391,
-0.33251163363456726,
0.4968201518058777,
-0.1942911595106125,
-0.26036548614501953,
-0.4967198371887207,
-0.4008511006832123,
-0.361142635345459,
0.014571329578757286,
-0.3001062273979187,
0.5211784839630127,
-0.2177254557609558,
0.15039318799972534,
-0.16639822721481323,
0.04734217748045921,
-0.0006776400259695947,
0.20790740847587585,
0.3163786828517914,
0.02681274339556694,
-0.42131248116493225,
0.01595354452729225,
-0.04538417607545853,
-0.1403956562280655,
-0.09964572638273239,
-0.6321994066238403,
0.7167221307754517,
-0.36779165267944336,
-0.3172825276851654,
-0.21965762972831726,
0.3539530038833618,
0.33245784044265747,
-0.22325894236564636,
0.7170805931091309,
0.3467613160610199,
-0.4999506175518036,
-0.3041861057281494,
-0.167369082570076,
-0.14307571947574615,
-0.5132668614387512,
0.568581223487854,
-0.2935282588005066,
-1.1229839324951172,
0.3111597001552582,
-0.26580968499183655,
-0.16492028534412384,
0.4667957127094269,
0.5251954197883606,
-0.048716966062784195,
0.7885550856590271,
0.7634499669075012,
-0.23730947077274323,
0.5635305643081665,
-0.3293536305427551,
0.04712309315800667,
-0.3424411118030548,
-0.14593440294265747,
-0.543307363986969,
-0.10280845314264297,
-0.2188010811805725,
-0.541230320930481,
0.03619774058461189,
0.5117865204811096,
-0.6258547306060791,
0.21790197491645813,
-0.2844811975955963,
0.7114601731300354,
0.5972176194190979,
0.201127827167511,
-0.10753872245550156,
0.05774715915322304,
-0.2725471258163452,
0.30347782373428345,
-0.7542012333869934,
-0.49914485216140747,
1.1002899408340454,
-0.03139757737517357,
0.7814387679100037,
-0.1331096887588501,
0.5495085716247559,
0.28473642468452454,
0.3277343809604645,
-0.6013087034225464,
0.41561827063560486,
-0.4124925434589386,
-0.6272459626197815,
-0.5115135908126831,
-0.46441125869750977,
-0.8257750272750854,
-0.10706079006195068,
-0.047036681324243546,
-0.6645656824111938,
0.17690956592559814,
0.49695122241973877,
-0.6570757031440735,
0.17493095993995667,
-0.8371813893318176,
1.3694021701812744,
-0.31164196133613586,
-0.13088905811309814,
-0.1103224977850914,
-0.8861335515975952,
0.2690577805042267,
-0.11629349738359451,
0.09223584830760956,
0.11907753348350525,
0.36682939529418945,
0.4464111924171448,
-0.6130802631378174,
1.138237476348877,
-0.09107514470815659,
-0.06263551861047745,
0.17449334263801575,
-0.0048309494741261005,
0.43724220991134644,
-0.21446208655834198,
-0.07684280723333359,
-0.17138612270355225,
-0.11905141919851303,
-0.6233482956886292,
-0.6105981469154358,
0.5755543112754822,
-0.7447617053985596,
-0.6508792042732239,
-0.04416864365339279,
-0.40356820821762085,
-0.30447325110435486,
0.3296997845172882,
0.5430058240890503,
0.41096967458724976,
-0.5907273292541504,
0.24642612040042877,
0.9218106269836426,
-0.08595865219831467,
0.36517763137817383,
0.36350035667419434,
0.13132649660110474,
-0.23950812220573425,
1.0430505275726318,
-0.25110766291618347,
0.5981572270393372,
0.7259257435798645,
-0.12661419808864594,
0.05684840306639671,
-0.5821788311004639,
-0.5216347575187683,
-0.08626405894756317,
-0.7638235092163086,
-0.04998640716075897,
-0.4761536717414856,
-0.28321292996406555,
-0.41189640760421753,
-0.3215119242668152,
-0.4762624204158783,
-0.24751737713813782,
-0.6736231446266174,
-0.02499591000378132,
0.04748411476612091,
0.6941904425621033,
-0.006826442666351795,
0.6054373383522034,
-0.8208020925521851,
0.3709118664264679,
0.7022250890731812,
0.39069220423698425,
0.03337648883461952,
-0.48542532324790955,
-0.6112097501754761,
0.2672004997730255,
-0.09843558073043823,
-0.7175290584564209,
0.2656196355819702,
0.5493402481079102,
0.3960590064525604,
0.4474617838859558,
-0.2645460367202759,
0.6171062588691711,
-0.9156634211540222,
0.6439574360847473,
0.12700767815113068,
-1.0664329528808594,
0.8102495670318604,
-0.4403240978717804,
0.4088076949119568,
0.4709635078907013,
0.6923641562461853,
-0.30117952823638916,
0.256943017244339,
-0.4650183320045471,
-0.677385687828064,
0.8232805728912354,
-0.031142987310886383,
0.0708077996969223,
-0.08272046595811844,
0.652417778968811,
0.0002792159793898463,
0.3162936866283417,
-0.4199869930744171,
-0.20110832154750824,
-0.48355844616889954,
-0.47258976101875305,
-0.6052724719047546,
-0.142240509390831,
-0.1135251522064209,
-0.3503339886665344,
0.5479467511177063,
-0.3517007827758789,
0.14867043495178223,
-0.22206711769104004,
-0.4719264805316925,
-0.1209392100572586,
0.44132187962532043,
0.790195643901825,
0.4752851128578186,
-0.14521653950214386,
-0.010810204781591892,
0.13331660628318787,
-0.5719252228736877,
0.3956073522567749,
0.34219008684158325,
-0.07749997824430466,
-0.36219775676727295,
0.17237357795238495,
0.9322221875190735,
0.6137548089027405,
-0.7438669204711914,
0.16805292665958405,
0.26739180088043213,
-0.168465256690979,
-0.09001681953668594,
0.37033161520957947,
0.24673178791999817,
0.0490114763379097,
0.192930206656456,
-0.01934877038002014,
-0.05190061405301094,
-0.47927525639533997,
0.26553821563720703,
0.39544034004211426,
-0.3619142174720764,
-0.5228272676467896,
0.8141658902168274,
0.15794777870178223,
-0.18001575767993927,
0.7641277313232422,
-0.29126521944999695,
-0.34608370065689087,
0.796234130859375,
0.6066328287124634,
0.6980598568916321,
-0.46899983286857605,
0.25925323367118835,
0.3454473316669464,
0.2543019950389862,
-0.5177475810050964,
0.30595093965530396,
-0.06699447333812714,
-0.7534322738647461,
-0.37273353338241577,
-0.9574722051620483,
-0.36657968163490295,
0.3613276779651642,
-0.725151777267456,
0.07391384243965149,
-0.8712412714958191,
0.20814746618270874,
0.14122091233730316,
-0.1391850858926773,
-0.9097956418991089,
0.7674715518951416,
0.10652545839548111,
0.6690688133239746,
-0.8569164276123047,
1.0620486736297607,
0.8322979211807251,
-0.4153699278831482,
-0.8315240144729614,
-0.5240927338600159,
0.0029185055755078793,
-0.5235331058502197,
0.8275175094604492,
0.14340263605117798,
-0.09199394285678864,
0.4260053336620331,
-0.5647103190422058,
-0.820508599281311,
1.0461705923080444,
0.5740190744400024,
-0.7874242663383484,
-0.4996522068977356,
0.3795381486415863,
0.5210177898406982,
-0.5374466180801392,
-0.12298919260501862,
0.6555872559547424,
-0.08844474703073502,
0.09261657297611237,
-0.8108242750167847,
0.006282507907599211,
-0.4601678252220154,
0.25009235739707947,
0.06776764988899231,
-0.36719900369644165,
1.1108818054199219,
-0.2734485864639282,
-0.28232356905937195,
0.5303615927696228,
0.7746821045875549,
0.1727636307477951,
-0.08180561661720276,
0.36123526096343994,
0.7814167737960815,
0.6499844789505005,
-0.17780496180057526,
1.0531138181686401,
-0.16687750816345215,
0.12047233432531357,
1.1460059881210327,
-0.15999560058116913,
0.7397271990776062,
0.015027343295514584,
-0.2321750968694687,
0.5745575428009033,
0.6915462613105774,
0.09736426919698715,
0.6851846575737,
0.3645063042640686,
-0.3973974585533142,
-0.5171331167221069,
0.3037712872028351,
-0.5266750454902649,
0.06941372156143188,
0.6405854225158691,
-0.4874444007873535,
-0.10412726551294327,
0.1336720734834671,
-0.29514384269714355,
-0.03266299515962601,
-0.4800330400466919,
0.46022120118141174,
0.111592136323452,
-0.5347681641578674,
0.586681067943573,
0.06307078152894974,
0.5170196294784546,
-0.6648240089416504,
-0.027447646483778954,
-0.03958112746477127,
0.10992372035980225,
-0.021870281547307968,
-0.12307190895080566,
0.014947840012609959,
-0.10083670169115067,
-0.5045939087867737,
-0.2625570595264435,
0.5516991019248962,
-0.5027958154678345,
-0.393671452999115,
-0.1900235116481781,
0.3460645079612732,
0.023842521011829376,
-0.1956593096256256,
-0.5027667284011841,
-0.20093494653701782,
-0.08755119144916534,
-0.09825178980827332,
0.4002341032028198,
0.37085872888565063,
0.041438065469264984,
0.5194026231765747,
0.5287723541259766,
-0.09670079499483109,
0.20693743228912354,
0.13434311747550964,
0.7833878397941589,
-0.8987407684326172,
-0.5893672108650208,
-0.6080101132392883,
0.5455785989761353,
0.37136608362197876,
-0.30327752232551575,
0.3335131108760834,
0.43143144249916077,
1.2209402322769165,
-0.5878163576126099,
0.8518239855766296,
-0.12257124483585358,
0.2743460237979889,
-0.8108614683151245,
0.595536470413208,
-0.3537920415401459,
0.13959254324436188,
-0.1563831865787506,
-0.7506793141365051,
-0.20932893455028534,
0.5859193801879883,
-0.22319187223911285,
0.5087133646011353,
0.5783547163009644,
0.7811186909675598,
-0.06390902400016785,
0.18498380482196808,
0.4116620123386383,
-0.024853739887475967,
0.11291872709989548,
0.8177535533905029,
0.758317232131958,
-0.2896821200847626,
0.16177751123905182,
-0.2848402261734009,
0.021581606939435005,
-0.20539164543151855,
-0.8165062069892883,
-0.9714118838310242,
-0.6033033132553101,
-0.31103187799453735,
-0.012808416970074177,
0.20914243161678314,
0.883610188961029,
0.9661283493041992,
-1.1555792093276978,
-0.20848801732063293,
-0.5417017340660095,
-0.19082826375961304,
-0.13880395889282227,
-0.14731554687023163,
0.2263762503862381,
-0.6966841220855713,
-0.7444785237312317,
0.5673675537109375,
0.04256740212440491,
0.42317259311676025,
-0.12183836847543716,
-0.25540879368782043,
-0.03666353225708008,
-0.2574360966682434,
0.6146495342254639,
0.9142027497291565,
-0.6753281354904175,
-0.15510427951812744,
0.10645624250173569,
-0.26725906133651733,
-0.20455200970172882,
1.0633877515792847,
-0.7709342837333679,
0.4197419285774231,
0.2536110281944275,
0.8524026274681091,
0.42924195528030396,
-0.04294038563966751,
0.9260266423225403,
-0.987465500831604,
0.28098052740097046,
0.23558121919631958,
0.18890804052352905,
0.36895400285720825,
-0.25787970423698425,
0.36006611585617065,
0.21092064678668976,
-0.3539893627166748,
-0.5449712872505188,
0.4275664985179901,
-0.7677327990531921,
-0.3096177279949188,
0.8203381299972534,
-0.21179772913455963,
0.044363003224134445,
0.060296181589365005,
0.2306300550699234,
0.4215850532054901,
0.1938626766204834,
0.541752815246582,
0.512970507144928,
0.07546088844537735,
-0.16768676042556763,
-0.34252288937568665,
0.9946535229682922,
0.6690846085548401,
-0.8990572094917297,
-0.12820832431316376,
0.5538092851638794,
0.2452390044927597,
0.09229779988527298,
0.5069242119789124,
-0.01047389954328537,
0.4918607473373413,
-0.05951594561338425,
0.058835718780756,
-0.1108517125248909,
-0.6558710932731628,
-0.5591761469841003,
0.17954806983470917,
0.11640100181102753,
0.00848548486828804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05602v2 | AttnLRP: Attention-Aware Layer-Wise Relevance Propagation for Transformers | 2024-02-08T12:01:24 | 2024-06-10T09:58:55 | Reduan Achtibat, Sayed Mohammad Vakilzadeh Hatefi, Maximilian Dreyer, Aakriti Jain, Thomas Wiegand, Sebastian Lapuschkin, Wojciech Samek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large Language Models are prone to biased predictions and hallucinations,
underlining the paramount importance of understanding their model-internal
reasoning process. However, achieving faithful attributions for the entirety of
a black-box transformer model and maintaining computational efficiency is an
unsolved challenge. By extending the Layer-wise Relevance Propagation
attribution method to handle attention layers, we address these challenges
effectively. While partial solutions exist, our method is the first to
faithfully and holistically attribute not only input but also latent
representations of transformer models with the computational efficiency similar
to a single backward pass. Through extensive evaluations against existing
methods on LLaMa 2, Mixtral 8x7b, Flan-T5 and vision transformer architectures,
we demonstrate that our proposed approach surpasses alternative methods in
terms of faithfulness and enables the understanding of latent representations,
opening up the door for concept-based explanations. We provide an LRP library
at https://github.com/rachtibat/LRP-eXplains-Transformers. | [
-0.01283245999366045,
-0.5327941179275513,
0.7842437624931335,
0.29150548577308655,
-0.2222203016281128,
-0.08762160688638687,
-0.24410855770111084,
-0.4456261098384857,
-0.1785539984703064,
0.6695235967636108,
-0.39520007371902466,
0.04956870153546333,
-0.41790395975112915,
-0.3963980972766876,
-0.6000807285308838,
0.7447411417961121,
0.019037466496229172,
-0.3420087993144989,
-0.1956949532032013,
0.09188591688871384,
-0.0958317294716835,
-0.38576769828796387,
-0.5187218189239502,
-0.8373847603797913,
0.8685362935066223,
0.2902319133281708,
0.7835019826889038,
0.4498201608657837,
0.7115976810455322,
0.2321517914533615,
-0.4465900957584381,
0.025242457166314125,
-0.5086284279823303,
0.2194531410932541,
-0.44956067204475403,
-0.38996702432632446,
-0.297751784324646,
-0.25034597516059875,
0.7220757007598877,
0.3956212103366852,
-0.3051132559776306,
0.387002557516098,
0.10262361913919449,
0.4829886853694916,
-0.6966365575790405,
-0.020777536556124687,
-0.9834488034248352,
0.22097842395305634,
-0.05354949086904526,
-0.5249959230422974,
-0.7751885056495667,
-0.1659543663263321,
0.05546046793460846,
-0.43858158588409424,
0.3614136874675751,
-0.03261185064911842,
0.6046530604362488,
0.6287980079650879,
-0.21147169172763824,
0.293779581785202,
-1.0966675281524658,
0.9695762395858765,
-0.39223456382751465,
0.655013382434845,
0.300597608089447,
0.7003852128982544,
0.05691935867071152,
-0.9658094644546509,
-0.5530619025230408,
-0.04053010791540146,
-0.25239211320877075,
0.25776711106300354,
-0.11532167345285416,
-0.08874346315860748,
0.140522301197052,
0.5768885016441345,
-0.20754575729370117,
-0.23990866541862488,
-0.3473883271217346,
-0.35720863938331604,
0.2052331268787384,
-0.23377715051174164,
-0.36322563886642456,
-0.10348967462778091,
-0.33978375792503357,
-0.3089296817779541,
-0.5649957060813904,
-0.15063941478729248,
0.06751561909914017,
0.17218376696109772,
-0.03379026800394058,
0.7306017279624939,
0.29924553632736206,
0.5926744937896729,
0.3059772849082947,
-0.03987528756260872,
0.16033312678337097,
-0.4146342873573303,
-0.10516383498907089,
0.21705478429794312,
0.545874297618866,
-0.033552296459674835,
0.03629104048013687,
-0.5991992950439453,
-0.2678561210632324,
0.014425208792090416,
0.8576313853263855,
-0.516805112361908,
-0.0011821695370599627,
0.22947396337985992,
-0.562004804611206,
-0.4336159825325012,
-0.25620588660240173,
-0.756125807762146,
-0.2621780037879944,
-0.05012322589755058,
0.5727173089981079,
-0.06315566599369049,
-0.2691993713378906,
0.07636617869138718,
0.05693051591515541,
0.5260642170906067,
0.3265269696712494,
-0.5580708980560303,
-0.051509588956832886,
0.8213298320770264,
0.6287749409675598,
-0.02900734171271324,
0.003919814247637987,
-0.46518445014953613,
0.47242018580436707,
0.039756957441568375,
0.7453437447547913,
-0.6070669889450073,
-0.00011603852908592671,
-0.16888485848903656,
-0.2588876187801361,
0.024529309943318367,
-0.46822524070739746,
0.9941022992134094,
-0.7803710699081421,
0.28075647354125977,
0.035617999732494354,
-0.22327332198619843,
-0.04092970862984657,
0.17817091941833496,
-0.5592631101608276,
1.0416498184204102,
0.32633763551712036,
-0.8274544477462769,
0.002246999414637685,
-0.7255983352661133,
-0.4811304807662964,
-0.22593706846237183,
0.026796087622642517,
-0.6202032566070557,
0.4759446680545807,
0.3384023606777191,
0.5036627650260925,
-0.26374223828315735,
0.3279174864292145,
-0.001759759383276105,
-0.35410282015800476,
0.2621508538722992,
-0.7444368004798889,
0.5156440734863281,
0.19840121269226074,
-0.3438689112663269,
0.2862752079963684,
-0.6271935105323792,
0.01904934272170067,
0.40473732352256775,
0.03527936711907387,
-0.06866800040006638,
-0.037844542413949966,
0.03759649023413658,
0.16978894174098969,
0.07758451253175735,
-0.4366375207901001,
-0.0040329922921955585,
-0.38025832176208496,
0.5000380277633667,
0.7270346879959106,
-0.1143595278263092,
0.6127935647964478,
-0.12449062615633011,
0.36169230937957764,
0.012685573659837246,
0.3781351149082184,
-0.16152817010879517,
-0.5747753977775574,
-0.7445282936096191,
0.10445310920476913,
-0.13098359107971191,
0.4685545563697815,
-0.7543461322784424,
0.33330702781677246,
-0.4570469856262207,
-0.5420535206794739,
-0.6029511094093323,
-0.1448005735874176,
0.3997308909893036,
0.9027548432350159,
0.7095156908035278,
-0.0321313813328743,
-0.35580143332481384,
-1.0105184316635132,
-0.19270695745944977,
-0.23121897876262665,
-0.2247045636177063,
0.44790682196617126,
0.2059209793806076,
-0.2510097026824951,
0.7525554299354553,
-0.34962671995162964,
-0.5309795141220093,
-0.4079521596431732,
-0.16717609763145447,
0.3556919991970062,
0.33965131640434265,
0.38778525590896606,
-0.937330961227417,
-0.28970834612846375,
0.17126215994358063,
-0.4602449834346771,
0.06369677186012268,
-0.028169957920908928,
-0.22594930231571198,
-0.18876798450946808,
0.35298705101013184,
-0.578982412815094,
0.2799675762653351,
0.5265309810638428,
-0.16451232135295868,
0.2615925371646881,
-0.004674297757446766,
-0.018286019563674927,
-0.869657576084137,
0.21611224114894867,
-0.11466579139232635,
-0.4247383177280426,
-0.6881760358810425,
0.2622334063053131,
0.17867878079414368,
-0.07467404752969742,
-0.525401771068573,
0.594740629196167,
-0.09961724281311035,
-0.14820478856563568,
-0.06509780883789062,
0.06549612432718277,
0.20362241566181183,
0.49825364351272583,
-0.02205190435051918,
0.8645576238632202,
0.39639705419540405,
-0.45228320360183716,
0.3249955475330353,
0.23402097821235657,
-0.2561688721179962,
0.2694311738014221,
-0.9007568359375,
0.4187796115875244,
-0.2894536852836609,
0.3429996967315674,
-0.7472329139709473,
-0.11869174242019653,
0.5287230610847473,
-0.26753291487693787,
0.36997389793395996,
-0.09886385500431061,
-0.5401967167854309,
-0.42849352955818176,
-0.11056722700595856,
0.7367562055587769,
0.5846062898635864,
-0.7776839137077332,
1.1067161560058594,
0.09981955587863922,
0.35073167085647583,
-0.7720310091972351,
-0.8704826235771179,
-0.0992279201745987,
-0.41704848408699036,
-0.4696641266345978,
0.7922105193138123,
0.09357079118490219,
-0.11254017800092697,
-0.0295475535094738,
-0.3511470854282379,
-0.1222039982676506,
-0.08977865427732468,
-0.12401676923036575,
-0.10493119806051254,
-0.317758172750473,
-0.043570276349782944,
-0.23499928414821625,
-0.2602933645248413,
0.18337872624397278,
-0.3450567424297333,
0.4080452024936676,
-0.04800496622920036,
-0.5192650556564331,
-0.31457453966140747,
0.13392159342765808,
0.39624759554862976,
-0.3356660008430481,
0.7371999621391296,
0.7614260315895081,
-0.27858850359916687,
-0.24219092726707458,
-0.7857973575592041,
-0.4502337574958801,
-0.5200455188751221,
0.2805488109588623,
-0.3106076419353485,
-0.7954332232475281,
0.7819547057151794,
0.300603985786438,
-0.06119602546095848,
0.5872620344161987,
0.49848076701164246,
0.07169356942176819,
0.7025291323661804,
0.7603106498718262,
-0.07363447546958923,
0.5698439478874207,
-0.05707350745797157,
0.4833359122276306,
-0.941382646560669,
-0.4222835898399353,
-0.4470399022102356,
-0.21325989067554474,
-0.17560407519340515,
-0.8920202255249023,
0.3344469666481018,
-0.0831616222858429,
-0.07158531248569489,
0.34746700525283813,
-0.7993878722190857,
0.6016878485679626,
0.34345871210098267,
0.41487690806388855,
0.36854007840156555,
0.2759638726711273,
0.23207004368305206,
-0.08816150575876236,
-0.7350703477859497,
-0.21800662577152252,
0.836349606513977,
0.666753888130188,
0.895896315574646,
0.13470521569252014,
0.3541180491447449,
0.15024319291114807,
0.35753872990608215,
-0.7616391777992249,
0.35221293568611145,
-0.10257977247238159,
-0.4438058137893677,
-0.15025463700294495,
-0.48544400930404663,
-0.58842533826828,
0.20844170451164246,
0.3090699315071106,
-0.8702113628387451,
0.26762187480926514,
0.5252460837364197,
-0.1949438601732254,
0.4155251383781433,
-0.426667720079422,
0.809449315071106,
-0.19258011877536774,
-0.6290358304977417,
-0.41118794679641724,
-0.7794941663742065,
0.3330334424972534,
-0.14137515425682068,
-0.07475868612527847,
0.26084843277931213,
-0.0091747110709548,
0.4517457187175751,
-0.09718724340200424,
0.6061499714851379,
-0.05247551202774048,
-0.5473410487174988,
0.3568243682384491,
-0.11578847467899323,
0.7196676135063171,
0.08010486513376236,
-0.32266074419021606,
0.10894611477851868,
-0.7397446036338806,
-0.14269104599952698,
-0.8921211957931519,
0.5735862255096436,
-0.5736978054046631,
-0.556885838508606,
-0.042741887271404266,
-0.46754777431488037,
-0.11712950468063354,
0.0940079391002655,
0.31648555397987366,
0.28338634967803955,
0.2944606840610504,
0.46053823828697205,
0.960578203201294,
-0.07818275690078735,
0.15571583807468414,
-0.01761670969426632,
-0.18199826776981354,
-0.06781093031167984,
0.9118621945381165,
-0.33484992384910583,
0.37343108654022217,
0.7240346670150757,
0.4059312641620636,
-0.443603515625,
-0.338552325963974,
-0.18674664199352264,
0.23024363815784454,
-1.106950044631958,
-0.33570170402526855,
-0.7432631850242615,
-0.48261579871177673,
-0.11367194354534149,
-0.16040420532226562,
-0.709585428237915,
-0.36773577332496643,
-0.35368531942367554,
0.19505250453948975,
0.25870269536972046,
0.45837339758872986,
0.22035528719425201,
0.4587256610393524,
-0.5071975588798523,
0.6598896980285645,
0.3331988453865051,
0.657047688961029,
0.37546220421791077,
-1.0625330209732056,
-0.12742385268211365,
-0.004325537476688623,
-0.4505694508552551,
-0.6443230509757996,
0.0552060529589653,
0.40446287393569946,
0.7561237215995789,
0.3588024079799652,
0.06160325929522514,
0.68494713306427,
-0.5113963484764099,
0.614086925983429,
-0.02034468576312065,
-0.9867252707481384,
0.7085585594177246,
-0.12133421003818512,
0.3540307581424713,
0.2892191708087921,
0.09992264211177826,
-0.273619145154953,
-0.5386958718299866,
-0.6887915730476379,
-0.9612876772880554,
0.6977173089981079,
0.5269796848297119,
0.20386873185634613,
0.3237411677837372,
0.6017698645591736,
-0.11965253949165344,
0.12397247552871704,
-1.037104845046997,
-0.4236544668674469,
-0.6065419316291809,
-0.12528353929519653,
-0.14547908306121826,
-0.4148560166358948,
-0.0374092273414135,
-0.2703031003475189,
0.6543837189674377,
-0.24522416293621063,
0.7815129160881042,
0.2927841246128082,
-0.22961458563804626,
-0.2874615788459778,
0.4142555296421051,
0.6947236657142639,
0.6905303597450256,
-0.22907871007919312,
0.44785866141319275,
-0.005678392015397549,
-0.3499200642108917,
0.04831293225288391,
-0.0644528716802597,
-0.07273745536804199,
-0.04135677218437195,
0.4444977939128876,
0.735778272151947,
0.21646684408187866,
-0.2577805519104004,
0.5809533596038818,
-0.0038284403271973133,
0.040455810725688934,
-0.30536216497421265,
0.023770291358232498,
-0.10254844278097153,
0.480959951877594,
0.667363166809082,
0.19375774264335632,
0.21094658970832825,
-0.3363933861255646,
0.2665674388408661,
0.3113705515861511,
-0.663968026638031,
-0.32764962315559387,
0.847456693649292,
-0.12499023228883743,
-0.10576990246772766,
0.571712076663971,
0.19815132021903992,
-0.8521832227706909,
0.4654220640659332,
0.7029815316200256,
0.9754055142402649,
-0.34880971908569336,
-0.0075516668148338795,
0.2816714644432068,
0.43982985615730286,
-0.17746596038341522,
-0.09466131776571274,
-0.279921293258667,
-0.8000203967094421,
-0.8132968544960022,
-0.5263510346412659,
-0.44150084257125854,
0.19489668309688568,
-0.5654282569885254,
0.14781585335731506,
-0.12244168668985367,
-0.028497887775301933,
0.10141724348068237,
-0.6149458289146423,
-0.5522817373275757,
0.007635309360921383,
0.25449761748313904,
0.674163818359375,
-0.5967865586280823,
0.8554596900939941,
0.6193188428878784,
-0.11151069402694702,
-0.7037514448165894,
0.24293260276317596,
-0.4842635989189148,
-0.9274013042449951,
0.6460347771644592,
0.217275470495224,
-0.38254407048225403,
0.06112714484333992,
-0.4640880227088928,
-0.9466356635093689,
0.8303831219673157,
0.581488847732544,
-0.2450636625289917,
0.005068134516477585,
0.20960669219493866,
0.602804958820343,
-0.19566844403743744,
0.4798405170440674,
0.18225304782390594,
0.6020868420600891,
0.3947635293006897,
-0.8616753220558167,
-0.0053927055560052395,
-0.04364221170544624,
0.04870910197496414,
0.023325007408857346,
-0.5109127759933472,
0.3463670015335083,
-0.39961525797843933,
-0.08549279719591141,
-0.2962746024131775,
0.8769087195396423,
0.052493903785943985,
0.04428980126976967,
0.5865378975868225,
0.3484255075454712,
0.2863847315311432,
-0.2273695319890976,
1.1124317646026611,
-0.15307238698005676,
0.4593693017959595,
1.1181812286376953,
-0.022631723433732986,
0.7280182242393494,
0.8160534501075745,
-0.1253671795129776,
0.32982635498046875,
0.24015949666500092,
0.10603488981723785,
0.8341177701950073,
-0.0015657299663871527,
0.011119522154331207,
-0.34814509749412537,
-0.46746698021888733,
-0.4141044616699219,
0.43094074726104736,
0.23464509844779968,
-0.6787568926811218,
-0.138985276222229,
0.010639437474310398,
-0.36654627323150635,
-0.07511270046234131,
-0.3489500880241394,
0.664505660533905,
0.1488531082868576,
-0.5328922271728516,
0.5235546231269836,
-0.21649740636348724,
0.6102750301361084,
-0.562928318977356,
-0.15478672087192535,
-0.04534232243895531,
0.5820775628089905,
-0.2620641887187958,
-1.0081156492233276,
0.6513612270355225,
-0.2737312614917755,
-0.36275798082351685,
-0.7022338509559631,
0.9904174208641052,
-0.4444139003753662,
-0.6457433700561523,
0.34903019666671753,
0.16701450943946838,
-0.08926073461771011,
-0.283962607383728,
-0.5080389976501465,
0.13773325085639954,
0.0452706553041935,
-0.48637956380844116,
-0.047802750021219254,
0.38037586212158203,
-0.03744000568985939,
0.9158875942230225,
0.25325092673301697,
-0.07573872059583664,
0.08514383435249329,
0.3174823522567749,
0.9697983860969543,
-0.38339200615882874,
-0.2917386293411255,
-0.6980822086334229,
0.7348859906196594,
0.03202581778168678,
0.07295101881027222,
0.5291396975517273,
0.373965859413147,
0.6451235413551331,
-0.09897156059741974,
0.3795084059238434,
0.19868969917297363,
0.3754614591598511,
-0.29509690403938293,
0.565203845500946,
-0.8266042470932007,
0.38068509101867676,
-0.3994808793067932,
-1.5054740905761719,
-0.4564220905303955,
0.9190091490745544,
-0.04462316632270813,
0.1534854620695114,
0.5345211029052734,
0.5181357264518738,
-0.6699891090393066,
-0.11212051659822464,
0.21713601052761078,
0.26650679111480713,
0.37724047899246216,
0.4916982650756836,
0.898743212223053,
-0.6649981737136841,
0.7057664394378662,
-0.626331090927124,
0.10763884335756302,
-0.2501053214073181,
-1.1523584127426147,
-0.7121629118919373,
-0.39972126483917236,
-0.30640554428100586,
-0.2372269332408905,
0.05202659219503403,
0.532293438911438,
0.5479157567024231,
-0.7288833260536194,
0.2152300328016281,
-0.13682767748832703,
0.20546162128448486,
-0.3119163513183594,
-0.25063690543174744,
0.45154181122779846,
-0.09726250171661377,
-0.31421709060668945,
0.31369081139564514,
0.1692182719707489,
-0.031840935349464417,
-0.59483802318573,
0.07664820551872253,
0.22563022375106812,
-0.15009096264839172,
0.7276816368103027,
-0.1269705891609192,
-1.0998109579086304,
-0.562507152557373,
0.055649787187576294,
0.00974853616207838,
0.2714695334434509,
0.9747586250305176,
-0.9461113810539246,
0.24306242167949677,
0.35997137427330017,
0.7573558688163757,
0.5987544655799866,
0.0033224804792553186,
0.5778294801712036,
-1.0121198892593384,
0.34031617641448975,
0.5106531381607056,
0.21858207881450653,
0.5228070020675659,
-0.6395228505134583,
0.521475613117218,
-0.05971033126115799,
-0.5179085731506348,
-0.8712481260299683,
0.29760661721229553,
-1.156233549118042,
0.11108572781085968,
1.0634320974349976,
-0.013413338921964169,
-0.22401992976665497,
-0.04730565473437309,
0.03890588879585266,
0.3813387453556061,
-0.4466889798641205,
0.8046945929527283,
0.20035292208194733,
0.1408429890871048,
-0.762252926826477,
-0.4036584496498108,
0.2917766869068146,
0.5901928544044495,
-0.5333225727081299,
0.384590208530426,
0.019908910617232323,
-0.2779527008533478,
0.5374825596809387,
0.2928633689880371,
-0.09888126701116562,
0.026456620544195175,
-0.31659284234046936,
-0.16346633434295654,
-0.09092504531145096,
-0.5205524563789368,
-0.2149730622768402,
0.15627150237560272,
-0.030510516837239265,
0.33397433161735535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05591v1 | SoftEDA: Rethinking Rule-Based Data Augmentation with Soft Labels | 2024-02-08T11:44:25 | 2024-02-08T11:44:25 | Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rule-based text data augmentation is widely used for NLP tasks due to its
simplicity. However, this method can potentially damage the original meaning of
the text, ultimately hurting the performance of the model. To overcome this
limitation, we propose a straightforward technique for applying soft labels to
augmented data. We conducted experiments across seven different classification
tasks and empirically demonstrated the effectiveness of our proposed approach.
We have publicly opened our source code for reproducibility. | [
-0.05432150140404701,
-0.9579771757125854,
0.3092828392982483,
-0.03680334612727165,
-0.4219553470611572,
-0.2974872887134552,
-0.18973472714424133,
-0.7194162011146545,
0.37378400564193726,
0.991155743598938,
-0.7751973867416382,
-0.5357350707054138,
-0.4423385560512543,
0.06945130228996277,
-0.3362340033054352,
1.5045559406280518,
-0.018832793459296227,
-0.3771721422672272,
-0.1499401479959488,
-0.4011145532131195,
-0.6907059550285339,
-0.6252190470695496,
-0.1622961461544037,
-0.22250425815582275,
0.7272337675094604,
0.6695660352706909,
1.1652791500091553,
0.7294659614562988,
0.7043581604957581,
0.37808653712272644,
-0.32888174057006836,
0.6134191155433655,
-0.34732410311698914,
0.37001708149909973,
-0.11847174912691116,
-0.5859807133674622,
-1.0211799144744873,
-0.1270747184753418,
0.5871878862380981,
1.1766325235366821,
-0.05140769109129906,
0.04139062389731407,
0.12901297211647034,
0.6514161825180054,
-0.5015468597412109,
0.07523822784423828,
-0.4779736399650574,
0.20001338422298431,
-0.36217933893203735,
-0.21435046195983887,
-0.28341466188430786,
-0.4947354197502136,
0.14008557796478271,
-0.8745743036270142,
0.42077770829200745,
-0.03248889371752739,
0.6213480234146118,
0.48151206970214844,
-0.4458538591861725,
-0.197798490524292,
-0.9296231269836426,
0.7444170117378235,
-0.7809599041938782,
0.21962293982505798,
0.16421976685523987,
-0.022231241688132286,
-0.16193948686122894,
-1.0647717714309692,
-0.6281549334526062,
0.022314097732305527,
-0.16174185276031494,
-0.21316419541835785,
0.19682422280311584,
0.23510022461414337,
0.42402905225753784,
0.5781076550483704,
-0.18154387176036835,
0.11143117398023605,
-0.3489380478858948,
-0.005261238198727369,
0.7476745843887329,
0.25964292883872986,
0.3472693860530853,
-0.15355367958545685,
-0.31952348351478577,
-0.16948054730892181,
-0.6368032097816467,
-0.22870668768882751,
0.27608418464660645,
0.7013946175575256,
0.2165641486644745,
0.8226037621498108,
-0.13559111952781677,
0.5419852137565613,
0.20557935535907745,
-0.11270737648010254,
0.9718142747879028,
-0.30559536814689636,
-0.22923098504543304,
0.18730662763118744,
0.4746279716491699,
0.37469062209129333,
-0.06189532205462456,
-0.40928009152412415,
-0.28605881333351135,
0.004933748859912157,
0.3713923990726471,
-0.7618173956871033,
0.18987955152988434,
0.1864463835954666,
-0.44291919469833374,
-0.4433619976043701,
-0.1209462359547615,
-0.904750406742096,
-0.5892274975776672,
-0.4106017053127289,
0.7565280199050903,
-0.2362031191587448,
-0.2597351670265198,
0.20470605790615082,
-0.10321782529354095,
-0.05718577653169632,
0.29486313462257385,
-0.9411330819129944,
0.5030354857444763,
1.1274508237838745,
0.6645792722702026,
0.05656926706433296,
-0.3312568664550781,
-0.3302482068538666,
0.12293370068073273,
-0.3906274735927582,
0.9569635391235352,
-0.4100182056427002,
-0.45810988545417786,
-0.07508634030818939,
0.20882272720336914,
0.13917727768421173,
-0.46827536821365356,
1.1156326532363892,
-0.25703033804893494,
0.20485559105873108,
-0.10954580456018448,
-0.7300487756729126,
-0.38651734590530396,
-0.12338767200708389,
-1.00052011013031,
0.8726617097854614,
0.008404872380197048,
-0.5325316786766052,
0.6955439448356628,
-0.6686944961547852,
-0.7486850023269653,
0.2782134711742401,
0.11738400161266327,
-0.6355534195899963,
0.0855313315987587,
0.021621892228722572,
0.5206766724586487,
0.004614589270204306,
0.48085686564445496,
-0.3580965995788574,
-0.4927087128162384,
0.3027685582637787,
-0.5742724537849426,
0.6115031242370605,
0.07501775771379471,
-0.4189792275428772,
0.1659965068101883,
-0.799281895160675,
0.053689926862716675,
-0.09338020533323288,
-0.3431243598461151,
-0.6869997382164001,
0.15758171677589417,
0.2284391224384308,
-0.11424817889928818,
0.19715987145900726,
-0.5197330117225647,
0.6308803558349609,
-0.8247039914131165,
-0.0932852029800415,
0.9157875180244446,
-0.3164106011390686,
0.6847389340400696,
-0.47457078099250793,
0.30965307354927063,
-0.2847372591495514,
0.2935638129711151,
-0.11397738009691238,
-0.6355109214782715,
-0.5121020078659058,
-0.20713910460472107,
0.7228664755821228,
0.5631793737411499,
-0.9544309973716736,
0.33918437361717224,
-0.28936830163002014,
-0.6323997378349304,
-0.8576933741569519,
0.6555386781692505,
0.18358953297138214,
0.7674241662025452,
0.564703106880188,
-0.3027760684490204,
-0.7113010287284851,
-0.9265708923339844,
-0.2573311924934387,
0.1541374772787094,
-0.02373211644589901,
0.395149290561676,
0.362172931432724,
-0.7236619591712952,
0.7324978709220886,
-0.717258095741272,
-0.4852128028869629,
-0.2060815542936325,
0.2514987289905548,
0.5753130316734314,
0.6051884889602661,
0.4654364287853241,
-1.0475252866744995,
0.07219823449850082,
-0.17146047949790955,
-0.6543532609939575,
-0.37401217222213745,
-0.0701347142457962,
0.13167640566825867,
0.1159871444106102,
0.3781207501888275,
-0.4262163043022156,
0.5507901906967163,
0.360912948846817,
-0.5385144948959351,
0.5844440460205078,
-0.364033967256546,
0.2620241045951843,
-0.8400996923446655,
-0.10762572288513184,
0.1851673573255539,
-0.13302871584892273,
-0.921223521232605,
0.26842740178108215,
0.001920874579809606,
-0.009404731914401054,
-0.5629841685295105,
0.4576490819454193,
-0.181947723031044,
0.15660716593265533,
-0.6190201640129089,
-0.290953665971756,
0.15474915504455566,
0.4933679401874542,
0.16745199263095856,
0.5599986910820007,
0.3469548225402832,
-0.7418872714042664,
0.3726860582828522,
0.33693352341651917,
-0.36472824215888977,
0.48026901483535767,
-0.9209089875221252,
0.15258359909057617,
-0.35161468386650085,
0.40034419298171997,
-0.8747280240058899,
-0.1477614790201187,
0.29520365595817566,
-0.1562431901693344,
0.31404465436935425,
-0.25655636191368103,
-0.6128858327865601,
0.019269375130534172,
-0.5361713767051697,
0.6840208172798157,
0.5055747628211975,
-0.7200620770454407,
0.7099898457527161,
0.6139340400695801,
-0.14450371265411377,
-0.40756136178970337,
-0.7481579780578613,
0.2342081069946289,
-0.5179188251495361,
-0.762148380279541,
0.776479184627533,
-0.0911710113286972,
-0.25518614053726196,
0.04189728572964668,
0.1424858123064041,
-0.2729417383670807,
0.11603840440511703,
0.5871878266334534,
0.22055085003376007,
-0.18302439153194427,
0.1654006391763687,
0.27353110909461975,
-0.178459033370018,
-0.24919696152210236,
0.15606345236301422,
0.17569348216056824,
-0.07177025824785233,
-0.0034202146343886852,
-0.44366106390953064,
0.4761626720428467,
0.3610222339630127,
0.1762193888425827,
0.8565308451652527,
0.4985182583332062,
-0.49901267886161804,
-0.3311249315738678,
-0.31655213236808777,
-0.08137945830821991,
-0.6355558037757874,
0.018033910542726517,
-0.2699204981327057,
-0.45275235176086426,
0.24033595621585846,
-0.2635643482208252,
0.3409578502178192,
0.5845339894294739,
0.3070838451385498,
-0.3125283122062683,
1.1930463314056396,
0.8155024647712708,
0.3316831886768341,
0.5418912172317505,
-0.19555775821208954,
-0.14335279166698456,
-0.8201355338096619,
-0.4121449291706085,
-0.5030131340026855,
-0.4739452004432678,
-0.7082441449165344,
-0.3824264407157898,
0.267706960439682,
-0.26257917284965515,
0.2320304661989212,
0.2973479926586151,
-0.6697449088096619,
0.189210906624794,
0.4185037612915039,
0.5239148736000061,
0.21709711849689484,
-0.10838724672794342,
0.4043290317058563,
-0.2540901005268097,
-0.7228650450706482,
-0.3819597363471985,
1.1773322820663452,
0.40662261843681335,
1.0160163640975952,
0.15331120789051056,
0.4532310366630554,
0.7306418418884277,
0.38316622376441956,
-0.7293936014175415,
0.5868415832519531,
-0.6414681077003479,
-0.6874316334724426,
0.014402491971850395,
-0.5264541506767273,
-1.2480249404907227,
0.08787157386541367,
-0.4951806366443634,
-0.268890917301178,
0.5207028388977051,
0.3142157196998596,
-0.20461294054985046,
0.1351792812347412,
-1.0515391826629639,
0.6607839465141296,
-0.31061893701553345,
-0.4230658710002899,
0.07723241299390793,
-0.35759320855140686,
0.3244433104991913,
-0.17088930308818817,
0.5051793456077576,
0.09849957376718521,
-0.36283984780311584,
1.4307256937026978,
-0.9776517748832703,
1.1440861225128174,
-0.2878919243812561,
-0.3649424612522125,
0.33869603276252747,
-0.29762253165245056,
0.32649436593055725,
-0.19864937663078308,
-0.11817646026611328,
0.03696515038609505,
-0.07617642730474472,
-0.3724703788757324,
-0.7976453900337219,
0.7387123107910156,
-0.44306373596191406,
-0.3702262341976166,
-0.37249556183815,
-0.5893541574478149,
-0.24733272194862366,
0.06208791956305504,
-0.20296089351177216,
0.6890839338302612,
0.19720064103603363,
0.33386510610580444,
0.6666245460510254,
-0.17324844002723694,
-0.04624498263001442,
0.5268864631652832,
-0.14718487858772278,
-0.4768856167793274,
1.0601459741592407,
0.39749303460121155,
-0.023763908073306084,
-0.0682692676782608,
0.2686474621295929,
-0.4253362715244293,
-0.5508977174758911,
-0.37347570061683655,
0.006360719911754131,
-0.432041734457016,
-0.2206728756427765,
-0.39692026376724243,
0.13732679188251495,
-0.5886302590370178,
-0.17941144108772278,
-0.2591756284236908,
-0.8445228934288025,
-0.4104776680469513,
-0.22475075721740723,
0.7849321961402893,
0.6946212649345398,
-0.21547862887382507,
0.5263797640800476,
-0.6772147417068481,
0.7276462316513062,
0.2418595850467682,
0.6824535727500916,
-0.4674457013607025,
-0.5604695081710815,
-0.08861025422811508,
0.34385448694229126,
0.06473163515329361,
-1.0787395238876343,
0.3172169029712677,
0.40251603722572327,
0.5383061170578003,
0.284362256526947,
-0.06867529451847076,
0.6486627459526062,
-0.683746874332428,
0.4628974497318268,
-0.06329981237649918,
-0.840328574180603,
0.7581554651260376,
-0.22068341076374054,
-0.05298912525177002,
0.7199960350990295,
0.07706748694181442,
-0.3653862476348877,
0.013544849120080471,
-0.8835952877998352,
-1.3361045122146606,
0.4214019775390625,
0.02995634451508522,
0.4049758017063141,
0.29623350501060486,
0.8088906407356262,
0.546202540397644,
0.2515872120857239,
-0.3196026384830475,
-0.46442633867263794,
-0.17285117506980896,
-0.5141502022743225,
-0.1217559203505516,
-0.3706674873828888,
0.19669070839881897,
-0.3300477862358093,
0.678417980670929,
-0.13964514434337616,
-0.03092341683804989,
0.18621836602687836,
-0.16604098677635193,
0.002942010760307312,
0.11828295141458511,
0.2361769825220108,
0.2964949309825897,
-0.33182159066200256,
0.022049201652407646,
0.3168228268623352,
-0.6007927060127258,
-0.05240544676780701,
0.3473901152610779,
-0.5865413546562195,
0.17179660499095917,
0.30339816212654114,
0.7097569704055786,
0.52484530210495,
-0.7618729472160339,
0.16499173641204834,
-0.017672887071967125,
-0.3480234146118164,
0.14812149107456207,
0.3345617949962616,
-0.5056908130645752,
-0.07735602557659149,
0.4094190001487732,
0.07880939543247223,
0.5443963408470154,
-0.8384711146354675,
0.641886293888092,
0.24488294124603271,
-0.4019347131252289,
-0.22347934544086456,
0.6025291085243225,
0.4302520155906677,
-0.595225989818573,
0.08617617189884186,
0.1276734322309494,
-0.6257639527320862,
0.54002445936203,
0.5834562182426453,
0.5346524715423584,
-0.23594823479652405,
0.2384476512670517,
-0.02540324069559574,
0.3206215798854828,
-0.054229140281677246,
0.3252822756767273,
0.09611749649047852,
-0.6704357266426086,
-0.7855415940284729,
-0.33504411578178406,
-0.7417101860046387,
0.07398199290037155,
-0.567631721496582,
0.21898625791072845,
-0.575192391872406,
-0.3279399871826172,
0.29946786165237427,
0.19015619158744812,
-0.5097798705101013,
0.5815167427062988,
0.17645111680030823,
0.8049383163452148,
-0.9543014764785767,
0.43769407272338867,
0.7091606259346008,
-0.2614041268825531,
-0.5307258367538452,
-0.34437593817710876,
-0.00570203410461545,
-0.47660160064697266,
0.1337578296661377,
0.0520687997341156,
0.049652714282274246,
-0.3845394551753998,
-0.8187904953956604,
-0.5102559328079224,
0.7290390729904175,
0.0897512435913086,
-0.29360437393188477,
0.13758574426174164,
0.12600724399089813,
0.7936475872993469,
-0.034436773508787155,
0.04915463179349899,
0.5336888432502747,
0.6365789175033569,
-0.050815947353839874,
-0.7499189376831055,
0.1366010308265686,
-0.5722401738166809,
-0.473635196685791,
0.19516946375370026,
-0.37413856387138367,
0.5650638937950134,
-0.16735903918743134,
-0.1918734461069107,
0.010152935981750488,
0.9596706628799438,
-0.044958412647247314,
0.7090741991996765,
0.7604156732559204,
0.4390048682689667,
0.9637536406517029,
-0.07637417316436768,
1.0360515117645264,
0.23292472958564758,
0.2097005844116211,
1.110088586807251,
-0.31962957978248596,
0.587824285030365,
0.33203986287117004,
-0.05832064896821976,
0.6702041625976562,
0.30750975012779236,
-0.08271326124668121,
0.42474013566970825,
-0.18791405856609344,
-0.19343625009059906,
0.14622041583061218,
-0.5730446577072144,
-0.3652132451534271,
0.31405404210090637,
0.69180828332901,
-0.11271161586046219,
0.030645092949271202,
0.16573868691921234,
0.13660243153572083,
0.14490856230258942,
-0.613174557685852,
0.9336465001106262,
-0.1542264223098755,
-0.33100005984306335,
0.42294391989707947,
0.10578791052103043,
1.1487079858779907,
-0.3330417573451996,
-0.310567170381546,
-0.008740246295928955,
0.3274991810321808,
-0.5258343815803528,
-1.1268634796142578,
0.5805880427360535,
0.2317366898059845,
-0.025971686467528343,
-0.40667158365249634,
1.2053710222244263,
-0.3738395869731903,
-0.7933116555213928,
-0.05491279438138008,
0.3897974491119385,
0.06967917084693909,
0.2049926519393921,
-0.7945305705070496,
-0.0669238492846489,
-0.06767264008522034,
-0.22399036586284637,
0.1811964362859726,
0.43943384289741516,
0.08503658324480057,
0.7894659638404846,
0.8796361684799194,
0.021018920466303825,
-0.0018569955136626959,
0.08427845686674118,
0.9172182679176331,
-0.6064077019691467,
-0.28239911794662476,
-0.6117473244667053,
0.447037935256958,
-0.016184357926249504,
-0.3180268406867981,
0.8282269239425659,
0.4805673062801361,
0.24561570584774017,
0.20395947992801666,
0.6438130140304565,
-0.0960765853524208,
0.6957993507385254,
-0.5466564893722534,
0.5096415281295776,
-0.705834686756134,
0.3907542824745178,
-0.605216383934021,
-0.7037310600280762,
-0.5174751877784729,
0.2689721882343292,
-0.24668358266353607,
-0.06502104550600052,
0.3088245689868927,
0.7860768437385559,
-0.10756965726613998,
0.14495234191417694,
-0.06157925724983215,
0.29663094878196716,
0.17963071167469025,
0.334012895822525,
0.5611671805381775,
-0.5382076501846313,
0.6620460748672485,
-0.6031972169876099,
-0.31368231773376465,
-0.2889130711555481,
-0.7977160811424255,
-0.5032488107681274,
-0.6078692078590393,
-0.5875008702278137,
-0.5540959239006042,
0.1284404844045639,
0.710279107093811,
0.6406792402267456,
-0.6427474021911621,
0.3609313368797302,
0.13848921656608582,
0.5320264101028442,
-0.3863253593444824,
-0.2718886435031891,
0.47512584924697876,
-0.056638751178979874,
-0.7695499062538147,
0.6242474317550659,
-0.2089802473783493,
0.1451355218887329,
0.027146579697728157,
0.040115755051374435,
-0.07106882333755493,
0.009661389514803886,
0.5507481694221497,
0.41721296310424805,
-0.015896666795015335,
-0.16782009601593018,
-0.280622273683548,
0.12071231752634048,
-0.03607308864593506,
0.7940502166748047,
-1.1164605617523193,
0.15480460226535797,
0.5534486174583435,
0.589276134967804,
0.207046777009964,
0.23933853209018707,
0.568486213684082,
-0.8342850804328918,
0.22887440025806427,
0.28897812962532043,
0.3061765730381012,
0.387580543756485,
-0.5469211935997009,
0.5156638622283936,
0.2800394594669342,
-0.4376484453678131,
-1.1719754934310913,
-0.10950660705566406,
-1.1984649896621704,
-0.4507889449596405,
1.3028916120529175,
0.19006505608558655,
-0.601645290851593,
-0.2439972311258316,
-0.5490300059318542,
-0.02546175755560398,
-0.320769339799881,
0.7402357459068298,
0.014246499165892601,
0.13323840498924255,
0.1443382054567337,
-0.4438994824886322,
0.5740848183631897,
0.4730607569217682,
-0.98241126537323,
-0.10783316195011139,
0.5509814620018005,
0.31033235788345337,
0.3127308189868927,
0.4859570562839508,
0.14103558659553528,
0.3654693067073822,
-0.06697467714548111,
-0.11194078624248505,
-0.19178344309329987,
-0.4323194622993469,
-0.2627440094947815,
0.30102476477622986,
-0.1506621092557907,
-0.05309683829545975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05584v1 | AutoAugment Is What You Need: Enhancing Rule-based Augmentation Methods in Low-resource Regimes | 2024-02-08T11:36:23 | 2024-02-08T11:36:23 | Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text data augmentation is a complex problem due to the discrete nature of
sentences. Although rule-based augmentation methods are widely adopted in
real-world applications because of their simplicity, they suffer from potential
semantic damage. Previous researchers have suggested easy data augmentation
with soft labels (softEDA), employing label smoothing to mitigate this problem.
However, finding the best factor for each model and dataset is challenging;
therefore, using softEDA in real-world applications is still difficult. In this
paper, we propose adapting AutoAugment to solve this problem. The experimental
results suggest that the proposed method can boost existing augmentation
methods and that rule-based methods can enhance cutting-edge pre-trained
language models. We offer the source code. | [
-0.21945388615131378,
-0.8855666518211365,
0.3922863006591797,
0.17002010345458984,
-0.4340314269065857,
0.0019067805260419846,
-0.20753787457942963,
-0.5478960871696472,
0.07968176156282425,
0.6473063230514526,
-0.6560829877853394,
-0.2592795491218567,
-0.5411615371704102,
0.21128958463668823,
-0.38331493735313416,
1.0389906167984009,
-0.07449416816234589,
-0.4466397166252136,
-0.21946744620800018,
-0.26685357093811035,
-0.5496746301651001,
-0.6082267165184021,
-0.30083411931991577,
-0.1611986607313156,
0.26980826258659363,
0.6839953064918518,
0.8755673766136169,
1.1053082942962646,
0.5462095141410828,
0.4914993643760681,
0.21129478514194489,
0.6631731390953064,
-0.4226893484592438,
0.18069662153720856,
-0.19074809551239014,
-0.2924190163612366,
-0.838190495967865,
-0.053226571530103683,
0.5501201152801514,
0.6805078983306885,
-0.09469197690486908,
-0.01213108655065298,
0.16480818390846252,
0.62754225730896,
-0.6038543581962585,
0.2350034862756729,
-0.42460569739341736,
-0.17115814983844757,
-0.13219881057739258,
-0.316699355840683,
-0.14076797664165497,
-0.45587432384490967,
0.2248842418193817,
-0.9603643417358398,
-0.0029666584450751543,
0.2500273883342743,
1.0077621936798096,
0.7069176435470581,
-0.18266279995441437,
-0.3056749403476715,
-0.8139119148254395,
0.6868173480033875,
-0.8400136232376099,
0.21818001568317413,
0.47209852933883667,
-0.035580262541770935,
-0.22477954626083374,
-0.7092309594154358,
-0.6595332622528076,
-0.08719278872013092,
-0.4847423732280731,
-0.1989731639623642,
-0.18438635766506195,
0.20048177242279053,
0.2488759160041809,
0.49679988622665405,
-0.4385925233364105,
0.2779156267642975,
-0.16430747509002686,
-0.21738910675048828,
0.7256587147712708,
0.01180208195000887,
0.46328866481781006,
-0.21382902562618256,
-0.1377096176147461,
-0.33066901564598083,
-0.23180513083934784,
-0.17292064428329468,
0.37186944484710693,
0.3528050184249878,
-0.11012955009937286,
0.3669775426387787,
-0.4649953246116638,
0.9057492613792419,
0.3695530891418457,
0.017193343490362167,
0.6692543625831604,
-0.7231558561325073,
-0.44517120718955994,
-0.0013668839819729328,
0.7010467648506165,
0.1797952502965927,
0.3140140771865845,
-0.12627065181732178,
-0.24673159420490265,
-0.21547117829322815,
0.14443795382976532,
-0.9955465793609619,
-0.3228057026863098,
-0.10602542012929916,
-0.42797017097473145,
-0.27194932103157043,
-0.09997540712356567,
-0.8748024702072144,
-0.3192814588546753,
-0.4395568370819092,
0.5257832407951355,
-0.43138620257377625,
-0.02708798088133335,
0.11472884565591812,
0.22950676083564758,
0.009984211064875126,
0.33628472685813904,
-0.9435147643089294,
0.2704741656780243,
0.478219598531723,
0.8354016542434692,
0.00014865297998767346,
-0.10064160078763962,
-0.5511780381202698,
0.11814424395561218,
-0.1128855049610138,
1.051951289176941,
-0.6397220492362976,
-0.39951977133750916,
-0.1742415577173233,
0.14273278415203094,
-0.008739876560866833,
-0.4012933373451233,
0.7047852873802185,
-0.2556578814983368,
0.4361014664173126,
0.15167579054832458,
-0.5463626384735107,
-0.20163792371749878,
-0.061427414417266846,
-0.7246032357215881,
1.1823421716690063,
0.2423117458820343,
-0.3101777136325836,
0.5822654366493225,
-1.0005911588668823,
-0.8748887777328491,
0.2349156141281128,
0.1317238211631775,
-0.5802811980247498,
-0.08592897653579712,
0.6387832760810852,
0.3922008275985718,
0.07716963440179825,
0.22200781106948853,
-0.17966966331005096,
-0.2298431396484375,
0.19332820177078247,
-0.4894382655620575,
0.6967209577560425,
0.18192821741104126,
-0.3274213969707489,
0.21273544430732727,
-0.9119431376457214,
0.010322141461074352,
-0.16556596755981445,
-0.3477540612220764,
-0.7678412795066833,
0.23021955788135529,
0.011366314254701138,
0.16403913497924805,
0.37866851687431335,
-0.34796062111854553,
0.3851045072078705,
-0.8059872388839722,
0.2536301612854004,
0.8786099553108215,
0.00021433680376503617,
0.8572183847427368,
-0.20290465652942657,
0.3120952844619751,
-0.0075918324291706085,
0.36591261625289917,
-0.2388872355222702,
-0.13796354830265045,
-1.0090886354446411,
-0.4939165711402893,
0.7121649980545044,
0.6817449331283569,
-1.0900545120239258,
0.7213337421417236,
-0.303842157125473,
-0.3616962134838104,
-0.9518495798110962,
0.7475582361221313,
0.10932575166225433,
0.5192318558692932,
0.6071551442146301,
-0.5067554712295532,
-0.6047444343566895,
-1.020326018333435,
-0.24014776945114136,
-0.12284895777702332,
-0.021522967144846916,
0.3580927550792694,
0.13933879137039185,
-0.5298594832420349,
1.162277102470398,
-0.6541915535926819,
-0.6262760162353516,
-0.001467783353291452,
0.35348716378211975,
0.1608327031135559,
0.6252637505531311,
0.6386100053787231,
-0.8301540613174438,
-0.2932504713535309,
-0.02840978279709816,
-0.6033682227134705,
-0.5450618267059326,
-0.22160553932189941,
-0.11888577789068222,
0.1385555863380432,
0.6607043147087097,
-0.1251913160085678,
0.3491630256175995,
0.505821168422699,
-0.44040215015411377,
-0.004719572141766548,
-0.6406718492507935,
0.15404580533504486,
-0.8382570147514343,
-0.08028499037027359,
0.20612168312072754,
-0.6290610432624817,
-0.7333129644393921,
-0.15230949223041534,
0.07724626362323761,
0.07867754995822906,
-0.17578507959842682,
0.5375416278839111,
-0.4713866114616394,
0.203249990940094,
-0.624190092086792,
0.11034118384122849,
0.06530371308326721,
0.3773522973060608,
-0.12543591856956482,
0.7863603234291077,
0.44976064562797546,
-0.8388816118240356,
0.40212348103523254,
0.25627759099006653,
-0.40382394194602966,
0.5468838214874268,
-0.524290919303894,
-0.07454056292772293,
-0.44702696800231934,
0.3381841480731964,
-0.9289059042930603,
-0.2867621183395386,
0.38211336731910706,
-0.0712456926703453,
0.2592463195323944,
-0.028300154954195023,
-0.6135834455490112,
-0.19153694808483124,
-0.20987018942832947,
0.4066520631313324,
0.6168596148490906,
-0.6777777075767517,
0.7884249687194824,
0.5117965936660767,
-0.5342007875442505,
-0.2589558959007263,
-0.5317667126655579,
0.29201194643974304,
-0.2631538510322571,
-0.35667818784713745,
0.5247349143028259,
-0.30300071835517883,
-0.13246466219425201,
0.011642826721072197,
0.2804142236709595,
-0.23518827557563782,
0.1732676923274994,
0.23876111209392548,
0.4046775698661804,
-0.06684238463640213,
0.21377676725387573,
0.2525859773159027,
-0.25450581312179565,
-0.40435218811035156,
-0.2655108869075775,
0.1840478926897049,
0.03355379030108452,
0.09506404399871826,
-0.4613817036151886,
0.14684055745601654,
0.46350401639938354,
-0.21517330408096313,
0.4406871795654297,
0.6695271134376526,
-0.3164282441139221,
-0.3432508111000061,
-0.5474250316619873,
-0.2678923010826111,
-0.6577969193458557,
0.32927805185317993,
-0.10224293172359467,
-0.8073928356170654,
0.06100332364439964,
-0.24009133875370026,
0.12548287212848663,
0.46745944023132324,
0.5595735907554626,
-0.17820361256599426,
0.9210353493690491,
1.0131075382232666,
-0.15313875675201416,
0.8065885305404663,
0.1143423542380333,
0.24379566311836243,
-0.513312041759491,
-0.04766181483864784,
-0.48609986901283264,
-0.2631172239780426,
-0.7799777984619141,
-0.40113067626953125,
0.15289495885372162,
-0.1524120718240738,
0.26228293776512146,
0.5078694224357605,
-0.7491248846054077,
0.36366233229637146,
0.35372278094291687,
0.2673504054546356,
0.3350526690483093,
0.13787317276000977,
0.24582608044147491,
-0.07222262024879456,
-0.9039422869682312,
-0.356690376996994,
0.6866515874862671,
0.45200100541114807,
0.916219174861908,
0.0040924446657299995,
0.5193435549736023,
0.6868025064468384,
0.5176311135292053,
-0.7805349826812744,
0.5435674786567688,
-0.5528410077095032,
-0.4519069492816925,
-0.431703120470047,
-0.6290338039398193,
-0.8693568706512451,
0.12946976721286774,
-0.4839763641357422,
-0.4373417794704437,
0.7214288115501404,
0.35145288705825806,
-0.5809129476547241,
-0.1987522840499878,
-0.8946341276168823,
0.5940343737602234,
-0.3486657738685608,
-0.34582844376564026,
0.10630815476179123,
-0.2832697629928589,
0.17777171730995178,
-0.4405754506587982,
0.7397316694259644,
-0.16754938662052155,
-0.10074565559625626,
1.0117287635803223,
-0.9114978313446045,
0.9589443206787109,
-0.2454778403043747,
-0.36391451954841614,
0.312834233045578,
-0.3037777841091156,
0.5821323394775391,
-0.2700340151786804,
0.026382967829704285,
-0.3279508948326111,
-0.1490618735551834,
-0.3779550790786743,
-0.7502338290214539,
0.7110751867294312,
-0.5703421235084534,
-0.35309287905693054,
-0.3297649919986725,
-0.6900336146354675,
-0.2994847297668457,
0.22965481877326965,
-0.04589397832751274,
0.42312318086624146,
-0.04390580579638481,
0.011727515608072281,
0.4952484667301178,
-0.07233598828315735,
0.8205607533454895,
0.7414470911026001,
-0.05318261682987213,
-0.4060060381889343,
1.1378690004348755,
0.23271536827087402,
-0.0230962373316288,
0.031060006469488144,
0.11810941994190216,
-0.44962412118911743,
-0.5395166277885437,
-0.7189671397209167,
0.09173800051212311,
-0.4786142110824585,
-0.3627827763557434,
-0.5961712598800659,
0.0782053992152214,
-0.44361671805381775,
-0.17783555388450623,
-0.14057891070842743,
-0.760148286819458,
-0.493548721075058,
-0.06459236890077591,
0.8638708591461182,
0.4984057545661926,
-0.29007968306541443,
0.7452250123023987,
-0.6429290175437927,
0.6918827891349792,
0.4648788273334503,
0.515659511089325,
-0.30977529287338257,
-0.8066402673721313,
-0.4127333164215088,
-0.0015085185877978802,
0.09484519809484482,
-0.6604704260826111,
0.43372347950935364,
0.7123735547065735,
0.37053391337394714,
0.2286384254693985,
0.13689970970153809,
0.9639302492141724,
-0.5917302370071411,
0.28891122341156006,
-0.04643919691443443,
-0.971968412399292,
0.583169162273407,
-0.1441410332918167,
0.2604908347129822,
0.9155489802360535,
0.09726303070783615,
-0.21471953392028809,
-0.39381399750709534,
-0.5685561299324036,
-1.18653404712677,
0.6464147567749023,
0.24619725346565247,
0.38658249378204346,
0.354331910610199,
0.6987932920455933,
0.04774564132094383,
-0.0016835401766002178,
-0.6399378180503845,
-0.2829074263572693,
-0.3392922580242157,
-0.6788751482963562,
-0.128892719745636,
-0.05964566394686699,
0.34706148505210876,
-0.3468371033668518,
1.0329372882843018,
-0.288745641708374,
-0.16254685819149017,
0.25611233711242676,
-0.5044392943382263,
-0.12535259127616882,
0.3143009841442108,
0.2933654487133026,
0.3467816710472107,
-0.11729691177606583,
-0.14536483585834503,
0.2958310544490814,
-0.5242031216621399,
0.31250396370887756,
0.6528136134147644,
-0.5787573456764221,
0.01647035963833332,
0.23192699253559113,
0.8120402097702026,
0.4206242859363556,
-0.5073078274726868,
0.3288896679878235,
-0.04828895255923271,
-0.12538579106330872,
0.20420005917549133,
0.40019017457962036,
-0.5208431482315063,
-0.028021907433867455,
0.5602462887763977,
-0.10466524213552475,
0.3436250388622284,
-0.6443910598754883,
0.5898164510726929,
0.19194425642490387,
-0.37420225143432617,
0.08917985111474991,
0.48094436526298523,
0.4953068196773529,
-0.3576686680316925,
0.24647605419158936,
-0.18715697526931763,
-0.5190658569335938,
0.28546443581581116,
0.4121173024177551,
0.6260590553283691,
-0.5391608476638794,
0.1803651750087738,
0.25544556975364685,
0.536709725856781,
0.020980168133974075,
0.1410926729440689,
-0.0014418839709833264,
-0.538688063621521,
-0.8768479228019714,
-0.769812285900116,
-0.2902246117591858,
0.0808342695236206,
-0.435658723115921,
0.07752631604671478,
-0.50251704454422,
-0.27545034885406494,
0.1494670957326889,
0.03916534036397934,
-0.5640761852264404,
0.5467172265052795,
0.1014210656285286,
0.7179440855979919,
-0.7689501643180847,
0.9043700098991394,
0.6399144530296326,
-0.18652832508087158,
-0.40784403681755066,
-0.13752679526805878,
-0.29156768321990967,
-0.5853608846664429,
0.3004189133644104,
-0.11431100219488144,
-0.1712154597043991,
0.19168828427791595,
-0.5633141994476318,
-0.6883072853088379,
0.8109305500984192,
0.013895281590521336,
-0.6101115942001343,
-0.07194020599126816,
0.13446593284606934,
0.5867034792900085,
-0.4173237383365631,
0.06996279209852219,
0.7041459083557129,
0.8407977223396301,
-0.19938308000564575,
-0.9191082119941711,
0.09321054071187973,
-0.33814510703086853,
-0.03274143859744072,
0.15665198862552643,
-0.4595729410648346,
0.3646407425403595,
0.1592341512441635,
-0.2600111961364746,
-0.04089907556772232,
0.9451149106025696,
-0.37911173701286316,
0.12052570283412933,
0.8679553270339966,
0.3496451675891876,
0.8157324194908142,
-0.05160447210073471,
0.8518591523170471,
-0.17123185098171234,
0.27815502882003784,
1.1967945098876953,
-0.25892019271850586,
0.47576704621315,
0.1849743276834488,
0.14516307413578033,
0.9297522902488708,
0.5342790484428406,
-0.22838176786899567,
0.6015077829360962,
-0.06067084148526192,
-0.18646062910556793,
-0.20580831170082092,
-0.4111112058162689,
-0.0194228645414114,
0.5960845947265625,
0.6444239020347595,
-0.18888187408447266,
-0.11232853680849075,
0.2990177869796753,
0.08040018379688263,
0.21902905404567719,
-0.44196924567222595,
1.1026650667190552,
-0.11760874837636948,
-0.4938438832759857,
0.49092164635658264,
0.3073272407054901,
0.8999059200286865,
-0.424873024225235,
-0.06873712688684464,
-0.13071031868457794,
0.13329043984413147,
-0.32778358459472656,
-0.50981205701828,
0.15357524156570435,
0.14639389514923096,
-0.12181778252124786,
-0.40921905636787415,
1.1911286115646362,
-0.7078259587287903,
-0.7404369115829468,
0.18176288902759552,
0.6387045383453369,
-0.2200632095336914,
0.2747795581817627,
-0.847761869430542,
-0.09456391632556915,
-0.06423240154981613,
0.036147598177194595,
0.16520345211029053,
0.45601871609687805,
0.06584416329860687,
0.5891015529632568,
0.7666764855384827,
-0.0266046691685915,
-0.04158792644739151,
-0.07202524691820145,
0.999512255191803,
-0.5607051849365234,
-0.6711630821228027,
-0.9381176233291626,
0.31588658690452576,
-0.2903798818588257,
0.03276423364877701,
0.8044082522392273,
0.4595090448856354,
0.48033323884010315,
0.1986956000328064,
0.9284934997558594,
-0.011826220899820328,
0.5366919040679932,
-0.5363816618919373,
0.8127994537353516,
-0.5500508546829224,
0.10231515765190125,
-0.44034290313720703,
-0.9166571497917175,
-0.39906859397888184,
0.7499088644981384,
-0.43465787172317505,
0.014963766559958458,
0.3617960810661316,
0.8393248915672302,
-0.3236808478832245,
-0.304386705160141,
0.15334050357341766,
0.40314292907714844,
0.01792730763554573,
0.2999909818172455,
0.44600874185562134,
-0.4548218846321106,
0.6326329708099365,
-0.3022554814815521,
-0.6306793093681335,
-0.35831519961357117,
-1.083707332611084,
-0.7481188178062439,
-0.5399762988090515,
-0.7030510902404785,
-0.2142670750617981,
0.20959340035915375,
0.7645260095596313,
0.9324538707733154,
-0.7449470162391663,
0.06990910321474075,
0.12297295778989792,
0.07070301473140717,
-0.002449066611006856,
-0.2875649631023407,
0.4490448832511902,
-0.4137130379676819,
-0.8025404214859009,
0.7114680409431458,
0.28787022829055786,
0.37890106439590454,
-0.043494511395692825,
0.010281200520694256,
-0.2741750478744507,
0.37457406520843506,
0.6839162111282349,
0.483239084482193,
-0.14816026389598846,
-0.20314113795757294,
-0.3665830194950104,
-0.07034280151128769,
0.15625643730163574,
0.8283855319023132,
-1.1066279411315918,
0.46697327494621277,
0.3081572651863098,
0.604371190071106,
0.27977821230888367,
0.4806637167930603,
0.6206004619598389,
-0.8561123609542847,
0.2905447781085968,
-0.016925986856222153,
0.19979864358901978,
0.551106870174408,
-0.3993750512599945,
0.39804941415786743,
0.10221999883651733,
-0.43225720524787903,
-0.779094934463501,
0.0825423151254654,
-0.7721327543258667,
-0.2865663766860962,
0.9135048985481262,
0.03159521520137787,
-0.390248566865921,
-0.43334218859672546,
-0.3129504323005676,
0.20184390246868134,
-0.4458349347114563,
0.7636243104934692,
0.5494711399078369,
0.06141391769051552,
-0.20836147665977478,
-0.503729522228241,
0.8008702397346497,
0.47765660285949707,
-1.308529257774353,
0.17450174689292908,
0.7206613421440125,
0.0933476909995079,
0.1405443698167801,
0.6416417360305786,
0.029775533825159073,
0.1686541587114334,
-0.4284520447254181,
-0.18188336491584778,
-0.238552525639534,
-0.17417988181114197,
-0.4374474585056305,
-0.09454872459173203,
-0.02105395495891571,
-0.00957487616688013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05581v1 | Establishing degrees of closeness between audio recordings along different dimensions using large-scale cross-lingual models | 2024-02-08T11:31:23 | 2024-02-08T11:31:23 | Maxime Fily, Guillaume Wisniewski, Severine Guillaume, Gilles Adda, Alexis Michaud | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In the highly constrained context of low-resource language studies, we
explore vector representations of speech from a pretrained model to determine
their level of abstraction with regard to the audio signal. We propose a new
unsupervised method using ABX tests on audio recordings with carefully curated
metadata to shed light on the type of information present in the
representations. ABX tests determine whether the representations computed by a
multilingual speech model encode a given characteristic. Three experiments are
devised: one on room acoustics aspects, one on linguistic genre, and one on
phonetic aspects. The results confirm that the representations extracted from
recordings with different linguistic/extra-linguistic characteristics differ
along the same lines. Embedding more audio signal in one vector better
discriminates extra-linguistic characteristics, whereas shorter snippets are
better to distinguish segmental information. The method is fully unsupervised,
potentially opening new research avenues for comparative work on
under-documented languages. | [
-0.8453618288040161,
-0.45267754793167114,
0.30873894691467285,
0.1360543668270111,
-0.14408090710639954,
0.004892369266599417,
-0.6063034534454346,
-0.501794695854187,
0.46577188372612,
0.3371337950229645,
-0.32585224509239197,
-0.6666004061698914,
-0.5721223950386047,
0.07966417819261551,
-0.5702337622642517,
0.3863212764263153,
0.11695975810289383,
0.24878308176994324,
-0.4025481045246124,
-0.5617700219154358,
-0.16897909343242645,
-0.8610036373138428,
-0.2409321665763855,
-0.44015833735466003,
0.23440133035182953,
0.03761105611920357,
0.5438039898872375,
0.5923786759376526,
0.35413244366645813,
0.2444373220205307,
-0.30374807119369507,
-0.20022176206111908,
-0.05199522152543068,
-0.17825676500797272,
-0.1482347846031189,
-0.599834680557251,
-0.09407013654708862,
0.12188321352005005,
0.9216398596763611,
1.1945518255233765,
0.017316242679953575,
0.4055623710155487,
0.14534088969230652,
0.11677169799804688,
-0.49182236194610596,
0.06506628543138504,
-0.3833296000957489,
0.27649256587028503,
-0.19337886571884155,
-0.29738298058509827,
-0.4142034649848938,
0.119804747402668,
-0.0533236600458622,
-0.3406853973865509,
0.3159337639808655,
-0.062000177800655365,
0.7629952430725098,
0.24241231381893158,
-0.4470413327217102,
-0.06290660798549652,
-1.0843702554702759,
1.0036360025405884,
-0.642459511756897,
1.0355960130691528,
0.5134405493736267,
0.18049956858158112,
0.2710227370262146,
-0.32442307472229004,
-0.421305388212204,
-0.08171764761209488,
-0.31287842988967896,
-0.18224211037158966,
-0.3102862536907196,
-0.06571080535650253,
0.41657060384750366,
0.37250036001205444,
-0.42396309971809387,
0.19415129721164703,
-0.33831048011779785,
-0.44749146699905396,
0.6017426252365112,
-0.31852567195892334,
0.3833272159099579,
-0.17509473860263824,
-0.15021511912345886,
-0.38214075565338135,
-0.6776886582374573,
0.12213359028100967,
0.4509793817996979,
0.40435922145843506,
-0.3044527471065521,
0.777115523815155,
-0.07518233358860016,
0.25249871611595154,
-0.11158876121044159,
-0.23872394859790802,
0.7086223363876343,
-0.3676435947418213,
0.16487161815166473,
0.5394548773765564,
0.8125927448272705,
0.06954827159643173,
0.07815461605787277,
-0.058229394257068634,
-0.3633716106414795,
0.05480430647730827,
-0.3047330677509308,
-0.49920541048049927,
-0.03804395720362663,
0.06730741262435913,
-0.7404761910438538,
0.34274056553840637,
0.006048101000487804,
-0.4030294418334961,
-0.20118416845798492,
-0.7880915403366089,
0.4090227484703064,
-0.3829544186592102,
-0.5306428670883179,
-0.11526942253112793,
-0.1711721271276474,
0.14789217710494995,
-0.24993686378002167,
-0.7651565074920654,
0.2878991663455963,
0.5764498710632324,
0.86207515001297,
-0.14278464019298553,
-0.30467689037323,
-0.6384623050689697,
0.08812598139047623,
-0.3755486309528351,
0.6565551161766052,
-0.8431403636932373,
-0.6306270360946655,
0.06330510973930359,
-0.1589837670326233,
0.4488527178764343,
-0.6503360867500305,
0.341347336769104,
-0.192116379737854,
0.050261422991752625,
-0.3056546747684479,
-0.491128146648407,
-0.1876540333032608,
-0.11276984214782715,
-0.7825115323066711,
1.0311282873153687,
0.2755619287490845,
-0.8329682946205139,
0.37588557600975037,
-0.34221282601356506,
-0.21272461116313934,
-0.3770667314529419,
-0.6148053407669067,
-0.22818523645401,
0.31992682814598083,
0.3129865229129791,
0.4568925201892853,
-0.044479694217443466,
-0.03567788004875183,
-0.22530119121074677,
-0.3596135973930359,
0.3761855661869049,
-0.5028191208839417,
0.7202469706535339,
-0.027339670807123184,
-0.038536135107278824,
-0.009403497911989689,
-1.0007573366165161,
-0.18861648440361023,
-0.15052196383476257,
-0.40625712275505066,
-0.8839598298072815,
-0.3255946636199951,
0.010847989469766617,
0.02251044660806656,
0.2517251670360565,
-0.9496346116065979,
-0.04034305363893509,
-0.4264107048511505,
0.2040948122739792,
0.2564888596534729,
0.05016886815428734,
0.5116480588912964,
-0.22571809589862823,
0.6053289771080017,
0.15559779107570648,
-0.17021338641643524,
-0.2888506352901459,
-0.0806901603937149,
-0.541935920715332,
-0.34967535734176636,
0.6995462775230408,
0.26198479533195496,
-0.3888780176639557,
0.4353795349597931,
-0.31284549832344055,
-0.2909115254878998,
-0.8924046754837036,
0.1304444819688797,
0.5170180797576904,
0.037872832268476486,
0.4581092596054077,
-0.6243973970413208,
-0.5284861922264099,
-0.9682424068450928,
-0.004328596405684948,
-0.06335506588220596,
-0.5565926432609558,
0.42271730303764343,
0.28251224756240845,
-0.4385213553905487,
0.8258181810379028,
-0.2355189025402069,
-0.3095889985561371,
-0.1204138919711113,
0.41707471013069153,
0.24801105260849,
0.2847159206867218,
0.8810101747512817,
-0.5008189082145691,
-0.2033722847700119,
0.10386141389608383,
-0.528418242931366,
-0.21330347657203674,
0.22955942153930664,
0.1943475753068924,
0.05790746584534645,
0.8022383451461792,
-0.3164632022380829,
0.3326166272163391,
0.5389455556869507,
-0.14475813508033752,
0.3748937249183655,
-0.280425101518631,
0.07714782655239105,
-0.6464232206344604,
-0.02375892736017704,
-0.17113882303237915,
-0.12842734158039093,
-0.47102075815200806,
-0.24930068850517273,
-0.16420947015285492,
-0.10574555397033691,
-0.5482441186904907,
0.4519203305244446,
-0.6526427268981934,
-0.6003323793411255,
-0.09163197875022888,
0.2492113709449768,
-0.11916681379079819,
0.6013087034225464,
0.36462751030921936,
0.5916746854782104,
0.7090779542922974,
-0.4659792482852936,
0.3860771656036377,
0.37072721123695374,
-0.5273948311805725,
0.4664560556411743,
-0.5896998643875122,
0.31230008602142334,
-0.27079179883003235,
-0.02695029228925705,
-1.0142091512680054,
-0.04745304957032204,
-0.4934326112270355,
-0.69969642162323,
0.30349764227867126,
-0.16582979261875153,
-0.4271388351917267,
0.09602904319763184,
-0.10936427116394043,
0.9829078316688538,
0.5437223315238953,
-0.5105240941047668,
0.7027133703231812,
0.7047370076179504,
-0.3784309923648834,
-0.47783946990966797,
-0.649601399898529,
-0.31296050548553467,
-0.46081098914146423,
-0.2974646985530853,
0.133762389421463,
0.22786661982536316,
-0.5812172293663025,
-0.09966029226779938,
-0.0495222769677639,
-0.15386149287223816,
-0.2812517583370209,
0.3608280122280121,
-0.0329144261777401,
-0.5868952870368958,
0.1315581202507019,
-0.035340480506420135,
0.14362376928329468,
0.3389393985271454,
-0.1295429766178131,
0.5922327637672424,
0.1741645783185959,
-0.4966595470905304,
-0.21512764692306519,
0.860448956489563,
0.4421391785144806,
-0.5505189299583435,
0.25507327914237976,
0.7249716520309448,
-0.21792194247245789,
-0.3994501233100891,
-0.3356485962867737,
-0.27187809348106384,
-0.38917067646980286,
0.2092079520225525,
-0.3323553204536438,
-0.7478787899017334,
0.8416788578033447,
-0.10712163895368576,
-0.06549061089754105,
0.1395682543516159,
0.33430397510528564,
0.05642097815871239,
0.9642238616943359,
0.7645523548126221,
-0.16353252530097961,
0.28398197889328003,
-0.4704892933368683,
0.09415331482887268,
-0.9529597759246826,
-0.3627687394618988,
-0.7752722501754761,
-0.2156408578157425,
-0.41937699913978577,
-0.5308051109313965,
0.4876846373081207,
-0.15065166354179382,
-0.08874646574258804,
0.2624189853668213,
-0.18538834154605865,
0.5334615111351013,
0.6643496751785278,
-0.1496705412864685,
0.26804542541503906,
0.08829709142446518,
-0.4617353677749634,
-0.1652454286813736,
-0.5413904190063477,
-0.16092687845230103,
1.1274938583374023,
0.5120911002159119,
0.5239470601081848,
0.252024382352829,
0.7070780396461487,
0.23437395691871643,
-0.104049451649189,
-0.9500385522842407,
0.31168848276138306,
-0.14137931168079376,
-0.3725165128707886,
-0.6190379858016968,
-0.339402437210083,
-0.9121592044830322,
0.4150497317314148,
-0.31965845823287964,
-0.6580959558486938,
0.45015522837638855,
-0.12421706318855286,
-0.4440421462059021,
0.13704665005207062,
-0.4742988049983978,
0.4409465789794922,
-0.0998157486319542,
-0.1525278091430664,
-0.08755513280630112,
-0.3714807629585266,
0.020907247439026833,
-0.3059125244617462,
0.5600001215934753,
-0.06028283014893532,
0.22015848755836487,
0.9480029940605164,
-0.2554967999458313,
0.6448307633399963,
-0.13208848237991333,
-0.4275951385498047,
0.2676060199737549,
0.32070446014404297,
-0.03942570835351944,
-0.022543588653206825,
0.0877869725227356,
0.6214034557342529,
0.2666463851928711,
-0.2259221225976944,
-0.6263408064842224,
0.5805102586746216,
-0.9917010068893433,
-0.4028415083885193,
-0.07348093390464783,
-0.4720199406147003,
-0.5026843547821045,
0.3081819415092468,
0.3587561249732971,
0.8427978157997131,
-0.29082977771759033,
0.41110169887542725,
0.6734614968299866,
-0.44609981775283813,
0.5512740612030029,
0.5093084573745728,
-0.37334710359573364,
0.06877226382493973,
0.7565577030181885,
0.12341102957725525,
0.0960192084312439,
0.6896511912345886,
0.2745046317577362,
-0.6732521057128906,
-0.5848202109336853,
-0.025822145864367485,
0.4595045745372772,
-0.8528993129730225,
0.19824694097042084,
-0.35023921728134155,
-0.147438183426857,
-0.5536189675331116,
0.2025214433670044,
-0.7279441356658936,
-0.40697264671325684,
-0.16198746860027313,
-0.20544640719890594,
0.13806597888469696,
0.6659724116325378,
-0.5216801166534424,
0.2083151936531067,
-0.7788691520690918,
0.46774059534072876,
0.2273678481578827,
0.2464548498392105,
-0.023951487615704536,
-0.6703153252601624,
-0.2738206684589386,
0.08350104093551636,
0.31022319197654724,
-0.6946346759796143,
0.4350989758968353,
0.28058162331581116,
0.6268631219863892,
0.6865269541740417,
0.2586926519870758,
0.3456103801727295,
-0.52423495054245,
0.7319146394729614,
0.21893729269504547,
-1.1083871126174927,
0.46631693840026855,
-0.4512658417224884,
0.30884626507759094,
0.3736400306224823,
0.49845147132873535,
-0.3438199460506439,
-0.4829550087451935,
-0.5562291741371155,
-0.7832403779029846,
0.33090832829475403,
0.03162232041358948,
0.10364243388175964,
0.2699286639690399,
-0.005739813670516014,
0.1725527048110962,
0.0297707412391901,
-0.41199442744255066,
-0.2747657597064972,
-0.33582818508148193,
0.22290877997875214,
-0.3637532591819763,
-0.08833765238523483,
-0.28408366441726685,
-0.37444302439689636,
0.2130851000547409,
0.16365976631641388,
0.4029184877872467,
0.18572650849819183,
0.012571243569254875,
0.14352844655513763,
0.33630865812301636,
0.29311734437942505,
0.6878156065940857,
-0.25779300928115845,
0.6435433626174927,
0.1742195039987564,
-0.4618091583251953,
0.3407467007637024,
-0.10889478027820587,
0.24602660536766052,
0.49999821186065674,
0.948615550994873,
0.6942253708839417,
0.15788418054580688,
-0.5563809871673584,
0.7232847809791565,
-0.04591638967394829,
-0.11238756030797958,
-0.5949161648750305,
-0.08386096358299255,
-0.044998202472925186,
0.08384876698255539,
0.027876779437065125,
-0.3436649441719055,
0.28761401772499084,
-0.730346143245697,
0.3900260329246521,
0.2842911183834076,
-0.5572237372398376,
-0.3900584578514099,
0.6064997315406799,
0.1684679239988327,
-0.18084637820720673,
0.5545529723167419,
-0.12218715250492096,
-0.19100430607795715,
0.42083868384361267,
0.27166253328323364,
0.5774416327476501,
-0.4821956753730774,
-0.025518424808979034,
0.4151420295238495,
0.12203644216060638,
0.04936618730425835,
0.18394865095615387,
-0.40967682003974915,
-0.7725881934165955,
-0.5770220756530762,
-0.8011744022369385,
-0.3192649781703949,
0.3858450651168823,
-1.0021203756332397,
0.23364073038101196,
-0.0761425644159317,
-0.1389283537864685,
0.29920047521591187,
-0.30535057187080383,
-0.6851712465286255,
-0.07888709008693695,
0.39761102199554443,
0.7421742677688599,
-1.1837700605392456,
0.8222354650497437,
0.5605453848838806,
-0.14276911318302155,
-0.9615129828453064,
-0.06103084236383438,
0.005363181699067354,
-0.5190743207931519,
0.7103930711746216,
-0.06033208221197128,
-0.3886524438858032,
-0.34395596385002136,
-0.27420899271965027,
-0.935265839099884,
0.5972549319267273,
0.5051352977752686,
-0.738427460193634,
0.059146005660295486,
0.5154425501823425,
0.5357216000556946,
-0.31267115473747253,
0.27028387784957886,
0.7512282133102417,
0.3411480188369751,
0.0619327686727047,
-1.326277732849121,
-0.18272742629051208,
-0.19135573506355286,
-0.12994810938835144,
0.13288679718971252,
-0.2784918546676636,
0.8933665156364441,
-0.07724279910326004,
-0.2764246463775635,
-0.33156928420066833,
0.6663673520088196,
-0.004925146233290434,
0.203574076294899,
0.6146595478057861,
0.34878265857696533,
0.7264313101768494,
0.03346947208046913,
0.8112689852714539,
-0.2678443491458893,
0.13481175899505615,
1.0384496450424194,
-0.04263625666499138,
0.8596020936965942,
0.5245460271835327,
-0.15266598761081696,
0.2086118757724762,
0.42848700284957886,
-0.07084100693464279,
0.4641612768173218,
0.3882320821285248,
-0.4526529908180237,
-0.33029940724372864,
-0.5922426581382751,
-0.4991787075996399,
0.9425757527351379,
0.29715463519096375,
-0.33481812477111816,
0.03953232243657112,
0.37513312697410583,
-0.02691704034805298,
0.26447397470474243,
-0.4518703818321228,
0.7003248929977417,
0.22215954959392548,
-0.4567369520664215,
0.7759846448898315,
-0.15175406634807587,
0.5494831800460815,
-0.4736626446247101,
-0.1561860293149948,
-0.2276604026556015,
0.009258798323571682,
-0.2433731108903885,
-0.6126331686973572,
0.39378035068511963,
-0.17507106065750122,
-0.06758833676576614,
-0.08162706345319748,
0.3782725930213928,
-0.656174898147583,
-0.26853135228157043,
0.6478071808815002,
0.44290098547935486,
0.5067009925842285,
0.04395408555865288,
0.05715440958738327,
0.2289850413799286,
-0.0394752100110054,
0.06520277261734009,
0.12465805560350418,
0.7231651544570923,
-0.0747004821896553,
0.27378222346305847,
0.5351833701133728,
0.47676733136177063,
0.11577942967414856,
0.37978845834732056,
0.5788645148277283,
-0.5966716408729553,
-0.7005489468574524,
-0.517942488193512,
0.017135031521320343,
0.13413701951503754,
-0.04813217744231224,
0.7895559668540955,
0.72164386510849,
1.3269304037094116,
-0.06873033940792084,
0.9311352968215942,
0.41288018226623535,
0.7585999965667725,
-0.6591544151306152,
0.519159197807312,
-0.4937540292739868,
0.3431691825389862,
-0.20103013515472412,
-0.9150463938713074,
-0.12651409208774567,
0.665229082107544,
-0.02732560783624649,
-0.20521776378154755,
0.6920979619026184,
0.6530436873435974,
-0.4987650215625763,
-0.1661292314529419,
0.43378180265426636,
0.18774093687534332,
0.035966262221336365,
0.3775748014450073,
0.9864956736564636,
0.11837557703256607,
0.4456010162830353,
-0.469774454832077,
-0.20434920489788055,
0.08563707768917084,
-0.5274888873100281,
-1.2959975004196167,
-0.9057639837265015,
-0.3500879406929016,
-0.10008469969034195,
-0.4815276861190796,
0.8440295457839966,
0.7544029355049133,
-0.7172226309776306,
-0.35453203320503235,
0.7304143309593201,
-0.04235684126615524,
-0.19968649744987488,
-0.11563793569803238,
0.6344841718673706,
0.3568325340747833,
-0.7180311679840088,
0.5389925837516785,
-0.04031245410442352,
0.21151374280452728,
-0.633759081363678,
0.06134958192706108,
0.15844863653182983,
0.3393353223800659,
0.5912644863128662,
0.3337344527244568,
-0.41668012738227844,
-0.43209078907966614,
-0.182948499917984,
0.3312652111053467,
0.2682526111602783,
0.9007229208946228,
-0.550399661064148,
0.38523781299591064,
0.715543806552887,
0.363648921251297,
0.369467556476593,
-0.09456174820661545,
0.47645580768585205,
-1.3256912231445312,
0.5528058409690857,
0.26568683981895447,
0.5996723175048828,
0.5369449257850647,
-0.06406058371067047,
0.16366149485111237,
-0.07827839255332947,
-0.14901135861873627,
-1.0145939588546753,
0.35574108362197876,
-1.1223773956298828,
-0.31691887974739075,
1.4907300472259521,
-0.21340297162532806,
-0.19897152483463287,
-0.30559593439102173,
-0.09189070016145706,
0.3788018524646759,
-0.34066903591156006,
0.6285575032234192,
0.7690022587776184,
-0.2826560437679291,
-0.13424068689346313,
-0.4531330466270447,
0.5215175151824951,
0.11384619772434235,
-0.20559453964233398,
0.06624025851488113,
0.2974230945110321,
0.2297617644071579,
0.6809662580490112,
0.46811410784721375,
-0.4006972908973694,
0.039036039263010025,
0.14623801410198212,
0.09621679037809372,
-0.13522495329380035,
-0.476421982049942,
-0.5352116227149963,
0.25832682847976685,
0.14346010982990265,
-0.3369789123535156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05571v1 | Traditional Machine Learning Models and Bidirectional Encoder Representations From Transformer (BERT)-Based Automatic Classification of Tweets About Eating Disorders: Algorithm Development and Validation Study | 2024-02-08T11:16:13 | 2024-02-08T11:16:13 | José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, José-Manuel Alija-Pérez, Maria-Esther Vidal, Rafael Pastor-Vargas, María Teresa García-Ordás | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Background: Eating disorders are increasingly prevalent, and social networks
offer valuable information.
Objective: Our goal was to identify efficient machine learning models for
categorizing tweets related to eating disorders.
Methods: Over three months, we collected tweets about eating disorders. A
2,000-tweet subset was labeled for: (1) being written by individuals with
eating disorders, (2) promoting eating disorders, (3) informativeness, and (4)
scientific content. Both traditional machine learning and deep learning models
were employed for classification, assessing accuracy, F1 score, and
computational time.
Results: From 1,058,957 collected tweets, transformer-based bidirectional
encoder representations achieved the highest F1 scores (71.1%-86.4%) across all
four categories.
Conclusions: Transformer-based models outperform traditional techniques in
classifying eating disorder-related tweets, though they require more
computational resources. | [
0.05322922021150589,
-0.761545717716217,
0.26200246810913086,
0.1630607396364212,
-0.10773205012083054,
0.38254430890083313,
0.008921219035983086,
-0.6446903944015503,
0.5714535117149353,
0.40380367636680603,
-0.27375397086143494,
-0.4488566219806671,
-1.0533400774002075,
0.24710066616535187,
-0.6494867205619812,
0.7424083948135376,
-0.3320404887199402,
0.4189414381980896,
0.09156015515327454,
-0.08674212545156479,
-0.16591663658618927,
-0.30418112874031067,
-0.605137050151825,
-0.2535269856452942,
0.47415053844451904,
0.31614771485328674,
0.6471726298332214,
0.366646409034729,
0.7746585607528687,
0.22905290126800537,
0.15098516643047333,
0.10309117287397385,
-0.5595872402191162,
0.017386799678206444,
-0.05072809010744095,
-0.044733066111803055,
-0.19045713543891907,
-0.008904967457056046,
0.17111477255821228,
0.7411524653434753,
-0.267194926738739,
0.3403496742248535,
0.20593443512916565,
0.6443926095962524,
-0.0869312435388565,
0.05423842743039131,
-0.21968790888786316,
0.40008002519607544,
-0.045258596539497375,
-0.04407107084989548,
-0.3341366648674011,
-0.7636727690696716,
0.12254250794649124,
-0.31275978684425354,
0.11839170753955841,
0.0663648173213005,
0.9651427865028381,
0.12891903519630432,
-0.7741195559501648,
-0.4848927855491638,
-0.578657865524292,
0.4762018322944641,
-0.5895881652832031,
0.46548929810523987,
0.44018420577049255,
0.5267983078956604,
0.1800527572631836,
-0.661204993724823,
-0.4194060266017914,
0.06258831918239594,
-0.2035529911518097,
-0.20609164237976074,
-0.20350155234336853,
-0.05338390916585922,
0.04333930090069771,
0.01372428797185421,
-0.767909586429596,
0.26930850744247437,
-0.50059974193573,
0.14410610496997833,
0.8750097751617432,
0.08839704096317291,
0.43234890699386597,
-0.43185457587242126,
-0.05175609514117241,
0.07701442390680313,
-0.1561214178800583,
-0.05825713649392128,
-0.2551525831222534,
-0.008654176257550716,
-0.029795944690704346,
0.811672568321228,
0.10761583596467972,
0.28489232063293457,
0.3233076333999634,
0.07598099857568741,
0.4376591145992279,
0.09381172806024551,
-0.422294944524765,
0.12992486357688904,
0.8507694602012634,
0.7940293550491333,
0.2248566746711731,
-0.29168474674224854,
-0.334757536649704,
-0.09165860712528229,
0.5080129504203796,
-0.9535669088363647,
-0.3188280761241913,
0.18351463973522186,
-0.7504122257232666,
-0.3719397485256195,
0.13502027094364166,
-0.6470077633857727,
-0.7776986956596375,
-0.04248970001935959,
0.37202170491218567,
-0.58372563123703,
-0.1835913062095642,
-0.11273016035556793,
-0.29216277599334717,
0.3897133469581604,
0.4527393877506256,
-0.7029228210449219,
0.376191645860672,
0.5967403650283813,
0.7555464506149292,
-0.17230671644210815,
0.3622623085975647,
-0.018626943230628967,
0.2716553509235382,
-0.445663720369339,
0.6390480399131775,
-0.6947540640830994,
-0.04384540393948555,
0.08349147439002991,
0.33964774012565613,
-0.46723267436027527,
-0.4638684093952179,
0.7852253317832947,
-0.6497939229011536,
-0.0980982631444931,
-0.3608068823814392,
-0.8594201803207397,
-0.6958400011062622,
0.17306137084960938,
-0.8571608662605286,
0.6702820062637329,
0.1725524365901947,
-0.5682777166366577,
0.37276455760002136,
-0.6771108508110046,
-0.852391242980957,
0.2544881999492645,
0.09870697557926178,
-0.39163216948509216,
0.1523270606994629,
0.4569198489189148,
0.9811306595802307,
-0.32093629240989685,
0.5823848247528076,
-0.29922300577163696,
-0.24025972187519073,
0.350749135017395,
-0.25972780585289,
0.5625537037849426,
0.3775005638599396,
-0.24490365386009216,
0.16684973239898682,
-0.3021903932094574,
-0.18884147703647614,
0.5438400506973267,
-0.13944202661514282,
-0.2175135612487793,
0.14770688116550446,
0.34293365478515625,
-0.04432596638798714,
-0.03707578778266907,
-0.6851125955581665,
0.14152413606643677,
-0.1888400912284851,
0.707132875919342,
0.5684936046600342,
0.08386164903640747,
0.2436230331659317,
-0.7470171451568604,
0.2567911744117737,
0.09699122607707977,
0.009187847375869751,
-0.002347766188904643,
-0.7481350302696228,
-0.38020622730255127,
0.005314968526363373,
0.24114571511745453,
0.618532121181488,
-0.7342618107795715,
0.7167270183563232,
-0.5034044981002808,
-0.481912225484848,
-0.6778239607810974,
-0.2448805421590805,
-0.07332630455493927,
0.621344804763794,
0.44064053893089294,
0.13845081627368927,
-0.5703753232955933,
-0.6207430958747864,
-0.11033588647842407,
0.31038838624954224,
-0.09992747008800507,
0.3153909146785736,
0.5272340178489685,
-0.40720415115356445,
0.44613927602767944,
-0.3219633996486664,
0.0023659183643758297,
-0.3999408185482025,
0.3115592896938324,
-0.10629252344369888,
0.3734889030456543,
0.7752270698547363,
-1.1052743196487427,
-1.0032662153244019,
0.20301496982574463,
-0.7227829694747925,
0.05239012464880943,
0.3179539740085602,
0.23203088343143463,
0.32356902956962585,
0.10991615802049637,
-0.27693361043930054,
0.5827881097793579,
0.5166584849357605,
-0.2599022686481476,
0.43325144052505493,
0.5041434168815613,
0.3356829285621643,
-1.029573917388916,
-0.14986705780029297,
0.39661890268325806,
-0.39030981063842773,
-0.5424741506576538,
-0.4270267188549042,
0.23909521102905273,
-0.15589219331741333,
-0.03668738901615143,
0.20536428689956665,
0.010242109186947346,
0.3112322986125946,
0.02902320958673954,
-0.45463550090789795,
-0.11523442715406418,
0.23173320293426514,
-0.025437066331505775,
0.23231832683086395,
0.647833526134491,
-0.34128671884536743,
0.47689735889434814,
-0.2661339342594147,
-0.33785560727119446,
0.2645212411880493,
-0.6695773601531982,
0.010907099582254887,
-0.36842080950737,
0.15220552682876587,
-1.48650324344635,
-0.45573121309280396,
0.4409306049346924,
-0.588614821434021,
0.3471740484237671,
0.13449116051197052,
-0.5980991721153259,
-0.877392053604126,
-0.44418904185295105,
0.19576989114284515,
0.5037796497344971,
-0.5754712820053101,
0.5852779746055603,
0.37791743874549866,
0.12549011409282684,
0.03619995340704918,
-0.7732429504394531,
-0.05717775970697403,
-0.15597806870937347,
-0.6145998239517212,
0.25661322474479675,
0.12390612065792084,
0.1258242130279541,
0.41604259610176086,
-0.11501200497150421,
-0.189917653799057,
-0.05749845132231712,
0.14565718173980713,
-0.1604955494403839,
-0.026545163244009018,
0.11703591048717499,
0.10889413952827454,
0.30292168259620667,
-0.06025347858667374,
0.016429107636213303,
0.5850746631622314,
0.037359852343797684,
-0.15710294246673584,
-0.7458109259605408,
0.6198664903640747,
0.6109669208526611,
-0.016032280400395393,
0.8088029026985168,
0.8014849424362183,
-0.6430697441101074,
-0.21429958939552307,
-0.5201107859611511,
-0.19351838529109955,
-0.4607659876346588,
0.2727947235107422,
-0.11192939430475235,
-0.6873602867126465,
0.5123510956764221,
0.1180371344089508,
-0.12368272244930267,
0.3821444511413574,
0.2690964639186859,
-0.588992714881897,
1.1115190982818604,
0.426837682723999,
-0.09872156381607056,
0.46805113554000854,
-0.41498351097106934,
0.15914830565452576,
-0.5125989317893982,
-0.30957841873168945,
-0.37343335151672363,
-0.6108312010765076,
-0.6786938309669495,
-0.44091787934303284,
0.2751888036727905,
-0.6384936571121216,
-0.4397549629211426,
0.26617076992988586,
-0.6936770081520081,
0.23075902462005615,
0.21234539151191711,
0.38582921028137207,
-0.2155933678150177,
0.0027433380018919706,
-0.1682536005973816,
-0.19180996716022491,
-0.3974989950656891,
-0.49304407835006714,
1.1885374784469604,
0.626142680644989,
0.871877908706665,
0.09531805664300919,
0.774590790271759,
0.7315158247947693,
0.8392137289047241,
-0.9236717820167542,
0.2798399329185486,
-0.48231205344200134,
-0.5936152935028076,
-0.170507550239563,
-0.6966961622238159,
-0.8106721639633179,
-0.051975641399621964,
0.18778595328330994,
-0.8057038187980652,
0.054445281624794006,
-0.3688371479511261,
-0.15060128271579742,
0.5955469012260437,
-1.0509116649627686,
0.7608041167259216,
-0.5233506560325623,
-0.036553189158439636,
0.02225794456899166,
-0.7460290789604187,
0.14716780185699463,
-0.0976840928196907,
0.10952198505401611,
-0.1677553653717041,
0.11682229489088058,
1.454877495765686,
-0.24917832016944885,
0.9926716685295105,
-0.2715234160423279,
0.09951318800449371,
-0.05105416104197502,
0.18242931365966797,
0.18751747906208038,
-0.13233764469623566,
-0.2829571068286896,
0.10025151073932648,
0.02248206175863743,
-0.19500873982906342,
-0.46431100368499756,
0.48695939779281616,
-0.8022980093955994,
-0.20423796772956848,
-0.5099501609802246,
-0.1064891442656517,
-0.28619545698165894,
0.40436169505119324,
-0.05690164491534233,
0.13181930780410767,
-0.14305658638477325,
0.33923694491386414,
0.5916414856910706,
0.07680421322584152,
0.5275878310203552,
0.3596067428588867,
-0.08341578394174576,
-0.5136186480522156,
0.7886924743652344,
0.308703750371933,
-0.3290310800075531,
0.7090399861335754,
0.23196858167648315,
-0.07902459055185318,
-0.393388032913208,
-0.14731082320213318,
0.40457290410995483,
-0.3583739399909973,
-0.4870540201663971,
-0.5500427484512329,
-0.4697934687137604,
-0.7685186862945557,
-0.43253016471862793,
-0.3296217620372772,
-0.18235604465007782,
-0.6934388875961304,
-0.4322938919067383,
0.01975482888519764,
1.0941932201385498,
0.10866566747426987,
0.23239479959011078,
-0.7867093086242676,
0.44634148478507996,
0.08273326605558395,
0.5242738127708435,
0.5372540354728699,
-0.27099940180778503,
-0.16794030368328094,
0.12994930148124695,
-0.7285019755363464,
-1.3931900262832642,
0.6735965013504028,
0.22993013262748718,
0.4608299136161804,
0.9353432655334473,
0.14302530884742737,
0.5129896402359009,
-0.1475989818572998,
0.6396527290344238,
0.3394363820552826,
-0.5927971601486206,
0.4897969663143158,
-0.020604340359568596,
0.03562267869710922,
0.21863780915737152,
1.1843641996383667,
-0.8897581100463867,
-0.05065838247537613,
-0.21307428181171417,
-0.4945119619369507,
0.7662084102630615,
-0.007054660003632307,
0.11419384926557541,
-0.12551458179950714,
0.1903604418039322,
0.3601219356060028,
0.22821906208992004,
-0.8249222040176392,
-0.2974506616592407,
-0.44999951124191284,
-0.6049639582633972,
-0.07997749745845795,
-0.47832590341567993,
0.1155010238289833,
-0.7903063297271729,
0.45440053939819336,
0.06257441639900208,
0.4267135560512543,
0.12099914252758026,
-0.14598841965198517,
-0.46956026554107666,
-0.03687363117933273,
0.1848701536655426,
0.4839431941509247,
-0.5681021213531494,
-0.04121106117963791,
-0.30611759424209595,
-0.6007137298583984,
-0.0005951586063019931,
0.44705256819725037,
-0.17454446852207184,
0.03309589624404907,
0.501864492893219,
0.7177823781967163,
0.0961027517914772,
-0.5403214693069458,
0.48448646068573,
-0.19884353876113892,
-0.45995795726776123,
-0.11868866533041,
-0.11637194454669952,
0.14739611744880676,
0.026854965835809708,
0.6529048681259155,
0.01208050362765789,
0.3351682126522064,
-0.3673610985279083,
0.2846430242061615,
0.16001878678798676,
-0.5108281373977661,
-0.587683379650116,
0.5040737986564636,
0.2555748224258423,
-0.2787225544452667,
0.8884840607643127,
-0.4013572037220001,
-0.6746060252189636,
0.6766558289527893,
0.4693318009376526,
1.0921789407730103,
-0.6855278611183167,
0.48534518480300903,
0.35343173146247864,
0.3887670636177063,
0.18274396657943726,
0.27206069231033325,
-0.19047746062278748,
-0.9573707580566406,
-0.053314968943595886,
-0.8322345018386841,
-0.11785721033811569,
0.05795837566256523,
-0.7717664241790771,
0.17888331413269043,
-0.2468680590391159,
-0.3348158895969391,
0.4691171646118164,
-0.14322572946548462,
-0.781851053237915,
0.10778576880693436,
0.3894391655921936,
0.7270435094833374,
-1.0434858798980713,
0.6970853209495544,
1.1916579008102417,
-0.2139042317867279,
-0.6196735501289368,
0.3775360882282257,
-0.0845252275466919,
-0.7690825462341309,
0.3920038640499115,
0.539897620677948,
0.41829022765159607,
-0.11562154442071915,
-0.7170135974884033,
-0.826719343662262,
0.8148350119590759,
-0.06648090481758118,
-0.5373688340187073,
-0.2885204553604126,
0.3858041763305664,
0.5843457579612732,
-0.31071025133132935,
0.14064009487628937,
0.5090492963790894,
0.5701832175254822,
0.5924230217933655,
-1.1735919713974,
-0.006725660525262356,
-0.22287213802337646,
0.1035940870642662,
0.04449324309825897,
-0.3648155629634857,
0.4788604974746704,
-0.3740086853504181,
-0.4439186453819275,
-0.375051349401474,
0.4582712948322296,
-0.3256160318851471,
0.5964092016220093,
0.17950071394443512,
0.6699304580688477,
0.8231096267700195,
-0.10547074675559998,
0.8439358472824097,
0.09328988939523697,
0.4036604166030884,
0.6580053567886353,
-0.2915616035461426,
0.5159637331962585,
0.15068791806697845,
-0.23549090325832367,
0.3694777488708496,
0.8611137270927429,
-0.150519460439682,
0.7580665946006775,
-0.05416131392121315,
0.2682116627693176,
0.033691227436065674,
-0.0027007218450307846,
-0.036008842289447784,
0.23686544597148895,
0.6793805360794067,
-0.7271815538406372,
-0.36569949984550476,
0.7049711346626282,
0.18547561764717102,
-0.16804036498069763,
-0.2809547781944275,
1.0308992862701416,
-0.03109222836792469,
-0.14538784325122833,
0.6274452209472656,
0.22859281301498413,
0.7001884579658508,
-0.17725561559200287,
-0.010389109142124653,
0.0573146678507328,
0.05310367792844772,
-0.2173854410648346,
-1.026469111442566,
0.6303883790969849,
-0.16348755359649658,
0.022633548825979233,
-0.39834263920783997,
0.8260847926139832,
-0.2898060381412506,
-0.9222123622894287,
0.24313600361347198,
0.224278524518013,
-0.03863823786377907,
0.04583394154906273,
-0.8109345436096191,
0.20468802750110626,
-0.05770634859800339,
-0.38096708059310913,
-0.1918698102235794,
0.47469642758369446,
-0.03476197272539139,
0.7518554925918579,
0.21522295475006104,
-0.16178318858146667,
0.12302365154027939,
-0.0120993135496974,
0.88053959608078,
-0.7154538035392761,
-0.5225133299827576,
-0.7206781506538391,
0.11941220611333847,
0.00047898790217004716,
0.31969279050827026,
0.7493091225624084,
0.4612565338611603,
0.5708385705947876,
-0.12610405683517456,
0.7484042644500732,
-0.4780481457710266,
0.8083801865577698,
-0.004157171584665775,
0.9610419869422913,
-0.8224688768386841,
0.030534792691469193,
-0.08869165927171707,
-0.16465723514556885,
-0.4732896089553833,
0.6205497980117798,
-0.6432506442070007,
0.35592344403266907,
0.7599208950996399,
0.4389723539352417,
-0.08291617035865784,
0.37782198190689087,
0.022733349353075027,
0.42770862579345703,
0.4999895691871643,
0.47901079058647156,
0.38484641909599304,
-0.42320162057876587,
-0.061951275914907455,
-0.5271322131156921,
-0.31271010637283325,
-0.8000007271766663,
-0.39546099305152893,
-0.8296326994895935,
-0.8806130886077881,
-0.2535821795463562,
-0.09239666163921356,
0.27784115076065063,
0.876853883266449,
0.891340970993042,
-1.0501240491867065,
-0.16086438298225403,
0.2561134696006775,
0.40466389060020447,
-0.5139704346656799,
-0.3382507562637329,
0.48966091871261597,
-0.05659705027937889,
-0.422830730676651,
-0.09405140578746796,
-0.2899380326271057,
0.10999681055545807,
0.1080758199095726,
0.03117877058684826,
-0.2763599455356598,
0.10664547979831696,
0.6569316387176514,
-0.07690427452325821,
-0.3341359794139862,
-0.07941167056560516,
-0.09880387037992477,
-0.19496731460094452,
0.257730096578598,
0.41524410247802734,
-0.39286062121391296,
0.39375773072242737,
0.2675395905971527,
0.4840598702430725,
0.4553185999393463,
0.3003801703453064,
0.24924328923225403,
-0.4637307822704315,
-0.5261208415031433,
0.732748806476593,
0.37124067544937134,
0.44080352783203125,
-0.4683215320110321,
0.21368558704853058,
0.30094006657600403,
-0.5383219718933105,
-0.8416220545768738,
-0.3623920977115631,
-1.0999420881271362,
-0.41119736433029175,
1.1926968097686768,
0.25486063957214355,
-0.6777298450469971,
-0.0015077326679602265,
-0.10462435334920883,
0.3109058141708374,
-0.6229304075241089,
0.8411034345626831,
0.39099976420402527,
-0.37040627002716064,
-0.17095020413398743,
-0.3855746388435364,
0.45925334095954895,
-0.13227035105228424,
-0.5465003848075867,
-0.22753818333148956,
0.2973237633705139,
0.5880799889564514,
-0.14706909656524658,
0.33511507511138916,
-0.00388221419416368,
0.114909827709198,
-0.4067207872867584,
0.06723733991384506,
0.00947427749633789,
-0.2782154679298401,
0.061163585633039474,
0.35721373558044434,
-0.5774419903755188,
-0.32021284103393555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05547v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05547v2 | Benchmarking Large Language Models on Communicative Medical Coaching: a Novel System and Dataset | 2024-02-08T10:32:06 | 2024-06-08T16:36:56 | Hengguan Huang, Songtao Wang, Hongfu Liu, Hao Wang, Ye Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional applications of natural language processing (NLP) in healthcare
have predominantly focused on patient-centered services, enhancing patient
interactions and care delivery, such as through medical dialogue systems.
However, the potential of NLP to benefit inexperienced doctors, particularly in
areas such as communicative medical coaching, remains largely unexplored. We
introduce "ChatCoach", a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist
medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient
consultations. ChatCoach (Our data and code are available online:
https://github.com/zerowst/Chatcoach)differentiates itself from conventional
dialogue systems by offering a simulated environment where medical learners can
practice dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides
immediate, structured feedback. This is facilitated by our proposed Generalized
Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which fosters the generation of structured
feedback and enhances the utilization of external knowledge sources.
Additionally, we have developed a dataset specifically for evaluating Large
Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework on communicative medical
coaching tasks. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of ChatCoach. | [
-0.154176265001297,
-0.6922698616981506,
0.30672717094421387,
0.15617211163043976,
-0.0988522619009018,
0.4070437550544739,
-0.49064815044403076,
-0.7055966854095459,
0.3328191637992859,
0.35073813796043396,
-0.45427072048187256,
-0.5764826536178589,
-0.6228967905044556,
0.08559894561767578,
-0.2620115876197815,
0.6312292218208313,
0.20311766862869263,
0.763721227645874,
-0.3974405527114868,
-0.28946593403816223,
-0.5032774209976196,
-0.7523228526115417,
-1.2196934223175049,
-0.6006565093994141,
0.3046613335609436,
0.508162260055542,
0.5842254757881165,
0.22156603634357452,
0.6430310606956482,
0.3600000739097595,
0.06778687983751297,
0.402192622423172,
-0.2782134413719177,
0.5381022691726685,
-0.10576479882001877,
-0.5948562622070312,
-0.46756842732429504,
-0.014715958386659622,
0.42703619599342346,
1.1882638931274414,
-0.6753852963447571,
-0.21498331427574158,
0.0331190750002861,
0.38581234216690063,
-0.352649450302124,
0.40455448627471924,
-0.7023130655288696,
0.20129041373729706,
0.336324006319046,
-0.25153106451034546,
-0.47306933999061584,
-0.45847100019454956,
0.26330509781837463,
-0.5511711239814758,
0.14696526527404785,
0.2114519625902176,
0.5905981659889221,
0.26389941573143005,
-0.23349754512310028,
-0.5158995985984802,
-0.5632351636886597,
0.7009298205375671,
-0.8057926893234253,
0.28481724858283997,
0.44692814350128174,
0.6207565069198608,
-0.3981073796749115,
-0.6366553902626038,
-0.3964782953262329,
-0.45279157161712646,
0.10653113573789597,
0.3978210985660553,
-0.23423276841640472,
0.29528898000717163,
0.16536688804626465,
0.24573758244514465,
-0.4110180139541626,
0.484876424074173,
-0.06134979799389839,
0.060692280530929565,
0.6189286708831787,
0.2945846915245056,
0.5967101454734802,
0.2748264968395233,
-0.015251973643898964,
-0.0819711685180664,
-0.5086678862571716,
-0.024716349318623543,
-0.28423523902893066,
0.15565930306911469,
-0.43122783303260803,
0.48054930567741394,
-0.20894111692905426,
0.5596625804901123,
-0.2588248550891876,
-0.09919335693120956,
0.15438207983970642,
-0.18155215680599213,
-0.3334076702594757,
-0.043706364929676056,
1.0539219379425049,
0.5889821648597717,
0.5704383254051208,
-0.46950119733810425,
0.18471744656562805,
0.2202536016702652,
0.37484434247016907,
-0.8104308247566223,
-0.24483239650726318,
0.21489931643009186,
-0.350384384393692,
-0.4353262782096863,
-0.32303446531295776,
-0.7720354795455933,
-0.4465404152870178,
-0.14814338088035583,
-0.19580285251140594,
-0.2738872170448303,
-0.06551233679056168,
0.19427098333835602,
0.07711635529994965,
0.2491941750049591,
0.4047626554965973,
-0.9499372243881226,
0.8903980851173401,
0.7212551832199097,
0.8840742111206055,
-0.3037935197353363,
-0.05038530007004738,
-0.7103931307792664,
-0.08659476786851883,
-0.5179855823516846,
0.8631874918937683,
-0.6007813811302185,
-0.6168940663337708,
0.26163792610168457,
-0.07924407720565796,
-0.12549792230129242,
-1.1015688180923462,
0.6100649237632751,
-0.024123450741171837,
0.20645006000995636,
0.21559889614582062,
-0.8035236597061157,
0.3314897418022156,
0.3296002447605133,
-0.5365638136863708,
0.6283850073814392,
0.030831068754196167,
-0.480102002620697,
0.2461746484041214,
-0.5680474638938904,
-0.5229278802871704,
0.2749943733215332,
-0.6762275099754333,
-0.5307386517524719,
0.13817402720451355,
0.29310154914855957,
0.3906960189342499,
-0.7250561714172363,
0.4424982964992523,
-0.4006507694721222,
-0.316218763589859,
0.2992453873157501,
-0.24495287239551544,
0.7618719935417175,
0.0033344777766615152,
-0.23913545906543732,
0.11793637275695801,
-0.6092283725738525,
0.295914888381958,
-0.09258047491312027,
-0.22663035988807678,
-0.21008886396884918,
0.0978441834449768,
-0.19756990671157837,
0.23927292227745056,
-0.5091077089309692,
-0.39673173427581787,
0.4550108313560486,
-0.5051246285438538,
0.3941150903701782,
0.1626434326171875,
0.18281376361846924,
0.11009535938501358,
-0.460980623960495,
0.752187192440033,
-0.04390614107251167,
0.29146823287010193,
-0.05121392756700516,
-0.7089226841926575,
-0.4943055808544159,
-0.40697363018989563,
0.22741812467575073,
0.41104087233543396,
-0.9877164959907532,
0.33746451139450073,
-0.2252936214208603,
-0.5104397535324097,
-0.8499926924705505,
-0.09599975496530533,
0.3819974362850189,
0.6922647356987,
0.3770039677619934,
-0.754039466381073,
-0.44244587421417236,
-0.672273576259613,
-0.12218930572271347,
-0.22716332972049713,
-0.22092244029045105,
0.6009413599967957,
0.40567559003829956,
-0.19342388212680817,
0.5426515936851501,
-0.3947778344154358,
-0.47189024090766907,
-0.2502005398273468,
0.10661593824625015,
0.10624127089977264,
0.5042650103569031,
0.3398725688457489,
-0.4698023200035095,
-0.5179737210273743,
0.10247448831796646,
-0.7899864315986633,
-0.1659543365240097,
-0.021098962053656578,
0.03268950432538986,
0.08845843374729156,
0.5300408005714417,
-0.5047751665115356,
0.288554847240448,
0.8859162330627441,
-0.191428080201149,
0.6648003458976746,
-0.566088855266571,
0.2334383875131607,
-1.173202633857727,
0.3416379392147064,
-0.16304782032966614,
-0.33450937271118164,
-0.6175409555435181,
-0.19558455049991608,
-0.2641650438308716,
-0.19118647277355194,
-0.1499248892068863,
0.4834049940109253,
-0.3092290461063385,
0.034034281969070435,
-0.384174108505249,
0.16779519617557526,
-0.2951943874359131,
0.44858407974243164,
0.17962807416915894,
0.6484100818634033,
0.5739572048187256,
-0.3735045790672302,
0.4326700270175934,
0.3936373293399811,
-0.670091450214386,
0.9894437193870544,
-0.9559885263442993,
0.17277121543884277,
0.33867642283439636,
0.5008975863456726,
-0.7258460521697998,
-0.262039452791214,
0.1722358763217926,
-0.5553484559059143,
0.11418949067592621,
-0.25015291571617126,
-0.47778451442718506,
-0.37337663769721985,
0.07387816905975342,
0.22409500181674957,
0.40125906467437744,
-0.23773221671581268,
0.3629860579967499,
0.721865713596344,
-0.4927217364311218,
-0.31042611598968506,
-0.5140873789787292,
0.3659401834011078,
0.25124087929725647,
-0.31869980692863464,
0.31607693433761597,
-0.14371907711029053,
-0.17894625663757324,
-0.11549206078052521,
0.01648729294538498,
-0.5145322680473328,
0.2750300168991089,
0.4222683310508728,
0.44798824191093445,
0.04333599656820297,
0.32696646451950073,
0.028204768896102905,
-0.023791179060935974,
0.17897437512874603,
-0.2665834426879883,
0.6929776668548584,
0.10440202802419662,
-0.3892335593700409,
-0.5316372513771057,
0.5797885060310364,
0.40142884850502014,
-0.261489599943161,
0.7505785226821899,
0.1612132042646408,
-0.27041521668434143,
-0.22237181663513184,
-0.41854918003082275,
-0.2748631536960602,
-0.3583391308784485,
0.43666505813598633,
0.13125814497470856,
-0.824461042881012,
0.3215898871421814,
-0.25665485858917236,
-0.01875549927353859,
0.04386245831847191,
0.7733071446418762,
-0.19744619727134705,
1.101844072341919,
0.377699077129364,
-0.1449122577905655,
0.22295863926410675,
-0.3092169761657715,
-0.04459035396575928,
-0.6491098999977112,
-0.2571968138217926,
-0.7088106870651245,
-0.2022460550069809,
-0.749640703201294,
-0.6721097826957703,
0.41842979192733765,
-0.29367199540138245,
0.06225552037358284,
-0.10716123878955841,
-0.3653474748134613,
0.3996140956878662,
0.5628451108932495,
0.06686237454414368,
0.3516479432582855,
-0.24358414113521576,
-0.5410391688346863,
0.05238177999854088,
-0.8779513239860535,
-0.18257611989974976,
0.9760287404060364,
0.1230984702706337,
0.7848585844039917,
-0.06093459576368332,
0.65464186668396,
0.04333244636654854,
0.5752199292182922,
-0.9226639866828918,
0.4818759858608246,
-0.06241178512573242,
-0.40841954946517944,
-0.06274903565645218,
-0.7271584272384644,
-1.2154771089553833,
0.2691025137901306,
-0.49439677596092224,
-0.5818542838096619,
-0.257699579000473,
0.025066619738936424,
-0.3697834610939026,
0.1310325413942337,
-0.7713699340820312,
0.650483250617981,
-0.04676614701747894,
-0.35608282685279846,
-0.34515172243118286,
-0.6631847023963928,
-0.08874144405126572,
0.02130287140607834,
0.17143705487251282,
-0.014502502046525478,
0.11957914382219315,
0.39241719245910645,
-0.4208770990371704,
0.9176625609397888,
-0.19669675827026367,
-0.042046647518873215,
0.06511333584785461,
-0.19958972930908203,
0.23661021888256073,
0.014135167002677917,
0.007836036384105682,
0.03763426095247269,
0.08990033715963364,
-0.48615437746047974,
-0.8268849849700928,
0.6204946041107178,
-0.636208176612854,
-0.32613345980644226,
-0.3741825222969055,
-0.5989403128623962,
-0.8667954802513123,
0.04311927407979965,
-0.048865485936403275,
0.4427638053894043,
-0.5161476731300354,
0.41296136379241943,
0.21181067824363708,
-0.4268784523010254,
0.17112994194030762,
0.6646581292152405,
-0.19144438207149506,
-0.37744441628456116,
0.5402035713195801,
0.06688753515481949,
0.350821316242218,
0.1737941950559616,
0.1442505121231079,
-0.09223336726427078,
-0.5517348647117615,
-0.018896857276558876,
0.2687240540981293,
-0.4805443584918976,
-0.0806574821472168,
-0.5329712629318237,
-0.3352758288383484,
-0.23842622339725494,
0.02664230763912201,
-0.24501582980155945,
-0.18780893087387085,
0.304768830537796,
0.14488114416599274,
-0.1897927224636078,
0.6789785027503967,
0.21444259583950043,
0.20665064454078674,
-0.6513306498527527,
0.15528367459774017,
0.2758578956127167,
0.5741351842880249,
0.10581148415803909,
-0.09689296782016754,
-0.47205987572669983,
0.0773538202047348,
-0.27353179454803467,
-0.5718323588371277,
0.4462411105632782,
0.1315367966890335,
0.6954575181007385,
0.18803170323371887,
-0.005273228976875544,
0.4562283754348755,
-0.7058517932891846,
0.653924822807312,
0.40509510040283203,
-0.5686376690864563,
0.2401927411556244,
-0.09758099168539047,
0.44047099351882935,
0.7214189767837524,
0.41623857617378235,
-0.9341676831245422,
-0.7859338521957397,
-0.6561354398727417,
-0.7656590938568115,
0.3794250190258026,
0.14611145853996277,
-0.025785136967897415,
-0.32078999280929565,
-0.023169133812189102,
-0.009673621505498886,
0.39466118812561035,
-0.12987631559371948,
0.010102837346494198,
0.38938429951667786,
-0.3863246738910675,
-0.186691552400589,
0.14328595995903015,
-0.34669873118400574,
-0.270626038312912,
0.5014684796333313,
-0.308671236038208,
0.5015456080436707,
0.33821702003479004,
0.012251515872776508,
0.05153428018093109,
0.24564050137996674,
0.6126112937927246,
0.4049675762653351,
-0.061506785452365875,
0.06706485152244568,
0.15625984966754913,
-0.6408883333206177,
0.06497497856616974,
0.048354774713516235,
0.2872714102268219,
0.2200060933828354,
0.6006171107292175,
0.5082792043685913,
0.627659022808075,
-0.9162577986717224,
0.5269007086753845,
-0.3922483026981354,
-0.2877352833747864,
-0.09204807132482529,
0.23865140974521637,
0.24464814364910126,
0.17091979086399078,
-0.01412681769579649,
0.0648677796125412,
0.08906575292348862,
-0.551592230796814,
0.3645825982093811,
0.4882529675960541,
-0.6307008862495422,
-0.2069236934185028,
0.5897394418716431,
0.5456702709197998,
-0.5702797770500183,
0.5080525875091553,
0.2566247284412384,
-0.22407767176628113,
0.5216396450996399,
0.37265539169311523,
0.7475336194038391,
-0.20825712382793427,
0.3529125154018402,
0.19430853426456451,
-0.1790224313735962,
-0.07466783374547958,
0.07385487109422684,
-0.13057471811771393,
-0.6207289695739746,
-0.5367617011070251,
-0.03962871804833412,
-1.1424660682678223,
-0.08896468579769135,
-0.7713707685470581,
0.0761493369936943,
-0.2884787619113922,
-0.274213582277298,
0.4786317050457001,
0.265103816986084,
-0.8755412101745605,
0.24911552667617798,
0.039857517927885056,
0.9017137885093689,
-0.41689446568489075,
1.2237472534179688,
0.49604809284210205,
-0.29729968309402466,
-0.9027479290962219,
0.1014380007982254,
0.0028076814487576485,
-1.0130717754364014,
0.4307618737220764,
0.0877811536192894,
-0.26346972584724426,
0.008357083424925804,
-0.5679459571838379,
0.06506072729825974,
0.91365647315979,
0.35790014266967773,
-0.7800869345664978,
-0.2643503248691559,
0.2172495573759079,
0.9506567716598511,
-0.6143567562103271,
0.6089797616004944,
0.3046315610408783,
-0.15066440403461456,
0.146217480301857,
-1.111742615699768,
-0.2977023422718048,
-0.3753122389316559,
-0.2841913402080536,
-0.08719107508659363,
-0.5466840267181396,
0.22275328636169434,
-0.19007103145122528,
0.07081783562898636,
0.2363082319498062,
0.07071197032928467,
0.11539661139249802,
0.1328071653842926,
0.4791497588157654,
0.4110937714576721,
1.2054486274719238,
-0.0587858110666275,
1.3089513778686523,
-0.39626622200012207,
0.35773852467536926,
1.5164132118225098,
-0.5818820595741272,
0.867908239364624,
0.48249465227127075,
-0.07584662735462189,
0.4730657935142517,
0.05976712703704834,
0.032832298427820206,
0.2713877260684967,
0.3937588930130005,
-0.34890368580818176,
-0.0841580182313919,
-0.48697859048843384,
-0.22544245421886444,
0.5810118317604065,
0.1956818550825119,
-0.43791401386260986,
0.02432158775627613,
-0.10874343663454056,
0.19996501505374908,
0.15704390406608582,
-0.1451234519481659,
1.0237776041030884,
0.3380851745605469,
-0.9987399578094482,
0.7532635927200317,
-0.4186944365501404,
0.3794116973876953,
-0.6073800921440125,
-0.14841310679912567,
-0.24724505841732025,
0.34860000014305115,
0.04455745220184326,
-0.6167188882827759,
0.07259828597307205,
0.026259474456310272,
0.24458812177181244,
-0.05258335918188095,
0.43086302280426025,
-0.6613069176673889,
-0.330269455909729,
0.4441865384578705,
0.5766843557357788,
0.03437008336186409,
0.15202750265598297,
-0.7218248844146729,
-0.06855488568544388,
-0.34125298261642456,
0.1627284735441208,
0.23638057708740234,
0.3564225733280182,
0.19025114178657532,
0.9165776371955872,
0.5730427503585815,
0.45527568459510803,
-0.2840658724308014,
0.5695904493331909,
0.8213079571723938,
-0.61802077293396,
-0.4367046654224396,
-0.6630986928939819,
0.2330787479877472,
-0.5112962126731873,
-0.30219557881355286,
0.4834553301334381,
0.6141358613967896,
0.6439432501792908,
0.1323372721672058,
0.7242545485496521,
0.25595974922180176,
0.6783009767532349,
-0.3516589105129242,
0.8416304588317871,
-0.3173237144947052,
-0.002589044626802206,
-0.2946423888206482,
-0.3101356327533722,
-0.6242110133171082,
0.6413261890411377,
-0.3120405673980713,
-0.08536607027053833,
0.7461829781532288,
0.5416980385780334,
0.1690288931131363,
0.17978207767009735,
0.6588678359985352,
0.24307775497436523,
0.690853476524353,
0.7183863520622253,
0.6943899989128113,
-0.060002487152814865,
0.24884089827537537,
0.0069884867407381535,
-0.2957207262516022,
-0.34819942712783813,
-0.5333364605903625,
-1.0786837339401245,
-0.37251022458076477,
-0.27056124806404114,
-0.28731396794319153,
0.33402305841445923,
1.370701551437378,
0.9891831278800964,
-0.7222639918327332,
-0.48994478583335876,
-0.08271339535713196,
-0.2616134285926819,
-0.436320036649704,
-0.10882289707660675,
0.17793820798397064,
-0.5472596883773804,
-0.7695093154907227,
0.36214810609817505,
0.34867140650749207,
-0.025386100634932518,
-0.06005605310201645,
-0.16212216019630432,
-0.20400868356227875,
0.15198016166687012,
0.44754669070243835,
0.17945672571659088,
-0.33314043283462524,
-0.13986633718013763,
0.09488940984010696,
-0.4397818446159363,
0.37225258350372314,
0.9285669326782227,
-0.6760463118553162,
0.7008008360862732,
-0.12293075025081635,
0.8631892800331116,
0.29830795526504517,
-0.16189253330230713,
0.8698500990867615,
-0.5104982256889343,
0.2062486708164215,
0.5804648995399475,
0.24410298466682434,
0.29916277527809143,
0.1638716608285904,
0.6988222599029541,
0.17070920765399933,
-0.7231939435005188,
-0.7784041166305542,
-0.0037540097255259752,
-0.9661787748336792,
-0.06277868151664734,
0.8992961645126343,
-0.38168901205062866,
-0.03871580585837364,
-0.26389068365097046,
-0.5582855939865112,
0.3184768557548523,
-0.2930335998535156,
1.019723892211914,
0.741579532623291,
-0.0892474502325058,
0.0007575543131679296,
-0.8492005467414856,
0.5280066132545471,
0.6495232582092285,
-1.2223684787750244,
-0.08726111054420471,
0.15697962045669556,
0.18281510472297668,
-0.22256042063236237,
0.9022952318191528,
-0.0008035458740778267,
0.30721724033355713,
-0.12159016728401184,
0.13712134957313538,
0.19788812100887299,
-0.1362178921699524,
-0.12740908563137054,
-0.08905251324176788,
0.02297348901629448,
-0.2292378693819046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05545v1 | Named Entity Recognition for Address Extraction in Speech-to-Text Transcriptions Using Synthetic Data | 2024-02-08T10:29:11 | 2024-02-08T10:29:11 | Bibiána Lajčinová, Patrik Valábek, Michal Spišiak | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper introduces an approach for building a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) model built upon a Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) architecture, specifically utilizing the SlovakBERT model.
This NER model extracts address parts from data acquired from speech-to-text
transcriptions. Due to scarcity of real data, a synthetic dataset using GPT API
was generated. The importance of mimicking spoken language variability in this
artificial data is emphasized. The performance of our NER model, trained solely
on synthetic data, is evaluated using small real test dataset. | [
-0.37008506059646606,
-0.7761241793632507,
0.6368624567985535,
-0.14666259288787842,
-0.0564982034265995,
0.0472525954246521,
-0.25410813093185425,
-0.8152804374694824,
0.3959856331348419,
0.7636358737945557,
-0.5223509669303894,
-0.3810078203678131,
-0.5073295831680298,
0.48890748620033264,
-0.67554771900177,
1.0881117582321167,
0.0958249419927597,
0.14770403504371643,
0.20316089689731598,
0.17123781144618988,
-0.3698935806751251,
-0.7799766659736633,
-0.6015785336494446,
-0.0657980814576149,
0.297372043132782,
0.31011584401130676,
0.3951588571071625,
0.45771732926368713,
0.44719448685646057,
0.2960361838340759,
0.01209061685949564,
0.036677733063697815,
-0.07133637368679047,
0.19348646700382233,
-0.12475372850894928,
-0.28226733207702637,
-0.3151318430900574,
-0.17778070271015167,
0.9507935047149658,
0.3624303340911865,
0.0106188440695405,
0.1675054281949997,
-0.3821064233779907,
0.33139750361442566,
-0.10940143465995789,
0.16853643953800201,
-0.849851131439209,
-0.07503952831029892,
-0.3281397819519043,
0.057083651423454285,
-0.5936840176582336,
-0.45805180072784424,
0.6701836585998535,
-0.3065050542354584,
0.5270617008209229,
0.012955265119671822,
1.063015341758728,
0.04418144002556801,
-0.2799361050128937,
-0.5327911376953125,
-1.2119712829589844,
0.41787007451057434,
-0.554780900478363,
0.6773862838745117,
-0.026211371645331383,
0.5601240992546082,
-0.25537383556365967,
-0.8614912629127502,
-0.8140330910682678,
-0.15756957232952118,
-0.09659375995397568,
0.013149134814739227,
-0.180746391415596,
-0.028209205716848373,
0.3786543309688568,
0.19816520810127258,
-0.38163959980010986,
-0.24485670030117035,
-0.5900399684906006,
-0.18337425589561462,
0.4537373483181,
-0.1410631239414215,
0.5223333835601807,
-0.29167410731315613,
-0.5255250334739685,
-0.01467955019325018,
-0.6309912204742432,
-0.133785679936409,
0.6256427764892578,
0.6757932305335999,
0.07423516362905502,
0.6672860383987427,
-0.05251385271549225,
0.4638099670410156,
0.44493383169174194,
0.0701083242893219,
0.3393336534500122,
0.1976533830165863,
-0.3417752683162689,
0.7543525695800781,
0.6063305735588074,
-0.35548514127731323,
0.35028108954429626,
-0.6301828026771545,
-0.4945894181728363,
-0.20360922813415527,
0.40322068333625793,
-0.6296998262405396,
-0.5572642683982849,
0.15956494212150574,
-0.2910439670085907,
-0.0742991641163826,
0.4118284285068512,
-0.9106274843215942,
0.044709865003824234,
-0.6358367204666138,
0.39870530366897583,
-0.525894820690155,
-0.24658069014549255,
-0.31373533606529236,
-0.2308323085308075,
0.3986600637435913,
0.2925276458263397,
-0.8572250008583069,
0.5673911571502686,
0.6073890328407288,
0.5308265686035156,
-0.2653522789478302,
0.10935820639133453,
-0.3843812048435211,
0.2790559232234955,
0.06934480369091034,
0.814950704574585,
-0.5739352107048035,
-0.33434855937957764,
-0.2082541286945343,
0.15135160088539124,
-0.05881710350513458,
-0.7596126198768616,
0.32398414611816406,
-0.7978906035423279,
0.1541822850704193,
0.05760829523205757,
-0.5724558234214783,
-0.044083405286073685,
0.13053037226200104,
-1.0566256046295166,
1.033128023147583,
0.26712897419929504,
-0.731776237487793,
0.1181652843952179,
-0.817314088344574,
-0.34829145669937134,
0.21326744556427002,
-0.13290633261203766,
-0.38771069049835205,
0.1281101256608963,
0.18378141522407532,
0.02613440528512001,
-0.3094061315059662,
0.3955354392528534,
0.17928673326969147,
-0.059432175010442734,
0.4115210175514221,
-0.6447646021842957,
0.674798846244812,
0.11956050992012024,
-0.2946292757987976,
-0.24494203925132751,
-1.1806069612503052,
0.004679323174059391,
0.1741376519203186,
-0.47721728682518005,
-0.4659322202205658,
0.14607848227024078,
0.3636361360549927,
0.11815590411424637,
0.2839556634426117,
-0.8225988149642944,
0.15703195333480835,
-0.5575127005577087,
0.28003841638565063,
0.5713281631469727,
0.13508543372154236,
0.49236270785331726,
0.10282894968986511,
0.34975793957710266,
0.06939981132745743,
-0.2827381491661072,
0.2788454294204712,
-0.39194977283477783,
-0.8754167556762695,
-0.3906802237033844,
0.941798746585846,
0.730790913105011,
-0.698710560798645,
0.2229028344154358,
-0.6381918787956238,
-0.4706886410713196,
-0.6628944277763367,
-0.34969428181648254,
0.1732950061559677,
0.5719811916351318,
0.4990704357624054,
-0.10402150452136993,
-0.9983139634132385,
-1.1348598003387451,
-0.0603879950940609,
-0.1014290526509285,
-0.17502617835998535,
0.4380652904510498,
0.4638684093952179,
-0.4337095618247986,
1.229508876800537,
-0.3396911323070526,
0.1157391369342804,
-0.3903311491012573,
0.2505144774913788,
0.2751942276954651,
0.5183104872703552,
0.21252819895744324,
-0.954940676689148,
-0.4843381345272064,
-0.09477471560239792,
-0.38391074538230896,
-0.03918684646487236,
-0.029313163831830025,
-0.19948939979076385,
-0.017554787918925285,
0.14675502479076385,
-0.8761404752731323,
0.38082629442214966,
0.34012606739997864,
0.005286989267915487,
0.7428399920463562,
-0.15411825478076935,
-0.20463016629219055,
-1.209821343421936,
-0.028762657195329666,
-0.007247042376548052,
-0.38566628098487854,
-0.9670242071151733,
-0.37290772795677185,
0.10978905856609344,
-0.33974310755729675,
-0.4874558746814728,
0.40934914350509644,
-0.6910299062728882,
-0.33604055643081665,
-0.02224775031208992,
0.015616991557180882,
-0.40529972314834595,
0.30596381425857544,
0.5103773474693298,
1.0443912744522095,
0.29020074009895325,
-0.5844851136207581,
0.6232253313064575,
0.4512782394886017,
-0.20105741918087006,
0.4524194896221161,
-0.661231279373169,
0.519281268119812,
-0.24337540566921234,
0.07203959673643112,
-0.8521328568458557,
-0.28580665588378906,
0.29789072275161743,
-0.6126021146774292,
0.5400938391685486,
-0.40700557827949524,
-0.6665316224098206,
-0.327123761177063,
0.46753910183906555,
0.3216495215892792,
0.667479932308197,
-0.8193002939224243,
0.8871944546699524,
0.706335723400116,
-0.43415942788124084,
-0.12637920677661896,
-0.6116949915885925,
0.21658927202224731,
-0.2204284965991974,
-0.24692407250404358,
0.7308397889137268,
0.3256544768810272,
-0.06256324797868729,
-0.12387211620807648,
0.011498427018523216,
-0.5745350122451782,
-0.3212226331233978,
0.22322168946266174,
0.5832667946815491,
-0.2653779685497284,
0.2704470455646515,
-0.15814442932605743,
-0.22803355753421783,
0.3549453616142273,
-0.3210349678993225,
0.5378323793411255,
0.09906607866287231,
-0.007265195250511169,
-0.5589596629142761,
0.4091551899909973,
0.4979589879512787,
-0.19686095416545868,
0.521108865737915,
0.17849907279014587,
-0.7349928021430969,
-0.11379870027303696,
-0.5404438376426697,
-0.07404939830303192,
-0.44182246923446655,
0.17005077004432678,
-0.5308710932731628,
-0.3071722984313965,
0.48644062876701355,
-0.25248757004737854,
-0.2847553789615631,
0.543777585029602,
0.40199747681617737,
-0.027216855436563492,
0.7084081172943115,
0.5995888113975525,
-0.17000168561935425,
0.4198547303676605,
-0.08363159745931625,
0.5380611419677734,
-0.8952191472053528,
-0.2989760637283325,
-0.7166407108306885,
-0.19602523744106293,
-0.8787814974784851,
-0.11088254302740097,
0.06481906771659851,
-0.48445039987564087,
-0.0676906630396843,
1.112525224685669,
-0.6574612855911255,
0.2984462082386017,
0.7308545708656311,
0.1568211168050766,
-0.05953962728381157,
0.02944895438849926,
-0.2584940195083618,
-0.202745258808136,
-0.25506824254989624,
-0.7308624386787415,
0.8271217942237854,
0.29205748438835144,
0.5784262418746948,
0.18739362061023712,
1.023216962814331,
0.23187169432640076,
0.3202744126319885,
-0.5620805025100708,
0.5168724656105042,
0.03695018216967583,
-0.7342936992645264,
-0.276992529630661,
-0.28828904032707214,
-0.7897368669509888,
-0.1789105087518692,
-0.02995235286653042,
-0.9448139667510986,
0.5131396055221558,
-0.09837506711483002,
-0.23664961755275726,
0.3240326941013336,
-0.616737961769104,
0.5104764699935913,
-0.24097417294979095,
0.12690532207489014,
0.41397824883461,
-0.660663902759552,
0.024986565113067627,
-0.1600220948457718,
-0.0838259905576706,
0.15334796905517578,
0.39138665795326233,
0.8151588439941406,
-0.2430976778268814,
0.6178653240203857,
-0.29409682750701904,
-0.07883400470018387,
0.3515724539756775,
-0.15384189784526825,
0.8739284873008728,
0.04834815859794617,
-0.18774789571762085,
0.3797863721847534,
-0.10739370435476303,
0.04918155446648598,
-0.4403092563152313,
0.5467458963394165,
-0.7155027985572815,
-0.30853167176246643,
-0.3695908486843109,
-0.4333113133907318,
-0.1856507807970047,
0.1364646703004837,
0.2869987487792969,
0.44768592715263367,
-0.34797659516334534,
0.0006201197393238544,
0.7003132700920105,
-0.2133437991142273,
0.3241792619228363,
0.38904398679733276,
0.2341606318950653,
-0.6145222187042236,
0.7481550574302673,
0.19729146361351013,
0.0870363712310791,
0.6174299716949463,
-0.3823981285095215,
-0.48146629333496094,
-0.3183320462703705,
-0.5567773580551147,
0.06954916566610336,
-0.3858382999897003,
-0.3211403787136078,
-0.7964503765106201,
-0.7927021980285645,
-0.4715074300765991,
0.2426256388425827,
-0.5571376085281372,
-0.45786911249160767,
-0.46053948998451233,
0.029804974794387817,
0.238378643989563,
0.6449010372161865,
0.08763241022825241,
0.2888587713241577,
-0.8052985668182373,
0.5121622085571289,
0.14948473870754242,
0.16750304400920868,
-0.21702921390533447,
-0.43049362301826477,
-0.04875288903713226,
0.2955693006515503,
-0.04666512832045555,
-1.3760943412780762,
0.8090441823005676,
0.10931166261434555,
0.615021288394928,
0.1620548963546753,
0.029050426557660103,
0.7436821460723877,
-1.0242483615875244,
0.55361407995224,
0.004196093883365393,
-0.8629236817359924,
0.7606967091560364,
-0.06995357573032379,
-0.14846359193325043,
0.42061692476272583,
0.267191082239151,
-0.23325347900390625,
-0.1482657641172409,
-0.8892672657966614,
-0.8657723069190979,
0.6921589970588684,
0.28407377004623413,
0.24647723138332367,
-0.28968891501426697,
0.4843442738056183,
0.15815088152885437,
0.1799776703119278,
-0.7431004643440247,
-0.3107091188430786,
0.10828831791877747,
-0.46650978922843933,
0.219140887260437,
-0.44844070076942444,
0.29283174872398376,
-0.1710195541381836,
0.6302484273910522,
0.3962055742740631,
0.9479629397392273,
0.4615824222564697,
-0.3011690378189087,
0.21366924047470093,
0.4894844591617584,
0.2831222712993622,
0.08860056102275848,
-0.37442371249198914,
0.12445677071809769,
0.32140883803367615,
-0.6038289666175842,
0.14985530078411102,
0.5114082098007202,
-0.5491107702255249,
0.5959196090698242,
-0.14391760528087616,
0.6695314645767212,
0.1729935109615326,
-0.5764553546905518,
0.32062315940856934,
0.08425744622945786,
-0.06894678622484207,
-0.8233100771903992,
-0.011457054875791073,
-0.13817670941352844,
0.3020922839641571,
0.3607209026813507,
-0.05486192926764488,
0.3667100965976715,
-0.443945050239563,
0.32834067940711975,
0.3845721483230591,
-0.4987744987010956,
-0.4949338138103485,
0.6980137228965759,
-0.05093110725283623,
-0.7935894131660461,
1.0009829998016357,
0.0753602683544159,
-0.7154887318611145,
0.8487728238105774,
0.9169832468032837,
1.1560406684875488,
-0.3196764588356018,
0.03862910717725754,
0.4625888466835022,
0.148362934589386,
-0.007481807377189398,
0.16515471041202545,
-0.1103658452630043,
-0.5879586935043335,
-0.04236710071563721,
-0.5748085975646973,
-0.47776922583580017,
0.16368412971496582,
-0.822493314743042,
0.4299149811267853,
-0.3337319493293762,
-0.23849067091941833,
0.3296346068382263,
-0.2876545786857605,
-0.9251938462257385,
0.3217082619667053,
0.31052201986312866,
0.7621806263923645,
-0.5174878835678101,
1.067397117614746,
0.6604904532432556,
-0.3931393623352051,
-0.7805585265159607,
0.15383222699165344,
-0.34342142939567566,
-0.5369151830673218,
1.2628486156463623,
0.1523783951997757,
0.08518967777490616,
0.2198818027973175,
-0.5435488820075989,
-1.12295663356781,
0.8886145949363708,
0.20019060373306274,
-0.7322303056716919,
-0.36151933670043945,
0.36098596453666687,
0.56663978099823,
-0.4828258454799652,
0.15603762865066528,
0.5036590695381165,
0.33131957054138184,
0.04378262534737587,
-0.8642915487289429,
-0.16049404442310333,
-0.18782062828540802,
0.08481863886117935,
0.39240792393684387,
-0.15035894513130188,
0.89208984375,
-0.17655052244663239,
-0.4542239010334015,
0.1402687132358551,
0.7359857559204102,
0.04976928234100342,
0.018890168517827988,
0.21007248759269714,
0.47130945324897766,
0.6782283186912537,
-0.28137969970703125,
0.6643197536468506,
-0.2753748893737793,
0.38392165303230286,
1.3159024715423584,
-0.4279571771621704,
1.0881017446517944,
0.6188368797302246,
-0.2181205004453659,
0.5988796949386597,
0.3504079282283783,
-0.2838835120201111,
0.9195346832275391,
0.34662774205207825,
-0.39271828532218933,
0.2307884246110916,
0.2720414400100708,
-0.20728141069412231,
0.5482820868492126,
0.3716054856777191,
-0.6364204287528992,
-0.20860210061073303,
-0.028617197647690773,
-0.2845720052719116,
-0.325997531414032,
0.10085708647966385,
1.0827529430389404,
-0.2511829733848572,
-0.39746102690696716,
0.2673691511154175,
0.1327223777770996,
0.3843132555484772,
-0.2968577444553375,
-0.34803420305252075,
0.24718241393566132,
0.010307456366717815,
0.2209426611661911,
-0.3831697404384613,
0.32481279969215393,
0.2805529236793518,
-0.524976909160614,
-0.08741229772567749,
0.8750476241111755,
-0.6775774359703064,
-0.5844558477401733,
0.058231599628925323,
0.2052086740732193,
0.36617547273635864,
-0.039020951837301254,
-0.3135460615158081,
-0.40989670157432556,
-0.11115938425064087,
-0.01988094300031662,
0.14532652497291565,
0.6305506825447083,
0.2552962899208069,
0.35090556740760803,
0.8617395162582397,
0.43589815497398376,
0.17173519730567932,
-0.05928405001759529,
0.6849703788757324,
-0.8730539679527283,
-0.4940401613712311,
-0.7955583930015564,
0.2982941269874573,
-0.2353995442390442,
-0.06974422186613083,
0.4750223159790039,
0.7890591621398926,
0.6914288401603699,
-0.34807726740837097,
0.8706631660461426,
-0.04464186728000641,
0.8700724840164185,
-0.3504302501678467,
0.430258572101593,
0.051100604236125946,
0.2440265417098999,
-0.2838827073574066,
-1.033808708190918,
0.00020414982282090932,
0.6839804649353027,
-0.4613235592842102,
-0.218715101480484,
0.34942933917045593,
0.7171764373779297,
-0.22148944437503815,
0.012056001462042332,
0.11672154068946838,
0.09563224762678146,
0.25046104192733765,
0.5752382874488831,
0.7570832967758179,
-0.8448566794395447,
0.2755049467086792,
-0.22084374725818634,
0.23886685073375702,
-0.25960925221443176,
-0.6427084803581238,
-0.589690625667572,
-0.60381680727005,
-0.2205049991607666,
-0.37749412655830383,
0.22619809210300446,
0.9901204109191895,
0.600561261177063,
-1.1065922975540161,
0.20357009768486023,
-0.2734715938568115,
-0.14142008125782013,
0.1845615953207016,
-0.28186196088790894,
0.5632494688034058,
-0.05469081178307533,
-1.0204726457595825,
0.34881165623664856,
0.22403143346309662,
0.6106091737747192,
0.05534050613641739,
0.06742793321609497,
-0.14308953285217285,
0.17254221439361572,
0.28924664855003357,
0.43695753812789917,
-0.8066827654838562,
-0.4174530506134033,
0.05955164134502411,
-0.2813514173030853,
0.2513536512851715,
0.5429590344429016,
-0.8792781829833984,
0.3717881739139557,
0.3853830099105835,
0.7949822545051575,
0.2974625825881958,
0.25319865345954895,
0.5132516622543335,
-0.6718661189079285,
0.003452182747423649,
0.27818867564201355,
0.3989187777042389,
0.28176334500312805,
-0.7209392189979553,
0.2085602879524231,
0.13265889883041382,
-0.3978748321533203,
-0.7428601384162903,
-0.004908582661300898,
-1.0105664730072021,
0.31103748083114624,
1.1658328771591187,
0.08272893726825714,
-0.3265042006969452,
-0.24368508160114288,
-0.40438345074653625,
0.45673128962516785,
-0.4516191780567169,
0.7476920485496521,
0.6786612868309021,
-0.1259024441242218,
-0.22329670190811157,
-0.7778587341308594,
0.2887796461582184,
-0.16752630472183228,
-0.8394786715507507,
-0.007015669718384743,
0.4444727301597595,
0.5173797607421875,
0.23656553030014038,
0.3783210515975952,
-0.29874780774116516,
0.1145499050617218,
0.06542910635471344,
0.30633851885795593,
0.22476652264595032,
-0.5275917053222656,
0.045883189886808395,
0.09113707393407822,
-0.2779781222343445,
-0.35569512844085693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05536v1 | Empowering machine learning models with contextual knowledge for enhancing the detection of eating disorders in social media posts | 2024-02-08T10:15:41 | 2024-02-08T10:15:41 | José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, María Teresa García-Ordás, Mayra Russo, Ahmad Sakor, Luis Daniel Fernandes Rotger, Maria-Esther Vidal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Social networks are vital for information sharing, especially in the health
sector for discussing diseases and treatments. These platforms, however, often
feature posts as brief texts, posing challenges for Artificial Intelligence
(AI) in understanding context. We introduce a novel hybrid approach combining
community-maintained knowledge graphs (like Wikidata) with deep learning to
enhance the categorization of social media posts. This method uses advanced
entity recognizers and linkers (like Falcon 2.0) to connect short post entities
to knowledge graphs. Knowledge graph embeddings (KGEs) and contextualized word
embeddings (like BERT) are then employed to create rich, context-based
representations of these posts.
Our focus is on the health domain, particularly in identifying posts related
to eating disorders (e.g., anorexia, bulimia) to aid healthcare providers in
early diagnosis. We tested our approach on a dataset of 2,000 tweets about
eating disorders, finding that merging word embeddings with knowledge graph
information enhances the predictive models' reliability. This methodology aims
to assist health experts in spotting patterns indicative of mental disorders,
thereby improving early detection and accurate diagnosis for personalized
medicine. | [
-0.08882979303598404,
-1.0821565389633179,
0.5374075770378113,
-0.09581656008958817,
-0.3711192011833191,
0.3861207664012909,
-0.05698613077402115,
-0.598463773727417,
0.8954283595085144,
0.44893649220466614,
-0.18409866094589233,
-0.621253252029419,
-0.8454324007034302,
-0.16505677998065948,
-0.45442789793014526,
0.7119260430335999,
-0.22323989868164062,
0.2858799993991852,
-0.43670639395713806,
-0.3166545629501343,
-0.30852022767066956,
-0.35823869705200195,
-0.9194088578224182,
-0.303233802318573,
0.6966250538825989,
0.1429387331008911,
0.5189148187637329,
0.4600794315338135,
0.26894497871398926,
0.20692574977874756,
0.1913842260837555,
0.7296640276908875,
-0.39965441823005676,
0.04990563914179802,
-0.2080906182527542,
-0.0433017872273922,
-0.3001796007156372,
-0.35455402731895447,
0.1895427107810974,
0.9721696972846985,
0.050601087510585785,
0.1105874702334404,
0.25523999333381653,
0.5088592767715454,
-0.3416581153869629,
0.12445187568664551,
-0.25370723009109497,
0.33851850032806396,
-0.10712847113609314,
-0.24356995522975922,
0.01642136462032795,
-0.14610931277275085,
0.0800054743885994,
-0.7343084812164307,
-0.0987311452627182,
-0.041739072650671005,
0.660186231136322,
0.38874176144599915,
-0.8789209127426147,
-0.3536998927593231,
-0.6817566156387329,
0.2822619676589966,
-0.51701420545578,
0.442135751247406,
0.4378150701522827,
0.3332672119140625,
-0.08523139357566833,
-0.7720757722854614,
-0.5597062110900879,
0.22645440697669983,
-0.36519381403923035,
-0.3087770938873291,
-0.2412819117307663,
-0.10419716686010361,
0.0558883361518383,
0.15553037822246552,
-0.8027348518371582,
0.16490302979946136,
-0.4558151364326477,
-0.21710506081581116,
0.6513779759407043,
0.12662801146507263,
0.6640163064002991,
-0.2818759083747864,
0.023211808875203133,
0.20384114980697632,
-0.30772292613983154,
0.09837032854557037,
-0.19746266305446625,
0.14109651744365692,
-0.07186306267976761,
0.6159129738807678,
-0.20686273276805878,
0.5632601976394653,
0.2636047303676605,
0.03641096502542496,
0.3774077594280243,
-0.2274378389120102,
-0.1562502533197403,
0.10531380027532578,
0.6166889667510986,
0.782433032989502,
0.020684653893113136,
-0.19003112614154816,
-0.05993304401636124,
0.1883654147386551,
0.3921499252319336,
-0.724226713180542,
-0.5194056034088135,
0.205224871635437,
-0.639580488204956,
-0.20241720974445343,
-0.10268742591142654,
-0.5541611313819885,
-1.0594056844711304,
-0.28193455934524536,
0.3084127902984619,
-0.6011039018630981,
-0.3597638010978699,
-0.14613021910190582,
-0.15638135373592377,
-0.0452456958591938,
0.26119863986968994,
-0.6538028717041016,
0.35163620114326477,
0.6300896406173706,
0.6052663922309875,
0.01292763464152813,
0.12210458517074585,
-0.356520414352417,
0.6313410401344299,
-0.26876476407051086,
0.7000852823257446,
-0.6023023128509521,
-0.11743868142366409,
-0.001306336373090744,
0.21554093062877655,
-0.19813181459903717,
-0.6593816876411438,
0.46156564354896545,
-0.5206472873687744,
-0.23896458745002747,
-0.5096812844276428,
-0.9892281889915466,
-0.4277045428752899,
0.27034372091293335,
-0.7031229734420776,
0.8029623031616211,
0.3059524595737457,
-0.7056522369384766,
0.6862224340438843,
-0.4386492073535919,
-0.9490677118301392,
0.3906834125518799,
-0.21982967853546143,
-0.3575611710548401,
0.07301308214664459,
0.5642780065536499,
0.8598352670669556,
0.09900445491075516,
0.47099271416664124,
-0.8268862366676331,
-0.17030011117458344,
0.007728222757577896,
0.18241505324840546,
0.3490358889102936,
0.24165455996990204,
-0.015168065205216408,
0.3412443995475769,
-0.3989439308643341,
-0.029438385739922523,
0.31360799074172974,
0.004064440261572599,
-0.8439569473266602,
0.3106125295162201,
-0.04027266800403595,
-0.05621659755706787,
0.0654793456196785,
-0.20727494359016418,
0.002188672311604023,
-0.2340622842311859,
0.7064760327339172,
0.4311008155345917,
0.3150138556957245,
0.28051429986953735,
-0.46243467926979065,
0.16160841286182404,
0.293826162815094,
0.04048674553632736,
0.007320526987314224,
-0.6119959354400635,
-0.22663311660289764,
-0.19888640940189362,
0.20912779867649078,
0.5747551321983337,
-1.0530829429626465,
0.8906764984130859,
-0.26858240365982056,
-0.33662763237953186,
-0.5061784982681274,
0.308733731508255,
-0.030252546072006226,
0.7358114719390869,
0.5625675916671753,
-0.06275472044944763,
-0.7127180695533752,
-0.5823636651039124,
-0.25608327984809875,
0.42053931951522827,
-0.17755749821662903,
0.4302688241004944,
0.5448454022407532,
-0.6552984714508057,
0.6111799478530884,
-0.3057084083557129,
-0.2394053041934967,
-0.3935306966304779,
-0.047975778579711914,
-0.20051120221614838,
0.4323275685310364,
0.7310889959335327,
-1.1288108825683594,
-0.7172128558158875,
0.31515786051750183,
-1.0098100900650024,
0.2524664103984833,
0.4843776226043701,
0.15631872415542603,
-0.09519284218549728,
0.3238789141178131,
-0.3201287090778351,
0.40855756402015686,
0.3022022247314453,
-0.4878648817539215,
0.020887579768896103,
0.1771484762430191,
0.18759068846702576,
-1.34473717212677,
-0.042721543461084366,
0.3370428681373596,
-0.4422532916069031,
-0.5469138026237488,
-0.2788064777851105,
0.05575738102197647,
-0.2952459752559662,
-0.06947774440050125,
0.5613609552383423,
0.0378122515976429,
0.05354030057787895,
-0.13525095582008362,
-0.29681941866874695,
0.06620685756206512,
0.0536680705845356,
-0.06391050666570663,
0.11638125032186508,
0.5606390833854675,
-0.5942175388336182,
0.3910408616065979,
-0.18974712491035461,
-0.3898276090621948,
0.4853072166442871,
-0.4660610556602478,
-0.08694243431091309,
-0.29578477144241333,
0.4239046275615692,
-0.9558871984481812,
-0.6019256711006165,
0.5479226112365723,
-0.6223481893539429,
0.16900096833705902,
0.2606494426727295,
-0.655920684337616,
-0.6811944842338562,
-0.11289753764867783,
0.5116190910339355,
0.1870819330215454,
-0.5353158116340637,
0.5485121607780457,
0.6352434158325195,
0.06285859644412994,
-0.06367027759552002,
-0.6700266003608704,
-0.07209553569555283,
-0.1823214590549469,
-0.6339158415794373,
0.3802907168865204,
0.24698792397975922,
-0.010189849883317947,
0.7674286961555481,
-0.05305046960711479,
-0.21997101604938507,
0.25744569301605225,
-0.0503741055727005,
-0.09232088923454285,
-0.1605871170759201,
0.3066822588443756,
0.5788002014160156,
0.2999919056892395,
-0.13457918167114258,
-0.4429715871810913,
0.652820885181427,
0.10958775877952576,
-0.05476303771138191,
-0.6447661519050598,
0.650576651096344,
0.41641876101493835,
-0.2558927536010742,
0.8121458292007446,
0.7723262310028076,
-1.0345255136489868,
-0.28889763355255127,
-0.3196685314178467,
-0.3992226719856262,
-0.42383068799972534,
0.2263832688331604,
0.054712098091840744,
-1.0170460939407349,
0.536220908164978,
-0.1186029314994812,
-0.4151872992515564,
0.27888941764831543,
0.21188075840473175,
-0.4492391347885132,
1.123857021331787,
0.6081862449645996,
-0.23042358458042145,
0.42229393124580383,
-0.22964271903038025,
0.33648303151130676,
-0.643320620059967,
-0.30264922976493835,
0.1452152580022812,
-0.575458824634552,
-0.40889275074005127,
-0.5082989931106567,
0.44823142886161804,
-0.14005634188652039,
-0.18637283146381378,
0.02402883768081665,
-0.5454429388046265,
0.3283870220184326,
0.19816215336322784,
0.6869962811470032,
-0.0071782805025577545,
-0.016743188723921776,
-0.25122103095054626,
-0.09099460393190384,
-0.7374597787857056,
-0.39220431447029114,
1.1226372718811035,
0.2328910082578659,
0.4566907584667206,
-0.18209432065486908,
0.8000239133834839,
0.7702061533927917,
0.5594995617866516,
-0.8027893900871277,
0.1213981881737709,
-0.34805411100387573,
-0.4838712811470032,
-0.04136629402637482,
-0.6883942484855652,
-0.8321508169174194,
-0.040265291929244995,
-0.3322388827800751,
-0.7672370672225952,
0.05863930284976959,
0.21779528260231018,
-0.5930451154708862,
0.5255329608917236,
-0.7680859565734863,
1.0503016710281372,
-0.4259965121746063,
-0.09420706331729889,
-0.19122548401355743,
-0.5449279546737671,
0.39570295810699463,
0.03679310902953148,
0.30033478140830994,
-0.0027039246633648872,
0.016908759251236916,
0.9911946654319763,
-0.2303907424211502,
0.915195643901825,
-0.15120328962802887,
0.29073566198349,
0.016855796799063683,
-0.15226969122886658,
0.052456557750701904,
0.06301742792129517,
0.14556409418582916,
-0.06570973992347717,
-0.02218296006321907,
-0.423953652381897,
-0.6764319539070129,
0.672515869140625,
-0.7324352264404297,
-0.07742267847061157,
-0.15260255336761475,
-0.31469616293907166,
-0.42284443974494934,
0.4598141312599182,
-0.08040963113307953,
0.2372056245803833,
-0.002561305882409215,
0.26828479766845703,
0.728774905204773,
-0.1912548542022705,
-0.031067868694663048,
0.25385820865631104,
-0.19944807887077332,
-0.546083390712738,
1.0636307001113892,
0.24537834525108337,
-0.3750721514225006,
0.3919406533241272,
0.2562781870365143,
-0.09021647274494171,
-0.3509710133075714,
-0.006602452602237463,
0.2788766920566559,
-0.6085329055786133,
-0.09334845095872879,
-0.751351535320282,
-0.27781161665916443,
-0.8799139857292175,
-0.30954328179359436,
-0.22351497411727905,
0.05645904317498207,
-0.5488355755805969,
-0.4629426896572113,
0.18519912660121918,
0.8734558820724487,
-0.07001511007547379,
0.1642744392156601,
-0.7593207955360413,
0.501615583896637,
0.18943685293197632,
0.3558231294155121,
0.563298761844635,
0.04896389693021774,
-0.26226407289505005,
0.11443471163511276,
-0.28843095898628235,
-1.0272305011749268,
0.43988266587257385,
0.10741101205348969,
0.5939509272575378,
0.8537004590034485,
0.20193754136562347,
0.5144088268280029,
-0.10155376046895981,
0.39973020553588867,
0.22433996200561523,
-0.5242357850074768,
0.7277914881706238,
-0.23591916263103485,
-0.05615212395787239,
0.5192180871963501,
1.1263039112091064,
-0.7985912561416626,
-0.1704607754945755,
-0.3620024025440216,
-0.7530927658081055,
0.18856064975261688,
-0.14822061359882355,
0.04946413263678551,
-0.14184434711933136,
0.4935891926288605,
0.06050289049744606,
0.24055472016334534,
-0.4887560307979584,
-0.2755108177661896,
-0.3612392544746399,
-0.46938106417655945,
-0.0831136628985405,
-0.11887555569410324,
-0.250883013010025,
-0.8653886318206787,
0.41114017367362976,
-0.17453575134277344,
0.13156524300575256,
0.14494989812374115,
-0.24415479600429535,
-0.16962099075317383,
-0.22593006491661072,
0.1777525246143341,
0.7017639875411987,
-0.0964994728565216,
0.1957882195711136,
-0.15298447012901306,
-0.11777493357658386,
-0.20937418937683105,
0.39668968319892883,
-0.15782248973846436,
-0.08843126893043518,
0.5243334174156189,
0.6453441977500916,
0.41658318042755127,
-0.609626829624176,
0.464584082365036,
-0.09407659620046616,
-0.18334998190402985,
-0.1792314201593399,
-0.061963628977537155,
0.23568204045295715,
0.3298248052597046,
0.42713144421577454,
-0.0794706642627716,
0.3464822769165039,
-0.6112721562385559,
0.49797046184539795,
0.3200984299182892,
-0.3768664002418518,
-0.4141763746738434,
0.5900023579597473,
0.37605994939804077,
-0.20791208744049072,
0.5451852679252625,
-0.3991398811340332,
-0.5680822730064392,
0.6349778771400452,
0.27293068170547485,
0.42597270011901855,
-0.31859326362609863,
0.34491434693336487,
0.2073892205953598,
0.2088094800710678,
0.2228982299566269,
0.28128647804260254,
-0.22944872081279755,
-0.9253987669944763,
-0.1581229418516159,
-0.6476942300796509,
-0.09593109786510468,
0.34919947385787964,
-0.6725068688392639,
0.12001756578683853,
-0.49825724959373474,
-0.16708633303642273,
0.44246819615364075,
0.05669241398572922,
-0.7533423900604248,
0.2203768938779831,
0.5269017815589905,
0.6067593097686768,
-1.1877249479293823,
0.8584518432617188,
0.8894072771072388,
-0.27669963240623474,
-0.6719781160354614,
0.20437602698802948,
-0.0022844457998871803,
-0.7166375517845154,
0.05228593200445175,
0.5254088640213013,
0.5370060205459595,
-0.13283994793891907,
-0.5567488670349121,
-0.7696138620376587,
0.9846712946891785,
0.04052785038948059,
-0.2849445939064026,
-0.17235195636749268,
0.1225733682513237,
0.6495188474655151,
-0.4446839988231659,
-0.22017185389995575,
0.4222322702407837,
0.600994884967804,
0.2563381493091583,
-0.6926575303077698,
0.1987208127975464,
-0.13992840051651,
-0.020719734951853752,
-0.016162261366844177,
-0.3244600296020508,
0.4794340133666992,
-0.3128891885280609,
-0.34285321831703186,
-0.20460280776023865,
0.6826794147491455,
0.07830286026000977,
0.8003939390182495,
0.40863656997680664,
0.8946607708930969,
1.2562636137008667,
0.17995211482048035,
0.9703006744384766,
-0.25405412912368774,
0.24426090717315674,
0.9265949726104736,
-0.45496416091918945,
0.5534321069717407,
0.18330958485603333,
0.043317556381225586,
0.5370523929595947,
1.1478052139282227,
0.01266488153487444,
0.6450561881065369,
-0.024849088862538338,
-0.17253009974956512,
-0.2610166072845459,
-0.36596521735191345,
-0.3519895076751709,
0.08420141786336899,
0.8394354581832886,
-0.6938877105712891,
-0.2554553151130676,
0.5074349045753479,
0.14831554889678955,
0.151589035987854,
-0.4628816843032837,
0.8906037211418152,
0.10441938787698746,
-0.13307441771030426,
0.2691279351711273,
-0.03507815673947334,
0.5968839526176453,
-0.26824119687080383,
-0.019015831872820854,
0.03958038613200188,
0.005340174771845341,
-0.3353441655635834,
-0.6923277974128723,
0.6996369957923889,
-0.4520412087440491,
-0.28312191367149353,
-0.1333276480436325,
1.0805662870407104,
-0.43744149804115295,
-0.8493950963020325,
0.6133232116699219,
0.491445392370224,
-0.15325845777988434,
-0.035838112235069275,
-0.7235243916511536,
-0.03327680379152298,
-0.3839026689529419,
0.048737358301877975,
0.15868039429187775,
0.5252271294593811,
-0.1275489181280136,
0.4895336627960205,
0.5318289399147034,
-0.10638152062892914,
-0.15480861067771912,
-0.2466834932565689,
1.1128188371658325,
-0.3712426722049713,
-0.5103967785835266,
-0.7669357657432556,
0.15101377665996552,
-0.25806358456611633,
0.10361025482416153,
0.5362067222595215,
0.4325126111507416,
0.8537136316299438,
0.1071481928229332,
0.8794958591461182,
-0.4628496766090393,
0.5629647970199585,
-0.13158313930034637,
1.0758541822433472,
-1.079842448234558,
-0.19689856469631195,
-0.03653338924050331,
-0.10444962233304977,
-0.30348068475723267,
0.4166126549243927,
-0.5691460371017456,
0.12792189419269562,
0.5986559987068176,
0.5279709696769714,
-0.19398117065429688,
-0.1040370762348175,
0.16317903995513916,
0.317181259393692,
0.13511809706687927,
0.5981936454772949,
0.5042940378189087,
-0.030951276421546936,
0.0013066494138911366,
-0.4470716416835785,
-0.2627340853214264,
-0.449929803609848,
-0.33833152055740356,
-0.9313780665397644,
-0.6815129518508911,
-0.2056533545255661,
-0.18122489750385284,
0.30676132440567017,
0.7594118118286133,
0.9956222176551819,
-0.7723466157913208,
0.19494953751564026,
0.21033993363380432,
0.6242936253547668,
-0.4940279424190521,
-0.30174848437309265,
0.3027494251728058,
0.07780247926712036,
-0.24658168852329254,
0.3739103078842163,
-0.05106350779533386,
-0.15620629489421844,
-0.12200602144002914,
0.03437409549951553,
-0.3103483319282532,
-0.22292329370975494,
0.612392008304596,
0.15573273599147797,
-0.46358054876327515,
-0.0829448401927948,
-0.33951130509376526,
-0.060157425701618195,
-0.0366407074034214,
0.5811894536018372,
-0.5757529139518738,
0.33123937249183655,
0.22562313079833984,
0.9141536355018616,
0.2588357925415039,
0.06846461445093155,
0.3243587613105774,
-0.5390660166740417,
-0.1410064846277237,
0.5094893574714661,
0.44624295830726624,
0.41495248675346375,
-0.8115602135658264,
0.17308863997459412,
0.6242606043815613,
-0.1371966451406479,
-0.6235268115997314,
-0.1666022390127182,
-0.9402593374252319,
-0.579836905002594,
1.0248172283172607,
-0.038007549941539764,
-0.6008504629135132,
-0.03340299054980278,
0.19756361842155457,
0.3737185597419739,
-0.3955504596233368,
0.8452371954917908,
0.4086446166038513,
-0.3139902949333191,
-0.07522083073854446,
-0.488730251789093,
0.38107094168663025,
0.10955695807933807,
-0.7418645620346069,
-0.4645407199859619,
0.23413711786270142,
0.5738437175750732,
-0.15119193494319916,
0.5692567229270935,
0.29372069239616394,
0.2571375370025635,
-0.39448416233062744,
-0.17489095032215118,
-0.062367070466279984,
-0.16948887705802917,
0.0732530727982521,
0.1235741600394249,
-0.5782107710838318,
-0.10488498955965042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05515v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05515v2 | NoisyICL: A Little Noise in Model Parameters Calibrates In-context Learning | 2024-02-08T09:48:02 | 2024-02-15T15:25:47 | Yufeng Zhao, Yoshihiro Sakai, Naoya Inoue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-Context Learning (ICL) is suffering from unsatisfactory performance and
under-calibration due to high prior bias and unfaithful confidence. Some
previous works fine-tuned language models for better ICL performance with
enormous datasets and computing costs. In this paper, we propose NoisyICL,
simply perturbing the model parameters by random noises to strive for better
performance and calibration. Our experiments on two models and 12 downstream
datasets show that NoisyICL can help ICL produce more accurate predictions. Our
further analysis indicates that NoisyICL enables the model to provide more fair
predictions, and also with more faithful confidence. Therefore, we believe that
NoisyICL is an effective calibration of ICL. Our experimental code is uploaded
to Github. | [
-0.3411612808704376,
-0.6835036277770996,
0.4357600510120392,
0.006542439106851816,
-0.2794748842716217,
0.028879784047603607,
-0.4033031463623047,
-0.7866107821464539,
-0.4702233374118805,
0.17273592948913574,
-0.5268222689628601,
-0.5553880929946899,
-0.21237586438655853,
-0.19263583421707153,
-0.3755200505256653,
1.2654392719268799,
0.3622457683086395,
0.5235664248466492,
0.05012216046452522,
0.021617770195007324,
-0.2211904227733612,
-0.21224592626094818,
-0.8204665780067444,
-0.5856474041938782,
0.5905854105949402,
0.5090984106063843,
0.7612144351005554,
0.37061479687690735,
0.21216422319412231,
0.1320837438106537,
-0.1968977302312851,
0.201110377907753,
-0.7078723311424255,
0.1926628053188324,
0.11605256795883179,
-0.3856031000614166,
-0.13338975608348846,
-0.09557782113552094,
0.7473952770233154,
0.9819917678833008,
-0.25837451219558716,
0.34956037998199463,
0.5388339757919312,
0.6256441473960876,
-0.8024081587791443,
0.19446377456188202,
-0.7204275727272034,
-0.03977212682366371,
-0.1642364114522934,
0.07602334022521973,
-0.5859942436218262,
-0.2836533486843109,
0.13891741633415222,
-0.6232584118843079,
-0.0848698690533638,
0.2594539225101471,
0.8024836182594299,
0.7299818992614746,
-0.058491144329309464,
-0.24273420870304108,
-1.0640876293182373,
1.0083673000335693,
-1.0501190423965454,
0.5728264451026917,
0.5078456401824951,
0.22925524413585663,
-0.10649127513170242,
-0.8536980748176575,
-0.18865114450454712,
-0.33698323369026184,
0.15953092277050018,
-0.029269061982631683,
0.1643708497285843,
0.10051683336496353,
0.4075911343097687,
0.06291577219963074,
-0.12852756679058075,
0.1171083003282547,
-0.30302664637565613,
-0.16827788949012756,
0.4941176474094391,
0.05515434220433235,
0.09681988507509232,
0.6407778859138489,
-0.21016331017017365,
0.0007056649192236364,
-0.9431211352348328,
0.3459436893463135,
0.7705278396606445,
0.5895833373069763,
-0.26148122549057007,
-0.12258581817150116,
-0.1092110276222229,
0.8436894416809082,
0.3812869191169739,
-0.24860744178295135,
0.15146806836128235,
0.13308189809322357,
-0.10418159514665604,
0.4542127847671509,
0.39021655917167664,
-0.017912479117512703,
0.27943119406700134,
-0.23630857467651367,
-0.4966914653778076,
-0.301471471786499,
0.029779164120554924,
-1.0606521368026733,
-0.7151374816894531,
0.19945697486400604,
-0.42291200160980225,
-0.4666559100151062,
0.061971571296453476,
-0.3444855809211731,
-0.19162824749946594,
-0.6462258696556091,
0.4487795829772949,
-0.3539966940879822,
-0.09811583906412125,
-0.004491438157856464,
0.29765069484710693,
-0.18042288720607758,
0.6269965767860413,
-0.8660744428634644,
0.4415532648563385,
0.45791706442832947,
0.3937227427959442,
-0.0840708315372467,
-0.2944687306880951,
-0.6748008728027344,
-0.0075992862693965435,
-0.6231581568717957,
0.6707881093025208,
-0.4557003974914551,
-0.10888102650642395,
-0.17477969825267792,
-0.5889214873313904,
0.014859667047858238,
-0.7282969951629639,
0.34892308712005615,
-0.508799135684967,
-0.146407350897789,
-0.2696801424026489,
-0.4824095368385315,
-0.07792776823043823,
0.020200146362185478,
-0.6022380590438843,
1.1331779956817627,
0.10257814079523087,
-0.6336249113082886,
0.8619604706764221,
-0.6218417882919312,
-0.2485826164484024,
0.23003697395324707,
-0.35943344235420227,
-0.3979572653770447,
-0.0038336014840751886,
0.05849963799118996,
0.1143660917878151,
-0.144327312707901,
0.2395181506872177,
-0.4904443621635437,
-0.9257808327674866,
0.478674054145813,
-0.8133770823478699,
0.9346542954444885,
0.5926111936569214,
-0.34368443489074707,
0.03171202540397644,
-0.7790510058403015,
0.27992525696754456,
-0.43159210681915283,
-0.4653187692165375,
-0.3777807354927063,
0.25731122493743896,
0.3242148458957672,
0.09375054389238358,
0.13156090676784515,
-0.4976056218147278,
-0.14986680448055267,
-0.7743443846702576,
0.16825583577156067,
0.6150652766227722,
-0.13415738940238953,
0.417184054851532,
-0.47559449076652527,
0.21665431559085846,
0.03763508051633835,
0.22773663699626923,
0.1948644071817398,
-0.40805554389953613,
-0.31632763147354126,
-0.3751579225063324,
0.4118092954158783,
0.01215048786252737,
-0.2396419495344162,
-0.17279934883117676,
0.09122801572084427,
-0.4013691842556,
-0.6765691041946411,
0.5139205455780029,
0.492647260427475,
0.7655419707298279,
0.2883490025997162,
-0.11584663391113281,
-0.5270929932594299,
-0.48104244470596313,
-0.3562232553958893,
-0.3779456615447998,
-0.063316211104393,
0.45157068967819214,
0.12679219245910645,
0.1218336746096611,
0.8080300092697144,
-0.048241447657346725,
-0.2729850113391876,
-0.028841868042945862,
0.1815309375524521,
0.10729917883872986,
0.36420994997024536,
0.7061964273452759,
-0.9372568726539612,
-0.9416593909263611,
-0.2423287034034729,
-0.3399340808391571,
-0.19943749904632568,
0.26654142141342163,
0.2291869968175888,
0.14725537598133087,
0.7674005031585693,
-0.028676314279437065,
0.41465288400650024,
0.4971975088119507,
-0.012374465353786945,
0.4510728120803833,
-0.13307954370975494,
-0.21437516808509827,
-0.6891395449638367,
-0.02361231856048107,
-0.2569393813610077,
-0.255403608083725,
-0.3954026699066162,
0.18505437672138214,
0.04839787259697914,
0.055022068321704865,
-0.7416006326675415,
0.5027188658714294,
-0.344570517539978,
0.22958776354789734,
-0.30076169967651367,
-0.040646862238645554,
-0.3128606379032135,
0.2420656532049179,
-0.17404216527938843,
0.9542504549026489,
0.740578293800354,
-0.6439706683158875,
-0.21698176860809326,
-0.1725853830575943,
-0.43664297461509705,
0.24019156396389008,
-0.3034367859363556,
0.08569663017988205,
-0.11452464014291763,
0.2884770929813385,
-1.0502455234527588,
-0.2999686300754547,
0.23407357931137085,
-0.11208339035511017,
0.4146697223186493,
-0.2723972201347351,
-0.38594505190849304,
0.16475529968738556,
-0.14514902234077454,
0.8625110387802124,
0.42956823110580444,
-0.8335809111595154,
0.3495822250843048,
0.5121523141860962,
0.39199137687683105,
-0.5300303101539612,
-0.7896900177001953,
-0.20813080668449402,
-0.09282366186380386,
-0.162704735994339,
0.3972524404525757,
-0.7375929951667786,
-0.5454070568084717,
-0.1140265092253685,
-0.000799807719886303,
-0.2874644100666046,
0.12630526721477509,
0.5247247219085693,
0.07581096142530441,
-0.4580807685852051,
0.16262264549732208,
-0.2203982174396515,
-0.06684276461601257,
0.07644297182559967,
-0.3396260738372803,
0.4277968406677246,
-0.3191526532173157,
-0.3127596080303192,
-0.6055390238761902,
-0.09682878106832504,
0.56446373462677,
0.19780795276165009,
0.4164746403694153,
0.5049023628234863,
-0.5127001404762268,
-0.6425177454948425,
-0.33785101771354675,
-0.46998149156570435,
-0.5152730345726013,
0.22692760825157166,
-0.2252340316772461,
-0.5661336183547974,
0.5570756196975708,
-0.12517431378364563,
0.07913214713335037,
0.12665750086307526,
0.5069200396537781,
-0.20449958741664886,
1.411129355430603,
0.6711148619651794,
-0.33032146096229553,
0.5635378360748291,
0.028689933940768242,
0.38490334153175354,
-0.6110305190086365,
-0.03900536894798279,
-0.5931711792945862,
-0.5211575627326965,
-0.5659893155097961,
0.02942153625190258,
0.22755438089370728,
0.027090609073638916,
-0.6136317253112793,
-0.13907510042190552,
-0.47060132026672363,
0.7647729516029358,
0.5479958653450012,
0.23544788360595703,
0.2815367579460144,
0.07323059439659119,
-0.23988115787506104,
-0.36801230907440186,
-0.6760701537132263,
-0.4564354121685028,
0.9241858124732971,
0.15658019483089447,
1.338876724243164,
-0.047571081668138504,
0.6522216796875,
-0.0016565817641094327,
0.5688551068305969,
-0.5186700820922852,
0.21003733575344086,
-0.28989121317863464,
-0.7380964159965515,
-0.33325478434562683,
-0.16015103459358215,
-0.5908783674240112,
-0.22793647646903992,
-0.10527177155017853,
-1.2702473402023315,
0.17812249064445496,
0.46827492117881775,
-0.7949132323265076,
0.44315242767333984,
-0.38242217898368835,
0.48772358894348145,
-0.09724728763103485,
-0.43120482563972473,
-0.1865527629852295,
-0.638619065284729,
0.28685975074768066,
-0.15492531657218933,
0.2179459184408188,
-0.090278260409832,
0.13869349658489227,
0.4588282108306885,
-0.3882114887237549,
1.1127288341522217,
-0.13417644798755646,
0.02803609147667885,
0.4807862341403961,
0.27410534024238586,
0.5263631343841553,
0.26130956411361694,
-0.4116598665714264,
0.19590836763381958,
0.11418435722589493,
-0.06079570949077606,
-0.45055755972862244,
1.0550496578216553,
-0.8948405981063843,
-0.10713474452495575,
-0.21162356436252594,
-0.8615814447402954,
-0.15972797572612762,
0.04974561184644699,
0.40794384479522705,
0.4431038200855255,
0.07880423218011856,
0.4398888647556305,
0.8253167867660522,
0.12162108719348907,
0.6153963804244995,
0.6787198781967163,
-0.3430376350879669,
-0.01969420351088047,
0.8496148586273193,
0.30298227071762085,
0.20809362828731537,
0.25446265935897827,
0.176491841673851,
-0.048542894423007965,
-0.5735334157943726,
-0.3602728545665741,
-0.3156896233558655,
-0.644959032535553,
-0.20652800798416138,
-0.40721818804740906,
-0.5675467848777771,
-0.05540526658296585,
-0.14593155682086945,
-0.6830951571464539,
-0.22840149700641632,
-0.44682249426841736,
0.10985206812620163,
-0.040980249643325806,
0.7594752907752991,
0.022904658690094948,
0.35418829321861267,
-0.2156078964471817,
0.015642177313566208,
0.02996722422540188,
0.5069672465324402,
0.1348576694726944,
-0.6341201066970825,
-0.43352237343788147,
0.2594829499721527,
-0.20249386131763458,
-0.44473183155059814,
0.3285168409347534,
0.4839620888233185,
0.4029209017753601,
0.5960299372673035,
0.24609637260437012,
1.0008736848831177,
-0.3812965452671051,
0.7091064453125,
-0.15155336260795593,
-0.8103621602058411,
0.2742622494697571,
-0.030617568641901016,
0.4943103492259979,
0.9115310311317444,
0.0016823316691443324,
0.00911450944840908,
-0.8387975692749023,
-0.7779737114906311,
-0.8091741800308228,
0.6081230044364929,
-0.17222855985164642,
0.2416907548904419,
0.3016932010650635,
0.5299160480499268,
0.13252197206020355,
0.1261483132839203,
-0.7496371269226074,
-0.35980162024497986,
0.16410258412361145,
-0.4492357075214386,
0.1469312608242035,
-0.27069830894470215,
0.019362272694706917,
-0.4199107885360718,
0.8469917178153992,
-0.1650872826576233,
-0.17805027961730957,
0.026809822767972946,
-0.14420591294765472,
-0.8730958104133606,
-0.18754640221595764,
0.45962628722190857,
0.7777073979377747,
-0.5111879706382751,
0.09194917976856232,
0.3937107026576996,
-0.6801583766937256,
-0.1820051074028015,
-0.056576285511255264,
-0.7296394109725952,
-0.08079361170530319,
0.10809464007616043,
0.4724160134792328,
0.6452487707138062,
-0.7747020721435547,
0.5536447763442993,
-0.33128049969673157,
-0.06728675961494446,
-0.6060206294059753,
0.4519285261631012,
-0.20416590571403503,
0.3699101507663727,
0.5907956957817078,
0.6510701179504395,
0.3062168061733246,
-0.23033525049686432,
0.44420281052589417,
0.5096498131752014,
-0.9323743581771851,
-0.3930685818195343,
1.1016608476638794,
-0.13042336702346802,
-0.33404672145843506,
0.6131628751754761,
-0.08869471400976181,
-0.19195117056369781,
0.5266521573066711,
0.7820936441421509,
0.6735586524009705,
-0.12595996260643005,
-0.0957893654704094,
0.3645668923854828,
0.2011236846446991,
-0.0407654345035553,
0.3405199348926544,
-0.12296967208385468,
-0.782351553440094,
-0.5705006122589111,
-0.7030428051948547,
-0.6118990182876587,
0.28442907333374023,
-0.5503838062286377,
0.4136221706867218,
-0.7220577597618103,
0.019992854446172714,
-0.08431413024663925,
0.2558495104312897,
-0.6941397786140442,
0.37227198481559753,
0.2020663470029831,
0.8471980094909668,
-0.6531096696853638,
1.252362847328186,
0.6989977955818176,
-0.39559975266456604,
-1.2737572193145752,
0.2770669162273407,
0.24791771173477173,
-0.46887877583503723,
0.8685292601585388,
0.10151100158691406,
-0.3578692674636841,
0.27469128370285034,
-1.0848373174667358,
-0.9763587117195129,
0.9038830399513245,
0.863972544670105,
-0.672843873500824,
0.27471402287483215,
0.09869508445262909,
0.537233293056488,
-0.6106470823287964,
0.31089702248573303,
0.08269956707954407,
0.3931715190410614,
-0.03926996886730194,
-0.672539234161377,
-0.12321218103170395,
0.0027001393027603626,
-0.27734842896461487,
-0.052274011075496674,
-0.6310840249061584,
1.0289146900177002,
-0.3738369643688202,
-0.0956251323223114,
0.22658516466617584,
0.5769050121307373,
0.17600145936012268,
0.49905848503112793,
0.5565361380577087,
0.2162283957004547,
0.958402693271637,
0.05021040141582489,
0.8801459074020386,
-0.8729269504547119,
0.3328497111797333,
1.4971238374710083,
-0.3366290330886841,
0.885199785232544,
0.640906810760498,
0.03845914825797081,
0.35348770022392273,
0.7759743928909302,
0.1740475744009018,
0.668788492679596,
0.07334724068641663,
-0.42022767663002014,
-0.39664849638938904,
-0.15401312708854675,
-0.08978431671857834,
0.18508780002593994,
0.33403053879737854,
-0.1441250592470169,
-0.3988855481147766,
0.013441983610391617,
-0.12706099450588226,
0.08605321496725082,
-0.21544836461544037,
0.6132078766822815,
0.1663956493139267,
-0.4098339080810547,
0.33018729090690613,
-0.21923252940177917,
0.41099122166633606,
-0.4706781208515167,
-0.21597081422805786,
-0.06411247700452805,
0.5291027426719666,
-0.14572972059249878,
-0.38444703817367554,
0.1281534880399704,
-0.38735824823379517,
-0.219845712184906,
-0.11364887654781342,
0.8356820344924927,
-0.6563748121261597,
-0.31411677598953247,
0.37716999650001526,
0.2160528004169464,
0.2677225172519684,
-0.15369513630867004,
-0.7917852401733398,
0.022296728566288948,
0.061498064547777176,
-0.11810048669576645,
0.5190377831459045,
0.3664126694202423,
0.048791948705911636,
0.8145983815193176,
0.830931544303894,
0.23709627985954285,
0.022987497970461845,
0.3212141990661621,
0.731670081615448,
-0.1255127191543579,
-0.40391185879707336,
-0.7654609084129333,
0.5091795921325684,
0.20717588067054749,
-0.6212630271911621,
0.6128299832344055,
0.6837427020072937,
1.2185758352279663,
0.11701640486717224,
0.48566773533821106,
0.15830302238464355,
0.4290652275085449,
-0.37625929713249207,
1.0312007665634155,
-0.5796418190002441,
0.7304526567459106,
-0.2527807652950287,
-0.786115288734436,
-0.6900396943092346,
0.7053753137588501,
-0.11280597746372223,
0.16383813321590424,
0.48517030477523804,
1.1179536581039429,
-0.3962637484073639,
0.06994760781526566,
0.7167383432388306,
0.44890689849853516,
0.041084110736846924,
0.24558643996715546,
0.7746506929397583,
-0.581505298614502,
0.4356355369091034,
-0.7498846054077148,
0.012159766629338264,
-0.33995822072029114,
-0.8590741753578186,
-0.6821343898773193,
-0.5235772728919983,
-0.5254515409469604,
-0.42577412724494934,
0.40562522411346436,
1.1298080682754517,
1.07362961769104,
-1.121577262878418,
-0.46867141127586365,
-0.06694298982620239,
0.0204785093665123,
-0.4895120859146118,
-0.22389818727970123,
0.17699044942855835,
-0.6961427927017212,
-0.9177643060684204,
0.4999561905860901,
0.16480982303619385,
-0.0991768166422844,
-0.15189814567565918,
-0.48845046758651733,
-0.016474274918437004,
0.04678662121295929,
0.17749640345573425,
0.24101391434669495,
-0.5907205939292908,
-0.25352224707603455,
-0.4694904685020447,
-0.3475375175476074,
0.14332596957683563,
0.5806556940078735,
-0.7943156957626343,
0.4628921151161194,
0.09265509992837906,
0.260569304227829,
0.5815912485122681,
-0.07400783896446228,
0.4929811358451843,
-0.7489607930183411,
0.47734108567237854,
0.35199370980262756,
0.21778693795204163,
0.13909900188446045,
-0.6065569519996643,
0.43572667241096497,
-0.21922804415225983,
-0.7271415591239929,
-0.9443827271461487,
-0.02250068634748459,
-0.5677098631858826,
-0.36616042256355286,
0.9494260549545288,
0.12229632586240768,
-0.26984816789627075,
-0.23203659057617188,
-0.28440916538238525,
0.13465799391269684,
-0.6454745531082153,
0.9003483653068542,
0.6221761107444763,
-0.043782010674476624,
-0.02578117325901985,
-0.8977102637290955,
0.9164451956748962,
0.4395146667957306,
-0.10185230523347855,
-0.11401388794183731,
0.3413713872432709,
0.4217919111251831,
-0.10035909712314606,
0.33144327998161316,
-0.12782022356987,
0.30526313185691833,
-0.05687320604920387,
-0.1586332470178604,
0.1667548269033432,
-0.44007810950279236,
-0.23899641633033752,
0.17724403738975525,
0.6365363001823425,
0.16545610129833221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05512v1 | GPTs Are Multilingual Annotators for Sequence Generation Tasks | 2024-02-08T09:44:02 | 2024-02-08T09:44:02 | Juhwan Choi, Eunju Lee, Kyohoon Jin, YoungBin Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data annotation is an essential step for constructing new datasets. However,
the conventional approach of data annotation through crowdsourcing is both
time-consuming and expensive. In addition, the complexity of this process
increases when dealing with low-resource languages owing to the difference in
the language pool of crowdworkers. To address these issues, this study proposes
an autonomous annotation method by utilizing large language models, which have
been recently demonstrated to exhibit remarkable performance. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate that the proposed method is not just cost-efficient
but also applicable for low-resource language annotation. Additionally, we
constructed an image captioning dataset using our approach and are committed to
open this dataset for future study. We have opened our source code for further
study and reproducibility. | [
-0.3797612190246582,
-0.4230705499649048,
0.46198272705078125,
0.158655047416687,
-0.6090511679649353,
0.0980825126171112,
-0.36407777667045593,
-0.4677562415599823,
0.05823942646384239,
0.5044996738433838,
-0.5175656080245972,
-0.2842565178871155,
-0.6142706871032715,
0.39754965901374817,
-0.30817556381225586,
0.9726102352142334,
-0.17331591248512268,
-0.19294758141040802,
0.25295108556747437,
-0.2562687397003174,
-0.2081986516714096,
-0.47051483392715454,
-0.6956045627593994,
0.12096735090017319,
0.40172991156578064,
0.2912985682487488,
0.910740315914154,
1.078285813331604,
0.384037047624588,
0.4023730158805847,
0.3801819682121277,
0.3865777552127838,
-0.053948983550071716,
0.09301798790693283,
-0.025893719866871834,
0.05348069593310356,
-0.05587293207645416,
0.13335654139518738,
0.7428910136222839,
0.44006791710853577,
0.16695204377174377,
0.2916083037853241,
-0.20052358508110046,
0.5967634320259094,
-0.22451923787593842,
0.6114270687103271,
-0.7613744735717773,
0.03330761194229126,
-0.4159008860588074,
-0.06122247129678726,
-0.3330369293689728,
-0.5426024794578552,
0.0016831548418849707,
-0.7282609343528748,
0.4148463010787964,
-0.13561907410621643,
0.6880285143852234,
0.33473554253578186,
0.009084654971957207,
-0.2254536896944046,
-0.5665144324302673,
0.5344981551170349,
-0.6704457998275757,
0.0557633601129055,
0.2960060238838196,
0.4350948929786682,
0.11597415059804916,
-0.6034055948257446,
-0.8683608174324036,
-0.31917300820350647,
-0.4594479501247406,
-0.2392844557762146,
0.3570070266723633,
-0.2391267865896225,
0.4260216951370239,
0.43367961049079895,
-0.628960132598877,
0.06715042889118195,
-0.35570964217185974,
-0.19290418922901154,
0.9773347973823547,
0.043419040739536285,
0.3711989223957062,
-0.4961407780647278,
-0.20669683814048767,
-0.04422875866293907,
-0.6543734669685364,
-0.3557187020778656,
0.4125058650970459,
0.8435494303703308,
-0.29037004709243774,
0.7641633749008179,
-0.3281295597553253,
0.7136122584342957,
-0.13379737734794617,
0.026119021698832512,
0.33121171593666077,
-0.20059597492218018,
-0.2730373442173004,
-0.24834947288036346,
1.2151095867156982,
-0.056912586092948914,
0.6817987561225891,
-0.3508059084415436,
-0.19021852314472198,
-0.26881441473960876,
-0.1979205161333084,
-0.8113380670547485,
-0.5470174551010132,
0.10530740767717361,
-0.14049096405506134,
-0.1961837112903595,
0.23061875998973846,
-0.809573769569397,
-0.563259482383728,
-0.4063284397125244,
0.2191469818353653,
-0.30803531408309937,
-0.27783963084220886,
-0.3120959401130676,
0.2548883259296417,
0.06492525339126587,
0.43512219190597534,
-0.8987457752227783,
-0.06996037811040878,
0.3860069811344147,
1.3014421463012695,
0.12092261761426926,
-0.4220997989177704,
-0.7596834301948547,
0.21552883088588715,
-0.21057651937007904,
0.706642210483551,
-0.5436978936195374,
-0.429958313703537,
-0.07186812162399292,
0.26722800731658936,
-0.04478927329182625,
-0.1384371519088745,
0.047144073992967606,
-0.5882770419120789,
0.16498948633670807,
-0.22964918613433838,
-0.457069993019104,
-0.14244799315929413,
-0.2197464108467102,
-1.0584803819656372,
0.8909806609153748,
0.09723098576068878,
-0.6696146130561829,
0.49388206005096436,
-1.005785346031189,
-0.5493906140327454,
0.8157151341438293,
-0.5497626662254333,
-0.4344261586666107,
-0.19934192299842834,
0.6433616280555725,
0.8408071398735046,
-0.10062864422798157,
0.4023117423057556,
0.05606803670525551,
-0.15910322964191437,
0.22894831001758575,
-0.30363282561302185,
0.4824088513851166,
0.23888614773750305,
-0.6530539989471436,
0.11681564152240753,
-0.4693761467933655,
0.06646351516246796,
0.33850014209747314,
-0.3189869225025177,
-0.02588159590959549,
0.025672253221273422,
0.26362448930740356,
0.33127087354660034,
-0.048591550439596176,
-0.4310756325721741,
0.7005211710929871,
-0.11153577268123627,
0.666627049446106,
0.8186004757881165,
0.0624210387468338,
0.2932521402835846,
0.030556432902812958,
0.4942988157272339,
-0.2168809473514557,
-0.0206037238240242,
-0.48552340269088745,
-0.734590470790863,
-0.30885905027389526,
-0.6565689444541931,
0.3989768326282501,
0.543308675289154,
-1.2509263753890991,
0.2987561821937561,
-0.4367690980434418,
-0.4950288236141205,
-0.7173217535018921,
0.3173818290233612,
0.4453154504299164,
0.30868133902549744,
0.3343054950237274,
-0.36931440234184265,
-0.448679119348526,
-0.8487581610679626,
0.18995732069015503,
-0.13874082267284393,
0.022314919158816338,
0.18959985673427582,
0.4968428611755371,
0.04553717374801636,
0.9248053431510925,
-0.3827875554561615,
-0.17109601199626923,
-0.07452662289142609,
0.4821193218231201,
0.050673436373472214,
0.6728160977363586,
0.4567379653453827,
-0.7605105042457581,
-0.5307576060295105,
0.19143818318843842,
-0.6750618815422058,
-0.03488015756011009,
-0.3351043164730072,
-0.08742615580558777,
0.5517427921295166,
0.42646822333335876,
-0.5861356854438782,
0.3099420666694641,
0.657058596611023,
-0.10096165537834167,
0.40387266874313354,
-0.06653161346912384,
0.3774024248123169,
-0.9714730381965637,
0.2580713927745819,
0.15977630019187927,
-0.37162020802497864,
-0.310258150100708,
-0.0733838751912117,
-0.041355594992637634,
-0.34738078713417053,
-0.4125065207481384,
0.6278064250946045,
-0.7997738122940063,
-0.1362268477678299,
-0.23647889494895935,
0.1629227250814438,
-0.31031909584999084,
0.38339805603027344,
0.4838109314441681,
1.0779513120651245,
0.5782455801963806,
-0.21611689031124115,
0.6202977895736694,
0.2693832218647003,
-0.4745806157588959,
0.1312488168478012,
-0.5695493221282959,
0.34891277551651,
-0.05877136066555977,
0.20136307179927826,
-1.1160926818847656,
-0.6117045283317566,
0.35298845171928406,
-0.35278722643852234,
0.1524081975221634,
-0.5839090943336487,
-0.9788346290588379,
-0.6495031118392944,
0.061357419937849045,
0.3882809281349182,
0.43125832080841064,
-0.7334913611412048,
0.1373554766178131,
0.35060080885887146,
-0.5241528749465942,
-0.2697583734989166,
-0.8406426906585693,
0.22863535583019257,
-0.2292112112045288,
-0.5031481385231018,
-0.2048923224210739,
0.22733169794082642,
-0.0069056665524840355,
-0.22430863976478577,
0.5844019055366516,
-0.1014331504702568,
-0.23860016465187073,
0.3412906527519226,
0.2531808018684387,
-0.11664845794439316,
0.4550388753414154,
-0.2646501362323761,
-0.31467297673225403,
-0.38009706139564514,
-0.5009605288505554,
0.48031169176101685,
-0.19458608329296112,
-0.5077453851699829,
-0.5276288390159607,
0.6505504250526428,
0.3970167338848114,
-0.6916312575340271,
0.5472783446311951,
0.678941547870636,
-0.4293340742588043,
-0.0188694279640913,
-0.75033038854599,
0.04161102697253227,
-0.5031259655952454,
0.4332720935344696,
-0.2886768877506256,
-1.0173428058624268,
0.545412003993988,
0.2066003531217575,
-0.03914942219853401,
0.45789939165115356,
0.7236071825027466,
0.3814549744129181,
0.7613686323165894,
0.3111022710800171,
-0.49181708693504333,
0.30973395705223083,
-0.03960184380412102,
0.153108611702919,
-0.34832119941711426,
0.27615323662757874,
-0.3707701563835144,
-0.10016743093729019,
-0.7994056940078735,
-0.8160508871078491,
0.2138950526714325,
-0.10032209008932114,
-0.2867063879966736,
0.3535322844982147,
-0.8795833587646484,
0.598599910736084,
0.7114118933677673,
-0.10835825651884079,
0.37980949878692627,
0.14536815881729126,
0.2821725606918335,
-0.03381749242544174,
-0.46625927090644836,
-0.8288097977638245,
1.0864437818527222,
0.09296228736639023,
0.5138396620750427,
0.09952301532030106,
0.6648245453834534,
0.3001176118850708,
0.6993428468704224,
-0.4378381371498108,
0.5866310596466064,
-0.1314568966627121,
-0.5448576211929321,
-0.8382381796836853,
-0.3976156413555145,
-0.8072755336761475,
0.06929091364145279,
-0.04843362048268318,
-0.8801804780960083,
-0.133586123585701,
0.21340501308441162,
-0.5295988917350769,
0.5051540732383728,
-0.9289456605911255,
0.8399096131324768,
-0.203802689909935,
-0.3806442320346832,
0.35942912101745605,
-0.7000592350959778,
0.22069264948368073,
-0.2142116129398346,
0.3381953239440918,
-0.14678411185741425,
0.11696166545152664,
0.6864219307899475,
-0.5833735466003418,
0.8983378410339355,
-0.63957279920578,
-0.09475544840097427,
0.7560229301452637,
-0.02274993807077408,
0.8666857481002808,
0.25208553671836853,
0.05007784441113472,
0.041837725788354874,
-0.4775543510913849,
-0.3556322455406189,
-0.19867092370986938,
0.6946977376937866,
-0.47275522351264954,
-0.43745157122612,
-0.21239963173866272,
-0.7226433753967285,
-0.046116411685943604,
0.13246014714241028,
-0.02556324563920498,
0.3056865632534027,
0.28394815325737,
-0.3625425398349762,
0.11163872480392456,
-0.19346588850021362,
0.9829617738723755,
0.31959056854248047,
-0.11547241359949112,
-0.6482514142990112,
0.8244733214378357,
0.26654747128486633,
0.13217824697494507,
0.05479453131556511,
0.023681042715907097,
-0.3309776484966278,
-0.5649750232696533,
-1.1842116117477417,
0.2575574219226837,
-0.44746705889701843,
-0.31711435317993164,
-0.5011174082756042,
0.13519340753555298,
-0.48431745171546936,
-0.23384027183055878,
-0.3449925184249878,
-0.46277883648872375,
0.14854486286640167,
-0.3247583210468292,
0.9278478622436523,
0.8304418325424194,
-0.1393306404352188,
0.361488938331604,
-0.8904933929443359,
0.26398202776908875,
0.5826839804649353,
0.473903626203537,
0.04840583726763725,
-0.03011823631823063,
-0.32827630639076233,
-0.09585133194923401,
0.019516725093126297,
-0.9036553502082825,
0.4800339937210083,
0.13192729651927948,
0.3582201898097992,
0.20059752464294434,
-0.19200170040130615,
0.8005749583244324,
-0.6200776696205139,
0.9417588114738464,
-0.0018256974872201681,
-1.1552761793136597,
0.5943624973297119,
-0.7347590923309326,
0.20378819108009338,
0.5004580020904541,
0.21855098009109497,
-0.4629191756248474,
-0.4236913025379181,
-0.4918341338634491,
-1.037029504776001,
0.585153341293335,
0.2734428644180298,
0.16310833394527435,
-0.3007030487060547,
0.47581717371940613,
0.3689778447151184,
0.28329575061798096,
-0.9162389636039734,
-0.04888413846492767,
-0.161420539021492,
-0.11584170162677765,
-0.2962225079536438,
0.027659427374601364,
-0.026807917281985283,
-0.17794178426265717,
0.6841234564781189,
-0.507845401763916,
0.21354344487190247,
0.3094484806060791,
-0.04688042774796486,
-0.3356974124908447,
0.10745768994092941,
0.48386234045028687,
0.43703803420066833,
0.17249339818954468,
-0.1407652646303177,
-0.06118178367614746,
-0.4657173454761505,
0.15900197625160217,
0.6662397384643555,
-0.20185378193855286,
0.20188485085964203,
0.3668007552623749,
0.7335715889930725,
-0.3093701899051666,
-0.6313136219978333,
0.5558610558509827,
0.35524681210517883,
0.035685960203409195,
-0.2973773777484894,
-0.46033307909965515,
0.14996090531349182,
0.3475674092769623,
0.6090953946113586,
-0.37063804268836975,
-0.08765748888254166,
-0.19040724635124207,
0.33752673864364624,
0.3714829683303833,
-0.0441921204328537,
-0.16737394034862518,
0.6818270087242126,
0.3434748649597168,
-0.060024600476026535,
0.7499346733093262,
-0.5820786952972412,
-0.35756173729896545,
0.5243449211120605,
0.12090329080820084,
0.9721887707710266,
-0.3645537495613098,
0.351578950881958,
0.426487535238266,
0.4695792496204376,
-0.2525573670864105,
0.17419584095478058,
-0.019993236288428307,
-0.31786414980888367,
-1.0201934576034546,
-0.46110832691192627,
-0.2611429691314697,
0.1391248255968094,
-0.4489558935165405,
0.11051812022924423,
-0.18948067724704742,
0.07478661090135574,
0.02078779973089695,
-0.11389317363500595,
-0.8956295251846313,
0.4534997344017029,
0.4694661796092987,
0.48469024896621704,
-1.0738005638122559,
0.9496777653694153,
0.7880693078041077,
-0.6456117033958435,
-0.9532138705253601,
-0.17652365565299988,
-0.11372405290603638,
-0.9136013388633728,
0.7182952761650085,
0.26951977610588074,
0.1699157953262329,
-0.05265951529145241,
-0.5947174429893494,
-0.8527337908744812,
1.148299217224121,
0.25954267382621765,
-0.7657096982002258,
0.014137315563857555,
0.41842591762542725,
0.4962945282459259,
-0.43194466829299927,
0.09469040483236313,
0.25090324878692627,
0.7482907772064209,
0.048909928649663925,
-1.1859105825424194,
0.3176719546318054,
-0.34346193075180054,
0.01979047805070877,
0.27066323161125183,
-0.5959389805793762,
0.8846386671066284,
-0.4059785008430481,
-0.30435848236083984,
0.24591335654258728,
0.7007218599319458,
0.16934868693351746,
-0.018806157633662224,
0.4800172746181488,
0.3524324893951416,
0.7550852298736572,
-0.25050580501556396,
1.0734390020370483,
-0.17066210508346558,
0.5314554572105408,
1.2634392976760864,
-0.2860172390937805,
0.6746033430099487,
0.5298020839691162,
-0.3676433563232422,
0.24354837834835052,
0.5135378241539001,
-0.3585854768753052,
0.4803812801837921,
0.6750996112823486,
-0.28126364946365356,
-0.2385767698287964,
0.16989083588123322,
-0.2514401972293854,
0.24457529187202454,
0.13783639669418335,
-0.6592744588851929,
-0.19233912229537964,
0.1444479525089264,
0.17738530039787292,
0.11883751302957535,
-0.41261300444602966,
0.759992241859436,
-0.2424091100692749,
-0.583641529083252,
0.3676612079143524,
-0.13615408539772034,
0.6149521470069885,
-0.3819405436515808,
-0.011175550520420074,
-0.043356217443943024,
-0.12336471676826477,
-0.169268399477005,
-0.7679150104522705,
0.3099590837955475,
0.3035350739955902,
0.003329690545797348,
-0.05056997016072273,
0.35939863324165344,
-0.4860941469669342,
-0.7566774487495422,
-0.09466671943664551,
0.7225262522697449,
0.2087128758430481,
-0.29220059514045715,
-0.48022615909576416,
-0.1486518383026123,
-0.015679024159908295,
-0.3679223656654358,
-0.0505635030567646,
0.6572473645210266,
-0.3352747857570648,
0.5128706097602844,
0.5956133604049683,
0.13118582963943481,
0.245873361825943,
0.17911779880523682,
0.7777037024497986,
-0.6544234752655029,
-0.5122778415679932,
-0.9812874794006348,
0.8209534287452698,
-0.12062156945466995,
-0.21684645116329193,
0.6422904133796692,
0.5736753344535828,
0.9265615344047546,
-0.4561254680156708,
1.4837117195129395,
-0.3497691750526428,
0.4873112142086029,
-0.48493486642837524,
0.7595378160476685,
-0.04009630158543587,
-0.09335678070783615,
-0.5502767562866211,
-0.6514953970909119,
-0.5063360333442688,
0.5680103898048401,
-0.554040789604187,
0.2052503526210785,
0.3514881432056427,
0.740664005279541,
0.18735437095165253,
0.11203671991825104,
-0.01095628272742033,
-0.005264298524707556,
0.43963655829429626,
0.5653417706489563,
0.5806179046630859,
-0.2822525203227997,
0.3902703523635864,
-0.48908063769340515,
-0.16090281307697296,
0.2910926043987274,
-1.0945994853973389,
-0.946242094039917,
-0.8088686466217041,
-0.6779652237892151,
-0.0892949178814888,
0.12691889703273773,
1.0447990894317627,
0.8861415386199951,
-0.906409740447998,
-0.04884810373187065,
-0.11597343534231186,
-0.37391918897628784,
-0.05768483132123947,
-0.2237265557050705,
0.7248775362968445,
-0.2706572115421295,
-0.90976881980896,
0.09198139607906342,
0.12950994074344635,
0.32928743958473206,
-0.41856443881988525,
0.1083708107471466,
-0.19044119119644165,
-0.28700512647628784,
0.3916551470756531,
0.40347445011138916,
-0.6867013573646545,
-0.6150286793708801,
-0.5111191272735596,
-0.05414702370762825,
0.014176098629832268,
0.7797552347183228,
-0.7396160364151001,
0.4654730260372162,
0.14022338390350342,
0.560767412185669,
0.34832486510276794,
0.29778414964675903,
0.4681076109409332,
-1.021018624305725,
0.4603956937789917,
0.12141817063093185,
0.34784185886383057,
0.8155418038368225,
-0.411834180355072,
0.7107865214347839,
0.1905594915151596,
-0.6341539621353149,
-0.6790462732315063,
0.1385466605424881,
-0.8663787245750427,
0.22751949727535248,
1.1865601539611816,
-0.35805532336235046,
-0.013031063601374626,
0.015817176550626755,
-0.3243570625782013,
0.28684118390083313,
-0.518477201461792,
0.8500480651855469,
0.5913536548614502,
0.0722266361117363,
-0.27118125557899475,
-0.6065354347229004,
0.5706509947776794,
-0.0843951404094696,
-0.9165146946907043,
0.34824812412261963,
0.6097589731216431,
0.08254554122686386,
0.31753283739089966,
0.7232208251953125,
-0.274059534072876,
0.04395085945725441,
-0.23073381185531616,
0.4776264429092407,
-0.32258811593055725,
0.10978043079376221,
-0.16726456582546234,
0.23333029448986053,
0.11338011920452118,
-0.4157567322254181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05467v1 | Rapid Optimization for Jailbreaking LLMs via Subconscious Exploitation and Echopraxia | 2024-02-08T07:56:49 | 2024-02-08T07:56:49 | Guangyu Shen, Siyuan Cheng, Kaiyuan Zhang, Guanhong Tao, Shengwei An, Lu Yan, Zhuo Zhang, Shiqing Ma, Xiangyu Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become prevalent across diverse sectors,
transforming human life with their extraordinary reasoning and comprehension
abilities. As they find increased use in sensitive tasks, safety concerns have
gained widespread attention. Extensive efforts have been dedicated to aligning
LLMs with human moral principles to ensure their safe deployment. Despite their
potential, recent research indicates aligned LLMs are prone to specialized
jailbreaking prompts that bypass safety measures to elicit violent and harmful
content. The intrinsic discrete nature and substantial scale of contemporary
LLMs pose significant challenges in automatically generating diverse,
efficient, and potent jailbreaking prompts, representing a continuous obstacle.
In this paper, we introduce RIPPLE (Rapid Optimization via Subconscious
Exploitation and Echopraxia), a novel optimization-based method inspired by two
psychological concepts: subconsciousness and echopraxia, which describe the
processes of the mind that occur without conscious awareness and the
involuntary mimicry of actions, respectively. Evaluations across 6 open-source
LLMs and 4 commercial LLM APIs show RIPPLE achieves an average Attack Success
Rate of 91.5\%, outperforming five current methods by up to 47.0\% with an 8x
reduction in overhead. Furthermore, it displays significant transferability and
stealth, successfully evading established detection mechanisms. The code of our
work is available at
\url{https://github.com/SolidShen/RIPPLE_official/tree/official} | [
-0.6693761944770813,
-1.0429788827896118,
0.6580960750579834,
0.5096040964126587,
-0.3618110418319702,
0.25531983375549316,
-0.2724882960319519,
-0.44450607895851135,
0.1186630055308342,
0.6636596918106079,
-0.79278963804245,
-0.34153684973716736,
-0.6290286183357239,
0.03641931340098381,
-0.2795202434062958,
0.6977447867393494,
-0.09881643950939178,
-0.16694222390651703,
0.2980591654777527,
-0.06022009998559952,
-0.6128925681114197,
-0.48172643780708313,
-0.41672125458717346,
-0.05291454493999481,
0.32817453145980835,
0.413686066865921,
0.4439195394515991,
0.5862613320350647,
0.5141493678092957,
0.27160096168518066,
-0.010839920490980148,
0.2743329703807831,
-0.7969747185707092,
0.150829017162323,
-0.06050732359290123,
-0.20065683126449585,
0.07749667763710022,
-0.14184848964214325,
0.4400743246078491,
0.4326191544532776,
-0.26087966561317444,
-0.017240026965737343,
0.1587209701538086,
0.6746245622634888,
-0.859767496585846,
-0.19148530066013336,
-0.7935221791267395,
0.20209527015686035,
-0.12300892174243927,
-0.1082831546664238,
-0.3279114365577698,
-0.49577897787094116,
-0.26147159934043884,
-0.4459662437438965,
-0.19253548979759216,
0.3333672285079956,
0.5574883222579956,
0.26241031289100647,
-0.060789596289396286,
-0.4107932150363922,
-0.5962598323822021,
0.8399379253387451,
-0.33976835012435913,
0.3995630741119385,
0.2065868079662323,
0.0757492259144783,
-0.38347721099853516,
-0.47282934188842773,
-0.5475015044212341,
-0.41502875089645386,
0.24864651262760162,
-0.16533711552619934,
-0.42498812079429626,
0.2728368043899536,
0.28607818484306335,
0.13248027861118317,
-0.3279823958873749,
0.343919962644577,
-0.004770137369632721,
-0.3152853548526764,
0.42818138003349304,
0.40849459171295166,
0.27029234170913696,
-0.1005188375711441,
-0.5504173636436462,
-0.19009460508823395,
-0.4298766553401947,
0.2521046996116638,
0.43266862630844116,
0.445452481508255,
-0.3003978729248047,
0.632495641708374,
0.12163623422384262,
0.5947054028511047,
0.17205725610256195,
-0.2501598596572876,
0.09958197176456451,
0.032933685928583145,
0.06029736250638962,
0.015919560566544533,
0.9076130986213684,
0.3836266100406647,
0.16772501170635223,
-0.12794430553913116,
-0.6091822981834412,
0.009529147297143936,
0.4703706204891205,
-0.6759922504425049,
0.49016043543815613,
0.540303647518158,
-0.5433447957038879,
-0.5582676529884338,
-0.11395449191331863,
-0.821079432964325,
-0.7983543872833252,
-0.11618703603744507,
0.27968618273735046,
-0.6166293621063232,
-0.13428820669651031,
0.18154427409172058,
-0.09724867343902588,
0.329875648021698,
-0.07761800289154053,
-0.9237858653068542,
0.33654069900512695,
1.0357717275619507,
1.057818055152893,
-0.05784224718809128,
-0.22254769504070282,
-0.5239277482032776,
-0.11080820113420486,
-0.38229888677597046,
0.6268176436424255,
-0.3473763167858124,
-0.9314696192741394,
-0.009644263423979282,
-0.48691046237945557,
0.06376636773347855,
-0.4922555387020111,
0.732234001159668,
-0.41697928309440613,
-0.4146782457828522,
-0.08365777134895325,
-0.46222037076950073,
0.10596632212400436,
0.3508530855178833,
-0.4816039204597473,
0.5886370539665222,
0.06434223800897598,
-0.6024448275566101,
0.06283234059810638,
-0.5192736387252808,
-0.45020973682403564,
-0.11447054147720337,
-0.00826108269393444,
-0.41183754801750183,
0.3226604163646698,
0.21744942665100098,
0.13213707506656647,
-0.28762292861938477,
0.2854364812374115,
-0.46546652913093567,
-0.48992136120796204,
0.46703630685806274,
-0.29321813583374023,
0.7369976043701172,
0.5909114480018616,
-0.46144163608551025,
0.039236776530742645,
-0.5277836322784424,
-0.04908566549420357,
0.0776195153594017,
-0.11500734090805054,
-0.4012591242790222,
0.003497628029435873,
0.037635840475559235,
-0.027414565905928612,
0.3363010585308075,
-0.6369059085845947,
0.2673017978668213,
-0.3739272952079773,
0.2544536590576172,
1.1829400062561035,
0.2793368697166443,
0.3177938163280487,
-0.1650380641222,
0.518609881401062,
-0.39335235953330994,
0.6726484298706055,
-0.02728138491511345,
-0.17904402315616608,
-0.43917879462242126,
-0.6351374983787537,
-0.28801989555358887,
0.8146777153015137,
-0.24609717726707458,
0.684404730796814,
0.140961155295372,
-0.5291166305541992,
-0.36691972613334656,
0.4223526120185852,
0.6217471361160278,
0.645117461681366,
0.21686412394046783,
-0.3050224483013153,
-0.9005205035209656,
-0.8949166536331177,
-0.7122615575790405,
-0.07811108976602554,
-0.013180403038859367,
0.4237572252750397,
0.12085189670324326,
-0.6626454591751099,
0.9148790240287781,
-0.5353806614875793,
-0.41354408860206604,
-0.39670950174331665,
0.055794887244701385,
0.5871554613113403,
0.4990578293800354,
0.27654731273651123,
-0.4701502025127411,
-0.21754519641399384,
-0.20353178679943085,
-0.91342693567276,
-0.32074689865112305,
-0.47679048776626587,
-0.2655351161956787,
-0.08347538113594055,
0.5299190282821655,
-0.7873815894126892,
0.13409538567066193,
0.2905326187610626,
-0.18481194972991943,
0.8285264372825623,
-0.037124138325452805,
-0.2062261551618576,
-0.7869108319282532,
-0.007848446257412434,
0.087696872651577,
0.09096674621105194,
-0.5929964184761047,
0.328844279050827,
0.1401759386062622,
-0.31606659293174744,
-0.5373057126998901,
0.6585655808448792,
-0.5078047513961792,
0.17913419008255005,
-0.3464590609073639,
0.14690199494361877,
-0.5160227417945862,
0.5406134128570557,
-0.22611534595489502,
0.6343035697937012,
0.6075924634933472,
-0.3492843210697174,
0.12422864884138107,
0.1741379201412201,
-0.35434862971305847,
0.2668501138687134,
-0.5187109708786011,
0.29566311836242676,
0.003417889354750514,
0.12754443287849426,
-0.4744252562522888,
-0.051993321627378464,
0.2940663695335388,
-0.23947133123874664,
0.06527376919984818,
-0.017786363139748573,
-0.32473793625831604,
-0.46123743057250977,
-0.6654022336006165,
0.24249093234539032,
0.84860759973526,
-0.5774232149124146,
0.7489476203918457,
0.5241751074790955,
-0.006702851969748735,
-0.8597866892814636,
-0.3731517195701599,
0.3546627163887024,
-0.3461495637893677,
-0.44504961371421814,
0.06004159152507782,
0.0016182997496798635,
-0.7087830901145935,
-0.4253716468811035,
-0.25322726368904114,
0.2711276412010193,
0.15010087192058563,
0.4870624542236328,
0.48502790927886963,
0.2582133710384369,
-0.35443320870399475,
0.04463396966457367,
-0.2156650274991989,
0.15980835258960724,
-0.374550461769104,
0.6456068754196167,
-0.33998164534568787,
-0.25071656703948975,
-0.49483680725097656,
0.36969518661499023,
0.5271109342575073,
-0.01450109202414751,
0.5952287316322327,
0.43944627046585083,
-0.12724430859088898,
-0.43412721157073975,
-0.8152374625205994,
-0.33011072874069214,
-0.628331184387207,
0.2607574760913849,
-0.38485702872276306,
-1.0184104442596436,
0.5623331069946289,
-0.2247805893421173,
0.04604417085647583,
-0.38060739636421204,
0.6426271796226501,
-0.031899888068437576,
1.0058835744857788,
0.7493780851364136,
-0.4648846983909607,
0.6779667735099792,
-0.19123475253582,
0.5610772967338562,
-0.8699041604995728,
-0.18427082896232605,
-0.424216628074646,
-0.196640282869339,
-0.5718250274658203,
-0.5301215052604675,
0.478202223777771,
0.2709697186946869,
-0.4342253804206848,
0.1803027242422104,
-0.5140334963798523,
0.5131622552871704,
0.36109814047813416,
0.10923399031162262,
0.08598117530345917,
0.0005713598220609128,
-0.3621216416358948,
0.15002964437007904,
-0.26869645714759827,
-0.43023863434791565,
1.1443136930465698,
0.3982847034931183,
1.1274104118347168,
-0.07218052446842194,
1.0275084972381592,
0.39587682485580444,
0.4415794312953949,
-0.7782750725746155,
0.7607279419898987,
0.03976362571120262,
-0.2954537868499756,
-0.1560843586921692,
-0.31604787707328796,
-1.0695189237594604,
0.34754011034965515,
-0.22838401794433594,
-1.095184326171875,
0.18984103202819824,
0.14303329586982727,
-0.24836532771587372,
0.3684502840042114,
-0.6709817051887512,
0.36646437644958496,
-0.4986772835254669,
-0.548732340335846,
-0.31381547451019287,
-0.6727440357208252,
0.7018890380859375,
-0.37009790539741516,
0.6873157620429993,
-0.2664352357387543,
-0.3084886074066162,
0.45563745498657227,
-0.7619901895523071,
0.9510800242424011,
-0.466503769159317,
-0.1142902597784996,
0.4393850862979889,
0.29276055097579956,
0.818629264831543,
0.2181663066148758,
0.07491700351238251,
0.25519436597824097,
-0.6719359755516052,
-0.32624223828315735,
-0.5061705708503723,
0.6885238289833069,
-0.8875056505203247,
-0.7922785878181458,
-0.13487564027309418,
-0.5344780683517456,
-0.44218483567237854,
0.42516836524009705,
0.2687360942363739,
0.08744502812623978,
-0.1691608726978302,
-0.26473501324653625,
0.7237571477890015,
-0.2385551780462265,
0.5299007892608643,
0.5147373676300049,
-0.26452016830444336,
-0.545161247253418,
0.8853946328163147,
-0.38155218958854675,
-0.09948655217885971,
0.18620768189430237,
0.32202214002609253,
-0.3774714469909668,
-0.7648230195045471,
0.03869946300983429,
0.3408638536930084,
-0.4969974458217621,
-0.15287677943706512,
-0.6365113854408264,
-0.03265919163823128,
-0.32207831740379333,
-0.6052537560462952,
-0.49998992681503296,
-0.1843111515045166,
0.012084893882274628,
-0.22507762908935547,
0.16442683339118958,
0.2805958390235901,
-0.5342935919761658,
0.05447069928050041,
-0.9122326970100403,
0.7350045442581177,
0.26226118206977844,
0.43507638573646545,
0.02745835855603218,
-0.26164916157722473,
-0.12013338506221771,
-0.15735873579978943,
-0.32901763916015625,
-0.7345255613327026,
0.4466240704059601,
-0.07120261341333389,
0.6456782221794128,
0.6945802569389343,
0.2681138813495636,
0.8094287514686584,
-0.37327027320861816,
0.47257131338119507,
0.5350012183189392,
-1.1558218002319336,
0.7176007032394409,
-0.3956928849220276,
-0.06017933040857315,
0.6718661189079285,
0.16223788261413574,
-0.6888546347618103,
-0.7575017213821411,
-0.3068956434726715,
-1.1284799575805664,
0.29264742136001587,
0.15707992017269135,
0.3990069031715393,
-0.1568755805492401,
0.3549339473247528,
0.15115457773208618,
0.062153033912181854,
-0.6341769099235535,
-0.09377704560756683,
-0.04713920131325722,
-0.029871640726923943,
0.0596071258187294,
-0.20456410944461823,
-0.4049575626850128,
-0.01541284378618002,
0.4534187316894531,
0.004225738346576691,
0.2738998234272003,
0.12967897951602936,
-0.2735968232154846,
-0.04088667035102844,
0.06520098447799683,
0.585260272026062,
0.23594734072685242,
-0.22272244095802307,
-0.0666310265660286,
0.11393970996141434,
-0.8114096522331238,
0.43820032477378845,
-0.11199542880058289,
-0.09257278591394424,
-0.309020459651947,
0.4827488660812378,
0.7486498951911926,
0.11677996069192886,
-1.2519652843475342,
0.40753254294395447,
-0.09709244966506958,
-0.03785661980509758,
-0.5186748504638672,
0.2028558850288391,
-0.40263429284095764,
0.33561134338378906,
0.5740278363227844,
0.21039219200611115,
0.05658796429634094,
-0.3274257481098175,
0.1288215070962906,
0.5695824027061462,
-0.2725383937358856,
0.005794262047857046,
0.6372360587120056,
0.2558732032775879,
-0.5882599353790283,
0.8492765426635742,
-0.0062009370885789394,
-0.3687134385108948,
0.4598827362060547,
0.5388792753219604,
1.3369823694229126,
-0.0011028724256902933,
-0.17303220927715302,
0.2961937189102173,
0.4744119942188263,
-0.13586971163749695,
0.23518779873847961,
-0.2574578523635864,
-1.058896541595459,
-0.18970589339733124,
-0.6229881048202515,
-0.5231431722640991,
-0.09479593485593796,
-0.727226734161377,
0.34560883045196533,
-0.8339779376983643,
-0.29595810174942017,
-0.5901729464530945,
-0.2472468465566635,
-0.2691676914691925,
-0.13552212715148926,
0.4027642607688904,
1.202260136604309,
-0.45810654759407043,
0.6638668179512024,
0.15906688570976257,
0.003449768526479602,
-0.8833436965942383,
-0.05921163409948349,
0.2646002173423767,
-1.237501859664917,
0.27579832077026367,
0.2676808536052704,
-0.3605388104915619,
-0.1491195410490036,
-0.6276074051856995,
-0.7319778800010681,
0.715146541595459,
0.3846278786659241,
-0.9553602337837219,
0.08811210095882416,
0.06332981586456299,
0.3117011487483978,
-0.22129195928573608,
-0.0635494589805603,
0.9210995435714722,
0.6831660866737366,
-0.20100292563438416,
-0.6025254130363464,
0.156962051987648,
-0.38336271047592163,
0.08779294788837433,
0.2292758673429489,
-0.7189099192619324,
0.5173801779747009,
-0.7252988815307617,
-0.05514264106750488,
0.16466882824897766,
0.28574037551879883,
0.9061335921287537,
0.1742829531431198,
0.7006422877311707,
0.8059359192848206,
0.6994453072547913,
0.10747097432613373,
1.3471930027008057,
-0.6526602506637573,
0.2926873564720154,
0.804720938205719,
-0.3868429362773895,
0.6430330276489258,
0.9279849529266357,
0.037150997668504715,
0.4417371451854706,
0.5807633399963379,
-0.053400155156850815,
0.6568869352340698,
0.38375458121299744,
-0.395052433013916,
-0.11338800191879272,
0.04898250848054886,
-0.173722043633461,
0.36576956510543823,
0.4002896845340729,
-0.1880529671907425,
0.09446442872285843,
0.4627615213394165,
0.37779974937438965,
-0.030279064550995827,
-0.3937460482120514,
0.7439882159233093,
0.2484261393547058,
-0.6218735575675964,
0.9331533908843994,
-0.0028605125844478607,
0.8376135230064392,
-0.7444453835487366,
0.3930996060371399,
-0.5789000391960144,
0.248881995677948,
-0.061160918325185776,
-0.5274470448493958,
0.10664751380681992,
0.3982483148574829,
0.3061208426952362,
-0.5774499177932739,
0.7500205636024475,
0.27777573466300964,
-0.44476377964019775,
0.5670459866523743,
0.22743530571460724,
-0.09278877824544907,
0.022811904549598694,
-0.7293872833251953,
0.6273642778396606,
0.048922259360551834,
-0.5473192930221558,
0.3865228593349457,
0.06487549096345901,
0.028359051793813705,
1.0759145021438599,
0.8545334935188293,
0.223134383559227,
-0.02448701299726963,
0.04393351823091507,
1.1093418598175049,
-0.8986360430717468,
-0.7144763469696045,
-1.083374261856079,
0.364292174577713,
-0.0766226053237915,
-0.23564434051513672,
0.8236254453659058,
0.6109338998794556,
0.444051057100296,
-0.013086685910820961,
0.8823801875114441,
0.01745302602648735,
0.19398058950901031,
-0.5067207217216492,
0.48984473943710327,
-0.18807877600193024,
0.6798136234283447,
-0.41574379801750183,
-0.9765559434890747,
-0.27372899651527405,
0.5345907211303711,
-0.24145282804965973,
-0.32306405901908875,
0.5081650614738464,
1.0276525020599365,
0.37408098578453064,
-0.08473213762044907,
0.15441912412643433,
0.3657234013080597,
0.3715327978134155,
0.661076009273529,
1.0193979740142822,
0.14548379182815552,
0.4916326105594635,
-0.41928526759147644,
-0.5428979396820068,
-0.29446902871131897,
-0.7168681621551514,
-0.6195029616355896,
-0.16354656219482422,
0.0702061802148819,
-0.4499860405921936,
0.1307733952999115,
1.0662373304367065,
0.6436559557914734,
-0.5405505299568176,
-0.593059241771698,
-0.3802844285964966,
0.30213281512260437,
-0.3343675136566162,
-0.23551583290100098,
-0.011720660142600536,
-0.6237170100212097,
-0.4717889428138733,
0.6260051131248474,
0.5166836977005005,
0.040571022778749466,
-0.19646991789340973,
-0.24151958525180817,
0.34078261256217957,
0.5030862092971802,
0.4938197135925293,
0.5490350127220154,
-0.6556719541549683,
-0.19071818888187408,
-0.07594835013151169,
-0.11566194146871567,
-0.10741603374481201,
1.2459542751312256,
-0.7156923413276672,
0.43630021810531616,
0.15180377662181854,
0.49236100912094116,
0.4879210591316223,
0.0789501965045929,
0.4491311013698578,
-0.6003025770187378,
0.6013250350952148,
0.5460922718048096,
0.35715174674987793,
-0.03660469874739647,
-0.4920463562011719,
0.26760926842689514,
0.09582238644361496,
-0.29364946484565735,
-1.175573468208313,
0.2804107069969177,
-1.0709835290908813,
-0.5265370607376099,
0.9143568873405457,
0.06965137273073196,
-0.4018283784389496,
-0.0738501325249672,
-0.3267149329185486,
-0.05164714902639389,
-0.49877119064331055,
1.1760714054107666,
0.24192024767398834,
-0.47342512011528015,
-0.13246731460094452,
-0.0588252954185009,
0.268373042345047,
0.24230210483074188,
-0.4932042062282562,
0.16144698858261108,
0.29832834005355835,
0.12437474727630615,
0.03895476087927818,
0.7083207368850708,
-0.1777898520231247,
0.21823790669441223,
0.2862309515476227,
0.21651646494865417,
-0.1951066553592682,
0.09819769114255905,
-0.42364737391471863,
0.43634697794914246,
0.11197324842214584,
-0.07607127726078033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05457v1 | It's Never Too Late: Fusing Acoustic Information into Large Language Models for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2024-02-08T07:21:45 | 2024-02-08T07:21:45 | Chen Chen, Ruizhe Li, Yuchen Hu, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi, Pin-Yu Chen, Ensiong Chng, Chao-Han Huck Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent studies have successfully shown that large language models (LLMs) can
be successfully used for generative error correction (GER) on top of the
automatic speech recognition (ASR) output. Specifically, an LLM is utilized to
carry out a direct mapping from the N-best hypotheses list generated by an ASR
system to the predicted output transcription. However, despite its
effectiveness, GER introduces extra data uncertainty since the LLM is trained
without taking into account acoustic information available in the speech
signal. In this work, we aim to overcome such a limitation by infusing acoustic
information before generating the predicted transcription through a novel late
fusion solution termed Uncertainty-Aware Dynamic Fusion (UADF). UADF is a
multimodal fusion approach implemented into an auto-regressive decoding process
and works in two stages: (i) It first analyzes and calibrates the token-level
LLM decision, and (ii) it then dynamically assimilates the information from the
acoustic modality. Experimental evidence collected from various ASR tasks shows
that UADF surpasses existing fusion mechanisms in several ways. It yields
significant improvements in word error rate (WER) while mitigating data
uncertainty issues in LLM and addressing the poor generalization relied with
sole modality during fusion. We also demonstrate that UADF seamlessly adapts to
audio-visual speech recognition. | [
-0.28146591782569885,
-0.7712569832801819,
0.44558092951774597,
0.12938034534454346,
-0.18488387763500214,
0.3291865885257721,
-0.1449308842420578,
-0.5380025506019592,
-0.19146722555160522,
0.2370210438966751,
-0.3704855740070343,
-0.2633790671825409,
-0.39171740412712097,
-0.02443649247288704,
-0.4923953413963318,
0.5252346396446228,
-0.03424476459622383,
0.09451699256896973,
-0.19592739641666412,
-0.0644344612956047,
-0.19602568447589874,
-0.3265206217765808,
-0.6964643597602844,
-0.48260512948036194,
0.386481374502182,
0.1666254997253418,
0.6425275206565857,
0.8732808828353882,
0.38731810450553894,
0.374865859746933,
-0.05033739656209946,
0.14911043643951416,
-0.2760835587978363,
0.08030359447002411,
0.16578109562397003,
-0.4060010313987732,
-0.5688324570655823,
-0.25881296396255493,
1.0680551528930664,
0.8744372129440308,
-0.4283970296382904,
-0.13914501667022705,
0.0665721446275711,
0.3537769019603729,
-0.5399622917175293,
0.19352813065052032,
-0.6098507046699524,
0.12589262425899506,
-0.3765069842338562,
-0.2427738606929779,
-0.24522821605205536,
-0.18407396972179413,
-0.024448364973068237,
-0.4928302764892578,
0.12156559526920319,
-0.12802079319953918,
0.5519523620605469,
0.7021692395210266,
-0.38010162115097046,
-0.10350547730922699,
-1.3305189609527588,
0.8710384368896484,
-0.7556992173194885,
0.7888334393501282,
0.37753915786743164,
0.49615293741226196,
-0.5089845061302185,
-0.4743865132331848,
-0.9362171292304993,
0.18516193330287933,
0.26309719681739807,
0.116469606757164,
-0.4309728145599365,
0.2703937292098999,
0.15267202258110046,
0.3823128342628479,
-0.493757039308548,
0.2339203953742981,
-0.12807752192020416,
-0.5731377601623535,
0.5806535482406616,
-0.05308545380830765,
0.22897833585739136,
0.02589293196797371,
-0.1636420488357544,
-0.417695015668869,
-0.4647026062011719,
-0.06096113845705986,
0.292094349861145,
0.2587767541408539,
-0.3606870174407959,
0.5106303691864014,
-0.021703854203224182,
0.9346708059310913,
0.2981903553009033,
-0.4434024393558502,
0.2953833043575287,
-0.39113059639930725,
-0.18449804186820984,
0.5158377289772034,
0.9026077389717102,
0.061518751084804535,
-0.2990659773349762,
0.007463831454515457,
-0.44355201721191406,
0.330676794052124,
-0.18975915014743805,
-0.30835554003715515,
-0.1383775919675827,
0.43002644181251526,
-0.14342135190963745,
-0.11554985493421555,
-0.10030033439397812,
-0.7153562307357788,
-0.3358517587184906,
-0.12962965667247772,
0.6647998690605164,
-0.27484336495399475,
-0.2740330994129181,
0.18660923838615417,
0.09783869981765747,
0.18819661438465118,
0.32495397329330444,
-0.6387647986412048,
-0.047540392726659775,
0.31978240609169006,
0.6778759956359863,
0.07651287317276001,
-0.2393231838941574,
-0.9590751528739929,
0.5149025321006775,
-0.3768180012702942,
0.8428863883018494,
-0.4212348461151123,
-0.5534934401512146,
-0.1819094568490982,
-0.36519211530685425,
-0.013165600597858429,
-0.3865746855735779,
0.5244140028953552,
-0.42480337619781494,
0.10338390618562698,
0.06869134306907654,
-0.5168458223342896,
-0.019658152014017105,
-0.15599878132343292,
-0.852724552154541,
0.663360595703125,
0.09058215469121933,
-0.5176349878311157,
0.3671517074108124,
-0.4416898787021637,
-0.5259841084480286,
-0.01792795956134796,
-0.39747151732444763,
-0.6114909052848816,
0.005067178513854742,
0.30690914392471313,
0.34364259243011475,
-0.10156775265932083,
0.23945635557174683,
-0.3297475576400757,
-0.33794859051704407,
0.25830402970314026,
-0.7386972308158875,
0.4492952525615692,
0.25566336512565613,
-0.31094956398010254,
-0.05448126792907715,
-0.9834271669387817,
-0.0012608296237885952,
-0.10633444786071777,
-0.6748617887496948,
-0.01991662196815014,
-0.15159332752227783,
-0.04030551388859749,
0.14586801826953888,
0.1695386916399002,
-0.5356498956680298,
-0.018002374097704887,
-0.5613831877708435,
0.3979107737541199,
0.6617659330368042,
-0.21300160884857178,
0.6367542147636414,
-0.38928118348121643,
0.4767937958240509,
-0.2456943839788437,
0.026761041954159737,
-0.12806282937526703,
-0.23383565247058868,
-0.7938436269760132,
-0.1841815710067749,
0.3282356858253479,
0.610529363155365,
-0.9361622333526611,
0.6997663378715515,
-0.14885076880455017,
-0.7377718687057495,
-0.6342783570289612,
0.17260044813156128,
0.436021089553833,
0.5609831809997559,
0.20898744463920593,
-0.31155380606651306,
-0.6839010119438171,
-0.4847900867462158,
-0.039911601692438126,
-0.5234141945838928,
0.038451340049505234,
0.32518652081489563,
-0.17421892285346985,
-0.4630005359649658,
0.8860316276550293,
-0.25869089365005493,
-0.6817218661308289,
-0.34576255083084106,
0.39823582768440247,
0.27740344405174255,
0.5858187675476074,
0.19426333904266357,
-0.8241310715675354,
-0.19651632010936737,
0.0674760565161705,
-0.68785160779953,
-0.15004271268844604,
-0.33049726486206055,
0.19834204018115997,
0.27878043055534363,
0.4945620596408844,
-0.5541830062866211,
0.1855831891298294,
0.9283804893493652,
-0.07913293689489365,
0.22037388384342194,
-0.4013335108757019,
0.08125914633274078,
-0.8755127787590027,
-0.11147111654281616,
-0.240465447306633,
-0.08855217695236206,
-0.5191596746444702,
-0.48573774099349976,
-0.08040962368249893,
-0.16409949958324432,
-0.4340539872646332,
0.5017322897911072,
-0.593997597694397,
-0.22653242945671082,
-0.3675934076309204,
-0.11060430854558945,
-0.10417262464761734,
0.11977336555719376,
-0.0933111235499382,
0.7443683743476868,
0.621567964553833,
-0.5651484131813049,
0.6975797414779663,
0.1935356855392456,
-0.2567265033721924,
0.30809471011161804,
-0.5262061953544617,
0.20192642509937286,
-0.16245973110198975,
0.5568700432777405,
-1.0164039134979248,
-0.5477088093757629,
0.07805491983890533,
-0.5440704226493835,
0.6475396156311035,
-0.04895209148526192,
-0.3816453218460083,
-0.48235777020454407,
0.11856882274150848,
0.7767367959022522,
0.42313721776008606,
-0.41891634464263916,
1.2271167039871216,
0.5876826047897339,
-0.3560256063938141,
-0.4651434123516083,
-0.8012343645095825,
0.09835512936115265,
-0.12001433968544006,
-0.7101155519485474,
0.4557724893093109,
-0.2183731496334076,
-0.17021740972995758,
-0.05608325079083443,
-0.10325577855110168,
-0.0807231143116951,
-0.1585787534713745,
0.17813868820667267,
0.16492465138435364,
-0.04993182420730591,
0.142729714512825,
0.05267278850078583,
-0.3131360411643982,
-0.26017245650291443,
-0.16424231231212616,
0.733042299747467,
-0.14232023060321808,
-0.6332977414131165,
-0.5512503981590271,
0.301832914352417,
0.6841121315956116,
-0.2942938506603241,
0.34246373176574707,
0.9714192748069763,
-0.6098985075950623,
-0.044931650161743164,
-0.8529514670372009,
-0.11939398944377899,
-0.49074509739875793,
0.2096012830734253,
-0.05662977695465088,
-0.6660260558128357,
0.4936698079109192,
0.12538516521453857,
-0.07280929386615753,
0.46277859807014465,
0.469409704208374,
-0.3473154604434967,
1.0636824369430542,
0.7407351136207581,
-0.17325137555599213,
0.5960783362388611,
-0.3103102743625641,
0.19497723877429962,
-0.5389591455459595,
-0.29703930020332336,
-0.3057233393192291,
-0.13024437427520752,
-0.34220799803733826,
-0.6607098579406738,
0.6974990963935852,
-0.26839518547058105,
0.21742212772369385,
0.03175784647464752,
-0.10008790343999863,
0.27619993686676025,
0.49804767966270447,
0.011043282225728035,
0.1639997661113739,
0.0267412718385458,
0.018212243914604187,
0.0361141711473465,
-0.9201738238334656,
-0.0552617684006691,
0.9878497123718262,
0.2740863561630249,
1.1302422285079956,
-0.07179329544305801,
0.7249999642372131,
0.33240246772766113,
-0.3010319769382477,
-0.6254042387008667,
0.37169426679611206,
-0.15297360718250275,
-0.12155703455209732,
-0.6708154082298279,
-0.5557019114494324,
-0.7931930422782898,
-0.015475969761610031,
-0.4595721364021301,
-0.1455916315317154,
0.3183091878890991,
0.5551953315734863,
-0.9345608949661255,
0.35945677757263184,
-0.586815357208252,
0.41076236963272095,
-0.47783222794532776,
-0.20767024159431458,
-0.1320195496082306,
-0.7615077495574951,
0.10079435259103775,
-0.5432620048522949,
0.50938481092453,
-0.0018329746089875698,
0.019212985411286354,
0.9394318461418152,
-0.21415996551513672,
0.7063324451446533,
-0.1840560883283615,
-0.3527851700782776,
0.21114163100719452,
-0.13547897338867188,
0.6806341409683228,
-0.25175052881240845,
-0.08995365351438522,
0.11521132290363312,
-0.2681989371776581,
-0.05406813696026802,
-0.540034830570221,
0.7534782290458679,
-0.6407615542411804,
-0.397775262594223,
-0.6215293407440186,
-0.7515051960945129,
-0.3221866488456726,
0.20574212074279785,
0.30174940824508667,
0.6335753798484802,
0.0002690788824111223,
0.12553933262825012,
0.8106503486633301,
-0.10983098298311234,
0.5919817686080933,
0.4164917469024658,
0.15056055784225464,
-0.5485864877700806,
1.060063362121582,
0.21752771735191345,
0.2739846110343933,
0.3995960056781769,
0.3057206869125366,
-0.47255077958106995,
-0.7120817303657532,
-0.4700617492198944,
0.39388537406921387,
-0.5491924285888672,
-0.2283550500869751,
-0.8431733846664429,
-0.25614458322525024,
-0.4699125289916992,
-0.15330074727535248,
-0.592113196849823,
-0.239543154835701,
-0.5266594886779785,
0.10508143156766891,
0.3137598931789398,
0.47078534960746765,
-0.5889967679977417,
0.410262793302536,
-1.1190537214279175,
0.42665767669677734,
0.4077868163585663,
0.267932653427124,
-0.24901536107063293,
-0.42577773332595825,
-0.1950228363275528,
0.2308570146560669,
0.033445388078689575,
-0.5846561789512634,
0.3145920932292938,
0.6452524065971375,
0.6894893646240234,
0.40434572100639343,
0.17452697455883026,
0.7657533884048462,
-0.36992964148521423,
0.6518919467926025,
0.3642718195915222,
-0.9447760581970215,
0.6315879821777344,
-0.4031783640384674,
0.5505943894386292,
0.1814020276069641,
-0.002843509428203106,
-0.44716745615005493,
-0.5109836459159851,
-0.5612040162086487,
-0.9822933077812195,
0.45018306374549866,
0.03876176476478577,
-0.04414089024066925,
0.46076181530952454,
-0.07453644275665283,
-0.05079016834497452,
0.09730847179889679,
-0.24394731223583221,
-0.04917532950639725,
-0.06754177808761597,
-0.287777304649353,
-0.359273761510849,
-0.2367594689130783,
-0.15505445003509521,
-0.2103189080953598,
0.5972871780395508,
-0.13499264419078827,
0.3801972270011902,
-0.0046570864506065845,
-0.04984656348824501,
-0.6508543491363525,
0.2994270920753479,
0.5200482606887817,
0.47896715998649597,
-0.15224172174930573,
0.09636387974023819,
0.24412792921066284,
-0.41464415192604065,
0.39052000641822815,
0.531213104724884,
0.17657646536827087,
0.043200183659791946,
0.6035590767860413,
0.7281610369682312,
0.3872658610343933,
-0.779024600982666,
0.5002164244651794,
-0.11933424323797226,
0.12845489382743835,
-0.5526216626167297,
0.06608828902244568,
-0.059030681848526,
0.48132234811782837,
0.5493897795677185,
0.22870148718357086,
0.07840918004512787,
-0.41480791568756104,
0.48673900961875916,
0.39973655343055725,
-0.2921278476715088,
-0.220182865858078,
0.7612016797065735,
0.18446099758148193,
-0.09481833130121231,
0.3961588740348816,
0.11575324833393097,
-0.464498907327652,
0.236885666847229,
0.46398645639419556,
0.7179449796676636,
-0.851813793182373,
-0.14059089124202728,
-0.011875631287693977,
-0.049078576266765594,
0.004922336433082819,
0.3505678176879883,
-0.09671002626419067,
-0.6854435801506042,
-0.6211032867431641,
-0.7580154538154602,
-0.29284730553627014,
0.05872226506471634,
-0.5188062191009521,
0.2810916006565094,
-0.33886194229125977,
-0.25749218463897705,
-0.05791764333844185,
-0.32677987217903137,
-0.591323733329773,
0.45247790217399597,
0.2676394581794739,
0.45204633474349976,
-0.9138618111610413,
0.8091983795166016,
0.45036229491233826,
-0.16668379306793213,
-0.9169519543647766,
0.03899889066815376,
0.1907867193222046,
-0.7386631965637207,
0.27908650040626526,
-0.2827823758125305,
-0.4187151789665222,
0.10708429664373398,
-0.24882903695106506,
-1.1022721529006958,
1.114764928817749,
0.5886951088905334,
-0.8566238284111023,
-0.26911622285842896,
0.11885558813810349,
0.30584341287612915,
-0.07219715416431427,
-0.1949557065963745,
0.5869912505149841,
0.44128572940826416,
0.7124848365783691,
-1.2680658102035522,
-0.41466930508613586,
-0.12802176177501678,
-0.243621826171875,
0.28588923811912537,
-0.39177432656288147,
0.8791738748550415,
-0.5315876603126526,
-0.33237290382385254,
-0.11692386120557785,
0.8050259947776794,
0.1591690480709076,
0.23618610203266144,
0.8268436193466187,
0.5444096922874451,
0.8712899088859558,
-0.1385205090045929,
0.8843538165092468,
-0.08870730549097061,
-0.030849827453494072,
1.000684142112732,
-0.13691812753677368,
0.8613340258598328,
0.527079164981842,
-0.1158159002661705,
-0.012193425558507442,
0.5797825455665588,
0.010368569754064083,
0.6008704304695129,
-0.08007484674453735,
-0.4756593108177185,
-0.4369232654571533,
-0.35372206568717957,
-0.6200598478317261,
0.879687488079071,
0.44610700011253357,
-0.14505477249622345,
-0.18656094372272491,
0.3639489412307739,
-0.13379491865634918,
-0.020022260025143623,
-0.25282707810401917,
0.9453996419906616,
0.1311056762933731,
-0.15276150405406952,
0.7200400233268738,
-0.2750486433506012,
0.7155318260192871,
-0.6556471586227417,
-0.18200233578681946,
0.030486468225717545,
0.3440622091293335,
-0.22951434552669525,
-0.6687933802604675,
0.26043158769607544,
-0.1783980280160904,
-0.1883149892091751,
-0.17003193497657776,
0.7013315558433533,
-0.9339390993118286,
-0.7136755585670471,
0.23682677745819092,
0.3522995412349701,
-0.010670991614460945,
0.06459686160087585,
-0.3367214798927307,
0.6731095314025879,
-0.004394582938402891,
0.2856419086456299,
0.0864172950387001,
0.12035063654184341,
0.22808992862701416,
0.8374142646789551,
0.8258944153785706,
0.5457579493522644,
0.04541151598095894,
0.0342128649353981,
0.9278703927993774,
-0.3625742495059967,
-0.662269651889801,
-0.6145818829536438,
0.45838239789009094,
0.29982224106788635,
0.1296982616186142,
0.5476698875427246,
0.4109764099121094,
0.8034763336181641,
0.16145853698253632,
0.9594011902809143,
0.2831156551837921,
0.5180627107620239,
-0.7384814023971558,
0.9537760019302368,
-0.7043191194534302,
0.2522914409637451,
-0.5049315094947815,
-0.8331172466278076,
-0.5319564938545227,
0.6286836266517639,
-0.047783106565475464,
0.09055352210998535,
0.2900438606739044,
0.7623589634895325,
0.05153142288327217,
-0.1424126923084259,
0.5228859186172485,
0.2684480845928192,
0.5280938148498535,
0.6120437383651733,
0.6865971088409424,
-0.4573710560798645,
0.798565685749054,
-0.2880237400531769,
-0.2664724290370941,
-0.3092536926269531,
-0.8596389889717102,
-0.3089336156845093,
-0.7652766704559326,
-0.33118078112602234,
-0.39094460010528564,
0.029949987307190895,
0.9100733399391174,
0.5898474454879761,
-0.6447542309761047,
-0.2187599390745163,
0.24522510170936584,
-0.06571388989686966,
-0.1422746628522873,
-0.07796990126371384,
0.412663072347641,
0.09297040849924088,
-0.730751097202301,
0.8486118316650391,
0.29188257455825806,
0.7263766527175903,
-0.2821010947227478,
-0.24518907070159912,
0.023530125617980957,
0.006558945868164301,
0.33423805236816406,
0.4174664616584778,
-0.7438486814498901,
-0.24707038700580597,
-0.18970538675785065,
0.04053931310772896,
-0.06113073602318764,
0.5857827663421631,
-0.7837980389595032,
0.9454731345176697,
0.35672253370285034,
0.7343273162841797,
0.26502594351768494,
-0.2811945974826813,
1.0786216259002686,
-0.4870927631855011,
0.1774277687072754,
0.47427669167518616,
0.4729117453098297,
0.7231041789054871,
-0.39680829644203186,
0.10325151681900024,
0.2882750630378723,
-0.4370097517967224,
-1.0020095109939575,
0.16464023292064667,
-1.1090925931930542,
0.22323337197303772,
1.1464470624923706,
0.1392248123884201,
-0.24305644631385803,
-0.2324516922235489,
-0.17895859479904175,
0.6251888275146484,
-0.5175706744194031,
0.7478047013282776,
0.5088191032409668,
-0.09057600796222687,
-0.2597601115703583,
0.07090358436107635,
0.6432469487190247,
0.12383189052343369,
-0.614989161491394,
0.011911504901945591,
0.6423501372337341,
-0.1783280074596405,
0.30874672532081604,
0.5591727495193481,
0.019404903054237366,
0.6224117279052734,
0.08124420791864395,
-0.1062515527009964,
-0.17109191417694092,
-0.4544007182121277,
-0.5755125284194946,
0.022200942039489746,
0.1836734414100647,
-0.20344379544258118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05455v1 | Large Language Models for Psycholinguistic Plausibility Pretesting | 2024-02-08T07:20:02 | 2024-02-08T07:20:02 | Samuel Joseph Amouyal, Aya Meltzer-Asscher, Jonathan Berant | cs.CL | cs.CL | In psycholinguistics, the creation of controlled materials is crucial to
ensure that research outcomes are solely attributed to the intended
manipulations and not influenced by extraneous factors. To achieve this,
psycholinguists typically pretest linguistic materials, where a common pretest
is to solicit plausibility judgments from human evaluators on specific
sentences. In this work, we investigate whether Language Models (LMs) can be
used to generate these plausibility judgements. We investigate a wide range of
LMs across multiple linguistic structures and evaluate whether their
plausibility judgements correlate with human judgements. We find that GPT-4
plausibility judgements highly correlate with human judgements across the
structures we examine, whereas other LMs correlate well with humans on commonly
used syntactic structures. We then test whether this correlation implies that
LMs can be used instead of humans for pretesting. We find that when
coarse-grained plausibility judgements are needed, this works well, but when
fine-grained judgements are necessary, even GPT-4 does not provide satisfactory
discriminative power. | [
-0.2370169460773468,
-0.9228540062904358,
0.8766565322875977,
0.4006091356277466,
-0.1388021856546402,
-0.17313624918460846,
-0.5292447209358215,
-0.6033927798271179,
-0.1034928411245346,
0.3079231083393097,
-0.17660072445869446,
-0.2697140574455261,
-0.3039773404598236,
0.24046453833580017,
-0.46069180965423584,
1.1586838960647583,
-0.1325831562280655,
0.02617439068853855,
-0.0946846529841423,
0.14945071935653687,
-0.2866502106189728,
-0.9876989126205444,
-0.2272752970457077,
-0.47973713278770447,
0.6113397479057312,
-0.10016237944364548,
0.9230632185935974,
0.05019180476665497,
0.5703682899475098,
0.31141161918640137,
0.11664075404405594,
-0.4499235153198242,
-0.29085683822631836,
-0.08705190569162369,
-0.37516626715660095,
-0.5555777549743652,
-0.8947531580924988,
0.25022798776626587,
0.4389720857143402,
0.9239219427108765,
-0.29931122064590454,
-0.0005201190942898393,
0.29544708132743835,
0.02086448110640049,
-0.4722353518009186,
0.18267153203487396,
-0.48067235946655273,
0.06149525195360184,
-0.29775315523147583,
-0.2037769854068756,
-0.5557001233100891,
-0.5289918184280396,
0.3230140209197998,
-0.47979381680488586,
0.3531908392906189,
0.1096167042851448,
0.9009655117988586,
-0.04538384824991226,
-0.33574673533439636,
-0.5022934079170227,
-0.8559471964836121,
0.5991603136062622,
-0.966624915599823,
0.536137044429779,
0.8970209360122681,
0.21578457951545715,
-0.1303817629814148,
-0.8509694337844849,
-0.685033917427063,
-0.9367795586585999,
-0.2912684381008148,
0.007410481106489897,
0.036819297820329666,
0.2563718855381012,
0.3332424461841583,
0.419027179479599,
-0.6967209577560425,
0.14461345970630646,
-0.2532069981098175,
-0.45838239789009094,
0.5332015156745911,
0.05235568434000015,
0.2831723690032959,
-0.057901669293642044,
-0.20613929629325867,
-0.15203867852687836,
-0.6226376295089722,
-0.06680469214916229,
0.6858291029930115,
0.31867730617523193,
-0.08369031548500061,
0.5627822279930115,
0.25689616799354553,
0.6146401166915894,
-0.10747413337230682,
-0.3106051981449127,
0.29382428526878357,
-0.6637691855430603,
-0.1906973421573639,
-0.18152816593647003,
0.8681615591049194,
0.26230719685554504,
0.5506872534751892,
-0.2169943004846573,
-0.30661532282829285,
0.22182774543762207,
0.21519918739795685,
-0.7927908897399902,
-0.5064170956611633,
0.060905735939741135,
-0.4453659653663635,
-0.14793457090854645,
-0.10916876792907715,
-0.607673168182373,
-0.3150375783443451,
-0.27644848823547363,
0.6018872857093811,
-0.48266714811325073,
-0.5406388640403748,
0.3122289180755615,
0.0766211599111557,
0.18014782667160034,
0.011564685963094234,
-0.6669623255729675,
0.486819326877594,
0.4092712700366974,
0.6611254215240479,
-0.05086062476038933,
-0.6067475080490112,
-0.23622001707553864,
-0.18880003690719604,
-0.433225154876709,
0.7772180438041687,
-0.5519506335258484,
-0.2845429480075836,
-0.23934267461299896,
0.08515136688947678,
-0.040403712540864944,
-0.5413029193878174,
0.8055083751678467,
-0.3407306373119354,
0.45146018266677856,
-0.1674511581659317,
-0.649303138256073,
-0.0788230448961258,
0.11714689433574677,
-0.6380194425582886,
0.5972306728363037,
0.1962256133556366,
-0.5678802132606506,
0.3468452990055084,
-0.6244982481002808,
-0.5750555992126465,
0.204653799533844,
-0.2814180254936218,
-0.4837822914123535,
0.2045869678258896,
-0.3378157615661621,
0.4224350154399872,
-0.3502119183540344,
0.7293777465820312,
-0.5446252226829529,
-0.3143836259841919,
0.4920004606246948,
-0.5528342127799988,
0.594957172870636,
0.13349676132202148,
-0.4309173822402954,
0.11813534796237946,
-0.43519601225852966,
0.042593736201524734,
0.23790434002876282,
-0.4262608289718628,
-0.32081738114356995,
0.13516132533550262,
0.199855774641037,
0.29745298624038696,
0.15157689154148102,
-0.28039422631263733,
-0.15164202451705933,
-0.39536112546920776,
0.27869102358818054,
0.6246026754379272,
-0.26149171590805054,
0.21007460355758667,
-0.37162989377975464,
0.724720299243927,
-0.1914253681898117,
-0.06408392637968063,
0.05065691098570824,
-0.36262327432632446,
-0.2928648591041565,
-0.3890981376171112,
0.2463316172361374,
0.34584102034568787,
-0.47374406456947327,
0.5435009598731995,
0.017404597252607346,
-0.42204004526138306,
-0.07543099671602249,
0.1511247307062149,
0.5639732480049133,
0.31359028816223145,
-0.03647489473223686,
-0.3586805760860443,
-0.6093603372573853,
-1.0022772550582886,
-0.5572876930236816,
-0.22763721644878387,
-0.3052595555782318,
0.12319264560937881,
0.5905844569206238,
0.061627596616744995,
0.9515347480773926,
-0.4651075005531311,
-0.15151554346084595,
-0.3010776937007904,
0.16504864394664764,
0.15841442346572876,
0.10582764446735382,
0.8486621379852295,
-0.7875849008560181,
-0.10633955150842667,
-0.3469181954860687,
-0.7203345894813538,
-0.31765061616897583,
0.1336301863193512,
0.3134852349758148,
0.1268955022096634,
0.3475685119628906,
-0.5559146404266357,
0.3867202401161194,
0.6584530472755432,
-0.592390775680542,
1.0659942626953125,
-0.4152522087097168,
-0.03921065106987953,
-0.7420922517776489,
0.1426299810409546,
0.03266030550003052,
-0.2877209782600403,
-0.6168733239173889,
0.16678959131240845,
-0.03771333396434784,
-0.05666748806834221,
-0.25861436128616333,
0.5532766580581665,
-0.36409714818000793,
-0.18041177093982697,
-0.05610640347003937,
0.13765272498130798,
-0.007138045504689217,
0.29945701360702515,
0.17735953629016876,
0.5713642239570618,
0.3415077328681946,
-0.5839479565620422,
0.03936879336833954,
-0.030477019026875496,
-0.715744137763977,
0.369547575712204,
-0.7483476996421814,
0.1499389111995697,
-0.008162040263414383,
0.48508545756340027,
-0.906395435333252,
-0.3921453356742859,
-0.10107400268316269,
-0.09971285611391068,
-0.07711456716060638,
0.23411902785301208,
-0.6981448531150818,
-0.37793678045272827,
-0.07524361461400986,
0.45925575494766235,
0.473520964384079,
-0.061719637364149094,
0.4519179165363312,
0.2452773004770279,
-0.6031807065010071,
-0.04450532793998718,
-0.5420072078704834,
0.01529985386878252,
-0.474185973405838,
-0.328046977519989,
-0.026058176532387733,
-0.548444390296936,
-0.5361944437026978,
-0.2777235805988312,
0.18947744369506836,
-0.14792084693908691,
0.2933524250984192,
0.28901034593582153,
0.3375377058982849,
-0.4374062716960907,
0.09557520598173141,
-0.4276984930038452,
0.026885991916060448,
0.15482299029827118,
0.08502169698476791,
0.7559969425201416,
-0.3374679684638977,
-0.592318594455719,
-0.29738649725914,
0.27007871866226196,
0.5225842595100403,
-0.3123565912246704,
0.44539037346839905,
0.4157538115978241,
-0.4134120047092438,
0.06283571571111679,
-0.5788469910621643,
-0.40798574686050415,
-0.4393802583217621,
0.6256105899810791,
-0.6632202863693237,
-0.694829523563385,
0.49027571082115173,
0.02617521770298481,
-0.19155950844287872,
0.14372190833091736,
0.9069457054138184,
0.017185769975185394,
0.9168493747711182,
0.4056870639324188,
0.2308979332447052,
0.43899211287498474,
0.15473441779613495,
0.6658930778503418,
-0.3145369291305542,
0.19655324518680573,
-0.4680066704750061,
-0.12076092511415482,
-0.5559566020965576,
-0.28266462683677673,
0.1809428483247757,
0.16599440574645996,
-0.1474069207906723,
0.177525594830513,
-0.04873286187648773,
0.618828535079956,
0.2375946342945099,
0.08177175372838974,
0.3790648579597473,
-0.1315852403640747,
-0.17478856444358826,
-0.09562794864177704,
-0.26955974102020264,
-0.7381293177604675,
1.0424960851669312,
0.4269449710845947,
0.5918033719062805,
0.24579907953739166,
0.26265013217926025,
0.001959142740815878,
0.6294807195663452,
-0.6601805686950684,
0.5640586018562317,
-0.2119050920009613,
-0.8823506832122803,
-0.318312406539917,
-0.3218816816806793,
-0.9532471299171448,
0.1426108181476593,
-0.15467841923236847,
-0.8371981382369995,
0.02107950486242771,
0.16212314367294312,
-0.49155959486961365,
0.12157490849494934,
-1.0512152910232544,
0.8018652200698853,
-0.4092918932437897,
-0.16334837675094604,
-0.12651488184928894,
-0.4688742756843567,
0.5372133851051331,
-0.5801644921302795,
0.3991639316082001,
-0.13347341120243073,
0.3587639033794403,
0.8070445656776428,
-0.23194098472595215,
0.8905491232872009,
-0.08192644268274307,
-0.4295380413532257,
0.10979236662387848,
0.3109803795814514,
0.2456091195344925,
-0.264242947101593,
-0.2972927987575531,
0.03078223392367363,
0.22886250913143158,
-0.3119041621685028,
-0.5040884613990784,
0.5077307820320129,
-0.6608737707138062,
-0.6510799527168274,
-0.266781210899353,
-0.7435979247093201,
-0.2680959105491638,
0.3558264970779419,
0.1942485272884369,
0.4087001085281372,
-0.3825795352458954,
0.22499969601631165,
0.08497440069913864,
-0.29337117075920105,
0.2149537205696106,
0.7897400259971619,
-0.46019822359085083,
0.05098995566368103,
0.8351250290870667,
0.10035175830125809,
0.4021514058113098,
-0.10377223789691925,
0.6320734620094299,
-0.41151461005210876,
-0.7421937584877014,
0.24292832612991333,
0.26145368814468384,
-0.4879577159881592,
0.14115433394908905,
-0.1990232616662979,
-0.17720362544059753,
-0.4953041970729828,
-0.02392791025340557,
-0.15940029919147491,
-0.003715463448315859,
0.2436034381389618,
-0.27568715810775757,
0.021962827071547508,
0.9051573872566223,
0.03387884795665741,
0.24759896099567413,
-0.503532350063324,
0.4814918041229248,
0.15118753910064697,
0.42090296745300293,
-0.03575742244720459,
-0.4932962656021118,
0.0487556979060173,
0.12555308640003204,
-0.30358028411865234,
-0.8713176250457764,
0.35869988799095154,
0.22742749750614166,
0.5001742839813232,
0.36390256881713867,
0.06843950599431992,
0.5588465929031372,
-0.5966412425041199,
0.7145560383796692,
0.22675515711307526,
-0.956531822681427,
0.30803367495536804,
-0.5867905020713806,
-0.1060670018196106,
0.3844221830368042,
0.4664468765258789,
-0.06575334817171097,
-0.5837011337280273,
-0.5806165933609009,
-0.8087491989135742,
0.43681707978248596,
0.1681656688451767,
0.04082660749554634,
0.05378653109073639,
0.2681625485420227,
0.3270655870437622,
0.09363185614347458,
-0.7952014207839966,
0.2399328202009201,
-0.10869718343019485,
-0.2868924140930176,
-0.6818663477897644,
-0.20210109651088715,
-0.11442528665065765,
-0.17030848562717438,
0.09353179484605789,
-0.03636898100376129,
-0.08073881268501282,
0.16086047887802124,
-0.19954094290733337,
0.05822059139609337,
0.5176101326942444,
0.7873659133911133,
1.0254039764404297,
-0.5024304986000061,
0.2741933763027191,
0.09503140300512314,
-0.5931950807571411,
0.2591068744659424,
0.18144072592258453,
0.14763596653938293,
-0.21778590977191925,
0.5496312379837036,
0.7859327793121338,
0.3121073246002197,
-0.6776219010353088,
0.6894392967224121,
-0.2778041958808899,
-0.2794870436191559,
-0.47717466950416565,
-0.14328087866306305,
0.21294090151786804,
0.22597558796405792,
0.1844681352376938,
-0.1570301502943039,
0.04884111136198044,
-0.9375149011611938,
0.2721335291862488,
0.26865366101264954,
0.2619768977165222,
-0.8353985548019409,
0.5216057300567627,
0.07717633247375488,
-0.646446943283081,
0.42823296785354614,
-0.31683504581451416,
-0.5631133317947388,
0.310202956199646,
0.8048151731491089,
0.6496089100837708,
-0.49762773513793945,
0.11382665485143661,
0.02522449381649494,
0.09989836812019348,
-0.3036540746688843,
0.17744888365268707,
0.14125598967075348,
-0.9357175230979919,
-0.5681151747703552,
-0.8130292296409607,
-0.4845304489135742,
0.4520017206668854,
-0.6374500393867493,
0.21756047010421753,
-0.30628448724746704,
-0.31268689036369324,
0.1339230239391327,
-0.0334656797349453,
-0.8914040327072144,
0.17027992010116577,
0.26639822125434875,
0.6343809366226196,
-1.2305073738098145,
0.8171095848083496,
0.594836413860321,
-0.43016889691352844,
-1.0610655546188354,
0.1624482125043869,
-0.15169604122638702,
-0.5812397599220276,
0.6892725825309753,
-0.07206042855978012,
0.0158237274736166,
-0.13362687826156616,
-0.386892169713974,
-0.5415021181106567,
0.959462583065033,
0.8912389874458313,
-0.5666061043739319,
-0.4741637110710144,
0.1224963366985321,
0.7247485518455505,
-0.1357908546924591,
0.5011301040649414,
0.7610809206962585,
0.6096826791763306,
-0.09621787816286087,
-1.4983314275741577,
0.18968063592910767,
-0.0890132263302803,
-0.30368873476982117,
-0.081433966755867,
-0.2656468451023102,
1.0869529247283936,
-0.18861037492752075,
-0.06237768009305,
0.0919450893998146,
0.301165908575058,
0.6723095774650574,
0.3040265142917633,
0.7939354181289673,
0.3369300365447998,
0.9305073618888855,
0.13266882300376892,
1.375913381576538,
-0.2386411726474762,
0.340347021818161,
1.4539053440093994,
-0.7254056334495544,
1.0154231786727905,
0.43343183398246765,
-0.38814833760261536,
0.5657550096511841,
0.586065411567688,
0.23076371848583221,
0.320182204246521,
0.3965279459953308,
-0.06778736412525177,
-0.3146306872367859,
-0.06410089135169983,
-0.25847819447517395,
0.6880869269371033,
0.32793518900871277,
-0.331754207611084,
-0.35497888922691345,
0.05257268622517586,
0.03775503486394882,
-0.0362282395362854,
0.056913550943136215,
0.4723641276359558,
0.34449484944343567,
-0.7176791429519653,
0.5640389323234558,
-0.23527447879314423,
0.596164882183075,
-0.842404842376709,
0.1847045123577118,
-0.07626151293516159,
0.5026057362556458,
-0.2494928389787674,
-0.7552881836891174,
0.3803800940513611,
0.07772265374660492,
0.05690477043390274,
-0.2249346673488617,
0.7374337315559387,
-0.3747110068798065,
-0.4235861003398895,
0.5186834931373596,
0.7270203232765198,
0.5389508008956909,
-0.24534153938293457,
-0.3308342397212982,
-0.11558651179075241,
-0.2777545154094696,
-0.5661640167236328,
0.6592690944671631,
0.3219996988773346,
-0.29028505086898804,
0.4570878744125366,
0.8026736974716187,
0.3782687783241272,
-0.15782763063907623,
0.36208149790763855,
0.6320310831069946,
-0.6279672980308533,
-0.573979377746582,
-0.9831008911132812,
0.19145824015140533,
0.22423113882541656,
-0.1282496303319931,
0.8645209670066833,
0.41945138573646545,
0.6006914377212524,
-0.09557776898145676,
0.7966656684875488,
0.10457606613636017,
0.29335856437683105,
-0.4905886948108673,
0.8693692684173584,
-0.24887916445732117,
0.07115035504102707,
-0.428923636674881,
-0.9418100714683533,
-0.20847363770008087,
0.7489352822303772,
-0.6441295146942139,
0.312458872795105,
0.9941489696502686,
0.7858399152755737,
-0.1418953537940979,
0.05339963734149933,
0.6685239672660828,
0.6441972851753235,
0.3323170244693756,
0.6386401653289795,
0.9225974678993225,
0.04790604114532471,
0.40684637427330017,
0.14757139980793,
-0.20640602707862854,
-0.017366742715239525,
-0.9956148266792297,
-0.9575616717338562,
-0.6237629652023315,
-0.15509819984436035,
-0.28286442160606384,
-0.09780887514352798,
0.7709522247314453,
0.6281154155731201,
-0.7093405723571777,
-0.30933481454849243,
0.004782806150615215,
-0.18438050150871277,
0.13117237389087677,
-0.27379199862480164,
0.39342451095581055,
0.008124888874590397,
-0.44850873947143555,
0.37965190410614014,
-0.04984090477228165,
0.25605013966560364,
-0.34069713950157166,
-0.1702275276184082,
0.0045751770958304405,
0.12202457338571548,
0.5888628959655762,
0.025834757834672928,
-0.960536777973175,
-0.5044699907302856,
-0.12316516786813736,
0.06114424392580986,
-0.1465563327074051,
0.9932222962379456,
-0.7412121295928955,
0.06232055276632309,
0.5138426423072815,
0.24355760216712952,
0.1600557118654251,
-0.028333010151982307,
0.9349545240402222,
-0.7066119313240051,
0.3024846911430359,
0.3518809974193573,
0.5906836986541748,
0.2935452461242676,
0.004172641318291426,
0.33910807967185974,
0.059739090502262115,
-0.6311025619506836,
-1.1086002588272095,
0.3361874520778656,
-0.7803142070770264,
-0.21766452491283417,
1.092934250831604,
-0.5002782940864563,
-0.028166357427835464,
-0.30772197246551514,
-0.19804364442825317,
0.062057241797447205,
0.0693167895078659,
0.585601806640625,
1.0402308702468872,
-0.12063777446746826,
-0.09330251812934875,
-0.716269850730896,
0.5222139954566956,
0.5624648928642273,
-0.8484578728675842,
0.14361689984798431,
0.21347589790821075,
0.6559557914733887,
0.40111055970191956,
0.9149980545043945,
-0.03157823532819748,
0.09043955057859421,
-0.08094329386949539,
-0.005785678047686815,
0.18298636376857758,
-0.05072476342320442,
-0.30967992544174194,
0.2574608623981476,
0.37541455030441284,
0.28449124097824097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05445v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05445v2 | Accurate LoRA-Finetuning Quantization of LLMs via Information Retention | 2024-02-08T06:53:31 | 2024-05-27T09:20:35 | Haotong Qin, Xudong Ma, Xingyu Zheng, Xiaoyang Li, Yang Zhang, Shouda Liu, Jie Luo, Xianglong Liu, Michele Magno | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The LoRA-finetuning quantization of LLMs has been extensively studied to
obtain accurate yet compact LLMs for deployment on resource-constrained
hardware. However, existing methods cause the quantized LLM to severely degrade
and even fail to benefit from the finetuning of LoRA. This paper proposes a
novel IR-QLoRA for pushing quantized LLMs with LoRA to be highly accurate
through information retention. The proposed IR-QLoRA mainly relies on two
technologies derived from the perspective of unified information: (1)
statistics-based Information Calibration Quantization allows the quantized
parameters of LLM to retain original information accurately; (2)
finetuning-based Information Elastic Connection makes LoRA utilizes elastic
representation transformation with diverse information. Comprehensive
experiments show that IR-QLoRA can significantly improve accuracy across LLaMA
and LLaMA2 families under 2-4 bit-widths, e.g., 4- bit LLaMA-7B achieves 1.4%
improvement on MMLU compared with the state-of-the-art methods. The significant
performance gain requires only a tiny 0.31% additional time consumption,
revealing the satisfactory efficiency of our IR-QLoRA. We highlight that
IR-QLoRA enjoys excellent versatility, compatible with various frameworks
(e.g., NormalFloat and Integer quantization) and brings general accuracy gains.
The code is available at https://github.com/htqin/ir-qlora. | [
-0.3887983560562134,
-0.6248986721038818,
0.3881504237651825,
0.06921403855085373,
-0.5673502087593079,
0.20722275972366333,
-0.19100764393806458,
-0.38383805751800537,
0.1750856637954712,
0.11865458637475967,
-0.2100716233253479,
-0.5533648729324341,
-0.0575653612613678,
-0.11707678437232971,
-0.16846953332424164,
0.7784264087677002,
-0.08025453984737396,
-0.00899504218250513,
0.2417650818824768,
-0.6835566759109497,
-0.4325111210346222,
-0.26984816789627075,
-0.1306886523962021,
-0.5110654234886169,
0.8581786751747131,
0.554473876953125,
0.7651153802871704,
0.6528754830360413,
0.6614347100257874,
0.19388121366500854,
-0.11364096403121948,
0.40019360184669495,
-0.5403681993484497,
-0.004071736708283424,
0.12553325295448303,
-0.7308562994003296,
-0.5412657260894775,
-0.3232472836971283,
0.8866088390350342,
0.24766279757022858,
-0.44997793436050415,
0.5807505249977112,
0.04787478223443031,
1.2571640014648438,
-0.8699815273284912,
-0.11694319546222687,
-0.6783570647239685,
0.10944179445505142,
-0.40605172514915466,
-0.5958881378173828,
-0.33086851239204407,
-0.5897427797317505,
-0.1365097612142563,
-0.7931855916976929,
-0.15976177155971527,
0.09313085675239563,
0.860072135925293,
0.4569942355155945,
-0.6022414565086365,
0.16253061592578888,
-1.0584274530410767,
0.709713339805603,
-0.6168321967124939,
0.5205667614936829,
0.2357291877269745,
0.5105672478675842,
0.06820599734783173,
-0.6150828003883362,
-0.24938960373401642,
0.07427965849637985,
0.3203268051147461,
0.1966325044631958,
-0.17172527313232422,
0.1936282068490982,
0.047755222767591476,
0.34168586134910583,
-0.4320726692676544,
0.26872992515563965,
-0.4280427098274231,
0.05588236078619957,
0.1807580143213272,
-0.053157988935709,
-0.30124932527542114,
0.21121177077293396,
-0.7986018657684326,
-0.17387279868125916,
-1.1272399425506592,
-0.07016950845718384,
0.38780495524406433,
0.10659915208816528,
-0.10472895950078964,
0.4758859872817993,
-0.11081492900848389,
0.408869206905365,
0.13980159163475037,
-0.31256967782974243,
0.12404967099428177,
0.02060610055923462,
-0.22985707223415375,
0.174931600689888,
0.553756594657898,
0.3535657525062561,
-0.05194472521543503,
0.1364767700433731,
-0.2958059310913086,
-0.01377398706972599,
-0.16390538215637207,
-0.9456548690795898,
0.022676613181829453,
0.2962898910045624,
-0.4002741873264313,
-0.03652075305581093,
0.16441325843334198,
-0.6169843077659607,
-0.14587169885635376,
-0.2722119390964508,
0.5973857641220093,
-0.39315035939216614,
0.031628698110580444,
0.11678467690944672,
0.17405462265014648,
0.19373546540737152,
0.4517784118652344,
-0.7163596153259277,
-0.020145738497376442,
0.6100205183029175,
0.7480976581573486,
0.026965700089931488,
0.23886454105377197,
-0.46827346086502075,
0.30707404017448425,
-0.2287510335445404,
0.8020387291908264,
0.13834863901138306,
0.23830623924732208,
-0.13315536081790924,
-0.4615080654621124,
0.4105452001094818,
-0.6492773294448853,
0.24119026958942413,
-0.9078100919723511,
-0.13508884608745575,
0.0762903168797493,
-0.33224862813949585,
-0.206821471452713,
0.21992698311805725,
-0.8067260384559631,
0.7684202194213867,
0.25559109449386597,
-0.4733019173145294,
0.0921994298696518,
-0.28250157833099365,
0.28407570719718933,
0.03128940239548683,
-0.30147430300712585,
-0.5926927924156189,
0.09037625789642334,
-0.13216808438301086,
-0.066970095038414,
-0.6343467831611633,
0.33080580830574036,
-0.3214966654777527,
-0.8472023606300354,
0.520044207572937,
-0.8841644525527954,
0.46246933937072754,
0.5323123335838318,
-0.3083703815937042,
-0.17558202147483826,
-0.8810017704963684,
0.42743194103240967,
-0.21238678693771362,
-0.6409294605255127,
-0.304413378238678,
-0.3796410858631134,
-0.03873752802610397,
-0.18968465924263,
0.5176463723182678,
-0.5351871848106384,
0.20670872926712036,
-0.16056686639785767,
0.384660929441452,
0.8571395874023438,
-0.2021487057209015,
0.4145464599132538,
-0.5179442167282104,
0.5078698396682739,
-0.13904139399528503,
0.3585933744907379,
0.014234479516744614,
-0.10165179520845413,
-0.6417779922485352,
-0.3009999692440033,
0.6759283542633057,
0.6028637290000916,
-0.6889095902442932,
0.43847042322158813,
-0.41571104526519775,
-0.5454273819923401,
-0.324651300907135,
0.19220541417598724,
0.35833030939102173,
0.2589539885520935,
0.26827937364578247,
-0.1662193089723587,
-0.4418160915374756,
-0.5550926923751831,
0.0013727121986448765,
-0.1865932196378708,
-0.107744500041008,
-0.07886876165866852,
0.03382651135325432,
-0.42185401916503906,
1.020626187324524,
-0.29565727710723877,
-0.8065273761749268,
0.19925028085708618,
0.16036900877952576,
0.41870442032814026,
0.7039339542388916,
0.39101091027259827,
-0.7636895179748535,
-0.2690112590789795,
0.2240782231092453,
-0.6719963550567627,
-0.05466520041227341,
-0.04214223846793175,
-0.24462106823921204,
0.17058134078979492,
-0.030496500432491302,
-0.36038023233413696,
0.5525688529014587,
0.7021083235740662,
-0.32930988073349,
0.3310374915599823,
-0.3480726480484009,
0.21569088101387024,
-0.8985691070556641,
0.09864423424005508,
0.1629568636417389,
-0.3622850179672241,
-0.42824020981788635,
0.12131959944963455,
0.3249450623989105,
0.2300937920808792,
-0.6989144682884216,
0.35715344548225403,
-0.41841328144073486,
-0.08317705988883972,
-0.09788742661476135,
0.09783869981765747,
0.17723287642002106,
0.5635190606117249,
-0.5567147135734558,
0.8669623136520386,
-0.17109252512454987,
-0.4436948001384735,
0.3118024170398712,
-0.028403904289007187,
-0.13343559205532074,
0.8109299540519714,
-0.48755520582199097,
0.0722467228770256,
-0.1863599419593811,
0.1610482782125473,
-0.5767821669578552,
0.10528549551963806,
0.02103988267481327,
-0.12080242484807968,
0.1116369217634201,
-0.32433342933654785,
-0.5744798183441162,
-0.01997646503150463,
-0.6508272886276245,
0.8017497658729553,
0.8398381471633911,
-0.6104891896247864,
0.6367301344871521,
0.10589120537042618,
0.1773270070552826,
-0.5017216205596924,
-0.9297698140144348,
-0.2619856595993042,
-0.5174674391746521,
-0.4854850471019745,
0.4542759656906128,
-0.26798421144485474,
-0.2968820631504059,
-0.17499218881130219,
-0.3403821885585785,
-0.3279327154159546,
-0.01235252059996128,
0.06826604902744293,
0.3562573492527008,
-0.42193934321403503,
0.41797617077827454,
-0.08479215949773788,
-0.19211281836032867,
-0.3259110152721405,
-0.3000793159008026,
0.48563510179519653,
-0.46023625135421753,
-0.3620799779891968,
-0.8544362783432007,
0.11031113564968109,
0.44863951206207275,
0.052574072033166885,
0.5448387265205383,
0.7523261308670044,
-0.32959216833114624,
-0.0560653917491436,
-0.8480685353279114,
-0.18604564666748047,
-0.5532532930374146,
0.21644289791584015,
-0.3236973285675049,
-0.8384104371070862,
0.715366542339325,
-0.1541343480348587,
-0.07935512065887451,
0.339008629322052,
-0.10030825436115265,
-0.5393550395965576,
0.827974259853363,
0.5088074803352356,
-0.05292142182588577,
0.7869182229042053,
-0.5863279104232788,
-0.060385994613170624,
-0.7832493185997009,
0.10312588512897491,
-0.346540242433548,
-0.4084131717681885,
-0.47444963455200195,
-0.30384358763694763,
0.7995201945304871,
0.3432570993900299,
-0.7032049894332886,
-0.02961602620780468,
-0.5202784538269043,
0.3995409309864044,
0.6143262386322021,
0.37902870774269104,
0.5900554656982422,
0.5030407905578613,
0.42447587847709656,
-0.1126207485795021,
-0.7661718726158142,
-0.571998119354248,
0.9682448506355286,
0.3715292811393738,
1.3782730102539062,
0.22663836181163788,
0.6606460213661194,
0.474357545375824,
0.13671976327896118,
-0.4303610324859619,
0.29570314288139343,
-0.22740022838115692,
-0.04210016131401062,
-0.3143868148326874,
-0.6912608742713928,
-0.8261476159095764,
0.18849729001522064,
-0.020426791161298752,
-0.523817777633667,
0.3288225829601288,
0.5373584628105164,
-0.605472981929779,
0.6382052302360535,
-0.5688858032226562,
0.2306981086730957,
-0.26405033469200134,
-0.38172024488449097,
-0.22832216322422028,
-0.542063295841217,
0.21372483670711517,
-0.1778292953968048,
0.039938777685165405,
-0.3247969448566437,
-0.1719944328069687,
0.7756707668304443,
-0.7269557118415833,
0.5653071403503418,
-0.17653247714042664,
-0.6369553804397583,
0.52916419506073,
-0.0004041101783514023,
0.6225154399871826,
0.05961441248655319,
-0.21319857239723206,
0.12921154499053955,
0.16257181763648987,
-0.3918941915035248,
-0.8792376518249512,
0.6389353275299072,
-0.6063094139099121,
-0.27418529987335205,
-0.2754158675670624,
-0.4721430540084839,
0.08163562417030334,
0.13321757316589355,
0.08212290704250336,
0.5747822523117065,
0.09733935445547104,
0.41835927963256836,
0.8248694539070129,
0.19716298580169678,
0.07650378346443176,
0.5681271553039551,
0.08287495374679565,
-0.8613221049308777,
1.2606927156448364,
0.3177771270275116,
0.41436222195625305,
0.47233888506889343,
0.2761368751525879,
-0.17401745915412903,
-0.5095080137252808,
-0.46047836542129517,
0.3608073592185974,
-0.592197060585022,
-0.8390836715698242,
0.006820776034146547,
-0.07143256813287735,
0.050232209265232086,
-0.19202372431755066,
-0.6578595638275146,
-0.5636482834815979,
-0.5679129958152771,
0.2137805074453354,
0.7719250917434692,
0.5289742946624756,
-0.28340384364128113,
0.7113946080207825,
-0.8720923066139221,
0.3387404680252075,
0.2782037556171417,
0.4745016098022461,
-0.12988246977329254,
-0.5112860202789307,
-0.267473429441452,
0.488511860370636,
-0.2949807643890381,
-0.5594554543495178,
0.226737841963768,
0.37873831391334534,
-0.08105418086051941,
0.5545111298561096,
0.31352901458740234,
0.9805787205696106,
-0.011873438954353333,
0.3137584328651428,
0.3172644078731537,
-0.7633435726165771,
0.6244060397148132,
-0.2865920066833496,
0.5163440108299255,
0.8014358878135681,
-0.07481265068054199,
-0.30809488892555237,
-0.3048422932624817,
-0.3233712315559387,
-0.8494647741317749,
0.4666135907173157,
-0.043604929000139236,
-0.21825388073921204,
0.524720311164856,
0.4117427170276642,
0.062495771795511246,
0.17310182750225067,
-0.7239459156990051,
-0.5516411662101746,
0.13856911659240723,
-0.5216954350471497,
0.4270859360694885,
-0.4733019173145294,
-0.22414787113666534,
0.14925949275493622,
0.6792759895324707,
-0.5406937599182129,
0.550530195236206,
0.2541552484035492,
-0.10218455642461777,
-0.16145743429660797,
0.32108479738235474,
0.5332561731338501,
0.6603996753692627,
-0.5192917585372925,
0.3611968159675598,
0.2265550047159195,
-0.5544633865356445,
0.7107172608375549,
0.07690872997045517,
-0.4342743158340454,
-0.17688074707984924,
-0.10812482982873917,
0.5414851903915405,
0.1629793792963028,
-0.5923985242843628,
0.3656848967075348,
-0.04854873567819595,
0.021615108475089073,
-0.5867897272109985,
0.01998514123260975,
-0.3169417083263397,
0.5783258676528931,
0.8079996109008789,
0.09621868282556534,
-0.04748086631298065,
-0.45697057247161865,
0.04009958356618881,
0.3015700578689575,
-0.30082643032073975,
-0.2472684234380722,
0.6111339926719666,
0.06252321600914001,
0.025180598720908165,
0.2762760818004608,
-0.16261978447437286,
-0.1291310340166092,
0.6025460362434387,
0.48408856987953186,
0.5335178971290588,
-0.03761330619454384,
0.050108253955841064,
0.14687223732471466,
0.009509121999144554,
-0.21995489299297333,
0.5656938552856445,
-0.24854756891727448,
-0.5083549618721008,
-0.17767181992530823,
-0.3331697881221771,
-0.4132486581802368,
-0.292583167552948,
-0.8006861209869385,
-0.0020775680895894766,
-0.5135993361473083,
-0.45111143589019775,
-0.7155415415763855,
0.08975017815828323,
-0.49718019366264343,
0.036118678748607635,
0.02029077336192131,
0.7945308089256287,
-0.22285260260105133,
0.7787442803382874,
0.18378430604934692,
-0.19369925558567047,
-0.7567123174667358,
-0.4229291081428528,
-0.14619868993759155,
-0.6768242716789246,
0.6008186936378479,
0.02588723413646221,
-0.3349350094795227,
0.1879241168498993,
-0.4739091098308563,
-1.1783950328826904,
1.8514775037765503,
0.7013642191886902,
-0.9286715984344482,
0.13144831359386444,
0.19922514259815216,
0.3534451127052307,
0.030052877962589264,
0.28020691871643066,
0.502166748046875,
0.4862426519393921,
0.06490125507116318,
-0.7370235919952393,
-0.053830474615097046,
-0.031223520636558533,
0.09438753873109818,
0.206516295671463,
-1.071234107017517,
0.583324134349823,
-0.33835071325302124,
-0.5058399438858032,
0.576470136642456,
0.9809295535087585,
0.6486690640449524,
0.26458561420440674,
0.4814918637275696,
0.500874400138855,
1.0007766485214233,
-0.23342029750347137,
0.5639864802360535,
-0.2593899369239807,
0.5103868842124939,
0.8553338646888733,
-0.2215423583984375,
0.7942733764648438,
0.6688463687896729,
-0.1536051332950592,
0.40600237250328064,
0.3066549599170685,
0.17569367587566376,
0.47188177704811096,
0.26388445496559143,
-0.6005792617797852,
0.19583235681056976,
-0.3164558410644531,
-0.45803365111351013,
0.1981874257326126,
0.24645079672336578,
-0.049653444439172745,
-0.019217250868678093,
0.2418542355298996,
-0.08245284110307693,
-0.23727591335773468,
-0.41088059544563293,
0.422104150056839,
0.024835197255015373,
-0.4635879099369049,
1.034759759902954,
-0.17891323566436768,
1.0266376733779907,
-0.5963144302368164,
-0.2442382425069809,
-0.37212881445884705,
0.2460375726222992,
-0.32486391067504883,
-0.4817485511302948,
-0.20426541566848755,
-0.09826131910085678,
-0.003353383392095566,
-0.0736992135643959,
0.6403798460960388,
-0.6203071475028992,
-0.2757653594017029,
0.030830850824713707,
0.3214739263057709,
-0.024882016703486443,
0.12976858019828796,
-0.17724883556365967,
0.38717055320739746,
0.13321872055530548,
-0.12695056200027466,
0.37242892384529114,
0.4525626599788666,
0.06067871302366257,
0.867367148399353,
0.4418044090270996,
0.28537285327911377,
0.27903348207473755,
0.16042940318584442,
0.71866774559021,
-0.8023245334625244,
-0.38244158029556274,
-0.48950082063674927,
0.23283526301383972,
0.3780779242515564,
-0.2719555199146271,
0.37095072865486145,
0.3762022852897644,
0.5084598064422607,
0.15933088958263397,
0.29571467638015747,
0.1576225608587265,
0.13548709452152252,
-0.9216794967651367,
0.5219082236289978,
-0.4445335566997528,
0.4619201421737671,
0.07917468249797821,
-1.0814458131790161,
-0.4073612689971924,
0.6006707549095154,
0.2903284728527069,
0.07519517838954926,
0.559733510017395,
0.7841672301292419,
0.07216985523700714,
-0.17357048392295837,
0.4144129157066345,
0.14987118542194366,
0.39556482434272766,
0.7393490672111511,
0.7632263898849487,
-0.8645805716514587,
0.6429392695426941,
-0.41502901911735535,
-0.20103608071804047,
-0.3721190094947815,
-0.7103474736213684,
-0.13761764764785767,
-0.31971636414527893,
-0.5387217998504639,
-0.08307044953107834,
0.2490750551223755,
0.8799948692321777,
0.8177921175956726,
-0.4754285514354706,
-0.1926587074995041,
0.014692757278680801,
0.10193638503551483,
-0.015995772555470467,
-0.2801746129989624,
0.32680949568748474,
-0.07721711695194244,
-0.43276676535606384,
0.2163018137216568,
0.23421069979667664,
0.6189015507698059,
-0.41794317960739136,
-0.2503541111946106,
0.04154869541525841,
-0.1786753237247467,
0.4213053286075592,
0.583076000213623,
-0.5973163843154907,
-0.3294576406478882,
-0.22370530664920807,
-0.3102383613586426,
0.4042304754257202,
0.4614257216453552,
-1.0290015935897827,
0.1409388929605484,
0.3015545606613159,
0.4729005694389343,
0.39586156606674194,
0.2036302387714386,
0.40276962518692017,
-0.6355735659599304,
0.22802984714508057,
0.18824122846126556,
0.3046010136604309,
0.12642143666744232,
-0.45565181970596313,
0.7264047861099243,
-0.07916408032178879,
-0.7973988652229309,
-0.8653931021690369,
-0.0849715992808342,
-1.1732542514801025,
0.33768630027770996,
1.032933235168457,
-0.13965828716754913,
-0.5025349259376526,
0.296682208776474,
-0.3428652584552765,
0.19924180209636688,
-0.61655592918396,
0.6601262092590332,
-0.23294208943843842,
0.025304581969976425,
-0.10863009095191956,
-0.21886123716831207,
0.1811666339635849,
0.5267098546028137,
-0.5803425312042236,
-0.1471889466047287,
0.38373419642448425,
-0.004663941450417042,
0.26716774702072144,
0.5632387399673462,
-0.012145654298365116,
0.6297699213027954,
-0.4094903767108917,
0.31638166308403015,
-0.07101850211620331,
-0.22525982558727264,
-0.6193907856941223,
0.24876905977725983,
0.3412010371685028,
-0.2915247678756714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05440v1 | Improving Agent Interactions in Virtual Environments with Language Models | 2024-02-08T06:34:11 | 2024-02-08T06:34:11 | Jack Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enhancing AI systems with efficient communication skills for effective human
assistance necessitates proactive initiatives from the system side to discern
specific circumstances and interact aptly. This research focuses on a
collective building assignment in the Minecraft dataset, employing language
modeling to enhance task understanding through state-of-the-art methods. These
models focus on grounding multi-modal understanding and task-oriented dialogue
comprehension tasks, providing insights into their interpretative and
responsive capabilities. Our experimental results showcase a substantial
improvement over existing methods, indicating a promising direction for future
research in this domain. | [
-0.39427465200424194,
-1.1847295761108398,
0.5441972017288208,
0.06316940486431122,
0.2078590989112854,
0.3469190299510956,
-0.22589942812919617,
-0.6443055868148804,
-0.2549145817756653,
0.3306097984313965,
-0.5996435880661011,
-0.2889694571495056,
-0.4674127697944641,
0.004439937882125378,
-0.019431499764323235,
0.5926279425621033,
0.039477281272411346,
-0.1562747061252594,
-0.6778038144111633,
-0.15287576615810394,
-0.8103721737861633,
-0.6093923449516296,
-0.7163485884666443,
-0.454518586397171,
0.2662583291530609,
0.27405813336372375,
1.077235460281372,
0.8265330195426941,
0.3750259280204773,
0.581064760684967,
0.06402165442705154,
0.2530985176563263,
-0.5348227024078369,
0.2350282520055771,
-0.36868026852607727,
-0.3599582016468048,
-0.5850294828414917,
-0.16721592843532562,
0.19451436400413513,
0.6404635310173035,
-0.12363924086093903,
0.13306204974651337,
-0.079645536839962,
0.10100244730710983,
-0.2955819070339203,
0.8461293578147888,
-0.55731201171875,
-0.2585190534591675,
0.2512935996055603,
0.0553152933716774,
-0.3442818522453308,
0.317333847284317,
0.2843915820121765,
-0.9079340696334839,
0.23906053602695465,
0.1401139348745346,
0.552798867225647,
0.3127371072769165,
-0.2414025366306305,
-0.15551777184009552,
-0.49574124813079834,
0.7561485767364502,
-0.6967597603797913,
0.36632558703422546,
0.5791633129119873,
0.16237705945968628,
-0.32878610491752625,
-0.39601805806159973,
-0.6583740711212158,
-0.4083271622657776,
-0.015444248914718628,
0.10755616426467896,
-0.23600032925605774,
0.399585485458374,
0.17367102205753326,
-0.06597700715065002,
-0.3164236843585968,
0.02288961410522461,
-0.3940373659133911,
-0.2277945876121521,
0.6604409217834473,
0.4110369384288788,
0.7327066659927368,
-0.2154025286436081,
-0.02250373549759388,
0.012474685907363892,
-0.09454198181629181,
0.27422046661376953,
0.1270279884338379,
0.6491405367851257,
-0.21107451617717743,
0.618115246295929,
-0.1692357063293457,
0.9538564682006836,
-0.0878712460398674,
-0.04479494318366051,
0.06005854159593582,
-0.6979373693466187,
-0.44640976190567017,
-0.286931574344635,
0.09719307720661163,
0.4989769458770752,
0.207815483212471,
-0.40282154083251953,
-0.028913138434290886,
0.44882524013519287,
0.7422157526016235,
-0.3681398034095764,
-0.06709577888250351,
0.4428776502609253,
-0.5782690048217773,
-0.4757404923439026,
-0.0719856470823288,
-0.31778958439826965,
-0.6195410490036011,
-0.7938850522041321,
0.3936511278152466,
-0.2243090569972992,
-0.8997752070426941,
0.08087269216775894,
-0.48664391040802,
0.03873780369758606,
0.5673498511314392,
-0.5548257231712341,
0.6296005845069885,
0.747645378112793,
0.7701494693756104,
0.04798141494393349,
-0.45041128993034363,
-0.541873574256897,
0.28780463337898254,
-0.08639183640480042,
0.6722114682197571,
-0.817725658416748,
-0.5520870685577393,
-0.19779419898986816,
0.0012679630890488625,
-0.06732938438653946,
-0.5644082427024841,
0.11534925550222397,
-0.18031398952007294,
0.2740482687950134,
-0.040879037231206894,
-0.15974411368370056,
-0.2337295562028885,
0.4865177869796753,
-0.6399065852165222,
0.7903082966804504,
0.4414212107658386,
-0.3432641923427582,
-0.13721926510334015,
-0.9534669518470764,
-0.14822274446487427,
0.11434933543205261,
-0.007470343261957169,
0.06568154692649841,
0.39921414852142334,
0.18374814093112946,
0.33965930342674255,
-0.2131195217370987,
0.13633690774440765,
-0.1522037833929062,
-0.3694058656692505,
0.2229570746421814,
-0.0943853110074997,
0.620206892490387,
0.24346816539764404,
-0.34092220664024353,
0.5202847719192505,
-0.47441792488098145,
0.11760859936475754,
0.03968599811196327,
0.008467824198305607,
-0.46980902552604675,
0.13069652020931244,
0.1191936656832695,
0.32071736454963684,
0.13518105447292328,
-0.1887560784816742,
0.48621782660484314,
-0.43658530712127686,
0.117100790143013,
0.8709208369255066,
-0.2538328766822815,
0.5720918774604797,
-0.4044100046157837,
0.7610623836517334,
-0.006128751207143068,
0.058929186314344406,
-0.08987689018249512,
-0.33934521675109863,
-0.40237778425216675,
-0.33003824949264526,
-0.08220048993825912,
0.7243751883506775,
-1.097512125968933,
-0.05751952901482582,
-0.27224934101104736,
-0.31598904728889465,
-0.6356395483016968,
0.24183157086372375,
0.6836003065109253,
0.4483989179134369,
0.25279515981674194,
-0.4615881145000458,
-0.59511399269104,
-0.5385155081748962,
-0.04721531271934509,
-0.5438632965087891,
0.02479846589267254,
0.5872454047203064,
0.036923471838235855,
-0.3054768741130829,
1.0076119899749756,
-0.08339861035346985,
0.02982897125184536,
-0.6262261271476746,
0.16938400268554688,
0.0868983119726181,
0.33022746443748474,
0.40713536739349365,
-0.95113205909729,
-0.49207058548927307,
0.2791156470775604,
-0.9052980542182922,
-0.1977841556072235,
-0.22817696630954742,
-0.1855664700269699,
-0.026252731680870056,
0.4997382164001465,
-0.6220102310180664,
0.40081334114074707,
0.5665794014930725,
-0.6448130011558533,
0.42284122109413147,
-0.21474646031856537,
0.26677337288856506,
-1.1181570291519165,
-0.37364745140075684,
0.11020329594612122,
-0.37827932834625244,
-0.996059238910675,
0.255029559135437,
-0.266810804605484,
-0.12854668498039246,
-0.5340447425842285,
0.7268311381340027,
-0.8907288908958435,
0.07968420535326004,
-0.6428819298744202,
0.3554011881351471,
-0.19238846004009247,
0.5707078576087952,
0.14998283982276917,
0.8853995203971863,
0.7755232453346252,
-0.44614097476005554,
0.6681263446807861,
0.25290781259536743,
-0.1373329758644104,
0.7636892199516296,
-0.8489006757736206,
0.2746049761772156,
-0.39971357583999634,
0.031810399144887924,
-0.9174003005027771,
-0.22936585545539856,
0.26338991522789,
-0.506302535533905,
-0.140797957777977,
-0.27626579999923706,
-0.4635303318500519,
-0.4053809940814972,
-0.03290659561753273,
0.273354709148407,
0.22668717801570892,
-0.16698089241981506,
0.9317548871040344,
0.5452201962471008,
-0.19535785913467407,
-0.4972672462463379,
-0.3832240104675293,
0.057579535990953445,
-0.0989990159869194,
-0.6974703669548035,
0.17463594675064087,
-0.07130331546068192,
-0.9732301831245422,
0.13783374428749084,
-0.0742289125919342,
-0.4086058437824249,
0.350686252117157,
0.7128533124923706,
0.27874666452407837,
-0.16332386434078217,
0.3657757639884949,
-0.29092004895210266,
-0.027613913640379906,
0.09984014183282852,
-0.09422603994607925,
0.4742305278778076,
-0.15046413242816925,
-0.29949235916137695,
-0.5721086859703064,
0.4930359721183777,
0.7231171131134033,
-0.4418830871582031,
1.1034399271011353,
0.4234023690223694,
-0.43863117694854736,
-0.21123479306697845,
-0.5314863920211792,
-0.13577839732170105,
-0.5263576507568359,
0.5314276814460754,
-0.7666260600090027,
-0.7189288139343262,
0.638399064540863,
-0.2290690690279007,
0.0731385201215744,
0.13256360590457916,
0.5596297383308411,
-0.1329333633184433,
1.1261165142059326,
0.8087314963340759,
-0.29145169258117676,
0.6758723258972168,
-0.14002206921577454,
0.1717837005853653,
-0.6570478081703186,
-0.23850931227207184,
-0.3376618027687073,
-0.15766999125480652,
-0.2126912623643875,
-0.7548084259033203,
0.1878580003976822,
-0.06305794417858124,
0.14432746171951294,
0.5119292736053467,
-0.4455665051937103,
0.40984636545181274,
0.2610219419002533,
0.2605510652065277,
0.14100410044193268,
-0.04008982330560684,
0.2167772352695465,
0.2936297059059143,
-0.5485854148864746,
-0.5245860815048218,
0.7271530032157898,
0.1917385309934616,
0.5201322436332703,
0.44261521100997925,
0.3120430111885071,
0.5424947738647461,
0.40821516513824463,
-0.5585185289382935,
0.4434165060520172,
0.5796200633049011,
-0.6524945497512817,
-0.6231899857521057,
-0.2763177752494812,
-1.1968625783920288,
0.6720338463783264,
-0.28952792286872864,
-0.843772292137146,
-0.0818450003862381,
0.07369347661733627,
-0.23218120634555817,
-0.03476868197321892,
-1.0479135513305664,
1.1038460731506348,
-0.03983819857239723,
-0.42911815643310547,
-0.6400389671325684,
-0.4620080888271332,
-0.0582234226167202,
0.38417547941207886,
0.6150174140930176,
-0.23260271549224854,
0.12421886622905731,
-0.08646233379840851,
-0.3179343044757843,
1.0124303102493286,
-0.40542837977409363,
-0.0440659336745739,
0.48067906498908997,
0.16755668818950653,
0.728936493396759,
0.0026478799991309643,
-0.455873042345047,
-0.29218244552612305,
0.008414460346102715,
-0.7370126843452454,
-0.8367097973823547,
0.61641526222229,
-0.9814355373382568,
-0.802236020565033,
0.014379063621163368,
-1.0792744159698486,
-0.23009951412677765,
-0.12395741045475006,
-0.530613362789154,
0.6938042044639587,
-0.4338802993297577,
0.008129608817398548,
0.4103938043117523,
-0.021276842802762985,
0.4172954857349396,
0.5270400047302246,
-0.010513792745769024,
0.09701517969369888,
0.930110514163971,
-0.1143820658326149,
0.4192025661468506,
-0.043693531304597855,
-0.1609020084142685,
-0.16977110505104065,
-0.41096943616867065,
-0.40692073106765747,
-0.04838177561759949,
-0.5173391699790955,
0.030396729707717896,
-0.8511465191841125,
0.04907403886318207,
-0.727384626865387,
-0.3078029453754425,
-0.0749998688697815,
-0.29326972365379333,
-0.2128801792860031,
-0.4299466013908386,
0.17372195422649384,
0.9873698353767395,
0.040219586342573166,
0.45757901668548584,
-0.8622761368751526,
0.5034162998199463,
0.3127995431423187,
0.0986444503068924,
0.1668449491262436,
-0.21796496212482452,
-0.5067453384399414,
0.12473978847265244,
-0.08713571727275848,
-1.0888299942016602,
0.3390447795391083,
-0.09139639139175415,
1.2282601594924927,
-0.07503383606672287,
-0.029943374916911125,
0.7576894164085388,
-0.3054746687412262,
0.882437527179718,
-0.14910566806793213,
-1.1621545553207397,
0.6134753227233887,
-0.608919620513916,
0.609306275844574,
0.39186036586761475,
-0.05329194292426109,
-0.666307806968689,
-0.5442469120025635,
-0.7753435373306274,
-0.6494567394256592,
0.7510926127433777,
0.30294570326805115,
0.3971901834011078,
0.14750421047210693,
0.2948828339576721,
-0.14210282266139984,
0.3512709140777588,
-0.6157187819480896,
-0.16202202439308167,
-0.12403411418199539,
-0.34524446725845337,
-0.005753527861088514,
0.006466669496148825,
-0.22623656690120697,
-0.3193416893482208,
0.458051860332489,
-0.17376509308815002,
0.3426459729671478,
0.014264766126871109,
-0.4989040195941925,
-0.10033030807971954,
0.19778764247894287,
0.5609586834907532,
1.0945831537246704,
0.27736297249794006,
0.23147426545619965,
0.48199349641799927,
-0.17236937582492828,
0.18614645302295685,
0.05974150821566582,
0.4276321828365326,
-0.3055194914340973,
0.5161750912666321,
0.7712611556053162,
-0.29511594772338867,
-0.8794152140617371,
0.40515872836112976,
-0.13792961835861206,
0.12064139544963837,
-0.03702208772301674,
0.3923526406288147,
0.12385755032300949,
0.5702782273292542,
0.16161951422691345,
-0.033121977001428604,
0.1187114417552948,
-0.8338099122047424,
0.08646803349256516,
0.43721550703048706,
-0.4282931685447693,
-0.44653695821762085,
0.40340501070022583,
0.5067164301872253,
-0.6102498173713684,
0.7929003238677979,
-0.091917023062706,
-0.4457955062389374,
0.992571234703064,
0.6150153279304504,
0.6448531746864319,
-0.3379517197608948,
0.4449005722999573,
0.03687024861574173,
0.38739776611328125,
0.07753434032201767,
0.4498768448829651,
-0.22922305762767792,
-0.9051313400268555,
-0.5676800012588501,
-0.12940587103366852,
-0.5181758403778076,
-0.26338374614715576,
-0.3484211266040802,
-0.1428273320198059,
-0.24909737706184387,
-0.2091701626777649,
-0.2076423168182373,
0.0027867162134498358,
-0.9843897819519043,
0.1626909077167511,
0.277351975440979,
0.4383352994918823,
-0.882379949092865,
0.8998122215270996,
1.0526846647262573,
-0.34195804595947266,
-0.7431978583335876,
-0.196898952126503,
0.28517529368400574,
-0.4762604832649231,
0.5422793030738831,
0.04254046455025673,
-0.2988952696323395,
-0.008664130233228207,
-0.7317616939544678,
-0.7320870161056519,
0.898337185382843,
0.1751909852027893,
-0.13139933347702026,
-0.019210083410143852,
-0.021486900746822357,
0.9037124514579773,
-0.36206045746803284,
0.54649418592453,
0.2734474837779999,
0.6595446467399597,
-0.4700709283351898,
-1.3669887781143188,
0.07482655346393585,
-0.7001556754112244,
0.13776443898677826,
-0.05024731159210205,
-0.6696978807449341,
0.40545353293418884,
-0.10973062366247177,
-0.08854887634515762,
-0.060641128569841385,
0.9110865592956543,
0.13502103090286255,
0.4076744019985199,
0.8589619994163513,
0.12482486665248871,
0.7819254398345947,
0.03822125121951103,
1.23884117603302,
-0.19583261013031006,
0.038061052560806274,
1.1837759017944336,
-0.042613692581653595,
0.48392781615257263,
0.5050441026687622,
-0.015448168851435184,
0.5363593697547913,
0.46439260244369507,
0.3338034451007843,
0.3772212862968445,
0.49315735697746277,
-0.4767903685569763,
-0.4224795997142792,
-0.7335267066955566,
-0.17570844292640686,
0.4937865436077118,
0.49141475558280945,
0.056054554879665375,
0.09492755681276321,
0.44737130403518677,
-0.1384618878364563,
0.3430611193180084,
-0.2329430878162384,
0.9925602674484253,
-0.22117239236831665,
-0.6447821855545044,
0.11295913904905319,
-0.11906281858682632,
0.4106770157814026,
-0.23876307904720306,
-0.2767706513404846,
0.037066563963890076,
0.004197454545646906,
-0.1452103555202484,
-0.42173945903778076,
0.35135576128959656,
-0.15460403263568878,
-0.41142794489860535,
-0.511644184589386,
0.7046836614608765,
-0.5649732947349548,
-0.3447732925415039,
0.2871844470500946,
0.8891584277153015,
0.07517807930707932,
-0.2631577253341675,
-0.7086226344108582,
0.3400569260120392,
-0.1700480729341507,
-0.1793144941329956,
0.06108963489532471,
0.5284912586212158,
-0.25691157579421997,
0.7502803802490234,
0.6528244614601135,
-0.0852341502904892,
0.08747991919517517,
0.15191464126110077,
1.0241252183914185,
-0.42811980843544006,
-0.30952614545822144,
-0.6278682351112366,
0.9113085865974426,
-0.3320770859718323,
0.06863026320934296,
0.7916561961174011,
0.2476215362548828,
0.9077684879302979,
-0.14737586677074432,
0.922128438949585,
-0.2643614113330841,
0.30752047896385193,
-0.16280953586101532,
0.3049241900444031,
-0.4791610538959503,
0.022211773321032524,
-0.2061721682548523,
-0.853306233882904,
-0.09850466251373291,
0.7099177837371826,
-0.07759224623441696,
-0.15737417340278625,
0.31931617856025696,
0.8685758709907532,
-0.14861975610256195,
-0.21897205710411072,
0.503109335899353,
0.19507725536823273,
0.566619336605072,
0.25067803263664246,
1.0462466478347778,
-0.06911338865756989,
0.35234278440475464,
-0.13132071495056152,
-0.15742580592632294,
0.07136182487010956,
-0.520108699798584,
-1.154201626777649,
-0.6307769417762756,
-0.25371479988098145,
-0.2196909785270691,
0.38281339406967163,
1.266893982887268,
1.0228915214538574,
-0.6674568057060242,
-0.49832087755203247,
0.015205263160169125,
0.2266274392604828,
-0.7061404585838318,
-0.21571311354637146,
-0.14153166115283966,
-0.4705126881599426,
-1.038500428199768,
0.8941636085510254,
0.140201598405838,
-0.07177703082561493,
-0.26447632908821106,
-0.24575531482696533,
-0.14541061222553253,
0.20242153108119965,
0.6882701516151428,
0.08705238252878189,
-0.9664986729621887,
-0.44014355540275574,
0.17234137654304504,
-0.2560085952281952,
-0.11102461069822311,
0.8616080284118652,
-0.8765994310379028,
0.8722986578941345,
0.7432230710983276,
0.7678039073944092,
0.18942199647426605,
0.5594848990440369,
1.0069329738616943,
-0.7077867388725281,
0.39827457070350647,
-0.07457195967435837,
0.037548162043094635,
0.22428491711616516,
-0.6811496019363403,
0.6670383214950562,
0.1907157152891159,
-0.42231258749961853,
-0.6718204617500305,
-0.10540797561407089,
-0.9065840244293213,
-0.437823623418808,
0.9454542994499207,
-0.05734783038496971,
-0.18241773545742035,
-0.5745382308959961,
-0.7626780271530151,
0.3988488018512726,
-0.3139168918132782,
0.8258382678031921,
0.9982039928436279,
-0.1699947714805603,
-0.6381549835205078,
-0.7734321355819702,
0.2895672023296356,
0.5750710368156433,
-1.1858859062194824,
0.11955636739730835,
0.9792916774749756,
-0.15518738329410553,
0.11498088389635086,
0.7692103981971741,
0.4198865592479706,
0.23152172565460205,
-0.041637420654296875,
0.16774879395961761,
-0.4452036917209625,
-0.3933403789997101,
-0.10343064367771149,
0.1589275449514389,
0.08784027397632599,
-0.22337615489959717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05435v1 | GPT-4 Generated Narratives of Life Events using a Structured Narrative Prompt: A Validation Study | 2024-02-08T06:20:01 | 2024-02-08T06:20:01 | Christopher J. Lynch, Erik Jensen, Madison H. Munro, Virginia Zamponi, Joseph Martinez, Kevin O'Brien, Brandon Feldhaus, Katherine Smith, Ann Marie Reinhold, Ross Gore | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.6.4 | Large Language Models (LLMs) play a pivotal role in generating vast arrays of
narratives, facilitating a systematic exploration of their effectiveness for
communicating life events in narrative form. In this study, we employ a
zero-shot structured narrative prompt to generate 24,000 narratives using
OpenAI's GPT-4. From this dataset, we manually classify 2,880 narratives and
evaluate their validity in conveying birth, death, hiring, and firing events.
Remarkably, 87.43% of the narratives sufficiently convey the intention of the
structured prompt. To automate the identification of valid and invalid
narratives, we train and validate nine Machine Learning models on the
classified datasets. Leveraging these models, we extend our analysis to predict
the classifications of the remaining 21,120 narratives. All the ML models
excelled at classifying valid narratives as valid, but experienced challenges
at simultaneously classifying invalid narratives as invalid. Our findings not
only advance the study of LLM capabilities, limitations, and validity but also
offer practical insights for narrative generation and natural language
processing applications. | [
0.14248274266719818,
-0.7523725032806396,
1.1599111557006836,
0.16927453875541687,
-0.1681096851825714,
-0.08978866785764694,
0.13180068135261536,
-0.35504674911499023,
-0.2129477709531784,
0.2944329082965851,
-0.6787349581718445,
-0.6697281002998352,
-0.2760865390300751,
0.39329060912132263,
-0.28312844038009644,
1.2055996656417847,
-0.31490325927734375,
-0.21811412274837494,
-0.15336592495441437,
-0.022579733282327652,
-0.5930055975914001,
-0.526664674282074,
-0.42749714851379395,
-0.24013222754001617,
0.6794542670249939,
0.12253467738628387,
0.5213614106178284,
0.6254431009292603,
0.1663581132888794,
0.17329369485378265,
0.18957124650478363,
0.2851300537586212,
-0.40988877415657043,
0.3820698857307434,
0.19889186322689056,
-0.3367379903793335,
-0.33727070689201355,
0.35670381784439087,
0.5468440055847168,
0.6182140111923218,
-0.0974157378077507,
0.25549110770225525,
0.0492837019264698,
0.2613229751586914,
-0.38632556796073914,
0.1064341738820076,
-0.3512919545173645,
0.35393255949020386,
-0.1232287660241127,
-0.22177819907665253,
-0.5434684157371521,
-0.8174741268157959,
0.014941807836294174,
-0.43891242146492004,
0.32017722725868225,
-0.07801762223243713,
0.9102789759635925,
0.07078284025192261,
-0.41896918416023254,
-0.4890804886817932,
-0.909835934638977,
0.5785043835639954,
-0.7483597993850708,
-0.05360090360045433,
0.18293385207653046,
0.3161529302597046,
-0.23118339478969574,
-0.7973857522010803,
-0.6070861220359802,
-0.3048573434352875,
-0.04432243853807449,
0.1257825791835785,
-0.08922230452299118,
0.11739318072795868,
0.3658045828342438,
0.4238290786743164,
-1.0540051460266113,
0.2760746479034424,
-0.34961262345314026,
-0.2629067599773407,
0.425871878862381,
0.6384338140487671,
0.5436896085739136,
-0.44917166233062744,
-0.26967906951904297,
0.2072843462228775,
-0.8265154957771301,
0.029697194695472717,
0.7228355407714844,
0.12881803512573242,
-0.1761762797832489,
0.7306283712387085,
-0.20896680653095245,
0.6539173126220703,
-0.11952013522386551,
-0.5817484259605408,
0.22489190101623535,
-0.42008814215660095,
-0.1858990341424942,
0.18516606092453003,
0.9099193811416626,
0.6388283967971802,
0.4823436737060547,
-0.13593976199626923,
-0.14696557819843292,
0.1612248718738556,
0.2605961561203003,
-0.8693190813064575,
0.18731942772865295,
0.4137862026691437,
-0.4851541817188263,
-0.5335184335708618,
-0.24306192994117737,
-0.5241097211837769,
-0.5186491012573242,
-0.029233193024992943,
0.13085924088954926,
-0.37541425228118896,
0.2228448987007141,
0.18556426465511322,
-0.22703517973423004,
0.38474103808403015,
0.5491472482681274,
-0.7336974143981934,
-0.19392231106758118,
0.5471473932266235,
0.8245391845703125,
-0.2587970197200775,
-0.12861043214797974,
-0.5510104298591614,
0.2049034982919693,
-0.38551396131515503,
0.7163057327270508,
-0.3836997449398041,
-0.2085840404033661,
0.14321880042552948,
-0.11509960889816284,
-0.0568990595638752,
-0.39624103903770447,
0.9868044853210449,
-0.405758261680603,
0.464334636926651,
0.0020964103750884533,
-0.5650307536125183,
-0.07763247936964035,
0.5941886305809021,
-0.4562588334083557,
0.6506763100624084,
0.08408500254154205,
-0.4275500178337097,
0.5582391023635864,
-0.4633609652519226,
-0.3282875716686249,
0.3380647301673889,
-0.5243963599205017,
-0.45005667209625244,
0.07687466591596603,
0.18417072296142578,
0.5739907026290894,
-0.136903315782547,
0.8756953477859497,
-0.09412983059883118,
-0.33996203541755676,
0.03866826370358467,
-0.6335507035255432,
0.5737752914428711,
0.30201855301856995,
-0.29119670391082764,
0.07444066554307938,
-0.7994046807289124,
-0.23198288679122925,
0.4173216223716736,
-0.5555208921432495,
0.22548091411590576,
-0.162863090634346,
-0.1494714319705963,
0.06300799548625946,
-0.07739201933145523,
-0.8093066811561584,
0.4914260804653168,
-0.41244804859161377,
0.40598851442337036,
0.4153708815574646,
0.4539669454097748,
0.17846882343292236,
-0.48029834032058716,
0.9376789331436157,
-0.0016523031517863274,
0.09030831605195999,
-0.949636697769165,
-0.8641217350959778,
-0.2037372887134552,
0.16243672370910645,
0.010720345191657543,
0.6786748170852661,
-0.8475589156150818,
0.27789077162742615,
-0.15107430517673492,
-0.3769325315952301,
-0.10273793339729309,
-0.24764013290405273,
0.07938989996910095,
0.9508554339408875,
0.19739815592765808,
0.11294388025999069,
-0.6636313796043396,
-0.6796103715896606,
-0.2887205481529236,
-0.3897203207015991,
-0.2727009952068329,
0.06080503761768341,
0.3384064733982086,
-0.2579135298728943,
1.1212713718414307,
-0.3880772590637207,
0.014747535809874535,
-0.4498610198497772,
0.39070457220077515,
0.41623198986053467,
0.28236421942710876,
0.6706682443618774,
-0.7036213874816895,
-0.23230698704719543,
-0.25899186730384827,
-1.1658447980880737,
-0.13385114073753357,
-0.5465115308761597,
0.3460826277732849,
0.3222457766532898,
0.047940708696842194,
-0.6389639973640442,
0.7734615206718445,
0.4177546799182892,
-0.42085087299346924,
0.9648212194442749,
-0.26391613483428955,
0.1883171796798706,
-0.7902987599372864,
-0.05867557227611542,
-0.015696456655859947,
-0.32138749957084656,
-0.590785562992096,
-0.32254257798194885,
0.03193151578307152,
-0.29902151226997375,
-0.4117458164691925,
0.7223177552223206,
-0.28369060158729553,
0.06214093789458275,
-0.09156733006238937,
0.21263326704502106,
0.026020534336566925,
0.42647889256477356,
-0.012797065079212189,
0.5421419739723206,
0.11603283882141113,
-0.43458065390586853,
0.5457989573478699,
0.5491215586662292,
-0.46997687220573425,
0.4230169653892517,
-0.538482666015625,
0.0028631524182856083,
-0.21844761073589325,
0.6967850923538208,
-1.0202083587646484,
-0.6256775259971619,
0.3702296018600464,
-0.4429098665714264,
-0.010379231534898281,
-0.08945470303297043,
-0.7193952798843384,
-0.3578545153141022,
-0.23134568333625793,
0.23437586426734924,
0.5628448724746704,
-0.3194868564605713,
0.7054004073143005,
0.00024187513918150216,
-0.36665600538253784,
-0.1799764484167099,
-0.7253363132476807,
0.3970390260219574,
-0.41220343112945557,
-0.6464577913284302,
0.12640169262886047,
-0.269845575094223,
-0.05800431966781616,
-0.15970478951931,
0.07082699239253998,
0.005575594026595354,
-0.1035703644156456,
0.5106936097145081,
0.44255366921424866,
-0.3352116048336029,
-0.14272408187389374,
0.02056110091507435,
-0.28707432746887207,
-0.03673052415251732,
-0.2620975971221924,
0.38227418065071106,
0.23293019831180573,
-0.4825062155723572,
-0.36345985531806946,
0.24310337007045746,
0.4329073429107666,
0.19162368774414062,
0.7967249155044556,
0.549194872379303,
-0.4796876013278961,
0.10955572128295898,
-0.5069637298583984,
0.30149856209754944,
-0.39301952719688416,
-0.11983855068683624,
-0.12847168743610382,
-1.0320186614990234,
0.5037866830825806,
0.12210705876350403,
0.24587084352970123,
0.44776836037635803,
0.6425842642784119,
0.11900594830513,
0.9826209545135498,
0.2579021453857422,
0.10835397243499756,
0.1362791657447815,
0.23556001484394073,
0.326164186000824,
-0.48199740052223206,
-0.1267930120229721,
-0.3059932589530945,
-0.045062366873025894,
-0.4052483141422272,
-0.09438084810972214,
0.6128047108650208,
0.04420967027544975,
-0.3614426851272583,
-0.04350725933909416,
-0.3061935305595398,
0.6274625062942505,
0.3610835373401642,
-0.17528215050697327,
0.6426372528076172,
-0.18141356110572815,
-0.30538272857666016,
-0.020989440381526947,
-0.506554901599884,
-1.094122052192688,
0.9559088945388794,
0.4518127143383026,
0.452474445104599,
0.010075271129608154,
0.7011983394622803,
0.28702521324157715,
0.43796002864837646,
-0.3269488215446472,
0.37471526861190796,
0.11842280626296997,
-0.6011233329772949,
-0.28956112265586853,
-0.38951489329338074,
-0.9933968186378479,
-0.15745264291763306,
0.047541543841362,
-0.8489685654640198,
-0.03243034705519676,
-0.06450068205595016,
-1.0343408584594727,
0.09260229766368866,
-0.7080489993095398,
0.9120728969573975,
-0.43257391452789307,
0.03277932479977608,
0.4057657718658447,
-0.7258891463279724,
0.5358514189720154,
-0.3378142714500427,
0.16350595653057098,
-0.09102912992238998,
0.07587603479623795,
0.45661017298698425,
-0.3964785039424896,
0.9811683893203735,
-0.13886648416519165,
-0.142968088388443,
0.5618471503257751,
0.12318796664476395,
0.6064361333847046,
0.0950322300195694,
-0.2452102154493332,
0.007532949559390545,
-0.09989411383867264,
-0.160074383020401,
-0.35005494952201843,
0.4316475987434387,
-0.5178663730621338,
-0.3978287875652313,
-0.2857707738876343,
-0.4772758185863495,
-0.23473772406578064,
0.13083508610725403,
0.31287217140197754,
0.6875864863395691,
-0.34382814168930054,
-0.004034485202282667,
0.3285621106624603,
-0.7616561055183411,
0.6564112305641174,
0.4323410093784332,
-0.4018751084804535,
-0.3817850947380066,
0.5812380313873291,
0.20082987844944,
0.19993804395198822,
0.08297964185476303,
0.18156075477600098,
-0.19868838787078857,
-0.8808009624481201,
-0.8088765144348145,
0.22194883227348328,
-0.7023423910140991,
-0.3474019169807434,
-0.8165909051895142,
-0.2950117290019989,
-0.4269799292087555,
-0.26202186942100525,
0.09988528490066528,
-0.13771405816078186,
-0.383428692817688,
-0.7411985993385315,
0.04284365475177765,
0.9660930037498474,
0.00860813818871975,
0.13646146655082703,
-1.187526822090149,
0.4636499881744385,
0.09320623427629471,
0.19127874076366425,
-0.2829913794994354,
-0.44931885600090027,
0.0886235162615776,
-0.09249573945999146,
-0.4923046827316284,
-0.9850603938102722,
0.5540401935577393,
0.08696918189525604,
0.5272216200828552,
0.39482906460762024,
0.1829630434513092,
0.4712356626987457,
-0.8648965954780579,
1.2963378429412842,
0.05314113199710846,
-0.6292824745178223,
0.7796971797943115,
-1.0339535474777222,
0.4194675087928772,
0.2790212631225586,
0.6354395747184753,
-0.45370063185691833,
-0.3784337639808655,
-0.7609861493110657,
-0.7377988696098328,
0.6710990071296692,
0.4516320526599884,
0.25591447949409485,
-0.15885044634342194,
0.7222496271133423,
0.31893545389175415,
0.13118767738342285,
-0.8886144161224365,
-0.23701360821723938,
0.00859219953417778,
-0.4126676619052887,
-0.005808462854474783,
-0.49694395065307617,
0.15771497786045074,
0.09081549942493439,
0.36522695422172546,
-0.17494237422943115,
0.08774194866418839,
0.16113437712192535,
0.014395149424672127,
-0.27211079001426697,
0.1617240458726883,
0.7741089463233948,
0.6272147297859192,
-0.11961815506219864,
-0.06588668376207352,
0.16732653975486755,
-0.3928910493850708,
0.2537021040916443,
0.07051355391740799,
-0.34005632996559143,
0.028994670137763023,
0.629154622554779,
0.911331057548523,
0.10209935903549194,
-0.839361846446991,
0.662961483001709,
-0.38540416955947876,
-0.31595978140830994,
-0.3389976918697357,
0.2041959911584854,
0.04995908588171005,
0.2717466652393341,
0.39867159724235535,
-0.25430285930633545,
-0.02412114106118679,
-0.6404176354408264,
0.04266923666000366,
-0.0007633257191628218,
-0.0988016277551651,
-0.46166184544563293,
0.702383279800415,
0.07775116711854935,
-0.2409769594669342,
0.7848241329193115,
-0.37212643027305603,
-0.3408161401748657,
0.5306938886642456,
0.4749755263328552,
0.8959027528762817,
-0.1338292509317398,
0.47886964678764343,
0.4582286477088928,
0.30482906103134155,
-0.008462163619697094,
-0.05372173339128494,
0.10806870460510254,
-0.9298112988471985,
-0.6607036590576172,
-1.0734423398971558,
-0.6030506491661072,
0.5582747459411621,
-0.37929490208625793,
0.20293360948562622,
-0.14530542492866516,
0.1521892249584198,
-0.17778195440769196,
-0.28996142745018005,
-0.5999664068222046,
0.21491116285324097,
0.6475765109062195,
0.7355513572692871,
-1.0223877429962158,
0.5311689376831055,
0.39429065585136414,
-0.7085226774215698,
-0.9425978064537048,
0.046087998896837234,
0.15800665318965912,
-0.5792076587677002,
0.5130887627601624,
0.40258297324180603,
0.29062262177467346,
0.02180422656238079,
-0.5966008901596069,
-0.49313828349113464,
1.2205183506011963,
0.48341813683509827,
-0.4487796723842621,
-0.42243286967277527,
0.4588022530078888,
0.7236409783363342,
-0.5658909678459167,
0.3175451159477234,
0.38263389468193054,
0.5748471021652222,
0.3780769109725952,
-0.9285764098167419,
-0.05877765268087387,
0.02556280605494976,
-0.056610941886901855,
-0.13228075206279755,
-0.1686360090970993,
0.6211565732955933,
-0.29959172010421753,
-0.5482266545295715,
0.28054073452949524,
0.644765317440033,
0.6741933822631836,
0.6645300388336182,
0.28278952836990356,
0.3635213077068329,
0.8390375971794128,
-0.15307463705539703,
1.3543100357055664,
0.061283815652132034,
0.14369921386241913,
0.9609135985374451,
-0.5724655985832214,
0.3129408061504364,
-0.10773906111717224,
-0.03331632539629936,
0.7003588080406189,
0.8450620174407959,
0.11573205143213272,
0.1293760985136032,
0.02996593713760376,
-0.34406551718711853,
-0.2391555905342102,
0.013625090010464191,
-0.07625782489776611,
0.2974061667919159,
0.16198675334453583,
-0.35507985949516296,
-0.45044299960136414,
0.3666941523551941,
-0.01807418279349804,
-0.1493428349494934,
-0.22343258559703827,
0.7781862020492554,
0.09718286246061325,
-0.8094048500061035,
0.22629313170909882,
-0.046046044677495956,
0.31943637132644653,
-0.5366743803024292,
-0.24534760415554047,
-0.20131555199623108,
-0.11287547647953033,
-0.15478140115737915,
-0.8113969564437866,
0.36338239908218384,
0.46755340695381165,
-0.20132651925086975,
-0.6311023831367493,
0.9221768379211426,
-0.21448419988155365,
-0.3160701096057892,
-0.26218274235725403,
0.5881277322769165,
0.3373846411705017,
-0.2765602469444275,
-0.31210052967071533,
0.1444515883922577,
0.1157887727022171,
-0.4379621148109436,
0.23856765031814575,
0.7473611831665039,
-0.1724112629890442,
0.38710731267929077,
0.6227632164955139,
-0.016581375151872635,
0.02716437540948391,
0.11068657040596008,
0.6225890517234802,
-0.9750964641571045,
-0.6543911695480347,
-1.0594114065170288,
0.7919928431510925,
0.17204207181930542,
-0.29343748092651367,
0.6904886364936829,
0.5883747339248657,
0.4019283354282379,
-0.031925998628139496,
0.9656217694282532,
0.25892162322998047,
0.7109321355819702,
-0.6020409464836121,
0.4260249137878418,
-0.01238646823912859,
0.1857023388147354,
-0.10277920961380005,
-0.7047685980796814,
-0.4320868253707886,
0.3468707501888275,
-0.5179945230484009,
0.2875935435295105,
0.6518586874008179,
0.42086061835289,
0.3434431254863739,
0.2172982394695282,
0.4384241998195648,
0.12106480449438095,
0.521107017993927,
0.4703996181488037,
1.177330493927002,
-0.31248241662979126,
0.5278053283691406,
0.4105994403362274,
-0.13503463566303253,
-0.13621971011161804,
-1.2358769178390503,
-0.7497652769088745,
-0.43016743659973145,
-0.3246943950653076,
-0.1204894483089447,
-0.01468383427709341,
0.5673912167549133,
0.3688686192035675,
-0.5122045278549194,
0.2794116735458374,
-0.09700512886047363,
-0.16472695767879486,
0.4544928967952728,
-0.28870517015457153,
-0.008000238798558712,
-0.3785320818424225,
-0.4487430453300476,
0.674595296382904,
0.6424899697303772,
0.12267911434173584,
-0.2300281822681427,
-0.17832085490226746,
0.07423433661460876,
0.08510078489780426,
0.5195181965827942,
0.11127734184265137,
-0.6611942648887634,
-0.48316681385040283,
-0.25149717926979065,
-0.21055646240711212,
0.11645954847335815,
0.9000046849250793,
-1.0898593664169312,
0.08045651763677597,
0.3223254382610321,
0.630933403968811,
0.38182175159454346,
0.21191012859344482,
0.7642174959182739,
-0.9112783074378967,
-0.27269601821899414,
0.3361082971096039,
0.4414767622947693,
0.29016217589378357,
-0.6367006897926331,
0.6338372826576233,
0.31055164337158203,
-0.842359721660614,
-0.9134349822998047,
0.28630387783050537,
-0.9218531847000122,
-0.135384663939476,
1.375404715538025,
-0.26097777485847473,
-0.13473495841026306,
-0.265572726726532,
-0.331167072057724,
0.16034431755542755,
-0.1541663557291031,
0.4052133858203888,
0.8381744027137756,
-0.4588252305984497,
-0.22186674177646637,
-0.8741470575332642,
0.36200210452079773,
-0.098318912088871,
-1.0703068971633911,
-0.060943569988012314,
0.8766528367996216,
0.20620444416999817,
0.11025004088878632,
0.7860859036445618,
-0.06281878054141998,
0.19478870928287506,
-0.2028520405292511,
-0.0703706368803978,
-0.32855069637298584,
-0.2556382119655609,
-0.4215400516986847,
0.4443182349205017,
-0.11487311869859695,
0.2017154097557068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05406v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05406v2 | Everybody Prune Now: Structured Pruning of LLMs with only Forward Passes | 2024-02-08T04:48:26 | 2024-02-09T19:53:56 | Lucio Dery, Steven Kolawole, Jean-François Kagy, Virginia Smith, Graham Neubig, Ameet Talwalkar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Given the generational gap in available hardware between lay practitioners
and the most endowed institutions, LLMs are becoming increasingly inaccessible
as they grow in size. Whilst many approaches have been proposed to compress
LLMs to make their resource consumption manageable, these methods themselves
tend to be resource intensive, putting them out of the reach of the very user
groups they target. In this work, we explore the problem of structured pruning
of LLMs using only forward passes. We seek to empower practitioners to prune
models so large that their available hardware has just enough memory to run
inference. We develop Bonsai, a gradient-free, perturbative pruning method
capable of delivering small, fast, and accurate pruned models.
We observe that Bonsai outputs pruned models that (i) outperform those
generated by more expensive gradient-based structured pruning methods, and (ii)
are twice as fast (with comparable accuracy) as those generated by
semi-structured pruning methods requiring comparable resources as Bonsai. We
also leverage Bonsai to produce a new sub-2B model using a single A6000 that
yields state-of-the-art performance on 4/6 tasks on the Huggingface Open LLM
leaderboard. | [
-0.263010710477829,
-0.7791709899902344,
0.5549641847610474,
0.6224454045295715,
-0.5736700296401978,
-0.19859515130519867,
-0.16777512431144714,
-0.47910425066947937,
0.19811983406543732,
0.5727798342704773,
-0.9847854375839233,
-0.4427884519100189,
-0.172268807888031,
-0.08108720928430557,
-0.47072094678878784,
0.8667057156562805,
0.14041875302791595,
-0.030352234840393066,
-0.3298870027065277,
-0.09411938488483429,
-0.3563968241214752,
-0.5462026596069336,
-0.4659270644187927,
-0.48651206493377686,
0.6192825436592102,
0.3979208767414093,
0.539025604724884,
0.5550082325935364,
0.3107450008392334,
0.22470436990261078,
-0.37517249584198,
0.16228139400482178,
-0.5459958910942078,
0.09832186251878738,
-0.05244332179427147,
-0.6375983357429504,
-0.7134910821914673,
-0.04607801511883736,
0.6867628693580627,
0.7112276554107666,
-0.3272969424724579,
0.3174309730529785,
0.13173092901706696,
0.6623628735542297,
-0.5474464893341064,
-0.20734219253063202,
-0.7498819828033447,
0.1379850059747696,
-0.3721737861633301,
-0.3931303024291992,
-0.43487903475761414,
-0.45919352769851685,
-0.4304989278316498,
-0.6828787326812744,
0.3656056225299835,
-0.09597906470298767,
0.7803028225898743,
0.4401785433292389,
-0.1413113921880722,
0.38210535049438477,
-0.7821071147918701,
0.7719889879226685,
-0.37129977345466614,
0.2303001433610916,
0.003705751383677125,
0.3013150990009308,
-0.2006002813577652,
-0.754618227481842,
0.021863216534256935,
-0.10336785763502121,
0.03902730718255043,
0.04175452142953873,
0.06967499107122421,
0.28691795468330383,
0.13696643710136414,
0.30025526881217957,
-0.19965560734272003,
0.28947243094444275,
-0.46579769253730774,
-0.09254546463489532,
0.842536211013794,
0.09465044736862183,
-0.14036978781223297,
0.01607244461774826,
-0.7852126955986023,
-0.010124586522579193,
-1.0675221681594849,
-0.16993200778961182,
0.23157629370689392,
-0.1769208163022995,
0.3680499494075775,
0.47485461831092834,
0.21497127413749695,
0.8247727155685425,
-0.29965052008628845,
-0.2843283712863922,
-0.40412798523902893,
-0.17357346415519714,
-0.6223470568656921,
-0.17557069659233093,
0.49445998668670654,
0.42029890418052673,
0.49948588013648987,
-0.06290998309850693,
-0.21652227640151978,
0.023508768528699875,
0.1026492789387703,
-1.00992751121521,
-0.7925760746002197,
0.26840102672576904,
-0.43907204270362854,
-0.2177937924861908,
-0.2104681134223938,
-0.6620739698410034,
-0.19897310435771942,
-0.10945360362529755,
0.05153905227780342,
-0.04807077348232269,
-0.29228121042251587,
-0.06235000118613243,
-0.09745814651250839,
0.1382054090499878,
0.8794127106666565,
-0.5348141193389893,
0.574666440486908,
0.8890417218208313,
1.0655044317245483,
0.10821209102869034,
-0.017840653657913208,
-0.3273570239543915,
0.26523473858833313,
-0.44235527515411377,
0.582923412322998,
-0.4014075696468353,
-0.9715895652770996,
-0.556189775466919,
-0.011561640538275242,
0.033780548721551895,
-0.7166318893432617,
0.47158339619636536,
-0.44367551803588867,
-0.2975500226020813,
-0.10924244672060013,
-0.3913218677043915,
-0.2763706147670746,
0.2419416606426239,
-0.5307424664497375,
0.6477113366127014,
-0.04159102588891983,
-0.4975842535495758,
0.043256670236587524,
-0.4015839695930481,
-0.44835537672042847,
0.14092625677585602,
-0.3420459032058716,
-0.6549286842346191,
0.3251674771308899,
-0.0024930578656494617,
0.5189804434776306,
-0.29611340165138245,
0.5524685382843018,
-0.5252841711044312,
-0.6066119074821472,
-0.17906273901462555,
-0.5401538014411926,
0.9392272233963013,
0.09231672435998917,
0.11610198020935059,
0.2434372752904892,
-0.41195252537727356,
0.12872038781642914,
0.27920472621917725,
-0.3776205778121948,
-0.13678383827209473,
-0.14005494117736816,
0.04598201438784599,
0.16383029520511627,
0.21583998203277588,
-0.5931957960128784,
0.4393422603607178,
-0.22542494535446167,
0.6331939101219177,
1.1290216445922852,
0.22094830870628357,
0.37063559889793396,
-0.5564584732055664,
0.6376954913139343,
-0.030470050871372223,
0.3953486680984497,
-0.15617914497852325,
-0.6493920087814331,
-0.5400835871696472,
-0.43659839034080505,
0.39547640085220337,
0.37627100944519043,
-0.07425455003976822,
0.30308037996292114,
-0.16280630230903625,
-0.5935268402099609,
-0.40871885418891907,
0.26207950711250305,
0.31940677762031555,
0.46315428614616394,
0.24791912734508514,
-0.5413033366203308,
-0.40587764978408813,
-1.0587512254714966,
-0.2478569746017456,
-0.08836761862039566,
-0.3889841139316559,
0.5367096066474915,
0.39631909132003784,
0.24287356436252594,
0.7877464890480042,
-0.5848096013069153,
-0.483434796333313,
0.09409617632627487,
-0.11889305710792542,
0.11930114775896072,
0.8116467595100403,
0.16424928605556488,
-0.8717431426048279,
0.018119992688298225,
-0.21385714411735535,
-0.562418520450592,
0.17796993255615234,
-0.32324111461639404,
-0.09592660516500473,
-0.0021289370488375425,
0.3675056993961334,
-0.813547670841217,
0.5885645151138306,
0.47822293639183044,
-0.15634356439113617,
0.6395390033721924,
-0.42012208700180054,
-0.48506081104278564,
-0.5786548852920532,
0.24091358482837677,
0.16440674662590027,
-0.4132787883281708,
-0.14350096881389618,
0.10111851990222931,
0.0931968241930008,
-0.19813457131385803,
-0.5181514620780945,
0.5664429664611816,
-0.7446589469909668,
-0.5486194491386414,
0.05429206043481827,
-0.008800318464636803,
0.2678791880607605,
0.6875403523445129,
0.0974244549870491,
0.5129596590995789,
0.3309093117713928,
-0.8285571336746216,
0.1721276193857193,
0.155794158577919,
-0.3125353455543518,
0.42457717657089233,
-0.8330495953559875,
0.07930553704500198,
-0.18599499762058258,
0.8037256002426147,
-0.5976434350013733,
-0.1251322627067566,
0.3908088505268097,
-0.10090529173612595,
0.550971269607544,
-0.23210200667381287,
-0.2108938843011856,
-0.2414761781692505,
-0.22750551998615265,
0.22687530517578125,
0.6657269597053528,
-0.4410325288772583,
0.5787188410758972,
0.18569444119930267,
-0.12765026092529297,
-0.2884417772293091,
-0.8597012758255005,
0.06339889019727707,
-0.24149926006793976,
-0.7073254585266113,
0.624237596988678,
-0.21758756041526794,
-0.28729957342147827,
0.02282649464905262,
-0.5926922559738159,
-0.0193472933024168,
0.672315776348114,
0.37637069821357727,
0.2474863976240158,
0.00593167869374156,
-0.09121258556842804,
-0.04557628184556961,
-0.04621921479701996,
0.050988759845495224,
-0.5635862350463867,
0.1990310102701187,
0.06298637390136719,
-0.5941433310508728,
-0.6135331392288208,
0.332173228263855,
0.45509782433509827,
-0.34358975291252136,
0.4765869379043579,
0.25138330459594727,
-0.24177122116088867,
-0.4421355426311493,
-0.3444039821624756,
-0.4508807361125946,
-0.4391043782234192,
0.4008282423019409,
-0.538108229637146,
-0.7199828028678894,
0.04409336298704147,
-0.4883153736591339,
0.7924589514732361,
0.1069900169968605,
0.29593679308891296,
-0.1013021394610405,
0.7488112449645996,
0.5770533084869385,
0.19297489523887634,
0.3042060136795044,
-0.48608046770095825,
0.09386738389730453,
-0.9016813635826111,
-0.5173414349555969,
-0.4701448380947113,
-0.7230650186538696,
-0.28861671686172485,
-0.6768516898155212,
0.40368473529815674,
0.4870600998401642,
-0.1782987266778946,
-0.03649530187249184,
-0.7635502219200134,
0.5720125436782837,
0.5467396974563599,
0.44213834404945374,
0.4743955731391907,
-0.01283644512295723,
0.3455432653427124,
0.20089757442474365,
-1.027354121208191,
-0.44724106788635254,
0.7842954993247986,
0.4627429246902466,
0.6465732455253601,
-0.20562106370925903,
0.7215695977210999,
0.056649211794137955,
0.9508414268493652,
-0.7799493670463562,
0.8888220191001892,
-0.009063750505447388,
-0.7708706855773926,
-0.19858993589878082,
-0.47794535756111145,
-0.7568271160125732,
0.49060577154159546,
0.31862983107566833,
-0.5865203738212585,
0.31686362624168396,
0.39029547572135925,
-0.4824109673500061,
0.6815850734710693,
-0.4352981448173523,
0.48728135228157043,
-0.3030960261821747,
-0.5629836916923523,
-0.2979735732078552,
-0.7476373910903931,
0.859826385974884,
-0.09720578789710999,
0.1726430356502533,
-0.40181413292884827,
-0.39458832144737244,
0.8175792098045349,
-0.6825506687164307,
0.9457117915153503,
-0.4917099177837372,
0.006676726974546909,
0.30159714818000793,
0.3890027105808258,
0.5437756180763245,
0.04421794414520264,
-0.006710901856422424,
0.2776351273059845,
-0.15244075655937195,
-0.7034806609153748,
-0.5961770415306091,
0.6965295672416687,
-0.48098865151405334,
-1.0071378946304321,
-0.16635949909687042,
-0.3687460422515869,
-0.056961022317409515,
-0.09750622510910034,
0.06502643972635269,
0.3285001218318939,
-0.14078104496002197,
0.22379998862743378,
0.5946977734565735,
0.167771115899086,
0.4513634145259857,
0.3851129710674286,
-0.08020401000976562,
-0.18735341727733612,
0.8570920825004578,
0.30108606815338135,
0.010242911987006664,
0.12508369982242584,
0.11428544670343399,
-0.10016616433858871,
-0.6452994346618652,
-0.4548121988773346,
0.2741885781288147,
-0.5179262161254883,
-0.3616127073764801,
-0.5748454332351685,
-0.1519431322813034,
0.0846693366765976,
-0.2832101881504059,
-0.2927005887031555,
-0.7218204736709595,
-0.37541303038597107,
-0.05459229275584221,
0.34806057810783386,
0.716738224029541,
-0.1633157730102539,
0.40293973684310913,
-0.8140530586242676,
0.07154079526662827,
0.0647638663649559,
0.13081763684749603,
0.23103080689907074,
-0.2719082236289978,
0.09744679182767868,
-0.1121848076581955,
-0.5306708216667175,
-0.7370393872261047,
0.4196464419364929,
0.4498881995677948,
0.26592373847961426,
0.4137938916683197,
0.07215278595685959,
0.7783991694450378,
-0.4541338384151459,
0.5166143774986267,
0.2831217348575592,
-0.5460878014564514,
0.40868067741394043,
-0.06877043098211288,
-0.0016465535154566169,
0.4125024676322937,
0.46296462416648865,
-0.19054126739501953,
-0.005780964158475399,
-0.9359449148178101,
-0.8968731164932251,
0.5265065431594849,
0.024781079962849617,
-0.26956361532211304,
0.3778049051761627,
0.46590954065322876,
-0.03762086108326912,
0.3829858601093292,
-0.5121574401855469,
0.013755930587649345,
-0.029053837060928345,
0.11660157144069672,
-0.18706205487251282,
-0.13596193492412567,
-0.374194473028183,
-0.2555914521217346,
0.7449450492858887,
0.0020613009110093117,
0.1362295001745224,
0.4033958911895752,
0.14184172451496124,
-0.12258891761302948,
0.11197985708713531,
0.15542201697826385,
0.7241858839988708,
-0.19679783284664154,
-0.11581150442361832,
-0.04947071522474289,
-0.09119649976491928,
0.44208717346191406,
0.017819272354245186,
-0.4685477912425995,
-0.009352038614451885,
0.17484021186828613,
0.5545895099639893,
0.5564021468162537,
-0.4437691569328308,
0.3900071680545807,
-0.048372846096754074,
-0.4263792932033539,
-0.1691061556339264,
0.1948614865541458,
0.2451624572277069,
0.23353388905525208,
0.035902634263038635,
0.5288059711456299,
-0.17394046485424042,
-0.3022111654281616,
0.20592424273490906,
0.4393640458583832,
-0.15704837441444397,
-0.3446308970451355,
0.7601695656776428,
0.5235474109649658,
-0.5651252269744873,
0.8552480340003967,
0.24786774814128876,
-0.3584604263305664,
0.6297824382781982,
0.3843788206577301,
0.7595253586769104,
-0.08633647114038467,
0.08090421557426453,
0.13764631748199463,
0.2809128165245056,
-0.2578315734863281,
0.17867138981819153,
-0.8014073967933655,
-0.1809225231409073,
-0.6172842383384705,
-0.9040054678916931,
-0.6540006399154663,
-0.14405174553394318,
-0.6130515933036804,
-0.008824635297060013,
-0.9733778834342957,
0.017687330022454262,
-0.3328264355659485,
0.28736379742622375,
-0.48226818442344666,
0.28198692202568054,
-0.17660900950431824,
1.4313993453979492,
-0.7739483714103699,
1.0035340785980225,
0.6068106293678284,
0.010237405076622963,
-0.6913344860076904,
-0.2364775687456131,
-0.03301188349723816,
-0.6671430468559265,
0.33994045853614807,
0.29952967166900635,
-0.007376692723482847,
0.25048205256462097,
-0.7023810148239136,
-0.4860502779483795,
1.2105077505111694,
0.47138068079948425,
-1.0820105075836182,
-0.5491800308227539,
-0.5651578903198242,
0.01277076918631792,
0.15573132038116455,
0.09310515224933624,
0.5821874737739563,
0.699273943901062,
0.40429338812828064,
-0.34154102206230164,
-0.04609861224889755,
-0.16202309727668762,
0.0063377870246768,
0.38935473561286926,
-0.9996225237846375,
0.9033734798431396,
-0.21512392163276672,
-0.31499096751213074,
0.2981770634651184,
0.7760963439941406,
0.7831586599349976,
0.29895684123039246,
0.6302908658981323,
0.5443586707115173,
1.118753433227539,
-0.08578509837388992,
1.082033395767212,
-0.27734020352363586,
0.04047806188464165,
1.0194429159164429,
-0.3538999557495117,
0.5689732432365417,
0.5365463495254517,
-0.21502768993377686,
0.2855733633041382,
0.9839826226234436,
0.18996639549732208,
0.13907894492149353,
0.4875250458717346,
-0.3852616250514984,
-0.5233175754547119,
-0.20044948160648346,
-0.22793157398700714,
0.12260738760232925,
0.4432200789451599,
0.008730767294764519,
-0.2565193474292755,
-0.14625264704227448,
0.18710625171661377,
-0.02428325079381466,
-0.528461217880249,
0.5478282570838928,
0.616856575012207,
-0.8366551995277405,
0.5116319060325623,
0.15407207608222961,
0.7775274515151978,
-0.8245972990989685,
0.05821419507265091,
-0.304034560918808,
0.25341325998306274,
-0.4788881838321686,
-0.5540684461593628,
0.4131816029548645,
-0.1276106834411621,
0.21941855549812317,
-0.7388095855712891,
0.9155769348144531,
-0.24223151803016663,
-0.455645889043808,
0.2798996567726135,
0.3883911967277527,
0.4999035596847534,
-0.20202836394309998,
-0.5897841453552246,
0.11826875805854797,
0.0899665504693985,
-0.5109274387359619,
0.44973087310791016,
0.2934171259403229,
-0.2876138687133789,
0.7780489921569824,
0.5833988785743713,
0.4781897962093353,
-0.13124892115592957,
-0.21325822174549103,
1.0674965381622314,
-0.6123346090316772,
-0.4081796109676361,
-0.8085047602653503,
0.34001973271369934,
-0.05486041679978371,
-0.3351532816886902,
0.7479218244552612,
0.3582231104373932,
0.7910326719284058,
0.3404572606086731,
0.34484514594078064,
0.24723011255264282,
0.10654577612876892,
-0.4073258340358734,
0.46198898553848267,
-0.7817862629890442,
0.33692488074302673,
0.18816590309143066,
-0.9051856398582458,
-0.18998980522155762,
0.49569228291511536,
-0.16469627618789673,
0.06370502710342407,
0.10726144909858704,
0.6834193468093872,
-0.08995142579078674,
0.29405149817466736,
0.3620372712612152,
0.23266775906085968,
0.32132017612457275,
0.7183820605278015,
0.6643387079238892,
0.0426769033074379,
0.390717089176178,
-0.44861865043640137,
-0.3637387156486511,
-0.32429683208465576,
-0.8954798579216003,
-0.43106532096862793,
-0.09537319839000702,
-0.28420135378837585,
-0.15517224371433258,
0.18137282133102417,
0.5759377479553223,
1.0391632318496704,
-0.31130045652389526,
-0.27220892906188965,
-0.5114615559577942,
0.23304212093353271,
-0.1945950835943222,
-0.16686275601387024,
0.28424033522605896,
0.17789049446582794,
-0.36651164293289185,
0.682038426399231,
0.3091331124305725,
-0.029305409640073776,
-0.6940841674804688,
-0.029706638306379318,
-0.15947499871253967,
-0.05245643109083176,
0.26733505725860596,
0.38565099239349365,
-0.5013018250465393,
0.27578943967819214,
-0.3107483386993408,
0.2532733976840973,
0.12903977930545807,
1.0251034498214722,
-1.0360842943191528,
0.027967194095253944,
0.19050651788711548,
0.5404155850410461,
0.8254818320274353,
0.4338941276073456,
0.5784134268760681,
-0.9122242331504822,
0.37568601965904236,
0.7472792863845825,
0.25792810320854187,
0.36688604950904846,
-0.24050886929035187,
0.4864066541194916,
0.36972740292549133,
-0.6564254760742188,
-0.911852240562439,
0.4135342836380005,
-0.5149025321006775,
-0.6499629616737366,
0.6271520853042603,
-0.47226855158805847,
-0.8409843444824219,
0.16649383306503296,
-0.08923710882663727,
0.15551351010799408,
-0.19865843653678894,
0.2972269058227539,
0.1379166841506958,
-0.146686390042305,
-0.16823633015155792,
-0.29739344120025635,
0.34735095500946045,
0.6478691101074219,
-0.6418081521987915,
0.17629948258399963,
0.5554591417312622,
0.17334599792957306,
-0.1760355830192566,
0.8851436376571655,
-0.06777654588222504,
0.16002753376960754,
-0.08972618728876114,
-0.09118542820215225,
-0.4311720132827759,
-0.9596710205078125,
-0.4950198531150818,
0.5490190982818604,
0.13407418131828308,
-0.16977643966674805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05403v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05403v2 | In-Context Principle Learning from Mistakes | 2024-02-08T04:42:29 | 2024-02-09T19:09:52 | Tianjun Zhang, Aman Madaan, Luyu Gao, Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Yiming Yang, Niket Tandon, Uri Alon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL, also known as few-shot prompting) has been the
standard method of adapting LLMs to downstream tasks, by learning from a few
input-output examples. Nonetheless, all ICL-based approaches only learn from
correct input-output pairs. In this paper, we revisit this paradigm, by
learning more from the few given input-output examples. We introduce Learning
Principles (LEAP): First, we intentionally induce the model to make mistakes on
these few examples; then we reflect on these mistakes, and learn explicit
task-specific "principles" from them, which help solve similar problems and
avoid common mistakes; finally, we prompt the model to answer unseen test
questions using the original few-shot examples and these learned general
principles. We evaluate LEAP on a wide range of benchmarks, including multi-hop
question answering (Hotpot QA), textual QA (DROP), Big-Bench Hard reasoning,
and math problems (GSM8K and MATH); in all these benchmarks, LEAP improves the
strongest available LLMs such as GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, GPT-4 turbo and
Claude-2.1. For example, LEAP improves over the standard few-shot prompting
using GPT-4 by 7.5% in DROP, and by 3.3% in HotpotQA. Importantly, LEAP does
not require any more input or examples than the standard few-shot prompting
settings. | [
-0.29932525753974915,
-0.6419742703437805,
0.6503176689147949,
0.04206257686018944,
-0.11164117604494095,
-0.03744438663125038,
0.010485371574759483,
-0.18089988827705383,
-0.5714031457901001,
0.282392293214798,
-0.6829144954681396,
-0.34995707869529724,
-0.46668869256973267,
0.02868715487420559,
-0.141180157661438,
1.2391104698181152,
-0.0972406342625618,
0.2302376627922058,
-0.09597300738096237,
0.061631713062524796,
-0.5775477886199951,
-0.3001728355884552,
-0.6625375747680664,
-0.36665526032447815,
0.3938215970993042,
0.9415958523750305,
0.014308680780231953,
0.2453439086675644,
0.5244629383087158,
0.0746840089559555,
-0.15518362820148468,
0.39302754402160645,
-0.7178241014480591,
-0.41985106468200684,
0.06262967735528946,
-0.6569202542304993,
0.05677536502480507,
0.015895197167992592,
0.5821626782417297,
0.589677631855011,
-0.12945246696472168,
-0.0324367955327034,
0.6952937245368958,
0.7697938084602356,
-0.7665174007415771,
0.20403459668159485,
-0.6638892889022827,
0.18944674730300903,
-0.014358943328261375,
-0.3157222867012024,
-0.6800163388252258,
-0.3317069709300995,
-0.05340295284986496,
-0.6635302305221558,
0.12370093911886215,
-0.25327208638191223,
0.6971212029457092,
0.2703649401664734,
-0.48518916964530945,
-0.3466980755329132,
-0.7474368810653687,
0.8737258911132812,
-0.7629057765007019,
0.4334656596183777,
0.3788500428199768,
0.35880252718925476,
-0.2787895202636719,
-0.6546115875244141,
-0.34746477007865906,
-0.007589009124785662,
0.027803286910057068,
0.22352443635463715,
0.15280434489250183,
0.014603612013161182,
0.4348790645599365,
-0.13228698074817657,
-0.08909162878990173,
-0.09155973047018051,
-0.4439968466758728,
0.039997488260269165,
0.5078417062759399,
0.20047178864479065,
-0.10600516200065613,
0.07718494534492493,
-0.5779910683631897,
-0.29148316383361816,
-1.3194644451141357,
0.6011884212493896,
-0.12447444349527359,
0.6060555577278137,
-0.17541788518428802,
0.08292345702648163,
0.009052395820617676,
0.6996450424194336,
0.41421085596084595,
-0.4243911802768707,
0.04862112179398537,
-0.370745450258255,
-0.2862893044948578,
-0.14485566318035126,
0.16681061685085297,
0.15378990769386292,
0.08543701469898224,
0.08338942378759384,
-0.08578222244977951,
-0.4962666630744934,
0.22933386266231537,
-0.5785241723060608,
-0.20126985013484955,
-0.13265275955200195,
-0.21835525333881378,
0.05297073349356651,
0.10597535967826843,
-0.47320297360420227,
-0.30446675419807434,
-0.2156476378440857,
0.6064478754997253,
-0.7658950686454773,
0.1461782604455948,
0.023741690441966057,
-0.05915010720491409,
0.7291358113288879,
0.7361454963684082,
-0.8100491762161255,
0.5018966197967529,
0.8843449354171753,
0.8197803497314453,
-0.18426720798015594,
-0.5373858213424683,
-0.8604415655136108,
0.04364866018295288,
-0.6412588357925415,
0.726681113243103,
-0.13410042226314545,
-0.5701059103012085,
0.001342790317721665,
-0.36568012833595276,
-0.3498842418193817,
-0.628212571144104,
0.3828074336051941,
-0.46571454405784607,
0.038285866379737854,
-0.5099640488624573,
-0.822096049785614,
-0.40767228603363037,
0.41053715348243713,
-0.20059162378311157,
0.7887197136878967,
-0.08237829804420471,
-0.5432783365249634,
0.8097378611564636,
-0.9530957341194153,
-0.27848851680755615,
-0.18169870972633362,
-0.18360430002212524,
-0.13219545781612396,
0.12890295684337616,
0.09443853795528412,
0.44461706280708313,
-0.0912541076540947,
-0.20376372337341309,
-0.17465464770793915,
-0.515853762626648,
-0.012527095153927803,
-0.35482004284858704,
0.8176202774047852,
0.06452681869268417,
-0.35687732696533203,
-0.23613645136356354,
-0.7202242016792297,
0.1907060742378235,
-0.006875539664179087,
-0.6661437749862671,
-0.337306410074234,
0.08128627389669418,
-0.2622702121734619,
0.3861226737499237,
-0.39199399948120117,
-0.26988232135772705,
0.15621265769004822,
-0.4755021929740906,
0.24469336867332458,
0.7596478462219238,
0.40554335713386536,
0.4356360137462616,
-0.4238899350166321,
0.2865641415119171,
0.43651309609413147,
0.17332874238491058,
-0.4539206027984619,
-0.3760511875152588,
-0.7138553857803345,
-0.1693645417690277,
-0.10795367509126663,
0.6547842025756836,
-0.6075353622436523,
-0.03676743060350418,
0.1678164005279541,
-0.284765362739563,
-0.10479488223791122,
0.6724165678024292,
0.5584291219711304,
0.8925557732582092,
0.47785788774490356,
-0.12350235879421234,
-0.241186261177063,
-0.4505862593650818,
-0.46982625126838684,
-0.5125694870948792,
0.14601780474185944,
0.24301110208034515,
0.41046828031539917,
0.1277526617050171,
0.9324564337730408,
-0.41218551993370056,
-0.19545422494411469,
-0.22995488345623016,
0.13399814069271088,
0.2344953566789627,
0.3933219015598297,
0.3630932867527008,
-0.8082085251808167,
-0.5546337962150574,
-0.15525992214679718,
-0.7002467513084412,
0.2691746652126312,
-0.07106894254684448,
0.08650368452072144,
0.06488765776157379,
0.4960293769836426,
-0.5272290110588074,
0.46273690462112427,
0.17656762897968292,
-0.18160399794578552,
0.344301700592041,
-0.035188134759664536,
-0.008802033960819244,
-1.161104440689087,
-0.5727792978286743,
0.15260030329227448,
-0.02846659906208515,
-0.6997921466827393,
0.23899511992931366,
0.39705124497413635,
0.20554675161838531,
-1.0532219409942627,
0.6065784692764282,
-0.27060166001319885,
0.04562703147530556,
-0.14761045575141907,
-0.23506638407707214,
0.053256068378686905,
0.4471396207809448,
-0.11955191195011139,
0.720641016960144,
0.4526122212409973,
-1.0046367645263672,
-0.05974283814430237,
0.21246445178985596,
-0.2013726383447647,
0.402272492647171,
-0.4790724515914917,
0.42917150259017944,
-0.08738554269075394,
0.1675371378660202,
-1.2336007356643677,
-0.01935104839503765,
0.20985624194145203,
-0.25361019372940063,
0.5191482305526733,
-0.28404632210731506,
-0.33557453751564026,
-0.12807859480381012,
-0.3918589651584625,
0.22123806178569794,
0.6269740462303162,
-0.912355363368988,
0.294043630361557,
-0.21186597645282745,
0.10065411031246185,
-0.7995418906211853,
-0.6773862242698669,
-0.1725752055644989,
-0.24414920806884766,
-0.2653108537197113,
0.08913660794496536,
-0.28280267119407654,
-0.3641645312309265,
-0.18292471766471863,
-0.0942273810505867,
-0.15853171050548553,
0.24056977033615112,
0.1706366389989853,
0.1377343386411667,
-0.2870821952819824,
0.21612931787967682,
-0.18749259412288666,
0.04584838077425957,
-0.11436078697443008,
-0.2676042318344116,
0.13169600069522858,
-0.3168448805809021,
-0.5252187252044678,
-0.3066273629665375,
0.06707991659641266,
0.37611114978790283,
0.22772671282291412,
0.24602638185024261,
0.2071731984615326,
-0.4365224540233612,
-0.3142065703868866,
-0.27048471570014954,
-0.5828374624252319,
-0.4363258481025696,
0.3227105736732483,
-0.48583748936653137,
-0.6892873644828796,
0.11600175499916077,
-0.27914154529571533,
0.526608943939209,
0.18122833967208862,
0.17581437528133392,
-0.6634914875030518,
0.7264125943183899,
1.0460638999938965,
-0.18777014315128326,
0.3463931381702423,
-0.49648213386535645,
0.21634985506534576,
-0.8554089665412903,
0.0846155509352684,
-0.21038073301315308,
-0.3132173418998718,
-0.4182516038417816,
-0.49330368638038635,
0.6078964471817017,
0.5125044584274292,
-0.47583165764808655,
0.17357327044010162,
0.004470003303140402,
0.5041364431381226,
0.7545281052589417,
0.2257097214460373,
0.25902071595191956,
-0.03497876226902008,
-0.40063825249671936,
-0.23793455958366394,
-0.923102080821991,
-0.4691272974014282,
1.2029519081115723,
0.21056461334228516,
0.9402536749839783,
0.16070351004600525,
1.187779188156128,
0.04159987345337868,
0.36703193187713623,
-0.9080033302307129,
0.46237245202064514,
0.10861790180206299,
-0.5981160402297974,
-0.27856606245040894,
-0.1239737719297409,
-0.6931817531585693,
0.19132213294506073,
-0.052280228585004807,
-0.7113247513771057,
0.29333531856536865,
0.5429514050483704,
-0.6972078680992126,
0.4172329008579254,
-0.7111583352088928,
0.5189277529716492,
-0.2284235805273056,
-0.48782113194465637,
-0.16809220612049103,
-0.698453962802887,
0.6865935921669006,
-0.13458561897277832,
0.04846590757369995,
0.1846202164888382,
-0.11500539630651474,
0.4041450619697571,
-0.2879347801208496,
1.2594796419143677,
-0.2765922546386719,
0.08617083728313446,
0.5521970987319946,
0.1504066437482834,
0.6526229977607727,
0.013299282640218735,
0.09237873554229736,
-0.008163472637534142,
-0.1969936192035675,
-0.3690668046474457,
-0.7799810171127319,
0.4363669753074646,
-0.7871306538581848,
-0.5535447001457214,
-0.40555790066719055,
-0.47918540239334106,
-0.5094013214111328,
0.0221402570605278,
0.4685724377632141,
0.3745695650577545,
-0.2351120561361313,
0.24426519870758057,
0.7250587940216064,
0.07948195189237595,
0.8394747972488403,
0.5395804047584534,
0.005473055876791477,
-0.30135297775268555,
0.49256107211112976,
0.061608824878931046,
0.4297665059566498,
0.502093493938446,
0.33263862133026123,
-0.35611727833747864,
-0.49889713525772095,
-0.47093290090560913,
0.091108538210392,
-1.0590516328811646,
-0.3390960097312927,
-0.5413650274276733,
-0.2214263528585434,
-0.265063613653183,
-0.348041832447052,
-0.3290490508079529,
-0.11378226429224014,
-0.32591208815574646,
-0.1305190473794937,
0.24547839164733887,
0.6986858248710632,
-0.2187473028898239,
0.29121822118759155,
-0.9420114159584045,
0.21614257991313934,
0.7379366159439087,
-0.1393614560365677,
-0.151458740234375,
-0.7744664549827576,
-0.22612252831459045,
-0.00248835701495409,
-0.7227426171302795,
-0.71946781873703,
0.18061761558055878,
0.3903401494026184,
0.5846124291419983,
0.6600082516670227,
-0.022547902539372444,
0.8960438966751099,
-0.6627439260482788,
0.8619107007980347,
0.2852317988872528,
-0.8226007223129272,
0.6075341105461121,
-0.021173402667045593,
0.29311591386795044,
0.6704908013343811,
0.5092751383781433,
-0.46210238337516785,
-0.08166215568780899,
-0.746908962726593,
-0.4753454327583313,
0.6727659106254578,
-0.05866654962301254,
0.17466723918914795,
0.15498501062393188,
0.529201328754425,
0.17086027562618256,
0.15565988421440125,
-0.7277505993843079,
-0.16934651136398315,
-0.027951359748840332,
-0.10389204323291779,
-0.19567881524562836,
-0.004077470395714045,
-0.3057180941104889,
-0.2640002369880676,
0.6530122756958008,
-0.540437638759613,
0.20891809463500977,
0.15843357145786285,
-0.3075809180736542,
-0.104261614382267,
0.2758524715900421,
0.8009691834449768,
0.9786231517791748,
-0.05925927311182022,
0.22402457892894745,
0.5213149189949036,
-0.2857404947280884,
0.4290003180503845,
-0.19544892013072968,
-0.5377194881439209,
-0.25035980343818665,
0.431780070066452,
0.7106903791427612,
0.47273901104927063,
-0.41764771938323975,
0.3778156042098999,
0.1698649525642395,
-0.19752821326255798,
0.0030119596049189568,
0.38980090618133545,
-0.012993646785616875,
0.3694990575313568,
0.6442760825157166,
0.224959596991539,
0.12674956023693085,
-0.6298908591270447,
0.5209214091300964,
0.30312806367874146,
-0.5006089210510254,
-0.3422638773918152,
0.42768290638923645,
-0.035813670605421066,
-0.29417121410369873,
0.4733463227748871,
-0.14641359448432922,
-0.2517280578613281,
0.6109781265258789,
0.884214460849762,
0.8681787848472595,
-0.08434587717056274,
0.3043808043003082,
0.43710485100746155,
0.33604687452316284,
-0.21887145936489105,
0.2292247861623764,
-0.21053588390350342,
-0.9374026656150818,
-0.3613201379776001,
-0.1730043590068817,
-0.7637119889259338,
0.13797543942928314,
-0.5666641592979431,
0.4779800474643707,
-0.8507270216941833,
0.26567432284355164,
-0.2880800664424896,
0.04810202866792679,
-0.6886023879051208,
0.2990354299545288,
0.057383760809898376,
0.9657785296440125,
-0.8495194911956787,
0.7446848154067993,
0.8239661455154419,
-0.4185532033443451,
-1.0501621961593628,
0.39008456468582153,
0.44125139713287354,
-1.0965162515640259,
0.9272482395172119,
-0.09357471764087677,
-0.03771892935037613,
0.06582364439964294,
-0.8762010931968689,
-0.8535818457603455,
0.9546623826026917,
0.23663853108882904,
-0.49755313992500305,
0.04244692251086235,
-0.18949636816978455,
0.12562096118927002,
-0.4985421597957611,
0.18947789072990417,
0.33014604449272156,
0.19003784656524658,
0.23207950592041016,
-0.6621930599212646,
-0.2411165088415146,
0.041959162801504135,
-0.1751394271850586,
0.06199139356613159,
-0.8062243461608887,
0.899039626121521,
-0.7589179277420044,
0.04218714311718941,
-0.18400448560714722,
0.4755997657775879,
0.7960483431816101,
0.7148503065109253,
0.5309853553771973,
0.3816280663013458,
0.752102792263031,
0.02635580115020275,
0.9389546513557434,
-0.015722842887043953,
0.35046079754829407,
1.3137954473495483,
-0.4542748034000397,
1.1187291145324707,
0.706662118434906,
-0.23726199567317963,
0.4176725447177887,
0.8626013994216919,
0.4128812849521637,
0.7850823998451233,
-0.031405963003635406,
-0.13068675994873047,
-0.09569764137268066,
0.4149044454097748,
-0.12450644373893738,
0.422706663608551,
0.42079246044158936,
-0.049174241721630096,
-0.508742094039917,
0.1329357922077179,
-0.009402298368513584,
-0.05199529230594635,
-0.4002598226070404,
0.9874371886253357,
0.37606528401374817,
-0.5649684071540833,
0.7111530303955078,
-0.32259249687194824,
0.5974763631820679,
-0.5811590552330017,
-0.43686556816101074,
-0.46845543384552,
0.32850584387779236,
0.007277869153767824,
-0.6643276214599609,
0.01672707498073578,
-0.03653639182448387,
-0.274140864610672,
-0.16627931594848633,
0.8254186511039734,
-0.13475781679153442,
-0.4720848500728607,
0.061554014682769775,
0.6371569633483887,
0.26580503582954407,
0.1539677381515503,
-0.7775576114654541,
-0.3928276002407074,
-0.08105740696191788,
-0.08393563330173492,
0.33591020107269287,
0.32967209815979004,
0.023465415462851524,
0.6490991115570068,
0.44342777132987976,
0.10086161643266678,
0.27922600507736206,
-0.24533137679100037,
0.6839868426322937,
-0.9251835346221924,
-0.5555298924446106,
-0.7883329391479492,
0.5687373876571655,
0.09894584119319916,
-0.5189895033836365,
0.741051197052002,
0.2899208068847656,
1.1730045080184937,
-0.01302157063037157,
0.9011104106903076,
0.21249112486839294,
0.4848982095718384,
-0.7913014888763428,
0.26376771926879883,
-0.5494688153266907,
0.18980973958969116,
-0.3618262708187103,
-0.8372367024421692,
-0.38150766491889954,
0.5436204075813293,
-0.18393495678901672,
0.055759280920028687,
0.8419163823127747,
0.6630375385284424,
-0.13852818310260773,
-0.1876750886440277,
0.678699254989624,
0.021002551540732384,
0.3549276888370514,
0.8654065132141113,
1.0082836151123047,
-0.713215172290802,
0.4691501557826996,
-0.3538738489151001,
-0.03985624387860298,
-0.4326266050338745,
-0.9589955806732178,
-0.6228262782096863,
-0.5178238153457642,
-0.4174428880214691,
-0.4116123616695404,
0.14386025071144104,
1.1470763683319092,
0.9411343336105347,
-0.7386516332626343,
-0.28370577096939087,
-0.3197494447231293,
0.3975411057472229,
-0.666274905204773,
-0.20417983829975128,
0.137663334608078,
-0.775137722492218,
-0.5750504732131958,
0.6702086329460144,
0.39729517698287964,
0.21788853406906128,
0.1146610900759697,
-0.5352293252944946,
-0.15522031486034393,
0.058002766221761703,
0.7197086811065674,
0.6488208174705505,
-0.6819612383842468,
-0.34552693367004395,
0.15356270968914032,
-0.048525046557188034,
0.4042759835720062,
1.013149619102478,
-0.6728003621101379,
0.2854517996311188,
0.42125070095062256,
0.9129409790039062,
0.38912278413772583,
-0.06537829339504242,
0.33439546823501587,
-0.7332026958465576,
0.08728676289319992,
0.2818049192428589,
0.3012513816356659,
0.2271508276462555,
-0.3736041486263275,
0.524929404258728,
0.30503034591674805,
-0.3361191153526306,
-0.6502613425254822,
0.24271073937416077,
-0.5396538376808167,
-0.13700902462005615,
1.307803988456726,
-0.28926903009414673,
-0.213067889213562,
-0.13688527047634125,
-0.1256874054670334,
-0.003448073985055089,
-0.24257105588912964,
0.761600136756897,
0.6803909540176392,
-0.6568672060966492,
-0.4740995466709137,
-0.4809883236885071,
0.6403731107711792,
0.6079985499382019,
-0.812399685382843,
-0.20883046090602875,
0.4448885917663574,
0.4343605041503906,
-0.031957339495420456,
0.744411826133728,
-0.06367176026105881,
0.5659341812133789,
-0.2335970401763916,
-0.053970545530319214,
0.23907630145549774,
-0.6141913533210754,
-0.6201995611190796,
0.12462153285741806,
0.42912381887435913,
-0.5308731198310852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10941v1 | Text2Data: Low-Resource Data Generation with Textual Control | 2024-02-08T03:41:39 | 2024-02-08T03:41:39 | Shiyu Wang, Yihao Feng, Tian Lan, Ning Yu, Yu Bai, Ran Xu, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural language serves as a common and straightforward control signal for
humans to interact seamlessly with machines. Recognizing the importance of this
interface, the machine learning community is investing considerable effort in
generating data that is semantically coherent with textual instructions. While
strides have been made in text-to-data generation spanning image editing, audio
synthesis, video creation, and beyond, low-resource areas characterized by
expensive annotations or complex data structures, such as molecules, motion
dynamics, and time series, often lack textual labels. This deficiency impedes
supervised learning, thereby constraining the application of advanced
generative models for text-to-data tasks. In response to these challenges in
the low-resource scenario, we propose Text2Data, a novel approach that utilizes
unlabeled data to understand the underlying data distribution through an
unsupervised diffusion model. Subsequently, it undergoes controllable
finetuning via a novel constraint optimization-based learning objective that
ensures controllability and effectively counteracts catastrophic forgetting.
Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that Text2Data is able to achieve
enhanced performance regarding controllability across various modalities,
including molecules, motions and time series, when compared to existing
baselines. | [
-0.005905746482312679,
-1.025346279144287,
0.4816378951072693,
0.11540381610393524,
-0.1190742701292038,
0.14580757915973663,
-0.3889504075050354,
-0.1693238466978073,
-0.0783822312951088,
0.6188209652900696,
-0.6122558116912842,
-0.5571320652961731,
-0.5938118100166321,
-0.11889690160751343,
-0.3753996193408966,
1.3400006294250488,
-0.35808372497558594,
-0.25182032585144043,
-0.44159919023513794,
-0.11147738248109818,
-0.39975717663764954,
-0.26674073934555054,
-0.5692199468612671,
-0.5150626301765442,
0.310896098613739,
0.6185020804405212,
0.6932083368301392,
0.7361119389533997,
0.3068307936191559,
0.17314405739307404,
0.014898133464157581,
0.5136111974716187,
-0.6928697824478149,
0.08816921710968018,
-0.27443307638168335,
-0.4038515090942383,
-0.06187182292342186,
0.021321909502148628,
0.37940743565559387,
0.7515790462493896,
-0.10423853248357773,
0.1238933876156807,
0.4252980947494507,
0.9070240259170532,
-0.5357012748718262,
0.13714320957660675,
-0.5195692181587219,
0.19678425788879395,
-0.28277215361595154,
-0.2391640841960907,
-0.3801146447658539,
-0.25452080368995667,
0.07854225486516953,
-0.9348554611206055,
0.3010932505130768,
-0.19575655460357666,
0.5780796408653259,
0.7865224480628967,
-0.4415307343006134,
-0.6873244643211365,
-0.8942511677742004,
0.8116655349731445,
-0.06852077692747116,
0.08024132251739502,
0.7858645915985107,
0.05535198375582695,
-0.12744712829589844,
-0.817022442817688,
-0.4955919682979584,
0.3242294490337372,
-0.15188360214233398,
0.21760191023349762,
-0.3181357681751251,
-0.2312832921743393,
0.008636623620986938,
-0.15633225440979004,
-0.5408395528793335,
0.2385532557964325,
-0.3461989164352417,
-0.1870933473110199,
0.427805095911026,
0.18060468137264252,
0.19233235716819763,
-0.36005017161369324,
-0.39747416973114014,
-0.018531907349824905,
-0.25053611397743225,
-0.12984305620193481,
0.3193308413028717,
0.3149673640727997,
-0.3900599777698517,
0.8191116452217102,
-0.13539506494998932,
0.29623401165008545,
-0.07598976790904999,
0.08750101178884506,
0.055553995072841644,
-0.4439598023891449,
-0.21154500544071198,
0.16765956580638885,
0.9620836973190308,
0.46174225211143494,
0.09961079061031342,
-0.33043113350868225,
-0.07970784604549408,
0.11295809596776962,
0.20792537927627563,
-0.9753210544586182,
-0.5295686721801758,
0.19607624411582947,
-0.4684615135192871,
-0.40972933173179626,
-0.20443688333034515,
-1.1879750490188599,
-0.5142250061035156,
-0.5218583345413208,
0.23897716403007507,
-0.5119557976722717,
-0.03938866779208183,
-0.02769865095615387,
-0.09235081076622009,
-0.26639366149902344,
0.2621336877346039,
-1.1588728427886963,
0.41527053713798523,
0.4088585376739502,
1.075265884399414,
-0.503568172454834,
0.22860638797283173,
-0.28562742471694946,
0.48438239097595215,
-0.49129945039749146,
0.5846217274665833,
-0.4428124725818634,
-0.5640096664428711,
-0.22554205358028412,
-0.2410093992948532,
0.1618245393037796,
-0.5922371745109558,
0.322702556848526,
-0.2701827883720398,
0.30468615889549255,
0.05297650396823883,
-0.5364883542060852,
0.021378040313720703,
-0.2079719752073288,
-0.7569075226783752,
1.2294559478759766,
0.265413373708725,
-0.821638286113739,
0.31108129024505615,
-0.7439123392105103,
-0.549492597579956,
-0.09754933416843414,
-0.33268123865127563,
-0.8014242053031921,
-0.13946308195590973,
-0.09997030347585678,
0.3781103193759918,
-0.46560510993003845,
0.4719443917274475,
0.09035637229681015,
-0.08745414763689041,
0.20001152157783508,
-0.8152165412902832,
0.4162479043006897,
0.2827651798725128,
-0.32786500453948975,
-0.27150025963783264,
-0.9251896739006042,
0.10171257704496384,
0.15053385496139526,
-0.6589707136154175,
-0.4825575649738312,
0.28286248445510864,
0.583836555480957,
-0.06493669748306274,
0.25283342599868774,
-0.34861862659454346,
0.19194403290748596,
-0.20516173541545868,
0.4724540710449219,
0.5741780400276184,
0.19793882966041565,
0.7766071557998657,
-0.08971505612134933,
0.2898697257041931,
-0.02105693332850933,
-0.24337129294872284,
-0.034370437264442444,
-0.3282143175601959,
-0.6023027300834656,
-0.005581969395279884,
0.2951367199420929,
0.7301349639892578,
-1.0621049404144287,
0.23010362684726715,
-0.08233978599309921,
-0.2930411398410797,
-0.46020275354385376,
0.531578540802002,
0.40272998809814453,
0.6577574610710144,
0.7250184416770935,
0.08740026503801346,
-0.5398342609405518,
-0.7549230456352234,
0.16445370018482208,
0.1618659794330597,
-0.40059301257133484,
0.2954968512058258,
0.4572206139564514,
-0.6308249235153198,
1.142291784286499,
-0.7100452184677124,
-0.48258501291275024,
-0.12832581996917725,
0.5890714526176453,
-0.2879841923713684,
0.7818422317504883,
0.48424282670021057,
-0.9006146788597107,
-0.14325262606143951,
0.09002836048603058,
-0.8411739468574524,
-0.22345654666423798,
-0.43300601840019226,
-0.42524972558021545,
0.5534048676490784,
0.5433766841888428,
-0.406636118888855,
0.3219008147716522,
0.5818061828613281,
-0.43536248803138733,
-0.0625830590724945,
-0.46492627263069153,
-0.2537725269794464,
-1.2426483631134033,
0.25734519958496094,
0.06103041395545006,
-0.05335277318954468,
-0.4349242150783539,
-0.6530358791351318,
0.046155039221048355,
-0.08769644796848297,
-0.1704401969909668,
0.45859092473983765,
-0.23483899235725403,
0.15582317113876343,
-0.14829596877098083,
-0.06527655571699142,
-0.06998249143362045,
0.4810536205768585,
0.19575177133083344,
0.7145810723304749,
0.17467916011810303,
-0.6857221722602844,
0.16682420670986176,
0.5085225105285645,
-0.2989041805267334,
0.5006258487701416,
-0.5032796263694763,
0.013034830801188946,
-0.43893831968307495,
-0.058162469416856766,
-0.830953061580658,
-0.5450383424758911,
0.1786673367023468,
-0.4682912826538086,
0.33252426981925964,
0.01920992136001587,
-0.572014570236206,
-0.05722518265247345,
-0.10548287630081177,
0.38354986906051636,
0.6928529143333435,
-0.4499278962612152,
0.27954602241516113,
0.5154668688774109,
-0.19605757296085358,
-0.08014222234487534,
-1.061608076095581,
0.0053820800967514515,
-0.05703219398856163,
-0.021854061633348465,
0.330535888671875,
-0.09540043026208878,
-0.14267215132713318,
0.18099191784858704,
0.0800195261836052,
-0.4673907160758972,
0.0526810884475708,
0.3942636251449585,
0.16040293872356415,
0.3079831302165985,
0.4319203495979309,
0.6937605142593384,
-0.35833197832107544,
-0.0015573007985949516,
-0.4759279489517212,
0.34259316325187683,
0.6507851481437683,
0.0980900228023529,
-0.713138222694397,
0.44465357065200806,
0.18196910619735718,
0.06884082406759262,
0.4957708418369293,
0.5271567106246948,
-0.44567763805389404,
-0.5363380908966064,
0.28436478972435,
0.040848616510629654,
-0.48926013708114624,
0.4280395209789276,
-0.018105557188391685,
-0.6641885042190552,
-0.05327599123120308,
-0.3159012496471405,
0.005274365656077862,
0.43887847661972046,
0.6301805377006531,
-0.5860524773597717,
0.6850414872169495,
0.6749972701072693,
0.23829996585845947,
0.3258739709854126,
-0.47079697251319885,
-0.2616889476776123,
-0.4148727059364319,
-0.6102275848388672,
-0.4390750527381897,
-0.5789558291435242,
-0.711677074432373,
-0.6585915684700012,
0.21335600316524506,
0.3202749788761139,
-0.33804017305374146,
0.09836947172880173,
-0.7112674713134766,
0.4294789135456085,
0.4760533273220062,
0.20534859597682953,
0.23985795676708221,
0.1893007755279541,
-0.018012940883636475,
-0.3318183720111847,
-0.5934520363807678,
-0.7250791192054749,
1.2374732494354248,
0.1205441951751709,
0.9414859414100647,
0.17214156687259674,
0.44619765877723694,
0.6076018214225769,
0.00011643950711004436,
-0.7022620439529419,
0.245467871427536,
-0.4754747152328491,
-0.18764346837997437,
-0.28492113947868347,
-0.6576139330863953,
-1.003091812133789,
-0.2226993441581726,
-0.40790995955467224,
-0.49539947509765625,
-0.04040488228201866,
0.32539090514183044,
-0.17389245331287384,
0.20439322292804718,
-0.9370347857475281,
0.683136522769928,
-0.12060105055570602,
-0.5531182885169983,
0.09713978320360184,
-0.5506907105445862,
0.17703405022621155,
-0.4176294207572937,
0.17389822006225586,
-0.0625053346157074,
-0.3580028712749481,
1.082571029663086,
-0.486197292804718,
1.021193265914917,
-0.21104080975055695,
-0.16649110615253448,
0.5308627486228943,
0.20094788074493408,
0.5535109043121338,
0.16344387829303741,
0.07817091792821884,
-0.044851887971162796,
-0.28658583760261536,
-0.40166595578193665,
-0.3251783847808838,
0.6324244737625122,
-0.7192898392677307,
0.2946235239505768,
-0.024679936468601227,
-0.5909191966056824,
-0.1826174557209015,
0.21723876893520355,
0.6012805700302124,
0.3549838662147522,
-0.17302779853343964,
0.26157116889953613,
0.8634072542190552,
-0.32778841257095337,
0.7378123998641968,
0.21961237490177155,
0.16209851205348969,
-0.4448307454586029,
1.1127197742462158,
0.2992795705795288,
0.26031455397605896,
0.6625030040740967,
-0.08530094474554062,
-0.3328688442707062,
-0.4531581699848175,
-0.6151229739189148,
-0.11388417333364487,
-0.2317427396774292,
-0.3541886508464813,
-0.7450335621833801,
0.020878804847598076,
-0.016180813312530518,
-0.2684023380279541,
-0.5106821060180664,
-0.5489397644996643,
-0.8416445255279541,
-0.30802181363105774,
0.6404180526733398,
0.7358359098434448,
-0.05044841393828392,
0.47829917073249817,
-0.540799617767334,
0.6321191787719727,
0.16345064342021942,
0.43480372428894043,
-0.20382381975650787,
-0.08166193962097168,
-0.3030165433883667,
0.14623785018920898,
-0.4651930034160614,
-0.6056888103485107,
0.2403961420059204,
0.2187359482049942,
-0.05725235491991043,
0.23516997694969177,
0.24947603046894073,
0.18885789811611176,
-0.6019731760025024,
0.5755853652954102,
0.31394559144973755,
-0.8181933760643005,
0.7961519360542297,
-0.32648158073425293,
0.2917332947254181,
0.4868088364601135,
0.38232871890068054,
-0.2967657744884491,
-0.31716686487197876,
-0.29868948459625244,
-0.9615941643714905,
0.7055704593658447,
0.49890559911727905,
0.23632577061653137,
0.23023702204227448,
0.36171749234199524,
0.2715167999267578,
0.2228168249130249,
-0.38292789459228516,
-0.15944519639015198,
-0.3991585969924927,
-0.7750319838523865,
-0.06992901861667633,
-0.3157593309879303,
-0.08859333395957947,
0.06812961399555206,
0.3181130588054657,
-0.26381680369377136,
0.2270505726337433,
0.11317885667085648,
0.02838079445064068,
-0.12641513347625732,
0.1610613763332367,
0.45254865288734436,
0.09127167612314224,
0.06998694688081741,
0.2821601629257202,
-0.10873773694038391,
-0.7785983085632324,
0.2712435722351074,
0.15273141860961914,
-0.6448555588722229,
0.03696243837475777,
0.34115999937057495,
0.8916747570037842,
0.15562470257282257,
-0.7737372517585754,
0.20612071454524994,
0.13536155223846436,
-0.5384491682052612,
-0.010638083331286907,
0.06707558035850525,
0.0017198094865307212,
0.05690770223736763,
0.26796579360961914,
0.24304887652397156,
0.04945690929889679,
-0.15336158871650696,
0.4740225672721863,
0.12220794707536697,
-0.4917092025279999,
-0.31586140394210815,
1.2261085510253906,
0.33775395154953003,
0.11203503608703613,
0.496745228767395,
-0.25285235047340393,
0.04780564084649086,
0.5910810232162476,
0.4560607671737671,
0.48413679003715515,
0.018120285123586655,
0.5302814841270447,
0.2565764784812927,
0.3016527593135834,
-0.05532669648528099,
0.3520606756210327,
-0.1736724078655243,
-0.560285210609436,
-0.10185731947422028,
-0.6478487849235535,
-0.16614864766597748,
0.009139173664152622,
-0.6623638272285461,
0.07810261100530624,
-0.6649105548858643,
-0.1812674105167389,
0.118672676384449,
-0.029630612581968307,
-0.42546743154525757,
0.3326287269592285,
-0.1703227460384369,
0.7065951824188232,
-0.7390324473381042,
0.8620081543922424,
0.3143884539604187,
-0.3331047296524048,
-0.45157545804977417,
-0.004214727785438299,
0.19666312634944916,
-0.4512435495853424,
0.582892656326294,
0.11206554621458054,
0.03718170151114464,
0.18671002984046936,
-0.5962091088294983,
-0.47148847579956055,
1.211394190788269,
0.2578134536743164,
-0.5600751638412476,
-0.0592028945684433,
0.3065910041332245,
0.49788326025009155,
0.10761058330535889,
-0.29475051164627075,
0.7041971683502197,
0.5966659188270569,
0.2215396612882614,
-0.45178771018981934,
-0.15541547536849976,
-0.13895373046398163,
0.11387746781110764,
0.4815017879009247,
-0.47225090861320496,
0.6560717821121216,
-0.357766717672348,
-0.42669999599456787,
0.057579509913921356,
0.6135334968566895,
-0.10372647643089294,
0.47706058621406555,
0.014527394436299801,
0.6484953761100769,
0.9265739321708679,
-0.2951555550098419,
0.8715104460716248,
0.10458803921937943,
0.4416407346725464,
1.260852336883545,
-0.09683524817228317,
0.7703956961631775,
0.5115543603897095,
-0.13118354976177216,
0.20892155170440674,
0.5284199714660645,
-0.08379936963319778,
0.8532462120056152,
0.0302754957228899,
-0.2606365382671356,
0.14396266639232635,
-0.35959556698799133,
0.0341225191950798,
0.42563506960868835,
0.4119407832622528,
-0.2715700566768646,
-0.21439513564109802,
0.3404552936553955,
0.2494114190340042,
0.5493014454841614,
-0.29237183928489685,
0.9951344132423401,
-0.26998019218444824,
-0.19847868382930756,
0.4783911108970642,
0.1711420863866806,
0.7972891926765442,
-0.48195257782936096,
-0.09921861439943314,
-0.2392735481262207,
0.1876952201128006,
-0.2849808931350708,
-0.9593293070793152,
0.5225293636322021,
0.45139819383621216,
-0.580797553062439,
-0.5012627243995667,
0.3491681218147278,
-0.7976344227790833,
-0.5146981477737427,
0.23423610627651215,
0.17422159016132355,
-0.03145359456539154,
0.36624643206596375,
-0.41390323638916016,
-0.07864934951066971,
0.14998169243335724,
-0.19597236812114716,
0.12033406645059586,
0.6477481126785278,
-0.18481189012527466,
0.5992543697357178,
0.5296330451965332,
0.06761978566646576,
-0.16110891103744507,
-0.2695237994194031,
0.7013983726501465,
-0.6124029755592346,
-0.42964422702789307,
-0.6021650433540344,
0.3314550518989563,
0.005360827781260014,
-0.31199485063552856,
0.2762150764465332,
0.9107363820075989,
0.7798177599906921,
0.12876610457897186,
1.1820743083953857,
-0.1994374543428421,
0.5875207781791687,
-1.0323598384857178,
1.0378928184509277,
-0.4363268315792084,
0.0050128442235291,
0.04474104568362236,
-0.4883482754230499,
-0.13386724889278412,
0.2159622460603714,
0.06851688772439957,
-0.21569615602493286,
0.5359630584716797,
0.6568612456321716,
0.06304890662431717,
-0.160771444439888,
0.007612267974764109,
0.14866222441196442,
0.2966312766075134,
0.8360223770141602,
0.3021352291107178,
-0.3660266399383545,
0.7061655521392822,
-0.10664793103933334,
-0.18319283425807953,
0.08700168877840042,
-0.6102358102798462,
-0.8198615908622742,
-0.7546194791793823,
-0.17939038574695587,
-0.2576240003108978,
-0.17997439205646515,
0.7733579277992249,
0.4682732820510864,
-0.7178543210029602,
0.06751030683517456,
-0.6382786631584167,
-0.009731698781251907,
0.21559065580368042,
-0.2319190800189972,
0.5458133220672607,
-0.1963285654783249,
-0.9356200695037842,
0.2627919018268585,
0.21060442924499512,
0.8043044209480286,
-0.0154263935983181,
-0.2798486351966858,
0.07785561680793762,
0.03455528989434242,
0.5602378249168396,
0.30619949102401733,
-0.22681964933872223,
0.16926296055316925,
-0.3417021632194519,
-0.5312291383743286,
-0.17703679203987122,
0.9131938219070435,
-0.9116767644882202,
0.4260402023792267,
0.21052901446819305,
0.9940098524093628,
0.4762216806411743,
0.11175370216369629,
0.43793919682502747,
-1.0134657621383667,
0.44978201389312744,
0.12717728316783905,
-0.2828359007835388,
0.2913509011268616,
-0.46560728549957275,
0.5677866339683533,
0.2944343090057373,
-0.28944292664527893,
-0.5404298901557922,
0.01554089318960905,
-1.017272710800171,
-0.5656806826591492,
1.0556879043579102,
0.3553082048892975,
-0.020565468817949295,
-0.02601395547389984,
-0.45591971278190613,
0.3979382812976837,
-0.5848572850227356,
0.7068449854850769,
0.3374384045600891,
-0.16091769933700562,
-0.05737191066145897,
-0.8325484395027161,
0.9833629727363586,
0.1985187828540802,
-1.1838446855545044,
0.3614443838596344,
0.7631635069847107,
0.02262272872030735,
-0.15946094691753387,
0.6808074712753296,
0.0851183608174324,
-0.047221843153238297,
-0.0916614755988121,
-0.08420168608427048,
-0.09430129081010818,
-0.4395000636577606,
-0.06933698058128357,
0.2189401537179947,
-0.5559552907943726,
-0.35274291038513184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05376v1 | Zero-Shot Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Guided by Evolutionary Algorithms in Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T03:17:38 | 2024-02-08T03:17:38 | Feihu Jin, Yifan Liu, Ying Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
diverse tasks and exhibited impressive reasoning abilities by applying
zero-shot Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, due to the evolving nature
of sentence prefixes during the pre-training phase, existing zero-shot CoT
prompting methods that employ identical CoT prompting across all task instances
may not be optimal. In this paper, we introduce a novel zero-shot prompting
method that leverages evolutionary algorithms to generate diverse promptings
for LLMs dynamically. Our approach involves initializing two CoT promptings,
performing evolutionary operations based on LLMs to create a varied set, and
utilizing the LLMs to select a suitable CoT prompting for a given problem.
Additionally, a rewriting operation, guided by the selected CoT prompting,
enhances the understanding of the LLMs about the problem. Extensive experiments
conducted across ten reasoning datasets demonstrate the superior performance of
our proposed method compared to current zero-shot CoT prompting methods on
GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. Moreover, in-depth analytical experiments underscore
the adaptability and effectiveness of our method in various reasoning tasks. | [
-0.3750676214694977,
-1.1918367147445679,
0.9875664114952087,
0.05287079140543938,
-0.6201058030128479,
0.3155021071434021,
-0.41332051157951355,
-0.21251314878463745,
0.3581905961036682,
0.2761191129684448,
-1.134079933166504,
-0.522584855556488,
-0.2927416265010834,
0.4376715123653412,
-0.17067955434322357,
0.8095862865447998,
-0.21877720952033997,
-0.2765443027019501,
0.08035185188055038,
0.1064351350069046,
-0.747406542301178,
-0.14936254918575287,
-0.5143873691558838,
-0.2998046278953552,
0.9667212963104248,
0.5075327754020691,
0.42206209897994995,
0.40848472714424133,
-0.10672632604837418,
0.19467060267925262,
-0.17913828790187836,
0.41457438468933105,
-0.4562709629535675,
0.575975775718689,
-0.3637940585613251,
-0.5405163764953613,
-0.07877419888973236,
-0.2784667909145355,
0.4611322581768036,
0.4783012568950653,
-0.01900462992489338,
0.11095035076141357,
-0.3158198595046997,
0.32581910490989685,
-1.0361799001693726,
-0.3034264147281647,
-1.2307820320129395,
0.258223295211792,
0.07029886543750763,
-0.7200790047645569,
-0.5327997207641602,
-0.2769664525985718,
-0.007046943064779043,
-0.5505799055099487,
0.09465836733579636,
-0.12912678718566895,
0.5111835598945618,
0.14132028818130493,
-0.18157243728637695,
-0.4005533754825592,
-0.6579557061195374,
0.7330401539802551,
-0.575936496257782,
0.2719540596008301,
-0.09957428276538849,
0.11034532636404037,
-0.3613206148147583,
-0.41091790795326233,
-0.8589982986450195,
-0.2661486864089966,
0.3983418941497803,
0.07697536796331406,
-0.16540341079235077,
-0.11654139310121536,
0.10753371566534042,
-0.012832505628466606,
-0.5512970685958862,
0.17641757428646088,
-0.2748371958732605,
0.2039632648229599,
0.3739026188850403,
0.018775347620248795,
0.12228874117136002,
0.19665955007076263,
-0.4056502878665924,
0.015433141961693764,
-0.9869264364242554,
-0.1310756504535675,
0.1781613975763321,
0.4018278121948242,
0.07263988256454468,
0.38790348172187805,
-0.379719078540802,
0.871605396270752,
0.19918853044509888,
0.20286498963832855,
0.17762090265750885,
-0.05415920540690422,
-0.3167339563369751,
0.32692140340805054,
0.802871823310852,
0.18519733846187592,
0.5277012586593628,
-0.19025534391403198,
-0.07598037272691727,
0.05475284531712532,
0.2692801058292389,
-0.43487250804901123,
-0.004515663720667362,
0.2228488177061081,
0.06060497462749481,
-0.6261135935783386,
-0.33317697048187256,
-0.9717678427696228,
-0.211131289601326,
-0.18891975283622742,
0.6151068806648254,
-0.4854374825954437,
0.005032581277191639,
0.3373526930809021,
-0.1259155124425888,
0.3987674117088318,
0.3785175681114197,
-1.0200490951538086,
-0.22799281775951385,
0.49186083674430847,
0.9148749113082886,
0.16460363566875458,
-0.49740564823150635,
-0.6743541359901428,
0.27107688784599304,
-0.4810245931148529,
1.0684672594070435,
-0.7524780631065369,
-0.35635268688201904,
-0.024898851290345192,
-0.3317851126194,
-0.06420919299125671,
-0.142518550157547,
0.27078649401664734,
-0.42107582092285156,
0.19315125048160553,
-0.30824795365333557,
-0.33488136529922485,
-0.09933166205883026,
0.6113271117210388,
-0.1118941605091095,
0.8348698019981384,
-0.08870624005794525,
-0.3816578984260559,
0.5540087223052979,
-0.6711375713348389,
-0.3770729899406433,
0.32199692726135254,
-0.5107274055480957,
-0.1973579078912735,
0.3055020570755005,
0.7067915797233582,
0.2700161337852478,
-0.24356286227703094,
0.2114095240831375,
-0.41705894470214844,
-0.43557754158973694,
0.025266757234930992,
-0.5160801410675049,
0.7605473399162292,
0.12773080170154572,
-0.5714928507804871,
0.20365847647190094,
-0.39049288630485535,
0.33919790387153625,
0.41978955268859863,
0.12905536592006683,
-0.11308453977108002,
-0.08257775008678436,
-0.9295012950897217,
0.1469198763370514,
0.07381892949342728,
-0.5193412899971008,
0.6631788015365601,
-0.32316523790359497,
0.5575857162475586,
0.8669223189353943,
0.37529778480529785,
0.10997092723846436,
-0.2598753571510315,
0.6871035695075989,
-0.11620752513408661,
0.19313709437847137,
-0.48255449533462524,
-0.6222254037857056,
-0.7016613483428955,
-0.03861381113529205,
-0.038497280329465866,
0.5654926896095276,
-1.016079306602478,
0.5737022161483765,
-0.15763753652572632,
-0.4743862748146057,
-0.3105747401714325,
0.060925763100385666,
0.28137660026550293,
0.37930727005004883,
0.4293515086174011,
-0.04408363997936249,
-0.3634975254535675,
-0.39291682839393616,
-0.28021690249443054,
-0.20051392912864685,
0.08231215178966522,
0.23094910383224487,
0.42556220293045044,
-0.06421846151351929,
0.9031841158866882,
-0.7051196098327637,
0.4212888479232788,
-0.42374303936958313,
0.4276242256164551,
0.22317154705524445,
0.13189098238945007,
0.564236044883728,
-0.12365584075450897,
-0.16776315867900848,
-0.11703406274318695,
-0.7356074452400208,
-0.4124806523323059,
-0.6578550934791565,
-0.4585159122943878,
-0.12504936754703522,
0.5006938576698303,
-0.6988744735717773,
0.31210440397262573,
0.24865400791168213,
-0.19075754284858704,
0.8583325147628784,
-0.23477301001548767,
0.009423292241990566,
-0.8122113943099976,
-0.07857955247163773,
-0.3045426309108734,
-0.003448251634836197,
-0.6300349235534668,
0.2422768473625183,
-0.0992106944322586,
0.031540919095277786,
-0.5023107528686523,
0.5607153177261353,
-0.6169355511665344,
0.17360448837280273,
-0.25594913959503174,
0.29420095682144165,
-0.0552779845893383,
0.5690581202507019,
0.024124138057231903,
0.7205150723457336,
0.8184456825256348,
-0.6947050094604492,
0.55101478099823,
0.3554396629333496,
-0.0857475996017456,
0.41769957542419434,
-0.4431392550468445,
0.5018816590309143,
-0.3186754882335663,
0.48395851254463196,
-0.6441424489021301,
0.09959578514099121,
0.280667781829834,
-0.2870813310146332,
0.006564044393599033,
-0.021440817043185234,
-0.24082575738430023,
-0.6439038515090942,
-0.5686926245689392,
0.5729718208312988,
0.4940161108970642,
-0.733846127986908,
0.4007273316383362,
-0.44110897183418274,
-0.2520730495452881,
-0.40970948338508606,
-0.47963130474090576,
0.3934626579284668,
-0.10278890281915665,
-0.3505679666996002,
0.18256783485412598,
-0.13586489856243134,
0.1414884477853775,
-0.18813231587409973,
-0.24341991543769836,
0.19416910409927368,
-0.1078629195690155,
-0.14041444659233093,
0.5018478035926819,
-0.23732075095176697,
0.09302805364131927,
0.30381619930267334,
0.03313303738832474,
-0.062097206711769104,
-0.6362453103065491,
0.9010376930236816,
0.08377359062433243,
-0.3245287835597992,
-0.3708365857601166,
0.13751542568206787,
0.5472869277000427,
-0.33984655141830444,
0.577595591545105,
0.1850278675556183,
0.00464749475941062,
-0.6888813972473145,
-0.5536593198776245,
-0.3177501857280731,
-0.5096507668495178,
-0.11525377631187439,
-0.4282967150211334,
-0.8928202390670776,
0.31153982877731323,
-0.23040394484996796,
0.10814465582370758,
0.027294546365737915,
0.9161481857299805,
0.10426752269268036,
0.7684975862503052,
0.10766593366861343,
0.16812372207641602,
0.5897749066352844,
-0.2473125159740448,
0.55875164270401,
-0.8693341612815857,
-0.2557719349861145,
-0.25038227438926697,
-0.35562461614608765,
-0.33907949924468994,
-0.42663753032684326,
0.30328643321990967,
0.23826903104782104,
-0.49471521377563477,
0.24527116119861603,
-0.7903160452842712,
0.8891454935073853,
0.47913411259651184,
0.16999027132987976,
0.1777510792016983,
0.058416761457920074,
-0.5661454796791077,
0.6503040790557861,
-0.7202399373054504,
-0.33809736371040344,
0.9743475914001465,
-0.052894555032253265,
0.6285430192947388,
-0.07509616017341614,
1.0363597869873047,
0.024120289832353592,
-0.0023283762857317924,
-0.8226000070571899,
0.7805401086807251,
0.1917080283164978,
-0.39876627922058105,
-0.30125534534454346,
-0.4074660837650299,
-1.1336655616760254,
0.18378688395023346,
-0.36601200699806213,
-1.0859203338623047,
0.20109471678733826,
0.181134432554245,
-0.8564613461494446,
0.443752646446228,
-0.504096269607544,
0.4512798488140106,
-0.46988794207572937,
-0.2584919035434723,
-0.08807720988988876,
-0.5645681619644165,
0.39993607997894287,
-0.15442535281181335,
-0.1248946338891983,
-0.17351719737052917,
-0.06336948275566101,
0.20965959131717682,
-0.4544581174850464,
0.5970059633255005,
-0.08324513584375381,
-0.10986851155757904,
0.5716772675514221,
0.38876500725746155,
0.6413725018501282,
-0.10522094368934631,
-0.17906740307807922,
-0.05042264237999916,
-0.19072438776493073,
-0.3716503977775574,
-0.7763047218322754,
0.7057847380638123,
-0.5296416878700256,
-0.7637446522712708,
-0.3789084851741791,
-0.5317379236221313,
-0.49268779158592224,
0.27258217334747314,
0.38151460886001587,
0.2445056289434433,
0.11867177486419678,
-0.0716201514005661,
0.4237353205680847,
-0.37856200337409973,
0.5364462733268738,
0.3931315839290619,
-0.14955808222293854,
-0.28887519240379333,
0.6746196150779724,
-0.10725659132003784,
0.5093784332275391,
0.19986338913440704,
0.36704757809638977,
-0.25074303150177,
-0.6759094595909119,
-0.6954907178878784,
0.17928104102611542,
-0.5389386415481567,
-0.3317703306674957,
-0.5253936648368835,
-0.10270664095878601,
-0.2080482840538025,
-0.7618488669395447,
0.041145361959934235,
-0.22388972342014313,
-0.12368191033601761,
-0.1815478354692459,
0.5307099223136902,
0.6573204398155212,
0.21420015394687653,
0.21616321802139282,
-0.7389784455299377,
0.38988223671913147,
0.5429962873458862,
0.4387229084968567,
0.3115169107913971,
-0.2739405930042267,
0.34373292326927185,
0.2419956922531128,
-0.5525582432746887,
-1.0491453409194946,
0.14759935438632965,
0.0785595029592514,
0.5139614343643188,
0.4207022786140442,
0.15169735252857208,
0.8762476444244385,
-0.7060983777046204,
1.0315871238708496,
0.47322046756744385,
-1.0470335483551025,
0.8876414895057678,
-0.5779616832733154,
0.643153965473175,
0.617039144039154,
0.13498495519161224,
-0.47493791580200195,
-0.5773603916168213,
-0.5635756850242615,
-0.8652820587158203,
0.5553529858589172,
0.27495092153549194,
0.24724212288856506,
-0.417912095785141,
0.6013370752334595,
0.13116419315338135,
0.1786423623561859,
-0.5132193565368652,
0.06977055966854095,
-0.14123044908046722,
-0.012966093607246876,
0.31334543228149414,
0.05603243038058281,
0.04912601038813591,
-0.2804507315158844,
0.5559998750686646,
-0.3296753168106079,
0.3445770740509033,
0.29589906334877014,
-0.06017008796334267,
-0.28063762187957764,
0.5829373598098755,
0.8083463907241821,
0.6161179542541504,
-0.09384804964065552,
0.13403332233428955,
0.7348340153694153,
-0.15001171827316284,
0.3571542501449585,
-0.44590461254119873,
-0.34240153431892395,
-0.06294983625411987,
0.3922559320926666,
1.050397276878357,
0.09210304915904999,
-0.589640736579895,
0.3146118223667145,
0.10288212448358536,
-0.4781787395477295,
-0.0025789893697947264,
0.38052573800086975,
-0.05405725538730621,
0.14430435001850128,
0.2779031991958618,
-0.25303027033805847,
-0.33016517758369446,
-0.8063120245933533,
0.009948131628334522,
0.477553129196167,
-0.09024480730295181,
-0.14259344339370728,
0.46078234910964966,
0.21278905868530273,
-0.42244645953178406,
0.5980660915374756,
-0.4584939777851105,
-0.5601020455360413,
0.4046139717102051,
0.7091560959815979,
1.1458048820495605,
-0.20794129371643066,
0.4319480359554291,
0.19409865140914917,
0.12777820229530334,
-0.08851119130849838,
0.4814040958881378,
-0.32096579670906067,
-0.8171348571777344,
-0.6556635499000549,
-0.5623576045036316,
-0.5528273582458496,
0.14679422974586487,
-0.3471145033836365,
0.4914309084415436,
-0.7495430707931519,
0.10171522200107574,
0.12106253951787949,
-0.44303464889526367,
-0.45453107357025146,
0.1410568505525589,
0.5293062925338745,
0.9854731559753418,
-0.5460165143013,
0.730927586555481,
0.47496625781059265,
-0.4043761193752289,
-0.8718706965446472,
0.29524195194244385,
0.16503535211086273,
-1.180749535560608,
0.33806002140045166,
0.04878372326493263,
-0.5508133769035339,
0.10731880366802216,
-0.7560074925422668,
-0.5211906433105469,
1.1689099073410034,
0.3540925979614258,
-0.8731577396392822,
-0.07667426764965057,
0.07764752209186554,
0.3895926773548126,
-0.5737455487251282,
0.41627803444862366,
0.5755596160888672,
0.3367097079753876,
0.6582564115524292,
-0.7240957021713257,
0.17450584471225739,
-0.08207356184720993,
-0.00105824985075742,
0.49083831906318665,
-0.4523297846317291,
0.7755841016769409,
-0.48842334747314453,
-0.07587815821170807,
0.08442699164152145,
0.258147269487381,
0.7551692128181458,
0.1501394361257553,
0.6438248753547668,
0.41482487320899963,
0.832588791847229,
0.05823160335421562,
0.8044261932373047,
-0.3278656005859375,
0.284486323595047,
1.1494126319885254,
-0.6845786571502686,
0.847251832485199,
0.4835565984249115,
0.10106991976499557,
0.9591394066810608,
0.42273491621017456,
-0.2116779088973999,
0.4209854304790497,
0.4190387427806854,
-0.6227939128875732,
-0.3796752095222473,
0.00003812797513091937,
-0.251896470785141,
0.39755257964134216,
0.12655486166477203,
-0.18219278752803802,
-0.5211004614830017,
-0.13047435879707336,
0.11938461661338806,
-0.23444601893424988,
-0.40649840235710144,
0.8801321983337402,
-0.08125688135623932,
-0.9623324275016785,
0.9630651473999023,
-0.3172718584537506,
0.7029795050621033,
-0.6095209121704102,
0.046780917793512344,
-0.1054588034749031,
-0.11105777323246002,
-0.05637899041175842,
-0.9723358750343323,
0.04592207819223404,
0.3647797107696533,
0.09181094169616699,
-0.31569191813468933,
0.44074714183807373,
-0.3942541480064392,
-0.5068219304084778,
0.2514723241329193,
0.5997875332832336,
0.08037019520998001,
-0.0057905325666069984,
-0.5855856537818909,
0.09861116111278534,
0.09820128232240677,
-0.1443442851305008,
0.046788234263658524,
0.638816237449646,
-0.22091680765151978,
0.6780829429626465,
0.9197376370429993,
0.2739073634147644,
0.04560605436563492,
0.3455349802970886,
1.0519521236419678,
-0.8685122728347778,
-0.5589123368263245,
-1.1409934759140015,
0.35336071252822876,
-0.05964551120996475,
-0.4112134277820587,
0.32833394408226013,
0.1338912695646286,
0.5901402831077576,
-0.01948440819978714,
0.8182700872421265,
0.06604119390249252,
0.03434352949261665,
-0.5725700855255127,
0.3847769498825073,
-0.3380657136440277,
0.23929303884506226,
-0.2291548103094101,
-1.0393694639205933,
-0.43435779213905334,
0.6766082048416138,
-0.5750635266304016,
0.10470649600028992,
0.940608024597168,
0.8024542927742004,
0.10528958588838577,
0.40956634283065796,
0.26120278239250183,
0.21322666108608246,
0.42762163281440735,
0.8504235148429871,
0.9246684908866882,
0.15344952046871185,
0.5231236219406128,
0.22643230855464935,
-0.310409814119339,
-0.10653208941221237,
-1.2352079153060913,
-0.9419546127319336,
-0.08131803572177887,
-0.26225122809410095,
-0.03917095810174942,
0.39135751128196716,
1.2755966186523438,
0.480060338973999,
-0.7503023147583008,
0.09930714219808578,
-0.6733266115188599,
-0.034323401749134064,
-0.18532933294773102,
-0.16845375299453735,
0.06883656233549118,
-0.6528537273406982,
-0.28355738520622253,
0.6039129495620728,
0.5633835792541504,
-0.06047225371003151,
-0.17621223628520966,
-0.004365929402410984,
-0.4726661145687103,
0.5681193470954895,
0.6351500749588013,
0.3443651497364044,
-0.8413305282592773,
-0.5228229761123657,
-0.021545005962252617,
0.4218321144580841,
-0.028143683448433876,
0.9359137415885925,
-1.0910629034042358,
0.6505744457244873,
0.5251370072364807,
0.3551400601863861,
0.5071752071380615,
-0.18276937305927277,
0.7036371231079102,
-0.7877704501152039,
0.16224563121795654,
0.43151330947875977,
0.3186035454273224,
0.03423935920000076,
-0.3746201992034912,
0.24469786882400513,
0.13151036202907562,
-0.46975216269493103,
-0.7912269830703735,
0.4759913980960846,
-0.9043017029762268,
-0.5200824737548828,
1.2438182830810547,
0.006034597754478455,
-0.18454064428806305,
0.04083896428346634,
-0.3457198143005371,
0.1875937134027481,
-0.38842320442199707,
0.9056249856948853,
0.704542875289917,
-0.37558886408805847,
-0.5166285634040833,
-0.22934800386428833,
0.14730973541736603,
0.5593939423561096,
-0.8424597978591919,
0.14707578718662262,
0.23619882762432098,
0.2522297203540802,
0.04434080794453621,
0.4102593958377838,
0.14533869922161102,
0.38762083649635315,
-0.04723385348916054,
-0.047776855528354645,
-0.19449268281459808,
-0.3456338047981262,
-0.3523162305355072,
-0.027188969776034355,
-0.007046466693282127,
-0.09295004606246948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05374v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05374v2 | CIC: A framework for Culturally-aware Image Captioning | 2024-02-08T03:12:25 | 2024-05-02T02:41:50 | Youngsik Yun, Jihie Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Image Captioning generates descriptive sentences from images using
Vision-Language Pre-trained models (VLPs) such as BLIP, which has improved
greatly. However, current methods lack the generation of detailed descriptive
captions for the cultural elements depicted in the images, such as the
traditional clothing worn by people from Asian cultural groups. In this paper,
we propose a new framework, \textbf{Culturally-aware Image Captioning (CIC)},
that generates captions and describes cultural elements extracted from cultural
visual elements in images representing cultures. Inspired by methods combining
visual modality and Large Language Models (LLMs) through appropriate prompts,
our framework (1) generates questions based on cultural categories from images,
(2) extracts cultural visual elements from Visual Question Answering (VQA)
using generated questions, and (3) generates culturally-aware captions using
LLMs with the prompts. Our human evaluation conducted on 45 participants from 4
different cultural groups with a high understanding of the corresponding
culture shows that our proposed framework generates more culturally descriptive
captions when compared to the image captioning baseline based on VLPs. Our code
and dataset will be made publicly available upon acceptance. | [
-0.5313779711723328,
-0.28680741786956787,
0.11378378421068192,
0.4400895833969116,
-0.4776962995529175,
0.24542340636253357,
-0.2985255718231201,
-0.6494722962379456,
0.3152349293231964,
0.6350433826446533,
-0.5413312911987305,
-0.6486815214157104,
-0.07432432472705841,
0.4516828656196594,
-0.16088956594467163,
0.6118952035903931,
-0.12399947643280029,
0.15454813838005066,
-0.37437382340431213,
-0.19821764528751373,
-0.241705521941185,
-0.3070368468761444,
-0.2663218080997467,
0.3472958505153656,
0.33370786905288696,
0.807426393032074,
0.5109391808509827,
0.6885120868682861,
0.7319638729095459,
0.26678481698036194,
0.15672002732753754,
0.4005427360534668,
-0.19990268349647522,
-0.08566323667764664,
-0.25017762184143066,
-0.5492217540740967,
-0.09469198435544968,
-0.08819799870252609,
0.2005080282688141,
0.40193748474121094,
0.12802281975746155,
0.4522048532962799,
-0.20895947515964508,
0.4908943176269531,
-0.8275013566017151,
0.18014417588710785,
-0.5076871514320374,
0.27120542526245117,
-0.03633730858564377,
-0.5123119354248047,
-0.32219013571739197,
-0.1539638191461563,
0.09206581860780716,
-0.6923249363899231,
0.29370445013046265,
0.3318295180797577,
0.7650118470191956,
0.1251021772623062,
-0.4987486004829407,
-0.38423803448677063,
-0.5727902054786682,
0.5074121356010437,
-0.31758618354797363,
0.15024279057979584,
0.43112561106681824,
0.5184449553489685,
0.33646079897880554,
-0.7251020073890686,
-0.7654065489768982,
-0.01884480193257332,
-0.1204712763428688,
0.4567941725254059,
0.21992380917072296,
-0.3538469076156616,
0.1942507028579712,
0.49413052201271057,
-0.616590142250061,
0.07897522300481796,
-0.5933521389961243,
-0.30847659707069397,
0.5961765646934509,
0.22545349597930908,
0.7208203077316284,
-0.3455975651741028,
-0.7545146346092224,
0.12041179835796356,
-0.8196741938591003,
0.13539355993270874,
-0.13645970821380615,
0.07815346866846085,
-0.5139138102531433,
0.491684228181839,
-0.6186611652374268,
0.37156373262405396,
-0.022298188880085945,
-0.1745467483997345,
0.08351241052150726,
-0.2898227274417877,
0.08566410094499588,
0.13715963065624237,
0.5330969095230103,
1.168355107307434,
0.6773858070373535,
0.0038119626697152853,
0.06267398595809937,
0.11371664702892303,
-0.204341322183609,
-0.7832504510879517,
-0.11243103444576263,
-0.004368353635072708,
-0.7628353834152222,
-0.3600049614906311,
0.36596471071243286,
-0.6604897379875183,
-0.6348041296005249,
-0.4264012575149536,
-0.35980936884880066,
-0.10366454720497131,
-0.250953733921051,
-0.15731696784496307,
-0.05977654457092285,
0.8488950729370117,
0.2744079530239105,
-0.7171535491943359,
-0.026030613109469414,
0.12095005065202713,
0.6731311082839966,
-0.27081748843193054,
-0.006118982098996639,
-0.2863222658634186,
0.3550472557544708,
-0.3146940767765045,
0.6071954965591431,
-0.3626388907432556,
-0.3690866231918335,
0.24677342176437378,
0.269583135843277,
0.4993000030517578,
-0.33143284916877747,
0.36898764967918396,
-0.5884788036346436,
0.14508368074893951,
-0.6710143685340881,
-0.05112743750214577,
-0.18319667875766754,
0.3234994411468506,
-0.7403722405433655,
0.33135268092155457,
-0.09219961613416672,
-0.8958167433738708,
0.5084834694862366,
-0.6413038372993469,
-0.5550580024719238,
0.7044504284858704,
-0.3222389817237854,
-0.16049614548683167,
-0.14552639424800873,
0.762117326259613,
0.46700894832611084,
-0.3618328869342804,
-0.008370024152100086,
-0.252697616815567,
-0.6743879914283752,
0.45609647035598755,
-0.0894375666975975,
0.8788396716117859,
0.7101643085479736,
-0.5597410798072815,
-0.04011416435241699,
-0.512117326259613,
0.04197699949145317,
0.21275992691516876,
-0.074832484126091,
-0.27674540877342224,
-0.04939188063144684,
0.07726887613534927,
0.12602807581424713,
0.4011629521846771,
-0.4043698310852051,
-0.1588941216468811,
0.04296654090285301,
0.46287763118743896,
0.6874502301216125,
0.12026648223400116,
0.5885710716247559,
-0.2200973927974701,
0.7342023253440857,
-0.007023693528026342,
0.23956789076328278,
-0.6971418261528015,
-0.042432740330696106,
-0.680321991443634,
-0.5657541751861572,
-0.07501199841499329,
0.6950933337211609,
-1.3662949800491333,
0.3143855631351471,
-0.37432581186294556,
-0.5471147298812866,
-0.26176947355270386,
0.0074591245502233505,
0.3635527491569519,
0.4493037462234497,
0.019888462498784065,
-0.5529071688652039,
-0.5917810797691345,
-0.9257428646087646,
0.3138628602027893,
-0.29477953910827637,
-0.14078389108181,
0.33577245473861694,
0.3865956962108612,
0.0029591526836156845,
0.6934068202972412,
-0.3892867863178253,
-0.32806435227394104,
-0.15198668837547302,
0.06901595741510391,
-0.19597013294696808,
0.36594319343566895,
0.5925537347793579,
-1.0618852376937866,
-0.5682719945907593,
0.0981571152806282,
-0.9239925742149353,
-0.15199753642082214,
-0.24334044754505157,
-0.35268640518188477,
0.4388633370399475,
0.7313297390937805,
-0.10951279103755951,
0.41828685998916626,
0.3718019127845764,
-0.14435982704162598,
0.7430722713470459,
0.11367584019899368,
0.5287930369377136,
-1.1120997667312622,
0.24164967238903046,
-0.04842611774802208,
-0.11300947517156601,
-0.013806475326418877,
0.4054886996746063,
0.08069364726543427,
-0.3070813715457916,
-0.6401359438896179,
0.4902495741844177,
-0.6190224885940552,
0.03850949928164482,
-0.040112774819135666,
-0.10780512541532516,
-0.00022474065190181136,
0.6323310732841492,
0.6980828046798706,
0.5478832125663757,
0.7843354940414429,
-0.40920162200927734,
0.4335867464542389,
0.26615530252456665,
-0.6885916590690613,
1.156554937362671,
-0.46382227540016174,
0.0817699059844017,
-0.4640677273273468,
0.2515814006328583,
-0.8858365416526794,
-0.425689160823822,
0.30682072043418884,
-0.3945300579071045,
-0.026885252445936203,
-0.09330626577138901,
-0.5890191197395325,
-0.588556706905365,
-0.16495059430599213,
0.5717005133628845,
0.46352171897888184,
-0.6082105040550232,
0.43193989992141724,
-0.017464283853769302,
-0.2000122368335724,
-0.46402934193611145,
-0.8198824524879456,
0.054594069719314575,
-0.4989692270755768,
-0.657743513584137,
-0.06742076575756073,
-0.27549800276756287,
0.030643770471215248,
-0.2593434154987335,
0.0652509331703186,
-0.1012357547879219,
0.06995261460542679,
0.19694791734218597,
0.3199872076511383,
-0.213342547416687,
0.04209375008940697,
-0.21833033859729767,
0.3017566204071045,
0.06549742072820663,
-0.3110087215900421,
0.4264911413192749,
-0.3568897843360901,
-0.28208890557289124,
-0.6122997999191284,
0.7656568884849548,
0.5911414623260498,
-0.9687245488166809,
0.29946333169937134,
0.7649790048599243,
-0.2725581228733063,
0.1925347000360489,
-0.34590020775794983,
-0.06328512728214264,
-0.4487343430519104,
0.29573532938957214,
-0.32143867015838623,
-0.8508267998695374,
0.649976909160614,
0.025790704414248466,
-0.10766175389289856,
0.05496680736541748,
0.5737297534942627,
-0.4896809756755829,
0.926550030708313,
0.5885907411575317,
0.07786133885383606,
0.4518035650253296,
-0.15543413162231445,
0.08044518530368805,
-0.3583190441131592,
-0.13425369560718536,
-0.3707221448421478,
-0.31244736909866333,
-0.8342054486274719,
-0.44213348627090454,
0.45962706208229065,
-0.11322825402021408,
-0.5229606628417969,
-0.02689436450600624,
-0.49069297313690186,
0.6998839378356934,
0.5985493063926697,
0.1414274275302887,
0.2744061350822449,
0.3600923717021942,
0.015085301361978054,
-0.10044753551483154,
-0.4988449513912201,
-0.6337621212005615,
0.8231610655784607,
0.16513152420520782,
0.7682942152023315,
0.14495941996574402,
0.4395241439342499,
0.4102989435195923,
0.5293630361557007,
-0.537373423576355,
0.6064131855964661,
-0.2984367609024048,
-0.622917115688324,
0.11833737045526505,
-0.24214130640029907,
-0.4509441554546356,
-0.15399089455604553,
-0.3579340875148773,
-0.5567704439163208,
0.20497100055217743,
0.31567439436912537,
-0.2773914635181427,
0.15508036315441132,
-0.4614056944847107,
0.44486895203590393,
-0.5217062830924988,
-0.20432806015014648,
0.2567121088504791,
-1.0143111944198608,
0.48769810795783997,
0.2693251371383667,
0.2619361877441406,
0.05293403938412666,
0.11930469423532486,
0.39411187171936035,
0.0017650129739195108,
1.0243741273880005,
-0.20061764121055603,
0.15302768349647522,
0.6321307420730591,
0.22331856191158295,
-0.025608092546463013,
0.001685290946625173,
0.2756909430027008,
0.10844907909631729,
0.1241154819726944,
-0.5104219913482666,
-0.4202110171318054,
0.40221595764160156,
-0.50742107629776,
-0.4103570580482483,
-0.07977405935525894,
-0.4311518371105194,
0.05141935124993324,
0.11604173481464386,
0.4379296898841858,
0.37387120723724365,
-0.030129047110676765,
0.40076833963394165,
0.5008831024169922,
-0.4806702435016632,
0.3472977578639984,
0.42587047815322876,
-0.18430636823177338,
-0.597511887550354,
0.7052468657493591,
-0.1680026352405548,
0.12974968552589417,
0.4740664064884186,
-0.05111687257885933,
-0.10501179099082947,
-0.29686781764030457,
-0.5192999839782715,
0.14634345471858978,
-0.8538435697555542,
-0.3335965871810913,
-0.10129180550575256,
-0.040067292749881744,
-0.31299200654029846,
-0.5318788886070251,
0.1679684966802597,
-0.10280164331197739,
-0.13396868109703064,
-0.08985906839370728,
0.13845917582511902,
0.15857142210006714,
0.05111600458621979,
0.5669782757759094,
-0.6140125393867493,
0.2998509109020233,
0.33942046761512756,
0.31400826573371887,
-0.06656599044799805,
-0.04043875262141228,
-0.18305246531963348,
0.1433623731136322,
-0.14624516665935516,
-0.6666533350944519,
0.2659282982349396,
0.0863456055521965,
0.2898232638835907,
0.732613205909729,
0.40538495779037476,
0.599483072757721,
-0.22553692758083344,
1.0068637132644653,
0.5009922385215759,
-0.6815091967582703,
0.5348221063613892,
-0.2570025622844696,
0.6502727270126343,
0.34197860956192017,
0.42536652088165283,
-0.7188444137573242,
-0.4578224718570709,
-0.2067025899887085,
-0.8094989657402039,
0.14625181257724762,
-0.0567246675491333,
0.3476548194885254,
-0.31997668743133545,
0.17038987576961517,
-0.02707878313958645,
0.0940757468342781,
-0.9222238659858704,
0.17068041861057281,
-0.4522952437400818,
-0.279472291469574,
0.17990413308143616,
-0.23459792137145996,
-0.15490420162677765,
-0.10499754548072815,
0.37821468710899353,
-0.5376150012016296,
0.11747584491968155,
0.5053017735481262,
-0.3479137718677521,
-0.12452314794063568,
0.07274235785007477,
0.43680256605148315,
0.6088915467262268,
0.06142847239971161,
0.036845091730356216,
-0.019909771159291267,
-0.09040116518735886,
-0.21474416553974152,
-0.18596938252449036,
-0.393991619348526,
-0.42220163345336914,
0.4618823230266571,
0.5429020524024963,
-0.41848769783973694,
-0.8820724487304688,
0.42022591829299927,
-0.27841946482658386,
-0.14482207596302032,
-0.7399497628211975,
-0.2912973165512085,
0.005070073064416647,
0.15425164997577667,
0.32780036330223083,
-0.07412440329790115,
0.21096734702587128,
-0.5591151118278503,
0.14198468625545502,
0.2920883595943451,
-0.4382842779159546,
-0.028353162109851837,
0.7356160283088684,
0.5619804859161377,
0.09123853594064713,
0.7499789595603943,
-0.07765614241361618,
-0.656003475189209,
0.6136691570281982,
0.36145883798599243,
0.3757827877998352,
-0.02256295643746853,
0.5999318361282349,
0.5196875929832458,
0.3826790452003479,
0.3248419761657715,
0.5418086647987366,
-0.3086716830730438,
-0.6771251559257507,
-0.507573127746582,
-0.5221023559570312,
-0.11457667499780655,
-0.2546089291572571,
-0.6725723147392273,
0.34341928362846375,
-0.5106526017189026,
0.18928727507591248,
-0.3767973482608795,
-0.16621637344360352,
-0.8691221475601196,
0.47246143221855164,
0.630364179611206,
0.9104948043823242,
-0.9570985436439514,
0.29550671577453613,
0.8423749804496765,
-0.6361612677574158,
-0.7414067387580872,
-0.16032597422599792,
-0.05592203140258789,
-0.6281806826591492,
0.5257583260536194,
0.34679296612739563,
-0.06450646370649338,
-0.32505083084106445,
-1.2150174379348755,
-0.6677646040916443,
1.1824581623077393,
0.10917668789625168,
-0.33703869581222534,
0.1509729027748108,
0.2969985902309418,
0.5802605748176575,
-0.9053061008453369,
-0.0321001335978508,
0.17081761360168457,
0.37574419379234314,
0.5391725301742554,
-0.5520957708358765,
0.03180212154984474,
-0.4526837170124054,
0.16721247136592865,
-0.4921448528766632,
-0.52848219871521,
0.38123729825019836,
-0.4450609087944031,
-0.3406772017478943,
0.675824761390686,
0.9690777063369751,
0.4223879873752594,
0.44560128450393677,
0.6628309488296509,
0.015029150992631912,
0.5914615988731384,
-0.22252365946769714,
1.1138123273849487,
-0.08717645704746246,
-0.13594883680343628,
1.1811021566390991,
-0.2624715566635132,
0.4745303690433502,
0.39086952805519104,
0.3066571354866028,
0.543601393699646,
0.7664117217063904,
-0.17699187994003296,
0.4718138873577118,
0.5133150815963745,
-0.20088976621627808,
-0.3717361092567444,
-0.6666828393936157,
-0.12212716042995453,
0.8810647130012512,
0.028426427394151688,
-0.5988407731056213,
0.1913171112537384,
0.039496537297964096,
-0.01201911922544241,
0.5815396904945374,
-0.5074333548545837,
0.8241130113601685,
-0.07800634205341339,
-0.6313974857330322,
0.5155238509178162,
-0.21660193800926208,
0.5582262277603149,
-0.44599154591560364,
-0.1000891849398613,
-0.37031829357147217,
-0.3718903362751007,
-0.22265984117984772,
-0.6142394542694092,
0.01579100266098976,
0.14178672432899475,
-0.3096804618835449,
-0.01580687426030636,
0.4023086726665497,
-0.694490909576416,
-0.6445395350456238,
-0.2732032537460327,
0.2886805534362793,
0.24081040918827057,
0.12743733823299408,
-0.25641146302223206,
-0.1399320363998413,
0.14777134358882904,
0.3896821439266205,
-0.3563525080680847,
0.3648289442062378,
-0.7420174479484558,
0.4912690222263336,
0.609692394733429,
0.00028743481379933655,
-0.046671561896800995,
0.22792449593544006,
0.33165690302848816,
-0.4532749652862549,
-0.7830747961997986,
-0.2852126359939575,
0.7407289147377014,
-0.34858810901641846,
0.08947228640317917,
0.1356208622455597,
0.31121721863746643,
0.9600576758384705,
-0.46006932854652405,
0.975494384765625,
-0.4673295021057129,
0.07220925390720367,
-0.47477295994758606,
0.8047360181808472,
-0.6143863797187805,
0.0341995544731617,
-0.1041983887553215,
-0.878298819065094,
-0.3520965874195099,
0.4069145619869232,
0.019015545025467873,
-0.144148588180542,
0.5526407957077026,
0.9596916437149048,
0.1868019998073578,
0.2027769535779953,
0.14690271019935608,
-0.024296307936310768,
0.256242573261261,
0.2997283339500427,
1.0387312173843384,
0.12540315091609955,
0.6240206956863403,
-0.5164358615875244,
-0.33995112776756287,
0.21715140342712402,
-1.0859706401824951,
-0.6657143831253052,
-0.8752581477165222,
-0.46927782893180847,
0.10743614286184311,
-0.2005859762430191,
0.8318780660629272,
0.7311327457427979,
-0.7076044082641602,
-0.21449609100818634,
0.4486236572265625,
-0.10710475593805313,
-0.2808209955692291,
-0.23556631803512573,
0.40045931935310364,
0.06868307292461395,
-0.7083551287651062,
-0.3170515298843384,
0.07224234193563461,
0.09837821125984192,
-0.3259167969226837,
-0.10699845850467682,
0.04492214322090149,
-0.15983830392360687,
0.6250952482223511,
0.19947104156017303,
-0.6281713247299194,
-0.45831191539764404,
0.12778770923614502,
-0.010537867434322834,
-0.1823311150074005,
0.8464884161949158,
-0.3651025891304016,
0.6551555395126343,
0.36278384923934937,
0.33588624000549316,
0.12117315083742142,
0.07679977267980576,
0.6601251363754272,
-0.7400410175323486,
0.11514213681221008,
0.10315891355276108,
0.5175122022628784,
0.7455981373786926,
-0.3748725652694702,
0.5246156454086304,
0.13093510270118713,
-0.20381705462932587,
-0.2593728005886078,
0.43751344084739685,
-1.2690850496292114,
-0.14363248646259308,
1.0024667978286743,
-0.411372572183609,
-0.3726224899291992,
0.2620219886302948,
-0.561488687992096,
0.11638820916414261,
0.01088884100317955,
0.7172150015830994,
0.4823385179042816,
0.5011350512504578,
-0.45827516913414,
0.03126772120594978,
0.07237343490123749,
0.2250775694847107,
-0.7254760265350342,
0.04455555975437164,
0.7503097057342529,
0.3474388122558594,
0.11180885881185532,
0.44696635007858276,
-0.45642372965812683,
0.6670551896095276,
-0.6422083377838135,
0.6181443929672241,
-0.08924519270658493,
-0.20309676229953766,
0.15851706266403198,
0.11787869036197662,
-0.06923086941242218,
-0.25959041714668274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05369v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05369v2 | Noise Contrastive Alignment of Language Models with Explicit Rewards | 2024-02-08T02:58:47 | 2024-07-03T13:53:06 | Huayu Chen, Guande He, Lifan Yuan, Ganqu Cui, Hang Su, Jun Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | User intentions are typically formalized as evaluation rewards to be
maximized when fine-tuning language models (LMs). Existing alignment methods,
such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), are mainly tailored for pairwise
preference data where rewards are implicitly defined rather than explicitly
given. In this paper, we introduce a general framework for LM alignment,
leveraging Noise Contrastive Estimation (NCE) to bridge the gap in handling
reward datasets explicitly annotated with scalar evaluations. Our framework
comprises two parallel algorithms, NCA and InfoNCA, both enabling the direct
extraction of an LM policy from reward data as well as preference data.
Notably, we show that the DPO loss is a special case of our proposed InfoNCA
objective under pairwise preference settings, thereby integrating and extending
current alignment theories. By comparing NCA and InfoNCA, we demonstrate that
the well-observed decreasing-likelihood trend of DPO/InfoNCA is caused by their
focus on adjusting relative likelihood across different responses. In contrast,
NCA optimizes the absolute likelihood for each response, thereby effectively
preventing the chosen likelihood from decreasing. We evaluate our methods in
both reward and preference settings with Mistral-8*7B and 7B models.
Experiments suggest that InfoNCA/NCA surpasses various preference baselines
when reward datasets are available. We also find NCA significantly outperforms
DPO in complex reasoning tasks like math and coding. | [
-0.3151395320892334,
-0.32871463894844055,
0.6173821091651917,
0.09368688613176346,
-0.13307484984397888,
-0.1802457869052887,
-0.4559789299964905,
-0.17607727646827698,
0.20099543035030365,
0.3944982588291168,
-0.6708421111106873,
-0.40619096159935,
-0.5707524418830872,
-0.0674055740237236,
-0.06416606903076172,
0.9845393300056458,
-0.022404678165912628,
-0.06953932344913483,
-0.2762734889984131,
-0.11918295919895172,
-0.576435923576355,
-0.2313045859336853,
-0.6805221438407898,
-0.1379413902759552,
0.8699020743370056,
0.47178664803504944,
0.7624342441558838,
0.9728299975395203,
0.6734656691551208,
0.228705495595932,
-0.1277373880147934,
0.2545223534107208,
-0.6764675974845886,
0.004022907931357622,
-0.14779822528362274,
-0.26957112550735474,
-0.12291756272315979,
-0.11385513097047806,
0.40349113941192627,
0.4688589572906494,
-0.13275586068630219,
-0.11479147523641586,
0.24969515204429626,
0.8929741382598877,
-0.9749374985694885,
0.09799934178590775,
-0.4878287613391876,
-0.09833669662475586,
-0.20668944716453552,
-0.3281134068965912,
-0.1939336359500885,
-0.5562970042228699,
0.18549591302871704,
-0.7713038921356201,
-0.30636268854141235,
-0.06267689168453217,
1.115410566329956,
0.5762578845024109,
-0.12783204019069672,
-0.34924501180648804,
-0.6420244574546814,
1.11247980594635,
-0.5641018748283386,
0.3844136595726013,
0.3313010632991791,
0.17892512679100037,
-0.14292193949222565,
-0.1342773288488388,
-0.5348296761512756,
-0.053938914090394974,
-0.18939360976219177,
0.2226620614528656,
-0.3035479485988617,
0.19370156526565552,
0.08848203718662262,
0.5417836308479309,
-0.5076130628585815,
0.503355860710144,
-0.20467573404312134,
-0.11460845172405243,
0.3400254547595978,
0.2061518132686615,
0.04904268682003021,
0.2804338037967682,
-0.32392418384552,
-0.27594393491744995,
-0.626246452331543,
0.2861374616622925,
0.6180440187454224,
0.5270392894744873,
-0.3882018029689789,
0.4574914872646332,
-0.19351986050605774,
1.0039896965026855,
0.505948543548584,
-0.029650632292032242,
0.1812460720539093,
-0.4671109616756439,
-0.01360464096069336,
0.20515641570091248,
0.8326184153556824,
0.47328802943229675,
0.07532928884029388,
-0.2545947730541229,
-0.12917032837867737,
0.16747860610485077,
0.07826437056064606,
-0.6805394291877747,
-0.0944877490401268,
0.35325539112091064,
-0.3292393684387207,
-0.617193877696991,
-0.019382426515221596,
-0.6545643210411072,
-0.6341949105262756,
-0.8808339238166809,
0.23482654988765717,
-0.04786740988492966,
-0.29778429865837097,
0.29571783542633057,
0.1663273423910141,
0.35393089056015015,
0.11063920706510544,
-1.225370168685913,
0.33710262179374695,
0.9394325613975525,
0.6292091012001038,
-0.41483065485954285,
-0.1432279348373413,
-0.7265725135803223,
-0.11391471326351166,
-0.3180590569972992,
0.69706791639328,
-0.6559165716171265,
0.1536884903907776,
0.09500078856945038,
-0.26217830181121826,
-0.07444753497838974,
-0.5375902652740479,
0.8195614814758301,
-0.4967508316040039,
0.4109741747379303,
-0.5410056114196777,
-0.6207701563835144,
0.005384205840528011,
0.18720677495002747,
-0.7900616526603699,
0.8464230298995972,
0.06469791382551193,
-1.1013233661651611,
0.539068341255188,
-0.5398041009902954,
-0.06208096072077751,
-0.418405681848526,
-0.28918495774269104,
-0.40239450335502625,
0.07395471632480621,
0.24980394542217255,
0.25607550144195557,
-0.4570763409137726,
0.49223044514656067,
-0.4468887150287628,
-0.6196683049201965,
0.15506082773208618,
-0.13337941467761993,
0.6781283020973206,
0.2671652138233185,
-0.41427165269851685,
0.43916282057762146,
-0.533718466758728,
-0.262309730052948,
-0.0012494779657572508,
-0.20635023713111877,
-0.5538360476493835,
0.07250924408435822,
-0.25258076190948486,
0.30543053150177,
0.4781317710876465,
-0.4643872380256653,
0.1708245724439621,
-0.44934916496276855,
0.033293142914772034,
1.1379817724227905,
-0.4338505268096924,
0.5424378514289856,
-0.3115943372249603,
0.3829095661640167,
0.15580019354820251,
0.25104668736457825,
0.3309103548526764,
-0.034803226590156555,
-0.6825319528579712,
-0.42012298107147217,
0.47042661905288696,
0.3430790305137634,
-0.1237003430724144,
0.6555092930793762,
-0.4153723418712616,
0.026770280674099922,
-0.9070100784301758,
0.14060541987419128,
0.478886216878891,
0.6918919086456299,
0.3005366623401642,
-0.037663787603378296,
-0.5515105128288269,
-1.1392426490783691,
-0.19544418156147003,
-0.035879045724868774,
0.0976380854845047,
0.29162895679473877,
-0.3950546979904175,
0.1024467870593071,
0.8331514596939087,
-0.43054378032684326,
-0.20781709253787994,
0.0825994685292244,
0.039612140506505966,
0.5494139790534973,
0.4354666471481323,
0.3560453951358795,
-0.8378018736839294,
-0.47409889101982117,
0.12900567054748535,
-0.5273709297180176,
-0.3534501791000366,
-0.07531505823135376,
-0.3610813617706299,
-0.0019444759236648679,
0.20583271980285645,
-0.03236367553472519,
0.21421319246292114,
0.833646297454834,
-0.19406719505786896,
0.4188849627971649,
0.15445208549499512,
0.26838839054107666,
-0.9775795936584473,
0.08560049533843994,
0.033846355974674225,
-0.012209256179630756,
-0.5777025818824768,
-0.29602837562561035,
-0.06381547451019287,
0.21399812400341034,
-0.04373255744576454,
0.7058894038200378,
-0.33646297454833984,
-0.07616361230611801,
-0.43689024448394775,
0.118626669049263,
-0.10064772516489029,
0.6666371822357178,
0.4042619466781616,
0.6185494661331177,
0.5842263698577881,
-0.7464367747306824,
-0.11364209651947021,
0.0978289470076561,
-0.3236962556838989,
0.732345461845398,
-0.472057044506073,
0.16281268000602722,
-0.13518816232681274,
-0.3257412016391754,
-0.8523193597793579,
0.004017753526568413,
0.41629835963249207,
-0.03280342370271683,
0.3764638602733612,
0.020574234426021576,
-0.09865593910217285,
0.02457638829946518,
-0.3567604720592499,
0.5753180384635925,
0.3125687539577484,
-0.8859966397285461,
0.13740551471710205,
0.3949088454246521,
-0.17751716077327728,
-1.0389610528945923,
-0.3306959569454193,
-0.16983027756214142,
-0.4586481750011444,
-0.41704148054122925,
0.5429516434669495,
-0.15700198709964752,
-0.46635153889656067,
0.0033119579311460257,
-0.2866688668727875,
-0.11744983494281769,
-0.026401259005069733,
0.20328837633132935,
0.3996357321739197,
-0.22464369237422943,
0.18439128994941711,
0.14099015295505524,
-0.231776624917984,
-0.2550991177558899,
-0.10703011602163315,
0.4916749596595764,
-0.1640627533197403,
-0.21394038200378418,
-0.41328153014183044,
0.1573759913444519,
0.06623423099517822,
-0.0665750503540039,
0.4739038348197937,
0.47326406836509705,
-0.02797192707657814,
0.23217181861400604,
-0.7746281027793884,
-0.32722076773643494,
-0.4806631803512573,
0.195675790309906,
-0.3991051912307739,
-0.9387015104293823,
0.22957201302051544,
0.08321670442819595,
0.3249160945415497,
0.2738080322742462,
0.4219192862510681,
-0.030248399823904037,
0.9779273271560669,
0.6307815313339233,
-0.30873435735702515,
0.7571296095848083,
0.21852818131446838,
0.1297542005777359,
-0.7618697285652161,
-0.017068156972527504,
-0.5388497710227966,
-0.5066174268722534,
-0.545394778251648,
-0.1493939608335495,
0.07144203037023544,
0.2830021381378174,
-0.33649805188179016,
0.24321170151233673,
-0.682827889919281,
0.5179882645606995,
0.6323767304420471,
0.10933384299278259,
0.2621191740036011,
0.24492686986923218,
-0.03167076036334038,
-0.30853399634361267,
-0.6587737202644348,
-0.2632553279399872,
0.9963143467903137,
0.08340995013713837,
0.6341221928596497,
-0.012790742330253124,
0.81923508644104,
0.034458160400390625,
0.116141676902771,
-0.6966837048530579,
0.18005035817623138,
-0.26210230588912964,
-0.06912881880998611,
-0.34083250164985657,
-0.5715912580490112,
-1.108860969543457,
0.06733117997646332,
-0.23630379140377045,
-0.779562771320343,
0.6750250458717346,
0.3902745544910431,
-0.25448107719421387,
0.02306891418993473,
-0.32412809133529663,
0.9395875930786133,
-0.29424527287483215,
-0.534936249256134,
-0.17288130521774292,
-0.582671046257019,
0.4677271246910095,
0.02749309130012989,
0.20998653769493103,
-0.23428429663181305,
0.04907349497079849,
0.5830326676368713,
-0.2975787818431854,
0.5465404987335205,
-0.05537085980176926,
-0.18730632960796356,
-0.13576118648052216,
0.004895381163805723,
0.675094485282898,
-0.39433765411376953,
-0.3308727443218231,
0.08196327090263367,
-0.20947611331939697,
-0.385981023311615,
-0.7128605842590332,
1.0148444175720215,
-0.6705063581466675,
-0.432345449924469,
-0.29716727137565613,
-0.7714042663574219,
-0.3115629255771637,
0.030032111331820488,
0.08430006355047226,
0.2227592021226883,
-0.1749429553747177,
-0.08097835630178452,
0.5609882473945618,
-0.04012602940201759,
0.17880158126354218,
0.5257152915000916,
-0.03974165767431259,
-0.33744552731513977,
1.0879238843917847,
-0.3451128900051117,
0.3061836361885071,
0.673406183719635,
0.6020104885101318,
-0.5495778918266296,
-0.5957818627357483,
-0.17142511904239655,
0.3226461112499237,
-0.5294167399406433,
0.00018954509869217873,
-0.38353753089904785,
0.25208330154418945,
-0.3191784918308258,
-0.30331525206565857,
-0.2809426784515381,
-0.39806684851646423,
-0.05559476464986801,
-0.09848935902118683,
0.3298151195049286,
0.4271467924118042,
-0.30084046721458435,
0.1676560491323471,
-0.255648136138916,
0.24842600524425507,
0.3036729097366333,
0.35961994528770447,
-0.4700057804584503,
-0.5716379284858704,
-0.16572260856628418,
0.11420167237520218,
0.022224215790629387,
-0.5020524263381958,
0.05681483447551727,
-0.14581318199634552,
0.43561676144599915,
0.5890957117080688,
0.17612409591674805,
0.9385721683502197,
0.019750375300645828,
0.2891269028186798,
0.432136207818985,
-0.6844308376312256,
0.32525748014450073,
-0.22531303763389587,
0.4016924798488617,
1.0113950967788696,
0.283515602350235,
-0.5146844983100891,
-0.19533579051494598,
-0.305122971534729,
-0.6582430005073547,
0.8192277550697327,
0.18368160724639893,
-0.227115198969841,
0.11469674855470657,
0.2801704406738281,
0.10381761193275452,
0.16325858235359192,
-0.7625451683998108,
-0.21691355109214783,
0.00683753564953804,
-0.5985034108161926,
0.046334654092788696,
-0.2340010404586792,
-0.39736562967300415,
0.033857591450214386,
0.7397143244743347,
-0.1346772313117981,
-0.08742130547761917,
-0.11624420434236526,
0.07295367866754532,
-0.06272962689399719,
0.29934361577033997,
0.631658673286438,
0.5473676323890686,
-0.3479589521884918,
0.005196092650294304,
-0.33691656589508057,
-0.06268945336341858,
0.12386555969715118,
0.16782890260219574,
-0.31537631154060364,
-0.21456576883792877,
-0.08486390113830566,
1.0981438159942627,
0.4838859736919403,
-0.574555516242981,
0.6755599975585938,
-0.13337041437625885,
-0.09959039092063904,
0.08032933622598648,
-0.11496306955814362,
0.08942198753356934,
-0.03822837769985199,
-0.3364972174167633,
-0.08798350393772125,
0.3202252686023712,
-0.18799152970314026,
0.033558957278728485,
0.5141685605049133,
-0.8931087255477905,
-0.2275124043226242,
0.4320463538169861,
-0.018145974725484848,
0.0014145661843940616,
0.4374661147594452,
-0.0034722972195595503,
0.07100839912891388,
0.45636671781539917,
0.3717719614505768,
0.9523296356201172,
-0.2983483374118805,
0.1505717784166336,
0.5536033511161804,
0.10690779983997345,
-0.08429116755723953,
0.2451571673154831,
-0.21902349591255188,
-0.8840734362602234,
-0.3761332333087921,
-0.670860230922699,
-0.3002452254295349,
0.24086500704288483,
-0.825461208820343,
0.4912368357181549,
-0.20645594596862793,
0.21931327879428864,
0.20136526226997375,
-0.2573491930961609,
-0.7183639407157898,
0.05505581572651863,
0.03253556042909622,
0.27432015538215637,
-0.6717771887779236,
0.7309417128562927,
0.45585358142852783,
-0.35477718710899353,
-0.8282088041305542,
-0.08289937674999237,
0.20755700767040253,
-0.8447710871696472,
0.6033583879470825,
0.03848441690206528,
-0.3370475769042969,
-0.14071911573410034,
-0.23993583023548126,
-0.9241072535514832,
0.7736852765083313,
0.6749867796897888,
-0.9324273467063904,
0.10821220278739929,
0.10754547268152237,
0.2564353942871094,
-0.4786154329776764,
0.17675934731960297,
0.6136759519577026,
0.7124583125114441,
0.17225289344787598,
-0.8172852993011475,
0.14290617406368256,
-0.08834619075059891,
-0.24304097890853882,
0.4494514465332031,
-0.44566261768341064,
0.5039005279541016,
-0.0479758121073246,
-0.20126068592071533,
-0.05375565588474274,
0.36966562271118164,
0.43103668093681335,
0.11023744195699692,
0.7873128056526184,
0.5810338854789734,
0.8130276799201965,
-0.10466234385967255,
1.0179214477539062,
-0.31918787956237793,
0.032712336629629135,
1.381843090057373,
-0.1961231231689453,
0.47742414474487305,
0.8026788830757141,
-0.14346952736377716,
0.41688913106918335,
0.7050309181213379,
0.2506557106971741,
0.7369798421859741,
0.36351531744003296,
-0.21680760383605957,
-0.253301739692688,
-0.39207592606544495,
-0.2804954946041107,
0.31914022564888,
0.09839142113924026,
-0.3419283628463745,
-0.07189887017011642,
-0.3901800811290741,
-0.023218804970383644,
0.31800687313079834,
-0.3055582642555237,
1.0574471950531006,
-0.10619492083787918,
-0.9947633147239685,
0.676548182964325,
-0.28210338950157166,
0.7193211913108826,
-0.6082502007484436,
-0.014666489325463772,
-0.2853366732597351,
0.22276616096496582,
-0.24794001877307892,
-0.4798741042613983,
0.19933255016803741,
-0.17952096462249756,
-0.31467145681381226,
0.06813699752092361,
0.49026256799697876,
-0.7817357778549194,
-0.20967143774032593,
0.3108488619327545,
0.025354785844683647,
0.19970247149467468,
-0.12008179724216461,
-0.8893493413925171,
0.2614426016807556,
0.07809284329414368,
-0.014648114331066608,
0.6542234420776367,
0.02689286693930626,
-0.07961970567703247,
0.2378511279821396,
0.5932193994522095,
0.08717595040798187,
-0.1702681928873062,
0.22904732823371887,
0.8150507211685181,
-0.5201522707939148,
-0.5035681128501892,
-0.8385414481163025,
0.3765493631362915,
-0.27820122241973877,
-0.24467937648296356,
0.5237380862236023,
0.7904656529426575,
0.6534730195999146,
0.16215035319328308,
0.6445592045783997,
0.21872033178806305,
0.49086230993270874,
-0.6877411603927612,
-0.0022353020031005144,
-0.5437883734703064,
0.3907800614833832,
-0.3743171989917755,
-1.0293965339660645,
-0.23480841517448425,
0.4884352684020996,
-0.36966392397880554,
-0.3127956688404083,
0.5580750703811646,
1.0461955070495605,
-0.2857615053653717,
-0.10873721539974213,
0.269983172416687,
-0.08812808245420456,
0.02625248208642006,
0.5634405016899109,
0.7141683101654053,
-0.10048658400774002,
0.4829968810081482,
-0.5597817897796631,
-0.3286057412624359,
-0.07541260123252869,
-1.0319366455078125,
-0.5808281302452087,
-0.4607385993003845,
-0.5970173478126526,
-0.34524333477020264,
0.20869207382202148,
0.8606868386268616,
0.6305450797080994,
-0.9695308208465576,
-0.595012366771698,
-0.3101877272129059,
0.3284825384616852,
-0.6550809144973755,
-0.22996337711811066,
0.6103970408439636,
-0.5437678694725037,
-0.9894654750823975,
0.4482652544975281,
0.4845040738582611,
-0.15172673761844635,
0.051311492919921875,
-0.44131141901016235,
-0.165220245718956,
0.0798056572675705,
0.0656915232539177,
0.5911992788314819,
-0.8380445241928101,
-0.12439705431461334,
-0.020216647535562515,
-0.19685624539852142,
0.31080833077430725,
0.8683261871337891,
-0.4386860728263855,
0.723463237285614,
0.509274959564209,
0.6984028220176697,
0.49689918756484985,
0.18522953987121582,
0.8693134188652039,
-0.5731680989265442,
0.20290140807628632,
0.14897845685482025,
0.28358617424964905,
0.2653649151325226,
-0.3620067536830902,
0.5651581883430481,
-0.20198506116867065,
-0.5819296836853027,
-0.850396990776062,
0.2241169959306717,
-1.1640491485595703,
-0.12636323273181915,
1.0891480445861816,
-0.048045285046100616,
-0.14436446130275726,
-0.09261409938335419,
-0.25287625193595886,
0.0351107083261013,
-0.4716337025165558,
0.9293888807296753,
0.632220983505249,
-0.10728024691343307,
-0.09566716849803925,
0.04783598706126213,
0.9436060190200806,
0.7267206311225891,
-0.8066219091415405,
0.21780544519424438,
0.61800217628479,
0.04218670725822449,
0.09397570788860321,
0.7680229544639587,
-0.22078347206115723,
0.40897002816200256,
-0.3273533880710602,
0.2975056767463684,
-0.10181118547916412,
-0.06979662925004959,
-0.7719324827194214,
-0.02323683351278305,
0.15805478394031525,
-0.3421831429004669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05359v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05359v6 | An Examination on the Effectiveness of Divide-and-Conquer Prompting in Large Language Models | 2024-02-08T02:37:30 | 2024-07-02T18:18:18 | Yizhou Zhang, Lun Du, Defu Cao, Qiang Fu, Yan Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Foundation models, such as Large language Models (LLMs), have attracted
significant amount of interest due to their large number of applications.
However, when handling tasks involving repetitive sub-tasks and/or deceptive
contents, such as arithmetic calculation and article-level fake news detection,
simple instructional prompts suffer from inaccurate responses. Existing works
show that more complicated prompting strategies, such as Chain-of-Thoughts and
Least-to-Most, can unlock LLM's powerful capacity in diverse areas. Recent
researches reveal that simple divide-and-conquer prompting strategy, i.e.
simply dividing the input sequence to multiple sub-inputs, can also
substantially improve LLM's performance in some specific tasks such as
misinformation detection. In this paper, we aim at examining the utility of
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and answer on which kind of tasks this
strategy gets advantages. Specifically, we provide a theoretic analysis to
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and help us identify the specific tasks
where DaC prompting can bring performance boost with theoretic guarantee. We
then present two cases (large integer arithmetic and fact verification) where
experimental results aligns with our theoretic analysis. | [
-0.7972680926322937,
-1.2403392791748047,
0.627547562122345,
0.4774135649204254,
-0.048015959560871124,
-0.037783343344926834,
-0.2125171720981598,
-0.25220927596092224,
-0.07069574296474457,
-0.08324617892503738,
-0.7097945213317871,
-0.05927872657775879,
-0.7878986597061157,
0.32689720392227173,
-0.5002899169921875,
0.7022486925125122,
-0.018301967531442642,
0.1180930808186531,
-0.38933226466178894,
0.15116313099861145,
-0.7369094491004944,
-0.5007308721542358,
-0.8122239112854004,
-0.32256221771240234,
0.6056217551231384,
0.5916424989700317,
0.44551846385002136,
0.6671685576438904,
0.28699836134910583,
0.30256888270378113,
-0.341100811958313,
0.33614861965179443,
-0.29118841886520386,
0.18490268290042877,
-0.012404241599142551,
-0.583682656288147,
-0.20740242302417755,
0.039782147854566574,
0.633886992931366,
0.6980337500572205,
-0.3830241560935974,
-0.19009070098400116,
0.015331000089645386,
0.808772623538971,
-0.7138951420783997,
-0.10792094469070435,
-0.4087240695953369,
-0.18870799243450165,
-0.12688958644866943,
-0.2380441576242447,
-0.6147329807281494,
-0.36080077290534973,
0.09096077084541321,
-0.3979332149028778,
0.04620812088251114,
-0.00182608631439507,
0.4530453383922577,
0.15939010679721832,
-0.6205422282218933,
-0.7760870456695557,
-0.4809724688529968,
0.7210115194320679,
-0.44801801443099976,
0.32594799995422363,
0.5133559107780457,
0.1801745891571045,
-0.20733265578746796,
-0.4035710096359253,
-0.7211950421333313,
-0.20733366906642914,
0.06541422754526138,
-0.026170548051595688,
-0.44081082940101624,
0.11073441058397293,
0.5253487229347229,
0.503576397895813,
-0.36701712012290955,
0.4130687713623047,
-0.2850811779499054,
-0.159150168299675,
0.29875385761260986,
0.18228133022785187,
0.5556070804595947,
-0.009267820045351982,
-0.3605847656726837,
-0.2861161231994629,
-0.9204687476158142,
0.2644132971763611,
0.367948442697525,
0.1085408478975296,
-0.11612239480018616,
0.5394994616508484,
-0.2451154738664627,
0.9323068857192993,
0.5230587720870972,
-0.43618783354759216,
-0.20135943591594696,
-0.3654922842979431,
-0.23023417592048645,
0.06636285036802292,
0.43941453099250793,
0.12749826908111572,
0.2537429928779602,
0.09662165492773056,
-0.18245822191238403,
0.16691036522388458,
0.18860875070095062,
-0.9607706665992737,
0.08770393580198288,
0.26238152384757996,
-0.14439831674098969,
-0.3923640251159668,
-0.1935736984014511,
-0.691674530506134,
-0.3618161082267761,
-0.3719383478164673,
0.35966727137565613,
-0.6697314381599426,
-0.061132341623306274,
0.3212396502494812,
0.0856209248304367,
-0.05655629187822342,
0.5419619083404541,
-1.0233205556869507,
0.17235204577445984,
0.872708261013031,
0.6998242735862732,
-0.4749479591846466,
-0.2634117007255554,
-0.9015465974807739,
-0.379008412361145,
-0.45421624183654785,
0.6085606813430786,
-0.32225823402404785,
-0.3635352551937103,
0.043502651154994965,
-0.3965103328227997,
-0.2844432294368744,
-0.626583993434906,
0.6062120795249939,
-0.799835741519928,
0.29791930317878723,
-0.9108558893203735,
-0.6713961362838745,
-0.22196951508522034,
0.5669543147087097,
-0.9462774395942688,
0.7713159918785095,
-0.26875540614128113,
-0.9091054201126099,
0.21989932656288147,
-0.6292603611946106,
-0.6994977593421936,
-0.06765511631965637,
-0.17968252301216125,
0.04464433714747429,
0.049806129187345505,
0.5926567912101746,
0.2963980436325073,
-0.33281105756759644,
0.2993755638599396,
0.04271037504076958,
-0.15052451193332672,
0.5684348344802856,
-0.8741720914840698,
0.8137289881706238,
0.06595401465892792,
-0.44816553592681885,
-0.17103931307792664,
-0.2693043053150177,
-0.16606056690216064,
0.011671784333884716,
-0.6020490527153015,
-0.36128976941108704,
-0.25708475708961487,
-0.6755797863006592,
0.10651424527168274,
0.060418225824832916,
-0.4111030697822571,
0.3720705807209015,
-0.43551164865493774,
0.07317497581243515,
0.7892169952392578,
0.1560695916414261,
0.3899894058704376,
-0.47180643677711487,
0.7817749977111816,
0.15279033780097961,
0.0120050348341465,
-0.32800257205963135,
-0.40042319893836975,
-0.7410343289375305,
-0.5994299650192261,
0.4779050946235657,
0.45025068521499634,
-0.9329907298088074,
0.08708084374666214,
0.061802640557289124,
-0.07159046083688736,
-0.3315439224243164,
-0.025408057495951653,
0.38993245363235474,
0.4427841007709503,
0.16596736013889313,
0.054608944803476334,
-0.39406025409698486,
-0.6222548484802246,
-0.06271933764219284,
-0.09068664908409119,
0.20355622470378876,
0.15151317417621613,
0.36850377917289734,
0.14377303421497345,
0.870121419429779,
-0.09953314065933228,
0.21571896970272064,
-0.3467298150062561,
0.15964359045028687,
0.11370594054460526,
0.030000055208802223,
0.4206547141075134,
-1.1726878881454468,
-0.6145540475845337,
-0.35621029138565063,
-0.39282023906707764,
-0.2394672930240631,
0.0007221146370284259,
0.11996904760599136,
0.3212898075580597,
0.15478557348251343,
-0.8562608957290649,
0.44717761874198914,
0.7113885283470154,
-0.2938151955604553,
0.8868131637573242,
0.012777232564985752,
0.5312614440917969,
-0.6760231852531433,
-0.09373559057712555,
-0.05282649025321007,
-0.11232822388410568,
-0.7695353031158447,
0.11715499311685562,
-0.06479693949222565,
0.346352219581604,
-0.31870731711387634,
0.27664801478385925,
-0.4410340487957001,
0.19339919090270996,
-0.5489919781684875,
0.12487038969993591,
-0.1827160269021988,
0.185640349984169,
-0.11917423456907272,
1.059983491897583,
0.5593215823173523,
-0.9611438512802124,
0.4538336396217346,
-0.0035196186508983374,
-0.3675772547721863,
0.8253557085990906,
-0.5675032734870911,
0.04550165683031082,
-0.11699996888637543,
0.3348930776119232,
-1.0753724575042725,
-0.16245603561401367,
-0.02238726057112217,
-0.3590715229511261,
0.1891438364982605,
0.0507182702422142,
-0.6574020385742188,
-0.4142037630081177,
-0.22863174974918365,
0.5196422338485718,
0.5207000374794006,
-1.1259737014770508,
0.4804583787918091,
-0.1365668624639511,
-0.20768722891807556,
-0.7730175852775574,
-0.3566100597381592,
-0.050239238888025284,
-0.3069938123226166,
-0.7062058448791504,
0.30360329151153564,
-0.355491578578949,
-0.49715882539749146,
-0.27192121744155884,
-0.2939915657043457,
0.32885584235191345,
0.11500849574804306,
0.3958113193511963,
0.36724981665611267,
-0.11854700744152069,
-0.07771007716655731,
0.09138055145740509,
0.009645628742873669,
0.19885268807411194,
-0.222434401512146,
0.6910320520401001,
-0.05887873098254204,
-0.6483196020126343,
-0.4119115471839905,
0.17334192991256714,
0.5752108693122864,
-0.1101689413189888,
0.6332996487617493,
0.05509194731712341,
-0.15822777152061462,
-0.28648635745048523,
-0.869796633720398,
-0.30524271726608276,
-0.48606929183006287,
-0.026624483987689018,
-0.42939600348472595,
-1.0093166828155518,
0.18841767311096191,
-0.2458416223526001,
0.026501059532165527,
0.3830904960632324,
0.838476300239563,
0.14480921626091003,
1.1049394607543945,
0.3679077625274658,
-0.20792452991008759,
0.17247864603996277,
-0.17144599556922913,
0.1652115434408188,
-0.5101878046989441,
-0.3118334114551544,
-0.5960350632667542,
-0.24203194677829742,
-0.09068983793258667,
-0.5342568159103394,
0.38504981994628906,
0.32194414734840393,
0.08399199694395065,
0.013284873217344284,
-0.2824547290802002,
0.6886560916900635,
0.499362975358963,
-0.21384064853191376,
0.529175341129303,
0.38014158606529236,
-0.38405269384384155,
-0.004871251527220011,
-0.8923369646072388,
-0.10109419375658035,
0.6859090328216553,
0.3052641451358795,
0.572862982749939,
0.12836740911006927,
0.6230184435844421,
0.5121357440948486,
0.15029458701610565,
-0.9590316414833069,
0.4759039282798767,
0.07341039180755615,
-0.5828316807746887,
-0.3492429256439209,
-0.4872312545776367,
-0.8014031648635864,
0.28300440311431885,
0.049585212022066116,
-0.5754685997962952,
0.5110469460487366,
0.07026991248130798,
-0.4330708384513855,
0.3805186152458191,
-0.475003719329834,
0.4772721230983734,
-0.28227272629737854,
0.04850292205810547,
-0.41734784841537476,
-0.2162529081106186,
0.4416162669658661,
-0.1464409977197647,
0.3084515631198883,
0.4230803847312927,
0.041785914450883865,
0.6829893589019775,
-0.3741970658302307,
0.8475269079208374,
-0.10916907340288162,
-0.2741489112377167,
0.3466140925884247,
0.33314910531044006,
0.8170517086982727,
-0.21498703956604004,
0.02362925559282303,
-0.2392389178276062,
-0.1939469277858734,
-0.21578864753246307,
-0.6165847182273865,
0.6456397175788879,
-0.4619366526603699,
-0.7185836434364319,
-0.4118456244468689,
-0.6316314339637756,
-0.2657621502876282,
0.03621399402618408,
0.5393816828727722,
0.4213445484638214,
-0.21861828863620758,
0.3689928650856018,
1.0517665147781372,
0.12522956728935242,
0.6195198893547058,
0.5396163463592529,
-0.1554020494222641,
-0.390726774930954,
0.608637273311615,
0.029584160074591637,
0.4912094175815582,
0.2980845868587494,
0.21042713522911072,
-0.38235366344451904,
-0.5323200225830078,
-0.6604946255683899,
0.20514217019081116,
-0.6913275122642517,
-0.2324383556842804,
-0.5199108123779297,
-0.05869920924305916,
-0.19367867708206177,
-0.07676856964826584,
-0.00899525173008442,
-0.3506912291049957,
-0.045257147401571274,
-0.34292906522750854,
0.23061029613018036,
0.8387258052825928,
-0.14143581688404083,
0.3200412094593048,
-0.3847469985485077,
0.23777781426906586,
0.7407754063606262,
-0.2392764687538147,
0.44721150398254395,
-0.5695024132728577,
-0.20597991347312927,
0.2142854779958725,
-0.25860390067100525,
-0.9309600591659546,
0.15723606944084167,
-0.2724059522151947,
0.547861635684967,
0.5246845483779907,
0.04745684191584587,
0.45227745175361633,
-0.29178744554519653,
0.6608334183692932,
0.32744520902633667,
-0.8522340059280396,
0.05150367692112923,
-0.15619058907032013,
0.2179272174835205,
0.29235389828681946,
0.6377166509628296,
-0.5919698476791382,
-0.10774680972099304,
-0.7087869644165039,
-0.42925766110420227,
0.7275391221046448,
0.14069107174873352,
-0.13027510046958923,
0.04343728721141815,
0.23793713748455048,
0.03782888129353523,
0.31525370478630066,
-0.47618889808654785,
-0.32856985926628113,
0.19076521694660187,
0.008619057014584541,
0.37714916467666626,
-0.6914698481559753,
-0.39506253600120544,
0.1543116271495819,
0.7553304433822632,
0.029594741761684418,
-0.06407766044139862,
0.1093878522515297,
-0.10495266318321228,
-0.2213226854801178,
0.5670823454856873,
0.6894193291664124,
0.7425870895385742,
0.3706302046775818,
0.24237625300884247,
0.31452739238739014,
-0.3798598051071167,
0.3775063157081604,
0.07016237080097198,
-0.3900100588798523,
-0.17291070520877838,
0.5009552836418152,
0.823250949382782,
-0.32538846135139465,
-0.44846829771995544,
0.589634120464325,
0.1728696972131729,
-0.34776660799980164,
0.23969608545303345,
0.13563065230846405,
0.19302590191364288,
0.22844475507736206,
0.7236974835395813,
-0.16915325820446014,
0.10621457546949387,
-0.48446622490882874,
-0.05927148088812828,
0.365033358335495,
-0.008962178602814674,
-0.1284770518541336,
0.13828128576278687,
-0.000676078605465591,
-0.39703038334846497,
0.5720806121826172,
-0.43499040603637695,
-1.0139085054397583,
0.751400351524353,
0.6441529393196106,
0.46718063950538635,
-0.48084715008735657,
0.4109676778316498,
0.1677650511264801,
0.2965150475502014,
-0.34137147665023804,
-0.02532433718442917,
-0.237049862742424,
-0.685727059841156,
-0.9958856105804443,
-0.5056712627410889,
-0.29138103127479553,
0.13930761814117432,
-0.5511894822120667,
0.01922212541103363,
-0.26247838139533997,
-0.05898129940032959,
0.18730470538139343,
0.02092880755662918,
-0.3862611651420593,
0.3994665741920471,
0.288027822971344,
1.1565766334533691,
-0.6771407127380371,
0.6416299343109131,
0.4884212613105774,
-0.061572201550006866,
-1.1996155977249146,
-0.002507500583305955,
0.2408234179019928,
-0.757536768913269,
0.885623574256897,
0.1225874274969101,
-0.1830930858850479,
-0.23413068056106567,
-0.5997719764709473,
-0.5456401705741882,
0.798833966255188,
0.2473662793636322,
-0.686277449131012,
-0.24035979807376862,
0.25424838066101074,
0.37547287344932556,
-0.4949534833431244,
0.11020167171955109,
0.6876293420791626,
0.5852170586585999,
0.5824222564697266,
-0.9032077193260193,
0.28599557280540466,
-0.045732710510492325,
-0.08814803510904312,
0.13865287601947784,
-0.3708832859992981,
0.9441744685173035,
-0.4036218225955963,
-0.14317461848258972,
-0.06859124451875687,
0.5720403790473938,
0.6171294450759888,
0.3721657693386078,
0.9856007099151611,
0.4654836654663086,
0.8568775057792664,
-0.10857459902763367,
1.0066230297088623,
-0.1276896744966507,
0.12460023164749146,
0.6370583772659302,
-0.06623385101556778,
0.49268752336502075,
0.3928563594818115,
-0.2624935209751129,
0.7161351442337036,
0.5772797465324402,
0.1580919325351715,
0.386667937040329,
0.07471910119056702,
-0.3828599154949188,
-0.4373747706413269,
-0.1803789585828781,
-0.38430002331733704,
0.11870654672384262,
0.42398878931999207,
-0.05303536728024483,
-0.12804719805717468,
0.13425016403198242,
0.16191673278808594,
-0.09576835483312607,
-0.19535516202449799,
0.7038467526435852,
0.1382158100605011,
-1.0740535259246826,
0.6550329923629761,
0.12374362349510193,
0.6931301951408386,
-0.5553186535835266,
-0.008943282999098301,
-0.33883851766586304,
-0.10470331460237503,
-0.1625043898820877,
-0.5681676268577576,
-0.08043897151947021,
0.02844216115772724,
-0.4633138179779053,
-0.1359543353319168,
0.6788092851638794,
-0.5544106960296631,
-0.06902821362018585,
0.09351139515638351,
0.29898983240127563,
-0.19090043008327484,
-0.34933093190193176,
-0.575742244720459,
0.11289019882678986,
0.25705838203430176,
-0.21710313856601715,
0.32986006140708923,
0.616155207157135,
-0.14515338838100433,
0.7451354265213013,
0.8731878995895386,
0.1803625524044037,
0.021365659311413765,
0.0559258833527565,
0.7530733942985535,
-0.2102542370557785,
-0.6863387823104858,
-1.1146008968353271,
0.31477272510528564,
-0.07124501466751099,
0.2898361086845398,
1.0344535112380981,
0.5320608615875244,
0.5504463315010071,
0.13278424739837646,
0.6681684255599976,
-0.16566209495067596,
0.4081098139286041,
-0.6507527232170105,
0.21126388013362885,
-0.4506909251213074,
0.3005012273788452,
0.03648701682686806,
-0.6994249224662781,
0.1123511791229248,
0.27880504727363586,
-0.4257795512676239,
0.12160103023052216,
0.8565918207168579,
0.6140738129615784,
0.03839579224586487,
0.3720821142196655,
0.2438199371099472,
0.19061142206192017,
0.21211400628089905,
0.5352582335472107,
1.0042479038238525,
0.04106564447283745,
0.5005460977554321,
-0.16461504995822906,
-0.3289947211742401,
-0.4009658098220825,
-0.6951904296875,
-0.9953396916389465,
-0.33703646063804626,
-0.20315031707286835,
-0.7043446898460388,
0.06359465420246124,
0.8658738732337952,
0.7240096926689148,
-0.817179799079895,
-0.1889144480228424,
-0.1448361873626709,
0.3632309138774872,
-0.25247442722320557,
-0.12484625726938248,
0.3548373281955719,
-0.0635937824845314,
-0.8197047114372253,
0.6384892463684082,
0.2066524624824524,
0.1814478635787964,
-0.3318479061126709,
-0.21482490003108978,
-0.20408011972904205,
0.32119789719581604,
0.5362877249717712,
0.35318246483802795,
-0.6543163061141968,
0.27765214443206787,
0.3117561638355255,
-0.17346979677677155,
-0.11137590557336807,
1.0643342733383179,
-0.5540658831596375,
0.4052504897117615,
0.6310529112815857,
0.7082201242446899,
0.48424896597862244,
0.43274927139282227,
0.5176780819892883,
-0.6258331537246704,
-0.047032780945301056,
0.03827659785747528,
0.1574929654598236,
0.4565275013446808,
-0.4440220296382904,
0.21343468129634857,
0.30919089913368225,
-0.42701730132102966,
-0.7327009439468384,
0.15525847673416138,
-0.6908538341522217,
-0.22559699416160583,
1.280794620513916,
-0.00814062636345625,
-0.26967474818229675,
0.23497693240642548,
-0.33528798818588257,
-0.08940258622169495,
-0.4150007963180542,
0.6793531179428101,
1.0233368873596191,
0.011942557990550995,
-0.005599696654826403,
-0.23916830122470856,
0.5080934762954712,
0.7070295214653015,
-0.6798816323280334,
0.08559507876634598,
0.6430555582046509,
0.2551453411579132,
0.40295538306236267,
0.568362832069397,
0.09336978197097778,
0.530319094657898,
-0.24543002247810364,
-0.41232526302337646,
-0.3212096095085144,
-0.669148862361908,
-0.4910316467285156,
0.1585695743560791,
0.13808810710906982,
-0.0011220882879570127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14590v1 | Scaling Up LLM Reviews for Google Ads Content Moderation | 2024-02-07T23:47:02 | 2024-02-07T23:47:02 | Wei Qiao, Tushar Dogra, Otilia Stretcu, Yu-Han Lyu, Tiantian Fang, Dongjin Kwon, Chun-Ta Lu, Enming Luo, Yuan Wang, Chih-Chun Chia, Ariel Fuxman, Fangzhou Wang, Ranjay Krishna, Mehmet Tek | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools for content moderation, but
their inference costs and latency make them prohibitive for casual use on large
datasets, such as the Google Ads repository. This study proposes a method for
scaling up LLM reviews for content moderation in Google Ads. First, we use
heuristics to select candidates via filtering and duplicate removal, and create
clusters of ads for which we select one representative ad per cluster. We then
use LLMs to review only the representative ads. Finally, we propagate the LLM
decisions for the representative ads back to their clusters. This method
reduces the number of reviews by more than 3 orders of magnitude while
achieving a 2x recall compared to a baseline non-LLM model. The success of this
approach is a strong function of the representations used in clustering and
label propagation; we found that cross-modal similarity representations yield
better results than uni-modal representations. | [
-0.5191907286643982,
-0.5721420645713806,
0.5794287919998169,
0.3206849694252014,
-0.529017984867096,
0.03662608191370964,
-0.5612388253211975,
-0.29362133145332336,
0.4659876823425293,
0.6787360310554504,
-0.23943382501602173,
-0.6870215535163879,
-0.7651196718215942,
0.12811821699142456,
-0.5309420824050903,
1.287153959274292,
0.09247870743274689,
0.11455735564231873,
-0.29406359791755676,
-0.17067763209342957,
-0.12360550463199615,
-0.091524139046669,
-0.9164854884147644,
-0.24413372576236725,
0.5353168845176697,
0.22284413874149323,
0.6972259283065796,
0.6198703050613403,
0.4277075231075287,
0.25208309292793274,
-0.5083546042442322,
0.24693600833415985,
-0.9185422658920288,
-0.08533934503793716,
-0.17980700731277466,
-0.3881911635398865,
-0.7713451385498047,
0.2493387907743454,
0.7671840190887451,
0.7152323126792908,
-0.26459330320358276,
0.08813722431659698,
0.03989304602146149,
0.7179263830184937,
-0.34646981954574585,
0.024954887107014656,
-0.8234202265739441,
-0.24457356333732605,
0.3671100437641144,
-0.11469417065382004,
-0.4252592921257019,
-0.48557794094085693,
0.23952557146549225,
-0.6687809824943542,
0.2841731905937195,
0.07909969240427017,
0.5469697117805481,
-0.09163733571767807,
-0.7902622222900391,
-0.4695514440536499,
-0.9104830622673035,
0.9355297088623047,
-0.6430925726890564,
0.16379860043525696,
0.3030814230442047,
0.2067752182483673,
0.035927340388298035,
-0.5605699419975281,
-0.2727092206478119,
-0.44406959414482117,
-0.07137971371412277,
-0.03080311231315136,
-0.18038395047187805,
-0.2342379242181778,
0.08155368268489838,
0.6843613386154175,
-0.2453104853630066,
0.054810963571071625,
-0.5429735779762268,
-0.21288973093032837,
0.825192391872406,
0.1889491230249405,
0.03959093987941742,
-0.03796950727701187,
-0.6374715566635132,
-0.1589655578136444,
-0.9426819086074829,
-0.002527485601603985,
0.4498496353626251,
0.13861429691314697,
0.20018434524536133,
0.4610576033592224,
-0.2883058190345764,
0.4324692487716675,
0.3157348036766052,
-0.1143450066447258,
0.002467384794726968,
-0.6927953958511353,
-0.20269425213336945,
-0.02692185901105404,
0.6229148507118225,
0.8405133485794067,
-0.07867065817117691,
0.09564810246229172,
-0.48359864950180054,
0.1311427503824234,
0.7744594216346741,
-0.8416404724121094,
-0.0669112503528595,
-0.05509796366095543,
-0.7086169719696045,
-0.21601200103759766,
0.062073130160570145,
-0.6599633693695068,
-0.5564887523651123,
-0.23060369491577148,
0.5032731294631958,
0.03495822474360466,
0.0571688674390316,
0.21147626638412476,
0.3480580449104309,
-0.23464883863925934,
0.47712814807891846,
-0.6685645580291748,
0.4173421263694763,
0.6225534081459045,
0.6219683885574341,
-0.35403677821159363,
0.1761319488286972,
-0.4719191789627075,
0.1349279284477234,
-0.3656517267227173,
0.9277571439743042,
-0.5504939556121826,
-0.6713331937789917,
-0.009467949159443378,
0.08774646371603012,
0.07393325865268707,
-0.6742634177207947,
0.5780341625213623,
-1.1068556308746338,
0.2568785846233368,
-0.35360196232795715,
-0.7014999389648438,
-0.5245900750160217,
0.38521677255630493,
-0.9763447642326355,
0.5284246206283569,
0.28333014249801636,
-0.25546887516975403,
0.5640705227851868,
-0.27900436520576477,
-0.6001077890396118,
0.019070139154791832,
0.10239075124263763,
-0.6769253611564636,
0.14033782482147217,
0.7138111591339111,
0.37640681862831116,
-0.2818557620048523,
0.23356810212135315,
-0.24690818786621094,
-0.3348662257194519,
-0.04970502853393555,
-0.3172217905521393,
0.3373054265975952,
0.34961801767349243,
-0.15580624341964722,
0.5186787843704224,
-0.45567888021469116,
-0.24796245992183685,
-0.02539975196123123,
-0.6444693207740784,
-0.2917743921279907,
0.06580956280231476,
0.042554158717393875,
-0.10273968428373337,
0.09708047658205032,
-0.3788699805736542,
0.3452967405319214,
-0.08508961647748947,
0.3792014718055725,
0.7843562364578247,
0.2406405657529831,
0.8935505151748657,
-0.4286525845527649,
0.5642482042312622,
-0.12401837855577469,
0.19313782453536987,
-0.05057018622756004,
-0.4363837242126465,
-0.6519538164138794,
-0.217062309384346,
0.22744488716125488,
-0.06244204193353653,
-0.5056539177894592,
0.5525461435317993,
-0.47506746649742126,
-0.4343419373035431,
-0.5805925130844116,
0.6884173154830933,
0.2953812777996063,
0.14985431730747223,
0.15080377459526062,
-0.5764970183372498,
-0.06723015010356903,
-0.6481245756149292,
-0.011908759362995625,
-0.08213289082050323,
-0.3478911519050598,
0.4833402633666992,
0.30176928639411926,
-0.518129825592041,
0.5553678274154663,
-0.447984516620636,
-0.6868129968643188,
-0.2579905688762665,
0.07812856137752533,
0.09652765840291977,
-0.02084692008793354,
0.3648683428764343,
-0.8298770189285278,
-0.5803669095039368,
-0.13953733444213867,
-0.03425680100917816,
-0.18411801755428314,
-0.16645537316799164,
0.31488731503486633,
0.21666847169399261,
0.3488626480102539,
-0.22214452922344208,
0.14696921408176422,
0.9173333048820496,
-0.33321285247802734,
0.21954676508903503,
-0.17818626761436462,
0.4316153824329376,
-1.022430181503296,
-0.2086416780948639,
0.27672427892684937,
-0.46221452951431274,
-0.13325217366218567,
-0.020385567098855972,
0.08478577435016632,
0.12505847215652466,
-0.26324713230133057,
0.3820306956768036,
-0.3989682197570801,
-0.013371587730944157,
-0.41405007243156433,
0.4495658874511719,
0.26071497797966003,
0.16207902133464813,
-0.21247194707393646,
0.8666421175003052,
0.3085734248161316,
-0.7660017609596252,
0.6084737181663513,
-0.07662037014961243,
-0.6909379959106445,
0.6182602643966675,
-0.7735499739646912,
0.0048657068982720375,
-0.1406891644001007,
0.7566799521446228,
-1.5450178384780884,
-0.03483295068144798,
-0.08845718950033188,
-0.15425637364387512,
-0.0058898767456412315,
-0.04606302082538605,
-0.5208337903022766,
-0.2570771276950836,
-0.6191409826278687,
0.23901650309562683,
0.3331436812877655,
-0.7684678435325623,
0.3871144950389862,
0.6171681880950928,
-0.29219192266464233,
0.03220666944980621,
-0.05716455727815628,
0.03591621667146683,
-0.18589960038661957,
-0.5236354470252991,
0.392442911863327,
-0.196199432015419,
-0.1336604207754135,
0.29269635677337646,
-0.19919517636299133,
0.2952269911766052,
-0.18204869329929352,
-0.04815840721130371,
0.09676534682512283,
-0.11043394356966019,
0.11547306180000305,
-0.09147949516773224,
-0.028600018471479416,
-0.0884019210934639,
-0.20617403090000153,
0.4221622049808502,
-0.15258020162582397,
-0.2434086799621582,
-0.17810267210006714,
0.31557461619377136,
0.6904433369636536,
-0.008341625332832336,
0.25389936566352844,
0.7813730239868164,
0.04138028621673584,
-0.36415326595306396,
-0.6008277535438538,
-0.3333463668823242,
-0.40472903847694397,
0.3567824363708496,
0.12833936512470245,
-1.3157368898391724,
0.4995420575141907,
-0.08953441679477692,
0.19618581235408783,
0.41723835468292236,
0.8342821598052979,
0.07251247763633728,
1.4891514778137207,
0.604743480682373,
-0.4350145757198334,
0.53626948595047,
-0.3430020213127136,
0.2479032576084137,
-0.9329622983932495,
-0.11624013632535934,
-0.12641537189483643,
-0.5711495876312256,
-0.46532437205314636,
-0.6611229777336121,
0.6383665800094604,
-0.11981404572725296,
0.2055879533290863,
0.2992561459541321,
-0.2861778140068054,
0.5468065738677979,
0.4643024802207947,
0.24764059484004974,
0.5304567217826843,
0.45773598551750183,
0.2502524256706238,
0.11561387032270432,
-0.4956686198711395,
-0.5374936461448669,
1.1418062448501587,
0.39045003056526184,
1.2243107557296753,
0.2579389214515686,
0.051440849900245667,
0.3884199857711792,
0.7615218758583069,
-0.8558202981948853,
0.6525573134422302,
-0.5022639632225037,
-0.6699352860450745,
-0.35826990008354187,
-0.5832076668739319,
-0.861565351486206,
0.30810901522636414,
-0.1951299011707306,
-0.2274935096502304,
-0.31584060192108154,
-0.04349460452795029,
-0.5158498287200928,
0.5995965600013733,
-0.46210524439811707,
0.11148201674222946,
-0.0516030453145504,
-0.2325955480337143,
-0.7779339551925659,
-0.26939013600349426,
0.29341962933540344,
-0.16863271594047546,
0.23385614156723022,
0.1076979786157608,
-0.11401486396789551,
0.7017675638198853,
-0.32750341296195984,
0.8635330200195312,
0.20348230004310608,
-0.5764505863189697,
0.5891497731208801,
0.228978231549263,
0.626498281955719,
0.41070663928985596,
0.16310185194015503,
-0.1028597429394722,
-0.3905983567237854,
-0.22437690198421478,
-0.6147333979606628,
1.169020652770996,
-0.6592610478401184,
-0.7469565868377686,
0.05017326399683952,
-0.6005310416221619,
-0.07185148447751999,
0.06705078482627869,
-0.05528222769498825,
0.1747542917728424,
-0.05874904617667198,
0.7310479283332825,
0.6724398732185364,
0.10672014206647873,
0.23966261744499207,
0.5035966634750366,
-0.3159297704696655,
-0.799436628818512,
0.6347134113311768,
0.04978465288877487,
0.5446771383285522,
0.03180066496133804,
0.30195167660713196,
-0.6457918882369995,
-0.4679800868034363,
-0.49464142322540283,
0.3154198229312897,
-0.573146402835846,
-0.03667837008833885,
-0.6763728857040405,
0.050104279071092606,
-0.6455578207969666,
-0.17926058173179626,
-0.401677668094635,
-0.24766014516353607,
-0.29689517617225647,
-0.03814836964011192,
0.27775371074676514,
0.9105569124221802,
0.0883442685008049,
0.6648911237716675,
-0.5911592245101929,
0.4447892904281616,
0.7340922951698303,
0.6801669001579285,
0.02326052263379097,
-0.7895034551620483,
-0.34650805592536926,
-0.10570564866065979,
-0.30533918738365173,
-0.4687601923942566,
0.28914502263069153,
-0.12296075373888016,
0.3440476953983307,
0.7608095407485962,
-0.1548905074596405,
0.5113659501075745,
-0.25949543714523315,
0.9621959328651428,
0.15207599103450775,
-0.5543728470802307,
0.19760267436504364,
-0.41244643926620483,
0.2933266758918762,
0.4906664490699768,
0.4872679114341736,
-0.46658289432525635,
-0.20551060140132904,
-0.2950488328933716,
-0.8791269063949585,
0.35175058245658875,
0.035193946212530136,
0.5406179428100586,
0.05166681855916977,
0.22080133855342865,
0.048846740275621414,
0.27489882707595825,
-0.6901346445083618,
-0.01011740043759346,
0.3129907250404358,
0.38835054636001587,
-0.47121894359588623,
-0.7131997346878052,
-0.4017745852470398,
-0.1978856921195984,
0.7911512851715088,
-0.11725611984729767,
-0.1363033652305603,
0.032948002219200134,
-0.011270595714449883,
-0.4846034646034241,
0.3257409930229187,
0.47840023040771484,
0.727954626083374,
-0.2503376603126526,
0.13909025490283966,
0.10733196139335632,
-0.45332080125808716,
0.143568217754364,
-0.29969486594200134,
-0.3387294411659241,
-0.12879720330238342,
0.09619215130805969,
0.7049379348754883,
0.20295722782611847,
-0.5410493016242981,
0.5342620015144348,
-0.19686545431613922,
-0.18034403026103973,
0.07516259700059891,
-0.12740769982337952,
0.04450986534357071,
0.21359381079673767,
0.11084107309579849,
-0.22756245732307434,
0.13696052134037018,
-0.5780741572380066,
0.3227054476737976,
0.4972780644893646,
-0.5198740363121033,
-0.26905161142349243,
0.7883812785148621,
0.4706021845340729,
-0.06102018058300018,
0.5611616969108582,
-0.0735219269990921,
-0.49581339955329895,
0.516329288482666,
0.6551021933555603,
0.9099119901657104,
-0.1944659799337387,
0.3180423378944397,
0.3827686905860901,
0.3978472054004669,
-0.21361200511455536,
-0.0840361937880516,
-0.056894998997449875,
-0.5946601033210754,
-0.6232426166534424,
-0.4854018986225128,
-0.6915131211280823,
0.34211069345474243,
-0.5518903732299805,
0.2299063801765442,
-0.5677799582481384,
-0.3198029398918152,
-0.13902658224105835,
0.36595863103866577,
-0.2892393171787262,
0.36855000257492065,
0.29634028673171997,
0.6724042296409607,
-0.9648624062538147,
0.5261185169219971,
0.7768843770027161,
-0.1213769018650055,
-0.603413999080658,
-0.08092232793569565,
0.19980376958847046,
-0.5278579592704773,
0.14014019072055817,
0.15339094400405884,
-0.33017751574516296,
-0.1589304506778717,
-0.6468337178230286,
-0.7622462511062622,
1.0259759426116943,
-0.049402181059122086,
-0.6194438338279724,
0.2549097537994385,
-0.29748672246932983,
0.7708389759063721,
-0.7557088136672974,
-0.013030723668634892,
0.31950441002845764,
0.24375751614570618,
0.21491344273090363,
-0.7189216613769531,
0.14379270374774933,
0.09564086049795151,
0.15990377962589264,
-0.060908325016498566,
-0.5802266001701355,
0.931145429611206,
-0.416950523853302,
-0.30475789308547974,
-0.06515711545944214,
0.5430803298950195,
0.33008912205696106,
0.26996245980262756,
0.9211040735244751,
0.5819153189659119,
0.41526710987091064,
0.37084153294563293,
1.2253929376602173,
-0.12100426107645035,
0.5880648493766785,
1.018222689628601,
-0.3066094219684601,
0.6413363218307495,
0.5687097907066345,
-0.18770329654216766,
0.46370989084243774,
0.6347326040267944,
-0.18243609368801117,
0.3954499065876007,
0.27572065591812134,
-0.48119720816612244,
-0.3618859648704529,
-0.446416437625885,
-0.13844427466392517,
-0.0014759302139282227,
0.22849597036838531,
-0.6959066987037659,
-0.4709206819534302,
-0.04609241709113121,
0.24187342822551727,
0.29923462867736816,
-0.5307324528694153,
0.8669731616973877,
0.0322871170938015,
-0.6297029256820679,
0.3848769962787628,
0.1640816628932953,
0.610141932964325,
-0.48278507590293884,
0.033245999366045,
-0.26282772421836853,
0.1592772901058197,
-0.05577653646469116,
-0.9647248387336731,
0.14916425943374634,
-0.10405072569847107,
-0.39843231439590454,
-0.6607502698898315,
0.6100710034370422,
-0.6833505034446716,
-0.6568731069564819,
0.5028308629989624,
0.21729479730129242,
-0.06763145327568054,
-0.23513539135456085,
-0.3461763560771942,
0.16588886082172394,
-0.03266581520438194,
-0.4934692978858948,
0.26936420798301697,
0.03952038288116455,
-0.44860124588012695,
0.578134298324585,
0.8436663150787354,
0.3981308341026306,
-0.017514629289507866,
0.37924209237098694,
1.0797098875045776,
-0.34508025646209717,
-0.6159783601760864,
-0.6198429465293884,
0.014731649309396744,
-0.09313567727804184,
0.07255066931247711,
0.8059268593788147,
0.5041685104370117,
1.1614859104156494,
-0.050723012536764145,
0.5408517122268677,
0.20277540385723114,
0.31992843747138977,
-0.3843684494495392,
0.7660397291183472,
-0.6710586547851562,
0.6281642317771912,
-0.06950320303440094,
-1.159913182258606,
-0.5374239683151245,
0.34368279576301575,
-0.4216007888317108,
0.014004494063556194,
0.49687132239341736,
1.0098861455917358,
0.026877082884311676,
-0.1876637190580368,
0.38021355867385864,
0.23324444890022278,
0.5261275172233582,
0.48651930689811707,
0.7081543803215027,
-0.3453044891357422,
0.8262760639190674,
-0.25697988271713257,
-0.1350499540567398,
-0.4001942276954651,
-0.7710192203521729,
-0.9617241621017456,
-0.32058587670326233,
-0.3237013518810272,
-0.6538903713226318,
-0.31913599371910095,
0.763849139213562,
0.9108167290687561,
-0.8000636696815491,
-0.3694334626197815,
0.3839394450187683,
0.3380923569202423,
-0.41982924938201904,
-0.17468522489070892,
0.33912068605422974,
-0.16669249534606934,
-1.0238134860992432,
0.39670756459236145,
0.33393576741218567,
-0.28666743636131287,
-0.6202064156532288,
0.00380596867762506,
0.06031092628836632,
0.18432150781154633,
0.9186577200889587,
-0.20745712518692017,
-0.6402231454849243,
-0.3217436969280243,
-0.08422594517469406,
-0.33404892683029175,
0.03451400250196457,
1.056876540184021,
-0.42455801367759705,
0.8914940357208252,
0.670085608959198,
0.4613075852394104,
0.3696805536746979,
0.3152708411216736,
0.39641422033309937,
-0.5500172972679138,
-0.27964285016059875,
0.06225890293717384,
0.11124169826507568,
0.2651035487651825,
-0.3019285202026367,
0.334539532661438,
0.12020838260650635,
-0.6739906668663025,
-0.4470558166503906,
0.28813597559928894,
-1.065049409866333,
-0.09832800179719925,
1.5008383989334106,
-0.03391754999756813,
-0.1534198522567749,
0.3262792229652405,
-0.35562223196029663,
-0.12868259847164154,
-0.46241146326065063,
1.2158074378967285,
0.6102780103683472,
0.1425803303718567,
-0.032437510788440704,
-0.2924816906452179,
0.31849759817123413,
0.3623175024986267,
-0.48672130703926086,
-0.03577681630849838,
0.6457458138465881,
0.5641908645629883,
0.12745946645736694,
0.6160573959350586,
-0.4720023572444916,
0.02547762170433998,
-0.3663730323314667,
-0.27999642491340637,
0.1291322112083435,
-0.5032581686973572,
-0.6851345896720886,
0.3000890612602234,
-0.13481608033180237,
0.035372134298086166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05318v1 | Navigating the Knowledge Sea: Planet-scale answer retrieval using LLMs | 2024-02-07T23:39:40 | 2024-02-07T23:39:40 | Dipankar Sarkar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Information retrieval is a rapidly evolving field of information retrieval,
which is characterized by a continuous refinement of techniques and
technologies, from basic hyperlink-based navigation to sophisticated
algorithm-driven search engines. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive
overview of the evolution of Information Retrieval Technology, with a
particular focus on the role of Large Language Models (LLMs) in bridging the
gap between traditional search methods and the emerging paradigm of answer
retrieval. The integration of LLMs in the realms of response retrieval and
indexing signifies a paradigm shift in how users interact with information
systems. This paradigm shift is driven by the integration of large language
models (LLMs) like GPT-4, which are capable of understanding and generating
human-like text, thus enabling them to provide more direct and contextually
relevant answers to user queries. Through this exploration, we seek to
illuminate the technological milestones that have shaped this journey and the
potential future directions in this rapidly changing field. | [
-0.6049960851669312,
-0.800057053565979,
1.1410233974456787,
-0.2138793021440506,
-0.09340915828943253,
0.4433978497982025,
0.046975553035736084,
-0.4480184018611908,
0.07962113618850708,
0.5860400199890137,
-0.5478784441947937,
-0.29405322670936584,
-0.41017866134643555,
0.04040573164820671,
-0.38441216945648193,
0.8384880423545837,
0.18162819743156433,
-0.10006509721279144,
-0.3385773301124573,
0.07904183119535446,
-0.2092110514640808,
-0.6625472903251648,
-0.39323094487190247,
-0.3979476988315582,
0.6280781626701355,
0.29877033829689026,
0.8434351086616516,
0.7212541699409485,
0.9091058969497681,
0.25893744826316833,
-0.28640976548194885,
0.11074203252792358,
-0.440462201833725,
0.3518603444099426,
-0.35388514399528503,
-0.7675320506095886,
-0.349240243434906,
-0.012002596631646156,
0.5719213485717773,
0.8513202667236328,
-0.19316285848617554,
0.239034041762352,
0.07068498432636261,
0.7944301962852478,
-0.3932725191116333,
0.11017617583274841,
-0.6026628613471985,
-0.027563851326704025,
-0.33427250385284424,
-0.7107492089271545,
-0.17636635899543762,
-0.48200365900993347,
0.29068100452423096,
-0.8415749073028564,
0.04549942910671234,
0.4256044328212738,
0.4592381417751312,
0.1680079698562622,
-0.6735391616821289,
-0.7021447420120239,
-0.8640837073326111,
0.7753347754478455,
-0.45003193616867065,
0.5491690635681152,
0.035595446825027466,
0.6071256399154663,
-0.3985610604286194,
-1.0423295497894287,
-0.5331886410713196,
-0.028355374932289124,
0.27972298860549927,
0.07676443457603455,
0.026878735050559044,
-0.05677170678973198,
0.04375821352005005,
0.43328651785850525,
-0.5798456072807312,
0.039816491305828094,
-0.57132887840271,
0.05491609498858452,
0.36190348863601685,
0.2388899028301239,
0.2079743891954422,
-0.2650117874145508,
-0.4249010980129242,
0.11084730178117752,
-1.0447824001312256,
-0.20533768832683563,
0.054593537002801895,
0.4592982828617096,
0.2397644966840744,
0.6653810143470764,
-0.1553771048784256,
0.8776698112487793,
-0.16957682371139526,
-0.34139975905418396,
0.012473559007048607,
-0.3391505181789398,
-0.08201562613248825,
-0.06883540749549866,
0.47109586000442505,
0.32232576608657837,
-0.02873152866959572,
-0.12813740968704224,
-0.15489159524440765,
-0.36859625577926636,
0.3092513680458069,
-0.6914737224578857,
0.07306654006242752,
-0.03766442835330963,
-0.5504177808761597,
-0.3192378282546997,
0.005227911286056042,
-1.0077764987945557,
-0.80422043800354,
-0.3747694194316864,
0.5037167072296143,
-0.0808369442820549,
-0.3419060707092285,
0.18172258138656616,
-0.09398039430379868,
0.47242701053619385,
0.3920717239379883,
-0.6756781935691833,
0.3140333592891693,
0.8968597054481506,
0.9249879121780396,
-0.10133687406778336,
0.27075526118278503,
-0.20075583457946777,
0.2650691866874695,
-0.30567824840545654,
0.7568854093551636,
-0.5692830085754395,
-0.7247934341430664,
0.18162661790847778,
-0.1568923145532608,
0.33287331461906433,
-0.6369723081588745,
0.4469844698905945,
-1.3539830446243286,
0.22638918459415436,
-0.6620759963989258,
-0.5933805704116821,
-0.44028958678245544,
0.6102110743522644,
-0.6028891801834106,
1.0035344362258911,
0.02240877039730549,
-0.7013269662857056,
0.020815683528780937,
-0.9192203283309937,
-0.0044215526431798935,
0.521794855594635,
-0.2196483612060547,
0.18652211129665375,
-0.09152345359325409,
0.013163313269615173,
0.2039157897233963,
-0.9962943196296692,
0.03486419469118118,
-0.2616293430328369,
-0.4790528416633606,
0.07285962253808975,
-0.026891034096479416,
0.3876417875289917,
0.35454031825065613,
-0.12650683522224426,
-0.13864094018936157,
-0.4909399449825287,
0.09905118495225906,
0.127268448472023,
-0.621667742729187,
-0.5035061836242676,
0.11767537891864777,
-0.17545470595359802,
0.5128597617149353,
0.7724328637123108,
-0.4448493421077728,
0.4323258697986603,
-0.011244330555200577,
0.717880368232727,
0.6304672956466675,
0.2594732344150543,
0.5169261693954468,
-0.2448604851961136,
0.6498157978057861,
0.04774940758943558,
0.25020352005958557,
-0.2743290662765503,
-0.6157260537147522,
-0.4032015800476074,
0.34593096375465393,
0.1344475895166397,
0.5942614674568176,
-0.9618076086044312,
0.07261960208415985,
-0.7180400490760803,
-0.6455498337745667,
-0.7097062468528748,
0.1891196221113205,
-0.05541987717151642,
0.5512377023696899,
0.47031041979789734,
0.022454572841525078,
-0.3216221034526825,
-0.7463069558143616,
-0.2126370370388031,
-0.3631688058376312,
-0.237277090549469,
0.4992804229259491,
0.2408173680305481,
-0.27730828523635864,
0.80424565076828,
-0.5802334547042847,
-0.05562959983944893,
-0.1962101310491562,
-0.15504240989685059,
0.43849411606788635,
0.10827827453613281,
0.07695131748914719,
-1.395546555519104,
-0.161210298538208,
0.20391754806041718,
-0.9257878065109253,
-0.08504393696784973,
0.21080882847309113,
-0.04140746220946312,
-0.25748804211616516,
0.9370166659355164,
-0.4975627362728119,
0.04473008215427399,
0.32726410031318665,
-0.12896870076656342,
0.43852317333221436,
-0.18400657176971436,
0.3865622878074646,
-1.0941967964172363,
0.21968214213848114,
-0.03659074008464813,
-0.05949299409985542,
-0.5204821228981018,
0.31622496247291565,
0.1667030304670334,
0.0805724486708641,
-0.07362686842679977,
0.4560546875,
-0.6725048422813416,
-0.5632299780845642,
-0.28533366322517395,
0.6929315328598022,
-0.13453541696071625,
0.006311941426247358,
-0.22519901394844055,
1.0538781881332397,
0.202828511595726,
-0.8806148171424866,
0.5505943894386292,
0.2724449336528778,
-0.23293088376522064,
0.6824485659599304,
-0.3675629496574402,
0.3130016624927521,
-0.2132079154253006,
0.1089337095618248,
-1.0914857387542725,
-0.08172950893640518,
-0.2317807674407959,
-0.24319282174110413,
0.039163704961538315,
-0.16833490133285522,
-0.8175022006034851,
-0.6475223302841187,
-0.2753104567527771,
0.4463502764701843,
0.4322214424610138,
-0.6082406640052795,
0.5816828012466431,
0.573691725730896,
-0.6627063155174255,
-0.4358919560909271,
-0.4492990970611572,
0.39918532967567444,
-0.3659259080886841,
-0.6083425283432007,
0.3450872004032135,
-0.3994186520576477,
-0.4317606985569,
-0.2518826127052307,
-0.16079501807689667,
0.06295330077409744,
0.02249975875020027,
-0.06758445501327515,
0.6231367588043213,
-0.3556487262248993,
0.34706225991249084,
-0.16544866561889648,
0.1647133231163025,
0.10776161402463913,
-0.5467063188552856,
0.686268150806427,
-0.2337249368429184,
-0.2335297018289566,
0.0010066890390589833,
0.1555464267730713,
0.7840147018432617,
-0.26837125420570374,
0.5644229054450989,
0.2703542709350586,
-0.11735132336616516,
0.3102215826511383,
-0.8237689137458801,
-0.23288145661354065,
-0.5573593974113464,
0.4430578947067261,
-0.44002917408943176,
-1.2186723947525024,
0.531918466091156,
-0.5891268253326416,
-0.098446786403656,
0.298710435628891,
0.24851128458976746,
-0.08887308835983276,
0.831343412399292,
0.901263415813446,
-0.11212795227766037,
0.366079181432724,
0.1341329962015152,
0.3208516240119934,
-1.1491211652755737,
-0.4773661196231842,
-0.5115669369697571,
-0.2534531354904175,
-1.087337851524353,
-0.5064259171485901,
0.8998170495033264,
-0.08994120359420776,
-0.502700686454773,
-0.0950414165854454,
-0.4210970997810364,
0.35432547330856323,
0.42681753635406494,
0.08473746478557587,
0.5959634780883789,
-0.12268392741680145,
-0.12379813939332962,
-0.11273305118083954,
-0.6808010339736938,
-0.5379135608673096,
1.2982577085494995,
0.2868078649044037,
0.8591142296791077,
0.36099132895469666,
0.48118463158607483,
0.2878870964050293,
0.23129130899906158,
-0.6538049578666687,
0.8660553693771362,
0.11360760033130646,
-0.6299225091934204,
-0.3515816926956177,
-0.4771810472011566,
-0.7680619359016418,
0.3400436341762543,
0.030271966010332108,
-0.526419997215271,
-0.022112399339675903,
-0.35034146904945374,
-0.22901490330696106,
0.4569227993488312,
-0.3016298711299896,
0.3550805449485779,
-0.237524151802063,
-0.46621018648147583,
-0.20718199014663696,
-0.9411576390266418,
0.2093081921339035,
-0.17908412218093872,
0.4988091289997101,
0.25916242599487305,
-0.4860887825489044,
0.7148709297180176,
0.12831248342990875,
0.3975144624710083,
-0.14157560467720032,
-0.3087827265262604,
0.21270477771759033,
0.259359747171402,
0.3092198669910431,
-0.25473058223724365,
-0.2305915355682373,
-0.2685428261756897,
-0.0105091892182827,
-0.33972427248954773,
-0.5009075999259949,
0.9476520419120789,
-0.5938735604286194,
-0.8353245854377747,
-0.24975843727588654,
-0.5303941369056702,
-0.3401542603969574,
0.4775640666484833,
-0.03121737390756607,
0.18738655745983124,
-0.05672423914074898,
0.2031179964542389,
1.2387384176254272,
-0.2513733208179474,
0.32326948642730713,
0.6739826798439026,
-0.6347989439964294,
-0.13124476373195648,
0.6726091504096985,
0.19808520376682281,
0.19620168209075928,
0.6199788451194763,
0.006679742597043514,
-0.5458085536956787,
-0.5570389032363892,
-0.1747926026582718,
0.4875958263874054,
-0.9339303970336914,
-0.2664410471916199,
-0.40592172741889954,
-0.1875341683626175,
-0.2178592085838318,
-0.015800893306732178,
0.015364068560302258,
-0.24379754066467285,
-0.10071167349815369,
-0.20440562069416046,
0.20691664516925812,
1.3101580142974854,
0.14232678711414337,
0.23297961056232452,
-0.7537246346473694,
0.14628516137599945,
0.34176892042160034,
0.25680866837501526,
-0.1516668200492859,
-0.5873419046401978,
-0.1284732073545456,
-0.16066104173660278,
-0.40901345014572144,
-0.9669654369354248,
0.2071763277053833,
-0.09301884472370148,
0.42973726987838745,
0.150271937251091,
-0.17045623064041138,
0.5319061875343323,
-0.4615320563316345,
0.9725499153137207,
-0.0008261905750259757,
-0.5108820199966431,
0.5285249352455139,
-0.6653379201889038,
0.521978497505188,
0.3322606682777405,
0.6076884865760803,
-0.9990818500518799,
0.0963648334145546,
-0.28060099482536316,
-1.0754623413085938,
0.38453876972198486,
-0.3689080476760864,
-0.015041742473840714,
0.142332062125206,
0.8069797158241272,
0.007129464764147997,
0.5792325139045715,
-0.5816115736961365,
-0.13524924218654633,
0.2195121943950653,
-0.007660996168851852,
-0.046714916825294495,
-0.23364712297916412,
0.018933065235614777,
0.0718298926949501,
0.8399341702461243,
-0.23414094746112823,
0.3685019910335541,
0.1993265450000763,
-0.056034527719020844,
-0.10632820427417755,
0.4782925546169281,
0.30318352580070496,
0.73689204454422,
-0.13642051815986633,
0.1673518568277359,
-0.05626548454165459,
-0.5455654859542847,
0.05688432976603508,
0.17617452144622803,
-0.18504415452480316,
-0.25213730335235596,
-0.025043144822120667,
0.47450295090675354,
0.17916758358478546,
-0.5708248615264893,
0.3539290428161621,
0.1075616106390953,
-0.035321470350027084,
-0.3907875418663025,
-0.05186302587389946,
0.35166069865226746,
0.45364663004875183,
1.0824211835861206,
-0.3685799837112427,
0.38210493326187134,
-0.6284613013267517,
-0.027258068323135376,
0.44589564204216003,
-0.3903062343597412,
-0.1783936470746994,
0.7098886966705322,
0.042034585028886795,
-0.16198840737342834,
0.6510812640190125,
0.07442857325077057,
-0.3566928803920746,
0.23125982284545898,
0.389670193195343,
0.5087312459945679,
-0.42271140217781067,
0.06272939592599869,
0.16334490478038788,
0.4401569664478302,
-0.042680371552705765,
0.34091633558273315,
-0.162733256816864,
-0.4567725360393524,
-0.18532532453536987,
-0.6708390712738037,
-0.47887155413627625,
0.22020410001277924,
-0.683445394039154,
-0.011438923887908459,
-0.3861200511455536,
-0.25878751277923584,
-0.008012610487639904,
0.08085290342569351,
-0.7082337737083435,
0.21478959918022156,
0.30406272411346436,
1.2316938638687134,
-0.44392359256744385,
0.5179218649864197,
1.0400934219360352,
-0.3792383074760437,
-0.3415769338607788,
0.15897241234779358,
0.2450142204761505,
-0.7681215405464172,
0.8944502472877502,
0.042616989463567734,
-0.24648258090019226,
0.3222901523113251,
-0.7668213248252869,
-1.154786467552185,
1.571876049041748,
0.01767902448773384,
-0.43064311146736145,
-0.4659591317176819,
0.33968400955200195,
0.5710123181343079,
-0.3416760265827179,
0.2996021807193756,
0.6941766738891602,
0.4572007656097412,
0.017664577811956406,
-1.0226211547851562,
0.07671879976987839,
-0.05973203480243683,
0.40284353494644165,
0.3100685477256775,
-0.6432990431785583,
0.7361988425254822,
-0.07264961302280426,
0.0009171851561404765,
0.21370315551757812,
0.6296067833900452,
0.26598644256591797,
0.08818185329437256,
0.2723037302494049,
0.20948094129562378,
0.8609411120414734,
-0.1907597780227661,
0.9367000460624695,
-0.2825026512145996,
0.13493850827217102,
0.5221819877624512,
-0.3917425870895386,
1.0204977989196777,
0.7542684078216553,
-0.37796998023986816,
0.6956090331077576,
0.5976225137710571,
0.33443892002105713,
0.40881335735321045,
0.21941833198070526,
-0.6366598010063171,
-0.23529189825057983,
-0.14776773750782013,
-0.2769930362701416,
0.23778913915157318,
0.7913705110549927,
-0.3000856637954712,
-0.4196268618106842,
-0.001651622587814927,
-0.03236275911331177,
0.07044927775859833,
-0.6667858362197876,
0.8878268599510193,
0.09431734681129456,
-0.7529817819595337,
0.3242085874080658,
-0.07604347914457321,
0.715700089931488,
-0.7530469298362732,
-0.022206760942935944,
-0.1784815639257431,
0.004886563867330551,
-0.07460661977529526,
-1.1248819828033447,
-0.24691654741764069,
-0.23969726264476776,
-0.22424307465553284,
-0.08372298628091812,
0.76551753282547,
-0.2138155996799469,
-0.03723224624991417,
0.4598817825317383,
0.7418544888496399,
0.1549340933561325,
-0.06952623277902603,
-0.6971021890640259,
0.01707678847014904,
0.008754367008805275,
-0.41537025570869446,
0.49471622705459595,
0.5653496980667114,
-0.11234967410564423,
1.095409870147705,
0.5978643298149109,
-0.15622104704380035,
0.28753647208213806,
-0.30447301268577576,
0.9935906529426575,
-0.9518715143203735,
-0.5710033774375916,
-0.6083492636680603,
0.0759294331073761,
-0.04375789687037468,
0.0825427994132042,
0.7123659253120422,
0.6309356689453125,
0.4112163186073303,
0.11739925295114517,
1.0877926349639893,
-0.058345720171928406,
0.7841091156005859,
-0.37989112734794617,
0.5083303451538086,
-0.5142297744750977,
0.5551736950874329,
-0.17877602577209473,
-1.0424869060516357,
-0.07921964675188065,
0.11757586151361465,
-0.575097918510437,
0.25838345289230347,
0.4268481135368347,
0.7878064513206482,
-0.023836784064769745,
0.15306179225444794,
0.2561505138874054,
0.2910321056842804,
0.4670853912830353,
0.3176879584789276,
0.8185303807258606,
-0.31744837760925293,
0.7390950918197632,
0.33969131112098694,
-0.3700126111507416,
-0.39160779118537903,
-0.7519586086273193,
-0.2304396629333496,
-0.7403774261474609,
0.054191604256629944,
-0.1700071394443512,
0.24688993394374847,
0.6747251749038696,
0.37660476565361023,
-0.3896816372871399,
-0.5195174217224121,
-0.0446496419608593,
-0.16370181739330292,
0.18817630410194397,
-0.2473568618297577,
0.08673354238271713,
-0.3849116861820221,
-0.46920046210289,
0.5268740057945251,
0.5122783780097961,
0.04637443646788597,
-0.49298229813575745,
0.04416825994849205,
-0.3814658522605896,
0.10306661576032639,
0.6027950644493103,
0.4149801731109619,
-0.45383578538894653,
0.005228414665907621,
0.3919217586517334,
-0.21624507009983063,
0.12222372740507126,
0.6492332220077515,
-0.9126092195510864,
0.45310357213020325,
0.2472725510597229,
0.793161928653717,
0.6096605658531189,
0.04209170490503311,
0.6322136521339417,
-0.4027898609638214,
-0.27072790265083313,
0.18261544406414032,
0.13324277102947235,
0.7602254748344421,
-0.34099602699279785,
0.6608899831771851,
0.19727031886577606,
-1.0000191926956177,
-0.6942575573921204,
0.2590641975402832,
-0.8366695642471313,
-0.24260163307189941,
1.137657880783081,
0.2013367861509323,
-0.25214576721191406,
-0.2063351720571518,
-0.20023739337921143,
-0.06164637580513954,
-0.17929287254810333,
0.7719869017601013,
0.7842780947685242,
-0.19614598155021667,
-0.19041591882705688,
-1.0792547464370728,
0.4114736020565033,
0.1536865383386612,
-0.8730043768882751,
-0.0371207557618618,
0.48417338728904724,
0.42954686284065247,
0.5753945112228394,
0.5184138417243958,
-0.35960787534713745,
0.10932218283414841,
-0.45187410712242126,
-0.0748111680150032,
0.33561190962791443,
-0.15602581202983856,
-0.18643294274806976,
0.3472481966018677,
0.41217881441116333,
0.09776125103235245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05294v1 | Examining Modality Incongruity in Multimodal Federated Learning for Medical Vision and Language-based Disease Detection | 2024-02-07T22:16:53 | 2024-02-07T22:16:53 | Pramit Saha, Divyanshu Mishra, Felix Wagner, Konstantinos Kamnitsas, J. Alison Noble | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Federated Learning (MMFL) utilizes multiple modalities in each
client to build a more powerful Federated Learning (FL) model than its unimodal
counterpart. However, the impact of missing modality in different clients, also
called modality incongruity, has been greatly overlooked. This paper, for the
first time, analyses the impact of modality incongruity and reveals its
connection with data heterogeneity across participating clients. We
particularly inspect whether incongruent MMFL with unimodal and multimodal
clients is more beneficial than unimodal FL. Furthermore, we examine three
potential routes of addressing this issue. Firstly, we study the effectiveness
of various self-attention mechanisms towards incongruity-agnostic information
fusion in MMFL. Secondly, we introduce a modality imputation network (MIN)
pre-trained in a multimodal client for modality translation in unimodal clients
and investigate its potential towards mitigating the missing modality problem.
Thirdly, we assess the capability of client-level and server-level
regularization techniques towards mitigating modality incongruity effects.
Experiments are conducted under several MMFL settings on two publicly available
real-world datasets, MIMIC-CXR and Open-I, with Chest X-Ray and radiology
reports. | [
-0.09676448255777359,
-0.7579456567764282,
0.2432023286819458,
0.12080961465835571,
-0.1167149543762207,
-0.19668865203857422,
0.011356833390891552,
-0.7381781935691833,
0.32819461822509766,
0.14353790879249573,
-0.6467731595039368,
-0.11074841767549515,
-0.3561198115348816,
0.28157904744148254,
0.1802935004234314,
0.9414446353912354,
0.09942968189716339,
0.41426268219947815,
-0.4143904447555542,
-0.5403050780296326,
-0.4149937927722931,
-0.4683833718299866,
-0.36634835600852966,
-0.39610570669174194,
0.5141002535820007,
0.4592772126197815,
1.0367019176483154,
0.7475996613502502,
0.7289422750473022,
0.22620563209056854,
0.41325366497039795,
0.22551186382770538,
-0.37708890438079834,
0.06910385936498642,
0.05360780283808708,
-0.4227310121059418,
-0.5073432326316833,
0.18679781258106232,
0.6469401717185974,
1.0086891651153564,
0.08920285850763321,
-0.006233586464077234,
-0.23902584612369537,
0.5438066720962524,
-0.5047001242637634,
0.2381448596715927,
-0.2063240110874176,
0.6585866808891296,
-0.3899606764316559,
-0.4559784531593323,
-0.21700961887836456,
0.2967401444911957,
0.28265824913978577,
-0.481993705034256,
0.2841527760028839,
0.04480420798063278,
0.5871822237968445,
0.37389957904815674,
-0.7273440361022949,
-0.3113786578178406,
-0.4305712878704071,
0.4360324740409851,
-0.5113864541053772,
0.7004232406616211,
0.5243754982948303,
0.22833994030952454,
-0.12038290500640869,
-0.5911663174629211,
-0.3629608154296875,
-0.3759406805038452,
-0.40436190366744995,
0.331205815076828,
-0.04697399213910103,
0.22467586398124695,
0.12016589194536209,
0.5059329271316528,
-0.7777373790740967,
0.12633225321769714,
-0.2589136064052582,
-0.5325098037719727,
0.4191107451915741,
0.19070257246494293,
0.32264280319213867,
-0.3168012797832489,
-0.7087825536727905,
0.0847720354795456,
-0.47386860847473145,
0.09576936066150665,
0.29636332392692566,
0.2347736805677414,
-0.41226816177368164,
0.38844650983810425,
-0.1694256067276001,
0.5622255206108093,
0.1274348944425583,
-0.6744452714920044,
0.5285791158676147,
-0.7088510990142822,
-0.4823016822338104,
-0.1147676333785057,
0.687475860118866,
-0.11892068386077881,
-0.49429261684417725,
-0.2451954483985901,
-0.1771940439939499,
-0.2346639335155487,
-0.08206166326999664,
-0.4508056640625,
-0.31143292784690857,
0.17435120046138763,
-0.9293337464332581,
-0.31037023663520813,
-0.06410974264144897,
-0.38331741094589233,
-0.2118244618177414,
-0.2470986396074295,
0.5765483975410461,
-0.6189220547676086,
-0.5283346772193909,
-0.11514807492494583,
0.06003561615943909,
-0.12889452278614044,
0.4229731857776642,
-0.6852911710739136,
-0.08740272372961044,
0.34016406536102295,
0.6339176297187805,
0.026709115132689476,
-0.4951862692832947,
-0.7503842115402222,
0.0978020504117012,
0.08327092230319977,
0.5101331472396851,
-0.6174652576446533,
-0.19067953526973724,
-0.29187434911727905,
0.0973878800868988,
-0.5835828185081482,
-0.48462894558906555,
0.2894788682460785,
-0.12298411130905151,
0.4866184592247009,
-0.13770079612731934,
-0.3615664839744568,
-0.2913497984409332,
0.3747270405292511,
-0.8013172149658203,
0.4961666166782379,
0.24854275584220886,
-0.5072160959243774,
0.4596455991268158,
-0.507915198802948,
-0.5452410578727722,
0.11878687888383865,
-0.5013452768325806,
-0.5177266597747803,
0.19275082647800446,
-0.1658915877342224,
0.573550820350647,
-0.21354304254055023,
0.1789247840642929,
-0.46260935068130493,
-0.29256612062454224,
0.47558143734931946,
-0.7693597078323364,
0.7418801784515381,
0.2398761659860611,
-0.3692249357700348,
-0.04878449812531471,
-0.8519684076309204,
-0.17191018164157867,
0.010216845199465752,
-0.41137057542800903,
-0.2561509907245636,
-0.16321136057376862,
0.2933671772480011,
0.45074209570884705,
-0.038847342133522034,
-0.35307732224464417,
-0.022961167618632317,
-0.3738234341144562,
0.2883255183696747,
0.5953277945518494,
-0.1437263935804367,
0.01605374552309513,
-0.7478553056716919,
0.514125645160675,
0.43378156423568726,
0.7108286619186401,
-0.37149778008461,
-0.3062064051628113,
-0.2976144850254059,
-0.8397102355957031,
-0.11270193755626678,
0.08984755724668503,
-1.0383262634277344,
-0.21757517755031586,
-0.08361944556236267,
-0.03832291439175606,
-0.5959775447845459,
0.0211106538772583,
0.7958396077156067,
0.6115074157714844,
0.32005491852760315,
-0.5176225304603577,
-0.2167908400297165,
-0.9403359889984131,
0.02705409564077854,
-0.06013414263725281,
0.3335111141204834,
0.4217110276222229,
0.2003827840089798,
-0.5575805902481079,
0.5023805499076843,
0.046556733548641205,
-0.8224180340766907,
0.09776590019464493,
0.1049528643488884,
-0.0886593833565712,
0.4238619804382324,
0.7156568169593811,
-1.0229573249816895,
-0.3529050350189209,
0.16460813581943512,
-0.7538855671882629,
0.0629916563630104,
-0.25084006786346436,
0.4374226927757263,
0.41475704312324524,
0.2576548457145691,
-0.11916036903858185,
0.38214293122291565,
0.7249166965484619,
-0.5472615957260132,
0.6001744270324707,
-0.3038075268268585,
0.40151646733283997,
-0.7012795805931091,
0.15775726735591888,
-0.08093101531267166,
-0.3642841577529907,
-0.7271806001663208,
0.17492541670799255,
0.052939195185899734,
-0.16505388915538788,
-0.19390222430229187,
0.23898068070411682,
-0.5928139686584473,
-0.15404388308525085,
-0.009455647319555283,
-0.3343085050582886,
0.14866900444030762,
0.5073270201683044,
-0.3891339600086212,
0.7073808312416077,
0.4587320387363434,
-0.21934890747070312,
0.06972034275531769,
0.04254700616002083,
0.10463322699069977,
0.7384911775588989,
-0.25451523065567017,
-0.14135096967220306,
-0.27616623044013977,
0.10371042788028717,
-1.0997462272644043,
-0.4620715081691742,
0.47664526104927063,
-0.3097250759601593,
0.47806206345558167,
0.001038925489410758,
-0.6157274842262268,
-0.1418951004743576,
-0.32851442694664,
0.8057745099067688,
-0.235060453414917,
-0.3474482297897339,
0.599314272403717,
0.22845089435577393,
0.3890219032764435,
-0.45107340812683105,
-0.8736299276351929,
-0.16387271881103516,
0.06888609379529953,
-0.7810035347938538,
-0.035402536392211914,
-0.5015215277671814,
0.009969357401132584,
-0.018674880266189575,
-0.21626289188861847,
-0.22145284712314606,
0.27086588740348816,
0.47171080112457275,
0.16644622385501862,
-0.39491552114486694,
0.5886816382408142,
-0.0821790024638176,
0.07629114389419556,
-0.16896721720695496,
0.04760327190160751,
0.3847723603248596,
-0.2390325665473938,
-0.9762058854103088,
-0.5210171341896057,
0.6195384860038757,
0.8137646317481995,
-0.2640218436717987,
0.38688868284225464,
0.8022051453590393,
-0.182092547416687,
0.13345415890216827,
-0.690132200717926,
-0.15142309665679932,
-0.40628308057785034,
0.2103421688079834,
-0.5586189031600952,
-1.0189205408096313,
0.39067986607551575,
0.2714182734489441,
-0.29834848642349243,
0.18056359887123108,
0.5137858390808105,
0.023453740403056145,
0.8558580279350281,
0.8700292706489563,
0.14888827502727509,
0.5545536875724792,
0.007321322802454233,
0.1030498817563057,
-0.5718088150024414,
-0.39346176385879517,
0.06756335496902466,
-0.3529939353466034,
-0.397759348154068,
-0.46404731273651123,
0.7613410949707031,
-0.27737829089164734,
0.27188605070114136,
-0.2742466330528259,
-0.3224364221096039,
0.19476330280303955,
0.24790535867214203,
0.5364996194839478,
0.6889181733131409,
0.055205438286066055,
-0.2928658425807953,
-0.16523240506649017,
-0.8561640977859497,
0.3033454716205597,
1.1458032131195068,
0.32465457916259766,
0.5305171012878418,
0.3332618474960327,
0.3490055203437805,
0.5681944489479065,
0.4811016917228699,
-0.8082868456840515,
0.07033686339855194,
-0.15393830835819244,
-0.5592711567878723,
-0.11171168833971024,
-0.6237903833389282,
-0.8499078750610352,
0.523516058921814,
-0.4114866554737091,
-0.23158475756645203,
0.6800034046173096,
0.2350306212902069,
-0.2514672577381134,
0.06110510230064392,
-0.7224529385566711,
0.8773261904716492,
-0.2269054502248764,
-0.311122864484787,
-0.23696035146713257,
-0.9185205698013306,
0.5577518343925476,
-0.15645189583301544,
0.359573632478714,
-0.16503380239009857,
0.04844990745186806,
0.0688730925321579,
-0.3652874827384949,
0.9342420697212219,
0.062444306910037994,
-0.011425028555095196,
-0.40835151076316833,
0.012611780315637589,
0.10048671066761017,
0.24288152158260345,
0.15556250512599945,
0.28775888681411743,
0.002468036487698555,
-0.4638952910900116,
-0.1626356989145279,
0.7129757404327393,
-0.7071491479873657,
-0.3479931950569153,
-0.5148285627365112,
-0.9497028589248657,
-0.3163415193557739,
0.20802536606788635,
0.2902625501155853,
1.0292123556137085,
0.07121088355779648,
0.06975387036800385,
0.8182685375213623,
0.10600932687520981,
0.4952557682991028,
0.7958117127418518,
0.11419346928596497,
-0.4593537747859955,
0.9033198952674866,
0.29872366786003113,
0.574526846408844,
0.43674853444099426,
0.17108558118343353,
0.21619205176830292,
-0.4338668882846832,
-0.433296263217926,
0.5244528651237488,
-0.688994288444519,
-0.25084996223449707,
-0.791617751121521,
-0.01913500390946865,
-0.45353880524635315,
0.018322408199310303,
-0.2144838273525238,
-0.14541609585285187,
-0.4275408089160919,
0.3976214528083801,
0.04718999192118645,
0.2783859372138977,
-0.36344754695892334,
0.0016487283864989877,
-0.6664587259292603,
-0.01678469404578209,
0.23530149459838867,
0.3854356110095978,
-0.002977194031700492,
-0.20093771815299988,
-0.38828468322753906,
0.16559506952762604,
0.005969244986772537,
-0.6779971718788147,
0.025603096932172775,
0.5295560956001282,
0.6485505700111389,
0.821134626865387,
-0.18121139705181122,
0.755569577217102,
-0.08704118430614471,
0.24934187531471252,
0.6084427833557129,
-0.621763288974762,
0.23525267839431763,
-0.32463738322257996,
0.28571799397468567,
0.4580843448638916,
0.3218079209327698,
-0.5399147868156433,
-0.33049634099006653,
-0.5708674788475037,
-0.3725361227989197,
0.600487232208252,
-0.04826376214623451,
-0.14754511415958405,
-0.11381678283214569,
0.13609610497951508,
0.5345069169998169,
0.19474169611930847,
-0.8101754188537598,
-0.536796510219574,
-0.32292595505714417,
-0.0736304521560669,
0.027472885325551033,
-0.2029111683368683,
-0.5084145069122314,
-0.21567288041114807,
0.25644877552986145,
-0.44519099593162537,
0.4048885703086853,
0.6530309915542603,
-0.3471812605857849,
-0.48320335149765015,
-0.006320342421531677,
0.8074133396148682,
0.6428407430648804,
0.04073326662182808,
0.16756831109523773,
-0.4041469991207123,
-0.6367673277854919,
-0.05632065609097481,
0.32473647594451904,
0.01960637792944908,
0.11481978744268417,
0.6313099265098572,
0.6814961433410645,
0.3623833954334259,
-0.8077474236488342,
0.8698555827140808,
0.015844812616705894,
-0.2187613695859909,
-0.031384631991386414,
-0.08006492257118225,
-0.4169723391532898,
0.5736908912658691,
0.42785587906837463,
0.4027416706085205,
0.39765021204948425,
-0.8830372095108032,
0.37286150455474854,
0.731311023235321,
-0.6688613891601562,
-0.4672183692455292,
0.6410129070281982,
-0.03147545084357262,
0.1658753603696823,
0.15688446164131165,
0.10465948283672333,
-0.09681224077939987,
0.48458927869796753,
0.5714670419692993,
0.40866345167160034,
-0.2492067664861679,
0.4527354836463928,
-0.25087741017341614,
0.45802977681159973,
0.19933761656284332,
0.1322094053030014,
-0.3450011909008026,
-0.592913031578064,
-0.3016728162765503,
-0.19543591141700745,
-0.24468953907489777,
0.03863817825913429,
-0.46257084608078003,
-0.029842181131243706,
-0.4516765773296356,
-0.10422986000776291,
0.12222081422805786,
-0.03480762988328934,
-0.6791814565658569,
0.17395353317260742,
0.13823947310447693,
0.5050961375236511,
-0.9375422596931458,
0.8528562784194946,
0.8389405012130737,
-0.7913070321083069,
-0.8120825886726379,
0.20056919753551483,
0.3294515907764435,
-0.901296854019165,
0.5189210176467896,
0.2691970467567444,
0.03248197212815285,
-0.10981494188308716,
-0.2605908513069153,
-0.9539800882339478,
1.3069504499435425,
0.293781042098999,
-0.10774759203195572,
0.16218094527721405,
0.33932772278785706,
0.48490405082702637,
-0.37055668234825134,
0.2000669240951538,
0.13071247935295105,
0.29807963967323303,
0.11240074783563614,
-1.207604169845581,
0.23012299835681915,
-0.2360803186893463,
-0.14478255808353424,
0.24917660653591156,
-0.9350271821022034,
1.1130834817886353,
-0.12067212164402008,
-0.34267473220825195,
-0.2844846844673157,
0.16835440695285797,
-0.27369868755340576,
0.6334537863731384,
0.3096904456615448,
0.5538060069084167,
0.7295474410057068,
0.13746941089630127,
0.8279651403427124,
-0.016422241926193237,
0.29045742750167847,
0.8419327139854431,
-0.07568302750587463,
0.13925772905349731,
0.5539332628250122,
0.052771564573049545,
0.259628564119339,
0.2957262098789215,
0.14711588621139526,
0.44304782152175903,
-0.37702038884162903,
-0.3082770109176636,
-0.14102715253829956,
-0.2177654504776001,
-0.6666478514671326,
0.6159704923629761,
0.25937825441360474,
-0.40215781331062317,
-0.4398477375507355,
0.8430491089820862,
0.10151182115077972,
-0.2642529010772705,
-0.15347492694854736,
0.6805307269096375,
-0.19006918370723724,
-0.1358579695224762,
0.6295684576034546,
-0.22710265219211578,
0.6532346606254578,
-0.679888904094696,
0.03410479798913002,
-0.6224700808525085,
0.14875800907611847,
-0.37604936957359314,
-0.09208201617002487,
0.20536509156227112,
-0.8386437892913818,
-0.5326040387153625,
0.015054361894726753,
0.6744405627250671,
-0.6041986346244812,
-0.19399388134479523,
0.24069780111312866,
0.7391918897628784,
-0.029129136353731155,
0.11335020512342453,
-0.586239218711853,
0.18404603004455566,
-0.07195114344358444,
0.03307003527879715,
0.729580283164978,
0.7084780335426331,
-0.00025723312865011394,
0.6928818821907043,
0.786994457244873,
-0.09650928527116776,
-0.030661961063742638,
-0.1487267166376114,
0.9186122417449951,
-0.2074822187423706,
-0.28102484345436096,
-0.56239253282547,
0.24274058640003204,
0.14941249787807465,
-0.35883191227912903,
0.7381565570831299,
0.38336101174354553,
0.8922789096832275,
-0.012402079999446869,
0.3321099579334259,
-0.0666201114654541,
0.0020509776659309864,
-0.40191641449928284,
0.7476736307144165,
-1.0835925340652466,
0.23137326538562775,
-0.02345130406320095,
-0.22016002237796783,
-0.5820691585540771,
0.30560240149497986,
-0.006766423583030701,
-0.4030693769454956,
0.8615507483482361,
0.7498100996017456,
-0.3240974545478821,
-0.0012910255463793874,
0.7537218332290649,
0.1882404088973999,
0.09899166226387024,
0.4897679090499878,
0.2839297354221344,
-0.3120390474796295,
0.4300670921802521,
-0.4518427550792694,
-0.48787543177604675,
-0.6745443940162659,
-0.5169367790222168,
-0.8131310939788818,
-0.6060265302658081,
-0.34950995445251465,
-0.13139422237873077,
-0.04414772614836693,
1.0188837051391602,
0.6797997951507568,
-0.4939398467540741,
0.013702042400836945,
0.2529285252094269,
0.09114935249090195,
-0.42837029695510864,
-0.25313422083854675,
0.264514297246933,
-0.38458186388015747,
-0.2809772491455078,
0.5491359233856201,
0.7703071236610413,
0.14278100430965424,
-0.45690134167671204,
0.22028343379497528,
-0.37699782848358154,
-0.254586398601532,
0.6807841658592224,
0.292388916015625,
-0.6260673999786377,
-0.3146398663520813,
-0.12379789352416992,
-0.3750654458999634,
0.33664843440055847,
0.894994854927063,
-0.7166571617126465,
0.9340439438819885,
0.18615710735321045,
0.5733358263969421,
-0.09336497634649277,
-0.3405984044075012,
0.2762810289859772,
-0.7959511876106262,
0.385021448135376,
0.34280332922935486,
0.4575977325439453,
0.17306794226169586,
-0.6981640458106995,
0.5252264142036438,
0.8783149719238281,
-0.38021981716156006,
-0.8423157930374146,
0.4278849959373474,
-0.9759044647216797,
-0.37207338213920593,
0.8083570599555969,
-0.10320721566677094,
0.04924864321947098,
-0.3875306248664856,
0.04111037030816078,
0.02777249924838543,
-0.10977868735790253,
0.8169255256652832,
0.4266209304332733,
-0.3903701603412628,
-0.20657674968242645,
-0.47254398465156555,
0.4256002604961395,
0.5455232858657837,
-0.5962197780609131,
-0.36195018887519836,
0.916480541229248,
0.4264848232269287,
0.11711534857749939,
0.9349308609962463,
-0.18191906809806824,
0.5547943115234375,
-0.15283721685409546,
-0.20322740077972412,
-0.5580439567565918,
-0.3014639914035797,
-0.37739264965057373,
0.427693247795105,
-0.3646874725818634,
-0.005891686305403709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05282v1 | TreeForm: End-to-end Annotation and Evaluation for Form Document Parsing | 2024-02-07T21:54:53 | 2024-02-07T21:54:53 | Ran Zmigrod, Zhiqiang Ma, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Visually Rich Form Understanding (VRFU) poses a complex research problem due
to the documents' highly structured nature and yet highly variable style and
content. Current annotation schemes decompose form understanding and omit key
hierarchical structure, making development and evaluation of end-to-end models
difficult. In this paper, we propose a novel F1 metric to evaluate form parsers
and describe a new content-agnostic, tree-based annotation scheme for VRFU:
TreeForm. We provide methods to convert previous annotation schemes into
TreeForm structures and evaluate TreeForm predictions using a modified version
of the normalized tree-edit distance. We present initial baselines for our
end-to-end performance metric and the TreeForm edit distance, averaged over the
FUNSD and XFUND datasets, of 61.5 and 26.4 respectively. We hope that TreeForm
encourages deeper research in annotating, modeling, and evaluating the
complexities of form-like documents. | [
-0.1468229442834854,
-0.9730672240257263,
0.27893441915512085,
0.22570838034152985,
-0.3285287022590637,
0.3048120439052582,
-0.16859406232833862,
-0.6464082598686218,
-0.0012420739512890577,
-0.06404091417789459,
-0.5985919237136841,
-0.5450573563575745,
-0.48807740211486816,
0.14030836522579193,
-0.32491612434387207,
0.6458766460418701,
-0.28796905279159546,
-0.16259002685546875,
-0.8212569355964661,
-0.06743932515382767,
-0.10108480602502823,
-0.49344152212142944,
-0.473417729139328,
0.1490686982870102,
0.43991416692733765,
0.19025357067584991,
0.8645022511482239,
0.7087327837944031,
0.6078084111213684,
0.2395271360874176,
-0.5383502840995789,
0.050945546478033066,
-0.4925837218761444,
0.3098810315132141,
0.09580275416374207,
-0.45753633975982666,
-0.5433828234672546,
-0.039705485105514526,
0.8204923868179321,
0.6968004703521729,
0.14245975017547607,
0.3247022032737732,
-0.23217429220676422,
0.4819066524505615,
-0.7053393721580505,
0.5191442966461182,
-0.338296115398407,
0.34441688656806946,
-0.40826162695884705,
-0.24364937841892242,
-0.4746028184890747,
-0.09694332629442215,
-0.002170831896364689,
-1.2011547088623047,
0.3386058807373047,
0.0827287957072258,
1.0821490287780762,
0.14586207270622253,
0.12347014993429184,
0.23039740324020386,
-0.49903255701065063,
0.1562058925628662,
-0.3460922837257385,
0.8097953200340271,
0.4782848656177521,
0.8320407867431641,
-0.011170264333486557,
-0.7200774550437927,
-0.595462441444397,
-0.16753804683685303,
-0.21538469195365906,
0.18976545333862305,
-0.43336957693099976,
0.395244300365448,
0.26883092522621155,
0.6216411590576172,
-0.5291731357574463,
0.07026175409555435,
-0.31832411885261536,
-0.28772351145744324,
0.5410584807395935,
-0.10293229669332504,
0.3221455514431,
-0.4713008999824524,
-0.2039729505777359,
-0.32584890723228455,
-0.4181050658226013,
0.7405866384506226,
0.27405086159706116,
0.0723690390586853,
-0.1973632425069809,
0.5118812918663025,
-0.35236606001853943,
0.7318930625915527,
-0.24531497061252594,
-0.014403983019292355,
0.3055640459060669,
-0.2143072932958603,
-0.8765865564346313,
0.025724783539772034,
0.6039102673530579,
0.303254097700119,
0.16383333504199982,
-0.3352251350879669,
-0.19506528973579407,
-0.11193374544382095,
-0.06312669813632965,
-0.8574894666671753,
-0.049464572221040726,
-0.20800352096557617,
-0.5346519947052002,
-0.5529871582984924,
0.21936644613742828,
-0.4133082926273346,
-0.34532323479652405,
-0.2726500928401947,
0.3031080663204193,
-0.4603978395462036,
-0.24805636703968048,
0.028096185997128487,
-0.27590081095695496,
0.2687278985977173,
1.0586012601852417,
-0.5436040759086609,
0.4919632375240326,
0.786853551864624,
1.0015404224395752,
0.06153182312846184,
-0.20335817337036133,
-0.8929780125617981,
0.005627835169434547,
-0.24769854545593262,
1.0817844867706299,
-0.8195582032203674,
-0.4526306688785553,
-0.3879935145378113,
0.06898777186870575,
0.010815833695232868,
-0.3227446973323822,
0.8066161870956421,
-0.12172780185937881,
0.4423757791519165,
-0.0019976391922682524,
-0.24996238946914673,
-0.6081534624099731,
0.18104670941829681,
-0.8284581899642944,
1.267790675163269,
0.9081447720527649,
-0.6062076687812805,
0.7543222308158875,
-0.5994628667831421,
-0.4414021074771881,
0.41427740454673767,
-0.3106061518192291,
-0.5199341773986816,
0.38310158252716064,
0.08624107390642166,
0.4244881570339203,
-0.2451542764902115,
0.2989323139190674,
-0.5314911603927612,
-0.3123800456523895,
-0.11274807900190353,
-0.6297383904457092,
0.5436240434646606,
0.09046260267496109,
-0.31484371423721313,
0.6729740500450134,
-0.9532483816146851,
-0.06300538033246994,
-0.07383961975574493,
-0.14902913570404053,
-0.33541080355644226,
-0.3133810758590698,
0.403359979391098,
0.21486349403858185,
-0.14615346491336823,
-0.5992115139961243,
0.2898661196231842,
-0.2889036238193512,
0.5729005932807922,
0.60679030418396,
-0.20330743491649628,
0.07389018684625626,
-0.1879284381866455,
0.836585283279419,
-0.15819759666919708,
0.37317848205566406,
-0.40824511647224426,
-0.476055383682251,
-0.36916518211364746,
-0.4380439519882202,
0.1681416779756546,
0.13013362884521484,
-0.045153819024562836,
0.1667708158493042,
-0.38972151279449463,
-0.5840890407562256,
-0.5365642309188843,
-0.007781003601849079,
0.2599990665912628,
0.6567211151123047,
0.1915472447872162,
-0.3257826268672943,
-0.47812846302986145,
-0.8005965352058411,
0.08220931887626648,
-0.46074914932250977,
0.29352831840515137,
0.23462536931037903,
0.19388610124588013,
-0.2210373729467392,
1.0226136445999146,
-0.21432141959667206,
-0.3207244575023651,
0.051674213260412216,
0.04021775349974632,
-0.2736891806125641,
0.23512326180934906,
0.7627943158149719,
-0.6962810754776001,
-0.2392803281545639,
0.2228083312511444,
-0.3330397307872772,
-0.13348866999149323,
-0.15218216180801392,
-0.19095000624656677,
0.032734181731939316,
0.38165703415870667,
-0.7273886799812317,
0.7738131880760193,
0.25888851284980774,
-0.8489178419113159,
0.5019739866256714,
-0.035178668797016144,
0.26665833592414856,
-0.44586697220802307,
0.30062729120254517,
0.05284562334418297,
-0.5161288380622864,
-0.05289240553975105,
-0.062164463102817535,
0.105071522295475,
-0.040287215262651443,
-0.3458070158958435,
0.4818963408470154,
-0.46151646971702576,
-0.2755194306373596,
0.23578493297100067,
-0.06837841868400574,
0.4646850824356079,
0.20546388626098633,
0.08258814364671707,
0.7226232886314392,
0.44072431325912476,
0.16951780021190643,
0.13054589927196503,
0.22686520218849182,
-0.17422078549861908,
0.5528733730316162,
-0.5218103528022766,
-0.22625970840454102,
-0.45354536175727844,
0.31600233912467957,
-1.372196078300476,
-0.14076381921768188,
0.0435270220041275,
-0.5839329957962036,
0.20274528861045837,
0.1215231716632843,
-0.4586055278778076,
-0.12147436290979385,
-0.6873906254768372,
0.4249417781829834,
0.16007184982299805,
-0.33130690455436707,
0.5550938844680786,
-0.046188145875930786,
-0.0896521657705307,
-0.14583562314510345,
-0.4211689531803131,
0.07787556946277618,
-0.07200194150209427,
-1.0112093687057495,
0.6434555649757385,
0.014078902080655098,
-0.1300649493932724,
0.10556167364120483,
-0.398110955953598,
-0.1692960262298584,
0.4818583130836487,
0.7303986549377441,
-0.15679116547107697,
-0.6499739289283752,
0.009242196567356586,
0.4315468370914459,
0.007992769591510296,
0.11996021866798401,
0.17745277285575867,
0.024663880467414856,
-0.26178988814353943,
-0.2568945586681366,
-0.36868804693222046,
0.17684748768806458,
0.8305176496505737,
-0.6106114387512207,
0.28055381774902344,
0.48632004857063293,
-0.8170311450958252,
-0.10781697183847427,
-0.33128058910369873,
0.37863224744796753,
-0.3352462351322174,
0.24675409495830536,
-0.7332226634025574,
-1.0394822359085083,
0.26250937581062317,
-0.008732428774237633,
0.24534834921360016,
0.8672952651977539,
0.16772262752056122,
0.007540943566709757,
0.676520824432373,
0.8163978457450867,
0.5211834907531738,
0.4583970904350281,
-0.3317910432815552,
-0.09138043969869614,
-0.5765335559844971,
-0.7618095874786377,
-0.5629865527153015,
-0.21853314340114594,
0.088063083589077,
-0.6306270956993103,
-0.003592451335862279,
0.878649890422821,
-0.009499273262917995,
0.24242891371250153,
-0.48661932349205017,
0.1993444859981537,
0.3250889182090759,
-0.272553414106369,
0.5067554116249084,
0.20304042100906372,
-0.13919515907764435,
-0.006042968947440386,
-0.39969825744628906,
-0.5342966914176941,
0.7214718461036682,
0.6994402408599854,
0.34555232524871826,
0.1288699209690094,
0.44396737217903137,
0.4093000888824463,
0.7343348264694214,
-0.8288082480430603,
0.09022200852632523,
-0.022674163803458214,
-0.03984125331044197,
-0.5947270393371582,
-0.07517796009778976,
-0.5973166227340698,
0.28778940439224243,
-0.22969673573970795,
-0.6938018202781677,
0.09485597163438797,
-0.05798228457570076,
-0.49583879113197327,
0.050169214606285095,
-0.8503735065460205,
1.2925747632980347,
-0.2888617217540741,
-0.2390829175710678,
0.12283280491828918,
-0.3916684091091156,
0.2845692038536072,
0.10322055220603943,
0.3493700921535492,
-0.20045413076877594,
0.014970684424042702,
0.872353196144104,
-0.5876088738441467,
0.4921393394470215,
-0.26267650723457336,
-0.041840896010398865,
0.256185382604599,
0.18795186281204224,
-0.0268536563962698,
0.38374146819114685,
-0.10496014356613159,
-0.014343969523906708,
0.2980835735797882,
-0.024802932515740395,
-0.8964976072311401,
0.3251969814300537,
-0.6900899410247803,
-0.3553067445755005,
-0.4032539129257202,
-0.20836418867111206,
-0.0756574347615242,
0.2672809362411499,
-0.04483296349644661,
0.2765018939971924,
-0.4321196675300598,
0.41775885224342346,
0.2534432113170624,
0.06641845405101776,
0.4029829502105713,
0.27475258708000183,
-0.4052571654319763,
-0.6185793876647949,
0.48680874705314636,
-0.07559160888195038,
-0.04554510489106178,
0.7084423303604126,
0.354240357875824,
-0.6085251569747925,
-0.4456987679004669,
-0.821820855140686,
-0.11322665214538574,
-0.6195337176322937,
-0.5127412676811218,
-0.8011953234672546,
-0.23488976061344147,
-0.4874625504016876,
-0.2545958459377289,
-0.04020579531788826,
-0.7625558376312256,
-0.2637680172920227,
-0.5829315781593323,
0.6756529808044434,
0.706028938293457,
0.04180344194173813,
0.4535983204841614,
-0.4253038465976715,
0.3960876762866974,
-0.11371170729398727,
0.8741162419319153,
0.0107313496991992,
-0.3418164551258087,
0.09468214958906174,
-0.2732062041759491,
-0.3105100393295288,
-0.8228310942649841,
-0.15822844207286835,
0.5628406405448914,
0.7851573824882507,
0.4274778962135315,
-0.3803919553756714,
1.0389556884765625,
-0.255941778421402,
0.6271910667419434,
0.3298531174659729,
-0.9511641263961792,
0.7226830124855042,
-0.04400372877717018,
-0.035322677344083786,
0.739850640296936,
0.09999015182256699,
-0.5522637367248535,
-0.09152520447969437,
-0.761239230632782,
-0.6327203512191772,
0.5831477046012878,
0.26643556356430054,
-0.2659062147140503,
0.32133662700653076,
0.33773526549339294,
0.505429744720459,
0.005318706389516592,
-0.6393768191337585,
0.07412932068109512,
-0.49967798590660095,
-0.1401681751012802,
-0.009163912385702133,
-0.13251543045043945,
0.24957674741744995,
-0.7200036644935608,
0.3035815954208374,
-0.09316331893205643,
-0.07949226349592209,
0.4212080240249634,
-0.2510747015476227,
-0.5675119161605835,
0.16550420224666595,
0.6174290180206299,
0.702555775642395,
-0.3478756248950958,
0.1591450572013855,
-0.2327095866203308,
-0.6066110134124756,
0.15833668410778046,
0.5871766209602356,
-0.2994057536125183,
0.27079394459724426,
0.7054626941680908,
0.9623953104019165,
0.17164430022239685,
-0.6535494923591614,
0.786257803440094,
-0.2519459128379822,
-0.3492744266986847,
-0.07916576415300369,
0.11718636751174927,
-0.13317428529262543,
-0.2351856678724289,
0.16101126372814178,
0.05764148756861687,
0.218040332198143,
-0.40412092208862305,
0.36280837655067444,
0.2863675355911255,
-0.7882164120674133,
-0.43243318796157837,
0.8312325477600098,
0.32793840765953064,
-0.3890500068664551,
0.10656102746725082,
-0.17721150815486908,
-0.2740701138973236,
0.5082656145095825,
0.3571779429912567,
1.170257806777954,
-0.1685778796672821,
0.5535359978675842,
0.2207503318786621,
0.3057895600795746,
0.4176677465438843,
0.28735533356666565,
-0.7023602724075317,
0.10835075378417969,
-0.56670743227005,
-1.166619062423706,
-0.14517302811145782,
0.31200453639030457,
-0.3475162386894226,
0.5002288222312927,
-0.6956631541252136,
0.1956130564212799,
0.3039746582508087,
0.055381957441568375,
-0.6610721349716187,
0.6369847655296326,
0.19943194091320038,
1.2706830501556396,
-0.6963268518447876,
0.38305607438087463,
0.9947286248207092,
-0.5865727066993713,
-0.7601879835128784,
-0.27590084075927734,
-0.017694780603051186,
-0.5677705407142639,
0.7250059843063354,
0.5951145887374878,
-0.13062012195587158,
-0.32287880778312683,
0.023725833743810654,
-0.6357361078262329,
1.1817641258239746,
0.4440833628177643,
-0.5762888193130493,
-0.43085217475891113,
0.2680731415748596,
0.5292818546295166,
-0.29837915301322937,
0.8122894167900085,
0.37267494201660156,
0.5293440222740173,
0.011816613376140594,
-0.9181683659553528,
0.1892649382352829,
-0.6684151291847229,
0.08486825972795486,
0.08985934406518936,
-0.4627738296985626,
0.4730243384838104,
-0.008586754091084003,
-0.43728458881378174,
-0.14293663203716278,
0.8350138068199158,
0.05759834870696068,
0.4025137722492218,
0.7084018588066101,
0.7464790940284729,
0.6411342024803162,
-0.03737376630306244,
0.7467272877693176,
-0.096359483897686,
0.2845621705055237,
0.8318583369255066,
0.0745762437582016,
0.6475940346717834,
0.3833731412887573,
-0.17860761284828186,
0.3821530342102051,
0.7409506440162659,
0.20342719554901123,
0.16032855212688446,
0.6105806231498718,
0.00021643498621415347,
-0.21928644180297852,
-0.15568767488002777,
-0.44378790259361267,
0.5039549469947815,
0.29300734400749207,
-0.4196318984031677,
-0.7075065970420837,
-0.05754268914461136,
0.13925579190254211,
0.3649795949459076,
-0.03976023569703102,
0.6926125884056091,
-0.05350745469331741,
-0.40364667773246765,
0.4683750867843628,
0.25392547249794006,
0.38540521264076233,
-0.5484912991523743,
-0.393428772687912,
-0.08698396384716034,
-0.3299528658390045,
-0.49452751874923706,
-0.9866068363189697,
0.3356580436229706,
0.15391817688941956,
-0.25009217858314514,
-0.39918845891952515,
0.5881777405738831,
-0.07625450193881989,
-0.6004499197006226,
0.2886327803134918,
0.3762684762477875,
-0.0805157870054245,
-0.4153170585632324,
-0.560909628868103,
0.36923548579216003,
-0.20966969430446625,
-0.32564109563827515,
-0.17972852289676666,
0.8360329270362854,
-0.5459303855895996,
0.2705603539943695,
0.7636077404022217,
-0.039195332676172256,
-0.00003693768667289987,
0.3987531363964081,
0.7580358982086182,
-0.6033046841621399,
-0.7879323363304138,
-0.8022673726081848,
0.5821256041526794,
-0.07990405708551407,
-0.771727979183197,
0.35053491592407227,
1.0461089611053467,
1.035376787185669,
0.28720736503601074,
0.8089385032653809,
-0.1574709564447403,
0.09228985011577606,
-0.23089586198329926,
0.8026015758514404,
-0.7386742234230042,
-0.2202776074409485,
-0.662452220916748,
-1.1049935817718506,
-0.47617578506469727,
0.5818881988525391,
-0.1605851948261261,
-0.15338106453418732,
0.46085336804389954,
0.33389386534690857,
-0.31833770871162415,
0.24350053071975708,
0.332882285118103,
-0.006876219995319843,
0.709909975528717,
0.5326427817344666,
0.661708414554596,
-0.14988774061203003,
0.4206995964050293,
-0.5139153003692627,
-0.5732635259628296,
-0.16532835364341736,
-0.9451878666877747,
-0.708601176738739,
-0.6974749565124512,
-0.32745635509490967,
-0.016789142042398453,
0.029248790815472603,
0.4821280837059021,
0.7627618312835693,
-0.4427013695240021,
0.007596309762448072,
-0.33269593119621277,
-0.14575710892677307,
-0.14247319102287292,
-0.3073100447654724,
0.645875871181488,
-0.03791043907403946,
-0.08452687412500381,
-0.010044287890195847,
0.7074300050735474,
0.1823713332414627,
-0.31560784578323364,
-0.10042495280504227,
0.1899644285440445,
-0.44089293479919434,
0.930490255355835,
0.13182826340198517,
-1.013890266418457,
-0.27400678396224976,
0.11820077896118164,
0.022312453016638756,
0.36843156814575195,
0.6111029982566833,
-0.9554073810577393,
0.6064770817756653,
0.578303337097168,
0.8214970827102661,
0.42017224431037903,
0.2972935736179352,
0.364665687084198,
-0.3955487906932831,
-0.013764816336333752,
0.2515936493873596,
0.3555346727371216,
0.48123183846473694,
-0.6570634841918945,
0.46087655425071716,
0.5267547965049744,
0.17427121102809906,
-0.9042250514030457,
-0.09959354996681213,
-1.3865065574645996,
-0.015446913428604603,
0.7626748085021973,
-0.21745583415031433,
-0.476589173078537,
0.442202627658844,
-0.7251178622245789,
0.31552696228027344,
-0.3568517863750458,
0.35239166021347046,
0.6351675987243652,
-0.3506036698818207,
-0.5342399477958679,
-0.43279579281806946,
0.7392022609710693,
0.3583759069442749,
-1.2168545722961426,
0.31096479296684265,
0.6469407081604004,
0.01369036827236414,
0.13976486027240753,
0.7442200183868408,
-0.19795849919319153,
0.6706965565681458,
-0.11776648461818695,
-0.21018560230731964,
-0.6656025052070618,
-0.5173524022102356,
-0.19072167575359344,
0.3027482330799103,
0.17147313058376312,
0.05150291696190834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07938v2 | Large Language User Interfaces: Voice Interactive User Interfaces powered by LLMs | 2024-02-07T21:08:49 | 2024-04-16T07:39:05 | Syed Mekael Wasti, Ken Q. Pu, Ali Neshati | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.1 | The evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) has showcased remarkable
capacities for logical reasoning and natural language comprehension. These
capabilities can be leveraged in solutions that semantically and textually
model complex problems. In this paper, we present our efforts toward
constructing a framework that can serve as an intermediary between a user and
their user interface (UI), enabling dynamic and real-time interactions. We
employ a system that stands upon textual semantic mappings of UI components, in
the form of annotations. These mappings are stored, parsed, and scaled in a
custom data structure, supplementary to an agent-based prompting backend
engine. Employing textual semantic mappings allows each component to not only
explain its role to the engine but also provide expectations. By comprehending
the needs of both the user and the components, our LLM engine can classify the
most appropriate application, extract relevant parameters, and subsequently
execute precise predictions of the user's expected actions. Such an integration
evolves static user interfaces into highly dynamic and adaptable solutions,
introducing a new frontier of intelligent and responsive user experiences. | [
-0.5375582575798035,
-0.9968313574790955,
0.9334620237350464,
0.4384540021419525,
0.1754085272550583,
0.42590469121932983,
-0.4274694621562958,
-0.6294434070587158,
0.3981848657131195,
0.5683100819587708,
-0.8275468349456787,
-0.3914376199245453,
-0.08123643696308136,
-0.03245745971798897,
-0.41309475898742676,
0.4257596731185913,
0.08324010670185089,
-0.298662394285202,
-0.36240169405937195,
-0.04449428245425224,
-0.36532455682754517,
-0.5724650025367737,
-0.5927769541740417,
-0.5201064348220825,
0.7786620259284973,
0.519589364528656,
1.0270811319351196,
0.3576727509498596,
-0.0049340673722326756,
0.4314327836036682,
0.11052893102169037,
0.20295748114585876,
-0.29303163290023804,
0.6715660095214844,
-0.27911582589149475,
-0.5023444890975952,
-0.478059858083725,
-0.13320204615592957,
0.5392195582389832,
0.5239400863647461,
-0.16220851242542267,
0.07365796715021133,
-0.15692436695098877,
0.17189019918441772,
-0.22430790960788727,
0.17275188863277435,
-0.5551732182502747,
-0.008440823294222355,
-0.003892237553372979,
-0.4765344262123108,
-0.36039841175079346,
-0.05578360706567764,
0.0750940591096878,
-0.9747875928878784,
-0.4884454011917114,
0.10830312967300415,
0.726063072681427,
0.4585191011428833,
-0.333016574382782,
-0.3394165337085724,
-0.812249481678009,
0.7297114729881287,
-0.7537472248077393,
0.3420584499835968,
0.04534195363521576,
0.5543113946914673,
-0.4953053295612335,
-0.8629191517829895,
-1.0160707235336304,
-0.5597975254058838,
0.027107251808047295,
-0.01820528879761696,
0.03491862863302231,
0.12632301449775696,
0.33168092370033264,
0.014183631166815758,
-0.24334262311458588,
0.6262168288230896,
0.2775719463825226,
-0.09742026776075363,
0.5873282551765442,
0.48022541403770447,
0.82459557056427,
0.1277584731578827,
-0.2737448513507843,
0.13475629687309265,
-0.7855305671691895,
-0.16076187789440155,
0.4293668270111084,
0.4951161742210388,
-0.35518354177474976,
0.6574780941009521,
-0.2873382568359375,
0.7860371470451355,
-0.054559651762247086,
-0.15936201810836792,
0.0734788253903389,
-0.05636896938085556,
-0.17799954116344452,
0.12277048826217651,
0.8350221514701843,
0.08002687245607376,
0.5176563858985901,
-0.10935547202825546,
-0.16617892682552338,
-0.22445981204509735,
0.12817271053791046,
-0.7375760078430176,
0.21106694638729095,
0.4095863401889801,
-0.31990402936935425,
-0.25611990690231323,
-0.13055405020713806,
-0.6144059896469116,
-0.6744307279586792,
-0.8117390275001526,
0.31433331966400146,
-0.11466182768344879,
-0.4371423125267029,
0.009730854071676731,
0.17490024864673615,
0.20651957392692566,
0.6917208433151245,
-1.0092864036560059,
0.3008277714252472,
0.7431909441947937,
0.6554059386253357,
-0.10855812579393387,
-0.22089353203773499,
-0.7470827102661133,
0.3983513116836548,
0.0762147530913353,
0.6138601303100586,
-0.7709597945213318,
-0.42810890078544617,
0.18501238524913788,
0.009649476036429405,
0.06361877918243408,
-0.5577179193496704,
0.26748308539390564,
-0.5709364414215088,
0.21382883191108704,
-0.10075025260448456,
-0.5091103315353394,
-0.17424677312374115,
0.12248467653989792,
-0.5573591589927673,
0.9072604775428772,
0.04509979486465454,
-0.4435510039329529,
-0.09361178427934647,
-0.9201931357383728,
-0.4150438606739044,
0.4182527959346771,
-0.32168588042259216,
0.04871131852269173,
-0.018962183967232704,
0.038597095757722855,
0.6059737205505371,
-0.3925721347332001,
0.3029116690158844,
-0.42100855708122253,
-0.36342453956604004,
0.5170410871505737,
-0.3531840443611145,
0.6594003438949585,
0.29649773240089417,
-0.3731106221675873,
0.4184091091156006,
-0.8885398507118225,
0.18025796115398407,
-0.003026107093319297,
-0.5048829913139343,
-0.13841819763183594,
0.4023902416229248,
0.38011354207992554,
0.3349374532699585,
0.48363906145095825,
-0.4557499885559082,
0.237308531999588,
-0.2996033728122711,
0.59959477186203,
0.43403640389442444,
-0.1329251527786255,
0.27701669931411743,
0.03641709312796593,
0.5543771982192993,
-0.17379307746887207,
-0.13770954310894012,
-0.38436150550842285,
-0.3143514096736908,
-0.6998483538627625,
-0.34615209698677063,
0.09770126640796661,
0.822184145450592,
-0.8093221783638,
0.545159637928009,
-0.4315595328807831,
-0.34863635897636414,
-0.345258504152298,
0.1138613373041153,
0.03378669172525406,
0.4424913227558136,
0.15075743198394775,
0.17677120864391327,
-0.24107661843299866,
-0.7977241277694702,
-0.15212228894233704,
-0.5819921493530273,
-0.5265839099884033,
0.4112660586833954,
0.030193503946065903,
-0.5825536251068115,
1.2433176040649414,
-0.1706361621618271,
-0.10265634953975677,
-0.32244616746902466,
0.20726002752780914,
0.003788629313930869,
0.2945958077907562,
0.4219702482223511,
-0.883741021156311,
-0.4051627516746521,
0.3989788293838501,
-0.9239807724952698,
-0.7484055757522583,
-0.3853198289871216,
-0.07478494942188263,
0.13511450588703156,
0.6762153506278992,
-0.6016333699226379,
0.16848473250865936,
0.5281331539154053,
-0.26779696345329285,
0.36574408411979675,
-0.15884432196617126,
0.05523558333516121,
-1.0838974714279175,
0.05227893590927124,
-0.09437538683414459,
-0.41436877846717834,
-0.6174608469009399,
-0.04679535701870918,
-0.16344334185123444,
-0.29079562425613403,
-0.48895928263664246,
0.9464929103851318,
-0.3975103199481964,
-0.21612098813056946,
-0.3510095775127411,
0.4877721965312958,
0.014612795785069466,
0.3931019902229309,
0.06606739014387131,
0.9248091578483582,
0.17323437333106995,
-0.35567134618759155,
0.7800394892692566,
0.18528388440608978,
-0.20042096078395844,
0.7525736093521118,
-0.7789992690086365,
-0.03360350802540779,
0.15396708250045776,
0.10601186007261276,
-0.8845464587211609,
-0.5544241070747375,
0.010750367306172848,
-0.31430327892303467,
0.14580188691616058,
0.08228784054517746,
-0.870334804058075,
-0.11240158975124359,
-0.004752051085233688,
-0.03528548777103424,
0.2502935230731964,
-0.5992411971092224,
1.1548081636428833,
0.4167459011077881,
-0.613787829875946,
-0.09965874254703522,
-0.6274989247322083,
0.5410832762718201,
-0.15840573608875275,
-0.8265992403030396,
0.12221074849367142,
-0.02908896654844284,
-0.45312756299972534,
-0.006122534163296223,
0.451374351978302,
-0.06373273581266403,
0.26240381598472595,
0.5217474699020386,
0.20934772491455078,
-0.24312472343444824,
0.335875540971756,
0.3205731511116028,
-0.17451579868793488,
0.032851532101631165,
-0.16830047965049744,
0.38378068804740906,
-0.05064483731985092,
-0.5945196747779846,
-0.7484381794929504,
0.6171950101852417,
1.030491590499878,
-0.30167585611343384,
0.5231010913848877,
0.5692718625068665,
-0.3479023575782776,
-0.029932893812656403,
-0.7017382979393005,
0.08772949129343033,
-0.5235725045204163,
0.3941652476787567,
-0.6075423955917358,
-1.119984745979309,
0.7588744759559631,
-0.3979496955871582,
0.2543303370475769,
0.11486286669969559,
0.9372668266296387,
-0.1578947752714157,
1.0704015493392944,
0.5136124491691589,
0.03607174754142761,
0.590788722038269,
0.35639989376068115,
0.18855400383472443,
-0.7095596194267273,
-0.3235703110694885,
-0.45605742931365967,
-0.3721263110637665,
-0.46168920397758484,
-0.1713283658027649,
0.4554421007633209,
-0.2872021496295929,
-0.30070996284484863,
0.0026300428435206413,
-0.18643490970134735,
0.09474366158246994,
0.4690605401992798,
-0.25404006242752075,
0.1653679609298706,
-0.03462619334459305,
-0.08615785092115402,
-0.13509881496429443,
-0.4183553457260132,
-0.766913890838623,
0.3054126799106598,
0.5992722511291504,
1.2075510025024414,
0.383280873298645,
0.22439830005168915,
0.25908926129341125,
0.3052217662334442,
-0.9438059329986572,
0.838218629360199,
0.17093251645565033,
-0.403430700302124,
-0.48269468545913696,
-0.27990955114364624,
-0.7600932121276855,
0.31790587306022644,
-0.5957010984420776,
-1.001585841178894,
0.0594446063041687,
0.07385263592004776,
-0.3896045982837677,
0.09900013357400894,
-1.0033818483352661,
0.5537670850753784,
-0.5066680312156677,
-0.6686988472938538,
-0.1606956273317337,
-0.6255738735198975,
0.009321622550487518,
-0.04906410723924637,
0.13781364262104034,
-0.30555403232574463,
-0.2907244861125946,
0.374733567237854,
-0.43144574761390686,
0.9837448000907898,
-0.3654627799987793,
-0.32808902859687805,
0.22102589905261993,
0.09083102643489838,
0.42684710025787354,
0.07517356425523758,
-0.32043445110321045,
-0.13239994645118713,
0.0622553825378418,
-0.08933088928461075,
-0.9617221355438232,
0.9775570631027222,
-0.5815420150756836,
-0.6356895565986633,
-0.12951819598674774,
-0.5538093447685242,
-0.45816853642463684,
0.2645880877971649,
-0.5130723714828491,
0.6120951771736145,
-0.16159529983997345,
0.20749767124652863,
0.7207547426223755,
-0.5693352222442627,
0.42345622181892395,
0.7233195304870605,
-0.5473214387893677,
-0.04370300471782684,
0.7729493379592896,
0.05092078074812889,
0.2251688688993454,
0.6066818833351135,
0.171239972114563,
-0.4851640462875366,
-0.2301706075668335,
-0.6460342407226562,
0.2252006083726883,
-0.47674015164375305,
0.08634518086910248,
-0.6166359186172485,
-0.16756846010684967,
-0.08606637269258499,
-0.33352214097976685,
-0.073356032371521,
-0.2669864892959595,
-0.5586109757423401,
0.06875673681497574,
0.33245477080345154,
0.782281756401062,
0.34883713722229004,
0.5397236347198486,
-0.8243708610534668,
0.24382135272026062,
0.46186399459838867,
0.30264025926589966,
0.051384199410676956,
-0.15372700989246368,
-0.2899964451789856,
-0.11834054440259933,
-0.009958603419363499,
-0.6357280015945435,
0.19712083041667938,
0.1298811137676239,
0.7282474040985107,
0.3404969573020935,
0.018754174932837486,
0.5193615555763245,
-0.6879099011421204,
0.9429384469985962,
0.10538285970687866,
-0.9172034859657288,
0.33824530243873596,
-0.5268848538398743,
0.5927241444587708,
0.4136226177215576,
0.0873851403594017,
-0.7159467935562134,
-0.3509649932384491,
-0.23947031795978546,
-0.8280476927757263,
0.5086745619773865,
-0.19043906033039093,
0.27716344594955444,
0.2346646934747696,
0.500153660774231,
-0.06612681597471237,
0.18953560292720795,
-0.3672717213630676,
0.046776849776506424,
0.03791259601712227,
-0.6515260338783264,
0.19048292934894562,
-0.2833849787712097,
0.004287002142518759,
-0.0681493952870369,
0.5704962611198425,
-0.46074509620666504,
0.11658870428800583,
-0.03967364504933357,
-0.1250486671924591,
-0.008024833165109158,
0.38054323196411133,
0.6515692472457886,
0.7653071284294128,
0.1638239026069641,
0.11829040199518204,
0.04843025654554367,
-0.3151096701622009,
0.1449127495288849,
0.2082221508026123,
0.05133362114429474,
-0.15399067103862762,
0.388456255197525,
0.935746967792511,
0.478290319442749,
-1.1549652814865112,
0.3509483337402344,
-0.28259170055389404,
0.08408689498901367,
-0.5227461457252502,
0.2651757299900055,
0.5081568360328674,
0.41338565945625305,
0.3753022253513336,
-0.6108495593070984,
0.0028943659272044897,
-0.5248004198074341,
-0.0421065054833889,
0.4102979004383087,
-0.3552319407463074,
-0.28865012526512146,
0.8855938911437988,
0.6090654730796814,
-0.6445459127426147,
0.2875225245952606,
0.3156459331512451,
-0.3994106650352478,
0.20203323662281036,
0.3490498661994934,
0.8644048571586609,
-0.32020312547683716,
-0.032770127058029175,
-0.15508729219436646,
0.08206811547279358,
0.3149077594280243,
0.23496347665786743,
-0.1943405419588089,
-0.39084765315055847,
-0.6292658448219299,
-0.5503326654434204,
-0.5660365223884583,
0.040034420788288116,
-0.28737911581993103,
0.2885989248752594,
-0.3864673972129822,
-0.15117283165454865,
0.12377926707267761,
-0.06243731454014778,
-0.4346558153629303,
0.2684723734855652,
0.1932641863822937,
1.068732500076294,
-0.5483026504516602,
0.7866531610488892,
0.8011658787727356,
-0.1843748539686203,
-0.6748028993606567,
-0.043085768818855286,
0.1140829399228096,
-0.7285178899765015,
0.7449840903282166,
-0.10880468040704727,
-0.5121093392372131,
0.010131347924470901,
-0.4477388858795166,
-0.5079863667488098,
0.9183803200721741,
0.5941232442855835,
-0.7074522376060486,
0.07835491746664047,
0.23857757449150085,
0.6482075452804565,
-0.4483146667480469,
0.35971954464912415,
0.32391759753227234,
0.5996960997581482,
0.07675047963857651,
-0.8688479065895081,
0.05596942827105522,
-0.2825329005718231,
0.20074690878391266,
0.05944477394223213,
-0.5446760058403015,
0.37342020869255066,
0.16960185766220093,
-0.17007260024547577,
0.16398338973522186,
0.7657119631767273,
-0.033239468932151794,
0.20401932299137115,
0.7049581408500671,
0.2537856698036194,
0.6369865536689758,
-0.09594040364027023,
0.8539440631866455,
-0.19548583030700684,
-0.1479973942041397,
1.1516704559326172,
-0.6895496845245361,
1.0438004732131958,
0.6586354374885559,
-0.09476061910390854,
0.7358559966087341,
0.5233519077301025,
0.531502902507782,
0.1285499483346939,
0.3757457435131073,
-0.745776355266571,
-0.31927716732025146,
-0.311736136674881,
-0.1762765347957611,
0.33483463525772095,
0.8078321218490601,
0.02623441442847252,
-0.1018257662653923,
0.16845908761024475,
0.061964187771081924,
0.38787177205085754,
0.01130063459277153,
0.9430832862854004,
0.07992643862962723,
-0.4819609522819519,
0.20737677812576294,
-0.08486958593130112,
0.5092957019805908,
-0.7509915828704834,
-0.16772648692131042,
0.17945431172847748,
-0.15090931951999664,
-0.3066967725753784,
-0.9692578911781311,
0.09699348360300064,
-0.09551020711660385,
-0.22766989469528198,
-0.41369855403900146,
0.800658643245697,
-0.5046889185905457,
-0.28669291734695435,
0.41028890013694763,
0.48869600892066956,
0.07363923639059067,
0.17931583523750305,
-0.5883365273475647,
0.592688798904419,
-0.24215379357337952,
-0.5266469120979309,
0.2447885125875473,
0.7082092761993408,
-0.1972888857126236,
1.004734992980957,
0.5949311852455139,
0.007571945898234844,
0.07941410690546036,
0.28598248958587646,
0.8357632756233215,
-0.493228554725647,
-0.7054964303970337,
-0.5813456177711487,
0.5926313996315002,
-0.27718955278396606,
0.07850100845098495,
0.48893606662750244,
0.41091427206993103,
0.2744836211204529,
0.24477575719356537,
0.9976620674133301,
-0.0014574750093743205,
0.7067158818244934,
-0.49664539098739624,
0.781633198261261,
-0.6773491501808167,
0.3952450752258301,
0.009887983091175556,
-0.7512612342834473,
-0.26905813813209534,
0.4220747947692871,
-0.11311881989240646,
0.00047244661254808307,
0.19420742988586426,
0.6906366944313049,
-0.14586471021175385,
-0.013462258502840996,
0.40431249141693115,
0.31545573472976685,
0.732305645942688,
0.22052988409996033,
0.9287763833999634,
0.31180697679519653,
0.10907454043626785,
0.3842330574989319,
-0.4268302321434021,
-0.4957953989505768,
-0.98701012134552,
-0.7809051871299744,
-0.6923593878746033,
-0.05176832899451256,
-0.1721436083316803,
0.009876685217022896,
1.1024377346038818,
0.7502084970474243,
-0.46384021639823914,
-0.38916435837745667,
0.224970281124115,
0.08778141438961029,
0.26536548137664795,
-0.24621805548667908,
-0.11464707553386688,
-0.40520456433296204,
-0.9759253263473511,
0.5639839172363281,
0.6323188543319702,
0.10325052589178085,
-0.8066672086715698,
-0.16229498386383057,
-0.06626839190721512,
0.25088047981262207,
0.8791655898094177,
0.5596598982810974,
-0.9601302146911621,
-0.5145375728607178,
-0.16441284120082855,
-0.15994364023208618,
-0.290650874376297,
0.7681536078453064,
-0.9859641194343567,
0.5975276231765747,
0.42213791608810425,
1.1404657363891602,
0.3507576286792755,
-0.11703866720199585,
0.7455505728721619,
-0.4958479702472687,
0.3223901391029358,
0.020614488050341606,
0.09487079828977585,
0.42016640305519104,
-0.46667376160621643,
0.25666379928588867,
-0.1356275975704193,
-0.4116106331348419,
-0.6981112957000732,
0.42135679721832275,
-1.227832555770874,
-0.13493956625461578,
1.1517213582992554,
-0.10557355731725693,
-0.25434890389442444,
-0.31368449330329895,
-0.4983764886856079,
0.029720861464738846,
-0.4023666977882385,
0.4213600158691406,
0.7382200956344604,
-0.2903335690498352,
-0.09541554003953934,
-0.752588152885437,
0.16071999073028564,
0.2397102564573288,
-1.1899148225784302,
0.1869601160287857,
0.6118173003196716,
0.040974102914333344,
0.1315324753522873,
0.6090852618217468,
0.01852787844836712,
-0.049790963530540466,
-0.35285961627960205,
-0.018492277711629868,
-0.15165391564369202,
-0.1485758125782013,
-0.16491641104221344,
0.046079475432634354,
0.1590876430273056,
-0.009600909426808357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10940v1 | Neural machine translation of clinical procedure codes for medical diagnosis and uncertainty quantification | 2024-02-07T20:11:56 | 2024-02-07T20:11:56 | Pei-Hung Chung, Shuhan He, Norawit Kijpaisalratana, Abdel-badih el Ariss, Byung-Jun Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) is designed to enhance clinician
decision-making by combining system-generated recommendations with medical
expertise. Given the high costs, intensive labor, and time-sensitive nature of
medical treatments, there is a pressing need for efficient decision support,
especially in complex emergency scenarios. In these scenarios, where
information can be limited, an advanced CDSS framework that leverages AI
(artificial intelligence) models to effectively reduce diagnostic uncertainty
has utility. Such an AI-enabled CDSS framework with quantified uncertainty
promises to be practical and beneficial in the demanding context of real-world
medical care. In this study, we introduce the concept of Medical Entropy,
quantifying uncertainties in patient outcomes predicted by neural machine
translation based on the ICD-9 code of procedures. Our experimental results not
only show strong correlations between procedure and diagnosis sequences based
on the simple ICD-9 code but also demonstrate the promising capacity to model
trends of uncertainties during hospitalizations through a data-driven approach. | [
0.07213611155748367,
-0.45541295409202576,
0.9516767263412476,
0.5317089557647705,
-0.5073047876358032,
-0.06393780559301376,
-0.1422504037618637,
-0.1743585765361786,
0.10001584142446518,
-0.06123717129230499,
-0.35623282194137573,
-0.5936693549156189,
-0.9527921080589294,
0.14805273711681366,
-0.32660067081451416,
0.8610401153564453,
-0.1555890589952469,
0.7436597943305969,
-0.1791151612997055,
0.2312905639410019,
-0.4344271123409271,
-0.3108861446380615,
-0.770554780960083,
-0.21267388761043549,
0.43994784355163574,
-0.0852719396352768,
1.1001719236373901,
0.605742335319519,
1.066361427307129,
0.2658471167087555,
0.06526658684015274,
0.03359014540910721,
0.4665326774120331,
0.3107573091983795,
0.35572436451911926,
-0.6641483306884766,
-0.3914209306240082,
-0.523762047290802,
0.2963864803314209,
0.6340398192405701,
-0.5177631378173828,
-0.08542466908693314,
-0.14923745393753052,
0.57054203748703,
-0.5928305983543396,
0.09892100840806961,
-0.1996132731437683,
0.6174941062927246,
0.19816535711288452,
-0.4226902723312378,
-0.25269272923469543,
-0.43907299637794495,
0.1522480696439743,
-0.7632491588592529,
-0.06696216017007828,
-0.13160602748394012,
0.36367467045783997,
1.0237122774124146,
-0.17268790304660797,
-0.3915064036846161,
-0.8093383312225342,
0.4756956100463867,
-0.7279284596443176,
0.4015907347202301,
0.6378538608551025,
0.4456540644168854,
-0.03208918124437332,
-0.8055506348609924,
-0.33171117305755615,
0.13760389387607574,
-0.056647129356861115,
0.08097159117460251,
-0.1770193725824356,
0.21667005121707916,
-0.16198289394378662,
0.13601498305797577,
-0.6267685294151306,
0.18796393275260925,
-0.4521523416042328,
-0.3481607437133789,
0.7067264318466187,
0.6372337937355042,
0.40994226932525635,
-0.019445952028036118,
-0.35250961780548096,
0.001522246515378356,
-0.18765830993652344,
-0.19326230883598328,
-0.2742156386375427,
-0.1244397908449173,
-0.46992698311805725,
0.2548627257347107,
-0.14282140135765076,
0.7058027982711792,
0.07548364251852036,
-0.39364951848983765,
0.46237480640411377,
0.05527567118406296,
-0.5886528491973877,
0.3147282898426056,
0.8867412209510803,
0.4110872447490692,
-0.29658058285713196,
-0.3219306170940399,
-0.1873553842306137,
0.026416340842843056,
0.5064467787742615,
-0.534134030342102,
-0.09425672143697739,
0.6321893930435181,
-0.869817852973938,
-0.7267381548881531,
-0.1639099270105362,
-0.6049924492835999,
-0.7069120407104492,
-0.38583528995513916,
-0.012987826019525528,
-0.8022174835205078,
-0.11977649480104446,
0.5455632209777832,
-0.06458953768014908,
-0.2196887582540512,
0.5842708945274353,
-0.33050477504730225,
0.1503383219242096,
0.42132967710494995,
0.8135883808135986,
-0.20958556234836578,
0.13797098398208618,
0.12256026268005371,
-0.15059877932071686,
-0.7592436671257019,
0.3679540753364563,
-0.4090102016925812,
-0.2768293619155884,
-0.10488428175449371,
-0.3908574879169464,
-0.07138893753290176,
-0.6351867318153381,
0.5885696411132812,
-0.5298627614974976,
-0.28844061493873596,
0.1522609293460846,
-0.3587001860141754,
-0.004058397375047207,
0.15029826760292053,
-0.3682619035243988,
0.48551395535469055,
0.22062428295612335,
-0.36679255962371826,
0.5199129581451416,
-0.31121471524238586,
-0.464252769947052,
0.17425210773944855,
-0.3279528319835663,
-0.4226490259170532,
0.3634200096130371,
-0.007961959578096867,
0.43056944012641907,
-0.6961633563041687,
0.7306379675865173,
-0.30775684118270874,
-0.009830918163061142,
0.4661652743816376,
-0.6394901275634766,
0.711341917514801,
0.8702463507652283,
-0.09108326584100723,
-0.00047282432205975056,
-0.9829275608062744,
0.2677592635154724,
-0.188192680478096,
-0.491971492767334,
-0.3308875262737274,
0.11103810369968414,
-0.1085791066288948,
0.30634793639183044,
0.20560231804847717,
-0.1176791861653328,
0.08908695727586746,
-0.1505509912967682,
0.4499358832836151,
0.5086097121238708,
0.1491193324327469,
0.4882448613643646,
-0.30125781893730164,
0.7390825152397156,
0.5483675599098206,
0.3977152705192566,
0.11354027688503265,
-0.7127196192741394,
-0.3538394272327423,
-0.07037271559238434,
0.4835716187953949,
0.9866421222686768,
-0.8062738180160522,
0.6254226565361023,
-0.038828980177640915,
-0.5005903244018555,
-0.9481184482574463,
-0.27958908677101135,
0.31636181473731995,
0.39150264859199524,
0.32646694779396057,
-0.12365805357694626,
-0.5468378663063049,
-0.7347346544265747,
0.24207371473312378,
-0.393512487411499,
-0.34296751022338867,
0.0335744246840477,
0.14961408078670502,
-0.38562580943107605,
0.4179021716117859,
-0.49994057416915894,
-0.30063292384147644,
0.37649205327033997,
0.1716688573360443,
0.19053122401237488,
0.8707234263420105,
0.22444117069244385,
-0.7744634747505188,
-0.20343266427516937,
0.30183541774749756,
-1.1913282871246338,
0.10558407753705978,
-0.5701329112052917,
-0.047482941299676895,
0.165340393781662,
0.5885460376739502,
-0.6613259315490723,
0.9580819010734558,
0.258635550737381,
-0.26604586839675903,
0.2855883538722992,
-0.7352491021156311,
0.21254120767116547,
-0.99025958776474,
-0.07970847189426422,
-0.17489969730377197,
0.1552271991968155,
-0.5208150148391724,
0.11510120332241058,
0.30210602283477783,
0.044374532997608185,
-0.21478116512298584,
0.06208275631070137,
-0.1299303025007248,
0.14179721474647522,
0.06754094362258911,
-0.4810456931591034,
0.003833046881482005,
0.08625379204750061,
0.03831932321190834,
0.5115653872489929,
0.9465803503990173,
-0.6841184496879578,
0.3466496467590332,
0.03973012417554855,
-0.4477343261241913,
0.6215070486068726,
-0.6422850489616394,
-0.15034419298171997,
-0.13227343559265137,
0.12006614357233047,
-0.43952566385269165,
-0.17877133190631866,
0.1933368444442749,
-0.603058934211731,
0.4012361764907837,
0.1699291467666626,
-0.48510897159576416,
-0.39693203568458557,
0.3194132149219513,
0.6347377896308899,
0.4430236518383026,
0.12543849647045135,
0.4214738607406616,
0.14118878543376923,
-0.2499651163816452,
-0.5779517292976379,
-1.0363346338272095,
0.26718851923942566,
-0.26878708600997925,
-0.5469929575920105,
0.5279542207717896,
-0.15072105824947357,
-0.5755255818367004,
-0.18617038428783417,
0.03917181119322777,
-0.3172563910484314,
0.3823418915271759,
0.2619644105434418,
0.20653264224529266,
-0.41354572772979736,
0.47066938877105713,
0.5830819010734558,
-0.13945594429969788,
0.3311491012573242,
-0.5858442783355713,
0.4484572410583496,
0.02545856311917305,
-0.4628460109233856,
-0.7631623148918152,
0.45351898670196533,
0.6974477171897888,
0.003351971274241805,
0.7497363686561584,
0.6129536628723145,
-0.9061993956565857,
0.13562077283859253,
-0.2546708881855011,
-0.027830304577946663,
-0.3589392900466919,
0.2603245973587036,
-0.18350669741630554,
-0.28799131512641907,
0.8975989818572998,
0.12206244468688965,
-0.6531496644020081,
0.3996976912021637,
0.723939061164856,
-0.2739584147930145,
1.456864833831787,
0.16794675588607788,
0.044389382004737854,
-0.17357759177684784,
-0.010108047164976597,
0.2293945848941803,
-0.44202062487602234,
-0.3749817907810211,
-0.5424435138702393,
-0.3425472378730774,
-0.4663005769252777,
-0.5777168869972229,
0.919150710105896,
0.2543283998966217,
-0.2389814704656601,
-0.27187052369117737,
-0.8643475770950317,
0.0751519501209259,
0.5039932727813721,
0.6902068257331848,
0.04863932728767395,
-0.27971476316452026,
-0.22322645783424377,
0.1464739888906479,
-0.7011614441871643,
-0.18558421730995178,
1.0686184167861938,
0.16132009029388428,
0.814521849155426,
0.04051899164915085,
0.731310248374939,
0.5286937355995178,
-0.19233225286006927,
-0.6552067399024963,
-0.024694878607988358,
0.10421747714281082,
-0.2984628677368164,
-0.314683198928833,
-0.3672889471054077,
-0.8940832018852234,
-0.19842900335788727,
-0.20026297867298126,
-0.3787153363227844,
0.7382975816726685,
-0.08567103743553162,
-1.082393765449524,
0.15978801250457764,
-0.6732109785079956,
0.5306970477104187,
-0.29401421546936035,
0.1903580278158188,
-0.25437554717063904,
-1.171839714050293,
0.04194463789463043,
-0.3626563251018524,
0.2274816483259201,
0.25998231768608093,
-0.30594462156295776,
0.37920814752578735,
-0.6276972889900208,
0.812890350818634,
0.06800051778554916,
-0.26158639788627625,
0.11831453442573547,
0.348966509103775,
0.311159610748291,
0.34089359641075134,
-0.26834750175476074,
0.3471300005912781,
0.06518888473510742,
-0.3216674029827118,
-0.7422928214073181,
0.3396919071674347,
-0.7629750967025757,
-0.3109389841556549,
-0.4200582504272461,
-0.7969961762428284,
-0.10190556198358536,
0.23467132449150085,
0.6589789390563965,
0.3362005352973938,
0.20141848921775818,
-0.08643188327550888,
0.6370229721069336,
-0.5769386887550354,
0.27981385588645935,
0.18160074949264526,
0.40934476256370544,
-0.4291898310184479,
0.7870506644248962,
0.17496246099472046,
0.011453391052782536,
0.5391839742660522,
0.13637812435626984,
0.13215762376785278,
-1.0180025100708008,
-0.4977200925350189,
-0.3397431969642639,
-0.5739123821258545,
-0.8208081126213074,
-0.4709285497665405,
-0.1778671145439148,
-0.5106976628303528,
-0.49456650018692017,
-0.04404702037572861,
-0.5296170115470886,
-0.6390455365180969,
-0.18489648401737213,
0.25161269307136536,
0.5646472573280334,
-0.36369723081588745,
0.24989330768585205,
-0.8743372559547424,
0.16474899649620056,
-0.12421726435422897,
0.34589293599128723,
-0.15523391962051392,
-0.1737702637910843,
-0.470317542552948,
0.15996311604976654,
-0.27291107177734375,
-0.9206780791282654,
0.7239592671394348,
-0.004570026881992817,
0.28642189502716064,
0.8158565759658813,
0.46334582567214966,
0.7091158628463745,
-0.43113550543785095,
0.6955509781837463,
0.43033626675605774,
-0.7571128010749817,
0.6792492270469666,
-0.20025207102298737,
0.016460787504911423,
0.3376668095588684,
0.27897909283638,
-0.3676762282848358,
-0.37128880620002747,
-0.8707513213157654,
-0.7847115993499756,
0.5102387070655823,
0.16908705234527588,
-0.30953359603881836,
-0.17374804615974426,
0.4551871716976166,
-0.06091388314962387,
0.28968673944473267,
0.0999685674905777,
-0.42593085765838623,
0.1008489727973938,
-0.6870373487472534,
0.05071140080690384,
0.1828038990497589,
-0.2200443148612976,
-0.29933616518974304,
0.3485967516899109,
0.007161844987422228,
0.6331613659858704,
0.5308899283409119,
0.14874503016471863,
-0.46163487434387207,
0.053810663521289825,
0.927183210849762,
0.38634830713272095,
-0.17584508657455444,
0.09045343101024628,
0.005090893711894751,
-0.6301288604736328,
0.1856474131345749,
0.16370077431201935,
-0.15739519894123077,
-0.06088140234351158,
0.20060136914253235,
0.674353837966919,
-0.43204545974731445,
-0.5352140069007874,
0.27335846424102783,
-0.1771049201488495,
-0.04399479180574417,
-0.4986361861228943,
-0.09535028040409088,
-0.11453694850206375,
0.3265324831008911,
0.25778812170028687,
0.9360482692718506,
0.5124608874320984,
0.006696077063679695,
0.4542137682437897,
0.12011018395423889,
-0.5196406841278076,
-0.2356020212173462,
0.7155448794364929,
0.07591139525175095,
-0.4877443015575409,
0.7390397787094116,
-0.17159931361675262,
-0.10365281999111176,
1.2307066917419434,
0.4645831882953644,
0.7947154641151428,
-0.3869684338569641,
0.2103053629398346,
0.16753068566322327,
0.3057570457458496,
-0.08405180275440216,
0.4041655361652374,
0.019663801416754723,
-0.6164305806159973,
-0.22837084531784058,
-0.36031877994537354,
-0.09337961673736572,
-0.15336455404758453,
-1.2446420192718506,
0.2274133563041687,
-0.6748279333114624,
-0.4253046214580536,
-0.1488855928182602,
-0.5401591658592224,
-0.635921061038971,
0.610453724861145,
0.38638487458229065,
0.9197447299957275,
-0.38119250535964966,
0.7238108515739441,
0.5893657207489014,
-0.3552204966545105,
-0.6870805621147156,
-0.2022998332977295,
0.196249857544899,
-1.1244759559631348,
0.5053136944770813,
-0.4166891872882843,
0.41531190276145935,
-0.331485778093338,
-0.46016132831573486,
-0.8957797288894653,
1.0408730506896973,
0.43613049387931824,
-0.3265671133995056,
-0.2954338788986206,
0.21933305263519287,
0.7838784456253052,
-0.38624611496925354,
0.1688670963048935,
0.5414072275161743,
0.3865979313850403,
-0.1922864466905594,
-0.9826633334159851,
0.1590341031551361,
-0.3749709725379944,
-0.08869733661413193,
0.30490925908088684,
-0.28494516015052795,
0.7776305079460144,
-0.632190465927124,
0.11006918549537659,
0.15676936507225037,
0.28038668632507324,
0.07539395987987518,
0.6836259365081787,
0.11616808921098709,
0.8313302397727966,
0.9727404713630676,
-0.11379271000623703,
1.2932522296905518,
-0.7028419971466064,
0.09976190328598022,
0.7043900489807129,
-0.12587817013263702,
0.4912774860858917,
0.5044140219688416,
-0.44296184182167053,
0.40870460867881775,
0.8979395031929016,
0.35962095856666565,
0.5925824046134949,
0.33108481764793396,
-0.44002780318260193,
-0.49018168449401855,
-0.10190017521381378,
-0.745861828327179,
0.13055582344532013,
1.0028280019760132,
-0.9348611831665039,
0.14656658470630646,
0.23884478211402893,
-0.11199642717838287,
-0.3637801706790924,
-0.2188783884048462,
0.9688701629638672,
0.2368655800819397,
-0.7608497142791748,
0.7482516765594482,
-0.0006439562421292067,
0.1641705334186554,
-0.44381242990493774,
-0.07705813646316528,
-0.026588955894112587,
0.17397595942020416,
-0.3634020686149597,
-0.4661596715450287,
0.3421493172645569,
-0.41987064480781555,
-0.4283084571361542,
-0.14817611873149872,
0.2960510551929474,
-0.08031745254993439,
-0.798161506652832,
-0.08910572528839111,
0.31322425603866577,
0.1377105861902237,
0.01931724324822426,
-0.8803389668464661,
0.11331935226917267,
0.03761942684650421,
0.1717512011528015,
0.40302255749702454,
0.9852157235145569,
0.01832587830722332,
0.8611530065536499,
0.2768443524837494,
0.4361202120780945,
0.0788094624876976,
-0.10425381362438202,
0.664375901222229,
-0.24967186152935028,
-0.5084919929504395,
-0.6514800190925598,
0.45909786224365234,
0.3524317741394043,
-0.5769505500793457,
-0.03098650835454464,
0.2097664177417755,
0.483966201543808,
-0.08487926423549652,
0.9154866933822632,
-0.09038497507572174,
0.10036887228488922,
-0.6033725738525391,
0.8892437815666199,
-0.5050546526908875,
0.48676809668540955,
-0.0681430995464325,
-0.029713839292526245,
-0.795255184173584,
0.6855579018592834,
0.10126608610153198,
-0.18288670480251312,
0.7483880519866943,
0.5777280926704407,
0.3737560212612152,
0.025346029549837112,
0.37865227460861206,
0.26956918835639954,
-0.10076917707920074,
0.5649809837341309,
0.3993065655231476,
-0.5571884512901306,
0.34615185856819153,
-0.5303366184234619,
-0.08802735060453415,
-0.04453851655125618,
-0.532667338848114,
-0.04273596033453941,
-0.646208643913269,
-0.5605559349060059,
-0.643369734287262,
0.0725073516368866,
0.9901315569877625,
0.840802013874054,
-0.9151590466499329,
0.08641043305397034,
-0.28948119282722473,
0.21885816752910614,
-0.7111423015594482,
-0.12012100219726562,
0.725570797920227,
-0.5645990967750549,
-0.3114664852619171,
0.189642071723938,
0.31475961208343506,
0.25381332635879517,
0.11390749365091324,
-0.3366917669773102,
0.30758777260780334,
-0.13028478622436523,
0.2907840311527252,
-0.20148420333862305,
-0.7308377623558044,
0.15166087448596954,
0.05308753624558449,
-0.17378345131874084,
0.10930629819631577,
0.7550216317176819,
-0.7344194650650024,
0.5771721601486206,
0.39531153440475464,
0.7833006381988525,
-0.1517661213874817,
-0.24516193568706512,
0.856554388999939,
-0.4211430251598358,
0.10194569081068039,
0.593732476234436,
0.48333895206451416,
-0.031147394329309464,
-0.8787740468978882,
0.4930076003074646,
0.22242823243141174,
-0.5534713268280029,
-0.8499691486358643,
-0.06749702990055084,
-0.6458801627159119,
-0.2912972569465637,
0.9425539374351501,
-0.2167031615972519,
0.1049051508307457,
-0.4593069851398468,
0.09041819721460342,
0.22030797600746155,
-0.4083516001701355,
0.959098756313324,
0.4132014214992523,
-0.24591463804244995,
0.041520241647958755,
-0.41358011960983276,
0.6576087474822998,
0.42587655782699585,
-0.5557123422622681,
-0.4328068494796753,
0.1803095042705536,
-0.24824108183383942,
0.48046231269836426,
0.4634348154067993,
-0.16818226873874664,
0.5042561888694763,
-0.016747083514928818,
0.13359011709690094,
0.29340115189552307,
-0.19153259694576263,
-0.5324646830558777,
0.11638770252466202,
-0.17279700934886932,
-0.28781750798225403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05224v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05224v2 | VerAs: Verify then Assess STEM Lab Reports | 2024-02-07T20:02:09 | 2024-04-25T16:16:36 | Berk Atil, Mahsa Sheikhi Karizaki, Rebecca J. Passonneau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With an increasing focus in STEM education on critical thinking skills,
science writing plays an ever more important role in curricula that stress
inquiry skills. A recently published dataset of two sets of college level lab
reports from an inquiry-based physics curriculum relies on analytic assessment
rubrics that utilize multiple dimensions, specifying subject matter knowledge
and general components of good explanations. Each analytic dimension is
assessed on a 6-point scale, to provide detailed feedback to students that can
help them improve their science writing skills. Manual assessment can be slow,
and difficult to calibrate for consistency across all students in large
classes. While much work exists on automated assessment of open-ended questions
in STEM subjects, there has been far less work on long-form writing such as lab
reports. We present an end-to-end neural architecture that has separate
verifier and assessment modules, inspired by approaches to Open Domain Question
Answering (OpenQA). VerAs first verifies whether a report contains any content
relevant to a given rubric dimension, and if so, assesses the relevant
sentences. On the lab reports, VerAs outperforms multiple baselines based on
OpenQA systems or Automated Essay Scoring (AES). VerAs also performs well on an
analytic rubric for middle school physics essays. | [
0.023932358250021935,
-0.8913301825523376,
0.7621502876281738,
0.21039603650569916,
0.2550899088382721,
0.5404069423675537,
0.0020030252635478973,
-0.3664382994174957,
0.16757841408252716,
0.25420400500297546,
-0.5134568810462952,
-0.5852099061012268,
-0.1587527096271515,
0.2157174050807953,
-0.5844734907150269,
1.0396857261657715,
-0.3201216459274292,
0.17822924256324768,
-0.6721661686897278,
0.14998166263103485,
-0.3546258211135864,
0.028673838824033737,
-0.5173563957214355,
-0.27876612544059753,
0.5199795961380005,
0.5282947421073914,
0.22814801335334778,
0.2977032959461212,
0.7559081315994263,
0.3922695815563202,
0.00846857763826847,
0.527769923210144,
-0.42261719703674316,
0.2549901008605957,
-0.31981995701789856,
-0.32792091369628906,
-0.31122925877571106,
-0.09793289750814438,
0.8931505680084229,
0.6130799055099487,
0.1429709792137146,
0.5269995331764221,
-0.24599087238311768,
0.7249879240989685,
-0.8669588565826416,
-0.15447810292243958,
-0.3693513870239258,
0.011927410028874874,
-0.011769609525799751,
-0.23635762929916382,
-0.8343674540519714,
-0.6948866844177246,
0.3215378224849701,
-0.5808721780776978,
0.2608112394809723,
0.17684198915958405,
1.025428056716919,
0.08542092144489288,
-0.38874784111976624,
-0.03951704874634743,
-0.8841376900672913,
0.6770641207695007,
0.13135495781898499,
0.2038218379020691,
0.31584957242012024,
0.43430957198143005,
-0.10242382436990738,
-0.8017724752426147,
-0.5316575169563293,
-0.4003083407878876,
0.11248043179512024,
0.4467359781265259,
-0.07848517596721649,
-0.07662706822156906,
-0.026031820103526115,
0.27306514978408813,
-0.5219266414642334,
0.031142255291342735,
-0.9243266582489014,
-0.5140759348869324,
0.5572215914726257,
0.29148727655410767,
0.008585294708609581,
0.020441383123397827,
-0.49421781301498413,
-0.1416381597518921,
-0.7003924250602722,
0.34410491585731506,
0.35550954937934875,
0.16964749991893768,
0.26986345648765564,
0.8100645542144775,
-0.40482819080352783,
0.579809844493866,
-0.008834299631416798,
0.14683105051517487,
0.2148180902004242,
-0.44890135526657104,
-0.17161184549331665,
0.11096780747175217,
0.8001624345779419,
0.374143123626709,
-0.1129593774676323,
0.016284994781017303,
0.0437060222029686,
0.057343289256095886,
0.5475401282310486,
-0.6791906356811523,
-0.06525004655122757,
0.48772549629211426,
0.05587930232286453,
-0.1784885823726654,
-0.13008487224578857,
-0.7729021310806274,
-0.4596218764781952,
-0.44661134481430054,
0.8844448924064636,
-0.5696055889129639,
0.22358137369155884,
0.17439498007297516,
-0.11954520642757416,
0.21544253826141357,
0.7683820724487305,
-0.5514715313911438,
0.6698659062385559,
0.424402117729187,
0.9087000489234924,
-0.05619783326983452,
-0.6233524084091187,
-0.7095184922218323,
-0.06275983154773712,
-0.6386762857437134,
1.0936028957366943,
-0.2795161306858063,
-0.26373401284217834,
-0.10166846215724945,
-0.2229870706796646,
0.06716370582580566,
-0.12358952313661575,
0.48720744252204895,
-0.5064697861671448,
0.2974441945552826,
-0.33970850706100464,
-0.4411099851131439,
0.01052540261298418,
0.22220931947231293,
-0.20185476541519165,
1.327153205871582,
0.4524976313114166,
-0.5706188082695007,
0.3934561312198639,
-0.7281439900398254,
-0.29627493023872375,
0.08767280727624893,
-0.0937768891453743,
-0.3019046187400818,
0.029254233464598656,
-0.12442336231470108,
0.3936387896537781,
-0.3685321807861328,
-0.06948352605104446,
0.20872701704502106,
-0.08728526532649994,
0.5398217439651489,
-0.1482350379228592,
0.3931269645690918,
-0.15399636328220367,
0.003222273662686348,
0.632245659828186,
-0.9825571179389954,
0.3823194205760956,
-0.2743791937828064,
-0.0943513959646225,
-0.03815566748380661,
-0.008607481606304646,
-0.32289525866508484,
-0.29024550318717957,
0.13034556806087494,
-1.1612977981567383,
-0.24802957475185394,
-0.20661689341068268,
0.04132229462265968,
0.7236910462379456,
-0.04822290316224098,
0.33361220359802246,
-0.5205450654029846,
0.37220054864883423,
-0.17287702858448029,
0.13155966997146606,
-0.10531365871429443,
-0.36983925104141235,
-0.6814606785774231,
-0.442371129989624,
0.11386725306510925,
0.6894401907920837,
-0.5090482831001282,
0.6417446136474609,
-0.1344970315694809,
-1.1869345903396606,
-0.7008582949638367,
-0.11332425475120544,
0.5488635897636414,
0.9792038798332214,
0.7697935700416565,
-0.34377187490463257,
-0.12885142862796783,
-0.7796126008033752,
0.032674938440322876,
-0.22211754322052002,
-0.14624054729938507,
-0.06446569412946701,
0.6957963705062866,
0.3650658428668976,
1.176493763923645,
-0.7675090432167053,
-0.24568431079387665,
-0.002845244947820902,
0.37150657176971436,
-0.008614310063421726,
0.47304415702819824,
0.2895297706127167,
-0.39923030138015747,
-0.486857533454895,
0.15334703028202057,
-0.44646018743515015,
-0.08792092651128769,
-0.08194496482610703,
-0.3322887718677521,
0.0040344479493796825,
0.2907489240169525,
-0.6549316048622131,
0.665418267250061,
0.09859918802976608,
-0.6806214451789856,
0.9768275618553162,
-0.5328842401504517,
0.4377351403236389,
-0.49072694778442383,
0.03718309849500656,
0.04174096882343292,
-0.1496817022562027,
-0.4653509259223938,
-0.23309315741062164,
0.2378879338502884,
0.23309004306793213,
-0.5305776000022888,
0.34285518527030945,
-0.4106315076351166,
-0.04752397909760475,
-0.13725298643112183,
0.16088561713695526,
0.4230618178844452,
-0.11453243345022202,
-0.09285971522331238,
0.48901858925819397,
0.8670888543128967,
-0.5670806765556335,
0.6802173852920532,
0.09488129615783691,
-0.49415385723114014,
0.828129768371582,
-0.7573320269584656,
0.04675140231847763,
-0.3945354223251343,
0.3231259286403656,
-0.9716029763221741,
-0.22699452936649323,
-0.27404528856277466,
-0.7889557480812073,
0.33789581060409546,
0.25512611865997314,
-0.4451819062232971,
-0.5380394458770752,
-0.6565768718719482,
-0.14360372722148895,
0.42147138714790344,
-0.34474170207977295,
0.9894896745681763,
-0.0642169937491417,
0.002583554480224848,
-0.9327681660652161,
-0.49826619029045105,
-0.30077436566352844,
0.12878496944904327,
-0.6279845237731934,
0.12619510293006897,
-0.21950583159923553,
-0.2480446994304657,
0.08252955973148346,
-0.08950182795524597,
-0.2971600294113159,
0.18764829635620117,
0.32829737663269043,
0.7361640930175781,
-0.30746057629585266,
0.26543349027633667,
0.5289886593818665,
-0.0653439313173294,
0.3138328194618225,
-0.029697610065340996,
0.22529925405979156,
-0.46254998445510864,
-0.44253969192504883,
-0.3653465509414673,
0.3402387201786041,
0.9690514802932739,
-0.31428849697113037,
0.696464478969574,
0.40882009267807007,
-0.4118013083934784,
-0.39460518956184387,
-0.55198073387146,
-0.2087365835905075,
-0.47615212202072144,
0.5050279498100281,
-0.36002790927886963,
-0.7750832438468933,
0.5362309217453003,
0.16096587479114532,
0.2516036629676819,
0.7436950206756592,
0.6491513252258301,
-0.15884354710578918,
0.3131557106971741,
0.5809579491615295,
0.47313201427459717,
-0.13675743341445923,
-0.16265074908733368,
0.3207036256790161,
-0.747883677482605,
-0.7249502539634705,
-0.9160659909248352,
0.015021226368844509,
0.11006643623113632,
-0.5158915519714355,
0.37995651364326477,
-0.2438112199306488,
-0.3045269548892975,
0.01500912569463253,
-0.8765387535095215,
0.9796521663665771,
0.3935329020023346,
0.08717787265777588,
0.22131934762001038,
-0.09363695979118347,
-0.13767065107822418,
0.00433135824277997,
-0.18853659927845,
-0.47434914112091064,
0.9292238354682922,
0.42893218994140625,
0.5842152833938599,
0.09529571235179901,
0.44504842162132263,
0.13227514922618866,
0.587908148765564,
-0.9789679050445557,
0.6947491765022278,
0.14285123348236084,
-0.7078216671943665,
-0.6273268461227417,
-0.2843596935272217,
-0.6641024351119995,
0.3141442537307739,
-0.3554285764694214,
-0.9218312501907349,
-0.0959673523902893,
-0.19351287186145782,
-0.8096510767936707,
0.14355529844760895,
-0.8492763042449951,
0.5401061177253723,
-0.033966731280088425,
-0.8080965280532837,
-0.3131508231163025,
-0.7343025207519531,
0.13755974173545837,
-0.22668547928333282,
0.004818939138203859,
-0.13606341183185577,
0.06158393621444702,
0.9196703433990479,
-0.37119123339653015,
0.7675755023956299,
0.10762549936771393,
0.20721065998077393,
0.784547746181488,
0.28127390146255493,
-0.20983071625232697,
0.14934363961219788,
-0.0344676747918129,
-0.26692062616348267,
0.38541504740715027,
-0.1810828596353531,
-0.4839789569377899,
0.6263600587844849,
-1.009710431098938,
-0.48353615403175354,
-0.8053489327430725,
-0.6416876316070557,
-0.17725838720798492,
0.21615494787693024,
0.16989219188690186,
0.4865286648273468,
-0.2260141372680664,
0.11843619495630264,
0.9615455865859985,
0.11420681327581406,
0.18889255821704865,
0.7619436383247375,
-0.2961651384830475,
-0.34871670603752136,
0.9057860970497131,
0.2173699140548706,
0.43920764327049255,
0.42628178000450134,
0.4643881320953369,
-0.2729507088661194,
-0.5724162459373474,
-0.5383006930351257,
0.2092423141002655,
-0.9398218989372253,
-0.5025820732116699,
-0.6481425762176514,
-0.4993099570274353,
-0.5238050222396851,
-0.5329416394233704,
-0.6080701351165771,
-0.42321258783340454,
-0.31419694423675537,
-0.4471050500869751,
0.629331648349762,
0.9614205360412598,
-0.24898448586463928,
0.09308554232120514,
-0.8256933689117432,
0.19290374219417572,
0.13129767775535583,
0.11135885864496231,
-0.20333896577358246,
-0.5571003556251526,
-0.1882391721010208,
-0.27655988931655884,
-0.47168365120887756,
-0.7876371741294861,
0.04814429581165314,
0.0314314104616642,
0.3325779438018799,
0.07644308358430862,
-0.17386947572231293,
0.2874234914779663,
-0.560525119304657,
0.9463050365447998,
0.39069104194641113,
-1.1958034038543701,
0.7093141078948975,
-0.12343334406614304,
-0.008666862733662128,
0.754926860332489,
0.6390807032585144,
-0.08050327003002167,
-0.44242480397224426,
-0.31083646416664124,
-0.5890805721282959,
0.4725196361541748,
0.07876628637313843,
0.033310241997241974,
0.11008882522583008,
0.43406814336776733,
0.2510908246040344,
-0.11611428111791611,
-0.4393749237060547,
-0.08130736649036407,
-0.21214795112609863,
-0.36343589425086975,
0.23511125147342682,
-0.035327281802892685,
-0.3635929226875305,
-0.454961359500885,
0.5314472913742065,
-0.2985095977783203,
-0.018429145216941833,
0.7133123278617859,
0.40705129504203796,
-0.23766885697841644,
0.36887168884277344,
0.49307066202163696,
0.8311446309089661,
-0.23077793419361115,
0.18108269572257996,
0.24156980216503143,
-0.7962273955345154,
0.1789766550064087,
-0.0665213093161583,
-0.20549416542053223,
-0.061018094420433044,
0.2784266173839569,
0.1817718744277954,
-0.41986697912216187,
-0.6697185635566711,
0.5431445240974426,
-0.2733195722103119,
-0.46289974451065063,
-0.19204457104206085,
0.23613464832305908,
-0.1534583419561386,
-0.1148810014128685,
0.35733562707901,
0.2525451183319092,
0.12527066469192505,
-0.5677090883255005,
-0.015947250649333,
0.07921735942363739,
-0.4445365071296692,
-0.27767425775527954,
0.24143534898757935,
0.0505429208278656,
-0.13248935341835022,
0.4207454323768616,
0.04722531884908676,
-0.416573703289032,
0.7726764678955078,
0.42012807726860046,
0.8013147115707397,
-0.5289553999900818,
0.537331223487854,
0.6322420835494995,
0.5421021580696106,
0.01869897171854973,
0.7804596424102783,
-0.0789324939250946,
-0.4450250267982483,
-0.5296775102615356,
-0.6067387461662292,
-0.9773122668266296,
-0.4406350255012512,
-0.5776570439338684,
0.3913017511367798,
-0.900371253490448,
-0.07611754536628723,
0.12443891912698746,
0.02729232981801033,
-0.397887647151947,
0.5575045347213745,
-0.30620700120925903,
0.9397234320640564,
-1.0546153783798218,
0.3820514678955078,
0.6819561123847961,
-0.311343252658844,
-0.6175643801689148,
-0.7021598219871521,
0.07890312373638153,
-0.3981929123401642,
0.8342461585998535,
0.20848488807678223,
-0.6792076230049133,
-0.28952014446258545,
-0.6392660140991211,
-1.1803085803985596,
1.1127678155899048,
-0.2101910561323166,
-0.06971576809883118,
0.37152954936027527,
-0.12956489622592926,
0.8673953413963318,
-0.32255977392196655,
0.5417824983596802,
0.34842944145202637,
0.3018747866153717,
0.23333092033863068,
-0.8327524065971375,
0.1424303948879242,
-0.15191523730754852,
-0.6982880234718323,
0.1265304982662201,
-0.5689060091972351,
0.7736992835998535,
-0.5021527409553528,
0.014064747840166092,
0.07624323666095734,
1.1167958974838257,
0.20403943955898285,
0.6720239520072937,
0.10607558488845825,
0.27907803654670715,
1.1963090896606445,
-0.2092238962650299,
0.8155661821365356,
0.15134365856647491,
-0.011913648806512356,
1.1849571466445923,
-0.6242406964302063,
1.044981837272644,
0.4786262810230255,
-0.23970267176628113,
0.8090462684631348,
0.3609590530395508,
-0.11203918606042862,
0.30860087275505066,
0.8003110885620117,
-0.36441799998283386,
0.02809809148311615,
-0.47982507944107056,
-0.20548713207244873,
0.4640413224697113,
0.6697474718093872,
0.10858242213726044,
-0.02557910978794098,
-0.19320760667324066,
-0.09093786031007767,
0.3434816002845764,
-0.2608790099620819,
0.21961748600006104,
-0.3027767539024353,
-0.8746587038040161,
-0.12592123448848724,
-0.10729867964982986,
0.04762643575668335,
-0.8407586216926575,
0.0572655089199543,
0.10369172692298889,
0.24578841030597687,
-0.46668171882629395,
-1.2998265027999878,
0.4492276906967163,
0.13644000887870789,
-0.1763327419757843,
-0.14298568665981293,
0.719235360622406,
-0.09910380840301514,
-0.47111886739730835,
0.04682721570134163,
0.528490424156189,
0.040365349501371384,
0.5705111622810364,
-0.0034639250952750444,
0.002376703079789877,
-0.3850908577442169,
-0.2775333821773529,
0.0006554183783009648,
0.46641647815704346,
0.15559011697769165,
0.811510443687439,
0.6518048048019409,
0.13783380389213562,
0.07792700082063675,
0.07991382479667664,
0.8495191931724548,
-0.3359602093696594,
-0.33850955963134766,
-0.5206938982009888,
0.8305084705352783,
-0.3877561390399933,
-0.6345996260643005,
0.6846098899841309,
0.7004474997520447,
0.45964688062667847,
0.0869378000497818,
0.6266505122184753,
0.15001778304576874,
0.8203745484352112,
-0.6741991639137268,
0.6801812648773193,
-0.1734611690044403,
-0.05885957553982735,
-0.05018399655818939,
-0.6553016901016235,
-0.5331443548202515,
0.5338442325592041,
-0.29665011167526245,
-0.10328695178031921,
1.4393678903579712,
0.5164391994476318,
0.39288684725761414,
0.2891353368759155,
0.16436298191547394,
0.2945890426635742,
0.5431349277496338,
0.4938451647758484,
1.1708532571792603,
-0.2840760052204132,
0.2135738730430603,
-0.40182656049728394,
-0.6135722398757935,
0.19161120057106018,
-0.7095133662223816,
-1.1931514739990234,
-0.5180265307426453,
-0.7529363036155701,
-0.7076328992843628,
-0.2672915458679199,
0.47676047682762146,
0.25996512174606323,
-0.39094412326812744,
-0.08673978596925735,
0.15742191672325134,
0.17304596304893494,
0.0292288176715374,
-0.25948983430862427,
0.5709752440452576,
-0.260544091463089,
-0.18435169756412506,
0.586443305015564,
0.6249136328697205,
0.15275774896144867,
-0.40146926045417786,
0.3951093256473541,
-0.02622189000248909,
0.45408403873443604,
0.5244289040565491,
0.24163994193077087,
-0.4351199269294739,
-0.5019574761390686,
0.4655285179615021,
-0.2504517734050751,
-0.016152217984199524,
0.5136739015579224,
-0.8897692561149597,
0.5367220640182495,
0.7431288361549377,
0.5302338004112244,
0.42425665259361267,
-0.38323864340782166,
0.21312259137630463,
-0.3511362373828888,
-0.45353466272354126,
0.5325167775154114,
0.30219319462776184,
0.530175507068634,
-0.4828076958656311,
0.3647007346153259,
0.05553680658340454,
-0.7462892532348633,
-0.8108136057853699,
-0.09916554391384125,
-1.34971284866333,
-0.10119672864675522,
0.642530083656311,
-0.3051353991031647,
-0.553829550743103,
-0.167150616645813,
-0.36209744215011597,
-0.014762036502361298,
-0.21800154447555542,
0.7753409743309021,
0.8418117165565491,
-0.21451576054096222,
0.3608204424381256,
-0.22178009152412415,
0.1010080873966217,
0.5277324318885803,
-1.125850796699524,
0.09565388411283493,
0.6544604897499084,
0.10813388228416443,
0.7454721927642822,
0.6764711141586304,
-0.10233519226312637,
0.6694950461387634,
0.15301339328289032,
-0.054711904376745224,
-0.12710538506507874,
-0.9089781641960144,
0.06194526329636574,
0.46837562322616577,
-0.20669449865818024,
-0.22339574992656708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05201v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05201v2 | The Effect of Sampling Temperature on Problem Solving in Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T19:11:23 | 2024-06-14T18:41:51 | Matthew Renze, Erhan Guven | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this research study, we empirically investigate the effect of sampling
temperature on the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various
problem-solving tasks. We created a multiple-choice question-and-answer (MCQA)
exam by randomly sampling problems from standard LLM benchmarks. Then, we used
nine popular LLMs with five prompt-engineering techniques to solve the MCQA
problems while increasing the sampling temperature from 0.0 to 1.6. Despite
anecdotal reports to the contrary, our empirical results indicate that changes
in temperature from 0.0 to 1.0 do not have a statistically significant impact
on LLM performance for problem-solving tasks. In addition, these results appear
to generalize across LLMs, prompt-engineering techniques, and problem domains.
All code, data, and supplemental materials are available on GitHub at:
https://github.com/matthewrenze/jhu-llm-temperature | [
-0.4911494553089142,
-0.9114169478416443,
0.8112966418266296,
0.2694292962551117,
-0.09898563474416733,
-0.024026794359087944,
-0.3957619071006775,
-0.3648957908153534,
0.1872103363275528,
0.38315603137016296,
-0.2791227400302887,
-0.351340115070343,
-0.3304806053638458,
0.091297447681427,
-0.31293386220932007,
0.48676490783691406,
-0.12377241998910904,
0.021945949643850327,
-0.44484463334083557,
0.29245060682296753,
-0.24873319268226624,
-0.8059943318367004,
-0.7958798408508301,
-0.20709915459156036,
0.703290581703186,
0.6799513101577759,
0.3667970299720764,
0.3926456570625305,
0.4166466295719147,
0.3071597218513489,
-0.2519969940185547,
-0.22784872353076935,
-0.4332675039768219,
0.5600129961967468,
0.08799464255571365,
-0.5275801420211792,
-0.014692173339426517,
0.06865285336971283,
0.6897942423820496,
0.6441283822059631,
-0.3665515184402466,
0.315525084733963,
-0.025484692305326462,
0.6903306245803833,
-0.6908632516860962,
0.24403773248195648,
-0.7780476808547974,
-0.3429606556892395,
-0.39872822165489197,
-0.29772651195526123,
-0.45868468284606934,
-0.08609788119792938,
-0.039920296519994736,
-0.48655256628990173,
0.39039793610572815,
0.29403939843177795,
0.34801995754241943,
0.25125765800476074,
-0.4061262309551239,
-0.23365917801856995,
-0.7276624441146851,
1.0676223039627075,
-0.8318278193473816,
0.17813824117183685,
0.1332152783870697,
0.16820010542869568,
-0.3694913685321808,
-0.25507912039756775,
-0.7968313097953796,
-0.2358558028936386,
0.5340194702148438,
0.1058533564209938,
0.052575960755348206,
-0.1454688310623169,
0.5831689834594727,
0.18755139410495758,
-0.5268086194992065,
0.2215372771024704,
-0.5865145325660706,
-0.02747575007379055,
0.672421395778656,
0.43109115958213806,
0.2828240394592285,
-0.060635942965745926,
-0.10415157675743103,
-0.2811664342880249,
-0.45710501074790955,
0.3307549059391022,
0.35036978125572205,
0.5043761134147644,
0.11526277661323547,
0.3768155872821808,
-0.209245502948761,
0.689996063709259,
-0.3769133985042572,
0.05493289604783058,
0.29813459515571594,
-0.05226815491914749,
-0.25773775577545166,
-0.19617825746536255,
0.5440032482147217,
0.17049625515937805,
0.3469308912754059,
-0.009670468978583813,
-0.09558725357055664,
-0.4997043311595917,
0.03501603379845619,
-0.7656498551368713,
-0.4566226303577423,
0.408875972032547,
0.018226968124508858,
-0.12571386992931366,
-0.029735352843999863,
-0.701205313205719,
-0.47419682145118713,
-0.3864539861679077,
0.17921249568462372,
0.12516328692436218,
-0.5026898384094238,
0.10736646503210068,
-0.44082948565483093,
0.287894070148468,
0.25546690821647644,
-0.6322329044342041,
0.21591782569885254,
0.4845160245895386,
0.5727299451828003,
-0.22334106266498566,
-0.3215486705303192,
-0.08536694198846817,
-0.08540073782205582,
-0.4357640743255615,
0.8988078236579895,
-0.688247561454773,
-0.6591068506240845,
-0.15425880253314972,
-0.09492256492376328,
-0.2591027021408081,
-0.8152958750724792,
0.26095637679100037,
-0.8140456676483154,
-0.03890872001647949,
-0.7601558566093445,
-0.3048502802848816,
0.23859423398971558,
0.3490191400051117,
-0.900036633014679,
1.2506980895996094,
-0.34652596712112427,
-0.6016271710395813,
0.10749822854995728,
-0.45467254519462585,
-0.09012200683355331,
-0.2323356419801712,
0.051016852259635925,
-0.20755313336849213,
0.15819436311721802,
0.16298529505729675,
0.4027065932750702,
-0.4410873353481293,
-0.11867780983448029,
-0.522580087184906,
-0.34302306175231934,
0.7777096629142761,
-0.27846792340278625,
0.6841804385185242,
0.273954838514328,
-0.019288310781121254,
-0.08717060834169388,
-0.6264950633049011,
0.22582755982875824,
0.4123114049434662,
-0.36519503593444824,
-0.37794119119644165,
-0.20063087344169617,
-0.16665218770503998,
0.13166461884975433,
0.12882694602012634,
-0.6359198689460754,
0.39838075637817383,
-0.2015112191438675,
0.07711740583181381,
0.7252923250198364,
0.3344101309776306,
0.45591792464256287,
-0.4942079484462738,
0.7697324156761169,
0.14151214063167572,
-0.3532191216945648,
-0.011323485523462296,
-0.7274201512336731,
-0.5922837257385254,
-0.14287585020065308,
0.23983876407146454,
0.7670372724533081,
-0.8523333072662354,
-0.42704156041145325,
0.24682554602622986,
-0.7025818228721619,
-0.10736968368291855,
0.34190890192985535,
0.16964688897132874,
0.3727230727672577,
0.28873082995414734,
0.15483112633228302,
-0.3688746392726898,
-0.7500658631324768,
-0.2789628207683563,
0.010041608475148678,
-0.1881265938282013,
0.3601493239402771,
0.5081543326377869,
0.40145742893218994,
1.0268667936325073,
-0.7271115779876709,
0.28072643280029297,
-0.13986895978450775,
0.2050466686487198,
0.5040175318717957,
0.5514382719993591,
0.5933067798614502,
-0.5777738094329834,
-0.37228599190711975,
-0.43467554450035095,
-0.5605484247207642,
-0.37806496024131775,
0.1920442283153534,
-0.0814630314707756,
0.4412132501602173,
0.7710843086242676,
-0.8677909970283508,
0.1300773322582245,
0.6434251666069031,
0.004177544265985489,
0.9342740774154663,
-0.05618293955922127,
0.348849356174469,
-1.0127698183059692,
0.1329326182603836,
0.35925763845443726,
0.2697056829929352,
-0.7507032155990601,
0.3640349209308624,
0.10640612244606018,
-0.2342454195022583,
-0.7731261253356934,
0.9002092480659485,
-0.5713614225387573,
0.2283426970243454,
-0.3708565831184387,
-0.012559090740978718,
-0.06290532648563385,
0.2243957817554474,
-0.1450178325176239,
0.9565646648406982,
0.47088608145713806,
-0.8578886985778809,
0.5670011043548584,
-0.2862679064273834,
-0.3548072278499603,
0.08579221367835999,
-0.6524530053138733,
0.44005081057548523,
-0.23087158799171448,
0.29036614298820496,
-1.0888296365737915,
-0.19703300297260284,
0.06539439409971237,
-0.5076625943183899,
0.2689143717288971,
0.09128442406654358,
-0.8615162372589111,
-0.36148035526275635,
-0.2021719515323639,
0.684686005115509,
0.39448001980781555,
-0.26441341638565063,
0.2851928770542145,
0.04112420231103897,
-0.5191634893417358,
-0.30988752841949463,
-0.5495993494987488,
-0.2322833091020584,
-0.3161203861236572,
-0.4139828681945801,
0.05885240435600281,
-0.48444342613220215,
-0.7336471080780029,
-0.31135156750679016,
-0.137187659740448,
-0.26260432600975037,
0.22623440623283386,
-0.046951618045568466,
0.09459877759218216,
-0.03869469836354256,
0.3698582649230957,
-0.15109345316886902,
0.01332408469170332,
0.5691941380500793,
0.07242348045110703,
0.7447587847709656,
0.12690338492393494,
-0.40743526816368103,
-0.11332165449857712,
0.5694612264633179,
0.37700942158699036,
-0.05233624204993248,
0.8664990663528442,
0.1343487650156021,
-0.3483411967754364,
-0.26337921619415283,
-0.7153185606002808,
-0.3199261724948883,
-0.530607283115387,
0.26123934984207153,
-0.6382449269294739,
-0.7572706937789917,
0.848172128200531,
0.2244047224521637,
0.1734529584646225,
0.39351725578308105,
0.6576700806617737,
-0.4727221727371216,
0.8511577248573303,
0.3391915559768677,
0.024995090439915657,
0.4630464017391205,
0.03881927207112312,
-0.036717489361763,
-0.7807040810585022,
-0.20407943427562714,
-1.0453983545303345,
-0.3896252512931824,
-0.5144429206848145,
-0.5544750094413757,
0.570902407169342,
0.027134371921420097,
-0.3288109600543976,
-0.14745892584323883,
-0.10558729618787766,
0.724530041217804,
0.8594785332679749,
0.1411263793706894,
0.10205934196710587,
-0.16045600175857544,
-0.05330001562833786,
-0.1014060229063034,
-0.6961507797241211,
-0.09936966747045517,
1.134940505027771,
0.2512637674808502,
0.7513332962989807,
0.15960364043712616,
0.8693124055862427,
-0.21787939965724945,
0.19099941849708557,
-0.5131213068962097,
0.6925758719444275,
0.21338148415088654,
-0.9702979326248169,
-0.5743498802185059,
-0.654599130153656,
-1.0206576585769653,
0.16332073509693146,
0.1362839937210083,
-0.7910687327384949,
-0.18342547118663788,
0.05991699919104576,
-0.21694284677505493,
0.3588970899581909,
-0.7462791800498962,
0.6104172468185425,
-0.038465406745672226,
-0.2041148990392685,
-0.16070497035980225,
-0.1765834093093872,
0.3798520565032959,
-0.11908148229122162,
0.5423750877380371,
-0.2610662877559662,
0.1451418697834015,
0.9561889171600342,
-0.04309171438217163,
0.9087899923324585,
-0.3350726366043091,
-0.29615044593811035,
0.37815138697624207,
0.186111181974411,
0.4505867660045624,
0.054207272827625275,
-0.5570394992828369,
-0.06664028763771057,
0.37123343348503113,
-0.9993308782577515,
-0.6840904355049133,
0.7734114527702332,
-0.7038198709487915,
-1.120489478111267,
-0.6888718008995056,
-1.0105684995651245,
-0.457119345664978,
-0.08124296367168427,
0.007247183471918106,
0.3529842793941498,
0.056431595236063004,
0.21444348990917206,
0.9577795267105103,
-0.49679243564605713,
0.5084949731826782,
0.6517858505249023,
-0.41984525322914124,
0.08493998646736145,
0.7481455206871033,
0.43803486227989197,
0.587026834487915,
0.12278106063604355,
0.2603864371776581,
0.04653773829340935,
-0.5493389368057251,
-0.4081844687461853,
0.2003365159034729,
-0.8139858841896057,
-0.07793030887842178,
-0.3741337060928345,
-0.3381689488887787,
-0.606514036655426,
0.02122674137353897,
-0.11308275908231735,
-0.22476045787334442,
-0.4780215322971344,
0.14476734399795532,
0.4829421639442444,
0.2810181975364685,
0.08034408092498779,
0.1475917249917984,
-0.8634691834449768,
0.07437121868133545,
0.29510951042175293,
0.11764851212501526,
0.0870218575000763,
-0.6721728444099426,
-0.19713979959487915,
0.06877855211496353,
-0.0549025796353817,
-0.8993924856185913,
0.2725520133972168,
-0.12026126682758331,
0.8115875720977783,
0.04006524011492729,
0.3302621841430664,
0.543677806854248,
-0.1581472009420395,
0.9638206958770752,
-0.010509790852665901,
-0.7443705201148987,
0.2929304540157318,
-0.40464848279953003,
1.1627111434936523,
0.40025264024734497,
0.48686841130256653,
-0.4485397934913635,
-0.6745166778564453,
-0.46872836351394653,
-0.8443690538406372,
0.22055087983608246,
-0.10052605718374252,
0.5158041715621948,
0.011430440470576286,
0.5163071155548096,
-0.10914500802755356,
0.043387364596128464,
-0.48550844192504883,
-0.353335440158844,
0.3904876112937927,
0.19683337211608887,
-0.25505974888801575,
-0.46496617794036865,
-0.014814243651926517,
-0.47202616930007935,
0.6723964810371399,
0.015838446095585823,
0.30269983410835266,
0.0579880028963089,
0.1313675194978714,
-0.1083802655339241,
0.5769729018211365,
0.7962238192558289,
0.6885718703269958,
-0.4723619520664215,
0.08470068871974945,
0.47809478640556335,
-0.34101006388664246,
-0.14725816249847412,
0.11846468597650528,
-0.05814092606306076,
-0.08282174915075302,
0.2383212000131607,
0.15241777896881104,
0.05894506350159645,
-0.6128533482551575,
-0.062097273766994476,
-0.0900292694568634,
-0.4090367257595062,
-0.3251824676990509,
0.3273121118545532,
0.17301461100578308,
0.2005382925271988,
0.716225802898407,
-0.08585721254348755,
0.046182624995708466,
-0.7486976385116577,
-0.08361591398715973,
0.48292577266693115,
0.07780211418867111,
-0.04400373995304108,
0.27795302867889404,
0.05750882998108864,
-0.18218682706356049,
0.8446353673934937,
-0.15662522614002228,
-0.5597034692764282,
1.0983948707580566,
0.8423177003860474,
0.18647438287734985,
-0.30745968222618103,
-0.05656765401363373,
0.43215858936309814,
0.34883755445480347,
0.09796509891748428,
0.7076907753944397,
0.14186012744903564,
-0.7964547872543335,
-0.48320385813713074,
-0.5306884050369263,
-0.888015627861023,
0.16230104863643646,
-0.6276653409004211,
-0.0753772109746933,
-0.49425697326660156,
-0.08816341310739517,
-0.2636517584323883,
0.08170343935489655,
-0.8895861506462097,
0.36444520950317383,
0.22180861234664917,
1.0851013660430908,
-0.7707188129425049,
0.7468507885932922,
0.66172856092453,
-0.15020844340324402,
-1.1166942119598389,
0.11730863153934479,
0.19382469356060028,
-0.6441106796264648,
0.501926600933075,
-0.05538828670978546,
-0.01987561769783497,
0.11497543752193451,
-0.7263485193252563,
-1.223407506942749,
0.9741473197937012,
0.3150785267353058,
-0.6441600918769836,
0.03741305693984032,
0.2226857841014862,
0.5575903058052063,
0.07483545690774918,
0.3054463863372803,
0.6786516904830933,
0.47710373997688293,
0.3024325668811798,
-1.2044932842254639,
0.008028803393244743,
-0.48699212074279785,
-0.1354043185710907,
0.2135521024465561,
-0.6586000919342041,
0.8497527241706848,
-0.2682269811630249,
-0.1135391965508461,
-0.031025473028421402,
0.6633564233779907,
0.7308624982833862,
0.661525547504425,
0.3721342086791992,
0.6077419519424438,
0.8830258846282959,
-0.07087625563144684,
1.14518141746521,
-0.26688870787620544,
0.16849660873413086,
0.8702538013458252,
-0.5046013593673706,
1.0351061820983887,
0.7886355519294739,
-0.20083069801330566,
0.1586632877588272,
0.6591663956642151,
0.2521286904811859,
0.2963932156562805,
0.7729684114456177,
-0.3646301031112671,
-0.20819643139839172,
-0.08315795660018921,
-0.7369982600212097,
0.23420992493629456,
0.3039951026439667,
-0.030590225011110306,
-0.08090336620807648,
0.1713506132364273,
0.16430777311325073,
-0.09016718715429306,
-0.39062872529029846,
0.3909924328327179,
0.3271041214466095,
-0.5322753190994263,
0.4806095063686371,
0.03568308427929878,
0.4942246973514557,
-0.21550032496452332,
0.2587859034538269,
-0.24407203495502472,
-0.17135822772979736,
-0.04193468764424324,
-1.0009920597076416,
0.3993751108646393,
0.04540101811289787,
-0.31155261397361755,
-0.3863513469696045,
0.4894186854362488,
-0.1387968212366104,
-0.6682158708572388,
-0.09830818325281143,
0.7292535901069641,
0.28470057249069214,
-0.2932206392288208,
-0.3612555265426636,
0.31317567825317383,
-0.3692984879016876,
-0.7421993613243103,
0.47846895456314087,
0.4202766716480255,
0.16624924540519714,
0.7280638813972473,
0.817984402179718,
-0.02849172241985798,
0.1488674283027649,
0.13764730095863342,
0.9344388246536255,
-0.8305376768112183,
-0.2503345310688019,
-0.7369301319122314,
0.2740228772163391,
0.041936807334423065,
-0.3119179308414459,
0.6723496913909912,
0.6212254166603088,
0.845683753490448,
-0.13260683417320251,
0.7270405888557434,
0.10088760405778885,
0.6925241351127625,
-1.0113290548324585,
0.44789016246795654,
-0.4429949223995209,
0.4108732342720032,
-0.3268505334854126,
-1.19089674949646,
-0.25610899925231934,
-0.059561651200056076,
-0.7712219953536987,
0.26219674944877625,
0.8211219906806946,
0.8962330222129822,
0.27285531163215637,
-0.1627345085144043,
0.31675398349761963,
0.2236771136522293,
0.460298627614975,
0.3916676938533783,
0.9150559306144714,
-0.049996644258499146,
0.49585166573524475,
-0.4037385880947113,
-0.15187625586986542,
0.015150877647101879,
-0.8053710460662842,
-0.8079028129577637,
-0.6409624814987183,
-0.30385473370552063,
-0.4721374213695526,
-0.027900787070393562,
1.0399521589279175,
0.37386441230773926,
-0.7809320688247681,
-0.24366901814937592,
0.39487066864967346,
-0.03599051758646965,
-0.12425035983324051,
-0.2717812955379486,
0.06989482045173645,
-0.35740023851394653,
-0.772948145866394,
0.35911861062049866,
-0.19902658462524414,
-0.16555753350257874,
-0.251508891582489,
0.2679345905780792,
-0.05687597766518593,
0.4771024286746979,
0.3171907663345337,
0.32661402225494385,
-0.5593892931938171,
-0.16011154651641846,
0.2869008779525757,
-0.33361420035362244,
0.044491447508335114,
0.85895836353302,
-0.6369941830635071,
0.19295015931129456,
0.6419180631637573,
0.6311962008476257,
0.6084931492805481,
-0.00918508879840374,
0.36641544103622437,
-0.827801525592804,
0.02809801883995533,
0.15497225522994995,
0.33599114418029785,
0.02540496364235878,
-0.3205588459968567,
-0.04712254926562309,
0.11977677792310715,
-0.7130452990531921,
-0.7620046138763428,
0.30058056116104126,
-1.0294976234436035,
-0.5265502333641052,
1.4583773612976074,
0.2762167453765869,
-0.3595322072505951,
0.04527841508388519,
-0.1710789054632187,
0.06202159821987152,
-0.544996440410614,
1.1516854763031006,
1.128310203552246,
-0.09979850798845291,
-0.6507079601287842,
-1.0870699882507324,
0.02558712102472782,
0.6029565334320068,
-0.7464207410812378,
-0.04821942374110222,
0.3807883560657501,
0.5610944032669067,
-0.12889482080936432,
0.7079098224639893,
0.3695424497127533,
0.2865367829799652,
-0.05382834002375603,
0.04966576397418976,
-0.23072507977485657,
-0.17576007544994354,
-0.20100459456443787,
0.29069843888282776,
0.26910531520843506,
0.20822609961032867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05200v1 | Are LLMs Ready for Real-World Materials Discovery? | 2024-02-07T19:10:36 | 2024-02-07T19:10:36 | Santiago Miret, N M Anoop Krishnan | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) create exciting possibilities for powerful
language processing tools to accelerate research in materials science. While
LLMs have great potential to accelerate materials understanding and discovery,
they currently fall short in being practical materials science tools. In this
position paper, we show relevant failure cases of LLMs in materials science
that reveal current limitations of LLMs related to comprehending and reasoning
over complex, interconnected materials science knowledge. Given those
shortcomings, we outline a framework for developing Materials Science LLMs
(MatSci-LLMs) that are grounded in materials science knowledge and hypothesis
generation followed by hypothesis testing. The path to attaining performant
MatSci-LLMs rests in large part on building high-quality, multi-modal datasets
sourced from scientific literature where various information extraction
challenges persist. As such, we describe key materials science information
extraction challenges which need to be overcome in order to build large-scale,
multi-modal datasets that capture valuable materials science knowledge.
Finally, we outline a roadmap for applying future MatSci-LLMs for real-world
materials discovery via: 1. Automated Knowledge Base Generation; 2. Automated
In-Silico Material Design; and 3. MatSci-LLM Integrated Self-Driving Materials
Laboratories. | [
-0.17628450691699982,
-0.6291369795799255,
1.127256989479065,
-0.051685649901628494,
0.08108089119195938,
0.5020349025726318,
-0.06845037639141083,
-0.3717482089996338,
-0.15995614230632782,
0.17809008061885834,
-0.6854092478752136,
-0.3610299825668335,
-0.34746336936950684,
0.19659055769443512,
-0.21052700281143188,
0.4730405807495117,
-0.4103412926197052,
0.10890115797519684,
-0.6069538593292236,
0.40390029549598694,
-0.2244349867105484,
-0.40047428011894226,
-0.29463061690330505,
-0.36598485708236694,
0.3244897425174713,
0.6559481024742126,
0.3261900246143341,
0.6503396034240723,
0.4915207326412201,
0.2009061723947525,
-0.08406100422143936,
0.6377173066139221,
-0.034229885786771774,
0.24784639477729797,
-0.16258209943771362,
-0.6664522290229797,
-0.4172554612159729,
0.2972699701786041,
0.6547625064849854,
0.869580864906311,
-0.03553135693073273,
0.1109243854880333,
-0.11523701250553131,
0.3360899090766907,
-0.24867065250873566,
0.0684954971075058,
-0.49869504570961,
0.4977375268936157,
-0.3182859718799591,
-0.5301136374473572,
-0.439835786819458,
0.03999249264597893,
0.08823101967573166,
-0.695720911026001,
0.42423832416534424,
0.4358966648578644,
0.7551713585853577,
0.004600731655955315,
-0.45073243975639343,
-0.4581901431083679,
-0.7855933308601379,
0.9465939998626709,
-0.6178697347640991,
0.6340281963348389,
0.3451175093650818,
0.41689619421958923,
-0.4922151267528534,
-0.7131327986717224,
-0.49913811683654785,
-0.42171627283096313,
0.1755717545747757,
0.07286930829286575,
0.8247391581535339,
-0.1691715568304062,
0.20912235975265503,
0.39078381657600403,
-0.34977737069129944,
0.10759980231523514,
-0.42780250310897827,
-0.37382838129997253,
0.2351127564907074,
0.4619413912296295,
0.19687211513519287,
0.07684227079153061,
-0.41044116020202637,
-0.0442764014005661,
-1.028124213218689,
-0.432619571685791,
0.27257952094078064,
0.38223445415496826,
-0.04550992324948311,
0.7319030165672302,
0.03047151304781437,
0.20972371101379395,
-0.4829099178314209,
-0.29896682500839233,
0.19297514855861664,
-0.6823587417602539,
0.057463388890028,
-0.08579088747501373,
0.4847404658794403,
-0.09286729991436005,
0.1720898151397705,
-0.33903566002845764,
-0.3050912022590637,
-0.1857224553823471,
-0.03895683214068413,
-0.9118915796279907,
-0.00047539957449771464,
0.3667026460170746,
-0.33442872762680054,
-0.20365197956562042,
0.08938474953174591,
-0.5486530661582947,
-0.7279783487319946,
-0.49618983268737793,
0.1912466585636139,
-0.08650589734315872,
-0.5890375971794128,
0.19704219698905945,
-0.42350488901138306,
0.06725604087114334,
0.5688998699188232,
-0.7782272100448608,
0.3301486670970917,
0.601306140422821,
1.049359917640686,
-0.2650928497314453,
-0.43898966908454895,
-0.22918029129505157,
0.24488742649555206,
-0.4275161921977997,
0.9476405382156372,
-0.24951988458633423,
-0.5771207213401794,
-0.3032151758670807,
0.11500906944274902,
0.2744283676147461,
-0.7106527090072632,
0.3895054757595062,
-0.11452668905258179,
0.056043174117803574,
-0.5625230669975281,
-0.31249791383743286,
0.25233790278434753,
0.3178557753562927,
-0.48558586835861206,
0.7602320313453674,
-0.003885906655341387,
-0.6734699010848999,
0.3123335540294647,
-0.4372270107269287,
-0.4177783727645874,
-0.1070561632514,
-0.38950011134147644,
-0.38105934858322144,
0.1534275859594345,
-0.39670032262802124,
0.6792083382606506,
-0.8651909828186035,
0.5518205165863037,
-0.48385557532310486,
-0.22253353893756866,
0.5944044589996338,
-0.49656587839126587,
0.1596563756465912,
0.3166162371635437,
-0.2237236201763153,
-0.32050877809524536,
-0.8308846950531006,
-0.33238685131073,
0.2951374053955078,
-0.3804223835468292,
0.10013257712125778,
0.4782333970069885,
0.09254100173711777,
0.3562248647212982,
0.31566816568374634,
-0.8070017099380493,
0.03480615094304085,
-0.0864732563495636,
0.5231699347496033,
1.0697489976882935,
-0.21366062760353088,
0.4821262061595917,
-0.2593317925930023,
0.40405628085136414,
0.09478987753391266,
-0.1449330598115921,
-0.3004295229911804,
-0.031911447644233704,
-0.8156222701072693,
0.08756791055202484,
0.24234884977340698,
0.3772159814834595,
-0.4660537540912628,
0.07634047418832779,
-0.17250850796699524,
-0.6953256726264954,
-0.04329104349017143,
0.09593722224235535,
0.11491786688566208,
0.5917127728462219,
0.07365860790014267,
-0.07963109761476517,
-0.6112766861915588,
-0.7213247418403625,
-0.12385009229183197,
0.10907416045665741,
0.06682676076889038,
0.3191261887550354,
0.3844636082649231,
-0.0957706943154335,
1.1035399436950684,
-0.6572848558425903,
-0.32158467173576355,
-0.09968505799770355,
0.022571232169866562,
0.2997201383113861,
0.36820438504219055,
-0.13846208155155182,
-0.9501392245292664,
-0.082676462829113,
0.07506169378757477,
-1.1435017585754395,
0.1587323248386383,
0.053212568163871765,
0.2705451250076294,
-0.07101079821586609,
0.8586492538452148,
-0.4886229932308197,
-0.052672117948532104,
0.1301921308040619,
-0.14542506635189056,
0.6187083721160889,
-0.23863260447978973,
-0.06931662559509277,
-0.9753695130348206,
0.043641623109579086,
0.19750605523586273,
-0.03330013155937195,
-0.5565958023071289,
-0.29979750514030457,
-0.03524613752961159,
-0.389279842376709,
-0.6151025295257568,
0.7819342613220215,
-0.7654447555541992,
-0.46529150009155273,
-0.09461851418018341,
0.04598445072770119,
0.15407797694206238,
0.16060900688171387,
0.16577933728694916,
0.860313355922699,
0.4534417688846588,
-0.7897710800170898,
0.3240736424922943,
-0.1107056736946106,
-0.5128632187843323,
0.44899386167526245,
-0.4424644410610199,
-0.21647217869758606,
-0.06500153243541718,
0.3185681700706482,
-0.6140127778053284,
-0.3869243562221527,
0.045538146048784256,
-0.07073019444942474,
0.35051846504211426,
0.17193299531936646,
-0.7831043601036072,
-0.3361450731754303,
-0.21830475330352783,
0.2111806869506836,
0.06651733815670013,
-0.6145122051239014,
0.8075250387191772,
0.3568071126937866,
-0.34521156549453735,
-0.40247514843940735,
-0.7189205884933472,
0.06800413131713867,
-0.14974181354045868,
-0.5882487893104553,
0.24416199326515198,
-0.6821408867835999,
-0.37376803159713745,
-0.25515010952949524,
-0.43939727544784546,
0.15605340898036957,
0.5766544938087463,
0.2403039187192917,
0.15461915731430054,
-0.16398796439170837,
0.4079339802265167,
-0.20684374868869781,
-0.2446213960647583,
0.14441844820976257,
-0.02855549193918705,
0.6763371825218201,
-0.19279949367046356,
-0.5377092957496643,
-0.10412392765283585,
0.06826581805944443,
0.5036991834640503,
-0.03531668335199356,
0.13742700219154358,
0.3531859517097473,
-0.6145636439323425,
-0.44023311138153076,
-0.4826117157936096,
-0.353224515914917,
-0.5405915975570679,
0.5186974406242371,
-0.6722822785377502,
-0.6718118190765381,
0.4940999448299408,
-0.5388215184211731,
0.10317441821098328,
0.2135811150074005,
0.3345969021320343,
-0.23139391839504242,
0.8597069978713989,
0.5970810055732727,
0.4536197781562805,
0.19526055455207825,
-0.13913887739181519,
0.4373047649860382,
-0.7837055921554565,
-0.5477668642997742,
-0.3237345516681671,
0.1348128765821457,
-0.1576927900314331,
-0.3320799469947815,
0.5015838146209717,
-0.3124033212661743,
-0.10470904409885406,
0.05815940350294113,
-0.4504737854003906,
0.46682658791542053,
0.1264200061559677,
0.02559293620288372,
0.49579310417175293,
0.1434735506772995,
0.0007877959287725389,
-0.019809186458587646,
-0.6213104724884033,
-0.5860810279846191,
0.9424524903297424,
0.536302924156189,
0.9906632304191589,
-0.21929168701171875,
0.25697556138038635,
0.47921451926231384,
0.021496284753084183,
-0.6709786057472229,
0.7280893325805664,
0.18098697066307068,
-0.6447960138320923,
-0.0407060831785202,
-0.45857468247413635,
-0.5945909023284912,
0.22119300067424774,
-0.15072233974933624,
-0.014780107885599136,
0.29478883743286133,
-0.08785339444875717,
-0.25099751353263855,
0.37549281120300293,
-0.6264893412590027,
0.6110922694206238,
-0.6693778038024902,
-0.3070578873157501,
-0.0412542000412941,
-0.4984315037727356,
0.20305195450782776,
-0.2692488133907318,
0.8021278381347656,
-0.6189385652542114,
-0.11254272609949112,
0.7486603856086731,
-0.25773534178733826,
0.8336898684501648,
-0.08739977329969406,
-0.5163981318473816,
0.38887280225753784,
0.27726393938064575,
0.2679111957550049,
0.11579032242298126,
-0.34677577018737793,
-0.10094190388917923,
-0.07512414455413818,
-0.19880202412605286,
-0.20733192563056946,
0.7700074911117554,
-0.32559114694595337,
-0.5224953889846802,
-0.6185946464538574,
-0.5522587299346924,
-0.22038133442401886,
0.14592605829238892,
0.149640753865242,
0.5113376975059509,
-0.27396294474601746,
-0.056815702468156815,
0.8181459903717041,
0.04073859378695488,
0.322248637676239,
0.5271397233009338,
0.18306966125965118,
-0.010075102560222149,
1.7033690214157104,
0.4256632626056671,
0.18097741901874542,
0.09859886765480042,
0.20866550505161285,
-0.022986864671111107,
-0.7072328925132751,
-0.329630583524704,
0.2705753445625305,
-0.7531220316886902,
-0.2648879587650299,
-0.5005273818969727,
-0.3099122643470764,
-0.31897324323654175,
-0.3352757692337036,
-0.44420334696769714,
-0.3020956218242645,
-0.5564820766448975,
-0.23231598734855652,
0.04740360379219055,
0.9335790276527405,
-0.16675980389118195,
0.03782961145043373,
-0.7035943865776062,
0.37113234400749207,
0.0443371944129467,
0.4534711539745331,
-0.12198511511087418,
-0.29126545786857605,
-0.4943028688430786,
-0.03816022351384163,
-0.04695632681250572,
-0.4562491178512573,
0.2375556379556656,
-0.04190485179424286,
0.6358302235603333,
0.11604537814855576,
-0.2160625457763672,
0.27978286147117615,
-0.5205560922622681,
0.6304804086685181,
-0.02172807790338993,
-0.5116197466850281,
0.4383504092693329,
-0.4187910854816437,
-0.1984899789094925,
0.25540438294410706,
0.48837804794311523,
-0.31974121928215027,
0.14812138676643372,
-0.6058602929115295,
-0.7081052660942078,
0.7365403175354004,
-0.23043310642242432,
-0.1949589103460312,
0.08392175287008286,
0.1972409337759018,
0.282936155796051,
0.15072478353977203,
-0.7981677055358887,
-0.0562710165977478,
0.06886475533246994,
-0.22704505920410156,
0.052234962582588196,
-0.2022998183965683,
-0.28314515948295593,
0.3037613332271576,
0.8303443789482117,
-0.36200129985809326,
0.15598900616168976,
0.30152878165245056,
-0.21369382739067078,
-0.07656003534793854,
0.2524755597114563,
0.523483157157898,
0.643738865852356,
-0.5122912526130676,
0.3316315710544586,
0.15396539866924286,
-0.26940229535102844,
0.2815156579017639,
-0.04439021646976471,
0.05363564193248749,
-0.3074604868888855,
0.04070068523287773,
0.5321781039237976,
0.012178515084087849,
-1.0740249156951904,
0.30557888746261597,
0.04073471203446388,
-0.15840855240821838,
-0.6230316758155823,
-0.10495833307504654,
0.06122598424553871,
0.22754326462745667,
0.5384209752082825,
-0.10415582358837128,
0.009496137499809265,
-0.854001522064209,
0.07483911514282227,
0.5081599950790405,
-0.14601415395736694,
-0.2416294813156128,
0.3844369649887085,
0.20474277436733246,
-0.05589159578084946,
0.3030598759651184,
-0.26704785227775574,
-0.4122345447540283,
0.9150649905204773,
0.6381564736366272,
0.2995937764644623,
0.0752575621008873,
0.07960323244333267,
0.19388988614082336,
0.2553705871105194,
-0.3884417712688446,
0.051545750349760056,
-0.15784375369548798,
-0.6852174997329712,
-0.07608605921268463,
-0.4534803628921509,
-0.8749087452888489,
-0.12620966136455536,
0.01149370614439249,
0.4945806562900543,
-0.7007383704185486,
0.266428679227829,
-0.25389933586120605,
0.24990302324295044,
-0.1521710306406021,
0.5755758881568909,
0.14732946455478668,
0.8262889385223389,
-0.9549042582511902,
0.3835242688655853,
0.19356083869934082,
-0.2720268666744232,
-0.32119590044021606,
-0.5090424418449402,
0.1714119017124176,
-0.668110191822052,
0.7027156352996826,
0.14281964302062988,
-0.15142056345939636,
-0.17000629007816315,
-0.8096155524253845,
-1.1495158672332764,
1.4060122966766357,
0.27148252725601196,
-0.1882430911064148,
-0.2759879231452942,
0.17818042635917664,
0.11606340855360031,
-0.2664346396923065,
0.2513199746608734,
0.3409321904182434,
0.5890501737594604,
-0.005048420280218124,
-0.48850440979003906,
0.1327640414237976,
-0.1471947431564331,
-0.5047089457511902,
0.14938940107822418,
-0.7386347651481628,
0.9247719645500183,
-0.15162761509418488,
-0.41226163506507874,
0.09243204444646835,
0.8576390743255615,
0.502098798751831,
0.4487433433532715,
0.39287295937538147,
0.48989179730415344,
0.7131363749504089,
-0.17720632255077362,
0.877423107624054,
0.08501755446195602,
0.08360222727060318,
0.8298677206039429,
-0.5811657309532166,
0.526313841342926,
0.4005368947982788,
-0.16444534063339233,
0.3491649329662323,
0.9386414289474487,
-0.20281976461410522,
0.14419861137866974,
0.3325660526752472,
-0.34015682339668274,
-0.5258758664131165,
-0.44566041231155396,
-0.4514423608779907,
-0.0159282349050045,
0.881238579750061,
0.06284590810537338,
-0.16751307249069214,
0.09132804721593857,
-0.07744225859642029,
-0.08853212743997574,
-0.004887769930064678,
0.24451352655887604,
0.24729083478450775,
-0.36943864822387695,
0.1544654816389084,
0.07342635840177536,
0.7637970447540283,
-0.5738949775695801,
-0.17665131390094757,
-0.1643727719783783,
-0.044253867119550705,
-0.26551198959350586,
-0.8966089487075806,
0.025929711759090424,
-0.3072426915168762,
-0.2684182822704315,
-0.43526920676231384,
0.9439823031425476,
-0.14848855137825012,
-0.2640751898288727,
0.03385492414236069,
0.6743980646133423,
0.2665594816207886,
0.17376957833766937,
-0.2005295753479004,
0.07012535631656647,
-0.09956160932779312,
-0.3146804869174957,
0.5532100796699524,
0.39824622869491577,
-0.038124460726976395,
0.9726200699806213,
0.888923704624176,
0.08826535195112228,
-0.0013304621679708362,
-0.1570984274148941,
0.7661553621292114,
-0.7747470140457153,
0.07411904633045197,
-0.5324050784111023,
0.25541210174560547,
-0.12155356258153915,
0.00835504662245512,
0.6182644963264465,
0.8433759808540344,
0.5819966197013855,
0.002388610737398267,
0.8774113059043884,
0.06097521632909775,
0.7604836225509644,
-0.5739525556564331,
0.41984593868255615,
-0.6097038984298706,
0.4598631262779236,
0.13152872025966644,
-0.810702919960022,
-0.2654362618923187,
0.38947758078575134,
0.20010064542293549,
0.0012140980688855052,
0.7808853983879089,
0.7324618697166443,
-0.2637503743171692,
-0.12906621396541595,
0.16415368020534515,
0.35855263471603394,
0.603049635887146,
0.12703056633472443,
0.963347852230072,
-0.2943844199180603,
0.57069331407547,
-0.20607499778270721,
0.05867942422628403,
-0.03343115374445915,
-1.047610878944397,
-0.5481271147727966,
-0.6301615238189697,
-0.07725352048873901,
-0.39273926615715027,
-0.2635571360588074,
0.6869374513626099,
0.6504622101783752,
-0.3633972704410553,
-0.41934558749198914,
-0.5150785446166992,
0.267485111951828,
0.5325085520744324,
-0.22335392236709595,
0.26037994027137756,
-0.5015112161636353,
-0.728956937789917,
0.9191508889198303,
0.3597883880138397,
0.31252530217170715,
-0.3651033639907837,
-0.13191314041614532,
-0.14671960473060608,
0.17244982719421387,
0.44420573115348816,
0.5727573037147522,
-0.29601651430130005,
-0.0025384346954524517,
0.34470757842063904,
-0.20869341492652893,
0.13178876042366028,
0.8137246370315552,
-0.713488757610321,
0.18796664476394653,
0.5631032586097717,
0.6812118887901306,
0.5499395132064819,
-0.4653604030609131,
0.6139683723449707,
-0.5118926167488098,
0.0705307126045227,
0.22667761147022247,
0.624321460723877,
0.5926384925842285,
-0.21077820658683777,
0.794424295425415,
0.5150145888328552,
-0.5723166465759277,
-1.0348846912384033,
0.4830847978591919,
-1.0950831174850464,
-0.49446597695350647,
1.1831557750701904,
0.258793443441391,
-0.2630741000175476,
-0.1525697261095047,
-0.2682332694530487,
0.1620660126209259,
-0.0192561037838459,
0.3410611152648926,
0.6601981520652771,
0.04791102930903435,
0.06212683022022247,
-0.6634931564331055,
0.3691038489341736,
0.5871332883834839,
-1.055298924446106,
0.280656635761261,
0.2868439555168152,
0.34455618262290955,
0.36957862973213196,
0.5728088617324829,
-0.24360747635364532,
0.10625067353248596,
-0.0019289228366687894,
0.07662619650363922,
-0.21387851238250732,
-0.6576933860778809,
0.09630968421697617,
0.07664164900779724,
0.31533515453338623,
0.4545998275279999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05195v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05195v2 | $λ$-ECLIPSE: Multi-Concept Personalized Text-to-Image Diffusion Models by Leveraging CLIP Latent Space | 2024-02-07T19:07:10 | 2024-04-09T22:14:37 | Maitreya Patel, Sangmin Jung, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite the recent advances in personalized text-to-image (P-T2I) generative
models, it remains challenging to perform finetuning-free multi-subject-driven
T2I in a resource-efficient manner. Predominantly, contemporary approaches,
involving the training of Hypernetworks and Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs), require heavy computing resources that range from 600 to 12300 GPU
hours of training. These subject-driven T2I methods hinge on Latent Diffusion
Models (LDMs), which facilitate T2I mapping through cross-attention layers.
While LDMs offer distinct advantages, P-T2I methods' reliance on the latent
space of these diffusion models significantly escalates resource demands,
leading to inconsistent results and necessitating numerous iterations for a
single desired image. In this paper, we present $\lambda$-ECLIPSE, an
alternative prior-training strategy that works in the latent space of a
pre-trained CLIP model without relying on the diffusion UNet models.
$\lambda$-ECLIPSE leverages the image-text interleaved pre-training for fast
and effective multi-subject-driven P-T2I. Through extensive experiments, we
establish that $\lambda$-ECLIPSE surpasses existing baselines in composition
alignment while preserving concept alignment performance, even with
significantly lower resource utilization. $\lambda$-ECLIPSE performs
multi-subject driven P-T2I with just 34M parameters and is trained on a mere 74
GPU hours. Additionally, $\lambda$-ECLIPSE demonstrates the unique ability to
perform multi-concept interpolations. | [
-0.49086809158325195,
-0.5561054348945618,
0.749250590801239,
0.4271926283836365,
-0.5148711204528809,
0.2371644675731659,
-0.11762704700231552,
-0.1599140167236328,
0.3699837028980255,
0.5077716708183289,
-0.42411553859710693,
-0.5512393116950989,
-0.5501567125320435,
-0.2069573700428009,
-0.3049249053001404,
0.8294649124145508,
-0.06647312641143799,
-0.01823124848306179,
0.01646306924521923,
-0.06933654844760895,
0.07751354575157166,
-0.1558598428964615,
-0.6455940008163452,
0.2675049901008606,
0.5797753930091858,
0.3637852966785431,
0.3166332244873047,
0.3345879912376404,
0.29114195704460144,
0.12038920074701309,
-0.2542435824871063,
0.1688033491373062,
-0.2271205186843872,
-0.09233778715133667,
-0.147580087184906,
-0.287479966878891,
-0.3717202842235565,
0.02853117138147354,
0.43149492144584656,
0.5745877623558044,
0.1762562394142151,
0.07083070278167725,
0.21527090668678284,
0.487958163022995,
-1.0924930572509766,
-0.3491508364677429,
-0.37601155042648315,
0.23654136061668396,
-0.3447096645832062,
-0.1934058666229248,
-0.27247709035873413,
-0.22948209941387177,
0.424502432346344,
-1.156241536140442,
0.3721463084220886,
-0.10224390774965286,
0.6028637290000916,
0.32124966382980347,
-0.46538791060447693,
-0.022737227380275726,
-0.7951460480690002,
0.8041414022445679,
-0.4351884126663208,
0.26165831089019775,
0.11115605384111404,
0.1545754373073578,
0.3427881896495819,
-0.7404134273529053,
-0.5557844638824463,
0.2605499029159546,
0.3270294666290283,
0.6085157990455627,
0.30876344442367554,
0.044792983680963516,
-0.05231071263551712,
0.28383997082710266,
-0.38118618726730347,
0.15614794194698334,
-0.2805301249027252,
0.03877245634794235,
0.18724550306797028,
0.0244447011500597,
-0.010474097914993763,
-0.14237123727798462,
-0.5318481922149658,
0.08533341437578201,
-0.7214754223823547,
-0.11195037513971329,
0.19441598653793335,
-0.22552819550037384,
-0.19458016753196716,
0.6358861327171326,
0.27291545271873474,
0.2554806172847748,
0.22117462754249573,
-0.10390111058950424,
0.025196271017193794,
-0.5842583179473877,
-0.06881609559059143,
-0.159705251455307,
0.7937426567077637,
0.4264174997806549,
-0.1881297528743744,
-0.34998905658721924,
0.13698649406433105,
-0.05414605513215065,
0.10137462615966797,
-1.2052459716796875,
-0.3341743052005768,
0.29734283685684204,
-0.3276810050010681,
-0.07518382370471954,
-0.1244010478258133,
-0.9164408445358276,
-0.355451762676239,
-0.05424615740776062,
0.18955057859420776,
-0.5809479355812073,
-0.39039871096611023,
-0.11812538653612137,
-0.38722488284111023,
-0.029682185500860214,
0.6349430680274963,
-0.7068169713020325,
0.18527327477931976,
0.5304210186004639,
1.3397722244262695,
-0.3399665653705597,
-0.20993570983409882,
-0.30088716745376587,
0.5118997097015381,
-0.5514681935310364,
0.6655247807502747,
-0.5320537686347961,
-0.6610821485519409,
-0.15666693449020386,
-0.007397125940769911,
0.07322761416435242,
-0.39113521575927734,
0.5078150629997253,
-0.5573215484619141,
0.49449440836906433,
-0.2021218091249466,
-0.8577306866645813,
-0.06664934009313583,
-0.10616014897823334,
-0.5410233736038208,
0.8610740303993225,
0.08711051195859909,
-0.9530773162841797,
0.4256601929664612,
-0.8634154796600342,
-0.07390613108873367,
0.0030454308725893497,
-0.119493268430233,
-0.6296659708023071,
0.04218846932053566,
0.27404850721359253,
0.6725330948829651,
-0.32698068022727966,
0.052463795989751816,
-0.7533870935440063,
-0.3032347857952118,
-0.04642554372549057,
-0.23009096086025238,
0.4808524549007416,
0.055326756089925766,
-0.4157499372959137,
0.2411007434129715,
-0.7346972227096558,
-0.285658597946167,
-0.05563430115580559,
-0.019961446523666382,
-0.8757045865058899,
-0.2176189124584198,
0.3761872351169586,
0.4225577712059021,
0.14286790788173676,
-0.6608886122703552,
0.145757257938385,
-0.5594838857650757,
0.23692432045936584,
0.807399570941925,
0.12878233194351196,
0.9207607507705688,
-0.09971961379051208,
0.5746504664421082,
0.4088824987411499,
-0.15540003776550293,
-0.6064849495887756,
-0.4749234616756439,
-0.5904664993286133,
-0.5601242184638977,
0.15383461117744446,
0.42903560400009155,
-0.9141698479652405,
0.44097578525543213,
-0.14624130725860596,
-0.47513604164123535,
-0.47154703736305237,
-0.005824762862175703,
0.4206653833389282,
0.7308931946754456,
0.42497459053993225,
-0.5494937896728516,
-0.20032000541687012,
-0.8292931318283081,
0.26498642563819885,
0.45517873764038086,
-0.23187057673931122,
0.6060918569564819,
0.5160220265388489,
-0.1871090829372406,
0.9527570009231567,
-0.6452149748802185,
-0.40631383657455444,
0.2597298324108124,
0.2148529440164566,
-0.26271381974220276,
0.4902190864086151,
0.851532518863678,
-0.7336956858634949,
-0.5969573259353638,
-0.23741388320922852,
-0.5548564195632935,
0.11007164418697357,
-0.2380412071943283,
-0.2946333885192871,
0.13230539858341217,
0.44562628865242004,
-0.33484458923339844,
0.4669715166091919,
0.7232569456100464,
-0.4234124720096588,
0.4927363991737366,
-0.4688994586467743,
0.17819844186306,
-1.5220673084259033,
0.22140614688396454,
0.46601617336273193,
-0.18467453122138977,
-0.23076356947422028,
-0.1300293207168579,
0.3002755641937256,
-0.11889954656362534,
-0.7010895609855652,
0.8234032392501831,
-0.5427361726760864,
-0.2935377359390259,
-0.4243640899658203,
0.15452758967876434,
0.15562859177589417,
0.5589130520820618,
0.4004635810852051,
1.148391604423523,
0.8125932216644287,
-1.0450838804244995,
-0.08487594872713089,
0.17534703016281128,
-0.31382399797439575,
0.6689208149909973,
-0.6449670791625977,
0.2737142741680145,
-0.13400313258171082,
0.44309717416763306,
-0.9618383049964905,
0.06113608181476593,
0.3025886118412018,
0.13483045995235443,
0.0008467333391308784,
0.15078718960285187,
-0.32144662737846375,
-0.19871363043785095,
-0.7697587609291077,
0.7531903982162476,
0.32858043909072876,
-0.6742872595787048,
0.634839653968811,
0.2511102259159088,
-0.07101412117481232,
-0.5859100818634033,
-0.5075197815895081,
0.016536595299839973,
-0.46915823221206665,
-0.61043781042099,
1.066225528717041,
-0.12676846981048584,
0.27649736404418945,
0.3727695047855377,
0.11054389178752899,
-0.27828729152679443,
0.1536404937505722,
0.2952081263065338,
0.11356902122497559,
-0.2636471092700958,
0.12347929179668427,
0.3653807044029236,
-0.15153902769088745,
-0.4466670751571655,
-0.7023656368255615,
0.3490443229675293,
0.44693872332572937,
-0.22086815536022186,
-0.6688397526741028,
0.357333779335022,
0.4639945924282074,
-0.2845962345600128,
0.8850436806678772,
0.7698075175285339,
-0.2370430827140808,
0.0330200120806694,
-0.3564212918281555,
-0.08738087117671967,
-0.4039806127548218,
0.5870068669319153,
-0.48687005043029785,
-0.824118971824646,
0.29352664947509766,
-0.6053465604782104,
0.35578060150146484,
0.2447444200515747,
0.49988052248954773,
-0.3538438677787781,
0.5497278571128845,
0.8416503071784973,
0.15952442586421967,
0.875396192073822,
-0.6045602560043335,
-0.24391309916973114,
-1.6281245946884155,
-0.0201212577521801,
-0.13648739457130432,
-0.1726597249507904,
-0.12168381363153458,
-0.9271464943885803,
0.512829065322876,
0.061489999294281006,
-0.3349873125553131,
0.1479073017835617,
-0.5516765117645264,
0.4338296055793762,
0.4798569083213806,
0.22511211037635803,
0.11359166353940964,
-0.10310205072164536,
-0.08820848166942596,
-0.3364615738391876,
-0.38494953513145447,
-0.5158687829971313,
1.5698860883712769,
0.1704695075750351,
0.6776188611984253,
0.3466588854789734,
0.5227864980697632,
0.016216708347201347,
0.41098344326019287,
-0.5847946405410767,
0.4188990592956543,
-0.5340331196784973,
-0.32101988792419434,
-0.33015674352645874,
-0.036593977361917496,
-0.9768540859222412,
0.4744481146335602,
-0.14556476473808289,
-0.474250853061676,
0.1660001277923584,
0.19392795860767365,
-0.532549262046814,
0.38244307041168213,
-0.8623659014701843,
0.8072608113288879,
-0.19069842994213104,
-0.616025984287262,
-0.38022005558013916,
-0.3126470148563385,
0.5395380854606628,
-0.3768065869808197,
0.0015894131502136588,
-0.10674214363098145,
-0.7262077927589417,
0.7726649045944214,
-0.4582713842391968,
0.7208223342895508,
-0.26987817883491516,
-0.18559537827968597,
0.035766325891017914,
-0.14204683899879456,
0.2598554193973541,
0.2503357231616974,
0.08325506746768951,
-0.12435515969991684,
-0.3139133155345917,
-0.4291168749332428,
-0.6213648915290833,
0.6396033763885498,
-0.8161812424659729,
-0.45524659752845764,
-0.23801448941230774,
0.12607358396053314,
-0.06870687007904053,
0.017928525805473328,
0.7447460889816284,
0.20520831644535065,
-0.46281716227531433,
0.04195826128125191,
0.7304099798202515,
-0.48294752836227417,
0.6588608026504517,
0.36585739254951477,
-0.1273360550403595,
-0.5900262594223022,
0.8394732475280762,
-0.1470974087715149,
0.16218100488185883,
0.5175778269767761,
0.016096893697977066,
-0.4405643045902252,
-0.35196271538734436,
-0.5464319586753845,
0.35805001854896545,
-0.3094579875469208,
0.1372845619916916,
-0.8609251976013184,
0.1864854395389557,
-0.26287129521369934,
-0.28569725155830383,
-0.7593234181404114,
-0.4765898585319519,
-0.8604109883308411,
0.30813729763031006,
0.01667146384716034,
0.2124660164117813,
0.35295575857162476,
0.4666244685649872,
-0.6692702174186707,
0.39581751823425293,
0.2109009325504303,
0.3533630073070526,
0.08850657939910889,
-0.47280943393707275,
-0.259898841381073,
-0.35624241828918457,
-0.6764785647392273,
-1.0266497135162354,
0.19578951597213745,
0.3601078987121582,
0.05993257835507393,
0.42915579676628113,
-0.2179664522409439,
0.700968325138092,
-0.6147690415382385,
0.7897132635116577,
0.5778398513793945,
-1.0142698287963867,
0.47084784507751465,
-0.0030791950412094593,
0.3105804920196533,
0.1592683643102646,
0.38765859603881836,
-0.5137740969657898,
-0.5261201858520508,
-0.5949128866195679,
-1.1152342557907104,
0.7921425700187683,
0.15181498229503632,
0.11263421922922134,
0.4363500475883484,
0.5118584036827087,
0.1653365045785904,
0.24555464088916779,
-0.520693302154541,
-0.2758837640285492,
-0.4605569541454315,
-0.21465401351451874,
-0.2821919322013855,
-0.2926839590072632,
0.061994362622499466,
-0.14720411598682404,
0.7053108811378479,
-0.24672649800777435,
0.2009185552597046,
0.35115566849708557,
-0.056565552949905396,
0.23051072657108307,
0.1693979650735855,
0.6364127993583679,
0.2577614486217499,
0.03401746228337288,
-0.01948806457221508,
-0.17098815739154816,
-0.3998688757419586,
0.43665796518325806,
0.26971396803855896,
-0.2909904420375824,
0.08731851726770401,
0.05345931649208069,
1.0756802558898926,
0.2881564199924469,
-0.3076859712600708,
0.7638341188430786,
-0.17751747369766235,
-0.17898209393024445,
-0.4597679376602173,
-0.049593109637498856,
0.26091268658638,
0.1812209188938141,
0.22610847651958466,
0.28608816862106323,
0.21548376977443695,
-0.05927756428718567,
0.14422757923603058,
0.2326604723930359,
-0.0342838317155838,
-0.5586932301521301,
1.0957814455032349,
0.5417407155036926,
0.0515298917889595,
0.11696940660476685,
-0.2715669274330139,
-0.12938734889030457,
0.6104886531829834,
0.23416678607463837,
1.1148401498794556,
-0.15871532261371613,
0.4137014150619507,
0.2841288149356842,
-0.11133672297000885,
-0.04902059957385063,
-0.10685894638299942,
-0.29826605319976807,
-0.6832311153411865,
-0.4958273470401764,
-0.2221449911594391,
-0.537632405757904,
0.2855241596698761,
-0.08689062297344208,
0.3208019435405731,
-0.7375900745391846,
-0.1925337165594101,
0.3794473111629486,
-0.24461115896701813,
-0.5248791575431824,
0.16789530217647552,
0.06306149810552597,
0.7496041059494019,
-0.6016045808792114,
0.9468713402748108,
0.8125343322753906,
-0.29541972279548645,
-0.6343510746955872,
0.42480915784835815,
-0.1285281777381897,
-0.06372886151075363,
0.5921317338943481,
0.12949061393737793,
-0.043937329202890396,
-0.0748261958360672,
-0.19050300121307373,
-0.7644893527030945,
1.1518769264221191,
0.44476810097694397,
-0.6751644611358643,
-0.21975481510162354,
-0.4421728551387787,
0.4478209316730499,
-0.4519217908382416,
0.47905030846595764,
0.2179129719734192,
0.08994008600711823,
0.27982035279273987,
-0.5617397427558899,
-0.2048768848180771,
-0.014665143564343452,
0.416632741689682,
0.053585346788167953,
-0.8959409594535828,
0.9762516021728516,
-0.22535525262355804,
-0.29629576206207275,
0.27629658579826355,
0.8231284618377686,
0.2806813716888428,
0.40897664427757263,
0.5348241329193115,
0.5787438154220581,
0.8121063709259033,
0.09719230234622955,
0.9675337076187134,
-0.47557392716407776,
0.3136734366416931,
0.9315708875656128,
-0.39832207560539246,
0.578424870967865,
0.3536359965801239,
0.014537766575813293,
0.33955520391464233,
0.8792392611503601,
0.1448511928319931,
0.9200976490974426,
-0.15623371303081512,
-0.4710223376750946,
0.07407674193382263,
0.03892681002616882,
-0.2827146351337433,
0.0010409975657239556,
0.32381051778793335,
-0.3231586217880249,
-0.11488401144742966,
0.4688703417778015,
-0.21214932203292847,
-0.049820706248283386,
-0.07767985761165619,
0.7546950578689575,
0.014273835346102715,
-0.6024678349494934,
0.2157326489686966,
0.2640899419784546,
1.3359838724136353,
-0.35110193490982056,
0.24366027116775513,
-0.19897931814193726,
0.20082350075244904,
-0.07619450986385345,
-0.7470402121543884,
0.33598753809928894,
0.042603641748428345,
-0.05875164270401001,
-0.19788557291030884,
0.339019238948822,
-0.5137528777122498,
-0.28273507952690125,
0.23758594691753387,
0.3515680432319641,
0.017585856840014458,
-0.1539059430360794,
-0.7627403140068054,
-0.3406660854816437,
-0.2152610570192337,
-0.35529595613479614,
0.1418832689523697,
0.5592849254608154,
0.04209534823894501,
0.41077739000320435,
0.28695833683013916,
0.10181921720504761,
-0.011398693546652794,
-0.02127886563539505,
0.7208852171897888,
-0.6920347213745117,
-0.8293357491493225,
-0.7556481957435608,
0.3196955621242523,
-0.047603052109479904,
-0.6941151022911072,
0.5439359545707703,
0.9451698064804077,
0.574454665184021,
-0.21737024188041687,
0.7887440323829651,
0.2521582841873169,
0.5959765911102295,
-0.7739915251731873,
0.3014799654483795,
-0.9745616912841797,
0.19516080617904663,
-0.6425146460533142,
-0.9625609517097473,
0.05477305129170418,
0.326109379529953,
-0.18334037065505981,
-0.02597941644489765,
0.7837322950363159,
0.5077908635139465,
-0.2616448998451233,
-0.14113666117191315,
0.11518730968236923,
-0.17888066172599792,
0.6619055867195129,
0.7556201219558716,
0.7146072387695312,
-0.22271506488323212,
0.31007200479507446,
-0.348647803068161,
-0.32620319724082947,
-0.15387850999832153,
-0.6989272832870483,
-0.7814616560935974,
-0.8865497708320618,
-0.670958399772644,
-0.14370222389698029,
-0.30109813809394836,
0.6317554116249084,
1.093592643737793,
-0.4284203052520752,
0.12729047238826752,
-0.35960739850997925,
-0.041222523897886276,
0.020739812403917313,
-0.17021332681179047,
0.7798066139221191,
-0.05302775278687477,
-1.0966484546661377,
0.057965945452451706,
0.6817996501922607,
0.4595468044281006,
-0.44089069962501526,
-0.12211494892835617,
0.13060486316680908,
0.042028896510601044,
0.5787122845649719,
0.18600040674209595,
-0.7011938691139221,
0.12425357848405838,
0.017045993357896805,
-0.3698453903198242,
0.23261190950870514,
0.9779151082038879,
-0.7714055180549622,
0.342172771692276,
0.038641806691884995,
0.9142565727233887,
0.9853641390800476,
-0.014324399642646313,
0.3293694853782654,
-0.9498243927955627,
0.773830771446228,
0.24491074681282043,
0.26269403100013733,
0.3268634080886841,
-0.3376304507255554,
0.43068909645080566,
0.4194418489933014,
-0.22738060355186462,
-0.35975295305252075,
0.16560667753219604,
-0.9110986590385437,
-0.6174113154411316,
0.9738172888755798,
-0.3085384964942932,
-0.17966488003730774,
0.028924783691763878,
-0.4593694806098938,
0.1094280257821083,
-0.5728912949562073,
0.7778376936912537,
0.6981461644172668,
-0.0807376354932785,
-0.4772324860095978,
-0.11199147999286652,
0.6038128733634949,
0.6744146943092346,
-1.017289638519287,
-0.3729861080646515,
0.364450603723526,
0.22199298441410065,
0.2710476815700531,
1.0673776865005493,
0.0770331546664238,
0.2830285131931305,
-0.30678436160087585,
-0.0017029624432325363,
0.16933473944664001,
-0.34734582901000977,
-0.18776515126228333,
0.3463455140590668,
-0.15947583317756653,
-0.5823125839233398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05188v1 | InCoRo: In-Context Learning for Robotics Control with Feedback Loops | 2024-02-07T19:01:11 | 2024-02-07T19:01:11 | Jiaqiang Ye Zhu, Carla Gomez Cano, David Vazquez Bermudez, Michal Drozdzal | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | One of the challenges in robotics is to enable robotic units with the
reasoning capability that would be robust enough to execute complex tasks in
dynamic environments. Recent advances in LLMs have positioned them as go-to
tools for simple reasoning tasks, motivating the pioneering work of Liang et
al. [35] that uses an LLM to translate natural language commands into low-level
static execution plans for robotic units. Using LLMs inside robotics systems
brings their generalization to a new level, enabling zero-shot generalization
to new tasks. This paper extends this prior work to dynamic environments. We
propose InCoRo, a system that uses a classical robotic feedback loop composed
of an LLM controller, a scene understanding unit, and a robot. Our system
continuously analyzes the state of the environment and provides adapted
execution commands, enabling the robot to adjust to changing environmental
conditions and correcting for controller errors. Our system does not require
any iterative optimization to learn to accomplish a task as it leverages
in-context learning with an off-the-shelf LLM model. Through an extensive
validation process involving two standardized industrial robotic units -- SCARA
and DELTA types -- we contribute knowledge about these robots, not popular in
the community, thereby enriching it. We highlight the generalization
capabilities of our system and show that (1) in-context learning in combination
with the current state-of-the-art LLMs is an effective way to implement a
robotic controller; (2) in static environments, InCoRo surpasses the prior art
in terms of the success rate; (3) in dynamic environments, we establish new
state-of-the-art for the SCARA and DELTA units, respectively. This research
paves the way towards building reliable, efficient, intelligent autonomous
systems that adapt to dynamic environments. | [
-0.054875630885362625,
-0.7427980303764343,
0.6842942833900452,
-0.089981310069561,
-0.2023354321718216,
0.15659505128860474,
-0.12823434174060822,
-0.46868783235549927,
0.01921107806265354,
0.3321644067764282,
-0.678466796875,
-0.5316331386566162,
-0.2651042342185974,
0.17466071248054504,
-0.05367307737469673,
0.9097752571105957,
-0.2785114347934723,
-0.12108699232339859,
0.04887105152010918,
-0.35304325819015503,
-0.4343540370464325,
-0.4295758008956909,
-0.5114786624908447,
-0.5950897932052612,
0.4429185092449188,
0.5794818997383118,
0.30635085701942444,
0.530389666557312,
0.3474264144897461,
0.27717384696006775,
-0.0725526288151741,
0.3769007623195648,
-0.49248263239860535,
0.26305070519447327,
-0.3196539878845215,
-0.43144291639328003,
-0.20210839807987213,
-0.39883413910865784,
0.48101606965065,
0.5233254432678223,
-0.24331849813461304,
-0.09371843189001083,
0.09129873663187027,
0.41017094254493713,
-0.7183327674865723,
0.05215876176953316,
-0.578870415687561,
0.5064521431922913,
0.3637969195842743,
-0.4599616229534149,
-0.19920384883880615,
-0.286704421043396,
0.028093159198760986,
-0.860080897808075,
-0.2727607190608978,
-0.21734412014484406,
0.7405948042869568,
0.5059237480163574,
-0.5774092078208923,
-0.6764169931411743,
-0.9888381361961365,
0.7198056578636169,
-0.4929894804954529,
0.2066078931093216,
-0.23123544454574585,
0.42165642976760864,
-0.47258877754211426,
-0.6040509939193726,
-0.5073115825653076,
-0.43194565176963806,
0.06872611492872238,
0.4674229621887207,
-0.0019006980583071709,
0.19693294167518616,
0.20283102989196777,
0.06753495335578918,
-0.22854891419410706,
0.26677587628364563,
-0.27181532979011536,
0.11183471977710724,
0.34456413984298706,
0.26709410548210144,
0.1457246094942093,
-0.08697013556957245,
-0.9322410225868225,
-0.16155803203582764,
-0.7647866606712341,
0.4507945775985718,
0.2618730366230011,
0.3261882960796356,
-0.2574441730976105,
0.2513859272003174,
-0.4536357820034027,
0.7290586829185486,
0.1521606296300888,
-0.5385505557060242,
0.042401671409606934,
-0.2128291130065918,
-0.517352283000946,
-0.04275226220488548,
0.4985598027706146,
0.08839885145425797,
0.01986880600452423,
-0.05409620702266693,
-0.2932707965373993,
-0.17386119067668915,
0.42551523447036743,
-0.21935027837753296,
-0.06385627388954163,
0.08411634713411331,
-0.2486724853515625,
-0.08776070177555084,
0.15089747309684753,
-0.7170143723487854,
-0.32608506083488464,
-0.5678794980049133,
0.4941774904727936,
-0.32543283700942993,
0.1689315140247345,
-0.19818101823329926,
-0.061644699424505234,
0.3226296901702881,
0.8015837669372559,
-0.5913470387458801,
0.048312678933143616,
0.3537600040435791,
0.885917603969574,
-0.06559135019779205,
-0.28852081298828125,
-0.6806883215904236,
0.5927304625511169,
-0.6442193388938904,
0.7595010995864868,
-0.41948407888412476,
-0.3313503563404083,
0.21305875480175018,
-0.020082887262105942,
0.09210193157196045,
-0.8599827885627747,
0.03167406842112541,
-0.4780031740665436,
-0.020718099549412727,
0.24246202409267426,
-0.23925070464611053,
-0.5339760184288025,
0.36200135946273804,
-0.050938863307237625,
0.8230031728744507,
0.351492315530777,
0.10426812618970871,
0.455885112285614,
-0.7127767205238342,
-0.5229861736297607,
0.04039373993873596,
-0.12451694160699844,
-0.07987741380929947,
-0.12800957262516022,
-0.21630489826202393,
0.3286292552947998,
0.14694200456142426,
0.19162243604660034,
-0.5756043791770935,
-0.6019091010093689,
0.1751151978969574,
-0.03859548643231392,
0.5021609663963318,
0.3169519305229187,
-0.45214393734931946,
0.6104260683059692,
-0.5607330203056335,
-0.027315163984894753,
-0.3159927725791931,
-0.48610398173332214,
-0.041921112686395645,
-0.0252662505954504,
-0.5293461680412292,
0.20036356151103973,
0.29178473353385925,
-0.20722781121730804,
0.27120962738990784,
-0.24265652894973755,
0.4383256733417511,
0.8463179469108582,
0.02154264785349369,
0.6250082850456238,
-0.16605867445468903,
0.8371787667274475,
-0.38588204979896545,
0.14867787063121796,
-0.4968476891517639,
-0.12610788643360138,
-0.8662396669387817,
-0.35849690437316895,
-0.19426004588603973,
0.7519002556800842,
-0.9122248888015747,
0.5084763169288635,
0.29062581062316895,
-0.22693666815757751,
0.16471657156944275,
0.5100401043891907,
0.43053528666496277,
0.6370114088058472,
0.3874562978744507,
-0.17420694231987,
-0.4491141438484192,
-0.5215144753456116,
0.19363915920257568,
-0.0017090169712901115,
-0.57622230052948,
0.48396846652030945,
0.41784706711769104,
-0.29832038283348083,
0.6733168363571167,
-0.12142470479011536,
-0.524033784866333,
-0.23700915277004242,
-0.1998121738433838,
0.42889049649238586,
0.3686182200908661,
0.3658207952976227,
-0.4647480249404907,
-0.21752451360225677,
0.3284022808074951,
-1.2037798166275024,
0.07093004137277603,
-0.2737467586994171,
-0.1914234608411789,
0.16004730761051178,
0.6305539608001709,
-0.2138460874557495,
0.3600216507911682,
0.40024274587631226,
0.02698187157511711,
0.169224813580513,
-0.5597749948501587,
-0.20992065966129303,
-0.4644384980201721,
0.05478743836283684,
0.07903718948364258,
-0.22747454047203064,
-0.37249499559402466,
0.5234335064888,
-0.1137005016207695,
0.016645656898617744,
-0.5426450967788696,
0.33375248312950134,
-0.20825091004371643,
-0.14968790113925934,
-0.3848027288913727,
0.2083439826965332,
-0.18380102515220642,
0.8228123784065247,
0.042037367820739746,
0.41091349720954895,
0.36174827814102173,
-1.204866647720337,
0.7214577198028564,
-0.08434070646762848,
-0.4483058750629425,
0.6145151853561401,
-0.580168604850769,
0.32099297642707825,
0.11217019706964493,
0.5994212627410889,
-0.7176343202590942,
-0.5273615717887878,
0.7364393472671509,
-0.16880665719509125,
0.17327873408794403,
0.023356713354587555,
-0.488105446100235,
-0.17355819046497345,
-0.25229763984680176,
-0.05904587730765343,
0.3956640958786011,
-0.7703939080238342,
0.5449047088623047,
0.34350964426994324,
0.3158724009990692,
-0.4242318272590637,
-0.5979578495025635,
-0.2097158133983612,
-0.3944474160671234,
-0.1417974829673767,
0.04297530651092529,
-0.18095020949840546,
-0.28914958238601685,
-0.16686299443244934,
-0.1956072598695755,
-0.18445871770381927,
0.37117940187454224,
0.11120012402534485,
0.19579696655273438,
0.0502157099545002,
0.29383447766304016,
0.35619089007377625,
-0.0852753296494484,
-0.08079929649829865,
-0.23658563196659088,
0.4242613911628723,
-0.10214193910360336,
-0.16300490498542786,
-0.6428573727607727,
-0.10400864481925964,
0.3269414007663727,
0.3942253887653351,
0.27897173166275024,
0.1314769834280014,
-0.3241784870624542,
-0.6621132493019104,
0.15334375202655792,
-0.20220796763896942,
-0.5364845395088196,
0.18264995515346527,
-0.41187745332717896,
-0.8389215469360352,
0.390225350856781,
-0.4870745539665222,
-0.06221602112054825,
0.12340190261602402,
0.4943329989910126,
-0.5699616074562073,
0.4139115512371063,
0.9230104088783264,
0.18962016701698303,
0.5915274620056152,
-0.43115314841270447,
0.11036742478609085,
-0.90151047706604,
-0.5271655917167664,
-0.0879109799861908,
-0.722602903842926,
-0.40537285804748535,
-0.45306357741355896,
0.7937547564506531,
0.3257328271865845,
-0.7182933688163757,
0.3322441577911377,
-0.7038482427597046,
0.2321576625108719,
0.6895807981491089,
0.3284653127193451,
0.30418866872787476,
-0.12038514018058777,
-0.13793005049228668,
0.46871939301490784,
-0.971893846988678,
-0.6661998629570007,
0.7361255288124084,
0.13065527379512787,
0.7883009910583496,
0.07105927914381027,
0.34307119250297546,
0.3469463288784027,
0.3427201211452484,
-0.8551524877548218,
0.42350271344184875,
0.03226076439023018,
-0.32575854659080505,
-0.29556623101234436,
-0.31741252541542053,
-0.9603743553161621,
0.2420482486486435,
0.1275307834148407,
-0.7667698860168457,
0.2976762652397156,
0.31003254652023315,
-0.6637440919876099,
0.41188034415245056,
-0.5566746592521667,
0.52217036485672,
-0.3898349106311798,
-0.27811741828918457,
-0.3532206416130066,
-0.8203189969062805,
0.4235360324382782,
0.08840526640415192,
0.14592286944389343,
-0.20499268174171448,
-0.4067457616329193,
0.06979319453239441,
-0.2967163324356079,
0.9506301879882812,
-0.1865987330675125,
-0.4394852817058563,
0.626090943813324,
0.14273659884929657,
0.293769508600235,
0.3324936628341675,
-0.13101844489574432,
0.15649348497390747,
-0.3128518760204315,
0.00479571707546711,
-0.7333781123161316,
0.6736910939216614,
-0.6551739573478699,
-0.36013472080230713,
-0.48060142993927,
-0.6748144626617432,
0.10842184722423553,
-0.06661342084407806,
0.11102249473333359,
0.24568164348602295,
0.20462483167648315,
0.37722039222717285,
0.5947792530059814,
-0.4203287363052368,
0.4717850387096405,
0.6798114776611328,
-0.1547808051109314,
-0.31539884209632874,
0.6118320822715759,
0.1574142724275589,
0.24249595403671265,
0.7754075527191162,
0.03177442401647568,
0.06015073508024216,
-0.14291322231292725,
-0.6624232530593872,
-0.2801496386528015,
-0.7806904315948486,
-0.576433539390564,
-0.18196499347686768,
-0.0007141715614125133,
0.006875414401292801,
-0.7831434011459351,
-0.11374292522668839,
0.012695711106061935,
-0.42448413372039795,
-0.015972720459103584,
0.3166581690311432,
1.0526446104049683,
-0.2986489236354828,
0.3093424141407013,
-0.46687087416648865,
0.23041656613349915,
0.425449937582016,
0.27128976583480835,
-0.04667486250400543,
-0.5462992191314697,
-0.13044266402721405,
0.08899891376495361,
-0.6464375257492065,
-0.626589298248291,
0.32210230827331543,
0.1448247730731964,
0.5795862078666687,
0.5971584320068359,
0.11942099779844284,
0.5638363361358643,
-0.21838964521884918,
0.6635964512825012,
-0.05951284244656563,
-1.1199294328689575,
0.8526932597160339,
-0.48309847712516785,
0.36996716260910034,
0.3090195059776306,
0.31105461716651917,
-0.46211546659469604,
-0.3698270320892334,
-0.3691663146018982,
-0.765807569026947,
0.7225544452667236,
-0.31855034828186035,
0.30498263239860535,
0.24594445526599884,
0.7976409792900085,
0.3681304156780243,
0.260025292634964,
-0.6473851203918457,
-0.06042461469769478,
0.023008722811937332,
0.04008909687399864,
0.10920077562332153,
0.047581952065229416,
-0.29773855209350586,
-0.24317844212055206,
0.3909790515899658,
-0.5874521136283875,
0.34978625178337097,
0.29358750581741333,
-0.03887353837490082,
-0.3864148259162903,
-0.05273551866412163,
0.7330238223075867,
0.8186622858047485,
-0.18431687355041504,
0.06611894071102142,
0.7279222011566162,
0.17398568987846375,
0.34501519799232483,
-0.521228015422821,
-0.35482650995254517,
-0.2324373722076416,
0.37838175892829895,
0.6159172654151917,
0.6141230463981628,
-0.8716030716896057,
0.035502173006534576,
0.5191383957862854,
0.05508358031511307,
-0.5219716429710388,
0.6448062062263489,
-0.29932016134262085,
0.41210681200027466,
0.33392778038978577,
0.22429117560386658,
0.05729445442557335,
-0.8500450253486633,
0.1989319622516632,
0.31532371044158936,
-0.5059881806373596,
-0.490918904542923,
0.4823929965496063,
0.22061382234096527,
-0.3119862973690033,
0.3011302053928375,
-0.2718851566314697,
-0.39941132068634033,
1.0989189147949219,
0.4413824677467346,
0.5967711210250854,
-0.12935827672481537,
0.2331145703792572,
0.512610673904419,
0.39775943756103516,
0.15024331212043762,
0.17560988664627075,
-0.48038312792778015,
-0.8189613223075867,
-0.17113418877124786,
-0.32922330498695374,
-1.0526047945022583,
0.05320482701063156,
-0.39675402641296387,
0.26327237486839294,
-1.1832170486450195,
0.32656019926071167,
-0.8181425333023071,
-0.1459914892911911,
-0.50656658411026,
0.3347257971763611,
0.21756543219089508,
0.549750030040741,
-0.30323708057403564,
0.9528815150260925,
0.8665720224380493,
-0.24016734957695007,
-0.567654013633728,
0.11874788999557495,
0.07033367455005646,
-0.6977375745773315,
0.7810512185096741,
0.15100859105587006,
-0.695956289768219,
-0.42969658970832825,
-0.871142566204071,
-1.1050617694854736,
1.2567938566207886,
0.5503940582275391,
-0.38769057393074036,
0.382159948348999,
-0.5037518739700317,
0.785733699798584,
-0.5869886875152588,
0.170035719871521,
0.21289017796516418,
0.43463748693466187,
-0.0012671960284933448,
-0.7486883997917175,
-0.16750827431678772,
-0.08487316220998764,
0.07270577549934387,
-0.09869594871997833,
-1.1406900882720947,
0.7601943016052246,
-0.31796157360076904,
-0.3187352418899536,
0.25245264172554016,
0.7855458855628967,
0.5801355242729187,
0.5850062370300293,
0.3680577278137207,
0.32283058762550354,
0.8236175775527954,
0.004883245564997196,
1.2668317556381226,
-0.16641733050346375,
0.24991288781166077,
1.1840131282806396,
-0.49839702248573303,
0.75491863489151,
0.14039792120456696,
-0.17080499231815338,
1.1353940963745117,
0.6221441030502319,
0.1419694721698761,
0.7278334498405457,
0.3059704601764679,
-0.32908543944358826,
-0.08851130306720734,
-0.08643326908349991,
-0.17888674139976501,
0.5561082363128662,
0.5479732155799866,
0.04638567566871643,
-0.12558823823928833,
0.25586435198783875,
-0.06932901591062546,
0.27219322323799133,
-0.3157721161842346,
0.7340777516365051,
0.04867693781852722,
-0.46348464488983154,
0.36681535840034485,
-0.05648316815495491,
0.8975892066955566,
-0.9066448211669922,
-0.1408042311668396,
-0.32461366057395935,
0.5598518252372742,
-0.14515507221221924,
-0.7229466438293457,
0.4132953882217407,
-0.0211341455578804,
0.12949395179748535,
-0.36513325572013855,
0.6656901836395264,
-0.29960012435913086,
-0.08510340750217438,
0.6969347596168518,
0.06676523387432098,
0.14722540974617004,
0.4003131687641144,
-0.3534216582775116,
0.040036391466856,
-0.07040427625179291,
-0.1157597005367279,
0.3006441593170166,
0.562979519367218,
0.16065828502178192,
1.1061443090438843,
0.33409538865089417,
-0.34389322996139526,
-0.05887645483016968,
-0.5032976269721985,
0.699597179889679,
-0.6092764139175415,
-0.2567048966884613,
-0.4676319360733032,
0.28493645787239075,
0.28013068437576294,
-0.6505883932113647,
0.8446276187896729,
0.257137268781662,
1.2661309242248535,
-0.019051339477300644,
0.7560648322105408,
0.0037183461245149374,
0.35068002343177795,
-0.6658989191055298,
0.374018132686615,
-0.7785663604736328,
0.1520465463399887,
0.0755382627248764,
-0.7337459325790405,
-0.41608309745788574,
0.8907423615455627,
-0.055812202394008636,
0.15675349533557892,
0.5335098505020142,
0.4430478513240814,
0.09776628762483597,
-0.35699760913848877,
0.4597983658313751,
0.20362767577171326,
0.19021321833133698,
0.7800300121307373,
0.9876930713653564,
-0.2052348107099533,
0.5220911502838135,
-0.4520467221736908,
-0.2620767056941986,
-0.2600799798965454,
-0.8677181601524353,
-0.3734072744846344,
-0.09843797981739044,
-0.2074335217475891,
-0.03154708445072174,
0.17117314040660858,
1.0573276281356812,
0.7499977350234985,
-0.8302889466285706,
-0.7325636148452759,
-0.27603384852409363,
0.5583890080451965,
-0.4287956655025482,
-0.23235972225666046,
-0.12955652177333832,
-0.7782164216041565,
-0.8835102319717407,
1.1417579650878906,
0.6544883847236633,
-0.4052712321281433,
-0.3494590222835541,
-0.35298678278923035,
-0.14985151588916779,
-0.040647100657224655,
0.6762790083885193,
0.6087667346000671,
-0.6878225207328796,
-0.5145132541656494,
-0.12784819304943085,
-0.04086099565029144,
0.28720223903656006,
0.720881998538971,
-1.2404431104660034,
0.5941357016563416,
0.39772137999534607,
0.23053862154483795,
0.30935174226760864,
-0.2514728307723999,
0.693849503993988,
-0.6193326115608215,
0.365705281496048,
0.06052398681640625,
0.34485605359077454,
0.2109554260969162,
-0.5132235884666443,
0.8408157229423523,
0.2771728038787842,
-0.5221378207206726,
-0.5910114645957947,
0.25799548625946045,
-0.8839372396469116,
-0.37419843673706055,
0.9184951186180115,
-0.3583119511604309,
-0.03634338080883026,
-0.027776846662163734,
-0.1058136522769928,
0.3358490765094757,
-0.5636008977890015,
0.953534722328186,
0.32156363129615784,
-0.5207406282424927,
-0.10255709290504456,
-0.44486719369888306,
0.14369340240955353,
0.23585228621959686,
-1.0775967836380005,
-0.4737418293952942,
0.35931524634361267,
0.16740097105503082,
0.21250171959400177,
0.306658536195755,
0.2436557561159134,
0.3364395797252655,
-0.2093978226184845,
0.2262965589761734,
0.15381205081939697,
-0.6656464338302612,
-0.6606789827346802,
0.4203537702560425,
-0.43091437220573425,
-0.24743275344371796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05111v1 | Edu-ConvoKit: An Open-Source Library for Education Conversation Data | 2024-02-07T18:59:31 | 2024-02-07T18:59:31 | Rose E. Wang, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce Edu-ConvoKit, an open-source library designed to handle
pre-processing, annotation and analysis of conversation data in education.
Resources for analyzing education conversation data are scarce, making the
research challenging to perform and therefore hard to access. We address these
challenges with Edu-ConvoKit. Edu-ConvoKit is open-source
(https://github.com/stanfordnlp/edu-convokit ), pip-installable
(https://pypi.org/project/edu-convokit/ ), with comprehensive documentation
(https://edu-convokit.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ ). Our demo video is available
at: https://youtu.be/zdcI839vAko?si=h9qlnl76ucSuXb8- . We include additional
resources, such as Colab applications of Edu-ConvoKit to three diverse
education datasets and a repository of Edu-ConvoKit related papers, that can be
found in our GitHub repository. | [
-0.5046951174736023,
-0.985958456993103,
0.11481376737356186,
0.04188132286071777,
0.0036448438186198473,
0.3833840787410736,
-0.3373463451862335,
-0.3226902484893799,
0.19086728990077972,
0.3283792734146118,
-0.6413038372993469,
-0.5893783569335938,
-0.5248076319694519,
-0.44818028807640076,
-0.41690751910209656,
0.8073185682296753,
0.19515106081962585,
0.1813741773366928,
-0.7886696457862854,
0.06902258098125458,
-0.4698902368545532,
-0.5152909755706787,
-0.6746575236320496,
-0.39728376269340515,
0.1689291000366211,
1.0887811183929443,
0.4982808232307434,
0.061036862432956696,
0.5775356888771057,
0.23459599912166595,
0.09363414347171783,
-0.1283576339483261,
-0.744223415851593,
0.3938811123371124,
-0.12267782539129257,
-0.13684003055095673,
-0.44206932187080383,
0.2218259572982788,
0.6039299964904785,
0.8374048471450806,
-0.5025585293769836,
0.25362643599510193,
0.5026271939277649,
0.867287278175354,
-0.7812098264694214,
0.3012341260910034,
-0.4101785719394684,
-0.18666960299015045,
-0.33117324113845825,
-0.06923389434814453,
-0.4955275356769562,
-0.5555102229118347,
0.47264355421066284,
-0.8269543051719666,
0.12331989407539368,
-0.3617313802242279,
0.5511666536331177,
0.28412237763404846,
-0.04387171193957329,
-0.4152247905731201,
-0.6439802050590515,
0.5525320768356323,
-0.18857799470424652,
0.5755565166473389,
0.5969808101654053,
0.6125349402427673,
-0.4668508768081665,
-1.0829168558120728,
-0.40843304991722107,
0.33653998374938965,
-0.005004243925213814,
0.29694005846977234,
-0.2479778230190277,
0.32299453020095825,
0.12695036828517914,
0.3319579064846039,
-0.6096153855323792,
-0.015070117078721523,
-0.6759118437767029,
-0.006984560750424862,
0.24103714525699615,
0.08957697451114655,
0.21535342931747437,
0.1139039471745491,
-0.08793216943740845,
-0.18133895099163055,
-0.38489654660224915,
0.36609014868736267,
0.6047267913818359,
0.21986472606658936,
-0.29778027534484863,
0.5090042948722839,
-0.23347239196300507,
0.5511760115623474,
-0.39914923906326294,
0.22441032528877258,
0.2503374218940735,
-0.30031657218933105,
-0.28915509581565857,
0.3741500675678253,
1.0159912109375,
0.2174200415611267,
0.08606945723295212,
0.326185017824173,
0.4888838529586792,
0.19496409595012665,
0.12343338876962662,
-1.1149725914001465,
-0.8356234431266785,
0.4294048547744751,
-0.2393784373998642,
-0.1497998982667923,
-0.05928223580121994,
-1.1418848037719727,
-0.3675173223018646,
-0.12255138903856277,
0.08975770324468613,
-0.39325979351997375,
-0.4230692684650421,
0.023489896208047867,
-0.10700631886720657,
0.01510363258421421,
0.45383572578430176,
-0.6733807325363159,
0.30117908120155334,
0.870508074760437,
0.9200356602668762,
-0.1407129019498825,
-0.034091487526893616,
-0.31953901052474976,
-0.34955543279647827,
-0.02255113422870636,
0.6008603572845459,
-0.9897915720939636,
-0.786532998085022,
0.3402554988861084,
-0.061267782002687454,
0.03880564123392105,
-0.5030788779258728,
0.7332809567451477,
0.029247570782899857,
0.516044020652771,
0.1347332000732422,
-0.6839035153388977,
0.11062934249639511,
0.2130075991153717,
-0.6333890557289124,
1.1574527025222778,
-0.0038304293993860483,
-0.6640461683273315,
0.0729784220457077,
-1.1366617679595947,
-0.20675314962863922,
0.5238277316093445,
-0.37964919209480286,
-0.28820177912712097,
-0.4999850392341614,
0.28951147198677063,
0.32986924052238464,
-0.4453756511211395,
0.9130186438560486,
-0.3358132243156433,
-0.39088279008865356,
0.1932070553302765,
-0.6516914367675781,
1.280290961265564,
0.34756147861480713,
0.11175400018692017,
0.06458056718111038,
-0.8932570219039917,
-0.09376797080039978,
-0.09931917488574982,
-0.278230756521225,
-0.5266258120536804,
0.05250249803066254,
-0.09928184002637863,
-0.2702944576740265,
0.270905464887619,
-0.7079669237136841,
0.42093461751937866,
-0.16379539668560028,
0.35415998101234436,
0.6174896359443665,
-0.40125495195388794,
0.565941572189331,
0.11771394312381744,
0.4685346186161041,
0.020259428769350052,
0.581317126750946,
-0.4508204460144043,
-0.7260209918022156,
-0.47485587000846863,
-0.17720864713191986,
0.05009901523590088,
0.35298335552215576,
-1.0026562213897705,
0.10457253456115723,
-0.2716832756996155,
-0.8058540225028992,
-1.026591420173645,
-0.2308940440416336,
-0.01681464910507202,
0.7022505402565002,
0.32745057344436646,
-0.20648126304149628,
-0.6801295280456543,
-0.5535595417022705,
0.18733300268650055,
-0.5850419402122498,
-0.038475941866636276,
0.351794570684433,
0.3360575735569,
-0.11879190057516098,
1.2722132205963135,
-0.6265002489089966,
-0.2670421600341797,
0.04948025196790695,
0.1567106395959854,
0.16037039458751678,
0.6736570596694946,
0.5181272029876709,
-0.75600266456604,
-0.44821637868881226,
-0.2645423114299774,
-0.6406499147415161,
-0.2137201428413391,
0.1736748218536377,
-0.27130207419395447,
-0.15320664644241333,
0.34073907136917114,
-0.42259088158607483,
0.45260342955589294,
0.7728486061096191,
-0.38558468222618103,
0.38851356506347656,
0.22015146911144257,
0.1995438039302826,
-1.1338822841644287,
0.07129150629043579,
-0.20371587574481964,
0.013941973447799683,
-0.5616006255149841,
-0.3477589190006256,
-0.01966899447143078,
-0.4615628123283386,
-0.71895831823349,
0.41356250643730164,
-0.03306726738810539,
0.3141529858112335,
0.15596573054790497,
0.34203025698661804,
-0.00845000147819519,
0.27676454186439514,
-0.05009007826447487,
1.018930435180664,
0.8641942143440247,
-0.38127315044403076,
0.7718643546104431,
0.7092477083206177,
-0.5369493961334229,
0.8418366312980652,
-0.5948127508163452,
0.1208140105009079,
0.2913701832294464,
0.40105146169662476,
-0.724700391292572,
-0.40008413791656494,
0.8298016786575317,
-0.5852737426757812,
0.08965959399938583,
-0.4421059489250183,
-0.19453877210617065,
-0.4159708023071289,
-0.5541294813156128,
0.35172632336616516,
0.19573403894901276,
-0.9422177672386169,
0.3339962065219879,
0.8359066247940063,
-0.26258549094200134,
-0.8757514357566833,
-0.24348536133766174,
0.088565893471241,
0.31491270661354065,
-0.4782581031322479,
-0.029185159131884575,
-0.5696957111358643,
-0.11940084397792816,
0.4260213077068329,
0.1552252471446991,
-0.4622657001018524,
0.1111210510134697,
0.7437093257904053,
0.578098714351654,
-0.11044931411743164,
0.09750941395759583,
0.09914982318878174,
0.14416296780109406,
0.24350474774837494,
-0.09965715557336807,
0.43383318185806274,
0.04475818946957588,
-0.35516229271888733,
-0.3923223614692688,
0.4113459587097168,
0.5942038297653198,
-0.0005371578736230731,
0.5335334539413452,
0.19790831208229065,
-0.4269058406352997,
-0.2784779667854309,
-0.2867833375930786,
-0.2569337487220764,
-0.5221781730651855,
0.1155567392706871,
-0.11354625225067139,
-0.8466711640357971,
0.16562867164611816,
-0.26182466745376587,
0.25308191776275635,
-0.12570564448833466,
0.1928032636642456,
-0.4575836956501007,
0.4664801359176636,
0.6259356141090393,
-0.030194120481610298,
0.9279881715774536,
-0.6122117638587952,
0.0467476025223732,
-0.6986885666847229,
-0.5678531527519226,
-0.713289737701416,
-0.4477905035018921,
-0.3491990566253662,
0.05554891377687454,
-0.06531063467264175,
-0.17651839554309845,
-0.04444640129804611,
0.14480067789554596,
-0.8895043134689331,
0.6906051635742188,
0.8263354301452637,
-0.25160908699035645,
0.10912898182868958,
-0.0967671200633049,
0.3614252805709839,
0.06023060157895088,
-0.7957819700241089,
-0.34166690707206726,
1.0011554956436157,
0.32857033610343933,
0.9313456416130066,
-0.09139963239431381,
0.6149494051933289,
0.06421364098787308,
0.39839163422584534,
-1.0278339385986328,
0.8861391544342041,
-0.04229627549648285,
-0.6372341513633728,
-0.2469170242547989,
-0.3719967305660248,
-1.2370206117630005,
0.13658589124679565,
-0.32494449615478516,
-0.7504651546478271,
0.35330986976623535,
0.06935277581214905,
-0.08660411834716797,
0.4826638400554657,
-0.8240054845809937,
1.207289695739746,
0.12548071146011353,
-0.21046282351016998,
-0.07399773597717285,
-0.4771108329296112,
0.1923975646495819,
0.03142162784934044,
0.2000674307346344,
-0.06910468637943268,
0.6569658517837524,
1.1667836904525757,
-0.3617669343948364,
0.9748877286911011,
-0.2313467115163803,
0.12824974954128265,
0.9184199571609497,
-0.21320590376853943,
0.20913004875183105,
-0.07651104032993317,
0.028553258627653122,
0.5468087196350098,
0.10003827512264252,
-0.1234813779592514,
-0.540591835975647,
0.8592048287391663,
-1.071359634399414,
-0.47455519437789917,
-0.5624215006828308,
-0.3966854512691498,
0.12624827027320862,
-0.06357406079769135,
0.11852377653121948,
0.4939988851547241,
-0.5110602974891663,
0.7189928293228149,
0.39940887689590454,
-0.15642030537128448,
0.4224441349506378,
0.5087015628814697,
-0.2706991136074066,
-0.28997284173965454,
1.0021615028381348,
0.5436236262321472,
-0.03594528138637543,
-0.1396581530570984,
0.10102517902851105,
0.02561412937939167,
-0.3774960935115814,
-0.2491636574268341,
0.041510164737701416,
-0.8604263663291931,
-0.15512537956237793,
-0.6884691715240479,
-0.3512248396873474,
-0.6833488345146179,
-0.2127975970506668,
-0.5498424768447876,
-0.435693621635437,
-0.6169873476028442,
-0.27105778455734253,
0.3259126543998718,
0.6309345364570618,
-0.06715386360883713,
0.6646429300308228,
-0.6357738971710205,
-0.06454987823963165,
0.2964661717414856,
0.4810142517089844,
-0.4900944232940674,
-0.2841397523880005,
-0.32567358016967773,
0.10501728951931,
-0.6816527843475342,
-0.7464739084243774,
0.14626376330852509,
0.36558786034584045,
0.2976047992706299,
0.332324743270874,
0.6302887797355652,
0.4815911650657654,
-0.252164751291275,
1.233593463897705,
0.2208198606967926,
-0.6294469833374023,
0.7872106432914734,
0.17458520829677582,
0.02436678484082222,
0.6105884909629822,
0.45681828260421753,
-0.49782493710517883,
-0.6293615102767944,
-0.8902114033699036,
-1.1182399988174438,
0.9695144295692444,
0.21787971258163452,
0.18758103251457214,
0.11472748219966888,
-0.1467428356409073,
0.28313544392585754,
0.225198894739151,
-0.06541388481855392,
-0.6987382173538208,
-0.5187188386917114,
-0.36645302176475525,
0.01961260661482811,
-0.4093801975250244,
-0.34398943185806274,
-0.22906434535980225,
0.7987874150276184,
0.18166343867778778,
-0.15780650079250336,
0.0005907060112804174,
0.16776494681835175,
-0.21626614034175873,
0.5744107365608215,
0.06455981731414795,
0.6338781118392944,
-0.5624195337295532,
0.03920229896903038,
-0.16219893097877502,
-1.2467849254608154,
-0.12128802388906479,
0.30742067098617554,
-0.14025408029556274,
0.3826391100883484,
-0.011287924833595753,
0.6767736077308655,
0.36750921607017517,
-0.6075465679168701,
0.6556172370910645,
-0.5431580543518066,
-0.044471122324466705,
-0.5684639811515808,
0.129229336977005,
-0.06722041219472885,
0.2778094410896301,
0.370756596326828,
-0.3242793679237366,
0.15740646421909332,
-0.4883340001106262,
0.2262578010559082,
0.17632421851158142,
-0.41966477036476135,
-0.26735809445381165,
0.6656333208084106,
0.8155003190040588,
-0.6462870836257935,
0.9420902729034424,
0.1660931259393692,
-0.1616887003183365,
0.5275483131408691,
0.5269200801849365,
0.8773102164268494,
-0.31855887174606323,
0.6976656317710876,
0.5518567562103271,
0.010012931190431118,
-0.014051155187189579,
0.16156859695911407,
-0.18898802995681763,
-0.7131056785583496,
-0.16690488159656525,
-0.25652286410331726,
-1.1852813959121704,
0.3168620765209198,
-0.7374846935272217,
0.3881273865699768,
-0.19608372449874878,
-0.20920884609222412,
0.19553174078464508,
-0.12240395694971085,
-0.721707820892334,
0.12396763265132904,
-0.08172357827425003,
0.9037407636642456,
-0.7561593055725098,
1.1553372144699097,
0.8308100700378418,
-0.021067548543214798,
-0.7178220152854919,
-0.60440993309021,
0.10309618711471558,
-0.21557734906673431,
0.5651161074638367,
0.10848724842071533,
-0.06984464824199677,
0.24519142508506775,
-1.004452109336853,
-0.2357904613018036,
1.0209553241729736,
0.58095383644104,
-0.9172271490097046,
0.06651072204113007,
0.03875316306948662,
0.24668973684310913,
-0.18394367396831512,
0.36357536911964417,
0.6261363625526428,
0.28211626410484314,
0.18555666506290436,
-0.7427057027816772,
-0.6390167474746704,
-0.4633729159832001,
-0.8426142930984497,
0.1514970064163208,
-0.20348882675170898,
0.6108960509300232,
0.043673325330019,
-0.46545282006263733,
-0.3757436275482178,
0.7028592228889465,
-0.0812181681394577,
0.9898990392684937,
0.07226236164569855,
0.5486066341400146,
0.9621613621711731,
-0.5333185195922852,
0.6914486289024353,
-0.3160678744316101,
0.5459774732589722,
1.6530951261520386,
0.2435341775417328,
0.7619152069091797,
0.4819472134113312,
-0.3084682524204254,
0.33375388383865356,
0.6266183257102966,
0.07901953905820847,
0.3174102306365967,
-0.2800857424736023,
-0.5460581183433533,
0.07392541319131851,
-0.33211517333984375,
-0.46311652660369873,
0.2117895632982254,
0.6617814898490906,
0.24568471312522888,
0.011509078554809093,
0.2078634798526764,
0.033874254673719406,
-0.07816492766141891,
-0.2858421206474304,
0.7171387672424316,
0.06780871748924255,
-0.4357973337173462,
0.3486952483654022,
-0.9130024313926697,
0.6361033916473389,
-0.5339651107788086,
-0.42526954412460327,
-0.11436875909566879,
-0.09810248762369156,
-0.3069882094860077,
-1.4138798713684082,
0.16279657185077667,
-0.0023082816042006016,
0.23358461260795593,
0.004214455373585224,
0.7817912101745605,
-0.8449697494506836,
0.04624996706843376,
0.4992188513278961,
0.3263653516769409,
0.447884738445282,
0.10431208461523056,
-0.6818658113479614,
0.3324599862098694,
-0.2739364206790924,
-0.23720689117908478,
0.12168806791305542,
0.37675371766090393,
0.2504466474056244,
0.7570012211799622,
0.8328426480293274,
0.09519945085048676,
-0.10528798401355743,
0.2013002187013626,
0.9324227571487427,
-0.001966167474165559,
-0.43487268686294556,
-0.6587497591972351,
0.721137285232544,
-0.17524228990077972,
-0.3259662091732025,
0.5127378106117249,
0.6667298674583435,
1.4722378253936768,
0.0913102775812149,
1.0182604789733887,
-0.2212507724761963,
0.19368664920330048,
0.16426558792591095,
0.843731701374054,
-0.2887435257434845,
0.14010241627693176,
-0.2400680035352707,
-0.9450411200523376,
-0.15071608126163483,
0.4380389451980591,
-0.20284228026866913,
-0.5856436491012573,
0.4902748465538025,
0.6330310702323914,
-0.09207937121391296,
0.44155749678611755,
0.3458263874053955,
0.2089482545852661,
0.8166172504425049,
0.3406408727169037,
0.867455005645752,
-0.42114588618278503,
0.9968921542167664,
-0.3839639127254486,
-0.3355461657047272,
-0.3855622112751007,
-0.5026395916938782,
-0.8884751796722412,
-0.8487570881843567,
-0.649959921836853,
-0.3739573359489441,
0.1476217657327652,
1.1484827995300293,
0.5147758722305298,
-0.8981392979621887,
-0.21248558163642883,
0.21782657504081726,
0.3571256697177887,
0.07942834496498108,
-0.25883060693740845,
0.31343820691108704,
-0.170024111866951,
-1.125917911529541,
0.5845714211463928,
-0.107512928545475,
0.011158507317304611,
-0.1326037049293518,
0.02717900648713112,
-0.14140668511390686,
0.014464326202869415,
0.45670220255851746,
0.535542368888855,
-0.2016293704509735,
-0.42825639247894287,
-0.3216119110584259,
-0.1552181839942932,
0.1610088050365448,
0.9258814454078674,
-0.7385839223861694,
1.1643316745758057,
0.5562146902084351,
0.7708199620246887,
0.13383713364601135,
-0.15147550404071808,
0.24756522476673126,
-0.8548771142959595,
0.29301440715789795,
0.2439204454421997,
0.30546483397483826,
0.38441136479377747,
-0.2001211941242218,
0.8728904128074646,
0.24139484763145447,
-0.8339805603027344,
-1.131809115409851,
0.003210883354768157,
-1.1401355266571045,
-0.10665353387594223,
0.7055292129516602,
-0.31218570470809937,
-0.08576033264398575,
-0.34212639927864075,
-0.6640214920043945,
0.44557809829711914,
-0.8554452061653137,
0.5758731961250305,
0.6896738409996033,
0.26856598258018494,
-0.26677951216697693,
-0.6666130423545837,
0.4299548864364624,
-0.25910890102386475,
-0.7944603562355042,
0.21326439082622528,
0.4792134761810303,
-0.030651753768324852,
0.3152482211589813,
0.7183741331100464,
0.07481297850608826,
0.03876543790102005,
-0.058903828263282776,
0.3447813391685486,
-0.3486801087856293,
-0.6519709229469299,
-0.0935337021946907,
0.35914236307144165,
-0.4602970480918884,
-0.835115909576416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05106v1 | Image captioning for Brazilian Portuguese using GRIT model | 2024-02-07T18:57:37 | 2024-02-07T18:57:37 | Rafael Silva de Alencar, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work presents the early development of a model of image captioning for
the Brazilian Portuguese language. We used the GRIT (Grid - and Region-based
Image captioning Transformer) model to accomplish this work. GRIT is a
Transformer-only neural architecture that effectively utilizes two visual
features to generate better captions. The GRIT method emerged as a proposal to
be a more efficient way to generate image captioning. In this work, we adapt
the GRIT model to be trained in a Brazilian Portuguese dataset to have an image
captioning method for the Brazilian Portuguese Language. | [
-0.37215763330459595,
-0.612540602684021,
0.3523503839969635,
0.4023415148258209,
-0.7646162509918213,
0.14251115918159485,
-0.029928680509328842,
-0.35538622736930847,
0.2769576907157898,
0.5961294174194336,
-0.2669941484928131,
-0.264352411031723,
-0.6670493483543396,
-0.14998430013656616,
-0.3404383659362793,
1.3763391971588135,
-0.1654575616121292,
0.6237872838973999,
-0.38196760416030884,
-0.10173549503087997,
-0.5862627625465393,
0.15404872596263885,
-0.9096930027008057,
-0.4195502698421478,
0.3210812509059906,
0.2616899013519287,
0.9933469295501709,
0.9664755463600159,
0.9703894257545471,
0.399825781583786,
0.16385748982429504,
-0.08821519464254379,
-0.5381778478622437,
-0.2880806624889374,
-0.19445574283599854,
-0.675621747970581,
-0.12478342652320862,
-0.10365889221429825,
0.5552330613136292,
0.3315865695476532,
0.09471870213747025,
-0.04788510128855705,
-0.13124796748161316,
0.3846991956233978,
-0.3374156355857849,
0.6482081413269043,
-0.6302841901779175,
0.06761223822832108,
-0.0038827285170555115,
-0.5318758487701416,
-0.11198633164167404,
-0.31929656863212585,
-0.003891743952408433,
-0.4224189817905426,
0.7328140735626221,
0.03349796310067177,
1.4798712730407715,
0.1822732836008072,
-0.006264776457101107,
-0.16937142610549927,
-0.9024375081062317,
0.5937085151672363,
-0.08161504566669464,
0.14084434509277344,
0.06528973579406738,
0.959130048751831,
0.4429970383644104,
-0.9078047871589661,
-0.27042439579963684,
-0.1273389756679535,
-0.22039882838726044,
0.09704059362411499,
-0.027512652799487114,
-0.010280932299792767,
-0.12416000664234161,
0.65825355052948,
-0.3348011374473572,
0.07310222834348679,
-0.8423591256141663,
-0.4397764801979065,
0.7777144312858582,
0.11250051856040955,
-0.031214948743581772,
0.04177047684788704,
-1.0418912172317505,
-0.34360262751579285,
-0.8413242101669312,
-0.03988706320524216,
0.20715272426605225,
0.33238908648490906,
-0.21816471219062805,
0.2645263075828552,
-0.013381808996200562,
0.6079767942428589,
-0.4525933563709259,
-0.5394777059555054,
0.0972830206155777,
0.11102414131164551,
-0.1855318248271942,
-0.012478516437113285,
0.6605322957038879,
0.6209853887557983,
0.470702201128006,
-0.4604122042655945,
-1.0091583728790283,
0.06060457229614258,
0.5814093947410583,
-0.6653870344161987,
-0.3093043267726898,
-0.0064768074080348015,
-0.29395341873168945,
-0.4942761957645416,
0.1716514527797699,
-1.043420672416687,
-0.645443320274353,
-0.17768777906894684,
0.5244547724723816,
-0.32167848944664,
0.25463762879371643,
-0.14593054354190826,
-0.31470030546188354,
0.5748336911201477,
0.3399992287158966,
-0.5259581804275513,
0.6429587006568909,
0.3718000650405884,
1.005894422531128,
-0.16962307691574097,
-0.5470532774925232,
-0.43036726117134094,
-0.011601446196436882,
-0.2226416915655136,
1.3306676149368286,
-0.2682816982269287,
-0.357593297958374,
0.26548272371292114,
0.30378109216690063,
0.23812709748744965,
-0.26288682222366333,
0.4518575668334961,
-0.6956660747528076,
-0.09817297011613846,
-0.19082430005073547,
-0.01559843122959137,
-0.48834195733070374,
0.11795453727245331,
-0.796044111251831,
0.8425774574279785,
0.5178585052490234,
-0.4777580499649048,
0.25938019156455994,
-0.77748042345047,
-0.49781933426856995,
0.5647879838943481,
-0.31732669472694397,
-0.5268882513046265,
0.10978469997644424,
0.26984313130378723,
0.266920804977417,
-0.540955662727356,
0.4317385256290436,
0.06594974547624588,
-0.6365381479263306,
0.21415038406848907,
-0.46877211332321167,
0.4012150764465332,
0.33583083748817444,
-0.34186750650405884,
0.15164612233638763,
-0.293655663728714,
-0.3523416519165039,
0.6924304962158203,
-0.1140323355793953,
0.1797894686460495,
-0.1546398252248764,
0.6128745675086975,
0.2972811758518219,
0.4766477942466736,
-0.627740204334259,
0.05182214081287384,
0.024877971038222313,
0.47998490929603577,
0.47141507267951965,
-0.06009894981980324,
0.6545588970184326,
-0.5833643078804016,
0.7115420699119568,
0.14855095744132996,
0.20829267799854279,
-0.5788907408714294,
-0.5771810412406921,
-1.0505377054214478,
-0.18282270431518555,
0.5188679695129395,
0.7674441337585449,
-1.1647411584854126,
-0.24606144428253174,
-0.8358911275863647,
-0.5772392153739929,
-0.8535298109054565,
0.03624042123556137,
0.794495701789856,
0.46860557794570923,
0.43843337893486023,
-0.5820632576942444,
-0.24537374079227448,
-1.2501662969589233,
0.29082798957824707,
0.293995201587677,
0.12297964096069336,
0.5369601845741272,
0.49787774682044983,
0.2568330764770508,
0.7438603043556213,
-0.6599807739257812,
-0.6143926382064819,
-0.15042129158973694,
0.15706177055835724,
0.06780939549207687,
0.459092915058136,
0.7451494336128235,
-0.9533476233482361,
-0.3668454885482788,
0.049441155046224594,
-0.515537440776825,
0.08682027459144592,
-0.2832415997982025,
0.011592047289013863,
0.26411172747612,
0.5534954071044922,
-0.19470998644828796,
0.6003054976463318,
0.30986377596855164,
0.02380739338696003,
0.35798782110214233,
-0.39888688921928406,
0.23271562159061432,
-0.7295647859573364,
-0.03505948558449745,
0.16546575725078583,
-0.4926573634147644,
-0.2823041081428528,
0.45179253816604614,
0.013673517853021622,
-0.19408276677131653,
-0.7656841278076172,
0.5808818936347961,
-0.510429859161377,
-0.38095879554748535,
-0.5404964685440063,
-0.08815676718950272,
0.17374935746192932,
0.7581333518028259,
0.507817268371582,
0.9584850668907166,
0.8498746156692505,
-0.27775633335113525,
0.3664286732673645,
0.0690402016043663,
-0.32150551676750183,
0.7356666922569275,
-0.9411411285400391,
0.08891100436449051,
-0.46442949771881104,
-0.13121385872364044,
-1.2184221744537354,
-0.10317064076662064,
-0.13057975471019745,
-0.27675533294677734,
0.6209263801574707,
-0.5818011164665222,
-0.19374461472034454,
-0.7301236987113953,
-0.28898823261260986,
-0.05355045571923256,
0.5139858722686768,
-0.5425595641136169,
0.4606647491455078,
0.4410901963710785,
-0.35408467054367065,
-0.3242051899433136,
-0.8279180526733398,
0.1823185384273529,
-0.3333524465560913,
-0.5011227130889893,
0.6370590329170227,
0.37902817130088806,
-0.07143422961235046,
-0.25762519240379333,
0.30445176362991333,
-0.5276311039924622,
-0.14184899628162384,
0.2806696891784668,
0.3969070017337799,
-0.3303830921649933,
0.1074344739317894,
0.1716369390487671,
-0.1940738409757614,
-0.08152550458908081,
0.049033503979444504,
0.8904776573181152,
-0.7060976624488831,
0.1798071563243866,
-0.13697749376296997,
0.42883872985839844,
0.45082056522369385,
-0.4869375228881836,
0.5273453593254089,
0.7471780180931091,
-0.13649755716323853,
0.05290800333023071,
-0.47756054997444153,
-0.3665103614330292,
-0.4866805672645569,
0.3965384364128113,
-0.4172666370868683,
-0.5496721863746643,
0.8461126685142517,
-0.030796868726611137,
-0.07599295675754547,
0.2835710644721985,
0.4477519094944,
-0.2817476987838745,
0.4105793535709381,
0.7303805351257324,
0.02314421348273754,
0.4941205084323883,
-0.5317026376724243,
-0.0921659916639328,
-0.5914973616600037,
-0.17913572490215302,
-0.5997389554977417,
-0.44639766216278076,
-0.6557819843292236,
-0.41905292868614197,
0.2908186614513397,
-0.14654916524887085,
-0.20063792169094086,
0.39494869112968445,
-0.5336790084838867,
0.7401763796806335,
0.7855162620544434,
0.45725762844085693,
-0.00960625521838665,
0.22721675038337708,
0.14880387485027313,
0.03540550917387009,
-0.7692758440971375,
-0.7227126955986023,
0.8125900626182556,
0.4290573298931122,
0.7439450025558472,
-0.19434645771980286,
0.5959656238555908,
0.4788021147251129,
0.3740827739238739,
-0.9415072798728943,
0.34498849511146545,
-0.11059728264808655,
-0.33170756697654724,
-0.18207016587257385,
0.151317298412323,
-1.3244619369506836,
0.09864717721939087,
-0.33743593096733093,
-0.34097060561180115,
-0.03733021020889282,
-0.023726936429739,
-0.25360018014907837,
0.20422524213790894,
-0.5601668357849121,
0.7723947167396545,
-0.22248482704162598,
-0.2856728434562683,
0.2661530077457428,
-0.8341964483261108,
-0.0016940002096816897,
0.24321329593658447,
0.37272655963897705,
0.2374209761619568,
-0.06915661692619324,
0.7862839102745056,
-0.21656064689159393,
0.6016296744346619,
-0.3097294569015503,
0.09757313877344131,
0.739578366279602,
0.3121432363986969,
0.44762441515922546,
0.08079466223716736,
0.36072206497192383,
0.5011692643165588,
-0.31250065565109253,
-0.5884647965431213,
-0.40429940819740295,
0.5648987293243408,
-0.7716370820999146,
-0.45712101459503174,
-0.3254961669445038,
-0.8428509831428528,
0.11917829513549805,
0.3211669921875,
0.32687482237815857,
0.40908095240592957,
-0.1384125053882599,
-0.04053523391485214,
0.46572768688201904,
0.11122412234544754,
1.0730907917022705,
0.5323697924613953,
-0.2601785659790039,
-0.698575496673584,
0.9990491271018982,
0.009694920852780342,
-0.02195587567985058,
0.36783167719841003,
0.11945073306560516,
-0.17700834572315216,
-0.8353971838951111,
-0.7157202363014221,
0.3183397352695465,
-0.700066864490509,
-0.5819060206413269,
-0.24140460789203644,
-0.21503877639770508,
-0.3239377439022064,
-0.5695989727973938,
-0.505855917930603,
-0.14862284064292908,
-0.02118843048810959,
0.10359611362218857,
0.4629947543144226,
0.7445006966590881,
0.46798697113990784,
0.9749873280525208,
-1.0019075870513916,
0.02436101622879505,
0.40170085430145264,
0.5413112044334412,
-0.35163187980651855,
-0.49713239073753357,
-0.2736184298992157,
0.07822541147470474,
-0.5567814707756042,
-0.9794943928718567,
0.7524308562278748,
0.12542244791984558,
0.41703879833221436,
0.4725033938884735,
-0.4060107469558716,
0.4364227056503296,
-0.6599636673927307,
0.8567318916320801,
-0.05961066111922264,
-0.7025851607322693,
0.5413963794708252,
-0.5971153378486633,
0.22847232222557068,
0.5754075646400452,
0.47922664880752563,
-0.09931796789169312,
-0.11226799339056015,
-0.7974187731742859,
-0.5550998449325562,
0.5008490085601807,
0.1970847249031067,
0.3702646493911743,
0.08615466952323914,
0.2560000419616699,
0.28733012080192566,
0.25926390290260315,
-0.8996755480766296,
-0.10214029997587204,
-0.37781214714050293,
0.11602254211902618,
-0.11945323646068573,
-0.07361682504415512,
-0.38022464513778687,
-0.12861420214176178,
0.5129913091659546,
-0.4758567214012146,
0.7877684235572815,
0.0549212321639061,
-0.29272547364234924,
-0.09045518189668655,
-0.022485937923192978,
0.7769847512245178,
0.4069357216358185,
-0.027460167184472084,
0.011128823272883892,
0.06971388310194016,
-0.5469114780426025,
-0.18446411192417145,
0.11395733058452606,
-0.2928715646266937,
0.21915625035762787,
0.2862216532230377,
1.1253548860549927,
0.2860429286956787,
-0.4082920551300049,
0.7340115308761597,
0.1980283260345459,
-0.06624457240104675,
-0.17221887409687042,
-0.01636986806988716,
0.0035485734697431326,
0.10859080404043198,
0.1698329895734787,
0.08559751510620117,
0.21281731128692627,
-0.22268740832805634,
0.013080297969281673,
0.3487125635147095,
-0.9070785045623779,
0.05209914967417717,
0.39910709857940674,
0.23105302453041077,
-0.5523383617401123,
0.6850466728210449,
-0.23434194922447205,
-0.5187979936599731,
0.923629879951477,
0.7263725996017456,
0.6275476813316345,
-0.26756107807159424,
0.4934755861759186,
0.18784378468990326,
0.5039412975311279,
0.018242355436086655,
0.7162091135978699,
0.06964634358882904,
-0.5696614384651184,
-0.16289500892162323,
-0.7484366297721863,
-0.3072783648967743,
-0.02995980717241764,
-0.8860512971878052,
0.6889541149139404,
-0.26531416177749634,
0.033179376274347305,
-0.02816627360880375,
-0.1869349330663681,
-0.9033983945846558,
0.5197409391403198,
0.25822898745536804,
0.8020710349082947,
-1.2204927206039429,
0.8390554785728455,
1.085392951965332,
-0.6103784441947937,
-0.33023741841316223,
-0.7817546129226685,
-0.5099982619285583,
-1.2068547010421753,
0.14085577428340912,
0.29228970408439636,
0.1644657701253891,
-0.09292197227478027,
-0.9653123617172241,
-0.8365219235420227,
1.3810408115386963,
0.3199290335178375,
-0.3012622594833374,
0.3977954387664795,
0.4105030298233032,
0.6354354619979858,
-0.7434276938438416,
0.26896634697914124,
0.5274787545204163,
0.4007558822631836,
0.5515714287757874,
-0.8682118654251099,
-0.2933778762817383,
-0.20618991553783417,
0.3897916376590729,
0.3435853123664856,
-0.7512259483337402,
1.0072784423828125,
-0.3849988281726837,
0.048556383699178696,
0.012369104661047459,
0.9344460368156433,
-0.050572387874126434,
0.28241872787475586,
0.23846198618412018,
0.458945631980896,
0.4964979887008667,
-0.4905577003955841,
1.4168647527694702,
-0.29562535881996155,
0.5611346364021301,
1.239504098892212,
0.14565695822238922,
0.5386560559272766,
0.4997425377368927,
-0.3069368600845337,
0.6689833402633667,
0.5557791590690613,
-0.4419021010398865,
0.5461101531982422,
0.08429524302482605,
0.0028906927909702063,
-0.09563836455345154,
-0.38853171467781067,
-0.11322415620088577,
1.0040702819824219,
0.2416934370994568,
-0.8188295960426331,
-0.546186089515686,
0.11163721978664398,
0.36688464879989624,
0.12314528226852417,
-0.6999410390853882,
0.7815860509872437,
-0.3048152029514313,
-0.7424277663230896,
0.49909767508506775,
0.1858777552843094,
0.5380723476409912,
-0.3660483658313751,
-0.1932230293750763,
-0.28508174419403076,
-0.2687726616859436,
0.09801334887742996,
-1.1589125394821167,
0.4241238534450531,
-0.11659713089466095,
-0.13044041395187378,
-0.22755569219589233,
0.6969747543334961,
-0.4452512562274933,
-0.699020504951477,
-0.25454819202423096,
0.4139259457588196,
0.6266882419586182,
-0.11604012548923492,
-0.6725367903709412,
-0.04229966178536415,
-0.1738927811384201,
0.16733352839946747,
0.2075471729040146,
-0.00046619304339401424,
-0.42688503861427307,
0.5307597517967224,
0.2822764217853546,
-0.01785624399781227,
-0.031342487782239914,
0.034348830580711365,
0.9142093658447266,
-0.5396257042884827,
-0.627638578414917,
-0.5890862345695496,
0.402864545583725,
-0.08036360144615173,
-0.3013421297073364,
0.41379794478416443,
0.7029081583023071,
0.4769820272922516,
-0.5915970802307129,
0.6688098907470703,
-0.1067693755030632,
-0.2790026068687439,
-0.3779863119125366,
0.9358447790145874,
-0.1149284839630127,
-0.31606778502464294,
-0.035362277179956436,
-1.143695592880249,
-0.3091921806335449,
0.6518945693969727,
-0.27146199345588684,
0.18713395297527313,
0.7659661173820496,
1.005892038345337,
0.16863679885864258,
0.1416010707616806,
0.31131404638290405,
0.021458394825458527,
0.08712644875049591,
0.5207138061523438,
0.2060704231262207,
-0.705242931842804,
0.5030446648597717,
-0.7917518019676208,
-0.21003496646881104,
0.09595334529876709,
-1.2281494140625,
-0.7614099383354187,
-0.6038283109664917,
-0.40299561619758606,
-0.6019477844238281,
-0.04163118451833725,
0.447156697511673,
0.5528399348258972,
-0.8935878872871399,
-0.28705576062202454,
-0.06743760406970978,
0.13189002871513367,
-0.24734215438365936,
-0.28796809911727905,
0.4541222155094147,
-0.3726194202899933,
-0.926264762878418,
-0.0925450250506401,
0.25706106424331665,
0.33924373984336853,
-0.5477357506752014,
-0.0033605899661779404,
-0.046335820108652115,
0.12715551257133484,
0.3196621537208557,
0.1408594399690628,
-0.35286417603492737,
-0.12621384859085083,
-0.2102934718132019,
-0.1565457433462143,
0.5403925776481628,
0.736946702003479,
-1.0017465353012085,
0.4795031249523163,
0.3121050000190735,
0.21205899119377136,
0.6181463003158569,
-0.24758005142211914,
0.29541149735450745,
-0.5625288486480713,
0.38162222504615784,
0.2863374650478363,
0.6052685976028442,
0.6860190033912659,
-0.3214804530143738,
0.527404248714447,
0.21837639808654785,
-0.30932551622390747,
-0.373161256313324,
-0.18132184445858002,
-1.329237699508667,
0.12199245393276215,
1.2541075944900513,
-0.40661925077438354,
-0.726096510887146,
0.010226129554212093,
-0.5500863194465637,
0.0997856855392456,
-0.4137192368507385,
0.9881781935691833,
0.5491796135902405,
0.3220779001712799,
-0.29098281264305115,
-0.138353630900383,
0.1521972268819809,
-0.19983306527137756,
-0.8244351148605347,
-0.5180299282073975,
0.33260998129844666,
0.18776442110538483,
0.4265236556529999,
0.16368240118026733,
-0.4982914328575134,
0.6764687895774841,
0.38007858395576477,
0.562531590461731,
-0.40746596455574036,
-0.7140311598777771,
-0.4903953969478607,
0.3446040153503418,
-0.2528131604194641,
-0.24170447885990143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05162v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05162v3 | Assessing the Brittleness of Safety Alignment via Pruning and Low-Rank Modifications | 2024-02-07T18:34:38 | 2024-07-01T07:11:17 | Boyi Wei, Kaixuan Huang, Yangsibo Huang, Tinghao Xie, Xiangyu Qi, Mengzhou Xia, Prateek Mittal, Mengdi Wang, Peter Henderson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) show inherent brittleness in their safety
mechanisms, as evidenced by their susceptibility to jailbreaking and even
non-malicious fine-tuning. This study explores this brittleness of safety
alignment by leveraging pruning and low-rank modifications. We develop methods
to identify critical regions that are vital for safety guardrails, and that are
disentangled from utility-relevant regions at both the neuron and rank levels.
Surprisingly, the isolated regions we find are sparse, comprising about $3\%$
at the parameter level and $2.5\%$ at the rank level. Removing these regions
compromises safety without significantly impacting utility, corroborating the
inherent brittleness of the model's safety mechanisms. Moreover, we show that
LLMs remain vulnerable to low-cost fine-tuning attacks even when modifications
to the safety-critical regions are restricted. These findings underscore the
urgent need for more robust safety strategies in LLMs. | [
-0.18536172807216644,
-0.8509532809257507,
0.5852282047271729,
-0.10572628676891327,
-0.3417527973651886,
0.20782262086868286,
-0.22538885474205017,
-0.23863385617733002,
-0.03305662050843239,
0.30153128504753113,
-0.47738930583000183,
-0.39600110054016113,
-0.8765220046043396,
-0.17099629342556,
-0.28555989265441895,
1.1151937246322632,
-0.133119136095047,
-0.20751939713954926,
0.22479772567749023,
-0.1138504147529602,
-0.4127109944820404,
-0.6021141409873962,
-0.5893654823303223,
-0.23185405135154724,
0.7517304420471191,
0.4328286945819855,
1.0283169746398926,
0.9230816960334778,
0.7500047087669373,
0.3156833350658417,
-0.664883553981781,
-0.34095126390457153,
-0.5119754076004028,
-0.005744539201259613,
-0.1923317015171051,
-0.4844789206981659,
-0.9063193202018738,
-0.18127846717834473,
0.5326673984527588,
0.7945606112480164,
-0.1871955692768097,
-0.22581638395786285,
0.43399572372436523,
0.5949632525444031,
-0.6378005146980286,
-0.18100175261497498,
-1.0364407300949097,
-0.15381862223148346,
-0.5366787910461426,
-0.10521116107702255,
-0.3668482303619385,
-0.3855777382850647,
0.002428960520774126,
-0.17103032767772675,
0.07993748784065247,
0.12715832889080048,
1.1998276710510254,
0.3758246898651123,
-0.5502228140830994,
0.1305880844593048,
-0.655653178691864,
0.9065794944763184,
-0.6162663102149963,
0.11144638061523438,
0.4358111619949341,
0.10338800400495529,
-0.5846955180168152,
-0.23287349939346313,
-0.22550901770591736,
-0.16321949660778046,
-0.03505551069974899,
-0.23536619544029236,
-0.05589768663048744,
0.4941282868385315,
0.21313899755477905,
0.19866779446601868,
-0.5386031866073608,
0.5544695258140564,
-0.31212520599365234,
-0.3230822682380676,
0.57534259557724,
0.2630541920661926,
0.5282325148582458,
-0.2807380259037018,
-0.33397048711776733,
-0.35612815618515015,
-1.207289695739746,
0.10620184242725372,
0.6882594227790833,
0.41875216364860535,
-0.07987184077501297,
0.517325222492218,
0.23128381371498108,
0.6436444520950317,
-0.15466636419296265,
-0.3616364002227783,
-0.05909567326307297,
-0.2599843144416809,
-0.19450530409812927,
0.21444308757781982,
0.8734595775604248,
0.5552043914794922,
0.1829589605331421,
-0.2294464409351349,
-0.2565544545650482,
0.07200160622596741,
0.2524608373641968,
-0.37114623188972473,
-0.2962104082107544,
0.3898467719554901,
-0.4580903649330139,
-0.5407602190971375,
-0.33840858936309814,
-0.5503944754600525,
-0.6354269981384277,
-0.09115955233573914,
0.2640766203403473,
-0.62273770570755,
-0.28711390495300293,
0.12746481597423553,
0.06842681765556335,
0.2438226342201233,
0.10016743093729019,
-1.2005141973495483,
0.0899973064661026,
0.906157910823822,
0.9361240267753601,
-0.06398003548383713,
-0.5222801566123962,
-0.37809252738952637,
0.21217986941337585,
-0.39252611994743347,
0.5767231583595276,
-0.20736347138881683,
-0.1913534551858902,
-0.20610593259334564,
0.27305853366851807,
-0.11602891981601715,
-0.45900827646255493,
0.9199318289756775,
-0.3419645428657532,
-0.5515033602714539,
-0.07529877871274948,
0.06547433137893677,
0.046803224831819534,
0.2666941285133362,
-0.709455668926239,
0.6010110378265381,
-0.12518204748630524,
-0.7972220778465271,
0.5107309222221375,
-0.10104691237211227,
-0.6331729292869568,
-0.4547661542892456,
-0.05031319707632065,
-0.6908484697341919,
0.26555976271629333,
0.02315119281411171,
0.2346167117357254,
-0.08595513552427292,
0.44917142391204834,
-0.6715079545974731,
-0.2189386636018753,
0.37265750765800476,
-0.6730765104293823,
0.5785079002380371,
0.0861419141292572,
-0.33340004086494446,
0.24666236340999603,
-0.6581844091415405,
-0.017202699556946754,
0.04386444017291069,
-0.48789703845977783,
-0.577882707118988,
0.40036576986312866,
0.041673146188259125,
0.2831851840019226,
0.44896069169044495,
-0.34076783061027527,
0.17074282467365265,
-0.69842129945755,
0.6542903780937195,
1.2426574230194092,
0.01245012879371643,
0.5893332958221436,
-0.29449522495269775,
0.21171028912067413,
0.25317278504371643,
0.48093825578689575,
0.5221479535102844,
-0.0749155730009079,
-0.7789616584777832,
-0.10588423162698746,
0.4864979088306427,
0.4248357117176056,
-0.4191349744796753,
0.5719345808029175,
-0.417577862739563,
-0.5520203709602356,
-0.5136794447898865,
0.21913939714431763,
0.556130588054657,
0.14100198447704315,
0.23695720732212067,
-0.3492518663406372,
-0.30237865447998047,
-1.0964241027832031,
-0.2805546820163727,
-0.3242228329181671,
0.041308071464300156,
-0.2265438288450241,
0.5170148015022278,
-0.03872448951005936,
0.8239606022834778,
-0.2926223874092102,
-0.05786916986107826,
-0.2405278980731964,
-0.07984244078397751,
0.1613256335258484,
0.8642997145652771,
0.49313411116600037,
-0.5652689337730408,
-0.13689865171909332,
0.054095812141895294,
-0.6142566204071045,
0.19233794510364532,
-0.09456011652946472,
-0.14007781445980072,
0.03434052690863609,
0.6060192584991455,
-0.5332117080688477,
0.39280417561531067,
0.4858158826828003,
-0.2341226488351822,
0.3703587055206299,
-0.14172491431236267,
-0.12873844802379608,
-0.8553692698478699,
-0.009391916915774345,
0.021288972347974777,
0.037941016256809235,
-0.7107060551643372,
0.02081131748855114,
0.13883386552333832,
0.02286972850561142,
-0.42855340242385864,
0.010304898023605347,
-0.5993887186050415,
0.023545250296592712,
-0.18995697796344757,
0.1919860690832138,
-0.1780114620923996,
0.3786373436450958,
-0.2276647686958313,
0.5609486699104309,
0.5983074903488159,
-0.4849599003791809,
-0.30755487084388733,
0.1114463210105896,
-0.4500073790550232,
0.22620496153831482,
-0.7462334036827087,
0.09360767900943756,
-0.23265360295772552,
-0.10516258329153061,
-0.6574012637138367,
-0.44619062542915344,
-0.0885959267616272,
0.05013725534081459,
0.4209766089916229,
-0.7910372614860535,
-0.47110703587532043,
0.1697145402431488,
-0.4283851385116577,
0.22702324390411377,
0.5591564774513245,
-0.20745649933815002,
0.2719254195690155,
0.7896382808685303,
-0.5864789485931396,
-0.6950008273124695,
-0.5491763949394226,
0.09542122483253479,
-0.6688570976257324,
-0.8066584467887878,
0.4322052001953125,
0.11394273489713669,
-0.4792301654815674,
-0.319191575050354,
-0.4074663817882538,
0.04339374601840973,
0.8196824193000793,
0.5060939192771912,
0.3434162437915802,
-0.01332788448780775,
-0.12265190482139587,
0.30930808186531067,
-0.220582976937294,
0.03795582801103592,
0.2698615789413452,
0.49398499727249146,
-0.22309094667434692,
-0.5289267301559448,
-0.25622883439064026,
0.19237877428531647,
0.9276061654090881,
-0.18995532393455505,
0.8649017810821533,
-0.005056359805166721,
-0.44898512959480286,
-0.15218082070350647,
-0.1430893838405609,
-0.2796846032142639,
-0.5691295862197876,
0.4439457654953003,
-0.2113739252090454,
-1.0691046714782715,
0.45160144567489624,
-0.3056052625179291,
0.34536242485046387,
0.17127107083797455,
0.24632367491722107,
-0.10276690870523453,
1.2762171030044556,
0.7353242039680481,
-0.18426749110221863,
0.43684065341949463,
0.2929340600967407,
0.5674291849136353,
-0.870413064956665,
-0.036369942128658295,
-0.6985413432121277,
-0.5260577201843262,
-0.6169177293777466,
-0.044070690870285034,
0.5880047082901001,
0.5816332697868347,
-0.25452426075935364,
0.6040832996368408,
-0.5150081515312195,
0.570835292339325,
0.06612260639667511,
0.0847119614481926,
0.1290256679058075,
-0.025453299283981323,
-0.12008350342512131,
-0.287826269865036,
-0.5355061888694763,
-0.8067612648010254,
0.7830786108970642,
0.7593030333518982,
1.0483814477920532,
0.5343886613845825,
0.6368492841720581,
-0.16269509494304657,
0.12384814023971558,
-0.7111499905586243,
0.6967770457267761,
-0.2941361963748932,
-0.46254992485046387,
-0.29898783564567566,
-0.37562426924705505,
-1.0377148389816284,
0.32052963972091675,
-0.40751025080680847,
-0.9626055359840393,
0.2670290470123291,
0.24121811985969543,
-0.5390585064888,
0.2622835636138916,
-0.9401171207427979,
0.9443688988685608,
-0.642015278339386,
-0.4056051969528198,
-0.17687483131885529,
-0.6863580942153931,
0.5273078083992004,
0.005474244710057974,
0.23745889961719513,
-0.2517925202846527,
0.26141053438186646,
0.7471401691436768,
-0.48172664642333984,
0.9850368499755859,
0.08589450269937515,
-0.15913020074367523,
-0.14917533099651337,
0.35020703077316284,
0.7248683571815491,
-0.12017905712127686,
-0.016881966963410378,
-0.03803909197449684,
-0.056781407445669174,
-0.2939496338367462,
-0.30189600586891174,
0.9270584583282471,
-0.7099010348320007,
-0.7536271810531616,
-0.6075445413589478,
-0.44313985109329224,
-0.387525349855423,
0.16591495275497437,
0.04322584345936775,
0.24844640493392944,
-0.1075025275349617,
0.32955360412597656,
0.8285562992095947,
-0.1702558994293213,
0.6593766212463379,
0.4095320999622345,
0.32741430401802063,
-0.25648218393325806,
0.7655779719352722,
0.2991272211074829,
0.35319066047668457,
-0.04370258376002312,
-0.08600299805402756,
-0.12883931398391724,
-1.2450498342514038,
-0.09916070848703384,
0.13471218943595886,
-0.7224067449569702,
-0.032765697687864304,
-0.3281385004520416,
-0.37063702940940857,
-0.22336171567440033,
-0.36524203419685364,
-0.4169272482395172,
-0.42801418900489807,
-0.12305206805467606,
-0.4377945065498352,
0.33053213357925415,
0.510575532913208,
0.0008803514065220952,
0.527378261089325,
-0.9226258397102356,
-0.11271559447050095,
0.1556726098060608,
0.3667577803134918,
-0.05740102753043175,
-0.4543592631816864,
-0.1257569044828415,
-0.3207738995552063,
-0.2627491056919098,
-0.7515577673912048,
0.3053734004497528,
-0.0861319750547409,
0.4349013864994049,
0.37399670481681824,
0.20984475314617157,
0.838505744934082,
-0.691074013710022,
0.5925528407096863,
0.35529324412345886,
-0.7977257370948792,
0.5270129442214966,
-0.4179779291152954,
-0.1396600902080536,
0.8312344551086426,
0.18620122969150543,
-0.18381217122077942,
-0.4349381923675537,
-0.48814067244529724,
-1.3475561141967773,
0.6005295515060425,
0.11678361892700195,
-0.12519995868206024,
-0.004433834925293922,
0.19938315451145172,
-0.17179857194423676,
-0.06531055271625519,
-0.9221658706665039,
0.010125567205250263,
0.2500787079334259,
-0.22482851147651672,
0.1486845761537552,
-0.3612527847290039,
-0.6626956462860107,
0.06487252563238144,
0.5210349559783936,
-0.04157828539609909,
-0.24404606223106384,
-0.14337973296642303,
-0.21068671345710754,
-0.10249703377485275,
0.80373615026474,
0.6749088168144226,
0.4765123724937439,
-0.3459266424179077,
0.4821699261665344,
0.273328959941864,
-0.5264172554016113,
0.2908923923969269,
-0.17855650186538696,
-0.1801692545413971,
-0.3173281252384186,
0.31636250019073486,
0.7813184857368469,
0.3054348826408386,
-0.5126675367355347,
0.3641383945941925,
-0.10803806781768799,
-0.020098799839615822,
-0.1374455988407135,
0.32613232731819153,
-0.040893711149692535,
-0.06523559987545013,
0.042651496827602386,
0.33684515953063965,
-0.30281707644462585,
-0.5013235211372375,
0.07781341671943665,
0.587023913860321,
-0.5241913795471191,
-0.4528856873512268,
0.5262489318847656,
0.19062012434005737,
-0.25422409176826477,
0.29878556728363037,
0.22933293879032135,
-0.37157726287841797,
0.5884559750556946,
0.23729802668094635,
0.9043194651603699,
0.018392471596598625,
-0.05599305033683777,
0.290062814950943,
1.0608434677124023,
-0.3144478499889374,
-0.1153760626912117,
0.4332405626773834,
-0.4397183954715729,
-0.42637595534324646,
-0.7964800000190735,
-0.2917804419994354,
0.2090614140033722,
-0.5286754965782166,
0.2427128702402115,
-0.8278682827949524,
-0.4708552062511444,
-0.16520364582538605,
-0.5038949847221375,
0.07364734262228012,
0.12650823593139648,
-0.23314230144023895,
0.6862258315086365,
-1.1527149677276611,
0.7621321082115173,
0.5063760876655579,
-0.24075934290885925,
-0.950948178768158,
0.3998831808567047,
0.12021307647228241,
-0.27855464816093445,
0.2709910273551941,
-0.06350391358137131,
-0.11032125353813171,
-0.28584641218185425,
-0.5837125182151794,
-0.9368100166320801,
1.0615540742874146,
0.6371811628341675,
-0.8201196193695068,
-0.25857171416282654,
0.07212361693382263,
0.39947429299354553,
0.45951393246650696,
-0.05944672226905823,
0.8319066762924194,
0.41501861810684204,
-0.3972286581993103,
-1.1841362714767456,
0.324379563331604,
-0.013591569848358631,
-0.07270558923482895,
0.6108212471008301,
-0.8551039695739746,
1.00357186794281,
0.09943852573633194,
-0.43893206119537354,
-0.06681733578443527,
0.2703545093536377,
0.5511199831962585,
-0.009624568745493889,
0.6570910811424255,
0.7126878499984741,
0.5827005505561829,
-0.41795989871025085,
0.6570455431938171,
-0.2617935836315155,
0.2196226865053177,
0.8997892737388611,
-0.43087461590766907,
0.9923458695411682,
0.9370275139808655,
-0.03616796061396599,
0.3531284034252167,
0.4876404404640198,
0.3781302273273468,
0.7675995230674744,
0.06266938149929047,
-0.2841135561466217,
-0.44396618008613586,
0.08528391271829605,
-0.16565442085266113,
0.25608590245246887,
0.46578267216682434,
-0.18090181052684784,
-0.32749852538108826,
-0.27198246121406555,
0.45481961965560913,
-0.15343737602233887,
-0.1968754231929779,
0.8151745200157166,
0.3426230549812317,
-0.8873722553253174,
0.7546507120132446,
0.18959079682826996,
0.6190655827522278,
-0.7441356778144836,
0.11834508925676346,
-0.1413438618183136,
0.37693560123443604,
-0.29127201437950134,
-0.9349355697631836,
0.5000566244125366,
0.16802681982517242,
0.009891558438539505,
-0.27552539110183716,
0.6817294955253601,
-0.07787231355905533,
0.06201321631669998,
0.42215144634246826,
0.03600507602095604,
-0.1622776836156845,
0.3184424340724945,
-0.6024947166442871,
0.3026408851146698,
-0.10145477950572968,
-0.22872324287891388,
1.0972446203231812,
0.2773570120334625,
-0.33941546082496643,
0.6773538589477539,
0.6753968000411987,
0.1360594928264618,
-0.0015823377761989832,
-0.19806143641471863,
0.9687183499336243,
-0.6243446469306946,
-0.3401341736316681,
-1.073693871498108,
0.8914657235145569,
-0.08631408214569092,
-0.3823263645172119,
0.7626073956489563,
0.18634742498397827,
0.5029224157333374,
0.04339899495244026,
0.7506332993507385,
-0.2698516547679901,
0.01867613010108471,
-0.8353813290596008,
1.2006261348724365,
-0.5273156762123108,
0.5641610026359558,
-0.31480181217193604,
-0.5874484181404114,
-0.2776567339897156,
0.47826793789863586,
-0.5101575255393982,
-0.3441111147403717,
0.7710519433021545,
1.1986206769943237,
-0.18724031746387482,
-0.5065977573394775,
0.337155282497406,
0.37952643632888794,
0.2456468939781189,
0.6706823110580444,
0.8514595627784729,
-0.37757062911987305,
0.8123006224632263,
-0.2027846872806549,
-0.19037048518657684,
-0.1314130425453186,
-0.9791536927223206,
-0.8916276693344116,
-0.38904184103012085,
-0.3898123502731323,
-0.6137131452560425,
0.09541227668523788,
0.6084514856338501,
0.5716003775596619,
-0.7309683561325073,
-0.053809162229299545,
-0.23030246794223785,
0.3482550382614136,
-0.08022486418485641,
-0.18197159469127655,
0.4595376253128052,
0.0553537979722023,
-0.4677189588546753,
0.8096117973327637,
0.4852502644062042,
0.23249144852161407,
-0.06469441950321198,
0.10747362673282623,
-0.053616609424352646,
-0.0050544049590826035,
0.1675722748041153,
0.48006293177604675,
-0.5797325372695923,
-0.6835395097732544,
-0.19845354557037354,
-0.3414672613143921,
-0.09509536623954773,
0.39183980226516724,
0.0415368378162384,
-0.022122956812381744,
0.600785493850708,
0.43170106410980225,
-0.05460701510310173,
0.07208945602178574,
0.5905542373657227,
-0.9674909114837646,
0.3659283518791199,
0.19914428889751434,
0.69514000415802,
0.37303754687309265,
-0.07080245018005371,
0.20087887346744537,
-0.03012605383992195,
-0.8244724273681641,
-1.292920708656311,
0.4790315330028534,
-1.1411467790603638,
-0.12485429644584656,
1.019721508026123,
-0.10649619251489639,
-0.7016150951385498,
-0.39276862144470215,
-0.1012532040476799,
0.023852813988924026,
-0.02791222743690014,
0.92410808801651,
0.7886892557144165,
0.24116232991218567,
-0.13409563899040222,
-0.390485942363739,
0.7687377333641052,
0.7343106269836426,
-0.6678226590156555,
0.20258988440036774,
0.41524606943130493,
0.5884339809417725,
0.32645151019096375,
0.3350656032562256,
-0.4334854781627655,
0.23037177324295044,
-0.09283442795276642,
-0.09270777553319931,
0.4437374174594879,
-0.39645063877105713,
-0.6659113764762878,
0.39494258165359497,
0.7762083411216736,
0.03876621276140213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05070v1 | A Roadmap to Pluralistic Alignment | 2024-02-07T18:21:17 | 2024-02-07T18:21:17 | Taylor Sorensen, Jared Moore, Jillian Fisher, Mitchell Gordon, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Christopher Michael Rytting, Andre Ye, Liwei Jiang, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Tim Althoff, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | With increased power and prevalence of AI systems, it is ever more critical
that AI systems are designed to serve all, i.e., people with diverse values and
perspectives. However, aligning models to serve pluralistic human values
remains an open research question. In this piece, we propose a roadmap to
pluralistic alignment, specifically using language models as a test bed. We
identify and formalize three possible ways to define and operationalize
pluralism in AI systems: 1) Overton pluralistic models that present a spectrum
of reasonable responses; 2) Steerably pluralistic models that can steer to
reflect certain perspectives; and 3) Distributionally pluralistic models that
are well-calibrated to a given population in distribution. We also propose and
formalize three possible classes of pluralistic benchmarks: 1) Multi-objective
benchmarks, 2) Trade-off steerable benchmarks, which incentivize models to
steer to arbitrary trade-offs, and 3) Jury-pluralistic benchmarks which
explicitly model diverse human ratings. We use this framework to argue that
current alignment techniques may be fundamentally limited for pluralistic AI;
indeed, we highlight empirical evidence, both from our own experiments and from
other work, that standard alignment procedures might reduce distributional
pluralism in models, motivating the need for further research on pluralistic
alignment. | [
-0.5762485265731812,
-0.0994143933057785,
0.4879135191440582,
0.12590323388576508,
-0.04394214227795601,
0.027893127873539925,
-0.06103048473596573,
-0.4678066074848175,
-0.008521300740540028,
0.5938248634338379,
-0.4955316483974457,
-0.3022236227989197,
-0.6918550729751587,
-0.1604260951280594,
-0.4371499717235565,
1.1994187831878662,
0.08472751080989838,
0.0032163457944989204,
-0.2609582841396332,
-0.6302905678749084,
-0.7052138447761536,
-0.4061562418937683,
0.12489557266235352,
-0.1646377593278885,
0.6532922983169556,
0.41725558042526245,
1.252057671546936,
0.7575404047966003,
0.7475063800811768,
0.2785007655620575,
0.2997351884841919,
-0.22075200080871582,
-0.29465752840042114,
-0.037707772105932236,
-0.32277911901474,
-0.2057410627603531,
-0.36470046639442444,
0.3712298572063446,
0.7055312395095825,
0.9226118326187134,
-0.1894514262676239,
0.1843523532152176,
-0.2845548093318939,
0.5141183733940125,
-0.8311941623687744,
-0.302136093378067,
-0.5220535397529602,
-0.12073016911745071,
-0.17335839569568634,
0.5468363761901855,
-0.14047467708587646,
-0.6877822875976562,
0.29654744267463684,
-0.44742169976234436,
-0.17459800839424133,
-0.0320967473089695,
0.7244372963905334,
0.413041889667511,
-0.6937326788902283,
-0.11479213833808899,
-0.7950944900512695,
1.1237282752990723,
-0.858401894569397,
0.34166648983955383,
-0.004188049118965864,
0.5480068325996399,
0.3121248185634613,
-0.18597511947155,
-0.6535298824310303,
-0.0957389622926712,
0.03398112952709198,
0.3036954998970032,
0.025751356035470963,
0.052610792219638824,
-0.0913960188627243,
0.0871182531118393,
-0.502985417842865,
0.327205091714859,
-0.5223839282989502,
0.21778225898742676,
1.025740385055542,
0.2081027626991272,
0.4260525405406952,
0.26467016339302063,
-0.639735996723175,
0.06232867017388344,
-0.33588939905166626,
-0.1297074407339096,
0.6202031373977661,
0.5875121355056763,
0.03864560276269913,
0.7601690292358398,
0.13068829476833344,
0.7122263312339783,
-0.08454645425081253,
0.09005636721849442,
0.1376594603061676,
-0.572597086429596,
0.0836515799164772,
0.031284283846616745,
0.4937547743320465,
0.5071768164634705,
0.3364979922771454,
-0.2402750849723816,
-0.3273232877254486,
0.40568241477012634,
0.8007852435112,
-0.39302781224250793,
0.24417191743850708,
0.2294541448354721,
-0.35217684507369995,
-0.2564065754413605,
0.10705656558275223,
-0.46857622265815735,
-0.5376529097557068,
-0.6862941980361938,
0.3090102970600128,
-0.21858525276184082,
-0.40634697675704956,
0.0997786670923233,
-0.4112698435783386,
0.33256083726882935,
0.3709808886051178,
-1.2441482543945312,
0.524359405040741,
1.0996291637420654,
0.755791187286377,
-0.37100934982299805,
-0.4813150465488434,
0.12035854905843735,
0.29771775007247925,
-0.4194495677947998,
0.830779492855072,
-0.6511534452438354,
-0.33048656582832336,
0.051404766738414764,
-0.5734472870826721,
-0.15422531962394714,
-0.6043346524238586,
0.3411554992198944,
-0.19587498903274536,
0.39405420422554016,
-0.44603490829467773,
-0.6760196685791016,
-0.23103483021259308,
0.5033122897148132,
-0.6525890827178955,
0.4588247835636139,
0.010118101723492146,
-0.45292729139328003,
0.4774360656738281,
-0.8675050735473633,
-0.2981453537940979,
0.06292475014925003,
-0.4304533898830414,
-0.2453043907880783,
0.017707642167806625,
-0.14553840458393097,
0.04528301954269409,
-0.3274684250354767,
0.6211112141609192,
-0.4905996024608612,
-0.2772907614707947,
-0.029543373733758926,
-0.3292311131954193,
0.9575420618057251,
0.12132648378610611,
-0.4598100185394287,
0.39304280281066895,
-0.2719495892524719,
-0.031177500262856483,
-0.2727798819541931,
-0.2218165397644043,
-0.17349527776241302,
0.2661845088005066,
0.1492443084716797,
0.1748935431241989,
0.2837305963039398,
-0.23296909034252167,
0.6717725396156311,
-0.49172112345695496,
0.2626032829284668,
1.0743250846862793,
-0.589206337928772,
0.8011828064918518,
-0.6264113783836365,
0.5792871713638306,
0.10418887436389923,
0.35257598757743835,
0.5252671241760254,
-0.6278020143508911,
-0.39248427748680115,
-0.30262237787246704,
0.18110837042331696,
0.5898904204368591,
0.229906365275383,
0.7800760865211487,
-0.37496811151504517,
-0.48288869857788086,
-0.9330130815505981,
0.04957075044512749,
0.10222823917865753,
0.25585949420928955,
0.391448974609375,
-0.35159990191459656,
-0.5498313903808594,
-1.1622161865234375,
-0.4317721128463745,
-0.5926657915115356,
0.1875229775905609,
0.25196734070777893,
0.4224907457828522,
-0.4807187616825104,
1.162158727645874,
-0.1458652913570404,
-0.15125545859336853,
-0.17992715537548065,
0.16919833421707153,
-0.002047816291451454,
0.4729364216327667,
0.3393484055995941,
-1.0925105810165405,
-0.07989678531885147,
0.12965843081474304,
-0.6361913084983826,
-0.009512389078736305,
0.0827827975153923,
-0.26042160391807556,
-0.2419625222682953,
0.13942550122737885,
-0.5171698331832886,
0.2719118297100067,
0.5649969577789307,
-0.23609042167663574,
0.48745402693748474,
0.32650744915008545,
0.046351201832294464,
-1.1431118249893188,
0.2079361081123352,
-0.04065530374646187,
0.105187326669693,
-0.5924606323242188,
0.14810264110565186,
-0.18531906604766846,
0.002439433243125677,
-0.15731677412986755,
0.7743694186210632,
-0.18579010665416718,
-0.28559410572052,
-0.0945332869887352,
0.25967860221862793,
-0.07943636178970337,
-0.01993054710328579,
-0.16849084198474884,
0.6223045587539673,
0.21699051558971405,
-0.23961561918258667,
0.36251014471054077,
0.3400716483592987,
0.001628583762794733,
0.7706639766693115,
-0.6327179074287415,
-0.30581337213516235,
-0.3404880464076996,
0.27285706996917725,
-0.9765275716781616,
0.06844932585954666,
0.20349867641925812,
-0.23143848776817322,
-0.32722529768943787,
-0.075348399579525,
0.005852790083736181,
-0.15168218314647675,
-0.1418173909187317,
0.886668860912323,
0.4329879879951477,
-0.42760956287384033,
0.8099458813667297,
0.6442350149154663,
-0.16485218703746796,
-0.7248790264129639,
-0.2974311113357544,
0.07134731113910675,
-0.4766432046890259,
-0.8770864009857178,
0.6416863203048706,
-0.2392892986536026,
-0.7378212809562683,
-0.14524905383586884,
0.21979691088199615,
0.04438624903559685,
0.15125787258148193,
0.2970976233482361,
0.36562779545783997,
-0.3987908363342285,
0.27590882778167725,
-0.2586539685726166,
-0.1458858847618103,
-0.2885373532772064,
-0.5387932062149048,
0.23586437106132507,
-0.4888993799686432,
-0.6771178245544434,
-0.14332319796085358,
0.6960033774375916,
0.7051738500595093,
-0.28675588965415955,
0.5700231790542603,
0.45054465532302856,
-0.4223906397819519,
0.2377941757440567,
-0.6633970141410828,
0.016750726848840714,
-0.3993743658065796,
0.15961343050003052,
-0.003113607643172145,
-0.6244053840637207,
0.4305451214313507,
-0.06437753140926361,
0.6930537819862366,
0.49097633361816406,
0.6094192862510681,
-0.10126083344221115,
1.484447956085205,
0.7231143116950989,
-0.2979068160057068,
0.2817745804786682,
0.028052259236574173,
0.4467732608318329,
-0.6496506333351135,
-0.10039710253477097,
-0.5512490272521973,
-0.7688865065574646,
-0.4037390351295471,
-0.14549867808818817,
0.18724828958511353,
0.06273670494556427,
-0.40711143612861633,
0.1586529016494751,
-0.6358833312988281,
0.386597216129303,
0.6849955916404724,
-0.6851381659507751,
-0.02406647428870201,
-0.5223386287689209,
0.1375616192817688,
-0.06567951291799545,
-0.44321179389953613,
-0.7662796974182129,
0.9507047533988953,
0.19880448281764984,
0.7145233750343323,
0.5090707540512085,
0.7511680722236633,
0.34135037660598755,
0.6221235990524292,
-0.6290599703788757,
0.37818995118141174,
-0.2711291015148163,
-0.9059918522834778,
-0.5273208618164062,
-0.009490828029811382,
-0.8893836140632629,
0.437107652425766,
-0.05913815274834633,
-0.5683744549751282,
0.32448869943618774,
-0.01874103769659996,
-0.41569602489471436,
0.16239936649799347,
-0.7400850653648376,
1.2683298587799072,
-0.45151281356811523,
0.17112384736537933,
-0.03134160861372948,
-0.8062878847122192,
0.5117480754852295,
0.29712286591529846,
0.28329673409461975,
-0.49704885482788086,
-0.1287141889333725,
0.6236128211021423,
-0.24705365300178528,
0.9208924174308777,
-0.18341733515262604,
-0.123073510825634,
-0.12118203938007355,
-0.43558770418167114,
0.2587292790412903,
-0.1728256642818451,
-0.1928197592496872,
0.23929062485694885,
0.06807581335306168,
-0.6898341178894043,
-0.35701316595077515,
0.5291976928710938,
-1.2849537134170532,
-0.6268104314804077,
-0.338877409696579,
-0.7129799723625183,
-0.10128165781497955,
0.2330976277589798,
0.036225322633981705,
-0.045028626918792725,
-0.5889676809310913,
-0.20766505599021912,
0.37603774666786194,
0.42289820313453674,
0.22960956394672394,
0.23120950162410736,
-0.09348181635141373,
-0.2622966170310974,
0.8764751553535461,
0.2667047381401062,
0.2795982360839844,
0.09349194169044495,
0.178315669298172,
-0.5625442266464233,
-0.5078737139701843,
-0.6137716174125671,
0.012503273785114288,
-0.6133165955543518,
0.03503977507352829,
-0.45475077629089355,
-0.1824772208929062,
-0.9055253267288208,
-0.5991633534431458,
-0.49703338742256165,
-0.3956362009048462,
-0.3062574565410614,
-0.017210809513926506,
-0.16482201218605042,
0.8015061020851135,
0.06385490298271179,
0.14106936752796173,
-0.502176821231842,
0.3088536560535431,
0.4601473808288574,
0.18912841379642487,
-0.24470509588718414,
-0.36581650376319885,
-0.005937911570072174,
0.1846250593662262,
-0.3197523057460785,
-0.7307789921760559,
0.049562711268663406,
-0.00033021479612216353,
0.8011234402656555,
0.6515735983848572,
0.06044725328683853,
0.8452596068382263,
-0.4327482581138611,
0.7380032539367676,
0.3749532699584961,
-0.9468644857406616,
0.5078721046447754,
-0.26694032549858093,
0.21155701577663422,
0.8039611577987671,
0.4194357991218567,
-0.9841455221176147,
-0.41516393423080444,
-0.6042234897613525,
-0.8308852314949036,
0.2416885644197464,
-0.13991518318653107,
0.23162905871868134,
0.060227856040000916,
-0.041345398873090744,
0.3596988022327423,
0.3167796730995178,
-0.7919563055038452,
0.14928732812404633,
-0.2978029251098633,
-0.7167394757270813,
-0.1261993795633316,
0.3441675901412964,
-0.6820539832115173,
-0.022789670154452324,
0.5757228136062622,
-0.32260215282440186,
-0.16755157709121704,
-0.30973106622695923,
-0.029458973556756973,
-0.0017895803321152925,
0.31851235032081604,
0.749563992023468,
0.8995347023010254,
0.105363629758358,
0.1601555049419403,
-0.31503868103027344,
-0.01623290590941906,
0.42034950852394104,
0.3650115132331848,
-0.4254310429096222,
-0.3416707217693329,
0.19800826907157898,
0.5397508144378662,
-0.06661220639944077,
-0.7769625782966614,
0.699803352355957,
0.006777675822377205,
-0.05108916759490967,
-0.28742659091949463,
0.16686834394931793,
0.09131905436515808,
0.4741174876689911,
0.13249821960926056,
0.3635100722312927,
0.09120459109544754,
-0.4837556481361389,
-0.014527502469718456,
0.896722137928009,
-0.5043190717697144,
-0.32678768038749695,
0.5628470182418823,
0.2858324944972992,
-0.5921667814254761,
0.7130014896392822,
-0.008319302462041378,
-0.2914707660675049,
0.5486719608306885,
0.4018121063709259,
0.9180229902267456,
-0.24188275635242462,
0.32181331515312195,
-0.03847656771540642,
0.4041769802570343,
-0.2581235468387604,
0.05029669031500816,
0.15806040167808533,
-1.166106939315796,
0.008710477501153946,
-0.3897381126880646,
-0.4343959093093872,
-0.49934959411621094,
-0.6911244988441467,
0.1989414393901825,
-0.4084288477897644,
-0.20979368686676025,
0.4317823350429535,
-0.18801014125347137,
-0.3907969295978546,
0.1586492657661438,
0.3924035131931305,
0.40364474058151245,
-1.1743662357330322,
0.3931971788406372,
0.6626266837120056,
-0.6077383160591125,
-0.511198103427887,
-0.028088631108403206,
0.2146652340888977,
-0.9292824864387512,
0.2166224718093872,
0.18489716947078705,
0.009662285447120667,
-0.09105446189641953,
-0.5605452060699463,
-0.9198065996170044,
0.9000753164291382,
0.3104994595050812,
-0.3776715099811554,
-0.14766421914100647,
0.13597936928272247,
0.3294111490249634,
-0.6706883907318115,
0.20265555381774902,
0.46923181414604187,
0.8737953901290894,
-0.1334313452243805,
-0.7143567204475403,
-0.06543294340372086,
-0.39033541083335876,
0.11836230754852295,
0.41903379559516907,
-0.6194918751716614,
0.8086771965026855,
-0.3305244445800781,
-0.22433598339557648,
0.0744309276342392,
0.5310983061790466,
0.37186887860298157,
0.26283037662506104,
0.5891268849372864,
0.7452141046524048,
0.7114925384521484,
0.04122556000947952,
0.5969278812408447,
-0.020306788384914398,
-0.06956848502159119,
0.802483856678009,
-0.6420165300369263,
0.7200295329093933,
0.7132479548454285,
-0.23843073844909668,
0.5799346566200256,
0.5686790943145752,
-0.20314958691596985,
0.3517351448535919,
0.18839189410209656,
-0.3249126970767975,
-0.24553710222244263,
-0.3564576208591461,
-0.5314306616783142,
0.3127352297306061,
0.12397316098213196,
-0.03732376918196678,
-0.11987954378128052,
-0.0776609554886818,
-0.5261526107788086,
0.1559329330921173,
0.018342792987823486,
0.9413434863090515,
-0.2719400227069855,
-1.0839227437973022,
0.4058643877506256,
0.12339992821216583,
0.6195099353790283,
-0.37622183561325073,
0.07735943049192429,
-0.10826973617076874,
0.13261881470680237,
-0.04245591163635254,
-0.6351037621498108,
0.24602651596069336,
-0.35657191276550293,
-0.5645447969436646,
-0.3407474160194397,
0.2953847646713257,
-0.45011141896247864,
-0.5964845418930054,
0.22546865046024323,
0.4347991645336151,
0.11704878509044647,
0.16610141098499298,
-0.8562575578689575,
-0.04545237496495247,
-0.1425844132900238,
0.20334342122077942,
0.24922610819339752,
0.036793120205402374,
-0.3309333324432373,
0.5477520227432251,
0.5177572965621948,
0.039706673473119736,
0.17952248454093933,
0.42202866077423096,
0.5843401551246643,
-0.7007232308387756,
-0.5770230293273926,
-0.8272097110748291,
0.793712854385376,
-0.09986717998981476,
-0.736025333404541,
0.4526159167289734,
0.5390443205833435,
0.7891032695770264,
0.37868326902389526,
1.0918391942977905,
0.04084988310933113,
0.10696867108345032,
0.002542374422773719,
0.2504372298717499,
-0.5710553526878357,
0.1046372801065445,
-0.09460852295160294,
-0.8180721402168274,
-0.3526213467121124,
0.44367629289627075,
-0.4037322998046875,
0.23073890805244446,
-0.05824848636984825,
0.6239338517189026,
-0.10017755627632141,
0.1586110144853592,
0.2523166537284851,
-0.0664782002568245,
0.43278196454048157,
0.13776984810829163,
1.1675513982772827,
-0.25048384070396423,
0.4016854166984558,
0.17805199325084686,
-0.22266998887062073,
-0.36471495032310486,
-0.5099312663078308,
-0.33407625555992126,
-0.5110493302345276,
-0.30890822410583496,
0.042614392936229706,
0.2773143947124481,
0.749716579914093,
0.9964286684989929,
-0.7596010565757751,
-0.48634472489356995,
-0.2054312825202942,
0.3724566698074341,
-0.4490239918231964,
-0.20147623121738434,
-0.19055946171283722,
-0.29744982719421387,
-0.6106909513473511,
0.0901772752404213,
0.5895969271659851,
0.15878194570541382,
-0.599784791469574,
-0.20794489979743958,
-0.41659411787986755,
0.30402207374572754,
0.06600608676671982,
0.35890403389930725,
-1.1260178089141846,
-0.3847239315509796,
-0.0712520107626915,
-0.3669675886631012,
0.19430749118328094,
0.7354093790054321,
-0.3035966455936432,
0.28484025597572327,
0.2807672619819641,
0.5889790654182434,
-0.0795111432671547,
0.5366064310073853,
0.8395135402679443,
-0.5411165356636047,
-0.062222667038440704,
0.9121902585029602,
0.08953779190778732,
0.21566101908683777,
-0.13040463626384735,
0.244613379240036,
0.0007348852814175189,
-0.6701861023902893,
-0.7986366152763367,
0.6308937668800354,
-0.7620291113853455,
-0.31665173172950745,
0.6994249224662781,
0.15411347150802612,
0.09796363860368729,
-0.17941898107528687,
-0.06288547068834305,
-0.011864181607961655,
-0.1139722615480423,
1.001171588897705,
0.7235614657402039,
-0.15818949043750763,
0.20107832551002502,
-0.12756074965000153,
0.15970322489738464,
0.676304817199707,
-0.9183420538902283,
0.06646829098463058,
0.5796122550964355,
-0.020687608048319817,
0.4463594853878021,
0.7270470857620239,
-0.046011462807655334,
0.18529997766017914,
-0.11395196616649628,
0.22635191679000854,
0.7938634753227234,
-0.39206206798553467,
-0.26975879073143005,
0.05485730618238449,
0.05231548100709915,
-0.09042961150407791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05044v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05044v4 | SALAD-Bench: A Hierarchical and Comprehensive Safety Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T17:33:54 | 2024-06-07T12:05:46 | Lijun Li, Bowen Dong, Ruohui Wang, Xuhao Hu, Wangmeng Zuo, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Jing Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Large Language Models (LLMs), ensuring
robust safety measures is paramount. To meet this crucial need, we propose
\emph{SALAD-Bench}, a safety benchmark specifically designed for evaluating
LLMs, attack, and defense methods. Distinguished by its breadth, SALAD-Bench
transcends conventional benchmarks through its large scale, rich diversity,
intricate taxonomy spanning three levels, and versatile
functionalities.SALAD-Bench is crafted with a meticulous array of questions,
from standard queries to complex ones enriched with attack, defense
modifications and multiple-choice. To effectively manage the inherent
complexity, we introduce an innovative evaluators: the LLM-based MD-Judge for
QA pairs with a particular focus on attack-enhanced queries, ensuring a
seamless, and reliable evaluation. Above components extend SALAD-Bench from
standard LLM safety evaluation to both LLM attack and defense methods
evaluation, ensuring the joint-purpose utility. Our extensive experiments shed
light on the resilience of LLMs against emerging threats and the efficacy of
contemporary defense tactics. Data and evaluator are released under
https://github.com/OpenSafetyLab/SALAD-BENCH. | [
-0.33574220538139343,
-0.8563668727874756,
0.5245764255523682,
0.16995692253112793,
0.04416550695896149,
0.4879578649997711,
-0.1536276936531067,
-0.28541111946105957,
0.12945730984210968,
0.1488572210073471,
-0.3282538652420044,
-0.5792465806007385,
-0.5131486654281616,
0.035707585513591766,
-0.7471073269844055,
1.012155294418335,
-0.010113159194588661,
0.25952795147895813,
-0.27601370215415955,
-0.18584799766540527,
-0.3340093493461609,
-0.4140208065509796,
-0.6067900061607361,
0.03326329588890076,
0.6213464736938477,
0.11132287234067917,
0.7429649233818054,
0.6029222011566162,
0.740121603012085,
0.3172042965888977,
-0.15086720883846283,
-0.0644821748137474,
-0.5155683159828186,
0.541269838809967,
-0.5769040584564209,
-0.4467260241508484,
-0.6045457124710083,
-0.008750411681830883,
0.6538498401641846,
0.7609721422195435,
-0.4566604495048523,
-0.037948865443468094,
0.036106742918491364,
0.8403460383415222,
-1.204451322555542,
-0.23683342337608337,
-0.7450066208839417,
0.023225748911499977,
-0.4324542284011841,
0.09736622124910355,
-0.2134358137845993,
-0.60390305519104,
-0.1649899184703827,
-0.2624654769897461,
-0.336161732673645,
-0.0785728171467781,
0.6630236506462097,
0.20345140993595123,
-0.6852812170982361,
0.2784622013568878,
-0.4121144711971283,
0.6814441680908203,
-0.3362753093242645,
0.4400440752506256,
0.37338319420814514,
0.8529952168464661,
-0.49573180079460144,
-0.7714901566505432,
-0.4075542092323303,
-0.2602629065513611,
0.4515056312084198,
0.1990451216697693,
-0.12362842261791229,
0.1114632785320282,
-0.028152918443083763,
0.6987611055374146,
-0.5079709887504578,
0.13011126220226288,
0.23168295621871948,
0.1701865792274475,
0.6827353835105896,
0.3673775792121887,
0.4357343316078186,
-0.04020320996642113,
-0.5622504949569702,
-0.34177353978157043,
-0.7852961421012878,
-0.026035338640213013,
-0.12298130244016647,
-0.06232641637325287,
-0.356469064950943,
0.35154929757118225,
-0.5212929844856262,
0.3505637049674988,
-0.15275971591472626,
-0.16090284287929535,
0.23156379163265228,
-0.29270482063293457,
-0.21819858253002167,
-0.3947456181049347,
1.0935341119766235,
0.6439295411109924,
0.12422056496143341,
-0.3658430576324463,
-0.43986427783966064,
0.22159090638160706,
0.5683794021606445,
-0.7051694393157959,
-0.2954447865486145,
0.18707019090652466,
-0.31825536489486694,
-0.615983784198761,
-0.1737828403711319,
-1.1264045238494873,
-0.9613277912139893,
0.20016412436962128,
0.28578948974609375,
-0.2691182792186737,
-0.32194310426712036,
-0.13095834851264954,
-0.15771368145942688,
0.29220807552337646,
0.005899996496737003,
-0.7218696475028992,
0.7023084759712219,
0.9638785123825073,
0.6996449828147888,
-0.4242863059043884,
-0.19890210032463074,
-0.7762641310691833,
0.2555358409881592,
-0.7134658694267273,
0.7559504508972168,
-0.3769383728504181,
-0.4360457956790924,
0.1439635306596756,
-0.07594234496355057,
0.02489343285560608,
-0.6088610291481018,
0.8126950263977051,
-0.4995206892490387,
-0.269904226064682,
-0.47770047187805176,
-0.302888423204422,
-0.035289496183395386,
0.6647932529449463,
-0.7477335333824158,
0.8288403749465942,
0.21879543364048004,
-0.7937694787979126,
0.34616196155548096,
-0.3279336988925934,
-0.7094610929489136,
0.17264604568481445,
-0.5768422484397888,
-0.29570212960243225,
0.02959292382001877,
0.06890099495649338,
0.2698410451412201,
-0.9359399080276489,
0.2666286826133728,
-0.7206394076347351,
-0.07452534884214401,
0.4404385983943939,
-0.4652041792869568,
0.5698447227478027,
0.12907740473747253,
-0.18239590525627136,
0.39938613772392273,
-0.87981778383255,
0.2963012456893921,
0.2699192762374878,
-0.6716360449790955,
-0.2890494465827942,
0.15789513289928436,
0.04785890877246857,
-0.028686966747045517,
0.31036806106567383,
-0.36055487394332886,
-0.2412540316581726,
-0.39127272367477417,
0.4158966541290283,
0.8839794397354126,
-0.08323027938604355,
0.3677249848842621,
-0.5312547087669373,
0.6330867409706116,
-0.24865107238292694,
0.2583760917186737,
0.131156325340271,
-0.0024327218998223543,
-0.4847196638584137,
-0.6829782128334045,
0.6404786705970764,
0.6577825546264648,
-0.6758471131324768,
0.5680288672447205,
-0.2694180905818939,
-0.726088285446167,
-0.24149689078330994,
-0.08845676481723785,
0.6044435501098633,
0.16489340364933014,
0.21246939897537231,
-0.5477975606918335,
-0.45634087920188904,
-0.9367808103561401,
-0.6209884881973267,
0.017717963084578514,
0.03572574630379677,
0.04867546632885933,
0.3264991044998169,
-0.36005717515945435,
0.7598851323127747,
-0.21071399748325348,
0.23047851026058197,
-0.15694473683834076,
-0.3081018030643463,
0.30411556363105774,
0.5069741010665894,
0.7132493257522583,
-0.592384397983551,
-0.6105157732963562,
-0.02796550653874874,
-0.8031132817268372,
-0.02313026413321495,
0.18630394339561462,
-0.32179850339889526,
0.1884213238954544,
0.3646408021450043,
-0.9129541516304016,
0.09995809942483902,
0.5527616143226624,
-0.21748127043247223,
0.6637656688690186,
0.25616276264190674,
0.2735327482223511,
-1.1304670572280884,
0.17085213959217072,
-0.03252512961626053,
-0.2956271171569824,
-0.6509358882904053,
0.6919887065887451,
0.2832847833633423,
0.2112928181886673,
-0.18754275143146515,
0.3654179871082306,
0.007206907961517572,
-0.09151200950145721,
-0.04120047762989998,
-0.12177915871143341,
-0.10177122801542282,
0.005981439724564552,
-0.5018079876899719,
0.6658125519752502,
0.729952335357666,
-0.45138636231422424,
0.3953953981399536,
-0.002695856848731637,
-0.612663984298706,
0.860245406627655,
-0.6711118221282959,
0.068984754383564,
0.20294739305973053,
0.3717505633831024,
-1.1487113237380981,
-0.3398461639881134,
0.32610300183296204,
-0.029547495767474174,
0.4164777398109436,
-0.06273848563432693,
-0.5488954782485962,
-0.17520268261432648,
-0.7221648693084717,
0.4065297544002533,
0.4227784276008606,
-0.6900462508201599,
0.7554610967636108,
0.7509430646896362,
-0.22022745013237,
-0.797493040561676,
-0.4409620761871338,
0.30024561285972595,
-0.404769629240036,
-0.5523653030395508,
0.33325642347335815,
-0.31999459862709045,
-0.5704430341720581,
-0.29834261536598206,
-0.5809981226921082,
-0.26409420371055603,
0.6320957541465759,
0.3224093019962311,
0.20345710217952728,
0.025580815970897675,
-0.12742029130458832,
0.08420006185770035,
-0.003394294297322631,
0.4317668676376343,
0.19509781897068024,
0.6563385128974915,
-0.0717904269695282,
-0.22151197493076324,
-0.22320018708705902,
0.32658034563064575,
0.7723496556282043,
-0.33919596672058105,
0.6330799460411072,
0.21606115996837616,
-0.21731337904930115,
-0.23271998763084412,
-0.5473738312721252,
0.07491642236709595,
-0.5102782249450684,
0.4967842400074005,
-0.5748896598815918,
-0.4880974590778351,
0.23580463230609894,
-0.23362818360328674,
0.20090308785438538,
0.31155914068222046,
0.42010703682899475,
-0.18609993159770966,
0.8266460299491882,
0.06887032836675644,
-0.36078640818595886,
0.32177335023880005,
0.10911699384450912,
-0.05983998626470566,
-0.6428651213645935,
-0.14120297133922577,
-0.5650730133056641,
-0.16865652799606323,
-0.5691439509391785,
-0.29617300629615784,
0.550638735294342,
0.12491700053215027,
-0.5949709415435791,
0.13857388496398926,
-0.059026606380939484,
0.5211665630340576,
0.40702295303344727,
-0.03838568553328514,
0.0777604803442955,
-0.24890606105327606,
-0.3109101355075836,
0.22461651265621185,
-0.3804977238178253,
-0.2648567855358124,
1.2661854028701782,
0.6133636832237244,
0.9338663816452026,
0.3842296600341797,
0.8237789273262024,
0.21522586047649384,
0.0751059502363205,
-0.7427012920379639,
0.8348680734634399,
-0.17539143562316895,
-0.5438766479492188,
-0.08424260467290878,
-0.6921873092651367,
-0.8399767875671387,
0.6255912184715271,
-0.3272406756877899,
-0.5601598024368286,
-0.19445179402828217,
-0.0976453647017479,
-0.3842381238937378,
0.05433721840381622,
-0.49872153997421265,
0.9379333853721619,
-0.4849238097667694,
-0.5418160557746887,
-0.38619470596313477,
-0.5098928809165955,
0.4947023093700409,
-0.16557544469833374,
0.48233914375305176,
-0.12479323148727417,
-0.13322369754314423,
0.5848854780197144,
-0.2978005111217499,
0.5564731359481812,
0.08110447973012924,
-0.2561204433441162,
-0.16636911034584045,
0.5542008280754089,
0.5384653806686401,
0.051091112196445465,
-0.007751032244414091,
0.13894283771514893,
0.19677862524986267,
-0.1070152074098587,
-0.2703777849674225,
0.9987258911132812,
-0.5443188548088074,
-0.7910796999931335,
-0.6207720041275024,
-0.6260016560554504,
-0.5251286625862122,
0.4502379596233368,
-0.2789151966571808,
0.024227464571595192,
-0.5352548956871033,
0.4811493158340454,
0.6967730522155762,
-0.17558838427066803,
0.4448310136795044,
0.5531725287437439,
-0.22799326479434967,
-0.6988301873207092,
0.6289522051811218,
-0.07335922867059708,
0.25071513652801514,
0.4447527527809143,
0.11749786138534546,
-0.20909979939460754,
-0.7011086940765381,
-0.249108225107193,
-0.20945730805397034,
-0.8193299174308777,
-0.4789625406265259,
-0.5112333297729492,
-0.21584877371788025,
-0.18288959562778473,
0.08613892644643784,
-0.522087812423706,
-0.49485236406326294,
0.2842995822429657,
-0.06294500082731247,
0.14900219440460205,
0.537594735622406,
-0.08585673570632935,
-0.0324794203042984,
-0.57437664270401,
0.6528313755989075,
0.42909061908721924,
0.5697464346885681,
-0.13304640352725983,
-0.12129168212413788,
-0.030627239495515823,
-0.1802709996700287,
-0.512773871421814,
-0.8399832248687744,
0.055398982018232346,
0.06164293736219406,
0.5900463461875916,
0.4389467239379883,
0.20042988657951355,
0.18211252987384796,
-0.7402052879333496,
0.5916910171508789,
0.42087849974632263,
-0.8034565448760986,
0.2692275047302246,
-0.44785764813423157,
0.17443028092384338,
0.6348230242729187,
0.32287833094596863,
-0.3144969642162323,
-0.18762269616127014,
-0.09197758883237839,
-0.9862690567970276,
0.31190788745880127,
-0.13457989692687988,
-0.223361998796463,
-0.2808883488178253,
-0.1330033391714096,
0.026561811566352844,
0.17145495116710663,
-0.5302470326423645,
-0.14967721700668335,
0.027038123458623886,
-0.2815083861351013,
0.07588561624288559,
-0.36816054582595825,
-0.645026683807373,
-0.15074974298477173,
0.49519285559654236,
0.022378647699952126,
-0.2943000793457031,
-0.4167470932006836,
0.14991168677806854,
-0.24506869912147522,
0.586729884147644,
0.03177974373102188,
0.5894089341163635,
-0.12498503178358078,
0.21007075905799866,
0.4169449806213379,
-0.347440242767334,
0.12269917875528336,
0.3640504479408264,
0.10947365313768387,
-0.3736729621887207,
0.2220708578824997,
0.13146495819091797,
0.4949641525745392,
-0.9348762631416321,
0.5404526591300964,
-0.23604682087898254,
-0.038669995963573456,
-0.21647444367408752,
0.37628716230392456,
0.19456395506858826,
0.262023001909256,
0.20729908347129822,
-0.0011549112387001514,
0.3675016164779663,
-0.6229987740516663,
0.09353991597890854,
0.8062129616737366,
-0.047274038195610046,
0.1602410525083542,
0.506640613079071,
0.27077311277389526,
-0.015174176543951035,
0.1707323044538498,
0.13483721017837524,
-0.3861202001571655,
0.45856577157974243,
0.2950091063976288,
0.8731628656387329,
-0.4748464822769165,
-0.005283174104988575,
0.15408790111541748,
0.2856076657772064,
-0.04914578050374985,
0.4975426495075226,
0.002024463377892971,
-0.42469629645347595,
0.06727610528469086,
-0.7754349112510681,
-0.25704091787338257,
0.2892431914806366,
-0.6001700758934021,
-0.11200127750635147,
-0.8536031246185303,
-0.20562025904655457,
0.08932619541883469,
-0.11892212927341461,
-0.3257058262825012,
0.1482279896736145,
0.045275162905454636,
1.2993946075439453,
-0.46412378549575806,
0.5737774968147278,
0.7072284817695618,
-0.2326972931623459,
-0.23378346860408783,
0.1487695425748825,
0.2200714647769928,
-0.5338659882545471,
0.2709271013736725,
0.059473272413015366,
-0.27069762349128723,
-0.6162785291671753,
-0.31124308705329895,
-0.8865408301353455,
1.0260003805160522,
0.42654648423194885,
-1.0308756828308105,
0.11101318150758743,
0.22237084805965424,
0.38367775082588196,
0.026096569374203682,
0.06931370496749878,
0.9365928769111633,
0.371783047914505,
-0.11892088502645493,
-1.122204303741455,
0.31430572271347046,
-0.23664464056491852,
0.24985858798027039,
0.30000025033950806,
-0.6853204369544983,
0.9605693221092224,
0.1412704586982727,
-0.3148502707481384,
0.5878133773803711,
0.3879444897174835,
0.43869975209236145,
0.15369975566864014,
0.6047744750976562,
0.9050886034965515,
0.6292819380760193,
-0.17203103005886078,
1.4572480916976929,
-0.32422417402267456,
-0.04566870257258415,
1.2167127132415771,
-0.44627246260643005,
1.0735539197921753,
0.4455051124095917,
-0.35335201025009155,
0.38656219840049744,
0.5053229331970215,
0.1862088143825531,
0.885715901851654,
0.5070511698722839,
-0.3436371982097626,
-0.30214646458625793,
-0.095070481300354,
-0.5240153074264526,
0.43298113346099854,
0.28917601704597473,
-0.3631773293018341,
-0.1683870106935501,
-0.4122166037559509,
0.11557987332344055,
0.2263345569372177,
-0.3206155300140381,
0.8357215523719788,
0.235207661986351,
-0.5889669060707092,
0.7961249947547913,
0.06453564763069153,
0.44322267174720764,
-0.5653334259986877,
0.038992688059806824,
-0.16327333450317383,
0.45008936524391174,
-0.10231474041938782,
-0.9120991230010986,
-0.19237546622753143,
-0.061098646372556686,
-0.06231526657938957,
0.23520128428936005,
0.43218904733657837,
-0.20676183700561523,
-0.06532694399356842,
0.40983128547668457,
0.3001663088798523,
-0.194949671626091,
0.02116619423031807,
-0.6539014577865601,
0.4689857065677643,
-0.5629962682723999,
-0.08324728161096573,
0.607375979423523,
0.20977771282196045,
0.07555222511291504,
0.6840314865112305,
0.43176084756851196,
-0.20680661499500275,
-0.1002141535282135,
0.19021378457546234,
1.1363075971603394,
-0.5492733716964722,
-0.6090980172157288,
-0.8953359127044678,
0.4291527271270752,
-0.2191445529460907,
-0.18359790742397308,
0.7060667276382446,
0.5811432003974915,
0.7332441210746765,
-0.05780017375946045,
0.835382342338562,
-0.1610211282968521,
0.6118826270103455,
-0.4902932345867157,
1.1894558668136597,
-0.5011520981788635,
0.21324701607227325,
-0.304380863904953,
-0.8266128897666931,
0.0004217498644720763,
0.4168614447116852,
-0.15720325708389282,
0.2019704133272171,
0.759730339050293,
0.6745090484619141,
-0.003494019852951169,
0.0713680312037468,
0.2052823156118393,
0.3647541403770447,
0.33276551961898804,
0.683533251285553,
1.1056318283081055,
-0.33236053586006165,
0.4331868290901184,
-0.1924787014722824,
-0.533221423625946,
-0.08632955700159073,
-0.6869152784347534,
-1.1857496500015259,
-0.31527388095855713,
-0.2252589911222458,
-0.4340330958366394,
0.5008009672164917,
0.9047950506210327,
0.6623080372810364,
-0.8754515051841736,
-0.38721349835395813,
-0.1990550011396408,
0.03743757680058479,
-0.36155837774276733,
-0.18561817705631256,
0.16895683109760284,
-0.5111467242240906,
-0.47755807638168335,
0.9832631349563599,
0.11197412014007568,
-0.2717364728450775,
-0.15294358134269714,
-0.0743454173207283,
-0.2424810379743576,
0.10398732870817184,
0.5536897778511047,
0.2559818923473358,
-0.5575053691864014,
-0.09063851833343506,
-0.6092954874038696,
-0.22985611855983734,
-0.2275739163160324,
0.31801363825798035,
-0.4526589512825012,
0.3430313169956207,
0.4601064920425415,
1.186020851135254,
0.019972093403339386,
-0.2791661322116852,
0.8123592138290405,
-0.575496256351471,
-0.35435327887535095,
0.12605509161949158,
0.5944849848747253,
0.29096919298171997,
-0.15382005274295807,
0.7710584402084351,
-0.06154220923781395,
-0.40007084608078003,
-1.1091010570526123,
0.3215998113155365,
-0.9349961876869202,
-0.35928860306739807,
1.180146336555481,
-0.19335487484931946,
-0.2644014060497284,
0.213375061750412,
0.06683766096830368,
0.03336918354034424,
-0.36837172508239746,
1.0797741413116455,
0.46151936054229736,
0.48421791195869446,
-0.11946993321180344,
-0.38128793239593506,
0.7017024159431458,
0.5670737624168396,
-1.2297101020812988,
0.16294775903224945,
0.46229374408721924,
0.44358593225479126,
0.02989637665450573,
0.23435094952583313,
-0.3016793429851532,
0.6952388882637024,
-0.039742954075336456,
-0.2834849953651428,
0.2974188029766083,
-0.6356458067893982,
-0.28287604451179504,
0.4047190845012665,
0.13173852860927582,
-0.40264442563056946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05034v1 | How BERT Speaks Shakespearean English? Evaluating Historical Bias in Contextual Language Models | 2024-02-07T17:07:53 | 2024-02-07T17:07:53 | Miriam Cuscito, Alfio Ferrara, Martin Ruskov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; J.5 | In this paper, we explore the idea of analysing the historical bias of
contextual language models based on BERT by measuring their adequacy with
respect to Early Modern (EME) and Modern (ME) English. In our preliminary
experiments, we perform fill-in-the-blank tests with 60 masked sentences (20
EME-specific, 20 ME-specific and 20 generic) and three different models (i.e.,
BERT Base, MacBERTh, English HLM). We then rate the model predictions according
to a 5-point bipolar scale between the two language varieties and derive a
weighted score to measure the adequacy of each model to EME and ME varieties of
English. | [
-0.6115960478782654,
-0.9375202059745789,
0.4152766168117523,
0.1973385065793991,
0.09456345438957214,
-0.4104365110397339,
-0.37832751870155334,
-0.4977218508720398,
0.45752379298210144,
0.32896915078163147,
-0.4246343672275543,
-0.18680566549301147,
-0.3037763833999634,
0.01095503568649292,
-0.20114578306674957,
0.7067817449569702,
-0.006159660872071981,
0.6713023781776428,
0.04630411043763161,
-0.17368988692760468,
-0.6018738746643066,
-0.4871059060096741,
-0.4454769790172577,
-0.37864890694618225,
0.44677314162254333,
0.11409907788038254,
0.8210521340370178,
0.25220078229904175,
-0.032833829522132874,
0.26704835891723633,
-0.3535505533218384,
-0.3024541139602661,
-0.35999107360839844,
0.47087952494621277,
-0.23272550106048584,
-0.478333979845047,
-0.16591860353946686,
0.09074510633945465,
0.36246293783187866,
0.8742600083351135,
0.13539229333400726,
0.05871344357728958,
0.07433031499385834,
0.4381466805934906,
-0.5567452907562256,
-0.11764206737279892,
-0.7639115452766418,
0.03167267516255379,
-0.07932659238576889,
-0.04019754379987717,
-0.6781209111213684,
-0.26652243733406067,
0.47834163904190063,
-0.25046294927597046,
0.15165092051029205,
0.02131647616624832,
0.799035370349884,
-0.35477080941200256,
-0.6591787338256836,
-0.21350306272506714,
-0.5835340619087219,
1.1657572984695435,
-1.0931365489959717,
0.35741207003593445,
0.40581071376800537,
0.29476165771484375,
-0.0675830990076065,
-0.4979339838027954,
-0.5541409254074097,
-0.6537154316902161,
-0.12205501645803452,
0.15914294123649597,
-0.16278381645679474,
-0.09788565337657928,
0.060521744191646576,
0.17357225716114044,
-0.5308473110198975,
0.05109420046210289,
-0.34557247161865234,
-0.15506751835346222,
0.49242499470710754,
-0.25234347581863403,
0.20623384416103363,
-0.33434954285621643,
-0.45525845885276794,
-0.05813358724117279,
-0.4752906858921051,
0.3025057017803192,
0.5659130811691284,
0.27064523100852966,
0.174833744764328,
0.3967897295951843,
0.1589757353067398,
0.9141676425933838,
0.251278817653656,
-0.0264121163636446,
-0.0366225391626358,
-0.042584940791130066,
-0.1860870122909546,
-0.05704681575298309,
0.36325955390930176,
0.2932296097278595,
0.627532958984375,
-0.13969430327415466,
0.012848090380430222,
-0.3120611906051636,
0.20546483993530273,
-0.3998931646347046,
0.048094913363456726,
0.047282423824071884,
-0.5428282618522644,
-0.06700052320957184,
-0.04571395367383957,
-0.376472532749176,
-0.14205768704414368,
-0.14657506346702576,
0.7209547162055969,
-0.5451808571815491,
-0.0017672678222879767,
-0.2326267957687378,
-0.24867519736289978,
0.2579359710216522,
0.3054591119289398,
-0.9815886616706848,
0.1625620424747467,
0.490843266248703,
0.38061168789863586,
0.030641669407486916,
-0.35320016741752625,
0.03261912986636162,
0.14434364438056946,
-0.3810502588748932,
0.5740667581558228,
-0.5565776228904724,
-0.1722577065229416,
0.2754409909248352,
0.11486763507127762,
-0.011406389996409416,
-0.20741337537765503,
0.6542404890060425,
-0.30918294191360474,
0.6744135022163391,
-0.3178376853466034,
-0.6295650005340576,
-0.47655510902404785,
0.2624380886554718,
-0.6360801458358765,
0.7699024081230164,
0.0011889704037457705,
-0.698015570640564,
0.565901517868042,
-0.2710875868797302,
-0.49222850799560547,
-0.18436861038208008,
-0.346796452999115,
0.009676966816186905,
0.23704476654529572,
0.2886771559715271,
0.410518616437912,
0.04037078469991684,
0.5418326258659363,
-0.23061925172805786,
-0.30472511053085327,
0.24992793798446655,
-0.5698453187942505,
1.1629196405410767,
0.13254372775554657,
-0.656714141368866,
-0.39674869179725647,
-0.5288114547729492,
-0.03150635212659836,
-0.2078031301498413,
-0.28654032945632935,
-0.7199220657348633,
0.245650514960289,
0.1827717125415802,
0.15994440019130707,
0.2521527409553528,
-0.7565762996673584,
0.02415287122130394,
-0.5227199196815491,
0.2796044647693634,
0.6809412240982056,
-0.1800844669342041,
0.16897739470005035,
-0.6310426592826843,
0.1958073228597641,
-0.11003147065639496,
0.11345262080430984,
-0.2802235782146454,
-0.7298360466957092,
-0.7248695492744446,
-0.1030636802315712,
0.426397442817688,
0.2962638735771179,
-0.23568831384181976,
0.59035724401474,
-0.11843722313642502,
-0.3625135123729706,
-0.49421462416648865,
-0.2164648026227951,
0.10165594518184662,
0.4815683662891388,
0.2065790593624115,
-0.3821561634540558,
-0.45509594678878784,
-1.371870994567871,
-0.4082917273044586,
-0.28678005933761597,
-0.34950894117355347,
0.6688553094863892,
0.42677509784698486,
-0.01483133528381586,
1.155516505241394,
0.0767122134566307,
0.053022660315036774,
-0.03348337858915329,
0.2700726091861725,
0.20998293161392212,
0.5542618632316589,
0.993842363357544,
-0.4187646508216858,
-0.569304347038269,
-0.046801161020994186,
-0.24826407432556152,
-0.33070212602615356,
0.03706345707178116,
0.07107070833444595,
0.3983476459980011,
0.24716822803020477,
-0.06339460611343384,
0.32853952050209045,
0.8620188236236572,
-0.5381814241409302,
0.3543860614299774,
-0.07325533777475357,
0.44015049934387207,
-1.1474153995513916,
0.009369587525725365,
-0.1824304163455963,
-0.21174588799476624,
-0.6871930360794067,
-0.3561982810497284,
-0.025671452283859253,
-0.05686996877193451,
-0.5312784314155579,
0.6224002242088318,
-0.5709183812141418,
-0.0011165820760652423,
0.08855853974819183,
0.38498520851135254,
0.1381400227546692,
0.42527830600738525,
-0.03420663997530937,
0.2841242253780365,
0.37036827206611633,
-0.44408103823661804,
0.08214797079563141,
0.03601290285587311,
-0.26841968297958374,
0.49200496077537537,
-0.5027596354484558,
0.0005163091118447483,
-0.2064337432384491,
0.20935969054698944,
-1.42219078540802,
0.027665691450238228,
-0.4646674692630768,
-0.582811176776886,
0.3584845960140228,
0.02591308020055294,
-0.02002631314098835,
-0.1299321949481964,
-0.3642301559448242,
0.3258970081806183,
0.46331262588500977,
-0.43890896439552307,
0.6311140656471252,
0.2496451884508133,
-0.36654019355773926,
-0.7938510179519653,
-0.9770295023918152,
0.03259279578924179,
0.0750679224729538,
-1.0061311721801758,
0.2561004161834717,
0.0314590260386467,
-0.7233380675315857,
-0.08533426374197006,
-0.1037023663520813,
-0.3565226197242737,
0.02493613213300705,
-0.07161279767751694,
0.0032238734420388937,
-0.3882790207862854,
0.0241299606859684,
0.3206552565097809,
0.44925716519355774,
-0.15037855505943298,
-0.07952461391687393,
0.5030514001846313,
0.24490094184875488,
-0.3558734059333801,
-0.09490014612674713,
0.42431360483169556,
0.6864977478981018,
0.3532533049583435,
0.7631863355636597,
0.3092334270477295,
-0.3587770164012909,
-0.03297661617398262,
-0.9713480472564697,
-0.45418959856033325,
-0.34964972734451294,
0.27443426847457886,
-0.23706269264221191,
-0.9344854950904846,
0.8557263016700745,
0.44440409541130066,
0.3219758868217468,
0.7996140718460083,
0.7470881342887878,
-0.12145105749368668,
0.9986516833305359,
0.30269575119018555,
-0.10686571151018143,
0.6567230820655823,
0.16434027254581451,
0.0616367943584919,
-0.5796910524368286,
0.06889553368091583,
-0.5148293972015381,
-0.617927610874176,
-0.8453191518783569,
0.02701551280915737,
0.4800800383090973,
-0.06172043830156326,
-0.29672524333000183,
0.3416539132595062,
0.043932560831308365,
0.33167004585266113,
0.6751485466957092,
0.11365910619497299,
0.053385958075523376,
-0.17302657663822174,
-0.45733386278152466,
-0.29315921664237976,
-0.4843296408653259,
-0.8319818377494812,
1.179044246673584,
0.5173467397689819,
0.5482208132743835,
0.39630454778671265,
0.37111222743988037,
0.45238053798675537,
0.31062617897987366,
-0.5885133147239685,
0.3309095501899719,
-0.16572941839694977,
-1.3414069414138794,
-0.4014776647090912,
0.06396081298589706,
-1.0215914249420166,
0.4890110492706299,
-0.16116119921207428,
-0.7064931392669678,
0.487165629863739,
0.19215571880340576,
-0.16384589672088623,
0.1314893513917923,
-0.7921082377433777,
0.7549299597740173,
-0.26015597581863403,
-0.4400310814380646,
-0.3242173492908478,
-0.7025719881057739,
0.5181671977043152,
0.17557723820209503,
0.3841519355773926,
0.03806661069393158,
0.0749829038977623,
0.806898832321167,
-0.2833453118801117,
0.8907032608985901,
-0.1037655845284462,
-0.1436002105474472,
0.13304482400417328,
0.2044970542192459,
0.29687243700027466,
-0.08825894445180893,
-0.2380017638206482,
0.14319787919521332,
0.2251351773738861,
-0.7926928997039795,
-0.33358585834503174,
0.6865389347076416,
-0.6562045216560364,
-0.48208898305892944,
-0.49188125133514404,
-0.5061700940132141,
-0.337002694606781,
0.08502931892871857,
0.14135295152664185,
0.6199497580528259,
-0.7361263036727905,
0.35140830278396606,
0.3078126609325409,
-0.3491019904613495,
0.7530788779258728,
0.9188973903656006,
-0.13942541182041168,
-0.23237614333629608,
0.03807241469621658,
0.21449178457260132,
0.46634146571159363,
0.35226166248321533,
0.2963567078113556,
-0.06461116671562195,
-0.22271817922592163,
-0.24597132205963135,
0.01933150365948677,
-0.5359497666358948,
0.23589886724948883,
-0.3394385576248169,
0.0010590835008770227,
-0.6010258793830872,
-0.40767619013786316,
-0.1379888504743576,
-0.4803968667984009,
0.030867664143443108,
0.07746869325637817,
0.026905454695224762,
0.9194101095199585,
-0.10210428386926651,
0.35617613792419434,
-0.38960662484169006,
-0.2619061768054962,
0.5616846680641174,
0.0023637886624783278,
0.06327725201845169,
-0.6471779942512512,
-0.22706985473632812,
0.28848013281822205,
-0.4989902079105377,
-1.2521668672561646,
0.3616162836551666,
0.12117376178503036,
0.8110082745552063,
0.5010127425193787,
-0.2522720992565155,
0.2835821509361267,
-0.7617996335029602,
1.3247666358947754,
0.013906341046094894,
-1.1044962406158447,
0.47921523451805115,
-0.3299615681171417,
0.06283074617385864,
0.3178568482398987,
0.27867522835731506,
-0.6001631617546082,
-0.7411907911300659,
-0.7925766110420227,
-0.8439193367958069,
0.502038300037384,
0.13503947854042053,
0.2625647783279419,
-0.18849995732307434,
0.17317229509353638,
0.4050089716911316,
0.13966822624206543,
-1.0425786972045898,
-0.47951942682266235,
-0.058277152478694916,
-0.12406137585639954,
-0.16096286475658417,
-0.5844605565071106,
-0.07732673734426498,
-0.2864261269569397,
0.6048691272735596,
0.2549246549606323,
0.16294236481189728,
0.3387306034564972,
-0.44779032468795776,
-0.10266265273094177,
0.7041988968849182,
0.9088205695152283,
1.124765396118164,
-0.6147280931472778,
0.27596452832221985,
0.37484505772590637,
-0.6538885235786438,
-0.0962788537144661,
-0.012172400020062923,
-0.33156585693359375,
0.5793998837471008,
0.727617621421814,
0.7405781745910645,
0.362608402967453,
-0.5448060631752014,
0.6170297265052795,
0.16523265838623047,
-0.09191906452178955,
-0.3620067834854126,
-0.3759048283100128,
-0.19396263360977173,
0.22628825902938843,
0.5982192158699036,
-0.04306397587060928,
0.0464324988424778,
-0.8454581499099731,
0.2725012004375458,
0.5704954862594604,
-0.5312472581863403,
-0.31135424971580505,
0.49456942081451416,
0.3683667480945587,
-0.06371547281742096,
0.010417190380394459,
0.20692242681980133,
-0.7184948325157166,
0.45753273367881775,
0.6218698620796204,
0.9336062073707581,
-0.5156749486923218,
-0.04298187419772148,
0.36413389444351196,
0.6725596785545349,
0.29209914803504944,
0.2733757793903351,
0.022554412484169006,
-0.7552872896194458,
-0.5447705984115601,
-0.5082063674926758,
-0.509435772895813,
0.27350348234176636,
-0.7377124428749084,
0.08055166155099869,
0.11812132596969604,
-0.27893438935279846,
0.10351252555847168,
-0.03505268320441246,
-0.4850761890411377,
0.26619595289230347,
0.1709068864583969,
0.8963562250137329,
-1.1497703790664673,
0.7305052876472473,
0.6195521354675293,
-0.22520361840724945,
-0.46950653195381165,
0.14053356647491455,
-0.09888626635074615,
-0.9115509986877441,
0.9522351026535034,
-0.13444878160953522,
0.08579680323600769,
-0.09409573674201965,
-0.4800648093223572,
-0.7876211404800415,
0.8416264057159424,
0.2848820090293884,
-0.5818465948104858,
0.2116265743970871,
-0.4831175208091736,
0.5637040138244629,
-0.46061328053474426,
0.7302199602127075,
0.5194841027259827,
0.6839397549629211,
-0.30294424295425415,
-1.2253612279891968,
-0.38339918851852417,
0.05756404995918274,
0.04411577433347702,
-0.038334887474775314,
-0.27985525131225586,
1.1627216339111328,
0.11974412947893143,
-0.05939631536602974,
-0.05550963059067726,
0.46552401781082153,
-0.26422396302223206,
0.14118362963199615,
0.48672106862068176,
0.3121512234210968,
0.5222252011299133,
-0.2245895117521286,
0.8840823769569397,
-0.4761418402194977,
0.4515549838542938,
0.7581545114517212,
-0.186837837100029,
1.0469111204147339,
0.5480659604072571,
-0.27731940150260925,
0.704548716545105,
0.5856967568397522,
0.21116076409816742,
0.4026144742965698,
0.2914646863937378,
-0.3334599435329437,
0.10052420198917389,
-0.01985679380595684,
-0.353499174118042,
0.29851293563842773,
-0.024780232459306717,
-0.6617056131362915,
-0.1571376621723175,
0.10507562756538391,
0.3636226952075958,
0.17553822696208954,
-0.4157428741455078,
0.6046134829521179,
-0.21393407881259918,
-0.8580150008201599,
0.5790777802467346,
-0.00730495061725378,
0.7597382664680481,
-0.572087287902832,
0.35231122374534607,
-0.3645113706588745,
0.07267140597105026,
0.09846611320972443,
-0.6090720891952515,
0.2575400173664093,
-0.010091946460306644,
-0.29805445671081543,
-0.13290680944919586,
0.2614656090736389,
-0.7654784917831421,
-0.29284602403640747,
0.1615552306175232,
0.5428088307380676,
0.27824917435646057,
0.3724556565284729,
-0.3843427300453186,
-0.1290692239999771,
0.15745003521442413,
-0.36619099974632263,
0.0056234984658658504,
0.2883787751197815,
0.05739739164710045,
0.31425338983535767,
0.13860338926315308,
0.2735385000705719,
0.30041590332984924,
0.23003993928432465,
0.30329519510269165,
-0.8436034917831421,
-0.3918462097644806,
-0.9333427548408508,
0.5250603556632996,
0.03446044400334358,
-0.35461726784706116,
0.8726522922515869,
0.5934645533561707,
0.7150242924690247,
-0.25683486461639404,
0.8369584083557129,
-0.20720291137695312,
0.7744783759117126,
-0.3764132261276245,
0.697792112827301,
-0.49338284134864807,
-0.13253343105316162,
-0.2964218556880951,
-0.8920206427574158,
0.05298558995127678,
0.8256078362464905,
-0.4191408157348633,
0.2643459141254425,
0.9985254406929016,
0.45171234011650085,
0.10368156433105469,
-0.029565954580903053,
0.5507823824882507,
0.6243175864219666,
0.13812558352947235,
0.33256688714027405,
0.7950741648674011,
-0.43407532572746277,
0.08075384795665741,
0.016108019277453423,
-0.4385952949523926,
-0.2913619577884674,
-0.9986857771873474,
-0.928200364112854,
-0.6705707311630249,
0.031502705067396164,
-0.42733511328697205,
0.024715345352888107,
0.8380544185638428,
0.538459062576294,
-1.202776312828064,
-0.5381937026977539,
0.38606294989585876,
0.08193013072013855,
-0.25906795263290405,
-0.218903049826622,
0.3682551383972168,
-0.40919193625450134,
-1.0420782566070557,
0.32911545038223267,
0.05141505226492882,
0.19633643329143524,
-0.5439390540122986,
0.12854596972465515,
-0.4441511929035187,
0.5801362991333008,
0.6652428507804871,
0.04085959494113922,
-1.2234677076339722,
-0.5896248817443848,
0.03285541012883186,
-0.18462251126766205,
-0.1271311640739441,
0.7551354765892029,
-0.3836507797241211,
0.7870880365371704,
0.6349874138832092,
0.10462668538093567,
0.3607809543609619,
0.042172495275735855,
0.9760832190513611,
-0.8488868474960327,
0.26232022047042847,
0.2978787422180176,
0.6594984531402588,
0.3288789689540863,
0.09376795589923859,
0.12776443362236023,
0.0848655104637146,
-0.5436244010925293,
-0.6835346221923828,
0.2602463364601135,
-1.0395249128341675,
-0.4164606034755707,
1.0236315727233887,
-0.08386987447738647,
-0.03193778917193413,
-0.2504531443119049,
-0.3678867518901825,
0.11138218641281128,
-0.12499259412288666,
0.7323789000511169,
1.2066316604614258,
-0.01609610579907894,
0.1813821792602539,
-0.741655707359314,
0.3136759102344513,
0.612818717956543,
-0.07501707226037979,
-0.30460694432258606,
0.5987054109573364,
0.25521954894065857,
0.26977741718292236,
0.20084048807621002,
0.10987206548452377,
0.04848219454288483,
-0.13973765075206757,
0.35822877287864685,
0.29524633288383484,
0.1048867255449295,
-0.24612019956111908,
0.09394190460443497,
0.060632869601249695,
-0.1991751790046692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05000v1 | Pedagogical Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T16:15:59 | 2024-02-07T16:15:59 | Shashank Sonkar, Kangqi Ni, Sapana Chaudhary, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce the novel concept of pedagogically aligned Large
Language Models (LLMs) that signifies a transformative shift in the application
of LLMs within educational contexts. Rather than providing direct responses to
user queries, pedagogically-aligned LLMs function as scaffolding tools,
breaking complex problems into manageable subproblems and guiding students
towards the final answer through constructive feedback and hints. The objective
is to equip learners with problem-solving strategies that deepen their
understanding and internalization of the subject matter. Previous research in
this field has primarily applied the supervised finetuning approach without
framing the objective as an alignment problem, hence not employing
reinforcement learning through human feedback (RLHF) methods. This study
reinterprets the narrative by viewing the task through the lens of alignment
and demonstrates how RLHF methods emerge naturally as a superior alternative
for aligning LLM behaviour. Building on this perspective, we propose a novel
approach for constructing a reward dataset specifically designed for the
pedagogical alignment of LLMs. We apply three state-of-the-art RLHF algorithms
and find that they outperform SFT significantly. Our qualitative analyses
across model differences and hyperparameter sensitivity further validate the
superiority of RLHF over SFT. Also, our study sheds light on the potential of
online feedback for enhancing the performance of pedagogically-aligned LLMs,
thus providing valuable insights for the advancement of these models in
educational settings. | [
-0.09741247445344925,
-0.8883290886878967,
0.5085441470146179,
-0.11295060813426971,
-0.06534671038389206,
0.38606733083724976,
-0.5661043524742126,
-0.1832500845193863,
0.1472349613904953,
0.26894688606262207,
-0.7960020899772644,
-0.38102760910987854,
-0.42061787843704224,
-0.11270761489868164,
-0.23655574023723602,
1.0514816045761108,
-0.24004986882209778,
0.2175302356481552,
-0.3035484254360199,
0.025711171329021454,
-0.5429199934005737,
-0.5097938776016235,
-0.2853705585002899,
-0.6413707733154297,
0.7164185643196106,
0.41150352358818054,
0.6038331389427185,
0.9806070923805237,
0.6787043213844299,
0.2430545836687088,
0.11989530175924301,
0.17617042362689972,
-0.6093719005584717,
0.13708215951919556,
-0.39762943983078003,
-0.3420916199684143,
-0.202861949801445,
-0.012119315564632416,
0.5579906105995178,
0.891693115234375,
-0.5871248841285706,
0.16757972538471222,
0.47591137886047363,
0.7583902478218079,
-0.5155501365661621,
0.11328455060720444,
-0.1612522155046463,
0.1146138459444046,
-0.27751174569129944,
-0.12802904844284058,
-0.47290077805519104,
-0.523998498916626,
0.04296821355819702,
-0.6288304924964905,
-0.2992754578590393,
-0.23284921050071716,
0.7358391284942627,
0.3430198132991791,
-0.18748411536216736,
-0.15952053666114807,
-0.5461289286613464,
0.9198495149612427,
-0.6122923493385315,
0.3722398579120636,
0.04602116346359253,
0.3228248059749603,
-0.17712949216365814,
-0.30767908692359924,
-0.3468855917453766,
0.019007384777069092,
0.02814083732664585,
-0.03456154465675354,
0.4335036873817444,
-0.0993141308426857,
-0.028036728501319885,
0.24822694063186646,
-0.5071080327033997,
0.5840640664100647,
-0.15804295241832733,
-0.16005006432533264,
0.6321510076522827,
0.33287400007247925,
-0.033106036484241486,
0.0433642715215683,
-0.6862462759017944,
-0.2131182849407196,
-0.8125427961349487,
0.36596521735191345,
0.5545049905776978,
0.5908746719360352,
-0.16427810490131378,
0.5675035119056702,
0.07317265123128891,
0.9263105392456055,
0.4000098705291748,
-0.5232460498809814,
0.1082475334405899,
-0.1527853161096573,
0.05603206902742386,
0.2969830632209778,
0.6820542216300964,
0.3456874191761017,
0.4493524134159088,
-0.028569446876645088,
-0.34303709864616394,
0.09078516811132431,
0.2729192078113556,
-0.5473206639289856,
-0.09400586783885956,
0.008319856598973274,
-0.25423556566238403,
-0.550000786781311,
0.04780521243810654,
-0.5932258367538452,
-0.39770081639289856,
-0.6840213537216187,
0.516212522983551,
-0.1772850900888443,
-0.20604003965854645,
0.06521064788103104,
0.5118288397789001,
0.4806266129016876,
0.4404170513153076,
-1.1382554769515991,
0.2316194772720337,
1.1727734804153442,
0.556186318397522,
-0.5483934879302979,
-0.47090959548950195,
-0.46367159485816956,
0.3363272249698639,
-0.30129095911979675,
0.4560971260070801,
-0.6006025075912476,
-0.044979240745306015,
0.21709072589874268,
0.10488235950469971,
0.03274461627006531,
-0.4779568910598755,
0.3503280580043793,
-0.2980153262615204,
0.3932250738143921,
-0.05546162649989128,
-0.7805806994438171,
-0.11851976811885834,
0.4796125292778015,
-0.4090673625469208,
1.0694506168365479,
-0.06472250819206238,
-0.530029833316803,
0.021134423092007637,
-0.26659300923347473,
-0.20700068771839142,
-0.0008398682111874223,
-0.39437979459762573,
-0.38289323449134827,
-0.11143087595701218,
0.1338028907775879,
0.49368923902511597,
-0.16803789138793945,
0.8858639001846313,
-0.10614520311355591,
-0.5855018496513367,
0.42179083824157715,
-0.41676953434944153,
0.5883911848068237,
0.01593889109790325,
-0.5001245737075806,
0.376944363117218,
-0.35329142212867737,
0.035096101462841034,
0.26101288199424744,
-0.5569171905517578,
-0.1457897424697876,
0.026364104822278023,
-0.07980156689882278,
0.16477860510349274,
0.4160487651824951,
-0.3786082863807678,
0.38114070892333984,
-0.47946882247924805,
0.47872212529182434,
0.991511344909668,
-0.33504539728164673,
0.4765503406524658,
-0.43993625044822693,
0.5739505290985107,
-0.32729336619377136,
0.1215985044836998,
-0.11297475546598434,
-0.05540702864527702,
-0.28488612174987793,
-0.08050920069217682,
0.4837992787361145,
0.4483243227005005,
-0.31487536430358887,
0.3136657774448395,
-0.28009530901908875,
-0.323722779750824,
-0.7513743042945862,
0.35637953877449036,
0.5227513313293457,
0.5581275820732117,
0.06142781302332878,
-0.16179078817367554,
-0.3951522409915924,
-0.8568423390388489,
-0.35918810963630676,
0.02753950096666813,
0.11401891708374023,
-0.003771580057218671,
0.2072206437587738,
0.04482671990990639,
0.7521169185638428,
-0.34949150681495667,
-0.13880522549152374,
-0.04216291755437851,
-0.16514459252357483,
0.25980934500694275,
0.5893261432647705,
0.008240161463618279,
-0.6553333401679993,
-0.47057947516441345,
-0.01514963898807764,
-0.6762918829917908,
-0.1681688278913498,
-0.003522728104144335,
-0.06818034499883652,
0.25353220105171204,
0.4263710677623749,
-0.39699938893318176,
-0.11360850930213928,
0.5516465306282043,
-0.15490813553333282,
0.401960164308548,
0.10227086395025253,
0.01042855717241764,
-0.764083981513977,
-0.06125529855489731,
-0.07188501954078674,
-0.36963599920272827,
-0.2687793970108032,
0.19623900949954987,
0.22607597708702087,
0.03296421840786934,
-0.4910232424736023,
0.5567184090614319,
-0.34603986144065857,
-0.06242683529853821,
-0.32486093044281006,
0.404306560754776,
-0.05469035357236862,
0.7095820903778076,
0.21559451520442963,
0.481850802898407,
0.22952614724636078,
-0.2052716612815857,
0.5055853128433228,
0.09791827201843262,
-0.3750011920928955,
0.8707076907157898,
-0.4279792606830597,
0.04380744695663452,
-0.00861856434494257,
0.260832816362381,
-0.8791738748550415,
-0.1984744668006897,
0.27117490768432617,
-0.26111847162246704,
0.5448423624038696,
-0.03727997839450836,
-0.2843143045902252,
-0.07187896966934204,
-0.30744218826293945,
0.4654887020587921,
0.37955811619758606,
-0.7013049721717834,
0.38415059447288513,
0.4266500771045685,
-0.20404335856437683,
-0.7657214999198914,
-0.40838661789894104,
-0.16614845395088196,
-0.4110148549079895,
-0.38302889466285706,
0.48817285895347595,
0.011750318109989166,
-0.26525577902793884,
-0.03313656523823738,
-0.23453933000564575,
0.21143598854541779,
0.1917051523923874,
0.2726564109325409,
0.6271242499351501,
-0.2132854163646698,
0.20929114520549774,
-0.2124282717704773,
-0.1253383308649063,
0.033275868743658066,
-0.2387496381998062,
0.48367857933044434,
-0.03116450645029545,
-0.5302980542182922,
-0.4496763348579407,
0.2401227205991745,
0.3163910210132599,
-0.3009249269962311,
0.633632481098175,
0.412306010723114,
-0.31155070662498474,
-0.03082042559981346,
-0.53909832239151,
-0.29991328716278076,
-0.46028587222099304,
0.31406065821647644,
-0.07450578361749649,
-1.0769481658935547,
0.203322172164917,
-0.1180332601070404,
0.1553017497062683,
0.12048047035932541,
0.6552491188049316,
-0.2782200872898102,
1.022496223449707,
0.5798946619033813,
0.15550556778907776,
0.5087839365005493,
0.0425611287355423,
0.2792043685913086,
-0.8741468191146851,
-0.6499833464622498,
-0.21836790442466736,
-0.5452202558517456,
-0.4260888695716858,
-0.19411563873291016,
0.023843606933951378,
0.33818644285202026,
-0.6290726065635681,
0.12085855007171631,
-0.6562705039978027,
0.4426532983779907,
0.25902169942855835,
0.06939783692359924,
0.13962145149707794,
-0.07533984631299973,
-0.1472085416316986,
-0.20109058916568756,
-0.7081974744796753,
-0.6165949106216431,
1.0361292362213135,
0.4423303008079529,
0.9261508584022522,
0.24383750557899475,
0.8782137036323547,
-0.02312668412923813,
0.4344569146633148,
-0.7916553616523743,
0.43400493264198303,
0.136359304189682,
-0.3224309980869293,
-0.5680340528488159,
-0.14866842329502106,
-0.9146754741668701,
0.18529826402664185,
-0.219204843044281,
-0.7575643062591553,
-0.14057020843029022,
-0.05016268417239189,
-0.3573383688926697,
0.1488589197397232,
-0.6046603322029114,
0.9777006506919861,
-0.5968090891838074,
-0.982681930065155,
-0.03059452399611473,
-0.635603129863739,
0.18714751303195953,
-0.14709973335266113,
0.49509912729263306,
-0.03864847123622894,
-0.009478767402470112,
0.8997867107391357,
-0.4425240159034729,
1.0214107036590576,
-0.1427682489156723,
-0.5177008509635925,
0.20834767818450928,
0.09658297151327133,
0.7358961701393127,
-0.33265137672424316,
0.17045551538467407,
-0.17307747900485992,
0.08664362132549286,
-0.39795494079589844,
-0.47285565733909607,
1.124197244644165,
-0.6821779608726501,
-0.9025285243988037,
-0.44666603207588196,
-0.8480375409126282,
-0.2977989614009857,
0.056933339685201645,
-0.26575008034706116,
0.18402718007564545,
-0.04719630628824234,
0.03620348870754242,
0.7303498387336731,
-0.08147554099559784,
0.35760268568992615,
0.5678808689117432,
-0.40835466980934143,
-0.23461146652698517,
0.998169481754303,
0.1101985052227974,
0.3761104345321655,
0.6468914151191711,
0.23858988285064697,
-0.5602996349334717,
-0.2635282576084137,
-0.3717888593673706,
0.3143845200538635,
-0.6890285015106201,
-0.25531408190727234,
-0.1835010051727295,
0.009482437744736671,
-0.3545154631137848,
-0.4970490634441376,
-0.30307888984680176,
-0.28532055020332336,
-0.12358109652996063,
-0.1994088590145111,
0.04342075064778328,
0.8474742770195007,
0.05194317176938057,
0.28425323963165283,
-0.5890967845916748,
-0.150538831949234,
0.35290876030921936,
0.389921635389328,
0.06189535930752754,
-0.47566840052604675,
-0.26988375186920166,
0.06494620442390442,
-0.5095991492271423,
-0.8254796266555786,
0.2101253867149353,
-0.10474812239408493,
0.5900431871414185,
0.21914981305599213,
-0.11899859458208084,
0.6653267741203308,
-0.3914678990840912,
0.6658200621604919,
0.3535856008529663,
-0.8422625064849854,
0.36760854721069336,
-0.44268715381622314,
0.24213479459285736,
0.33695003390312195,
0.2975728511810303,
-0.5053063035011292,
-0.012996603734791279,
-0.4070558249950409,
-0.8159240484237671,
0.6567836999893188,
-0.41220059990882874,
-0.03590603545308113,
0.21505732834339142,
0.4139215052127838,
0.29086732864379883,
0.25701385736465454,
-0.7873413562774658,
-0.050098858773708344,
-0.05513472482562065,
-0.6321702599525452,
-0.11820464581251144,
-0.14506855607032776,
-0.35992342233657837,
-0.15450049936771393,
0.7219468355178833,
-0.2464512139558792,
-0.10315568745136261,
-0.21610437333583832,
-0.15765060484409332,
-0.3410950303077698,
0.3826269507408142,
0.4972459673881531,
0.7781524658203125,
-0.0413433276116848,
0.13319514691829681,
-0.20777028799057007,
-0.08473613113164902,
0.4175231456756592,
-0.051602356135845184,
-0.026012180373072624,
-0.5274559855461121,
0.4223008453845978,
0.56280517578125,
0.6929737329483032,
-0.8881115317344666,
0.614752471446991,
0.2789515256881714,
-0.13431411981582642,
-0.20739294588565826,
0.11444493383169174,
0.40240538120269775,
0.49371257424354553,
0.2592029571533203,
-0.5455726385116577,
-0.3113260269165039,
-0.573314905166626,
0.038337428122758865,
0.5337245464324951,
-0.4513595998287201,
-0.05449768900871277,
0.540267825126648,
0.1233845129609108,
-0.7145382761955261,
0.5562215447425842,
0.29822802543640137,
-0.4197928309440613,
0.5692017674446106,
0.757023274898529,
0.5134832262992859,
-0.24769063293933868,
0.26291993260383606,
0.31018924713134766,
0.06703872978687286,
-0.3480771481990814,
0.04831115901470184,
-0.1991458237171173,
-0.6321036219596863,
-0.780608594417572,
-0.7043542265892029,
-0.4339067339897156,
0.00808172021061182,
-0.8343205451965332,
0.3232171833515167,
-0.3377333879470825,
0.1497890055179596,
-0.09208398312330246,
-0.062374792993068695,
-0.2703980505466461,
-0.0018676219042390585,
0.2392227053642273,
0.48163965344429016,
-0.7908124923706055,
0.9021041989326477,
0.7974777817726135,
-0.16932742297649384,
-1.1543573141098022,
-0.08487308025360107,
0.2198052704334259,
-0.8745521306991577,
0.7184898257255554,
0.08655586838722229,
0.10559523105621338,
0.06250574439764023,
-0.47748321294784546,
-0.9510736465454102,
1.1230928897857666,
0.552261233329773,
-0.9994466304779053,
-0.14172959327697754,
0.03979814797639847,
0.3845013678073883,
-0.42435646057128906,
-0.09859520196914673,
0.4397512674331665,
0.5628025531768799,
-0.05959315970540047,
-0.9459964036941528,
0.02115965262055397,
0.04426922649145126,
-0.1744314283132553,
0.5992146730422974,
-0.5996753573417664,
0.6176230311393738,
-0.21358317136764526,
-0.05417374521493912,
-0.06277907639741898,
0.37532997131347656,
0.43242040276527405,
0.10768014192581177,
0.23156201839447021,
0.718086838722229,
0.6460718512535095,
-0.3307479918003082,
0.7494611740112305,
-0.0890202522277832,
0.49210989475250244,
1.1588916778564453,
-0.28866705298423767,
0.7785887718200684,
1.0259606838226318,
-0.3371667265892029,
0.4814120829105377,
0.7811881899833679,
0.040410302579402924,
0.5174475908279419,
0.4621029794216156,
0.061092574149370193,
-0.4166659414768219,
-0.25233250856399536,
-0.31570371985435486,
0.343374639749527,
0.20006144046783447,
-0.08330439776182175,
-0.25158265233039856,
0.042212773114442825,
-0.22774627804756165,
0.6637200713157654,
-0.5769942402839661,
0.6633781790733337,
-0.06940270960330963,
-0.946624755859375,
0.624588131904602,
-0.02370617352426052,
0.8282524943351746,
-0.519787073135376,
-0.15788264572620392,
-0.0065484545193612576,
0.31702497601509094,
-0.47730401158332825,
-1.0254175662994385,
0.10504966974258423,
-0.1690824180841446,
-0.14188385009765625,
-0.4572059214115143,
0.28347834944725037,
-0.8205490708351135,
-0.23475410044193268,
0.1889558732509613,
0.30571073293685913,
-0.07786735892295837,
0.4513213336467743,
-0.6364023089408875,
0.30628278851509094,
0.03295287489891052,
-0.053144894540309906,
0.7527657747268677,
0.22448723018169403,
-0.20794087648391724,
0.5770148634910583,
0.4568383991718292,
-0.025147315114736557,
-0.13483448326587677,
-0.02729494497179985,
0.4777224361896515,
-0.532333254814148,
-0.4703197777271271,
-0.8674098253250122,
0.39545193314552307,
0.292989045381546,
-0.1721733957529068,
0.6260938048362732,
0.4158865809440613,
1.1891443729400635,
0.070204958319664,
0.3830035924911499,
0.25445523858070374,
0.529784619808197,
-0.5788305401802063,
0.14953400194644928,
-0.3042576313018799,
0.48223623633384705,
-0.20308369398117065,
-0.9097961187362671,
-0.17674915492534637,
0.6954708695411682,
-0.4861258268356323,
-0.039822597056627274,
0.43349725008010864,
0.5788636803627014,
0.17796555161476135,
-0.058296531438827515,
0.18111290037631989,
-0.018065443262457848,
0.07667981833219528,
0.7072585821151733,
1.093405842781067,
-0.15476469695568085,
0.2853178381919861,
-0.3828801214694977,
-0.12402913719415665,
-0.2842850983142853,
-0.878065824508667,
-0.657175600528717,
-0.485971599817276,
-0.423204630613327,
-0.207437664270401,
0.29904064536094666,
1.1834222078323364,
0.3367014229297638,
-0.5979517102241516,
-0.48224255442619324,
-0.05904877558350563,
0.29323169589042664,
-0.44355225563049316,
-0.2845727503299713,
0.5242577195167542,
-0.21876148879528046,
-0.7266970276832581,
0.25071650743484497,
0.24692456424236298,
-0.042730677872896194,
-0.5123388171195984,
-0.38024231791496277,
-0.3958439826965332,
-0.14385096728801727,
0.2217952013015747,
0.23262667655944824,
-0.9377883076667786,
-0.39077135920524597,
0.10667401552200317,
-0.2996843159198761,
0.018198644742369652,
0.7623315453529358,
-0.8044646382331848,
0.19126302003860474,
0.2882334589958191,
0.9540678858757019,
0.2937057912349701,
0.08661635220050812,
0.4605395495891571,
-0.49070075154304504,
-0.012670634314417839,
0.21663586795330048,
0.23266318440437317,
0.4454924166202545,
-0.3887538015842438,
0.40897461771965027,
0.004869379103183746,
-0.6251489520072937,
-1.0380256175994873,
0.18818432092666626,
-0.7207261919975281,
-0.35214224457740784,
0.8692425489425659,
-0.14552347362041473,
-0.2035617083311081,
0.29368263483047485,
-0.2061864286661148,
0.2687046527862549,
-0.19023603200912476,
0.9455000758171082,
0.8821874260902405,
-0.1875084936618805,
-0.18390633165836334,
-0.1949949562549591,
0.24122057855129242,
0.7513517737388611,
-0.5729379653930664,
0.15565285086631775,
0.4304986596107483,
0.4006558656692505,
-0.03811538591980934,
0.28289833664894104,
-0.30676764249801636,
0.18412868678569794,
-0.5434826016426086,
0.07009447365999222,
-0.2335653007030487,
-0.2942923903465271,
-0.6749611496925354,
0.38146281242370605,
0.21489636600017548,
-0.06487070769071579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04978v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04978v2 | An Enhanced Prompt-Based LLM Reasoning Scheme via Knowledge Graph-Integrated Collaboration | 2024-02-07T15:56:17 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 | Yihao Li, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in a
multitude of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, they encounter challenges
in practical applications, including issues with hallucinations, inadequate
knowledge updating, and limited transparency in the reasoning process. To
overcome these limitations, this study innovatively proposes a collaborative
training-free reasoning scheme involving tight cooperation between Knowledge
Graph (KG) and LLMs. This scheme first involves using LLMs to iteratively
explore KG, selectively retrieving a task-relevant knowledge subgraph to
support reasoning. The LLMs are then guided to further combine inherent
implicit knowledge to reason on the subgraph while explicitly elucidating the
reasoning process. Through such a cooperative approach, our scheme achieves
more reliable knowledge-based reasoning and facilitates the tracing of the
reasoning results. Experimental results show that our scheme significantly
progressed across multiple datasets, notably achieving over a 10% improvement
on the QALD10 dataset compared to the best baseline and the fine-tuned
state-of-the-art (SOTA) work. Building on this success, this study hopes to
offer a valuable reference for future research in the fusion of KG and LLMs,
thereby enhancing LLMs' proficiency in solving complex issues. | [
-0.35555145144462585,
-0.6244151592254639,
0.9024276733398438,
0.22553713619709015,
-0.214875265955925,
0.3907794952392578,
-0.3424217998981476,
-0.3813847601413727,
0.2187855839729309,
0.5015023350715637,
-0.7470880746841431,
-0.7185789942741394,
-0.539419949054718,
0.35814177989959717,
0.0918969064950943,
0.4001253843307495,
-0.2224086970090866,
0.09551034867763519,
-0.6351988315582275,
-0.26298436522483826,
-0.6527621746063232,
-0.39412739872932434,
-0.6560518145561218,
-0.6198545098304749,
0.6538623571395874,
0.5864585638046265,
0.5923348665237427,
0.24586986005306244,
0.3480582535266876,
0.28328225016593933,
-0.19514323770999908,
0.898093581199646,
-0.31688883900642395,
0.5518062710762024,
-0.3329241871833801,
-0.4315713346004486,
-0.4335211217403412,
-0.0977000892162323,
0.28836590051651,
0.847980797290802,
-0.02998066321015358,
-0.2071588933467865,
0.30735665559768677,
0.6860963702201843,
-0.3840692937374115,
0.3755551874637604,
-0.6007462739944458,
-0.07698528468608856,
0.06669836491346359,
-0.22508341073989868,
-0.5355191230773926,
-0.37995272874832153,
-0.032608792185783386,
-0.8975708484649658,
-0.19006206095218658,
0.3890291154384613,
0.4114859998226166,
0.391583114862442,
-0.14172688126564026,
-0.39330142736434937,
-0.2307833433151245,
0.6243546605110168,
-0.4905291795730591,
0.36260348558425903,
0.26123329997062683,
0.42327767610549927,
-0.5181016325950623,
-0.7551195025444031,
-0.7177186012268066,
-0.2477957308292389,
-0.17474813759326935,
0.13038165867328644,
-0.06454262882471085,
0.22277231514453888,
0.31570979952812195,
0.12183663994073868,
-0.5460155606269836,
0.15501263737678528,
0.16519679129123688,
-0.4288633465766907,
0.5045486092567444,
0.21768027544021606,
0.2532444894313812,
-0.1276063770055771,
-0.37361884117126465,
0.17794977128505707,
-0.5257585644721985,
-0.06255584210157394,
0.007488316390663385,
0.4701555669307709,
-0.14970754086971283,
0.6989033818244934,
-0.5226666927337646,
0.631129264831543,
-0.16959761083126068,
-0.06085563823580742,
0.11077060550451279,
-0.3861115574836731,
-0.2051469385623932,
0.0782097578048706,
0.8954647183418274,
0.444112628698349,
0.2986215353012085,
-0.4359584450721741,
-0.02147342637181282,
0.19420507550239563,
-0.39688628911972046,
-0.3689347505569458,
-0.14773547649383545,
0.2727457880973816,
-0.02833356149494648,
0.018479814752936363,
-0.3694325387477875,
-0.33552756905555725,
-0.5174081921577454,
-0.4650552570819855,
0.36575886607170105,
-0.5894570350646973,
-0.11541572213172913,
0.2621977925300598,
-0.18839693069458008,
0.02822793647646904,
0.6938562989234924,
-0.6476821899414062,
0.13710017502307892,
0.8170657753944397,
0.704645574092865,
-0.1436329036951065,
-0.2321799099445343,
-0.6603026986122131,
0.45498836040496826,
-0.1370544135570526,
0.9632312059402466,
-0.4696325659751892,
-0.19391097128391266,
-0.24681919813156128,
-0.22283527255058289,
-0.13676555454730988,
-0.5791648030281067,
0.4650588631629944,
-0.6238268613815308,
0.2037239968776703,
-0.44029372930526733,
-0.7622512578964233,
-0.11457862704992294,
0.7448152303695679,
-0.4958082437515259,
0.9981192350387573,
0.0836733877658844,
-0.9075446128845215,
0.20602908730506897,
-0.5135411620140076,
-0.0645526573061943,
0.48207828402519226,
-0.5088786482810974,
-0.02606196515262127,
-0.6278602480888367,
0.5312256813049316,
0.43394315242767334,
-0.4284045994281769,
0.5195127129554749,
-0.5074595212936401,
-0.32778456807136536,
0.03871965408325195,
-0.07773986458778381,
0.9136948585510254,
-0.018719779327511787,
-0.14872819185256958,
0.33680981397628784,
-0.6029670238494873,
0.19948935508728027,
0.14365719258785248,
-0.16472092270851135,
-0.2633090913295746,
-0.5368494987487793,
-0.6992799639701843,
-0.0034883792977780104,
0.4982859194278717,
-0.3574831187725067,
0.5020889043807983,
-0.22772450745105743,
0.1469634473323822,
0.6525620818138123,
0.14868202805519104,
0.5181699991226196,
-0.35193490982055664,
0.38306868076324463,
-0.2303166687488556,
0.22274470329284668,
-0.07218527793884277,
-0.6854894161224365,
-0.7204828262329102,
-0.35982081294059753,
0.08222014456987381,
0.6065767407417297,
-1.1845452785491943,
0.5046119689941406,
-0.06514468044042587,
-0.13043202459812164,
-0.3450537621974945,
0.16457469761371613,
0.32432419061660767,
0.8102723956108093,
0.536750316619873,
-0.024213992059230804,
-0.5755966901779175,
-0.6327173113822937,
-0.1880304366350174,
-0.16449393332004547,
-0.06485548615455627,
0.43773627281188965,
0.25348296761512756,
-0.18558648228645325,
1.1266798973083496,
-0.3747345209121704,
-0.24627821147441864,
-0.657695472240448,
0.06332240998744965,
0.26378515362739563,
0.36791953444480896,
0.1273173987865448,
-0.39196377992630005,
-0.6024462580680847,
-0.1750251054763794,
-1.0697095394134521,
-0.3592272698879242,
0.09877185523509979,
-0.549566388130188,
-0.004467719700187445,
0.5504154562950134,
-0.6730427742004395,
0.019560934975743294,
0.4370865821838379,
-0.42487573623657227,
0.5469236373901367,
-0.19019508361816406,
0.041189294308423996,
-1.054175853729248,
-0.2111557424068451,
-0.298897922039032,
-0.28753358125686646,
-0.20257237553596497,
0.03067256696522236,
-0.23207738995552063,
0.054949041455984116,
-0.06654620915651321,
0.5604488849639893,
-0.3151701092720032,
-0.007497061509639025,
-0.10972132533788681,
0.5857515335083008,
0.16506440937519073,
0.5744079947471619,
-0.01485522836446762,
0.7386804223060608,
0.6499943137168884,
-0.4939342737197876,
0.6981277465820312,
0.43847718834877014,
-0.10886282473802567,
0.618467390537262,
-0.3470630645751953,
0.37098297476768494,
-0.02979877032339573,
0.4355418086051941,
-0.869143009185791,
-0.2456621378660202,
0.5969976782798767,
-0.5286560654640198,
0.09739866107702255,
0.034245897084474564,
-0.8552531003952026,
-0.3247790038585663,
-0.06892022490501404,
0.06264344602823257,
0.2312551885843277,
-0.6843013763427734,
0.782538890838623,
0.0936368852853775,
-0.08578607439994812,
-0.5825092792510986,
-0.36177632212638855,
0.24074265360832214,
0.04252462461590767,
-1.1183068752288818,
0.3842310905456543,
-0.048114530742168427,
-0.41646629571914673,
0.15635168552398682,
0.021163171157240868,
0.038061100989580154,
0.05628550052642822,
0.07533162087202072,
0.1817050278186798,
0.07431226223707199,
0.21893687546253204,
0.21176202595233917,
-0.4381333887577057,
-0.06508147716522217,
-0.33438149094581604,
0.5670068860054016,
-0.08921802043914795,
-0.5115553736686707,
-0.45819059014320374,
0.3662542998790741,
0.2907453775405884,
-0.0900118350982666,
0.8635101914405823,
0.39178356528282166,
-0.25881150364875793,
-0.39049455523490906,
-0.5268076062202454,
-0.33945244550704956,
-0.4788020849227905,
-0.11504627764225006,
-0.24458648264408112,
-1.244510531425476,
0.47194498777389526,
-0.6312842965126038,
-0.1984025239944458,
0.10111888498067856,
0.4007824957370758,
-0.1889665424823761,
0.7948600053787231,
0.4740861654281616,
0.09490733593702316,
0.0805964469909668,
-0.20920388400554657,
0.09371250867843628,
-0.8519058227539062,
-0.759526252746582,
-0.37083759903907776,
-0.11192285269498825,
-0.020869940519332886,
-0.595710277557373,
0.5996628999710083,
0.4722610414028168,
-0.20150060951709747,
0.0025880022440105677,
-0.44823282957077026,
0.5245883464813232,
0.6404367685317993,
0.29620540142059326,
0.638796865940094,
-0.10070184618234634,
-0.8158344030380249,
0.002213850384578109,
-0.9043375849723816,
-0.41036316752433777,
0.6436214447021484,
-0.06745930016040802,
0.44308310747146606,
-0.009419924579560757,
0.8070207238197327,
0.23008014261722565,
0.19532206654548645,
-0.6779500246047974,
0.9891600012779236,
0.21566785871982574,
-0.03433598205447197,
-0.4636645019054413,
-0.5124559998512268,
-0.7418556213378906,
0.21253430843353271,
-0.2891194522380829,
-0.7578228116035461,
-0.38863757252693176,
0.11885014921426773,
-0.17753979563713074,
0.2069094330072403,
-0.570735514163971,
0.5779206156730652,
-0.0940871462225914,
-0.5094531774520874,
-0.31524670124053955,
-0.7083733677864075,
0.32064321637153625,
0.2503420412540436,
0.2853289544582367,
-0.3245117962360382,
0.16198354959487915,
0.6131079196929932,
-0.5481696128845215,
0.7946484088897705,
-0.3388257920742035,
-0.09033479541540146,
0.4688337743282318,
0.1217159554362297,
0.8745779395103455,
0.08360665291547775,
-0.12673546373844147,
-0.028862357139587402,
-0.588297963142395,
-0.24604278802871704,
-0.8908715844154358,
0.5115132331848145,
-0.48015743494033813,
-0.7524735927581787,
-0.07894349843263626,
-1.0211488008499146,
-0.6350660920143127,
0.22247788310050964,
-0.012197595089673996,
0.24300509691238403,
0.31742554903030396,
0.15748904645442963,
0.6408768892288208,
-0.11749622225761414,
0.2560342848300934,
0.4626893103122711,
-0.2501119077205658,
-0.6247838139533997,
0.5092863440513611,
-0.010008400306105614,
0.226856991648674,
0.4100968837738037,
0.3808732032775879,
-0.4271741211414337,
-0.5831302404403687,
-0.4942500591278076,
0.3580760955810547,
-0.9669907689094543,
-0.18655383586883545,
-0.7268562316894531,
-0.058485113084316254,
-0.4337252974510193,
-0.2578832805156708,
-0.05744588375091553,
-0.40133315324783325,
-0.06004074588418007,
-0.022272499278187752,
0.6159133315086365,
0.34189918637275696,
0.022594790905714035,
0.08949961513280869,
-0.9328346252441406,
0.20645762979984283,
0.5069482922554016,
0.2572037875652313,
0.053815945982933044,
-0.3702566623687744,
-0.0994764044880867,
-0.2355145514011383,
-0.05052889138460159,
-0.7251396775245667,
0.090975321829319,
-0.31890663504600525,
0.9056285619735718,
-0.016757631674408913,
0.38742783665657043,
0.4570356607437134,
-0.09136523306369781,
0.7424376606941223,
0.26237952709198,
-0.9119029641151428,
0.4830326735973358,
-0.5184054970741272,
0.23576731979846954,
0.6205300688743591,
0.3243330717086792,
-0.4793340861797333,
-0.5460318326950073,
-0.4906305968761444,
-0.7970088720321655,
0.5303559303283691,
0.3056989014148712,
-0.3795422911643982,
0.16745468974113464,
0.38173046708106995,
0.04004262015223503,
0.10860836505889893,
-0.5843251347541809,
-0.1602727323770523,
0.20958073437213898,
-0.38048937916755676,
0.4788326025009155,
-0.004573911428451538,
-0.3328397274017334,
-0.37918519973754883,
0.7096984386444092,
-0.5049416422843933,
0.008855505846440792,
0.16237977147102356,
-0.042304616421461105,
0.06376942247152328,
0.26988640427589417,
0.1562976986169815,
0.33829665184020996,
0.056724146008491516,
0.23888978362083435,
0.41876423358917236,
-0.05211761221289635,
0.05593271926045418,
0.10450117290019989,
-0.0475873239338398,
-0.15832802653312683,
0.5574159622192383,
0.6444457769393921,
0.08872633427381516,
-0.7079801559448242,
0.6027830243110657,
-0.15317709743976593,
-0.32230648398399353,
0.030022531747817993,
0.20705530047416687,
0.5791808366775513,
0.8034613728523254,
0.2379276305437088,
-0.04325930401682854,
-0.15210255980491638,
-0.1044931635260582,
0.19407640397548676,
0.5548677444458008,
-0.2031487226486206,
0.07619080692529678,
0.46481332182884216,
0.2932565212249756,
-0.26065778732299805,
0.6278786659240723,
-0.6404597759246826,
-0.5302023887634277,
0.5216981172561646,
0.5328819751739502,
0.5996378660202026,
0.10218886286020279,
0.31281641125679016,
0.2786482274532318,
0.1481906622648239,
-0.2041439563035965,
0.37848150730133057,
-0.4145897626876831,
-1.0007028579711914,
-0.6557156443595886,
-0.24063719809055328,
-0.8838066458702087,
-0.01989823579788208,
-0.3091568052768707,
0.27722224593162537,
-0.354718953371048,
0.24157686531543732,
-0.504381000995636,
-0.02356371469795704,
-0.24657335877418518,
-0.0033217987511307,
0.2602633237838745,
0.9813086986541748,
-0.6516717672348022,
0.7906039953231812,
0.5146542191505432,
-0.2743915915489197,
-1.2265753746032715,
-0.06933896988630295,
-0.1763216257095337,
-0.9915918111801147,
0.6045423150062561,
0.40992042422294617,
-0.3125922679901123,
0.14299309253692627,
-0.7385401129722595,
-0.6482443809509277,
1.4715852737426758,
0.6885143518447876,
-0.765424907207489,
-0.052447084337472916,
0.11582082509994507,
0.3035593032836914,
-0.2626611292362213,
0.0879572257399559,
0.33827799558639526,
0.4532512128353119,
0.647317111492157,
-0.8709761500358582,
0.35623899102211,
0.006470125634223223,
-0.4437326490879059,
-0.009535557590425014,
-0.7878309488296509,
0.6373926401138306,
-0.416780948638916,
-0.1640293449163437,
-0.0844479501247406,
0.6678710579872131,
0.8870500326156616,
0.5917547941207886,
0.6423273086547852,
0.6902996897697449,
1.3645488023757935,
0.10291597992181778,
0.721727728843689,
-0.43627724051475525,
0.18249501287937164,
1.1389001607894897,
-0.4971892535686493,
0.418088436126709,
0.483571320772171,
-0.05747884139418602,
0.7187541127204895,
0.3307041823863983,
0.19681453704833984,
0.4153114855289459,
0.06747107952833176,
-0.6699455976486206,
-0.7042691707611084,
-0.5926998257637024,
-0.31768953800201416,
0.0780751034617424,
0.4122420847415924,
-0.19464683532714844,
-0.4950093626976013,
-0.02017153427004814,
0.07915380597114563,
0.24039915204048157,
-0.388642817735672,
0.7354999780654907,
0.28870415687561035,
-0.7166895866394043,
0.3774406909942627,
-0.20888976752758026,
0.6255497336387634,
-0.5977016687393188,
-0.14344185590744019,
-0.17377065122127533,
-0.10364890843629837,
-0.2726650536060333,
-0.8966436386108398,
0.1212640330195427,
-0.04180710390210152,
0.0319070965051651,
-0.38916921615600586,
1.00338876247406,
-0.401748389005661,
0.026496125385165215,
0.5557553172111511,
0.8940291404724121,
0.0007645083242096007,
-0.08047982305288315,
-0.5270544290542603,
-0.0016821183962747455,
-0.043226372450590134,
0.039868831634521484,
0.28962457180023193,
0.7012010216712952,
-0.0364886149764061,
0.8231120109558105,
0.6114970445632935,
-0.02264244481921196,
-0.236374631524086,
0.48019590973854065,
1.1650207042694092,
-0.48365527391433716,
-0.5867132544517517,
-0.8631770610809326,
0.3128068745136261,
-0.25345346331596375,
0.21037067472934723,
0.71138995885849,
0.39093634486198425,
0.6413435935974121,
0.2871242165565491,
0.9078092575073242,
0.20588424801826477,
0.5648807287216187,
-0.8047730922698975,
0.4525652527809143,
-0.13580751419067383,
0.41072937846183777,
-0.02988157607614994,
-0.6534768342971802,
-0.535567045211792,
0.554393470287323,
-0.23287689685821533,
-0.22784408926963806,
0.7719424962997437,
0.7145144939422607,
0.32286033034324646,
0.18932262063026428,
0.1617533564567566,
0.015379942953586578,
0.3622118830680847,
0.7464035153388977,
0.9675344228744507,
0.1927650272846222,
0.7079014778137207,
-0.19832921028137207,
-0.2797583043575287,
0.015288402326405048,
-1.0738284587860107,
-0.9274863004684448,
-0.18300719559192657,
-0.2002497911453247,
-0.4502706229686737,
0.06502556055784225,
1.2100987434387207,
0.28732991218566895,
-0.38660916686058044,
0.2145165652036667,
-0.5405014753341675,
0.38583171367645264,
-0.1309768557548523,
-0.23251773416996002,
0.2766958177089691,
-0.48518627882003784,
-0.4377732276916504,
0.6372686624526978,
0.43899649381637573,
-0.06303100287914276,
-0.281689316034317,
-0.40286052227020264,
-0.00436009606346488,
-0.0743744969367981,
0.47274401783943176,
-0.07732100039720535,
-0.5400750637054443,
-0.2995733618736267,
0.13565869629383087,
-0.11184141039848328,
0.03600158914923668,
0.7883695363998413,
-1.0667163133621216,
0.48139652609825134,
0.6247739791870117,
0.7392512559890747,
0.3023239076137543,
-0.12875550985336304,
0.41419363021850586,
-0.8442067503929138,
0.09435124695301056,
0.30574727058410645,
0.4007887542247772,
0.4868909418582916,
-0.4988665282726288,
0.4617103338241577,
0.6654243469238281,
-0.4814176857471466,
-0.724599301815033,
0.3364509642124176,
-1.1004831790924072,
-0.2384764701128006,
1.2402384281158447,
-0.32255473732948303,
-0.02727491781115532,
-0.39002561569213867,
-0.3657709062099457,
0.5659308433532715,
-0.5457568764686584,
0.6059485673904419,
0.7400210499763489,
-0.6348809003829956,
-0.24151840806007385,
0.010720385238528252,
0.2557578682899475,
0.3880508244037628,
-1.005996584892273,
0.1298890858888626,
0.41916507482528687,
0.028367841616272926,
0.10751131176948547,
0.9346650838851929,
0.1385832130908966,
-0.06851750612258911,
0.06692291051149368,
-0.14483918249607086,
-0.5603349804878235,
-0.4106014370918274,
-0.005179747473448515,
0.44966810941696167,
0.1662590205669403,
0.02546808309853077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04967v1 | Text or Image? What is More Important in Cross-Domain Generalization Capabilities of Hate Meme Detection Models? | 2024-02-07T15:44:55 | 2024-02-07T15:44:55 | Piush Aggarwal, Jawar Mehrabanian, Weigang Huang, Özge Alacam, Torsten Zesch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | This paper delves into the formidable challenge of cross-domain
generalization in multimodal hate meme detection, presenting compelling
findings. We provide enough pieces of evidence supporting the hypothesis that
only the textual component of hateful memes enables the existing multimodal
classifier to generalize across different domains, while the image component
proves highly sensitive to a specific training dataset. The evidence includes
demonstrations showing that hate-text classifiers perform similarly to
hate-meme classifiers in a zero-shot setting. Simultaneously, the introduction
of captions generated from images of memes to the hate-meme classifier worsens
performance by an average F1 of 0.02. Through blackbox explanations, we
identify a substantial contribution of the text modality (average of 83%),
which diminishes with the introduction of meme's image captions (52%).
Additionally, our evaluation on a newly created confounder dataset reveals
higher performance on text confounders as compared to image confounders with an
average $\Delta$F1 of 0.18. | [
-0.6548507809638977,
-0.6895419955253601,
0.2998511791229248,
-0.12142905592918396,
-0.35720109939575195,
0.11123687028884888,
-0.09291347861289978,
-0.6625005602836609,
0.04421622306108475,
0.17873987555503845,
-0.6325353384017944,
-0.25862640142440796,
-1.1189370155334473,
0.1583123654127121,
-0.3838519752025604,
1.0436725616455078,
0.1551545262336731,
-0.192996546626091,
-0.23756815493106842,
-0.3389706611633301,
-0.38321956992149353,
-0.6756905317306519,
-0.6793680191040039,
-0.2035185545682907,
0.9549266695976257,
0.2335597723722458,
0.8267526626586914,
0.2730048894882202,
0.4519784450531006,
0.22091609239578247,
0.5215842127799988,
-0.10633534938097,
-0.3368833661079407,
0.19103766977787018,
-0.2703109383583069,
-0.4776492714881897,
-0.13478855788707733,
0.24756436049938202,
0.09356940537691116,
0.08176407963037491,
0.455179363489151,
-0.13187193870544434,
-0.23431698977947235,
0.4179632365703583,
-0.7076764702796936,
-0.26820629835128784,
-0.9776646494865417,
0.1659957468509674,
-0.21840010583400726,
-0.38499754667282104,
-0.49880605936050415,
0.115664042532444,
0.33061593770980835,
-0.5324403643608093,
0.6145858764648438,
0.21855616569519043,
0.7787134647369385,
0.1162916049361229,
-0.7285880446434021,
-0.5262231826782227,
-0.763595461845398,
1.266225814819336,
-0.26780807971954346,
0.47804561257362366,
0.007074063178151846,
0.2413199096918106,
0.21822510659694672,
-0.337186336517334,
-0.8482314348220825,
0.1243765652179718,
0.027526194229722023,
-0.01986994780600071,
-0.76295405626297,
-0.08182091265916824,
0.24207887053489685,
0.5020760297775269,
-0.8235552906990051,
0.1690613329410553,
-0.38585948944091797,
-0.4163101613521576,
0.4604399800300598,
-0.0232777651399374,
0.6922249794006348,
-0.03482883796095848,
-0.5870270729064941,
-0.20494963228702545,
-0.5952433347702026,
-0.16609624028205872,
0.43484750390052795,
0.0001314408436883241,
-0.07023981958627701,
0.5841615796089172,
0.16330285370349884,
0.5165078639984131,
0.023817408829927444,
-0.07857827097177505,
0.20059292018413544,
-0.2160363346338272,
-0.14303821325302124,
-0.28039026260375977,
0.8479163646697998,
0.7816209197044373,
0.6407132744789124,
-0.24310292303562164,
-0.015885131433606148,
0.6655170917510986,
0.48089298605918884,
-0.9732450246810913,
-0.11786524206399918,
-0.056696124374866486,
-0.5171321034431458,
-0.2930392622947693,
-0.43745192885398865,
-0.886047899723053,
-0.4283524453639984,
-0.13207271695137024,
0.22298578917980194,
-0.4249498248100281,
-0.13827072083950043,
-0.19615468382835388,
-0.5948117971420288,
0.0855991393327713,
0.4851142466068268,
-0.8500517010688782,
0.15810997784137726,
0.2800804376602173,
0.5388807654380798,
-0.3837144076824188,
-0.16535231471061707,
-0.31313544511795044,
0.023170622065663338,
-0.2110968828201294,
1.0730175971984863,
-0.90792316198349,
-0.040197622030973434,
-0.05418912321329117,
0.11811719834804535,
-0.30504676699638367,
-0.6213248372077942,
0.4647636413574219,
-0.5502032041549683,
0.2566234767436981,
0.05079392343759537,
-0.4742850363254547,
-0.3250185549259186,
0.2906041741371155,
-0.6018238067626953,
0.37825697660446167,
0.14700233936309814,
-0.7590728998184204,
0.7101178169250488,
-0.559545636177063,
-0.4074738025665283,
-0.17754362523555756,
-0.20647400617599487,
-0.7331193685531616,
0.14057523012161255,
-0.0692090168595314,
0.7050138711929321,
-0.20553742349147797,
-0.02619466930627823,
-0.667657196521759,
-0.093881756067276,
0.38848939538002014,
-0.4446384608745575,
0.36913082003593445,
0.23327359557151794,
-0.6245027780532837,
-0.27133166790008545,
-0.6619526147842407,
-0.35749003291130066,
0.40434128046035767,
-0.12443166971206665,
-1.0488169193267822,
-0.04023582488298416,
0.1805419623851776,
0.3725529909133911,
-0.18278133869171143,
-0.8249159455299377,
-0.12709864974021912,
0.21996332705020905,
0.07995495200157166,
0.7570834159851074,
-0.2003205567598343,
0.44729942083358765,
-0.4561103284358978,
0.571961522102356,
0.3895440995693207,
0.1710900217294693,
-0.08740328252315521,
-0.733709990978241,
-0.2951582074165344,
-0.3495343029499054,
0.022230632603168488,
0.4007602035999298,
-0.8260321617126465,
-0.21851663291454315,
0.09743073582649231,
-0.23950020968914032,
-0.12963557243347168,
0.08673476427793503,
0.5652408599853516,
0.2686208188533783,
0.5791635513305664,
-0.2436230182647705,
-0.6468562483787537,
-1.260206937789917,
-0.5026766657829285,
0.06901467591524124,
0.05816435068845749,
0.43169090151786804,
0.6820489168167114,
-0.5171419382095337,
0.40956854820251465,
-0.4498547911643982,
-0.39396601915359497,
0.09222361445426941,
0.2575130760669708,
-0.27211177349090576,
0.3977257013320923,
1.1654859781265259,
-1.2401418685913086,
-0.6141571402549744,
-0.16529567539691925,
-0.7137112021446228,
-0.1332290917634964,
-0.09737726300954819,
0.14947432279586792,
0.267677903175354,
0.3135361075401306,
-0.18077605962753296,
0.5174158811569214,
0.7906486988067627,
-0.554165780544281,
0.561954915523529,
0.40277236700057983,
0.736404299736023,
-0.8042070269584656,
-0.3056432902812958,
0.44703057408332825,
-0.09320643544197083,
-0.7663269639015198,
-0.0971904993057251,
0.04305974394083023,
0.03178775683045387,
-0.45449379086494446,
0.2827819287776947,
-0.3300264775753021,
0.3607436716556549,
-0.2682608664035797,
-0.07643172144889832,
0.020265482366085052,
0.4886322617530823,
-0.14701727032661438,
0.744272768497467,
0.33711791038513184,
-0.5405575633049011,
0.3251614570617676,
0.17076973617076874,
-0.12623737752437592,
1.02486252784729,
-0.4199756383895874,
-0.02825327403843403,
-0.2734465003013611,
0.1414094716310501,
-1.2192327976226807,
0.06985501199960709,
0.6107196807861328,
-0.5759907960891724,
0.3467954099178314,
-0.14903821051120758,
-0.22611896693706512,
-0.2571769952774048,
-0.4436511695384979,
0.873720645904541,
0.2301022857427597,
-0.4866447150707245,
0.5855001211166382,
0.28570571541786194,
0.09659186750650406,
-0.7493091225624084,
-0.7782332897186279,
0.15898869931697845,
-0.31959378719329834,
-0.49908679723739624,
0.4838215112686157,
-0.35074037313461304,
-0.19555334746837616,
0.021911630406975746,
-0.14144903421401978,
-0.3167579174041748,
0.08077867329120636,
0.4587443172931671,
-0.0686265081167221,
-0.16826273500919342,
0.28703752160072327,
0.21359434723854065,
-0.06168923154473305,
0.046515002846717834,
-0.12273742258548737,
0.36053937673568726,
0.18298183381557465,
-0.1299603432416916,
-0.2144116312265396,
0.578929603099823,
0.6108888387680054,
0.2264329046010971,
0.6335048079490662,
0.48113423585891724,
-0.36625078320503235,
-0.4077471196651459,
-0.5396908521652222,
0.10343516618013382,
-0.4070437550544739,
0.29905956983566284,
-0.4267311990261078,
-1.0204529762268066,
0.38937363028526306,
0.21778951585292816,
-0.07690691947937012,
0.6336513757705688,
0.37369436025619507,
-0.09028496593236923,
0.8444599509239197,
0.6798673868179321,
-0.06691793352365494,
0.46912503242492676,
-0.11351031810045242,
0.2789151072502136,
-0.4635871946811676,
-0.2741212248802185,
-0.6407029032707214,
-0.3769746422767639,
-0.4340476095676422,
-0.504878580570221,
0.05893595516681671,
-0.5926865339279175,
0.11545433849096298,
0.3563939034938812,
-0.6058463454246521,
0.3339051306247711,
0.32753223180770874,
0.14834381639957428,
0.1867353916168213,
0.5252034664154053,
0.05608031153678894,
-0.4815714657306671,
-0.4681127369403839,
-0.29427021741867065,
1.3899873495101929,
0.35752543807029724,
0.8927841782569885,
0.23626188933849335,
0.19429947435855865,
0.8947176933288574,
0.4413808286190033,
-0.6810489892959595,
0.3113963305950165,
-0.6224014759063721,
-0.852732241153717,
0.04443223401904106,
-0.29739072918891907,
-0.9446119070053101,
0.30052775144577026,
-0.36120739579200745,
-0.1668429672718048,
0.05872463807463646,
0.30607283115386963,
0.29498741030693054,
0.6464582681655884,
-0.791010320186615,
0.9925989508628845,
-0.03807446360588074,
-0.17748218774795532,
-0.5921047329902649,
-0.2689751088619232,
0.3132246136665344,
-0.19693569839000702,
0.48857173323631287,
-0.18739216029644012,
-0.16480033099651337,
0.8115281462669373,
0.042808398604393005,
1.0261293649673462,
-0.28999271988868713,
-0.11735173314809799,
0.1302303522825241,
0.16113196313381195,
-0.13810765743255615,
-0.5937770009040833,
0.24788318574428558,
0.24588148295879364,
-0.29991206526756287,
-0.6047682762145996,
-0.5925819873809814,
0.5898644328117371,
-0.6484801173210144,
-0.36809200048446655,
-0.2863771319389343,
-0.6305627822875977,
-0.04481065273284912,
-0.01456135418266058,
0.3100719153881073,
0.5874654054641724,
-0.31892937421798706,
0.15259528160095215,
0.9040707349777222,
-0.5802173614501953,
0.26368460059165955,
0.38755732774734497,
-0.00580790126696229,
-0.41169172525405884,
1.1224806308746338,
0.15416520833969116,
0.4756790101528168,
0.5817103981971741,
0.006211447529494762,
-0.1659122258424759,
-0.5997859239578247,
-0.6536476612091064,
0.10760387778282166,
-0.7454249858856201,
-0.2324381023645401,
-0.9743646383285522,
0.12149587273597717,
-0.2505549490451813,
-0.2717374563217163,
0.001326894387602806,
-0.46533262729644775,
-0.22146378457546234,
0.24915312230587006,
0.1762978732585907,
0.7247953414916992,
0.08605258911848068,
0.4370313882827759,
-0.45140132308006287,
0.5159082412719727,
0.5628591179847717,
0.42867064476013184,
0.12169567495584488,
-0.691609263420105,
-0.24974815547466278,
0.03125490993261337,
-0.6639024615287781,
-0.89081871509552,
0.09715621173381805,
0.10385111719369888,
0.44471773505210876,
0.5709264874458313,
-0.068098284304142,
0.4326653480529785,
-0.3828888237476349,
0.6208130717277527,
0.42693543434143066,
-0.6744640469551086,
0.32255473732948303,
-0.2606576383113861,
-0.013797163031995296,
0.09724170714616776,
0.9688440561294556,
-0.47806522250175476,
-0.8859349489212036,
-0.6290692090988159,
-0.2107507437467575,
0.40770983695983887,
0.24303966760635376,
0.36536818742752075,
-0.10080496966838837,
0.1266472041606903,
0.4201366901397705,
0.21473103761672974,
-1.067490577697754,
-0.7078794240951538,
-0.3454694449901581,
-0.1086379736661911,
-0.0852852612733841,
-0.6255788803100586,
0.01572312042117119,
-0.1840507984161377,
0.7003658413887024,
-0.1525244563817978,
0.41924604773521423,
0.14873769879341125,
-0.3902396857738495,
-0.15711626410484314,
0.27870917320251465,
0.8061684966087341,
0.42132654786109924,
-0.04280659928917885,
0.4520230293273926,
-0.20190417766571045,
-0.4330749809741974,
0.3473789691925049,
-0.12236249446868896,
-0.14294718205928802,
0.25195518136024475,
0.4078066051006317,
0.5914385914802551,
0.11805657297372818,
-0.5005390048027039,
0.9095019102096558,
-0.15799641609191895,
-0.5571480989456177,
-0.0606166273355484,
-0.12790153920650482,
-0.3779169023036957,
0.2521391808986664,
0.6416857838630676,
0.4226241707801819,
0.3168986439704895,
-0.4040076434612274,
0.4617825746536255,
0.7326191663742065,
-0.38704952597618103,
-0.6118054986000061,
0.8346924781799316,
0.08037165552377701,
0.09689687937498093,
-0.17174966633319855,
0.004656890872865915,
-0.8614180684089661,
0.8044664859771729,
0.6478717923164368,
0.737191379070282,
-0.3073892295360565,
0.49093979597091675,
0.19535212218761444,
0.5297674536705017,
0.6741858124732971,
-0.10656025260686874,
-0.005552803166210651,
-0.950154721736908,
-0.037331558763980865,
-0.40560609102249146,
-0.44491899013519287,
0.3372247517108917,
-0.05400913581252098,
0.11442717909812927,
-0.5076570510864258,
0.037501197308301926,
0.7756809592247009,
-0.27553045749664307,
-0.5908808708190918,
0.6044250130653381,
0.4091087877750397,
0.6203898787498474,
-1.0634394884109497,
0.2550150752067566,
0.8524625897407532,
-0.3935448229312897,
-0.1983892023563385,
-0.06721809506416321,
0.11319158971309662,
-0.8446683883666992,
0.596200168132782,
0.27794474363327026,
-0.07936437427997589,
-0.34740447998046875,
-0.9092472195625305,
-0.27632850408554077,
0.4472021758556366,
0.09221775084733963,
-0.3139181435108185,
0.29658615589141846,
0.19816900789737701,
0.5435382723808289,
-0.7409655451774597,
0.24206699430942535,
0.13925623893737793,
0.2831985056400299,
-0.11289025098085403,
-0.4792639911174774,
0.2677410840988159,
-0.22217021882534027,
-0.0738375261425972,
0.2640449106693268,
-0.5234159827232361,
0.9690050482749939,
-0.037333693355321884,
-0.22495757043361664,
-0.4417808949947357,
0.32743847370147705,
-0.36785033345222473,
0.8132275342941284,
0.7305361032485962,
0.6024222373962402,
0.07087041437625885,
0.12459733337163925,
0.9798417687416077,
0.23978400230407715,
0.149833545088768,
0.6897403001785278,
0.24125857651233673,
0.23902671039104462,
0.4584227204322815,
-0.1986975520849228,
0.8074947595596313,
0.41473549604415894,
-0.3695940375328064,
0.44492048025131226,
0.12846113741397858,
-0.5408809781074524,
-0.3117247223854065,
-0.23296679556369781,
-0.27152690291404724,
0.21559903025627136,
0.24999120831489563,
-0.6729971766471863,
-0.5028172731399536,
0.42349380254745483,
0.2433805614709854,
0.3821357190608978,
-0.17484335601329803,
0.5812628865242004,
-0.06148465350270271,
-0.2886720895767212,
0.7496016025543213,
0.05013924837112427,
1.0302928686141968,
-0.4046470522880554,
0.05265568196773529,
0.14704696834087372,
0.23624755442142487,
-0.39738979935646057,
-0.5988956689834595,
0.5210607051849365,
0.05256282538175583,
-0.8582751154899597,
-0.12090399116277695,
0.8896727561950684,
-0.4862087070941925,
-0.005889809224754572,
0.678888738155365,
0.37789082527160645,
0.21609556674957275,
-0.4359280467033386,
-0.8887981176376343,
0.12192066013813019,
0.16417454183101654,
0.00637787813320756,
0.5705921053886414,
0.5338231325149536,
-0.20165422558784485,
0.5461621880531311,
0.5805826783180237,
-0.4628562033176422,
0.36504805088043213,
0.07079589366912842,
0.8711137175559998,
-0.6133831143379211,
0.08842824399471283,
-1.0057122707366943,
0.31578007340431213,
-0.05717052146792412,
-0.21476010978221893,
0.625092089176178,
0.7144036293029785,
1.0340824127197266,
-0.4585476517677307,
1.1892600059509277,
-0.32906126976013184,
0.5728275179862976,
-0.0826338678598404,
0.4538988471031189,
-1.0336039066314697,
-0.22703474760055542,
-0.5642211437225342,
-0.5221478939056396,
-0.4950793981552124,
0.1823757439851761,
-0.3594776690006256,
-0.04024341702461243,
0.7921756505966187,
0.7437883019447327,
-0.32607778906822205,
-0.031023910269141197,
0.6906430125236511,
0.12554903328418732,
0.48429054021835327,
0.6219338774681091,
0.9252137541770935,
-0.8530150055885315,
0.8583246469497681,
-0.38986849784851074,
-0.4401130676269531,
-0.11682505905628204,
-0.6614300012588501,
-1.211319923400879,
-0.5951929092407227,
-0.6481006741523743,
-0.44099995493888855,
-0.12911973893642426,
0.49283865094184875,
0.4085294008255005,
-0.9975826740264893,
0.07030311971902847,
0.3568444550037384,
0.47443464398384094,
0.09782273322343826,
-0.27275487780570984,
-0.17623473703861237,
-0.36080726981163025,
-0.8023468255996704,
-0.05409134179353714,
0.3844146430492401,
0.27202093601226807,
0.18088330328464508,
-0.04338585585355759,
-0.4547385275363922,
0.20607654750347137,
0.905035674571991,
0.16730733215808868,
-0.6185911893844604,
-0.5228481292724609,
-0.16922590136528015,
-0.23054717481136322,
0.14388839900493622,
0.9572698473930359,
-0.43596968054771423,
0.3871675729751587,
0.04576302319765091,
0.6970294713973999,
0.2533106207847595,
-0.047672804445028305,
0.37772586941719055,
-0.6254903674125671,
0.19251616299152374,
-0.06045294180512428,
0.17400409281253815,
0.3140316307544708,
-0.2814117968082428,
0.46957775950431824,
0.9482535719871521,
-0.39582523703575134,
-0.6517208218574524,
0.26034024357795715,
-0.8800866007804871,
-0.4057174026966095,
0.8550128936767578,
0.03893328085541725,
-0.21904951333999634,
-0.3622468411922455,
-0.20816627144813538,
-0.01197726372629404,
-0.5658515095710754,
0.6670007705688477,
0.702904224395752,
0.21584802865982056,
-0.2891894280910492,
-0.3350614309310913,
0.39689046144485474,
0.5503248572349548,
-0.5675787925720215,
-0.15822511911392212,
0.8200252652168274,
0.5284788012504578,
0.35658156871795654,
0.486762672662735,
-0.03801076486706734,
0.557025671005249,
0.011071212589740753,
0.4230954349040985,
0.1627117246389389,
-0.30758148431777954,
-0.16562490165233612,
0.33496996760368347,
-0.45648491382598877,
-0.3777919113636017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04957v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04957v2 | Reconfidencing LLMs from the Grouping Loss Perspective | 2024-02-07T15:40:22 | 2024-06-18T20:31:56 | Lihu Chen, Alexandre Perez-Lebel, Fabian M. Suchanek, Gaël Varoquaux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), including ChatGPT and LLaMA, are susceptible to
generating hallucinated answers in a confident tone. While efforts to elicit
and calibrate confidence scores have proven useful, recent findings show that
controlling uncertainty must go beyond calibration: predicted scores may
deviate significantly from the actual posterior probabilities due to the impact
of grouping loss. In this work, we construct a new evaluation dataset derived
from a knowledge base to assess confidence scores given to answers of Mistral
and LLaMA. Experiments show that they tend to be overconfident. Further, we
show that they are more overconfident on some answers than others, \emph{eg}
depending on the nationality of the person in the query. In
uncertainty-quantification theory, this is grouping loss. To address this, we
propose a solution to reconfidence LLMs, canceling not only calibration but
also grouping loss. The LLMs, after the reconfidencing process, indicate
improved confidence alignment with the accuracy of their responses. | [
-0.3129887282848358,
-0.6469546556472778,
0.6232452988624573,
0.17864501476287842,
-0.18015331029891968,
0.3929428160190582,
-0.2615852653980255,
-0.07225363701581955,
0.22343972325325012,
0.43411898612976074,
-0.5115888118743896,
-0.5755491256713867,
-0.7726705074310303,
-0.05406772345304489,
-0.5978972911834717,
0.9727879166603088,
-0.22623063623905182,
-0.1399291753768921,
-0.15283383429050446,
-0.13005313277244568,
-0.5199897885322571,
-0.7120429277420044,
-0.7036020755767822,
-0.5247161388397217,
0.6432097554206848,
0.43089553713798523,
0.7533667683601379,
0.35722845792770386,
0.3543494641780853,
0.23376213014125824,
-0.09332746267318726,
0.1549428105354309,
-0.9621273875236511,
0.19117392599582672,
-0.14667661488056183,
-1.0539748668670654,
-0.18254493176937103,
0.14256252348423004,
0.5886848568916321,
0.8195272088050842,
-0.9642376899719238,
0.09103841334581375,
0.049962662160396576,
0.6708912253379822,
-0.6692206859588623,
0.08446066081523895,
-0.9210282564163208,
0.0951700508594513,
0.1814429759979248,
-0.4001682996749878,
-0.5224801898002625,
-0.7439482808113098,
0.12311027944087982,
-0.5406182408332825,
0.29073166847229004,
0.15270638465881348,
0.6771376132965088,
0.6484287977218628,
-0.3577060401439667,
-0.22695930302143097,
-0.7270625233650208,
0.8873873949050903,
-0.5269580483436584,
0.1693437248468399,
0.5847556591033936,
0.12852218747138977,
-0.4725673496723175,
-0.3457227051258087,
-0.3895718455314636,
0.09209104627370834,
0.07053008675575256,
0.28890010714530945,
-0.13657912611961365,
-0.050795622169971466,
-0.258958101272583,
0.629523754119873,
-0.5535677075386047,
0.08952644467353821,
-0.2179834097623825,
-0.3561374247074127,
0.780070424079895,
0.2588137090206146,
-0.29685845971107483,
0.30506211519241333,
-0.26190152764320374,
-0.07316609472036362,
-0.8373915553092957,
-0.17926804721355438,
0.1502840518951416,
0.11725297570228577,
0.26422762870788574,
0.6738734245300293,
-0.1036759689450264,
0.3357389271259308,
0.39342132210731506,
-0.3488781452178955,
0.11426316201686859,
0.087931327521801,
-0.335114985704422,
0.26565128564834595,
0.5017427206039429,
0.8119163513183594,
0.5094461441040039,
-0.1408696323633194,
-0.11478836834430695,
0.07804863899946213,
0.1484033316373825,
-0.569341778755188,
-0.1849217265844345,
0.31861385703086853,
-0.4650529623031616,
-0.27096813917160034,
-0.09219475090503693,
-0.4599956274032593,
-0.6372353434562683,
-0.19876056909561157,
0.5155245661735535,
-0.2416667342185974,
-0.2059730887413025,
0.35909146070480347,
-0.15595270693302155,
0.4594743549823761,
0.6169318556785583,
-0.6107673645019531,
0.47292158007621765,
0.6847923398017883,
0.7949357628822327,
-0.30874988436698914,
-0.1424654871225357,
-0.17939017713069916,
-0.0010681637795642018,
-0.6723966002464294,
0.6007022261619568,
-0.30360081791877747,
-0.9319062829017639,
-0.0725325420498848,
-0.03786860778927803,
-0.14511317014694214,
-0.6554611921310425,
0.2178722769021988,
-0.6477628946304321,
0.5196394324302673,
-0.31467634439468384,
-0.803799569606781,
-0.583544135093689,
0.5654059648513794,
-0.4913875460624695,
0.9799604415893555,
0.18502944707870483,
-0.6027038097381592,
0.24722346663475037,
0.21571949124336243,
-0.14973963797092438,
-0.24651683866977692,
-0.2595261037349701,
-0.14783185720443726,
0.2850019633769989,
0.15839825570583344,
0.45349499583244324,
-0.3838750422000885,
0.09965576231479645,
-0.21855869889259338,
-0.6014807820320129,
0.5216282606124878,
-0.4652828276157379,
0.4037680923938751,
-0.01855427213013172,
-0.07401484251022339,
-0.16095271706581116,
-0.5586153268814087,
0.2803100049495697,
-0.12211631238460541,
-0.447100967168808,
-0.3568932116031647,
0.06887916475534439,
-0.45431211590766907,
-0.034687358886003494,
0.10689321905374527,
-0.4259825050830841,
0.2888735234737396,
-0.18481330573558807,
0.24792668223381042,
1.0757622718811035,
0.369364857673645,
0.32107529044151306,
-0.6394844651222229,
0.6726692914962769,
-0.13707393407821655,
0.15451665222644806,
0.28501659631729126,
-0.6558976769447327,
-0.9590432047843933,
0.017675574868917465,
0.01514962688088417,
0.7517169117927551,
-0.6682195663452148,
0.34330931305885315,
-0.26586002111434937,
-0.6905015110969543,
-0.5838338732719421,
-0.03907551243901253,
0.25445887446403503,
0.5473828315734863,
0.175123929977417,
-0.4772297441959381,
-0.4638940989971161,
-0.804889440536499,
-0.05416274443268776,
-0.47224950790405273,
-0.16802097856998444,
0.059966955333948135,
0.2816139757633209,
-0.28014349937438965,
0.8086702823638916,
-0.7021998763084412,
-0.2398170828819275,
-0.028843916952610016,
0.11095589399337769,
0.2895134687423706,
0.36209195852279663,
0.036471668630838394,
-0.7739066481590271,
-0.13383112847805023,
0.006637154147028923,
-0.420133113861084,
0.11471834033727646,
-0.0865076333284378,
0.019740309566259384,
0.38618004322052,
0.4611392319202423,
-0.6184927821159363,
0.53305983543396,
0.7705406546592712,
0.022518442943692207,
0.6519477367401123,
0.24709714949131012,
0.3958527743816376,
-1.1250979900360107,
-0.27326416969299316,
-0.20686212182044983,
-0.21297305822372437,
-0.24717293679714203,
-0.22211095690727234,
-0.38027146458625793,
0.45808351039886475,
-0.14330871403217316,
0.0652833804488182,
-0.1998964548110962,
0.026688208803534508,
-0.11832435429096222,
0.3131231963634491,
0.22667402029037476,
0.4794461131095886,
0.026324614882469177,
0.7538970708847046,
0.417498379945755,
-0.5708078742027283,
0.4366430938243866,
0.20589324831962585,
-0.44186922907829285,
0.5569242835044861,
-0.7167444825172424,
0.045254699885845184,
-0.38708770275115967,
0.4507948160171509,
-1.361036777496338,
-0.33609768748283386,
0.28887939453125,
-0.69676673412323,
0.3011902868747711,
-0.04127901792526245,
-0.0633067712187767,
-0.0714353621006012,
-0.5137864947319031,
0.49490922689437866,
0.440496563911438,
-0.29259011149406433,
0.35929250717163086,
0.369110107421875,
-0.1702897846698761,
-0.9749363660812378,
-1.1629788875579834,
0.019687511026859283,
-0.5114748477935791,
-0.41990774869918823,
0.4850863218307495,
-0.11210224777460098,
-0.4280988276004791,
-0.02206319198012352,
-0.28608283400535583,
-0.1880258321762085,
-0.09501022100448608,
0.3532201051712036,
0.1824665516614914,
-0.12711703777313232,
0.6787718534469604,
-0.27824944257736206,
-0.07473060488700867,
0.13241764903068542,
-0.033882591873407364,
0.7425543069839478,
-0.29195916652679443,
-0.5248903632164001,
-0.23973901569843292,
0.39761048555374146,
0.29960986971855164,
-0.18031945824623108,
1.0445289611816406,
0.4080692529678345,
-0.29569706320762634,
-0.016601894050836563,
-0.919930100440979,
-0.05885292962193489,
-0.45439842343330383,
0.4945879280567169,
-0.2136588990688324,
-1.3907791376113892,
1.0073703527450562,
-0.031757526099681854,
-0.09942006319761276,
0.5302822589874268,
0.8424467444419861,
-0.02850605547428131,
0.7299981713294983,
0.7592909932136536,
-0.3416205048561096,
0.17052723467350006,
-0.17283478379249573,
0.16144824028015137,
-0.7612109184265137,
-0.4199604392051697,
-0.37004682421684265,
-0.21643386781215668,
-0.8220380544662476,
-0.508105456829071,
0.24213191866874695,
0.012580000795423985,
-0.36820903420448303,
-0.05459127202630043,
-0.5875531435012817,
0.5932713747024536,
0.4676700234413147,
0.22919870913028717,
0.363552063703537,
-0.20268473029136658,
0.38869351148605347,
0.0345408134162426,
-0.6593161821365356,
-0.48893922567367554,
1.160512924194336,
0.357491135597229,
1.4209703207015991,
0.2781280279159546,
0.9754233360290527,
0.12463671714067459,
0.5603640079498291,
-1.2067583799362183,
0.3184967041015625,
0.33553794026374817,
-0.5294424891471863,
-0.47849684953689575,
-0.7153285145759583,
-0.8438855409622192,
0.3072223663330078,
0.06597905606031418,
-0.9303846955299377,
0.3828200697898865,
-0.014458907768130302,
-0.6106593012809753,
0.15463577210903168,
-0.522996723651886,
0.4322839081287384,
0.14499545097351074,
0.06596458703279495,
-0.09610674530267715,
-0.7451685070991516,
0.8108099699020386,
-0.31303468346595764,
0.04277116060256958,
-0.14406871795654297,
-0.233088418841362,
0.6717274188995361,
-0.37853914499282837,
0.9195414185523987,
0.20073924958705902,
-0.6256898641586304,
0.5156417489051819,
0.23337000608444214,
0.31252554059028625,
0.14483925700187683,
-0.407869815826416,
0.016571396961808205,
0.10068970173597336,
-0.0755615308880806,
-0.8364591598510742,
0.7610170841217041,
-0.6904319524765015,
-0.8336195349693298,
-0.286760538816452,
-0.39470237493515015,
-0.06351546198129654,
-0.15461884438991547,
0.6618394255638123,
0.05473288521170616,
-0.23834243416786194,
0.034659869968891144,
0.8890394568443298,
-0.24101223051548004,
0.12993226945400238,
0.27095356583595276,
-0.2933363616466522,
-0.540749728679657,
0.43507203459739685,
0.17305085062980652,
0.5699805617332458,
0.20608019828796387,
0.047541894018650055,
-0.4267789125442505,
-0.33807143568992615,
0.07058853656053543,
0.21559244394302368,
-0.8267384767532349,
-0.4104470908641815,
0.04496714100241661,
-0.2320147156715393,
-0.44931137561798096,
-0.10798753052949905,
-0.3670436441898346,
-0.559205949306488,
-0.1680363416671753,
-0.2814105153083801,
0.3753136694431305,
0.6408929824829102,
-0.01924099214375019,
0.6949690580368042,
-0.7139260172843933,
-0.013423087075352669,
0.3260531425476074,
0.3231833875179291,
-0.05460122227668762,
-0.8802231550216675,
-0.04739886149764061,
0.03740597143769264,
-0.08925066143274307,
-1.1242270469665527,
0.2998957633972168,
0.3946070075035095,
0.610356867313385,
0.5015027523040771,
0.20622943341732025,
0.9007239937782288,
-0.2685287892818451,
0.6583474278450012,
-0.016888368874788284,
-0.8897644281387329,
0.39591315388679504,
0.014322619885206223,
0.14806212484836578,
0.6444540619850159,
0.43437570333480835,
-0.95868319272995,
-0.3885151445865631,
-0.5223820209503174,
-0.6894232034683228,
0.3139219582080841,
0.060947589576244354,
0.05141491815447807,
-0.07039052248001099,
0.679296612739563,
-0.15178902447223663,
0.36676111817359924,
-0.7437928318977356,
-0.3368355631828308,
-0.009618249721825123,
-0.09701584279537201,
-0.2609347105026245,
-0.43415799736976624,
-0.49891212582588196,
-0.08851758390665054,
0.7399867177009583,
0.1023571789264679,
0.20443183183670044,
0.43192270398139954,
0.1344987452030182,
-0.3375518321990967,
0.24697662889957428,
0.4993683099746704,
0.473623126745224,
-0.24456600844860077,
0.16762807965278625,
0.34329143166542053,
-0.4031681418418884,
0.5691707134246826,
-0.20548754930496216,
0.17366835474967957,
-0.131890207529068,
0.6572959423065186,
0.3562527596950531,
-0.10379193723201752,
-0.47852569818496704,
0.6486390829086304,
-0.18911267817020416,
-0.2331874668598175,
-0.5183334946632385,
-0.00850888155400753,
0.046825751662254333,
0.12238464504480362,
0.428646057844162,
0.11047085374593735,
0.11708641797304153,
-0.5689219832420349,
0.33999109268188477,
0.24994710087776184,
-0.41337448358535767,
0.10819549858570099,
0.21707698702812195,
-0.14362545311450958,
-0.10888750106096268,
0.7651719450950623,
-0.20790335536003113,
-0.8178277611732483,
0.5625320076942444,
0.4713635742664337,
0.7031586766242981,
-0.8152560591697693,
0.2526038885116577,
0.24730588495731354,
0.7250332236289978,
-0.3506132960319519,
0.12380091100931168,
0.26860958337783813,
-1.0957404375076294,
-0.8040173053741455,
-0.43647634983062744,
-0.42370784282684326,
-0.09112965315580368,
-1.040200114250183,
-0.1868181824684143,
-0.4303325414657593,
-0.3686559498310089,
-0.5739325881004333,
-0.11963266134262085,
-0.21521484851837158,
0.3333692252635956,
0.04517418518662453,
0.6583252549171448,
-0.771388828754425,
0.6352025270462036,
0.38998937606811523,
-0.17289166152477264,
-0.9390569925308228,
0.05183528736233711,
0.2602899372577667,
-1.1071230173110962,
0.39212819933891296,
0.2829577922821045,
-0.39588287472724915,
-0.10676076263189316,
-0.6537904143333435,
-1.0845539569854736,
1.1289502382278442,
0.27576401829719543,
-0.4808087944984436,
0.13294927775859833,
0.19836248457431793,
0.5052459836006165,
-0.21453605592250824,
-0.02478761598467827,
0.7869715094566345,
0.3311615288257599,
0.4670356214046478,
-0.9170126914978027,
0.11707639694213867,
0.18308505415916443,
-0.1299780309200287,
0.2455407828092575,
-0.7767879962921143,
1.1334601640701294,
-0.26814666390419006,
-0.4214493930339813,
0.14216051995754242,
0.5596145987510681,
0.31365346908569336,
0.06491102278232574,
0.5140991806983948,
0.6655627489089966,
1.0716131925582886,
-0.20889931917190552,
0.8856529593467712,
0.0974002256989479,
0.4118991792201996,
1.3665342330932617,
-0.18812821805477142,
1.0511690378189087,
0.6393139362335205,
-0.3583410084247589,
0.44753217697143555,
0.9984410405158997,
0.24977737665176392,
0.4550173282623291,
0.6523224115371704,
-0.43313834071159363,
-0.5385063886642456,
-0.047565534710884094,
-0.3842678666114807,
0.6401268243789673,
0.7692260146141052,
-0.27281060814857483,
-0.11116975545883179,
-0.24651767313480377,
0.17493700981140137,
0.041626427322626114,
-0.44987842440605164,
0.45521286129951477,
0.31381353735923767,
-0.615478515625,
0.8535333871841431,
-0.05552617833018303,
0.5670475363731384,
-0.4094575345516205,
0.06609612703323364,
-0.5526826977729797,
0.2429559975862503,
-0.3609401285648346,
-0.8468424677848816,
0.3758074939250946,
-0.4060247838497162,
-0.059863392263650894,
0.27258068323135376,
0.3864228129386902,
-0.708396852016449,
-0.5055605173110962,
0.043883297592401505,
0.5271248817443848,
0.37191420793533325,
-0.37114202976226807,
-0.44595837593078613,
-0.014267046935856342,
0.23199711740016937,
-0.36093389987945557,
-0.12240101397037506,
0.5396203994750977,
-0.1155596673488617,
1.1596907377243042,
0.2365560233592987,
-0.1085471510887146,
0.08473408967256546,
0.07203054428100586,
0.9197207093238831,
-0.5221876502037048,
0.09324169903993607,
-0.9978029131889343,
0.1510484665632248,
0.10680682212114334,
-0.4030264914035797,
0.9009567499160767,
0.4022985100746155,
0.6976109743118286,
0.2174631804227829,
0.5825597643852234,
0.14172358810901642,
0.5347495079040527,
-0.5008158683776855,
0.6949995160102844,
-0.46337810158729553,
0.414817214012146,
-0.36958208680152893,
-0.9205787181854248,
-0.6011936664581299,
0.7124407291412354,
-0.08237496763467789,
-0.005657278932631016,
0.5138888955116272,
1.115842580795288,
0.4686123728752136,
-0.15157507359981537,
0.3214126527309418,
0.19136826694011688,
0.3137085437774658,
0.806264340877533,
1.1515291929244995,
-0.5056544542312622,
0.6590271592140198,
-0.14569582045078278,
-0.3571309447288513,
-0.11904638260602951,
-0.812340497970581,
-0.6511964201927185,
-0.396842360496521,
-0.3494172692298889,
-0.20653460919857025,
0.00045708174002356827,
0.60931396484375,
0.40171918272972107,
-0.7253949046134949,
-0.23567646741867065,
0.11796160787343979,
0.16590404510498047,
-0.10525625944137573,
-0.21106231212615967,
0.4758032560348511,
-0.15764620900154114,
-0.4156472384929657,
0.21917998790740967,
0.0253615640103817,
0.317542165517807,
-0.37328803539276123,
-0.10215368866920471,
0.030149048194289207,
0.1284114569425583,
0.5666717886924744,
-0.006476891227066517,
-0.9212011098861694,
-0.6024129390716553,
-0.0910361036658287,
-0.09167326986789703,
-0.07500222325325012,
0.4276505410671234,
-0.7102895975112915,
0.11697637289762497,
0.13581524789333344,
0.5425131320953369,
0.25457048416137695,
0.3936328887939453,
0.8485667109489441,
-0.9758929014205933,
0.07834941893815994,
0.2895737588405609,
0.3017332851886749,
0.3774610757827759,
-0.35144031047821045,
0.6753681898117065,
0.04187995195388794,
-0.8552147746086121,
-0.6011366248130798,
0.18346863985061646,
-1.0351978540420532,
-0.07089489698410034,
1.0196003913879395,
-0.3110346794128418,
-0.08168228715658188,
0.0265948586165905,
-0.44670370221138,
0.2710639536380768,
-0.3594391345977783,
1.0343679189682007,
1.0456857681274414,
-0.16701334714889526,
-0.2351350635290146,
-0.12138049304485321,
0.5173220634460449,
0.5807803273200989,
-0.6562033295631409,
0.2534444332122803,
0.5970176458358765,
0.08012289553880692,
0.23666304349899292,
0.6829137206077576,
0.004646082874387503,
0.04147765412926674,
0.0006911850650794804,
0.26570162177085876,
0.4602985084056854,
-0.05131850764155388,
-0.4400262236595154,
0.04539318010210991,
0.2945624887943268,
-0.434343546628952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04918v1 | Prompting Implicit Discourse Relation Annotation | 2024-02-07T14:44:42 | 2024-02-07T14:44:42 | Frances Yung, Mansoor Ahmad, Merel Scholman, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained large language models, such as ChatGPT, archive outstanding
performance in various reasoning tasks without supervised training and were
found to have outperformed crowdsourcing workers. Nonetheless, ChatGPT's
performance in the task of implicit discourse relation classification, prompted
by a standard multiple-choice question, is still far from satisfactory and
considerably inferior to state-of-the-art supervised approaches. This work
investigates several proven prompting techniques to improve ChatGPT's
recognition of discourse relations. In particular, we experimented with
breaking down the classification task that involves numerous abstract labels
into smaller subtasks. Nonetheless, experiment results show that the inference
accuracy hardly changes even with sophisticated prompt engineering, suggesting
that implicit discourse relation classification is not yet resolvable under
zero-shot or few-shot settings. | [
-0.5972315073013306,
-0.7720051407814026,
0.8195900917053223,
0.23965907096862793,
-0.12155764549970627,
-0.05843985825777054,
-0.11641115695238113,
-0.45052120089530945,
-0.21240776777267456,
0.11072015017271042,
-0.7609702944755554,
-0.2417626678943634,
-0.5485425591468811,
0.21711429953575134,
-0.13883034884929657,
1.157746434211731,
0.11454147100448608,
0.13837915658950806,
-0.2527458071708679,
-0.023574968799948692,
-0.42838385701179504,
-0.5897116661071777,
-1.1061382293701172,
-0.28885480761528015,
0.8058096766471863,
0.3413318693637848,
0.4902845621109009,
0.16814059019088745,
-0.03559745103120804,
0.2893131673336029,
-0.36317530274391174,
0.4326777458190918,
-0.3625235855579376,
0.2699558138847351,
-0.020858867093920708,
-0.36746126413345337,
-0.11518487334251404,
0.3349267542362213,
0.47062161564826965,
0.7095507979393005,
0.334457129240036,
0.1841578185558319,
0.19517602026462555,
0.39727047085762024,
-0.6695502996444702,
0.6053193807601929,
-0.5152338743209839,
-0.05496630817651749,
-0.14667579531669617,
-0.16309203207492828,
-0.8559257984161377,
-0.48644301295280457,
0.41537779569625854,
-0.651051938533783,
0.21741360425949097,
0.2904049754142761,
0.8774498105049133,
0.32714393734931946,
-0.49517905712127686,
-0.25944316387176514,
-0.5408031344413757,
0.40498843789100647,
-0.3329518139362335,
0.22015361487865448,
0.6343932747840881,
0.17892564833164215,
-0.20754596590995789,
-0.6767225861549377,
-0.48123952746391296,
-0.5032221078872681,
-0.5209681391716003,
0.22632844746112823,
-0.10824566334486008,
0.46166425943374634,
0.7615995407104492,
-0.10302752256393433,
-0.41311323642730713,
0.06974129378795624,
-0.3604893684387207,
-0.14220504462718964,
0.28447791934013367,
-0.096260204911232,
0.1116928830742836,
-0.3963225185871124,
-0.23172099888324738,
0.12543641030788422,
-0.7784448862075806,
0.10200877487659454,
0.20328854024410248,
0.24101634323596954,
0.20640131831169128,
0.4339146614074707,
-0.07181459665298462,
0.5652111768722534,
0.22359497845172882,
0.16159047186374664,
0.04097943380475044,
-0.1161997839808464,
-0.04157145321369171,
0.07250731438398361,
0.7707505226135254,
0.024189118295907974,
0.5801288485527039,
0.3087710738182068,
0.21703554689884186,
0.04352870211005211,
-0.016478316858410835,
-0.6557469964027405,
-0.47878149151802063,
0.17325884103775024,
-0.08746203780174255,
0.1225586012005806,
-0.1472335010766983,
-0.41294610500335693,
-0.37421566247940063,
-0.4081067144870758,
0.16558651626110077,
-0.5798115134239197,
-0.07786881178617477,
-0.2787843644618988,
-0.22850297391414642,
0.3559035360813141,
0.728117048740387,
-0.8457027077674866,
0.17141574621200562,
0.6686529517173767,
0.8432784080505371,
0.09638277441263199,
-0.2181691825389862,
-0.6656013131141663,
0.018314115703105927,
-0.28118082880973816,
1.2426589727401733,
-0.6195284128189087,
-0.4661187529563904,
0.037051718682050705,
-0.05875171348452568,
-0.2838450074195862,
-0.16031426191329956,
0.4713174104690552,
-0.4284559190273285,
0.5569276213645935,
-0.483933687210083,
-0.5230352878570557,
-0.15233179926872253,
0.37771087884902954,
-0.39801663160324097,
0.9988712668418884,
-0.09760598838329315,
-1.0228807926177979,
0.3645147383213043,
-0.7459387183189392,
-0.2504478394985199,
0.09445229172706604,
-0.2774347960948944,
-0.22680193185806274,
-0.11361773312091827,
0.7016491293907166,
0.5532913208007812,
0.09033598005771637,
0.14205928146839142,
-0.21133917570114136,
-0.3883160948753357,
0.18577370047569275,
-0.42492127418518066,
0.7940554022789001,
-0.04618899151682854,
-0.07181881368160248,
0.039385709911584854,
-0.5365673303604126,
-0.08284702897071838,
-0.15901322662830353,
-0.04254401475191116,
-0.38904231786727905,
-0.20051103830337524,
-0.3999083340167999,
0.27335238456726074,
-0.12776002287864685,
-0.4481169879436493,
0.3909543454647064,
-0.4559544324874878,
0.2743532359600067,
0.8594744801521301,
0.2687815725803375,
0.3771555423736572,
-0.14157810807228088,
0.5249063968658447,
-0.04352819547057152,
-0.13871771097183228,
-0.5069405436515808,
-0.8235620856285095,
-1.0638056993484497,
-0.15714038908481598,
0.646068811416626,
0.5884343385696411,
-1.0486526489257812,
-0.2050965130329132,
-0.2365397810935974,
-0.36135798692703247,
-0.43529319763183594,
-0.3349781036376953,
0.5510852336883545,
0.709458589553833,
0.40451085567474365,
0.04206380248069763,
-0.4685046970844269,
-0.8454702496528625,
-0.09447789192199707,
-0.6116666793823242,
-0.04855967313051224,
0.48959532380104065,
0.45838335156440735,
0.27027544379234314,
0.8900769948959351,
-0.7036488056182861,
-0.07106269150972366,
0.09984029829502106,
0.8248751163482666,
-0.11242716759443283,
0.390191912651062,
0.44467440247535706,
-0.461360365152359,
-0.5561431050300598,
-0.06317735463380814,
-0.4442880153656006,
-0.24527481198310852,
0.018292034044861794,
-0.06680233776569366,
0.21214711666107178,
0.6391454339027405,
-0.7985113263130188,
0.3806694447994232,
0.2837284207344055,
0.005394378677010536,
0.7586642503738403,
0.09417746961116791,
0.21490919589996338,
-0.653060793876648,
-0.12743401527404785,
-0.04609883204102516,
-0.26926350593566895,
-0.6129777431488037,
-0.43639490008354187,
-0.08034820109605789,
-0.1587521731853485,
-0.6675702929496765,
0.5413429141044617,
-0.7408611178398132,
0.07663869857788086,
-0.17312321066856384,
0.11336564272642136,
-0.12600627541542053,
0.7736665606498718,
0.44212988018989563,
0.899779736995697,
0.5597357749938965,
-0.7420401573181152,
0.1813151240348816,
0.501798152923584,
0.06608618050813675,
0.6782933473587036,
-0.6475408673286438,
0.5456767678260803,
-0.45140209794044495,
0.5428085327148438,
-1.3834989070892334,
-0.33644261956214905,
0.5566093325614929,
-0.5619417428970337,
0.33882391452789307,
-0.7869663238525391,
-0.4051634967327118,
-0.193623885512352,
-0.22773988544940948,
0.39433524012565613,
0.544446587562561,
-0.6388655304908752,
0.3639731705188751,
0.014541026204824448,
-0.48106521368026733,
-0.6246360540390015,
-0.5176382660865784,
-0.0818944126367569,
-0.025455452501773834,
-0.4043809175491333,
-0.005810950882732868,
0.19807161390781403,
-0.16077762842178345,
-0.08884097635746002,
0.004390188492834568,
-0.2950301170349121,
-0.36293935775756836,
0.4673282504081726,
0.28316935896873474,
-0.13454125821590424,
0.5119076371192932,
0.2940407991409302,
-0.33196842670440674,
0.15534646809101105,
-0.029893599450588226,
0.2412382811307907,
-0.046627603471279144,
-0.35236719250679016,
-0.5041350722312927,
0.32524192333221436,
0.2228584736585617,
-0.13019733130931854,
0.668366014957428,
0.3606034517288208,
-0.12079279869794846,
0.00242676236666739,
-0.6927422285079956,
-0.3173513412475586,
-0.4547804594039917,
-0.06988626718521118,
-0.4301418364048004,
-1.2320683002471924,
0.16375544667243958,
-0.3819103240966797,
0.24245820939540863,
0.21887381374835968,
0.06646066904067993,
-0.13898180425167084,
1.1691991090774536,
0.11404746770858765,
0.11092065274715424,
0.31259575486183167,
0.1542668491601944,
0.05678777024149895,
-0.709536612033844,
-0.0532371886074543,
-0.7934688925743103,
0.030903955921530724,
-0.6745626926422119,
-0.2611337900161743,
0.427642285823822,
-0.42969268560409546,
-0.11175043135881424,
0.11396684497594833,
-0.5714579820632935,
0.459011048078537,
0.3165830075740814,
0.0210273340344429,
0.3808344006538391,
-0.14088362455368042,
-0.00602090684697032,
-0.2322591096162796,
-0.713679313659668,
-0.42919921875,
0.456258624792099,
0.15192700922489166,
0.4627176821231842,
-0.22757621109485626,
0.6269439458847046,
-0.08627954125404358,
0.6227446794509888,
-0.8669579029083252,
0.6847425103187561,
0.21717026829719543,
-0.5633864402770996,
-0.33236822485923767,
-0.4245397448539734,
-1.1874611377716064,
0.3953184485435486,
-0.09843951463699341,
-0.7878457903862,
0.20616257190704346,
0.39312320947647095,
-0.5167545080184937,
-0.22041146457195282,
-0.9534829258918762,
0.5067746043205261,
0.15352384746074677,
-0.1550818830728531,
0.24054893851280212,
-0.5833989381790161,
0.553469181060791,
0.22606869041919708,
0.2167748063802719,
-0.2356748729944229,
-0.005183867644518614,
0.5765382051467896,
-0.4358431398868561,
0.9364585876464844,
-0.29009872674942017,
-0.04224380478262901,
0.37166765332221985,
0.08260467648506165,
0.5661348104476929,
0.1414240151643753,
0.10467659682035446,
-0.23980043828487396,
-0.2010602504014969,
-0.3142423629760742,
-0.8848166465759277,
0.47391319274902344,
-0.3814418911933899,
-0.8456586599349976,
-0.4694068431854248,
-0.3489404320716858,
-0.6223511099815369,
0.05443105101585388,
0.42360374331474304,
0.21358099579811096,
-0.12797661125659943,
-0.151333749294281,
0.6957679986953735,
-0.005644191987812519,
0.4261898398399353,
0.25049880146980286,
-0.24080757796764374,
-0.03637019544839859,
0.5676788687705994,
0.3767699897289276,
0.17019329965114594,
0.08411788195371628,
0.03947833180427551,
-0.5080752968788147,
-0.351484090089798,
-0.3470495045185089,
0.2786400020122528,
-0.5989524126052856,
-0.13762015104293823,
-0.8308982849121094,
-0.2517232298851013,
-0.462952584028244,
0.009475854225456715,
-0.2586328983306885,
-0.5917672514915466,
-0.2501783072948456,
-0.34953632950782776,
0.4927699565887451,
0.6299494504928589,
0.1308339238166809,
0.35439953207969666,
-0.6599913835525513,
0.15324319899082184,
0.6816422939300537,
0.04090672731399536,
-0.029012449085712433,
-0.3659193515777588,
0.29181554913520813,
-0.12710461020469666,
-0.11308493465185165,
-1.023099660873413,
-0.008032465353608131,
0.1763773262500763,
0.2441193014383316,
0.3649511933326721,
0.16795608401298523,
0.9305649399757385,
-0.706717312335968,
0.8838738203048706,
0.0287022665143013,
-0.887971818447113,
0.8942207098007202,
-0.38800525665283203,
0.4810652732849121,
0.4637766182422638,
0.7786703109741211,
-0.3624178469181061,
-0.5075685977935791,
-0.7452676296234131,
-0.7681360840797424,
0.9013590812683105,
0.41475239396095276,
0.31173476576805115,
-0.14336273074150085,
0.2948552668094635,
0.06307364255189896,
0.0929885134100914,
-0.8148717284202576,
-0.34417054057121277,
-0.15769153833389282,
0.2782948911190033,
0.2834632694721222,
-0.37223997712135315,
0.10998343676328659,
-0.4020671248435974,
0.8323197364807129,
-0.1862143874168396,
0.27200353145599365,
0.294656902551651,
-0.02210402302443981,
0.2476627677679062,
0.48077383637428284,
0.49106383323669434,
0.6617972254753113,
0.16240088641643524,
0.2609252631664276,
0.4576585590839386,
-0.21429170668125153,
0.4251755475997925,
0.36784517765045166,
-0.30796560645103455,
0.34510669112205505,
0.22390469908714294,
0.7735588550567627,
0.38230231404304504,
-0.2655971646308899,
0.4630313515663147,
-0.22511960566043854,
-0.40171438455581665,
-0.17356649041175842,
0.1005198284983635,
0.25529763102531433,
-0.04061237350106239,
0.29665765166282654,
-0.19934190809726715,
0.18445317447185516,
-0.289005309343338,
0.013064654543995857,
0.3331749141216278,
-0.5549405813217163,
-0.05968722328543663,
0.32359543442726135,
0.20257672667503357,
-0.16715367138385773,
0.7608359456062317,
-0.4800111651420593,
-0.46495673060417175,
0.13105225563049316,
0.14824886620044708,
0.6409797668457031,
-0.4310150444507599,
0.5109303593635559,
0.513401985168457,
0.28955671191215515,
-0.2572094798088074,
-0.02386368066072464,
-0.2995254695415497,
-0.6254001259803772,
-0.9066862463951111,
-0.008744649589061737,
-0.7091760635375977,
0.21802884340286255,
-0.5012592673301697,
0.2531832754611969,
-0.5436973571777344,
-0.2578468322753906,
0.22416575253009796,
-0.3341713845729828,
-0.4622056186199188,
0.09236221760511398,
0.10331035405397415,
0.6238579750061035,
-0.6696035861968994,
0.473018079996109,
0.7244013547897339,
-0.39750903844833374,
-1.0542964935302734,
-0.053319428116083145,
0.09754662960767746,
-0.40407875180244446,
0.7412075400352478,
0.3502940833568573,
-0.16431055963039398,
0.13082191348075867,
-0.8696407079696655,
-0.512637197971344,
0.46407148241996765,
0.5539718866348267,
-0.3250061869621277,
-0.09845495969057083,
-0.04928332194685936,
0.5060089230537415,
-0.003222591010853648,
0.5712785124778748,
0.41617313027381897,
0.7111992239952087,
0.33764252066612244,
-1.0275436639785767,
0.17725388705730438,
-0.16999702155590057,
-0.06687746942043304,
0.19073624908924103,
-0.5121089816093445,
0.5858107209205627,
0.0019119539065286517,
-0.41091445088386536,
-0.10045920312404633,
0.8476997017860413,
0.3498941957950592,
0.4176875650882721,
0.6216304898262024,
0.12009517848491669,
0.8395677804946899,
-0.4614282250404358,
0.7870601415634155,
0.28118324279785156,
0.1324034035205841,
1.277668833732605,
-0.31358474493026733,
0.5803980231285095,
0.3339308202266693,
-0.17452123761177063,
0.5714859962463379,
0.7297894954681396,
-0.0010540992952883244,
0.13421206176280975,
0.038998398929834366,
-0.38080716133117676,
-0.30504128336906433,
-0.3849049210548401,
-0.4141709506511688,
0.4335618019104004,
0.5590661764144897,
-0.12083700299263,
-0.25339049100875854,
0.0016840872121974826,
0.2762698829174042,
-0.1834678202867508,
-0.3564353287220001,
0.9212347269058228,
0.3246484398841858,
-1.2030563354492188,
0.5417708158493042,
-0.5533846616744995,
0.5039637088775635,
-0.34401872754096985,
-0.2501017153263092,
-0.07593984156847,
-0.6019078493118286,
-0.31243813037872314,
-0.7006853818893433,
0.10134489834308624,
-0.08704127371311188,
0.19910362362861633,
-0.32612648606300354,
1.0357187986373901,
-0.3410802185535431,
-0.17737790942192078,
-0.055426280945539474,
0.746803343296051,
0.31897029280662537,
-0.19950538873672485,
-0.5438864827156067,
-0.3597569465637207,
-0.19509056210517883,
-0.4419339597225189,
0.20401917397975922,
0.7043610215187073,
-0.04014382138848305,
0.5066880583763123,
0.7542333006858826,
-0.283818781375885,
-0.11401571333408356,
0.13899175822734833,
0.8511554002761841,
-0.4313425123691559,
-0.4731220304965973,
-0.8274290561676025,
0.5179502964019775,
-0.2822053134441376,
-0.2539270222187042,
0.8577949404716492,
0.16505160927772522,
0.5738037824630737,
-0.12659695744514465,
0.8186522126197815,
0.14528684318065643,
0.6003177165985107,
-0.6098532676696777,
0.24464914202690125,
0.04307987540960312,
0.05207676440477371,
-0.4712408483028412,
-0.7981829047203064,
-0.21817688643932343,
0.523508608341217,
-0.6152413487434387,
0.2503010034561157,
0.9270742535591125,
0.6596373319625854,
0.07820312678813934,
0.312898725271225,
0.29095447063446045,
0.12038778513669968,
0.15231716632843018,
0.43632176518440247,
1.3608119487762451,
0.06392889469861984,
0.8080540895462036,
-0.0495997853577137,
-0.13644033670425415,
0.05794057622551918,
-0.9944420456886292,
-1.1215810775756836,
-0.5399035811424255,
-0.546088695526123,
-0.25314751267433167,
0.20360194146633148,
0.9569456577301025,
0.8377920985221863,
-0.5484552979469299,
0.29138389229774475,
-0.15435633063316345,
0.1647285372018814,
-0.10443223267793655,
-0.24840039014816284,
0.3536553978919983,
-0.4727937877178192,
-0.895730197429657,
0.1800316423177719,
0.2586425542831421,
0.21248379349708557,
-0.12443205714225769,
0.26754048466682434,
-0.2939067780971527,
-0.047231525182724,
0.7214530110359192,
0.4281165599822998,
-0.5832777619361877,
-0.5132583975791931,
-0.2528750002384186,
0.1853589415550232,
0.16452743113040924,
0.9549077749252319,
-0.8750097155570984,
0.09114748984575272,
0.4973302483558655,
0.4656754434108734,
0.6785498857498169,
0.2248537391424179,
0.47944149374961853,
-1.1516945362091064,
0.21362833678722382,
0.3596244156360626,
0.23079748451709747,
0.2640960216522217,
-0.49936532974243164,
0.6102506518363953,
0.014987340196967125,
-0.6687160134315491,
-0.5749518275260925,
0.38364624977111816,
-0.8095828890800476,
-0.2217588573694229,
1.1865921020507812,
-0.3965320289134979,
-0.14245647192001343,
-0.6646932363510132,
-0.8367627859115601,
0.14151661098003387,
-0.6887041330337524,
0.5276446342468262,
0.9689671993255615,
-0.6531703472137451,
-0.5781341791152954,
-0.5805931091308594,
0.824114978313446,
0.5138509273529053,
-0.7914811372756958,
0.12435843050479889,
0.7217585444450378,
-0.08620345592498779,
0.3438428044319153,
0.9226199388504028,
0.13380642235279083,
0.47999078035354614,
-0.07311058789491653,
-0.37009209394454956,
-0.12044721096754074,
-0.16693545877933502,
-0.004090442787855864,
0.3984811007976532,
0.2707388699054718,
-0.08185994625091553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04914v1 | Personalized Text Generation with Fine-Grained Linguistic Control | 2024-02-07T14:41:08 | 2024-02-07T14:41:08 | Bashar Alhafni, Vivek Kulkarni, Dhruv Kumar, Vipul Raheja | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the text generation capabilities of large language models become
increasingly prominent, recent studies have focused on controlling particular
aspects of the generated text to make it more personalized. However, most
research on controllable text generation focuses on controlling the content or
modeling specific high-level/coarse-grained attributes that reflect authors'
writing styles, such as formality, domain, or sentiment. In this paper, we
focus on controlling fine-grained attributes spanning multiple linguistic
dimensions, such as lexical and syntactic attributes. We introduce a novel
benchmark to train generative models and evaluate their ability to generate
personalized text based on multiple fine-grained linguistic attributes. We
systematically investigate the performance of various large language models on
our benchmark and draw insights from the factors that impact their performance.
We make our code, data, and pretrained models publicly available. | [
-0.469232439994812,
-0.92207270860672,
0.44269102811813354,
0.3579666316509247,
0.1326238363981247,
0.04948046803474426,
-0.46010956168174744,
-0.32335135340690613,
-0.07985617965459824,
0.5765182375907898,
-0.5365471243858337,
-0.6597078442573547,
-0.4826294779777527,
0.16868124902248383,
-0.3132209777832031,
1.3003047704696655,
0.04654603824019432,
-0.22313492000102997,
-0.25679439306259155,
-0.09424102306365967,
-0.27913886308670044,
-0.7407229542732239,
-0.5353719592094421,
-0.4235020875930786,
0.735002875328064,
0.17689496278762817,
0.8704192638397217,
0.47799986600875854,
0.590271532535553,
0.30474981665611267,
-0.2248796671628952,
0.0702022984623909,
-0.36308133602142334,
0.1473747342824936,
-0.4095573425292969,
-0.28577035665512085,
-0.48368117213249207,
-0.07987449318170547,
0.6417610049247742,
0.5509030222892761,
-0.1443762332201004,
0.2836495339870453,
0.17934492230415344,
0.38951489329338074,
-0.7008668780326843,
0.02577320858836174,
-0.6925264596939087,
0.06609596312046051,
-0.43509605526924133,
-0.1788969188928604,
-0.5506991744041443,
-0.6338399648666382,
-0.040452681481838226,
-0.49308228492736816,
0.42331916093826294,
-0.03441186994314194,
0.9202134013175964,
-0.03442179784178734,
-0.23037631809711456,
-0.2905184328556061,
-1.0796902179718018,
0.8588321208953857,
-0.8206141591072083,
0.1322336345911026,
0.5873690843582153,
0.26796141266822815,
0.07879878580570221,
-0.7980807423591614,
-0.5024109482765198,
-0.3718970715999603,
-0.13087932765483856,
0.008747700601816177,
-0.05706218630075455,
-0.013293726369738579,
0.16557811200618744,
0.43688929080963135,
-0.3053121864795685,
0.34677010774612427,
0.039055995643138885,
-0.1797744631767273,
0.6021425724029541,
0.39916378259658813,
0.24821868538856506,
-0.174075186252594,
-0.2368893176317215,
-0.25884002447128296,
-0.3185299336910248,
0.14803194999694824,
0.6181498169898987,
0.3911740183830261,
-0.13820523023605347,
0.6508812308311462,
-0.611863911151886,
0.5520967245101929,
0.06232121214270592,
-0.18665584921836853,
0.23215752840042114,
-0.503755509853363,
-0.05885482206940651,
-0.022336173802614212,
1.0986789464950562,
0.1999499350786209,
0.397681325674057,
-0.34389644861221313,
-0.36952289938926697,
-0.11330021917819977,
0.3302507698535919,
-0.959294319152832,
-0.23279979825019836,
0.1393624097108841,
-0.5165839791297913,
-0.6875482201576233,
-0.16063354909420013,
-0.6547128558158875,
-0.46013009548187256,
-0.2779969274997711,
0.19769956171512604,
-0.6427371501922607,
0.03546096384525299,
-0.04048710688948631,
0.065936379134655,
-0.026981227099895477,
0.08656704425811768,
-1.342848777770996,
0.29793599247932434,
0.5298764705657959,
0.7640915513038635,
-0.22113560140132904,
-0.3958463966846466,
-0.49485793709754944,
0.24051569402217865,
-0.3008236885070801,
0.6721352934837341,
-0.8312034010887146,
-0.1180487796664238,
0.2809502184391022,
-0.5010825991630554,
0.21356728672981262,
-0.380405455827713,
0.2739141583442688,
-0.45462316274642944,
0.10525912791490555,
-0.0931522399187088,
-0.4700961112976074,
0.2623883783817291,
0.171889990568161,
-0.5038763880729675,
0.8908494114875793,
0.13308286666870117,
-0.6909092664718628,
0.5927169322967529,
-0.2419593334197998,
-0.5075991749763489,
0.14297746121883392,
-0.412149578332901,
-0.7796806693077087,
0.39209693670272827,
0.022510001435875893,
0.8299776315689087,
-0.39320147037506104,
0.520146369934082,
-0.334256649017334,
0.275432288646698,
0.48073312640190125,
-0.33549103140830994,
0.09526530653238297,
0.27701494097709656,
-0.2697528302669525,
0.2649713456630707,
-1.1548999547958374,
0.40201544761657715,
0.14417500793933868,
-0.5046907067298889,
-0.42803439497947693,
0.01742495223879814,
0.4679168462753296,
0.15538273751735687,
0.47089681029319763,
-0.4848378896713257,
0.06331601738929749,
-0.24337004125118256,
0.32683810591697693,
0.6782428026199341,
-0.02967921644449234,
0.5118729472160339,
-0.2959604561328888,
0.47034770250320435,
-0.004243981558829546,
-0.16670919954776764,
-0.24072995781898499,
-0.15955394506454468,
-0.5589725375175476,
-0.0057037826627492905,
0.36247262358665466,
0.20341607928276062,
-0.5349695086479187,
0.5866262912750244,
-0.013116138055920601,
-0.5840461254119873,
-0.3102436661720276,
0.3620920479297638,
0.8598664402961731,
0.028888048604130745,
0.29142919182777405,
-0.3860219717025757,
0.04546599090099335,
-1.0138142108917236,
-0.519697904586792,
0.21697767078876495,
-0.2189822942018509,
0.5082908272743225,
0.2941873371601105,
-0.06599985063076019,
0.8929786682128906,
-0.8160702586174011,
-0.27263039350509644,
-0.43062594532966614,
0.5971640944480896,
-0.4174620807170868,
0.6246741414070129,
0.6733503937721252,
-0.6924166679382324,
-0.5184526443481445,
0.2955567240715027,
-0.489493727684021,
-0.4006485939025879,
-0.4250335693359375,
-0.1929446905851364,
-0.00785732176154852,
0.43865448236465454,
-0.41664159297943115,
0.2995862662792206,
0.6912817358970642,
-0.580966591835022,
0.6295377612113953,
-0.41819798946380615,
-0.08103341609239578,
-1.2534223794937134,
0.2930190861225128,
0.2973751127719879,
-0.30987051129341125,
-0.6557339429855347,
0.26742029190063477,
0.10430403798818588,
-0.11063399165868759,
-0.2679082453250885,
0.44468703866004944,
-0.21187761425971985,
0.09196769446134567,
-0.14891012012958527,
-0.13858410716056824,
0.033494967967271805,
0.5744302868843079,
0.04972267150878906,
0.7066695690155029,
0.245466947555542,
-0.5909612774848938,
0.08848308026790619,
0.3372243642807007,
-0.44195085763931274,
0.5720361471176147,
-0.7279834151268005,
0.09870750457048416,
-0.10351826250553131,
-0.05612409859895706,
-0.6522606015205383,
-0.5524085164070129,
-0.3575390875339508,
-0.15928944945335388,
0.2654029130935669,
0.475455105304718,
-0.668427586555481,
0.048700083047151566,
-0.05642079934477806,
0.1225074976682663,
0.3353658616542816,
-0.2765622138977051,
0.6038039326667786,
0.09783170372247696,
-0.41232380270957947,
0.09065241366624832,
-0.6605489253997803,
-0.038341421633958817,
-0.06421622633934021,
-0.2809121012687683,
0.5489639639854431,
-0.16842080652713776,
-0.10230804234743118,
-0.15600332617759705,
0.24484916031360626,
-0.11438155919313431,
0.14475153386592865,
0.18264944851398468,
-0.27155762910842896,
-0.11957579106092453,
0.11566409468650818,
0.39087533950805664,
-0.1061679944396019,
-0.048413489013910294,
0.04199298471212387,
0.906287431716919,
0.02198869176208973,
0.01840253360569477,
-0.6424168944358826,
0.3604380786418915,
0.2811015844345093,
-0.7570884227752686,
0.934868335723877,
0.7491163015365601,
-0.1129198670387268,
-0.49241286516189575,
-0.5179173946380615,
-0.04254213720560074,
-0.4958670139312744,
0.5108881592750549,
-0.5610054135322571,
-0.8509463667869568,
0.5795131325721741,
-0.00880936998873949,
0.014510329812765121,
0.34983357787132263,
0.8203670978546143,
0.23643818497657776,
1.2135934829711914,
0.8995208740234375,
-0.05189574509859085,
0.5535484552383423,
0.00607516011223197,
-0.060514673590660095,
-0.6437470316886902,
-0.28038451075553894,
-0.7097129225730896,
-0.385569304227829,
-0.9168808460235596,
-0.05245194211602211,
-0.06810823827981949,
0.09371695667505264,
-0.4469853639602661,
0.24524642527103424,
-0.5779944062232971,
0.4067050516605377,
0.7938492298126221,
0.07691363990306854,
0.26427072286605835,
-0.11295600980520248,
-0.24857386946678162,
0.034197475761175156,
-0.4115575850009918,
-0.7225227952003479,
0.7909148335456848,
0.29726019501686096,
1.09525465965271,
0.06590976566076279,
0.6754698157310486,
0.1625651866197586,
0.08115110546350479,
-0.3815546929836273,
0.4205375909805298,
-0.707210123538971,
-0.49534282088279724,
-0.1408376693725586,
-0.6025694012641907,
-0.6229867339134216,
0.014124064706265926,
-0.46337518095970154,
-0.875389039516449,
-0.04947445169091225,
0.42148858308792114,
-0.5021508932113647,
0.21069589257240295,
-0.8181683421134949,
0.9249736070632935,
-0.21814145147800446,
-0.48785263299942017,
-0.10013565421104431,
-0.4495600759983063,
0.2292884737253189,
-0.38160425424575806,
-0.22373710572719574,
-0.2745947539806366,
0.03085765428841114,
0.45061883330345154,
-0.2555783987045288,
0.9380077719688416,
0.12442896515130997,
-0.034806862473487854,
-0.06448112428188324,
0.3130037486553192,
0.49781638383865356,
0.11678453534841537,
-0.015095463022589684,
0.15197652578353882,
-0.11688589304685593,
-0.2414630800485611,
-0.2624891996383667,
1.0252524614334106,
-0.7650824189186096,
-0.2926521599292755,
-0.07394975423812866,
-0.5107994675636292,
-0.3625623285770416,
0.49943438172340393,
0.5951138138771057,
0.6521931290626526,
-0.41995373368263245,
0.40801045298576355,
0.5399304032325745,
-0.6228779554367065,
0.49889180064201355,
0.17729298770427704,
-0.20112642645835876,
-0.44049879908561707,
0.9863157868385315,
-0.06088387221097946,
0.5542014837265015,
0.6702276468276978,
0.5357954502105713,
0.014864934608340263,
-0.5800899863243103,
-0.3281705379486084,
-0.14764133095741272,
-0.399771511554718,
-0.32210665941238403,
-0.7816226482391357,
-0.263594388961792,
-0.45112287998199463,
-0.33714020252227783,
-0.43573346734046936,
-0.17073440551757812,
-0.463674396276474,
0.24656715989112854,
0.2528155446052551,
0.9523910880088806,
0.6587954163551331,
0.7646883726119995,
-0.7602296471595764,
0.4755944609642029,
0.19238434731960297,
0.6314876079559326,
0.025079965591430664,
-0.1288088858127594,
-0.18373747169971466,
-0.16268442571163177,
-0.7338334918022156,
-0.569979190826416,
0.38915756344795227,
0.44138064980506897,
0.2694947421550751,
0.4018745422363281,
-0.1135072410106659,
0.24044166505336761,
-0.8068519234657288,
0.8625320792198181,
0.28971564769744873,
-1.0629736185073853,
0.6981544494628906,
-0.3805449903011322,
0.8554911613464355,
0.5296388268470764,
0.1907120943069458,
-0.2943653464317322,
-0.9197313785552979,
-0.5315881967544556,
-0.6603217720985413,
0.7059563994407654,
0.5248263478279114,
0.5163860321044922,
0.09419719129800797,
0.3856525123119354,
0.28777390718460083,
0.4257122278213501,
-0.7691106796264648,
0.0024310436565428972,
-0.13189326226711273,
-0.43196746706962585,
-0.34319937229156494,
-0.4560402035713196,
0.09000475704669952,
0.05485386401414871,
0.4018001854419708,
-0.19574634730815887,
-0.16337473690509796,
-0.10165031999349594,
0.25412753224372864,
0.021901536732912064,
0.4073789119720459,
0.700403094291687,
0.4707266092300415,
0.009276852011680603,
0.17807182669639587,
-0.06524629890918732,
-0.4373667240142822,
-0.10828123986721039,
0.12103765457868576,
-0.4181363880634308,
-0.13774341344833374,
0.34911784529685974,
1.1178722381591797,
0.13618893921375275,
-0.35806745290756226,
0.41069453954696655,
-0.032319240272045135,
-0.19482025504112244,
-0.03511166200041771,
0.34208622574806213,
-0.011003081686794758,
0.11558588594198227,
-0.14935556054115295,
0.24749723076820374,
-0.04797939583659172,
-0.3128189146518707,
-0.07228577136993408,
0.36593538522720337,
-0.20151925086975098,
-0.6337233781814575,
1.1324621438980103,
0.3290446698665619,
-0.23964610695838928,
0.24358469247817993,
-0.1964680552482605,
-0.22167502343654633,
0.31555497646331787,
0.7006822824478149,
1.0769046545028687,
-0.21682588756084442,
0.3599783778190613,
0.31067827343940735,
0.07371122390031815,
0.07059167325496674,
0.11070892959833145,
-0.13212208449840546,
-0.8232754468917847,
-0.20093883574008942,
-1.0824849605560303,
-0.19268429279327393,
0.37720319628715515,
-0.6666688919067383,
0.12871922552585602,
-0.7021926045417786,
-0.4684072434902191,
0.5631139278411865,
-0.08078846335411072,
-0.7987788319587708,
0.41299471259117126,
0.13757824897766113,
0.784903883934021,
-0.7984781265258789,
0.7770869731903076,
0.7042655944824219,
-0.4073086678981781,
-0.644820511341095,
0.08603363484144211,
-0.17754028737545013,
-0.37051692605018616,
0.6225008964538574,
0.16153784096240997,
-0.1286109834909439,
0.04773222655057907,
-0.4780418276786804,
-0.6182979941368103,
0.7837198376655579,
0.1620604246854782,
-0.6132347583770752,
-0.11965897679328918,
0.3795740306377411,
0.7543759346008301,
-0.3234228491783142,
-0.03269815817475319,
0.759840190410614,
0.22966256737709045,
-0.06453707069158554,
-0.9086009860038757,
-0.15133734047412872,
-0.20942650735378265,
0.6462606191635132,
0.35775017738342285,
-0.6839157342910767,
0.8286296129226685,
-0.015733009204268456,
0.04104521870613098,
0.311475932598114,
0.7921254634857178,
0.0808166116476059,
0.170652374625206,
0.19028091430664062,
0.5564348101615906,
0.6106581091880798,
-0.07733040302991867,
1.3265951871871948,
-0.5590183734893799,
0.24264195561408997,
1.3081802129745483,
-0.278339684009552,
0.8482168316841125,
0.19068340957164764,
0.06274136155843735,
0.43467557430267334,
0.21470032632350922,
-0.017642883583903313,
0.5835029482841492,
0.1513098180294037,
-0.3868568241596222,
-0.16087889671325684,
-0.2796812355518341,
-0.20668186247348785,
0.6602624654769897,
0.09349492192268372,
-0.7508363127708435,
-0.034462131559848785,
0.20900623500347137,
0.07225080579519272,
0.5956701636314392,
-0.2307603508234024,
1.0631295442581177,
-0.2084866613149643,
-0.6001068949699402,
0.1639905571937561,
0.32015976309776306,
0.7329281568527222,
-0.8386602997779846,
0.3098269999027252,
-0.22774077951908112,
0.45511266589164734,
-0.14990191161632538,
-0.8721712827682495,
0.05571086332201958,
0.31401827931404114,
-0.28225305676460266,
-0.5514086484909058,
0.681854248046875,
-0.569831371307373,
-0.6114484071731567,
-0.10013032704591751,
0.13149794936180115,
-0.29459723830223083,
-0.004415699280798435,
-0.36827656626701355,
0.10924162715673447,
-0.08980284631252289,
-0.5333050489425659,
0.39197441935539246,
0.5664718747138977,
-0.09294608980417252,
0.6261324286460876,
0.5881757736206055,
0.49136218428611755,
0.11468663066625595,
0.34400445222854614,
0.8465136289596558,
-0.7431399822235107,
-0.6277946829795837,
-0.7661641836166382,
0.24802400171756744,
-0.15290310978889465,
-1.0197780132293701,
0.7469826340675354,
0.6982805728912354,
1.0609945058822632,
-0.31530916690826416,
0.819301187992096,
-0.22797805070877075,
0.3341164290904999,
-0.6833056807518005,
0.9643059372901917,
-0.3947310745716095,
-0.1484164148569107,
-0.33097466826438904,
-0.890681266784668,
-0.3243575394153595,
0.34604060649871826,
-0.25328096747398376,
0.33237582445144653,
0.46475541591644287,
0.6578404903411865,
0.015584249049425125,
-0.17940598726272583,
0.4357220232486725,
0.12919968366622925,
0.5492523908615112,
0.29518428444862366,
0.7438053488731384,
0.0019710289780050516,
0.11230836063623428,
-0.697242259979248,
-0.12254488468170166,
0.05345945805311203,
-1.0155094861984253,
-1.0238592624664307,
-0.69448322057724,
-0.3074114918708801,
-0.24931779503822327,
-0.25006335973739624,
0.6887168884277344,
0.6430414915084839,
-0.8808131814002991,
-0.11249911785125732,
-0.44104239344596863,
-0.32909709215164185,
-0.053711555898189545,
-0.2543725371360779,
0.22567704319953918,
-0.6904850602149963,
-0.8427245616912842,
-0.14313527941703796,
0.18257346749305725,
0.10294847190380096,
-0.5096398591995239,
0.10857971012592316,
0.09328329563140869,
0.18225321173667908,
0.7338090538978577,
0.0019205897115170956,
-0.5985138416290283,
-0.19181640446186066,
-0.24748584628105164,
-0.5677009224891663,
-0.0917995423078537,
1.1585376262664795,
-0.42568767070770264,
0.5691704750061035,
0.6437527537345886,
0.48583176732063293,
0.2803022563457489,
0.20289666950702667,
0.6616090536117554,
-1.2311594486236572,
0.08040396869182587,
0.15637244284152985,
-0.020207982510328293,
0.3507407307624817,
-0.47573041915893555,
-0.0061682118102908134,
-0.1489984095096588,
-0.7686442136764526,
-0.4693944752216339,
0.1668059527873993,
-0.8699288964271545,
-0.22458156943321228,
1.265817642211914,
-0.02837146818637848,
0.01609092392027378,
0.45754197239875793,
-0.19166311621665955,
0.06437567621469498,
-0.31806614995002747,
0.7588483095169067,
0.5789640545845032,
-0.015434181317687035,
0.026321083307266235,
-0.5528998970985413,
0.779941976070404,
0.3248581886291504,
-1.074556589126587,
0.31092599034309387,
0.4996011257171631,
0.09488189220428467,
0.14775235950946808,
0.5450960397720337,
0.02854984439909458,
-0.024041736498475075,
-0.05112401396036148,
0.325041264295578,
-0.024789970368146896,
-0.4494694769382477,
-0.28511330485343933,
0.30933278799057007,
0.15716904401779175,
0.149909108877182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04902v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04902v3 | L4Q: Parameter Efficient Quantization-Aware Fine-Tuning on Large Language Models | 2024-02-07T14:35:05 | 2024-05-22T20:23:54 | Hyesung Jeon, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-joon Kim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Due to the high memory and computational costs associated with Large Language
Models, model compression via quantization and parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT) methods, such as low-rank adaptation (LoRA), are gaining popularity.
This has led to active research on quantization-aware PEFT techniques, which
aim to create models with high accuracy and low memory overhead. Among
quantization methods, post-training quantization (PTQ) is more commonly used in
previous works than quantization-aware training (QAT), despite QAT's potential
for higher accuracy. This preference is due to PTQ's low training overhead.
However, PTQ-based PEFT methods often utilize high-precision parameters, making
it difficult to fully exploit the efficiency of quantization. Additionally,
they have limited adaptation ability due to a reduced and constrained LoRA
parameter structure. To overcome these challenges, we propose L4Q, which
leverages joint quantization and fine-tuning to reduce QAT's memory overhead
and produce models that consist entirely of quantized weights while achieving
effective adaptation to downstream tasks. By design, L4Q allows quantization
parameters to reflect weight updates, while weight updates reduce quantization
errors. Our experiments demonstrate that this coupled quantization and
fine-tuning approach yields superior accuracy compared to decoupled fine-tuning
schemes in sub-4-bit quantization. Using the LLaMA model families and
instructional datasets, we showcase L4Q's capabilities in language tasks and
few-shot in-context learning. | [
-0.20168136060237885,
-0.6438500881195068,
0.5861654877662659,
-0.05643116682767868,
-0.40102723240852356,
0.16942256689071655,
-0.2976132035255432,
-0.20166638493537903,
-0.30715349316596985,
0.4919881522655487,
-0.20515823364257812,
-0.4663974940776825,
-0.3139585852622986,
0.05780933052301407,
-0.22044944763183594,
0.998873233795166,
-0.08982980251312256,
-0.17478956282138824,
0.036994822323322296,
-0.31392982602119446,
-0.22323276102542877,
-0.6645126938819885,
-0.8822463154792786,
-0.12207301706075668,
0.5510942935943604,
0.3499922454357147,
0.7164903879165649,
0.5688400268554688,
0.28948327898979187,
0.21951721608638763,
0.01984926499426365,
0.11508537828922272,
-0.6923354268074036,
-0.08028474450111389,
0.07250632345676422,
-0.7142441868782043,
-0.7548916935920715,
-0.16755682229995728,
0.9517600536346436,
0.5941997170448303,
-0.07310310006141663,
0.31890684366226196,
0.1138606145977974,
0.8623772263526917,
-0.9055044651031494,
0.09587052464485168,
-0.7266486287117004,
-0.06787282228469849,
-0.25783923268318176,
-0.2738058567047119,
-0.07077834010124207,
-0.39333826303482056,
-0.2579043209552765,
-0.8867921829223633,
-0.017338771373033524,
-0.04004502668976784,
0.7748668789863586,
0.49849212169647217,
-0.5240098834037781,
0.2729073762893677,
-0.6456404328346252,
0.9278734922409058,
-0.8924170136451721,
0.6555476784706116,
0.686241090297699,
0.10102082043886185,
0.06342247873544693,
-0.7121937274932861,
-0.35913029313087463,
0.17188753187656403,
0.34660056233406067,
0.025017932057380676,
-0.1332409381866455,
0.3334769606590271,
0.3732721209526062,
0.36675140261650085,
-0.39549943804740906,
0.16769932210445404,
-0.23820926249027252,
-0.14025402069091797,
0.3410665690898895,
-0.058958496898412704,
-0.1207403913140297,
0.2603902220726013,
-0.06915576010942459,
0.00005478082675836049,
-0.9646987915039062,
0.2370406985282898,
0.41647568345069885,
0.23692190647125244,
-0.03981446102261543,
0.18128740787506104,
-0.6354976296424866,
0.8644765019416809,
0.33354222774505615,
-0.3122839331626892,
0.07450743764638901,
-0.5389829277992249,
-0.17818067967891693,
-0.03614652901887894,
0.621949315071106,
0.18196214735507965,
0.01232756394892931,
-0.035117946565151215,
-0.30763787031173706,
-0.2180940955877304,
-0.04674168676137924,
-1.0498954057693481,
-0.40525299310684204,
0.1816857010126114,
-0.36561715602874756,
-0.1624985784292221,
-0.5452452301979065,
-0.4086092710494995,
-0.12827813625335693,
-0.25019222497940063,
0.9182505011558533,
-0.492631196975708,
0.06898258626461029,
0.20466849207878113,
0.20954762399196625,
0.41623085737228394,
0.4128882884979248,
-1.0536563396453857,
0.4695837199687958,
0.6838685870170593,
0.5910833477973938,
0.0799555778503418,
-0.18523205816745758,
-1.0171961784362793,
0.3131415545940399,
-0.3298148810863495,
0.6024786233901978,
-0.36769938468933105,
0.0917649194598198,
-0.33180129528045654,
-0.20539964735507965,
0.1303289383649826,
-0.4324468970298767,
0.5751689672470093,
-0.5981968641281128,
0.05948031693696976,
-0.25691458582878113,
-0.42337337136268616,
-0.25393256545066833,
0.23263245820999146,
-0.7047638297080994,
1.1249150037765503,
0.3370591402053833,
-0.6240606904029846,
0.3121681213378906,
-0.4143800139427185,
-0.1217488944530487,
0.09091035276651382,
-0.02016090787947178,
-0.6089535355567932,
0.21377286314964294,
0.4108600616455078,
0.4575842022895813,
-0.4270133972167969,
0.0717230886220932,
-0.30454882979393005,
-0.7289795279502869,
0.04497063159942627,
-0.32808148860931396,
0.3723992705345154,
0.07470027357339859,
-0.17052651941776276,
0.27327221632003784,
-0.7227707505226135,
0.1987345963716507,
0.03561266511678696,
-0.6610153317451477,
-0.4729480445384979,
-0.08339088410139084,
-0.3794177174568176,
-0.10396301001310349,
0.4478236734867096,
-0.07710113376379013,
0.2665019929409027,
-0.6166387796401978,
0.6227834820747375,
0.5960926413536072,
-0.05824996531009674,
0.6456468105316162,
-0.19972029328346252,
0.5069507956504822,
-0.1728074997663498,
0.2542487680912018,
-0.0533599816262722,
-0.19028028845787048,
-0.7289766669273376,
-0.32988256216049194,
0.7671008706092834,
0.3076293170452118,
-0.9067402482032776,
0.20468366146087646,
-0.27709415555000305,
-0.24532312154769897,
-0.44892004132270813,
0.30126523971557617,
0.3979605734348297,
0.3040659427642822,
0.27143606543540955,
-0.17078867554664612,
-0.3828495740890503,
-0.7364003658294678,
-0.3691747188568115,
-0.04706951230764389,
-0.017372028902173042,
-0.030511412769556046,
0.26122114062309265,
0.18044166266918182,
0.5747204422950745,
-0.2573404610157013,
-0.08078272640705109,
-0.133989155292511,
-0.007033020723611116,
0.3502306044101715,
0.4519040882587433,
0.570741593837738,
-0.5328067541122437,
-0.4729554057121277,
-0.015969788655638695,
-0.2589567303657532,
-0.039730507880449295,
-0.0450214184820652,
-0.3465999364852905,
0.14112409949302673,
0.36171016097068787,
-0.4184055030345917,
0.09936929494142532,
0.769006609916687,
-0.23042291402816772,
0.23873430490493774,
-0.27944567799568176,
0.1657649576663971,
-0.9728551506996155,
-0.017508547753095627,
-0.21962979435920715,
-0.6393568515777588,
-0.5736955404281616,
0.1729109287261963,
0.3627387583255768,
-0.11175324022769928,
-0.36155837774276733,
0.37157511711120605,
-0.46050798892974854,
-0.27683600783348083,
-0.21527199447155,
-0.11593453586101532,
0.26247185468673706,
0.7223176956176758,
-0.1524030715227127,
0.7848324179649353,
0.5574986338615417,
-0.5333452224731445,
0.12390062212944031,
-0.048264142125844955,
-0.17079247534275055,
0.4461936950683594,
-0.6247555017471313,
0.18505115807056427,
0.2145889699459076,
0.1550002247095108,
-0.5686025023460388,
-0.10959220677614212,
0.2635567784309387,
-0.11614467948675156,
0.12224499881267548,
-0.36262446641921997,
-0.7016018629074097,
0.081158347427845,
-0.5640745759010315,
0.8091514110565186,
0.6871007680892944,
-0.48250845074653625,
0.6160141825675964,
0.1509690135717392,
-0.09422235935926437,
-0.42599061131477356,
-0.3088200092315674,
-0.20937737822532654,
-0.5014111995697021,
-0.13775962591171265,
0.5937219858169556,
-0.22171498835086823,
0.11799100041389465,
-0.20930957794189453,
-0.3374495506286621,
-0.29560768604278564,
0.2503269612789154,
-0.10557183623313904,
-0.21901629865169525,
-0.1592331975698471,
0.13784295320510864,
0.4228880703449249,
0.021958811208605766,
-0.2317439168691635,
-0.2589658200740814,
0.4030204713344574,
-0.314433753490448,
-0.03655929118394852,
-0.5812422037124634,
0.19247108697891235,
0.40041103959083557,
-0.4992440640926361,
0.6795343160629272,
0.7686008214950562,
-0.4788902997970581,
-0.1695307046175003,
-0.31965094804763794,
-0.2478654533624649,
-0.4938463568687439,
0.3966299891471863,
-0.6848575472831726,
-1.146208643913269,
0.3528035283088684,
-0.3339252173900604,
0.00012918960419483483,
0.12047164142131805,
0.5500347018241882,
-0.08000920712947845,
1.065627932548523,
0.5787149667739868,
0.0625949427485466,
0.6268649697303772,
-0.14449191093444824,
0.21701522171497345,
-0.7945080995559692,
0.3110598623752594,
-0.400984525680542,
-0.46192824840545654,
-0.44401806592941284,
-0.6485950946807861,
0.5433881878852844,
0.6713191866874695,
-0.5622892379760742,
0.2493179738521576,
-0.3871827721595764,
0.5754191875457764,
0.7444396018981934,
0.23473916947841644,
0.42757636308670044,
-0.05105733498930931,
0.2701762616634369,
0.013029646128416061,
-0.8030537366867065,
-0.0802280604839325,
1.1010375022888184,
0.3081205189228058,
0.6721300482749939,
0.25908195972442627,
0.7472082376480103,
0.028223274275660515,
-0.23487725853919983,
-0.9306470155715942,
0.4466279447078705,
-0.1723029613494873,
-0.07167713344097137,
-0.4648759067058563,
-0.5113462805747986,
-0.8983550071716309,
0.23761822283267975,
-0.32671481370925903,
-0.48083066940307617,
0.12798398733139038,
0.4501420259475708,
-0.8295774459838867,
0.1466551274061203,
-0.5583677291870117,
0.8800540566444397,
-0.3860422670841217,
-0.4981180727481842,
-0.3841046988964081,
-0.43466487526893616,
0.40914347767829895,
-0.5838204622268677,
0.2126236855983734,
-0.2919301688671112,
-0.37105122208595276,
0.7786458730697632,
-0.3357402980327606,
0.8319846987724304,
-0.11858395487070084,
-0.36949819326400757,
0.00918988324701786,
0.13764667510986328,
0.6473160982131958,
0.11934991180896759,
-0.1362897902727127,
0.20704106986522675,
0.542913019657135,
-0.5833437442779541,
-0.7567279934883118,
0.7623441815376282,
-0.8759334683418274,
-0.4824143350124359,
-0.09883730113506317,
-0.6425769925117493,
-0.4318273365497589,
0.20999158918857574,
-0.05909009277820587,
0.36679649353027344,
0.2681466042995453,
0.27989286184310913,
0.6075344681739807,
-0.3830793499946594,
0.30323782563209534,
0.39937448501586914,
-0.1250021606683731,
-0.5123305320739746,
0.9065936803817749,
0.012645714916288853,
0.2791845500469208,
0.6041454076766968,
0.323246568441391,
-0.16365638375282288,
-0.83673095703125,
-0.2689746618270874,
0.32519909739494324,
-0.4975009858608246,
-0.6141453981399536,
-0.2275533527135849,
-0.018394015729427338,
-0.20292510092258453,
-0.018688661977648735,
-0.6429013013839722,
-0.6003197431564331,
-0.3111370801925659,
0.24796296656131744,
0.6215636134147644,
0.15466614067554474,
0.13707692921161652,
0.6274685263633728,
-0.9217247366905212,
0.5587610006332397,
0.5194021463394165,
0.4165419638156891,
-0.3049599826335907,
-0.7786776423454285,
-0.635974109172821,
-0.011584938503801823,
-0.30439144372940063,
-0.6013839244842529,
0.2947918772697449,
0.6797406673431396,
0.26084426045417786,
0.22880049049854279,
0.2849370837211609,
0.8951912522315979,
-0.48657408356666565,
0.5969929099082947,
-0.014499354176223278,
-1.3207041025161743,
0.46963709592819214,
-0.4008825421333313,
0.49383991956710815,
0.5226551294326782,
0.34649503231048584,
-0.07851751148700714,
-0.052944477647542953,
-0.2819264829158783,
-0.7953958511352539,
0.6370812058448792,
0.15474966168403625,
0.046253081411123276,
0.47081249952316284,
0.7583639621734619,
0.1007467657327652,
0.2057413011789322,
-0.8850157856941223,
0.2607494592666626,
-0.11936505883932114,
-0.3288635313510895,
0.15763293206691742,
-0.26498010754585266,
-0.1236763671040535,
-0.4436427652835846,
0.5605385303497314,
-0.5801796317100525,
0.20719914138317108,
-0.25967004895210266,
0.01312556117773056,
-0.2177174985408783,
0.2321072518825531,
0.378787100315094,
0.5425295233726501,
-0.16284771263599396,
0.18150843679904938,
0.4587239921092987,
-0.09356473386287689,
0.022863732650876045,
0.07155796885490417,
-0.0017995003145188093,
-0.39745548367500305,
0.13941246271133423,
1.0732303857803345,
0.6477235555648804,
-0.7210586667060852,
0.5137135982513428,
-0.10374357551336288,
-0.4377557933330536,
-0.20260323584079742,
0.2147914320230484,
0.09121188521385193,
0.5641832947731018,
0.20267397165298462,
-0.20761877298355103,
0.24387119710445404,
-0.42099931836128235,
-0.09408485144376755,
0.4306122064590454,
0.06849287450313568,
-0.5898328423500061,
0.7642569541931152,
0.2234201282262802,
-0.08018428087234497,
0.21710878610610962,
-0.11348471790552139,
-0.28999751806259155,
0.1475624442100525,
0.39345377683639526,
0.44598516821861267,
-0.22569310665130615,
-0.0953531265258789,
0.4562457799911499,
-0.005705981981009245,
-0.27073919773101807,
0.47175705432891846,
-0.3506472408771515,
-0.6553150415420532,
-0.8144282698631287,
-0.9005308151245117,
-0.40811848640441895,
0.21717894077301025,
-0.6214930415153503,
0.33548542857170105,
-0.5723363161087036,
-0.16728393733501434,
-0.26789742708206177,
0.06767144054174423,
-0.45701542496681213,
0.041723910719156265,
0.12696288526058197,
0.4914815127849579,
-0.5670652389526367,
1.2376946210861206,
0.5744972825050354,
-0.1306115835905075,
-0.9357446432113647,
0.06708966940641403,
-0.43072327971458435,
-0.6358048319816589,
0.5083522200584412,
-0.12672513723373413,
0.04140019044280052,
0.5560989379882812,
-0.4630759358406067,
-1.2298526763916016,
1.18242347240448,
0.7265326380729675,
-0.7965440154075623,
-0.16777582466602325,
0.059840258210897446,
0.34435391426086426,
0.1584443897008896,
-0.017571518197655678,
0.7169822454452515,
0.2973272204399109,
-0.09631288796663284,
-1.0514004230499268,
0.13343539834022522,
0.13951700925827026,
0.0778224989771843,
0.5186048746109009,
-0.8392990231513977,
0.8595758676528931,
0.1020960807800293,
0.059057097882032394,
0.2679237127304077,
0.6101146936416626,
0.48999783396720886,
0.011104714125394821,
0.5242295861244202,
0.513906717300415,
0.673336923122406,
-0.007168507669121027,
0.7692970633506775,
-0.4503540098667145,
0.3515695631504059,
1.0918834209442139,
-0.24757976830005646,
1.0748960971832275,
0.5213519930839539,
-0.32623714208602905,
0.304625540971756,
0.6382908225059509,
0.2905431389808655,
0.6328237056732178,
0.1561867892742157,
-0.39882296323776245,
-0.4753299951553345,
0.09096679836511612,
-0.17502140998840332,
0.6125277280807495,
0.45997077226638794,
-0.045634105801582336,
-0.08395450562238693,
0.002875375095754862,
-0.13879336416721344,
-0.12371588498353958,
-0.5869844555854797,
0.6745105385780334,
0.17129990458488464,
-0.4397604167461395,
1.1830137968063354,
0.1265813708305359,
0.6190928220748901,
-0.5851709842681885,
-0.08034425228834152,
-0.23293137550354004,
0.13088521361351013,
-0.055635303258895874,
-0.3736785054206848,
0.12764890491962433,
-0.01643882319331169,
-0.011811813339591026,
-0.2805458903312683,
0.5250652432441711,
-0.43800923228263855,
-0.3482484221458435,
-0.07757753878831863,
0.5130199790000916,
0.11546092480421066,
-0.3310772180557251,
-0.7631976008415222,
0.36566227674484253,
-0.05736815184354782,
-0.24014748632907867,
0.6730343103408813,
0.5366166830062866,
-0.19949708878993988,
0.4846632182598114,
0.5597102046012878,
0.15094773471355438,
-0.057569388300180435,
0.12607955932617188,
0.8182154893875122,
-0.7525741457939148,
-0.3995673656463623,
-0.6485698223114014,
0.24949140846729279,
0.31782180070877075,
-0.109859898686409,
0.515070378780365,
0.35810387134552,
0.8206474184989929,
0.0938347652554512,
0.5682416558265686,
0.2797600328922272,
0.517966091632843,
-0.8645021915435791,
0.45708221197128296,
-0.7810204029083252,
0.24445770680904388,
-0.09697473049163818,
-0.9568549990653992,
-0.4965539574623108,
0.6342813968658447,
-0.25348466634750366,
0.1495889574289322,
0.6024854183197021,
0.5860625505447388,
-0.11233051121234894,
-0.4772917330265045,
0.6558154225349426,
0.2244250476360321,
0.05691947042942047,
0.9465580582618713,
0.6645272374153137,
-0.6419166922569275,
0.6226930022239685,
-0.3022984266281128,
-0.10288981348276138,
-0.214246928691864,
-0.8618892431259155,
-0.8745589852333069,
-0.5216363668441772,
-0.4572345018386841,
0.05604787915945053,
0.20156536996364594,
0.7236208319664001,
0.9105268716812134,
-0.6478821635246277,
-0.05349388346076012,
-0.13766074180603027,
-0.1648111492395401,
-0.27756398916244507,
-0.17382608354091644,
0.511063814163208,
-0.12468772381544113,
-0.946351945400238,
0.4223048985004425,
0.22931212186813354,
0.023509768769145012,
-0.03316875547170639,
-0.25560763478279114,
0.10430430620908737,
-0.06903155893087387,
0.7512485384941101,
0.3176441490650177,
-0.7263227105140686,
-0.34525108337402344,
-0.24567276239395142,
0.185404971241951,
0.10557717829942703,
0.600028395652771,
-1.0350425243377686,
0.16832731664180756,
0.37341469526290894,
0.7877000570297241,
0.5931366682052612,
0.1413664072751999,
0.6535797715187073,
-0.7873433232307434,
0.2102697342634201,
0.22330428659915924,
0.22862574458122253,
0.24814152717590332,
-0.3621695637702942,
0.43563124537467957,
0.021453533321619034,
-0.770409882068634,
-0.8939775228500366,
0.21209801733493805,
-1.1067198514938354,
-0.2518072724342346,
0.9363152384757996,
-0.05286100134253502,
-0.26157712936401367,
0.14702673256397247,
-0.2850663959980011,
0.4181455075740814,
-0.42059773206710815,
0.5336282849311829,
0.2564956247806549,
-0.31797245144844055,
-0.8068106174468994,
-0.6174108386039734,
0.6760291457176208,
0.5815113186836243,
-0.8852061629295349,
-0.06668829917907715,
0.3513694107532501,
0.30404937267303467,
-0.45673903822898865,
0.6403632760047913,
0.19380782544612885,
0.3108958303928375,
-0.3125928044319153,
0.14541073143482208,
0.020762493833899498,
0.056826308369636536,
-0.40573421120643616,
0.08756589144468307,
0.6744665503501892,
-0.08673317730426788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04889v2 | Detecting Generated Native Ads in Conversational Search | 2024-02-07T14:22:51 | 2024-04-30T09:15:42 | Sebastian Schmidt, Ines Zelch, Janek Bevendorff, Benno Stein, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Conversational search engines such as YouChat and Microsoft Copilot use large
language models (LLMs) to generate responses to queries. It is only a small
step to also let the same technology insert ads within the generated responses
- instead of separately placing ads next to a response. Inserted ads would be
reminiscent of native advertising and product placement, both of which are very
effective forms of subtle and manipulative advertising. Considering the high
computational costs associated with LLMs, for which providers need to develop
sustainable business models, users of conversational search engines may very
well be confronted with generated native ads in the near future. In this paper,
we thus take a first step to investigate whether LLMs can also be used as a
countermeasure, i.e., to block generated native ads. We compile the Webis
Generated Native Ads 2024 dataset of queries and generated responses with
automatically inserted ads, and evaluate whether LLMs or fine-tuned sentence
transformers can detect the ads. In our experiments, the investigated LLMs
struggle with the task but sentence transformers achieve precision and recall
values above 0.9. | [
-0.3653784692287445,
-1.0192725658416748,
0.41988658905029297,
0.13256607949733734,
-0.2806955873966217,
0.3301907181739807,
-0.1253998726606369,
-0.715156078338623,
0.6308966875076294,
0.7698580026626587,
-0.5540985465049744,
-0.42820608615875244,
-0.10998817533254623,
-0.003381196642294526,
-0.5190208554267883,
0.7272197008132935,
0.4958212077617645,
-0.304941326379776,
-0.48114636540412903,
0.17444850504398346,
-0.6446790099143982,
-0.6941614747047424,
-0.5865080952644348,
-0.08892475068569183,
0.14341013133525848,
0.29764682054519653,
0.6487674117088318,
0.2554672360420227,
0.30563244223594666,
0.35289132595062256,
-0.05751114711165428,
0.3428707718849182,
-0.42384830117225647,
0.2915412187576294,
0.034510985016822815,
-0.5644257068634033,
-0.43407365679740906,
-0.08309322595596313,
0.3653331995010376,
0.4091164767742157,
-0.267519474029541,
-0.2815099060535431,
-0.025174638256430626,
0.31125879287719727,
-0.4933350682258606,
-0.13936741650104523,
-1.2664637565612793,
-0.010018423199653625,
-0.2844774127006531,
-0.24860602617263794,
-0.5185666084289551,
-0.4350050687789917,
0.2566356062889099,
-0.4392310082912445,
0.47232580184936523,
-0.03035673126578331,
1.0587538480758667,
0.04032755270600319,
-0.5942562222480774,
-0.56141597032547,
-0.7990075945854187,
0.7380677461624146,
-1.015541434288025,
0.23307129740715027,
0.2793038487434387,
0.28732478618621826,
-0.5226051807403564,
-0.8168531656265259,
-0.5109260082244873,
-0.16287872195243835,
-0.2632952034473419,
0.0368446446955204,
-0.6358057260513306,
0.02125861495733261,
0.2234296351671219,
0.3213938772678375,
-0.8573890924453735,
0.3966030776500702,
-0.5400322675704956,
-0.4314669072628021,
0.8011033535003662,
0.15830758213996887,
0.4005120098590851,
-0.22063258290290833,
-0.5551971793174744,
0.2267748862504959,
-0.8193972110748291,
0.026701947674155235,
0.4516768753528595,
0.44349801540374756,
0.12359990924596786,
0.5694741606712341,
-0.3235442638397217,
0.7597864270210266,
0.051624707877635956,
-0.02671140991151333,
-0.15209244191646576,
-0.3845643103122711,
-0.01964504085481167,
0.37419289350509644,
1.0025352239608765,
0.4107376039028168,
0.699897825717926,
0.0789208859205246,
-0.4233395457267761,
0.5317440032958984,
0.45767560601234436,
-0.5993375778198242,
-0.040758151561021805,
-0.0022793698590248823,
-0.14738035202026367,
-0.3167833387851715,
-0.1640612930059433,
-0.49019870162010193,
-0.318187952041626,
0.07435095310211182,
0.15047065913677216,
0.015569901093840599,
-0.049760255962610245,
0.3153808116912842,
0.2998788356781006,
0.12991605699062347,
-0.3598780930042267,
-0.8226454854011536,
0.667908251285553,
0.5748890042304993,
0.6476487517356873,
-0.20942573249340057,
0.20285114645957947,
-0.7459277510643005,
-0.04099174588918686,
-0.25590163469314575,
1.0408846139907837,
-0.4066047966480255,
-0.8277272582054138,
0.21480105817317963,
-0.013350372202694416,
-0.21646329760551453,
-0.8374084830284119,
0.43514999747276306,
-0.8425413370132446,
0.3677375316619873,
0.056759726256132126,
-0.4844382405281067,
-0.16631700098514557,
0.3574065566062927,
-0.6302354335784912,
0.9518154263496399,
-0.3026224672794342,
-0.2200392484664917,
0.20160768926143646,
-0.7278476357460022,
-0.8598647117614746,
0.25322604179382324,
-0.05364754796028137,
-0.6066774725914001,
0.040534090250730515,
0.5602647066116333,
0.3613004684448242,
-0.07183126360177994,
0.373892605304718,
-0.19606709480285645,
-0.33747628331184387,
0.5999706387519836,
-0.6413457989692688,
0.6002410650253296,
0.4068606197834015,
-0.31514567136764526,
-0.01705114170908928,
-0.4144391119480133,
-0.32105553150177,
0.4732682406902313,
-0.3598773777484894,
-0.3872666656970978,
0.3238592743873596,
-0.11231198161840439,
0.06425903737545013,
0.48062628507614136,
-0.7231819033622742,
0.10675255954265594,
-0.5469174385070801,
0.4002940058708191,
0.6517197489738464,
0.15754997730255127,
0.12058959901332855,
-0.04232826456427574,
0.8498219847679138,
-0.1444019377231598,
-0.043987613171339035,
-0.3479629456996918,
-0.7472469210624695,
-0.555704653263092,
-0.04172668233513832,
0.06549008190631866,
0.23671378195285797,
-0.4702146649360657,
0.3110803961753845,
-0.3323576748371124,
-0.3876681327819824,
-0.3306800127029419,
0.3556559383869171,
0.23530542850494385,
0.5472332835197449,
0.013783300295472145,
-0.3080923557281494,
-0.5267209410667419,
-0.9417528510093689,
-0.3249293863773346,
0.0453844778239727,
-0.1533413678407669,
0.4996379613876343,
0.09689118713140488,
-0.062081754207611084,
1.1564401388168335,
-0.7161036133766174,
-0.352705717086792,
-0.15116222202777863,
0.13069087266921997,
0.09013315290212631,
0.140492245554924,
0.6664823293685913,
-0.9843074083328247,
-0.5283114910125732,
-0.2635709345340729,
-0.39337828755378723,
-0.4244947135448456,
-0.37595486640930176,
0.32402360439300537,
0.42625492811203003,
0.712364673614502,
-0.7276734709739685,
0.3059934675693512,
0.7318716645240784,
-0.30424898862838745,
0.4865954518318176,
-0.1557714343070984,
-0.22897055745124817,
-1.1498775482177734,
-0.0075411684811115265,
0.254470556974411,
-0.5392467379570007,
-0.4310033321380615,
-0.21413935720920563,
-0.1237938180565834,
-0.3786870539188385,
-0.5136668682098389,
0.3942815959453583,
-0.3052501976490021,
-0.28347623348236084,
-0.3287188708782196,
0.545825719833374,
0.2795596718788147,
0.3871960937976837,
0.13757272064685822,
1.158958911895752,
0.20405124127864838,
-0.8675663471221924,
0.119112528860569,
0.24825197458267212,
-0.5476104617118835,
0.5435822606086731,
-1.058135747909546,
0.2903863191604614,
0.22927799820899963,
0.44964906573295593,
-1.3430659770965576,
-0.047906406223773956,
-0.1532038152217865,
-0.5644336938858032,
-0.15687918663024902,
-0.015735231339931488,
-0.6272267699241638,
-0.5763588547706604,
-0.23902584612369537,
0.17531143128871918,
0.32807934284210205,
-0.5815780162811279,
0.48227572441101074,
0.3811980187892914,
-0.3662319779396057,
-0.16727428138256073,
-0.5627517700195312,
0.3057959973812103,
-0.2791319191455841,
-0.6598456501960754,
0.4894348382949829,
-0.06696754693984985,
-0.10306656360626221,
-0.05667982995510101,
0.21877625584602356,
0.2508319020271301,
0.32103419303894043,
-0.01954587548971176,
0.2807043194770813,
-0.348664253950119,
-0.115758515894413,
0.006365760695189238,
0.02356407605111599,
0.12533970177173615,
-0.13229569792747498,
0.7631901502609253,
0.04712817072868347,
-0.5414681434631348,
-0.48842862248420715,
0.14691545069217682,
0.9193774461746216,
-0.6294735074043274,
0.29656487703323364,
0.42769524455070496,
-0.3415798544883728,
0.20860858261585236,
-0.6095277667045593,
-0.25055304169654846,
-0.6328415870666504,
0.21975034475326538,
-0.07580035924911499,
-0.7253755331039429,
0.5126225352287292,
0.06631116569042206,
0.055204663425683975,
0.3062610924243927,
0.5311285257339478,
0.009400848299264908,
1.7694400548934937,
0.2986935079097748,
-0.07089755684137344,
0.46153995394706726,
-0.14799992740154266,
0.4540054500102997,
-0.7597501277923584,
-0.2952345907688141,
-0.44168391823768616,
-0.5815593004226685,
-0.9940803647041321,
0.15116864442825317,
0.4736992120742798,
-0.17904475331306458,
0.1686505377292633,
0.5144596099853516,
-0.43692395091056824,
0.33731380105018616,
0.8636001348495483,
-0.01190460566431284,
0.22747497260570526,
0.2041243612766266,
-0.1146046370267868,
-0.18102186918258667,
-0.4580845832824707,
-0.42708978056907654,
0.9215865135192871,
0.049315307289361954,
0.7206762433052063,
0.16834993660449982,
0.3971884250640869,
0.43720269203186035,
0.03353932499885559,
-0.9998008608818054,
0.7432156205177307,
-0.2837981581687927,
-0.7423654794692993,
0.23864293098449707,
-0.08473776280879974,
-1.4088189601898193,
0.08488008379936218,
-0.22823527455329895,
-0.952382504940033,
-0.04144445061683655,
0.06308601051568985,
-0.5750429630279541,
0.384669691324234,
-0.7500616312026978,
0.5418015122413635,
-0.5122426748275757,
-0.3358714282512665,
-0.29462143778800964,
-0.20743106305599213,
0.2369348704814911,
0.0459277480840683,
0.10047335922718048,
0.07437646389007568,
0.16645339131355286,
0.6423408389091492,
-0.12347175925970078,
1.056624412536621,
0.018990589305758476,
-0.21952508389949799,
0.6329731941223145,
0.370178759098053,
0.7048382759094238,
-0.2089260220527649,
0.3220304846763611,
-0.16901354491710663,
-0.23807914555072784,
-0.5769941806793213,
-0.395138680934906,
0.9235174059867859,
-0.20548242330551147,
-0.7981582880020142,
-0.1608913093805313,
-0.6701406836509705,
-0.11478086560964584,
0.33021461963653564,
0.3064405918121338,
0.3915214538574219,
-0.39700692892074585,
0.30662888288497925,
0.6341961622238159,
-0.40725040435791016,
0.4930241107940674,
0.7973792552947998,
-0.1937607228755951,
-0.2787984609603882,
1.0488280057907104,
-0.17025332152843475,
0.23698991537094116,
0.1052568256855011,
0.41848114132881165,
-0.6346683502197266,
-0.48663294315338135,
-0.20749124884605408,
0.2666226029396057,
-0.1944107562303543,
-0.2566060423851013,
-0.5944504737854004,
-0.14877355098724365,
-0.6233015656471252,
-0.18815593421459198,
-0.38002899289131165,
-0.19405029714107513,
-0.2739379405975342,
0.03008432872593403,
0.2810135781764984,
0.9463363289833069,
0.1266554892063141,
0.550267219543457,
-0.7972286939620972,
0.31896311044692993,
0.5173389911651611,
0.19390995800495148,
-0.0211806520819664,
-0.14404232800006866,
-0.17877323925495148,
0.35749343037605286,
-0.7076382040977478,
-0.4771098494529724,
0.5387930870056152,
0.1108286902308464,
0.381740003824234,
0.8126177191734314,
0.07608616352081299,
0.3661348223686218,
-0.2428019940853119,
1.0746707916259766,
-0.034381937235593796,
-0.47856786847114563,
0.5777137875556946,
-0.5165050029754639,
0.35081860423088074,
0.05259554833173752,
0.28641200065612793,
-0.6121800541877747,
-0.24922318756580353,
-0.5081014037132263,
-0.7546015381813049,
0.46806788444519043,
0.1509682685136795,
0.6407232880592346,
-0.2634340226650238,
-0.03456570953130722,
-0.2204059362411499,
0.15679293870925903,
-0.5970839262008667,
0.017772939056158066,
0.2509104907512665,
0.028471773490309715,
-0.03713120520114899,
-0.3465498983860016,
0.3408549726009369,
0.16546115279197693,
0.43744614720344543,
0.02083258330821991,
-0.05293743684887886,
-0.06078289821743965,
-0.19902357459068298,
0.03204057738184929,
0.13399992883205414,
0.8361510038375854,
0.09080293774604797,
-0.2706533372402191,
-0.06920137256383896,
-0.28123781085014343,
-0.33969786763191223,
-0.21776874363422394,
0.09189179539680481,
-0.28061458468437195,
0.018027929589152336,
-0.06283356249332428,
0.4150826930999756,
0.20572064816951752,
-0.9741547107696533,
0.5456576943397522,
-0.19027705490589142,
-0.03812407702207565,
-0.33273303508758545,
-0.17350657284259796,
0.21516671776771545,
-0.06531737744808197,
0.31382107734680176,
-0.07524871081113815,
0.23581698536872864,
-0.4700019657611847,
0.1837683916091919,
0.9282389283180237,
-0.41572389006614685,
-0.5041691660881042,
0.8613541722297668,
0.48769211769104004,
-0.782043993473053,
0.7717660665512085,
-0.0445253811776638,
-0.9955371022224426,
0.6086942553520203,
0.9177629351615906,
0.9360135793685913,
-0.2661897540092468,
0.0016211001202464104,
0.1440643072128296,
0.20948582887649536,
0.26404744386672974,
0.06887143105268478,
-0.1126789078116417,
-0.866899847984314,
-0.4732188582420349,
-0.2195081263780594,
-0.34977057576179504,
0.5389386415481567,
-0.6240434646606445,
0.4162045121192932,
-0.21408963203430176,
-0.10936617106199265,
0.14121966063976288,
-0.09539595991373062,
-0.6434556841850281,
0.037986524403095245,
0.5720682740211487,
0.4786814749240875,
-0.7550298571586609,
0.5089662075042725,
0.5971674919128418,
-0.19763816893100739,
-0.23066887259483337,
-0.0957322046160698,
0.20992021262645721,
-0.830161988735199,
0.2437283843755722,
0.3404026925563812,
-0.5704587697982788,
-0.002783483825623989,
-0.7057806849479675,
-0.5681917071342468,
0.7519071698188782,
0.16600657999515533,
-0.5053392052650452,
0.04572771489620209,
0.33749642968177795,
0.5697323679924011,
-0.26203593611717224,
-0.10159888863563538,
0.49034440517425537,
0.013111595064401627,
-0.10278871655464172,
-0.9572000503540039,
-0.025112805888056755,
-0.16626764833927155,
-0.0646415427327156,
0.06310120224952698,
-0.4739915132522583,
0.6304466128349304,
-0.022758906707167625,
-0.41652095317840576,
0.2405928075313568,
0.21087414026260376,
0.23985148966312408,
0.43574437499046326,
0.47662287950515747,
0.4789770245552063,
0.3908122479915619,
0.19656050205230713,
1.1411664485931396,
-0.22378255426883698,
0.019795497879385948,
0.8902419209480286,
-0.46508070826530457,
0.8279604911804199,
0.33821114897727966,
-0.14496108889579773,
0.7310514450073242,
0.5697104334831238,
0.030534978955984116,
0.2981184720993042,
0.14852018654346466,
-0.29058733582496643,
-0.32809606194496155,
-0.6771872639656067,
0.08765735477209091,
0.8012816905975342,
0.7564644813537598,
-0.29436618089675903,
-0.27143242955207825,
-0.06448201090097427,
0.1541569083929062,
0.6650189161300659,
0.09922866523265839,
0.8924247026443481,
-0.06425341963768005,
-0.8165755867958069,
0.7669152021408081,
-0.08616963028907776,
1.051543951034546,
-0.6748469471931458,
0.03009883128106594,
-0.4995841085910797,
0.17272000014781952,
-0.04974164441227913,
-0.5042672753334045,
0.2359517514705658,
0.07273759692907333,
0.1439570188522339,
-0.03412403538823128,
0.8651710748672485,
-0.3096259534358978,
-0.5267508625984192,
0.17094027996063232,
0.3521939814090729,
0.1148030236363411,
-0.23859843611717224,
-0.6755709648132324,
-0.18108895421028137,
0.09512407332658768,
-0.2412206083536148,
0.21346832811832428,
-0.07662706077098846,
-0.26084649562835693,
0.7574725151062012,
0.9805240035057068,
0.08713560551404953,
0.06500992178916931,
-0.028115950524806976,
0.6653157472610474,
-0.4345370829105377,
-0.6748509407043457,
-0.7305826544761658,
0.14967942237854004,
-0.11500462889671326,
0.03340836241841316,
0.6451148390769958,
0.75729900598526,
0.9113368988037109,
0.21490134298801422,
0.7243555784225464,
0.3075489401817322,
0.3549683392047882,
-0.4400706887245178,
0.6546871066093445,
-0.6733862161636353,
0.6029242277145386,
-0.20596706867218018,
-0.8534826636314392,
-0.15916837751865387,
0.1488124132156372,
-0.396891325712204,
-0.11275140941143036,
0.2271871119737625,
1.0469744205474854,
-0.4007682204246521,
-0.16053076088428497,
0.32594579458236694,
-0.10527072846889496,
0.7391740679740906,
0.4728563725948334,
0.8566300868988037,
-0.3318362236022949,
1.097602128982544,
-0.252383291721344,
0.2687099277973175,
-0.39166510105133057,
-0.6381271481513977,
-0.8207846879959106,
-0.3013889491558075,
-0.25640878081321716,
-0.26751944422721863,
-0.37633752822875977,
0.6697840094566345,
0.5732524991035461,
-0.8950375914573669,
-0.4469356834888458,
-0.1649406999349594,
0.13761232793331146,
-0.1787130981683731,
-0.3331964313983917,
0.24820683896541595,
-0.12102769315242767,
-1.0855337381362915,
0.7550911903381348,
0.017055824398994446,
0.3707423210144043,
-0.4705810546875,
0.14124752581119537,
-0.5818795561790466,
0.3194372057914734,
0.5833960175514221,
0.3332621157169342,
-0.7460952401161194,
-0.09351672977209091,
0.5195644497871399,
-0.16520558297634125,
0.09792345017194748,
1.0286961793899536,
-1.075659990310669,
0.8874889612197876,
0.2967067062854767,
0.5017562508583069,
0.5267690420150757,
0.16275137662887573,
0.8339301943778992,
-0.9271137714385986,
0.14987534284591675,
0.28743335604667664,
0.31038716435432434,
0.596000611782074,
-0.409776896238327,
0.24165382981300354,
0.1207289844751358,
-0.32310938835144043,
-0.7910173535346985,
0.44089171290397644,
-0.6416128277778625,
-0.19939661026000977,
0.9311632513999939,
0.1290246844291687,
0.06132117658853531,
-0.12038514763116837,
-0.2593006491661072,
-0.09455841779708862,
-0.43655475974082947,
0.8804457783699036,
0.30205267667770386,
-0.061243873089551926,
0.36528390645980835,
-0.4478510022163391,
0.18637029826641083,
0.5917726755142212,
-0.4024173319339752,
-0.12665536999702454,
0.3683379888534546,
0.25845959782600403,
0.40898823738098145,
0.39903944730758667,
-0.10604654997587204,
0.28676462173461914,
-0.20719201862812042,
-0.0932844951748848,
-0.024839747697114944,
0.07992641627788544,
-0.22749994695186615,
-0.2844865024089813,
0.17052315175533295,
-0.6043176054954529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04875v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04875v3 | On Provable Length and Compositional Generalization | 2024-02-07T14:16:28 | 2024-06-07T20:25:05 | Kartik Ahuja, Amin Mansouri | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Out-of-distribution generalization capabilities of sequence-to-sequence
models can be studied from the lens of two crucial forms of generalization:
length generalization -- the ability to generalize to longer sequences than
ones seen during training, and compositional generalization: the ability to
generalize to token combinations not seen during training. In this work, we
provide first provable guarantees on length and compositional generalization
for common sequence-to-sequence models -- deep sets, transformers, state space
models, and recurrent neural nets -- trained to minimize the prediction error.
Taking a first principles perspective, we study the realizable case, i.e., the
labeling function is realizable on the architecture. We show that limited
capacity versions of these different architectures achieve both length and
compositional generalization. Across different architectures, we also find that
a linear relationship between the learned representation and the representation
in the labeling function is necessary for length and compositional
generalization. | [
-0.3492197096347809,
-0.3965277075767517,
0.7345144152641296,
0.1391477882862091,
-0.36810025572776794,
-0.10213863849639893,
-0.2699068486690521,
-0.47144752740859985,
0.22466494143009186,
0.5500690340995789,
-0.5824753642082214,
-0.0867728665471077,
-0.5671230554580688,
-0.17889997363090515,
-0.5761398077011108,
0.9584699869155884,
0.13244549930095673,
-0.08033950626850128,
-0.35184240341186523,
-0.380422443151474,
-0.45575830340385437,
-0.6039128303527832,
-0.06571231782436371,
-0.28690025210380554,
0.657314658164978,
0.09798511117696762,
1.0228132009506226,
0.7129948735237122,
0.6595151424407959,
0.2297949492931366,
-0.0070321098901331425,
0.08527347445487976,
-0.32285574078559875,
0.027149125933647156,
-0.03224959596991539,
-0.7001224756240845,
-0.273531049489975,
-0.1567120999097824,
0.9662140011787415,
0.9107257127761841,
0.013839958235621452,
0.12747952342033386,
-0.15185250341892242,
0.8805795311927795,
-0.586412787437439,
-0.09652973711490631,
-0.1821908950805664,
0.4656573235988617,
0.1376049965620041,
0.15081390738487244,
-0.5418815612792969,
-0.27929985523223877,
0.516666829586029,
-0.8556198477745056,
0.2131490409374237,
-0.13928455114364624,
0.5092287063598633,
0.2256079465150833,
-0.3171636760234833,
-0.10214078426361084,
-1.136096715927124,
0.9211684465408325,
-0.5085022449493408,
0.5419853329658508,
0.13876748085021973,
0.6211946606636047,
0.03197925165295601,
-0.9500750303268433,
-0.4189824163913727,
-0.4475342333316803,
-0.513817310333252,
0.030309176072478294,
-0.051930882036685944,
0.31532207131385803,
0.2202579528093338,
0.6185587048530579,
-0.7251553535461426,
0.13929256796836853,
-0.3830665647983551,
-0.13411590456962585,
0.5528563857078552,
0.08623149245977402,
0.12305361032485962,
0.3282855749130249,
-0.31554916501045227,
-0.15199428796768188,
-0.7480824589729309,
-0.1350824385881424,
0.37415099143981934,
-0.21386027336120605,
-0.09650087356567383,
0.6600646376609802,
0.03125327080488205,
0.7365685701370239,
-0.09307961910963058,
0.2821282148361206,
-0.08642646670341492,
-0.3267534375190735,
-0.3582363724708557,
-0.17282544076442719,
0.4605221748352051,
-0.27044567465782166,
0.26514390110969543,
-0.5613656640052795,
-0.1269097924232483,
-0.04436090216040611,
0.3739241063594818,
-0.6668698191642761,
0.012847259640693665,
0.14858797192573547,
-0.6813219785690308,
0.044611960649490356,
0.45497840642929077,
-0.20949622988700867,
-0.15624526143074036,
-0.5563278794288635,
0.5832067728042603,
-0.2934231162071228,
-0.145005002617836,
0.31585994362831116,
-0.15778113901615143,
0.002625685650855303,
-0.3944481313228607,
-1.171759009361267,
0.45191630721092224,
0.9095563292503357,
0.8853700757026672,
0.10661393404006958,
-0.11130957305431366,
-0.14253933727741241,
0.13015048205852509,
-0.4158555567264557,
0.24492575228214264,
-0.3644425868988037,
-0.3517034351825714,
0.0010917304316535592,
-0.22164961695671082,
0.005546881817281246,
-0.5385047793388367,
0.0761961117386818,
-0.7391436696052551,
-0.2004123032093048,
-0.21523019671440125,
-0.9720808863639832,
-0.1754123866558075,
-0.10402858257293701,
-0.7875344157218933,
0.20461313426494598,
0.33396995067596436,
-0.6596012711524963,
0.3685830533504486,
-0.5286117792129517,
-0.7088043093681335,
-0.1811830997467041,
-0.11695125699043274,
-0.5664105415344238,
0.5409682989120483,
-0.3240995705127716,
0.40004247426986694,
0.0253695547580719,
0.4898219704627991,
-0.2799780070781708,
-0.4712769091129303,
0.49791595339775085,
-0.41426554322242737,
0.28303858637809753,
0.46767282485961914,
-0.021854231134057045,
0.11944220960140228,
-0.9680353999137878,
-0.0658404752612114,
0.03065667673945427,
-0.761263370513916,
0.03513471037149429,
0.29820626974105835,
-0.3853519856929779,
-0.20012523233890533,
0.3579239249229431,
-0.44997638463974,
0.23452404141426086,
-0.7431398630142212,
0.6087580919265747,
0.4989885687828064,
0.02849559299647808,
1.0003753900527954,
-0.3081938922405243,
0.4902660846710205,
0.15234772861003876,
0.34968066215515137,
-0.37288522720336914,
-0.31146499514579773,
-0.7110058069229126,
-0.23489594459533691,
0.4890173375606537,
0.6106240749359131,
-0.5169435143470764,
0.570976734161377,
-0.3905348777770996,
-0.4940958321094513,
0.04189853370189667,
-0.12102769315242767,
0.6036772727966309,
0.29937461018562317,
0.36121320724487305,
-0.2575051486492157,
-0.7441326379776001,
-1.1434813737869263,
-0.16987740993499756,
-0.04129031300544739,
-0.273821622133255,
-0.06481751799583435,
0.29402199387550354,
-0.22975915670394897,
1.2989920377731323,
-0.7466933727264404,
-0.010325722396373749,
-0.3356572389602661,
-0.1350880116224289,
0.49270889163017273,
0.5886256098747253,
0.4529712200164795,
-0.6462838649749756,
-0.20668913424015045,
-0.07632520794868469,
-0.6786431074142456,
0.4261472225189209,
-0.12221240997314453,
-0.04786151647567749,
-0.15189778804779053,
0.17051661014556885,
-0.46805185079574585,
0.5701373815536499,
0.4781782031059265,
-0.06027297303080559,
0.22705130279064178,
-0.6329740285873413,
-0.47430628538131714,
-0.962872326374054,
-0.19252872467041016,
0.1564818173646927,
-0.1646728217601776,
-0.9653832912445068,
-0.07193414121866226,
-0.15403373539447784,
-0.10015276819467545,
-0.3733609616756439,
0.41038599610328674,
-0.13659892976284027,
-0.5762219429016113,
0.018798133358359337,
-0.44535204768180847,
0.10564505308866501,
0.35068345069885254,
0.27363428473472595,
0.5696389079093933,
0.5856024026870728,
-0.9496372938156128,
0.12463013082742691,
0.2564278244972229,
-0.5294627547264099,
0.17353889346122742,
-0.8712789416313171,
-0.22804059088230133,
-0.26135751605033875,
0.4334084987640381,
-0.7769571542739868,
-0.1648886650800705,
0.2919269800186157,
-0.23557591438293457,
0.35653671622276306,
-0.1137770563364029,
-0.21992194652557373,
-0.32585132122039795,
0.130562886595726,
0.6791136264801025,
0.62933349609375,
-0.4175061285495758,
0.5516611933708191,
-0.014344431459903717,
0.4220961034297943,
-0.7816880345344543,
-0.9576801657676697,
-0.46613577008247375,
-0.12102761119604111,
-0.7631406784057617,
0.5626450777053833,
-0.21038766205310822,
-0.13561506569385529,
-0.3333069086074829,
-0.048072148114442825,
-0.23194323480129242,
0.029180480167269707,
0.201601043343544,
0.015755511820316315,
-0.2742083966732025,
0.3596333861351013,
0.013422138057649136,
-0.12897804379463196,
-0.1368723213672638,
-0.6618481278419495,
0.5006635189056396,
-0.05076199769973755,
-0.458232581615448,
-0.1952679604291916,
0.4249843657016754,
0.18094933032989502,
-0.16491760313510895,
0.79497230052948,
0.4837512969970703,
-0.28654152154922485,
-0.17604273557662964,
-0.14181673526763916,
-0.40705472230911255,
-0.46323779225349426,
0.4515446126461029,
-0.25034499168395996,
-0.8852407336235046,
0.7709301710128784,
0.22036822140216827,
0.013747217133641243,
0.24379070103168488,
0.02723586931824684,
-0.09318907558917999,
0.7706091403961182,
0.4399074614048004,
-0.09746682643890381,
0.5399987101554871,
-0.7722783088684082,
0.45839834213256836,
-0.6223427653312683,
-0.18419280648231506,
-0.03044460155069828,
-0.6869295239448547,
-0.5546886920928955,
-0.2614571452140808,
0.3557044267654419,
0.014730642549693584,
-0.36742648482322693,
0.4677169620990753,
-0.5635476112365723,
0.7337721586227417,
0.8405175805091858,
0.315868616104126,
-0.18943358957767487,
0.07841382920742035,
0.03681895136833191,
0.059616800397634506,
-0.6460387706756592,
-0.10480429977178574,
1.122352123260498,
0.5269619226455688,
0.4218284785747528,
0.22723235189914703,
0.8805148005485535,
0.44365376234054565,
0.05155272036790848,
-0.9037796854972839,
0.5475821495056152,
-0.6498737931251526,
-0.6375587582588196,
-0.39292004704475403,
-0.19871653616428375,
-0.9404664635658264,
0.08834198862314224,
-0.09876818209886551,
-0.35634011030197144,
0.6190524697303772,
0.3431529998779297,
-0.42618685960769653,
0.28428179025650024,
-0.49194496870040894,
0.5666320323944092,
-0.15342815220355988,
0.10847078263759613,
-0.25222569704055786,
-0.8704133629798889,
0.42925140261650085,
0.19592830538749695,
-0.031214695423841476,
0.20808115601539612,
0.13398286700248718,
0.539421796798706,
-0.6414594054222107,
0.9056866765022278,
-0.10421498864889145,
0.07759328186511993,
0.6100135445594788,
0.18485279381275177,
0.29645875096321106,
0.15145163238048553,
0.3112483024597168,
0.16087915003299713,
-0.13927176594734192,
-0.39356857538223267,
-0.52165687084198,
0.25921282172203064,
-0.8037891983985901,
-0.4822280704975128,
0.018128249794244766,
-0.26216354966163635,
-0.19382110238075256,
-0.04586618393659592,
0.7344636917114258,
0.626168429851532,
-0.29725512862205505,
0.22999364137649536,
0.9647002220153809,
-0.11132829636335373,
0.6507207155227661,
-0.019155628979206085,
0.005160295404493809,
-0.5580540895462036,
0.9311823844909668,
0.29495322704315186,
0.46105435490608215,
0.7390696406364441,
0.3707544803619385,
-0.5718885064125061,
-0.49656325578689575,
-0.027046682313084602,
0.05831378698348999,
-0.9914106726646423,
-0.0635465681552887,
-0.32916775345802307,
-0.46457675099372864,
-0.19054099917411804,
-0.2349914163351059,
-0.3643657863140106,
-0.7741391658782959,
-0.6621844172477722,
-0.35592910647392273,
-0.06923273205757141,
0.92955482006073,
-0.3395865857601166,
0.580797553062439,
-0.8274277448654175,
0.3384956419467926,
0.6351807117462158,
0.3062586784362793,
0.029153181239962578,
-0.6904057264328003,
-0.46374809741973877,
-0.0019251771736890078,
-0.38285723328590393,
-0.7711832523345947,
0.07504815608263016,
0.4735790193080902,
0.4300861358642578,
0.6509570479393005,
-0.250245600938797,
0.30686154961586,
-0.3853857219219208,
0.708457350730896,
0.4776328206062317,
-0.8207672834396362,
0.38178277015686035,
-0.20911072194576263,
0.02386450581252575,
0.19429543614387512,
0.3303348124027252,
-0.471370667219162,
0.10640764236450195,
-0.5602476596832275,
-0.6928985714912415,
0.29995059967041016,
0.07481075078248978,
0.44724759459495544,
-0.19304373860359192,
0.5493492484092712,
0.1446927934885025,
0.20262330770492554,
-0.6052896976470947,
-0.3201599717140198,
-0.48661088943481445,
-0.23688647150993347,
-0.23612825572490692,
-0.4815400540828705,
-0.04540957510471344,
-0.053210534155368805,
0.4141622483730316,
-0.02600305713713169,
0.4127781093120575,
0.23525185883045197,
-0.09288670867681503,
0.33745503425598145,
0.44462910294532776,
1.0529512166976929,
1.0070643424987793,
-0.14757956564426422,
0.06831216812133789,
-0.16073912382125854,
-0.27874094247817993,
0.5691535472869873,
-0.15111708641052246,
-0.15027238428592682,
-0.04127030447125435,
0.558525025844574,
1.0013880729675293,
0.268197625875473,
-0.4096958339214325,
0.4885820746421814,
0.4037357270717621,
-0.2763702869415283,
-0.3760506212711334,
0.15213674306869507,
0.18994000554084778,
0.30473792552948,
0.10781612992286682,
0.097349613904953,
0.33141669631004333,
-0.34643465280532837,
0.23427407443523407,
0.18975624442100525,
-0.27037313580513,
-0.5952019691467285,
0.5274069905281067,
-0.12263268232345581,
-0.14262084662914276,
0.6309678554534912,
-0.10785342752933502,
-0.25182652473449707,
0.9057918190956116,
0.5443926453590393,
0.8922234177589417,
0.07377935945987701,
0.4613340497016907,
0.3498700261116028,
-0.12648282945156097,
-0.3396690785884857,
0.02266557700932026,
-0.22686757147312164,
-0.8662453889846802,
-0.24749869108200073,
-0.5770856142044067,
-0.2848595082759857,
-0.10475736856460571,
-0.6564254760742188,
-0.07335229218006134,
-0.8067132234573364,
-0.43350017070770264,
-0.10236137360334396,
-0.40014755725860596,
-0.5404029488563538,
0.31570732593536377,
0.12635943293571472,
0.7000253200531006,
-0.6893891096115112,
0.565445601940155,
0.40370973944664,
-0.39353424310684204,
-0.7113456130027771,
-0.42170003056526184,
-0.5178965330123901,
-0.6805817484855652,
0.9436355233192444,
0.1286754608154297,
0.3561784327030182,
-0.09270903468132019,
-0.3897815942764282,
-0.8130873441696167,
1.261681079864502,
0.4604467749595642,
-0.926737368106842,
-0.04089624062180519,
0.6448835134506226,
0.513327956199646,
-0.546929657459259,
-0.1270870715379715,
0.7716929316520691,
0.4347304105758667,
0.32765498757362366,
-0.49726659059524536,
-0.3729901611804962,
0.3937860131263733,
0.3966047167778015,
0.14837142825126648,
-0.5426982045173645,
0.8115448355674744,
-0.30680087208747864,
-0.17331621050834656,
0.24146780371665955,
0.7742953896522522,
0.28922224044799805,
0.3807477355003357,
0.23375988006591797,
0.9585400223731995,
0.45499518513679504,
-0.15767697989940643,
1.1516083478927612,
-0.083278127014637,
0.1585150957107544,
1.123975396156311,
0.06176454573869705,
0.649334192276001,
0.2905273139476776,
-0.49092522263526917,
0.3126627802848816,
0.6813899278640747,
-0.07101849466562271,
0.8322868943214417,
0.6592051386833191,
-0.4843953549861908,
-0.14204543828964233,
0.13715559244155884,
-0.33763179183006287,
0.15041503310203552,
0.1876872479915619,
-0.848061203956604,
0.26518842577934265,
0.030648570507764816,
-0.21161018311977386,
0.07389964908361435,
-0.3254926800727844,
0.8534119725227356,
0.14107312262058258,
-0.7332434058189392,
0.47004929184913635,
-0.0804678201675415,
0.5382980108261108,
-0.6132005453109741,
0.19294540584087372,
-0.28331246972084045,
0.2482972890138626,
-0.020353971049189568,
-0.7644715905189514,
0.3905496299266815,
-0.7574186325073242,
-0.6540261507034302,
0.19542934000492096,
0.6824841499328613,
-0.2878498136997223,
-0.382933646440506,
0.034589167684316635,
-0.034344758838415146,
-0.2710965871810913,
-0.03448266163468361,
-0.20606905221939087,
-0.25515520572662354,
-0.2757287621498108,
-0.2372361272573471,
0.3924977779388428,
-0.1609693318605423,
-0.032769858837127686,
0.6688079833984375,
0.40816664695739746,
-0.010845514014363289,
0.6848523020744324,
0.018076464533805847,
0.729562520980835,
-0.321146696805954,
-0.5768133997917175,
-0.9257487654685974,
0.6123453974723816,
0.1782417595386505,
-0.038871001452207565,
-0.24600376188755035,
0.48299640417099,
0.7926939725875854,
-0.7453952431678772,
0.8421483039855957,
0.15284784138202667,
0.04961499944329262,
-0.5386589169502258,
0.32572826743125916,
-0.3290978670120239,
0.09752088785171509,
0.4981786012649536,
-1.2366949319839478,
-0.41229403018951416,
0.46267610788345337,
-0.18136343359947205,
-0.08059661090373993,
0.46150392293930054,
0.5284036993980408,
-0.09355557709932327,
-0.17023244500160217,
0.5397728681564331,
-0.26204416155815125,
0.3432098925113678,
0.6765913963317871,
0.6997671127319336,
-0.38568395376205444,
0.34199920296669006,
-0.2069823294878006,
0.10776681452989578,
-0.1050892248749733,
-0.7434068322181702,
-0.6747736930847168,
-0.70872563123703,
-0.08070803433656693,
-0.1471279412508011,
-0.04526786878705025,
0.3364861309528351,
1.031304955482483,
-0.7126878499984741,
0.016573432832956314,
-0.47247546911239624,
0.06202247738838196,
-0.12605397403240204,
-0.17279943823814392,
0.15464428067207336,
-0.2399348020553589,
-0.2800815999507904,
0.3355225622653961,
0.3230286240577698,
0.4858607053756714,
-0.3571593165397644,
-0.4324657917022705,
0.232334166765213,
0.4568345844745636,
0.5350272059440613,
0.6306447982788086,
-0.6775778532028198,
-0.3428973853588104,
-0.1422228068113327,
0.36562421917915344,
0.1464885175228119,
1.083875060081482,
-0.5039212703704834,
0.30181074142456055,
0.7660298347473145,
0.6949613094329834,
0.2580849826335907,
-0.10439654439687729,
0.5353139042854309,
-1.1757540702819824,
0.20040085911750793,
0.15888534486293793,
0.5410813093185425,
0.05116013437509537,
-0.4090152978897095,
0.6514805555343628,
0.17497383058071136,
-0.5880375504493713,
-0.38193169236183167,
0.9615399241447449,
-0.8134249448776245,
-0.29395392537117004,
0.7713207602500916,
-0.5237970352172852,
0.05956708639860153,
0.4109906852245331,
0.17509105801582336,
0.42875581979751587,
0.1008368581533432,
0.3766854703426361,
0.7095351815223694,
-0.03720449283719063,
-0.02252526953816414,
-0.025619329884648323,
0.43145328760147095,
0.23884962499141693,
-0.6117006540298462,
-0.1526242345571518,
0.41710010170936584,
0.27986112236976624,
0.35065221786499023,
0.4233231842517853,
0.18475477397441864,
0.22161069512367249,
-0.2543371915817261,
-0.4154980480670929,
-0.21980024874210358,
-0.5968545079231262,
-0.3087216019630432,
0.06739398092031479,
0.016172906383872032,
-0.3562129735946655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04858v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04858v2 | CodeIt: Self-Improving Language Models with Prioritized Hindsight Replay | 2024-02-07T13:55:27 | 2024-07-01T10:03:33 | Natasha Butt, Blazej Manczak, Auke Wiggers, Corrado Rainone, David W. Zhang, Michaël Defferrard, Taco Cohen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models are increasingly solving tasks that are commonly
believed to require human-level reasoning ability. However, these models still
perform very poorly on benchmarks of general intelligence such as the
Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC). In this paper, we approach ARC as a
programming-by-examples problem, and introduce a novel and scalable method for
language model self-improvement called Code Iteration (CodeIt). Our method
iterates between 1) program sampling and hindsight relabeling, and 2) learning
from prioritized experience replay. By relabeling the goal of an episode (i.e.,
the target program output given input) to the realized output produced by the
sampled program, our method effectively deals with the extreme sparsity of
rewards in program synthesis. Applying CodeIt to the ARC dataset, we
demonstrate that prioritized hindsight replay, along with pre-training and
data-augmentation, leads to successful inter-task generalization. CodeIt is the
first neuro-symbolic approach that scales to the full ARC evaluation dataset.
Our method solves 15% of ARC evaluation tasks, achieving state-of-the-art
performance and outperforming existing neural and symbolic baselines. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Qualcomm-AI-research/codeit . | [
-0.21161895990371704,
-0.5849460959434509,
0.48887068033218384,
0.4213739335536957,
0.10809407383203506,
0.3936980664730072,
-0.4302218556404114,
-0.03357284143567085,
0.28210002183914185,
0.45365485548973083,
-0.43478429317474365,
-0.5228860378265381,
-0.5066819787025452,
-0.09956581890583038,
-0.46072259545326233,
0.9649898409843445,
-0.03213565796613693,
-0.13628828525543213,
-0.12456327676773071,
-0.2064456194639206,
-0.8364577293395996,
-0.7551624774932861,
-0.5595575571060181,
-0.3137040138244629,
0.37424808740615845,
0.8022535443305969,
0.4459836184978485,
0.4105435907840729,
0.49644553661346436,
0.29622015357017517,
0.5185970664024353,
-0.1464555263519287,
-0.6038247346878052,
0.07179905474185944,
-0.10659840703010559,
-0.4270591139793396,
-0.3702561855316162,
-0.018500516191124916,
0.5515866875648499,
0.5990405082702637,
-0.16756117343902588,
0.10632657259702682,
-0.07934961467981339,
0.5900512933731079,
-0.6689461469650269,
0.13310129940509796,
-0.44594210386276245,
-0.1678759604692459,
0.2832019627094269,
-0.23741833865642548,
-0.4143884479999542,
-0.4648604393005371,
-0.0970524400472641,
-0.5551897287368774,
0.05962791666388512,
0.11674206703901291,
0.6144831776618958,
0.41145074367523193,
0.1455991417169571,
-0.01933349296450615,
-0.7916218042373657,
0.8574141263961792,
-0.7717084884643555,
0.1649349182844162,
0.3880787789821625,
0.2675318717956543,
0.022247251123189926,
-0.9452179670333862,
-0.42765310406684875,
-0.3734770715236664,
0.03761691600084305,
-0.05528876557946205,
-0.5131394863128662,
0.08635009080171585,
0.2820318937301636,
0.40475499629974365,
-0.59303879737854,
-0.10481344163417816,
-0.43604061007499695,
-0.2936232089996338,
0.5736463665962219,
0.11621331423521042,
0.307653546333313,
0.29324576258659363,
-0.016308069229125977,
-0.350020170211792,
-0.6221557855606079,
-0.10068516433238983,
0.16553683578968048,
-0.01632598042488098,
0.22871075570583344,
0.4000259041786194,
-0.4544520080089569,
0.43814101815223694,
0.10492778569459915,
0.4523073434829712,
0.5851020216941833,
-0.3889901340007782,
-0.12279980629682541,
-0.06897591054439545,
0.4544733762741089,
0.18852920830249786,
0.3916984498500824,
-0.41290220618247986,
-0.2955765128135681,
0.39128661155700684,
0.6375049352645874,
-0.6582717895507812,
-0.574895977973938,
0.3219325542449951,
-0.29019680619239807,
-0.1905904859304428,
-0.4214637279510498,
-0.5752438902854919,
-0.05350437015295029,
-0.44414275884628296,
0.48507562279701233,
-0.5699098110198975,
-0.453800767660141,
0.16344961524009705,
0.10306718945503235,
0.03858000412583351,
0.17432814836502075,
-0.7601765394210815,
0.3287099301815033,
0.8184049725532532,
0.5883472561836243,
-0.23489849269390106,
-0.7509790062904358,
-0.5728069543838501,
-0.2309773564338684,
-0.6447434425354004,
0.8508743643760681,
-0.6547877788543701,
-0.13512086868286133,
-0.31589630246162415,
-0.38755863904953003,
-0.06146134436130524,
-0.6864588856697083,
0.2514595091342926,
-0.25331422686576843,
-0.1162760928273201,
0.1328069567680359,
-0.5051807165145874,
-0.149727001786232,
0.26218411326408386,
-0.371478796005249,
1.1617971658706665,
0.03076072409749031,
-0.4841940104961395,
0.334251344203949,
-0.7545404434204102,
-0.3743123412132263,
-0.11889807879924774,
-0.3144983649253845,
-0.328299880027771,
0.39340806007385254,
0.3853484094142914,
0.4090036451816559,
-0.11732832342386246,
0.7369459271430969,
-0.13789793848991394,
-0.60183185338974,
-0.19719932973384857,
-0.33887824416160583,
-0.015486136078834534,
0.15340527892112732,
-0.664164125919342,
0.5574910640716553,
-0.7536225318908691,
0.41826868057250977,
0.042789217084646225,
-0.11916731297969818,
-0.3741006553173065,
-0.005361273419111967,
-0.21752159297466278,
0.1927194595336914,
0.04068252444267273,
-0.2577700614929199,
0.31580936908721924,
-0.763529896736145,
0.5632445216178894,
0.7604904770851135,
-0.022891094908118248,
0.6536493301391602,
-0.33774417638778687,
0.5775467157363892,
-0.11597488820552826,
0.08960945159196854,
-0.34914568066596985,
-0.35284921526908875,
-0.9257691502571106,
0.01969539374113083,
0.2467154562473297,
0.4146827459335327,
-0.6881677508354187,
0.19936048984527588,
-0.3895339369773865,
-0.4584779143333435,
-0.4159986674785614,
-0.06413356214761734,
0.6693775057792664,
0.2913443446159363,
0.5878462791442871,
-0.462971031665802,
-0.4556376039981842,
-0.9848286509513855,
-0.28666481375694275,
-0.31763070821762085,
-0.08497393876314163,
0.2551710605621338,
0.4201635420322418,
-0.30274146795272827,
0.9938305020332336,
-0.41426318883895874,
0.009540009312331676,
-0.3651817739009857,
0.5965786576271057,
0.38891926407814026,
0.7573281526565552,
0.17357729375362396,
-0.5406462550163269,
0.04349572956562042,
-0.23066821694374084,
-0.6618495583534241,
-0.040621496737003326,
-0.3291696310043335,
-0.12667691707611084,
-0.06035280227661133,
0.6460540890693665,
0.00867462158203125,
0.5305873155593872,
0.4594448208808899,
-0.39153987169265747,
0.6692456007003784,
-0.39815253019332886,
0.3704383969306946,
-0.6382041573524475,
0.1739972084760666,
-0.374882310628891,
-0.026803992688655853,
-0.4917784035205841,
0.19502697885036469,
0.04188773036003113,
-0.1839102804660797,
-0.2154487520456314,
0.5914283394813538,
-0.4068705141544342,
-0.20460058748722076,
-0.43564146757125854,
-0.21933646500110626,
-0.31073084473609924,
1.0577731132507324,
0.16573764383792877,
0.9023332595825195,
0.5851183533668518,
-0.5965027213096619,
0.07764700800180435,
-0.17773117125034332,
-0.27419447898864746,
0.14142167568206787,
-0.7348122000694275,
0.34802737832069397,
0.025978336110711098,
-0.13738960027694702,
-1.1191562414169312,
0.2219383865594864,
0.1612333357334137,
-0.4795266091823578,
0.16957056522369385,
0.05779805779457092,
-0.11181674152612686,
-0.3678409457206726,
-0.009549149312078953,
0.7563181519508362,
0.5659645795822144,
-0.46400025486946106,
0.825307309627533,
0.22732245922088623,
-0.19674959778785706,
-0.7991628050804138,
-0.4682832956314087,
0.27993300557136536,
-0.09175948798656464,
-0.3377658724784851,
0.15213705599308014,
-0.29353204369544983,
-0.17446619272232056,
-0.08895988017320633,
-0.3671341836452484,
-0.11591309309005737,
-0.021348947659134865,
0.4119170606136322,
-0.014099988155066967,
-0.2252228558063507,
0.2846290171146393,
0.13646425306797028,
-0.3738507032394409,
0.14758439362049103,
-0.43881794810295105,
0.6302844882011414,
-0.5161952376365662,
-0.3065689206123352,
-0.22259163856506348,
0.33987361192703247,
0.25190243124961853,
-0.32489603757858276,
0.049282338470220566,
0.2666492760181427,
-0.2667112648487091,
-0.30276671051979065,
-0.7991555333137512,
-0.46351078152656555,
-0.43482473492622375,
0.5825992822647095,
-0.5799180269241333,
-0.9090558886528015,
0.2254638373851776,
-0.4076181650161743,
0.2146914005279541,
0.19611673057079315,
0.4089031219482422,
0.08252089470624924,
0.859778642654419,
0.7842685580253601,
-0.4766177833080292,
0.42396509647369385,
-0.5775858759880066,
0.1812586933374405,
-0.4573792815208435,
0.12860530614852905,
-0.34331950545310974,
-0.3585875928401947,
0.010650146752595901,
-0.5580523014068604,
0.02336418256163597,
0.2432340681552887,
-0.48152458667755127,
0.4386189877986908,
-0.7000293731689453,
0.5579341053962708,
0.8702147006988525,
0.09252273291349411,
0.41115885972976685,
-0.05541598051786423,
-0.22501018643379211,
-0.06399219483137131,
-0.9685498476028442,
-0.34927135705947876,
1.1958928108215332,
0.17909325659275055,
0.7745932340621948,
-0.3836531937122345,
1.0672610998153687,
0.5199365019798279,
0.616182267665863,
-0.44063863158226013,
0.5737398862838745,
0.16074122488498688,
-0.22509370744228363,
-0.4615251421928406,
-0.37924909591674805,
-0.7635161876678467,
0.024277832359075546,
0.04817579686641693,
-0.6220645904541016,
0.3275477886199951,
0.4394869804382324,
-0.33257415890693665,
-0.0115578044205904,
-0.8748509883880615,
1.146482229232788,
-0.17833441495895386,
-0.2992694079875946,
-0.8247580528259277,
-0.5000084638595581,
0.2038183957338333,
0.00945128221064806,
0.19377492368221283,
-0.09395834058523178,
0.16971276700496674,
0.5539358854293823,
-0.3863282799720764,
0.8123782873153687,
-0.020637271925807,
0.25695833563804626,
0.2710613012313843,
0.3218819499015808,
0.3782312273979187,
0.14277969300746918,
0.16867460310459137,
0.4180190861225128,
-0.24390862882137299,
-0.42712369561195374,
-0.8421831130981445,
0.6516152024269104,
-0.6387434005737305,
-0.7877110838890076,
-0.3679225444793701,
-0.5092078447341919,
-0.20487654209136963,
0.10021647810935974,
0.03842570260167122,
0.6465174555778503,
-0.2498437613248825,
-0.043254267424345016,
0.35651934146881104,
-0.39923033118247986,
0.5253705978393555,
0.1441705971956253,
-0.2613305449485779,
-0.41360846161842346,
1.081662893295288,
-0.23743750154972076,
0.24271443486213684,
0.2741324007511139,
0.06824333220720291,
-0.08376915752887726,
-0.5866867899894714,
-0.29714280366897583,
0.13879644870758057,
-0.697730302810669,
-0.24599438905715942,
-0.5924903154373169,
-0.09588431566953659,
-0.22652019560337067,
-0.31845980882644653,
-0.6382806301116943,
-0.39928171038627625,
0.20933690667152405,
-0.06117315962910652,
0.1852559596300125,
0.6028019785881042,
-0.21736019849777222,
0.13921110332012177,
-0.35566049814224243,
0.3221687376499176,
0.26646438241004944,
0.46625247597694397,
0.1223653256893158,
-0.28868046402931213,
-0.2638641893863678,
-0.01550049614161253,
-0.071120485663414,
-0.4663790762424469,
0.35819023847579956,
0.10471555590629578,
0.5585957765579224,
-0.11987760663032532,
0.05436260998249054,
0.7489655017852783,
-0.6029516458511353,
0.4137687683105469,
0.20769670605659485,
-1.0710229873657227,
0.6970566511154175,
-0.0339379757642746,
0.4472743570804596,
0.7768872976303101,
-0.001533114118501544,
-0.5214694142341614,
-0.6997271776199341,
-0.6571491360664368,
-0.9990354776382446,
0.5461548566818237,
0.3032531440258026,
0.13504023849964142,
-0.12729452550411224,
0.35841935873031616,
-0.15333925187587738,
0.13895393908023834,
-0.5660228729248047,
-0.15915869176387787,
-0.43606802821159363,
-0.17844589054584503,
-0.22121046483516693,
-0.10987953841686249,
0.026714200153946877,
-0.3347403407096863,
0.546627402305603,
-0.38948768377304077,
0.5352777242660522,
0.3325348496437073,
-0.2646726369857788,
0.32843586802482605,
0.239400714635849,
0.5650759339332581,
0.9153514504432678,
0.09465140849351883,
-0.08253896236419678,
0.14697977900505066,
-0.41936829686164856,
0.2572821378707886,
-0.14802756905555725,
0.1251055747270584,
-0.1540064960718155,
0.30066055059432983,
0.6242260932922363,
0.6369967460632324,
-0.9527037143707275,
0.5552576780319214,
-0.2618921995162964,
-0.09674666821956635,
-0.3707786202430725,
0.18373961746692657,
-0.03958461806178093,
0.4308755695819855,
0.44115912914276123,
0.2516680359840393,
0.2935584485530853,
-0.45201465487480164,
0.5845891833305359,
-0.013192400336265564,
-0.18072864413261414,
-0.08729787915945053,
0.8241758346557617,
0.025234071537852287,
-0.350967675447464,
0.7391467094421387,
-0.12391906976699829,
-0.32365408539772034,
0.8331626653671265,
0.4128192365169525,
1.0135877132415771,
-0.16487182676792145,
0.20957282185554504,
0.675454318523407,
0.1539180725812912,
-0.24317258596420288,
0.38451263308525085,
-0.21916989982128143,
-0.7640829086303711,
-0.6919888854026794,
-0.3816708028316498,
-0.30066409707069397,
-0.2281596064567566,
-0.3927024304866791,
0.08045750111341476,
-0.5043126344680786,
0.025462517514824867,
-0.22340454161167145,
-0.2656448781490326,
-0.5407224893569946,
0.29959747195243835,
-0.19235345721244812,
0.8253231644630432,
-0.5728617906570435,
1.1453717947006226,
0.3814350366592407,
-0.6329730153083801,
-1.0917432308197021,
0.02602580189704895,
-0.5211751461029053,
-0.9517350792884827,
0.724317193031311,
0.07201048731803894,
-0.0896243304014206,
0.2694840431213379,
-0.488905668258667,
-0.9592251181602478,
0.7297543287277222,
0.3691211938858032,
-0.7350841760635376,
-0.2312438189983368,
-0.17624245584011078,
0.6141352653503418,
-0.5123152732849121,
0.5073643326759338,
0.6137191653251648,
0.3969520628452301,
-0.0248386412858963,
-0.7333757281303406,
-0.07481155544519424,
-0.5069210529327393,
0.05556464195251465,
0.22475489974021912,
-0.3387945592403412,
0.4551226794719696,
-0.44446879625320435,
-0.03907203674316406,
0.17866359651088715,
0.7570462822914124,
0.2544509470462799,
0.38930612802505493,
0.4465568959712982,
0.5713601112365723,
0.40657708048820496,
-0.21399664878845215,
1.0581496953964233,
-0.46542999148368835,
0.2634828984737396,
1.4532549381256104,
0.030359312891960144,
0.7876918315887451,
0.40466728806495667,
0.06192495673894882,
0.500863254070282,
0.3727431893348694,
0.014375858008861542,
0.5034816265106201,
0.4345403015613556,
0.17455999553203583,
-0.3622884452342987,
0.3652116358280182,
-0.39677974581718445,
0.42860305309295654,
0.15491169691085815,
-0.26715371012687683,
-0.15931642055511475,
0.24694140255451202,
-0.11519617587327957,
0.3487856090068817,
-0.3600117266178131,
0.7534780502319336,
-0.16727709770202637,
-0.8532538414001465,
0.845552384853363,
-0.21485142409801483,
0.7212893962860107,
-0.5404101014137268,
-0.41961079835891724,
-0.527776300907135,
0.39391082525253296,
0.06272942572832108,
-0.4960453510284424,
0.5207569003105164,
-0.21504011750221252,
-0.0757049024105072,
-0.26003140211105347,
0.45874229073524475,
-0.3330099582672119,
-0.4570777416229248,
0.4044722020626068,
0.4203217625617981,
0.26513198018074036,
-0.26008230447769165,
-0.6489461064338684,
0.05690247192978859,
-0.07430101186037064,
-0.21703119575977325,
0.1941041499376297,
0.0793842300772667,
-0.2300112396478653,
0.8963702321052551,
0.43695005774497986,
-0.00555039569735527,
0.17088629305362701,
0.17851822078227997,
0.9639242887496948,
-0.8228748440742493,
-0.5756791830062866,
-0.6445761919021606,
0.4359419643878937,
-0.09875635802745819,
-0.5610868334770203,
0.516030490398407,
0.7183530926704407,
1.041904330253601,
-0.0645645260810852,
0.6670483946800232,
0.014376906678080559,
0.3971084654331207,
-0.3070649802684784,
0.5172474384307861,
-0.40557852387428284,
0.2290184199810028,
-0.5297707915306091,
-0.7757246494293213,
-0.3722986578941345,
0.6711446046829224,
-0.5202829837799072,
0.003508723573759198,
0.7577655911445618,
0.8914167881011963,
0.07892325520515442,
-0.04678405076265335,
0.48889416456222534,
0.23041002452373505,
0.13305944204330444,
0.9770293235778809,
0.840278148651123,
-0.38778552412986755,
0.5654439926147461,
-0.27505743503570557,
-0.3304081857204437,
0.12933114171028137,
-0.6818295121192932,
-0.6262266039848328,
-0.6331835985183716,
-0.42904427647590637,
-0.16812482476234436,
0.43848878145217896,
0.8125094771385193,
0.8743599653244019,
-0.9477468132972717,
-0.4082668721675873,
-0.4722793400287628,
0.16419774293899536,
-0.7043408155441284,
-0.19445215165615082,
0.297863245010376,
-0.691643476486206,
-0.6821938753128052,
0.5105352401733398,
0.48725274205207825,
-0.5503782033920288,
-0.02516166679561138,
-0.2732234001159668,
-0.09744282811880112,
-0.13356924057006836,
0.3728327453136444,
0.6000952124595642,
-0.7241236567497253,
-0.4131568372249603,
-0.009562429040670395,
0.15511652827262878,
0.34155017137527466,
1.2488725185394287,
-1.2518965005874634,
0.46349772810935974,
0.2127724140882492,
1.0093436241149902,
0.583981990814209,
-0.06301114708185196,
0.9235736131668091,
-0.5337614417076111,
0.04858598858118057,
0.5226820707321167,
0.3056429624557495,
-0.13284409046173096,
-0.2664819359779358,
0.8190947771072388,
0.15379053354263306,
-0.6517670750617981,
-0.6467432379722595,
0.15757852792739868,
-0.5500519871711731,
-0.40118247270584106,
0.8552438020706177,
-0.17372813820838928,
0.03689848631620407,
-0.13487063348293304,
-0.26531943678855896,
-0.03890388831496239,
-0.46954983472824097,
0.8455030918121338,
0.5095006227493286,
-0.17279812693595886,
-0.3713374733924866,
-0.2670826315879822,
0.36440783739089966,
0.735113263130188,
-0.7288808226585388,
0.1933746486902237,
0.6769222617149353,
0.327745646238327,
0.06824170053005219,
0.9883036613464355,
0.008864893577992916,
0.5343112945556641,
0.06235872954130173,
0.40838757157325745,
-0.08597784489393234,
-0.7470132112503052,
-0.47016820311546326,
0.14953143894672394,
0.12428044527769089,
-0.10421312600374222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04854v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04854v4 | Hierarchical Tree-structured Knowledge Graph For Academic Insight Survey | 2024-02-07T13:54:06 | 2024-07-03T01:34:52 | Jinghong Li, Huy Phan, Wen Gu, Koichi Ota, Shinobu Hasegawa | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG | Research surveys have always posed a challenge for beginner researchers who
lack of research training. These researchers struggle to understand the
directions within their research topic, and the discovery of new research
findings within a short time. One way to provide intuitive assistance to
beginner researchers is by offering relevant knowledge graphs(KG) and
recommending related academic papers. However, existing navigation knowledge
graphs primarily rely on keywords in the research field and often fail to
present the logical hierarchy among multiple related papers clearly. Moreover,
most recommendation systems for academic papers simply rely on high text
similarity, which can leave researchers confused as to why a particular article
is being recommended. They may lack of grasp important information about the
insight connection between "Issue resolved" and "Issue finding" that they hope
to obtain. To address these issues, this study aims to support research insight
surveys for beginner researchers by establishing a hierarchical tree-structured
knowledge graph that reflects the inheritance insight of research topics and
the relevance insight among the academic papers. | [
-0.3202967345714569,
-0.5504339933395386,
0.7021387815475464,
0.0672089084982872,
-0.1647777408361435,
0.5148801803588867,
0.36338576674461365,
-0.36562198400497437,
0.4294562041759491,
-0.0495784617960453,
-0.6413097977638245,
-0.727235734462738,
-0.5250267386436462,
-0.04466157779097557,
-0.1296200305223465,
1.3568915128707886,
0.023467926308512688,
-0.2865443527698517,
-0.7185548543930054,
-0.13441699743270874,
-0.08307740837335587,
-0.19084976613521576,
-0.9740869998931885,
-0.4039423167705536,
0.9337045550346375,
0.519548773765564,
0.4968281388282776,
0.5042204260826111,
0.5778076648712158,
0.20496714115142822,
-0.40104952454566956,
0.18116234242916107,
-0.7614525556564331,
0.13723528385162354,
-0.058692000806331635,
-0.3744812309741974,
-0.5874074101448059,
-0.15991348028182983,
0.4325117766857147,
1.1909114122390747,
0.22309017181396484,
0.28884559869766235,
0.4593360424041748,
0.9048181772232056,
-0.616774320602417,
0.5147367119789124,
-0.44386714696884155,
0.20996224880218506,
-0.33998072147369385,
-0.6870146989822388,
-0.21032863855361938,
-0.5088208317756653,
0.3817673325538635,
-1.1486698389053345,
0.27172812819480896,
0.21664275228977203,
0.6604056358337402,
-0.14167676866054535,
-0.6135714054107666,
-0.2292207032442093,
-0.5599501729011536,
0.3640236258506775,
-0.38643398880958557,
0.05830923095345497,
0.4291495680809021,
0.31314244866371155,
0.012481685727834702,
-0.7717427611351013,
0.018696129322052002,
0.11830569803714752,
-0.5480093359947205,
0.270413875579834,
-0.20477882027626038,
0.05831817537546158,
0.024085044860839844,
0.12622880935668945,
-0.5281617641448975,
-0.2966638207435608,
-0.29530662298202515,
0.06335469335317612,
0.3232053816318512,
0.47797465324401855,
0.004316563718020916,
-0.4197036623954773,
-0.09958240389823914,
0.014708475209772587,
-0.48112207651138306,
0.38935980200767517,
0.35733044147491455,
0.3822920322418213,
0.06672779470682144,
0.20479947328567505,
-0.4660126566886902,
0.5789989829063416,
0.2789302170276642,
-0.3731476366519928,
0.4232065677642822,
-0.5093587636947632,
0.055303722620010376,
0.11629647016525269,
0.5325469374656677,
0.36528483033180237,
0.07187355309724808,
-0.36509889364242554,
0.21529747545719147,
-0.3745831251144409,
0.2939874827861786,
-0.8076671361923218,
-0.5358173847198486,
-0.13929052650928497,
-0.7338964343070984,
-0.5194805860519409,
-0.08815865963697433,
-0.6981247067451477,
-0.45352044701576233,
-0.062439169734716415,
0.0916757807135582,
-0.535409688949585,
-0.5009778738021851,
-0.4795503616333008,
-0.25527992844581604,
0.03424009680747986,
0.42739996314048767,
-0.6461554765701294,
0.39155250787734985,
0.5210005640983582,
0.8714609146118164,
-0.15495455265045166,
0.014231800101697445,
0.22396637499332428,
0.3329780697822571,
-0.11381343752145767,
0.8200315833091736,
-0.7303123474121094,
-0.8077379465103149,
-0.05121266096830368,
-0.022127533331513405,
-0.0853472650051117,
-0.20162872970104218,
0.8356515765190125,
-0.5895110368728638,
0.33418309688568115,
-0.39435625076293945,
-0.3771299421787262,
-0.3552723228931427,
0.7016698718070984,
-0.30615919828414917,
0.8800287842750549,
0.417388379573822,
-1.4545971155166626,
0.517989993095398,
-0.8511238694190979,
-0.370798259973526,
0.44149425625801086,
-0.37984904646873474,
-0.35040491819381714,
-0.3469862937927246,
0.25888755917549133,
0.17315006256103516,
-0.10534577071666718,
0.09687040746212006,
-0.3317250907421112,
0.08867301046848297,
-0.42466577887535095,
0.13699476420879364,
0.899587094783783,
0.1555107831954956,
-0.1203971728682518,
0.07945811748504639,
-0.6940704584121704,
0.11439748853445053,
0.124727264046669,
-0.24620182812213898,
-1.1180202960968018,
0.21421299874782562,
-0.13372448086738586,
-0.406200647354126,
0.3451405167579651,
-0.4512210786342621,
0.3570877015590668,
-0.16857419908046722,
0.10590857267379761,
0.4298282563686371,
0.3684689402580261,
0.3364386260509491,
-0.3281518816947937,
0.8318649530410767,
0.22696101665496826,
-0.05785546079277992,
0.015803232789039612,
-0.6053540706634521,
-0.47053247690200806,
0.3694280683994293,
0.4118821620941162,
0.4061545729637146,
-0.5544929504394531,
0.2712477147579193,
-0.45312145352363586,
-0.43288734555244446,
-0.21544738113880157,
-0.11953893303871155,
0.34928062558174133,
1.067868709564209,
0.22300869226455688,
-0.11063846200704575,
-0.6872084736824036,
-0.925701379776001,
-0.02134934812784195,
-0.3727925419807434,
0.05210911110043526,
0.6081148982048035,
0.588129460811615,
-0.0289152804762125,
1.2210477590560913,
-0.8289669156074524,
-0.4927818179130554,
-0.005637323018163443,
0.5245295166969299,
0.1302887350320816,
0.3662242293357849,
0.6897305846214294,
-0.811327338218689,
-0.6361338496208191,
0.22422084212303162,
-0.5114075541496277,
0.030426044017076492,
0.29693493247032166,
-0.2602657079696655,
-0.4760490953922272,
0.32441332936286926,
-0.3151330053806305,
0.13761058449745178,
0.19275817275047302,
-0.566026508808136,
0.3729804754257202,
0.08133958280086517,
0.245498925447464,
-1.2652015686035156,
0.3830212354660034,
0.10166856646537781,
0.03619632124900818,
-0.35538381338119507,
-0.1875240057706833,
-0.13073013722896576,
0.0631604865193367,
0.2844295799732208,
0.18753652274608612,
-0.35987502336502075,
0.2919515371322632,
-0.018744198605418205,
0.16426432132720947,
-0.04449962452054024,
0.24680238962173462,
-0.14307206869125366,
0.5684979557991028,
0.4832197427749634,
-0.3141659200191498,
-0.33283814787864685,
0.4247494637966156,
-0.34172821044921875,
0.7469611167907715,
-0.6311240196228027,
0.05117721110582352,
-0.33719193935394287,
0.20361846685409546,
-1.0063008069992065,
-0.09183600544929504,
0.19190998375415802,
-0.7558018565177917,
0.161054328083992,
-0.3804530203342438,
-0.12232095003128052,
-0.2729920446872711,
-0.3486975431442261,
0.6593102812767029,
0.271484911441803,
-0.16742746531963348,
0.4370822310447693,
0.43351271748542786,
-0.5255674123764038,
-0.740749180316925,
-0.10918223112821579,
-0.04437066987156868,
-0.3844861388206482,
-0.7163299322128296,
0.7022965550422668,
0.17918074131011963,
-0.22707219421863556,
0.5446208119392395,
-0.15763349831104279,
-0.19057691097259521,
0.129287987947464,
0.44388237595558167,
0.020037941634655,
-0.40647679567337036,
-0.031447384506464005,
0.010345708578824997,
0.03180708736181259,
0.4785083532333374,
-0.20998673141002655,
0.05649328604340553,
-0.09548241645097733,
-0.1186615452170372,
0.00416886992752552,
0.1938321590423584,
0.6362833380699158,
-0.058500129729509354,
0.39015883207321167,
0.32141855359077454,
-0.3230777978897095,
-0.052404358983039856,
-0.10324645042419434,
-0.014880356378853321,
-0.39998364448547363,
0.26448914408683777,
-0.4906274080276489,
-0.9266330599784851,
0.49540287256240845,
-0.37883615493774414,
0.22677969932556152,
0.5433616638183594,
0.05223023146390915,
-0.3518121540546417,
1.2394617795944214,
0.6026890873908997,
-0.234541118144989,
0.34047210216522217,
-0.46057212352752686,
0.2974138855934143,
-0.9045597910881042,
-0.7795329093933105,
-1.0998189449310303,
-0.5252485275268555,
-0.34433653950691223,
-0.0039046676829457283,
0.6861345767974854,
-0.000902232073713094,
-0.19002744555473328,
-0.06922642141580582,
-0.6141762733459473,
0.41827765107154846,
0.6454926133155823,
0.11798646301031113,
0.42459988594055176,
0.23526696860790253,
-0.4090472459793091,
-0.0726168304681778,
-0.8865580558776855,
-0.3031075894832611,
0.8930802941322327,
0.15260815620422363,
0.6935015320777893,
-0.12585274875164032,
0.7268273234367371,
0.12069243937730789,
0.20411446690559387,
-0.8021337985992432,
0.29440397024154663,
0.1301737278699875,
-0.5308551788330078,
-0.37484705448150635,
-0.577195942401886,
-1.452080488204956,
0.1517510712146759,
-0.1707831621170044,
-0.629932701587677,
0.36101454496383667,
0.07028532773256302,
-0.32065349817276,
0.27004173398017883,
-0.168893501162529,
0.7348737716674805,
-0.003611515508964658,
-0.18752403557300568,
-0.013723618350923061,
-0.5394021272659302,
0.4527616798877716,
0.19727526605129242,
0.41653427481651306,
0.13446350395679474,
0.2671654224395752,
1.2003114223480225,
-0.3709813058376312,
0.7143216133117676,
-0.48865801095962524,
0.2881951332092285,
0.2054533213376999,
0.19968843460083008,
0.3746938109397888,
-0.0012796946102753282,
0.10926203429698944,
-0.4919738471508026,
0.18606342375278473,
-0.21676549315452576,
-0.6442904472351074,
0.519546627998352,
-0.9203013777732849,
-0.7256726622581482,
-0.3095947802066803,
-0.6511158347129822,
-0.5262247323989868,
0.2921723425388336,
0.03660277649760246,
0.1878783106803894,
-0.21709465980529785,
0.6195285320281982,
0.6233171820640564,
0.37404191493988037,
-0.03609228506684303,
0.36037299036979675,
-0.2113684117794037,
-0.2563633322715759,
0.5447421073913574,
0.21742451190948486,
-0.39668944478034973,
0.45149728655815125,
0.5190263390541077,
-0.3016173243522644,
-1.056944727897644,
-0.14623112976551056,
-0.11363165825605392,
-0.5138416290283203,
-0.2816898822784424,
-0.7292445302009583,
-0.29284030199050903,
-0.4424184262752533,
-0.14081716537475586,
0.23517632484436035,
-0.5592140555381775,
-0.21341626346111298,
-0.23261351883411407,
0.6180562376976013,
0.7961729764938354,
0.09569572657346725,
0.3134208619594574,
-0.44605714082717896,
0.24915729463100433,
0.3807927966117859,
0.28907838463783264,
0.4376752972602844,
-0.4563400447368622,
-0.44255146384239197,
-0.21369104087352753,
-0.4826299846172333,
-0.7930265665054321,
0.09449180960655212,
0.05076700821518898,
0.6758420467376709,
0.8177979588508606,
0.19785889983177185,
0.8196399211883545,
-0.2536799907684326,
0.4436628222465515,
0.18636973202228546,
-0.29837697744369507,
0.820493757724762,
-0.781406044960022,
0.3030187487602234,
1.087199330329895,
0.9614870548248291,
-0.17178484797477722,
-0.333261102437973,
-0.7282793521881104,
-0.9060277342796326,
0.49852892756462097,
0.1773422658443451,
-0.32847025990486145,
0.3680950105190277,
0.2508206069469452,
-0.01784062758088112,
0.12257615476846695,
-0.7019568681716919,
-0.3141902983188629,
-0.0929267406463623,
-0.1455986648797989,
0.2718832492828369,
-0.1882852464914322,
-0.45354944467544556,
-0.6396498084068298,
0.5378983616828918,
-0.11515969038009644,
-0.20811909437179565,
0.26025086641311646,
0.43123918771743774,
-0.4065624475479126,
0.20589879155158997,
-0.19664210081100464,
0.8838514685630798,
-0.5165290832519531,
0.3838613033294678,
-0.18835893273353577,
-0.5319687128067017,
0.04812074825167656,
0.048873987048864365,
-0.6570441126823425,
-0.036584898829460144,
0.346803218126297,
0.44192129373550415,
0.2579563856124878,
0.04449038580060005,
0.2377922236919403,
0.10860566049814224,
-0.6062533259391785,
-0.0745578408241272,
-0.06504330039024353,
0.5039301514625549,
-0.058775998651981354,
0.5261104106903076,
0.12120532244443893,
0.4219505190849304,
-0.6855565309524536,
-0.018498361110687256,
0.6371700167655945,
-0.340465784072876,
0.05164699628949165,
0.5061560869216919,
0.3855009377002716,
-0.34564417600631714,
0.6812134385108948,
-0.0763980895280838,
-0.46736976504325867,
0.6528761982917786,
0.42087382078170776,
0.7153229117393494,
0.1046387329697609,
0.2942100167274475,
0.4807964563369751,
0.23493029177188873,
0.3529872000217438,
0.15725895762443542,
-0.2717283070087433,
-0.5279219150543213,
-0.0906439945101738,
-0.6867110133171082,
-0.5123801231384277,
0.20418401062488556,
-0.739966869354248,
-0.1205088272690773,
-0.3621387481689453,
-0.20617231726646423,
0.17075103521347046,
0.16952700912952423,
-0.4410483241081238,
0.19500283896923065,
-0.33285585045814514,
0.9833481907844543,
-0.6692835092544556,
0.7297912836074829,
0.9527775645256042,
-0.1374928504228592,
-0.8684380650520325,
-0.10580514371395111,
-0.03038667142391205,
-0.5057059526443481,
0.706903874874115,
-0.1090279147028923,
-0.4493890404701233,
0.05047931522130966,
-0.3402051031589508,
-0.8925759792327881,
1.2293105125427246,
-0.14645080268383026,
-0.3293885588645935,
-0.3816205561161041,
-0.017375944182276726,
0.5595405697822571,
-0.5623912215232849,
0.21134454011917114,
0.3910156786441803,
0.6606091856956482,
0.29570433497428894,
-0.4737178683280945,
-0.02824561484158039,
-0.5547767281532288,
-0.23186416923999786,
0.257546067237854,
-0.2308562844991684,
0.7027486562728882,
-0.07622266560792923,
-0.16280683875083923,
-0.29808270931243896,
0.47367456555366516,
0.42543673515319824,
0.8180139660835266,
0.7675348520278931,
0.6777219772338867,
0.7790833115577698,
0.05446333810687065,
0.7053468823432922,
-0.48086294531822205,
0.22426797449588776,
1.122093677520752,
0.0884084552526474,
0.5606745481491089,
0.4881021976470947,
-0.3944963216781616,
0.9890703558921814,
0.974350094795227,
0.06379617750644684,
0.5921305418014526,
0.11393953114748001,
-0.15069100260734558,
0.04053546488285065,
-0.296762615442276,
-0.814750611782074,
0.0016319354763254523,
0.6497849225997925,
-0.4286636412143707,
-0.40519052743911743,
-0.5102363228797913,
0.016128238290548325,
-0.03497174754738808,
-0.49883517622947693,
0.6754334568977356,
-0.06543302536010742,
-0.6230083107948303,
0.23631872236728668,
-0.22158467769622803,
0.5490662455558777,
-0.8335958123207092,
-0.024601217359304428,
-0.2827192544937134,
-0.3567989766597748,
-0.6835509538650513,
-0.9094979166984558,
0.19955255091190338,
-0.1059304028749466,
-0.28862735629081726,
-0.306711882352829,
0.7497971057891846,
0.0033130820374935865,
-0.5268172025680542,
0.22881782054901123,
0.8546561598777771,
0.13203756511211395,
0.17395436763763428,
-0.6310065388679504,
-0.4438125789165497,
-0.046762753278017044,
-0.24813354015350342,
0.293398916721344,
0.5919808745384216,
0.09991499036550522,
0.5592144131660461,
0.35654065012931824,
0.12237874418497086,
-0.08258290588855743,
-0.009007900021970272,
0.8569747805595398,
-0.39670872688293457,
-0.651381254196167,
-0.4961388111114502,
0.35686132311820984,
-0.276567667722702,
-0.45017826557159424,
0.9066222906112671,
0.7833558320999146,
0.682176947593689,
0.05161045864224434,
0.984644889831543,
-0.34204572439193726,
0.6212788224220276,
-0.08705271780490875,
0.7160969376564026,
-0.7256242036819458,
-0.12262072414159775,
-0.475224107503891,
-0.7527366280555725,
-0.22160300612449646,
0.5265520215034485,
-0.4255863130092621,
0.07963145524263382,
0.8395146131515503,
0.4969109296798706,
-0.28488922119140625,
0.09515047073364258,
-0.11104940623044968,
0.103509820997715,
-0.09382488578557968,
0.5275307297706604,
0.8813928365707397,
0.22908346354961395,
0.8596700429916382,
-0.32088956236839294,
-0.35463225841522217,
-0.21106718480587006,
-0.7464067935943604,
-0.8085466623306274,
-0.6030364036560059,
-0.4606967270374298,
-0.2247539460659027,
0.1737734079360962,
0.3027433454990387,
0.8685680031776428,
-0.7572614550590515,
-0.26085415482521057,
-0.3822042942047119,
0.37719202041625977,
-0.11917463690042496,
-0.33818644285202026,
0.6882728934288025,
-0.29382357001304626,
-0.28120550513267517,
0.3696059584617615,
0.13733911514282227,
-0.09794515371322632,
-0.28317761421203613,
0.017913663759827614,
-0.1453167051076889,
-0.29375696182250977,
0.43785110116004944,
0.33749476075172424,
-0.31492191553115845,
-0.1531180590391159,
-0.12994635105133057,
0.07161328196525574,
0.36269456148147583,
1.2854795455932617,
-0.9832130670547485,
0.2278991937637329,
0.7245873212814331,
0.7382446527481079,
0.6685348749160767,
0.2640358805656433,
0.21932587027549744,
-0.727857768535614,
-0.19187088310718536,
0.46990084648132324,
0.28746047616004944,
0.06466822326183319,
-0.45931684970855713,
0.7800962328910828,
0.34731870889663696,
-0.68636155128479,
-0.5823981165885925,
-0.007151032332330942,
-1.1071828603744507,
-0.31014952063560486,
0.6084926128387451,
-0.2341393232345581,
-0.07352709025144577,
-0.4177161157131195,
-0.29726818203926086,
0.09159140288829803,
-0.4410322904586792,
1.040027141571045,
0.6187344789505005,
-0.5958403944969177,
-0.18164901435375214,
-0.3158239424228668,
0.5630725622177124,
0.45452794432640076,
-0.9451237916946411,
-0.10494488477706909,
0.3650418221950531,
0.10130272060632706,
0.4270881414413452,
0.702699601650238,
-0.060220979154109955,
-0.04331943392753601,
0.20526762306690216,
-0.3505105972290039,
-0.0005690953112207353,
-0.37923020124435425,
0.25132519006729126,
0.9810020327568054,
0.5018802285194397,
-0.08204733580350876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15391v1 | CapsF: Capsule Fusion for Extracting psychiatric stressors for suicide from twitter | 2024-02-07T13:41:22 | 2024-02-07T13:41:22 | Mohammad Ali Dadgostarnia, Ramin Mousa, Saba Hesaraki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Along with factors such as cancer, blood pressure, street accidents and
stroke, suicide has been one of Iran main causes of death. One of the main
reasons for suicide is psychological stressors. Identifying psychological
stressors in an at risk population can help in the early prevention of suicidal
and suicidal behaviours. In recent years, the widespread popularity and flow of
real time information sharing of social media have allowed for potential early
intervention in large scale and even small scale populations. However, some
automated approaches to extract psychiatric stressors from Twitter have been
presented, but most of this research has been for non Persian languages. This
study aims to investigate the techniques of detecting psychological stress
related to suicide from Persian tweets using learning based methods. The
proposed capsule based approach achieved a binary classification accuracy of
0.83. | [
-0.21975268423557281,
-0.9907023310661316,
0.6597828269004822,
0.4086008071899414,
-0.11573994904756546,
0.4975031614303589,
-0.3917527198791504,
-0.29446303844451904,
0.32327044010162354,
0.04712245240807533,
-0.9734517931938171,
-0.7230514287948608,
-0.717411994934082,
0.4144282042980194,
-0.14702175557613373,
0.7214298844337463,
-0.1744336634874344,
0.07153087109327316,
0.11068445444107056,
0.23977410793304443,
-0.3486473858356476,
-0.2669391334056854,
-1.1150157451629639,
0.24120371043682098,
0.6251081228256226,
0.6969277858734131,
0.36954692006111145,
-0.23047304153442383,
0.7145480513572693,
0.34252187609672546,
0.225388303399086,
0.2741960287094116,
-0.27693650126457214,
0.08385682851076126,
-0.11304701119661331,
-0.016122350469231606,
0.10118429362773895,
-0.15231075882911682,
0.3549014925956726,
0.22046178579330444,
-0.2074057161808014,
0.32851579785346985,
0.0588066503405571,
0.4250965416431427,
-0.6570116281509399,
0.03265927731990814,
-0.19583532214164734,
0.47125357389450073,
-0.3616674244403839,
0.11060542613267899,
-0.13484801352024078,
-0.7402257323265076,
-0.3194156587123871,
-0.7003439664840698,
0.07955632358789444,
0.25322800874710083,
0.7405275106430054,
0.23384606838226318,
-0.30896854400634766,
-0.22300368547439575,
-0.8739508390426636,
1.0619580745697021,
-0.3390553891658783,
0.04034193232655525,
0.11505841463804245,
0.6408750414848328,
-0.06981402635574341,
-0.15129828453063965,
-0.8107210993766785,
0.20963940024375916,
-0.22254040837287903,
0.00424146419391036,
-0.12543171644210815,
0.06809134781360626,
0.263813853263855,
0.4911079704761505,
-0.5844606161117554,
-0.11828120052814484,
-0.634064257144928,
-0.3505879342556,
0.5026763081550598,
0.14797955751419067,
1.0460004806518555,
-0.4735150635242462,
-0.23891039192676544,
0.022307323291897774,
0.1238519474864006,
-0.015511647798120975,
-0.011105147190392017,
0.28164586424827576,
-0.3314031660556793,
0.5039587020874023,
0.0017933174967765808,
0.2401961237192154,
0.2781871557235718,
-0.2209414690732956,
0.34232714772224426,
0.03206750005483627,
-0.1661342829465866,
-0.07380612939596176,
1.2801834344863892,
0.23777025938034058,
0.2868552803993225,
-0.10829091817140579,
0.24855461716651917,
-0.16300849616527557,
0.3713948428630829,
-0.5607333779335022,
-0.08586977422237396,
0.4919085204601288,
-0.6974523663520813,
-0.4212942123413086,
-0.14920423924922943,
-0.8816172480583191,
-0.4024369716644287,
0.26838213205337524,
0.31383419036865234,
-0.9307042956352234,
-0.3824250102043152,
-0.054595716297626495,
-0.4486289918422699,
0.31108319759368896,
0.284023642539978,
-0.4902457594871521,
0.38190343976020813,
0.5135855078697205,
1.1284816265106201,
-0.6117256879806519,
0.1346786469221115,
-0.18379555642604828,
-0.13894151151180267,
-0.3096732497215271,
1.002954125404358,
-0.3196823000907898,
-0.27260246872901917,
0.2661905586719513,
-0.02829866297543049,
-0.16418367624282837,
-0.23970897495746613,
0.9305437207221985,
-0.1910412311553955,
0.358929306268692,
-0.8427523970603943,
-0.42029356956481934,
-0.10191620886325836,
0.22863373160362244,
-0.6433129906654358,
1.0908957719802856,
0.3437453806400299,
-1.0060560703277588,
0.5316022634506226,
-0.7812706828117371,
-0.5752545595169067,
0.30396196246147156,
0.04862997680902481,
-0.5825836658477783,
-0.14705908298492432,
0.46407678723335266,
0.7305455803871155,
-0.33403831720352173,
0.19884741306304932,
-0.3291279375553131,
-0.21764667332172394,
0.32947736978530884,
0.14650005102157593,
0.9143853187561035,
0.5498799085617065,
0.004702286329120398,
0.11663269996643066,
-0.49802082777023315,
-0.046742092818021774,
0.022547343745827675,
0.020079491659998894,
-0.3232976198196411,
0.08012546598911285,
0.4456663727760315,
0.4784716069698334,
-0.11372529715299606,
-1.069421410560608,
0.048250164836645126,
-0.03370280563831329,
0.12145569175481796,
0.45112958550453186,
0.9981980919837952,
-0.04600333794951439,
-0.35468989610671997,
0.7630486488342285,
0.23948852717876434,
0.5303298830986023,
0.6103082299232483,
-0.5239518284797668,
-0.23152673244476318,
-0.8057345747947693,
-0.3800329566001892,
0.8303923606872559,
-0.7283186316490173,
0.5184512138366699,
0.17637713253498077,
-0.8173062801361084,
-0.21427775919437408,
0.05944066122174263,
0.5221472978591919,
0.5652236938476562,
0.47841617465019226,
0.042998071759939194,
-0.8618297576904297,
-0.9673898220062256,
-0.5055294036865234,
0.024959303438663483,
0.03039288893342018,
0.22085686028003693,
0.35691753029823303,
0.027882490307092667,
0.6537016034126282,
-0.8970863819122314,
-0.4693298041820526,
-0.5898228883743286,
0.30636560916900635,
0.18378795683383942,
0.4909898042678833,
0.44977906346321106,
-0.7889923453330994,
-0.7076560258865356,
-0.2815781235694885,
-0.9931088089942932,
-0.23073036968708038,
-0.41489914059638977,
-0.31689539551734924,
-0.10466434806585312,
0.4150483310222626,
-0.7252081036567688,
0.4050019681453705,
-0.14509683847427368,
-0.015094541944563389,
0.6180444359779358,
0.2314041554927826,
0.3913646936416626,
-1.3960040807724,
0.24011346697807312,
0.24544380605220795,
-0.2162313461303711,
-0.769669771194458,
-0.41555118560791016,
0.06668179482221603,
-0.394045889377594,
-0.6232291460037231,
0.18994204699993134,
-0.4515282213687897,
0.3239403963088989,
-0.1314103901386261,
-0.0667790099978447,
-0.2823414206504822,
0.33169957995414734,
-0.03855249285697937,
0.7053075432777405,
0.4055044651031494,
-0.23223380744457245,
0.1934536248445511,
0.5583987236022949,
-0.28202682733535767,
0.6088715195655823,
-0.3091427981853485,
-0.25975459814071655,
-0.293433278799057,
0.24359583854675293,
-1.213854432106018,
-0.36207476258277893,
0.5909761190414429,
-0.5418376326560974,
0.18510392308235168,
0.29170143604278564,
-0.5437057018280029,
-0.8360875248908997,
-0.46444034576416016,
0.3415612578392029,
0.5231022834777832,
0.12487943470478058,
0.47718918323516846,
0.5157870650291443,
-0.12532570958137512,
-0.4082127809524536,
-0.5647105574607849,
0.04365672543644905,
-0.4152487516403198,
-0.12640133500099182,
0.20212791860103607,
0.03451668471097946,
-0.3072957694530487,
-0.052745308727025986,
0.1267811506986618,
-0.10411721467971802,
0.041573915630578995,
0.6962237358093262,
0.17686684429645538,
0.07754547894001007,
0.33713847398757935,
0.3589768707752228,
0.069803386926651,
-0.0002716753806453198,
-0.07690475136041641,
0.5445437431335449,
0.09106942266225815,
-0.011299709789454937,
-0.8813627362251282,
0.7447977066040039,
0.37323153018951416,
0.014146632514894009,
1.3616067171096802,
0.9640783071517944,
-0.7450148463249207,
-0.2057151347398758,
-0.8675654530525208,
0.06416014581918716,
-0.4564265012741089,
-0.13496698439121246,
0.094706691801548,
-0.7038329243659973,
0.6011859774589539,
-0.17765797674655914,
-0.45278292894363403,
0.5548393130302429,
0.5373682975769043,
-0.0932285487651825,
0.7032454013824463,
0.6751368641853333,
-0.46366262435913086,
0.5132132768630981,
0.04228910803794861,
0.4697161614894867,
-0.5346906185150146,
-0.22999298572540283,
-0.2921731173992157,
-0.3228183686733246,
-0.4402676224708557,
-0.33361881971359253,
0.7324856519699097,
-0.14906015992164612,
-0.3130530118942261,
0.34344276785850525,
-0.6587960720062256,
0.4352627694606781,
0.4206083416938782,
0.3541880249977112,
-0.20565950870513916,
0.017543749883770943,
-0.1732170581817627,
-0.031112592667341232,
-0.14270862936973572,
-0.20574544370174408,
0.6451846361160278,
-0.06337638944387436,
0.37212812900543213,
-0.09178074449300766,
0.7466272711753845,
0.6365106701850891,
0.2776561975479126,
-0.5338698625564575,
0.4948762357234955,
0.09991808235645294,
-0.7295551300048828,
-0.3091924488544464,
-0.3147987127304077,
-0.4302290976047516,
-0.4641155004501343,
-0.269368052482605,
-1.105963945388794,
0.2043810933828354,
-0.2654559016227722,
-0.8840840458869934,
0.3621124029159546,
-0.4544316232204437,
0.6109381318092346,
-0.010891525074839592,
-0.05813442915678024,
-0.1657504141330719,
-0.7557752132415771,
0.5980890393257141,
-0.14913368225097656,
0.3145131766796112,
-0.31325915455818176,
0.10129351168870926,
1.110372543334961,
-0.6456913352012634,
0.8316916823387146,
-0.26734891533851624,
0.3142282962799072,
0.3791211247444153,
0.09162752330303192,
0.035648755729198456,
-0.10312933474779129,
-0.004157384857535362,
0.06537149846553802,
0.014568745158612728,
-0.5110329985618591,
-0.3772960305213928,
0.5427013635635376,
-1.0676395893096924,
-0.3845139741897583,
-0.5259436964988708,
-0.5188408493995667,
-0.3500455319881439,
0.23995055258274078,
0.3256858289241791,
-0.15214349329471588,
-0.11160452663898468,
-0.36275210976600647,
0.3857167959213257,
-0.678238034248352,
0.6194623708724976,
0.10667213797569275,
0.03477119654417038,
-0.6920705437660217,
0.6213837265968323,
-0.08899887651205063,
-0.09583061933517456,
0.5437254309654236,
0.2649769186973572,
0.15469561517238617,
-0.042002830654382706,
0.04160549119114876,
0.5296643972396851,
-0.33497515320777893,
-0.5270949602127075,
-0.7153611779212952,
-0.27208200097084045,
-0.7429323196411133,
-0.25634410977363586,
-0.25904378294944763,
-0.37078985571861267,
-0.5383079051971436,
-0.5367260575294495,
0.6054693460464478,
0.5586403608322144,
-0.5606905817985535,
0.34414124488830566,
-0.9363119006156921,
0.5085380673408508,
-0.07393063604831696,
-0.03693176433444023,
-0.05663464590907097,
0.1692541539669037,
-0.2532879114151001,
-0.34201115369796753,
-0.5079265236854553,
-1.3676475286483765,
0.5228248834609985,
0.4496004283428192,
0.168733149766922,
0.9894810914993286,
0.3611251711845398,
0.789276123046875,
-0.12933756411075592,
0.8629160523414612,
0.1396748125553131,
-0.8820922374725342,
0.8077734708786011,
-0.5813133716583252,
-0.07272595167160034,
0.7370796799659729,
1.2032263278961182,
-1.1678466796875,
-0.35961097478866577,
-0.49776285886764526,
-0.36686912178993225,
0.8280335068702698,
0.45451661944389343,
-0.23950575292110443,
-0.36071205139160156,
0.7456319332122803,
0.09195766597986221,
0.06411166489124298,
-0.26523223519325256,
-0.3312956690788269,
0.2214251011610031,
-0.3992694914340973,
0.0806734710931778,
-0.39094850420951843,
0.22134654223918915,
-0.3422204852104187,
0.6378517150878906,
0.3335186243057251,
0.5830944180488586,
0.4264388382434845,
-0.007789821829646826,
-0.692836582660675,
-0.05428140237927437,
0.34597131609916687,
0.16872909665107727,
-0.5089899897575378,
-0.15636208653450012,
0.1712283492088318,
-0.512394368648529,
0.10539127886295319,
-0.058877911418676376,
-0.19185946881771088,
-0.18148112297058105,
0.286345899105072,
0.29626181721687317,
0.019961431622505188,
-0.7053269743919373,
0.6484588384628296,
-0.17126548290252686,
-0.07257628440856934,
-0.8464527726173401,
-0.038123719394207,
-0.09761372953653336,
0.2599165141582489,
0.5512813925743103,
-0.051433976739645004,
0.32977625727653503,
-0.49377211928367615,
0.36066970229148865,
0.4123809337615967,
-0.3690119683742523,
-0.5422863364219666,
0.3566415309906006,
-0.1361061930656433,
-0.3312861919403076,
0.6146958470344543,
-0.34237340092658997,
-0.9876807928085327,
0.2732892334461212,
0.33172377943992615,
0.9708528518676758,
-0.6172342896461487,
0.6962081789970398,
0.6643502116203308,
0.10336921364068985,
0.06372636556625366,
0.724900484085083,
-0.30763328075408936,
-0.6463524103164673,
-0.13295415043830872,
-0.7299957871437073,
-0.42157137393951416,
0.13234500586986542,
-0.7761014699935913,
0.35646119713783264,
-0.7000485062599182,
-0.2522478699684143,
-0.17526154220104218,
0.32628658413887024,
-0.4282732903957367,
0.39533311128616333,
0.6068332195281982,
0.7786977291107178,
-1.3894169330596924,
0.3202371597290039,
0.403580904006958,
-0.7251386642456055,
-0.7848801016807556,
0.2300661951303482,
0.21798831224441528,
-0.641667366027832,
0.5015702843666077,
0.2729319930076599,
0.28247880935668945,
-0.35400089621543884,
-0.617913007736206,
-0.9570956230163574,
0.8502615094184875,
0.01366369891911745,
-0.15370620787143707,
-0.17177967727184296,
0.5586475133895874,
0.6365208029747009,
-0.13694095611572266,
0.3419612944126129,
0.2667332589626312,
0.43139544129371643,
0.06402981281280518,
-0.6655157208442688,
0.4604125916957855,
-0.3276721239089966,
-0.08683483302593231,
0.3280947804450989,
-0.7955449223518372,
0.7711310982704163,
-0.0076412176713347435,
-0.6315602660179138,
-0.20735983550548553,
0.5629284977912903,
-0.02916603907942772,
0.19729936122894287,
0.4040466547012329,
0.7029677033424377,
0.714895486831665,
0.4293632209300995,
0.9157624244689941,
-0.12468357384204865,
0.41863659024238586,
0.5024315118789673,
-0.18328431248664856,
0.8570554256439209,
0.48243001103401184,
-0.14812792837619781,
0.7446531057357788,
0.6737998723983765,
-0.0017617656849324703,
0.5190144181251526,
0.1860276311635971,
-0.35836607217788696,
-0.4172433018684387,
-0.07702493667602539,
0.1179875060915947,
0.06996621191501617,
0.8190917372703552,
-0.3099994659423828,
-0.3618234694004059,
0.8235153555870056,
0.3719943165779114,
-0.0801481232047081,
-0.002061030361801386,
0.8145216703414917,
0.13580866158008575,
-0.6164350509643555,
0.35451892018318176,
-0.15181484818458557,
0.3470163643360138,
-0.14013022184371948,
0.16834546625614166,
0.1420624703168869,
0.24871835112571716,
-0.18317881226539612,
-0.5264935493469238,
0.8469734191894531,
0.086405910551548,
0.034832663834095,
-0.2528138756752014,
1.2537404298782349,
0.011850952170789242,
-0.9785959720611572,
0.23334908485412598,
0.6859822869300842,
0.1278264820575714,
-0.5257596969604492,
-0.6522955894470215,
-0.2197953760623932,
-0.28383809328079224,
-0.20647791028022766,
-0.035621896386146545,
0.32993581891059875,
0.0640772357583046,
0.6520469188690186,
0.511283814907074,
0.20171144604682922,
-0.2227381318807602,
-0.4033661186695099,
0.7696319222450256,
-0.7446704506874084,
-0.13197903335094452,
-0.9191519618034363,
0.2584838271141052,
-0.3491224944591522,
-0.293273389339447,
0.803838849067688,
0.47594913840293884,
0.1460147202014923,
-0.3662026524543762,
0.8140026926994324,
-0.4055412709712982,
1.0516866445541382,
-0.042886752635240555,
1.187661051750183,
-0.4254501760005951,
-0.254160612821579,
-0.40147489309310913,
-0.38941508531570435,
-0.591363251209259,
0.3318067789077759,
-0.6908735036849976,
-0.2074044644832611,
1.0067850351333618,
0.6700157523155212,
-0.0053058648481965065,
-0.05108882486820221,
0.14211039245128632,
0.2796384394168854,
0.26226258277893066,
0.644183874130249,
0.5929385423660278,
-0.5886632204055786,
0.3513285219669342,
-0.4863908886909485,
-0.26660168170928955,
-0.1676758974790573,
-0.5351182818412781,
-1.3004047870635986,
-0.9194338321685791,
-0.5186907649040222,
-0.2570194602012634,
0.15763910114765167,
1.1754331588745117,
0.31331953406333923,
-1.0593241453170776,
0.09713421761989594,
-0.1375424712896347,
0.14181523025035858,
-0.30832529067993164,
-0.26571863889694214,
0.5810151696205139,
-0.404590368270874,
-0.1506391167640686,
-0.05150660127401352,
0.17531463503837585,
-0.3231710195541382,
0.15733957290649414,
0.5672417879104614,
-0.5058010220527649,
0.3073371350765228,
0.15363261103630066,
0.4119326174259186,
-0.3826470971107483,
-0.3270445466041565,
-0.12071956694126129,
-0.0875542014837265,
-0.01624690368771553,
0.7368301153182983,
-0.8533636331558228,
-0.2555180490016937,
0.5480015873908997,
0.2174084186553955,
0.14769089221954346,
0.11927124112844467,
0.3321848511695862,
-0.839668333530426,
-0.17825649678707123,
0.13955403864383698,
0.23631548881530762,
0.34844711422920227,
-0.8707067370414734,
-0.024985743686556816,
0.4442192018032074,
-0.4276169240474701,
-0.6588518619537354,
-0.18076448142528534,
-1.171437382698059,
-0.10183554887771606,
1.027000069618225,
-0.15917366743087769,
-0.8012883067131042,
-0.14616039395332336,
-0.35191360116004944,
0.8254520297050476,
-0.5442305207252502,
1.171645998954773,
0.5250718593597412,
-0.07524798810482025,
-0.14262014627456665,
-0.1419615000486374,
0.8195635080337524,
0.028783153742551804,
-0.9291725158691406,
-0.2141079604625702,
0.027229471132159233,
0.3019251525402069,
0.26437607407569885,
0.5767835378646851,
0.06323078274726868,
0.3482670485973358,
-0.2313222438097,
0.09036441147327423,
0.16908642649650574,
0.09388173371553421,
0.15130923688411713,
0.2813265323638916,
-0.6077632308006287,
-0.23194454610347748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04838v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04838v4 | PaDeLLM-NER: Parallel Decoding in Large Language Models for Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-07T13:39:38 | 2024-02-15T01:52:16 | Jinghui Lu, Ziwei Yang, Yanjie Wang, Xuejing Liu, Brian Mac Namee, Can Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we aim to reduce generation latency for Named Entity
Recognition (NER) with Large Language Models (LLMs). The main cause of high
latency in LLMs is the sequential decoding process, which autoregressively
generates all labels and mentions for NER, significantly increase the sequence
length. To this end, we introduce Parallel Decoding in LLM for NE}
(PaDeLLM-NER), a approach that integrates seamlessly into existing generative
model frameworks without necessitating additional modules or architectural
modifications. PaDeLLM-NER allows for the simultaneous decoding of all
mentions, thereby reducing generation latency. Experiments reveal that
PaDeLLM-NER significantly increases inference speed that is 1.76 to 10.22 times
faster than the autoregressive approach for both English and Chinese.
Simultaneously it maintains the quality of predictions as evidenced by the
performance that is on par with the state-of-the-art across various datasets. | [
-0.547965407371521,
-0.8087837100028992,
0.36135679483413696,
0.5839754939079285,
-0.30559664964675903,
0.19347403943538666,
-0.31173110008239746,
-0.520038902759552,
0.3685312271118164,
0.8109614253044128,
-0.1399085372686386,
-0.688361406326294,
-0.6626914739608765,
0.41409382224082947,
-0.3769338130950928,
0.8569879531860352,
-0.16331516206264496,
0.12469371408224106,
-0.14344695210456848,
-0.06467743963003159,
-0.17798025906085968,
-0.687976062297821,
-1.0322275161743164,
-0.3600182831287384,
0.7857503890991211,
0.4250759184360504,
0.41347965598106384,
0.9078906774520874,
0.7579876780509949,
0.24716944992542267,
-0.10438492149114609,
0.2632504403591156,
-0.40185311436653137,
0.4227592945098877,
0.09000568091869354,
-0.5136143565177917,
-0.9088559746742249,
-0.3412051200866699,
0.9378024935722351,
0.9035705924034119,
-0.04675843194127083,
-0.07015983015298843,
0.01279421430081129,
0.7352326512336731,
-0.6069461107254028,
0.26877033710479736,
-0.3952062726020813,
0.049080949276685715,
-0.2853506803512573,
-0.3417067229747772,
-0.5432103872299194,
-0.3441013991832733,
-0.10457049310207367,
-0.43725910782814026,
0.48140949010849,
0.3701242506504059,
0.646673858165741,
0.02230587601661682,
-0.3036683201789856,
-0.13261771202087402,
-0.7013586163520813,
0.6715731620788574,
-0.5935153961181641,
0.28508326411247253,
0.398722767829895,
0.1829691380262375,
-0.3971504271030426,
-0.7215238809585571,
-0.769372284412384,
-0.16205653548240662,
-0.0879119336605072,
0.03388913720846176,
-0.13871505856513977,
0.3582071363925934,
0.4381117522716522,
0.5426028370857239,
-0.7359628677368164,
0.4844810664653778,
0.04622204974293709,
-0.15399444103240967,
0.6753571629524231,
0.40640056133270264,
0.2860819399356842,
-0.10406821966171265,
-0.5263755321502686,
-0.0930156260728836,
-0.9740509986877441,
-0.2109687179327011,
0.394122451543808,
0.16818146407604218,
-0.12287837266921997,
0.37124156951904297,
-0.23068766295909882,
0.684851348400116,
0.04755519703030586,
-0.09383195638656616,
0.22190822660923004,
-0.028079358860850334,
-0.183983713388443,
0.3087918758392334,
0.7971032857894897,
0.29564815759658813,
0.004857110325247049,
-0.31398895382881165,
-0.28497758507728577,
0.11824645847082138,
-0.35999563336372375,
-1.210990309715271,
-0.4114079177379608,
0.19570621848106384,
-0.8221719861030579,
-0.05393647029995918,
0.06406356394290924,
-0.9550132751464844,
-0.27318817377090454,
-0.27104806900024414,
0.16137690842151642,
-0.2099079042673111,
-0.342965692281723,
0.23058784008026123,
0.08513259887695312,
0.3053722679615021,
0.38485708832740784,
-0.7794981002807617,
0.6928372383117676,
0.8124225735664368,
0.81337571144104,
-0.34232795238494873,
-0.4362017512321472,
-1.0507420301437378,
0.16633790731430054,
-0.39890021085739136,
0.9465131163597107,
-0.5744373202323914,
-0.49156561493873596,
-0.3172456622123718,
0.1738586723804474,
-0.18048736453056335,
-0.8197952508926392,
0.3350439965724945,
-0.817176103591919,
-0.14639422297477722,
-0.17557963728904724,
-0.8975883722305298,
-0.1395556628704071,
-0.001794545678421855,
-0.777959406375885,
0.6645249128341675,
-0.41850921511650085,
-0.842017412185669,
0.19529445469379425,
-0.4178854525089264,
-0.6242756843566895,
0.18768110871315002,
-0.21426895260810852,
-0.4297678470611572,
0.20678925514221191,
0.47477781772613525,
0.7406578660011292,
-0.6342943906784058,
0.33452552556991577,
-0.3172576129436493,
-0.39019301533699036,
0.1888156533241272,
-0.38827377557754517,
0.5753152966499329,
0.1467682421207428,
-0.24429135024547577,
-0.052249908447265625,
-0.8948227167129517,
-0.1889081746339798,
0.015374092385172844,
-0.37753719091415405,
-0.32980769872665405,
-0.06743621081113815,
0.2448253184556961,
-0.08894073963165283,
0.006473778281360865,
-0.5141630172729492,
0.10150014609098434,
-0.31982916593551636,
0.2291221171617508,
0.483081191778183,
0.026242321357131004,
0.5750067234039307,
-0.23958539962768555,
0.5833359956741333,
0.16130338609218597,
-0.40560972690582275,
-0.5395660400390625,
-0.4028071165084839,
-1.0222280025482178,
-0.41826358437538147,
0.6222724318504333,
0.5481147170066833,
-0.6456936597824097,
0.39492177963256836,
-0.3468151390552521,
-0.30195796489715576,
-0.34714236855506897,
-0.06156448647379875,
0.5431722402572632,
0.4884145259857178,
0.403057336807251,
-0.38746485114097595,
-0.6621071100234985,
-0.7241950631141663,
-0.10267636924982071,
-0.011964716017246246,
-0.05114932730793953,
0.4309227466583252,
0.487209290266037,
-0.2931790053844452,
0.5846874117851257,
-0.3020385205745697,
-0.040529847145080566,
-0.36038586497306824,
0.4490581750869751,
0.3030000329017639,
0.5981441736221313,
0.24176056683063507,
-0.7137778997421265,
-0.6563108563423157,
-0.014700236730277538,
-0.8093600273132324,
-0.2633051574230194,
-0.006343401037156582,
0.010668830014765263,
0.2427414506673813,
0.7314329147338867,
-0.6902886629104614,
0.36891812086105347,
0.5737228989601135,
-0.0860484391450882,
0.46637293696403503,
-0.43536633253097534,
0.08106990158557892,
-1.170759916305542,
-0.042424436658620834,
-0.1792691946029663,
-0.15763799846172333,
-0.4794974625110626,
-0.03781746327877045,
0.1381104737520218,
-0.14401617646217346,
-0.06693778932094574,
0.8126384615898132,
-1.1347142457962036,
-0.35380861163139343,
-0.5358997583389282,
0.13635526597499847,
0.09970671683549881,
0.06670962274074554,
0.20178955793380737,
1.0306476354599,
0.6540017127990723,
-0.8389213681221008,
0.4014759361743927,
0.17629501223564148,
-0.383439838886261,
0.511343777179718,
-0.7064483165740967,
0.13285812735557556,
-0.25558891892433167,
0.49363383650779724,
-0.4911244213581085,
-0.2641303539276123,
0.010808560065925121,
-0.3177966773509979,
0.6842030882835388,
-0.10616564005613327,
-0.6569735407829285,
-0.33472558856010437,
0.0039260596968233585,
0.791618287563324,
0.5557968020439148,
-0.9660434722900391,
0.5611255764961243,
0.5140060782432556,
-0.3731216490268707,
-0.5705241560935974,
-0.7790695428848267,
0.4129907190799713,
-0.2611615061759949,
-0.5724959969520569,
0.7621713876724243,
0.0921468436717987,
-0.14119794964790344,
0.05620046332478523,
0.09235825389623642,
-0.08421476185321808,
-0.21540839970111847,
0.1567898690700531,
0.1707940399646759,
-0.4769591987133026,
0.17590507864952087,
-0.059977754950523376,
-0.6462696194648743,
-0.0789489895105362,
-0.2791023254394531,
0.6331756711006165,
-0.07697920501232147,
-0.07315534353256226,
-0.6514561772346497,
0.5919934511184692,
0.36525022983551025,
-0.4017453193664551,
0.9354833364486694,
0.44722825288772583,
-0.3794931173324585,
-0.4302676320075989,
-0.7237647771835327,
-0.27194058895111084,
-0.420773983001709,
0.2704698443412781,
-0.5553935766220093,
-0.99952632188797,
0.8595549464225769,
-0.2644750475883484,
-0.6897339820861816,
0.23382800817489624,
0.4978996515274048,
-0.01730310544371605,
0.6995589733123779,
0.5605999827384949,
-0.21606943011283875,
0.253971129655838,
-0.30905357003211975,
0.3956722021102905,
-0.9553223848342896,
-0.32165294885635376,
-0.5260979533195496,
-0.21633921563625336,
-0.7209708094596863,
-0.7633079886436462,
-0.06281699985265732,
0.3953254520893097,
-0.14277975261211395,
0.3894258439540863,
-0.2950490415096283,
0.5366125702857971,
0.4662754535675049,
-0.0565292090177536,
0.4586372673511505,
0.19631138443946838,
-0.19687128067016602,
-0.05550796538591385,
-0.768302857875824,
-0.4739535450935364,
1.034094214439392,
0.19742214679718018,
0.9121837615966797,
-0.07183310389518738,
0.9681356549263,
0.09940928965806961,
0.24801763892173767,
-0.5756921768188477,
0.7296318411827087,
-0.3590508997440338,
-0.20626835525035858,
-0.015435758978128433,
-0.6200759410858154,
-1.2302374839782715,
0.16136857867240906,
-0.0241592638194561,
-0.6373768448829651,
0.3230566382408142,
0.10297761112451553,
-0.21989546716213226,
0.5639672875404358,
-0.2538051903247833,
0.6493515372276306,
-0.0663098692893982,
-0.17669805884361267,
-0.2476663738489151,
-0.44261178374290466,
0.30928167700767517,
0.10841316729784012,
-0.043523963540792465,
-0.3266330361366272,
-0.14670917391777039,
0.7418414950370789,
-0.5069136619567871,
0.4551912248134613,
-0.1675097495317459,
0.11185365915298462,
0.12050695717334747,
-0.13054560124874115,
0.7944568991661072,
0.2625240087509155,
-0.10447009652853012,
0.47755053639411926,
-0.4833326041698456,
-0.45714831352233887,
-0.4697425067424774,
0.999223530292511,
-0.6160640120506287,
-0.48268672823905945,
-0.36374902725219727,
-0.5166877508163452,
0.0996471643447876,
0.09828630834817886,
0.43550267815589905,
0.47365930676460266,
-0.18102668225765228,
0.23699018359184265,
0.9269087314605713,
-0.450328528881073,
0.6314681768417358,
0.4991554915904999,
-0.3438374102115631,
-0.7036396861076355,
0.8057149648666382,
0.16672579944133759,
-0.04551514983177185,
0.8076685667037964,
-0.35201603174209595,
-0.23533396422863007,
-0.9544305801391602,
-0.16435763239860535,
0.46191516518592834,
-0.4266206920146942,
-0.40172138810157776,
-1.0745761394500732,
-0.3114486336708069,
-0.13991938531398773,
0.04965834319591522,
-0.32279157638549805,
-0.3148585557937622,
-0.3863682746887207,
-0.08762062340974808,
0.42045193910598755,
0.5860010981559753,
-0.16347730159759521,
0.41996005177497864,
-0.9071069359779358,
0.5413385629653931,
0.11107791215181351,
0.3111101984977722,
0.061010368168354034,
-0.28303685784339905,
-0.13612262904644012,
-0.35535895824432373,
0.2798144519329071,
-0.7957925796508789,
0.5167532563209534,
0.06582988053560257,
0.5229493379592896,
0.29760468006134033,
0.14550979435443878,
0.696327269077301,
-0.6606563329696655,
0.32199805974960327,
0.19556374847888947,
-0.7917692065238953,
0.30185842514038086,
-0.2752447724342346,
0.015744628384709358,
0.23239634931087494,
0.18245559930801392,
-0.5089638829231262,
-0.017396923154592514,
-0.35015425086021423,
-1.0387520790100098,
0.608845055103302,
0.11055883020162582,
0.06657137721776962,
-0.35900241136550903,
0.2793887257575989,
0.2949850559234619,
0.18011848628520966,
-0.3870280385017395,
-0.33364662528038025,
0.33314335346221924,
0.094089575111866,
-0.22075268626213074,
-0.7594253420829773,
0.21647657454013824,
-0.10263831168413162,
0.5671901106834412,
0.11811355501413345,
0.5728437900543213,
0.178347647190094,
-0.25454428791999817,
0.14652252197265625,
0.21591490507125854,
0.28814804553985596,
0.29246288537979126,
-0.09104280918836594,
0.16217045485973358,
0.14939796924591064,
-0.3210075795650482,
0.18354474008083344,
0.5485188961029053,
-0.14516723155975342,
0.2569246292114258,
0.34082430601119995,
1.1041920185089111,
0.26022017002105713,
-0.3208928406238556,
0.43658018112182617,
-0.1452929973602295,
-0.04848441481590271,
-0.36013808846473694,
-0.1040990948677063,
0.1512303501367569,
0.3336644172668457,
0.32615402340888977,
-0.05119221284985542,
0.10945949703454971,
0.003147076815366745,
0.15049630403518677,
0.17098955810070038,
0.21849359571933746,
-0.22918446362018585,
0.7741314172744751,
0.3021607995033264,
-0.39450234174728394,
0.7993567585945129,
-0.2862248420715332,
-0.1971360296010971,
0.9908196926116943,
0.6434909105300903,
1.1128548383712769,
-0.28407174348831177,
0.12305746227502823,
0.44839948415756226,
0.03420726954936981,
-0.3019973039627075,
0.35499104857444763,
-0.13996654748916626,
-0.7906996011734009,
-0.5475987792015076,
-0.9158247709274292,
-0.41626834869384766,
0.2955688238143921,
-0.8044589161872864,
0.11017449200153351,
-0.43041783571243286,
-0.18296460807323456,
-0.05187992379069328,
-0.18413226306438446,
-0.6692087650299072,
-0.0337296798825264,
0.13012151420116425,
0.8736026287078857,
-0.3529926836490631,
0.9375251531600952,
0.5901023149490356,
-0.28794464468955994,
-0.7786321640014648,
0.24406684935092926,
-0.3638603389263153,
-0.5587282180786133,
0.9698584675788879,
0.4813219904899597,
-0.17168323695659637,
0.299458384513855,
0.002277070889249444,
-0.9635631442070007,
1.072746992111206,
0.46389833092689514,
-0.8871076703071594,
-0.08226040005683899,
0.06637021154165268,
0.3798203468322754,
-0.6422321200370789,
0.11748700588941574,
0.34877991676330566,
0.3490389287471771,
-0.24904997646808624,
-0.8883209228515625,
-0.04860139265656471,
-0.22558541595935822,
0.510576605796814,
0.3609265089035034,
-0.5470229387283325,
1.1065430641174316,
-0.34953153133392334,
-0.3898109495639801,
0.4468531012535095,
0.693103015422821,
0.42389991879463196,
0.5494312047958374,
0.03793703764677048,
0.7950982451438904,
0.8434076905250549,
-0.12299998849630356,
1.0109341144561768,
-0.6742891073226929,
0.42073917388916016,
1.2323949337005615,
-0.34249386191368103,
1.0809966325759888,
0.3961430788040161,
-0.29849499464035034,
0.45551177859306335,
0.5709455609321594,
-0.08011770993471146,
0.4313942790031433,
0.2673729658126831,
-0.6039660573005676,
-0.21578273177146912,
0.032875798642635345,
-0.7189440727233887,
0.36774951219558716,
0.502906858921051,
-0.42609870433807373,
-0.21004074811935425,
0.2059706598520279,
0.0901850163936615,
0.21133539080619812,
-0.446511834859848,
0.5791658759117126,
0.34049174189567566,
-0.4333588480949402,
0.5896320343017578,
0.1325232833623886,
0.8633857369422913,
-0.18558913469314575,
-0.08347680419683456,
-0.4331308901309967,
0.3722788691520691,
-0.12973777949810028,
-0.3638560473918915,
0.04621939733624458,
-0.08605783432722092,
-0.555896520614624,
-0.22800089418888092,
0.7585675120353699,
-0.6198508143424988,
-0.5141863226890564,
0.8058182001113892,
0.613551676273346,
0.34771206974983215,
-0.06290066242218018,
-0.46777451038360596,
0.09665592014789581,
-0.45336782932281494,
-0.25351977348327637,
0.38242602348327637,
0.3501836955547333,
0.026761947199702263,
0.6122077107429504,
0.68510901927948,
0.13763554394245148,
0.20105330646038055,
0.14629919826984406,
0.6849644780158997,
-0.8781352639198303,
-0.4611450135707855,
-0.7543455958366394,
0.12054961174726486,
-0.052007611840963364,
0.11434069275856018,
0.7749196887016296,
0.7149205207824707,
0.9456123113632202,
-0.1809622347354889,
0.6978986263275146,
0.22154656052589417,
0.5535145998001099,
-0.7179038524627686,
0.7781664729118347,
-0.23865516483783722,
0.5082152485847473,
-0.06637756526470184,
-1.150968313217163,
-0.4614264667034149,
0.48876458406448364,
-0.3930606245994568,
0.059544339776039124,
0.7270199060440063,
1.0212599039077759,
0.0455293208360672,
-0.05365920066833496,
0.3750307261943817,
0.3760867714881897,
0.027540190145373344,
0.5537854433059692,
0.7774966359138489,
-0.47009769082069397,
0.3143366277217865,
-0.25927701592445374,
-0.06932802498340607,
-0.32515934109687805,
-0.914907693862915,
-0.9569254517555237,
-0.20935161411762238,
-0.3867763876914978,
-0.18731269240379333,
0.3425571024417877,
0.6284879446029663,
0.583000123500824,
-1.0969957113265991,
-0.3991624414920807,
-0.569683849811554,
-0.008322671055793762,
0.02585216611623764,
-0.24350374937057495,
0.541607141494751,
-0.447028249502182,
-0.8956010937690735,
0.4966201186180115,
0.5365387201309204,
-0.03959517553448677,
0.09831226617097855,
-0.4023166298866272,
0.04439997300505638,
-0.21767957508563995,
0.47410112619400024,
0.36460909247398376,
-0.834601104259491,
0.2169613093137741,
-0.11008457094430923,
-0.1825421005487442,
0.17476382851600647,
0.998596727848053,
-0.8160141110420227,
0.4740926921367645,
0.5781979560852051,
0.877647340297699,
0.794581949710846,
-0.13379313051700592,
0.5955049395561218,
-0.17182333767414093,
0.3468623757362366,
0.3112606704235077,
0.5422638058662415,
0.4216506779193878,
-0.2775491774082184,
0.2219025194644928,
0.3851271867752075,
-0.6540020704269409,
-0.8074807524681091,
0.18161970376968384,
-0.8404777646064758,
-0.029917564243078232,
0.9503728151321411,
-0.44053635001182556,
-0.1191374659538269,
-0.06983581930398941,
0.038553014397621155,
0.21366272866725922,
-0.3909285068511963,
0.45773154497146606,
0.46434956789016724,
-0.28887104988098145,
-0.4609225392341614,
-0.41267716884613037,
0.3487392067909241,
0.39348840713500977,
-0.7428253293037415,
0.05596598982810974,
0.44081026315689087,
0.2237139493227005,
-0.1456935703754425,
0.7933592796325684,
-0.02549983561038971,
0.3384528160095215,
0.3296818733215332,
0.12184776365756989,
-0.12359654158353806,
-0.46062788367271423,
-0.4213774800300598,
0.31222519278526306,
0.059228528290987015,
-0.30852407217025757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10938v1 | News Source Credibility Assessment: A Reddit Case Study | 2024-02-07T13:39:24 | 2024-02-07T13:39:24 | Arash Amini, Yigit Ege Bayiz, Ashwin Ram, Radu Marculescu, Ufuk Topcu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | In the era of social media platforms, identifying the credibility of online
content is crucial to combat misinformation. We present the CREDiBERT
(CREDibility assessment using Bi-directional Encoder Representations from
Transformers), a source credibility assessment model fine-tuned for Reddit
submissions focusing on political discourse as the main contribution. We adopt
a semi-supervised training approach for CREDiBERT, leveraging Reddit's
community-based structure. By encoding submission content using CREDiBERT and
integrating it into a Siamese neural network, we significantly improve the
binary classification of submission credibility, achieving a 9% increase in F1
score compared to existing methods. Additionally, we introduce a new version of
the post-to-post network in Reddit that efficiently encodes user interactions
to enhance the binary classification task by nearly 8% in F1 score. Finally, we
employ CREDiBERT to evaluate the susceptibility of subreddits with respect to
different topics. | [
-0.28844109177589417,
-0.8200900554656982,
0.4305662214756012,
0.4441792070865631,
-0.480848103761673,
0.3728465437889099,
-0.5389161705970764,
-0.34221237897872925,
0.2077195644378662,
0.08154870569705963,
-0.15423083305358887,
-0.6316797733306885,
-0.9260087609291077,
0.2493557333946228,
-0.7500640153884888,
0.8371872901916504,
0.16786226630210876,
0.15194614231586456,
-0.47395768761634827,
-0.16297408938407898,
-0.2748260200023651,
-0.538746178150177,
-0.3963034451007843,
-0.11395163834095001,
0.7149194478988647,
0.31568989157676697,
0.7229872345924377,
0.31506451964378357,
0.8672214150428772,
0.25876671075820923,
-0.06485870480537415,
0.08045478165149689,
-0.4663718342781067,
-0.1552484631538391,
-0.7234522700309753,
-0.3098905682563782,
-0.06017788499593735,
0.11500892788171768,
0.26937511563301086,
0.23723284900188446,
-0.3276982605457306,
0.664260983467102,
0.13096708059310913,
0.5177624225616455,
-0.5769908428192139,
0.18192380666732788,
-0.7632725238800049,
-0.13173502683639526,
-0.18786200881004333,
-0.5189682841300964,
-0.5405139923095703,
-0.7747017741203308,
0.09583546966314316,
-0.35783496499061584,
0.28371259570121765,
-0.2891351878643036,
1.0594172477722168,
0.1622747927904129,
-0.47268882393836975,
-0.35543790459632874,
-0.8480498790740967,
0.5987111330032349,
-0.40804773569107056,
0.674340009689331,
0.10052929818630219,
0.4518963098526001,
0.12666453421115875,
-1.101767659187317,
-0.622496485710144,
0.10858263075351715,
-0.16961908340454102,
0.19837456941604614,
-0.04661816358566284,
-0.21104373037815094,
-0.15590354800224304,
0.10766614973545074,
-0.42987900972366333,
-0.45672062039375305,
-0.6964991688728333,
-0.48951202630996704,
0.6602170467376709,
-0.4696985185146332,
0.1303071826696396,
-0.47584518790245056,
-0.42423921823501587,
-0.2953072190284729,
-0.34396207332611084,
-0.092497318983078,
0.5158780217170715,
0.37938904762268066,
-0.04957633838057518,
0.6706966757774353,
-0.033772580325603485,
0.5436869859695435,
0.2644575238227844,
-0.2889031171798706,
0.13259485363960266,
-0.5496036410331726,
0.12104145437479019,
0.25663483142852783,
0.7274594306945801,
0.8359397649765015,
0.2760431170463562,
0.2515089511871338,
0.03937549144029617,
0.4209313988685608,
0.4644860625267029,
-0.6439158320426941,
-0.20363061130046844,
0.043599046766757965,
-0.5780988931655884,
-0.5621767044067383,
0.5712855458259583,
-1.0535335540771484,
-0.32761478424072266,
-0.2145182341337204,
0.2414708435535431,
-0.11687128990888596,
-0.17933058738708496,
0.0012376904487609863,
-0.2779307961463928,
-0.03569579869508743,
0.4774046540260315,
-0.09738627821207047,
0.007392795290797949,
0.6535361409187317,
0.8446919918060303,
-0.20401757955551147,
-0.07413982599973679,
-0.31583455204963684,
-0.2494029849767685,
-0.09467727690935135,
1.1237061023712158,
-0.7730394005775452,
0.1959969699382782,
0.316318154335022,
0.08762583136558533,
0.09986700117588043,
-0.2654820680618286,
0.9248570203781128,
-1.0281473398208618,
0.33165836334228516,
0.10477910935878754,
-0.4487451910972595,
-0.32036420702934265,
0.5654571056365967,
-0.7460616230964661,
0.8732871413230896,
0.33906760811805725,
-1.0044163465499878,
0.30373847484588623,
-0.4571409225463867,
-0.5691725611686707,
-0.13088227808475494,
-0.05308070778846741,
-0.25278592109680176,
-0.06175566092133522,
0.15793468058109283,
0.12269770354032516,
0.13998019695281982,
0.3436652719974518,
-0.18418122828006744,
-0.1688757985830307,
0.565724790096283,
-0.612589955329895,
0.7766594886779785,
0.009565983898937702,
-0.012930932454764843,
-0.25629547238349915,
-0.8066318035125732,
0.13525940477848053,
-0.1815914362668991,
-0.7258490324020386,
-0.2861112952232361,
-0.23039110004901886,
-0.020540572702884674,
0.25260189175605774,
0.33635956048965454,
-0.779278039932251,
-0.27087023854255676,
-0.050669364631175995,
0.8812464475631714,
0.3638831377029419,
0.4574710428714752,
0.27584198117256165,
-0.1796487718820572,
0.2585631310939789,
0.07401827722787857,
0.2667781710624695,
0.1872572898864746,
-0.4234378933906555,
-0.6579500436782837,
0.17530004680156708,
1.0344451665878296,
0.6306475400924683,
-0.7637212872505188,
0.3733450472354889,
-0.40532058477401733,
-0.696952760219574,
-0.419408917427063,
0.07265505939722061,
-0.10085204988718033,
0.4505886137485504,
0.45126742124557495,
-0.25919023156166077,
-0.6594616174697876,
-0.9538437128067017,
-0.8528708815574646,
-0.4736935794353485,
-0.14356690645217896,
-0.0738152489066124,
0.41255897283554077,
-0.20780113339424133,
0.8701867461204529,
-0.03306978940963745,
-0.15373685956001282,
-0.05826742574572563,
0.4268909692764282,
0.005734574981033802,
0.17970989644527435,
0.36282798647880554,
-1.0015069246292114,
-0.5713533759117126,
-0.21141575276851654,
-0.6444986462593079,
0.08569324016571045,
-0.16704386472702026,
0.006199991330504417,
0.02072695828974247,
0.22506417334079742,
-0.6957651972770691,
0.44596999883651733,
0.814606249332428,
-0.34130993485450745,
0.3089902698993683,
0.13891737163066864,
0.8242140412330627,
-0.6250425577163696,
-0.31177952885627747,
0.3792203962802887,
-0.6155361533164978,
-0.3657723665237427,
-0.052509013563394547,
0.3408523201942444,
-0.10445503145456314,
-0.7568133473396301,
-0.01665462553501129,
-0.15050989389419556,
0.04620976746082306,
-0.1198156476020813,
0.5584083795547485,
0.3862472176551819,
0.3160182535648346,
0.01914074271917343,
0.5223003625869751,
0.19544418156147003,
-0.5129953026771545,
0.38158559799194336,
0.18035924434661865,
-0.45567020773887634,
0.7237755060195923,
-0.6937181949615479,
0.25361233949661255,
-0.03295955806970596,
0.2736140787601471,
-0.8584708571434021,
-0.29161983728408813,
0.09491404891014099,
-1.0532950162887573,
0.1755698323249817,
-0.16630379855632782,
-0.617106020450592,
-0.3462005853652954,
-0.10553207248449326,
0.38531845808029175,
0.2630085051059723,
-0.520825982093811,
0.5576351284980774,
0.27219513058662415,
-0.19403308629989624,
-0.304074227809906,
-0.7868900299072266,
0.25984659790992737,
0.08575204759836197,
-0.6310049295425415,
0.30698513984680176,
0.1431514024734497,
-0.36930641531944275,
0.19902527332305908,
0.02722165174782276,
-0.40064582228660583,
-0.17136137187480927,
0.07409156858921051,
-0.019614730030298233,
-0.19766491651535034,
0.0069812992587685585,
-0.01693759672343731,
0.01368674822151661,
0.14886119961738586,
0.2267082929611206,
0.25262317061424255,
-0.07801573723554611,
-0.537246823310852,
-0.8044842481613159,
0.03651027753949165,
0.7507765293121338,
-0.2623555064201355,
0.7455182671546936,
0.24061927199363708,
-0.3431675434112549,
-0.10233771800994873,
-0.5199894905090332,
-0.47969895601272583,
-0.40050071477890015,
0.30135658383369446,
0.525865375995636,
-0.7559506893157959,
0.17444658279418945,
-0.05787455663084984,
0.16166667640209198,
0.5243698358535767,
0.5839776396751404,
-0.12607818841934204,
0.7385688424110413,
0.4112291634082794,
0.21819211542606354,
0.2535753548145294,
0.3786305785179138,
0.49225303530693054,
0.019407877698540688,
-0.36652958393096924,
-0.6497840285301208,
-0.3435865044593811,
-0.3535814583301544,
-0.6587331891059875,
0.05500602349638939,
-0.06988394260406494,
-0.011072129011154175,
0.6927858591079712,
-0.7027519345283508,
0.5350257158279419,
0.6603807806968689,
0.3142806589603424,
0.7524502277374268,
0.27610498666763306,
0.3618965446949005,
-0.31852999329566956,
-0.618080198764801,
-0.6529330015182495,
0.8624997138977051,
0.7414776682853699,
0.8231777548789978,
-0.05836339294910431,
0.20768454670906067,
1.0547374486923218,
0.5476486682891846,
-0.48487886786460876,
0.5112316608428955,
0.2665848135948181,
-0.7124332785606384,
0.029665686190128326,
-0.3641715943813324,
-0.29752853512763977,
-0.08291171491146088,
-0.4015807509422302,
-0.1711336076259613,
0.3347049057483673,
-0.1370917707681656,
-0.37238672375679016,
0.23684509098529816,
-0.5762438774108887,
0.38010019063949585,
-0.3107149302959442,
-0.4216371178627014,
-0.403917521238327,
-0.4904322624206543,
0.2470407783985138,
0.04368910938501358,
0.2943266034126282,
0.21538443863391876,
0.04263679310679436,
0.8215909600257874,
0.058138083666563034,
0.9293168783187866,
-0.08706570416688919,
0.23917223513126373,
0.6768965721130371,
0.007473745383322239,
0.35135388374328613,
0.46545934677124023,
-0.12239089608192444,
0.9100539684295654,
0.06860154867172241,
-0.18899287283420563,
-0.7160769701004028,
0.6168892979621887,
-0.6909213066101074,
-0.37370210886001587,
-0.5321115255355835,
-0.03413551300764084,
-0.05236018821597099,
0.21446670591831207,
0.27357155084609985,
0.3872638940811157,
-0.34189286828041077,
0.7470993995666504,
0.5222145318984985,
-0.0016203323611989617,
0.15693308413028717,
0.444680780172348,
0.12831386923789978,
-0.8438557982444763,
0.44591376185417175,
0.12060598284006119,
-0.00563005218282342,
0.2914077043533325,
0.026866568252444267,
-0.4631633460521698,
-0.3444686830043793,
-0.34346866607666016,
0.07868071645498276,
-0.8844934105873108,
-0.6541197896003723,
-0.38020220398902893,
-0.6840389370918274,
-0.3035794794559479,
-0.047407105565071106,
-0.793335497379303,
-0.6626606583595276,
-0.1693490892648697,
-0.373102068901062,
0.1790948063135147,
0.6231171488761902,
0.11158283054828644,
0.06723041832447052,
-0.957500159740448,
0.04998435080051422,
0.20081186294555664,
0.42331811785697937,
-0.4469418227672577,
-0.6656795144081116,
-0.14185437560081482,
0.4234626293182373,
-0.41196128726005554,
-0.9726499319076538,
-0.10256737470626831,
-0.011926836334168911,
0.5060983896255493,
0.5292840003967285,
0.5028767585754395,
0.4605652689933777,
-0.29938769340515137,
0.8923256397247314,
0.21034111082553864,
-0.618377149105072,
0.607062578201294,
-0.1672535240650177,
-0.3972134590148926,
0.853571355342865,
0.4903733432292938,
-0.24645069241523743,
-0.6214884519577026,
-0.8150567412376404,
-0.3359750509262085,
-0.14170949161052704,
0.5403591990470886,
0.16505588591098785,
-0.29378604888916016,
0.4042401611804962,
-0.06316401809453964,
0.33345726132392883,
-0.8845107555389404,
-0.03447200357913971,
-0.7755450010299683,
-0.2608054280281067,
0.2456548810005188,
-0.47878792881965637,
-0.4077901244163513,
-0.31396859884262085,
0.5475519895553589,
0.17843082547187805,
0.3377213478088379,
0.733244776725769,
-0.25547680258750916,
-0.2020571529865265,
0.33984535932540894,
0.7779796123504639,
1.0612503290176392,
0.03292691707611084,
0.3195068836212158,
-0.08369598537683487,
-0.2495453953742981,
-0.018398882821202278,
-0.1172061637043953,
-0.3023265600204468,
0.43379920721054077,
0.7375379800796509,
0.01151479221880436,
0.30056118965148926,
-0.5120640993118286,
0.8650947213172913,
-0.5106375813484192,
-0.536067545413971,
-0.4476419985294342,
-0.10733356326818466,
0.2228977084159851,
0.40155574679374695,
0.30788499116897583,
0.5074774622917175,
-0.2577901780605316,
-0.49400779604911804,
0.5309212803840637,
0.022635875269770622,
-0.6010006070137024,
-0.42985114455223083,
0.509307324886322,
0.6223147511482239,
-0.6788153648376465,
0.5093461275100708,
0.13738460838794708,
-0.8282709121704102,
0.38759085536003113,
0.20934522151947021,
0.3489993214607239,
-0.1102389395236969,
0.37675610184669495,
0.889459490776062,
0.6169939041137695,
-0.22069723904132843,
-0.215236634016037,
0.18498456478118896,
-0.7697353363037109,
-0.16875174641609192,
-0.6040425896644592,
-0.41319671273231506,
0.011471489444375038,
-0.6072580218315125,
0.25849154591560364,
-0.6132690906524658,
-0.5154198408126831,
-0.3051012456417084,
0.13580282032489777,
-0.3888762295246124,
-0.06679388880729675,
-0.14003854990005493,
1.3320372104644775,
-0.9495126605033875,
0.37460464239120483,
0.6297252774238586,
-0.14913536608219147,
-0.48440900444984436,
0.18020892143249512,
-0.013329457491636276,
-0.36712369322776794,
0.4183265268802643,
-0.011138473637402058,
0.003863121848553419,
-0.21095408499240875,
-0.6889110207557678,
-0.5294991731643677,
0.9938828349113464,
0.4486081302165985,
-0.5994641780853271,
0.2608800530433655,
0.240164116024971,
0.5009655356407166,
-0.31124281883239746,
0.13366219401359558,
0.25150761008262634,
0.7095698714256287,
-0.09932738542556763,
-0.7450188994407654,
-0.03363872691988945,
-0.19103026390075684,
-0.15403200685977936,
-0.24339288473129272,
-0.7359225153923035,
0.610163152217865,
0.06478904187679291,
-0.5573847889900208,
-0.34790268540382385,
0.9721503853797913,
0.1997484415769577,
0.36596259474754333,
0.6262302398681641,
0.333724707365036,
0.663916826248169,
-0.1287030428647995,
0.6437969207763672,
-0.6096388101577759,
0.6978963017463684,
0.9832868576049805,
-0.07294092327356339,
1.0742437839508057,
0.48808521032333374,
0.019510960206389427,
1.0879164934158325,
0.7443068623542786,
-0.18904535472393036,
0.5274912714958191,
-0.22839225828647614,
0.021229315549135208,
-0.4181636571884155,
-0.16118812561035156,
-0.284490704536438,
0.4580646753311157,
0.2579067349433899,
-0.6888337135314941,
-0.6078431010246277,
0.13594132661819458,
-0.05833618342876434,
0.6721664667129517,
-0.1761825978755951,
0.4376547932624817,
-0.03442081809043884,
-0.8301727175712585,
0.11055515706539154,
0.0002783575328066945,
0.37449365854263306,
-0.261980801820755,
-0.37146124243736267,
-0.05732947587966919,
0.3315911889076233,
-0.35682180523872375,
-1.1018048524856567,
0.43899819254875183,
0.027011800557374954,
-0.02528093196451664,
-0.10960989445447922,
1.2688099145889282,
-0.4865328073501587,
-0.7596620321273804,
0.38141003251075745,
0.43177762627601624,
-0.23781095445156097,
-0.12211049348115921,
-0.7009217739105225,
0.20402073860168457,
-0.14644044637680054,
-0.42953890562057495,
0.09744914621114731,
0.49337470531463623,
0.2164568454027176,
0.573078453540802,
0.7853142619132996,
-0.05168890208005905,
-0.24016337096691132,
-0.04819019138813019,
0.9462944269180298,
-0.44846364855766296,
-0.4508095979690552,
-0.7289308309555054,
0.28738588094711304,
-0.47995254397392273,
-0.006554265972226858,
1.0693609714508057,
0.5208300352096558,
0.8619882464408875,
0.1820114105939865,
0.7418375611305237,
-0.14738917350769043,
0.8508622646331787,
-0.19480513036251068,
0.9087722897529602,
-0.31241023540496826,
0.2033616155385971,
0.001594472792930901,
-0.7335002422332764,
-0.46596357226371765,
0.7586164474487305,
-0.08470295369625092,
-0.004595562815666199,
0.842667818069458,
0.9465216994285583,
-0.2082609385251999,
0.28214743733406067,
0.14343789219856262,
0.21080420911312103,
0.018360447138547897,
0.13058093190193176,
1.0330334901809692,
-0.3464806079864502,
0.8510192632675171,
-0.6201798915863037,
-0.17112433910369873,
-0.29741179943084717,
-0.9535735249519348,
-1.2159432172775269,
-0.3000310957431793,
-0.6726216673851013,
-0.8729680180549622,
0.18031013011932373,
0.5249465703964233,
0.6841504573822021,
-0.6512662172317505,
0.2910841703414917,
0.054411087185144424,
0.25246143341064453,
-0.2633122503757477,
-0.36269432306289673,
0.12525305151939392,
0.2561090886592865,
-0.3994207978248596,
0.037014905363321304,
0.2563389539718628,
-0.38986271619796753,
-0.44936373829841614,
0.1743139922618866,
-0.36786648631095886,
0.1967591494321823,
0.6311767101287842,
0.1699538677930832,
-0.46285751461982727,
-0.9048729538917542,
0.06020815670490265,
-0.18456128239631653,
0.23675473034381866,
0.80483078956604,
-0.5507336854934692,
-0.008375338278710842,
0.6391693353652954,
0.5457473397254944,
0.15900760889053345,
0.836575448513031,
0.3327711224555969,
-0.6730116605758667,
-0.11051754653453827,
0.3863752484321594,
0.10420611500740051,
0.5527279376983643,
-0.5688077211380005,
0.25916844606399536,
0.43604305386543274,
-0.6351295113563538,
-0.61985182762146,
-0.08235238492488861,
-1.0094623565673828,
-0.19378836452960968,
1.2466063499450684,
-0.10964768379926682,
-0.5729941725730896,
-0.3382398188114166,
0.15252119302749634,
0.19371289014816284,
-0.5299597978591919,
0.8789600729942322,
0.7911533117294312,
0.2742324769496918,
-0.39908644556999207,
-0.7109898328781128,
0.1413791924715042,
-0.2728418707847595,
-0.5381923317909241,
0.051569342613220215,
0.2402305006980896,
0.6188429594039917,
0.5615559220314026,
0.45407918095588684,
-0.3228522837162018,
0.4004407525062561,
-0.030893316492438316,
-0.09483201801776886,
0.09368860721588135,
-0.5469399094581604,
0.13513296842575073,
0.6095084547996521,
-0.17627142369747162,
-0.1216978058218956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06988v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06988v1 | Guiding LLMs The Right Way: Fast, Non-Invasive Constrained Generation | 2024-02-07T13:36:02 | 2024-02-07T13:36:02 | Luca Beurer-Kellner, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | To ensure that text generated by large language models (LLMs) is in an
expected format, constrained decoding proposes to enforce strict formal
language constraints during generation. However, as we show in this work, not
only do such methods incur performance overhead during generation, but many of
them also significantly impair task accuracy, if they do not correctly align
the underlying LLM sub-word vocabularies with external constraints. To address
this, we present a novel decoding algorithm, DOMINO, that can enforce
constraints in a fully subword-aligned fashion, while leveraging
pre-computation and speculative decoding to achieve virtually no overhead and
in some cases even almost 2$\times$ speedup over unconstrained decoding --
thereby outperforming existing approaches by a wide margin. | [
0.01686410792171955,
-0.5553382039070129,
0.5661276578903198,
0.28697502613067627,
-0.5983565449714661,
0.15362828969955444,
-0.10165756940841675,
-0.09319188445806503,
0.1983606517314911,
1.0242518186569214,
-0.9813970327377319,
-0.8679456114768982,
-0.5576250553131104,
0.27866214513778687,
-0.23609915375709534,
0.9830144047737122,
-0.08540152758359909,
-0.0902201309800148,
-0.3674711585044861,
0.11561121791601181,
-0.1916739046573639,
-0.22086212038993835,
-0.16256539523601532,
-0.2742135226726532,
0.26777374744415283,
0.4998147189617157,
0.8559955358505249,
1.3689148426055908,
0.3020423352718353,
0.28068143129348755,
-0.08149951696395874,
0.7648828625679016,
-0.5630416870117188,
0.01321864128112793,
-0.13741567730903625,
-0.5417224168777466,
-0.32371118664741516,
-0.3545234501361847,
0.6182140707969666,
0.5189110636711121,
-0.3016793727874756,
0.08866704255342484,
0.06901825964450836,
0.7203220725059509,
-0.8123641014099121,
0.01438956893980503,
-0.7550204992294312,
0.11393564939498901,
-0.5767053961753845,
-0.621665894985199,
-0.6598016619682312,
-0.5482573509216309,
-0.2965022623538971,
-0.9622495770454407,
0.21815161406993866,
0.13956433534622192,
0.8283616900444031,
0.5317274332046509,
-0.601012647151947,
-0.5945302844047546,
-0.629805862903595,
0.7320454716682434,
-0.5161604881286621,
0.45594462752342224,
0.3366147577762604,
-0.15577948093414307,
-0.5233559012413025,
-0.4953184127807617,
-0.5495755076408386,
0.061585620045661926,
0.12894481420516968,
0.08638142049312592,
-0.004971632268279791,
0.2966637909412384,
0.33616647124290466,
0.1872820109128952,
-0.5318461656570435,
0.2491883486509323,
-0.16001376509666443,
-0.43510398268699646,
0.48480120301246643,
0.4646812081336975,
0.1904047578573227,
-0.4321141242980957,
-0.18667036294937134,
0.1264215111732483,
-1.0091800689697266,
-0.12551124393939972,
0.41725268959999084,
0.3178345561027527,
-0.11132294684648514,
0.7020326852798462,
-0.027530144900083542,
0.6705361604690552,
0.1539793610572815,
-0.15291675925254822,
-0.19372226297855377,
-0.48544734716415405,
-0.2538881003856659,
0.13140825927257538,
0.7506555914878845,
0.45094263553619385,
0.09973075240850449,
-0.12514187395572662,
-0.1023978516459465,
0.4022431969642639,
0.1572110652923584,
-0.5379063487052917,
-0.3407151699066162,
0.07207374274730682,
-0.04290736839175224,
-0.16029076278209686,
-0.2962716519832611,
-0.7582000494003296,
-0.5483960509300232,
-0.048263952136039734,
-0.10452628135681152,
-0.4979335367679596,
-0.01258748210966587,
0.09464449435472488,
-0.0005875099450349808,
0.3818508982658386,
0.07559563219547272,
-1.06696355342865,
0.16173017024993896,
0.8502553105354309,
0.6831462383270264,
0.4224236011505127,
0.10558167845010757,
-0.8003976941108704,
0.6815453171730042,
-0.9301276803016663,
0.5826123952865601,
-0.47987815737724304,
-0.667670488357544,
0.29561787843704224,
-0.27717307209968567,
0.21949483454227448,
-0.5615915656089783,
0.6956666707992554,
-0.5672749876976013,
-0.01635732129216194,
-0.3429214358329773,
-0.7099485993385315,
0.27453145384788513,
0.318576455116272,
-0.5006988644599915,
0.9622611403465271,
0.0815674290060997,
-0.5722094178199768,
0.571392297744751,
-0.2809083163738251,
-0.728904664516449,
0.24863477051258087,
-0.44223082065582275,
-0.5667568445205688,
0.3069429397583008,
0.7487136125564575,
0.3324534296989441,
-0.34395068883895874,
0.2836388051509857,
-0.03032752312719822,
-0.24375542998313904,
0.002690129680559039,
-0.20742040872573853,
0.6991515159606934,
0.17117464542388916,
-0.3285078704357147,
0.16421553492546082,
-0.855951189994812,
0.18186324834823608,
0.019058557227253914,
-0.47375163435935974,
-0.06494122743606567,
0.22296586632728577,
-0.387131005525589,
-0.18048468232154846,
0.5097144246101379,
-0.565218448638916,
0.5538970232009888,
-0.4130142629146576,
0.4289535880088806,
0.9233660101890564,
-0.016791287809610367,
0.5783365368843079,
-0.1813940852880478,
0.6092106103897095,
-0.07885801047086716,
0.25545454025268555,
-0.005656224209815264,
-0.1391782909631729,
-0.8508158326148987,
-0.20476511120796204,
0.32920926809310913,
0.6506263613700867,
-1.1967289447784424,
0.48999491333961487,
-0.4763789176940918,
-0.3900315761566162,
-0.6826877593994141,
0.6462723016738892,
0.7919433116912842,
0.35416072607040405,
0.323244571685791,
-0.14089971780776978,
-0.7091735005378723,
-1.004884123802185,
-0.2349427044391632,
-0.007906409911811352,
0.12991610169410706,
0.31506428122520447,
0.01466301828622818,
-0.3413068354129791,
0.5557308793067932,
-0.46139252185821533,
-0.15297028422355652,
-0.4267723858356476,
0.09126536548137665,
0.2803124785423279,
0.609825074672699,
0.005788939539343119,
-0.6355703473091125,
-0.645813524723053,
0.03489416837692261,
-0.6505632996559143,
-0.3003811240196228,
-0.31797078251838684,
-0.23772209882736206,
0.4784639775753021,
0.7627573609352112,
-0.7874607443809509,
0.34231171011924744,
0.6587580442428589,
-0.09684628248214722,
0.22001489996910095,
-0.4625633656978607,
-0.41483914852142334,
-1.017235517501831,
-0.29631292819976807,
-0.20799897611141205,
-0.3582005500793457,
-0.5438471436500549,
0.08196668326854706,
0.44658738374710083,
-0.015268640592694283,
-0.2036917805671692,
0.04444420710206032,
-1.0544943809509277,
0.14291773736476898,
-0.17644673585891724,
0.2031625211238861,
0.1883813887834549,
0.2495303452014923,
0.0978165864944458,
0.727325439453125,
0.44784262776374817,
-0.7864096760749817,
0.2657431364059448,
0.14997419714927673,
-0.6276236176490784,
0.34815138578414917,
-0.2111915647983551,
0.2944398522377014,
-0.3215990662574768,
0.37797486782073975,
-0.582368791103363,
0.02064313180744648,
0.34883832931518555,
-0.1682758778333664,
0.4460203945636749,
-0.19055277109146118,
-0.6797615885734558,
-0.258091539144516,
-0.08745303004980087,
0.49665960669517517,
0.6561940908432007,
-0.596172571182251,
0.7539775967597961,
0.21806204319000244,
0.4378949999809265,
-0.7392728328704834,
-0.6279428601264954,
0.2275812327861786,
0.0430351123213768,
-0.5364164113998413,
0.4951569736003876,
-0.028279617428779602,
0.011920885182917118,
0.12163717299699783,
-0.15944595634937286,
0.11384701728820801,
-0.2221859097480774,
0.12491174787282944,
0.145469069480896,
-0.07123322784900665,
-0.33652523159980774,
0.23717978596687317,
-0.17209313809871674,
-0.14482371509075165,
-0.5214437246322632,
0.47886601090431213,
0.5038138031959534,
-0.21727542579174042,
-0.6751082539558411,
0.33020418882369995,
0.6100600957870483,
-0.2116224318742752,
0.5783677101135254,
0.3894162178039551,
-0.13438160717487335,
-0.7385099530220032,
-0.3796353340148926,
0.17474769055843353,
-0.6048175692558289,
0.3622240722179413,
-0.6242713332176208,
-0.6020897626876831,
0.293251633644104,
-0.16643542051315308,
0.15216118097305298,
0.1179865375161171,
0.40252548456192017,
0.14302003383636475,
1.0401015281677246,
0.922325074672699,
0.08458951860666275,
0.374066561460495,
-0.04845743626356125,
0.3200109601020813,
-0.9204393625259399,
-0.35019999742507935,
-0.406993567943573,
-0.03366245701909065,
-0.6197163462638855,
-0.6541547179222107,
0.17429739236831665,
0.3329950273036957,
0.3027062714099884,
0.4324414134025574,
-0.6839942336082458,
0.6993858814239502,
0.5817157626152039,
0.05234934762120247,
-0.004766120109707117,
-0.3318696916103363,
-0.44342276453971863,
-0.1768774539232254,
-1.0035369396209717,
-0.44147470593452454,
1.156639814376831,
0.06845524162054062,
0.7733862400054932,
0.36281976103782654,
0.9043980240821838,
0.09221461415290833,
0.4657524526119232,
-0.4352647662162781,
0.8776293396949768,
-0.4311155378818512,
-0.704517662525177,
-0.13232643902301788,
-0.5810800790786743,
-0.9441821575164795,
-0.087581105530262,
-0.24172650277614594,
-0.5877042412757874,
-0.0453973188996315,
0.36851072311401367,
-0.4215255081653595,
0.35030099749565125,
-0.40266939997673035,
0.44521987438201904,
-0.2683168947696686,
-0.5985672473907471,
0.06849879026412964,
-0.41602861881256104,
0.4261441230773926,
0.13350793719291687,
0.3054109811782837,
-0.12963122129440308,
-0.23885399103164673,
0.4473194181919098,
-0.6254565715789795,
0.8678545355796814,
-0.31988853216171265,
-0.37699007987976074,
0.37398841977119446,
0.43997952342033386,
0.8581888675689697,
0.030417514964938164,
-0.09913194924592972,
-0.20739300549030304,
0.013527334667742252,
-0.5832896828651428,
-0.7260832190513611,
0.6462636590003967,
-0.6427258253097534,
-0.9267135858535767,
-0.3315173387527466,
-0.7641836404800415,
-0.22051557898521423,
0.30452027916908264,
0.7818006277084351,
0.5326166749000549,
-0.19678746163845062,
-0.04211790859699249,
0.9179832339286804,
-0.14516401290893555,
0.1628163754940033,
0.46313121914863586,
-0.08710973709821701,
-0.6106717586517334,
1.0421748161315918,
0.29043418169021606,
0.1091713234782219,
0.9613205790519714,
0.13148105144500732,
-0.6416068077087402,
-0.9799282550811768,
-0.8529887795448303,
0.1780634969472885,
-0.608590304851532,
-0.18388064205646515,
-0.08038464188575745,
0.01530651655048132,
-0.8140544891357422,
-0.4261482357978821,
-0.38012343645095825,
-0.15407763421535492,
-0.4333381950855255,
-0.09097656607627869,
-0.11838027834892273,
0.8890191316604614,
-0.19204218685626984,
0.29487961530685425,
-1.0858845710754395,
0.2368176132440567,
-0.041468895971775055,
0.2134411782026291,
-0.4970797896385193,
-0.18801312148571014,
-0.2987539768218994,
-0.298727810382843,
-0.24740010499954224,
-0.9577626585960388,
0.24546556174755096,
-0.01391327753663063,
0.4265320599079132,
0.6059420108795166,
0.41756147146224976,
0.827431857585907,
-0.7004989981651306,
0.7288799285888672,
0.13105261325836182,
-1.3172314167022705,
0.3705057203769684,
-0.4810967743396759,
0.45879924297332764,
0.4818398058414459,
0.11103388667106628,
-0.35032081604003906,
-0.28949490189552307,
-0.3488527238368988,
-0.8785204887390137,
0.42750459909439087,
0.2392408400774002,
0.07081159949302673,
-0.08197533339262009,
0.7046730518341064,
-0.09892237931489944,
0.14346955716609955,
-0.8303844332695007,
0.0017448060680180788,
-0.13589489459991455,
-0.5426793694496155,
-0.2973799705505371,
-0.48044076561927795,
-0.4545000195503235,
0.13935965299606323,
0.7508755922317505,
-0.11458349972963333,
0.13122890889644623,
0.351961225271225,
-0.15369558334350586,
-0.15814197063446045,
0.3076416552066803,
0.9323513507843018,
0.4089803695678711,
0.0501750186085701,
0.18195794522762299,
0.13040876388549805,
-0.26910853385925293,
0.15492823719978333,
-0.13339532911777496,
-0.4636424779891968,
-0.10260538756847382,
0.5307826995849609,
0.6584616303443909,
0.07211897522211075,
-0.5731253027915955,
0.34781014919281006,
-0.054820895195007324,
-0.46398308873176575,
-0.3126620352268219,
0.13382713496685028,
-0.062419988214969635,
0.15858477354049683,
-0.006023420952260494,
-0.3202015459537506,
-0.3492116928100586,
-0.24044789373874664,
0.11420369893312454,
0.6852374076843262,
-0.2392939180135727,
-0.18128694593906403,
0.554906964302063,
0.46775728464126587,
-0.47658097743988037,
0.8162358403205872,
-0.38097870349884033,
-0.5606788396835327,
0.43991145491600037,
0.770483136177063,
0.7923955321311951,
-0.009800519794225693,
0.034133221954107285,
0.12411406636238098,
0.8036336898803711,
0.15881764888763428,
0.5283401012420654,
-0.3648056387901306,
-0.8634293675422668,
-0.5101831555366516,
-0.5581856966018677,
-0.40990597009658813,
-0.02868609130382538,
-0.6404449939727783,
0.011045395396649837,
-1.1277493238449097,
-0.07141980528831482,
-0.417814701795578,
0.07761567831039429,
-0.4094981849193573,
0.2833070158958435,
0.11359661817550659,
0.9875438809394836,
-0.36418628692626953,
1.1120433807373047,
0.4338792860507965,
0.15516211092472076,
-0.9316763877868652,
0.04879416897892952,
0.23493953049182892,
-0.9015982747077942,
0.37223026156425476,
0.10568148642778397,
-0.4457704424858093,
0.1138971820473671,
-0.3517255187034607,
-0.7661848664283752,
0.9596118927001953,
0.3880406618118286,
-0.9441121220588684,
-0.09498251974582672,
0.4818181097507477,
0.23855482041835785,
-0.1398160606622696,
-0.150705024600029,
0.30371883511543274,
0.49657389521598816,
0.02422681264579296,
-0.6761731505393982,
0.28564947843551636,
-0.3295985758304596,
-0.03845648840069771,
0.8152139782905579,
-0.6643790602684021,
0.6104907393455505,
-0.13125744462013245,
-0.724249005317688,
0.39985987544059753,
0.6895356178283691,
0.07988841086626053,
0.21136239171028137,
0.40255337953567505,
0.8840171694755554,
0.9472422003746033,
-0.08525119721889496,
1.0265203714370728,
-0.5992625951766968,
-0.03868318349123001,
0.849931001663208,
-0.2148962765932083,
0.5709968209266663,
0.5920288562774658,
0.10055088996887207,
0.671302855014801,
0.6557644009590149,
0.16866262257099152,
0.5796111822128296,
0.42795756459236145,
-0.3268366754055023,
-0.46937525272369385,
-0.28020432591438293,
-0.1898239403963089,
0.2731826901435852,
0.6254400610923767,
-0.23846571147441864,
0.015887731686234474,
-0.44161128997802734,
0.13412299752235413,
0.5361200571060181,
-0.3899349272251129,
0.623119056224823,
-0.04880569130182266,
-0.978753924369812,
0.6921238303184509,
0.22748848795890808,
0.6560307145118713,
-0.8220036625862122,
0.2627826929092407,
-0.10623303055763245,
0.3691492974758148,
-0.26423123478889465,
-0.44445011019706726,
0.22136373817920685,
-0.17386402189731598,
-0.12262965738773346,
-0.2890947461128235,
0.40246570110321045,
-0.4206584692001343,
-0.5580704808235168,
0.2237447053194046,
0.23306310176849365,
-0.16133882105350494,
0.45242923498153687,
-0.5657602548599243,
0.3019345700740814,
0.28514179587364197,
0.002628754358738661,
-0.005250527523458004,
0.6674829721450806,
0.1532261222600937,
0.6754791140556335,
0.7677402496337891,
0.1873614639043808,
0.42721593379974365,
-0.1700848937034607,
0.7930393815040588,
-0.8172392249107361,
-0.742662250995636,
-0.9648026823997498,
0.288685142993927,
0.11129801720380783,
-0.4220518469810486,
0.9781956076622009,
0.6211263537406921,
0.7065783143043518,
0.3567269444465637,
0.5701477527618408,
0.3147570788860321,
0.23180174827575684,
-1.1033318042755127,
0.20315222442150116,
-0.560343325138092,
0.3597266376018524,
-0.17511148750782013,
-0.7801774144172668,
-0.5073661208152771,
0.35695868730545044,
-0.37571316957473755,
-0.3815918266773224,
0.5462321043014526,
1.07619309425354,
0.19443649053573608,
-0.06591492146253586,
0.2866736948490143,
0.0032732144463807344,
0.5266688466072083,
1.012413740158081,
0.8218160271644592,
-0.10154475271701813,
0.8136005401611328,
-0.3854018747806549,
-0.2680986523628235,
0.12683500349521637,
-1.03861403465271,
-0.944860577583313,
-0.24819062650203705,
-0.2192975878715515,
-0.5120564699172974,
0.14336635172367096,
0.6544208526611328,
0.9217648506164551,
-0.3527545928955078,
-0.34218937158584595,
-0.5861374735832214,
0.2765917479991913,
-0.11774773895740509,
-0.10647480934858322,
0.2558217942714691,
-0.11335215717554092,
-0.9766119718551636,
0.6794995069503784,
0.34728145599365234,
0.12160889804363251,
-0.37361279129981995,
-0.3604971766471863,
-0.010331076569855213,
0.4579414129257202,
0.20940306782722473,
0.42635494470596313,
-0.6245555877685547,
-0.07375902682542801,
-0.04380718618631363,
-0.24592134356498718,
0.015339621342718601,
1.200752854347229,
-0.49979060888290405,
0.3033026456832886,
0.35877934098243713,
0.7499495148658752,
0.48111605644226074,
0.1147252544760704,
0.7705433964729309,
-0.9172163605690002,
0.10120096057653427,
0.38632503151893616,
0.19136092066764832,
0.3219951391220093,
-0.6804752349853516,
0.05410318821668625,
0.23472175002098083,
-0.5086439847946167,
-0.9115452170372009,
0.8037128448486328,
-0.6987925171852112,
-0.4081811308860779,
1.0034468173980713,
0.06589166074991226,
-0.5232083797454834,
-0.18883004784584045,
0.07996566593647003,
0.3017421364784241,
-0.32733413577079773,
0.5202640891075134,
0.528274655342102,
-0.3407761752605438,
-0.3634738326072693,
0.04462531954050064,
0.726565420627594,
0.8118444681167603,
-0.4508607089519501,
0.2021750807762146,
0.5321936011314392,
0.14078940451145172,
0.26170945167541504,
0.7867307066917419,
0.0057788570411503315,
0.0024710199795663357,
0.24578739702701569,
-0.2408490628004074,
-0.2991686761379242,
-0.5463370084762573,
-0.08546651899814606,
0.31676816940307617,
0.07632896304130554,
-0.23643091320991516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04833v2 | Long Is More for Alignment: A Simple but Tough-to-Beat Baseline for Instruction Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-07T13:32:11 | 2024-06-04T17:20:01 | Hao Zhao, Maksym Andriushchenko, Francesco Croce, Nicolas Flammarion | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a consensus that instruction fine-tuning of LLMs requires
high-quality data, but what are they? LIMA (NeurIPS 2023) and AlpaGasus (ICLR
2024) are state-of-the-art methods for selecting such high-quality examples,
either via manual curation or using GPT-3.5-Turbo as a quality scorer. We show
that the extremely simple baseline of selecting the 1,000 instructions with
longest responses -- that intuitively contain more learnable information and
are harder to overfit -- from standard datasets can consistently outperform
these sophisticated methods according to GPT-4 and PaLM-2 as judges, while
remaining competitive on the Open LLM benchmarks that test factual knowledge.
We demonstrate this for several LLMs (Llama-2-7B, Llama-2-13B, Mistral-7B-v0.1)
and datasets (Alpaca-52k, Evol-Instruct-70k). In addition, a lightweight
refinement of such long instructions can further improve the abilities of the
fine-tuned LLMs, and allows us to obtain competitive results on MT-Bench and
the 2nd highest-ranked Llama-2-7B-based model on AlpacaEval 2.0, while training
on only 1,000 examples and no extra preference data. We also conduct a thorough
analysis of our models to ensure that their enhanced performance is not simply
due to GPT-4's preference for longer responses. Overall, our findings suggest
that fine-tuning on the longest responses should be the default baseline for
any work on instruction fine-tuning. We provide our code at
https://github.com/tml-epfl/long-is-more-for-alignment. | [
-0.5543283820152283,
-0.6286752820014954,
0.5584991574287415,
-0.10166307538747787,
-0.4167930483818054,
0.04905272647738457,
-0.4564684331417084,
-0.7228586077690125,
-0.0619700625538826,
0.40058648586273193,
-0.5832017064094543,
-0.7550325989723206,
-0.7603365182876587,
0.04862677678465843,
-0.46581414341926575,
1.294873833656311,
-0.22402244806289673,
-0.1863565891981125,
-0.22998203337192535,
-0.4203067719936371,
-0.5420237183570862,
-0.22450938820838928,
-0.4905816614627838,
-0.3808036148548126,
0.6247528195381165,
0.7544026374816895,
0.861202597618103,
1.122187852859497,
0.6828739643096924,
0.21124857664108276,
-0.22631755471229553,
0.4123435914516449,
-0.5502519011497498,
-0.1647130250930786,
0.07667597383260727,
-0.5629608035087585,
-0.7516114115715027,
0.21038514375686646,
0.4738788902759552,
0.6827206611633301,
-0.15177850425243378,
0.4898083508014679,
0.18151462078094482,
1.0312687158584595,
-0.48290687799453735,
0.05993172526359558,
-0.19624078273773193,
0.042491067200899124,
-0.31614869832992554,
-0.3201329708099365,
-0.332243949174881,
-0.7423613667488098,
0.1396508365869522,
-0.7978578805923462,
-0.1250452995300293,
0.13488593697547913,
1.020402431488037,
0.5664427280426025,
-0.44357597827911377,
-0.5953739881515503,
-0.6560592651367188,
0.9665988683700562,
-0.588708758354187,
0.5360333919525146,
0.3965763747692108,
0.40059733390808105,
-0.26768630743026733,
-0.5857672095298767,
-0.33447083830833435,
-0.3662704527378082,
0.13067024946212769,
0.21571603417396545,
0.1280728578567505,
0.048745546489953995,
0.4540422856807709,
0.30757227540016174,
-0.43538084626197815,
0.7146007418632507,
-0.46634986996650696,
0.08742748200893402,
0.4254608452320099,
0.20352165400981903,
-0.21516674757003784,
0.2592037320137024,
-0.5420850515365601,
-0.018513891845941544,
-1.2032475471496582,
0.2504723370075226,
0.5036206841468811,
0.010056834667921066,
-0.21296542882919312,
0.6372237205505371,
-0.3356070816516876,
0.990478515625,
0.29171302914619446,
-0.4299980103969574,
0.07994451373815536,
-0.08498041331768036,
-0.1803233027458191,
0.11921139061450958,
0.47426918148994446,
0.6469576954841614,
0.12744936347007751,
0.02847358211874962,
-0.2972678542137146,
-0.15387733280658722,
0.014448549598455429,
-0.8319664001464844,
0.018546326085925102,
-0.038027096539735794,
-0.37943562865257263,
0.15933263301849365,
0.0163209680467844,
-0.6248418688774109,
-0.1453738957643509,
-1.0371127128601074,
0.33509379625320435,
-0.38097718358039856,
0.594348669052124,
0.26940497756004333,
0.13532422482967377,
0.82330322265625,
0.40436622500419617,
-0.8066215515136719,
0.451701819896698,
1.170360803604126,
0.668558657169342,
-0.40061500668525696,
-0.37771064043045044,
-0.6363590955734253,
0.07354376465082169,
-0.5875721573829651,
0.701169490814209,
-0.5457866191864014,
-0.20137743651866913,
-0.17232297360897064,
-0.007868972606956959,
0.2985475957393646,
-0.4908568263053894,
0.6827003955841064,
-0.6206495761871338,
0.5338096022605896,
-0.6561005115509033,
-0.8782294988632202,
0.027898695319890976,
0.09501617401838303,
-0.4688062369823456,
1.0333852767944336,
0.046715572476387024,
-0.26205044984817505,
0.6202897429466248,
-0.48613524436950684,
-0.42832350730895996,
-0.18599103391170502,
-0.1226537823677063,
-0.5211843252182007,
-0.0032975245267152786,
0.23837211728096008,
0.37600985169410706,
-0.5817785263061523,
0.056985240429639816,
-0.25028935074806213,
-0.7541760802268982,
-0.003164241323247552,
-0.4367089867591858,
0.49317091703414917,
0.1652286946773529,
-0.5514071583747864,
-0.019829588010907173,
-0.7687224745750427,
0.16479583084583282,
-0.2405022829771042,
-0.6640614867210388,
0.12478014081716537,
-0.001511504058726132,
-0.6779142022132874,
0.04230301454663277,
0.41287028789520264,
-0.44145241379737854,
0.23127776384353638,
-0.2591530680656433,
0.3275356590747833,
1.039199709892273,
-0.31011107563972473,
0.3490712344646454,
-0.5264852046966553,
0.38084515929222107,
-0.2827834188938141,
0.4518257975578308,
0.10497675091028214,
-0.4378710091114044,
-1.0540827512741089,
-0.07444121688604355,
0.22699159383773804,
0.48992419242858887,
-0.2510329782962799,
0.7829382419586182,
-0.4880504608154297,
-0.46181192994117737,
-0.6267812252044678,
0.5266634225845337,
0.634044885635376,
0.6216577291488647,
0.5936535596847534,
-0.3607633709907532,
-0.41180458664894104,
-0.7800194025039673,
0.14679113030433655,
0.1641637086868286,
0.08520826697349548,
0.1085188165307045,
0.41666755080223083,
0.04770459979772568,
0.6215296983718872,
-0.5235151052474976,
-0.08885295689105988,
0.1551191210746765,
-0.04183070734143257,
0.4028550684452057,
0.2870594263076782,
0.45591190457344055,
-0.26039764285087585,
-0.47281500697135925,
0.05683404952287674,
-0.661517858505249,
0.023759936913847923,
0.04717729613184929,
-0.409992516040802,
0.12844499945640564,
0.47729605436325073,
-0.6487701535224915,
0.23480410873889923,
0.40361326932907104,
0.0750683844089508,
0.39216113090515137,
-0.15711326897144318,
0.08430231362581253,
-0.780813455581665,
-0.09213552623987198,
-0.08849325776100159,
-0.14326047897338867,
-0.24539417028427124,
0.24763630330562592,
0.192048117518425,
0.2073647528886795,
-0.29332345724105835,
0.29518869519233704,
-0.6055651903152466,
-0.20168529450893402,
-0.4270981252193451,
-0.01810307428240776,
0.16748741269111633,
0.43601930141448975,
-0.1255270391702652,
0.9332577586174011,
0.20423904061317444,
-0.6230738162994385,
0.6519092321395874,
0.15911704301834106,
-0.7188094854354858,
0.6136850118637085,
-0.7474367618560791,
0.39309361577033997,
-0.09953048825263977,
0.3457023501396179,
-0.7024829983711243,
-0.3085981011390686,
-0.041945990175008774,
-0.16850657761096954,
0.5542002320289612,
-0.1721622794866562,
-0.3308406174182892,
-0.48139628767967224,
-0.5059266686439514,
0.17469005286693573,
0.8583235144615173,
-0.8676403164863586,
-0.028116049244999886,
0.01042763702571392,
-0.05066391080617905,
-0.9307796955108643,
-0.4612872302532196,
-0.10291889309883118,
-0.3369959592819214,
-0.277557373046875,
0.23739370703697205,
-0.19382379949092865,
0.12750326097011566,
-0.4193401038646698,
-0.482087641954422,
0.10649673640727997,
0.14834532141685486,
0.2733876407146454,
0.2547430694103241,
-0.5159980058670044,
0.013579492457211018,
0.1380915641784668,
-0.2819901704788208,
-0.011410227976739407,
-0.23435832560062408,
0.4666142165660858,
-0.12361015379428864,
-0.7038223743438721,
-0.7765318155288696,
0.13211087882518768,
0.5815095901489258,
-0.19503597915172577,
0.508533775806427,
0.5269239544868469,
-0.09357292950153351,
0.08052413910627365,
-0.6329900622367859,
0.03477419912815094,
-0.4782167077064514,
0.13526582717895508,
-0.13405218720436096,
-0.7796164155006409,
0.2627427279949188,
-0.09560462832450867,
0.34659889340400696,
0.2754427194595337,
0.36602962017059326,
-0.34539660811424255,
0.9008455872535706,
0.5793100595474243,
-0.268024206161499,
0.4701382517814636,
-0.3239523768424988,
-0.10577995330095291,
-0.9013772010803223,
-0.33521655201911926,
-0.4855106472969055,
-0.6588374972343445,
-0.5736913084983826,
-0.40226349234580994,
0.2584887444972992,
0.0909859910607338,
-0.6235416531562805,
0.2735327482223511,
-0.7151483297348022,
0.9375240802764893,
0.6628300547599792,
0.24388130009174347,
0.15992988646030426,
-0.07993178814649582,
0.14788059890270233,
-0.01992236077785492,
-0.29047533869743347,
-0.7002685070037842,
1.1728477478027344,
0.37329426407814026,
1.0078983306884766,
0.1731012761592865,
0.8959301114082336,
-0.1400224268436432,
0.18149827420711517,
-0.8485703468322754,
0.4423322379589081,
-0.272612988948822,
-0.2773439288139343,
-0.3078996539115906,
-0.18284118175506592,
-0.9885732531547546,
-0.40565016865730286,
0.12998425960540771,
-0.3052324950695038,
0.0366021990776062,
0.16872340440750122,
-0.7779161334037781,
0.03910205140709877,
-0.6899620890617371,
0.45366233587265015,
-0.5825296640396118,
-0.4046088457107544,
-0.02053605020046234,
-0.8498293161392212,
0.16505418717861176,
0.10846617817878723,
-0.09288375824689865,
-0.3119698464870453,
-0.40147849917411804,
0.8166598677635193,
-0.3825162649154663,
0.7493196129798889,
-0.06198818236589432,
-0.21603836119174957,
0.28355202078819275,
-0.2362096905708313,
0.5706234574317932,
-0.03412861377000809,
-0.18996743857860565,
-0.15045560896396637,
-0.18831448256969452,
-0.5705642700195312,
-0.6013808250427246,
0.8658081293106079,
-1.0198919773101807,
-0.7359880208969116,
-0.13307352364063263,
-0.1963997483253479,
-0.12921293079853058,
0.12575829029083252,
0.4120534658432007,
0.3587814271450043,
0.1257590651512146,
0.4380975067615509,
0.8586370944976807,
-0.12820574641227722,
0.22885383665561676,
0.3071209192276001,
0.2392745018005371,
-0.3432994782924652,
0.8727725148200989,
0.2870504558086395,
0.372162789106369,
0.5662703514099121,
0.18548466265201569,
-0.26730263233184814,
-0.7367316484451294,
-0.601296067237854,
0.017870023846626282,
-0.7769889235496521,
-0.5398692488670349,
-0.20208923518657684,
-0.16068027913570404,
-0.12598255276679993,
-0.22203031182289124,
-0.3360605239868164,
-0.46376925706863403,
-0.48413559794425964,
-0.3317265212535858,
0.36087000370025635,
0.7510899901390076,
0.20457695424556732,
0.552168607711792,
-0.5893778800964355,
0.37841561436653137,
0.49731600284576416,
0.46849432587623596,
-0.21147514879703522,
-0.7313685417175293,
-0.2419474720954895,
0.07720331102609634,
-0.5550104379653931,
-0.5878639221191406,
-0.023652492091059685,
0.3810475170612335,
0.42851439118385315,
0.4139972925186157,
-0.2859036922454834,
1.2228522300720215,
-0.4691166579723358,
0.6354005932807922,
0.02613467536866665,
-0.6849076747894287,
0.43757307529449463,
-0.04916367679834366,
0.24872297048568726,
0.6643925309181213,
0.5724710822105408,
-0.21040721237659454,
-0.14724133908748627,
-0.2533086836338043,
-0.7752774953842163,
0.5065966248512268,
-0.14424224197864532,
0.11028804630041122,
0.034707702696323395,
0.6705753803253174,
0.5920315384864807,
0.19395381212234497,
-0.4914204478263855,
-0.10033515095710754,
-0.056546326726675034,
-0.28498584032058716,
-0.04201268032193184,
-0.2632019519805908,
-0.3555510342121124,
-0.4316561222076416,
0.5153349041938782,
-0.19537757337093353,
0.2400677651166916,
-0.17875507473945618,
-0.13092833757400513,
-0.17549560964107513,
0.30234605073928833,
0.7736977934837341,
0.8846437335014343,
-0.10924485325813293,
-0.07158566266298294,
0.45151251554489136,
-0.22619330883026123,
0.10130463540554047,
0.056370168924331665,
-0.08334960788488388,
-0.33645766973495483,
0.6096081733703613,
0.8972974419593811,
0.13772627711296082,
-0.26016613841056824,
0.4542633295059204,
0.24018485844135284,
-0.03169090300798416,
-0.20211419463157654,
0.28624191880226135,
0.0070179058238863945,
0.17199763655662537,
0.08379454910755157,
-0.17425641417503357,
0.0045817517675459385,
-0.47921669483184814,
0.13578705489635468,
0.32945138216018677,
-0.26319754123687744,
-0.2450312077999115,
0.3639366924762726,
0.10466356575489044,
-0.07059597223997116,
0.605571985244751,
-0.1424751877784729,
-0.21048258244991302,
0.7468714714050293,
0.38777247071266174,
0.19083015620708466,
-0.01986623741686344,
-0.05526056885719299,
0.363949179649353,
0.15051785111427307,
-0.3318827152252197,
0.313487708568573,
-0.18852069973945618,
-0.18746335804462433,
-0.5638195276260376,
-0.6795440912246704,
-0.5415858626365662,
0.1140274628996849,
-0.9266239404678345,
0.5285788774490356,
-0.8986846804618835,
-0.15257962048053741,
-0.07490018010139465,
0.2365735024213791,
-0.7559165954589844,
0.17475925385951996,
0.17470736801624298,
0.8191124200820923,
-0.5547994375228882,
0.6795629858970642,
0.45458680391311646,
-0.06732966750860214,
-0.8042333722114563,
-0.31743741035461426,
0.05913505703210831,
-1.2018303871154785,
0.49155867099761963,
0.36008045077323914,
-0.0039017032831907272,
-0.22150403261184692,
-0.749204695224762,
-1.0216283798217773,
1.3925286531448364,
0.5764212608337402,
-0.9130159020423889,
-0.32352790236473083,
0.1416717767715454,
0.6914005875587463,
-0.10414468497037888,
0.3680638372898102,
0.8342614769935608,
0.3703727722167969,
0.1956586092710495,
-0.9187687039375305,
-0.1419195532798767,
0.18318913877010345,
-0.30637386441230774,
0.5257165431976318,
-1.0064265727996826,
0.7782406806945801,
-0.34686148166656494,
0.024376001209020615,
0.4616285562515259,
0.7914347052574158,
0.29740533232688904,
0.29825863242149353,
0.05260360613465309,
0.8358489871025085,
0.871480405330658,
-0.20694759488105774,
0.8525874614715576,
-0.31647971272468567,
0.13049328327178955,
1.4594786167144775,
-0.20874790847301483,
0.8099911212921143,
0.4808511734008789,
-0.16613246500492096,
0.49890077114105225,
0.7766201496124268,
-0.07661829888820648,
0.35503074526786804,
0.3046814799308777,
0.10092578828334808,
-0.23173904418945312,
0.06886990368366241,
-0.5041456818580627,
0.49796876311302185,
0.3559383451938629,
-0.21105526387691498,
-0.2003510296344757,
-0.2319243848323822,
0.07545725256204605,
0.010020437650382519,
-0.16817767918109894,
0.8336540460586548,
0.16592739522457123,
-0.8421960473060608,
0.8854430317878723,
-0.07301826775074005,
0.6940807104110718,
-0.33141249418258667,
-0.14666679501533508,
-0.3887723684310913,
0.032780274748802185,
-0.29851582646369934,
-1.0216588973999023,
-0.06114207208156586,
0.20477034151554108,
0.029613357037305832,
-0.1412181705236435,
0.1301056295633316,
-0.10088524967432022,
-0.19302307069301605,
0.11477795243263245,
0.30774548649787903,
0.13346682488918304,
0.4791564643383026,
-0.6857711672782898,
-0.04394049942493439,
-0.13929319381713867,
-0.24892421066761017,
0.3759464919567108,
0.38311129808425903,
-0.18504470586776733,
0.703253984451294,
0.6480070352554321,
0.03916037082672119,
0.28923866152763367,
-0.038578301668167114,
0.7734852433204651,
-0.6461794972419739,
-0.04934738203883171,
-0.9259785413742065,
0.09806650876998901,
-0.09597481042146683,
-0.6535181999206543,
0.44700515270233154,
0.7319962382316589,
0.9503604769706726,
0.299248605966568,
0.14287546277046204,
0.2981678545475006,
0.42243751883506775,
-0.8819959163665771,
0.2423195242881775,
-0.41566094756126404,
0.3679271340370178,
0.207020103931427,
-1.0375388860702515,
-0.08930563926696777,
0.4302287995815277,
-0.3075927793979645,
0.05812700092792511,
0.5418476462364197,
0.5875291228294373,
-0.19456733763217926,
0.03356705978512764,
0.1915522962808609,
-0.07707704603672028,
0.3744509816169739,
1.0219188928604126,
1.0361850261688232,
-0.3004153370857239,
0.5500961542129517,
-0.4161231219768524,
-0.12502384185791016,
-0.23913292586803436,
-0.7837483882904053,
-0.7911403179168701,
-0.1527664214372635,
-0.11744063347578049,
-0.07585228979587555,
0.28238558769226074,
1.1915115118026733,
0.6015347242355347,
-0.6514198184013367,
-0.3242463767528534,
0.23435737192630768,
0.12358290702104568,
-0.10852067917585373,
-0.07910113036632538,
0.49236735701560974,
-0.30361849069595337,
-0.6550662517547607,
0.3848651647567749,
0.19297564029693604,
0.36341747641563416,
0.283332496881485,
-0.2778069078922272,
0.20075340569019318,
-0.13267828524112701,
0.6076878905296326,
0.43221142888069153,
-0.6755698919296265,
-0.49205660820007324,
0.13258662819862366,
-0.36822786927223206,
0.44008123874664307,
0.4134282171726227,
-0.5098230242729187,
0.1050952821969986,
0.2525599002838135,
0.6818714141845703,
0.36670249700546265,
0.0609501488506794,
0.35038071870803833,
-0.640608549118042,
-0.021460046991705894,
0.27597957849502563,
0.36135077476501465,
0.24955089390277863,
-0.37164127826690674,
0.4739895761013031,
-0.26096290349960327,
-0.8119866847991943,
-0.7730374336242676,
0.22439806163311005,
-1.0453323125839233,
0.1281767636537552,
1.1002098321914673,
-0.25716501474380493,
-0.3293962776660919,
0.23205606639385223,
-0.2200193852186203,
0.409245103597641,
-0.41621676087379456,
0.8728093504905701,
0.7705291509628296,
-0.40047046542167664,
0.08601973205804825,
-0.6085731387138367,
0.5242230296134949,
0.6442459225654602,
-0.9309983849525452,
-0.09280258417129517,
0.4979341924190521,
0.3035404682159424,
-0.014447253197431564,
0.19565553963184357,
-0.15783259272575378,
0.6354740858078003,
-0.5542438626289368,
-0.377314954996109,
-0.20733143389225006,
-0.5745964050292969,
-0.24789707362651825,
-0.0615977942943573,
0.4122908413410187,
-0.1096210852265358
] |
Subsets and Splits