id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08898v1 | UniEnc-CASSNAT: An Encoder-only Non-autoregressive ASR for Speech SSL Models | 2024-02-14T02:11:04 | 2024-02-14T02:11:04 | Ruchao Fan, Natarajan Balaji Shanka, Abeer Alwan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Non-autoregressive automatic speech recognition (NASR) models have gained
attention due to their parallelism and fast inference. The encoder-based NASR,
e.g. connectionist temporal classification (CTC), can be initialized from the
speech foundation models (SFM) but does not account for any dependencies among
intermediate tokens. The encoder-decoder-based NASR, like CTC alignment-based
single-step non-autoregressive transformer (CASS-NAT), can mitigate the
dependency problem but is not able to efficiently integrate SFM. Inspired by
the success of recent work of speech-text joint pre-training with a shared
transformer encoder, we propose a new encoder-based NASR, UniEnc-CASSNAT, to
combine the advantages of CTC and CASS-NAT. UniEnc-CASSNAT consists of only an
encoder as the major module, which can be the SFM. The encoder plays the role
of both the CASS-NAT encoder and decoder by two forward passes. The first pass
of the encoder accepts the speech signal as input, while the concatenation of
the speech signal and the token-level acoustic embedding is used as the input
for the second pass. Examined on the Librispeech 100h, MyST, and Aishell1
datasets, the proposed UniEnc-CASSNAT achieves state-of-the-art NASR results
and is better or comparable to CASS-NAT with only an encoder and hence, fewer
model parameters. Our codes are publicly available. | [
-0.40446019172668457,
-0.3423321843147278,
-0.04523368924856186,
0.2502377927303314,
-0.4066268801689148,
0.2750023901462555,
-0.21547485888004303,
-0.3370169401168823,
0.4584406316280365,
0.47716739773750305,
-0.3343924283981323,
-0.3520865738391876,
-0.5318626165390015,
0.2503660321235657,
-0.788023054599762,
0.6659079790115356,
0.1931774914264679,
0.30410000681877136,
0.07588257640600204,
-0.20241980254650116,
-0.08921970427036285,
-0.6246767640113831,
-0.571374237537384,
-0.21169458329677582,
0.06680266559123993,
0.3165050745010376,
0.40039488673210144,
0.32694342732429504,
0.4020380973815918,
0.3119436502456665,
-0.3059857189655304,
0.08389125764369965,
-0.03043370507657528,
0.13014620542526245,
0.003694877726957202,
-0.24448221921920776,
-0.34687691926956177,
-0.31442952156066895,
0.9727075099945068,
0.5207513570785522,
-0.2122727483510971,
0.13684138655662537,
0.06505588442087173,
0.6969749927520752,
-0.7179574966430664,
0.07424838095903397,
-0.3643273115158081,
-0.033205546438694,
-0.32767924666404724,
-0.23659391701221466,
-0.6020044088363647,
-0.19235289096832275,
0.10780957341194153,
-0.3664669692516327,
0.2364054173231125,
-0.16704347729682922,
0.5555533170700073,
0.5057035684585571,
-0.5797780752182007,
0.00046611911966465414,
-0.9328384399414062,
0.5555611848831177,
-0.6158760190010071,
0.8988533616065979,
0.15788863599300385,
0.5361226201057434,
-0.09650357067584991,
-0.5027247071266174,
-0.45067036151885986,
-0.10059741884469986,
-0.04844353348016739,
0.2682896852493286,
-0.38561198115348816,
0.09730623662471771,
-0.11547654867172241,
0.32354310154914856,
-0.8854982852935791,
0.08976094424724579,
-0.33356791734695435,
-0.17108549177646637,
0.554100513458252,
-0.08496683090925217,
0.016342824324965477,
0.0518583282828331,
-0.5573175549507141,
-0.11257503181695938,
-0.577207088470459,
-0.06200709566473961,
-0.004951075185090303,
0.5472176671028137,
-0.37983962893486023,
0.25431588292121887,
-0.2637116014957428,
0.6656674742698669,
0.3591383993625641,
0.19587695598602295,
0.32948482036590576,
-0.2765212059020996,
-0.16372281312942505,
0.6953024864196777,
1.072202444076538,
-0.298101544380188,
0.21675615012645721,
-0.28055718541145325,
-0.24994900822639465,
0.2834746241569519,
-0.07653392106294632,
-0.6468779444694519,
-0.3566586375236511,
-0.14744678139686584,
-0.4594576954841614,
-0.11280709505081177,
0.17656490206718445,
-0.6252325177192688,
0.035755790770053864,
-0.30730006098747253,
0.3433528542518616,
-0.09363899379968643,
-0.31680312752723694,
0.01186829898506403,
0.22814908623695374,
0.3579130470752716,
0.08416251838207245,
-0.4714246690273285,
0.7821749448776245,
0.20672650635242462,
0.9260260462760925,
-0.38850221037864685,
0.05744173005223274,
-0.6868377327919006,
-0.08515246212482452,
-0.157826766371727,
0.6730239987373352,
-0.41550058126449585,
-0.5129902362823486,
-0.3505929410457611,
0.13442447781562805,
-0.219986692070961,
-0.16028589010238647,
0.3943229913711548,
-0.7332985997200012,
0.05159207805991173,
-0.047419626265764236,
-0.6081922054290771,
-0.10110421478748322,
-0.263826459646225,
-0.8391699194908142,
0.57622891664505,
-0.29104819893836975,
-0.8598839640617371,
-0.02934085577726364,
-1.1301090717315674,
-0.3602389693260193,
0.06870945543050766,
-0.11087454110383987,
-0.3226873278617859,
-0.05225180462002754,
0.21646122634410858,
0.03885965049266815,
-0.6530469655990601,
0.47174471616744995,
-0.02826710417866707,
-0.3163885772228241,
0.5144985914230347,
-0.8765107989311218,
0.963529109954834,
0.5073663592338562,
-0.4177974760532379,
0.11243660748004913,
-0.7484558820724487,
0.07174195349216461,
0.0022570749279111624,
-0.19006648659706116,
-0.018822383135557175,
-0.2899453043937683,
0.5071865916252136,
0.35213416814804077,
0.2176227569580078,
-0.8644744753837585,
-0.42881226539611816,
-0.37257251143455505,
0.4157751500606537,
0.28404366970062256,
0.060264769941568375,
0.6251651048660278,
-0.22623610496520996,
0.23209671676158905,
0.08676543086767197,
0.17634983360767365,
0.14693452417850494,
-0.24083711206912994,
-0.8750254511833191,
-0.2082318514585495,
0.7389891147613525,
0.515550434589386,
-0.6499952673912048,
0.4012404680252075,
-0.2224513292312622,
-0.5404551029205322,
-0.4629349708557129,
-0.21880288422107697,
0.6952555179595947,
0.37315982580184937,
0.5972858667373657,
-0.38853999972343445,
-0.8635320663452148,
-0.7007473707199097,
-0.005791153758764267,
-0.22507770359516144,
0.22577746212482452,
-0.07679367810487747,
0.2442714273929596,
0.06065211445093155,
1.0435338020324707,
0.03290620446205139,
-0.45788872241973877,
-0.45357173681259155,
0.12031447142362595,
0.07446184754371643,
0.5801265239715576,
0.2811855971813202,
-0.9349197745323181,
-0.6045140027999878,
-0.1496923565864563,
-0.40874654054641724,
-0.21242232620716095,
-0.037512339651584625,
0.2495204657316208,
0.4198879897594452,
0.489869087934494,
-0.26197704672813416,
0.7180300951004028,
0.5158230662345886,
-0.22009247541427612,
0.31451091170310974,
-0.28061795234680176,
-0.04679710417985916,
-0.9366939067840576,
0.21441833674907684,
-0.2722164988517761,
-0.36700212955474854,
-1.1337624788284302,
-0.43943139910697937,
0.16447454690933228,
-0.047327082604169846,
-0.7118515372276306,
0.5821047425270081,
-0.43466633558273315,
-0.3438839614391327,
-0.5087578296661377,
-0.10246504843235016,
-0.12829287350177765,
0.353299081325531,
0.587620198726654,
0.9115860462188721,
0.4834838807582855,
-0.8229345679283142,
0.07554472982883453,
0.5860517621040344,
0.01771163009107113,
0.2861486077308655,
-0.7014361023902893,
0.14598241448402405,
-0.1264428347349167,
0.3817136287689209,
-0.5187830924987793,
0.29330354928970337,
-0.07555444538593292,
-0.7750957608222961,
0.4126250743865967,
-0.0327136293053627,
-0.5165509581565857,
-0.271010160446167,
0.22247853875160217,
0.5112387537956238,
0.44029027223587036,
-0.7685221433639526,
0.724936842918396,
0.3927645683288574,
0.13137640058994293,
-0.406699001789093,
-1.029945969581604,
-0.00017516962543595582,
0.013960286043584347,
-0.39209917187690735,
0.4055083096027374,
-0.10214758664369583,
0.0647742822766304,
0.024462712928652763,
-0.10162806510925293,
-0.39428195357322693,
-0.18702463805675507,
0.2777824401855469,
0.2808712124824524,
-0.40750664472579956,
-0.04665405675768852,
-0.09089473634958267,
-0.5485320687294006,
-0.2695106565952301,
-0.4149949550628662,
0.42079710960388184,
-0.5084802508354187,
-0.4136340618133545,
-0.8937863707542419,
0.4855724573135376,
0.5079057812690735,
-0.5741451978683472,
0.4312728941440582,
0.4656694233417511,
-0.2333281934261322,
0.09972476214170456,
-0.6979753971099854,
-0.3505629003047943,
-0.4786364734172821,
0.03355439379811287,
-0.1783868819475174,
-0.9254666566848755,
0.31691601872444153,
0.15844953060150146,
0.08944126218557358,
0.28456148505210876,
0.39882683753967285,
0.13583463430404663,
0.6313265562057495,
0.4853511452674866,
-0.13326989114284515,
0.38134217262268066,
-0.234803706407547,
-0.00912631954997778,
-0.9809797406196594,
-0.12479516863822937,
-0.33765900135040283,
-0.3065677881240845,
-0.5847464799880981,
-0.23856671154499054,
0.2507146894931793,
-0.3160460591316223,
-0.47146621346473694,
0.6077892780303955,
-0.5424773097038269,
0.4126284122467041,
0.5288451313972473,
-0.2874998450279236,
0.41662541031837463,
-0.15946173667907715,
-0.2375577837228775,
0.018362047150731087,
-0.7871176600456238,
-0.23190726339817047,
0.9860150814056396,
0.0072767892852425575,
0.7085890173912048,
0.1893693506717682,
0.7807682156562805,
0.2769777476787567,
-0.16380156576633453,
-0.3393753170967102,
0.5869255661964417,
-0.7810336351394653,
-0.6004688143730164,
-0.14451254904270172,
-0.4617263078689575,
-0.7956794500350952,
0.23118340969085693,
-0.1179283857345581,
-0.6354237198829651,
0.7530257105827332,
0.19597241282463074,
-0.4436188042163849,
0.5737336277961731,
-0.20858781039714813,
0.5654278993606567,
-0.4112818241119385,
-0.09751871973276138,
0.28407034277915955,
-0.9627828001976013,
0.009254657663404942,
-0.027224762365221977,
0.018116828054189682,
0.08584041148424149,
0.24043028056621552,
0.9057353734970093,
-0.43224796652793884,
0.6929248571395874,
-0.49351269006729126,
0.42788851261138916,
0.5033506751060486,
0.12222860008478165,
0.3601101338863373,
-0.1831606924533844,
-0.035751912742853165,
0.27167782187461853,
0.07632561028003693,
0.07099193334579468,
-0.542603611946106,
0.5297946929931641,
-0.8276142477989197,
-0.18370674550533295,
-0.4915464222431183,
-0.18094640970230103,
-0.29379239678382874,
0.09693309664726257,
0.40963321924209595,
0.6656181812286377,
-0.3293203115463257,
0.4038420021533966,
0.6173578500747681,
0.1320757269859314,
0.6736968159675598,
0.8672996163368225,
0.019664769992232323,
-0.6493997573852539,
0.8859705328941345,
-0.1029757559299469,
0.4635002911090851,
0.5275608897209167,
0.15310046076774597,
-0.5524904131889343,
-0.3462282717227936,
-0.32289862632751465,
0.2333594560623169,
-0.4759480655193329,
-0.4586302638053894,
-0.7839696407318115,
-0.8608173727989197,
-0.1697942465543747,
-0.2137911319732666,
-0.9472196698188782,
-0.5419023633003235,
-0.6192604303359985,
0.1824752390384674,
0.5021466016769409,
0.4112596809864044,
-0.5739872455596924,
0.525041401386261,
-0.7291538119316101,
0.20594632625579834,
0.10807766020298004,
-0.08947410434484482,
-0.06250380724668503,
-0.6799110770225525,
0.06563328206539154,
0.20863129198551178,
0.07573910057544708,
-0.7019190788269043,
0.7376355528831482,
0.5284892916679382,
0.27319249510765076,
0.45465347170829773,
0.45536044239997864,
0.696523129940033,
-0.3117820620536804,
0.4070814549922943,
0.4034211039543152,
-0.9490806460380554,
0.4380980134010315,
0.16700616478919983,
0.486939936876297,
0.7808768153190613,
-0.043212126940488815,
-0.5681259632110596,
-0.2417047768831253,
-0.390727698802948,
-0.5255743861198425,
0.8495686650276184,
0.49097856879234314,
-0.43499118089675903,
0.08378662168979645,
0.01152270007878542,
-0.0699140802025795,
-0.06984778493642807,
-0.36651626229286194,
-0.44856196641921997,
-0.7059359550476074,
-0.20485791563987732,
-0.027556786313652992,
-0.10406282544136047,
0.43239930272102356,
-0.08596540242433548,
0.7138387560844421,
0.02313544787466526,
0.5562807321548462,
0.4287447929382324,
-0.39680400490760803,
0.10576844960451126,
0.5680744647979736,
0.39183154702186584,
-0.1018160805106163,
-0.1588807851076126,
0.2394644021987915,
0.3471502363681793,
-0.45689132809638977,
0.39582136273384094,
0.1806049793958664,
-0.3025904595851898,
0.317771315574646,
-0.0996231883764267,
0.9136900901794434,
0.6178706288337708,
-0.2709205150604248,
0.7161559462547302,
-0.40417829155921936,
-0.28009822964668274,
-0.771837055683136,
-0.15643353760242462,
-0.06699956208467484,
0.2531123459339142,
0.17183518409729004,
0.05930911749601364,
0.29314854741096497,
0.07157982140779495,
0.4840320348739624,
0.4155426323413849,
-0.6563135385513306,
-0.46856364607810974,
0.6930151581764221,
0.12563550472259521,
-0.2395709902048111,
0.6282646656036377,
-0.2703651189804077,
-0.5455551147460938,
0.4826180934906006,
0.969357430934906,
1.0363587141036987,
-0.7258169054985046,
0.19294092059135437,
0.43609148263931274,
0.09424076229333878,
-0.0057442220859229565,
0.49313580989837646,
-0.35765600204467773,
-0.6011285185813904,
-0.2978878915309906,
-0.7549273371696472,
-0.3391585350036621,
-0.07959634810686111,
-0.9919661283493042,
0.23564742505550385,
-0.33434176445007324,
-0.11662580072879791,
-0.2914274036884308,
-0.16423651576042175,
-0.6829415559768677,
0.08134547621011734,
0.10162793099880219,
0.7990109324455261,
-0.6680764555931091,
1.1098674535751343,
0.32556188106536865,
-0.10805127024650574,
-0.554307222366333,
-0.2298763394355774,
0.24627000093460083,
-0.43676725029945374,
0.8527487516403198,
0.05562405288219452,
-0.4429283142089844,
0.1438913345336914,
-0.0038370718248188496,
-1.3683193922042847,
1.0649631023406982,
0.1800229251384735,
-0.7248407602310181,
-0.21555238962173462,
0.3704400360584259,
0.43586406111717224,
-0.45623865723609924,
0.16113455593585968,
0.42825236916542053,
0.4039095938205719,
0.503113865852356,
-1.3293696641921997,
-0.07376190274953842,
-0.31745073199272156,
0.14470145106315613,
0.25114578008651733,
-0.643017590045929,
0.7078342437744141,
-0.04945475235581398,
-0.573914110660553,
0.18163403868675232,
0.7390386462211609,
0.12478641420602798,
0.050406310707330704,
0.541395366191864,
0.2245524525642395,
0.4805980622768402,
0.03714151307940483,
0.36653271317481995,
-0.43627429008483887,
0.10260962694883347,
1.5408774614334106,
-0.19041191041469574,
1.0047014951705933,
0.1785731166601181,
0.023888137191534042,
0.3875978887081146,
0.13173431158065796,
0.015410514548420906,
0.8441648483276367,
-0.08927923440933228,
-0.43789446353912354,
-0.347380667924881,
-0.1757207214832306,
-0.4266276955604553,
0.9612411856651306,
0.38450831174850464,
-0.2599373161792755,
-0.36512991786003113,
0.135781928896904,
-0.22441540658473969,
-0.16873833537101746,
-0.2117961198091507,
0.987698495388031,
0.32829204201698303,
0.029906153678894043,
0.6091358065605164,
-0.08741655200719833,
0.8215327262878418,
-0.6508606672286987,
0.2963526248931885,
0.1341821849346161,
0.10326976329088211,
-0.17771834135055542,
-0.21243330836296082,
0.6825361251831055,
0.18450532853603363,
0.006452690344303846,
-0.061793964356184006,
0.7701884508132935,
-0.5788938403129578,
-0.40298938751220703,
0.4205490052700043,
0.4222865700721741,
0.21518313884735107,
0.05016614869236946,
-0.545525074005127,
0.09768418222665787,
-0.21409812569618225,
0.2263931930065155,
0.09798812866210938,
0.059124063700437546,
0.09033625572919846,
0.48332348465919495,
0.8517032861709595,
0.010895004495978355,
0.068658746778965,
0.1506813019514084,
0.5836416482925415,
-0.6265652775764465,
-0.7490817308425903,
-0.5750073790550232,
0.30209818482398987,
0.18539094924926758,
-0.05952933803200722,
0.5061956644058228,
0.5608713626861572,
0.3645745813846588,
0.19545716047286987,
0.5059742331504822,
0.2221459597349167,
0.5537465214729309,
-0.33636847138404846,
1.0433958768844604,
-0.4122006893157959,
-0.04678674414753914,
-0.090275838971138,
-0.6564053297042847,
-0.5126965045928955,
0.6588980555534363,
-0.042477089911699295,
-0.08060985058546066,
0.5946517586708069,
0.6680617332458496,
0.06645572185516357,
0.6836879849433899,
0.416810005903244,
0.05136552080512047,
0.231826514005661,
0.6972966194152832,
0.6237921714782715,
-0.430451363325119,
0.5306078195571899,
-0.2616906464099884,
-0.10996366292238235,
-0.18299654126167297,
-0.5491883754730225,
-0.7389038801193237,
-0.8980766534805298,
-0.3615726828575134,
0.04962724819779396,
0.27647385001182556,
1.0961567163467407,
0.6204056143760681,
-1.1027506589889526,
-0.2817869782447815,
-0.3534924387931824,
-0.36551082134246826,
0.014789219945669174,
-0.16258789598941803,
0.4847949743270874,
-0.05100807547569275,
-0.26039522886276245,
0.8116294145584106,
0.20984403789043427,
0.3862672448158264,
-0.18000589311122894,
-0.3503057360649109,
-0.2889704704284668,
0.09505734592676163,
0.21121272444725037,
0.5669493675231934,
-0.6955553293228149,
0.09724481403827667,
0.166092649102211,
0.3475148379802704,
0.26821568608283997,
0.6631988883018494,
-0.9551228284835815,
0.5350351929664612,
0.2705610394477844,
0.6075315475463867,
0.6247065663337708,
-0.2187289446592331,
0.37782853841781616,
-0.4485291838645935,
0.07404828071594238,
0.39837977290153503,
0.4606913626194,
0.4444379210472107,
-0.0672878846526146,
0.16588853299617767,
-0.0923624336719513,
-0.4934956133365631,
-0.5962887406349182,
0.17470422387123108,
-0.7949880361557007,
0.1890738308429718,
0.9596332907676697,
-0.0325327143073082,
-0.4016638994216919,
-0.37642985582351685,
0.2973722219467163,
0.4650728404521942,
-0.7056114077568054,
0.22283335030078888,
0.1127668246626854,
-0.16359423100948334,
-0.12564770877361298,
-0.12480851262807846,
0.2753843665122986,
0.1980079710483551,
-0.5970925092697144,
0.20865090191364288,
0.17746178805828094,
0.2422580122947693,
0.13040150701999664,
0.6021501421928406,
-0.5269446969032288,
0.4425606429576874,
-0.032725248485803604,
0.19617117941379547,
-0.3768763840198517,
-0.6063076853752136,
-0.5847693681716919,
-0.11522558331489563,
-0.2195388525724411,
-0.4299054741859436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08874v1 | Tree-Based Hard Attention with Self-Motivation for Large Language Models | 2024-02-14T00:40:51 | 2024-02-14T00:40:51 | Chenxi Lin, Jiayu Ren, Guoxiu He, Zhuoren Jiang, Haiyan Yu, Xiaomin Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) excel at understanding and generating
plain text, they are not specifically tailored to handle hierarchical text
structures. Extracting the task-desired property from their natural language
responses typically necessitates additional processing steps. In fact,
selectively comprehending the hierarchical structure of large-scale text is
pivotal to understanding its substance. Aligning LLMs more closely with the
classification or regression values of specific task through prompting also
remains challenging. To this end, we propose a novel framework called
Tree-Based Hard Attention with Self-Motivation for Large Language Models
(TEAROOM). TEAROOM incorporates a tree-based hard attention mechanism for LLMs
to process hierarchically structured text inputs. By leveraging prompting, it
enables a frozen LLM to selectively focus on relevant leaves in relation to the
root, generating a tailored symbolic representation of their relationship.
Moreover, TEAROOM comprises a self-motivation strategy for another LLM equipped
with a trainable adapter and a linear layer. The selected symbolic outcomes are
integrated into another prompt, along with the predictive value of the task. We
iteratively feed output values back into the prompt, enabling the trainable LLM
to progressively approximate the golden truth. TEAROOM outperforms existing
state-of-the-art methods in experimental evaluations across three benchmark
datasets, showing its effectiveness in estimating task-specific properties.
Through comprehensive experiments and analysis, we have validated the ability
of TEAROOM to gradually approach the underlying golden truth through multiple
inferences. | [
0.261299192905426,
-0.7436394691467285,
0.7916019558906555,
0.4612271785736084,
-0.07304616272449493,
0.06755173951387405,
-0.333374559879303,
-0.11886899173259735,
0.08616922795772552,
0.5483356714248657,
-0.9133068323135376,
-0.4853872060775757,
-0.2299787551164627,
0.11313720792531967,
-0.1796908676624298,
1.1691052913665771,
-0.18446515500545502,
-0.521400511264801,
-0.24761110544204712,
-0.09660334885120392,
-0.5524802207946777,
-0.6160135865211487,
-0.33817172050476074,
-0.36678922176361084,
0.8513624668121338,
0.3601127862930298,
0.372431218624115,
0.7886306643486023,
0.45058929920196533,
0.31140783429145813,
-0.0634206160902977,
-0.0903155505657196,
-0.46101105213165283,
0.4525824785232544,
-0.3359522819519043,
-0.5188857913017273,
-0.3127474784851074,
0.057492174208164215,
0.40113919973373413,
0.41777560114860535,
-0.16997069120407104,
0.4114055931568146,
0.3626607060432434,
0.8062847852706909,
-0.7844073176383972,
0.5045338869094849,
-0.6812872886657715,
0.22859561443328857,
-0.18824879825115204,
-0.4243697226047516,
-0.558864176273346,
-0.07377597689628601,
0.013934032060205936,
-0.31675493717193604,
0.34486308693885803,
-0.1108516976237297,
0.6946125030517578,
0.5989450216293335,
-0.34938016533851624,
-0.290892094373703,
-0.5874260663986206,
0.83030104637146,
-0.4576452672481537,
0.3212856352329254,
0.43633344769477844,
0.06749818474054337,
0.06033185124397278,
-0.35618770122528076,
-0.19485725462436676,
-0.4293089509010315,
-0.06465601176023483,
0.19249600172042847,
-0.007523315027356148,
0.2159138023853302,
0.13240888714790344,
0.42015570402145386,
-0.46335113048553467,
0.10081404447555542,
0.042856812477111816,
-0.028747573494911194,
0.34829506278038025,
0.2569473683834076,
0.3063090741634369,
-0.44570648670196533,
-0.2766934037208557,
-0.06494298577308655,
-0.42951107025146484,
0.2525406777858734,
-0.15374904870986938,
0.5243618488311768,
0.05370516702532768,
0.5226960778236389,
-0.3191789388656616,
0.4715573787689209,
0.5292897820472717,
-0.3579637408256531,
0.09495677798986435,
-0.09024817496538162,
-0.31978699564933777,
0.2478780895471573,
0.7941980361938477,
0.1937398612499237,
0.2543804943561554,
-0.24429906904697418,
-0.3455904424190521,
0.08593947440385818,
0.14338546991348267,
-0.8773901462554932,
-0.13589592278003693,
0.4692147672176361,
-0.3565855026245117,
-0.45864152908325195,
-0.6237416863441467,
-0.6120198369026184,
-0.19688859581947327,
-0.39046549797058105,
0.3098985552787781,
-0.39093342423439026,
-0.29920506477355957,
-0.02325497195124626,
0.3593926727771759,
0.04450793191790581,
0.3832171857357025,
-1.2762207984924316,
0.17032425105571747,
0.7612540125846863,
1.0508010387420654,
-0.3023765981197357,
-0.40392667055130005,
-0.8414801359176636,
0.3833663761615753,
-0.3036265969276428,
0.7059577703475952,
-0.522020161151886,
0.27659305930137634,
0.04250381514430046,
-0.10942777246236801,
-0.33317703008651733,
-0.45447802543640137,
0.4474198520183563,
-0.5614560842514038,
0.4311351478099823,
-0.0168010164052248,
-0.349052369594574,
-0.2671205401420593,
0.6088016033172607,
-0.5557438135147095,
1.066965937614441,
0.09126076102256775,
-0.788368821144104,
0.1112535297870636,
-0.6868062615394592,
-0.4050503969192505,
0.17006024718284607,
-0.13762515783309937,
-0.2765449583530426,
0.33235761523246765,
0.31874364614486694,
0.5332674384117126,
-0.3226836025714874,
0.5741924047470093,
-0.31254300475120544,
-0.004341502208262682,
-0.040889255702495575,
-0.5133475661277771,
0.711894154548645,
0.05024829879403114,
-0.595272958278656,
0.3903265595436096,
-0.34745997190475464,
0.1372162252664566,
0.31772175431251526,
-0.4851106107234955,
-0.39173367619514465,
0.1482546180486679,
-0.0563894547522068,
0.3052847385406494,
0.4424082040786743,
-0.35808444023132324,
0.35337063670158386,
-0.533319354057312,
0.334763765335083,
0.901861846446991,
-0.1702849417924881,
0.14400653541088104,
0.08211427927017212,
0.7253915071487427,
-0.10969328880310059,
0.07268992811441422,
-0.4103188216686249,
0.17886732518672943,
-0.5562027096748352,
-0.394024521112442,
0.3430529534816742,
0.4154391884803772,
-0.4001500606536865,
0.39708036184310913,
-0.14091180264949799,
-0.09588772803544998,
-0.7024024724960327,
0.4546014368534088,
0.5006082057952881,
0.3277662396430969,
0.21061356365680695,
-0.18997251987457275,
-0.32773709297180176,
-0.7240534424781799,
-0.13715828955173492,
-0.33420294523239136,
0.08880678564310074,
0.44532620906829834,
0.35787472128868103,
-0.06215569004416466,
0.9657108783721924,
-0.5876498818397522,
-0.8132668733596802,
-0.450855016708374,
0.11730460077524185,
0.4388083517551422,
0.17376457154750824,
0.2287391573190689,
-0.5414310693740845,
-0.5442438721656799,
0.006960806902498007,
-0.6589599251747131,
-0.2652158737182617,
-0.19584938883781433,
0.005274489987641573,
0.28639933466911316,
0.34890905022621155,
-0.7449458241462708,
0.0026014705654233694,
0.6863272190093994,
-0.36305850744247437,
0.562608540058136,
-0.05388282239437103,
0.04795568063855171,
-0.8497982025146484,
0.08839946985244751,
0.019491037353873253,
-0.29784032702445984,
-0.4752301871776581,
0.21007131040096283,
0.17322784662246704,
0.21957933902740479,
-0.3965488076210022,
0.5520137548446655,
-0.5147896409034729,
0.04357880353927612,
-0.4538346230983734,
0.012199916876852512,
-0.11841104179620743,
1.0091321468353271,
0.16145694255828857,
0.5126744508743286,
0.504439651966095,
-0.49735867977142334,
0.2885414958000183,
0.0821244865655899,
-0.13057060539722443,
0.5262627005577087,
-0.707998514175415,
0.2310505360364914,
-0.04486656188964844,
0.20702381432056427,
-0.9605512022972107,
-0.30412957072257996,
0.14640386402606964,
-0.24445368349552155,
0.19672323763370514,
-0.3691495358943939,
-0.6898391842842102,
-0.39946436882019043,
-0.3579595685005188,
0.40260013937950134,
0.38496291637420654,
-0.6637110114097595,
0.7867211103439331,
0.20017968118190765,
-0.1550547033548355,
-0.3502664864063263,
-0.38594791293144226,
0.1525060087442398,
-0.32787999510765076,
-0.31162014603614807,
0.2523859441280365,
-0.212416872382164,
0.012726298533380032,
-0.05818646773695946,
-0.24766044318675995,
0.06751957535743713,
0.1655726432800293,
0.39008039236068726,
0.2490357756614685,
-0.3817107081413269,
0.2237481027841568,
-0.16316725313663483,
-0.14912134408950806,
0.3440704345703125,
-0.34435445070266724,
0.6201572418212891,
-0.16724850237369537,
-0.2985803186893463,
-0.557599663734436,
0.17889782786369324,
0.6970534324645996,
-0.4825453460216522,
0.4006095826625824,
0.3203014135360718,
-0.23024027049541473,
-0.3164728879928589,
-0.6074850559234619,
-0.26430195569992065,
-0.5209489464759827,
0.42169466614723206,
-0.44682776927948,
-1.0367181301116943,
0.031110621988773346,
-0.0016785432817414403,
0.1918257474899292,
0.29301249980926514,
0.7410411238670349,
-0.13758113980293274,
1.4900872707366943,
0.6472744345664978,
-0.38856086134910583,
0.3720996379852295,
0.059008050709962845,
-0.01324959471821785,
-0.8739887475967407,
-0.07271962612867355,
-0.5034381151199341,
-0.22047318518161774,
-0.3097817301750183,
-0.28301265835762024,
0.02628994546830654,
0.025430958718061447,
-0.1720006763935089,
-0.03387804329395294,
-0.8241854906082153,
0.6230927109718323,
0.5879870057106018,
-0.01482432521879673,
0.27345964312553406,
0.024609288200736046,
-0.0054825604893267155,
-0.09434129297733307,
-0.6934322118759155,
-0.39852452278137207,
0.5805326700210571,
0.5715723633766174,
0.8149201273918152,
-0.07840798050165176,
0.8106598854064941,
0.10944520682096481,
0.5493550896644592,
-1.0743091106414795,
0.6387913823127747,
-0.1133139356970787,
-0.6592198610305786,
-0.3372642993927002,
-0.436583012342453,
-1.041111707687378,
0.3580637574195862,
0.3127492368221283,
-0.813888430595398,
-0.32488930225372314,
0.37066325545310974,
-0.3725522458553314,
0.0720345750451088,
-0.6815265417098999,
1.1445788145065308,
-0.5825456976890564,
-0.4478224813938141,
-0.1839393824338913,
-0.3426198959350586,
0.4507935047149658,
-0.06965377181768417,
0.20207054913043976,
-0.26429206132888794,
0.041097529232501984,
0.811098575592041,
-0.16613975167274475,
1.288691759109497,
-0.18678931891918182,
-0.2700040936470032,
0.24944999814033508,
0.44249245524406433,
0.6737670302391052,
-0.4271560609340668,
0.22013671696186066,
-0.3316532075405121,
-0.05900802090764046,
-0.13193407654762268,
-0.6044668555259705,
0.7984981536865234,
-0.5665144920349121,
-1.0361078977584839,
-0.5090227723121643,
-0.671301007270813,
-0.23649439215660095,
0.27790603041648865,
-0.3011445999145508,
0.20282778143882751,
0.03825083374977112,
0.13646043837070465,
0.5355669260025024,
0.16200630366802216,
0.4873792827129364,
0.5370778441429138,
-0.533870279788971,
-0.28745269775390625,
0.982119619846344,
-0.04087256267666817,
0.21550244092941284,
0.41554197669029236,
0.508895754814148,
-0.4075981080532074,
-0.41796422004699707,
-0.35244062542915344,
0.396197646856308,
-0.4742738604545593,
-0.30919840931892395,
-0.9116133451461792,
-0.17257945239543915,
-0.2195289582014084,
-0.03186490386724472,
-0.3239348232746124,
-0.12687630951404572,
-0.27909016609191895,
-0.10248082131147385,
0.423825204372406,
0.7419068217277527,
0.16015270352363586,
0.0975584164261818,
-0.779164731502533,
0.3396071791648865,
0.5596664547920227,
0.4301372170448303,
0.19394372403621674,
-0.5662072896957397,
-0.14639605581760406,
-0.17312268912792206,
-0.3654097616672516,
-0.897818386554718,
0.4285856783390045,
0.07353555411100388,
0.2001197785139084,
0.33368048071861267,
0.0768776386976242,
0.6629872918128967,
-0.6123251914978027,
0.4228646457195282,
0.32500943541526794,
-0.9834505319595337,
0.8666878342628479,
-0.3125399947166443,
0.6435533761978149,
0.7274296879768372,
0.2513480484485626,
-0.5811315774917603,
-0.6110638976097107,
-0.529174268245697,
-0.7122923135757446,
1.1112544536590576,
0.08833366632461548,
0.23496802151203156,
0.13292723894119263,
0.23017925024032593,
-0.15812095999717712,
0.064836286008358,
-1.1856632232666016,
0.030347995460033417,
0.03368160501122475,
-0.6376172304153442,
0.09356170892715454,
-0.3263189196586609,
0.01383457612246275,
0.04868367686867714,
0.5946955680847168,
-0.40403610467910767,
-0.25297921895980835,
0.19838537275791168,
-0.07131487131118774,
-0.4316595196723938,
0.2322969138622284,
-0.0026415004394948483,
0.2002839893102646,
-0.26855161786079407,
0.41915276646614075,
0.09774847328662872,
-0.3399336636066437,
0.30010733008384705,
-0.03936164826154709,
-0.31334710121154785,
-0.12477961927652359,
0.5294734835624695,
0.7065028548240662,
0.19893476366996765,
-0.6470692753791809,
0.449235200881958,
0.18084709346294403,
-0.17594052851200104,
0.21692490577697754,
0.23473402857780457,
0.22279013693332672,
0.2483578473329544,
0.35265660285949707,
-0.3586246073246002,
0.2105013132095337,
-0.5913717746734619,
-0.04019686207175255,
0.49845004081726074,
-0.6860442757606506,
-0.45377764105796814,
0.5434613823890686,
0.20916371047496796,
-0.5348794460296631,
0.4051452577114105,
-0.08830343931913376,
-0.8781453967094421,
0.5106943845748901,
0.6353499293327332,
1.1718661785125732,
-0.47167807817459106,
0.39767155051231384,
0.44965389370918274,
0.1795485019683838,
0.08138416707515717,
-0.09426693618297577,
-0.42995280027389526,
-0.3430447578430176,
-0.8011651039123535,
-0.7977054715156555,
-0.29463717341423035,
0.3133123517036438,
-0.3232535421848297,
-0.0011733490973711014,
-0.3414291441440582,
0.027094781398773193,
-0.004815869964659214,
-0.03943302482366562,
-0.39309102296829224,
0.3308267593383789,
0.19500301778316498,
0.6203511357307434,
-0.677949070930481,
0.5952371954917908,
0.4728260636329651,
-0.3290143311023712,
-1.0500470399856567,
0.31918302178382874,
0.018597232177853584,
-0.8551552891731262,
0.8594959378242493,
0.6119595766067505,
-0.18394580483436584,
0.0663226768374443,
-0.6422560811042786,
-1.0635077953338623,
0.7260500192642212,
0.31536608934402466,
-0.7508628368377686,
-0.2513731122016907,
0.0854218602180481,
0.5263960361480713,
-0.3526810109615326,
0.16746866703033447,
0.4060482382774353,
0.32243338227272034,
0.4261700212955475,
-0.7646703720092773,
0.32282593846321106,
-0.07269640266895294,
-0.13136141002178192,
0.3832670748233795,
-0.7119604349136353,
0.2683790922164917,
-0.4111476540565491,
-0.3935892879962921,
-0.39972883462905884,
0.7370909452438354,
0.6003106832504272,
0.21117985248565674,
0.9133342504501343,
0.38197895884513855,
0.5232603549957275,
0.22049851715564728,
0.8833840489387512,
-0.2811184525489807,
0.4744299352169037,
1.3360260725021362,
-0.41196417808532715,
0.8578619956970215,
0.5091449022293091,
-0.1943286657333374,
0.4641279876232147,
0.6913022398948669,
0.18436092138290405,
0.6733563542366028,
0.18921473622322083,
-0.13248512148857117,
-0.3706018030643463,
-0.32583561539649963,
-0.07439035177230835,
0.35125139355659485,
0.06147519871592522,
-0.24810901284217834,
-0.2616141438484192,
-0.1218910813331604,
0.11772998422384262,
-0.17277884483337402,
-0.3498455286026001,
0.9470785856246948,
0.018580175936222076,
-1.2009292840957642,
0.5931144952774048,
-0.1484796553850174,
0.44037938117980957,
-0.5368940830230713,
0.06360558420419693,
-0.07375937700271606,
0.31821686029434204,
-0.18363983929157257,
-0.7994080781936646,
0.019991271197795868,
0.2784579396247864,
-0.20902186632156372,
-0.48453012108802795,
0.562243640422821,
-0.6031537055969238,
-0.5630871653556824,
0.26119548082351685,
0.3946589231491089,
-0.037422046065330505,
-0.4659678041934967,
-0.8438419103622437,
-0.0279287938028574,
0.2856082320213318,
-0.6323240995407104,
0.24642185866832733,
0.8554095029830933,
0.09618193656206131,
0.6383973360061646,
0.6101201772689819,
-0.07654471695423126,
-0.33700916171073914,
0.27135127782821655,
0.8226360082626343,
-0.8108968138694763,
-0.4946863055229187,
-1.1244714260101318,
0.39149442315101624,
0.28619906306266785,
-0.24307382106781006,
0.652614176273346,
0.47291380167007446,
0.2958141267299652,
0.0065082283690571785,
0.5262476205825806,
0.17451521754264832,
0.34255149960517883,
-0.4919321537017822,
0.3112914562225342,
-0.7488709688186646,
0.03911122307181358,
-0.25876328349113464,
-0.9221398830413818,
-0.2564302384853363,
0.45407405495643616,
-0.3689400851726532,
0.09237653017044067,
0.8239676356315613,
0.6206567287445068,
0.005441977642476559,
-0.12830181419849396,
0.13530918955802917,
0.44621169567108154,
0.31219756603240967,
0.8266451954841614,
0.9793488383293152,
0.2294110357761383,
0.6532084941864014,
-0.10437468439340591,
-0.4940376877784729,
-0.36371248960494995,
-0.8749691843986511,
-0.9589105248451233,
-0.580807089805603,
-0.5805065631866455,
-0.35194745659828186,
0.023265883326530457,
1.0609045028686523,
0.6968225836753845,
-0.7281014919281006,
-0.23515567183494568,
-0.2208053171634674,
0.15329106152057648,
-0.1581745594739914,
-0.295250803232193,
0.6518051028251648,
-0.7923506498336792,
-0.5702674984931946,
0.13767006993293762,
0.6976723670959473,
-0.13448171317577362,
-0.48809659481048584,
0.06961439549922943,
-0.12112664431333542,
0.06562935560941696,
0.7172611355781555,
0.10568457841873169,
-0.8186803460121155,
-0.18789449334144592,
0.13316431641578674,
-0.43459588289260864,
0.27852141857147217,
0.7555800080299377,
-0.9080449938774109,
0.15146733820438385,
0.18958163261413574,
0.6307883262634277,
0.650837242603302,
-0.06717272847890854,
0.28313934803009033,
-0.49653390049934387,
-0.3713074326515198,
0.45473238825798035,
0.1637984812259674,
0.3583211898803711,
-0.5352523922920227,
0.5198748707771301,
-0.002655605087056756,
-0.540294885635376,
-0.7864201664924622,
0.06156584620475769,
-0.8806073069572449,
-0.375604510307312,
1.2885215282440186,
0.06276314705610275,
-0.8101457953453064,
0.04974089190363884,
-0.5410027503967285,
-0.10021071135997772,
-0.3861575126647949,
1.1021497249603271,
0.6995596885681152,
-0.04318235442042351,
-0.30552780628204346,
-0.25724855065345764,
0.4558412432670593,
0.9546278119087219,
-0.9286085367202759,
0.7948007583618164,
0.6102980971336365,
0.12824316322803497,
0.3426398038864136,
0.803820013999939,
0.13493408262729645,
0.18782542645931244,
-0.6281777024269104,
0.13297446072101593,
0.13385604321956635,
-0.49093419313430786,
-0.29244452714920044,
0.5570154786109924,
0.13483914732933044,
-0.09825754910707474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08846v1 | An Embarrassingly Simple Approach for LLM with Strong ASR Capacity | 2024-02-13T23:25:04 | 2024-02-13T23:25:04 | Ziyang Ma, Guanrou Yang, Yifan Yang, Zhifu Gao, Jiaming Wang, Zhihao Du, Fan Yu, Qian Chen, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Xie Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we focus on solving one of the most important tasks in the
field of speech processing, i.e., automatic speech recognition (ASR), with
speech foundation encoders and large language models (LLM). Recent works have
complex designs such as compressing the output temporally for the speech
encoder, tackling modal alignment for the projector, and utilizing
parameter-efficient fine-tuning for the LLM. We found that delicate designs are
not necessary, while an embarrassingly simple composition of off-the-shelf
speech encoder, LLM, and the only trainable linear projector is competent for
the ASR task. To be more specific, we benchmark and explore various
combinations of LLMs and speech encoders, leading to the optimal LLM-based ASR
system, which we call SLAM-ASR. The proposed SLAM-ASR provides a clean setup
and little task-specific design, where only the linear projector is trained. To
the best of our knowledge, SLAM-ASR achieves the best performance on the
Librispeech benchmark among LLM-based ASR models and even outperforms the
latest LLM-based audio-universal model trained on massive pair data. Finally,
we explore the capability emergence of LLM-based ASR in the process of modal
alignment. We hope that our study can facilitate the research on extending LLM
with cross-modality capacity and shed light on the LLM-based ASR community. | [
-0.24775700271129608,
-0.4148086905479431,
0.34059032797813416,
0.038525279611349106,
-0.21719492971897125,
0.11226923018693924,
-0.42179813981056213,
-0.5021020174026489,
0.11412441730499268,
0.23872072994709015,
-0.17707258462905884,
-0.23078516125679016,
-0.8151289820671082,
0.049510180950164795,
-0.556675910949707,
0.5753390192985535,
-0.16188591718673706,
0.10710960626602173,
0.0014124613953754306,
-0.3222702443599701,
-0.20336014032363892,
-0.28056299686431885,
-0.5800086259841919,
-0.5031734704971313,
0.20654787123203278,
0.3188628852367401,
0.42822057008743286,
0.8620953559875488,
0.6082677245140076,
0.24737265706062317,
-0.2645992636680603,
0.2508696913719177,
-0.47659507393836975,
-0.1310523897409439,
0.057054873555898666,
-0.0914781391620636,
-0.5623238682746887,
-0.3397041857242584,
0.7617877125740051,
0.9136461615562439,
-0.26428383588790894,
0.1976347714662552,
0.24584849178791046,
0.4186168909072876,
-0.5487642288208008,
0.09435155242681503,
-0.7087560892105103,
-0.17874912917613983,
-0.2705385684967041,
-0.20410612225532532,
-0.2354237139225006,
0.03980909287929535,
-0.0812612771987915,
-0.533301591873169,
0.013686793856322765,
0.09177686274051666,
0.6268085241317749,
0.7501900792121887,
-0.3262377381324768,
-0.5840340852737427,
-1.111959457397461,
0.6045204997062683,
-0.5246004462242126,
0.7424483895301819,
0.18296831846237183,
0.4436209499835968,
0.07398436963558197,
-0.3531542718410492,
-0.5546640157699585,
-0.09533955156803131,
0.22795100510120392,
-0.060868315398693085,
-0.21459662914276123,
0.20128624141216278,
0.3597198724746704,
0.3734578490257263,
-0.7502021193504333,
0.19510981440544128,
-0.40502166748046875,
-0.1996343731880188,
0.6103264689445496,
0.04383861646056175,
0.0659998208284378,
-0.047368790954351425,
-0.42104703187942505,
0.03831427916884422,
-0.7852527499198914,
0.1834104061126709,
0.00036325686960481107,
0.47558462619781494,
-0.1610809564590454,
0.8645419478416443,
-0.19334974884986877,
0.877199113368988,
0.03471226617693901,
-0.33955782651901245,
0.07109567523002625,
-0.23092004656791687,
-0.17727075517177582,
0.3227570354938507,
0.8479267954826355,
-0.15120036900043488,
0.2730425298213959,
-0.16888107359409332,
-0.5016005039215088,
0.3398438096046448,
0.21085184812545776,
-0.4027445316314697,
-0.048772022128105164,
-0.024768570438027382,
-0.20919227600097656,
0.1289614886045456,
-0.15167205035686493,
-0.241876021027565,
-0.2502194046974182,
-0.4632256329059601,
0.9368115067481995,
-0.3231034576892853,
0.14543993771076202,
0.21699486672878265,
0.33401843905448914,
0.28941380977630615,
0.3415677845478058,
-0.7231058478355408,
0.49840113520622253,
0.668889045715332,
0.7383104562759399,
-0.24028882384300232,
-0.0002116822579409927,
-0.6553890109062195,
0.5247799158096313,
-0.1019422709941864,
0.6311843991279602,
-0.4585368037223816,
-0.4406058192253113,
-0.12882231175899506,
-0.31093424558639526,
0.07758364081382751,
-0.6126335859298706,
0.5737683176994324,
-0.3143254816532135,
-0.2819966673851013,
-0.21508118510246277,
-0.6122148036956787,
-0.14694376289844513,
0.03910885378718376,
-0.5322508215904236,
0.568012535572052,
-0.32565319538116455,
-0.26989445090293884,
0.1691620945930481,
-0.6944856643676758,
-0.5034992694854736,
-0.06814330816268921,
-0.4103846251964569,
-0.2485889345407486,
0.22993874549865723,
0.14531970024108887,
0.26763811707496643,
-0.47483861446380615,
0.22393611073493958,
0.1248609721660614,
-0.5611532926559448,
0.3389154076576233,
-0.5164458155632019,
0.6090584993362427,
0.3852955996990204,
-0.35147157311439514,
-0.05972675606608391,
-0.9807361364364624,
-0.27512988448143005,
-0.015061039477586746,
-0.7442225813865662,
-0.03267277032136917,
0.07615269720554352,
0.13675011694431305,
-0.0947902575135231,
0.38405320048332214,
-0.4697459042072296,
0.06150362640619278,
-0.5479171276092529,
0.31298917531967163,
0.5959450006484985,
-0.5447357892990112,
0.6039348244667053,
-0.2960306406021118,
0.31264999508857727,
-0.3783416152000427,
-0.2985345423221588,
-0.06165594607591629,
-0.2408476173877716,
-0.97618567943573,
-0.47438961267471313,
0.3748904764652252,
0.5473247766494751,
-0.5170319676399231,
0.40722814202308655,
-0.5129569172859192,
-0.19561660289764404,
-0.7103676199913025,
0.3496008515357971,
0.6478101015090942,
0.3812578618526459,
0.250186949968338,
-0.40672942996025085,
-0.658333420753479,
-0.8483387231826782,
-0.17129957675933838,
-0.12871554493904114,
-0.10403235256671906,
0.24781115353107452,
0.14784526824951172,
-0.1477982997894287,
0.8857003450393677,
-0.35031720995903015,
-0.38059568405151367,
-0.16687209904193878,
-0.05139104276895523,
0.27771952748298645,
0.41533082723617554,
-0.020590657368302345,
-0.6821209788322449,
-0.3833513855934143,
0.010578349232673645,
-0.6137649416923523,
-0.31279921531677246,
0.1376272290945053,
0.40441930294036865,
0.15822333097457886,
0.4392760097980499,
-0.6655446290969849,
0.20090965926647186,
0.3561575710773468,
-0.03652308136224747,
0.09116511046886444,
-0.09878414124250412,
-0.1412712186574936,
-0.8585180640220642,
0.09726213663816452,
-0.1350407749414444,
-0.3352416455745697,
-0.9594770073890686,
-0.007863271981477737,
-0.12602907419204712,
-0.40971606969833374,
-0.30358457565307617,
0.46799635887145996,
-0.628542423248291,
-0.3029647171497345,
-0.4558786153793335,
0.14943520724773407,
-0.31181958317756653,
0.38015133142471313,
-0.07229913026094437,
0.677548885345459,
0.4449542760848999,
-0.3963199853897095,
0.42320096492767334,
0.22479408979415894,
-0.15529391169548035,
0.3043709397315979,
-0.7049561738967896,
0.2781779170036316,
-0.20524278283119202,
0.13914622366428375,
-1.0106195211410522,
-0.3343338668346405,
0.16610406339168549,
-0.348235160112381,
0.6794157028198242,
-0.1436637043952942,
-0.3827891945838928,
-0.3366706669330597,
0.07585844397544861,
0.5841264724731445,
0.5532251000404358,
-0.5967493653297424,
0.8509644269943237,
0.6067280173301697,
-0.031278304755687714,
-0.24144281446933746,
-0.708748459815979,
0.027920853346586227,
-0.3119867742061615,
-0.6727598905563354,
0.3602961003780365,
-0.10723006725311279,
-0.23138320446014404,
-0.2266860157251358,
-0.32561540603637695,
0.0563359372317791,
-0.11876664310693741,
0.5003927946090698,
-0.0626307800412178,
-0.3339122533798218,
-0.029393579810857773,
-0.3129443824291229,
-0.4551919102668762,
-0.25591710209846497,
0.013318629935383797,
0.5901610851287842,
-0.3800249695777893,
-0.7652928233146667,
-0.5003358125686646,
0.35573577880859375,
0.5927588939666748,
-0.034426163882017136,
0.1611502766609192,
0.3364264667034149,
-0.555607795715332,
-0.11264995485544205,
-0.7159730195999146,
-0.08347465097904205,
-0.49731799960136414,
0.2167026698589325,
-0.414731502532959,
-0.8885000944137573,
0.3555141091346741,
-0.09753064066171646,
-0.12810763716697693,
0.006153239868581295,
0.6266375184059143,
-0.1641141176223755,
0.7089372873306274,
0.5772756338119507,
-0.3232113718986511,
0.24756762385368347,
-0.26102352142333984,
0.3400515615940094,
-0.866426408290863,
-0.06067835912108421,
-0.3231064975261688,
-0.5598434209823608,
-0.3491227328777313,
-0.7087384462356567,
0.5612034797668457,
0.015356038697063923,
-0.2650533616542816,
0.4511321485042572,
-0.49088436365127563,
0.3159639239311218,
0.6057237386703491,
-0.06609433889389038,
0.4255007803440094,
0.005386694334447384,
0.28806397318840027,
0.0379766970872879,
-0.644677996635437,
-0.4992830753326416,
0.949886679649353,
0.3129868507385254,
1.0787489414215088,
0.22291482985019684,
0.728966236114502,
0.025110017508268356,
-0.24486097693443298,
-0.9423767924308777,
0.7160546183586121,
-0.45168668031692505,
-0.1879628598690033,
-0.3617668151855469,
-0.16810917854309082,
-0.7546777725219727,
0.14911174774169922,
-0.0888134092092514,
-0.5768053531646729,
0.18149150907993317,
0.23240765929222107,
-0.6169593930244446,
0.09653426706790924,
-0.48181042075157166,
0.43893176317214966,
-0.4279918670654297,
-0.023285742849111557,
-0.05220142379403114,
-0.6552843451499939,
0.0468718595802784,
-0.08090446144342422,
0.31162694096565247,
-0.21615248918533325,
-0.2354961782693863,
0.6771160364151001,
-0.10683561861515045,
0.7625200748443604,
-0.18283571302890778,
-0.004273728467524052,
0.1918403059244156,
0.0605136938393116,
0.46158838272094727,
-0.16663002967834473,
-0.1209893450140953,
0.13644900918006897,
-0.4033598005771637,
-0.060207024216651917,
-0.5455929636955261,
0.6317870616912842,
-0.943686306476593,
-0.629652738571167,
-0.21793195605278015,
-0.7618681788444519,
-0.3310406804084778,
-0.0969529002904892,
0.06066029146313667,
0.6978328227996826,
-0.14370833337306976,
0.37808236479759216,
0.6345367431640625,
0.08970864117145538,
0.5864627361297607,
0.7101813554763794,
0.04115508869290352,
-0.35138532519340515,
1.1904531717300415,
0.3342132270336151,
0.28457367420196533,
0.5515671968460083,
0.20595122873783112,
-0.06907495111227036,
-0.786743700504303,
-0.4882315695285797,
0.21865607798099518,
-0.404764860868454,
-0.26641646027565,
-0.6096453070640564,
-0.47903144359588623,
-0.36255940794944763,
-0.522646427154541,
-0.7305288314819336,
-0.5969880223274231,
-0.4499987065792084,
0.24861349165439606,
0.1715766042470932,
0.55987149477005,
-0.298788458108902,
0.3395184874534607,
-0.48358842730522156,
0.5955991744995117,
0.47736820578575134,
0.05999128520488739,
-0.2558942139148712,
-0.6745492219924927,
-0.1034071296453476,
0.018750129267573357,
-0.24846923351287842,
-0.5111008882522583,
0.4418047070503235,
0.4816341996192932,
0.4743698835372925,
0.5779321193695068,
0.054223015904426575,
0.7543118000030518,
-0.6918704509735107,
0.6006208658218384,
0.23025424778461456,
-0.9255979657173157,
0.6470690369606018,
-0.3610699474811554,
0.36647653579711914,
0.5652328729629517,
0.20614740252494812,
-0.28955352306365967,
-0.3273513913154602,
-0.29797348380088806,
-0.957411527633667,
0.5947364568710327,
0.13920409977436066,
-0.13573774695396423,
0.420415461063385,
0.21218499541282654,
0.022501638159155846,
0.17854511737823486,
-0.6975212693214417,
-0.20708303153514862,
-0.08294112980365753,
-0.4867846667766571,
-0.17904336750507355,
-0.3254912197589874,
-0.4076583683490753,
-0.21281056106090546,
0.5585476756095886,
-0.1651168018579483,
0.2677137851715088,
0.034685418009757996,
-0.36146029829978943,
-0.2508094012737274,
0.3231317102909088,
0.6910619139671326,
0.43651458621025085,
0.015513564459979534,
0.3802471160888672,
0.3695678114891052,
-0.16476422548294067,
0.3442087173461914,
0.22948400676250458,
-0.19122031331062317,
-0.24441950023174286,
0.3092556297779083,
0.9382117390632629,
0.6353460550308228,
-0.8294854760169983,
0.5151514410972595,
0.388734370470047,
0.04037986323237419,
-0.4080490469932556,
0.1309853345155716,
0.2222014218568802,
0.5077105164527893,
0.4642837345600128,
0.015195338055491447,
0.273908406496048,
-0.40482619404792786,
0.17471401393413544,
0.6082803606987,
-0.2859196662902832,
-0.36508479714393616,
0.7171175479888916,
0.2403532862663269,
-0.7350818514823914,
0.1721685379743576,
-0.14283904433250427,
-0.4487721920013428,
0.3246873915195465,
0.7793682217597961,
0.7725486755371094,
-0.32001617550849915,
-0.3061322271823883,
0.10362318158149719,
0.24713097512722015,
-0.1622253805398941,
0.21899829804897308,
-0.2789124548435211,
-0.8757352828979492,
-0.3980918526649475,
-0.8697048425674438,
-0.40894514322280884,
-0.07159929722547531,
-0.5551468729972839,
0.37373507022857666,
-0.3953621983528137,
0.15825840830802917,
-0.22920314967632294,
-0.048348259180784225,
-0.45420894026756287,
0.119158536195755,
0.45004984736442566,
0.6374186277389526,
-0.6952365040779114,
0.960763692855835,
0.6576395034790039,
-0.03178483620285988,
-0.8229267001152039,
-0.04054121673107147,
0.4573473632335663,
-1.0958284139633179,
0.6099284887313843,
0.05476401373744011,
-0.33367231488227844,
-0.09582237154245377,
-0.26980912685394287,
-1.1005871295928955,
1.0122159719467163,
0.5197272300720215,
-0.867872953414917,
-0.16186311841011047,
0.372261643409729,
0.4464036822319031,
-0.3513624966144562,
-0.29695039987564087,
0.48514798283576965,
0.2747863829135895,
0.41057902574539185,
-1.2556957006454468,
-0.04238058999180794,
-0.20375707745552063,
0.1053580567240715,
0.027256779372692108,
-0.7016118764877319,
0.5830269455909729,
-0.09970753639936447,
-0.19873186945915222,
0.10110882669687271,
0.7303733825683594,
0.4188048541545868,
0.38057202100753784,
0.6424899101257324,
0.7755799889564514,
0.5735058784484863,
-0.1221965029835701,
0.8170353174209595,
-0.25466880202293396,
0.04615513235330582,
1.1905808448791504,
-0.23579086363315582,
1.1029552221298218,
0.6055679321289062,
-0.09289674460887909,
-0.15911242365837097,
0.173323392868042,
0.12336056679487228,
0.5790589451789856,
0.23991592228412628,
-0.48308637738227844,
-0.30022746324539185,
-0.10817023366689682,
-0.27205929160118103,
1.051776647567749,
0.27815666794776917,
0.014135506004095078,
-0.17803144454956055,
0.26426777243614197,
-0.20481300354003906,
0.12876862287521362,
-0.34708738327026367,
0.9062773585319519,
0.4437682032585144,
-0.012050887569785118,
0.5698269009590149,
-0.2501285970211029,
0.8810263872146606,
-0.5704066753387451,
0.2381841093301773,
0.16189278662204742,
0.16364789009094238,
-0.08963505923748016,
-0.46807706356048584,
0.48575788736343384,
0.12919867038726807,
-0.3572576642036438,
-0.4202919900417328,
0.7482166886329651,
-0.6404981017112732,
-0.573123574256897,
0.21633590757846832,
0.4258744716644287,
0.08773764222860336,
0.21703538298606873,
-0.21448272466659546,
0.6568937301635742,
-0.11217955499887466,
-0.025226721540093422,
0.35709863901138306,
0.3016618490219116,
0.33258843421936035,
0.7018416523933411,
0.4930301904678345,
0.34943094849586487,
0.06824542582035065,
0.028823236003518105,
0.8342694640159607,
-0.6193557977676392,
-0.3012544810771942,
-0.6810848712921143,
0.4849229156970978,
0.23759949207305908,
0.08581067621707916,
0.5475873351097107,
0.660097599029541,
0.640552818775177,
0.236259326338768,
0.47994473576545715,
-0.004091347102075815,
0.61783766746521,
-0.5046218633651733,
0.6543025970458984,
-0.6513018608093262,
0.5463265180587769,
-0.12251749634742737,
-0.7344588041305542,
-0.43194323778152466,
0.891524076461792,
-0.17537319660186768,
-0.07434704899787903,
0.21217788755893707,
0.9517995119094849,
-0.128241166472435,
0.025192493572831154,
0.4678589403629303,
0.3955775797367096,
0.3256910443305969,
0.6388285160064697,
0.788910448551178,
-0.4872153699398041,
0.7367587089538574,
-0.13660454750061035,
-0.21319256722927094,
-0.31001016497612,
-0.5993492007255554,
-0.42213207483291626,
-0.7080899477005005,
-0.2799801230430603,
-0.08468104153871536,
0.20889730751514435,
1.1410496234893799,
0.6869891881942749,
-0.9068002700805664,
-0.6055281758308411,
0.0865820124745369,
-0.08975014090538025,
0.09301906079053879,
-0.12630677223205566,
0.14680197834968567,
-0.04742661491036415,
-0.7310208082199097,
1.0217338800430298,
0.4044717848300934,
0.030115235596895218,
-0.06328444182872772,
-0.3187413215637207,
0.04114671051502228,
-0.02722221240401268,
0.565934419631958,
0.4654191732406616,
-0.9637142419815063,
-0.5724315047264099,
-0.17551371455192566,
-0.11814192682504654,
0.10102309286594391,
0.8353503942489624,
-0.6519057750701904,
0.6070171594619751,
0.2725437879562378,
0.9312482476234436,
0.5508336424827576,
-0.17957843840122223,
0.7067542672157288,
-0.6047288179397583,
0.08908405900001526,
0.3226749002933502,
0.4106764495372772,
0.4396592080593109,
-0.0457332469522953,
0.49088016152381897,
0.02643374167382717,
-0.615605890750885,
-1.0374257564544678,
0.17210470139980316,
-1.4342621564865112,
0.10308733582496643,
1.310995101928711,
0.28197258710861206,
0.0090476768091321,
-0.09594154357910156,
-0.22873489558696747,
0.281171053647995,
-0.3857099413871765,
0.7035226821899414,
0.3381701111793518,
-0.4395105242729187,
-0.12799209356307983,
-0.37006187438964844,
0.333504319190979,
0.20261815190315247,
-0.4018906354904175,
-0.05788137763738632,
0.4399578273296356,
0.18447071313858032,
0.2943827509880066,
0.7247397899627686,
0.05462492257356644,
0.1461431235074997,
-0.05444679036736488,
-0.09046296030282974,
-0.260111927986145,
-0.4236968755722046,
-0.6327729821205139,
0.48963043093681335,
0.11664216220378876,
-0.22109071910381317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08837v1 | Learning to Generate Context-Sensitive Backchannel Smiles for Embodied AI Agents with Applications in Mental Health Dialogues | 2024-02-13T22:47:22 | 2024-02-13T22:47:22 | Maneesh Bilalpur, Mert Inan, Dorsa Zeinali, Jeffrey F. Cohn, Malihe Alikhani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Addressing the critical shortage of mental health resources for effective
screening, diagnosis, and treatment remains a significant challenge. This
scarcity underscores the need for innovative solutions, particularly in
enhancing the accessibility and efficacy of therapeutic support. Embodied
agents with advanced interactive capabilities emerge as a promising and
cost-effective supplement to traditional caregiving methods. Crucial to these
agents' effectiveness is their ability to simulate non-verbal behaviors, like
backchannels, that are pivotal in establishing rapport and understanding in
therapeutic contexts but remain under-explored. To improve the rapport-building
capabilities of embodied agents we annotated backchannel smiles in videos of
intimate face-to-face conversations over topics such as mental health, illness,
and relationships. We hypothesized that both speaker and listener behaviors
affect the duration and intensity of backchannel smiles. Using cues from speech
prosody and language along with the demographics of the speaker and listener,
we found them to contain significant predictors of the intensity of backchannel
smiles. Based on our findings, we introduce backchannel smile production in
embodied agents as a generation problem. Our attention-based generative model
suggests that listener information offers performance improvements over the
baseline speaker-centric generation approach. Conditioned generation using the
significant predictors of smile intensity provides statistically significant
improvements in empirical measures of generation quality. Our user study by
transferring generated smiles to an embodied agent suggests that agent with
backchannel smiles is perceived to be more human-like and is an attractive
alternative for non-personal conversations over agent without backchannel
smiles. | [
-0.6315507888793945,
-0.6201527118682861,
0.8473466634750366,
0.2891935110092163,
-0.06685285270214081,
0.005349210929125547,
-0.27288588881492615,
-0.3990325331687927,
0.4077104330062866,
0.39415574073791504,
-0.9720174074172974,
-0.5164106488227844,
-0.3133920133113861,
-0.01032355334609747,
-0.14010633528232574,
0.8926644921302795,
0.4131839871406555,
0.08226954936981201,
-0.18333004415035248,
-0.07801628857851028,
-0.5505425930023193,
-0.3059161305427551,
-0.8939006328582764,
-0.5659534931182861,
0.7526693344116211,
0.1573609709739685,
1.0042372941970825,
-0.08672702312469482,
-0.12952475249767303,
0.2857099771499634,
0.36239364743232727,
0.11209500581026077,
-0.5560572743415833,
0.5557101368904114,
-0.33792465925216675,
-0.38294875621795654,
-0.6190304756164551,
-0.0018297812202945352,
0.3022438883781433,
0.41259074211120605,
-0.29825329780578613,
0.06499695777893066,
-0.14668647944927216,
0.42187753319740295,
-0.6362749338150024,
0.23086033761501312,
-0.2844165563583374,
0.47710850834846497,
0.07522229105234146,
-0.4944412410259247,
-0.4376886487007141,
-0.06826376914978027,
0.20025600492954254,
-0.6166216135025024,
0.05486835911870003,
-0.3793829679489136,
0.5703752636909485,
0.4098237454891205,
-0.3354244530200958,
-0.039552465081214905,
-0.7868515253067017,
0.39806801080703735,
-0.6229825019836426,
0.6113172173500061,
0.49354538321495056,
0.2827589511871338,
-0.4285854697227478,
-0.6599976420402527,
-0.7581791877746582,
-0.21917138993740082,
0.06433649361133575,
0.38705459237098694,
-0.5589881539344788,
0.2154201716184616,
0.3323766589164734,
-0.007449919357895851,
-0.41941338777542114,
-0.15145599842071533,
0.15795759856700897,
-0.02441980689764023,
0.8776180744171143,
0.2029634267091751,
0.8065679669380188,
0.05704730004072189,
0.1680237501859665,
-0.39588943123817444,
-0.4960033595561981,
0.04417602717876434,
0.08792456984519958,
0.3189496695995331,
-0.25014594197273254,
0.5649867653846741,
0.03618493676185608,
-0.10067002475261688,
0.3048032820224762,
-0.35942935943603516,
0.21453802287578583,
0.17435699701309204,
-0.06846879422664642,
0.14361537992954254,
0.3997165262699127,
0.4166199862957001,
0.25672391057014465,
-0.009476874954998493,
-0.1258411705493927,
-0.16638323664665222,
0.7306191325187683,
-0.9788573384284973,
0.06085167080163956,
0.33444321155548096,
-0.4620462656021118,
-0.020069938153028488,
-0.10233496129512787,
-0.6460456252098083,
-0.3301183879375458,
-0.3240639865398407,
0.4535456597805023,
-0.6066159009933472,
-0.5775038003921509,
-0.4806366562843323,
-0.24068036675453186,
0.5387340188026428,
0.3226245939731598,
-0.9224027395248413,
0.3379605710506439,
0.6816574931144714,
0.8776755928993225,
0.24135926365852356,
-0.15378934144973755,
-0.5849538445472717,
0.379170686006546,
-0.42685621976852417,
0.5229023098945618,
-0.33358901739120483,
-0.5071722865104675,
0.15991105139255524,
0.03258509561419487,
-0.12341618537902832,
-0.32006189227104187,
-0.09381522238254547,
-0.24970169365406036,
0.07378794997930527,
-0.20197536051273346,
-0.1999116837978363,
0.1283179074525833,
0.04610522836446762,
-0.4140338599681854,
0.4232116937637329,
0.39443615078926086,
-0.5365219712257385,
0.17283709347248077,
-0.5324029326438904,
-0.8716816306114197,
0.2966480553150177,
-0.40952128171920776,
-0.37617751955986023,
0.5488337278366089,
0.20915913581848145,
0.3771096467971802,
0.1585599035024643,
0.067295603454113,
-0.3415133059024811,
-0.4925577640533447,
0.6555718183517456,
-0.31366395950317383,
0.5645385384559631,
0.08635012805461884,
-0.8200525045394897,
0.26455071568489075,
-0.35773035883903503,
-0.07803933322429657,
0.10339511185884476,
0.22645603120326996,
-0.12765070796012878,
0.07040026038885117,
-0.04702536016702652,
0.3736213743686676,
-0.31960171461105347,
-0.44272100925445557,
-0.3720637559890747,
-0.7095577716827393,
0.3040325939655304,
0.7065455317497253,
0.28774797916412354,
-0.05975792557001114,
-0.4590362012386322,
0.729395866394043,
-0.012717719189822674,
0.1710820198059082,
-0.272955060005188,
-0.6860658526420593,
-0.5950214266777039,
-0.6163693070411682,
-0.4496197998523712,
0.3145151138305664,
-0.9749099612236023,
0.21845123171806335,
-0.10750482976436615,
-0.4034106731414795,
-0.6601760387420654,
-0.30586135387420654,
0.5207854509353638,
0.42797985672950745,
0.27529773116111755,
-0.5189709067344666,
-0.20400457084178925,
-0.6170518398284912,
0.008180186152458191,
-0.30143940448760986,
-0.05559893697500229,
0.7443460822105408,
0.3278570771217346,
-0.45866066217422485,
0.9609681963920593,
-0.28550389409065247,
-0.15605084598064423,
-0.13700218498706818,
0.08457424491643906,
-0.36149120330810547,
0.36229661107063293,
0.532615065574646,
-0.7720915675163269,
-0.14996065199375153,
-0.1097879558801651,
-0.8271670341491699,
0.21026472747325897,
0.010519989766180515,
-0.2165805846452713,
0.3676687180995941,
0.22127798199653625,
-1.0840942859649658,
0.6952382326126099,
0.42342159152030945,
-0.36987990140914917,
0.3040041923522949,
-0.17138750851154327,
0.344811350107193,
-0.9228482246398926,
0.05277646332979202,
-0.04728032648563385,
-0.1429235339164734,
-0.6601570844650269,
-0.08343648910522461,
-0.4961811602115631,
-0.7673453688621521,
-0.47550398111343384,
0.642230749130249,
-0.17303481698036194,
-0.5320726037025452,
-0.2506178319454193,
0.3092952370643616,
-0.12254906445741653,
0.7574032545089722,
0.16479714214801788,
0.7619035243988037,
0.46137669682502747,
-0.3902369439601898,
0.5191075205802917,
0.542402446269989,
0.3725683391094208,
1.0582515001296997,
-0.5583145022392273,
0.30150407552719116,
-0.08403916656970978,
0.7181314826011658,
-1.0039082765579224,
-0.40238261222839355,
0.3678503930568695,
-0.8865182399749756,
0.465093731880188,
0.22159573435783386,
-0.1684540957212448,
-0.24261310696601868,
-0.33466488122940063,
0.1628754734992981,
0.6739250421524048,
-0.5781871676445007,
0.6196874380111694,
0.364861398935318,
-0.450592964887619,
-0.29491493105888367,
-0.9119028449058533,
0.2016993910074234,
-0.28177934885025024,
-0.8258039951324463,
0.3690468966960907,
-0.019367268308997154,
-0.20702791213989258,
-0.13634182512760162,
-0.007244176231324673,
0.2731091380119324,
0.16301679611206055,
0.488155722618103,
-0.052811406552791595,
-0.37184250354766846,
0.4231242835521698,
0.42392319440841675,
-0.034114230424165726,
0.2714497447013855,
-0.42927923798561096,
0.28641605377197266,
-0.15514467656612396,
-0.48363062739372253,
-0.7577271461486816,
0.7661790251731873,
0.5607312917709351,
-0.15872572362422943,
0.8893678784370422,
0.8552168011665344,
-0.5902223587036133,
-0.0960925966501236,
-0.4038234353065491,
-0.6650263667106628,
-0.4612927734851837,
0.09211158752441406,
-0.6306095719337463,
-0.7946652173995972,
0.4391747713088989,
0.24581918120384216,
-0.19950488209724426,
-0.10010828077793121,
0.7517681121826172,
-0.11855482310056686,
1.5539703369140625,
0.424477756023407,
0.3763253390789032,
0.6124799251556396,
-0.01687237247824669,
0.2806057929992676,
-0.8210589289665222,
-0.3277990221977234,
-0.19787514209747314,
-0.12403387576341629,
-0.9244349598884583,
-0.12123055011034012,
0.3281884491443634,
-0.47865360975265503,
-0.45337632298469543,
-0.08554448187351227,
-0.23065800964832306,
-0.4514921307563782,
0.39936795830726624,
0.5864526033401489,
0.06665002554655075,
-0.06473755836486816,
0.03447809815406799,
-0.2412998378276825,
-0.4532058537006378,
-0.36483460664749146,
0.5906879305839539,
0.4157133996486664,
0.5357626080513,
0.368501752614975,
0.9064614176750183,
0.40359529852867126,
0.48697811365127563,
-0.7974624037742615,
0.5606555938720703,
0.15162967145442963,
-0.4031369388103485,
-0.32736071944236755,
-0.4654960632324219,
-1.0601348876953125,
0.008260676637291908,
-0.15689389407634735,
-1.1054418087005615,
0.41613879799842834,
0.3521658480167389,
-0.4623582661151886,
-0.1940900981426239,
-0.43115511536598206,
0.7841807007789612,
-0.12041208148002625,
-0.5084621906280518,
-0.4834025800228119,
-0.8304584622383118,
0.11999320238828659,
0.3224027156829834,
0.0816333144903183,
-0.19862531125545502,
0.12322108447551727,
0.2671152353286743,
-0.47852465510368347,
0.8677194714546204,
-0.3953998386859894,
-0.3633745610713959,
0.2144789695739746,
-0.009463276714086533,
0.177304208278656,
0.3627867102622986,
0.37829604744911194,
-0.11681970953941345,
-0.2015552818775177,
-0.36242762207984924,
-0.9682915210723877,
0.6157491207122803,
-1.0302093029022217,
-0.9027442336082458,
-0.14498361945152283,
-0.34926319122314453,
-0.6771018505096436,
-0.0022868115920573473,
0.12200424075126648,
0.4562017321586609,
-0.2543751299381256,
-0.03006194718182087,
0.7216075658798218,
-0.6175661087036133,
0.15448597073554993,
0.3344350755214691,
-0.008198886178433895,
-0.46533203125,
1.0666694641113281,
-0.2085169106721878,
0.37056249380111694,
0.2646811008453369,
0.11062972247600555,
-0.22840675711631775,
0.042754165828228,
-0.24500438570976257,
0.4246005117893219,
-0.5979340672492981,
-0.13705725967884064,
-0.6327513456344604,
-0.3152332901954651,
-0.8444076776504517,
-0.16709259152412415,
-0.44876325130462646,
-0.14862936735153198,
-0.317770779132843,
-0.1168791651725769,
0.364302396774292,
0.2969278395175934,
-0.2411704659461975,
0.17723044753074646,
-0.5715399384498596,
0.25972554087638855,
0.6951097846031189,
0.20402555167675018,
0.3446943759918213,
-0.0760900229215622,
-0.22814688086509705,
0.32661572098731995,
-0.45652878284454346,
-1.0203664302825928,
0.4569939970970154,
0.3137611746788025,
0.6386996507644653,
0.36710280179977417,
-0.02115182764828205,
0.6262348890304565,
-0.20782631635665894,
0.7298592925071716,
0.16541101038455963,
-0.9350862503051758,
0.8514161705970764,
-0.5237551331520081,
0.12685765326023102,
0.1776171624660492,
0.21981696784496307,
-0.6613813638687134,
-0.6346830725669861,
-0.9633251428604126,
-0.7626922726631165,
0.6759416460990906,
0.5068482756614685,
0.52714604139328,
-0.19400589168071747,
0.27714675664901733,
-0.188487708568573,
0.46086254715919495,
-0.20673736929893494,
-0.11178871244192123,
-0.7525666952133179,
-0.3214398920536041,
-0.2184075266122818,
-0.04920230060815811,
-0.29500290751457214,
0.24012073874473572,
0.7773857116699219,
-0.44060176610946655,
0.7648648023605347,
0.5480366945266724,
0.05295124650001526,
-0.40414687991142273,
0.1609092801809311,
0.7147791981697083,
0.3444678783416748,
-0.10547030717134476,
0.09644909203052521,
-0.04145393893122673,
-0.4258335828781128,
-0.00890294834971428,
0.1944495290517807,
0.10734124481678009,
-0.13309238851070404,
0.26552465558052063,
0.8193671107292175,
0.35842540860176086,
-0.900454580783844,
0.5645352005958557,
-0.26689398288726807,
0.27145498991012573,
-0.36660876870155334,
0.31344640254974365,
0.24863159656524658,
0.7913162112236023,
0.23274032771587372,
-0.313033789396286,
0.3164577782154083,
-0.9071531891822815,
0.4380813539028168,
0.44194495677948,
-0.6484996676445007,
-0.47218143939971924,
0.44623300433158875,
0.2870667576789856,
-0.6442444920539856,
0.913016676902771,
0.017644908279180527,
-0.26992252469062805,
0.37910887598991394,
0.7829866409301758,
1.114105224609375,
-0.3723149597644806,
0.5138843059539795,
0.03675943613052368,
-0.1940021961927414,
0.22714002430438995,
0.011648828163743019,
-0.5148967504501343,
-0.8148500323295593,
-0.02363085374236107,
-0.2502903938293457,
-0.5368630290031433,
-0.09967001527547836,
-0.8646690249443054,
0.020551392808556557,
-0.21951653063297272,
-0.6137535572052002,
-0.033014290034770966,
0.1308537721633911,
-0.533505380153656,
0.2616962790489197,
0.601689875125885,
0.43428319692611694,
-0.7818701267242432,
0.495978444814682,
0.7028360366821289,
-0.6943601965904236,
-0.8385264277458191,
0.22307252883911133,
0.07418717443943024,
-0.7790123224258423,
0.2194143384695053,
0.2955349087715149,
-0.4740237295627594,
0.16377584636211395,
-0.5210448503494263,
-0.5388587713241577,
1.2918744087219238,
0.7027680277824402,
0.03654380142688751,
-0.20740704238414764,
-0.13842417299747467,
0.824504554271698,
-0.60649174451828,
0.35751479864120483,
0.5787990689277649,
0.3812137246131897,
0.4077931344509125,
-0.7692999243736267,
0.2893211245536804,
-0.4794008135795593,
0.5183513760566711,
-0.23801717162132263,
-0.7542195320129395,
0.5497144460678101,
-0.3624400496482849,
-0.31752437353134155,
0.28642046451568604,
0.8448058366775513,
0.8697080016136169,
0.7541401982307434,
0.26359474658966064,
0.3003877103328705,
0.546044647693634,
0.08082406222820282,
0.9354114532470703,
-0.03044840134680271,
0.0726848691701889,
0.849919319152832,
-0.327903151512146,
0.5724412798881531,
0.4547397196292877,
0.23097501695156097,
0.6780009865760803,
0.4527059495449066,
0.0918508917093277,
0.32175177335739136,
0.18446339666843414,
-0.3630959093570709,
-0.06325936317443848,
-0.5435196161270142,
-0.34019234776496887,
0.4228253662586212,
0.649936854839325,
-0.18453839421272278,
0.20246972143650055,
0.6597934365272522,
0.1853128969669342,
0.11851385980844498,
-0.1463666558265686,
0.7733761072158813,
0.4390707015991211,
-0.8402110934257507,
0.1428358405828476,
-0.3409052789211273,
0.10558211803436279,
-0.36329954862594604,
-0.20112501084804535,
-0.3873386085033417,
0.24165698885917664,
-0.26517096161842346,
-0.6794568300247192,
0.06771781295537949,
-0.14893116056919098,
0.18174633383750916,
-0.2802591323852539,
0.8033978343009949,
-0.38194721937179565,
-0.017387578263878822,
0.4412166476249695,
0.4744492173194885,
0.35547736287117004,
-0.007992113009095192,
-0.5850027203559875,
0.001455591875128448,
-0.38134485483169556,
-0.4350087642669678,
0.42138782143592834,
0.46124130487442017,
0.0032887328416109085,
0.7109127044677734,
0.41445839405059814,
-0.0005543660372495651,
-0.32310062646865845,
0.4319412410259247,
0.7473698854446411,
-0.7064504623413086,
-0.5670881271362305,
-0.4596107602119446,
0.5253726243972778,
0.02901948057115078,
-0.1849346160888672,
0.5428704023361206,
-0.01779012568295002,
0.5516747236251831,
0.04895429313182831,
0.5699329376220703,
0.020764142274856567,
-0.0018689432181417942,
-0.21894970536231995,
0.80521559715271,
-0.6757879257202148,
-0.3179912269115448,
-0.5790227651596069,
-0.5039339661598206,
-0.01423613354563713,
0.8277473449707031,
-0.07344977557659149,
0.4779498875141144,
0.2442440688610077,
0.7350150346755981,
0.3187081217765808,
0.2910168170928955,
0.5274230241775513,
0.2112608104944229,
0.5432109832763672,
0.5799760222434998,
1.0553765296936035,
-0.0013194509083405137,
0.15928786993026733,
-0.22807691991329193,
-0.27083492279052734,
-0.2983059585094452,
-0.4077761173248291,
-0.9125743508338928,
-0.5716424584388733,
-0.31401199102401733,
-0.5794758200645447,
0.47909772396087646,
1.0047104358673096,
0.9004527926445007,
-0.47509822249412537,
-0.07614130526781082,
-0.05414038524031639,
-0.011294162832200527,
-0.3966527283191681,
-0.2839047610759735,
0.09029554575681686,
-0.35831329226493835,
-0.45190125703811646,
0.32645857334136963,
0.44775307178497314,
0.19177427887916565,
-0.5109574198722839,
-0.21480496227741241,
0.1314370036125183,
0.2112714946269989,
0.6881016492843628,
0.48689767718315125,
-0.5924913287162781,
-0.5556803345680237,
-0.008922219276428223,
-0.27562037110328674,
0.014538547024130821,
0.8106679320335388,
-0.834204912185669,
0.2595961391925812,
0.024701297283172607,
0.42537617683410645,
0.7947444915771484,
0.11364756524562836,
1.0278913974761963,
-0.7751244306564331,
0.24950063228607178,
0.42781785130500793,
0.03560585156083107,
0.45205098390579224,
-0.6039595603942871,
0.14884048700332642,
0.18621255457401276,
-0.29206570982933044,
-0.8059391975402832,
0.36360040307044983,
-0.7859424948692322,
-0.049169257283210754,
0.9000566601753235,
-0.4819561839103699,
-0.23674079775810242,
0.18001197278499603,
-0.2333182692527771,
0.6695885062217712,
-0.6648004651069641,
0.7128836512565613,
0.2312813401222229,
-0.6248928308486938,
-0.3979845643043518,
-0.3558955788612366,
0.5170608758926392,
0.2798217535018921,
-0.9225452542304993,
-0.2668904960155487,
0.41272926330566406,
0.08778795599937439,
0.21603423357009888,
0.6331722736358643,
-0.015548535622656345,
0.5678864121437073,
0.25777092576026917,
0.05130200833082199,
0.23610292375087738,
-0.2849767506122589,
-0.1803324818611145,
-0.07616344094276428,
-0.05141206458210945,
0.13269273936748505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08831v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08831v1 | eCeLLM: Generalizing Large Language Models for E-commerce from Large-scale, High-quality Instruction Data | 2024-02-13T22:26:24 | 2024-02-13T22:26:24 | Bo Peng, Xinyi Ling, Ziru Chen, Huan Sun, Xia Ning | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | With tremendous efforts on developing effective e-commerce models,
conventional e-commerce models show limited success in generalist e-commerce
modeling, and suffer from unsatisfactory performance on new users and new
products - a typical out-of-domain generalization challenge. Meanwhile, large
language models (LLMs) demonstrate outstanding performance in generalist
modeling and out-of-domain generalizability in many fields. Toward fully
unleashing their power for e-commerce, in this paper, we construct ECInstruct,
the first open-sourced, large-scale, and high-quality benchmark instruction
dataset for e-commerce. Leveraging ECInstruct, we develop eCeLLM, a series of
e-commerce LLMs, by instruction-tuning general-purpose LLMs. Our comprehensive
experiments and evaluation demonstrate that eCeLLM models substantially
outperform baseline models, including the most advanced GPT-4, and the
state-of-the-art task-specific models in in-domain evaluation. Moreover, eCeLLM
exhibits excellent generalizability to out-of-domain settings, including unseen
products and unseen instructions, highlighting its superiority as a generalist
e-commerce model. Both the ECInstruct dataset and the eCeLLM models show great
potential in empowering versatile and effective LLMs for e-commerce. ECInstruct
and eCeLLM models are publicly accessible through
https://ninglab.github.io/eCeLLM. | [
-0.3197801411151886,
-0.8860323429107666,
0.2916176915168762,
-0.06976373493671417,
0.005243842490017414,
0.0409080795943737,
-0.584030270576477,
-0.6266422271728516,
-0.18018096685409546,
0.7609491944313049,
-0.5865023136138916,
-1.0186357498168945,
-0.4113551080226898,
-0.17006312310695648,
-0.642617404460907,
0.9623521566390991,
0.12624764442443848,
-0.09240850061178207,
-0.3768503665924072,
-0.09573451429605484,
0.22288067638874054,
-0.738623857498169,
-0.3373306095600128,
0.06581664830446243,
0.1560012251138687,
0.5265392661094666,
0.21410946547985077,
0.4938589632511139,
0.35149312019348145,
0.30037829279899597,
0.4190559387207031,
0.26300063729286194,
-0.4502512216567993,
0.049949850887060165,
-0.3839270770549774,
-0.5306885242462158,
-0.8825200200080872,
-0.2209860384464264,
0.1792060285806656,
0.6858198046684265,
-0.6763028502464294,
0.5813727974891663,
0.2391703724861145,
0.7331979274749756,
-0.6389496326446533,
0.09228742867708206,
-0.484925240278244,
-0.38822147250175476,
0.1619926542043686,
0.07458881288766861,
-0.9255228042602539,
-0.3782939314842224,
0.15700851380825043,
-0.8757467865943909,
0.35098201036453247,
0.5248871445655823,
0.6919057369232178,
-0.10910312831401825,
-0.4502551257610321,
-0.46628713607788086,
-0.8388990759849548,
1.0037810802459717,
-0.5699951648712158,
0.5520995855331421,
0.4240294396877289,
0.24096600711345673,
0.05934320390224457,
-1.042661190032959,
-0.010458406992256641,
0.02423465996980667,
0.23206795752048492,
0.35037633776664734,
-0.38708028197288513,
0.16200599074363708,
0.22322648763656616,
0.30192679166793823,
-0.7762765288352966,
0.4225763976573944,
-0.2134348601102829,
0.15217116475105286,
0.440348356962204,
0.257254958152771,
0.3445860743522644,
0.4216791093349457,
-0.3250292241573334,
0.09321246296167374,
-0.869270920753479,
-0.13332855701446533,
0.5869285464286804,
0.17098039388656616,
-0.09958991408348083,
0.3344149589538574,
-0.26572608947753906,
0.7587555050849915,
0.2201964408159256,
0.09586077928543091,
-0.06377501785755157,
0.10978399962186813,
-0.4182797968387604,
-0.1280009001493454,
0.3444381356239319,
0.4687820076942444,
-0.009503675624728203,
-0.10897571593523026,
-0.18935495615005493,
-0.1785573661327362,
0.26954978704452515,
-1.1176457405090332,
-0.15816538035869598,
0.4020794630050659,
-0.6834977269172668,
0.08987392485141754,
0.2690662443637848,
-0.754790723323822,
0.1033891886472702,
-0.4968653619289398,
0.3927510678768158,
-0.020625587552785873,
-0.06350451707839966,
0.3476076126098633,
0.3026520013809204,
0.24250641465187073,
0.18012790381908417,
-1.0441445112228394,
0.9283993244171143,
0.9450480937957764,
0.6382660269737244,
-0.018789255991578102,
0.02188088372349739,
-0.33482688665390015,
0.41256675124168396,
-0.11929292976856232,
0.5401392579078674,
-0.6939386129379272,
-0.09067936986684799,
0.38025858998298645,
0.41931721568107605,
0.1651671826839447,
-0.695464551448822,
0.5625954270362854,
-0.7761024236679077,
-0.04771335795521736,
0.2609623074531555,
-1.3055567741394043,
-0.3709716200828552,
0.35399946570396423,
-0.7303359508514404,
0.5694025754928589,
-0.04012797400355339,
-0.2520706355571747,
0.10334338247776031,
-0.4267673194408417,
-0.3796623647212982,
0.23138068616390228,
0.1312359720468521,
-0.5736827254295349,
0.3555995523929596,
0.14564643800258636,
0.614433765411377,
-0.6651580333709717,
-0.22695232927799225,
-0.32578784227371216,
-0.45233798027038574,
0.0046005393378436565,
-0.2856593430042267,
0.7183697819709778,
0.07473539561033249,
-0.48126715421676636,
-0.45824846625328064,
-0.7426413297653198,
0.357657790184021,
0.09905560314655304,
-0.06225201487541199,
-0.40124809741973877,
0.0649551972746849,
0.22124531865119934,
-0.10975024104118347,
0.225464329123497,
-0.4939589202404022,
0.4372810125350952,
-0.2799178957939148,
0.6173507571220398,
0.7826031446456909,
-0.28884321451187134,
0.3889315128326416,
-0.26916489005088806,
0.6344566941261292,
-0.33816292881965637,
0.34292709827423096,
-0.4170514643192291,
-0.41510695219039917,
-0.8241344690322876,
-0.12412410229444504,
0.38334333896636963,
0.3784900903701782,
-0.30662816762924194,
0.4058643877506256,
-0.16516996920108795,
-0.4432186782360077,
-0.23402391374111176,
0.04718545079231262,
0.062079496681690216,
-0.0007688422920182347,
0.45100346207618713,
-0.12051255255937576,
-0.30178555846214294,
-1.0383752584457397,
-0.3172955811023712,
0.19511839747428894,
-0.30323246121406555,
0.4006240665912628,
0.4389244318008423,
-0.38994142413139343,
0.36668890714645386,
-0.495796799659729,
-0.2210402488708496,
-0.2074475735425949,
0.2657107412815094,
0.35347598791122437,
0.1911478489637375,
0.31192055344581604,
-0.4458466172218323,
-0.63558030128479,
0.1918744146823883,
-0.2955569326877594,
-0.12626558542251587,
-0.0037510839756578207,
-0.1840822547674179,
0.28850382566452026,
0.26668843626976013,
-0.30719685554504395,
0.3367616534233093,
0.81822669506073,
-0.021337978541851044,
0.6520113348960876,
-0.5766088962554932,
0.3063817322254181,
-1.0109301805496216,
-0.13939587771892548,
0.20736798644065857,
-0.22484156489372253,
-0.4649789333343506,
0.09453892707824707,
0.43424829840660095,
-0.10985295474529266,
-0.39547184109687805,
0.18360118567943573,
-0.7704830169677734,
-0.17727088928222656,
-0.19862069189548492,
0.14281006157398224,
0.2819512188434601,
0.39185017347335815,
-0.12988504767417908,
0.5054178237915039,
0.518984854221344,
-0.7673656344413757,
0.2647864520549774,
0.10727273672819138,
-0.7500940561294556,
0.7571704983711243,
-0.8065257668495178,
0.24090395867824554,
0.1294616460800171,
0.16317468881607056,
-0.4849209487438202,
-0.2940497398376465,
-0.0767943412065506,
-0.013620719313621521,
0.49533379077911377,
-0.47514766454696655,
-0.6404248476028442,
-0.377069890499115,
0.05830572172999382,
0.3843671381473541,
0.8885998129844666,
-0.8710513710975647,
0.5592703819274902,
0.24383558332920074,
-0.25074002146720886,
-0.2905054986476898,
-0.4958559572696686,
-0.0684952363371849,
-0.07036575675010681,
-0.4618755280971527,
0.6167449951171875,
-0.3750205338001251,
-0.037434861063957214,
-0.10588803142309189,
0.09760955721139908,
-0.0919889509677887,
-0.056311871856451035,
0.03654557839035988,
0.41193243861198425,
-0.12063373625278473,
0.22506867349147797,
0.21620504558086395,
-0.03752266243100166,
0.24067968130111694,
-0.7753380537033081,
0.4522615969181061,
-0.024786701425909996,
-0.8394858241081238,
-0.35864463448524475,
0.36349400877952576,
0.460983544588089,
-0.14825588464736938,
0.5556666254997253,
0.07313930988311768,
-0.44431471824645996,
-0.9411431550979614,
-0.5057197213172913,
-0.17401914298534393,
-0.4821324348449707,
0.590947151184082,
0.03578666225075722,
-0.8105902671813965,
0.1693916618824005,
-0.48293307423591614,
0.20839768648147583,
0.09209346771240234,
0.48977530002593994,
-0.07980956137180328,
1.3731828927993774,
0.6801660060882568,
0.20279882848262787,
0.2526535391807556,
-0.3510296046733856,
0.2704014480113983,
-0.8534699082374573,
-0.14601044356822968,
-0.530988872051239,
-0.3369280993938446,
-0.6227121353149414,
-0.274490088224411,
0.070245161652565,
0.037302110344171524,
-0.5612654089927673,
0.3310757875442505,
-0.5273513793945312,
0.7563605904579163,
0.4882483184337616,
0.4741085469722748,
0.30922025442123413,
0.3904350697994232,
0.10147904604673386,
0.07243660092353821,
-0.5586081743240356,
-0.7486740946769714,
1.639167070388794,
0.08534674346446991,
0.9322624802589417,
0.22804316878318787,
0.4795849025249481,
0.3007829189300537,
0.46384599804878235,
-0.7676861882209778,
0.3621445894241333,
-0.5506981015205383,
-0.5424414873123169,
0.14875753223896027,
-0.2864852845668793,
-0.8857969641685486,
-0.2162119597196579,
0.10361146181821823,
-0.6531534194946289,
-0.18256047368049622,
0.26372432708740234,
-0.27232205867767334,
0.5631411671638489,
-0.6098130941390991,
0.7235357761383057,
-0.7215579152107239,
-0.9520733952522278,
-0.36208993196487427,
-0.14336027204990387,
0.17567357420921326,
0.0377299003303051,
0.4901552200317383,
0.20373564958572388,
-0.2908889353275299,
0.588661789894104,
-0.518096387386322,
0.8251516222953796,
0.1194169744849205,
-0.12878751754760742,
0.2975693345069885,
0.06012610346078873,
0.7818094491958618,
-0.371194064617157,
0.15540650486946106,
0.3815509080886841,
-0.32330095767974854,
-0.5607709884643555,
-0.7197790145874023,
0.8128482699394226,
-0.6568211913108826,
-0.528799831867218,
0.05193197727203369,
-0.0873616635799408,
-0.2795546054840088,
0.1445850282907486,
0.1934497207403183,
0.7906680703163147,
-0.5510516166687012,
0.4348927140235901,
0.859117329120636,
-0.512771487236023,
0.3253284692764282,
0.6995270252227783,
-0.1748625934123993,
-0.35553309321403503,
0.8965473771095276,
0.13332028687000275,
0.5133354067802429,
0.5027830600738525,
-0.057463422417640686,
-0.34387168288230896,
-0.42237988114356995,
-0.473869264125824,
0.007506990339607,
-0.6862106919288635,
-0.18416813015937805,
-0.4046195447444916,
0.08121323585510254,
-0.09178611636161804,
-0.34374338388442993,
-0.4279847741127014,
-0.2829159200191498,
-0.07349798083305359,
-0.2248474508523941,
0.1469738483428955,
0.9662917852401733,
0.0005534577649086714,
0.08395203948020935,
-0.9659677743911743,
0.007724030874669552,
0.48338621854782104,
0.5824790000915527,
0.32207709550857544,
-0.4104880690574646,
-0.7423558831214905,
0.2278674989938736,
-0.3880257308483124,
-0.5063544511795044,
0.3257427513599396,
0.3146721124649048,
0.651290237903595,
0.7278043031692505,
0.09546845406293869,
0.32964888215065,
-0.6572649478912354,
0.6357223987579346,
0.31717419624328613,
-0.9790979623794556,
0.31879931688308716,
-0.33976447582244873,
-0.00036490437923930585,
0.07318831235170364,
0.5783290863037109,
-0.3971044719219208,
-0.02311716042459011,
-0.6272900104522705,
-1.2149683237075806,
0.69414883852005,
-0.045292939990758896,
0.1421973556280136,
-0.14947734773159027,
0.10923847556114197,
0.6012881398200989,
0.30426862835884094,
-0.29657700657844543,
-0.3361060321331024,
-0.08660664409399033,
-0.3596178889274597,
0.026551250368356705,
-0.18932406604290009,
0.09351463615894318,
-0.050048794597387314,
0.7955155968666077,
0.10665412992238998,
0.21426326036453247,
-0.36807283759117126,
-0.44608622789382935,
-0.07149329781532288,
0.4346112012863159,
0.3698538541793823,
0.8392629623413086,
0.0579436756670475,
-0.13629299402236938,
-0.09469190984964371,
-0.46886226534843445,
0.25054043531417847,
-0.15076464414596558,
-0.18533915281295776,
-0.3577005863189697,
0.13652509450912476,
0.32768476009368896,
0.4318024516105652,
-0.7432717680931091,
0.5061039328575134,
0.01280286442488432,
-0.15820369124412537,
-0.37196168303489685,
-0.02577781118452549,
0.25645238161087036,
0.09214329719543457,
0.2212909311056137,
-0.26577702164649963,
0.2905292212963104,
-0.40472084283828735,
0.1938304305076599,
0.17719969153404236,
-0.028035664930939674,
-0.4702261686325073,
0.7442644834518433,
0.33563271164894104,
-0.37847259640693665,
0.7988135814666748,
-0.05718795955181122,
-0.5174766778945923,
0.929641604423523,
0.8156746625900269,
1.0677438974380493,
-0.26814737915992737,
0.3736342787742615,
0.5538693070411682,
0.5178149342536926,
-0.26489192247390747,
0.001994600985199213,
-0.0035349498502910137,
-0.43920207023620605,
-0.3034713566303253,
-0.4398214817047119,
-0.8536442518234253,
0.08802581578493118,
-1.0821720361709595,
0.25685587525367737,
-0.394051194190979,
0.03936709463596344,
-0.5287249088287354,
-0.19350378215312958,
-1.0121444463729858,
0.1250440776348114,
0.011696348898112774,
0.6353442072868347,
-0.5269667506217957,
0.5526660680770874,
0.5654181241989136,
-0.22103531658649445,
-0.5412291288375854,
-0.2474699318408966,
-0.17853869497776031,
-0.630523145198822,
0.5173648595809937,
0.4806569516658783,
-0.15067492425441742,
0.23666147887706757,
-0.7423346638679504,
-0.4765866696834564,
1.182160496711731,
0.21248652040958405,
-1.4998555183410645,
0.3568933606147766,
0.3245570957660675,
0.2717115879058838,
-0.5744025707244873,
0.5738655924797058,
0.42532026767730713,
0.2994455099105835,
-0.2808285057544708,
-0.33265528082847595,
-0.11764296889305115,
-0.16997843980789185,
-0.22996698319911957,
0.38620373606681824,
-0.7374132871627808,
0.7215757966041565,
-0.023300651460886,
-0.25911277532577515,
0.2079380750656128,
0.14077028632164001,
0.044104378670454025,
0.2585983872413635,
0.1639610379934311,
0.8035191297531128,
0.9080401062965393,
-0.051004521548748016,
0.8867586255073547,
-0.6675696969032288,
0.5874480605125427,
1.299058437347412,
-0.3979634940624237,
1.0785378217697144,
-0.05872029811143875,
-0.29136931896209717,
0.6563835740089417,
0.4965628385543823,
-0.06204887852072716,
0.1654081642627716,
0.2071685791015625,
-0.2341398000717163,
-0.3859710097312927,
0.21589888632297516,
-0.3033689558506012,
0.08677380532026291,
0.48646172881126404,
-0.3901699483394623,
-0.01825251244008541,
-0.10122717916965485,
-0.18514986336231232,
-0.028123948723077774,
-0.6587595343589783,
0.5469902753829956,
0.07570166885852814,
-0.10565751045942307,
0.5050894618034363,
-0.033762235194444656,
0.4964360296726227,
-0.5080296397209167,
-0.20318272709846497,
-0.15286269783973694,
0.2600363492965698,
-0.18710511922836304,
-0.15306606888771057,
-0.14269669353961945,
0.13293719291687012,
-0.19581370055675507,
-0.2293466031551361,
0.5260630249977112,
-0.4307585656642914,
-0.6974091529846191,
0.5272505283355713,
0.4014958441257477,
-0.0326378270983696,
0.019431790336966515,
-0.5497292876243591,
-0.006429730448871851,
-0.31162357330322266,
-0.47425201535224915,
0.4367619752883911,
0.4553172290325165,
0.3473399579524994,
0.5124461054801941,
0.5397971868515015,
-0.02662969008088112,
-0.03327712044119835,
0.21537482738494873,
0.40127214789390564,
-0.6057344675064087,
-0.3906724452972412,
-0.6909259557723999,
0.48566097021102905,
-0.3057868480682373,
-0.1373026818037033,
0.8178398013114929,
0.7851508259773254,
1.2126259803771973,
-0.16076426208019257,
0.9902224540710449,
0.3524588346481323,
0.390308678150177,
-0.40902262926101685,
0.7315323352813721,
-0.7170663475990295,
0.36976689100265503,
-0.08797446638345718,
-1.210412859916687,
-0.06494447588920593,
0.3744314908981323,
-0.1915055811405182,
0.12052608281373978,
0.7235338091850281,
0.7471579313278198,
-0.3675926923751831,
0.27102982997894287,
0.6746582388877869,
0.3745019733905792,
0.02548462152481079,
0.6287383437156677,
0.7806597352027893,
-0.4450204372406006,
0.5648701786994934,
-0.2605716288089752,
-0.5270448923110962,
-0.3870077133178711,
-0.8758857846260071,
-0.8986670970916748,
-0.21711818873882294,
-0.4377865195274353,
0.13154900074005127,
-0.0112577173858881,
1.1874881982803345,
0.8228030800819397,
-0.9325987100601196,
-0.5083345174789429,
-0.14902998507022858,
-0.21004436910152435,
-0.6179357171058655,
-0.129145547747612,
0.4160929024219513,
-0.2569325268268585,
-1.0495915412902832,
0.1568061262369156,
0.533328115940094,
-0.013497118838131428,
-0.0935305804014206,
-0.013934248127043247,
0.38133642077445984,
0.34177061915397644,
0.8577039241790771,
0.07380205392837524,
-0.5020184516906738,
-0.08632361143827438,
0.32127535343170166,
0.20584897696971893,
-0.157836452126503,
0.9228314161300659,
-0.18717961013317108,
0.376776784658432,
0.07607893645763397,
0.708003044128418,
0.4691331088542938,
-0.013961534947156906,
0.478453129529953,
-0.22647292912006378,
-0.09567470103502274,
0.04252191260457039,
0.5094959139823914,
0.07295002788305283,
-0.08743380010128021,
0.3483777940273285,
-0.16382978856563568,
-0.8804164528846741,
-0.42864668369293213,
0.44602885842323303,
-0.5645605325698853,
-0.4359804093837738,
0.8631606698036194,
-0.31605932116508484,
-0.4477217197418213,
-0.2025972604751587,
0.06305839121341705,
-0.007229618262499571,
-0.25766876339912415,
0.8215940594673157,
0.6815241575241089,
0.1585705429315567,
-0.09895726293325424,
-0.5537371039390564,
-0.22695410251617432,
0.21367204189300537,
-0.934531033039093,
0.2913069725036621,
0.6165996193885803,
0.2139526903629303,
-0.5081721544265747,
-0.023376133292913437,
0.12711258232593536,
0.2716061770915985,
-0.013371944427490234,
0.24142327904701233,
-0.23217888176441193,
-0.42419514060020447,
0.03217773139476776,
0.3933137059211731,
0.024713344871997833,
-0.06792182475328445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08830v1 | Sequence graphs realizations and ambiguity in language models | 2024-02-13T22:22:51 | 2024-02-13T22:22:51 | Sammy Khalife, Yann Ponty, Laurent Bulteau | cs.DS | cs.DS, cs.CC, cs.CL | Several popular language models represent local contexts in an input text as
bags of words. Such representations are naturally encoded by a sequence graph
whose vertices are the distinct words occurring in x, with edges representing
the (ordered) co-occurrence of two words within a sliding window of size w.
However, this compressed representation is not generally bijective, and may
introduce some degree of ambiguity. Some sequence graphs may admit several
realizations as a sequence, while others may not admit any realization. In this
paper, we study the realizability and ambiguity of sequence graphs from a
combinatorial and computational point of view. We consider the existence and
enumeration of realizations of a sequence graph under multiple settings: window
size w, presence/absence of graph orientation, and presence/absence of weights
(multiplicities). When w = 2, we provide polynomial time algorithms for
realizability and enumeration in all cases except the undirected/weighted
setting, where we show the #P-hardness of enumeration. For a window of size at
least 3, we prove hardness of all variants, even when w is considered as a
constant, with the notable exception of the undirected/unweighted case for
which we propose an XP algorithms for both (realizability and enumeration)
problems, tight due to a corresponding W[1]-hardness result. We conclude with
an integer program formulation to solve the realizability problem, and with
dynamic programming to solve the enumeration problem. This work leaves open the
membership to NP for both problems, a non-trivial question due to the existence
of minimum realizations having exponential size on the instance encoding. | [
-0.31143656373023987,
-0.7704722881317139,
0.8141888976097107,
0.3574422597885132,
-0.15944230556488037,
0.4205116331577301,
-0.13709419965744019,
-0.6283912658691406,
0.1161215603351593,
0.09850174933671951,
-0.5613858699798584,
0.08007090538740158,
-0.7013829350471497,
0.5065087676048279,
-0.34115591645240784,
0.47327718138694763,
-0.1601589322090149,
-0.17395292222499847,
-0.1004631519317627,
-0.32099613547325134,
-0.28284895420074463,
-0.6694879531860352,
-0.1922231763601303,
-0.22705277800559998,
0.4023187458515167,
0.16464895009994507,
1.1392028331756592,
0.8071892261505127,
0.19350957870483398,
0.4270281493663788,
-0.2357902079820633,
0.09483495354652405,
-0.4906367361545563,
0.30275240540504456,
0.31924018263816833,
-0.33935242891311646,
-0.17434372007846832,
-0.09649961441755295,
1.1027870178222656,
1.1404353380203247,
0.1661192774772644,
0.11530455946922302,
0.07497972249984741,
0.5823165774345398,
-0.43953755497932434,
-0.09143238514661789,
-0.2853430509567261,
0.4030352532863617,
-0.1985698789358139,
-0.018518036231398582,
-0.5166819095611572,
-0.37340667843818665,
0.2024337351322174,
-0.592690110206604,
-0.13933223485946655,
0.2287663072347641,
0.9128922820091248,
0.04785789176821709,
-0.47508370876312256,
-0.32921576499938965,
-0.9022048711776733,
0.7813720703125,
-0.7823302745819092,
0.4892016351222992,
-0.05589163303375244,
0.2473367601633072,
-0.5927581787109375,
-0.6832907795906067,
-0.6664445400238037,
0.09277510643005371,
-0.23550352454185486,
-0.1118718683719635,
-0.180145725607872,
0.2836260199546814,
0.6326616406440735,
0.5226063132286072,
-0.8506510257720947,
0.09739592671394348,
-0.0799764096736908,
-0.15862251818180084,
0.35735929012298584,
0.148318812251091,
0.2880755364894867,
-0.0989888459444046,
0.013487383723258972,
0.07383999973535538,
-0.692904531955719,
-0.03237500414252281,
0.6632766723632812,
0.261444091796875,
-0.0016990385483950377,
0.6538816094398499,
-0.10385480523109436,
1.2527320384979248,
-0.2680426836013794,
0.04665641859173775,
0.423245906829834,
-0.05705150216817856,
-0.19821502268314362,
-0.11070060729980469,
0.48389387130737305,
-0.33840692043304443,
0.4230976998806,
-0.24055829644203186,
-0.024181168526411057,
-0.17423810064792633,
-0.01393637154251337,
-0.6475194692611694,
0.10420138388872147,
0.40482714772224426,
-0.5141746997833252,
-0.09700428694486618,
0.35630905628204346,
-0.3738703727722168,
-0.24636150896549225,
-0.19455909729003906,
0.45303794741630554,
-0.39630186557769775,
-0.2061501443386078,
-0.0062082926742732525,
-0.2817634046077728,
0.09808313101530075,
0.05348357930779457,
-0.3883570730686188,
0.4743834435939789,
0.7990736365318298,
0.9199370741844177,
0.31514936685562134,
-0.2361127883195877,
-0.41734716296195984,
-0.05392853915691376,
-0.2651500701904297,
0.009767601266503334,
-0.8720712065696716,
-0.34476661682128906,
0.019612692296504974,
-0.004536102991551161,
-0.251903235912323,
-0.25923460721969604,
0.08143136650323868,
-0.6573566794395447,
0.09333430975675583,
-0.10942693054676056,
-0.870654821395874,
-0.1992952674627304,
0.04964325577020645,
-0.4991163909435272,
0.6441598534584045,
0.28444746136665344,
-0.7811421751976013,
-0.052589062601327896,
-0.23000071942806244,
-0.6153435111045837,
0.07297731190919876,
-0.10890007019042969,
-0.2840350866317749,
0.22622042894363403,
-0.5000427961349487,
-0.04503212496638298,
0.09689399600028992,
0.10253631323575974,
-0.22680924832820892,
-0.6452704071998596,
0.2385355830192566,
-0.4125364422798157,
0.77988201379776,
0.4199613630771637,
-0.11710020899772644,
-0.13554449379444122,
-0.7325212359428406,
0.4231537878513336,
0.3192698657512665,
-0.368943989276886,
-0.2731623351573944,
0.42154356837272644,
-0.5425103306770325,
0.04713974893093109,
0.32676517963409424,
-0.5718247890472412,
0.49522897601127625,
-0.7132531404495239,
0.7743706107139587,
0.6456741690635681,
-0.06840822100639343,
0.32176724076271057,
0.0023569101467728615,
0.5000941753387451,
-0.007883179932832718,
0.07108967006206512,
-0.2481435388326645,
-0.9468910694122314,
-0.735773503780365,
0.1169903501868248,
0.4957689344882965,
0.7343418598175049,
-0.7943994402885437,
0.47363653779029846,
-0.25570905208587646,
-0.24495671689510345,
-0.04776042699813843,
-0.2689487338066101,
0.5842317342758179,
0.23752616345882416,
-0.07327061146497726,
-0.4087463617324829,
-0.6074697971343994,
-0.7755250334739685,
-0.23258565366268158,
-0.10701537132263184,
0.08989854902029037,
0.3896426856517792,
0.3180798292160034,
-0.040929362177848816,
1.067282795906067,
-0.8662199378013611,
0.512058675289154,
-0.11081472039222717,
0.5751035213470459,
0.5252898335456848,
0.5015196800231934,
0.48502758145332336,
-0.805126965045929,
-0.36557140946388245,
-0.3745346963405609,
-0.6379112005233765,
0.08357593417167664,
-0.12011907249689102,
0.14473149180412292,
0.014141678810119629,
0.02319725602865219,
-0.17225609719753265,
0.8049113750457764,
0.5178985595703125,
-0.16522715985774994,
0.5278233885765076,
-0.6013379096984863,
-0.17187123000621796,
-0.6601940393447876,
-0.18299318850040436,
-0.13740520179271698,
-0.4453466534614563,
-1.0438121557235718,
0.12322011590003967,
-0.18920916318893433,
-0.31262609362602234,
-0.20810842514038086,
0.3047977685928345,
-0.6189437508583069,
-0.3962938189506531,
0.03258547559380531,
0.15092569589614868,
-0.028198279440402985,
0.4846385717391968,
0.022442011162638664,
0.4269791543483734,
0.6217423677444458,
-0.7432727813720703,
0.17335528135299683,
0.08710500597953796,
-0.32683148980140686,
0.11026737838983536,
-0.5881025195121765,
0.271275132894516,
-0.4111611545085907,
0.19559144973754883,
-0.8157064318656921,
0.011755266226828098,
0.5649358034133911,
-0.31009137630462646,
0.1794748455286026,
-0.34927865862846375,
-0.39763402938842773,
-0.748775839805603,
-0.1021479070186615,
0.8789864182472229,
0.47276973724365234,
-0.28320667147636414,
0.007747758645564318,
0.176436647772789,
0.2358849197626114,
-0.6454230546951294,
-0.3331454396247864,
0.06413242965936661,
0.004095941781997681,
-0.6230895519256592,
0.38731908798217773,
-0.20096899569034576,
-0.24541325867176056,
0.013890636153519154,
0.08959705382585526,
-0.21789903938770294,
-0.009106503799557686,
0.3726150691509247,
-0.1070455014705658,
0.027541445568203926,
-0.001983068184927106,
-0.20048928260803223,
-0.07020466774702072,
-0.5613388419151306,
-0.4916498064994812,
0.6706462502479553,
-0.24840737879276276,
-0.5463660955429077,
-0.05358688533306122,
0.5251244902610779,
0.3002210557460785,
-0.053731441497802734,
0.6377825140953064,
0.38144776225090027,
-0.7213478088378906,
0.021329624578356743,
0.05641281604766846,
0.2385077327489853,
-0.5247923135757446,
0.11526031792163849,
-0.7040479779243469,
-1.032712459564209,
0.8303794860839844,
-0.03776315599679947,
-0.09698764979839325,
0.15183553099632263,
0.4333536922931671,
0.05267633497714996,
1.2913126945495605,
0.27585288882255554,
0.2210044264793396,
0.3917158246040344,
-0.4471243917942047,
0.8659534454345703,
-0.8428192734718323,
0.13904441893100739,
-0.47137928009033203,
-0.5966765880584717,
-0.9135903716087341,
-0.2265467494726181,
0.5698854923248291,
0.06330621987581253,
-0.3757108449935913,
0.540709912776947,
-0.5751921534538269,
0.48275384306907654,
0.5911234021186829,
-0.17339704930782318,
0.08823751658201218,
-0.2897889316082001,
-0.13090576231479645,
-0.18800511956214905,
-0.8105688691139221,
-0.2936217188835144,
0.5365030765533447,
0.0893135592341423,
0.22921957075595856,
0.3137035071849823,
0.7331130504608154,
0.37718403339385986,
-0.19754743576049805,
-0.7866472601890564,
0.509935736656189,
-0.22447490692138672,
-0.18934816122055054,
-0.5274302959442139,
-0.6352429986000061,
-1.2974735498428345,
0.28575554490089417,
-0.0379449762403965,
-1.1674364805221558,
0.6009430289268494,
0.2363142967224121,
-0.37493932247161865,
0.34685492515563965,
-0.6040840744972229,
0.8681127429008484,
-0.15473847091197968,
-0.24668678641319275,
-0.15984311699867249,
-0.9403478503227234,
0.31449174880981445,
0.23577071726322174,
0.46463337540626526,
-0.1165757104754448,
0.3110099732875824,
0.4734320342540741,
-1.020363688468933,
0.6669720411300659,
-0.15850460529327393,
0.123073048889637,
0.5675525665283203,
0.43599843978881836,
0.7662395238876343,
-0.1773368865251541,
-0.1217469871044159,
-0.02976502664387226,
0.2010648250579834,
-0.3774348497390747,
-0.5688667297363281,
0.5501633286476135,
-0.5149959921836853,
-0.6145336627960205,
-0.6655623912811279,
-0.48392486572265625,
-0.11935394257307053,
0.3180560767650604,
0.28233101963996887,
1.0100992918014526,
-0.07980429381132126,
-0.41894063353538513,
0.2743673622608185,
-0.34402239322662354,
0.6680915951728821,
0.061650339514017105,
-0.1353580802679062,
0.026565102860331535,
1.4477953910827637,
0.6511141657829285,
0.3222993016242981,
0.28148123621940613,
0.08141561597585678,
-0.008127677254378796,
-0.5598234534263611,
-0.5425577163696289,
0.18181993067264557,
-0.5522590279579163,
-0.0010128184221684933,
-0.10239450633525848,
-0.4995938241481781,
-0.3562375009059906,
-0.14731474220752716,
-0.0025822846218943596,
-0.9765653610229492,
-0.13961057364940643,
0.0988730639219284,
0.07858901470899582,
0.9040500521659851,
-0.0801115557551384,
0.3839718699455261,
-0.6163780689239502,
0.20220308005809784,
0.25078392028808594,
0.5243207812309265,
0.25221359729766846,
-0.2831433415412903,
-0.3321019411087036,
-0.03026033192873001,
-0.12773121893405914,
-1.3589482307434082,
0.4949933886528015,
0.19466854631900787,
0.2571468651294708,
0.5922216773033142,
0.05199190601706505,
0.7346132397651672,
-0.6443309187889099,
0.6843726634979248,
-0.1731591373682022,
-1.0915309190750122,
0.07739908248186111,
-0.16221250593662262,
0.1294342428445816,
0.26321694254875183,
0.3013826012611389,
-0.849823534488678,
-0.406925767660141,
-0.9026194214820862,
-0.9512327313423157,
0.5902303457260132,
0.39278194308280945,
0.05904731526970863,
-0.07050397992134094,
0.5233501195907593,
-0.11413860321044922,
0.3998199701309204,
-0.3848932385444641,
-0.37993982434272766,
-0.26946622133255005,
-0.051746152341365814,
0.3542615473270416,
-0.3787490725517273,
0.10288693755865097,
-0.3395770788192749,
0.3002147674560547,
0.049367163330316544,
0.5990763902664185,
0.0967959463596344,
-0.20773643255233765,
0.1709059327840805,
0.2814585864543915,
0.6305742263793945,
0.9493337869644165,
-0.26790139079093933,
0.44464111328125,
-0.17663854360580444,
-0.12594541907310486,
0.2196015864610672,
-0.15129441022872925,
-0.27577799558639526,
-0.115799181163311,
0.4401722848415375,
0.8177869319915771,
0.23316484689712524,
-0.7120180726051331,
0.3602485954761505,
0.28154584765434265,
0.2781114876270294,
-0.38473042845726013,
-0.06600247323513031,
-0.25894895195961,
-0.15598192811012268,
0.21581558883190155,
-0.1049262285232544,
0.3981807827949524,
-0.5854396224021912,
0.10717301070690155,
0.4793742001056671,
-0.31937500834465027,
-0.3655760884284973,
0.5104513764381409,
0.02736038528382778,
-0.6742823719978333,
0.9758725762367249,
-0.8907691836357117,
-0.8189921975135803,
0.8594635128974915,
0.8221189379692078,
0.5974225401878357,
0.07726719975471497,
0.16793709993362427,
0.4842202067375183,
0.10575710982084274,
0.058325592428445816,
0.36178484559059143,
0.07067804783582687,
-1.010947823524475,
-0.3302774429321289,
-0.49216124415397644,
-0.590753436088562,
-0.42238539457321167,
-0.4220088720321655,
-0.07574541866779327,
-0.42274370789527893,
-0.26419028639793396,
0.016598470509052277,
-0.26657038927078247,
-0.34808674454689026,
0.02207312546670437,
0.1524108499288559,
0.6990623474121094,
-0.787786066532135,
0.7293234467506409,
0.5659225583076477,
-0.12308378517627716,
-0.5813598036766052,
-0.3023691475391388,
0.12156692147254944,
-0.7638513445854187,
0.26284629106521606,
0.08264265209436417,
0.11532917618751526,
0.2886529266834259,
-0.3433225750923157,
-0.8316438794136047,
0.8097429871559143,
0.2323346585035324,
-0.5163366198539734,
0.03961287438869476,
0.3065181076526642,
0.38753825426101685,
-0.4006495177745819,
0.20409215986728668,
0.5337404608726501,
0.949845552444458,
0.21732893586158752,
-0.8095551133155823,
0.06450703740119934,
-0.17367814481258392,
0.25577086210250854,
0.3817638158798218,
-0.5717460513114929,
1.021225094795227,
-0.20965828001499176,
-0.4718397259712219,
0.19249701499938965,
0.4763057827949524,
0.012714938260614872,
0.07567396759986877,
0.6139400601387024,
0.5847778916358948,
1.0367637872695923,
-0.44977810978889465,
1.3258626461029053,
-0.4162096679210663,
0.19900919497013092,
0.9015538692474365,
-0.20176725089550018,
0.42842262983322144,
0.2907211482524872,
-0.55997234582901,
0.600896418094635,
0.8497180938720703,
0.17245441675186157,
0.1204991564154625,
0.726026177406311,
-0.2705213725566864,
-0.22820286452770233,
0.052047666162252426,
-0.2124541699886322,
0.020262284204363823,
0.41024208068847656,
-0.24076904356479645,
-0.030804652720689774,
-0.17584164440631866,
0.15012432634830475,
0.03085588850080967,
0.006482338532805443,
0.35005491971969604,
0.05895853042602539,
-0.47800034284591675,
0.6315920352935791,
0.34499573707580566,
0.27915146946907043,
-0.578591525554657,
-0.16357240080833435,
0.10774645209312439,
-0.16422399878501892,
-0.38852211833000183,
-0.8538831472396851,
0.3957712948322296,
-0.3897887170314789,
-0.10597515106201172,
-0.17208699882030487,
0.5012468099594116,
-0.27807945013046265,
-0.5573943257331848,
-0.10193417221307755,
0.4982803165912628,
0.31165236234664917,
0.23284058272838593,
-0.34396302700042725,
0.18756283819675446,
-0.14334769546985626,
-0.2857409715652466,
0.1431986689567566,
0.25207388401031494,
-0.3520950675010681,
0.6284135580062866,
0.0650206059217453,
0.07802700996398926,
0.41472867131233215,
0.1511455476284027,
0.6001879572868347,
-0.4477207064628601,
-0.42582425475120544,
-0.8397729992866516,
0.23140878975391388,
-0.05172516033053398,
0.012671094387769699,
0.5918460488319397,
0.6843878030776978,
0.4680194854736328,
0.07878617197275162,
0.7616913318634033,
-0.5084078311920166,
0.061978794634342194,
-0.18767915666103363,
0.06377028673887253,
-0.3439508378505707,
0.06773553043603897,
-0.24024313688278198,
-0.7573911547660828,
-0.4845113754272461,
0.7138482332229614,
-0.40927964448928833,
-0.19237308204174042,
0.49191007018089294,
0.47237032651901245,
0.1253640502691269,
0.04587860405445099,
0.048582304269075394,
0.2678011655807495,
0.12633389234542847,
0.7189405560493469,
0.5320293307304382,
-0.17175470292568207,
0.2918317914009094,
-0.2451578676700592,
-0.3572731018066406,
-0.16164034605026245,
-0.9214522838592529,
-0.16164742410182953,
-0.7901321649551392,
-0.24309252202510834,
-0.4284120798110962,
0.035115815699100494,
0.7738662958145142,
0.5547171235084534,
-0.6704245805740356,
-0.40443047881126404,
0.004818683490157127,
0.9853460192680359,
-0.6073959469795227,
-0.2736853361129761,
0.42132309079170227,
-0.1026950404047966,
-0.855812132358551,
0.42697030305862427,
0.4059229791164398,
0.31106579303741455,
-0.21853284537792206,
-0.37053778767585754,
-0.11411572247743607,
0.1980445235967636,
0.515954852104187,
0.9237398505210876,
-0.28458037972450256,
-0.9644104242324829,
-0.195357546210289,
0.34504377841949463,
0.34073498845100403,
1.0489624738693237,
-0.8820818066596985,
0.5816221833229065,
0.9668402075767517,
0.1261601448059082,
0.5194765329360962,
0.12238447368144989,
0.7809985876083374,
-0.9917621612548828,
0.49692070484161377,
0.0432886965572834,
0.5710392594337463,
0.041196804493665695,
-0.25913459062576294,
0.6498714685440063,
0.46847495436668396,
-0.3384209871292114,
-1.0867528915405273,
0.9561280608177185,
-0.8628755211830139,
-0.2999328076839447,
0.6853486895561218,
-0.1611093133687973,
-0.06326127797365189,
-0.28114020824432373,
0.08379363268613815,
0.3407354950904846,
0.03866402804851532,
0.2740946114063263,
0.7119358777999878,
-0.630073070526123,
0.16204680502414703,
-0.34406352043151855,
0.30783072113990784,
-0.019945675507187843,
-0.1843058168888092,
-0.15041565895080566,
0.4558102786540985,
-0.11977589875459671,
0.33474093675613403,
0.6679235100746155,
-0.002981322817504406,
-0.29122960567474365,
-0.14177919924259186,
-0.26918303966522217,
-0.13827849924564362,
-0.3027799129486084,
-0.1959686130285263,
0.3650663495063782,
0.1681993156671524,
0.04527783766388893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08788v1 | Syllable based DNN-HMM Cantonese Speech to Text System | 2024-02-13T20:54:24 | 2024-02-13T20:54:24 | Timothy Wong, Claire Li, Sam Lam, Billy Chiu, Qin Lu, Minglei Li, Dan Xiong, Roy Shing Yu, Vincent T. Y. Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, 94-06, I.2.7 | This paper reports our work on building up a Cantonese Speech-to-Text (STT)
system with a syllable based acoustic model. This is a part of an effort in
building a STT system to aid dyslexic students who have cognitive deficiency in
writing skills but have no problem expressing their ideas through speech. For
Cantonese speech recognition, the basic unit of acoustic models can either be
the conventional Initial-Final (IF) syllables, or the Onset-Nucleus-Coda (ONC)
syllables where finals are further split into nucleus and coda to reflect the
intra-syllable variations in Cantonese. By using the Kaldi toolkit, our system
is trained using the stochastic gradient descent optimization model with the
aid of GPUs for the hybrid Deep Neural Network and Hidden Markov Model
(DNN-HMM) with and without I-vector based speaker adaptive training technique.
The input features of the same Gaussian Mixture Model with speaker adaptive
training (GMM-SAT) to DNN are used in all cases. Experiments show that the
ONC-based syllable acoustic modeling with I-vector based DNN-HMM achieves the
best performance with the word error rate (WER) of 9.66% and the real time
factor (RTF) of 1.38812. | [
-0.0379941500723362,
-0.9708060026168823,
0.46566686034202576,
0.4776291251182556,
-0.20955954492092133,
0.1965339332818985,
0.05380679666996002,
-0.21381495893001556,
0.2990023195743561,
0.2310764640569687,
-0.5585212111473083,
-0.3601441979408264,
-0.43802329897880554,
0.10280022025108337,
0.06418069452047348,
0.41661781072616577,
0.331078439950943,
0.3195018768310547,
0.42844629287719727,
-0.0184030719101429,
-0.6442316174507141,
-0.6304812431335449,
-1.018589973449707,
-0.4747849106788635,
0.4448484182357788,
0.2719414532184601,
0.5193746089935303,
0.6400940418243408,
0.20572936534881592,
0.26180773973464966,
-0.39308780431747437,
-0.05946097522974014,
-0.36311861872673035,
-0.26015326380729675,
0.14889824390411377,
-0.3590451180934906,
-0.6330366134643555,
-0.22299787402153015,
0.7719785571098328,
0.583055317401886,
-0.47600457072257996,
-0.1316252201795578,
0.008360952138900757,
0.6209787130355835,
-0.24331355094909668,
0.17698752880096436,
-0.4950907826423645,
0.2967316806316376,
-0.04027373716235161,
-0.48279884457588196,
-0.3217105567455292,
-0.18017880618572235,
0.11046158522367477,
-0.6012125611305237,
-0.23696888983249664,
-0.3129681646823883,
0.6246652603149414,
0.5333222150802612,
-0.3828161954879761,
-0.24422572553157806,
-0.6874797344207764,
0.7159782648086548,
-1.1785767078399658,
0.516998291015625,
0.4702425003051758,
0.13917624950408936,
-0.2591995298862457,
-0.7464845180511475,
-0.6474971771240234,
-0.6603336334228516,
0.36137816309928894,
0.580682098865509,
0.054751649498939514,
0.3372996747493744,
0.259192556142807,
0.46163204312324524,
-0.785616934299469,
0.5046765208244324,
-0.21103380620479584,
-0.056039247661828995,
0.6390447616577148,
0.24347278475761414,
0.5192485451698303,
-0.27206164598464966,
-0.5165140628814697,
-0.1267099231481552,
-0.2554655075073242,
0.19394449889659882,
0.5808328986167908,
0.5825967788696289,
-0.23768368363380432,
0.4967880845069885,
-0.17644281685352325,
0.6021080613136292,
0.1437743902206421,
-0.4971899092197418,
0.12626078724861145,
-0.2821875214576721,
-0.292816698551178,
0.5963861346244812,
0.6703842282295227,
-0.041478972882032394,
0.041080694645643234,
0.0780128762125969,
-0.20658870041370392,
0.23014667630195618,
0.08011560142040253,
-0.5696364045143127,
-0.41385650634765625,
0.19600583612918854,
-0.4978380799293518,
-0.365463525056839,
-0.11026138067245483,
-0.37175601720809937,
-0.14785297214984894,
-0.5565268993377686,
0.5406622290611267,
-0.6269064545631409,
-0.5139448642730713,
0.1855156421661377,
-0.21955975890159607,
-0.042575910687446594,
0.12673217058181763,
-0.7760297656059265,
0.3279859721660614,
0.5282694101333618,
1.0154495239257812,
-0.019901784136891365,
-0.32865312695503235,
-0.44591742753982544,
-0.03253694996237755,
-0.3794028162956238,
0.30183514952659607,
-0.2160068154335022,
-0.574152410030365,
-0.30844366550445557,
-0.27588021755218506,
-0.46988677978515625,
-0.6737669706344604,
0.6651864647865295,
-0.2520838975906372,
-0.15823185443878174,
0.12193728983402252,
-0.7796795964241028,
-0.28999215364456177,
-0.1946176290512085,
-0.8662870526313782,
1.3671127557754517,
0.1529468297958374,
-0.7716410160064697,
0.0008860268862918019,
-0.6146095991134644,
-0.3499816656112671,
0.3618505895137787,
-0.027749400585889816,
-0.08837072551250458,
-0.05907250940799713,
0.04369378462433815,
0.33489835262298584,
0.09324251860380173,
0.3428451120853424,
0.0882139652967453,
-0.5682139992713928,
0.3213793635368347,
-0.8089069128036499,
1.0694166421890259,
0.3059752881526947,
-0.522436797618866,
0.13407692313194275,
-1.1643803119659424,
0.17881500720977783,
-0.0452786460518837,
-0.8805568218231201,
-0.2947996258735657,
-0.1661231815814972,
0.23293238878250122,
0.09359467774629593,
0.2085261344909668,
-0.5040271282196045,
0.007103689946234226,
-0.550741970539093,
0.5024999976158142,
0.6469847559928894,
-0.13285116851329803,
0.11972446739673615,
-0.28835970163345337,
0.3339599668979645,
0.314104288816452,
-0.1898837834596634,
0.09937617182731628,
-0.7340682148933411,
-0.5386853218078613,
-0.3772810101509094,
0.3761843144893646,
1.1135578155517578,
-0.9404175281524658,
0.580696702003479,
-0.044702719897031784,
-0.5003088116645813,
-0.6220287680625916,
-0.1810513585805893,
0.2821466624736786,
0.6257025599479675,
0.1938537210226059,
-0.21308256685733795,
-0.5596924424171448,
-0.6543633937835693,
0.1379571557044983,
-0.5068977475166321,
-0.025108566507697105,
0.3633860647678375,
0.19367410242557526,
-0.2448238730430603,
0.572043240070343,
-0.31673815846443176,
-0.12207332998514175,
-0.31008848547935486,
0.027164921164512634,
0.1482928991317749,
0.31136491894721985,
0.2778143882751465,
-0.9621210098266602,
-0.4887634813785553,
0.09629492461681366,
-0.5820084810256958,
-0.19135774672031403,
0.03069615550339222,
0.22633960843086243,
0.30837053060531616,
0.3896787166595459,
-0.38251256942749023,
0.7609949111938477,
0.48622119426727295,
-0.09543686360120773,
0.8299236297607422,
-0.34684261679649353,
0.14596666395664215,
-1.2292943000793457,
-0.05244773253798485,
0.04991777613759041,
-0.0443328432738781,
-1.0391991138458252,
-0.12647688388824463,
-0.057969387620687485,
-0.12676119804382324,
-0.5462154150009155,
0.4364819824695587,
-0.10160188376903534,
0.08956801146268845,
-0.5145651698112488,
0.28757065534591675,
-0.18790952861309052,
0.706838846206665,
0.07979511469602585,
0.669516921043396,
0.5734306573867798,
-0.8191205859184265,
0.7046493291854858,
0.2006882280111313,
-0.23024030029773712,
0.4084709882736206,
-0.5814494490623474,
0.07501359283924103,
0.2760561406612396,
0.2559524476528168,
-0.8448411226272583,
0.18745632469654083,
0.28939107060432434,
-0.5089012980461121,
0.41066309809684753,
0.019504573196172714,
-0.13770386576652527,
-0.3880070149898529,
0.08160331845283508,
0.49285659193992615,
0.18163160979747772,
-0.5748295783996582,
0.34362950921058655,
0.2635059654712677,
-0.517369270324707,
-0.6600619554519653,
-0.6299981474876404,
0.38058462738990784,
-0.2475394904613495,
-0.6892515420913696,
0.3545885980129242,
-0.05812544748187065,
-0.2436130940914154,
-0.041443921625614166,
0.12335524708032608,
-0.4693392813205719,
0.03516668081283569,
0.13054630160331726,
0.1458379477262497,
-0.481784850358963,
0.20868240296840668,
-0.23461705446243286,
-0.20001237094402313,
-0.36968907713890076,
-0.5264946818351746,
0.5736364126205444,
-0.029362862929701805,
-0.0666288435459137,
-0.9493706822395325,
0.5978478789329529,
0.24752937257289886,
-0.04776041954755783,
0.35808849334716797,
0.6682373881340027,
-0.29330286383628845,
-0.39253297448158264,
-0.14035414159297943,
-0.17081233859062195,
-0.46567827463150024,
0.7855451107025146,
-0.6598128080368042,
-0.9297046065330505,
0.4433828592300415,
0.08824218809604645,
-0.5049536228179932,
0.23151880502700806,
0.6481698751449585,
0.07983308285474777,
0.5973792672157288,
0.7400585412979126,
-0.32087811827659607,
0.42996200919151306,
-0.09965552389621735,
0.3159056305885315,
-0.6854105591773987,
0.15566453337669373,
-0.2711259722709656,
-0.20349743962287903,
-0.6002053618431091,
-0.4787238836288452,
0.024194950237870216,
0.10894443094730377,
-0.11608684808015823,
0.20083767175674438,
-0.49834632873535156,
-0.15729045867919922,
0.8278413414955139,
0.29344984889030457,
0.2108933925628662,
-0.1650635004043579,
-0.37013673782348633,
0.018147829920053482,
-0.9521227478981018,
-0.40902990102767944,
0.689760148525238,
0.5584614276885986,
0.6847043633460999,
0.08376061171293259,
0.4973837733268738,
0.297775000333786,
-0.38714364171028137,
-1.1037729978561401,
0.723331868648529,
-0.46306154131889343,
-0.20450985431671143,
-0.6603055000305176,
-0.7204017043113708,
-0.5408334136009216,
0.018176835030317307,
0.2595532238483429,
-0.7571044564247131,
0.06641383469104767,
-0.19766339659690857,
-0.39297905564308167,
0.6594430804252625,
-0.445799320936203,
0.5803354978561401,
-0.21846804022789001,
0.17257936298847198,
-0.097230464220047,
-0.45769762992858887,
0.12654411792755127,
0.03833227604627609,
-0.2567060589790344,
-0.07165324687957764,
0.16701968014240265,
0.8454405665397644,
-0.6234477758407593,
0.8453147411346436,
-0.34905800223350525,
-0.34157952666282654,
0.5190930962562561,
-0.16706658899784088,
0.2388383001089096,
-0.1789855808019638,
-0.1799088567495346,
0.37022867798805237,
-0.041127219796180725,
-0.17221277952194214,
-0.5675011277198792,
0.5386496186256409,
-0.7979748249053955,
-0.5171491503715515,
-0.3181050419807434,
-0.7615707516670227,
-0.09074334800243378,
-0.05145103856921196,
0.31723347306251526,
0.7841578125953674,
-0.25575459003448486,
-0.015112532302737236,
0.6384234428405762,
-0.34655219316482544,
0.6326285600662231,
0.21596264839172363,
-0.0023960694670677185,
-0.5589260458946228,
1.024375081062317,
0.48334914445877075,
0.2874452471733093,
0.5747044086456299,
0.4315842390060425,
-0.43395254015922546,
-0.560550332069397,
-0.7843834757804871,
0.1091587170958519,
-0.5903169512748718,
0.25512275099754333,
-0.4606272280216217,
-0.6891361474990845,
-0.5167548060417175,
0.20091377198696136,
-0.2693551778793335,
-0.6718628406524658,
-0.47423219680786133,
-0.27059781551361084,
0.554074227809906,
0.8231658339500427,
-0.08912605047225952,
0.4871344268321991,
-0.7658662796020508,
0.32502058148384094,
0.22845497727394104,
0.22554588317871094,
0.34061476588249207,
-0.8809535503387451,
-0.42576104402542114,
0.20016130805015564,
-0.28187108039855957,
-0.7578843235969543,
0.5391094088554382,
0.37241432070732117,
0.523354172706604,
0.10525017231702805,
-0.0243583545088768,
0.7344377636909485,
-0.5813061594963074,
0.7955312728881836,
0.18493607640266418,
-0.7973923683166504,
0.564931333065033,
-0.3735710382461548,
0.21041017770767212,
0.026036974042654037,
0.23167990148067474,
-0.5645195841789246,
-0.19475547969341278,
-0.36925968527793884,
-0.7694121599197388,
0.6421714425086975,
0.19201576709747314,
-0.2627570927143097,
0.2869523763656616,
0.33974793553352356,
0.023025143891572952,
0.014011225663125515,
-0.5249624848365784,
-0.4859139919281006,
-0.3831489682197571,
-0.5652746558189392,
-0.12828534841537476,
-0.36098918318748474,
0.08493699133396149,
-0.06304217875003815,
0.8398609757423401,
-0.23755991458892822,
0.12330561876296997,
0.3752880394458771,
0.1038871482014656,
0.12357257306575775,
0.3332619071006775,
0.7479921579360962,
0.36696186661720276,
-0.18376514315605164,
-0.18551219999790192,
0.2413112223148346,
-1.02223801612854,
0.5176024436950684,
0.18911591172218323,
-0.1646517813205719,
0.1439649909734726,
0.05308821424841881,
1.270244836807251,
0.2908995449542999,
-0.36211636662483215,
0.2285984754562378,
-0.11768078804016113,
-0.3138870596885681,
-0.2622987627983093,
-0.02080312743782997,
0.2982335686683655,
0.2501280903816223,
0.5227563381195068,
-0.18443185091018677,
0.11784486472606659,
-0.41981691122055054,
0.5301398634910583,
0.07820349931716919,
-0.6113805174827576,
-0.25900375843048096,
0.5031982064247131,
0.037125252187252045,
-0.6455939412117004,
0.44528716802597046,
0.03417566418647766,
-0.5696592330932617,
0.6622635722160339,
0.8058562874794006,
1.0220884084701538,
-0.6165212392807007,
0.3098486363887787,
0.23561833798885345,
0.0023249636869877577,
0.11558663100004196,
0.5445614457130432,
-0.0366659015417099,
-0.5747866630554199,
-0.27308744192123413,
-0.7784021496772766,
-0.3899883031845093,
0.21080687642097473,
-0.6493803858757019,
-0.054853636771440506,
-0.48481032252311707,
-0.38111862540245056,
0.007069393061101437,
0.24381116032600403,
-0.10366091877222061,
0.6429194808006287,
0.23185859620571136,
0.8184382319450378,
-0.5325510501861572,
1.0531264543533325,
0.6193913817405701,
-0.19174382090568542,
-1.3592557907104492,
-0.00642085075378418,
0.019894137978553772,
-0.5758551955223083,
0.9011865258216858,
0.05607493594288826,
-0.24459531903266907,
0.3063223361968994,
0.03460356965661049,
-0.7576978802680969,
1.0476820468902588,
0.06914655864238739,
-0.7211418151855469,
0.03488325700163841,
0.44258496165275574,
0.48620468378067017,
-0.3044619858264923,
-0.0052056931890547276,
0.40198248624801636,
0.3378687798976898,
0.14109881222248077,
-1.3416106700897217,
-0.3257063329219818,
-0.27432557940483093,
0.2526806890964508,
-0.2175806760787964,
-0.7477622032165527,
1.0028775930404663,
0.023690687492489815,
-0.3608953356742859,
0.33654505014419556,
0.6165210008621216,
0.4284574091434479,
0.5240092277526855,
0.4867240786552429,
0.9916102886199951,
0.9479033946990967,
-0.01554443035274744,
0.679007351398468,
-0.16309261322021484,
-0.06864776462316513,
1.0479896068572998,
-0.3652395009994507,
1.0367398262023926,
0.285006046295166,
-0.2753976583480835,
0.28880178928375244,
0.7230685949325562,
0.3067582845687866,
0.41188353300094604,
0.40699610114097595,
-0.485378623008728,
0.13429179787635803,
-0.11210604012012482,
-0.24533893167972565,
0.6474336385726929,
0.1631380170583725,
0.13798409700393677,
0.19165612757205963,
0.22327899932861328,
-0.27903464436531067,
0.07143102586269379,
-0.5152125954627991,
0.9016161561012268,
0.5668303370475769,
-0.1867472231388092,
0.7143900990486145,
-0.10861477255821228,
0.8637628555297852,
-0.7306280136108398,
0.01691020280122757,
0.0014415635960176587,
0.263609915971756,
-0.2010844498872757,
-0.5492696166038513,
-0.09541437774896622,
-0.11651251465082169,
-0.40030479431152344,
0.36144208908081055,
0.8079761862754822,
-0.6174080967903137,
-0.6391701102256775,
0.5996173024177551,
0.4393966794013977,
0.233652263879776,
0.025416197255253792,
-0.7293519973754883,
0.08936834335327148,
0.03265799582004547,
-0.20111916959285736,
0.21967455744743347,
0.6026742458343506,
-0.03580141440033913,
0.7178518772125244,
0.5850598216056824,
0.507254421710968,
0.41684913635253906,
0.48684418201446533,
0.5404501557350159,
-0.9374660849571228,
-1.0480419397354126,
-0.6374414563179016,
0.37272366881370544,
0.27948427200317383,
-0.2756100296974182,
0.7979620695114136,
0.43124493956565857,
0.6172181963920593,
-0.04792141914367676,
0.9959732294082642,
0.2911238372325897,
0.6201486587524414,
-0.5752418041229248,
0.9959070086479187,
-0.5558134913444519,
-0.05143929645419121,
-0.34013015031814575,
-0.7693420052528381,
0.03223159909248352,
0.4978266656398773,
0.2108030617237091,
0.1590799242258072,
0.5523609519004822,
0.8996513485908508,
0.269989550113678,
0.3871508538722992,
0.727836549282074,
0.16161620616912842,
0.22072194516658783,
0.5668463706970215,
0.9044414162635803,
-0.6030483245849609,
0.2095746397972107,
-0.35278233885765076,
-0.4139735698699951,
-0.2712194621562958,
-0.5935106873512268,
-0.46436217427253723,
-0.6595394611358643,
-0.39306867122650146,
-0.1486266851425171,
0.11331860721111298,
0.6150520443916321,
0.4513797163963318,
-0.562566339969635,
-0.5677584409713745,
0.1830790638923645,
-0.20735299587249756,
-0.49778977036476135,
-0.27421900629997253,
0.6202988028526306,
-0.14334499835968018,
-0.6864905953407288,
0.8018019199371338,
0.48214924335479736,
0.1756773293018341,
-0.10802210867404938,
-0.34955474734306335,
-0.49664822220802307,
0.2289150357246399,
0.5434176921844482,
0.20504409074783325,
-0.7644613981246948,
-0.3089905381202698,
-0.026858603581786156,
-0.2502210736274719,
0.25163495540618896,
0.5011318325996399,
-0.47669219970703125,
0.3540889322757721,
0.35896623134613037,
0.5711248517036438,
0.19521735608577728,
0.13559721410274506,
0.4347255825996399,
-0.5904580354690552,
0.39265793561935425,
0.3488861322402954,
0.24573884904384613,
0.5375471711158752,
-0.423063188791275,
0.28259238600730896,
0.4293881356716156,
-0.6789731979370117,
-0.7849621176719666,
0.1562843918800354,
-1.2988426685333252,
-0.14856378734111786,
0.9533438682556152,
-0.20653149485588074,
-0.28621843457221985,
-0.3408682346343994,
-0.5707946419715881,
0.5600541830062866,
-0.23955656588077545,
0.5325315594673157,
0.42761966586112976,
-0.09300771355628967,
-0.062260258942842484,
-0.5911900401115417,
0.4655399024486542,
0.330885112285614,
-0.2565132975578308,
0.015766656026244164,
0.20644420385360718,
0.07367826998233795,
0.06633422523736954,
0.8412671089172363,
0.19582292437553406,
0.2565704584121704,
0.5603690147399902,
0.013183677569031715,
-0.19698935747146606,
-0.31829383969306946,
-0.4605957567691803,
0.028908587992191315,
-0.19531941413879395,
-0.3644261658191681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08787v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08787v4 | Rethinking Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T20:51:58 | 2024-07-02T02:15:50 | Sijia Liu, Yuanshun Yao, Jinghan Jia, Stephen Casper, Nathalie Baracaldo, Peter Hase, Yuguang Yao, Chris Yuhao Liu, Xiaojun Xu, Hang Li, Kush R. Varshney, Mohit Bansal, Sanmi Koyejo, Yang Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We explore machine unlearning (MU) in the domain of large language models
(LLMs), referred to as LLM unlearning. This initiative aims to eliminate
undesirable data influence (e.g., sensitive or illegal information) and the
associated model capabilities, while maintaining the integrity of essential
knowledge generation and not affecting causally unrelated information. We
envision LLM unlearning becoming a pivotal element in the life-cycle management
of LLMs, potentially standing as an essential foundation for developing
generative AI that is not only safe, secure, and trustworthy, but also
resource-efficient without the need of full retraining. We navigate the
unlearning landscape in LLMs from conceptual formulation, methodologies,
metrics, and applications. In particular, we highlight the often-overlooked
aspects of existing LLM unlearning research, e.g., unlearning scope, data-model
interaction, and multifaceted efficacy assessment. We also draw connections
between LLM unlearning and related areas such as model editing, influence
functions, model explanation, adversarial training, and reinforcement learning.
Furthermore, we outline an effective assessment framework for LLM unlearning
and explore its applications in copyright and privacy safeguards and
sociotechnical harm reduction. | [
-0.0839456170797348,
-0.8783451914787292,
0.38550299406051636,
-0.2770666778087616,
-0.22368650138378143,
0.5204347372055054,
-0.434365451335907,
-0.2674534022808075,
-0.3391979932785034,
0.8058561086654663,
-0.4381791651248932,
-0.41973876953125,
-0.6534098982810974,
-0.4331977963447571,
-0.48831549286842346,
1.0950888395309448,
0.032509177923202515,
0.17917150259017944,
-0.5662634968757629,
-0.12831546366214752,
-0.35944274067878723,
-0.6465529203414917,
-0.6738564372062683,
-0.6945133209228516,
0.6489579081535339,
0.45106086134910583,
0.5112407207489014,
0.6688079833984375,
0.28760838508605957,
0.2697531282901764,
-0.40468713641166687,
0.21075572073459625,
-0.8017551898956299,
0.2675914466381073,
-0.10673688352108002,
-0.3949030339717865,
-0.4127950966358185,
-0.024473048746585846,
0.7515988349914551,
1.1258262395858765,
-0.23828941583633423,
0.22609832882881165,
0.48094049096107483,
0.8516624569892883,
-0.7316458821296692,
0.24045467376708984,
-0.7872647643089294,
0.004991603083908558,
-0.23890165984630585,
-0.060141757130622864,
-0.511168360710144,
0.10019990801811218,
-0.16482779383659363,
-0.47766634821891785,
0.06925597786903381,
-0.0442003570497036,
0.2801644504070282,
0.40426138043403625,
-0.5427538752555847,
-0.14072111248970032,
-0.9515144228935242,
0.9537183046340942,
-0.4733409285545349,
0.4533195197582245,
0.4511447250843048,
0.04880480468273163,
-0.475490540266037,
-0.8426946997642517,
-0.3034308850765228,
-0.017264002934098244,
0.25331494212150574,
0.07235296070575714,
-0.4424756169319153,
0.039144668728113174,
0.16834302246570587,
0.47812914848327637,
-0.3496527075767517,
0.510748028755188,
-0.43630632758140564,
-0.14383606612682343,
0.7098264098167419,
0.06855770200490952,
0.16645695269107819,
0.20339083671569824,
-0.36524781584739685,
0.24652515351772308,
-1.1548620462417603,
-0.10992969572544098,
0.39208462834358215,
0.08608171343803406,
0.08641034364700317,
0.5608815550804138,
-0.03263859823346138,
0.24708792567253113,
-0.21800078451633453,
-0.000840386317577213,
0.3675038516521454,
0.08343429863452911,
-0.28467074036598206,
-0.3634748160839081,
0.9199737310409546,
0.17452119290828705,
0.34536653757095337,
-0.5446036458015442,
-0.4040854871273041,
-0.3027328550815582,
0.4355482757091522,
-0.6516965627670288,
-0.030311690643429756,
0.08386719971895218,
-0.6278867125511169,
-0.47786611318588257,
0.027574904263019562,
-0.9024611115455627,
-0.5768821835517883,
-0.5515896677970886,
0.3098439872264862,
-0.4159262478351593,
-0.33161523938179016,
-0.018063394352793694,
0.18669599294662476,
0.06233372539281845,
0.05712554603815079,
-0.8152399063110352,
0.10054729878902435,
0.77567458152771,
0.40369388461112976,
-0.25951647758483887,
-0.44811493158340454,
-0.31050917506217957,
0.18540675938129425,
-0.2885257303714752,
0.2004806101322174,
-0.4177134931087494,
-0.7345753908157349,
0.19527965784072876,
0.22403565049171448,
0.03127409145236015,
-0.7300984859466553,
0.35325703024864197,
-0.6789721846580505,
0.11264301836490631,
0.09368891268968582,
-0.843234658241272,
-0.5455188751220703,
0.05408412590622902,
-0.5517850518226624,
0.8050053119659424,
-0.08828545361757278,
-0.5595165491104126,
0.25697481632232666,
-0.8221631646156311,
-0.47421562671661377,
-0.01677192561328411,
0.05633556842803955,
-0.598005473613739,
0.399873286485672,
-0.13425010442733765,
0.5947846174240112,
-0.31688743829727173,
0.5314977765083313,
-0.4557548463344574,
-0.1453939527273178,
0.5028277039527893,
-0.8164883852005005,
1.0278569459915161,
0.42815113067626953,
-0.16103680431842804,
0.1563805788755417,
-0.617370069026947,
0.03834879770874977,
0.2578721344470978,
-0.4244459867477417,
-0.19216597080230713,
0.007551989983767271,
-0.13099130988121033,
-0.2728932499885559,
0.3894730508327484,
-0.48055240511894226,
0.1688738912343979,
-0.13417597115039825,
0.6759989261627197,
0.8057941198348999,
0.025961322709918022,
0.574430525302887,
-0.3150880038738251,
0.48467645049095154,
-0.07508601993322372,
0.2962275743484497,
-0.22407574951648712,
-0.21478289365768433,
-0.7490475177764893,
-0.25005456805229187,
0.4566778540611267,
0.49663692712783813,
-0.5520489811897278,
0.27437591552734375,
0.033068280667066574,
-0.49384626746177673,
-0.5855967998504639,
0.5857695937156677,
0.5958865284919739,
0.2533295452594757,
0.2878941297531128,
-0.26861125230789185,
-0.5419108271598816,
-0.7804475426673889,
-0.23935389518737793,
-0.17256046831607819,
0.03775496408343315,
-0.033539265394210815,
0.49789974093437195,
-0.6762638688087463,
0.6633622646331787,
-0.29590076208114624,
-0.1921040266752243,
-0.4571455717086792,
0.11647405475378036,
-0.19526495039463043,
0.4864506721496582,
0.058841124176979065,
-0.7748422622680664,
-0.036614205688238144,
-0.025564897805452347,
-1.0657609701156616,
0.1155666932463646,
0.05843460559844971,
0.19386602938175201,
0.3379371762275696,
0.8523841500282288,
-0.5982510447502136,
0.4168347418308258,
0.39154183864593506,
0.10629867762327194,
0.44718730449676514,
-0.5804842114448547,
-0.1766739785671234,
-1.1102412939071655,
0.1682976335287094,
-0.48843395709991455,
-0.10389439016580582,
-0.8531047105789185,
0.26901575922966003,
-0.0394427590072155,
-0.19563692808151245,
-0.4851644039154053,
0.38959622383117676,
-0.7616286277770996,
-0.05347161740064621,
-0.5423585176467896,
-0.07188405096530914,
-0.0965430736541748,
0.5672125816345215,
-0.3736512362957001,
0.6735844016075134,
0.4965517222881317,
-0.5684221386909485,
0.2113247513771057,
-0.1175088956952095,
-0.31476229429244995,
0.08665212243795395,
-0.4388258755207062,
0.3615856468677521,
-0.2541452646255493,
0.05805256962776184,
-0.6361290216445923,
0.10801990330219269,
0.07401537150144577,
-0.40323784947395325,
0.5191969275474548,
-0.14556482434272766,
-0.6429898738861084,
-0.022752884775400162,
-0.19895032048225403,
0.5677914023399353,
0.6503714919090271,
-0.5279210209846497,
0.4775638282299042,
0.8943819999694824,
0.13232269883155823,
-0.673957109451294,
-0.4420967400074005,
0.02130885049700737,
-0.5273450016975403,
-0.28307658433914185,
0.3285893201828003,
-0.10414959490299225,
-0.3539220094680786,
-0.03830486536026001,
0.13944627344608307,
-0.18795408308506012,
0.5608699321746826,
0.5790244340896606,
0.18640188872814178,
0.009151177480816841,
0.253430038690567,
-0.19253098964691162,
-0.3716201186180115,
0.28881606459617615,
-0.3498828411102295,
0.44685491919517517,
-0.041083671152591705,
-0.5455955266952515,
-0.2326701432466507,
0.34910500049591064,
0.6779190301895142,
-0.2385958731174469,
0.7134931683540344,
0.5761390924453735,
-0.6394774913787842,
-0.1611904799938202,
-0.2520243227481842,
0.034448109567165375,
-0.4198126196861267,
0.4371470510959625,
-0.02680138312280178,
-1.0810959339141846,
0.5434180498123169,
-0.4248061180114746,
0.35597357153892517,
0.3392559587955475,
0.7404067516326904,
-0.223603755235672,
0.8391091227531433,
1.1438699960708618,
-0.30942192673683167,
0.40473976731300354,
-0.3938307464122772,
0.41908979415893555,
-0.9399273991584778,
-0.47373467683792114,
-0.22964626550674438,
-0.1694515347480774,
-0.6505822539329529,
-0.3669259548187256,
0.14488159120082855,
0.4315127432346344,
-0.4536650478839874,
-0.05954334884881973,
0.02862447500228882,
0.7489323019981384,
0.495644748210907,
0.015706924721598625,
0.5023527145385742,
-0.060976795852184296,
0.04371035099029541,
0.17496967315673828,
-0.5648099184036255,
-0.6791813969612122,
1.4906374216079712,
0.4588332772254944,
0.8531007766723633,
0.06773790717124939,
0.5984955430030823,
0.32979026436805725,
0.37746134400367737,
-0.7215375304222107,
0.3972153663635254,
-0.3221088647842407,
-0.5680168271064758,
-0.3283921778202057,
-0.41001686453819275,
-1.1568310260772705,
0.11923924833536148,
-0.2680658996105194,
-0.7528823018074036,
-0.29643067717552185,
0.12333264201879501,
-0.23057134449481964,
0.8216778039932251,
-0.5255237221717834,
0.8450377583503723,
-0.4281057119369507,
-0.2894480228424072,
-0.3577118515968323,
-0.4842436611652374,
0.48920372128486633,
-0.4575962424278259,
0.33553680777549744,
0.029246406629681587,
0.06790178269147873,
0.6932189464569092,
-0.10058551281690598,
1.2018722295761108,
-0.043849170207977295,
-0.3021050691604614,
0.2073909193277359,
0.18488751351833344,
0.3135431110858917,
0.006782615091651678,
0.08964074403047562,
0.5347971320152283,
-0.14383059740066528,
-0.16940739750862122,
-0.5836468935012817,
0.41784432530403137,
-0.8418886661529541,
-0.6611694693565369,
0.012157467193901539,
-0.7755599021911621,
-0.24978122115135193,
0.2813258469104767,
0.2523995637893677,
0.15244849026203156,
-0.5595102310180664,
0.39169183373451233,
1.0009708404541016,
-0.2586004137992859,
0.3835917115211487,
0.613943874835968,
-0.38464850187301636,
-0.29152992367744446,
1.1483516693115234,
-0.016413571313023567,
0.3474298119544983,
0.5066089630126953,
0.15448731184005737,
-0.26787498593330383,
-0.6664151549339294,
-0.26032698154449463,
0.19568857550621033,
-0.6748383641242981,
-0.1730179488658905,
-0.41152408719062805,
-0.34116604924201965,
-0.3069794178009033,
0.08063872903585434,
-0.48463931679725647,
-0.22354751825332642,
-0.5021126866340637,
-0.18840572237968445,
0.19729898869991302,
1.0188542604446411,
-0.24325913190841675,
0.4226338565349579,
-0.6645780801773071,
0.008670000359416008,
0.07060788571834564,
0.2121470868587494,
0.15480175614356995,
-0.7588331699371338,
-0.31044888496398926,
0.13340841233730316,
-0.6127153038978577,
-0.4255044162273407,
0.33868902921676636,
-0.0029442342929542065,
0.7791282534599304,
0.6328117251396179,
0.02016238123178482,
0.3370021879673004,
-0.5757942199707031,
0.5514045357704163,
0.2060479372739792,
-0.8626018762588501,
0.14179733395576477,
-0.3597143590450287,
-0.07604552805423737,
0.36466941237449646,
0.2524518668651581,
-0.7395288348197937,
-0.3669131100177765,
-0.8777336478233337,
-0.9336891174316406,
0.18689770996570587,
-0.1356758177280426,
0.32461610436439514,
0.41880494356155396,
0.4883705675601959,
0.3249886929988861,
0.4125848114490509,
-0.6109683513641357,
-0.3415115773677826,
0.09710002690553665,
-0.16547012329101562,
-0.4102688431739807,
-0.5041598081588745,
-0.1890498846769333,
-0.07330214977264404,
0.7115865349769592,
0.051970113068819046,
0.01540448796004057,
-0.516925036907196,
-0.3166273832321167,
-0.08384032547473907,
0.4421462416648865,
0.3517749309539795,
0.7077786326408386,
0.15357229113578796,
0.31125888228416443,
0.37960654497146606,
-0.29453614354133606,
0.09850776195526123,
-0.3166176378726959,
-0.35210734605789185,
-0.47646090388298035,
0.4258573353290558,
0.49405568838119507,
0.34558922052383423,
-0.7245938777923584,
0.2682751715183258,
0.18879768252372742,
-0.28753378987312317,
-0.49083593487739563,
0.04087282344698906,
0.19391517341136932,
0.21964924037456512,
0.08061662316322327,
-0.29404976963996887,
-0.16654814779758453,
-0.7124274969100952,
0.4321807324886322,
0.6516348123550415,
-0.6195725798606873,
-0.2963562309741974,
0.6070526838302612,
0.1859157234430313,
-0.34038102626800537,
0.7191210389137268,
0.0038074154872447252,
-0.5320488810539246,
0.46777451038360596,
0.5143237709999084,
0.938071072101593,
-0.18850833177566528,
0.04539821296930313,
-0.1606738120317459,
0.5184023380279541,
-0.03333614766597748,
-0.15794417262077332,
0.0886744037270546,
-0.7908112406730652,
-0.3172623813152313,
-0.3320266306400299,
-0.4743119776248932,
0.6723344922065735,
-0.6950263977050781,
-0.02998153306543827,
-0.5527388453483582,
0.22564350068569183,
-0.0899835154414177,
0.07718627899885178,
-0.3370407223701477,
-0.048980358988046646,
0.004787692800164223,
0.6478164792060852,
-0.7592871785163879,
0.8998196721076965,
0.5179489254951477,
-0.3503733277320862,
-0.6441382765769958,
0.030460143461823463,
0.46104419231414795,
-1.0845292806625366,
0.43781325221061707,
0.08139743655920029,
-0.13487112522125244,
-0.08826430886983871,
-0.5089410543441772,
-0.5794627070426941,
1.1007462739944458,
0.5865755677223206,
-0.4073427617549896,
0.46504297852516174,
0.2257288098335266,
0.3896036148071289,
-0.3851757049560547,
0.046254001557826996,
0.5361121296882629,
0.10844117403030396,
-0.1347157210111618,
-0.5009666681289673,
-0.11818508058786392,
-0.17364847660064697,
-0.14371171593666077,
0.31893983483314514,
-0.5881503224372864,
0.7907190918922424,
-0.5312182903289795,
-0.18939010798931122,
0.14853788912296295,
0.6935299038887024,
-0.10635731369256973,
0.4262160658836365,
0.48922520875930786,
0.5980364680290222,
1.0823328495025635,
0.166624516248703,
0.6708753705024719,
-0.19341906905174255,
0.340898722410202,
1.0190584659576416,
-0.31674984097480774,
0.7041662335395813,
0.5131083726882935,
0.0029428754933178425,
0.14078091084957123,
0.6999222040176392,
0.041956376284360886,
0.24483716487884521,
0.4471733272075653,
-0.40730878710746765,
-0.2813853621482849,
-0.13957515358924866,
-0.15051089227199554,
0.6145423650741577,
0.20130608975887299,
-0.3466583788394928,
-0.25375065207481384,
0.10904769599437714,
0.352445513010025,
0.06275217235088348,
-0.18553565442562103,
0.8439674973487854,
0.28820574283599854,
-0.3050207495689392,
0.3160548806190491,
0.09851643443107605,
0.4102635085582733,
-0.3362467885017395,
0.15030144155025482,
-0.3541693091392517,
0.4953312277793884,
-0.09490811824798584,
-0.7731519341468811,
0.3480455279350281,
0.3214489221572876,
-0.503554105758667,
-0.4563416838645935,
0.5911051034927368,
-0.6138393878936768,
-0.31272387504577637,
0.5614423155784607,
0.8288144469261169,
0.3603503108024597,
0.02763974666595459,
-0.823046088218689,
-0.09576328098773956,
0.10254170000553131,
-0.17446470260620117,
0.6830700635910034,
0.7026792764663696,
-0.06824445724487305,
1.078206181526184,
0.8351362943649292,
-0.04086058959364891,
-0.18222728371620178,
0.20007985830307007,
0.7186461687088013,
-0.6161075234413147,
-0.011817160062491894,
-0.8871511220932007,
0.37606459856033325,
0.20389117300510406,
-0.17221474647521973,
0.6959730982780457,
0.5862895846366882,
0.9949073791503906,
0.3210470974445343,
0.8321272134780884,
0.36591508984565735,
0.393575519323349,
-0.7318076491355896,
1.0481157302856445,
-0.713300347328186,
0.5524716377258301,
0.029088640585541725,
-0.721629798412323,
-0.3684214949607849,
0.10501745343208313,
0.0471448116004467,
0.09364347904920578,
0.4871182143688202,
0.8291557431221008,
0.050746314227581024,
0.08627215027809143,
0.5904415249824524,
0.06426812708377838,
0.3708716928958893,
0.45632103085517883,
1.1228469610214233,
-0.16625942289829254,
0.5655133724212646,
-0.1705329567193985,
-0.13317559659481049,
0.056077517569065094,
-0.8598969578742981,
-0.8462584018707275,
-0.6237484812736511,
-0.21054314076900482,
-0.05208292976021767,
0.0454077273607254,
0.5885127186775208,
0.3912189304828644,
-0.6164563298225403,
-0.48896998167037964,
-0.0041073402389883995,
0.4802441895008087,
-0.06510056555271149,
-0.14629440009593964,
0.23340988159179688,
-0.31742823123931885,
-0.5090965032577515,
0.46463242173194885,
0.16499905288219452,
0.12930673360824585,
-0.5178605914115906,
-0.1486477255821228,
0.130178764462471,
-0.23494061827659607,
0.6231585144996643,
0.4638885259628296,
-0.6365459561347961,
-0.05264005810022354,
-0.12234559655189514,
0.11734463274478912,
-0.22831125557422638,
1.0352985858917236,
-0.49166369438171387,
0.17406868934631348,
0.15931670367717743,
0.9723902344703674,
0.13311272859573364,
-0.2572958469390869,
0.6525709629058838,
-0.6482508778572083,
-0.024516137316823006,
-0.045682698488235474,
0.5496006011962891,
0.32351112365722656,
-0.22496534883975983,
0.47844865918159485,
0.271795392036438,
-0.690423309803009,
-1.1358674764633179,
0.32068440318107605,
-0.5754166841506958,
-0.5579402446746826,
1.1157708168029785,
-0.2228170484304428,
-0.2122553437948227,
-0.23987306654453278,
0.2098945826292038,
0.4182906448841095,
-0.14248831570148468,
0.8235161304473877,
0.4181981682777405,
0.06922996789216995,
-0.18762411177158356,
-0.6416481137275696,
0.29709526896476746,
0.38465461134910583,
-0.8402599096298218,
0.7835273146629333,
0.3357803225517273,
0.30604228377342224,
0.017903415486216545,
0.40126144886016846,
-0.2510441839694977,
-0.027896568179130554,
-0.321479469537735,
0.25378528237342834,
-0.28580760955810547,
-0.5945082902908325,
-0.7167986631393433,
-0.003633747575804591,
0.08167095482349396,
-0.2606204152107239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08785v1 | InstructGraph: Boosting Large Language Models via Graph-centric Instruction Tuning and Preference Alignment | 2024-02-13T20:47:17 | 2024-02-13T20:47:17 | Jianing Wang, Junda Wu, Yupeng Hou, Yao Liu, Ming Gao, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do current large language models (LLMs) better solve graph reasoning and
generation tasks with parameter updates? In this paper, we propose
InstructGraph, a framework that empowers LLMs with the abilities of graph
reasoning and generation by instruction tuning and preference alignment.
Specifically, we first propose a structured format verbalizer to unify all
graph data into a universal code-like format, which can simply represent the
graph without any external graph-specific encoders. Furthermore, a graph
instruction tuning stage is introduced to guide LLMs in solving graph reasoning
and generation tasks. Finally, we identify potential hallucination problems in
graph tasks and sample negative instances for preference alignment, the target
of which is to enhance the output's reliability of the model. Extensive
experiments across multiple graph-centric tasks exhibit that InstructGraph can
achieve the best performance and outperform GPT-4 and LLaMA2 by more than 13\%
and 38\%, respectively. | [
-0.19335082173347473,
-0.7739060521125793,
0.5883592963218689,
-0.047277744859457016,
-0.08717866241931915,
0.32511287927627563,
-0.39475494623184204,
-0.21832408010959625,
0.10472993552684784,
0.6991991996765137,
-0.33722779154777527,
-0.7692172527313232,
-0.5651240348815918,
-0.06478085368871689,
-0.2344134896993637,
0.8824190497398376,
0.02046162821352482,
0.10647159069776535,
-0.5817946791648865,
0.18320535123348236,
-0.4439408481121063,
-0.5041105151176453,
-0.7625226378440857,
-0.6564125418663025,
0.2518388032913208,
0.689667284488678,
0.817755401134491,
0.8202036619186401,
0.05095982551574707,
0.32302162051200867,
0.07127594947814941,
0.5968966484069824,
-0.657917320728302,
0.03249039128422737,
-0.025770867243409157,
-0.07891669124364853,
-0.5948857665061951,
-0.20225512981414795,
0.6911064386367798,
0.8599671721458435,
0.11779780685901642,
0.10760331153869629,
0.23842820525169373,
0.5790717005729675,
-0.1846613734960556,
0.5695449113845825,
-0.6111804842948914,
-0.32493865489959717,
-0.078014075756073,
-0.31539711356163025,
-0.825915515422821,
-0.7108513116836548,
-0.4174494445323944,
-0.5059048533439636,
-0.0007373505504801869,
0.34871116280555725,
0.7058609127998352,
0.295015811920166,
-0.4860171675682068,
-0.07660230994224548,
-0.3606717884540558,
0.3089163303375244,
-0.6963586211204529,
0.3648638129234314,
0.23909667134284973,
0.12717972695827484,
-0.4563903510570526,
-0.8174612522125244,
-0.31107887625694275,
-0.2022278606891632,
-0.0654737800359726,
-0.23196594417095184,
-0.08828819543123245,
0.33095332980155945,
0.2681081295013428,
0.15029652416706085,
-0.66252201795578,
0.6524693965911865,
-0.00017316998855676502,
-0.22461849451065063,
0.5445861220359802,
0.12079424411058426,
0.3917783796787262,
-0.029516972601413727,
0.06708594411611557,
-0.24127702414989471,
-0.9894201755523682,
-0.08717822283506393,
0.5691929459571838,
0.5652973055839539,
0.1986231803894043,
0.6400009989738464,
-0.2943512499332428,
1.1077600717544556,
0.29232078790664673,
0.08692286908626556,
0.22984398901462555,
-0.022803286090493202,
-0.11317413300275803,
0.5382850170135498,
0.7866524457931519,
0.4233704209327698,
0.4748532474040985,
-0.3034292459487915,
-0.09088271856307983,
0.2007783204317093,
0.06504306942224503,
-1.091558814048767,
-0.4420883059501648,
0.12287983298301697,
-0.056402500718832016,
-0.1773354411125183,
-0.07823119312524796,
-0.46964046359062195,
-0.41700369119644165,
-0.4732799530029297,
0.13323181867599487,
-0.620770275592804,
0.0023457480128854513,
0.3064767122268677,
0.029166165739297867,
0.08960823714733124,
0.2742706835269928,
-1.2224746942520142,
0.1711074560880661,
0.9429036378860474,
0.6055782437324524,
-0.04418725520372391,
-0.3510448634624481,
-0.7975466847419739,
0.2895888388156891,
-0.4840890169143677,
0.7508601546287537,
-0.8456519246101379,
-0.26328301429748535,
-0.07152734696865082,
0.2029503583908081,
-0.14035461843013763,
-0.4502946734428406,
0.1716538518667221,
-0.505456268787384,
0.10728751868009567,
-0.2165447473526001,
-0.9969513416290283,
-0.07012752443552017,
0.1714513599872589,
-0.3370856046676636,
1.1042346954345703,
0.324505090713501,
-0.6005359292030334,
0.1967254877090454,
-0.4735470414161682,
-0.607284665107727,
0.2763109803199768,
-0.24289028346538544,
-0.26814159750938416,
-0.23879025876522064,
0.4023459851741791,
0.5041569471359253,
-0.18443040549755096,
0.30055180191993713,
-0.42984065413475037,
-0.5843254923820496,
0.060423437505960464,
-0.13575543463230133,
0.8364800810813904,
-0.22218440473079681,
-0.3072553277015686,
0.5288794636726379,
-0.5392675995826721,
0.3822701871395111,
0.2039707899093628,
-0.09130164980888367,
-0.04527230188250542,
-0.020213903859257698,
-0.3180820643901825,
-0.004649168811738491,
0.36214888095855713,
-0.6212117671966553,
0.5619844794273376,
-0.38042616844177246,
0.7347259521484375,
0.9671878218650818,
-0.0612504780292511,
0.37748026847839355,
-0.03661251440644264,
0.47956225275993347,
-0.34548041224479675,
0.1963159590959549,
-0.05986148491501808,
-0.48623260855674744,
-0.6912742853164673,
-0.17874597012996674,
0.17281484603881836,
0.37937065958976746,
-0.5032424330711365,
0.4891475737094879,
-0.4980049133300781,
-0.38602888584136963,
-0.43892380595207214,
0.10575583577156067,
0.4710748791694641,
0.7778789401054382,
0.21986998617649078,
0.010218087583780289,
-0.2822505533695221,
-0.6622950434684753,
0.12182062864303589,
-0.11208201944828033,
0.21027769148349762,
0.3465355634689331,
0.09540761262178421,
-0.29393720626831055,
0.6786566376686096,
-0.6870593428611755,
-0.06977618485689163,
-0.2710120975971222,
-0.32715243101119995,
0.1930171102285385,
0.32117369771003723,
0.51433265209198,
-0.3076641261577606,
-0.6136155128479004,
0.2564007043838501,
-0.7193282842636108,
-0.19234561920166016,
0.398906946182251,
-0.4073798656463623,
0.23732128739356995,
0.7749245762825012,
-0.4896993339061737,
-0.10881929099559784,
0.588158369064331,
-0.31347694993019104,
0.33029624819755554,
-0.19887876510620117,
-0.06950788199901581,
-0.9545014500617981,
-0.28972628712654114,
-0.21901728212833405,
-0.4813542664051056,
-0.2762465178966522,
-0.06992439180612564,
0.05626625940203667,
-0.34832605719566345,
-0.024488355964422226,
0.35718417167663574,
-0.3485068082809448,
-0.032913289964199066,
-0.23859213292598724,
0.33270856738090515,
0.1693805307149887,
0.4427165985107422,
-0.15583375096321106,
0.7798588871955872,
0.6413230895996094,
-0.2763132154941559,
0.40459954738616943,
0.3404790461063385,
-0.3975803256034851,
0.15497973561286926,
-0.6747586727142334,
0.6660355925559998,
-0.2476750761270523,
0.2070642113685608,
-0.9929482340812683,
-0.47043609619140625,
0.24743138253688812,
-0.16033095121383667,
0.6617335081100464,
-0.3760981261730194,
-0.7412658929824829,
-0.3561917543411255,
-0.08422590792179108,
0.0013876555021852255,
0.40425509214401245,
-0.8583747148513794,
0.2717163860797882,
0.4014785885810852,
0.025547964498400688,
-0.5732244849205017,
-0.20723600685596466,
-0.0642453283071518,
-0.01188396755605936,
-0.6008744239807129,
0.2867749035358429,
-0.1623472422361374,
0.02683011256158352,
0.1815004050731659,
0.06001581996679306,
0.3302747905254364,
-0.0836530551314354,
0.38900095224380493,
0.2901371717453003,
-0.17365849018096924,
0.17325694859027863,
0.35724881291389465,
-0.38425010442733765,
-0.00933657493442297,
-0.7953676581382751,
0.8483936190605164,
-0.3540385961532593,
-0.5538349747657776,
-0.26431146264076233,
0.2142409384250641,
0.3694770634174347,
-0.3732192814350128,
0.48441025614738464,
0.27032580971717834,
-0.03732174262404442,
-0.43659624457359314,
-0.16059572994709015,
-0.1923983246088028,
-0.5074570775032043,
0.5366698503494263,
-0.2067849189043045,
-1.0778406858444214,
0.06175858899950981,
-0.36697328090667725,
0.006286064628511667,
0.10909299552440643,
0.5699780583381653,
-0.009014877490699291,
1.2914243936538696,
0.47933948040008545,
-0.19476757943630219,
0.4986616373062134,
-0.24538148939609528,
0.4305247664451599,
-0.745915949344635,
-0.20696982741355896,
-0.3507516384124756,
-0.1059291660785675,
-0.5398994088172913,
-0.17324775457382202,
0.46509024500846863,
0.012576834298670292,
-0.7256362438201904,
0.28512874245643616,
-1.0251704454421997,
0.7827613949775696,
0.5087310075759888,
0.19606992602348328,
0.1570909172296524,
0.056100063025951385,
0.06743810325860977,
0.08487022668123245,
-0.8668923377990723,
-0.6532885432243347,
1.0312455892562866,
-0.11901126056909561,
0.7325263619422913,
-0.04140292853116989,
0.7324822545051575,
0.04292278736829758,
0.44614699482917786,
-0.7518150806427002,
0.6485171318054199,
-0.45045778155326843,
-0.17477212846279144,
-0.4420757591724396,
-0.2676231861114502,
-0.7646903991699219,
0.07035110890865326,
-0.023736918345093727,
-0.8802997469902039,
-0.23396693170070648,
0.4494355618953705,
0.10405082255601883,
0.2384195327758789,
-0.8162493109703064,
1.152808427810669,
-0.4060467481613159,
-0.1703619658946991,
-0.05979008600115776,
-0.4099659323692322,
0.1737198680639267,
0.20488399267196655,
0.03431113436818123,
-0.22803756594657898,
0.26705479621887207,
0.26547372341156006,
-0.4780687093734741,
1.1335680484771729,
-0.12330435961484909,
0.025470586493611336,
0.2487843632698059,
0.16288496553897858,
0.8145692348480225,
-0.020298944786190987,
-0.30980193614959717,
0.006724605802446604,
-0.13041339814662933,
-0.16503989696502686,
-0.9481545686721802,
0.8596442341804504,
-0.7888867259025574,
-0.7594929337501526,
0.06776783615350723,
-0.6089744567871094,
-0.35381603240966797,
0.364816278219223,
0.4341832995414734,
0.7642777562141418,
-0.09882360696792603,
0.04519987851381302,
0.6168296337127686,
0.09612073749303818,
0.18359972536563873,
-0.022786425426602364,
-0.44540780782699585,
-0.3903849422931671,
1.0890049934387207,
0.04221254959702492,
0.4534779191017151,
0.4192914664745331,
0.2599433660507202,
-0.2754107713699341,
-0.4886294901371002,
-0.7604698538780212,
0.31863099336624146,
-1.044777750968933,
-0.26436373591423035,
-0.4764019250869751,
-0.291029691696167,
-0.34930241107940674,
-0.37512797117233276,
-0.3910481035709381,
-0.3751339316368103,
-0.17028483748435974,
-0.27438148856163025,
0.5810532569885254,
0.7745590806007385,
0.3374001085758209,
0.2297627329826355,
-0.2799668610095978,
-0.16773144900798798,
0.29817092418670654,
0.37014901638031006,
-0.1558164805173874,
-0.3953859806060791,
-0.300487756729126,
-0.06125974282622337,
-0.19681201875209808,
-0.6267616748809814,
0.0062590413726866245,
0.11353867501020432,
0.35910603404045105,
0.4553699493408203,
0.04504433646798134,
0.5943576693534851,
-0.6030605435371399,
0.48869776725769043,
-0.06370138376951218,
-1.048511266708374,
0.40701618790626526,
-0.2347508817911148,
0.10429149866104126,
0.35776862502098083,
0.19584208726882935,
-0.3468782305717468,
-0.47502827644348145,
-0.41034743189811707,
-0.7857337594032288,
0.5738927125930786,
-0.3019985258579254,
0.2632618248462677,
-0.1200069859623909,
0.4696212708950043,
0.06073179095983505,
0.16789357364177704,
-0.5468462705612183,
-0.06687937676906586,
-0.6065215468406677,
-0.38231518864631653,
-0.19725751876831055,
-0.1449776291847229,
-0.25560152530670166,
-0.46075379848480225,
0.7272368669509888,
-0.6443731784820557,
0.021731628105044365,
-0.294072687625885,
0.021648086607456207,
-0.017336608842015266,
0.1014564037322998,
0.09610658138990402,
0.7725668549537659,
-0.12100744992494583,
0.25595584511756897,
-0.07586264610290527,
-0.05542605742812157,
0.1973971128463745,
0.1911110132932663,
-0.369281142950058,
-0.23278596997261047,
0.4833492040634155,
1.0875864028930664,
0.3071446120738983,
-0.5500715970993042,
0.4342757761478424,
0.24624711275100708,
-0.009899873286485672,
-0.04874222353100777,
0.3381849527359009,
0.3795248568058014,
0.10616210103034973,
-0.26770904660224915,
-0.37381109595298767,
-0.1350189596414566,
-0.2855418920516968,
-0.08758466690778732,
0.6387732028961182,
-0.4191749095916748,
-0.18663091957569122,
0.8762398362159729,
-0.03656339645385742,
-0.41810452938079834,
0.9451606273651123,
-0.4047345817089081,
-0.4217134118080139,
0.5587027668952942,
1.077521800994873,
0.7422091960906982,
0.011261374689638615,
0.38142910599708557,
0.3010246157646179,
0.2310246080160141,
0.22629381716251373,
0.15891820192337036,
0.02915344201028347,
-0.8846322298049927,
-0.509567379951477,
-0.36747169494628906,
-0.547136127948761,
-0.14783011376857758,
-0.42483484745025635,
0.1754034012556076,
-0.5318124294281006,
-0.08628382533788681,
0.2357252687215805,
-0.14282764494419098,
-0.33160796761512756,
-0.1080469936132431,
0.014118141494691372,
0.48741111159324646,
-0.7278141379356384,
1.044999122619629,
0.7719051241874695,
-0.2365799993276596,
-1.0312210321426392,
-0.22098815441131592,
-0.08916924893856049,
-0.7643446922302246,
0.545329749584198,
0.27811145782470703,
-0.5315022468566895,
0.4259068965911865,
-0.8212850093841553,
-0.7815382480621338,
1.023787021636963,
1.0527734756469727,
-0.5481224060058594,
0.1775004267692566,
0.05384695902466774,
0.3933399021625519,
-0.5388250946998596,
-0.0835629552602768,
0.367620587348938,
0.37664467096328735,
0.15420082211494446,
-0.4790426194667816,
0.23286567628383636,
-0.1642359048128128,
-0.04022574424743652,
0.42139968276023865,
-0.8372563123703003,
0.733001708984375,
-0.36009469628334045,
-0.13621751964092255,
-0.3058997690677643,
0.49226707220077515,
0.2746473252773285,
0.01768355630338192,
0.3646877110004425,
0.3646749258041382,
1.177038311958313,
-0.11727562546730042,
1.1864248514175415,
-0.7362093925476074,
0.09918463975191116,
1.2529469728469849,
-0.41000232100486755,
0.49708881974220276,
0.10982843488454819,
0.004491503816097975,
0.7073426246643066,
0.7367432713508606,
0.12036682665348053,
0.20225220918655396,
0.06562698632478714,
0.011521593667566776,
-0.4836353659629822,
-0.20947085320949554,
-0.28053247928619385,
0.48402589559555054,
0.2963729202747345,
-0.1945713311433792,
-0.04339778050780296,
-0.26318609714508057,
0.46583327651023865,
0.1913154274225235,
-0.16658556461334229,
0.5832977890968323,
-0.09383431822061539,
-0.6435700058937073,
0.6726008057594299,
-0.1960967779159546,
-0.020835908129811287,
-0.6684662699699402,
-0.1666707992553711,
-0.2176043540239334,
0.18846963346004486,
-0.2723104655742645,
-0.7867065668106079,
-0.09794146567583084,
-0.29152366518974304,
-0.21128784120082855,
-0.30217674374580383,
0.5885254740715027,
-0.44168317317962646,
-0.3886970281600952,
0.45031630992889404,
0.23882253468036652,
0.026473941281437874,
0.10253928601741791,
-0.32472583651542664,
0.125362366437912,
0.05421380698680878,
-0.0408591590821743,
0.4332204759120941,
0.4704357087612152,
-0.3013053238391876,
0.6697795987129211,
0.5372868776321411,
-0.059337761253118515,
-0.022927405312657356,
0.43484559655189514,
1.065068244934082,
-0.37633469700813293,
-0.35428985953330994,
-0.8627848029136658,
0.12743911147117615,
-0.29893720149993896,
-0.2099079042673111,
1.0080817937850952,
0.7076079845428467,
0.8170746564865112,
0.11960263550281525,
0.7090715765953064,
0.1709890067577362,
0.00349164055660367,
-0.711802065372467,
0.5122219920158386,
-0.2879227101802826,
0.056961946189403534,
-0.3278297781944275,
-1.016567349433899,
-0.2589809000492096,
0.29611122608184814,
-0.317609578371048,
-0.03561878949403763,
0.5333822965621948,
1.1154115200042725,
-0.038622502237558365,
-0.030370457097887993,
-0.013851339928805828,
0.18350079655647278,
0.4012048840522766,
0.5764153003692627,
0.6539127230644226,
0.07473069429397583,
0.36140763759613037,
-0.27597108483314514,
-0.29146265983581543,
-0.060733284801244736,
-0.8472884893417358,
-1.024584412574768,
-0.47355809807777405,
-0.4598653316497803,
-0.5695509910583496,
-0.03548480570316315,
1.0408700704574585,
0.7545928955078125,
-0.6418914794921875,
-0.28333190083503723,
-0.06528922915458679,
0.38637611269950867,
-0.28990575671195984,
-0.1775067001581192,
0.7683939933776855,
-0.5378708243370056,
-0.8936900496482849,
0.6707163453102112,
0.6050674915313721,
-0.04181068018078804,
-0.1267671138048172,
-0.17082098126411438,
0.3192076086997986,
-0.014215509407222271,
0.7479254603385925,
0.18586966395378113,
-0.47600194811820984,
-0.5960277318954468,
-0.06720605492591858,
-0.07271513342857361,
0.21983927488327026,
0.7934103608131409,
-0.4661846160888672,
0.6768698692321777,
0.23011696338653564,
0.5286229252815247,
0.6927101612091064,
0.06103110685944557,
0.3978467285633087,
-0.6176921129226685,
0.3020637333393097,
0.03563331812620163,
0.43747031688690186,
0.5792756080627441,
-0.576802670955658,
0.4666112959384918,
0.03177747502923012,
-0.7327178120613098,
-0.8063151240348816,
0.450632244348526,
-0.8122525811195374,
-0.2748371958732605,
1.1373215913772583,
0.1255892515182495,
-0.2191047966480255,
0.14663834869861603,
-0.1962611973285675,
0.2823386490345001,
-0.3401348292827606,
0.523262083530426,
0.4830735921859741,
-0.547724187374115,
0.0163577888160944,
-0.2379414588212967,
0.43818891048431396,
0.014654475264251232,
-0.7700843811035156,
0.24522808194160461,
0.7575069069862366,
0.2785751223564148,
-0.1606278270483017,
0.6766802668571472,
-0.1037258431315422,
-0.11145823448896408,
0.044957708567380905,
0.11842983961105347,
-0.6084380149841309,
-0.3292946517467499,
-0.09459204971790314,
0.17983902990818024,
0.4571060836315155,
-0.13598297536373138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08777v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08777v2 | DNABERT-S: Learning Species-Aware DNA Embedding with Genome Foundation Models | 2024-02-13T20:21:29 | 2024-02-15T04:55:23 | Zhihan Zhou, Weimin Wu, Harrison Ho, Jiayi Wang, Lizhen Shi, Ramana V Davuluri, Zhong Wang, Han Liu | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL | Effective DNA embedding remains crucial in genomic analysis, particularly in
scenarios lacking labeled data for model fine-tuning, despite the significant
advancements in genome foundation models. A prime example is metagenomics
binning, a critical process in microbiome research that aims to group DNA
sequences by their species from a complex mixture of DNA sequences derived from
potentially thousands of distinct, often uncharacterized species. To fill the
lack of effective DNA embedding models, we introduce DNABERT-S, a genome
foundation model that specializes in creating species-aware DNA embeddings. To
encourage effective embeddings to error-prone long-read DNA sequences, we
introduce Manifold Instance Mixup (MI-Mix), a contrastive objective that mixes
the hidden representations of DNA sequences at randomly selected layers and
trains the model to recognize and differentiate these mixed proportions at the
output layer. We further enhance it with the proposed Curriculum Contrastive
Learning (C$^2$LR) strategy. Empirical results on 18 diverse datasets showed
DNABERT-S's remarkable performance. It outperforms the top baseline's
performance in 10-shot species classification with just a 2-shot training while
doubling the Adjusted Rand Index (ARI) in species clustering and substantially
increasing the number of correctly identified species in metagenomics binning.
The code, data, and pre-trained model are publicly available at
https://github.com/Zhihan1996/DNABERT_S. | [
-0.5103343725204468,
-0.5861241817474365,
0.20441187918186188,
-0.006959954276680946,
-0.4948495626449585,
0.3662402629852295,
-0.06327752023935318,
0.03769399970769882,
0.5259897708892822,
0.28914403915405273,
-0.3958614766597748,
-0.5134719014167786,
-0.638163149356842,
0.1314946562051773,
-0.45812103152275085,
0.826972246170044,
0.12726156413555145,
0.24987053871154785,
-0.16650213301181793,
-0.45697686076164246,
-0.02605176903307438,
-0.31625813245773315,
-0.14390458166599274,
-0.1253407597541809,
0.8804107308387756,
0.5868427157402039,
0.5018602013587952,
0.9224663972854614,
0.53770911693573,
0.09347206354141235,
-0.3117813467979431,
0.09792228043079376,
-0.7716241478919983,
0.24947184324264526,
-0.21016241610050201,
-0.4065188765525818,
-0.09375333786010742,
0.033951833844184875,
0.6007562279701233,
1.0908076763153076,
-0.23642133176326752,
0.06724157184362411,
0.14677694439888,
0.6716165542602539,
-0.8874408602714539,
-0.18108446896076202,
-0.3646356165409088,
0.5034155249595642,
-0.23781320452690125,
-0.32499414682388306,
-0.41807007789611816,
-0.3341182470321655,
0.15319696068763733,
-0.436361163854599,
0.3697505593299866,
-0.1467207670211792,
0.060096658766269684,
0.36481279134750366,
-0.48225101828575134,
-0.09657620638608932,
-0.6464899778366089,
0.5613256096839905,
-0.3812774121761322,
0.4591085910797119,
-0.033069245517253876,
0.2804587185382843,
-0.16934433579444885,
-0.5700294375419617,
-0.3537088930606842,
0.07761622965335846,
0.10493584722280502,
0.28054842352867126,
-0.05681804195046425,
0.015144843608140945,
0.4129337668418884,
0.5217624306678772,
-0.5392652153968811,
-0.3238729238510132,
-0.537239134311676,
0.20468364655971527,
0.16664451360702515,
-0.1362593173980713,
-0.03471384570002556,
-0.06068563461303711,
-0.34499654173851013,
-0.44829756021499634,
-0.9614062309265137,
0.17520363628864288,
0.35226547718048096,
0.2572939693927765,
0.06316959857940674,
0.5956950783729553,
-0.007263698149472475,
0.40450119972229004,
0.17814356088638306,
0.4681450128555298,
0.35583311319351196,
0.09122028946876526,
-0.3514740765094757,
0.29815971851348877,
0.32650676369667053,
0.17218081653118134,
-0.1638389229774475,
-0.04448011890053749,
0.18496352434158325,
0.03825349733233452,
0.2906859219074249,
-1.0795314311981201,
-0.6821140646934509,
0.40567588806152344,
-0.4338169991970062,
-0.4805111289024353,
0.12008456140756607,
-0.7843689322471619,
-0.6057740449905396,
-0.04255659505724907,
0.4140404462814331,
-0.4875570237636566,
-0.2753460109233856,
0.20750536024570465,
-0.41980883479118347,
0.2722470164299011,
0.13951432704925537,
-0.8349621295928955,
0.10521969944238663,
0.6187134981155396,
0.8399273157119751,
0.03768836706876755,
-0.13434894382953644,
-0.6870783567428589,
0.42342665791511536,
-0.2519746422767639,
0.37340718507766724,
-0.7704858779907227,
-0.7506400346755981,
-0.2283603847026825,
0.006722701713442802,
-0.004896649159491062,
-0.5865119099617004,
0.2609262764453888,
-0.260749489068985,
-0.25918859243392944,
-0.5903688073158264,
-0.7519716620445251,
-0.2811802327632904,
0.08934857696294785,
-0.6320996284484863,
0.6162852644920349,
0.20386837422847748,
-1.0012421607971191,
0.46464911103248596,
-0.35354292392730713,
-0.1629534512758255,
0.17589150369167328,
-0.40421736240386963,
-0.5824289917945862,
-0.12302033603191376,
0.045658010989427567,
0.5961904525756836,
0.04699241742491722,
0.302753210067749,
-0.6778643727302551,
-0.3983473777770996,
-0.0061147864907979965,
0.281258225440979,
1.1102039813995361,
0.11015922576189041,
-0.4086725115776062,
0.07250089198350906,
-0.45304834842681885,
-0.4450795352458954,
0.06726713478565216,
-0.21273908019065857,
-0.33313411474227905,
0.143477201461792,
-0.27368414402008057,
-0.22916312515735626,
-0.42690685391426086,
-0.6730448603630066,
0.5023598670959473,
-0.012160702608525753,
0.4711781144142151,
0.45468413829803467,
-0.05091111361980438,
0.5265913009643555,
-0.44959840178489685,
0.3152512311935425,
0.14878131449222565,
0.06472980976104736,
-0.25302138924598694,
-0.5042598247528076,
-0.7104209065437317,
-0.2945883274078369,
0.665734589099884,
0.6333203315734863,
-0.703620195388794,
0.49367979168891907,
-0.29767873883247375,
-0.6716680526733398,
-0.19423192739486694,
0.24015182256698608,
0.3356855809688568,
0.46858903765678406,
0.5548136830329895,
-0.9446269869804382,
-0.4538652002811432,
-0.8466183543205261,
0.07868511974811554,
0.2468952089548111,
0.07213693857192993,
0.46891263127326965,
0.6711973547935486,
-0.5521618723869324,
0.7082738280296326,
-0.39492034912109375,
-0.034558266401290894,
-0.30405962467193604,
0.23107533156871796,
0.10280603170394897,
0.8514475226402283,
0.6480486989021301,
-0.7527185082435608,
-0.1288241147994995,
-0.20066343247890472,
-0.7959941625595093,
0.2235739380121231,
0.25350022315979004,
-0.32567888498306274,
-0.37925630807876587,
0.43756595253944397,
-0.2525104582309723,
0.28904709219932556,
0.4590677320957184,
-0.03357793763279915,
0.16510705649852753,
-0.057710349559783936,
0.04097966104745865,
-0.7949086427688599,
-0.06480666995048523,
-0.0912361666560173,
-0.19022583961486816,
-0.7087523937225342,
0.4672773778438568,
0.42571941018104553,
0.010100673884153366,
-0.36999115347862244,
-0.12724347412586212,
-0.2562192678451538,
-0.1716395765542984,
0.14864934980869293,
-0.16135351359844208,
-0.07639724761247635,
0.24386753141880035,
-0.027281174436211586,
0.5397167801856995,
0.4963756799697876,
-0.39699262380599976,
0.22212427854537964,
0.3604971170425415,
-0.13019311428070068,
0.5347475409507751,
-0.5546684265136719,
-0.004173289518803358,
0.11986520886421204,
0.6962395906448364,
-0.5786052942276001,
-0.1435297280550003,
0.4532705247402191,
-0.2928199768066406,
0.5278493165969849,
-0.5048138499259949,
-0.1823982149362564,
-0.3674977123737335,
-0.6718249917030334,
0.7303532958030701,
0.39344629645347595,
-0.7756038308143616,
0.8927660584449768,
0.22920362651348114,
-0.18750137090682983,
-0.6493095755577087,
-0.7685160040855408,
-0.052564557641744614,
-0.3815298080444336,
-0.6280880570411682,
0.3348594307899475,
-0.20152415335178375,
0.09416495263576508,
-0.03824073076248169,
-0.14091871678829193,
0.2092662900686264,
0.21116824448108673,
0.29810455441474915,
-0.024293698370456696,
-0.22823256254196167,
0.19098564982414246,
0.29627469182014465,
-0.09530318528413773,
-0.004682906437665224,
-0.3001161813735962,
0.4583565294742584,
-0.04694225266575813,
-0.4208295941352844,
0.059474729001522064,
0.3936014771461487,
0.2211768478155136,
-0.1817743182182312,
0.727226972579956,
0.6673772931098938,
-0.4044000208377838,
-0.32303616404533386,
-0.23652100563049316,
-0.2573762536048889,
-0.4018462896347046,
-0.046894967555999756,
-0.1758430004119873,
-0.9563014507293701,
0.4196370244026184,
-0.45191946625709534,
-0.05418998375535011,
0.34384042024612427,
0.23350971937179565,
-0.4412384033203125,
0.5102762579917908,
0.5747535228729248,
-0.01715969108045101,
0.3712855875492096,
-0.8274233937263489,
0.0016112694283947349,
-1.0685683488845825,
-0.14788921177387238,
-0.3614281117916107,
-0.3081452548503876,
-0.5131793022155762,
-0.8096373081207275,
0.21607226133346558,
0.22082601487636566,
-0.5547466278076172,
0.4210575520992279,
-0.5404735803604126,
0.6082176566123962,
0.8215964436531067,
0.429817259311676,
-0.11042405664920807,
0.07771249860525131,
-0.5214925408363342,
0.19236412644386292,
-0.8704606294631958,
-0.18492391705513,
1.4413684606552124,
0.12960097193717957,
0.6065751314163208,
0.3756210505962372,
1.1613839864730835,
0.4895347058773041,
0.28358590602874756,
-0.577900230884552,
0.1532629281282425,
-0.5160666704177856,
-0.35183385014533997,
0.03114594705402851,
-0.5770952105522156,
-0.7970851063728333,
0.32860666513442993,
-0.40596213936805725,
-0.344857782125473,
0.7524361610412598,
0.2174557000398636,
-0.47202879190444946,
0.5145131945610046,
-0.4371122419834137,
0.8839296698570251,
-0.21879324316978455,
-0.5055155754089355,
-0.17976628243923187,
-0.8769828081130981,
0.5393757224082947,
-0.014890308491885662,
0.09490144997835159,
0.13701413571834564,
0.23000185191631317,
0.720630943775177,
-0.2903074026107788,
0.684230625629425,
-0.23325587809085846,
0.09170445799827576,
0.05839154124259949,
0.5604736804962158,
0.2503798305988312,
0.0897381380200386,
0.00801047869026661,
0.06304208189249039,
-0.07867707312107086,
-0.6263922452926636,
-0.3145569860935211,
0.5088120102882385,
-0.7336813807487488,
-0.6230887174606323,
-0.3890085816383362,
-0.06383083760738373,
-0.029298720881342888,
0.00010400138125987723,
0.22013680636882782,
0.4883386194705963,
-0.2429017722606659,
0.7586084604263306,
1.0573961734771729,
-0.37002673745155334,
0.0534810833632946,
0.16068986058235168,
-0.25753599405288696,
-0.6288694739341736,
0.9173704981803894,
-0.1080402061343193,
0.24451757967472076,
0.32083404064178467,
0.28264856338500977,
0.1593911200761795,
-0.36222919821739197,
-0.7345232963562012,
-0.011035989038646221,
-0.8481467366218567,
-0.21752120554447174,
-0.7899327278137207,
-0.1645500361919403,
-0.1136947050690651,
-0.672386109828949,
-0.1714211404323578,
-0.41138169169425964,
-0.1645035445690155,
-0.2473698854446411,
0.16820810735225677,
0.7561601996421814,
-0.45236828923225403,
0.4098378121852875,
-0.7651320099830627,
0.3093307912349701,
0.5147274136543274,
0.10900942981243134,
-0.17328959703445435,
-0.2999613881111145,
0.0062791937962174416,
0.20397613942623138,
-0.34867653250694275,
-1.0166912078857422,
0.15405768156051636,
0.3989778459072113,
0.6121703386306763,
0.546519935131073,
-0.20613768696784973,
0.2710738480091095,
-0.2913086712360382,
0.5882208347320557,
0.04468163475394249,
-1.0331014394760132,
0.5991460084915161,
-0.668515145778656,
-0.13709548115730286,
0.610288679599762,
0.3780829608440399,
-0.471784770488739,
-0.3531120717525482,
-0.6539555788040161,
-0.985779345035553,
0.4692656695842743,
0.3928903639316559,
-0.04023710638284683,
0.04126778617501259,
0.22187432646751404,
0.261813223361969,
0.37234655022621155,
-0.7577278017997742,
-0.45046111941337585,
-0.3839460611343384,
-0.22195911407470703,
-0.24507801234722137,
-0.4161040484905243,
-0.5399484038352966,
-0.6332359313964844,
0.6139761209487915,
0.01199557725340128,
0.33575108647346497,
0.10383917391300201,
-0.43104273080825806,
-0.19030287861824036,
0.04920368641614914,
0.6682764291763306,
0.3605612814426422,
-0.833277702331543,
0.38232114911079407,
0.005417948588728905,
-0.36603206396102905,
0.07360735535621643,
0.2236696034669876,
-0.05480361729860306,
-0.29808589816093445,
0.25492343306541443,
0.1548660695552826,
0.298094242811203,
-0.3327091634273529,
0.70421302318573,
0.06497904658317566,
-0.3166140019893646,
0.07891097664833069,
0.29661017656326294,
0.37157201766967773,
0.5149810910224915,
0.36932313442230225,
0.25567692518234253,
0.4044358730316162,
-0.4261893332004547,
0.3088529407978058,
0.20103412866592407,
-0.17131325602531433,
0.1173093393445015,
0.5763815641403198,
0.41298991441726685,
0.1943332552909851,
0.5018274188041687,
-0.4939476549625397,
-0.8271626830101013,
1.0507395267486572,
0.2796376943588257,
0.7699955105781555,
-0.3793362081050873,
0.3182615041732788,
0.5518803000450134,
0.29143956303596497,
-0.028952723369002342,
0.08981742709875107,
-0.42557841539382935,
-0.6628483533859253,
0.26524272561073303,
-0.4209732413291931,
-0.8617243766784668,
-0.32133638858795166,
-0.6769039630889893,
0.11877015978097916,
-0.664524257183075,
0.19525399804115295,
0.062356702983379364,
-0.2103169560432434,
-0.6112524271011353,
0.018840143457055092,
0.08453425019979477,
0.965819776058197,
-1.045240879058838,
0.6503890156745911,
0.2623964548110962,
-0.358124703168869,
-0.44608554244041443,
-0.23974771797657013,
0.25928640365600586,
-0.4551137685775757,
0.54180508852005,
0.534350574016571,
-0.29688411951065063,
-0.003824392566457391,
-0.5691020488739014,
-0.754964292049408,
1.4159295558929443,
0.13348978757858276,
-0.7301249504089355,
0.6855020523071289,
-0.13572727143764496,
0.3153958320617676,
-0.6784679293632507,
0.08792250603437424,
0.518092930316925,
0.17398476600646973,
0.15818284451961517,
0.014860290102660656,
-0.06635910272598267,
-0.28164875507354736,
-0.020249826833605766,
0.22107701003551483,
-0.5302712321281433,
1.105326771736145,
-0.101333849132061,
-0.07005848735570908,
0.0057488237507641315,
0.3864983022212982,
0.3405809700489044,
0.31112873554229736,
0.4633459746837616,
0.9236266016960144,
0.8011959195137024,
-0.221905916929245,
0.767014741897583,
-0.3218957483768463,
0.4454204738140106,
1.0632983446121216,
-0.2529905140399933,
0.9006346464157104,
0.2970280945301056,
-0.2292584925889969,
0.7307264804840088,
1.092952847480774,
-0.3674919903278351,
0.6513723731040955,
0.42567178606987,
-0.2124015986919403,
-0.3424444794654846,
0.1683630347251892,
-0.8336622714996338,
0.20382697880268097,
0.6714402437210083,
-0.6411001682281494,
0.04731542989611626,
-0.10839518159627914,
-0.39316973090171814,
-0.32939863204956055,
-0.16652712225914001,
0.45212602615356445,
-0.03588396683335304,
0.002785331569612026,
0.28602170944213867,
-0.1906878501176834,
0.6903769969940186,
-0.21088793873786926,
-0.13089653849601746,
-0.49419766664505005,
0.03877272084355354,
-0.2834952175617218,
-0.5898752212524414,
-0.11860787868499756,
-0.27266526222229004,
-0.20645420253276825,
-0.09280357509851456,
0.35657641291618347,
-0.5862765908241272,
-0.5722543597221375,
0.6576636433601379,
0.4414767622947693,
0.10515879094600677,
0.31089842319488525,
-0.553765058517456,
-0.17798955738544464,
-0.02550939843058586,
-0.11106447130441666,
0.027276594191789627,
0.0840444415807724,
0.3406941592693329,
0.5867422223091125,
0.5793129801750183,
-0.031112799420952797,
-0.14085187017917633,
0.04972883686423302,
0.9509836435317993,
-0.6454298496246338,
-0.325379878282547,
-0.6549660563468933,
0.3072953224182129,
-0.028367409482598305,
0.09468406438827515,
0.46866464614868164,
0.7793596982955933,
1.2071382999420166,
-0.0942748486995697,
0.6901659369468689,
0.08671854436397552,
0.4542241394519806,
-0.24694500863552094,
0.49401596188545227,
-0.602579653263092,
0.28078967332839966,
-0.2457299530506134,
-1.0255141258239746,
-0.4741753339767456,
0.6933626532554626,
-0.19703897833824158,
0.27113425731658936,
0.5860078930854797,
0.6024889349937439,
-0.39025163650512695,
0.17093545198440552,
0.13268844783306122,
0.03745148703455925,
0.2997921407222748,
0.4893023371696472,
0.7417065501213074,
-0.16588439047336578,
0.2521840035915375,
-0.6122690439224243,
-0.2860035300254822,
-0.6509642004966736,
-0.9457985758781433,
-0.7044800519943237,
-0.35333681106567383,
-0.15955066680908203,
-0.21594209969043732,
0.17612898349761963,
0.9471712708473206,
0.5192859172821045,
-0.9210218191146851,
-0.21793067455291748,
-0.08519184589385986,
0.0013282560976222157,
-0.017779381945729256,
-0.12333393096923828,
0.29129526019096375,
0.192243754863739,
-0.20603486895561218,
0.31559473276138306,
0.4803421199321747,
0.16964967548847198,
-0.013351422734558582,
-0.034859612584114075,
-0.3242625594139099,
-0.08070807158946991,
0.261777400970459,
0.42118003964424133,
-0.5424544811248779,
-0.2376992553472519,
-0.30393558740615845,
-0.20912136137485504,
0.19081565737724304,
1.0511049032211304,
-0.6415317058563232,
0.7380822896957397,
0.18517693877220154,
0.8678625226020813,
0.5485039949417114,
0.028357766568660736,
0.5044764876365662,
-0.6338770985603333,
-0.03955702483654022,
0.07986630499362946,
0.7940492630004883,
0.6141118407249451,
-0.3154626488685608,
0.8632508516311646,
0.43115705251693726,
-0.4360641837120056,
-0.49126318097114563,
0.20754139125347137,
-1.0788633823394775,
-0.38828930258750916,
0.8960493206977844,
-0.3198222517967224,
-0.10240966826677322,
0.12706086039543152,
-0.07278987020254135,
0.4324215352535248,
-0.19593445956707,
0.6773421764373779,
0.482015460729599,
0.09335345774888992,
-0.12096253782510757,
-0.15444085001945496,
0.40019625425338745,
0.5497782826423645,
-0.6090825796127319,
-0.09341241419315338,
0.41827094554901123,
0.4192989766597748,
0.13377909362316132,
0.05408263951539993,
0.32906514406204224,
0.5966740846633911,
0.18480144441127777,
0.06429789960384369,
-0.12191936373710632,
-0.5136309862136841,
-0.40490126609802246,
0.031601231545209885,
-0.08965052664279938,
-0.0801941454410553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10963v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10963v2 | GLoRe: When, Where, and How to Improve LLM Reasoning via Global and Local Refinements | 2024-02-13T20:16:29 | 2024-06-25T03:14:10 | Alex Havrilla, Sharath Raparthy, Christoforus Nalmpantis, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Maksym Zhuravinskyi, Eric Hambro, Roberta Raileanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-of-the-art language models can exhibit impressive reasoning refinement
capabilities on math, science or coding tasks. However, recent work
demonstrates that even the best models struggle to identify \textit{when and
where to refine} without access to external feedback. Outcome-based Reward
Models (\textbf{ORMs}), trained to predict correctness of the final answer
indicating when to refine, offer one convenient solution for deciding when to
refine. Process Based Reward Models (\textbf{PRMs}), trained to predict
correctness of intermediate steps, can then be used to indicate where to
refine. But they are expensive to train, requiring extensive human annotations.
In this paper, we propose Stepwise ORMs (\textbf{SORMs}) which are trained,
only on synthetic data, to approximate the expected future reward of the
optimal policy or $V^{\star}$. More specifically, SORMs are trained to predict
the correctness of the final answer when sampling the current policy many times
(rather than only once as in the case of ORMs). Our experiments show that SORMs
can more accurately detect incorrect reasoning steps compared to ORMs, thus
improving downstream accuracy when doing refinements. We then train
\textit{global} refinement models, which take only the question and a draft
solution as input and predict a corrected solution, and \textit{local}
refinement models which also take as input a critique indicating the location
of the first reasoning error. We generate training data for both models
synthetically by reusing data used to train the SORM. We find combining global
and local refinements, using the ORM as a reranker, significantly outperforms
either one individually, as well as a best of three sample baseline. With this
strategy we can improve the accuracy of a LLaMA-2 13B model (already fine-tuned
with RL) on GSM8K from 53\% to 65\% when greedily sampled. | [
-0.10759781301021576,
-0.5272074937820435,
0.771369218826294,
-0.22184684872627258,
0.01980843022465706,
0.043778326362371445,
-0.1524743139743805,
-0.3749628961086273,
-0.09177876263856888,
0.5813212394714355,
-0.8840878009796143,
-0.45937588810920715,
-0.3331826329231262,
0.019884560257196426,
0.17816846072673798,
0.7932742238044739,
-0.3511595129966736,
0.46802544593811035,
-0.30527275800704956,
-0.158417746424675,
-0.466882586479187,
-0.5496565699577332,
-0.9828343391418457,
-0.7075635194778442,
0.48041480779647827,
0.62930828332901,
0.3751770555973053,
0.43544313311576843,
0.48660680651664734,
0.3609035611152649,
-0.2666151225566864,
0.7255346775054932,
-0.5194986462593079,
0.18557687103748322,
-0.5645663142204285,
-0.7541700601577759,
-0.4026365280151367,
0.09756089001893997,
0.22769153118133545,
0.3561781346797943,
-0.4145638346672058,
0.13202285766601562,
-0.1182321161031723,
0.6812150478363037,
-0.6192532181739807,
0.10358419269323349,
-0.6244174242019653,
-0.08960074186325073,
-0.03323522210121155,
-0.4914877116680145,
-0.27476099133491516,
-0.8132579922676086,
-0.1363069862127304,
-0.42948460578918457,
0.31284087896347046,
0.017796458676457405,
0.7214528918266296,
0.4691488444805145,
-0.12065701931715012,
-0.41738128662109375,
-0.6596876382827759,
1.0002305507659912,
-0.7157237529754639,
0.3186257481575012,
0.30235177278518677,
0.5795512795448303,
-0.5404134392738342,
-0.5134232640266418,
-0.28829827904701233,
-0.4809747040271759,
-0.11400580406188965,
0.13386750221252441,
0.23395897448062897,
-0.039030179381370544,
0.358516663312912,
0.4686841666698456,
-0.26493626832962036,
-0.11899592727422714,
-0.48811882734298706,
-0.40223440527915955,
0.7850886583328247,
0.17225930094718933,
-0.08079356700181961,
-0.10313961654901505,
-0.4511255621910095,
0.08350765705108643,
-1.1480170488357544,
0.1614670306444168,
0.44826531410217285,
0.35487860441207886,
0.2989373803138733,
0.4430557191371918,
-0.4224950969219208,
0.6969724297523499,
0.07242756336927414,
-0.45120611786842346,
0.061213742941617966,
-0.6380539536476135,
-0.13223017752170563,
-0.020709402859210968,
0.25787070393562317,
0.11406558007001877,
0.23263852298259735,
0.030162455514073372,
-0.36743006110191345,
0.01551244966685772,
0.3705418109893799,
-0.7035380601882935,
-0.004241696558892727,
0.23172029852867126,
-0.28547170758247375,
-0.1862846463918686,
-0.1235991045832634,
-0.3009706139564514,
-0.5795956254005432,
-0.853458046913147,
0.21655228734016418,
-0.26686522364616394,
0.03799525648355484,
0.18453992903232574,
0.07403793185949326,
0.18878956139087677,
0.60760098695755,
-0.794974684715271,
0.08921106159687042,
0.5859398245811462,
0.7555015683174133,
-0.0007715483079664409,
-0.11930646002292633,
-0.5830285549163818,
-0.023670261725783348,
-0.40700793266296387,
1.086732029914856,
-0.46342477202415466,
-0.45411500334739685,
-0.029039468616247177,
-0.09868217259645462,
0.017415856942534447,
-0.9858101606369019,
0.7632169723510742,
-0.5719908475875854,
0.015565880574285984,
-0.5643696188926697,
-0.2679387331008911,
-0.23799972236156464,
0.4064846634864807,
-0.31754276156425476,
1.003829002380371,
-0.1403440535068512,
-0.6082118153572083,
0.39249345660209656,
-0.6486219167709351,
-0.2945978045463562,
-0.4068513512611389,
-0.09253887832164764,
-0.2648555040359497,
0.1851229965686798,
0.3110883831977844,
0.2439141422510147,
-0.3731549382209778,
0.3360668122768402,
-0.34001538157463074,
-0.5650393962860107,
-0.04837266355752945,
-0.12224747240543365,
0.4611424505710602,
0.313816100358963,
-0.19871051609516144,
0.573535680770874,
-0.7823788523674011,
0.2531225383281708,
-0.11275659501552582,
-0.5706123113632202,
-0.030627939850091934,
0.16249601542949677,
-0.7197158336639404,
0.28985339403152466,
0.17877593636512756,
-0.5186744332313538,
0.4176606237888336,
-0.40415239334106445,
0.6280408501625061,
0.8581899404525757,
0.20182381570339203,
0.5797003507614136,
-0.3763684928417206,
0.568505048751831,
-0.238807812333107,
0.3574952781200409,
-0.034436456859111786,
-0.40926408767700195,
-0.8817316293716431,
-0.15723252296447754,
0.19873324036598206,
0.7449362874031067,
-0.6861824989318848,
0.047803450375795364,
0.014413154684007168,
-0.546734631061554,
-0.5151718854904175,
0.09438404440879822,
0.3463984429836273,
0.614048182964325,
0.4908112585544586,
-0.16772755980491638,
-0.5968052744865417,
-0.8196636438369751,
-0.30376654863357544,
-0.2637467682361603,
0.05720587819814682,
0.18639247119426727,
0.46093228459358215,
-0.06883976608514786,
0.9172737002372742,
-0.40938156843185425,
-0.11540908366441727,
-0.2026207596063614,
0.3136453628540039,
0.14140409231185913,
0.2961970269680023,
-0.29108700156211853,
-0.6733380556106567,
-0.08363718539476395,
-0.08507869392633438,
-0.8545181751251221,
-0.28376126289367676,
-0.054734211415052414,
-0.26072296500205994,
0.39347386360168457,
0.7747806906700134,
-0.41674357652664185,
0.5690698027610779,
0.05188536271452904,
-0.06497171521186829,
0.713495671749115,
-0.4844551980495453,
0.20117464661598206,
-0.42438870668411255,
-0.03166733682155609,
-0.018086383119225502,
-0.18547171354293823,
-0.4653097689151764,
0.2800063490867615,
-0.14853577315807343,
0.13569986820220947,
-0.43038955330848694,
0.657442569732666,
-0.4668368101119995,
-0.09922276437282562,
-0.27484941482543945,
0.06062543764710426,
-0.14986881613731384,
0.5157507061958313,
0.21390867233276367,
0.8951900005340576,
0.3072863519191742,
-0.5517053008079529,
0.41457024216651917,
-0.03446977958083153,
-0.4518949091434479,
0.8235859870910645,
-0.623826801776886,
0.15927305817604065,
-0.1139606162905693,
0.5232579708099365,
-0.8806582689285278,
-0.13225926458835602,
0.40245845913887024,
-0.322003573179245,
0.35699954628944397,
-0.14925186336040497,
-0.3359246850013733,
-0.19235412776470184,
-0.2758537530899048,
0.17525753378868103,
0.4043600261211395,
-0.6535801887512207,
0.6391032934188843,
0.13307982683181763,
-0.1375054270029068,
-0.5249954462051392,
-0.6120193004608154,
-0.32297778129577637,
-0.20423756539821625,
-0.7469257712364197,
0.3406694531440735,
-0.10396403074264526,
-0.30377450585365295,
-0.2711212933063507,
-0.5001037120819092,
0.2323753833770752,
-0.13308851420879364,
0.33980539441108704,
0.2781496047973633,
0.07629826664924622,
0.13619478046894073,
-0.257345050573349,
-0.4559195637702942,
0.16778111457824707,
-0.39756181836128235,
0.40398070216178894,
-0.15839168429374695,
-0.7159736156463623,
-0.15109771490097046,
0.05994601547718048,
0.31242144107818604,
-0.31880509853363037,
0.4591999351978302,
0.46668896079063416,
-0.2055303156375885,
-0.2680015563964844,
-0.7933828830718994,
-0.2520979344844818,
-0.4730651378631592,
0.18776126205921173,
-0.32374444603919983,
-0.8114425539970398,
0.5880822539329529,
-0.34288644790649414,
0.05979728698730469,
0.25592517852783203,
0.6287615895271301,
0.03169942647218704,
0.9529081583023071,
0.469218909740448,
0.12658582627773285,
0.3694004416465759,
-0.3923484981060028,
0.2822679877281189,
-0.8866545557975769,
-0.7362980246543884,
-0.3985544741153717,
-0.3319430947303772,
-0.43952110409736633,
-0.7599157094955444,
0.2656097114086151,
0.43827369809150696,
-0.4586327373981476,
-0.09051776677370071,
-0.5029463171958923,
0.5611346364021301,
0.7692494988441467,
0.16835278272628784,
0.23719966411590576,
0.13335663080215454,
-0.3049982488155365,
-0.01243247464299202,
-0.8167742490768433,
-0.5471690893173218,
1.0204871892929077,
0.12691450119018555,
0.7893064618110657,
-0.19477126002311707,
0.7532890439033508,
0.15174442529678345,
0.673869788646698,
-0.5656273365020752,
0.6542726755142212,
0.33386456966400146,
-0.4675886929035187,
-0.193839430809021,
-0.5381453037261963,
-0.6340222954750061,
0.1777588129043579,
0.03578192740678787,
-0.6852350234985352,
0.31424856185913086,
0.18244284391403198,
-0.4980868101119995,
0.3173413574695587,
-0.5561635494232178,
0.7435519099235535,
-0.11095870286226273,
-0.6542767286300659,
-0.35106390714645386,
-0.60595703125,
0.31904059648513794,
0.1911429613828659,
0.3159853518009186,
-0.09678017348051071,
0.07637804746627808,
0.27128440141677856,
-0.9175384044647217,
0.6971903443336487,
-0.34640970826148987,
-0.14007048308849335,
0.6682367324829102,
-0.02655155025422573,
0.6353821754455566,
0.05137757584452629,
-0.2770692706108093,
0.12514926493167877,
-0.4214795231819153,
-0.3155844807624817,
-0.7207918167114258,
0.764349102973938,
-0.45572564005851746,
-0.8492607474327087,
-0.5075918436050415,
-0.3880038857460022,
-0.3053063750267029,
-0.17372402548789978,
0.23715908825397491,
0.4081045687198639,
0.2346922755241394,
-0.4975524842739105,
0.7662460803985596,
-0.15208286046981812,
0.09517403692007065,
0.4666959047317505,
-0.19362322986125946,
-0.5026683807373047,
0.822035014629364,
0.1679532825946808,
0.38914716243743896,
0.2279689759016037,
0.13640739023685455,
-0.6602759957313538,
-0.5017191767692566,
-0.2777526378631592,
0.31209245324134827,
-1.1480722427368164,
-0.37358683347702026,
0.06704852730035782,
-0.3288451135158539,
-0.12016922980546951,
-0.2859072685241699,
-0.14091576635837555,
-0.2768898010253906,
-0.0683603435754776,
-0.24487420916557312,
0.304512083530426,
0.8146111965179443,
-0.41254693269729614,
-0.05967145413160324,
-0.5020166635513306,
0.1320735365152359,
0.2744980752468109,
0.17951010167598724,
0.04359562322497368,
-0.7908783555030823,
-0.028058860450983047,
0.08990079909563065,
-0.3279312551021576,
-0.6839957237243652,
0.20482566952705383,
-0.08298645168542862,
0.6621030569076538,
0.10986030101776123,
-0.2179834246635437,
0.8738713264465332,
-0.535096287727356,
0.545339047908783,
-0.06467399001121521,
-0.7125281095504761,
0.9111236929893494,
-0.07514332234859467,
0.3273879587650299,
0.5937352776527405,
0.36570268869400024,
-0.3534410893917084,
-0.2841944098472595,
-0.6080209016799927,
-0.8634203672409058,
0.7287601828575134,
-0.09576952457427979,
-0.2291025072336197,
0.021147189661860466,
0.7847389578819275,
0.0038221676368266344,
0.10024252533912659,
-0.5367122292518616,
-0.03979908302426338,
0.13206757605075836,
0.1798706352710724,
0.13228778541088104,
-0.27669787406921387,
-0.13188312947750092,
-0.2488252818584442,
1.036960244178772,
-0.12775741517543793,
0.12055131047964096,
0.3813124895095825,
0.13939400017261505,
-0.13189639151096344,
0.33665773272514343,
0.6741513609886169,
0.9314239621162415,
-0.2269575446844101,
0.16436241567134857,
0.4140901267528534,
-0.01703869365155697,
0.32543066143989563,
-0.04358554631471634,
-0.27707478404045105,
-0.14674538373947144,
0.32766997814178467,
0.5020833015441895,
0.22856144607067108,
-0.6765576601028442,
0.08486227691173553,
0.20919589698314667,
-0.07748053967952728,
-0.16705980896949768,
0.31857240200042725,
0.19892454147338867,
0.56725013256073,
0.0790378674864769,
0.509920060634613,
0.1318656951189041,
-0.6249703168869019,
-0.006228247191756964,
0.32418292760849,
-0.2785177230834961,
-0.0018718435894697905,
0.5785419344902039,
-0.06060764566063881,
-0.3709750473499298,
0.6601033210754395,
-0.5462685227394104,
-0.6661498546600342,
0.43481507897377014,
0.38877129554748535,
0.45742008090019226,
-0.28931140899658203,
0.27428537607192993,
0.6390666961669922,
0.08155204355716705,
-0.46890610456466675,
0.6755280494689941,
0.06377818435430527,
-0.5774518847465515,
-0.6743203401565552,
-0.6779013872146606,
-0.5205227136611938,
-0.04184117540717125,
-0.5213313102722168,
0.36014506220817566,
-0.5741697549819946,
-0.11606131494045258,
-0.35309016704559326,
0.11561094224452972,
-0.48948705196380615,
0.3801873028278351,
0.11150956153869629,
0.9392936825752258,
-0.7353630661964417,
0.6493024230003357,
0.8431886434555054,
-0.5003319978713989,
-0.9131320118904114,
-0.25017213821411133,
0.1027674525976181,
-1.0181488990783691,
0.9127528667449951,
0.07570357620716095,
-0.46500691771507263,
-0.38358670473098755,
-0.569672167301178,
-1.0181775093078613,
1.2038744688034058,
0.44262421131134033,
-0.4453009068965912,
0.1900632232427597,
0.045584190636873245,
0.551072895526886,
-0.19358639419078827,
0.5591028332710266,
0.7276754975318909,
0.48326215147972107,
0.7643887400627136,
-0.6348769664764404,
0.11296339333057404,
-0.10221251845359802,
0.06786765903234482,
0.13231517374515533,
-0.7192511558532715,
0.7842105031013489,
-0.5542780756950378,
-0.09296179562807083,
0.12831801176071167,
0.6727926731109619,
0.8956860303878784,
0.22865405678749084,
0.34805524349212646,
0.7287808060646057,
1.0872184038162231,
-0.3591282069683075,
1.2243837118148804,
0.1362624168395996,
0.1581735759973526,
1.0191253423690796,
-0.2580225169658661,
0.9446824789047241,
0.356971800327301,
-0.21508115530014038,
0.719901978969574,
1.0769362449645996,
0.19374094903469086,
0.7679073810577393,
0.7347164154052734,
-0.1809128075838089,
-0.6046362519264221,
-0.18198110163211823,
-0.3157721757888794,
0.09654617309570312,
0.14903764426708221,
-0.011040648445487022,
-0.3896174430847168,
-0.2967085540294647,
0.08426558971405029,
0.08442925661802292,
-0.7329899072647095,
0.40834492444992065,
0.130822092294693,
-1.0397381782531738,
0.6964995265007019,
0.2637650668621063,
0.4967317283153534,
-0.6978245377540588,
-0.16507095098495483,
-0.7223590016365051,
0.40124958753585815,
-0.4903358221054077,
-0.4349863529205322,
0.41364482045173645,
-0.04717855900526047,
-0.24782916903495789,
-0.3192637264728546,
0.9876858592033386,
-0.3719457983970642,
-0.5068362355232239,
0.097352534532547,
0.27153444290161133,
0.23939692974090576,
-0.11001069098711014,
-0.751690149307251,
0.02252860926091671,
0.08878938108682632,
-0.21714165806770325,
0.24937015771865845,
0.4756549894809723,
-0.3810634911060333,
0.9921747446060181,
0.7543777823448181,
0.4261495769023895,
-0.07890273630619049,
0.24127569794654846,
0.7618694305419922,
-0.45935627818107605,
-0.39352789521217346,
-0.9658596515655518,
0.5145421028137207,
-0.1527414470911026,
-0.16436463594436646,
0.6765312552452087,
0.35850825905799866,
1.0229690074920654,
0.18816804885864258,
0.5724837183952332,
0.28605201840400696,
0.5419403910636902,
-0.8938835263252258,
0.21653033792972565,
-0.6694278717041016,
0.6101633906364441,
0.4230315089225769,
-0.8405861258506775,
-0.1989118903875351,
1.0035936832427979,
-0.850587785243988,
0.34284308552742004,
0.6476488709449768,
1.0331976413726807,
0.07293765246868134,
0.22877973318099976,
-0.12994255125522614,
0.05599220097064972,
0.23505206406116486,
0.6381583213806152,
1.1469897031784058,
-0.11120948195457458,
0.33238735795021057,
0.014671506360173225,
-0.20827113091945648,
-0.2048429250717163,
-0.9590282440185547,
-0.6794859766960144,
0.053056858479976654,
-0.41375988721847534,
-0.3178378939628601,
0.21564067900180817,
0.8099576830863953,
0.7167685627937317,
-0.9939425587654114,
-0.29270467162132263,
-0.2745557427406311,
0.34536096453666687,
-0.23018020391464233,
-0.14343944191932678,
0.25302252173423767,
-0.7305341362953186,
-0.3581252098083496,
0.5925406217575073,
0.4153894782066345,
-0.3271087110042572,
-0.38122037053108215,
-0.31119316816329956,
-0.056056536734104156,
0.2669931948184967,
0.24247361719608307,
0.37008199095726013,
-0.9309256672859192,
-0.33730122447013855,
-0.08657203614711761,
-0.09210172295570374,
0.12719686329364777,
0.8847596645355225,
-0.8414927124977112,
0.4098822772502899,
0.41271674633026123,
0.41036003828048706,
0.48201483488082886,
0.10094691812992096,
0.5266742706298828,
-0.6345146298408508,
-0.1542256772518158,
0.09652124345302582,
0.47989290952682495,
0.4591186046600342,
-0.19630476832389832,
0.8611389994621277,
0.19482421875,
-0.8026777505874634,
-0.6664928793907166,
0.3510025441646576,
-0.4806036055088043,
-0.21103331446647644,
1.211796522140503,
-0.35714784264564514,
-0.1335316002368927,
0.027333861216902733,
-0.5047311186790466,
0.15673206746578217,
-0.2105291187763214,
0.8404279351234436,
0.7737783193588257,
-0.40496736764907837,
0.20076796412467957,
-0.6100561618804932,
0.7384599447250366,
0.4907027781009674,
-0.9891111254692078,
0.11742610484361649,
0.5354040265083313,
0.31553149223327637,
0.2410271167755127,
0.8572428822517395,
-0.043304864317178726,
0.12544579803943634,
-0.10329534858465195,
-0.03929780423641205,
-0.23195432126522064,
-0.46675756573677063,
-0.33961570262908936,
0.13111546635627747,
0.09354951977729797,
0.0005594502435997128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10962v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10962v3 | Measuring and Controlling Instruction (In)Stability in Language Model Dialogs | 2024-02-13T20:10:29 | 2024-05-01T16:47:42 | Kenneth Li, Tianle Liu, Naomi Bashkansky, David Bau, Fernanda Viégas, Hanspeter Pfister, Martin Wattenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | System-prompting is a standard tool for customizing language-model chatbots,
enabling them to follow a specific instruction. An implicit assumption in the
use of system prompts is that they will be stable, so the chatbot will continue
to generate text according to the stipulated instructions for the duration of a
conversation. We propose a quantitative benchmark to test this assumption,
evaluating instruction stability via self-chats between two instructed
chatbots. Testing popular models like LLaMA2-chat-70B and GPT-3.5, we reveal a
significant instruction drift within eight rounds of conversations. An
empirical and theoretical analysis of this phenomenon suggests the transformer
attention mechanism plays a role, due to attention decay over long exchanges.
To combat attention decay and instruction drift, we propose a lightweight
method called split-softmax, which compares favorably against two strong
baselines. | [
-0.13222451508045197,
-1.0054153203964233,
0.2422831654548645,
0.28592804074287415,
0.17642803490161896,
0.075985848903656,
-0.33530211448669434,
0.09954573959112167,
-0.2354707419872284,
0.3695943355560303,
-0.5797442197799683,
-0.05960673466324806,
-0.4530591368675232,
0.008729125373065472,
-0.5917977690696716,
1.028646469116211,
0.05638992786407471,
0.16903994977474213,
-0.5215569138526917,
-0.13059325516223907,
-1.0558795928955078,
-0.35442233085632324,
-0.7723630666732788,
-0.3069606125354767,
0.019715407863259315,
0.6436642408370972,
0.7363150119781494,
0.4124857187271118,
0.5409137606620789,
0.3949184715747833,
-0.19875752925872803,
-0.15476517379283905,
-0.750373363494873,
0.6914018988609314,
0.2575819790363312,
-0.688101053237915,
-0.2711123526096344,
-0.17290480434894562,
0.6724156141281128,
0.4850327670574188,
-0.4471254050731659,
0.05336128920316696,
0.48322606086730957,
0.30764609575271606,
-0.533604085445404,
0.03766578435897827,
-0.40588217973709106,
-0.34561052918434143,
0.0481281578540802,
-0.02667178399860859,
-0.7841084599494934,
-0.3866274356842041,
0.33253517746925354,
-0.0415254682302475,
0.1134990006685257,
-0.23578065633773804,
0.9241263270378113,
0.4941166043281555,
-0.15442246198654175,
-0.2982242703437805,
-0.5379383563995361,
0.7161617875099182,
-0.6280903816223145,
0.48626580834388733,
0.45752066373825073,
0.3153938353061676,
-0.2837812602519989,
-0.338390588760376,
-0.3262566924095154,
-0.6466013193130493,
-0.01654900424182415,
0.21177752315998077,
-0.24093246459960938,
0.16332578659057617,
0.2267201691865921,
0.024962080642580986,
-0.2306121438741684,
0.3308226764202118,
-0.38692012429237366,
-0.23124480247497559,
0.22830311954021454,
0.4158255457878113,
0.46822112798690796,
-0.05512820929288864,
-0.47467276453971863,
-0.14292903244495392,
-0.8104109764099121,
0.1656406670808792,
0.26279979944229126,
0.08276811242103577,
-0.38590008020401,
0.47397857904434204,
0.09187614172697067,
0.22874392569065094,
0.6604896783828735,
-0.33458828926086426,
0.024423716589808464,
-0.1944551318883896,
-0.15587858855724335,
0.27778375148773193,
0.8910467624664307,
0.689928412437439,
0.12107192724943161,
-0.0019882088527083397,
-0.27245986461639404,
0.1384650319814682,
0.24587827920913696,
-0.8055544495582581,
0.007273420691490173,
0.2586468458175659,
-0.4855254590511322,
0.029770122841000557,
-0.3076549470424652,
-0.6892958283424377,
-0.10176293551921844,
-0.03347356617450714,
0.3771556615829468,
-0.5528320074081421,
-0.042073093354701996,
-0.07286185026168823,
-0.03692150488495827,
0.3317379653453827,
0.251686692237854,
-1.2511221170425415,
0.5594608783721924,
0.7205199599266052,
0.8784310817718506,
-0.3700762689113617,
-0.11004091799259186,
-0.4349741041660309,
-0.05057676136493683,
-0.24566736817359924,
0.7264189124107361,
-0.49942511320114136,
-0.4609755575656891,
0.1628994345664978,
0.20566560328006744,
-0.3392394483089447,
-0.5350939035415649,
0.39464259147644043,
-0.39317938685417175,
0.6630260944366455,
0.22687196731567383,
-0.8564165830612183,
0.2097339630126953,
0.43926766514778137,
-0.42232176661491394,
1.113042950630188,
-0.007648884784430265,
-0.5796574950218201,
0.031454477459192276,
-0.6606947779655457,
-0.14812436699867249,
-0.06277620047330856,
-0.0826110914349556,
-0.2776258885860443,
-0.12583018839359283,
0.018535980954766273,
0.23926347494125366,
-0.16303424537181854,
0.04329431802034378,
-0.1628553420305252,
-0.4587821960449219,
0.33513009548187256,
-0.757524847984314,
0.7395641207695007,
-0.27125486731529236,
-0.5637879371643066,
0.022108664736151695,
-0.36708009243011475,
-0.1114998534321785,
-0.11858291923999786,
-0.3331657648086548,
-0.021407069638371468,
0.21886815130710602,
-0.46180376410484314,
-0.06706215441226959,
0.21814095973968506,
-0.626292884349823,
0.32095086574554443,
-0.47926065325737,
0.43181633949279785,
0.7520726323127747,
0.11086638271808624,
0.47944480180740356,
-0.04055747017264366,
0.7634149789810181,
-0.07196889817714691,
0.2429894506931305,
-0.7339473366737366,
-0.46725037693977356,
-1.2542403936386108,
0.3144444227218628,
0.25083059072494507,
0.8732205629348755,
-0.37376639246940613,
0.24752329289913177,
-0.3024151921272278,
-0.2459690123796463,
-0.5621257424354553,
0.017169615253806114,
0.7739789485931396,
0.4150817394256592,
0.059833597391843796,
-0.12131806463003159,
0.1630277782678604,
-0.8323235511779785,
0.10535673052072525,
-0.16987407207489014,
-0.019163696095347404,
-0.04669073969125748,
0.11655344069004059,
-0.30881279706954956,
0.7119882106781006,
-0.13056525588035583,
0.2579292953014374,
-0.2668048143386841,
0.042611557990312576,
-0.001995057798922062,
0.5232987999916077,
0.4266292452812195,
-0.14662742614746094,
-0.5613476037979126,
-0.1701369434595108,
-0.5975351333618164,
-0.03558346629142761,
-0.12886887788772583,
-0.23760360479354858,
0.48091983795166016,
0.6166614890098572,
-0.7550874948501587,
0.6443411111831665,
0.6650763154029846,
-0.22031743824481964,
0.3956880271434784,
-0.06437810510396957,
0.15361350774765015,
-0.7088514566421509,
-0.3580001890659332,
0.034796107560396194,
-0.1433112770318985,
-0.669485867023468,
-0.36702650785446167,
0.23236437141895294,
-0.06051766127347946,
-0.29081040620803833,
0.34413400292396545,
-0.3843580186367035,
0.282559871673584,
-0.40543320775032043,
0.35486072301864624,
-0.24664035439491272,
0.3996446430683136,
-0.1932060420513153,
0.8845083713531494,
0.53996342420578,
-0.6297268271446228,
0.2420753687620163,
0.29491743445396423,
-0.05943194031715393,
0.5520917177200317,
-1.0440776348114014,
0.5556102991104126,
0.046091049909591675,
0.19318510591983795,
-1.1685320138931274,
-0.18716955184936523,
0.35059022903442383,
-0.3505198359489441,
0.4491949677467346,
-0.24484661221504211,
-0.4599062502384186,
-0.2162300944328308,
-0.09433861821889877,
-0.022913433611392975,
0.5482429265975952,
-0.2245737612247467,
0.3811541199684143,
0.4024218022823334,
-0.13118807971477509,
-0.54921555519104,
-0.4690071940422058,
-0.15740732848644257,
-0.060251347720623016,
-0.7206358313560486,
-0.09003723412752151,
-0.16026094555854797,
-0.42978325486183167,
-0.09616544842720032,
-0.22437280416488647,
0.15625764429569244,
0.10159419476985931,
0.5854728817939758,
0.42751288414001465,
-0.33653703331947327,
0.2881200313568115,
0.2826964855194092,
-0.3538813591003418,
0.3135806918144226,
-0.03602057322859764,
0.6727235317230225,
-0.12542365491390228,
-0.37926769256591797,
-0.8969713449478149,
0.2050197571516037,
0.630036473274231,
0.010288523510098457,
0.8076627850532532,
0.07795772701501846,
-0.05900660529732704,
-0.04748458042740822,
-0.6083912253379822,
-0.5220745801925659,
-0.5716067552566528,
0.14989382028579712,
-0.16132093966007233,
-0.7712852358818054,
0.5905482172966003,
0.07058218121528625,
0.3396637439727783,
0.2837335467338562,
0.750098705291748,
-0.2641368806362152,
1.2231074571609497,
0.8088899850845337,
-0.005543245002627373,
0.6583156585693359,
-0.0750017836689949,
0.05163799598813057,
-0.5073581337928772,
-0.18497154116630554,
-0.5716930627822876,
-0.3269710838794708,
-0.5717319250106812,
-0.12230879068374634,
0.3393670618534088,
-0.21125058829784393,
-0.4442122280597687,
0.23495273292064667,
-0.6109602451324463,
0.6937984824180603,
0.4904521405696869,
0.021042441949248314,
-0.1521044820547104,
-0.2689889669418335,
0.007992872968316078,
0.09216861426830292,
-0.6660773754119873,
-0.7689718008041382,
0.768096923828125,
0.48974183201789856,
1.0328160524368286,
-0.13642685115337372,
0.43701115250587463,
0.15474508702754974,
0.3419453203678131,
-0.655247151851654,
0.6302286386489868,
0.17650094628334045,
-0.7402338981628418,
-0.5005573034286499,
-0.2623977065086365,
-1.0174636840820312,
-0.09909077733755112,
0.24831582605838776,
-0.9572340846061707,
-0.08682386577129364,
0.3071921765804291,
-0.3580399751663208,
-0.28119131922721863,
-0.9759932160377502,
1.079241394996643,
-0.37574145197868347,
-0.28346821665763855,
-0.2613435983657837,
-0.9463560581207275,
0.103997603058815,
0.43267184495925903,
-0.12429413199424744,
-0.30846932530403137,
-0.1401432454586029,
0.6802543997764587,
-0.4583587944507599,
0.9596659541130066,
-0.14871346950531006,
-0.20912984013557434,
0.460654616355896,
0.22717732191085815,
0.42169585824012756,
-0.05898723751306534,
-0.06425857543945312,
-0.18987105786800385,
-0.0013616298092529178,
-0.3553028404712677,
-0.8372306227684021,
0.5353837013244629,
-0.9286580085754395,
-0.7058561444282532,
-0.07148892432451248,
-0.20432357490062714,
-0.1517307013273239,
0.0077543496154248714,
0.2751886546611786,
0.6186383366584778,
-0.04199136793613434,
0.4221775531768799,
0.880058228969574,
0.03447442129254341,
0.5957422852516174,
0.4196580946445465,
-0.17189928889274597,
-0.3127795159816742,
0.5195080637931824,
0.12901698052883148,
0.9106685519218445,
0.30472153425216675,
0.30004143714904785,
-0.1016942709684372,
-0.28329119086265564,
-0.7073011994361877,
-0.04988008737564087,
-0.785612165927887,
-0.27204030752182007,
-0.3786356747150421,
-0.1923883706331253,
-0.15063607692718506,
-0.0642593652009964,
-0.43005409836769104,
-0.20010091364383698,
-0.14904603362083435,
-0.0738019347190857,
0.29293087124824524,
0.8433597087860107,
0.4806159436702728,
0.6249246001243591,
-0.9441984295845032,
-0.2497347742319107,
0.220800518989563,
0.2871650159358978,
-0.12181615084409714,
-0.7932955026626587,
-0.39514783024787903,
0.05610198155045509,
-0.5492612719535828,
-1.1390812397003174,
0.0026454096660017967,
0.25879740715026855,
0.6726248860359192,
0.6887817978858948,
-0.07391959428787231,
0.4717327356338501,
-0.4751484990119934,
1.001683235168457,
0.20444084703922272,
-1.131056547164917,
0.7199751734733582,
-0.4880395531654358,
0.7620532512664795,
0.5940932035446167,
0.19410784542560577,
-0.766035795211792,
-0.8473614454269409,
-0.5802875757217407,
-0.5471068024635315,
0.9823607802391052,
0.04504319280385971,
0.7327892780303955,
-0.1264207363128662,
0.3443432152271271,
0.1269410103559494,
-0.09974890947341919,
-0.4538024067878723,
-0.4005427360534668,
-0.2054046243429184,
-0.32340970635414124,
0.3640429377555847,
-0.41849377751350403,
-0.19308307766914368,
0.020158767700195312,
0.3602621853351593,
-0.15627452731132507,
0.33678460121154785,
-0.30499786138534546,
-0.02281090058386326,
-0.21846532821655273,
0.06586920469999313,
0.6489413976669312,
0.6229956150054932,
-0.0441993810236454,
0.010520786978304386,
0.3871731460094452,
-0.7667897939682007,
0.35940495133399963,
-0.3492131233215332,
-0.343068927526474,
-0.1220373660326004,
0.27708470821380615,
0.8062455058097839,
0.7353397607803345,
-0.7996249794960022,
0.5222933888435364,
-0.26197293400764465,
-0.02555214986205101,
0.04245070368051529,
0.44470736384391785,
0.1267009973526001,
-0.029491502791643143,
0.08577907830476761,
0.001858344185166061,
-0.2572205066680908,
-0.42170631885528564,
0.2135278582572937,
0.2496320754289627,
-0.5945907831192017,
-0.3236342668533325,
0.5338584780693054,
0.5431020855903625,
-0.6376663446426392,
0.9586907625198364,
-0.18039065599441528,
-0.585473358631134,
0.4699287712574005,
0.782282292842865,
0.9943621158599854,
-0.3995705842971802,
0.19797037541866302,
0.20403485000133514,
0.38702592253685,
-0.10989932715892792,
-0.027365243062376976,
0.02246689796447754,
-0.6311238408088684,
-0.18272563815116882,
-0.09148664027452469,
-0.6948912739753723,
-0.26520055532455444,
-0.6150097250938416,
0.30128014087677,
-0.5199362635612488,
-0.4463721513748169,
-0.30402320623397827,
-0.34383946657180786,
-0.2474084496498108,
-0.08775977045297623,
0.33089664578437805,
0.6393135190010071,
-0.6051392555236816,
0.6173025965690613,
0.264278382062912,
-0.1275973618030548,
-0.6458518505096436,
0.17639054358005524,
0.11307167261838913,
-0.7266011834144592,
0.5619867444038391,
0.45743781328201294,
-0.4904044568538666,
-0.44202756881713867,
-1.054839849472046,
-1.159266471862793,
0.8769370913505554,
0.6507201194763184,
-0.8011395335197449,
0.19575326144695282,
-0.21112459897994995,
0.520679771900177,
-0.12242872267961502,
0.5692134499549866,
0.7205073833465576,
0.1327640563249588,
0.09912849962711334,
-1.1600079536437988,
-0.19080661237239838,
-0.34594446420669556,
-0.25838908553123474,
0.4962928295135498,
-1.0895040035247803,
0.6614535450935364,
0.042701538652181625,
-0.597800612449646,
-0.03307399898767471,
0.8706840872764587,
0.12766581773757935,
0.2949545085430145,
0.5670679807662964,
0.5107389688491821,
0.6204677224159241,
-0.2230340987443924,
0.7059630751609802,
-0.6664489507675171,
0.21721510589122772,
1.076756477355957,
-0.04951221123337746,
0.9481029510498047,
0.1638941764831543,
-0.1316898912191391,
0.76402747631073,
0.5266638398170471,
0.044901084154844284,
0.2971920669078827,
0.005381857510656118,
0.039754804223775864,
-0.13033625483512878,
0.1368962973356247,
-0.23369571566581726,
0.4757615625858307,
0.5293064117431641,
-0.22249741852283478,
0.030479298904538155,
0.125291109085083,
0.4871317744255066,
-0.2306697815656662,
-0.08234594017267227,
0.8713507652282715,
-0.07874920964241028,
-1.0432668924331665,
0.8264086842536926,
-0.45276010036468506,
0.39088645577430725,
-0.5122987031936646,
0.11489399522542953,
-0.3937792181968689,
0.3916441798210144,
0.07505001127719879,
-0.7619249224662781,
-0.0723128691315651,
0.18443229794502258,
-0.1147274523973465,
-0.2913108766078949,
0.696553111076355,
-0.3754141926765442,
-0.4028503894805908,
0.15736182034015656,
0.32270926237106323,
0.25511324405670166,
0.5460798740386963,
-0.7150105237960815,
0.40309756994247437,
-0.06347421556711197,
-0.3542015850543976,
0.24186226725578308,
0.5466014742851257,
-0.013861816376447678,
0.8863746523857117,
0.06263385713100433,
-0.5735800266265869,
0.4549897313117981,
0.16556179523468018,
0.87017422914505,
-0.26915857195854187,
-0.23016008734703064,
-0.9821999669075012,
0.5299450755119324,
-0.12776504456996918,
-0.6440141201019287,
1.2404544353485107,
0.27306386828422546,
0.5778295993804932,
0.2975173890590668,
0.5509604811668396,
-0.09353134036064148,
0.1333790421485901,
-0.45018064975738525,
0.5522159337997437,
-0.17885757982730865,
0.20821969211101532,
0.06034146994352341,
-0.7307956218719482,
0.02170003578066826,
0.2531576454639435,
-0.32706794142723083,
-0.039743196219205856,
0.6430321931838989,
0.8501763343811035,
0.29587453603744507,
0.10884615033864975,
-0.02385222725570202,
-0.0029770261608064175,
0.3043704926967621,
0.11718209832906723,
1.2009419202804565,
-0.17819179594516754,
0.6922364234924316,
-0.12359786033630371,
-0.23649604618549347,
-0.38579490780830383,
-0.47844812273979187,
-1.0667622089385986,
-0.27340659499168396,
-0.3322034776210785,
-0.5667229890823364,
0.23722121119499207,
0.9076851010322571,
0.7972818613052368,
-0.7565612196922302,
-0.48642706871032715,
0.006246140226721764,
0.07811614871025085,
-0.3228565752506256,
-0.16714419424533844,
0.2753872573375702,
-0.854580819606781,
-0.7320188879966736,
0.3480687141418457,
0.557816207408905,
0.09717380255460739,
-0.6426444053649902,
0.008588751778006554,
0.2145707607269287,
0.2590126693248749,
0.3454703092575073,
0.17274020612239838,
-0.5947661995887756,
-0.30502888560295105,
0.31350526213645935,
-0.3531881272792816,
0.30753692984580994,
0.6254746913909912,
-0.44190317392349243,
0.6314791440963745,
0.5253119468688965,
0.47523602843284607,
0.2655983865261078,
0.14998474717140198,
0.7911219000816345,
-0.5427511930465698,
0.1232256218791008,
0.26073864102363586,
0.10869289934635162,
0.3381950259208679,
-0.18926851451396942,
0.1534300595521927,
-0.06134255230426788,
-1.186915397644043,
-0.8028820753097534,
-0.07648380100727081,
-0.7697784304618835,
0.22964049875736237,
1.0904721021652222,
-0.2339179962873459,
-0.5060095191001892,
0.005477875005453825,
-0.27978846430778503,
0.020106816664338112,
-0.8735213279724121,
0.7971385717391968,
0.7015986442565918,
-0.30727994441986084,
-0.5060160756111145,
-0.5800552368164062,
0.4627709984779358,
0.39769285917282104,
-0.6168553233146667,
0.16169473528862,
0.48629066348075867,
0.07635752856731415,
0.5098708868026733,
0.3963775932788849,
0.17163711786270142,
0.32015106081962585,
0.32832998037338257,
-0.15664604306221008,
0.5584807395935059,
-0.35485830903053284,
-0.22845789790153503,
0.15631312131881714,
-0.1817639023065567,
-0.5059831738471985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08764v1 | A Dataset for the Detection of Dehumanizing Language | 2024-02-13T19:58:24 | 2024-02-13T19:58:24 | Paul Engelmann, Peter Brunsgaard Trolle, Christian Hardmeier | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dehumanization is a mental process that enables the exclusion and ill
treatment of a group of people. In this paper, we present two data sets of
dehumanizing text, a large, automatically collected corpus and a smaller,
manually annotated data set. Both data sets include a combination of political
discourse and dialogue from movie subtitles. Our methods give us a broad and
varied amount of dehumanization data to work with, enabling further exploratory
analysis and automatic classification of dehumanization patterns. Both data
sets will be publicly released. | [
-0.5367693901062012,
-1.0918540954589844,
0.06544917821884155,
-0.09388011693954468,
-0.3380570411682129,
0.19546031951904297,
-0.3800332248210907,
-0.3023158013820648,
0.3706836700439453,
0.7459210753440857,
-0.4837816655635834,
-0.6054068803787231,
-0.8062418699264526,
0.1796773225069046,
-0.5685269832611084,
1.0828584432601929,
0.2333667278289795,
-0.22647660970687866,
-0.1286906898021698,
-0.20245663821697235,
-0.49872252345085144,
-0.5741126537322998,
-0.010645031929016113,
-0.10009153187274933,
0.2315826117992401,
0.7272555828094482,
1.125405192375183,
0.8838934898376465,
0.4450324475765228,
0.3660668730735779,
0.12239197641611099,
-0.01127204392105341,
-0.29530537128448486,
0.45666560530662537,
-0.33994144201278687,
-0.29572412371635437,
0.3267185091972351,
0.40191373229026794,
0.4430738389492035,
0.4490043520927429,
0.14465977251529694,
0.27445682883262634,
-0.2114471048116684,
0.5358773469924927,
-0.5694936513900757,
0.1540229469537735,
-0.33316493034362793,
0.363811194896698,
-0.4520275890827179,
0.09147126972675323,
0.042476508766412735,
-0.5442854166030884,
-0.16932232677936554,
-0.14876136183738708,
0.2690078318119049,
-0.10241676867008209,
0.42567360401153564,
0.7874827980995178,
-0.09999874234199524,
-0.16648299992084503,
-0.7691705822944641,
0.6889628767967224,
-0.4785233438014984,
-0.027255700901150703,
0.9835502505302429,
0.241233691573143,
0.17144063115119934,
-0.26241543889045715,
-0.7452012300491333,
-0.2035091370344162,
-0.40789559483528137,
-0.1483582705259323,
-0.2520467936992645,
-0.11951363831758499,
0.45578229427337646,
0.6244471073150635,
-0.6363128423690796,
0.36203327775001526,
-0.7142173647880554,
-0.18440820276737213,
0.7246696352958679,
0.002960209734737873,
0.5285786390304565,
-0.7162802219390869,
-0.08370877057313919,
0.0006076504359953105,
-0.10971212387084961,
-0.47243955731391907,
0.5426422357559204,
0.2633746564388275,
-0.13482776284217834,
0.5848020911216736,
-0.40445756912231445,
0.4279729425907135,
-0.41943275928497314,
0.1170068085193634,
0.34720101952552795,
-0.06455908715724945,
-0.3083806037902832,
0.20360806584358215,
0.5944752097129822,
0.5261038541793823,
0.5574195384979248,
-0.010995384305715561,
-0.157292440533638,
0.42153045535087585,
-0.04640413820743561,
-0.592775821685791,
-0.5488787293434143,
0.14465190470218658,
-0.37601780891418457,
-0.27213695645332336,
-0.2758306562900543,
-0.988858163356781,
-0.9747920632362366,
-0.6966649889945984,
-0.11273122578859329,
-0.3078022003173828,
-0.3378741145133972,
-0.18787473440170288,
-0.3663268983364105,
-0.12044212222099304,
0.14240136742591858,
-0.7317107319831848,
0.24489270150661469,
0.3709713816642761,
0.8056252598762512,
-0.009329510852694511,
0.21667757630348206,
-0.4390144944190979,
0.06974131613969803,
-0.1609347015619278,
0.7139374017715454,
-0.808889627456665,
-0.1498243659734726,
0.04556233808398247,
0.11996643245220184,
0.20782707631587982,
-0.8545509576797485,
0.5632786750793457,
-0.1303481012582779,
0.2837181091308594,
-0.08170788735151291,
-0.3200302720069885,
-0.2966998517513275,
0.19574451446533203,
-0.9699490666389465,
1.0264148712158203,
0.3415720462799072,
-1.0687540769577026,
0.26977479457855225,
-0.5822439789772034,
-0.21280528604984283,
0.18341569602489471,
-0.32829564809799194,
-0.16588284075260162,
-0.11224748939275742,
0.08084394782781601,
0.3956599235534668,
-0.2531455457210541,
0.4080476462841034,
-0.3225443363189697,
-0.5270275473594666,
0.29006683826446533,
-0.27919572591781616,
0.7433008551597595,
0.3595970869064331,
-0.6445387601852417,
-0.0557711161673069,
-0.673348069190979,
-0.26973289251327515,
0.16879668831825256,
-0.04266417771577835,
-0.5899219512939453,
0.08032853156328201,
0.35314372181892395,
0.4476228654384613,
0.052684392780065536,
-0.4980005621910095,
0.02847990207374096,
-0.33144500851631165,
0.3217605948448181,
0.6342278718948364,
0.007008872460573912,
0.13880810141563416,
-0.2766668498516083,
0.6045607328414917,
0.08887152373790741,
-0.04947023466229439,
0.08404581993818283,
-0.31582754850387573,
-0.5944730639457703,
-0.4554648697376251,
0.16670948266983032,
1.1103556156158447,
-0.5216253399848938,
0.5665229558944702,
0.059314798563718796,
-0.26767733693122864,
-0.4025198221206665,
0.007415964268147945,
0.26015862822532654,
0.3129405975341797,
0.40599778294563293,
0.18960842490196228,
-0.8774957060813904,
-1.3648022413253784,
0.11361313611268997,
-0.24677704274654388,
-0.1321812868118286,
-0.011808490380644798,
0.6581819653511047,
-0.3169388473033905,
0.7891678214073181,
-0.5171042084693909,
-0.46351346373558044,
-0.04220907762646675,
0.42251235246658325,
-0.14449745416641235,
0.5294749736785889,
0.4369741678237915,
-0.9124917387962341,
-0.09685280919075012,
-0.14451085031032562,
-0.9766806364059448,
-0.3907720744609833,
0.29189807176589966,
-0.027295619249343872,
0.22125999629497528,
0.8334616422653198,
0.01348167471587658,
0.6957896947860718,
0.28648072481155396,
-0.09087105840444565,
0.07317768037319183,
-0.04141508787870407,
0.42901745438575745,
-0.7514784932136536,
-0.009476862847805023,
-0.16301798820495605,
-0.24447070062160492,
-0.46423593163490295,
-0.42146801948547363,
-0.2972329556941986,
-0.07638756930828094,
-0.3143308758735657,
0.09754862636327744,
-0.1395500749349594,
0.20112760365009308,
-0.18640148639678955,
0.5092597007751465,
-0.20405639708042145,
0.30438968539237976,
0.2586732804775238,
0.13609181344509125,
0.4884239435195923,
-0.15859681367874146,
0.7627749443054199,
0.6071137189865112,
-0.44789186120033264,
0.35254040360450745,
-0.34904032945632935,
0.27709531784057617,
-0.7927812933921814,
0.22482529282569885,
-1.2116131782531738,
-0.7009333372116089,
0.7549802660942078,
0.10254176706075668,
-0.27781426906585693,
0.08160105347633362,
-0.8144827485084534,
-0.23808975517749786,
-0.49225494265556335,
0.44396936893463135,
0.3071894645690918,
-0.0035870422143489122,
-0.15560494363307953,
0.8085944652557373,
-0.41867902874946594,
-0.5292356610298157,
-0.8407032489776611,
0.22540856897830963,
-0.6949922442436218,
-0.13809822499752045,
0.10140810161828995,
0.0860753059387207,
-0.6843241453170776,
-0.014131302013993263,
0.3723701536655426,
-0.22985753417015076,
0.11601424217224121,
0.5240971446037292,
0.04233232140541077,
0.22397741675376892,
0.566230058670044,
0.27253177762031555,
0.05030204728245735,
-0.05067259073257446,
0.12316109240055084,
0.4641495645046234,
0.4123082756996155,
-0.04189518466591835,
-0.43419957160949707,
0.9664617776870728,
0.6359398365020752,
-0.18029733002185822,
0.6800338625907898,
0.5680484771728516,
-0.8413630723953247,
0.004719912074506283,
-0.24332858622074127,
-0.04264324530959129,
-0.3342498540878296,
0.2594127058982849,
-0.08588101714849472,
-0.6546565890312195,
0.5096530914306641,
0.20069251954555511,
-0.24033983051776886,
0.2793278992176056,
0.5906846523284912,
0.28227806091308594,
0.894850492477417,
0.4959756135940552,
-0.25701090693473816,
0.42671728134155273,
-0.10134167969226837,
0.2107975333929062,
-0.2974857985973358,
-0.35800662636756897,
-0.746368944644928,
-0.6789668798446655,
-0.6804207563400269,
-0.45723265409469604,
-0.02093619294464588,
0.09267131984233856,
-0.15095442533493042,
0.26858261227607727,
-0.9133360981941223,
0.5791338086128235,
0.4408513903617859,
0.24227240681648254,
0.43947890400886536,
-0.07166528701782227,
0.27475741505622864,
-0.3344392478466034,
-0.09605926275253296,
-0.9252536296844482,
0.6117830872535706,
0.25908249616622925,
0.6248258948326111,
0.2647465169429779,
0.5203378796577454,
0.9962702393531799,
0.5916865468025208,
-0.7745016813278198,
0.444456547498703,
-0.2648285925388336,
-0.9356744885444641,
-0.3224262595176697,
-0.21792930364608765,
-0.8114439249038696,
-0.03659838065505028,
-0.045107122510671616,
-0.9642119407653809,
0.38510775566101074,
-0.051665861159563065,
-0.15255625545978546,
0.15678150951862335,
-0.5199285745620728,
0.7625526189804077,
0.18531060218811035,
0.2321150302886963,
-0.43492037057876587,
-0.8360995054244995,
0.4440447986125946,
-0.4393775165081024,
0.4469505846500397,
-0.6212267279624939,
-0.003887098515406251,
1.1129106283187866,
0.044846221804618835,
1.0028449296951294,
-0.3509579002857208,
-0.2671714723110199,
0.35821473598480225,
-0.00913912057876587,
0.07011086493730545,
0.14226113259792328,
-0.08152744174003601,
0.03410046920180321,
0.036116912961006165,
-0.24956560134887695,
-0.3094189465045929,
0.5153889656066895,
-0.5674659013748169,
-0.6076319813728333,
-0.2507496774196625,
-0.7069310545921326,
-0.012716289609670639,
-0.1277136206626892,
0.2528451383113861,
0.2394549697637558,
-0.26565298438072205,
0.13561804592609406,
0.4586254954338074,
-0.5313170552253723,
0.3717372417449951,
0.20477977395057678,
-0.3125510811805725,
-0.38172614574432373,
0.6214799284934998,
0.3207167983055115,
-0.09494106471538544,
0.2534005343914032,
0.058224644511938095,
-0.42087775468826294,
-0.2733749747276306,
-0.3679523468017578,
0.1406519114971161,
-0.835760235786438,
-0.2716495096683502,
-0.7765958905220032,
-0.05451885238289833,
-0.5990537405014038,
0.23251479864120483,
0.21526817977428436,
-0.6654726266860962,
-0.24857798218727112,
-0.3265572190284729,
0.5623233318328857,
0.7273224592208862,
-0.44017094373703003,
0.17499344050884247,
-0.6346055269241333,
0.6828373670578003,
0.1398695707321167,
-0.09993837773799896,
-0.6378164291381836,
-0.40261128544807434,
-0.3315558135509491,
0.26737019419670105,
-0.10282380878925323,
-1.0976251363754272,
0.39603719115257263,
0.23786412179470062,
0.3262368142604828,
0.30364280939102173,
0.43025416135787964,
0.3564611077308655,
-0.24911189079284668,
0.6454396843910217,
-0.3242906332015991,
-0.8714281916618347,
1.0781973600387573,
-0.27997469902038574,
0.09465082734823227,
0.6186385750770569,
0.5498387813568115,
-0.9177966713905334,
-0.7966541051864624,
-0.5376598238945007,
-0.6059935688972473,
0.9496199488639832,
0.06370676308870316,
0.2526220381259918,
-0.3658685088157654,
0.04715897887945175,
0.3110576868057251,
0.37963220477104187,
-0.24401506781578064,
-0.25404080748558044,
-0.2724950611591339,
-0.32814159989356995,
-0.17277927696704865,
-0.02573476918041706,
-0.4343920052051544,
-0.43484795093536377,
0.20023545622825623,
-0.013789485208690166,
0.07092460244894028,
0.1354924589395523,
-0.4212509095668793,
-0.1183929443359375,
0.10744752734899521,
0.4510567784309387,
0.4574447274208069,
-0.18445611000061035,
0.21134598553180695,
-0.23564040660858154,
-0.3993179500102997,
0.23383565247058868,
0.30640602111816406,
0.13679572939872742,
0.23853342235088348,
0.15177220106124878,
0.47069185972213745,
-0.2377457469701767,
-1.0351924896240234,
0.28829050064086914,
0.1416650265455246,
-0.04393418878316879,
-0.4770476520061493,
0.059441938996315,
-0.3133704662322998,
0.3660961091518402,
0.35249754786491394,
-0.17514902353286743,
0.545404851436615,
-0.6120057106018066,
0.5491501688957214,
0.2318745255470276,
-0.2694317102432251,
-0.23037564754486084,
0.5519457459449768,
0.04522671177983284,
-0.33822697401046753,
0.7379753589630127,
-0.15042512118816376,
-0.5702487826347351,
0.5485836267471313,
0.22261734306812286,
0.7506747245788574,
-0.36699485778808594,
0.7026042938232422,
0.2253234088420868,
0.33105045557022095,
0.2558748722076416,
0.05902663245797157,
-0.21409596502780914,
-0.5769846439361572,
-0.4498938322067261,
-0.5473721027374268,
-0.34051313996315,
0.5499653816223145,
-0.7791823744773865,
0.15393412113189697,
-0.43956437706947327,
0.04992186278104782,
0.33541321754455566,
-0.20877154171466827,
-0.23252761363983154,
0.36190372705459595,
0.6538253426551819,
0.5714628100395203,
-1.3382326364517212,
0.606560468673706,
0.49737051129341125,
-0.2753380537033081,
-0.08100401610136032,
0.06172225996851921,
0.26037049293518066,
-0.43644246459007263,
0.8943034410476685,
0.3599831461906433,
0.024587053805589676,
-0.23452064394950867,
-0.5411629676818848,
-0.4717787802219391,
0.26053059101104736,
0.6119047403335571,
-0.08420931547880173,
0.22081619501113892,
0.3118572533130646,
0.48917487263679504,
-0.21108554303646088,
-0.05640222504734993,
1.1151180267333984,
0.890598714351654,
-0.4943053722381592,
-0.8005854487419128,
0.13601423799991608,
-0.37926530838012695,
-0.24566811323165894,
0.41617995500564575,
-0.5027647614479065,
0.5000781416893005,
0.254070520401001,
-0.5352782011032104,
-0.05075239762663841,
0.33972659707069397,
-0.31460633873939514,
0.2450670301914215,
0.7623167634010315,
0.3538997173309326,
0.9023000001907349,
-0.16480371356010437,
0.5185584425926208,
0.18668705224990845,
0.2156938761472702,
0.901322603225708,
-0.1811060756444931,
0.28332605957984924,
0.18028278648853302,
0.05558594688773155,
0.5410693883895874,
0.7202064394950867,
0.05754290893673897,
0.5429160594940186,
0.713826060295105,
-0.41735130548477173,
-0.10458550602197647,
-0.5238696932792664,
-0.14372271299362183,
0.7631282806396484,
0.560463547706604,
-0.4534834027290344,
-0.338397741317749,
0.6415994167327881,
0.12969404458999634,
0.36490732431411743,
0.008063582703471184,
0.843337893486023,
-0.22595754265785217,
-0.5239325761795044,
0.6282594203948975,
-0.08796193450689316,
0.3128555417060852,
0.07780821621417999,
-0.2413298636674881,
-0.1670800894498825,
0.025316337123513222,
-0.34487906098365784,
-0.6526111364364624,
0.8334681391716003,
0.11858020722866058,
-0.37639495730400085,
-0.2072695791721344,
0.6910977363586426,
-0.5313351154327393,
-0.17245836555957794,
0.18243196606636047,
0.5079301595687866,
0.6810470819473267,
-0.13484419882297516,
-0.5770704746246338,
0.06851475685834885,
0.08672945201396942,
-0.11048419773578644,
0.008364921435713768,
0.5656996369361877,
-0.496441513299942,
0.4463313817977905,
0.2220468372106552,
-0.2276620715856552,
-0.05799012631177902,
0.27369070053100586,
0.8132142424583435,
-0.7774248123168945,
-0.2086702287197113,
-0.8366387486457825,
0.33522462844848633,
-0.37927907705307007,
-0.3350564241409302,
0.4866761565208435,
0.5146444439888,
0.6277360916137695,
-0.017805084586143494,
0.9460102915763855,
-0.433103084564209,
0.6479792594909668,
-0.17746299505233765,
0.3247752785682678,
-0.22566960752010345,
-0.06021135672926903,
-0.2558406889438629,
-0.820865273475647,
-0.44732144474983215,
0.6873652935028076,
-0.43946272134780884,
-0.14283506572246552,
0.5002387762069702,
0.876793384552002,
0.07221943140029907,
0.3411870300769806,
0.3265390396118164,
0.08916584402322769,
-0.02744876593351364,
0.25266537070274353,
1.2504409551620483,
-0.06134244427084923,
0.29970231652259827,
-0.3979414105415344,
-0.5777003169059753,
-0.25706976652145386,
-0.49337491393089294,
-0.8924874663352966,
-0.8056334257125854,
-0.6291247010231018,
-0.0177370123565197,
-0.04572296515107155,
0.6970108151435852,
0.5719353556632996,
-0.6979494094848633,
0.14793510735034943,
0.18270719051361084,
0.17638005316257477,
-0.013529093936085701,
-0.31510064005851746,
0.2732885479927063,
-0.1143953874707222,
-1.3304188251495361,
0.23650775849819183,
0.2582114040851593,
-0.08188078552484512,
-0.5479166507720947,
0.3920992612838745,
-0.29243290424346924,
0.18728384375572205,
0.2798426151275635,
-0.04071277379989624,
-0.3916527330875397,
-0.3680855929851532,
-0.4476495683193207,
-0.07041995227336884,
-0.13921155035495758,
0.8468797206878662,
-0.9690982699394226,
0.2305147647857666,
0.5182254910469055,
0.2841520309448242,
0.18594501912593842,
0.15092889964580536,
0.03850492835044861,
-0.96747225522995,
0.7108997702598572,
0.43185731768608093,
0.16818587481975555,
0.4877861738204956,
-0.5137597322463989,
0.5966183543205261,
0.30943596363067627,
-0.47706854343414307,
-1.007519006729126,
0.37351933121681213,
-0.5885393619537354,
-0.42739471793174744,
0.8046808838844299,
0.0800815001130104,
-0.13176611065864563,
-0.662098228931427,
-0.5894046425819397,
0.5111292600631714,
-0.2090824991464615,
0.8512529134750366,
0.7641388177871704,
-0.08589887619018555,
0.005416862666606903,
-0.6469188928604126,
0.4973265826702118,
0.1397215574979782,
-0.8778632283210754,
0.4061390459537506,
0.8784852623939514,
-0.05174984037876129,
0.4732297658920288,
0.471039742231369,
-0.16460421681404114,
-0.06749218702316284,
-0.1840985268354416,
-0.1513284295797348,
0.18588927388191223,
-0.17656582593917847,
-0.277992308139801,
0.31124356389045715,
-0.7175849080085754,
-0.38053008913993835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08761v1 | JAMDEC: Unsupervised Authorship Obfuscation using Constrained Decoding over Small Language Models | 2024-02-13T19:54:29 | 2024-02-13T19:54:29 | Jillian Fisher, Ximing Lu, Jaehun Jung, Liwei Jiang, Zaid Harchaoui, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The permanence of online content combined with the enhanced authorship
identification techniques calls for stronger computational methods to protect
the identity and privacy of online authorship when needed, e.g., blind reviews
for scientific papers, anonymous online reviews, or anonymous interactions in
the mental health forums. In this paper, we propose an unsupervised
inference-time approach to authorship obfuscation to address the unique
challenges of authorship obfuscation: lack of supervision data for diverse
authorship and domains, and the need for a sufficient level of revision beyond
simple paraphrasing to obfuscate the authorship, all the while preserving the
original content and fluency.
We introduce JAMDEC, a user-controlled, inference-time algorithm for
authorship obfuscation that can be in principle applied to any text and
authorship. Our approach builds on small language models such as GPT2-XL in
order to help avoid disclosing the original content to proprietary LLM's APIs,
while also reducing the performance gap between small and large language models
via algorithmic enhancement. The key idea behind our approach is to boost the
creative power of smaller language models through constrained decoding, while
also allowing for user-specified controls and flexibility. Experimental results
demonstrate that our approach based on GPT2-XL outperforms previous
state-of-the-art methods based on comparably small models, while performing
competitively against GPT3.5 175B, a propriety model that is two orders of
magnitudes larger. | [
-0.15349337458610535,
-0.8304681777954102,
0.8233911395072937,
0.13407674431800842,
-0.21306100487709045,
0.19796496629714966,
-0.36207279562950134,
-0.5291361212730408,
0.13366754353046417,
0.8274655342102051,
-0.5515680313110352,
-0.4859054386615753,
-0.7964823842048645,
0.33049219846725464,
-0.14402741193771362,
0.8829048871994019,
0.09410014748573303,
-0.16197538375854492,
-0.2842950224876404,
0.1547715961933136,
-0.08496645092964172,
-0.11413881182670593,
-0.32392093539237976,
-0.08232389390468597,
0.3021593987941742,
0.12088180333375931,
0.4201432168483734,
0.6979063749313354,
0.31507164239883423,
0.24624048173427582,
-0.2562818229198456,
0.26152586936950684,
-0.6360093951225281,
0.06142966449260712,
-0.3108278214931488,
-0.3390192985534668,
-0.5380699634552002,
0.026751233264803886,
0.4592018127441406,
0.9160914421081543,
-0.23165565729141235,
-0.021150711923837662,
0.33382368087768555,
0.31907105445861816,
-1.0438412427902222,
0.31444215774536133,
-0.4773613512516022,
-0.23168295621871948,
-0.3077406883239746,
-0.019472522661089897,
-0.6168031692504883,
-0.4289548993110657,
-0.3439268469810486,
-0.6118077039718628,
0.13347676396369934,
-0.005160090513527393,
0.3729235827922821,
0.24198295176029205,
-0.21702957153320312,
-0.20934134721755981,
-0.9736243486404419,
0.9295440316200256,
-0.7810698747634888,
0.029046041890978813,
0.6715453267097473,
0.006455087102949619,
-0.11147812008857727,
-0.8360469341278076,
-0.39352157711982727,
0.011700380593538284,
-0.21758586168289185,
0.24491256475448608,
-0.3368922770023346,
0.2257518470287323,
0.2928321659564972,
0.2770519554615021,
-0.5042245388031006,
0.03746866434812546,
-0.31336602568626404,
-0.10061216354370117,
0.5725875496864319,
0.08147641271352768,
0.1492161899805069,
-0.10646801441907883,
-0.1678084433078766,
0.14981140196323395,
-0.6659877300262451,
-0.14035536348819733,
0.5732516646385193,
0.06271949410438538,
0.04178530350327492,
0.6453965306282043,
-0.16916228830814362,
0.3296663165092468,
0.1901189088821411,
-0.11191123723983765,
-0.20241330564022064,
-0.199097141623497,
-0.10982971638441086,
0.0766075998544693,
0.859375536441803,
0.05978846549987793,
-0.1280231475830078,
-0.33677953481674194,
-0.049100615084171295,
-0.019719300791621208,
0.19187690317630768,
-0.810653805732727,
-0.5110273361206055,
0.0945468619465828,
-0.43667036294937134,
-0.23673276603221893,
0.5490326285362244,
-0.7836164236068726,
-0.6571804285049438,
-0.06889395415782928,
0.2107067108154297,
-0.11723431199789047,
-0.2132110595703125,
0.10760292410850525,
0.02612009271979332,
-0.1892113834619522,
0.23163020610809326,
-0.7957550883293152,
0.5059567093849182,
0.7062603831291199,
0.6878198981285095,
-0.2895214855670929,
-0.14619863033294678,
-0.519054114818573,
0.40607765316963196,
-0.11894910782575607,
0.4068976938724518,
-0.6304255723953247,
-0.24595004320144653,
-0.2983468770980835,
0.12916971743106842,
-0.03467904031276703,
-0.11536531895399094,
0.26952219009399414,
-0.5714771747589111,
0.18392671644687653,
0.07316713780164719,
-0.6324948072433472,
0.03926459327340126,
-0.4353703260421753,
-0.7147505879402161,
0.5095239281654358,
0.2579740881919861,
-0.8230094909667969,
-0.05832841992378235,
-0.6766692996025085,
-0.3520240783691406,
0.2651298940181732,
-0.058648645877838135,
-0.5118456482887268,
0.22389979660511017,
0.7017859816551208,
0.3503769338130951,
-0.32537657022476196,
0.024230824783444405,
-0.4501079320907593,
-0.2117844521999359,
0.2801350951194763,
-0.19393295049667358,
1.3099209070205688,
0.34745708107948303,
-0.24891182780265808,
-0.16304278373718262,
-0.49286791682243347,
0.2504817247390747,
0.20498694479465485,
-0.0224947277456522,
-0.6328945159912109,
-0.13731831312179565,
-0.0051261186599731445,
-0.3791203200817108,
0.17718009650707245,
-0.9000101089477539,
0.22913870215415955,
-0.6091961860656738,
0.5513269305229187,
0.5978821516036987,
0.3656144440174103,
0.5628900527954102,
-0.18624165654182434,
0.5970652103424072,
-0.5002968907356262,
0.2555456757545471,
-0.0021338346414268017,
-0.7769519686698914,
0.009460708126425743,
-0.6404012441635132,
0.6076298952102661,
0.5961801409721375,
-0.7644619941711426,
0.5189046859741211,
-0.11872322112321854,
-0.37980225682258606,
-0.7421057224273682,
0.37271133065223694,
0.670280933380127,
0.16558144986629486,
0.34061166644096375,
-0.44271120429039,
-0.4354535937309265,
-0.6402363777160645,
-0.5985082983970642,
0.08556695282459259,
-0.4644118547439575,
0.18674412369728088,
0.29877346754074097,
-0.33050161600112915,
1.0114182233810425,
-0.7924637198448181,
-0.35526442527770996,
-0.5171087384223938,
0.4318433701992035,
0.05482393503189087,
0.6497378945350647,
0.4294203817844391,
-0.7311831116676331,
-0.5513677000999451,
-0.06409353762865067,
-0.6572673916816711,
-0.6068081259727478,
-0.20355020463466644,
0.09240695089101791,
-0.0006947546498849988,
0.6513539552688599,
-0.48772192001342773,
0.767583429813385,
0.45622608065605164,
-0.3893262445926666,
0.47359704971313477,
-0.11800228804349899,
0.14739666879177094,
-0.7542180418968201,
0.13812512159347534,
-0.4484986960887909,
-0.3636663556098938,
-0.4882010519504547,
0.19343701004981995,
0.08908393979072571,
-0.005088132340461016,
-0.15935412049293518,
0.43526408076286316,
-0.827297031879425,
0.3359857499599457,
-0.36721721291542053,
-0.01010701060295105,
0.030206669121980667,
0.4948236346244812,
-0.07467548549175262,
0.3507421910762787,
0.42791932821273804,
-0.20772378146648407,
0.0723264142870903,
0.37678903341293335,
-0.6857936382293701,
0.3649986684322357,
-0.5048766732215881,
0.46773454546928406,
-0.08685341477394104,
0.21563127636909485,
-0.7316446304321289,
-0.3958878815174103,
0.2119688242673874,
-0.43822675943374634,
0.3857324719429016,
-0.4174027442932129,
-0.5573621392250061,
-0.14570511877536774,
-0.2555600702762604,
0.4963957667350769,
0.6571120619773865,
-0.45903730392456055,
0.558539628982544,
0.5007182359695435,
-0.5630471706390381,
-0.3850281536579132,
-0.6685205101966858,
0.13622093200683594,
0.1477988362312317,
-0.28950929641723633,
0.6723714470863342,
-0.2909669876098633,
-0.364687442779541,
0.2880425751209259,
-0.060120150446891785,
-0.27382728457450867,
0.0574316643178463,
0.46937766671180725,
0.17588280141353607,
0.136084645986557,
-0.46530070900917053,
0.6201766133308411,
-0.11769978702068329,
-0.055984120815992355,
-0.3887532949447632,
-0.029822738841176033,
0.16122692823410034,
-0.4134824275970459,
-0.42382439970970154,
0.7094346880912781,
0.3098919093608856,
-0.11884749680757523,
0.7994283437728882,
0.4894121587276459,
-0.3733980655670166,
-0.4906480014324188,
-0.5121815204620361,
-0.4867372214794159,
-0.4643675684928894,
0.08516018837690353,
-0.022630790248513222,
-1.1244899034500122,
0.4235195517539978,
-0.01508247572928667,
-0.04586317017674446,
0.3066267967224121,
0.5868130326271057,
-0.007068040780723095,
0.9184311628341675,
0.7966017127037048,
0.05520312860608101,
0.333846777677536,
-0.15158213675022125,
0.10725735127925873,
-0.7864001989364624,
-0.006188532337546349,
-0.26080355048179626,
-0.02376936934888363,
-0.4644520580768585,
-0.4317265450954437,
0.3848235011100769,
0.17549405992031097,
0.062346894294023514,
0.36584314703941345,
-0.6014732122421265,
0.889014482498169,
0.5705357789993286,
0.2971916198730469,
0.448879599571228,
-0.0100229037925601,
-0.1837836056947708,
-0.10886251926422119,
-0.5911325812339783,
-0.31203970313072205,
1.2264912128448486,
0.05792511999607086,
0.9843867421150208,
0.30070364475250244,
0.6272423267364502,
0.5984440445899963,
0.19244706630706787,
-0.2931092083454132,
0.3658490777015686,
0.04378019645810127,
-0.6915250420570374,
-0.3444036543369293,
-0.6332382559776306,
-0.7657800316810608,
0.18690380454063416,
-0.11027051508426666,
-1.0496078729629517,
0.3351939916610718,
0.07302992790937424,
-0.33669331669807434,
0.6290509104728699,
-0.5515404939651489,
0.6587650179862976,
0.19443923234939575,
-0.6766471862792969,
0.09771493822336197,
-0.9011267423629761,
0.5012920498847961,
-0.2931157648563385,
0.18175821006298065,
0.22832058370113373,
0.02220265567302704,
0.6993739008903503,
-0.6017881035804749,
1.0096560716629028,
-0.14962191879749298,
0.09889958798885345,
0.33889538049697876,
0.29316145181655884,
0.8320503234863281,
0.20796331763267517,
0.15912367403507233,
0.2831926941871643,
0.08175361156463623,
-0.40286460518836975,
-0.452119916677475,
0.8243793249130249,
-0.541623055934906,
-0.5362772345542908,
-0.2538388967514038,
-0.44426169991493225,
-0.23918619751930237,
0.43384867906570435,
0.5392258167266846,
0.20340244472026825,
-0.10332559049129486,
0.37000253796577454,
0.4675135612487793,
0.04502769187092781,
0.3226224482059479,
0.42919325828552246,
0.16374728083610535,
-0.5937695503234863,
0.6844940781593323,
-0.13475482165813446,
0.24510832130908966,
0.3878389596939087,
0.23436829447746277,
-0.27819696068763733,
-0.7104995846748352,
-0.1764531284570694,
0.46016502380371094,
-0.5549513697624207,
-0.09071014821529388,
-0.7992494106292725,
-0.022952012717723846,
-0.7264270782470703,
-0.24108804762363434,
-0.3954111933708191,
-0.6547593474388123,
-0.33085158467292786,
0.13132427632808685,
0.1294613778591156,
0.8766747713088989,
-0.2418488711118698,
0.441739022731781,
-0.47200635075569153,
0.44322335720062256,
0.2884959578514099,
0.46797263622283936,
-0.11339293420314789,
-0.45209652185440063,
-0.2137235850095749,
-0.07452809065580368,
-0.30331578850746155,
-1.009017825126648,
0.3137262761592865,
-0.05401040241122246,
0.5179277062416077,
0.6319141983985901,
0.5501379370689392,
0.3634670078754425,
-0.3601866066455841,
0.6014941930770874,
0.03552546352148056,
-1.0106258392333984,
0.332692414522171,
-0.3145357370376587,
0.24494482576847076,
0.5650514364242554,
0.07217556983232498,
-0.14785762131214142,
-0.7813694477081299,
-0.515653133392334,
-0.896312415599823,
0.9475159049034119,
0.767855167388916,
-0.3829253315925598,
0.26915374398231506,
0.2988087832927704,
0.2768353521823883,
0.24663572013378143,
-0.7988598346710205,
-0.031707532703876495,
-0.15733923017978668,
-0.0842912495136261,
-0.005715425591915846,
-0.4937690496444702,
-0.29444220662117004,
-0.1461203694343567,
0.5824176669120789,
-0.08780405670404434,
0.4777592420578003,
0.26833730936050415,
-0.191886305809021,
-0.07542014122009277,
0.35000044107437134,
0.35456228256225586,
0.583733320236206,
-0.32577061653137207,
0.13942328095436096,
-0.06267485022544861,
-0.7552739381790161,
-0.1178341805934906,
0.2511853873729706,
-0.29283607006073,
-0.3248097598552704,
0.6581861972808838,
0.4934430420398712,
-0.08637450635433197,
-0.4114615321159363,
0.5542985796928406,
0.06402957439422607,
-0.2194213569164276,
-0.10793787240982056,
0.15650545060634613,
-0.049514491111040115,
0.31790390610694885,
0.2954850196838379,
0.014245468191802502,
0.19822929799556732,
-0.09056226909160614,
-0.05548360198736191,
0.3170402944087982,
-0.35752084851264954,
-0.4518035352230072,
1.003888726234436,
-0.017257649451494217,
0.07151187211275101,
0.2662428319454193,
-0.3608960509300232,
-0.21305996179580688,
0.5952282547950745,
0.5969160199165344,
1.187256932258606,
-0.3651668131351471,
-0.024101974442601204,
0.15672825276851654,
0.6439610719680786,
-0.11766612529754639,
0.15540310740470886,
-0.26260095834732056,
-0.21818719804286957,
-0.446934312582016,
-0.49246537685394287,
-0.5260739922523499,
0.14186209440231323,
-0.6685925722122192,
-0.1802472323179245,
-0.5992783904075623,
-0.05007275193929672,
0.0025280395057052374,
-0.11148469150066376,
-0.2407536804676056,
-0.21072295308113098,
0.028193000704050064,
0.38075578212738037,
-0.6856937408447266,
0.87319016456604,
0.3904728889465332,
0.015453038737177849,
-0.43356648087501526,
0.07116707414388657,
0.4696291387081146,
-0.14944890141487122,
0.004232552368193865,
-0.09865120053291321,
-0.4032050669193268,
0.1966826319694519,
-0.8108530044555664,
-0.44664376974105835,
1.1074728965759277,
0.4958200752735138,
-0.5012589693069458,
0.1514424830675125,
-0.03771238401532173,
0.3835412561893463,
-0.4447338283061981,
0.061865538358688354,
0.30797281861305237,
0.5353680849075317,
-0.1157941222190857,
-0.6887662410736084,
0.21571485698223114,
-0.1788027286529541,
-0.0021767558064311743,
0.016794024035334587,
-0.21710450947284698,
0.890008807182312,
-0.3963572680950165,
-0.5263410210609436,
0.4076830744743347,
0.5088622570037842,
-0.03958399221301079,
0.29741549491882324,
0.34305888414382935,
0.27321451902389526,
0.6619305610656738,
0.10623285174369812,
1.0720974206924438,
-0.05415922775864601,
0.6231971383094788,
1.2199991941452026,
-0.2736491560935974,
0.3119485378265381,
0.3982122540473938,
-0.2730770707130432,
0.36053743958473206,
0.09780628234148026,
-0.08378924429416656,
0.7331740260124207,
-0.08631306886672974,
-0.12557557225227356,
-0.3714572489261627,
0.024920573458075523,
-0.14340417087078094,
0.1888127326965332,
0.25234830379486084,
-0.36155152320861816,
0.017854822799563408,
0.19504234194755554,
0.299911767244339,
0.39340856671333313,
-0.22373706102371216,
0.6238279342651367,
0.14014855027198792,
-0.4727088212966919,
0.40155819058418274,
0.39273136854171753,
0.2992083430290222,
-0.6331052780151367,
0.055784668773412704,
-0.13300347328186035,
0.4203267991542816,
-0.1589154452085495,
-0.6545073986053467,
0.2546069920063019,
0.13937199115753174,
-0.20704622566699982,
-0.34724441170692444,
0.7724766135215759,
-0.4925180673599243,
-0.5500685572624207,
0.35277876257896423,
0.4087384045124054,
0.0033341762609779835,
-0.28552478551864624,
-0.34318652749061584,
-0.08568131178617477,
0.06035264953970909,
-0.2544347047805786,
0.19615252315998077,
0.2800692915916443,
-0.16853287816047668,
0.43288618326187134,
0.7049326300621033,
0.2912900447845459,
-0.2771977186203003,
-0.14853787422180176,
0.8327245712280273,
-0.4511139988899231,
-0.8257353901863098,
-0.8251528739929199,
0.16566607356071472,
-0.07415691763162613,
-0.011473632417619228,
0.927506685256958,
0.49539655447006226,
0.6874982118606567,
-0.38480374217033386,
0.9037797451019287,
-0.30898386240005493,
0.7355892658233643,
-0.596415102481842,
1.22963547706604,
-0.5648882985115051,
0.43976908922195435,
-0.6025794744491577,
-0.6207009553909302,
-0.5638353228569031,
0.24958783388137817,
-0.3203887939453125,
0.0565464161336422,
0.7989692687988281,
0.8764180541038513,
-0.329100638628006,
0.1352206915616989,
0.33442214131355286,
0.46355438232421875,
0.2030545026063919,
0.6963936686515808,
0.5566596388816833,
-0.09392624348402023,
0.6205998659133911,
-0.5297980904579163,
-0.5029932856559753,
-0.28574442863464355,
-0.908619225025177,
-1.2707641124725342,
-0.47259828448295593,
-0.42342302203178406,
-0.27996376156806946,
0.10459008812904358,
0.6869053244590759,
0.5576764345169067,
-0.9742485880851746,
0.03202919661998749,
-0.17995476722717285,
0.2573449909687042,
-0.7743712663650513,
-0.16922062635421753,
0.5280377864837646,
0.35944557189941406,
-0.7699732184410095,
0.5565869212150574,
0.2698206901550293,
-0.0880637839436531,
-0.2076437920331955,
0.006906899157911539,
-0.06728705763816833,
0.29937943816185,
0.3464207053184509,
0.42613184452056885,
-0.7940928936004639,
0.07465901970863342,
-0.14568114280700684,
-0.09792748838663101,
-0.21744805574417114,
0.9960699081420898,
-0.6280834674835205,
0.760076642036438,
0.3894363045692444,
0.46675458550453186,
0.6480633616447449,
0.3138186037540436,
0.20522300899028778,
-0.8104296326637268,
0.07584721595048904,
0.4854848086833954,
0.2229236513376236,
0.10898871719837189,
-0.49648502469062805,
0.381161093711853,
0.547792911529541,
-0.539074718952179,
-0.8758096694946289,
0.2517932057380676,
-1.1388124227523804,
-0.6389595866203308,
1.0671629905700684,
-0.4120182394981384,
-0.33813756704330444,
-0.3511824607849121,
-0.09181076288223267,
0.048783279955387115,
-0.3874339461326599,
0.8494943976402283,
0.42565205693244934,
-0.06581196188926697,
-0.21907639503479004,
-0.4313484728336334,
0.529650092124939,
0.14072227478027344,
-0.6754846572875977,
0.41588276624679565,
0.4504304826259613,
0.10008475929498672,
-0.04308142140507698,
0.5749232769012451,
-0.28038454055786133,
0.22118651866912842,
0.07988616824150085,
0.019181521609425545,
-0.6197584867477417,
-0.5293956995010376,
-0.23820434510707855,
0.4434647560119629,
-0.3351527750492096,
0.014092564582824707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08756v1 | Learning How To Ask: Cycle-Consistency Refines Prompts in Multimodal Foundation Models | 2024-02-13T19:49:17 | 2024-02-13T19:49:17 | Maurice Diesendruck, Jianzhe Lin, Shima Imani, Gayathri Mahalingam, Mingyang Xu, Jie Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | When LLMs perform zero-shot inference, they typically use a prompt with a
task specification, and generate a completion. However, there is no work to
explore the possibility of the reverse - going from completion to task
specification. In this paper, we employ both directions to perform
cycle-supervised learning entirely in-context. Our goal is to create a forward
map f : X -> Y (e.g. image -> generated caption), coupled with a backward map g
: Y -> X (e.g. caption -> generated image) to construct a cycle-consistency
"loss" (formulated as an update to the prompt) to enforce g(f(X)) ~= X. The
technique, called CyclePrompt, uses cycle-consistency as a free supervisory
signal to iteratively craft the prompt. Importantly, CyclePrompt reinforces
model performance without expensive fine-tuning, without training data, and
without the complexity of external environments (e.g. compilers, APIs). We
demonstrate CyclePrompt in two domains: code generation and image captioning.
Our results on the HumanEval coding benchmark put us in first place on the
leaderboard among models that do not rely on extra training data or usage of
external environments, and third overall. Compared to the GPT4 baseline, we
improve accuracy from 80.5% to 87.2%. In the vision-language space, we generate
detailed image captions which outperform baseline zero-shot GPT4V captions,
when tested against natural (VQAv2) and diagrammatic (FigureQA) visual
question-answering benchmarks. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first
use of self-supervised learning for prompting. | [
-0.39198654890060425,
-0.6489993333816528,
0.7764550447463989,
0.24929045140743256,
-0.3103010058403015,
-0.13450342416763306,
-0.1440800279378891,
-0.25283536314964294,
-0.1164449080824852,
0.6295254826545715,
-1.1067349910736084,
-0.7390637397766113,
-0.4611693024635315,
0.2978481352329254,
-0.4256078004837036,
0.9374347925186157,
-0.3521448075771332,
0.08041340112686157,
-0.6569070219993591,
-0.18751077353954315,
-0.8149217367172241,
-0.2073439359664917,
-0.4752625823020935,
-0.2102048397064209,
0.6165480017662048,
0.5646788477897644,
0.19608058035373688,
0.5043326020240784,
0.07136205583810806,
0.2803665101528168,
0.4522462785243988,
0.46190446615219116,
-0.49177148938179016,
0.5906702876091003,
-0.04020577296614647,
-0.22246307134628296,
-0.05646052584052086,
0.45412328839302063,
0.23545125126838684,
0.6121823191642761,
-0.08649928867816925,
0.03265940770506859,
0.15389317274093628,
0.5028198957443237,
-0.7673848271369934,
0.5244426727294922,
-0.45261645317077637,
0.12557293474674225,
0.17578166723251343,
-0.6789373159408569,
-0.6445863246917725,
-0.26449429988861084,
-0.1693238914012909,
-0.8857321739196777,
0.28272545337677,
0.13041208684444427,
0.8710277080535889,
0.43800482153892517,
-0.5434120893478394,
-0.3903338611125946,
-0.39443182945251465,
0.5326338410377502,
-0.2687705457210541,
0.33574748039245605,
0.42506974935531616,
0.3506910502910614,
0.026946360245347023,
-0.7441756725311279,
-0.534516453742981,
-0.17808040976524353,
-0.018246646970510483,
0.46802204847335815,
-0.11462821811437607,
-0.025175699964165688,
0.2660660445690155,
0.1050107404589653,
-0.47354069352149963,
-0.25735267996788025,
-0.4168373942375183,
-0.38482335209846497,
0.38694867491722107,
0.14847742021083832,
-0.06987246870994568,
-0.10040812194347382,
-0.44723138213157654,
-0.1870335191488266,
-0.8916473388671875,
0.19674961268901825,
0.13369962573051453,
0.2575124502182007,
-0.03821377828717232,
0.6236017346382141,
-0.45799288153648376,
0.8275631070137024,
0.41810154914855957,
0.2394024133682251,
0.1808585524559021,
-0.47105464339256287,
-0.24904765188694,
-0.2698405385017395,
0.6144505143165588,
0.6080012321472168,
0.3353988528251648,
-0.38173630833625793,
-0.061693716794252396,
-0.08636045455932617,
0.40708568692207336,
-0.809615433216095,
-0.2641562521457672,
0.10454357415437698,
0.006110513117164373,
-0.32081711292266846,
0.09463212639093399,
-0.6662885546684265,
-0.19895605742931366,
-0.6691917777061462,
0.588682234287262,
-0.31435641646385193,
0.21753033995628357,
-0.1324348896741867,
0.10348175466060638,
0.40590861439704895,
0.554395854473114,
-0.3923155665397644,
-0.12542928755283356,
0.3565310835838318,
0.849049985408783,
-0.19746069610118866,
-0.3579375147819519,
-0.9972648024559021,
0.05098264291882515,
-0.6885629296302795,
0.7393628358840942,
-0.15006276965141296,
-0.36345213651657104,
0.01817019283771515,
0.2559279203414917,
-0.15573342144489288,
-0.6011955738067627,
0.023352723568677902,
-0.45269492268562317,
0.4734000265598297,
-0.41929158568382263,
-0.5687679052352905,
-0.13324597477912903,
0.5025726556777954,
-0.23964646458625793,
0.8529089689254761,
0.09445185214281082,
-0.5772470831871033,
0.45979049801826477,
-0.43147531151771545,
-0.2713603973388672,
-0.229050412774086,
-0.34011581540107727,
-0.35250425338745117,
-0.22816847264766693,
0.3736201822757721,
0.5895269513130188,
0.08126042038202286,
0.30665841698646545,
-0.22921501100063324,
-0.2888176143169403,
0.07922667264938354,
-0.43745332956314087,
0.6256704926490784,
0.07022081315517426,
-0.4569859206676483,
0.3834852874279022,
-0.7202441692352295,
0.132765993475914,
0.07650105655193329,
-0.011137384921312332,
0.12313000112771988,
-0.3308854401111603,
-0.35301244258880615,
0.31053662300109863,
0.014956574887037277,
-0.49146461486816406,
0.38088464736938477,
-0.05667423456907272,
0.5416426062583923,
0.8585669994354248,
0.3282307982444763,
0.3678593337535858,
-0.34260094165802,
0.7095085978507996,
0.1531306952238083,
0.22642141580581665,
-0.7142364382743835,
-0.6768076419830322,
-0.6918517351150513,
-0.20704343914985657,
-0.13544297218322754,
0.7038881182670593,
-1.034936785697937,
0.024311548098921776,
0.11616061627864838,
-0.17280562222003937,
-0.3225642144680023,
0.31630367040634155,
0.6171509027481079,
1.0989271402359009,
0.5101415514945984,
-0.28473830223083496,
-0.3931281566619873,
-0.7070369720458984,
0.3311023414134979,
-0.07900570333003998,
0.18913592398166656,
0.39572611451148987,
0.38465428352355957,
-0.1574450433254242,
1.0295318365097046,
-0.49245861172676086,
-0.06348683685064316,
0.06235427409410477,
0.40329310297966003,
0.054830268025398254,
0.5495582222938538,
0.3032464385032654,
-0.6245267391204834,
-0.40877440571784973,
-0.4638248682022095,
-0.9812291264533997,
-0.27535349130630493,
-0.07360959053039551,
-0.34069427847862244,
0.35175102949142456,
0.6068958044052124,
-0.6765821576118469,
0.5496073365211487,
0.5223690271377563,
-0.3466334640979767,
0.666311502456665,
-0.2584509551525116,
0.38738778233528137,
-0.9641555547714233,
-0.04948771372437477,
-0.26586517691612244,
-0.48529645800590515,
-0.41523727774620056,
0.20530915260314941,
0.19515761733055115,
-0.20658418536186218,
-0.4487921893596649,
0.5378108024597168,
-0.3895854651927948,
-0.09786217659711838,
-0.17541146278381348,
0.09721488505601883,
0.33386319875717163,
0.5952171683311462,
-0.0672183632850647,
1.1644905805587769,
0.7975252866744995,
-0.666479229927063,
0.3867432177066803,
0.3881043493747711,
-0.1355377435684204,
0.8014498949050903,
-0.5463466048240662,
0.31580331921577454,
-0.25927188992500305,
0.3828422427177429,
-1.3490660190582275,
-0.34638524055480957,
0.5092191696166992,
-0.49731194972991943,
0.5173817276954651,
-0.019346149638295174,
-0.30056098103523254,
-0.378549724817276,
-0.25144222378730774,
0.3235625922679901,
0.5428436398506165,
-0.6548791527748108,
0.3978134095668793,
-0.3152259886264801,
0.029349040240049362,
-0.6873798966407776,
-0.7441827654838562,
-0.042902108281850815,
0.04186302423477173,
-0.64466792345047,
0.23076161742210388,
-0.3623124659061432,
0.10142803937196732,
-0.11684831231832504,
-0.20217150449752808,
-0.15605464577674866,
-0.07963262498378754,
0.6094187498092651,
0.3298959732055664,
-0.09705910831689835,
0.17770032584667206,
-0.0969645157456398,
-0.2131345272064209,
-0.11068014055490494,
-0.3344995379447937,
0.4906122088432312,
-0.19369514286518097,
-0.5243685841560364,
-0.6889885663986206,
0.37126243114471436,
0.3666369616985321,
-0.1666903793811798,
0.3325832784175873,
0.38906019926071167,
-0.06533648818731308,
-0.22110110521316528,
-0.49582600593566895,
-0.3605751693248749,
-0.4700578451156616,
-0.16304443776607513,
-0.20697170495986938,
-0.8393771052360535,
0.4621170163154602,
0.10019823163747787,
0.03297259286046028,
0.14146177470684052,
0.431857705116272,
-0.5509513020515442,
0.8579650521278381,
0.6108139157295227,
0.36314061284065247,
0.2530032992362976,
-0.4881708025932312,
-0.06312233209609985,
-0.6338648200035095,
-0.3975047767162323,
-0.08633752912282944,
-0.05437271669507027,
-0.17030569911003113,
-0.5501332879066467,
0.5176602602005005,
0.328814834356308,
-0.4465138614177704,
0.28691956400871277,
-0.4700008034706116,
0.22552506625652313,
0.693836510181427,
0.20351997017860413,
0.3094756603240967,
-0.065097875893116,
-0.26338985562324524,
0.06821850687265396,
-0.7181836366653442,
-0.2991870641708374,
0.9231501221656799,
-0.18031293153762817,
0.49104365706443787,
-0.42482253909111023,
1.0313917398452759,
0.16712574660778046,
0.43200692534446716,
-0.5530624985694885,
0.5140804052352905,
0.2404220551252365,
-0.5626415014266968,
-0.1557472050189972,
-0.24371914565563202,
-0.8955754041671753,
0.0031941276974976063,
0.013292554765939713,
-0.41142013669013977,
0.21842101216316223,
0.5962901711463928,
-0.44588610529899597,
-0.0994817316532135,
-0.5360730886459351,
1.0543960332870483,
-0.03264773637056351,
-0.5889996886253357,
0.03314952552318573,
-0.6717708706855774,
0.38440456986427307,
0.23917856812477112,
0.28090065717697144,
-0.05107351765036583,
0.015128349885344505,
0.15283261239528656,
-0.325632780790329,
1.1488929986953735,
-0.37502598762512207,
-0.005931740161031485,
0.541113555431366,
0.15191125869750977,
0.48857012391090393,
0.04478589817881584,
0.35529598593711853,
-0.10411269217729568,
-0.04788212478160858,
-0.4507005214691162,
-0.7251999378204346,
0.42197996377944946,
-0.5120883584022522,
-0.6114023327827454,
-0.1833009272813797,
-0.6824049353599548,
-0.32080861926078796,
0.0005255123833194375,
0.5334471464157104,
0.6347487568855286,
0.2642057240009308,
0.081241175532341,
0.699507474899292,
-0.29159191250801086,
0.43565070629119873,
0.5057322382926941,
-0.31518828868865967,
-0.36364713311195374,
0.7914189696311951,
-0.03812063857913017,
0.3263047933578491,
0.1746070235967636,
0.043884970247745514,
-0.38503125309944153,
-0.325682669878006,
-0.6952528953552246,
0.034537412226200104,
-1.0253782272338867,
-0.5043299198150635,
-0.45221611857414246,
-0.15734227001667023,
-0.4320223331451416,
-0.3706291913986206,
-0.34246373176574707,
-0.2542424499988556,
-0.3584136664867401,
-0.2758006751537323,
0.3244488537311554,
0.5360684394836426,
-0.07425335049629211,
0.19653435051441193,
-0.5792226791381836,
0.21195213496685028,
0.5205135941505432,
-0.02395380660891533,
-0.14240196347236633,
-0.4430404603481293,
0.2188890427350998,
-0.06241435930132866,
-0.6695981621742249,
-1.0879279375076294,
0.21256449818611145,
0.2390507310628891,
0.4792432487010956,
0.3944680690765381,
0.19094564020633698,
0.8194749355316162,
-0.5865039229393005,
0.8852194547653198,
0.1947869211435318,
-0.9277255535125732,
0.701019823551178,
-0.3704637289047241,
0.18324591219425201,
0.5758615136146545,
0.34333503246307373,
-0.43441054224967957,
-0.5930324196815491,
-0.5822510719299316,
-0.8301378488540649,
0.4674718677997589,
0.20192548632621765,
0.278891921043396,
-0.3258594870567322,
0.6500478982925415,
0.22744764387607574,
0.4837496280670166,
-0.745459794998169,
-0.14682845771312714,
-0.620220959186554,
-0.24226783215999603,
0.038330309092998505,
0.051469750702381134,
-0.33497902750968933,
-0.2570367157459259,
0.604404866695404,
-0.5123973488807678,
0.3817104697227478,
0.5175952911376953,
-0.10566025227308273,
-0.10350144654512405,
0.23689758777618408,
0.7467261552810669,
0.8924426436424255,
0.07513145357370377,
0.18361732363700867,
0.05262487754225731,
0.13457603752613068,
0.25759968161582947,
-0.044345688074827194,
-0.5201659798622131,
-0.13522596657276154,
0.6997523903846741,
0.7551820278167725,
0.4143611490726471,
-0.782899796962738,
0.7902713418006897,
0.3200399577617645,
-0.49526968598365784,
-0.24203333258628845,
0.11918824911117554,
0.109818235039711,
0.38394850492477417,
0.22919796407222748,
0.015778519213199615,
0.07527729123830795,
-0.707247793674469,
0.517930269241333,
0.3632885217666626,
-0.5845958590507507,
-0.15442480146884918,
0.7560197114944458,
-0.06647312641143799,
0.09694259613752365,
0.8146617412567139,
-0.5353741645812988,
-0.35280314087867737,
0.7002267241477966,
0.39889970421791077,
0.6406148076057434,
0.06807645410299301,
0.6109787821769714,
0.45818567276000977,
-0.047254689037799835,
-0.077301025390625,
0.5591208338737488,
-0.39211970567703247,
-0.6683233976364136,
-0.5413561463356018,
-0.3277240991592407,
-0.417705237865448,
-0.36248350143432617,
-0.8240114450454712,
0.07425935566425323,
-0.5273350477218628,
-0.00844426266849041,
-0.19547098875045776,
-0.2653447389602661,
-0.5545702576637268,
0.22910280525684357,
0.0765719935297966,
0.7956194281578064,
-0.6430255770683289,
0.7457209825515747,
0.5047888159751892,
-0.8025179505348206,
-0.847291111946106,
-0.11883522570133209,
0.11761622130870819,
-1.153916597366333,
0.6800033450126648,
0.5518546104431152,
-0.03566018119454384,
0.09147598594427109,
-1.0671061277389526,
-0.6246219277381897,
1.528751254081726,
0.4334551990032196,
-0.6220124959945679,
-0.06284824013710022,
-0.3472179174423218,
0.264627069234848,
-0.6750834584236145,
0.025071799755096436,
0.06338255852460861,
0.5417114496231079,
0.6395295858383179,
-0.5606345534324646,
0.12625367939472198,
0.03820519894361496,
-0.19932731986045837,
-0.13179071247577667,
-0.47938272356987,
0.8598377108573914,
-0.5471973419189453,
-0.310030996799469,
0.36829549074172974,
0.5677873492240906,
0.501957893371582,
0.7548586130142212,
0.41732627153396606,
0.40560364723205566,
0.7659277319908142,
-0.24812212586402893,
1.2221382856369019,
-0.4679979681968689,
0.3563930094242096,
1.3095859289169312,
-0.20331630110740662,
0.7165104150772095,
0.5803207755088806,
0.1845768541097641,
0.6149386167526245,
0.7360794544219971,
-0.15022584795951843,
0.8083630800247192,
-0.06760010123252869,
0.051710937172174454,
-0.6302207708358765,
0.01961800456047058,
-0.11690954864025116,
0.23153215646743774,
-0.16147880256175995,
-0.23908917605876923,
-0.40744203329086304,
0.3324072062969208,
-0.12655209004878998,
0.3001984655857086,
-0.23460915684700012,
0.6661297082901001,
0.03978352248668671,
-0.8455726504325867,
0.5775420069694519,
-0.28721216320991516,
0.40191635489463806,
-0.4743805229663849,
-0.1200026422739029,
-0.29284384846687317,
-0.09355022013187408,
0.016410157084465027,
-0.8102231025695801,
0.4418247640132904,
-0.11548811197280884,
-0.3737803101539612,
-0.4927248954772949,
0.24497239291667938,
-0.6130768060684204,
-0.31584569811820984,
0.26470035314559937,
0.547416090965271,
0.20185185968875885,
-0.20387114584445953,
-0.6451640725135803,
-0.14644336700439453,
-0.12174569815397263,
-0.20056529343128204,
0.06074493005871773,
0.2990322411060333,
-0.07135134935379028,
0.6831950545310974,
0.40029698610305786,
-0.27565211057662964,
0.2685335874557495,
0.14653128385543823,
0.8281304836273193,
-0.43824338912963867,
-0.19474300742149353,
-0.5325943231582642,
0.6313916444778442,
0.02943507768213749,
-0.38372722268104553,
0.5933092832565308,
0.4083901345729828,
0.9246504306793213,
-0.16527853906154633,
0.5226413607597351,
-0.044881418347358704,
0.24843142926692963,
-0.8571601510047913,
0.24678419530391693,
-0.6990415453910828,
-0.058459192514419556,
0.04049649462103844,
-0.6888395547866821,
-0.14758265018463135,
0.6282054781913757,
-0.30941691994667053,
0.04947067052125931,
0.7640537619590759,
0.9431460499763489,
0.0513894259929657,
-0.01905420795083046,
0.3327625095844269,
0.09352479875087738,
0.24282307922840118,
0.6065352559089661,
1.0386830568313599,
-0.2886159121990204,
0.6240958571434021,
-0.4607275128364563,
-0.11609375476837158,
0.11393401026725769,
-1.0608731508255005,
-0.8162816166877747,
-0.6564763784408569,
-0.45354777574539185,
-0.3537905514240265,
0.33424046635627747,
0.8631241321563721,
1.0467512607574463,
-0.9203245043754578,
0.07357285916805267,
-0.3342773914337158,
-0.11105477064847946,
-0.39128708839416504,
-0.21827749907970428,
0.11184504628181458,
-0.8444851636886597,
-0.4983602464199066,
0.42885318398475647,
0.3339669704437256,
0.02255280129611492,
-0.24076204001903534,
-0.28637805581092834,
0.02563571371138096,
-0.03794622793793678,
0.503826379776001,
0.1853751689195633,
-0.8383131623268127,
-0.374685138463974,
0.1957918256521225,
-0.043836578726768494,
0.22605451941490173,
0.9141120910644531,
-0.7213830947875977,
0.6085077524185181,
0.21664218604564667,
0.5138078331947327,
0.7180641889572144,
0.2104879766702652,
0.5609703660011292,
-0.9364717602729797,
-0.012720201164484024,
0.10115478932857513,
0.31657829880714417,
0.5518242716789246,
-0.4021088182926178,
0.5079697966575623,
0.519652783870697,
-0.49793633818626404,
-0.4618698060512543,
0.37725841999053955,
-1.1471152305603027,
-0.4213402271270752,
0.9729995131492615,
-0.437775582075119,
-0.08444636315107346,
-0.002208864549174905,
-0.2715096175670624,
0.2618947923183441,
-0.22512215375900269,
0.7142584919929504,
0.7420382499694824,
-0.3413549065589905,
-0.5481278896331787,
-0.7308979630470276,
0.30515211820602417,
0.22026686370372772,
-0.5792811512947083,
0.061230774968862534,
0.7948166131973267,
0.5027584433555603,
0.1119362935423851,
0.7571309208869934,
-0.01500750333070755,
0.42122218012809753,
-0.28490278124809265,
-0.04112853854894638,
-0.6138797402381897,
-0.6816841959953308,
-0.21796837449073792,
0.3327594995498657,
-0.2628640830516815,
-0.2683638334274292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08680v1 | Mitigating Object Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models via Classifier-Free Guidance | 2024-02-13T18:59:05 | 2024-02-13T18:59:05 | Linxi Zhao, Yihe Deng, Weitong Zhang, Quanquan Gu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The advancement of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has increasingly
highlighted the critical issue of their tendency to hallucinate non-existing
objects in the images. To address this issue, previous works focused on using
specially curated datasets or powerful LLMs (e.g., GPT-3.5) to rectify the
outputs of LVLMs. However, these approaches require either expensive
training/fine-tuning or API access to advanced LLMs to correct the model's
output post-generation. In this paper, we tackle this challenge by introducing
a framework called Mitigating hallucinAtion via classifieR-Free guIdaNcE
(MARINE), which is both training-free and API-free, and can effectively and
efficiently reduce object hallucinations during the generation process.
Specifically, MARINE enriches the visual context of LVLMs by integrating
existing open-source vision models, and employs classifier-free guidance to
incorporate the additional object grounding features to improve the precision
of LVLMs' generations. Through comprehensive evaluations across $6$ popular
LVLMs with diverse evaluation metrics, we demonstrate the effectiveness of
MARINE, which even outperforms existing fine-tuning-based methods. Remarkably,
it not only reduces hallucinations but also improves the detailedness of LVLMs'
generations, as assessed by GPT-4V. | [
-0.6097978353500366,
-0.4905608296394348,
0.6329912543296814,
-0.026277972385287285,
-0.7180665731430054,
-0.23629134893417358,
-0.24610397219657898,
-0.5078911185264587,
-0.00953493732959032,
0.9700126051902771,
-0.6508895754814148,
-0.8444336652755737,
-0.3077802062034607,
-0.12652599811553955,
-0.08076642453670502,
0.6728442311286926,
0.25101813673973083,
-0.080414779484272,
-0.3527038097381592,
-0.10763547569513321,
-0.7044731974601746,
-0.4712470471858978,
-0.7091851234436035,
-0.08014645427465439,
0.5380799174308777,
0.15755723416805267,
0.8052830696105957,
0.6822550296783447,
0.5585017204284668,
0.11206670850515366,
-0.0844927504658699,
0.713762640953064,
-0.5954768657684326,
0.08506488054990768,
-0.31773921847343445,
-0.16631250083446503,
-0.4745420217514038,
-0.32909175753593445,
0.26295027136802673,
0.585212767124176,
-0.08839015662670135,
0.0840752124786377,
0.08203332871198654,
0.9589124917984009,
-0.6808040738105774,
0.5255841016769409,
-0.8724331259727478,
0.25617948174476624,
-0.03843878582119942,
-0.5019368529319763,
-0.4310154616832733,
-0.04825710132718086,
-0.003826654050499201,
-0.8143643736839294,
0.5260980725288391,
0.17583370208740234,
0.6357394456863403,
0.7287859916687012,
-0.15137630701065063,
0.01504417136311531,
-0.5615721344947815,
0.7556244134902954,
-0.4745684862136841,
0.6519080996513367,
0.4715358316898346,
0.32586386799812317,
-0.2520766854286194,
-0.15021643042564392,
-0.29636359214782715,
-0.17238281667232513,
0.09920656681060791,
0.2589341104030609,
0.0385889895260334,
0.3463524580001831,
0.309815913438797,
0.11499205231666565,
-0.591480553150177,
0.16294008493423462,
-0.57222980260849,
-0.22165217995643616,
0.6907758116722107,
-0.058967117220163345,
-0.08302418887615204,
-0.026796067133545876,
-0.16671250760555267,
-0.3031885325908661,
-0.8675150871276855,
-0.20835497975349426,
0.19385357201099396,
0.4981323480606079,
0.19519031047821045,
0.7688306570053101,
-0.37072426080703735,
0.5355305671691895,
-0.018108239397406578,
0.01821012981235981,
0.36568769812583923,
0.1357751041650772,
-0.1559886485338211,
0.23266883194446564,
0.41586437821388245,
1.062923550605774,
0.5891980528831482,
-0.2400905191898346,
-0.3940773904323578,
0.25520753860473633,
0.4078841507434845,
-0.629460334777832,
-0.19047439098358154,
0.1947091966867447,
-0.6664720177650452,
-0.498769611120224,
-0.0958188995718956,
-0.9552469849586487,
-0.7781305909156799,
-0.3886593282222748,
0.4594157040119171,
-0.10525859147310257,
-0.20094072818756104,
0.21758928894996643,
-0.0839724913239479,
0.41968441009521484,
0.5162107348442078,
-0.7080262899398804,
-0.13422662019729614,
0.555353581905365,
0.9374915957450867,
-0.37615731358528137,
0.028201671317219734,
-0.8525776863098145,
0.3635709285736084,
-0.5837394595146179,
0.8670667409896851,
-0.44298478960990906,
-0.5796430706977844,
-0.014879393391311169,
0.18694140017032623,
0.41281595826148987,
-0.8248847723007202,
0.3839658498764038,
-0.15691745281219482,
0.07363221794366837,
-0.10823068767786026,
-0.26351895928382874,
-0.47935375571250916,
0.19020900130271912,
-0.4642382264137268,
0.8703795075416565,
-0.004057881888002157,
-0.4360150098800659,
0.39774879813194275,
-0.3378620743751526,
-0.11719029396772385,
0.13912063837051392,
-0.3052263557910919,
-0.6826115846633911,
0.4861376881599426,
0.647000253200531,
0.6182710528373718,
-0.22727014124393463,
0.3687020242214203,
-0.46728914976119995,
-0.6309688091278076,
-0.3262220025062561,
-0.46091246604919434,
0.3199373185634613,
0.14074692130088806,
-0.4929260015487671,
0.5192970037460327,
-0.9368689060211182,
-0.025237631052732468,
0.024552544578909874,
0.17907573282718658,
-0.3131091892719269,
0.2364971935749054,
-0.24603445827960968,
0.154180645942688,
-0.12881818413734436,
-0.19796383380889893,
0.21905691921710968,
-0.3649809956550598,
0.1046994999051094,
0.8459933400154114,
0.2104886919260025,
0.2729543447494507,
-0.3276519477367401,
0.32733219861984253,
0.16088896989822388,
0.3504044711589813,
-0.20890852808952332,
-0.6016466617584229,
-0.9215994477272034,
-0.2891620695590973,
-0.5705558657646179,
0.4959738850593567,
-0.9927918910980225,
0.3682417571544647,
-0.059281736612319946,
-0.5112730264663696,
-0.39450204372406006,
-0.02459895610809326,
0.26430752873420715,
0.4750393033027649,
0.7883270382881165,
-0.3215457797050476,
-0.652095377445221,
-0.86557537317276,
-0.0021493560634553432,
-0.07648979127407074,
-0.17853429913520813,
0.4377163052558899,
0.3113037943840027,
-0.4754468500614166,
0.5884866714477539,
-0.4104294180870056,
-0.5186578631401062,
0.09759556502103806,
-0.2230672836303711,
-0.10258141905069351,
0.48822852969169617,
0.3186894655227661,
-0.720548152923584,
0.013733146712183952,
0.06779251992702484,
-1.0178685188293457,
-0.21942898631095886,
-0.22956351935863495,
-0.20607075095176697,
0.37370970845222473,
0.6849523782730103,
-0.6303249597549438,
0.787790834903717,
0.20756907761096954,
-0.2046274095773697,
0.5129914879798889,
-0.3258788585662842,
-0.2842380702495575,
-0.6755207777023315,
-0.19302178919315338,
-0.06367120891809464,
-0.06571932882070541,
-0.4139203429222107,
0.08639734983444214,
0.02218417264521122,
-0.12719318270683289,
-0.4929468631744385,
0.41882458329200745,
-0.43978601694107056,
-0.13719511032104492,
-0.3282460570335388,
0.17001491785049438,
-0.14580737054347992,
0.46014609932899475,
0.48122185468673706,
0.5076286792755127,
0.6954774856567383,
-0.6242167949676514,
0.2654232382774353,
0.14124754071235657,
-0.16687381267547607,
0.4308459758758545,
-0.4368433356285095,
0.12457925826311111,
-0.5676115155220032,
0.08416055142879486,
-0.6181699633598328,
-0.0535351000726223,
0.4433322548866272,
0.014493879862129688,
0.07672528922557831,
-0.1565544605255127,
-0.15454258024692535,
-0.39651456475257874,
-0.5151753425598145,
0.17846986651420593,
0.5966871380805969,
-0.7912764549255371,
0.5233109593391418,
0.004328687209635973,
0.16457349061965942,
-0.6138288974761963,
-0.6101417541503906,
0.020252622663974762,
-0.23158371448516846,
-0.29577451944351196,
0.17837347090244293,
-0.31725770235061646,
-0.0956340879201889,
-0.12383148074150085,
-0.3520229160785675,
0.3016272485256195,
0.04473843798041344,
0.4581276774406433,
0.5254963636398315,
-0.24784770607948303,
0.14263497292995453,
-0.012290112674236298,
-0.18265286087989807,
0.026753952726721764,
-0.5855203866958618,
0.6233400702476501,
-0.1758788675069809,
-0.5319652557373047,
-0.33717769384384155,
0.11088529229164124,
0.794919490814209,
-0.4406541883945465,
0.5799609422683716,
0.5627686977386475,
-0.2610620856285095,
-0.358129620552063,
-0.7295866012573242,
-0.23864486813545227,
-0.5020402669906616,
0.5301582217216492,
-0.40792593359947205,
-0.7677070498466492,
0.2290317863225937,
0.11863592267036438,
-0.12321390211582184,
0.31529122591018677,
0.37295112013816833,
0.16516976058483124,
1.0685057640075684,
0.5643172860145569,
0.10390489548444748,
0.27570703625679016,
-0.13676609098911285,
0.20252646505832672,
-0.8454634547233582,
-0.6128578186035156,
0.11655768752098083,
-0.1288301646709442,
-0.5266689658164978,
-0.7354264855384827,
0.1600220799446106,
0.11582016944885254,
-0.06324665248394012,
-0.1038125604391098,
-0.9778934121131897,
0.8713433742523193,
0.42290112376213074,
0.25615987181663513,
0.2969745695590973,
0.4279651641845703,
-0.0029899836517870426,
0.03700857236981392,
-0.48899129033088684,
-0.46446746587753296,
1.1747639179229736,
0.17388741672039032,
0.6897523403167725,
-0.25848162174224854,
0.6854786276817322,
0.21522676944732666,
0.1352538764476776,
-0.8394649028778076,
0.8599221110343933,
-0.2389156073331833,
-0.1825038641691208,
-0.28283897042274475,
-0.5482997298240662,
-0.7115812301635742,
0.6094178557395935,
-0.2893596589565277,
-0.7073020339012146,
0.36317846179008484,
0.1334161013364792,
-0.22478832304477692,
0.5460124015808105,
-0.3108600974082947,
0.695940375328064,
-0.29708656668663025,
-0.5445665717124939,
-0.07971597462892532,
-0.48313021659851074,
0.40332674980163574,
-0.3038632869720459,
0.11775150150060654,
-0.20427767932415009,
-0.065897636115551,
0.23339195549488068,
-0.15910828113555908,
0.8935670256614685,
-0.4523770809173584,
-0.40828660130500793,
0.26078271865844727,
0.08953661471605301,
0.5027386546134949,
0.03936880826950073,
0.28759878873825073,
0.3645964562892914,
-0.3591097295284271,
-0.1662871539592743,
-0.4461885690689087,
0.6322126388549805,
-0.6066831350326538,
-0.7100731134414673,
-0.20087386667728424,
-0.7600986957550049,
-0.13225071132183075,
0.09680459648370743,
0.3853861093521118,
0.17433978617191315,
0.14698690176010132,
0.36675018072128296,
0.8956447243690491,
-0.629589855670929,
0.2999390661716461,
0.24357861280441284,
-0.7389841079711914,
-0.5888457298278809,
1.1840003728866577,
0.19783423840999603,
0.07895223796367645,
0.1423952877521515,
-0.0306243933737278,
-0.35479429364204407,
-0.7014738321304321,
-0.44591403007507324,
0.22320182621479034,
-0.7408463358879089,
-0.23065844178199768,
-0.4782852828502655,
-0.24478907883167267,
-0.2419319450855255,
-0.3282196819782257,
-0.4023556411266327,
-0.41784435510635376,
-0.39142510294914246,
-0.12381216138601303,
0.21978014707565308,
0.6068795919418335,
0.05588654801249504,
0.11722627282142639,
-0.5471407771110535,
0.4894503355026245,
0.27258795499801636,
0.41292864084243774,
0.0826190784573555,
-0.3713287115097046,
0.13332371413707733,
-0.00046588003169745207,
-0.13067667186260223,
-0.48839515447616577,
0.48114094138145447,
0.1526576280593872,
0.506051778793335,
0.6046369671821594,
0.044526852667331696,
0.9192395210266113,
-0.34249448776245117,
0.8448426723480225,
0.11533918231725693,
-0.8163906335830688,
0.659779965877533,
-0.3331162631511688,
0.18542082607746124,
0.1610351800918579,
-0.08116980642080307,
-0.42977607250213623,
-0.5401307940483093,
-0.3769010603427887,
-1.0907657146453857,
0.5265378952026367,
0.24754074215888977,
-0.08676044642925262,
0.05126045271754265,
0.520140528678894,
0.1297597885131836,
0.42746680974960327,
-0.6814178824424744,
0.036908555775880814,
-0.6154392957687378,
-0.2653735876083374,
-0.2957090139389038,
-0.09595713764429092,
0.07943639904260635,
-0.3443490266799927,
0.7953903079032898,
-0.1617671102285385,
-0.033639416098594666,
0.17502541840076447,
-0.2448253184556961,
-0.11996851116418839,
-0.09846850484609604,
0.8802238702774048,
0.2290969043970108,
-0.3490511178970337,
0.3842158913612366,
0.2502223253250122,
-0.3932415843009949,
0.09968065470457077,
-0.29555290937423706,
-0.45979517698287964,
-0.050345323979854584,
0.11586137861013412,
0.9136011600494385,
-0.07541079819202423,
-0.7936863303184509,
0.34133607149124146,
0.09136349707841873,
-0.3460678458213806,
-0.2500614523887634,
0.22228941321372986,
-0.21735785901546478,
0.46798378229141235,
0.2592238485813141,
0.3085634708404541,
-0.09887530654668808,
-0.14671948552131653,
0.14486056566238403,
0.5273564457893372,
-0.4116464853286743,
-0.07490259408950806,
0.9198167324066162,
-0.05136045068502426,
-0.16013139486312866,
0.6282672882080078,
-0.20922255516052246,
-0.29919344186782837,
0.4598497748374939,
0.5986903309822083,
1.04130220413208,
-0.11797025799751282,
0.1841007024049759,
0.34823498129844666,
0.5830464363098145,
-0.5079506039619446,
0.29994997382164,
-0.10363934934139252,
-0.6132153272628784,
-0.2097245305776596,
-0.6671567559242249,
-0.2778227925300598,
0.36027979850769043,
-0.5973143577575684,
0.2823137938976288,
-0.5630998015403748,
0.14461854100227356,
-0.5774952173233032,
-0.4609716534614563,
-0.5384284853935242,
0.2150317132472992,
0.6068519353866577,
0.5017231702804565,
-0.5990647673606873,
0.7445133328437805,
0.454734742641449,
-0.5748240947723389,
-0.4435206353664398,
-0.02109639160335064,
-0.1002952829003334,
-0.7606483697891235,
0.5933064222335815,
0.7335976958274841,
-0.46371400356292725,
0.12618814408779144,
-0.5466124415397644,
-0.7667219042778015,
1.097624659538269,
0.3730153441429138,
-0.8169364333152771,
0.006298551335930824,
0.30036938190460205,
0.40903931856155396,
-0.48962023854255676,
-0.1681881844997406,
0.34233734011650085,
0.5174907445907593,
0.10609876364469528,
-0.5834135413169861,
0.11830181628465652,
-0.22066141664981842,
0.2965552508831024,
0.09096693247556686,
-0.5962845683097839,
0.5354523658752441,
-0.34625616669654846,
-0.15416696667671204,
0.06281639635562897,
0.4916800260543823,
0.3934500813484192,
0.4611325263977051,
0.6945860385894775,
0.5595386028289795,
1.0609521865844727,
-0.07399323582649231,
0.6362528800964355,
-0.14080452919006348,
0.15005914866924286,
1.1215248107910156,
-0.34386199712753296,
0.8370878100395203,
0.6924450397491455,
0.32005757093429565,
0.17485152184963226,
0.4868108332157135,
-0.5175368785858154,
0.776246190071106,
0.3366275429725647,
-0.18133197724819183,
-0.3158581852912903,
-0.09478416293859482,
-0.5603021383285522,
0.4334612488746643,
0.3311331272125244,
-0.32573452591896057,
-0.06663113087415695,
0.4613855481147766,
-0.38787999749183655,
-0.24570786952972412,
-0.736449122428894,
0.7176735401153564,
-0.04039767384529114,
-0.49287179112434387,
0.8996071219444275,
-0.4840351641178131,
0.708633303642273,
-0.2889915406703949,
-0.1505846530199051,
-0.312418669462204,
0.343575119972229,
-0.3809899091720581,
-0.39447546005249023,
0.3041842579841614,
0.047795478254556656,
-0.1840054988861084,
-0.0960191935300827,
0.8013032674789429,
-0.5844106078147888,
-0.5406585335731506,
0.3990836441516876,
0.501143217086792,
0.4932573139667511,
-0.6255884170532227,
-0.2024412602186203,
0.13741306960582733,
0.17931197583675385,
-0.17635007202625275,
0.09378789365291595,
0.42058172821998596,
-0.3346153199672699,
0.8086548447608948,
0.7933810949325562,
0.24948027729988098,
0.06301342695951462,
0.2423766404390335,
0.7485299110412598,
-0.7042062878608704,
-0.10599806159734726,
-0.891728401184082,
0.3986246883869171,
-0.04792385920882225,
-0.0942145586013794,
0.5518351793289185,
0.637099027633667,
1.0168081521987915,
-0.452716201543808,
0.6219366192817688,
0.578917384147644,
-0.019974403083324432,
-0.6956587433815002,
0.8727635145187378,
-0.7942700386047363,
0.5896626114845276,
-0.24298781156539917,
-1.3816678524017334,
-0.8178209066390991,
0.928465723991394,
-0.17772036790847778,
-0.15810519456863403,
0.5497199892997742,
1.1798537969589233,
-0.07777402549982071,
-0.13135609030723572,
0.6747137308120728,
0.09661039710044861,
0.3121316432952881,
0.30606287717819214,
0.9868608117103577,
-0.061879537999629974,
0.6835792064666748,
-0.3799958825111389,
0.021544717252254486,
-0.23755234479904175,
-0.8649711012840271,
-1.041488766670227,
-0.18895579874515533,
-0.39431050419807434,
-0.18981528282165527,
0.3086221516132355,
0.9461219310760498,
0.6530454754829407,
-0.7474201917648315,
-0.1290045827627182,
-0.4114680588245392,
-0.10741226375102997,
-0.22998154163360596,
-0.18531818687915802,
0.43792107701301575,
-0.40391242504119873,
-0.40080252289772034,
0.6168522834777832,
0.5127124786376953,
0.5065438151359558,
-0.35422953963279724,
-0.21214169263839722,
0.5218955874443054,
-0.015857718884944916,
0.9104218482971191,
-0.05277913063764572,
-1.0890755653381348,
-0.49203282594680786,
-0.07967573404312134,
0.23865608870983124,
0.15704551339149475,
0.4832785129547119,
-1.0326924324035645,
0.6092100739479065,
-0.016045957803726196,
0.4159899055957794,
0.5046076774597168,
-0.1465402990579605,
0.2981603443622589,
-0.6616523861885071,
0.5034266710281372,
0.08344903588294983,
0.2859669625759125,
0.43319976329803467,
-0.4268988370895386,
0.7852550745010376,
0.357591450214386,
-0.44675251841545105,
-1.0196937322616577,
0.1833948940038681,
-1.0122798681259155,
-0.31908929347991943,
1.0226813554763794,
0.34005212783813477,
-0.15273867547512054,
-0.022126832976937294,
-0.7104712724685669,
0.3612078130245209,
-0.2667172849178314,
1.011006474494934,
0.47852808237075806,
0.0816621407866478,
-0.3393065631389618,
-0.7295383810997009,
0.4961598217487335,
0.40201491117477417,
-0.8091572523117065,
0.389671266078949,
0.7414460182189941,
-0.05431818589568138,
-0.0044653164222836494,
0.17009387910366058,
-0.02206398732960224,
0.05770781636238098,
-0.11189251393079758,
0.34551119804382324,
-0.32756996154785156,
-0.5642070174217224,
-0.3631282448768616,
0.23691289126873016,
-0.23635804653167725,
-0.1189069077372551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08679v2 | COLD-Attack: Jailbreaking LLMs with Stealthiness and Controllability | 2024-02-13T18:58:48 | 2024-06-07T00:13:08 | Xingang Guo, Fangxu Yu, Huan Zhang, Lianhui Qin, Bin Hu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Jailbreaks on large language models (LLMs) have recently received increasing
attention. For a comprehensive assessment of LLM safety, it is essential to
consider jailbreaks with diverse attributes, such as contextual coherence and
sentiment/stylistic variations, and hence it is beneficial to study
controllable jailbreaking, i.e. how to enforce control on LLM attacks. In this
paper, we formally formulate the controllable attack generation problem, and
build a novel connection between this problem and controllable text generation,
a well-explored topic of natural language processing. Based on this connection,
we adapt the Energy-based Constrained Decoding with Langevin Dynamics (COLD), a
state-of-the-art, highly efficient algorithm in controllable text generation,
and introduce the COLD-Attack framework which unifies and automates the search
of adversarial LLM attacks under a variety of control requirements such as
fluency, stealthiness, sentiment, and left-right-coherence. The controllability
enabled by COLD-Attack leads to diverse new jailbreak scenarios which not only
cover the standard setting of generating fluent (suffix) attack with
continuation constraint, but also allow us to address new controllable attack
settings such as revising a user query adversarially with paraphrasing
constraint, and inserting stealthy attacks in context with position constraint.
Our extensive experiments on various LLMs (Llama-2, Mistral, Vicuna, Guanaco,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4) show COLD-Attack's broad applicability, strong
controllability, high success rate, and attack transferability. Our code is
available at https://github.com/Yu-Fangxu/COLD-Attack. | [
-0.22161069512367249,
-0.9923161864280701,
0.14315105974674225,
0.3187471926212311,
-0.10065987706184387,
0.44579586386680603,
-0.2876548767089844,
-0.4712798297405243,
0.31729409098625183,
0.4942733645439148,
-0.5830857753753662,
-0.6164368987083435,
-0.6794193387031555,
-0.03591926395893097,
-0.40525156259536743,
1.066285490989685,
-0.3369205594062805,
-0.3404739499092102,
0.2209625244140625,
0.03349155932664871,
-0.22138652205467224,
-0.6773019433021545,
-0.22883173823356628,
0.010599646717309952,
0.1995772123336792,
0.086028091609478,
0.9671611785888672,
0.4514612555503845,
0.4718005061149597,
0.24420052766799927,
-0.1650877445936203,
-0.21056944131851196,
-0.3358621895313263,
0.527845561504364,
-0.07829076796770096,
-0.20554213225841522,
-0.5061939358711243,
0.03512420877814293,
0.32776036858558655,
0.18030288815498352,
-0.1966981291770935,
-0.5083726048469543,
-0.17162689566612244,
0.5411162972450256,
-0.7698331475257874,
-0.17692101001739502,
-0.9417970776557922,
0.13243842124938965,
-0.5844570398330688,
0.1734301745891571,
-0.21534928679466248,
-0.1337304413318634,
-0.14125485718250275,
-0.26129335165023804,
0.2549547553062439,
0.026165924966335297,
0.9059122800827026,
0.2515769600868225,
-0.3148273527622223,
-0.5370270013809204,
-0.489726722240448,
0.727656900882721,
-0.8601454496383667,
0.2423320710659027,
0.3506990969181061,
0.08800642937421799,
-0.36817440390586853,
-0.3485943377017975,
-0.36122363805770874,
-0.4371299743652344,
0.06341779232025146,
0.05578019097447395,
-0.533284068107605,
0.166540265083313,
0.167413592338562,
0.0909140333533287,
-0.44412216544151306,
0.32770827412605286,
-0.23617292940616608,
-0.3628511428833008,
0.6356157064437866,
0.25251641869544983,
0.4538963735103607,
-0.18118508160114288,
-0.47837039828300476,
0.22375771403312683,
-0.40514320135116577,
0.08648232370615005,
0.4711822271347046,
0.25688838958740234,
-0.4920773506164551,
0.4816461503505707,
-0.21042238175868988,
0.805627167224884,
0.06090565398335457,
-0.020839858800172806,
-0.22176139056682587,
-0.1623162478208542,
-0.3406800925731659,
0.02034318633377552,
0.9851508140563965,
0.3472526967525482,
0.029508018866181374,
-0.5292344689369202,
-0.24772004783153534,
-0.18279320001602173,
-0.002881303895264864,
-0.8256151676177979,
-0.4645707309246063,
0.29502981901168823,
0.04004034399986267,
-0.6107192039489746,
0.05081437528133392,
-0.7832955121994019,
-0.363587886095047,
0.13579818606376648,
-0.039308030158281326,
-0.4152339696884155,
-0.3502538204193115,
-0.05024801567196846,
-0.07436661422252655,
0.3406849801540375,
-0.04407750442624092,
-1.025913953781128,
0.5161309838294983,
0.46833524107933044,
0.7879094481468201,
-0.36013659834861755,
0.04126855731010437,
-0.35854360461235046,
0.3713110089302063,
-0.3210592269897461,
0.2089260220527649,
-0.46832147240638733,
-0.3610018789768219,
-0.13725465536117554,
-0.32225164771080017,
-0.10261484980583191,
-0.4000784754753113,
0.18695557117462158,
-0.8773031234741211,
-0.14984728395938873,
0.029049087315797806,
-0.46281561255455017,
0.24591515958309174,
0.5063890814781189,
-0.7593488097190857,
0.38004541397094727,
-0.23314344882965088,
-0.8622514009475708,
0.1186918243765831,
-0.41201359033584595,
-0.5746430158615112,
-0.1277162730693817,
-0.06044359505176544,
-0.44517186284065247,
0.06151720881462097,
0.0035853716544806957,
0.5099045038223267,
-0.19160465896129608,
0.43990468978881836,
-0.18429678678512573,
0.25181886553764343,
0.5177674293518066,
-0.24986959993839264,
0.7041070461273193,
0.3518444895744324,
-0.5976782441139221,
0.015944207087159157,
-0.6636369824409485,
0.16694115102291107,
0.31168118119239807,
-0.3907787501811981,
-0.3273790776729584,
0.06779754906892776,
-0.0007313235546462238,
-0.17637218534946442,
0.4633706212043762,
-0.46157318353652954,
0.32759061455726624,
-0.45560985803604126,
0.5999391674995422,
0.48965656757354736,
0.123329758644104,
0.532416582107544,
0.15436220169067383,
0.5786687135696411,
-0.07209635525941849,
0.08050306886434555,
0.06536848098039627,
-0.17392121255397797,
-0.3898642957210541,
-0.2831156253814697,
0.04886298254132271,
0.9324127435684204,
-0.8510295152664185,
0.20432989299297333,
0.2743067145347595,
-0.5447205901145935,
-0.09587088972330093,
0.5997145175933838,
0.7127851247787476,
0.25909310579299927,
0.4708968997001648,
0.14388221502304077,
-0.3366401493549347,
-0.8781940937042236,
-0.6111915707588196,
0.1360202431678772,
0.27649426460266113,
0.06917959451675415,
0.16158001124858856,
-0.25016117095947266,
0.7890864014625549,
-0.5208269357681274,
0.032284632325172424,
-0.5589896440505981,
-0.08908787369728088,
0.24830031394958496,
0.8936643004417419,
0.5105245113372803,
-0.6347731351852417,
-0.29995834827423096,
-0.23645798861980438,
-0.8588740825653076,
-0.13337762653827667,
-0.17043405771255493,
-0.12351301312446594,
0.23235918581485748,
0.7797171473503113,
-0.8280590772628784,
0.5249067544937134,
0.49475765228271484,
-0.35448339581489563,
0.49077627062797546,
-0.15689818561077118,
-0.17352721095085144,
-1.1939284801483154,
0.0015583920758217573,
-0.0000028830872906837612,
-0.02398105338215828,
-1.00992751121521,
0.5420784950256348,
0.1299833059310913,
-0.28999000787734985,
-0.5347549915313721,
0.4051235318183899,
-0.5318918228149414,
0.5340285301208496,
-0.2714169919490814,
0.0288435947149992,
-0.24409770965576172,
0.29619988799095154,
-0.25633811950683594,
0.3102602958679199,
0.5844376087188721,
-0.5797212719917297,
0.46853598952293396,
-0.23985840380191803,
-0.10455115139484406,
0.20522765815258026,
-0.6221976280212402,
0.3902411460876465,
-0.00879514217376709,
0.05932530015707016,
-0.4803231954574585,
-0.4013805687427521,
0.2715659737586975,
-0.29792988300323486,
0.6238085031509399,
0.004460768774151802,
-0.5325692892074585,
0.003838460659608245,
-0.10409343242645264,
0.2992731034755707,
0.37063920497894287,
-0.3926818370819092,
0.3254002630710602,
0.24589356780052185,
0.02445935271680355,
-0.6732529997825623,
-0.6546590924263,
0.5685646533966064,
-0.19813314080238342,
-0.4468003213405609,
0.33106523752212524,
-0.29775533080101013,
-0.7835494875907898,
-0.15360981225967407,
-0.06860319525003433,
-0.03436322137713432,
0.5296714901924133,
0.1485898196697235,
0.24212846159934998,
0.30405110120773315,
-0.28969457745552063,
0.41022026538848877,
-0.07364505529403687,
0.17305050790309906,
-0.17212523519992828,
0.5102189779281616,
-0.13724380731582642,
0.09802816063165665,
-0.5674724578857422,
0.3439010679721832,
0.5098450779914856,
-0.007173104211688042,
0.5826804041862488,
0.3324570953845978,
-0.25697582960128784,
-0.2974590063095093,
-0.2743237018585205,
-0.07531313598155975,
-0.5415664315223694,
0.163834348320961,
-0.5009835958480835,
-0.9838338494300842,
0.33784469962120056,
0.12873294949531555,
0.198759064078331,
0.11903581768274307,
0.41369009017944336,
-0.09558620303869247,
0.7109097838401794,
0.523070752620697,
-0.5195426940917969,
0.2734004557132721,
-0.061694446951150894,
0.12455255538225174,
-0.4475836157798767,
-0.35283538699150085,
-0.4114166498184204,
-0.39242836833000183,
-0.7918733954429626,
0.04953145980834961,
-0.017604954540729523,
0.5423944592475891,
-0.10750896483659744,
0.41828152537345886,
-0.3551063537597656,
0.4854409992694855,
0.23674637079238892,
0.12689648568630219,
-0.03784364461898804,
-0.2259141206741333,
-0.45769068598747253,
-0.09775540977716446,
-0.48541417717933655,
-0.014483591541647911,
0.7811762690544128,
0.17936775088310242,
1.0595048666000366,
0.4960281252861023,
0.8879672288894653,
0.3004087507724762,
0.2641347646713257,
-0.7181073427200317,
0.645186185836792,
-0.12120670080184937,
-0.6924538612365723,
0.07469592243432999,
-0.45912352204322815,
-0.8860568404197693,
-0.08062664419412613,
-0.22108787298202515,
-0.9800417423248291,
-0.24178630113601685,
0.3343823552131653,
-0.18595030903816223,
0.6275713443756104,
-0.47882217168807983,
0.5315439701080322,
-0.49627548456192017,
-0.6105296015739441,
0.10936334729194641,
-0.7905173301696777,
0.7897759079933167,
-0.12155547738075256,
0.3223431706428528,
-0.19902460277080536,
-0.14436577260494232,
0.779365062713623,
-0.6730999946594238,
0.9647404551506042,
-0.45147034525871277,
-0.23396392166614532,
0.10162781178951263,
0.5655423402786255,
0.6575831770896912,
0.27334970235824585,
0.017320843413472176,
-0.0615328811109066,
-0.18250106275081635,
-0.5650884509086609,
-0.554462730884552,
0.8262562155723572,
-0.6605103015899658,
-1.1454720497131348,
-0.29998886585235596,
-0.7090409994125366,
-0.11319602280855179,
0.23777064681053162,
0.5198791027069092,
0.37044557929039,
-0.20961163938045502,
-0.196156308054924,
0.887711763381958,
-0.2973061203956604,
0.7676283121109009,
0.4445972144603729,
-0.3673807680606842,
-0.6503434777259827,
0.7751038670539856,
-0.13667823374271393,
0.3967503309249878,
0.5440640449523926,
0.21726594865322113,
0.2734954059123993,
-0.7292874455451965,
-0.2265291064977646,
0.013118674978613853,
-0.365016907453537,
-0.35872337222099304,
-0.5649825930595398,
-0.3246169984340668,
-0.4929875433444977,
-0.5051029324531555,
-0.15494784712791443,
-0.3409125804901123,
-0.34441956877708435,
-0.20053763687610626,
0.4759966731071472,
0.5342725515365601,
-0.29205888509750366,
0.4863046407699585,
-0.7034010887145996,
0.4670427739620209,
0.27743497490882874,
-0.10980913043022156,
-0.3418552875518799,
-0.15269967913627625,
-0.16975972056388855,
-0.3552147150039673,
-0.2473326474428177,
-1.2729829549789429,
0.5871466994285583,
0.05130712315440178,
0.3604527711868286,
0.5126818418502808,
0.3795814514160156,
0.24453166127204895,
-0.3143390715122223,
0.6666086316108704,
0.4985271096229553,
-1.1656410694122314,
0.8756036162376404,
-0.4195711314678192,
0.614941418170929,
0.5244455933570862,
0.07758784294128418,
-0.13913024961948395,
-0.721938967704773,
-0.7168522477149963,
-1.0550905466079712,
0.3654364347457886,
0.30999720096588135,
0.34414201974868774,
0.12429105490446091,
0.4960263967514038,
-0.037530794739723206,
0.225528746843338,
-0.5913790464401245,
-0.2612537443637848,
-0.1676051914691925,
-0.11214546114206314,
-0.038844503462314606,
-0.15524080395698547,
-0.3382813632488251,
-0.005174516700208187,
0.530921220779419,
0.2223101258277893,
0.09650508314371109,
0.09382116794586182,
-0.17632248997688293,
0.1300978809595108,
0.562432587146759,
0.7522815465927124,
0.09104745090007782,
-0.3002285659313202,
0.39824947714805603,
0.00869970116764307,
-0.7510198950767517,
0.17016460001468658,
0.19613678753376007,
-0.5225228071212769,
-0.0596691332757473,
0.32312196493148804,
0.8305616974830627,
0.11019676923751831,
-0.5834698677062988,
0.24154113233089447,
-0.08764568716287613,
-0.15337534248828888,
-0.2191474735736847,
0.31054362654685974,
-0.19469986855983734,
0.1865183711051941,
0.23445862531661987,
0.3690703213214874,
-0.251463919878006,
-0.32015976309776306,
0.06892642378807068,
0.7744048833847046,
-0.5903308391571045,
-0.5117597579956055,
0.8578087687492371,
0.06274614483118057,
-0.31265535950660706,
0.5742592811584473,
-0.39089447259902954,
-0.7397101521492004,
0.6430585384368896,
0.6831613779067993,
1.0660443305969238,
-0.31905820965766907,
-0.05902775749564171,
0.11296288669109344,
0.7732218503952026,
0.2695218622684479,
0.3690851628780365,
-0.35864323377609253,
-0.8839337825775146,
-0.02325090765953064,
-0.39046233892440796,
-0.49109211564064026,
0.17253708839416504,
-0.7484287619590759,
-0.04124840348958969,
-1.1581794023513794,
-0.24901092052459717,
-0.38676753640174866,
-0.16469070315361023,
-0.4631428122520447,
0.28209978342056274,
-0.021174436435103416,
0.9799021482467651,
-0.4237133860588074,
1.0862914323806763,
0.36510390043258667,
0.1636957824230194,
-0.5725182294845581,
0.14959168434143066,
0.4230057895183563,
-0.5199229717254639,
0.8009725213050842,
0.10288732498884201,
-0.14831633865833282,
-0.11747029423713684,
-0.9592185616493225,
-0.8454029560089111,
0.9956575632095337,
0.20824281871318817,
-0.8181419968605042,
0.02983090654015541,
-0.09677288681268692,
0.09690466523170471,
-0.019080350175499916,
-0.3382331430912018,
0.90155029296875,
0.3851942718029022,
-0.07937011122703552,
-0.7281947731971741,
0.23486335575580597,
-0.36696651577949524,
-0.26561349630355835,
0.48303598165512085,
-0.6830089688301086,
0.5488046407699585,
-0.4931928813457489,
-0.1353420466184616,
0.26419082283973694,
0.8199046850204468,
0.4902994632720947,
0.4809613823890686,
0.11409834772348404,
0.8400998115539551,
0.614753007888794,
-0.09790976345539093,
0.928084135055542,
-0.44975754618644714,
0.004369562026113272,
1.2060518264770508,
-0.2039773166179657,
0.7973206043243408,
0.6179112195968628,
0.1599648892879486,
0.200197234749794,
0.31395581364631653,
0.07748391479253769,
0.7374429702758789,
0.6369048953056335,
-0.5399883985519409,
0.040098149329423904,
0.15917623043060303,
-0.23125222325325012,
0.2686684727668762,
0.6258984208106995,
-0.2451324462890625,
-0.10475186258554459,
0.40434834361076355,
0.9410114884376526,
0.08722211420536041,
-0.32261374592781067,
0.6666267514228821,
0.12985184788703918,
-0.2836337983608246,
0.7384084463119507,
0.3714336156845093,
0.9060842394828796,
-0.7697877883911133,
0.6091118454933167,
-0.34387707710266113,
0.05105633661150932,
-0.28451162576675415,
-0.3726622760295868,
0.20702648162841797,
0.49033644795417786,
-0.04780023172497749,
-0.18355277180671692,
0.7394065856933594,
-0.05526044964790344,
-0.3822843134403229,
0.3549373149871826,
0.19697321951389313,
0.0718558058142662,
0.4587090015411377,
-0.7883419990539551,
0.43075844645500183,
0.11501516401767731,
-0.4311293661594391,
0.4957830011844635,
0.009593297727406025,
0.26088058948516846,
0.5617703199386597,
0.45192378759384155,
0.2027667909860611,
0.2592407166957855,
-0.28594857454299927,
1.0082234144210815,
-0.7951387166976929,
-0.23665806651115417,
-1.0227611064910889,
0.20251233875751495,
0.009215406142175198,
-0.22890272736549377,
0.7126690745353699,
0.4149038791656494,
0.5103307962417603,
0.21007516980171204,
1.053398847579956,
-0.3720966577529907,
-0.005256290081888437,
-1.0734937191009521,
0.9303305745124817,
-0.14539000391960144,
0.47307196259498596,
-0.35241514444351196,
-0.5268300771713257,
-0.48770877718925476,
-0.020829947665333748,
-0.3565483093261719,
-0.12182153016328812,
0.5076649188995361,
0.766460657119751,
0.24634051322937012,
-0.3061760663986206,
0.3863215148448944,
0.3695785701274872,
0.6057242751121521,
0.7370898723602295,
0.6583613753318787,
-0.26521241664886475,
0.3618835210800171,
-0.3783515989780426,
-0.40636661648750305,
0.22032763063907623,
-0.8957690000534058,
-1.078393578529358,
-0.2110268771648407,
-0.42205578088760376,
-0.7029566168785095,
0.07166161388158798,
0.7905747294425964,
0.4689066708087921,
-0.7827122807502747,
-0.331789493560791,
-0.34771379828453064,
0.1463681161403656,
0.06055976077914238,
-0.2796994745731354,
0.2717396020889282,
-0.35432323813438416,
-0.5801588296890259,
0.9298195838928223,
0.27847379446029663,
0.26931053400039673,
-0.1805722415447235,
-0.14787915349006653,
-0.1020420715212822,
0.2448558211326599,
0.2659834027290344,
0.7061790227890015,
-0.5873573422431946,
0.2762514054775238,
-0.02349463477730751,
-0.1214284896850586,
-0.2463427186012268,
1.1302686929702759,
-0.5869107842445374,
0.528653085231781,
0.22432871162891388,
0.6813485622406006,
0.4172942638397217,
-0.19237194955348969,
0.430000901222229,
-0.7995699644088745,
0.2702861428260803,
0.24667033553123474,
0.11988575756549835,
0.19216188788414001,
-0.4531547725200653,
-0.07243435084819794,
0.4437662661075592,
-0.3036859631538391,
-0.5691495537757874,
0.6301820874214172,
-1.093730092048645,
-0.599761426448822,
1.023229956626892,
-0.11658244580030441,
-0.27470892667770386,
0.010479643009603024,
0.0681227445602417,
0.12466142326593399,
-0.5276736617088318,
0.4999130666255951,
0.41309401392936707,
-0.15125037729740143,
-0.3091370165348053,
-0.4280559718608856,
0.7650191187858582,
0.32416799664497375,
-0.9057063460350037,
0.11960464715957642,
0.31186914443969727,
0.2064889520406723,
0.16959479451179504,
0.18905164301395416,
0.03930911049246788,
-0.08571211248636246,
-0.25049635767936707,
-0.19359831511974335,
-0.15567700564861298,
-0.13359077274799347,
-0.32497215270996094,
0.6154782772064209,
-0.07146289199590683,
0.062339283525943756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08666v1 | Improving Generalization in Semantic Parsing by Increasing Natural Language Variation | 2024-02-13T18:48:23 | 2024-02-13T18:48:23 | Irina Saparina, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text-to-SQL semantic parsing has made significant progress in recent years,
with various models demonstrating impressive performance on the challenging
Spider benchmark. However, it has also been shown that these models often
struggle to generalize even when faced with small perturbations of previously
(accurately) parsed expressions. This is mainly due to the linguistic form of
questions in Spider which are overly specific, unnatural, and display limited
variation. In this work, we use data augmentation to enhance the robustness of
text-to-SQL parsers against natural language variations. Existing approaches
generate question reformulations either via models trained on Spider or only
introduce local changes. In contrast, we leverage the capabilities of large
language models to generate more realistic and diverse questions. Using only a
few prompts, we achieve a two-fold increase in the number of questions in
Spider. Training on this augmented dataset yields substantial improvements on a
range of evaluation sets, including robustness benchmarks and out-of-domain
data. | [
-0.4774531424045563,
-0.988492488861084,
0.4256027042865753,
-0.01982436701655388,
-0.3463287353515625,
-0.01687333546578884,
-0.25265440344810486,
-0.6019284129142761,
0.22010479867458344,
0.7756607532501221,
-0.579925537109375,
-0.4027889370918274,
-0.4983687996864319,
0.6687334775924683,
-0.26808297634124756,
0.9421728849411011,
0.19591528177261353,
0.1267804056406021,
-0.18690125644207,
-0.31001755595207214,
-0.5016323924064636,
-0.4695557653903961,
-0.31186774373054504,
0.09864996373653412,
0.2833474278450012,
0.29328614473342896,
0.9318538308143616,
0.6796356439590454,
0.5376309752464294,
0.32338014245033264,
-0.3094507157802582,
0.5136440396308899,
-0.13767315447330475,
0.4367641508579254,
-0.5664478540420532,
-0.7538410425186157,
-0.09599637985229492,
-0.41254061460494995,
0.9265021085739136,
1.2858315706253052,
0.0640026107430458,
-0.18453411757946014,
-0.10941605269908905,
0.7413056492805481,
-0.64726322889328,
-0.1538347601890564,
-1.0324885845184326,
-0.20766443014144897,
0.013659455813467503,
-0.021245907992124557,
-0.28651726245880127,
-0.22270190715789795,
0.27467837929725647,
-0.7334674000740051,
0.6594623327255249,
-0.16802342236042023,
1.0257880687713623,
0.32519277930259705,
-0.5638936161994934,
-0.0873849093914032,
-0.6415273547172546,
0.6339311003684998,
-0.6108690500259399,
0.4734669029712677,
0.41797810792922974,
0.4608299434185028,
-0.42717820405960083,
-0.715083658695221,
-0.38029590249061584,
-0.3257169723510742,
0.0034596463665366173,
-0.3136413097381592,
-0.15481172502040863,
-0.14219193160533905,
0.29556846618652344,
0.4982270300388336,
-0.5288360714912415,
-0.16174356639385223,
0.007951824925839901,
-0.022932950407266617,
0.5464550256729126,
0.3935334384441376,
0.49247387051582336,
-0.06627308577299118,
-0.07614883035421371,
-0.5108914375305176,
-0.31527405977249146,
0.26012393832206726,
0.5302639007568359,
0.5508087873458862,
0.30745986104011536,
0.8044893741607666,
-0.7212470769882202,
1.0927314758300781,
0.2168838530778885,
0.43113476037979126,
0.24624057114124298,
-0.508114755153656,
-0.03096836619079113,
-0.3949189782142639,
0.14909128844738007,
0.3864978551864624,
0.03022562898695469,
-0.3945935368537903,
0.049207791686058044,
0.16380472481250763,
0.3274381160736084,
-0.4884602129459381,
-0.2805812954902649,
0.3802903890609741,
0.09667149186134338,
-0.13813351094722748,
0.14905375242233276,
-0.9656214714050293,
-0.6915991306304932,
-0.436663419008255,
0.12452252954244614,
-0.5525780916213989,
-0.21268413960933685,
0.49985551834106445,
-0.5547880530357361,
0.4152553677558899,
0.4914896488189697,
-0.9922840595245361,
0.5221793055534363,
0.6045910120010376,
0.23203517496585846,
-0.20538429915905,
-0.19285377860069275,
-0.6274529099464417,
0.3388797342777252,
-0.5098098516464233,
1.027115821838379,
-0.9721924662590027,
-0.1330391764640808,
-0.17117367684841156,
0.17326152324676514,
-0.09334223717451096,
-0.8655529022216797,
0.43680131435394287,
-0.5624378323554993,
0.48060813546180725,
-0.3457474410533905,
-0.6202461123466492,
0.05798273906111717,
0.6253238320350647,
-0.641883909702301,
1.0326166152954102,
0.2652212977409363,
-0.8468446135520935,
0.7720479965209961,
-0.4883113205432892,
-0.25961539149284363,
0.060614947229623795,
-0.14437782764434814,
-0.2686207890510559,
0.20439660549163818,
0.6267823576927185,
-0.029927823692560196,
-0.3408395051956177,
0.22858589887619019,
-0.3038391172885895,
-0.05850004777312279,
0.1490023136138916,
-0.17998531460762024,
0.5561646223068237,
-0.011218449100852013,
-0.24519723653793335,
0.09440818428993225,
-1.036271095275879,
0.24569709599018097,
0.13984625041484833,
-0.33037838339805603,
-0.4452964663505554,
-0.05424823611974716,
-0.30796554684638977,
-0.14749249815940857,
0.18612687289714813,
-0.7162171602249146,
0.25936877727508545,
-1.1392643451690674,
0.020544400438666344,
0.45751768350601196,
0.18698863685131073,
0.612054705619812,
-0.21754637360572815,
0.390889436006546,
0.21949826180934906,
0.010811164043843746,
-0.1867174506187439,
-0.5747055411338806,
-0.9000424146652222,
-0.18474401533603668,
0.3858863413333893,
0.5451083779335022,
-0.8263660073280334,
0.5795662999153137,
-0.375558465719223,
-0.321143239736557,
-0.5272292494773865,
0.2184036672115326,
-0.1798599660396576,
0.5573779344558716,
0.737654447555542,
-0.3526025414466858,
-0.5564318299293518,
-0.8936235308647156,
-0.8094830513000488,
0.0492897629737854,
-0.35139012336730957,
0.29880213737487793,
0.26318225264549255,
-0.2695333957672119,
1.4629490375518799,
-0.650402307510376,
0.0008539641858078539,
-0.34373053908348083,
0.005233113653957844,
0.18408247828483582,
0.6145390272140503,
0.1491520255804062,
-1.0400713682174683,
-0.4342654049396515,
0.09180740267038345,
-0.35573747754096985,
0.06510885804891586,
-0.15274915099143982,
0.019063662737607956,
0.27975884079933167,
0.01644572988152504,
-0.6628091931343079,
0.4324926733970642,
0.01871204376220703,
-0.48175954818725586,
0.34218481183052063,
-0.13738711178302765,
0.1606721580028534,
-1.1274453401565552,
-0.22043849527835846,
-0.2332867830991745,
-0.2386222630739212,
-0.829867959022522,
0.30198416113853455,
0.032340146601200104,
-0.30628496408462524,
-0.24379894137382507,
0.37570497393608093,
-0.3193665146827698,
0.08063671737909317,
-0.1626695841550827,
0.004489343613386154,
0.3714524507522583,
0.15313951671123505,
0.053479425609111786,
0.6840454339981079,
0.6860948801040649,
-0.6511402130126953,
0.47159042954444885,
0.2698817253112793,
-0.015761669725179672,
0.28171390295028687,
-0.6918520927429199,
0.2414035201072693,
-0.40582090616226196,
0.2900986075401306,
-1.0807390213012695,
-0.5891206860542297,
0.05203666165471077,
-0.6112071871757507,
0.13789720833301544,
-0.26999732851982117,
-0.6572320461273193,
-0.03889673575758934,
-0.5684872269630432,
0.2242637425661087,
0.2630714178085327,
-0.7190197706222534,
0.7319415807723999,
0.10266869515180588,
-0.01730680651962757,
-0.3289065659046173,
-0.8177550435066223,
0.3823853135108948,
-0.23130740225315094,
-1.1188048124313354,
0.2805233597755432,
0.0934082418680191,
-0.2561068534851074,
-0.21076954901218414,
-0.15458987653255463,
-0.43545350432395935,
-0.0056596240028738976,
-0.3591563403606415,
0.1596963256597519,
-0.20063495635986328,
0.35500311851501465,
0.1201326847076416,
-0.02346871793270111,
-0.08920268714427948,
-0.29954057931900024,
0.7414770722389221,
-0.1601145714521408,
-0.3262096643447876,
-0.15019917488098145,
0.6054651737213135,
-0.15278390049934387,
-0.37299594283103943,
0.7014036774635315,
0.2991528809070587,
-0.2876291871070862,
-0.17873017489910126,
-0.594906747341156,
-0.38502195477485657,
-0.4781128466129303,
0.33793607354164124,
-0.5117496848106384,
-1.0729265213012695,
0.3965822458267212,
-0.20411713421344757,
-0.14269934594631195,
0.5403032898902893,
0.251625120639801,
0.05151614174246788,
1.3764536380767822,
0.6268357634544373,
0.3551984131336212,
0.2168729305267334,
-0.05486645549535751,
-0.014476608484983444,
-0.5286961197853088,
-0.026390302926301956,
-0.7251754999160767,
0.20917053520679474,
-0.8156552314758301,
-0.6562235951423645,
0.13417872786521912,
0.08075348287820816,
-0.048066724091768265,
0.5067022442817688,
-0.6079150438308716,
0.6199678778648376,
0.22841492295265198,
0.2570231854915619,
0.2880345284938812,
0.23143334686756134,
0.00750303827226162,
-0.15184389054775238,
-0.5782691836357117,
-0.4860991835594177,
0.9771592617034912,
0.259044885635376,
0.6369711756706238,
0.3008304536342621,
0.6721833348274231,
0.041611265391111374,
-0.3458458185195923,
-0.35209670662879944,
0.4705561101436615,
-0.24037767946720123,
-0.5541644096374512,
-0.4356516897678375,
-0.5595496892929077,
-1.0503041744232178,
0.4230498969554901,
-0.13464011251926422,
-0.7499344944953918,
0.5780068635940552,
0.19666792452335358,
0.11995754390954971,
0.16359497606754303,
-0.8995500802993774,
0.6463685035705566,
0.21531707048416138,
-0.4305521547794342,
0.12228371202945709,
-0.8827143311500549,
0.029384270310401917,
0.04643269255757332,
-0.10122305899858475,
0.035719871520996094,
-0.4532783329486847,
0.21414291858673096,
-0.5967915058135986,
0.8538430333137512,
-0.12012610584497452,
-0.15096941590309143,
0.30177372694015503,
-0.15589416027069092,
0.8049571514129639,
0.13166789710521698,
-0.23147553205490112,
-0.3231765627861023,
-0.15398946404457092,
-0.7399190068244934,
-0.8516228199005127,
0.32240721583366394,
-0.4244142770767212,
-0.7553262710571289,
-0.2975367307662964,
-0.7150323390960693,
-0.8495821952819824,
-0.011205959133803844,
0.20317868888378143,
0.32432931661605835,
0.06801510602235794,
0.20561350882053375,
0.8074222207069397,
-0.32584279775619507,
0.1742963045835495,
0.22947722673416138,
-0.10126578062772751,
-0.5668073892593384,
0.7329323887825012,
-0.18400956690311432,
0.4655718207359314,
0.3925586938858032,
0.3229219615459442,
-0.5798177719116211,
-0.3854328989982605,
-0.7293720245361328,
-0.07197478413581848,
-0.7973281741142273,
-0.11023356020450592,
-0.8772225379943848,
0.2548777759075165,
-0.8909623622894287,
0.10679810494184494,
-0.026276051998138428,
-0.8583332300186157,
-0.3040701746940613,
0.055869411677122116,
0.43845951557159424,
0.39082515239715576,
0.2610315680503845,
0.2200220823287964,
-0.6424715518951416,
0.47102639079093933,
0.4457530975341797,
0.44010820984840393,
-0.5010260939598083,
-0.6429715156555176,
0.22147692739963531,
0.23595057427883148,
-0.10854834318161011,
-1.0647070407867432,
0.14526410400867462,
0.3356935381889343,
0.38655292987823486,
-0.1414870172739029,
0.10505231469869614,
0.8760905265808105,
-0.31566962599754333,
1.075066089630127,
0.13678017258644104,
-0.7999205589294434,
0.885104775428772,
-0.4742516875267029,
0.5045743584632874,
0.8962607383728027,
0.18641787767410278,
-0.13680024445056915,
-0.5317498445510864,
-0.605876624584198,
-0.9555524587631226,
0.5787293314933777,
0.2535117566585541,
0.5965648889541626,
-0.04649144783616066,
0.26624637842178345,
0.19194304943084717,
0.0029480778612196445,
-0.5709909200668335,
0.10178657621145248,
-0.35674533247947693,
-0.08126868307590485,
0.19155770540237427,
-0.1105002835392952,
0.057592038065195084,
-0.5682538151741028,
0.3278268575668335,
-0.3698669970035553,
-0.2238091379404068,
0.3344113528728485,
-0.20428098738193512,
0.11834901571273804,
0.6229132413864136,
0.363834023475647,
0.6858848929405212,
-0.09669795632362366,
0.20039375126361847,
0.7052060961723328,
-0.34658554196357727,
-0.08949604630470276,
0.25612473487854004,
-0.21836210787296295,
0.15944713354110718,
0.1769673377275467,
0.6514346599578857,
-0.28106310963630676,
-0.881344199180603,
0.3438185453414917,
-0.05005064234137535,
0.02819722704589367,
0.10116252303123474,
0.2475510835647583,
-0.1195022389292717,
-0.033002305775880814,
0.13286487758159637,
0.014379825443029404,
0.44181060791015625,
-0.5828801989555359,
0.27910134196281433,
0.30567964911460876,
-0.3087352514266968,
0.11380952596664429,
0.3939841687679291,
-0.11942791193723679,
-0.15156503021717072,
0.2911456823348999,
-0.12894663214683533,
-0.3933119475841522,
0.6332355737686157,
0.7714269161224365,
0.7042570114135742,
-0.10247255861759186,
0.08448965102434158,
0.22315390408039093,
0.28993773460388184,
0.21987856924533844,
0.6111631989479065,
-0.2325764149427414,
-0.5792716145515442,
-0.5005043148994446,
-0.506337583065033,
-0.6111507415771484,
-0.24703705310821533,
-0.5678424835205078,
0.4690232276916504,
-0.4382687509059906,
-0.1218114122748375,
-0.036620959639549255,
-0.037026312202215195,
-0.26713210344314575,
0.4984864890575409,
-0.4245679974555969,
1.070730209350586,
-0.5403147339820862,
0.715918779373169,
1.1782506704330444,
-0.5644447207450867,
-0.5933371782302856,
0.1409379541873932,
-0.5926802754402161,
-0.3828943073749542,
0.2878660261631012,
0.25696486234664917,
0.06617694348096848,
-0.13975219428539276,
-0.6279696226119995,
-0.7135691046714783,
0.4765489101409912,
0.5300835967063904,
-0.20441964268684387,
0.0330422967672348,
0.9803453087806702,
0.8315762281417847,
-0.4015793204307556,
0.026538744568824768,
0.7234774827957153,
0.38018620014190674,
0.19927380979061127,
-0.4580710828304291,
-0.11994647234678268,
-0.23896893858909607,
0.2592439651489258,
0.49089664220809937,
0.03452124819159508,
0.8543886542320251,
-0.06427256762981415,
-0.09629165381193161,
0.028640873730182648,
0.6126972436904907,
0.21718573570251465,
0.258664071559906,
0.6854158043861389,
0.6291306614875793,
0.7339349985122681,
-0.045152757316827774,
1.1717702150344849,
-0.02244473434984684,
0.19913223385810852,
1.3878625631332397,
-0.22819821536540985,
0.6871421337127686,
0.5801510214805603,
-0.1863064020872116,
0.5485411286354065,
0.6110210418701172,
-0.1849512904882431,
0.23654286563396454,
0.31114786863327026,
-0.4013974666595459,
-0.47794467210769653,
-0.30245620012283325,
-0.46012964844703674,
0.3854762315750122,
0.2075740396976471,
-0.18586088716983795,
-0.6688271164894104,
0.004552348982542753,
-0.18791159987449646,
0.5836833715438843,
0.00028435199055820704,
1.151852011680603,
-0.406532347202301,
-0.4653586447238922,
0.6190044283866882,
-0.023802805691957474,
0.4106144607067108,
-0.5973480939865112,
-0.2691969871520996,
-0.24285000562667847,
-0.04244507476687431,
-0.19167402386665344,
-0.7083510160446167,
0.5902254581451416,
0.25200366973876953,
-0.36448201537132263,
0.1284254938364029,
0.872871994972229,
-0.4073778986930847,
-0.6046801209449768,
0.09640553593635559,
0.2344687581062317,
0.08991721272468567,
-0.2682971656322479,
-0.4497511684894562,
-0.060229960829019547,
-0.0024664499796926975,
0.06750822067260742,
0.31220051646232605,
0.3798040449619293,
-0.09845910966396332,
0.5408921241760254,
0.7967231273651123,
0.06737907975912094,
0.423711895942688,
0.09609314799308777,
1.2740858793258667,
-0.5492051839828491,
-0.4852764308452606,
-0.6738223433494568,
0.6668169498443604,
-0.5783095955848694,
-0.4924207925796509,
0.7046703696250916,
0.7125005722045898,
0.7072849869728088,
-0.09515036642551422,
0.3459828197956085,
-0.04411672055721283,
0.8366847038269043,
-0.3284114897251129,
0.20209790766239166,
-0.5889749526977539,
0.4615156054496765,
-0.22592757642269135,
-0.9845909476280212,
-0.44285520911216736,
0.20341046154499054,
-0.30243954062461853,
-0.11052874475717545,
0.49742892384529114,
0.9127013087272644,
0.031831663101911545,
0.34333616495132446,
0.2649332284927368,
-0.09756975620985031,
0.3166975975036621,
0.30439990758895874,
0.9075565934181213,
-0.44650399684906006,
0.5584455728530884,
-0.42207810282707214,
-0.15576520562171936,
0.2791420817375183,
-0.7107023596763611,
-0.6364225149154663,
-0.4466315805912018,
-0.2469358891248703,
-0.39365482330322266,
0.20526178181171417,
0.9047002792358398,
0.42568206787109375,
-0.9569087624549866,
0.04030846059322357,
-0.469081848859787,
0.03121103346347809,
0.14081503450870514,
-0.27195197343826294,
0.26239144802093506,
-1.0331344604492188,
-0.6238473057746887,
0.6070238351821899,
0.05682644248008728,
0.04279816150665283,
0.09527088701725006,
0.3518492877483368,
-0.3891374468803406,
0.19174377620220184,
0.49621081352233887,
0.03657526522874832,
-0.5035951733589172,
-0.33290407061576843,
0.09438377618789673,
0.0985594391822815,
0.30398908257484436,
0.5011908411979675,
-0.8141747713088989,
0.5838553309440613,
0.639801025390625,
1.1434341669082642,
0.4321998953819275,
0.322933167219162,
0.6205878853797913,
-1.0070947408676147,
0.05955564230680466,
0.48095545172691345,
0.06422196328639984,
0.6106210350990295,
-0.39051979780197144,
0.5764820575714111,
0.32647716999053955,
-0.19565711915493011,
-0.8634803891181946,
0.47675564885139465,
-0.8821616768836975,
-0.3754119277000427,
1.1027443408966064,
0.11082446575164795,
-0.15146513283252716,
-0.39794987440109253,
-0.28131672739982605,
0.01970835216343403,
-0.03968999534845352,
0.5455790758132935,
0.5607605576515198,
-0.2930382788181305,
-0.03233907371759415,
-0.13898013532161713,
0.4540879726409912,
0.9484610557556152,
-1.1604223251342773,
0.2551076412200928,
0.5483399033546448,
0.43025729060173035,
0.15450097620487213,
0.1287137269973755,
-0.16112415492534637,
0.44402772188186646,
0.019060101360082626,
-0.2568624019622803,
0.31616920232772827,
-0.1642598956823349,
-0.6380454301834106,
0.2701338231563568,
0.08713077008724213,
-0.1471502184867859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08644v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08644v3 | Tandem Transformers for Inference Efficient LLMs | 2024-02-13T18:24:08 | 2024-03-26T11:13:56 | Aishwarya P S, Pranav Ajit Nair, Yashas Samaga, Toby Boyd, Sanjiv Kumar, Prateek Jain, Praneeth Netrapalli | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The autoregressive nature of conventional large language models (LLMs)
inherently limits inference speed, as tokens are generated sequentially. While
speculative and parallel decoding techniques attempt to mitigate this, they
face limitations: either relying on less accurate smaller models for generation
or failing to fully leverage the base LLM's representations.
We introduce a novel architecture, Tandem transformers, to address these
issues. This architecture uniquely combines (1) a small autoregressive model
and (2) a large model operating in block mode (processing multiple tokens
simultaneously). The small model's predictive accuracy is substantially
enhanced by granting it attention to the large model's richer representations.
On the PaLM2 pretraining dataset, a tandem of PaLM2-Bison and PaLM2-Gecko
demonstrates a 3.3% improvement in next-token prediction accuracy over a
standalone PaLM2-Gecko, offering a 1.16x speedup compared to a PaLM2-Otter
model with comparable downstream performance. We further incorporate the tandem
model within the speculative decoding (SPEED) framework where the large model
validates tokens from the small model. This ensures that the Tandem of
PaLM2-Bison and PaLM2-Gecko achieves substantial speedup (around 1.14x faster
than using vanilla PaLM2-Gecko in SPEED) while maintaining identical downstream
task accuracy. | [
-0.24480193853378296,
-0.7105499505996704,
0.48979219794273376,
0.591654360294342,
-0.4115496277809143,
0.5280343890190125,
-0.19767890870571136,
-0.6929010152816772,
0.30807361006736755,
0.6164337396621704,
-0.3132810890674591,
-0.2937893569469452,
-0.7617253065109253,
0.07819361239671707,
-0.8398211002349854,
0.6367629766464233,
-0.07477392256259918,
0.0854598879814148,
0.13737739622592926,
-0.10692675411701202,
-0.26940008997917175,
-0.5442134141921997,
-0.6783779859542847,
-0.16515593230724335,
0.3498081862926483,
0.5067929625511169,
0.9046094417572021,
0.6975929737091064,
0.2999036908149719,
0.3314196765422821,
0.20839908719062805,
0.36728236079216003,
-0.2901778221130371,
0.09402305632829666,
0.10994601249694824,
-0.5294572114944458,
-0.3410904109477997,
-0.09635321795940399,
0.7862995266914368,
0.7686581611633301,
-0.0034210113808512688,
0.16876578330993652,
-0.07594147324562073,
0.5984746217727661,
-0.6749418377876282,
0.06315245479345322,
-0.5938190221786499,
-0.06013397499918938,
-0.3848404586315155,
-0.09368719905614853,
-0.8223252296447754,
-0.16329053044319153,
-0.1457752138376236,
-0.5442058444023132,
0.4935663640499115,
0.3744566738605499,
0.470262736082077,
0.30395519733428955,
-0.5018054246902466,
-0.00580004183575511,
-0.9430745244026184,
0.8106638789176941,
-0.49083346128463745,
0.5348986387252808,
0.030151603743433952,
0.2658368647098541,
-0.044733159244060516,
-1.0632200241088867,
-0.7548752427101135,
-0.03922174498438835,
-0.1843278557062149,
0.16677816212177277,
-0.1699448525905609,
0.011014348827302456,
0.06781116873025894,
0.3951359689235687,
-0.4511353075504303,
0.3905176818370819,
-0.1370651125907898,
-0.28964748978614807,
0.6133347153663635,
0.3442031741142273,
-0.11258365958929062,
-0.0541558600962162,
-0.514191746711731,
-0.21760603785514832,
-0.5488638281822205,
-0.3128998577594757,
0.5819933414459229,
0.21518567204475403,
-0.2274879664182663,
0.456926554441452,
0.14543329179286957,
0.6101154685020447,
0.27807411551475525,
0.1685032844543457,
0.21531076729297638,
-0.524987518787384,
-0.05972152575850487,
0.02932049334049225,
0.8824557065963745,
0.11834057420492172,
0.026291439309716225,
-0.4337511658668518,
-0.303639680147171,
0.20396670699119568,
0.14290402829647064,
-0.6679911613464355,
-0.3255593478679657,
0.3154769241809845,
-0.42899173498153687,
-0.1597847193479538,
0.11944640427827835,
-0.7399473786354065,
-0.1254902333021164,
-0.18346312642097473,
0.24078045785427094,
-0.37605035305023193,
-0.38927727937698364,
0.34719499945640564,
-0.23358385264873505,
0.17311502993106842,
0.15140953660011292,
-1.2893916368484497,
0.700778067111969,
0.8260565996170044,
1.0359368324279785,
-0.484811395406723,
-0.354350209236145,
-0.8141904473304749,
0.3012523651123047,
-0.39117035269737244,
0.9571099877357483,
-0.43031299114227295,
-0.6033884882926941,
-0.2346063256263733,
-0.1500072032213211,
-0.23818059265613556,
-0.3343205153942108,
0.6366182565689087,
-0.8590747714042664,
-0.11100423336029053,
-0.07076548039913177,
-0.5575456619262695,
0.019348755478858948,
-0.4092954993247986,
-0.8068649768829346,
1.052281379699707,
0.004247007891535759,
-0.8299942016601562,
0.4285310208797455,
-0.4169410467147827,
-0.6752079129219055,
-0.01738647185266018,
-0.08568280190229416,
-0.3096502721309662,
0.25003916025161743,
0.3176799416542053,
0.39576074481010437,
-0.5021898746490479,
0.2769653797149658,
-0.5081763863563538,
-0.5936546325683594,
-0.11427374184131622,
-0.6643264889717102,
0.5326368808746338,
0.1249769777059555,
-0.209178164601326,
0.19309236109256744,
-0.7393190860748291,
-0.29327547550201416,
0.07147141546010971,
-0.22254712879657745,
-0.21984657645225525,
0.090139240026474,
0.25122907757759094,
-0.08026662468910217,
0.28524836897850037,
-0.5086353421211243,
0.12092679738998413,
-0.3844980299472809,
0.17075353860855103,
0.7661070823669434,
-0.18205265700817108,
0.7185356616973877,
-0.09728963673114777,
0.3920263350009918,
0.3034372627735138,
0.13190563023090363,
-0.002908367197960615,
-0.4456760287284851,
-0.8503241539001465,
-0.28563037514686584,
0.31987735629081726,
0.47815704345703125,
-0.8690181374549866,
0.5628698468208313,
-0.43425261974334717,
-0.48615387082099915,
-0.39519622921943665,
0.23366814851760864,
0.3105027675628662,
0.39626380801200867,
0.31988102197647095,
-0.4883870482444763,
-0.7195132374763489,
-0.9588596820831299,
-0.4149605631828308,
-0.2113923877477646,
0.12395419180393219,
-0.0875474289059639,
0.3281171917915344,
-0.09521028399467468,
0.7582313418388367,
-0.24263668060302734,
0.2796265184879303,
-0.3820566236972809,
0.448017418384552,
0.37836015224456787,
0.568783700466156,
0.3944844603538513,
-0.7725045084953308,
-0.5543336272239685,
-0.14600569009780884,
-0.5816066861152649,
-0.026028061285614967,
-0.19776400923728943,
-0.09557737410068512,
0.48303085565567017,
0.3595871031284332,
-0.6987317800521851,
0.15408927202224731,
0.7595688104629517,
-0.2719489336013794,
0.6369037628173828,
-0.3938138782978058,
-0.08770488947629929,
-1.0418055057525635,
-0.07055334746837616,
-0.0016210144385695457,
-0.3371618986129761,
-0.5475550889968872,
-0.17405177652835846,
0.30935466289520264,
0.40165814757347107,
-0.263410747051239,
0.5519807934761047,
-0.561974287033081,
-0.5589098930358887,
-0.36250317096710205,
-0.08171823620796204,
0.030387548729777336,
0.09916935861110687,
0.1992388218641281,
1.3062381744384766,
0.5648701786994934,
-0.5502666234970093,
0.2331235110759735,
0.1668100357055664,
-0.33880671858787537,
-0.10060128569602966,
-0.6918696165084839,
0.28407809138298035,
0.07764236629009247,
0.6222522854804993,
-0.8880417346954346,
-0.24635308980941772,
0.046452414244413376,
-0.25385549664497375,
0.45199868083000183,
0.02202708087861538,
-1.07137131690979,
-0.7787466049194336,
-0.20340435206890106,
0.5170586705207825,
0.7110288739204407,
-0.9281585812568665,
0.8676698207855225,
0.3174947202205658,
0.12220356613397598,
-0.867021381855011,
-0.8397714495658875,
0.03605850040912628,
-0.14900526404380798,
-0.7398057579994202,
0.41221919655799866,
0.19481490552425385,
-0.18156717717647552,
-0.07843328267335892,
-0.12964704632759094,
0.16899994015693665,
0.030557289719581604,
0.3118222951889038,
0.4894745349884033,
-0.38414496183395386,
-0.016859564930200577,
0.2569453716278076,
-0.4313027858734131,
0.009321263991296291,
-0.6858992576599121,
0.7236055135726929,
-0.3190944790840149,
-0.32006707787513733,
-0.36892935633659363,
0.40962451696395874,
0.6005832552909851,
-0.1913883537054062,
1.0452710390090942,
0.8097137212753296,
0.03480851650238037,
-0.20532310009002686,
-0.8858755230903625,
-0.17590832710266113,
-0.5166136026382446,
0.08306528627872467,
-0.4594060480594635,
-0.8067921996116638,
0.7078614234924316,
0.028943663462996483,
0.0012894326355308294,
0.5206655263900757,
0.6759120225906372,
0.21668939292430878,
1.0615776777267456,
0.4166470766067505,
-0.25551939010620117,
0.3013054430484772,
-0.24339957535266876,
0.18139958381652832,
-0.7220680713653564,
-0.09251995384693146,
-0.2857547104358673,
-0.15605057775974274,
-0.42611798644065857,
-0.6771422028541565,
0.2392389178276062,
0.2787003219127655,
-0.2281990349292755,
0.5136519074440002,
-0.2771235406398773,
0.3988792896270752,
0.9084072709083557,
0.1319362074136734,
0.5480890870094299,
0.13578329980373383,
-0.25976818799972534,
0.2990201711654663,
-0.8645281791687012,
-0.5336135625839233,
1.3846213817596436,
0.2821935713291168,
0.6453999876976013,
0.08257484436035156,
0.6916660666465759,
0.3412124216556549,
0.46601518988609314,
-0.465783953666687,
0.5801252126693726,
-0.4519827961921692,
-0.5808382034301758,
-0.030168332159519196,
-0.341032475233078,
-0.7109391093254089,
0.28469884395599365,
-0.08292263001203537,
-0.8042965531349182,
0.08959992974996567,
0.32739847898483276,
-0.5087388753890991,
0.4620477557182312,
-0.9157595634460449,
0.5821372270584106,
-0.21642348170280457,
-0.8341213464736938,
-0.5950731039047241,
-0.7599701285362244,
0.7462477684020996,
-0.4467881917953491,
-0.07647235691547394,
0.048169687390327454,
-0.2123791128396988,
0.6192535161972046,
-0.5565483570098877,
0.7892295718193054,
-0.16119997203350067,
-0.06762976199388504,
0.39479953050613403,
-0.07515762001276016,
0.7849102020263672,
0.09202378243207932,
-0.46865734457969666,
0.31928229331970215,
-0.12939509749412537,
-0.5215216875076294,
-0.5261025428771973,
0.7187511324882507,
-0.8541834354400635,
-0.7712634801864624,
-0.2759423851966858,
-0.7037829160690308,
-0.35210171341896057,
0.05182868242263794,
0.2034139633178711,
0.34772786498069763,
0.11349187046289444,
-0.15755301713943481,
0.20210158824920654,
-0.011761569418013096,
0.5667043328285217,
0.48630213737487793,
-0.07298994064331055,
-0.23317255079746246,
0.6495701670646667,
-0.22344131767749786,
0.45908334851264954,
0.4153553545475006,
-0.06596730649471283,
-0.7801229953765869,
-0.8693304061889648,
-0.5407398343086243,
0.2615470588207245,
-0.725766658782959,
-0.02040025033056736,
-0.8686776757240295,
-0.12616918981075287,
-0.4477863311767578,
0.019209500402212143,
-0.4561019241809845,
-0.5981982946395874,
-0.3249025046825409,
-0.08392057567834854,
0.4409790635108948,
0.6762934327125549,
-0.36134928464889526,
0.5900755524635315,
-1.108260154724121,
0.4473218619823456,
0.15542080998420715,
0.15394552052021027,
0.07928624004125595,
-0.6430020332336426,
-0.2384401261806488,
-0.19477440416812897,
-0.12016643583774567,
-0.619853138923645,
0.4804314970970154,
-0.14259009063243866,
0.4126308560371399,
0.3006112575531006,
0.025744056329131126,
0.8380019664764404,
-0.5024901032447815,
0.7005993723869324,
0.3189435303211212,
-1.0345165729522705,
0.09351484477519989,
-0.18439634144306183,
-0.03558919578790665,
0.4957422614097595,
0.15355731546878815,
-0.2396731674671173,
-0.3474813997745514,
-0.6282039284706116,
-0.8234575986862183,
0.8475142121315002,
0.140786275267601,
-0.030312422662973404,
-0.17502076923847198,
0.24842463433742523,
0.42758241295814514,
0.060567304491996765,
-0.312917023897171,
-0.306368887424469,
-0.012919910252094269,
-0.19014239311218262,
-0.4016517698764801,
-0.3054386079311371,
0.16933785378932953,
-0.3333239257335663,
0.6641227006912231,
-0.20546403527259827,
0.2946726381778717,
-0.06286151707172394,
-0.15397299826145172,
-0.15769582986831665,
-0.13040791451931,
0.3160134255886078,
0.2113935798406601,
-0.1578756868839264,
0.32376888394355774,
0.36872178316116333,
-0.38709867000579834,
0.16816513240337372,
0.37450459599494934,
0.15410897135734558,
0.08802615106105804,
0.4988883137702942,
0.8394564986228943,
0.45286333560943604,
-0.49982038140296936,
0.32155656814575195,
-0.10307764261960983,
-0.032085664570331573,
-0.48306015133857727,
0.04774858430027962,
0.17558574676513672,
0.45405814051628113,
0.33454349637031555,
0.5096296668052673,
0.10587769746780396,
-0.1861940324306488,
0.33600327372550964,
0.32411518692970276,
0.23807978630065918,
-0.3494427800178528,
0.9299574494361877,
0.2656068205833435,
-0.12135722488164902,
0.6056454181671143,
-0.16577737033367157,
-0.3646774888038635,
0.7246624231338501,
0.6701917052268982,
0.924213171005249,
-0.008463423699140549,
-0.03317803889513016,
0.25820040702819824,
0.010788545943796635,
-0.542881429195404,
0.12807203829288483,
-0.40591999888420105,
-0.9151427149772644,
-0.6107620596885681,
-0.9034525752067566,
-0.3520403504371643,
-0.26588743925094604,
-0.7402815818786621,
0.04057222604751587,
-0.36739832162857056,
-0.072137251496315,
0.034455686807632446,
-0.00036368699511513114,
-0.7116700410842896,
-0.13617227971553802,
0.32085511088371277,
1.1781415939331055,
-0.7805363535881042,
1.3525880575180054,
0.22731691598892212,
-0.15341225266456604,
-0.9675117135047913,
0.013651963323354721,
-0.09504389762878418,
-1.1298589706420898,
0.9777801632881165,
0.2529553472995758,
-0.418874055147171,
0.23780949413776398,
-0.1620904803276062,
-0.9245815873146057,
1.1968028545379639,
0.2507651746273041,
-0.829659640789032,
-0.22975337505340576,
0.22905507683753967,
0.42698702216148376,
-0.2882533371448517,
0.41945308446884155,
0.9972399473190308,
0.48371627926826477,
0.2865171730518341,
-0.9005889892578125,
0.07888393849134445,
-0.023764433339238167,
0.16757671535015106,
0.35660192370414734,
-0.8143235445022583,
0.8481153249740601,
-0.2757143974304199,
-0.34076520800590515,
0.41175782680511475,
0.9727596044540405,
0.3698311448097229,
0.12245312333106995,
0.7023465633392334,
0.48837968707084656,
0.6168580055236816,
-0.04946335777640343,
1.3178565502166748,
-0.7846612334251404,
0.2967461943626404,
1.187596321105957,
-0.44600799679756165,
0.9742214679718018,
0.6496861577033997,
-0.13636581599712372,
0.5423757433891296,
0.4879848062992096,
0.07323537021875381,
0.392652690410614,
-0.08287233114242554,
-0.5871975421905518,
-0.5831182599067688,
0.20667290687561035,
-0.1727697253227234,
0.43314477801322937,
0.5828363299369812,
-0.5365884900093079,
-0.15364305675029755,
-0.13383735716342926,
-0.3313237130641937,
0.01235844474285841,
-0.12555837631225586,
0.33618998527526855,
0.12079118192195892,
-0.8383944034576416,
0.47412142157554626,
0.2271905243396759,
0.8377598524093628,
-0.5435965657234192,
0.32957586646080017,
-0.12812194228172302,
0.4826866388320923,
0.004340993240475655,
-0.7151334285736084,
0.40931886434555054,
-0.07586341351270676,
-0.0204561036080122,
-0.3551011085510254,
0.6853475570678711,
-0.1742551326751709,
-0.7284829616546631,
0.6517033576965332,
0.455669105052948,
0.0052199638448655605,
0.07998648285865784,
-0.5307384133338928,
0.31911879777908325,
-0.2671707570552826,
-0.27691712975502014,
-0.06946492940187454,
0.16272279620170593,
0.043497126549482346,
0.6068260073661804,
0.7923489809036255,
0.09716137498617172,
0.36617591977119446,
0.2995283901691437,
0.8295778036117554,
-0.6295186281204224,
-0.4237512946128845,
-0.921626627445221,
0.2475222647190094,
-0.18812595307826996,
-0.034242190420627594,
0.932853102684021,
0.8282121419906616,
0.6378156542778015,
-0.13514943420886993,
0.7374088168144226,
0.20270733535289764,
0.3786078095436096,
-0.6877278685569763,
0.3414734899997711,
-0.37558332085609436,
0.5056670904159546,
0.15554960072040558,
-0.7334585785865784,
-0.2119940221309662,
0.21223598718643188,
-0.5131966471672058,
-0.05416898429393768,
0.6669490933418274,
0.818352460861206,
-0.19385211169719696,
0.5114479064941406,
0.24698394536972046,
0.29087644815444946,
0.239914208650589,
0.759724497795105,
0.8539382219314575,
-0.5067152380943298,
0.45271286368370056,
-0.37135425209999084,
-0.03635646775364876,
-0.24236366152763367,
-0.6048172116279602,
-0.9357935190200806,
-0.3638142943382263,
-0.06516427546739578,
-0.39624273777008057,
0.07413999736309052,
0.8197820782661438,
0.930438756942749,
-0.7196075320243835,
-0.2442905753850937,
-0.6620455384254456,
-0.16375833749771118,
-0.1372445523738861,
-0.23946164548397064,
0.33867794275283813,
-0.45793646574020386,
-0.9669391512870789,
0.5782732963562012,
0.40848445892333984,
0.11231891065835953,
-0.30141350626945496,
-0.15893742442131042,
0.05220843479037285,
0.06842038035392761,
0.5448194742202759,
0.23406419157981873,
-0.7841014862060547,
-0.3782290816307068,
-0.23102407157421112,
-0.06077677011489868,
-0.02282017655670643,
1.014560341835022,
-1.024355173110962,
0.21043826639652252,
0.353731632232666,
0.6877194046974182,
0.9533824920654297,
0.06711583584547043,
0.7963003516197205,
-0.5403611660003662,
0.5398252010345459,
0.24204356968402863,
0.5289120674133301,
0.22659677267074585,
-0.25593090057373047,
0.2651771306991577,
0.4050706923007965,
-0.28516554832458496,
-0.6612566709518433,
0.318782240152359,
-1.0795143842697144,
-0.22103606164455414,
1.1193058490753174,
0.027897775173187256,
-0.34863516688346863,
-0.16865505278110504,
0.1782246083021164,
0.48287269473075867,
-0.33940228819847107,
0.4914243519306183,
0.4143999218940735,
-0.03990356996655464,
-0.13878078758716583,
-0.31854134798049927,
0.11619562655687332,
0.7408737540245056,
-0.6319937705993652,
0.18265098333358765,
0.2837158441543579,
0.14225156605243683,
0.10038560628890991,
0.45672282576560974,
-0.012485321611166,
0.21260827779769897,
0.5458259582519531,
-0.18660451471805573,
-0.10422311723232269,
-0.4413839876651764,
-0.13968344032764435,
0.19081544876098633,
-0.09840884804725647,
-0.30684730410575867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08638v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08638v5 | SemRel2024: A Collection of Semantic Textual Relatedness Datasets for 13 Languages | 2024-02-13T18:04:53 | 2024-05-31T15:57:58 | Nedjma Ousidhoum, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Mohamed Abdalla, Idris Abdulmumin, Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Sanchit Ahuja, Alham Fikri Aji, Vladimir Araujo, Abinew Ali Ayele, Pavan Baswani, Meriem Beloucif, Chris Biemann, Sofia Bourhim, Christine De Kock, Genet Shanko Dekebo, Oumaima Hourrane, Gopichand Kanumolu, Lokesh Madasu, Samuel Rutunda, Manish Shrivastava, Thamar Solorio, Nirmal Surange, Hailegnaw Getaneh Tilaye, Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Genta Winata, Seid Muhie Yimam, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring and quantifying semantic relatedness is central to representing
language and holds significant implications across various NLP tasks. While
earlier NLP research primarily focused on semantic similarity, often within the
English language context, we instead investigate the broader phenomenon of
semantic relatedness. In this paper, we present \textit{SemRel}, a new semantic
relatedness dataset collection annotated by native speakers across 13
languages: \textit{Afrikaans, Algerian Arabic, Amharic, English, Hausa, Hindi,
Indonesian, Kinyarwanda, Marathi, Moroccan Arabic, Modern Standard Arabic,
Spanish,} and \textit{Telugu}. These languages originate from five distinct
language families and are predominantly spoken in Africa and Asia -- regions
characterised by a relatively limited availability of NLP resources. Each
instance in the SemRel datasets is a sentence pair associated with a score that
represents the degree of semantic textual relatedness between the two
sentences. The scores are obtained using a comparative annotation framework. We
describe the data collection and annotation processes, challenges when building
the datasets, baseline experiments, and their impact and utility in NLP. | [
-0.6072315573692322,
-0.2816319167613983,
0.3845500648021698,
0.28927111625671387,
-0.3464379608631134,
-0.27293381094932556,
-0.3799108862876892,
-0.6776288151741028,
0.34383106231689453,
0.687412679195404,
-0.6740196943283081,
-0.5946647524833679,
-0.46242180466651917,
0.5360769033432007,
-0.15483707189559937,
1.0417476892471313,
-0.09648074209690094,
0.025414472445845604,
-0.2988920509815216,
-0.8214641213417053,
-0.3754010796546936,
-0.6547280550003052,
-0.12073230743408203,
-0.3401189148426056,
0.7611557245254517,
0.2153661549091339,
0.6672858595848083,
0.28898924589157104,
1.0518341064453125,
0.2474612444639206,
-0.012810817919671535,
0.19615299999713898,
-0.31763696670532227,
0.457357794046402,
-0.5826693177223206,
-0.28665968775749207,
-0.16218766570091248,
-0.3294951617717743,
0.393049031496048,
0.5702469348907471,
0.5459380149841309,
0.3357049524784088,
-0.027168523520231247,
0.5742676854133606,
-0.4822729527950287,
0.04314740002155304,
-0.5490186810493469,
-0.11276095360517502,
-0.6269121170043945,
-0.4278164505958557,
-0.16087627410888672,
-0.030036482959985733,
0.053317274898290634,
-0.4418005347251892,
0.47276169061660767,
-0.03335867449641228,
0.9899888038635254,
0.36445707082748413,
-0.4451788067817688,
-0.5026831030845642,
-0.32990211248397827,
0.6285838484764099,
-0.5876600742340088,
0.2085808664560318,
0.7386747598648071,
0.28799059987068176,
0.14823803305625916,
-0.48204484581947327,
-0.3944287598133087,
0.20143620669841766,
-0.44442620873451233,
0.04749653860926628,
0.10554637759923935,
-0.5483673214912415,
0.09757064282894135,
0.10604666918516159,
-0.7853222489356995,
-0.1488162875175476,
-0.019108068197965622,
-0.2865782678127289,
0.557193398475647,
0.03428412601351738,
0.42796820402145386,
-0.4725637137889862,
-0.5047262907028198,
-0.10340967029333115,
-0.8565754294395447,
-0.5217211842536926,
0.31092023849487305,
0.43381467461586,
-0.2678338289260864,
0.6596007943153381,
-0.22634071111679077,
0.767247200012207,
-0.7660788297653198,
0.15200532972812653,
0.6695666909217834,
-0.7146641612052917,
0.3620535135269165,
0.05402199923992157,
0.8201707601547241,
0.5364084243774414,
0.5198389291763306,
-0.20699888467788696,
-0.08443543314933777,
0.41818875074386597,
-0.19698050618171692,
-0.3209381103515625,
-0.05243207886815071,
-0.11353332549333572,
-0.3554143011569977,
-0.009619071148335934,
-0.07334284484386444,
-0.47848615050315857,
-0.2956351935863495,
-0.4054687023162842,
0.353251576423645,
-0.5088425874710083,
-0.1737678498029709,
-0.03438903018832207,
-0.09303230047225952,
0.4638393521308899,
-0.05451792851090431,
-0.5377984046936035,
0.3558814525604248,
0.9942216873168945,
0.764671266078949,
-0.2710482180118561,
-0.5813624858856201,
-0.13504965603351593,
0.1505022644996643,
0.010245099663734436,
1.0803987979888916,
-0.7443065047264099,
-0.2623484432697296,
-0.058970946818590164,
0.20258013904094696,
-0.12768377363681793,
-0.58841472864151,
0.7493926882743835,
-0.4760358929634094,
0.012333614751696587,
-0.2795458137989044,
-0.38055846095085144,
-0.29686281085014343,
0.36960434913635254,
-0.7531831860542297,
1.0670979022979736,
-0.016845613718032837,
-1.125138282775879,
0.37179017066955566,
-0.19953468441963196,
-0.5611414909362793,
0.14978401362895966,
-0.21758489310741425,
-0.12676994502544403,
0.044563669711351395,
0.11200600862503052,
0.6028950214385986,
-0.3554649353027344,
0.24544349312782288,
-0.21296490728855133,
-0.18632721900939941,
0.28682804107666016,
-0.1893487572669983,
0.5848435759544373,
0.36386337876319885,
-0.11652421951293945,
0.0032771648839116096,
-0.8931336998939514,
-0.08644293993711472,
0.010364764370024204,
0.15745972096920013,
-0.9083570241928101,
-0.3213942348957062,
0.3828479051589966,
0.48781028389930725,
0.3962786793708801,
-0.5022241473197937,
-0.41189059615135193,
-0.3756978511810303,
0.268549382686615,
0.29309597611427307,
0.2961159348487854,
0.17761485278606415,
-0.4060750901699066,
0.31859973073005676,
-0.0871959775686264,
-0.269818514585495,
-0.4547420144081116,
-0.4903225600719452,
-0.8064380288124084,
0.017099734395742416,
0.33395230770111084,
0.5623551607131958,
-0.5084145069122314,
0.30295583605766296,
-0.7067916989326477,
-0.44868722558021545,
-0.41815176606178284,
0.16055084764957428,
0.453848272562027,
0.26098930835723877,
0.3821699619293213,
-0.17007695138454437,
-0.7159170508384705,
-1.0718334913253784,
-0.2177397906780243,
-0.08182304352521896,
0.10180795937776566,
0.29114606976509094,
0.6289673447608948,
-0.2994559407234192,
0.521151065826416,
-0.1866079717874527,
-0.657108724117279,
0.020592303946614265,
-0.13006925582885742,
0.09782534837722778,
0.2531438171863556,
0.5973541140556335,
-0.6591724753379822,
-0.5478692650794983,
0.28300613164901733,
-0.8427166938781738,
-0.144073948264122,
0.18870769441127777,
-0.3938915431499481,
0.35558512806892395,
0.6592922210693359,
-0.011543843895196915,
0.28833770751953125,
0.6667660474777222,
-0.47734901309013367,
-0.08002591878175735,
-0.13640518486499786,
-0.020432444289326668,
-1.443570852279663,
0.260893851518631,
-0.14648810029029846,
-0.14988964796066284,
-0.19094377756118774,
0.10974328219890594,
-0.042743489146232605,
-0.08299341052770615,
-0.46561819314956665,
0.7677128314971924,
-0.276040256023407,
-0.0538569875061512,
-0.1007625013589859,
0.4618840217590332,
-0.16278688609600067,
0.22705122828483582,
0.3595525920391083,
0.7422022223472595,
0.15203441679477692,
-0.37505921721458435,
0.24788883328437805,
0.5843032002449036,
-0.21206209063529968,
0.8144411444664001,
-0.6604626178741455,
-0.12870372831821442,
-0.08401694893836975,
0.08214657008647919,
-0.6992138028144836,
-0.12883052229881287,
-0.12572865188121796,
-0.580193042755127,
-0.19619418680667877,
0.06437298655509949,
-0.4901779294013977,
0.16189676523208618,
-0.21098098158836365,
0.4723705053329468,
0.12041807919740677,
-0.17465688288211823,
0.5173025727272034,
0.40102818608283997,
-0.4483230710029602,
-0.4884127676486969,
-0.8289689421653748,
0.27581310272216797,
-0.28837594389915466,
-0.7846070528030396,
0.1397942155599594,
0.325529009103775,
-0.4028380215167999,
0.2756439447402954,
0.29257628321647644,
0.14883846044540405,
0.08615689724683762,
0.4444371163845062,
0.04348558932542801,
-0.21312591433525085,
0.37803345918655396,
-0.28795361518859863,
-0.46027612686157227,
-0.011198466643691063,
0.07249873131513596,
0.7313624024391174,
-0.19957754015922546,
-0.2523994445800781,
0.10344395786523819,
0.3530246913433075,
-0.09373912215232849,
-0.4127937853336334,
0.8328709006309509,
0.7234799861907959,
-0.3208342492580414,
0.0524492971599102,
-0.540580689907074,
-0.1658550202846527,
-0.3220602869987488,
0.15612459182739258,
-0.6844536662101746,
-0.8535415530204773,
0.767311692237854,
0.07316553592681885,
-0.055885396897792816,
0.7864781022071838,
0.5327853560447693,
0.1372239589691162,
0.42838433384895325,
0.3924061059951782,
-0.05345562845468521,
0.15209153294563293,
-0.1610322892665863,
0.09152621775865555,
-0.7653965353965759,
-0.2710660994052887,
-0.8982462286949158,
-0.2069389373064041,
-1.0471196174621582,
-0.7024630904197693,
-0.12296943366527557,
-0.4121968150138855,
-0.2987678050994873,
0.8579090237617493,
-0.014842082746326923,
0.4727705717086792,
0.43146267533302307,
-0.30213820934295654,
0.4503926634788513,
0.13854362070560455,
-0.2622632682323456,
-0.35172057151794434,
-0.555302083492279,
-0.6741069555282593,
0.8066281676292419,
-0.05575535073876381,
0.5047011971473694,
0.39740827679634094,
0.885259747505188,
0.2660268247127533,
0.025475122034549713,
-0.3497348129749298,
0.5388023257255554,
-0.15862809121608734,
-0.6007614135742188,
-0.10166126489639282,
-0.31196892261505127,
-1.0138112306594849,
-0.040206149220466614,
-0.3472147285938263,
-0.699606716632843,
0.0336112342774868,
-0.3922326862812042,
0.2859955132007599,
-0.2519913911819458,
-0.39966896176338196,
0.7010611295700073,
-0.10901285707950592,
-0.4376198351383209,
-0.055786680430173874,
-1.1552411317825317,
-0.04568301513791084,
-0.22529561817646027,
0.3958115875720978,
-0.6597455739974976,
-0.24392344057559967,
0.706242561340332,
-0.4814433455467224,
0.6574920415878296,
0.3944445252418518,
-0.13196656107902527,
0.11245859414339066,
0.18996071815490723,
0.18692311644554138,
0.11263490468263626,
-0.3937355875968933,
0.24009700119495392,
0.27545055747032166,
-0.49985912442207336,
-0.4196901023387909,
1.1473664045333862,
-0.623131513595581,
0.07360216975212097,
-0.7817457318305969,
-0.5079066157341003,
-0.2764050364494324,
0.4469737410545349,
0.2242739200592041,
0.4695385992527008,
-0.25562626123428345,
0.16752400994300842,
0.3132655918598175,
-0.1781640350818634,
0.4046567976474762,
0.6157529354095459,
-0.22513678669929504,
-0.5092086791992188,
1.2206734418869019,
-0.027353042736649513,
0.034042347222566605,
0.6566701531410217,
-0.07881907373666763,
-0.43561673164367676,
-0.0327901653945446,
-0.14574547111988068,
0.6411970853805542,
-0.7286209464073181,
-0.2575284242630005,
-0.7046716213226318,
-0.23961099982261658,
-0.27495571970939636,
-0.2810611426830292,
-0.006093274336308241,
-0.5781019330024719,
0.04424208775162697,
-0.06832852959632874,
0.6540453433990479,
0.6894427537918091,
0.015157287009060383,
0.007042355369776487,
-0.8219496607780457,
0.18457305431365967,
-0.1049332469701767,
0.17954663932323456,
-0.18498408794403076,
-0.38023701310157776,
0.007781528402119875,
-0.24640050530433655,
0.11455709487199783,
-0.5130174160003662,
0.25496047735214233,
0.5414764285087585,
0.3974827826023102,
0.13829027116298676,
0.3593407869338989,
0.4937077462673187,
-0.5898349285125732,
0.6853909492492676,
-0.060593381524086,
-0.6887131333351135,
0.6435762643814087,
-0.46967634558677673,
0.3894481062889099,
1.053723931312561,
0.5717968344688416,
-0.88863605260849,
-0.36427587270736694,
-0.7624108791351318,
-1.151585340499878,
0.4153304696083069,
0.4980778694152832,
0.30179500579833984,
-0.398501992225647,
-0.1919221729040146,
0.13057787716388702,
-0.06765855103731155,
-0.32294243574142456,
-0.26868921518325806,
0.14986328780651093,
-0.5205114483833313,
-0.6056363582611084,
-0.2688513696193695,
-0.1385289430618286,
0.21373723447322845,
0.8395214676856995,
-0.10299288481473923,
0.08490286022424698,
0.16116991639137268,
-0.36964818835258484,
0.3881901204586029,
0.30665087699890137,
0.48314064741134644,
0.6348029375076294,
-0.11594215780496597,
0.5978877544403076,
0.3518163859844208,
-0.5293440818786621,
0.02103656344115734,
0.24524430930614471,
-0.2007390260696411,
0.2546410858631134,
0.7950620651245117,
0.5531845092773438,
0.3405458927154541,
-0.7451611161231995,
0.5320355892181396,
-0.09626692533493042,
0.12389080971479416,
-0.5495296120643616,
-0.34132152795791626,
0.3707977831363678,
-0.099341981112957,
0.002628169022500515,
0.00866776704788208,
0.22049738466739655,
-0.22480395436286926,
0.39685723185539246,
0.2342580407857895,
-0.9757492542266846,
-0.33379265666007996,
0.2587462067604065,
0.26552724838256836,
-0.25178441405296326,
0.312776118516922,
-0.010823204182088375,
-0.5111052393913269,
0.3830314576625824,
0.5122346878051758,
0.4398021399974823,
0.08793545514345169,
0.2640974819660187,
0.47424834966659546,
0.19733336567878723,
0.2047167867422104,
0.45598646998405457,
0.035145506262779236,
-0.8330523371696472,
-0.42090368270874023,
-0.8264061212539673,
-0.16269448399543762,
-0.2346201241016388,
-0.7791750431060791,
0.5422740578651428,
-0.015470917336642742,
-0.12723203003406525,
0.17058834433555603,
-0.07488029450178146,
-0.7935209274291992,
0.1530960500240326,
-0.02103729359805584,
0.7195342779159546,
-0.9547415971755981,
0.42507538199424744,
0.9811795949935913,
-0.41739797592163086,
-0.667752206325531,
-0.29169970750808716,
0.10879290103912354,
-0.8178064227104187,
0.6460521221160889,
0.1801958978176117,
-0.05117953568696976,
-0.0705762505531311,
0.03980884701013565,
-0.6115013360977173,
0.8434498906135559,
0.04543554037809372,
-0.31547918915748596,
0.29695984721183777,
0.38965046405792236,
0.8190440535545349,
-0.2852964401245117,
0.32845303416252136,
0.6628161072731018,
0.24854178726673126,
-0.05003415420651436,
-0.6713333129882812,
0.046621136367321014,
-0.6672684550285339,
0.14457644522190094,
0.603056788444519,
-0.6148409247398376,
0.36968737840652466,
0.07567144930362701,
-0.10509359836578369,
0.15158134698867798,
0.5239049792289734,
0.14045490324497223,
0.4454320967197418,
0.1206558421254158,
0.7125476002693176,
0.5079771280288696,
-0.14876458048820496,
0.8492624759674072,
-0.614844799041748,
0.2880605459213257,
1.5577574968338013,
-0.5727766752243042,
1.0161396265029907,
0.5751966834068298,
-0.04990342631936073,
0.2979363203048706,
0.3845679759979248,
0.08697804063558578,
0.33412519097328186,
0.16098791360855103,
-0.4828963279724121,
-0.09260093420743942,
-0.8855491876602173,
-0.5654242038726807,
0.43271926045417786,
0.35372665524482727,
-0.6560556292533875,
-0.47034892439842224,
-0.07191967964172363,
0.2472699135541916,
0.5418678522109985,
0.08806400001049042,
1.103092908859253,
0.2096143513917923,
-0.3642657399177551,
0.22881381213665009,
-0.3030000925064087,
0.5018208026885986,
-0.5999065637588501,
-0.08618602901697159,
-0.10568923503160477,
0.14648035168647766,
-0.2387406826019287,
-0.808124303817749,
0.575825035572052,
0.010909765027463436,
-0.09499287605285645,
0.1919069141149521,
0.843131959438324,
-0.44725704193115234,
-0.6162493228912354,
0.5751907229423523,
0.7879534363746643,
0.3291705846786499,
0.26637354493141174,
-0.37298959493637085,
0.1254138946533203,
-0.16853661835193634,
0.1750125139951706,
0.21139876544475555,
0.6408137679100037,
-0.43176522850990295,
0.4686242938041687,
0.5196130275726318,
0.16830448806285858,
-0.011494742706418037,
0.26928627490997314,
0.7107115983963013,
-0.7810858488082886,
-0.18150201439857483,
-0.6416191458702087,
-0.023718101903796196,
-0.15993008017539978,
-0.6972691416740417,
1.1373064517974854,
0.7590140700340271,
1.21852445602417,
-0.026897290721535683,
0.8219727873802185,
-0.08262836933135986,
0.8782819509506226,
-0.4046258330345154,
0.6115644574165344,
-0.3263455927371979,
0.2664795517921448,
-0.5203873515129089,
-1.3079578876495361,
-0.5755661725997925,
0.7398298978805542,
-0.49895113706588745,
-0.30285245180130005,
0.8496651649475098,
0.8331426382064819,
-0.057820841670036316,
0.1403818577528,
0.34376972913742065,
-0.17266888916492462,
-0.16221167147159576,
0.46782049536705017,
0.721219003200531,
-0.7056720852851868,
0.26429834961891174,
-0.4626287817955017,
0.2860713303089142,
-0.07693222910165787,
-0.7920344471931458,
-0.8909280896186829,
-0.832298755645752,
-0.12499107420444489,
-0.4443848133087158,
0.1599317193031311,
0.9483923316001892,
0.1116727963089943,
-0.9707253575325012,
-0.12776918709278107,
-0.017066199332475662,
-0.13901276886463165,
0.10483308881521225,
-0.16850155591964722,
0.4495738446712494,
-0.19793446362018585,
-0.37166517972946167,
-0.04633308947086334,
0.1566111147403717,
0.12466958165168762,
-0.055498018860816956,
-0.18927814066410065,
-0.5147432088851929,
-0.03340248391032219,
0.5118721723556519,
0.14733904600143433,
-0.463204950094223,
-0.24778997898101807,
-0.00880295131355524,
-0.250508576631546,
-0.3349480628967285,
0.7007415294647217,
-0.712235152721405,
0.3687349259853363,
0.7948451638221741,
0.6929154992103577,
0.30014288425445557,
-0.010045310482382774,
0.4240412414073944,
-0.5940418243408203,
0.5287593603134155,
0.2981626093387604,
0.37204110622406006,
0.7631635069847107,
0.08400144428014755,
1.1910170316696167,
-0.01753690093755722,
-0.5745273232460022,
-0.5610187649726868,
0.29438838362693787,
-0.929643452167511,
0.1384696513414383,
1.3115707635879517,
-0.3693940043449402,
-0.36943477392196655,
-0.43854284286499023,
-0.31406310200691223,
-0.0034957730676978827,
-0.07341282814741135,
0.19596916437149048,
0.6656460165977478,
0.20007145404815674,
0.11960840225219727,
-0.36451953649520874,
0.37374192476272583,
0.49511370062828064,
-0.6893606781959534,
-0.20552411675453186,
0.31781911849975586,
0.15277016162872314,
0.47145575284957886,
0.369864821434021,
-0.22053004801273346,
0.04674418643116951,
0.04391128197312355,
-0.015373492613434792,
0.2409178614616394,
-0.17291846871376038,
-0.25806596875190735,
-0.14244697988033295,
0.055326566100120544,
0.1968790739774704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08631v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08631v2 | Knowledge Editing on Black-box Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T17:59:34 | 2024-02-17T16:06:10 | Xiaoshuai Song, Zhengyang Wang, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Yutao Mou, Jinxu Zhao, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge editing (KE) aims to efficiently and precisely modify the behavior
of large language models (LLMs) to update specific knowledge without negatively
influencing other knowledge. Current research primarily focuses on white-box
LLMs editing, overlooking an important scenario: black-box LLMs editing, where
LLMs are accessed through interfaces and only textual output is available. In
this paper, we first officially introduce KE on black-box LLMs and then propose
a comprehensive evaluation framework to overcome the limitations of existing
evaluations that are not applicable to black-box LLMs editing and lack
comprehensiveness. To tackle privacy leaks of editing data and style
over-editing in current methods, we introduce a novel postEdit framework,
resolving privacy concerns through downstream post-processing and maintaining
textual style consistency via fine-grained editing to original responses.
Experiments and analysis on two benchmarks demonstrate that postEdit
outperforms all baselines and achieves strong generalization, especially with
huge improvements on style retention (average $+20.82\%\uparrow$). | [
-0.0746055617928505,
-0.9330013990402222,
0.7731622457504272,
0.14033553004264832,
-0.16261889040470123,
0.2452758401632309,
-0.6477065682411194,
-0.5488391518592834,
0.06320594251155853,
0.6565638184547424,
-0.24712060391902924,
-0.8835813999176025,
-0.7724228501319885,
-0.14474983513355255,
-0.3624103367328644,
0.8036760091781616,
-0.13837383687496185,
-0.21581420302391052,
-0.138898566365242,
-0.11323019117116928,
-0.46022164821624756,
-0.47779011726379395,
-0.6446502804756165,
-0.047935787588357925,
0.4631718397140503,
0.29517224431037903,
0.8489012718200684,
0.57230144739151,
0.38484686613082886,
0.3347468078136444,
-0.5352556109428406,
0.1728937327861786,
-0.6879650354385376,
0.005774965044111013,
-0.6023255586624146,
-0.32652050256729126,
-0.6587815284729004,
-0.4407365918159485,
0.7896655201911926,
0.4827112853527069,
-0.023447511717677116,
0.1643121987581253,
0.22795362770557404,
0.6664532423019409,
-0.8702491521835327,
0.051689766347408295,
-0.7121861577033997,
-0.11796847730875015,
-0.09508869051933289,
-0.11619006842374802,
-0.4226469099521637,
-0.3859860599040985,
0.10421591252088547,
-0.6314188241958618,
-0.010489042848348618,
-0.19809868931770325,
0.6289235353469849,
0.1666835993528366,
-0.21875302493572235,
-0.12359533458948135,
-0.9562780857086182,
0.60170978307724,
-0.8196812868118286,
0.7621914744377136,
0.4107052683830261,
0.18970441818237305,
-0.14482665061950684,
-0.637030303478241,
-0.5172893404960632,
-0.06734668463468552,
-0.13679271936416626,
-0.08106737583875656,
-0.30981263518333435,
0.12893438339233398,
0.2680736482143402,
0.4742080271244049,
-0.28642919659614563,
0.14958496391773224,
-0.4172682464122772,
-0.20451077818870544,
0.8483850955963135,
-0.06538469344377518,
0.101949542760849,
-0.14488691091537476,
-0.125388041138649,
0.0715741515159607,
-0.7801827192306519,
-0.041334327310323715,
0.44305098056793213,
-0.0761030837893486,
-0.09971439093351364,
0.7284703254699707,
-0.6247738599777222,
0.5395879745483398,
0.010616322048008442,
-0.020719632506370544,
0.053405243903398514,
-0.2977280914783478,
-0.3297441005706787,
-0.08791956305503845,
0.7747117280960083,
0.7579935789108276,
0.19703248143196106,
-0.40531298518180847,
-0.3055129945278168,
-0.23531757295131683,
0.35156068205833435,
-0.7601438760757446,
0.030277185142040253,
0.26564398407936096,
-0.48242509365081787,
-0.43016231060028076,
0.07137659192085266,
-0.9967103600502014,
-0.625336229801178,
-0.38609665632247925,
0.624573290348053,
-0.34128081798553467,
-0.3050617575645447,
0.47617271542549133,
0.05932586267590523,
-0.08978693187236786,
0.6757459044456482,
-0.7033215761184692,
0.18032720685005188,
0.9157750606536865,
0.759114146232605,
-0.05307707563042641,
-0.21684518456459045,
-0.39821651577949524,
0.4019809663295746,
-0.3172345459461212,
0.5686033964157104,
-0.7259454727172852,
-0.3915446698665619,
0.13862648606300354,
0.04011288285255432,
0.29353636503219604,
-0.3263237774372101,
0.15782903134822845,
-0.9209612607955933,
-0.05265475809574127,
-0.32809141278266907,
-0.6993411183357239,
-0.011251451447606087,
0.3026078939437866,
-0.3763188421726227,
0.9665963053703308,
-0.030017487704753876,
-0.7534457445144653,
0.36866533756256104,
-0.8706201910972595,
-0.32117584347724915,
-0.08412465453147888,
0.22667986154556274,
-0.36653217673301697,
0.21015475690364838,
0.20728357136249542,
0.5121053457260132,
0.17299571633338928,
0.37413161993026733,
-0.4024292528629303,
-0.45568564534187317,
0.2939154803752899,
-0.07486271858215332,
0.504974365234375,
0.11701718717813492,
-0.2615034580230713,
0.28547772765159607,
-0.9397438764572144,
-0.16968338191509247,
-0.030881281942129135,
-0.35347941517829895,
-0.6176950931549072,
-0.1912449598312378,
-0.26665565371513367,
-0.06337633728981018,
0.5200760960578918,
-0.973108172416687,
0.45659053325653076,
-0.287075400352478,
0.45924025774002075,
1.0273151397705078,
0.18376930058002472,
0.5680705904960632,
-0.17965032160282135,
0.415235698223114,
-0.18668729066848755,
0.3292018473148346,
0.050942402333021164,
-0.31894350051879883,
-0.6234739422798157,
-0.038851045072078705,
0.6353760957717896,
0.5587775707244873,
-0.7284160852432251,
0.319862425327301,
-0.29233402013778687,
-0.5928872227668762,
-0.5044164061546326,
0.3957168161869049,
0.31267040967941284,
0.09226732701063156,
0.23786316812038422,
-0.1704813539981842,
-0.32377946376800537,
-0.9384827613830566,
-0.38708916306495667,
0.07645104825496674,
-0.16960887610912323,
0.1737777590751648,
0.36962559819221497,
-0.581960141658783,
0.7978454828262329,
-0.6215528249740601,
0.0030291154980659485,
-0.0010770370718091726,
0.06781737506389618,
-0.22714126110076904,
0.5460415482521057,
0.38229286670684814,
-0.33412864804267883,
-0.251859575510025,
0.20149417221546173,
-0.7195918560028076,
-0.11852791160345078,
0.023225659504532814,
-0.41589877009391785,
0.013609381392598152,
0.6392438411712646,
-0.6813206076622009,
0.6297284960746765,
0.6345818042755127,
-0.39779937267303467,
0.5095722079277039,
-0.07271630316972733,
0.35455143451690674,
-1.0375804901123047,
-0.012729968875646591,
-0.13772396743297577,
-0.31636008620262146,
-0.5180832743644714,
0.14243915677070618,
0.3488675653934479,
-0.340624064207077,
-0.4864625334739685,
0.7549550533294678,
-0.31529200077056885,
-0.021133095026016235,
-0.21211518347263336,
-0.15040592849254608,
0.10031650960445404,
0.5578064322471619,
-0.04149240627884865,
0.675581157207489,
0.34361979365348816,
-0.4101976752281189,
0.24900449812412262,
0.2506997883319855,
-0.48955008387565613,
0.4190293848514557,
-0.6304861307144165,
0.49894261360168457,
-0.21381783485412598,
0.001988951815292239,
-0.8144262433052063,
-0.004695956129580736,
0.1639564484357834,
-0.24053572118282318,
0.3915192484855652,
-0.2369481474161148,
-0.7365442514419556,
0.01154787465929985,
-0.5415754914283752,
0.1471461057662964,
0.26146242022514343,
-0.35142555832862854,
0.44304266571998596,
0.21682900190353394,
-0.4038534164428711,
-0.6701355576515198,
-0.7038017511367798,
0.26082026958465576,
0.12590284645557404,
-0.6168512105941772,
0.25303536653518677,
-0.20043286681175232,
-0.4320293366909027,
0.27661260962486267,
-0.1357048898935318,
-0.1437031477689743,
0.11642579734325409,
-0.1672232300043106,
0.05228649824857712,
-0.22309857606887817,
0.05904197692871094,
0.3427448272705078,
-0.0349462516605854,
-0.09013012051582336,
-0.2623278796672821,
0.3393402397632599,
0.10614177584648132,
-0.38511741161346436,
-0.5637651085853577,
0.2157215029001236,
0.5048910975456238,
-0.4224057197570801,
0.7307961583137512,
0.4127240478992462,
-0.5178835391998291,
-0.24874745309352875,
-0.8715139031410217,
-0.12765894830226898,
-0.514946699142456,
0.370468407869339,
-0.2695218026638031,
-1.2607413530349731,
0.37130308151245117,
-0.025988634675741196,
0.2521219253540039,
0.16526110470294952,
0.31642624735832214,
0.012387053109705448,
0.5799752473831177,
0.9500828385353088,
0.11935824900865555,
0.6059997081756592,
-0.03318043053150177,
0.29272377490997314,
-0.7881191372871399,
0.1037151962518692,
-0.3055626451969147,
-0.3836776614189148,
-0.6759302020072937,
-0.31175148487091064,
0.1541057676076889,
0.23646382987499237,
0.026933899149298668,
0.2586176097393036,
-0.46777865290641785,
0.6075121760368347,
0.5257172584533691,
0.4201897084712982,
0.6070038676261902,
-0.1254437118768692,
0.12468595057725906,
-0.01977248676121235,
-0.35124990344047546,
-0.6548295021057129,
1.4312493801116943,
0.5457188487052917,
0.756863534450531,
0.22028158605098724,
0.6854256391525269,
0.39368870854377747,
0.44224923849105835,
-0.7117188572883606,
0.6266112327575684,
-0.20521821081638336,
-0.5068207383155823,
-0.46946582198143005,
-0.36035671830177307,
-0.6104257702827454,
0.012875134125351906,
-0.31281283497810364,
-0.9539081454277039,
0.3588933050632477,
0.31108614802360535,
-0.2688824534416199,
0.7149672508239746,
-0.8797575831413269,
0.9022646546363831,
0.09093731641769409,
-0.6913788914680481,
-0.25215351581573486,
-0.3600003123283386,
0.5028867125511169,
-0.25391432642936707,
0.22051401436328888,
0.24568282067775726,
0.027738552540540695,
0.7646679878234863,
-0.47012844681739807,
0.8118497133255005,
-0.2784694731235504,
-0.2064240276813507,
-0.002464529825374484,
0.42825987935066223,
0.5560632348060608,
0.27043312788009644,
-0.22423072159290314,
0.4831898808479309,
0.1710408478975296,
-0.32419267296791077,
-0.8500872254371643,
0.6329721212387085,
-0.5766720175743103,
-0.6913725137710571,
-0.0979664996266365,
-0.6021016240119934,
-0.48218053579330444,
0.30272001028060913,
0.04278765618801117,
0.44635772705078125,
-0.16232529282569885,
0.5081571340560913,
0.74517822265625,
-0.6106998324394226,
0.1712769865989685,
0.5877611041069031,
-0.33140993118286133,
-0.49324724078178406,
0.611160397529602,
0.25362837314605713,
0.3825012743473053,
0.5328935980796814,
0.38656917214393616,
-0.2713770270347595,
-0.9346446990966797,
-0.5387147665023804,
0.3353997468948364,
-0.6915077567100525,
-0.0637301355600357,
-0.748885989189148,
-0.27422434091567993,
-0.48513567447662354,
-0.42664027214050293,
-0.4807097613811493,
-0.4797818660736084,
0.19369833171367645,
-0.179419606924057,
0.5341210961341858,
1.0789124965667725,
-0.12907181680202484,
0.6224112510681152,
-0.735632061958313,
0.3843816816806793,
0.4678928256034851,
0.9285678267478943,
0.023458601906895638,
-0.33791205286979675,
-0.25701746344566345,
0.07039017230272293,
-0.31692466139793396,
-0.7744797468185425,
-0.16877113282680511,
-0.24743005633354187,
0.24047328531742096,
0.17955997586250305,
-0.014941858127713203,
0.6902307271957397,
-0.4567530155181885,
0.6786278486251831,
-0.19614277780056,
-1.1121337413787842,
0.4874351918697357,
-0.46474626660346985,
0.4049533009529114,
0.6334957480430603,
-0.036119863390922546,
-0.7594862580299377,
-0.6895316243171692,
-0.6482985615730286,
-0.5385644435882568,
0.6460089087486267,
0.13329261541366577,
0.1963527798652649,
0.3696902096271515,
0.4510806202888489,
0.1433173269033432,
0.6904793977737427,
-0.7190614342689514,
-0.09814828634262085,
-0.2334621101617813,
-0.14116571843624115,
0.03201178461313248,
-0.7768501043319702,
-0.006342026870697737,
-0.2801256477832794,
0.8036412000656128,
0.30606403946876526,
0.13172076642513275,
0.18079505860805511,
-0.2779589593410492,
-0.25227677822113037,
0.8065976500511169,
0.5591963529586792,
1.0888108015060425,
-0.36596235632896423,
-0.0003182122018188238,
0.26855579018592834,
-0.36789458990097046,
-0.041569631546735764,
0.1880321055650711,
-0.631571352481842,
-0.05376144498586655,
0.3141682744026184,
0.6649069786071777,
0.4269493520259857,
-0.3667881488800049,
0.5475358963012695,
-0.07844918221235275,
-0.22552907466888428,
0.07904449850320816,
0.030334310606122017,
0.11857964098453522,
0.12948615849018097,
-0.021438058465719223,
0.058713894337415695,
0.08639928698539734,
-0.5086051821708679,
0.2813930809497833,
0.3354317545890808,
-0.1253354251384735,
-0.30042946338653564,
0.7327474355697632,
0.10072331875562668,
-0.41422155499458313,
0.03958334028720856,
-0.2428283840417862,
-0.3759606182575226,
0.09359878301620483,
0.19041511416435242,
0.7797302603721619,
-0.3905423581600189,
0.11304266005754471,
0.1592954695224762,
0.541669487953186,
0.11238394677639008,
0.12092719972133636,
-0.1507178544998169,
-0.7114295363426208,
-0.5607005953788757,
-0.7833259105682373,
-0.6068517565727234,
0.6428637504577637,
-0.43003928661346436,
0.4330716133117676,
-0.9221332669258118,
0.20489224791526794,
-0.06425341963768005,
-0.14265112578868866,
-0.6164963245391846,
0.12349003553390503,
-0.10347408801317215,
0.9260402917861938,
-0.5637253522872925,
0.7255708575248718,
0.7434236407279968,
-0.0349123477935791,
-0.5019475221633911,
0.05378282070159912,
-0.008625472895801067,
-0.704116940498352,
0.09339670836925507,
-0.05628877878189087,
-0.031243223696947098,
-0.0882483720779419,
-0.48812565207481384,
-0.7641409039497375,
0.8004095554351807,
0.5076103806495667,
-0.9512564539909363,
0.07885181158781052,
0.27670779824256897,
0.5498528480529785,
0.2604837417602539,
-0.11194784939289093,
0.6359386444091797,
0.5954746007919312,
-0.06302610784769058,
-0.9336085319519043,
0.030339546501636505,
-0.18439514935016632,
-0.04725686088204384,
0.2141452431678772,
-0.630508542060852,
0.38968703150749207,
0.3203768730163574,
-0.060812290757894516,
-0.14335469901561737,
0.4627421796321869,
-0.02154107205569744,
0.26346051692962646,
0.4699752926826477,
0.7473145127296448,
0.6811461448669434,
0.13874466717243195,
0.9039829969406128,
-0.23240143060684204,
0.24267514050006866,
1.1115927696228027,
-0.23234468698501587,
0.7400020956993103,
0.22096939384937286,
-0.024901852011680603,
0.2746795117855072,
0.400747686624527,
0.09639959782361984,
0.3521828353404999,
0.05367305874824524,
-0.31154346466064453,
0.0477437749505043,
0.08049050718545914,
-0.3677971363067627,
0.45214128494262695,
0.0973629429936409,
-0.20672738552093506,
-0.13479314744472504,
-0.014748957008123398,
0.5780187845230103,
0.3092780113220215,
-0.3987351953983307,
1.0843242406845093,
-0.0171036496758461,
-0.4078950583934784,
0.3822305500507355,
0.2726621627807617,
0.7538996338844299,
-0.7031822800636292,
0.0023288775701075792,
0.070334292948246,
0.07068416476249695,
-0.2898695170879364,
-1.0048823356628418,
0.5911834239959717,
0.27792787551879883,
-0.07675056159496307,
-0.37247249484062195,
0.9574365615844727,
-0.5538500547409058,
-0.6401485204696655,
0.48594585061073303,
0.36706387996673584,
-0.23900537192821503,
-0.26345327496528625,
-0.5372735857963562,
0.3233503997325897,
-0.04341871291399002,
-0.38881462812423706,
0.19692140817642212,
0.5600314736366272,
0.012535739690065384,
0.3211623430252075,
0.7496297359466553,
0.42466437816619873,
-0.044237248599529266,
-0.03733384236693382,
0.7938229441642761,
-0.758102297782898,
-0.6312328577041626,
-0.9768511056900024,
0.6554141640663147,
-0.21433493494987488,
-0.2419947385787964,
0.5716686248779297,
0.5492094159126282,
1.0014456510543823,
-0.03989001736044884,
1.0020170211791992,
0.12911444902420044,
0.4856596291065216,
-0.7844345569610596,
0.9345540404319763,
-0.47371649742126465,
0.16005344688892365,
-0.6257776618003845,
-1.0063166618347168,
-0.37458011507987976,
0.2758825719356537,
-0.6679617166519165,
-0.3209396004676819,
0.6915950179100037,
1.004054307937622,
-0.3416883647441864,
0.09845384955406189,
0.41753101348876953,
0.5445295572280884,
0.2693672478199005,
0.259956955909729,
0.7842770218849182,
-0.32788318395614624,
0.4194628894329071,
-0.7295442223548889,
-0.1792774498462677,
0.030619053170084953,
-0.8827199339866638,
-0.9313315153121948,
-0.35241270065307617,
-0.32822850346565247,
-0.16183535754680634,
0.314339280128479,
0.6643028855323792,
0.6468275189399719,
-0.7796837091445923,
-0.1121605634689331,
0.27345892786979675,
0.2715088427066803,
-0.011835597455501556,
-0.24411235749721527,
0.4169383943080902,
0.04621623456478119,
-0.6210565567016602,
0.4289359152317047,
0.3678989112377167,
-0.10844531655311584,
-0.09890593588352203,
0.16988268494606018,
-0.04620867222547531,
0.020710142329335213,
0.8624522089958191,
-0.03474460169672966,
-0.5233761668205261,
-0.6731433272361755,
-0.3143423795700073,
0.1724381297826767,
0.17965683341026306,
0.7561404705047607,
-0.22475489974021912,
0.5982731580734253,
0.3923374116420746,
1.1453968286514282,
0.49108830094337463,
0.1450151950120926,
0.6170034408569336,
-0.9395716190338135,
0.21996591985225677,
-0.06444098055362701,
0.4725874364376068,
0.48820433020591736,
-0.6340176463127136,
0.2849096953868866,
0.20543350279331207,
-0.5399953722953796,
-0.8461720943450928,
0.017739420756697655,
-0.9361357688903809,
-0.2823435664176941,
1.4059878587722778,
0.009456833824515343,
-0.31301823258399963,
-0.030736614018678665,
-0.35478347539901733,
0.25774478912353516,
-0.5175562500953674,
0.749914824962616,
1.042186975479126,
0.33246347308158875,
-0.31067338585853577,
-0.758745014667511,
0.4516306519508362,
0.22704122960567474,
-0.7649592757225037,
0.33307740092277527,
0.6238277554512024,
0.4556273818016052,
-0.0924290120601654,
0.6191492676734924,
-0.23451071977615356,
0.34875723719596863,
-0.5486008524894714,
0.20021812617778778,
-0.3352486789226532,
-0.20493005216121674,
-0.4480530321598053,
0.17708657681941986,
0.2307637482881546,
-0.09638302028179169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08594v1 | Bayesian Multi-Task Transfer Learning for Soft Prompt Tuning | 2024-02-13T16:57:02 | 2024-02-13T16:57:02 | Haeju Lee, Minchan Jeong, Se-Young Yun, Kee-Eung Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt tuning, in which prompts are optimized to adapt large-scale
pre-trained language models to downstream tasks instead of fine-tuning the full
model parameters, has been shown to be particularly effective when the prompts
are trained in a multi-task transfer learning setting. These methods generally
involve individually training prompts for each source task and then aggregating
them to provide the initialization of the prompt for the target task. However,
this approach critically ignores the fact that some of the source tasks could
be negatively or positively interfering with each other. We argue that when we
extract knowledge from source tasks via training source prompts, we need to
consider this correlation among source tasks for better transfer to target
tasks. To this end, we propose a Bayesian approach where we work with the
posterior distribution of prompts across source tasks. We obtain representative
source prompts corresponding to the samples from the posterior utilizing Stein
Variational Gradient Descent, which are then aggregated to constitute the
initial target prompt. We show extensive experimental results on the standard
benchmark NLP tasks, where our Bayesian multi-task transfer learning approach
outperforms the state-of-the-art methods in many settings. Furthermore, our
approach requires no auxiliary models other than the prompt itself, achieving a
high degree of parameter efficiency. | [
-0.23587368428707123,
-0.6535319089889526,
0.8066391348838806,
0.27941232919692993,
-0.11860626190900803,
-0.3878518342971802,
-0.32054054737091064,
0.09072685986757278,
-0.34650030732154846,
0.510801374912262,
-1.1585793495178223,
-0.3980160653591156,
-0.7383350729942322,
0.08104614168405533,
0.07165070623159409,
1.2493382692337036,
0.3218570649623871,
-0.1552807241678238,
0.17841312289237976,
0.03204146400094032,
-0.8956979513168335,
-0.1929621547460556,
-0.9408891201019287,
0.037591468542814255,
0.8311125636100769,
0.4642498195171356,
0.2576487064361572,
0.24041052162647247,
0.43620315194129944,
0.23739485442638397,
0.12944281101226807,
0.42014527320861816,
-0.12213492393493652,
0.3608708679676056,
-0.6096853017807007,
-0.5193358063697815,
0.036320313811302185,
-0.07377995550632477,
0.5858429074287415,
0.9526578187942505,
-0.14129553735256195,
0.04600994288921356,
0.24300140142440796,
0.5343216061592102,
-0.8909957408905029,
0.3684871792793274,
-0.6191821694374084,
-0.0614037960767746,
-0.021254602819681168,
-0.26471951603889465,
-0.49303510785102844,
-0.3896022439002991,
0.3416235148906708,
-0.7454855442047119,
0.6209672689437866,
-0.05889744311571121,
0.3034727871417999,
0.25964006781578064,
-0.6862106919288635,
-0.1168474406003952,
-0.5140894651412964,
0.7188791632652283,
-0.6376504302024841,
0.0023187343031167984,
0.26860153675079346,
0.2326725423336029,
-0.33050379157066345,
-0.31355828046798706,
-0.45276859402656555,
-0.3762701451778412,
-0.08390729129314423,
0.25027039647102356,
-0.18064261972904205,
0.03536573052406311,
0.4377310276031494,
-0.19966086745262146,
-0.6837436556816101,
0.08269096165895462,
-0.27359846234321594,
-0.06757169216871262,
0.5046685338020325,
0.03966851532459259,
0.2692503333091736,
-0.1149434819817543,
-0.4339568018913269,
-0.4150160253047943,
-0.43886464834213257,
0.20483388006687164,
0.12235376238822937,
1.0066734552383423,
-0.06312521547079086,
0.3281184434890747,
-0.08610410988330841,
1.0536736249923706,
0.23069283366203308,
-0.1417822539806366,
0.13264554738998413,
-0.4183632731437683,
0.0932900682091713,
-0.017486240714788437,
0.7905692458152771,
0.18775829672813416,
0.17536714673042297,
-0.16373537480831146,
0.00531688192859292,
-0.00396387092769146,
0.4628745913505554,
-0.5201056599617004,
-0.1865973174571991,
-0.16328983008861542,
-0.3597995936870575,
0.03741275519132614,
0.08352991938591003,
-0.7955934405326843,
-0.5739568471908569,
-0.6568261981010437,
0.7793693542480469,
-0.44346457719802856,
-0.27645644545555115,
-0.05232003703713417,
-0.3472707271575928,
-0.060142990201711655,
0.2860662341117859,
-1.0957989692687988,
0.009950833395123482,
0.5036103129386902,
0.8390920162200928,
-0.3829774260520935,
-0.4398859739303589,
-1.1257898807525635,
0.27927008271217346,
-0.4059828519821167,
0.9551533460617065,
-0.4102158546447754,
-0.4550479054450989,
0.2619791328907013,
0.3470262885093689,
-0.39820945262908936,
-0.2597845494747162,
0.5494925379753113,
-0.10574119538068771,
0.2600705623626709,
-0.4967648684978485,
-0.30304262042045593,
-0.3100259304046631,
-0.2295076549053192,
-0.555063784122467,
0.7672334909439087,
0.4231082499027252,
-0.44202443957328796,
0.45244529843330383,
-0.5175356864929199,
-0.8115439414978027,
-0.11016415059566498,
0.02884000539779663,
-0.05710930749773979,
0.3674619495868683,
0.5989516973495483,
0.8202226758003235,
-0.22613094747066498,
0.4667261242866516,
-0.4087814688682556,
-0.19238805770874023,
0.20842556655406952,
-0.5626834630966187,
0.846780002117157,
0.2836826741695404,
-0.39992305636405945,
0.2951643466949463,
-0.8134086728096008,
-0.38001886010169983,
-0.36392056941986084,
0.011111479252576828,
-0.4441325068473816,
-0.2158365249633789,
-0.12386568635702133,
0.20492888987064362,
0.07433833926916122,
-0.31418001651763916,
0.4728798568248749,
-0.3411668837070465,
0.14608906209468842,
0.8393760323524475,
0.14059749245643616,
0.6980206370353699,
-0.5797361135482788,
0.46226340532302856,
0.1341305524110794,
0.06555044651031494,
-0.36993610858917236,
-0.6056566834449768,
-0.3293209969997406,
-0.21955958008766174,
0.08050542324781418,
0.7147531509399414,
-0.7675132751464844,
0.4586765766143799,
-0.10748325288295746,
-0.4688686728477478,
-0.525489091873169,
0.05682065710425377,
0.11888318508863449,
0.8747898936271667,
0.45484215021133423,
-0.06591862440109253,
0.10440493375062943,
-0.864396333694458,
-0.4130461812019348,
-0.13521765172481537,
-0.21448683738708496,
0.3094716966152191,
0.0520855188369751,
0.14479686319828033,
0.8180397748947144,
-0.5148832201957703,
-0.3099778890609741,
-0.15193094313144684,
0.7374132871627808,
0.721890926361084,
0.8624297380447388,
0.5673798322677612,
-0.6721064448356628,
-0.5623770356178284,
0.021827591583132744,
-0.28513991832733154,
-0.4613201320171356,
-0.6477888226509094,
-0.27752137184143066,
-0.05225025489926338,
0.4652405083179474,
-0.7886026501655579,
0.0865713506937027,
0.4170162081718445,
-0.3229633867740631,
0.5984982848167419,
-0.3361227214336395,
0.4034045934677124,
-1.3821370601654053,
0.23041711747646332,
0.38299137353897095,
0.025498023256659508,
-0.5395386219024658,
-0.3156382143497467,
0.17993022501468658,
-0.14811424911022186,
-0.2951451539993286,
0.5983555316925049,
-0.38521674275398254,
0.13819560408592224,
-0.42216911911964417,
-0.048974160104990005,
-0.028329145163297653,
0.7677311301231384,
0.18002423644065857,
0.8773357272148132,
0.7371297478675842,
-0.7657976746559143,
0.43543025851249695,
0.23006169497966766,
-0.38583996891975403,
1.0148595571517944,
-0.5183535218238831,
-0.07611802220344543,
-0.3699333667755127,
0.08822647482156754,
-1.3107759952545166,
0.12249457836151123,
0.5213811993598938,
-0.4037993550300598,
0.5842034220695496,
-0.5111114978790283,
-0.2666567862033844,
0.1302449107170105,
0.06571819633245468,
0.0925258994102478,
0.4370187819004059,
-0.5247213244438171,
0.47100597620010376,
-0.11932174861431122,
-0.7663493752479553,
-0.6031146049499512,
-0.5180665850639343,
-0.32441598176956177,
-0.4155614674091339,
-0.31849205493927,
0.7035087943077087,
-0.11759363114833832,
0.2545359432697296,
-0.08742399513721466,
-0.1759883016347885,
-0.20570296049118042,
0.019738493487238884,
0.21952013671398163,
0.30558380484580994,
-0.18910162150859833,
0.29239559173583984,
0.5532371997833252,
-0.13868847489356995,
0.053690988570451736,
-0.34405335783958435,
-0.022587113082408905,
0.37036794424057007,
-0.3459985852241516,
-0.4960310459136963,
0.6380294561386108,
0.3127061724662781,
-0.05015139654278755,
0.8933308124542236,
1.111952781677246,
-0.12589333951473236,
-0.4073760509490967,
-0.5794819593429565,
-0.42542022466659546,
-0.44929197430610657,
0.2234441488981247,
-0.47881442308425903,
-0.8129533529281616,
0.24915403127670288,
-0.4776958227157593,
0.2255171239376068,
0.3826501965522766,
0.3268451988697052,
-0.031822867691516876,
1.2331602573394775,
0.8596218824386597,
-0.19074006378650665,
0.8473239541053772,
0.07976584136486053,
-0.11255726963281631,
-0.737663745880127,
-0.07021687179803848,
-0.8311069011688232,
-0.2353174388408661,
-0.5203954577445984,
-0.28325778245925903,
0.44255924224853516,
0.15304890275001526,
-0.46923601627349854,
0.40228214859962463,
-0.3424752950668335,
0.08600930869579315,
0.9934293031692505,
0.3063868284225464,
0.010886810719966888,
0.09076663106679916,
-0.023810625076293945,
0.05161336809396744,
-0.8455884456634521,
0.01841420866549015,
0.919231653213501,
-0.1617027372121811,
0.5791087746620178,
0.16029204428195953,
0.31689417362213135,
0.3936713635921478,
0.16511400043964386,
-0.5884425044059753,
0.19028250873088837,
-0.20946522057056427,
-0.4045729339122772,
-0.3272113800048828,
-0.7437666654586792,
-1.2593157291412354,
0.2827143371105194,
-0.34753426909446716,
-0.7645309567451477,
0.5108191967010498,
0.0525997132062912,
-0.6202643513679504,
-0.02270740643143654,
-0.7747330069541931,
1.0861330032348633,
0.022145036607980728,
-0.4695779085159302,
-0.12514331936836243,
-0.9401006698608398,
0.19659453630447388,
-0.00008653250552015379,
0.300061970949173,
-0.29716211557388306,
-0.052122462540864944,
0.7081166505813599,
0.02122313342988491,
0.9877699017524719,
-0.3753603398799896,
-0.1728702187538147,
0.04715851694345474,
0.05588812008500099,
0.6736879348754883,
0.20856331288814545,
0.009707501158118248,
-0.16669736802577972,
-0.015135837718844414,
-0.40671399235725403,
-0.8608441948890686,
0.525103747844696,
-0.6724333763122559,
-0.4380800724029541,
-0.3653872609138489,
-0.6526913642883301,
-0.5620064735412598,
0.0909528061747551,
0.3287741243839264,
0.4610300660133362,
0.20286136865615845,
-0.157125785946846,
0.6365832686424255,
-0.20495736598968506,
0.49940717220306396,
0.7130870819091797,
0.426209032535553,
-0.31838083267211914,
0.8817276954650879,
-0.20337064564228058,
0.05311722680926323,
0.4816311299800873,
0.20641276240348816,
-0.45942866802215576,
-0.4335290491580963,
-0.521583616733551,
0.23413687944412231,
-0.4797443151473999,
-0.3073986768722534,
-0.3291539251804352,
0.0761694386601448,
-0.6018912196159363,
-0.16259725391864777,
-0.16353030502796173,
-0.1892002373933792,
-0.6306771636009216,
0.23028583824634552,
0.3532385230064392,
0.24747303128242493,
-0.17491616308689117,
0.8260442018508911,
-1.309187889099121,
0.32577821612358093,
0.4678696393966675,
0.09988130629062653,
-0.31292182207107544,
-0.8806067705154419,
-0.013113186694681644,
-0.016567746177315712,
-0.15421923995018005,
-1.2765743732452393,
0.4716075658798218,
0.35792112350463867,
0.8669512271881104,
0.37804004549980164,
0.25678521394729614,
0.5033249258995056,
-0.47719672322273254,
0.7504859566688538,
0.4765072464942932,
-0.914781391620636,
0.9207497835159302,
-0.5421003103256226,
0.4377410113811493,
0.7613540291786194,
0.7235709428787231,
-0.45522087812423706,
-0.022132636979222298,
-0.45206934213638306,
-0.5696075558662415,
0.847395122051239,
-0.21051165461540222,
0.14116443693637848,
0.016812672838568687,
0.4368598461151123,
0.5662260055541992,
0.3147224187850952,
-0.44615891575813293,
-0.07377271354198456,
0.19709426164627075,
-0.37565961480140686,
-0.38005855679512024,
0.07810953259468079,
0.004583061207085848,
-0.18197748064994812,
0.5731238126754761,
-0.5694992542266846,
0.2107643336057663,
0.10737619549036026,
-0.169541135430336,
-0.047480180859565735,
0.3395347595214844,
0.4093717634677887,
0.7550953030586243,
-0.07918385416269302,
0.1267835944890976,
0.0963410958647728,
-0.1687021553516388,
0.26028284430503845,
0.3223225176334381,
0.0013665047008544207,
0.08674104511737823,
0.34852123260498047,
1.0491394996643066,
0.2951122522354126,
-0.39967289566993713,
0.7104191184043884,
0.17430008947849274,
-0.2532254755496979,
0.2329048067331314,
0.30015960335731506,
-0.17466890811920166,
0.5363267064094543,
0.23481157422065735,
0.4545297622680664,
0.3902871906757355,
-0.4966571629047394,
0.1126037985086441,
0.4839378297328949,
-0.3700483441352844,
-0.29469287395477295,
0.36802807450294495,
0.06436245888471603,
-0.14971289038658142,
0.8026126623153687,
-0.05580029636621475,
-0.2319377064704895,
0.4220412075519562,
0.7136446237564087,
0.858435332775116,
-0.4990442395210266,
0.5262458324432373,
0.5974622964859009,
0.23344096541404724,
-0.2894487679004669,
0.24110151827335358,
-0.4080573618412018,
-0.47671958804130554,
-0.9242716431617737,
-0.5691804885864258,
-0.3739955425262451,
-0.010506205260753632,
-0.7180200815200806,
0.3283282220363617,
-0.027094649150967598,
-0.31924211978912354,
-0.03241525590419769,
-0.2945399582386017,
-0.6405236721038818,
0.03412311151623726,
0.11260182410478592,
0.5508285760879517,
-1.1249470710754395,
0.5467424988746643,
0.730061948299408,
-0.3379842936992645,
-0.638149619102478,
-0.05971516668796539,
-0.3412095606327057,
-0.5788686871528625,
0.3977646231651306,
0.13075843453407288,
0.23337426781654358,
0.17883145809173584,
-0.41095292568206787,
-0.9245334267616272,
0.6380763649940491,
0.6815195083618164,
-0.6925845742225647,
-0.028260966762900352,
-0.3004719018936157,
0.09141069650650024,
-0.15977156162261963,
0.2546387016773224,
0.46489283442497253,
0.4344373941421509,
0.08939903229475021,
-0.9159643650054932,
0.24709175527095795,
-0.17302897572517395,
0.1392124593257904,
0.12233319133520126,
-0.35895538330078125,
0.8098348379135132,
-0.2640703320503235,
-0.14516840875148773,
-0.11365155875682831,
0.7168116569519043,
0.35524874925613403,
0.1149127259850502,
0.6212320923805237,
0.02385292574763298,
0.6961713433265686,
0.10698142647743225,
0.7614164352416992,
-0.28604331612586975,
0.06274177879095078,
0.982740581035614,
-0.04728085547685623,
0.6393234729766846,
0.5111926794052124,
-0.32477036118507385,
0.5167259573936462,
0.6253674626350403,
-0.033628713339567184,
0.9158732295036316,
0.23301385343074799,
-0.321878582239151,
-0.3088894188404083,
-0.16201701760292053,
-0.34198102355003357,
0.0017752074636518955,
0.43365252017974854,
-0.25109872221946716,
-0.27359798550605774,
0.37962448596954346,
-0.2775586247444153,
-0.17849507927894592,
-0.3576183617115021,
0.9242519736289978,
0.14874356985092163,
-1.2793277502059937,
0.30359962582588196,
-0.13522814214229584,
0.7216244339942932,
-0.8643061518669128,
-0.19963689148426056,
-0.16292907297611237,
-0.05202806368470192,
0.02550782635807991,
-0.5375632047653198,
0.23212064802646637,
-0.3234335482120514,
-0.2073458880186081,
-0.39526572823524475,
0.856349527835846,
-0.5553644895553589,
-0.3814811706542969,
-0.057786788791418076,
0.8314093351364136,
-0.009348493069410324,
-0.5014615654945374,
-0.6249273419380188,
-0.44762882590293884,
-0.28531041741371155,
-0.2736321985721588,
0.5217644572257996,
0.5955610871315002,
0.26570701599121094,
0.3827177882194519,
0.8986512422561646,
0.32001161575317383,
0.10853641480207443,
0.17640358209609985,
0.5406706929206848,
-0.4926290512084961,
-0.6998618841171265,
-0.8397215008735657,
0.5956454873085022,
0.075637087225914,
-0.4978477358818054,
0.6062493324279785,
-0.06688100844621658,
0.49799659848213196,
-0.23921553790569305,
0.9266451597213745,
0.15491142868995667,
0.45979809761047363,
-0.6683391332626343,
0.30597540736198425,
-0.5047156810760498,
0.05044473335146904,
-0.4422524869441986,
-1.093569278717041,
-0.14469635486602783,
0.7686218023300171,
-0.13965384662151337,
0.14044754207134247,
0.7222498059272766,
0.6684752702713013,
-0.12587334215641022,
0.1154642403125763,
0.14107581973075867,
-0.4055824279785156,
0.07148203998804092,
0.8026691675186157,
0.8787655234336853,
0.0581432543694973,
0.46214017271995544,
-0.37512579560279846,
-0.628363847732544,
-0.12787599861621857,
-0.9838548898696899,
-0.7451173663139343,
-0.8473780155181885,
-0.4700790047645569,
-0.06715236604213715,
0.27550894021987915,
0.9332881569862366,
0.9655434489250183,
-0.7889772057533264,
-0.18889836966991425,
-0.3258942663669586,
0.05788750946521759,
-0.868091344833374,
-0.23224900662899017,
0.4927392601966858,
-1.0367906093597412,
-0.62774658203125,
0.6314430236816406,
-0.039890263229608536,
-0.07561902701854706,
-0.0027849844191223383,
0.3947450816631317,
0.012021128088235855,
-0.20258700847625732,
0.6320809721946716,
0.004570106044411659,
-0.3689040541648865,
-0.1154036819934845,
-0.022231129929423332,
0.029353603720664978,
-0.2690412998199463,
0.969980001449585,
-0.8140942454338074,
0.20051559805870056,
0.6333604454994202,
0.803600013256073,
0.562122642993927,
0.05549577996134758,
0.8235453367233276,
-0.9982566237449646,
-0.15247441828250885,
0.1009296327829361,
0.17897044122219086,
0.1027846708893776,
-0.39262819290161133,
0.30143803358078003,
0.39189013838768005,
-0.6120976805686951,
-0.5202511548995972,
0.12627637386322021,
-1.3451271057128906,
-0.6409887075424194,
1.1585693359375,
-0.34997671842575073,
-0.0658421441912651,
-0.12545271217823029,
-0.36931726336479187,
0.48122668266296387,
-0.4915804862976074,
0.7224758267402649,
0.5373005867004395,
-0.20666135847568512,
-0.35087689757347107,
-0.5876389145851135,
0.5493065118789673,
0.6794032454490662,
-0.7119438052177429,
0.09200656414031982,
0.620087206363678,
0.18559429049491882,
0.128042533993721,
0.45606791973114014,
0.467507004737854,
0.4177825450897217,
-0.037537239491939545,
-0.21865159273147583,
0.09567902982234955,
-0.5835109353065491,
-0.5106660723686218,
0.3802778720855713,
-0.16924507915973663,
-0.2930714786052704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08702v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08702v3 | PRompt Optimization in Multi-Step Tasks (PROMST): Integrating Human Feedback and Heuristic-based Sampling | 2024-02-13T16:38:01 | 2024-06-16T18:01:06 | Yongchao Chen, Jacob Arkin, Yilun Hao, Yang Zhang, Nicholas Roy, Chuchu Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.RO | Prompt optimization aims to find the best prompt to a large language model
(LLM) for a given task. LLMs have been successfully used to help find and
improve prompt candidates for single-step tasks. However, realistic tasks for
agents are multi-step and introduce new challenges: (1) Prompt content is
likely to be more extensive and complex, making it more difficult for LLMs to
analyze errors, (2) the impact of an individual step is difficult to evaluate,
and (3) different people may have varied preferences about task execution.
While humans struggle to optimize prompts, they are good at providing feedback
about LLM outputs; we therefore introduce a new LLM-driven discrete prompt
optimization framework PROMST that incorporates human-designed feedback rules
to automatically offer direct suggestions for improvement. We also use an extra
learned heuristic model that predicts prompt performance to efficiently sample
from prompt candidates. This approach significantly outperforms both
human-engineered prompts and several other prompt optimization methods across
11 representative multi-step tasks (an average 10.6\%-29.3\% improvement to
current best methods on five LLMs respectively). We believe our work can serve
as a benchmark for automatic prompt optimization for LLM-driven multi-step
tasks. Datasets and Codes are available at
https://github.com/yongchao98/PROMST. Project Page is available at
https://yongchao98.github.io/MIT-REALM-PROMST/. | [
-0.5119515061378479,
-0.6690298318862915,
0.8580906391143799,
0.3881014287471771,
-0.19579434394836426,
0.27888527512550354,
-0.173939049243927,
-0.054489925503730774,
-0.23803523182868958,
0.18939055502414703,
-1.345629334449768,
-0.4604358673095703,
-0.1796116977930069,
0.6232216954231262,
0.1093420460820198,
0.7868729829788208,
0.07581278681755066,
0.23885753750801086,
-0.16800318658351898,
0.13125097751617432,
-0.7979238629341125,
-0.29607072472572327,
-1.0917189121246338,
-0.22475822269916534,
0.7262589931488037,
0.6333093643188477,
0.3014075458049774,
0.4320482909679413,
0.30874869227409363,
0.3562797009944916,
-0.08371254056692123,
0.38395658135414124,
-0.25429314374923706,
0.44280630350112915,
-0.12246837466955185,
-0.05948380380868912,
-0.04209888353943825,
-0.03324752300977707,
0.48762065172195435,
0.4527721405029297,
-0.08730820566415787,
0.05363098531961441,
0.03364405408501625,
0.5045163631439209,
-0.5817217230796814,
0.15698900818824768,
-0.06383475661277771,
-0.12204886972904205,
0.03116970881819725,
-0.36917465925216675,
-0.5079616904258728,
-0.6097433567047119,
0.1855982393026352,
-0.6185470819473267,
0.19413156807422638,
0.20398834347724915,
0.3262021541595459,
0.5075128674507141,
-0.44896626472473145,
-0.20960332453250885,
-0.5355823040008545,
0.9498122334480286,
-0.4826408326625824,
0.25873515009880066,
0.05611196905374527,
0.40823888778686523,
-0.32279831171035767,
-0.4826880097389221,
-0.22226731479167938,
-0.4819070100784302,
0.13025672733783722,
0.09755147248506546,
-0.000507631222717464,
0.25513362884521484,
0.38663211464881897,
-0.084748275578022,
-0.5442860126495361,
0.032298266887664795,
-0.023309960961341858,
-0.38959136605262756,
0.5794832110404968,
0.4193692207336426,
0.2373664379119873,
-0.2212659865617752,
-0.5696205496788025,
-0.3323911130428314,
-0.2414880394935608,
0.5556215643882751,
0.2961517572402954,
0.6148589253425598,
0.09288053214550018,
0.2042751908302307,
-0.2896901071071625,
0.5425662994384766,
0.20039232075214386,
-0.12693579494953156,
0.30378615856170654,
-0.7163422107696533,
0.43429264426231384,
-0.12048017233610153,
0.7961639761924744,
0.34104689955711365,
-0.013834981247782707,
0.12592813372612,
-0.6072189807891846,
0.12057894468307495,
0.33683839440345764,
-0.8264156579971313,
0.13745059072971344,
0.3522045314311981,
-0.1298414021730423,
-0.2134627103805542,
-0.038425903767347336,
-0.8588585257530212,
-0.6733257174491882,
-0.6361401677131653,
0.4689495265483856,
-0.37230831384658813,
0.11619111895561218,
-0.015981527045369148,
-0.2325257956981659,
0.020000187680125237,
0.7306624054908752,
-0.45413556694984436,
0.3598111867904663,
0.7000692486763,
0.8269346356391907,
-0.4179215729236603,
-0.43993234634399414,
-1.1269440650939941,
-0.5443328619003296,
-0.39042311906814575,
1.0141688585281372,
-0.4661831855773926,
-0.5226054787635803,
-0.048296842724084854,
-0.08477237075567245,
-0.2559041380882263,
-0.23076853156089783,
1.0397562980651855,
-0.38695383071899414,
0.1074969694018364,
-0.5900195240974426,
-0.3808163106441498,
0.014210396446287632,
0.25176456570625305,
-0.7523172497749329,
1.2266151905059814,
0.2011769562959671,
-0.5432974100112915,
0.18342643976211548,
-0.95041823387146,
-0.22626303136348724,
0.12170793116092682,
-0.10358503460884094,
-0.3125726878643036,
0.18246780335903168,
0.49571484327316284,
0.18325814604759216,
-0.6497132778167725,
0.261749267578125,
0.09192056953907013,
-0.4482782483100891,
0.21821805834770203,
-0.27172815799713135,
0.7298246622085571,
0.2216222584247589,
-0.41965144872665405,
0.7207466959953308,
-0.7322415709495544,
0.06998208910226822,
-0.21185535192489624,
-0.4668232500553131,
-0.017327355220913887,
-0.03074106015264988,
-0.1454475224018097,
0.31951388716697693,
0.18904437124729156,
-0.6138551831245422,
0.18607309460639954,
-0.22925183176994324,
0.14945656061172485,
1.0572036504745483,
0.31416553258895874,
0.3839288651943207,
-0.49507007002830505,
1.0378342866897583,
-0.08014983683824539,
0.4391595125198364,
-0.6271665692329407,
-0.3297054171562195,
-0.3129175901412964,
-0.26933637261390686,
0.050262559205293655,
0.6254474520683289,
-0.851424515247345,
0.299886018037796,
0.17152079939842224,
-0.47773250937461853,
-0.5564137101173401,
-0.10458444058895111,
0.39519017934799194,
0.5959823131561279,
0.19729439914226532,
-0.09884897619485855,
-0.37157928943634033,
-0.6811714172363281,
-0.23276059329509735,
-0.04199937731027603,
0.18681921064853668,
0.2843072712421417,
0.4190082550048828,
-0.18312150239944458,
1.0101878643035889,
-0.4670252203941345,
-0.09360093623399734,
-0.3395896553993225,
0.1555805653333664,
0.4794389307498932,
0.39680904150009155,
0.16592402756214142,
-0.5706081390380859,
-0.5433700680732727,
-0.2805003225803375,
-0.19155089557170868,
-0.45749086141586304,
-0.5122687816619873,
-0.15091753005981445,
-0.05717877298593521,
0.36687415838241577,
-0.6336625814437866,
0.17172938585281372,
0.10928267985582352,
-0.46285390853881836,
0.9721695184707642,
-0.3147498667240143,
0.39330193400382996,
-0.8085977435112,
-0.08360657095909119,
0.2695639431476593,
-0.12201626598834991,
-0.5888352990150452,
0.1320577710866928,
0.16402830183506012,
-0.18451808393001556,
-0.47907447814941406,
0.7110693454742432,
-0.4704524874687195,
0.1035919189453125,
-0.30084335803985596,
-0.003430597949773073,
-0.11428677290678024,
0.8078102469444275,
-0.19635343551635742,
1.1327118873596191,
0.5877720713615417,
-0.667123019695282,
0.5255778431892395,
0.20558035373687744,
-0.006077001802623272,
0.9049127101898193,
-0.7879228591918945,
0.34768661856651306,
-0.2882358133792877,
0.2613203525543213,
-1.2308608293533325,
-0.09232347458600998,
0.1831444352865219,
-0.4780452251434326,
-0.055679801851511,
0.17452356219291687,
-0.5901084542274475,
-0.565858006477356,
-0.7968878149986267,
0.25991156697273254,
0.520095944404602,
-0.4659891426563263,
0.5755035877227783,
-0.10559429973363876,
-0.17338144779205322,
-0.4979514479637146,
0.08064848184585571,
-0.1676659733057022,
-0.12855581939220428,
-0.5375949740409851,
0.19804278016090393,
-0.5182622671127319,
-0.11297504603862762,
-0.4673093557357788,
-0.2033008635044098,
0.05548788607120514,
0.03530967980623245,
0.17090272903442383,
0.13091859221458435,
0.051043763756752014,
0.07657604664564133,
0.07010611891746521,
-0.5153787136077881,
0.16219587624073029,
-0.4060075879096985,
0.6657736301422119,
-0.0932149812579155,
-0.5124797224998474,
-0.8585471510887146,
0.38928553462028503,
0.34699293971061707,
-0.050239067524671555,
0.017497653141617775,
0.8042471408843994,
-0.20777025818824768,
-0.21639123558998108,
-0.3897952437400818,
-0.6161943674087524,
-0.5321957468986511,
0.15511372685432434,
-0.5505725741386414,
-0.66154545545578,
0.3640175461769104,
-0.3590829074382782,
0.5613090395927429,
0.3284892737865448,
0.4359988570213318,
-0.005708846729248762,
1.1886022090911865,
0.4769822955131531,
0.06935308873653412,
0.3880240023136139,
-0.08847156912088394,
-0.23273120820522308,
-0.7941789031028748,
-0.2043599933385849,
-1.0665180683135986,
-0.2975965738296509,
-0.4038252830505371,
-0.4838457405567169,
0.5695344805717468,
-0.22641895711421967,
-0.32503554224967957,
0.33310070633888245,
-0.5061019062995911,
0.3528890311717987,
1.1431176662445068,
0.15666408836841583,
0.166688472032547,
-0.22610346972942352,
-0.5066690444946289,
-0.1710793823003769,
-0.6961515545845032,
-0.2837453782558441,
0.6853530406951904,
0.16071316599845886,
0.8082594871520996,
-0.22632475197315216,
0.8329223990440369,
0.3948596715927124,
-0.3497326076030731,
-0.8257607221603394,
0.6739598512649536,
0.20423217117786407,
-0.29466328024864197,
-0.4827881455421448,
-0.3888966143131256,
-1.1744519472122192,
0.23981602489948273,
0.16545027494430542,
-0.6344605088233948,
0.13030436635017395,
0.18130213022232056,
-0.735883891582489,
-0.16002950072288513,
-0.45353636145591736,
0.7365216612815857,
-0.1399942934513092,
-0.3684271574020386,
-0.09901553392410278,
-0.9285869002342224,
-0.15543340146541595,
-0.17919911444187164,
0.37424224615097046,
-0.12412454932928085,
-0.26130184531211853,
0.5688239932060242,
-0.6527560949325562,
0.9416698217391968,
-0.43469011783599854,
-0.1285843551158905,
0.28021353483200073,
-0.07795839756727219,
0.835680365562439,
0.04741594195365906,
-0.22042851150035858,
-0.4527885913848877,
-0.02434605173766613,
-0.276201993227005,
-0.64193195104599,
0.4042638838291168,
-0.7892016172409058,
-0.5560920238494873,
-0.4062647521495819,
-0.47669410705566406,
-0.3089387118816376,
0.18150010704994202,
0.22346815466880798,
0.7469953894615173,
0.1310979127883911,
-0.2128172218799591,
0.669850766658783,
-0.22453922033309937,
0.7859503626823425,
0.2954981327056885,
0.10768305510282516,
-0.7129935622215271,
0.7475574016571045,
-0.43344634771347046,
0.06679247319698334,
0.43055999279022217,
0.5981793999671936,
-0.6424243450164795,
-0.47388696670532227,
-0.5997587442398071,
0.08466242253780365,
-0.690413236618042,
-0.1496129035949707,
-0.6352337002754211,
0.22074095904827118,
-0.4188877046108246,
-0.21344828605651855,
-0.2513933777809143,
-0.18904539942741394,
-0.45047539472579956,
0.20277325809001923,
0.32190799713134766,
0.562510073184967,
-0.12091661244630814,
0.6856340765953064,
-0.9624611139297485,
0.21481256186962128,
0.1806129664182663,
-0.022547338157892227,
-0.13540002703666687,
-0.35022348165512085,
-0.07064839452505112,
-0.24312464892864227,
-0.3187665045261383,
-0.9639289379119873,
0.2769373059272766,
0.019720666110515594,
0.7769820690155029,
0.31524717807769775,
0.35743823647499084,
0.6162784695625305,
-0.4807412028312683,
0.8325393795967102,
0.23449131846427917,
-0.8354001641273499,
0.6571977734565735,
-0.33718961477279663,
0.7807245254516602,
0.9333645701408386,
0.3823491334915161,
-0.719366192817688,
-0.14204396307468414,
-0.3988037705421448,
-0.7669570446014404,
1.0710034370422363,
0.10117309540510178,
-0.007642322685569525,
0.14144064486026764,
0.3613700568675995,
0.2900022268295288,
0.4569716155529022,
-0.308244526386261,
-0.11532402038574219,
0.24917827546596527,
-0.15566706657409668,
0.0700426697731018,
-0.18268583714962006,
0.0395970493555069,
-0.08148178458213806,
0.6126328706741333,
-0.42443567514419556,
0.24511758983135223,
0.2195751965045929,
0.0004733723180834204,
-0.2185569852590561,
0.2299908548593521,
0.6835802793502808,
0.5600884556770325,
0.20707090198993683,
0.0016694837249815464,
0.18732036650180817,
-0.5418775081634521,
0.39788317680358887,
0.18687736988067627,
-0.43362486362457275,
0.0793423131108284,
0.24568115174770355,
0.8904248476028442,
0.15585093200206757,
-0.7114859223365784,
0.48068204522132874,
-0.18044759333133698,
-0.11858981847763062,
-0.2586278021335602,
0.2662859559059143,
-0.3412016034126282,
0.5073488354682922,
0.47880178689956665,
0.24005363881587982,
0.356335312128067,
-0.0883244052529335,
0.27763429284095764,
0.2793530225753784,
-0.4745990037918091,
-0.4227219223976135,
0.5944344997406006,
0.3913496434688568,
-0.7952293753623962,
0.5291877388954163,
-0.49861741065979004,
-0.5355666279792786,
0.5275482535362244,
0.2710705101490021,
1.1673870086669922,
-0.4274294376373291,
0.4147821366786957,
0.6855475306510925,
0.21115590631961823,
-0.14567606151103973,
0.6547508239746094,
-0.1965407431125641,
-0.32766568660736084,
-0.6832291483879089,
-0.551962673664093,
-0.5192452073097229,
-0.3007901906967163,
-0.31684720516204834,
0.6567822694778442,
-0.37096676230430603,
-0.3739156126976013,
-0.3398928940296173,
0.3447535037994385,
-0.6411505937576294,
0.03419141471385956,
-0.2762517035007477,
0.8614090085029602,
-0.4738345146179199,
0.23779703676700592,
0.7079946994781494,
-0.3025014400482178,
-0.7718052864074707,
-0.07492858916521072,
0.36633118987083435,
-0.5643307566642761,
0.41407838463783264,
0.2466604858636856,
-0.12666553258895874,
0.21483102440834045,
-0.32877716422080994,
-0.8661421537399292,
0.9455122351646423,
0.22466391324996948,
-0.705414354801178,
-0.3258594572544098,
0.004632396623492241,
0.26767319440841675,
-0.26558205485343933,
0.539604663848877,
0.48057809472084045,
0.6851468682289124,
0.4174257218837738,
-0.8585277199745178,
0.13879919052124023,
-0.1262342482805252,
0.29640164971351624,
0.19181779026985168,
-0.5903957486152649,
0.9078003764152527,
-0.4637206494808197,
-0.14795580506324768,
0.16766797006130219,
0.445051372051239,
0.7467173933982849,
0.3885015547275543,
0.8569979071617126,
0.17294827103614807,
0.8117693066596985,
-0.0154310567304492,
1.0678209066390991,
-0.2988329529762268,
0.10042070597410202,
1.0516817569732666,
-0.20019246637821198,
0.23762214183807373,
0.45035386085510254,
-0.1834826022386551,
0.30384907126426697,
1.1701853275299072,
0.11350800842046738,
0.5337613224983215,
0.42642465233802795,
-0.3608160614967346,
-0.30315276980400085,
-0.2088203877210617,
0.10650745034217834,
0.029604149982333183,
0.0632399246096611,
0.061725690960884094,
-0.46104148030281067,
0.18002332746982574,
0.0017446286510676146,
-0.06838579475879669,
-0.1868058741092682,
0.8910452127456665,
-0.12690137326717377,
-1.0180186033248901,
0.28051671385765076,
-0.04032478109002113,
0.6103529334068298,
-0.5120370388031006,
-0.0364435650408268,
-0.23137617111206055,
-0.05674181506037712,
0.02169056050479412,
-0.3337772488594055,
-0.2812839150428772,
-0.09831509739160538,
0.13529258966445923,
-0.30980184674263,
0.7196944355964661,
-0.07152828574180603,
-0.2704273760318756,
-0.0041673798114061356,
0.7986250519752502,
0.09245456010103226,
-0.29176193475723267,
-0.7966482639312744,
0.16116870939731598,
0.0760931670665741,
-0.5219435691833496,
-0.13718709349632263,
0.5638518333435059,
-0.27801254391670227,
0.7639772295951843,
0.8785808682441711,
0.054122719913721085,
-0.055796559900045395,
0.4244042634963989,
0.7620902061462402,
-0.8552465438842773,
-0.7291266322135925,
-1.0386714935302734,
0.6922509670257568,
-0.1135750412940979,
-0.5468849539756775,
0.46389803290367126,
0.49032270908355713,
0.40639573335647583,
-0.02591814287006855,
0.7776021361351013,
0.189731165766716,
0.6109686493873596,
-0.2947859466075897,
0.0013406629441305995,
-0.3585827946662903,
0.19769544899463654,
-0.553290605545044,
-0.9951664805412292,
0.006212807260453701,
0.2716406285762787,
0.1249498799443245,
0.22510065138339996,
0.9990534782409668,
0.7948316931724548,
0.4083003103733063,
0.08147124946117401,
0.19913746416568756,
-0.3248622715473175,
0.4597117304801941,
0.5388991832733154,
1.16228187084198,
0.003406679956242442,
0.5420523285865784,
-0.3127744197845459,
-0.4225841164588928,
-0.19944262504577637,
-0.8031121492385864,
-0.7765483856201172,
-0.7605965733528137,
-0.4815787076950073,
-0.020870350301265717,
0.04458530992269516,
1.513154149055481,
0.7712725400924683,
-0.5378801822662354,
-0.3575266897678375,
-0.23836350440979004,
0.11839373409748077,
-0.5059221386909485,
-0.18864470720291138,
0.25376105308532715,
-0.9612935185432434,
-0.9304013848304749,
0.5741226673126221,
0.1527491956949234,
0.026146292686462402,
-0.31246432662010193,
-0.1655222475528717,
0.030124898999929428,
0.08973473310470581,
0.6562355756759644,
-0.10093317925930023,
-0.5582723021507263,
-0.04347389191389084,
0.5360311269760132,
-0.14302600920200348,
0.1469210833311081,
1.0089187622070312,
-0.8196304440498352,
0.2585289776325226,
0.5542510151863098,
0.8267888426780701,
0.17510904371738434,
0.21009361743927002,
0.5658642649650574,
-0.8753783106803894,
-0.31077104806900024,
0.500112771987915,
0.2332092672586441,
0.1921512484550476,
-0.4788386821746826,
0.600814163684845,
0.275718629360199,
-0.6301337480545044,
-0.6735068559646606,
0.23996251821517944,
-1.03901207447052,
-0.28031525015830994,
1.2921271324157715,
0.09230530261993408,
-0.29150211811065674,
-0.15296301245689392,
-0.7446115612983704,
0.12174446880817413,
-1.1008785963058472,
0.5412786602973938,
0.5655077695846558,
-0.5258321166038513,
-0.4222455322742462,
-0.5474933385848999,
0.6757210493087769,
0.343644917011261,
-1.0777043104171753,
-0.024029375985264778,
0.8572852611541748,
-0.10318751633167267,
0.01150551624596119,
0.88641756772995,
0.25828567147254944,
0.650293231010437,
-0.2475065439939499,
-0.0982041209936142,
0.011778456158936024,
-0.47385933995246887,
-0.5322425365447998,
0.2820116877555847,
0.12670883536338806,
-0.31083786487579346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08581v1 | Improving Factual Error Correction for Abstractive Summarization via Data Distillation and Conditional-generation Cloze | 2024-02-13T16:35:48 | 2024-02-13T16:35:48 | Yiyang Li, Lei Li, Dingxin Hu, Xueyi Hao, Marina Litvak, Natalia Vanetik, Yanquan Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Improving factual consistency in abstractive summarization has been a focus
of current research. One promising approach is the post-editing method.
However, previous works have yet to make sufficient use of factual factors in
summaries and suffers from the negative effect of the training datasets. In
this paper, we first propose a novel factual error correction model FactCloze
based on a conditional-generation cloze task. FactCloze can construct the
causality among factual factors while being able to determine whether the blank
can be answered or not. Then, we propose a data distillation method to generate
a more faithful summarization dataset SummDSC via multiple-dimensional
evaluation. We experimentally validate the effectiveness of our approach, which
leads to an improvement in multiple factual consistency metrics compared to
baselines. | [
-0.2028011530637741,
-0.7047387957572937,
0.6901969909667969,
0.11734122782945633,
-0.44786402583122253,
0.14807246625423431,
-0.2144814282655716,
-0.14671123027801514,
0.27790483832359314,
0.20497159659862518,
-0.44738414883613586,
-0.6115795969963074,
-0.8595566153526306,
0.5525736212730408,
-0.31866753101348877,
1.38112211227417,
-0.2519722580909729,
0.0009424487943761051,
-0.4830946624279022,
-0.4166058599948883,
-0.6515422463417053,
-0.3325136601924896,
-0.34436675906181335,
0.0651693120598793,
0.3385547697544098,
0.4391842186450958,
0.4640723168849945,
0.508227527141571,
0.22966814041137695,
0.3586674630641937,
-0.1339729279279709,
0.7045568823814392,
-0.7476581931114197,
-0.1867438703775406,
-0.32289138436317444,
-0.36918577551841736,
-0.7261928915977478,
-0.0030919797718524933,
0.3245546519756317,
0.6273518204689026,
-0.33099663257598877,
0.34532061219215393,
0.04568728804588318,
0.768061637878418,
-0.6750807762145996,
0.44010353088378906,
-0.6417860388755798,
-0.1405816525220871,
0.04703104496002197,
-0.14867819845676422,
-0.3878273069858551,
-0.9581999778747559,
0.23596203327178955,
-0.6266430020332336,
0.6927897930145264,
0.011295405216515064,
0.670874834060669,
0.392324298620224,
-0.5917344093322754,
-0.4140675961971283,
-0.6121191382408142,
0.49121591448783875,
-1.1069003343582153,
-0.07141605764627457,
0.09923267364501953,
-0.03832612559199333,
-0.09540832042694092,
-0.6813753247261047,
-0.7254817485809326,
-0.10235416144132614,
-0.393790602684021,
0.2319583147764206,
-0.10596918314695358,
0.1435299962759018,
0.49440693855285645,
0.32464322447776794,
-0.4684634506702423,
-0.5189810395240784,
-0.7315788269042969,
-0.5444033741950989,
0.7923658490180969,
0.2294052392244339,
0.058361440896987915,
0.039142463356256485,
-0.18298673629760742,
0.08249617367982864,
-0.5746375918388367,
-0.14093855023384094,
0.1412935107946396,
0.1654726266860962,
-0.062314972281455994,
0.7420194149017334,
-0.36530494689941406,
0.5090581774711609,
0.47859498858451843,
-0.6138097643852234,
0.4154525101184845,
-0.8425126671791077,
-0.0010825047502294183,
0.7971323132514954,
0.05978134274482727,
0.8273005485534668,
-0.16897493600845337,
0.0907462015748024,
0.04977511987090111,
0.26801595091819763,
-0.004708272870630026,
-0.9470242857933044,
-0.5206455588340759,
0.4533590078353882,
-0.22873495519161224,
-0.294271856546402,
0.1855916529893875,
-0.5634421706199646,
-0.5059803128242493,
-0.6541197896003723,
0.4394315183162689,
-0.3168124854564667,
0.059832457453012466,
0.17372657358646393,
-0.5454156398773193,
-0.5403994917869568,
0.6313408017158508,
-0.6390822529792786,
0.16353826224803925,
0.2225850373506546,
0.9245126247406006,
0.1875535100698471,
-0.14832189679145813,
-0.6004893183708191,
0.2518315315246582,
-0.27977094054222107,
0.8809642195701599,
-0.09667513519525528,
-0.3056449592113495,
-0.24910171329975128,
-0.15723185241222382,
-0.011989441700279713,
-0.5053229331970215,
0.30554112792015076,
-0.3961387872695923,
0.3001677989959717,
-0.7803097367286682,
-0.529689371585846,
-0.3971080780029297,
0.24674086272716522,
-0.6079373955726624,
0.5357796549797058,
-0.038395386189222336,
-1.025189995765686,
0.7095718383789062,
-0.512993574142456,
-0.5654401183128357,
-0.4942401349544525,
0.11774099618196487,
-0.7701526284217834,
0.2713463008403778,
0.2806398868560791,
0.06762797385454178,
0.19488799571990967,
0.4349043667316437,
-0.10200061649084091,
-0.16906942427158356,
0.02234296314418316,
-0.35126352310180664,
0.6907525062561035,
-0.14984755218029022,
-0.3142143189907074,
0.08200416713953018,
-1.215893030166626,
-0.29152995347976685,
-0.2766058146953583,
-0.39946091175079346,
-0.20628349483013153,
0.1291147619485855,
-0.5630834698677063,
0.23799730837345123,
0.3386940658092499,
-0.7580254077911377,
0.170904740691185,
-0.0016738269478082657,
0.03774303197860718,
0.4881154000759125,
0.3662988841533661,
0.14447401463985443,
-0.36989709734916687,
0.05163469910621643,
0.24942244589328766,
-0.0960279330611229,
-0.19374577701091766,
-0.17108888924121857,
-0.6010215878486633,
-0.5262100696563721,
0.5565531849861145,
0.7264857292175293,
-0.9840119481086731,
0.4585408866405487,
-0.16537249088287354,
-0.39209306240081787,
-0.22151672840118408,
0.16399472951889038,
0.3432105779647827,
0.9558968544006348,
0.6346883177757263,
0.00008589774370193481,
-0.9072866439819336,
-0.6351378560066223,
0.03526340425014496,
-0.1406088024377823,
0.06303874403238297,
-0.26937177777290344,
0.40930256247520447,
-0.06796158105134964,
1.1388616561889648,
-0.915468156337738,
-0.16262972354888916,
-0.2943345010280609,
0.6031969785690308,
0.24555401504039764,
0.3281501233577728,
0.6074492931365967,
-0.5389068722724915,
-0.35282444953918457,
-0.4306829273700714,
-0.8305910229682922,
-0.3469632565975189,
-0.11302409321069717,
0.1249580904841423,
0.36599454283714294,
0.392775297164917,
-0.6607605218887329,
0.7334153652191162,
0.28115561604499817,
-0.11998695135116577,
0.8987101912498474,
-0.5947751998901367,
0.5496875643730164,
-0.7071396708488464,
0.061379220336675644,
-0.17637519538402557,
-0.20550602674484253,
-0.5040927529335022,
-0.6274858713150024,
0.1407817155122757,
0.08332246541976929,
-0.4245351552963257,
-0.09566815942525864,
-0.46727752685546875,
0.2758431136608124,
-0.5682061910629272,
0.3038807809352875,
0.23777872323989868,
0.41004446148872375,
0.055579762905836105,
0.6025612950325012,
0.28992530703544617,
-0.7562155723571777,
0.4439018666744232,
0.5137000679969788,
-0.29448947310447693,
0.597797691822052,
-0.7801094055175781,
-0.23749428987503052,
-0.6438814401626587,
0.6839784979820251,
-1.0961084365844727,
-0.2948589622974396,
0.09229466319084167,
-0.13891945779323578,
0.19823993742465973,
0.023798590525984764,
-0.421645849943161,
-0.15169008076190948,
-0.6880751252174377,
0.29967623949050903,
0.24790485203266144,
-0.624825656414032,
0.45160841941833496,
0.0316571481525898,
-0.4712110757827759,
-0.7017645835876465,
-0.3735341727733612,
0.11924943327903748,
-0.09012165665626526,
-0.7503814101219177,
0.23026786744594574,
-0.04932161793112755,
-0.3976078927516937,
0.045470211654901505,
-0.4825308322906494,
0.139255091547966,
-0.2381931096315384,
-0.2007274031639099,
0.5636504292488098,
-0.12495246529579163,
-0.037963565438985825,
0.3446936309337616,
-0.1901344656944275,
0.06262775510549545,
-0.025380292907357216,
-0.01633523963391781,
0.1622253805398941,
0.1700112223625183,
-0.5371820330619812,
-0.04611596465110779,
0.4063093960285187,
-0.1557244509458542,
0.7985537648200989,
0.12320975214242935,
-0.13229432702064514,
-0.07596838474273682,
-0.6017675995826721,
-0.2554587423801422,
-0.4086129665374756,
0.32006457448005676,
0.04904315248131752,
-0.38195228576660156,
0.5321701169013977,
-0.153739795088768,
0.34016910195350647,
0.41188666224479675,
0.17307479679584503,
-0.20212151110172272,
0.7039595246315002,
0.5324668884277344,
0.32394036650657654,
-0.02581106871366501,
-0.10237801820039749,
0.38543209433555603,
-0.48891231417655945,
-0.1424822062253952,
-0.26271456480026245,
-0.07516439259052277,
-0.3727886974811554,
-0.09831715375185013,
0.7557370066642761,
-0.042821381241083145,
0.14457909762859344,
0.24232326447963715,
0.039785731583833694,
0.5005096793174744,
0.3379186689853668,
0.2506019175052643,
0.5635583996772766,
0.03265783563256264,
0.12839430570602417,
0.02679242007434368,
-0.7584951519966125,
-0.5563056468963623,
1.0340780019760132,
-0.11123751848936081,
0.3347647488117218,
0.193381667137146,
0.4743562936782837,
0.45477163791656494,
0.36282405257225037,
-0.045937854796648026,
0.3084103763103485,
-0.13829384744167328,
-0.7693204283714294,
-0.3519446551799774,
-0.3624218702316284,
-0.3723038136959076,
0.5279178023338318,
-0.5020104050636292,
-0.46076714992523193,
0.40795767307281494,
0.7527068257331848,
-0.613433301448822,
0.3127812147140503,
-0.7635616660118103,
0.7703133225440979,
0.03501462936401367,
-0.3326503336429596,
-0.33452701568603516,
-0.8960952758789062,
0.8518398404121399,
-0.01652352698147297,
0.2835846245288849,
-0.053178250789642334,
0.2764219641685486,
0.3574568033218384,
-1.0253791809082031,
0.8635753989219666,
-0.44600972533226013,
-0.07996254414319992,
0.5671678185462952,
-0.12806959450244904,
0.726721465587616,
0.4020042419433594,
-0.04131050780415535,
0.1382998824119568,
0.02188638411462307,
-0.4842797517776489,
-0.8179550170898438,
0.19562695920467377,
-0.3041691482067108,
-0.6174056529998779,
-0.6983903050422668,
-0.48198947310447693,
-0.24446238577365875,
-0.008555506356060505,
0.44479402899742126,
0.8193290829658508,
-0.3120928704738617,
0.010276570916175842,
0.8684731125831604,
-0.08823633939027786,
0.3340553939342499,
0.5306474566459656,
0.0908375009894371,
-0.45083701610565186,
0.8800609111785889,
0.27710047364234924,
0.2678844630718231,
0.18428285419940948,
0.14150305092334747,
-0.40492990612983704,
-0.7102692723274231,
-0.6232407689094543,
0.2530803680419922,
-0.584359347820282,
-0.3067789375782013,
-0.5580377578735352,
0.04678833857178688,
-0.4739549458026886,
-0.14523978531360626,
-0.24925096333026886,
-0.7128275036811829,
-0.15264682471752167,
-0.5008772015571594,
0.4420337378978729,
0.5312792658805847,
-0.5436585545539856,
0.29695895314216614,
-0.778697669506073,
0.5921309590339661,
0.20213772356510162,
-0.006707774940878153,
-0.12047693878412247,
-0.5593515038490295,
-0.28038227558135986,
0.34602609276771545,
-0.2957007884979248,
-0.5902840495109558,
-0.14712335169315338,
0.23239751160144806,
0.1910616010427475,
0.3524986803531647,
0.2867281138896942,
0.7000729441642761,
-0.6751053333282471,
0.7347283363342285,
0.356345534324646,
-1.0894047021865845,
0.5309738516807556,
-0.11741712689399719,
0.1252339780330658,
1.008736491203308,
0.10051905363798141,
-0.21745193004608154,
-0.425239235162735,
-0.7013717293739319,
-0.7406577467918396,
0.6098441481590271,
0.4782995879650116,
-0.2722267806529999,
0.04855385422706604,
0.45621684193611145,
0.41859760880470276,
0.7122657895088196,
-0.41707995533943176,
-0.5442535281181335,
-0.5552689433097839,
-0.21847115457057953,
-0.1396654099225998,
-0.486735075712204,
-0.17516489326953888,
-0.2683261036872864,
1.0656176805496216,
0.242040753364563,
-0.5631345510482788,
0.4456484615802765,
-0.25359225273132324,
0.22951900959014893,
0.1838373988866806,
1.098697304725647,
1.1511688232421875,
-0.563201367855072,
0.26196444034576416,
0.5286092162132263,
-0.5045800805091858,
0.3481750786304474,
0.05043840780854225,
-0.2742384076118469,
0.4348306357860565,
0.4838339388370514,
0.5762780904769897,
0.05194321274757385,
-0.5256504416465759,
0.5592377781867981,
-0.07612147182226181,
-0.17860235273838043,
-0.12642870843410492,
0.21051760017871857,
-0.2149970978498459,
-0.026394477114081383,
0.2888377904891968,
0.5650323033332825,
0.3653053343296051,
-0.5363269448280334,
0.2607974112033844,
-0.16498230397701263,
0.22189484536647797,
-0.2950335144996643,
0.6995263695716858,
0.3144327700138092,
0.5056333541870117,
0.4088122844696045,
-0.4762081801891327,
-0.3622293472290039,
0.5897504687309265,
0.38572630286216736,
0.44909319281578064,
-0.23165011405944824,
0.43350949883461,
0.7966979146003723,
0.2728407382965088,
-0.2426542490720749,
0.08807656168937683,
0.1304560899734497,
-0.49423742294311523,
-0.5576793551445007,
-0.10592156648635864,
-0.34037938714027405,
-0.07136092334985733,
-0.4832364618778229,
0.4132411777973175,
-0.3549636900424957,
-0.06106141582131386,
-0.07515878230333328,
-0.14950381219387054,
-0.17838408052921295,
0.46689093112945557,
-0.19354821741580963,
0.5973960161209106,
-0.9727003574371338,
0.3202820420265198,
0.4724879264831543,
-0.3950526714324951,
-0.4295768737792969,
-0.20100225508213043,
0.3082580864429474,
-0.13281632959842682,
0.385237455368042,
-0.23884819447994232,
-0.37814903259277344,
-0.31092825531959534,
-0.37939122319221497,
-0.9289829134941101,
1.2188371419906616,
0.3373242914676666,
-0.6051279306411743,
0.35475078225135803,
-0.05882519856095314,
0.4965198338031769,
-0.08569803833961487,
-0.00831286609172821,
0.695751965045929,
0.7220776677131653,
0.15611359477043152,
-0.6079354882240295,
0.11032408475875854,
0.013522607274353504,
-0.14604026079177856,
-0.012538589537143707,
-0.5074198246002197,
0.5884823203086853,
-0.6516951322555542,
-0.27045178413391113,
-0.10147423297166824,
1.0215247869491577,
0.5540544986724854,
0.7496739029884338,
0.47089168429374695,
0.496141642332077,
1.0637762546539307,
-0.04697135090827942,
0.8215458393096924,
-0.15421636402606964,
0.18260584771633148,
1.5146613121032715,
-0.489554762840271,
0.20401029288768768,
0.30215132236480713,
-0.16075564920902252,
0.4895860254764557,
0.29140523076057434,
-0.13852117955684662,
0.7452285885810852,
0.08304497599601746,
-0.440519243478775,
0.24600403010845184,
0.31465840339660645,
-0.3972180187702179,
0.32771745324134827,
0.040173862129449844,
0.0014632074162364006,
-0.5106527805328369,
-0.029697010293602943,
0.4330446422100067,
0.28713223338127136,
-0.30574873089790344,
0.6976909637451172,
-0.1960737258195877,
-0.5686009526252747,
0.4154115617275238,
0.14301176369190216,
0.3972558081150055,
-0.4167998135089874,
-0.25662961602211,
-0.35042715072631836,
0.12213174253702164,
-0.5376390814781189,
-0.19836144149303436,
0.4463554322719574,
0.2553522288799286,
-0.5480425357818604,
0.3325210511684418,
0.421796053647995,
-0.6832887530326843,
-0.6989077925682068,
-0.4221181869506836,
0.07915547490119934,
-0.03827471286058426,
0.11242446303367615,
-0.11176291853189468,
0.033139150589704514,
0.12621091306209564,
0.2510038912296295,
-0.160610631108284,
0.5294956564903259,
0.18717145919799805,
0.03216393291950226,
0.5324106812477112,
0.13717585802078247,
0.06717165559530258,
-0.11969386786222458,
0.481228232383728,
-0.33926156163215637,
-0.6215162873268127,
-0.9724423885345459,
0.8361794352531433,
-0.5366579294204712,
-0.3286319673061371,
1.0299688577651978,
0.8988195061683655,
0.5610770583152771,
-0.33756372332572937,
1.160688042640686,
-0.1612929403781891,
0.5175495743751526,
-0.7793803811073303,
0.4554823935031891,
0.01275637373328209,
0.3001721203327179,
-0.2153468281030655,
-0.9260921478271484,
-0.24093730747699738,
0.3197784125804901,
-0.2919836938381195,
-0.23520731925964355,
0.9892178177833557,
0.7067658305168152,
-0.1620706468820572,
0.23680593073368073,
-0.03333393856883049,
0.6574432253837585,
0.24258290231227875,
0.014683730900287628,
0.6170865297317505,
-0.6115456819534302,
0.15941424667835236,
-0.42485442757606506,
-0.46709322929382324,
-0.2781841456890106,
-1.1169489622116089,
-0.8277940154075623,
-0.34499073028564453,
-0.9595873951911926,
-0.5223731398582458,
0.24574802815914154,
0.8601195216178894,
0.2326679229736328,
-1.0326415300369263,
0.1058509573340416,
0.030805489048361778,
0.2812540829181671,
-0.30775344371795654,
-0.11883470416069031,
0.6782481670379639,
-0.4138776361942291,
-0.4957790672779083,
0.22127260267734528,
0.2485852688550949,
0.0530194491147995,
0.37017616629600525,
0.3456465005874634,
-0.04807284101843834,
0.3136090338230133,
0.854105532169342,
0.26496875286102295,
-0.33439865708351135,
-0.3797024190425873,
-0.5344328284263611,
0.22771668434143066,
0.21257038414478302,
0.9898107051849365,
-0.35073256492614746,
0.3923095762729645,
0.43469953536987305,
0.27262672781944275,
0.4585787057876587,
0.6183712482452393,
0.5255230069160461,
-0.7948260307312012,
0.1925717443227768,
-0.25850751996040344,
0.49024271965026855,
0.28285443782806396,
-0.476472407579422,
0.24745593965053558,
0.3786064684391022,
-0.34342512488365173,
-0.6500180959701538,
-0.18351627886295319,
-1.0354225635528564,
-0.30680403113365173,
0.8230186104774475,
-0.0852322205901146,
-0.07820812612771988,
-0.3970884382724762,
-0.5833514332771301,
0.4275623857975006,
-0.3005293309688568,
1.326891541481018,
0.7890679836273193,
-0.2720811367034912,
0.3836226463317871,
-0.2661285698413849,
0.613136351108551,
0.1259780079126358,
-0.8154695630073547,
0.2735026776790619,
1.1061941385269165,
0.5760722160339355,
0.23721842467784882,
0.43959036469459534,
-0.05352379381656647,
0.5735131502151489,
0.19207638502120972,
0.16402798891067505,
-0.35305413603782654,
-0.3619807958602905,
-0.020163217559456825,
0.06850504130125046,
-0.2886449992656708,
-0.09148526936769485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08577v1 | Test-Time Backdoor Attacks on Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T16:28:28 | 2024-02-13T16:28:28 | Dong Lu, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Qian Liu, Xianjun Yang, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Backdoor attacks are commonly executed by contaminating training data, such
that a trigger can activate predetermined harmful effects during the test
phase. In this work, we present AnyDoor, a test-time backdoor attack against
multimodal large language models (MLLMs), which involves injecting the backdoor
into the textual modality using adversarial test images (sharing the same
universal perturbation), without requiring access to or modification of the
training data. AnyDoor employs similar techniques used in universal adversarial
attacks, but distinguishes itself by its ability to decouple the timing of
setup and activation of harmful effects. In our experiments, we validate the
effectiveness of AnyDoor against popular MLLMs such as LLaVA-1.5, MiniGPT-4,
InstructBLIP, and BLIP-2, as well as provide comprehensive ablation studies.
Notably, because the backdoor is injected by a universal perturbation, AnyDoor
can dynamically change its backdoor trigger prompts/harmful effects, exposing a
new challenge for defending against backdoor attacks. Our project page is
available at https://sail-sg.github.io/AnyDoor/. | [
0.06261930614709854,
-1.1689826250076294,
0.33738064765930176,
0.11436661332845688,
-0.09524829685688019,
-0.15700101852416992,
-0.11594992130994797,
-0.3176642954349518,
-0.18699847161769867,
0.6283003687858582,
-0.5181406140327454,
-0.6669081449508667,
-0.312284916639328,
-0.12162597477436066,
-0.6921427249908447,
0.9742339253425598,
0.12559978663921356,
-0.040650565177202225,
0.1990068554878235,
-0.14716754853725433,
-0.3731626272201538,
-0.6769593954086304,
-0.5606042742729187,
-0.08400765061378479,
0.8679353594779968,
0.04183619096875191,
0.8698056936264038,
0.34966805577278137,
0.2701193690299988,
0.3388403654098511,
0.12064805626869202,
-0.4731418192386627,
-0.37125149369239807,
0.5286054015159607,
-0.1205984503030777,
-0.4736465811729431,
-0.3522774875164032,
-0.057773247361183167,
0.9556156992912292,
0.22920306026935577,
-0.12697522342205048,
0.1998901069164276,
-0.18677222728729248,
0.21419072151184082,
-0.8516139984130859,
-0.29383328557014465,
-0.8905898332595825,
0.24482786655426025,
-0.518048107624054,
-0.11623912304639816,
-0.5715614557266235,
-0.24520011246204376,
-0.364981472492218,
-0.2620978355407715,
0.06473027914762497,
0.09312030673027039,
0.6661214828491211,
0.1775260865688324,
-0.5002495646476746,
-0.11298561841249466,
-0.39493146538734436,
0.5794790983200073,
-0.8588784337043762,
0.6587568521499634,
-0.025163110345602036,
0.280753493309021,
-0.43908730149269104,
-0.43955114483833313,
-0.6929031014442444,
-0.5118443965911865,
-0.02967291884124279,
-0.058943718671798706,
-0.186422199010849,
0.06995982676744461,
0.384766548871994,
0.08973214030265808,
-1.0565427541732788,
0.4330809712409973,
-0.10102927684783936,
-0.4142672121524811,
0.3989449739456177,
0.3974243104457855,
0.4797087609767914,
-0.15603092312812805,
-0.4293864965438843,
-0.31743255257606506,
-0.9558308124542236,
0.1200215220451355,
0.470127135515213,
0.23949357867240906,
-0.20385056734085083,
0.7620793581008911,
0.20996873080730438,
0.5460887551307678,
-0.26471462845802307,
-0.09196464717388153,
0.08957549184560776,
-0.38501569628715515,
-0.30705904960632324,
0.050366539508104324,
0.8702362179756165,
-0.002167387632653117,
0.017418786883354187,
-0.1178654134273529,
-0.25190266966819763,
0.19197480380535126,
0.26537054777145386,
-0.9905447959899902,
0.02958284318447113,
0.2850874066352844,
-0.3298851251602173,
-0.6663562655448914,
-0.032158128917217255,
-0.9897156953811646,
-0.571411669254303,
0.638952910900116,
0.5930283069610596,
-0.4349420666694641,
-0.15238262712955475,
0.05949778854846954,
-0.07820175588130951,
0.4997769296169281,
-0.026282191276550293,
-0.43445491790771484,
-0.035329293459653854,
0.5086251497268677,
0.6471338868141174,
0.10377931594848633,
-0.643572211265564,
-0.8035869598388672,
0.07443803548812866,
-0.23390384018421173,
0.5172930359840393,
-0.5830420851707458,
-0.5733737945556641,
0.17766568064689636,
-0.04471879452466965,
-0.10874633491039276,
-0.14850863814353943,
0.09298831224441528,
-0.8671995997428894,
0.21879230439662933,
0.22674597799777985,
-0.15476824343204498,
-0.22060216963291168,
0.5692526698112488,
-0.7254764437675476,
0.6270735859870911,
-0.179185688495636,
-0.5865318179130554,
-0.08158596605062485,
-0.8785759210586548,
-0.6142222881317139,
-0.299807071685791,
-0.300472229719162,
-0.6812893152236938,
-0.04185314476490021,
0.0342944860458374,
0.4127039909362793,
0.01951020210981369,
-0.21035633981227875,
-0.7225774526596069,
-0.07346028089523315,
0.7475667595863342,
-0.8851408958435059,
1.1843563318252563,
0.11219409108161926,
-0.49239373207092285,
0.18486420810222626,
-0.8164577484130859,
-0.21229033172130585,
0.33208346366882324,
-0.15924932062625885,
-0.2568880617618561,
-0.4154210090637207,
0.0137223144993186,
0.22757524251937866,
0.18448157608509064,
-0.93162602186203,
0.4921720027923584,
-0.2991134822368622,
0.09054111689329147,
0.9212711453437805,
0.23791377246379852,
0.2403949350118637,
-0.1328701674938202,
0.679633378982544,
-0.1154065951704979,
0.6400575637817383,
-0.6772578954696655,
-0.5422272086143494,
-0.269275039434433,
-0.4633450210094452,
0.3678393065929413,
0.490300714969635,
-0.7106854319572449,
0.021992772817611694,
-0.050564393401145935,
-0.5530930161476135,
-0.2199563980102539,
0.07396633177995682,
0.6721994280815125,
0.24171794950962067,
0.060179270803928375,
-0.12848231196403503,
-0.23403054475784302,
-0.6768500804901123,
-0.21459652483463287,
-0.06691243499517441,
-0.11026200652122498,
0.17744866013526917,
0.8101608753204346,
-0.4858897626399994,
0.5957338809967041,
-0.5571693778038025,
-0.38353970646858215,
0.28130772709846497,
0.14749300479888916,
0.03512778878211975,
0.40573740005493164,
0.6822433471679688,
-0.6283840537071228,
-0.3336028456687927,
-0.15648287534713745,
-0.8355170488357544,
-0.04745854064822197,
-0.33525604009628296,
0.06232863664627075,
0.22916801273822784,
0.34795698523521423,
-0.7267395853996277,
0.6399388909339905,
1.01851487159729,
-0.5597241520881653,
0.8043003678321838,
-0.13464991748332977,
0.18651507794857025,
-0.8382691144943237,
0.19134174287319183,
-0.41325560212135315,
-0.1773761808872223,
-0.6019983887672424,
0.5463129878044128,
0.23704738914966583,
-0.5558857917785645,
-0.7436537146568298,
0.8444640040397644,
-0.13223345577716827,
-0.03568947687745094,
0.16734114289283752,
0.05101819336414337,
0.08376805484294891,
0.5519329905509949,
-0.5308473706245422,
0.6352156400680542,
0.5947887897491455,
-0.2445204108953476,
0.6592882871627808,
0.23245877027511597,
-0.1533336192369461,
0.3311959207057953,
-0.46990907192230225,
0.3995247185230255,
0.06321098655462265,
0.6490464806556702,
-1.2479057312011719,
-0.07604333013296127,
0.5815422534942627,
-0.7600407600402832,
0.42591238021850586,
-0.022941166535019875,
-0.6661201119422913,
0.1109224334359169,
-0.6830893754959106,
0.4771517217159271,
0.2201768457889557,
-0.7077956795692444,
1.005948781967163,
-0.09330770373344421,
0.04206939414143562,
-0.8133537769317627,
-0.7009130120277405,
0.25262418389320374,
-0.015792028978466988,
-0.6511663198471069,
0.07198169827461243,
-0.15367601811885834,
-0.13598479330539703,
0.007083213422447443,
-0.018544547259807587,
-0.06278526037931442,
0.28306931257247925,
0.5612468719482422,
0.3502940237522125,
-0.05654458701610565,
0.013068832457065582,
-0.1344478875398636,
0.04405994713306427,
0.11732601374387741,
-0.23469847440719604,
0.6673933863639832,
-0.00478580454364419,
-0.7917671799659729,
-0.3508833944797516,
0.5425560474395752,
0.9583223462104797,
-0.4776915907859802,
0.7417833209037781,
0.5819109678268433,
-0.18817204236984253,
-0.10451605916023254,
-0.6907057762145996,
-0.2851387560367584,
-0.5209706425666809,
0.43593594431877136,
-0.48168131709098816,
-0.6969018578529358,
0.5619091391563416,
0.4243067502975464,
0.37992337346076965,
0.08298132568597794,
0.45502084493637085,
0.032856665551662445,
1.1969186067581177,
0.3394148647785187,
-0.2746944725513458,
0.5358615517616272,
-0.3430587351322174,
-0.24536673724651337,
-0.6287559866905212,
-0.16143842041492462,
-0.5003688335418701,
-0.10169939696788788,
-0.36050596833229065,
0.006428586784750223,
0.26918262243270874,
-0.38260918855667114,
-0.42634233832359314,
0.18292313814163208,
0.09839624911546707,
0.28805384039878845,
0.2020706981420517,
0.2223808318376541,
0.3535041809082031,
-0.12441811710596085,
-0.394914448261261,
0.20060326159000397,
-0.6709628105163574,
-0.06455925107002258,
1.3070329427719116,
0.39682385325431824,
1.125802993774414,
0.27076056599617004,
0.36538389325141907,
0.2727925181388855,
0.5956799983978271,
-0.45775970816612244,
0.6503403782844543,
-0.2477470487356186,
-1.0647823810577393,
-0.31322067975997925,
-0.43239825963974,
-1.0654674768447876,
0.32905468344688416,
-0.40835389494895935,
-0.6145023107528687,
-0.02912224642932415,
0.2312680184841156,
-0.45150673389434814,
0.699467122554779,
-0.5068498253822327,
0.9825373291969299,
-0.5330897569656372,
-0.2544536292552948,
-0.17187008261680603,
-0.6406101584434509,
0.4706798493862152,
-0.45239394903182983,
0.3000791668891907,
0.2599995732307434,
-0.054335493594408035,
0.36571773886680603,
0.06590988487005234,
1.0691951513290405,
-0.14719823002815247,
-0.5449087619781494,
-0.27230626344680786,
0.5107229351997375,
0.68593430519104,
0.21847273409366608,
0.06716656684875488,
0.44171279668807983,
-0.16923345625400543,
-0.4865306317806244,
-0.8886149525642395,
0.6951791644096375,
-0.4058266282081604,
-0.5948053598403931,
-0.44617047905921936,
-0.43741366267204285,
0.0815054252743721,
0.15858227014541626,
0.27252182364463806,
0.7383691072463989,
-0.09513359516859055,
0.25484466552734375,
0.5172024965286255,
-0.5654061436653137,
0.3600360155105591,
0.769830048084259,
-0.4329153001308441,
-0.2759195566177368,
0.8771883845329285,
-0.21122588217258453,
0.35120806097984314,
0.3565432131290436,
0.25855299830436707,
-0.33697906136512756,
-0.44727614521980286,
-0.4119943678379059,
0.2869545519351959,
-0.6359430551528931,
-0.22609251737594604,
-0.47453272342681885,
-0.19995062053203583,
-0.548672616481781,
-0.025996023789048195,
-0.653444230556488,
-0.1528560221195221,
0.2119123935699463,
0.25141099095344543,
0.1165754646062851,
0.5008371472358704,
-0.03673720732331276,
0.1475038230419159,
-1.1321238279342651,
0.2165990024805069,
0.5395177602767944,
0.3038554787635803,
0.006926329806447029,
-0.6020841598510742,
-0.0794505700469017,
0.05127484351396561,
-0.32638421654701233,
-1.0290143489837646,
-0.013263209722936153,
-0.014520823955535889,
0.47659268975257874,
0.6365727186203003,
0.0406208373606205,
0.35499799251556396,
-0.689561128616333,
0.8955453038215637,
0.25428545475006104,
-0.7879011034965515,
0.24444758892059326,
-0.3210363984107971,
0.3959822654724121,
0.17424112558364868,
0.23869895935058594,
-0.6730673909187317,
-0.6718951463699341,
-0.5383577942848206,
-0.6249359846115112,
0.022061757743358612,
0.304696261882782,
0.2764582931995392,
0.4298326373100281,
0.16686367988586426,
0.16235187649726868,
0.34631824493408203,
-0.7931296825408936,
-0.3396747410297394,
-0.2997765839099884,
0.20853586494922638,
-0.09955959767103195,
-0.15286001563072205,
-0.2260846495628357,
0.17847959697246552,
0.48869767785072327,
0.332600861787796,
0.09460382163524628,
-0.018213413655757904,
-0.41549044847488403,
0.024525295943021774,
0.5969247221946716,
0.7516416907310486,
0.31666430830955505,
-0.20836172997951508,
0.18865300714969635,
0.27012407779693604,
-0.4676486849784851,
0.3066641390323639,
0.15053926408290863,
-0.1660718321800232,
-0.00613723648712039,
0.6079643368721008,
0.3790619969367981,
0.2653936445713043,
-0.7244136929512024,
0.6692001819610596,
-0.19466903805732727,
-0.17870216071605682,
-0.3025455176830292,
-0.04501667246222496,
-0.5428170561790466,
0.49487999081611633,
0.22510521113872528,
-0.1028623953461647,
-0.17889896035194397,
-0.7331768274307251,
0.21747073531150818,
0.6175677180290222,
-0.31590157747268677,
-0.4720827341079712,
0.61570143699646,
0.17945411801338196,
-0.33922669291496277,
0.5611145496368408,
0.020193373784422874,
-0.9714698195457458,
0.2901732325553894,
0.6150267720222473,
0.9792270660400391,
-0.6925569176673889,
-0.04509364068508148,
-0.16451279819011688,
0.5966994762420654,
0.46998533606529236,
-0.026394318789243698,
0.06276313215494156,
-0.7891117334365845,
-0.522592306137085,
-0.3153553605079651,
-0.3725826144218445,
0.4735802412033081,
-0.2552313208580017,
-0.08847712725400925,
-0.5389493107795715,
0.11216289550065994,
-0.15572096407413483,
-0.41102996468544006,
-0.3870745599269867,
0.09939921647310257,
0.2386859804391861,
0.7473523020744324,
-0.8588786125183105,
0.7307896614074707,
0.6248214840888977,
-0.2432112693786621,
-0.49048158526420593,
0.17925183475017548,
0.4634934663772583,
-0.6271709203720093,
0.8526726961135864,
0.02100648544728756,
-0.3260713517665863,
-0.06320187449455261,
-0.5459758639335632,
-0.5579913854598999,
0.6882143020629883,
0.2756044864654541,
-0.2736997604370117,
-0.09147533774375916,
-0.11063773185014725,
0.21983037889003754,
-0.1292276829481125,
-0.05279223248362541,
0.26096493005752563,
0.6924770474433899,
-0.24617460370063782,
-0.6108368039131165,
0.33397960662841797,
-0.3390049338340759,
-0.22095945477485657,
0.2543981969356537,
-0.44373685121536255,
0.9353870749473572,
-0.14000006020069122,
-0.3903774917125702,
0.15365925431251526,
0.3433722257614136,
0.2957707345485687,
0.15203137695789337,
0.8767751455307007,
0.5926976799964905,
0.1977008730173111,
0.23124700784683228,
1.1466543674468994,
-0.23617561161518097,
0.11701394617557526,
1.1012836694717407,
-0.30948126316070557,
0.749786913394928,
0.39436283707618713,
0.12062915414571762,
0.33403581380844116,
0.2643721103668213,
-0.3119943141937256,
0.24002502858638763,
0.23256878554821014,
-0.22608870267868042,
0.005005094688385725,
0.07247015088796616,
-0.7205621004104614,
0.8118349313735962,
0.17956800758838654,
-0.0831466093659401,
-0.36835765838623047,
0.5574886798858643,
0.320025771856308,
-0.07945552468299866,
-0.10349588096141815,
0.33166730403900146,
-0.1539284735918045,
-0.25909504294395447,
0.6893405914306641,
0.009544878266751766,
0.75528484582901,
-0.9918026328086853,
-0.04297588765621185,
-0.24465566873550415,
0.26785144209861755,
-0.06006401777267456,
-0.5560579299926758,
-0.038043856620788574,
0.07299701124429703,
0.2224125862121582,
-0.07406052201986313,
0.602155327796936,
-0.4486163854598999,
-0.12771481275558472,
0.48866453766822815,
-0.005502407904714346,
-0.13953866064548492,
-0.38119766116142273,
-0.6256626844406128,
0.13398489356040955,
-0.1207038089632988,
-0.5129392743110657,
0.3933011293411255,
0.06799671798944473,
0.1703028678894043,
0.7913017868995667,
0.9874030947685242,
0.29593250155448914,
0.22264260053634644,
0.11509063839912415,
1.0301932096481323,
-0.5735467076301575,
-0.3050747513771057,
-1.0657601356506348,
0.4317583739757538,
0.08340257406234741,
-0.17475268244743347,
1.1886683702468872,
0.6487463712692261,
0.7570143342018127,
0.07975956052541733,
0.6911027431488037,
0.19500644505023956,
0.038960911333560944,
-0.6753550171852112,
0.97669517993927,
-0.783257246017456,
0.3619053363800049,
-0.31908008456230164,
-0.6842753291130066,
-0.5110068321228027,
0.11223389953374863,
-0.08040925860404968,
-0.13944950699806213,
0.889290988445282,
1.1741349697113037,
0.15401792526245117,
-0.07212276756763458,
0.5422505736351013,
0.7061334252357483,
0.6822364926338196,
0.4165702760219574,
1.0941401720046997,
-0.2965205907821655,
1.1454551219940186,
-0.25085851550102234,
-0.3369838297367096,
-0.10779961943626404,
-0.8424636125564575,
-1.2776442766189575,
-0.30793526768684387,
0.04509221389889717,
-0.6810005307197571,
0.460197389125824,
0.6978486776351929,
0.24349002540111542,
-0.687512218952179,
-0.12040529400110245,
0.6065099835395813,
0.0663541778922081,
-0.012135975062847137,
-0.15908949077129364,
0.37456467747688293,
-0.12558646500110626,
-0.22931359708309174,
0.40185534954071045,
0.3456753194332123,
0.020938757807016373,
-0.6129183769226074,
0.2824399471282959,
-0.31132909655570984,
-0.12266416847705841,
0.5500264167785645,
0.40158402919769287,
-0.5484678745269775,
-0.42341408133506775,
0.06263931840658188,
-0.17175701260566711,
-0.28594693541526794,
0.9398141503334045,
-0.29174166917800903,
0.46836644411087036,
0.42091619968414307,
0.7855843901634216,
0.4225357472896576,
-0.3574613034725189,
0.5006109476089478,
-1.0997314453125,
0.4109219014644623,
0.15725578367710114,
0.26795926690101624,
-0.016628026962280273,
-0.30897870659828186,
0.18157422542572021,
0.2364686131477356,
-0.4028744697570801,
-0.996776282787323,
0.4771255850791931,
-0.5002717971801758,
-0.6492888331413269,
1.2359123229980469,
-0.22419260442256927,
-0.4102749228477478,
-0.06905370950698853,
-0.14979581534862518,
0.18807946145534515,
-0.44042709469795227,
0.9243382811546326,
0.5125292539596558,
0.30652397871017456,
0.010919829830527306,
-0.4958624243736267,
0.17040278017520905,
0.35132381319999695,
-0.6282809376716614,
0.06761734187602997,
0.29807209968566895,
0.26285815238952637,
0.24353258311748505,
0.2571238577365875,
-0.3864407539367676,
0.4101526141166687,
0.10895489901304245,
0.04406914860010147,
-0.4550371766090393,
-0.38708701729774475,
-0.5971230864524841,
0.25846201181411743,
-0.4715419411659241,
-0.45664578676223755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08567v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08567v2 | Agent Smith: A Single Image Can Jailbreak One Million Multimodal LLM Agents Exponentially Fast | 2024-02-13T16:06:17 | 2024-06-03T14:15:03 | Xiangming Gu, Xiaosen Zheng, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Qian Liu, Ye Wang, Jing Jiang, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MA | A multimodal large language model (MLLM) agent can receive instructions,
capture images, retrieve histories from memory, and decide which tools to use.
Nonetheless, red-teaming efforts have revealed that adversarial images/prompts
can jailbreak an MLLM and cause unaligned behaviors. In this work, we report an
even more severe safety issue in multi-agent environments, referred to as
infectious jailbreak. It entails the adversary simply jailbreaking a single
agent, and without any further intervention from the adversary, (almost) all
agents will become infected exponentially fast and exhibit harmful behaviors.
To validate the feasibility of infectious jailbreak, we simulate multi-agent
environments containing up to one million LLaVA-1.5 agents, and employ
randomized pair-wise chat as a proof-of-concept instantiation for multi-agent
interaction. Our results show that feeding an (infectious) adversarial image
into the memory of any randomly chosen agent is sufficient to achieve
infectious jailbreak. Finally, we derive a simple principle for determining
whether a defense mechanism can provably restrain the spread of infectious
jailbreak, but how to design a practical defense that meets this principle
remains an open question to investigate. Our project page is available at
https://sail-sg.github.io/Agent-Smith/. | [
-0.20783017575740814,
-1.1622995138168335,
0.6026039719581604,
0.10799938440322876,
-0.0839853584766388,
0.21722057461738586,
0.05107136443257332,
-0.7895141839981079,
0.3678079843521118,
0.7019455432891846,
-0.3629002273082733,
-0.17583678662776947,
-0.4782859683036804,
0.07195478677749634,
-0.2566489279270172,
1.0519174337387085,
0.16216707229614258,
-0.22498424351215363,
-0.019325105473399162,
-0.18404412269592285,
-0.4788956046104431,
-0.660631000995636,
-0.5171261429786682,
-0.02615225687623024,
0.5137279033660889,
0.3177107274532318,
0.964851975440979,
0.5768164396286011,
0.5504196286201477,
0.4868810772895813,
0.017343422397971153,
0.2126019448041916,
-0.5344992876052856,
0.5700570344924927,
-0.12655657529830933,
-0.4879731833934784,
-0.4593592584133148,
-0.019576936960220337,
0.35074886679649353,
-0.07556165009737015,
0.04805491492152214,
-0.26021137833595276,
-0.45755627751350403,
0.6186280846595764,
-0.5191841125488281,
-0.25085359811782837,
-0.8611279129981995,
-0.07566782087087631,
-0.2049509435892105,
-0.11069376766681671,
-0.7705938220024109,
0.11484064906835556,
-0.08543775975704193,
-0.5319336652755737,
-0.3437035083770752,
-0.016835136339068413,
0.5683383941650391,
0.10333552956581116,
-0.6345133781433105,
-0.11397137492895126,
-0.5307440161705017,
0.42053258419036865,
-0.3546273112297058,
-0.29312941431999207,
0.30031102895736694,
0.3614855706691742,
-0.5586056113243103,
-0.5151704549789429,
-0.39194583892822266,
-0.5240175724029541,
0.2062993198633194,
-0.29169920086860657,
-0.28895965218544006,
0.12473419308662415,
0.07900673151016235,
-0.40433546900749207,
-0.33196020126342773,
-0.1371581107378006,
-0.4640146493911743,
-0.1624877154827118,
0.6106294393539429,
0.2812311053276062,
0.8395234942436218,
0.21772414445877075,
-0.6857491135597229,
0.04683469980955124,
-0.6664919853210449,
0.1585635542869568,
0.2600438594818115,
0.19002649188041687,
-0.24843518435955048,
0.42757269740104675,
0.30642300844192505,
0.26658180356025696,
0.004220275208353996,
-0.33225497603416443,
0.2937981188297272,
-0.44754496216773987,
0.01418465655297041,
0.08456302434206009,
0.8626300096511841,
0.4573075473308563,
0.30517879128456116,
-0.5441370606422424,
-0.12634608149528503,
-0.007727886084467173,
0.6265294551849365,
-0.8564305305480957,
-0.1701173186302185,
0.5076820254325867,
-0.18288275599479675,
-0.5682930946350098,
0.10581090301275253,
-0.6137035489082336,
-0.7600924968719482,
0.5738818049430847,
0.45218831300735474,
-0.4548639953136444,
-0.4103497564792633,
-0.2459711879491806,
-0.4726417660713196,
0.11335884034633636,
0.2905409634113312,
-0.41115429997444153,
0.03376412019133568,
0.4886021018028259,
0.8423911333084106,
0.027295298874378204,
-0.7540624737739563,
-0.5047144889831543,
0.22451536357402802,
-0.37718287110328674,
0.9237146973609924,
-0.03977071866393089,
-0.23437021672725677,
-0.3204330801963806,
0.18096233904361725,
-0.1400674432516098,
-0.28925031423568726,
-0.21302394568920135,
-0.6437402367591858,
-0.5674313902854919,
0.18114560842514038,
-0.26534131169319153,
-0.06790405511856079,
0.40072667598724365,
-0.7718455195426941,
0.028523219749331474,
-0.11532559245824814,
-0.5861010551452637,
0.07090308517217636,
-0.5689079761505127,
-0.47756433486938477,
0.036403365433216095,
-0.03157370537519455,
-0.5714823603630066,
-0.27359554171562195,
-0.17401741445064545,
0.23230725526809692,
0.08129169791936874,
0.24474434554576874,
-0.7795531153678894,
-0.27628761529922485,
0.7247114777565002,
-0.33536073565483093,
0.8877763748168945,
0.4701288938522339,
-0.3814307153224945,
0.0871807187795639,
-0.19960835576057434,
0.14309288561344147,
0.44789785146713257,
-0.08117814362049103,
-0.4569112956523895,
0.11476670950651169,
-0.1918763667345047,
0.1326393038034439,
0.07613082975149155,
-0.581183135509491,
0.5002400875091553,
-0.18829090893268585,
0.5800975561141968,
0.865275502204895,
0.20541918277740479,
0.3804866671562195,
-0.5124271512031555,
0.5601986646652222,
0.144002765417099,
0.4396231770515442,
-0.6467394828796387,
-0.40493088960647583,
-0.11908774822950363,
-0.6282687187194824,
-0.11933308094739914,
0.7564018964767456,
-0.9089587926864624,
-0.20117077231407166,
0.15634584426879883,
-0.37490299344062805,
-0.30526992678642273,
0.26169025897979736,
0.8651711940765381,
-0.09345720708370209,
0.23102037608623505,
-0.22094257175922394,
-0.3330356478691101,
-0.7696040272712708,
-0.3373333513736725,
-0.07030624896287918,
0.5520483255386353,
0.32652172446250916,
0.6174485087394714,
-0.415166974067688,
0.6515018939971924,
-0.05664418265223503,
0.05656027793884277,
-0.36434879899024963,
-0.18219731748104095,
0.09018317610025406,
0.5503779053688049,
0.8261080384254456,
-0.7338190674781799,
-0.3554163873195648,
-0.10246977210044861,
-1.0169569253921509,
0.25748276710510254,
-0.17283038794994354,
-0.08060606569051743,
0.3324699401855469,
0.4365881681442261,
-0.9583828449249268,
0.6945861577987671,
0.397847056388855,
-0.955417811870575,
0.8504731059074402,
-0.39474037289619446,
0.37136274576187134,
-0.9637612700462341,
-0.2534967362880707,
-0.03116397000849247,
-0.4213064908981323,
-0.9290218949317932,
0.8787646293640137,
0.07963693886995316,
-0.1242627501487732,
-0.8807713389396667,
0.4131936728954315,
-0.33977192640304565,
0.23706378042697906,
-0.41735827922821045,
0.11332482844591141,
0.06346304714679718,
0.265532523393631,
-0.5008265972137451,
1.0171228647232056,
0.5807021260261536,
-0.398762971162796,
0.5967950820922852,
0.023439345881342888,
-0.18464767932891846,
0.3139723539352417,
-0.7973929643630981,
0.37014004588127136,
-0.3271976113319397,
0.2420314997434616,
-0.8418461084365845,
0.07288018614053726,
0.3956242501735687,
-0.310194730758667,
0.22646410763263702,
-0.1875409483909607,
-0.4279288947582245,
0.06209532171487808,
-0.5001496076583862,
0.39676693081855774,
0.16274714469909668,
-0.47788944840431213,
0.4104297161102295,
0.6341741681098938,
0.10197372734546661,
-0.7204901576042175,
-0.5993188619613647,
0.4586363136768341,
-0.47327250242233276,
-0.9684427976608276,
0.11073324829339981,
-0.15590523183345795,
-0.8617997765541077,
0.10813391208648682,
0.09923569858074188,
-0.24897634983062744,
0.6924322247505188,
0.57476806640625,
0.5500652194023132,
0.020161554217338562,
-0.04515451565384865,
-0.34342893958091736,
0.052913591265678406,
0.1219833716750145,
-0.010861188173294067,
0.2879493236541748,
-0.37346887588500977,
-0.3295307159423828,
-0.22132308781147003,
0.6301091313362122,
0.9045073986053467,
0.06670358777046204,
1.0940529108047485,
-0.10431425273418427,
0.011374210007488728,
-0.2844918370246887,
-0.21987269818782806,
-0.08206140249967575,
-0.5162047147750854,
0.42020338773727417,
-0.5488005876541138,
-0.5193599462509155,
0.4978361427783966,
0.030664777383208275,
0.1314055323600769,
-0.0023453645408153534,
0.3234770596027374,
-0.06690334528684616,
0.7928799986839294,
0.49748173356056213,
-0.27004456520080566,
0.2615438997745514,
-0.3174559772014618,
0.08783356845378876,
-0.4856974184513092,
-0.14092229306697845,
-0.32063063979148865,
-0.15196114778518677,
-0.4980723559856415,
-0.2805604338645935,
0.4420471787452698,
0.091417096555233,
-0.32359835505485535,
0.5246129631996155,
-0.24921441078186035,
0.8515243530273438,
0.2859944701194763,
0.3299451172351837,
0.14882993698120117,
-0.32152584195137024,
-0.4834010601043701,
0.46379712224006653,
-0.4299282133579254,
-0.33944299817085266,
0.9996120929718018,
0.39913150668144226,
0.9546594023704529,
0.4898815155029297,
0.6515917181968689,
0.7139826416969299,
0.18636231124401093,
-0.5702072978019714,
0.614199161529541,
-0.0051384358666837215,
-0.9438164234161377,
-0.3488703966140747,
-0.21245667338371277,
-1.1743618249893188,
0.6355074048042297,
-0.24123238027095795,
-0.9660177230834961,
-0.06194859743118286,
0.2410682886838913,
-0.3290337026119232,
0.2895916700363159,
-0.9426771998405457,
0.9385299682617188,
-0.4222843050956726,
-0.5639235377311707,
-0.24711300432682037,
-0.8520721793174744,
0.6474260091781616,
-0.2159241884946823,
0.639448344707489,
-0.312232106924057,
0.19549018144607544,
0.16696183383464813,
-0.6228549480438232,
0.8371047973632812,
-0.2971438467502594,
0.23264795541763306,
0.411754310131073,
0.3381878137588501,
0.6070123314857483,
0.15181668102741241,
0.0742524042725563,
-0.13521775603294373,
0.09793000668287277,
-0.4856015741825104,
-0.4831235706806183,
0.42808040976524353,
-0.8646294474601746,
-0.8097743391990662,
-0.39882174134254456,
-0.6312698721885681,
0.27760881185531616,
-0.03694247826933861,
0.018216261640191078,
0.4655998945236206,
0.020827066153287888,
-0.00824962928891182,
0.48839956521987915,
-0.24440523982048035,
0.6382213830947876,
0.5825804471969604,
-0.19013617932796478,
-0.476980596780777,
0.8356004357337952,
-0.026274967938661575,
0.5323055982589722,
-0.08824939280748367,
0.0980895459651947,
0.038103312253952026,
-0.531173586845398,
-0.5213757753372192,
0.06436032056808472,
-0.5260128974914551,
-0.2781275808811188,
-0.40412312746047974,
-0.2040589600801468,
-0.382638543844223,
-0.32074815034866333,
-0.47132647037506104,
-0.2575334906578064,
0.0907197967171669,
0.1893475204706192,
0.5837650299072266,
0.6373352408409119,
0.05996602028608322,
0.2509801983833313,
-0.954764187335968,
0.41016116738319397,
0.220991313457489,
-0.03482445329427719,
-0.1375850886106491,
-0.3574613332748413,
-0.3040141463279724,
0.15701575577259064,
-0.47660934925079346,
-1.1318327188491821,
0.48166191577911377,
0.14001698791980743,
0.8287416100502014,
0.6093838810920715,
0.3550039529800415,
0.6501734852790833,
-0.5874984264373779,
0.5409202575683594,
0.36709851026535034,
-0.6685935854911804,
0.6157287955284119,
-0.35457807779312134,
0.0896058976650238,
0.4462254047393799,
0.02264302968978882,
-0.37918800115585327,
-0.9398556351661682,
-0.4735208749771118,
-0.9070492386817932,
0.3260997533798218,
-0.04659920558333397,
0.09934427589178085,
-0.050289399921894073,
0.18368607759475708,
-0.14472651481628418,
0.059867870062589645,
-0.8571266531944275,
-0.44477397203445435,
-0.08064110577106476,
0.2712562382221222,
-0.12624727189540863,
-0.17752549052238464,
-0.46406546235084534,
-0.020838208496570587,
0.4520910084247589,
0.13348737359046936,
0.2469918131828308,
0.2837150990962982,
-0.5175965428352356,
0.003199619008228183,
0.4391970634460449,
0.7708590030670166,
0.4570362865924835,
-0.1118713766336441,
0.2970932722091675,
-0.2922649085521698,
-0.5587995648384094,
0.6772258281707764,
0.03484448045492172,
-0.20466655492782593,
-0.3509397506713867,
0.3362099528312683,
0.5508155822753906,
-0.18803738057613373,
-1.0472397804260254,
0.7584367990493774,
-0.21764227747917175,
-0.24019001424312592,
-0.5539288520812988,
0.3280019760131836,
-0.18912482261657715,
0.7696537971496582,
0.3604106307029724,
0.3202108144760132,
-0.09498833864927292,
-0.8710070252418518,
0.5058784484863281,
0.8815156817436218,
-0.028968336060643196,
-0.2683659791946411,
0.6780217289924622,
0.1855057179927826,
-0.4108693599700928,
0.6483504772186279,
-0.36837369203567505,
-0.562825620174408,
1.1487977504730225,
0.8490526676177979,
0.8455313444137573,
-0.2628742754459381,
0.14461104571819305,
-0.16094684600830078,
0.6773120760917664,
-0.01902725175023079,
0.007366414647549391,
0.23807352781295776,
-0.9918765425682068,
-0.4590798318386078,
-0.0007359090377576649,
-0.2593405246734619,
0.06231378763914108,
-0.17235252261161804,
-0.127254918217659,
-0.5581694841384888,
-0.3876032829284668,
0.14438661932945251,
-0.2948710024356842,
-0.2001020759344101,
-0.4162692129611969,
0.12683464586734772,
0.8403284549713135,
-0.7546249628067017,
1.0204269886016846,
0.6933578252792358,
-0.102574922144413,
-0.7027711868286133,
-0.25900742411613464,
0.5493221879005432,
-0.8035118579864502,
0.5073134303092957,
0.4970562756061554,
-0.22056461870670319,
-0.40886592864990234,
-0.7353302836418152,
-0.6391715407371521,
1.0004429817199707,
0.37798187136650085,
-0.29942795634269714,
0.2375706136226654,
-0.3749504089355469,
0.14883604645729065,
-0.5761210322380066,
0.266480416059494,
0.5097810626029968,
0.3624406158924103,
-0.058177851140499115,
-0.8015186786651611,
0.12763312458992004,
-0.7633209824562073,
-0.2165582776069641,
0.3948740065097809,
-0.5553331971168518,
0.8620955944061279,
-1.145459771156311,
-0.07746468484401703,
0.31434008479118347,
0.12400946021080017,
0.5457847118377686,
0.6321672797203064,
0.5650202035903931,
0.6469384431838989,
0.358650267124176,
0.22613808512687683,
1.0630961656570435,
-0.377664178609848,
-0.01063966378569603,
0.9915477633476257,
-0.2573963701725006,
0.4464801847934723,
0.5539469718933105,
-0.011013013310730457,
0.3279167115688324,
0.05417608469724655,
-0.20548751950263977,
0.573260486125946,
0.21493135392665863,
-0.5184372067451477,
-0.06749846786260605,
-0.10422378778457642,
-0.2832365334033966,
0.6087396740913391,
0.1717205047607422,
-0.32523030042648315,
0.009943250566720963,
0.4208071529865265,
0.2490711659193039,
0.028313109651207924,
-0.34251677989959717,
0.7308073043823242,
-0.0779901072382927,
-0.4020985960960388,
0.5471969842910767,
-0.0466289296746254,
0.6096324920654297,
-0.4721335470676422,
-0.0005809016292914748,
0.04251231253147125,
0.25010865926742554,
-0.02342871204018593,
-0.558689296245575,
0.03826935216784477,
0.018620982766151428,
-0.000044023148802807555,
-0.07225330173969269,
0.892057478427887,
-0.177755668759346,
0.06455991417169571,
0.4534805119037628,
0.40790480375289917,
0.43874290585517883,
0.028373993933200836,
-0.5791621208190918,
0.04904818907380104,
-0.23186098039150238,
-0.4344329237937927,
0.7293064594268799,
0.21434344351291656,
0.15195928514003754,
1.0744870901107788,
0.6321884989738464,
0.16865627467632294,
0.1408361792564392,
-0.27713075280189514,
0.9447546601295471,
-0.6745462417602539,
-0.33701398968696594,
-1.37852144241333,
0.5693048238754272,
-0.06351757049560547,
0.14022241532802582,
0.7872467041015625,
0.20563745498657227,
0.38652029633522034,
0.03830210492014885,
0.797919511795044,
-0.134565070271492,
-0.14577190577983856,
-0.3254813253879547,
0.8264743685722351,
-0.33574503660202026,
0.2099256068468094,
-0.3870887756347656,
-0.17603524029254913,
0.11970443278551102,
0.3823164999485016,
0.16844876110553741,
-0.35000327229499817,
0.8361613750457764,
0.8125575184822083,
0.5326254367828369,
-0.1696534901857376,
0.432229608297348,
0.1363985687494278,
0.3447445333003998,
0.6668043732643127,
1.0389281511306763,
-0.18396276235580444,
0.7884973287582397,
-0.2392922341823578,
-0.3402697741985321,
0.022160468623042107,
-0.9177281856536865,
-0.9164441227912903,
-0.19134469330310822,
-0.12964239716529846,
-0.7644847631454468,
0.5835859775543213,
1.085349202156067,
0.6812781691551208,
-0.3744562566280365,
-0.18138645589351654,
0.1635701209306717,
0.40533098578453064,
-0.39646199345588684,
-0.20944346487522125,
-0.3171042203903198,
-0.3039815425872803,
-0.2135104238986969,
0.6007328629493713,
0.3241579234600067,
0.1815096139907837,
-0.14333413541316986,
-0.10475082695484161,
-0.21215303242206573,
-0.046017907559871674,
0.5619531273841858,
0.627461850643158,
-0.6242987513542175,
-0.07709269970655441,
-0.2888258993625641,
-0.336017370223999,
-0.08549198508262634,
0.7572806477546692,
-0.5778533220291138,
0.4374178946018219,
-0.01731201820075512,
0.6986923217773438,
0.0597340352833271,
-0.03912447392940521,
0.47865793108940125,
-0.5065622925758362,
0.5735992789268494,
0.037074580788612366,
0.3086356818675995,
-0.3216102719306946,
-0.6750743985176086,
0.22395040094852448,
0.45797067880630493,
-0.7626739144325256,
-0.7707359790802002,
0.2959269881248474,
-0.7790631651878357,
-0.8545418977737427,
1.0019563436508179,
-0.5330900549888611,
-0.4591456353664398,
-0.36402544379234314,
0.08007784187793732,
-0.19803018867969513,
-0.6119937300682068,
0.8226364254951477,
0.4201350808143616,
-0.12011592835187912,
-0.38283246755599976,
-0.7708567380905151,
0.09008746594190598,
-0.15749233961105347,
-0.8124940395355225,
-0.08601030707359314,
0.3674921989440918,
0.2949180603027344,
0.23329131305217743,
0.8439839482307434,
-0.03402911499142647,
0.6122384667396545,
0.24749596416950226,
0.02925921604037285,
-0.5563887357711792,
-0.6705190539360046,
-0.14404688775539398,
0.3182414770126343,
0.17575590312480927,
-0.29653051495552063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08562v1 | Higher Layers Need More LoRA Experts | 2024-02-13T16:04:21 | 2024-02-13T16:04:21 | Chongyang Gao, Kezhen Chen, Jinmeng Rao, Baochen Sun, Ruibo Liu, Daiyi Peng, Yawen Zhang, Xiaoyuan Guo, Jie Yang, VS Subrahmanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Parameter-efficient tuning (PEFT) techniques like low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
offer training efficiency on Large Language Models, but their impact on model
performance remains limited. Recent efforts integrate LoRA and
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) to improve the performance of PEFT methods. Despite
promising results, research on improving the efficiency of LoRA with MoE is
still in its early stages. Recent studies have shown that experts in the MoE
architecture have different strengths and also exhibit some redundancy. Does
this statement also apply to parameter-efficient MoE? In this paper, we
introduce a novel parameter-efficient MoE method,
\textit{\textbf{M}oE-L\textbf{o}RA with \textbf{L}ayer-wise Expert
\textbf{A}llocation (MoLA)} for Transformer-based models, where each model
layer has the flexibility to employ a varying number of LoRA experts. We
investigate several architectures with varying layer-wise expert
configurations. Experiments on six well-known NLP and commonsense QA benchmarks
demonstrate that MoLA achieves equal or superior performance compared to all
baselines. We find that allocating more LoRA experts to higher layers further
enhances the effectiveness of models with a certain number of experts in total.
With much fewer parameters, this allocation strategy outperforms the setting
with the same number of experts in every layer. This work can be widely used as
a plug-and-play parameter-efficient tuning approach for various applications.
The code is available at https://github.com/GCYZSL/MoLA. | [
-0.5599976181983948,
-0.6664520502090454,
0.2884988784790039,
0.23390509188175201,
-0.10462558269500732,
0.06919319927692413,
-0.2083122879266739,
-0.3200637400150299,
0.2520338296890259,
0.46113479137420654,
-0.1356804221868515,
-0.10585193336009979,
-0.5508495569229126,
-0.18119753897190094,
-0.16788309812545776,
0.6500577330589294,
0.23654532432556152,
-0.32994845509529114,
0.094693623483181,
-0.27080976963043213,
-0.2852924168109894,
-0.13083070516586304,
-0.65505450963974,
-0.45779868960380554,
0.8014676570892334,
0.38577404618263245,
0.7166227102279663,
0.5285103917121887,
0.49845564365386963,
0.3388482928276062,
-0.1973337084054947,
0.6368415951728821,
-0.5827314853668213,
-0.04779043793678284,
-0.23407329618930817,
-0.5231021642684937,
-0.9098247289657593,
-0.09969115257263184,
0.4070990979671478,
0.47153082489967346,
-0.5006712675094604,
0.05288730189204216,
-0.08707103133201599,
0.7178119421005249,
-0.9259031414985657,
-0.2076190859079361,
-1.1409341096878052,
-0.005621477495878935,
-0.04144086316227913,
-0.5226132869720459,
-0.6064997315406799,
-0.048373036086559296,
0.12217314541339874,
-0.780460000038147,
-0.1726752370595932,
0.20695312321186066,
0.8475258350372314,
0.5617548227310181,
-0.34051376581192017,
0.2750338315963745,
-0.5446130633354187,
0.9748469591140747,
-0.8637440800666809,
0.4666779041290283,
0.3318652808666229,
0.27698779106140137,
-0.03069179132580757,
-0.17840184271335602,
-0.32324865460395813,
0.06836389005184174,
0.17459313571453094,
0.21015284955501556,
-0.1670275330543518,
-0.21105565130710602,
0.07476174086332321,
0.204161137342453,
0.04054541140794754,
0.44543033838272095,
-0.4539831280708313,
-0.025032607838511467,
0.6787431240081787,
-0.16283796727657318,
-0.02202068641781807,
0.07220028340816498,
-0.3611801862716675,
0.03175918757915497,
-0.6789947748184204,
-0.08492504060268402,
0.5830181837081909,
0.16879068315029144,
0.07225559651851654,
0.27665504813194275,
-0.17473244667053223,
0.5669942498207092,
0.5012075304985046,
-0.5406793355941772,
0.3213610053062439,
0.13311739265918732,
-0.004345782101154327,
-0.15566515922546387,
0.5886023044586182,
0.013590024784207344,
0.16858462989330292,
-0.23543520271778107,
-0.20947562158107758,
-0.3646581172943115,
0.3842394948005676,
-0.5440934300422668,
-0.5041778087615967,
-0.06522727012634277,
-0.11531663686037064,
-0.36486443877220154,
-0.1284719705581665,
-0.6529585719108582,
-0.4257493317127228,
-0.1781761795282364,
0.7411007285118103,
-0.4335944652557373,
-0.3425540328025818,
0.23712168633937836,
-0.10852788388729095,
0.34773343801498413,
0.28525951504707336,
-0.9826321601867676,
0.10615023970603943,
0.623489499092102,
0.43964892625808716,
-0.25803953409194946,
-0.3832632005214691,
-0.8569016456604004,
0.2814328372478485,
-0.2398453652858734,
0.839417040348053,
-0.6269994974136353,
-0.10846683382987976,
-0.3550340533256531,
-0.510276198387146,
-0.4306633174419403,
-0.7088105082511902,
0.6220400929450989,
-0.7319343686103821,
0.21370212733745575,
-0.13479755818843842,
-0.10317177325487137,
-0.20573323965072632,
-0.16025789082050323,
-0.50457364320755,
1.3359713554382324,
0.26661351323127747,
-0.47201448678970337,
0.2861096262931824,
-0.9056224822998047,
-0.4858923852443695,
-0.07986748963594437,
-0.04163419082760811,
-0.4004095196723938,
0.4164641499519348,
0.7213374376296997,
0.45880773663520813,
-0.10632972419261932,
-0.10605504363775253,
-0.08953099697828293,
-0.41364365816116333,
0.18568022549152374,
-0.38788992166519165,
0.6412004232406616,
0.17544297873973846,
-0.1984717696905136,
-0.032098617404699326,
-0.9039182662963867,
0.13291636109352112,
-0.0650254487991333,
-0.7485009431838989,
-0.4355751872062683,
0.09264203161001205,
-0.2352149337530136,
-0.16875207424163818,
0.2368054836988449,
-0.17662622034549713,
0.13911671936511993,
-0.48855671286582947,
0.717159628868103,
0.9024893641471863,
-0.07245467603206635,
0.566908061504364,
-0.30519014596939087,
0.369397908449173,
0.16664201021194458,
0.16117547452449799,
-0.007360065821558237,
-0.5779134035110474,
-1.0671230554580688,
-0.42671331763267517,
0.4142582416534424,
0.4222180247306824,
-0.8764070868492126,
0.7894740104675293,
-0.22410574555397034,
-0.6079426407814026,
-0.93288254737854,
0.4072960913181305,
0.42322325706481934,
0.6047739386558533,
0.4434436857700348,
0.06966286152601242,
-0.2060486525297165,
-1.0283061265945435,
-0.3581114709377289,
-0.15990878641605377,
0.08214961737394333,
0.36339375376701355,
0.2830323874950409,
0.06356009095907211,
1.0328223705291748,
-0.5096840262413025,
-0.11878423392772675,
-0.026232147589325905,
-0.02143821492791176,
0.4260013699531555,
0.5005495548248291,
0.7596005797386169,
-0.646493136882782,
-0.6899412274360657,
0.3353799879550934,
-0.4202536642551422,
-0.19283641874790192,
0.25836434960365295,
-0.5392789244651794,
0.14321774244308472,
0.20522458851337433,
-0.3382073640823364,
-0.14001977443695068,
0.7930161356925964,
0.016861580312252045,
0.048033457249403,
-0.2429271787405014,
-0.0196389053016901,
-1.1050547361373901,
-0.05342165008187294,
-0.02623753994703293,
-0.2754109799861908,
-0.6658992767333984,
0.39600178599357605,
0.05743611603975296,
-0.05154591053724289,
-0.41430652141571045,
0.369809627532959,
-0.4053713083267212,
0.2824114263057709,
-0.1445147693157196,
0.09686098992824554,
0.0031387689523398876,
0.8155202865600586,
-0.22257469594478607,
0.8693640828132629,
0.6217306852340698,
-0.6100744009017944,
0.011793678626418114,
0.16999363899230957,
-0.5016017556190491,
0.7102483510971069,
-0.5963557958602905,
0.5378669500350952,
0.009394049644470215,
-0.1174493283033371,
-0.555182695388794,
-0.191855788230896,
0.2017029970884323,
-0.07777390629053116,
-0.019227640703320503,
-0.209926038980484,
-0.2977217137813568,
-0.12293075025081635,
-0.23640409111976624,
0.3216306269168854,
0.8150601387023926,
-0.6601423025131226,
1.1689412593841553,
0.48333650827407837,
-0.08912468701601028,
-0.6096389293670654,
-0.6776079535484314,
-0.1369973123073578,
-0.48413604497909546,
-0.661470890045166,
0.3832704424858093,
-0.20182745158672333,
-0.06111517548561096,
-0.14537975192070007,
-0.18919572234153748,
-0.29975801706314087,
0.39375609159469604,
-0.017499547451734543,
-0.16912347078323364,
-0.5329843759536743,
-0.0029805032536387444,
0.5023330450057983,
-0.3074148893356323,
-0.2206224501132965,
0.022457534447312355,
0.5267983675003052,
-0.18380169570446014,
-0.5422286987304688,
-0.4947502315044403,
0.35973674058914185,
0.5395700931549072,
-0.3746461272239685,
0.8881154656410217,
0.6030949354171753,
0.01658760942518711,
-0.48772966861724854,
-0.9935999512672424,
0.014612380415201187,
-0.5601298809051514,
0.41432300209999084,
-0.4990355670452118,
-0.5159494280815125,
0.53767329454422,
0.036968376487493515,
0.3251881003379822,
0.5296688079833984,
0.4150001108646393,
-0.03668808192014694,
0.763469934463501,
0.5763009786605835,
-0.3359583020210266,
0.5054570436477661,
-0.16189436614513397,
0.4464576542377472,
-0.7799679040908813,
0.044623732566833496,
-0.4345664083957672,
-0.5912393927574158,
-0.18806950747966766,
-0.5245539546012878,
0.7627972364425659,
0.253521203994751,
-0.14570939540863037,
0.3262690305709839,
-0.4924716353416443,
0.8353530764579773,
0.6732809543609619,
0.461988240480423,
0.5750100612640381,
0.26644617319107056,
0.2210349440574646,
0.3303627669811249,
-0.9853309392929077,
-0.16880486905574799,
0.811652421951294,
0.44016700983047485,
0.7274823784828186,
0.23484797775745392,
0.7083665728569031,
0.1513136476278305,
0.036827366799116135,
-0.7131814956665039,
0.6500460505485535,
-0.2861711084842682,
-0.44319310784339905,
-0.45293158292770386,
-0.2989742159843445,
-0.6010109186172485,
0.5165464282035828,
-0.31847211718559265,
-0.4962332546710968,
0.5793192982673645,
0.3008422255516052,
-0.6415895819664001,
0.43407946825027466,
-0.921680212020874,
0.12520095705986023,
-0.060821112245321274,
-0.12081804871559143,
-0.30716872215270996,
-0.25345471501350403,
0.05591645836830139,
-0.5050555467605591,
-0.13446223735809326,
-0.3152647912502289,
-0.20523673295974731,
0.7466866970062256,
-0.3622627556324005,
0.6116119623184204,
-0.3365817070007324,
-0.5346662998199463,
0.09066157788038254,
-0.3174937963485718,
0.7196268439292908,
-0.053467459976673126,
-0.7275739908218384,
0.1812434047460556,
-0.3051562011241913,
-0.6431710124015808,
-0.6678358316421509,
0.6898133158683777,
-1.117221474647522,
-0.7422153353691101,
0.2628140151500702,
-0.6094083786010742,
-0.5275089740753174,
0.11434172838926315,
0.30524569749832153,
0.34230634570121765,
0.4307968318462372,
0.6609714031219482,
0.8193421959877014,
-0.05968446657061577,
0.3356529772281647,
0.5253811478614807,
0.06213283911347389,
-0.2941657602787018,
0.9427709579467773,
0.12101699411869049,
0.2114351987838745,
0.6161242723464966,
0.4651576280593872,
0.20783773064613342,
-0.710707426071167,
-0.29441383481025696,
0.08827270567417145,
-0.6147750020027161,
-0.22777342796325684,
-0.6296408772468567,
-0.3102635443210602,
0.037083178758621216,
-0.37255823612213135,
-0.6102409958839417,
-0.31927743554115295,
-0.13876202702522278,
0.1302688866853714,
0.5453049540519714,
0.07887502014636993,
0.4057808220386505,
0.6922932863235474,
-0.4958620071411133,
0.3978303372859955,
0.5862334966659546,
0.321621835231781,
0.14869162440299988,
-0.6822741627693176,
-0.3111321032047272,
-0.12139752507209778,
-0.24131560325622559,
-0.5180844664573669,
0.06713351607322693,
0.5487241148948669,
0.8327645659446716,
0.5473306179046631,
0.2161489576101303,
0.878159761428833,
-0.34724438190460205,
0.5137617588043213,
0.06651246547698975,
-0.9543173909187317,
0.3227054178714752,
-0.5337655544281006,
0.09295593202114105,
0.5881347060203552,
0.06498155742883682,
0.2613878548145294,
-0.37189778685569763,
-0.37415245175361633,
-0.8226744532585144,
0.7040807008743286,
0.21529321372509003,
0.4130469262599945,
0.445382684469223,
0.3103365898132324,
0.3887227773666382,
0.06695036590099335,
-0.6241047978401184,
-0.190688818693161,
0.11122387647628784,
-0.06478829681873322,
0.19285383820533752,
-0.31698310375213623,
-0.3288956880569458,
-0.43233606219291687,
0.8512301445007324,
-0.3143044114112854,
0.27482470870018005,
-0.17895831167697906,
-0.18365274369716644,
-0.23512201011180878,
0.3506404161453247,
0.27956119179725647,
0.9830283522605896,
-0.15244188904762268,
-0.060981422662734985,
0.5729432702064514,
-0.08918172121047974,
-0.09322500973939896,
-0.1966988891363144,
-0.1794268786907196,
-0.18151183426380157,
0.3253220319747925,
0.9918667674064636,
0.42540985345840454,
-0.39696013927459717,
0.25779375433921814,
0.4893249571323395,
-0.5360411405563354,
0.03219952806830406,
0.72190922498703,
0.05003733932971954,
0.48227614164352417,
0.6933708190917969,
0.28694993257522583,
-0.24714641273021698,
-0.32880616188049316,
-0.2250475287437439,
0.15245629847049713,
0.04041804000735283,
-0.15557651221752167,
0.44520118832588196,
0.6494871973991394,
-0.42528170347213745,
0.3646751642227173,
0.15356533229351044,
-0.1473371833562851,
0.31790584325790405,
0.3413616716861725,
0.704697847366333,
-0.2185852974653244,
0.06807903200387955,
-0.10754050314426422,
0.036513399332761765,
-0.008333920501172543,
0.16788770258426666,
0.09662475436925888,
-0.8044998049736023,
-0.45693323016166687,
-0.485143780708313,
-0.32910242676734924,
-0.05274399369955063,
-0.604637086391449,
0.2436540275812149,
-0.41007503867149353,
-0.240126371383667,
0.11593815684318542,
-0.2503539025783539,
-0.5216567516326904,
-0.270078182220459,
-0.21958447992801666,
0.8865333199501038,
-0.6871576905250549,
0.9456379413604736,
0.7255184650421143,
0.019226349890232086,
-0.74941086769104,
0.06361695379018784,
-0.4851885437965393,
-1.1234548091888428,
0.490873247385025,
-0.38033315539360046,
-0.33558759093284607,
0.2081775665283203,
-0.31322944164276123,
-0.7703201174736023,
1.0589019060134888,
0.6436495184898376,
-0.5526282787322998,
-0.15570946037769318,
-0.22102250158786774,
0.5498790740966797,
-0.28605756163597107,
0.2245025783777237,
0.3966359496116638,
0.5762624740600586,
0.01062509324401617,
-0.9511163234710693,
-0.274159699678421,
-0.3371362090110779,
-0.016028305515646935,
0.31106916069984436,
-0.9167945981025696,
0.8710851669311523,
-0.06460927426815033,
0.14434106647968292,
0.1026996299624443,
0.8751890063285828,
0.25286006927490234,
0.052924949675798416,
0.9642943739891052,
0.39959001541137695,
0.902983546257019,
0.09379588812589645,
0.7411246299743652,
-0.4044056236743927,
0.2856330871582031,
0.8278528451919556,
-0.02056247740983963,
1.2283765077590942,
0.5449274182319641,
-0.31897473335266113,
0.6225366592407227,
0.14031364023685455,
-0.06624290347099304,
0.5655109882354736,
-0.21129384636878967,
0.07720598578453064,
-0.5895143747329712,
0.1291620433330536,
-0.5345050096511841,
0.45430102944374084,
0.01322427298873663,
-0.3222087025642395,
-0.05593549832701683,
-0.15098385512828827,
-0.1304711550474167,
0.04270581901073456,
-0.2776637077331543,
0.7154240608215332,
-0.022919129580259323,
-0.5506219863891602,
0.7634525895118713,
0.033770736306905746,
0.7332063317298889,
-0.5408602356910706,
0.27165278792381287,
-0.24820813536643982,
0.21474003791809082,
-0.3467910587787628,
-0.35413432121276855,
-0.1886134296655655,
-0.16973689198493958,
-0.33924582600593567,
-0.09641898423433304,
0.49125662446022034,
-0.3528560400009155,
-0.68925940990448,
0.08366313576698303,
0.6737329363822937,
0.016847247257828712,
-0.21832621097564697,
-0.5257603526115417,
-0.2740028500556946,
-0.16991399228572845,
-0.3666192591190338,
0.4003640115261078,
0.2749771773815155,
0.04215395450592041,
0.7418598532676697,
0.5208079814910889,
0.09500142186880112,
0.30014851689338684,
0.06325170397758484,
0.9736576676368713,
-0.30886760354042053,
-0.5541650056838989,
-0.5653116703033447,
0.571083664894104,
-0.06468921899795532,
-0.39081260561943054,
0.5867778658866882,
0.30743274092674255,
0.54133540391922,
-0.22314170002937317,
0.5188254714012146,
0.14769330620765686,
0.4417782127857208,
-0.7822978496551514,
0.7156235575675964,
-0.7667062878608704,
0.4288748502731323,
-0.2779887914657593,
-1.1761635541915894,
-0.010731608606874943,
0.4735145568847656,
-0.24777130782604218,
0.21094132959842682,
0.4862031936645508,
0.867016077041626,
-0.37983182072639465,
-0.1634151190519333,
0.36201757192611694,
0.26407697796821594,
0.2312232404947281,
0.5894879102706909,
0.7806257009506226,
-0.4712096154689789,
0.44070354104042053,
-0.32603374123573303,
-0.1338447630405426,
-0.5234172344207764,
-0.9490271806716919,
-0.9450652003288269,
-0.3449574410915375,
-0.5036336779594421,
0.30113282799720764,
0.10892468690872192,
0.9134342670440674,
1.1089874505996704,
-0.8531816005706787,
0.10815601050853729,
0.3493788242340088,
0.11750183254480362,
-0.5500295162200928,
-0.1766524314880371,
0.4276745021343231,
-0.09293796867132187,
-0.9571152925491333,
0.7537604570388794,
0.24762868881225586,
-0.5464740991592407,
-0.3819986581802368,
-0.1795090138912201,
0.021493829786777496,
0.2816915214061737,
0.771503746509552,
0.009962127543985844,
-0.9041768312454224,
-0.24329230189323425,
-0.236432284116745,
0.16984079778194427,
0.2647014558315277,
0.5080039501190186,
-0.5938602685928345,
0.1483929455280304,
0.6546355485916138,
0.804139256477356,
0.07160703837871552,
0.22249017655849457,
0.589013397693634,
-0.7156934142112732,
-0.07320306450128555,
0.05239925533533096,
0.33174875378608704,
-0.08886533230543137,
-0.37544897198677063,
0.6517415046691895,
0.04257107526063919,
-0.393375039100647,
-0.8608977198600769,
-0.044047921895980835,
-1.3563772439956665,
-0.09726368635892868,
1.0929155349731445,
0.03487464785575867,
0.02849067933857441,
0.06112342327833176,
-0.3508332073688507,
-0.32700440287590027,
-0.7835161089897156,
0.9277621507644653,
0.445615291595459,
-0.1303972750902176,
-0.4221968948841095,
-0.38164636492729187,
-0.07894375920295715,
0.7029363512992859,
-0.8173677921295166,
-0.29568254947662354,
-0.10247046500444412,
0.14677616953849792,
0.3286806643009186,
0.368125855922699,
0.20270591974258423,
0.04614986851811409,
-0.23434753715991974,
-0.2746565341949463,
-0.5631179809570312,
-0.44629958271980286,
-0.003839820623397827,
0.4321832060813904,
0.2391357272863388,
0.01651027798652649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08526v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08526v3 | Can LLMs Learn New Concepts Incrementally without Forgetting? | 2024-02-13T15:29:50 | 2024-06-18T06:56:44 | Junhao Zheng, Shengjie Qiu, Qianli Ma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across various
tasks, yet their ability to learn incrementally without forgetting remains
underexplored. Incremental learning (IL) is crucial as it enables models to
acquire new knowledge while retaining previously learned information, akin to
human learning. Existing benchmarks for IL are insufficient due to data leakage
issues and the overqualification of LLMs. To address these challenges, we
introduce Concept-1K, a novel dataset comprising 1,023 recently emerged
concepts across diverse domains. The concepts in Concept-1K are discrete,
interpretable units of knowledge that allow for fine-grained analysis of
learning and forgetting processes. Using Concept-1K as a testbed, we aim to
answer the question: ``Can LLMs learn new concepts incrementally without
forgetting like humans?'' Our investigation reveals that LLMs still suffer from
catastrophic forgetting and that LoRA, despite fine-tuning fewer parameters,
may lead to more forgetting on training data. Additionally, we explore the
roles of in-context learning, model scale, buffer size, and pretraining in IL
performance. These findings highlight the strengths and limitations of LLMs in
IL scenarios and provide a robust benchmark for future research. | [
-0.3289584815502167,
-0.8165653944015503,
0.30998921394348145,
-0.017412889748811722,
-0.2434578239917755,
0.38706448674201965,
0.0616474375128746,
-0.39002731442451477,
0.09523452073335648,
0.38795432448387146,
-0.7140144109725952,
-0.49660637974739075,
-0.6523515582084656,
0.017424825578927994,
-0.3428879976272583,
0.7189993858337402,
-0.07732728868722916,
-0.1149585023522377,
-0.4197046458721161,
-0.3817358911037445,
-0.6943503618240356,
-0.45626842975616455,
-0.8351883888244629,
-0.5751293301582336,
0.6484264135360718,
0.6660072207450867,
0.11149438470602036,
0.5652098655700684,
0.3899560570716858,
0.1970197856426239,
-0.026094887405633926,
0.12647715210914612,
-0.6824026703834534,
0.12772655487060547,
-0.1738923043012619,
-0.6222735047340393,
-0.3802085518836975,
0.04428722709417343,
1.0618038177490234,
1.0469698905944824,
-0.33389711380004883,
0.06738495081663132,
0.0729655921459198,
1.015934944152832,
-0.6533759832382202,
0.05343621224164963,
-1.102507472038269,
0.2538819909095764,
-0.10729939490556717,
-0.16775815188884735,
-0.27815133333206177,
-0.3233322501182556,
0.24259258806705475,
-0.5948777198791504,
0.11029553413391113,
-0.22557303309440613,
0.7876320481300354,
0.5300694108009338,
-0.03816730156540871,
-0.6092684864997864,
-0.4270024001598358,
0.5419631600379944,
-0.49511802196502686,
0.3728469908237457,
0.4710004925727844,
0.09940819442272186,
0.03397829458117485,
-0.42507991194725037,
-0.48375746607780457,
-0.3932279646396637,
0.24136562645435333,
0.03633047267794609,
0.20215141773223877,
-0.40478813648223877,
0.28409236669540405,
0.1767113357782364,
-0.29644298553466797,
0.37038180232048035,
-0.2727371156215668,
0.0027764965780079365,
0.4066791534423828,
0.21930339932441711,
-0.03132416307926178,
0.10589738190174103,
-0.5077818632125854,
0.003439550055190921,
-1.1516573429107666,
-0.020022055134177208,
-0.03537360951304436,
0.2570677101612091,
-0.235603466629982,
0.24500150978565216,
-0.20698338747024536,
0.17175263166427612,
-0.07562246918678284,
-0.2956351637840271,
0.2545662224292755,
-0.14817100763320923,
-0.05768771842122078,
0.04653024673461914,
0.3915388286113739,
-0.34343165159225464,
0.2355991005897522,
-0.37917807698249817,
0.017216769978404045,
-0.006000044755637646,
0.27899619936943054,
-0.5564155578613281,
-0.1762024462223053,
0.0811738520860672,
0.07852829992771149,
0.10236156731843948,
-0.034777700901031494,
-0.2732931077480316,
-0.3463743031024933,
-0.22888773679733276,
0.38986364006996155,
-0.6736657619476318,
-0.3987012803554535,
-0.04856739565730095,
0.13621269166469574,
0.33438098430633545,
0.44154754281044006,
-0.6372478008270264,
0.4312392771244049,
0.7050786018371582,
0.8703112602233887,
-0.4624849557876587,
-0.6065887808799744,
-0.2635188102722168,
-0.04720044136047363,
-0.7724007368087769,
0.7784680128097534,
-0.40718698501586914,
-0.45560479164123535,
-0.17593814432621002,
-0.23067262768745422,
-0.16199035942554474,
-0.9474318027496338,
0.02370094321668148,
-0.37971317768096924,
-0.4015829265117645,
-0.3950222432613373,
-0.859032928943634,
0.1261201947927475,
0.40947118401527405,
-0.5389062166213989,
0.8742755651473999,
0.2349691540002823,
-0.594572901725769,
0.5368592143058777,
-0.390947163105011,
-0.33545079827308655,
0.23082885146141052,
-0.333517849445343,
-0.46436169743537903,
0.3614863455295563,
-0.40342873334884644,
0.44053390622138977,
-0.1324578821659088,
0.06794557720422745,
-0.34850960969924927,
-0.3584023714065552,
0.43034058809280396,
-0.29938000440597534,
0.2973507046699524,
0.028588462620973587,
0.1432013064622879,
-0.26932212710380554,
-0.8323293924331665,
-0.10609280318021774,
0.2775334119796753,
-0.5257097482681274,
-0.2975650429725647,
0.00910840556025505,
-0.7049200534820557,
0.26916956901550293,
0.1224788948893547,
-0.5406509041786194,
0.36636531352996826,
-0.11746688187122345,
0.40398287773132324,
0.7657639384269714,
0.1091231033205986,
0.3534330427646637,
-0.39151832461357117,
0.5044640898704529,
0.40163540840148926,
-0.30004239082336426,
-0.7675366401672363,
-0.05150379613041878,
-1.036300778388977,
-0.20726172626018524,
0.21858274936676025,
0.3627084791660309,
-0.7141455411911011,
0.12559163570404053,
-0.381459504365921,
-0.4093460738658905,
-0.23997405171394348,
0.3544559180736542,
0.2993077337741852,
0.565000057220459,
0.10974607616662979,
-0.37403419613838196,
-0.357776015996933,
-0.4230472147464752,
0.05748429894447327,
0.01246756874024868,
0.18335993587970734,
0.2999141812324524,
0.7183054685592651,
-0.1182747483253479,
0.7840255498886108,
-0.3131014406681061,
-0.30713409185409546,
-0.25374528765678406,
0.09066863358020782,
-0.12533371150493622,
0.4310011565685272,
0.08074917644262314,
-0.4355888068675995,
-0.3380564749240875,
-0.002581828273832798,
-1.0377751588821411,
0.3778081238269806,
-0.11007850617170334,
0.16322773694992065,
0.2560577094554901,
0.8530368804931641,
-0.6343700289726257,
0.16561196744441986,
0.1899951845407486,
-0.21343256533145905,
0.4707757234573364,
-0.31241491436958313,
-0.4710734188556671,
-0.8323639631271362,
-0.16953019797801971,
-0.16275182366371155,
-0.08703488856554031,
-0.34388142824172974,
0.05474993214011192,
0.21477608382701874,
0.07382725924253464,
-0.544604480266571,
0.8098912835121155,
-0.2257373332977295,
0.07850579172372818,
-0.25803712010383606,
0.15011750161647797,
-0.17366814613342285,
0.45007163286209106,
0.07795652747154236,
0.5698326230049133,
0.6567825078964233,
-0.9835488796234131,
-0.05213286727666855,
0.2505861222743988,
-0.57405686378479,
0.5509464144706726,
-0.44893425703048706,
0.4324846863746643,
-0.27378836274147034,
0.33904221653938293,
-0.8346381187438965,
-0.15405458211898804,
0.0049331337213516235,
-0.4683302044868469,
0.42399853467941284,
0.09994190186262131,
-0.628173291683197,
-0.07944901287555695,
-0.17416083812713623,
0.14733922481536865,
0.30849286913871765,
-0.23204979300498962,
0.2651384472846985,
0.4602513015270233,
-0.373086154460907,
-0.5924029350280762,
-0.44447582960128784,
-0.09001705050468445,
-0.3039436638355255,
-0.07298225164413452,
-0.031487781554460526,
0.009029984474182129,
-0.04102880507707596,
-0.08714896440505981,
-0.299446165561676,
-0.16179144382476807,
0.31406664848327637,
0.3315635025501251,
0.1436721831560135,
-0.02543497458100319,
0.7041605114936829,
-0.2613546848297119,
-0.2801702618598938,
0.018015548586845398,
-0.4100639522075653,
0.6250826120376587,
0.08720483630895615,
-0.4580056071281433,
-0.2681887149810791,
0.19151923060417175,
0.5117912292480469,
-0.053623050451278687,
0.7292486429214478,
0.4384750425815582,
-0.4994744658470154,
-0.30067530274391174,
-0.4567767381668091,
-0.1949571669101715,
-0.40738776326179504,
0.7495779991149902,
-0.5588977336883545,
-1.103125810623169,
0.5011288523674011,
-0.36916738748550415,
0.024590112268924713,
0.25920096039772034,
0.2864919900894165,
-0.39797985553741455,
0.37954962253570557,
1.0106396675109863,
-0.3368648290634155,
0.3571681082248688,
-0.4318884611129761,
-0.1133992150425911,
-0.8428236842155457,
-0.20801232755184174,
-0.29216468334198,
-0.276592493057251,
-0.46803590655326843,
-0.25548726320266724,
0.3570929765701294,
0.3931729793548584,
-0.45449233055114746,
-0.06448094546794891,
0.11501206457614899,
0.6206607222557068,
0.26383480429649353,
0.06808067858219147,
0.4594585597515106,
0.027890590950846672,
-0.12544244527816772,
0.1515817791223526,
-0.8343347907066345,
-0.31513452529907227,
1.1654611825942993,
0.5276062488555908,
0.777290403842926,
-0.176010861992836,
0.7202522158622742,
0.23913660645484924,
0.4847378432750702,
-0.6098259687423706,
0.43175917863845825,
-0.09435844421386719,
-0.4220813512802124,
-0.40643954277038574,
-0.46599456667900085,
-0.8222760558128357,
-0.0070006586611270905,
0.034943412989377975,
-0.7122256755828857,
-0.06178191304206848,
0.2718808054924011,
-0.48489120602607727,
0.3427062928676605,
-0.5054647922515869,
0.6104102730751038,
-0.0525599829852581,
-0.2776727080345154,
-0.33547765016555786,
-0.3298991620540619,
0.2975936233997345,
-0.5194182395935059,
0.03615979477763176,
-0.5615519881248474,
-0.21607446670532227,
0.5098767280578613,
-0.11357489973306656,
0.8879818916320801,
-0.19503578543663025,
-0.4216344356536865,
0.4595886468887329,
0.012664041481912136,
0.5844268798828125,
0.10204610228538513,
0.007662126328796148,
0.292266845703125,
-0.27250564098358154,
-0.5209158658981323,
-0.41929686069488525,
0.7358049750328064,
-0.6581574082374573,
-0.27843397855758667,
-0.3080783784389496,
-0.4602159261703491,
-0.47582048177719116,
-0.12808452546596527,
0.38335973024368286,
0.1041354313492775,
-0.2605632543563843,
0.20010146498680115,
1.1136431694030762,
-0.3171294331550598,
0.2892453968524933,
0.727810263633728,
-0.11203192174434662,
-0.10650917887687683,
1.2336506843566895,
0.4808068573474884,
0.6308507919311523,
0.46656012535095215,
0.06199386715888977,
-0.12552040815353394,
-0.709530770778656,
-0.1275397390127182,
0.2451668381690979,
-0.7680996656417847,
-0.16426081955432892,
-0.7253819108009338,
-0.2992155849933624,
0.09019695967435837,
-0.01821151189506054,
-0.681954026222229,
-0.316104918718338,
0.00279481359757483,
-0.17299847304821014,
0.20691846311092377,
0.7999258041381836,
0.13769270479679108,
0.2446255087852478,
-0.5606641173362732,
0.2972032427787781,
0.37361761927604675,
0.41944554448127747,
0.23443041741847992,
-0.6533621549606323,
-0.4516950249671936,
-0.12380287051200867,
-0.4136370122432709,
-0.13431879878044128,
0.1981315165758133,
0.4116125702857971,
0.370076447725296,
0.37151020765304565,
-0.22761863470077515,
0.6182637214660645,
-0.604798436164856,
0.4315800666809082,
0.12135135382413864,
-0.7056463360786438,
0.5233464241027832,
-0.18269775807857513,
0.7575958967208862,
0.5785775184631348,
0.5586363673210144,
-0.6701916456222534,
-0.20009984076023102,
-0.5288419127464294,
-0.7421057224273682,
0.6200485825538635,
-0.1600208878517151,
0.3647315502166748,
-0.12188471108675003,
0.6429873108863831,
0.4817720949649811,
0.28893446922302246,
-0.6142423152923584,
-0.35753288865089417,
-0.06267496943473816,
0.0027812286280095577,
-0.1516975611448288,
-0.2653847634792328,
0.2063310593366623,
-0.36142224073410034,
0.5015808343887329,
-0.2347247451543808,
0.20808927714824677,
-0.11791107058525085,
-0.3311368227005005,
-0.06997328251600266,
0.16438879072666168,
0.46279484033584595,
0.9750800132751465,
-0.09406164288520813,
-0.022322624921798706,
0.5941978693008423,
-0.5508980751037598,
0.36702847480773926,
-0.29975342750549316,
-0.18518303334712982,
-0.1571972519159317,
0.5289722681045532,
0.6752802729606628,
0.3881237208843231,
-0.8773619532585144,
0.0666341632604599,
-0.018547384068369865,
-0.22011524438858032,
-0.5671849846839905,
0.24574874341487885,
0.4027857184410095,
-0.015739675611257553,
0.49681079387664795,
0.03347829356789589,
-0.5223631262779236,
-0.8022094964981079,
0.38091689348220825,
0.5280331969261169,
-0.6101994514465332,
-0.3644903302192688,
0.3010975122451782,
-0.0837821364402771,
-0.017696306109428406,
0.6265515685081482,
-0.3203192353248596,
-0.10595930367708206,
0.6508693695068359,
0.3799792230129242,
0.7367405891418457,
-0.3091971278190613,
0.16282428801059723,
0.4550068974494934,
0.18942159414291382,
-0.06561330705881119,
0.1401839554309845,
-0.13413746654987335,
-1.064405083656311,
-0.2986002564430237,
-0.620781421661377,
-0.5367327928543091,
0.4215645492076874,
-0.5014947652816772,
-0.03642631322145462,
-0.8495394587516785,
0.21995338797569275,
0.05434468388557434,
0.11385635286569595,
-0.75025475025177,
0.20215575397014618,
0.19172902405261993,
1.0888608694076538,
-0.5820746421813965,
1.3114030361175537,
0.41380661725997925,
-0.3217408061027527,
-0.622240424156189,
-0.1216852217912674,
-0.008965739980340004,
-0.8373057246208191,
0.7303107380867004,
0.26320937275886536,
-0.14491663873195648,
0.11277994513511658,
-0.7090944647789001,
-0.9409112334251404,
1.1684331893920898,
0.33298081159591675,
-0.5509936809539795,
0.028593529015779495,
0.32365676760673523,
0.26750436425209045,
-0.6006273627281189,
-0.06620031595230103,
0.7209298610687256,
0.12379724532365799,
0.33249804377555847,
-0.629227876663208,
-0.4572988450527191,
-0.09890624135732651,
-0.22108814120292664,
0.0895170196890831,
-0.7602490782737732,
1.0817726850509644,
-0.4333970546722412,
-0.27056875824928284,
0.09320474416017532,
0.45262449979782104,
0.17229758203029633,
0.2929857671260834,
0.24372154474258423,
0.9118212461471558,
0.9030254483222961,
-0.08068685978651047,
0.8579363822937012,
-0.013871870003640652,
0.2779247760772705,
1.545291543006897,
-0.47012418508529663,
1.0993413925170898,
0.09151257574558258,
-0.3076794147491455,
0.4272543787956238,
0.5941864252090454,
0.3936968445777893,
0.48653703927993774,
0.14915674924850464,
-0.36710792779922485,
-0.23341402411460876,
-0.07059342414140701,
-0.3379810154438019,
0.4999277591705322,
0.7271871566772461,
0.10893985629081726,
-0.18871335685253143,
0.15298070013523102,
0.0008266375516541302,
-0.12274425476789474,
-0.4738229215145111,
1.0263831615447998,
0.3677668869495392,
-0.4650067687034607,
0.8913351893424988,
-0.31534555554389954,
0.6789968609809875,
-0.9924007654190063,
0.007220114581286907,
-0.5495182275772095,
0.43927088379859924,
0.09267240762710571,
-0.35015246272087097,
0.14942285418510437,
-0.16790515184402466,
-0.16714678704738617,
0.06866815686225891,
0.38758715987205505,
-0.4202170968055725,
-0.5473120212554932,
0.10075301676988602,
0.72052401304245,
0.004719036631286144,
-0.16689586639404297,
-0.5255185961723328,
0.17488276958465576,
-0.1793793886899948,
0.15343868732452393,
0.5390300750732422,
0.6185312271118164,
-0.0677410140633583,
1.3627328872680664,
0.2212691754102707,
0.1450224369764328,
0.20473554730415344,
-0.08904117345809937,
0.7064242362976074,
-0.8910635113716125,
-0.2286328375339508,
-0.9049187898635864,
0.13408797979354858,
0.26564088463783264,
-0.4941185712814331,
0.8061227202415466,
0.3836679756641388,
1.2155708074569702,
0.07808215171098709,
0.9515340328216553,
0.2981218695640564,
0.7068050503730774,
-0.6065967679023743,
0.5497110486030579,
-0.3931305408477783,
0.39771831035614014,
-0.1620568335056305,
-0.5860888957977295,
0.07513799518346786,
0.4781190752983093,
-0.00325789419002831,
-0.08985660970211029,
0.7821310758590698,
0.47544416785240173,
0.1446671336889267,
-0.08258633315563202,
0.4378744959831238,
0.3321477174758911,
0.10187356173992157,
0.7117234468460083,
0.9669062495231628,
-0.27036961913108826,
0.13266095519065857,
-0.050049152225255966,
0.10891792178153992,
0.07521121203899384,
-0.7014827728271484,
-0.7287870049476624,
-0.5910077691078186,
-0.5324541926383972,
0.02988956682384014,
0.11704377830028534,
0.9725546836853027,
0.6759443879127502,
-0.8113910555839539,
-0.250355064868927,
-0.3287378251552582,
0.35088980197906494,
-0.07856794446706772,
-0.11010007560253143,
0.19588643312454224,
-0.6968252658843994,
-0.43389803171157837,
0.24761180579662323,
0.5045239329338074,
0.11590123921632767,
-0.5404075980186462,
-0.2634763717651367,
-0.2738102078437805,
0.0034831517841666937,
0.6388713717460632,
0.5128419399261475,
-0.5607377886772156,
-0.05370686948299408,
-0.26555559039115906,
0.10234280675649643,
0.2978055775165558,
0.9179654717445374,
-1.2406439781188965,
0.2735709249973297,
-0.1888064444065094,
0.8025436401367188,
0.43029552698135376,
-0.1852397471666336,
0.15231262147426605,
-0.9720596075057983,
0.3070111572742462,
0.19321630895137787,
0.1360735148191452,
0.418253630399704,
0.02430438995361328,
0.4114682674407959,
0.19650466740131378,
-0.1571716070175171,
-0.6512589454650879,
0.3109991252422333,
-0.3976706862449646,
-0.376282274723053,
0.736365795135498,
-0.3220827579498291,
0.16683804988861084,
-0.2197655439376831,
0.216831237077713,
-0.13665109872817993,
-0.11937139928340912,
0.870498776435852,
0.9207548499107361,
-0.0027474183589220047,
-0.3898230195045471,
-0.7807047367095947,
0.5241258144378662,
0.21590173244476318,
-0.9554067254066467,
0.07316043227910995,
0.18380539119243622,
0.4998362064361572,
0.08922108262777328,
0.8042017817497253,
0.050175219774246216,
0.036370713263750076,
0.12239059060811996,
-0.27976951003074646,
0.11578814685344696,
-0.579075038433075,
-0.2484884262084961,
0.1700054109096527,
0.17811143398284912,
-0.1434117555618286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08498v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08498v4 | Auditing Counterfire: Evaluating Advanced Counterargument Generation with Evidence and Style | 2024-02-13T14:53:12 | 2024-04-20T03:47:18 | Preetika Verma, Kokil Jaidka, Svetlana Churina | cs.CL | cs.CL | We audited large language models (LLMs) for their ability to create
evidence-based and stylistic counter-arguments to posts from the Reddit
ChangeMyView dataset. We benchmarked their rhetorical quality across a host of
qualitative and quantitative metrics and then ultimately evaluated them on
their persuasive abilities as compared to human counter-arguments. Our
evaluation is based on Counterfire: a new dataset of 32,000 counter-arguments
generated from large language models (LLMs): GPT-3.5 Turbo and Koala and their
fine-tuned variants, and PaLM 2, with varying prompts for evidence use and
argumentative style. GPT-3.5 Turbo ranked highest in argument quality with
strong paraphrasing and style adherence, particularly in `reciprocity' style
arguments. However, the stylistic counter-arguments still fall short of human
persuasive standards, where people also preferred reciprocal to evidence-based
rebuttals. The findings suggest that a balance between evidentiality and
stylistic elements is vital to a compelling counter-argument. We close with a
discussion of future research directions and implications for evaluating LLM
outputs. | [
-0.3639328181743622,
-0.7937688231468201,
0.5464852452278137,
0.08690060675144196,
-0.5077796578407288,
0.017965402454137802,
0.006425225641578436,
-0.11128304898738861,
0.17034637928009033,
0.5233963131904602,
-0.40113550424575806,
-0.41881200671195984,
-0.629483163356781,
0.2835942804813385,
-0.4841630756855011,
1.01244056224823,
-0.04976100102066994,
0.06808625161647797,
-0.17390650510787964,
-0.2461581826210022,
-0.7107967734336853,
-0.5574547648429871,
-0.4228464663028717,
-0.48815613985061646,
0.5886545181274414,
0.5620427131652832,
0.5890777111053467,
0.4276914596557617,
0.2614670991897583,
0.22830799221992493,
0.2678041458129883,
-0.2123776525259018,
-0.5170605182647705,
0.2552509009838104,
-0.45136934518814087,
-0.21044519543647766,
-0.3344790041446686,
0.04155515879392624,
0.21047534048557281,
-0.0033115106634795666,
-0.20012067258358002,
0.12365224212408066,
-0.23615844547748566,
0.527681827545166,
-0.7457269430160522,
-0.17049577832221985,
-1.1668771505355835,
-0.33790725469589233,
-0.37174031138420105,
-0.3803943395614624,
-0.42930465936660767,
-0.6084717512130737,
0.2601235508918762,
-0.4250365197658539,
0.09111763536930084,
-0.1177520677447319,
1.0521435737609863,
0.02680087275803089,
-0.43894311785697937,
-0.6040161848068237,
-0.5192838907241821,
0.6566951870918274,
-1.0092442035675049,
0.18546275794506073,
-0.0035290399100631475,
0.24715162813663483,
-0.07203520089387894,
-0.946042537689209,
-0.5272576808929443,
0.07048118114471436,
-0.06623345613479614,
0.2998679280281067,
-0.8464304804801941,
-0.15502366423606873,
0.1488756239414215,
0.09860622882843018,
-0.7251171469688416,
0.12683407962322235,
-0.12328162789344788,
-0.24368929862976074,
0.7531380653381348,
0.20009665191173553,
0.07142464816570282,
0.04050131142139435,
-0.12255778163671494,
-0.29870617389678955,
-1.1507633924484253,
-0.18932613730430603,
0.6178349256515503,
0.0037151917349547148,
0.16253213584423065,
0.2903198301792145,
-0.30045169591903687,
0.2915653884410858,
0.19136804342269897,
-0.019865667447447777,
-0.28131359815597534,
-0.5497165322303772,
-0.13896512985229492,
0.2394501119852066,
0.970808744430542,
0.7522553205490112,
0.49288254976272583,
0.23256605863571167,
-0.11005360633134842,
0.2705758810043335,
0.4678633213043213,
-1.0091934204101562,
-0.471010684967041,
0.051576849073171616,
-0.5219686031341553,
-0.32941246032714844,
-0.09355858713388443,
-1.0265778303146362,
-0.44865015149116516,
-0.0744471549987793,
0.31380695104599,
-0.2170657515525818,
-0.4253496825695038,
0.048880960792303085,
-0.3044200539588928,
-0.019417988136410713,
0.09458239376544952,
-0.8339733481407166,
0.08962009102106094,
0.8223332166671753,
0.6327179074287415,
0.12730328738689423,
0.026292940601706505,
-0.39543792605400085,
-0.13840198516845703,
-0.7809202075004578,
1.21300208568573,
-1.027021884918213,
-0.5347524285316467,
0.2082844227552414,
0.03752703592181206,
0.0865970179438591,
-0.8019199371337891,
0.8849145174026489,
-0.4231386184692383,
0.2619284689426422,
-0.5635501742362976,
-0.42425063252449036,
-0.35693082213401794,
0.23031586408615112,
-0.2702568769454956,
0.7055259943008423,
-0.13066445291042328,
-0.548589825630188,
0.823065459728241,
-0.4490896165370941,
-0.4777846336364746,
0.10129053890705109,
-0.30815109610557556,
-0.6361175179481506,
0.2344357818365097,
0.20878462493419647,
0.06061839684844017,
-0.5346889495849609,
0.5246621370315552,
-0.32073622941970825,
-0.11543439328670502,
0.127364844083786,
-0.3540080487728119,
0.49112585186958313,
0.35537034273147583,
-0.4959360659122467,
0.3530319631099701,
-0.6898303031921387,
0.06314318627119064,
0.1995096206665039,
-0.11438548564910889,
-0.3518206477165222,
-0.00010663305874913931,
-0.1763618141412735,
0.11638250201940536,
0.07556310296058655,
-0.6001764535903931,
0.05752788111567497,
-0.13965126872062683,
0.6020485758781433,
0.7005130052566528,
0.27701061964035034,
-0.3406915068626404,
-0.550193727016449,
0.576566755771637,
-0.25905534625053406,
-0.2522386908531189,
-0.34993085265159607,
-0.5287759304046631,
-0.4659757912158966,
0.054935913532972336,
0.024623539298772812,
0.4972996115684509,
-0.41464880108833313,
0.2057427167892456,
-0.15290747582912445,
-0.8713832497596741,
-0.22775591909885406,
-0.021925052627921104,
0.49557027220726013,
0.5267119407653809,
0.311694860458374,
-0.34278857707977295,
-0.808566153049469,
-0.9472646713256836,
-0.8347592353820801,
-0.37560009956359863,
-0.029783474281430244,
0.1879960596561432,
0.6850621700286865,
0.06843508034944534,
0.876645028591156,
-0.21924535930156708,
0.46751534938812256,
-0.1735406219959259,
0.8003525137901306,
0.13421322405338287,
0.3618013262748718,
0.6356093287467957,
-0.3350883424282074,
-0.46707361936569214,
-0.33018696308135986,
-0.7950958609580994,
-0.7697962522506714,
-0.3347599506378174,
0.023358553647994995,
0.1846775859594345,
0.3657275140285492,
-0.5789775848388672,
0.4136963486671448,
0.24856726825237274,
-0.44961583614349365,
0.8615902066230774,
0.4001668393611908,
0.43438440561294556,
-0.7186200022697449,
-0.005478535313159227,
0.027366550639271736,
0.15620972216129303,
-0.637227475643158,
-0.02920777164399624,
-0.12695206701755524,
0.03240177407860756,
-0.3386143445968628,
0.6045078039169312,
-0.07103521376848221,
0.2522801160812378,
-0.35544103384017944,
-0.10866688936948776,
0.20861974358558655,
0.08934438973665237,
0.20115044713020325,
0.8798732757568359,
0.22403427958488464,
-0.3268658518791199,
0.5883455276489258,
-0.10649753361940384,
-0.5378080606460571,
0.997734010219574,
-0.9727073907852173,
0.29263705015182495,
0.2366032600402832,
0.5307278037071228,
-1.1553049087524414,
-0.08639022707939148,
-0.03515345975756645,
-0.21884271502494812,
0.12759600579738617,
-0.3745853900909424,
-0.36496466398239136,
-0.2151714563369751,
-0.3916715085506439,
0.19255265593528748,
0.5111101269721985,
-0.4460547864437103,
0.339933842420578,
-0.001800872152671218,
-0.42648231983184814,
-0.4290454387664795,
-0.4606461226940155,
0.5861513614654541,
-0.7000671625137329,
-0.45921027660369873,
0.22466564178466797,
-0.012952819466590881,
-0.6964485049247742,
-0.2876987159252167,
-0.19636282324790955,
0.3659459054470062,
-0.04731707647442818,
0.11159881949424744,
-0.0832582339644432,
-0.49524107575416565,
-0.019441772252321243,
-0.09187396615743637,
0.011734622530639172,
0.3054247498512268,
-0.06691575050354004,
0.7173373699188232,
-0.1724688559770584,
-0.40882861614227295,
-0.4056992828845978,
0.2143525332212448,
0.5839903950691223,
0.0950939878821373,
0.4040943682193756,
0.34791630506515503,
-0.09264292567968369,
0.3292975425720215,
-0.870597243309021,
-0.3828777074813843,
-0.46313712000846863,
0.351168692111969,
-0.3220250904560089,
-0.5498631000518799,
0.4639211893081665,
-0.08116843551397324,
0.563393235206604,
0.7182906270027161,
0.7083445191383362,
0.19678519666194916,
0.8969115018844604,
0.05122009664773941,
0.2753845751285553,
0.5141499042510986,
0.046719640493392944,
0.21826794743537903,
-0.4075120985507965,
-0.028849707916378975,
-0.614356517791748,
-0.2226816713809967,
-0.3892177939414978,
0.0954083800315857,
-0.01412456389516592,
0.06323131173849106,
-0.5805787444114685,
0.43395721912384033,
-0.3956212103366852,
0.3947133421897888,
0.3247166574001312,
-0.31074202060699463,
0.22560831904411316,
-0.037266846746206284,
-0.10940277576446533,
-0.37165775895118713,
-0.5975329279899597,
-0.9125592112541199,
1.4378223419189453,
0.3983793556690216,
0.74761962890625,
0.25252094864845276,
0.5348167419433594,
0.39030149579048157,
0.7611119151115417,
-0.6532152891159058,
0.6037005186080933,
-0.1648070365190506,
-0.5525375604629517,
-0.00014353675942402333,
-0.35624223947525024,
-0.8502807021141052,
0.27833619713783264,
-0.24022476375102997,
-0.6057274341583252,
0.08223612606525421,
0.30143827199935913,
-0.29599547386169434,
0.3663964867591858,
-0.6280560493469238,
0.9822607636451721,
-0.3560677766799927,
-0.5968732237815857,
-0.37812596559524536,
-0.22188779711723328,
0.5386658906936646,
-0.0801503136754036,
-0.17375448346138,
-0.0703735277056694,
0.09980195015668869,
1.1067343950271606,
-0.44205400347709656,
0.6888263821601868,
-0.08948921412229538,
-0.3963680565357208,
0.5174140930175781,
0.24858660995960236,
0.4480521082878113,
-0.035158365964889526,
-0.12693512439727783,
0.20725570619106293,
0.21769683063030243,
-0.3103688061237335,
-0.47423988580703735,
0.6974678635597229,
-0.312691867351532,
-0.9029988646507263,
-0.3358846604824066,
-0.23937200009822845,
-0.232905775308609,
0.2172054648399353,
0.45606422424316406,
0.7212889790534973,
-0.6666609644889832,
0.4978916347026825,
0.47513052821159363,
-0.34483465552330017,
0.3989684581756592,
0.6842257380485535,
0.048015888780355453,
-0.7359631061553955,
0.9543368220329285,
0.19157706201076508,
0.32480570673942566,
0.16541022062301636,
0.7277491688728333,
-0.5285893678665161,
-0.7089433073997498,
-0.7144888639450073,
0.01694517396390438,
-0.7349947690963745,
-0.2148001343011856,
-0.5396615862846375,
0.09938622266054153,
-0.7557598948478699,
-0.1526167243719101,
-0.284134179353714,
-0.530652642250061,
0.114201121032238,
0.22205452620983124,
0.37001314759254456,
1.1064358949661255,
0.13142797350883484,
0.5133941769599915,
-0.6533654928207397,
-0.09997990727424622,
0.5428400635719299,
0.027200590819120407,
0.04988779500126839,
-0.7268290519714355,
0.11106573045253754,
-0.020855823531746864,
-0.7599956393241882,
-0.7804949283599854,
0.3070313632488251,
-0.002577106701210141,
0.420337438583374,
0.7044606804847717,
0.173167884349823,
0.7126408219337463,
-0.4298645555973053,
1.0166364908218384,
0.16785313189029694,
-0.664595901966095,
0.4325932264328003,
-0.5372710824012756,
0.43799060583114624,
0.5025062561035156,
0.3682258427143097,
-0.4642637073993683,
-0.3014250695705414,
-0.7558536529541016,
-0.5462085604667664,
0.06488179415464401,
-0.10868024826049805,
-0.0059868642129004,
-0.2271784245967865,
0.06262192875146866,
0.1730794757604599,
0.3340510129928589,
-0.43156886100769043,
0.24839185178279877,
-0.6284425854682922,
-0.25277912616729736,
0.25433656573295593,
-0.4513426125049591,
-0.5871725678443909,
-0.0024374278727918863,
0.5678224563598633,
-0.057404935359954834,
-0.0673152282834053,
0.06535609066486359,
0.045737724751234055,
-0.17137132585048676,
0.6669171452522278,
1.1779454946517944,
0.9735494256019592,
-0.08837748318910599,
0.2743658125400543,
0.20452998578548431,
-0.4096749424934387,
0.17503148317337036,
-0.112193763256073,
-0.22536201775074005,
0.12752290070056915,
0.7729510068893433,
0.47983646392822266,
-0.01752130128443241,
-0.6485682725906372,
0.19578728079795837,
-0.007722306530922651,
-0.3944976031780243,
-0.056292902678251266,
-0.06316395103931427,
0.1714196652173996,
0.04162630811333656,
0.2998534142971039,
-0.09896212071180344,
-0.11202571541070938,
-0.9274555444717407,
0.10857713967561722,
0.6500567197799683,
-0.09797270596027374,
-0.45117998123168945,
0.6426159143447876,
0.333625853061676,
-0.3093809485435486,
0.06907965242862701,
0.15276460349559784,
-0.6052723526954651,
0.5743457078933716,
0.581359326839447,
1.0073622465133667,
-0.10447727143764496,
-0.24268291890621185,
0.4959811270236969,
0.2468917965888977,
-0.011350051499903202,
0.12381329387426376,
0.05890565365552902,
-0.49667948484420776,
-0.05384540557861328,
-0.3248744606971741,
-0.5088387131690979,
0.5222906470298767,
-0.22479170560836792,
0.1756923943758011,
-0.7651915550231934,
-0.14321942627429962,
-0.012497181072831154,
0.10078313946723938,
-0.26322922110557556,
0.06305842101573944,
-0.33629435300827026,
0.8848506212234497,
-1.0488312244415283,
0.40658068656921387,
0.627763569355011,
-0.4326043725013733,
-0.3106437623500824,
0.17376360297203064,
0.47800907492637634,
-0.7496004700660706,
0.7234983444213867,
0.07349549978971481,
-0.5812019109725952,
-0.49534961581230164,
-0.6736037731170654,
-0.4571375548839569,
0.7942344546318054,
0.20963168144226074,
-0.7057941555976868,
0.312123566865921,
-0.09235595911741257,
0.6731463074684143,
-0.5795804262161255,
0.43720191717147827,
0.5759083032608032,
0.4466884434223175,
0.23165231943130493,
-0.8665582537651062,
0.28428903222084045,
-0.21510352194309235,
-0.3127569854259491,
-0.009694327600300312,
-0.6649811267852783,
0.5826022028923035,
0.016770174726843834,
-0.44852733612060547,
0.26683804392814636,
0.5424869656562805,
0.3461182415485382,
0.5710911154747009,
0.4824737310409546,
0.8047983646392822,
0.1879614144563675,
-0.13856220245361328,
0.7338293194770813,
-0.344203382730484,
-0.13913339376449585,
1.18156898021698,
-0.4724802076816559,
1.0009092092514038,
0.35457974672317505,
-0.19120502471923828,
0.8098201155662537,
0.6521075963973999,
0.14404121041297913,
0.34925732016563416,
0.3642076551914215,
-0.1534879505634308,
-0.3782021999359131,
-0.31972721219062805,
-0.5444865822792053,
0.41038358211517334,
0.32550951838493347,
-0.23838713765144348,
-0.23104964196681976,
-0.5429946780204773,
0.5832133293151855,
0.42514654994010925,
0.08620824664831161,
0.9556302428245544,
-0.1038181409239769,
-1.149779200553894,
0.8501890897750854,
-0.2560052275657654,
0.7374992370605469,
-0.5753368139266968,
-0.28760427236557007,
-0.30603012442588806,
0.08990376442670822,
-0.24044755101203918,
-1.0128920078277588,
0.2980378568172455,
0.32477426528930664,
0.1925191432237625,
-0.28867805004119873,
0.5683082938194275,
-0.21427668631076813,
-0.18701235949993134,
-0.07313688844442368,
0.17393264174461365,
0.11915475875139236,
0.15156494081020355,
-0.6327133178710938,
0.05202164873480797,
-0.3034011423587799,
-0.253853440284729,
0.2675882875919342,
0.49766725301742554,
-0.1440938264131546,
0.5967736840248108,
0.675244927406311,
0.13822810351848602,
-0.2494632452726364,
0.2563588619232178,
0.8008483052253723,
-0.5488602519035339,
-0.2036484330892563,
-1.115878939628601,
0.09953456372022629,
-0.23603969812393188,
-0.5081426501274109,
0.9193347096443176,
0.6257733702659607,
0.6883458495140076,
0.1613490730524063,
0.6541648507118225,
0.10379259288311005,
0.5681232810020447,
-0.509660005569458,
0.702290952205658,
-0.5162832736968994,
0.2936224341392517,
-0.46550223231315613,
-0.7825189828872681,
0.03551764041185379,
0.4398660361766815,
-0.5106590986251831,
0.08506694436073303,
0.6176884174346924,
0.9354249238967896,
0.03370052948594093,
0.24450616538524628,
0.1851959526538849,
0.15705978870391846,
0.6238951086997986,
0.4750918745994568,
0.9480857849121094,
-0.297364741563797,
0.8419448733329773,
0.09742528945207596,
0.04178294166922569,
-0.274942010641098,
-1.213991403579712,
-0.8065834045410156,
-0.3050857186317444,
-0.46742013096809387,
-0.5906165242195129,
0.04675189405679703,
0.7128750681877136,
0.5589821934700012,
-0.9621460437774658,
-0.2960544526576996,
-0.12592560052871704,
0.05277315154671669,
-0.10496588051319122,
-0.25694239139556885,
0.053155992180109024,
0.028150370344519615,
-0.29848483204841614,
0.46624019742012024,
0.3498355746269226,
-0.1587943732738495,
-0.28288090229034424,
-0.06946997344493866,
-0.4419637620449066,
0.6389132738113403,
0.569324254989624,
0.579688549041748,
-1.0542513132095337,
-0.5383104085922241,
-0.2498568743467331,
0.024039920419454575,
-0.05950615927577019,
1.1942155361175537,
-0.5243250131607056,
0.498644083738327,
0.7444798350334167,
0.5371187329292297,
0.09723228216171265,
0.28689056634902954,
0.7994167804718018,
-0.36094191670417786,
-0.21639390289783478,
0.06358335167169571,
0.49173328280448914,
0.3409893214702606,
0.11421003937721252,
0.5782022476196289,
0.4828929007053375,
-0.6673606634140015,
-0.8661994934082031,
0.4241570234298706,
-0.4591243267059326,
-0.2634375989437103,
1.044723629951477,
-0.3267804980278015,
0.16809804737567902,
-0.3212648034095764,
-0.19572950899600983,
-0.062151096761226654,
-0.5854657888412476,
0.8424203991889954,
1.1097451448440552,
-0.23116521537303925,
-0.3922731578350067,
-0.3459846079349518,
0.5601715445518494,
0.7376148700714111,
-0.7801673412322998,
0.4717687666416168,
0.528737485408783,
0.4000188112258911,
0.23678433895111084,
0.5153034329414368,
-0.14861750602722168,
0.48785731196403503,
0.37807443737983704,
-0.25561150908470154,
0.14256490767002106,
-0.1798502802848816,
-0.3101441264152527,
-0.09978878498077393,
0.11846520006656647,
0.1606139838695526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08496v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08496v3 | A Systematic Review of Data-to-Text NLG | 2024-02-13T14:51:45 | 2024-02-27T00:05:28 | Chinonso Cynthia Osuji, Thiago Castro Ferreira, Brian Davis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This systematic review undertakes a comprehensive analysis of current
research on data-to-text generation, identifying gaps, challenges, and future
directions within the field. Relevant literature in this field on datasets,
evaluation metrics, application areas, multilingualism, language models, and
hallucination mitigation methods is reviewed. Various methods for producing
high-quality text are explored, addressing the challenge of hallucinations in
data-to-text generation. These methods include re-ranking, traditional and
neural pipeline architecture, planning architectures, data cleaning, controlled
generation, and modification of models and training techniques. Their
effectiveness and limitations are assessed, highlighting the need for
universally applicable strategies to mitigate hallucinations. The review also
examines the usage, popularity, and impact of datasets, alongside evaluation
metrics, with an emphasis on both automatic and human assessment. Additionally,
the evolution of data-to-text models, particularly the widespread adoption of
transformer models, is discussed. Despite advancements in text quality, the
review emphasizes the importance of research in low-resourced languages and the
engineering of datasets in these languages to promote inclusivity. Finally,
several application domains of data-to-text are highlighted, emphasizing their
relevance in such domains. Overall, this review serves as a guiding framework
for fostering innovation and advancing data-to-text generation. | [
-0.41589823365211487,
-0.8503989577293396,
0.20964932441711426,
0.27451539039611816,
-0.2451920211315155,
-0.11873975396156311,
-0.30688172578811646,
-0.4707150459289551,
0.12204385548830032,
0.8785141110420227,
-0.620337188243866,
-0.6783922910690308,
-0.5463999509811401,
0.5862928032875061,
-0.8873096108436584,
1.247509241104126,
0.07557692378759384,
0.02335129864513874,
-0.0475580208003521,
0.171238511800766,
-0.7629916071891785,
-0.7473486065864563,
-0.41500720381736755,
-0.17177613079547882,
0.5013706088066101,
0.34290382266044617,
0.8770095705986023,
0.6513466835021973,
0.68672776222229,
0.048200491815805435,
-0.015361788682639599,
0.2818055748939514,
-0.7186437249183655,
0.285071462392807,
-0.014507529325783253,
-0.16337136924266815,
-0.4776919186115265,
-0.16009843349456787,
0.5797950029373169,
1.0393383502960205,
-0.4771983027458191,
-0.03598905727267265,
-0.006872724741697311,
1.0861235857009888,
-0.25344282388687134,
-0.229440838098526,
-0.6133849620819092,
0.39663657546043396,
-0.2367480844259262,
-0.20842641592025757,
-0.6212496161460876,
-0.5440337657928467,
0.23694168031215668,
-0.5500431656837463,
0.29243603348731995,
0.4448845684528351,
0.46101176738739014,
0.5045543313026428,
-0.40732914209365845,
-0.839522659778595,
-0.9533302783966064,
0.8807042837142944,
-0.6754964590072632,
0.4800560474395752,
0.243869349360466,
0.14617951214313507,
-0.09218017756938934,
-0.9158639907836914,
-0.40864112973213196,
-0.14757542312145233,
-0.0756182000041008,
0.24500839412212372,
-0.0583932101726532,
-0.13404324650764465,
0.26263391971588135,
0.5961380004882812,
-0.8370835185050964,
-0.16050966084003448,
-0.5506173372268677,
0.0947631374001503,
0.7914186120033264,
0.23513510823249817,
0.24722087383270264,
-0.403049498796463,
-0.19099874794483185,
-0.09431859105825424,
-0.7114229798316956,
-0.6004937887191772,
0.5260056257247925,
0.5341949462890625,
0.5133644938468933,
0.8092628717422485,
-0.29671889543533325,
0.6120344996452332,
-0.10030314326286316,
0.03199392929673195,
0.21097484230995178,
-0.7393851280212402,
-0.22348234057426453,
0.25486770272254944,
0.8499254584312439,
0.4035053849220276,
0.09854613244533539,
-0.5979880690574646,
-0.23742710053920746,
-0.10694841295480728,
0.8307973742485046,
-0.6070327758789062,
-0.10831979662179947,
0.241659477353096,
-0.7117263078689575,
-0.5717799663543701,
0.13213270902633667,
-1.1619045734405518,
-0.2740001082420349,
-0.40274307131767273,
0.04490116611123085,
-0.1802261769771576,
-0.27171212434768677,
0.43317583203315735,
-0.08810305595397949,
0.004060673527419567,
0.05824042856693268,
-0.801959753036499,
0.44476452469825745,
0.459166556596756,
0.6387324333190918,
-0.6103001236915588,
-0.1440049260854721,
0.12236481159925461,
0.038378141820430756,
-0.7220292091369629,
0.8018379807472229,
-0.17395803332328796,
-0.4299093782901764,
0.46477434039115906,
-0.16735027730464935,
0.09428240358829498,
-0.5915992856025696,
0.9411094188690186,
-0.23493991792201996,
0.7715674638748169,
-0.277073472738266,
-0.4537196755409241,
-0.28883978724479675,
0.06089571863412857,
-0.7330763339996338,
1.325831413269043,
0.023996202275156975,
-0.8406246304512024,
0.6012973189353943,
-0.42864182591438293,
-0.6454107761383057,
0.057367950677871704,
-0.1384030282497406,
-0.6606264114379883,
0.3345876634120941,
0.3221757113933563,
0.4322430193424225,
-0.7038382291793823,
0.7363061904907227,
0.21224457025527954,
-0.3576289713382721,
0.0006132907001301646,
-0.35548990964889526,
0.47579383850097656,
0.37985607981681824,
-0.42435774207115173,
0.07395906746387482,
-0.8874815106391907,
0.17415738105773926,
0.19179803133010864,
-0.13908401131629944,
-0.09592187404632568,
0.25541797280311584,
0.346805602312088,
0.234018474817276,
-0.2134077250957489,
-0.05461367219686508,
0.09578416496515274,
-0.4342741370201111,
0.36134594678878784,
0.26209670305252075,
0.1852310299873352,
0.34809619188308716,
-0.3906558156013489,
0.27112117409706116,
-0.17236466705799103,
0.2717176377773285,
-0.19125886261463165,
-0.49695658683776855,
-0.6716655492782593,
0.1833161562681198,
0.3289918303489685,
0.44200363755226135,
-0.9461566805839539,
1.0268203020095825,
-0.15393070876598358,
-0.5800228714942932,
-0.6037940979003906,
-0.10927919298410416,
-0.02114252559840679,
0.4791471064090729,
0.5069727897644043,
-0.4295567572116852,
-0.45528462529182434,
-0.8149912357330322,
0.12234245985746384,
-0.16828131675720215,
-0.09098024666309357,
0.30888742208480835,
0.4717896282672882,
-0.509242832660675,
0.846459686756134,
-0.40401363372802734,
-0.379072904586792,
-0.2812815010547638,
0.1938977837562561,
0.018694892525672913,
0.1885301172733307,
0.21396204829216003,
-0.5939210653305054,
-0.13708291947841644,
-0.09731362015008926,
-1.0406955480575562,
-0.12477932125329971,
-0.3718273937702179,
-0.24707747995853424,
0.17382581532001495,
0.3296999931335449,
-0.3203897774219513,
0.4348999261856079,
0.5414303541183472,
-0.18769416213035583,
0.5412706732749939,
0.02038007788360119,
0.330782413482666,
-1.0792133808135986,
0.28026407957077026,
-0.11237610131502151,
0.15838976204395294,
-0.9257616400718689,
-0.18907330930233002,
-0.22622787952423096,
-0.2116018831729889,
-0.03471406176686287,
0.3186088502407074,
-0.2518494129180908,
-0.004920140374451876,
-0.4036753177642822,
0.16860967874526978,
-0.08870955556631088,
0.15485015511512756,
0.11650417745113373,
0.6201707124710083,
0.5683192610740662,
-0.6475513577461243,
0.43428218364715576,
0.6023047566413879,
-0.4466981887817383,
0.3589501678943634,
-0.5390982627868652,
0.14093387126922607,
-0.16615821421146393,
0.305594265460968,
-0.7136086225509644,
-0.22322580218315125,
0.31669119000434875,
-0.39274299144744873,
0.1701466590166092,
0.30670979619026184,
-0.8019831776618958,
-0.29216617345809937,
-0.3062869906425476,
0.26370394229888916,
0.41567274928092957,
-0.5999501943588257,
0.16569292545318604,
0.4685136079788208,
-0.29599687457084656,
-0.47179296612739563,
-0.8029459118843079,
0.5187069773674011,
-0.2870798408985138,
-0.6118625998497009,
0.31060323119163513,
0.005697380751371384,
-0.207002654671669,
-0.3341491222381592,
0.05208110064268112,
-0.04706598073244095,
-0.1946703940629959,
-0.25292691588401794,
0.1865675002336502,
0.11165894567966461,
0.4064452350139618,
0.03954261541366577,
0.016160929575562477,
0.3508196771144867,
-0.19966113567352295,
0.46117398142814636,
0.3366440534591675,
-0.153159037232399,
0.056700535118579865,
0.4756866991519928,
0.028138242661952972,
0.1435445100069046,
0.37368661165237427,
0.6127889156341553,
-0.35820841789245605,
-0.5695865154266357,
-0.3419543206691742,
-0.4898895025253296,
-0.3590899407863617,
0.38024237751960754,
0.16128237545490265,
-0.6723581552505493,
0.13945095241069794,
-0.1666601151227951,
0.19417008757591248,
0.489213764667511,
0.646165132522583,
-0.09310663491487503,
0.8720057606697083,
0.8315786123275757,
0.22850289940834045,
0.2826557755470276,
0.13496918976306915,
0.6907191872596741,
-0.6271459460258484,
-0.2772563099861145,
-0.652191698551178,
-0.05556138977408409,
-0.8127416372299194,
-0.3220202922821045,
0.056402016431093216,
0.04578759893774986,
0.2606858015060425,
0.1263347864151001,
-1.0611666440963745,
0.06569483131170273,
0.12995938956737518,
-0.16033518314361572,
0.529407799243927,
0.28713276982307434,
0.20593102276325226,
-0.24527259171009064,
-0.9324780106544495,
-0.8165251016616821,
1.4078658819198608,
0.33826500177383423,
0.8709263205528259,
-0.2940295338630676,
0.4826470613479614,
0.422523558139801,
0.2362968474626541,
-0.6510630249977112,
0.47799885272979736,
-0.22439150512218475,
-0.7206510901451111,
-0.3663881719112396,
-0.5945200324058533,
-0.9025618433952332,
-0.0157735925167799,
-0.2945604920387268,
-0.3452129662036896,
-0.045113705098629,
-0.12938939034938812,
-0.052743010222911835,
0.0870109498500824,
-0.4206427037715912,
0.4278516173362732,
-0.2425786256790161,
-0.27643147110939026,
0.05800124630331993,
-0.5529968738555908,
0.6663366556167603,
-0.30807405710220337,
0.07228720188140869,
0.15756316483020782,
0.1631012111902237,
1.0206066370010376,
-0.0706949457526207,
0.5151722431182861,
0.18767645955085754,
-0.5434427261352539,
0.4389478266239166,
-0.22112151980400085,
0.4220774471759796,
0.16037560999393463,
-0.05420699343085289,
0.5708012580871582,
-0.37327060103416443,
-0.006977195385843515,
-0.4834897816181183,
0.33025452494621277,
-0.2726272940635681,
-0.12070997804403305,
-0.45445120334625244,
-0.5515625476837158,
-0.2523037791252136,
-0.00196689460426569,
0.567434549331665,
0.1880500465631485,
-0.23801515996456146,
0.25199463963508606,
0.9134520292282104,
-0.5820107460021973,
0.15958794951438904,
-0.12773117423057556,
-0.5233032703399658,
-0.6602654457092285,
0.9553264379501343,
0.12346486747264862,
0.08151844143867493,
0.10383696109056473,
-0.07737451046705246,
-0.3620208501815796,
-0.7399813532829285,
-0.5091538429260254,
0.20552168786525726,
-0.5513574481010437,
-0.03552417457103729,
-0.6020934581756592,
-0.4291017949581146,
-0.3480844795703888,
-0.12174482643604279,
-0.4146762490272522,
-0.4512912929058075,
-0.31120094656944275,
-0.17369377613067627,
0.34062281250953674,
1.0107510089874268,
0.12993624806404114,
0.37482360005378723,
-0.3399392068386078,
0.5259273052215576,
-0.0297675970941782,
0.3680948317050934,
-0.017318181693553925,
-0.3904990255832672,
-0.24555541574954987,
-0.20116202533245087,
-0.3062516152858734,
-0.7366310954093933,
0.4610907733440399,
-0.04026021435856819,
0.37781742215156555,
0.03417548909783363,
0.06442756205797195,
0.5179705023765564,
-0.5112875699996948,
0.9682850241661072,
0.3357609510421753,
-0.7269303202629089,
0.7026368379592896,
-0.31559884548187256,
0.026175616309046745,
0.5538447499275208,
0.26080209016799927,
-0.8767402172088623,
-0.4065715968608856,
-0.4058090150356293,
-1.2248666286468506,
0.5934121012687683,
0.6339088678359985,
-0.01458836067467928,
0.04396994039416313,
0.3955168128013611,
0.4719315469264984,
0.5635228753089905,
-0.8059031963348389,
-0.4166093170642853,
-0.2750789523124695,
-0.18901047110557556,
0.1196264997124672,
-0.042860545217990875,
-0.1189134493470192,
0.010749026201665401,
0.6269904375076294,
-0.20378084480762482,
0.49253740906715393,
0.11190768331289291,
0.03968073055148125,
-0.12700213491916656,
0.22859400510787964,
0.42222386598587036,
0.6474194526672363,
-0.023834532126784325,
-0.2476474642753601,
0.1551763117313385,
-0.7095291018486023,
0.02967318333685398,
-0.07679877430200577,
-0.5568968653678894,
0.29046201705932617,
0.271299809217453,
0.707939863204956,
-0.06170178949832916,
-0.48249363899230957,
0.15692177414894104,
-0.3040740191936493,
-0.6906399130821228,
-0.09978729486465454,
-0.17218494415283203,
-0.3915215730667114,
-0.3105044364929199,
0.4480517506599426,
0.03754568099975586,
0.3278970420360565,
-0.3947146236896515,
0.28487154841423035,
0.13261018693447113,
-0.467560738325119,
-0.1960333287715912,
0.4458779990673065,
0.2325204610824585,
-0.02850707620382309,
0.7796503901481628,
-0.013355092145502567,
-0.004140912555158138,
0.3368416428565979,
0.3542706370353699,
0.9265038967132568,
0.012038012966513634,
0.29243528842926025,
0.5104484558105469,
0.724850594997406,
-0.43502941727638245,
0.4052760601043701,
0.22852247953414917,
-0.35199135541915894,
-0.33991122245788574,
-0.43453890085220337,
-0.44423553347587585,
0.2633628249168396,
-0.5797041654586792,
0.354472279548645,
-0.13912586867809296,
-0.3349268138408661,
-0.16844043135643005,
0.01954900659620762,
-0.4335041642189026,
0.4460873007774353,
0.048726774752140045,
0.7768495082855225,
-0.6599668860435486,
0.473026841878891,
0.18794028460979462,
-0.2427041381597519,
-0.32640373706817627,
0.30091392993927,
-0.13656291365623474,
-0.2704930901527405,
0.24002085626125336,
0.07124657183885574,
0.1796634942293167,
-0.004030101466923952,
-0.5335191488265991,
-0.7448402643203735,
1.0138564109802246,
-0.01096322387456894,
-0.5245532393455505,
-0.26923567056655884,
0.42924579977989197,
0.8040773272514343,
-0.3046673536300659,
0.1828993707895279,
0.660794198513031,
0.5375981330871582,
-0.06227767840027809,
-0.5848506689071655,
-0.09894030541181564,
-0.11743661761283875,
0.14672116935253143,
0.10659927129745483,
-0.44919756054878235,
0.45398226380348206,
0.061233364045619965,
-0.5194607377052307,
-0.17738698422908783,
0.5681584477424622,
0.2691085636615753,
0.2145860493183136,
0.13540585339069366,
0.4280811548233032,
0.7615284323692322,
-0.3776140809059143,
0.8319013118743896,
-0.32233473658561707,
0.21013011038303375,
0.8829653859138489,
-0.6082730293273926,
0.5824585556983948,
0.620822012424469,
0.02689138613641262,
0.012618888169527054,
0.5453552603721619,
-0.3658621609210968,
0.5898937582969666,
0.4876028299331665,
0.12243429571390152,
0.2577277719974518,
-0.3767242431640625,
-0.4607822000980377,
0.20008033514022827,
0.30284127593040466,
-0.4975369870662689,
-0.13830414414405823,
0.0937260240316391,
-0.23998330533504486,
0.22058120369911194,
0.09365689009428024,
1.0731091499328613,
-0.09376613795757294,
-0.7872121334075928,
0.4911985397338867,
-0.020679183304309845,
0.7388390302658081,
-0.5840927362442017,
-0.0013830389361828566,
-0.24876463413238525,
-0.20580218732357025,
-0.4734656810760498,
-0.813565731048584,
0.6729021072387695,
0.3554193079471588,
-0.23912644386291504,
-0.6943786144256592,
0.7658248543739319,
-0.41538122296333313,
-0.592156708240509,
0.4050242006778717,
0.6718709468841553,
0.19976764917373657,
0.03412041813135147,
-0.5341371893882751,
0.20116128027439117,
0.04741508141160011,
-0.4015173614025116,
0.09176615625619888,
0.6233706474304199,
-0.0038983162958174944,
0.37688148021698,
0.5445488095283508,
0.23942899703979492,
0.20913425087928772,
0.43747198581695557,
0.6990688443183899,
-0.8956053853034973,
-0.16597731411457062,
-0.5103115439414978,
0.399463951587677,
-0.024209104478359222,
-0.5391499996185303,
0.7337565422058105,
0.7552796602249146,
1.0034290552139282,
0.024828219786286354,
1.020519495010376,
-0.06976301223039627,
0.5393815040588379,
-0.6115172505378723,
0.9118562936782837,
-0.3723065257072449,
0.1294822245836258,
-0.3518434464931488,
-1.2200227975845337,
-0.45933997631073,
0.5612900257110596,
0.035157423466444016,
0.10988108068704605,
1.0034099817276,
0.6924594640731812,
0.33328118920326233,
0.37139543890953064,
0.38799747824668884,
-0.14340989291667938,
0.26855331659317017,
0.29394739866256714,
0.9453233480453491,
-1.0675748586654663,
0.6699001789093018,
-0.0722699910402298,
0.028873760253190994,
-0.056271497160196304,
-0.7343466877937317,
-0.8599544763565063,
-0.74861741065979,
-0.4110109508037567,
-0.23631927371025085,
-0.007293530274182558,
0.6372154951095581,
0.7051061391830444,
-0.5650467872619629,
-0.4248522222042084,
-0.29717817902565,
-0.05480513721704483,
-0.28855574131011963,
-0.20755839347839355,
0.2136310338973999,
-0.5457684397697449,
-0.5997846126556396,
0.22425566613674164,
0.3613617718219757,
-0.017651395872235298,
-0.38759830594062805,
-0.11333128064870834,
-0.006753819063305855,
0.17669734358787537,
0.644331157207489,
-0.20657192170619965,
-0.5792304277420044,
0.2626066207885742,
0.23358272016048431,
-0.42479774355888367,
0.14389221370220184,
0.8542529344558716,
-0.3794904053211212,
0.39176663756370544,
0.5257050395011902,
0.5758056044578552,
0.3077293038368225,
-0.10223894566297531,
0.6449273824691772,
-0.8584176301956177,
-0.2639961242675781,
0.5522432923316956,
-0.06447433680295944,
0.4584870934486389,
-0.48544442653656006,
0.751481294631958,
0.023921148851513863,
-0.6604897379875183,
-1.006813645362854,
0.0226111002266407,
-0.739371120929718,
-0.15165024995803833,
1.171194076538086,
0.4831450283527374,
-0.06917555630207062,
-0.22355662286281586,
-0.4275422692298889,
0.18567614257335663,
-0.3286142647266388,
1.4397610425949097,
0.9983440041542053,
0.04783737659454346,
-0.0015264281537383795,
-0.8875187635421753,
0.9258618950843811,
0.3277166187763214,
-1.6010277271270752,
0.6237514615058899,
0.3781217932701111,
-0.6300482749938965,
0.23978327214717865,
0.2825319468975067,
-0.3846474587917328,
0.08235692232847214,
-0.008371111936867237,
0.2766436040401459,
0.41816553473472595,
-0.5388832688331604,
-0.49575382471084595,
0.035384878516197205,
-0.24604114890098572,
0.44525453448295593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08479v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08479v4 | Plausible Extractive Rationalization through Semi-Supervised Entailment Signal | 2024-02-13T14:12:32 | 2024-02-25T16:25:45 | Wei Jie Yeo, Ranjan Satapathy, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing use of complex and opaque black box models requires the
adoption of interpretable measures, one such option is extractive rationalizing
models, which serve as a more interpretable alternative. These models, also
known as Explain-Then-Predict models, employ an explainer model to extract
rationales and subsequently condition the predictor with the extracted
information. Their primary objective is to provide precise and faithful
explanations, represented by the extracted rationales. In this paper, we take a
semi-supervised approach to optimize for the plausibility of extracted
rationales. We adopt a pre-trained natural language inference (NLI) model and
further fine-tune it on a small set of supervised rationales ($10\%$). The NLI
predictor is leveraged as a source of supervisory signals to the explainer via
entailment alignment. We show that, by enforcing the alignment agreement
between the explanation and answer in a question-answering task, the
performance can be improved without access to ground truth labels. We evaluate
our approach on the ERASER dataset and show that our approach achieves
comparable results with supervised extractive models and outperforms
unsupervised approaches by $> 100\%$. | [
-0.2709171772003174,
-1.1670674085617065,
0.7767835259437561,
-0.14730946719646454,
-0.1818505972623825,
-0.23854905366897583,
-0.21744030714035034,
-0.2916920781135559,
-0.03366023302078247,
0.6337385177612305,
-0.7702566385269165,
-0.1878119558095932,
-0.6076663136482239,
0.1747073233127594,
-0.35508570075035095,
0.8497136235237122,
-0.11200516670942307,
-0.16505075991153717,
-0.32834592461586,
0.22770066559314728,
-0.44110286235809326,
-0.24544565379619598,
-0.6853934526443481,
-0.3154692053794861,
0.1342548429965973,
0.21662527322769165,
0.7158524394035339,
1.0546616315841675,
0.31143298745155334,
0.3535630404949188,
-0.11559289693832397,
0.3204527199268341,
-0.22656291723251343,
-0.023272478953003883,
-0.17825216054916382,
-0.5524555444717407,
-0.2538646161556244,
0.1382433921098709,
0.20372828841209412,
0.6576616764068604,
-0.381349116563797,
0.13166706264019012,
-0.05575559660792351,
0.3483925759792328,
-0.6337366104125977,
0.11717379093170166,
-0.5137448310852051,
-0.18434473872184753,
0.24636892974376678,
-0.5377978682518005,
-0.6713507175445557,
-0.49602243304252625,
0.5552745461463928,
-1.0803056955337524,
0.11474598199129105,
0.22972643375396729,
1.177822470664978,
0.4563044607639313,
-0.2725146412849426,
-0.33170196413993835,
-0.8637399077415466,
1.151634693145752,
-0.8454293012619019,
0.17295002937316895,
0.3507866859436035,
0.5672091245651245,
-0.12208276987075806,
-0.8453075289726257,
-0.5845164656639099,
0.11910680681467056,
-0.4899357259273529,
0.4088130295276642,
-0.2244807928800583,
-0.02417173981666565,
0.4558282196521759,
0.29867494106292725,
-0.12330373376607895,
-0.09677713364362717,
-0.4424600601196289,
-0.31345123052597046,
0.670975923538208,
0.06314726173877716,
0.3140312433242798,
-0.0517304427921772,
-0.47266438603401184,
0.2243906557559967,
-0.3725659251213074,
0.39179158210754395,
0.25845104455947876,
0.036680854856967926,
0.16447973251342773,
0.7873279452323914,
-0.17540743947029114,
0.7510995864868164,
0.40927988290786743,
-0.20134100317955017,
-0.22058606147766113,
-0.4768538773059845,
-0.3898474872112274,
0.34266039729118347,
0.4739466607570648,
0.3652486503124237,
0.31364303827285767,
-0.5422586798667908,
-0.28768184781074524,
0.3420625925064087,
0.4041435420513153,
-0.8224955797195435,
-0.25323882699012756,
0.45792660117149353,
-0.4314236342906952,
-0.42685970664024353,
0.07247409969568253,
-0.948970377445221,
-0.17155976593494415,
-0.9320594668388367,
0.5305412411689758,
-0.5001764297485352,
-0.19756098091602325,
0.2599527835845947,
-0.40685248374938965,
0.50275719165802,
0.4163894057273865,
-0.7438796758651733,
0.06524986028671265,
0.7023555636405945,
0.5424411296844482,
-0.13758495450019836,
0.17297403514385223,
-0.6019454002380371,
0.5377473831176758,
-0.3552178144454956,
0.7270101308822632,
-0.7090192437171936,
0.11354990303516388,
-0.03715572878718376,
0.2323492169380188,
-0.2334558218717575,
-0.528497040271759,
0.743728756904602,
-0.578007698059082,
0.652252733707428,
-0.13616310060024261,
-0.7740043997764587,
-0.3466898500919342,
0.18141409754753113,
-0.45456671714782715,
0.737846851348877,
-0.1155628189444542,
-0.8391647934913635,
0.4694054424762726,
-0.7364161610603333,
-0.3684476613998413,
-0.07663770020008087,
0.13586975634098053,
-0.3845923840999603,
0.07820338010787964,
0.6192637085914612,
0.21650058031082153,
-0.20968568325042725,
0.8987345695495605,
-0.3262079060077667,
-0.19904647767543793,
0.4663412570953369,
-0.4433865249156952,
1.030588150024414,
0.19545871019363403,
-0.3108667731285095,
0.39392003417015076,
-0.7862199544906616,
-0.04024246707558632,
0.19952477514743805,
-0.13908140361309052,
-0.4443039894104004,
0.08654235303401947,
-0.5188280940055847,
0.17958194017410278,
0.23450222611427307,
-0.6054163575172424,
-0.46097564697265625,
-0.7186813354492188,
0.3947901725769043,
0.8509630560874939,
0.30780309438705444,
0.9409576058387756,
-0.43845081329345703,
0.5569143295288086,
0.0420355349779129,
0.19269144535064697,
-0.13863025605678558,
-0.07241388410329819,
-0.773223340511322,
-0.7031874060630798,
0.22228902578353882,
0.4963296353816986,
-0.7359519600868225,
0.4698007106781006,
-0.1588646024465561,
-0.22890301048755646,
-0.8097026944160461,
0.012789905071258545,
0.18568070232868195,
0.8961370587348938,
0.29977139830589294,
0.4554886817932129,
-0.6328526139259338,
-1.3070391416549683,
-0.663972020149231,
0.20125974714756012,
-0.2804539203643799,
-0.18643757700920105,
0.26753097772598267,
0.08886302262544632,
1.3722882270812988,
-0.48308393359184265,
-0.03873894363641739,
-0.3595361113548279,
0.2172202616930008,
0.45896291732788086,
0.46633511781692505,
-0.014069607481360435,
-0.9656890630722046,
-0.2140766680240631,
-0.026146866381168365,
-1.1159143447875977,
-0.20171527564525604,
-0.35717281699180603,
-0.5559530258178711,
-0.013696820475161076,
0.4852619767189026,
-0.6531814932823181,
0.6504533290863037,
-0.16539804637432098,
-0.018150215968489647,
0.39896854758262634,
-0.2676924169063568,
-0.3021165132522583,
-0.967738151550293,
-0.0005829681758768857,
0.27556124329566956,
-0.21873492002487183,
-0.7472401857376099,
-0.19064192473888397,
0.011308863759040833,
0.2026841938495636,
-0.15092158317565918,
0.23963728547096252,
-0.49862056970596313,
0.19148452579975128,
-0.17827828228473663,
0.2116473764181137,
0.31178101897239685,
0.45336049795150757,
0.28283074498176575,
0.599217414855957,
0.5575867891311646,
-0.6250912547111511,
-0.1780966818332672,
0.33795166015625,
-0.12219270318746567,
0.32741591334342957,
-0.9043421745300293,
-0.04311109706759453,
-0.35994285345077515,
0.023748304694890976,
-0.7437600493431091,
-0.3711913228034973,
0.23587676882743835,
-0.23708327114582062,
0.3010282814502716,
-0.24557194113731384,
-0.23794907331466675,
-0.11477025598287582,
-0.1594785451889038,
-0.12306447327136993,
0.6635114550590515,
-0.7205308079719543,
1.0747038125991821,
0.5949305295944214,
-0.05356452614068985,
-0.4611908793449402,
-0.30455970764160156,
-0.4655854403972626,
-0.7140623331069946,
-0.6294510960578918,
0.24038733541965485,
0.15202084183692932,
-0.4171691834926605,
-0.08384290337562561,
-0.4599292278289795,
0.0498177632689476,
0.43490344285964966,
0.24084874987602234,
0.6420259475708008,
-0.27192965149879456,
-0.21584397554397583,
0.2848610579967499,
-0.371521919965744,
0.5886471271514893,
-0.28674495220184326,
0.10067661106586456,
-0.0720842182636261,
-0.17348375916481018,
-0.6212642788887024,
0.3249455392360687,
0.2588047981262207,
-0.3702522814273834,
0.9694609045982361,
0.3202095329761505,
-0.6435572504997253,
-0.27312836050987244,
-0.37783682346343994,
-0.47995424270629883,
-0.4728238582611084,
0.05439777672290802,
-0.18069139122962952,
-0.6281479001045227,
0.4043610990047455,
-0.3471221327781677,
0.25154349207878113,
0.3005538284778595,
0.3917531669139862,
-0.20473609864711761,
1.4180052280426025,
0.40883931517601013,
0.4935077428817749,
0.29878637194633484,
-0.16169337928295135,
0.7932528257369995,
-0.6039986610412598,
-0.4530469477176666,
-0.23773038387298584,
-0.06037027761340141,
-0.3041831851005554,
0.11110978573560715,
0.0957985371351242,
0.5160614252090454,
-0.006695224437862635,
0.11932070553302765,
-0.6335353851318359,
0.5724745988845825,
0.4356115162372589,
0.13088899850845337,
0.22099784016609192,
0.014427575282752514,
0.2701665163040161,
-0.03824298456311226,
-0.5320214033126831,
-0.9814844727516174,
0.7390406131744385,
0.4603923261165619,
0.49584445357322693,
0.11799488961696625,
0.5885202884674072,
-0.12192681431770325,
0.4002760350704193,
-0.612259566783905,
0.3604133725166321,
0.24591003358364105,
-0.7014076113700867,
-0.40624669194221497,
-0.3633701801300049,
-0.8240236639976501,
0.40092235803604126,
-0.4321066439151764,
-0.9110743403434753,
0.2597839832305908,
0.10061177611351013,
-0.3777399957180023,
-0.11120133101940155,
-1.0487704277038574,
1.044079065322876,
-0.16575326025485992,
-0.39949503540992737,
0.06485816836357117,
-0.7414531707763672,
0.5153368711471558,
-0.2710871696472168,
0.3630945086479187,
-0.06592734158039093,
0.23853573203086853,
0.9178842306137085,
-0.5415310263633728,
0.6945115923881531,
-0.4790690541267395,
0.10189704596996307,
0.27423304319381714,
0.008818315342068672,
0.5949796438217163,
0.15765449404716492,
-0.09375269711017609,
-0.15417888760566711,
0.18809553980827332,
-0.37636417150497437,
-0.9342359304428101,
0.1253686398267746,
-0.44079452753067017,
-0.9150603413581848,
-0.16984745860099792,
-0.7335442900657654,
-0.09080912917852402,
0.24819201231002808,
0.17968447506427765,
0.4963251054286957,
0.21451210975646973,
0.12204868346452713,
0.6731123328208923,
-0.06793147325515747,
0.2956065237522125,
0.4376369118690491,
-0.15317723155021667,
-0.002995830262079835,
0.8962207436561584,
-0.03324570134282112,
0.28783169388771057,
0.16755139827728271,
0.4652099013328552,
-0.6099662184715271,
-0.6709675192832947,
-0.34134531021118164,
0.1467728614807129,
-0.7080458998680115,
-0.01964435540139675,
-0.7706953883171082,
-0.146543949842453,
-0.16941358149051666,
-0.2886926531791687,
0.12944728136062622,
-0.4241107404232025,
-0.4161325693130493,
-0.432343453168869,
0.27013877034187317,
0.2995804250240326,
0.2121906578540802,
0.5754846930503845,
-0.5294870734214783,
0.48784446716308594,
0.1345544159412384,
-0.19547079503536224,
-0.11396364867687225,
-0.8890052437782288,
0.04379855468869209,
0.3955809473991394,
-0.2637248635292053,
-0.8728834390640259,
0.6342316269874573,
0.02319873869419098,
0.7761209011077881,
0.5725367069244385,
0.5850574970245361,
0.9378612041473389,
-0.08134230971336365,
0.3309992253780365,
0.04654388129711151,
-0.8365384340286255,
0.754662811756134,
-0.1731388419866562,
-0.07416772097349167,
0.5721952319145203,
0.4128420948982239,
0.2899363040924072,
-0.7302061319351196,
-0.7884019017219543,
-0.8237395286560059,
1.055505394935608,
0.3335069417953491,
-0.29847511649131775,
0.0853222981095314,
0.31584808230400085,
0.29383018612861633,
0.0034974366426467896,
-0.6585713624954224,
-0.004190147388726473,
-0.10289855301380157,
-0.5866351127624512,
0.07280471920967102,
-0.1316605657339096,
-0.31630802154541016,
-0.19821272790431976,
0.7982635498046875,
-0.11722365766763687,
0.016374977305531502,
0.24134013056755066,
-0.3208763897418976,
-0.019612904638051987,
0.4534794092178345,
0.10844570398330688,
0.95162433385849,
-0.4217741787433624,
0.23989860713481903,
0.15187779068946838,
0.1407189816236496,
-0.0877155065536499,
0.2948057949542999,
-0.5604385137557983,
-0.2030511051416397,
0.4081318974494934,
0.5945202112197876,
-0.05372234061360359,
-0.6895048022270203,
0.6101671457290649,
-0.12169782817363739,
-0.19460369646549225,
-0.5548411011695862,
-0.037987902760505676,
0.099886953830719,
0.2791060209274292,
0.20079390704631805,
0.21110710501670837,
0.22046716511249542,
-0.2952353358268738,
0.33705800771713257,
0.5047215223312378,
-0.35106152296066284,
-0.30984699726104736,
0.7715488076210022,
-0.231744647026062,
-0.09361349791288376,
0.5779476165771484,
-0.05360860750079155,
-0.5774586796760559,
0.6077719926834106,
0.8443644642829895,
0.5189052820205688,
0.2806420624256134,
0.21937108039855957,
0.4928196966648102,
0.3151338994503021,
-0.19270512461662292,
0.10843764990568161,
-0.01804256998002529,
-0.8236074447631836,
-0.6413196325302124,
-0.7402018308639526,
-0.10968485474586487,
-0.15305782854557037,
-1.072015404701233,
0.1233891174197197,
-0.3821578919887543,
0.14279526472091675,
0.6665359139442444,
-0.3821682929992676,
-0.3056383430957794,
0.2509859502315521,
-0.09442076832056046,
0.7768820524215698,
-1.0329548120498657,
0.6852320432662964,
0.4222480058670044,
-0.4297124743461609,
-1.2102466821670532,
-0.14756545424461365,
-0.22690421342849731,
-0.6419404149055481,
0.2841586470603943,
0.5177579522132874,
0.01092458050698042,
0.060261279344558716,
-0.7571671605110168,
-0.4628433585166931,
0.9432978630065918,
0.5818560719490051,
-0.20884650945663452,
0.06350170075893402,
-0.10435289889574051,
0.526766836643219,
-0.48449698090553284,
0.37976932525634766,
1.0477197170257568,
0.6190056204795837,
0.20911911129951477,
-0.08416823297739029,
0.2518153190612793,
-0.30100274085998535,
-0.20922181010246277,
0.2597152292728424,
0.18861421942710876,
0.28004688024520874,
-0.28169652819633484,
-0.673622727394104,
-0.17563557624816895,
0.8474711179733276,
0.40204763412475586,
0.6467109322547913,
0.5377955436706543,
0.5034329295158386,
0.8495057821273804,
-0.22592344880104065,
1.2563380002975464,
0.02973962388932705,
-0.003667136887088418,
0.971746027469635,
-0.09799937903881073,
0.6028013825416565,
0.8221468925476074,
0.11447043716907501,
0.350719153881073,
0.7457881569862366,
0.038314126431941986,
0.6642677783966064,
-0.12051638960838318,
0.09812179207801819,
-0.5623503923416138,
-0.3641813397407532,
0.26346999406814575,
0.28262659907341003,
0.1653745025396347,
-0.309187650680542,
-0.14155925810337067,
-0.21088574826717377,
-0.11058204621076584,
0.28197547793388367,
-0.1362825632095337,
1.06203293800354,
-0.06708384305238724,
-1.0378146171569824,
0.4419395327568054,
-0.05389675870537758,
0.2558920681476593,
-0.44285574555397034,
-0.13432690501213074,
-0.07401848584413528,
0.2660748362541199,
-0.29178571701049805,
-0.7071094512939453,
0.592964231967926,
-0.007673146203160286,
-0.33382105827331543,
-0.46559152007102966,
0.7581091523170471,
-0.5933496952056885,
-0.6041601896286011,
0.22718815505504608,
0.5157230496406555,
-0.011441499926149845,
-0.03785119578242302,
-0.5002976655960083,
-0.5947868824005127,
0.28647980093955994,
-0.15498025715351105,
0.2382667511701584,
0.7177324295043945,
-0.24457353353500366,
0.5161831974983215,
1.1642765998840332,
-0.06652113795280457,
0.21040259301662445,
-0.11676648259162903,
0.7941373586654663,
-0.34229233860969543,
-0.38345006108283997,
-1.052195429801941,
0.5951489806175232,
-0.4094284176826477,
0.15066483616828918,
0.704281747341156,
0.6343384981155396,
0.5367251038551331,
-0.038470491766929626,
0.5638469457626343,
0.08221703767776489,
0.6731159687042236,
-0.5991921424865723,
0.20794889330863953,
-0.5390945672988892,
0.3977089822292328,
0.0738200768828392,
-0.7948846817016602,
-0.059943292289972305,
0.5407437086105347,
-0.6272716522216797,
-0.33044955134391785,
0.5999574065208435,
0.9366298913955688,
-0.132024884223938,
0.7220037579536438,
-0.053128115832805634,
0.13183213770389557,
0.23288676142692566,
0.31490176916122437,
1.3026707172393799,
-0.14540793001651764,
0.5311861634254456,
-0.5125028491020203,
-0.36204639077186584,
0.2933451235294342,
-0.8910682797431946,
-0.9313464760780334,
-0.17259345948696136,
-0.4528893828392029,
-0.2768101096153259,
-0.32637351751327515,
0.5380668640136719,
0.4433833956718445,
-0.9869844913482666,
0.24355749785900116,
-0.256514310836792,
0.24859130382537842,
-0.35710233449935913,
-0.2772984206676483,
0.5303751826286316,
-0.24413536489009857,
-0.49146923422813416,
0.36720186471939087,
0.21991455554962158,
-0.050078000873327255,
0.4190109372138977,
-0.12209516763687134,
-0.16450683772563934,
0.21033987402915955,
0.2178269326686859,
0.012133937329053879,
-0.9178403615951538,
-0.26511088013648987,
0.12124310433864594,
0.17579255998134613,
0.012625652365386486,
0.5649675726890564,
-0.5078986287117004,
0.5182981491088867,
0.2780716121196747,
0.7723455429077148,
0.40545904636383057,
0.5917870998382568,
0.8490766882896423,
-0.43854159116744995,
0.008137603290379047,
0.03378995507955551,
0.40834930539131165,
0.1549382209777832,
-0.4582456052303314,
0.44516050815582275,
-0.10639441758394241,
-0.3411642014980316,
-0.8797478079795837,
-0.1476527452468872,
-1.0541765689849854,
-0.3729459345340729,
0.9206627607345581,
-0.29973259568214417,
-0.5338574647903442,
-0.4079773426055908,
-0.21456801891326904,
0.4980033040046692,
-0.2757623791694641,
0.6678280234336853,
0.4467390775680542,
0.009324334561824799,
-0.27323010563850403,
-0.574411153793335,
0.3536429703235626,
0.5149425268173218,
-0.9773894548416138,
0.19705930352210999,
0.5131924152374268,
0.14408564567565918,
0.18652941286563873,
0.18731701374053955,
-0.2223527580499649,
0.18384277820587158,
-0.22916428744792938,
-0.21532835066318512,
-0.2876572012901306,
-0.1651412546634674,
-0.2381647825241089,
0.2715623080730438,
-0.26593929529190063,
-0.23812319338321686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08467v1 | Lying Blindly: Bypassing ChatGPT's Safeguards to Generate Hard-to-Detect Disinformation Claims at Scale | 2024-02-13T13:50:08 | 2024-02-13T13:50:08 | Freddy Heppell, Mehmet E. Bakir, Kalina Bontcheva | cs.CL | cs.CL | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more proficient, their misuse in
large-scale viral disinformation campaigns is a growing concern. This study
explores the capability of ChatGPT to generate unconditioned claims about the
war in Ukraine, an event beyond its knowledge cutoff, and evaluates whether
such claims can be differentiated by human readers and automated tools from
human-written ones. We compare war-related claims from ClaimReview, authored by
IFCN-registered fact-checkers, and similar short-form content generated by
ChatGPT. We demonstrate that ChatGPT can produce realistic, target-specific
disinformation cheaply, fast, and at scale, and that these claims cannot be
reliably distinguished by humans or existing automated tools. | [
-0.35690730810165405,
-0.6119884848594666,
0.652592122554779,
-0.013955892063677311,
-0.07847840338945389,
0.4594539403915405,
-0.27547213435173035,
-0.4070497453212738,
-0.1910276561975479,
0.34936055541038513,
-0.4867154657840729,
-0.40245217084884644,
-0.6732147336006165,
-0.06153266131877899,
-0.5487520098686218,
1.1068294048309326,
0.12926751375198364,
-0.299540638923645,
-0.11033343523740768,
0.30373111367225647,
0.09224016964435577,
-0.7173500657081604,
-0.46154099702835083,
-0.3487246632575989,
0.3338746130466461,
0.7421470880508423,
0.556450605392456,
0.42528679966926575,
0.5849454998970032,
0.30116206407546997,
0.10425719618797302,
-0.012193217873573303,
-0.5313712954521179,
-0.15861725807189941,
-0.05070611834526062,
-0.5888893008232117,
0.03981691971421242,
0.2957629859447479,
0.2995796799659729,
0.15481644868850708,
-0.45498672127723694,
0.2817182242870331,
0.19359444081783295,
0.6282522678375244,
-0.3587910234928131,
0.11764150112867355,
-0.9282965064048767,
-0.11651574820280075,
-0.2475050389766693,
0.09869876503944397,
-0.6435180306434631,
-0.22005073726177216,
0.403624027967453,
-0.4056984782218933,
0.6159318089485168,
0.11159713566303253,
1.0070884227752686,
0.20453117787837982,
-0.3912374675273895,
-0.5453978776931763,
-0.8167915344238281,
0.5340906381607056,
-0.6379761099815369,
0.06019630655646324,
0.3779545724391937,
0.38815826177597046,
-0.2644549012184143,
-0.7898892164230347,
-0.578910231590271,
-0.5311444997787476,
0.046781864017248154,
0.17195026576519012,
-0.6521758437156677,
-0.02344135195016861,
0.5878480076789856,
0.16949443519115448,
-0.6262235641479492,
0.030930448323488235,
-0.5511690378189087,
-0.6413968801498413,
0.5656173229217529,
-0.17589688301086426,
0.32382458448410034,
-0.6922675371170044,
-0.6261638402938843,
0.025811411440372467,
-0.8597617745399475,
0.027467574924230576,
0.5234687328338623,
-0.09837903082370758,
-0.24206867814064026,
0.7553439140319824,
-0.3608502447605133,
0.2675870656967163,
0.13934168219566345,
-0.3618081212043762,
-0.3875966966152191,
-0.1711176633834839,
-0.2602066397666931,
0.5527031421661377,
0.8202221393585205,
0.6605479717254639,
0.017208484932780266,
-0.17256119847297668,
-0.008834258653223515,
0.4073718190193176,
0.1911507397890091,
-0.9720681309700012,
-0.2521609961986542,
0.07043800503015518,
-0.26894599199295044,
-0.4828570485115051,
0.06837684661149979,
-0.9065024852752686,
-0.718895435333252,
0.16825136542320251,
0.3839257061481476,
-0.2977648675441742,
-0.05218162760138512,
0.13771827518939972,
-0.33949849009513855,
-0.05983992666006088,
0.2184033840894699,
-0.20768818259239197,
0.06172030046582222,
0.34321480989456177,
0.8718423843383789,
0.1283882111310959,
0.07407265156507492,
-0.5586701035499573,
-0.3112030625343323,
-0.43587541580200195,
0.7773096561431885,
-0.0670151636004448,
-0.38509511947631836,
0.09522556513547897,
-0.19728566706180573,
0.48399484157562256,
-0.3741191327571869,
0.6153880953788757,
-0.6840288043022156,
0.21554632484912872,
-0.13407650589942932,
-0.3880959451198578,
-0.1738104373216629,
0.2849402129650116,
-0.4983152747154236,
0.7512384653091431,
-0.08689708262681961,
-0.8569905757904053,
0.605044960975647,
-0.12833622097969055,
-0.1525796502828598,
-0.0024209092371165752,
-0.28136518597602844,
-0.5035075545310974,
-0.1767856925725937,
-0.10788662731647491,
0.41357502341270447,
-0.5351310968399048,
0.26892030239105225,
-0.13483285903930664,
-0.02856106497347355,
0.5330824851989746,
-0.9021704792976379,
0.49494338035583496,
0.11813385039567947,
-0.8395617008209229,
-0.3646466135978699,
-0.8114718794822693,
-0.36714640259742737,
0.17113567888736725,
-0.7554978132247925,
-0.16189660131931305,
0.2740478813648224,
-0.3304818272590637,
0.28049302101135254,
0.20865464210510254,
-0.8969794511795044,
0.3734390437602997,
-0.2515234351158142,
0.24314028024673462,
0.455512136220932,
-0.036078061908483505,
0.12347619235515594,
-0.5719630122184753,
0.36098921298980713,
0.2254633605480194,
0.10671000927686691,
-0.028689036145806313,
-0.4905732274055481,
-0.9037466645240784,
-0.04783971235156059,
0.36059629917144775,
0.5813881158828735,
-0.9903777837753296,
0.047027334570884705,
-0.20605537295341492,
-0.8975146412849426,
-0.20902682840824127,
-0.08387008309364319,
0.285424143075943,
0.6426247954368591,
0.08584477007389069,
0.1409570276737213,
-0.6550922393798828,
-0.9624284505844116,
-0.20949769020080566,
-0.4268255829811096,
-0.23562705516815186,
-0.0029908050782978535,
0.3154742121696472,
-0.1540040820837021,
0.8342345952987671,
-0.3528231680393219,
-0.1586790829896927,
-0.18633051216602325,
0.5032045841217041,
-0.10323917865753174,
0.03656275197863579,
0.3109067976474762,
-0.818272590637207,
-0.6536468863487244,
-0.08115225285291672,
-0.3952784538269043,
0.07784177362918854,
-0.27336055040359497,
0.41905370354652405,
0.2998276948928833,
0.5338018536567688,
-0.5949354767799377,
0.567161500453949,
0.5916503071784973,
-0.38469406962394714,
0.6787586808204651,
-0.3769127130508423,
0.33118724822998047,
-1.0564930438995361,
-0.2707912027835846,
0.06482670456171036,
-0.45045584440231323,
-0.5789433717727661,
-0.46050578355789185,
0.03876873478293419,
-0.11233030259609222,
-0.49013933539390564,
0.08550873398780823,
-0.46835020184516907,
0.3931754231452942,
-0.3806004226207733,
0.3240360617637634,
-0.1141233816742897,
-0.01587955839931965,
-0.050693709403276443,
0.4919600784778595,
0.669196367263794,
-0.43186959624290466,
0.45839715003967285,
0.15234912931919098,
-0.7215422987937927,
0.25784987211227417,
-0.4168784022331238,
-0.147955521941185,
-0.07713942974805832,
0.5445883870124817,
-0.9842275381088257,
-0.5016880631446838,
0.29356205463409424,
-0.5351591110229492,
-0.08749325573444366,
-0.5530750751495361,
-0.5458132028579712,
-0.14726002514362335,
-0.18175381422042847,
-0.08134032785892487,
1.113402009010315,
-0.5372416973114014,
0.3690832853317261,
0.2880735397338867,
-0.07163889706134796,
-0.5593001842498779,
-0.8596869707107544,
0.273788183927536,
-0.4432041347026825,
-0.3730272054672241,
0.05737460032105446,
0.21174177527427673,
-0.5691251754760742,
-0.1299082338809967,
-0.20889566838741302,
-0.04284932091832161,
-0.18989603221416473,
0.668694019317627,
0.12109691649675369,
-0.33926889300346375,
0.29055631160736084,
-0.5256347060203552,
-0.025980008766055107,
0.307422935962677,
-0.22104357182979584,
0.3914077877998352,
-0.05218881741166115,
-0.7700837850570679,
-0.4994184076786041,
0.31386297941207886,
0.7314714193344116,
0.13732896745204926,
0.6410754323005676,
0.43395790457725525,
-0.19082792103290558,
-0.2906738221645355,
-0.9596995711326599,
-0.22381098568439484,
-0.44940733909606934,
0.2124079167842865,
0.2501984238624573,
-0.7401131987571716,
0.26115909218788147,
-0.32825955748558044,
0.1739501804113388,
0.7081419825553894,
0.3482038080692291,
0.004470435436815023,
0.79234379529953,
0.5788986682891846,
-0.154787078499794,
0.058631740510463715,
0.10384923964738846,
0.15171442925930023,
-0.23960119485855103,
-0.08907230943441391,
-0.5990380048751831,
-0.08129996806383133,
-0.8600404858589172,
-0.5495294332504272,
0.37492984533309937,
-0.0710553452372551,
-0.07093967497348785,
-0.06963013857603073,
-0.4484577476978302,
0.530956506729126,
0.4779731333255768,
0.12305835634469986,
0.43778496980667114,
0.18322427570819855,
0.11509185284376144,
-0.015089339576661587,
-0.8946856260299683,
-0.6979020833969116,
1.1085548400878906,
0.3085702955722809,
0.8322381377220154,
0.19980087876319885,
0.48412713408470154,
0.5804125666618347,
0.6052846908569336,
-0.874434232711792,
0.43130388855934143,
-0.08942440897226334,
-0.6209287643432617,
-0.29632604122161865,
-0.3326268196105957,
-0.7785190939903259,
-0.04856666177511215,
-0.10228215157985687,
-0.7228142023086548,
0.01660062186419964,
0.20637550950050354,
-0.353268563747406,
0.5620706677436829,
-0.6414531469345093,
0.3253934979438782,
-0.1197136640548706,
0.0752798467874527,
-0.38491225242614746,
-0.3847663104534149,
0.4331044852733612,
-0.2383546680212021,
0.17347009479999542,
-0.24461188912391663,
0.03482497110962868,
0.7208464741706848,
-0.39681386947631836,
1.1966781616210938,
-0.08089857548475266,
-0.06933261454105377,
0.7005447745323181,
0.29759663343429565,
0.6233882308006287,
0.3561810553073883,
0.02137279510498047,
0.10481122136116028,
-0.0260680690407753,
-0.3394703269004822,
-0.1506805568933487,
0.4289725720882416,
-0.6464937329292297,
-0.9501268267631531,
-0.636996865272522,
-0.1995600461959839,
-0.002217736328020692,
0.2036849558353424,
0.6128803491592407,
0.5387844443321228,
-0.7114449143409729,
0.49136263132095337,
0.9713567495346069,
-0.24752174317836761,
0.2870277464389801,
0.7715994715690613,
-0.16715216636657715,
0.07027047872543335,
0.9383134245872498,
0.16524338722229004,
0.5477197766304016,
0.3095644414424896,
0.45745155215263367,
-0.30101290345191956,
-0.3965878486633301,
-0.5475390553474426,
-0.040753815323114395,
-0.7545192837715149,
-0.28505367040634155,
-0.30904632806777954,
-0.339045912027359,
0.06483649462461472,
-0.05968966335058212,
-0.42982178926467896,
-0.19475211203098297,
0.19503872096538544,
-0.07321622222661972,
0.6803616285324097,
0.9241244792938232,
-0.3051000237464905,
0.4218043088912964,
-0.6532677412033081,
0.35524001717567444,
0.46630239486694336,
-0.006487834732979536,
-0.5284838676452637,
-0.4889354407787323,
-0.09540308266878128,
0.41160327196121216,
-0.3537346124649048,
-0.9534032344818115,
0.08333903551101685,
-0.14874745905399323,
0.18327365815639496,
0.35205236077308655,
0.3990321457386017,
0.33625274896621704,
-0.5690451860427856,
0.9613521695137024,
0.12716498970985413,
-0.7336894869804382,
0.2871735692024231,
-0.4005342423915863,
0.07348822057247162,
0.14386805891990662,
0.6006290316581726,
-0.5013031363487244,
-0.41146862506866455,
-1.1048328876495361,
-0.4523463249206543,
0.5256008505821228,
0.20010104775428772,
-0.03164445608854294,
0.11349720507860184,
0.13218049705028534,
-0.028728824108839035,
-0.04064539447426796,
-0.6008303761482239,
-0.10762140899896622,
-0.2279183566570282,
0.1317729502916336,
-0.1373165398836136,
-0.46565112471580505,
-0.378528356552124,
0.28243210911750793,
0.6997992992401123,
-0.1429615169763565,
0.04505971074104309,
0.6825025081634521,
-0.18536260724067688,
-0.00693888496607542,
0.5427447557449341,
0.5538108348846436,
0.5549083948135376,
0.2372186928987503,
0.3392113447189331,
0.2671986520290375,
-0.4828021228313446,
0.3795401453971863,
0.11350000649690628,
-0.17809924483299255,
0.41828134655952454,
0.31218525767326355,
0.42402637004852295,
0.16090582311153412,
-0.9367667436599731,
0.8291888236999512,
-0.19787821173667908,
-0.46391451358795166,
-0.4384734034538269,
-0.11067170649766922,
0.27119505405426025,
0.45966705679893494,
0.23001854121685028,
0.0016898132162168622,
-0.10813701897859573,
-0.44674983620643616,
0.4087996780872345,
0.5040367841720581,
-0.24050506949424744,
-0.18847499787807465,
0.46311691403388977,
0.08636904507875443,
-0.05472481623291969,
0.5581204295158386,
-0.09114332497119904,
-0.37666845321655273,
0.5256935358047485,
0.17613008618354797,
0.4034503400325775,
-0.17589759826660156,
0.6092069745063782,
0.22090980410575867,
0.6306182146072388,
-0.27294519543647766,
-0.1769838184118271,
0.08835096657276154,
-0.5196883678436279,
-0.33319589495658875,
-0.24187636375427246,
-0.4099515974521637,
0.5869747996330261,
-0.5217475295066833,
0.18630410730838776,
-0.49119624495506287,
-0.09486085921525955,
0.1404789686203003,
-0.14695404469966888,
-0.7074699997901917,
0.020066438242793083,
0.287922203540802,
0.9569544792175293,
-0.6093393564224243,
0.4762398302555084,
0.1574157327413559,
-0.28517982363700867,
-0.8921934366226196,
0.37133359909057617,
0.5657283067703247,
-0.5914772152900696,
0.634143054485321,
0.033201683312654495,
-0.28770238161087036,
-0.12192549556493759,
-0.6712270975112915,
-0.6713008880615234,
0.8035096526145935,
0.4958009421825409,
-0.6826054453849792,
-0.027064191177487373,
0.5369641184806824,
0.2963462769985199,
0.047158047556877136,
-0.15268944203853607,
0.40501639246940613,
0.363976389169693,
-0.00684133218601346,
-1.082157015800476,
0.10235334932804108,
0.3673480749130249,
-0.49448469281196594,
-0.07891630381345749,
-0.8465158343315125,
0.583520770072937,
-0.14212696254253387,
-0.44005441665649414,
-0.09586898237466812,
0.4490461051464081,
-0.10193975269794464,
0.148252934217453,
0.5743524432182312,
0.2016715258359909,
0.6347399353981018,
-0.1337328553199768,
0.8605420589447021,
-0.043133459985256195,
0.27769848704338074,
0.7364962697029114,
-0.043431125581264496,
0.5986570119857788,
0.15442264080047607,
0.020797405391931534,
0.46227288246154785,
0.5549885630607605,
-0.07107958942651749,
0.14928904175758362,
0.328612744808197,
-0.5937690138816833,
-0.2578464150428772,
-0.11947446316480637,
-0.0675702840089798,
0.6598728895187378,
0.4902496337890625,
-0.2526625692844391,
-0.6758006811141968,
-0.08558797091245651,
0.33067357540130615,
-0.027105122804641724,
-0.09267520904541016,
0.9306516647338867,
0.048979565501213074,
-0.8048019409179688,
0.7058320641517639,
0.013394681736826897,
0.6469134092330933,
-0.8080621361732483,
-0.06687652319669724,
0.14965173602104187,
0.13106060028076172,
-0.1724255532026291,
-0.7173624038696289,
0.18267688155174255,
0.4401700496673584,
-0.12708421051502228,
-0.16290564835071564,
0.9499209523200989,
-0.48145791888237,
-0.3186103105545044,
-0.19919320940971375,
0.6458539962768555,
0.15545739233493805,
-0.4124290347099304,
-0.4702114462852478,
0.002139794174581766,
0.2789381444454193,
-0.4103182852268219,
0.3006139397621155,
0.6003221273422241,
-0.03321617469191551,
0.8507102131843567,
0.626885712146759,
0.22557634115219116,
-0.026046857237815857,
-0.29105037450790405,
0.7590575814247131,
-0.3589364290237427,
-0.21319691836833954,
-1.1269927024841309,
0.4868523180484772,
-0.1620880663394928,
0.09058333188295364,
0.9501553773880005,
0.567152202129364,
0.5616540312767029,
-0.08745680749416351,
1.374656081199646,
-0.1794542819261551,
0.6882590651512146,
-0.6038169264793396,
0.9911667704582214,
-0.1862836629152298,
0.04308532178401947,
0.054443005472421646,
-0.24990053474903107,
0.030420901253819466,
0.17761340737342834,
-0.2829888164997101,
-0.4665500223636627,
0.6559831500053406,
0.8664144277572632,
-0.07240281999111176,
-0.27930527925491333,
0.48562535643577576,
0.3797031044960022,
0.5862835645675659,
0.3079372048377991,
1.181269884109497,
-0.05941357463598251,
1.0196642875671387,
-0.21710868179798126,
-0.2939089834690094,
-0.316907674074173,
-1.109010100364685,
-1.0381190776824951,
-0.6310650706291199,
-0.3089476525783539,
-0.5790943503379822,
-0.15956151485443115,
0.5177316069602966,
0.6086939573287964,
-0.2805432081222534,
0.13945883512496948,
0.19340771436691284,
0.010348871350288391,
0.3132280111312866,
-0.1607561856508255,
0.31966421008110046,
0.011961485259234905,
-0.5666448473930359,
0.3282073438167572,
0.06048211082816124,
0.2741500735282898,
-0.5474527478218079,
0.2564345598220825,
0.1955140233039856,
0.31612706184387207,
0.44874054193496704,
0.4289805293083191,
-0.9743832349777222,
-0.4305986762046814,
-0.19883513450622559,
-0.14642523229122162,
0.029737092554569244,
0.8096378445625305,
-0.6867662072181702,
0.28501418232917786,
0.23388010263442993,
0.719136118888855,
0.2279381901025772,
0.07386577129364014,
0.47012656927108765,
-0.7636894583702087,
0.2745967507362366,
0.12034501135349274,
0.2650308310985565,
0.4219469130039215,
-0.5561925768852234,
0.067861407995224,
0.2169058620929718,
-0.6444553136825562,
-0.7113717794418335,
0.14800779521465302,
-0.8399056196212769,
-0.15446026623249054,
1.411623477935791,
-0.045029304921627045,
-0.05300901457667351,
-0.36579015851020813,
-0.44529154896736145,
0.2312958687543869,
-0.35873010754585266,
1.2315033674240112,
1.0997756719589233,
0.03632060065865517,
0.3175399899482727,
-0.8774122595787048,
0.9479828476905823,
0.06082610785961151,
-0.7936685681343079,
0.3500474989414215,
0.5977051258087158,
0.713383674621582,
0.35845667123794556,
0.41160449385643005,
0.11654892563819885,
0.3684285283088684,
0.341515451669693,
-0.0878690853714943,
0.13435928523540497,
-0.2026856243610382,
0.15958134829998016,
0.14016877114772797,
0.19237755239009857,
-0.1625017672777176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08403v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08403v4 | LLMs and the Human Condition | 2024-02-13T12:04:43 | 2024-05-08T10:07:05 | Peter Wallis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Theory based AI research has had a hard time recently and the aim here is to
propose a model of what LLMs are actually doing when they impress us with their
language skills. The model integrates three established theories of human
decision-making from philosophy, sociology, and computer science. The paper
starts with the collective understanding of reasoning from the early days of AI
research - primarily because that model is how we humans think we think, and is
the most accessible. It then describes what is commonly thought of as "reactive
systems" which is the position taken by many philosophers and indeed many
contemporary AI researchers. The third component to the proposed model is from
sociology and, although not flattering to our modern ego, provides an
explanation to a puzzle that for many years has occupied those of us working on
conversational user interfaces. | [
-0.3464113473892212,
-0.6893407702445984,
1.0105350017547607,
-0.083151675760746,
0.2417658567428589,
0.1866379827260971,
-0.032518647611141205,
-0.683475136756897,
0.16622738540172577,
0.16623534262180328,
-0.5713390111923218,
-0.040400125086307526,
-0.3448389172554016,
0.22901006042957306,
-0.2789142429828644,
0.44204992055892944,
0.20422662794589996,
0.2993188500404358,
-0.4475639760494232,
-0.0142511036247015,
-0.28642305731773376,
-0.7770389914512634,
-0.7875766158103943,
-0.9307324886322021,
0.5873607397079468,
0.4635346531867981,
1.0631608963012695,
0.3589631915092468,
0.6452468633651733,
0.32478663325309753,
-0.1829170435667038,
-0.1997232735157013,
-0.32881399989128113,
0.14481259882450104,
-0.240010604262352,
-0.701831579208374,
-0.28575068712234497,
0.43284717202186584,
0.44109728932380676,
0.8159951567649841,
-0.3636549711227417,
-0.14675098657608032,
0.008044793270528316,
0.72381192445755,
-0.31989380717277527,
-0.059183672070503235,
-0.31921353936195374,
0.2284863144159317,
0.032795168459415436,
-0.13492262363433838,
-0.421960711479187,
-0.21473608911037445,
0.12328960746526718,
-0.44348016381263733,
0.11477764695882797,
0.1683165282011032,
0.7125433087348938,
0.19644923508167267,
-0.5988695025444031,
-0.03411002457141876,
-1.0352427959442139,
0.7674927115440369,
-0.5848785042762756,
0.27078524231910706,
0.6924123764038086,
0.17130093276500702,
-0.4062749445438385,
-0.5211445093154907,
-0.8589345216751099,
-0.5834456086158752,
-0.3015729784965515,
0.01776391640305519,
0.024633901193737984,
0.10316005349159241,
0.3825499713420868,
0.2603205740451813,
-0.36619558930397034,
0.22664062678813934,
-0.6604119539260864,
-0.11999186128377914,
0.778645932674408,
0.5188498497009277,
0.6410261392593384,
0.05210832506418228,
-0.323697954416275,
0.43277209997177124,
-0.6146439909934998,
0.11408285051584244,
0.0695260688662529,
0.027675369754433632,
-0.15367120504379272,
0.6059292554855347,
-0.20777538418769836,
0.7880896925926208,
-0.28701692819595337,
-0.2127537578344345,
-0.19843238592147827,
0.07819630205631256,
-0.2738456428050995,
-0.3269230127334595,
0.5605646371841431,
0.3796440362930298,
0.50709468126297,
-0.22556637227535248,
-0.19899201393127441,
0.7827306389808655,
0.6012017726898193,
-0.2842736840248108,
-0.11020483821630478,
0.05986151844263077,
-0.49551519751548767,
-0.4205445945262909,
-0.142419695854187,
-0.5377264618873596,
-0.6936485171318054,
-0.7846049666404724,
0.22127528488636017,
-0.271272748708725,
-0.37172558903694153,
0.05355418846011162,
0.09971225261688232,
0.3299775719642639,
0.33404701948165894,
-0.856708824634552,
0.5216464400291443,
0.8089152574539185,
0.6472353935241699,
-0.498952180147171,
-0.5080698132514954,
0.22782358527183533,
0.17039383947849274,
-0.44957438111305237,
1.061100721359253,
-0.6777198910713196,
-0.6051599979400635,
-0.11609642207622528,
-0.19415390491485596,
0.06288880109786987,
-0.3647597134113312,
0.4790939390659332,
-0.3885388672351837,
0.18731100857257843,
-0.3503837287425995,
-0.4595171809196472,
-0.2093721330165863,
0.405547559261322,
-0.5433224439620972,
0.8546573519706726,
-0.0001844575599534437,
-0.5623375177383423,
0.13047544658184052,
-0.995962381362915,
-0.5431256294250488,
0.08656596392393112,
-0.20462368428707123,
0.05709702894091606,
0.10882977396249771,
-0.4212796092033386,
0.43218183517456055,
-0.6185804605484009,
0.2949962317943573,
-0.6606536507606506,
-0.19165262579917908,
0.8863242268562317,
-0.07547120004892349,
0.8604279160499573,
0.49448657035827637,
-0.09623140841722488,
0.19898533821105957,
-0.36548271775245667,
-0.12370071560144424,
0.09772802889347076,
-0.3453110456466675,
-0.16713427007198334,
0.5436921119689941,
-0.48887911438941956,
0.2958918809890747,
0.020356884226202965,
-0.27148616313934326,
0.31924495100975037,
-0.24054712057113647,
0.8460128307342529,
0.7847684621810913,
-0.14577975869178772,
0.7458747029304504,
-0.7139329314231873,
0.4572559893131256,
-0.2066233605146408,
0.30150163173675537,
0.23763522505760193,
-0.5751558542251587,
-1.0554885864257812,
0.1361810266971588,
-0.1221204400062561,
0.7777648568153381,
-0.4312586188316345,
-0.08288626372814178,
0.0896558165550232,
-0.22981855273246765,
-0.3159971237182617,
0.017202414572238922,
0.15260861814022064,
0.3983329236507416,
0.04442423954606056,
-0.1128954291343689,
-0.39023473858833313,
-0.9446609020233154,
-0.4018278419971466,
-0.5521132946014404,
0.07560504972934723,
0.17479366064071655,
0.4219951629638672,
-0.3772021234035492,
0.9593036770820618,
-0.4029492437839508,
0.14813879132270813,
-0.3293880522251129,
0.03469042852520943,
0.08564136922359467,
0.43472355604171753,
0.299521803855896,
-0.8085979223251343,
-0.026742586866021156,
-0.12916606664657593,
-0.8680688738822937,
0.052229128777980804,
0.27045097947120667,
-0.32437044382095337,
0.24463680386543274,
0.6506711840629578,
-0.7945671677589417,
0.4924294948577881,
0.1297776699066162,
-0.6342242360115051,
0.5384985208511353,
-0.06089618802070618,
0.0947536751627922,
-0.879923939704895,
0.008709358051419258,
0.3371323347091675,
-0.23451821506023407,
-0.9389199614524841,
0.09886793047189713,
-0.33366379141807556,
-0.3893488943576813,
-0.4543900489807129,
0.598641574382782,
-0.36648091673851013,
-0.13787102699279785,
-0.3098262548446655,
0.27222511172294617,
-0.19135747849941254,
0.232476145029068,
-0.22013510763645172,
0.6165569424629211,
0.5709601044654846,
-1.0974619388580322,
0.36383193731307983,
-0.20330815017223358,
-0.3611055016517639,
0.7744082808494568,
-0.5404160022735596,
0.2818419635295868,
-0.26151782274246216,
0.014176592230796814,
-0.854816734790802,
-0.5131124258041382,
0.39054787158966064,
-0.595940113067627,
0.009594181552529335,
0.2918606698513031,
-0.23081094026565552,
-0.6635869145393372,
0.1530192345380783,
0.2509351670742035,
0.6289764046669006,
-0.0033296067267656326,
0.8848599195480347,
0.7814596891403198,
-0.1760849803686142,
-0.11425363272428513,
-0.7396087050437927,
0.14335322380065918,
-0.3835774064064026,
-0.5457468032836914,
0.39618173241615295,
-0.303501695394516,
-1.199569582939148,
0.15047670900821686,
0.09470223635435104,
-0.4060497283935547,
0.5387647151947021,
0.19738450646400452,
0.5003127455711365,
0.06176195666193962,
0.11245182901620865,
-0.6580174565315247,
-0.2519761025905609,
0.19837528467178345,
0.16040480136871338,
0.30377253890037537,
-0.008557422086596489,
-0.4902557134628296,
-0.8458139300346375,
0.2881421744823456,
0.9072674512863159,
0.10138744860887527,
0.516295850276947,
0.221289724111557,
-0.4382674992084503,
0.11676689982414246,
-0.48854783177375793,
-0.2950727939605713,
-0.4312136769294739,
0.07236996293067932,
-0.3356229364871979,
-0.8331705927848816,
0.5716948509216309,
0.0130658820271492,
-0.008210588246583939,
0.35750648379325867,
0.7062782049179077,
-0.5264286398887634,
1.1784842014312744,
0.7567515969276428,
-0.2494310587644577,
0.4411061704158783,
-0.03149770200252533,
0.13997222483158112,
-0.6471987366676331,
-0.34841325879096985,
-0.5294795036315918,
-0.6054631471633911,
-0.5369201302528381,
-0.30913981795310974,
0.2620833218097687,
0.0188420619815588,
-0.45714840292930603,
-0.23505370318889618,
-0.3640061616897583,
0.4313484728336334,
0.5810845494270325,
0.2500993609428406,
-0.0032703736796975136,
-0.43823960423469543,
0.016138913109898567,
0.2529538869857788,
-0.5964118242263794,
-0.7482754588127136,
0.7062095403671265,
0.310261070728302,
0.8243758082389832,
0.36047181487083435,
0.4998822510242462,
0.6597601175308228,
0.7070005536079407,
-0.9993812441825867,
0.8479630947113037,
0.4051888585090637,
-0.8155786395072937,
-0.17570039629936218,
-0.24254006147384644,
-1.141596794128418,
0.15854300558567047,
-0.27523916959762573,
-0.9256709814071655,
0.13307374715805054,
0.292081743478775,
-0.3340299725532532,
0.23829849064350128,
-0.6017395853996277,
0.4931839108467102,
-0.312888503074646,
-0.43550243973731995,
-0.6491512060165405,
-0.7773362398147583,
0.6696732640266418,
0.4166404902935028,
0.6167891025543213,
-0.5966172218322754,
0.07712970674037933,
0.8387903571128845,
-0.17280326783657074,
1.0198007822036743,
-0.13247869908809662,
-0.1764664351940155,
0.48527300357818604,
0.21647122502326965,
0.2634473741054535,
-0.06894121319055557,
-0.3003677725791931,
-0.22382211685180664,
0.034115176647901535,
-0.5801961421966553,
-0.6068065762519836,
0.4105914831161499,
-0.9575130343437195,
-0.9791509509086609,
-0.5651460289955139,
-0.4747849404811859,
-0.16505418717861176,
0.05411810055375099,
-0.12576475739479065,
0.2228444218635559,
-0.5264137387275696,
-0.19110602140426636,
0.5753509998321533,
0.0521390438079834,
0.49389296770095825,
0.8405728936195374,
-0.5114766955375671,
-0.0743570402264595,
0.5615028142929077,
-0.1696322113275528,
0.29051434993743896,
0.16245882213115692,
0.10003397613763809,
0.08270402252674103,
-0.18277698755264282,
0.11386920511722565,
0.2585379481315613,
-0.7416117787361145,
-0.10584670305252075,
-0.2816694378852844,
-0.09311730414628983,
-0.37512028217315674,
-0.24389353394508362,
-0.03001278080046177,
-0.13877911865711212,
-0.6326677799224854,
0.016417313367128372,
0.1400611698627472,
1.3547985553741455,
-0.1736622452735901,
0.3348183333873749,
-0.3854864835739136,
0.5654785633087158,
0.4887664020061493,
0.33011406660079956,
-0.02436567097902298,
-0.45707541704177856,
-0.3431287109851837,
0.08894429355859756,
-0.46762436628341675,
-1.075537085533142,
0.14281798899173737,
-0.14993003010749817,
0.9058254361152649,
0.5581950545310974,
-0.05899205058813095,
0.29660090804100037,
-0.3595643639564514,
0.8417421579360962,
0.08673344552516937,
-0.7784754037857056,
0.392644464969635,
-0.1752762794494629,
-0.15219411253929138,
0.34193912148475647,
0.35138022899627686,
-0.8007243275642395,
-0.127902090549469,
-0.5222854614257812,
-0.34628966450691223,
0.6356611847877502,
-0.052097391337156296,
0.07135423272848129,
-0.11852509528398514,
0.6335763335227966,
-0.13328935205936432,
-0.34072816371917725,
-0.9931700229644775,
-0.32201871275901794,
0.18880616128444672,
0.0772489383816719,
-0.2478049248456955,
-0.5047418475151062,
-0.21968187391757965,
-0.5365580320358276,
0.552271842956543,
0.07511714845895767,
0.45531195402145386,
0.14418257772922516,
-0.10895464569330215,
-0.19217737019062042,
0.3617425560951233,
0.7693397402763367,
0.9671253561973572,
0.07690144330263138,
0.28677311539649963,
0.11978039890527725,
0.019021732732653618,
0.6480804085731506,
-0.3035355806350708,
0.01317550428211689,
-0.38925978541374207,
0.220924511551857,
0.7959594130516052,
0.1341637670993805,
-0.3813364505767822,
0.12578201293945312,
0.01442955806851387,
-0.16444815695285797,
-0.5941421985626221,
0.45920228958129883,
0.13526791334152222,
0.48563575744628906,
0.38449975848197937,
0.25742611289024353,
-0.012155700474977493,
-0.9946735501289368,
0.05508286878466606,
0.4743247330188751,
-0.23353826999664307,
-0.6203752160072327,
0.5931642055511475,
0.4806849956512451,
-1.1161837577819824,
0.5469671487808228,
-0.22930702567100525,
-0.5768940448760986,
0.5581274628639221,
0.5956323742866516,
0.8095456957817078,
-0.3538772761821747,
0.1827717423439026,
0.04478112608194351,
0.2964463531970978,
-0.4622825086116791,
0.5490931272506714,
0.12574249505996704,
-1.2109112739562988,
-0.4787091314792633,
-0.49803823232650757,
-0.7031786441802979,
-0.030674610286951065,
-0.7045804858207703,
0.2815052568912506,
-0.25395452976226807,
-0.4842134416103363,
-0.029311276972293854,
-0.20531253516674042,
-0.7997955083847046,
0.18674254417419434,
0.3382439911365509,
0.7696834206581116,
-0.9229039549827576,
0.8418313264846802,
0.9927074313163757,
-0.16346845030784607,
-0.5855730175971985,
0.03511418402194977,
0.1364915370941162,
-1.0217763185501099,
0.7710888981819153,
0.015329391695559025,
-0.2164958268404007,
0.11171098053455353,
-0.7929093241691589,
-1.0587098598480225,
0.8990542888641357,
0.4544474184513092,
-0.22730305790901184,
-0.13151653110980988,
-0.1975189596414566,
0.4643278419971466,
-0.3183939754962921,
0.06555665284395218,
0.8291735649108887,
0.704343855381012,
-0.24345815181732178,
-0.69432532787323,
-0.2672984004020691,
-0.517366886138916,
0.031401701271533966,
0.07655741274356842,
-0.6355513334274292,
0.9288668036460876,
-0.4841964542865753,
-0.3255612254142761,
0.0310882106423378,
0.7445970773696899,
0.1573203057050705,
0.40478432178497314,
0.29819926619529724,
0.685309112071991,
0.7383270859718323,
0.015647204592823982,
1.4351866245269775,
-0.35156041383743286,
0.18995127081871033,
0.537391185760498,
-0.4040359556674957,
0.5173120498657227,
0.3672897219657898,
-0.6873812079429626,
0.8096193671226501,
0.8728803396224976,
0.5044964551925659,
0.32163870334625244,
0.38730260729789734,
-0.39413130283355713,
-0.3601846992969513,
-0.07757493108510971,
-0.17222194373607635,
0.6996355652809143,
0.6681366562843323,
-0.14133091270923615,
0.2819088101387024,
-0.06520327925682068,
-0.04948795586824417,
0.04076924920082092,
-0.3721364140510559,
0.8728721737861633,
0.1968960016965866,
-0.8991850018501282,
0.33798688650131226,
0.010689911432564259,
0.5356690883636475,
-0.20200057327747345,
0.10272327065467834,
-0.21428194642066956,
-0.10317016392946243,
-0.06083009019494057,
-0.82213294506073,
0.2645872235298157,
-0.2835090458393097,
-0.4753713309764862,
-0.363423615694046,
0.9438946843147278,
0.05717454478144646,
-0.6022745966911316,
0.23205378651618958,
0.7153841257095337,
0.4964469373226166,
0.4861624538898468,
-0.6811858415603638,
0.116343192756176,
-0.03196508064866066,
-0.34761571884155273,
0.25679370760917664,
0.4319595396518707,
0.05810292437672615,
1.11089026927948,
0.40070363879203796,
0.19878073036670685,
-0.2996267080307007,
-0.07864560931921005,
0.6682406663894653,
-1.1846625804901123,
-0.37967994809150696,
-1.3448609113693237,
0.43780237436294556,
0.012645791284739971,
-0.10748769342899323,
0.3002200722694397,
0.1644085794687271,
0.33099713921546936,
0.3953994810581207,
0.9197105765342712,
-0.11080767214298248,
0.6562285423278809,
-0.4373094439506531,
0.6518120169639587,
-0.5469925403594971,
0.23293277621269226,
-0.2086842805147171,
-0.6530457139015198,
-0.2946363091468811,
0.7580471634864807,
-0.49918508529663086,
0.1200592964887619,
0.6715497970581055,
0.64971923828125,
0.17951267957687378,
0.008271314203739166,
0.30881786346435547,
0.2245797961950302,
0.2735007405281067,
0.27816563844680786,
1.2706729173660278,
0.4670875370502472,
0.02398901991546154,
-0.06858600676059723,
-0.1905059665441513,
-0.38972094655036926,
-0.7356254458427429,
-0.7305545806884766,
-0.5980323553085327,
-0.1291646957397461,
-0.2814767360687256,
0.005507278721779585,
0.8284801244735718,
0.5340254902839661,
-0.44222545623779297,
-0.5928667187690735,
-0.24221111834049225,
0.4638722240924835,
0.06459233164787292,
-0.2579501271247864,
-0.15536482632160187,
-0.527789831161499,
-0.3970392644405365,
0.3681989312171936,
0.27873125672340393,
0.2879941165447235,
-0.5876744985580444,
-0.34814491868019104,
-0.25143226981163025,
0.2195013463497162,
0.7277072072029114,
0.405100017786026,
-0.9616305828094482,
-0.390852153301239,
-0.05331334471702576,
-0.3202770948410034,
0.23819296061992645,
1.0800938606262207,
-0.9072390794754028,
0.08954339474439621,
0.1790160834789276,
0.32021698355674744,
0.08074060827493668,
-0.007110279053449631,
0.752145528793335,
-0.036994241178035736,
0.24690498411655426,
0.42323121428489685,
0.5690704584121704,
0.4390185475349426,
-0.20796100795269012,
0.7132799029350281,
0.45312562584877014,
-0.8371811509132385,
-0.9493187069892883,
0.5796683430671692,
-0.5935098528862,
-0.44225528836250305,
1.0756372213363647,
0.2069171816110611,
-0.1937667727470398,
-0.16854509711265564,
-0.11343902349472046,
0.3987608850002289,
-0.3038625419139862,
1.19443941116333,
0.6635143160820007,
-0.8300198316574097,
-0.2823491096496582,
-0.8392535448074341,
0.5342695713043213,
0.5624234676361084,
-0.9376831650733948,
-0.1146523654460907,
0.5016528964042664,
0.0745331346988678,
0.16641554236412048,
0.9496467113494873,
0.3360172212123871,
0.1250167340040207,
-0.3231150507926941,
0.23693189024925232,
0.42229822278022766,
-0.21786794066429138,
0.018452754244208336,
-0.10734590142965317,
0.42164555191993713,
0.2982094883918762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08392v1 | Large Language Models as Minecraft Agents | 2024-02-13T11:37:30 | 2024-02-13T11:37:30 | Chris Madge, Massimo Poesio | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work we examine the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the
challenging setting of acting as a Minecraft agent. We apply and evaluate LLMs
in the builder and architect settings, introduce clarification questions and
examining the challenges and opportunities for improvement. In addition, we
present a platform for online interaction with the agents and an evaluation
against previous works. | [
-0.3639965057373047,
-1.066203236579895,
0.7307801842689514,
0.2632277309894562,
0.15019148588180542,
0.32227134704589844,
-0.4640480577945709,
-0.7498999834060669,
0.09310276061296463,
0.802249014377594,
-0.6235893964767456,
-0.4195656180381775,
-0.44871053099632263,
0.37885087728500366,
-0.15092803537845612,
0.33224886655807495,
-0.30578047037124634,
0.051784712821245193,
-0.48309144377708435,
0.21070615947246552,
-0.5523711442947388,
-0.39319300651550293,
-0.9841370582580566,
-0.4742726683616638,
0.4394631087779999,
0.30098170042037964,
0.9205880165100098,
0.5678927302360535,
0.6201733946800232,
0.56697016954422,
-0.25179505348205566,
0.15986944735050201,
-0.48165884613990784,
0.5008948445320129,
-0.5037310123443604,
-0.38686203956604004,
-0.42541512846946716,
0.07600339502096176,
0.5130305290222168,
0.6895649433135986,
-0.0529385469853878,
0.5102574229240417,
-0.4385661482810974,
0.2379073202610016,
-0.20876017212867737,
0.5836449265480042,
-0.4055313766002655,
0.12173032760620117,
0.04675193503499031,
-0.06711830198764801,
-0.492879182100296,
-0.22908218204975128,
0.1467227041721344,
-0.32468152046203613,
-0.29485219717025757,
0.2371387928724289,
0.5812365412712097,
0.06653028726577759,
-0.6556127071380615,
-0.5529417991638184,
-0.8887892961502075,
0.8611259460449219,
-0.8112829327583313,
0.20780885219573975,
0.28645801544189453,
0.5870000123977661,
-0.5628221035003662,
-0.6832229495048523,
-0.5622387528419495,
-0.7251529693603516,
0.18675968050956726,
-0.038592368364334106,
-0.03182031959295273,
0.07654022425413132,
0.5197156667709351,
0.30808794498443604,
-0.4547489583492279,
0.47381114959716797,
-0.4536657929420471,
-0.16467294096946716,
0.9984606504440308,
0.6848571300506592,
0.4191274046897888,
0.056841667741537094,
-0.09268921613693237,
0.14183764159679413,
-0.7266846895217896,
-0.2019651085138321,
0.4815130829811096,
0.5689077377319336,
-0.012302182614803314,
0.8483355641365051,
-0.042598824948072433,
0.8047699928283691,
-0.3740629553794861,
-0.44069400429725647,
0.056093260645866394,
0.21984000504016876,
-0.2462518811225891,
-0.2495681643486023,
0.4518262445926666,
0.434701144695282,
0.4631216824054718,
-0.059906356036663055,
-0.38586339354515076,
-0.02244381606578827,
0.2722531259059906,
-0.8288255333900452,
0.2532830536365509,
0.44649019837379456,
-0.6009582281112671,
-0.4391283690929413,
-0.33337849378585815,
-0.47154584527015686,
-0.7969163060188293,
-0.3603828251361847,
0.41468924283981323,
0.17305371165275574,
-0.6276959180831909,
0.10210362076759338,
-0.2747521996498108,
0.4229697585105896,
0.44422444701194763,
-0.608316957950592,
0.48786503076553345,
0.6797796487808228,
0.7543214559555054,
0.10513029992580414,
-0.40955784916877747,
-0.22437655925750732,
0.19812209904193878,
-0.4583083689212799,
0.5156145095825195,
-0.682835042476654,
-0.7059674263000488,
0.3084593415260315,
0.0599680058658123,
0.1913689821958542,
-0.6599599123001099,
0.2379399538040161,
-0.5213861465454102,
0.18359220027923584,
0.0793331190943718,
-0.7087549567222595,
-0.14153750240802765,
0.681125283241272,
-0.7032715082168579,
0.8563393354415894,
0.4446869492530823,
-0.21603348851203918,
-0.3068380653858185,
-0.9059605598449707,
-0.31581538915634155,
0.21178032457828522,
0.003490140661597252,
0.04970433562994003,
0.4793837368488312,
-0.22361451387405396,
0.6063144207000732,
-0.3821195960044861,
-0.012981297448277473,
-0.22878442704677582,
-0.289803147315979,
0.4427737593650818,
-0.2688641846179962,
0.7633063197135925,
0.47027578949928284,
-0.20972493290901184,
0.30647411942481995,
-0.6717602014541626,
0.15949197113513947,
0.4320645034313202,
-0.4121547341346741,
-0.08736218512058258,
0.3795897960662842,
0.08095677942037582,
0.48791763186454773,
0.3146677017211914,
-0.5240489840507507,
0.4051227569580078,
-0.36487334966659546,
0.37541159987449646,
0.7415071725845337,
-0.11189883202314377,
0.034486573189496994,
-0.4694628119468689,
0.8540194630622864,
-0.2978995144367218,
0.028149062767624855,
-0.023451590910553932,
-0.4507051706314087,
-0.4573114812374115,
-0.14312787353992462,
0.04710227996110916,
0.49544721841812134,
-0.7734964489936829,
-0.06297703832387924,
-0.16443680226802826,
-0.6789281964302063,
-0.3598082661628723,
0.4072355628013611,
0.2414003312587738,
-0.038609474897384644,
-0.11141820251941681,
-0.27369585633277893,
-0.494706928730011,
-0.6619036197662354,
-0.06486709415912628,
-0.20126879215240479,
-0.09833481162786484,
0.5881003737449646,
0.5571666359901428,
-0.5200670957565308,
0.710808277130127,
-0.38060787320137024,
0.044668786227703094,
-0.6678686738014221,
-0.3331039845943451,
0.24726493656635284,
0.360641747713089,
0.5679581761360168,
-0.6940363049507141,
-0.7046061754226685,
0.08626841008663177,
-0.9155193567276001,
-0.09346558898687363,
0.023934857919812202,
0.16359055042266846,
0.09916378557682037,
0.8253636956214905,
-0.9570990800857544,
0.21252262592315674,
0.8499583005905151,
-0.47995367646217346,
0.7395008206367493,
-0.2273612767457962,
-0.1598442643880844,
-1.2780920267105103,
-0.37809422612190247,
-0.05773439258337021,
-0.6299601793289185,
-0.6783213019371033,
0.5448654294013977,
-0.3452855944633484,
-0.331805944442749,
-0.7688198089599609,
0.9752857685089111,
-0.9612240791320801,
-0.13765043020248413,
-0.5988020896911621,
0.41759857535362244,
-0.20906873047351837,
0.07147274911403656,
0.013266394846141338,
0.5529388189315796,
0.6789801716804504,
-0.47082388401031494,
1.159881830215454,
0.05526629462838173,
-0.45915135741233826,
0.5450185537338257,
-0.6714360117912292,
0.25478070974349976,
-0.21994824707508087,
0.07777401804924011,
-0.8529354333877563,
-0.4221818447113037,
-0.027320098131895065,
-0.1531916856765747,
0.47477367520332336,
-0.07881520688533783,
-0.7230983972549438,
-0.8389188051223755,
-0.2996414601802826,
0.057233743369579315,
0.508843719959259,
-0.4536155164241791,
0.943671464920044,
0.490800678730011,
-0.1931445449590683,
-0.1338563710451126,
-0.47720587253570557,
0.3057722747325897,
-0.34620219469070435,
-0.916110098361969,
-0.0414288155734539,
-0.33437293767929077,
-1.0187715291976929,
-0.001058843219652772,
0.19600743055343628,
-0.03201597183942795,
0.29224371910095215,
0.571143627166748,
0.04697360470890999,
-0.46978670358657837,
0.0900811105966568,
-0.5351462364196777,
0.2094758301973343,
0.38089174032211304,
0.0216035395860672,
0.6909502148628235,
-0.21564118564128876,
-0.34461668133735657,
-0.2327815741300583,
0.4276633858680725,
0.6908955574035645,
-0.2063729465007782,
1.028981328010559,
0.2840138077735901,
-0.3825293481349945,
-0.40054216980934143,
-0.7878233790397644,
0.1737353801727295,
-0.6017358899116516,
0.5685528516769409,
-0.6468682289123535,
-1.1051803827285767,
0.800459623336792,
-0.4927940368652344,
0.13601505756378174,
0.494412362575531,
0.8917359113693237,
-0.09591217339038849,
1.0367919206619263,
0.7368675470352173,
-0.1188109815120697,
0.46276965737342834,
-0.034440405666828156,
0.043919019401073456,
-0.9290407299995422,
-0.29616665840148926,
-0.43661949038505554,
-0.3261169195175171,
-0.5132107734680176,
-0.6389390826225281,
-0.14178001880645752,
-0.32959771156311035,
-0.29133340716362,
0.2912829518318176,
-0.06051669642329216,
0.73508220911026,
0.20013675093650818,
0.02966831624507904,
0.1812448799610138,
-0.2654801607131958,
0.11748860776424408,
0.2679795026779175,
-0.3486858010292053,
-0.871737003326416,
1.0612506866455078,
0.7111673951148987,
1.064237356185913,
0.6228445172309875,
0.4156453311443329,
0.2356010228395462,
0.5399401187896729,
-0.9263136982917786,
0.7359176874160767,
0.3408507704734802,
-1.1212793588638306,
-0.5472291707992554,
-0.5349541306495667,
-1.0338350534439087,
0.3573307991027832,
-0.2568546235561371,
-0.865502655506134,
-0.32379478216171265,
-0.14913596212863922,
-0.0567331500351429,
0.4673084020614624,
-0.753760814666748,
0.9267817139625549,
-0.370699942111969,
-0.29996025562286377,
-0.19623960554599762,
-0.4070295989513397,
0.3052152097225189,
0.12294864654541016,
0.3632606863975525,
-0.244826540350914,
-0.0189876276999712,
0.18993590772151947,
-0.5293786525726318,
0.9738777875900269,
-0.01396062783896923,
-0.3354431688785553,
0.6301901340484619,
0.47765687108039856,
0.8158848881721497,
-0.07916704565286636,
-0.26491084694862366,
-0.14078477025032043,
-0.11259380728006363,
-0.3968695104122162,
-0.41353124380111694,
0.9212366938591003,
-0.8757708668708801,
-1.091839075088501,
-0.34492629766464233,
-0.7479747533798218,
-0.38616737723350525,
0.15680523216724396,
-0.38771674036979675,
0.41414541006088257,
-0.5414038300514221,
0.15587924420833588,
0.548589825630188,
-0.3386748135089874,
0.6529319286346436,
0.7074663043022156,
-0.6714158654212952,
0.031440671533346176,
0.718564510345459,
0.017168857157230377,
0.5333200693130493,
0.09031157195568085,
0.18206392228603363,
-0.14891588687896729,
-0.8058945536613464,
-0.34114670753479004,
0.22459372878074646,
-0.7180867195129395,
-0.03623313456773758,
-0.28371119499206543,
-0.4377763271331787,
-0.33872339129447937,
-0.2304719239473343,
-0.3336281180381775,
-0.2693887948989868,
-0.14214447140693665,
-0.2089454084634781,
0.10890460014343262,
1.3042776584625244,
0.3147546350955963,
0.39092332124710083,
-0.748432457447052,
-0.03843913599848747,
0.5471268892288208,
0.5050289630889893,
-0.05307811126112938,
-0.5380915999412537,
-0.3155665099620819,
-0.18286634981632233,
-0.07555033266544342,
-0.9333757758140564,
0.2952956259250641,
-0.14092718064785004,
0.9333304166793823,
0.2923695743083954,
-0.28460949659347534,
0.3131085932254791,
-0.6633491516113281,
1.0026427507400513,
-0.15082642436027527,
-0.8517515063285828,
0.2631135880947113,
-0.5193974375724792,
0.26483941078186035,
0.11882475763559341,
0.3191649615764618,
-0.598173975944519,
-0.2825547754764557,
-0.4418637454509735,
-0.6034714579582214,
0.43642657995224,
0.057748351246118546,
0.7522692680358887,
-0.09621019661426544,
0.3506324589252472,
-0.22966280579566956,
0.40555572509765625,
-0.9702463746070862,
-0.2605658769607544,
0.23551732301712036,
-0.0740981325507164,
-0.240055650472641,
-0.688443660736084,
-0.15858027338981628,
0.10488644242286682,
0.6377298831939697,
0.03228601813316345,
-0.009384862147271633,
-0.19028019905090332,
-0.36792340874671936,
-0.3607018291950226,
0.17210285365581512,
0.8296463489532471,
0.9185898303985596,
-0.07762954384088516,
0.19628499448299408,
0.4834096431732178,
-0.2811754643917084,
0.11875876784324646,
-0.1597202718257904,
0.270486980676651,
-0.08941413462162018,
0.6181613206863403,
0.7047908902168274,
0.0010047968244180083,
-1.0861070156097412,
0.549319863319397,
-0.07293757051229477,
-0.22853036224842072,
-0.5267640948295593,
-0.01606619358062744,
0.5888546109199524,
0.7228185534477234,
-0.03236475586891174,
-0.4814246892929077,
-0.18702104687690735,
-1.0659421682357788,
-0.3711245357990265,
0.6112343668937683,
-0.33726921677589417,
-0.19790267944335938,
0.5017186403274536,
0.3535650968551636,
-0.7722254395484924,
0.694762110710144,
-0.27283725142478943,
-0.5694042444229126,
0.83812016248703,
0.9568554162979126,
0.883026659488678,
-0.38621631264686584,
0.13172098994255066,
-0.1460023671388626,
0.6319676637649536,
-0.21232736110687256,
0.5544484257698059,
0.4422796666622162,
-0.6770605444908142,
-0.5308804512023926,
-0.5826946496963501,
-0.7998313903808594,
0.015592813491821289,
-0.04116319864988327,
0.15378139913082123,
-0.6952152252197266,
-0.2152566909790039,
-0.20068009197711945,
0.2525308132171631,
-0.8089374303817749,
0.16412556171417236,
0.48301443457603455,
1.173972487449646,
-0.6242325901985168,
0.5808281898498535,
1.0306322574615479,
-0.30062663555145264,
-0.9220941662788391,
-0.3581659197807312,
0.2553091049194336,
-0.785777747631073,
0.6884682178497314,
-0.05332138389348984,
0.01948242262005806,
-0.08976670354604721,
-0.6958216428756714,
-1.032343864440918,
1.1650127172470093,
0.23362648487091064,
-0.46426156163215637,
0.0032003175001591444,
0.20488110184669495,
0.89405357837677,
-0.6990029811859131,
0.43690580129623413,
0.08332674950361252,
0.5106911659240723,
0.022675128653645515,
-1.2047345638275146,
0.1380138397216797,
-0.29920536279678345,
0.22568213939666748,
0.06392727047204971,
-1.0675206184387207,
0.9041352272033691,
-0.12571409344673157,
0.10160420089960098,
0.18203216791152954,
0.6440210938453674,
0.004370842128992081,
0.08680486679077148,
0.4722381830215454,
0.18001873791217804,
0.6330651640892029,
0.053312163800001144,
1.244629144668579,
-0.15743401646614075,
0.3413202464580536,
1.216914176940918,
-0.5398606061935425,
0.9051060676574707,
0.2865970730781555,
-0.2964977025985718,
0.6849789023399353,
0.5775009989738464,
0.0024107322096824646,
-0.046629734337329865,
0.9065372943878174,
-0.40794721245765686,
-0.20949870347976685,
-0.2115495502948761,
-0.3741230368614197,
0.5929818153381348,
0.49708086252212524,
-0.32589003443717957,
-0.009952055290341377,
0.031176121905446053,
-0.0023831676226109266,
0.23385308682918549,
-0.7572116255760193,
0.6948774456977844,
0.22974538803100586,
-0.18168024718761444,
-0.09965693205595016,
0.3261277973651886,
0.2519448697566986,
-0.5115207433700562,
0.054328907281160355,
-0.11055812239646912,
0.1705813854932785,
-0.15936248004436493,
-0.6966170072555542,
0.2338944375514984,
-0.03641548007726669,
-0.09022888541221619,
-0.23790177702903748,
0.7897904515266418,
-0.36775824427604675,
-0.7304244041442871,
0.27850642800331116,
0.6829264760017395,
0.3663451671600342,
-0.2140800803899765,
-0.49831336736679077,
0.326911985874176,
-0.3781539797782898,
-0.7057351469993591,
0.2520793676376343,
0.7412163615226746,
-0.20626790821552277,
0.9647315144538879,
0.47874051332473755,
0.33511996269226074,
0.1176764965057373,
0.0680074617266655,
0.8204496502876282,
-0.9844968914985657,
-0.2782352864742279,
-0.9354868531227112,
0.40328821539878845,
-0.2916961908340454,
-0.13580133020877838,
1.0708143711090088,
0.6621392965316772,
0.7558621168136597,
-0.32204875349998474,
0.5657151937484741,
-0.060357123613357544,
0.49240943789482117,
-0.3725415766239166,
0.602444589138031,
-0.43338003754615784,
0.39562520384788513,
-0.26236623525619507,
-1.2346216440200806,
-0.21019962430000305,
0.5409308671951294,
-0.14115317165851593,
0.1241893395781517,
0.5068280100822449,
0.8186854124069214,
0.16557860374450684,
-0.2478657066822052,
0.824988842010498,
0.49003177881240845,
0.4986898899078369,
0.5186925530433655,
1.3617609739303589,
-0.015187609940767288,
0.3223426342010498,
0.046558644622564316,
0.031275589019060135,
-0.26115089654922485,
-0.9972853064537048,
-1.743310809135437,
-0.14666365087032318,
-0.310696542263031,
-0.5620039701461792,
-0.03445447236299515,
1.4769856929779053,
0.5600517392158508,
-0.5696730613708496,
-0.7006138563156128,
0.6446589231491089,
0.43840616941452026,
-0.028179261833429337,
-0.15389153361320496,
-0.07210014760494232,
-0.10505000501871109,
-0.8884175419807434,
0.770348310470581,
0.25581467151641846,
0.23344776034355164,
-0.7934122681617737,
-0.19567100703716278,
-0.06552783399820328,
0.4531570076942444,
0.9818457365036011,
0.21179679036140442,
-0.5881009101867676,
-0.5429484248161316,
-0.1644476354122162,
-0.4342842698097229,
-0.25892189145088196,
0.660351037979126,
-0.4358384311199188,
0.577498733997345,
0.442275732755661,
0.6756190657615662,
0.5213128328323364,
-0.20504465699195862,
0.6631314158439636,
-0.5797655582427979,
0.26121291518211365,
0.0981493666768074,
0.3683011531829834,
0.3489009439945221,
-0.22169129550457,
0.5929749608039856,
0.028569471091032028,
-0.5546921491622925,
-0.8905516266822815,
0.2658854126930237,
-0.7753298878669739,
-0.38837963342666626,
1.3420071601867676,
-0.06478284299373627,
-0.3383195400238037,
-0.11938710510730743,
-0.3535512387752533,
-0.20989739894866943,
0.09512867033481598,
0.6929939389228821,
1.1211321353912354,
0.07863296568393707,
-0.2791159152984619,
-0.8804508447647095,
0.26819124817848206,
-0.1117003783583641,
-0.8564435243606567,
-0.2643243372440338,
0.7464281916618347,
0.44061416387557983,
0.08300155401229858,
0.5507568717002869,
0.06436242163181305,
-0.12250782549381256,
0.23290273547172546,
0.07105064392089844,
-0.3866617679595947,
-0.2960752844810486,
-0.20507878065109253,
0.2594369053840637,
0.6273484230041504,
0.3010142743587494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08382v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08382v2 | Punctuation Restoration Improves Structure Understanding without Supervision | 2024-02-13T11:22:52 | 2024-02-21T08:35:57 | Junghyun Min, Minho Lee, Woochul Lee, Yeonsoo Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unsupervised learning objectives like language modeling and de-noising
constitute a significant part in producing pre-trained models that perform
various downstream applications from natural language understanding to
conversational tasks. However, despite impressive generative capabilities of
recent large language models, their abilities to capture syntactic or semantic
structure within text lag behind. We hypothesize that the mismatch between
linguistic performance and competence in machines is attributable to
insufficient transfer of linguistic structure knowledge to computational
systems with currently popular pre-training objectives. We show that
punctuation restoration as a learning objective improves in- and
out-of-distribution performance on structure-related tasks like named entity
recognition, open information extraction, chunking, and part-of-speech tagging.
Punctuation restoration is an effective learning objective that can improve
structure understanding and yield a more robust structure-aware representations
of natural language. | [
-0.06487084925174713,
-0.847910463809967,
0.6876481771469116,
0.10866390913724899,
-0.4067692160606384,
0.25873494148254395,
-0.24467763304710388,
-0.27623921632766724,
0.11829689890146255,
0.4843049943447113,
-0.12690001726150513,
-0.2363092601299286,
-0.3138979971408844,
0.2540595233440399,
-0.4541594386100769,
0.9804344773292542,
-0.023205047473311424,
-0.08607217669487,
-0.41865378618240356,
0.3273962438106537,
-0.34310996532440186,
-0.746151328086853,
-0.5559022426605225,
-0.43484070897102356,
0.22089679539203644,
0.04835546016693115,
0.52031010389328,
0.8744372129440308,
0.5523846745491028,
0.33015093207359314,
-0.12352290004491806,
0.06636494398117065,
-0.38343802094459534,
-0.2237233817577362,
-0.051176805049180984,
-0.6416012644767761,
-0.11734309047460556,
-0.06447064876556396,
0.9437893629074097,
1.6525607109069824,
-0.01547298301011324,
-0.39754652976989746,
0.5386385917663574,
0.8226668238639832,
-0.7597312927246094,
0.3462219536304474,
-0.39375782012939453,
0.08570466935634613,
-0.13835978507995605,
-0.32591134309768677,
-0.4897305965423584,
-0.3130209147930145,
-0.03098185546696186,
-0.9847394824028015,
0.201655775308609,
-0.04694252088665962,
0.8528184294700623,
0.6265286207199097,
-0.2291000783443451,
-0.052278175950050354,
-0.6241077780723572,
0.5552539825439453,
-0.5204264521598816,
0.6355100870132446,
0.540422260761261,
-0.19589102268218994,
-0.3759749233722687,
-0.7003321647644043,
-0.35825997591018677,
0.088546022772789,
-0.40946322679519653,
0.21628358960151672,
-0.09583507478237152,
0.35630396008491516,
0.3115593492984772,
0.5346249938011169,
-0.2703135013580322,
0.06281758844852448,
-0.49478840827941895,
-0.48325514793395996,
0.003241962054744363,
-0.12397371977567673,
0.2668096721172333,
-0.07776734977960587,
-0.5649019479751587,
-0.24002112448215485,
-0.6455577611923218,
0.3827653229236603,
0.5404897332191467,
0.3664076328277588,
-0.23708432912826538,
0.19239400327205658,
-0.09258333593606949,
0.8345257043838501,
-0.20785678923130035,
-0.19330905377864838,
0.3580857515335083,
-0.6042208671569824,
-0.41887685656547546,
0.12964296340942383,
0.43726423382759094,
0.04838947579264641,
0.4918327033519745,
-0.5227455496788025,
0.2967311441898346,
0.17142830789089203,
0.19655808806419373,
-0.6894344091415405,
-0.5685579180717468,
-0.25852110981941223,
-0.07068389654159546,
-0.05029165744781494,
0.4907267987728119,
-0.3332957625389099,
-0.15821018815040588,
-0.34794944524765015,
0.10683998465538025,
-0.6444666385650635,
-0.19963662326335907,
0.6411607265472412,
-0.5367821455001831,
0.08062712103128433,
0.48241686820983887,
-0.7358886003494263,
0.17181247472763062,
0.5841395258903503,
0.6283300518989563,
-0.03527791425585747,
-0.2944968044757843,
-0.49935421347618103,
0.22541756927967072,
-0.6051088571548462,
0.780003547668457,
-0.5655866861343384,
-0.34681427478790283,
-0.21364662051200867,
0.12077000737190247,
-0.6650025844573975,
-0.5991639494895935,
0.6893748044967651,
-0.31347066164016724,
0.38269805908203125,
-0.1909707486629486,
-0.4993833601474762,
-0.42936548590660095,
0.23883087933063507,
-0.47057628631591797,
0.7413880228996277,
0.09839733690023422,
-0.8239213228225708,
0.31356969475746155,
-0.5364300608634949,
-0.7057692408561707,
0.004262201953679323,
0.14523270726203918,
-0.6183229684829712,
0.29664990305900574,
0.11766421794891357,
0.24445641040802002,
0.31780216097831726,
0.0018511326052248478,
-0.42308858036994934,
-0.502202033996582,
0.22113989293575287,
-0.12992359697818756,
0.6899451017379761,
-0.004473819397389889,
0.02763480134308338,
-0.13311460614204407,
-0.7079035639762878,
-0.06250517070293427,
-0.19176188111305237,
-0.640571117401123,
-0.5951521992683411,
-0.023563595488667488,
-0.29068902134895325,
-0.04934876412153244,
0.07203351706266403,
-0.4697991907596588,
0.04345747455954552,
-0.9397304654121399,
0.7655247449874878,
0.5208378434181213,
0.22719213366508484,
0.6470405459403992,
-0.18657836318016052,
0.42058730125427246,
0.23474900424480438,
-0.11076109111309052,
-0.496250718832016,
-0.03775439038872719,
-0.8466123342514038,
-0.6971246004104614,
0.19274494051933289,
0.4248315691947937,
-0.8397238850593567,
0.460944801568985,
-0.11203797906637192,
0.047723863273859024,
-0.5389139652252197,
0.21376514434814453,
0.7164597511291504,
0.8712273240089417,
0.44401228427886963,
-0.6203446388244629,
-0.8786045908927917,
-0.7847961187362671,
-0.2513516843318939,
-0.3541647791862488,
-0.015145422890782356,
0.060632579028606415,
0.26199856400489807,
0.02974577620625496,
0.7765042781829834,
-0.22715488076210022,
-0.35355210304260254,
-0.1346438080072403,
0.026820814236998558,
0.14363595843315125,
0.40903252363204956,
0.2999595105648041,
-0.5041104555130005,
-0.41683563590049744,
-0.1403321921825409,
-0.7574920058250427,
-0.26385781168937683,
-0.06692429631948471,
-0.18419580161571503,
0.04708888754248619,
0.6793620586395264,
-0.4560021460056305,
0.5217460989952087,
0.13962224125862122,
-0.2695414125919342,
0.5931717157363892,
-0.13417017459869385,
0.3073805272579193,
-0.9697152972221375,
0.38793912529945374,
-0.6555301547050476,
-0.49726495146751404,
-0.6715368032455444,
-0.05644288659095764,
0.1270347237586975,
-0.3035823106765747,
-0.7046617269515991,
0.2286214381456375,
-0.6238390207290649,
-0.07428743690252304,
-0.20607125759124756,
0.2883991599082947,
0.5786112546920776,
0.3607732653617859,
0.003952441271394491,
1.0379819869995117,
0.5570580363273621,
-0.7332969307899475,
-0.3382151424884796,
0.6711739301681519,
-0.26651307940483093,
0.5785293579101562,
-0.5050841569900513,
0.1661524474620819,
-0.10005033761262894,
-0.10940079391002655,
-0.9218209385871887,
-0.1796259582042694,
0.15656429529190063,
-0.5436190366744995,
0.24162448942661285,
-0.2034655213356018,
-0.4280512034893036,
-0.11953625828027725,
-0.5142775774002075,
0.19653519988059998,
0.3481278717517853,
-0.4198208153247833,
0.157694473862648,
0.05722292512655258,
0.05288255214691162,
-0.3258213400840759,
-0.6183936595916748,
-0.035716913640499115,
-0.13769282400608063,
-0.37060797214508057,
0.28368842601776123,
-0.07867836952209473,
-0.38098281621932983,
-0.17508608102798462,
-0.11684077233076096,
-0.046725086867809296,
0.7045800089836121,
0.26176729798316956,
0.1785157024860382,
-0.22416403889656067,
0.3870195150375366,
-0.16206100583076477,
0.08770263195037842,
0.08680183440446854,
-0.21108822524547577,
0.6423166394233704,
0.3391872048377991,
-0.26986831426620483,
-0.7703414559364319,
0.046415261924266815,
0.33600354194641113,
-0.45094436407089233,
0.6377086043357849,
0.3041798770427704,
-0.14360173046588898,
-0.12768475711345673,
-0.38058021664619446,
-0.25080594420433044,
-0.4397073984146118,
0.37438932061195374,
-0.5060218572616577,
-0.8840024471282959,
0.3425486981868744,
0.015305222012102604,
-0.5356115102767944,
0.4144458472728729,
0.12521986663341522,
-0.4475971460342407,
0.4254385530948639,
1.1798754930496216,
-0.06433285027742386,
0.8294191956520081,
0.09203378856182098,
0.23405756056308746,
-0.6883091330528259,
-0.30199241638183594,
-0.6738104224205017,
0.14373934268951416,
-0.05044703185558319,
-0.14711947739124298,
0.10118962824344635,
0.7045803666114807,
0.017892565578222275,
0.5593966245651245,
-0.3724442422389984,
0.3341677188873291,
0.38797345757484436,
0.23566579818725586,
0.514733076095581,
0.46075472235679626,
-0.19086529314517975,
-0.09577697515487671,
-0.5826846361160278,
-0.48749256134033203,
0.6895855069160461,
-0.04316004738211632,
0.5253646969795227,
-0.38690900802612305,
0.6763871312141418,
0.18271656334400177,
-0.07992246747016907,
-0.6117019057273865,
0.2445882111787796,
-0.07070071250200272,
-0.14429455995559692,
-0.13755714893341064,
-0.5751607418060303,
-0.9712619781494141,
0.14294648170471191,
-0.10749431699514389,
-0.7091979384422302,
0.3240208029747009,
0.21076732873916626,
-0.3428988456726074,
0.3667066991329193,
-0.9160645604133606,
0.9043547511100769,
0.31524962186813354,
-0.2574504613876343,
-0.06274180114269257,
-0.5757154226303101,
0.24211978912353516,
-0.2383827567100525,
0.18168365955352783,
0.13977625966072083,
0.07362791150808334,
0.7956829071044922,
-0.45242175459861755,
0.8858968019485474,
-0.08583980798721313,
0.15287882089614868,
0.1365814357995987,
0.0502670593559742,
0.2962314188480377,
-0.33700209856033325,
-0.1162463128566742,
0.06610444188117981,
-0.14751757681369781,
-0.2206481695175171,
-0.717371940612793,
0.21328124403953552,
-0.6694946885108948,
-0.5999758243560791,
-0.07158829271793365,
-0.5863038301467896,
-0.014038863591849804,
0.28442803025245667,
0.06861859560012817,
0.07520008832216263,
-0.2758916914463043,
0.49062034487724304,
0.6353102326393127,
-0.010626455768942833,
0.7745623588562012,
0.4994402229785919,
0.17340362071990967,
-0.43987327814102173,
0.5624818801879883,
-0.18958856165409088,
0.2247038185596466,
0.6648674011230469,
-0.17710451781749725,
-0.19551847875118256,
-0.5395082235336304,
-0.14785364270210266,
0.3910805583000183,
-0.5840123295783997,
-0.10368894785642624,
-0.7924044728279114,
-0.02150285616517067,
-0.351929247379303,
-0.1808975785970688,
-0.09527091681957245,
-0.5501577258110046,
-0.7328753471374512,
-0.17653261125087738,
0.07426942139863968,
0.4265882074832916,
0.00957784429192543,
0.6154393553733826,
-0.46705561876296997,
-0.048553407192230225,
-0.07338196784257889,
0.19564731419086456,
-0.22496885061264038,
-0.8528618216514587,
-0.28548458218574524,
-0.13536591827869415,
-0.3267332911491394,
-0.6661655306816101,
0.1696641445159912,
0.5400022268295288,
0.44860053062438965,
0.5214411616325378,
-0.012110807932913303,
0.9964699745178223,
-0.6581459045410156,
0.44768664240837097,
0.3982778787612915,
-1.1770144701004028,
0.5331968069076538,
0.04396998509764671,
0.1867642104625702,
0.6695327162742615,
0.24192161858081818,
-0.4373563826084137,
-0.29920944571495056,
-0.4682736396789551,
-0.5046291947364807,
0.6246790885925293,
0.38246795535087585,
-0.15437191724777222,
-0.08203418552875519,
0.46688759326934814,
0.0904264971613884,
0.4182945191860199,
-0.6394516229629517,
0.31057026982307434,
-0.39812397956848145,
-0.10127093642950058,
-0.23375749588012695,
-0.12518788874149323,
-0.036497991532087326,
-0.05408784747123718,
0.5540934205055237,
-0.08367157727479935,
0.12780500948429108,
0.31881406903266907,
-0.5308398008346558,
0.011755496263504028,
0.47916510701179504,
0.4182072579860687,
0.5450716614723206,
0.07179460674524307,
0.4153008460998535,
-0.02402961626648903,
-0.3402603268623352,
-0.0880540981888771,
0.4478757083415985,
-0.22209234535694122,
-0.2003123164176941,
0.6884455680847168,
0.7476214170455933,
0.39417368173599243,
-0.32743558287620544,
0.5117130279541016,
0.3347781002521515,
-0.09255743771791458,
-0.03825860470533371,
0.12555371224880219,
-0.06843339651823044,
0.10445445030927658,
0.1816306710243225,
0.09557751566171646,
0.1075422465801239,
-0.645783543586731,
0.35609298944473267,
0.5540035963058472,
-0.33351776003837585,
-0.6721632480621338,
0.7424290776252747,
0.003027947386726737,
-0.4929317235946655,
0.6865006685256958,
0.16584861278533936,
-0.5499026775360107,
0.44457483291625977,
0.6683835387229919,
0.47315075993537903,
-0.12442509829998016,
0.06833232939243317,
0.352609246969223,
0.3903709650039673,
-0.01908287964761257,
0.3213352560997009,
-0.4305843710899353,
-0.6521478891372681,
-0.4824058711528778,
-0.7878334522247314,
-0.16907921433448792,
-0.32001805305480957,
-0.6303272247314453,
0.007685780990868807,
-0.4920039176940918,
-0.12760023772716522,
-0.03560904785990715,
-0.062424108386039734,
-0.7044481039047241,
0.0993623211979866,
-0.04264769330620766,
0.7126286625862122,
-0.8779799938201904,
0.784410834312439,
0.6451738476753235,
-0.8597894310951233,
-0.7457208037376404,
-0.2187212109565735,
-0.7049408555030823,
-0.7223166227340698,
0.4886810779571533,
0.34256744384765625,
-0.13730011880397797,
0.0980614498257637,
-0.4959889054298401,
-0.5977586507797241,
0.711751401424408,
1.0052955150604248,
-0.43717169761657715,
-0.19378694891929626,
0.4965762794017792,
0.5628262162208557,
0.011995416134595871,
0.043526288121938705,
0.2834677994251251,
0.37700316309928894,
-0.31023484468460083,
-1.0457735061645508,
-0.012560165487229824,
-0.023270465433597565,
-0.14676213264465332,
0.38903284072875977,
-0.2910684049129486,
0.7209713459014893,
-0.26913565397262573,
-0.5400856733322144,
0.136243999004364,
0.3907119035720825,
-0.023975754156708717,
-0.08206980675458908,
0.5783982872962952,
0.7777542471885681,
0.7334122657775879,
-0.3260282278060913,
1.011510968208313,
-0.2497406154870987,
0.14398404955863953,
0.8895664215087891,
0.004644777160137892,
0.7420731782913208,
0.835814893245697,
-0.17326584458351135,
0.6978179216384888,
0.4920954704284668,
0.15910932421684265,
0.46691030263900757,
-0.028414404019713402,
0.04663146659731865,
-0.5122383236885071,
-0.39163121581077576,
-0.34468594193458557,
0.48875075578689575,
0.12908607721328735,
-0.5286320447921753,
-0.27469632029533386,
0.06458910554647446,
0.16491104662418365,
0.3826068341732025,
-0.15293766558170319,
0.9609957337379456,
0.09008761495351791,
-0.4467466175556183,
0.709450900554657,
-0.40790292620658875,
0.22933410108089447,
-0.5337727069854736,
-0.23512741923332214,
-0.43462905287742615,
0.3453853130340576,
-0.19704049825668335,
-0.39627036452293396,
0.6382859945297241,
-0.5070310831069946,
-0.4864060580730438,
-0.4700245261192322,
0.5971945524215698,
-0.5540347099304199,
-0.18758365511894226,
0.404680073261261,
0.4368874132633209,
0.5710063576698303,
-0.3419434428215027,
-0.4339389503002167,
0.11266551911830902,
-0.005858731456100941,
0.087093286216259,
0.04303469881415367,
0.3964027166366577,
0.16115768253803253,
0.4232034683227539,
0.7307906150817871,
0.03211584687232971,
-0.022887129336595535,
0.1061868742108345,
0.9870114326477051,
-0.5235760807991028,
-0.7947902679443359,
-1.0969977378845215,
0.5256271958351135,
-0.02238536812365055,
-0.08474171906709671,
0.9165311455726624,
0.7258720397949219,
1.0806334018707275,
-0.18175041675567627,
0.41232991218566895,
0.3114831745624542,
0.460102915763855,
-0.5581445693969727,
0.6833149194717407,
-0.4174988269805908,
-0.10294542461633682,
-0.28530001640319824,
-0.7598819732666016,
-0.567209780216217,
0.42008906602859497,
-0.4355437755584717,
-0.35411885380744934,
0.9291183948516846,
0.612250804901123,
-0.11831013858318329,
-0.47489795088768005,
0.7273789048194885,
0.1965796798467636,
0.1160150095820427,
0.53731369972229,
0.6515392661094666,
-0.2558983266353607,
0.8024227023124695,
-0.09531237930059433,
-0.1747148185968399,
0.1196591854095459,
-0.6038912534713745,
-1.1076151132583618,
-0.43952682614326477,
-0.33794236183166504,
0.012409326620399952,
0.48508355021476746,
0.28689709305763245,
0.8274475932121277,
-0.6930237412452698,
-0.03811125084757805,
-0.28945037722587585,
0.17909033596515656,
-0.14699743688106537,
-0.24846507608890533,
0.6191530823707581,
-0.8775427341461182,
-0.5239856243133545,
0.8022815585136414,
0.42712631821632385,
0.11287728697061539,
0.10152840614318848,
0.1835416555404663,
-0.2308126837015152,
-0.1636173278093338,
0.5261000990867615,
0.44127053022384644,
-0.5546296834945679,
-0.3309272825717926,
0.04523146152496338,
0.10506399720907211,
0.5300606489181519,
0.8888489603996277,
-0.9681088924407959,
0.35834169387817383,
0.369536817073822,
0.752753496170044,
0.35498732328414917,
0.16973231732845306,
0.4297664165496826,
-1.0258667469024658,
0.3889174163341522,
-0.18131405115127563,
0.6690948605537415,
0.7684441208839417,
-0.37540963292121887,
0.46414893865585327,
0.7309549450874329,
-0.10462898015975952,
-0.8455690145492554,
0.3210015594959259,
-0.6608235836029053,
-0.217014878988266,
0.6557546854019165,
-0.36669012904167175,
-0.3345062732696533,
-0.2426789551973343,
-0.18367071449756622,
0.727075457572937,
-0.16909116506576538,
0.6239399313926697,
0.5653246641159058,
0.12933313846588135,
-0.1879444420337677,
-0.07790055125951767,
0.6504626870155334,
0.6131829023361206,
-0.9497792720794678,
0.18504683673381805,
0.31265321373939514,
0.3212774097919464,
0.347892165184021,
0.46845656633377075,
-0.16144169867038727,
0.07021787017583847,
-0.23831383883953094,
0.3957049548625946,
-0.3282463252544403,
-0.5068005919456482,
-0.23811611533164978,
0.35664257407188416,
-0.015390278771519661,
-0.5538768172264099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08349v2 | Evaluating the Data Model Robustness of Text-to-SQL Systems Based on Real User Queries | 2024-02-13T10:28:57 | 2024-06-18T15:10:01 | Jonathan Fürst, Catherine Kosten, Farhard Nooralahzadeh, Yi Zhang, Kurt Stockinger | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL | Text-to-SQL systems (also known as NL-to-SQL systems) have become an
increasingly popular solution for bridging the gap between user capabilities
and SQL-based data access. These systems translate user requests in natural
language to valid SQL statements for a specific database. Recent Text-to-SQL
systems have benefited from the rapid improvement of transformer-based language
models. However, while Text-to-SQL systems that incorporate such models
continuously reach new high scores on -- often synthetic -- benchmark datasets,
a systematic exploration of their robustness towards different data models in a
real-world, realistic scenario is notably missing. This paper provides the
first in-depth evaluation of the data model robustness of Text-to-SQL systems
in practice based on a multi-year international project focused on Text-to-SQL
interfaces. Our evaluation is based on a real-world deployment of FootballDB, a
system that was deployed over a 9 month period in the context of the FIFA World
Cup 2022, during which about 6K natural language questions were asked and
executed. All of our data is based on real user questions that were asked live
to the system. We manually labeled and translated a subset of these questions
for three different data models. For each data model, we explore the
performance of representative Text-to-SQL systems and language models. We
further quantify the impact of training data size, pre-, and post-processing
steps as well as language model inference time. Our comprehensive evaluation
sheds light on the design choices of real-world Text-to-SQL systems and their
impact on moving from research prototypes to real deployments. Last, we provide
a new benchmark dataset to the community, which is the first to enable the
evaluation of different data models for the same dataset and is substantially
more challenging than most previous datasets in terms of query complexity. | [
-0.41517311334609985,
-0.9596503376960754,
0.41861626505851746,
0.282124400138855,
-0.18675579130649567,
0.018040074035525322,
-0.14775773882865906,
-0.7342707514762878,
-0.4215993881225586,
0.42153504490852356,
-0.6253218054771423,
-0.4466898739337921,
-0.22718675434589386,
0.46102648973464966,
-0.7372147440910339,
0.9112030863761902,
0.12893663346767426,
-0.013432635925710201,
-0.5474878549575806,
-0.2343684732913971,
-0.39351707696914673,
-0.8465589880943298,
-0.16055497527122498,
0.05253026634454727,
-0.023839464411139488,
0.039440713822841644,
0.8521332740783691,
0.5328298211097717,
0.8105722665786743,
0.1519201099872589,
-0.13665398955345154,
-0.03664475306868553,
-0.5945375561714172,
0.39135631918907166,
-0.30059266090393066,
-0.42480146884918213,
-0.31141331791877747,
-0.25784751772880554,
0.5707799196243286,
0.720180869102478,
-0.13815726339817047,
0.08428402990102768,
0.0843915268778801,
0.6463393568992615,
-0.502589225769043,
0.07151341438293457,
-0.7249512076377869,
-0.08516015112400055,
-0.032387446612119675,
0.20623779296875,
-0.5655613541603088,
-0.3324596583843231,
0.37702450156211853,
-0.4246639609336853,
0.13075339794158936,
0.08690430223941803,
0.9941901564598083,
0.05581900104880333,
-0.4994453191757202,
-0.25511136651039124,
-0.9667210578918457,
0.7717107534408569,
-0.6721559762954712,
0.5739684700965881,
0.31230971217155457,
0.6588216423988342,
-0.21830983459949493,
-0.570948600769043,
-0.534779965877533,
-0.30910933017730713,
-0.16110418736934662,
-0.031424544751644135,
-0.053218331187963486,
-0.17589633166790009,
0.25742217898368835,
0.1447102129459381,
-0.7659673690795898,
0.045295726507902145,
0.0623789057135582,
-0.11413965374231339,
0.7386355400085449,
0.2885728180408478,
0.061159711331129074,
-0.12336961179971695,
-0.4840448200702667,
-0.030091863125562668,
-0.6530470252037048,
-0.13080289959907532,
0.23980407416820526,
0.5676428079605103,
-0.11695706844329834,
0.5405126810073853,
-0.40805482864379883,
0.8940224051475525,
-0.3737628161907196,
0.0946759358048439,
-0.21404680609703064,
-0.7400965690612793,
-0.13705959916114807,
-0.5264401435852051,
0.9173319339752197,
0.43709540367126465,
0.4955472946166992,
-0.5514358878135681,
-0.4350752532482147,
0.07640545815229416,
0.39587658643722534,
-0.8047772645950317,
-0.0008477326482534409,
0.31821539998054504,
-0.5189206600189209,
-0.5824378728866577,
0.10906139016151428,
-0.8540483713150024,
-0.23916420340538025,
-0.035552818328142166,
0.40258949995040894,
-0.25048768520355225,
-0.3078978955745697,
-0.05014253780245781,
0.36015042662620544,
0.19366462528705597,
0.16110233962535858,
-0.6664745211601257,
0.6419627070426941,
0.698695719242096,
0.7275556921958923,
-0.5446012020111084,
-0.009205194190144539,
-0.06332123279571533,
-0.07718674838542938,
-0.3613915741443634,
0.9787026047706604,
-0.37260353565216064,
-0.4976922571659088,
0.225762739777565,
-0.0053140767849981785,
-0.1547820270061493,
-0.6815288066864014,
0.7701608538627625,
-0.6108497381210327,
0.25647294521331787,
-0.26052168011665344,
-0.814166247844696,
0.31314724683761597,
0.5061594247817993,
-0.7346091866493225,
1.1789379119873047,
0.12548385560512543,
-0.6251440644264221,
0.6440479755401611,
-0.4756445586681366,
-0.42683327198028564,
-0.14986418187618256,
-0.03168414905667305,
-0.5973078608512878,
-0.019079037010669708,
0.16218993067741394,
0.38869816064834595,
-0.7311726212501526,
0.46787384152412415,
-0.5388291478157043,
-0.5692409873008728,
0.47143325209617615,
-0.4923287630081177,
0.7685337066650391,
0.18631282448768616,
-0.04945093020796776,
-0.31695428490638733,
-0.9220247268676758,
0.14448437094688416,
0.24823491275310516,
-0.39852362871170044,
-0.12918196618556976,
0.2600241005420685,
0.28891676664352417,
0.2282894253730774,
-0.08559929579496384,
-0.4086824059486389,
0.1876920759677887,
-0.43873825669288635,
0.4137054979801178,
0.315702348947525,
-0.00223804940469563,
0.38418343663215637,
-0.23605839908123016,
0.5504134297370911,
-0.008614313788712025,
0.2967468202114105,
-0.3177446722984314,
-0.3213437497615814,
-0.3004778027534485,
-0.02867281623184681,
0.6061243414878845,
0.7583459615707397,
-0.5873023867607117,
0.46042290329933167,
-0.3758564591407776,
-0.4788001775741577,
-0.07375235855579376,
-0.21432073414325714,
0.17519745230674744,
0.49264630675315857,
0.28485333919525146,
-0.07038737833499908,
-0.39103150367736816,
-0.864252507686615,
-0.5083104968070984,
-0.43478497862815857,
-0.0446363240480423,
0.33298179507255554,
0.7099851965904236,
0.04557660594582558,
1.0419437885284424,
-0.34883353114128113,
-0.09673669189214706,
-0.13231830298900604,
-0.16844888031482697,
0.18470411002635956,
0.5033427476882935,
0.5967874526977539,
-0.7005565166473389,
-0.42155569791793823,
-0.21051812171936035,
-0.8078652620315552,
0.009043402969837189,
-0.12996047735214233,
-0.12873463332653046,
0.42658519744873047,
0.28475964069366455,
-0.49963802099227905,
0.6035612225532532,
0.5210508108139038,
-0.49746084213256836,
0.7743397355079651,
-0.03651558980345726,
0.1904815435409546,
-0.8322598338127136,
0.35713186860084534,
0.058821167796850204,
-0.23193378746509552,
-0.7389453053474426,
0.006988905370235443,
0.08478013426065445,
-0.23930592834949493,
-0.24482768774032593,
0.4211289882659912,
-0.32589712738990784,
-0.1344590187072754,
0.1465105265378952,
-0.08971282094717026,
0.09535538405179977,
0.07946260273456573,
-0.002850131131708622,
0.8749001622200012,
0.5234717130661011,
-0.6784244775772095,
0.20054584741592407,
0.35312482714653015,
-0.679692804813385,
0.894146740436554,
-0.7308094501495361,
0.1690066158771515,
0.07990024983882904,
0.2521822154521942,
-1.1873760223388672,
-0.15925200283527374,
0.021283037960529327,
-0.5202921628952026,
0.03142140805721283,
-0.2687098979949951,
-0.6310750842094421,
-0.29768723249435425,
-0.027968158945441246,
0.3218481242656708,
0.18540968000888824,
-0.5110962390899658,
0.3624667525291443,
0.36984509229660034,
0.0845990777015686,
-0.3592773377895355,
-0.7168866395950317,
0.361020565032959,
-0.16193559765815735,
-0.7753200531005859,
0.2563915550708771,
0.1119677796959877,
-0.28949254751205444,
-0.04481251910328865,
-0.24886810779571533,
-0.6669152975082397,
0.26594921946525574,
-0.07594994455575943,
0.4674625098705292,
-0.22805072367191315,
0.14466492831707,
0.045352719724178314,
0.07067003101110458,
0.17129701375961304,
-0.08476660400629044,
0.17710790038108826,
0.11798469722270966,
-0.24419064819812775,
-0.3536438047885895,
0.4900200068950653,
0.34014201164245605,
-0.1615688055753708,
1.0500826835632324,
0.12337463349103928,
-0.5078774690628052,
-0.3291853368282318,
-0.36996400356292725,
-0.2983652949333191,
-0.3652716875076294,
0.476598858833313,
-0.48697012662887573,
-0.5224499702453613,
0.5648623108863831,
-0.08080610632896423,
0.28968876600265503,
0.3448673188686371,
0.21628664433956146,
-0.47479456663131714,
1.2352943420410156,
0.5214341282844543,
0.30804091691970825,
0.2900044620037079,
-0.06204456090927124,
0.20595206320285797,
-0.29441651701927185,
-0.4368342459201813,
-0.9922941327095032,
-0.006239146459847689,
-0.3797939121723175,
-0.3351844549179077,
0.08091696351766586,
0.0035796542651951313,
-0.06632440537214279,
0.48864051699638367,
-0.32905226945877075,
0.48111847043037415,
-0.15829892456531525,
-0.026179421693086624,
0.5338860154151917,
0.12145364284515381,
-0.11464807391166687,
-0.37617436051368713,
-0.7566263675689697,
-0.7096161842346191,
1.1315850019454956,
0.25859788060188293,
0.8424174785614014,
0.15187039971351624,
0.3015425205230713,
0.5002350211143494,
0.29828518629074097,
-0.6286589503288269,
0.5098729729652405,
-0.17172537744045258,
-0.9581102132797241,
-0.26672282814979553,
-0.5253978967666626,
-0.8186588287353516,
0.28265997767448425,
-0.5510756373405457,
-0.5506511926651001,
0.3005197048187256,
0.1614493578672409,
-0.10465800762176514,
0.08855417370796204,
-0.7694510221481323,
0.9198964834213257,
-0.2280287742614746,
-0.6448997259140015,
0.30937203764915466,
-0.6843295693397522,
0.28405600786209106,
-0.22261942923069,
0.3390003740787506,
-0.011240823194384575,
-0.20176786184310913,
0.5689408779144287,
-0.5502645373344421,
0.46197596192359924,
-0.20781999826431274,
-0.2005849927663803,
0.10679135471582413,
0.24811166524887085,
0.5878121852874756,
0.03559551015496254,
-0.5408316850662231,
0.14503741264343262,
0.37792375683784485,
-0.3913552165031433,
-0.6801437735557556,
0.47627007961273193,
-0.21584278345108032,
-0.28694769740104675,
-0.5001682639122009,
-0.2936907708644867,
-0.5910164713859558,
0.1265735924243927,
0.09614629298448563,
0.4767066240310669,
-0.6926614046096802,
0.4569365680217743,
0.6634039282798767,
-0.21276405453681946,
0.24626711010932922,
0.45122191309928894,
-0.37232160568237305,
-0.10223042219877243,
0.702131986618042,
0.17551186680793762,
0.366280734539032,
0.43191206455230713,
-0.07543328404426575,
-0.6781556606292725,
-0.6594791412353516,
-0.6898255348205566,
0.16671161353588104,
-0.38011404871940613,
-0.3161136507987976,
-0.3937092125415802,
0.10197877138853073,
-0.20995774865150452,
0.12483228743076324,
-0.352742075920105,
-0.5260180234909058,
-0.24442027509212494,
0.0845140889286995,
0.07773692905902863,
0.6451014280319214,
0.5286655426025391,
0.2938011586666107,
-0.6533734202384949,
0.15674568712711334,
-0.13079652190208435,
0.8115637898445129,
-0.2266560047864914,
-0.5566339492797852,
-0.36966606974601746,
-0.09212497621774673,
0.07966821640729904,
-1.1319200992584229,
0.10596135258674622,
0.4018009603023529,
0.4601633548736572,
0.0996575877070427,
0.20817162096500397,
0.4743172526359558,
-0.31366822123527527,
0.7150461077690125,
-0.3602832853794098,
-0.755433201789856,
0.41041329503059387,
-0.3892015516757965,
0.21135497093200684,
0.821242094039917,
0.37451452016830444,
-0.1497630476951599,
-0.11029794067144394,
-0.29716727137565613,
-0.7411092519760132,
0.7702894806861877,
0.4187113344669342,
0.015039319172501564,
0.19557470083236694,
0.4820728898048401,
0.1416238695383072,
0.16305020451545715,
-0.5657414197921753,
-0.14898979663848877,
-0.1379590630531311,
-0.21984022855758667,
0.23748941719532013,
-0.13790039718151093,
0.08627145737409592,
-0.10500826686620712,
0.45504850149154663,
-0.2146240770816803,
0.29198840260505676,
0.0028161383233964443,
-0.29071053862571716,
0.284153550863266,
0.27324050664901733,
0.13708646595478058,
0.700296938419342,
-0.3398827612400055,
-0.25766706466674805,
0.24773618578910828,
-0.40982291102409363,
0.10986706614494324,
0.18101520836353302,
-0.4495592415332794,
0.05705191195011139,
0.27958768606185913,
0.6982147693634033,
0.27788659930229187,
-0.858245849609375,
0.48430073261260986,
-0.45029962062835693,
-0.2504320442676544,
0.08300992101430893,
-0.1443498432636261,
-0.035989414900541306,
-0.21742360293865204,
0.2327764481306076,
0.07592727243900299,
0.18457944691181183,
-0.5225774645805359,
0.2602806091308594,
0.5104203820228577,
-0.5148674845695496,
-0.3081023395061493,
0.8427475094795227,
0.25603172183036804,
-0.21569541096687317,
0.4597969949245453,
0.29519057273864746,
-0.3146873414516449,
0.5379839539527893,
0.6689582467079163,
0.5612689256668091,
-0.182932510972023,
0.1956256628036499,
0.4144415259361267,
0.41978710889816284,
-0.23958297073841095,
0.4492591619491577,
-0.07500729709863663,
-0.47890692949295044,
-0.3205014169216156,
-0.5193877220153809,
-0.4755904972553253,
-0.06974023580551147,
-0.8176409006118774,
0.2947997450828552,
-0.31374943256378174,
-0.5158857107162476,
-0.17705287039279938,
-0.026555122807621956,
-0.6225529909133911,
0.4711582362651825,
-0.2870561480522156,
1.301551103591919,
-0.9448540806770325,
0.7484665513038635,
0.7563221454620361,
-0.1253640353679657,
-0.38788604736328125,
-0.009464636445045471,
-0.19345594942569733,
-0.39042314887046814,
0.14184081554412842,
-0.06495362520217896,
0.176376610994339,
-0.24387623369693756,
-0.4544817805290222,
-0.505660891532898,
0.782680332660675,
0.4815468490123749,
-0.5931919813156128,
-0.0850992277264595,
0.6436758637428284,
0.8205037713050842,
-0.23239947855472565,
0.21650269627571106,
0.819340705871582,
0.24074116349220276,
-0.03034459799528122,
-0.7770124673843384,
0.05385500192642212,
-0.07860907912254333,
0.08546789735555649,
0.2648179829120636,
-0.3318069875240326,
0.42320746183395386,
-0.025399621576070786,
-0.24663113057613373,
0.12222424149513245,
0.6824963092803955,
0.12019968777894974,
0.08886758983135223,
0.6523005366325378,
0.2630077302455902,
0.5943790674209595,
-0.4294402003288269,
1.256449818611145,
-0.19141484797000885,
0.48041480779647827,
0.9020388126373291,
-0.4223968982696533,
1.0331628322601318,
0.4148516058921814,
-0.5459614396095276,
0.22212767601013184,
0.35636264085769653,
-0.015643315389752388,
0.31819283962249756,
0.19294840097427368,
-0.17562879621982574,
-0.29087987542152405,
0.003600741270929575,
-0.26523616909980774,
0.2186869978904724,
0.33060401678085327,
-0.16015858948230743,
-0.23568584024906158,
-0.24233891069889069,
-0.19751815497875214,
0.3110930621623993,
0.3543732762336731,
0.869096040725708,
-0.08928000926971436,
-0.689605712890625,
0.6060821413993835,
-0.14665168523788452,
0.5204723477363586,
-0.5680440068244934,
0.004948167596012354,
-0.39381030201911926,
0.11252448707818985,
-0.26642337441444397,
-0.973166286945343,
0.5299366116523743,
0.4928099811077118,
-0.08936522901058197,
-0.05350944772362709,
0.8167823553085327,
-0.2763584554195404,
-0.5964544415473938,
0.12906350195407867,
0.4828416109085083,
0.08903054147958755,
-0.12647375464439392,
-0.8409776091575623,
0.4454333484172821,
-0.10179559886455536,
-0.3145642578601837,
0.4223710894584656,
0.2725044786930084,
-0.1717924326658249,
0.7363708019256592,
0.5432625412940979,
0.013337780721485615,
0.016712786629796028,
0.10043274611234665,
0.6404771208763123,
-0.6260949373245239,
-0.33024126291275024,
-0.705248236656189,
0.42067092657089233,
-0.0574827566742897,
-0.1628570705652237,
0.6406242251396179,
0.7921343445777893,
0.5199676156044006,
0.06117958202958107,
0.7942725419998169,
-0.16382360458374023,
0.7031407952308655,
-0.2603432238101959,
0.8198691010475159,
-0.5377445220947266,
0.5458472371101379,
-0.3862484395503998,
-0.9902177453041077,
-0.39526495337486267,
0.44560137391090393,
0.035243451595306396,
0.07522204518318176,
0.4513774812221527,
0.854102611541748,
0.09778234362602234,
0.2904755175113678,
0.3105509877204895,
0.06533307582139969,
0.48379194736480713,
0.20833918452262878,
0.7825066447257996,
-0.7172609567642212,
0.9852718710899353,
-0.2735733091831207,
-0.14690418541431427,
-0.23533062636852264,
-0.9675598740577698,
-0.7403795123100281,
-0.5624281764030457,
-0.15707257390022278,
-0.5374406576156616,
0.3439679741859436,
0.5796374082565308,
0.6531631946563721,
-1.0706992149353027,
-0.4511474072933197,
-0.023968975991010666,
-0.04760725051164627,
-0.2983454763889313,
-0.20184257626533508,
0.28987938165664673,
-0.0918392539024353,
-0.5838149189949036,
0.2825152277946472,
0.03553343936800957,
0.11455567926168442,
-0.33720237016677856,
0.176926389336586,
-0.23019729554653168,
0.20402713119983673,
0.6078022718429565,
0.36422890424728394,
-0.19607578217983246,
-0.03385543450713158,
0.402351975440979,
-0.2317596971988678,
0.03451349213719368,
0.5981615781784058,
-0.9149031043052673,
0.4266260862350464,
0.5636011362075806,
0.6940061450004578,
0.5113105177879333,
0.2885611653327942,
0.7499246597290039,
-0.5040320158004761,
-0.1190626472234726,
0.33199426531791687,
-0.029737358912825584,
0.40350812673568726,
-0.13930252194404602,
0.6238853335380554,
0.20111910998821259,
-0.539945662021637,
-1.2996711730957031,
-0.049880269914865494,
-0.784502387046814,
-0.05407506972551346,
0.8709507584571838,
-0.08593954145908356,
-0.0775383785367012,
-0.4658586084842682,
-0.1387893408536911,
0.032175928354263306,
-0.24123020470142365,
0.7438218593597412,
0.8443428874015808,
-0.06774129718542099,
0.20192907750606537,
-0.6079760193824768,
0.49915811419487,
0.43692806363105774,
-1.1215240955352783,
0.3221208155155182,
0.3773474097251892,
0.17239387333393097,
-0.40367817878723145,
0.35493460297584534,
-0.2664916515350342,
0.07636644691228867,
-0.01713458076119423,
-0.40928640961647034,
0.1901407539844513,
-0.37351754307746887,
-0.268079936504364,
0.25660133361816406,
-0.1002533957362175,
0.20900647342205048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08341v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08341v2 | Eliciting Personality Traits in Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T10:09:00 | 2024-02-15T09:12:40 | Airlie Hilliard, Cristian Munoz, Zekun Wu, Adriano Soares Koshiyama | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being utilized by both
candidates and employers in the recruitment context. However, with this comes
numerous ethical concerns, particularly related to the lack of transparency in
these "black-box" models. Although previous studies have sought to increase the
transparency of these models by investigating the personality traits of LLMs,
many of the previous studies have provided them with personality assessments to
complete. On the other hand, this study seeks to obtain a better understanding
of such models by examining their output variations based on different input
prompts. Specifically, we use a novel elicitation approach using prompts
derived from common interview questions, as well as prompts designed to elicit
particular Big Five personality traits to examine whether the models were
susceptible to trait-activation like humans are, to measure their personality
based on the language used in their outputs. To do so, we repeatedly prompted
multiple LMs with different parameter sizes, including Llama-2, Falcon,
Mistral, Bloom, GPT, OPT, and XLNet (base and fine tuned versions) and examined
their personality using classifiers trained on the myPersonality dataset. Our
results reveal that, generally, all LLMs demonstrate high openness and low
extraversion. However, whereas LMs with fewer parameters exhibit similar
behaviour in personality traits, newer and LMs with more parameters exhibit a
broader range of personality traits, with increased agreeableness, emotional
stability, and openness. Furthermore, a greater number of parameters is
positively associated with openness and conscientiousness. Moreover, fine-tuned
models exhibit minor modulations in their personality traits, contingent on the
dataset. Implications and directions for future research are discussed. | [
-0.6022435426712036,
-0.6268864274024963,
0.860867440700531,
0.15922200679779053,
0.0169761311262846,
-0.15462538599967957,
-0.48630496859550476,
-0.5514251589775085,
0.1793709397315979,
0.3707539439201355,
-0.6607831120491028,
-0.24887046217918396,
-0.6328136324882507,
0.3509717583656311,
-0.10117875784635544,
1.0053744316101074,
0.15712174773216248,
0.08697392791509628,
0.0693836659193039,
-0.19926424324512482,
-0.42560455203056335,
-0.8634138107299805,
-0.6254152059555054,
-0.5633638501167297,
1.0432336330413818,
0.399392306804657,
0.6944587826728821,
0.36168408393859863,
0.07115398347377777,
0.23445509374141693,
-0.3336286246776581,
-0.08761397749185562,
-0.5381233096122742,
0.28980258107185364,
-0.30931857228279114,
-0.5200864672660828,
-0.3835660219192505,
0.3086299002170563,
0.5038902759552002,
0.7321892976760864,
-0.08426205813884735,
0.4228035807609558,
0.11330076307058334,
0.5883255004882812,
-0.547257125377655,
0.08145616203546524,
-0.7087247371673584,
-0.12837150692939758,
-0.14139334857463837,
-0.022873615846037865,
-0.5721560716629028,
-0.3019684851169586,
0.08625763654708862,
-0.07018080353736877,
0.008221258409321308,
0.05574070289731026,
0.5152881145477295,
-0.10593699663877487,
-0.5788808465003967,
-0.3574698865413666,
-0.7171326875686646,
0.8523749113082886,
-0.7636131048202515,
0.15295948088169098,
0.4540582597255707,
0.25441399216651917,
0.10371667891740799,
-0.1602652668952942,
-0.6954862475395203,
-0.35186895728111267,
-0.20603013038635254,
0.02605026587843895,
0.0629565566778183,
-0.014049742370843887,
0.4262602925300598,
0.4160749018192291,
-0.5634419918060303,
0.6455017924308777,
-0.14203430712223053,
0.13790105283260345,
0.6781216859817505,
0.322722852230072,
-0.13785932958126068,
0.07732684910297394,
0.1172734946012497,
-0.3251386284828186,
-0.7132975459098816,
0.18497535586357117,
0.8542113304138184,
0.2118176966905594,
-0.1682220995426178,
0.6473073363304138,
-0.38334307074546814,
0.510391891002655,
0.3415916860103607,
0.017194153741002083,
0.10606503486633301,
-0.17351767420768738,
-0.1734297126531601,
-0.1076088473200798,
0.7317492961883545,
0.22517943382263184,
0.53504878282547,
0.2387164682149887,
-0.2750264108181,
-0.2564314007759094,
0.17150279879570007,
-0.9565499424934387,
0.034668389707803726,
0.7611822485923767,
-0.661770224571228,
-0.4816274344921112,
0.06990523636341095,
-0.7003790736198425,
-0.5577719211578369,
-0.13805796205997467,
0.040367092937231064,
-0.2538928687572479,
-0.4105156362056732,
-0.07711189240217209,
0.01407434418797493,
0.7224276661872864,
0.24223604798316956,
-1.2566488981246948,
-0.007756954524666071,
0.6370642781257629,
0.6246143579483032,
-0.23029035329818726,
-0.2158442586660385,
-0.6499252319335938,
-0.16377322375774384,
-0.2769510746002197,
0.4085950553417206,
-0.8895020484924316,
-0.3808823823928833,
0.08153838664293289,
0.023136474192142487,
0.07314824312925339,
-0.5244026780128479,
0.45707935094833374,
-0.4271600842475891,
0.2024591863155365,
-0.6465502381324768,
-0.43679913878440857,
-0.06873077154159546,
0.3475322723388672,
-0.4935013949871063,
0.8500475883483887,
0.17256611585617065,
-0.4931037724018097,
0.37005847692489624,
-0.5254291296005249,
-0.02653539553284645,
0.03618950769305229,
-0.5655480623245239,
-0.44658541679382324,
0.28782832622528076,
0.044315554201602936,
0.837114691734314,
-0.11741655319929123,
0.24500232934951782,
-0.5566295385360718,
-0.2919592559337616,
0.9638686776161194,
-0.19668209552764893,
0.7643795013427734,
-0.09304528683423996,
-0.14900417625904083,
0.1443006992340088,
-0.5393888354301453,
0.04958392307162285,
0.23860131204128265,
-0.3845212757587433,
-0.14763325452804565,
-0.10698891431093216,
-0.1764451563358307,
0.37757501006126404,
0.24442604184150696,
-0.6735570430755615,
0.2257928103208542,
-0.28785407543182373,
0.19784976541996002,
1.0022741556167603,
0.01953388750553131,
0.18616913259029388,
-0.5299971699714661,
0.47224149107933044,
0.07803703844547272,
0.11415059864521027,
-0.16482393443584442,
-0.4408628046512604,
-0.5444884896278381,
-0.425533652305603,
-0.19345830380916595,
0.30450868606567383,
-0.025045694783329964,
0.7668986320495605,
-0.10086426883935928,
-0.7638463377952576,
-0.37497803568840027,
0.2547473907470703,
0.4772240221500397,
-0.009895655326545238,
0.02098028175532818,
-0.2063640058040619,
-0.29295840859413147,
-0.8757485151290894,
-0.35268163681030273,
-0.2572842538356781,
-0.22011633217334747,
0.8014507293701172,
0.6969414949417114,
-0.0212401170283556,
0.5625246167182922,
-0.40743711590766907,
0.2567985951900482,
-0.5012221336364746,
-0.06046753749251366,
0.5266695022583008,
0.24166759848594666,
0.6236631870269775,
-0.7400004267692566,
-0.4834102690219879,
0.07692259550094604,
-0.5049513578414917,
-0.08159152418375015,
-0.05358879268169403,
0.1342662125825882,
0.019219297915697098,
0.309095561504364,
-0.6628853678703308,
0.17635424435138702,
0.5801408290863037,
-0.44596385955810547,
0.8641270995140076,
0.09274540841579437,
-0.06666658818721771,
-0.7880581021308899,
0.19701112806797028,
-0.03752271458506584,
0.09236112236976624,
-0.6399371027946472,
0.2481418251991272,
-0.08504100888967514,
0.0946640595793724,
-0.4695841670036316,
0.7141379714012146,
-0.5156241655349731,
-0.2653214633464813,
-0.07713550329208374,
-0.16186568140983582,
-0.002625965280458331,
0.522934079170227,
0.04003620147705078,
0.7353140711784363,
0.33714035153388977,
-0.7576282024383545,
0.4036399722099304,
0.3774660527706146,
-0.22678010165691376,
0.7910115718841553,
-0.8369841575622559,
0.3930540084838867,
-0.4246150255203247,
0.33015212416648865,
-0.9938569664955139,
-0.5515226721763611,
-0.13412001729011536,
-0.46062836050987244,
0.11542361974716187,
0.017960932105779648,
-0.4445907175540924,
-0.21780914068222046,
-0.4716675877571106,
0.026290394365787506,
0.5853140354156494,
-0.3100818395614624,
0.555158257484436,
-0.13804107904434204,
-0.4944946765899658,
-0.2982470691204071,
-0.6318802833557129,
-0.19597674906253815,
-0.3463338315486908,
-0.30342185497283936,
0.08514833450317383,
-0.5697246193885803,
-0.46280694007873535,
-0.5861801505088806,
0.22994309663772583,
0.03654695302248001,
0.17906802892684937,
0.2398041933774948,
0.33804866671562195,
-0.21598738431930542,
-0.18036644160747528,
-0.04902225360274315,
0.22102856636047363,
0.08424539864063263,
-0.006506536155939102,
0.6885398626327515,
-0.26690390706062317,
-0.2737288773059845,
-0.36041271686553955,
0.4314205050468445,
0.7720134854316711,
-0.29522520303726196,
1.1570703983306885,
0.7183389067649841,
0.08506012707948685,
-0.05580134317278862,
-0.6674126982688904,
-0.5469865798950195,
-0.4686315655708313,
0.3659343421459198,
-0.34413522481918335,
-1.1926199197769165,
0.8389462232589722,
0.16672706604003906,
0.19061438739299774,
0.042783141136169434,
1.0745489597320557,
-0.16561390459537506,
1.073215126991272,
0.554856538772583,
0.11034299433231354,
0.5408957004547119,
0.08519916981458664,
0.1330336481332779,
-1.0405986309051514,
-0.2356134057044983,
-0.5683258175849915,
-0.44920605421066284,
-0.6609246730804443,
-0.06535188108682632,
0.2791393995285034,
-0.32973405718803406,
-0.35184019804000854,
-0.1492973119020462,
-0.31092846393585205,
0.4360432028770447,
0.33494067192077637,
0.040003396570682526,
0.11418048292398453,
-0.2475452870130539,
-0.1743069291114807,
-0.06000968813896179,
-0.13663162291049957,
-0.6163347959518433,
1.1411433219909668,
0.5612586140632629,
0.7319173216819763,
0.4525662958621979,
0.43707603216171265,
-0.012005035765469074,
0.27105942368507385,
-0.6738299131393433,
0.6360878944396973,
0.006136543117463589,
-0.7673726081848145,
-0.44310709834098816,
-0.18761706352233887,
-0.7650217413902283,
0.26352354884147644,
-0.3176933228969574,
-1.018384575843811,
0.36977630853652954,
0.20218805968761444,
-0.4391414523124695,
0.04334337264299393,
-0.6016101837158203,
0.6161591410636902,
-0.3438572883605957,
-0.3646109998226166,
0.035272806882858276,
-0.6900914907455444,
0.4288282096385956,
-0.3387376368045807,
-0.14659424126148224,
-0.27352651953697205,
-0.05143122002482414,
0.23929092288017273,
-0.04763854295015335,
0.9866371750831604,
0.1102883368730545,
-0.2516345679759979,
-0.18777711689472198,
0.20790448784828186,
0.8415626883506775,
-0.12148451060056686,
-0.5783413052558899,
0.1268412470817566,
0.006607525050640106,
-0.3041470944881439,
-0.6799957752227783,
0.5787092447280884,
-0.8680922389030457,
-0.5420942306518555,
-0.1740274429321289,
-0.5118555426597595,
-0.37967976927757263,
0.062482524663209915,
0.17802029848098755,
0.14173480868339539,
-0.24250778555870056,
0.4672052264213562,
0.8232523798942566,
-0.5581939220428467,
0.19825078547000885,
0.7192313075065613,
-0.32833433151245117,
0.12910303473472595,
0.560387372970581,
-0.03816389665007591,
0.7148903608322144,
0.1421339362859726,
0.3093452751636505,
-0.21761518716812134,
-0.4507715702056885,
-0.28186196088790894,
0.4511682987213135,
-0.5278418064117432,
0.25543490052223206,
-0.5341976881027222,
-0.17836947739124298,
-0.4484627842903137,
-0.13187995553016663,
-0.18639914691448212,
0.03951115906238556,
-0.2705756425857544,
-0.2004195898771286,
0.3149626553058624,
0.8801213502883911,
0.563980221748352,
0.3212500810623169,
-0.4286816418170929,
0.028965840116143227,
0.3906925916671753,
0.2730853259563446,
0.1561272144317627,
-0.6204680800437927,
0.07837660610675812,
-0.12966273725032806,
-0.32294192910194397,
-0.9348693490028381,
0.39133819937705994,
0.18278855085372925,
0.5747264623641968,
0.6457657814025879,
-0.1946108341217041,
0.14046815037727356,
-0.22011823952198029,
0.8515454530715942,
-0.0321197547018528,
-0.5723595023155212,
0.43914565443992615,
-0.6077547073364258,
0.22318533062934875,
0.5333265066146851,
0.5600989460945129,
-0.5227853655815125,
-0.6318826079368591,
-0.5490676164627075,
-0.5021294355392456,
0.5746913552284241,
0.26129579544067383,
0.39548394083976746,
-0.00618277071043849,
0.399253785610199,
0.3703223466873169,
0.41347968578338623,
-0.8210635781288147,
-0.23920930922031403,
-0.0527445450425148,
-0.20919828116893768,
0.007483277004212141,
-0.48582005500793457,
-0.08155857771635056,
-0.09893887490034103,
0.3609790802001953,
-0.23074673116207123,
0.14695870876312256,
0.029049178585410118,
0.2927466332912445,
0.1357714831829071,
0.7220594882965088,
0.5400325059890747,
0.49120864272117615,
-0.3463638424873352,
0.1249888464808464,
0.2665213644504547,
-0.3376554846763611,
0.20424580574035645,
-0.2950262129306793,
-0.07937270402908325,
-0.15320444107055664,
0.1580139845609665,
0.8076292872428894,
-0.07151322066783905,
-0.728798508644104,
0.670163094997406,
0.0784560814499855,
-0.09356456249952316,
-0.3330238461494446,
0.22118046879768372,
0.18127748370170593,
0.19909624755382538,
0.19827629625797272,
-0.4069059193134308,
-0.022576939314603806,
-0.7981669306755066,
-0.34230417013168335,
0.650688886642456,
-0.20873446762561798,
-0.3979555368423462,
0.33050987124443054,
0.22566093504428864,
-0.17500443756580353,
0.4610919952392578,
-0.30634230375289917,
-0.24112388491630554,
0.5145487189292908,
0.4343906342983246,
0.802817702293396,
-0.31720250844955444,
0.05371367558836937,
0.29642465710639954,
0.24467770755290985,
0.08016151934862137,
0.4618246853351593,
0.07081835716962814,
-0.8503639101982117,
-0.43561893701553345,
-0.7257924675941467,
-0.6870896220207214,
0.47095295786857605,
-0.7639977931976318,
0.08759396523237228,
-0.49667927622795105,
-0.15149644017219543,
-0.06485538929700851,
-0.14839258790016174,
-0.7734959125518799,
0.06478267163038254,
0.26364612579345703,
0.7258226275444031,
-0.8801916241645813,
0.6041309833526611,
0.8314164876937866,
-0.33682119846343994,
-0.9401425719261169,
0.014884657226502895,
0.10986551642417908,
-0.8468543887138367,
0.6959087252616882,
0.2635863721370697,
0.2615981996059418,
-0.006747551262378693,
-0.6403806805610657,
-0.5863760113716125,
1.0121601819992065,
0.4531184434890747,
-0.4849065840244293,
-0.23017215728759766,
0.19431467354297638,
0.4015290141105652,
-0.5411080718040466,
0.5661572217941284,
0.641126811504364,
0.5927916169166565,
0.0128426942974329,
-0.9985581636428833,
0.18765200674533844,
-0.22871164977550507,
0.18162325024604797,
-0.16173487901687622,
-0.7977698445320129,
0.8691561818122864,
-0.26383721828460693,
0.17602156102657318,
0.12541675567626953,
0.495754599571228,
0.6173262596130371,
-0.02140979841351509,
0.4760532081127167,
0.11175654828548431,
0.9092145562171936,
0.20192214846611023,
1.0057909488677979,
-0.38195812702178955,
0.0812782570719719,
0.9310800433158875,
-0.6849940419197083,
0.8898288011550903,
0.5383473038673401,
-0.14432372152805328,
0.7485153675079346,
0.43556711077690125,
-0.05063510313630104,
-0.020669344812631607,
0.10832005739212036,
-0.19083631038665771,
-0.1912839561700821,
-0.2708742916584015,
-0.05832075700163841,
0.5884194374084473,
0.3579155206680298,
-0.6039441823959351,
0.13183964788913727,
0.00494340481236577,
0.17229683697223663,
-0.09042034298181534,
-0.28470537066459656,
0.61137855052948,
0.13396410644054413,
-0.815895140171051,
0.35515204071998596,
-0.06648758798837662,
0.8067414164543152,
-0.7024701833724976,
0.1115548238158226,
-0.3238205015659332,
-0.12243403494358063,
-0.2844015657901764,
-1.0850679874420166,
0.12895885109901428,
0.011219190433621407,
-0.21566076576709747,
-0.37262412905693054,
0.4346168339252472,
-0.27684229612350464,
-0.15921354293823242,
0.1195961982011795,
0.5294640064239502,
0.3810974657535553,
-0.28940439224243164,
-0.41260772943496704,
0.22772201895713806,
-0.17812871932983398,
-0.4611993730068207,
0.5291529893875122,
0.3655985891819,
0.011188540607690811,
0.698459804058075,
0.8387889266014099,
0.42828887701034546,
-0.06345394253730774,
0.060902565717697144,
0.6258613467216492,
-0.6721886396408081,
-0.558692991733551,
-1.02876615524292,
0.4312300682067871,
-0.08762554079294205,
-0.5171805024147034,
0.7550634741783142,
0.23525775969028473,
0.5526825189590454,
-0.19247181713581085,
0.7341076731681824,
0.15169653296470642,
0.537085771560669,
-0.46834859251976013,
0.6116109490394592,
-0.3032524287700653,
0.20730309188365936,
-0.22197546064853668,
-0.9046590328216553,
0.38547614216804504,
0.3447582423686981,
-0.4143034815788269,
0.41486528515815735,
0.5261280536651611,
0.8463217616081238,
0.19232100248336792,
-0.07513237744569778,
0.5610737800598145,
0.566589891910553,
0.2757629454135895,
0.6005169749259949,
0.7808008790016174,
0.23096682131290436,
0.2573164999485016,
0.14781206846237183,
-0.21257738769054413,
-0.49459096789360046,
-0.7944808602333069,
-1.0170578956604004,
-0.44368863105773926,
-0.13202480971813202,
-0.4748522639274597,
-0.20272870361804962,
0.8613741397857666,
0.5867502093315125,
-0.5404638051986694,
-0.2137443870306015,
0.151983380317688,
0.006790915038436651,
-0.04940345138311386,
-0.25029876828193665,
-0.11234091967344284,
0.17916996777057648,
-0.6012387275695801,
0.10901634395122528,
0.2707889676094055,
0.13181401789188385,
-0.773895263671875,
0.022452346980571747,
0.16871696710586548,
0.4154515564441681,
0.6133326292037964,
0.36619478464126587,
-0.7979776263237,
-0.5781112909317017,
0.2496860772371292,
-0.1948263794183731,
-0.16002941131591797,
0.6395725607872009,
-0.42621636390686035,
0.07507902383804321,
0.351047545671463,
0.37231358885765076,
0.2019485980272293,
-0.07459449023008347,
0.6136394143104553,
-0.8638321161270142,
0.0978522077202797,
0.2790529429912567,
0.31735020875930786,
0.3416287899017334,
-0.5958428978919983,
0.26576748490333557,
-0.16379781067371368,
-0.690364420413971,
-0.7833997011184692,
0.4868408143520355,
-1.1246154308319092,
-0.0020064159762114286,
1.5454919338226318,
0.01918794959783554,
-0.01676921546459198,
-0.08054109662771225,
-0.20226441323757172,
-0.15796466171741486,
-0.3810036778450012,
0.6064199805259705,
0.8680810928344727,
-0.2989734411239624,
-0.19970642030239105,
-0.7205410003662109,
0.3038691580295563,
0.4038101136684418,
-0.8079068064689636,
0.2571971118450165,
0.3679219186306,
0.28967395424842834,
-0.037140313535928726,
0.6519915461540222,
-0.10715048015117645,
0.1711539626121521,
-0.34267324209213257,
0.03662297502160072,
0.06312385201454163,
0.0549486018717289,
-0.44478315114974976,
0.05112336948513985,
0.43092307448387146,
0.3208030164241791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08327v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08327v2 | PreFLMR: Scaling Up Fine-Grained Late-Interaction Multi-modal Retrievers | 2024-02-13T09:47:07 | 2024-06-05T11:46:23 | Weizhe Lin, Jingbiao Mei, Jinghong Chen, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) excel in natural language and visual
understanding but are challenged by exacting tasks such as Knowledge-based
Visual Question Answering (KB-VQA) which involve the retrieval of relevant
information from document collections to use in shaping answers to questions.
We present an extensive training and evaluation framework, M2KR, for KB-VQA.
M2KR contains a collection of vision and language tasks which we have
incorporated into a single suite of benchmark tasks for training and evaluating
general-purpose multi-modal retrievers. We use M2KR to develop PreFLMR, a
pre-trained version of the recently developed Fine-grained Late-interaction
Multi-modal Retriever (FLMR) approach to KB-VQA, and we report new
state-of-the-art results across a range of tasks. We also present
investigations into the scaling behaviors of PreFLMR intended to be useful in
future developments in general-purpose multi-modal retrievers. | [
-0.5620583891868591,
-1.010806679725647,
0.3113154470920563,
0.11086898297071457,
-0.04105991870164871,
-0.15107551217079163,
0.025516116991639137,
-0.2287614643573761,
-0.20645083487033844,
0.31999048590660095,
-0.49927738308906555,
0.1968076527118683,
-0.6683892011642456,
-0.019532840698957443,
-0.20940113067626953,
0.8368542194366455,
-0.13527365028858185,
0.3573387563228607,
-0.5016132593154907,
-0.02650323510169983,
-0.420148104429245,
-0.6301475763320923,
-0.40535029768943787,
-0.21890592575073242,
0.7448896765708923,
0.48950105905532837,
0.7771257162094116,
0.1895047128200531,
1.021034598350525,
0.4322017431259155,
0.03291885554790497,
0.10886314511299133,
-0.8056634664535522,
-0.13470132648944855,
-0.09080862253904343,
-0.4171209931373596,
-0.5670697093009949,
-0.12996415793895721,
0.47272565960884094,
0.41491326689720154,
0.008612573146820068,
0.3763265311717987,
-0.1932176649570465,
0.7041522264480591,
-0.9889180064201355,
0.2617519795894623,
-0.371581494808197,
0.2751123011112213,
-0.15808555483818054,
-0.3612218499183655,
-0.3007117509841919,
0.02953830175101757,
0.31411826610565186,
-0.8963396549224854,
0.049467820674180984,
0.07549320161342621,
0.8306189179420471,
0.11409761756658554,
-0.706199586391449,
-0.2559168040752411,
-0.7567853927612305,
0.7497501373291016,
-0.1567842811346054,
0.6986087560653687,
0.5888319611549377,
0.8131972551345825,
0.05361254885792732,
-0.9885431528091431,
-0.5265551209449768,
-0.12478237599134445,
-0.14331859350204468,
0.024779263883829117,
-0.16706937551498413,
0.18045391142368317,
0.06912997364997864,
0.5085030198097229,
-0.4419553279876709,
-0.3006000518798828,
-0.39317601919174194,
-0.44120070338249207,
0.32322636246681213,
0.37437933683395386,
0.018901199102401733,
-0.11651434749364853,
-0.32102933526039124,
-0.1694561243057251,
-0.3010118901729584,
0.39465534687042236,
-0.16864076256752014,
0.03476085513830185,
0.011301962658762932,
0.8074665665626526,
-0.41548728942871094,
0.9772050380706787,
0.30634811520576477,
-0.22353418171405792,
0.27297309041023254,
-0.8065811395645142,
-0.3446037173271179,
-0.5224624276161194,
0.5592869520187378,
0.5310729146003723,
0.31409287452697754,
0.048392120748758316,
-0.5071240663528442,
-0.3418298065662384,
0.522367000579834,
-1.0100187063217163,
-0.3015117347240448,
-0.21708713471889496,
-0.649006724357605,
-0.2660852372646332,
-0.046851713210344315,
-0.7868309020996094,
-0.09137008339166641,
-0.5053719282150269,
1.3798390626907349,
-0.2625158429145813,
-0.3841337263584137,
0.11904212087392807,
-0.01732589490711689,
0.5437361001968384,
0.533174455165863,
-0.7687874436378479,
0.2628806531429291,
0.5417792201042175,
0.5365384221076965,
0.1993567794561386,
-0.3243059813976288,
-1.0639567375183105,
0.06742141395807266,
-0.17461088299751282,
0.6401198506355286,
-0.7114437818527222,
-0.276770681142807,
-0.04588222876191139,
0.1562681943178177,
-0.12540042400360107,
-0.6247414946556091,
0.24502834677696228,
-0.950263500213623,
0.19327639043331146,
-0.5752344727516174,
-0.1999688297510147,
-0.0335095152258873,
0.6263740062713623,
-0.5294695496559143,
0.8014664053916931,
0.3948614001274109,
-0.8591181039810181,
0.41353732347488403,
-0.6355487108230591,
-0.3406566083431244,
-0.1748044639825821,
-0.43733516335487366,
-0.18449999392032623,
0.2613641321659088,
0.3625572621822357,
0.6119716763496399,
-0.20516660809516907,
-0.036769043654203415,
-0.24031613767147064,
-0.342710018157959,
0.20235532522201538,
-0.3604397177696228,
0.12575703859329224,
0.4173694849014282,
-0.03541066497564316,
0.5180058479309082,
-0.7466800808906555,
0.10870567709207535,
0.09056404232978821,
-0.5935131311416626,
-0.1062367632985115,
-0.1965624839067459,
0.3787451982498169,
0.4302327632904053,
0.47098228335380554,
-0.2672280967235565,
-0.11371932923793793,
-0.02654273994266987,
0.32778850197792053,
0.648565411567688,
-0.18407423794269562,
0.6206175684928894,
-0.37587153911590576,
0.579663872718811,
0.3765406906604767,
0.4721871614456177,
-0.3710620105266571,
-0.012758682481944561,
-0.7936504483222961,
-0.3872620165348053,
0.044135451316833496,
0.32870709896087646,
-1.186631679534912,
-0.042338721454143524,
-0.33235374093055725,
-0.4893297851085663,
-0.4098900854587555,
0.3356781601905823,
0.728997528553009,
0.6461283564567566,
0.5256482362747192,
-0.4678416848182678,
-0.34986910223960876,
-0.9909389019012451,
-0.05947422236204147,
0.12821897864341736,
-0.11834421008825302,
0.425746351480484,
0.4097711741924286,
-0.3930114805698395,
0.9897544980049133,
-0.45759761333465576,
-0.527430534362793,
-0.15358877182006836,
0.36573028564453125,
-0.18684516847133636,
0.38489511609077454,
0.3426518440246582,
-1.2730646133422852,
-0.31366869807243347,
-0.0353458896279335,
-0.5402523875236511,
0.23687271773815155,
0.13240638375282288,
-0.07500652223825455,
-0.07114804536104202,
0.7458240389823914,
-0.5655403733253479,
0.20009446144104004,
0.38111424446105957,
-0.3521917164325714,
0.6292476654052734,
-0.24497835338115692,
0.5679152607917786,
-0.9287705421447754,
0.28058239817619324,
-0.2967923879623413,
-0.33224621415138245,
-0.734510064125061,
0.08504170179367065,
0.2006402611732483,
-0.09997297823429108,
-0.7580456137657166,
0.6098241806030273,
-0.6531123518943787,
-0.33597493171691895,
-0.07930266112089157,
-0.1598498821258545,
-0.0009155937586911023,
0.2846401631832123,
-0.030638348311185837,
0.9830479025840759,
0.3145076334476471,
-0.6319652199745178,
0.2831176519393921,
0.06924284994602203,
-0.30261868238449097,
0.7525528073310852,
-0.5627284646034241,
0.1932782232761383,
-0.3187609016895294,
-0.15050919353961945,
-1.0188614130020142,
-0.28434330224990845,
-0.08846462517976761,
-0.33895960450172424,
0.40764033794403076,
-0.16684290766716003,
-0.48544690012931824,
-0.40316370129585266,
-0.2048691362142563,
0.6544572710990906,
0.15635575354099274,
-0.3017088770866394,
1.120985984802246,
0.22496066987514496,
-0.0809127688407898,
-0.7217990159988403,
-0.5263157486915588,
-0.42332959175109863,
0.12691091001033783,
-0.6209114789962769,
-0.049747806042432785,
-0.3905758857727051,
-0.14196571707725525,
-0.13398981094360352,
-0.2810925543308258,
-0.42681652307510376,
0.0059564863331615925,
0.11320200562477112,
-0.03631886839866638,
-0.614533543586731,
-0.029420966282486916,
-0.19619227945804596,
-0.12072493135929108,
0.020642194896936417,
0.20583972334861755,
0.6530938744544983,
-0.5204368829727173,
-0.4039172828197479,
-0.11306972056627274,
0.14112533628940582,
0.6467169523239136,
-0.5761944055557251,
0.524631917476654,
1.0022355318069458,
-0.18496198952198029,
0.6333276033401489,
-0.8442791700363159,
-0.18566948175430298,
-0.5417546629905701,
0.6571601629257202,
-0.8533968329429626,
-1.3346922397613525,
0.17003698647022247,
-0.10025302320718765,
-0.11960402131080627,
0.23872630298137665,
0.7233777046203613,
-0.19272397458553314,
0.9970822334289551,
0.901751697063446,
0.08236072212457657,
0.5370763540267944,
0.043814919888973236,
-0.2048359513282776,
-0.6375142931938171,
-0.36731410026550293,
-0.19651447236537933,
-0.34277263283729553,
-0.017363231629133224,
-0.8877770304679871,
0.37277737259864807,
0.4092530310153961,
-0.2675711512565613,
-0.06209573149681091,
-0.08947701752185822,
0.6789289116859436,
0.48802709579467773,
0.06442410498857498,
0.40714243054389954,
-0.04269211366772652,
-0.1066962406039238,
-0.15474094450473785,
-0.6052777171134949,
-0.1971627026796341,
1.1389822959899902,
0.21504436433315277,
0.8482149243354797,
0.1391807198524475,
0.27062368392944336,
0.0962148904800415,
0.37727853655815125,
-0.8031316995620728,
0.4859806001186371,
0.03468110039830208,
-0.8616506457328796,
-0.3954007029533386,
-0.5569445490837097,
-0.9324894547462463,
0.46950405836105347,
-0.45402589440345764,
-0.3661537766456604,
-0.04422598332166672,
0.3821184039115906,
-0.29679742455482483,
0.06185498461127281,
-0.7543834447860718,
1.2444772720336914,
-0.46257272362709045,
-0.23269371688365936,
-0.36188095808029175,
-0.9434898495674133,
0.3997889757156372,
-0.32864809036254883,
0.33762356638908386,
0.11761566251516342,
-0.22381864488124847,
0.5796457529067993,
-0.20463381707668304,
0.5518587827682495,
-0.48976314067840576,
0.015456488355994225,
0.08035717904567719,
0.2050396203994751,
0.2363441288471222,
-0.08867455273866653,
0.14934372901916504,
-0.1706804782152176,
0.4136088788509369,
-0.4803866147994995,
-0.5647470355033875,
0.3586423993110657,
-0.8888513445854187,
-0.3592235743999481,
-0.1875791698694229,
-0.6376075148582458,
-0.297223299741745,
0.5091525912284851,
0.10177750140428543,
0.5696118474006653,
-0.43115171790122986,
0.5665277242660522,
0.6683560013771057,
-0.04117614030838013,
0.23554301261901855,
0.8179321885108948,
-0.6438890099525452,
-0.5945641994476318,
0.8815544843673706,
0.059775978326797485,
0.3538256883621216,
0.9476295709609985,
0.13988935947418213,
-0.15155041217803955,
-0.42636579275131226,
-0.4413020610809326,
-0.15834663808345795,
-0.6096263527870178,
-0.33186545968055725,
-0.7359588146209717,
-0.1850525140762329,
-0.23780930042266846,
-0.1776311993598938,
-0.38702619075775146,
-0.19912433624267578,
-0.36527079343795776,
0.19028060138225555,
0.13067874312400818,
0.5258660316467285,
-0.12232012301683426,
0.6168286800384521,
-0.9163037538528442,
0.6730127930641174,
0.7367339730262756,
0.4083014726638794,
-0.11383160203695297,
-0.5685407519340515,
-0.42585065960884094,
-0.07715996354818344,
-0.2667889893054962,
-0.3583962321281433,
0.11619925498962402,
0.31336668133735657,
0.43014734983444214,
0.541718602180481,
-0.14705413579940796,
0.8235794901847839,
-0.6972017288208008,
0.5996394157409668,
0.43909838795661926,
-0.6886547803878784,
0.5140847563743591,
-0.29912084341049194,
0.5696209669113159,
0.782876193523407,
0.7463851571083069,
-0.33071455359458923,
0.2280810922384262,
-0.14187726378440857,
-0.6556634902954102,
0.623647928237915,
-0.012474856339395046,
0.17872010171413422,
0.194502592086792,
0.1573711484670639,
0.014259150251746178,
0.4174617826938629,
-0.5722624063491821,
-0.006027630064636469,
-0.41377776861190796,
-0.275973379611969,
-0.5492277145385742,
-0.531200110912323,
-0.20644457638263702,
-0.3729681372642517,
0.22409403324127197,
-0.23035933077335358,
0.22308820486068726,
0.22111976146697998,
-0.7725939154624939,
-0.1967591494321823,
0.41717401146888733,
0.7448435425758362,
0.8155330419540405,
-0.41724181175231934,
0.3516135513782501,
-0.03959294408559799,
-0.7225567698478699,
0.19932551681995392,
0.3670103847980499,
0.1659906506538391,
-0.4929903447628021,
0.3101988136768341,
0.5896012187004089,
0.5205222368240356,
-0.8241231441497803,
0.9897028207778931,
-0.3632124960422516,
-0.20035526156425476,
-0.23424620926380157,
-0.09516080468893051,
0.0318809449672699,
0.5055277943611145,
0.49301066994667053,
0.03865563124418259,
0.08989562094211578,
-0.40945833921432495,
0.4638703465461731,
0.5042626857757568,
-0.6009936332702637,
-0.37810683250427246,
0.6329444050788879,
0.22959540784358978,
-0.22635844349861145,
0.5413132905960083,
-0.03652089089155197,
-0.33576440811157227,
0.23370781540870667,
0.3436431884765625,
0.32565760612487793,
-0.15510298311710358,
-0.007842492312192917,
0.05602382868528366,
0.4372294843196869,
0.11673495918512344,
0.6043508648872375,
-0.2913943827152252,
-0.6160393953323364,
-0.40405842661857605,
-0.8294991254806519,
-0.13386796414852142,
0.1658969670534134,
-0.7427829504013062,
0.2450542151927948,
-0.49238404631614685,
-0.25677746534347534,
-0.12991763651371002,
-0.009792543947696686,
-0.9874482154846191,
0.29845935106277466,
-0.05714324861764908,
0.9597705006599426,
-0.5378409624099731,
0.7035992741584778,
0.8959506154060364,
-0.7279226183891296,
-0.6635804176330566,
-0.14424936473369598,
0.21323294937610626,
-0.7818282842636108,
0.9324891567230225,
0.2219044417142868,
-0.22876697778701782,
0.17211033403873444,
-0.25838789343833923,
-1.0404987335205078,
1.2646137475967407,
0.183134064078331,
-0.5049235224723816,
-0.1565370112657547,
0.24663768708705902,
0.4224987030029297,
-0.22378070652484894,
0.5300990343093872,
0.21716715395450592,
0.39992231130599976,
0.07190126180648804,
-1.2315130233764648,
-0.15187327563762665,
-0.25940272212028503,
-0.07598516345024109,
0.19383953511714935,
-0.6606159806251526,
0.9149528741836548,
-0.1549304872751236,
0.2833694517612457,
0.018105074763298035,
0.7809324264526367,
0.11776157468557358,
0.46361005306243896,
0.6733395457267761,
0.3922150135040283,
0.40199899673461914,
0.055926453322172165,
0.8189038634300232,
-0.002323383232578635,
0.14552056789398193,
1.2233741283416748,
-0.03027378022670746,
1.1637938022613525,
0.7627079486846924,
-0.0655021145939827,
0.02412578836083412,
0.4522068202495575,
0.14457572996616364,
0.576026201248169,
0.1734296977519989,
-0.09695733338594437,
-0.4287264049053192,
0.02188466116786003,
-0.4535709619522095,
0.5726211071014404,
0.19276273250579834,
-0.10130719095468521,
-0.16585110127925873,
0.33697810769081116,
-0.2663819193840027,
-0.2031068652868271,
-0.7251474261283875,
0.8572342395782471,
0.04778142273426056,
-0.21998481452465057,
0.4916172921657562,
-0.18228495121002197,
0.9754992723464966,
-0.8115932941436768,
0.23286227881908417,
-0.19399534165859222,
0.3877773582935333,
-0.01880900003015995,
-0.5925582647323608,
0.1539587825536728,
-0.1320437341928482,
-0.46693655848503113,
-0.08201663196086884,
0.9414311647415161,
-0.4140735864639282,
-0.5832880735397339,
0.32714059948921204,
0.8149394392967224,
0.0405910387635231,
-0.3325032889842987,
-0.5822774171829224,
0.06665848940610886,
-0.34244388341903687,
-0.4670071303844452,
0.6230536103248596,
0.6367911696434021,
0.12125983089208603,
0.7534747123718262,
0.5106827616691589,
-0.3782781660556793,
0.40321454405784607,
0.1609056442975998,
1.0525952577590942,
-0.6417509317398071,
-0.10551697015762329,
-0.4210749864578247,
0.5027880668640137,
0.24764105677604675,
-0.14017637073993683,
0.49936386942863464,
0.8948312997817993,
1.0118929147720337,
-0.42756569385528564,
0.1384948045015335,
-0.060918599367141724,
0.3527328073978424,
-0.5628999471664429,
0.8405777812004089,
-1.051024079322815,
-0.3468167781829834,
-0.3730285167694092,
-0.8280848860740662,
-0.06880040466785431,
0.557968258857727,
-0.2979462146759033,
0.08884164690971375,
0.4585985839366913,
0.8630146384239197,
-0.4938660264015198,
-0.29453930258750916,
0.6207420825958252,
0.22418208420276642,
0.15639181435108185,
0.4990057051181793,
1.08980131149292,
-0.32840025424957275,
1.0128755569458008,
-0.22322122752666473,
-0.15235531330108643,
-0.430000364780426,
-0.6385713815689087,
-0.8025652766227722,
-0.6234061121940613,
0.07138664275407791,
-0.007934625260531902,
-0.05435219779610634,
0.7993515133857727,
0.9319049715995789,
-0.5640794038772583,
-0.1922817975282669,
0.2613183259963989,
-0.4703781306743622,
0.013761056587100029,
-0.2089725136756897,
0.05147459730505943,
-0.51482754945755,
-0.3369598388671875,
0.3595854640007019,
0.17853277921676636,
0.1503261774778366,
-0.3076074719429016,
-0.2851506471633911,
-0.37240999937057495,
-0.1041514128446579,
1.121200442314148,
0.13709084689617157,
-0.6309232115745544,
-0.3888697624206543,
0.1857520341873169,
-0.1298612505197525,
0.2036445140838623,
0.8892285823822021,
-0.7209994196891785,
0.5925124287605286,
0.44653910398483276,
0.9077495336532593,
0.8189043402671814,
-0.07212799042463303,
0.5621450543403625,
-0.701621949672699,
0.10340661555528641,
0.12348976731300354,
0.05302853509783745,
0.24452902376651764,
-0.04945545271039009,
0.3074418902397156,
-0.004509170074015856,
-0.5595404505729675,
-0.6749765276908875,
0.2072077989578247,
-1.0255403518676758,
-0.2255413979291916,
0.8189169764518738,
0.09444265067577362,
-0.1121407300233841,
-0.036794595420360565,
-0.3744969964027405,
0.010309997946023941,
-0.09082164615392685,
0.35185226798057556,
0.7195222973823547,
-0.11703837662935257,
-0.5566580891609192,
-0.6552055478096008,
0.5658622980117798,
0.5653318762779236,
-0.8547192811965942,
-0.0970897227525711,
0.6872484683990479,
0.4147105813026428,
0.19914308190345764,
1.1799565553665161,
-0.2618425786495209,
0.3149097263813019,
-0.1727835237979889,
-0.1862543821334839,
-0.208753302693367,
-0.5120164155960083,
-0.3774561882019043,
0.30264028906822205,
0.2849881947040558,
-0.003619719296693802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08318v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08318v3 | Values That Are Explicitly Present in Fairy Tales: Comparing Samples from German, Italian and Portuguese Traditions | 2024-02-13T09:26:19 | 2024-05-06T07:19:08 | Alba Morollon Diaz-Faes, Carla Sofia Ribeiro Murteira, Martin Ruskov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, J.5; K.4.m | Looking at how social values are represented in fairy tales can give insights
about the variations in communication of values across cultures. We study how
values are communicated in fairy tales from Portugal, Italy and Germany using a
technique called word embedding with a compass to quantify vocabulary
differences and commonalities. We study how these three national traditions
differ in their explicit references to values. To do this, we specify a list of
value-charged tokens, consider their word stems and analyse the distance
between these in a bespoke pre-trained Word2Vec model. We triangulate and
critically discuss the validity of the resulting hypotheses emerging from this
quantitative model. Our claim is that this is a reusable and reproducible
method for the study of the values explicitly referenced in historical corpora.
Finally, our preliminary findings hint at a shared cultural understanding and
the expression of values such as Benevolence, Conformity, and Universalism
across the studied cultures, suggesting the potential existence of a
pan-European cultural memory. | [
-0.18999403715133667,
-0.3799407184123993,
0.21375727653503418,
0.1694122850894928,
-0.48491862416267395,
0.07125731557607651,
-0.07115386426448822,
-1.0403591394424438,
0.7706025242805481,
0.07565945386886597,
-0.2845059335231781,
-0.26815515756607056,
-0.6632944941520691,
0.13268712162971497,
-0.07577218860387802,
0.6641956567764282,
-0.16250763833522797,
0.292599618434906,
-0.2562727928161621,
-0.5278477668762207,
-0.21261043846607208,
-0.789922833442688,
0.03485141694545746,
-0.18706734478473663,
0.36738380789756775,
0.37254971265792847,
0.6829002499580383,
0.4289516806602478,
0.18185870349407196,
0.12230361998081207,
-0.3728300929069519,
0.4010423719882965,
-0.6596104502677917,
0.0979391410946846,
-0.4866347014904022,
-0.5317248106002808,
-0.2014450579881668,
0.3690391778945923,
0.3217432200908661,
0.5210689306259155,
0.19682422280311584,
0.12869149446487427,
0.2506611943244934,
0.48431017994880676,
-0.4748440384864807,
0.5253743529319763,
-0.604218065738678,
0.16262070834636688,
0.09444806724786758,
-0.30204179883003235,
-0.04868634417653084,
-0.8021396994590759,
0.317476749420166,
-0.5712347030639648,
0.23991338908672333,
-0.2071683257818222,
1.5249255895614624,
-0.28077539801597595,
-0.5346106290817261,
-0.8365950584411621,
-0.3184719979763031,
1.0560269355773926,
0.022704219445586205,
0.0719061940908432,
0.3749406933784485,
0.03178240731358528,
0.25568002462387085,
-0.3979834318161011,
-0.20507168769836426,
-0.10923540592193604,
-0.23063847422599792,
0.2578667104244232,
-0.47065451741218567,
-0.5578503012657166,
-0.09390242397785187,
0.26742157340049744,
0.012506360188126564,
-0.04773879796266556,
-0.66013103723526,
-0.06463158130645752,
0.5863839387893677,
0.11456459760665894,
0.172872856259346,
-0.12809963524341583,
-0.15438058972358704,
-0.28517279028892517,
-1.1911983489990234,
0.4480103850364685,
0.6050724387168884,
0.3276309370994568,
0.11251237988471985,
0.5098894238471985,
0.3692123591899872,
0.03986027091741562,
0.07317434996366501,
-0.13664567470550537,
0.34572920203208923,
-0.5039474964141846,
0.6576682329177856,
0.31609049439430237,
0.12567448616027832,
0.8217405676841736,
1.0251957178115845,
-0.06387992203235626,
-0.07233934849500656,
0.1381034553050995,
0.23828628659248352,
-0.8029773235321045,
0.1472567915916443,
-0.4176546335220337,
-0.5570774078369141,
-0.34456270933151245,
0.08429338037967682,
-0.6329393982887268,
-0.015902988612651825,
-0.17770420014858246,
0.2055964469909668,
-0.44462621212005615,
-0.2903388440608978,
0.12861575186252594,
-0.5406677722930908,
0.4886859953403473,
0.3012208044528961,
-1.4196363687515259,
0.19450366497039795,
0.8672400712966919,
0.7251421213150024,
-0.030827738344669342,
-0.30208903551101685,
-0.05804802477359772,
0.11321622133255005,
-0.8502674102783203,
0.8811735510826111,
-0.7259834408760071,
-0.9032164812088013,
0.21452736854553223,
0.3398181200027466,
0.3116019666194916,
-0.29456156492233276,
0.6716021299362183,
-0.33171048760414124,
0.2310979813337326,
-0.7527067065238953,
-0.5844101309776306,
-0.2126227766275406,
-0.04503422975540161,
-0.6832050085067749,
0.8606305718421936,
0.08987043052911758,
-0.8455429673194885,
0.6138206124305725,
-0.11742770671844482,
-0.4914748966693878,
-0.03627810627222061,
-0.3649025857448578,
-0.07387405633926392,
0.5684465765953064,
-0.05268401280045509,
0.3416265845298767,
-0.24901022017002106,
-0.18235698342323303,
-0.3561822772026062,
-0.4610236585140228,
0.045737750828266144,
-0.5809914469718933,
0.6591017842292786,
0.23251697421073914,
-0.28520503640174866,
-0.5313742160797119,
-0.437214732170105,
0.05824081599712372,
0.2243296355009079,
0.21186992526054382,
-0.8980284929275513,
-0.08678528666496277,
-0.002482375595718622,
0.24797916412353516,
0.4128325879573822,
-0.5082756280899048,
0.14631351828575134,
-0.20513682067394257,
0.32972392439842224,
0.4724503755569458,
0.04121163487434387,
0.31061816215515137,
-0.35408303141593933,
0.37310919165611267,
0.1262740194797516,
-0.10284654796123505,
-0.2184637188911438,
-0.5374961495399475,
-0.5506608486175537,
0.01736898347735405,
0.3017238676548004,
0.6014592051506042,
-0.2254868447780609,
0.3955221176147461,
-0.34223583340644836,
-0.516930103302002,
-0.9058196544647217,
-0.3197721242904663,
0.07898173481225967,
0.2774103283882141,
0.09377686679363251,
-0.21415232121944427,
-0.11820945888757706,
-1.0410860776901245,
-0.34503173828125,
-0.3271992802619934,
-0.43514806032180786,
0.3139879107475281,
0.7478570938110352,
0.4401240050792694,
0.9523633122444153,
-0.5311926603317261,
-0.01707206852734089,
0.1415010690689087,
0.36107996106147766,
0.16767913103103638,
0.3302185535430908,
0.7007988095283508,
-0.8381662964820862,
-0.10824134200811386,
0.057964980602264404,
-0.6074213981628418,
-0.12703679502010345,
0.11550227552652359,
0.05494476482272148,
0.3721482455730438,
-0.11044609546661377,
0.0921865925192833,
0.693301796913147,
0.6190065145492554,
-0.7961879372596741,
0.3940582871437073,
-0.43242162466049194,
0.7085062265396118,
-1.0690001249313354,
-0.09239155799150467,
-0.07637041807174683,
0.06413935124874115,
-0.28234514594078064,
-0.5698857307434082,
0.4205686151981354,
0.2514246106147766,
-0.5977728962898254,
0.7026012539863586,
-0.2766989469528198,
-0.19040758907794952,
-0.0675271674990654,
0.0017346383538097143,
0.5571526288986206,
-0.09901510179042816,
0.7889817953109741,
0.8168497085571289,
0.16494183242321014,
-0.3821573853492737,
0.1873151808977127,
0.2792021632194519,
-0.0651511624455452,
1.4352896213531494,
-0.5802135467529297,
-0.12501154839992523,
-0.14793749153614044,
-0.07797852158546448,
-0.6316356658935547,
0.23994037508964539,
0.008430669084191322,
-0.6286565661430359,
-0.10338927805423737,
-0.575390636920929,
-0.6831764578819275,
0.12731368839740753,
-0.2022647261619568,
0.1692511886358261,
0.7272922396659851,
-0.5989152193069458,
0.12551279366016388,
0.5801475048065186,
-0.29433897137641907,
-0.36351320147514343,
-0.695587158203125,
0.055417440831661224,
-0.7154415249824524,
-0.9699025750160217,
0.45685702562332153,
0.000025693343559396453,
-0.39807581901550293,
0.14979223906993866,
-0.11659739166498184,
-0.30152302980422974,
0.038048021495342255,
0.08905626088380814,
0.22310678660869598,
-0.1752922385931015,
0.6262896656990051,
0.39483314752578735,
-0.12161551415920258,
-0.015402587130665779,
-0.3777924180030823,
0.11486390978097916,
-0.7810429334640503,
-0.3262658715248108,
0.006025238428264856,
0.7849825024604797,
0.4037860035896301,
-0.2442072480916977,
0.8526671528816223,
0.3876674473285675,
-0.5074639916419983,
0.08438075333833694,
-0.5116905570030212,
-0.23228296637535095,
-0.3839895725250244,
-0.10851556062698364,
-0.5684643983840942,
-0.889590322971344,
0.6829262375831604,
-0.026000671088695526,
-0.008574278093874454,
0.7367672324180603,
0.15873031318187714,
-0.3128180205821991,
0.5803016424179077,
0.5811180472373962,
0.2909536063671112,
0.17639857530593872,
-0.2552618682384491,
0.037885673344135284,
-0.2101072371006012,
-0.289485365152359,
-0.7217280864715576,
-0.04522628337144852,
-0.8727973103523254,
-0.5242512822151184,
0.4525018334388733,
0.5229411125183105,
-0.14945484697818756,
0.03498084843158722,
-0.21843057870864868,
0.6529989242553711,
0.30748698115348816,
-0.4489944577217102,
0.6432499885559082,
0.10281632840633392,
-0.09218308329582214,
-0.3509654700756073,
-0.727617621421814,
-1.2064834833145142,
0.6327090859413147,
0.48074084520339966,
0.6114451289176941,
-0.038656000047922134,
0.6768599152565002,
-0.053355034440755844,
-0.04129320755600929,
-0.8431198596954346,
0.017526037991046906,
-0.2315080463886261,
-0.5804662108421326,
-0.1648247390985489,
-0.005301996599882841,
-1.3042287826538086,
0.2570154666900635,
-0.15199923515319824,
-0.934708297252655,
0.46239814162254333,
-0.14792566001415253,
-0.3689853847026825,
0.4083656668663025,
-0.46387413144111633,
0.8039968013763428,
-0.3195076584815979,
-0.5321618318557739,
-0.3680467903614044,
-0.39994513988494873,
0.03060193359851837,
0.16707809269428253,
0.16988812386989594,
-0.13570092618465424,
-0.16942749917507172,
0.8041926622390747,
0.024270515888929367,
0.8120244741439819,
0.3172900974750519,
-0.41396230459213257,
0.5996124148368835,
0.30824562907218933,
0.2577195167541504,
0.08687561005353928,
0.05755374953150749,
0.5117352604866028,
0.8405492305755615,
-0.6248701810836792,
-0.2052871286869049,
0.7880241274833679,
-0.7635074853897095,
-0.31298619508743286,
-0.759758472442627,
-0.20874053239822388,
0.11336706578731537,
-0.11102994531393051,
0.1590280830860138,
0.4173986315727234,
-0.5558435320854187,
0.2959563732147217,
0.7350463271141052,
-0.22781239449977875,
0.4936050474643707,
0.7184826731681824,
0.048505425453186035,
-0.36338967084884644,
0.3784532845020294,
0.5439801812171936,
0.3534444570541382,
0.04754865914583206,
0.20647327601909637,
-0.44127950072288513,
0.08832905441522598,
-0.4458456337451935,
0.2323485165834427,
-0.7310107350349426,
0.11788608133792877,
-0.25265467166900635,
-0.01851702481508255,
-0.25742271542549133,
-0.6884422898292542,
-0.7556539177894592,
-0.34889304637908936,
-0.42732641100883484,
-0.4221802055835724,
1.0005892515182495,
0.8887720108032227,
-0.513766884803772,
-0.17824970185756683,
-1.0892904996871948,
-0.08466551452875137,
0.22939708828926086,
0.37584373354911804,
-0.2119189202785492,
-0.19940532743930817,
-0.04694908484816551,
0.23608478903770447,
-0.007752119097858667,
-1.163618564605713,
0.5464699864387512,
-0.2755648195743561,
0.5028877258300781,
0.5702032446861267,
-0.0026848239358514547,
0.6448261141777039,
-0.5423949360847473,
0.9846411347389221,
0.24311059713363647,
-0.9945468902587891,
0.33083072304725647,
-0.15158867835998535,
-0.03452162444591522,
0.526909589767456,
0.6092097163200378,
-1.077772617340088,
0.08787897229194641,
-1.0888621807098389,
-0.7539495825767517,
0.22419467568397522,
0.17771901190280914,
0.43347540497779846,
-0.3548525869846344,
0.19826626777648926,
0.41167908906936646,
0.16250565648078918,
-0.3249300420284271,
-0.19980838894844055,
-0.47119036316871643,
0.13844671845436096,
-0.07154975831508636,
-0.10517054796218872,
-0.2504188120365143,
-0.2586972713470459,
0.1251664161682129,
-0.03955504298210144,
0.21717865765094757,
0.1792052686214447,
-0.10950478166341782,
-0.21205365657806396,
0.39181002974510193,
0.2987615466117859,
1.055299162864685,
-0.009799261577427387,
0.2577939033508301,
0.6627537608146667,
-0.4125787615776062,
0.18335217237472534,
-0.0860750749707222,
0.06413035094738007,
0.3225037455558777,
0.35746338963508606,
0.6611548066139221,
0.41224485635757446,
-0.2683769762516022,
0.47576799988746643,
-0.07795484364032745,
-0.07864411175251007,
-0.7200565934181213,
-0.23033910989761353,
0.44547051191329956,
0.09910925477743149,
0.35567814111709595,
-0.3672153949737549,
-0.2298315465450287,
-0.9718729257583618,
0.1452452689409256,
0.22097304463386536,
-0.6477839350700378,
-0.5134610533714294,
0.15468843281269073,
0.3409467339515686,
-0.21589705348014832,
0.4107666313648224,
-0.4097076654434204,
-0.544468879699707,
0.6638484001159668,
0.36086007952690125,
0.517336368560791,
-0.15674670040607452,
0.4901769459247589,
0.2812299132347107,
0.23698654770851135,
-0.04262344911694527,
0.3685569167137146,
0.1995626986026764,
-0.8070939183235168,
-0.10524965822696686,
-0.5688477158546448,
-0.2417670339345932,
-0.26758185029029846,
-0.6701720952987671,
0.2656747102737427,
0.3362281322479248,
0.2212311029434204,
-0.34265002608299255,
0.34009024500846863,
-0.8375215530395508,
0.012822225689888,
0.1981508433818817,
0.8348995447158813,
-1.2740141153335571,
0.7926064729690552,
0.10236529260873795,
-0.5217178463935852,
-0.7213520407676697,
-0.10226824134588242,
-0.028153376653790474,
-0.5941604971885681,
0.7983149290084839,
0.09550072997808456,
-0.44305315613746643,
-0.25542399287223816,
-0.19025678932666779,
-0.908845067024231,
1.1832642555236816,
-0.12228047102689743,
-0.2681256830692291,
0.07356828451156616,
0.32127463817596436,
0.8674304485321045,
-0.738308846950531,
0.5156044960021973,
0.741269052028656,
0.5998397469520569,
0.6048785448074341,
-0.9415948987007141,
-0.4472174644470215,
-0.22406183183193207,
0.009668968617916107,
-0.15548084676265717,
-0.5825672745704651,
0.4648573696613312,
-0.10638228803873062,
-0.32515403628349304,
-0.056084174662828445,
0.6809947490692139,
0.40557166934013367,
0.3738899827003479,
0.2573113739490509,
0.20934239029884338,
1.0248898267745972,
-0.1278214007616043,
0.7562717199325562,
-0.4582579433917999,
0.2182401567697525,
0.5547808408737183,
-0.24247069656848907,
0.6833701133728027,
0.5257240533828735,
-0.1476821005344391,
0.36415454745292664,
0.8919665813446045,
-0.1513248234987259,
0.38434848189353943,
0.4845705032348633,
-0.1682717353105545,
-0.04776013270020485,
-0.5131151080131531,
-0.6830187439918518,
0.5513347387313843,
0.4759909510612488,
-0.38129955530166626,
-0.2352301925420761,
-0.20492887496948242,
0.7417429685592651,
-0.00418872432783246,
-0.6456030011177063,
0.6592833399772644,
0.3248794972896576,
-0.7288355827331543,
0.6171960234642029,
-0.2980462312698364,
0.6411619782447815,
-0.784529447555542,
-0.18888473510742188,
-0.3013935089111328,
-0.04182270169258118,
0.0827871710062027,
-1.0279881954193115,
0.38701778650283813,
0.3010885715484619,
0.045395415276288986,
-0.5936015248298645,
0.4300924241542816,
-0.5397047400474548,
-0.6445583701133728,
0.3861328661441803,
0.6863605976104736,
0.3634527921676636,
0.24300730228424072,
-0.3303805887699127,
-0.2987822890281677,
-0.3150520920753479,
-0.06467919796705246,
0.27618131041526794,
0.8947409987449646,
-0.2506732940673828,
0.2664021849632263,
0.2201601266860962,
0.2692722976207733,
-0.1959250271320343,
-0.045568861067295074,
0.509495198726654,
-0.6496844291687012,
-0.6924104690551758,
-0.7143001556396484,
0.5691715478897095,
-0.2634008228778839,
-0.5951873660087585,
0.734074592590332,
0.3861493766307831,
0.947022557258606,
-0.08246660232543945,
0.5400551557540894,
0.2043921798467636,
0.2982963025569916,
-0.43331676721572876,
0.9839661121368408,
-0.3830246031284332,
0.0766775831580162,
-0.22155696153640747,
-0.6221826672554016,
0.31462880969047546,
0.8801844120025635,
-0.3806942105293274,
-0.19763121008872986,
0.871261715888977,
0.4417321979999542,
0.16545839607715607,
0.3613622486591339,
0.33196353912353516,
-0.11418444663286209,
0.022843316197395325,
0.31524866819381714,
1.1897822618484497,
-0.07127106934785843,
0.28415828943252563,
-0.13637511432170868,
-0.11541765183210373,
-0.024822840467095375,
-1.0588544607162476,
-0.5250828266143799,
-0.9151138663291931,
-0.23973526060581207,
-0.5912059545516968,
0.45181360840797424,
1.1556310653686523,
0.34129488468170166,
-0.7267674803733826,
-0.3253414034843445,
0.4049265384674072,
0.1132744550704956,
-0.19012589752674103,
-0.135601207613945,
0.614329993724823,
-0.07164301723241806,
-0.9097459316253662,
0.1276361048221588,
0.15250158309936523,
0.4625220000743866,
-0.2895274758338928,
-0.014188257977366447,
0.25994810461997986,
0.5681755542755127,
0.4551814794540405,
-0.03767529875040054,
-0.59343421459198,
-0.9284693598747253,
-0.06065644323825836,
-0.00823619682341814,
0.2935512661933899,
0.6864408850669861,
-0.5981602668762207,
0.242549329996109,
0.5497982501983643,
0.004158650990575552,
0.4639321267604828,
-0.117246612906456,
0.5338358879089355,
-0.3922305703163147,
0.06530393660068512,
0.5969627499580383,
0.425447940826416,
0.10383769124746323,
-0.24782907962799072,
0.4055362343788147,
0.2947066128253937,
-0.161410391330719,
-0.29410356283187866,
0.33976733684539795,
-0.5836691856384277,
-0.47119075059890747,
1.1300626993179321,
-0.5796477198600769,
-0.2155555933713913,
-0.0008440667879767716,
-0.06648086756467819,
0.11485017091035843,
-0.31873834133148193,
0.875606894493103,
1.082201600074768,
0.20655642449855804,
0.09738919883966446,
-0.6053650379180908,
0.5983710289001465,
0.055528633296489716,
-0.6826982498168945,
-0.03782684728503227,
0.563830554485321,
0.5154794454574585,
0.19360341131687164,
0.010556948371231556,
-0.5498963594436646,
0.13108883798122406,
0.2596038281917572,
0.053574368357658386,
0.12053258717060089,
-0.28183043003082275,
-0.36856940388679504,
0.27645716071128845,
-0.24768111109733582,
-0.027706369757652283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08309v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08309v2 | Prompted Contextual Vectors for Spear-Phishing Detection | 2024-02-13T09:12:55 | 2024-02-14T08:10:38 | Daniel Nahmias, Gal Engelberg, Dan Klein, Asaf Shabtai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, I.2.7 | Spear-phishing attacks present a significant security challenge, with large
language models (LLMs) escalating the threat by generating convincing emails
and facilitating target reconnaissance. To address this, we propose a detection
approach based on a novel document vectorization method that utilizes an
ensemble of LLMs to create representation vectors. By prompting LLMs to reason
and respond to human-crafted questions, we quantify the presence of common
persuasion principles in the email's content, producing prompted contextual
document vectors for a downstream supervised machine learning model. We
evaluate our method using a unique dataset generated by a proprietary system
that automates target reconnaissance and spear-phishing email creation. Our
method achieves a 91% F1 score in identifying LLM-generated spear-phishing
emails, with the training set comprising only traditional phishing and benign
emails. Key contributions include an innovative document vectorization method
utilizing LLM reasoning, a publicly available dataset of high-quality
spear-phishing emails, and the demonstrated effectiveness of our method in
detecting such emails. This methodology can be utilized for various document
classification tasks, particularly in adversarial problem domains. | [
-0.32729291915893555,
-0.9502193927764893,
0.19305092096328735,
0.043449386954307556,
-0.33583053946495056,
-0.17623403668403625,
-0.05506640672683716,
0.0383046455681324,
0.15985548496246338,
0.46443259716033936,
-0.5554267168045044,
-0.7057715654373169,
-0.6680975556373596,
0.29638710618019104,
-0.6075145602226257,
0.8143467307090759,
0.0747346356511116,
0.09866831451654434,
-0.18966828286647797,
0.15280118584632874,
-0.49526557326316833,
-0.3422721326351166,
-0.5961796641349792,
-0.22354207932949066,
0.5750346779823303,
0.5599652528762817,
-0.040340133011341095,
0.5466487407684326,
0.45403000712394714,
0.27936747670173645,
0.23570945858955383,
-0.11996888369321823,
-0.5981926321983337,
0.41443514823913574,
-0.07894040644168854,
-0.5219624042510986,
-0.31893157958984375,
0.24289314448833466,
0.28690361976623535,
0.13502858579158783,
0.07267582416534424,
0.14424045383930206,
0.23407582938671112,
0.36773616075515747,
-0.6882702112197876,
-0.06347687542438507,
-0.7225472927093506,
-0.16667404770851135,
-0.526236355304718,
-0.9214882254600525,
-0.9096046090126038,
0.06795554608106613,
0.2049342691898346,
-0.6602807641029358,
0.3527032136917114,
0.14170235395431519,
0.2535194158554077,
-0.2977946102619171,
-0.5589763522148132,
-0.5979393124580383,
-0.3499418795108795,
0.580641508102417,
-0.06812448799610138,
0.3419789969921112,
0.4093596637248993,
0.36114951968193054,
-0.3621515929698944,
-0.6579946875572205,
-0.2440793365240097,
-0.20000715553760529,
-0.1600250005722046,
0.07631644606590271,
-0.5001786351203918,
-0.06685912609100342,
0.2046327441930771,
-0.02023416943848133,
-0.9274334907531738,
0.12608325481414795,
-0.25954750180244446,
-0.21825817227363586,
0.5579143166542053,
-0.05472547188401222,
0.3162485659122467,
-0.21309205889701843,
-0.4175836741924286,
-0.2976476550102234,
-0.7062917947769165,
0.2485170215368271,
0.33133044838905334,
0.1977379471063614,
-0.1086183488368988,
0.44006556272506714,
0.00034486345248296857,
0.607795000076294,
0.44313421845436096,
-0.20918484032154083,
-0.12735730409622192,
0.32231593132019043,
-0.35858431458473206,
0.21511033177375793,
0.559146523475647,
0.22945939004421234,
0.1235431432723999,
0.05947407707571983,
-0.3212276101112366,
0.26969805359840393,
0.5392785668373108,
-0.7379950284957886,
-0.27433422207832336,
0.453355610370636,
-0.5006923675537109,
-0.5747029185295105,
0.0856233686208725,
-0.5966280102729797,
-0.6765247583389282,
-0.17153075337409973,
0.09419801086187363,
-0.5757462978363037,
-0.21526837348937988,
-0.10300860553979874,
-0.5674156546592712,
0.5416513681411743,
0.4155762493610382,
-0.73853600025177,
-0.0513141006231308,
1.0657575130462646,
0.32264816761016846,
-0.3278796672821045,
-0.2551691234111786,
-1.1731610298156738,
0.3465808629989624,
-0.2976827919483185,
0.915972113609314,
-0.7168089747428894,
-0.3824082016944885,
0.41557827591896057,
-0.14723163843154907,
0.16750764846801758,
-0.3798016309738159,
0.9543684720993042,
-0.7240810394287109,
0.34838902950286865,
-0.2208220660686493,
-0.6561169624328613,
-0.07789657264947891,
0.7794914245605469,
-0.4220224916934967,
0.7700883746147156,
0.09431000053882599,
-0.9123424291610718,
0.47680866718292236,
-0.23698358237743378,
-0.5937633514404297,
0.6386181712150574,
-0.3177083134651184,
-0.22363945841789246,
0.010191849432885647,
0.3113510310649872,
0.9087586402893066,
-0.41300055384635925,
0.09211340546607971,
-0.4597408175468445,
-0.1194181740283966,
0.3488549590110779,
-0.4119545817375183,
0.6276435256004333,
-0.022580895572900772,
-0.27358171343803406,
0.16572535037994385,
-0.6004952192306519,
-0.38319674134254456,
0.31790217757225037,
-0.19792459905147552,
-0.5920147895812988,
-0.4039565622806549,
0.019890541210770607,
-0.11410614848136902,
0.10428310930728912,
-0.28695961833000183,
0.24775934219360352,
-0.25493380427360535,
0.03134249523282051,
0.8433974385261536,
0.23957893252372742,
0.6256965398788452,
-0.39373132586479187,
0.5733934044837952,
0.0634511411190033,
0.04232961684465408,
-0.46457359194755554,
-0.5786651372909546,
-0.7209183573722839,
-0.44793060421943665,
-0.3515491783618927,
0.6955654621124268,
-0.7186156511306763,
0.34924060106277466,
-0.44248536229133606,
-0.4036913216114044,
0.05126499757170677,
0.12265512347221375,
0.12290938943624496,
0.8345960974693298,
0.30951836705207825,
0.3270595967769623,
-0.37311848998069763,
-0.7632231116294861,
-0.41700467467308044,
-0.3281903862953186,
-0.45786499977111816,
0.058174923062324524,
0.615946888923645,
0.052577633410692215,
0.7411990761756897,
-0.4370478093624115,
-0.3295016884803772,
-0.20038114488124847,
0.6050983667373657,
0.0512855164706707,
0.38478028774261475,
0.6092655658721924,
-0.984682559967041,
-0.41377609968185425,
-0.25773102045059204,
-0.8618249297142029,
-0.11134108155965805,
-0.14488601684570312,
0.0446377731859684,
-0.12388616800308228,
0.5981253981590271,
-0.4799664318561554,
0.26606422662734985,
-0.0376165509223938,
-0.30333882570266724,
0.14000853896141052,
-0.044900938868522644,
0.4371550381183624,
-1.069521188735962,
-0.06934794038534164,
0.38781094551086426,
0.011245430447161198,
-1.044899344444275,
-0.010197972878813744,
0.401752769947052,
-0.23952898383140564,
-0.3546944260597229,
0.5325709581375122,
-0.36992937326431274,
0.16069629788398743,
-0.3026960790157318,
0.2017802596092224,
0.04638604447245598,
0.39070138335227966,
0.12458232790231705,
0.38234245777130127,
0.758254885673523,
-0.5891662836074829,
0.683631181716919,
0.28573957085609436,
-0.008767719380557537,
1.6335119009017944,
-0.60136878490448,
0.09483098983764648,
-0.22396497428417206,
0.6417397856712341,
-1.1056276559829712,
-0.6429822444915771,
0.7690291404724121,
-0.8245735168457031,
0.3902594745159149,
-0.39775538444519043,
0.0833057090640068,
-0.2424211949110031,
-0.6587725281715393,
0.27166491746902466,
0.422780305147171,
-0.569453239440918,
1.0292985439300537,
0.13862313330173492,
-0.13082188367843628,
-0.5224234461784363,
-0.5210678577423096,
0.15239869058132172,
-0.5692440867424011,
-1.002561092376709,
0.41135236620903015,
0.2342715561389923,
-0.20670579373836517,
-0.47055765986442566,
0.03540124371647835,
0.130165696144104,
0.19017839431762695,
0.23099268972873688,
0.23735842108726501,
-0.07579469680786133,
0.11415719240903854,
-0.10924595594406128,
-0.1599816381931305,
0.43722546100616455,
-0.4742682874202728,
0.45471489429473877,
0.2405044585466385,
-0.5733053684234619,
-0.44825220108032227,
0.518744945526123,
0.3199425935745239,
-0.35313013195991516,
0.5124688148498535,
0.7098817229270935,
-0.5076130032539368,
-0.36154186725616455,
-0.6102456450462341,
-0.6729923486709595,
-0.497096449136734,
-0.11691027134656906,
-0.2579996585845947,
-0.7255739569664001,
0.38005775213241577,
-0.10650338232517242,
0.08914250880479813,
0.29693281650543213,
0.33279478549957275,
-0.22848303616046906,
0.7658060789108276,
0.19047948718070984,
-0.1982399821281433,
0.2509687542915344,
-0.23665925860404968,
-0.022576361894607544,
-0.5454066395759583,
-0.37590521574020386,
-0.4809800088405609,
-0.027281379327178,
-0.4302672743797302,
-0.2196069359779358,
0.41091784834861755,
0.0431213304400444,
-0.052165765315294266,
0.3091587424278259,
-0.4241015315055847,
0.07657355815172195,
0.5728563070297241,
-0.07982359826564789,
-0.11364003270864487,
0.14380566775798798,
-0.22370421886444092,
0.3243037462234497,
-0.5274046063423157,
-0.5661406517028809,
1.3348097801208496,
0.14472907781600952,
0.44624194502830505,
0.16242381930351257,
0.8298689723014832,
0.7575215101242065,
0.5693129897117615,
-0.6287261843681335,
0.6763107776641846,
0.31864017248153687,
-0.13748179376125336,
-0.14858755469322205,
-0.08407962322235107,
-1.4220294952392578,
0.11917910724878311,
-0.4521503150463104,
-0.7570640444755554,
-0.11688104271888733,
0.06491312384605408,
-0.10376176238059998,
-0.03952467814087868,
-0.26643046736717224,
0.710111141204834,
0.18330562114715576,
-0.2822209894657135,
-0.13572004437446594,
-0.33059173822402954,
0.3290242850780487,
-0.20214487612247467,
0.19829723238945007,
0.06374316662549973,
0.07612449675798416,
0.7177079319953918,
-0.098163902759552,
0.7322253584861755,
-0.10956187546253204,
-0.37218379974365234,
0.13008108735084534,
0.12837572395801544,
1.0289474725723267,
0.3469591438770294,
0.1316394805908203,
-0.31016722321510315,
-0.6180397272109985,
-0.40953585505485535,
-0.6944030523300171,
0.6673086285591125,
-0.19756989181041718,
-0.8136472702026367,
-0.5043042898178101,
-0.3147842288017273,
-0.02725137770175934,
0.12760451436042786,
0.3920912742614746,
0.37845930457115173,
-0.4495623707771301,
0.29701218008995056,
0.8723925948143005,
0.034391239285469055,
0.3325582444667816,
0.6197144389152527,
0.13354268670082092,
-0.47509366273880005,
0.7948132753372192,
-0.1904616355895996,
-0.36820828914642334,
0.5213717818260193,
0.20938092470169067,
-0.30871525406837463,
-0.6860414743423462,
-0.3828601539134979,
0.04705130681395531,
-0.8851485252380371,
-0.22274458408355713,
-0.5046290159225464,
0.12016443908214569,
-0.9461763501167297,
-0.5812389254570007,
0.3402694761753082,
0.22278711199760437,
-0.47726982831954956,
0.04632935672998428,
0.2946139872074127,
0.48607873916625977,
0.2862471342086792,
0.36327216029167175,
-0.7919076085090637,
0.39643627405166626,
0.4470060467720032,
-0.3118551969528198,
-0.3360956609249115,
-0.6840275526046753,
0.3093756437301636,
-0.012667391449213028,
-0.12523771822452545,
-1.126266598701477,
0.22542625665664673,
-0.14564432203769684,
0.7162986993789673,
0.6682353615760803,
0.4852063059806824,
-0.005416214000433683,
-0.18240715563297272,
0.7081328630447388,
0.07815425843000412,
-0.6747831106185913,
0.8133320808410645,
-0.688138484954834,
0.060381099581718445,
0.01922803372144699,
0.7612753510475159,
-0.658181369304657,
-0.4373703896999359,
-0.6227877140045166,
-0.48291832208633423,
0.49154356122016907,
0.28583595156669617,
0.08037257939577103,
-0.11881520599126816,
0.25408461689949036,
-0.0637701079249382,
-0.09504525363445282,
-0.4717860221862793,
-0.2125716656446457,
0.10309585183858871,
-0.08194940537214279,
-0.027649570256471634,
-0.32235652208328247,
-0.47885626554489136,
0.14197967946529388,
0.7110015749931335,
-0.16489002108573914,
0.09795299917459488,
-0.13107164204120636,
-0.39004483819007874,
0.020352395251393318,
0.31636789441108704,
0.7311824560165405,
0.5020532011985779,
0.09079253673553467,
0.11765245348215103,
0.1948193460702896,
-0.4486679136753082,
0.39862677454948425,
0.18426644802093506,
-0.264512836933136,
-0.06144341453909874,
0.7253007888793945,
0.3967067003250122,
0.030494723469018936,
-0.2694436013698578,
0.9171146154403687,
-0.08039794862270355,
-0.270656555891037,
-0.5960821509361267,
0.008998625911772251,
0.005177912302315235,
0.21206212043762207,
0.8231427073478699,
-0.15212586522102356,
0.07941800355911255,
-0.06130589544773102,
0.4175646901130676,
0.7523154020309448,
-0.04718981310725212,
-0.039257559925317764,
0.3159675896167755,
0.5029020309448242,
-0.424390584230423,
0.5261709690093994,
-0.04074060916900635,
-0.5010675191879272,
0.34863194823265076,
0.3804975748062134,
0.8551557064056396,
-0.6534199714660645,
0.34794703125953674,
0.1347706913948059,
0.34587475657463074,
-0.03543166071176529,
-0.0025153248570859432,
-0.18483276665210724,
-0.5503755211830139,
0.1269158124923706,
-0.1902005821466446,
-0.32181912660598755,
0.4315459430217743,
-0.719232976436615,
0.6841729283332825,
-0.29806703329086304,
0.06761129945516586,
0.3047700822353363,
-0.4625118672847748,
-0.3838946521282196,
0.04821077734231949,
0.2589203417301178,
0.9574735760688782,
-0.9679170846939087,
0.5998523235321045,
0.4369257688522339,
-0.04055630788207054,
-0.3182702362537384,
0.14304737746715546,
0.5455780625343323,
-0.7293046116828918,
0.7965651154518127,
0.49330833554267883,
-0.15801262855529785,
-0.1975710242986679,
-0.46898534893989563,
-0.2500145137310028,
1.114243507385254,
0.48682883381843567,
-0.11751972883939743,
0.2998822331428528,
0.4532926082611084,
0.15783675014972687,
-0.5045269727706909,
0.07961578667163849,
0.3096778690814972,
0.39506828784942627,
0.26842251420021057,
-0.08998063951730728,
0.06820525974035263,
-0.33859992027282715,
-0.15168313682079315,
0.14644616842269897,
-0.12998509407043457,
0.7738761305809021,
0.5748453140258789,
-0.26057395339012146,
-0.44432273507118225,
1.069154977798462,
0.4783923029899597,
0.48545196652412415,
0.45673489570617676,
0.3885137438774109,
0.9594086408615112,
-0.060778357088565826,
0.7553041577339172,
-0.37673476338386536,
-0.06759767979383469,
0.6674144864082336,
-0.39036524295806885,
0.731909453868866,
0.4317682385444641,
0.23998288810253143,
0.26527008414268494,
0.5999149680137634,
-0.12552647292613983,
0.11400936543941498,
0.4795078635215759,
-0.6182880401611328,
-0.341124027967453,
-0.04566332325339317,
-0.24741022288799286,
0.6244019269943237,
0.43831413984298706,
-0.4867832660675049,
-0.2539067268371582,
0.4324791729450226,
-0.0593024305999279,
0.13434293866157532,
-0.4775918126106262,
0.5444493293762207,
-0.15206614136695862,
-0.9239567518234253,
0.7026645541191101,
0.23264633119106293,
0.7750958800315857,
-0.6083849668502808,
0.15677015483379364,
-0.192702978849411,
0.1414218544960022,
0.02216382324695587,
-0.5402094125747681,
-0.0046718185767531395,
0.2264517843723297,
0.24976979196071625,
-0.5661237835884094,
1.24681556224823,
-0.2881013751029968,
-0.19216877222061157,
-0.011591838672757149,
0.23252038657665253,
0.05848575755953789,
-0.290088951587677,
-0.5655940771102905,
-0.05157288908958435,
-0.33281129598617554,
-0.4796716272830963,
0.38742566108703613,
0.490325003862381,
-0.07449279725551605,
0.8504608273506165,
0.7538216710090637,
-0.4085225462913513,
-0.3606339395046234,
-0.07869066298007965,
0.8330984115600586,
-0.09462843835353851,
-0.643575131893158,
-1.1299762725830078,
0.3149588108062744,
-0.5458252429962158,
-0.11395280808210373,
1.0251754522323608,
0.6987715363502502,
0.8572431206703186,
-0.06076858937740326,
0.7012882828712463,
0.40168046951293945,
0.3231737017631531,
-0.42995983362197876,
0.46965891122817993,
-0.2381976991891861,
0.29888367652893066,
-0.2058647722005844,
-0.7288635969161987,
-0.18650604784488678,
0.34041354060173035,
-0.3822319209575653,
-0.0971309244632721,
0.38473451137542725,
0.749366283416748,
-0.2504481375217438,
0.23032636940479279,
0.2389354109764099,
-0.32972827553749084,
0.509138286113739,
0.2922087609767914,
0.7868641018867493,
-0.33510467410087585,
0.680691659450531,
0.04890471696853638,
-0.3248841464519501,
-0.5956249237060547,
-1.1087894439697266,
-1.2508487701416016,
-0.7646089196205139,
-0.40025579929351807,
-0.457743763923645,
-0.1159989982843399,
0.8842049837112427,
0.4574345052242279,
-0.7291924953460693,
-0.15651236474514008,
-0.13920807838439941,
-0.12492288649082184,
0.024043409153819084,
-0.1972426474094391,
0.20137664675712585,
-0.29243364930152893,
-0.3970729112625122,
0.5693991780281067,
0.4814116656780243,
0.3410409390926361,
-0.41867145895957947,
-0.16234375536441803,
-0.22788485884666443,
0.3267250955104828,
0.44295066595077515,
0.23930388689041138,
-0.6382681131362915,
-0.10751492530107498,
0.2747267782688141,
-0.40623414516448975,
-0.12477926909923553,
0.9965727925300598,
-0.6242690086364746,
-0.07991335541009903,
0.7260450720787048,
0.7461727857589722,
0.3644973933696747,
-0.12881161272525787,
0.6338432431221008,
-0.898556113243103,
0.07090673595666885,
0.31114423274993896,
0.370148628950119,
0.3267294466495514,
-0.5645955801010132,
0.2356436848640442,
0.30594369769096375,
-0.1435394287109375,
-0.5771454572677612,
0.33608683943748474,
-0.9477739930152893,
-0.3048655092716217,
1.1457552909851074,
-0.5487504005432129,
-0.36689138412475586,
-0.2776412069797516,
-0.20083792507648468,
0.09692858159542084,
-0.4369538128376007,
0.47662004828453064,
0.5804738402366638,
0.12964481115341187,
-0.2584485113620758,
0.00018224725499749184,
0.6847622394561768,
0.30894115567207336,
-0.9304313659667969,
0.24060602486133575,
0.47412869334220886,
0.07613089680671692,
0.05657851696014404,
0.5645803213119507,
0.47471103072166443,
0.520675778388977,
-0.1485213041305542,
-0.4044705927371979,
-0.0883110761642456,
-0.20049366354942322,
-0.3254987895488739,
0.5548032522201538,
-0.4300965368747711,
-0.050003983080387115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08303v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08303v4 | ChatCell: Facilitating Single-Cell Analysis with Natural Language | 2024-02-13T09:06:14 | 2024-02-20T02:26:39 | Yin Fang, Kangwei Liu, Ningyu Zhang, Xinle Deng, Penghui Yang, Zhuo Chen, Xiangru Tang, Mark Gerstein, Xiaohui Fan, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.HC, cs.LG | As Large Language Models (LLMs) rapidly evolve, their influence in science is
becoming increasingly prominent. The emerging capabilities of LLMs in task
generalization and free-form dialogue can significantly advance fields like
chemistry and biology. However, the field of single-cell biology, which forms
the foundational building blocks of living organisms, still faces several
challenges. High knowledge barriers and limited scalability in current methods
restrict the full exploitation of LLMs in mastering single-cell data, impeding
direct accessibility and rapid iteration. To this end, we introduce ChatCell,
which signifies a paradigm shift by facilitating single-cell analysis with
natural language. Leveraging vocabulary adaptation and unified sequence
generation, ChatCell has acquired profound expertise in single-cell biology and
the capability to accommodate a diverse range of analysis tasks. Extensive
experiments further demonstrate ChatCell's robust performance and potential to
deepen single-cell insights, paving the way for more accessible and intuitive
exploration in this pivotal field. Our project homepage is available at
https://zjunlp.github.io/project/ChatCell. | [
-0.19522249698638916,
-0.9147186875343323,
0.18291592597961426,
0.5676233768463135,
-0.24460476636886597,
0.43115100264549255,
-0.34288880228996277,
-0.3685580790042877,
0.09574764221906662,
0.7956053018569946,
-0.7211165428161621,
-0.9075093865394592,
-0.19328080117702484,
0.2832129895687103,
-0.5646774172782898,
1.1586483716964722,
0.47478803992271423,
0.13017715513706207,
-0.675242006778717,
-0.2742389142513275,
-0.04649065062403679,
-0.346649706363678,
-0.6856456995010376,
-0.14599555730819702,
0.6721354722976685,
0.7126560807228088,
0.5507821440696716,
0.3446636199951172,
0.429779052734375,
0.3123105466365814,
-0.2013896256685257,
0.2796900272369385,
-0.6120278835296631,
0.20892411470413208,
0.04916391521692276,
-0.27495941519737244,
-0.6800951361656189,
-0.20454667508602142,
0.7144801616668701,
1.1735745668411255,
-0.0668158158659935,
0.10019610077142715,
0.24137738347053528,
0.9053022265434265,
-0.1389373391866684,
0.19663695991039276,
-0.8318285942077637,
0.34183087944984436,
-0.24906787276268005,
-0.004031730350106955,
-0.45819181203842163,
-0.4921560287475586,
0.3918488323688507,
-0.4695993661880493,
0.1674974113702774,
-0.2574141323566437,
0.358624666929245,
0.21815258264541626,
-0.30884671211242676,
-0.2551769018173218,
-0.5349406599998474,
0.4674317240715027,
-0.8420447111129761,
0.04999246820807457,
-0.07650934159755707,
0.34632351994514465,
-0.46036064624786377,
-0.9726668000221252,
-0.2836974263191223,
-0.46286600828170776,
-0.09797179698944092,
0.23582395911216736,
-0.12047263979911804,
0.30806899070739746,
-0.1342776119709015,
0.17434756457805634,
-0.27438071370124817,
0.0069665745832026005,
-0.5099532008171082,
-0.29295259714126587,
0.5848769545555115,
0.20717893540859222,
0.6062082648277283,
-0.15488453209400177,
-0.35592368245124817,
0.33275356888771057,
-0.3104705810546875,
0.14312945306301117,
0.13613806664943695,
0.8698561191558838,
-0.22265519201755524,
0.22558237612247467,
-0.0726010799407959,
0.545491099357605,
-0.4516644775867462,
0.3674486577510834,
0.00812179408967495,
-0.42893508076667786,
-0.22686269879341125,
0.3428909480571747,
1.1258658170700073,
-0.11360334604978561,
0.1723952442407608,
-0.2080594152212143,
0.4223978519439697,
-0.19735799729824066,
0.4982287883758545,
-0.9938603639602661,
-0.13612323999404907,
0.49532195925712585,
-0.28760209679603577,
-0.4514075219631195,
-0.07148944586515427,
-1.4708164930343628,
-0.5733844041824341,
-0.055466312915086746,
0.1897226721048355,
-0.43515509366989136,
0.03559507802128792,
0.14238211512565613,
-0.11139756441116333,
0.10815298557281494,
0.3116251230239868,
-0.5257585644721985,
0.6757532954216003,
0.3725944757461548,
1.054764986038208,
-0.27915120124816895,
-0.08174805343151093,
-0.4540806710720062,
-0.11379791051149368,
-0.29494309425354004,
0.881812572479248,
-0.4244289994239807,
-0.9001638889312744,
0.08987252414226532,
-0.38952505588531494,
-0.009849182330071926,
-0.30682268738746643,
0.6940388679504395,
-0.09908130764961243,
0.006803218740969896,
-0.15393224358558655,
-0.38738349080085754,
0.2146543711423874,
-0.001424355898052454,
-0.6927177906036377,
0.738300621509552,
-0.25613585114479065,
-0.6806854605674744,
0.07926848530769348,
-1.3065943717956543,
-0.36596640944480896,
0.37836766242980957,
-0.4165608882904053,
-0.3619955778121948,
-0.08110544830560684,
0.06547655910253525,
0.2707703411579132,
-0.22260552644729614,
0.09807699918746948,
-0.35614311695098877,
0.12541796267032623,
0.42925915122032166,
-0.23148678243160248,
0.6713669896125793,
0.4332720935344696,
0.43391749262809753,
0.45481473207473755,
-0.8046767711639404,
0.3982451856136322,
-0.14367355406284332,
-0.30028536915779114,
0.11002833396196365,
0.38942670822143555,
-0.1085323840379715,
-0.17072419822216034,
0.28622967004776,
-0.8089874982833862,
0.5602352619171143,
-0.6217599511146545,
0.4756651222705841,
0.29703962802886963,
-0.04867101088166237,
0.48182156682014465,
0.05800686776638031,
0.11941476166248322,
0.11126236617565155,
0.12637966871261597,
-0.19829146564006805,
-0.6849237084388733,
-0.44417083263397217,
-0.24153739213943481,
0.15002740919589996,
0.4229416847229004,
-0.48675090074539185,
0.03665753826498985,
-0.24416688084602356,
-0.6910120844841003,
-0.7760971188545227,
0.36790311336517334,
0.15171152353286743,
0.342242032289505,
0.5839312076568604,
-0.16324801743030548,
-0.7657398581504822,
-0.9790524244308472,
-0.3044215142726898,
0.07497996091842651,
-0.08477949351072311,
0.0678781196475029,
0.2902078926563263,
-0.25488293170928955,
1.4809046983718872,
-0.43181312084198,
-0.33433932065963745,
-0.6798107028007507,
0.3649892508983612,
0.3773423731327057,
0.3645552694797516,
0.14682167768478394,
-0.9500718712806702,
-0.5081464648246765,
0.48166295886039734,
-0.6591543555259705,
-0.3381027579307556,
-0.016234789043664932,
-0.18806932866573334,
-0.09919869154691696,
0.518469512462616,
-0.42987343668937683,
0.6533526182174683,
0.3910509943962097,
-0.23372547328472137,
0.4421037435531616,
-0.5110498070716858,
-0.12848149240016937,
-0.994091808795929,
0.1454177349805832,
-0.11588713526725769,
0.008999238722026348,
-1.268869400024414,
-0.4392733573913574,
0.14236027002334595,
-0.11133728176355362,
-0.31817880272865295,
0.48035457730293274,
-0.28314778208732605,
-0.16699261963367462,
-0.41522476077079773,
-0.030518433079123497,
-0.0869203507900238,
0.19669531285762787,
-0.11363597959280014,
0.8584338426589966,
0.5059663653373718,
-0.7067078948020935,
0.051592983305454254,
0.7170958518981934,
-0.2082645744085312,
-0.2665083408355713,
-0.5822434425354004,
0.28303462266921997,
-0.23991380631923676,
0.23454639315605164,
-1.0123274326324463,
-0.28370752930641174,
0.18851353228092194,
-0.5303536057472229,
0.14975641667842865,
-0.054928719997406006,
-0.28129029273986816,
-0.34766703844070435,
-0.186941996216774,
0.18095137178897858,
0.2892862558364868,
-0.5395066142082214,
0.5537141561508179,
0.38833388686180115,
-0.41253548860549927,
-0.18532924354076385,
-0.5053054690361023,
0.4115335941314697,
0.22819800674915314,
-0.828601062297821,
0.418529212474823,
-0.3118193447589874,
-0.28059330582618713,
-0.20486286282539368,
-0.32885101437568665,
-0.5151509642601013,
0.03469241410493851,
0.36961886286735535,
0.391385942697525,
-0.3384661078453064,
0.5651161670684814,
0.0375707671046257,
-0.025919795036315918,
-0.06265516579151154,
-0.2928007245063782,
0.34416085481643677,
-0.2700243294239044,
-0.06265122443437576,
-0.27398204803466797,
0.44274231791496277,
0.934759259223938,
-0.36796367168426514,
0.5890745520591736,
0.26146650314331055,
-0.2524048686027527,
-0.3031637370586395,
-0.14482393860816956,
0.12360118329524994,
-0.47824668884277344,
0.5302830934524536,
0.04874322563409805,
-0.7158241271972656,
0.4210420250892639,
-0.2108202427625656,
0.19891642034053802,
0.15984639525413513,
0.45419785380363464,
0.08506541699171066,
0.7445535063743591,
0.80201256275177,
-0.008881743997335434,
0.1669250875711441,
0.1949821412563324,
0.2701249122619629,
-0.5375154614448547,
-0.3318433165550232,
-0.8528907895088196,
-0.05276785418391228,
-0.3427915573120117,
-0.5544020533561707,
0.3531899154186249,
-0.11604698747396469,
0.07670271396636963,
0.175574392080307,
-0.47167178988456726,
0.4977175295352936,
0.049805283546447754,
0.1552276909351349,
0.4208337068557739,
-0.25587567687034607,
-0.2393936663866043,
0.10378795117139816,
-0.7414162158966064,
-0.9262742400169373,
0.756588339805603,
0.28573140501976013,
0.7166764140129089,
-0.02648461051285267,
0.4710928499698639,
0.2039623111486435,
0.516975998878479,
-0.8444494605064392,
0.8072478771209717,
-0.4420183598995209,
-0.4892013669013977,
-0.30953672528266907,
-0.5041481256484985,
-1.2007315158843994,
0.33450761437416077,
-0.18090157210826874,
-1.1937100887298584,
-0.2270214706659317,
0.013343517668545246,
-0.611697256565094,
0.5479788184165955,
-0.8122888207435608,
1.1022474765777588,
-0.22134053707122803,
-0.43218937516212463,
0.1147676408290863,
-0.6445760130882263,
0.3123680353164673,
-0.05294240638613701,
0.45754408836364746,
-0.17622052133083344,
-0.09503834694623947,
0.7069905996322632,
-0.31890374422073364,
1.0704039335250854,
0.12218248844146729,
-0.051637303084135056,
0.40358662605285645,
0.04369664564728737,
0.04051418974995613,
0.3795774579048157,
-0.23234672844409943,
0.10390247404575348,
0.2527138888835907,
-0.6350089311599731,
-0.1969977468252182,
0.6806663870811462,
-0.6226941347122192,
-0.49466946721076965,
0.045262936502695084,
-0.7282334566116333,
-0.49787774682044983,
0.020750755444169044,
0.16808724403381348,
0.47655126452445984,
-0.525587260723114,
0.3126479983329773,
0.5952202081680298,
-0.5751186609268188,
0.5832746624946594,
0.16163478791713715,
-0.7566981315612793,
0.04062511771917343,
0.6238866448402405,
-0.11944159120321274,
0.39691540598869324,
0.3791324198246002,
0.3384988605976105,
-0.15727238357067108,
-0.7713078856468201,
-0.22844573855400085,
-0.2724156379699707,
-0.3719165623188019,
-0.17748861014842987,
-0.8744907975196838,
-0.4766387939453125,
-0.5148941278457642,
0.04050619900226593,
-0.60962975025177,
-0.10722339898347855,
-0.24310460686683655,
-0.05618388578295708,
0.30956193804740906,
0.6672878861427307,
0.050081249326467514,
0.03804532438516617,
-1.2449032068252563,
0.30181875824928284,
0.4820404052734375,
0.33808448910713196,
-0.27746474742889404,
-0.23058171570301056,
-0.09340941905975342,
0.2777668237686157,
-0.2188534438610077,
-1.1722241640090942,
0.6436363458633423,
0.47351741790771484,
0.485155314207077,
0.21259690821170807,
-0.23274676501750946,
0.6072750687599182,
-0.46586671471595764,
0.6103131771087646,
0.20769506692886353,
-0.8049027919769287,
0.488832026720047,
-0.4033772945404053,
0.631342351436615,
0.5504574775695801,
0.13975824415683746,
-0.8021066784858704,
-0.363847941160202,
-0.2606857419013977,
-0.7770697474479675,
0.5637178421020508,
0.5940885543823242,
0.27781710028648376,
0.0003123300848528743,
0.21347111463546753,
0.39264732599258423,
0.022682491689920425,
-0.4739122688770294,
-0.18472756445407867,
-0.4082476496696472,
-0.29095694422721863,
0.16262853145599365,
0.13630035519599915,
0.04057200253009796,
-0.3106113076210022,
0.31068411469459534,
-0.40908414125442505,
0.4387073814868927,
0.5837184190750122,
0.04399207606911659,
-0.014254812151193619,
0.729056179523468,
0.4254486560821533,
0.3085874021053314,
-0.29889485239982605,
-0.0696791410446167,
0.465817391872406,
-0.5576244592666626,
-0.35834309458732605,
-0.026354394853115082,
0.24837172031402588,
0.06633259356021881,
0.2886994779109955,
0.3405205011367798,
0.4583922028541565,
-0.799919068813324,
0.11729583144187927,
-0.058150094002485275,
-0.2002345323562622,
0.022167878225445747,
0.14328743517398834,
0.48355230689048767,
-0.018409686163067818,
0.7755140662193298,
0.08068647980690002,
0.0335569828748703,
-0.7803303003311157,
0.45667698979377747,
0.43255579471588135,
-0.7954730987548828,
-0.3010208010673523,
0.3238721191883087,
0.3808597922325134,
-0.4839251637458801,
0.3276374340057373,
-0.16628678143024445,
-0.4863474667072296,
1.0019724369049072,
0.580790102481842,
0.8733855485916138,
0.05003804713487625,
0.40303799510002136,
0.41998136043548584,
0.05308567360043526,
0.3173956573009491,
-0.13719257712364197,
0.1297856718301773,
-0.8811397552490234,
-0.3419327735900879,
-0.740601122379303,
-0.6284852623939514,
-0.15089133381843567,
-0.6056597232818604,
0.12743476033210754,
-0.4952045679092407,
0.19643570482730865,
0.5073273181915283,
-0.03424062952399254,
-0.4735877215862274,
-0.11427773535251617,
0.4361134469509125,
1.2683398723602295,
-0.15116220712661743,
1.1427770853042603,
0.6793118119239807,
-0.2114562690258026,
-0.295518696308136,
-0.29209432005882263,
0.41881635785102844,
-0.4409974217414856,
0.7624362707138062,
0.4439935088157654,
-0.15456220507621765,
0.010878263041377068,
-1.0033138990402222,
-0.4935307800769806,
1.0482019186019897,
-0.01356204878538847,
-0.4976974129676819,
0.14547675848007202,
0.2595391869544983,
0.8130490183830261,
-0.7072106003761292,
0.15414080023765564,
0.5910309553146362,
0.3812215328216553,
0.3300374746322632,
-0.68525230884552,
-0.2420429289340973,
-0.2705112099647522,
-0.4011315405368805,
0.5200269222259521,
-0.4388103187084198,
0.6832022070884705,
-0.4066126048564911,
-0.51634681224823,
0.4746069312095642,
0.7433788180351257,
-0.26909422874450684,
0.48385170102119446,
0.053730059415102005,
0.07444547861814499,
0.860603392124176,
-0.02950078807771206,
0.8509885668754578,
0.05645310506224632,
0.31311824917793274,
1.1495153903961182,
-0.49067455530166626,
0.7117905616760254,
0.5055614113807678,
-0.45366525650024414,
0.36713412404060364,
-0.05792327970266342,
0.12593674659729004,
0.012564517557621002,
0.4728301465511322,
-0.563052773475647,
-0.3448043465614319,
-0.14557889103889465,
-0.08529061079025269,
0.3726063072681427,
0.6865795850753784,
0.25452250242233276,
-0.6756463050842285,
-0.24024361371994019,
-0.17287850379943848,
0.33695685863494873,
-0.583755373954773,
0.6619570255279541,
0.08740270882844925,
-0.16424892842769623,
-0.20504538714885712,
-0.47459399700164795,
0.5806185007095337,
-1.0111933946609497,
-0.07859203964471817,
-0.5140669345855713,
-0.2147596776485443,
-0.2655963599681854,
-0.6769406795501709,
0.35750526189804077,
0.15212993323802948,
0.16656248271465302,
-0.11196506023406982,
1.0201354026794434,
-0.32502758502960205,
-0.44866153597831726,
0.4736134111881256,
0.7759870886802673,
-0.03802604600787163,
-0.03269112482666969,
-0.416068971157074,
-0.18480761349201202,
0.23149164021015167,
-0.05191197618842125,
0.37785986065864563,
0.4413183927536011,
0.282166451215744,
0.9734526872634888,
0.7485485076904297,
-0.10711531341075897,
0.09873682260513306,
-0.0926363542675972,
0.873923659324646,
-1.092631220817566,
0.0076286038383841515,
-0.93490070104599,
0.6566261649131775,
-0.5123913288116455,
-0.3485759198665619,
0.4272230863571167,
0.5612160563468933,
0.30045202374458313,
-0.04728969931602478,
0.8018297553062439,
-0.11054199188947678,
0.39789819717407227,
-0.4493033289909363,
0.9896836876869202,
-0.1424293965101242,
0.3744428753852844,
-0.1712438464164734,
-0.35578128695487976,
-0.6143971085548401,
0.26362666487693787,
-0.23450110852718353,
-0.4586084485054016,
0.8607975840568542,
0.7727243900299072,
0.22058506309986115,
0.561835527420044,
0.5596826672554016,
0.5849414467811584,
0.367721289396286,
0.4074207544326782,
1.0185853242874146,
-0.04898184910416603,
1.0220749378204346,
0.04457714408636093,
-0.03394404426217079,
0.1208355650305748,
-0.9419369101524353,
-0.9696162939071655,
-0.3608323931694031,
-0.3926352262496948,
0.003386537777259946,
-0.017039494588971138,
1.188973069190979,
0.4809851050376892,
-0.8980848789215088,
-0.5678621530532837,
-0.34091395139694214,
0.07766477018594742,
0.2694113552570343,
-0.19280236959457397,
-0.02833440527319908,
-0.9535198211669922,
-0.48416057229042053,
0.669921875,
0.8831467032432556,
0.07123403251171112,
0.01587487757205963,
0.10153581947088242,
-0.3578799068927765,
0.2936649024486542,
0.5514324307441711,
0.6350637078285217,
-0.38255220651626587,
-0.04934098199009895,
-0.07150065898895264,
-0.4023260772228241,
0.4267197549343109,
0.8062808513641357,
-0.7696287631988525,
0.41607850790023804,
0.25578001141548157,
0.8338632583618164,
0.20493103563785553,
-0.16124415397644043,
0.6134747266769409,
-0.6630304455757141,
-0.13887012004852295,
0.32003989815711975,
0.18998004496097565,
0.2591250240802765,
-0.2099294513463974,
0.44739246368408203,
-0.08417055755853653,
-0.5411584377288818,
-0.4723505973815918,
0.22370311617851257,
-1.473622441291809,
-0.5003360509872437,
0.9609509110450745,
0.10895213484764099,
-0.3873794376850128,
-0.248331680893898,
-0.7636053562164307,
0.2555675208568573,
-0.6091057658195496,
0.7697425484657288,
0.6542049646377563,
-0.0673941895365715,
0.10949605703353882,
-0.7826884984970093,
0.5317431688308716,
0.4064538776874542,
-1.4896780252456665,
0.22700898349285126,
0.10230961441993713,
-0.006554402410984039,
0.2855122983455658,
0.48051178455352783,
-0.2764136791229248,
0.07805994898080826,
-0.07663039863109589,
0.18050290644168854,
0.17360547184944153,
-0.1438767910003662,
-0.29367420077323914,
0.40636855363845825,
-0.014131361618638039,
-0.18393582105636597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08277v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08277v5 | Towards Faithful and Robust LLM Specialists for Evidence-Based Question-Answering | 2024-02-13T08:12:48 | 2024-06-03T16:48:59 | Tobias Schimanski, Jingwei Ni, Mathias Kraus, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Advances towards more faithful and traceable answers of Large Language Models
(LLMs) are crucial for various research and practical endeavors. One avenue in
reaching this goal is basing the answers on reliable sources. However, this
Evidence-Based QA has proven to work insufficiently with LLMs in terms of
citing the correct sources (source quality) and truthfully representing the
information within sources (answer attributability). In this work, we
systematically investigate how to robustly fine-tune LLMs for better source
quality and answer attributability. Specifically, we introduce a data
generation pipeline with automated data quality filters, which can synthesize
diversified high-quality training and testing data at scale. We further
introduce four test sets to benchmark the robustness of fine-tuned specialist
models. Extensive evaluation shows that fine-tuning on synthetic data improves
performance on both in- and out-of-distribution. Furthermore, we show that data
quality, which can be drastically improved by proposed quality filters, matters
more than quantity in improving Evidence-Based QA. | [
-0.3685010075569153,
-0.7693949341773987,
0.7689700126647949,
-0.3304651379585266,
-0.10389472544193268,
0.3451143503189087,
-0.1391236037015915,
-0.4085593521595001,
-0.04435857757925987,
0.6928947567939758,
-0.5847939848899841,
-0.41190752387046814,
-0.5539482831954956,
0.2437526285648346,
-0.48679301142692566,
0.7036227583885193,
-0.0809376910328865,
0.30473554134368896,
-0.4028887450695038,
-0.4024437963962555,
-0.3082948327064514,
-0.311151385307312,
-0.6417337656021118,
-0.22378350794315338,
0.37811386585235596,
0.4401317536830902,
1.0217111110687256,
1.0390502214431763,
0.44232848286628723,
0.2249884307384491,
-0.0642576664686203,
0.5880285501480103,
-0.4897518754005432,
0.39606285095214844,
-0.5186342597007751,
-0.700332522392273,
-0.44067850708961487,
-0.042563606053590775,
0.4812183082103729,
0.7109427452087402,
-0.3004969358444214,
0.33683595061302185,
0.12375783920288086,
0.37425944209098816,
-0.5159059166908264,
-0.06326289474964142,
-1.0182498693466187,
-0.4150828719139099,
-0.06775231659412384,
-0.29580044746398926,
-0.2830047607421875,
-0.7625335454940796,
-0.15334948897361755,
-0.5630889534950256,
0.32911416888237,
-0.0016383867477998137,
0.9473616480827332,
0.7217056751251221,
-0.31548959016799927,
-0.33567148447036743,
-0.531670093536377,
0.8131058812141418,
-0.9690273404121399,
0.3345981538295746,
0.7002044320106506,
0.35160356760025024,
-0.22682413458824158,
-0.5545175075531006,
-0.24385282397270203,
-0.07237514108419418,
0.05174367129802704,
-0.04702678322792053,
0.1492587924003601,
-0.22137698531150818,
0.09422913938760757,
0.26735442876815796,
-0.42225560545921326,
0.2829434275627136,
0.024822760373353958,
-0.35190349817276,
0.7063403129577637,
0.32472679018974304,
0.0047110277228057384,
0.17101234197616577,
0.2102794051170349,
0.1697426736354828,
-0.9640904068946838,
0.04928704351186752,
0.3862597942352295,
0.393471896648407,
0.4716777801513672,
0.690819501876831,
-0.41656380891799927,
0.7580664157867432,
0.18416155874729156,
-0.24485339224338531,
-0.2772400379180908,
-0.6427764296531677,
0.16655351221561432,
-0.34170660376548767,
0.5421452522277832,
-0.00955362431704998,
0.48822784423828125,
-0.23855054378509521,
-0.30171889066696167,
-0.057350486516952515,
0.26748570799827576,
-0.813055157661438,
-0.39863890409469604,
0.3797810673713684,
-0.32490262389183044,
-0.4742580056190491,
-0.08855356276035309,
-0.44397222995758057,
-0.19294916093349457,
-0.34260624647140503,
0.2779353857040405,
-0.28914588689804077,
-0.2039923220872879,
0.1328287124633789,
0.3024851083755493,
0.14368291199207306,
0.297762930393219,
-0.6264282464981079,
0.2934184670448303,
0.6191244721412659,
0.4576945900917053,
-0.2526708245277405,
0.12087558954954147,
-1.0397980213165283,
0.054324518889188766,
-0.5464202761650085,
1.0511813163757324,
-0.5540565848350525,
-0.11571057885885239,
0.16024483740329742,
0.06456177681684494,
0.1723087579011917,
-0.7667526602745056,
0.7499741315841675,
-0.7746959328651428,
0.2958727777004242,
-0.4232054650783539,
-0.6439136862754822,
0.20261652767658234,
0.4846104681491852,
-0.46567240357398987,
0.8271276950836182,
0.12351400405168533,
-0.5765324234962463,
0.3943253457546234,
-0.14490658044815063,
-0.17204473912715912,
-0.1362987607717514,
-0.078717902302742,
-0.34225770831108093,
0.1291586309671402,
0.5275439620018005,
0.32018887996673584,
-0.2955849766731262,
0.373770534992218,
-0.5570984482765198,
-0.17355480790138245,
0.5980836749076843,
-0.6120274066925049,
0.7393657565116882,
0.39788323640823364,
0.15011410415172577,
-0.11806251853704453,
-0.9846516847610474,
0.3691193759441376,
-0.19540393352508545,
-0.5623691082000732,
-0.15182138979434967,
0.3687171936035156,
-0.2365758866071701,
0.1788560450077057,
-0.0055838534608483315,
-0.5979771018028259,
-0.07821609079837799,
-0.31975632905960083,
0.5083653330802917,
0.6841734051704407,
0.10090387612581253,
0.07386142015457153,
-0.49146249890327454,
0.5804780721664429,
-0.19053107500076294,
0.005714465864002705,
-0.010534167289733887,
-0.33018743991851807,
-0.5692161917686462,
-0.27719801664352417,
0.4981703460216522,
0.4703045189380646,
-0.9114887714385986,
0.5656453967094421,
-0.3783096671104431,
-0.4242406189441681,
-0.8156386017799377,
0.36856067180633545,
0.2641884982585907,
0.7982248663902283,
0.4777771532535553,
-0.46945643424987793,
-0.2460092008113861,
-0.7849400043487549,
-0.5035281181335449,
-0.46964389085769653,
-0.2573888301849365,
0.17363864183425903,
0.22878049314022064,
-0.0739288479089737,
1.176587462425232,
-0.48976266384124756,
0.17514021694660187,
0.022001823410391808,
-0.1285744607448578,
0.32247355580329895,
0.3096395432949066,
0.1740044504404068,
-0.43311190605163574,
-0.4573984742164612,
-0.3009438216686249,
-0.5952752232551575,
-0.3909243643283844,
0.17793548107147217,
-0.11120262742042542,
0.12721005082130432,
0.4182754456996918,
-0.5776531100273132,
-0.07437941431999207,
0.3150697946548462,
-0.3967289328575134,
0.5933732390403748,
0.11988011002540588,
0.13372452557086945,
-1.0953056812286377,
0.10132621973752975,
-0.045730698853731155,
-0.6024174690246582,
-0.4777355194091797,
0.13735629618167877,
0.019347649067640305,
0.07150190323591232,
-0.33984309434890747,
0.36956679821014404,
-0.2572714686393738,
0.13197200000286102,
-0.4020345211029053,
0.0023608484771102667,
0.17427872121334076,
0.07416649162769318,
-0.0756414607167244,
0.8181375861167908,
0.4634755253791809,
-0.480381041765213,
0.35404402017593384,
0.5072571039199829,
-0.29159462451934814,
0.7993683218955994,
-0.7762531042098999,
0.13002559542655945,
-0.043131083250045776,
0.114674411714077,
-0.902877926826477,
-0.5383976101875305,
0.04374590143561363,
-0.5305510759353638,
0.4632021486759186,
-0.548627495765686,
-0.6534558534622192,
0.015800613909959793,
-0.2772634029388428,
0.1589389443397522,
0.5421719551086426,
-0.48976728320121765,
0.3347473442554474,
0.29628339409828186,
-0.4162639081478119,
-0.5627187490463257,
-0.7368416786193848,
-0.041853561997413635,
-0.20695140957832336,
-0.7403262853622437,
-0.1418335884809494,
-0.0797242820262909,
-0.3804711401462555,
-0.0036065084859728813,
-0.2853780686855316,
-0.4884149432182312,
0.15087905526161194,
-0.32756391167640686,
0.22070136666297913,
-0.3775615692138672,
0.003065103432163596,
0.04732893407344818,
-0.11869827657938004,
0.4339212477207184,
-0.06651969254016876,
0.21212032437324524,
0.15042434632778168,
-0.6923877596855164,
-0.17343229055404663,
0.30860552191734314,
0.6022611856460571,
-0.4550360441207886,
0.5532562136650085,
0.44728347659111023,
-0.25238826870918274,
-0.19169160723686218,
-0.7095540761947632,
-0.5276225805282593,
-0.48497098684310913,
0.4077620208263397,
-0.2561721205711365,
-0.9691296219825745,
0.6800230741500854,
0.1599266082048416,
0.27812984585762024,
0.3432582914829254,
0.41643068194389343,
-0.19953913986682892,
1.1875160932540894,
0.21392327547073364,
0.06577746570110321,
0.06137586757540703,
0.11646419763565063,
-0.027938751503825188,
-0.5073695182800293,
0.030986415222287178,
-0.8560647368431091,
0.05363190546631813,
-0.4461905360221863,
-0.22853855788707733,
0.4249763786792755,
0.0989832803606987,
-0.16337549686431885,
-0.022230949252843857,
-0.5394071936607361,
0.5337029099464417,
0.3840407431125641,
0.26371216773986816,
0.5616021752357483,
-0.041012637317180634,
0.31430283188819885,
-0.02317609265446663,
-0.8128042817115784,
-0.7990617156028748,
1.255431056022644,
0.5628105401992798,
1.105079174041748,
0.024138882756233215,
0.296334445476532,
-0.11248721182346344,
0.22750042378902435,
-0.5191321969032288,
0.38287466764450073,
-0.026053329929709435,
-0.772322952747345,
-0.2998404800891876,
-0.4105958044528961,
-0.6838406920433044,
0.04722335934638977,
-0.23618000745773315,
-0.3588322401046753,
0.2515413761138916,
0.2699204385280609,
-0.44444113969802856,
0.10447162389755249,
-0.4224907457828522,
0.5566239953041077,
-0.15693137049674988,
-0.6884049773216248,
-0.09521399438381195,
-0.6252957582473755,
0.3393104672431946,
-0.2977310121059418,
0.07275587320327759,
-0.2902134954929352,
-0.07325000315904617,
0.5293083786964417,
-0.39869987964630127,
0.6127626299858093,
-0.11274853348731995,
-0.34151536226272583,
0.42201822996139526,
0.08274539560079575,
0.8050426840782166,
0.5498947501182556,
-0.34433481097221375,
-0.17386196553707123,
0.2799767851829529,
-0.6355668306350708,
-0.5590513944625854,
0.7407221794128418,
-0.655305027961731,
-0.6750894784927368,
-0.19135770201683044,
-0.5339120626449585,
-0.7683115601539612,
0.12579335272312164,
0.2541266679763794,
0.48969051241874695,
0.026668550446629524,
0.3070782423019409,
1.247687816619873,
-0.09341912716627121,
0.014076728373765945,
0.814994215965271,
0.1832580715417862,
-0.4325878620147705,
0.7005277276039124,
0.18433523178100586,
0.38603833317756653,
0.16149093210697174,
0.03305981308221817,
-0.6266345977783203,
-1.0232343673706055,
-0.5871181488037109,
0.10494044423103333,
-0.6503077745437622,
-0.4296019971370697,
-0.3145178556442261,
-0.24203018844127655,
-0.2310958206653595,
0.11897727847099304,
-0.5958292484283447,
-0.4082699716091156,
-0.4356652498245239,
-0.036177728325128555,
0.3343103229999542,
0.28379592299461365,
0.20486147701740265,
-0.12700973451137543,
-0.7890994548797607,
0.37448957562446594,
0.40080440044403076,
0.456311970949173,
-0.4959068298339844,
-0.8363335132598877,
-0.368786484003067,
0.35921183228492737,
-0.32700878381729126,
-0.6268123984336853,
0.08810721337795258,
0.3517949879169464,
0.617354691028595,
0.15538804233074188,
0.24136897921562195,
0.5834131836891174,
-0.29147642850875854,
0.8596075773239136,
-0.27350425720214844,
-0.5487717986106873,
0.610305905342102,
-0.5562919974327087,
0.23817552626132965,
0.9483370780944824,
0.27869755029678345,
0.03435782343149185,
-0.8013598918914795,
-0.3711223304271698,
-0.7591768503189087,
0.4395979642868042,
0.20010945200920105,
0.09229832887649536,
0.18011139333248138,
0.5947133302688599,
0.37393125891685486,
0.13942046463489532,
-0.3374437093734741,
-0.016966359689831734,
-0.28185218572616577,
-0.39189285039901733,
0.000604961474891752,
-0.12988828122615814,
-0.41584277153015137,
-0.203349769115448,
0.7975338697433472,
-0.5174629092216492,
-0.09178034216165543,
0.17031297087669373,
-0.0258440263569355,
-0.3081541955471039,
0.42116671800613403,
0.20060822367668152,
1.1246241331100464,
-0.215099036693573,
0.2086610198020935,
0.2839995324611664,
-0.3055989146232605,
0.3731920123100281,
0.1528491973876953,
-0.3239824175834656,
0.13445135951042175,
0.38667866587638855,
0.26416832208633423,
-0.329499214887619,
-0.8100013136863708,
0.2879505753517151,
0.04230504855513573,
-0.12976087629795074,
-0.1467573493719101,
0.4461134076118469,
0.07737945765256882,
-0.03388207405805588,
0.40584319829940796,
0.1464233100414276,
0.08147887885570526,
-0.46344223618507385,
0.3438960313796997,
0.5746120810508728,
-0.38043493032455444,
-0.24079227447509766,
0.8578128218650818,
0.10248138755559921,
-0.10655254125595093,
0.6488273739814758,
0.2561877965927124,
-0.15598011016845703,
0.38958123326301575,
0.25196996331214905,
0.607805073261261,
-0.11785745620727539,
0.06565229594707489,
0.26301267743110657,
0.08876148611307144,
-0.33837077021598816,
0.33726298809051514,
0.25692251324653625,
-0.6622434258460999,
-0.8481028079986572,
-0.40278294682502747,
-0.5901550650596619,
0.07578088343143463,
-0.732229471206665,
0.11150802671909332,
-0.15114381909370422,
-0.02946947142481804,
-0.18784049153327942,
0.10171734541654587,
-0.501812219619751,
0.36684122681617737,
-0.2554963231086731,
1.0367844104766846,
-0.7096039056777954,
0.8719385266304016,
0.7616098523139954,
-0.12419938296079636,
-0.9372968077659607,
-0.06180538237094879,
-0.2336162030696869,
-0.7078344821929932,
0.026552729308605194,
-0.2455192506313324,
-0.041314881294965744,
0.040630221366882324,
-0.9348248243331909,
-0.984214186668396,
1.099663257598877,
0.8442842960357666,
-0.35989564657211304,
0.17917400598526,
0.26454171538352966,
0.786764919757843,
-0.210509791970253,
0.3381637930870056,
0.5813724398612976,
0.39952191710472107,
0.07357492297887802,
-0.7846003770828247,
0.07082560658454895,
-0.10239725559949875,
-0.18203909695148468,
-0.11942477524280548,
-0.5488420724868774,
0.26716238260269165,
0.09648901224136353,
0.09575457125902176,
0.19951198995113373,
0.5664714574813843,
0.5864145159721375,
0.1769150346517563,
0.3346383571624756,
0.4814847707748413,
0.822272002696991,
-0.2670772969722748,
0.8528074026107788,
-0.42668163776397705,
0.1779831200838089,
0.9993679523468018,
-0.109456866979599,
0.8644057512283325,
0.6091964840888977,
-0.2049507051706314,
0.39433732628822327,
0.8697043657302856,
-0.12208860367536545,
0.5141958594322205,
0.1290057748556137,
-0.11711502075195312,
-0.6268017292022705,
-0.3023175001144409,
-0.18633407354354858,
0.21575815975666046,
0.12312515079975128,
-0.3560483753681183,
-0.1274663209915161,
-0.3828173279762268,
-0.09954430162906647,
0.41553670167922974,
-0.34943944215774536,
0.6338350176811218,
-0.031292740255594254,
-0.9509718418121338,
0.7719641923904419,
-0.10091943293809891,
0.5437076091766357,
-0.6663346886634827,
0.2405126690864563,
-0.5654476881027222,
0.05598792806267738,
-0.4283563792705536,
-1.0563727617263794,
0.518314003944397,
0.172604501247406,
-0.24442484974861145,
-0.16999171674251556,
0.8323811292648315,
-0.4862234592437744,
-0.42790156602859497,
-0.37607166171073914,
0.8515989184379578,
0.09367600083351135,
-0.06780201941728592,
-0.5735176801681519,
-0.08693485707044601,
0.009845620021224022,
-0.3733213245868683,
0.2765680253505707,
0.48715150356292725,
-0.012094120495021343,
1.101383924484253,
0.5858600735664368,
0.31491366028785706,
0.05904232710599899,
-0.1859297752380371,
0.8851698637008667,
-0.17578348517417908,
-0.15253661572933197,
-0.7101678252220154,
0.647132933139801,
-0.029474977403879166,
-0.19800342619419098,
0.7643262147903442,
0.44444116950035095,
0.7703291177749634,
0.007534358184784651,
0.6695215702056885,
0.1363958865404129,
0.8470560312271118,
-0.5149244666099548,
0.6903256177902222,
-0.4578201472759247,
0.4902428984642029,
0.005099939182400703,
-0.9540794491767883,
-0.251813679933548,
0.28395146131515503,
0.08785755187273026,
-0.12770813703536987,
0.369904100894928,
1.0296058654785156,
-0.3007584512233734,
-0.3483605682849884,
0.1395045667886734,
0.1539204865694046,
0.6066657900810242,
0.4305357038974762,
0.8768699765205383,
-0.3816777467727661,
0.8520235419273376,
0.009418006986379623,
0.09385137259960175,
0.12408988922834396,
-0.6373315453529358,
-0.6990299820899963,
-0.20303145051002502,
-0.6202712655067444,
-0.46132829785346985,
0.14643827080726624,
0.7394483089447021,
0.7989558577537537,
-1.072972059249878,
0.15704205632209778,
-0.33116695284843445,
0.02907387539744377,
-0.13098134100437164,
-0.20280243456363678,
0.334848016500473,
-0.482517272233963,
-0.6140956878662109,
0.43889880180358887,
-0.12725773453712463,
-0.17474375665187836,
-0.43017327785491943,
-0.2179347723722458,
0.19117972254753113,
0.2940860688686371,
0.2860880494117737,
0.28004053235054016,
-0.6059035062789917,
-0.5502601861953735,
0.15839745104312897,
-0.17705778777599335,
0.03361479192972183,
0.42807769775390625,
-0.5919128656387329,
0.34885603189468384,
0.43450868129730225,
0.9035918712615967,
0.05521764978766441,
0.36504191160202026,
0.7727565765380859,
-0.5957465767860413,
-0.4078352451324463,
0.6006112694740295,
0.2665388882160187,
0.5251393914222717,
-0.16303083300590515,
0.6840724945068359,
0.003779883962124586,
-0.919900119304657,
-1.0354828834533691,
0.346344918012619,
-0.8204455375671387,
-0.17590782046318054,
1.2711892127990723,
-0.33361366391181946,
0.2013566792011261,
-0.5703020691871643,
-0.05024576559662819,
0.12973254919052124,
-0.2041572481393814,
0.9662670493125916,
0.9746919274330139,
-0.23055504262447357,
-0.23433254659175873,
-0.495036244392395,
0.5801002383232117,
0.5855095386505127,
-0.8329715728759766,
0.10048603266477585,
0.6528826951980591,
0.6961241364479065,
-0.035284362733364105,
0.45402640104293823,
-0.22690680623054504,
0.170339435338974,
-0.24612104892730713,
-0.48171183466911316,
-0.21313594281673431,
-0.05423155426979065,
-0.16907961666584015,
0.2962667644023895,
0.6443302035331726,
0.014345524832606316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08259v1 | A Survey of Table Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T07:17:52 | 2024-02-13T07:17:52 | Xuanliang Zhang, Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table reasoning, which aims to generate the corresponding answer to the
question following the user requirement according to the provided table, and
optionally a text description of the table, effectively improving the
efficiency of obtaining information. Recently, using Large Language Models
(LLMs) has become the mainstream method for table reasoning, because it not
only significantly reduces the annotation cost but also exceeds the performance
of previous methods. However, existing research still lacks a summary of
LLM-based table reasoning works. Due to the existing lack of research,
questions about which techniques can improve table reasoning performance in the
era of LLMs, why LLMs excel at table reasoning, and how to enhance table
reasoning abilities in the future, remain largely unexplored. This gap
significantly limits progress in research. To answer the above questions and
advance table reasoning research with LLMs, we present this survey to analyze
existing research, inspiring future work. In this paper, we analyze the
mainstream techniques used to improve table reasoning performance in the LLM
era, and the advantages of LLMs compared to pre-LLMs for solving table
reasoning. We provide research directions from both the improvement of existing
methods and the expansion of practical applications to inspire future research. | [
-0.5296655893325806,
-0.8942529559135437,
0.9551845192909241,
-0.2086852490901947,
-0.19720229506492615,
-0.0381048358976841,
-0.25310614705085754,
-0.5947763919830322,
0.1016010269522667,
0.5704500675201416,
-0.3922959864139557,
-0.7649070024490356,
-0.44297531247138977,
0.20207563042640686,
-0.4201000928878784,
0.532845139503479,
-0.19246171414852142,
0.19422318041324615,
-0.45736828446388245,
-0.12576480209827423,
-0.5462304353713989,
-0.5830541253089905,
-0.24843956530094147,
-0.42797979712486267,
0.6749469041824341,
0.7270110249519348,
0.5298933386802673,
0.46661701798439026,
0.6230021119117737,
0.2866482734680176,
-0.29189547896385193,
0.4647200107574463,
-0.1100253090262413,
0.37344351410865784,
0.057901252061128616,
-0.6491371393203735,
-0.6334667801856995,
-0.39131641387939453,
0.653658926486969,
0.6595211625099182,
-0.14080369472503662,
0.12800000607967377,
-0.11693471670150757,
0.7272330522537231,
-0.48604318499565125,
0.41862034797668457,
-0.7069537043571472,
0.06571488082408905,
-0.5811823010444641,
-0.1799056977033615,
-0.5390201210975647,
-0.48331397771835327,
-0.07555937021970749,
-0.19283020496368408,
-0.19535866379737854,
0.23459839820861816,
0.21854786574840546,
-0.14679662883281708,
-0.3760179877281189,
-0.207403764128685,
-0.9038516283035278,
0.6787260174751282,
-0.9641622304916382,
0.7255350351333618,
0.16952142119407654,
0.452490895986557,
-0.4045219123363495,
-0.7554900050163269,
-0.6393555998802185,
-0.6801967620849609,
-0.0879531055688858,
-0.23627571761608124,
0.06639950722455978,
-0.06291257590055466,
0.49103817343711853,
0.18816491961479187,
-0.5340192317962646,
0.3462633192539215,
-0.08303922414779663,
0.03858745098114014,
0.699614942073822,
0.36000052094459534,
0.23620669543743134,
0.021198276430368423,
-0.007396108470857143,
0.014153734780848026,
-1.0655418634414673,
-0.06862665712833405,
-0.19075524806976318,
0.03776497021317482,
0.22540846467018127,
0.6775381565093994,
-0.3947598338127136,
1.120431900024414,
-0.7638248205184937,
-0.24772487580776215,
-0.08331822603940964,
-0.14601652324199677,
-0.08787223696708679,
-0.20013190805912018,
0.43841060996055603,
0.3943764865398407,
0.1843235045671463,
-0.3152971565723419,
-0.17207957804203033,
-0.026985272765159607,
-0.2874375283718109,
-0.44230443239212036,
0.19381186366081238,
0.006860697641968727,
-0.33106520771980286,
0.1334235966205597,
-0.18304754793643951,
-0.908036470413208,
-0.5806780457496643,
-0.3580780029296875,
0.22603413462638855,
-0.1628335565328598,
-0.20802538096904755,
-0.09694632142782211,
0.03821690380573273,
0.46640604734420776,
0.7826510667800903,
-0.8020166158676147,
0.2256171703338623,
0.9155155420303345,
0.7289261817932129,
-0.3937491476535797,
-0.023233061656355858,
-0.12617887556552887,
0.29702165722846985,
-0.4939855635166168,
1.1131020784378052,
-0.6691341996192932,
-0.38961490988731384,
0.2715246081352234,
-0.19953519105911255,
0.30796778202056885,
-0.5604737401008606,
0.5504473447799683,
-0.5056572556495667,
-0.05417030677199364,
-0.6900591254234314,
-0.5041505098342896,
-0.2855137586593628,
0.5279572606086731,
-0.6380370855331421,
0.7274027466773987,
-0.22725273668766022,
-0.5570139288902283,
0.4809023439884186,
-0.7950885891914368,
-0.4180757403373718,
0.21190111339092255,
-0.3776125907897949,
-0.3839637339115143,
0.12809385359287262,
0.5196071267127991,
0.5433889031410217,
-0.7548321485519409,
0.4020399749279022,
-0.3889572024345398,
-0.4528953731060028,
0.5022626519203186,
-0.10918121039867401,
0.2345837503671646,
0.3495166599750519,
-0.12953153252601624,
0.18532223999500275,
-0.5559898614883423,
-0.020417802035808563,
0.1257471740245819,
-0.3729216456413269,
0.054043468087911606,
0.25434744358062744,
-0.30369600653648376,
0.01479737926274538,
0.048169564455747604,
-0.3512658476829529,
0.39199507236480713,
-0.1631334275007248,
0.5700724124908447,
0.47231659293174744,
-0.02653457783162594,
0.4327516257762909,
-0.38738614320755005,
0.4357638657093048,
-0.19271612167358398,
-0.06686089187860489,
-0.002847601193934679,
-0.4737997055053711,
-0.7497737407684326,
0.10545769333839417,
0.3983841836452484,
0.456950843334198,
-0.6873393654823303,
0.09251130372285843,
-0.2428847849369049,
-0.5332220792770386,
-0.01597694493830204,
-0.008407755754888058,
0.04972287639975548,
0.5522649884223938,
0.44405338168144226,
0.19136258959770203,
-0.7052021622657776,
-0.9565462470054626,
-0.37412816286087036,
-0.1291361302137375,
0.20521186292171478,
0.3524242639541626,
0.35730594396591187,
0.013778600841760635,
0.7301071286201477,
-0.4766383469104767,
-0.005981381516903639,
-0.8567615747451782,
-0.19110265374183655,
0.22174081206321716,
0.3082388639450073,
0.09925141930580139,
-0.45432987809181213,
-0.39490821957588196,
0.0013858126476407051,
-0.6841948628425598,
-0.0568302646279335,
0.17523731291294098,
-0.009148413315415382,
0.5274628400802612,
0.6725224852561951,
-0.755780816078186,
0.2741272747516632,
0.2608710825443268,
-0.003311312524601817,
0.4268026053905487,
-0.012539252638816833,
0.21215611696243286,
-0.5585135817527771,
-0.07456837594509125,
0.006335914600640535,
0.03984105587005615,
-0.5165126919746399,
0.10995249450206757,
0.021887704730033875,
-0.19374346733093262,
-0.25991490483283997,
0.6732500195503235,
-0.8321711421012878,
-0.1139061376452446,
-0.2469407171010971,
0.3580811321735382,
-0.2640092074871063,
0.15982861816883087,
0.19731347262859344,
0.7597960233688354,
0.46989765763282776,
-0.5183350443840027,
0.33978044986724854,
0.18672487139701843,
-0.4560930132865906,
0.18323832750320435,
-0.5317263007164001,
-0.03406255692243576,
-0.2886267304420471,
0.4386790990829468,
-1.214547872543335,
-0.06925416737794876,
0.17668937146663666,
-0.18637827038764954,
0.37042075395584106,
0.052206140011548996,
-0.6619154810905457,
-0.790887176990509,
-0.22696329653263092,
-0.05414760485291481,
0.6904276609420776,
-0.5101975202560425,
0.676029622554779,
0.352767676115036,
-0.07640498131513596,
-0.7139285206794739,
-0.7872173190116882,
0.24691148102283478,
-0.45893537998199463,
-0.8099285364151001,
0.1918310672044754,
0.1436590850353241,
-0.6930052042007446,
-0.30731552839279175,
-0.337442547082901,
0.13130992650985718,
-0.12070685625076294,
-0.05946352332830429,
0.23469898104667664,
-0.28934600949287415,
0.3881811499595642,
-0.08498033881187439,
-0.01138092577457428,
0.199986070394516,
-0.049183499068021774,
0.6638922691345215,
-0.09199739992618561,
-0.2628442645072937,
-0.2481215000152588,
0.2555573880672455,
0.34869879484176636,
-0.2691456973552704,
0.6706373691558838,
0.21962930262088776,
-0.263276606798172,
-0.30563753843307495,
-1.144701600074768,
-0.27154064178466797,
-0.41680920124053955,
0.4429154396057129,
-0.3411203920841217,
-1.106735348701477,
0.6086787581443787,
-0.27359259128570557,
0.14746125042438507,
0.4496020972728729,
0.5123456120491028,
0.0030184166971594095,
0.858426570892334,
0.2457124888896942,
0.15867142379283905,
0.1710246354341507,
-0.174813374876976,
0.07174363732337952,
-0.7311850190162659,
-0.5925754308700562,
-0.8898998498916626,
-0.25565963983535767,
-0.41333842277526855,
-0.49872690439224243,
0.3347901403903961,
-0.19546683132648468,
-0.09519072622060776,
0.10220582783222198,
-0.5398423075675964,
0.4339749813079834,
0.4931294620037079,
0.18243330717086792,
0.5592643022537231,
-0.09725011885166168,
0.009765762835741043,
-0.0686979666352272,
-0.5945464968681335,
-0.5288001894950867,
0.9576391577720642,
0.34500300884246826,
0.8143394589424133,
0.0600832961499691,
0.5641002655029297,
0.24549594521522522,
0.45342814922332764,
-0.4858531355857849,
1.01262629032135,
0.17816759645938873,
-0.6690824627876282,
-0.6060762405395508,
-0.557680606842041,
-0.7886265516281128,
0.41920235753059387,
-0.15304893255233765,
-0.8759397864341736,
-0.1795990765094757,
0.29031801223754883,
0.09818900376558304,
0.36575552821159363,
-0.502730667591095,
0.8651158213615417,
-0.3445591330528259,
-0.4464331567287445,
-0.038756463676691055,
-0.41753003001213074,
0.5528063178062439,
0.14988936483860016,
0.26921722292900085,
-0.20406004786491394,
-0.09037888795137405,
0.7963961362838745,
-0.533607542514801,
0.5146892666816711,
-0.365066796541214,
-0.18306191265583038,
0.5488259196281433,
0.10990440100431442,
0.7290090322494507,
0.14130862057209015,
-0.33828872442245483,
-0.04841845855116844,
-0.2210075855255127,
0.06158275902271271,
-0.6030535697937012,
0.7674579620361328,
-0.2632467746734619,
-1.021628737449646,
-0.25786951184272766,
-0.6241546273231506,
-0.5632339715957642,
-0.10698053240776062,
-0.08827671408653259,
0.17902882397174835,
0.024795178323984146,
0.3190097510814667,
0.6168316602706909,
-0.11966753751039505,
0.5899890065193176,
0.40033918619155884,
-0.4519917070865631,
-0.27943652868270874,
0.33129775524139404,
0.4100774824619293,
-0.13807228207588196,
0.6559141874313354,
0.3654833137989044,
-0.6207599639892578,
-1.0180320739746094,
-0.45167091488838196,
0.2685133218765259,
-0.6874815821647644,
-0.32523250579833984,
-0.6980091333389282,
-0.05219414457678795,
-0.3306581377983093,
-0.05375909060239792,
-0.004128190688788891,
-0.6072539687156677,
0.12156665325164795,
-0.14912688732147217,
0.5276084542274475,
0.4860913157463074,
0.1651586890220642,
0.28988537192344666,
-0.7420982122421265,
0.019412707537412643,
0.5077085494995117,
0.3755261301994324,
0.5185227394104004,
-0.3654042184352875,
0.054674405604600906,
-0.28861451148986816,
-0.08972582221031189,
-1.072508454322815,
0.24651697278022766,
-0.2665935754776001,
0.8777527809143066,
0.07658270746469498,
-0.18156901001930237,
0.6061679124832153,
-0.5574967861175537,
0.6854393482208252,
0.10533618927001953,
-0.8400481939315796,
0.5311209559440613,
-0.2919691205024719,
0.2871547341346741,
0.40246084332466125,
0.3692053258419037,
-0.43543484807014465,
-0.10214579105377197,
-0.28375574946403503,
-0.8477513790130615,
0.49360191822052,
-0.06204647943377495,
-0.1392984539270401,
0.21120797097682953,
0.38599899411201477,
0.16011621057987213,
0.06525179743766785,
-0.9817700386047363,
0.01303704734891653,
0.4237799346446991,
0.1325986683368683,
0.04090101271867752,
-0.3804131746292114,
0.13165105879306793,
-0.5171619653701782,
0.6115599870681763,
0.1496557593345642,
0.09472770243883133,
-0.0823497474193573,
-0.027435850352048874,
-0.1520315557718277,
0.6406788229942322,
0.5706308484077454,
1.0024806261062622,
-0.007841495797038078,
0.20954486727714539,
0.6970496773719788,
0.0014310396509245038,
0.03750656545162201,
0.17067952454090118,
-0.2172604203224182,
-0.014259587973356247,
0.2241530418395996,
0.5774013996124268,
-0.20355315506458282,
-0.7714746594429016,
0.2725053131580353,
0.08331812173128128,
-0.1793450564146042,
-0.40424269437789917,
0.19830165803432465,
0.6485138535499573,
0.30753061175346375,
0.33790552616119385,
-0.5589884519577026,
0.2625931203365326,
-0.6130993962287903,
0.05874152109026909,
0.6808617115020752,
-0.1581093817949295,
0.29974883794784546,
0.5881817936897278,
-0.04962064325809479,
-0.5043848752975464,
0.5089935064315796,
0.06572899967432022,
-0.20945140719413757,
0.5167152881622314,
0.587977945804596,
0.28765738010406494,
-0.12420506775379181,
0.06261224299669266,
0.24251946806907654,
0.28081560134887695,
-0.30634963512420654,
0.5014454126358032,
-0.2119704931974411,
-0.46126309037208557,
-0.6453958749771118,
-0.5633403062820435,
-0.5531426668167114,
0.30383557081222534,
0.009790962561964989,
0.30275022983551025,
-0.21932832896709442,
-0.1072121262550354,
-0.037175502628088,
-0.13155639171600342,
-0.3999660909175873,
0.001231829053722322,
0.1424393653869629,
1.0187792778015137,
-0.5435253977775574,
0.5197871327400208,
0.566680908203125,
-0.4057363271713257,
-0.7687295079231262,
-0.32632219791412354,
-0.09971730411052704,
-0.7552496194839478,
0.5093802809715271,
0.06409946084022522,
0.19762402772903442,
-0.25386515259742737,
-0.6685627698898315,
-0.8408635854721069,
0.8746384382247925,
0.15435610711574554,
-0.801322877407074,
-0.16910716891288757,
0.5016624331474304,
0.5681989192962646,
-0.17941364645957947,
0.24230723083019257,
0.756041407585144,
0.8363974690437317,
0.367859423160553,
-0.6313123106956482,
0.20728054642677307,
-0.018007585778832436,
0.09232641756534576,
0.5188242793083191,
-0.30036482214927673,
0.6439297199249268,
-0.11636782437562943,
0.13444556295871735,
0.013433094136416912,
0.7573783993721008,
0.5006441473960876,
0.4533376097679138,
0.29996415972709656,
0.5892462134361267,
0.4065527319908142,
-0.282339870929718,
0.7874203324317932,
0.14342506229877472,
0.0013895963784307241,
0.8350556492805481,
-0.5278799533843994,
0.7747372984886169,
0.28624024987220764,
-0.36854037642478943,
0.4961642026901245,
0.4509650468826294,
-0.2844046652317047,
0.035888366401195526,
0.7037652134895325,
-0.253068208694458,
-0.4008333683013916,
-0.02512882649898529,
-0.5988307595252991,
0.5038430690765381,
0.6068481802940369,
-0.4297823905944824,
-0.4797968566417694,
-0.16685345768928528,
0.15677548944950104,
0.24378395080566406,
-0.4654358923435211,
0.8120356798171997,
0.07809726893901825,
-0.7200222015380859,
0.42428186535835266,
0.10290077328681946,
0.4130895137786865,
-0.4684724509716034,
-0.2735629379749298,
-0.33842816948890686,
-0.07723945379257202,
-0.18340067565441132,
-0.7388028502464294,
0.14298611879348755,
-0.0999150425195694,
0.3043103516101837,
-0.08080888539552689,
0.9080080986022949,
-0.24411442875862122,
-0.317987859249115,
-0.02992585115134716,
1.000831961631775,
0.2716984152793884,
-0.003170134499669075,
-0.30713459849357605,
0.21638058125972748,
-0.09708678722381592,
-0.18261116743087769,
0.1849317103624344,
0.5225454568862915,
-0.14197613298892975,
0.72674959897995,
0.4620783030986786,
0.1815282255411148,
-0.04599863663315773,
0.10244256258010864,
0.8824999332427979,
-0.8729197382926941,
-0.26559510827064514,
-1.0641670227050781,
0.3682057857513428,
-0.19395354390144348,
-0.05412375181913376,
0.755888044834137,
0.6122487783432007,
0.49681800603866577,
-0.25801676511764526,
0.5637639760971069,
0.08487070351839066,
0.7805233597755432,
-0.6622514128684998,
0.5464963912963867,
-0.43662774562835693,
0.3407430052757263,
-0.4050315320491791,
-1.1976146697998047,
-0.7128904461860657,
0.4051245450973511,
-0.5351598858833313,
0.3120214343070984,
0.6895642280578613,
0.7311947345733643,
0.28733235597610474,
0.22769242525100708,
0.2574480175971985,
0.16631180047988892,
0.319620281457901,
0.4318447709083557,
1.261968970298767,
0.15387363731861115,
0.6404809355735779,
-0.010876638814806938,
-0.222367063164711,
-0.2183316946029663,
-0.8811076283454895,
-0.847100555896759,
-0.3532678484916687,
-0.08013381063938141,
-0.1320907324552536,
0.2680332362651825,
0.7233260273933411,
0.46927937865257263,
-0.6089461445808411,
-0.43637165427207947,
-0.2618246078491211,
0.28743597865104675,
0.04554474353790283,
-0.16748106479644775,
0.515381932258606,
-0.2970125675201416,
-0.46605348587036133,
0.2822723388671875,
0.16617177426815033,
-0.09113185107707977,
-0.22723999619483948,
0.15862050652503967,
-0.2534116208553314,
-0.10372503101825714,
0.6753852963447571,
0.3882370889186859,
-0.7100362777709961,
-0.06614777445793152,
-0.01531962864100933,
0.1439998894929886,
0.32962146401405334,
0.8865953087806702,
-0.52875816822052,
-0.09760107100009918,
0.7538471221923828,
0.6746183037757874,
0.7616663575172424,
-0.10318002849817276,
0.3154662251472473,
-0.2877088487148285,
-0.09713028371334076,
0.5023913979530334,
0.5693401098251343,
0.2368205487728119,
-0.16974705457687378,
0.6585322022438049,
-0.03333612531423569,
-0.7075274586677551,
-0.7641399502754211,
0.2869004011154175,
-0.978896975517273,
-0.4255046546459198,
1.212978482246399,
0.2691061198711395,
-0.2112284153699875,
-0.06461291015148163,
-0.1905805915594101,
0.23330508172512054,
-0.3611471951007843,
0.8920454978942871,
0.6236791014671326,
-0.6636433005332947,
-0.48116636276245117,
-0.4172303080558777,
0.48479026556015015,
0.26329928636550903,
-1.2633622884750366,
0.2894798219203949,
0.8355672359466553,
-0.110761359333992,
0.03976261988282204,
0.5889596343040466,
-0.507652223110199,
0.09858623892068863,
-0.08886348456144333,
0.025815051048994064,
-0.19068855047225952,
-0.4718582332134247,
0.031429678201675415,
0.4603525698184967,
0.5877233147621155,
0.28218144178390503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08227v1 | Privacy-Preserving Language Model Inference with Instance Obfuscation | 2024-02-13T05:36:54 | 2024-02-13T05:36:54 | Yixiang Yao, Fei Wang, Srivatsan Ravi, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language Models as a Service (LMaaS) offers convenient access for developers
and researchers to perform inference using pre-trained language models.
Nonetheless, the input data and the inference results containing private
information are exposed as plaintext during the service call, leading to
privacy issues. Recent studies have started tackling the privacy issue by
transforming input data into privacy-preserving representation from the
user-end with the techniques such as noise addition and content perturbation,
while the exploration of inference result protection, namely decision privacy,
is still a blank page. In order to maintain the black-box manner of LMaaS,
conducting data privacy protection, especially for the decision, is a
challenging task because the process has to be seamless to the models and
accompanied by limited communication and computation overhead. We thus propose
Instance-Obfuscated Inference (IOI) method, which focuses on addressing the
decision privacy issue of natural language understanding tasks in their
complete life-cycle. Besides, we conduct comprehensive experiments to evaluate
the performance as well as the privacy-protection strength of the proposed
method on various benchmarking tasks. | [
-0.226716086268425,
-1.1981425285339355,
0.618582546710968,
-0.07019154727458954,
-0.18919289112091064,
0.014083550311625004,
-0.20759263634681702,
-0.6284166574478149,
-0.15782225131988525,
0.8913739323616028,
-0.5291544795036316,
-0.5420500636100769,
-0.26593050360679626,
-0.1779082864522934,
-0.25978463888168335,
0.68984454870224,
0.20924222469329834,
-0.16758988797664642,
-0.35687094926834106,
-0.003503292566165328,
-0.04829034209251404,
-0.3672025203704834,
-0.6303375959396362,
-0.12128397077322006,
0.06067098677158356,
0.4487890899181366,
0.3673705458641052,
0.6989014744758606,
0.07958683371543884,
0.2916138768196106,
-0.18275003135204315,
0.23419831693172455,
-0.31129956245422363,
0.21772797405719757,
-0.12306533008813858,
-0.4392022490501404,
-0.38201257586479187,
0.030002228915691376,
0.5193758010864258,
0.8920732736587524,
-0.3219337463378906,
0.23725947737693787,
0.19756260514259338,
0.34753698110580444,
-1.0622271299362183,
0.19801369309425354,
-0.5186149477958679,
-0.011628236621618271,
-0.017240872606635094,
0.1405724734067917,
-0.6175516843795776,
-0.2534262537956238,
0.13115356862545013,
-0.21639443933963776,
0.03958161920309067,
0.25307804346084595,
0.9691546559333801,
0.11094115674495697,
0.014622383750975132,
-0.000945229665376246,
-0.9985904097557068,
0.8952949643135071,
-1.1101715564727783,
0.28998100757598877,
1.0262396335601807,
0.22961030900478363,
-0.0363556444644928,
-0.48189178109169006,
-0.5929573774337769,
-0.16430512070655823,
-0.12467164546251297,
0.02841750904917717,
-0.244362011551857,
0.11831800639629364,
0.09335659444332123,
0.46360862255096436,
-0.4031151235103607,
0.37622907757759094,
-0.22874143719673157,
-0.032756950706243515,
0.6311273574829102,
-0.23482251167297363,
0.1262100338935852,
-0.09981372952461243,
-0.27221789956092834,
0.11817151308059692,
-0.4987998306751251,
0.02779751643538475,
0.5368152260780334,
0.16257570683956146,
-0.05449957028031349,
0.5003564953804016,
-0.6208164691925049,
0.6311666965484619,
-0.14777301251888275,
-0.19670268893241882,
0.26100319623947144,
-0.16322244703769684,
-0.6575495004653931,
0.08044779300689697,
0.9942960739135742,
0.10741744190454483,
0.13046571612358093,
-0.6762736439704895,
0.17289595305919647,
-0.11393977701663971,
0.1661916971206665,
-0.8761767745018005,
0.29469165205955505,
0.5172683000564575,
-0.3225695490837097,
-0.2985862195491791,
0.1653219759464264,
-0.8075836300849915,
-0.2659345865249634,
0.0016637719236314297,
0.24623246490955353,
-0.3323523700237274,
-0.11462651193141937,
0.4061817526817322,
0.48243018984794617,
0.015929844230413437,
-0.022146498784422874,
-0.84983229637146,
0.6009988188743591,
0.744677722454071,
0.530264139175415,
0.02240288071334362,
-0.11439014226198196,
-0.5638489127159119,
0.42971786856651306,
-0.058448273688554764,
0.4823641777038574,
-0.5000821948051453,
-0.4508567154407501,
-0.03244621306657791,
-0.07280174642801285,
0.02815559133887291,
-0.41856762766838074,
0.5848965644836426,
-0.39481455087661743,
0.36160460114479065,
0.4519922733306885,
-0.6355255842208862,
-0.39067867398262024,
-0.0013752086088061333,
-0.3542095720767975,
0.7119711637496948,
-0.3802835941314697,
-0.4322326183319092,
0.17851293087005615,
-0.5949892997741699,
-0.2976131737232208,
0.0030167896766215563,
-0.1419089138507843,
-0.9710175395011902,
0.11360269784927368,
0.4155735373497009,
0.499246746301651,
-0.11582157015800476,
0.2618391513824463,
-0.4982752799987793,
-0.13231387734413147,
0.35723403096199036,
-0.39747512340545654,
0.7990230917930603,
0.32427918910980225,
-0.41639384627342224,
0.013923991471529007,
-0.9016420245170593,
0.07973037660121918,
0.11901991814374924,
0.16568836569786072,
-0.7738577127456665,
0.06056346744298935,
-0.36177554726600647,
-0.2089066356420517,
0.17311322689056396,
-0.9561108350753784,
0.06248633936047554,
-0.4285326302051544,
0.3819418251514435,
0.6454340815544128,
0.07919961214065552,
0.6098827123641968,
0.09814102947711945,
0.41523540019989014,
0.1424860954284668,
0.5029746294021606,
-0.1446441262960434,
-0.7260477542877197,
-0.6587615013122559,
-0.3076320290565491,
0.3913116753101349,
0.5410757660865784,
-0.3606380820274353,
0.4867246448993683,
-0.16938182711601257,
-0.34678035974502563,
-0.8681129217147827,
0.006641913205385208,
0.6187044382095337,
0.5638046860694885,
0.04215147718787193,
-0.20442834496498108,
-0.37670278549194336,
-1.1760907173156738,
-0.3611069321632385,
0.02459162101149559,
0.02156587690114975,
0.45607584714889526,
0.15949204564094543,
-0.3104915916919708,
1.1355700492858887,
-0.571689784526825,
-0.3135437071323395,
-0.13441281020641327,
0.23648786544799805,
0.05109351873397827,
0.6912641525268555,
0.3437442183494568,
-0.7132053375244141,
-0.20693852007389069,
-0.0003983250935561955,
-0.6741589903831482,
-0.3690279722213745,
0.06214102357625961,
-0.29059502482414246,
0.18657980859279633,
0.4856541156768799,
-0.06615374982357025,
0.9225001931190491,
0.6896738409996033,
-0.4427775740623474,
0.06660657376050949,
-0.261282354593277,
0.133229061961174,
-0.8612494468688965,
-0.010413629934191704,
-0.17195650935173035,
-0.5349889993667603,
-0.8742457628250122,
0.22025670111179352,
0.043239228427410126,
-0.19899308681488037,
-0.3441612124443054,
0.4406081438064575,
-0.5738725662231445,
-0.04019035026431084,
-0.18099462985992432,
-0.10473788529634476,
-0.13088840246200562,
0.4802388846874237,
0.07552354037761688,
0.7862831950187683,
0.7033219933509827,
-0.5600058436393738,
-0.5758377909660339,
0.11953969299793243,
-0.43042007088661194,
0.21386542916297913,
-0.3560093343257904,
0.6205269694328308,
-0.14069144427776337,
-0.34038445353507996,
-0.6451233625411987,
0.1353018581867218,
0.4646131694316864,
-0.28568676114082336,
-0.1134876012802124,
-0.16157987713813782,
-0.5807839035987854,
0.0480923056602478,
-0.24807804822921753,
0.2514496147632599,
0.6012159585952759,
-0.4174050986766815,
0.698830246925354,
0.42692336440086365,
-0.02044893056154251,
-0.5241766571998596,
-0.9566146731376648,
0.012228339910507202,
-0.12281201034784317,
-0.3180225193500519,
0.31033390760421753,
-0.3001261353492737,
-0.36995774507522583,
0.1907166689634323,
-0.10415101796388626,
-0.44576263427734375,
0.36073362827301025,
0.6470500826835632,
0.16922339797019958,
-0.20010466873645782,
-0.4538472592830658,
0.25007811188697815,
-0.1796870231628418,
-0.10560313612222672,
0.03100748173892498,
0.41451534628868103,
-0.07165326923131943,
-0.5080443620681763,
-0.871701180934906,
0.6075400114059448,
0.25089019536972046,
-0.4936632215976715,
1.1281445026397705,
0.16011358797550201,
-0.41922178864479065,
-0.2806164622306824,
-0.7562020421028137,
-0.15241265296936035,
-0.47332221269607544,
-0.033514607697725296,
-0.1625714898109436,
-0.9076931476593018,
0.3954693675041199,
0.05427933856844902,
0.27268463373184204,
-0.12820793688297272,
0.1713455468416214,
0.12375615537166595,
0.8757096529006958,
0.6246143579483032,
-0.18768011033535004,
0.47585463523864746,
-0.21101392805576324,
0.5118144750595093,
-0.7320136427879333,
-0.12095256894826889,
-0.6698566675186157,
0.07752390950918198,
-0.3054133951663971,
-0.18560823798179626,
0.06490674614906311,
0.27371931076049805,
0.14932216703891754,
0.052504416555166245,
-0.19028662145137787,
0.5283318758010864,
0.5878671407699585,
0.3921053111553192,
0.6886952519416809,
0.27053505182266235,
0.2880324125289917,
0.07829783856868744,
-0.357334703207016,
-0.5679064393043518,
0.9903350472450256,
0.26447826623916626,
0.5197354555130005,
0.35696932673454285,
1.079672932624817,
0.10784216970205307,
0.2738516926765442,
-0.5439769625663757,
0.7264816164970398,
-0.0036391355097293854,
-0.2569219172000885,
-0.2709698975086212,
-0.5472084879875183,
-0.9679267406463623,
0.4026664197444916,
-0.02454318292438984,
-1.3472237586975098,
0.35223814845085144,
0.03558843582868576,
-0.3773886263370514,
0.32058292627334595,
-0.782063364982605,
0.676917314529419,
0.12997768819332123,
-0.6781257390975952,
-0.10186073184013367,
-0.30213624238967896,
0.5492119193077087,
0.052826039493083954,
0.6514555215835571,
-0.03720638155937195,
0.02432883158326149,
0.48743340373039246,
-0.5749858021736145,
0.8477287888526917,
-0.1435997039079666,
-0.06444644927978516,
0.12821225821971893,
0.05115139111876488,
0.40589696168899536,
0.22876299917697906,
-0.2772436738014221,
0.3303530812263489,
-0.2756132185459137,
-0.33125025033950806,
-0.593762218952179,
0.6346709132194519,
-0.4126174747943878,
-0.7654845118522644,
-0.3263717591762543,
-0.5188926458358765,
-0.4256395697593689,
0.3943096101284027,
-0.033358585089445114,
0.26657891273498535,
-0.13654345273971558,
0.18600040674209595,
0.6533176302909851,
-0.18041953444480896,
0.7009297609329224,
0.8983301520347595,
-0.36697858572006226,
-0.10323726385831833,
0.6919448971748352,
-0.130776509642601,
0.4717399477958679,
0.14914099872112274,
0.37575411796569824,
-0.11419382691383362,
-0.9952439665794373,
-0.3687145411968231,
0.2531694769859314,
-0.21941018104553223,
0.0751638114452362,
-0.6203723549842834,
-0.11350733041763306,
-0.3984612822532654,
0.15151502192020416,
-0.31963467597961426,
-0.13448278605937958,
-0.15050210058689117,
-0.0036164247430860996,
0.162873312830925,
0.4865718483924866,
-0.03156038746237755,
0.298739492893219,
-0.4639744460582733,
0.586999237537384,
0.23062288761138916,
0.6169410943984985,
-0.05163418501615524,
-0.2526380121707916,
-0.0509507842361927,
0.16269375383853912,
0.10402491688728333,
-0.7522816061973572,
0.23702718317508698,
0.23096585273742676,
0.48200523853302,
0.6197662353515625,
0.1783601939678192,
0.769767701625824,
-0.49847549200057983,
0.5797438621520996,
-0.33123648166656494,
-0.8674466609954834,
0.5704320669174194,
-0.013829094357788563,
0.2595791518688202,
0.6998764276504517,
-0.1986721307039261,
-0.16478325426578522,
-0.6652466058731079,
-0.8164587020874023,
-0.7910584807395935,
0.9267367720603943,
0.5792826414108276,
-0.031310997903347015,
0.16715383529663086,
0.3175046741962433,
0.1935974806547165,
0.29209867119789124,
-0.6589242219924927,
-0.5449283719062805,
0.1531938910484314,
0.020067179575562477,
0.031921736896038055,
-0.33857911825180054,
0.05604024976491928,
-0.06386452168226242,
0.7440723776817322,
0.16193777322769165,
0.05271703004837036,
0.0718860775232315,
-0.16853196918964386,
0.20308536291122437,
0.5611403584480286,
0.43440142273902893,
0.5307483673095703,
-0.29592159390449524,
-0.029565859586000443,
-0.07036460191011429,
-0.575322687625885,
-0.005834308452904224,
0.26966261863708496,
-0.6802495121955872,
-0.12224334478378296,
0.025131916627287865,
0.7469682097434998,
0.2137385755777359,
-0.6981796622276306,
0.35952451825141907,
-0.28751295804977417,
0.05006881430745125,
-0.1694873720407486,
0.26092854142189026,
-0.09278235584497452,
-0.028710132464766502,
0.1639033854007721,
-0.13448664546012878,
0.41827622056007385,
-0.5960320830345154,
-0.02488729916512966,
0.4541633725166321,
-0.2632046341896057,
-0.0031950194388628006,
0.6018996238708496,
-0.029846584424376488,
-0.45178812742233276,
0.34705135226249695,
-0.28711503744125366,
-0.07232492417097092,
0.39118650555610657,
0.45107656717300415,
1.070561170578003,
-0.523065447807312,
0.09345892071723938,
0.025226673111319542,
0.2980717718601227,
-0.020818039774894714,
0.32114213705062866,
-0.3363505005836487,
-0.6070141196250916,
-0.22125884890556335,
-0.46880581974983215,
-0.4529615342617035,
0.49582502245903015,
-1.035729169845581,
-0.261227011680603,
-0.5746191143989563,
0.19512097537517548,
0.0034082781057804823,
-0.5098135471343994,
-0.3487558364868164,
0.11136264353990555,
0.12030745297670364,
0.6489375233650208,
-0.47535422444343567,
0.8951507210731506,
0.3435858488082886,
-0.3219180405139923,
-0.370865136384964,
0.08967791497707367,
-0.04791654646396637,
-0.5492778420448303,
0.23315973579883575,
0.08432960510253906,
-0.36694973707199097,
-0.06428591161966324,
-0.4949299395084381,
-0.38288915157318115,
0.7121888399124146,
0.49784815311431885,
-0.6972054839134216,
0.33473819494247437,
0.479232519865036,
0.31229543685913086,
-0.18020421266555786,
-0.00400364026427269,
0.6589274406433105,
0.34158581495285034,
-0.44522374868392944,
-0.7023520469665527,
-0.01313637476414442,
-0.10176126658916473,
-0.02161448448896408,
0.06346804648637772,
-0.26074889302253723,
0.5148476362228394,
0.05619547888636589,
-0.37186431884765625,
0.2865627408027649,
0.917369544506073,
0.20058903098106384,
0.3696485161781311,
0.6122421026229858,
0.557282030582428,
0.6307764053344727,
0.08675086498260498,
1.2523770332336426,
-0.027390656992793083,
0.4426596462726593,
1.1345380544662476,
-0.2280193418264389,
0.90875244140625,
0.5402675271034241,
-0.07286252826452255,
0.3876873552799225,
0.26440173387527466,
0.31825992465019226,
0.6925703883171082,
0.09090960025787354,
-0.459378719329834,
-0.18010444939136505,
-0.25214695930480957,
-0.19794709980487823,
0.4967561960220337,
0.31373298168182373,
-0.4175415635108948,
-0.14818839728832245,
0.03797978535294533,
0.4255777597427368,
0.27567893266677856,
-0.2115752100944519,
0.9853119254112244,
-0.053822074085474014,
-0.5121152400970459,
0.41682448983192444,
0.10865108668804169,
0.5486473441123962,
-0.5142887234687805,
-0.014777777716517448,
-0.2390419989824295,
0.21499764919281006,
-0.1386232227087021,
-0.46679195761680603,
0.24590124189853668,
0.041454341262578964,
-0.18413814902305603,
-0.24105189740657806,
0.4373241364955902,
-0.4602775573730469,
-0.49699509143829346,
0.23115867376327515,
0.31764236092567444,
0.15202830731868744,
-0.10109329968690872,
-0.5266181230545044,
0.0282340869307518,
-0.001814700081013143,
-0.2739584147930145,
0.37562012672424316,
0.06986396014690399,
0.01180495135486126,
0.5671429634094238,
0.6103691458702087,
0.10682753473520279,
0.013282504864037037,
0.40253835916519165,
0.44967004656791687,
-0.35881203413009644,
-0.8350579738616943,
-0.898094892501831,
0.3561088442802429,
-0.37491095066070557,
-0.1276509016752243,
0.7697127461433411,
0.7224586009979248,
0.5960541367530823,
-0.04752272740006447,
0.8000463247299194,
0.22270572185516357,
0.5561336278915405,
-0.8003609776496887,
0.9981793165206909,
-0.32272785902023315,
0.359750896692276,
-0.2695249617099762,
-0.5058573484420776,
-0.3030815124511719,
0.3637895882129669,
-0.4608432352542877,
-0.08850690722465515,
0.5524216890335083,
0.8938540816307068,
-0.4397224485874176,
0.2449876368045807,
0.3482023775577545,
0.3655065596103668,
0.27306005358695984,
0.3027617931365967,
0.454452782869339,
-0.4065905213356018,
0.20744629204273224,
-0.8182119131088257,
-0.3288998603820801,
0.04125681892037392,
-0.947387158870697,
-0.9888725876808167,
-0.42371341586112976,
-0.513922393321991,
-0.06278324872255325,
0.2837030589580536,
0.22670519351959229,
0.940179705619812,
-0.9895992279052734,
-0.31995561718940735,
-0.24218882620334625,
0.05963728949427605,
-0.5258792042732239,
-0.1999601274728775,
0.4400708079338074,
0.0959797278046608,
-1.0425183773040771,
0.6311269998550415,
0.2651563882827759,
-0.03543464094400406,
-0.35260820388793945,
0.18896716833114624,
-0.31461286544799805,
0.08818106353282928,
0.3800137937068939,
0.46992048621177673,
-0.9078044295310974,
-0.16723540425300598,
-0.4437948763370514,
0.2004804164171219,
-0.043965503573417664,
0.6551458239555359,
-0.8596514463424683,
0.5618873238563538,
0.15756872296333313,
0.8874014616012573,
0.6099125146865845,
0.046976882964372635,
0.4916120767593384,
-0.7189649343490601,
0.5510596632957458,
0.013208216987550259,
0.507136881351471,
0.17265869677066803,
-0.5055330991744995,
0.40786439180374146,
-0.14917606115341187,
-0.28381335735321045,
-1.0178444385528564,
0.219266876578331,
-1.009110450744629,
-0.3752885162830353,
1.0330737829208374,
-0.3108568489551544,
-0.5672934055328369,
-0.3252091705799103,
-0.18175537884235382,
0.06427381932735443,
-0.6028491258621216,
0.7732111811637878,
0.29796934127807617,
-0.06528964638710022,
-0.45791447162628174,
-0.7456047534942627,
0.35297223925590515,
0.49582144618034363,
-1.241074800491333,
0.15074068307876587,
0.2647249698638916,
0.07773014903068542,
0.019905228167772293,
0.3603821098804474,
-0.12666207551956177,
0.042687561362981796,
-0.45165106654167175,
-0.0635455995798111,
-0.43285661935806274,
0.019883520901203156,
-0.4430910348892212,
0.2595489025115967,
-0.0565798357129097,
-0.7521273493766785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08219v2 | BBox-Adapter: Lightweight Adapting for Black-Box Large Language Models | 2024-02-13T05:15:46 | 2024-05-28T17:04:45 | Haotian Sun, Yuchen Zhuang, Wei Wei, Chao Zhang, Bo Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Adapting state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 and Gemini
for specific tasks is challenging. Due to the opacity in their parameters,
embeddings, and even output probabilities, existing fine-tuning adaptation
methods are inapplicable. Consequently, adapting these black-box LLMs is only
possible through their API services, raising concerns about transparency,
privacy, and cost. To address these challenges, we introduce BBox-Adapter, a
novel lightweight adapter for black-box LLMs. BBox-Adapter distinguishes target
and source domain data by treating target data as positive and source data as
negative. It employs a ranking-based Noise Contrastive Estimation (NCE) loss to
promote the likelihood of target domain data while penalizing that of the
source domain. Furthermore, it features an online adaptation mechanism, which
incorporates real-time positive data sampling from ground-truth, human, or AI
feedback, coupled with negative data from previous adaptations. Extensive
experiments demonstrate BBox-Adapter's effectiveness and cost efficiency. It
improves model performance by up to 6.77% across diverse tasks and domains,
while reducing training and inference costs by 31.30x and 1.84x, respectively. | [
-0.33670517802238464,
-0.6412824988365173,
0.47214841842651367,
0.23472419381141663,
-0.38358166813850403,
-0.045890990644693375,
-0.29679855704307556,
-0.5572290420532227,
-0.11507765203714371,
0.4852963089942932,
-0.46611177921295166,
-0.4659176766872406,
-0.39304623007774353,
-0.08160267025232315,
-0.0701853483915329,
0.9630411863327026,
0.2570376694202423,
-0.2550904154777527,
0.011749808676540852,
-0.07875297963619232,
-0.7898311614990234,
-0.10770945996046066,
-0.8230832815170288,
-0.10142450779676437,
0.328515887260437,
0.1584506779909134,
0.8048927783966064,
0.4050725996494293,
0.15353602170944214,
0.30830806493759155,
0.08218157291412354,
-0.1368025690317154,
-0.7146824598312378,
-0.06632129848003387,
-0.6853734850883484,
-0.6244446635246277,
-0.5395902991294861,
-0.5464326739311218,
0.5031756162643433,
0.5098822712898254,
-0.13607670366764069,
0.1412767767906189,
-0.031677424907684326,
0.5606170296669006,
-0.7348265647888184,
0.033341459929943085,
-1.1432284116744995,
-0.13750964403152466,
0.06830832362174988,
-0.03016068786382675,
-0.2846260964870453,
-0.10584522038698196,
-0.023185305297374725,
-0.5872771739959717,
0.14986519515514374,
0.23813971877098083,
0.620124876499176,
0.3552160859107971,
-0.11909108608961105,
-0.11879424005746841,
-0.7712270021438599,
0.8210647702217102,
-1.0020217895507812,
0.37336280941963196,
0.009488684125244617,
0.30906814336776733,
-0.18973052501678467,
-0.2625516355037689,
-0.47770920395851135,
-0.05197964608669281,
0.2644558548927307,
0.2615021765232086,
-0.4892340898513794,
-0.03732768073678017,
0.11956451833248138,
0.16321676969528198,
-0.4912601709365845,
0.2377776801586151,
-0.346021443605423,
-0.3110460937023163,
0.5423405170440674,
-0.06330621242523193,
0.19272729754447937,
0.11095882207155228,
-0.009761988185346127,
0.35718998312950134,
-0.6364439725875854,
-0.24044382572174072,
0.24794122576713562,
0.4361235201358795,
-0.388242244720459,
0.19093814492225647,
-0.22473052144050598,
0.916892409324646,
0.19705888628959656,
-0.25624969601631165,
0.24217933416366577,
-0.2522890269756317,
-0.03153219446539879,
0.23367710411548615,
0.5542249083518982,
0.41523435711860657,
-0.07576382905244827,
-0.4349208176136017,
-0.1941063106060028,
-0.010914487764239311,
0.37210458517074585,
-1.1930183172225952,
-0.14319634437561035,
0.2837117910385132,
-0.3263097107410431,
0.005811257287859917,
-0.27378517389297485,
-0.8797035217285156,
-0.40727633237838745,
-0.15160450339317322,
0.863910436630249,
-0.1250247359275818,
-0.30254727602005005,
0.4203508198261261,
-0.14014306664466858,
0.2358010858297348,
0.6775011420249939,
-0.7034014463424683,
0.46942973136901855,
0.5108432769775391,
0.9859089851379395,
-0.18528783321380615,
-0.07185205072164536,
-0.6551678776741028,
0.14563563466072083,
-0.2554630935192108,
0.7115991115570068,
-0.48668843507766724,
-0.2706567645072937,
-0.1875610500574112,
0.30416494607925415,
0.1166573017835617,
-0.6306030750274658,
0.6384572386741638,
-0.4141712188720703,
-0.044847868382930756,
0.12853164970874786,
-0.36340299248695374,
0.021409565582871437,
0.010810596868395805,
-0.43583476543426514,
0.9270568490028381,
0.36625930666923523,
-0.5955921411514282,
0.287473201751709,
-0.6091055870056152,
-0.3578060567378998,
0.20954732596874237,
0.26018208265304565,
-0.6783431768417358,
0.36761966347694397,
0.2933160960674286,
0.5807366371154785,
-0.2756184935569763,
-0.12463077157735825,
-0.8431529998779297,
-0.6520940065383911,
0.12083021551370621,
-0.16572445631027222,
0.6689750552177429,
0.17338575422763824,
-0.37845367193222046,
0.11368881911039352,
-1.0285691022872925,
-0.2760504484176636,
0.18893417716026306,
-0.209758922457695,
-0.5574936866760254,
0.1296311765909195,
0.02771928533911705,
0.26249563694000244,
0.19965261220932007,
-0.7128222584724426,
0.17573538422584534,
-0.33770328760147095,
0.4743160605430603,
0.791523277759552,
-0.23453111946582794,
0.4112022817134857,
-0.18892963230609894,
0.4621243476867676,
0.015084990300238132,
0.05258012190461159,
-0.037874460220336914,
-0.4889949560165405,
-0.5688911080360413,
-0.49028611183166504,
0.2610590159893036,
0.4751179814338684,
-0.6785579323768616,
0.6467633247375488,
-0.6052489280700684,
-0.6704862117767334,
-0.932506263256073,
0.4036378264427185,
0.09111348539590836,
0.3937147259712219,
0.3467116951942444,
-0.26401183009147644,
-0.17494000494480133,
-0.6184597611427307,
-0.03706475719809532,
0.10976352542638779,
-0.3192947804927826,
0.5632489323616028,
0.3967510759830475,
-0.47564753890037537,
0.7996469140052795,
-0.4770711064338684,
-0.1409749835729599,
-0.22741490602493286,
-0.20427173376083374,
0.42745885252952576,
0.3257584571838379,
0.8219796419143677,
-0.41613471508026123,
-0.41661760210990906,
0.18323969841003418,
-0.3973309099674225,
-0.3710451126098633,
-0.03497885912656784,
-0.15105728805065155,
-0.033125683665275574,
0.3323153257369995,
-0.2873042821884155,
0.10780337452888489,
1.1490886211395264,
-0.45009225606918335,
0.4589184522628784,
-0.24630887806415558,
-0.28974318504333496,
-1.2767424583435059,
-0.1043865755200386,
0.031056175008416176,
-0.42316731810569763,
-0.5220261216163635,
-0.197626993060112,
0.2584855258464813,
-0.30303284525871277,
-0.40331101417541504,
0.8292021155357361,
-0.35319268703460693,
-0.1536877155303955,
-0.6520602703094482,
0.2714698910713196,
0.036554522812366486,
0.3150477409362793,
-0.019383681938052177,
0.8900765776634216,
0.8148307204246521,
-0.5571383833885193,
0.19690340757369995,
0.05427560955286026,
-0.2089386135339737,
0.707481861114502,
-0.5449849367141724,
0.17894421517848969,
-0.16085347533226013,
0.18402858078479767,
-0.8076842427253723,
0.1806471347808838,
0.29212984442710876,
-0.05757952854037285,
0.15309599041938782,
-0.6347402930259705,
-0.120020791888237,
-0.10507737100124359,
-0.49107322096824646,
0.35904645919799805,
0.5198556780815125,
-0.6367052793502808,
0.8186269998550415,
0.18408270180225372,
-0.5017282962799072,
-0.5045684576034546,
-0.6729740500450134,
0.17691515386104584,
-0.126722514629364,
-0.268035888671875,
0.434598445892334,
-0.46347352862358093,
0.14023412764072418,
0.2978940010070801,
-0.3642975687980652,
-0.017503205686807632,
0.2832772433757782,
0.19724752008914948,
0.39117980003356934,
-0.46566179394721985,
-0.2165890783071518,
0.15462861955165863,
-0.012989208102226257,
-0.016149181872606277,
-0.5562968850135803,
0.27406713366508484,
0.1733272522687912,
-0.14768503606319427,
-0.19214364886283875,
0.02704573981463909,
0.4921703040599823,
0.05289378762245178,
0.9346629977226257,
0.8420237898826599,
-0.43809956312179565,
-0.597621738910675,
-0.5209398865699768,
-0.059393707662820816,
-0.548196017742157,
0.7162547707557678,
-0.3328499495983124,
-0.9366242289543152,
0.305580735206604,
-0.15205524861812592,
-0.02127193845808506,
0.08547177910804749,
0.7108204364776611,
0.37619829177856445,
0.5233793258666992,
0.5739424228668213,
-0.44098106026649475,
0.6522474884986877,
0.28864505887031555,
0.2689727544784546,
-0.890630841255188,
0.3030632734298706,
-0.5783872604370117,
-0.14886315166950226,
-0.6173223257064819,
-0.3843989372253418,
0.09481532871723175,
0.0031605027616024017,
0.048458587378263474,
0.37664031982421875,
-0.554044783115387,
0.35665592551231384,
0.3234471082687378,
0.29744765162467957,
0.22518141567707062,
-0.1403890997171402,
0.3578040599822998,
0.07341808080673218,
-0.5804005861282349,
-0.057413250207901,
1.2723842859268188,
0.30115950107574463,
1.0519928932189941,
0.3944213092327118,
0.4547502398490906,
0.14983905851840973,
0.5599477887153625,
-0.8484246730804443,
0.4248605966567993,
-0.1738462746143341,
-0.6903765797615051,
-0.14845259487628937,
-0.7476836442947388,
-0.9528124928474426,
0.3648234009742737,
-0.5801518559455872,
-0.7459878921508789,
0.23026317358016968,
0.21055454015731812,
-0.18150594830513,
0.24655702710151672,
-0.9005835056304932,
0.9190078973770142,
-0.3114473819732666,
-0.7133824229240417,
-0.12226516753435135,
-0.09647451341152191,
0.2170659303665161,
-0.48812103271484375,
0.5926003456115723,
-0.34840404987335205,
-0.27072837948799133,
0.5310250520706177,
0.028165491297841072,
0.8703597784042358,
-0.43772080540657043,
-0.06130295619368553,
-0.014966716058552265,
0.08010878413915634,
0.709851861000061,
0.19003130495548248,
-0.18107500672340393,
0.3565741777420044,
-0.1141844317317009,
-0.587052583694458,
-0.6211181282997131,
0.793077290058136,
-0.9055621027946472,
-0.5242841839790344,
-0.2667660415172577,
-0.7653143405914307,
-0.2649075984954834,
0.4438757598400116,
-0.27554425597190857,
0.3573603332042694,
-0.06513376533985138,
0.41583341360092163,
0.5282528400421143,
-0.4570194482803345,
0.2066241353750229,
0.9504666328430176,
-0.1877741515636444,
-0.45637834072113037,
1.1874868869781494,
-0.10222718864679337,
0.40274983644485474,
0.6625314354896545,
0.40399879217147827,
-0.2673257887363434,
-1.2689093351364136,
-0.3553543984889984,
0.4721238613128662,
-0.5110278129577637,
-0.22434061765670776,
-0.46635472774505615,
-0.11818760633468628,
-0.21269889175891876,
-0.37273865938186646,
-0.37396037578582764,
-0.3123556673526764,
-0.16476355493068695,
0.11294643580913544,
0.350189745426178,
0.344914972782135,
0.3195468485355377,
0.43107786774635315,
-0.5068548917770386,
0.5202342867851257,
0.4592668116092682,
0.6044015288352966,
-0.27723240852355957,
-0.8788379430770874,
-0.4821476638317108,
-0.356619656085968,
-0.2692072093486786,
-0.5825332403182983,
0.19902394711971283,
0.44826099276542664,
0.33704274892807007,
0.11664635688066483,
0.1881987601518631,
0.7884881496429443,
-0.5995993614196777,
0.47050631046295166,
-0.008119391277432442,
-0.9330251216888428,
0.25139039754867554,
-0.2766532599925995,
0.531466543674469,
0.3074031174182892,
0.16370455920696259,
-0.20941941440105438,
-0.3332037031650543,
-0.09891292452812195,
-0.782293975353241,
0.7727193236351013,
0.09671832621097565,
0.24898384511470795,
0.40447351336479187,
0.6631371974945068,
0.13999353349208832,
0.23048442602157593,
-0.9632130861282349,
-0.19660510122776031,
-0.5472602248191833,
-0.5211106538772583,
-0.32459038496017456,
-0.09330155700445175,
0.08660636842250824,
-0.002941855462267995,
0.6962063312530518,
-0.4774056375026703,
0.3172580301761627,
-0.10700974613428116,
-0.3032533824443817,
-0.13944919407367706,
0.6443073749542236,
0.3427584171295166,
0.6362429261207581,
-0.4387770891189575,
-0.03257332742214203,
0.4776422083377838,
-0.46437275409698486,
-0.10599297285079956,
0.4738282263278961,
-0.2765083909034729,
-0.08105161041021347,
0.24777717888355255,
0.9076041579246521,
0.5344883799552917,
-0.694075882434845,
0.5245987176895142,
-0.0657958835363388,
-0.1368907392024994,
0.04193564131855965,
0.3812153935432434,
0.369382381439209,
0.16917890310287476,
0.22335021197795868,
0.18754573166370392,
0.28127506375312805,
-0.6278707981109619,
-0.07159550487995148,
0.661117434501648,
-0.21525532007217407,
-0.5629165768623352,
0.6849607825279236,
0.34138426184654236,
-0.2613239288330078,
-0.011296991258859634,
-0.0979984849691391,
-0.08287180960178375,
0.10857455432415009,
0.9271554350852966,
0.7620556354522705,
-0.35810407996177673,
-0.0936959832906723,
0.2642313241958618,
0.3492814898490906,
0.09029487520456314,
0.07116251438856125,
0.11849302798509598,
-0.9512021541595459,
-0.5921760201454163,
-0.7487443685531616,
-0.5573122501373291,
0.24465084075927734,
-0.5315061211585999,
0.40171122550964355,
-0.5627607703208923,
0.008617340587079525,
0.07922777533531189,
-0.09471576660871506,
-0.7218838334083557,
0.06931108981370926,
0.22659209370613098,
0.9156433939933777,
-0.689376711845398,
0.8960868716239929,
0.5389934778213501,
0.07505924254655838,
-0.25944942235946655,
-0.07613368332386017,
-0.03267093002796173,
-0.9652199745178223,
-0.1545131355524063,
0.003780184080824256,
-0.171281635761261,
0.19435685873031616,
-0.17718565464019775,
-0.7054548859596252,
1.1148359775543213,
0.8328647017478943,
-0.8468246459960938,
0.1410234421491623,
-0.05977310240268707,
0.3310069143772125,
-0.25941339135169983,
0.35142117738723755,
0.3312108814716339,
0.3981437087059021,
-0.23003125190734863,
-0.827427089214325,
0.44687342643737793,
-0.08690368384122849,
0.02913316898047924,
0.23052792251110077,
-0.6766617298126221,
0.38519087433815,
-0.011909639462828636,
0.15834225714206696,
-0.18358628451824188,
0.40376004576683044,
0.21453453600406647,
0.20496053993701935,
0.5800443887710571,
0.29905059933662415,
0.5347310304641724,
0.004827169701457024,
0.7928012609481812,
-0.319307804107666,
0.23525221645832062,
0.9163407683372498,
-0.5001623630523682,
0.8180946707725525,
0.2426711618900299,
-0.25731486082077026,
0.47285622358322144,
0.10500534623861313,
-0.17851971089839935,
0.5058258771896362,
0.034275513142347336,
-0.26120150089263916,
-0.08627399057149887,
0.10878991335630417,
-0.25350484251976013,
-0.021984344348311424,
0.5299149751663208,
0.06954062730073929,
-0.09950118511915207,
-0.1730017066001892,
0.04063577577471733,
-0.15689416229724884,
-0.5702776908874512,
0.8379623293876648,
0.10000390559434891,
-0.4093032777309418,
0.603158175945282,
0.08334773033857346,
0.9013839364051819,
-0.7743316292762756,
0.09995543956756592,
0.03837869316339493,
0.4402623474597931,
-0.30155500769615173,
-0.491962194442749,
0.13738884031772614,
-0.12391819804906845,
-0.08888567984104156,
0.20804330706596375,
0.8111611604690552,
-0.38067948818206787,
-0.6637297868728638,
0.645717203617096,
0.33905112743377686,
-0.24879218637943268,
-0.25936806201934814,
-1.0947285890579224,
0.49099552631378174,
-0.13149693608283997,
-0.0748550295829773,
0.7095292806625366,
0.571823000907898,
0.23021529614925385,
0.6917965412139893,
0.7704370021820068,
0.39599716663360596,
0.12145263701677322,
-0.01080328319221735,
0.9084639549255371,
-0.8818395733833313,
-0.4018034040927887,
-0.533765435218811,
0.4991346001625061,
0.024128753691911697,
-0.04139101132750511,
0.6433883309364319,
0.4967179596424103,
0.7613334655761719,
-0.11413045972585678,
1.1072719097137451,
0.18542107939720154,
0.40905725955963135,
-0.5917751789093018,
0.38841375708580017,
-0.6578480005264282,
0.29735469818115234,
-0.40852805972099304,
-0.9415308833122253,
-0.24691522121429443,
0.3620363771915436,
-0.2829759418964386,
0.0050726947374641895,
0.520036518573761,
1.026057481765747,
-0.4535474479198456,
-0.34051641821861267,
0.5261958837509155,
0.5288012623786926,
0.39199569821357727,
0.4715521037578583,
0.3474448621273041,
-0.42171844840049744,
0.9211480617523193,
-0.15512524545192719,
-0.4919813275337219,
-0.49340084195137024,
-1.0229171514511108,
-1.1472389698028564,
-0.014544361270964146,
-0.4374525845050812,
-0.2514331042766571,
0.3643515706062317,
0.8783732056617737,
1.043838381767273,
-0.9839770197868347,
-0.16074547171592712,
0.001340055139735341,
0.08716973662376404,
-0.4110569655895233,
-0.2410658746957779,
0.2577093839645386,
-0.2081272155046463,
-0.7082380652427673,
0.5286127924919128,
0.4069715738296509,
-0.19253693521022797,
0.1261005848646164,
-0.18964463472366333,
0.4373381435871124,
0.1687668114900589,
0.612392008304596,
0.26792868971824646,
-0.650401771068573,
-0.3240620493888855,
-0.45088815689086914,
0.32767075300216675,
0.15383630990982056,
0.5004416704177856,
-0.5338124632835388,
0.5947485566139221,
-0.09522861242294312,
1.0541598796844482,
0.6047147512435913,
-0.06635034084320068,
0.4384269118309021,
-0.5102890729904175,
0.4358842968940735,
-0.03808506205677986,
0.5545310378074646,
0.4120986759662628,
-0.2757136821746826,
0.07293853163719177,
0.2858867347240448,
-0.5940355658531189,
-0.851805567741394,
0.15329720079898834,
-1.3297017812728882,
-0.31394174695014954,
1.054850459098816,
-0.07395686209201813,
-0.37624499201774597,
-0.44343212246894836,
-0.44019925594329834,
-0.18570587038993835,
-0.7748491168022156,
0.8726336359977722,
0.45986396074295044,
0.2541086673736572,
-0.4818839728832245,
-0.69996577501297,
0.07060784101486206,
0.05267214775085449,
-0.923811674118042,
0.03875633329153061,
0.2974572777748108,
0.7277973890304565,
-0.021499477326869965,
0.47360295057296753,
0.0760786384344101,
0.24377425014972687,
0.020100202411413193,
0.12061205506324768,
-0.12048204988241196,
0.10233321785926819,
-0.48863130807876587,
0.06371870636940002,
0.4464319348335266,
0.05217410996556282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08183v1 | Pixel Sentence Representation Learning | 2024-02-13T02:46:45 | 2024-02-13T02:46:45 | Chenghao Xiao, Zhuoxu Huang, Danlu Chen, G Thomas Hudson, Yizhi Li, Haoran Duan, Chenghua Lin, Jie Fu, Jungong Han, Noura Al Moubayed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Pretrained language models are long known to be subpar in capturing sentence
and document-level semantics. Though heavily investigated, transferring
perturbation-based methods from unsupervised visual representation learning to
NLP remains an unsolved problem. This is largely due to the discreteness of
subword units brought by tokenization of language models, limiting small
perturbations of inputs to form semantics-preserved positive pairs. In this
work, we conceptualize the learning of sentence-level textual semantics as a
visual representation learning process. Drawing from cognitive and linguistic
sciences, we introduce an unsupervised visual sentence representation learning
framework, employing visually-grounded text perturbation methods like typos and
word order shuffling, resonating with human cognitive patterns, and enabling
perturbation to texts to be perceived as continuous. Our approach is further
bolstered by large-scale unsupervised topical alignment training and natural
language inference supervision, achieving comparable performance in semantic
textual similarity (STS) to existing state-of-the-art NLP methods.
Additionally, we unveil our method's inherent zero-shot cross-lingual
transferability and a unique leapfrogging pattern across languages during
iterative training. To our knowledge, this is the first representation learning
method devoid of traditional language models for understanding sentence and
document semantics, marking a stride closer to human-like textual
comprehension. Our code is available at
https://github.com/gowitheflow-1998/Pixel-Linguist | [
-0.08232779055833817,
-0.8441795706748962,
0.6287082433700562,
0.20379820466041565,
-0.5352878570556641,
0.03663913533091545,
-0.16190865635871887,
-0.000864238478243351,
0.1878754049539566,
0.6950697898864746,
-0.7112053036689758,
-0.9055081009864807,
-0.5865514278411865,
-0.15020637214183807,
-0.4409644305706024,
0.7426562905311584,
0.17799222469329834,
0.08389194309711456,
-0.4066110849380493,
0.07844263315200806,
-0.42093899846076965,
-0.4998096823692322,
-0.22455479204654694,
-0.203043133020401,
0.49153608083724976,
0.3653188645839691,
0.5801368951797485,
0.3819692134857178,
0.4271913468837738,
0.2719743251800537,
0.08884219825267792,
-0.3177328407764435,
-0.5179390907287598,
0.009213561192154884,
-0.11650350689888,
-0.49334561824798584,
0.1630813032388687,
0.05523453652858734,
0.5251278877258301,
0.7568591237068176,
-0.07115005701780319,
-0.07580585777759552,
-0.08277973532676697,
0.4935712516307831,
-0.601922333240509,
0.11516052484512329,
-0.8214454650878906,
0.4306046962738037,
-0.2558262050151825,
-0.5334965586662292,
-0.6841554641723633,
0.1711973249912262,
0.09837263822555542,
-0.7891454100608826,
0.12584072351455688,
-0.03283564746379852,
0.9742826819419861,
0.4435172379016876,
-0.40117356181144714,
-0.09449458867311478,
-0.21462158858776093,
0.558669924736023,
-0.5042560696601868,
0.14860929548740387,
0.23312240839004517,
0.021705368533730507,
-0.2039748877286911,
-0.999048113822937,
-0.5512966513633728,
-0.13801969587802887,
0.031902458518743515,
0.3278261125087738,
-0.07213428616523743,
-0.08828268200159073,
0.3052816390991211,
0.2362755835056305,
-0.4508586525917053,
0.16833800077438354,
-0.01824202574789524,
-0.13690760731697083,
0.17878134548664093,
0.04531148821115494,
0.7127047777175903,
-0.5249986052513123,
-0.8193963766098022,
-0.3245108425617218,
-0.685155987739563,
0.12496049702167511,
0.02404499426484108,
0.06095912680029869,
-0.09353331476449966,
0.7040591239929199,
0.15740348398685455,
0.5025067329406738,
-0.14218290150165558,
0.40802907943725586,
0.1250247210264206,
-0.25311094522476196,
-0.29459473490715027,
-0.06389010697603226,
0.9918147921562195,
0.2454029768705368,
0.520499587059021,
-0.23149612545967102,
0.039214618504047394,
0.30153363943099976,
0.48419898748397827,
-0.672151505947113,
-0.31176450848579407,
-0.30353933572769165,
-0.31746429204940796,
-0.24215324223041534,
0.2571616470813751,
-0.8866721391677856,
-0.42836296558380127,
-0.26139652729034424,
0.36400604248046875,
-0.7388442158699036,
0.019821209833025932,
0.3271261155605316,
-0.053436897695064545,
0.18445713818073273,
0.26357099413871765,
-0.9612626433372498,
0.2294243574142456,
0.3895292580127716,
0.593782365322113,
0.04051903635263443,
-0.4820801019668579,
-0.507561445236206,
-0.05579399690032005,
-0.5190262794494629,
0.8823779821395874,
-0.6314313411712646,
-0.3482290506362915,
0.09002026170492172,
-0.11820020526647568,
0.004452537279576063,
-0.23075103759765625,
0.2850295901298523,
-0.433246910572052,
0.2729785740375519,
0.05825839191675186,
-0.5618910789489746,
-0.17005227506160736,
-0.0037250788882374763,
-0.36593201756477356,
0.8257625699043274,
-0.017246710136532784,
-0.8857703804969788,
0.5402476787567139,
-0.3538283705711365,
-0.1273542195558548,
0.28215211629867554,
-0.4391400218009949,
-0.33710548281669617,
0.22748985886573792,
0.517784059047699,
0.6286925077438354,
0.11737339198589325,
-0.0606205053627491,
-0.18148837983608246,
-0.4449886083602905,
0.06650698930025101,
-0.30286705493927,
0.7564367651939392,
-0.2164541780948639,
-0.24740351736545563,
0.4980757534503937,
-0.7545382976531982,
0.04014291986823082,
0.10365287214517593,
0.010359327308833599,
-0.4706231355667114,
-0.050304342061281204,
0.37132537364959717,
0.23048031330108643,
0.03725980967283249,
-0.5929559469223022,
0.2531912326812744,
-0.38020265102386475,
0.572722852230072,
0.5497627258300781,
0.16977690160274506,
0.6096205115318298,
0.1952304244041443,
0.46503156423568726,
0.2242935448884964,
-0.3403484523296356,
-0.6459326148033142,
-0.271022766828537,
-0.7359488010406494,
-0.3320103883743286,
0.45666754245758057,
0.3769865334033966,
-1.0888680219650269,
0.3766562044620514,
-0.3681362271308899,
-0.06859324872493744,
-0.2651583254337311,
0.0939883142709732,
0.30815717577934265,
0.37854981422424316,
0.5110092163085938,
-0.306389182806015,
-0.37064844369888306,
-0.5488974452018738,
-0.27108824253082275,
-0.06472331285476685,
0.006836759392172098,
-0.23005059361457825,
0.5898180603981018,
-0.33281639218330383,
0.9499694108963013,
-0.2799448072910309,
-0.57200026512146,
-0.11557522416114807,
0.6561372876167297,
-0.04401281848549843,
0.45893946290016174,
0.5469536781311035,
-0.7801443338394165,
-0.33264875411987305,
-0.12168125063180923,
-0.7160168290138245,
-0.03995547443628311,
-0.36771252751350403,
-0.05996428802609444,
0.3780680298805237,
0.9755915999412537,
-0.48473507165908813,
0.8217243552207947,
0.4434032738208771,
-0.8234798312187195,
0.2079603374004364,
-0.3853517770767212,
0.02859645150601864,
-0.9763936996459961,
-0.2200668603181839,
0.17246270179748535,
-0.4885452687740326,
-0.20000556111335754,
0.08160530030727386,
0.15819916129112244,
-0.2537636458873749,
-0.3927702307701111,
0.3239259719848633,
-0.5365882515907288,
-0.12638504803180695,
-0.1232396736741066,
0.13306453824043274,
-0.2832740247249603,
0.6446470022201538,
0.27245959639549255,
0.5491083264350891,
0.7252737283706665,
-0.2951354384422302,
0.20656663179397583,
0.49235692620277405,
-0.3845427930355072,
0.47091469168663025,
-0.4418998956680298,
0.005372584331780672,
-0.31958651542663574,
0.15918117761611938,
-1.060276985168457,
0.0009988478850573301,
0.09436898678541183,
-0.638447642326355,
0.24532514810562134,
-0.05332192778587341,
-0.5918959379196167,
0.02143254689872265,
-0.14994347095489502,
0.2680272161960602,
0.46825528144836426,
-0.5144157409667969,
0.4404832422733307,
0.08225581049919128,
0.03788164258003235,
-0.5751587748527527,
-0.911748468875885,
0.4285769760608673,
0.10060690343379974,
-0.3995947241783142,
0.46701356768608093,
0.44664859771728516,
0.1355653703212738,
0.21988607943058014,
-0.13654881715774536,
0.13669927418231964,
-0.16618598997592926,
0.3414374887943268,
0.33317968249320984,
-0.1415828913450241,
0.38858646154403687,
-0.20984452962875366,
-0.41081199049949646,
-0.0003424380556680262,
-0.4318484961986542,
0.5990553498268127,
-0.07174838334321976,
-0.35200703144073486,
-0.4171122908592224,
0.2824575901031494,
0.3682909905910492,
-0.342887282371521,
0.5186863541603088,
0.6321364045143127,
-0.3239891529083252,
-0.2688540816307068,
-0.14040115475654602,
0.035660769790410995,
-0.34050917625427246,
0.5146008729934692,
-0.4287635385990143,
-0.787859320640564,
0.16459757089614868,
-0.0689392015337944,
-0.2114197313785553,
0.49570369720458984,
0.3319851756095886,
-0.40030637383461,
0.49852973222732544,
1.051279902458191,
0.17538130283355713,
0.6713061332702637,
-0.21159833669662476,
-0.05080670490860939,
-0.5096614956855774,
-0.20725855231285095,
-0.24576669931411743,
-0.1328607052564621,
-0.490451842546463,
-0.5451174378395081,
0.06392882764339447,
0.2026381641626358,
-0.3568020164966583,
0.36820289492607117,
-0.25100237131118774,
0.3749576210975647,
0.5101007223129272,
0.27049294114112854,
0.20067176222801208,
0.4226823151111603,
-0.48855331540107727,
-0.5657119750976562,
-0.647246778011322,
-0.49035611748695374,
0.8281979560852051,
0.15743020176887512,
0.7927063703536987,
-0.19899316132068634,
0.6615569591522217,
0.20219720900058746,
-0.14773771166801453,
-0.8270842432975769,
0.6519216299057007,
-0.5966266989707947,
0.2068854719400406,
-0.2250126749277115,
-0.46645408868789673,
-0.8870244026184082,
0.2860448360443115,
-0.7649624347686768,
-0.9583021402359009,
0.23194141685962677,
-0.20013202726840973,
-0.03284408152103424,
0.25957754254341125,
-0.692282497882843,
1.1362292766571045,
-0.21320559084415436,
-0.4108547866344452,
-0.1635151207447052,
-0.6536470651626587,
-0.18269230425357819,
0.25432470440864563,
-0.1435772031545639,
0.18427561223506927,
-0.16918635368347168,
0.3863927125930786,
-0.3379950225353241,
1.0046319961547852,
-0.09503719955682755,
0.007514593657106161,
-0.025793395936489105,
0.17395028471946716,
0.09232298284769058,
0.010067645460367203,
0.38836219906806946,
0.1178165152668953,
0.10635789483785629,
-0.6174730062484741,
-0.6386573314666748,
0.5662473440170288,
-0.6586302518844604,
-0.3546329438686371,
-0.52219158411026,
-0.46030646562576294,
-0.2819932699203491,
0.36056843400001526,
0.5466864705085754,
0.387173593044281,
-0.2065870612859726,
0.3896041214466095,
0.6623165011405945,
-0.3604317307472229,
0.6318832635879517,
0.04060092195868492,
-0.5174105763435364,
-0.3482224941253662,
0.7280208468437195,
-0.09808162599802017,
0.00690457783639431,
0.862887978553772,
-0.06688316911458969,
-0.33178138732910156,
-0.48359405994415283,
-0.2651447653770447,
0.09153463691473007,
-0.866702675819397,
0.09598954021930695,
-0.530627965927124,
-0.10497984290122986,
-0.26948124170303345,
-0.23859091103076935,
-0.07691977918148041,
-0.22609388828277588,
-0.5670873522758484,
-0.02975558117032051,
0.13904213905334473,
0.6482416391372681,
0.44078803062438965,
0.37850096821784973,
-0.6444064974784851,
0.5040184855461121,
0.08068486303091049,
0.3045264184474945,
-0.31774893403053284,
-0.40448275208473206,
0.18098720908164978,
-0.10321886837482452,
-0.19328752160072327,
-0.8159052729606628,
0.43447232246398926,
0.12366291135549545,
0.3210149109363556,
0.2778092920780182,
-0.09889073669910431,
0.8261995315551758,
-0.5019816756248474,
0.855717122554779,
0.6487403512001038,
-1.1478605270385742,
0.5781459212303162,
-0.3706672191619873,
0.628505527973175,
0.46136602759361267,
0.28992560505867004,
-0.6521664261817932,
-0.1637476682662964,
-0.5903334617614746,
-0.8468089699745178,
0.4822726547718048,
0.1272774636745453,
0.33951371908187866,
0.06803089380264282,
0.45351818203926086,
-0.09186526387929916,
0.10016775131225586,
-1.0622072219848633,
0.10949251055717468,
-0.625636875629425,
-0.4846299886703491,
-0.3087300658226013,
-0.2402663379907608,
0.30696263909339905,
-0.24103032052516937,
0.35373857617378235,
-0.35463544726371765,
0.21567358076572418,
0.37792864441871643,
-0.590622067451477,
0.08483491092920303,
0.2538645267486572,
0.2345643937587738,
0.547694742679596,
0.07645079493522644,
0.29971185326576233,
-0.2643967270851135,
-0.3671722412109375,
-0.04022340103983879,
-0.11130136251449585,
-0.13361921906471252,
0.041380640119314194,
0.6225038766860962,
0.8662727475166321,
0.4808221459388733,
-0.5758272409439087,
0.7889522910118103,
-0.034409526735544205,
-0.27512356638908386,
-0.18040458858013153,
-0.28019005060195923,
0.09302125126123428,
0.05878937244415283,
0.36489802598953247,
0.1355663239955902,
-0.10905983299016953,
-0.749243438243866,
0.34589684009552,
0.42452019453048706,
-0.8370660543441772,
-0.031187567859888077,
0.6600207090377808,
0.011382773518562317,
-0.10544557124376297,
0.661386251449585,
0.07172967493534088,
-0.4541332721710205,
0.4762946665287018,
0.5405604243278503,
0.6051638722419739,
0.3502485156059265,
0.6603116393089294,
0.26246023178100586,
0.24924440681934357,
-0.04139029234647751,
0.0369158573448658,
-0.16572844982147217,
-0.6595478057861328,
-0.5108373165130615,
-0.49048393964767456,
-0.07629799842834473,
-0.09052444249391556,
-0.4692779779434204,
0.38070735335350037,
-0.6111235022544861,
0.013135467655956745,
-0.06857344508171082,
-0.17224353551864624,
-0.321243554353714,
0.22650130093097687,
0.38997822999954224,
0.8609617948532104,
-0.6044300198554993,
0.6780213713645935,
1.0583937168121338,
-0.7977526187896729,
-0.4485592544078827,
0.30018550157546997,
-0.15667115151882172,
-0.7123938202857971,
0.7798643708229065,
0.26217570900917053,
-0.14630024135112762,
0.2451411783695221,
-0.7967216372489929,
-0.3786877989768982,
0.8485420346260071,
0.5444782376289368,
-0.577549397945404,
-0.10108776390552521,
0.18339240550994873,
0.8329678773880005,
-0.4095412790775299,
0.1310764104127884,
-0.013494668528437614,
0.05548540875315666,
0.3323780596256256,
-0.23557910323143005,
0.08886433392763138,
-0.29151105880737305,
0.5010150671005249,
0.07970385253429413,
-0.13155502080917358,
0.6053910255432129,
-0.12560658156871796,
-0.5842599272727966,
0.2185835987329483,
0.7460829019546509,
-0.1908210963010788,
-0.08491846919059753,
0.2887366712093353,
0.763702392578125,
0.5398272275924683,
-0.3564874529838562,
1.013017177581787,
0.08026062697172165,
0.40593618154525757,
1.01044762134552,
0.08412675559520721,
1.0038899183273315,
0.8624637126922607,
0.04166732355952263,
0.8355807662010193,
0.6763970851898193,
-0.03425348177552223,
0.5198067426681519,
0.3128078579902649,
0.09360228478908539,
-0.4895814061164856,
0.189832866191864,
0.026167359203100204,
0.45844998955726624,
0.3190915584564209,
-0.3567253053188324,
-0.46186167001724243,
0.14411555230617523,
-0.3055465519428253,
0.6818138360977173,
-0.3959231674671173,
0.8719798922538757,
0.07116059958934784,
-0.429113507270813,
0.5193248987197876,
-0.2619718313217163,
0.8449691534042358,
-0.6052932739257812,
-0.2402838170528412,
0.09450086951255798,
0.1591074913740158,
-0.3032861351966858,
-0.8909599184989929,
0.15286807715892792,
-0.1665511280298233,
-0.09341703355312347,
-0.531858503818512,
0.6513833999633789,
-0.5650771856307983,
-0.518179178237915,
0.4118151366710663,
0.23805375397205353,
-0.10066335648298264,
-0.1010671928524971,
-0.45451095700263977,
-0.30960729718208313,
-0.05324815213680267,
-0.016869978979229927,
0.27015724778175354,
0.6399239897727966,
-0.08549866825342178,
0.5190026164054871,
0.3764699101448059,
0.13189268112182617,
0.23662221431732178,
0.2701468765735626,
0.5732767581939697,
-0.8759139776229858,
-0.5975219011306763,
-0.73126220703125,
0.6507267355918884,
-0.013049880973994732,
-0.42901304364204407,
0.4387645125389099,
0.09129036962985992,
0.9169036149978638,
-0.282595694065094,
0.4465828239917755,
0.07019364833831787,
-0.10705054551362991,
-1.0380438566207886,
0.712699830532074,
-0.5046724677085876,
0.1423891931772232,
-0.3813595473766327,
-0.8843566179275513,
-0.7136297821998596,
0.6806951761245728,
-0.34152743220329285,
-0.290831595659256,
1.0714316368103027,
0.4463961720466614,
-0.017113205045461655,
0.003925722558051348,
0.4788879156112671,
0.2165144681930542,
-0.011787839233875275,
0.4777427017688751,
0.8438986539840698,
-0.40215426683425903,
0.42061370611190796,
-0.06377138942480087,
-0.18088792264461517,
0.12986701726913452,
-1.002622365951538,
-0.9142124056816101,
-0.8230573534965515,
-0.36312612891197205,
-0.0622805692255497,
0.17320767045021057,
0.777999997138977,
0.5627855062484741,
-0.5197924375534058,
0.008233205415308475,
-0.7513279318809509,
-0.07549282163381577,
-0.09441017359495163,
-0.22413520514965057,
0.2695859968662262,
-0.8665637969970703,
-0.5566893815994263,
-0.0005264532519504428,
0.5011441111564636,
0.04633065685629845,
-0.18980760872364044,
0.30344969034194946,
-0.5063081383705139,
-0.22889269888401031,
0.6311282515525818,
0.06076265871524811,
-0.681617796421051,
-0.1279880404472351,
-0.0844775065779686,
-0.22374193370342255,
0.3427277207374573,
0.9347872138023376,
-1.0010031461715698,
0.5037967562675476,
0.5215861797332764,
0.9132058024406433,
0.7589271664619446,
-0.10266132652759552,
0.3957482576370239,
-0.9368699789047241,
0.3451446294784546,
0.12437136471271515,
0.6001413464546204,
0.3414700925350189,
-0.2821570932865143,
0.27391698956489563,
0.38182422518730164,
-0.06555213034152985,
-0.30760642886161804,
0.41055527329444885,
-1.0570875406265259,
-0.5413994193077087,
1.0443140268325806,
-0.22791613638401031,
-0.2992372512817383,
0.1851867288351059,
-0.42715612053871155,
0.1661967635154724,
-0.2592291235923767,
0.5327120423316956,
0.8061845898628235,
0.22249934077262878,
-0.6790311932563782,
-0.08987174928188324,
0.25232452154159546,
0.6355247497558594,
-0.8276337385177612,
-0.09717758744955063,
0.6387532353401184,
0.053434234112501144,
0.30780723690986633,
0.4407089054584503,
-0.4460785984992981,
0.21827995777130127,
0.12273914366960526,
0.2696355879306793,
0.023664843291044235,
-0.3219853639602661,
-0.4951435327529907,
0.3125768303871155,
-0.31723472476005554,
-0.21341511607170105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08155v1 | CMA-R:Causal Mediation Analysis for Explaining Rumour Detection | 2024-02-13T01:31:08 | 2024-02-13T01:31:08 | Lin Tian, Xiuzhen Zhang, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We apply causal mediation analysis to explain the decision-making process of
neural models for rumour detection on Twitter. Interventions at the input and
network level reveal the causal impacts of tweets and words in the model
output. We find that our approach CMA-R -- Causal Mediation Analysis for Rumour
detection -- identifies salient tweets that explain model predictions and show
strong agreement with human judgements for critical tweets determining the
truthfulness of stories. CMA-R can further highlight causally impactful words
in the salient tweets, providing another layer of interpretability and
transparency into these blackbox rumour detection systems. Code is available
at: https://github.com/ltian678/cma-r. | [
-0.5342704653739929,
-0.8479143381118774,
0.8810831308364868,
0.4474671185016632,
-0.4244112968444824,
-0.14584514498710632,
-0.13656935095787048,
-0.6364356875419617,
0.8610811829566956,
0.4107804000377655,
-0.9038203358650208,
-0.32598447799682617,
-1.0003348588943481,
-0.049748171120882034,
-0.40898260474205017,
0.7400628328323364,
0.19530272483825684,
0.32737916707992554,
0.49303507804870605,
-0.1671684980392456,
-0.8382483720779419,
-0.21006929874420166,
-0.7900059819221497,
-0.20262829959392548,
1.2210495471954346,
0.37552550435066223,
0.7816001772880554,
0.23226134479045868,
0.5040918588638306,
0.22975026071071625,
0.25502726435661316,
0.13710835576057434,
-0.36385273933410645,
0.42082345485687256,
-0.44271180033683777,
-0.4895789623260498,
-0.10822729766368866,
0.3344268500804901,
0.4250033497810364,
0.372356653213501,
-0.13403992354869843,
0.6172800064086914,
-0.30516353249549866,
0.7582699060440063,
-0.9149226546287537,
0.13429507613182068,
-0.85470050573349,
0.06426095962524414,
-0.05817074701189995,
-0.7148005366325378,
-0.3884330689907074,
-0.41068196296691895,
0.1629675328731537,
-0.30902352929115295,
0.011307580396533012,
0.3249785304069519,
0.8792094588279724,
0.4090917408466339,
-0.3016273081302643,
-0.345636785030365,
-1.0602757930755615,
0.699370265007019,
-0.4312492907047272,
0.1325041651725769,
0.376345157623291,
0.7269230484962463,
0.06155439466238022,
-0.5061837434768677,
-0.623774528503418,
-0.16350926458835602,
-0.25187569856643677,
0.1360875368118286,
-0.6636687517166138,
-0.2760683298110962,
0.14998963475227356,
-0.12676724791526794,
-0.15520091354846954,
-0.11807005107402802,
-0.5423489809036255,
-0.16605275869369507,
0.23264943063259125,
0.05978603661060333,
0.36730730533599854,
0.02283390797674656,
-0.13003511726856232,
0.40651214122772217,
-0.5645976662635803,
-0.4671972990036011,
0.300953209400177,
0.2915922701358795,
-0.07944667339324951,
0.6490716934204102,
0.053479138761758804,
0.4471031129360199,
0.32350510358810425,
-0.3024371862411499,
-0.14554688334465027,
-0.07309343665838242,
-0.38181570172309875,
0.44905346632003784,
0.7220255732536316,
0.4658651053905487,
-0.014710061252117157,
-0.4995720386505127,
-0.14209283888339996,
0.6424521803855896,
0.4436602294445038,
-0.88265460729599,
0.17816008627414703,
0.2311001569032669,
-0.9220244884490967,
-0.6697203516960144,
0.1739305853843689,
-0.9234416484832764,
-0.5548552870750427,
-0.4739133417606354,
0.7219655513763428,
0.10391423851251602,
-0.5748338103294373,
0.1905800998210907,
-0.3256434500217438,
0.13735471665859222,
0.3095545768737793,
-0.43813106417655945,
0.47100648283958435,
0.6388264298439026,
0.42598357796669006,
0.046058494597673416,
-0.15343016386032104,
-0.6065723896026611,
0.11395229399204254,
-0.5315222144126892,
1.0668848752975464,
-0.5167811512947083,
0.04893764480948448,
-0.05291931703686714,
-0.040102362632751465,
-0.2686280608177185,
-0.49946141242980957,
0.7178722023963928,
-0.8628357648849487,
0.41079840064048767,
-0.471333771944046,
-0.12766863405704498,
-0.6317266821861267,
0.1993357539176941,
-0.8854809999465942,
0.5827764868736267,
-0.07257747650146484,
-1.0561528205871582,
0.5336481332778931,
-0.6859002113342285,
-0.2444559931755066,
-0.44444310665130615,
0.2898564338684082,
-0.4016101062297821,
0.40705668926239014,
0.1600627899169922,
0.403917521238327,
-0.7103440761566162,
0.8511795401573181,
-0.35509762167930603,
-0.1842207908630371,
0.6387742757797241,
-0.6884995102882385,
0.8177381753921509,
0.3422912359237671,
-0.6852865219116211,
0.24660778045654297,
-0.8595864772796631,
-0.42541494965553284,
-0.04001722112298012,
0.260064035654068,
-0.12251276522874832,
0.10054744780063629,
-0.19220679998397827,
0.5682275295257568,
-0.17160439491271973,
-0.44154661893844604,
-0.20270739495754242,
0.24544648826122284,
0.06185828149318695,
0.24608923494815826,
0.5336118340492249,
0.3287751078605652,
-0.5179357528686523,
0.5416816473007202,
0.42399871349334717,
0.28195706009864807,
0.22637122869491577,
-0.6059548854827881,
-0.6351756453514099,
-0.06295696645975113,
0.1518908590078354,
0.3831618130207062,
-0.4765687584877014,
0.1925433874130249,
0.16277480125427246,
-0.4030831754207611,
-0.7226256728172302,
-0.3670966923236847,
0.18450094759464264,
0.5937233567237854,
0.23092085123062134,
0.0035514114424586296,
-0.924502968788147,
-1.0497019290924072,
-0.37317365407943726,
-0.1380436271429062,
0.12328042089939117,
-0.17373736202716827,
0.21550768613815308,
-0.2594592869281769,
0.9035009741783142,
-0.36103132367134094,
-0.3908067047595978,
-0.052465781569480896,
0.4332762360572815,
0.18118233978748322,
0.03146786987781525,
0.6976140737533569,
-0.8043021559715271,
-0.3081260025501251,
-0.3323584794998169,
-0.5849545001983643,
-0.5290393233299255,
-0.10203167796134949,
-0.23390087485313416,
0.2064378708600998,
0.33759385347366333,
-0.6630356311798096,
0.7539281845092773,
0.5205371379852295,
-0.7286257743835449,
0.9448806643486023,
0.4394940137863159,
0.5830491185188293,
-1.1493157148361206,
0.08078009635210037,
0.04918130859732628,
-0.08390980213880539,
-0.6252057552337646,
-0.2838084399700165,
-0.18131347000598907,
0.06916043907403946,
-0.2531532645225525,
0.14146623015403748,
-0.47634926438331604,
-0.2414373755455017,
-0.4363652169704437,
0.45638588070869446,
-0.11563195288181305,
0.29787760972976685,
-0.10356958955526352,
0.5191577076911926,
0.5140613913536072,
-0.5205861926078796,
-0.036899369210004807,
-0.10765586048364639,
-0.04330660030245781,
0.454925000667572,
-0.24215802550315857,
-0.4710938036441803,
-0.27471816539764404,
0.03781746327877045,
-1.1996417045593262,
0.03673102706670761,
0.7897206544876099,
-0.8672845363616943,
0.098056361079216,
-0.09124399721622467,
-0.4632824659347534,
-0.22677046060562134,
-0.2562587857246399,
0.18695087730884552,
0.15817661583423615,
-0.6671485900878906,
0.9274558424949646,
0.4610707759857178,
0.3309006989002228,
-0.6743744611740112,
-0.6349388957023621,
0.2652381956577301,
-0.4608447551727295,
-0.5664212703704834,
0.16950330138206482,
0.05069318041205406,
-0.722072184085846,
0.30972757935523987,
-0.02135377749800682,
-0.1056135967373848,
0.02869441546499729,
0.4086070954799652,
0.3211628794670105,
-0.4953003227710724,
-0.2903863191604614,
-0.21090257167816162,
-0.446090430021286,
0.714728832244873,
-0.09512205421924591,
0.27663248777389526,
0.1852114051580429,
-0.049945324659347534,
-0.8309310078620911,
0.24313229322433472,
0.8253006339073181,
0.08469794690608978,
1.2459206581115723,
0.9296388030052185,
-0.5281375646591187,
-0.06876607239246368,
-0.9504299163818359,
-0.27827563881874084,
-0.38817957043647766,
-0.2120686173439026,
-0.13689011335372925,
-0.6232210993766785,
0.8647425770759583,
-0.016663644462823868,
-0.41814109683036804,
0.7725793123245239,
0.6452946066856384,
0.35144153237342834,
0.8423576354980469,
0.5664305090904236,
-0.36798566579818726,
0.2580212354660034,
0.08303051441907883,
0.38868260383605957,
-0.5093042850494385,
-0.28506380319595337,
-0.851082444190979,
-0.22953782975673676,
-0.5321678519248962,
-0.4520021975040436,
-0.0560896061360836,
-0.11082145571708679,
-0.08228156715631485,
0.13887128233909607,
-0.4891161322593689,
0.34881845116615295,
0.4782083332538605,
0.1874348670244217,
0.4154556393623352,
-0.15422064065933228,
0.054888829588890076,
-0.20658321678638458,
-0.625505805015564,
-0.3037911057472229,
0.698112428188324,
0.45405036211013794,
0.6662507057189941,
0.253682941198349,
0.2875983417034149,
0.25292325019836426,
0.9714283347129822,
-0.804102897644043,
0.3767900764942169,
0.4952537715435028,
-0.9177418947219849,
-0.009812840260565281,
-0.21008595824241638,
-0.6698780059814453,
0.2798919677734375,
-0.6811761260032654,
-0.7041361927986145,
0.3008509576320648,
-0.2719428539276123,
-0.08030755072832108,
0.6454751491546631,
-0.5492986440658569,
0.519332766532898,
0.25429755449295044,
-0.26017799973487854,
-0.6353688836097717,
-0.48499730229377747,
1.049217700958252,
-0.241997629404068,
0.41708752512931824,
-0.12248913198709488,
-0.12536731362342834,
0.9320379495620728,
-0.3967663645744324,
1.035200834274292,
-0.39166712760925293,
0.06677958369255066,
0.43756818771362305,
0.29708918929100037,
0.35837522149086,
0.11053352057933807,
0.01314480323344469,
0.10298512876033783,
-0.30763283371925354,
-0.16582439839839935,
-0.42366793751716614,
0.5898100733757019,
-0.5955198407173157,
-0.5642200708389282,
-0.5569435358047485,
-0.5674189925193787,
-0.09058213233947754,
0.08875123411417007,
-0.0022430915851145983,
0.16725073754787445,
-0.14776740968227386,
0.0478191003203392,
0.6067687273025513,
-0.14660559594631195,
0.4959072470664978,
1.0279815196990967,
-0.4018460810184479,
-0.5315595269203186,
0.41892215609550476,
0.11240922659635544,
-0.10171118378639221,
0.49881961941719055,
0.4321189820766449,
-0.0731004849076271,
-0.7972307801246643,
0.135513037443161,
0.2912554144859314,
-0.5397828221321106,
-0.4541872441768646,
-0.6835756897926331,
-0.31781861186027527,
0.0371687225997448,
-0.06608127802610397,
-0.24860066175460815,
-0.4251531660556793,
-0.34352433681488037,
-0.14247581362724304,
0.23048920929431915,
1.0933129787445068,
-0.3360256254673004,
0.6177541017532349,
-0.634316086769104,
0.6695064902305603,
0.2564123570919037,
0.3263101875782013,
0.2726401686668396,
-0.5377141833305359,
-0.2500606179237366,
-0.1719391942024231,
-0.3642372488975525,
-1.0939414501190186,
0.5883120894432068,
-0.5080713033676147,
0.34824323654174805,
0.8922424912452698,
-0.012215936556458473,
0.72601717710495,
-0.388019859790802,
0.6694908142089844,
0.44047975540161133,
-0.6102883815765381,
0.35228872299194336,
-0.5378701090812683,
-0.15906767547130585,
0.4968041181564331,
0.5168659090995789,
-0.30358102917671204,
-0.5757322907447815,
-0.7884929180145264,
-0.2360060214996338,
0.6015892028808594,
0.2481408715248108,
-0.39397814869880676,
-0.218438059091568,
0.18542462587356567,
0.14417777955532074,
0.20599521696567535,
-0.6644452810287476,
-0.6315068602561951,
0.24715203046798706,
0.19710326194763184,
0.20657974481582642,
-0.9999725818634033,
-0.3080209195613861,
-0.15569457411766052,
0.8219026923179626,
0.3451124131679535,
0.46725958585739136,
0.026864590123295784,
-0.09156385064125061,
-0.8304218649864197,
0.0510684996843338,
0.7818892598152161,
1.3405848741531372,
-0.47108185291290283,
0.10191865265369415,
-0.06371713429689407,
-0.5418692231178284,
-0.012891600839793682,
0.09557059407234192,
-0.0209884624928236,
0.3539949655532837,
0.4281534254550934,
0.3650844097137451,
0.6937384605407715,
-0.11219441145658493,
0.518551230430603,
-0.5912299752235413,
-0.5651138424873352,
-0.3556293547153473,
-0.31722092628479004,
0.38185083866119385,
0.45655977725982666,
0.7097461223602295,
0.4980425536632538,
0.2860203981399536,
-0.5238249897956848,
0.313688725233078,
0.39533308148384094,
-0.297400563955307,
-0.4315134882926941,
0.8957074284553528,
-0.18658119440078735,
-0.1305924504995346,
0.2049190104007721,
0.05110834538936615,
-0.5781072378158569,
0.6188679337501526,
0.6948753595352173,
1.2579553127288818,
-0.3178551495075226,
0.5056142807006836,
0.5343251824378967,
0.6238362789154053,
-0.22483201324939728,
0.16378888487815857,
0.29336610436439514,
-0.9218026995658875,
-0.5194836854934692,
-0.4353417158126831,
-0.5288511514663696,
0.18359409272670746,
-0.8466078042984009,
0.3213859498500824,
-0.33785930275917053,
-0.18361908197402954,
0.5399675965309143,
0.24410054087638855,
-0.5728774070739746,
0.15786603093147278,
0.0987604409456253,
1.0749852657318115,
-1.0287251472473145,
0.7441607117652893,
0.0886208638548851,
-0.49514567852020264,
-1.0960725545883179,
0.18837839365005493,
0.15001602470874786,
-0.8163546323776245,
0.8510506749153137,
0.028052974492311478,
-0.10981014370918274,
-0.4901558458805084,
-0.6910342574119568,
-0.9982866644859314,
1.3732430934906006,
0.36178192496299744,
-0.46623459458351135,
0.35455650091171265,
-0.0703209862112999,
0.4056246876716614,
-0.7663859724998474,
0.28544795513153076,
0.5775669813156128,
0.8480077385902405,
0.4240145683288574,
-0.623069703578949,
0.34898579120635986,
0.20831309258937836,
-0.22322551906108856,
0.06947550177574158,
-0.5512269735336304,
0.3268723487854004,
-0.2963079512119293,
-0.06715366244316101,
-0.13026763498783112,
0.7046123147010803,
0.3813346326351166,
0.802454948425293,
0.4385288655757904,
0.4627406895160675,
0.45610034465789795,
-0.13302992284297943,
0.9528997540473938,
-0.5413954257965088,
0.15904220938682556,
0.9809919595718384,
0.04472717270255089,
0.6358506679534912,
0.4684625566005707,
-0.13837464153766632,
0.5990797877311707,
0.6335482597351074,
0.14592769742012024,
0.6549246311187744,
0.0822649598121643,
-0.35787442326545715,
0.09236067533493042,
-0.1555837243795395,
-0.06259072571992874,
0.10555187612771988,
0.7094532251358032,
-0.5283410549163818,
-0.47229984402656555,
-0.06945227831602097,
0.331379234790802,
-0.05214748904109001,
-0.5699536800384521,
0.4520120918750763,
0.09345624595880508,
-0.8301380276679993,
0.34435659646987915,
0.040584977716207504,
0.6952815651893616,
-0.6109224557876587,
-0.02241327613592148,
0.02063314989209175,
-0.024985209107398987,
-0.3115713894367218,
-0.42338743805885315,
0.8032991886138916,
-0.3859822750091553,
-0.5032854676246643,
0.23224037885665894,
1.1964043378829956,
-0.4958002269268036,
-0.31974703073501587,
0.8408136963844299,
0.6246586441993713,
-0.004844022449105978,
-0.2802640199661255,
-0.8786613941192627,
0.3282937705516815,
-0.18490301072597504,
-0.3292817771434784,
0.26676154136657715,
0.7797447443008423,
0.10354754328727722,
0.574070155620575,
0.635929524898529,
0.11363783478736877,
-0.19596876204013824,
0.3103201687335968,
1.1208539009094238,
-0.851408064365387,
-0.2513357698917389,
-0.8954421281814575,
0.25116634368896484,
0.07735985517501831,
0.1448366791009903,
0.7855665683746338,
0.3207617700099945,
0.15681079030036926,
-0.23190361261367798,
0.4244925081729889,
-0.07502681761980057,
0.6109662055969238,
-0.3601369857788086,
0.9118700623512268,
-0.1250261664390564,
0.35811567306518555,
-0.34867236018180847,
-1.0486440658569336,
-0.6254401803016663,
0.16918975114822388,
-0.4499037563800812,
-0.1299000233411789,
1.4183069467544556,
1.0526504516601562,
-0.049798209220170975,
0.2786821126937866,
0.4978434443473816,
0.6323758363723755,
-0.0502651073038578,
-0.0026579482946544886,
0.6558354496955872,
-0.4955891966819763,
0.4620682895183563,
-0.17041361331939697,
-0.27764081954956055,
-0.3669157028198242,
-1.0837494134902954,
-1.1751407384872437,
-0.4981464445590973,
-0.31569331884384155,
-0.7272353172302246,
0.1030823290348053,
0.5881360173225403,
0.6469663381576538,
-0.8794248700141907,
-0.03707728534936905,
0.12764699757099152,
0.5075608491897583,
-0.42504212260246277,
-0.36454084515571594,
0.35245564579963684,
-0.4469109773635864,
-0.19540855288505554,
0.18464727699756622,
0.299444317817688,
-0.34027352929115295,
-0.34485045075416565,
0.17568357288837433,
-0.5837724804878235,
0.4268333911895752,
0.764458954334259,
0.12334536015987396,
-0.5276644229888916,
-0.3276149332523346,
-0.4240039587020874,
-0.002907787449657917,
-0.21280188858509064,
1.0262588262557983,
-0.8178579807281494,
-0.06497281789779663,
0.29255062341690063,
0.5085538625717163,
0.48849567770957947,
-0.10813625156879425,
0.6728089451789856,
-0.2687987685203552,
0.2081417739391327,
-0.06630116701126099,
0.3566751778125763,
-0.07116271555423737,
-0.7375137209892273,
0.6527655124664307,
0.19495990872383118,
-0.5844900608062744,
-0.6762982606887817,
-0.2815568745136261,
-1.3120477199554443,
-0.4360516369342804,
0.9883715510368347,
0.2437121868133545,
-0.6774962544441223,
-0.28910645842552185,
-0.2641688585281372,
0.1516508162021637,
-0.49313628673553467,
1.2211148738861084,
0.7605669498443604,
0.2429208755493164,
-0.2518461048603058,
-0.9564605951309204,
0.587713897228241,
-0.012403375469148159,
-0.5719842314720154,
-0.14512866735458374,
0.5148667097091675,
0.5516011118888855,
0.23865091800689697,
0.7495273947715759,
-0.3974568843841553,
0.48191529512405396,
0.1904338300228119,
-0.14368708431720734,
-0.00821677502244711,
-0.4069589674472809,
-0.19630654156208038,
0.41818028688430786,
-0.09724409878253937,
-0.35835695266723633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08114v2 | Active Preference Learning for Large Language Models | 2024-02-12T23:09:00 | 2024-06-28T08:22:01 | William Muldrew, Peter Hayes, Mingtian Zhang, David Barber | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become more capable, fine-tuning techniques
for aligning with human intent are increasingly important. A key consideration
for aligning these models is how to most effectively use human resources, or
model resources in the case where LLMs themselves are used as oracles.
Reinforcement learning from Human or AI preferences (RLHF/RLAIF) is the most
prominent example of such a technique, but is complex and often unstable.
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has recently been proposed as a simpler
and more stable alternative. In this work, we develop an active learning
strategy for DPO to make better use of preference labels. We propose a
practical acquisition function for prompt/completion pairs based on the
predictive entropy of the language model and a measure of certainty of the
implicit preference model optimized by DPO. We demonstrate how our approach
improves both the rate of learning and final performance of fine-tuning on
pairwise preference data. | [
-0.21507470309734344,
-0.6746858358383179,
0.6485791206359863,
0.04489808902144432,
-0.3216441571712494,
-0.05418326333165169,
-0.7278109192848206,
-0.34707996249198914,
-0.1457354724407196,
0.3417075276374817,
-0.36187776923179626,
-0.37245607376098633,
-0.43159931898117065,
0.15551473200321198,
0.3637503385543823,
0.6238676309585571,
-0.29589617252349854,
-0.07525651156902313,
-0.1534440666437149,
-0.1074749082326889,
-0.4202254116535187,
-0.2564629316329956,
-1.0457382202148438,
-0.5593247413635254,
0.8053892850875854,
0.6581789255142212,
0.789493978023529,
0.9320152401924133,
0.253871887922287,
0.27672919631004333,
-0.011015264317393303,
0.4129512906074524,
-0.28650856018066406,
0.6401556730270386,
-0.0457514151930809,
-0.3404664099216461,
-0.5254619121551514,
0.13691522181034088,
0.6267783641815186,
0.7160528898239136,
-0.3020031154155731,
-0.0586613267660141,
-0.2739259898662567,
0.835184633731842,
-0.8026755452156067,
0.32465222477912903,
-0.6163178086280823,
0.2962101697921753,
0.23456119000911713,
-0.09699578583240509,
-0.5311358571052551,
-0.35452285408973694,
0.4359990954399109,
-0.68592768907547,
-0.21095891296863556,
0.21707603335380554,
0.5718401670455933,
0.5971170663833618,
-0.47992143034935,
-0.08624996989965439,
-0.6082025766372681,
0.9615600109100342,
-0.32940739393234253,
0.5972903966903687,
0.8080359697341919,
-0.13305389881134033,
-0.15852312743663788,
-0.22328400611877441,
-0.3482320010662079,
-0.493807315826416,
0.03393053635954857,
-0.019432049244642258,
0.05943217873573303,
0.32818111777305603,
0.10909660160541534,
0.18594315648078918,
-0.342830628156662,
0.4989311695098877,
-0.08534613251686096,
-0.13548420369625092,
0.7476749420166016,
-0.10379739850759506,
0.15946602821350098,
0.03989419713616371,
-0.34685027599334717,
-0.1839337795972824,
-0.49544820189476013,
0.21073246002197266,
0.3784525692462921,
0.5024917721748352,
0.03406437486410141,
0.3946513235569,
-0.1484323889017105,
1.0183488130569458,
0.39407187700271606,
-0.3237885534763336,
0.29055431485176086,
0.2395075559616089,
-0.23925812542438507,
0.26798564195632935,
0.5724959373474121,
0.02879667468369007,
0.24246299266815186,
-0.25668975710868835,
-0.39781245589256287,
-0.26078319549560547,
0.21324938535690308,
-0.5200417637825012,
-0.10889308899641037,
0.4481712281703949,
-0.19209209084510803,
-0.361057311296463,
-0.17858724296092987,
-0.20343735814094543,
-0.3337632417678833,
-0.6677085161209106,
0.3236018121242523,
-0.20938237011432648,
-0.337548166513443,
0.35290828347206116,
0.18352949619293213,
0.13474254310131073,
0.422324538230896,
-1.1967108249664307,
-0.046074312180280685,
0.7038227319717407,
0.5532628297805786,
-0.5401086807250977,
-0.20215292274951935,
-0.8426131010055542,
0.24138449132442474,
-0.3729626536369324,
0.416975736618042,
-0.6299661993980408,
-0.3310268521308899,
-0.02427227422595024,
-0.14688469469547272,
0.053552620112895966,
-0.48873651027679443,
0.6608682870864868,
-0.7972187995910645,
0.08269932121038437,
-0.19063782691955566,
-0.35370102524757385,
-0.1954842209815979,
0.22230736911296844,
-0.6638627052307129,
0.9584922194480896,
-0.10137076675891876,
-0.45200690627098083,
0.6154815554618835,
-0.4203425347805023,
-0.4972900450229645,
-0.009573077782988548,
-0.006372722797095776,
-0.5068807005882263,
-0.0816212072968483,
0.002350015100091696,
0.6404432058334351,
0.027974165976047516,
0.4928247928619385,
-0.4992522597312927,
-0.12801964581012726,
0.22901789844036102,
-0.25732868909835815,
0.4603711664676666,
0.2979746162891388,
-0.24416503310203552,
0.35667285323143005,
-0.5532176494598389,
-0.16405726969242096,
0.04869367927312851,
-0.7567366361618042,
-0.6578341126441956,
0.10145479440689087,
-0.46505919098854065,
-0.07082025706768036,
0.6035506725311279,
-0.26937374472618103,
0.46924322843551636,
-0.3814695477485657,
0.10162133723497391,
1.1109952926635742,
-0.14831718802452087,
0.907931387424469,
0.1983405202627182,
0.5260306596755981,
-0.12031172960996628,
0.13384497165679932,
0.2718468904495239,
-0.1324101835489273,
-0.8820613026618958,
-0.4087596535682678,
0.33107247948646545,
0.5303308367729187,
-0.5138660073280334,
0.719863772392273,
0.08938676863908768,
-0.2392786294221878,
-0.3820109963417053,
0.43906930088996887,
0.495373398065567,
0.48947009444236755,
0.221879243850708,
-0.04169429838657379,
-0.29063746333122253,
-0.9566773772239685,
0.052907999604940414,
-0.5384958386421204,
0.12444800138473511,
0.7294183373451233,
-0.11343631148338318,
-0.11510158330202103,
0.8129632472991943,
-0.7152025103569031,
0.15213021636009216,
-0.24351292848587036,
0.004021437373012304,
0.231365367770195,
0.32334625720977783,
0.3366753160953522,
-1.0302393436431885,
-0.6846625804901123,
0.01638983003795147,
-0.5753123164176941,
0.12153562158346176,
0.25971847772598267,
-0.3198418915271759,
0.40751180052757263,
0.220359206199646,
-0.31872302293777466,
-0.15447169542312622,
0.5494973063468933,
-0.2772742211818695,
0.017253099009394646,
-0.3791903555393219,
-0.005398138426244259,
-0.6519718170166016,
0.06619282811880112,
0.13805288076400757,
-0.34467580914497375,
-0.4837210178375244,
-0.25916874408721924,
0.1308121681213379,
-0.10310804843902588,
-0.43251290917396545,
0.9256628155708313,
-0.6250333189964294,
0.12525126338005066,
-0.2184382677078247,
-0.13956788182258606,
-0.3348754942417145,
0.5798839926719666,
0.6185053586959839,
0.5660924315452576,
0.7387424111366272,
-0.8510008454322815,
0.442293256521225,
0.11957195401191711,
-0.07373533397912979,
0.08881427347660065,
-0.5836247801780701,
0.3124890625476837,
-0.27517732977867126,
0.10366348922252655,
-0.8927786350250244,
-0.2902163565158844,
0.33667489886283875,
-0.2201111614704132,
0.6033402681350708,
-0.21198810636997223,
-0.05058440566062927,
-0.09090187400579453,
-0.08933952450752258,
0.5024762749671936,
0.5129257440567017,
-0.6506511569023132,
0.4859434962272644,
0.5092833638191223,
-0.09137876331806183,
-0.9822892546653748,
-0.06324563175439835,
-0.3325763940811157,
-0.35531312227249146,
-0.35209083557128906,
0.23561879992485046,
0.05548128858208656,
-0.4305000603199005,
-0.24995794892311096,
-0.2968554198741913,
0.09124153107404709,
0.2984313368797302,
0.13639451563358307,
0.31171301007270813,
0.2135363072156906,
0.360797643661499,
-0.14830639958381653,
-0.34496501088142395,
-0.31960955262184143,
-0.28761640191078186,
0.4450891613960266,
0.037631284445524216,
-0.07289475947618484,
-0.17128807306289673,
0.08022567629814148,
0.46976548433303833,
-0.28818944096565247,
0.6476547718048096,
0.4530688524246216,
-0.15595421195030212,
-0.40213078260421753,
-0.5100029706954956,
-0.44730088114738464,
-0.44554033875465393,
0.24992863833904266,
-0.32752737402915955,
-0.7412746548652649,
0.1402348130941391,
0.027502212673425674,
0.16357773542404175,
0.16401994228363037,
0.4188542664051056,
0.14682184159755707,
1.117326259613037,
0.8029545545578003,
-0.18231864273548126,
0.8737603425979614,
-0.018113667145371437,
0.03169481083750725,
-0.47520315647125244,
-0.266037255525589,
-0.3440398573875427,
-0.4256340563297272,
-0.29228484630584717,
-0.3156621754169464,
0.44686445593833923,
0.18615484237670898,
-0.37992340326309204,
0.04880662262439728,
-0.34755387902259827,
0.3906005620956421,
0.8004931807518005,
0.4675883650779724,
0.23509761691093445,
0.15069995820522308,
0.019161006435751915,
0.03961711376905441,
-0.6794649958610535,
-0.30141910910606384,
0.9570313692092896,
0.47202059626579285,
0.823115348815918,
0.09553039073944092,
0.663933277130127,
0.2668343484401703,
-0.09668178856372833,
-1.1114572286605835,
0.37638232111930847,
-0.18761374056339264,
-0.5317856669425964,
-0.6612836122512817,
-0.4784923195838928,
-1.0765403509140015,
-0.045090001076459885,
-0.2467927634716034,
-0.3941415548324585,
0.344555526971817,
0.5479689240455627,
-0.4608432650566101,
0.07380333542823792,
-0.6422649621963501,
0.7280243635177612,
-0.6116423606872559,
-0.7253667116165161,
-0.35950616002082825,
-0.6396163105964661,
0.28676894307136536,
-0.056776054203510284,
-0.1819949895143509,
-0.3664805591106415,
-0.3803628385066986,
0.7365232706069946,
0.1463388353586197,
0.820176362991333,
-0.3174951672554016,
-0.33055296540260315,
0.032602813094854355,
0.08252845704555511,
0.629271924495697,
0.22903451323509216,
-0.534750759601593,
-0.22316911816596985,
-0.6153801679611206,
-0.27097856998443604,
-0.46479249000549316,
0.6006569266319275,
-1.0871403217315674,
-0.7215256094932556,
-0.4229806661605835,
-0.2808782458305359,
-0.3979600965976715,
0.11632761359214783,
-0.248803973197937,
0.2755648195743561,
-0.13357698917388916,
0.04323510453104973,
1.0410076379776,
-0.2050553411245346,
0.41881871223449707,
0.7596367597579956,
0.08749303221702576,
-0.4296363592147827,
0.6988379955291748,
-0.16026203334331512,
0.3780118525028229,
0.5112035870552063,
0.42750218510627747,
-0.4451075494289398,
-0.5207505822181702,
-0.375341534614563,
0.3342859148979187,
-0.47402504086494446,
-0.2474597692489624,
-0.5333288908004761,
0.12822388112545013,
-0.38237109780311584,
-0.18670743703842163,
-0.3826216459274292,
-0.3607119023799896,
-0.3284548223018646,
-0.1489284485578537,
0.6051902770996094,
0.3505000174045563,
-0.1913398951292038,
0.03395799174904823,
-0.5510293841362,
0.2986348271369934,
0.7401039004325867,
0.4266529381275177,
-0.10124312341213226,
-0.4986843168735504,
-0.11489838361740112,
-0.019592853263020515,
-0.008897976949810982,
-0.6150698065757751,
0.25411713123321533,
0.20964176952838898,
0.8329354524612427,
0.5159192085266113,
0.4384762644767761,
0.3365754187107086,
-0.2077294886112213,
0.37005287408828735,
0.1370190531015396,
-0.7000324726104736,
0.7472668886184692,
-0.3963186740875244,
0.09570155292749405,
0.7463517189025879,
0.7900123596191406,
-0.4901486933231354,
0.16359689831733704,
-0.5663743019104004,
-0.9724571704864502,
0.934990406036377,
-0.31449663639068604,
0.01653398387134075,
0.0011559358099475503,
0.6642276048660278,
0.21116995811462402,
0.21268364787101746,
-0.6589567065238953,
-0.36267033219337463,
0.3543240427970886,
-0.04911785200238228,
-0.28186672925949097,
-0.2857075333595276,
-0.23711247742176056,
-0.22668614983558655,
1.0342674255371094,
-0.2072587013244629,
-0.05712135136127472,
-0.00046966105583123863,
0.060427889227867126,
-0.3240340054035187,
0.20264270901679993,
0.3096773624420166,
0.5240126252174377,
-0.5415693521499634,
0.12479459494352341,
0.013049600645899773,
-0.23350758850574493,
0.3733867108821869,
-0.12443168461322784,
-0.25593459606170654,
-0.44561320543289185,
0.060279060155153275,
1.2674199342727661,
0.07164699584245682,
-0.6954880356788635,
0.43615052103996277,
0.010836194269359112,
-0.02277482859790325,
-0.23020586371421814,
0.4256419241428375,
-0.1249547004699707,
0.13494990766048431,
0.2454175502061844,
-0.10003602504730225,
-0.07080350071191788,
-0.6345950961112976,
0.1339317262172699,
0.4562492072582245,
-0.7627390027046204,
-0.11506596207618713,
0.2782590687274933,
0.5798956155776978,
-0.2987843155860901,
0.6718363761901855,
-0.2657168209552765,
-0.5944835543632507,
0.46684712171554565,
0.4541078507900238,
0.8994041085243225,
-0.2160063534975052,
0.22903409600257874,
0.5952208042144775,
-0.13183271884918213,
-0.4561627507209778,
0.040268734097480774,
-0.42808830738067627,
-1.0572643280029297,
-0.2711428701877594,
-0.7972663640975952,
-0.5610427856445312,
-0.09313170611858368,
-0.6129809617996216,
0.6464126110076904,
-0.37779560685157776,
-0.12606869637966156,
-0.2731614410877228,
0.20818865299224854,
-0.3439294695854187,
0.20018917322158813,
0.33682671189308167,
0.48149651288986206,
-0.9063440561294556,
0.9093850255012512,
0.944613516330719,
-0.2345225214958191,
-0.8338255882263184,
-0.10149728506803513,
-0.2253495156764984,
-1.045530915260315,
0.7805292010307312,
-0.21384470164775848,
-0.06960107386112213,
0.11121047288179398,
-0.4297633469104767,
-0.7796355485916138,
0.8145405054092407,
0.5153718590736389,
-0.6251397132873535,
-0.033960066735744476,
-0.5252735614776611,
0.2197909653186798,
-0.2571756839752197,
0.01680840738117695,
0.5300388336181641,
0.7049254179000854,
0.27542996406555176,
-0.8230435848236084,
0.04651182144880295,
0.1273907870054245,
-0.3920253813266754,
0.48134228587150574,
-0.9117535948753357,
0.4412250518798828,
-0.3985942602157593,
-0.01083188783377409,
-0.33962905406951904,
0.6893748044967651,
0.4069501459598541,
0.09555087983608246,
1.0094391107559204,
0.3799642026424408,
0.8885602951049805,
0.09740298241376877,
0.7418819665908813,
-0.21915622055530548,
0.15080922842025757,
0.7985391020774841,
-0.28105661273002625,
1.0484058856964111,
0.5892077088356018,
-0.14749093353748322,
0.05140671133995056,
0.9236634969711304,
0.22580215334892273,
0.6421812772750854,
0.16452452540397644,
-0.4951712191104889,
-0.8589144945144653,
-0.26309117674827576,
-0.1171722337603569,
0.47871115803718567,
0.35828953981399536,
-0.30130529403686523,
0.1841966062784195,
-0.031970612704753876,
0.16901502013206482,
0.1534273773431778,
-0.3316560387611389,
1.1150556802749634,
-0.020612753927707672,
-1.291519284248352,
0.6374282240867615,
0.010150594636797905,
0.6943060159683228,
-0.6106838583946228,
0.14623680710792542,
-0.1900596022605896,
0.23914290964603424,
-0.118097685277462,
-0.629638671875,
-0.2393822968006134,
-0.1866856962442398,
-0.3620363175868988,
-0.47612297534942627,
0.5789819359779358,
-0.850555956363678,
-0.2788206934928894,
0.32158124446868896,
0.31549763679504395,
-0.06836438179016113,
0.18329943716526031,
-0.7171597480773926,
-0.03117337077856064,
0.2786802053451538,
-0.2891874611377716,
0.219172403216362,
0.21509957313537598,
0.06667132675647736,
0.672123908996582,
0.4789685606956482,
0.35235342383384705,
-0.25043413043022156,
-0.05213628336787224,
0.49055662751197815,
-0.4358203709125519,
-0.3027023673057556,
-0.8128040432929993,
0.27114924788475037,
0.054903142154216766,
-0.293913871049881,
0.531257688999176,
0.4200129806995392,
0.49889832735061646,
0.038523782044649124,
0.666132390499115,
0.029506592079997063,
0.29198214411735535,
-0.6854472160339355,
0.3437725603580475,
-0.7598787546157837,
0.19980111718177795,
-0.01578444428741932,
-1.0657892227172852,
-0.29955151677131653,
0.7008156180381775,
-0.38736557960510254,
-0.047443609684705734,
0.3953563868999481,
0.6847995519638062,
-0.19959881901741028,
-0.40292513370513916,
0.28823286294937134,
-0.0888906717300415,
0.029889380559325218,
0.5681770443916321,
0.6612626314163208,
-0.05577044561505318,
0.29195651412010193,
-0.4293813109397888,
-0.5205560326576233,
-0.19761472940444946,
-0.9913707971572876,
-0.8083829283714294,
-0.6203470230102539,
-0.5650842785835266,
-0.23665939271450043,
0.2626323103904724,
1.3985240459442139,
0.7440524101257324,
-0.5176424980163574,
-0.24820098280906677,
0.15148743987083435,
0.2947693169116974,
-0.10465801507234573,
-0.06813957542181015,
0.4040672183036804,
-0.6065740585327148,
-0.9984523057937622,
0.3934270441532135,
0.1730441451072693,
0.10743017494678497,
-0.24608762562274933,
-0.4868635833263397,
-0.25522786378860474,
-0.11267101764678955,
0.4256679117679596,
0.5176568031311035,
-0.6683230996131897,
-0.2749907672405243,
0.1066560298204422,
-0.16732780635356903,
-0.0501835010945797,
0.8162766695022583,
-0.5883194208145142,
0.5189349055290222,
0.7653626203536987,
0.6167588233947754,
0.4141962230205536,
0.19686828553676605,
1.0702943801879883,
-0.6381189823150635,
0.36412110924720764,
0.22459164261817932,
0.2919100821018219,
0.3226996958255768,
-0.5636635422706604,
0.45999419689178467,
0.03970755636692047,
-0.675367534160614,
-0.81898432970047,
0.23180311918258667,
-1.105558156967163,
-0.3377436697483063,
1.6018821001052856,
-0.11516124755144119,
-0.15583078563213348,
-0.04414200037717819,
-0.20260269939899445,
0.37332287430763245,
-0.925823450088501,
0.7639486193656921,
0.4537314474582672,
-0.1418173909187317,
0.013720725663006306,
-0.17532549798488617,
0.7840203046798706,
0.6341729164123535,
-0.3804732859134674,
0.30288445949554443,
0.5664762258529663,
0.13959099352359772,
-0.11844953894615173,
0.6023589372634888,
0.3223661482334137,
0.17267116904258728,
-0.5167717337608337,
0.12252644449472427,
-0.12156867235898972,
-0.534006655216217,
-0.4431099593639374,
-0.0355079285800457,
0.633882462978363,
-0.18073607981204987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08113v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08113v3 | Addressing cognitive bias in medical language models | 2024-02-12T23:08:37 | 2024-02-20T23:45:43 | Samuel Schmidgall, Carl Harris, Ime Essien, Daniel Olshvang, Tawsifur Rahman, Ji Woong Kim, Rojin Ziaei, Jason Eshraghian, Peter Abadir, Rama Chellappa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | There is increasing interest in the application large language models (LLMs)
to the medical field, in part because of their impressive performance on
medical exam questions. While promising, exam questions do not reflect the
complexity of real patient-doctor interactions. In reality, physicians'
decisions are shaped by many complex factors, such as patient compliance,
personal experience, ethical beliefs, and cognitive bias. Taking a step toward
understanding this, our hypothesis posits that when LLMs are confronted with
clinical questions containing cognitive biases, they will yield significantly
less accurate responses compared to the same questions presented without such
biases. In this study, we developed BiasMedQA, a benchmark for evaluating
cognitive biases in LLMs applied to medical tasks. Using BiasMedQA we evaluated
six LLMs, namely GPT-4, Mixtral-8x70B, GPT-3.5, PaLM-2, Llama 2 70B-chat, and
the medically specialized PMC Llama 13B. We tested these models on 1,273
questions from the US Medical Licensing Exam (USMLE) Steps 1, 2, and 3,
modified to replicate common clinically-relevant cognitive biases. Our analysis
revealed varying effects for biases on these LLMs, with GPT-4 standing out for
its resilience to bias, in contrast to Llama 2 70B-chat and PMC Llama 13B,
which were disproportionately affected by cognitive bias. Our findings
highlight the critical need for bias mitigation in the development of medical
LLMs, pointing towards safer and more reliable applications in healthcare. | [
-0.3404175043106079,
-0.7973915338516235,
1.0569478273391724,
0.09435094147920609,
-0.09507476538419724,
-0.1494535207748413,
-0.38729098439216614,
-0.4601297378540039,
0.004840670619159937,
0.724867582321167,
-0.643036425113678,
-0.420647531747818,
-0.717287003993988,
-0.03160630166530609,
0.0669156163930893,
0.9422531723976135,
-0.10921981185674667,
0.7460969686508179,
-0.3326672315597534,
-0.15675199031829834,
-0.7742041349411011,
-0.8029977679252625,
-0.6286619901657104,
-0.6256473660469055,
0.23881487548351288,
-0.05520123988389969,
0.6809090375900269,
0.18344725668430328,
0.4296746850013733,
0.13167616724967957,
-0.0785273015499115,
-0.11254732310771942,
-0.2089090198278427,
0.12832428514957428,
-0.3072826564311981,
-0.6190441846847534,
-0.5304086804389954,
0.2792258560657501,
0.19777753949165344,
0.800007700920105,
-0.16781392693519592,
0.11983256042003632,
-0.12224631756544113,
0.6177400350570679,
-0.5470244884490967,
0.21393698453903198,
-0.692125678062439,
0.052484624087810516,
-0.3749663531780243,
-0.11543593555688858,
-0.40279871225357056,
-0.3527074158191681,
0.2020581066608429,
-0.3874286711215973,
0.1209024041891098,
-0.10570791363716125,
0.6314315795898438,
0.5508242249488831,
-0.6076735258102417,
-0.4494662582874298,
-0.3733436167240143,
0.8469130396842957,
-0.939037561416626,
0.29916706681251526,
0.5541097521781921,
0.19855897128582,
-0.2498456984758377,
-0.3836814761161804,
-0.47351691126823425,
-0.3070499002933502,
0.28452029824256897,
0.2119821459054947,
0.12463460862636566,
0.2420356571674347,
0.45084384083747864,
0.06150383502244949,
-0.3076658546924591,
0.17274683713912964,
-0.27486035227775574,
-0.4410659670829773,
0.47421491146087646,
0.46240541338920593,
0.2316897213459015,
0.12560735642910004,
-0.13664090633392334,
0.006250783801078796,
-0.7340620160102844,
-0.21137458086013794,
0.07771285623311996,
-0.28462591767311096,
0.05518351122736931,
0.5512911677360535,
0.10257577896118164,
0.5984336137771606,
0.17096009850502014,
-0.27392420172691345,
0.268349289894104,
-0.3091305196285248,
-0.253080815076828,
-0.00015651511785108596,
0.7122792601585388,
0.7217838168144226,
0.6482431888580322,
0.27936115860939026,
0.09000643342733383,
0.4879070222377777,
0.54937344789505,
-0.5680550932884216,
-0.17447471618652344,
0.42436128854751587,
-0.4567338228225708,
-0.30238062143325806,
-0.5592178702354431,
-0.6536806225776672,
-0.6756677031517029,
-0.12376022338867188,
0.14819379150867462,
-0.3994121849536896,
0.018124191090464592,
0.28903302550315857,
0.16097156703472137,
0.26735156774520874,
0.4414571523666382,
-0.7263234257698059,
0.3781580328941345,
0.5420365929603577,
0.3096509277820587,
-0.2964138984680176,
0.08640198409557343,
-0.09891565144062042,
0.027862856164574623,
-0.4366280436515808,
0.6593036651611328,
-0.6404796242713928,
-0.5428094267845154,
0.006937534548342228,
-0.23076637089252472,
-0.11667057871818542,
-0.8311818242073059,
0.8391406536102295,
-0.34385359287261963,
0.35746869444847107,
-0.6149609088897705,
-0.6163114905357361,
-0.09984403103590012,
0.3922865390777588,
-0.3659502863883972,
0.6230451464653015,
-0.047119855880737305,
-0.814838171005249,
0.5628984570503235,
-0.49450400471687317,
-0.32634851336479187,
-0.1775815784931183,
-0.8381444215774536,
-0.4429784119129181,
0.10277379304170609,
0.521960973739624,
0.30641913414001465,
-0.7507436871528625,
0.4549115002155304,
-0.25059762597084045,
-0.21426139771938324,
0.5826264023780823,
-0.6623924374580383,
0.8698446154594421,
0.037498682737350464,
-0.3916131854057312,
-0.0893673226237297,
-0.35972893238067627,
0.1911652833223343,
0.13665136694908142,
-0.4739498794078827,
-0.4450603425502777,
0.023833760991692543,
0.028907617554068565,
0.41992780566215515,
0.09686186164617538,
-0.5984987616539001,
0.0664789006114006,
-0.27487248182296753,
0.3883160948753357,
0.8712288737297058,
0.14730143547058105,
0.26489266753196716,
-0.47619038820266724,
0.5725792646408081,
0.20625826716423035,
0.44798576831817627,
0.2206401824951172,
-0.7381725907325745,
-0.5080601572990417,
-0.29220202565193176,
0.13519619405269623,
0.47372719645500183,
-0.6497368216514587,
0.04026903584599495,
-0.1335151195526123,
-0.28675734996795654,
-0.6610555648803711,
-0.00554737588390708,
0.5755333304405212,
0.751500129699707,
0.32793834805488586,
-0.5556203126907349,
-0.21456217765808105,
-1.1450365781784058,
-0.6751160025596619,
-0.1635274589061737,
-0.10645066946744919,
0.6984713673591614,
0.42398130893707275,
-0.3268553614616394,
0.6356754899024963,
-0.5603044629096985,
-0.45967355370521545,
0.18285083770751953,
-0.2864578366279602,
0.2558448910713196,
0.3597674071788788,
0.5332364439964294,
-0.5237861275672913,
-0.21679487824440002,
-0.37059125304222107,
-0.6831123232841492,
-0.478848934173584,
-0.18116611242294312,
-0.033535536378622055,
0.22120890021324158,
0.21006500720977783,
-0.7760119438171387,
0.2649206221103668,
0.5948168635368347,
-0.35393497347831726,
0.5149543285369873,
-0.04221779853105545,
0.16717207431793213,
-0.7474114298820496,
-0.22217300534248352,
-0.009033150039613247,
-0.02817225083708763,
-0.5733017325401306,
-0.1500193476676941,
0.11231853067874908,
0.41113534569740295,
-0.38410472869873047,
0.5230465531349182,
-0.4215868413448334,
-0.012184349820017815,
-0.17404404282569885,
0.07741670310497284,
-0.06892119348049164,
0.26843374967575073,
0.0458642914891243,
0.6008527278900146,
0.44847655296325684,
-0.4745214283466339,
-0.09109346568584442,
0.17857298254966736,
-0.33598220348358154,
0.8386016488075256,
-0.5105295777320862,
0.2800327241420746,
0.023448001593351364,
0.45614632964134216,
-0.5311808586120605,
0.019491486251354218,
0.2537685036659241,
-0.3539680242538452,
0.149562805891037,
0.03316124901175499,
-0.3508164584636688,
-0.3554132878780365,
-0.21411475539207458,
0.7209873199462891,
0.5257045030593872,
-0.16270184516906738,
0.4445866644382477,
0.6344104409217834,
-0.11984043568372726,
-0.6763485670089722,
-0.7715497016906738,
-0.03504320606589317,
0.01736643724143505,
-0.49792200326919556,
0.26506197452545166,
-0.27390626072883606,
-0.4130735993385315,
-0.2948022782802582,
-0.2912687361240387,
-0.13494344055652618,
-0.14593514800071716,
0.3425617814064026,
0.5039721131324768,
-0.12495101988315582,
0.022988732904195786,
0.052324485033750534,
0.05891655385494232,
0.4473191797733307,
-0.24308374524116516,
0.6036478877067566,
0.12346179783344269,
-0.5410444140434265,
-0.1674589365720749,
0.13303154706954956,
0.7651225924491882,
-0.10595519840717316,
0.494159072637558,
0.2377927005290985,
-0.4691859781742096,
0.16782033443450928,
-1.0906469821929932,
-0.34747329354286194,
-0.4070947766304016,
0.4841279685497284,
-0.23038461804389954,
-0.9612705707550049,
0.39156466722488403,
0.07227644324302673,
0.07725624740123749,
0.21733619272708893,
1.2123502492904663,
-0.12774866819381714,
1.0110732316970825,
-0.01689249277114868,
-0.15567414462566376,
0.14953993260860443,
0.19650378823280334,
-0.10982386022806168,
-1.0470027923583984,
-0.1655019074678421,
-0.25543537735939026,
-0.034207768738269806,
-0.5300864577293396,
-0.8488308787345886,
0.5786911249160767,
-0.5715911984443665,
-0.1988833099603653,
-0.3725626468658447,
-0.5095850229263306,
0.3317281901836395,
0.34414494037628174,
0.30160656571388245,
0.3245246112346649,
-0.23380790650844574,
-0.46367746591567993,
-0.27815648913383484,
-0.614483118057251,
-0.46482592821121216,
1.4984145164489746,
0.4483548402786255,
0.7853618860244751,
-0.10397087782621384,
0.358091801404953,
0.1684195101261139,
0.4516632556915283,
-0.5207998752593994,
0.48424986004829407,
0.09895870834589005,
-1.0896714925765991,
-0.006010128650814295,
-0.463310569524765,
-0.790861964225769,
0.4760895371437073,
-0.2454928755760193,
-0.44766712188720703,
-0.018602272495627403,
0.04958499222993851,
-0.14005611836910248,
0.06670919060707092,
-0.5223614573478699,
0.5225017666816711,
-0.3876219391822815,
-0.3160812556743622,
-0.2847898006439209,
-0.594774603843689,
0.5987885594367981,
-0.4039664566516876,
0.3856308162212372,
-0.2855122983455658,
-0.24109001457691193,
0.7329359650611877,
-0.33035558462142944,
0.8761575222015381,
-0.1587866097688675,
-0.19752056896686554,
0.11040961742401123,
0.026155170053243637,
0.2488187551498413,
0.22619636356830597,
-0.028393305838108063,
0.3588859438896179,
0.17522789537906647,
-0.5863001346588135,
-0.3311464786529541,
0.714625895023346,
-0.7634201645851135,
-0.7029414176940918,
-0.6860844492912292,
-0.7730986475944519,
-0.6279489994049072,
0.18864253163337708,
0.180825337767601,
0.21963246166706085,
-0.2814166843891144,
-0.3541131317615509,
0.7244982719421387,
-0.5511885285377502,
-0.0004705777973867953,
0.7769214510917664,
-0.06644557416439056,
-0.23573420941829681,
0.10912243276834488,
0.19688297808170319,
0.3908563554286957,
-0.10146975517272949,
0.15604889392852783,
-0.18787451088428497,
-0.6923889517784119,
-0.3478761911392212,
0.5221959948539734,
-0.6711931824684143,
0.022767333313822746,
-0.5048989653587341,
-0.05550287291407585,
-0.20540998876094818,
-0.015099750831723213,
-0.4011284410953522,
-0.1770533174276352,
0.015347238630056381,
-0.010682688094675541,
0.15003269910812378,
0.7170528173446655,
0.5939479470252991,
0.07369156926870346,
-0.5300008654594421,
0.14577889442443848,
0.013107848353683949,
0.337640643119812,
-0.21884915232658386,
-0.4355773329734802,
0.11710157245397568,
-0.07427135854959488,
-0.327435702085495,
-0.9199305176734924,
0.030313530936837196,
-0.18846553564071655,
0.6729443073272705,
0.2906072735786438,
-0.024833234027028084,
0.375939279794693,
-0.807027280330658,
0.7776651978492737,
0.2230295091867447,
-0.823807418346405,
0.41766446828842163,
-0.4440477788448334,
0.4685116708278656,
0.5797848105430603,
0.2275911569595337,
-0.38695842027664185,
-0.557609498500824,
-0.5583438873291016,
-0.5181353092193604,
0.3157966732978821,
0.1999276727437973,
0.09954854100942612,
-0.24474048614501953,
0.6705717444419861,
0.007200848776847124,
0.18699069321155548,
-0.6333953738212585,
-0.2945948541164398,
0.1965036541223526,
-0.3306798040866852,
0.08591608703136444,
-0.3443329334259033,
-0.3369581699371338,
-0.06448036432266235,
0.4560593366622925,
-0.09352369606494904,
0.14373330771923065,
0.3062472641468048,
-0.03402256220579147,
0.0683060809969902,
0.46350598335266113,
0.702467143535614,
0.6541839241981506,
-0.13772641122341156,
0.12846682965755463,
0.47555622458457947,
-0.9934214353561401,
0.08998844772577286,
-0.18665507435798645,
-0.20996233820915222,
-0.2497062385082245,
0.360372394323349,
0.2990950644016266,
0.0020575339440256357,
-0.9410173296928406,
0.6463648080825806,
-0.1536729484796524,
-0.17321068048477173,
-0.3269217610359192,
-0.037522170692682266,
0.14019009470939636,
0.23663516342639923,
0.024191739037632942,
0.19758646190166473,
0.1141391173005104,
-0.4979442358016968,
0.14751246571540833,
0.6492626070976257,
-0.5772786736488342,
-0.07552595436573029,
0.7932977676391602,
0.16824807226657867,
0.09895633161067963,
0.5275822281837463,
0.4361113905906677,
-0.5275436639785767,
0.5115159153938293,
0.421291708946228,
0.4822200536727905,
-0.3034861981868744,
-0.17013326287269592,
0.10324563831090927,
0.5843406915664673,
-0.05851142480969429,
0.3437606990337372,
0.34967535734176636,
-0.8252840638160706,
-0.38847318291664124,
-0.14224477112293243,
-0.48424550890922546,
0.06760205328464508,
-0.6853910088539124,
-0.023037677630782127,
-0.7561204433441162,
-0.8287808895111084,
-0.09626849740743637,
0.0228313896805048,
-0.7750662565231323,
0.39885422587394714,
0.22043125331401825,
0.8384221792221069,
-0.6598668098449707,
0.937628984451294,
0.7447613477706909,
-0.36971691250801086,
-0.5139207243919373,
0.05850832909345627,
0.3690430819988251,
-1.1151964664459229,
0.38447484374046326,
-0.10099906474351883,
0.12893471121788025,
-0.5306156277656555,
-0.3819016218185425,
-0.5701916217803955,
1.0843827724456787,
0.4470231831073761,
-0.5318780541419983,
0.053788501769304276,
0.24744154512882233,
0.5477113723754883,
-0.4373581111431122,
0.4692724049091339,
0.814194917678833,
0.36716988682746887,
-0.27069374918937683,
-1.189413070678711,
0.40457460284233093,
0.03330487385392189,
0.008988926187157631,
0.03634870797395706,
-0.5952290892601013,
0.8541480302810669,
-0.2878057658672333,
0.19559982419013977,
-0.2224069982767105,
0.0728648453950882,
0.5255095362663269,
0.34937363862991333,
0.4292747974395752,
0.47385373711586,
0.9348371624946594,
-0.05112551897764206,
1.2174242734909058,
-0.1581377387046814,
0.12790347635746002,
1.0248873233795166,
-0.6892248392105103,
0.5633293986320496,
0.9011566042900085,
-0.2137172967195511,
0.25728490948677063,
0.4591869115829468,
0.12636098265647888,
0.30082374811172485,
0.4858895242214203,
-0.22946017980575562,
-0.18980708718299866,
-0.18880753219127655,
-0.38549742102622986,
0.15260155498981476,
0.6567496061325073,
-0.6098931431770325,
0.20449528098106384,
-0.06827213615179062,
0.5108261704444885,
0.07794409245252609,
-0.2660106122493744,
0.4511447846889496,
0.39001864194869995,
-0.654582142829895,
0.4990464746952057,
-0.04099474474787712,
0.6251286268234253,
-0.4791637063026428,
0.17601868510246277,
-0.13629096746444702,
0.31886526942253113,
-0.1627005785703659,
-0.8110771775245667,
0.004732517525553703,
0.03369464725255966,
-0.32670316100120544,
0.05414401367306709,
0.5661712288856506,
-0.0716165229678154,
-0.38503003120422363,
0.362484872341156,
0.5795024633407593,
0.15579432249069214,
-0.10387155413627625,
-0.8916323781013489,
0.37442684173583984,
0.13664545118808746,
-0.23142307996749878,
0.5302447080612183,
0.041533876210451126,
-0.26617634296417236,
0.8377230763435364,
0.5808489322662354,
0.32943713665008545,
0.16642628610134125,
0.3185557723045349,
0.8444185256958008,
-0.5620015263557434,
-0.10953471064567566,
-0.8999451994895935,
0.10850859433412552,
-0.03189809247851372,
-0.2719231843948364,
0.5700404644012451,
0.3655993640422821,
0.5689178109169006,
-0.025392383337020874,
0.9364830851554871,
0.3539927899837494,
0.3765205144882202,
-0.7480696439743042,
0.7380897998809814,
-0.2610020935535431,
0.655219316482544,
-0.35505038499832153,
-0.8139054179191589,
-0.30799123644828796,
0.5492183566093445,
-0.6052027344703674,
0.4967251121997833,
0.7976155281066895,
0.7165202498435974,
0.24572502076625824,
0.03423193842172623,
0.34519779682159424,
0.4696006178855896,
0.3535560667514801,
0.9910290837287903,
0.7185831665992737,
-0.3526191711425781,
0.3271061182022095,
0.07584945112466812,
-0.4022889733314514,
-0.06094720587134361,
-0.6649339199066162,
-1.1511657238006592,
-0.10302195698022842,
-0.3226202726364136,
-0.52577143907547,
0.15772420167922974,
0.9186944365501404,
0.5476946830749512,
-0.6903359889984131,
-0.02339872345328331,
0.2804124653339386,
-0.09789805114269257,
-0.08852951228618622,
-0.17249427735805511,
0.3568841516971588,
-0.06392514705657959,
-0.5500954985618591,
0.086075559258461,
0.21812064945697784,
-0.23282842338085175,
-0.21217040717601776,
-0.06355568021535873,
-0.09363078325986862,
0.47886598110198975,
0.3165394961833954,
-0.13490885496139526,
-0.9563678503036499,
-0.3050621747970581,
0.002055179327726364,
-0.3419308364391327,
0.1424883008003235,
0.8548728823661804,
-0.788384735584259,
0.35273516178131104,
0.048126816749572754,
0.6580758094787598,
0.4787735939025879,
-0.20952655375003815,
0.6863695383071899,
-0.29355695843696594,
-0.1417677104473114,
0.4704137146472931,
0.4120033383369446,
0.20361441373825073,
-0.3060905933380127,
0.4301396310329437,
0.10035586357116699,
-0.6736854314804077,
-0.5662721395492554,
0.3139926493167877,
-1.0612003803253174,
-0.2990861237049103,
1.0786837339401245,
0.13477714359760284,
-0.01052288431674242,
-0.24237731099128723,
-0.45149505138397217,
-0.0007299701683223248,
-0.2667701542377472,
0.7012538909912109,
0.8545899391174316,
-0.2794357240200043,
-0.030438847839832306,
-1.2099735736846924,
0.5212998986244202,
0.9947010278701782,
-0.6704754829406738,
0.0016617837827652693,
0.5806517601013184,
0.7287293076515198,
-0.0991738885641098,
1.1542903184890747,
-0.6289307475090027,
0.3958283066749573,
-0.1462041288614273,
0.08980811387300491,
0.22529062628746033,
0.3037756085395813,
-0.30241724848747253,
-0.1590319275856018,
0.2906578481197357,
0.0029182040598243475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10958v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10958v2 | Relative Preference Optimization: Enhancing LLM Alignment through Contrasting Responses across Identical and Diverse Prompts | 2024-02-12T22:47:57 | 2024-05-27T20:05:03 | Yueqin Yin, Zhendong Wang, Yi Gu, Hai Huang, Weizhu Chen, Mingyuan Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the field of large language models (LLMs), aligning models with the
diverse preferences of users is a critical challenge. Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) has played a key role in this area. It works by using pairs
of preferences derived from the same prompts, and it functions without needing
an additional reward model. However, DPO does not fully reflect the complex
nature of human learning, which often involves understanding contrasting
responses to not only identical but also similar questions. To overcome this
shortfall, we propose Relative Preference Optimization (RPO). RPO is designed
to discern between more and less preferred responses derived from both
identical and related prompts. It introduces a contrastive weighting mechanism,
enabling the tuning of LLMs using a broader range of preference data, including
both paired and unpaired sets. This approach expands the learning capabilities
of the model, allowing it to leverage insights from a more varied set of
prompts. Through empirical tests, including dialogue and summarization tasks,
and evaluations using the AlpacaEval2.0 leaderboard, RPO has demonstrated a
superior ability to align LLMs with user preferences and to improve their
adaptability during the training process. Our code can be viewed at
https://github.com/yinyueqin/relative-preference-optimization | [
-0.4675585925579071,
-0.3800523579120636,
0.4658743143081665,
0.14848293364048004,
-0.3082554042339325,
0.14542271196842194,
-0.41890794038772583,
-0.2422117292881012,
0.2346349060535431,
0.36547988653182983,
-0.9065696597099304,
-0.25120657682418823,
-0.3718680739402771,
0.31108060479164124,
0.35736003518104553,
0.8421531319618225,
-0.1221102923154831,
0.142544224858284,
-0.49868589639663696,
-0.3214869797229767,
-0.6213135123252869,
-0.3819997012615204,
-0.6937534213066101,
-0.7693904638290405,
0.7186112403869629,
0.7911126017570496,
0.49325788021087646,
0.7445397973060608,
0.4527163803577423,
0.25713911652565,
-0.03619927167892456,
0.49329638481140137,
-0.6866558194160461,
0.49949124455451965,
-0.20237980782985687,
-0.5034633278846741,
-0.18013472855091095,
-0.18437311053276062,
0.5118767619132996,
0.5997708439826965,
-0.047082167118787766,
-0.016650211066007614,
0.3348955512046814,
1.0343568325042725,
-0.6441949605941772,
-0.22001595795154572,
-0.6652100682258606,
0.20267610251903534,
0.08709024637937546,
-0.43813687562942505,
-0.2095300704240799,
-0.4951661229133606,
0.30300402641296387,
-0.6857970952987671,
0.06781579554080963,
0.17347095906734467,
0.674865186214447,
0.42155927419662476,
-0.27156689763069153,
-0.13906234502792358,
-0.45963647961616516,
1.042620062828064,
-0.42701804637908936,
0.2778782248497009,
0.24193190038204193,
0.1556473672389984,
-0.25728639960289,
-0.21843475103378296,
-0.4808516502380371,
-0.35324618220329285,
-0.012439584359526634,
0.3225036561489105,
-0.041007764637470245,
-0.07978697866201401,
0.03382996469736099,
0.3347332179546356,
-0.5838521122932434,
0.5007591843605042,
0.17036956548690796,
-0.1682513803243637,
0.2955531179904938,
0.3398323357105255,
0.1117400974035263,
0.010383197106420994,
-0.4385053217411041,
-0.1625915914773941,
-0.5568744540214539,
0.3501305878162384,
0.7752264142036438,
0.5837284922599792,
-0.2334805727005005,
0.5163692235946655,
-0.3477335274219513,
0.7515735626220703,
0.3445594012737274,
-0.4476682245731354,
0.3789438009262085,
-0.21857744455337524,
0.17902402579784393,
-0.0016451954143121839,
0.7412741184234619,
0.7913574576377869,
0.23432409763336182,
0.06041845679283142,
-0.21848973631858826,
0.016241034492850304,
0.2015879601240158,
-0.7251699566841125,
-0.0054964954033494,
0.15169645845890045,
-0.4183122515678406,
-0.5078192353248596,
-0.08266053348779678,
-0.8344961404800415,
-0.555023193359375,
-0.5413021445274353,
0.018734736368060112,
-0.13589884340763092,
-0.09088709205389023,
0.17599017918109894,
-0.03301314637064934,
0.08570488542318344,
0.2877906858921051,
-1.2257122993469238,
0.2470923364162445,
0.8335694074630737,
0.7550034523010254,
-0.5294191241264343,
-0.3835848271846771,
-0.6584205627441406,
-0.09829423576593399,
-0.09186279028654099,
0.8280123472213745,
-0.7204597592353821,
-0.7157303690910339,
0.003953058272600174,
-0.38868045806884766,
0.13767707347869873,
-0.577409565448761,
0.8182234764099121,
-0.4968125522136688,
0.5472800135612488,
-0.5857096910476685,
-0.4191017746925354,
0.11087292432785034,
0.42049890756607056,
-0.3775157034397125,
0.9959589838981628,
-0.04846157506108284,
-0.9124850034713745,
0.22331774234771729,
-0.38488054275512695,
-0.2160290777683258,
-0.2638642191886902,
-0.3388969302177429,
-0.5293350219726562,
0.16182124614715576,
0.23762676119804382,
0.04971921816468239,
-0.39662304520606995,
0.0735439732670784,
-0.46543604135513306,
-0.40270957350730896,
0.1814250946044922,
-0.07732772827148438,
0.4379991590976715,
0.11231924593448639,
-0.15674830973148346,
0.5114951729774475,
-0.5195273756980896,
-0.1326584815979004,
0.31911545991897583,
-0.41056469082832336,
-0.46762973070144653,
0.00995281059294939,
-0.42495253682136536,
-0.024899179115891457,
0.5427538752555847,
-0.33220958709716797,
0.37071821093559265,
-0.4708555042743683,
0.12956006824970245,
1.1989455223083496,
-0.1848587840795517,
0.49725690484046936,
-0.477547287940979,
0.7350431680679321,
-0.2225639373064041,
0.16538995504379272,
0.22400237619876862,
-0.24331887066364288,
-0.6390100121498108,
-0.304144024848938,
0.12283998727798462,
0.5997596979141235,
-0.4333394467830658,
0.7561275959014893,
-0.30972820520401,
-0.12383107841014862,
-0.5255616903305054,
0.2857334017753601,
0.40829411149024963,
1.1951953172683716,
0.2456502467393875,
-0.24352549016475677,
-0.5162525177001953,
-1.215508222579956,
0.04299091175198555,
-0.3402968943119049,
-0.08333712816238403,
0.6794114708900452,
-0.12655112147331238,
-0.14886142313480377,
0.9641815423965454,
-0.933411180973053,
-0.10805990546941757,
-0.270515114068985,
-0.2874956429004669,
0.33330056071281433,
0.2047036588191986,
0.5021824240684509,
-0.7101982235908508,
-0.6967791318893433,
0.03972015902400017,
-0.30533069372177124,
-0.6139801740646362,
0.06742584705352783,
-0.4167526066303253,
-0.07542058080434799,
0.09020876884460449,
-0.17648741602897644,
-0.3807015120983124,
0.5248661041259766,
0.03204907104372978,
0.6468502879142761,
-0.16964487731456757,
0.1858387440443039,
-1.0379648208618164,
0.08143942803144455,
0.0004743211902678013,
-0.2115762084722519,
-0.3459514379501343,
-0.043405234813690186,
-0.014035239815711975,
0.06319359689950943,
-0.22929488122463226,
0.6633159518241882,
-0.3220672905445099,
0.004817681387066841,
-0.49448105692863464,
0.3263995051383972,
0.19431529939174652,
0.6324543952941895,
0.2051095962524414,
1.0280494689941406,
0.5966728329658508,
-0.4902985692024231,
0.5380009412765503,
0.3164835572242737,
-0.11030419915914536,
0.619331419467926,
-0.6148771047592163,
0.3754131495952606,
-0.11415527760982513,
0.11848181486129761,
-0.9677724838256836,
-0.01362552773207426,
0.507847011089325,
-0.3041377067565918,
0.29300469160079956,
-0.0858263298869133,
-0.13469572365283966,
-0.15912501513957977,
-0.8794111013412476,
0.4653967022895813,
0.467223584651947,
-0.7252046465873718,
0.4790215790271759,
0.22943542897701263,
-0.2595570385456085,
-1.0278903245925903,
-0.22097381949424744,
-0.347951203584671,
-0.5709784626960754,
-0.3307495713233948,
0.4090842604637146,
-0.3099319338798523,
-0.289551705121994,
-0.29488781094551086,
-0.36648422479629517,
0.41319218277931213,
0.09594931453466415,
0.1251785159111023,
0.4767223298549652,
-0.11297829449176788,
0.23755484819412231,
0.08119194954633713,
-0.32586923241615295,
-0.21172292530536652,
-0.17099511623382568,
0.7809450030326843,
-0.019174786284565926,
-0.1644410490989685,
-0.35517236590385437,
0.3623252213001251,
0.1574142873287201,
-0.09792220592498779,
0.44696956872940063,
0.2793981730937958,
0.13294801115989685,
-0.23616209626197815,
-0.46682432293891907,
-0.19715771079063416,
-0.5363488793373108,
0.3602787256240845,
-0.6183871626853943,
-0.8726099729537964,
0.4835120737552643,
0.018267542123794556,
0.11993800103664398,
0.1689268946647644,
0.6819880604743958,
0.03435447812080383,
0.7556648254394531,
0.5585227012634277,
-0.3637620508670807,
0.8495302796363831,
0.2206958681344986,
-0.11105131357908249,
-0.9690613150596619,
-0.18514002859592438,
-0.7254225611686707,
-0.46059584617614746,
-0.43345004320144653,
-0.12316635996103287,
0.16291283071041107,
-0.12436734139919281,
-0.114864282310009,
-0.0013851483818143606,
-0.6743389964103699,
0.6611467003822327,
0.6697738766670227,
0.2666603922843933,
0.25002139806747437,
0.1591278612613678,
-0.33056995272636414,
-0.242264062166214,
-0.4662158787250519,
-0.5945626497268677,
1.0438421964645386,
0.3520514667034149,
0.8990042209625244,
0.08163600414991379,
0.8390992879867554,
0.1533593237400055,
0.07910822331905365,
-1.0343595743179321,
0.493632972240448,
-0.23324424028396606,
-0.03128974512219429,
-0.0855415090918541,
-0.6903976798057556,
-0.8969997763633728,
0.3762159049510956,
-0.2577281594276428,
-0.5941306352615356,
0.13047567009925842,
0.3423502743244171,
-0.45999157428741455,
-0.03485788032412529,
-0.6866018176078796,
0.6716517210006714,
-0.3284607529640198,
-0.4556156098842621,
-0.13732294738292694,
-0.8271546959877014,
0.16855204105377197,
-0.03609278425574303,
-0.20510438084602356,
-0.2445169985294342,
-0.44408127665519714,
0.5451400279998779,
-0.115521140396595,
0.7681612372398376,
0.037581805139780045,
-0.20594322681427002,
-0.1025080755352974,
-0.0887555330991745,
0.4120749533176422,
0.06463797390460968,
-0.2499702274799347,
-0.22188492119312286,
-0.4174611270427704,
-0.2688162326812744,
-0.7120489478111267,
1.0631998777389526,
-1.0341135263442993,
-0.8841325640678406,
-0.23597638309001923,
-0.4642404317855835,
-0.5524786710739136,
0.046268660575151443,
0.20500905811786652,
0.31080523133277893,
-0.15281976759433746,
-0.15013355016708374,
0.6818799376487732,
-0.07097730040550232,
0.11725537478923798,
0.5580363869667053,
-0.22297708690166473,
-0.6403519511222839,
0.7202655673027039,
-0.5606180429458618,
0.4170199930667877,
0.8301162123680115,
0.7480020523071289,
-0.5051819682121277,
-0.6735334396362305,
-0.21152043342590332,
0.34848347306251526,
-0.7286328673362732,
-0.21618807315826416,
-0.4897821545600891,
0.37726643681526184,
-0.3706839978694916,
-0.1938713937997818,
-0.1905600130558014,
-0.4576497972011566,
-0.46368005871772766,
-0.062499914318323135,
0.13532273471355438,
0.19003020226955414,
-0.004975869320333004,
0.28525832295417786,
-0.48437419533729553,
0.4542098939418793,
0.558590292930603,
0.2171090692281723,
-0.14594770967960358,
-0.8084480166435242,
0.07300051301717758,
-0.08814578503370285,
-0.41170090436935425,
-0.6053521037101746,
-0.04047200828790665,
0.07503502070903778,
0.6869795918464661,
0.49664634466171265,
0.2241208851337433,
0.6826555728912354,
-0.481920063495636,
0.4738903045654297,
0.34195488691329956,
-0.7335425615310669,
0.6448676586151123,
-0.09945079684257507,
0.23061706125736237,
1.0758681297302246,
0.5388893485069275,
-0.5259281992912292,
-0.03252845257520676,
-0.15730415284633636,
-0.6994739174842834,
0.6775174736976624,
-0.09116336703300476,
0.2871834933757782,
0.21977248787879944,
0.5146558880805969,
0.48453328013420105,
0.10411442071199417,
-0.7237370610237122,
-0.4134192168712616,
-0.06658776849508286,
-0.31883668899536133,
0.023945769295096397,
-0.4128003418445587,
-0.40124502778053284,
0.09922619163990021,
0.8264370560646057,
-0.2549302577972412,
-0.1490759551525116,
0.11349982023239136,
0.29047805070877075,
-0.18311607837677002,
0.1443762332201004,
0.7500503063201904,
0.5643635392189026,
-0.3886008560657501,
0.06044022738933563,
0.009220286272466183,
-0.3513120114803314,
0.1469234824180603,
0.0477982759475708,
-0.11732809990644455,
-0.28764766454696655,
0.3151264786720276,
0.8270150423049927,
-0.16633328795433044,
-0.7309087514877319,
0.27217695116996765,
-0.2855660915374756,
0.05016114562749863,
0.1810426563024521,
0.2616821825504303,
-0.033356618136167526,
0.1376238614320755,
0.08114365488290787,
-0.10884847491979599,
0.11245360225439072,
-0.5246244668960571,
0.027654027566313744,
0.5372264981269836,
-0.2998693883419037,
-0.08969343453645706,
0.3519347608089447,
0.5208836793899536,
-0.47899413108825684,
0.3876991271972656,
0.111629419028759,
-0.5924938321113586,
0.4257907271385193,
0.49317947030067444,
0.8913494944572449,
-0.2764733135700226,
0.05123047158122063,
0.29768747091293335,
-0.023543396964669228,
0.032102346420288086,
0.0030258509796112776,
-0.22431980073451996,
-1.1522592306137085,
-0.06788896769285202,
-0.4086633026599884,
-0.7353799939155579,
-0.0026902509853243828,
-0.6738572120666504,
0.4900742769241333,
-0.44635674357414246,
-0.21383371949195862,
-0.05963599309325218,
0.22787900269031525,
-0.2532455325126648,
-0.02210107445716858,
0.10136382281780243,
0.5353641510009766,
-0.7329806685447693,
0.721145510673523,
0.7863277196884155,
-0.1861308217048645,
-0.41596975922584534,
0.2639195919036865,
0.09229664504528046,
-1.2124046087265015,
0.48137983679771423,
0.1264520138502121,
-0.5206798315048218,
-0.22949625551700592,
-0.14536510407924652,
-0.43178439140319824,
0.856731653213501,
0.5584617853164673,
-0.7492133378982544,
0.16352754831314087,
0.006085061002522707,
0.4524933099746704,
-0.5960578322410583,
0.17799676954746246,
0.35533571243286133,
0.21212047338485718,
0.3077569603919983,
-0.8022048473358154,
0.06747674942016602,
0.004332858603447676,
0.025003042072057724,
0.3190835416316986,
-0.811450719833374,
0.35863247513771057,
-0.21784217655658722,
-0.012154828757047653,
0.04360100254416466,
0.5342344641685486,
0.6185118556022644,
0.0889640748500824,
0.7505262494087219,
0.4632547199726105,
0.6837689876556396,
0.12557123601436615,
0.8381964564323425,
-0.23851102590560913,
0.230400949716568,
1.3970590829849243,
-0.577934205532074,
0.6345056891441345,
0.8574402332305908,
-0.2168317288160324,
0.3620305061340332,
0.8043543100357056,
0.1299799382686615,
0.7848430871963501,
0.3158416152000427,
-0.38458937406539917,
-0.35437050461769104,
-0.45023876428604126,
-0.4998469948768616,
0.28349754214286804,
-0.12409008294343948,
-0.23577100038528442,
0.008323502726852894,
-0.28344419598579407,
-0.07869474589824677,
0.5250967741012573,
-0.04663824290037155,
0.9048226475715637,
0.05061417073011398,
-0.7798506021499634,
0.5014979839324951,
-0.022458219900727272,
0.8858594298362732,
-0.8351842761039734,
0.19043280184268951,
-0.599265456199646,
0.16791804134845734,
-0.09711532294750214,
-0.7346582412719727,
-0.05775414779782295,
-0.04897516965866089,
-0.35619673132896423,
-0.2627139091491699,
0.48052793741226196,
-0.4002084732055664,
-0.26580747961997986,
0.3355046510696411,
0.2776319682598114,
-0.24102532863616943,
0.15828000009059906,
-0.8994126915931702,
0.26166898012161255,
0.37872299551963806,
-0.17414091527462006,
0.38964393734931946,
0.26123711466789246,
0.2450982630252838,
0.8425877690315247,
0.4572221040725708,
0.12898105382919312,
-0.5368446707725525,
0.3631526827812195,
0.9414235949516296,
-0.4288170635700226,
-0.6454288959503174,
-1.0344901084899902,
0.22061637043952942,
-0.1526666283607483,
-0.4953809082508087,
0.6316308975219727,
0.7591989636421204,
0.6040705442428589,
-0.06467606872320175,
0.46492496132850647,
0.4408734142780304,
0.6008703708648682,
-0.6889916062355042,
0.05357584357261658,
-0.7205804586410522,
0.4749602675437927,
-0.2106907069683075,
-1.2030844688415527,
-0.16560453176498413,
0.5552300810813904,
-0.25710585713386536,
-0.09037905186414719,
0.5706247687339783,
0.7952892184257507,
-0.05642477050423622,
-0.1655045598745346,
0.17485639452934265,
-0.3698343336582184,
0.25669118762016296,
0.6849923133850098,
1.0069618225097656,
0.1568971425294876,
0.575918436050415,
-0.3842979073524475,
-0.41422849893569946,
-0.20468582212924957,
-1.0204252004623413,
-0.9160899519920349,
-0.27178817987442017,
-0.375649094581604,
-0.1268884241580963,
0.007713127415627241,
1.3326853513717651,
0.45855584740638733,
-0.63382887840271,
-0.4222249388694763,
0.2109382599592209,
0.4410751760005951,
-0.06875619292259216,
-0.19574731588363647,
0.25926563143730164,
-0.3332821726799011,
-0.9009805917739868,
0.38269856572151184,
0.26264193654060364,
0.2020406424999237,
-0.00937312189489603,
-0.26429659128189087,
0.11744270473718643,
0.005991447251290083,
0.33370441198349,
0.29002073407173157,
-0.6542111039161682,
-0.31947943568229675,
0.04359849914908409,
-0.11630421876907349,
0.41663840413093567,
0.8810073137283325,
-0.5296469330787659,
0.4446372091770172,
0.6390289068222046,
0.7020391821861267,
0.21621344983577728,
0.447206974029541,
0.7280730605125427,
-0.8100652098655701,
0.19340990483760834,
0.2696758210659027,
0.4216057062149048,
0.4933928847312927,
-0.5051014423370361,
0.4362328350543976,
0.13864439725875854,
-0.5646156072616577,
-0.7947724461555481,
0.5688422322273254,
-1.2541942596435547,
-0.20375286042690277,
1.1719661951065063,
-0.06716322153806686,
0.13569238781929016,
0.20698438584804535,
-0.5573315024375916,
-0.015882709994912148,
-0.816836953163147,
0.9618051648139954,
0.7388408184051514,
-0.42031270265579224,
0.04194172844290733,
-0.020383313298225403,
0.4074440002441406,
0.8282214999198914,
-0.732020378112793,
0.13650763034820557,
0.5802315473556519,
0.321256548166275,
0.05428817495703697,
0.653104305267334,
0.19286715984344482,
-0.05098102241754532,
-0.321005642414093,
-0.01927468739449978,
-0.1491055190563202,
-0.13747283816337585,
-0.5761452913284302,
0.09552184492349625,
0.33919665217399597,
-0.5446282625198364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08100v1 | Investigating the Impact of Data Contamination of Large Language Models in Text-to-SQL Translation | 2024-02-12T22:35:40 | 2024-02-12T22:35:40 | Federico Ranaldi, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Dario Onorati, Leonardo Ranaldi, Cristina Giannone, Andrea Favalli, Raniero Romagnoli, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding textual description to generate code seems to be an achieved
capability of instruction-following Large Language Models (LLMs) in zero-shot
scenario. However, there is a severe possibility that this translation ability
may be influenced by having seen target textual descriptions and the related
code. This effect is known as Data Contamination.
In this study, we investigate the impact of Data Contamination on the
performance of GPT-3.5 in the Text-to-SQL code-generating tasks. Hence, we
introduce a novel method to detect Data Contamination in GPTs and examine
GPT-3.5's Text-to-SQL performances using the known Spider Dataset and our new
unfamiliar dataset Termite. Furthermore, we analyze GPT-3.5's efficacy on
databases with modified information via an adversarial table disconnection
(ATD) approach, complicating Text-to-SQL tasks by removing structural pieces of
information from the database. Our results indicate a significant performance
drop in GPT-3.5 on the unfamiliar Termite dataset, even with ATD modifications,
highlighting the effect of Data Contamination on LLMs in Text-to-SQL
translation tasks. | [
-0.2636156678199768,
-1.1053733825683594,
0.6043714284896851,
-0.25681450963020325,
-0.47587355971336365,
0.0009537373553030193,
0.04217865690588951,
-0.6092474460601807,
-0.21200159192085266,
0.8851647973060608,
-0.36744973063468933,
-0.7320995330810547,
-0.714432418346405,
0.13213075697422028,
-0.8425931334495544,
1.3930785655975342,
-0.1666913628578186,
-0.35924068093299866,
-0.027638019993901253,
0.4064061641693115,
-0.38401007652282715,
-0.7161617279052734,
-0.38163068890571594,
-0.14206892251968384,
0.3046206831932068,
0.1321602463722229,
0.9108177423477173,
0.9920181035995483,
0.6718467473983765,
0.25853580236434937,
-0.2935113310813904,
0.03952888399362564,
-0.4917379319667816,
0.05736694112420082,
-0.330383837223053,
-0.566247284412384,
-0.37114056944847107,
-0.26020434498786926,
0.49432748556137085,
0.3519599437713623,
-0.030145462602376938,
-0.10040018707513809,
0.03539983183145523,
0.6814087629318237,
-0.4464725852012634,
0.26772940158843994,
-0.799548864364624,
0.045405078679323196,
-0.5524898171424866,
-0.34503254294395447,
-0.606172502040863,
-0.23134537041187286,
-0.1151215210556984,
-0.4780314862728119,
0.47049659490585327,
-0.25035199522972107,
0.9041123390197754,
0.3843022882938385,
-0.5419334173202515,
-0.14411699771881104,
-0.9772366285324097,
0.37931981682777405,
-0.6687772274017334,
-0.0669434443116188,
0.39765238761901855,
0.0331304706633091,
-0.4230508804321289,
-0.4595814049243927,
-0.7181940078735352,
-0.04466636851429939,
-0.24573850631713867,
-0.27047014236450195,
-0.1275252252817154,
-0.02693062461912632,
0.2915140390396118,
0.26551553606987,
-0.6828873753547668,
-0.0741841197013855,
-0.3567037582397461,
0.015753980726003647,
0.5350997447967529,
0.1854681521654129,
0.36562636494636536,
-0.4469051659107208,
-0.3110327422618866,
0.029925387352705002,
-1.0133841037750244,
-0.5936380624771118,
0.1880682110786438,
0.3961683213710785,
0.012890573590993881,
0.6812475323677063,
-0.09615686535835266,
0.6700400710105896,
-0.3738546669483185,
0.27297499775886536,
0.06460273265838623,
-0.5724116563796997,
-0.3576743006706238,
-0.09367062151432037,
0.8999684453010559,
0.17787384986877441,
0.2336127609014511,
-0.5604239106178284,
-0.18249955773353577,
-0.11929994821548462,
0.37447211146354675,
-0.752930760383606,
-0.29123252630233765,
0.2811886668205261,
-0.1633072942495346,
-0.5145730376243591,
-0.19700868427753448,
-0.6400034427642822,
-0.6772367358207703,
-0.0733024999499321,
0.6641417145729065,
-0.37591347098350525,
-0.16753675043582916,
0.1579979658126831,
0.24993303418159485,
-0.09659535437822342,
0.29336443543434143,
-0.6793512105941772,
0.27191922068595886,
0.6872127652168274,
0.8041696548461914,
-0.5414506196975708,
-0.11796505749225616,
-0.4198392927646637,
0.5071854591369629,
-0.4461953341960907,
0.5491958856582642,
-0.19657395780086517,
-0.566697895526886,
-0.15145383775234222,
-0.06642856448888779,
-0.20891989767551422,
-0.6786762475967407,
0.299209326505661,
-0.6298068761825562,
0.3137665390968323,
0.023622596636414528,
-0.6331306099891663,
-0.3187793493270874,
0.05927085503935814,
-0.9748122692108154,
0.7927317023277283,
0.11066653579473495,
-0.8800039291381836,
0.40919941663742065,
-0.6019989848136902,
-0.6530962586402893,
0.2546897828578949,
-0.23978300392627716,
-0.5460811853408813,
0.033367134630680084,
0.09535016864538193,
0.48545128107070923,
-0.21078462898731232,
0.1442306637763977,
-0.10618531703948975,
-0.6780639290809631,
0.28875240683555603,
-0.4731757640838623,
0.4552895128726959,
0.11588694900274277,
-0.6511572599411011,
-0.1624021977186203,
-0.6905645132064819,
0.05852492153644562,
0.12970860302448273,
-0.17587924003601074,
-0.16776354610919952,
0.26613447070121765,
-0.06368432193994522,
0.3401067554950714,
-0.04801644757390022,
-0.25242552161216736,
0.26426246762275696,
-0.3156139850616455,
0.1333613395690918,
0.7096521854400635,
0.3833814561367035,
-0.07171264290809631,
-0.19935788214206696,
0.4490586519241333,
0.2288602590560913,
-0.03212771937251091,
0.08921799808740616,
-0.40328168869018555,
-0.5963317155838013,
-0.10670320689678192,
0.17074760794639587,
0.5992650985717773,
-1.2219067811965942,
0.20551256835460663,
-0.56490159034729,
-0.47564607858657837,
-0.17493022978305817,
-0.14275892078876495,
0.4395478665828705,
0.30287936329841614,
0.5981672406196594,
0.036237217485904694,
-0.13911575078964233,
-0.8739833235740662,
-0.37866902351379395,
-0.015274076722562313,
-0.16887566447257996,
0.2264423370361328,
0.83733731508255,
-0.14886316657066345,
0.7737060189247131,
-0.7330000400543213,
-0.3338348865509033,
-0.03623345494270325,
0.0251793060451746,
0.31735971570014954,
0.5810117125511169,
0.29235363006591797,
-0.4277876019477844,
-0.4857770800590515,
0.1471838504076004,
-0.7198401093482971,
0.11205226927995682,
-0.1557607799768448,
-0.10252536833286285,
0.4839881658554077,
0.4930915832519531,
-0.6501385569572449,
0.552127480506897,
0.423274964094162,
-0.36140352487564087,
0.5950025916099548,
-0.17529675364494324,
0.4978315532207489,
-1.0930323600769043,
0.3064223825931549,
-0.06793274730443954,
-0.08408569544553757,
-0.8513857126235962,
0.12351882457733154,
0.1484050303697586,
-0.049604956060647964,
-0.6948127746582031,
0.02835880033671856,
-0.31098905205726624,
0.04275912418961525,
-0.05168509483337402,
0.3438320755958557,
0.006043713539838791,
0.282563179731369,
0.0756932944059372,
1.1712521314620972,
0.20695924758911133,
-0.44303956627845764,
0.06436434388160706,
0.36222994327545166,
-0.2611904740333557,
0.22890211641788483,
-0.5064921975135803,
0.34659573435783386,
0.2617517411708832,
0.1898435354232788,
-0.8752698302268982,
-0.10997610539197922,
0.38443654775619507,
-0.39667218923568726,
0.4961685240268707,
-0.42877456545829773,
-0.9038048386573792,
0.03961911052465439,
-0.20575328171253204,
0.21925394237041473,
0.0008429071167483926,
-0.40502429008483887,
0.1475561410188675,
0.039668869227170944,
-0.1595374047756195,
-0.4253615736961365,
-0.9651986360549927,
0.40348339080810547,
-0.3572598397731781,
-0.5508606433868408,
0.27406978607177734,
0.3214989900588989,
-0.02804221399128437,
-0.08988484740257263,
-0.20221790671348572,
-0.2386408895254135,
0.19413776695728302,
0.024733705446124077,
0.5454632043838501,
0.1336313933134079,
0.15077847242355347,
0.051522042602300644,
0.12065770477056503,
0.3137663006782532,
0.12999208271503448,
0.5671446323394775,
0.22360648214817047,
-0.29704558849334717,
-0.39509284496307373,
0.1861729770898819,
0.39960020780563354,
-0.10415872931480408,
1.1936606168746948,
0.19591747224330902,
-0.1816432625055313,
-0.05016011372208595,
-0.1749214082956314,
-0.03714841231703758,
-0.425231009721756,
0.6121618747711182,
-0.4211667478084564,
-0.41326993703842163,
0.4078238010406494,
0.2672290503978729,
-0.30431750416755676,
0.6723730564117432,
-0.02732153795659542,
0.09232167154550552,
0.900784969329834,
0.40450209379196167,
-0.0840206891298294,
0.3624003231525421,
-0.24953581392765045,
0.10317781567573547,
-0.7480952739715576,
-0.2529172897338867,
-0.6951742172241211,
0.09761154651641846,
-0.6889001131057739,
-0.6261835694313049,
0.17687565088272095,
-0.0228155218064785,
-0.2379918098449707,
0.4431056082248688,
-0.505837082862854,
0.6485723853111267,
0.018115656450390816,
0.2456739842891693,
0.5972027778625488,
0.11840373277664185,
0.08111553639173508,
-0.0001370049430988729,
-0.17856036126613617,
-0.5163217186927795,
1.3047765493392944,
0.05708863586187363,
0.6203049421310425,
0.29732173681259155,
0.7017366290092468,
0.43186306953430176,
0.12203526496887207,
-0.1098453626036644,
0.6784806847572327,
-0.5044668912887573,
-0.6146510243415833,
-0.08944084495306015,
-0.9077206254005432,
-0.7950474619865417,
0.18192166090011597,
0.04874611273407936,
-0.9002763628959656,
-0.1772049367427826,
-0.1642022728919983,
0.11479832977056503,
0.4085971415042877,
-0.7468592524528503,
0.8137917518615723,
-0.0006329808966256678,
-0.5970614552497864,
-0.14145401120185852,
-0.5338197946548462,
0.4063977003097534,
-0.4862360954284668,
0.20001310110092163,
0.10238935053348541,
-0.144611656665802,
0.6209142208099365,
-0.23092323541641235,
0.5398414731025696,
-0.1674729436635971,
-0.58045494556427,
-0.1360311657190323,
0.4599733352661133,
0.9066932201385498,
-0.05591807886958122,
-0.07689482718706131,
0.4235227108001709,
-0.1220313087105751,
-0.14546169340610504,
-0.3113762438297272,
0.5735409259796143,
-0.6313846111297607,
-0.4803178310394287,
-0.49779775738716125,
-0.6159706711769104,
-0.20954307913780212,
0.2716556489467621,
0.4123634099960327,
0.1269165575504303,
0.01464673038572073,
0.2361857295036316,
0.776085615158081,
-0.3892270624637604,
0.3649961054325104,
0.6601037383079529,
-0.23689979314804077,
-0.1961704045534134,
0.9606927037239075,
0.13781899213790894,
0.5964187979698181,
0.4755508303642273,
-0.4421299695968628,
-0.4194434881210327,
-0.8404836654663086,
-0.6186628341674805,
0.24000020325183868,
-0.4677373766899109,
-0.22662906348705292,
-0.45047181844711304,
-0.14398221671581268,
0.04409529268741608,
0.14663197100162506,
-0.2828506529331207,
-0.48494309186935425,
-0.4934470057487488,
0.003533381735906005,
0.38354021310806274,
0.9041527509689331,
0.4166129529476166,
0.48312097787857056,
-0.8297777771949768,
0.2165278047323227,
-0.35801875591278076,
0.4977181553840637,
-0.4344869554042816,
-0.474077433347702,
-0.41711321473121643,
0.21267452836036682,
-0.24207699298858643,
-1.1501680612564087,
0.2875860333442688,
0.10034715384244919,
0.2090190351009369,
0.044856831431388855,
-0.0867120772600174,
0.422576367855072,
-0.26650285720825195,
0.8926456570625305,
-0.20492273569107056,
-1.113495945930481,
0.5762423872947693,
-0.7968868613243103,
0.30556657910346985,
0.2963906228542328,
0.2322659194469452,
-0.4529363811016083,
-0.7698753476142883,
-0.47864171862602234,
-1.050044298171997,
0.9390001893043518,
0.5430276989936829,
-0.30674275755882263,
-0.04230483993887901,
0.47643446922302246,
-0.14991366863250732,
0.47247985005378723,
-0.7249516844749451,
-0.22803688049316406,
0.23522843420505524,
0.155935138463974,
-0.16822242736816406,
-0.0745619386434555,
-0.024213455617427826,
0.27019447088241577,
0.6911007761955261,
0.09716243296861649,
0.06810252368450165,
-0.24742813408374786,
-0.28947970271110535,
-0.030088024213910103,
0.3439810574054718,
0.5336716175079346,
0.37833356857299805,
-0.1429957002401352,
0.056325819343328476,
0.045244090259075165,
-0.7329814434051514,
0.03671713173389435,
0.3311634361743927,
-0.35662293434143066,
-0.09166975319385529,
0.3204174339771271,
0.3964851498603821,
-0.13603909313678741,
-0.42670056223869324,
0.31137189269065857,
-0.1538371592760086,
0.0019693791400641203,
0.22996817529201508,
0.10579627007246017,
-0.031245069578289986,
-0.24159206449985504,
0.416105717420578,
0.04763463884592056,
0.31663981080055237,
-0.3409040868282318,
0.524653971195221,
0.1970268189907074,
-0.19703271985054016,
0.02735612913966179,
0.658653199672699,
-0.0504412017762661,
0.2473382204771042,
0.7393834590911865,
0.0757436752319336,
-0.3850197494029999,
0.5896944999694824,
0.40984755754470825,
0.8241418600082397,
-0.3750970959663391,
0.1004500463604927,
-0.1668732464313507,
0.5357487201690674,
0.2120799571275711,
0.30655765533447266,
0.20730726420879364,
-0.36788004636764526,
-0.7116285562515259,
-0.24850793182849884,
-0.06952693313360214,
0.3249034583568573,
-0.6750041842460632,
0.08912237733602524,
0.015956701710820198,
0.023212973028421402,
-0.05875575169920921,
0.06595170497894287,
-0.2345251888036728,
0.2140958458185196,
-0.09465315192937851,
0.4166638255119324,
-0.9961509108543396,
0.8409597873687744,
0.23859402537345886,
-0.4079623818397522,
-0.8207463026046753,
0.3125532269477844,
0.07766717672348022,
-0.325330525636673,
0.4399655759334564,
0.0984487384557724,
-0.06749759614467621,
0.031752947717905045,
-0.0684940367937088,
-0.7031320333480835,
0.7675290703773499,
0.5697863101959229,
-0.24327822029590607,
0.014455997385084629,
0.6594685316085815,
0.57994145154953,
0.25007879734039307,
0.23382249474525452,
0.8862161040306091,
0.2680807113647461,
-0.08580746501684189,
-0.9157354831695557,
0.3896303176879883,
-0.21294067800045013,
0.1628856658935547,
0.7670406103134155,
-0.2605903744697571,
0.7291362285614014,
-0.03723287954926491,
-0.34616971015930176,
0.0034090064000338316,
0.13559655845165253,
0.06034284830093384,
-0.10620610415935516,
0.18524552881717682,
0.3414938151836395,
0.488137811422348,
-0.3176277279853821,
0.8905958533287048,
-0.2329258769750595,
0.5764334201812744,
1.3221700191497803,
-0.43034476041793823,
0.963618814945221,
0.403668612241745,
-0.31656908988952637,
0.31117886304855347,
0.5005651116371155,
-0.21570806205272675,
0.5057052373886108,
0.31402820348739624,
-0.45366474986076355,
0.34064215421676636,
0.0336855910718441,
-0.6174830794334412,
0.3780604898929596,
0.3518421947956085,
-0.5697673559188843,
-0.4267388880252838,
0.04569600895047188,
0.3787214756011963,
-0.06359834969043732,
0.03650094196200371,
0.9399203658103943,
-0.5380035042762756,
-0.5903425216674805,
0.8625081777572632,
-0.050474584102630615,
0.24406889081001282,
-0.40644752979278564,
-0.2629801034927368,
-0.3401217460632324,
0.32346802949905396,
-0.3690037727355957,
-1.0159541368484497,
0.5281665921211243,
0.08561388403177261,
-0.046583544462919235,
0.009293944574892521,
0.39112618565559387,
-0.4830437898635864,
-0.011379809118807316,
0.2616809606552124,
0.2946464717388153,
0.4077090322971344,
-0.47589021921157837,
-0.3237098157405853,
0.17813929915428162,
0.3272666335105896,
-0.3267384469509125,
0.4905777871608734,
0.489880234003067,
-0.04573395475745201,
0.6554547548294067,
0.5371123552322388,
0.25556132197380066,
-0.08206677436828613,
-0.13055194914340973,
0.985507071018219,
-0.48207491636276245,
-0.18854670226573944,
-1.0250648260116577,
0.2769297957420349,
0.07539846003055573,
0.15014056861400604,
0.8018022775650024,
1.057492971420288,
0.6490093469619751,
-0.20522451400756836,
0.7454339861869812,
-0.20515960454940796,
0.41261857748031616,
-0.5824626088142395,
0.9092767834663391,
-0.3270829916000366,
0.7690290808677673,
-0.4888204336166382,
-0.705559253692627,
-0.2964244484901428,
0.10927640646696091,
-0.3123028874397278,
0.03330955281853676,
1.0325857400894165,
0.8395618200302124,
0.12503644824028015,
0.13011585175991058,
0.16778914630413055,
0.47622060775756836,
0.7120079398155212,
0.46589764952659607,
0.3323308527469635,
-0.5462027192115784,
1.0521248579025269,
-0.16946223378181458,
-0.06818938255310059,
0.024734463542699814,
-0.7162311673164368,
-0.5736250877380371,
-0.40166470408439636,
-0.3354344964027405,
-0.5403724908828735,
0.4073367118835449,
0.185860276222229,
0.2283812314271927,
-0.553665041923523,
-0.06176605075597763,
-0.4712054431438446,
-0.018656697124242783,
-0.18023189902305603,
-0.22779400646686554,
0.7310023307800293,
-0.19268514215946198,
-0.5955551266670227,
0.31816792488098145,
-0.03522619232535362,
0.17685739696025848,
0.003924453165382147,
0.4747336804866791,
-0.22557581961154938,
-0.17239850759506226,
0.4276539087295532,
-0.1564987450838089,
-0.37972956895828247,
-0.2875899374485016,
-0.2671595811843872,
-0.2647368907928467,
-0.05251356214284897,
0.43590378761291504,
-0.6644645929336548,
0.4051109552383423,
0.227524071931839,
0.4135796129703522,
0.6836995482444763,
0.12374681234359741,
0.73580002784729,
-0.9922730922698975,
-0.1146964430809021,
0.1620239019393921,
0.00809948518872261,
0.25175386667251587,
-0.8070520758628845,
0.8328462243080139,
0.19293062388896942,
-0.5542827248573303,
-0.8052310347557068,
0.0723966732621193,
-0.5527855157852173,
-0.33106526732444763,
1.3028219938278198,
-0.17860400676727295,
-0.11953583359718323,
-0.21627609431743622,
-0.10322519391775131,
0.2877572178840637,
-0.22573640942573547,
0.9442422986030579,
0.771916925907135,
-0.03209667280316353,
0.04882274568080902,
-0.8688411712646484,
0.7151727676391602,
0.17608444392681122,
-1.1960002183914185,
0.4549044072628021,
0.6081142425537109,
0.3287324905395508,
-0.027910953387618065,
0.230290949344635,
-0.48386114835739136,
0.25822025537490845,
-0.015151710249483585,
0.036059726029634476,
0.0008551824721507728,
-0.05710985139012337,
-0.27073439955711365,
0.1354721486568451,
-0.1109672412276268,
-0.2784568965435028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08093v2 | BASE TTS: Lessons from building a billion-parameter Text-to-Speech model on 100K hours of data | 2024-02-12T22:21:30 | 2024-02-15T18:57:26 | Mateusz Łajszczak, Guillermo Cámbara, Yang Li, Fatih Beyhan, Arent van Korlaar, Fan Yang, Arnaud Joly, Álvaro Martín-Cortinas, Ammar Abbas, Adam Michalski, Alexis Moinet, Sri Karlapati, Ewa Muszyńska, Haohan Guo, Bartosz Putrycz, Soledad López Gambino, Kayeon Yoo, Elena Sokolova, Thomas Drugman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, eess.AS | We introduce a text-to-speech (TTS) model called BASE TTS, which stands for
$\textbf{B}$ig $\textbf{A}$daptive $\textbf{S}$treamable TTS with
$\textbf{E}$mergent abilities. BASE TTS is the largest TTS model to-date,
trained on 100K hours of public domain speech data, achieving a new
state-of-the-art in speech naturalness. It deploys a 1-billion-parameter
autoregressive Transformer that converts raw texts into discrete codes
("speechcodes") followed by a convolution-based decoder which converts these
speechcodes into waveforms in an incremental, streamable manner. Further, our
speechcodes are built using a novel speech tokenization technique that features
speaker ID disentanglement and compression with byte-pair encoding. Echoing the
widely-reported "emergent abilities" of large language models when trained on
increasing volume of data, we show that BASE TTS variants built with 10K+ hours
and 500M+ parameters begin to demonstrate natural prosody on textually complex
sentences. We design and share a specialized dataset to measure these emergent
abilities for text-to-speech. We showcase state-of-the-art naturalness of BASE
TTS by evaluating against baselines that include publicly available large-scale
text-to-speech systems: YourTTS, Bark and TortoiseTTS. Audio samples generated
by the model can be heard at https://amazon-ltts-paper.com/. | [
-0.29993268847465515,
-0.9042549729347229,
0.3774752914905548,
0.18094851076602936,
-0.6108752489089966,
0.16499105095863342,
-0.45428466796875,
-0.47754010558128357,
0.09035272151231766,
0.5582050681114197,
-0.20760810375213623,
-0.283406525850296,
-0.5651115775108337,
0.24679724872112274,
-0.4321170449256897,
1.131040096282959,
0.6325299143791199,
-0.07542143017053604,
0.2671893239021301,
-0.03624903783202171,
-0.33751893043518066,
-0.6930901408195496,
-0.742179274559021,
0.11945018172264099,
0.3986184298992157,
0.30214983224868774,
0.7499579191207886,
0.8123896718025208,
0.14168167114257812,
0.2246241569519043,
-0.38247931003570557,
-0.00774573115631938,
-0.47203969955444336,
0.21794655919075012,
0.008311630226671696,
-0.2922613024711609,
-0.46397361159324646,
-0.1846996396780014,
0.7161610126495361,
0.9672740697860718,
0.024517156183719635,
0.14457854628562927,
-0.004034969490021467,
0.495785653591156,
-0.37858498096466064,
0.00020962888083886355,
-0.41222766041755676,
-0.09744784235954285,
-0.36409297585487366,
-0.23048262298107147,
-0.8395410776138306,
-0.21613991260528564,
0.524278461933136,
-0.17405804991722107,
0.20126233994960785,
-0.10192113369703293,
0.37435421347618103,
0.15054580569267273,
-0.694196879863739,
-0.23669865727424622,
-1.1186637878417969,
0.6662890315055847,
-0.5628764033317566,
0.8558694124221802,
0.13188889622688293,
0.20973354578018188,
-0.13876858353614807,
-0.8936982750892639,
-0.3137151300907135,
-0.7115076184272766,
0.08835414052009583,
-0.007222143933176994,
-0.46962326765060425,
0.19598136842250824,
0.2752723693847656,
0.2591017782688141,
-0.6535903811454773,
0.056393057107925415,
-0.411294162273407,
-0.025602418929338455,
0.3904905617237091,
-0.16860364377498627,
0.18530575931072235,
-0.2711852490901947,
-0.24914869666099548,
-0.006418574135750532,
-0.573127806186676,
0.03262438252568245,
0.141524538397789,
0.4989505708217621,
-0.05500221252441406,
0.6078214049339294,
-0.12827664613723755,
0.6418513059616089,
0.17424578964710236,
0.012511078268289566,
0.13714005053043365,
-0.255086749792099,
-0.2465803325176239,
0.17518609762191772,
0.7723413705825806,
-0.13643431663513184,
0.43220317363739014,
-0.751467764377594,
-0.038796715438365936,
-0.15671749413013458,
0.25079333782196045,
-0.6124805212020874,
-0.022051753476262093,
0.17772221565246582,
-0.37317490577697754,
0.014048590324819088,
-0.087422676384449,
-0.6369162797927856,
-0.2690295875072479,
-0.4655057489871979,
0.314525842666626,
-0.6579561829566956,
-0.4610889256000519,
0.09499439597129822,
-0.1565404236316681,
0.0007780882297083735,
-0.223159059882164,
-1.05148184299469,
0.5562869310379028,
0.5703393220901489,
0.997685432434082,
-0.16779978573322296,
-0.2216845154762268,
-0.6082198023796082,
0.09652192145586014,
-0.5044779777526855,
0.5793960094451904,
-0.2701853811740875,
-0.6638057231903076,
-0.2256038933992386,
-0.19530487060546875,
0.16032518446445465,
-0.48503434658050537,
0.5556182861328125,
-0.3840567171573639,
-0.07742143422365189,
-0.04563985392451286,
-0.5314335823059082,
0.181629940867424,
-0.21668383479118347,
-0.6827452778816223,
1.0319581031799316,
-0.034561388194561005,
-0.4408459961414337,
0.15750311315059662,
-0.7809412479400635,
-0.5439198017120361,
0.17652668058872223,
0.1053057536482811,
-0.12546104192733765,
0.40886855125427246,
-0.08127032965421677,
0.3450342118740082,
-0.3706287741661072,
0.5044652223587036,
0.07310948520898819,
-0.22252437472343445,
0.323737770318985,
-0.9238359332084656,
0.8911622166633606,
0.23663519322872162,
-0.44069135189056396,
-0.13701213896274567,
-0.7287732362747192,
0.06735661625862122,
0.06408851593732834,
-0.20880265533924103,
-0.23016946017742157,
-0.032302916049957275,
0.10617106407880783,
-0.08974074572324753,
0.15228323638439178,
-0.465969979763031,
0.025281015783548355,
-0.6283493041992188,
0.827103853225708,
0.4426923394203186,
-0.01513153687119484,
0.2958621680736542,
-0.24164575338363647,
0.3611477017402649,
-0.28559818863868713,
0.19309620559215546,
-0.4780927896499634,
-0.5717493891716003,
-0.5245504379272461,
-0.21229188144207,
0.5082183480262756,
0.27583783864974976,
-0.20502528548240662,
0.8784228563308716,
-0.6089800596237183,
-0.8284294009208679,
-0.22892190515995026,
-0.3862428367137909,
0.2355484962463379,
0.4287509322166443,
0.4328674376010895,
-0.1339031308889389,
-0.7298250198364258,
-0.838534414768219,
-0.22279126942157745,
-0.1944745033979416,
-0.2834315299987793,
-0.20774675905704498,
0.47040626406669617,
-0.13985586166381836,
1.3725049495697021,
-0.21610991656780243,
0.28186213970184326,
-0.11987415701150894,
0.357717901468277,
-0.09374398738145828,
0.500573456287384,
0.517734169960022,
-0.7511287927627563,
-0.18968869745731354,
-0.24617278575897217,
-0.4340451955795288,
0.0026933636981993914,
0.12476552277803421,
0.004233271349221468,
0.14163511991500854,
0.5249766111373901,
-0.7448386549949646,
0.16325047612190247,
0.5868279337882996,
-0.4021458327770233,
0.8132773041725159,
-0.24318644404411316,
-0.08970985561609268,
-1.3040149211883545,
0.17646721005439758,
0.06850043684244156,
-0.2929355502128601,
-0.9047316908836365,
-0.15610270202159882,
-0.22990532219409943,
-0.3009718656539917,
-0.3688323497772217,
0.40295523405075073,
-0.5149689316749573,
-0.3119766414165497,
-0.1351584494113922,
-0.1551440954208374,
-0.33933109045028687,
0.344216912984848,
0.1530960351228714,
0.6847266554832458,
0.5310630202293396,
-0.5599938035011292,
0.4376218914985657,
0.07431264966726303,
-0.024177201092243195,
0.5430780053138733,
-0.7750664353370667,
0.4531548321247101,
-0.011544648557901382,
0.5468513369560242,
-1.0000029802322388,
-0.09140979498624802,
-0.14303769171237946,
-0.6403123736381531,
0.12014520168304443,
-0.5174339413642883,
-0.7061671018600464,
-0.20347988605499268,
0.08095841854810715,
0.30391034483909607,
0.7089262008666992,
-0.47043174505233765,
0.639173686504364,
0.5058891177177429,
-0.6338004469871521,
-0.36886411905288696,
-0.6707627177238464,
0.6510660648345947,
-0.10839493572711945,
-0.5893871784210205,
0.4741126298904419,
-0.07553591579198837,
-0.02778991311788559,
0.1308465301990509,
-0.12021473795175552,
-0.17432977259159088,
-0.074007548391819,
0.2546117901802063,
0.09334054589271545,
-0.3599317669868469,
0.39297032356262207,
-0.03032904677093029,
-0.31811103224754333,
0.1170278936624527,
-0.5253660678863525,
0.7787730693817139,
-0.2567671537399292,
-0.14813123643398285,
-0.40173575282096863,
0.49057111144065857,
0.9594191908836365,
-0.14129266142845154,
0.5422326922416687,
0.30230435729026794,
-0.5192549824714661,
-0.13538607954978943,
-0.4893101155757904,
-0.094929538667202,
-0.4545007348060608,
0.45677822828292847,
-0.2607259750366211,
-0.6633461713790894,
0.32518941164016724,
-0.10488203912973404,
0.17797532677650452,
0.47251975536346436,
0.23940667510032654,
0.04944727569818497,
1.074655532836914,
0.606598973274231,
0.014222081750631332,
0.718851625919342,
-0.28888994455337524,
-0.057992249727249146,
-0.49708226323127747,
-0.18478548526763916,
-0.4799623191356659,
-0.044379644095897675,
-0.6023823022842407,
-0.4056607782840729,
0.3158580958843231,
-0.07935459911823273,
-0.5476281046867371,
0.2750735580921173,
-0.4342247545719147,
0.3995310664176941,
0.5837147235870361,
0.08013056963682175,
0.36266645789146423,
0.07156883180141449,
0.10390320420265198,
-0.10815195739269257,
-0.580299973487854,
-0.6809306740760803,
1.3534787893295288,
0.5728685259819031,
0.3625837564468384,
0.015465475618839264,
0.49761760234832764,
0.3306604027748108,
0.19380436837673187,
-0.8835330009460449,
0.6426857113838196,
-0.6305509805679321,
-0.3902503252029419,
-0.4481865465641022,
-0.4770261347293854,
-0.9299145936965942,
-0.09131041914224625,
-0.16175910830497742,
-0.6567130088806152,
-0.042447853833436966,
0.1489771604537964,
-0.4132118225097656,
0.30258649587631226,
-1.0263330936431885,
0.6051419377326965,
-0.37899985909461975,
-0.11439792811870575,
-0.05589371919631958,
-0.7211194634437561,
0.035773858428001404,
0.16788648068904877,
-0.002057294361293316,
0.3015846908092499,
-0.09567864239215851,
1.0699995756149292,
-0.3690105974674225,
0.8384506106376648,
-0.19482773542404175,
-0.1928180307149887,
0.25138115882873535,
0.002488406142219901,
0.4856908917427063,
-0.1461942344903946,
0.10646988451480865,
0.28781357407569885,
-0.32420992851257324,
-0.24321654438972473,
-0.5057753920555115,
0.3605475425720215,
-0.6084409952163696,
-0.21051272749900818,
-0.2060149908065796,
-0.1570752114057541,
-0.6026872992515564,
0.2685485780239105,
0.5474079847335815,
0.9438396096229553,
-0.4285159409046173,
0.6661549806594849,
0.8311237692832947,
0.13531866669654846,
0.475963294506073,
0.5086419582366943,
0.18078143894672394,
-0.6649678945541382,
0.9461371302604675,
0.4243691861629486,
0.3059117794036865,
0.2600533962249756,
0.3063639998435974,
-0.5255712866783142,
-0.7831263542175293,
-0.38625043630599976,
0.2869357764720917,
-0.47261086106300354,
0.049059297889471054,
-0.6362277269363403,
-0.46602320671081543,
-0.35028305649757385,
-0.012476718984544277,
-0.648382306098938,
-0.22557520866394043,
-0.29442140460014343,
-0.2733841836452484,
0.41711902618408203,
0.8768360018730164,
-0.03411583974957466,
0.4486532211303711,
-1.0474854707717896,
0.4928184449672699,
0.3810132145881653,
0.4874410927295685,
-0.023514186963438988,
-0.7529359459877014,
-0.27680569887161255,
0.3364338278770447,
0.029729267582297325,
-1.071241855621338,
0.34330180287361145,
0.014436583034694195,
0.40720707178115845,
0.11960872262716293,
0.03164241090416908,
0.4969825744628906,
-0.6755121946334839,
0.9334121346473694,
0.2705470025539398,
-1.2042323350906372,
0.4986446499824524,
-0.4745495915412903,
0.226194366812706,
0.2225949615240097,
0.205027237534523,
-0.6999335289001465,
-0.5138476490974426,
-0.8348429799079895,
-0.9711272120475769,
0.46566951274871826,
0.4992837905883789,
0.22916851937770844,
0.09140805900096893,
0.35060957074165344,
0.1609000712633133,
0.0745745301246643,
-0.5819443464279175,
-0.26392418146133423,
-0.2517359256744385,
-0.42358240485191345,
-0.19520874321460724,
-0.34793391823768616,
-0.013818474486470222,
-0.1726265549659729,
0.2849288582801819,
-0.06867031008005142,
0.39164039492607117,
0.06231565773487091,
-0.240474134683609,
-0.03438563272356987,
0.46757498383522034,
0.6153984665870667,
0.4838954508304596,
-0.25269815325737,
0.25220987200737,
0.189701646566391,
-0.8189435005187988,
0.20104381442070007,
0.2725342810153961,
0.23837807774543762,
0.16826677322387695,
0.41608333587646484,
0.910358190536499,
0.2644914388656616,
-0.7455811500549316,
0.314975768327713,
0.1031959056854248,
-0.20735210180282593,
-0.2787413001060486,
-0.14690560102462769,
0.1048767939209938,
0.11807786673307419,
0.9047461152076721,
0.10454099625349045,
-0.020558053627610207,
-0.575176477432251,
0.37577468156814575,
0.16520118713378906,
-0.34947898983955383,
-0.5639132261276245,
0.5406717658042908,
0.4383910000324249,
-0.4384927451610565,
0.24995803833007812,
-0.1348201036453247,
-0.2029893845319748,
0.6528051495552063,
0.6781348586082458,
1.1005786657333374,
-0.2605148255825043,
0.209548220038414,
0.13169898092746735,
0.3242398798465729,
-0.3738561272621155,
0.05051850900053978,
0.12789082527160645,
-0.30821558833122253,
-0.45337286591529846,
-0.38764819502830505,
-0.616347074508667,
0.41059401631355286,
-0.5036788582801819,
0.1644217073917389,
-0.3729064166545868,
-0.43585145473480225,
0.23411400616168976,
-0.09791314601898193,
-0.41580119729042053,
0.4787834882736206,
0.2785980999469757,
0.8443378210067749,
-0.8660599589347839,
0.43883752822875977,
0.5176191329956055,
-0.19218134880065918,
-0.5326184630393982,
0.25317853689193726,
-0.31845489144325256,
-0.4158332645893097,
0.7218871712684631,
0.0851283147931099,
-0.3409488797187805,
0.4136756360530853,
-0.6197327375411987,
-0.8640576004981995,
0.9059963822364807,
0.7980657815933228,
-0.7572440505027771,
-0.34600529074668884,
0.28049036860466003,
0.7261507511138916,
-0.2888684570789337,
0.19120432436466217,
0.7040464878082275,
0.16139470040798187,
-0.07273789495229721,
-1.1210662126541138,
-0.08418739587068558,
-0.09408187866210938,
-0.13225679099559784,
0.07531645148992538,
-0.5312331318855286,
0.7692968249320984,
-0.16116444766521454,
-0.2654033601284027,
0.024533433839678764,
0.5384840369224548,
0.1488739252090454,
0.10937144607305527,
0.7936369776725769,
0.4298436939716339,
0.7597165107727051,
-0.09264637529850006,
0.6780521869659424,
-0.22819513082504272,
0.11034722626209259,
0.9869784712791443,
0.058752771466970444,
1.0002306699752808,
0.10617124289274216,
-0.12664222717285156,
0.41028669476509094,
0.39986586570739746,
0.2989753186702728,
0.3808324933052063,
0.029396848753094673,
-0.3213284909725189,
-0.12629401683807373,
-0.06310262531042099,
-0.3691565990447998,
0.5313321948051453,
0.5194346308708191,
-0.3324837386608124,
-0.14386188983917236,
0.3393845558166504,
-0.1491301953792572,
-0.22661437094211578,
-0.063617043197155,
0.8069241642951965,
-0.0540030337870121,
-0.45574185252189636,
0.6583273410797119,
-0.22841094434261322,
0.7344402074813843,
-0.7190632224082947,
0.160982146859169,
0.10724040120840073,
-0.27170330286026,
0.03103841096162796,
-0.8694713115692139,
0.23621657490730286,
0.5047960877418518,
-0.31861570477485657,
-0.2927665710449219,
0.43273741006851196,
-0.3125723600387573,
-0.20543844997882843,
0.16476163268089294,
0.4291628301143646,
0.013908425346016884,
-0.12623925507068634,
-0.2756117880344391,
-0.12321801483631134,
-0.3170703053474426,
-0.2571902573108673,
-0.012651265598833561,
0.576704740524292,
0.09507406502962112,
0.57435542345047,
0.6500722765922546,
0.23135854303836823,
0.14077036082744598,
0.05167047306895256,
0.6703528165817261,
-0.937410295009613,
-0.8355241417884827,
-0.8050671219825745,
0.6354671716690063,
-0.008214840665459633,
-0.5935514569282532,
0.401766836643219,
0.684319019317627,
0.4345560073852539,
0.02135227993130684,
1.0517699718475342,
0.011407758109271526,
0.5918381810188293,
-0.5200974941253662,
0.45999979972839355,
-0.14426621794700623,
0.03906421735882759,
-0.12689746916294098,
-0.7514893412590027,
-0.07115055620670319,
0.2900157868862152,
-0.2521069347858429,
0.13917453587055206,
0.6342953443527222,
0.4277171492576599,
0.06555323302745819,
0.18604278564453125,
0.1983170509338379,
0.3846331238746643,
0.3737345337867737,
0.2398216724395752,
0.8394429087638855,
-0.23538652062416077,
0.9387728571891785,
-0.03270448371767998,
-0.4011808931827545,
-0.36264926195144653,
-0.6995614171028137,
-0.5188943147659302,
-0.7712083458900452,
-0.22717410326004028,
-0.2037399411201477,
0.25084421038627625,
1.0519402027130127,
0.8264119625091553,
-0.6782239079475403,
-0.25705671310424805,
-0.5101802349090576,
-0.3488668203353882,
-0.18889668583869934,
-0.21749286353588104,
0.3198520839214325,
-0.15234510600566864,
-0.8252015113830566,
0.5565615296363831,
0.15393255650997162,
0.505047082901001,
-0.20662832260131836,
0.04411688446998596,
0.23617327213287354,
0.15523791313171387,
0.7096481919288635,
0.4538094997406006,
-0.46634116768836975,
-0.3396465480327606,
0.3992771506309509,
-0.11835676431655884,
-0.0335523895919323,
0.708196759223938,
-0.7547225952148438,
0.5118892192840576,
0.37300118803977966,
0.5659551024436951,
0.2245296835899353,
0.014533288776874542,
0.7967399954795837,
-0.9601143002510071,
0.11195770651102066,
0.5881980061531067,
0.26905831694602966,
0.29952380061149597,
-0.14406852424144745,
0.23619578778743744,
0.31297019124031067,
-0.42574846744537354,
-1.0519930124282837,
0.22308585047721863,
-1.1211744546890259,
-0.09991756826639175,
1.2193410396575928,
0.16599306464195251,
0.03562770038843155,
-0.3107615113258362,
-0.424064964056015,
0.6493021249771118,
-0.5224955677986145,
0.6025916337966919,
0.5123803615570068,
-0.03726835921406746,
0.0015493042301386595,
-0.5977895855903625,
0.590644359588623,
0.2940331697463989,
-0.7007110118865967,
0.5097233057022095,
0.4706674814224243,
0.3732544481754303,
0.3143762946128845,
0.6261239647865295,
0.15237799286842346,
0.32380932569503784,
0.27307841181755066,
-0.20288313925266266,
-0.05025390535593033,
-0.4714145064353943,
-0.4601193964481354,
0.20148317515850067,
-0.05818773806095123,
-0.29788240790367126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08086v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08086v2 | Text-centric Alignment for Multi-Modality Learning | 2024-02-12T22:07:43 | 2024-05-20T19:18:52 | Yun-Da Tsai, Ting-Yu Yen, Pei-Fu Guo, Zhe-Yan Li, Shou-De Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | This research paper addresses the challenge of modality mismatch in
multimodal learning, where the modalities available during inference differ
from those available at training. We propose the Text-centric Alignment for
Multi-Modality Learning (TAMML) approach, an innovative method that utilizes
Large Language Models (LLMs) with in-context learning and foundation models to
enhance the generalizability of multimodal systems under these conditions. By
leveraging the unique properties of text as a unified semantic space, TAMML
demonstrates significant improvements in handling unseen, diverse, and
unpredictable modality combinations. TAMML not only adapts to varying
modalities but also maintains robust performance, showcasing the potential of
foundation models in overcoming the limitations of traditional fixed-modality
frameworks in embedding representations. This study contributes to the field by
offering a flexible, effective solution for real-world applications where
modality availability is dynamic and uncertain. | [
-0.24047254025936127,
-0.8567538261413574,
0.5145431756973267,
0.09378611296415329,
-0.25512608885765076,
0.032944291830062866,
-0.4080449342727661,
-0.2699407935142517,
-0.09151281416416168,
0.19502542912960052,
-0.6062721610069275,
-0.33242934942245483,
-0.4709469676017761,
0.2040778547525406,
-0.11154528707265854,
0.8529824018478394,
-0.2240423858165741,
0.4862646460533142,
-0.50571608543396,
-0.45692551136016846,
-0.8553211092948914,
-0.3587367832660675,
-0.045273445546627045,
-0.38365933299064636,
0.3208385109901428,
0.3171316385269165,
0.7259770631790161,
0.8475940227508545,
0.5994794964790344,
0.30819427967071533,
0.30482786893844604,
0.4613253176212311,
-0.21812395751476288,
0.5267918109893799,
-0.3255355954170227,
-0.154978409409523,
-0.4863482713699341,
0.07769429683685303,
0.728094220161438,
0.7024352550506592,
0.021256137639284134,
-0.24901005625724792,
-0.08268089592456818,
0.3054139316082001,
-0.635004460811615,
-0.2425752878189087,
-0.5530444979667664,
0.21464210748672485,
-0.02013636752963066,
-0.30400899052619934,
-0.6247690916061401,
-0.028946077451109886,
0.3066866397857666,
-0.8183225393295288,
-0.02031882293522358,
-0.12095922976732254,
0.6776065230369568,
0.4773971736431122,
-0.9398179650306702,
-0.2814538776874542,
-0.5121365189552307,
1.153592824935913,
-0.3237261474132538,
0.9351387023925781,
0.3694959878921509,
0.314898282289505,
0.020405689254403114,
-0.3245447874069214,
-0.5903620719909668,
0.1278749257326126,
-0.19703924655914307,
0.056775324046611786,
0.42266085743904114,
0.06831484287977219,
-0.13097985088825226,
0.2817073464393616,
-0.589189887046814,
-0.11528997123241425,
0.32473891973495483,
-0.2028590589761734,
0.4104618728160858,
0.29122939705848694,
0.31618404388427734,
-0.0232954453676939,
-1.0793190002441406,
-0.08701898902654648,
-0.4595363438129425,
-0.029955273494124413,
0.02211376465857029,
0.5391850471496582,
-0.4052926003932953,
0.5936049818992615,
0.19724947214126587,
0.942940354347229,
0.17199382185935974,
-0.7727808952331543,
0.4185448884963989,
-0.7742708325386047,
-0.40241819620132446,
-0.03631182014942169,
0.7383093237876892,
0.23094016313552856,
-0.24146179854869843,
-0.17822250723838806,
-0.29308223724365234,
-0.11035439372062683,
0.25079330801963806,
-0.6509009003639221,
0.40932825207710266,
0.20457305014133453,
-0.3700192868709564,
-0.39433687925338745,
0.15391506254673004,
-0.7016372084617615,
-0.4957747161388397,
-0.6881346702575684,
0.9125906229019165,
-0.5516357421875,
-0.39024797081947327,
0.11085645854473114,
0.08732137829065323,
0.2758726179599762,
0.5973977446556091,
-0.9538112878799438,
-0.16771942377090454,
0.6790023446083069,
0.7223224639892578,
-0.3202454745769501,
-0.6358245015144348,
-0.3353046774864197,
0.5008183121681213,
-0.12500330805778503,
0.3557814061641693,
-0.6994357705116272,
-0.3808460831642151,
-0.1597762107849121,
0.10136444866657257,
-0.4169451594352722,
-0.0933765321969986,
0.21926352381706238,
-0.26810190081596375,
0.7719364166259766,
-0.12634851038455963,
-0.4509912133216858,
-0.2424042671918869,
0.3674268126487732,
-0.737076461315155,
1.010485291481018,
0.20121750235557556,
-0.7120999693870544,
0.32072144746780396,
-0.47815290093421936,
-0.47851911187171936,
-0.4563751220703125,
-0.523634135723114,
-0.6662511825561523,
0.14403623342514038,
-0.1764824092388153,
0.5115964412689209,
-0.2281653732061386,
0.6064613461494446,
-0.10300139337778091,
-0.3916143476963043,
0.7359120845794678,
-0.7818818092346191,
0.5782866477966309,
0.3110738694667816,
-0.41542690992355347,
0.19121509790420532,
-0.784186601638794,
-0.09282273799180984,
-0.21760988235473633,
-0.49491119384765625,
-0.4629870653152466,
-0.11299736052751541,
0.4973416328430176,
0.3507469594478607,
0.3586534261703491,
-0.3543941080570221,
0.29416924715042114,
-0.001847551786340773,
0.127030611038208,
0.8609136343002319,
-0.48460447788238525,
0.7498571276664734,
-0.44803133606910706,
0.36531224846839905,
0.22101683914661407,
0.07753694802522659,
-0.49299347400665283,
-0.08749420195817947,
-0.4738915264606476,
-0.7881722450256348,
0.4267398715019226,
0.32783129811286926,
-0.7597331404685974,
0.20104984939098358,
-0.4044731855392456,
-0.1586279571056366,
-0.6622945070266724,
0.07981835305690765,
0.5747163891792297,
0.615810215473175,
0.33500999212265015,
-0.39605847001075745,
-0.5058368444442749,
-0.5337554216384888,
-0.13002242147922516,
0.039283834397792816,
0.42881590127944946,
0.2391659915447235,
0.17368178069591522,
-0.6196386218070984,
1.1900031566619873,
0.03802942484617233,
-0.28871864080429077,
-0.10677944123744965,
0.23459970951080322,
-0.2089223563671112,
0.5600482225418091,
0.5187644958496094,
-1.3021715879440308,
-0.4226644039154053,
0.36896222829818726,
-0.7331799268722534,
-0.16587737202644348,
-0.18995140492916107,
-0.11316003650426865,
0.39677974581718445,
0.33703193068504333,
-0.3685500919818878,
0.15268245339393616,
0.7608595490455627,
-0.744196355342865,
0.33949798345565796,
0.16096502542495728,
0.3614763617515564,
-1.606388807296753,
0.1645108461380005,
-0.17519427835941315,
-0.4773715138435364,
-0.6951329708099365,
-0.024486636742949486,
0.3491457998752594,
-0.04124634340405464,
-0.39196112751960754,
0.5513828992843628,
-0.38875845074653625,
0.09327451884746552,
-0.23977191746234894,
0.060433123260736465,
0.4746304452419281,
0.22990673780441284,
0.14097712934017181,
1.009421706199646,
0.2518254220485687,
-0.3169773817062378,
0.08243022114038467,
0.310059130191803,
0.1753789782524109,
0.9934685826301575,
-0.09762485325336456,
-0.19620464742183685,
-0.19795052707195282,
0.24422228336334229,
-0.967433512210846,
-0.48031046986579895,
0.13115891814231873,
-0.4084281027317047,
0.6329168081283569,
0.1432054489850998,
0.08900269120931625,
0.5011377334594727,
-0.4653225839138031,
0.8490318059921265,
-0.26866328716278076,
-0.43873220682144165,
1.1161413192749023,
0.18007078766822815,
0.17901381850242615,
-1.0911734104156494,
-0.7644587159156799,
-0.2042296677827835,
-0.28040874004364014,
-0.41892340779304504,
0.4683716297149658,
-0.30975157022476196,
-0.18621937930583954,
-0.054084207862615585,
-0.1755945384502411,
-0.1880662441253662,
0.31741127371788025,
0.42521464824676514,
0.37538132071495056,
-0.46766847372055054,
0.5076113939285278,
0.0041404906660318375,
-0.19996817409992218,
-0.449469655752182,
-0.06654948741197586,
0.5044277906417847,
-0.17537444829940796,
-0.5960609316825867,
-0.42075246572494507,
0.6895783543586731,
0.9658633470535278,
-0.2918030321598053,
0.7057624459266663,
0.7756825089454651,
-0.3540417551994324,
0.08736290782690048,
-0.4422163665294647,
0.0273293349891901,
-0.4151729345321655,
0.306344211101532,
-0.49854138493537903,
-1.1061333417892456,
0.052546728402376175,
-0.03828540816903114,
-0.04496840015053749,
0.17791414260864258,
0.6791574954986572,
-0.028387892991304398,
0.9257504343986511,
1.0261659622192383,
0.15496817231178284,
0.6689610481262207,
0.1037653461098671,
0.2626780867576599,
-0.8116796016693115,
-0.46069595217704773,
-0.33558499813079834,
-0.37866735458374023,
-0.33948880434036255,
-0.5824544429779053,
0.3200002610683441,
-0.06080252304673195,
-0.4170672595500946,
0.20417413115501404,
-0.27669090032577515,
0.4400564432144165,
0.27596771717071533,
0.10884800553321838,
0.7001394629478455,
0.07407872378826141,
-0.2682015001773834,
-0.2851468622684479,
-0.2614748477935791,
-0.386605829000473,
0.9847486615180969,
0.3007976710796356,
0.8673061728477478,
0.5889737010002136,
0.3729911148548126,
0.09082423150539398,
0.3246060609817505,
-0.9065831303596497,
0.11838512867689133,
0.019218964502215385,
-0.6852286458015442,
-0.23747406899929047,
-0.45698070526123047,
-0.7285720109939575,
0.694056510925293,
-0.5856789946556091,
-0.3790600895881653,
0.31673261523246765,
-0.3071865439414978,
-0.12336447834968567,
0.10294514149427414,
-0.6854730248451233,
1.0651307106018066,
-0.46244797110557556,
-0.4239285886287689,
0.04085797443985939,
-0.7873765826225281,
0.25593605637550354,
-0.39574283361434937,
0.4682530164718628,
-0.1212998554110527,
-0.5013751983642578,
0.06775714457035065,
-0.15211723744869232,
0.9121313691139221,
0.13235168159008026,
-0.23609991371631622,
-0.12917381525039673,
0.10592852532863617,
-0.0222629364579916,
-0.036149486899375916,
-0.06721233576536179,
-0.16484491527080536,
-0.035940710455179214,
-0.2428816258907318,
-0.4157002866268158,
0.5661216378211975,
-1.0648722648620605,
-0.18546923995018005,
-0.6042971014976501,
-0.9081974029541016,
-0.5053446292877197,
0.3743266761302948,
0.1644875407218933,
0.6073740124702454,
-0.25889334082603455,
0.4505433738231659,
0.8700115084648132,
0.17453792691230774,
0.6541367173194885,
0.668994665145874,
-0.27519604563713074,
-0.7635933756828308,
0.8668978214263916,
-0.1775447428226471,
0.42472001910209656,
0.7411885261535645,
0.14684957265853882,
-0.2861299514770508,
-0.1930842101573944,
-0.545735239982605,
0.18548078835010529,
-0.6576610803604126,
-0.46184319257736206,
-0.7310569882392883,
0.005801178514957428,
-0.22546537220478058,
-0.4216286540031433,
-0.37006089091300964,
-0.3747965395450592,
-0.5043148994445801,
0.11690088361501694,
0.1255367547273636,
0.5235952734947205,
0.054803866893053055,
0.5232512950897217,
-0.6834278106689453,
0.19377295672893524,
0.4052864611148834,
0.5773488283157349,
-0.3472229540348053,
-0.52479487657547,
-0.34008437395095825,
0.02247878722846508,
-0.5376641154289246,
-0.8530704379081726,
0.054059792309999466,
0.41748759150505066,
0.5106778740882874,
0.4864919185638428,
-0.271477609872818,
0.7632742524147034,
-0.17401082813739777,
0.67307049036026,
0.5709194540977478,
-1.0841301679611206,
0.29081225395202637,
-0.49763864278793335,
0.15880142152309418,
0.8244554996490479,
0.5299569368362427,
-0.6379708647727966,
0.17229488492012024,
-0.3072586953639984,
-0.5851936340332031,
0.39243951439857483,
-0.2614552080631256,
0.07895440608263016,
0.19397929310798645,
-0.05581654608249664,
0.6219019889831543,
0.4901203215122223,
-1.0178412199020386,
-0.011377152055501938,
-0.3390999436378479,
-0.8758971095085144,
0.06559909880161285,
-0.15636701881885529,
-0.32069769501686096,
-0.2307087481021881,
0.5677034854888916,
-0.578446626663208,
0.1711142361164093,
0.08508135378360748,
-0.49599841237068176,
-0.30695343017578125,
0.3617033064365387,
0.819706916809082,
0.8678264617919922,
0.08426263183355331,
0.4412788152694702,
-0.0717429369688034,
-0.6134381890296936,
0.43212026357650757,
-0.046169474720954895,
-0.04856506362557411,
0.09560738503932953,
0.29145658016204834,
0.5825069546699524,
0.6405004262924194,
-0.9192230701446533,
1.03537118434906,
-0.23730866611003876,
0.10298735648393631,
0.08731759339570999,
-0.13162460923194885,
-0.1718885898590088,
0.3681293725967407,
0.26449427008628845,
0.11531060189008713,
-0.26626014709472656,
-0.5186606049537659,
0.31059959530830383,
0.6939966678619385,
-0.6268015503883362,
-0.26033321022987366,
0.6762059330940247,
0.2002323716878891,
-0.17267504334449768,
0.07554599642753601,
0.24192367494106293,
-0.32322362065315247,
0.23205481469631195,
0.7906408905982971,
0.8844022750854492,
-0.45272132754325867,
0.1975223422050476,
-0.09678591787815094,
0.10112942010164261,
-0.05348702147603035,
0.23188668489456177,
-0.1236107274889946,
-0.8421362042427063,
-0.5224547982215881,
-0.6489608287811279,
-0.4327946901321411,
-0.16408328711986542,
-0.395740270614624,
0.5065087676048279,
-0.267039030790329,
-0.18503355979919434,
-0.35438430309295654,
-0.20980295538902283,
-0.4089973270893097,
0.2527066469192505,
0.11021444946527481,
0.5784994959831238,
-0.9552552103996277,
0.842137336730957,
0.9439585208892822,
-0.24863481521606445,
-0.6196494698524475,
-0.05716296657919884,
0.31505170464515686,
-0.6028882265090942,
0.054051388055086136,
0.3592313230037689,
-0.2174127697944641,
-0.19303880631923676,
-0.27762889862060547,
-0.8204359412193298,
1.5001424551010132,
0.5210579037666321,
-0.16634772717952728,
0.08517961949110031,
0.40448492765426636,
0.1857030838727951,
-0.7390373349189758,
0.19544436037540436,
0.23785638809204102,
0.40993303060531616,
-0.059386998414993286,
-1.0012526512145996,
-0.055105067789554596,
-0.1379089504480362,
0.05550311133265495,
0.3618449568748474,
-0.7405312657356262,
0.9516487717628479,
0.2209705114364624,
-0.10644218325614929,
0.09187015891075134,
0.4202688932418823,
0.17444264888763428,
0.5397427082061768,
0.378639817237854,
0.7850474119186401,
0.758709192276001,
-0.21722479164600372,
0.5586825609207153,
-0.1449873298406601,
0.4941355884075165,
0.9918670654296875,
-0.062283702194690704,
0.652960479259491,
0.8828014731407166,
0.1501230001449585,
0.514112114906311,
0.4488181173801422,
0.44199222326278687,
0.5758135318756104,
-0.5967474579811096,
-0.4175835847854614,
-0.4164770245552063,
-0.4109233319759369,
-0.5179714560508728,
0.7722858786582947,
0.24789658188819885,
-0.3810468912124634,
-0.293143093585968,
0.241341695189476,
0.07238918542861938,
0.27120399475097656,
-0.04796670004725456,
0.7656320333480835,
-0.14615824818611145,
-0.40338659286499023,
0.3459397852420807,
-0.029019612818956375,
0.8153421878814697,
-0.6506020426750183,
-0.0358511246740818,
-0.07118307054042816,
0.046337079256772995,
-0.24677817523479462,
-0.41502270102500916,
0.18364880979061127,
-0.42114192247390747,
-0.5516191720962524,
-0.4709385633468628,
0.6479099988937378,
-0.8286780118942261,
-0.25448742508888245,
0.03384212777018547,
0.7364634871482849,
-0.49078235030174255,
0.3185262084007263,
-0.45274052023887634,
0.4968847334384918,
-0.14075881242752075,
-0.10847683995962143,
0.5087080001831055,
0.7968804836273193,
-0.05005037039518356,
0.4326349198818207,
0.34094685316085815,
-0.5089218020439148,
-0.10650061815977097,
-0.19623622298240662,
0.6782146096229553,
-0.622261106967926,
-0.38273411989212036,
-0.9279413819313049,
0.770787239074707,
0.17984513938426971,
-0.5077818036079407,
0.554892897605896,
0.5697994232177734,
0.8332586288452148,
-0.039009787142276764,
0.6503228545188904,
-0.1020730510354042,
0.26424625515937805,
-0.48318344354629517,
0.3938445746898651,
-0.8070039749145508,
0.10869217664003372,
-0.33300963044166565,
-0.9159056544303894,
-0.3094936013221741,
0.6329670548439026,
0.09258890897035599,
-0.10974814742803574,
0.8666024804115295,
0.5930062532424927,
-0.34126347303390503,
0.25173303484916687,
0.3576812446117401,
-0.16907237470149994,
0.20823058485984802,
0.4599001705646515,
0.8727457523345947,
-0.4219667315483093,
0.1733725219964981,
-0.19687235355377197,
-0.2408689558506012,
-0.35901132225990295,
-1.0735769271850586,
-0.603270411491394,
-0.9833357334136963,
-0.04261099919676781,
-0.21409328281879425,
-0.22724351286888123,
1.313875675201416,
0.5203457474708557,
-0.5133181214332581,
-0.23312953114509583,
0.32047519087791443,
0.3348047733306885,
-0.24736757576465607,
-0.2504654824733734,
0.07809832692146301,
-0.32347410917282104,
-0.7690902352333069,
0.4447002410888672,
0.3856164216995239,
0.2513958811759949,
-0.25659680366516113,
-0.1287330538034439,
-0.29289597272872925,
-0.007785414811223745,
0.6763948798179626,
-0.020278537645936012,
-0.6704848408699036,
-0.5056622624397278,
0.18295606970787048,
-0.5628018975257874,
0.1530841439962387,
1.003117322921753,
-0.6299149394035339,
0.7210054993629456,
0.45840397477149963,
1.148573398590088,
-0.06701201945543289,
0.11148283630609512,
0.6107128262519836,
-0.9125617742538452,
0.28927358984947205,
0.14477472007274628,
0.3184538781642914,
0.44488194584846497,
-0.273690402507782,
0.5104346871376038,
0.48820042610168457,
-0.31878232955932617,
-0.8219676613807678,
0.355730801820755,
-1.3217350244522095,
-0.3697583079338074,
1.0401540994644165,
0.30338117480278015,
-0.024813886731863022,
-0.14073798060417175,
-0.2873110771179199,
0.2952733039855957,
-0.019275275990366936,
0.674927294254303,
0.7992462515830994,
0.1381072849035263,
-0.03359699621796608,
-0.32087239623069763,
0.21828384697437286,
0.5399129986763,
-0.606705367565155,
-0.08778956532478333,
0.6699240207672119,
0.20008371770381927,
0.22133323550224304,
0.45410794019699097,
-0.26337361335754395,
0.36135798692703247,
-0.4915008842945099,
-0.04640892520546913,
-0.08675891160964966,
-0.5756970643997192,
-0.6642764210700989,
0.15084654092788696,
-0.1711479276418686,
-0.06308427453041077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08078v1 | Large Language Models as Agents in Two-Player Games | 2024-02-12T21:44:32 | 2024-02-12T21:44:32 | Yang Liu, Peng Sun, Hang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | By formally defining the training processes of large language models (LLMs),
which usually encompasses pre-training, supervised fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning with human feedback, within a single and unified machine
learning paradigm, we can glean pivotal insights for advancing LLM
technologies. This position paper delineates the parallels between the training
methods of LLMs and the strategies employed for the development of agents in
two-player games, as studied in game theory, reinforcement learning, and
multi-agent systems. We propose a re-conceptualization of LLM learning
processes in terms of agent learning in language-based games. This framework
unveils innovative perspectives on the successes and challenges in LLM
development, offering a fresh understanding of addressing alignment issues
among other strategic considerations. Furthermore, our two-player game approach
sheds light on novel data preparation and machine learning techniques for
training LLMs. | [
-0.2711174488067627,
-0.7936776876449585,
0.6563900709152222,
-0.19956737756729126,
0.08812406659126282,
0.5000123381614685,
-0.5014086365699768,
-0.35493436455726624,
0.015674306079745293,
0.7511576414108276,
-0.7456752061843872,
-0.23860858380794525,
-0.5110093951225281,
-0.06174474582076073,
0.029303807765245438,
0.8302739262580872,
-0.21660791337490082,
0.4835191071033478,
-0.24150387942790985,
-0.08758027106523514,
-0.4832838475704193,
-0.5490553975105286,
-1.06333589553833,
-0.8902497291564941,
0.6532574892044067,
0.4393855631351471,
0.804972231388092,
0.8499659895896912,
0.3399372398853302,
0.378268301486969,
0.3378303349018097,
0.16668197512626648,
-0.6857784390449524,
0.5155506730079651,
-0.2002502679824829,
-0.6366452574729919,
-0.25414586067199707,
0.27783939242362976,
0.7270494103431702,
0.6880739331245422,
-0.022019080817699432,
0.06778878718614578,
0.0554339699447155,
0.5925473570823669,
-0.24931398034095764,
0.36318299174308777,
-0.4564279317855835,
0.27850261330604553,
0.05199192091822624,
-0.34832242131233215,
-0.524863600730896,
-0.005731021054089069,
0.21900467574596405,
-0.6898401379585266,
0.10462222248315811,
-0.051929689943790436,
0.5796005129814148,
0.22172941267490387,
-0.44061076641082764,
-0.361476868391037,
-0.9229959845542908,
0.774787187576294,
-0.47474411129951477,
0.22163788974285126,
0.1389637291431427,
0.5587691068649292,
-0.49996843934059143,
-0.40300172567367554,
-0.35763922333717346,
-0.18327270448207855,
0.29501041769981384,
-0.10521325469017029,
0.22082491219043732,
0.11246821284294128,
0.2304573804140091,
-0.3613988161087036,
-0.32489413022994995,
0.7007428407669067,
-0.14755584299564362,
-0.011226843111217022,
1.0567866563796997,
0.18304012715816498,
0.18627065420150757,
0.7800126075744629,
-0.45877984166145325,
-0.08271564543247223,
-1.0429706573486328,
-0.17848260700702667,
0.4648679196834564,
0.5605693459510803,
-0.04325380176305771,
0.35714641213417053,
0.19618482887744904,
0.28654807806015015,
0.06300608068704605,
-0.3815035820007324,
0.1487312912940979,
0.13710474967956543,
-0.0021510024089366198,
-0.06697592884302139,
0.7626296877861023,
0.11713073402643204,
0.4744699001312256,
-0.5210976004600525,
-0.49335750937461853,
0.0870734304189682,
0.26115068793296814,
-0.613337516784668,
0.04471713304519653,
0.11413060873746872,
-0.3568873405456543,
-0.2716641426086426,
-0.046368908137083054,
-0.5562815070152283,
-0.5748192667961121,
-0.6114932894706726,
0.535114049911499,
0.06768240034580231,
-0.4128876030445099,
-0.08496686816215515,
-0.05856848135590553,
0.5649988651275635,
0.33745792508125305,
-1.1393671035766602,
0.32862260937690735,
1.105617880821228,
0.27435874938964844,
-0.11157454550266266,
-0.7510796785354614,
-0.49661144614219666,
0.3234426975250244,
-0.7548311948776245,
0.7444228529930115,
-0.4651952385902405,
-0.3021598756313324,
0.2775641679763794,
-0.05111512541770935,
0.22414812445640564,
-0.4691278636455536,
-0.06905379891395569,
-0.7119171023368835,
0.032424475997686386,
-0.2087620347738266,
-0.717629075050354,
0.03054235875606537,
0.39299535751342773,
-0.5718451738357544,
0.6757139563560486,
-0.12575595080852509,
-0.22839806973934174,
0.4244985282421112,
-0.5724050402641296,
-0.5317617654800415,
0.12308362871408463,
-0.291168749332428,
-0.3666992485523224,
0.224854975938797,
-0.23311857879161835,
0.5570079684257507,
-0.6588762998580933,
0.12038587033748627,
-0.44949138164520264,
-0.2448417991399765,
0.41407322883605957,
-0.03881675750017166,
0.43405085802078247,
0.23070356249809265,
-0.1693401038646698,
0.2075810730457306,
-0.24763916432857513,
0.09343376010656357,
0.40964728593826294,
-0.5349413752555847,
0.19129076600074768,
0.612969696521759,
-0.22532521188259125,
0.46690425276756287,
0.1301327496767044,
-0.15112896263599396,
0.35391443967819214,
-0.41850027441978455,
0.5637609958648682,
0.6140233874320984,
-0.28019848465919495,
0.7388598918914795,
-0.23768942058086395,
0.5193952322006226,
-0.29218971729278564,
0.18446806073188782,
-0.1517152041196823,
-0.1374249905347824,
-0.6397521495819092,
-0.01261726301163435,
0.21920794248580933,
0.5005370378494263,
-0.8721122741699219,
0.22178274393081665,
-0.11348944157361984,
-0.3637421131134033,
-0.5091632604598999,
0.22909358143806458,
0.41264745593070984,
-0.01569901779294014,
0.0498434454202652,
-0.4187978208065033,
-0.7059568166732788,
-0.502601683139801,
-0.10388165712356567,
-0.31378692388534546,
0.20836299657821655,
0.24972444772720337,
0.512981653213501,
-0.4112096428871155,
0.7217379808425903,
-0.045199763029813766,
-0.13112331926822662,
-0.5630230903625488,
0.036435604095458984,
-0.36995211243629456,
0.4141755998134613,
0.31342098116874695,
-0.678951621055603,
-0.5298839211463928,
-0.03890717402100563,
-0.8838216662406921,
0.08538378030061722,
-0.028033863753080368,
0.12932901084423065,
0.35721737146377563,
0.9072905778884888,
-0.433172345161438,
-0.040220022201538086,
0.4757985472679138,
-0.1996050775051117,
0.4233224391937256,
-0.360211044549942,
-0.13742892444133759,
-0.9718713760375977,
-0.3566153347492218,
-0.1895017921924591,
-0.14818964898586273,
-0.8275312185287476,
0.5327136516571045,
-0.3566710948944092,
0.09031541645526886,
-0.40154629945755005,
0.7111861705780029,
-0.9322790503501892,
-0.4368467926979065,
-0.7166265249252319,
0.37250596284866333,
-0.19834694266319275,
0.39864596724510193,
0.24210339784622192,
0.4580371677875519,
0.6481216549873352,
-0.5694885849952698,
0.6643279790878296,
-0.0559653714299202,
-0.07244734466075897,
0.46871742606163025,
-0.48586156964302063,
0.35436928272247314,
-0.31085923314094543,
0.24871456623077393,
-0.7405372262001038,
-0.07276767492294312,
0.2133120596408844,
-0.3970095217227936,
0.4890229105949402,
-0.08351533114910126,
-0.6952722072601318,
-0.3685470521450043,
-0.09425319731235504,
0.24383829534053802,
0.49263331294059753,
-0.28174906969070435,
0.5357834100723267,
0.8190687298774719,
0.07860219478607178,
-0.6342937350273132,
-0.6341326832771301,
0.031089134514331818,
-0.21636126935482025,
-0.32608503103256226,
-0.033306557685136795,
0.08239734172821045,
-0.3912069797515869,
-0.19173049926757812,
0.29259639978408813,
-0.24089862406253815,
0.4813336431980133,
0.19140979647636414,
0.0566316619515419,
-0.3198574185371399,
0.5184610486030579,
-0.43628132343292236,
-0.31514492630958557,
0.08905786275863647,
-0.5045762658119202,
0.6523478627204895,
0.3001786172389984,
-0.2769865393638611,
-0.07042942196130753,
0.2866245210170746,
0.12254450470209122,
-0.31249991059303284,
0.667873740196228,
0.4019281268119812,
-0.14289231598377228,
-0.373599648475647,
-0.4555543065071106,
-0.23481552302837372,
-0.3556252419948578,
0.67921382188797,
-0.49082842469215393,
-1.047834873199463,
0.5547882914543152,
-0.4840908944606781,
0.14217087626457214,
0.42484530806541443,
0.882044792175293,
-0.20064939558506012,
1.1676291227340698,
0.9409400224685669,
-0.04533625394105911,
0.3795148730278015,
-0.1519719958305359,
-0.010480009019374847,
-0.5413092374801636,
-0.3969402015209198,
-0.5670202970504761,
-0.3967423141002655,
-0.49318623542785645,
-0.5646904706954956,
-0.09833289682865143,
0.09616494923830032,
-0.5780148506164551,
0.10669796913862228,
0.0832304134964943,
0.8103715777397156,
0.3569034934043884,
-0.12695229053497314,
0.09304279834032059,
-0.09459005296230316,
-0.1333235651254654,
0.12158709764480591,
-0.7140093445777893,
-0.5301281809806824,
1.2538776397705078,
0.5952097773551941,
0.7228343486785889,
0.2224048674106598,
0.8124464154243469,
0.07010208815336227,
0.3039124608039856,
-0.8028035759925842,
0.3702648878097534,
0.21526621282100677,
-0.8296177983283997,
-0.6741743683815002,
-0.3333359360694885,
-1.182760238647461,
0.18664716184139252,
-0.5066574215888977,
-0.5202776789665222,
-0.3109871745109558,
-0.14546158909797668,
-0.2213904708623886,
0.4247123599052429,
-0.6429740190505981,
0.8796746134757996,
-0.4375486969947815,
-0.4243086278438568,
-0.34445783495903015,
-0.7474717497825623,
0.06755086779594421,
-0.16012124717235565,
0.3505864143371582,
-0.08454925566911697,
-0.3605462908744812,
0.648386538028717,
-0.16126349568367004,
0.7661957144737244,
-0.20957615971565247,
-0.4430950880050659,
0.4660089612007141,
0.04770880565047264,
0.39406996965408325,
-0.07033350318670273,
0.20498012006282806,
-0.1792333871126175,
-0.17354901134967804,
-0.5584607720375061,
-0.43554964661598206,
0.45814740657806396,
-1.0950794219970703,
-0.562950849533081,
-0.40498238801956177,
-0.6755279302597046,
-0.33818644285202026,
0.13934572041034698,
-0.049027543514966965,
0.03335309773683548,
-0.7393930554389954,
-0.14969977736473083,
0.9098294377326965,
-0.17855939269065857,
0.3594042658805847,
0.9058047533035278,
-0.32504481077194214,
-0.08225617557764053,
0.9266958832740784,
-0.029547840356826782,
0.3916732966899872,
0.5310437083244324,
-0.10162299871444702,
-0.238412544131279,
-0.62382572889328,
-0.10879810154438019,
0.35926353931427,
-0.45441174507141113,
0.017874008044600487,
-0.1832958459854126,
-0.24271148443222046,
-0.3348580598831177,
0.057518891990184784,
-0.5599668025970459,
0.12420184165239334,
-0.3179853856563568,
0.1003011092543602,
-0.16359978914260864,
1.0525150299072266,
-0.06384013593196869,
0.6150755286216736,
-0.5707283020019531,
0.0938105508685112,
0.39639952778816223,
0.31163984537124634,
0.06630805134773254,
-0.28505387902259827,
-0.44301387667655945,
0.2380649447441101,
-0.325942724943161,
-0.7359402179718018,
0.1298292577266693,
0.173320934176445,
0.6904263496398926,
0.48841091990470886,
-0.4592113494873047,
0.188263401389122,
-0.7323954105377197,
0.699490487575531,
0.26384493708610535,
-0.6010912656784058,
0.22551119327545166,
-0.310299277305603,
0.05143893137574196,
0.2986062467098236,
0.37681981921195984,
-0.7314639091491699,
0.11574540287256241,
-0.4624984562397003,
-0.42425990104675293,
1.0173486471176147,
-0.403340607881546,
0.1455186903476715,
0.0772014930844307,
0.4205397367477417,
0.18798622488975525,
0.35716676712036133,
-0.5969014763832092,
-0.24309909343719482,
0.40063491463661194,
0.013726882636547089,
-0.7135093808174133,
-0.39815467596054077,
-0.2608416974544525,
0.025234563276171684,
0.6916104555130005,
-0.2472018301486969,
0.27201440930366516,
-0.44556939601898193,
-0.2754092812538147,
-0.37183016538619995,
0.18703210353851318,
0.37671175599098206,
0.6264582276344299,
0.275667279958725,
-0.0016054160660132766,
-0.0035433226730674505,
-0.04670646786689758,
0.48151111602783203,
0.030036387965083122,
-0.010334293358027935,
-0.5396542549133301,
0.5649164319038391,
0.9772949814796448,
0.213833749294281,
-0.7524842023849487,
0.3879784941673279,
0.022376352921128273,
-0.5708795189857483,
-0.2959066331386566,
0.10447888821363449,
0.21994131803512573,
0.7882331013679504,
0.25956177711486816,
-0.37355780601501465,
-0.32538384199142456,
-1.0425606966018677,
0.09352004528045654,
0.6469300985336304,
-0.5732272267341614,
-0.38873597979545593,
0.46334177255630493,
0.22772015631198883,
-0.5675961971282959,
0.36660483479499817,
-0.33507466316223145,
-0.5760586857795715,
0.6621297001838684,
0.601445734500885,
0.9225550293922424,
-0.3637816309928894,
0.4675883948802948,
-0.02204235829412937,
0.2535722255706787,
-0.498972088098526,
0.15871265530586243,
0.11637396365404129,
-0.8657057881355286,
-0.5516236424446106,
-0.332319051027298,
-0.3217817544937134,
-0.0036138289142400026,
-0.23262828588485718,
0.2605149745941162,
-0.46295076608657837,
-0.1526566594839096,
0.013559618964791298,
0.46131962537765503,
-0.6370298266410828,
-0.18421082198619843,
0.6808745265007019,
0.5395660400390625,
-0.8521888256072998,
0.8507276773452759,
0.8910680413246155,
-0.48448535799980164,
-0.7786298394203186,
-0.24025286734104156,
0.08839646726846695,
-0.7317870855331421,
0.6138633489608765,
-0.1754002869129181,
0.08043111115694046,
0.027653371915221214,
-0.6978049278259277,
-0.860863447189331,
0.9787165522575378,
0.5001018047332764,
-0.538670539855957,
-0.2698187828063965,
0.32039082050323486,
0.6580301523208618,
-0.7686259150505066,
0.30226898193359375,
0.7258728742599487,
0.20385749638080597,
0.0793854370713234,
-0.7551442384719849,
-0.30839645862579346,
0.17252877354621887,
0.0507124625146389,
0.291006475687027,
-0.7582662105560303,
0.7733387351036072,
-0.4328661262989044,
-0.20783022046089172,
0.2235403060913086,
0.7546707987785339,
0.01993529312312603,
0.20933403074741364,
0.20416595041751862,
0.4174061119556427,
0.4978802800178528,
-0.1602822244167328,
0.5691468715667725,
0.0017222758615389466,
0.40951859951019287,
0.9684038758277893,
-0.6819002032279968,
0.6564575433731079,
0.3286145329475403,
-0.2183477282524109,
0.2840399742126465,
0.6999454498291016,
-0.04507477208971977,
0.30822861194610596,
0.6227321028709412,
0.022779889404773712,
-0.3993750810623169,
0.013120787218213081,
-0.2615047097206116,
0.6251657605171204,
0.43362221121788025,
-0.20083525776863098,
-0.3933975398540497,
-0.0441947765648365,
0.052010875195264816,
0.279132604598999,
-0.5092145204544067,
1.1523171663284302,
0.08781693130731583,
-0.72198486328125,
0.20675703883171082,
0.045127902179956436,
0.4566664397716522,
-0.6027116179466248,
-0.040119849145412445,
0.005408473778516054,
0.3303889334201813,
0.11579880863428116,
-0.5865651965141296,
-0.2855943441390991,
-0.10787706822156906,
-0.23899003863334656,
-0.14348401129245758,
0.33590683341026306,
-0.5684407949447632,
-0.20123916864395142,
0.48689040541648865,
0.7555328607559204,
0.29102179408073425,
0.1723327487707138,
-0.9287089109420776,
0.16386495530605316,
-0.29191529750823975,
-0.0871083065867424,
0.6049200296401978,
0.7148842215538025,
0.04293122887611389,
0.6123685836791992,
0.2650667130947113,
0.2795007824897766,
-0.09355884790420532,
0.0928836390376091,
0.4732595384120941,
-0.5875902771949768,
-0.3978033661842346,
-0.9306421279907227,
0.06325928866863251,
0.22531861066818237,
-0.03805529326200485,
0.5445178747177124,
0.3994414210319519,
0.9904730916023254,
0.07807455956935883,
0.7192298769950867,
0.25365713238716125,
0.43535736203193665,
-0.48400551080703735,
0.5683109164237976,
-0.3828316628932953,
0.1794254332780838,
-0.1437194049358368,
-1.070635199546814,
-0.21485064923763275,
0.3392515182495117,
-0.177727609872818,
0.2880631685256958,
0.5146738886833191,
0.6090046763420105,
0.28343465924263,
-0.32157784700393677,
0.25082072615623474,
0.22683925926685333,
0.425290584564209,
0.8337352871894836,
1.0428636074066162,
-0.3232352137565613,
0.17641408741474152,
0.2047255039215088,
-0.048789504915475845,
-0.36260196566581726,
-0.5806521773338318,
-1.2385319471359253,
-0.6145230531692505,
-0.20128090679645538,
-0.24452611804008484,
0.16819405555725098,
1.2465543746948242,
0.5555857419967651,
-0.5561860799789429,
-0.7251522541046143,
0.08056841790676117,
0.2795468270778656,
-0.2615361213684082,
-0.05390572547912598,
0.10093085467815399,
-0.65834641456604,
-0.6777838468551636,
0.27078673243522644,
0.13756364583969116,
0.09141671657562256,
-0.6499764323234558,
-0.7312837839126587,
-0.31692057847976685,
0.24089603126049042,
0.5940483808517456,
0.7013340592384338,
-0.6933889985084534,
-0.11563366651535034,
-0.24479317665100098,
-0.27307742834091187,
-0.049752090126276016,
0.8458825945854187,
-0.6891427636146545,
0.3698488175868988,
0.2216479331254959,
0.6990363001823425,
0.2524416148662567,
-0.30745017528533936,
0.7047993540763855,
-0.5858603119850159,
0.5313435792922974,
0.16313177347183228,
-0.018476644530892372,
0.3099468946456909,
0.08736661821603775,
0.38416197896003723,
0.08025476336479187,
-0.5791906714439392,
-0.8855631351470947,
0.5180590152740479,
-0.36074450612068176,
-0.42587074637413025,
1.166057825088501,
0.028050627559423447,
-0.27113106846809387,
0.09448216110467911,
-0.04150818660855293,
0.5194514989852905,
-0.15042439103126526,
0.5268200635910034,
0.6997478008270264,
0.20467904210090637,
-0.08850857615470886,
-0.4802892804145813,
0.7008942365646362,
-0.04292156547307968,
-0.5595765113830566,
0.054823461920022964,
0.5541040897369385,
0.06866302341222763,
-0.031117785722017288,
0.5799489617347717,
0.13990500569343567,
0.2437313050031662,
0.1555328518152237,
0.3850446343421936,
-0.048297055065631866,
-0.6621079444885254,
-0.3985438346862793,
0.02826017327606678,
0.49478021264076233,
0.09939134120941162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08064v1 | Beyond LLMs: Advancing the Landscape of Complex Reasoning | 2024-02-12T21:14:45 | 2024-02-12T21:14:45 | Jennifer Chu-Carroll, Andrew Beck, Greg Burnham, David OS Melville, David Nachman, A. Erdem Özcan, David Ferrucci | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Since the advent of Large Language Models a few years ago, they have often
been considered the de facto solution for many AI problems. However, in
addition to the many deficiencies of LLMs that prevent them from broad industry
adoption, such as reliability, cost, and speed, there is a whole class of
common real world problems that Large Language Models perform poorly on,
namely, constraint satisfaction and optimization problems. These problems are
ubiquitous and current solutions are highly specialized and expensive to
implement. At Elemental Cognition, we developed our EC AI platform which takes
a neuro-symbolic approach to solving constraint satisfaction and optimization
problems. The platform employs, at its core, a precise and high performance
logical reasoning engine, and leverages LLMs for knowledge acquisition and user
interaction. This platform supports developers in specifying application logic
in natural and concise language while generating application user interfaces to
interact with users effectively. We evaluated LLMs against systems built on the
EC AI platform in three domains and found the EC AI systems to significantly
outperform LLMs on constructing valid and optimal solutions, on validating
proposed solutions, and on repairing invalid solutions. | [
-0.5046064257621765,
-0.6502844095230103,
1.2777538299560547,
0.18995225429534912,
0.16798581182956696,
0.37701085209846497,
-0.4351940155029297,
-0.841295063495636,
0.014928724616765976,
0.4100748300552368,
-0.8402183055877686,
-0.5637243986129761,
-0.3826257884502411,
0.17028501629829407,
-0.04757790267467499,
0.464645117521286,
-0.007313990965485573,
0.06760117411613464,
-0.749969482421875,
-0.022362951189279556,
-0.3585050702095032,
-0.6189227104187012,
-0.5042072534561157,
-0.7282971739768982,
0.3369256854057312,
0.3671495020389557,
0.5040464997291565,
0.3325672149658203,
0.5962120890617371,
0.36508068442344666,
-0.007334722205996513,
0.5931875705718994,
-0.11521593481302261,
0.21846358478069305,
-0.41343995928764343,
-0.7803152799606323,
-0.34957265853881836,
-0.2567062973976135,
0.06412702053785324,
0.8233587741851807,
-0.17231164872646332,
-0.11503226310014725,
-0.11854616552591324,
0.5778613686561584,
-0.6553736925125122,
0.17717789113521576,
-0.6591446399688721,
0.10031832754611969,
0.03851927071809769,
0.027897030115127563,
-0.5147895216941833,
-0.13375720381736755,
0.1689922958612442,
-1.066687822341919,
-0.4404345750808716,
0.18017221987247467,
0.7404084801673889,
0.7248221039772034,
-0.4139275848865509,
-0.36265257000923157,
-1.0671545267105103,
1.035224437713623,
-0.5323443412780762,
0.3562827408313751,
0.13904428482055664,
0.10328178107738495,
-0.48071426153182983,
-0.6371212601661682,
-0.6214727163314819,
-0.3072112500667572,
0.21997950971126556,
0.18093304336071014,
-0.3630419969558716,
0.29821261763572693,
0.23599576950073242,
-0.08449157327413559,
-0.32326972484588623,
0.4453454911708832,
-0.14228464663028717,
-0.2841290235519409,
0.6525838971138,
0.4951654076576233,
0.3962114751338959,
0.2362445592880249,
-0.17872026562690735,
0.2030138373374939,
-0.9375536441802979,
-0.04882511496543884,
0.2051074504852295,
-0.059095896780490875,
0.166433647274971,
0.4733959138393402,
-0.241839200258255,
0.6568617820739746,
-0.2564186453819275,
0.07821930199861526,
0.09910652041435242,
0.16657817363739014,
-0.052855558693408966,
-0.0036021608393639326,
0.2995309829711914,
0.1380821317434311,
0.1890919804573059,
-0.3846861720085144,
-0.3007677495479584,
0.5160884261131287,
0.2966289222240448,
-0.379747211933136,
-0.08518552780151367,
0.6087695360183716,
-0.12045620381832123,
-0.026893632486462593,
-0.21011224389076233,
-0.3157920241355896,
-0.4323243796825409,
-0.9799676537513733,
0.2260821908712387,
-0.4228464663028717,
-0.1759471744298935,
0.39011508226394653,
-0.04907867684960365,
0.3431762754917145,
0.5395720601081848,
-0.5261734127998352,
0.403174489736557,
1.098645567893982,
0.4899207651615143,
-0.20354795455932617,
-0.11879923194646835,
-0.2085767388343811,
0.24886873364448547,
-0.28884077072143555,
0.9821308255195618,
-0.5961718559265137,
-0.24676044285297394,
-0.1350025236606598,
-0.35585588216781616,
0.2735190987586975,
-0.824819028377533,
0.8195846676826477,
-0.5690072178840637,
-0.18394914269447327,
-0.3598070442676544,
-0.7321687340736389,
-0.29105648398399353,
0.6878829598426819,
-0.3409678041934967,
0.6858986616134644,
-0.27738043665885925,
-0.24787239730358124,
0.1704508513212204,
-0.7194317579269409,
-0.2996213138103485,
0.17594140768051147,
-0.39273619651794434,
0.011744613759219646,
0.20052470266819,
-0.012451939284801483,
0.22438161075115204,
-0.6276699900627136,
0.23631994426250458,
-0.48770394921302795,
-0.22336429357528687,
0.04324842989444733,
-0.1906147301197052,
0.5929255485534668,
0.27562376856803894,
-0.49604687094688416,
0.1449110507965088,
-0.8106289505958557,
0.35882431268692017,
0.03382287546992302,
-0.24519601464271545,
-0.411687433719635,
0.39719873666763306,
-0.24131694436073303,
0.3900383412837982,
0.5136203765869141,
-0.5636947154998779,
0.19464920461177826,
-0.46320220828056335,
0.81962651014328,
0.8884584903717041,
-0.2234310507774353,
0.2959800362586975,
-0.10612011700868607,
0.3556210696697235,
-0.01023173425346613,
0.007850407622754574,
0.17984476685523987,
-0.2523820996284485,
-1.0134893655776978,
-0.17470669746398926,
0.046352729201316833,
0.7954382300376892,
-0.5228181481361389,
0.749173104763031,
-0.26020342111587524,
-0.505286693572998,
-0.2560819983482361,
0.25357967615127563,
0.24329157173633575,
0.42264312505722046,
0.349537193775177,
0.1281488686800003,
-0.4833850562572479,
-1.101908564567566,
-0.16457511484622955,
-0.18011367321014404,
-0.21762420237064362,
0.570307731628418,
0.5691172480583191,
-0.5118025541305542,
0.8168694972991943,
-0.493194043636322,
-0.22797532379627228,
-0.24609772861003876,
-0.052863944321870804,
0.25855204463005066,
0.4125782549381256,
0.1252496838569641,
-0.6594840288162231,
-0.043516453355550766,
0.33531585335731506,
-1.0728720426559448,
-0.13456884026527405,
-0.10266172885894775,
-0.2916710674762726,
0.26010578870773315,
0.5014769434928894,
-1.0122599601745605,
0.06588223576545715,
0.34308922290802,
-0.23145334422588348,
0.5843187570571899,
-0.317560076713562,
-0.21154500544071198,
-0.7729863524436951,
0.07545336335897446,
-0.004782446194440126,
-0.07664506137371063,
-0.19000332057476044,
0.1298701912164688,
-0.23910267651081085,
-0.11566650122404099,
-0.398347407579422,
0.46954500675201416,
-0.5185737609863281,
-0.13373975455760956,
-0.11591111123561859,
0.4757932424545288,
0.1369023472070694,
0.5983231067657471,
0.14265021681785583,
0.49772003293037415,
0.5906023979187012,
-0.7613292336463928,
0.5890800952911377,
0.2322075068950653,
-0.23042623698711395,
0.7557546496391296,
-0.807603657245636,
0.18300752341747284,
-0.16774269938468933,
0.27302348613739014,
-0.5243825316429138,
-0.1224619671702385,
-0.003929405473172665,
-0.14658568799495697,
0.01752864010632038,
0.3979824483394623,
-0.4764651954174042,
-0.39453333616256714,
-0.07891062647104263,
0.3471353054046631,
0.3308909833431244,
-0.49444669485092163,
0.9818286299705505,
0.3731132447719574,
0.12989740073680878,
-0.4621574282646179,
-0.6983030438423157,
0.28759440779685974,
-0.05098865181207657,
-0.8606709241867065,
0.5532304048538208,
-0.08286479860544205,
-0.6693757176399231,
0.16781418025493622,
-0.24820517003536224,
0.13250701129436493,
0.22287724912166595,
0.02451297827064991,
0.18642020225524902,
-0.1731400042772293,
0.19226719439029694,
0.14562669396400452,
-0.4033009707927704,
0.3688816726207733,
-0.554863452911377,
0.5351128578186035,
-0.32847508788108826,
-0.6149510741233826,
-0.6214823722839355,
0.2560345232486725,
0.7362180352210999,
-0.36144834756851196,
0.4967067539691925,
0.10294010490179062,
-0.6046819686889648,
-0.4726603031158447,
-0.5129933953285217,
-0.2011311650276184,
-0.4715637266635895,
0.5433985590934753,
-0.6005938649177551,
-0.6787371039390564,
0.5716456770896912,
-0.542098879814148,
0.29557228088378906,
0.3557746410369873,
0.43878239393234253,
-0.32465800642967224,
1.3050830364227295,
0.6047773957252502,
0.04145736247301102,
0.09771137684583664,
-0.3700699210166931,
0.31287699937820435,
-0.9058908224105835,
-0.48892784118652344,
-0.44586381316185,
-0.6884927153587341,
-0.24319259822368622,
-0.1746547967195511,
0.5886563062667847,
0.11891376227140427,
-0.5322140455245972,
0.14729918539524078,
-0.5721740126609802,
0.5341183543205261,
0.583559513092041,
0.22466827929019928,
0.41485488414764404,
-0.224349245429039,
-0.13000556826591492,
-0.18822596967220306,
-0.6504710912704468,
-0.7076241374015808,
0.8532501459121704,
0.17187267541885376,
0.6631947159767151,
0.20041802525520325,
0.41490596532821655,
0.24934245645999908,
0.29183483123779297,
-0.8524888157844543,
0.6755724549293518,
-0.016700975596904755,
-0.5481381416320801,
-0.1646653115749359,
-0.37337881326675415,
-0.8258865475654602,
0.20315708220005035,
-0.323740690946579,
-0.9312177300453186,
0.048451051115989685,
0.058468885719776154,
-0.3792468309402466,
0.36459824442863464,
-0.519676685333252,
0.6605673432350159,
-0.5503754019737244,
-0.5280488133430481,
-0.5725692510604858,
-0.6486346125602722,
0.31949183344841003,
0.16425079107284546,
0.13935433328151703,
-0.16548866033554077,
-0.3668902814388275,
0.29816803336143494,
-0.3881470561027527,
0.7363619804382324,
0.12482649832963943,
-0.12109164148569107,
0.33374151587486267,
0.19255124032497406,
0.6019834280014038,
0.007321981713175774,
-0.24142388999462128,
0.1160249412059784,
-0.37233197689056396,
-0.31573665142059326,
-0.796172022819519,
0.8905152082443237,
-1.0030020475387573,
-0.878099262714386,
-0.23043982684612274,
-0.5927019715309143,
-0.5375059247016907,
0.23694325983524323,
0.0526314415037632,
0.31033262610435486,
-0.14652711153030396,
0.16759143769741058,
0.9599305987358093,
-0.29681703448295593,
0.32998529076576233,
0.21867936849594116,
0.04976298660039902,
-0.27095210552215576,
0.8293943405151367,
-0.06409718096256256,
0.2326347827911377,
0.45682352781295776,
-0.020884674042463303,
-0.3246791660785675,
-0.4042079746723175,
-0.3817339539527893,
0.07524201273918152,
-0.7345390319824219,
-0.22813011705875397,
-0.6946024894714355,
-0.24647800624370575,
0.05248446762561798,
-0.4386586844921112,
-0.4409896731376648,
-0.4625328481197357,
-0.23880372941493988,
-0.18078213930130005,
-0.0433686263859272,
0.5915034413337708,
0.09438513219356537,
0.08128313720226288,
-0.8203487396240234,
-0.00029214724781922996,
0.09899739176034927,
0.12728166580200195,
0.027763115242123604,
-0.0195742379873991,
-0.010753165930509567,
0.05930415913462639,
-0.6728016138076782,
-0.5498555898666382,
0.04069533571600914,
-0.008089857175946236,
0.7695532441139221,
0.37658780813217163,
0.05171304568648338,
0.5507338047027588,
-0.24097181856632233,
0.6538566946983337,
0.13913722336292267,
-1.1087790727615356,
0.4720081090927124,
-0.1984015703201294,
0.2020229995250702,
0.41584914922714233,
0.23592525720596313,
-0.38203203678131104,
-0.34844088554382324,
-0.5892398953437805,
-0.9486905932426453,
0.5068336725234985,
0.22046083211898804,
0.11668819189071655,
0.19759176671504974,
0.5370908975601196,
-0.20487084984779358,
0.1901550143957138,
-0.732293426990509,
-0.34393030405044556,
0.3436829745769501,
-0.3469415009021759,
0.19110289216041565,
0.14616142213344574,
-0.17792977392673492,
-0.2621353268623352,
0.9762324690818787,
-0.11822187155485153,
0.007141930051147938,
0.21673010289669037,
-0.13193395733833313,
-0.011651276610791683,
0.15064848959445953,
0.5458335876464844,
0.7453437447547913,
0.2922254502773285,
0.05711609870195389,
0.1684134155511856,
-0.022287793457508087,
0.1472800225019455,
-0.11267752200365067,
-0.2371007204055786,
-0.3902491629123688,
0.35229969024658203,
0.597797155380249,
-0.09596654772758484,
-1.2100666761398315,
0.18472398817539215,
0.23785775899887085,
-0.32987216114997864,
-0.5407414436340332,
0.24292117357254028,
0.32353803515434265,
0.34007784724235535,
0.20170457661151886,
0.2837662100791931,
0.2445726990699768,
-0.4823477566242218,
-0.0018646500539034605,
0.5815514326095581,
-0.440053254365921,
-0.29544398188591003,
0.7464491724967957,
0.555278480052948,
-0.38711783289909363,
0.9005264639854431,
0.08938007056713104,
-0.7582605481147766,
0.9117270112037659,
0.5293340682983398,
0.7696435451507568,
0.20491375029087067,
0.02576793171465397,
0.14265860617160797,
0.587755024433136,
0.14883637428283691,
0.35613444447517395,
-0.08754026144742966,
-0.9168815612792969,
-0.4535847306251526,
-0.4505201578140259,
-0.6286190748214722,
-0.03727960214018822,
-0.17833007872104645,
0.4375258684158325,
-0.7081063389778137,
-0.10793029516935349,
-0.18486356735229492,
0.06816178560256958,
-0.6189186573028564,
0.21070876717567444,
0.34919431805610657,
0.9539337158203125,
-0.4689749479293823,
0.3508455753326416,
0.9690986275672913,
-0.3249143064022064,
-0.6499156355857849,
-0.4158603250980377,
-0.015755748376250267,
-0.6276794672012329,
0.6032918095588684,
0.16824465990066528,
-0.3433527946472168,
0.04699022322893143,
-0.7171555757522583,
-0.7870685458183289,
1.087952733039856,
0.6741061806678772,
-0.7977553606033325,
-0.006221816409379244,
0.24840021133422852,
0.5660660862922668,
-0.33819177746772766,
0.15607066452503204,
0.5887341499328613,
0.7345718741416931,
-0.016584156081080437,
-0.5377359390258789,
-0.09653487056493759,
-0.20989562571048737,
-0.2815599739551544,
0.42386990785598755,
-0.804558515548706,
0.5253633856773376,
-0.23556703329086304,
0.014910208061337471,
-0.0371212363243103,
0.6467997431755066,
0.68259197473526,
0.3908165693283081,
0.4239918887615204,
0.9854466915130615,
0.9297845363616943,
-0.22021304070949554,
0.8952906727790833,
-0.4690774977207184,
0.15599824488162994,
0.9471696019172668,
-0.6310229897499084,
0.7152575850486755,
0.6706133484840393,
-0.16634835302829742,
0.7211881279945374,
0.6755106449127197,
0.28787001967430115,
0.23096470534801483,
0.5258201956748962,
-0.4665463864803314,
-0.8284607529640198,
-0.2814527451992035,
-0.10240719467401505,
0.27396151423454285,
0.8098244071006775,
0.09068172425031662,
-0.17945119738578796,
-0.11267350614070892,
-0.1572486311197281,
0.32092583179473877,
-0.29134637117385864,
0.7445868253707886,
0.4554833173751831,
-0.6648474335670471,
0.17476893961429596,
0.04132483899593353,
0.4604625999927521,
-0.44772425293922424,
-0.14210635423660278,
-0.04050770401954651,
0.4508267939090729,
-0.3888360261917114,
-0.5769503116607666,
0.3655761778354645,
-0.28315985202789307,
-0.14263616502285004,
-0.10423260182142258,
0.6691989302635193,
-0.09590917825698853,
-0.5231272578239441,
0.3552984595298767,
0.7660234570503235,
-0.0026384335942566395,
-0.04691145196557045,
-0.6797974109649658,
0.08784385770559311,
-0.25400489568710327,
-0.2691184878349304,
-0.10417016595602036,
0.7356355786323547,
-0.1791919618844986,
1.2202668190002441,
0.7193610668182373,
-0.0025815062690526247,
-0.23969703912734985,
-0.13527081906795502,
0.8680590391159058,
-0.7124817371368408,
-0.43702733516693115,
-0.9133237600326538,
0.3757787346839905,
-0.12525629997253418,
-0.36487656831741333,
0.3028638958930969,
0.6121245622634888,
0.7826629877090454,
0.29087311029434204,
0.7921751141548157,
-0.14657162129878998,
0.10296260565519333,
-0.5017780661582947,
0.3020041882991791,
-0.7907459735870361,
0.6396216154098511,
-0.057417165488004684,
-1.2005716562271118,
-0.6671463251113892,
0.4411592185497284,
-0.45241013169288635,
-0.13144551217556,
0.6555392146110535,
0.587322473526001,
-0.14088192582130432,
0.06856529414653778,
0.34901976585388184,
0.2781772315502167,
0.6000564694404602,
0.9639330506324768,
1.1911284923553467,
0.0068388208746910095,
0.4009886682033539,
-0.08016493171453476,
-0.1789865642786026,
0.011667964048683643,
-0.8185153007507324,
-0.5524964928627014,
-0.14593733847141266,
-0.23031431436538696,
-0.16531902551651,
-0.0010633609490469098,
1.310542345046997,
0.6079925298690796,
-0.5577700734138489,
-0.23996788263320923,
-0.5267953872680664,
0.39139002561569214,
-0.14649668335914612,
-0.1955641508102417,
0.11836343258619308,
-0.5288769006729126,
-0.870021641254425,
0.2642926871776581,
0.6131922602653503,
-0.37384915351867676,
-0.49247220158576965,
-0.24803359806537628,
0.030161000788211823,
0.2956465482711792,
0.6227014660835266,
0.27196627855300903,
-0.8116185069084167,
-0.3405274450778961,
0.24077488481998444,
-0.23642125725746155,
0.03295788913965225,
0.7193514108657837,
-0.719957709312439,
0.07978808134794235,
0.33871644735336304,
1.1045918464660645,
0.22817659378051758,
-0.21957002580165863,
0.7404001355171204,
-0.13846375048160553,
0.16335535049438477,
0.509498655796051,
0.5499727129936218,
0.22204464673995972,
-0.4321267604827881,
0.4574131965637207,
0.2594795525074005,
-0.4941856563091278,
-0.6842122077941895,
0.43535447120666504,
-0.8983649611473083,
-0.42409345507621765,
0.9480006694793701,
-0.06607111543416977,
-0.39841845631599426,
-0.14269612729549408,
-0.16599775850772858,
-0.09971681982278824,
-0.2850305438041687,
0.8559155464172363,
0.824921190738678,
-0.5254201889038086,
0.24609555304050446,
-0.22135403752326965,
0.12985090911388397,
0.851608157157898,
-1.1011258363723755,
-0.15792304277420044,
0.6449270248413086,
0.08092593401670456,
0.3849879503250122,
0.31257107853889465,
0.004019583109766245,
0.16309203207492828,
-0.10962343961000443,
0.3633675277233124,
0.07259909808635712,
-0.5448185205459595,
0.01237474288791418,
0.06556868553161621,
0.20023833215236664,
0.10778182744979858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08021v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08021v2 | Careless Whisper: Speech-to-Text Hallucination Harms | 2024-02-12T19:35:37 | 2024-05-03T02:18:20 | Allison Koenecke, Anna Seo Gyeong Choi, Katelyn X. Mei, Hilke Schellmann, Mona Sloane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Speech-to-text services aim to transcribe input audio as accurately as
possible. They increasingly play a role in everyday life, for example in
personal voice assistants or in customer-company interactions. We evaluate Open
AI's Whisper, a state-of-the-art automated speech recognition service
outperforming industry competitors, as of 2023. While many of Whisper's
transcriptions were highly accurate, we find that roughly 1\% of audio
transcriptions contained entire hallucinated phrases or sentences which did not
exist in any form in the underlying audio. We thematically analyze the
Whisper-hallucinated content, finding that 38\% of hallucinations include
explicit harms such as perpetuating violence, making up inaccurate
associations, or implying false authority. We then study why hallucinations
occur by observing the disparities in hallucination rates between speakers with
aphasia (who have a lowered ability to express themselves using speech and
voice) and a control group. We find that hallucinations disproportionately
occur for individuals who speak with longer shares of non-vocal durations -- a
common symptom of aphasia. We call on industry practitioners to ameliorate
these language-model-based hallucinations in Whisper, and to raise awareness of
potential biases amplified by hallucinations in downstream applications of
speech-to-text models. | [
-0.11592794209718704,
-0.794292688369751,
0.6509469151496887,
0.5303122401237488,
-0.0056537725031375885,
-0.374663382768631,
0.1033439114689827,
-1.0359104871749878,
0.4585631489753723,
0.7922927737236023,
-0.5701913237571716,
-0.3762938678264618,
-0.6799615025520325,
0.024310806766152382,
-0.7754142880439758,
0.8036105036735535,
0.33352130651474,
0.16252945363521576,
0.10151095688343048,
-0.008320584893226624,
-0.6507442593574524,
-0.6426125168800354,
-0.5256476998329163,
0.11269168555736542,
0.25513795018196106,
0.10555744171142578,
0.9116740226745605,
0.38536474108695984,
0.24711428582668304,
0.23092995584011078,
-0.08154307305812836,
0.008473150432109833,
-0.6040566563606262,
0.30276960134506226,
0.2970271110534668,
-0.31127768754959106,
-0.4916258752346039,
0.050046078860759735,
0.22914500534534454,
0.7100937366485596,
-0.5290862917900085,
-0.08026871085166931,
0.046284232288599014,
0.6281846165657043,
-0.461927205324173,
-0.15061362087726593,
-0.8128361701965332,
0.292531818151474,
-0.2304530143737793,
-0.22830641269683838,
-0.6308877468109131,
-0.5025755763053894,
0.518724262714386,
-0.6128140687942505,
0.3296829164028168,
0.21317392587661743,
0.5950943231582642,
0.861546516418457,
0.09182117879390717,
-0.8879882097244263,
-1.0821276903152466,
0.5738707780838013,
-0.3209003508090973,
0.5013416409492493,
0.5996351838111877,
0.22901348769664764,
0.011285991407930851,
-0.6632290482521057,
-0.49711209535598755,
-0.3241879343986511,
0.06538722664117813,
0.13142570853233337,
-0.47039955854415894,
0.2576117515563965,
0.13355673849582672,
0.33088603615760803,
-0.5325634479522705,
0.11358868330717087,
-0.47300219535827637,
-0.5094039440155029,
0.6876131296157837,
0.18627233803272247,
0.5071816444396973,
0.10213807225227356,
-0.012016965076327324,
0.12468545883893967,
-0.3854345381259918,
-0.37812644243240356,
0.5828971266746521,
0.34183162450790405,
0.2793571949005127,
0.6672897934913635,
0.09103679656982422,
0.48263874650001526,
-0.16388994455337524,
-0.12331182509660721,
0.18345406651496887,
0.17161831259727478,
-0.2989368140697479,
0.7725042700767517,
0.6917215585708618,
0.3373764455318451,
0.43363070487976074,
-0.6261151432991028,
0.06756249070167542,
0.15795108675956726,
0.6076937317848206,
-0.38700929284095764,
-0.13666830956935883,
0.5211657881736755,
-0.6013853549957275,
-0.2857644557952881,
0.016741350293159485,
-0.792473554611206,
-0.8469385504722595,
-0.15787170827388763,
0.788162350654602,
-0.3515472412109375,
-0.06176990270614624,
0.43050381541252136,
-0.5095108151435852,
0.08409646153450012,
0.2815830111503601,
-0.7132587432861328,
0.5160667300224304,
0.46083104610443115,
1.0753034353256226,
-0.2354307770729065,
-0.48180198669433594,
-0.4687487781047821,
0.1822059452533722,
-0.3524484932422638,
0.7832716703414917,
-0.2109449952840805,
-0.7710015773773193,
0.14123930037021637,
-0.2122420221567154,
0.02143103815615177,
-0.9686134457588196,
0.8236111402511597,
0.039409514516592026,
0.2456493377685547,
-0.11077719926834106,
-0.2951921224594116,
-0.10159922391176224,
-0.4458526372909546,
-0.7030389904975891,
0.4861244261264801,
-0.3426368832588196,
-0.4974847435951233,
0.28231412172317505,
-0.6024930477142334,
-0.4972085654735565,
-0.09732288867235184,
-0.15717624127864838,
-0.39888545870780945,
0.3458121418952942,
0.064125657081604,
0.2951642572879791,
0.10541129857301712,
-0.08859111368656158,
-0.0027967302594333887,
-0.6456660032272339,
0.311494380235672,
-0.7037654519081116,
0.8406462073326111,
0.11416243016719818,
-0.4728565514087677,
0.18014807999134064,
-0.5955211520195007,
-0.2985554337501526,
0.03678521513938904,
0.14472445845603943,
-0.39427927136421204,
0.27475860714912415,
0.05003548786044121,
-0.06491777300834656,
-0.09143399447202682,
-0.40897318720817566,
-0.1920423060655594,
-0.7063961625099182,
0.3155480921268463,
0.8132174611091614,
0.24447129666805267,
0.20576588809490204,
-0.7694128155708313,
0.2856192886829376,
-0.028889931738376617,
0.62555992603302,
-0.00028623852995224297,
-0.6865891218185425,
-0.6270039677619934,
-0.25979122519493103,
-0.28212475776672363,
0.5129730105400085,
-0.25141653418540955,
0.4232446551322937,
-0.16977432370185852,
-0.5027414560317993,
-1.075226902961731,
-0.533658504486084,
0.1020929217338562,
0.6371394395828247,
0.645737886428833,
-0.1574988067150116,
-0.5063649415969849,
-0.8175851702690125,
-0.4638330340385437,
-0.21829067170619965,
-0.03627445176243782,
0.3045719265937805,
0.059443749487400055,
-0.3955126702785492,
0.832528829574585,
-0.48113393783569336,
-1.0574835538864136,
0.24321435391902924,
0.054935719817876816,
-0.25169211626052856,
0.13119086623191833,
0.07568198442459106,
-0.588412880897522,
-0.35314613580703735,
-0.2787458896636963,
-0.6978305578231812,
-0.1844293624162674,
-0.34661203622817993,
0.2575854957103729,
0.4193914532661438,
0.40439170598983765,
-0.5799561738967896,
0.6219953894615173,
0.5113391280174255,
-0.37454843521118164,
0.7993779182434082,
-0.1453029215335846,
0.01741793379187584,
-0.7882828712463379,
-0.1117100641131401,
-0.37526944279670715,
0.16695840656757355,
-0.6646689176559448,
-0.36100196838378906,
-0.5990156531333923,
-0.153801828622818,
-0.378898024559021,
0.20185454189777374,
-0.32949385046958923,
-0.24926570057868958,
-0.17475749552249908,
0.3497864007949829,
-0.24466539919376373,
0.14142365753650665,
0.05275145173072815,
1.0108561515808105,
0.6424130797386169,
-0.5118878483772278,
0.11659847944974899,
0.5052233338356018,
-0.42706477642059326,
0.10322640836238861,
-0.5658044815063477,
0.25143396854400635,
-0.04485537111759186,
0.08228202909231186,
-0.6718022227287292,
-0.10681014508008957,
0.18316982686519623,
-0.6891125440597534,
-0.1443062275648117,
0.38201451301574707,
-0.3774232566356659,
0.0572933703660965,
-0.26823168992996216,
0.13619723916053772,
0.7244485020637512,
-0.5071207284927368,
0.5940807461738586,
0.6933965682983398,
-0.18980157375335693,
-0.48877784609794617,
-0.9062724113464355,
0.421501487493515,
-0.06340858340263367,
-0.3911205232143402,
0.433799147605896,
-0.04242599382996559,
-0.4827387034893036,
-0.24757041037082672,
-0.24999164044857025,
-0.004596755374222994,
-0.025633182376623154,
0.6199014782905579,
0.046076782047748566,
0.1504460722208023,
0.09078767895698547,
0.20726794004440308,
-0.04457405209541321,
0.44047221541404724,
-0.15607452392578125,
0.652199923992157,
0.1423291116952896,
-0.29996469616889954,
-0.7925639152526855,
0.5149174928665161,
0.6692567467689514,
0.17960450053215027,
0.5181396007537842,
0.17614498734474182,
-0.48816096782684326,
-0.25670430064201355,
-0.6676793098449707,
-0.3505304157733917,
-0.42736178636550903,
0.2984243929386139,
-0.08775601536035538,
-0.5317061543464661,
0.4874149560928345,
0.0911867544054985,
-0.05589708313345909,
0.28746771812438965,
0.4160611927509308,
-0.24821197986602783,
1.1787081956863403,
0.5048026442527771,
-0.2143869698047638,
0.23957636952400208,
0.042204078286886215,
0.3108220398426056,
-0.44406968355178833,
-0.59562748670578,
-0.767470121383667,
0.17958486080169678,
-0.5702557563781738,
-0.1827971488237381,
0.3690725862979889,
-0.22827351093292236,
0.19067344069480896,
0.1494239717721939,
-0.7804633378982544,
0.2818250060081482,
0.41908854246139526,
0.14353683590888977,
0.5676581859588623,
0.05550302937626839,
0.1789323091506958,
-0.3190782964229584,
-0.3937334418296814,
-0.7152280211448669,
0.8404483199119568,
0.5434055924415588,
0.7888069748878479,
0.04763460159301758,
0.7284311056137085,
0.5542320013046265,
-0.0853988453745842,
-1.036583662033081,
0.36694467067718506,
-0.13697446882724762,
-0.5634183287620544,
-0.5943337082862854,
-0.1305561065673828,
-0.6905768513679504,
-0.0555269755423069,
0.07299209386110306,
-0.9021970629692078,
0.24441401660442352,
0.15040431916713715,
-0.38815292716026306,
0.11280447989702225,
-0.7633146643638611,
0.40710729360580444,
-0.04913535714149475,
0.009937543421983719,
-0.2867947220802307,
-0.4833678603172302,
0.2730759382247925,
0.01694648526608944,
0.26086118817329407,
0.011699117720127106,
0.0020117268431931734,
0.9701546430587769,
-0.41339948773384094,
0.9571772217750549,
-0.2567977011203766,
-0.41172486543655396,
0.23214539885520935,
0.1773199737071991,
0.39884957671165466,
-0.19812741875648499,
-0.016743959859013557,
0.46984270215034485,
-0.05652189999818802,
-0.0047156899236142635,
-0.5287753939628601,
0.46235591173171997,
-0.7677097916603088,
-0.5332903265953064,
-0.4969331920146942,
-0.33148297667503357,
-0.3109998404979706,
-0.016043275594711304,
0.7047498822212219,
0.332258403301239,
-0.5462004542350769,
-0.20267608761787415,
0.9967382550239563,
-0.25515487790107727,
0.3525902032852173,
0.22453612089157104,
-0.30713194608688354,
-0.47737041115760803,
1.1429321765899658,
0.21291232109069824,
0.15896601974964142,
0.12468871474266052,
0.18160532414913177,
-0.3242812156677246,
-0.6948089003562927,
-0.16203086078166962,
0.34219425916671753,
-0.6010993719100952,
0.21785135567188263,
-1.0583559274673462,
-0.3037184476852417,
-0.6546522974967957,
-0.07022207230329514,
-0.3230363130569458,
-0.3117036819458008,
-0.5628437399864197,
0.04758881777524948,
0.23525260388851166,
0.801769495010376,
-0.009633797220885754,
0.21897634863853455,
-0.6024661064147949,
0.43449699878692627,
0.46871888637542725,
0.2736164927482605,
0.06689979135990143,
-0.5823705792427063,
0.020567994564771652,
-0.024373270571231842,
-0.30090951919555664,
-0.8856849074363708,
0.31480637192726135,
0.21885159611701965,
0.3648194372653961,
0.5126917362213135,
0.3419743776321411,
0.7895578145980835,
-0.7099000215530396,
1.0486751794815063,
0.2030499130487442,
-1.1420073509216309,
0.5098424553871155,
-0.026978813111782074,
-0.01689109206199646,
0.5970404744148254,
0.5056121945381165,
-0.8458622097969055,
-0.8077203631401062,
-0.5062150359153748,
-0.7538410425186157,
0.4614661931991577,
0.34143444895744324,
0.2613258957862854,
0.013692249543964863,
0.05685341730713844,
0.4508688151836395,
0.14062029123306274,
-0.6388734579086304,
-0.436914324760437,
-0.41625645756721497,
-0.11848627030849457,
0.08211039751768112,
-0.3613368570804596,
-0.15958333015441895,
-0.10562606900930405,
0.6443575024604797,
0.18666690587997437,
0.7253246903419495,
0.4931849539279938,
-0.08673181384801865,
-0.2992075979709625,
-0.0659000352025032,
0.9182848930358887,
0.34336984157562256,
-0.11633886396884918,
-0.05786607414484024,
0.09446854889392853,
-0.9589036703109741,
-0.13066326081752777,
0.10347277671098709,
-0.0554225817322731,
0.34111863374710083,
0.5997686982154846,
0.8522577881813049,
-0.15520229935646057,
-0.913891077041626,
0.6257832050323486,
-0.14063820242881775,
-0.3649385869503021,
-0.5672422051429749,
0.10912760347127914,
-0.25776705145835876,
0.0012181082274764776,
0.41867005825042725,
0.2928939461708069,
0.6677321791648865,
-0.7534567713737488,
0.20902377367019653,
0.38623538613319397,
-0.7575298547744751,
-0.2658635675907135,
0.6707863807678223,
0.16826918721199036,
-0.8447081446647644,
0.5581066608428955,
0.30532923340797424,
-0.49254950881004333,
0.1585794985294342,
0.35511261224746704,
1.4307888746261597,
-0.4170016944408417,
0.12259691953659058,
-0.14228405058383942,
0.5335492491722107,
-0.11126166582107544,
0.2859019935131073,
-0.08752081543207169,
-0.45276182889938354,
-0.047608599066734314,
-0.39284494519233704,
-0.6739998459815979,
0.2393045574426651,
-0.6779534816741943,
0.28294289112091064,
-0.14925558865070343,
-0.13717886805534363,
0.1139209046959877,
-0.39987048506736755,
-0.12899038195610046,
0.05130420997738838,
-0.04173879325389862,
0.7704361081123352,
-0.7457102537155151,
0.475716233253479,
0.017413439229130745,
-0.350425660610199,
-0.4773828387260437,
0.7783687710762024,
-0.05176051706075668,
-0.6584824323654175,
0.11536633968353271,
0.37512531876564026,
-0.43212348222732544,
0.10433236509561539,
-0.5137657523155212,
-0.5384892225265503,
0.8576804399490356,
0.18642576038837433,
-0.630535364151001,
-0.3473164141178131,
0.2635195553302765,
0.6686148047447205,
0.02318185195326805,
-0.010862205177545547,
0.505563497543335,
0.3799040913581848,
-0.07951986789703369,
-1.1755924224853516,
-0.08987948298454285,
0.2103554904460907,
-0.27277734875679016,
0.05812634900212288,
-0.5193261504173279,
0.38344860076904297,
-0.2280626744031906,
-0.4251101016998291,
0.040759649127721786,
0.3699018359184265,
0.04388415440917015,
0.5482502579689026,
0.39108777046203613,
0.29565954208374023,
0.8376868367195129,
0.08448658138513565,
0.8230390548706055,
0.06324533373117447,
-0.21003501117229462,
1.146500825881958,
-0.4093528091907501,
0.8546833992004395,
0.694293737411499,
0.02811809815466404,
0.21270209550857544,
0.06921270489692688,
0.1889633983373642,
0.6990047693252563,
0.15219253301620483,
-0.394911527633667,
0.2612740099430084,
-0.2657366693019867,
-0.39147740602493286,
0.41345036029815674,
0.3647390902042389,
-0.35782232880592346,
0.09700566530227661,
0.5156829953193665,
-0.24222105741500854,
0.252304345369339,
0.06851296871900558,
1.2329318523406982,
0.07675745338201523,
-0.4886488914489746,
0.4243749678134918,
-0.23425373435020447,
0.6660804748535156,
-0.4237254858016968,
-0.06276962906122208,
0.07148835062980652,
-0.003566063940525055,
-0.12870147824287415,
-0.2999655306339264,
0.7638858556747437,
-0.009333127178251743,
-0.16184741258621216,
-0.25719815492630005,
0.5394958257675171,
-0.25278764963150024,
-0.03339220583438873,
0.4472757577896118,
0.23829270899295807,
0.47901657223701477,
-0.5118514895439148,
-0.5195403099060059,
0.4086993634700775,
-0.029988601803779602,
0.14039510488510132,
-0.002370176836848259,
0.3303315341472626,
0.15050138533115387,
0.5610299110412598,
0.4062586724758148,
0.4507097005844116,
0.16680529713630676,
0.22753027081489563,
0.5710180401802063,
-0.5936462879180908,
-0.5765807032585144,
-0.75560063123703,
0.31721898913383484,
-0.13429906964302063,
-0.548105001449585,
0.5585970282554626,
0.5650712847709656,
0.6078565120697021,
-0.12210550904273987,
0.8267988562583923,
0.18380917608737946,
0.6653977632522583,
-0.6520004272460938,
1.216298222541809,
-0.36493775248527527,
0.11896286904811859,
-0.43132010102272034,
-0.9514251351356506,
-0.2512391209602356,
0.6929566860198975,
-0.15141309797763824,
-0.05332948639988899,
0.8264132738113403,
0.7851414084434509,
0.46003881096839905,
0.4889746308326721,
0.58208829164505,
0.5308930277824402,
0.3145882189273834,
0.0678701177239418,
0.9842678308486938,
-0.5918408036231995,
0.6694445610046387,
-0.3053596615791321,
-0.21550382673740387,
-0.2264169603586197,
-0.5407272577285767,
-0.7461872100830078,
-0.8863956332206726,
-0.3240518271923065,
-0.3024725317955017,
0.16899757087230682,
0.7081305384635925,
0.5066848397254944,
-0.595020592212677,
-0.3350292146205902,
-0.3418005108833313,
0.0228874571621418,
-0.3517058789730072,
-0.28787291049957275,
0.22001296281814575,
-0.19290871918201447,
-0.713897705078125,
0.4906657636165619,
0.40833207964897156,
0.5085947513580322,
-0.44578659534454346,
-0.1736629754304886,
0.2777593433856964,
0.3268171548843384,
0.5874882936477661,
0.062068164348602295,
-1.0548769235610962,
-0.03199674189090729,
0.12666085362434387,
-0.13370764255523682,
-0.12078914791345596,
0.7471969723701477,
-0.6196483373641968,
0.4732966721057892,
0.10518703609704971,
0.37999576330184937,
0.11346182227134705,
-0.216961070895195,
0.4282933175563812,
-0.5607199668884277,
0.09789913147687912,
0.7170120477676392,
-0.1307908296585083,
0.08464982360601425,
-0.7227088809013367,
0.0798393040895462,
0.12944115698337555,
-0.4790070354938507,
-1.1960574388504028,
-0.08741775155067444,
-0.8686819672584534,
-0.4356785714626312,
0.8571246266365051,
0.43990617990493774,
0.02601754665374756,
-0.4426107704639435,
-0.5886341333389282,
0.23548495769500732,
-0.48810139298439026,
1.3690272569656372,
0.6460381746292114,
-0.23879505693912506,
0.15987160801887512,
-0.5151740312576294,
1.1182940006256104,
0.3840288817882538,
-0.8089809417724609,
0.4559417963027954,
0.5129935145378113,
-0.23494185507297516,
0.4306778013706207,
0.7450869083404541,
-0.127310112118721,
0.32149046659469604,
0.25010064244270325,
0.07422974705696106,
-0.03638756647706032,
-0.652859091758728,
-0.6077852845191956,
0.298753947019577,
0.1116679236292839,
-0.23512102663516998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08017v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08017v2 | Lumos : Empowering Multimodal LLMs with Scene Text Recognition | 2024-02-12T19:27:26 | 2024-06-01T21:46:50 | Ashish Shenoy, Yichao Lu, Srihari Jayakumar, Debojeet Chatterjee, Mohsen Moslehpour, Pierce Chuang, Abhay Harpale, Vikas Bhardwaj, Di Xu, Shicong Zhao, Longfang Zhao, Ankit Ramchandani, Xin Luna Dong, Anuj Kumar | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce Lumos, the first end-to-end multimodal question-answering system
with text understanding capabilities. At the core of Lumos is a Scene Text
Recognition (STR) component that extracts text from first person point-of-view
images, the output of which is used to augment input to a Multimodal Large
Language Model (MM-LLM). While building Lumos, we encountered numerous
challenges related to STR quality, overall latency, and model inference. In
this paper, we delve into those challenges, and discuss the system
architecture, design choices, and modeling techniques employed to overcome
these obstacles. We also provide a comprehensive evaluation for each component,
showcasing high quality and efficiency. | [
-0.19787326455116272,
-0.8844953775405884,
1.1004725694656372,
0.17375239729881287,
-0.27081966400146484,
0.23408463597297668,
0.09166637063026428,
-0.6736768484115601,
-0.011718778870999813,
0.4690023362636566,
-0.705554187297821,
-0.216918483376503,
-0.696172297000885,
0.2501899302005768,
-0.3928707242012024,
0.8383135795593262,
-0.1203044131398201,
-0.06378336250782013,
-0.5350080728530884,
-0.04639063775539398,
-0.24934488534927368,
-0.3119061291217804,
-0.4523603618144989,
0.08828161656856537,
0.7680714130401611,
0.35827305912971497,
0.5245895385742188,
0.0350288525223732,
0.5473009347915649,
0.38594239950180054,
-0.1748916506767273,
0.5217545628547668,
-0.32132411003112793,
0.38119322061538696,
0.04457707330584526,
-0.16812308132648468,
-0.4370095133781433,
-0.30092713236808777,
0.5491943359375,
0.43391427397727966,
0.15996886789798737,
0.04085003212094307,
-0.040928181260824203,
0.3107500970363617,
-0.516261100769043,
-0.333393394947052,
-0.4568575620651245,
0.17248331010341644,
-0.0215486790984869,
-0.2002314031124115,
-0.44489598274230957,
-0.20282770693302155,
0.34127190709114075,
-0.7182510495185852,
-0.14842651784420013,
-0.002701064106076956,
0.9235524535179138,
0.17844542860984802,
-0.6002264022827148,
-0.4885868430137634,
-0.8912712931632996,
0.8866565823554993,
-0.3891085386276245,
0.38019490242004395,
0.262187123298645,
0.4393763244152069,
0.09759596735239029,
-0.7172719836235046,
-0.5896485447883606,
0.15589208900928497,
-0.025395121425390244,
0.17520567774772644,
-0.05943979322910309,
-0.026003170758485794,
0.014344741590321064,
0.4873844385147095,
-0.47376343607902527,
-0.2065875083208084,
-0.4317910969257355,
-0.3286166489124298,
0.2656451463699341,
0.2517659366130829,
0.2645876109600067,
-0.20914967358112335,
-0.7572841048240662,
0.21402665972709656,
-0.5171497464179993,
0.4398725926876068,
-0.03378937020897865,
-0.11384574323892593,
0.11204610764980316,
0.523209273815155,
0.14189738035202026,
0.8747036457061768,
-0.511883020401001,
-0.41966649889945984,
0.1698930710554123,
-0.6096562743186951,
-0.279712975025177,
-0.34623730182647705,
0.8351158499717712,
0.2171904742717743,
-0.21237991750240326,
-0.020101923495531082,
-0.5346519351005554,
-0.2030571848154068,
0.09844623506069183,
-0.7026160955429077,
0.4591154456138611,
0.2323414385318756,
-0.3638659417629242,
-0.22509250044822693,
-0.060303717851638794,
-1.0335172414779663,
-0.47161805629730225,
-0.010584632866084576,
0.7520917057991028,
-0.3050623834133148,
-0.0630994662642479,
0.03278118371963501,
-0.013136419467628002,
0.3310450315475464,
0.8654398322105408,
-0.7062559723854065,
0.10969647765159607,
0.2203735113143921,
0.8410318493843079,
0.08395352959632874,
-0.05601910874247551,
-0.580480694770813,
0.043388623744249344,
-0.258647620677948,
0.7843981385231018,
-0.5904701948165894,
-0.5538946986198425,
-0.158360093832016,
0.015857873484492302,
0.09089046716690063,
-0.09135644137859344,
0.519480288028717,
-0.5890068411827087,
0.3938770890235901,
-0.3647295832633972,
-0.3527117669582367,
0.09332253783941269,
0.3657725751399994,
-0.4855625629425049,
0.9860697388648987,
0.04831688106060028,
-0.6628417372703552,
-0.017457591369748116,
-0.39215654134750366,
-0.3750697374343872,
0.040743786841630936,
-0.2604067921638489,
-0.11999747157096863,
0.28626441955566406,
0.37959957122802734,
0.3981739282608032,
-0.34126928448677063,
0.14679491519927979,
0.056992579251527786,
-0.2348080724477768,
0.6189030408859253,
-0.5503279566764832,
0.2463376820087433,
0.610750138759613,
0.32660263776779175,
0.23950597643852234,
-0.817914605140686,
-0.11311477422714233,
0.07847137004137039,
-0.4579421579837799,
-0.3915087580680847,
0.3207809627056122,
0.04494471848011017,
0.33436042070388794,
0.691521942615509,
-0.7937745451927185,
0.0069148908369243145,
-0.12036112695932388,
0.652776300907135,
0.7994973659515381,
-0.28891509771347046,
0.5581486225128174,
-0.18140092492103577,
0.4870254397392273,
0.13503839075565338,
0.26245376467704773,
-1.0466145277023315,
-0.6731622219085693,
-0.7283144593238831,
-0.3095202147960663,
-0.07649297267198563,
0.7587970495223999,
-1.102730631828308,
-0.008041620254516602,
-0.20795203745365143,
-0.39109307527542114,
-0.5394425392150879,
0.2009715735912323,
0.40766051411628723,
0.59850013256073,
0.19220082461833954,
0.2655073404312134,
-0.3189099431037903,
-0.8352143168449402,
0.19159771502017975,
-0.009985826909542084,
-0.15821786224842072,
0.5753096342086792,
0.5361714959144592,
-0.30124372243881226,
1.077073574066162,
-0.5655571222305298,
-0.1521572321653366,
-0.39265698194503784,
0.002656700788065791,
0.15707240998744965,
0.21066997945308685,
0.37592560052871704,
-0.8909582495689392,
-0.22943249344825745,
0.2764189541339874,
-0.9768898487091064,
-0.10807071626186371,
-0.028488056734204292,
0.20331650972366333,
-0.06383752077817917,
0.595586895942688,
-0.5158578157424927,
0.3531182110309601,
0.5304933190345764,
-0.35060447454452515,
0.39463910460472107,
-0.5877265930175781,
0.40772920846939087,
-1.291090488433838,
-0.1223086342215538,
-0.03781168907880783,
-0.4088432490825653,
-0.8277841806411743,
0.044941626489162445,
0.15918231010437012,
-0.3454250395298004,
-0.5345974564552307,
0.6039695739746094,
-0.39804109930992126,
-0.4629072844982147,
-0.10244163870811462,
0.40511906147003174,
0.580364465713501,
0.41544440388679504,
-0.04166068509221077,
1.0471659898757935,
0.32750359177589417,
-0.6940210461616516,
0.46802839636802673,
0.13485190272331238,
-0.5341023206710815,
0.6064009666442871,
-0.8371005654335022,
0.25191476941108704,
-0.24335767328739166,
-0.11082396656274796,
-1.3232215642929077,
-0.3037130534648895,
-0.008373823948204517,
-0.35567381978034973,
-0.1103861853480339,
0.20904859900474548,
-0.39196065068244934,
-0.25370272994041443,
-0.2677561044692993,
0.42858535051345825,
0.3310088813304901,
-0.5104079246520996,
0.7672985792160034,
0.3776405453681946,
-0.5432656407356262,
-0.6075592041015625,
-0.6131813526153564,
0.19149671494960785,
0.08017782121896744,
-0.7165150046348572,
0.33376404643058777,
-0.23980635404586792,
-0.2211897373199463,
-0.3076379597187042,
0.12378953397274017,
-0.40856263041496277,
-0.08851197361946106,
0.123494952917099,
0.24900215864181519,
-0.16616889834403992,
0.2831261456012726,
0.30184417963027954,
-0.0635964572429657,
-0.2800696790218353,
0.07116465270519257,
0.3660057783126831,
-0.3145584166049957,
-0.40776950120925903,
-0.4107895791530609,
0.4504798352718353,
0.8991715312004089,
-0.23982226848602295,
0.299837589263916,
0.3271612226963043,
-0.4016754627227783,
0.049316223710775375,
-0.4647755026817322,
0.1300201117992401,
-0.5075398683547974,
0.4784007966518402,
-0.6169328093528748,
-1.007092833518982,
0.5760488510131836,
-0.04701489582657814,
0.19425690174102783,
-0.08136113733053207,
0.24104110896587372,
-0.47764888405799866,
0.7181942462921143,
0.7247784733772278,
0.2127283215522766,
0.5322661995887756,
0.3451787233352661,
0.14759905636310577,
-0.7582287192344666,
-0.49171391129493713,
-0.43363985419273376,
-0.3589423596858978,
0.060839079320430756,
-0.8106123805046082,
0.4157196581363678,
-0.15803486108779907,
0.15202854573726654,
0.2659197747707367,
-0.24889615178108215,
0.4889577031135559,
0.30482354760169983,
0.40080976486206055,
0.5895329713821411,
0.045824069529771805,
-0.15241217613220215,
-0.44787776470184326,
-0.4198578894138336,
-0.7597936987876892,
0.6074156761169434,
0.5050786733627319,
1.08464777469635,
0.16000084578990936,
0.3129121959209442,
0.19586381316184998,
-0.01894453354179859,
-0.5847344994544983,
0.9296990036964417,
-0.25480929017066956,
-0.42737528681755066,
-0.21634703874588013,
-0.30917680263519287,
-0.7343445420265198,
0.42909136414527893,
-0.1721852719783783,
-0.5653561949729919,
0.2676643133163452,
-0.13562722504138947,
-0.5492765307426453,
0.29830071330070496,
-0.6491905450820923,
0.6475858688354492,
-0.5577987432479858,
-0.5149890780448914,
-0.005316680297255516,
-0.6980694532394409,
0.24354352056980133,
0.0512443371117115,
0.6360164284706116,
-0.05565250664949417,
-0.38199469447135925,
0.46142899990081787,
-0.24342916905879974,
0.6724369525909424,
-0.03911728784441948,
-0.5151174068450928,
0.4282008111476898,
0.11970243602991104,
0.07817629724740982,
0.10064248740673065,
0.01484413631260395,
-0.021451497450470924,
0.02600819058716297,
-0.2502521574497223,
-0.5574370622634888,
0.549602746963501,
-0.7012016177177429,
-0.16716709733009338,
-0.32041701674461365,
-0.7171902060508728,
-0.04527849704027176,
0.1662265807390213,
0.13999007642269135,
0.8676726222038269,
-0.3933505713939667,
0.107278972864151,
1.0880426168441772,
-0.7505086064338684,
0.8045675754547119,
0.39963433146476746,
-0.8735260963439941,
-0.7238598465919495,
1.0124155282974243,
-0.26778745651245117,
0.45271316170692444,
0.7426543831825256,
-0.02939634956419468,
-0.18771275877952576,
-0.29826152324676514,
-0.7792500853538513,
-0.08552750200033188,
-0.8669040203094482,
-0.06785530596971512,
-0.6674870252609253,
-0.34705308079719543,
-0.08741958439350128,
-0.3167034387588501,
-0.34414437413215637,
-0.2653380334377289,
-0.4921564757823944,
-0.10320162773132324,
0.19192588329315186,
0.957567572593689,
0.389909952878952,
0.5202836990356445,
-1.0649420022964478,
0.612467885017395,
0.667491614818573,
0.11143968999385834,
-0.49260613322257996,
-0.6534912586212158,
-0.061538346111774445,
0.026743488386273384,
-0.10852809250354767,
-0.9688928723335266,
0.34634631872177124,
0.36699044704437256,
0.3651612102985382,
0.6852030158042908,
-0.30178284645080566,
0.5777565240859985,
-0.5277347564697266,
0.8873507380485535,
0.2678086757659912,
-1.005151391029358,
0.8575618267059326,
-0.3033173680305481,
0.4137239456176758,
0.41655904054641724,
0.07211484014987946,
-0.5500741004943848,
-0.10014677792787552,
0.037276577204465866,
-0.6280425190925598,
0.617751955986023,
0.25052115321159363,
0.3020390272140503,
0.2232622504234314,
0.433738648891449,
0.30814483761787415,
0.478986531496048,
-1.0256019830703735,
0.12594108283519745,
-0.12988649308681488,
-0.41196900606155396,
-0.07386533170938492,
-0.46602514386177063,
0.06665448844432831,
-0.08066411316394806,
0.16439208388328552,
-0.038511767983436584,
0.34465426206588745,
0.6094082593917847,
-0.7445938587188721,
0.04004940018057823,
0.6032001376152039,
0.995697021484375,
0.6190727353096008,
-0.04144726321101189,
0.35621410608291626,
0.16306400299072266,
-0.42650169134140015,
0.2714812755584717,
-0.1876266598701477,
-0.30788707733154297,
0.20706787705421448,
0.35156264901161194,
0.889919638633728,
0.5629581212997437,
-0.9711164236068726,
0.6028148531913757,
-0.20068347454071045,
-0.12324617803096771,
-0.050822142511606216,
-0.15177561342716217,
-0.03595713898539543,
0.251641184091568,
0.7439180016517639,
0.06529324501752853,
-0.1655571311712265,
-0.38916677236557007,
0.03014391101896763,
0.5493435263633728,
-0.6003764867782593,
-0.4689737856388092,
0.6075782775878906,
0.4885530471801758,
-0.3373066186904907,
0.21995007991790771,
-0.13433177769184113,
-0.4909907579421997,
0.5619610548019409,
0.3525194227695465,
0.5418169498443604,
-0.4720097780227661,
0.3431732654571533,
0.2574668824672699,
0.7971562147140503,
0.3287051022052765,
0.4556037187576294,
-0.33229660987854004,
-0.8095663785934448,
-0.30275166034698486,
-0.7544894814491272,
-0.6808082461357117,
-0.08532223105430603,
-0.2955288887023926,
0.17360353469848633,
-0.6519049406051636,
-0.015352088026702404,
-0.2780672013759613,
-0.4401068687438965,
-0.14812181890010834,
0.21285691857337952,
0.4094482660293579,
0.711965799331665,
-0.6395077109336853,
0.7295134663581848,
0.8968648314476013,
-0.2515416145324707,
0.10996479541063309,
-0.4492102265357971,
-0.17681832611560822,
-0.801002562046051,
0.7340030074119568,
0.36952105164527893,
-0.42328134179115295,
-0.04657992348074913,
-0.5278707146644592,
-0.6113592386245728,
1.212986707687378,
0.20602190494537354,
-0.6620208024978638,
-0.10274766385555267,
0.4035968780517578,
0.41389063000679016,
-0.45622187852859497,
0.4097333550453186,
0.093117855489254,
0.2586415112018585,
0.16065774857997894,
-0.756096601486206,
-0.20855824649333954,
-0.3291383385658264,
-0.006145646795630455,
0.11016055941581726,
-0.4096829891204834,
1.0090086460113525,
-0.5064221620559692,
-0.19911329448223114,
0.3090415894985199,
0.754869818687439,
0.26262766122817993,
0.6001876592636108,
0.6322934031486511,
0.42743608355522156,
0.6429569125175476,
-0.3359033465385437,
0.7585945129394531,
-0.06527234613895416,
0.1470208764076233,
0.8784878849983215,
-0.47878625988960266,
0.923527181148529,
0.7302004098892212,
-0.3053452968597412,
0.47562655806541443,
0.7176457047462463,
0.37856853008270264,
0.5912616848945618,
-0.33202433586120605,
-0.6191010475158691,
-0.3463006615638733,
0.07105021178722382,
-0.3588624894618988,
0.08925244212150574,
0.6563369631767273,
-0.2570353150367737,
-0.2846701443195343,
0.3317296504974365,
-0.35049009323120117,
0.06620705127716064,
-0.295274943113327,
0.7853521108627319,
0.13698230683803558,
-0.4564991593360901,
-0.24422717094421387,
-0.07427889853715897,
0.7737472057342529,
-1.0309876203536987,
0.17221055924892426,
-0.2128532975912094,
0.16693061590194702,
-0.07143799960613251,
-0.8968963623046875,
0.21082428097724915,
0.037212274968624115,
-0.2923547625541687,
-0.7065203785896301,
1.1405810117721558,
-0.5171458125114441,
-0.6407141089439392,
0.30038467049598694,
0.6443101167678833,
0.0954875573515892,
0.06424892693758011,
-0.5048426389694214,
0.2508048117160797,
-0.15989400446414948,
-0.2281271368265152,
0.2948282063007355,
0.6380252838134766,
0.3144056499004364,
0.8413012623786926,
0.6134514212608337,
-0.3211488723754883,
0.14327597618103027,
-0.06842542439699173,
0.7394458651542664,
-0.7019157409667969,
-0.504213273525238,
-0.8934156894683838,
0.6619194149971008,
-0.005599227733910084,
-0.33764347434043884,
0.6620835065841675,
0.3876139223575592,
0.1876412183046341,
-0.024157466366887093,
0.615757405757904,
-0.052977461367845535,
0.43411746621131897,
-0.504342257976532,
0.5100443363189697,
-0.9328301548957825,
0.37409940361976624,
-0.5637102127075195,
-0.683564305305481,
-0.08333862572908401,
0.7967959642410278,
-0.009112766943871975,
-0.14799746870994568,
0.7529236078262329,
0.6298345327377319,
0.026964684948325157,
0.0961700901389122,
0.6264991760253906,
0.07066056877374649,
0.2723798453807831,
0.8235060572624207,
1.2821532487869263,
-0.7640162706375122,
0.8481683731079102,
-0.06193656101822853,
-0.17860780656337738,
-0.03805450350046158,
-0.8024618029594421,
-0.6503573060035706,
-0.7092573642730713,
-0.03607797250151634,
-0.05453754961490631,
-0.20546993613243103,
0.5077175498008728,
0.49364593625068665,
-0.47817009687423706,
-0.18412227928638458,
0.08423127233982086,
0.45206812024116516,
0.25021249055862427,
-0.14232699573040009,
-0.1893608421087265,
-0.2994023263454437,
-0.8019556403160095,
0.609113335609436,
0.7755473852157593,
0.10158517956733704,
-0.29874011874198914,
-0.07067558914422989,
-0.3251243233680725,
0.06042991206049919,
1.0860837697982788,
0.0025161069352179766,
-0.6816364526748657,
-0.08701560646295547,
0.5663915276527405,
-0.37850192189216614,
0.13938692212104797,
0.8704233765602112,
-0.6822075247764587,
0.593616247177124,
0.6015506386756897,
0.8223433494567871,
0.24015824496746063,
-0.20058117806911469,
0.49021831154823303,
-0.7821123600006104,
0.20402891933918,
-0.04482021927833557,
0.584806501865387,
0.36584433913230896,
-0.1698877513408661,
0.19926641881465912,
0.2221127599477768,
-0.5697367787361145,
-0.7942408323287964,
0.3925837576389313,
-1.0618737936019897,
-0.3919143080711365,
0.8714166283607483,
-0.22161878645420074,
-0.29274991154670715,
-0.27719825506210327,
-0.5712116360664368,
-0.2838822901248932,
-0.16929568350315094,
0.2055153101682663,
0.8946251273155212,
0.07071439921855927,
-0.6037360429763794,
-0.8799694180488586,
-0.04541444033384323,
0.3638654947280884,
-1.1978824138641357,
-0.14858004450798035,
0.6632482409477234,
0.13932394981384277,
0.3384115695953369,
0.9392765760421753,
-0.08872020989656448,
0.1313498616218567,
-0.3543596565723419,
0.022556724026799202,
0.09271882474422455,
-0.5157217979431152,
-0.3753242790699005,
0.2805427014827728,
-0.29979854822158813,
-0.16306573152542114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08015v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08015v5 | Walia-LLM: Enhancing Amharic-LLaMA by Integrating Task-Specific and Generative Datasets | 2024-02-12T19:25:11 | 2024-04-29T07:14:51 | Israel Abebe Azime, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Tadesse Destaw Belay, Mitiku Yohannes Fuge, Aman Kassahun Wassie, Eyasu Shiferaw Jada, Yonas Chanie, Walelign Tewabe Sewunetie, Seid Muhie Yimam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have received a lot of attention in natural
language processing (NLP) research because of their exceptional performance in
understanding and generating human languages. However, low-resource languages
are left behind due to the unavailability of resources. In this work, we focus
on enhancing the LLaMA-2-Amharic model by integrating task-specific and
generative datasets to improve language model performance for Amharic. We
compile an Amharic instruction fine-tuning dataset and fine-tuned
LLaMA-2-Amharic model. The fine-tuned model shows promising results in
different NLP tasks. We open-source our dataset creation pipeline, instruction
datasets, trained models, and evaluation outputs to promote language-specific
studies on these models. | [
-0.1665589064359665,
-0.8556174039840698,
0.3186165690422058,
0.2820735573768616,
-0.289106160402298,
0.2102496325969696,
-0.5240055322647095,
-0.7645123600959778,
0.44708698987960815,
0.6318097114562988,
-0.339706152677536,
-0.6409605145454407,
-0.6425221562385559,
0.054090093821287155,
-0.3400014638900757,
1.079667329788208,
-0.28248104453086853,
-0.10405919700860977,
-0.2025475651025772,
-0.14236468076705933,
-0.4760498106479645,
-0.5113942623138428,
-0.5665890574455261,
-0.1798437237739563,
0.4417515695095062,
0.6673910617828369,
0.8199155926704407,
0.8972855806350708,
0.22828905284404755,
0.19679440557956696,
-0.14776389300823212,
0.4679645597934723,
-0.6126489043235779,
0.0633949488401413,
-0.1341414600610733,
-0.5125718712806702,
-0.8052354454994202,
-0.19443731009960175,
0.6095715165138245,
0.7382157444953918,
-0.4925394654273987,
0.36497122049331665,
0.230513334274292,
0.38987088203430176,
-0.7793881297111511,
0.3185954988002777,
-0.5586097836494446,
-0.14939118921756744,
-0.44457900524139404,
-0.06929735094308853,
-0.14679962396621704,
-0.2192487269639969,
-0.13925647735595703,
-0.6528719067573547,
0.17308679223060608,
0.13381227850914001,
0.5246925950050354,
0.4628053903579712,
-0.19437795877456665,
-0.492519348859787,
-0.8500893712043762,
0.988793671131134,
-0.9104053378105164,
0.12863793969154358,
0.440323144197464,
-0.016980687156319618,
-0.11030648648738861,
-0.43036702275276184,
-0.4935564696788788,
-0.11142602562904358,
0.043663445860147476,
-0.220439150929451,
-0.33317509293556213,
0.06256994605064392,
0.23769810795783997,
0.5679728388786316,
-0.38696053624153137,
0.5187712907791138,
-0.26697131991386414,
-0.03611234948039055,
0.6186606884002686,
0.36669760942459106,
0.16344892978668213,
-0.27178454399108887,
-0.23545216023921967,
0.08639045804738998,
-0.8651869893074036,
-0.08971794694662094,
0.4530232548713684,
0.5023370385169983,
-0.3634741008281708,
0.7393658757209778,
-0.4071749150753021,
0.7753313183784485,
-0.405972421169281,
-0.18461820483207703,
0.266262412071228,
-0.3850764334201813,
-0.17576730251312256,
-0.011818300001323223,
0.6478506922721863,
0.14855319261550903,
0.28325673937797546,
-0.24799734354019165,
-0.3594738245010376,
0.01887645572423935,
0.24694640934467316,
-0.8343535661697388,
-0.12699487805366516,
0.08172549307346344,
-0.41319647431373596,
-0.4901138246059418,
-0.3634769320487976,
-0.8570563197135925,
-0.2669559419155121,
-0.4983193874359131,
0.1384795755147934,
-0.11249785870313644,
-0.0702332854270935,
0.0670924037694931,
0.5120581388473511,
0.0997362807393074,
0.2728482782840729,
-1.4056118726730347,
0.5086042284965515,
0.6619848608970642,
0.8417490124702454,
-0.4275907278060913,
-0.3986148536205292,
-0.8010982275009155,
0.34053435921669006,
-0.34456121921539307,
0.7501676082611084,
-0.789990246295929,
-0.43113014101982117,
0.11109428852796555,
0.0189104825258255,
0.032416462898254395,
-0.8220785856246948,
0.7774463295936584,
-0.5676573514938354,
-0.06701616197824478,
-0.3457179367542267,
-0.45993301272392273,
-0.42509645223617554,
0.11492277681827545,
-0.7691201567649841,
1.093901515007019,
0.31554266810417175,
-0.6211561560630798,
-0.024402407929301262,
-0.8670699000358582,
-0.6451882123947144,
0.07906682044267654,
-0.13973228633403778,
-0.19280502200126648,
0.21589243412017822,
0.5261463522911072,
0.3572857081890106,
-0.8302537798881531,
0.3348385989665985,
-0.18685127794742584,
-0.4616972804069519,
0.06829161196947098,
-0.34592828154563904,
0.7029327750205994,
0.1054198145866394,
-0.10894452035427094,
0.2259361445903778,
-0.6842683553695679,
-0.05573168769478798,
0.027738895267248154,
-0.727185070514679,
-0.12053500860929489,
-0.006150876171886921,
0.2205267697572708,
-0.09849152714014053,
0.6467602252960205,
-0.4759014844894409,
0.435502827167511,
-0.24216970801353455,
0.24482807517051697,
0.5093891620635986,
-0.17461441457271576,
0.36424723267555237,
-0.26168784499168396,
0.6597273945808411,
-0.0022558909840881824,
0.06472074240446091,
0.10178136825561523,
-0.5412209033966064,
-1.043674111366272,
-0.2516138255596161,
0.5178603529930115,
0.9003906846046448,
-0.6538141369819641,
0.33831363916397095,
-0.2581501007080078,
-0.3454190492630005,
-0.7829120755195618,
0.6030059456825256,
0.33751457929611206,
0.49962854385375977,
0.5973688960075378,
-0.3846268951892853,
-0.750543475151062,
-1.0129848718643188,
0.16146881878376007,
-0.016391607001423836,
-0.2453620433807373,
0.3783656060695648,
0.35080280900001526,
-0.6443619132041931,
0.6324466466903687,
-0.600603461265564,
-0.23382709920406342,
-0.32121795415878296,
0.08503279089927673,
0.42582666873931885,
0.42284104228019714,
0.4542655348777771,
-0.3683294653892517,
-0.2981470823287964,
-0.0012590223923325539,
-0.935242235660553,
-0.44521722197532654,
0.2431163638830185,
-0.22327207028865814,
0.12026117742061615,
0.35074418783187866,
-0.5398629903793335,
0.4546303451061249,
0.6824220418930054,
-0.1073601022362709,
0.6482320427894592,
-0.2945103645324707,
0.15378306806087494,
-1.127426266670227,
0.030126960948109627,
-0.3223559260368347,
-0.17693005502223969,
-0.6597155928611755,
0.02947358973324299,
-0.08744598180055618,
-0.1085149422287941,
-0.20712848007678986,
0.37057918310165405,
-0.3340742886066437,
-0.38221657276153564,
-0.6243005990982056,
0.028747351840138435,
-0.12144182622432709,
0.5710270404815674,
-0.015595673583447933,
1.0175342559814453,
0.813023567199707,
-0.7503265142440796,
0.4821632206439972,
0.4141259789466858,
-0.5013610124588013,
0.05225982144474983,
-0.7700855135917664,
0.13129010796546936,
0.1820366382598877,
-0.08565112948417664,
-0.47158288955688477,
-0.4316672682762146,
0.3585488200187683,
0.12659068405628204,
0.24711135029792786,
-0.020123621448874474,
-0.7076064348220825,
-0.04585747420787811,
-0.21901732683181763,
0.4842192232608795,
0.43177396059036255,
-0.8287585377693176,
0.5215739607810974,
0.47041305899620056,
-0.4114117920398712,
-0.6151309609413147,
-0.5837977528572083,
0.22084864974021912,
-0.10555051267147064,
-0.420137494802475,
0.6690641045570374,
0.07893168181180954,
-0.1707780659198761,
-0.009081846103072166,
0.40596041083335876,
0.2869229316711426,
0.023674694821238518,
0.25169968605041504,
0.3356625735759735,
-0.3577761948108673,
0.1985938847064972,
0.253326952457428,
-0.09316979348659515,
-0.11645295470952988,
-0.014833477325737476,
0.6571165323257446,
-0.06459905952215195,
-0.2841993272304535,
-0.3023620843887329,
0.49079394340515137,
0.3125975728034973,
-0.40368348360061646,
0.9317298531532288,
0.5110604763031006,
-0.44607844948768616,
-0.19212926924228668,
-0.45076438784599304,
0.01882380060851574,
-0.4220651388168335,
0.3610396087169647,
-0.2187630981206894,
-0.9744219779968262,
0.4255985915660858,
-0.19769509136676788,
0.07119908928871155,
0.12677550315856934,
0.7812883257865906,
-0.061312805861234665,
0.7292126417160034,
0.8388352394104004,
-0.4427373707294464,
0.46139878034591675,
-0.26743316650390625,
0.1579805463552475,
-1.2128902673721313,
-0.11831928789615631,
-0.20301201939582825,
-0.45546913146972656,
-0.6804521679878235,
-0.774797260761261,
0.15433643758296967,
0.29485130310058594,
0.03564155846834183,
0.35835960507392883,
-0.1480351984500885,
0.41432294249534607,
0.5285018086433411,
0.14873184263706207,
0.34259408712387085,
0.18738533556461334,
0.12056056410074234,
0.17659178376197815,
-0.714954137802124,
-0.9181895852088928,
1.2633731365203857,
0.2592985928058624,
0.8461025953292847,
0.33210742473602295,
0.5307750701904297,
0.4565260410308838,
0.3894355297088623,
-0.7568137049674988,
0.5563844442367554,
-0.45489993691444397,
-0.29755041003227234,
-0.20510844886302948,
-0.28621941804885864,
-0.943658709526062,
0.1848732978105545,
-0.2260458618402481,
-0.8614961504936218,
0.19291436672210693,
0.2627188265323639,
-0.3242352604866028,
0.2609485983848572,
-0.5737953186035156,
0.8227872848510742,
-0.3141336143016815,
-0.4066762328147888,
-0.4964974820613861,
-0.20818787813186646,
0.5221431255340576,
-0.15444184839725494,
0.1365678757429123,
-0.28510215878486633,
-0.35972100496292114,
0.8241179585456848,
-0.516810417175293,
0.9236606955528259,
-0.05170562490820885,
-0.4424738585948944,
0.47908857464790344,
-0.09318307042121887,
0.6813784837722778,
0.07509301602840424,
-0.36499887704849243,
0.11684828996658325,
-0.3784468173980713,
-0.5741375684738159,
-0.4755571484565735,
0.8072195053100586,
-0.7123070359230042,
-0.6225364804267883,
0.10846929997205734,
-0.8098288178443909,
-0.2195223718881607,
-0.24168136715888977,
0.04918342083692551,
0.36631467938423157,
-0.24947558343410492,
0.014938456006348133,
0.39555367827415466,
-0.15855805575847626,
0.36793333292007446,
0.4739702343940735,
-0.34578800201416016,
-0.2580903172492981,
0.9258776903152466,
-0.150429368019104,
0.05846467614173889,
0.33677276968955994,
0.00555158918723464,
-0.13552379608154297,
-0.7646750211715698,
-0.6167254447937012,
0.24025145173072815,
-0.6547027230262756,
-0.4569912254810333,
-0.38043999671936035,
-0.053691647946834564,
-0.1796189397573471,
0.12736642360687256,
-0.2688005566596985,
-0.3467812240123749,
-0.6583155393600464,
-0.02660958468914032,
0.5864955186843872,
0.9793758988380432,
-0.07988665252923965,
0.6537519097328186,
-0.7650672793388367,
0.3931482136249542,
0.35658755898475647,
0.2714933156967163,
0.2504430413246155,
-0.6840534210205078,
-0.49867552518844604,
0.10194531083106995,
-0.1609925925731659,
-0.8031243681907654,
0.40518948435783386,
0.25822219252586365,
0.32841700315475464,
0.3332003951072693,
-0.28716981410980225,
0.6617423892021179,
-0.44711774587631226,
0.4643460512161255,
-0.1151108667254448,
-0.9875572323799133,
0.6344153881072998,
-0.27681583166122437,
0.2969185709953308,
0.46723058819770813,
0.33844640851020813,
-0.26123276352882385,
-0.07218857109546661,
-0.24390123784542084,
-0.6475474834442139,
0.7295156717300415,
0.3390546441078186,
0.11291611939668655,
0.16429051756858826,
0.49450671672821045,
0.16606631875038147,
0.2763325870037079,
-0.6187863349914551,
-0.03436494618654251,
0.051014792174100876,
-0.2620539665222168,
-0.24196180701255798,
-0.4647342264652252,
0.02590782195329666,
-0.1852264255285263,
0.7137908935546875,
-0.05726589262485504,
0.008165392093360424,
-0.3878611922264099,
-0.2953803837299347,
-0.2694161534309387,
0.30629962682724,
0.29650259017944336,
0.5088075995445251,
-0.10085516422986984,
0.13645164668560028,
0.6138634085655212,
-0.575981080532074,
0.05833044648170471,
0.2282976508140564,
-0.30259713530540466,
-0.21353426575660706,
0.5387340784072876,
1.0128647089004517,
0.35639941692352295,
-0.8775076270103455,
0.13872113823890686,
0.10218370705842972,
0.29215240478515625,
-0.026136772707104683,
0.37489789724349976,
0.24801203608512878,
0.36634039878845215,
0.12983033061027527,
-0.09422685950994492,
0.2650505602359772,
-0.5451356172561646,
-0.02417539618909359,
0.3130994141101837,
0.0015593947609886527,
-0.41536596417427063,
0.505957305431366,
0.3083842098712921,
-0.3918861150741577,
0.7368317246437073,
-0.4206748306751251,
-0.48704150319099426,
0.48101550340652466,
0.7583222985267639,
0.5332776308059692,
-0.3547595739364624,
0.09087390452623367,
0.4676333963871002,
0.28730592131614685,
0.1853131353855133,
0.43057364225387573,
-0.17661872506141663,
-0.6630499958992004,
-0.5606776475906372,
-0.9300830960273743,
-0.5067534446716309,
0.3274901211261749,
-0.6765181422233582,
0.3151509165763855,
-0.21873290836811066,
-0.025741135701537132,
-0.3131876289844513,
0.12008558213710785,
-0.6090621948242188,
0.1373346745967865,
0.21544627845287323,
0.5577256679534912,
-0.9002480506896973,
1.0060421228408813,
0.43541738390922546,
-0.11858447641134262,
-0.6514807343482971,
0.033070772886276245,
-0.38169920444488525,
-0.8257393836975098,
0.5050374269485474,
0.15282149612903595,
-0.2777256369590759,
0.003243624232709408,
-0.5218541622161865,
-1.0602734088897705,
1.1446888446807861,
0.6471590399742126,
-0.8801292777061462,
-0.042325373739004135,
0.32399699091911316,
0.5804619789123535,
-0.6808912754058838,
-0.10728612542152405,
0.7812598943710327,
0.1702200174331665,
-0.006320435553789139,
-0.7404497265815735,
0.08478809148073196,
-0.1674935668706894,
0.14248992502689362,
0.2366810292005539,
-0.4097053110599518,
0.7515043020248413,
-0.5491779446601868,
-0.1896636188030243,
0.31625211238861084,
0.9695143103599548,
0.31674864888191223,
-0.10613182187080383,
0.5794716477394104,
0.6551868319511414,
0.9950695633888245,
0.26725584268569946,
1.0191415548324585,
-0.24927985668182373,
0.08414403349161148,
1.3892390727996826,
-0.28428924083709717,
1.1941931247711182,
0.3763740360736847,
-0.2656634747982025,
0.6741185784339905,
0.6732170581817627,
-0.052063409239053726,
0.391374409198761,
0.33915451169013977,
-0.6670761704444885,
-0.22484564781188965,
-0.5519561171531677,
-0.21220262348651886,
0.7740405797958374,
0.6702994108200073,
-0.24310925602912903,
-0.06434126943349838,
-0.07111067324876785,
-0.04081971198320389,
-0.09956198185682297,
-0.21097612380981445,
0.633974015712738,
-0.00805809535086155,
-0.6278585195541382,
0.7510420680046082,
0.2886029779911041,
0.7852898836135864,
-0.3894813060760498,
-0.06726918369531631,
-0.22617223858833313,
-0.09830073267221451,
-0.36446699500083923,
-0.5465003252029419,
0.31455156207084656,
0.5274301767349243,
-0.3045807182788849,
0.09839360415935516,
0.6710168123245239,
-0.6448678374290466,
-0.5874955058097839,
0.5017684102058411,
0.6086010932922363,
0.4035332202911377,
0.1727784425020218,
-0.5436020493507385,
0.2770216763019562,
0.13359248638153076,
-0.13129636645317078,
0.23523560166358948,
0.08168713748455048,
-0.06894202530384064,
0.512183666229248,
0.6071797609329224,
0.19507881999015808,
-0.02284196764230728,
0.41147810220718384,
0.9316774010658264,
-0.49946558475494385,
-0.10205547511577606,
-0.849840521812439,
0.04587223380804062,
0.11516030132770538,
-0.2817750871181488,
0.5017592310905457,
0.7290056347846985,
0.6057920455932617,
-0.2624317705631256,
0.650996744632721,
-0.12930630147457123,
0.5695290565490723,
-0.7276194095611572,
0.4226974844932556,
-0.42095863819122314,
0.4452892541885376,
0.15030334889888763,
-1.0587821006774902,
0.03558308258652687,
0.45299986004829407,
-0.31084030866622925,
0.001558523392304778,
0.3056843876838684,
1.039519190788269,
-0.22644084692001343,
0.03085293248295784,
0.14979355037212372,
0.07236562669277191,
0.13884353637695312,
0.6987137198448181,
0.8997730016708374,
-0.36523598432540894,
0.4118347465991974,
-0.3803086578845978,
-0.24665561318397522,
-0.275544673204422,
-0.8827812671661377,
-0.9049865007400513,
-0.4627296030521393,
-0.29010269045829773,
0.21534527838230133,
-0.07358218729496002,
0.7858265042304993,
0.538159191608429,
-0.9459995627403259,
-0.5540125370025635,
-0.0900292918086052,
0.13569413125514984,
0.04135969281196594,
-0.13676823675632477,
0.3801075518131256,
-0.48684191703796387,
-0.8421780467033386,
0.588304877281189,
0.23315346240997314,
0.16728578507900238,
-0.21608975529670715,
-0.1631605178117752,
-0.29561588168144226,
-0.04363393411040306,
0.7382009029388428,
0.17761313915252686,
-0.6584811210632324,
0.033305082470178604,
-0.19767186045646667,
0.01582449860870838,
0.10032312572002411,
0.7036182284355164,
-0.6989272236824036,
0.21477854251861572,
0.21257635951042175,
0.637368381023407,
0.5803137421607971,
0.08875401318073273,
0.7039175033569336,
-0.8227917551994324,
0.20556971430778503,
0.11951984465122223,
0.4860436022281647,
0.6618631482124329,
-0.2770434617996216,
0.676479160785675,
-0.09978335350751877,
-0.39343586564064026,
-0.7959912419319153,
0.1718316674232483,
-0.8179401159286499,
-0.002848773030564189,
1.086557149887085,
-0.039073292165994644,
-0.15991196036338806,
0.0871477872133255,
-0.15098708868026733,
0.5543222427368164,
-0.22457996010780334,
0.7685393691062927,
0.6110148429870605,
-0.25704675912857056,
0.1456129103899002,
-0.8120117783546448,
0.4371984601020813,
0.5479743480682373,
-1.4113810062408447,
0.3680133521556854,
0.24573498964309692,
-0.058898527175188065,
0.15357844531536102,
0.24612613022327423,
0.2299434244632721,
0.12943236529827118,
-0.14121697843074799,
0.05773752182722092,
0.0490955151617527,
-0.37813740968704224,
-0.2951677441596985,
-0.10437055677175522,
0.2824843227863312,
-0.23592987656593323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08005v1 | Refined Direct Preference Optimization with Synthetic Data for Behavioral Alignment of LLMs | 2024-02-12T19:10:13 | 2024-02-12T19:10:13 | Víctor Gallego | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce \emph{refined Direct Preference Optimization}
(rDPO), a method for improving the behavioral alignment of Large Language
Models (LLMs) without the need for human-annotated data. The method involves
creating synthetic data using self-critique prompting by a teacher LLM and then
utilising a generalized DPO loss function to distil to a student LLM. The loss
function incorporates an additional external reward model to improve the
quality of synthetic data, making rDPO robust to potential noise in the
synthetic dataset. rDPO is shown to be effective in a diverse set of
behavioural alignment tasks, such as improved safety, robustness against
role-playing, and reduced sycophancy. Code to be released at
https://github.com/vicgalle/refined-dpo. | [
-0.31120291352272034,
-0.6772640943527222,
0.6277053952217102,
0.1571580171585083,
-0.17426708340644836,
0.09300459176301956,
-0.40819957852363586,
-0.2544443905353546,
0.2549116909503937,
0.6317038536071777,
-1.0788565874099731,
-0.42331662774086,
-0.2713322639465332,
0.39344310760498047,
-0.06995119154453278,
0.7116018533706665,
-0.11106012761592865,
0.16052988171577454,
-0.4779905378818512,
0.2151983082294464,
-0.5422859191894531,
-0.5275934338569641,
-0.5351695418357849,
-0.6564064025878906,
0.41401076316833496,
0.6866933107376099,
0.44029301404953003,
0.8214165568351746,
0.45388954877853394,
0.3350852131843567,
-0.08394955843687057,
0.6064176559448242,
-0.7094066143035889,
0.3523026406764984,
-0.2718594968318939,
-0.34182047843933105,
-0.5857654809951782,
0.0840153843164444,
0.6461829543113708,
0.6516502499580383,
-0.1966552585363388,
0.008165801875293255,
0.27265071868896484,
1.0615565776824951,
-0.5975068807601929,
-0.16316218674182892,
-0.4860455095767975,
0.34091782569885254,
0.12740033864974976,
-0.41889330744743347,
-0.5063446164131165,
-0.5598847270011902,
0.21907077729701996,
-0.7268277406692505,
0.01683812402188778,
-0.053999003022909164,
0.5631606578826904,
0.46668022871017456,
-0.4275437593460083,
-0.008248425088822842,
-0.9263265132904053,
1.0198678970336914,
-0.4262373149394989,
0.2510068416595459,
0.338713139295578,
0.14010967314243317,
-0.5776035189628601,
-0.43346256017684937,
-0.6634915471076965,
-0.2666045129299164,
-0.04998672381043434,
0.15699432790279388,
0.26113784313201904,
0.41365841031074524,
0.10423002392053604,
0.4511110484600067,
-0.41446653008461,
0.21066688001155853,
-0.07790882885456085,
-0.12975208461284637,
0.7484331130981445,
0.27974799275398254,
0.09679283946752548,
-0.1404116451740265,
-0.39878711104393005,
-0.07162976264953613,
-0.6752587556838989,
-0.009696905501186848,
0.8083176612854004,
0.43967926502227783,
0.11728288978338242,
0.7192003130912781,
-0.3584960997104645,
0.9694530963897705,
0.4533382058143616,
-0.29650282859802246,
0.2227269560098648,
-0.5043120980262756,
-0.09626097977161407,
0.15130163729190826,
0.7388166785240173,
0.529929518699646,
0.42816802859306335,
0.04821564257144928,
-0.30073025822639465,
0.02000284381210804,
0.21427050232887268,
-0.6148286461830139,
-0.08797158300876617,
0.3301732838153839,
-0.3037228286266327,
-0.6485801339149475,
-0.13996300101280212,
-0.9306917786598206,
-0.3162560760974884,
-0.9958634972572327,
0.12239189445972443,
-0.24029529094696045,
-0.10577502846717834,
0.3649480640888214,
-0.031133154407143593,
0.14552633464336395,
0.3168858587741852,
-1.2695603370666504,
0.4609893262386322,
0.8371028900146484,
0.7348052263259888,
-0.42525234818458557,
-0.18485531210899353,
-0.5058287978172302,
0.34241145849227905,
-0.30737268924713135,
0.6548199653625488,
-0.7689102292060852,
-0.6823328137397766,
-0.03112867847084999,
-0.2185802310705185,
-0.046283066272735596,
-0.6385618448257446,
0.9199227094650269,
-0.24016782641410828,
0.4110245406627655,
-0.2159227430820465,
-0.6064868569374084,
0.14789514243602753,
0.3956385552883148,
-0.5423747301101685,
1.225040316581726,
-0.1061478778719902,
-0.495206356048584,
0.3453977108001709,
-0.49872180819511414,
-0.3262284994125366,
-0.424507737159729,
-0.20127582550048828,
-0.2935665547847748,
0.08442392945289612,
0.24082797765731812,
0.13800464570522308,
-0.05404527485370636,
0.5008184909820557,
-0.4439164698123932,
-0.4218124449253082,
0.23045413196086884,
-0.09154675155878067,
0.5402042269706726,
0.06387891620397568,
-0.1447298377752304,
0.3833285868167877,
-0.9440041184425354,
0.12654820084571838,
0.04767748340964317,
-0.3201032876968384,
-0.516929030418396,
0.13567709922790527,
-0.3846663236618042,
0.21694694459438324,
0.462398499250412,
-0.588809609413147,
0.7103924751281738,
-0.31102725863456726,
0.30405840277671814,
1.2342240810394287,
-0.11175304651260376,
0.5821462869644165,
-0.3487580418586731,
0.6038581132888794,
-0.3694133758544922,
0.42135709524154663,
0.4869978129863739,
-0.2647956907749176,
-0.5463730096817017,
-0.5257880687713623,
0.25008243322372437,
0.42076483368873596,
-0.33606940507888794,
0.831811785697937,
-0.17189298570156097,
-0.08298768848180771,
-0.42757177352905273,
0.17824622988700867,
0.18272805213928223,
0.89472895860672,
0.14752459526062012,
-0.12437921017408371,
-0.9944474697113037,
-1.0297212600708008,
0.15235714614391327,
-0.09726894646883011,
0.12457592040300369,
0.35234954953193665,
0.111971415579319,
-0.5183694958686829,
1.132256269454956,
-0.8864232897758484,
-0.24524764716625214,
-0.16411367058753967,
-0.1608717143535614,
0.058173950761556625,
0.5872615575790405,
0.45333394408226013,
-0.4889412820339203,
-0.4813113808631897,
-0.044345006346702576,
-0.38393744826316833,
-0.4128563404083252,
0.05094742029905319,
-0.5389557480812073,
0.18821677565574646,
0.10829984396696091,
-0.48964864015579224,
-0.020570695400238037,
0.6272690296173096,
-0.13347379863262177,
0.7193655371665955,
-0.22513557970523834,
0.19304338097572327,
-0.883863091468811,
0.11013270169496536,
-0.08625850081443787,
-0.23173148930072784,
-0.5947246551513672,
-0.2336186170578003,
-0.15319472551345825,
-0.19346514344215393,
-0.11140257865190506,
0.6006264090538025,
-0.25351589918136597,
0.05980915576219559,
-0.36146849393844604,
0.16059629619121552,
0.06690694391727448,
0.4702852964401245,
0.48890063166618347,
0.7922035455703735,
0.40140601992607117,
-0.7315312027931213,
0.29162725806236267,
0.4853046238422394,
0.037432312965393066,
0.5423293113708496,
-0.5932485461235046,
0.36838534474372864,
-0.14832065999507904,
0.1087387204170227,
-0.997675895690918,
-0.1365043669939041,
0.424894779920578,
-0.23730503022670746,
0.4305734932422638,
-0.2680339813232422,
-0.2057468444108963,
-0.18270479142665863,
-0.6994695663452148,
0.3053610622882843,
0.37159958481788635,
-0.6152433753013611,
0.19713972508907318,
0.29330965876579285,
-0.04896232485771179,
-0.7908188104629517,
-0.4144596457481384,
-0.09916447103023529,
-0.3384609520435333,
-0.5250173807144165,
0.5454495549201965,
-0.18406647443771362,
-0.1344534307718277,
-0.23332121968269348,
-0.22538001835346222,
0.1136978417634964,
-0.09541238844394684,
-0.005457662511616945,
0.4058643579483032,
0.23418670892715454,
0.15951211750507355,
0.0403764471411705,
-0.2237018346786499,
0.026592349633574486,
-0.05767691135406494,
0.7389220595359802,
0.25248289108276367,
0.004693522583693266,
-0.495648592710495,
0.30475836992263794,
0.15623992681503296,
0.02936595492064953,
0.3026731014251709,
0.15481796860694885,
-0.08542569726705551,
-0.5263515114784241,
-0.23309890925884247,
-0.35925278067588806,
-0.5829471349716187,
0.1927124559879303,
-0.3843928277492523,
-0.5616650581359863,
0.33354926109313965,
-0.12547461688518524,
-0.22964933514595032,
0.14122341573238373,
0.33715787529945374,
0.052599456161260605,
1.0568467378616333,
0.5681924819946289,
-0.01976368948817253,
0.8306962251663208,
-0.12058869749307632,
0.0029412955045700073,
-0.8787420988082886,
-0.3555804491043091,
-0.46557652950286865,
-0.5738525986671448,
-0.7945100665092468,
-0.23104572296142578,
0.04345042631030083,
-0.22955550253391266,
-0.42001911997795105,
0.09186907857656479,
-0.9544991254806519,
0.4223121404647827,
0.8078814148902893,
0.3410574197769165,
0.4916010797023773,
0.11287154257297516,
-0.12251272797584534,
-0.4187629222869873,
-0.40067699551582336,
-0.6564844250679016,
1.2986663579940796,
0.1645125299692154,
1.0236897468566895,
0.008551888167858124,
1.1442266702651978,
0.22219803929328918,
0.005962683353573084,
-1.0801820755004883,
0.83394455909729,
-0.06301943212747574,
-0.4347381591796875,
-0.29468709230422974,
-0.4953237771987915,
-0.9521846771240234,
0.10262300819158554,
-0.29483872652053833,
-0.5297003984451294,
0.25955215096473694,
0.3239455819129944,
-0.08433812111616135,
-0.10809343308210373,
-0.6022422313690186,
0.7549436688423157,
-0.35215556621551514,
-0.6108399629592896,
-0.23086996376514435,
-0.3674226701259613,
0.557434618473053,
0.059045325964689255,
-0.35392555594444275,
-0.15961061418056488,
-0.29781070351600647,
0.7175144553184509,
-0.4864059090614319,
0.848295271396637,
-0.1872224509716034,
-0.23156708478927612,
0.16992837190628052,
0.06986723840236664,
0.6912541389465332,
-0.021437352523207664,
-0.276022732257843,
-0.24345692992210388,
-0.07786824554204941,
-0.1623842716217041,
-0.7859123349189758,
0.9145339727401733,
-0.8995081782341003,
-0.882809579372406,
-0.5091454386711121,
-0.41087567806243896,
-0.44228875637054443,
0.2091006338596344,
-0.11768890172243118,
0.2118474543094635,
-0.15327373147010803,
-0.11005942523479462,
0.5699548721313477,
-0.07337559759616852,
0.1870621144771576,
0.49227476119995117,
-0.13112638890743256,
-0.762481153011322,
0.6152521371841431,
-0.120697982609272,
0.3059541881084442,
0.5315514206886292,
0.5689987540245056,
-0.5963106155395508,
-0.6577799320220947,
-0.20546270906925201,
0.29949408769607544,
-0.5954746603965759,
-0.11359336227178574,
-0.20007310807704926,
0.13690124452114105,
-0.3760768473148346,
-0.22710834443569183,
-0.49867820739746094,
-0.6572309136390686,
-0.36968904733657837,
-0.3567696511745453,
0.33448243141174316,
0.6240962743759155,
-0.14272700250148773,
0.1774318367242813,
-0.3548923432826996,
0.3071947991847992,
0.3190658390522003,
0.5835168957710266,
-0.30325791239738464,
-0.5287449955940247,
0.15881778299808502,
0.2160509079694748,
-0.49655285477638245,
-0.6057196855545044,
0.4949381649494171,
0.18407009541988373,
0.6786383390426636,
0.4534248113632202,
0.3552130162715912,
0.9359202980995178,
-0.5253990888595581,
0.419321209192276,
0.09414644539356232,
-0.8573556542396545,
0.8774765133857727,
-0.46166935563087463,
-0.11023982614278793,
0.7473844289779663,
0.4025748372077942,
-0.4268099367618561,
0.03573737293481827,
-0.2571454644203186,
-0.6851066946983337,
0.689351499080658,
-0.01824888214468956,
0.12878800928592682,
-0.012407558038830757,
0.6540215015411377,
0.2780747711658478,
0.31953683495521545,
-0.7776600122451782,
-0.5087587237358093,
0.003427688032388687,
-0.4341515898704529,
0.01701340265572071,
-0.5424650311470032,
-0.5580277442932129,
-0.41209882497787476,
0.7713648676872253,
-0.1474214494228363,
0.25253432989120483,
0.3881259560585022,
0.29740995168685913,
-0.321270227432251,
0.09349150955677032,
0.8309326767921448,
0.5563632845878601,
-0.5896565914154053,
0.004477534908801317,
-0.22965604066848755,
-0.5548032522201538,
0.6324653029441833,
-0.003961569629609585,
-0.4084543287754059,
-0.21806111931800842,
0.14441721141338348,
0.4847281575202942,
0.021886911243200302,
-0.6046686172485352,
0.2003796100616455,
-0.06205356866121292,
-0.29334768652915955,
-0.27001985907554626,
0.16606800258159637,
-0.3589293360710144,
-0.13412462174892426,
0.1337515115737915,
-0.1824292242527008,
0.2813106179237366,
-0.5608792304992676,
0.27264153957366943,
0.521992564201355,
-0.16458763182163239,
-0.4020751118659973,
0.45237815380096436,
0.578951895236969,
-0.2024618536233902,
0.51434326171875,
0.0789189487695694,
-0.26724502444267273,
0.3771314322948456,
0.7006555795669556,
1.0212385654449463,
-0.2175953984260559,
0.41386425495147705,
0.5102657079696655,
0.017592674121260643,
-0.19263409078121185,
0.245642751455307,
-0.12589949369430542,
-0.9716581106185913,
-0.5614978671073914,
-0.36377567052841187,
-0.8292238116264343,
0.15085774660110474,
-0.6391023993492126,
0.5273386836051941,
-0.5829527378082275,
-0.21280965209007263,
-0.19477787613868713,
0.3873578906059265,
-0.2953220009803772,
0.08026394993066788,
0.02502645179629326,
0.4741966128349304,
-0.7348609566688538,
0.8246473073959351,
0.7559794783592224,
-0.03955218568444252,
-0.3923453390598297,
-0.025225406512618065,
-0.0714496448636055,
-0.9276323914527893,
0.8057965636253357,
0.009932216256856918,
-0.25821009278297424,
-0.08550020307302475,
-0.27246561646461487,
-0.9694398641586304,
0.9032012224197388,
0.6816036701202393,
-0.8275670409202576,
0.13044437766075134,
0.3883923292160034,
0.6547942161560059,
-0.33124083280563354,
-0.008389278315007687,
0.5370264649391174,
0.6599878072738647,
0.20716528594493866,
-0.7305078506469727,
0.1479516625404358,
0.11140386760234833,
-0.11269143223762512,
0.3290818929672241,
-0.7081800699234009,
0.40390411019325256,
-0.18171720206737518,
-0.043773625046014786,
-0.0544675812125206,
0.37306323647499084,
0.3324696719646454,
0.18829065561294556,
0.37967580556869507,
0.6380960941314697,
0.9143567085266113,
-0.06689418107271194,
0.8815082907676697,
-0.31221598386764526,
0.30803847312927246,
1.2875417470932007,
-0.5572157502174377,
0.6468481421470642,
0.8831025958061218,
-0.35510876774787903,
0.34785962104797363,
0.8517260551452637,
0.20677118003368378,
0.8050333857536316,
0.3397531807422638,
-0.25245401263237,
-0.29357481002807617,
-0.122565358877182,
-0.1626511961221695,
0.5021172165870667,
-0.07428422570228577,
-0.16756196320056915,
0.2229992300271988,
-0.3179219961166382,
-0.2650495767593384,
0.5157548785209656,
-0.2627369165420532,
0.8751419186592102,
-0.15194541215896606,
-0.899354100227356,
0.7905496954917908,
-0.23830340802669525,
0.7549588084220886,
-0.6874382495880127,
0.06774235516786575,
-0.42587578296661377,
0.4094134271144867,
-0.4216752350330353,
-0.7264788746833801,
0.4008302688598633,
-0.3105452060699463,
-0.24977141618728638,
-0.36315014958381653,
0.6204493641853333,
-0.620214581489563,
-0.36851581931114197,
0.2431667298078537,
0.2080906480550766,
-0.3089810013771057,
0.1678551286458969,
-0.6093565821647644,
0.09729020297527313,
0.18603841960430145,
-0.45165738463401794,
0.39114198088645935,
0.25280725955963135,
0.1752220243215561,
0.9424000382423401,
0.5318780541419983,
0.19860760867595673,
-0.33746567368507385,
0.02297443524003029,
0.7882351279258728,
-0.7967724800109863,
-0.30602729320526123,
-0.9696056246757507,
0.2814157009124756,
-0.23307855427265167,
-0.2076779454946518,
0.8384760022163391,
0.6927772164344788,
0.8329135775566101,
-0.35476070642471313,
0.7354114055633545,
0.19156301021575928,
0.4229491651058197,
-0.6193587779998779,
-0.08685928583145142,
-0.33800169825553894,
0.26172032952308655,
-0.3151286840438843,
-0.9953874945640564,
-0.1717093139886856,
0.7205176949501038,
-0.5243735909461975,
-0.03275854513049126,
0.5837193727493286,
0.8636327385902405,
0.06253965944051743,
-0.31493088603019714,
0.25448092818260193,
-0.4013160467147827,
0.23427194356918335,
0.3305884599685669,
0.9050320386886597,
-0.0674980953335762,
0.41357019543647766,
-0.6616129279136658,
-0.12492109090089798,
-0.24823881685733795,
-1.0520673990249634,
-0.8553420901298523,
-0.34782594442367554,
-0.5646337866783142,
-0.12686452269554138,
0.043061256408691406,
1.199022889137268,
0.6460943222045898,
-0.6356956362724304,
-0.369874507188797,
-0.2478681355714798,
0.30548304319381714,
-0.26021090149879456,
-0.25410929322242737,
0.21781882643699646,
-0.38473474979400635,
-1.2671654224395752,
0.44019192457199097,
0.09557803720235825,
0.38770791888237,
-0.1171642392873764,
-0.3075500726699829,
-0.13854460418224335,
0.03880907967686653,
0.5829722285270691,
0.127207413315773,
-0.47789546847343445,
-0.48523300886154175,
0.037592291831970215,
0.001591415610164404,
0.1869087964296341,
0.8734869360923767,
-0.5320073366165161,
0.5634786486625671,
0.626901388168335,
0.4271295666694641,
0.34577587246894836,
0.4675980806350708,
1.022669792175293,
-1.0290428400039673,
0.38915765285491943,
0.33188241720199585,
0.2593173384666443,
0.271694540977478,
-0.5972742438316345,
0.7101661562919617,
0.2567721903324127,
-0.6607546806335449,
-0.9829737544059753,
0.3340703845024109,
-1.3153795003890991,
-0.03036532551050186,
1.3910126686096191,
0.26004692912101746,
-0.14980706572532654,
0.24033983051776886,
-0.6455439925193787,
-0.0023230598308146,
-0.7310266494750977,
1.0060374736785889,
0.5191839337348938,
-0.40928274393081665,
-0.006177614443004131,
-0.20935854315757751,
0.8959304690361023,
0.4986554980278015,
-0.68248051404953,
0.22071650624275208,
0.714089035987854,
0.29273587465286255,
-0.28837355971336365,
0.5014907121658325,
0.03679097071290016,
-0.049236640334129333,
-0.2990337312221527,
0.3209976553916931,
-0.3490138649940491,
-0.05391186848282814,
-0.42202749848365784,
-0.10672782361507416,
0.2886970043182373,
-0.5288668274879456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16878v1 | EvoGPT-f: An Evolutionary GPT Framework for Benchmarking Formal Math Languages | 2024-02-12T19:10:11 | 2024-02-12T19:10:11 | Johnathan Mercer | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE | Formal mathematics is the discipline of translating mathematics into a
programming language in which any statement can be unequivocally checked by a
computer. Mathematicians and computer scientists have spent decades of
painstaking formalization efforts developing languages such as Coq, HOL, and
Lean. Machine learning research has converged on these formal math corpora and
given rise to an assortment of methodologies to aid in interactive and
automated theorem proving. However, these papers have primarily focused on one
method, for one proof task, in one language. This paper introduces EvoGPT-f: a
novel evolutionary framework for the first systematic quantitative analysis of
the differential machine learnability of five formal math corpora (Lean 3, Lean
4, Coq, HOL 4, HOL Light) using four tokenization methods (character,
word-level, Byte Pair Encoding and StarCoder tokenizer). This paper does not
put to rest the question of the "best" or "easiest" language to learn. Rather,
this framework and preliminary findings begin to illuminate the differential
machine learnability of these languages, offering a foundation to forge more
systematic quantitative and qualitative comparative research across
communities. | [
-0.36135584115982056,
-0.8783818483352661,
0.2673252522945404,
0.11578720808029175,
-0.3226572871208191,
0.510938823223114,
-0.1764100193977356,
-0.5812186002731323,
-0.22537072002887726,
-0.27309584617614746,
-0.354956716299057,
-0.47664132714271545,
-0.593097448348999,
0.45828309655189514,
-0.27317729592323303,
0.6076093316078186,
-0.23572848737239838,
0.10785304754972458,
-0.25614359974861145,
-0.3576247990131378,
0.20346006751060486,
-0.5019526481628418,
-0.6104696989059448,
-0.21215210855007172,
-0.005225914530456066,
-0.03343184292316437,
0.607276976108551,
0.6016270518302917,
0.5920520424842834,
0.29621371626853943,
0.3269248604774475,
-0.047403134405612946,
-0.5713176131248474,
0.09533064067363739,
0.12525950372219086,
-0.461907297372818,
-0.23503626883029938,
-0.446094810962677,
0.6206762790679932,
0.6828644275665283,
-0.11983446776866913,
0.3459499180316925,
0.02154550887644291,
0.6835001707077026,
-0.563616156578064,
0.5077151656150818,
-0.6988608241081238,
0.2389431595802307,
-0.2609582245349884,
-0.1771625280380249,
-0.16694878041744232,
-0.6027765870094299,
0.10635709762573242,
-0.8032708764076233,
0.19382408261299133,
0.017886413261294365,
0.8002774715423584,
0.3353388011455536,
-0.24830029904842377,
-0.46125200390815735,
-0.5382806062698364,
0.7667593359947205,
-0.5206904411315918,
0.6929328441619873,
0.21953794360160828,
0.598614513874054,
0.13931971788406372,
-0.8262106776237488,
-0.17833608388900757,
-0.12905026972293854,
0.1371188908815384,
-0.05530942976474762,
-0.15961778163909912,
-0.08880789577960968,
0.2994389533996582,
0.4073082208633423,
-0.7555570006370544,
-0.1502966433763504,
-0.35478153824806213,
-0.23282977938652039,
0.580402672290802,
-0.1660510003566742,
0.46034738421440125,
0.6159077882766724,
-0.16453780233860016,
-0.23947486281394958,
-0.8212574124336243,
0.028947047889232635,
0.4118571877479553,
0.05605008453130722,
0.004504159092903137,
0.21401609480381012,
-0.041378047317266464,
0.5709686875343323,
-0.047322507947683334,
-0.05606985464692116,
0.3417436182498932,
-0.06868738681077957,
-0.20462793111801147,
-0.03431249037384987,
0.7512246966362,
-0.34186646342277527,
0.21861036121845245,
-0.16229969263076782,
-0.3978719711303711,
0.18372102081775665,
-0.06416793912649155,
-0.8720561265945435,
-0.3486207127571106,
-0.13768333196640015,
-0.16203026473522186,
-0.3817673325538635,
-0.04821908846497536,
-1.028329849243164,
0.12000950425863266,
-0.2950080633163452,
0.43527206778526306,
-0.7024117708206177,
-0.1319216936826706,
0.07908247411251068,
-0.009220059029757977,
0.3990774154663086,
0.2486141324043274,
-1.1285762786865234,
0.699623167514801,
1.0637599229812622,
0.763213038444519,
0.06603195518255234,
-0.31331658363342285,
-0.5210030674934387,
-0.19979500770568848,
-0.347972571849823,
0.5291467905044556,
-0.7644297480583191,
-0.26419195532798767,
0.2024783194065094,
-0.3780515193939209,
-0.08969250321388245,
-0.4520331621170044,
0.7123073935508728,
-0.6044870615005493,
0.3362797498703003,
-0.2135132998228073,
-0.6433192491531372,
-0.3777751922607422,
0.1514519304037094,
-0.34801599383354187,
1.3092118501663208,
0.5023306608200073,
-0.49789971113204956,
0.8241356611251831,
-0.5014357566833496,
-0.4600830376148224,
0.4604591429233551,
-0.438644677400589,
-0.6394559741020203,
0.17589659988880157,
0.13028110563755035,
0.19179140031337738,
-0.4188348054885864,
0.29796966910362244,
-0.5204262137413025,
-0.3821924030780792,
-0.3446086645126343,
-0.2215167135000229,
0.7771453857421875,
0.43957602977752686,
-0.8916261792182922,
-0.13255679607391357,
-0.8606971502304077,
0.41276299953460693,
0.30737602710723877,
-0.21197837591171265,
-0.5431658625602722,
0.04391579329967499,
-0.23982727527618408,
0.312518447637558,
0.13095811009407043,
-0.19594350457191467,
0.19288402795791626,
-0.30783748626708984,
0.7150942087173462,
0.7563889622688293,
-0.4038516879081726,
0.2628842890262604,
-0.17731161415576935,
0.6146390438079834,
-0.3607132136821747,
0.052326884120702744,
-0.19183287024497986,
-0.5762408971786499,
-0.5792554616928101,
-0.5744151473045349,
0.42169997096061707,
0.4086795151233673,
-0.5387367606163025,
0.41859737038612366,
-0.273857057094574,
-0.3541703522205353,
-0.39514797925949097,
0.1481925994157791,
0.39142489433288574,
0.2856113910675049,
0.2953541874885559,
-0.21528691053390503,
-0.3397448658943176,
-0.720596194267273,
-0.4228152930736542,
-0.4029308259487152,
-0.013883832842111588,
0.2855183780193329,
0.6178194284439087,
-0.22766456007957458,
0.5519244074821472,
-0.15306659042835236,
0.3302690386772156,
0.22527997195720673,
0.3081515431404114,
-0.009569060988724232,
0.2798157036304474,
0.7672492265701294,
-0.49454474449157715,
-0.6262518167495728,
0.07415536791086197,
-0.8150324821472168,
-0.21598900854587555,
0.040795885026454926,
-0.17082016170024872,
0.1422029435634613,
0.2601168751716614,
-0.09350492805242538,
0.11401821672916412,
0.5379966497421265,
-0.31302449107170105,
0.4926292598247528,
-0.05510672554373741,
0.049044787883758545,
-0.4277108311653137,
0.2837081253528595,
-0.24096326529979706,
-0.310100793838501,
-0.5878593325614929,
0.5488157868385315,
0.11486812680959702,
-0.1614937037229538,
-0.026806114241480827,
0.5418012738227844,
-0.35819974541664124,
-0.2625539004802704,
0.3554229438304901,
-0.19034330546855927,
-0.40174487233161926,
0.5399589538574219,
-0.032814379781484604,
0.5866823792457581,
0.732366144657135,
-0.748430609703064,
0.14780893921852112,
-0.09381710737943649,
-0.03719677776098251,
0.5629875063896179,
-0.8448814153671265,
0.3204449713230133,
0.0968489870429039,
-0.11129148304462433,
-0.9646356701850891,
0.031164566054940224,
0.18254834413528442,
-0.4180143475532532,
0.4129675328731537,
-0.15995262563228607,
-0.3757557272911072,
-0.23972392082214355,
-0.24231603741645813,
0.6311340928077698,
0.828902006149292,
-0.5567846894264221,
0.46161478757858276,
0.2104547619819641,
-0.21423517167568207,
-0.5139999389648438,
-0.30447036027908325,
-0.1767636090517044,
-0.19189882278442383,
-0.9180233478546143,
0.2375226467847824,
-0.06131542846560478,
-0.47707322239875793,
-0.11595229804515839,
-0.26375168561935425,
-0.23259684443473816,
0.24534082412719727,
-0.252653032541275,
0.16398756206035614,
-0.4800550043582916,
0.12215128540992737,
-0.06601349264383316,
-0.10981068760156631,
0.03265506401658058,
-0.6767006516456604,
0.5838390588760376,
-0.5984487533569336,
-0.6457595825195312,
0.11051518470048904,
-0.04888206720352173,
0.4706985652446747,
-0.10596305131912231,
0.16651411354541779,
0.6516317129135132,
-0.41436898708343506,
-0.47281819581985474,
-0.257607102394104,
-0.1517619639635086,
-0.45192834734916687,
0.18403416872024536,
-0.6576060056686401,
-0.9549983739852905,
0.4164911210536957,
-0.3384802043437958,
0.565876305103302,
0.769249439239502,
0.5674943923950195,
0.5459608435630798,
0.935961902141571,
0.5947698354721069,
0.032352838665246964,
0.2759096324443817,
-0.06268812716007233,
0.10045018792152405,
-0.09146261215209961,
-0.03933550789952278,
-0.7551870346069336,
-0.16344712674617767,
-0.8071624040603638,
-0.2931199371814728,
0.2623225748538971,
0.19580961763858795,
-0.43568500876426697,
0.31633391976356506,
-0.5796944499015808,
0.3560008108615875,
0.43238505721092224,
-0.32156386971473694,
0.4069530963897705,
0.1598050892353058,
-0.6675939559936523,
-0.05889306217432022,
-0.5325120091438293,
-0.47519493103027344,
1.190145492553711,
0.35346734523773193,
0.5252189040184021,
0.024360883980989456,
0.9998658299446106,
-0.05899500474333763,
0.28598859906196594,
-0.6001597046852112,
0.4213946461677551,
-0.031646907329559326,
-0.3971739411354065,
-0.5186998844146729,
-0.700739324092865,
-0.7914775013923645,
0.42556533217430115,
0.03814699873328209,
-0.4498731195926666,
0.010070284828543663,
0.21578021347522736,
0.10077562928199768,
0.22374668717384338,
-0.5529988408088684,
0.743108868598938,
-0.5786897540092468,
-0.5980283617973328,
-0.1523202806711197,
-0.5104243755340576,
0.5390012264251709,
-0.30204612016677856,
0.48589515686035156,
-0.1305343508720398,
-0.21802674233913422,
0.46855807304382324,
-0.5465314388275146,
0.5091370344161987,
-0.09713229537010193,
-0.08893802762031555,
0.17945680022239685,
0.5169996023178101,
0.5405317544937134,
0.24415233731269836,
0.021075768396258354,
0.24582485854625702,
0.28001588582992554,
-0.5687552094459534,
-0.4417141377925873,
0.41766807436943054,
-0.7961015701293945,
-0.17875292897224426,
-0.5983479619026184,
0.11784420162439346,
-0.24146440625190735,
0.3324809968471527,
0.19664306938648224,
0.3654313385486603,
-0.4712877571582794,
0.035438645631074905,
0.7682032585144043,
-0.12151982635259628,
0.3435281813144684,
0.44254058599472046,
-0.38571611046791077,
-0.42600736021995544,
1.0216022729873657,
-0.1458224058151245,
0.1166553944349289,
0.6652954816818237,
0.44952714443206787,
-0.36732661724090576,
-0.4320409595966339,
-0.4466455578804016,
0.04066744074225426,
-0.6940653324127197,
0.1389482021331787,
-0.45887863636016846,
-0.03579775243997574,
-0.3544105589389801,
-0.5022823214530945,
-0.28115084767341614,
-0.7282266616821289,
0.18191564083099365,
0.058311838656663895,
0.2286064177751541,
0.6000517010688782,
-0.17703208327293396,
-0.4130795896053314,
-0.5570299029350281,
0.1681244820356369,
0.6570728421211243,
0.3246789872646332,
-0.2796456813812256,
-0.37896427512168884,
0.2882779836654663,
-0.1156928539276123,
-0.2870695888996124,
-0.3467108905315399,
0.3157184422016144,
0.7181470990180969,
0.6692139506340027,
0.48252514004707336,
-0.1822742521762848,
0.602510392665863,
-0.6165950894355774,
0.5919954180717468,
0.2712743878364563,
-1.1902412176132202,
0.19105450809001923,
-0.30668172240257263,
0.12289461493492126,
0.6241905689239502,
0.4695567786693573,
-0.6166259050369263,
-0.16090209782123566,
-0.7858006954193115,
-0.8166376352310181,
0.1000489667057991,
0.21696917712688446,
-0.20977716147899628,
0.2186232954263687,
0.12686662375926971,
0.6323747634887695,
0.39415302872657776,
-0.4269952178001404,
-0.13406333327293396,
-0.4365531802177429,
-0.3705742657184601,
-0.09886062890291214,
0.09432534128427505,
-0.22704502940177917,
-0.31626781821250916,
0.4404725730419159,
-0.3829699456691742,
0.5456011891365051,
-0.12071653455495834,
-0.21995103359222412,
-0.06377244740724564,
0.29537469148635864,
0.7006685137748718,
1.0552886724472046,
-0.12403102219104767,
0.3586322069168091,
0.15624399483203888,
-0.7056158185005188,
0.07595043629407883,
0.30524614453315735,
-0.47637155652046204,
0.19948254525661469,
0.5846216082572937,
0.5502346158027649,
0.48847559094429016,
-0.6404518485069275,
0.1872391700744629,
-0.06474512815475464,
-0.511715292930603,
-0.2700066864490509,
-0.11326450854539871,
-0.37717774510383606,
-0.3775779902935028,
0.4609735310077667,
-0.04129842668771744,
0.2567393481731415,
-0.6687905788421631,
0.5474681258201599,
0.49310749769210815,
-0.2434093952178955,
-0.7582398653030396,
0.7010465264320374,
0.3168421983718872,
-0.22026458382606506,
0.456658273935318,
-0.40803956985473633,
-0.7607219219207764,
0.5601564645767212,
0.4986145496368408,
1.180927038192749,
-0.20962058007717133,
0.308329313993454,
0.6255926489830017,
0.3003481924533844,
-0.05292625352740288,
0.3612927496433258,
-0.21014738082885742,
-0.31569233536720276,
-0.17791195213794708,
-0.7419406771659851,
-0.5262527465820312,
-0.17100311815738678,
-0.32401135563850403,
0.4475947320461273,
-0.6554973125457764,
0.24957843124866486,
0.052899956703186035,
0.08960539847612381,
-0.9228042960166931,
-0.059021566063165665,
0.058568380773067474,
0.5904617309570312,
-0.6308754086494446,
0.4473632574081421,
0.7858880162239075,
-0.03674294427037239,
-0.538163959980011,
-0.33410367369651794,
0.31135445833206177,
-1.3312097787857056,
0.7655875086784363,
-0.0012201278004795313,
-0.16894899308681488,
0.0656517967581749,
-0.6528380513191223,
-0.6825546026229858,
1.002297282218933,
0.3222016394138336,
-0.8023683428764343,
0.09726908802986145,
0.18913404643535614,
0.6783142685890198,
-0.318656325340271,
0.5387656092643738,
0.3843305706977844,
0.4462237060070038,
0.3546835780143738,
-0.8539847731590271,
0.1193632036447525,
-0.2473723143339157,
-0.18910154700279236,
0.542023241519928,
-0.6763330698013306,
0.7677417993545532,
-0.147943913936615,
-0.37465548515319824,
-0.30284613370895386,
0.4180489480495453,
0.2819952070713043,
0.4543461501598358,
0.3385827839374542,
0.6555542349815369,
1.0445518493652344,
-0.3642246425151825,
0.8139638304710388,
-0.6731602549552917,
0.5356464982032776,
0.5857324600219727,
-0.30062490701675415,
0.6177896857261658,
0.2975255846977234,
-0.6335782408714294,
0.3700059950351715,
0.7470462918281555,
-0.07701167464256287,
0.44562584161758423,
0.6817985773086548,
-0.27320101857185364,
-0.10113655775785446,
0.5513333678245544,
-0.659705400466919,
0.08790984749794006,
0.36138486862182617,
-0.20837236940860748,
-0.20778092741966248,
-0.6169552803039551,
0.044415395706892014,
-0.2046796679496765,
-0.09262792021036148,
0.6600502133369446,
0.15207801759243011,
-0.547275722026825,
0.872809886932373,
-0.1581471562385559,
0.6282597780227661,
-0.810015857219696,
-0.17655959725379944,
-0.09858039021492004,
0.18665803968906403,
-0.11848273128271103,
-0.2594504952430725,
0.1614602655172348,
-0.2017195224761963,
0.5050265192985535,
-0.009054270572960377,
0.54188472032547,
-0.32161155343055725,
-0.6402533650398254,
0.02940245158970356,
0.6499470472335815,
0.0957954153418541,
0.38951197266578674,
-0.8795158863067627,
0.018398467451334,
-0.2905605435371399,
-0.031352847814559937,
0.3452293276786804,
0.7609176635742188,
-0.021557647734880447,
0.7709029316902161,
0.6124679446220398,
-0.0937204360961914,
0.31260326504707336,
-0.03784261271357536,
0.8051331043243408,
-0.3570678234100342,
-0.5263407230377197,
-0.979121208190918,
0.14636310935020447,
0.06537239253520966,
-0.5823705196380615,
0.7254277467727661,
0.6348617076873779,
0.9936729669570923,
-0.07258325070142746,
0.9492203593254089,
-0.2731839418411255,
0.05503591522574425,
-0.5436632037162781,
0.25283366441726685,
-0.3442302346229553,
0.1606326401233673,
-0.5309280157089233,
-1.1144591569900513,
-0.4022080898284912,
0.7593022584915161,
-0.14528968930244446,
0.20588986575603485,
1.046088457107544,
0.3190385103225708,
-0.1017037108540535,
0.1648387312889099,
0.4423641264438629,
-0.2382264882326126,
0.33868762850761414,
0.7785463929176331,
0.6894817352294922,
-0.38838261365890503,
0.5637655258178711,
-0.24038591980934143,
-0.4862469732761383,
-0.22375740110874176,
-0.7641302943229675,
-0.9848038554191589,
-0.5734595060348511,
-0.5452225804328918,
-0.10122653841972351,
0.31621870398521423,
0.8606556057929993,
0.6379857659339905,
-0.855003297328949,
-0.14521533250808716,
-0.44784754514694214,
0.026900000870227814,
-0.6037606000900269,
-0.2176719307899475,
0.5253251194953918,
-0.5873987674713135,
-0.6465422511100769,
0.08787030726671219,
0.5723937749862671,
0.029475698247551918,
-0.2894611060619354,
-0.34661760926246643,
0.2182210385799408,
-0.07442362606525421,
0.52520352602005,
0.7771320343017578,
-0.38214772939682007,
-0.1940663903951645,
0.24979008734226227,
0.02733212150633335,
0.1421019583940506,
1.1067954301834106,
-0.4300301671028137,
0.6080177426338196,
0.7252002954483032,
0.8252745270729065,
0.3653052747249603,
-0.21540415287017822,
0.7830835580825806,
-0.33317798376083374,
-0.03467144817113876,
0.43805012106895447,
0.3527642786502838,
0.0698169469833374,
-0.2142389565706253,
0.9477660059928894,
0.5292385816574097,
-0.7643668055534363,
-0.7943180203437805,
0.21911783516407013,
-0.4479140341281891,
-0.026006100699305534,
0.9025294184684753,
-0.21367484331130981,
-0.1820363700389862,
-0.36261481046676636,
0.21716581284999847,
-0.18903422355651855,
-0.4981544017791748,
0.9687513113021851,
0.7668243646621704,
-0.059412889182567596,
-0.10716027021408081,
-0.7386153340339661,
0.800606906414032,
0.27217406034469604,
-0.7947345972061157,
-0.24565385282039642,
0.230983704328537,
0.36127257347106934,
0.08566376566886902,
0.5766119956970215,
-0.2828686237335205,
0.33555668592453003,
0.35341784358024597,
-0.026420699432492256,
-0.06037735939025879,
-0.05796103924512863,
-0.44837334752082825,
0.2039203643798828,
0.1440514773130417,
0.19698135554790497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07899v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07899v2 | A systematic investigation of learnability from single child linguistic input | 2024-02-12T18:58:58 | 2024-05-10T18:54:59 | Yulu Qin, Wentao Wang, Brenden M. Lake | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in generating
linguistically coherent text, sparking discussions about their relevance to
understanding human language learnability. However, a significant gap exists
between the training data for these models and the linguistic input a child
receives. LMs are typically trained on data that is orders of magnitude larger
and fundamentally different from child-directed speech (Warstadt and Bowman,
2022; Warstadt et al., 2023; Frank, 2023a). Addressing this discrepancy, our
research focuses on training LMs on subsets of a single child's linguistic
input. Previously, Wang, Vong, Kim, and Lake (2023) found that LMs trained in
this setting can form syntactic and semantic word clusters and develop
sensitivity to certain linguistic phenomena, but they only considered LSTMs and
simpler neural networks trained from just one single-child dataset. Here, to
examine the robustness of learnability from single-child input, we
systematically train six different model architectures on five datasets (3
single-child and 2 baselines). We find that the models trained on single-child
datasets showed consistent results that matched with previous work,
underscoring the robustness of forming meaningful syntactic and semantic
representations from a subset of a child's linguistic input. | [
-0.20538564026355743,
-0.6041155457496643,
0.392506867647171,
-0.09743790328502655,
-0.15271610021591187,
0.05647021904587746,
-0.4118189215660095,
-0.3054177463054657,
-0.2785584628582001,
0.32083916664123535,
-0.7616663575172424,
-0.44449079036712646,
-0.6197017431259155,
0.02489316463470459,
-0.6704895496368408,
0.8273018002510071,
0.16454468667507172,
0.02013552375137806,
-0.43377360701560974,
-0.14238815009593964,
-0.25041091442108154,
-0.6456927061080933,
-0.6804618835449219,
-0.3301967680454254,
0.7605257630348206,
0.5054135322570801,
0.5043685436248779,
0.7973437309265137,
0.28930753469467163,
0.2857869267463684,
-0.1915605515241623,
-0.27821871638298035,
-0.4660757780075073,
0.16219232976436615,
-0.3563939332962036,
-0.3236018419265747,
-0.16848894953727722,
-0.07562262564897537,
0.8501444458961487,
1.3504488468170166,
-0.1389755755662918,
0.19950923323631287,
0.5492976307868958,
0.7547350525856018,
-0.33462125062942505,
0.2699041962623596,
-1.1082314252853394,
0.16697920858860016,
-0.14477764070034027,
0.3763640522956848,
-0.6524205207824707,
-0.10817097872495651,
0.3388912081718445,
-0.6230926513671875,
0.5391443371772766,
-0.5170366764068604,
0.8516178727149963,
0.22277741134166718,
-0.31794461607933044,
-0.30977773666381836,
-0.6276522278785706,
0.8458839654922485,
-0.8181971311569214,
0.4835115373134613,
0.6500649452209473,
0.05952032655477524,
0.010785503312945366,
-0.7545117139816284,
-0.45638659596443176,
-0.09920837730169296,
-0.3440246880054474,
-0.17088524997234344,
-0.019770609214901924,
-0.08949914574623108,
0.2679198086261749,
0.02829306572675705,
-0.6387162804603577,
0.3036690950393677,
-0.40914949774742126,
-0.048005785793066025,
0.3570566177368164,
0.13362614810466766,
0.3921786844730377,
0.06421811133623123,
-0.29864081740379333,
-0.21331773698329926,
-0.4454382658004761,
0.45278316736221313,
0.3222229480743408,
1.0524691343307495,
-0.32202935218811035,
0.27137261629104614,
-0.14063112437725067,
0.734998881816864,
-0.0002771315921563655,
-0.4666474461555481,
0.007794735487550497,
-0.5032973885536194,
0.21625825762748718,
-0.11088937520980835,
0.7678242325782776,
-0.2848502993583679,
0.6390098333358765,
-0.32475242018699646,
-0.3119160234928131,
0.4337617754936218,
0.6582967042922974,
-0.45707404613494873,
-0.26754269003868103,
0.10754595696926117,
-0.37614306807518005,
-0.4579954445362091,
0.1644245684146881,
-0.6515424251556396,
-0.2942146956920624,
-0.15940821170806885,
0.2929884195327759,
-0.5705040097236633,
-0.3235170245170593,
0.08634275943040848,
0.11769834905862808,
0.17890359461307526,
-0.07637102901935577,
-1.0175353288650513,
0.5147840976715088,
0.5386550426483154,
0.4271032214164734,
-0.46087679266929626,
-0.6314694881439209,
-0.21368318796157837,
-0.1997174769639969,
-0.3792908191680908,
0.7105210423469543,
-0.40452903509140015,
-0.3991451561450958,
0.173116996884346,
-0.15340647101402283,
-0.6328446865081787,
-0.7077456116676331,
0.386791855096817,
-0.4386472702026367,
0.08809757232666016,
-0.025906115770339966,
-0.48347190022468567,
-0.13017131388187408,
0.09277061372995377,
-0.7568549513816833,
0.6451723575592041,
0.16120575368404388,
-0.899604082107544,
0.9096118211746216,
-0.21271680295467377,
-0.736137866973877,
-0.18660424649715424,
-0.13854756951332092,
-0.5808917284011841,
0.17707563936710358,
0.17340025305747986,
0.3209267556667328,
0.3196290135383606,
0.2688494324684143,
-0.490612268447876,
-0.1339694708585739,
0.2873933017253876,
-0.8452016115188599,
0.7133517861366272,
-0.09827668219804764,
-0.13173705339431763,
-0.13039341568946838,
-0.9774817824363708,
0.2527632415294647,
0.2674960494041443,
-0.6796839833259583,
-0.15184594690799713,
0.23854203522205353,
-0.15391966700553894,
0.38944491744041443,
0.024668317288160324,
-0.5595687031745911,
0.19221797585487366,
-0.5803362131118774,
0.20426416397094727,
0.6125843524932861,
-0.19900575280189514,
0.39417150616645813,
-0.2936181426048279,
0.5781561732292175,
0.22158071398735046,
-0.07595199346542358,
-0.3346845805644989,
-0.2559714913368225,
-0.8296049237251282,
-0.21410995721817017,
0.3087741732597351,
0.21409472823143005,
-0.8427035212516785,
0.29316723346710205,
-0.23043476045131683,
-0.2569184899330139,
-0.4039137065410614,
0.3886309564113617,
0.6273104548454285,
0.5767733454704285,
0.13814418017864227,
-0.4054270386695862,
-0.5834789276123047,
-0.8379321694374084,
-0.37888726592063904,
-0.2964994013309479,
0.26875001192092896,
-0.04175890237092972,
0.39084917306900024,
0.13103853166103363,
0.8843443393707275,
0.10646230727434158,
0.1931886225938797,
-0.5035960674285889,
-0.10527320206165314,
0.25537821650505066,
0.4197576642036438,
0.2540324926376343,
-0.5346013903617859,
-0.5768842101097107,
-0.0751526802778244,
-0.7360100150108337,
0.2197931557893753,
0.09990578889846802,
0.32958921790122986,
0.1587822437286377,
0.1661854386329651,
-0.38837680220603943,
0.843288004398346,
0.5698400735855103,
-0.3433411121368408,
0.34691643714904785,
-0.12130158394575119,
-0.43247753381729126,
-0.9530489444732666,
-0.13164441287517548,
-0.19634853303432465,
-0.18819911777973175,
-1.0946125984191895,
0.06382699310779572,
0.0037718743551522493,
0.020306890830397606,
-0.6552246809005737,
0.4065789580345154,
-0.31172993779182434,
0.03931419551372528,
-0.3218003511428833,
-0.0087366858497262,
-0.28979721665382385,
0.5202109813690186,
-0.0017980895936489105,
0.7051846981048584,
0.8977822065353394,
-0.9446247816085815,
-0.1407117396593094,
-0.05118795111775398,
-0.41711297631263733,
0.3612699806690216,
-0.8987469673156738,
0.305422842502594,
-0.25500261783599854,
-0.0740484818816185,
-0.9991341829299927,
-0.32333192229270935,
-0.0653141438961029,
-0.3888072669506073,
0.456111878156662,
-0.01460261270403862,
-0.47866854071617126,
-0.22779123485088348,
0.03526029363274574,
0.4596010744571686,
0.3627701997756958,
-0.7879432439804077,
0.44177165627479553,
0.43352341651916504,
-0.18442077934741974,
-0.42821770906448364,
-0.6167498230934143,
-0.367164671421051,
-0.06054580211639404,
-0.5271199345588684,
-0.1745891571044922,
0.10566345602273941,
-0.1242690458893776,
0.06826257705688477,
-0.2971106171607971,
-0.4360392987728119,
0.3839884400367737,
0.3378249406814575,
0.1834448277950287,
-0.3649848699569702,
0.34035199880599976,
-0.1851600706577301,
-0.23358039557933807,
-0.06593635678291321,
-0.18722966313362122,
0.6029217839241028,
-0.059293005615472794,
-0.5457832217216492,
-0.35291609168052673,
0.19555583596229553,
0.4838109612464905,
-0.0963294729590416,
0.9433647394180298,
0.3261452615261078,
-0.49664929509162903,
-0.7918744683265686,
0.12686291337013245,
-0.292066752910614,
-0.43850767612457275,
0.36708226799964905,
-0.43986400961875916,
-0.7426331043243408,
0.3905964195728302,
0.41880854964256287,
0.27097445726394653,
0.40802013874053955,
0.2581138014793396,
-0.12273384630680084,
1.089837908744812,
0.7458521723747253,
-0.03747041895985603,
0.19368508458137512,
-0.10554429143667221,
0.02298387698829174,
-0.3815477788448334,
-0.25533416867256165,
-0.6248447299003601,
-0.2324436902999878,
-0.46611982583999634,
-0.12359072268009186,
0.13816769421100616,
-0.03442320227622986,
-0.17984387278556824,
0.4236942529678345,
-0.3693121075630188,
0.383575439453125,
0.6086024641990662,
0.2047693431377411,
0.3788689374923706,
0.2195756882429123,
-0.4686349332332611,
-0.03676244243979454,
-1.3148117065429688,
-0.7476752996444702,
1.0363566875457764,
0.412700355052948,
0.9368000030517578,
0.05424516648054123,
0.6341358423233032,
-0.09945686161518097,
0.25758007168769836,
-0.7237312197685242,
0.5841881036758423,
-0.5462989807128906,
-0.7394933104515076,
-0.2693709433078766,
-0.3961368501186371,
-1.3468331098556519,
0.34645721316337585,
-0.3318961560726166,
-0.9530998468399048,
0.12047077715396881,
0.22029072046279907,
-0.28018033504486084,
0.4809872806072235,
-0.7920423150062561,
0.8466470241546631,
-0.14076542854309082,
-0.21361371874809265,
0.20927999913692474,
-0.6030716896057129,
0.24297194182872772,
-0.4012329876422882,
0.3699832260608673,
0.0641317293047905,
-0.08641287684440613,
0.6865149140357971,
-0.40215539932250977,
1.1310250759124756,
0.001502949045971036,
-0.1632327288389206,
0.2913750112056732,
0.10557451099157333,
0.08495458215475082,
-0.028330525383353233,
0.06640127301216125,
-0.018993284553289413,
0.07985741645097733,
-0.6436856389045715,
-0.43586236238479614,
0.6002471446990967,
-0.7521699070930481,
-0.32634297013282776,
-0.42765486240386963,
-0.5638988614082336,
-0.47309133410453796,
0.21753384172916412,
0.3311885893344879,
0.7001808285713196,
-0.15309128165245056,
0.23419834673404694,
0.8087548613548279,
-0.11497995257377625,
0.6186606287956238,
0.4326172471046448,
-0.427261620759964,
-0.010379414074122906,
0.7850229144096375,
0.1495007872581482,
0.5712090730667114,
0.04704680293798447,
0.19451197981834412,
-0.14538072049617767,
-0.4121817648410797,
-0.2608296573162079,
0.07800156623125076,
-0.6508883237838745,
0.18065178394317627,
-0.29049479961395264,
-0.39554089307785034,
-0.15570446848869324,
0.04039441794157028,
-0.7133980989456177,
-0.44570091366767883,
-0.24982300400733948,
-0.1590633988380432,
-0.2502129077911377,
1.250504732131958,
0.25081872940063477,
0.21217253804206848,
-0.7490031719207764,
0.25338491797447205,
0.6093143820762634,
0.4601929783821106,
0.1729179173707962,
-0.9657595753669739,
-0.25099411606788635,
0.1591312438249588,
0.08739575743675232,
-0.7391441464424133,
0.10753629356622696,
0.41136544942855835,
0.6371660232543945,
0.4793287217617035,
-0.25505968928337097,
0.5201911926269531,
-0.5111167430877686,
0.8230953812599182,
0.04641105607151985,
-0.7652417421340942,
0.6044893860816956,
-0.19532407820224762,
0.6160422563552856,
0.8079129457473755,
0.2687690258026123,
-0.1700112223625183,
-0.24093863368034363,
-0.7612080574035645,
-0.6713119149208069,
0.9082950949668884,
-0.00900407787412405,
0.2222898304462433,
0.2521263659000397,
0.14134463667869568,
0.5622164607048035,
0.06176219508051872,
-0.7466416954994202,
-0.2673983871936798,
-0.04660584405064583,
-0.31096041202545166,
-0.120191790163517,
0.1198577731847763,
0.10061647742986679,
-0.22458219528198242,
0.5669821500778198,
-0.12261997908353806,
-0.003276111325249076,
-0.2740830183029175,
0.011280656792223454,
0.005369978956878185,
0.3062395453453064,
0.284339964389801,
0.8479808568954468,
0.1202133297920227,
0.557439923286438,
0.064881831407547,
-0.4612971544265747,
0.14772175252437592,
-0.00433743093162775,
-0.4572232663631439,
0.19393613934516907,
0.9023399353027344,
0.8348178267478943,
0.2737014591693878,
-0.6089586615562439,
0.4324464499950409,
-0.2183789163827896,
-0.20273442566394806,
-0.091078981757164,
0.1496475487947464,
0.18400168418884277,
-0.17350441217422485,
-0.008721168152987957,
0.04866410791873932,
-0.3849485218524933,
-0.8257074356079102,
0.3473643362522125,
0.36388248205184937,
-0.6786943078041077,
-0.5985510945320129,
0.38325101137161255,
-0.20571444928646088,
-0.28588220477104187,
0.6369990110397339,
-0.10230608284473419,
-0.4035998284816742,
0.5872041583061218,
0.610977292060852,
0.8422945737838745,
-0.09754154831171036,
0.3548167943954468,
0.5552579164505005,
0.5055556893348694,
0.11225958913564682,
-0.011212210170924664,
0.04066801071166992,
-1.0773515701293945,
-0.15860258042812347,
-0.5727697014808655,
-0.18429245054721832,
0.21010184288024902,
-0.9104354977607727,
-0.10371354222297668,
-0.39902040362358093,
-0.21102601289749146,
0.03370308876037598,
-0.4992242455482483,
-0.971619188785553,
0.2951284646987915,
0.194291889667511,
0.6845616698265076,
-0.9143893122673035,
0.8298251032829285,
0.9548138380050659,
-0.46891722083091736,
-1.3466404676437378,
-0.01015468593686819,
-0.1407240331172943,
-0.8719770312309265,
0.3401637673377991,
0.006702576298266649,
-0.029322154819965363,
-0.3374275863170624,
-0.6500808000564575,
-0.8411723971366882,
0.7166311740875244,
0.18398340046405792,
-0.35200589895248413,
-0.1575288474559784,
0.37263575196266174,
0.6400518417358398,
-0.4335385859012604,
-0.1584434062242508,
0.5914192199707031,
0.00554884085431695,
-0.041586291044950485,
-0.9541106224060059,
-0.22755800187587738,
-0.1098427101969719,
0.1283009648323059,
0.02239609695971012,
-0.3093138337135315,
0.7642728686332703,
-0.25241902470588684,
-0.5157378911972046,
-0.033189963549375534,
0.47914576530456543,
0.23618796467781067,
0.37658417224884033,
0.6532687544822693,
0.6718928217887878,
0.5743371844291687,
-0.18727155029773712,
1.0499110221862793,
-0.31132304668426514,
0.41110843420028687,
1.303051233291626,
0.05925758555531502,
0.9789227247238159,
0.5034171938896179,
-0.40629830956459045,
0.4526849091053009,
0.439007431268692,
0.5322137475013733,
0.5663041472434998,
0.12984266877174377,
-0.2976364493370056,
-0.2873467803001404,
0.10603131353855133,
-0.08476067334413528,
0.4412161111831665,
0.35509157180786133,
-0.43404415249824524,
-0.2866100072860718,
-0.05122898519039154,
0.027573736384510994,
0.4097685217857361,
-0.29211583733558655,
0.9474438428878784,
0.27629247307777405,
-0.5588747262954712,
0.7130783796310425,
-0.34455034136772156,
0.7189041376113892,
-0.8489109873771667,
0.1146460548043251,
-0.2262614369392395,
0.07194558531045914,
-0.2896045744419098,
-0.681522786617279,
0.0730617344379425,
0.2594132721424103,
-0.3199573755264282,
-0.05383279174566269,
0.992906391620636,
-0.5203419923782349,
-0.7701084017753601,
0.11239949613809586,
0.9185442328453064,
0.056204162538051605,
0.28023669123649597,
-0.4694000482559204,
0.04618626460433006,
0.0266480203717947,
-0.27901098132133484,
0.4526852071285248,
0.2491723746061325,
0.3270834684371948,
0.9014491438865662,
0.4793269634246826,
0.26723289489746094,
0.5560050010681152,
0.09650064259767532,
0.8462564945220947,
-0.3620918393135071,
-0.06859183311462402,
-0.5934648513793945,
0.6169618964195251,
0.3001447021961212,
-0.606981635093689,
0.6570484042167664,
0.1907021850347519,
1.1585607528686523,
-0.16845422983169556,
1.009253740310669,
0.09381429851055145,
0.7907898426055908,
-0.3384367823600769,
0.5912056565284729,
-0.3868117034435272,
0.33431315422058105,
-0.1225847601890564,
-0.7224171161651611,
-0.19357259571552277,
0.6728400588035583,
-0.07763104140758514,
0.3238740563392639,
0.7092487812042236,
0.7546260952949524,
-0.15429070591926575,
0.027497680857777596,
0.5376319885253906,
-0.051081541925668716,
-0.12154452502727509,
0.58127361536026,
0.8911734819412231,
-0.19744069874286652,
0.436901330947876,
-0.5329751968383789,
0.06370706856250763,
0.4245561361312866,
-0.48566415905952454,
-0.9839012026786804,
-0.4497416019439697,
-0.1542673110961914,
-0.3237937390804291,
0.15714408457279205,
0.793270468711853,
0.7170788645744324,
-0.9936307072639465,
-0.26927638053894043,
-0.2254970818758011,
0.09424123913049698,
-0.16795673966407776,
-0.18347670137882233,
0.18782781064510345,
-0.6132094264030457,
-0.6311331987380981,
0.6713414192199707,
-0.036535657942295074,
-0.17083075642585754,
-0.46938756108283997,
0.03389118239283562,
-0.1654374897480011,
0.11529923975467682,
0.4827980101108551,
0.5044429302215576,
-0.6904445886611938,
-0.4805990755558014,
-0.09523411840200424,
-0.4416346848011017,
0.0129257095977664,
0.6101630926132202,
-0.7738339304924011,
0.7095807194709778,
0.2517349123954773,
0.7952145934104919,
0.1687750667333603,
-0.034280404448509216,
0.38528892397880554,
-0.8182339072227478,
0.0025103376246988773,
0.22280248999595642,
0.2624688446521759,
0.3795107305049896,
0.1932004988193512,
0.43582940101623535,
0.2766939699649811,
-0.3247620761394501,
-0.6409581303596497,
0.4081178903579712,
-0.7871047258377075,
-0.2212897688150406,
1.1501866579055786,
-0.3278784155845642,
-0.14145176112651825,
-0.2533700466156006,
0.0593755766749382,
0.16219839453697205,
-0.16814769804477692,
0.45952168107032776,
0.8053029179573059,
0.02845940925180912,
-0.07993040233850479,
-0.38573145866394043,
0.20314249396324158,
0.630495011806488,
-0.597703218460083,
-0.20521409809589386,
0.06599194556474686,
0.3823520541191101,
0.14394329488277435,
0.4389151334762573,
-0.07354982942342758,
0.23083330690860748,
0.5311482548713684,
-0.052439235150814056,
0.15560387074947357,
-0.47775205969810486,
-0.7238781452178955,
0.38253194093704224,
0.43014663457870483,
-0.26138338446617126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07896v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07896v2 | Suppressing Pink Elephants with Direct Principle Feedback | 2024-02-12T18:57:46 | 2024-02-13T18:44:11 | Louis Castricato, Nathan Lile, Suraj Anand, Hailey Schoelkopf, Siddharth Verma, Stella Biderman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing methods for controlling language models, such as RLHF and
Constitutional AI, involve determining which LLM behaviors are desirable and
training them into a language model. However, in many cases, it is desirable
for LLMs to be controllable at inference time, so that they can be used in
multiple contexts with diverse needs. We illustrate this with the Pink Elephant
Problem: instructing an LLM to avoid discussing a certain entity (a ``Pink
Elephant''), and instead discuss a preferred entity (``Grey Elephant''). We
apply a novel simplification of Constitutional AI, Direct Principle Feedback,
which skips the ranking of responses and uses DPO directly on critiques and
revisions. Our results show that after DPF fine-tuning on our synthetic Pink
Elephants dataset, our 13B fine-tuned LLaMA 2 model significantly outperforms
Llama-2-13B-Chat and a prompted baseline, and performs as well as GPT-4 in on
our curated test set assessing the Pink Elephant Problem. | [
-0.5866471529006958,
-1.0539815425872803,
0.3002500534057617,
0.5625821352005005,
-0.3820509612560272,
0.03452562913298607,
-0.46314865350723267,
-0.46818581223487854,
-0.006003093905746937,
0.6753875613212585,
-0.6018070578575134,
-0.4105164110660553,
-0.6828919649124146,
0.29350581765174866,
-0.3986530601978302,
0.8003053069114685,
-0.03263644129037857,
0.010655504651367664,
0.24701598286628723,
-0.019063083454966545,
-0.4784089922904968,
-0.40809154510498047,
-0.764659583568573,
-0.6323388814926147,
0.5395640134811401,
0.38978683948516846,
0.719571590423584,
0.7569230198860168,
0.5110531449317932,
0.22760139405727386,
-0.5121263861656189,
0.26870352029800415,
-0.6725464463233948,
-0.09821872413158417,
0.049644410610198975,
-0.7813125252723694,
-0.32489147782325745,
0.16477930545806885,
0.6789689064025879,
0.5363708734512329,
-0.5347976684570312,
-0.40914514660835266,
0.3658706247806549,
0.6850074529647827,
-0.5262489318847656,
0.3254249393939972,
-0.807929277420044,
0.19335293769836426,
0.21704410016536713,
0.012184882536530495,
-0.47785744071006775,
-0.30346107482910156,
0.097616046667099,
-0.7416766285896301,
0.03693469986319542,
0.01521539967507124,
0.9628062844276428,
0.6422699093818665,
-0.3351054787635803,
-0.2363157719373703,
-0.8932693004608154,
0.8460069894790649,
-0.464665025472641,
0.05612686648964882,
0.869665265083313,
-0.11678700894117355,
-0.261007159948349,
-0.34511885046958923,
-0.7848851680755615,
-0.6676917672157288,
-0.2912091314792633,
-0.014512551948428154,
-0.13299855589866638,
0.28957030177116394,
0.1990886926651001,
0.06358834356069565,
-0.024724768474698067,
0.3815633952617645,
-0.30520370602607727,
-0.11553001403808594,
0.5371416211128235,
-0.12088409066200256,
0.060194581747055054,
-0.0528908371925354,
-0.09961538761854172,
0.03959032520651817,
-1.1380900144577026,
-0.1394445300102234,
0.2690921425819397,
0.0744590163230896,
0.047925908118486404,
0.6257537603378296,
-0.27942487597465515,
0.404441773891449,
0.4457385241985321,
0.03889306262135506,
-0.3288361728191376,
-0.09148887544870377,
-0.14872361719608307,
-0.10709446668624878,
0.5914561152458191,
0.2890956401824951,
0.2920832633972168,
-0.09054362773895264,
-0.5893043279647827,
0.3078784942626953,
0.11329744756221771,
-0.7590512037277222,
-0.15421457588672638,
0.1325836032629013,
-0.48813873529434204,
-0.3646954298019409,
-0.33062469959259033,
-0.6451377868652344,
-0.5312764644622803,
-0.6337929368019104,
0.3223452866077423,
-0.19352734088897705,
-0.28856053948402405,
-0.09684087336063385,
0.12489035725593567,
0.3392900824546814,
0.5663345456123352,
-0.890891969203949,
0.4462350606918335,
0.8753963112831116,
0.6588836908340454,
-0.20120584964752197,
-0.1274804025888443,
-0.4274217188358307,
0.33320319652557373,
-0.6327093243598938,
0.603166937828064,
-0.8652716279029846,
-0.9528477191925049,
0.0030098604038357735,
-0.18486690521240234,
0.06382197141647339,
-0.8982434868812561,
0.3673557639122009,
-0.35466137528419495,
0.11405357718467712,
-0.2958279848098755,
-0.46290603280067444,
-0.2949187159538269,
0.2367803305387497,
-0.3842599391937256,
0.4603816866874695,
-0.5574300289154053,
-0.600771963596344,
0.43862566351890564,
-0.583403468132019,
-0.38292762637138367,
-0.393901526927948,
-0.4272986054420471,
-0.4029325246810913,
-0.1301008015871048,
0.40381476283073425,
0.2623113691806793,
-0.06555167585611343,
0.217573881149292,
-0.5896795392036438,
-0.5157485008239746,
-0.06458718329668045,
-0.08807367086410522,
0.40652742981910706,
0.28122609853744507,
-0.5182101726531982,
0.2928975522518158,
-0.9455293416976929,
-0.32384613156318665,
0.15898607671260834,
-0.5628759860992432,
-0.27498504519462585,
0.2747245132923126,
-0.5128161311149597,
-0.08000217378139496,
-0.003432940924540162,
-0.2188834846019745,
0.22986628115177155,
-0.15289388597011566,
0.6375201940536499,
1.0718656778335571,
0.04414064437150955,
0.6695281863212585,
-0.671259880065918,
0.3928529620170593,
0.017930058762431145,
-0.09187055379152298,
0.20702315866947174,
-0.42041948437690735,
-1.2721384763717651,
-0.5400810837745667,
0.17713582515716553,
0.6944696307182312,
-0.4267212152481079,
0.40118229389190674,
0.10732552409172058,
-0.45196086168289185,
-0.4350399374961853,
0.28266093134880066,
0.32099029421806335,
0.3182831406593323,
0.24527432024478912,
-0.17366991937160492,
-0.24169421195983887,
-0.9401950836181641,
-0.10880732536315918,
-0.24828223884105682,
0.05571715533733368,
0.36007776856422424,
0.21560440957546234,
-0.07107383012771606,
0.7304700613021851,
-0.07398229092359543,
-0.36004069447517395,
-0.3497537076473236,
0.36545947194099426,
0.14892806112766266,
0.7160152792930603,
0.4207232594490051,
-0.6140890717506409,
-0.10441796481609344,
-0.17431436479091644,
-0.4060526192188263,
-0.2916393280029297,
-0.1135265901684761,
0.008716695941984653,
0.0945729911327362,
0.3977993130683899,
-0.763055682182312,
0.6275886297225952,
0.16843611001968384,
-0.09929265081882477,
0.10140129178762436,
-0.23715989291667938,
-0.006483414676040411,
-0.538814127445221,
-0.040630072355270386,
-0.18010380864143372,
0.029491767287254333,
-0.38768649101257324,
-0.17430157959461212,
0.08019646257162094,
-0.0425528846681118,
-0.1783454567193985,
0.5238652229309082,
-0.42615199089050293,
0.2552844285964966,
-0.3647351861000061,
-0.08780021220445633,
-0.28553009033203125,
0.6347758769989014,
0.36959001421928406,
0.6813515424728394,
0.3612942099571228,
-1.26531183719635,
-0.018836041912436485,
0.559862494468689,
-0.07023987174034119,
0.45279476046562195,
-0.8679478168487549,
0.35081830620765686,
-0.23036527633666992,
0.37576043605804443,
-0.8475233912467957,
0.05483531579375267,
0.42481693625450134,
-0.08868592977523804,
0.6533275842666626,
-0.11412811279296875,
-0.18911348283290863,
-0.11303746700286865,
-0.4275352358818054,
-0.20018251240253448,
0.6070860028266907,
-0.29472342133522034,
0.3036242425441742,
0.4029620289802551,
-0.37195494771003723,
-0.752223789691925,
-0.8335956931114197,
0.0455329567193985,
-0.31489479541778564,
-0.12362480908632278,
0.22108298540115356,
-0.13192789256572723,
-0.41534507274627686,
-0.07016663253307343,
-0.0881863459944725,
-0.12581296265125275,
0.30191317200660706,
0.25295835733413696,
0.03625820204615593,
0.06071433797478676,
0.19870427250862122,
0.15104489028453827,
-0.030265534296631813,
0.028886891901493073,
0.3098656237125397,
0.4408596158027649,
0.2428138256072998,
-0.4899280071258545,
-0.8363553285598755,
0.24330243468284607,
0.49200066924095154,
-0.31338414549827576,
0.41823258996009827,
0.21587324142456055,
-0.17620757222175598,
-0.3185873031616211,
-0.4849037826061249,
-0.7006623148918152,
-0.47375771403312683,
0.2580192983150482,
-0.3324487805366516,
-0.9846556782722473,
0.33226320147514343,
-0.043713197112083435,
0.3779143691062927,
0.13215722143650055,
0.7159315943717957,
0.1721278578042984,
1.1259516477584839,
0.7599430084228516,
-0.23641793429851532,
0.7596790790557861,
-0.17699024081230164,
0.159030944108963,
-0.666924774646759,
-0.04928254336118698,
-0.7441015839576721,
-0.3624001443386078,
-0.8247172832489014,
-0.01711045764386654,
0.09908905625343323,
0.3690016269683838,
-0.3282123804092407,
-0.0003671207814477384,
-0.5497939586639404,
0.4488232135772705,
0.7840218544006348,
0.3736668527126312,
0.3089885711669922,
-0.046204760670661926,
-0.2889080345630646,
-0.05959712713956833,
-0.5462065935134888,
-0.6995992064476013,
1.1665791273117065,
0.4077605903148651,
1.0161848068237305,
0.10725399106740952,
0.7847259640693665,
0.28288063406944275,
0.4588295519351959,
-0.6818810701370239,
0.7738346457481384,
0.0664641261100769,
-0.3866932988166809,
-0.20504310727119446,
-0.3497573137283325,
-0.8210418224334717,
0.5711643695831299,
-0.1502406895160675,
-0.5223817825317383,
0.17120207846164703,
0.2836228311061859,
-0.470149427652359,
0.10440608859062195,
-0.6003623008728027,
0.32616958022117615,
0.051069311797618866,
-0.45555558800697327,
-0.8540548086166382,
-0.3401053249835968,
0.47817233204841614,
-0.17116141319274902,
0.09441198408603668,
-0.4874063730239868,
-0.20762866735458374,
0.6695407629013062,
-0.5328801274299622,
1.1428122520446777,
-0.11365731060504913,
-0.18510231375694275,
0.384050577878952,
0.2946653366088867,
0.6306909322738647,
0.2653311491012573,
-0.04119919240474701,
-0.012298214249312878,
-0.1346615105867386,
-0.27491605281829834,
-0.29723259806632996,
0.7270127534866333,
-1.0861936807632446,
-1.267572045326233,
-0.2324383556842804,
-0.2377314418554306,
-0.3285377025604248,
0.10927383601665497,
0.05502326041460037,
-0.0893857479095459,
-0.015813490375876427,
0.20727922022342682,
0.48330557346343994,
-0.2247060239315033,
0.548048734664917,
0.7179950475692749,
-0.22708888351917267,
-0.3614967465400696,
0.5445569157600403,
0.19869683682918549,
0.23226971924304962,
0.447806179523468,
0.39681634306907654,
-0.44571125507354736,
-0.6037691831588745,
-0.117939293384552,
0.4033353328704834,
-0.6183432936668396,
0.025927618145942688,
-0.6150250434875488,
0.008781478740274906,
-0.26015228033065796,
0.12773504853248596,
-0.10892415046691895,
-0.5949851274490356,
-0.62310791015625,
-0.05662098526954651,
0.299329549074173,
1.1246693134307861,
-0.50050288438797,
0.3026903569698334,
-0.5718657374382019,
0.4592271149158478,
0.7376816272735596,
0.2069341540336609,
-0.1288069635629654,
-0.6255592107772827,
0.6740614771842957,
0.10863495618104935,
-0.7219598293304443,
-0.825340211391449,
0.10435816645622253,
0.4192848801612854,
0.5779295563697815,
0.5116422772407532,
0.3095165193080902,
0.6951736807823181,
-0.5611003041267395,
0.684928834438324,
-0.04501862823963165,
-1.035496711730957,
0.8366940021514893,
-0.1916094422340393,
-0.09252788871526718,
0.05116924270987511,
0.21636681258678436,
-0.25956302881240845,
-0.7800818681716919,
-0.31680116057395935,
-0.451008141040802,
0.7935572862625122,
0.32140031456947327,
0.3364183306694031,
-0.04090406745672226,
0.5695388913154602,
-0.22789031267166138,
0.46261805295944214,
-0.725559413433075,
0.008656306192278862,
0.07551132142543793,
0.16851358115673065,
0.037660203874111176,
-0.6108313798904419,
-0.49237820506095886,
-0.2921377420425415,
0.6811073422431946,
0.09193897992372513,
0.08825447410345078,
0.3592177629470825,
0.05456886813044548,
-0.4004291594028473,
0.27976271510124207,
0.9404993653297424,
0.7359532713890076,
-0.06525106728076935,
0.035697709769010544,
0.2549099922180176,
-0.3091147243976593,
0.2272299826145172,
-0.004983191844075918,
-0.49128004908561707,
-0.029237041249871254,
0.27883589267730713,
0.5907782912254333,
0.05200923979282379,
-0.27413108944892883,
0.13813170790672302,
-0.1389315128326416,
-0.17850033938884735,
0.09433583170175552,
0.2217235267162323,
-0.07384102791547775,
0.0974125787615776,
0.03873227536678314,
-0.05300543084740639,
-0.15191833674907684,
-0.2733645737171173,
0.2824140191078186,
0.4595617651939392,
-0.4028324484825134,
-0.2564697265625,
0.731316864490509,
0.5230783224105835,
-0.20213830471038818,
0.4229440987110138,
0.06809071451425552,
-0.5279845595359802,
0.810255765914917,
0.3632616102695465,
0.6385675668716431,
-0.27539926767349243,
-0.006435154937207699,
0.27741071581840515,
0.6605536341667175,
-0.09460747987031937,
0.2198132574558258,
-0.30851927399635315,
-0.7559957504272461,
-0.33387649059295654,
-0.43178632855415344,
-0.8263132572174072,
0.31992989778518677,
-0.6011118292808533,
0.44374531507492065,
-1.0089161396026611,
-0.13387586176395416,
-0.1807999312877655,
0.12431880831718445,
-0.3701835870742798,
-0.15589183568954468,
0.03933602571487427,
0.7753015160560608,
-0.3407059609889984,
0.9498150944709778,
0.47089409828186035,
-0.39101913571357727,
-0.7495397329330444,
-0.038945578038692474,
0.231123149394989,
-1.1326814889907837,
0.5992268323898315,
0.17420697212219238,
-0.03724296763539314,
-0.11669345200061798,
-0.7316314578056335,
-0.4564095139503479,
0.7748909592628479,
0.5372429490089417,
-0.9723160266876221,
0.3348565101623535,
-0.018548594787716866,
0.32003891468048096,
0.02359512634575367,
0.02815508097410202,
0.6413081288337708,
0.6515069007873535,
0.15257509052753448,
-1.2722777128219604,
-0.1926729530096054,
0.12104575335979462,
-0.05051484704017639,
-0.009796209633350372,
-0.9727093577384949,
0.7384398579597473,
-0.37982916831970215,
-0.1732281893491745,
0.187326580286026,
0.6660997271537781,
0.2601129710674286,
-0.08317773044109344,
0.6850048303604126,
0.5671850442886353,
0.7948697805404663,
-0.16665664315223694,
0.989911675453186,
-0.3485460579395294,
0.3799743354320526,
1.0704164505004883,
-0.6085256934165955,
0.872050940990448,
0.5737653374671936,
-0.17906340956687927,
-0.12341159582138062,
0.831677258014679,
0.3297858238220215,
0.8557935357093811,
0.6538777947425842,
-0.18718385696411133,
-0.29969415068626404,
-0.22770392894744873,
-0.5202098488807678,
0.40869489312171936,
0.4246138036251068,
-0.02540244348347187,
-0.14921993017196655,
-0.33890536427497864,
0.34590116143226624,
0.11864364892244339,
-0.35516637563705444,
0.9980677962303162,
0.17614386975765228,
-0.7140841484069824,
0.8295629620552063,
-0.1810237169265747,
0.6805395483970642,
-0.6972917914390564,
-0.3214048445224762,
-0.7199755907058716,
0.4265477955341339,
0.10278381407260895,
-0.495831161737442,
0.3042709231376648,
-0.014098281040787697,
0.0290762260556221,
-0.24515153467655182,
0.44004398584365845,
-0.5858867168426514,
-0.18653714656829834,
0.32548484206199646,
0.3418864905834198,
-0.22078794240951538,
0.08250612020492554,
-0.737603485584259,
0.11557459831237793,
-0.04217255115509033,
-0.5698201656341553,
0.1510196179151535,
0.5246314406394958,
-0.05706905201077461,
1.0721402168273926,
0.6099877953529358,
0.357685387134552,
-0.015103715471923351,
-0.1929245889186859,
0.8832518458366394,
-0.5179572105407715,
-0.5920482873916626,
-0.8751687407493591,
-0.25434610247612,
0.0758240595459938,
-0.21990686655044556,
0.348317414522171,
-0.0679638683795929,
0.7747373580932617,
0.07130259275436401,
0.6855021119117737,
0.2254604697227478,
0.6696387529373169,
-0.6421142816543579,
0.8883001804351807,
-0.548496425151825,
0.48301517963409424,
0.07096633315086365,
-0.8196752667427063,
-0.358463317155838,
0.8530011177062988,
-0.1623411923646927,
-0.002014729892835021,
0.4734343886375427,
1.0035455226898193,
0.1677868813276291,
-0.005013001151382923,
0.46972453594207764,
0.4838683009147644,
0.5991024971008301,
0.27014076709747314,
1.3082283735275269,
0.2855859398841858,
0.5319061875343323,
-0.4705396294593811,
-0.07745452225208282,
-0.2012712061405182,
-0.8920510411262512,
-0.9013866782188416,
-0.003841293277218938,
-0.3921947479248047,
-0.27721354365348816,
-0.061458770185709,
0.8957495093345642,
0.8795443773269653,
-1.0471538305282593,
-0.23914915323257446,
-0.2645722031593323,
0.4771258533000946,
0.05013369396328926,
-0.13131767511367798,
0.22149771451950073,
-0.5167093276977539,
-0.858380913734436,
0.23349632322788239,
0.290752112865448,
0.24427883327007294,
-0.2455260455608368,
-0.14698359370231628,
-0.0010613732738420367,
0.2266293466091156,
0.2742767632007599,
0.23388239741325378,
-1.1682075262069702,
-0.4295971691608429,
-0.31784918904304504,
-0.19021190702915192,
-0.011914107948541641,
0.7894169688224792,
-0.3807344436645508,
0.2883361279964447,
0.19999709725379944,
0.6757609248161316,
0.17852093279361725,
-0.33137670159339905,
0.707665205001831,
-0.36308541893959045,
0.6937060356140137,
0.3340737521648407,
0.4851134121417999,
0.10639869421720505,
-0.2586861252784729,
0.6272445321083069,
0.3380430340766907,
-0.49054718017578125,
-0.6396859288215637,
0.21240462362766266,
-0.6179604530334473,
-0.05831940099596977,
1.3310796022415161,
-0.21451017260551453,
-0.08283621817827225,
0.11459202319383621,
-0.7194333672523499,
0.09732493758201599,
-0.6237685084342957,
1.0331705808639526,
0.8443732857704163,
-0.09869309514760971,
-0.3378795385360718,
-0.3110477030277252,
0.741847813129425,
0.8233031034469604,
-0.6667854189872742,
-0.02863992750644684,
0.5052860975265503,
0.25952988862991333,
-0.09000487625598907,
0.7368177175521851,
0.10682608187198639,
0.15948304533958435,
-0.2688305377960205,
-0.12556816637516022,
0.14265844225883484,
-0.2823844850063324,
-0.6104159951210022,
0.1320456713438034,
0.436069130897522,
-0.47732359170913696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07891v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07891v3 | Label-Efficient Model Selection for Text Generation | 2024-02-12T18:54:02 | 2024-06-06T11:07:17 | Shir Ashury-Tahan, Ariel Gera, Benjamin Sznajder, Leshem Choshen, Liat Ein-Dor, Eyal Shnarch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Model selection for a given target task can be costly, as it may entail
extensive annotation of the quality of outputs of different models. We
introduce DiffUse, an efficient method to make an informed decision between
candidate text generation models based on preference annotations. DiffUse
reduces the required amount of annotations, thus saving valuable time and
resources in performing evaluation. DiffUse intelligently selects instances by
clustering embeddings that represent the semantic differences between model
outputs. Thus, it is able to identify a subset of examples that are more
informative for preference decisions. Our method is model-agnostic, and can be
applied to any text generation model for selecting between models, prompts and
configurations. Moreover, we propose a practical iterative approach for
dynamically determining how many instances to annotate. In a series of
experiments over hundreds of model pairs, we demonstrate that DiffUse can
dramatically reduce the required number of annotations -- by up to 75% -- while
maintaining high evaluation reliability. | [
-0.36452749371528625,
-0.7549515962600708,
0.8635462522506714,
0.38061684370040894,
-0.2394295632839203,
-0.1534920483827591,
-0.17109628021717072,
-0.3741801083087921,
-0.18743175268173218,
0.3293493092060089,
-0.27396315336227417,
-0.3069595694541931,
-0.728152871131897,
-0.08174915611743927,
-0.6058295965194702,
1.0495152473449707,
-0.013077805750072002,
-0.32596251368522644,
-0.5860952734947205,
-0.09014413505792618,
-0.1835717409849167,
-0.23591291904449463,
-0.7565715312957764,
-0.5512104630470276,
0.6084773540496826,
0.010333534330129623,
0.5016335248947144,
0.5593046545982361,
0.3493194878101349,
0.28043240308761597,
-0.4537205100059509,
0.4170514941215515,
-0.4359143078327179,
0.4117377996444702,
-0.099977508187294,
-0.09892276674509048,
-0.16567407548427582,
0.0773552805185318,
0.5369873046875,
0.6174913644790649,
0.1716991513967514,
0.42531102895736694,
-0.02524440363049507,
0.7232400178909302,
-1.029815912246704,
-0.22657643258571625,
-0.6582987904548645,
0.08767746388912201,
-0.14957629144191742,
0.11825508624315262,
-0.8586131930351257,
-0.46184223890304565,
0.2856251895427704,
-0.8675829172134399,
0.2135808914899826,
-0.0672840029001236,
0.7041245102882385,
0.2405155897140503,
-0.5148270130157471,
-0.19623415172100067,
-0.98500657081604,
0.9067436456680298,
-0.34781041741371155,
0.14888517558574677,
0.47487103939056396,
0.057788752019405365,
0.24269087612628937,
-0.7895753979682922,
-0.2485610395669937,
-0.4783916175365448,
-0.2117014080286026,
0.2969798445701599,
-0.17442816495895386,
0.03858814015984535,
0.27874138951301575,
0.2755127549171448,
-0.2689700722694397,
-0.04834989458322525,
-0.1805613487958908,
-0.1266084909439087,
0.6646525859832764,
-0.25429245829582214,
0.06340785324573517,
-0.09395486861467361,
-0.4059772789478302,
-0.017892438918352127,
-0.5009444952011108,
-0.34041649103164673,
0.3708059787750244,
0.06637419760227203,
0.22422747313976288,
0.4847427010536194,
-0.06452042609453201,
1.0375703573226929,
0.18361063301563263,
-0.14681491255760193,
0.21482793986797333,
-0.2926294803619385,
-0.25465482473373413,
-0.10171132534742355,
0.7944344282150269,
0.21256601810455322,
0.03864579647779465,
-0.18176555633544922,
-0.24758148193359375,
0.17837148904800415,
0.2955019772052765,
-1.029672384262085,
-0.2365342080593109,
0.15984219312667847,
-0.6437000632286072,
-0.6992740631103516,
-0.19406016170978546,
-0.44522377848625183,
-0.46582090854644775,
-0.12826521694660187,
0.3817339837551117,
-0.33593395352363586,
-0.2909437119960785,
-0.26854681968688965,
-0.6197662353515625,
-0.46351611614227295,
0.4826449155807495,
-0.8475775122642517,
-0.07982839643955231,
0.37497416138648987,
1.0078457593917847,
-0.2998102307319641,
0.16675928235054016,
-0.43722110986709595,
0.5491828918457031,
-0.38402536511421204,
1.0472166538238525,
-0.9765878319740295,
-0.872160792350769,
-0.13651496171951294,
-0.5407964587211609,
0.05305370315909386,
-0.5525391101837158,
0.5086668133735657,
-0.4979587197303772,
0.1823185235261917,
-0.18834418058395386,
-0.8641756176948547,
-0.2864006459712982,
-0.11387455463409424,
-0.9917049407958984,
1.308559775352478,
0.4772462844848633,
-0.8343942761421204,
0.7108767032623291,
-0.7922548651695251,
-0.4424637258052826,
0.031266726553440094,
-0.14070141315460205,
-0.5493901371955872,
0.2321607768535614,
0.03785942867398262,
0.672599732875824,
-0.29046162962913513,
0.36354342103004456,
-0.36143580079078674,
0.03811727091670036,
-0.03189690783619881,
-0.35717451572418213,
0.47402575612068176,
0.4759986996650696,
-0.35965314507484436,
0.20073427259922028,
-0.9350868463516235,
0.03282786160707474,
-0.07491593807935715,
-0.30144575238227844,
-0.7492985129356384,
0.14477761089801788,
0.29810038208961487,
0.012129483744502068,
0.15325462818145752,
-0.3576606810092926,
0.3139623701572418,
-0.06409016251564026,
0.32987159490585327,
0.762869656085968,
0.22100801765918732,
0.9709230065345764,
-0.25657665729522705,
0.4425460994243622,
-0.05418180301785469,
0.2200022041797638,
-0.053888361901044846,
-0.7105655670166016,
-0.843601405620575,
-0.5556198954582214,
0.6462001204490662,
0.26428741216659546,
-0.6131967306137085,
0.4156312942504883,
0.18999260663986206,
-0.8012049198150635,
-0.44171464443206787,
0.14100433886051178,
0.2795172333717346,
0.5049671530723572,
0.32184696197509766,
0.18164929747581482,
-0.17294295132160187,
-1.0368857383728027,
-0.23888634145259857,
-0.12992411851882935,
0.20166124403476715,
0.42072927951812744,
0.2878475785255432,
-0.258152574300766,
1.1039501428604126,
-0.7381203770637512,
0.11788028478622437,
-0.3807591199874878,
0.3485269546508789,
-0.2395235300064087,
0.365551233291626,
0.9005553722381592,
-1.0794992446899414,
-0.7092030048370361,
0.21995817124843597,
-0.5645912289619446,
-0.34412774443626404,
-0.5739299058914185,
-0.6539604663848877,
0.11352811008691788,
0.45008617639541626,
-0.43753424286842346,
0.5747623443603516,
0.5444636344909668,
-0.31772708892822266,
0.24638676643371582,
-0.32146671414375305,
-0.005906782578676939,
-0.8647340536117554,
0.24445876479148865,
0.17204633355140686,
-0.3253660202026367,
-0.656918466091156,
-0.26787081360816956,
0.1442364752292633,
0.23323076963424683,
-0.1674806773662567,
1.0221396684646606,
-0.5721597075462341,
0.27475669980049133,
-0.23131762444972992,
0.20552095770835876,
0.2667725682258606,
-0.059598859399557114,
0.23860132694244385,
0.5458317399024963,
0.364949107170105,
-0.8506804704666138,
-0.07069175690412521,
0.23123668134212494,
-0.4057961106300354,
0.32780352234840393,
-0.5037364959716797,
0.11939476430416107,
-0.20167438685894012,
0.268840491771698,
-0.7538465857505798,
0.026281112805008888,
0.1230778843164444,
-0.0755707174539566,
0.15879052877426147,
-0.02391982637345791,
-0.3306753933429718,
-0.08022391051054001,
-0.06950083374977112,
0.29719284176826477,
0.4596307575702667,
-0.690542459487915,
0.6504073739051819,
0.16550834476947784,
-0.08362410962581635,
-0.31988486647605896,
-0.46149906516075134,
-0.3318102955818176,
-0.2435634732246399,
-0.4652928411960602,
0.5347432494163513,
-0.26516738533973694,
-0.32101210951805115,
0.09360239654779434,
0.08322619646787643,
-0.16806240379810333,
0.37913453578948975,
0.2891446650028229,
0.16895918548107147,
0.2937926650047302,
0.30446478724479675,
0.705327570438385,
-0.32068243622779846,
-0.37188276648521423,
-0.2660427987575531,
0.09511243551969528,
0.46487048268318176,
-0.16599634289741516,
-0.1596071720123291,
0.6362518668174744,
0.3475245535373688,
-0.2450047731399536,
0.6994560360908508,
0.6068075895309448,
-0.18815456330776215,
-0.7085837721824646,
-0.5242137312889099,
0.11847402155399323,
-0.4752182364463806,
0.2962803244590759,
-0.2801169455051422,
-0.6903864741325378,
0.12156273424625397,
-0.38021814823150635,
0.3624190092086792,
0.6374505162239075,
0.4674743413925171,
0.18661905825138092,
1.0943472385406494,
0.8578612804412842,
0.20211854577064514,
0.7580938935279846,
-0.3075295388698578,
0.11539561301469803,
-0.5972081422805786,
-0.20736484229564667,
-0.5353983640670776,
-0.2303418070077896,
-0.28930941224098206,
-0.48460203409194946,
0.4354077875614166,
0.176739901304245,
-0.12449384480714798,
0.007844299077987671,
-1.097880244255066,
0.5438947081565857,
0.6968094110488892,
0.0518605001270771,
0.3537835478782654,
0.05033671110868454,
-0.09604023396968842,
0.15340949594974518,
-0.6169703006744385,
-0.7164657115936279,
0.998822808265686,
0.013510461896657944,
0.25130781531333923,
0.12035165727138519,
0.807741105556488,
0.4064107835292816,
0.8121536374092102,
-0.5146992802619934,
0.44109949469566345,
-0.27937552332878113,
-0.689780592918396,
-0.20249582827091217,
-0.46798914670944214,
-0.7088983654975891,
0.35957199335098267,
-0.4763226807117462,
-0.5375247001647949,
0.16379234194755554,
0.24819518625736237,
-0.5819924473762512,
0.2614137530326843,
-0.8411622643470764,
0.6883289813995361,
0.06110779941082001,
-0.24242208898067474,
-0.22448046505451202,
-0.1733444333076477,
0.353272944688797,
-0.43855077028274536,
-0.017675036564469337,
-0.22597980499267578,
-0.1349032074213028,
0.7489456534385681,
-0.3832334876060486,
0.49379873275756836,
-0.18747954070568085,
-0.060647834092378616,
0.4139876365661621,
0.08540929108858109,
0.2700040638446808,
0.016239866614341736,
-0.6823908090591431,
-0.08732017874717712,
-0.3484492897987366,
-0.027205176651477814,
-0.6109389066696167,
0.5748801231384277,
-0.5322723388671875,
-0.25508612394332886,
-0.29470589756965637,
-0.36602282524108887,
-0.016172366216778755,
0.2835686504840851,
0.7952089905738831,
0.39471307396888733,
-0.2529882490634918,
-0.044214922934770584,
0.5735493898391724,
-0.27969083189964294,
0.7604901790618896,
-0.004641518462449312,
-0.44792285561561584,
-0.43039318919181824,
0.8757434487342834,
0.22824817895889282,
0.5843485593795776,
0.3518998622894287,
0.3600277304649353,
-0.21944215893745422,
-0.5389361381530762,
-0.6025827527046204,
0.045194853097200394,
-0.6514618992805481,
-0.3237326145172119,
-0.9394525289535522,
-0.12167707830667496,
0.03871415928006172,
-0.6439581513404846,
-0.39448249340057373,
-0.7511775493621826,
-0.6240455508232117,
-0.2564067244529724,
0.6453272700309753,
1.0198476314544678,
-0.019491946324706078,
0.5533772110939026,
-0.613081157207489,
0.394142746925354,
0.42625269293785095,
0.21580533683300018,
0.1590479612350464,
-0.40435510873794556,
-0.07232513278722763,
-0.2906559109687805,
-0.48958852887153625,
-1.0067799091339111,
0.2865294814109802,
0.33587735891342163,
0.4960709810256958,
0.5986786484718323,
0.1248367503285408,
0.4263233542442322,
-0.5826656818389893,
0.7600862979888916,
0.24654258787631989,
-1.1036726236343384,
0.7825634479522705,
-0.2684788107872009,
0.12432471662759781,
0.5944446921348572,
0.4280899167060852,
-0.23027807474136353,
-0.37966036796569824,
-0.8150153160095215,
-1.1101435422897339,
0.4770757555961609,
0.4423714280128479,
-0.04090045019984245,
-0.06350205093622208,
0.5099645853042603,
0.4479336142539978,
0.24266700446605682,
-0.7014886736869812,
-0.5061632394790649,
0.021792657673358917,
-0.03421444818377495,
0.0394357331097126,
-0.44049859046936035,
-0.04141226410865784,
-0.26119929552078247,
0.9263985753059387,
0.09142445772886276,
0.11290039122104645,
0.09299114346504211,
-0.007193635683506727,
0.16123829782009125,
0.06922931969165802,
0.42452317476272583,
0.4669523239135742,
-0.010490025393664837,
0.042073361575603485,
0.03983493149280548,
-0.2931435704231262,
0.337984174489975,
0.04732384905219078,
-0.8614912629127502,
0.5783814191818237,
0.18897829949855804,
1.0499730110168457,
-0.08426184207201004,
-0.20826159417629242,
0.48260703682899475,
0.02594611980021,
-0.22686074674129486,
-0.08645174652338028,
0.1685572862625122,
0.22024676203727722,
0.1687094122171402,
-0.033918771892786026,
0.27078455686569214,
0.5005460977554321,
-0.034505657851696014,
-0.011126928962767124,
0.35107266902923584,
-0.2952629625797272,
0.12000586837530136,
0.8763899803161621,
0.5701770186424255,
-0.10579492151737213,
0.30614396929740906,
-0.5381836295127869,
-0.22823308408260345,
0.654340386390686,
0.3869892656803131,
1.1594316959381104,
-0.2953020930290222,
0.7005221247673035,
0.45220091938972473,
0.09552799165248871,
-0.34313350915908813,
-0.13206955790519714,
-0.17693586647510529,
-0.5453218221664429,
-0.2921338379383087,
-0.6667136549949646,
-0.454429566860199,
-0.14738577604293823,
-0.6436707377433777,
0.27499571442604065,
-0.4931466281414032,
-0.5819653868675232,
0.4019418954849243,
-0.3853592574596405,
-0.38899585604667664,
0.21129868924617767,
0.24239571392536163,
0.8790524005889893,
-0.8631042838096619,
0.6390320658683777,
0.6985431909561157,
-0.21116498112678528,
-0.5074736475944519,
-0.13403937220573425,
-0.3117348253726959,
-0.18873101472854614,
0.8363893032073975,
0.29701533913612366,
-0.035326626151800156,
-0.07605031877756119,
-0.4841720461845398,
-0.7765672206878662,
1.0151461362838745,
0.28702470660209656,
-0.5344988107681274,
0.14231528341770172,
-0.3799920976161957,
0.25122031569480896,
-0.428803414106369,
0.7298693656921387,
0.5266984105110168,
0.7537175416946411,
0.09467259049415588,
-0.7168441414833069,
-0.07750704884529114,
-0.21599236130714417,
0.508132815361023,
0.21098153293132782,
-0.7249709367752075,
0.7424774765968323,
-0.26203861832618713,
-0.25132259726524353,
0.17144718766212463,
0.75694739818573,
0.36751073598861694,
0.3181637227535248,
0.7176506519317627,
0.2026563435792923,
1.0559566020965576,
-0.03764709457755089,
0.946062445640564,
-0.15936927497386932,
0.41252753138542175,
1.0165700912475586,
-0.3054935336112976,
0.7222165465354919,
0.27994638681411743,
0.08173486590385437,
0.5263665318489075,
0.6216025948524475,
-0.04054466262459755,
0.6703980565071106,
0.19284796714782715,
-0.7152070999145508,
-0.6040464043617249,
-0.1854163557291031,
-0.3343844413757324,
0.23447053134441376,
0.13526763021945953,
-0.7092820405960083,
-0.14394733309745789,
-0.01135861687362194,
0.15389493107795715,
0.09082334488630295,
-0.1057986244559288,
0.8005332946777344,
-0.11721935868263245,
-0.7432193160057068,
0.21701638400554657,
0.044873420149087906,
0.6520113945007324,
-0.6811097860336304,
-0.1608901470899582,
-0.06340717524290085,
0.08638596534729004,
-0.34544581174850464,
-0.4486805498600006,
0.1523849368095398,
0.15561865270137787,
-0.7354199290275574,
-0.6403926014900208,
0.7921851873397827,
-0.43632635474205017,
-0.7573557496070862,
0.3346611261367798,
0.3334318697452545,
-0.11298831552267075,
-0.21676580607891083,
-0.5342209935188293,
0.10184972733259201,
0.26667848229408264,
-0.6506072282791138,
0.06886979192495346,
0.3552180528640747,
-0.10973192751407623,
0.5706955194473267,
0.587166428565979,
0.14252513647079468,
-0.10674497485160828,
0.08272313326597214,
0.830773651599884,
-0.4203234314918518,
-0.47749850153923035,
-0.8308571577072144,
0.7070854902267456,
-0.5755748152732849,
-0.4224243462085724,
0.6127820014953613,
0.6409143209457397,
0.5145009160041809,
-0.030237432569265366,
1.4415910243988037,
-0.035557087510824203,
0.5547768473625183,
-0.42431357502937317,
0.8694977164268494,
-0.49296918511390686,
0.24184595048427582,
-0.5080987811088562,
-1.1620404720306396,
-0.2639653980731964,
1.017127275466919,
-0.3814751207828522,
0.34075823426246643,
0.645290732383728,
0.48920631408691406,
0.05749236419796944,
0.04382126405835152,
0.25078555941581726,
-0.0569227933883667,
0.45460525155067444,
0.2335825115442276,
0.9109818935394287,
-0.17451626062393188,
0.22680534422397614,
-0.33189070224761963,
-0.5535939335823059,
0.03462274372577667,
-1.2628018856048584,
-0.886112630367279,
-0.5326208472251892,
-0.6955628991127014,
-0.21301978826522827,
-0.23028011620044708,
0.7495045065879822,
0.9027640223503113,
-0.45048752427101135,
0.06037447974085808,
-0.033081479370594025,
0.17583812773227692,
-0.10756722837686539,
-0.16389192640781403,
0.3798900544643402,
-0.35705122351646423,
-0.8445778489112854,
0.2564403712749481,
0.2828282415866852,
0.022990085184574127,
-0.1348874866962433,
0.22547465562820435,
-0.11403637379407883,
0.2741473317146301,
0.7752183079719543,
-0.14025390148162842,
-0.4587920904159546,
-0.08727225661277771,
-0.37417855858802795,
-0.004882314242422581,
-0.3407098352909088,
0.6492280960083008,
-0.7629061937332153,
0.5421349406242371,
0.4540245532989502,
0.4504269063472748,
0.6427740454673767,
-0.0004394278221298009,
0.4804176688194275,
-0.7210435271263123,
0.30139535665512085,
0.1677737832069397,
0.026559287682175636,
0.36363187432289124,
-0.5117372870445251,
0.6174455285072327,
0.1802828311920166,
-0.58330237865448,
-0.7330634593963623,
0.24212706089019775,
-0.9880615472793579,
-0.5580109357833862,
1.7512831687927246,
-0.00339226215146482,
0.03472055122256279,
0.09085486084222794,
-0.43233150243759155,
0.02866094931960106,
-0.5252941846847534,
0.5269380807876587,
0.5828443169593811,
-0.31255272030830383,
0.2659290134906769,
-0.4708422124385834,
0.8437113761901855,
0.3608611822128296,
-0.8839552402496338,
0.17465642094612122,
0.6591783165931702,
0.05691732466220856,
0.3004128634929657,
0.7257474660873413,
0.27645134925842285,
0.05272040143609047,
0.08466467261314392,
0.17040014266967773,
0.022201593965291977,
-0.3279061019420624,
0.00434859050437808,
0.2623213529586792,
0.11675289273262024,
-0.059669800102710724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07876v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07876v4 | Policy Improvement using Language Feedback Models | 2024-02-12T18:41:34 | 2024-04-18T20:35:32 | Victor Zhong, Dipendra Misra, Xingdi Yuan, Marc-Alexandre Côté | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce Language Feedback Models (LFMs) that identify desirable
behaviour - actions that help achieve tasks specified in the instruction - for
imitation learning in instruction following. To train LFMs, we obtain feedback
from Large Language Models (LLMs) on visual trajectories verbalized to language
descriptions. First, by using LFMs to identify desirable behaviour to imitate,
we improve in task-completion rate over strong behavioural cloning baselines on
three distinct language grounding environments (Touchdown, ScienceWorld, and
ALFWorld). Second, LFMs outperform using LLMs as experts to directly predict
actions, when controlling for the number of LLM output tokens. Third, LFMs
generalize to unseen environments, improving task-completion rate by 3.5-12.0%
through one round of adaptation. Finally, LFM can be modified to provide
human-interpretable feedback without performance loss, allowing human
verification of desirable behaviour for imitation learning. | [
-0.10539287328720093,
-0.8554326295852661,
0.5485225319862366,
0.3348979949951172,
0.23007163405418396,
0.23793330788612366,
-0.3173410892486572,
-0.40764176845550537,
0.1943722665309906,
0.6844233870506287,
-0.727220892906189,
-0.2563733160495758,
-0.503826916217804,
-0.12064265459775925,
-0.3656390309333801,
0.8573310375213623,
-0.21113313734531403,
0.23650290071964264,
-0.18021012842655182,
0.20180244743824005,
-0.5329242944717407,
-0.5344203114509583,
-0.7464572787284851,
-0.7671158909797668,
0.4520227611064911,
0.4859556555747986,
0.6385809183120728,
0.5174892544746399,
0.38036710023880005,
0.33354395627975464,
-0.10286898910999298,
0.3972072899341583,
-0.6436281204223633,
-0.24699510633945465,
-0.3052484393119812,
-0.338030606508255,
-0.39618897438049316,
0.09896279871463776,
0.7261440753936768,
0.6487351059913635,
-0.39951619505882263,
-0.19404920935630798,
0.5025500655174255,
0.5929007530212402,
-0.421138733625412,
0.6377158761024475,
-0.09174803644418716,
0.15399478375911713,
0.5090080499649048,
-0.20480337738990784,
-0.4672746956348419,
-0.4330034554004669,
0.07743518799543381,
-0.5786848068237305,
-0.10127907991409302,
0.0003522509359754622,
0.6573585271835327,
0.0009059756412170827,
-0.11787919700145721,
-0.4243416488170624,
-0.8303514719009399,
0.8400970101356506,
-0.8505946397781372,
0.41790035367012024,
0.6015368700027466,
0.05987279862165451,
-0.5911230444908142,
-0.5971518754959106,
-0.4803027808666229,
-0.6731128096580505,
-0.3288061022758484,
0.0009028232307173312,
0.13080404698848724,
0.3548892140388489,
0.29550325870513916,
0.21610431373119354,
-0.06329300254583359,
0.18351253867149353,
-0.3435742259025574,
-0.33044299483299255,
0.4982689619064331,
0.28114309906959534,
0.10381007194519043,
0.017295723780989647,
-0.0019495072774589062,
-0.41616153717041016,
-0.7270044684410095,
0.6759766936302185,
0.2132239192724228,
0.3734772205352783,
0.04849005863070488,
0.2365425080060959,
-0.5088161826133728,
0.7355471849441528,
0.12664519250392914,
-0.40439000725746155,
0.21771250665187836,
-0.3973933160305023,
-0.07377290725708008,
-0.5074672698974609,
0.4924524426460266,
0.28987884521484375,
0.23204544186592102,
-0.15507520735263824,
-0.5668023228645325,
-0.17592856287956238,
0.4283389151096344,
-0.6011691689491272,
0.05247689038515091,
0.0024032730143517256,
-0.38554611802101135,
-0.38566824793815613,
0.11517437547445297,
-0.7434587478637695,
-0.28509455919265747,
-0.6936581134796143,
0.6852905750274658,
-0.5316276550292969,
-0.4010014832019806,
-0.01302990224212408,
-0.040133241564035416,
0.450516015291214,
0.6068686246871948,
-0.910649836063385,
0.38894468545913696,
0.9132521748542786,
0.6827611327171326,
-0.2839997410774231,
-0.74093097448349,
-0.6640833020210266,
0.08510606735944748,
-0.6209263205528259,
0.6568701267242432,
-0.5858740210533142,
-0.5638806223869324,
0.4155431091785431,
0.25135424733161926,
-0.19173529744148254,
-0.6852646470069885,
0.1717406064271927,
-0.3134857714176178,
0.1694440245628357,
-0.4206656813621521,
-0.5868496894836426,
-0.479936420917511,
0.5990025401115417,
-0.5091132521629333,
1.135986089706421,
0.28787803649902344,
-0.07556413859128952,
0.40265563130378723,
-0.9862461090087891,
-0.4581650495529175,
-0.13952234387397766,
-0.0026427863631397486,
-0.19032210111618042,
0.027224384248256683,
0.2674546539783478,
0.569361686706543,
0.15814247727394104,
0.30824750661849976,
-0.09369266033172607,
-0.6113007068634033,
0.17773225903511047,
-0.3202311098575592,
0.3130677342414856,
-0.021458201110363007,
-0.5131263136863708,
0.49473926424980164,
-0.6354963779449463,
0.29070863127708435,
-0.035867344588041306,
-0.7017456889152527,
-0.1824263036251068,
0.18869991600513458,
-0.1736915558576584,
0.1870584934949875,
0.1763329654932022,
-0.20480749011039734,
0.27854597568511963,
-0.2918933629989624,
0.34609341621398926,
0.8825411796569824,
0.26358094811439514,
0.4721003770828247,
-0.5674702525138855,
0.7663646936416626,
-0.12907187640666962,
0.3825834095478058,
-0.2723488509654999,
-0.1723737120628357,
-0.836938738822937,
-0.14605705440044403,
0.002780854469165206,
0.5166946649551392,
-0.8266693949699402,
0.047050703316926956,
-0.29392653703689575,
-0.2316650003194809,
-0.33349698781967163,
0.2932927906513214,
0.7831030488014221,
0.1912575662136078,
0.08756476640701294,
-0.48597627878189087,
-0.44267913699150085,
-0.5992096066474915,
-0.21367666125297546,
-0.5234833359718323,
0.3268805742263794,
0.3186533749103546,
0.5352016687393188,
-0.13740231096744537,
0.6985242366790771,
-0.03789019212126732,
-0.26290977001190186,
-0.44178658723831177,
0.15193434059619904,
0.17191331088542938,
0.44273996353149414,
0.39331719279289246,
-0.5409038662910461,
-0.43812406063079834,
-0.11888796091079712,
-0.6627147197723389,
-0.056033048778772354,
-0.06298831105232239,
0.08036122471094131,
0.3174251914024353,
0.6391196846961975,
-0.27395498752593994,
0.4240230321884155,
0.5586282014846802,
-0.14936381578445435,
0.5467663407325745,
-0.37116846442222595,
0.44811421632766724,
-0.49428123235702515,
-0.22965581715106964,
-0.25778982043266296,
-0.5195612907409668,
-0.6551541686058044,
0.449208527803421,
-0.09977823495864868,
0.06363308429718018,
-0.6347301602363586,
0.48041942715644836,
-0.4825610816478729,
-0.14930669963359833,
-0.413238525390625,
-0.06471500545740128,
-0.3210127055644989,
0.9615790843963623,
0.21435272693634033,
0.9772573113441467,
0.5666772723197937,
-0.8530768752098083,
0.17721869051456451,
0.01769990101456642,
-0.4694572389125824,
0.3716919422149658,
-0.4709530174732208,
0.07181466370820999,
-0.10847577452659607,
0.21227295696735382,
-0.7262136340141296,
-0.242960587143898,
0.2734227478504181,
-0.12087813764810562,
0.28798049688339233,
0.07851474732160568,
-0.3577476441860199,
-0.5541955828666687,
-0.2959074079990387,
-0.21735137701034546,
0.771339476108551,
-0.5804470777511597,
0.729332447052002,
0.28408586978912354,
0.1286938190460205,
-0.846859872341156,
-0.45410338044166565,
-0.08316463232040405,
0.15657278895378113,
0.006963768973946571,
0.0624028779566288,
-0.07315441966056824,
-0.16780255734920502,
-0.018615655601024628,
0.1173563152551651,
0.061529017984867096,
0.04643800109624863,
0.4532572329044342,
-0.06438910216093063,
-0.07882040739059448,
-0.15490300953388214,
-0.20717506110668182,
0.179326593875885,
0.18293464183807373,
-0.17895881831645966,
0.5707347989082336,
-0.2389824539422989,
-0.45884549617767334,
-0.5570422410964966,
0.16236615180969238,
0.6724953055381775,
0.00799645110964775,
0.7115422487258911,
0.4275047481060028,
-0.1557973474264145,
-0.4183405041694641,
-0.37729182839393616,
-0.31962600350379944,
-0.5142838954925537,
0.7070130705833435,
-0.37897372245788574,
-0.8269612193107605,
0.2106868326663971,
-0.22881676256656647,
0.29618892073631287,
-0.08335106819868088,
0.36357131600379944,
-0.17053979635238647,
1.0870667695999146,
1.0260117053985596,
-0.23222078382968903,
0.7826488018035889,
-0.5454672574996948,
0.0740610733628273,
-0.5828031301498413,
-0.39110711216926575,
-0.2208467423915863,
-0.06507212668657303,
-0.44789472222328186,
-0.451908141374588,
0.16321447491645813,
0.30084824562072754,
-0.019633661955595016,
0.4238991141319275,
-0.17430941760540009,
0.5867729187011719,
0.7635383009910583,
0.3771474063396454,
0.11536221206188202,
0.11558567732572556,
-0.12008903175592422,
-0.020705077797174454,
-0.791293203830719,
-0.46578606963157654,
0.8764885663986206,
0.36562687158584595,
0.9219450354576111,
0.06628426164388657,
0.714618980884552,
0.43894946575164795,
0.7614505290985107,
-0.9419130086898804,
0.8586511015892029,
-0.04477690905332565,
-0.09786094725131989,
-0.4865310490131378,
-0.2150488644838333,
-0.6800530552864075,
0.1738954782485962,
-0.14963513612747192,
-0.6337061524391174,
-0.16381734609603882,
0.6877185106277466,
-0.08990050852298737,
0.20963522791862488,
-0.3703548014163971,
0.6663090586662292,
-0.21498385071754456,
-0.4879350960254669,
-0.815928041934967,
-0.08857008069753647,
0.13568340241909027,
0.18402159214019775,
0.3751165270805359,
0.11100730299949646,
0.22205334901809692,
0.603689432144165,
-0.4852381944656372,
1.293090581893921,
-0.5945450663566589,
-0.32041987776756287,
0.3849433362483978,
0.2262023538351059,
0.7868848443031311,
-0.530738890171051,
0.0018539086449891329,
-0.06152450665831566,
-0.004095152020454407,
-0.24899651110172272,
-0.78952956199646,
0.5765572786331177,
-0.6053126454353333,
-0.8670175075531006,
-0.23833879828453064,
-0.6491737365722656,
-0.29614269733428955,
0.029838234186172485,
-0.16708646714687347,
0.36651691794395447,
-0.49211356043815613,
-0.022942453622817993,
0.5514880418777466,
-0.1835671216249466,
0.612256646156311,
0.9875489473342896,
-0.7701858878135681,
-0.23387455940246582,
1.0461595058441162,
0.002117633819580078,
0.44289466738700867,
0.4593068063259125,
0.1144234761595726,
-0.343113511800766,
-0.4421112835407257,
-0.3559032082557678,
0.14951956272125244,
-0.8982996344566345,
-0.0009341389522887766,
-0.5335788726806641,
-0.2679699659347534,
-0.40951254963874817,
-0.03721325471997261,
-0.2260231375694275,
-0.20276160538196564,
-0.07945262640714645,
-0.16900092363357544,
0.3858252763748169,
1.263120174407959,
-0.35350939631462097,
0.6065434813499451,
-0.4932515323162079,
-0.03788716718554497,
0.3836115002632141,
0.2893516421318054,
0.22107766568660736,
-0.7040737271308899,
-0.374521404504776,
0.11004770547151566,
-0.4491477310657501,
-0.6700337529182434,
0.42146530747413635,
0.40127530694007874,
0.7914637923240662,
0.3186945617198944,
-0.3840027153491974,
0.8133522272109985,
-0.7874799966812134,
0.9304870963096619,
-0.004475296940654516,
-1.0122755765914917,
0.5349578857421875,
-0.12205035239458084,
0.06835433095693588,
0.20583483576774597,
0.24804487824440002,
-0.46607500314712524,
-0.6373668909072876,
-0.36104288697242737,
-0.5331925749778748,
0.8258700370788574,
-0.21330764889717102,
0.3585509657859802,
0.1345902979373932,
0.439269095659256,
-0.04464994743466377,
0.2361600399017334,
-0.80339115858078,
0.04496302083134651,
-0.08344081789255142,
-0.1314569115638733,
-0.2047906070947647,
-0.24867823719978333,
0.006140722893178463,
-0.283093124628067,
0.9583359360694885,
-0.24365538358688354,
0.22671186923980713,
-0.005608375649899244,
-0.15548010170459747,
-0.2001022845506668,
0.3488432765007019,
0.821220338344574,
0.87872713804245,
-0.003526433138176799,
-0.02033771201968193,
0.2041642814874649,
-0.36917832493782043,
0.41958317160606384,
-0.38688158988952637,
-0.3550257980823517,
-0.005238756537437439,
0.3614112138748169,
0.8818013072013855,
0.3053169846534729,
-0.8244607448577881,
0.5648186206817627,
0.1910548210144043,
-0.14525483548641205,
-0.5312196016311646,
0.6380748748779297,
-0.25153613090515137,
0.19370843470096588,
0.008579201065003872,
-0.1121956929564476,
0.045146021991968155,
-0.7905740141868591,
0.29779455065727234,
0.530879020690918,
-0.6576248407363892,
-0.39274266362190247,
0.35689544677734375,
0.15492799878120422,
-0.6698512434959412,
0.36206579208374023,
-0.15779751539230347,
-0.6949504613876343,
0.6672706007957458,
0.7677822113037109,
0.5519232153892517,
-0.4294564723968506,
0.6568870544433594,
0.45618942379951477,
0.43468695878982544,
-0.6217665076255798,
0.5433415174484253,
-0.10815305262804031,
-0.6705095767974854,
-0.695155143737793,
-0.5421432852745056,
-0.806877851486206,
0.30604949593544006,
-0.8556681275367737,
0.20374424755573273,
-0.6534913182258606,
0.017490476369857788,
-0.3757742941379547,
-0.3239479959011078,
-0.6357178688049316,
0.08564276248216629,
-0.291439414024353,
0.8621358275413513,
-0.8664461374282837,
0.9151439666748047,
0.7161784172058105,
-0.5588076114654541,
-0.9871156811714172,
-0.05190880224108696,
-0.14686545729637146,
-1.0595743656158447,
0.706428587436676,
0.09956017136573792,
-0.2870262563228607,
-0.15364870429039001,
-0.7175386548042297,
-0.8773490190505981,
0.7660145163536072,
0.15819908678531647,
-0.7737976908683777,
-0.03202791139483452,
0.1391441375017166,
0.8158232569694519,
-0.48142877221107483,
0.18153738975524902,
0.7006377577781677,
0.3966303765773773,
-0.24365094304084778,
-1.0065397024154663,
-0.08202808350324631,
-0.037539929151535034,
0.1579703986644745,
0.18830379843711853,
-0.5238210558891296,
0.28734835982322693,
-0.4427981972694397,
0.20057852566242218,
0.33257731795310974,
0.8022452592849731,
0.25006285309791565,
0.11152568459510803,
0.6960436105728149,
0.3167183995246887,
0.525764524936676,
-0.10172805935144424,
1.2396571636199951,
-0.26306068897247314,
0.16725680232048035,
1.1714725494384766,
-0.22648166120052338,
1.0431612730026245,
0.6444989442825317,
-0.20972515642642975,
0.6961618065834045,
0.4654877483844757,
0.16524365544319153,
0.8196116089820862,
0.26887619495391846,
-0.02928941138088703,
-0.09737500548362732,
-0.31094688177108765,
-0.00953598041087389,
0.42133840918540955,
0.5592365860939026,
-0.44072335958480835,
0.11848314851522446,
0.38066601753234863,
-0.02956608682870865,
0.31366127729415894,
-0.5981044769287109,
0.9040930271148682,
-0.13901840150356293,
-1.1425427198410034,
0.6056442856788635,
0.02191300317645073,
0.6835864782333374,
-0.6720561981201172,
-0.5929331183433533,
-0.35413220524787903,
0.2971167266368866,
-0.0048329588025808334,
-0.6814032196998596,
0.141950324177742,
-0.20072244107723236,
-0.3101900517940521,
-0.5246953368186951,
0.39440861344337463,
-0.7413625717163086,
-0.19588901102542877,
0.4958469569683075,
0.37047508358955383,
0.31184688210487366,
0.45209741592407227,
-0.676150381565094,
-0.11459575593471527,
0.234059140086174,
-0.2520304322242737,
0.37462735176086426,
0.0700070858001709,
-0.16095829010009766,
0.8195743560791016,
0.489561527967453,
0.39071229100227356,
0.046756960451602936,
0.11921376734972,
0.6453381180763245,
-0.5442988872528076,
-0.5622401833534241,
-0.5080513954162598,
0.2829133868217468,
0.011205270886421204,
-0.08608803153038025,
0.5001668930053711,
0.07372039556503296,
1.0945848226547241,
-0.334734708070755,
0.642507791519165,
-0.044123414903879166,
0.6465417146682739,
-0.8014670610427856,
0.36241599917411804,
-0.4847466051578522,
0.29447776079177856,
-0.15910440683364868,
-0.8477608561515808,
0.13772067427635193,
0.7949476838111877,
-0.18274813890457153,
0.11309783160686493,
0.6099203824996948,
1.121179223060608,
-0.09371893107891083,
-0.23892444372177124,
0.4806789457798004,
0.19124479591846466,
0.39980289340019226,
0.4247889518737793,
1.1712974309921265,
-0.2309110313653946,
0.377803236246109,
-0.48125362396240234,
-0.27781200408935547,
-0.030578700825572014,
-0.9292721748352051,
-0.8378567695617676,
-0.3879765272140503,
-0.37618258595466614,
-0.5315887928009033,
0.3439694344997406,
1.1244654655456543,
0.8990933299064636,
-1.0810855627059937,
-0.5317086577415466,
-0.2229737788438797,
-0.024597667157649994,
-0.7576122879981995,
-0.3400039076805115,
0.19483472406864166,
-0.5902653336524963,
-0.80772864818573,
0.5986118316650391,
0.16235047578811646,
0.09602503478527069,
-0.45298847556114197,
-0.6210152506828308,
0.10804367810487747,
0.1446775197982788,
0.6408048868179321,
0.6048529148101807,
-1.0890828371047974,
-0.4687703847885132,
-0.04986989498138428,
-0.04329220578074455,
-0.0729270726442337,
1.0146620273590088,
-0.7744308114051819,
0.12217763066291809,
0.2537948489189148,
0.5328727960586548,
0.2635310888290405,
-0.25880539417266846,
0.7584514617919922,
-0.7279939651489258,
0.29208189249038696,
-0.02009844221174717,
0.3797425627708435,
0.29059723019599915,
-0.2503369450569153,
0.6629102826118469,
-0.007297163363546133,
-0.5325661897659302,
-0.7969210147857666,
0.17436474561691284,
-0.43871429562568665,
-0.13618434965610504,
1.2191650867462158,
-0.5074105858802795,
-0.3406433165073395,
0.1704925000667572,
-0.3137194812297821,
-0.10256743431091309,
-0.46198081970214844,
0.8468111753463745,
0.6199789047241211,
-0.2559466063976288,
-0.3607611656188965,
-0.4530450999736786,
0.7036279439926147,
0.6081362366676331,
-0.8015510439872742,
-0.001225858461111784,
0.5737451910972595,
0.3696305751800537,
0.11613437533378601,
0.7794506549835205,
-0.06650274246931076,
0.3961032032966614,
-0.3120129108428955,
0.178672656416893,
-0.047513749450445175,
-0.4651596248149872,
-0.532366156578064,
-0.056435566395521164,
0.3691708445549011,
-0.09127987176179886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07871v1 | Scaling Laws for Fine-Grained Mixture of Experts | 2024-02-12T18:33:47 | 2024-02-12T18:33:47 | Jakub Krajewski, Jan Ludziejewski, Kamil Adamczewski, Maciej Pióro, Michał Krutul, Szymon Antoniak, Kamil Ciebiera, Krystian Król, Tomasz Odrzygóźdź, Piotr Sankowski, Marek Cygan, Sebastian Jaszczur | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Mixture of Experts (MoE) models have emerged as a primary solution for
reducing the computational cost of Large Language Models. In this work, we
analyze their scaling properties, incorporating an expanded range of variables.
Specifically, we introduce a new hyperparameter, granularity, whose adjustment
enables precise control over the size of the experts. Building on this, we
establish scaling laws for fine-grained MoE, taking into account the number of
training tokens, model size, and granularity. Leveraging these laws, we derive
the optimal training configuration for a given computational budget. Our
findings not only show that MoE models consistently outperform dense
Transformers but also highlight that the efficiency gap between dense and MoE
models widens as we scale up the model size and training budget. Furthermore,
we demonstrate that the common practice of setting the size of experts in MoE
to mirror the feed-forward layer is not optimal at almost any computational
budget. | [
-0.8026305437088013,
-0.8443529605865479,
0.4480828046798706,
0.34390220046043396,
0.21970969438552856,
-0.2975504994392395,
-0.6236779689788818,
-0.30282658338546753,
0.1961151361465454,
0.6805293560028076,
-0.13537096977233887,
0.20405322313308716,
-0.8204692602157593,
-0.18511848151683807,
-0.4675234258174896,
0.9923028349876404,
0.35144516825675964,
-0.2207501083612442,
-0.2370961308479309,
0.0030778872314840555,
-0.36484965682029724,
-0.21411168575286865,
-0.38338643312454224,
-0.5336763262748718,
0.34439998865127563,
0.5323266983032227,
1.2468624114990234,
1.1273283958435059,
0.6277241110801697,
0.3874429762363434,
-0.23314684629440308,
0.027475018054246902,
-0.6057175397872925,
-0.11005838215351105,
-0.42986172437667847,
-0.5867466926574707,
-0.6128957867622375,
-0.17397166788578033,
0.46508872509002686,
0.9311820268630981,
-0.5008926391601562,
-0.06996498256921768,
0.1180211752653122,
0.4218408465385437,
-0.7637516260147095,
0.1594177484512329,
-0.9273723363876343,
0.03045359067618847,
-0.06249449774622917,
-0.18008844554424286,
-0.4131743609905243,
-0.046720970422029495,
0.09315552562475204,
-0.7414839267730713,
0.24320566654205322,
-0.023823332041502,
0.8201847076416016,
0.4130522608757019,
-0.3584558963775635,
-0.149749755859375,
-0.8226606249809265,
1.224737524986267,
-0.7030395269393921,
0.09107263386249542,
0.5377357006072998,
0.3427669405937195,
0.003695986233651638,
-0.5434690713882446,
-0.3164569139480591,
0.004077584948390722,
-0.02870466746389866,
-0.20638418197631836,
-0.28054001927375793,
0.11409037560224533,
-0.12713414430618286,
0.5593883991241455,
-0.1322895586490631,
0.3867919445037842,
-0.42453286051750183,
-0.053622618317604065,
0.7970873117446899,
0.4354044198989868,
0.12784415483474731,
0.254842072725296,
-0.34378519654273987,
-0.029642635956406593,
-0.10010950267314911,
-0.24456706643104553,
0.10737644881010056,
0.256460577249527,
-0.05978354439139366,
0.3444358706474304,
-0.29086804389953613,
0.666581392288208,
0.7002889513969421,
-0.4572417140007019,
0.06464813649654388,
-0.18322597444057465,
-0.029422657564282417,
-0.008363118395209312,
0.6703150868415833,
0.5438774228096008,
0.688082754611969,
-0.3752051591873169,
-0.2674526274204254,
-0.6294057369232178,
0.5207946300506592,
-1.0516775846481323,
-0.3810584545135498,
0.019753873348236084,
-0.18013837933540344,
-0.4104461371898651,
-0.23491360247135162,
-0.5321084856987,
-0.278105229139328,
-0.6439783573150635,
0.767710268497467,
-0.3512571454048157,
-0.49503231048583984,
0.0910036638379097,
-0.0974530577659607,
-0.06580083072185516,
0.3980177640914917,
-1.615291714668274,
0.41249507665634155,
0.8897982239723206,
0.6854868531227112,
0.16558082401752472,
-0.4252406656742096,
-0.27945342659950256,
0.21161949634552002,
-0.5354878902435303,
0.6964395046234131,
-0.8397039771080017,
-0.45419785380363464,
-0.18027135729789734,
-0.6026540994644165,
-0.17431578040122986,
-0.8270002603530884,
0.039169274270534515,
-0.41893744468688965,
-0.23447099328041077,
-0.17417436838150024,
-0.5552435517311096,
-0.09881691634654999,
0.17957353591918945,
-0.21532630920410156,
1.07270085811615,
0.4014132022857666,
-0.6347270011901855,
0.5796124339103699,
-0.4018315374851227,
-0.38726669549942017,
0.1521545946598053,
-0.2517566382884979,
-0.11755985021591187,
0.4504103362560272,
0.20499034225940704,
0.9182120561599731,
-0.15691235661506653,
0.4183087944984436,
-0.5672869086265564,
-0.18500114977359772,
0.11411472409963608,
-0.3704911172389984,
0.49505680799484253,
0.3642409145832062,
-0.09499041736125946,
0.0617990680038929,
-0.9606247544288635,
0.0492752343416214,
-0.1999668926000595,
-0.6632285118103027,
-0.4132441282272339,
-0.013325262814760208,
0.08620131760835648,
-0.004890397656708956,
0.3165115416049957,
-0.2835528254508972,
0.3230178952217102,
-0.05484353005886078,
0.6525240540504456,
0.8352404236793518,
-0.032507434487342834,
0.8773654699325562,
-0.16818861663341522,
0.16515405476093292,
0.12212949991226196,
0.12153174728155136,
0.0036199772730469704,
-0.4184844493865967,
-0.625210165977478,
-0.5908284187316895,
0.31855228543281555,
0.24848544597625732,
-0.4989054501056671,
0.6378505825996399,
-0.4433843195438385,
-0.7180878520011902,
-0.5054506659507751,
0.31642043590545654,
0.16151337325572968,
0.4432941675186157,
0.4361746609210968,
-0.25856131315231323,
0.016644667834043503,
-1.2061703205108643,
-0.25971731543540955,
0.02104884199798107,
-0.21352194249629974,
0.41089877486228943,
0.3978823125362396,
-0.2849292457103729,
1.2826942205429077,
-0.5481269359588623,
-0.055331259965896606,
-0.1318732500076294,
0.360891193151474,
0.10534243285655975,
0.7811293005943298,
0.848641037940979,
-0.690470278263092,
-0.624938428401947,
0.5547354817390442,
-0.48374953866004944,
-0.3483293950557709,
0.01749391295015812,
-0.07189317047595978,
-0.4007294476032257,
0.5449892282485962,
-0.42968809604644775,
-0.056201543658971786,
0.5671007633209229,
-0.10035881400108337,
0.5487567782402039,
-0.427937775850296,
-0.09703608602285385,
-1.0937005281448364,
-0.2718357741832733,
0.23900049924850464,
-0.3995315134525299,
-0.7203974723815918,
0.4827196002006531,
0.04831542819738388,
0.06999684125185013,
-0.41989314556121826,
0.5741575360298157,
-0.16042055189609528,
-0.0178524162620306,
-0.3889468312263489,
-0.13519036769866943,
-0.10656410455703735,
0.6356709003448486,
-0.08903384208679199,
0.9736282229423523,
0.8298817276954651,
-0.846740186214447,
0.1918448805809021,
-0.11519084870815277,
-0.18347878754138947,
0.9232962131500244,
-0.8571501970291138,
-0.11996620893478394,
0.1363838016986847,
0.05115564912557602,
-0.4486992657184601,
-0.4827369451522827,
-0.4378449320793152,
-0.1374405473470688,
0.46643921732902527,
-0.18134373426437378,
-0.5569790601730347,
0.06616240739822388,
-0.04920443519949913,
0.5434786081314087,
0.6443102359771729,
-0.25529417395591736,
0.9905977845191956,
0.4170553684234619,
-0.3473788797855377,
-0.23995821177959442,
-0.8094170093536377,
-0.016067134216427803,
-0.26013559103012085,
-0.7821627855300903,
0.1928287297487259,
-0.1844278872013092,
-0.5401102304458618,
-0.1116095557808876,
0.06478802114725113,
-0.685167670249939,
0.10249999910593033,
-0.0785268172621727,
-0.4376663267612457,
-0.5828962326049805,
-0.13262364268302917,
0.3301214575767517,
-0.1027129739522934,
0.067809097468853,
-0.21264491975307465,
0.7211792469024658,
-0.21434152126312256,
0.05299954116344452,
-0.3788359761238098,
0.33602821826934814,
0.7665588855743408,
-0.20126929879188538,
0.8581870794296265,
0.8791648745536804,
-0.08420979231595993,
-0.08396921306848526,
-0.7454997301101685,
-0.047501396387815475,
-0.540448784828186,
0.6627299785614014,
-0.4976564645767212,
-0.5029800534248352,
0.7430577278137207,
0.07447442412376404,
0.19598472118377686,
0.7854267358779907,
0.9708690643310547,
0.18356385827064514,
1.043571949005127,
0.5824943780899048,
-0.23004184663295746,
0.5448507070541382,
-0.1901523619890213,
-0.12488273531198502,
-0.7569402456283569,
0.022530987858772278,
-0.5056998133659363,
-0.49559447169303894,
-0.3786117434501648,
-0.5986686944961548,
0.6040501594543457,
0.2224816381931305,
-0.39188358187675476,
0.1943407952785492,
-0.34527093172073364,
0.9485653638839722,
0.6767783164978027,
0.17244912683963776,
0.12810637056827545,
-0.03596489503979683,
0.18748298287391663,
0.2025294303894043,
-0.8928983211517334,
-0.26637372374534607,
0.9989781379699707,
0.49989956617355347,
0.8743937611579895,
-0.09094522148370743,
0.6113079786300659,
0.18701986968517303,
-0.0725284218788147,
-0.805968165397644,
0.5636029243469238,
-0.16660894453525543,
-0.9011090993881226,
-0.45026537775993347,
-0.6857823133468628,
-0.6801953911781311,
0.5371093153953552,
-0.16367597877979279,
-0.680173933506012,
0.4345681667327881,
0.1742662489414215,
-0.5005034804344177,
0.6216436624526978,
-0.7964464426040649,
0.3965115249156952,
0.16622230410575867,
-0.1623167246580124,
-0.5054596066474915,
-0.5218205451965332,
0.09327670931816101,
-0.4366650879383087,
0.2415095865726471,
-0.06468173861503601,
-0.18129675090312958,
0.6586077809333801,
-0.7232720851898193,
0.775644838809967,
-0.07535741478204727,
-0.14057369530200958,
0.3877244293689728,
0.27158257365226746,
0.41198447346687317,
-0.024144334718585014,
-0.06592879444360733,
0.28159013390541077,
-0.2782713770866394,
-0.9252477288246155,
-0.4374752342700958,
0.6843338012695312,
-0.9952585697174072,
-0.40849339962005615,
0.2646801769733429,
-1.139000654220581,
-0.18429259955883026,
0.270943284034729,
0.4160720705986023,
0.5845036506652832,
0.2958437204360962,
0.783109724521637,
0.9712350964546204,
0.231223925948143,
0.4301219880580902,
0.4389066696166992,
-0.20243637263774872,
-0.15958887338638306,
1.1673388481140137,
0.534559428691864,
0.5964393019676208,
0.2869099974632263,
0.5239099860191345,
0.37375330924987793,
-0.723843514919281,
-0.5054166316986084,
-0.15956369042396545,
-0.3881668150424957,
-0.045572713017463684,
-0.7725028395652771,
-0.10023512691259384,
-0.33791378140449524,
-0.5422307252883911,
-0.7340160608291626,
-0.511110246181488,
-0.35485154390335083,
0.17858678102493286,
0.3507646918296814,
0.6835970878601074,
-0.06327667832374573,
0.7736011743545532,
-0.7210596203804016,
-0.031029393896460533,
0.6473552584648132,
0.3570403754711151,
0.1577325165271759,
-0.7725793719291687,
-0.7088094353675842,
-0.0554400309920311,
-0.43794238567352295,
-0.19675958156585693,
0.10619744658470154,
0.4008493423461914,
0.31087642908096313,
1.0579559803009033,
-0.17787687480449677,
0.8460594415664673,
-0.6466566324234009,
0.732515275478363,
0.20132194459438324,
-0.867665708065033,
0.0890701562166214,
-0.695441722869873,
0.19729146361351013,
0.5997734665870667,
0.09191033989191055,
-0.011806229129433632,
-0.5625266432762146,
-0.6704733967781067,
-0.8712600469589233,
0.5767516493797302,
0.3098936080932617,
0.6536434888839722,
0.24555514752864838,
0.279676616191864,
0.4314805567264557,
0.0921815037727356,
-0.32597512006759644,
-0.026944704353809357,
0.06493951380252838,
-0.2021038830280304,
-0.045370981097221375,
-0.11537228524684906,
-0.11729949712753296,
-0.41515427827835083,
0.6047666072845459,
-0.07785610854625702,
-0.007992378436028957,
-0.2117360681295395,
0.040666352957487106,
-0.13215941190719604,
0.143764927983284,
0.597726047039032,
0.8386669158935547,
-0.13348621129989624,
-0.010304347611963749,
0.2537728548049927,
-0.6136510372161865,
-0.1303376704454422,
-0.14743061363697052,
-0.06071456894278526,
-0.0989861711859703,
0.5118569731712341,
0.8477110266685486,
0.6995042562484741,
-0.44442570209503174,
0.46263039112091064,
0.3903176784515381,
-0.478687584400177,
0.20350053906440735,
0.6605238914489746,
-0.041417889297008514,
0.38321200013160706,
0.46537530422210693,
0.4089566767215729,
0.04292973875999451,
-0.37136295437812805,
0.04719388857483864,
0.15432873368263245,
-0.19329364597797394,
-0.4129190444946289,
0.5382298827171326,
0.4177166223526001,
-0.28916215896606445,
0.5036525130271912,
0.036449335515499115,
-0.277015745639801,
0.6276931762695312,
0.3620432913303375,
0.4823712408542633,
-0.2385563850402832,
0.005370563827455044,
-0.06834959983825684,
0.2699700891971588,
-0.27785754203796387,
-0.2829512059688568,
-0.09060896933078766,
-0.6911819577217102,
-0.20293158292770386,
-0.5200239419937134,
-0.5354452133178711,
-0.24431246519088745,
-0.9151448607444763,
0.18133850395679474,
-0.5704206228256226,
-0.24087880551815033,
0.22967515885829926,
-0.16446441411972046,
-0.583276629447937,
0.39499881863594055,
-0.04713106155395508,
0.8829896450042725,
-0.7750211954116821,
0.5700928568840027,
0.630662202835083,
-0.21292266249656677,
-0.6907240152359009,
-0.20224837958812714,
-0.13268440961837769,
-1.051102638244629,
0.23675572872161865,
-0.17329227924346924,
0.31591153144836426,
0.05371999740600586,
-0.557654619216919,
-0.8892557621002197,
0.8303078413009644,
0.43133124709129333,
-0.6385080218315125,
-0.23127759993076324,
-0.01977740228176117,
0.49369290471076965,
-0.3924271762371063,
0.32002952694892883,
0.6072221994400024,
0.38553306460380554,
-0.03168284893035889,
-1.2028160095214844,
-0.6158279776573181,
-0.05767710506916046,
-0.0012400418054312468,
0.469338983297348,
-0.8072457313537598,
1.4143261909484863,
0.061449259519577026,
0.506420373916626,
-0.3122277557849884,
0.8889110684394836,
-0.08369907736778259,
0.24791505932807922,
0.5275169014930725,
0.7542206645011902,
0.6435002684593201,
0.12392281740903854,
1.2160446643829346,
-0.4553805887699127,
0.7034698724746704,
0.9339830279350281,
0.02085411548614502,
0.7628113627433777,
0.4563009738922119,
-0.4998849630355835,
0.36463624238967896,
0.45175057649612427,
0.006896169390529394,
0.21702547371387482,
-0.07913004606962204,
0.030725708231329918,
-0.41013118624687195,
-0.0381169393658638,
-0.45641404390335083,
0.2976926565170288,
0.2210228145122528,
-0.4251301884651184,
-0.20281566679477692,
0.047258149832487106,
0.28004181385040283,
0.04521724581718445,
-0.896647572517395,
0.9076699614524841,
-0.10556742548942566,
-0.2935514748096466,
0.5576739311218262,
-0.0006175267626531422,
0.658448338508606,
-0.5534141063690186,
0.5666115880012512,
-0.24082374572753906,
0.2388702630996704,
-0.29149115085601807,
-0.8333998322486877,
0.030429329723119736,
-0.05711843818426132,
-0.4829206168651581,
0.1069028377532959,
0.3983725309371948,
-0.5084436535835266,
-0.7488653659820557,
-0.20061805844306946,
0.2207399606704712,
0.2665274441242218,
-0.3101031184196472,
-0.45963597297668457,
-0.3371022343635559,
-0.33184340596199036,
-0.5189028382301331,
0.617696225643158,
0.8071316480636597,
-0.04081769287586212,
0.7403161525726318,
0.14125341176986694,
0.2480093240737915,
0.5724465847015381,
-0.13711252808570862,
0.8385170698165894,
-0.27161863446235657,
-0.7128647565841675,
-0.7546961903572083,
0.42684265971183777,
-0.04648755490779877,
-0.46324479579925537,
0.5967118144035339,
0.44320693612098694,
0.7647817730903625,
-0.03052111156284809,
0.5154755115509033,
0.06090155616402626,
0.0415138304233551,
-0.4170924723148346,
0.6177168488502502,
-0.6606529951095581,
-0.18961532413959503,
-0.14934056997299194,
-1.1337281465530396,
-0.04974982142448425,
0.37204575538635254,
-0.2519516944885254,
0.325214684009552,
0.20593729615211487,
0.6095408797264099,
-0.5709983706474304,
-0.10952992737293243,
0.4818168878555298,
0.35796740651130676,
0.2833402454853058,
0.27770426869392395,
0.22684139013290405,
-0.06918775290250778,
0.33712899684906006,
-0.3648579716682434,
-0.29927289485931396,
-0.6347938776016235,
-0.49974730610847473,
-0.8134439587593079,
-0.3171291649341583,
-0.4788500964641571,
0.10777940601110458,
-0.5335316061973572,
1.0050760507583618,
1.2746566534042358,
-0.6434029340744019,
-0.18508456647396088,
0.007345282007008791,
-0.28798237442970276,
-0.3403313159942627,
-0.25983870029449463,
0.008419432677328587,
-0.6628088355064392,
-0.9515538215637207,
0.06759041547775269,
0.39174869656562805,
-0.107293039560318,
-0.48262205719947815,
-0.21551869809627533,
0.1532014012336731,
0.7424005270004272,
0.6872368454933167,
-0.028782028704881668,
-0.6106693744659424,
-0.16206952929496765,
-0.5905201435089111,
-0.27550607919692993,
0.15717841684818268,
0.7728462219238281,
-0.25129184126853943,
0.5465269684791565,
0.4997633099555969,
0.8297719359397888,
0.18612614274024963,
0.023992685601115227,
0.5177451968193054,
-0.8317690491676331,
0.2614116668701172,
0.11567496508359909,
0.29391562938690186,
-0.13124994933605194,
-0.397674024105072,
0.38525334000587463,
-0.07961975783109665,
-0.8251903653144836,
-0.8666371703147888,
0.001800502184778452,
-0.9760643839836121,
-0.30142292380332947,
1.1143454313278198,
-0.03274909034371376,
-0.16029174625873566,
0.2209349274635315,
-0.32302477955818176,
-0.3032076954841614,
-0.6116655468940735,
0.7183995246887207,
0.9964150786399841,
-0.16374798119068146,
0.07250861823558807,
-0.5267359614372253,
-0.03895144909620285,
0.6814267039299011,
-0.4859652817249298,
0.08100785315036774,
0.06404518336057663,
0.20504577457904816,
0.3716875910758972,
0.264448344707489,
0.1622350662946701,
0.005378867499530315,
0.24963229894638062,
-0.015013178810477257,
-0.16599567234516144,
-0.5170366764068604,
-0.29078420996665955,
0.32188308238983154,
0.0003434401878621429,
0.1350143402814865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07872v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07872v1 | PIVOT: Iterative Visual Prompting Elicits Actionable Knowledge for VLMs | 2024-02-12T18:33:47 | 2024-02-12T18:33:47 | Soroush Nasiriany, Fei Xia, Wenhao Yu, Ted Xiao, Jacky Liang, Ishita Dasgupta, Annie Xie, Danny Driess, Ayzaan Wahid, Zhuo Xu, Quan Vuong, Tingnan Zhang, Tsang-Wei Edward Lee, Kuang-Huei Lee, Peng Xu, Sean Kirmani, Yuke Zhu, Andy Zeng, Karol Hausman, Nicolas Heess, Chelsea Finn, Sergey Levine, Brian Ichter | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Vision language models (VLMs) have shown impressive capabilities across a
variety of tasks, from logical reasoning to visual understanding. This opens
the door to richer interaction with the world, for example robotic control.
However, VLMs produce only textual outputs, while robotic control and other
spatial tasks require outputting continuous coordinates, actions, or
trajectories. How can we enable VLMs to handle such settings without
fine-tuning on task-specific data?
In this paper, we propose a novel visual prompting approach for VLMs that we
call Prompting with Iterative Visual Optimization (PIVOT), which casts tasks as
iterative visual question answering. In each iteration, the image is annotated
with a visual representation of proposals that the VLM can refer to (e.g.,
candidate robot actions, localizations, or trajectories). The VLM then selects
the best ones for the task. These proposals are iteratively refined, allowing
the VLM to eventually zero in on the best available answer. We investigate
PIVOT on real-world robotic navigation, real-world manipulation from images,
instruction following in simulation, and additional spatial inference tasks
such as localization. We find, perhaps surprisingly, that our approach enables
zero-shot control of robotic systems without any robot training data,
navigation in a variety of environments, and other capabilities. Although
current performance is far from perfect, our work highlights potentials and
limitations of this new regime and shows a promising approach for
Internet-Scale VLMs in robotic and spatial reasoning domains. Website:
pivot-prompt.github.io and HuggingFace:
https://huggingface.co/spaces/pivot-prompt/pivot-prompt-demo. | [
-0.3739820718765259,
-0.7944623231887817,
0.8185877799987793,
0.15753056108951569,
-0.344338059425354,
-0.2630898654460907,
-0.17577451467514038,
0.18768255412578583,
0.1540600210428238,
0.5810590386390686,
-1.0068389177322388,
-0.692799985408783,
-0.2934330105781555,
-0.23829297721385956,
-0.40946081280708313,
0.6818258762359619,
0.05687986686825752,
-0.07157250493764877,
-0.45560574531555176,
-0.14606960117816925,
-0.8037376999855042,
-0.20214562118053436,
-0.29696357250213623,
-0.00016028503887355328,
0.6724100708961487,
0.5706579089164734,
0.5716357827186584,
0.5030437111854553,
0.44505345821380615,
0.2322605401277542,
0.09562642127275467,
0.1894083321094513,
-0.526942789554596,
0.2842246890068054,
-0.2166375368833542,
-0.37984156608581543,
0.06285133957862854,
-0.25180813670158386,
0.36534905433654785,
0.6955877542495728,
-0.017027130350470543,
0.2837126553058624,
-0.23908787965774536,
1.0680896043777466,
-0.819350004196167,
0.2693944275379181,
-0.49606797099113464,
0.31541454792022705,
0.0713462233543396,
-0.32428523898124695,
-0.3132230043411255,
-0.15225493907928467,
0.032139334827661514,
-0.9666926264762878,
0.14831748604774475,
0.2505401074886322,
0.9234862923622131,
0.6665857434272766,
0.10314636677503586,
0.06916246563196182,
-0.8263347148895264,
0.5152967572212219,
-0.2728859484195709,
0.24873675405979156,
0.23694001138210297,
0.7446903586387634,
0.030676601454615593,
-0.619009792804718,
-0.6241719126701355,
-0.2933467924594879,
0.12721455097198486,
0.43236544728279114,
-0.43448641896247864,
-0.0005617167335003614,
0.4208333194255829,
-0.18866784870624542,
-0.7493343353271484,
-0.15965165197849274,
-0.6937029957771301,
0.22373612225055695,
0.3655698299407959,
0.37205737829208374,
0.19110722839832306,
0.016803858801722527,
-0.43758144974708557,
-0.27354612946510315,
-0.7364991307258606,
0.6567295789718628,
-0.08962900191545486,
0.37898707389831543,
0.10708540678024292,
0.9980453848838806,
-0.4730820655822754,
1.214639663696289,
0.05780861899256706,
0.353745698928833,
0.019503995776176453,
-0.3690687119960785,
-0.09811247140169144,
-0.3043805658817291,
0.6186808943748474,
0.8608059883117676,
0.4522453546524048,
0.16414588689804077,
0.04579706862568855,
0.003103341907262802,
0.6745495200157166,
-0.3950299918651581,
-0.36449646949768066,
0.46675142645835876,
-0.1341264247894287,
0.061222970485687256,
0.23106026649475098,
-0.7740768194198608,
-0.34846559166908264,
-0.37395724654197693,
0.5593633055686951,
-0.24809539318084717,
0.013230848126113415,
0.24248769879341125,
-0.36349189281463623,
0.4942619502544403,
0.7264335751533508,
-0.5217807292938232,
-0.13796696066856384,
0.5996937155723572,
0.9173067808151245,
-0.18543456494808197,
-0.5300482511520386,
-1.072150707244873,
0.036320216953754425,
-0.49544599652290344,
0.8117698431015015,
-0.6677600145339966,
-0.31216099858283997,
0.1211627647280693,
-0.1289893537759781,
-0.10694751143455505,
-0.4876372814178467,
-0.055456340312957764,
-0.34506192803382874,
0.2757006287574768,
-0.44725501537323,
-0.12400954961776733,
-0.2958519160747528,
0.5126060247421265,
-0.43782028555870056,
0.9138425588607788,
-0.04123765230178833,
-0.45302870869636536,
0.5256784558296204,
-0.9378339052200317,
-0.2221197634935379,
0.28561931848526,
-0.1792290210723877,
-0.3872290253639221,
0.18062038719654083,
0.3603665828704834,
0.38940003514289856,
-0.05920374020934105,
0.050824131816625595,
-0.3279549479484558,
-0.3658761978149414,
-0.1626664400100708,
0.034520287066698074,
0.6139184236526489,
-0.006194148678332567,
-0.384477436542511,
0.6931908130645752,
-0.17367255687713623,
0.17101030051708221,
0.3076660633087158,
0.19305375218391418,
0.03823325037956238,
0.07383041083812714,
-0.40795964002609253,
0.033111412078142166,
0.20902790129184723,
-0.29790371656417847,
0.6542920470237732,
-0.0704832524061203,
0.14940842986106873,
0.4732826352119446,
0.058147020637989044,
0.6264747381210327,
-0.0437435545027256,
0.6510459780693054,
-0.14433006942272186,
0.5086082220077515,
-0.4685196876525879,
-0.7695896029472351,
-0.7272484302520752,
-0.17956824600696564,
-0.2057695984840393,
0.6940923929214478,
-1.2674978971481323,
0.04321438446640968,
-0.1911873072385788,
-0.28371015191078186,
-0.251451700925827,
0.06683096289634705,
0.2118459939956665,
0.8112525343894958,
0.4015321731567383,
-0.0700959861278534,
-0.14828039705753326,
-0.5116727948188782,
-0.10177639126777649,
-0.17493341863155365,
-0.19373257458209991,
0.2496187537908554,
0.3989652693271637,
0.20355866849422455,
1.044209599494934,
-0.558112382888794,
-0.3360251784324646,
-0.328050434589386,
-0.04828896000981331,
0.27061986923217773,
0.16233587265014648,
0.49518468976020813,
-0.9837832450866699,
-0.4949876666069031,
0.034558236598968506,
-0.8076444268226624,
-0.22170132398605347,
-0.29043471813201904,
-0.2419060468673706,
-0.14973580837249756,
0.4914270043373108,
-0.593600332736969,
1.0013984441757202,
0.12091287225484848,
-0.4043138027191162,
0.43711209297180176,
-0.38560011982917786,
0.0013931033900007606,
-0.2936234474182129,
0.19569310545921326,
-0.05443049967288971,
-0.18147383630275726,
-0.7068106532096863,
0.16469138860702515,
0.008372613228857517,
-0.31112512946128845,
-0.49873650074005127,
0.6743515729904175,
-0.4873806834220886,
-0.39209991693496704,
-0.23619583249092102,
0.4305112361907959,
0.022900640964508057,
0.737701416015625,
0.2785011827945709,
0.7002089023590088,
0.749910831451416,
-0.6895910501480103,
0.46478259563446045,
0.3126237988471985,
0.1296728104352951,
0.6864123344421387,
-0.7219679951667786,
-0.20255568623542786,
-0.3246321678161621,
-0.2137042135000229,
-0.9156256318092346,
-0.15753218531608582,
0.5875564217567444,
-0.5827135443687439,
-0.11878352612257004,
-0.26552942395210266,
-0.23349156975746155,
-0.695264458656311,
-0.4149461090564728,
0.08769462257623672,
0.3706703186035156,
-0.4552818536758423,
0.5928542017936707,
-0.06263073533773422,
-0.02626180835068226,
-0.46028652787208557,
-0.25739896297454834,
0.07738370448350906,
-0.061010438948869705,
-0.4062873423099518,
-0.23275373876094818,
-0.27499067783355713,
-0.23945902287960052,
0.16429182887077332,
-0.013414433225989342,
-0.04925788566470146,
-0.0454602912068367,
0.33792367577552795,
0.559916615486145,
-0.13123735785484314,
-0.01690283603966236,
0.018726645037531853,
-0.32303306460380554,
-0.1918007731437683,
-0.5506542921066284,
0.478060245513916,
-0.3236991763114929,
-0.8156427145004272,
-0.43280455470085144,
0.4892236888408661,
0.6271677017211914,
-0.4713636040687561,
0.4070928394794464,
0.5388683676719666,
-0.07582078874111176,
-0.05681993439793587,
-0.19291414320468903,
-0.18083301186561584,
-0.4634122848510742,
0.19023922085762024,
-0.2534457743167877,
-0.6749019026756287,
0.08391039073467255,
-0.2566600739955902,
0.3828187584877014,
0.10918129235506058,
0.6696516275405884,
-0.5166393518447876,
0.8870566487312317,
0.7477146983146667,
0.2845504879951477,
0.8823165893554688,
-0.43853145837783813,
0.3257133662700653,
-0.48979607224464417,
-0.3865254521369934,
-0.26116007566452026,
-0.42683398723602295,
0.05185319110751152,
-0.7587518095970154,
0.9093199372291565,
0.08468993753194809,
-0.40982651710510254,
0.25763046741485596,
-0.6727718114852905,
0.6682219505310059,
0.8851205706596375,
0.12029767781496048,
0.09567645192146301,
0.15584421157836914,
-0.047463007271289825,
-0.14265187084674835,
-0.9762678146362305,
-0.2893694341182709,
0.5726917386054993,
-0.2921146750450134,
0.48186659812927246,
-0.2660078704357147,
0.3500741720199585,
0.21131695806980133,
-0.07852574437856674,
-0.9569374918937683,
0.6254883408546448,
0.06490732729434967,
-0.22023579478263855,
-0.5708496570587158,
0.005832984112203121,
-1.0383589267730713,
0.19547836482524872,
-0.2763460874557495,
-0.8545119762420654,
0.20964187383651733,
0.5277891159057617,
-0.5140920281410217,
0.20306625962257385,
-0.5717350840568542,
0.8878612518310547,
-0.5138237476348877,
-0.6924852728843689,
0.08137873560190201,
-0.7304857969284058,
-0.06847915798425674,
0.48063212633132935,
-0.16800221800804138,
-0.09205948561429977,
-0.2294367104768753,
0.02129974588751793,
-0.3428434431552887,
0.8969531059265137,
-0.6302974820137024,
0.3144174814224243,
0.2516792416572571,
0.2693747580051422,
0.3182147145271301,
-0.16089002788066864,
0.08053068071603775,
0.09139040857553482,
-0.2235066145658493,
-0.4754100441932678,
-0.9447807669639587,
0.13264499604701996,
-0.27329614758491516,
-0.7031881809234619,
-0.12952031195163727,
-0.4310719966888428,
-0.229974165558815,
0.3095974326133728,
0.3697008490562439,
0.2129640281200409,
0.3630822002887726,
0.2302456945180893,
0.602543830871582,
-0.18902890384197235,
0.5364471673965454,
0.33316588401794434,
-0.5831663608551025,
-0.129495769739151,
0.9766765236854553,
-0.10347910225391388,
0.17010441422462463,
0.4500132203102112,
0.23035511374473572,
-0.12976223230361938,
-0.5326536297798157,
-0.8568110466003418,
0.11654976010322571,
-0.5261436700820923,
-0.2684535086154938,
-0.33548787236213684,
0.033404961228370667,
0.07817929238080978,
-0.6490817070007324,
-0.4888223707675934,
-0.3582172095775604,
-0.276395708322525,
0.04334338754415512,
0.44446149468421936,
0.8399320840835571,
-0.030821841210126877,
0.2942483127117157,
-0.6002049446105957,
0.49845510721206665,
0.31151342391967773,
0.11178135126829147,
-0.1729251742362976,
-0.22119684517383575,
-0.023767873644828796,
-0.019494980573654175,
-0.11894161999225616,
-0.7093257308006287,
0.5156832933425903,
0.07903049141168594,
0.6387280821800232,
0.38344910740852356,
0.2817210257053375,
0.8444175124168396,
-0.6563464403152466,
1.075373649597168,
0.3347874879837036,
-0.7167844176292419,
1.0574405193328857,
-0.3043150007724762,
0.5279096364974976,
0.5363852977752686,
0.35057660937309265,
-0.4166390299797058,
-0.20236918330192566,
-0.25267598032951355,
-1.0170172452926636,
0.4587678611278534,
0.11012915521860123,
-0.03795740380883217,
0.3880898654460907,
0.3531133234500885,
0.011212770827114582,
0.5160460472106934,
-0.41497889161109924,
-0.20399649441242218,
-0.5036613941192627,
-0.06414778530597687,
0.19395259022712708,
0.037972886115312576,
-0.3637804090976715,
-0.2800598442554474,
0.15738612413406372,
-0.5024641752243042,
0.4471030533313751,
0.33676162362098694,
-0.126364603638649,
0.033966269344091415,
-0.33701837062835693,
0.8895648121833801,
0.6525276899337769,
0.32270458340644836,
-0.0838126689195633,
-0.0702623575925827,
-0.15677207708358765,
-0.16405102610588074,
-0.4120524823665619,
-0.4042775630950928,
-0.012236353941261768,
0.30675455927848816,
0.995620608329773,
-0.02229316718876362,
-0.728259265422821,
0.7470369338989258,
-0.02394605614244938,
-0.12478486448526382,
-0.12303333729505539,
0.27899426221847534,
-0.12643714249134064,
0.5600322484970093,
0.4724821150302887,
0.13113626837730408,
0.06237911432981491,
-0.13482549786567688,
0.09204521775245667,
0.4070320129394531,
-0.48845192790031433,
-0.2554823160171509,
0.7339223623275757,
-0.026134952902793884,
-0.5947554707527161,
0.5693916082382202,
-0.10764545202255249,
-0.674243152141571,
0.5209288597106934,
0.022605573758482933,
0.717249870300293,
0.32304900884628296,
0.49157044291496277,
0.5158610939979553,
0.4491104185581207,
0.1740482598543167,
0.4837357699871063,
-0.6272332668304443,
-0.42654746770858765,
-0.30479493737220764,
-0.12833663821220398,
-0.7983989119529724,
-0.4944324791431427,
-0.6834888458251953,
0.15414433181285858,
-0.6928890943527222,
0.032514747232198715,
-0.4762873649597168,
-0.3857615888118744,
-0.6303609013557434,
-0.06561610847711563,
0.14231255650520325,
0.7598099112510681,
-0.5200862884521484,
0.5164579749107361,
0.7578532695770264,
-0.37262052297592163,
-0.4031982421875,
0.05024205148220062,
0.1707756370306015,
-1.134358286857605,
0.7489849925041199,
0.10975530743598938,
-0.31147345900535583,
-0.26707056164741516,
-1.0019620656967163,
-0.5008711218833923,
0.9510737061500549,
0.30445173382759094,
-0.6042906641960144,
0.01651405543088913,
-0.05060487240552902,
0.43731844425201416,
-0.28862959146499634,
-0.11447856575250626,
0.06266330927610397,
0.6811957955360413,
0.46951383352279663,
-0.6783185601234436,
-0.2777930796146393,
-0.5075194835662842,
0.12314820289611816,
-0.08618984371423721,
-0.6092464923858643,
0.577414333820343,
-0.6966952085494995,
0.021345552057027817,
0.06750015914440155,
0.49401095509529114,
0.3137315809726715,
0.556261420249939,
0.4624372124671936,
0.20558276772499084,
0.7802676558494568,
-0.1842302829027176,
0.9772275686264038,
-0.23715434968471527,
0.12260093539953232,
1.1778461933135986,
-0.29627612233161926,
0.9010441899299622,
0.7387706637382507,
0.05443562939763069,
0.15756967663764954,
0.4663500189781189,
-0.04796962812542915,
0.6246517896652222,
-0.15118366479873657,
-0.09547916054725647,
-0.4529612958431244,
0.01541038230061531,
-0.026840977370738983,
0.4250403940677643,
0.31144970655441284,
0.20703952014446259,
-0.3524012565612793,
0.5068142414093018,
-0.3183513283729553,
0.14604413509368896,
-0.34206539392471313,
0.9058530926704407,
-0.2624182105064392,
-0.6661772727966309,
0.3846542239189148,
-0.707631528377533,
0.22347523272037506,
-0.6523227095603943,
-0.33984625339508057,
-0.2876475155353546,
-0.13484257459640503,
0.03117387555539608,
-1.07338285446167,
0.3644714057445526,
0.0944463238120079,
-0.19366455078125,
-0.5394673347473145,
0.5575826168060303,
-0.3065112829208374,
-0.3414844572544098,
0.056123558431863785,
0.596737802028656,
0.055253952741622925,
-0.3885127305984497,
-0.5853540301322937,
0.26348093152046204,
0.19386084377765656,
-0.2876194417476654,
-0.03566376492381096,
0.5580974221229553,
-0.15286009013652802,
1.1820831298828125,
0.5841951370239258,
0.10200255364179611,
0.19397959113121033,
-0.19308502972126007,
0.9050410985946655,
-0.7246578335762024,
-0.26832208037376404,
-0.5374869704246521,
0.8719293475151062,
-0.19779299199581146,
-0.25197070837020874,
0.596923828125,
0.14484156668186188,
0.7962512373924255,
-0.22993694245815277,
0.4983961880207062,
-0.022261831909418106,
0.200459286570549,
-0.47311028838157654,
0.424959272146225,
-0.7875688672065735,
0.15101207792758942,
-0.05903228744864464,
-0.6792294383049011,
-0.7275219559669495,
0.7731527090072632,
-0.6273460984230042,
-0.17206111550331116,
0.4175676703453064,
0.6319047212600708,
0.14049585163593292,
-0.24775663018226624,
0.8051846027374268,
-0.08623203635215759,
0.2555811107158661,
0.3072931170463562,
0.7147502899169922,
0.10912073403596878,
0.5621496438980103,
-0.2660796046257019,
-0.08179578185081482,
-0.4165491461753845,
-0.8741080164909363,
-0.7223350405693054,
-0.7409685850143433,
-0.17547254264354706,
-0.032297391444444656,
0.12287847697734833,
0.6694347262382507,
0.7027521729469299,
-0.4958244562149048,
-0.16166117787361145,
-0.17745691537857056,
0.26853814721107483,
-0.33636945486068726,
-0.19227121770381927,
-0.07105956226587296,
-0.329191654920578,
-0.6221054792404175,
0.37328290939331055,
0.8232031464576721,
-0.14209704101085663,
-0.127718985080719,
-0.026463445276021957,
0.08338827639818192,
-0.3497936725616455,
0.7486765384674072,
0.7051121592521667,
-0.6991601586341858,
-0.1621621549129486,
0.3460918068885803,
0.17840956151485443,
0.3243798017501831,
0.9531739354133606,
-0.9626487493515015,
0.9538045525550842,
0.3897022604942322,
0.6255964636802673,
0.6248510479927063,
-0.07253535091876984,
0.6419064402580261,
-0.42620038986206055,
0.17461159825325012,
0.23943890631198883,
0.22431643307209015,
0.2742372453212738,
-0.3443974256515503,
0.6280649304389954,
0.1427312195301056,
-0.1379087269306183,
-0.5398815870285034,
0.22700753808021545,
-1.1694918870925903,
-0.21267841756343842,
0.8017248511314392,
-0.16722720861434937,
-0.5483589768409729,
0.12019329518079758,
-0.6920042634010315,
-0.19931133091449738,
-0.40115827322006226,
0.433732807636261,
0.18285225331783295,
-0.485963374376297,
-0.5668948292732239,
-0.5992053747177124,
0.19045810401439667,
0.4581475853919983,
-0.6346656680107117,
0.14647437632083893,
0.6698549389839172,
-0.153391495347023,
0.11706289649009705,
0.3940482437610626,
0.18859319388866425,
0.6860588192939758,
-0.06628691405057907,
0.0541134811937809,
-0.3840996026992798,
-0.7598929405212402,
-0.4116194546222687,
0.33245983719825745,
-0.11500009149312973,
-0.48359984159469604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07865v2 | Prismatic VLMs: Investigating the Design Space of Visually-Conditioned Language Models | 2024-02-12T18:21:14 | 2024-05-30T13:08:48 | Siddharth Karamcheti, Suraj Nair, Ashwin Balakrishna, Percy Liang, Thomas Kollar, Dorsa Sadigh | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Visually-conditioned language models (VLMs) have seen growing adoption in
applications such as visual dialogue, scene understanding, and robotic task
planning; adoption that has fueled a wealth of new models such as LLaVa,
InstructBLIP, and PaLI-3. Despite the volume of new releases, key design
decisions around image preprocessing, architecture, and optimization are
under-explored, making it challenging to understand what factors account for
model performance $-$ a challenge further complicated by the lack of objective,
consistent evaluations. To address these gaps, we first compile a suite of
standardized evaluations spanning visual question answering, object
localization, and challenge sets that probe properties such as hallucination;
evaluations that provide fine-grained insight VLM capabilities. Second, we
rigorously investigate VLMs along key design axes, including pretrained visual
representations and training from base vs. instruct-tuned language models,
amongst others. We couple our analysis with three resource contributions: (1) a
unified framework for evaluating VLMs, (2) optimized, flexible training code,
and (3) checkpoints for all models, including a family of VLMs at the 7-13B
scale that strictly outperform InstructBLIP and LLaVa v1.5, the
state-of-the-art in open VLMs. | [
-0.43619224429130554,
-0.4184717833995819,
0.5286072492599487,
0.5296408534049988,
-0.3654172420501709,
-0.005687249358743429,
-0.19213798642158508,
-0.4370141625404358,
-0.20563334226608276,
0.6610050201416016,
-0.5310717821121216,
-0.5208871960639954,
-0.25618213415145874,
0.020988784730434418,
-0.3391668498516083,
0.5490431189537048,
-0.11893568187952042,
0.2860969603061676,
-0.37937381863594055,
-0.23061232268810272,
-0.49714910984039307,
-0.4628641605377197,
-0.011924793012440205,
-0.20151051878929138,
0.24328167736530304,
0.1632593721151352,
0.6384126543998718,
0.4404483139514923,
0.5630370378494263,
0.27603092789649963,
-0.021362092345952988,
-0.03299893066287041,
-0.6949297785758972,
0.19680927693843842,
-0.04399164393544197,
-0.14638389647006989,
-0.18854397535324097,
-0.26032131910324097,
0.5952099561691284,
0.8022457361221313,
-0.09734008461236954,
0.3634118139743805,
0.1301743984222412,
0.6605404615402222,
-0.9385812282562256,
0.45141103863716125,
-0.4980098009109497,
0.2840310335159302,
-0.19735652208328247,
-0.18584850430488586,
-0.6361537575721741,
-0.09568236768245697,
0.19616132974624634,
-0.7254447937011719,
-0.031109176576137543,
0.3370867967605591,
0.7662047147750854,
0.508102297782898,
-0.13409395515918732,
0.01495380513370037,
-0.7703881859779358,
0.7436559200286865,
-0.4343879818916321,
0.829567015171051,
0.24882639944553375,
0.30525273084640503,
-0.024661466479301453,
-0.8511241674423218,
-0.3722328841686249,
-0.1985614150762558,
-0.03505933657288551,
0.10982012748718262,
-0.4247373938560486,
0.30148088932037354,
0.26972296833992004,
0.3888382315635681,
-0.9798761010169983,
0.2384243607521057,
-0.5718930959701538,
-0.1965755671262741,
0.371224045753479,
0.3544614017009735,
0.2793729603290558,
-0.1627529114484787,
-0.4987528324127197,
-0.08346401154994965,
-0.6027674078941345,
0.022440169006586075,
-0.1354047805070877,
0.08247336000204086,
-0.11354909837245941,
0.7137760519981384,
-0.36089980602264404,
1.0419930219650269,
-0.3877192437648773,
0.05211508646607399,
0.3677312731742859,
-0.43466222286224365,
-0.5254319906234741,
-0.42186763882637024,
0.6238207817077637,
0.4584214985370636,
0.4940374493598938,
-0.17779171466827393,
-0.35648784041404724,
0.13509272038936615,
0.4320487678050995,
-0.8763567805290222,
-0.26335904002189636,
0.08556817471981049,
-0.5979775786399841,
-0.1516036093235016,
-0.2158517986536026,
-0.6334331035614014,
-0.4847342371940613,
-0.7731215357780457,
0.30697911977767944,
-0.38540351390838623,
-0.1497129648923874,
0.3408290147781372,
-0.2343847006559372,
0.4878491759300232,
0.4825776517391205,
-0.6307010054588318,
0.27816617488861084,
0.5367857217788696,
0.6308755874633789,
-0.09015536308288574,
-0.4112657904624939,
-0.2787686288356781,
-0.19049566984176636,
-0.5208917260169983,
0.7461015582084656,
-0.7726107835769653,
-0.37860164046287537,
0.17162136733531952,
-0.30424290895462036,
-0.10134799033403397,
-0.535904586315155,
0.18216851353645325,
-0.5402625203132629,
0.2609332203865051,
-0.39297759532928467,
-0.19621361792087555,
-0.09114467352628708,
0.08153414726257324,
-0.4833138585090637,
0.8115813732147217,
0.4250344932079315,
-0.7248830795288086,
0.6068313717842102,
-0.2654822766780853,
0.02789846435189247,
0.2883896827697754,
-0.3816465437412262,
-0.21762551367282867,
0.4401070475578308,
0.11781661957502365,
0.2789593040943146,
-0.42431244254112244,
0.12519371509552002,
-0.3144703805446625,
-0.40909186005592346,
0.11075244843959808,
-0.13391944766044617,
0.6804965734481812,
0.4651169776916504,
-0.1462833285331726,
0.5992349982261658,
-0.8170795440673828,
0.3569681942462921,
0.13658297061920166,
-0.04252028465270996,
-0.3375619351863861,
-0.08520201593637466,
0.23896604776382446,
0.1379290670156479,
0.06521481275558472,
-0.2902478575706482,
0.16318762302398682,
-0.16103801131248474,
0.1593969166278839,
0.718163013458252,
-0.17361338436603546,
0.4761604368686676,
0.13375549018383026,
0.7071065306663513,
-0.09257188439369202,
0.558171808719635,
-0.15047387778759003,
-0.3042425215244293,
-0.9432376027107239,
-0.4246096611022949,
-0.027145108208060265,
0.536762535572052,
-1.1172670125961304,
-0.11520393192768097,
-0.12738876044750214,
-0.41147151589393616,
-0.456386536359787,
0.158060222864151,
0.7543701529502869,
0.48254215717315674,
0.23709356784820557,
-0.49621325731277466,
-0.631822943687439,
-1.112103819847107,
-0.14486175775527954,
-0.23857662081718445,
-0.11634364724159241,
0.2339087873697281,
0.3993133306503296,
-0.2351049929857254,
0.8739283084869385,
-0.33391422033309937,
-0.05368531122803688,
-0.43677690625190735,
-0.1399400234222412,
-0.1065787747502327,
0.1567162126302719,
0.919866144657135,
-0.5825868844985962,
-0.29885244369506836,
-0.15043790638446808,
-1.029645323753357,
-0.3458634614944458,
0.11814076453447342,
-0.06330752372741699,
0.13126187026500702,
0.5774407386779785,
-0.372549444437027,
0.6073617339134216,
0.4420880377292633,
-0.42132267355918884,
0.544174075126648,
-0.1329495757818222,
-0.17185470461845398,
-0.3945345878601074,
0.07112203538417816,
-0.010720659047365189,
-0.012373671866953373,
-0.7908396124839783,
0.3304753005504608,
0.14305861294269562,
-0.3731829524040222,
-0.638185977935791,
0.6558482050895691,
-0.6858299970626831,
-0.31623172760009766,
-0.10266800969839096,
0.15603026747703552,
-0.03663409501314163,
0.8515886068344116,
0.30396440625190735,
0.6145578026771545,
0.778700053691864,
-0.4554702043533325,
0.0894312858581543,
0.14581653475761414,
-0.6108810901641846,
0.5090508460998535,
-0.8861892223358154,
0.08952762186527252,
-0.5111122131347656,
0.0000049203836169908755,
-0.8159326910972595,
-0.07070521265268326,
0.34965983033180237,
-0.0030891878996044397,
0.2214641124010086,
-0.047689035534858704,
-0.41335755586624146,
-0.32430940866470337,
-0.2828314006328583,
0.7067696452140808,
0.4974527955055237,
-0.42364931106567383,
0.5951446890830994,
0.33568260073661804,
0.11762925982475281,
-0.5091962218284607,
-0.4503759741783142,
0.016957389190793037,
-0.06294258683919907,
-0.5753111839294434,
0.05012083426117897,
-0.033550020307302475,
-0.5865140557289124,
0.01302378624677658,
-0.06165163964033127,
0.0838070809841156,
0.051562536507844925,
0.37048694491386414,
0.21278338134288788,
-0.4235455095767975,
-0.05489398539066315,
-0.39786747097969055,
-0.1692506968975067,
-0.10342434793710709,
-0.3831639289855957,
0.6180093884468079,
-0.5799088478088379,
-0.6172963380813599,
-0.21758157014846802,
0.29779252409935,
0.5932319164276123,
-0.5722919702529907,
0.5533280372619629,
0.4427992105484009,
-0.3760886490345001,
-0.34496742486953735,
-0.4311579763889313,
0.204043447971344,
-0.44969603419303894,
0.45745813846588135,
-0.3898870050907135,
-0.6987041234970093,
0.3974461257457733,
0.2670559585094452,
-0.0015658596530556679,
0.064820297062397,
0.7248936891555786,
0.10837643593549728,
0.8445193767547607,
0.9961949586868286,
0.26107773184776306,
0.6456081867218018,
-0.23621845245361328,
0.19627229869365692,
-0.8421003818511963,
-0.5235798954963684,
-0.3172813951969147,
-0.025248752906918526,
-0.4367590844631195,
-0.6195805668830872,
0.4010264277458191,
-0.00456556212157011,
-0.28297603130340576,
0.29246553778648376,
-0.39351755380630493,
0.4324890375137329,
0.48286592960357666,
-0.14287739992141724,
0.042265407741069794,
-0.10268324613571167,
-0.11744541674852371,
-0.10387308895587921,
-0.8474667072296143,
-0.4727035164833069,
0.9415695667266846,
0.3191455006599426,
0.9458809494972229,
-0.020083501935005188,
0.48143118619918823,
-0.05045385658740997,
0.3252158761024475,
-0.7572564482688904,
0.6243006587028503,
0.07131758332252502,
-0.2597469985485077,
-0.292278915643692,
-0.07351862639188766,
-0.9042646288871765,
0.7390502691268921,
-0.010615960694849491,
-0.9688907861709595,
0.4215824604034424,
0.24659943580627441,
-0.21201319992542267,
-0.1268952488899231,
-0.711682915687561,
1.207780122756958,
-0.5083029270172119,
-0.5168418884277344,
-0.07044032961130142,
-0.61040198802948,
0.639140784740448,
0.14503853023052216,
0.07078937441110611,
0.0058914609253406525,
0.05393490195274353,
0.37406104803085327,
-0.20854587852954865,
0.7921218872070312,
-0.12679822742938995,
0.11411700397729874,
0.12745392322540283,
0.25896671414375305,
-0.03349527716636658,
-0.10439109802246094,
0.1762927770614624,
0.13456249237060547,
0.1416648030281067,
-0.3473174571990967,
-0.8011288046836853,
0.3503418564796448,
-0.5854968428611755,
-0.568101704120636,
-0.26712363958358765,
-0.3603578209877014,
-0.36139097809791565,
0.2898508906364441,
0.2939264178276062,
0.6892229318618774,
-0.28731486201286316,
0.41002851724624634,
0.6798933148384094,
-0.3975376784801483,
0.25922372937202454,
0.4478016793727875,
-0.8861387372016907,
-0.20570559799671173,
1.0354515314102173,
-0.14740973711013794,
0.3639693856239319,
0.2005537897348404,
-0.0114375539124012,
-0.1734195202589035,
-0.7258189916610718,
-0.502687931060791,
0.13963653147220612,
-0.9527544975280762,
-0.010883123613893986,
-0.37888434529304504,
-0.3906295895576477,
-0.16725896298885345,
-0.0387573316693306,
-0.46232524514198303,
-0.15194517374038696,
-0.316798597574234,
0.0888628363609314,
-0.08347906917333603,
0.8817048668861389,
0.15723654627799988,
0.1334659904241562,
-0.4262305200099945,
0.5169784426689148,
0.22242042422294617,
0.5853979587554932,
-0.06545551121234894,
-0.34995678067207336,
-0.16765621304512024,
-0.18040595948696136,
-0.08368299156427383,
-0.744945228099823,
0.4494466483592987,
0.12600618600845337,
0.847525417804718,
0.32745361328125,
0.08850256353616714,
0.7629221081733704,
-0.47944584488868713,
0.7948281168937683,
0.09472167491912842,
-0.7685773372650146,
0.5250100493431091,
-0.10364128649234772,
0.38183003664016724,
0.5016437768936157,
0.058160800486803055,
-0.4233395755290985,
-0.3252907395362854,
-0.43503832817077637,
-0.7442526817321777,
0.4008280634880066,
0.32055941224098206,
-0.11089248210191727,
0.2803262770175934,
0.043643925338983536,
-0.031619418412446976,
0.3845474421977997,
-0.7224159836769104,
-0.06710191071033478,
-0.5772795081138611,
-0.05672382563352585,
-0.0941583663225174,
-0.45827633142471313,
-0.09132152050733566,
-0.303126722574234,
0.11996021866798401,
-0.09512695670127869,
0.09837444871664047,
0.0463625006377697,
-0.4673340618610382,
0.14401622116565704,
-0.0416548065841198,
0.902101993560791,
0.8945847153663635,
-0.10800518095493317,
0.0910637229681015,
-0.09478094428777695,
-0.22284352779388428,
-0.1857864260673523,
-0.17965473234653473,
-0.15279041230678558,
-0.0873919352889061,
0.5645321607589722,
1.2939581871032715,
0.2902018129825592,
-0.8312070965766907,
0.5489733219146729,
-0.36620867252349854,
-0.049739133566617966,
-0.35020357370376587,
0.08201522380113602,
-0.3121355473995209,
0.32027530670166016,
0.000630831578746438,
0.04288012161850929,
0.1448218822479248,
-0.5182886719703674,
-0.02322990447282791,
0.5872229933738708,
-0.455038845539093,
-0.39705708622932434,
0.6007680892944336,
0.19974566996097565,
-0.42426633834838867,
0.8305794596672058,
-0.03639509901404381,
-0.6762868165969849,
0.24193823337554932,
0.28954318165779114,
1.034332513809204,
0.13515332341194153,
0.18994492292404175,
0.09231999516487122,
0.565645694732666,
0.1878160834312439,
0.4008426070213318,
-0.3672603666782379,
-0.6450284719467163,
-0.19752785563468933,
-0.8688457012176514,
-0.33625438809394836,
0.15497639775276184,
-0.6881440281867981,
0.24108323454856873,
-0.4869903028011322,
0.0538107231259346,
-0.4278424084186554,
-0.4244716167449951,
-0.993419885635376,
0.09639394283294678,
0.457191526889801,
0.9431139826774597,
-0.7005642056465149,
0.7291022539138794,
0.3614991009235382,
-0.42871391773223877,
-0.4123021364212036,
-0.2095184326171875,
0.13495373725891113,
-0.9931092858314514,
0.8343470692634583,
0.10578007996082306,
-0.37002965807914734,
-0.2937993109226227,
-0.48604804277420044,
-0.9723973870277405,
0.8117235898971558,
0.498299777507782,
-0.49650993943214417,
-0.01929342746734619,
0.09254283457994461,
0.8078503012657166,
-0.2854083478450775,
0.06272100657224655,
0.5990990996360779,
0.32314571738243103,
0.0461435504257679,
-1.1020458936691284,
-0.20094935595989227,
-0.6392486095428467,
0.36633244156837463,
-0.06372004002332687,
-0.5274900794029236,
0.6326621174812317,
-0.28885117173194885,
-0.32694438099861145,
0.20833119750022888,
0.5908114314079285,
0.5209708213806152,
0.19376985728740692,
0.3760426640510559,
0.5032427906990051,
0.49264752864837646,
-0.09098269045352936,
1.2392847537994385,
-0.33846989274024963,
0.08164327591657639,
0.9202345013618469,
-0.22782866656780243,
0.786773145198822,
0.6895889043807983,
0.10155248641967773,
0.18865475058555603,
0.6366275548934937,
0.098516084253788,
0.6515634059906006,
0.4874206781387329,
0.12959623336791992,
-0.33676964044570923,
-0.11055206507444382,
-0.4056231379508972,
0.6311488151550293,
0.4683891236782074,
-0.2366645336151123,
-0.2116978019475937,
0.3007771670818329,
-0.37761542201042175,
0.024468565359711647,
-0.11771312355995178,
0.6643788814544678,
0.1348029375076294,
-0.6339341402053833,
0.8991889953613281,
-0.35705137252807617,
0.20515203475952148,
-0.5409490466117859,
-0.01100394781678915,
-0.34275710582733154,
0.22807832062244415,
0.05157778412103653,
-0.7385558485984802,
0.135540172457695,
0.009418263100087643,
0.04208320379257202,
-0.6217693090438843,
0.5757669806480408,
-0.20760631561279297,
-0.48462432622909546,
0.26515427231788635,
0.4966295063495636,
0.14592060446739197,
0.021091055124998093,
-0.4307822287082672,
0.7452046275138855,
-0.16305068135261536,
-0.45161494612693787,
0.2929303050041199,
0.4640919268131256,
-0.1316690295934677,
0.9153422713279724,
0.3544391393661499,
0.011961357668042183,
0.21529242396354675,
0.3944699466228485,
1.0185034275054932,
-0.4862615466117859,
-0.17561650276184082,
-0.6022404432296753,
0.7045351266860962,
-0.04746989905834198,
-0.5587302446365356,
0.7141653299331665,
0.5631309151649475,
1.081316590309143,
-0.23770590126514435,
0.6073493957519531,
0.23453989624977112,
-0.08205448091030121,
-0.8612455725669861,
0.49065855145454407,
-0.6522426605224609,
0.31870439648628235,
-0.48032912611961365,
-0.9536212682723999,
-0.4513329565525055,
0.5906921625137329,
-0.2765653729438782,
-0.04523107782006264,
0.5522111654281616,
0.7317767143249512,
0.04353080689907074,
-0.2129182368516922,
0.4507265090942383,
-0.10470765084028244,
0.47893026471138,
0.5117881298065186,
1.1703890562057495,
-0.07926035672426224,
0.2989499270915985,
-0.45908692479133606,
-0.17589609324932098,
-0.34450992941856384,
-0.83274906873703,
-0.8875094652175903,
-0.8299399614334106,
-0.1952042281627655,
-0.03399988263845444,
-0.09839598089456558,
0.5234065651893616,
0.771673321723938,
-0.4496971070766449,
-0.48809465765953064,
-0.02438494749367237,
0.0671112909913063,
0.07504318654537201,
-0.1382492333650589,
0.11192856729030609,
-0.34013888239860535,
-0.4447779953479767,
0.2949889004230499,
0.535072922706604,
0.13410025835037231,
-0.5966387987136841,
-0.16219322383403778,
0.4750747084617615,
-0.03802520036697388,
0.9370865821838379,
0.3624606430530548,
-1.1244685649871826,
-0.3142198324203491,
0.17839142680168152,
-0.19614852964878082,
-0.15674591064453125,
0.9456920027732849,
-0.9435678720474243,
0.7208444476127625,
0.7053558826446533,
0.392421692609787,
0.5236910581588745,
-0.1274004876613617,
0.7429517507553101,
-0.4329051673412323,
0.5166336297988892,
0.3560181260108948,
0.6170845031738281,
0.33244216442108154,
0.16925658285617828,
0.5082355737686157,
0.11776002496480942,
-0.27367183566093445,
-1.202152967453003,
0.3311063051223755,
-1.1067126989364624,
-0.3179677724838257,
1.0686219930648804,
0.14563286304473877,
-0.44660887122154236,
0.09568829089403152,
-0.41193336248397827,
-0.25609153509140015,
0.12032337486743927,
0.5123388171195984,
0.4810228943824768,
-0.32203197479248047,
-0.449341744184494,
-0.5994162559509277,
0.5420908331871033,
0.1884540468454361,
-0.5592553615570068,
0.15041081607341766,
0.7829778790473938,
0.0000016921318319873535,
0.043744251132011414,
0.5916169285774231,
0.008973576128482819,
0.3614254593849182,
0.12826335430145264,
0.12222865968942642,
-0.19721351563930511,
-0.7059219479560852,
-0.33720487356185913,
0.2392774224281311,
0.31947189569473267,
-0.1896401047706604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07862v1 | AI-Augmented Predictions: LLM Assistants Improve Human Forecasting Accuracy | 2024-02-12T18:14:43 | 2024-02-12T18:14:43 | Philipp Schoenegger, Peter S. Park, Ezra Karger, Philip E. Tetlock | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) show impressive capabilities, matching and
sometimes exceeding human performance in many domains. This study explores the
potential of LLMs to augment judgement in forecasting tasks. We evaluated the
impact on forecasting accuracy of two GPT-4-Turbo assistants: one designed to
provide high-quality advice ('superforecasting'), and the other designed to be
overconfident and base-rate-neglecting. Participants (N = 991) had the option
to consult their assigned LLM assistant throughout the study, in contrast to a
control group that used a less advanced model (DaVinci-003) without direct
forecasting support. Our preregistered analyses reveal that LLM augmentation
significantly enhances forecasting accuracy by 23% across both types of
assistants, compared to the control group. This improvement occurs despite the
superforecasting assistant's higher accuracy in predictions, indicating the
augmentation's benefit is not solely due to model prediction accuracy.
Exploratory analyses showed a pronounced effect in one forecasting item,
without which we find that the superforecasting assistant increased accuracy by
43%, compared with 28% for the biased assistant. We further examine whether LLM
augmentation disproportionately benefits less skilled forecasters, degrades the
wisdom-of-the-crowd by reducing prediction diversity, or varies in
effectiveness with question difficulty. Our findings do not consistently
support these hypotheses. Our results suggest that access to an LLM assistant,
even a biased one, can be a helpful decision aid in cognitively demanding tasks
where the answer is not known at the time of interaction. | [
-0.2550353407859802,
-0.3857591450214386,
0.604343593120575,
0.24817979335784912,
-0.11314798891544342,
0.25875961780548096,
-0.08913881331682205,
-1.062678337097168,
0.19563420116901398,
0.25179868936538696,
-0.5046504139900208,
0.11915328353643417,
-0.8163684606552124,
0.2716822624206543,
-0.18173827230930328,
0.6858662962913513,
0.3768937885761261,
0.519382119178772,
-0.6007346510887146,
0.4438929557800293,
-0.6510183215141296,
-0.6283200979232788,
-0.7795284390449524,
-0.526064932346344,
0.33860504627227783,
0.35390374064445496,
1.1847580671310425,
0.6020039916038513,
0.47293081879615784,
0.4157435894012451,
-0.05520273745059967,
0.7161067724227905,
-0.10275048017501831,
-0.002236519008874893,
0.02138511650264263,
-0.5337250232696533,
-0.826930582523346,
0.17604155838489532,
0.18174350261688232,
0.5364377498626709,
-0.23316539824008942,
-0.16008706390857697,
0.2921864986419678,
0.4960467219352722,
-0.5535923838615417,
0.38604652881622314,
-0.6898201107978821,
-0.1900321990251541,
-0.004378261044621468,
-0.18553577363491058,
-0.0789913609623909,
-0.05577201768755913,
0.5398117899894714,
-0.8586076498031616,
0.10440019518136978,
0.22252222895622253,
0.47706159949302673,
0.7287672758102417,
-0.056533392518758774,
-0.20041151344776154,
-0.8499815464019775,
0.7061702609062195,
-0.5872675776481628,
0.4839702546596527,
0.5729363560676575,
0.2394719421863556,
-0.16244807839393616,
-0.39388567209243774,
-0.49462994933128357,
-0.2684191167354584,
0.03271546959877014,
0.451481431722641,
-0.22600530087947845,
0.14846597611904144,
0.3304721713066101,
0.2746928632259369,
0.02898034267127514,
0.3850686550140381,
-0.3248176872730255,
-0.18225829303264618,
0.7548500895500183,
0.28729596734046936,
0.05198430269956589,
0.016170509159564972,
-0.2049965262413025,
0.05456012487411499,
-0.4481373131275177,
-0.19027695059776306,
0.2600572109222412,
0.09367044270038605,
0.16880804300308228,
0.3838481903076172,
-0.11377209424972534,
0.6049404144287109,
0.24596500396728516,
-0.389910489320755,
0.091143898665905,
-0.1680925488471985,
-0.33128175139427185,
-0.020370062440633774,
0.4116871953010559,
0.4958692491054535,
0.5651061534881592,
-0.2983272075653076,
-0.06013396009802818,
-0.053571052849292755,
0.1193651631474495,
-0.4525641202926636,
-0.2512112855911255,
-0.03992938995361328,
0.09237925708293915,
-0.2237969934940338,
0.11806992441415787,
-0.5089866518974304,
-0.8457046151161194,
-0.5880916714668274,
0.19826126098632812,
-0.22107157111167908,
0.010830399580299854,
-0.07658009231090546,
-0.28084293007850647,
-0.05658556893467903,
0.8822176456451416,
-0.8486925959587097,
0.2949792146682739,
0.7267826795578003,
0.6270523071289062,
-0.20841065049171448,
-0.4981240928173065,
-0.48131370544433594,
0.045305658131837845,
-0.4188004732131958,
0.9060540795326233,
-0.5624092221260071,
-0.6970749497413635,
-0.27789589762687683,
-0.2621876001358032,
0.14718404412269592,
-0.7960589528083801,
0.511777400970459,
-0.40611064434051514,
0.16223254799842834,
-0.2070426344871521,
-0.4500153660774231,
-0.13565923273563385,
0.15164755284786224,
-0.588537335395813,
1.0289661884307861,
-0.03416352719068527,
-0.34775474667549133,
0.5979861617088318,
-0.4487920105457306,
-0.35220834612846375,
0.12863239645957947,
-0.15141203999519348,
-0.042409710586071014,
0.018312761560082436,
0.814491331577301,
0.6274313926696777,
-0.5167382955551147,
0.15585164725780487,
-0.2030736654996872,
-0.36188027262687683,
0.23464731872081757,
-0.8322871327400208,
0.20312714576721191,
-0.10592202097177505,
-0.2771264314651489,
0.05442607030272484,
-0.5262801647186279,
-0.29390719532966614,
-0.13985049724578857,
-0.318807989358902,
-0.24946463108062744,
-0.05670477822422981,
-0.14631398022174835,
0.084633968770504,
0.214179128408432,
-0.37213921546936035,
0.297810435295105,
-0.7529891133308411,
-0.017896920442581177,
1.2377694845199585,
-0.30175819993019104,
0.5905418395996094,
-0.42586392164230347,
0.8005553483963013,
-0.18710918724536896,
0.1543523520231247,
-0.11179395020008087,
-0.7365525364875793,
-0.4755380153656006,
-0.142522931098938,
0.24557292461395264,
0.7226653695106506,
-1.0017693042755127,
0.09859944880008698,
-0.36475223302841187,
-0.5043918490409851,
-0.5718162655830383,
0.20950540900230408,
0.3812996447086334,
0.6039847731590271,
0.3607255220413208,
0.1419333964586258,
-0.6917321085929871,
-0.5400724411010742,
-0.3701992630958557,
-0.1400388926267624,
-0.1629079282283783,
0.44992920756340027,
0.1213463619351387,
-0.17489120364189148,
0.6454871892929077,
-0.4223783612251282,
-0.29862433671951294,
-0.13743305206298828,
-0.07060576975345612,
0.16232351958751678,
0.33155107498168945,
0.26172876358032227,
-0.6484751105308533,
-0.3674737811088562,
-0.07449088245630264,
-0.5696393251419067,
-0.013761901296675205,
-0.05003718286752701,
0.2850976288318634,
0.40839388966560364,
0.07360831648111343,
-0.6746812462806702,
0.5517054796218872,
0.6010097861289978,
-0.1787511110305786,
0.7173483967781067,
-0.4449014365673065,
0.014898461289703846,
-0.7698819637298584,
-0.4590366780757904,
0.1443026065826416,
-0.2302628457546234,
-0.5497699975967407,
-0.26491421461105347,
-0.18579784035682678,
0.22940456867218018,
-0.2847178280353546,
0.8247444033622742,
-0.4179753363132477,
-0.25334951281547546,
-0.5458402037620544,
-0.022943738847970963,
-0.0022060698829591274,
0.17176342010498047,
0.19336938858032227,
1.3510024547576904,
0.4059895873069763,
-0.456503689289093,
0.402545303106308,
0.17576731741428375,
-0.3875376284122467,
0.24457356333732605,
-0.5985254645347595,
0.39777177572250366,
0.03927472233772278,
0.24147440493106842,
-0.6941305994987488,
-0.3040211796760559,
0.09116892516613007,
-0.6054790616035461,
0.19737660884857178,
0.2465325891971588,
-0.310729444026947,
-0.4033913016319275,
-0.19944585859775543,
0.19855529069900513,
0.5474116802215576,
-0.687890887260437,
0.9089000821113586,
0.28607720136642456,
-0.3721831142902374,
-0.8234825134277344,
-0.8608472347259521,
0.2530346214771271,
0.011129648424685001,
-0.5454359650611877,
0.5221432447433472,
-0.0794895812869072,
-0.44767627120018005,
-0.315525084733963,
-0.08086412400007248,
0.3032815456390381,
0.1292748600244522,
0.5427232384681702,
0.8961900472640991,
0.19777342677116394,
0.09933051466941833,
-0.3088776469230652,
-0.24045200645923615,
0.13109345734119415,
-0.26893365383148193,
0.2920670807361603,
0.028317444026470184,
-0.36518943309783936,
-0.49705740809440613,
-0.13161322474479675,
0.5010711550712585,
0.011692946776747704,
0.60617995262146,
0.42549264430999756,
-0.3429003655910492,
0.3193444013595581,
-1.045423984527588,
-0.2096795290708542,
-0.5316841006278992,
0.22336485981941223,
-0.27780792117118835,
-0.638460636138916,
0.2916838526725769,
0.19650934636592865,
-0.023698685690760612,
0.46531420946121216,
0.48702481389045715,
-0.10196154564619064,
1.4967255592346191,
0.3892030119895935,
-0.5097528696060181,
0.5650334358215332,
-0.2791444957256317,
-0.1591864377260208,
-0.98826003074646,
-0.42458274960517883,
-0.2963297963142395,
-0.14551720023155212,
-0.479839950799942,
-0.5542048811912537,
0.5070074796676636,
-0.07960207760334015,
-0.10446862131357193,
-0.22363124787807465,
-0.5615560412406921,
0.3864363431930542,
0.785853922367096,
0.19302326440811157,
0.4447595477104187,
-0.06798103451728821,
0.3376689553260803,
-0.12317343801259995,
-0.7534204721450806,
-0.3846568763256073,
1.3536043167114258,
0.3548601269721985,
0.7693178057670593,
-0.2069883793592453,
0.33911511301994324,
0.5279831886291504,
0.6796370148658752,
-0.832635223865509,
0.3502451777458191,
-0.23058368265628815,
-0.3518841862678528,
-0.41139140725135803,
-0.350690096616745,
-0.6514431238174438,
0.017140310257673264,
-0.4942867159843445,
-0.6753982901573181,
0.3389989733695984,
0.5216972231864929,
-0.6191409826278687,
0.1669488102197647,
-0.7325071096420288,
0.20064657926559448,
-0.5542545914649963,
-0.39081957936286926,
-0.36666715145111084,
-0.2919173836708069,
0.1305035799741745,
-0.13566558063030243,
0.33753716945648193,
-0.07809334993362427,
-0.21451593935489655,
0.8236604332923889,
-0.4109465181827545,
0.6376816630363464,
-0.18531987071037292,
0.03897496312856674,
-0.06803233176469803,
-0.0834418460726738,
0.9121260643005371,
-0.044918857514858246,
-0.5381075739860535,
0.1894695907831192,
-0.24355390667915344,
-0.30195072293281555,
-0.8686105012893677,
0.735383927822113,
-0.9738155007362366,
-1.1508893966674805,
-0.5027334094047546,
-0.8275626301765442,
-0.48079997301101685,
-0.06485696136951447,
0.05314718559384346,
0.5209866762161255,
0.09260894358158112,
-0.12198997288942337,
0.17209328711032867,
0.16465818881988525,
0.20416198670864105,
0.34343260526657104,
-0.19255128502845764,
-0.6346415281295776,
0.7664493322372437,
0.2948836386203766,
0.18638688325881958,
0.1510665863752365,
0.30063238739967346,
-0.5348419547080994,
-0.6349825263023376,
-0.43573570251464844,
-0.057395607233047485,
-0.6267470717430115,
-0.23527230322360992,
-0.42472440004348755,
0.1069289967417717,
-0.7021076083183289,
-0.09354611486196518,
0.06647752970457077,
-0.5801629424095154,
-0.5696325898170471,
-0.4290269911289215,
0.49411946535110474,
0.8318953514099121,
-0.0886588841676712,
0.39950817823410034,
-0.6309979557991028,
-0.004065218381583691,
0.5459343791007996,
-0.01042062509804964,
0.1537836343050003,
-0.5074059367179871,
-0.347442090511322,
0.22802403569221497,
-0.2657609283924103,
-0.4960930645465851,
0.5891597867012024,
0.053759895265102386,
0.5575048327445984,
0.5121801495552063,
-0.1940985769033432,
1.127809762954712,
-0.3147834539413452,
0.9183743596076965,
0.1784396916627884,
-0.5918099284172058,
0.19760021567344666,
-0.25050267577171326,
0.2832290530204773,
0.23936843872070312,
0.1239502802491188,
-0.07982823252677917,
-0.3482081890106201,
-0.7217272520065308,
-0.6277511119842529,
0.7988737225532532,
-0.07192002981901169,
0.12137924134731293,
-0.028736025094985962,
0.3933577537536621,
0.0367097370326519,
0.2964309751987457,
-0.2439730316400528,
-0.2384355664253235,
-0.13987527787685394,
0.19930459558963776,
-0.48489606380462646,
-0.35012128949165344,
0.24531319737434387,
-0.5357006788253784,
0.8190688490867615,
-0.04093270003795624,
0.27580690383911133,
0.3668029010295868,
0.2899267077445984,
-0.3053528964519501,
0.10797475278377533,
0.5147861838340759,
0.8399523496627808,
-0.24668706953525543,
-0.10081970691680908,
0.8334245085716248,
-0.4578191936016083,
-0.08585052937269211,
0.4729268252849579,
0.217843160033226,
-0.27817222476005554,
0.6680889129638672,
0.766598105430603,
0.09176422655582428,
-0.7502294778823853,
0.06413420289754868,
0.056608375161886215,
-0.0293948445469141,
-0.5090941190719604,
0.2099473923444748,
-0.09099482744932175,
0.37280306220054626,
0.6799587607383728,
0.5297859311103821,
0.23397968709468842,
-0.6633135676383972,
-0.2333391308784485,
0.5935540795326233,
-0.2586688995361328,
-0.12409057468175888,
0.8112548589706421,
0.36847683787345886,
-0.5898212194442749,
0.5050501227378845,
0.08252368122339249,
-0.6577674746513367,
0.7158684730529785,
0.5394675135612488,
0.7374733090400696,
-0.4571349322795868,
-0.16421543061733246,
-0.21998940408229828,
0.16560108959674835,
-0.23576144874095917,
0.10828959196805954,
0.1010708436369896,
-0.9173721671104431,
-0.6119637489318848,
-0.4080197215080261,
-0.7760236263275146,
-0.06727081537246704,
-0.46621978282928467,
-0.03334037587046623,
-0.46244096755981445,
-0.2992021143436432,
0.09631065279245377,
0.1714574098587036,
-0.9939063191413879,
0.4082110524177551,
0.17296481132507324,
1.0715627670288086,
-0.4356927275657654,
0.7408798933029175,
0.9211751818656921,
-0.14177760481834412,
-1.0689278841018677,
0.15684103965759277,
-0.004690440837293863,
-1.1142233610153198,
0.44275256991386414,
0.045336391776800156,
-0.24983882904052734,
0.04132268577814102,
-0.13821475207805634,
-0.8671684265136719,
1.1969220638275146,
0.4613797962665558,
-0.6851798295974731,
-0.36829936504364014,
0.06252247840166092,
0.5579420328140259,
-0.41249585151672363,
0.7138578295707703,
0.6987844109535217,
0.6826270222663879,
0.22433732450008392,
-1.2380404472351074,
-0.12709550559520721,
-0.0867023766040802,
-0.06045762076973915,
0.006889310199767351,
-0.44805410504341125,
0.7111645936965942,
-0.3805231750011444,
0.1457039713859558,
0.2724582850933075,
0.7455079555511475,
0.1627916693687439,
0.6398879289627075,
0.6088242530822754,
0.31708797812461853,
0.9008105397224426,
-0.07092419266700745,
1.4176665544509888,
-0.29947492480278015,
-0.2418634444475174,
1.0930883884429932,
-0.21498510241508484,
0.6394602656364441,
0.4903160631656647,
-0.3692554533481598,
0.4276893138885498,
0.3900570571422577,
0.17562133073806763,
0.2762383818626404,
-0.4259556829929352,
-0.19575749337673187,
-0.40981781482696533,
-0.4800921380519867,
-0.39217835664749146,
0.33428311347961426,
0.5919671058654785,
-0.26544666290283203,
0.266316294670105,
0.1633831411600113,
-0.09633636474609375,
0.12272512167692184,
-0.6262282729148865,
0.9300635457038879,
0.051982056349515915,
-0.9281339645385742,
0.38385912775993347,
-0.25451335310935974,
0.7560664415359497,
-0.22280874848365784,
-0.17694243788719177,
0.038796566426754,
0.27002453804016113,
-0.2578641474246979,
-0.7860519886016846,
0.23241892457008362,
-0.10282135009765625,
-0.18877248466014862,
-0.2166413813829422,
0.9145447015762329,
-0.11436187475919724,
-0.7541459798812866,
0.32163214683532715,
0.7103075981140137,
-0.0024221923667937517,
-0.26510852575302124,
-0.6514449715614319,
-0.27545467019081116,
-0.11048184335231781,
-0.1829107254743576,
0.20297342538833618,
-0.02069825679063797,
-0.09197115898132324,
0.8723480105400085,
0.9494423866271973,
0.39424431324005127,
-0.22381743788719177,
0.04376045614480972,
0.963748574256897,
-0.4319828152656555,
-0.35102638602256775,
-1.0155611038208008,
0.21772146224975586,
-0.06344087421894073,
-0.06287114322185516,
0.7513474225997925,
0.3599371314048767,
0.537769615650177,
0.04023369774222374,
0.9072076082229614,
0.42175984382629395,
0.6667861342430115,
-0.48522165417671204,
0.17516906559467316,
-0.5231915712356567,
0.5639211535453796,
-0.28031232953071594,
-0.8200235962867737,
-0.10253491997718811,
0.09111617505550385,
-0.9716580510139465,
0.09967933595180511,
0.16505272686481476,
0.7542352676391602,
0.1671152412891388,
0.15870466828346252,
0.4443688988685608,
0.1056552305817604,
0.23492473363876343,
0.15539145469665527,
1.0211116075515747,
0.044683340936899185,
0.582045316696167,
-0.5298945903778076,
-0.28087782859802246,
-0.24758565425872803,
-0.6369293928146362,
-0.9114829897880554,
-0.10846102237701416,
0.15479496121406555,
-0.10488324612379074,
0.473624587059021,
1.3213640451431274,
0.6897943019866943,
-0.5294050574302673,
-0.07119426131248474,
-0.07558714598417282,
0.14226365089416504,
-0.3313910961151123,
-0.22179703414440155,
0.4140772223472595,
0.01574661210179329,
-0.9702858924865723,
0.6135694980621338,
0.20960722863674164,
0.24712184071540833,
-0.32550516724586487,
-0.2985789179801941,
0.05541861057281494,
0.19329020380973816,
0.4828009009361267,
-0.05948701128363609,
-1.0418063402175903,
-0.29275402426719666,
0.13189713656902313,
0.28359609842300415,
-0.04959337040781975,
0.41439399123191833,
-1.0957061052322388,
0.5188035368919373,
0.1992914229631424,
0.6823318004608154,
0.2451334148645401,
0.5020222663879395,
0.894437849521637,
-0.5931796431541443,
0.18017342686653137,
0.23814909160137177,
0.4998297393321991,
0.3459610342979431,
-0.8950453996658325,
0.48861685395240784,
0.15297985076904297,
-0.7000575065612793,
-0.574158787727356,
-0.1683509796857834,
-0.48309603333473206,
0.005196850746870041,
0.9710655212402344,
0.0273121390491724,
-0.06503642350435257,
-0.13665428757667542,
-0.5942517518997192,
0.11153597384691238,
-0.7955401539802551,
0.858934760093689,
0.6617332100868225,
-0.4609466791152954,
-0.2965746819972992,
-0.4985685348510742,
0.594480574131012,
0.6219766736030579,
-0.6902251839637756,
-0.09456382691860199,
0.4734937846660614,
-0.029321352019906044,
0.20071466267108917,
0.48613980412483215,
0.49778908491134644,
0.6147433519363403,
-0.40900418162345886,
-0.2268967628479004,
-0.6308913826942444,
-0.40119698643684387,
-0.35690054297447205,
-0.31919065117836,
0.3482447564601898,
-0.01201524306088686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07859v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07859v2 | Lissard: Long and Simple Sequential Reasoning Datasets | 2024-02-12T18:10:17 | 2024-02-20T15:12:13 | Mirelle Bueno, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models are now capable of solving tasks that require dealing with
long sequences consisting of hundreds of thousands of tokens. However, they
often fail on tasks that require repetitive use of simple rules, even on
sequences that are much shorter than those seen during training. For example,
state-of-the-art LLMs can find common items in two lists with up to 20 items
but fail when lists have 80 items. In this paper, we introduce Lissard, a
benchmark comprising seven tasks whose goal is to assess the ability of models
to process and generate wide-range sequence lengths, requiring repetitive
procedural execution. Our evaluation of open-source (Mistral-7B and
Mixtral-8x7B) and proprietary models (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) show a consistent
decline in performance across all models as the complexity of the sequence
increases. The datasets and code are available at
https://github.com/unicamp-dl/Lissard | [
-0.3091573119163513,
-0.37961089611053467,
0.598757266998291,
0.4929050803184509,
-0.13598234951496124,
-0.06626652926206589,
-0.22036518156528473,
-0.23385192453861237,
-0.22913001477718353,
0.6746701002120972,
-0.48507925868034363,
-0.4742969572544098,
-0.5125547647476196,
0.3297951817512512,
-0.8133086562156677,
0.9410502910614014,
-0.14815478026866913,
0.12313412129878998,
-0.08664286136627197,
-0.3377149999141693,
-0.5889856219291687,
-0.2957466244697571,
-0.44495606422424316,
-0.17227375507354736,
0.37446293234825134,
0.47576650977134705,
0.7317402958869934,
0.6055157780647278,
0.369681715965271,
0.26680269837379456,
-0.06124242767691612,
0.511377215385437,
-0.6568878889083862,
0.5385385155677795,
-0.38297170400619507,
-0.20376800000667572,
-0.5028938055038452,
-0.25660818815231323,
0.755335807800293,
1.0509400367736816,
-0.14321936666965485,
0.32273024320602417,
0.17316004633903503,
0.6892836093902588,
-0.30272161960601807,
-0.043343715369701385,
-0.2967894673347473,
-0.13798363506793976,
-0.47284674644470215,
0.26804298162460327,
-0.450446218252182,
-0.24107006192207336,
-0.02358410693705082,
-0.7831345200538635,
0.1632034033536911,
0.253279447555542,
0.3865496814250946,
0.14286014437675476,
-0.3962482213973999,
-0.5814799070358276,
-0.7684632539749146,
0.8967094421386719,
-0.6423114538192749,
0.49918052554130554,
0.20595352351665497,
0.1188434511423111,
-0.46387147903442383,
-0.9692419171333313,
-0.36004891991615295,
-0.2763218283653259,
0.13380078971385956,
-0.3142525851726532,
-0.17811141908168793,
0.024218032136559486,
1.0047694444656372,
0.08406378328800201,
-0.835537314414978,
-0.1311287134885788,
-0.48623204231262207,
-0.042068831622600555,
0.4484659433364868,
0.5950627326965332,
0.033919621258974075,
-0.2629149556159973,
-0.22653821110725403,
0.18463566899299622,
-0.7393460869789124,
0.03881388157606125,
0.3873542547225952,
0.13064631819725037,
0.08015915751457214,
0.5562567114830017,
-0.5183617472648621,
0.7970154285430908,
-0.08950300514698029,
0.0568973682820797,
0.16019490361213684,
-0.37188956141471863,
-0.1388639658689499,
-0.5355080366134644,
0.7304206490516663,
0.14598441123962402,
0.38135096430778503,
-0.11910894513130188,
-0.492217481136322,
-0.05010076239705086,
-0.07098539918661118,
-0.703377366065979,
-0.29954156279563904,
0.23327161371707916,
-0.23729699850082397,
-0.060778722167015076,
-0.2857753336429596,
-0.5427176356315613,
-0.4125625789165497,
-0.46486836671829224,
0.11798562109470367,
-0.43747177720069885,
0.16342195868492126,
0.28532588481903076,
0.010964135639369488,
-0.04682007059454918,
0.3309212327003479,
-0.6077495813369751,
0.9231129884719849,
0.851557731628418,
0.9087613224983215,
-0.42547038197517395,
-0.31958043575286865,
-0.7912424802780151,
-0.3448505103588104,
-0.49317607283592224,
0.6816738247871399,
-0.3266453444957733,
-0.4446716010570526,
-0.35547855496406555,
0.19241724908351898,
0.13939134776592255,
-0.5942128896713257,
0.6571445465087891,
-0.4847804009914398,
-0.19239243865013123,
-0.6351872682571411,
-0.4802402853965759,
-0.054730307310819626,
0.05110706388950348,
-0.8418318033218384,
1.3339470624923706,
0.11331494152545929,
-0.5558858513832092,
0.23236307501792908,
-0.3064802885055542,
-0.4891488254070282,
0.06419332325458527,
-0.19936919212341309,
-0.27466049790382385,
0.11252328753471375,
-0.07831107079982758,
0.39657148718833923,
-0.9005197882652283,
0.5506267547607422,
-0.4192900061607361,
-0.3771544098854065,
0.27231016755104065,
-0.3913422226905823,
0.6355315446853638,
0.27570581436157227,
-0.3816691040992737,
-0.0465923435986042,
-0.9452546238899231,
0.07601407170295715,
-0.08287420123815536,
-0.25849834084510803,
-0.1446266919374466,
0.15980155766010284,
0.08130982518196106,
0.4791322350502014,
-0.10857291519641876,
-0.3408607840538025,
0.3422372341156006,
-0.29240888357162476,
0.4458824098110199,
0.7897762060165405,
-0.2363668829202652,
0.37314021587371826,
-0.754715621471405,
0.5756027698516846,
0.12427522242069244,
-0.1424068808555603,
-0.06542487442493439,
-0.5886378884315491,
-0.9802935719490051,
-0.12170913070440292,
0.37920933961868286,
0.536508321762085,
-0.866035521030426,
-0.025164853781461716,
-0.5361851453781128,
-0.28672361373901367,
-0.21090196073055267,
0.6170067191123962,
0.4710380733013153,
0.3950985372066498,
0.19128942489624023,
-0.7037931084632874,
-0.5900917053222656,
-0.8214832544326782,
-0.21798425912857056,
0.2943352460861206,
0.023541230708360672,
0.1714758276939392,
0.7232383489608765,
-0.021427219733595848,
0.8689192533493042,
-0.06766942143440247,
0.23375362157821655,
-0.14939574897289276,
0.1956080049276352,
0.6402423977851868,
0.33609554171562195,
0.09219229966402054,
-0.3367931544780731,
-0.3185769021511078,
-0.18270358443260193,
-0.7511464357376099,
-0.18296490609645844,
-0.013056901283562183,
0.04647479206323624,
0.26519957184791565,
0.28399670124053955,
-0.7396814227104187,
0.4248203933238983,
0.3503853976726532,
-0.18390460312366486,
0.6435790657997131,
-0.09938513487577438,
-0.02792087197303772,
-0.8154129385948181,
0.22172045707702637,
-0.11692653596401215,
-0.5214150547981262,
-0.7184093594551086,
-0.22957894206047058,
-0.0320945642888546,
-0.2604596018791199,
-0.3519744575023651,
0.7852570414543152,
-0.6497789621353149,
-0.3910876214504242,
0.0035359167959541082,
0.01480394322425127,
-0.07686244696378708,
0.37648141384124756,
0.000821136636659503,
0.6154295206069946,
0.36354413628578186,
-0.6625658869743347,
0.7622779011726379,
-0.020613783970475197,
-0.7156952619552612,
0.3543039858341217,
-0.945702850818634,
0.3232119083404541,
-0.03439488634467125,
0.1567845642566681,
-0.9859874248504639,
-0.28383496403694153,
0.2143343687057495,
-0.11678586155176163,
0.14402855932712555,
-0.06249713897705078,
-0.5374897122383118,
-0.4298197627067566,
-0.26917701959609985,
0.7557764649391174,
0.6343987584114075,
-0.3157438635826111,
0.4353258013725281,
-0.13654084503650665,
-0.23225365579128265,
-0.823850154876709,
-0.6322925686836243,
-0.09241271764039993,
-0.04503330960869789,
-0.8857935667037964,
-0.013074100948870182,
-0.16546131670475006,
-0.4361771047115326,
0.038319334387779236,
-0.09102831780910492,
0.3066255748271942,
0.09041033685207367,
0.5022063255310059,
-0.07640769332647324,
-0.3688233196735382,
0.22324830293655396,
-0.2705281972885132,
-0.30233874917030334,
-0.16173017024993896,
-0.4851076006889343,
0.5525131821632385,
-0.12990999221801758,
-0.7039685249328613,
0.052088502794504166,
0.5393781661987305,
0.5667197704315186,
0.08749668300151825,
0.32218751311302185,
0.19799219071865082,
-0.39604291319847107,
-0.7865498661994934,
-0.48764142394065857,
0.05945604667067528,
-0.4181285798549652,
0.4123266637325287,
-0.4296721816062927,
-0.6093277931213379,
0.6830700039863586,
-0.032295744866132736,
0.043648917227983475,
0.2598094940185547,
0.5313066840171814,
0.07054378092288971,
0.7845655679702759,
0.10283390432596207,
-0.16407912969589233,
-0.07611936330795288,
-0.2771356701850891,
0.13753777742385864,
-0.6063385009765625,
0.073825903236866,
-0.2999210059642792,
-0.27371102571487427,
-0.6170264482498169,
-0.8566727638244629,
0.2735397219657898,
0.264812707901001,
-0.49027857184410095,
0.268613338470459,
-0.43931636214256287,
0.5265487432479858,
0.678525447845459,
-0.10733022540807724,
0.4588969051837921,
-0.1667909175157547,
-0.2519024908542633,
0.18231642246246338,
-0.6494043469429016,
-0.5748988389968872,
1.3398641347885132,
0.14986447989940643,
0.9570804238319397,
0.09308390319347382,
0.6126618981361389,
0.4526848793029785,
0.28178179264068604,
-0.6147913932800293,
0.7290897369384766,
-0.19593848288059235,
-0.580208420753479,
-0.38086840510368347,
-0.27936848998069763,
-0.9834008812904358,
-0.012109123170375824,
0.10640138387680054,
-0.5512863993644714,
0.07986853271722794,
0.1220807209610939,
-0.35709306597709656,
-0.035518065094947815,
-0.1313459575176239,
0.7884584069252014,
-0.277804434299469,
-0.553536593914032,
0.11990807950496674,
-0.5266449451446533,
0.6182001829147339,
-0.10934893786907196,
0.46726083755493164,
-0.3936740756034851,
0.12056944519281387,
0.7649718523025513,
-0.6156238317489624,
0.7166040539741516,
0.014065775088965893,
0.28152400255203247,
0.2096197009086609,
0.30747684836387634,
0.665591835975647,
0.05264439433813095,
-0.09908632189035416,
0.0017090118490159512,
0.010039512999355793,
-0.5030671954154968,
-0.42951709032058716,
0.6899164915084839,
-0.5203754305839539,
-0.436029851436615,
-0.6865695714950562,
-0.5902928709983826,
-0.2688886821269989,
0.13201390206813812,
0.3320658206939697,
0.8805125951766968,
-0.2214450091123581,
-0.05249499902129173,
0.7174651026725769,
0.035360876470804214,
0.3508716821670532,
0.24438555538654327,
-0.3731940984725952,
-0.449383020401001,
0.701100766658783,
0.18556499481201172,
0.44344308972358704,
-0.11364644020795822,
-0.20283271372318268,
-0.05402136966586113,
-0.723226010799408,
-0.4847988784313202,
0.17459936439990997,
-1.0254361629486084,
-0.2633292078971863,
-0.22906556725502014,
-0.10729139298200607,
-0.31401726603507996,
0.12262919545173645,
-0.16001425683498383,
-0.5796251893043518,
-0.18735972046852112,
0.1462753415107727,
0.322953999042511,
1.1959843635559082,
-0.05737816169857979,
-0.0809146985411644,
-0.6453261971473694,
0.4204334318637848,
0.3598175644874573,
0.28818410634994507,
-0.006150893401354551,
-0.5402957797050476,
-0.007099099922925234,
0.04748537763953209,
-0.3998088836669922,
-0.6722164154052734,
0.42018598318099976,
0.07912758737802505,
0.5827958583831787,
0.10952170938253403,
-0.09869134426116943,
0.48114991188049316,
-0.6686683893203735,
0.6590011119842529,
0.0348830446600914,
-1.0547479391098022,
0.07993347942829132,
-0.5188826322555542,
0.28983741998672485,
0.2638965845108032,
0.5802180171012878,
-0.8753390908241272,
-0.02869916334748268,
-0.387302964925766,
-0.7781473994255066,
0.5865529775619507,
0.13014402985572815,
-0.2335406243801117,
-0.2290993332862854,
0.1411544233560562,
0.10605747252702713,
0.027588535100221634,
-0.4508875608444214,
-0.1687048226594925,
0.11883034557104111,
-0.40428832173347473,
-0.1659172922372818,
-0.3434765934944153,
-0.08059488981962204,
-0.12405848503112793,
0.6823769807815552,
-0.1397680789232254,
0.16150064766407013,
-0.056524500250816345,
-0.4195910394191742,
0.1573021411895752,
0.3300016522407532,
0.9461954236030579,
0.766334593296051,
0.06916815787553787,
-0.01388288289308548,
0.364168643951416,
-0.33894237875938416,
0.25649863481521606,
0.13559554517269135,
-0.05343693494796753,
0.1564948558807373,
0.507333517074585,
0.6417913436889648,
0.5722164511680603,
-0.7431710362434387,
0.48136523365974426,
0.13694627583026886,
-0.25093844532966614,
-0.4264371395111084,
-0.25245800614356995,
0.3258391320705414,
0.17688940465450287,
0.030653389170765877,
0.04363417625427246,
0.2934704124927521,
-0.4475459158420563,
0.32697999477386475,
0.16937255859375,
-0.15016598999500275,
-0.2587965726852417,
0.5178180932998657,
0.21528133749961853,
-0.2723633348941803,
0.9216464757919312,
-0.524377167224884,
-0.34516364336013794,
0.6051352620124817,
0.21291008591651917,
0.5910977125167847,
-0.07951859384775162,
-0.06316210329532623,
0.26075688004493713,
0.15789029002189636,
-0.7176259160041809,
0.5268193483352661,
-0.0732366293668747,
-0.6771803498268127,
-0.4989224374294281,
-0.6792982220649719,
-0.394624799489975,
0.00012451354996301234,
-0.5795914530754089,
0.560361921787262,
-0.5552608966827393,
-0.10830630362033844,
0.09975805878639221,
-0.23770414292812347,
-0.8664713501930237,
-0.16018277406692505,
0.0008205235935747623,
0.9522548317909241,
-0.6987385749816895,
0.747469425201416,
0.1529167741537094,
-0.3074209690093994,
-0.6981211304664612,
-0.7299968004226685,
0.33662936091423035,
-0.7532196640968323,
1.2007966041564941,
0.0045731100253760815,
0.017711862921714783,
-0.30465930700302124,
-0.327289342880249,
-0.9791709184646606,
1.0376579761505127,
0.17576263844966888,
-1.019327998161316,
-0.45173031091690063,
0.45527973771095276,
0.3682449758052826,
-0.2605346441268921,
0.3285357654094696,
0.7135796546936035,
0.24907632172107697,
0.07722773402929306,
-1.2878222465515137,
0.09827820956707001,
-0.22554601728916168,
0.07494037598371506,
0.46913400292396545,
-0.19563406705856323,
1.2729367017745972,
-0.07672356814146042,
-0.07872218638658524,
0.5871332883834839,
0.34557923674583435,
0.38578635454177856,
0.3943553864955902,
0.38155052065849304,
0.864569365978241,
0.9016866087913513,
-0.24239999055862427,
0.9930233359336853,
-0.26560020446777344,
0.4016752541065216,
1.2623227834701538,
-0.4769282042980194,
0.7529309988021851,
0.020386487245559692,
-0.14153386652469635,
0.44584494829177856,
0.5042206645011902,
0.10875201970338821,
0.32028335332870483,
0.7575029134750366,
-0.2634616196155548,
-0.49730148911476135,
0.2942645251750946,
-0.13009339570999146,
0.003368971636518836,
0.5520032048225403,
-0.3701924681663513,
-0.30512985587120056,
0.13307832181453705,
-0.11885883659124374,
-0.050152696669101715,
-0.2951081097126007,
0.5622193217277527,
0.48625314235687256,
-0.7255963683128357,
0.799678385257721,
-0.18342088162899017,
0.5347996950149536,
-0.29046228528022766,
-0.16784940659999847,
-0.22280770540237427,
0.28016263246536255,
-0.1452186554670334,
-0.6399477124214172,
0.05295297130942345,
-0.05252331122756004,
-0.2527979612350464,
-0.21870110929012299,
0.6668406128883362,
-0.2999013662338257,
-0.5545199513435364,
0.1391739398241043,
0.49819573760032654,
0.26490283012390137,
0.2872612774372101,
-0.5042735934257507,
0.10488513112068176,
-0.2389058917760849,
-0.350572794675827,
0.14292849600315094,
0.5267160534858704,
-0.5179974436759949,
0.8500443696975708,
0.5376088619232178,
0.2296696901321411,
0.15689407289028168,
-0.03626669943332672,
0.8509231805801392,
-0.7607557773590088,
-0.11673566699028015,
-0.6885849237442017,
0.5169119834899902,
-0.23888377845287323,
-0.4643658399581909,
0.6329812407493591,
0.716331422328949,
0.8319887518882751,
0.008248879574239254,
0.770372211933136,
0.05230605974793434,
0.929677426815033,
-0.6356079578399658,
0.20443807542324066,
-0.10811971873044968,
0.5776073932647705,
-0.031681593507528305,
-0.7068666815757751,
-0.07000980526208878,
0.40635401010513306,
-0.4226301908493042,
0.11114329099655151,
0.8234441876411438,
0.8196238279342651,
-0.23684680461883545,
-0.044581979513168335,
0.4497978091239929,
0.10693157464265823,
0.13713163137435913,
0.8981091380119324,
1.0350759029388428,
-0.2925325334072113,
0.34462326765060425,
-0.2080131322145462,
0.11916433274745941,
-0.094230517745018,
-0.8953114748001099,
-0.9467467665672302,
-0.6488495469093323,
-0.0031390024814754725,
-0.6335831880569458,
0.28345993161201477,
1.1215693950653076,
0.7165977954864502,
-0.8856218457221985,
-0.4832431375980377,
-0.14196306467056274,
0.13788209855556488,
-0.052159152925014496,
-0.11641208827495575,
0.02117656171321869,
-0.3660880923271179,
-0.4348396956920624,
0.3347335457801819,
0.18951651453971863,
-0.2272186577320099,
-0.06324223428964615,
-0.18192347884178162,
0.1177983507514,
0.012080084532499313,
0.3963545560836792,
0.49213406443595886,
-0.8918986320495605,
-0.3345966935157776,
0.19971613585948944,
-0.1464255154132843,
-0.1921262890100479,
1.102312684059143,
-0.6818732619285583,
0.3463011085987091,
0.7412763237953186,
0.47249287366867065,
0.6575973629951477,
-0.029200930148363113,
0.6251803040504456,
-0.5657166838645935,
-0.07880336046218872,
0.5233754515647888,
0.629270613193512,
0.1995159089565277,
0.18279771506786346,
0.5536423325538635,
0.4801611602306366,
-0.7875742316246033,
-0.8761886954307556,
0.26487842202186584,
-1.034279704093933,
-0.06946633011102676,
1.3501018285751343,
-0.19584131240844727,
-0.137826070189476,
-0.46346569061279297,
0.0012412851210683584,
-0.24471566081047058,
-0.3918599486351013,
0.2036646157503128,
0.9756681323051453,
-0.18360958993434906,
0.04847773164510727,
-0.8640188574790955,
0.7367373704910278,
0.3393593728542328,
-0.6132897734642029,
0.24511535465717316,
0.5498560070991516,
0.8164399266242981,
0.08962312340736389,
0.8676906824111938,
0.19399377703666687,
0.6264333128929138,
0.004963407758623362,
-0.062247589230537415,
-0.06778719276189804,
-0.25414925813674927,
-0.4964582622051239,
-0.004989094100892544,
0.3458605408668518,
0.2296472191810608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07844v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07844v4 | Mercury: A Code Efficiency Benchmark for Code Large Language Models | 2024-02-12T17:53:22 | 2024-06-11T17:44:56 | Mingzhe Du, Anh Tuan Luu, Bin Ji, Qian Liu, See-Kiong Ng | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Amidst the recent strides in evaluating Large Language Models for Code (Code
LLMs), existing benchmarks have mainly focused on the functional correctness of
generated code, neglecting the importance of their computational efficiency. To
fill the gap, we present Mercury, the first code efficiency benchmark for Code
LLMs. It comprises 1,889 Python tasks, each accompanied by adequate solutions
that serve as real-world efficiency baselines, enabling a comprehensive
analysis of the runtime distribution. Based on the distribution, we introduce a
new metric Beyond, which computes a runtime-percentile-weighted Pass score to
reflect functional correctness and code efficiency simultaneously. On Mercury,
leading Code LLMs can achieve 65% on Pass, while less than 50% on Beyond. Given
that an ideal Beyond score would be aligned with the Pass score, it indicates
that while Code LLMs exhibit impressive capabilities in generating functionally
correct code, there remains a notable gap in their efficiency. Finally, our
empirical experiments reveal that Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) serves
as a robust baseline for enhancing code efficiency compared with Supervised
Fine Tuning (SFT), which paves a promising avenue for future exploration of
efficient code generation. Our code and data are available on GitHub:
https://github.com/Elfsong/Mercury. | [
-0.1312711089849472,
-0.44625040888786316,
0.728817880153656,
0.18378856778144836,
-0.1368553787469864,
-0.04265058413147926,
-0.7576876282691956,
0.0858675092458725,
-0.0679904893040657,
0.49318817257881165,
-0.41575732827186584,
-0.8688229322433472,
-0.40298590064048767,
0.060088906437158585,
-0.016314225271344185,
0.5806577205657959,
0.13850559294223785,
-0.39387959241867065,
-0.3926732540130615,
0.12164410948753357,
-0.23807324469089508,
-0.48077186942100525,
-0.04506264999508858,
-0.20886234939098358,
0.6458996534347534,
0.5550176501274109,
0.7461118102073669,
0.977472722530365,
0.9043586254119873,
0.2493779957294464,
0.06619074940681458,
0.1286315768957138,
-0.5467314124107361,
0.16455648839473724,
0.14332786202430725,
-0.31336912512779236,
-0.683448314666748,
0.03143954649567604,
0.5811764001846313,
0.49066439270973206,
-0.02485540695488453,
0.4706399738788605,
-0.010926867835223675,
0.9309857487678528,
-0.9620698094367981,
0.31334158778190613,
-0.6151426434516907,
0.00705652916803956,
-0.21811866760253906,
-0.4493272602558136,
-0.385883092880249,
-0.5831448435783386,
-0.3832891285419464,
-0.8299935460090637,
-0.40813201665878296,
-0.25965598225593567,
0.2048226147890091,
0.8549408912658691,
-0.16854527592658997,
-0.20216122269630432,
-0.26257801055908203,
0.8365209698677063,
-0.7468071579933167,
0.41951316595077515,
0.2752726674079895,
-0.09272976219654083,
-0.13055117428302765,
-0.7394047379493713,
-0.46979308128356934,
-0.6970577239990234,
0.1511978954076767,
0.1127612441778183,
-0.2917397916316986,
0.046171240508556366,
0.43376389145851135,
0.7032814621925354,
-0.5894109606742859,
-0.012057294137775898,
-0.004886806942522526,
0.016395440325140953,
0.5056241154670715,
0.10927340388298035,
0.05866868048906326,
-0.08664587140083313,
0.05348562076687813,
-0.24120526015758514,
-0.619803786277771,
0.0932169109582901,
0.43278035521507263,
0.31013453006744385,
-0.08283697068691254,
0.5877960324287415,
-0.15166978538036346,
0.6115201711654663,
-0.14651504158973694,
-0.11809883266687393,
0.43092867732048035,
0.16174980998039246,
-0.2159298211336136,
-0.1334877461194992,
0.47981974482536316,
0.428029328584671,
0.1870638132095337,
-0.14140325784683228,
-0.09259150177240372,
0.52525794506073,
0.6283473968505859,
-0.900357723236084,
-0.46947410702705383,
0.29305410385131836,
-0.4530351459980011,
-0.36848655343055725,
0.13675473630428314,
-0.14299878478050232,
-0.5781921744346619,
-0.43320703506469727,
0.07429085671901703,
-0.2690548002719879,
-0.33563026785850525,
0.18793541193008423,
0.011283804662525654,
0.15528719127178192,
-0.019563892856240273,
-0.5285541415214539,
0.13914185762405396,
1.4094655513763428,
0.7746263146400452,
-0.5163443088531494,
-0.23097948729991913,
-0.8861048817634583,
-0.29254794120788574,
-0.5660477876663208,
0.5498924255371094,
-0.49163976311683655,
-0.2800962030887604,
0.020130127668380737,
-0.1993505209684372,
0.17842067778110504,
-0.8422325849533081,
0.6367334127426147,
-0.441575825214386,
-0.3711511790752411,
-0.3522786796092987,
-0.5999566316604614,
-0.10004904121160507,
0.26529279351234436,
-0.5104985237121582,
1.2802982330322266,
0.3998597264289856,
-0.6775380969047546,
0.48927128314971924,
-0.5495867133140564,
-0.411884605884552,
0.2747047543525696,
0.03948087990283966,
-0.2893974781036377,
0.29790234565734863,
-0.14259067177772522,
0.3674613833427429,
-0.17648018896579742,
0.2484508752822876,
-0.6028993725776672,
-0.755630612373352,
0.3285394310951233,
-0.18196430802345276,
0.3851015567779541,
0.43022623658180237,
-0.3788459300994873,
0.14510424435138702,
-0.6464929580688477,
0.3255566358566284,
-0.2660961151123047,
-0.7419322729110718,
-0.46510419249534607,
0.05255941301584244,
-0.07346998900175095,
0.05302657559514046,
0.3932735025882721,
-0.39502665400505066,
0.39138299226760864,
-0.14114300906658173,
0.3527454733848572,
0.874648928642273,
-0.4184408187866211,
0.39035189151763916,
-0.45340096950531006,
0.5339327454566956,
-0.45801687240600586,
0.2362905740737915,
-0.2016625702381134,
-0.2666245996952057,
-0.619717538356781,
-0.6569069623947144,
0.13348810374736786,
0.6584266424179077,
-0.49505385756492615,
0.7242743372917175,
-0.1961132138967514,
-0.6673864126205444,
-0.40855759382247925,
0.3067706227302551,
0.5516467690467834,
0.2773095369338989,
0.09256571531295776,
-0.1778232306241989,
-0.3755350410938263,
-0.891591489315033,
-0.41202765703201294,
-0.3164418637752533,
0.11971692740917206,
0.4484959840774536,
0.42472678422927856,
-0.4983738660812378,
0.7440365552902222,
-0.7660213112831116,
0.2962525486946106,
-0.10775432735681534,
-0.3362063467502594,
0.6931096315383911,
0.4479558765888214,
0.30419281125068665,
-0.6531883478164673,
-0.4485635459423065,
0.08306757360696793,
-0.6471719741821289,
-0.6289252042770386,
0.22494091093540192,
-0.3225262761116028,
0.366931289434433,
0.3985770046710968,
-0.04307304322719574,
-0.11020587384700775,
0.9240633845329285,
-0.18763120472431183,
0.5579319000244141,
-0.4549846053123474,
0.3232995271682739,
-0.6700071096420288,
0.38823139667510986,
-0.07850381731987,
-0.3184678554534912,
-0.34163394570350647,
0.3952931761741638,
0.43253791332244873,
-0.03701183572411537,
-0.40862685441970825,
0.2583548128604889,
-0.23887382447719574,
-0.2536766231060028,
-0.30513685941696167,
-0.13698530197143555,
-0.2487303912639618,
0.582853376865387,
-0.06540850549936295,
1.061273455619812,
0.6236842274665833,
-0.7025854587554932,
0.3342466652393341,
-0.27218520641326904,
-0.2997114658355713,
0.4145532250404358,
-0.5254437923431396,
0.20226378738880157,
0.2850009500980377,
0.015478863380849361,
-0.7929240465164185,
-0.045311979949474335,
0.024696845561265945,
-0.26459774374961853,
0.09414831548929214,
0.06916450709104538,
-0.546730637550354,
-0.5458569526672363,
-0.7094309329986572,
0.39701125025749207,
0.8662810325622559,
-0.6144642233848572,
-0.023319033905863762,
0.4944652318954468,
0.00366282369941473,
-0.6022542119026184,
-0.6329150795936584,
-0.034524064511060715,
-0.3404427766799927,
-0.6034843325614929,
0.29296597838401794,
-0.33600914478302,
-0.3985069990158081,
-0.18639148771762848,
-0.39473187923431396,
0.09196988493204117,
0.28907322883605957,
0.3339468538761139,
0.021021459251642227,
-0.1379852443933487,
0.09545686841011047,
-0.08431150019168854,
-0.4125407636165619,
0.023809749633073807,
-0.4644799828529358,
0.5787646770477295,
-0.35916414856910706,
-0.3113100528717041,
-0.39900195598602295,
-0.04310505837202072,
0.5265880823135376,
-0.011619861237704754,
0.2582956552505493,
0.014087767340242863,
0.05645895004272461,
-0.2929886281490326,
-0.5186567306518555,
0.08821806311607361,
-0.5130525231361389,
0.2769116461277008,
-0.34598058462142944,
-0.8473842144012451,
0.45821303129196167,
-0.14969612658023834,
0.29691529273986816,
0.35644641518592834,
0.6590638756752014,
0.27124181389808655,
0.6501607894897461,
0.7038734555244446,
-0.17832234501838684,
0.5490096807479858,
-0.2995249927043915,
-0.20868906378746033,
-0.5733670592308044,
0.17474551498889923,
-0.41157835721969604,
-0.14267311990261078,
-0.9148581027984619,
-0.7879883050918579,
0.5361874103546143,
0.030170505866408348,
-0.5103150606155396,
0.47767776250839233,
-0.7598264813423157,
0.4546149969100952,
0.7560536861419678,
0.13909728825092316,
0.5238861441612244,
-0.3067593276500702,
0.14391407370567322,
-0.048328835517168045,
-0.579584538936615,
-0.5345170497894287,
1.0603673458099365,
0.18703323602676392,
0.8397502303123474,
-0.20888592302799225,
0.8815097212791443,
0.8086898922920227,
0.4405592978000641,
-0.682668149471283,
0.45304015278816223,
-0.3357265591621399,
-0.23528406023979187,
0.10637862980365753,
-0.8044026494026184,
-0.6552409529685974,
0.2195359319448471,
0.12342746555805206,
-0.19934825599193573,
-0.1232302114367485,
0.28084126114845276,
-0.2596319615840912,
0.05071243643760681,
-0.503318727016449,
1.1841975450515747,
-0.2095671147108078,
-0.4056112468242645,
-0.3178132474422455,
-0.24524050951004028,
0.4848617613315582,
-0.27312713861465454,
0.2351435124874115,
-0.12382397055625916,
-0.3933592140674591,
0.47900521755218506,
-0.5803060531616211,
0.2843681275844574,
-0.13728003203868866,
-0.28092724084854126,
0.2515988349914551,
0.15588034689426422,
0.27061963081359863,
0.06750225275754929,
-0.4415196180343628,
0.1561528742313385,
-0.19239990413188934,
-0.30725520849227905,
-0.23682670295238495,
0.856738805770874,
-0.5844794511795044,
-0.11183012276887894,
-0.3951374590396881,
-0.5378618836402893,
0.13916297256946564,
0.0803494080901146,
0.1228322759270668,
0.5438322424888611,
0.00466528395190835,
0.08670230209827423,
0.5097516775131226,
-0.6181023716926575,
0.32312414050102234,
0.49419960379600525,
-0.118678517639637,
-0.4445975720882416,
0.8790085911750793,
-0.1703961193561554,
0.21120716631412506,
0.33432114124298096,
0.2867097854614258,
-0.22202417254447937,
-0.3153362572193146,
-0.3490312695503235,
0.32188794016838074,
-0.5619590878486633,
-0.25947704911231995,
-0.34459084272384644,
0.18738166987895966,
-0.2797512114048004,
-0.48757973313331604,
-0.5634068250656128,
-0.3021664321422577,
0.013700868934392929,
0.24224014580249786,
0.41392505168914795,
0.5958505868911743,
-0.2546418607234955,
0.3076825737953186,
-0.7088518142700195,
0.42817559838294983,
0.11683638393878937,
0.5937151312828064,
-0.3210718631744385,
-0.5081440210342407,
-0.34312158823013306,
-0.2532433271408081,
-0.4676094949245453,
-0.4368588924407959,
0.18402129411697388,
0.056987300515174866,
0.6144482493400574,
0.22478613257408142,
0.3287315368652344,
0.5250876545906067,
-0.2656325101852417,
0.717806339263916,
-0.012323053553700447,
-1.146767020225525,
0.3509741425514221,
-0.4801649749279022,
0.33540499210357666,
0.7833701372146606,
-0.1673981100320816,
-0.5490192770957947,
-0.5517619848251343,
-0.4921775758266449,
-0.7660127282142639,
0.6855812072753906,
0.18156182765960693,
-0.029702216386795044,
-0.010034528560936451,
0.35106539726257324,
0.2301311045885086,
0.3361370861530304,
-0.7030048966407776,
-0.3478708863258362,
0.14913994073867798,
-0.1572304517030716,
-0.18082067370414734,
0.011917553842067719,
0.26413974165916443,
-0.21906299889087677,
0.6568747758865356,
-0.20361579954624176,
0.09232642501592636,
-0.07760687172412872,
-0.3022712171077728,
-0.0777108371257782,
0.19318705797195435,
0.5261043310165405,
0.7245140075683594,
-0.2831178605556488,
0.19716611504554749,
0.0440116748213768,
-0.5638749599456787,
-0.10702463984489441,
0.033217236399650574,
0.14232592284679413,
-0.37125441431999207,
0.4134182333946228,
0.2974119484424591,
0.05103375390172005,
-0.9072898030281067,
0.47376757860183716,
0.03522547334432602,
-0.07984592765569687,
-0.17317479848861694,
0.3709094524383545,
-0.04906507581472397,
0.34714269638061523,
0.335529625415802,
-0.30949667096138,
0.25731024146080017,
-0.5787990093231201,
0.32712841033935547,
0.345232218503952,
-0.17468246817588806,
-0.042671240866184235,
0.6060522794723511,
0.18440838158130646,
-0.21580234169960022,
0.5346409678459167,
-0.33061760663986206,
-0.5890461802482605,
0.7446731925010681,
0.23495523631572723,
0.9798147678375244,
0.22345511615276337,
-0.027979521080851555,
0.29394838213920593,
0.3207244873046875,
-0.1960953325033188,
0.5579373240470886,
-0.38591593503952026,
-0.15705855190753937,
-0.720452070236206,
-0.6937872171401978,
-0.7226548194885254,
-0.2675190269947052,
-0.4552234411239624,
0.2801651358604431,
-0.24195614457130432,
-0.1547255963087082,
-0.3659178614616394,
0.3818099796772003,
-0.2563086450099945,
-0.040802426636219025,
0.5890058279037476,
1.0338802337646484,
-0.5903620719909668,
0.7502996921539307,
0.6148435473442078,
0.11054296791553497,
-0.6821468472480774,
-0.09164460003376007,
-0.19137555360794067,
-0.6474741697311401,
0.38256585597991943,
0.4354690909385681,
-0.20688220858573914,
-0.16768191754817963,
-0.43334293365478516,
-0.6123448014259338,
0.8434205055236816,
0.5968061089515686,
-0.5295138955116272,
0.4684670865535736,
0.10858319699764252,
0.38432398438453674,
-0.3029876947402954,
0.3255566358566284,
0.8772859573364258,
0.7136767506599426,
-0.22098217904567719,
-0.8810733556747437,
-0.031593501567840576,
-0.4987039864063263,
0.1856224238872528,
0.38720235228538513,
-0.5221747159957886,
0.9094231128692627,
-0.21318534016609192,
0.03020704723894596,
0.16059455275535583,
0.3043679893016815,
0.595920979976654,
0.545820415019989,
0.5612853765487671,
0.6694200038909912,
0.7931890487670898,
-0.20912835001945496,
1.3166279792785645,
-0.7318129539489746,
0.446706622838974,
0.4721614420413971,
-0.2629244327545166,
0.696501612663269,
0.16588081419467926,
-0.2946486473083496,
0.35416486859321594,
0.5454024076461792,
0.1464509814977646,
0.5667722225189209,
0.6454012989997864,
0.07888613641262054,
-0.4610341489315033,
0.21235418319702148,
-0.5780460834503174,
0.32979318499565125,
-0.09084367752075195,
-0.12061040848493576,
0.09831223636865616,
-0.2724910080432892,
0.13694357872009277,
0.2639445662498474,
-0.47560015320777893,
0.6189329624176025,
0.11425984650850296,
-0.9380785226821899,
0.9027686715126038,
-0.05521644279360771,
1.0630745887756348,
-0.5384979844093323,
0.17332029342651367,
-0.31261327862739563,
0.6719644665718079,
-0.3455183506011963,
-0.7377341985702515,
0.2106933742761612,
0.2979087829589844,
-0.2983821630477905,
-0.3657743036746979,
0.3637678623199463,
-0.14195643365383148,
-0.3755386471748352,
0.2215067744255066,
0.2885235548019409,
0.33079665899276733,
-0.4063927233219147,
-0.5532355308532715,
0.411260187625885,
-0.16838012635707855,
-0.36450278759002686,
0.12590165436267853,
0.35091832280158997,
0.2800321877002716,
0.41990652680397034,
0.7649461627006531,
0.08296684175729752,
0.08763669431209564,
-0.07501149922609329,
1.0065011978149414,
-0.7821601033210754,
-0.7852868437767029,
-1.0102782249450684,
0.34821945428848267,
-0.07786290347576141,
-0.48510828614234924,
0.8487873673439026,
0.9586670398712158,
0.6641806364059448,
-0.12471536546945572,
0.6437093019485474,
-0.08389745652675629,
0.45713192224502563,
-0.24462752044200897,
0.5256088376045227,
-0.7952376008033752,
0.27544447779655457,
-0.7622819542884827,
-1.2634203433990479,
-0.3904525339603424,
0.6261345148086548,
-0.3688223361968994,
-0.044021207839250565,
0.606084942817688,
0.8246818780899048,
-0.09071122109889984,
-0.16545554995536804,
0.28137558698654175,
-0.15571169555187225,
0.30705153942108154,
0.8728346824645996,
1.081221103668213,
-0.08831989020109177,
0.4143997132778168,
-0.38690823316574097,
-0.5637248158454895,
-0.3584652841091156,
-1.1260113716125488,
-0.4856739044189453,
-0.19197088479995728,
-0.4014627933502197,
-0.22542575001716614,
-0.04001559317111969,
0.9930422902107239,
0.7373221516609192,
-0.4140259325504303,
-0.44018155336380005,
-0.23301181197166443,
0.08824224770069122,
-0.5801892280578613,
-0.15319481492042542,
0.3382216691970825,
-0.6024458408355713,
-0.5685921311378479,
0.33661606907844543,
0.3695051968097687,
-0.7092763781547546,
-0.08017441630363464,
-0.44045910239219666,
0.5310592651367188,
-0.01899043470621109,
0.6751331090927124,
0.13554328680038452,
-0.3193410336971283,
-0.02412208914756775,
0.3705563545227051,
-0.4687400162220001,
0.0652129203081131,
1.1932028532028198,
-0.7426754236221313,
0.1436598151922226,
0.6029249429702759,
0.720595121383667,
0.19888563454151154,
0.15246956050395966,
0.3580145835876465,
-0.36408838629722595,
-0.01072082482278347,
0.16836923360824585,
0.0806780532002449,
0.2648179829120636,
-0.2679029405117035,
0.625850260257721,
0.134805366396904,
-1.0003184080123901,
-1.0498651266098022,
0.10142166167497635,
-1.209249496459961,
-0.2675705850124359,
1.4995254278182983,
-0.08666513860225677,
-0.2781495749950409,
0.2423696517944336,
-0.1738489717245102,
0.22338557243347168,
-0.5942788124084473,
0.5799824595451355,
0.24122966825962067,
-0.12952911853790283,
0.2982563078403473,
-0.5813737511634827,
0.4332113564014435,
0.31302475929260254,
-0.9246829152107239,
0.6170201897621155,
0.7249380946159363,
0.1509523242712021,
-0.05584482103586197,
0.7792685031890869,
0.06979183107614517,
0.4937806725502014,
-0.036184072494506836,
0.13654333353042603,
-0.2862359881401062,
-0.29835426807403564,
-0.3652333915233612,
0.08985240012407303,
0.28164350986480713,
-0.12780095636844635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07841v1 | Do Membership Inference Attacks Work on Large Language Models? | 2024-02-12T17:52:05 | 2024-02-12T17:52:05 | Michael Duan, Anshuman Suri, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Sewon Min, Weijia Shi, Luke Zettlemoyer, Yulia Tsvetkov, Yejin Choi, David Evans, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Membership inference attacks (MIAs) attempt to predict whether a particular
datapoint is a member of a target model's training data. Despite extensive
research on traditional machine learning models, there has been limited work
studying MIA on the pre-training data of large language models (LLMs). We
perform a large-scale evaluation of MIAs over a suite of language models (LMs)
trained on the Pile, ranging from 160M to 12B parameters. We find that MIAs
barely outperform random guessing for most settings across varying LLM sizes
and domains. Our further analyses reveal that this poor performance can be
attributed to (1) the combination of a large dataset and few training
iterations, and (2) an inherently fuzzy boundary between members and
non-members. We identify specific settings where LLMs have been shown to be
vulnerable to membership inference and show that the apparent success in such
settings can be attributed to a distribution shift, such as when members and
non-members are drawn from the seemingly identical domain but with different
temporal ranges. We release our code and data as a unified benchmark package
that includes all existing MIAs, supporting future work. | [
-0.3602412939071655,
-0.6117193102836609,
0.5029473900794983,
-0.21996799111366272,
-0.30479952692985535,
0.08793242275714874,
0.22026805579662323,
-0.6619508862495422,
0.18192723393440247,
0.3757648766040802,
-0.9961592555046082,
-0.4175867438316345,
-0.753977358341217,
0.09182318300008774,
-0.5878204107284546,
0.5654120445251465,
0.6861984133720398,
0.27657151222229004,
-0.1925402283668518,
-0.1412486582994461,
-0.2390827089548111,
-0.9552337527275085,
-0.3904818892478943,
0.0023279739543795586,
0.49798157811164856,
0.035895586013793945,
0.8607422113418579,
0.4820674657821655,
0.45549046993255615,
0.2759207487106323,
-0.058358628302812576,
-0.12486116588115692,
-0.5439130663871765,
0.145002543926239,
-0.15310221910476685,
-0.9544951915740967,
-0.2483368217945099,
-0.043571390211582184,
0.698046088218689,
0.7916176319122314,
-0.07358473539352417,
-0.011421623639762402,
-0.17741933465003967,
0.4286274015903473,
-0.6988719701766968,
-0.08019183576107025,
-1.1123125553131104,
0.10252606123685837,
-0.380633682012558,
0.10613927990198135,
-0.6084832549095154,
-0.021215150132775307,
0.12074515968561172,
0.01426923181861639,
0.21271824836730957,
0.15598389506340027,
0.8996002078056335,
0.20927436649799347,
-0.5451713800430298,
-0.2275802195072174,
-0.3196033239364624,
0.8300232291221619,
-1.0843100547790527,
0.6028207540512085,
0.5496185421943665,
0.417282372713089,
-0.5910547375679016,
-0.1670960783958435,
-0.5587115287780762,
-0.27426594495773315,
0.0034451852552592754,
-0.19646872580051422,
-0.23900829255580902,
0.10913696885108948,
0.35812604427337646,
0.28067684173583984,
-0.3878333866596222,
0.5534867644309998,
-0.15235131978988647,
0.07786024361848831,
0.6414963603019714,
0.24397817254066467,
0.21842679381370544,
-0.21708503365516663,
-0.4563569128513336,
0.07429647445678711,
-0.8994657397270203,
-0.36556360125541687,
0.445624440908432,
0.2996750771999359,
-0.24566364288330078,
0.5649135708808899,
-0.07675113528966904,
0.7020877599716187,
-0.16291281580924988,
-0.023405179381370544,
0.015759581699967384,
-0.1121605858206749,
-0.4171448349952698,
-0.3639081120491028,
0.7763049602508545,
0.12583090364933014,
0.3245260715484619,
-0.4643952548503876,
-0.4268496036529541,
-0.12263298779726028,
0.08895301073789597,
-0.6910873055458069,
-0.19461628794670105,
0.0875723659992218,
-0.41489288210868835,
-0.12692753970623016,
0.49608081579208374,
-0.8245554566383362,
-0.512771487236023,
-0.123291976749897,
0.42391011118888855,
-0.22982452809810638,
-0.04453285038471222,
0.10864382237195969,
-0.10543910413980484,
0.15846776962280273,
0.26468920707702637,
-0.678264856338501,
0.20708416402339935,
0.7913650274276733,
0.7669951319694519,
-0.05492505431175232,
-0.4171898066997528,
-0.5853145718574524,
0.03215128183364868,
-0.2711402475833893,
0.6627589464187622,
-0.7391571998596191,
-0.37706616520881653,
0.17997917532920837,
-0.20999924838542938,
-0.5705810189247131,
-0.5183443427085876,
0.09134204685688019,
-0.9357145428657532,
-0.10211840271949768,
-0.2327623963356018,
-0.7249022126197815,
0.23717346787452698,
0.08015519380569458,
-0.7140448093414307,
0.6138458251953125,
0.22163592278957367,
-0.8642123341560364,
0.4952572286128998,
-0.28808170557022095,
-0.19851315021514893,
-0.3504737615585327,
-0.059692494571208954,
-0.35010647773742676,
0.5089460611343384,
-0.02625451050698757,
0.5289802551269531,
-0.3025464713573456,
-0.10678944736719131,
-0.7049259543418884,
-0.39883697032928467,
0.8900036811828613,
-0.5431771874427795,
0.8931941986083984,
0.25191348791122437,
-0.4136447608470917,
-0.047027554363012314,
-0.5031408667564392,
-0.057539284229278564,
0.12954610586166382,
-0.15489667654037476,
-0.366004079580307,
0.43335530161857605,
-0.3601897060871124,
0.35665351152420044,
-0.09230517596006393,
-0.27886226773262024,
0.499227911233902,
-0.37540486454963684,
0.23138390481472015,
0.9408677816390991,
0.12100620567798615,
0.2347216159105301,
-0.24062050879001617,
0.7026898860931396,
-0.06490229070186615,
0.1883535385131836,
0.10992410778999329,
-0.2532464563846588,
-0.7433574795722961,
-0.5312309265136719,
0.6029307246208191,
0.13215011358261108,
-0.7681018710136414,
0.6192559599876404,
-0.3146882951259613,
-0.551872193813324,
-0.23282913863658905,
-0.11318974196910858,
0.2633182108402252,
-0.1590377241373062,
0.231862872838974,
-0.15522649884223938,
-0.09061332046985626,
-0.8896427154541016,
-0.29757949709892273,
-0.365553081035614,
-0.31881624460220337,
0.1520264446735382,
0.7391090989112854,
-0.24720795452594757,
0.8608531951904297,
-0.4033738374710083,
-0.11893779039382935,
-0.14259818196296692,
0.033197857439517975,
0.038474537432193756,
0.3209545612335205,
0.9437677264213562,
-0.511735200881958,
-0.21209868788719177,
-0.31841713190078735,
-0.45231738686561584,
-0.1582881361246109,
-0.24873490631580353,
-0.06852402538061142,
0.48714759945869446,
0.3742392659187317,
-0.8247803449630737,
0.5980221629142761,
0.9055591821670532,
-0.6291369199752808,
0.6218889355659485,
0.2369992733001709,
0.09540120512247086,
-1.0212243795394897,
0.018904149532318115,
-0.3438514471054077,
-0.1634938269853592,
-0.6566539406776428,
0.42964550852775574,
-0.07057023793458939,
0.09334934502840042,
-0.27848994731903076,
0.3781980574131012,
-0.606391191482544,
-0.34516414999961853,
-0.0990201011300087,
-0.2956913113594055,
-0.3064247965812683,
0.3805878758430481,
-0.1811639666557312,
0.581787645816803,
0.7313424348831177,
-0.5629682540893555,
-0.1707960069179535,
0.1877797693014145,
-0.6715521216392517,
0.40447908639907837,
-0.3300302028656006,
0.48469865322113037,
0.11855067312717438,
0.335419625043869,
-0.9241538643836975,
-0.411843478679657,
0.32308122515678406,
-0.5700467824935913,
0.30487576127052307,
-0.36359378695487976,
-0.6636279821395874,
-0.14580532908439636,
-0.398727685213089,
0.13042427599430084,
0.2260124832391739,
-0.6144099831581116,
0.5896907448768616,
0.3990061581134796,
0.0917767658829689,
-0.8213909268379211,
-0.6532520651817322,
0.22560377418994904,
-0.4604147970676422,
-0.5109522342681885,
-0.18560880422592163,
-0.08570481091737747,
-0.4285484254360199,
-0.2128930538892746,
-0.38544127345085144,
-0.35984739661216736,
0.6234148740768433,
0.23904100060462952,
-0.008646361529827118,
-0.18561339378356934,
0.016139846295118332,
-0.22830289602279663,
0.27958932518959045,
0.4016241133213043,
0.0831499993801117,
0.8309451341629028,
0.2863306999206543,
-0.8016495108604431,
-0.4508608281612396,
0.4686262905597687,
0.8586239218711853,
-0.29729676246643066,
1.2917569875717163,
-0.02266610786318779,
-0.36652058362960815,
-0.6096855401992798,
-0.47585439682006836,
-0.24008050560951233,
-0.4794906675815582,
0.5841444134712219,
-0.40942704677581787,
-0.8846102952957153,
0.7677941918373108,
0.1564514935016632,
0.31945350766181946,
0.33849993348121643,
0.20554333925247192,
-0.14477141201496124,
1.094408392906189,
0.5781047940254211,
-0.4908958077430725,
0.4535362422466278,
-0.08876922726631165,
0.14379602670669556,
-0.31005236506462097,
-0.22233334183692932,
-1.1001017093658447,
-0.3110464811325073,
-0.26097625494003296,
-0.6479194164276123,
0.04694322496652603,
0.3457929790019989,
-0.0875527560710907,
0.2342020571231842,
0.2943320572376251,
0.47888487577438354,
0.24264821410179138,
-0.07516859471797943,
0.13577179610729218,
0.1287832409143448,
0.17474114894866943,
0.11961198598146439,
-0.9014390110969543,
-0.1293378621339798,
0.8790076971054077,
0.4428354799747467,
0.9062674045562744,
0.4956474006175995,
0.6169959306716919,
0.4728739857673645,
0.4743365943431854,
-0.8397560715675354,
0.5409305691719055,
0.16676177084445953,
-0.7475691437721252,
-0.23251599073410034,
-0.7461711764335632,
-0.9289230704307556,
0.4050775170326233,
-0.39679473638534546,
-0.8762329816818237,
0.5238555073738098,
-0.029516547918319702,
0.07102988660335541,
0.4541725814342499,
-0.506156861782074,
0.7076297402381897,
-0.14300629496574402,
0.16817139089107513,
-0.24250955879688263,
-0.7770630717277527,
0.34862565994262695,
-0.5351978540420532,
0.23670002818107605,
-0.13229022920131683,
0.026277795433998108,
0.700090229511261,
-0.5300331711769104,
1.0488710403442383,
-0.24897873401641846,
-0.1468638777732849,
0.1582033932209015,
0.4694689214229584,
0.3901534676551819,
0.010464341379702091,
-0.52275151014328,
0.7575110197067261,
-0.016832107678055763,
-0.42340943217277527,
-0.5730581879615784,
0.3745448589324951,
-0.6227654218673706,
-0.8262431025505066,
-0.532321572303772,
-0.3912322521209717,
-0.46310940384864807,
-0.01628757268190384,
0.08076225966215134,
0.30597949028015137,
-0.1376870572566986,
0.48689547181129456,
0.31296736001968384,
-0.022185303270816803,
0.31443458795547485,
0.6264272332191467,
-0.09102094918489456,
-0.29284778237342834,
0.5883827209472656,
0.08793485164642334,
0.6979564428329468,
0.27350056171417236,
-0.13707134127616882,
-0.13224896788597107,
-0.9490070343017578,
-0.4183271527290344,
0.32761043310165405,
-0.6163744330406189,
-0.479735791683197,
-0.4053576588630676,
-0.12695854902267456,
-0.3018093407154083,
0.03551527485251427,
-0.20876076817512512,
-0.3422321379184723,
-0.16514255106449127,
-0.012026057578623295,
-0.041020799428224564,
0.7521424889564514,
0.2083059400320053,
0.7430002689361572,
-1.0659136772155762,
-0.07658284157514572,
0.02902069129049778,
0.2503942847251892,
0.009463871829211712,
-0.7247664928436279,
-0.3602030575275421,
0.10994184762239456,
0.1853717416524887,
-1.2321125268936157,
0.15959486365318298,
0.3720380961894989,
0.6725430488586426,
0.9480400681495667,
0.0967632457613945,
0.5699449181556702,
-0.5634852647781372,
0.8721121549606323,
-0.004220533184707165,
-0.9759189486503601,
0.035285502672195435,
-0.4312659204006195,
0.18213148415088654,
0.7225825786590576,
0.485480934381485,
-0.34283939003944397,
-0.509680449962616,
-0.6741985082626343,
-0.3761080205440521,
0.8949704170227051,
0.31106194853782654,
0.4063494801521301,
-0.19963887333869934,
0.3908711075782776,
-0.05227544158697128,
0.21629072725772858,
-0.6202986240386963,
-0.3331422507762909,
0.3798999488353729,
0.06635070592164993,
-0.11706235259771347,
-0.33536481857299805,
0.03782246634364128,
0.06757575273513794,
0.4266452491283417,
-0.2047397643327713,
0.24300356209278107,
-0.1605352759361267,
-0.05601184442639351,
-0.3008984327316284,
0.0022233661729842424,
0.2978411316871643,
1.0496715307235718,
0.02901333197951317,
-0.022576648741960526,
0.16743342578411102,
-0.17618431150913239,
-0.10349541902542114,
-0.019521331414580345,
0.09999284893274307,
0.16938725113868713,
0.7805154323577881,
0.5664516687393188,
0.22647656500339508,
-0.9214574098587036,
0.5577376484870911,
-0.19151978194713593,
-0.1771140843629837,
-0.05461234599351883,
0.2254083752632141,
0.22665032744407654,
0.11826130747795105,
0.31892478466033936,
0.1307464987039566,
-0.11938569694757462,
-0.8467773795127869,
0.26127126812934875,
0.943581223487854,
-0.19569453597068787,
-0.529115617275238,
0.4163595139980316,
-0.07734773308038712,
-0.3200218975543976,
0.6814593076705933,
0.36374738812446594,
-0.8646255731582642,
0.7034838199615479,
0.4648450016975403,
0.5429643392562866,
-0.7451534867286682,
0.11184891313314438,
0.02021983452141285,
0.5179017186164856,
0.3090350925922394,
-0.1561478227376938,
-0.0574340745806694,
-0.670941948890686,
-0.20792607963085175,
-0.8853324055671692,
-0.30044353008270264,
0.25909388065338135,
-0.6830577850341797,
0.12658151984214783,
-0.44978997111320496,
-0.061467014253139496,
-0.1394938975572586,
-0.1588025987148285,
-0.4421826899051666,
0.232377290725708,
0.19239582121372223,
1.1355847120285034,
-0.860997200012207,
0.8053426146507263,
0.38692712783813477,
0.1039358526468277,
-0.5906949043273926,
0.4559537172317505,
0.13588647544384003,
-0.6106443405151367,
0.5845860838890076,
0.14546167850494385,
-0.11942046880722046,
-0.3716695308685303,
-0.556233823299408,
-0.9495322108268738,
0.6769269704818726,
0.6331703662872314,
-0.4881354570388794,
-0.18606014549732208,
0.5028780102729797,
0.44874656200408936,
-0.07177256047725677,
-0.030903389677405357,
0.6099464297294617,
0.21487030386924744,
0.020219868049025536,
-0.8664653897285461,
-0.1722981333732605,
-0.017115894705057144,
-0.4865848422050476,
0.4047694504261017,
-0.746704638004303,
0.9638434052467346,
0.09388075023889542,
-0.29831036925315857,
0.2951691448688507,
0.7469645142555237,
0.12391625344753265,
0.10633159428834915,
0.9182569980621338,
0.46324244141578674,
0.8023556470870972,
0.007276548538357019,
1.1893856525421143,
-0.10258635133504868,
0.32173335552215576,
1.075911045074463,
-0.5460207462310791,
0.8495616316795349,
0.3322784900665283,
-0.2816295027732849,
0.11893903464078903,
0.7037245631217957,
0.022284748032689095,
0.4174344837665558,
0.4040731191635132,
-0.3343189060688019,
-0.45539456605911255,
0.17341729998588562,
-0.42970654368400574,
0.5730555057525635,
0.5181592702865601,
-0.40186870098114014,
-0.15896262228488922,
-0.3989073932170868,
0.14057444036006927,
-0.38579171895980835,
-0.11669814586639404,
0.7522318959236145,
0.2810094952583313,
-0.3855161666870117,
0.49208396673202515,
0.1233711689710617,
0.38768234848976135,
-0.9982852935791016,
-0.056136976927518845,
-0.34573617577552795,
0.14353898167610168,
-0.0406990647315979,
-0.2620398998260498,
0.18886713683605194,
0.026015937328338623,
0.1988472044467926,
0.31578168272972107,
0.5008702874183655,
-0.1791873425245285,
-0.2645777463912964,
0.41813722252845764,
0.580357551574707,
0.189618319272995,
-0.16557154059410095,
-0.6769279837608337,
0.049614470452070236,
0.09004110842943192,
-0.5997874140739441,
0.7550421953201294,
0.4438456594944,
-0.0794927105307579,
0.6881227493286133,
0.6972699761390686,
0.12177637219429016,
0.1773117035627365,
-0.02484099753201008,
1.0712076425552368,
-0.34039828181266785,
-0.43237829208374023,
-1.0181621313095093,
0.2018609344959259,
-0.14640364050865173,
-0.28227394819259644,
0.9423655271530151,
0.43959641456604004,
0.9345495104789734,
-0.19250762462615967,
0.3670809864997864,
0.001671183155849576,
0.09982883930206299,
-0.9957900047302246,
1.0736474990844727,
-0.6114115118980408,
0.42225390672683716,
-0.27351340651512146,
-1.2759253978729248,
-0.41399943828582764,
0.42098915576934814,
-0.20889949798583984,
0.17874738574028015,
0.7053065896034241,
0.8777673840522766,
-0.029757561162114143,
0.019262798130512238,
0.5286944508552551,
0.25494250655174255,
0.444030225276947,
0.17931410670280457,
1.1437325477600098,
-0.03663177043199539,
0.09868369251489639,
-0.06430412828922272,
0.006986140739172697,
-0.22453084588050842,
-0.5992857813835144,
-1.4039340019226074,
-0.23013700544834137,
0.02457517571747303,
-0.368243008852005,
0.29430368542671204,
0.9037853479385376,
0.7619186043739319,
-0.7841750383377075,
-0.1044803038239479,
0.3378390967845917,
-0.025591649115085602,
0.07027051597833633,
-0.2038567066192627,
0.5029048323631287,
0.011423895135521889,
-0.7977356314659119,
0.7100908160209656,
-0.2715252935886383,
-0.19209320843219757,
-0.23270215094089508,
0.027310432866215706,
-0.39673805236816406,
0.46525201201438904,
0.21743237972259521,
0.017129523679614067,
-0.533083438873291,
-0.620196521282196,
-0.20745640993118286,
-0.044507961720228195,
-0.10095389187335968,
0.8854511976242065,
-0.473285049200058,
-0.052226919680833817,
0.387023001909256,
0.874014675617218,
-0.13634584844112396,
0.2706602215766907,
0.4251308739185333,
-0.8292042016983032,
0.15183253586292267,
0.3165033757686615,
0.6655307412147522,
-0.039848875254392624,
-0.43269458413124084,
0.48213350772857666,
0.24153225123882294,
-0.4673959016799927,
-1.1179720163345337,
0.17812299728393555,
-0.8730448484420776,
-0.6499947905540466,
0.9429898858070374,
-0.42643821239471436,
-0.25532597303390503,
-0.08186616003513336,
0.1255980283021927,
-0.1292959302663803,
-0.15825147926807404,
0.9203736186027527,
0.7750042676925659,
0.14391697943210602,
0.22152550518512726,
-0.619759738445282,
0.30667033791542053,
0.6350811719894409,
-0.9090492725372314,
0.3893262445926666,
0.8898393511772156,
0.41165676712989807,
-0.044657059013843536,
0.27473172545433044,
0.06918326020240784,
0.24331627786159515,
0.03439732640981674,
-0.18871983885765076,
0.048816513270139694,
-0.6393193006515503,
-0.617855966091156,
0.27759748697280884,
0.14514227211475372,
0.1960257589817047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07827v1 | Aya Model: An Instruction Finetuned Open-Access Multilingual Language Model | 2024-02-12T17:34:13 | 2024-02-12T17:34:13 | Ahmet Üstün, Viraat Aryabumi, Zheng-Xin Yong, Wei-Yin Ko, Daniel D'souza, Gbemileke Onilude, Neel Bhandari, Shivalika Singh, Hui-Lee Ooi, Amr Kayid, Freddie Vargus, Phil Blunsom, Shayne Longpre, Niklas Muennighoff, Marzieh Fadaee, Julia Kreutzer, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in large language models (LLMs) have centered around a
handful of data-rich languages. What does it take to broaden access to
breakthroughs beyond first-class citizen languages? Our work introduces Aya, a
massively multilingual generative language model that follows instructions in
101 languages of which over 50% are considered as lower-resourced. Aya
outperforms mT0 and BLOOMZ on the majority of tasks while covering double the
number of languages. We introduce extensive new evaluation suites that broaden
the state-of-art for multilingual eval across 99 languages -- including
discriminative and generative tasks, human evaluation, and simulated win rates
that cover both held-out tasks and in-distribution performance. Furthermore, we
conduct detailed investigations on the optimal finetuning mixture composition,
data pruning, as well as the toxicity, bias, and safety of our models. We
open-source our instruction datasets and our model at
https://hf.co/CohereForAI/aya-101 | [
0.07444258779287338,
-0.8439992070198059,
0.3247433304786682,
0.3362504839897156,
0.2840019464492798,
-0.015984760597348213,
-0.45728248357772827,
-0.2089265137910843,
-0.13045775890350342,
0.5583776831626892,
-0.7380818724632263,
-0.6160508990287781,
-0.4645393192768097,
-0.04396952688694,
-0.48963090777397156,
0.652867317199707,
0.049536384642124176,
0.3575495481491089,
-0.07441042363643646,
-0.14601144194602966,
-0.2869955599308014,
-0.44962844252586365,
-0.47440099716186523,
-0.23423759639263153,
0.42692333459854126,
0.8846003413200378,
0.558009922504425,
0.815342366695404,
0.41612857580184937,
0.27083155512809753,
-0.15325979888439178,
0.01924271509051323,
-0.3219479024410248,
0.08699491620063782,
0.04197192192077637,
-0.8033114671707153,
-0.515087902545929,
-0.2100462019443512,
0.7705823183059692,
0.8099699020385742,
-0.5662524104118347,
0.296273410320282,
-0.04971209540963173,
0.7799076437950134,
-0.7099049091339111,
0.406509667634964,
-0.4301331341266632,
0.023306777700781822,
-0.46817341446876526,
0.22602233290672302,
-0.5313361883163452,
-0.43552783131599426,
0.130479633808136,
-0.6229562163352966,
0.13231298327445984,
-0.12999878823757172,
0.4307159185409546,
0.10769026726484299,
-0.109420046210289,
-0.4652102291584015,
-0.6400638818740845,
0.9100615382194519,
-0.5767247080802917,
0.5086227059364319,
0.23678916692733765,
0.6072958111763,
0.18872393667697906,
-0.5447011590003967,
-0.4067309498786926,
-0.476541131734848,
0.3067031800746918,
0.028343496844172478,
-0.30238059163093567,
0.28158390522003174,
-0.05343662574887276,
0.6186268329620361,
-0.3726111352443695,
0.3804346024990082,
-0.47109535336494446,
0.015403630211949348,
0.4514663815498352,
0.3446859121322632,
0.33177459239959717,
-0.07168572396039963,
-0.22529777884483337,
-0.06466172635555267,
-0.8111488223075867,
-0.14687925577163696,
0.39250892400741577,
0.5245170593261719,
-0.38457775115966797,
0.6453374028205872,
-0.29979783296585083,
0.649236798286438,
-0.32572171092033386,
-0.08641977608203888,
0.03269238397479057,
-0.24205023050308228,
-0.1766919195652008,
-0.09258580207824707,
0.8157789707183838,
-0.1110159233212471,
0.2674376666545868,
-0.14730486273765564,
0.05609586089849472,
-0.10679226368665695,
0.15303853154182434,
-0.9425507187843323,
-0.3156779110431671,
-0.0339919812977314,
-0.5029106140136719,
-0.025861315429210663,
-0.20070786774158478,
-0.893074631690979,
-0.5749656558036804,
-0.3160586655139923,
0.4008914530277252,
-0.27769267559051514,
-0.243510439991951,
0.34510236978530884,
0.3082943558692932,
-0.009621131233870983,
0.5104759335517883,
-1.0542569160461426,
0.2684815227985382,
0.6355533003807068,
0.8813959956169128,
-0.11197850853204727,
-0.5852140188217163,
-0.3778071105480194,
-0.1198350116610527,
-0.4135875105857849,
0.294337660074234,
-0.5545886754989624,
-0.3736039996147156,
0.21947583556175232,
0.08191075921058655,
-0.09877729415893555,
-0.5940344333648682,
0.2245231717824936,
-0.504438042640686,
0.2058197557926178,
-0.364990234375,
-0.30516496300697327,
-0.3457059860229492,
0.16542886197566986,
-0.8138288259506226,
0.6729190945625305,
0.11369752883911133,
-0.43332019448280334,
-0.02474505454301834,
-1.096712350845337,
-0.353087842464447,
0.16336731612682343,
0.04667960852384567,
-0.08498281985521317,
0.19746099412441254,
-0.0479322150349617,
0.15387102961540222,
-0.5205137729644775,
0.12699933350086212,
-0.25383245944976807,
-0.1636611968278885,
0.22484581172466278,
-0.9834805130958557,
0.9939692616462708,
0.25436365604400635,
-0.27358439564704895,
0.5346642732620239,
-0.609348714351654,
-0.11720128357410431,
0.10548153519630432,
-0.4994617700576782,
-0.1768679916858673,
-0.20055808126926422,
0.26914483308792114,
0.10632539540529251,
0.2912791073322296,
-0.5029650926589966,
0.4374662935733795,
-0.4036029279232025,
0.4498513340950012,
0.6474641561508179,
-0.16295018792152405,
0.4939197301864624,
-0.0442296639084816,
0.7947002649307251,
-0.1446954309940338,
0.46852239966392517,
-0.5460111498832703,
-0.4211496412754059,
-1.0720031261444092,
-0.20736545324325562,
0.4352240562438965,
0.7494183778762817,
-0.6641301512718201,
0.06968053430318832,
-0.2430383861064911,
-0.41739600896835327,
-1.20801842212677,
0.4269639253616333,
0.6614246368408203,
0.11771881580352783,
0.36505210399627686,
-0.2341955453157425,
-0.27768611907958984,
-0.904488742351532,
0.08486834168434143,
-0.08251722902059555,
0.1171419695019722,
0.18129898607730865,
0.2885936498641968,
-0.38246849179267883,
0.4553804099559784,
-0.527026355266571,
-0.23040296137332916,
-0.45876649022102356,
-0.1507118195295334,
-0.04832688346505165,
0.3431304693222046,
0.39188867807388306,
-0.4166847765445709,
-0.4292683005332947,
0.016266001388430595,
-0.7498053312301636,
0.15276344120502472,
0.21094264090061188,
-0.2712264060974121,
0.15983305871486664,
0.32740920782089233,
-0.5463675260543823,
0.17448154091835022,
0.5771015286445618,
0.025044778361916542,
0.4595199227333069,
-0.40858885645866394,
0.15451139211654663,
-0.9758933782577515,
0.08153276890516281,
-0.04409810155630112,
0.059854187071323395,
-0.757391095161438,
0.64311683177948,
0.14220334589481354,
-0.3898334801197052,
-0.6272268891334534,
0.5453959703445435,
-0.48647016286849976,
-0.039995014667510986,
-0.30108505487442017,
-0.16569779813289642,
-0.0705060064792633,
0.27612078189849854,
-0.007666654419153929,
0.8138332962989807,
0.7443450093269348,
-0.541321337223053,
0.4580230414867401,
0.17733708024024963,
-0.6954367160797119,
0.024128103628754616,
-0.503118634223938,
-0.03439533710479736,
-0.2557092607021332,
0.04915817081928253,
-0.6625855565071106,
-0.3931231200695038,
0.21327941119670868,
-0.10194705426692963,
0.3636971116065979,
-0.08024020493030548,
-0.5209394693374634,
-0.1827705204486847,
-0.13022466003894806,
0.3988257944583893,
0.3663676977157593,
-0.7810203433036804,
0.20944352447986603,
0.3718391954898834,
-0.1767476499080658,
-0.6443041563034058,
-0.8542750477790833,
0.08847922831773758,
-0.1419810950756073,
-0.321525901556015,
-0.0361814945936203,
-0.1829460710287094,
-0.27129364013671875,
-0.01548281405121088,
0.12164849787950516,
-0.21672548353672028,
0.31610217690467834,
0.00015025139146018773,
0.11419392377138138,
-0.4109116494655609,
0.1103849858045578,
0.006210306193679571,
-0.02388189174234867,
0.0016814798582345247,
-0.27479082345962524,
0.6601220369338989,
-0.27571791410446167,
-0.6114434599876404,
-0.526153028011322,
0.45049217343330383,
0.6831035017967224,
-0.4427678883075714,
0.8836193680763245,
0.489248663187027,
-0.5950554013252258,
-0.21665151417255402,
-0.2736607491970062,
0.06401341408491135,
-0.43670278787612915,
0.6502384543418884,
-0.18673843145370483,
-0.7189359068870544,
0.3848128616809845,
0.07092525064945221,
0.32786139845848083,
0.5025628209114075,
0.6007816791534424,
0.32131099700927734,
0.9321983456611633,
0.863329291343689,
-0.2558268904685974,
0.6156022548675537,
-0.4654529392719269,
-0.025921646505594254,
-0.4458286166191101,
-0.40196695923805237,
-0.5153544545173645,
0.014737250283360481,
-0.46857181191444397,
-0.63009113073349,
0.465069442987442,
0.23087811470031738,
-0.11573035269975662,
0.08472220599651337,
-0.138442724943161,
0.5439147353172302,
0.6959620118141174,
0.0722334235906601,
0.3690947890281677,
0.06711491197347641,
0.12979581952095032,
-0.04006199166178703,
-0.8961843252182007,
-0.4469861388206482,
1.16795814037323,
0.49459782242774963,
0.9937184453010559,
0.30358976125717163,
0.557608425617218,
0.2673678696155548,
0.693061113357544,
-1.028718113899231,
0.29546165466308594,
-0.506209671497345,
-0.8983463644981384,
-0.3365773558616638,
-0.5224724411964417,
-0.8129054307937622,
0.21970759332180023,
0.004629465285688639,
-0.6356824636459351,
-0.1630283147096634,
0.17297156155109406,
-0.2938140034675598,
0.19017256796360016,
-0.9145933985710144,
1.1820966005325317,
-0.43502023816108704,
-0.3111650347709656,
-0.533674955368042,
-0.405048668384552,
0.7182944416999817,
0.09053356945514679,
0.45863044261932373,
0.028167258948087692,
-0.018572412431240082,
0.48523077368736267,
-0.25660911202430725,
0.8586291670799255,
-0.3033350110054016,
-0.22173382341861725,
0.40946662425994873,
-0.06262144446372986,
-0.02301817387342453,
-0.08596137166023254,
-0.22103312611579895,
0.17786000669002533,
-0.21350806951522827,
-0.4748140871524811,
-0.47871243953704834,
0.8105987310409546,
-0.6426359415054321,
-0.44688680768013,
-0.14691133797168732,
-0.4910339117050171,
0.07550468295812607,
0.07125343382358551,
0.323265939950943,
0.5497209429740906,
-0.3210807144641876,
0.25246232748031616,
0.7048097252845764,
-0.575638473033905,
0.39413347840309143,
0.7365273237228394,
-0.2708294689655304,
-0.3404443860054016,
1.2114022970199585,
0.152635857462883,
0.33497363328933716,
0.48207423090934753,
0.34829992055892944,
-0.306196004152298,
-0.3838749825954437,
-1.1031863689422607,
0.06664398312568665,
-0.8109212517738342,
-0.11809416860342026,
-0.4271726906299591,
-0.19286423921585083,
-0.14485470950603485,
0.2355649620294571,
-0.6357104778289795,
-0.3612236976623535,
-0.05027474835515022,
0.06089526787400246,
0.13560070097446442,
1.0747253894805908,
0.10054801404476166,
0.4584091901779175,
-0.7583598494529724,
0.2599075436592102,
0.23642487823963165,
0.46956881880760193,
0.44419562816619873,
-0.39296695590019226,
-0.5002852082252502,
0.20844636857509613,
-0.32408004999160767,
-1.0542160272598267,
0.2630408704280853,
0.3991170823574066,
0.6654884815216064,
0.39073583483695984,
-0.24626025557518005,
0.5314670205116272,
-0.6114509105682373,
0.6321274638175964,
0.20062032341957092,
-0.9423398971557617,
0.4500582814216614,
-0.24924752116203308,
0.4522583782672882,
0.562991738319397,
0.44155338406562805,
-0.7288644313812256,
-0.1479979008436203,
-0.32513096928596497,
-0.8660067915916443,
0.7443735003471375,
-0.20163658261299133,
0.2517843544483185,
0.12180446088314056,
0.2087572067975998,
0.2954653799533844,
0.4126703441143036,
-0.7396735548973083,
-0.5400302410125732,
-0.09497307240962982,
-0.38636669516563416,
-0.19676953554153442,
-0.16476178169250488,
-0.03268662840127945,
-0.22529296576976776,
0.5714619159698486,
-0.04752423241734505,
0.1260136365890503,
-0.36620190739631653,
-0.252739280462265,
-0.12127808481454849,
0.5765424966812134,
0.5807381272315979,
0.4848834276199341,
0.15561942756175995,
-0.10204467177391052,
0.14448188245296478,
-0.5861441493034363,
0.17693907022476196,
0.36214926838874817,
-0.4137963652610779,
-0.11230067908763885,
0.4654686748981476,
0.912678062915802,
0.32792744040489197,
-0.7833756804466248,
0.39838454127311707,
-0.0991416722536087,
0.05570245161652565,
-0.0742378979921341,
0.1483244150876999,
-0.04711095616221428,
0.12744052708148956,
0.369388222694397,
-0.046903979033231735,
0.3396604657173157,
-0.65231853723526,
-0.06390558928251266,
0.3392738699913025,
-0.42837271094322205,
-0.4215293526649475,
0.6585624814033508,
0.19459186494350433,
-0.1819695383310318,
0.4693233072757721,
-0.480275422334671,
-0.504895806312561,
0.4497203826904297,
0.4137870669364929,
0.8146425485610962,
-0.525233805179596,
0.18734556436538696,
0.4104616045951843,
0.4969725012779236,
-0.3543564975261688,
0.2640727460384369,
0.07787880301475525,
-0.3155456483364105,
-0.3924828767776489,
-0.691313624382019,
-0.7341791391372681,
0.3528325855731964,
-0.6759822368621826,
0.11126261204481125,
-0.2627362608909607,
0.3194202780723572,
-0.06829331070184708,
0.14181356132030487,
-0.5335673689842224,
0.04468296095728874,
0.1532769650220871,
0.9771820306777954,
-1.0584262609481812,
0.7844057679176331,
0.7769184708595276,
-0.3211592435836792,
-0.4889065623283386,
0.11203756928443909,
0.13962684571743011,
-0.6763977408409119,
0.09134314954280853,
0.3865925967693329,
0.1627742350101471,
0.10830868780612946,
-0.32924601435661316,
-0.7442638278007507,
0.8758642673492432,
0.9160547852516174,
-0.5738759636878967,
-0.1875583380460739,
-0.0026405996177345514,
0.445657342672348,
-0.25658154487609863,
0.2466890513896942,
0.5606634616851807,
0.2813730239868164,
-0.04389875754714012,
-0.7757570743560791,
-0.3462912142276764,
-0.32053279876708984,
-0.24601656198501587,
0.08668316900730133,
-0.7400335073471069,
0.728985071182251,
-0.4611983895301819,
-0.1848442554473877,
0.39202451705932617,
0.6800401210784912,
0.2833365797996521,
0.2565213143825531,
0.24502351880073547,
0.27514198422431946,
0.8369419574737549,
-0.06932363659143448,
1.206436038017273,
-0.3228573501110077,
0.03216852247714996,
0.9356184601783752,
0.16232292354106903,
0.97688227891922,
-0.09493174403905869,
-0.2613324522972107,
0.4627796709537506,
0.5129845142364502,
0.2786893844604492,
0.47501832246780396,
0.40575772523880005,
-0.514651894569397,
-0.12608851492404938,
-0.3912105858325958,
-0.5016883015632629,
0.6316326856613159,
0.5360685586929321,
-0.13370467722415924,
-0.19625353813171387,
0.12410204857587814,
-0.10810855776071548,
0.178510382771492,
-0.419021338224411,
0.5977388024330139,
0.004188193008303642,
-0.6711849570274353,
0.5850654244422913,
0.48163890838623047,
0.7390411496162415,
-0.5972110629081726,
-0.007086089812219143,
-0.31525787711143494,
0.2971126139163971,
-0.16297319531440735,
-0.45291006565093994,
0.1121177226305008,
0.3828645348548889,
-0.20278285443782806,
-0.22206436097621918,
0.45403003692626953,
-0.923133134841919,
-0.6275830864906311,
0.18637800216674805,
0.6017788648605347,
0.10736323893070221,
0.07706109434366226,
-0.6477617621421814,
0.17865273356437683,
-0.2277246117591858,
-0.14739759266376495,
0.2704724669456482,
0.22609220445156097,
-0.19303563237190247,
0.7165911793708801,
0.3251970112323761,
0.05464804172515869,
0.3671802282333374,
0.3907569348812103,
0.6251779794692993,
-0.4043908417224884,
-0.45324087142944336,
-0.6902999877929688,
0.3618340790271759,
0.28527387976646423,
-0.43740254640579224,
0.8649458289146423,
0.767686128616333,
0.7782557010650635,
-0.21386250853538513,
0.82912278175354,
0.13640883564949036,
0.2724135220050812,
-0.562146782875061,
0.8362088799476624,
-0.5134195685386658,
0.11641684919595718,
-0.039425838738679886,
-0.8096069097518921,
-0.009125081822276115,
0.43615663051605225,
-0.0325266495347023,
0.17578959465026855,
0.32977426052093506,
0.6343144178390503,
-0.16345936059951782,
-0.017282556742429733,
0.07439753413200378,
0.035304758697748184,
0.1026320606470108,
0.7011039853096008,
0.9338659644126892,
-0.37615329027175903,
0.5451322793960571,
-0.45673757791519165,
-0.2849811613559723,
-0.14177723228931427,
-0.5723513960838318,
-0.7331186532974243,
-0.4838109314441681,
-0.24730618298053741,
-0.06657590717077255,
0.052826445549726486,
0.9298378825187683,
0.7406490445137024,
-0.9437952041625977,
-0.5898465514183044,
-0.3031236231327057,
0.15067121386528015,
-0.16132694482803345,
-0.170993834733963,
0.17577560245990753,
-0.37313422560691833,
-0.974541962146759,
0.7545864582061768,
0.07869613915681839,
0.060026541352272034,
-0.734691321849823,
-0.31015074253082275,
0.0032350115943700075,
-0.12124386429786682,
0.49323171377182007,
0.3173852562904358,
-0.82132488489151,
0.26183655858039856,
0.23973257839679718,
-0.25543448328971863,
-0.23868428170681,
0.5769869089126587,
-0.23069071769714355,
0.663755476474762,
0.35264310240745544,
0.7229306697845459,
0.3998105227947235,
-0.061860259622335434,
0.5825466513633728,
-0.8194878101348877,
0.1386520266532898,
-0.09026134014129639,
0.0892702117562294,
0.5791212916374207,
0.038958337157964706,
0.3609713912010193,
0.030041266232728958,
-0.16236628592014313,
-0.8458914160728455,
0.1978316754102707,
-0.5599209070205688,
-0.16024470329284668,
1.144486904144287,
-0.34721818566322327,
-0.19015493988990784,
0.30752354860305786,
-0.10290122032165527,
0.3825058937072754,
-0.2480834275484085,
0.7797248363494873,
0.7069572806358337,
0.32061970233917236,
-0.3053990602493286,
-0.8402332067489624,
0.44783246517181396,
0.3499450981616974,
-1.094103455543518,
0.3261476755142212,
0.6406555771827698,
0.010876494459807873,
0.14520640671253204,
0.5338850021362305,
-0.025593407452106476,
0.5271731019020081,
-0.009213590994477272,
0.20365308225154877,
-0.1709972321987152,
-0.9626778364181519,
-0.8688015341758728,
0.20334842801094055,
0.5053614377975464,
-0.30447447299957275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07818v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07818v4 | Differentially Private Zeroth-Order Methods for Scalable Large Language Model Finetuning | 2024-02-12T17:24:15 | 2024-05-09T09:41:23 | Z Liu, J Lou, W Bao, Y Hu, B Li, Z Qin, K Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Fine-tuning on task-specific datasets is a widely-embraced paradigm of
harnessing the powerful capability of pretrained LLMs for various downstream
tasks. Due to the popularity of LLMs fine-tuning and its accompanying privacy
concerns, differentially private (DP) fine-tuning of pretrained LLMs has been
widely used to safeguarding the privacy of task-specific datasets. Lying at the
design core of DP LLM fine-tuning methods is the satisfactory tradeoff among
privacy, utility, and scalability. Most existing methods build upon the seminal
work of DP-SGD. Despite pushing the scalability of DP-SGD to its limit,
DP-SGD-based fine-tuning methods are unfortunately limited by the inherent
inefficiency of SGD.
In this paper, we investigate the potential of DP zeroth-order methods for
LLM pretraining, which avoids the scalability bottleneck of SGD by
approximating the gradient with the more efficient zeroth-order gradient.
Rather than treating the zeroth-order method as a drop-in replacement for SGD,
this paper presents a comprehensive study both theoretically and empirically.
First, we propose the stagewise DP zeroth-order method (DP-ZOSO) that
dynamically schedules key hyperparameters. This design is grounded on the
synergy between DP random perturbation and the gradient approximation error of
the zeroth-order method, and its effect on fine-tuning trajectory.
We provide theoretical analysis for both proposed methods. We conduct
extensive empirical analysis on both encoder-only masked language model and
decoder-only autoregressive language model, achieving impressive results in
terms of scalability and utility (compared with DPZero, DP-ZOPO improves 4.5%
on SST-5, 5.5% on MNLI with RoBERTa-Large and 9.2% on CB, 3.9% on BoolQ with
OPT-2.7B when $\epsilon=4$). | [
-0.45009270310401917,
-0.6508514881134033,
0.3166338801383972,
0.22185184061527252,
-0.4133917987346649,
0.17588111758232117,
-0.32905054092407227,
-0.4400811195373535,
-0.04586681351065636,
0.5565592050552368,
-0.6083964109420776,
-0.7287836670875549,
-0.582444965839386,
-0.07069674134254456,
-0.27700918912887573,
0.829759955406189,
0.22738327085971832,
0.14760984480381012,
0.4495178461074829,
-0.09925761073827744,
-0.118583545088768,
-0.6784064173698425,
-0.4575277268886566,
0.0937998965382576,
0.5526717305183411,
0.46718937158584595,
0.6356373429298401,
1.2030895948410034,
0.32775190472602844,
0.2910114526748657,
-0.27364224195480347,
0.040249936282634735,
-0.6297796964645386,
0.19232231378555298,
-0.05070427060127258,
-0.49094292521476746,
-0.6933929920196533,
0.07006359100341797,
0.6076616644859314,
0.7933496832847595,
-0.3030799627304077,
0.28579744696617126,
0.19921837747097015,
0.7213565111160278,
-0.9318560361862183,
0.24381598830223083,
-0.6267762780189514,
0.25810185074806213,
-0.34934544563293457,
-0.20259885489940643,
-0.23945282399654388,
-0.45026564598083496,
-0.1366799920797348,
-0.31869077682495117,
0.2509346604347229,
-0.1622341275215149,
0.5879954099655151,
0.5450996160507202,
0.04756442457437515,
0.15441498160362244,
-0.890122652053833,
0.8788046836853027,
-1.0072144269943237,
0.6256694793701172,
0.3781414031982422,
0.21300087869167328,
-0.08558356761932373,
-0.43426942825317383,
-0.4450092315673828,
-0.30838778614997864,
0.10833605378866196,
-0.03736303001642227,
0.20099467039108276,
0.554676353931427,
0.42522260546684265,
0.7861749529838562,
-0.3388746380805969,
0.8318067193031311,
0.027661871165037155,
0.025379061698913574,
0.6478520631790161,
0.28691744804382324,
-0.04409939423203468,
0.14600913226604462,
-0.15472865104675293,
-0.0765705481171608,
-0.8044494986534119,
0.019923703745007515,
0.47870898246765137,
0.3830503523349762,
-0.04768294841051102,
0.27174270153045654,
-0.6863002777099609,
0.7624861001968384,
0.4723126292228699,
-0.11236075311899185,
0.17430979013442993,
-0.1674683392047882,
-0.38864853978157043,
-0.0014456380158662796,
0.7198612093925476,
0.2566711902618408,
0.29655781388282776,
-0.3318013548851013,
-0.22947300970554352,
0.009696345776319504,
-0.11871373653411865,
-1.0055694580078125,
-0.03052324429154396,
0.31702691316604614,
-0.07613562047481537,
-0.4538978338241577,
-0.21597249805927277,
-0.863859236240387,
-0.40492504835128784,
-0.4624832570552826,
0.43411412835121155,
0.015541170723736286,
-0.10693304985761642,
0.35463085770606995,
0.46791625022888184,
-0.0462503619492054,
0.19104382395744324,
-1.2281739711761475,
0.4648475646972656,
0.7716656923294067,
0.7193790078163147,
-0.18038855493068695,
-0.34094128012657166,
-0.7142771482467651,
-0.0342223159968853,
-0.4957737624645233,
0.07831044495105743,
-0.3455691635608673,
-0.1687701791524887,
0.0021652141585946083,
-0.014718123711645603,
0.08717283606529236,
-0.4605714976787567,
0.5351594686508179,
-0.6239502429962158,
-0.053539078682661057,
-0.12736745178699493,
-0.4423322081565857,
-0.049979496747255325,
-0.03560731187462807,
-0.23959362506866455,
0.7429754734039307,
-0.11651413142681122,
-0.5680857300758362,
0.3174351751804352,
-0.32072070240974426,
-0.34250152111053467,
0.01519902516156435,
-0.30257347226142883,
-0.3458651304244995,
0.12687727808952332,
0.2792748510837555,
0.9859212636947632,
-0.12929721176624298,
0.2573494017124176,
-0.5815265774726868,
-0.6439628005027771,
-0.11113670468330383,
-0.5611751675605774,
0.7665409445762634,
0.2250148206949234,
-0.880155622959137,
-0.063905730843544,
-1.1215051412582397,
0.24249352514743805,
0.05444159358739853,
-0.13249938189983368,
-0.38114258646965027,
-0.1155700534582138,
-0.28452903032302856,
0.21421943604946136,
0.35804662108421326,
-0.582176923751831,
0.005148966796696186,
-0.7840327024459839,
0.568528950214386,
1.0004199743270874,
-0.12993167340755463,
0.6553932428359985,
0.017811832949519157,
0.5175696611404419,
-0.08217848092317581,
0.5104613304138184,
0.07521192729473114,
-0.21506942808628082,
-0.6053829789161682,
-0.42225995659828186,
0.47948747873306274,
0.47754228115081787,
-0.2560739815235138,
0.6258001327514648,
-0.03967852517962456,
-0.505342423915863,
-0.38944390416145325,
-0.013125838711857796,
0.6511353254318237,
0.3606297969818115,
0.25009262561798096,
-0.20475591719150543,
0.05666651576757431,
-0.7216544151306152,
-0.08580854535102844,
0.2438410371541977,
-0.07138247042894363,
0.36881938576698303,
-0.14503081142902374,
-0.03673519194126129,
0.43322303891181946,
-0.6389845609664917,
-0.3002854585647583,
0.2051268070936203,
-0.11857276409864426,
0.39878547191619873,
0.6252084374427795,
0.5761003494262695,
-0.4375954568386078,
-0.6598531007766724,
0.021829046308994293,
-0.3275509774684906,
-0.24101987481117249,
0.20798170566558838,
-0.18235892057418823,
0.2323363572359085,
0.3884314298629761,
-0.37409135699272156,
0.2248489409685135,
0.6712332367897034,
-0.10872912406921387,
0.20536726713180542,
-0.5446207523345947,
0.004433382302522659,
-0.9213968515396118,
-0.2576521337032318,
-0.10057470947504044,
-0.23064373433589935,
-0.7505792379379272,
0.30377283692359924,
0.16064022481441498,
-0.14704257249832153,
-0.37945255637168884,
0.37449315190315247,
-0.5604484677314758,
0.03844615817070007,
-0.20420753955841064,
-0.07800555974245071,
-0.24970555305480957,
0.7614229917526245,
-0.13301801681518555,
0.5444811582565308,
0.7150286436080933,
-0.8127278685569763,
-0.08122295886278152,
-0.004170509520918131,
-0.2717399597167969,
0.20075839757919312,
-0.672903835773468,
0.20209234952926636,
-0.1043802872300148,
-0.2687993347644806,
-0.7444672584533691,
0.20853492617607117,
0.4341355264186859,
-0.044327884912490845,
0.6262639760971069,
-0.43446680903434753,
-0.5810593366622925,
-0.00590050034224987,
-0.2685915529727936,
0.343131422996521,
0.6264915466308594,
-0.6280239224433899,
-0.054576341062784195,
0.3011639714241028,
-0.2920715808868408,
-0.8608159422874451,
-0.5447252988815308,
-0.0851619616150856,
-0.23419588804244995,
-0.3483506143093109,
0.5483709573745728,
-0.3843695819377899,
-0.11121592670679092,
-0.4334886372089386,
-0.3829871118068695,
-0.3040809631347656,
0.21731029450893402,
0.2373608946800232,
0.026109226047992706,
-0.20354892313480377,
-0.39369136095046997,
0.3936317563056946,
-0.36241140961647034,
-0.13564971089363098,
-0.27461156249046326,
0.4905710816383362,
0.013003187254071236,
-0.3076585531234741,
-0.4379119277000427,
0.16462014615535736,
0.6806206703186035,
-0.23682619631290436,
0.6345402598381042,
0.4363212585449219,
-0.22101889550685883,
-0.4212058186531067,
-0.6827515363693237,
-0.21407712996006012,
-0.571037769317627,
0.2733980417251587,
-0.14933685958385468,
-0.9732526540756226,
0.5159462094306946,
0.05935114994645119,
0.2516481280326843,
0.05796322226524353,
0.7180387377738953,
0.3345261216163635,
0.9651291966438293,
0.761143147945404,
-0.23983587324619293,
0.7196866869926453,
-0.3416377305984497,
0.1448492407798767,
-0.5221821069717407,
0.18238897621631622,
-0.466259241104126,
-0.3463812470436096,
-0.9920461773872375,
-0.2281275987625122,
0.14530430734157562,
0.32858535647392273,
-0.2860795855522156,
0.25250059366226196,
-0.6569470167160034,
0.7810144424438477,
0.527484118938446,
0.1578863114118576,
0.525890588760376,
0.11589441448450089,
-0.007930606603622437,
-0.13787025213241577,
-0.571925163269043,
-0.20878061652183533,
0.9823843240737915,
0.3000697195529938,
0.7835891246795654,
-0.16591516137123108,
1.0188730955123901,
-0.010578353889286518,
-0.18367469310760498,
-0.5359192490577698,
0.6591923832893372,
-0.478963702917099,
-0.3284670412540436,
-0.6318244934082031,
-0.3335410952568054,
-0.7260411977767944,
0.45547667145729065,
0.02942930907011032,
-0.7757738828659058,
0.5307223796844482,
0.12941281497478485,
-0.6291866898536682,
0.038091227412223816,
-0.6981220245361328,
0.5343162417411804,
-0.19343070685863495,
-0.5880012512207031,
-0.31990689039230347,
-0.6489410996437073,
0.22625872492790222,
-0.1203160434961319,
0.02813737466931343,
-0.3033607006072998,
0.08179774880409241,
0.501541793346405,
-0.5621005892753601,
0.8137121200561523,
-0.49603205919265747,
-0.33580586314201355,
-0.35110825300216675,
0.2060636430978775,
0.6691842079162598,
0.3874911069869995,
-0.16043411195278168,
0.5741069912910461,
0.07270254194736481,
-0.3029702603816986,
-0.6833961606025696,
1.086098074913025,
-0.7947474122047424,
-0.7906602025032043,
-0.25720474123954773,
-0.2631736397743225,
-0.2898636758327484,
0.45075690746307373,
0.16638948023319244,
0.5994501709938049,
0.31423330307006836,
-0.043317876756191254,
0.7263004779815674,
-0.13661356270313263,
0.6081281900405884,
0.9292058348655701,
0.14682818949222565,
-0.3328658640384674,
0.9020024538040161,
0.47289708256721497,
0.3257620930671692,
0.5592439770698547,
0.3023374676704407,
-0.2971165180206299,
-1.1245534420013428,
-0.523314356803894,
0.20286643505096436,
-0.4129350185394287,
-0.09924984723329544,
-0.48564526438713074,
-0.2791118919849396,
-0.17283141613006592,
-0.11575494706630707,
-0.783784031867981,
-0.5791026949882507,
-0.27723756432533264,
-0.008211927488446236,
0.20287390053272247,
0.42143920063972473,
-0.19691842794418335,
0.008816885761916637,
-0.6088203191757202,
0.5133728384971619,
0.12816104292869568,
0.767776608467102,
0.03359886258840561,
-0.5337088704109192,
-0.18040241301059723,
0.2765907049179077,
-0.12453170865774155,
-0.47432035207748413,
0.32326963543891907,
0.0066817752085626125,
0.494480162858963,
0.502280056476593,
0.4619230031967163,
0.7854532599449158,
-0.8099454045295715,
0.6004072427749634,
-0.10818763822317123,
-0.8145108819007874,
0.27963000535964966,
-0.46949267387390137,
-0.05588534101843834,
0.5684832334518433,
0.3944496512413025,
-0.15868143737316132,
-0.5238975286483765,
-0.40887710452079773,
-1.0084823369979858,
0.8273914456367493,
0.23395873606204987,
0.28102996945381165,
0.2954465448856354,
0.6096352338790894,
0.2734663486480713,
0.39404571056365967,
-0.43486934900283813,
-0.6784584522247314,
-0.061438240110874176,
0.004860899411141872,
-0.3910577893257141,
-0.3157152831554413,
-0.018930092453956604,
-0.3483835458755493,
0.46444153785705566,
-0.03534935414791107,
0.02344929426908493,
-0.005440884735435247,
0.14256922900676727,
0.014421147294342518,
0.36609557271003723,
0.665176272392273,
0.7897561192512512,
-0.414665549993515,
-0.17531871795654297,
-0.03961754962801933,
-0.45924869179725647,
0.3086871802806854,
0.44888728857040405,
-0.28871655464172363,
-0.09675566852092743,
-0.2782171964645386,
0.6740477681159973,
0.15512344241142273,
-0.26862820982933044,
0.390838623046875,
-0.07377037405967712,
-0.2530217170715332,
-0.05283500626683235,
0.21446284651756287,
-0.20445695519447327,
0.43186432123184204,
0.09567919373512268,
-0.12172842025756836,
0.13940554857254028,
0.036570947617292404,
-0.03037441149353981,
0.3621333837509155,
-0.28233861923217773,
-0.3379157781600952,
0.7950267195701599,
0.0872020572423935,
-0.3104097843170166,
0.28953367471694946,
-0.08636891096830368,
-0.029206790030002594,
0.3252909481525421,
0.3064201772212982,
1.0435630083084106,
-0.19541318714618683,
0.17261509597301483,
0.012601113878190517,
0.06446727365255356,
-0.23266412317752838,
0.1759144812822342,
-0.40055978298187256,
-0.5913785696029663,
-0.6483464241027832,
-0.8381699323654175,
-0.4448122978210449,
0.4678831398487091,
-0.704911470413208,
0.1599796861410141,
-0.8666143417358398,
0.007793797645717859,
-0.07974831014871597,
0.21801772713661194,
-0.4195159375667572,
0.20757141709327698,
0.0936707928776741,
0.45738497376441956,
-0.35667121410369873,
0.8623106479644775,
0.3495962619781494,
-0.08718761801719666,
-0.698076069355011,
0.3167940378189087,
-0.2330583781003952,
-0.8329102993011475,
0.578485906124115,
-0.17023470997810364,
-0.19392578303813934,
0.3811657726764679,
-0.23888704180717468,
-0.8889498710632324,
0.9575337171554565,
0.7823032736778259,
-1.1912336349487305,
-0.035387177020311356,
0.2904145121574402,
0.6818100810050964,
0.16039308905601501,
0.07201746851205826,
0.22308063507080078,
0.1375477910041809,
-0.1275547593832016,
-0.8946553468704224,
0.26287364959716797,
0.10047362744808197,
0.15358595550060272,
0.2538442313671112,
-0.9270975589752197,
0.7268401384353638,
-0.07821496576070786,
-0.22969301044940948,
-0.06739066541194916,
0.26149287819862366,
0.030155623331665993,
0.031032796949148178,
0.4613579213619232,
0.4127669632434845,
0.6466761231422424,
0.24565161764621735,
0.7375015020370483,
-0.8243929743766785,
0.473715215921402,
0.9138538837432861,
-0.2517261505126953,
0.6188969612121582,
0.4581720530986786,
-0.20596826076507568,
-0.018270129337906837,
0.6482005715370178,
0.18476952612400055,
0.8863316774368286,
0.44963470101356506,
-0.10440158098936081,
-0.12241211533546448,
0.14814789593219757,
-0.6100455522537231,
0.06543293595314026,
-0.05398927256464958,
-0.1710120141506195,
-0.22458328306674957,
-0.23944459855556488,
0.022268060594797134,
0.05276930332183838,
-0.34944450855255127,
0.631585419178009,
0.20182837545871735,
-0.1958705186843872,
1.1179420948028564,
0.12649625539779663,
0.8924114108085632,
-0.4208747446537018,
0.21004945039749146,
-0.4859657287597656,
0.5388321280479431,
-0.105095773935318,
-0.3095579445362091,
0.14781062304973602,
-0.12852558493614197,
-0.17302387952804565,
-0.5058121085166931,
0.2138039618730545,
-0.3498305082321167,
-0.2955671548843384,
0.3981263041496277,
0.3523305058479309,
-0.16816744208335876,
-0.11825187504291534,
-0.713486909866333,
-0.13670167326927185,
-0.23416082561016083,
-0.3673476576805115,
0.8207159638404846,
0.3807913064956665,
0.0679003894329071,
0.46761026978492737,
0.5503496527671814,
0.17507869005203247,
0.17334261536598206,
0.1852583885192871,
0.7759625315666199,
-0.5030262470245361,
-0.8080337047576904,
-1.037627935409546,
0.14354825019836426,
0.26935285329818726,
-0.13975362479686737,
0.8746749758720398,
0.20049747824668884,
1.187453031539917,
-0.12124847620725632,
0.5376580953598022,
0.13462546467781067,
0.4538729190826416,
-0.6948908567428589,
0.8346787691116333,
-0.5564891695976257,
0.3901219964027405,
-0.5070846080780029,
-0.9000507593154907,
-0.3675236105918884,
0.37098968029022217,
-0.2205023318529129,
-0.06135360151529312,
0.43848246335983276,
0.969304084777832,
-0.16719597578048706,
-0.05142571032047272,
0.6268759965896606,
0.3354978561401367,
0.13794249296188354,
0.3292335569858551,
0.6831583976745605,
-0.3840138018131256,
0.1949533224105835,
-0.811111330986023,
-0.27445876598358154,
0.00280083273537457,
-0.6928346157073975,
-0.9707725048065186,
-0.39739668369293213,
-0.3763067126274109,
-0.15116338431835175,
0.42519670724868774,
0.7573260068893433,
0.7905245423316956,
-0.7167332172393799,
-0.2024236023426056,
-0.3788225054740906,
0.059115562587976456,
-0.32722583413124084,
-0.17518390715122223,
0.32746756076812744,
-0.27328816056251526,
-1.045291543006897,
0.3815179169178009,
0.33252522349357605,
0.1534537672996521,
-0.3507276773452759,
0.04514172673225403,
0.2273682802915573,
-0.08112407475709915,
0.5152255892753601,
0.2237808257341385,
-0.6196186542510986,
-0.02709989994764328,
-0.0073865256272256374,
0.007634130772203207,
0.11353500187397003,
0.6979728937149048,
-0.3467332720756531,
0.15015678107738495,
0.4426819682121277,
0.7308787703514099,
0.6146690249443054,
-0.048829786479473114,
0.5405189990997314,
-0.6173084378242493,
0.3734176456928253,
0.19773440062999725,
-0.06319461017847061,
-0.07890819758176804,
-0.7754065990447998,
0.21612420678138733,
0.17767873406410217,
-0.6692343354225159,
-0.9373855590820312,
0.2486076056957245,
-0.8113670945167542,
-0.011686201207339764,
1.0956889390945435,
-0.31242668628692627,
-0.008421911858022213,
0.044544924050569534,
0.02290407381951809,
0.0647798627614975,
-0.49103403091430664,
0.9855262041091919,
0.3482248783111572,
-0.07931694388389587,
-0.04364941269159317,
-0.49938076734542847,
0.6768423318862915,
0.5713785290718079,
-0.40480148792266846,
0.47831958532333374,
0.3833525776863098,
0.327597051858902,
-0.22422008216381073,
0.7305091619491577,
-0.1352929174900055,
-0.11948192864656448,
-0.4001994729042053,
-0.41648009419441223,
-0.46243149042129517,
-0.369198203086853,
-0.6700433492660522,
0.19761517643928528,
0.09612176567316055,
-0.43152183294296265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07817v1 | Injecting Wiktionary to improve token-level contextual representations using contrastive learning | 2024-02-12T17:22:42 | 2024-02-12T17:22:42 | Anna Mosolova, Marie Candito, Carlos Ramisch | cs.CL | cs.CL | While static word embeddings are blind to context, for lexical semantics
tasks context is rather too present in contextual word embeddings, vectors of
same-meaning occurrences being too different (Ethayarajh, 2019). Fine-tuning
pre-trained language models (PLMs) using contrastive learning was proposed,
leveraging automatically self-augmented examples (Liu et al., 2021b). In this
paper, we investigate how to inject a lexicon as an alternative source of
supervision, using the English Wiktionary. We also test how dimensionality
reduction impacts the resulting contextual word embeddings. We evaluate our
approach on the Word-In-Context (WiC) task, in the unsupervised setting (not
using the training set). We achieve new SoTA result on the original WiC test
set. We also propose two new WiC test sets for which we show that our
fine-tuning method achieves substantial improvements. We also observe
improvements, although modest, for the semantic frame induction task. Although
we experimented on English to allow comparison with related work, our method is
adaptable to the many languages for which large Wiktionaries exist. | [
-0.5431212186813354,
-0.4303274154663086,
0.18613770604133606,
-0.05126383155584335,
-0.6267178654670715,
-0.2273184359073639,
-0.18328715860843658,
-0.4489685595035553,
0.2982010543346405,
0.3232671916484833,
-0.4534594714641571,
-0.47313275933265686,
-0.5939952731132507,
0.3731018602848053,
-0.35871535539627075,
0.8742583990097046,
-0.20993301272392273,
0.2980664372444153,
-0.5115355253219604,
-0.49630874395370483,
-0.7395253777503967,
-0.40406784415245056,
-0.4500423073768616,
-0.23712825775146484,
0.6545482873916626,
0.4925561547279358,
0.5200738310813904,
0.5374190211296082,
0.35028350353240967,
0.3167600631713867,
-0.3312939405441284,
0.55760258436203,
-0.4502771496772766,
-0.16662079095840454,
-0.6714783906936646,
-0.35407042503356934,
0.23487213253974915,
0.17046906054019928,
0.33480218052864075,
1.0186164379119873,
0.018168078735470772,
-0.07315749675035477,
0.5146007537841797,
0.3771345913410187,
-1.07554030418396,
0.028771884739398956,
-0.7513639330863953,
0.08645278215408325,
-0.1612299233675003,
-0.30199146270751953,
-0.23904167115688324,
0.2765623927116394,
0.20502139627933502,
-0.8545506596565247,
0.24252912402153015,
0.17826585471630096,
0.8881511688232422,
0.4269184172153473,
-0.5154531598091125,
-0.48883721232414246,
-0.3488505780696869,
0.7444210648536682,
-0.7142691016197205,
0.38011011481285095,
0.354482501745224,
-0.09039698541164398,
-0.2386801689863205,
-0.911705732345581,
-0.6551011204719543,
-0.3335951566696167,
-0.3827999532222748,
0.34700873494148254,
0.25496917963027954,
0.10961876064538956,
0.02800823003053665,
0.42364370822906494,
-0.055676981806755066,
0.22386126220226288,
-0.28176364302635193,
-0.01657376065850258,
0.16778457164764404,
0.14873181283473969,
0.22026707231998444,
-0.424331933259964,
-0.43221843242645264,
-0.027445225045084953,
-0.7743899822235107,
-0.26055043935775757,
0.15890182554721832,
0.41557687520980835,
-0.16524352133274078,
0.5847902894020081,
-0.252989262342453,
0.5799121260643005,
0.10117852687835693,
0.10074607282876968,
0.4011194407939911,
-0.5551257133483887,
-0.038144830614328384,
0.09642048925161362,
0.38999271392822266,
0.40742427110671997,
0.11653969436883926,
-0.16846823692321777,
-0.13702857494354248,
0.2270263284444809,
0.23643088340759277,
-0.6720166206359863,
-0.30926743149757385,
-0.0623297281563282,
-0.3852505385875702,
-0.23783066868782043,
0.2538261115550995,
-0.3019324541091919,
-0.4196679890155792,
-0.4185411036014557,
0.9459972381591797,
-0.6076171398162842,
-0.043482281267642975,
0.019984956830739975,
-0.35419899225234985,
0.14618459343910217,
0.041583821177482605,
-1.0420324802398682,
0.13228978216648102,
0.5753928422927856,
0.8776118755340576,
-0.3212483525276184,
-0.5000773072242737,
-0.424201101064682,
0.32091212272644043,
-0.7717276811599731,
0.7803803086280823,
-0.4381448030471802,
-0.6064728498458862,
0.339258074760437,
-0.03201911598443985,
0.1861824095249176,
-0.849324643611908,
0.26086747646331787,
-0.18998099863529205,
0.43708643317222595,
-0.4872552752494812,
-0.8325495719909668,
0.23720833659172058,
0.0910392701625824,
-0.3411779999732971,
1.0825027227401733,
0.11499054729938507,
-1.1795954704284668,
0.6999753713607788,
-0.7260770797729492,
-0.4421510696411133,
0.11640331149101257,
-0.16462954878807068,
0.05087669566273689,
0.4296607971191406,
0.2272612452507019,
0.6068450808525085,
0.2902123034000397,
-0.08774274587631226,
-0.09917016327381134,
-0.7126063704490662,
-0.04035373777151108,
-0.021153263747692108,
0.5592082142829895,
0.2608211040496826,
-0.46431413292884827,
0.17175306379795074,
-0.7777588367462158,
-0.3363834023475647,
-0.1135106086730957,
-0.1945154368877411,
-0.9839348196983337,
0.07456457614898682,
-0.052487630397081375,
0.18253856897354126,
0.17550867795944214,
-0.6052590608596802,
-0.18598836660385132,
-1.041943907737732,
0.29265663027763367,
0.8620231747627258,
-0.08369633555412292,
0.5538037419319153,
0.0986485406756401,
-0.09941697120666504,
0.46250560879707336,
0.0357692576944828,
-0.08871452510356903,
-0.13972237706184387,
-0.919640302658081,
-0.36717280745506287,
0.40277066826820374,
0.14354991912841797,
-1.232641577720642,
0.6022852063179016,
-0.16674701869487762,
-0.17470499873161316,
-0.43067666888237,
0.38817334175109863,
0.370088130235672,
0.6641417741775513,
0.5739533305168152,
-0.3097878098487854,
-0.47783124446868896,
-0.9544543623924255,
-0.29475507140159607,
0.20934012532234192,
-0.26113590598106384,
0.1102927103638649,
0.6156878471374512,
-0.2913619875907898,
0.8515881299972534,
-0.4347742199897766,
-0.5531100034713745,
-0.03565710410475731,
0.18198232352733612,
-0.031023625284433365,
0.5392414331436157,
0.3188540041446686,
-0.7984903454780579,
-0.6649348139762878,
-0.031026436015963554,
-0.624230146408081,
-0.30210980772972107,
0.24559134244918823,
-0.2048427015542984,
0.06407946348190308,
0.9997900128364563,
-0.4011996388435364,
0.44862091541290283,
0.49544426798820496,
-0.6140995025634766,
0.2448294758796692,
-0.518612802028656,
-0.09123868495225906,
-1.5746877193450928,
-0.17014843225479126,
-0.3379100561141968,
-0.12433784455060959,
-0.4920436441898346,
0.22289375960826874,
0.31864431500434875,
0.014299541711807251,
-0.5832197666168213,
0.6361847519874573,
-0.3217771053314209,
0.09151744097471237,
-0.470028281211853,
0.44412705302238464,
0.03874041512608528,
0.1955113261938095,
-0.22484880685806274,
1.0192621946334839,
0.33817699551582336,
-0.7344945669174194,
0.1870569884777069,
0.3336496353149414,
-0.5643340349197388,
0.6406347751617432,
-0.40426215529441833,
-0.10103908181190491,
-0.32836729288101196,
0.1646752655506134,
-1.0130839347839355,
-0.12021855264902115,
0.11033783107995987,
-0.13449627161026,
0.39761465787887573,
0.4917382597923279,
-0.579592227935791,
0.06482043117284775,
-0.43626895546913147,
0.2668408453464508,
0.3229958713054657,
-1.1503276824951172,
0.46017006039619446,
0.14523866772651672,
0.258163183927536,
-0.5272693634033203,
-0.8615247011184692,
0.07174007594585419,
-0.2392098307609558,
-0.011070058681070805,
0.8557208180427551,
0.07790333777666092,
-0.29168885946273804,
0.22816188633441925,
-0.15693508088588715,
0.1650380790233612,
0.0357571542263031,
0.24441196024417877,
0.04800666123628616,
0.15476186573505402,
0.5344805717468262,
0.07390293478965759,
-0.09543483704328537,
-0.08689402788877487,
-0.224588543176651,
0.5085312724113464,
0.28778088092803955,
-0.3591947853565216,
-0.34400662779808044,
0.5019962191581726,
0.12442126125097275,
-0.32565218210220337,
1.022487759590149,
0.6864159107208252,
-0.27280861139297485,
-0.28612715005874634,
-0.5464078783988953,
-0.17235593497753143,
-0.5317739248275757,
0.357755184173584,
-0.5822592377662659,
-0.9367265105247498,
0.3936907947063446,
-0.24204044044017792,
-0.06522933393716812,
0.5946033596992493,
0.42931798100471497,
-0.39924168586730957,
0.963096559047699,
0.6400237083435059,
0.06343168765306473,
0.8676785230636597,
-0.3560141324996948,
0.18830645084381104,
-0.8066952228546143,
-0.2363003045320511,
-0.38891103863716125,
-0.13046857714653015,
-0.7873002290725708,
-0.42194393277168274,
0.26414620876312256,
0.19329139590263367,
0.006299537606537342,
0.1505783498287201,
-0.419455885887146,
0.4331367313861847,
0.4563365876674652,
0.14402465522289276,
0.08509998023509979,
-0.08633435517549515,
-0.6213486194610596,
-0.04646706208586693,
-0.7404434084892273,
-0.15555961430072784,
0.8219268918037415,
0.060798972845077515,
0.5086395144462585,
-0.04765664413571358,
1.0016580820083618,
-0.14463181793689728,
0.41965922713279724,
-0.7164753675460815,
0.3667513430118561,
-0.5910515189170837,
-0.37138622999191284,
-0.19275924563407898,
-0.25460222363471985,
-0.8688695430755615,
0.40134337544441223,
-0.3174285888671875,
-0.4370391070842743,
0.37794801592826843,
0.1604180634021759,
-0.16009947657585144,
0.18792687356472015,
-0.9622546434402466,
0.7595446109771729,
0.2790314853191376,
-0.3857419788837433,
-0.5824931859970093,
-0.3757936954498291,
0.0011377990012988448,
0.05002142861485481,
0.17577436566352844,
0.034581661224365234,
-0.42588427662849426,
0.6501789093017578,
-0.6610803604125977,
0.8911293745040894,
-0.2818886637687683,
-0.19236885011196136,
0.016000928357243538,
-0.2843122184276581,
0.31149202585220337,
-0.1418931782245636,
0.18597911298274994,
0.06626611202955246,
0.16053810715675354,
-0.6744874715805054,
-0.5995197296142578,
1.0198343992233276,
-0.5990068316459656,
-0.6860579252243042,
-0.25570788979530334,
-0.6488882899284363,
-0.5560775399208069,
0.027004308998584747,
0.5056226253509521,
0.5915356874465942,
-0.17281237244606018,
0.45086991786956787,
0.5897408723831177,
-0.22562892735004425,
0.34998819231987,
0.22018218040466309,
0.06649202108383179,
-0.22127361595630646,
0.7507343888282776,
0.33054789900779724,
0.09115918725728989,
0.45957568287849426,
0.4778188169002533,
-0.3614681363105774,
-0.4862305521965027,
-0.005288892891258001,
0.10157331824302673,
-0.8862698078155518,
-0.20271676778793335,
-0.37919533252716064,
-0.00939706340432167,
-0.4773974120616913,
-0.2401599884033203,
-0.18271023035049438,
-0.08209763467311859,
-0.45281076431274414,
-0.1748802661895752,
0.32465484738349915,
0.9050565361976624,
-0.20140507817268372,
0.19750423729419708,
-0.3819912075996399,
0.36264657974243164,
0.5072344541549683,
0.41548436880111694,
-0.11760266125202179,
-0.7162181735038757,
-0.43518397212028503,
-0.21129699051380157,
-0.01540708914399147,
-0.7047497034072876,
0.08739001303911209,
0.3840702772140503,
0.5036683082580566,
0.5722084641456604,
0.07630607485771179,
0.981564998626709,
-0.8276398777961731,
1.0100388526916504,
0.27233773469924927,
-1.0021395683288574,
0.49450570344924927,
0.0031485946383327246,
0.5451938509941101,
0.6809700727462769,
0.43849050998687744,
-0.3689141869544983,
-0.4722735285758972,
-0.4320337772369385,
-0.870232880115509,
0.24790489673614502,
-0.08682522177696228,
0.7819433212280273,
-0.42221584916114807,
0.6299410462379456,
0.17985022068023682,
-0.05880504846572876,
-0.4213411808013916,
-0.14448444545269012,
-0.4954543113708496,
-0.4537280797958374,
-0.4117205739021301,
-0.6039639115333557,
0.00927584245800972,
-0.5545066595077515,
0.5947826504707336,
-0.15588660538196564,
-0.22471141815185547,
0.36934125423431396,
-0.13232463598251343,
0.33972182869911194,
0.19624435901641846,
0.23665720224380493,
0.7140277624130249,
0.0758545771241188,
0.4969119429588318,
0.8012391924858093,
-0.363656222820282,
-0.1787092536687851,
-0.0045835645869374275,
-0.04093867912888527,
0.21535617113113403,
0.48654672503471375,
0.6995880007743835,
0.8556585311889648,
-0.5869153141975403,
0.5983396172523499,
0.18571360409259796,
-0.2369668185710907,
-0.22603844106197357,
-0.04693964123725891,
0.24620476365089417,
0.06236252188682556,
0.19020038843154907,
-0.40886756777763367,
0.18241457641124725,
-0.575544536113739,
0.07968319207429886,
0.5667928457260132,
-0.34152474999427795,
0.016827357932925224,
0.40765708684921265,
0.2193031907081604,
-0.07096553593873978,
0.1595337688922882,
-0.15975646674633026,
-0.35182324051856995,
0.013795042410492897,
0.7079058289527893,
0.5356951355934143,
-0.34701356291770935,
-0.13962027430534363,
0.31508922576904297,
-0.02054315246641636,
0.07165681570768356,
0.22745779156684875,
-0.33411893248558044,
-0.8444757461547852,
-0.48701879382133484,
-0.6406707167625427,
-0.2689971625804901,
0.02929222397506237,
-0.639706015586853,
0.19225703179836273,
-0.2845821678638458,
0.17649903893470764,
-0.05390061438083649,
0.0795234963297844,
-0.7337391376495361,
0.26333385705947876,
-0.09365500509738922,
1.0401129722595215,
-0.8205593228340149,
0.9177078604698181,
0.7467407584190369,
-0.4666203260421753,
-0.7816121578216553,
0.18919049203395844,
-0.3958278298377991,
-0.3996274471282959,
0.7157242894172668,
0.3318719267845154,
-0.29385650157928467,
0.05056208744645119,
-0.5434947609901428,
-0.7988623380661011,
0.9194303154945374,
0.21038414537906647,
-0.3270704746246338,
0.03461508825421333,
0.010687029920518398,
0.714007556438446,
-0.33050230145454407,
-0.20765991508960724,
0.38389456272125244,
0.08499908447265625,
-0.12546078860759735,
-0.65528804063797,
-0.12441171705722809,
-0.05673767626285553,
0.455049067735672,
-0.047270920127630234,
-0.32727110385894775,
0.7763541340827942,
0.1983276903629303,
-0.42536798119544983,
0.1846124529838562,
0.9140695333480835,
-0.040021710097789764,
-0.0038770202081650496,
0.8139889240264893,
0.6701571345329285,
0.396893709897995,
0.16351105272769928,
1.1169553995132446,
-0.2638919949531555,
0.18744517862796783,
1.1475398540496826,
-0.12861046195030212,
1.1377400159835815,
1.1709160804748535,
0.0944439023733139,
0.716288685798645,
0.5246514678001404,
0.15790510177612305,
0.9447926878929138,
0.14681556820869446,
-0.33047765493392944,
-0.08912487328052521,
-0.5874884128570557,
-0.1267467886209488,
0.6786997318267822,
0.3037627935409546,
-0.22777338325977325,
-0.2022758275270462,
0.4571143090724945,
-0.155757874250412,
0.554034411907196,
-0.5232785940170288,
0.9688640236854553,
0.16676099598407745,
-0.38577786087989807,
0.5323060154914856,
-0.017783714458346367,
1.1560386419296265,
-0.6064246892929077,
-0.08153761178255081,
-0.3606959879398346,
0.18784618377685547,
-0.32425442337989807,
-0.31679585576057434,
0.43239107728004456,
-0.11720889061689377,
0.13331754505634308,
-0.049299560487270355,
0.7009282112121582,
-0.5374649167060852,
-0.22501049935817719,
0.5640131235122681,
0.42310962080955505,
-0.06335874646902084,
0.13285169005393982,
-0.28134796023368835,
-0.2578692138195038,
-0.40846389532089233,
-0.08509509265422821,
0.5073392987251282,
0.5413366556167603,
0.06223608925938606,
0.3265765905380249,
0.5243828296661377,
0.1799352765083313,
-0.03493942320346832,
0.3242408335208893,
0.9979579448699951,
-0.4628283679485321,
-0.6935381889343262,
-0.7277809381484985,
0.30241620540618896,
-0.23379777371883392,
-0.4346238076686859,
0.9170005917549133,
0.38535499572753906,
1.414516568183899,
-0.17610451579093933,
0.33325618505477905,
0.08017145097255707,
0.4967929422855377,
-0.6216531991958618,
0.6805744171142578,
-0.9222202897071838,
-0.028736714273691177,
-0.1467764973640442,
-0.6579355597496033,
-0.20167510211467743,
0.7027705907821655,
-0.13892896473407745,
-0.29764524102211,
0.9394338726997375,
0.9992126822471619,
-0.12310871481895447,
-0.24449361860752106,
0.657548189163208,
0.1436322033405304,
-0.08752532303333282,
0.0845315009355545,
0.9898326396942139,
-0.3111918270587921,
0.4517189860343933,
-0.6056478023529053,
-0.11080217361450195,
-0.03156815841794014,
-0.8133213520050049,
-1.0931885242462158,
-0.9100508093833923,
-0.03670606389641762,
-0.21071217954158783,
0.11732520908117294,
1.1046655178070068,
0.5047507286071777,
-1.0667572021484375,
0.03576680272817612,
-0.22018054127693176,
-0.09569858014583588,
-0.24924160540103912,
-0.18984219431877136,
0.5744746327400208,
-0.8164869546890259,
-0.8008822798728943,
0.49568408727645874,
0.13930565118789673,
-0.17648983001708984,
-0.4087810218334198,
0.06264650076627731,
-0.3712124228477478,
0.08811787515878677,
0.8281457424163818,
-0.2555575966835022,
-0.8283920288085938,
-0.8206664323806763,
-0.5048717856407166,
-0.21334317326545715,
-0.12478917092084885,
0.8319167494773865,
-0.7122173309326172,
0.6588082313537598,
0.47876647114753723,
0.7039457559585571,
0.3870351016521454,
-0.2717587351799011,
0.3423498272895813,
-1.0370643138885498,
0.5682438015937805,
-0.0751471295952797,
0.5896719694137573,
0.41958436369895935,
-0.2436036467552185,
0.3990412950515747,
0.20887066423892975,
0.01661856286227703,
-0.7253468632698059,
0.22442561388015747,
-0.40695372223854065,
-0.664741039276123,
1.0548261404037476,
-0.1259104609489441,
-0.14920702576637268,
-0.263910174369812,
-0.29890739917755127,
0.4660336673259735,
0.18633733689785004,
0.8795982003211975,
0.6971097588539124,
0.12389177829027176,
0.05612340196967125,
-0.3173513114452362,
0.6892102360725403,
0.7054430246353149,
-0.6581224203109741,
-0.10257140547037125,
0.20825570821762085,
0.49637022614479065,
0.31071773171424866,
0.34044432640075684,
-0.17067234218120575,
0.011547012254595757,
0.13629797101020813,
-0.0076627591624855995,
-0.10721397399902344,
-0.023925164714455605,
-0.5488746762275696,
0.08838564902544022,
0.09786511212587357,
-0.398980975151062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07812v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Thought Process as Sequential Decision Making | 2024-02-12T17:17:50 | 2024-02-12T17:17:50 | Thomas Pouplin, Hao Sun, Samuel Holt, Mihaela van der Schaar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, H.3.3; I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.8 | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their strong ability to assist
people and show "sparks of intelligence". However, several open challenges
hinder their wider application: such as concerns over privacy, tendencies to
produce hallucinations, and difficulties in handling long contexts. In this
work, we address those challenges by introducing the Retrieval-Augmented
Thought Process (RATP). Given access to external knowledge, RATP formulates the
thought generation of LLMs as a multiple-step decision process. To optimize
such a thought process, RATP leverages Monte-Carlo Tree Search, and learns a
Q-value estimator that permits cost-efficient inference. In addressing the task
of question-answering with private data, where ethical and security concerns
limit LLM training methods, RATP achieves a 50% improvement over existing
in-context retrieval-augmented language models. | [
-0.37102943658828735,
-0.6566203236579895,
0.7494681477546692,
0.020247548818588257,
-0.1447058767080307,
0.3439861536026001,
-0.37149113416671753,
-0.6054096817970276,
0.1337425410747528,
0.5055819749832153,
-0.601435124874115,
-0.261401891708374,
-0.32804325222969055,
0.11358696222305298,
-0.18638066947460175,
0.8552709817886353,
0.04334471747279167,
-0.024504413828253746,
0.11692795157432556,
0.14209440350532532,
-0.3709324896335602,
-0.5283063650131226,
-0.7099266052246094,
-0.20236974954605103,
0.5785189867019653,
0.3611410856246948,
0.7804670333862305,
0.03747224807739258,
0.4853706359863281,
0.18770118057727814,
-0.11848761141300201,
0.4821770489215851,
-0.5702756643295288,
0.457787424325943,
-0.520106315612793,
-0.46542471647262573,
-0.2635572552680969,
-0.0024290450382977724,
0.6211726069450378,
0.5239090919494629,
-0.18102723360061646,
0.08780156075954437,
-0.1121242493391037,
0.9446476101875305,
-0.8304322361946106,
-0.07479235529899597,
-0.9087526202201843,
0.15204936265945435,
0.06552975624799728,
-0.4946436882019043,
-0.5525075197219849,
-0.5826130509376526,
0.18944039940834045,
-0.397799551486969,
-0.0708584412932396,
0.2024896740913391,
0.45059219002723694,
0.06846144050359726,
-0.12116655707359314,
-0.304454505443573,
-0.7681798934936523,
0.5976617932319641,
-0.38446205854415894,
0.4108206629753113,
0.5893436074256897,
0.2371550351381302,
-0.42824476957321167,
-0.5426321625709534,
-0.5130642652511597,
-0.1480722427368164,
0.09026718884706497,
-0.10561525076627731,
0.3808780014514923,
0.14596876502037048,
0.3855079114437103,
0.38972383737564087,
-0.3640734851360321,
-0.2898775041103363,
-0.24099113047122955,
0.04369032755494118,
0.7213383913040161,
-0.09689734876155853,
-0.016695814207196236,
-0.22735252976417542,
-0.33066728711128235,
-0.038273125886917114,
-0.5904837846755981,
-0.14743266999721527,
0.18407657742500305,
0.31106290221214294,
0.35255929827690125,
0.6269187927246094,
-0.40887773036956787,
0.44830402731895447,
-0.13437537848949432,
0.01551478449255228,
0.28360500931739807,
-0.21876811981201172,
-0.2430254966020584,
-0.011638626456260681,
0.38940078020095825,
0.01214616559445858,
0.38201969861984253,
-0.14752978086471558,
-0.3426814377307892,
-0.3032986521720886,
0.28974083065986633,
-0.6967494487762451,
-0.06316721439361572,
0.5560152530670166,
-0.20617777109146118,
-0.18427236378192902,
-0.27978742122650146,
-0.5186008214950562,
-0.33022499084472656,
-0.19674313068389893,
0.6404200196266174,
-0.6459931135177612,
-0.22674106061458588,
0.2266073375940323,
-0.005121131427586079,
0.20641982555389404,
0.7083852887153625,
-0.7267282605171204,
0.5086617469787598,
0.7056543827056885,
0.7866891622543335,
-0.23599855601787567,
0.14920498430728912,
-0.6247640252113342,
0.18673290312290192,
-0.6204623579978943,
0.7536928057670593,
-0.8183233141899109,
-0.5502885580062866,
-0.1274162232875824,
-0.3521053194999695,
-0.003184753004461527,
-0.5434148907661438,
0.43398815393447876,
-0.991054117679596,
0.3806113004684448,
-0.4433213472366333,
-0.606968104839325,
-0.0807671844959259,
0.5820883512496948,
-0.3572653830051422,
1.1996455192565918,
-0.08938666433095932,
-1.089465856552124,
0.25014033913612366,
-0.7671896815299988,
-0.03307928517460823,
0.4437747001647949,
-0.5366994142532349,
-0.11545825749635696,
0.10776115208864212,
0.26646333932876587,
0.302399605512619,
-0.1794615536928177,
0.1692468822002411,
-0.3047667443752289,
-0.30902770161628723,
0.37721946835517883,
-0.1891016811132431,
0.8466092348098755,
0.3198903799057007,
-0.21530792117118835,
0.08952376246452332,
-0.5184698104858398,
0.3504098653793335,
0.08696059137582779,
-0.4453750252723694,
-0.5470920205116272,
0.13792036473751068,
-0.37719976902008057,
0.3251712918281555,
0.2733272314071655,
-0.5658297538757324,
0.31602469086647034,
-0.5174804925918579,
-0.011185663752257824,
0.8847723603248596,
0.3024020195007324,
0.3518131673336029,
-0.3192824423313141,
0.4796425402164459,
0.03124692104756832,
0.20233877003192902,
0.0806783139705658,
-0.6353211998939514,
-0.5529667139053345,
-0.09636101126670837,
0.1660740226507187,
0.6149682402610779,
-0.9319717884063721,
0.17080768942832947,
-0.1180584505200386,
-0.1217961236834526,
-0.5728413462638855,
-0.08352747559547424,
0.24787773191928864,
0.2572363018989563,
0.26387375593185425,
-0.2613011300563812,
-0.3017827570438385,
-0.7739206552505493,
-0.2474573254585266,
-0.26297828555107117,
0.0768107995390892,
0.3343244791030884,
0.6918616890907288,
-0.06863660365343094,
0.760002613067627,
-0.5382721424102783,
-0.05896172299981117,
-0.07734037935733795,
0.10078353434801102,
0.2213667333126068,
0.5145214796066284,
-0.18129056692123413,
-0.8207423686981201,
-0.3045639991760254,
-0.024350740015506744,
-0.5330215096473694,
0.15352794528007507,
-0.06520865857601166,
-0.5019041299819946,
0.13948288559913635,
0.2956463098526001,
-0.7442699074745178,
0.3751320242881775,
0.0034967774990946054,
-0.06660435348749161,
0.5013972520828247,
-0.38901978731155396,
0.23717522621154785,
-0.9430612325668335,
-0.049410928040742874,
-0.4305993616580963,
-0.2527818977832794,
-0.3735223412513733,
0.4079560339450836,
0.10301709920167923,
-0.11253271996974945,
-0.4155941307544708,
0.5454866886138916,
-0.6752414107322693,
-0.35212182998657227,
-0.30497807264328003,
0.34029197692871094,
-0.19748815894126892,
0.5427280068397522,
0.29133230447769165,
1.0304450988769531,
0.40705791115760803,
-0.5821321606636047,
0.03858286142349243,
0.2696886956691742,
-0.5438824892044067,
0.3404206335544586,
-0.11715611070394516,
0.5163451433181763,
-0.32613733410835266,
0.08937426656484604,
-0.7302353382110596,
-0.06138269603252411,
0.22160878777503967,
-0.43516525626182556,
0.2215469628572464,
0.0831335261464119,
-0.8047993183135986,
-0.17932263016700745,
-0.6133427023887634,
0.47394561767578125,
0.4321732521057129,
-0.5763093829154968,
0.5760675072669983,
0.433663010597229,
-0.18327006697654724,
-0.7792062759399414,
-0.4533476233482361,
0.11128585040569305,
-0.0037250188179314137,
-0.39584171772003174,
0.2785053551197052,
-0.1862860918045044,
-0.28558996319770813,
-0.1768876612186432,
-0.01779581420123577,
0.07859823852777481,
0.04400361329317093,
0.012361838482320309,
0.004068442620337009,
0.12603840231895447,
0.44664520025253296,
0.04289049282670021,
0.0669570341706276,
0.276025652885437,
-0.19155530631542206,
0.3820439279079437,
-0.005460475571453571,
-0.34984251856803894,
-0.04588023200631142,
0.4135562479496002,
0.14272354543209076,
-0.37289297580718994,
0.7496760487556458,
0.1595953404903412,
-0.5443602204322815,
-0.6284508109092712,
-0.6154353618621826,
-0.254768967628479,
-0.4698411226272583,
0.22984839975833893,
-0.4846147894859314,
-0.9600834846496582,
0.40496915578842163,
-0.19727666676044464,
0.2751210927963257,
0.03204625844955444,
0.6948755979537964,
-0.09333190321922302,
1.0564230680465698,
0.3766222298145294,
0.21876107156276703,
0.5074574947357178,
-0.1599145084619522,
0.22595073282718658,
-1.0378599166870117,
-0.385027676820755,
-0.32373207807540894,
-0.27060213685035706,
-0.6793791055679321,
-0.8975878953933716,
0.5818368792533875,
0.041422419250011444,
-0.22570236027240753,
-0.12384779751300812,
-0.5499694347381592,
0.44702985882759094,
0.7009024024009705,
0.5446837544441223,
0.5599169731140137,
-0.0728330984711647,
-0.23255655169487,
0.08390667289495468,
-0.6683284640312195,
-0.49520647525787354,
1.104599118232727,
0.15914109349250793,
0.7898546457290649,
0.10939525067806244,
0.9738379120826721,
0.23559688031673431,
0.3701757490634918,
-0.6024590134620667,
0.9047497510910034,
0.45986390113830566,
-0.851248562335968,
-0.40069490671157837,
-0.32930630445480347,
-0.9603146314620972,
0.6438868641853333,
-0.3545598089694977,
-0.9648650288581848,
0.07577955722808838,
-0.022997962310910225,
-0.4747411906719208,
0.3816979229450226,
-0.3787756562232971,
0.3894049823284149,
-0.29256319999694824,
-0.5557335615158081,
-0.5984078049659729,
-0.7374323606491089,
0.6342547535896301,
-0.1665268987417221,
0.3083852529525757,
-0.07098238170146942,
-0.15391595661640167,
0.7238168716430664,
-0.35971689224243164,
0.3989122807979584,
-0.0774003267288208,
-0.10740583389997482,
0.5877257585525513,
0.27031201124191284,
0.6743946671485901,
0.14544004201889038,
-0.19331465661525726,
-0.42490625381469727,
0.007109377533197403,
-0.2097776085138321,
-0.6089340448379517,
0.6247062087059021,
-0.5437281131744385,
-0.965971052646637,
-0.6771397590637207,
-0.6335510015487671,
-0.49707528948783875,
0.0697348341345787,
-0.21219617128372192,
0.06361377239227295,
-0.11945084482431412,
0.01889454759657383,
0.850240170955658,
-0.4910721480846405,
0.3236290216445923,
0.42840883135795593,
-0.7758836150169373,
-0.34870755672454834,
0.5261904001235962,
0.13715800642967224,
0.4102853834629059,
0.5934669375419617,
0.22158946096897125,
-0.3515169620513916,
-0.6308181285858154,
0.026208870112895966,
0.32163122296333313,
-0.7028435468673706,
-0.1820402890443802,
-0.7556754350662231,
-0.34042197465896606,
-0.12798987329006195,
0.20150017738342285,
-0.24941188097000122,
-0.6205587387084961,
-0.09386688470840454,
-0.30767589807510376,
0.5152010917663574,
0.47264477610588074,
-0.21542741358280182,
-0.13955052196979523,
-0.6230141520500183,
0.5158873200416565,
0.5148147344589233,
0.3748089373111725,
0.07499930262565613,
-0.490571528673172,
-0.2951933741569519,
-0.023341843858361244,
-0.3742676079273224,
-0.960527241230011,
0.32486435770988464,
0.013599863275885582,
0.22092194855213165,
0.015905585139989853,
0.28262290358543396,
0.5214025974273682,
-0.6152002215385437,
0.5112483501434326,
-0.2443551868200302,
-0.5857437252998352,
0.7509065866470337,
-0.23165731132030487,
0.22422687709331512,
0.6446858048439026,
0.40027907490730286,
-0.3463800847530365,
-0.48439499735832214,
-0.629902184009552,
-0.6355845332145691,
0.6235861778259277,
0.3958774209022522,
0.020957907661795616,
-0.43096813559532166,
0.32635626196861267,
-0.054443877190351486,
0.3998863101005554,
-0.5820648670196533,
0.07013488560914993,
0.4369327425956726,
0.16634978353977203,
0.31345292925834656,
-0.2889842987060547,
-0.07787512987852097,
-0.3305630683898926,
0.8081169724464417,
-0.04594864696264267,
0.32121941447257996,
0.4607219994068146,
0.020762501284480095,
-0.29673871397972107,
0.4593263566493988,
0.40218427777290344,
0.7278445363044739,
-0.4727676808834076,
0.2246064990758896,
0.2491193562746048,
-0.18179073929786682,
0.024905189871788025,
-0.08856022357940674,
-0.16907432675361633,
-0.053764522075653076,
-0.12281130999326706,
0.31831374764442444,
0.1617840677499771,
-0.8935851454734802,
0.4186042249202728,
-0.0018330422462895513,
-0.09063224494457245,
-0.5535581707954407,
0.14242736995220184,
0.21325844526290894,
0.5914693474769592,
0.544078528881073,
-0.06301235407590866,
0.4082300662994385,
-0.6934711337089539,
0.2504638135433197,
0.6907045841217041,
-0.0038180144038051367,
-0.012465753592550755,
0.6379644274711609,
0.13783720135688782,
-0.48180750012397766,
0.696181058883667,
-0.27778559923171997,
-0.5000408887863159,
0.3028732240200043,
0.30037832260131836,
0.9992895722389221,
-0.23869118094444275,
0.2571744918823242,
0.2923194468021393,
0.33726516366004944,
-0.3296087980270386,
0.8961246013641357,
-0.28407272696495056,
-0.8672366142272949,
-0.7111698985099792,
-0.4754799008369446,
-0.6563494205474854,
0.12824025750160217,
-0.5741643309593201,
0.1204744502902031,
-0.5895918011665344,
-0.2467234581708908,
-0.42530399560928345,
0.18496182560920715,
-0.5314182043075562,
0.31337228417396545,
0.23188146948814392,
1.0577620267868042,
-0.3175847828388214,
1.0461832284927368,
0.24338914453983307,
-0.2088615596294403,
-0.5349332690238953,
-0.14231930673122406,
-0.4385169744491577,
-0.7954214215278625,
0.8825575113296509,
0.09538187831640244,
-0.26467785239219666,
-0.006761477328836918,
-0.5841978192329407,
-0.9011628031730652,
0.7062578201293945,
0.2722662687301636,
-0.5902083516120911,
-0.28354859352111816,
-0.20800597965717316,
0.5320080518722534,
-0.2828761041164398,
0.16190871596336365,
0.3975681960582733,
0.3037901222705841,
0.026970289647579193,
-0.7202844023704529,
0.05044082924723625,
-0.10342639684677124,
-0.03515860438346863,
0.4201469421386719,
-0.49661606550216675,
0.6934533715248108,
-0.5669898986816406,
-0.36295971274375916,
-0.11989058554172516,
0.7717511653900146,
0.6074643135070801,
0.10580528527498245,
0.36345335841178894,
0.4837273955345154,
0.8877411484718323,
0.32887881994247437,
1.0631645917892456,
-0.31276077032089233,
0.15946806967258453,
1.3367769718170166,
-0.35644662380218506,
1.3277169466018677,
0.5303422212600708,
-0.21234741806983948,
0.4870946705341339,
0.8001987338066101,
0.5060113668441772,
0.602288007736206,
0.2538619637489319,
-0.5211607813835144,
-0.33531755208969116,
0.03263115882873535,
-0.3355690836906433,
0.03976336866617203,
0.566434383392334,
-0.4022107720375061,
0.012398431077599525,
-0.23518992960453033,
-0.11016537994146347,
0.1889118105173111,
-0.4107474982738495,
0.695148766040802,
0.12185405194759369,
-0.7446569204330444,
0.43695393204689026,
-0.06773960590362549,
0.5064328908920288,
-0.4237208664417267,
-0.1393560916185379,
-0.030984925106167793,
0.021184224635362625,
-0.11445051431655884,
-0.9242185950279236,
0.15333397686481476,
-0.0074111465364694595,
0.002277179853990674,
-0.47328677773475647,
0.5875859260559082,
-0.48021095991134644,
-0.5250251293182373,
0.36555829644203186,
0.7563163042068481,
0.34656885266304016,
-0.1614142805337906,
-0.8680503368377686,
-0.15794622898101807,
-0.1435316503047943,
-0.5358661413192749,
0.40116915106773376,
0.533271849155426,
-0.16478057205677032,
0.8393343687057495,
0.4478144645690918,
0.20655100047588348,
0.11424558609724045,
0.09421483427286148,
0.9196218252182007,
-0.7750017642974854,
-0.5390574932098389,
-0.7176877856254578,
0.25708672404289246,
-0.17860350012779236,
-0.02583351358771324,
0.45752614736557007,
0.6605027914047241,
1.0423710346221924,
0.18682609498500824,
0.6951987743377686,
0.14711731672286987,
0.9145166873931885,
-0.6579582691192627,
0.30990973114967346,
-0.33453866839408875,
0.5202714800834656,
-0.3203769028186798,
-0.882569432258606,
-0.09498077630996704,
0.7624087333679199,
-0.6159570813179016,
0.2911299169063568,
0.8872138261795044,
0.7701036930084229,
0.20518246293067932,
0.16717024147510529,
0.37964990735054016,
-0.00013362790923565626,
0.18296252191066742,
0.7738555073738098,
1.0302367210388184,
-0.36926257610321045,
0.1576717048883438,
-0.3681495487689972,
-0.05353192985057831,
0.013890134170651436,
-0.8197509050369263,
-0.9011852741241455,
-0.5386779308319092,
-0.29365381598472595,
-0.2776336371898651,
0.12862858176231384,
1.367992639541626,
0.5307310819625854,
-0.6737980246543884,
-0.4623557925224304,
0.018949490040540695,
0.3166639506816864,
-0.09352666884660721,
-0.2446741908788681,
0.3433666527271271,
-0.5656005144119263,
-0.45085906982421875,
0.43141523003578186,
0.38504332304000854,
-0.19584819674491882,
-0.28861549496650696,
-0.011562255211174488,
-0.7359381318092346,
0.3384138345718384,
0.7142648696899414,
0.08073201775550842,
-0.6424952745437622,
-0.4954589307308197,
-0.1665114164352417,
-0.06579075008630753,
0.26328667998313904,
0.8576655983924866,
-0.906171977519989,
0.719810962677002,
0.49632978439331055,
0.9014855027198792,
0.7267334461212158,
0.2557663917541504,
0.5416123270988464,
-0.5735964179039001,
-0.05221851170063019,
0.5643932223320007,
0.24157367646694183,
0.3097250461578369,
-0.43820831179618835,
0.6686802506446838,
0.00891636498272419,
-0.6274052262306213,
-0.8233314752578735,
0.34451016783714294,
-0.646208643913269,
-0.5775339007377625,
0.9859895706176758,
0.16921545565128326,
-0.25386685132980347,
-0.07800916582345963,
-0.44488051533699036,
0.09534993767738342,
-0.49218854308128357,
0.894894540309906,
0.5394501686096191,
-0.4075503349304199,
-0.4121975302696228,
-0.5899285078048706,
0.7106249332427979,
0.36805352568626404,
-0.8962023854255676,
0.12660333514213562,
0.5528935194015503,
0.03904181346297264,
0.03272279351949692,
1.0456163883209229,
-0.14836691319942474,
0.047576043754816055,
-0.23296509683132172,
0.04993140324950218,
0.30484381318092346,
-0.37901970744132996,
-0.12148638069629669,
0.4602873921394348,
0.3688102960586548,
-0.239476278424263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07788v1 | Multi-Intent Attribute-Aware Text Matching in Searching | 2024-02-12T16:54:22 | 2024-02-12T16:54:22 | Mingzhe Li, Xiuying Chen, Jing Xiang, Qishen Zhang, Changsheng Ma, Chenchen Dai, Jinxiong Chang, Zhongyi Liu, Guannan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text matching systems have become a fundamental service in most searching
platforms. For instance, they are responsible for matching user queries to
relevant candidate items, or rewriting the user-input query to a pre-selected
high-performing one for a better search experience. In practice, both the
queries and items often contain multiple attributes, such as the category of
the item and the location mentioned in the query, which represent condensed key
information that is helpful for matching. However, most of the existing works
downplay the effectiveness of attributes by integrating them into text
representations as supplementary information. Hence, in this work, we focus on
exploring the relationship between the attributes from two sides. Since
attributes from two ends are often not aligned in terms of number and type, we
propose to exploit the benefit of attributes by multiple-intent modeling. The
intents extracted from attributes summarize the diverse needs of queries and
provide rich content of items, which are more refined and abstract, and can be
aligned for paired inputs. Concretely, we propose a multi-intent
attribute-aware matching model (MIM), which consists of three main components:
attribute-aware encoder, multi-intent modeling, and intent-aware matching. In
the attribute-aware encoder, the text and attributes are weighted and processed
through a scaled attention mechanism with regard to the attributes' importance.
Afterward, the multi-intent modeling extracts intents from two ends and aligns
them. Herein, we come up with a distribution loss to ensure the learned intents
are diverse but concentrated, and a kullback-leibler divergence loss that
aligns the learned intents. Finally, in the intent-aware matching, the intents
are evaluated by a self-supervised masking task, and then incorporated to
output the final matching result. | [
-0.20454952120780945,
-0.26642218232154846,
0.8511099815368652,
0.38841864466667175,
-0.0191185362637043,
-0.3332676291465759,
0.1039368286728859,
-0.37926727533340454,
0.3277820348739624,
0.7200769186019897,
-0.716128408908844,
-0.36018887162208557,
-0.36588799953460693,
0.060522809624671936,
-0.28567740321159363,
0.940692663192749,
-0.13694263994693756,
-0.1571110486984253,
-0.5444194674491882,
-0.5430383682250977,
-0.7043982148170471,
-0.37364789843559265,
-0.6192727088928223,
-0.15897110104560852,
0.7170708179473877,
0.40782901644706726,
0.482608437538147,
0.556294322013855,
0.8136860728263855,
0.16772474348545074,
0.17301012575626373,
0.35156160593032837,
-0.3415185213088989,
0.45679402351379395,
-0.0956936851143837,
-0.33156171441078186,
-0.49585291743278503,
0.32085156440734863,
0.5594333410263062,
0.14677560329437256,
0.06563378870487213,
0.059944506734609604,
0.014280172064900398,
0.727637529373169,
-0.8093264698982239,
-0.235908642411232,
-0.5778871178627014,
-0.10030630975961685,
-0.15166331827640533,
-0.27859655022621155,
-0.5782099962234497,
-0.16823387145996094,
0.2414935678243637,
-0.6258643865585327,
0.12733842432498932,
0.18453045189380646,
0.7388838529586792,
0.2294606864452362,
-0.7068395018577576,
-0.598418653011322,
-0.49614134430885315,
0.8672871589660645,
-0.46651336550712585,
0.5381621718406677,
0.6126110553741455,
0.24420496821403503,
0.0744180828332901,
-0.3765546381473541,
-0.5915097594261169,
0.0370367132127285,
-0.5547640919685364,
0.20875371992588043,
0.26820340752601624,
-0.0003479791630525142,
-0.15908819437026978,
0.2864968776702881,
-0.580321192741394,
-0.00346143520437181,
-0.02102656103670597,
-0.03641289100050926,
0.8021024465560913,
0.06521697342395782,
0.4400672912597656,
0.02919464372098446,
-0.7615258097648621,
-0.2617562413215637,
-0.42327386140823364,
0.09828820079565048,
0.4150378406047821,
0.28141629695892334,
0.10098393261432648,
0.8035049438476562,
-0.24919696152210236,
0.5101191401481628,
0.09235307574272156,
-0.2526661455631256,
0.007325149606913328,
-0.767561674118042,
0.09254905581474304,
0.19157686829566956,
0.9326212406158447,
0.45153072476387024,
-0.049665383994579315,
-0.1093837097287178,
-0.09400773048400879,
-0.13698700070381165,
0.2777135372161865,
-0.6885875463485718,
-0.03661036118865013,
0.19344009459018707,
-0.6515429615974426,
-0.2151535004377365,
-0.07541905343532562,
-0.40015488862991333,
-0.3357163369655609,
-0.043547116219997406,
0.7931996583938599,
-0.48012056946754456,
-0.0041387551464140415,
0.37496381998062134,
-0.06904734671115875,
0.5090925097465515,
0.12477351725101471,
-1.031427264213562,
0.17346063256263733,
0.7040139436721802,
0.80908203125,
-0.009748433716595173,
-0.29513874650001526,
-0.26034119725227356,
0.4883616864681244,
0.020791513845324516,
0.905716061592102,
-0.8030494451522827,
-0.05455932021141052,
-0.35057225823402405,
-0.24138663709163666,
-0.19251377880573273,
0.0521252304315567,
0.73588627576828,
-0.7755753397941589,
0.4545172154903412,
-0.26143878698349,
-0.5251870155334473,
-0.5255436301231384,
0.35633450746536255,
-1.10689377784729,
1.278936505317688,
-0.051162801682949066,
-0.7328775525093079,
0.29953712224960327,
-0.9944295287132263,
-0.5213406682014465,
-0.010549061931669712,
-0.0005023900885134935,
-0.8651962280273438,
0.12767904996871948,
0.2595616579055786,
0.46983662247657776,
-0.3816366493701935,
-0.15958164632320404,
-0.47697412967681885,
-0.1578494757413864,
0.3605808615684509,
-0.2473198026418686,
0.5879642367362976,
-0.10630867630243301,
-0.055665481835603714,
-0.037705037742853165,
-0.33353736996650696,
-0.008836161345243454,
-0.12878713011741638,
-0.1446952074766159,
-0.806107759475708,
0.29305410385131836,
-0.08655832707881927,
0.4115341007709503,
0.3547866642475128,
-0.5018926858901978,
0.22836188971996307,
-0.01273423433303833,
0.036060355603694916,
0.5025357604026794,
-0.16379830241203308,
0.7798357009887695,
-0.4344441890716553,
0.19112062454223633,
-0.03407641872763634,
0.1839396357536316,
-0.2624984085559845,
-0.4838964641094208,
-0.38599780201911926,
-0.34528955817222595,
0.08981285989284515,
0.4695488512516022,
-0.36972755193710327,
0.36289554834365845,
-0.2560994625091553,
-0.4609626233577728,
-0.8450360298156738,
-0.01915637217462063,
0.24115729331970215,
0.285869300365448,
0.3766435980796814,
-0.3414905369281769,
-0.18455193936824799,
-0.8142229914665222,
-0.5703748464584351,
0.03544532507658005,
-0.05761539563536644,
0.7628557682037354,
0.19394852221012115,
-0.16514869034290314,
1.0645484924316406,
-0.754912257194519,
-1.034466028213501,
-0.23379145562648773,
0.00024410791229456663,
-0.07515618205070496,
0.45681318640708923,
0.6989559531211853,
-1.132770299911499,
-0.8445022106170654,
0.10380179435014725,
-0.4543202519416809,
-0.09820448607206345,
-0.15394318103790283,
-0.4273667633533478,
-0.1424289047718048,
0.14801634848117828,
-0.6447744965553284,
0.36902329325675964,
0.4988408088684082,
-0.521952748298645,
0.4501669704914093,
-0.12674164772033691,
0.4500146210193634,
-1.2780563831329346,
0.050362661480903625,
0.17068296670913696,
0.04212013632059097,
-0.8214259743690491,
-0.07636755704879761,
0.3260832726955414,
0.1750437319278717,
-0.2417217642068863,
0.5175861120223999,
-0.5552759766578674,
-0.09220917522907257,
-0.22766003012657166,
0.044335104525089264,
0.49399465322494507,
0.3724168837070465,
0.1107497438788414,
0.7742488384246826,
0.5131536722183228,
-0.6581072211265564,
0.20185646414756775,
0.2281615287065506,
-0.032974954694509506,
0.7825450897216797,
-0.41858163475990295,
0.07547585666179657,
-0.30511829257011414,
0.1840476095676422,
-1.004156231880188,
-0.17582440376281738,
-0.06627213954925537,
-0.4855442941188812,
-0.005033082794398069,
-0.055683307349681854,
-0.34396159648895264,
-0.06791789829730988,
-0.8837215900421143,
1.0740303993225098,
-0.07717584818601608,
-0.48718976974487305,
1.0788228511810303,
0.20497336983680725,
-0.09763675183057785,
-0.7381497621536255,
-0.4274560511112213,
-0.2264733612537384,
-0.3717869520187378,
-0.7198217511177063,
0.6851558685302734,
-0.15829704701900482,
0.4078691899776459,
0.12570980191230774,
-0.01739419624209404,
-0.32774975895881653,
0.17485745251178741,
-0.021084556356072426,
0.24615490436553955,
-0.10957279801368713,
0.16876736283302307,
0.02329484559595585,
-0.018735786899924278,
-0.28622692823410034,
-0.20448750257492065,
0.39505690336227417,
0.06991422176361084,
-0.5466036200523376,
-0.47933751344680786,
0.786416232585907,
0.6623197197914124,
-0.6719510555267334,
0.9932384490966797,
0.7942292094230652,
-0.4311131238937378,
0.18099617958068848,
-0.6921448707580566,
-0.21624192595481873,
-0.4619515538215637,
0.2516269087791443,
-0.5367604494094849,
-0.8635435104370117,
0.645755410194397,
0.3561428487300873,
0.07569530606269836,
0.3929833173751831,
0.2747400403022766,
-0.341961145401001,
1.3989533185958862,
0.6805298924446106,
0.18005967140197754,
0.44493329524993896,
0.003349233651533723,
0.6723668575286865,
-1.3010600805282593,
-0.6442824602127075,
-0.5483875274658203,
-0.5692304372787476,
-0.7226150035858154,
-0.14664219319820404,
0.3171875774860382,
-0.13727322220802307,
0.1400611847639084,
0.6199694871902466,
-0.608977735042572,
0.5406854152679443,
0.8456050753593445,
0.21654821932315826,
0.19498740136623383,
-0.12413953989744186,
0.2391911745071411,
-0.1054651290178299,
-0.335537314414978,
-0.2654654383659363,
1.1170539855957031,
0.11288923025131226,
1.0768156051635742,
0.44874995946884155,
0.5791433453559875,
0.04169537127017975,
0.1568349003791809,
-0.8780127763748169,
0.3173332214355469,
-0.43098342418670654,
-0.5981112122535706,
-0.32362231612205505,
-0.4522516131401062,
-0.8104991912841797,
0.3982190191745758,
-0.24877102673053741,
-0.6563675403594971,
0.21778422594070435,
0.10304580628871918,
-0.3433275520801544,
0.10845492035150528,
-0.6658092737197876,
0.9432622790336609,
-0.5715873837471008,
-0.17699864506721497,
-0.061537180095911026,
-0.5547423362731934,
0.3467119038105011,
0.04541269689798355,
-0.09884054958820343,
-0.359269917011261,
-0.019511010497808456,
0.786281943321228,
0.18019390106201172,
0.258750319480896,
0.18535448610782623,
-0.028575856238603592,
0.013418333604931831,
0.05888993293046951,
0.4249579906463623,
0.014786921441555023,
0.11485373228788376,
-0.2832491397857666,
-0.059400323778390884,
-0.23582126200199127,
-0.6784218549728394,
0.7213285565376282,
-0.4997212290763855,
-0.2849923074245453,
-0.46194320917129517,
-0.7335049510002136,
0.15027570724487305,
0.4479387402534485,
0.13609716296195984,
0.4854337275028229,
0.04860999807715416,
0.3769032061100006,
0.940568208694458,
0.046101830899715424,
0.35275694727897644,
0.4823775589466095,
0.17012503743171692,
-0.1343667358160019,
0.8993032574653625,
-0.24248090386390686,
0.12619870901107788,
0.7820555567741394,
0.0944330245256424,
-0.7711353898048401,
-0.20701754093170166,
-0.026463322341442108,
0.29318469762802124,
-0.47634047269821167,
-0.42072275280952454,
-0.8518543839454651,
-0.04131190478801727,
-0.6109726428985596,
-0.2254093587398529,
-0.26361507177352905,
-0.09387938678264618,
-0.40751326084136963,
0.29100701212882996,
0.3144499957561493,
0.5963094234466553,
0.23249392211437225,
0.5171106457710266,
-0.5538973212242126,
0.45943936705589294,
0.5054271817207336,
0.8762521743774414,
-0.18615980446338654,
-0.12176131457090378,
-0.2937699854373932,
0.08164156228303909,
-0.36572185158729553,
-1.0155431032180786,
0.21116599440574646,
0.43783295154571533,
0.555537223815918,
0.4889831244945526,
0.21449561417102814,
0.4863310158252716,
-0.36736875772476196,
0.3969677984714508,
0.1887650340795517,
-0.5066726803779602,
0.465876042842865,
0.15099658071994781,
0.12270990014076233,
0.8869259357452393,
0.4656573235988617,
-0.7703657746315002,
-0.12005925923585892,
-0.20737886428833008,
-0.7711725234985352,
0.9919491410255432,
0.384403795003891,
-0.08661193400621414,
0.20325173437595367,
0.1513151228427887,
0.011203003115952015,
-0.14012931287288666,
-0.9814907312393188,
-0.19586394727230072,
-0.07287857681512833,
-0.6937693357467651,
0.28546372056007385,
-0.33019086718559265,
0.12702733278274536,
0.20652048289775848,
0.8071245551109314,
-0.08589935302734375,
0.3477593958377838,
0.07879722863435745,
-0.38288798928260803,
0.4776982069015503,
0.3238520622253418,
0.5149787068367004,
-0.041097111999988556,
-0.29146119952201843,
0.32719504833221436,
-0.24779577553272247,
-0.7167477607727051,
0.2830204665660858,
0.1513029783964157,
-0.1478671133518219,
-0.09663336724042892,
-0.0019876372534781694,
0.6111783981323242,
0.050545431673526764,
-0.42068272829055786,
0.7261773943901062,
-0.4655286371707916,
0.07099352777004242,
0.10361348092556,
0.005761680193245411,
0.04069644957780838,
0.06602933257818222,
0.5449520945549011,
-0.00981147214770317,
0.5626834034919739,
-0.37265610694885254,
0.1525963991880417,
0.8172178268432617,
-0.46060240268707275,
-0.1972554326057434,
0.5116022229194641,
0.13433869183063507,
-0.3524946868419647,
0.4506729245185852,
-0.20325297117233276,
-0.7642058730125427,
0.4400128722190857,
0.48438236117362976,
1.0241413116455078,
-0.4278756082057953,
0.0968194231390953,
0.17464566230773926,
0.3917042016983032,
-0.20601193606853485,
0.17174680531024933,
-0.21904337406158447,
-0.6766072511672974,
-0.37644079327583313,
-0.5066006779670715,
-0.15590915083885193,
0.03868382051587105,
-0.657040536403656,
0.2957923114299774,
0.2693231701850891,
-0.08507496863603592,
0.15836460888385773,
-0.030788147822022438,
-0.7403603792190552,
0.055529139935970306,
-0.19704432785511017,
0.6295625567436218,
-0.8851488828659058,
0.3044763207435608,
0.8356718420982361,
-0.2194795161485672,
-0.645547091960907,
-0.06311163306236267,
-0.25841209292411804,
-0.530878484249115,
0.0946042537689209,
0.6619097590446472,
-0.2539159953594208,
-0.05532817915081978,
-0.17182433605194092,
-1.0966095924377441,
1.3032416105270386,
0.10399457812309265,
-0.029235567897558212,
-0.02617470547556877,
0.17822064459323883,
0.04918837919831276,
-0.5774699449539185,
0.5401452779769897,
0.3513232171535492,
0.3059585392475128,
-0.07502338290214539,
-0.8246130347251892,
0.10349471867084503,
0.02085915394127369,
0.04881002753973007,
0.5067532658576965,
-0.4966907799243927,
0.8628574013710022,
-0.10032545775175095,
-0.33014315366744995,
-0.02569425106048584,
0.5662559866905212,
0.2470400184392929,
0.5082105398178101,
0.3059024512767792,
0.6894998550415039,
0.3649832606315613,
-0.03496531397104263,
0.6574937105178833,
-0.2985244691371918,
0.6245951056480408,
0.967805027961731,
-0.4146033227443695,
0.7230390310287476,
0.3673865795135498,
0.07727571576833725,
0.4389050304889679,
0.4220716655254364,
0.3542003035545349,
0.8348973989486694,
-0.43566611409187317,
-0.5894330739974976,
-0.1652253270149231,
-0.22421489655971527,
-0.19874794781208038,
0.5882303714752197,
0.3784289062023163,
-0.38583508133888245,
-0.30164167284965515,
-0.10775243490934372,
-0.28944098949432373,
0.06422830373048782,
-0.20613615214824677,
1.109326958656311,
-0.26056376099586487,
-0.678993821144104,
-0.26399654150009155,
0.11465423554182053,
0.7759984135627747,
-0.5401871800422668,
-0.05520892143249512,
-0.15316060185432434,
0.11861672252416611,
-0.3060035705566406,
-1.094586730003357,
0.0331854410469532,
-0.4882144033908844,
-0.557275116443634,
-0.21290142834186554,
1.0632922649383545,
-0.8913183808326721,
-0.40449753403663635,
0.18072843551635742,
-0.025192495435476303,
-0.040432460606098175,
-0.3209289312362671,
-0.4901834726333618,
-0.161518856883049,
-0.215160071849823,
-0.07596061378717422,
0.285654753446579,
0.4965076148509979,
-0.04180655628442764,
0.7103760838508606,
0.590326726436615,
-0.30287283658981323,
0.020513003692030907,
-0.02144002728164196,
0.5625289082527161,
-0.5409395098686218,
-0.7289589643478394,
-0.9642584919929504,
0.2969268262386322,
-0.16760820150375366,
-0.07741722464561462,
0.6100502610206604,
0.7177926301956177,
0.5189365148544312,
0.12832878530025482,
0.5788523554801941,
0.03479444608092308,
0.19733479619026184,
-0.3677275478839874,
0.7080406546592712,
-0.579741895198822,
0.11683399230241776,
-0.1159486174583435,
-1.0520662069320679,
-0.16844674944877625,
0.6140099763870239,
0.16178375482559204,
0.15995217859745026,
0.5101763010025024,
0.7987097501754761,
-0.44554755091667175,
-0.3612402081489563,
0.09010092169046402,
-0.44005122780799866,
0.23532265424728394,
0.8150671720504761,
0.4717409908771515,
-0.7691102027893066,
0.6153694987297058,
-0.09354598075151443,
-0.19551889598369598,
-0.634077787399292,
-0.8234542608261108,
-0.5575215816497803,
-0.8672434091567993,
-0.12834423780441284,
-0.10402099788188934,
-0.2982478439807892,
0.3499740660190582,
0.6469205617904663,
-0.49121782183647156,
0.0039041186682879925,
0.264708936214447,
0.5703299045562744,
-0.35348761081695557,
-0.2627783715724945,
0.5166281461715698,
0.004138362593948841,
-0.36229386925697327,
0.0945618748664856,
0.602496862411499,
0.23409728705883026,
-0.21644344925880432,
-0.18327966332435608,
-0.5961784720420837,
0.2419295459985733,
0.8316262364387512,
-0.00006863435555715114,
-0.4801274240016937,
-0.40420129895210266,
0.5240312814712524,
-0.33710476756095886,
-0.02465239353477955,
0.8353525400161743,
-0.6327871084213257,
0.5095799565315247,
0.4178449511528015,
0.6248960494995117,
0.36207228899002075,
0.2031879872083664,
0.35494464635849,
-1.060283899307251,
-0.3677452802658081,
0.34285619854927063,
0.07373388856649399,
0.48013097047805786,
-0.7218037843704224,
0.337230920791626,
-0.3089941442012787,
-0.5839201807975769,
-0.7361112236976624,
0.42095673084259033,
-1.1959668397903442,
0.08728347718715668,
1.0741631984710693,
0.09465694427490234,
-0.04669683799147606,
-0.043664779514074326,
-0.25306808948516846,
0.06713873893022537,
-0.3027171492576599,
0.6796674728393555,
0.7263940572738647,
-0.3838786482810974,
-0.22915975749492645,
-0.058750636875629425,
0.45791730284690857,
0.46090638637542725,
-0.60478276014328,
-0.15843108296394348,
0.15633030235767365,
0.05469461530447006,
0.2783867418766022,
0.7306812405586243,
0.11347289383411407,
0.511130154132843,
-0.3813197612762451,
-0.009465989656746387,
0.22987696528434753,
-0.39022111892700195,
-0.028292475268244743,
0.01118103414773941,
-0.06629834324121475,
-0.4182250499725342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07787v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07787v3 | Extensible Multi-Granularity Fusion Network for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-02-12T16:52:26 | 2024-03-04T08:42:32 | Xiaowei Zhao, Yong Zhou, Xiujuan Xu, Yu Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) evaluates sentiment expressions within
a text to comprehend sentiment information. Previous studies integrated
external knowledge, such as knowledge graphs, to enhance the semantic features
in ABSA models. Recent research has examined the use of Graph Neural Networks
(GNNs) on dependency and constituent trees for syntactic analysis. With the
ongoing development of ABSA, more innovative linguistic and structural features
are being incorporated (e.g. latent graph), but this also introduces complexity
and confusion. As of now, a scalable framework for integrating diverse
linguistic and structural features into ABSA does not exist. This paper
presents the Extensible Multi-Granularity Fusion (EMGF) network, which
integrates information from dependency and constituent syntactic, attention
semantic , and external knowledge graphs. EMGF, equipped with multi-anchor
triplet learning and orthogonal projection, efficiently harnesses the combined
potential of each granularity feature and their synergistic interactions,
resulting in a cumulative effect without additional computational expenses.
Experimental findings on SemEval 2014 and Twitter datasets confirm EMGF's
superiority over existing ABSA methods. | [
-0.6273308396339417,
-1.1019238233566284,
0.48083317279815674,
0.40780356526374817,
-0.30918624997138977,
0.09841158241033554,
0.03288329392671585,
-0.45616135001182556,
0.8021641373634338,
0.3402269184589386,
-0.30517810583114624,
-0.5147216320037842,
-0.43506529927253723,
-0.013168291188776493,
-0.24258266389369965,
0.9854607582092285,
-0.07959529012441635,
-0.17804454267024994,
-0.2917581796646118,
-0.44501644372940063,
-0.17449253797531128,
-0.6241376996040344,
-0.37726569175720215,
-0.347186416387558,
0.6055150628089905,
0.09533432871103287,
0.6171156167984009,
0.2852962911128998,
0.5641754865646362,
0.41375675797462463,
-0.056169070303440094,
0.2764057219028473,
0.014171265065670013,
0.19426487386226654,
-0.25431710481643677,
-0.1253400593996048,
-0.7436346411705017,
-0.27939265966415405,
0.5686109066009521,
0.8846895098686218,
0.18848010897636414,
-0.035355012863874435,
0.2749820053577423,
0.7387210726737976,
-0.514763593673706,
0.6721742153167725,
-0.381256103515625,
0.15012149512767792,
0.05964551120996475,
0.11509890854358673,
0.12244878709316254,
-0.242177352309227,
0.1568879336118698,
-0.25962725281715393,
-0.08512943238019943,
-0.09320026636123657,
0.8369709849357605,
0.10872404277324677,
-0.35292771458625793,
-0.10610518604516983,
-0.5021040439605713,
0.5059546828269958,
-0.41267460584640503,
0.24635736644268036,
0.023314332589507103,
0.08497962355613708,
0.30953171849250793,
-0.5744988322257996,
-0.3870583474636078,
0.2227458953857422,
-0.2340984344482422,
0.2892763614654541,
-0.23577040433883667,
0.4062362611293793,
-0.296501100063324,
0.7428185343742371,
-0.22795195877552032,
-0.01865517534315586,
-0.020789707079529762,
-0.18000094592571259,
0.4385908842086792,
0.04866296797990799,
0.053063586354255676,
-0.609062671661377,
-0.262418270111084,
-0.06765493005514145,
-0.4602203667163849,
-0.05344349890947342,
0.3602689504623413,
0.6404649615287781,
-0.2595706582069397,
0.41324591636657715,
-0.42247718572616577,
0.7902957797050476,
0.06922128796577454,
0.11560965329408646,
0.7348842024803162,
-0.6168486475944519,
-0.3635600805282593,
-0.08003934472799301,
1.0446345806121826,
-0.10537859797477722,
-0.593325138092041,
-0.023310374468564987,
-0.23610243201255798,
-0.09476698189973831,
0.15649840235710144,
-0.4673982262611389,
-0.208786278963089,
0.44055548310279846,
-0.44315874576568604,
-0.4306822717189789,
0.143271341919899,
-0.8991785645484924,
-0.22659233212471008,
-0.3003174662590027,
0.4486181437969208,
-0.5154182314872742,
-0.3183373510837555,
-0.5532841086387634,
-0.11203362792730331,
0.058768272399902344,
0.11815840750932693,
-0.7042405605316162,
-0.016218675300478935,
0.8807840943336487,
1.057704210281372,
0.1805456578731537,
-0.3035476803779602,
-0.2743271589279175,
0.07696760445833206,
-0.05759573355317116,
1.1516226530075073,
-0.7132486701011658,
-0.12516048550605774,
0.06554881483316422,
-0.1522906869649887,
-0.18984805047512054,
-0.31176093220710754,
0.3557613790035248,
-0.25404199957847595,
-0.06316382437944412,
-0.18855024874210358,
-0.2304747849702835,
-0.9097476601600647,
0.6761446595191956,
-0.8797120451927185,
0.7899608016014099,
0.4357069134712219,
-0.6929562091827393,
0.41285860538482666,
-0.822288990020752,
-0.5130652785301208,
-0.1451214849948883,
-0.3359883725643158,
-0.480764240026474,
0.2040073573589325,
0.47858554124832153,
0.6186473369598389,
-0.04134521633386612,
0.36066851019859314,
-0.61173415184021,
0.2921581566333771,
0.07891829311847687,
-0.2729963958263397,
0.2690346837043762,
0.08854672312736511,
-0.09769271314144135,
0.3173903226852417,
-0.5591042041778564,
0.010833540000021458,
-0.25147104263305664,
-0.2646777629852295,
-0.4468506872653961,
-0.19035373628139496,
-0.15645378828048706,
0.46492016315460205,
0.19371606409549713,
-0.5181652903556824,
0.016952749341726303,
-0.5639562606811523,
0.3993571996688843,
0.42708060145378113,
0.210776224732399,
0.4102274775505066,
-0.27651217579841614,
0.3185191750526428,
0.24278895556926727,
0.17319728434085846,
-0.32765355706214905,
-0.48376861214637756,
-0.6680833101272583,
-0.1707889884710312,
0.08155863732099533,
0.2838398218154907,
-1.0075041055679321,
0.7499495148658752,
-0.41574394702911377,
-0.35525599122047424,
-0.40641677379608154,
0.29670611023902893,
0.37464916706085205,
0.22197255492210388,
0.24935035407543182,
-0.48518484830856323,
-0.4630535840988159,
-1.0513012409210205,
-0.18209373950958252,
-0.27256762981414795,
0.30295372009277344,
0.5336642861366272,
0.46627286076545715,
0.09510203450918198,
1.0904148817062378,
-0.3524651825428009,
-0.7822147607803345,
-0.6303583383560181,
0.32494401931762695,
0.12854094803333282,
0.1900676190853119,
0.4205494523048401,
-1.0465381145477295,
-0.30839142203330994,
0.4210149645805359,
-0.892993152141571,
-0.1499500870704651,
-0.014648174867033958,
0.04847051575779915,
0.13816402852535248,
0.1424950659275055,
-0.26694658398628235,
0.09375742077827454,
0.9657028913497925,
-0.3322882652282715,
0.17374302446842194,
0.074835404753685,
0.09507782012224197,
-1.3445508480072021,
0.06090690940618515,
0.11027718335390091,
-0.2538183927536011,
-0.5905316472053528,
0.05491727218031883,
-0.03947046771645546,
-0.1793394684791565,
-0.4643498361110687,
0.2921651601791382,
-0.27598509192466736,
-0.34855854511260986,
-0.297056645154953,
0.2658379077911377,
0.370643675327301,
0.7106552124023438,
-0.16734986007213593,
0.3438819944858551,
0.41186586022377014,
-0.36435815691947937,
0.49877506494522095,
0.18878281116485596,
0.11738404631614685,
0.7610200047492981,
-0.4137662947177887,
0.060464560985565186,
0.07707423716783524,
0.2739945352077484,
-0.5491810441017151,
-0.34674787521362305,
0.3564852178096771,
-0.26853230595588684,
0.2880309522151947,
-0.12870827317237854,
-0.2693932354450226,
-0.19244594871997833,
-0.5068485736846924,
0.4355754256248474,
-0.11201921850442886,
-0.452593058347702,
1.374382495880127,
0.6588577032089233,
-0.32746031880378723,
-0.45871108770370483,
-0.521336019039154,
0.1507982462644577,
-0.0734696015715599,
-0.8411489129066467,
0.4045431315898895,
0.5546659827232361,
-0.31601065397262573,
0.3885367214679718,
0.291164755821228,
-0.06918804347515106,
-0.08691637963056564,
0.49857333302497864,
-0.051864854991436005,
-0.09912516921758652,
0.2612574100494385,
0.3066343367099762,
-0.09641513973474503,
-0.15182280540466309,
-0.3567969799041748,
0.7358424067497253,
-0.6226562857627869,
-0.41801223158836365,
-0.2057654857635498,
0.4863605499267578,
0.38781923055648804,
-0.23188377916812897,
0.7310054302215576,
0.481025755405426,
-0.23491300642490387,
-0.11715783178806305,
-0.45081737637519836,
0.16635830700397491,
-0.4172532260417938,
0.6423203945159912,
-0.24866510927677155,
-0.9132893085479736,
0.7138285636901855,
-0.10481934249401093,
-0.09796952456235886,
0.6925789713859558,
0.48346349596977234,
0.18769624829292297,
0.8409956693649292,
0.5889794230461121,
-0.16432833671569824,
0.6391576528549194,
-0.43829867243766785,
0.3033153712749481,
-1.2238155603408813,
-0.36857718229293823,
-0.2992485761642456,
-0.33243483304977417,
-0.2591480612754822,
-0.4424421787261963,
0.5929811000823975,
-0.02137228474020958,
-0.014750717207789421,
0.00164999277330935,
-0.27327802777290344,
0.1836106926202774,
0.28955087065696716,
0.08669527620077133,
0.25238388776779175,
-0.08930837363004684,
0.03518462926149368,
0.42494601011276245,
-0.584638774394989,
-0.12392130494117737,
0.7937329411506653,
0.4211367964744568,
0.6141926050186157,
0.07120547443628311,
0.5774661302566528,
0.17580752074718475,
0.27097734808921814,
-1.1216049194335938,
0.37790653109550476,
-0.4338360130786896,
-0.18526409566402435,
-0.19064044952392578,
-0.5506560802459717,
-0.510040819644928,
0.4736672043800354,
-0.14674517512321472,
-0.6771884560585022,
0.31478244066238403,
0.17695832252502441,
-0.3814753293991089,
0.5700305104255676,
-0.5882033705711365,
0.5386214256286621,
-0.08170370012521744,
-0.11553950607776642,
-0.0672692134976387,
-0.31161338090896606,
0.29056432843208313,
-0.3048418462276459,
0.29347968101501465,
-0.06074947491288185,
0.009510058909654617,
0.7767727375030518,
-0.46010756492614746,
1.088022232055664,
-0.18157123029232025,
-0.020971056073904037,
0.36123961210250854,
-0.12342997640371323,
0.41100916266441345,
0.1250871866941452,
-0.05779729783535004,
0.5403391122817993,
-0.38236796855926514,
-0.11198923736810684,
-0.7044742107391357,
0.8615176677703857,
-0.6909545063972473,
-0.42392802238464355,
-0.24323830008506775,
-0.7006266713142395,
-0.3456641137599945,
0.16913391649723053,
-0.023302854970097542,
0.677012026309967,
-0.287781298160553,
0.20860539376735687,
0.09959671646356583,
-0.03665180131793022,
0.6689292192459106,
0.10335565358400345,
-0.41966599225997925,
-0.763508141040802,
1.077020525932312,
0.34305840730667114,
0.24122217297554016,
0.4588874876499176,
0.32844895124435425,
-0.188521608710289,
-0.49919593334198,
-0.5343729853630066,
0.07507409155368805,
-0.6812347173690796,
-0.5174073576927185,
-1.011911153793335,
-0.3206428289413452,
-0.3942777216434479,
-0.07240594178438187,
-0.49439719319343567,
-0.4956507682800293,
0.04410208761692047,
-0.12448009103536606,
0.44201865792274475,
0.9260867834091187,
-0.215219646692276,
0.4423092007637024,
-0.9849498271942139,
-0.07530832290649414,
0.28698012232780457,
0.36202147603034973,
0.06564147025346756,
-0.0763726606965065,
-0.3756125867366791,
-0.06088423728942871,
-0.5991887450218201,
-0.7232654690742493,
0.47083133459091187,
0.47819429636001587,
0.33603987097740173,
0.6254387497901917,
-0.2517302632331848,
0.40916380286216736,
0.05059044808149338,
0.8605086207389832,
0.22490592300891876,
-1.1324639320373535,
0.47757166624069214,
-0.40351393818855286,
0.303404301404953,
0.5688939690589905,
0.03890383988618851,
-0.5065581798553467,
-0.405381441116333,
-0.5227620005607605,
-1.0174864530563354,
0.6467185616493225,
0.09148052334785461,
0.07127416133880615,
0.03034358285367489,
0.12905928492546082,
0.309341698884964,
0.263418585062027,
-0.4519314467906952,
-0.1372201293706894,
-0.39756283164024353,
-0.35464778542518616,
0.26283252239227295,
-0.05663199722766876,
-0.3267902731895447,
-0.042051881551742554,
0.747205913066864,
-0.6822410821914673,
0.29469192028045654,
0.13821014761924744,
0.024112453684210777,
0.20688961446285248,
0.18451325595378876,
-0.062441617250442505,
0.5058276653289795,
0.022008515894412994,
0.22042621672153473,
0.16564533114433289,
-0.3358606994152069,
-0.1280500441789627,
0.2809247374534607,
-0.19075362384319305,
-0.16352559626102448,
0.4473091661930084,
0.8081427812576294,
0.2715992331504822,
-0.012710466980934143,
0.5440474152565002,
0.09599702805280685,
-0.1320628970861435,
-0.208308607339859,
-0.2293662428855896,
0.010159127414226532,
0.25530582666397095,
0.24430610239505768,
0.20863336324691772,
0.15902207791805267,
-0.6357837319374084,
0.21510790288448334,
0.4671521484851837,
-0.81072998046875,
-0.6043331027030945,
-0.10738557577133179,
0.4667755961418152,
-0.03061935491859913,
0.34980523586273193,
-0.3182617425918579,
-0.7720648050308228,
0.5879228115081787,
0.2769226133823395,
1.0605732202529907,
-0.165268212556839,
0.6039982438087463,
0.0257872287184,
0.04895416274666786,
0.2705823481082916,
0.41242295503616333,
0.1859445571899414,
-0.8423988223075867,
-0.4933781027793884,
-0.8842296004295349,
-0.386803537607193,
-0.17817167937755585,
-0.5203976035118103,
-0.10943440347909927,
-0.5070610046386719,
-0.09839454293251038,
0.08867841958999634,
-0.21903395652770996,
-0.6292253136634827,
0.085533507168293,
-0.04101954773068428,
0.43851709365844727,
-1.083643913269043,
0.5404493808746338,
0.8851593732833862,
-0.6400956511497498,
-0.8303338289260864,
-0.10086893290281296,
0.03336168825626373,
-0.674295961856842,
0.30544787645339966,
0.38870692253112793,
0.001276651513762772,
-0.39455175399780273,
-0.11113034933805466,
-0.9538441896438599,
1.0510958433151245,
-0.020848499611020088,
-0.07330147922039032,
0.059292975813150406,
0.2154180258512497,
0.4130796194076538,
-0.7377950549125671,
0.28021249175071716,
0.5203689336776733,
0.4013810455799103,
0.1556568592786789,
-0.8721826672554016,
0.04086965322494507,
-0.1917857527732849,
-0.036624256521463394,
0.6412160396575928,
-0.918464183807373,
1.015368938446045,
0.14704442024230957,
-0.06176885589957237,
-0.4452415406703949,
0.8759651780128479,
-0.2768293619155884,
0.32259368896484375,
0.660377562046051,
0.7679940462112427,
0.5557790994644165,
-0.2784355878829956,
0.8952650427818298,
-0.3498685956001282,
0.5986954569816589,
0.9883196353912354,
-0.1415187120437622,
0.7773323059082031,
0.42208823561668396,
-0.14754082262516022,
0.8362654447555542,
0.3490045666694641,
0.13313867151737213,
0.3124465048313141,
-0.3066445589065552,
-0.3318380117416382,
-0.12216173857450485,
-0.6354297399520874,
-0.21698452532291412,
0.7801240086555481,
0.6419793963432312,
-0.6824795007705688,
-0.4746704697608948,
0.23784270882606506,
-0.005067321937531233,
-0.23424690961837769,
-0.5039056539535522,
1.0631976127624512,
0.3207227289676666,
-0.4195531904697418,
-0.1990332007408142,
-0.14540012180805206,
0.5750774145126343,
-0.6909204125404358,
-0.013233697973191738,
-0.18024449050426483,
0.1683719903230667,
-0.5906873345375061,
-0.97382652759552,
0.7915656566619873,
-0.3360840678215027,
-0.10405126959085464,
0.14296801388263702,
0.7921277284622192,
-0.3019762933254242,
-0.631036639213562,
0.4951073229312897,
0.8258136510848999,
-0.1738593876361847,
-0.45914384722709656,
-0.6518480777740479,
-0.0181270781904459,
-0.15437814593315125,
-0.2970770299434662,
0.46438032388687134,
0.5210657119750977,
0.09715843200683594,
0.47211241722106934,
0.45464688539505005,
0.1603192239999771,
-0.470600962638855,
0.28816866874694824,
1.299540638923645,
-0.6074669361114502,
-0.8232508897781372,
-0.7968001365661621,
0.1450880914926529,
-0.2964547574520111,
-0.21093136072158813,
0.6744041442871094,
0.3990934491157532,
0.5259086489677429,
0.4622518718242645,
1.029876708984375,
-0.4704480469226837,
0.11998741328716278,
-0.520029604434967,
0.6366019248962402,
-0.4748675525188446,
0.05384248122572899,
-0.2804310917854309,
-1.1136566400527954,
-0.4964556097984314,
0.19205926358699799,
-0.41688990592956543,
0.3474366068840027,
0.8597792387008667,
0.5918480753898621,
-0.1089540347456932,
0.3542959988117218,
0.27272260189056396,
0.2309906929731369,
0.5427770614624023,
0.4266262650489807,
0.5962015986442566,
-0.16246187686920166,
0.5500971078872681,
-0.5931025743484497,
-0.4063112437725067,
-0.00610473332926631,
-0.8248695731163025,
-0.6856862902641296,
-0.6614043712615967,
-0.19706861674785614,
-0.36637377738952637,
-0.27076780796051025,
0.9198061227798462,
0.4881725609302521,
-0.7364819049835205,
0.2682656943798065,
0.09447596222162247,
0.20953191816806793,
-0.47527754306793213,
-0.2809238135814667,
0.8554381132125854,
-0.4902525544166565,
-0.606715738773346,
0.2231447398662567,
0.7908763289451599,
-0.2354307621717453,
-0.5583450198173523,
0.32077106833457947,
-0.08779969066381454,
0.0013414924032986164,
0.6933830380439758,
0.13700374960899353,
-0.4079896807670593,
-0.5586048364639282,
-0.39988887310028076,
0.3095419108867645,
0.30725911259651184,
0.7817240953445435,
-0.8384606838226318,
0.49000999331474304,
0.71613609790802,
0.5697283148765564,
-0.11891291290521622,
0.33423516154289246,
0.6477909684181213,
-0.8677055239677429,
0.005419899243861437,
0.18997618556022644,
0.6102976202964783,
0.6024206280708313,
-0.3124721944332123,
0.3404930531978607,
0.1657036691904068,
-0.34196025133132935,
-0.25060272216796875,
0.18969587981700897,
-0.9725079536437988,
-0.1509837657213211,
1.2926496267318726,
-0.3701918423175812,
-0.566922664642334,
-0.4582468569278717,
-0.05953647196292877,
0.05972089618444443,
-0.6076996922492981,
0.6296118497848511,
0.4943384528160095,
-0.48312151432037354,
0.12227103859186172,
0.08684364706277847,
0.19196867942810059,
0.19949813187122345,
-1.1598390340805054,
0.030252641066908836,
0.3695406913757324,
-0.1700589656829834,
0.5690370202064514,
0.5011188387870789,
-0.20590940117835999,
-0.06500933319330215,
0.2559126913547516,
-0.0702580139040947,
-0.4674479365348816,
-0.4838627576828003,
-0.6264075040817261,
0.6218942403793335,
-0.20046594738960266,
-0.06556559354066849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07776v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07776v2 | TELLER: A Trustworthy Framework for Explainable, Generalizable and Controllable Fake News Detection | 2024-02-12T16:41:54 | 2024-05-28T06:14:34 | Hui Liu, Wenya Wang, Haoru Li, Haoliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of fake news has emerged as a severe societal problem,
raising significant interest from industry and academia. While existing
deep-learning based methods have made progress in detecting fake news
accurately, their reliability may be compromised caused by the non-transparent
reasoning processes, poor generalization abilities and inherent risks of
integration with large language models (LLMs). To address this challenge, we
propose {\methodname}, a novel framework for trustworthy fake news detection
that prioritizes explainability, generalizability and controllability of
models. This is achieved via a dual-system framework that integrates cognition
and decision systems, adhering to the principles above. The cognition system
harnesses human expertise to generate logical predicates, which guide LLMs in
generating human-readable logic atoms. Meanwhile, the decision system deduces
generalizable logic rules to aggregate these atoms, enabling the identification
of the truthfulness of the input news across diverse domains and enhancing
transparency in the decision-making process. Finally, we present comprehensive
evaluation results on four datasets, demonstrating the feasibility and
trustworthiness of our proposed framework. Our implementation is available at
\url{https://github.com/less-and-less-bugs/Trust_TELLER}. | [
-0.04420476034283638,
-0.9857176542282104,
0.9067515134811401,
0.17364807426929474,
-0.2656160593032837,
0.2320408672094345,
-0.12681792676448822,
-0.6223105192184448,
0.2176845818758011,
0.32024893164634705,
-0.30165180563926697,
-0.3691750466823578,
-0.7137210369110107,
-0.4043962061405182,
-0.7612327337265015,
0.9346268773078918,
0.002950183814391494,
0.12133752554655075,
0.07614971697330475,
-0.027386389672756195,
-0.03880292922258377,
-0.2529414892196655,
-0.5752877593040466,
-0.4509262144565582,
0.08950237184762955,
0.07664693146944046,
0.8951829075813293,
0.5453360676765442,
0.06662103533744812,
0.22084102034568787,
0.17134878039360046,
0.1714094877243042,
-0.18394310772418976,
-0.31108811497688293,
-0.6551846265792847,
-0.4345680773258209,
-0.23290246725082397,
0.28167083859443665,
0.2719215452671051,
0.2096237987279892,
-0.19759388267993927,
0.18126657605171204,
-0.21393969655036926,
0.38468456268310547,
-0.4807620942592621,
0.01876188814640045,
-0.7103478908538818,
-0.10846053808927536,
-0.055935245007276535,
-0.09245327115058899,
-0.4101727604866028,
-0.31661584973335266,
0.141760915517807,
-0.6475619673728943,
0.2551988363265991,
0.0972890630364418,
1.0740582942962646,
0.0228330809623003,
-0.5998579859733582,
-0.4659513533115387,
-0.7031395435333252,
0.5744595527648926,
-0.39337989687919617,
0.5007799863815308,
0.23631802201271057,
0.5548721551895142,
-0.04680013656616211,
-0.6837670803070068,
-0.8682608008384705,
-0.21497583389282227,
-0.021905459463596344,
0.058456867933273315,
-0.4647684395313263,
-0.1264425665140152,
-0.2715098261833191,
0.17070159316062927,
-0.6809940934181213,
-0.08424379676580429,
-0.12280458211898804,
-0.847682535648346,
0.19699223339557648,
-0.3263654410839081,
0.2880063056945801,
-0.04173629730939865,
-0.5481114387512207,
-0.003834938630461693,
-0.27363619208335876,
-0.04144785553216934,
0.67544025182724,
0.018328845500946045,
-0.295502632856369,
0.31536173820495605,
-0.45092424750328064,
0.5685412883758545,
0.4429174065589905,
-0.2555384933948517,
0.20272955298423767,
-0.2907876968383789,
-0.47401177883148193,
0.16611935198307037,
0.5696238279342651,
0.11717315018177032,
0.31278589367866516,
-0.1998334378004074,
-0.1311434656381607,
0.7483828067779541,
0.36473891139030457,
-0.5066344738006592,
-0.0788978785276413,
0.16607651114463806,
-0.5684337615966797,
-0.8115001320838928,
0.2630057632923126,
-0.5281668305397034,
-0.33368125557899475,
-0.4627741873264313,
0.5737763047218323,
-0.616737961769104,
-0.621732771396637,
0.3151658773422241,
-0.2660265564918518,
0.12436773627996445,
0.5005325675010681,
-0.35744431614875793,
0.03796076402068138,
0.6695895195007324,
0.4913038909435272,
0.06728990375995636,
-0.13199737668037415,
-0.5995609164237976,
0.30822649598121643,
-0.5447033047676086,
0.6124389171600342,
-0.5455642938613892,
0.2036134898662567,
-0.20938999950885773,
-0.29843369126319885,
0.09471221268177032,
-0.302234947681427,
0.6912906169891357,
-0.8693549036979675,
0.30757060647010803,
0.2254728525876999,
-0.4379575550556183,
-0.16746453940868378,
0.4899996817111969,
-0.5604066252708435,
0.5400208234786987,
0.11159404367208481,
-0.627844512462616,
0.42899730801582336,
-0.3054719865322113,
-0.5056785941123962,
-0.2525090277194977,
-0.2498059868812561,
-0.11586059629917145,
0.26150497794151306,
0.3542613983154297,
0.28031501173973083,
0.14049778878688812,
0.8112152814865112,
-0.3524976968765259,
-0.23702606558799744,
0.4634038805961609,
-0.7688599824905396,
0.7551355957984924,
0.3338911533355713,
-0.5195789933204651,
0.2158580720424652,
-0.6961200833320618,
0.04347751662135124,
0.022506248205900192,
-0.22148622572422028,
-0.21819451451301575,
-0.26272401213645935,
-0.08352626860141754,
0.11508338898420334,
0.33540183305740356,
-0.38112613558769226,
-0.3517700731754303,
-0.2651192545890808,
0.3169167637825012,
0.9959773421287537,
-0.16154693067073822,
0.727846086025238,
-0.24557098746299744,
0.129677876830101,
0.3303024470806122,
0.31554093956947327,
-0.14432433247566223,
-0.12263958156108856,
-0.8142139315605164,
-0.3693290650844574,
0.26422443985939026,
0.7485717535018921,
-0.841054379940033,
0.6155640482902527,
-0.13354085385799408,
-0.3034364879131317,
-0.2646274268627167,
0.07159548997879028,
0.7382113933563232,
0.7367726564407349,
0.45182129740715027,
0.13835284113883972,
-0.4183356761932373,
-1.1256808042526245,
-0.8885047435760498,
-0.16098426282405853,
-0.13609600067138672,
-0.30688780546188354,
0.5143777132034302,
-0.26676616072654724,
1.039764642715454,
-0.10455364733934402,
-0.13044297695159912,
-0.07122744619846344,
-0.03781495988368988,
0.2573591470718384,
0.38595113158226013,
0.38900166749954224,
-1.149940848350525,
-0.24510037899017334,
-0.11756058037281036,
-0.8727378249168396,
0.061742883175611496,
-0.30861473083496094,
-0.14783163368701935,
0.4680933356285095,
0.4534081518650055,
-0.8475138545036316,
0.7592636346817017,
0.49185505509376526,
-0.7122329473495483,
0.7931525111198425,
-0.028485525399446487,
0.019803250208497047,
-0.970458984375,
-0.18895989656448364,
0.13544787466526031,
-0.5854217410087585,
-0.4575768709182739,
0.1524834930896759,
0.08614623546600342,
0.05297736078500748,
-0.18036994338035583,
0.6720468401908875,
-0.06791888922452927,
0.0751713216304779,
-0.2416255921125412,
0.01670796610414982,
0.3021884262561798,
0.32127875089645386,
-0.04522110894322395,
0.3441236913204193,
0.5680917501449585,
-0.6398292779922485,
0.34755975008010864,
-0.15580078959465027,
-0.40429046750068665,
0.9657993316650391,
-0.5298553109169006,
-0.18992504477500916,
-0.02979634329676628,
0.685692310333252,
-0.451498419046402,
-0.420238733291626,
0.724221408367157,
-0.9338670969009399,
0.0939180850982666,
-0.042387496680021286,
-0.67291259765625,
-0.22076286375522614,
-0.038784489035606384,
-0.21955165266990662,
0.284126877784729,
-0.7879297137260437,
0.9363540410995483,
0.1301777958869934,
0.3847246766090393,
-0.5960720181465149,
-0.8792980909347534,
0.11068526655435562,
-0.0570099800825119,
-0.8035501837730408,
0.36076444387435913,
-0.07556312531232834,
-0.5398657917976379,
0.32354432344436646,
-0.7987632155418396,
-0.1516106128692627,
-0.03551357612013817,
0.05730298534035683,
0.26522815227508545,
-0.10567188262939453,
0.33286532759666443,
0.38307714462280273,
-0.33686715364456177,
0.02691589668393135,
-0.7205504775047302,
0.379865825176239,
-0.591265857219696,
-0.37713345885276794,
-0.848044216632843,
0.22305230796337128,
0.5556696653366089,
-0.2285596877336502,
0.7226569056510925,
0.828404426574707,
-0.4917406439781189,
-0.5297402143478394,
-0.7549460530281067,
-0.22889931499958038,
-0.49484702944755554,
0.1156688705086708,
-0.27610597014427185,
-0.9495124220848083,
0.37462735176086426,
0.00645419443026185,
-0.35686954855918884,
0.3205455541610718,
0.4148001968860626,
0.14552730321884155,
0.7783079743385315,
0.5262772440910339,
-0.24945500493049622,
0.12132549285888672,
0.2063918262720108,
0.4152785539627075,
-0.03753800317645073,
-0.20577813684940338,
-0.14802685379981995,
-0.13306975364685059,
-0.22102822363376617,
-0.6206492781639099,
0.06578000634908676,
0.4672496020793915,
-0.35806167125701904,
0.013675360940396786,
-0.5453140735626221,
0.575629711151123,
0.6625010371208191,
0.1659393459558487,
0.8053587675094604,
0.16597479581832886,
-0.26566389203071594,
0.22340518236160278,
-0.09926511347293854,
-0.5933511257171631,
0.9730350375175476,
0.38560181856155396,
0.782048761844635,
0.219365194439888,
0.5688233971595764,
0.5541845560073853,
0.23069241642951965,
-0.4366306960582733,
0.34320327639579773,
0.09953837841749191,
-0.9835265874862671,
-0.21402370929718018,
-0.5331207513809204,
-0.26074397563934326,
0.27439528703689575,
-0.22304512560367584,
-0.5974829196929932,
0.047731224447488785,
0.27968505024909973,
-0.1682274341583252,
0.458176851272583,
-0.8281633257865906,
0.36884570121765137,
-0.37475869059562683,
-0.16128583252429962,
-0.742007315158844,
-0.5551540851593018,
0.6872593760490417,
-0.23819395899772644,
0.45197296142578125,
-0.12439554184675217,
-0.06857339292764664,
0.47753429412841797,
-0.13918164372444153,
1.0106077194213867,
-0.2695182263851166,
0.2114349603652954,
0.3027791380882263,
0.2197744995355606,
0.5393226146697998,
0.6681609153747559,
0.1835964471101761,
0.3526785373687744,
-0.09001113474369049,
-0.31933560967445374,
-0.559461236000061,
0.8631985783576965,
-0.6111863851547241,
-0.4949492812156677,
-0.6458247900009155,
-0.4135512113571167,
-0.23433758318424225,
0.5757672190666199,
0.29184478521347046,
0.1743408888578415,
-0.346203088760376,
0.05633450299501419,
0.9480964541435242,
-0.1396438181400299,
0.2037072777748108,
0.7255740761756897,
-0.5013743042945862,
-0.3781834542751312,
0.9372329711914062,
-0.21931025385856628,
-0.11048441380262375,
0.35212409496307373,
0.2827253043651581,
-0.2545241713523865,
-0.5086884498596191,
-0.39274337887763977,
0.020043058320879936,
-0.532546877861023,
-0.19262704253196716,
-0.5193952918052673,
-0.32440680265426636,
-0.5768432021141052,
-0.31540510058403015,
-0.4105784296989441,
-0.31401270627975464,
-0.20380808413028717,
-0.4162312150001526,
0.17950496077537537,
0.41470375657081604,
-0.2761423587799072,
0.37623587250709534,
-0.5834557414054871,
0.9456599354743958,
0.4078819155693054,
0.563442587852478,
-0.16318513453006744,
-0.35619738698005676,
-0.15256968140602112,
0.24981996417045593,
-0.10842092335224152,
-0.8200066089630127,
0.175460547208786,
-0.1197991818189621,
0.7682997584342957,
0.7971267700195312,
0.19564971327781677,
0.31245169043540955,
-0.08340130001306534,
0.35254183411598206,
0.4042983651161194,
-1.3445391654968262,
0.4088992178440094,
-0.6426685452461243,
-0.184843048453331,
0.5278996825218201,
0.19226966798305511,
-0.28534334897994995,
-0.34938836097717285,
-0.7148173451423645,
-0.45523640513420105,
0.5550722479820251,
0.19890056550502777,
0.179933562874794,
0.1464848816394806,
0.2543210983276367,
0.1766931563615799,
0.4161989986896515,
-0.8567068576812744,
-0.1124788224697113,
-0.4719901978969574,
-0.28209397196769714,
0.23477661609649658,
-0.11675243079662323,
-0.4647752642631531,
-0.05611318722367287,
0.7053260803222656,
-0.21999868750572205,
0.13498663902282715,
0.3022787570953369,
-0.39935389161109924,
-0.03238550201058388,
0.36938512325286865,
0.4182702898979187,
0.8716322779655457,
-0.014045370742678642,
0.12767110764980316,
-0.366665780544281,
-0.40597468614578247,
-0.009079600684344769,
0.13965022563934326,
-0.43824294209480286,
-0.07542362809181213,
0.5343375205993652,
0.49386492371559143,
-0.03741072863340378,
-0.5614010691642761,
0.66949862241745,
0.043429695069789886,
-0.4471696615219116,
-0.7903480529785156,
0.16858159005641937,
0.2932734787464142,
0.516277015209198,
0.7099946737289429,
0.6775259375572205,
-0.0011797629995271564,
-0.5232300758361816,
0.3726876378059387,
0.45041579008102417,
-0.41522690653800964,
-0.36065995693206787,
0.5068947672843933,
0.2207309752702713,
-0.10131404548883438,
0.4807032644748688,
-0.4206463098526001,
-0.5491172075271606,
0.4658374786376953,
0.469820111989975,
0.4584471583366394,
-0.20040377974510193,
0.7542554140090942,
-0.1421022117137909,
0.6720989346504211,
-0.2704656720161438,
-0.018782619386911392,
0.13380493223667145,
-1.2399994134902954,
-0.36082902550697327,
-0.7240891456604004,
-0.13087408244609833,
0.36402925848960876,
-0.6600245833396912,
0.05244725942611694,
-0.7599969506263733,
0.08268791437149048,
-0.10097318887710571,
-0.01280527375638485,
-0.49989965558052063,
0.37540292739868164,
0.3244198262691498,
1.195812702178955,
-0.83504319190979,
0.9305298328399658,
0.2860392928123474,
-0.03880664333701134,
-0.6042764782905579,
0.22802582383155823,
0.5283358693122864,
-0.9076406359672546,
0.3605923354625702,
0.39008915424346924,
-0.25251275300979614,
-0.23907114565372467,
-0.6951872110366821,
-0.6419459581375122,
1.0099984407424927,
0.6698967814445496,
-0.507307231426239,
-0.2110058218240738,
-0.059781674295663834,
0.4923003911972046,
-0.4094804525375366,
-0.14382141828536987,
0.5708407163619995,
0.9885203838348389,
0.06488195061683655,
-0.666169285774231,
0.07152441889047623,
-0.0975157618522644,
-0.35610559582710266,
-0.004536518361419439,
-0.7209591865539551,
0.6237635612487793,
-0.18181587755680084,
-0.16190029680728912,
-0.10021258890628815,
0.7942090034484863,
0.3718282878398895,
0.9926576614379883,
0.5042047500610352,
0.9989802241325378,
0.9463547468185425,
-0.05025054141879082,
0.8893521428108215,
-0.015189525671303272,
0.04599878191947937,
1.3684353828430176,
-0.014795569702982903,
0.4051389992237091,
0.48025980591773987,
0.08791829645633698,
0.9083976149559021,
0.28104427456855774,
-0.131792351603508,
0.45182809233665466,
-0.017098236829042435,
-0.13914582133293152,
-0.6414462327957153,
-0.0024220736231654882,
-0.28471139073371887,
0.6447591781616211,
0.5234703421592712,
-0.5226077437400818,
-0.37086111307144165,
0.03859294205904007,
0.2971826195716858,
0.4015074074268341,
-0.3431036174297333,
0.03949645906686783,
0.10953741520643234,
-0.3537857234477997,
-0.12255662679672241,
0.2316751778125763,
0.9166299104690552,
-0.9328221082687378,
0.09902309626340866,
0.02112937718629837,
0.40256568789482117,
-0.3165889084339142,
-0.5377421975135803,
0.5199577808380127,
-0.19033510982990265,
-0.5293346643447876,
-0.26662880182266235,
1.0222456455230713,
-0.17569097876548767,
-0.5142889022827148,
0.569731593132019,
0.7181704044342041,
-0.44425374269485474,
-0.44277748465538025,
-0.6832786798477173,
0.16343273222446442,
0.08444259315729141,
-0.4272436499595642,
0.42138782143592834,
0.19487300515174866,
-0.28890368342399597,
0.6539669036865234,
1.1372597217559814,
-0.06102637201547623,
-0.10247959196567535,
-0.19194532930850983,
0.8013512492179871,
-0.42432141304016113,
-0.8178603649139404,
-0.6223690509796143,
0.27325478196144104,
-0.42323487997055054,
-0.09963839501142502,
0.8587658405303955,
0.49456527829170227,
0.941996157169342,
0.017913753166794777,
0.9873637557029724,
-0.0949305072426796,
0.7453015446662903,
-0.5393675565719604,
0.9628267884254456,
-0.2749065160751343,
0.2607024908065796,
0.049952246248722076,
-0.6233731508255005,
-0.216986283659935,
0.5068501830101013,
-0.23601505160331726,
-0.022248070687055588,
0.708884596824646,
0.7552371621131897,
-0.22917607426643372,
0.02760506048798561,
0.08987415581941605,
0.30884408950805664,
0.40279102325439453,
0.3276973366737366,
0.7229658961296082,
-0.08452647924423218,
0.9430466890335083,
-0.14936593174934387,
-0.30151093006134033,
-0.22602663934230804,
-0.860379159450531,
-0.8608975410461426,
-0.29970288276672363,
-0.14311198890209198,
-0.6514968276023865,
0.11934477090835571,
0.2984333038330078,
0.9355154633522034,
-0.7790988683700562,
0.43035995960235596,
-0.2788764536380768,
0.51698237657547,
-0.26558971405029297,
-0.36343464255332947,
0.24330250918865204,
0.0281592458486557,
-0.4387189745903015,
0.5654165744781494,
0.21726705133914948,
-0.05558839067816734,
-0.11552754789590836,
-0.3083374798297882,
-0.00820651464164257,
0.3744051456451416,
0.23072227835655212,
0.24951915442943573,
-0.9362021088600159,
-0.45800259709358215,
-0.07707317173480988,
-0.07081498950719833,
-0.46373826265335083,
0.7869912981987,
-1.1552550792694092,
0.3661302924156189,
0.33548930287361145,
0.4324755370616913,
0.4331256151199341,
-0.054495517164468765,
0.39934301376342773,
-0.5204476714134216,
0.27779436111450195,
0.17025718092918396,
-0.010898604057729244,
0.1829938143491745,
-0.6066182255744934,
0.38119930028915405,
0.4554062485694885,
-0.1766398400068283,
-0.7027379274368286,
0.5595905780792236,
-1.0795055627822876,
-0.6315056085586548,
0.7740005850791931,
0.04871182143688202,
-0.2898622155189514,
-0.32768845558166504,
0.27798646688461304,
0.2581142485141754,
-0.7096683979034424,
0.5934760570526123,
0.5443115830421448,
-0.007130470126867294,
0.017080122604966164,
-0.28209173679351807,
0.2997612953186035,
0.0868803933262825,
-0.5623413324356079,
-0.3062308132648468,
0.6894932985305786,
0.6291747093200684,
0.41409948468208313,
0.6664252281188965,
-0.26358509063720703,
0.2599952816963196,
0.15041103959083557,
-0.24289757013320923,
-0.5118238925933838,
-0.5816237926483154,
-0.23068663477897644,
0.12480320781469345,
-0.4840185046195984,
0.08833561092615128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07770v1 | Quantitative knowledge retrieval from large language models | 2024-02-12T16:32:37 | 2024-02-12T16:32:37 | David Selby, Kai Spriestersbach, Yuichiro Iwashita, Dennis Bappert, Archana Warrier, Sumantrak Mukherjee, Muhammad Nabeel Asim, Koichi Kise, Sebastian Vollmer | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, stat.AP | Large language models (LLMs) have been extensively studied for their
abilities to generate convincing natural language sequences, however their
utility for quantitative information retrieval is less well understood. In this
paper we explore the feasibility of LLMs as a mechanism for quantitative
knowledge retrieval to aid data analysis tasks such as elicitation of prior
distributions for Bayesian models and imputation of missing data. We present a
prompt engineering framework, treating an LLM as an interface to a latent space
of scientific literature, comparing responses in different contexts and domains
against more established approaches. Implications and challenges of using LLMs
as 'experts' are discussed. | [
-0.21995413303375244,
-0.7122973203659058,
1.2721402645111084,
0.15508155524730682,
-0.031118769198656082,
0.03744716942310333,
-0.23309025168418884,
-0.1532812863588333,
-0.0805257111787796,
0.4613378047943115,
-0.2210523933172226,
-0.4514800012111664,
-0.448606014251709,
0.21843035519123077,
-0.5447068810462952,
0.48383772373199463,
0.0912175104022026,
0.05496843904256821,
-0.30251145362854004,
0.010145673528313637,
-0.3129720389842987,
-0.6146846413612366,
-0.4774920344352722,
-0.28224170207977295,
0.7297568917274475,
0.2800973057746887,
0.8096336722373962,
0.21254129707813263,
0.5628783106803894,
0.3505474030971527,
-0.17154477536678314,
-0.007436978165060282,
-0.34556064009666443,
0.2710285186767578,
-0.19209043681621552,
-0.565210223197937,
-0.03148510679602623,
0.006762891076505184,
0.8495801091194153,
1.2229039669036865,
0.0275462344288826,
-0.0045306263491511345,
0.13981197774410248,
0.5591055750846863,
-0.44023236632347107,
0.05099325627088547,
-0.7038128972053528,
-0.05195152759552002,
0.01083019282668829,
-0.47488707304000854,
-0.5965037941932678,
-0.6776207089424133,
0.41252854466438293,
-0.48626112937927246,
0.05244327709078789,
0.32795608043670654,
0.44117456674575806,
0.1871073693037033,
-0.6015545725822449,
-0.4868229925632477,
-0.6276109218597412,
0.9113821387290955,
-0.9635847210884094,
0.3673730194568634,
0.34359312057495117,
0.48710930347442627,
-0.4683605134487152,
-0.6850109100341797,
-0.5742063522338867,
-0.5787708759307861,
-0.3446819484233856,
-0.15761959552764893,
0.05209846794605255,
-0.006699694786220789,
0.4433840215206146,
0.257232666015625,
-0.7022228837013245,
0.24730031192302704,
-0.24140115082263947,
-0.0014935523504391313,
0.5735353827476501,
0.2567916512489319,
0.270596444606781,
-0.25747790932655334,
-0.1493731290102005,
0.11320547014474869,
-0.9927641153335571,
-0.14421769976615906,
0.27213427424430847,
0.33253714442253113,
0.17941640317440033,
0.8613066673278809,
-0.26299938559532166,
0.800726592540741,
-0.3487415313720703,
0.0008307578973472118,
-0.010374704375863075,
-0.11062214523553848,
-0.013520384207367897,
-0.19104795157909393,
0.902155876159668,
-0.11814053356647491,
0.22219695150852203,
-0.17791903018951416,
-0.3628869354724884,
-0.5355825424194336,
-0.048284247517585754,
-0.7525184750556946,
-0.30274367332458496,
0.1612876057624817,
-0.4422289729118347,
0.05697425827383995,
0.03534690663218498,
-0.6481465101242065,
-0.4268636405467987,
-0.41119062900543213,
0.429450124502182,
-0.36129245162010193,
-0.1911504715681076,
0.01696542091667652,
-0.3690580427646637,
0.2369428277015686,
0.26168009638786316,
-0.7255268096923828,
0.11624733358621597,
0.6170791983604431,
0.8340070843696594,
-0.05569450557231903,
0.16515617072582245,
-0.48828262090682983,
0.17364132404327393,
-0.4408802390098572,
0.7431841492652893,
-0.7753052711486816,
-0.6003935933113098,
0.07055376470088959,
-0.10549923032522202,
0.18102487921714783,
-0.6077614426612854,
0.2719506621360779,
-1.051316261291504,
0.10506859421730042,
-0.3790407180786133,
-0.7005138397216797,
-0.2960759401321411,
-0.0483785904943943,
-0.6718456745147705,
0.8069186210632324,
0.06037139892578125,
-0.6875937581062317,
0.05428047105669975,
-0.28068605065345764,
-0.20034801959991455,
0.36993736028671265,
-0.4447673559188843,
0.17024001479148865,
0.09131230413913727,
-0.0687759667634964,
0.6627580523490906,
-0.6463601589202881,
0.6220337748527527,
-0.7328463196754456,
-0.15952572226524353,
0.557162344455719,
-0.4552088975906372,
0.6885549426078796,
0.44902992248535156,
0.17689305543899536,
-0.2519574463367462,
-0.73665452003479,
-0.07559812813997269,
-0.042814552783966064,
-0.31490013003349304,
-0.7513681054115295,
0.16415345668792725,
-0.5050114393234253,
-0.05168711394071579,
0.34416258335113525,
-0.37401247024536133,
0.32805174589157104,
-0.4511096775531769,
0.5058678388595581,
0.4912852942943573,
0.16750910878181458,
0.694471538066864,
-0.3012903928756714,
0.5011023283004761,
-0.2999424636363983,
-0.43274256587028503,
-0.24778732657432556,
-0.43945804238319397,
-0.23189042508602142,
-0.29483911395072937,
0.21143877506256104,
0.49787089228630066,
-0.9891100525856018,
0.19347327947616577,
-0.22266435623168945,
-0.3762252628803253,
-0.2087555229663849,
0.1918921321630478,
0.048849917948246,
0.5625766515731812,
0.2183971256017685,
0.26629123091697693,
-0.3869091868400574,
-0.8440571427345276,
-0.24978706240653992,
-0.28140074014663696,
-0.6606987714767456,
0.35194918513298035,
0.41438180208206177,
0.05465242266654968,
1.3005825281143188,
-0.644399106502533,
0.26889553666114807,
-0.09353134781122208,
0.2898963689804077,
0.6666100025177002,
0.3000497817993164,
0.4908351004123688,
-0.8247368335723877,
-0.3429465889930725,
0.04215041548013687,
-1.043017029762268,
-0.3922499120235443,
0.12173430621623993,
-0.09971068054437637,
-0.25783929228782654,
0.6452917456626892,
-0.9105991125106812,
0.029031364247202873,
0.14952532947063446,
-0.02043738402426243,
0.6558396220207214,
-0.04431373253464699,
0.24494612216949463,
-0.9416652321815491,
0.41439318656921387,
0.1515713632106781,
-0.14231286942958832,
-0.5633383393287659,
-0.04284753277897835,
0.14392927289009094,
-0.15937037765979767,
-0.3216356933116913,
0.9711308479309082,
-0.5257784128189087,
-0.09912241250276566,
-0.28983038663864136,
0.3620506525039673,
-0.08577558398246765,
0.01691717468202114,
0.21360087394714355,
0.8474035859107971,
0.34514713287353516,
-0.9234203696250916,
0.42063912749290466,
0.3181535601615906,
-0.41269615292549133,
0.43513092398643494,
-0.8809331655502319,
0.012941299937665462,
-0.4423052668571472,
-0.17425823211669922,
-1.2975631952285767,
-0.35730814933776855,
0.06922608613967896,
-0.48041361570358276,
0.37507742643356323,
-0.2001209855079651,
-0.61409592628479,
-0.5542938709259033,
-0.15253013372421265,
0.3690199851989746,
0.582994282245636,
-0.42689093947410583,
0.42042404413223267,
0.3835282325744629,
-1.0234836339950562,
-0.374267578125,
-0.3289211094379425,
-0.05089787393808365,
-0.5115652084350586,
-0.5273225903511047,
0.12231308966875076,
-0.2527921199798584,
-0.7287638783454895,
-0.14415110647678375,
0.159003347158432,
-0.13689492642879486,
0.19841328263282776,
-0.07594440132379532,
0.357761949300766,
-0.2980160415172577,
0.5470991134643555,
0.1306677609682083,
0.12488498538732529,
0.33827725052833557,
-0.26071852445602417,
0.2167135626077652,
0.3765040636062622,
-0.33172935247421265,
-0.0029796864837408066,
0.3359740376472473,
0.3333675265312195,
0.09476789832115173,
0.5893639922142029,
0.08109904080629349,
-0.3714371621608734,
-0.11916390061378479,
-0.7201104760169983,
-0.4340832829475403,
-0.5243891477584839,
0.2741589844226837,
-0.4232087731361389,
-0.9956738352775574,
0.5164728760719299,
-0.2639347314834595,
0.006974372081458569,
0.33724117279052734,
0.3411829173564911,
-0.2704082727432251,
1.016819715499878,
0.6429030895233154,
-0.05120529979467392,
0.4130828380584717,
0.07041247934103012,
0.1794346421957016,
-0.5967250466346741,
-0.17596542835235596,
-1.0220192670822144,
0.025294216349720955,
-0.14356084167957306,
-0.21153858304023743,
0.5093653202056885,
0.23258109390735626,
-0.43533968925476074,
-0.004116936586797237,
-0.06085807457566261,
0.3016054034233093,
0.48030710220336914,
0.1318826675415039,
0.42517295479774475,
0.011240886524319649,
-0.16975226998329163,
-0.022437188774347305,
-0.7129616141319275,
-0.895007312297821,
0.7313288450241089,
0.31106773018836975,
0.9993049502372742,
0.12033732235431671,
0.15425212681293488,
0.2227240353822708,
0.5248178839683533,
-0.7783901691436768,
0.6602094769477844,
0.07909458875656128,
-0.42297813296318054,
-0.4795045256614685,
-0.8174299597740173,
-0.9804676175117493,
0.17579631507396698,
0.007972308434545994,
-0.6211041212081909,
0.1391020119190216,
-0.20369800925254822,
-0.4894126355648041,
-0.025196604430675507,
-0.5221839547157288,
0.5152510404586792,
-0.24958620965480804,
-0.141633540391922,
-0.11255607008934021,
-0.622377336025238,
0.5309187769889832,
-0.4785265028476715,
0.40991300344467163,
-0.13909763097763062,
-0.15395811200141907,
0.8900604844093323,
-0.5245659351348877,
0.7758169770240784,
-0.2413795292377472,
-0.3313179910182953,
0.361128032207489,
0.22605520486831665,
0.5186073780059814,
0.23804186284542084,
-0.44209784269332886,
-0.2950914800167084,
0.18626469373703003,
-0.31878530979156494,
-0.8858545422554016,
0.7311482429504395,
-0.5911592841148376,
-0.9204285144805908,
-0.09560245275497437,
-0.6364947557449341,
-0.45755642652511597,
0.19613642990589142,
-0.10349088162183762,
0.3450412154197693,
0.07128053903579712,
0.34394946694374084,
0.9485800266265869,
-0.5848033428192139,
0.5494116544723511,
1.013262152671814,
-0.13881109654903412,
-0.2356010228395462,
0.5596025586128235,
0.27427423000335693,
0.08795610815286636,
0.6597347259521484,
0.13306604325771332,
-0.5327647924423218,
-0.6085519790649414,
-0.0685657188296318,
0.42428264021873474,
-0.5990196466445923,
-0.3996448814868927,
-0.777690589427948,
-0.14557640254497528,
-0.3516559302806854,
-0.0024550659582018852,
0.11398356407880783,
-0.26902005076408386,
-0.5162745118141174,
-0.15021705627441406,
0.583258867263794,
0.8533528447151184,
0.09676474332809448,
0.49093398451805115,
-1.0326522588729858,
0.12005184590816498,
0.24476787447929382,
0.07465124130249023,
0.11715158820152283,
-0.7465895414352417,
-0.1357693374156952,
0.16725054383277893,
-0.00784201081842184,
-1.2284847497940063,
0.6247938275337219,
-0.038742873817682266,
0.7994152903556824,
0.10694846510887146,
0.22006124258041382,
0.39463964104652405,
-0.46312570571899414,
0.7234765291213989,
-0.001436693361029029,
-0.636600136756897,
0.5336160659790039,
-0.42483681440353394,
0.2374551147222519,
0.20396625995635986,
1.1506820917129517,
-0.3465464115142822,
-0.3515201210975647,
-0.32412222027778625,
-0.8716054558753967,
0.24440793693065643,
-0.17183449864387512,
0.08156629651784897,
-0.2347487360239029,
0.7669849991798401,
0.33720663189888,
0.4526034891605377,
-0.3203010559082031,
0.16444049775600433,
0.44334352016448975,
-0.43322044610977173,
-0.13544359803199768,
-0.40746864676475525,
0.05604058504104614,
0.08933302015066147,
0.659835934638977,
-0.2610011100769043,
0.08953297883272171,
0.3483005166053772,
-0.24439828097820282,
0.07043585181236267,
0.26160332560539246,
0.14815178513526917,
0.8105461597442627,
0.03658208250999451,
0.20370952785015106,
0.12023507803678513,
-0.0791986957192421,
0.0982927605509758,
0.2427455633878708,
-0.23832949995994568,
-0.0005958600086160004,
0.2870698869228363,
0.3106338679790497,
0.3383467495441437,
-0.806678831577301,
0.2846364676952362,
0.23350974917411804,
0.046760957688093185,
-0.31675490736961365,
-0.1533580869436264,
0.0822780653834343,
0.4971560835838318,
1.009364366531372,
-0.44067516922950745,
0.3095878064632416,
-0.45934468507766724,
0.4429744780063629,
0.6060128211975098,
-0.01113580260425806,
-0.3274756371974945,
0.6604899168014526,
-0.1367025226354599,
-0.0887414813041687,
0.6902413368225098,
0.015938658267259598,
-0.17573204636573792,
0.5536306500434875,
0.2579376995563507,
0.3673623502254486,
-0.10786395519971848,
0.25968360900878906,
0.31694653630256653,
0.007437729276716709,
-0.22663582861423492,
0.38071000576019287,
0.14838196337223053,
-0.5250079035758972,
-0.8453729748725891,
-0.7383406758308411,
-0.3298521339893341,
-0.004616547375917435,
-0.34711095690727234,
0.2713073790073395,
-0.23258429765701294,
-0.25935521721839905,
-0.0319361574947834,
-0.14875982701778412,
-0.6574828028678894,
-0.0661267638206482,
0.07613729685544968,
1.0722733736038208,
-0.6724231839179993,
0.6188551187515259,
0.5975351333618164,
-0.45599451661109924,
-0.904514491558075,
-0.37292802333831787,
-0.2709500193595886,
-0.5772706866264343,
0.978349506855011,
-0.17173105478286743,
0.2543689012527466,
0.2028958648443222,
-0.8251890540122986,
-1.031490445137024,
0.9646511077880859,
0.5073458552360535,
-0.7387228608131409,
-0.11876485496759415,
-0.02833733893930912,
0.5562891364097595,
-0.21635451912879944,
0.6533777713775635,
0.34114107489585876,
0.46790552139282227,
0.29891347885131836,
-0.8007757663726807,
0.23962849378585815,
-0.06673447042703629,
0.004066863562911749,
0.04904526099562645,
-0.4124675989151001,
0.7230220437049866,
-0.24962303042411804,
-0.14609280228614807,
0.42210134863853455,
1.0180710554122925,
0.46461477875709534,
0.3155742287635803,
0.09084068983793259,
0.0921921581029892,
1.0829986333847046,
0.14812570810317993,
0.8827671408653259,
-0.1981869488954544,
0.24552151560783386,
0.8048173189163208,
-0.488995760679245,
0.9948186874389648,
0.5510826110839844,
-0.4420771598815918,
0.3486891984939575,
0.7354996204376221,
0.2571530044078827,
0.5981359481811523,
0.3075138330459595,
-0.37141838669776917,
-0.126420795917511,
-0.15507306158542633,
-0.4296863079071045,
-0.31592416763305664,
0.6375541687011719,
-0.27470043301582336,
-0.13575895130634308,
0.16996172070503235,
-0.17861495912075043,
-0.0560586079955101,
-0.40140441060066223,
0.7073000073432922,
0.5365868210792542,
-0.5966789126396179,
0.4034479260444641,
-0.2748894691467285,
0.39884859323501587,
-0.6036458015441895,
-0.15927939116954803,
-0.38876378536224365,
-0.3398207724094391,
-0.1508737951517105,
-1.024030089378357,
0.21069779992103577,
-0.21937336027622223,
-0.13243350386619568,
-0.07014156132936478,
0.7816202044487,
-0.41402244567871094,
-0.2929089367389679,
0.08646795898675919,
0.7969304919242859,
0.33098310232162476,
-0.22289252281188965,
-0.2673932611942291,
-0.19720673561096191,
-0.28455850481987,
-0.5171828866004944,
0.23376911878585815,
0.8239224553108215,
-0.025207912549376488,
1.042732834815979,
0.5411878228187561,
0.07303130626678467,
0.13948895037174225,
0.09158444404602051,
0.8278493285179138,
-0.914027750492096,
-0.199199378490448,
-0.8961808681488037,
0.2956606149673462,
0.08015890419483185,
0.3070126473903656,
0.8313751816749573,
0.33441898226737976,
0.471436470746994,
-0.2412346601486206,
1.0204309225082397,
0.0043807728216052055,
0.7226927280426025,
-0.6862064003944397,
0.4532739222049713,
-0.4121861159801483,
0.5610829591751099,
-0.0606246180832386,
-0.8820606470108032,
-0.3580839931964874,
0.34729382395744324,
-0.6742313504219055,
0.11123048514127731,
0.6153751015663147,
0.8347322940826416,
0.16483917832374573,
0.07826048880815506,
0.42249274253845215,
0.5455555319786072,
0.2478925734758377,
0.39626261591911316,
1.3182445764541626,
0.10165973007678986,
0.4371064305305481,
0.2499651461839676,
-0.3243734836578369,
-0.11640164256095886,
-0.6793864369392395,
-0.9724039435386658,
-0.5220767855644226,
-0.024482766166329384,
-0.06636261194944382,
0.12802909314632416,
0.8424937725067139,
0.37894949316978455,
-0.6623137593269348,
-0.10932351648807526,
0.0969940796494484,
0.23965388536453247,
0.40226998925209045,
-0.25268450379371643,
0.1468546837568283,
-0.5542901754379272,
-0.604511022567749,
0.6745381951332092,
0.1954578161239624,
0.2513737976551056,
-0.39378249645233154,
-0.032902833074331284,
0.018835067749023438,
-0.039591655135154724,
0.6941812634468079,
0.24054484069347382,
-0.4307590126991272,
-0.2353786826133728,
0.2899138629436493,
-0.3069254159927368,
-0.25416767597198486,
0.9200806021690369,
-1.0505778789520264,
-0.15116538107395172,
0.9440361261367798,
0.7905213236808777,
0.22205275297164917,
-0.02745009958744049,
0.9722439050674438,
-0.5045924782752991,
-0.06394662708044052,
0.34586820006370544,
0.4340921938419342,
0.26473623514175415,
-0.4204650819301605,
0.4858551025390625,
0.18540768325328827,
-0.7276098728179932,
-0.7490799427032471,
0.03633048012852669,
-0.7920448780059814,
-0.4323665499687195,
1.336992859840393,
-0.1674187332391739,
-0.2454705536365509,
-0.2730839252471924,
-0.25202441215515137,
-0.005015640053898096,
-0.36676037311553955,
0.6247541904449463,
0.7817868590354919,
0.27176618576049805,
-0.35971158742904663,
-0.8399835824966431,
0.22691261768341064,
0.4733215868473053,
-0.5548285841941833,
-0.12609423696994781,
0.6096488237380981,
0.2934091091156006,
-0.02204248681664467,
0.5937095880508423,
-0.07486046105623245,
-0.14703845977783203,
-0.36010971665382385,
-0.1616116464138031,
0.40342897176742554,
-0.28808870911598206,
-0.273639053106308,
0.3827442228794098,
0.4921083450317383,
0.5361752510070801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07767v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07767v2 | Text Detoxification as Style Transfer in English and Hindi | 2024-02-12T16:30:41 | 2024-06-09T18:48:06 | Sourabrata Mukherjee, Akanksha Bansal, Atul Kr. Ojha, John P. McCrae, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper focuses on text detoxification, i.e., automatically converting
toxic text into non-toxic text. This task contributes to safer and more
respectful online communication and can be considered a Text Style Transfer
(TST) task, where the text style changes while its content is preserved. We
present three approaches: knowledge transfer from a similar task, multi-task
learning approach, combining sequence-to-sequence modeling with various
toxicity classification tasks, and delete and reconstruct approach. To support
our research, we utilize a dataset provided by Dementieva et al.(2021), which
contains multiple versions of detoxified texts corresponding to toxic texts. In
our experiments, we selected the best variants through expert human annotators,
creating a dataset where each toxic sentence is paired with a single,
appropriate detoxified version. Additionally, we introduced a small Hindi
parallel dataset, aligning with a part of the English dataset, suitable for
evaluation purposes. Our results demonstrate that our approach effectively
balances text detoxication while preserving the actual content and maintaining
fluency. | [
0.24607598781585693,
-0.6545485854148865,
0.3022595942020416,
0.2330731600522995,
-0.3868401348590851,
0.16811829805374146,
-0.16876210272312164,
-0.6215139031410217,
-0.14873184263706207,
0.3214989900588989,
-0.378446489572525,
-0.3697241544723511,
-0.5840458273887634,
0.48367616534233093,
-0.590741753578186,
1.3142790794372559,
-0.2086843103170395,
-0.08120239526033401,
0.14735068380832672,
-0.006722564343363047,
-0.7810909748077393,
-0.14583808183670044,
-0.92540043592453,
-0.2987343668937683,
0.4580485224723816,
0.5331592559814453,
0.21029669046401978,
0.407964289188385,
0.43080973625183105,
0.20593981444835663,
-0.1050795316696167,
0.10637574642896652,
-0.6664959788322449,
0.31243863701820374,
-0.6468536257743835,
-0.3070667088031769,
0.2659672796726227,
-0.015276323072612286,
0.2806958556175232,
0.07695014029741287,
-0.15063737332820892,
-0.04133540391921997,
0.13848777115345,
1.0263499021530151,
-0.6832453608512878,
0.07778941094875336,
-0.5887116193771362,
0.13331152498722076,
-0.08242494612932205,
-0.3280280530452728,
-0.7073174715042114,
-0.5852777361869812,
0.010455599054694176,
-0.5125225782394409,
-0.37762483954429626,
-0.04712580144405365,
0.7521795630455017,
0.33110931515693665,
-0.9383437633514404,
-0.2080942541360855,
-1.0844852924346924,
0.8669775128364563,
-0.5172002911567688,
0.3578700125217438,
0.31437811255455017,
0.21806927025318146,
0.3153727352619171,
-0.5611221194267273,
-0.4075683057308197,
0.17956039309501648,
-0.1468370109796524,
0.44776037335395813,
0.08756978064775467,
-0.1452472060918808,
-0.12591876089572906,
0.21726804971694946,
-0.5495742559432983,
-0.1789831966161728,
-0.6577668190002441,
-0.19117134809494019,
0.6576571464538574,
-0.006055075209587812,
0.9511317610740662,
-0.46525895595550537,
-0.6815266609191895,
0.05723774805665016,
-0.6795088648796082,
-0.3954612612724304,
0.1735285073518753,
0.34801527857780457,
-0.01610909029841423,
0.27158159017562866,
-0.05469920113682747,
0.17298872768878937,
-0.08546072244644165,
-0.3421970307826996,
0.2845101058483124,
-0.8167933225631714,
-0.10269510746002197,
0.2747199535369873,
0.8552947044372559,
0.4856288731098175,
0.3574250638484955,
-0.3067930042743683,
0.1716945767402649,
-0.19686324894428253,
0.7374153137207031,
-0.916316568851471,
-0.27544480562210083,
0.21798056364059448,
-0.7313494682312012,
-0.4090989828109741,
-0.2444385439157486,
-1.306659460067749,
-0.6313677430152893,
-0.3847944438457489,
0.5972657799720764,
-0.7661856412887573,
-0.5794427990913391,
0.08577477186918259,
-0.29513776302337646,
0.22603726387023926,
0.47406744956970215,
-0.7120122909545898,
0.04189322888851166,
0.2217656373977661,
1.0680465698242188,
-0.5473738312721252,
0.12257994711399078,
0.03494838625192642,
0.48656192421913147,
-0.23654823005199432,
0.720413327217102,
-0.5340251326560974,
-0.5080549120903015,
0.033064667135477066,
-0.13009266555309296,
-0.2451697587966919,
-0.37053218483924866,
0.8475586771965027,
-0.2636871039867401,
0.30340853333473206,
-0.3398512899875641,
-0.22158057987689972,
-0.34386295080184937,
0.025571856647729874,
-0.6556715965270996,
1.0312501192092896,
-0.07863990217447281,
-1.0329415798187256,
0.06760599464178085,
-0.7293994426727295,
-0.8662316799163818,
-0.06414927542209625,
0.4781859219074249,
-0.30590692162513733,
-0.21143005788326263,
-0.22550800442695618,
0.2462375909090042,
0.019143057987093925,
-0.07420894503593445,
0.03545396775007248,
-0.4208979308605194,
-0.19049812853336334,
-0.1853432059288025,
0.8423564434051514,
0.7907670140266418,
-0.30771955847740173,
0.3582252264022827,
-0.5086578130722046,
-0.030185813084244728,
0.056112006306648254,
-0.2885904014110565,
-0.6601603627204895,
0.051461417227983475,
0.648643970489502,
0.6133584380149841,
-0.009348945692181587,
-0.6173316240310669,
-0.18605707585811615,
-0.1833319514989853,
0.5914397239685059,
0.7051599025726318,
0.5435691475868225,
0.29865339398384094,
-0.8247047662734985,
0.22222673892974854,
0.050838787108659744,
0.18631957471370697,
0.038273632526397705,
-0.4817487895488739,
-0.4562023878097534,
0.030217140913009644,
-0.18577931821346283,
1.0337119102478027,
-1.09641695022583,
0.05711697041988373,
-0.3427612781524658,
-0.8908365368843079,
-0.003502640873193741,
0.04712678864598274,
0.5767088532447815,
0.484544962644577,
0.6709740161895752,
-0.16573528945446014,
-0.452236533164978,
-0.6493822932243347,
-0.5490517616271973,
-0.19686979055404663,
0.2758651375770569,
-0.043977703899145126,
0.5047329664230347,
-0.16080643236637115,
0.5415118336677551,
-0.4703267514705658,
-0.5050671100616455,
-0.37576454877853394,
0.41067251563072205,
-0.5228622555732727,
0.6513304114341736,
0.4948353171348572,
-0.9199923276901245,
-0.8547490835189819,
0.16679511964321136,
-0.6312466859817505,
-0.26401662826538086,
-0.47069182991981506,
-0.40434640645980835,
0.12835238873958588,
0.6050705313682556,
-0.10078486800193787,
0.4337533414363861,
0.2660120725631714,
-0.03970365971326828,
0.7028228044509888,
-0.024342523887753487,
0.6174702048301697,
-1.5089701414108276,
0.28107988834381104,
0.2901289165019989,
-0.1818048357963562,
-1.2118723392486572,
0.07664431631565094,
0.08736363798379898,
-0.13240714371204376,
-0.8159695863723755,
0.8624747395515442,
-0.30973926186561584,
0.6691956520080566,
-0.24669289588928223,
-0.029581930488348007,
0.12034864723682404,
0.4749599099159241,
0.10315219312906265,
0.8485506772994995,
0.19242317974567413,
-0.480313241481781,
-0.011473194696009159,
0.5064942240715027,
0.07621713727712631,
0.807762622833252,
-0.36110642552375793,
0.11921264231204987,
-0.36510926485061646,
0.13109780848026276,
-1.1811697483062744,
-0.03893271088600159,
0.483287513256073,
-0.02952849492430687,
0.31732940673828125,
-0.03967755660414696,
-0.7623978853225708,
-0.019463058561086655,
-0.4071555435657501,
0.40803787112236023,
0.5694136023521423,
-0.09637892246246338,
0.37204834818840027,
0.29960933327674866,
-0.3115716576576233,
-0.29744505882263184,
-0.7944040298461914,
0.08646170049905777,
-0.6862368583679199,
-0.08202935755252838,
0.38392946124076843,
-0.26604264974594116,
-0.18230487406253815,
-0.16816586256027222,
-0.2719660699367523,
-0.49140816926956177,
0.024791216477751732,
0.26956242322921753,
0.07707773149013519,
0.5237012505531311,
0.3372710347175598,
0.32802116870880127,
0.13489404320716858,
0.012811149470508099,
0.21911460161209106,
0.32799655199050903,
0.16004714369773865,
-0.08606074750423431,
-0.794173002243042,
0.6902483105659485,
0.6015364527702332,
-0.2156342715024948,
0.8740948438644409,
0.8250628709793091,
-0.4934563636779785,
0.017603710293769836,
-0.2725864052772522,
0.061090316623449326,
-0.4734649956226349,
0.27321332693099976,
-0.1778399795293808,
-0.42963850498199463,
0.4435502588748932,
-0.3120156526565552,
0.1282130628824234,
0.608903169631958,
0.5144410133361816,
0.13383053243160248,
0.6226536631584167,
0.7872593998908997,
0.04321673512458801,
0.8621010780334473,
0.15816040337085724,
0.4142349362373352,
-0.608727753162384,
-0.33530953526496887,
-0.44315725564956665,
-0.22060935199260712,
-0.4917319416999817,
-0.1453973799943924,
0.32897263765335083,
-0.20807641744613647,
-0.45317304134368896,
0.4906249940395355,
-0.664931058883667,
0.5293383598327637,
0.2544451951980591,
0.6168206334114075,
0.45617949962615967,
-0.14728133380413055,
0.031826164573431015,
-0.052159979939460754,
-0.1787901073694229,
-0.5533651113510132,
0.9168739914894104,
0.07303538918495178,
0.579266369342804,
0.3236061930656433,
0.7917842268943787,
0.39318689703941345,
0.5959740281105042,
-0.5919907093048096,
0.46399396657943726,
-0.37320828437805176,
-0.7899623513221741,
-0.16248276829719543,
-0.46268829703330994,
-0.6707993745803833,
-0.035232868045568466,
-0.20206168293952942,
-0.8296540975570679,
-0.10401636362075806,
-0.2811642587184906,
-0.08783289045095444,
0.5366093516349792,
-1.1336565017700195,
0.781486988067627,
-0.042865607887506485,
-0.44954049587249756,
-0.24490952491760254,
-0.8281576633453369,
0.6571869850158691,
-0.612637460231781,
0.4441436529159546,
0.0073197027668356895,
0.0010903851361945271,
0.9621005654335022,
-0.11266239732503891,
0.9378939867019653,
0.20331516861915588,
-0.22922520339488983,
0.2594863176345825,
0.24952059984207153,
0.2503354847431183,
-0.3116496205329895,
-0.22533263266086578,
0.10027259588241577,
0.35880446434020996,
-0.25014728307724,
-0.2879696190357208,
0.5015653371810913,
-0.7540873885154724,
-0.2604203224182129,
-0.40628546476364136,
-0.6082645058631897,
-0.25726908445358276,
0.6422757506370544,
0.23803669214248657,
0.21220897138118744,
0.051008619368076324,
-0.18861809372901917,
0.5963036417961121,
-0.484566330909729,
0.4927073121070862,
-0.05860971286892891,
-0.028441336005926132,
-0.1972605288028717,
0.9432045817375183,
-0.08866814523935318,
0.6118435263633728,
0.4583266079425812,
0.3976367712020874,
-0.40226054191589355,
-0.5476980209350586,
-0.21390698850154877,
0.17957884073257446,
-1.0265916585922241,
-0.12258384376764297,
-0.5193801522254944,
-0.539404571056366,
-0.4805854260921478,
-0.10407675802707672,
-0.24447113275527954,
-0.009799184277653694,
-0.4973343014717102,
-0.1289382427930832,
0.7085156440734863,
1.0770217180252075,
0.026777833700180054,
0.19138503074645996,
-1.1501857042312622,
0.27466821670532227,
0.08075713366270065,
0.4563213288784027,
-0.02023950405418873,
-0.4040519595146179,
-0.11399856954813004,
0.035276710987091064,
-0.42196375131607056,
-1.5188976526260376,
0.5602734088897705,
0.302965372800827,
0.45714071393013,
0.3357890546321869,
0.331815630197525,
0.5973078608512878,
-0.5188364386558533,
0.7891629934310913,
0.2030452936887741,
-0.8828650116920471,
0.6898422837257385,
-0.4677372872829437,
0.1505490094423294,
0.8075671792030334,
0.8245939612388611,
-1.1381479501724243,
-0.5042842030525208,
-0.15219630300998688,
-0.9089140892028809,
0.46926039457321167,
0.36700934171676636,
0.26741117238998413,
-0.08553708344697952,
0.4126488268375397,
0.4319961369037628,
-0.0264833215624094,
-0.5681493282318115,
-0.3502601981163025,
-0.4651992917060852,
-0.510430097579956,
0.29234132170677185,
-0.2604576349258423,
-0.048299312591552734,
-0.10438250005245209,
0.6533852219581604,
0.33794787526130676,
0.2988477349281311,
0.14440052211284637,
-0.42621612548828125,
0.031378552317619324,
0.6310728192329407,
0.6182726621627808,
0.4158015847206116,
-0.18333816528320312,
0.24697497487068176,
0.10834137350320816,
-0.8468899726867676,
0.37187883257865906,
-0.2587149739265442,
-0.12434490025043488,
-0.23706366121768951,
0.011493664234876633,
0.4883975088596344,
0.20660196244716644,
-0.5259034037590027,
0.2100825011730194,
-0.07777202129364014,
-0.0948217436671257,
0.10365884006023407,
-0.014080794528126717,
-0.10676552355289459,
-0.30702561140060425,
0.34544676542282104,
0.25358691811561584,
0.3011939525604248,
-0.5823010206222534,
0.5062751770019531,
0.032897185534238815,
-0.37665244936943054,
-0.1871967762708664,
0.9370691776275635,
0.5240035057067871,
-0.021962828934192657,
0.3239552080631256,
-0.3097180724143982,
-0.5925253033638,
0.3147367238998413,
0.546000063419342,
0.8876014947891235,
-0.35914185643196106,
0.31908929347991943,
0.8399989008903503,
0.18735824525356293,
-0.20826812088489532,
0.1748739331960678,
0.18701328337192535,
-0.42232805490493774,
-0.5118113160133362,
-0.5568099617958069,
-0.12137890607118607,
0.07241135090589523,
-0.5098085403442383,
0.09228600561618805,
-0.4529990255832672,
0.15960894525051117,
-0.25080668926239014,
-0.08305807411670685,
-0.26084330677986145,
0.08776850253343582,
0.0004607279843185097,
0.7553080916404724,
-1.4845219850540161,
0.647803544998169,
0.6774681806564331,
-0.6803305745124817,
-0.694729745388031,
0.376083642244339,
0.524777352809906,
-0.4059140384197235,
0.6938861012458801,
0.4091298580169678,
-0.035849958658218384,
0.16569022834300995,
-0.06543781608343124,
-0.9660704135894775,
0.8173545002937317,
-0.020765898749232292,
-0.12908129394054413,
-0.08756458759307861,
0.048020873218774796,
0.6183989644050598,
0.45289817452430725,
0.3552362620830536,
0.35642749071121216,
0.5275487303733826,
0.34234416484832764,
-1.198294997215271,
0.4391198754310608,
-0.64814692735672,
0.1078202947974205,
0.2396530956029892,
-0.6734635829925537,
0.37127751111984253,
-0.0568404383957386,
-0.6904006600379944,
0.009925421327352524,
0.46746382117271423,
-0.20856991410255432,
0.02110055834054947,
0.39167889952659607,
0.5581346750259399,
0.5878125429153442,
0.06614076346158981,
0.8326306939125061,
-0.21525612473487854,
0.21030257642269135,
0.9262105822563171,
-0.34251418709754944,
0.764922559261322,
0.3870244324207306,
-0.006908984389156103,
0.6393502950668335,
0.7424058318138123,
0.36350300908088684,
0.8209816217422485,
0.07420720160007477,
-0.2860361337661743,
0.03137738257646561,
-0.4290142059326172,
-0.2022598385810852,
0.3313184082508087,
0.10246497392654419,
-0.21649590134620667,
-0.6026182174682617,
0.34662917256355286,
0.4015693664550781,
0.21839827299118042,
-0.27005600929260254,
0.9331781268119812,
-0.11297778785228729,
-0.5476537942886353,
0.26457592844963074,
-0.11293603479862213,
0.7288519740104675,
-0.3424926698207855,
-0.14434413611888885,
-0.09467250108718872,
0.04296882823109627,
-0.36820435523986816,
-1.0081777572631836,
0.9634993076324463,
-0.18615557253360748,
0.039848096668720245,
-0.9193583726882935,
1.1113791465759277,
-0.6552798748016357,
-0.30757567286491394,
0.07607781887054443,
0.5564855337142944,
0.24130961298942566,
-0.04641338065266609,
-0.693137526512146,
-0.14201892912387848,
-0.08286915719509125,
-0.001551740220747888,
0.4920129179954529,
0.35458874702453613,
-0.2793455719947815,
0.6576604843139648,
0.6113458275794983,
0.07448264956474304,
0.12451867014169693,
-0.005280042067170143,
0.5410935878753662,
-0.5780692100524902,
-0.29282766580581665,
-0.8038374781608582,
0.5269094705581665,
0.02664143405854702,
-0.15174533426761627,
0.79930180311203,
0.46335622668266296,
0.6291657090187073,
-0.1392097771167755,
0.8652549386024475,
-0.1470058113336563,
0.2949182093143463,
-0.424270898103714,
1.186934232711792,
-0.549820065498352,
-0.21846957504749298,
-0.5720915198326111,
-0.4864741563796997,
-0.3602946400642395,
0.4215661287307739,
-0.22503265738487244,
0.28802987933158875,
1.1207513809204102,
0.49538475275039673,
0.23514099419116974,
0.06643867492675781,
-0.013004299253225327,
0.10974948108196259,
0.3528401255607605,
0.7590518593788147,
0.40345335006713867,
-0.4452427923679352,
0.682063102722168,
-0.5209819078445435,
-0.16688799858093262,
-0.07693120837211609,
-1.1339048147201538,
-0.7279427647590637,
-1.0494657754898071,
-0.5618568062782288,
-0.31102678179740906,
0.08435291051864624,
0.7156469225883484,
0.5848103761672974,
-0.6087379455566406,
0.12338802963495255,
0.003962735179811716,
0.3095751106739044,
-0.5660767555236816,
-0.30813029408454895,
0.3171638250350952,
-0.22727574408054352,
-0.7682809233665466,
-0.01340995728969574,
0.21234819293022156,
0.07152856141328812,
0.058354709297418594,
0.44249922037124634,
-0.6066935062408447,
0.1239987164735794,
0.7945874929428101,
0.21674735844135284,
-0.3636842370033264,
-0.7158963680267334,
-0.3097255229949951,
-0.30846622586250305,
0.1584758162498474,
0.5414502620697021,
-0.39148223400115967,
0.457447350025177,
0.7976908683776855,
0.6488293409347534,
0.12480270862579346,
0.17254602909088135,
0.21226352453231812,
-0.8653795719146729,
-0.13018664717674255,
-0.061142392456531525,
0.10447093844413757,
0.4578041434288025,
-0.672834575176239,
0.5895320177078247,
0.34443703293800354,
-0.427126407623291,
-0.7508034706115723,
0.2841118574142456,
-1.2433151006698608,
-0.5022262930870056,
1.7110657691955566,
0.003603240242227912,
-0.2530232071876526,
-0.49717947840690613,
-0.5572192668914795,
0.8094214200973511,
-0.27730509638786316,
0.9150537252426147,
0.8048045635223389,
-0.08195572346448898,
-0.36664000153541565,
-0.7117036581039429,
0.6503487825393677,
0.08539874106645584,
-1.536107063293457,
0.18726393580436707,
0.2474953979253769,
0.6865221858024597,
0.20379436016082764,
0.5807160139083862,
-0.33359861373901367,
0.027213260531425476,
-0.3940180242061615,
0.06518424302339554,
0.02344462275505066,
-0.2874423861503601,
-0.018488118425011635,
-0.056772176176309586,
-0.3805704414844513,
-0.04542620852589607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07754v1 | Diffusion of Thoughts: Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Diffusion Language Models | 2024-02-12T16:23:28 | 2024-02-12T16:23:28 | Jiacheng Ye, Shansan Gong, Liheng Chen, Lin Zheng, Jiahui Gao, Han Shi, Chuan Wu, Zhenguo Li, Wei Bi, Lingpeng Kong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Diffusion models have gained attention in text processing, offering many
potential advantages over traditional autoregressive models. This work explores
the integration of diffusion models and Chain-of-Thought (CoT), a
well-established technique to improve the reasoning ability in autoregressive
language models. We propose Diffusion-of-Thought (DoT), allowing reasoning
steps to diffuse over time through the diffusion process. In contrast to
traditional autoregressive language models that make decisions in a
left-to-right, token-by-token manner, DoT offers more flexibility in the
trade-off between computation and reasoning performance. Our experimental
results demonstrate the effectiveness of DoT in multi-digit multiplication and
grade school math problems. Additionally, DoT showcases promising
self-correction abilities and benefits from existing reasoning-enhancing
techniques like self-consistency decoding. Our findings contribute to the
understanding and development of reasoning capabilities in diffusion language
models. | [
-0.576436460018158,
-1.3435665369033813,
1.090726375579834,
0.2641794979572296,
-0.2752454876899719,
0.30141305923461914,
-0.019148435443639755,
-0.2091623693704605,
0.13163559138774872,
0.4058510661125183,
-0.23713059723377228,
-0.23365743458271027,
-0.7245656251907349,
-0.12139882147312164,
-0.8246403932571411,
0.5996593832969666,
-0.36773285269737244,
-0.13952331244945526,
-0.046086788177490234,
-0.053397513926029205,
-0.4592514932155609,
-0.7662113308906555,
-0.8537898063659668,
-0.31773632764816284,
0.48087969422340393,
0.0767265036702156,
0.6377701759338379,
0.4289826452732086,
0.2876581847667694,
0.22457240521907806,
-0.22541427612304688,
0.1870681643486023,
-0.262895405292511,
0.2617831528186798,
-0.5175670385360718,
-0.2307281643152237,
-0.9183965921401978,
0.012014736421406269,
0.7186679840087891,
0.8054490089416504,
-0.39995795488357544,
-0.08576890826225281,
-0.09228448569774628,
1.0802297592163086,
-0.8595269918441772,
-0.2624768316745758,
-0.415077805519104,
-0.012966194190084934,
-0.0055792792700231075,
0.08628357946872711,
-0.6237700581550598,
-0.3554444909095764,
0.17045140266418457,
-0.2934693694114685,
-0.10685449838638306,
-0.10836363583803177,
0.03455009311437607,
0.2722811698913574,
-0.4758346974849701,
-0.3882995545864105,
-0.9833518862724304,
0.7001045346260071,
-0.49821895360946655,
0.31708839535713196,
0.5341071486473083,
0.1474824696779251,
-0.13516230881214142,
-0.6910545229911804,
-0.8745121955871582,
0.23786035180091858,
0.12170841544866562,
-0.041242796927690506,
-0.39987823367118835,
-0.17839346826076508,
0.036762434989213943,
0.3641667366027832,
-0.3333570659160614,
-0.28109294176101685,
-0.10066144913434982,
0.14064323902130127,
0.4585731029510498,
0.04365202412009239,
0.1295797973871231,
0.32265010476112366,
-0.5420694947242737,
0.036055952310562134,
-0.485246479511261,
-0.3267049491405487,
0.0468837134540081,
-0.12602181732654572,
0.18315204977989197,
0.3546162247657776,
-0.28499576449394226,
0.8524547815322876,
0.25588351488113403,
0.25915762782096863,
0.06921170651912689,
-0.3330903649330139,
-0.360440731048584,
-0.06295200437307358,
0.5967139005661011,
-0.08448526263237,
0.26421070098876953,
0.08916158974170685,
-0.1402362436056137,
0.09665018320083618,
0.1764082908630371,
-0.4300052523612976,
-0.43133053183555603,
0.21067073941230774,
-0.4905310571193695,
-0.18847747147083282,
-0.4177209436893463,
-0.6796526908874512,
-0.19456151127815247,
-0.13724495470523834,
0.38562098145484924,
-0.5192145705223083,
-0.7047005295753479,
0.5367238521575928,
-0.25235143303871155,
-0.3341645300388336,
0.6327300071716309,
-0.7143051624298096,
0.4546140134334564,
0.5981212258338928,
0.762111246585846,
-0.40215080976486206,
-0.17846553027629852,
-0.12380314618349075,
0.13664180040359497,
-0.5331824421882629,
1.187584400177002,
-0.8904856443405151,
-0.5220599174499512,
-0.2677437961101532,
-0.4749101996421814,
-0.2480890452861786,
-0.2743525505065918,
0.29507866501808167,
-0.5824358463287354,
0.2780918776988983,
-0.14305131137371063,
-0.8424159288406372,
-0.2121797502040863,
0.26123473048210144,
-0.4804970324039459,
1.205399513244629,
-0.07426941394805908,
-0.7279611825942993,
0.2001143991947174,
-0.6902573704719543,
-0.3753165900707245,
-0.08396244049072266,
0.07097682356834412,
-0.28752946853637695,
-0.05972329527139664,
0.1437799036502838,
0.246784046292305,
-0.08314645290374756,
0.12838983535766602,
-0.5617592334747314,
0.04530484229326248,
0.5354944467544556,
-0.7198349833488464,
0.8593222498893738,
0.5389547944068909,
-0.3636026680469513,
-0.2210504114627838,
-0.6197404265403748,
0.11514521390199661,
-0.09392371773719788,
0.04946938157081604,
-0.6647363901138306,
0.13551722466945648,
-0.4416011869907379,
0.26541373133659363,
0.17527270317077637,
-0.13343214988708496,
0.5182293653488159,
-0.0003815065138041973,
0.40649595856666565,
0.764457643032074,
0.2746824324131012,
0.892913281917572,
-0.07013058662414551,
0.5800262093544006,
0.3888663947582245,
0.4209132492542267,
-0.09383046627044678,
-0.8929533958435059,
-1.0092496871948242,
-0.1802702099084854,
0.3061094284057617,
0.32480400800704956,
-0.8449552059173584,
0.3545081615447998,
0.33093929290771484,
-0.2674383521080017,
-0.29180097579956055,
-0.04999347776174545,
0.2767575681209564,
0.5806887745857239,
0.5799544453620911,
-0.17089158296585083,
-0.14016938209533691,
-0.44755324721336365,
-0.11990253627300262,
-0.17403827607631683,
0.47350725531578064,
-0.03652491420507431,
0.36677390336990356,
-0.2903287708759308,
1.0604857206344604,
-0.7565839290618896,
0.08517379313707352,
-0.15414251387119293,
0.38547879457473755,
-0.09133493155241013,
0.5831860899925232,
0.249447301030159,
-0.7465662360191345,
-0.6089472770690918,
-0.19469860196113586,
-0.4440096616744995,
-0.03374220430850983,
-0.16454939544200897,
-0.6401535868644714,
0.10218740999698639,
0.4606301188468933,
-0.3816760182380676,
0.8220424652099609,
0.40058544278144836,
-0.833685040473938,
0.5105183720588684,
-0.5489078760147095,
0.19821499288082123,
-0.9377222061157227,
-0.21128369867801666,
-0.13187822699546814,
-0.4208076000213623,
-0.5616241097450256,
-0.1863810420036316,
0.07839953899383545,
0.28741714358329773,
-0.25274398922920227,
0.6729108691215515,
-0.5686665177345276,
0.033330775797367096,
-0.6080085635185242,
0.48395782709121704,
0.08247457444667816,
0.16545070707798004,
0.07707864791154861,
0.8861298561096191,
0.862625777721405,
-1.1471562385559082,
0.2513757050037384,
-0.010936780832707882,
-0.19460007548332214,
0.8781037330627441,
-0.20492537319660187,
0.25841566920280457,
-0.08991546183824539,
0.45539289712905884,
-0.9769312739372253,
0.5193411111831665,
0.20175528526306152,
-0.21886993944644928,
-0.15887457132339478,
-0.06744134426116943,
-0.5469997525215149,
-0.4595666229724884,
0.08834153413772583,
0.9131198525428772,
0.5571309328079224,
-0.4600833058357239,
0.5464009046554565,
0.4652041792869568,
-0.00962746236473322,
-0.4897043704986572,
-0.6353635191917419,
-0.059772294014692307,
-0.275812029838562,
-0.32638511061668396,
0.13396240770816803,
-0.27420881390571594,
-0.4569430649280548,
0.26040929555892944,
0.1092752143740654,
-0.5190026164054871,
-0.01794811338186264,
-0.31276193261146545,
0.0672798603773117,
0.034575458616018295,
0.5534029006958008,
0.30932891368865967,
-0.17437517642974854,
0.03011343441903591,
-0.7501099705696106,
0.4697181284427643,
-0.02963915467262268,
-0.3750397264957428,
-0.04265410453081131,
0.2696608603000641,
0.5337899327278137,
-0.13946610689163208,
0.6605533361434937,
0.18631193041801453,
-0.22067931294441223,
-0.6996055841445923,
-0.5389021039009094,
0.14581793546676636,
-0.4137621223926544,
-0.27934354543685913,
-0.5263975858688354,
-0.5908129215240479,
0.5717211365699768,
-0.35727471113204956,
-0.3630162477493286,
0.484157532453537,
0.70155268907547,
-0.3858460485935211,
1.0656261444091797,
0.551327109336853,
0.2256888747215271,
0.570773184299469,
-0.5124130845069885,
0.3874114155769348,
-1.029056191444397,
0.059370145201683044,
-0.07215050607919693,
-0.16505013406276703,
-0.19381171464920044,
-1.0328186750411987,
0.17510409653186798,
0.2441457360982895,
-0.11922254413366318,
0.19630026817321777,
-0.5931105017662048,
0.6573525667190552,
0.2646722197532654,
0.09801457822322845,
0.47298115491867065,
-0.2239094376564026,
-0.35659271478652954,
0.41500964760780334,
-0.781058132648468,
-0.40524375438690186,
0.7627027034759521,
0.2681242823600769,
0.8304041624069214,
0.047920793294906616,
0.6307279467582703,
0.7913786172866821,
0.19344310462474823,
-0.42281749844551086,
0.689085841178894,
-0.16154399514198303,
-0.6146727204322815,
-0.4488197863101959,
-0.40230393409729004,
-0.9441216588020325,
0.41212785243988037,
0.009270548820495605,
-0.5512733459472656,
0.5332151651382446,
0.24104590713977814,
-0.2126757949590683,
0.6105977892875671,
-0.6917051672935486,
0.5066826343536377,
0.005256631411612034,
-0.21011556684970856,
-0.8739627599716187,
-0.11118880659341812,
0.34922680258750916,
-0.17321722209453583,
0.38522645831108093,
0.0034725547302514315,
0.020055675879120827,
0.49751102924346924,
-0.7309809923171997,
0.5939009785652161,
0.13137051463127136,
-0.4572906196117401,
0.8470778465270996,
0.40106087923049927,
0.45524075627326965,
-0.15338215231895447,
-0.09430453181266785,
-0.011651595123112202,
-0.1887771338224411,
-0.4301551580429077,
-0.7931110858917236,
0.6572263836860657,
-0.290584921836853,
-0.6374115943908691,
-0.5097460150718689,
-0.35091593861579895,
-0.07887442409992218,
0.25477802753448486,
0.054061003029346466,
0.3412272036075592,
-0.10484807193279266,
-0.28290313482284546,
0.8798565864562988,
0.22615665197372437,
0.7667891979217529,
0.4319349229335785,
-0.6924468874931335,
-0.5220285058021545,
0.6841055750846863,
0.24469539523124695,
0.7440542578697205,
0.1364363729953766,
0.32979458570480347,
-0.3383108377456665,
-0.1611049324274063,
-0.45811760425567627,
0.28501081466674805,
-0.9648361206054688,
-0.02410428784787655,
-0.721800684928894,
-0.1704939603805542,
-0.0642801970243454,
-0.27677199244499207,
-0.4579750895500183,
-0.9743086099624634,
-0.13920451700687408,
-0.09915055334568024,
0.454751193523407,
1.0318433046340942,
-0.17351524531841278,
0.11626721173524857,
-0.40720126032829285,
0.2829340994358063,
0.48901399970054626,
0.6363343596458435,
0.5185848474502563,
-0.42425718903541565,
-0.4491181969642639,
0.05089302361011505,
-0.22734679281711578,
-0.8108615875244141,
0.17897628247737885,
-0.27927374839782715,
0.41590285301208496,
0.2765958905220032,
-0.12585648894309998,
0.7377372980117798,
-0.648810863494873,
0.7668966054916382,
0.3153951168060303,
-1.1695431470870972,
0.6197004318237305,
-0.07842967659235,
0.3580288887023926,
0.19081127643585205,
0.1454228162765503,
-0.4250871539115906,
-0.7114696502685547,
-0.8802576065063477,
-0.3887363076210022,
0.21178221702575684,
0.42473408579826355,
-0.3085952401161194,
-0.5406050682067871,
0.25651901960372925,
0.09163203090429306,
-0.026368537917733192,
-0.38187283277511597,
-0.4036857783794403,
-0.02575618401169777,
0.004924996290355921,
0.29288190603256226,
-0.2911267876625061,
0.1357903629541397,
-0.36153721809387207,
0.6050316691398621,
0.11406467109918594,
0.285320907831192,
0.31610748171806335,
-0.17030583322048187,
0.017773661762475967,
0.2540534436702728,
0.5806352496147156,
0.8608006238937378,
0.21640411019325256,
0.5276279449462891,
0.36707597970962524,
-0.4710776209831238,
0.4045800268650055,
-0.4083406925201416,
-0.1429823935031891,
-0.07167477905750275,
0.08348903805017471,
0.4009582996368408,
-0.082222118973732,
-0.08134403079748154,
0.3976445198059082,
-0.18320371210575104,
-0.21098773181438446,
-0.16451367735862732,
0.1369757205247879,
0.14922058582305908,
0.33859121799468994,
0.27433863282203674,
0.26342713832855225,
0.44181719422340393,
-0.5162054896354675,
0.18646062910556793,
0.22143612802028656,
-0.21018126606941223,
-0.23561182618141174,
0.6210614442825317,
0.34003928303718567,
-0.3594162166118622,
0.3413536250591278,
-0.32332736253738403,
-0.5271698832511902,
0.5487596392631531,
0.5719253420829773,
1.1955879926681519,
-0.27303028106689453,
0.3632693290710449,
0.12774327397346497,
-0.020260009914636612,
-0.42037636041641235,
0.3317488431930542,
-0.43685752153396606,
-0.7090587615966797,
-0.6263354420661926,
-0.21752935647964478,
-0.3533455729484558,
-0.4398333430290222,
-0.4122422933578491,
0.12567785382270813,
-0.48973384499549866,
-0.7193374633789062,
-0.14497381448745728,
-0.45885005593299866,
-0.468113511800766,
0.3690955638885498,
0.348356693983078,
0.9381090402603149,
-0.5984925627708435,
1.2648320198059082,
0.3883090019226074,
-0.43681207299232483,
-0.34060126543045044,
0.24105940759181976,
-0.4543547034263611,
-0.5732624530792236,
0.8624650835990906,
-0.2756490409374237,
-0.7247979044914246,
0.0203353650867939,
-0.2079784870147705,
-1.097604751586914,
0.783696174621582,
-0.17070627212524414,
-0.45327287912368774,
0.1127714291214943,
-0.24159714579582214,
0.7634282112121582,
-0.546786367893219,
0.2601884603500366,
0.5928742289543152,
0.24430161714553833,
0.16458411514759064,
-0.8492195010185242,
-0.11315292119979858,
0.1163494735956192,
0.08678751438856125,
0.4737449884414673,
-0.7220749258995056,
1.106203556060791,
-0.24265168607234955,
-0.3639746308326721,
-0.260062575340271,
0.6361712217330933,
0.08389880508184433,
0.3215210437774658,
0.7326922416687012,
0.8409502506256104,
0.9988351464271545,
0.20499823987483978,
0.9566763043403625,
-0.31761446595191956,
0.4492946267127991,
1.0887932777404785,
-0.15784914791584015,
0.969417154788971,
0.2973287105560303,
-0.43742021918296814,
1.3633960485458374,
0.2804403305053711,
0.5093203186988831,
0.5946530103683472,
0.05009886622428894,
-0.48656028509140015,
-0.42612531781196594,
0.42197999358177185,
-0.3169575035572052,
0.06039758771657944,
0.49895161390304565,
-0.27824488282203674,
-0.10116977244615555,
0.05422859266400337,
-0.017197398468852043,
0.26224616169929504,
-0.364126592874527,
0.7763532400131226,
0.1309620589017868,
-0.7403740286827087,
0.5293051600456238,
-0.3846709430217743,
0.3333902955055237,
-0.1104075089097023,
-0.32908180356025696,
-0.24092143774032593,
0.40823227167129517,
0.04658699035644531,
-1.2633945941925049,
0.388995885848999,
0.03672824054956436,
-0.43822363018989563,
-0.6840716600418091,
0.5725592970848083,
-0.6272755861282349,
-0.6668710708618164,
0.370138943195343,
0.7211099863052368,
0.21166327595710754,
0.10233177244663239,
-0.8711283206939697,
-0.09095559269189835,
-0.21919283270835876,
-0.09631440788507462,
0.07750483602285385,
1.0245511531829834,
-0.13870756328105927,
0.9512184858322144,
0.4536105990409851,
0.25601479411125183,
0.16458608210086823,
0.268546998500824,
0.8554339408874512,
-0.7612308263778687,
-0.8761667609214783,
-1.1408747434616089,
0.3894546329975128,
-0.1793968826532364,
-0.14846889674663544,
0.7484968304634094,
0.46298402547836304,
0.4581737220287323,
0.16027911007404327,
0.7220355272293091,
0.08035525679588318,
0.6901832818984985,
-0.5362061858177185,
0.5374590158462524,
-0.2164781540632248,
0.34426793456077576,
-0.28093186020851135,
-0.7655391097068787,
-0.09635723382234573,
0.9021047949790955,
-0.5631670951843262,
0.021108292043209076,
1.2411143779754639,
0.08613196760416031,
-0.043233711272478104,
-0.08256670832633972,
0.25395917892456055,
0.10639265179634094,
0.3859924077987671,
0.5049875974655151,
0.9257014989852905,
-0.30824339389801025,
0.3171929121017456,
-0.08999599516391754,
-0.385262131690979,
0.01209032442420721,
-0.8589202761650085,
-0.8837044835090637,
-0.6809992790222168,
-0.4836590588092804,
-0.407416969537735,
-0.008603074587881565,
0.48536908626556396,
0.6131888031959534,
-0.5339566469192505,
-0.24292585253715515,
-0.5846992135047913,
0.6698285937309265,
-0.4405853748321533,
-0.20226530730724335,
0.32769060134887695,
-0.6402570009231567,
-0.6036339402198792,
0.22141048312187195,
0.5313244462013245,
0.2039760947227478,
-0.6787682771682739,
0.06719125062227249,
-0.5756320953369141,
0.6074730157852173,
0.8109622001647949,
-0.0325818806886673,
-0.6980150938034058,
-0.09745322167873383,
-0.14214026927947998,
-0.1471155881881714,
0.09025019407272339,
0.9843393564224243,
-1.0590426921844482,
0.9601535797119141,
0.5842401385307312,
0.19067876040935516,
0.6180242300033569,
0.17200054228305817,
0.8190715312957764,
-0.21972408890724182,
0.17368601262569427,
0.15578560531139374,
0.44111645221710205,
0.08280225098133087,
-0.3835042119026184,
0.5532912611961365,
0.24964359402656555,
-0.7128347158432007,
-0.5612954497337341,
0.42247632145881653,
-0.5477880835533142,
-0.6754606366157532,
1.1831125020980835,
0.009446077048778534,
-0.29271599650382996,
-0.3234293758869171,
-0.2799607515335083,
-0.016388505697250366,
-0.33563873171806335,
0.8866207599639893,
1.0702052116394043,
-0.4456680119037628,
-0.1443393975496292,
-0.03504430130124092,
0.6500865817070007,
0.4769945442676544,
-0.8242271542549133,
0.3729207515716553,
0.3898552358150482,
0.0836929976940155,
0.22977490723133087,
1.092114806175232,
-0.08473314344882965,
0.2337549477815628,
0.17205575108528137,
-0.16622231900691986,
0.34992715716362,
-0.42381390929222107,
-0.28332099318504333,
-0.07315254956483841,
-0.06185416504740715,
-0.1366865485906601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07744v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07744v2 | Towards Unified Alignment Between Agents, Humans, and Environment | 2024-02-12T16:14:22 | 2024-02-14T18:43:54 | Zonghan Yang, An Liu, Zijun Liu, Kaiming Liu, Fangzhou Xiong, Yile Wang, Zeyuan Yang, Qingyuan Hu, Xinrui Chen, Zhenhe Zhang, Fuwen Luo, Zhicheng Guo, Peng Li, Yang Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid progress of foundation models has led to the prosperity of
autonomous agents, which leverage the universal capabilities of foundation
models to conduct reasoning, decision-making, and environmental interaction.
However, the efficacy of agents remains limited when operating in intricate,
realistic environments. In this work, we introduce the principles of
$\mathbf{U}$nified $\mathbf{A}$lignment for $\mathbf{A}$gents
($\mathbf{UA}^2$), which advocate for the simultaneous alignment of agents with
human intentions, environmental dynamics, and self-constraints such as the
limitation of monetary budgets. From the perspective of $\mathbf{UA}^2$, we
review the current agent research and highlight the neglected factors in
existing agent benchmarks and method candidates. We also conduct
proof-of-concept studies by introducing realistic features to WebShop,
including user profiles to demonstrate intentions, personalized reranking for
complex environmental dynamics, and runtime cost statistics to reflect
self-constraints. We then follow the principles of $\mathbf{UA}^2$ to propose
an initial design of our agent, and benchmark its performance with several
candidate baselines in the retrofitted WebShop. The extensive experimental
results further prove the importance of the principles of $\mathbf{UA}^2$. Our
research sheds light on the next steps of autonomous agent research with
improved general problem-solving abilities. | [
-0.4281139075756073,
-0.3308676481246948,
0.6272727847099304,
-0.05396655201911926,
0.08725425601005554,
0.2459842562675476,
0.032962605357170105,
-0.6325294375419617,
0.013937106356024742,
0.4223356544971466,
-0.5407253503799438,
-0.14579442143440247,
0.12546080350875854,
-0.003266755025833845,
-0.15646249055862427,
0.5735122561454773,
0.015040879137814045,
-0.22721192240715027,
-0.20299948751926422,
-0.3259703516960144,
-0.4934839606285095,
-0.21365246176719666,
-0.40399155020713806,
-0.48316746950149536,
0.21539156138896942,
0.3398418426513672,
1.1599985361099243,
1.0457611083984375,
0.5255360007286072,
0.3657897412776947,
0.3496723175048828,
-0.09594592452049255,
-0.07944783568382263,
0.20160479843616486,
-0.5454549789428711,
-0.14785917103290558,
-0.33106473088264465,
0.2632163465023041,
0.3270844519138336,
0.3788987994194031,
-0.25799641013145447,
-0.06153853237628937,
0.055245865136384964,
0.5586484670639038,
-0.8551757335662842,
0.004387503489851952,
-0.09688188135623932,
-0.152367502450943,
0.2350873351097107,
-0.11667569726705551,
-0.19235751032829285,
0.05865805596113205,
0.013308853842318058,
-1.0675500631332397,
0.23722290992736816,
0.1540110558271408,
1.1100001335144043,
0.611894965171814,
-0.6997886300086975,
-0.139150932431221,
-1.001265048980713,
0.7725359201431274,
-0.43491196632385254,
0.21708457171916962,
0.04984619840979576,
0.4132285714149475,
-0.4548911154270172,
-0.5979169607162476,
-0.4100581705570221,
0.14876016974449158,
-0.33166804909706116,
0.07257439941167831,
-0.5377709865570068,
0.310738742351532,
-0.17946919798851013,
-0.06035412475466728,
-0.43216294050216675,
0.1060817614197731,
-0.03541397303342819,
-0.21802113950252533,
0.8816207647323608,
0.1529209017753601,
0.4154343903064728,
0.055040303617715836,
-0.8495938777923584,
-0.3864813446998596,
-0.4712909460067749,
0.3478379547595978,
0.33742839097976685,
0.3950656056404114,
0.10952463746070862,
0.300239235162735,
-0.3838060200214386,
0.3227609395980835,
0.18107250332832336,
-0.07531966269016266,
-0.10902577638626099,
-0.3527427911758423,
-0.05340408533811569,
-0.4539443552494049,
0.5758501887321472,
0.3948092460632324,
0.23612451553344727,
-0.478423535823822,
-0.40910646319389343,
0.17202310264110565,
0.8043555617332458,
-0.4526505172252655,
-0.1928902417421341,
0.2427465170621872,
-0.22543887794017792,
-0.1789827197790146,
0.43164023756980896,
-0.8971782922744751,
-0.2976137697696686,
-0.6884257793426514,
0.6541818976402283,
0.2075241357088089,
-0.40499401092529297,
-0.008625488728284836,
-0.03895057365298271,
0.33064883947372437,
0.40893930196762085,
-0.6105163097381592,
0.5930134057998657,
0.6767601370811462,
0.388704389333725,
0.07273977994918823,
-0.5151558518409729,
-0.017108870670199394,
0.4435814917087555,
-0.2236001193523407,
1.0290803909301758,
-0.31647324562072754,
-0.3454318344593048,
-0.09393728524446487,
-0.08992128074169159,
0.058903757482767105,
-0.06381313502788544,
0.30998292565345764,
-0.265284925699234,
-0.08309920877218246,
-0.49087759852409363,
-0.298141211271286,
-0.37753865122795105,
0.01546802744269371,
-0.31298327445983887,
0.4984678328037262,
0.0496382862329483,
-0.2852668762207031,
0.313693642616272,
-0.8663937449455261,
-0.33148738741874695,
0.04127860441803932,
-0.19259394705295563,
-0.22865965962409973,
0.06697221100330353,
-0.05479705333709717,
-0.030957447364926338,
-0.26852697134017944,
0.20986387133598328,
-0.33674708008766174,
-0.33887457847595215,
0.034663643687963486,
-0.30407312512397766,
0.8717062473297119,
0.39764726161956787,
-0.6935352683067322,
0.19412843883037567,
-0.3844928741455078,
-0.001307866768911481,
-0.002915080636739731,
0.031937986612319946,
-0.1484350860118866,
0.09510818868875504,
0.21876192092895508,
0.028224725276231766,
0.3825322389602661,
-0.3848516047000885,
0.5521466732025146,
0.09429315477609634,
0.20616161823272705,
1.038162350654602,
-0.09170524775981903,
0.8783150911331177,
-0.351685494184494,
0.6896098256111145,
-0.7158124446868896,
0.40651965141296387,
0.05269605293869972,
-0.19631090760231018,
-0.5698275566101074,
-0.3392830789089203,
-0.053110331296920776,
0.5351641178131104,
0.060592468827962875,
0.5033158659934998,
0.07864140719175339,
-0.2704392075538635,
-0.1355011761188507,
0.08621851354837418,
0.6107925772666931,
0.1962447613477707,
0.38757196068763733,
-0.4052846133708954,
-0.4607265591621399,
-0.811691403388977,
-0.13483187556266785,
-0.3197794258594513,
-0.006204434670507908,
0.33823031187057495,
0.49047374725341797,
-0.6139681339263916,
1.4472304582595825,
-0.3474898040294647,
-0.36737072467803955,
0.329253226518631,
0.06308507174253464,
-0.2571265995502472,
0.7291221618652344,
0.783552348613739,
-0.8902692198753357,
-0.06695899367332458,
0.044721830636262894,
-0.9697912335395813,
-0.1718532294034958,
0.003815265605226159,
-0.4920293688774109,
0.12755829095840454,
0.3726876974105835,
-0.98066246509552,
0.8329978585243225,
0.011829759925603867,
-0.7966882586479187,
0.1942882537841797,
-0.4491114020347595,
0.03371512144804001,
-0.992967426776886,
-0.031767357140779495,
0.18301904201507568,
0.09567846357822418,
-0.5708694458007812,
0.5431367754936218,
-0.062026429921388626,
0.01485005859285593,
-0.1593242734670639,
0.8623597025871277,
-0.8164103627204895,
-0.36633044481277466,
-0.6179157495498657,
-0.15982550382614136,
0.3240925967693329,
0.3803739845752716,
-0.2220153510570526,
0.687025249004364,
0.26487284898757935,
-0.8068013191223145,
0.5784050226211548,
0.42910972237586975,
0.34432682394981384,
0.7904359102249146,
-0.6041491627693176,
0.21733058989048004,
-0.1276780217885971,
0.557818591594696,
-0.9901914596557617,
-0.20991091430187225,
0.1453780233860016,
-0.28445547819137573,
0.3032981753349304,
0.05540313199162483,
-0.49994462728500366,
-0.5665938258171082,
-0.042338546365499496,
0.3000342547893524,
0.44461336731910706,
-0.6290766596794128,
1.0906814336776733,
0.36472126841545105,
0.33356547355651855,
-0.6278513669967651,
-0.3778573274612427,
0.10653289407491684,
-0.39264026284217834,
-0.6720993518829346,
0.11963719129562378,
-0.19038406014442444,
-0.7446302771568298,
0.3190603256225586,
-0.28362226486206055,
0.1918572634458542,
0.5697401165962219,
0.22559164464473724,
-0.0402764268219471,
-0.13738176226615906,
-0.007409939542412758,
-0.12042920291423798,
-0.4490200877189636,
0.09456125646829605,
-0.36839058995246887,
0.1511843502521515,
-0.3856102526187897,
-0.39096835255622864,
-0.45231106877326965,
0.2896133065223694,
0.6124778985977173,
-0.3222331404685974,
0.27546966075897217,
0.33673062920570374,
-0.5340195894241333,
0.20407262444496155,
-0.5841239094734192,
-0.1614018827676773,
-0.5251650810241699,
-0.020778439939022064,
-0.3481943607330322,
-0.3524267077445984,
0.6937785148620605,
-0.04198060184717178,
0.2749790847301483,
0.623166561126709,
0.24572685360908508,
-0.20618991553783417,
0.9777393341064453,
0.8898769617080688,
-0.019482918083667755,
0.2902916669845581,
-0.35890552401542664,
0.012685381807386875,
-0.9713923335075378,
-0.2578991651535034,
-0.5382096171379089,
-0.5428300499916077,
-0.34621062874794006,
-0.029876239597797394,
0.12456241995096207,
0.4258250296115875,
-0.6632940769195557,
0.5938042402267456,
-0.6237401366233826,
0.6082289814949036,
0.6822207570075989,
-0.18500134348869324,
0.21298320591449738,
-0.17633363604545593,
-0.05897018685936928,
0.3380798399448395,
-0.35037508606910706,
-0.6299920082092285,
0.9840686321258545,
0.21074098348617554,
0.8870100975036621,
0.6923195123672485,
0.6400501132011414,
0.4659586250782013,
0.1985897421836853,
-0.4086998403072357,
0.4216667413711548,
0.2628491520881653,
-0.7631861567497253,
-0.47723817825317383,
0.024528881534934044,
-1.3740659952163696,
0.5379153490066528,
-0.12776154279708862,
-1.0429385900497437,
0.6289057731628418,
0.11008692532777786,
-0.5252464413642883,
0.13490429520606995,
-0.7163868546485901,
0.9220068454742432,
-0.586479127407074,
-0.579084575176239,
-0.2272014021873474,
-0.7628455758094788,
-0.1881084144115448,
0.23989039659500122,
0.37620121240615845,
-0.33618706464767456,
-0.3721989095211029,
0.056211043149232864,
-0.38612183928489685,
0.7040775418281555,
-0.3240508437156677,
-0.1374996304512024,
0.524520218372345,
0.06148621812462807,
0.645240843296051,
0.026486339047551155,
0.3428255021572113,
-0.19666582345962524,
-0.18483902513980865,
-0.7073975801467896,
-0.5232347249984741,
0.5357661843299866,
-0.9936599731445312,
-0.7164295315742493,
-0.5206314325332642,
-0.672196090221405,
-0.15383291244506836,
0.18232864141464233,
0.20178084075450897,
0.23457321524620056,
-0.4854130446910858,
0.20698630809783936,
0.4183356463909149,
0.35950976610183716,
0.6638654470443726,
0.8494385480880737,
-0.23121938109397888,
-0.2383432537317276,
0.5862312912940979,
-0.15225020051002502,
0.18566492199897766,
0.2529630661010742,
0.4759017527103424,
-0.606658935546875,
-0.22931541502475739,
-0.5440332889556885,
-0.1443801373243332,
-0.5819739699363708,
-0.48680412769317627,
-0.6084168553352356,
0.19031110405921936,
-0.6165840029716492,
-0.637647271156311,
-0.35447806119918823,
-0.12785983085632324,
-0.4540793299674988,
-0.0653756856918335,
0.3441503643989563,
0.9453287124633789,
-0.6054940819740295,
0.31604325771331787,
-0.33970850706100464,
0.4617600739002228,
0.6960868239402771,
0.0745319053530693,
-0.04954840987920761,
-0.18628275394439697,
-0.19771170616149902,
0.4720781147480011,
-0.40408968925476074,
-0.665635883808136,
0.14496444165706635,
-0.048174768686294556,
1.1017011404037476,
0.798163890838623,
0.33644619584083557,
0.5052443146705627,
-0.01642462983727455,
0.19099892675876617,
-0.1473337709903717,
-0.7533552646636963,
0.47992953658103943,
-0.7597494125366211,
0.03278600051999092,
0.7385155558586121,
-0.022405926138162613,
-0.15847988426685333,
-0.2508309781551361,
-0.8310994505882263,
-0.7866889238357544,
0.5025267004966736,
0.5653169751167297,
0.01831636019051075,
0.3189515173435211,
0.3879005014896393,
-0.1314631700515747,
0.2516911029815674,
-0.5093607306480408,
-0.3577761650085449,
-0.2926831543445587,
-0.002265924122184515,
-0.27872997522354126,
0.13947351276874542,
-0.31452807784080505,
-0.31821897625923157,
0.756147027015686,
-0.30198925733566284,
0.12531258165836334,
0.05396198108792305,
0.026108257472515106,
-0.5217927694320679,
0.30822816491127014,
0.580427348613739,
0.6644644141197205,
-0.2875167429447174,
0.021679842844605446,
-0.2887856960296631,
-0.15518057346343994,
0.7599243521690369,
0.3759247064590454,
-0.46950435638427734,
-0.5501607060432434,
-0.012025709263980389,
0.3904019296169281,
0.16636954247951508,
-0.393388569355011,
0.3030303120613098,
-0.0035510200541466475,
-0.04574195295572281,
-0.3441651463508606,
0.19033567607402802,
-0.1967834085226059,
0.7001316547393799,
0.6000485420227051,
0.37157702445983887,
0.3582993447780609,
-0.7999348044395447,
0.329012930393219,
0.7220419049263,
-0.1663561463356018,
-0.33015313744544983,
0.9264135360717773,
0.49926820397377014,
-0.5555574893951416,
0.5494722723960876,
-0.55555659532547,
-0.4869663119316101,
1.03183114528656,
0.5668221116065979,
1.056257963180542,
-0.3715199828147888,
0.2160627394914627,
0.2185916304588318,
0.51374751329422,
-0.466889351606369,
-0.05347920209169388,
-0.08307614922523499,
-0.9501748085021973,
0.033520977944135666,
-0.5491721630096436,
-0.47852224111557007,
-0.4174293279647827,
-0.7138671875,
-0.0913388580083847,
-0.5455662608146667,
0.012700066901743412,
-0.28776565194129944,
0.3856414258480072,
-0.6023209691047668,
0.2814794182777405,
-0.13777022063732147,
0.3495037257671356,
-0.8840304017066956,
0.45901617407798767,
0.9754845499992371,
-0.5410441160202026,
-0.8894314765930176,
0.1448533684015274,
0.48713448643684387,
-0.7245635390281677,
-0.06622941046953201,
0.2636429965496063,
-0.2611537277698517,
0.1002698466181755,
-0.5598980188369751,
-1.3027468919754028,
1.4607884883880615,
0.3674210011959076,
-0.32107195258140564,
0.00895312987267971,
-0.3033885061740875,
0.6899401545524597,
-0.5546356439590454,
-0.08552497625350952,
0.6015345454216003,
0.8761572241783142,
0.05131284147500992,
-0.7544693946838379,
-0.02796879969537258,
-0.547137439250946,
-0.16095764935016632,
0.3742802143096924,
-1.017048954963684,
0.8978793025016785,
-0.4552465081214905,
-0.37333792448043823,
0.5695304274559021,
0.6559113264083862,
0.14941845834255219,
0.5137619376182556,
0.5447144508361816,
0.7707667350769043,
0.6028233766555786,
-0.07500533014535904,
0.9644193053245544,
-0.23106303811073303,
0.6284664273262024,
0.8914694786071777,
-0.19815249741077423,
0.41990944743156433,
0.18619826436042786,
-0.36614951491355896,
0.7301180362701416,
0.43108174204826355,
-0.052264608442783356,
0.4854886829853058,
0.051323819905519485,
-0.18767690658569336,
-0.24407100677490234,
-0.40988969802856445,
-0.40884339809417725,
0.5966295003890991,
0.01870930753648281,
0.4046476185321808,
-0.12572740018367767,
-0.1917060911655426,
-0.11722911894321442,
0.4026006758213043,
-0.22198110818862915,
0.7995766401290894,
-0.2389199435710907,
-0.4734247326850891,
-0.11772780120372772,
-0.0868784636259079,
0.49025100469589233,
-0.376772403717041,
0.0395965650677681,
-0.2535878121852875,
0.32406073808670044,
-0.11546415835618973,
-0.5119649767875671,
0.04163423180580139,
-0.3419857919216156,
-0.06488587707281113,
-0.38549545407295227,
0.6249072551727295,
0.061161626130342484,
-0.3676568567752838,
0.30191048979759216,
0.4405752420425415,
-0.1069502905011177,
-0.06546112149953842,
-0.5886444449424744,
-0.35689443349838257,
-0.279751181602478,
-0.2895893454551697,
0.30014750361442566,
0.43192586302757263,
0.002660369733348489,
0.6419011950492859,
0.5830599069595337,
-0.5164192914962769,
-0.4092562198638916,
-0.24066510796546936,
0.5511789917945862,
-0.732496976852417,
-0.7265757322311401,
-0.5132236480712891,
0.4868391156196594,
0.2045506238937378,
-0.34297338128089905,
0.605785071849823,
0.47348952293395996,
0.6415528059005737,
0.292387992143631,
0.48825764656066895,
0.008904874324798584,
0.20002934336662292,
-0.12668399512767792,
0.5040680170059204,
-0.6695603728294373,
0.08014271408319473,
-0.4559156596660614,
-1.111628770828247,
0.007301543839275837,
0.9406169056892395,
0.3345344066619873,
0.3140905797481537,
0.4397878050804138,
0.4237459897994995,
0.1436394304037094,
-0.16280686855316162,
0.08395032584667206,
-0.11925563961267471,
0.401429146528244,
0.31052833795547485,
0.8337701559066772,
-0.3352820575237274,
0.42521896958351135,
-0.5092157125473022,
-0.10502619296312332,
-0.126644104719162,
-0.7229708433151245,
-0.541216254234314,
-0.43405425548553467,
-0.19942688941955566,
-0.31829094886779785,
-0.052010245621204376,
0.9326826333999634,
0.7449833154678345,
-0.5082470774650574,
-0.4328182339668274,
-0.5440659523010254,
0.09578783065080643,
-0.4500463902950287,
-0.22783468663692474,
0.21556824445724487,
-0.034431781619787216,
-0.4169274866580963,
0.37087664008140564,
0.38483235239982605,
0.5442062020301819,
-0.5951716303825378,
-0.4870798587799072,
-0.26468896865844727,
0.31877800822257996,
-0.03202751278877258,
0.857244610786438,
-0.9349293112754822,
-0.5558779835700989,
-0.008565452881157398,
-0.2388811707496643,
0.06522930413484573,
0.7951356172561646,
-0.8370164632797241,
0.38514742255210876,
-0.009998120367527008,
0.4039163887500763,
0.0513775497674942,
0.4817192852497101,
0.682887077331543,
-0.470634788274765,
0.29386961460113525,
0.19092491269111633,
0.4188138246536255,
0.1501682698726654,
-0.586074948310852,
0.9188762903213501,
0.17589902877807617,
-0.6832730174064636,
-0.47524067759513855,
0.43637436628341675,
-0.9244800806045532,
-0.35332146286964417,
1.0414916276931763,
-0.02622090093791485,
-0.060418855398893356,
-0.1478811353445053,
-0.2163936197757721,
0.12753069400787354,
-0.6272661685943604,
0.829632043838501,
0.4475330710411072,
-0.3896277844905853,
0.026673423126339912,
0.06231190264225006,
0.06814990937709808,
0.18466992676258087,
-0.9906919598579407,
-0.03787759318947792,
0.7934032082557678,
0.03282354772090912,
0.5027475357055664,
0.7134416103363037,
0.4322659373283386,
0.5001572966575623,
0.0989154502749443,
0.4308052957057953,
-0.021710634231567383,
-0.6059277057647705,
-0.31722280383110046,
-0.0010661218548193574,
0.07120050489902496,
-0.21049603819847107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07742v1 | Asking Multimodal Clarifying Questions in Mixed-Initiative Conversational Search | 2024-02-12T16:04:01 | 2024-02-12T16:04:01 | Yifei Yuan, Clemencia Siro, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | In mixed-initiative conversational search systems, clarifying questions are
used to help users who struggle to express their intentions in a single query.
These questions aim to uncover user's information needs and resolve query
ambiguities. We hypothesize that in scenarios where multimodal information is
pertinent, the clarification process can be improved by using non-textual
information. Therefore, we propose to add images to clarifying questions and
formulate the novel task of asking multimodal clarifying questions in
open-domain, mixed-initiative conversational search systems. To facilitate
research into this task, we collect a dataset named Melon that contains over 4k
multimodal clarifying questions, enriched with over 14k images. We also propose
a multimodal query clarification model named Marto and adopt a prompt-based,
generative fine-tuning strategy to perform the training of different stages
with different prompts. Several analyses are conducted to understand the
importance of multimodal contents during the query clarification phase.
Experimental results indicate that the addition of images leads to significant
improvements of up to 90% in retrieval performance when selecting the relevant
images. Extensive analyses are also performed to show the superiority of Marto
compared with discriminative baselines in terms of effectiveness and
efficiency. | [
-0.7791450023651123,
-1.1355293989181519,
0.5730316042900085,
0.18916314840316772,
-0.45459356904029846,
-0.23731115460395813,
-0.4198462963104248,
-0.4340340793132782,
0.13935919106006622,
0.4474140703678131,
-0.9975392818450928,
-0.3480766713619232,
-0.4219149053096771,
0.25068220496177673,
0.06245274841785431,
0.7948214411735535,
-0.05553088337182999,
0.12827058136463165,
-0.580741286277771,
-0.5083343982696533,
-1.042052984237671,
0.1327589601278305,
-0.7724155187606812,
-0.03731365501880646,
0.7524755001068115,
0.6543480157852173,
0.7774960398674011,
0.20015697181224823,
0.4958658814430237,
0.3877653181552887,
-0.1031445786356926,
0.6765052676200867,
-0.4657048285007477,
0.5870923399925232,
-0.20884960889816284,
-0.6776915192604065,
0.11285358667373657,
-0.24346843361854553,
0.509401798248291,
0.5245587229728699,
0.04625251889228821,
-0.12237434089183807,
-0.3674076795578003,
0.49092623591423035,
-0.8724409341812134,
0.018467098474502563,
-0.7042139768600464,
0.20296838879585266,
0.24637676775455475,
-0.7637903690338135,
-0.36931926012039185,
-0.18777281045913696,
0.036659080535173416,
-0.8367342352867126,
0.34897980093955994,
0.06321021914482117,
0.9675750136375427,
0.1898534595966339,
-0.8874247670173645,
-0.42560040950775146,
-0.7285788655281067,
0.7411065101623535,
-0.24172911047935486,
0.3900184631347656,
0.27006879448890686,
0.4961402714252472,
0.046781860291957855,
-0.5843902826309204,
-0.5827369093894958,
-0.08003628998994827,
-0.44761595129966736,
0.2078515738248825,
-0.002593540819361806,
0.19061404466629028,
0.3270187973976135,
0.23410740494728088,
-0.5686131119728088,
-0.31073522567749023,
-0.4526716470718384,
-0.20654834806919098,
0.3418624699115753,
0.04687630757689476,
0.330295205116272,
-0.03882939741015434,
-0.6302812099456787,
-0.3343719244003296,
-0.43813958764076233,
0.2642207443714142,
-0.03661968931555748,
0.0664353296160698,
0.10885770618915558,
0.7689346671104431,
-0.33528804779052734,
0.39354556798934937,
0.12412533164024353,
-0.093501515686512,
0.18590371310710907,
-0.8220803737640381,
0.10542267560958862,
-0.28828781843185425,
0.5759255290031433,
0.9741449356079102,
-0.006616652011871338,
0.22151532769203186,
-0.24877412617206573,
-0.12723520398139954,
0.2392885684967041,
-0.950737714767456,
0.11032561212778091,
0.24397118389606476,
-0.481234073638916,
0.28848281502723694,
-0.04858378320932388,
-0.7848719358444214,
-0.2874126434326172,
-0.45780956745147705,
0.6069369316101074,
-0.482388973236084,
-0.17433814704418182,
-0.09756741672754288,
-0.5141143798828125,
0.19081592559814453,
0.854259729385376,
-0.6558231711387634,
-0.32244887948036194,
0.16083268821239471,
0.502753734588623,
0.4773677587509155,
-0.05722719803452492,
-0.37634798884391785,
0.006889865733683109,
-0.24565811455249786,
0.7551853656768799,
-0.7127668857574463,
-0.5436605215072632,
-0.19396619498729706,
0.3388788402080536,
-0.4932614862918854,
-0.5466911196708679,
0.36118218302726746,
-0.6892295479774475,
0.3632872700691223,
-0.35735437273979187,
-0.20178347826004028,
-0.5319600701332092,
0.7408998012542725,
-0.5699425935745239,
0.9502977728843689,
-0.279951274394989,
-0.4543222486972809,
0.2992471754550934,
-0.7361065149307251,
-0.2355467677116394,
0.17799274623394012,
-0.4263386130332947,
-0.24771687388420105,
0.014909323304891586,
0.6042799949645996,
0.31234437227249146,
-0.11458367854356766,
0.27714866399765015,
-0.21298275887966156,
-0.11802934855222702,
0.5239527821540833,
-0.46193060278892517,
0.20392709970474243,
0.2660854756832123,
-0.20845967531204224,
0.3573472201824188,
-0.43009501695632935,
0.3057406544685364,
0.0009561410406604409,
-0.25178298354148865,
-0.31125518679618835,
-0.20977908372879028,
-0.3796609342098236,
0.2394738644361496,
0.43792369961738586,
-0.48314622044563293,
-0.023110821843147278,
0.15058717131614685,
0.29084476828575134,
0.5611333847045898,
0.28683459758758545,
0.36597347259521484,
-0.29525139927864075,
0.5810444355010986,
0.4228563904762268,
0.5909086465835571,
-0.9194662570953369,
-0.9190874695777893,
-0.7490313649177551,
-0.33220574259757996,
-0.028862889856100082,
0.5258643627166748,
-1.2376248836517334,
-0.1975545436143875,
0.042503997683525085,
-0.2141137719154358,
-0.7599416375160217,
-0.02236631140112877,
0.5360921025276184,
0.537592887878418,
0.3962209224700928,
-0.22110441327095032,
-0.4831182360649109,
-1.1568411588668823,
0.0697951391339302,
-0.03625417500734329,
0.18370100855827332,
1.0518523454666138,
0.6451245546340942,
-0.3639567792415619,
0.8200432658195496,
-0.5445226430892944,
0.12895655632019043,
0.052995018661022186,
0.40673330426216125,
-0.16130653023719788,
0.46235769987106323,
0.3243637681007385,
-1.4498541355133057,
-0.27940821647644043,
0.15678025782108307,
-0.7818215489387512,
0.36064815521240234,
-0.19273555278778076,
-0.12877750396728516,
-0.20329701900482178,
0.4872525632381439,
-1.009389042854309,
0.3090265393257141,
0.20585088431835175,
-0.08233342319726944,
0.46884360909461975,
-0.6037068963050842,
0.9417176842689514,
-0.7721577882766724,
0.002384832827374339,
-0.12407391518354416,
-0.021347686648368835,
-0.6848641037940979,
0.29345375299453735,
0.325872004032135,
-0.48153331875801086,
-0.42337724566459656,
0.5340906381607056,
-0.425817608833313,
0.27249854803085327,
-0.013461250811815262,
0.31762412190437317,
0.4511488378047943,
0.6091996431350708,
-0.1285117119550705,
0.9577616453170776,
0.5401660203933716,
-0.8182579874992371,
0.12126795947551727,
0.345627099275589,
0.015539794228971004,
0.8028483390808105,
-0.5889853239059448,
0.28548750281333923,
-0.6817898750305176,
0.26461830735206604,
-1.5119717121124268,
-0.2211793065071106,
0.050054892897605896,
-0.4170782268047333,
0.05429697036743164,
-0.3006671071052551,
-0.4834691286087036,
-0.32803046703338623,
-0.35922771692276,
0.9505255222320557,
-0.06587878614664078,
-0.6324946880340576,
0.5810130834579468,
0.03796810656785965,
-0.09680108726024628,
-0.6336932182312012,
-0.3106335699558258,
0.004113409668207169,
-0.15294457972049713,
-1.0801057815551758,
0.2876631021499634,
-0.436112642288208,
-0.04784419387578964,
-0.2648123502731323,
0.14927373826503754,
-0.22673384845256805,
-0.015024668537080288,
0.2387174516916275,
0.3531360924243927,
-0.33492881059646606,
0.3046218156814575,
-0.023626724258065224,
0.2206244170665741,
-0.3154607117176056,
0.24150770902633667,
0.35603001713752747,
-0.2906637489795685,
-0.4807324707508087,
-0.5044602751731873,
0.6408851146697998,
0.6078187227249146,
-0.4209423065185547,
0.6340011954307556,
0.9028328657150269,
-0.002722662640735507,
0.21518178284168243,
-0.6797999739646912,
-0.6377920508384705,
-0.489990234375,
-0.05974774435162544,
-0.5945490598678589,
-1.1355782747268677,
0.6806120276451111,
-0.10974082350730896,
-0.17167040705680847,
0.2560611069202423,
0.3911736011505127,
-0.4543975591659546,
1.461190104484558,
0.29958376288414,
0.6824592351913452,
0.4205174446105957,
-0.14571811258792877,
0.23389413952827454,
-0.7320432066917419,
-0.8359496593475342,
-0.5051084160804749,
-0.4922544062137604,
-0.6271135210990906,
-0.5785819888114929,
0.4880843460559845,
0.07976798713207245,
0.526721715927124,
0.23112741112709045,
-0.2216186225414276,
0.3552227318286896,
0.8278884887695312,
0.5178848505020142,
0.18083037436008453,
-0.21355746686458588,
-0.2739294767379761,
0.04328140243887901,
-0.46045389771461487,
-0.13662290573120117,
0.7830581068992615,
0.03719475120306015,
0.6805926561355591,
0.02063278667628765,
0.31806766986846924,
0.050176482647657394,
-0.2135038524866104,
-0.6530938148498535,
0.6875048279762268,
0.21620307862758636,
-0.9700084328651428,
-0.07347193360328674,
-0.5331325531005859,
-1.1405166387557983,
0.6150631904602051,
-0.37337344884872437,
-0.2123083472251892,
0.4742579460144043,
0.21327424049377441,
-0.26701539754867554,
-0.13744235038757324,
-1.129040241241455,
0.8514279127120972,
-0.27806392312049866,
-0.24402585625648499,
-0.45948365330696106,
-0.9309139251708984,
0.23426829278469086,
0.36514097452163696,
0.3605319857597351,
-0.11488047242164612,
0.007333674468100071,
0.33326131105422974,
-0.20299436151981354,
0.6157814264297485,
-0.35102710127830505,
0.09242583066225052,
0.3967306315898895,
-0.2908551096916199,
0.30423465371131897,
0.19529442489147186,
0.261852502822876,
-0.2624121904373169,
0.16646093130111694,
-0.26442307233810425,
-0.9630261659622192,
0.5859754085540771,
-0.431063711643219,
-0.506075918674469,
0.3307388126850128,
-0.8247557878494263,
-0.09053513407707214,
0.21339952945709229,
-0.07751250267028809,
0.5420597791671753,
0.07444987446069717,
0.476055771112442,
1.050411343574524,
-0.260833740234375,
0.18066316843032837,
0.4311690926551819,
0.031109102070331573,
-0.45071718096733093,
0.7327685356140137,
-0.44571152329444885,
0.18597805500030518,
0.559036910533905,
0.17144954204559326,
-0.5177204608917236,
-0.457688570022583,
-0.6464802026748657,
0.4275303781032562,
-0.8960860371589661,
0.007176355458796024,
-0.5164756774902344,
0.3650715947151184,
-0.36594247817993164,
0.16021645069122314,
-0.0523240827023983,
-0.3688870668411255,
-0.4761950373649597,
0.3682239055633545,
0.3066871166229248,
0.37680497765541077,
0.38748517632484436,
0.3443751037120819,
-0.8586372137069702,
0.5440145134925842,
0.4409236013889313,
0.11121127009391785,
-0.32635003328323364,
-0.2923949658870697,
-0.10748401284217834,
0.48177453875541687,
-0.45894473791122437,
-0.7330226898193359,
-0.01483263447880745,
0.31739217042922974,
0.6004379987716675,
0.6982013583183289,
-0.027124039828777313,
1.1944098472595215,
-0.3014872372150421,
0.6680029630661011,
0.37606680393218994,
-0.20897792279720306,
0.8547211289405823,
-0.3380674421787262,
0.33566272258758545,
0.9095370769500732,
0.37984058260917664,
-0.5118452310562134,
-0.09164436161518097,
-0.3937970697879791,
-0.8231422305107117,
0.6257129311561584,
0.23417893052101135,
0.13866864144802094,
-0.31233102083206177,
0.3050004541873932,
-0.06811652332544327,
0.5304674506187439,
-0.46880611777305603,
-0.20655183494091034,
-0.1874668449163437,
0.028325293213129044,
0.1626385748386383,
-0.20574524998664856,
-0.5953981876373291,
-0.06071208789944649,
0.4627957344055176,
-0.27968114614486694,
0.33911600708961487,
0.2114296704530716,
-0.3818841278553009,
0.15398091077804565,
0.6588567495346069,
0.904120683670044,
0.4770558476448059,
-0.17636997997760773,
0.1307772994041443,
-0.15709172189235687,
-0.1605297327041626,
-0.15335506200790405,
-0.01044484879821539,
-0.09337980300188065,
0.04254762828350067,
-0.04276613891124725,
1.1547439098358154,
0.2693749666213989,
-0.9179806113243103,
0.5820239186286926,
-0.3440344035625458,
-0.2311374694108963,
0.1236296221613884,
0.024744484573602676,
-0.16327454149723053,
0.40650635957717896,
0.1567816436290741,
0.23241034150123596,
0.19927383959293365,
-0.7738452553749084,
-0.06845100969076157,
0.8150671720504761,
-0.2235681414604187,
-0.00673747668042779,
0.23995979130268097,
0.2714739441871643,
-0.04193383827805519,
0.6461853384971619,
-0.04214489087462425,
-0.29382872581481934,
0.5755487084388733,
0.37219366431236267,
0.3262934684753418,
-0.06207117810845375,
0.2705840766429901,
0.3136518895626068,
0.3736981749534607,
0.14133471250534058,
0.428948312997818,
-0.5914309620857239,
-0.5656119585037231,
-0.158639594912529,
-0.11500199139118195,
-0.44991976022720337,
-0.09565681219100952,
-0.5868891477584839,
0.13762758672237396,
-0.3086877167224884,
-0.44580528140068054,
0.01316645834594965,
-0.36100876331329346,
-0.5946145057678223,
0.42910757660865784,
-0.06887543201446533,
0.6060978770256042,
-0.5170271992683411,
0.10660994797945023,
0.8439729809761047,
-0.6023620963096619,
-0.5740836262702942,
-0.4782896041870117,
-0.15877313911914825,
-0.8751975297927856,
0.473539263010025,
0.3885367512702942,
-0.12776754796504974,
-0.24969668686389923,
-0.48630666732788086,
-0.6108039617538452,
1.38706636428833,
0.1258821338415146,
-0.23678869009017944,
-0.2084359973669052,
-0.030249275267124176,
0.349997341632843,
-0.41523197293281555,
0.9481917023658752,
-0.07632336020469666,
0.6772481799125671,
0.6138952970504761,
-0.7723938226699829,
-0.09630213677883148,
-0.40894219279289246,
0.12492823600769043,
0.34802278876304626,
-0.26916390657424927,
0.8376705050468445,
-0.4338942766189575,
-0.43143004179000854,
0.25277045369148254,
0.34615954756736755,
0.16911718249320984,
0.8019636273384094,
0.6278058290481567,
0.6044459342956543,
0.7820708751678467,
-0.1236315444111824,
0.9105323553085327,
-0.08485601842403412,
0.1078355461359024,
0.9525620937347412,
0.04331376776099205,
0.7204740643501282,
0.7534582018852234,
0.2811985909938812,
0.5086602568626404,
0.5865022540092468,
0.09800824522972107,
0.48819276690483093,
-0.4082006812095642,
-0.46726396679878235,
-0.27838754653930664,
-0.38888874650001526,
-0.23818933963775635,
0.23592743277549744,
0.49822545051574707,
-0.42229390144348145,
-0.43986865878105164,
0.45007631182670593,
-0.2414437085390091,
0.005971914157271385,
-0.2578549385070801,
0.9426537752151489,
-0.34066760540008545,
-1.1034393310546875,
0.6216784119606018,
0.015645934268832207,
0.5212180018424988,
-0.7071643471717834,
-0.047358039766550064,
-0.28438669443130493,
0.14026325941085815,
-0.3378048539161682,
-0.7995792031288147,
-0.10848179459571838,
-0.5014173984527588,
-0.2721943259239197,
-0.2522921562194824,
0.5019937753677368,
-0.6972069144248962,
-0.11792323738336563,
0.10980759561061859,
0.3603845238685608,
0.20083975791931152,
-0.2711678147315979,
-0.9190831184387207,
-0.04048016667366028,
0.12708422541618347,
0.26408401131629944,
0.008997921831905842,
0.6546025276184082,
-0.24670180678367615,
0.8191649913787842,
0.7589142918586731,
-0.5559345483779907,
0.2750377357006073,
0.3378753364086151,
0.9332888126373291,
-0.33128562569618225,
-0.15951289236545563,
-0.5207821726799011,
0.7119267582893372,
-0.028028152883052826,
-0.26674506068229675,
0.7763405442237854,
0.40710949897766113,
0.6704115867614746,
-0.14854466915130615,
0.25940725207328796,
-0.02052414044737816,
0.10874546319246292,
-0.6027750968933105,
0.21385706961154938,
-0.9167664051055908,
0.09928645193576813,
0.11436966806650162,
-0.4486275315284729,
0.02118087001144886,
0.3483966886997223,
-0.10764625668525696,
0.2970621883869171,
0.8352546095848083,
1.3421603441238403,
-0.21683675050735474,
0.35419416427612305,
0.1881236881017685,
-0.1357288360595703,
0.2667870819568634,
0.23687680065631866,
1.0668631792068481,
-0.38762736320495605,
0.7528514862060547,
-0.316216379404068,
-0.06700699031352997,
-0.46456143260002136,
-0.5231515169143677,
-0.7814308404922485,
-0.7563732266426086,
-0.31158915162086487,
-0.05013308674097061,
-0.040058061480522156,
0.5779513716697693,
0.8426872491836548,
-0.45285093784332275,
0.022570908069610596,
0.24767154455184937,
0.1830110102891922,
0.037162091583013535,
-0.2580181956291199,
-0.24139368534088135,
-0.4063871502876282,
-0.4628389775753021,
0.6522688865661621,
0.36205509305000305,
0.11343265324831009,
-0.04444684460759163,
-0.0433938093483448,
-0.6983759999275208,
-0.025453349575400352,
0.7402451038360596,
0.08321043848991394,
-0.7032141089439392,
-0.15932302176952362,
0.3119949996471405,
0.1364607810974121,
0.41331011056900024,
1.0914970636367798,
-0.5488088130950928,
0.9316216707229614,
0.3763117790222168,
0.36300644278526306,
0.7411631941795349,
0.2914596498012543,
0.2849652171134949,
-1.187914490699768,
0.112301766872406,
0.23592497408390045,
0.3202478885650635,
0.43502599000930786,
-0.3355482220649719,
0.042292073369026184,
0.18568706512451172,
-0.46144595742225647,
-0.36160093545913696,
0.32815268635749817,
-1.0610179901123047,
-0.28723785281181335,
0.9264302253723145,
0.03706562891602516,
-0.19050775468349457,
-0.03141900524497032,
-0.6151009202003479,
-0.05126786604523659,
-0.5814653038978577,
0.44069430232048035,
0.5894374847412109,
-0.16767100989818573,
-0.5827209949493408,
-0.4781431555747986,
0.023369956761598587,
0.6407546997070312,
-0.7296733260154724,
-0.3023172616958618,
0.7694357633590698,
-0.054685112088918686,
0.45279231667518616,
0.6129571199417114,
-0.12331271916627884,
0.5907289981842041,
-0.30472150444984436,
-0.14458808302879333,
0.06308522075414658,
-0.4862016439437866,
-0.13383877277374268,
0.3747432827949524,
-0.0494978241622448,
-0.40790268778800964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07729v1 | AIR-Bench: Benchmarking Large Audio-Language Models via Generative Comprehension | 2024-02-12T15:41:22 | 2024-02-12T15:41:22 | Qian Yang, Jin Xu, Wenrui Liu, Yunfei Chu, Ziyue Jiang, Xiaohuan Zhou, Yichong Leng, Yuanjun Lv, Zhou Zhao, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Recently, instruction-following audio-language models have received broad
attention for human-audio interaction. However, the absence of benchmarks
capable of evaluating audio-centric interaction capabilities has impeded
advancements in this field. Previous models primarily focus on assessing
different fundamental tasks, such as Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), and
lack an assessment of the open-ended generative capabilities centered around
audio. Thus, it is challenging to track the progression in the Large
Audio-Language Models (LALMs) domain and to provide guidance for future
improvement. In this paper, we introduce AIR-Bench (\textbf{A}udio
\textbf{I}nst\textbf{R}uction \textbf{Bench}mark), the first benchmark designed
to evaluate the ability of LALMs to understand various types of audio signals
(including human speech, natural sounds, and music), and furthermore, to
interact with humans in the textual format. AIR-Bench encompasses two
dimensions: \textit{foundation} and \textit{chat} benchmarks. The former
consists of 19 tasks with approximately 19k single-choice questions, intending
to inspect the basic single-task ability of LALMs. The latter one contains 2k
instances of open-ended question-and-answer data, directly assessing the
comprehension of the model on complex audio and its capacity to follow
instructions. Both benchmarks require the model to generate hypotheses
directly. We design a unified framework that leverages advanced language
models, such as GPT-4, to evaluate the scores of generated hypotheses given the
meta-information of the audio. Experimental results demonstrate a high level of
consistency between GPT-4-based evaluation and human evaluation. By revealing
the limitations of existing LALMs through evaluation results, AIR-Bench can
provide insights into the direction of future research. | [
-0.6351876258850098,
-0.8721270561218262,
0.4816935658454895,
0.3208230137825012,
0.11189565807580948,
-0.13761916756629944,
-0.32408300042152405,
-0.2549089193344116,
-0.2651987671852112,
0.3723096549510956,
-0.6344898343086243,
-0.43619459867477417,
-0.4110429584980011,
-0.17752209305763245,
-0.829108715057373,
0.47528037428855896,
-0.11460375040769577,
-0.13706742227077484,
-0.3964036703109741,
-0.2561241388320923,
-0.5502244234085083,
-0.4931197762489319,
-0.6249440312385559,
-0.2781543433666229,
-0.025537850335240364,
0.323335736989975,
0.33048054575920105,
0.47416090965270996,
0.2684536874294281,
0.27661827206611633,
-0.09032689779996872,
-0.17639140784740448,
-0.2070242166519165,
0.22539468109607697,
0.2360491007566452,
-0.22880499064922333,
-0.35890993475914,
0.09465325623750687,
0.5801407694816589,
0.7966465353965759,
-0.440064400434494,
0.22559089958667755,
-0.036773934960365295,
0.6150711178779602,
-0.5311622023582458,
0.04441985487937927,
-0.6863664388656616,
-0.03146565705537796,
-0.012191744521260262,
-0.25615546107292175,
-0.3264155685901642,
0.07290925830602646,
0.05944707989692688,
-0.7273544669151306,
0.33072003722190857,
-0.07670599967241287,
0.7910626530647278,
0.5843233466148376,
-0.24289046227931976,
-0.05410873144865036,
-0.8406831622123718,
0.6325365304946899,
-0.608978807926178,
0.8274190425872803,
0.7369539141654968,
0.6640267372131348,
0.010514084249734879,
-0.5270125865936279,
-0.7165395617485046,
-0.2972615361213684,
0.26769858598709106,
0.2116931825876236,
-0.30485430359840393,
-0.1340387463569641,
0.24230122566223145,
0.35105806589126587,
-0.588163435459137,
-0.028188399970531464,
-0.06448708474636078,
0.04084812104701996,
0.39392000436782837,
0.06759291887283325,
0.4220093786716461,
0.08580014109611511,
-0.4314410388469696,
-0.3550291657447815,
-0.6233794689178467,
-0.03595821559429169,
0.10046147555112839,
0.02563534304499626,
-0.1948937028646469,
0.45401063561439514,
-0.4068124294281006,
0.6957753896713257,
-0.12598201632499695,
0.07454009354114532,
0.3114266097545624,
-0.3817066550254822,
-0.2693367302417755,
-0.0729825347661972,
0.6906797289848328,
0.1319369077682495,
0.11620315164327621,
-0.24996452033519745,
-0.1940145194530487,
0.07636874914169312,
0.16424588859081268,
-0.7568743824958801,
-0.13526499271392822,
0.18518730998039246,
-0.19613274931907654,
-0.02411656267940998,
-0.0788905918598175,
-0.6759157776832581,
-0.3854242265224457,
-0.5794305801391602,
0.7017204761505127,
-0.445686936378479,
-0.5135703086853027,
0.15871991217136383,
-0.06969951838254929,
0.23267072439193726,
0.24951335787773132,
-0.9381369352340698,
0.6087538599967957,
0.6253816485404968,
0.7180082201957703,
-0.1010567769408226,
-0.373726487159729,
-0.668592631816864,
0.245489701628685,
-0.24863320589065552,
0.8933750987052917,
-0.625534176826477,
-0.3657161295413971,
-0.23097790777683258,
-0.4762328267097473,
-0.25941893458366394,
-0.7698258757591248,
0.6687109470367432,
-0.30453017354011536,
-0.010232613421976566,
-0.1638253927230835,
-0.6625409126281738,
-0.07258739322423935,
0.16809889674186707,
-0.4331643879413605,
1.0637699365615845,
0.018881574273109436,
-0.5003588199615479,
0.32781797647476196,
-0.7264183163642883,
-0.3095603585243225,
-0.1286882609128952,
-0.5362958312034607,
-0.24922241270542145,
-0.06558450311422348,
0.49234938621520996,
0.1783583164215088,
-0.5229540467262268,
0.24933815002441406,
-0.28522926568984985,
-0.5374177694320679,
0.37056857347488403,
-0.65605628490448,
0.45583391189575195,
0.08686884492635727,
-0.6170222163200378,
0.14277736842632294,
-0.7447448968887329,
0.12442994862794876,
-0.1272459775209427,
-0.21777190268039703,
-0.04712774232029915,
0.14802870154380798,
0.29821786284446716,
-0.007536306977272034,
-0.24580003321170807,
-0.4988802373409271,
-0.2803554832935333,
-0.16355155408382416,
0.47755786776542664,
0.47171419858932495,
-0.019373495131731033,
0.14542058110237122,
-0.37240999937057495,
0.6685274243354797,
-0.21749915182590485,
-0.03675198554992676,
-0.330493688583374,
-0.1930156797170639,
-0.5895282626152039,
-0.3666950762271881,
0.3085543215274811,
0.3921486437320709,
-0.16199173033237457,
0.46584516763687134,
-0.2851982116699219,
-0.5492680668830872,
-0.6834716796875,
0.2927669286727905,
0.38436925411224365,
0.3705313801765442,
0.564237117767334,
-0.062438689172267914,
-0.38606351613998413,
-0.6123648881912231,
-0.25945544242858887,
-0.27451953291893005,
-0.356550931930542,
0.5064350366592407,
0.10486144572496414,
-0.37536051869392395,
1.0240507125854492,
-0.3720596134662628,
-0.3232375681400299,
-0.03518449515104294,
0.5499811172485352,
0.13544140756130219,
0.39278489351272583,
0.4302811026573181,
-0.8160393238067627,
-0.375548779964447,
-0.10149659961462021,
-0.5691996216773987,
-0.5308966040611267,
0.06327909231185913,
-0.0933714210987091,
-0.019444774836301804,
0.8228849172592163,
-0.7621439695358276,
0.46767953038215637,
0.5394609570503235,
-0.21478909254074097,
0.5273272395133972,
0.07516428083181381,
0.21259327232837677,
-0.6487954258918762,
0.2769708037376404,
-0.08282572776079178,
0.16555295884609222,
-0.579970121383667,
-0.10595414787530899,
-0.13612240552902222,
-0.22215840220451355,
-0.21798202395439148,
0.730907678604126,
-0.34184613823890686,
-0.4440385401248932,
-0.4084659814834595,
0.21445666253566742,
0.07262187451124191,
0.4131908714771271,
0.17701706290245056,
0.7913078665733337,
0.4952477216720581,
-0.392631858587265,
0.17310185730457306,
0.20583195984363556,
-0.5377933979034424,
0.5740415453910828,
-0.8362429738044739,
0.28938743472099304,
0.0239229965955019,
0.4439917206764221,
-1.200128436088562,
-0.12993617355823517,
-0.281441867351532,
-0.629817008972168,
0.0599931962788105,
-0.15131720900535583,
-0.5828185677528381,
-0.2016105353832245,
0.13689982891082764,
0.5658655166625977,
0.41480234265327454,
-0.5920498371124268,
0.7098193168640137,
0.42090776562690735,
-0.2852220833301544,
-0.3818398714065552,
-0.386972576379776,
-0.05645541474223137,
-0.31021103262901306,
-0.497650146484375,
0.27546602487564087,
-0.3314734399318695,
-0.35920292139053345,
0.01645800471305847,
-0.5683660507202148,
-0.24699321389198303,
0.12059279531240463,
0.45369431376457214,
0.12792685627937317,
-0.2590292692184448,
0.10230405628681183,
-0.06546435505151749,
-0.12042362987995148,
0.1470199078321457,
0.047464217990636826,
0.5976659059524536,
-0.3247804343700409,
-0.569706916809082,
-0.4100058078765869,
0.16297191381454468,
0.768231213092804,
-0.448383629322052,
0.20127910375595093,
0.80267733335495,
-0.35723185539245605,
-0.2010839283466339,
-0.8157634735107422,
-0.12593507766723633,
-0.4579310119152069,
0.27947378158569336,
-0.5684735774993896,
-0.6110724806785583,
0.29054248332977295,
-0.015539724379777908,
-0.00632718950510025,
0.21786536276340485,
0.5805904865264893,
-0.15431615710258484,
1.0260471105575562,
0.10447812080383301,
-0.16523198783397675,
0.3422854542732239,
-0.34661000967025757,
-0.19548775255680084,
-0.9996416568756104,
-0.18328896164894104,
-0.6656374931335449,
-0.16889742016792297,
0.013473904691636562,
-0.48247137665748596,
0.4703997075557709,
0.3396056890487671,
-0.3352774381637573,
0.38751378655433655,
-0.20436587929725647,
0.46441903710365295,
0.493367463350296,
-0.18307383358478546,
0.25598621368408203,
-0.21848537027835846,
-0.24408577382564545,
0.3431619703769684,
-0.35089704394340515,
-0.22719359397888184,
1.0249931812286377,
0.439395934343338,
0.7349787354469299,
0.28517550230026245,
0.44575774669647217,
0.19534701108932495,
0.3149661719799042,
-0.5877783894538879,
0.46285295486450195,
0.04425695911049843,
-0.6359281539916992,
-0.5017000436782837,
-0.49478232860565186,
-0.9407044053077698,
0.5723049640655518,
-0.0979945957660675,
-0.7261939644813538,
-0.011579636484384537,
0.0066444724798202515,
-0.36525610089302063,
-0.03163038566708565,
-0.775353193283081,
0.9403700232505798,
-0.3347403109073639,
-0.1781313270330429,
-0.28826436400413513,
-0.3423041105270386,
0.15602199733257294,
-0.10963865369558334,
0.4485839605331421,
-0.4779462516307831,
0.08530917763710022,
0.7550356984138489,
-0.22686801850795746,
0.47010472416877747,
-0.41949188709259033,
0.08516979217529297,
0.26648855209350586,
0.03484822437167168,
-0.14527928829193115,
0.14593082666397095,
-0.12431339174509048,
-0.01528872735798359,
0.21970917284488678,
-0.24117085337638855,
-0.5772941708564758,
0.7449967861175537,
-1.0188615322113037,
-0.4219396114349365,
-0.040671456605196,
-0.6264692544937134,
-0.7852881550788879,
0.23740659654140472,
0.004804135765880346,
0.7187272310256958,
-0.33600133657455444,
0.38059961795806885,
0.5405316352844238,
-0.25101280212402344,
0.324200302362442,
0.8369263410568237,
-0.33281299471855164,
-0.30143317580223083,
0.687113344669342,
-0.2223619967699051,
0.13622942566871643,
0.4741201400756836,
0.28432273864746094,
-0.5255153775215149,
-0.5663830637931824,
-0.5208667516708374,
-0.08261104673147202,
-0.5897642970085144,
-0.03277737274765968,
-0.6094825267791748,
-0.09375692903995514,
-0.3442385792732239,
0.19547703862190247,
-0.27221813797950745,
-0.23163698613643646,
-0.061619970947504044,
-0.07759922742843628,
0.20522813498973846,
0.5200843811035156,
-0.06575409322977066,
0.1217115968465805,
-0.667846143245697,
0.7431927919387817,
0.5859355330467224,
0.48853281140327454,
0.09716004878282547,
-0.6335435509681702,
-0.08502986282110214,
0.1011146754026413,
-0.28779199719429016,
-0.6937379837036133,
0.056849002838134766,
0.3451850116252899,
0.8788774013519287,
0.3478924036026001,
-0.008383650332689285,
0.7048953175544739,
-0.5533246397972107,
0.44764041900634766,
0.01918434537947178,
-1.0997854471206665,
0.5253767967224121,
-0.5723782181739807,
0.44071266055107117,
0.8739822506904602,
0.10931277275085449,
-0.5476463437080383,
-0.35623544454574585,
-0.5297663807868958,
-0.7958605289459229,
0.6504418253898621,
0.34462204575538635,
-0.05619106814265251,
0.09399639070034027,
0.03607718646526337,
0.010754729621112347,
0.11821150779724121,
-0.36143356561660767,
-0.03573395684361458,
-0.3734045624732971,
-0.13624250888824463,
-0.1540101170539856,
0.22120250761508942,
-0.11813640594482422,
-0.4488115608692169,
0.631129264831543,
-0.03065674565732479,
0.30341213941574097,
0.04673256352543831,
-0.13006910681724548,
-0.23512394726276398,
0.3957003355026245,
0.5072383284568787,
0.5315843224525452,
-0.507413387298584,
0.18741732835769653,
0.04443184658885002,
-0.2209584265947342,
0.3210003077983856,
0.40301722288131714,
0.14632248878479004,
-0.09842594712972641,
0.27978596091270447,
0.9984292984008789,
0.3677808940410614,
-1.0776093006134033,
0.656945526599884,
-0.2419784516096115,
-0.24700520932674408,
-0.5011730790138245,
0.10424656420946121,
0.36794936656951904,
0.03404134139418602,
0.546476423740387,
-0.009807741269469261,
0.19587881863117218,
-0.6060710549354553,
0.5189891457557678,
0.2952623665332794,
-0.4384665787220001,
-0.18465591967105865,
0.8808596730232239,
0.24744246900081635,
-0.13503946363925934,
0.5529634952545166,
0.06130948290228844,
-0.40710875391960144,
0.6693253517150879,
0.40758270025253296,
0.9185380339622498,
-0.17632052302360535,
-0.0338355153799057,
0.34893983602523804,
0.12014813721179962,
0.023016907274723053,
0.1353646069765091,
-0.40043824911117554,
-0.725642740726471,
-0.4525276720523834,
-0.6869251728057861,
-0.6688811779022217,
0.4868251383304596,
-0.873704731464386,
0.1011003628373146,
-0.20490345358848572,
-0.02263384498655796,
0.22628509998321533,
-0.15759558975696564,
-0.7838176488876343,
0.21009334921836853,
0.2757265865802765,
0.9642530679702759,
-0.8218251466751099,
0.9518833160400391,
0.6904289722442627,
-0.29226773977279663,
-0.7357437610626221,
0.3032712936401367,
0.07600883394479752,
-0.7525360584259033,
0.5557969212532043,
0.3641720712184906,
-0.14018748700618744,
0.02598235383629799,
-0.17596334218978882,
-0.7360743284225464,
0.9871625304222107,
0.26353520154953003,
-0.4774166941642761,
0.15448550879955292,
0.1558666229248047,
0.5064142346382141,
-0.16265787184238434,
0.47380751371383667,
0.743511974811554,
0.5972976684570312,
0.13115239143371582,
-1.0008010864257812,
-0.09446372091770172,
-0.6406362056732178,
-0.22242166101932526,
0.19107235968112946,
-0.3928973972797394,
0.6772610545158386,
0.012385159730911255,
-0.10459421575069427,
0.14420628547668457,
0.49633660912513733,
0.3987296223640442,
0.4014255404472351,
1.007901906967163,
0.8649820685386658,
0.42099055647850037,
-0.15972985327243805,
0.8548411726951599,
-0.17916284501552582,
0.20136229693889618,
1.2311664819717407,
-0.3399260342121124,
1.259920358657837,
0.3069536089897156,
-0.340766042470932,
0.5223760008811951,
0.3044905960559845,
0.01733454316854477,
0.5380076169967651,
0.47116535902023315,
-0.38198405504226685,
-0.20474964380264282,
-0.034237831830978394,
-0.3935922086238861,
0.6763949990272522,
0.4256787896156311,
0.21237024664878845,
-0.053646720945835114,
0.10193517059087753,
-0.36451855301856995,
0.16420701146125793,
-0.06087467819452286,
0.90909743309021,
-0.020129606127738953,
-0.7787870764732361,
0.7511405944824219,
-0.1663012057542801,
0.39055317640304565,
-0.5072044730186462,
-0.022038573399186134,
-0.11886939406394958,
0.11370176821947098,
0.04964297264814377,
-0.542482316493988,
0.1683225780725479,
0.11213497817516327,
-0.1103745624423027,
-0.10623760521411896,
0.3867519497871399,
-0.6391363143920898,
-0.18197879195213318,
0.3719632029533386,
0.4446902275085449,
0.05224215239286423,
-0.27826136350631714,
-0.6255937218666077,
0.44284331798553467,
-0.37948524951934814,
-0.23099881410598755,
0.28781354427337646,
0.28112518787384033,
0.2507454752922058,
0.5405663847923279,
0.6268789768218994,
-0.02843252383172512,
0.04975453019142151,
0.4479950964450836,
0.5064755082130432,
-0.49746227264404297,
-0.5155478715896606,
-0.5579797029495239,
0.18477655947208405,
0.0894831046462059,
-0.16977554559707642,
0.49387046694755554,
0.5875154137611389,
0.6910204887390137,
0.19917558133602142,
0.9880996942520142,
0.016956055536866188,
0.8262194395065308,
-0.5043114423751831,
0.6733724474906921,
-0.5947156548500061,
0.4081287384033203,
-0.34734612703323364,
-0.8683720231056213,
0.08381347358226776,
0.5360624194145203,
-0.20368371903896332,
0.16536986827850342,
0.5988261699676514,
0.6346443891525269,
-0.22914016246795654,
0.31174275279045105,
0.21785211563110352,
0.1645752638578415,
0.365180104970932,
0.5421748161315918,
1.0045521259307861,
-0.31332552433013916,
0.7725565433502197,
-0.2669506371021271,
-0.34467795491218567,
-0.1742362678050995,
-0.6477539539337158,
-0.812993586063385,
-0.6853351593017578,
-0.2053767889738083,
-0.09340419620275497,
-0.11279778927564621,
0.7328161597251892,
0.8913332223892212,
-0.75166916847229,
-0.5507844686508179,
-0.3876190483570099,
-0.27967941761016846,
-0.570819079875946,
-0.25850746035575867,
0.4456705152988434,
-0.18731287121772766,
-0.6626855731010437,
0.9252528548240662,
0.011063757352530956,
0.012165497988462448,
-0.15505319833755493,
-0.2975611090660095,
0.0003219599602743983,
0.14028674364089966,
0.39951246976852417,
0.3872115910053253,
-0.8577947020530701,
-0.22621838748455048,
0.014362530782818794,
0.09926768392324448,
-0.13400760293006897,
0.741253137588501,
-0.806720495223999,
0.5816970467567444,
0.3127727508544922,
1.046530842781067,
0.8775995373725891,
0.15505710244178772,
0.6304911375045776,
-0.7441787719726562,
-0.1484813392162323,
0.1287607103586197,
0.33378320932388306,
0.4534723460674286,
0.2989053726196289,
0.6145353317260742,
0.08019779622554779,
-0.522821307182312,
-0.8918579816818237,
-0.06210437789559364,
-1.0835214853286743,
-0.26684707403182983,
1.3080722093582153,
0.014873807318508625,
0.3094583749771118,
-0.16149398684501648,
-0.18686246871948242,
0.2240028828382492,
-0.24748626351356506,
0.7260808348655701,
0.7331680655479431,
-0.22726863622665405,
-0.26157623529434204,
-0.802361011505127,
0.32908567786216736,
0.7686499357223511,
-1.0616739988327026,
0.3103954792022705,
0.4234668016433716,
0.20459415018558502,
0.007664651609957218,
0.9080435633659363,
-0.13459882140159607,
0.4494209587574005,
0.038306400179862976,
-0.04555657505989075,
-0.11279552429914474,
-0.3503698408603668,
-0.17586316168308258,
0.09911733865737915,
0.10718436539173126,
-0.2486013025045395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07726v1 | Unsupervised Sign Language Translation and Generation | 2024-02-12T15:39:05 | 2024-02-12T15:39:05 | Zhengsheng Guo, Zhiwei He, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Rui Wang, Kehai Chen, Zhaopeng Tu, Yong Xu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Motivated by the success of unsupervised neural machine translation (UNMT),
we introduce an unsupervised sign language translation and generation network
(USLNet), which learns from abundant single-modality (text and video) data
without parallel sign language data. USLNet comprises two main components:
single-modality reconstruction modules (text and video) that rebuild the input
from its noisy version in the same modality and cross-modality back-translation
modules (text-video-text and video-text-video) that reconstruct the input from
its noisy version in the different modality using back-translation
procedure.Unlike the single-modality back-translation procedure in text-based
UNMT, USLNet faces the cross-modality discrepancy in feature representation, in
which the length and the feature dimension mismatch between text and video
sequences. We propose a sliding window method to address the issues of aligning
variable-length text with video sequences. To our knowledge, USLNet is the
first unsupervised sign language translation and generation model capable of
generating both natural language text and sign language video in a unified
manner. Experimental results on the BBC-Oxford Sign Language dataset (BOBSL)
and Open-Domain American Sign Language dataset (OpenASL) reveal that USLNet
achieves competitive results compared to supervised baseline models, indicating
its effectiveness in sign language translation and generation. | [
0.09004440158605576,
-0.07880980521440506,
0.10135442018508911,
0.25095149874687195,
-0.7898997068405151,
0.1507565677165985,
-0.019602496176958084,
-0.06330413371324539,
0.19712617993354797,
0.6661456823348999,
-0.4833301603794098,
-0.6173052787780762,
-0.674933910369873,
-0.03205200284719467,
-0.5521647334098816,
0.9174607992172241,
-0.05872919037938118,
0.4298585057258606,
0.2712329626083374,
-0.18605364859104156,
-0.13259020447731018,
0.049922507256269455,
-0.6300399899482727,
-0.32162410020828247,
-0.11328102648258209,
0.08940242975950241,
0.7483581900596619,
0.41618818044662476,
0.3431205749511719,
0.2571859359741211,
0.09806039184331894,
0.25980380177497864,
-0.15548700094223022,
-0.06376014649868011,
0.28438544273376465,
0.03279747813940048,
-0.36227983236312866,
-0.12005802243947983,
0.8262531161308289,
0.9136042594909668,
0.3169252574443817,
0.1643620729446411,
-0.1786893606185913,
0.6347560286521912,
-0.07551483064889908,
0.03760799393057823,
-0.6292935013771057,
0.44372376799583435,
-0.23572947084903717,
-0.07298555225133896,
-0.26460689306259155,
-0.2869868278503418,
-0.20828314125537872,
-0.3555687963962555,
0.38127776980400085,
-0.12576645612716675,
0.30268821120262146,
0.5036560297012329,
-0.9506432414054871,
0.054561447352170944,
-0.6420750617980957,
0.4923776686191559,
-0.8825133442878723,
0.6373609304428101,
0.08185070753097534,
-0.007073814049363136,
-0.45465734601020813,
-0.6248107552528381,
-0.3537663221359253,
-0.22791491448879242,
0.022160017862915993,
0.2617252767086029,
-0.12287458777427673,
0.053931593894958496,
-0.06590361148118973,
0.16559138894081116,
-0.7069719433784485,
0.3068241775035858,
-0.4827714264392853,
-0.366914838552475,
0.7034929394721985,
0.16830536723136902,
0.22682559490203857,
-0.2759245038032532,
-0.6608482599258423,
-0.06123032048344612,
-0.5267292857170105,
0.12659426033496857,
0.30025890469551086,
0.7222031354904175,
-0.16976313292980194,
0.5942867398262024,
0.08714351803064346,
0.6815559267997742,
-0.02931593917310238,
-0.2452605962753296,
0.21620722115039825,
-0.45016011595726013,
-0.2767922878265381,
0.10284478962421417,
1.2376987934112549,
0.19262118637561798,
-0.043447379022836685,
-0.21164579689502716,
-0.34309813380241394,
-0.09787220507860184,
-0.016088619828224182,
-0.48483848571777344,
0.033062566071748734,
-0.11710179597139359,
-0.4536092281341553,
-0.27611321210861206,
0.3666471540927887,
-0.4073932468891144,
-0.38741248846054077,
-0.33561238646507263,
0.4617694914340973,
-0.22304022312164307,
-0.5358819365501404,
0.1647326797246933,
0.005085419863462448,
-0.030914142727851868,
0.2656041085720062,
-0.40901514887809753,
0.21862804889678955,
0.4750896692276001,
0.8774978518486023,
-0.5413530468940735,
-0.21049675345420837,
-0.36711958050727844,
-0.22958685457706451,
-0.2954069972038269,
-0.010831448249518871,
-0.05202866718173027,
-0.26074594259262085,
0.020820431411266327,
-0.05156103894114494,
-0.08962489664554596,
-0.1798524111509323,
0.170293390750885,
-0.38060569763183594,
0.26994752883911133,
0.2824963629245758,
-0.303295761346817,
0.07835930585861206,
-0.38227930665016174,
-0.6186164617538452,
0.908126950263977,
-0.0002978161792270839,
-0.3938957452774048,
0.423483282327652,
-0.7244592905044556,
-0.8257970809936523,
-0.05524926260113716,
-0.2372257262468338,
-0.48708775639533997,
0.43267711997032166,
-0.08089759200811386,
0.5126835703849792,
-0.29045620560646057,
0.2895815968513489,
0.5942833423614502,
-0.11447592824697495,
0.4014507532119751,
-0.7870852947235107,
0.8965703845024109,
0.23880107700824738,
-0.616600513458252,
-0.04655193164944649,
-0.9862980246543884,
-0.10284506529569626,
0.004484838340431452,
-0.36867257952690125,
-0.06748682260513306,
-0.31286200881004333,
0.28901052474975586,
0.49558156728744507,
0.32109329104423523,
-0.9756208658218384,
-0.07059240341186523,
-0.15196499228477478,
0.1527668535709381,
0.594647228717804,
-0.08478040248155594,
0.31125712394714355,
0.2587873935699463,
0.4781092703342438,
0.505099892616272,
0.3869512379169464,
-0.07379666715860367,
-0.6984614133834839,
-0.5917801856994629,
0.1562650501728058,
-0.04442025348544121,
0.11220337450504303,
-0.773312509059906,
0.38750606775283813,
-0.11088794469833374,
-0.02107340469956398,
-0.4986802637577057,
0.2278168797492981,
0.8930715322494507,
0.45162084698677063,
0.4220205247402191,
-0.7895435690879822,
-0.4874764382839203,
-0.4888061285018921,
0.18432793021202087,
-0.27540674805641174,
0.07686561346054077,
-0.29261520504951477,
0.31587541103363037,
0.2292540967464447,
0.5679910778999329,
-0.1389019936323166,
-0.5271651744842529,
0.019947269931435585,
0.40032055974006653,
0.36530882120132446,
0.46783703565597534,
0.09749751538038254,
-1.022160530090332,
-0.6484732627868652,
0.33735692501068115,
-0.5371472835540771,
-0.12787997722625732,
-0.44594186544418335,
0.19543932378292084,
0.2963812053203583,
0.4491969048976898,
-0.1863330751657486,
0.6849555969238281,
0.8761160969734192,
-0.6201237440109253,
0.468855619430542,
-0.13020136952400208,
0.09560197591781616,
-1.4006202220916748,
0.07963591814041138,
-0.129110187292099,
-0.4548919200897217,
-0.6805073618888855,
-0.2131567746400833,
-0.182857945561409,
-0.3801277279853821,
-0.5908225774765015,
0.12040676921606064,
-0.8305610418319702,
-0.5622268915176392,
-0.5016392469406128,
0.3227459192276001,
-0.15120041370391846,
0.3562319576740265,
0.02509523741900921,
0.8073207139968872,
0.7878683805465698,
-0.4862479567527771,
0.3194911479949951,
0.34202179312705994,
-0.023726757615804672,
0.3868626654148102,
-0.3362143039703369,
0.004897865932434797,
-0.12882807850837708,
-0.1553204357624054,
-0.8815280795097351,
0.14911814033985138,
0.0039029638282954693,
-0.595862865447998,
0.4729519784450531,
-0.025173040106892586,
0.02552931196987629,
-0.3525450825691223,
0.07036222517490387,
0.13162469863891602,
0.601413369178772,
-0.7056680917739868,
0.33769652247428894,
0.1645210236310959,
0.3657786548137665,
-0.7259210348129272,
-0.7917041778564453,
0.23665094375610352,
0.23109322786331177,
-0.5141279101371765,
-0.0010331046069040895,
0.13167031109333038,
0.13438032567501068,
-0.08211462944746017,
-0.46619725227355957,
-0.11145899444818497,
-0.05022269859910011,
0.32553520798683167,
0.0029989934992045164,
-0.45984914898872375,
0.0638955682516098,
-0.00934282224625349,
-0.29964059591293335,
-0.002675832947716117,
-0.6041591763496399,
0.21976642310619354,
-0.08984001725912094,
-0.45334428548812866,
-0.40755197405815125,
0.413774698972702,
0.8205679655075073,
-0.15280377864837646,
0.5031803250312805,
0.7911260724067688,
-0.09170222282409668,
-0.08444391936063766,
-0.04627270624041557,
-0.11338725686073303,
-0.4077115058898926,
0.30225932598114014,
-0.17808088660240173,
-0.9978440999984741,
0.31746965646743774,
-0.11000152677297592,
0.3820088505744934,
0.12136416882276535,
0.4262844920158386,
0.0327465683221817,
1.0343427658081055,
0.617713987827301,
0.23400628566741943,
0.4783008396625519,
0.028823457658290863,
0.06726966053247452,
-0.7236533164978027,
-0.3165270686149597,
-0.22655647993087769,
-0.44131144881248474,
-0.03409381955862045,
-0.5591951608657837,
0.40447455644607544,
0.07453085482120514,
-0.3134620189666748,
0.9591265320777893,
-0.6371878981590271,
0.22906546294689178,
0.37790802121162415,
-0.0335884727537632,
0.7425733804702759,
0.05929166451096535,
-0.4693658649921417,
-0.2652623951435089,
-0.3582022190093994,
-0.37909165024757385,
1.076857328414917,
0.08734224736690521,
0.7385274767875671,
0.49226248264312744,
0.5799254179000854,
0.2966557443141937,
0.23173463344573975,
-0.4845326542854309,
0.7691455483436584,
-0.5746626257896423,
-0.40721115469932556,
-0.473886102437973,
-0.6793755888938904,
-1.083143949508667,
0.300736665725708,
-0.36672618985176086,
-0.7434401512145996,
-0.08383112400770187,
0.1329771876335144,
0.20795899629592896,
0.5179769396781921,
-0.5042122602462769,
0.7336028218269348,
-0.6500136256217957,
-0.004327462054789066,
0.30038872361183167,
-0.9865280985832214,
0.4607474207878113,
-0.3601308763027191,
-0.2876228392124176,
0.1004132479429245,
0.06604676693677902,
0.5181868672370911,
-0.8416098356246948,
1.136411190032959,
-0.10414892435073853,
-0.22209703922271729,
0.06290467083454132,
0.24667420983314514,
0.2837201952934265,
0.02829449065029621,
0.23019437491893768,
0.05653838813304901,
-0.4401170313358307,
-0.09457796066999435,
-0.5537921190261841,
0.4310508966445923,
-0.8308740854263306,
-0.34272336959838867,
-0.1885368525981903,
-0.43286171555519104,
-0.1860525906085968,
0.3062182664871216,
0.4404888153076172,
0.4955623149871826,
-0.5303610563278198,
0.08710765093564987,
0.547553300857544,
0.26804643869400024,
0.768781840801239,
0.7900166511535645,
-0.3811475336551666,
-0.4627966582775116,
0.6977731585502625,
-0.32989707589149475,
0.4640029966831207,
0.4745508134365082,
0.14373555779457092,
-0.43718594312667847,
-0.5888066291809082,
-0.6784722805023193,
0.17868635058403015,
-0.48219746351242065,
-0.37827757000923157,
-0.2574310302734375,
-0.12676629424095154,
-0.5172803997993469,
0.05523179844021797,
-0.7834261059761047,
-0.5975834727287292,
-0.25393593311309814,
-0.0635085254907608,
0.43561071157455444,
0.6343458890914917,
-0.3763379752635956,
0.5029444694519043,
-0.6234118938446045,
0.2793377935886383,
0.1875568926334381,
0.1296127438545227,
-0.12153500318527222,
-0.5640512704849243,
-0.20591683685779572,
-0.045902933925390244,
-0.2079835832118988,
-0.847179114818573,
0.06005658581852913,
0.33619704842567444,
0.3035297095775604,
0.5969855189323425,
-0.07080078125,
0.43337973952293396,
-0.3848339915275574,
0.8288787007331848,
1.2681951522827148,
-0.915881335735321,
0.3305386006832123,
-0.14287129044532776,
0.4676533341407776,
0.4433964192867279,
0.29338449239730835,
-0.7514554262161255,
-0.4266555607318878,
-0.44682151079177856,
-0.6459305882453918,
0.5015765428543091,
0.6208375692367554,
0.01038345880806446,
0.16236500442028046,
-0.03682893142104149,
0.26810741424560547,
0.3426257073879242,
-0.9691429138183594,
-0.4049481749534607,
-0.7712503671646118,
-0.25286000967025757,
-0.037329431623220444,
0.6497425436973572,
-0.06366666406393051,
-0.13718919456005096,
0.6597006320953369,
-0.3632909655570984,
0.1601586788892746,
0.07053105533123016,
-0.15600113570690155,
-0.34684354066848755,
0.1835990846157074,
0.6484367251396179,
0.4753260314464569,
0.16907696425914764,
0.2100287824869156,
-0.21188555657863617,
-0.9391319751739502,
0.3301866948604584,
-0.028765834867954254,
-0.5478445291519165,
0.4397833049297333,
0.18864746391773224,
1.1210700273513794,
0.21722562611103058,
-0.27952295541763306,
0.7982706427574158,
-0.013640105724334717,
-0.21621327102184296,
-0.27763232588768005,
-0.2556450664997101,
-0.04159010946750641,
0.0805053561925888,
0.3850899636745453,
0.29724255204200745,
-0.31676194071769714,
-0.39001208543777466,
0.447506308555603,
0.3944343328475952,
-0.7430031895637512,
-0.5378054976463318,
0.9808841347694397,
0.28655996918678284,
-0.5637226104736328,
0.4105776846408844,
0.04814129322767258,
-0.343828022480011,
0.4498850703239441,
0.9449120759963989,
1.0395797491073608,
-0.08211658149957657,
0.8068508505821228,
0.2716137766838074,
0.4291709065437317,
0.029495637863874435,
0.4188665449619293,
-0.03150058537721634,
-0.7052832841873169,
-0.3644791543483734,
-0.5092266201972961,
-0.12263098359107971,
0.11603760719299316,
-0.54063880443573,
-0.15415196120738983,
-0.4591977000236511,
-0.34116435050964355,
-0.42349234223365784,
-0.36950814723968506,
-0.5272771120071411,
0.2696744203567505,
0.17601048946380615,
0.6937267184257507,
-1.1670325994491577,
0.6388776302337646,
0.8200305700302124,
-0.6396766901016235,
-0.7780663371086121,
-0.09583650529384613,
0.0523398220539093,
-0.7547315955162048,
0.5309587121009827,
-0.1806875765323639,
-0.3485562801361084,
0.16332930326461792,
-0.4788137674331665,
-0.7849355340003967,
1.0375690460205078,
0.2681565582752228,
-0.132398322224617,
0.22856782376766205,
0.6222103834152222,
0.5915112495422363,
-0.571127712726593,
-0.23560461401939392,
0.3895002603530884,
0.4575449228286743,
0.29010891914367676,
-0.9268975257873535,
0.293253093957901,
-0.028483789414167404,
0.1517142951488495,
0.5860254168510437,
-0.582936704158783,
0.4910822808742523,
-0.11393878608942032,
-0.3594849705696106,
0.14203688502311707,
0.8810843229293823,
-0.13113030791282654,
0.1386452615261078,
0.2881653904914856,
0.43373751640319824,
0.5278031229972839,
-0.15739749372005463,
0.2462218999862671,
-0.0537433996796608,
0.06180189922451973,
0.9452322125434875,
-0.015670103952288628,
0.4165101945400238,
0.7206686735153198,
-0.059798214584589005,
0.18528951704502106,
0.04306931421160698,
0.17276622354984283,
0.2810025215148926,
0.1419556587934494,
-0.33623242378234863,
-0.38620713353157043,
-0.054192930459976196,
-0.12745152413845062,
0.6274348497390747,
0.005544446874409914,
-0.5161508321762085,
-0.5758907198905945,
0.17793717980384827,
-0.023785391822457314,
0.4091431498527527,
-0.3611845076084137,
0.47725576162338257,
0.3698677718639374,
-0.4092663824558258,
0.38401705026626587,
-0.01366624515503645,
0.6332576870918274,
-0.8580907583236694,
0.1370995193719864,
-0.5268774628639221,
0.015162734314799309,
-0.19450218975543976,
-0.7023792862892151,
0.150845468044281,
0.0690537616610527,
0.12794649600982666,
-0.34759777784347534,
0.5356513857841492,
-0.5727002024650574,
-0.40320897102355957,
0.07247316837310791,
0.5301695466041565,
0.5020759105682373,
0.5098528265953064,
-0.7648930549621582,
-0.07847195863723755,
0.14328058063983917,
-0.08351682126522064,
0.2781889736652374,
0.692468523979187,
-0.1516328901052475,
0.39006316661834717,
0.7319120168685913,
-0.03554202988743782,
0.48245570063591003,
0.45614293217658997,
0.6719659566879272,
-0.5993868112564087,
-0.37754330039024353,
-0.22590093314647675,
0.8122572302818298,
-0.06775989383459091,
-0.9144324064254761,
0.8018795251846313,
0.605036735534668,
0.535955548286438,
-0.2780894637107849,
0.500462532043457,
-0.062264490872621536,
-0.15882940590381622,
-0.6248146295547485,
0.601476788520813,
-0.6260309219360352,
-0.22885935008525848,
-0.4706292450428009,
-0.7606857419013977,
-0.5977315902709961,
0.33983972668647766,
0.4620092809200287,
-0.20930758118629456,
0.7478564977645874,
0.8414203524589539,
-0.14525680243968964,
-0.07964882254600525,
0.7375836372375488,
0.020565275102853775,
0.052751898765563965,
0.6571535468101501,
0.2954410910606384,
-0.8848860859870911,
0.8413474559783936,
0.25471651554107666,
-0.2462013214826584,
0.023580968379974365,
-0.889942467212677,
-0.9757841229438782,
-0.9381203651428223,
-0.5032998919487,
-0.3716202974319458,
-0.2329842448234558,
0.7545938491821289,
0.5694530606269836,
-0.6546638011932373,
-0.41824427247047424,
-0.2933618724346161,
0.07484207302331924,
-0.41067320108413696,
-0.18842843174934387,
0.35130807757377625,
0.05968332290649414,
-0.5248157978057861,
0.8962244987487793,
0.41554972529411316,
0.4353509843349457,
-0.6345205903053284,
-0.392863005399704,
-0.15130136907100677,
-0.09469585120677948,
0.31144532561302185,
0.7339051961898804,
-0.4912458658218384,
-0.2951779365539551,
0.011728931218385696,
-0.15883947908878326,
0.20247682929039001,
1.0641123056411743,
-0.4083367884159088,
0.42221444845199585,
0.4043647050857544,
0.5233343243598938,
0.5675670504570007,
-0.039728835225105286,
0.563237726688385,
-1.3400945663452148,
0.185524582862854,
0.11773001402616501,
0.34593409299850464,
0.5050786733627319,
-0.2482450157403946,
0.4228728413581848,
0.3530447483062744,
-0.1715359389781952,
-0.3766270875930786,
0.8227092623710632,
-1.1824426651000977,
-0.2119828760623932,
0.9728507995605469,
0.07897757738828659,
-0.23262615501880646,
-0.5527868270874023,
0.0367637574672699,
0.39051398634910583,
-0.28746241331100464,
0.43810713291168213,
-0.0915612056851387,
-0.06473485380411148,
-0.23019281029701233,
0.028309185057878494,
0.4166489541530609,
0.2685096263885498,
-0.22750858962535858,
-0.009637570939958096,
0.5481473803520203,
0.10504483431577682,
0.38662105798721313,
0.7474092245101929,
-0.39095476269721985,
0.2779448628425598,
0.06365571171045303,
0.3093157708644867,
-0.5867093801498413,
-0.42420366406440735,
-0.3553954064846039,
0.016331523656845093,
-0.21169395744800568,
-0.3237908184528351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07721v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07721v2 | LoRA-drop: Efficient LoRA Parameter Pruning based on Output Evaluation | 2024-02-12T15:34:56 | 2024-06-18T15:13:12 | Hongyun Zhou, Xiangyu Lu, Wang Xu, Conghui Zhu, Tiejun Zhao, Muyun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) is currently the most commonly used
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) method, it introduces auxiliary
parameters for each layer to fine-tune the pre-trained model under limited
computing resources. However, it still faces resource consumption challenges
during training when scaling up to larger models. Most previous studies have
tackled this issue by using pruning techniques, which involve removing LoRA
parameters deemed unimportant. Nonetheless, these efforts only analyze LoRA
parameter features to evaluate their importance, such as parameter count, size,
and gradient. In fact, the output of LoRA (product of LoRA parameter and hidden
state), directly impacts the final results. Preliminary experiments indicate
that a fraction of LoRA elements possesses significantly high output values,
substantially influencing the layer output. Motivated by the observation, we
propose LoRA-drop. Concretely, LoRA-drop evaluates the importance of LoRA based
on the LoRA output. Then we retain LoRA for important layers and the other
layers share the same LoRA. We conduct abundant experiments with models of
different scales on NLU and NLG tasks. Results demonstrate that LoRA-drop can
achieve performance comparable to full fine-tuning and LoRA, while retaining
50\% of the LoRA parameters on average. | [
-0.6384221315383911,
-0.8905484080314636,
0.2997019290924072,
-0.09641341865062714,
-0.5603517293930054,
-0.1740204244852066,
-0.25779929757118225,
-0.42148247361183167,
0.20761971175670624,
0.5274185538291931,
-0.6957171559333801,
-0.2841970920562744,
-0.5040878653526306,
-0.12521912157535553,
-0.6165412068367004,
1.2427165508270264,
0.08868500590324402,
-0.5009005665779114,
0.12179825454950333,
-0.29491204023361206,
-0.46982714533805847,
-0.39432141184806824,
-0.8325290679931641,
-0.5048474073410034,
1.0599572658538818,
0.4818354845046997,
0.4277254343032837,
0.6704116463661194,
0.7409353852272034,
0.2282305508852005,
-0.3456183969974518,
0.2311764657497406,
-0.8905717730522156,
-0.3634273409843445,
-0.014063159003853798,
-0.4706650376319885,
-0.6112220883369446,
0.1740112006664276,
0.7986346483230591,
0.7984727621078491,
-0.40985533595085144,
0.5537425875663757,
0.3027682900428772,
0.8281500935554504,
-0.9939448833465576,
-0.30191880464553833,
-0.7329225540161133,
0.19154620170593262,
-0.17981314659118652,
-0.24511843919754028,
-0.42834651470184326,
-0.3078557550907135,
-0.08141239732503891,
-0.669231116771698,
0.042641375213861465,
-0.1872740089893341,
1.011123538017273,
0.5525659918785095,
-0.20315010845661163,
0.37737706303596497,
-0.9543523192405701,
0.9432079792022705,
-0.8162027597427368,
0.14880962669849396,
0.3474942147731781,
0.30586951971054077,
0.18386328220367432,
-0.5186105370521545,
-0.0974428802728653,
-0.09580134600400925,
0.26557350158691406,
0.15231144428253174,
0.09010390192270279,
-0.022868184372782707,
0.2630188763141632,
0.4474064111709595,
0.18688994646072388,
0.41641485691070557,
-0.5407211780548096,
0.13651131093502045,
0.4542853832244873,
0.003919550217688084,
-0.1682894080877304,
-0.0448211245238781,
-0.36043620109558105,
-0.06428531557321548,
-1.0856646299362183,
0.044291555881500244,
0.4612860679626465,
0.3960016667842865,
0.11856375634670258,
0.30250048637390137,
-0.18485990166664124,
0.771744430065155,
0.3287874162197113,
-0.20192235708236694,
0.13019856810569763,
-0.13402490317821503,
-0.3774961531162262,
-0.11927340924739838,
0.4751332104206085,
0.169986292719841,
-0.1394725888967514,
0.029449310153722763,
0.041709333658218384,
-0.06536911427974701,
0.3037374019622803,
-0.9325800538063049,
-0.24229241907596588,
-0.1159190833568573,
-0.6370047926902771,
-0.5729193091392517,
-0.11926853656768799,
-0.6977211236953735,
-0.5729941129684448,
-0.07204830646514893,
0.7345386147499084,
-0.353039413690567,
-0.1643105000257492,
-0.004107723943889141,
-0.0021630367264151573,
0.27256426215171814,
0.7106794714927673,
-0.6260802149772644,
0.47890499234199524,
0.6617635488510132,
0.7621222138404846,
-0.4769834578037262,
-0.34180331230163574,
-1.1693100929260254,
0.12321089208126068,
-0.15232527256011963,
0.6531680226325989,
-0.2888701856136322,
-0.22353513538837433,
-0.36844298243522644,
-0.08035889267921448,
-0.23481309413909912,
-0.7336865067481995,
0.6521899104118347,
-0.3118760287761688,
0.044257987290620804,
-0.34036949276924133,
-0.22614434361457825,
-0.2757534384727478,
0.02337145060300827,
-0.7498600482940674,
0.9469045996665955,
0.17363128066062927,
-0.6766666769981384,
0.371930330991745,
-0.9177341461181641,
-0.4862053394317627,
-0.07118478417396545,
-0.02160019986331463,
-0.6711207032203674,
0.4257100522518158,
0.2621344029903412,
0.1256914585828781,
-0.4717848300933838,
-0.25167131423950195,
-0.1682695597410202,
-0.6900973320007324,
-0.0772634819149971,
-0.34497469663619995,
0.4581505060195923,
0.09019914269447327,
-0.3049755394458771,
0.018810445442795753,
-0.9339452385902405,
0.2666645646095276,
0.057858359068632126,
-0.7170636653900146,
-0.27292877435684204,
0.25217968225479126,
0.10318021476268768,
-0.05116637051105499,
0.14549291133880615,
-0.42629972100257874,
0.07502896338701248,
-0.541413426399231,
0.7075814604759216,
0.8440778851509094,
0.22653540968894958,
0.4302906095981598,
-0.24611733853816986,
0.4232895076274872,
-0.07635665684938431,
0.5599514245986938,
0.3299882411956787,
-0.33985885977745056,
-0.9285966753959656,
-0.34920719265937805,
0.6115177869796753,
0.1818271428346634,
-0.4219604432582855,
0.5043326020240784,
-0.09492739289999008,
-0.6201156377792358,
-0.423094242811203,
0.3329848051071167,
0.3882244825363159,
0.6452518105506897,
0.14425447583198547,
-0.23422111570835114,
-0.3054857552051544,
-0.9517412185668945,
-0.22541464865207672,
-0.18941588699817657,
-0.030013246461749077,
0.19917643070220947,
0.29574158787727356,
0.19466643035411835,
0.9712085127830505,
-0.5854353904724121,
-0.5779116749763489,
-0.27345091104507446,
0.0997471809387207,
0.47290199995040894,
0.5447045564651489,
0.6080854535102844,
-0.5209670662879944,
-0.21090982854366302,
0.19485068321228027,
-0.4802494943141937,
0.10747246444225311,
0.2010636180639267,
-0.27631431818008423,
-0.0981219932436943,
0.11445100605487823,
-0.3873637020587921,
0.5787866711616516,
0.7372799515724182,
-0.13532939553260803,
0.2591988742351532,
-0.2958550751209259,
-0.040808070451021194,
-0.764173150062561,
0.3419419527053833,
-0.12398753315210342,
-0.07404975593090057,
-0.48883625864982605,
0.10417594015598297,
-0.1406880021095276,
-0.24445867538452148,
-0.5963541865348816,
0.378765732049942,
-0.27709144353866577,
-0.21197286248207092,
-0.10329899936914444,
-0.10263969749212265,
0.35012906789779663,
0.6660623550415039,
-0.07780356705188751,
0.49761924147605896,
0.014442484825849533,
-0.6516509652137756,
-0.00997926201671362,
0.06204264238476753,
-0.4218166768550873,
0.31428763270378113,
-0.6127730011940002,
0.3932214081287384,
0.27899643778800964,
0.03589525446295738,
-0.3534451723098755,
-0.07166098803281784,
0.21260924637317657,
0.16374655067920685,
-0.14606861770153046,
-0.5563991665840149,
-0.2970926761627197,
-0.1492290049791336,
-0.553503155708313,
0.15891452133655548,
0.7451779246330261,
-0.5578212738037109,
0.6608545780181885,
0.29389750957489014,
0.16093038022518158,
-0.5218802094459534,
-0.5665063261985779,
-0.38753023743629456,
-0.6927192211151123,
-0.2513104975223541,
0.3648032248020172,
-0.27018460631370544,
0.1615014374256134,
-0.0710153579711914,
-0.3000732362270355,
-0.18454024195671082,
0.4404560923576355,
0.5126729607582092,
0.11269490420818329,
-0.24253742396831512,
-0.16907410323619843,
0.16544239223003387,
0.12045972794294357,
-0.022487571462988853,
0.16042682528495789,
0.45454612374305725,
-0.1253765970468521,
-0.5209606289863586,
-0.6108921766281128,
0.11971572786569595,
0.4152725338935852,
-0.23805199563503265,
0.9237803220748901,
0.7904616594314575,
-0.2685736119747162,
-0.5771687030792236,
-0.34268003702163696,
-0.2878222167491913,
-0.5364035964012146,
0.5176353454589844,
-0.3669706881046295,
-0.4383096694946289,
0.5295184254646301,
-0.39779964089393616,
0.25786274671554565,
0.47494831681251526,
0.06585339456796646,
-0.3279886841773987,
0.8224839568138123,
0.891141951084137,
-0.00844387337565422,
0.8099545240402222,
-0.7429554462432861,
0.3636159300804138,
-0.8838273286819458,
0.11832211911678314,
-0.4872555434703827,
-0.728186845779419,
-0.2221815288066864,
-0.23703600466251373,
0.5302467942237854,
0.5471200346946716,
-0.18077901005744934,
0.15255123376846313,
-0.8047535419464111,
0.5553435683250427,
0.5277105569839478,
0.3693741261959076,
0.3632979094982147,
0.2545408010482788,
0.4523279666900635,
0.043938420712947845,
-0.681291937828064,
-0.0496201254427433,
0.8276153206825256,
0.40852609276771545,
0.7573282718658447,
-0.06408457458019257,
0.934751033782959,
0.3795508146286011,
0.16804631054401398,
-1.0301340818405151,
0.6955888271331787,
-0.39567795395851135,
-0.14032107591629028,
-0.634732186794281,
-0.5642891526222229,
-0.8715635538101196,
0.1022399365901947,
-0.08214408159255981,
-0.5651583671569824,
0.34961020946502686,
0.36670953035354614,
-0.7333260178565979,
0.38795074820518494,
-0.738288402557373,
0.7224987149238586,
-0.14352302253246307,
-0.2886652946472168,
-0.50374436378479,
-0.15840858221054077,
0.13120761513710022,
-0.3057909309864044,
0.022678982466459274,
-0.31104862689971924,
-0.174393430352211,
1.2824513912200928,
-0.766059935092926,
0.8242476582527161,
-0.4607395827770233,
-0.238821342587471,
0.32462888956069946,
0.08123014867305756,
0.6530746221542358,
-0.07234489172697067,
-0.3282654881477356,
0.2521072328090668,
0.08563735336065292,
-0.25863879919052124,
-0.8034024834632874,
0.8188697695732117,
-1.1433415412902832,
-0.4626539647579193,
-0.1257140040397644,
-0.3072985112667084,
-0.2999318242073059,
0.07414694875478745,
0.4241560101509094,
0.323580801486969,
-0.12177890539169312,
0.29095932841300964,
0.38044020533561707,
-0.1741260588169098,
0.4771212339401245,
0.36382004618644714,
-0.28566139936447144,
-0.41006338596343994,
1.0678831338882446,
0.41616201400756836,
0.2422885149717331,
0.19465245306491852,
0.4391251504421234,
0.13017688691616058,
-0.954094409942627,
-0.2760734558105469,
0.22145499289035797,
-0.6740682125091553,
-0.3245532214641571,
-0.13807223737239838,
-0.5809563994407654,
0.3377474844455719,
-0.08311355113983154,
-0.6493324637413025,
-0.48784908652305603,
-0.1540057510137558,
0.10284063965082169,
0.6473026871681213,
0.6769329309463501,
0.09447377175092697,
0.6894751191139221,
-0.630041778087616,
0.4357278645038605,
0.5187103748321533,
0.3794078528881073,
-0.11198526620864868,
-0.7401021122932434,
-0.45393264293670654,
-0.06845022737979889,
-0.12918305397033691,
-0.5510006546974182,
0.3124314546585083,
0.6717296838760376,
0.3435031473636627,
0.4595784842967987,
0.24803513288497925,
0.8423771262168884,
-0.2551848888397217,
0.6185203194618225,
0.2655699849128723,
-0.9511599540710449,
0.8792246580123901,
-0.3896458148956299,
0.2313612550497055,
0.6384614706039429,
-0.2742018401622772,
-0.03455226868391037,
0.0939168706536293,
-0.5106234550476074,
-0.967003345489502,
0.9506116509437561,
0.15504595637321472,
-0.20900583267211914,
0.40510669350624084,
0.3942427337169647,
0.2543017864227295,
0.2164524495601654,
-0.5519554018974304,
-0.034285809844732285,
0.042356692254543304,
0.046320926398038864,
0.14090563356876373,
-0.11190661787986755,
-0.33237165212631226,
-0.3813498318195343,
0.539604902267456,
-0.18567126989364624,
0.07199878990650177,
-0.1795559674501419,
-0.15456674993038177,
-0.2580631673336029,
0.14907866716384888,
0.08989040553569794,
0.9178552031517029,
-0.4733673930168152,
-0.09101907908916473,
0.412141352891922,
-0.5068557858467102,
-0.09205902367830276,
-0.32786405086517334,
-0.4193573594093323,
-0.07951603829860687,
0.15625916421413422,
0.8159807324409485,
0.23158271610736847,
-0.5518472790718079,
0.2702472507953644,
0.19047924876213074,
-0.25687462091445923,
-0.12996284663677216,
0.27566879987716675,
-0.10255736857652664,
-0.11200226843357086,
0.4345376193523407,
0.3949302136898041,
0.11043096333742142,
-0.4860580265522003,
-0.1801030933856964,
0.1588231325149536,
-0.19745543599128723,
-0.2900990843772888,
0.3018999993801117,
0.5480382442474365,
-0.1673627644777298,
0.5016511678695679,
0.2445365935564041,
-0.026507526636123657,
0.8196132183074951,
0.27300769090652466,
0.6726664304733276,
-0.039103128015995026,
0.2961476147174835,
0.20806744694709778,
0.16563765704631805,
-0.09640967100858688,
0.19268493354320526,
0.0713164359331131,
-0.41024520993232727,
-0.7057726383209229,
-0.9188286662101746,
-0.43681085109710693,
0.499518483877182,
-0.9236190319061279,
0.25610628724098206,
-0.8578331470489502,
-0.39824455976486206,
0.09682808071374893,
0.1935984045267105,
-0.621803879737854,
0.009104283526539803,
0.021698396652936935,
0.7434812784194946,
-0.9007933735847473,
0.9854169487953186,
0.623185932636261,
-0.24498291313648224,
-0.7377328276634216,
-0.12612546980381012,
-0.37092259526252747,
-0.6117373108863831,
0.6758840084075928,
-0.0860079899430275,
-0.41256973147392273,
0.08540444076061249,
-0.3614097833633423,
-0.9860548973083496,
0.9438350796699524,
0.9016393423080444,
-0.5445455312728882,
-0.19218182563781738,
0.04579661786556244,
0.3189334273338318,
-0.18795035779476166,
-0.04333982244133949,
0.6300531625747681,
0.526275098323822,
0.051195550709962845,
-0.9752434492111206,
-0.18224510550498962,
-0.19138094782829285,
0.05901812016963959,
0.37630945444107056,
-0.7878174781799316,
1.042371153831482,
-0.10204590857028961,
-0.1421308070421219,
0.11399830132722855,
0.47449228167533875,
0.2983953356742859,
0.15680788457393646,
0.925530195236206,
0.5348936319351196,
0.6515622138977051,
0.06357815116643906,
0.720302939414978,
-0.15338578820228577,
0.3906554877758026,
1.162371277809143,
-0.3761621415615082,
1.3266572952270508,
0.592860221862793,
-0.28142741322517395,
0.3355850875377655,
0.6138738393783569,
0.021429231390357018,
0.756575882434845,
0.1402701884508133,
0.06868941336870193,
-0.19049851596355438,
-0.18735674023628235,
-0.42066675424575806,
0.5235512256622314,
0.15934208035469055,
-0.13786566257476807,
-0.0714317336678505,
0.0717955008149147,
-0.05673997476696968,
-0.13265961408615112,
-0.5901445150375366,
0.7404165863990784,
0.040537551045417786,
-0.6239849328994751,
0.9967930316925049,
-0.1660289764404297,
0.5553756356239319,
-0.6715706586837769,
-0.17207936942577362,
-0.4570589065551758,
0.528699517250061,
-0.4393670856952667,
-0.19691894948482513,
0.08915823698043823,
0.010860965587198734,
-0.2654550075531006,
-0.09104999154806137,
0.6401808261871338,
0.09862697124481201,
-0.6237784624099731,
0.5455721616744995,
0.7156599164009094,
0.19030340015888214,
-0.22869810461997986,
-0.5350112318992615,
0.40810737013816833,
-0.04152185469865799,
-0.4049469232559204,
0.7031660079956055,
0.1419999897480011,
0.014280708506703377,
0.49821770191192627,
0.5449612736701965,
0.433864563703537,
0.186196431517601,
0.343954861164093,
1.0567749738693237,
-0.571622908115387,
-0.5247346758842468,
-0.5471767783164978,
0.11978454142808914,
-0.11244447529315948,
-0.20844672620296478,
0.555940568447113,
0.37869489192962646,
0.4277016520500183,
0.042617376893758774,
0.6936612725257874,
-0.14810167253017426,
0.551934540271759,
-0.5377668142318726,
0.8214137554168701,
-0.6256454586982727,
0.5193530917167664,
-0.2418539673089981,
-1.1796855926513672,
0.29365774989128113,
0.42724546790122986,
-0.28918319940567017,
0.07554648071527481,
0.7167651057243347,
0.4021793007850647,
-0.32478630542755127,
-0.29841557145118713,
0.41307947039604187,
0.2130700945854187,
-0.06264401227235794,
0.5914064049720764,
0.8328070640563965,
-0.7071738243103027,
0.7714415788650513,
-0.5277726650238037,
-0.11155354976654053,
-0.23468080163002014,
-0.9329400062561035,
-0.7165801525115967,
-0.31052345037460327,
-0.6811772584915161,
-0.0643785297870636,
0.2549571096897125,
0.4067578613758087,
1.1401549577713013,
-0.7383355498313904,
-0.2907033860683441,
0.05865836888551712,
0.043057892471551895,
-0.7492880821228027,
-0.17085379362106323,
0.7017582058906555,
0.15107689797878265,
-0.5822878479957581,
0.6107462048530579,
0.1357467770576477,
-0.4356657564640045,
-0.27252548933029175,
-0.14896436035633087,
-0.13165046274662018,
0.022587625309824944,
0.6044883131980896,
0.3630897104740143,
-0.715607762336731,
-0.3450436294078827,
-0.3812214732170105,
0.35393664240837097,
0.25469037890434265,
0.5315569043159485,
-1.0227073431015015,
-0.2369798719882965,
0.3955296277999878,
0.48510676622390747,
0.63088059425354,
0.1944693624973297,
0.4200614094734192,
-0.910650372505188,
0.21680215001106262,
0.1338912695646286,
0.16986404359340668,
0.10553724318742752,
-0.36446240544319153,
0.7976550459861755,
0.03380454331636429,
-0.3405848443508148,
-1.1030805110931396,
0.0953003391623497,
-1.217880368232727,
-0.12036235630512238,
0.9052793979644775,
-0.24313348531723022,
-0.5731990337371826,
0.3395577073097229,
-0.15714280307292938,
0.14130401611328125,
-0.45762011408805847,
0.7366527915000916,
0.18559357523918152,
-0.17410996556282043,
-0.562238872051239,
-0.4366595149040222,
0.5288097858428955,
0.5702581405639648,
-1.03615140914917,
0.04195776581764221,
0.30321407318115234,
0.284551203250885,
0.2345714122056961,
0.4127768576145172,
0.1306336224079132,
0.16671952605247498,
-0.174589142203331,
-0.08613553643226624,
-0.20960353314876556,
-0.281780481338501,
-0.3297210931777954,
0.6051661372184753,
0.42787015438079834,
-0.4756636321544647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07689v2 | OrderBkd: Textual backdoor attack through repositioning | 2024-02-12T14:53:37 | 2024-04-06T21:41:10 | Irina Alekseevskaia, Konstantin Arkhipenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The use of third-party datasets and pre-trained machine learning models poses
a threat to NLP systems due to possibility of hidden backdoor attacks. Existing
attacks involve poisoning the data samples such as insertion of tokens or
sentence paraphrasing, which either alter the semantics of the original texts
or can be detected. Our main difference from the previous work is that we use
the reposition of a two words in a sentence as a trigger. By designing and
applying specific part-of-speech (POS) based rules for selecting these tokens,
we maintain high attack success rate on SST-2 and AG classification datasets
while outperforming existing attacks in terms of perplexity and semantic
similarity to the clean samples. In addition, we show the robustness of our
attack to the ONION defense method. All the code and data for the paper can be
obtained at https://github.com/alekseevskaia/OrderBkd. | [
0.032605335116386414,
-0.9504003524780273,
0.2997850179672241,
0.13027219474315643,
-0.20125018060207367,
0.13806486129760742,
0.31747934222221375,
-0.41487377882003784,
0.18124860525131226,
0.86375892162323,
-0.354958176612854,
-0.8453450798988342,
-0.6525296568870544,
-0.07012523710727692,
-0.7045132517814636,
0.8805462718009949,
0.1821890026330948,
-0.04663341864943504,
0.1671290099620819,
-0.06423711031675339,
-0.45487281680107117,
-0.7342904210090637,
-0.3408680856227875,
-0.012909159064292908,
0.5893346071243286,
0.33475416898727417,
1.0162572860717773,
0.5639804005622864,
0.5644654631614685,
0.26261183619499207,
0.026647299528121948,
-0.3397659659385681,
-0.10604386031627655,
0.5187800526618958,
-0.6162088513374329,
-0.546775221824646,
-0.17548111081123352,
0.05382588133215904,
0.2631736993789673,
0.33884698152542114,
-0.33287209272384644,
-0.0011584863532334566,
-0.23422914743423462,
0.6930832266807556,
-0.700912594795227,
-0.2153632640838623,
-0.8442845940589905,
0.2965835928916931,
-0.2375466227531433,
-0.042148273438215256,
-0.7708080410957336,
-0.1334259957075119,
0.12895773351192474,
-0.316142201423645,
0.030309922993183136,
0.1725902408361435,
0.9840469360351562,
0.17579540610313416,
0.028638791292905807,
-0.42809590697288513,
-0.23271553218364716,
0.37336093187332153,
-0.6236670017242432,
0.6856220364570618,
0.4458475708961487,
0.027127228677272797,
-0.3846345543861389,
-0.9984919428825378,
-0.5946189761161804,
-0.019950129091739655,
-0.10151226073503494,
0.23638004064559937,
-0.26887404918670654,
-0.11340649425983429,
0.22901996970176697,
0.03243986889719963,
-0.6823373436927795,
0.44642460346221924,
-0.30185404419898987,
-0.02762887254357338,
0.5287988185882568,
0.01076484378427267,
0.5237581133842468,
-0.36964651942253113,
-0.49930933117866516,
-0.3958047330379486,
-0.772930383682251,
-0.12427990883588791,
0.630081295967102,
0.3952534794807434,
0.08674043416976929,
0.8645473122596741,
-0.1500285118818283,
0.43758097290992737,
0.29352641105651855,
0.2682880759239197,
0.33326461911201477,
-0.17049726843833923,
-0.4375481605529785,
0.17355714738368988,
0.6449413895606995,
0.5064753293991089,
-0.24885210394859314,
-0.24838508665561676,
-0.11305645108222961,
0.09263721108436584,
0.7454337477684021,
-0.5412526726722717,
-0.25153836607933044,
0.34953415393829346,
-0.6136361360549927,
-0.6709176301956177,
0.2766604423522949,
-1.062759280204773,
-0.351182758808136,
0.27243930101394653,
0.3203643560409546,
-0.5136310458183289,
-0.12614981830120087,
-0.14444653689861298,
-0.2058207243680954,
0.6872742176055908,
-0.09894048422574997,
-0.8421856164932251,
0.32515352964401245,
1.157010793685913,
0.722970187664032,
-0.06240541487932205,
-0.5000342726707458,
-0.4139043390750885,
0.3068813681602478,
-0.7740063667297363,
0.5797791481018066,
-0.5939049124717712,
-0.3940311670303345,
0.029074011370539665,
0.06240377947688103,
0.12340022623538971,
-0.44563305377960205,
0.5981216430664062,
-0.9380090236663818,
0.4027350842952728,
0.006998248398303986,
-0.43944287300109863,
-0.13312433660030365,
0.15570439398288727,
-0.4291054308414459,
1.1209712028503418,
0.0907718762755394,
-0.9341423511505127,
0.25646957755088806,
-0.39206239581108093,
-0.7097768783569336,
0.22870686650276184,
-0.18541720509529114,
-0.4301614463329315,
0.2053014487028122,
0.09114466607570648,
0.6562383770942688,
0.3301612138748169,
-0.14303499460220337,
-0.144019216299057,
0.013126303441822529,
0.17731499671936035,
-0.17466595768928528,
0.9592236876487732,
0.4372662901878357,
-0.31883424520492554,
-0.03864714503288269,
-0.5864030122756958,
0.18489858508110046,
0.21047870814800262,
-0.15973666310310364,
-0.6796960830688477,
0.15560635924339294,
-0.24021019041538239,
0.27571338415145874,
0.07082366943359375,
-0.5932215452194214,
0.2860346734523773,
-1.0501558780670166,
0.29819121956825256,
0.8280900120735168,
0.14286155998706818,
0.604922890663147,
-0.04716930165886879,
0.6268460750579834,
-0.059309910982847214,
0.39771685004234314,
-0.19541090726852417,
-0.7366170883178711,
-0.04738718271255493,
-0.0550057478249073,
0.4226236343383789,
1.0382115840911865,
-1.0104773044586182,
0.5675508379936218,
-0.04127131402492523,
-0.5791301727294922,
-0.4796890914440155,
-0.12912796437740326,
0.5607910752296448,
0.4739333391189575,
0.36879709362983704,
-0.024165945127606392,
-0.3137534260749817,
-0.9242334365844727,
-0.41279035806655884,
-0.25113245844841003,
-0.26672089099884033,
-0.09219515323638916,
0.4734739363193512,
-0.2820465862751007,
0.8950095772743225,
-0.7804942727088928,
-0.1144585832953453,
0.0016545612597838044,
0.042623285204172134,
0.0639534592628479,
0.50721675157547,
0.49352142214775085,
-1.0186001062393188,
-0.5600171685218811,
-0.1576191782951355,
-0.7378992438316345,
-0.3741649389266968,
0.12420941889286041,
-0.21425046026706696,
0.45059171319007874,
0.8867720365524292,
-0.6766622066497803,
0.755265474319458,
0.4993213713169098,
-0.46756717562675476,
0.5008125901222229,
-0.10986994951963425,
-0.0032548706512898207,
-1.4721232652664185,
-0.5102151036262512,
-0.40799978375434875,
0.02217678353190422,
-0.7423521876335144,
0.5126835107803345,
0.11172349750995636,
-0.33349475264549255,
-0.6720461249351501,
0.2122654914855957,
-0.16040949523448944,
-0.05767161399126053,
-0.06146132946014404,
0.10927668958902359,
-0.05121200159192085,
0.38529378175735474,
-0.30700501799583435,
0.3809177279472351,
0.4150274097919464,
-0.3048594892024994,
0.5864059925079346,
0.5082595944404602,
-0.4142819344997406,
0.7795249819755554,
-0.4898018538951874,
0.33428215980529785,
0.2232915163040161,
0.34220677614212036,
-1.1258553266525269,
-0.08873072266578674,
0.9720362424850464,
-0.7998452186584473,
0.49555689096450806,
-0.12271487712860107,
-0.7157953977584839,
-0.3241193890571594,
-0.3906971514225006,
0.07310429215431213,
0.35675448179244995,
-0.5124732255935669,
0.6413798332214355,
0.3310755491256714,
-0.46891069412231445,
-0.8058531880378723,
-0.8256886601448059,
0.3660151958465576,
-0.15833662450313568,
-0.6432973742485046,
0.5781583189964294,
0.1878148913383484,
-0.31123867630958557,
0.010604048147797585,
-0.16986694931983948,
0.0316530279815197,
0.22250834107398987,
0.5232535004615784,
-0.07686654478311539,
-0.10208731144666672,
0.005368542857468128,
0.14126989245414734,
-0.29349425435066223,
0.172119602560997,
-0.4653959274291992,
0.5187591314315796,
0.31846168637275696,
-0.48470550775527954,
-0.6124979257583618,
0.7773635387420654,
0.40141135454177856,
0.004789216909557581,
0.8313449025154114,
0.2454490065574646,
-0.2815377414226532,
-0.18745562434196472,
-0.23689933121204376,
-0.16796483099460602,
-0.5127747058868408,
0.5177227854728699,
-0.32577499747276306,
-0.1927623599767685,
0.21215642988681793,
0.23045657575130463,
0.21473833918571472,
0.25424984097480774,
0.3664645850658417,
-0.2923312783241272,
0.8530969023704529,
0.5290369391441345,
-0.04803778603672981,
0.46849656105041504,
-0.023557940497994423,
0.21826273202896118,
-0.5339530110359192,
-0.20071539282798767,
-0.6159670352935791,
-0.20570282638072968,
-0.8074833154678345,
-0.04108285903930664,
-0.4452291429042816,
0.02434384636580944,
0.05750821530818939,
0.5169804692268372,
-0.5739553570747375,
0.5462368130683899,
0.5141519904136658,
0.28394031524658203,
-0.23515138030052185,
0.06777797639369965,
-0.43183594942092896,
0.058697376400232315,
-0.5210431218147278,
-0.38559243083000183,
1.0109528303146362,
0.36329442262649536,
0.7076478600502014,
0.17212319374084473,
0.7012845873832703,
0.4791816174983978,
0.05920608714222908,
-0.6546021103858948,
0.7015715837478638,
-0.3298431932926178,
-0.5958280563354492,
-0.369425505399704,
-0.12164121866226196,
-1.0623666048049927,
0.14915472269058228,
0.028146935626864433,
-0.7224427461624146,
0.24235257506370544,
-0.33988162875175476,
-0.27320194244384766,
0.2874191105365753,
-1.1370024681091309,
0.7318805456161499,
-0.29307571053504944,
-0.09474921226501465,
0.03689758852124214,
-0.9609743356704712,
-0.21022562682628632,
-0.16264192759990692,
0.22224730253219604,
0.28192415833473206,
-0.09413564205169678,
1.1444908380508423,
-0.6386948227882385,
0.6801463961601257,
-0.4821368455886841,
-0.33640873432159424,
-0.03728504851460457,
0.12378507107496262,
0.7208301424980164,
-0.13982151448726654,
0.07561496645212173,
0.2923855781555176,
-0.06115008145570755,
-0.47501760721206665,
-0.6697699427604675,
0.5171911120414734,
-0.4374852180480957,
-0.9073826670646667,
-0.515214741230011,
-0.21341387927532196,
-0.013823243789374828,
0.24162621796131134,
0.6252924799919128,
0.2902884781360626,
0.22229748964309692,
0.5431600213050842,
0.5341370701789856,
-0.57568359375,
0.5635194778442383,
0.5480008721351624,
-0.19771119952201843,
-0.729681670665741,
0.7986977100372314,
0.4323897659778595,
0.28382349014282227,
0.6158525943756104,
0.22623685002326965,
-0.23682783544063568,
-0.8384705185890198,
-0.05874553322792053,
-0.04713931307196617,
-0.6510945558547974,
-0.3566332459449768,
-0.6104025840759277,
-0.2134961187839508,
-0.8417894840240479,
-0.3906414210796356,
-0.3830822706222534,
-0.3274197578430176,
-0.09834855794906616,
-0.44718313217163086,
0.1794448047876358,
0.6493955850601196,
0.1003945991396904,
0.6366721391677856,
-0.6247417330741882,
0.45153599977493286,
0.12887391448020935,
0.40212127566337585,
-0.21381066739559174,
-0.47719788551330566,
-0.22693446278572083,
-0.09360895305871964,
-0.3632521331310272,
-1.357201099395752,
0.49333739280700684,
-0.34444472193717957,
0.4913356602191925,
0.206410750746727,
0.4109836220741272,
0.22542829811573029,
-0.6226325631141663,
0.8591105341911316,
0.10421691834926605,
-0.6750669479370117,
0.5396295189857483,
-0.16244246065616608,
0.1528448760509491,
0.3747731149196625,
0.3139215409755707,
-0.49910226464271545,
-0.6161322593688965,
-0.9405096173286438,
-1.2479435205459595,
0.8123076558113098,
0.42296916246414185,
0.045708030462265015,
0.06765609979629517,
0.3866962790489197,
0.14275231957435608,
0.1750519722700119,
-0.5849489569664001,
-0.3883613049983978,
-0.3232615888118744,
-0.35727614164352417,
0.2391599714756012,
-0.47085028886795044,
0.022189153358340263,
0.19330884516239166,
0.8198509812355042,
0.4265919625759125,
0.19466401636600494,
0.2499678134918213,
-0.1949280947446823,
0.24215608835220337,
0.24117399752140045,
0.503916323184967,
0.5338536500930786,
0.036073002964258194,
-0.15629689395427704,
0.09141816943883896,
-0.9243280291557312,
0.14283889532089233,
0.23521804809570312,
-0.3915591835975647,
0.027685344219207764,
0.3884020447731018,
0.2335633486509323,
0.1605154573917389,
-0.1427510678768158,
0.563133716583252,
-0.057003237307071686,
-0.16381612420082092,
-0.24652761220932007,
-0.26204535365104675,
-0.3391852080821991,
0.5374533534049988,
0.6463550329208374,
-0.14036515355110168,
-0.1886642724275589,
-0.322658509016037,
0.6601957082748413,
0.2744595408439636,
-0.34216243028640747,
-0.21480868756771088,
0.36587706208229065,
0.006971932016313076,
-0.9559634327888489,
0.6053415536880493,
0.005633439403027296,
-0.8127316832542419,
0.49191638827323914,
0.5083875060081482,
1.043728232383728,
-0.751160740852356,
0.25235310196876526,
-0.3928295075893402,
0.6082826852798462,
0.23611976206302643,
0.13854552805423737,
0.0850953608751297,
-0.7691740393638611,
-0.05538279935717583,
-0.4184408187866211,
-0.27359315752983093,
0.21159479022026062,
-0.6020035147666931,
0.32914218306541443,
-0.7702199816703796,
0.05454342067241669,
0.07431583106517792,
-0.13918383419513702,
-0.018266674131155014,
0.11066674441099167,
-0.07512232661247253,
0.8096017837524414,
-0.7209540605545044,
0.7076665759086609,
0.46782517433166504,
-0.25679901242256165,
-0.48115456104278564,
0.31363072991371155,
-0.11688021570444107,
-0.7028936147689819,
0.7670382857322693,
0.08784610778093338,
0.11197070777416229,
-0.08191444724798203,
-0.7555602192878723,
-0.51054847240448,
0.731852114200592,
0.054658886045217514,
-0.26497113704681396,
-0.1773768812417984,
-0.0586714893579483,
0.40613603591918945,
-0.0971735417842865,
-0.3631645739078522,
0.19036103785037994,
0.26991456747055054,
-0.07029099017381668,
-0.41114166378974915,
0.014798582531511784,
-0.16014251112937927,
-0.1710241287946701,
0.3780427575111389,
-0.3318656086921692,
0.7462826371192932,
0.3203224837779999,
-0.2965119183063507,
-0.038098786026239395,
0.67965167760849,
0.15055322647094727,
0.5685684680938721,
0.34599870443344116,
1.0024056434631348,
0.47338181734085083,
-0.09111767262220383,
0.8435999751091003,
0.03998802602291107,
-0.03295360505580902,
1.2783757448196411,
-0.5406947135925293,
1.0940765142440796,
0.4187561273574829,
-0.11961305141448975,
0.5586235523223877,
0.6069924831390381,
-0.3811374306678772,
0.9511832594871521,
0.09510617703199387,
0.23123188316822052,
0.551922082901001,
0.348245769739151,
-0.7519221901893616,
0.5028870105743408,
0.5420204401016235,
-0.4594224989414215,
-0.10391416400671005,
0.37546318769454956,
0.17659005522727966,
0.09064719080924988,
-0.20938128232955933,
0.9904934763908386,
-0.01976916193962097,
-0.38989150524139404,
0.27217939496040344,
0.1834634244441986,
0.4556298553943634,
-0.6042452454566956,
0.10601375252008438,
-0.19726470112800598,
0.27171990275382996,
-0.3873443603515625,
-0.7869965434074402,
0.47727471590042114,
-0.10965137183666229,
-0.1921187937259674,
-0.5094406604766846,
0.5408630967140198,
-0.016989553347229958,
-0.2967039942741394,
0.41627320647239685,
0.006253587082028389,
0.03190040588378906,
-0.12192641943693161,
-0.8071744441986084,
-0.23375414311885834,
-0.1821243017911911,
-0.3228197693824768,
0.3437129855155945,
0.6486090421676636,
0.028186233714222908,
0.42909517884254456,
0.8211172223091125,
0.04431939497590065,
0.23588280379772186,
-0.08734980970621109,
0.6315471529960632,
-0.7577461004257202,
-1.0476710796356201,
-1.1096580028533936,
0.045962218195199966,
-0.21949464082717896,
0.11365583539009094,
1.1743016242980957,
0.6297736763954163,
0.926197350025177,
0.07044381648302078,
0.6222091317176819,
0.011699783615767956,
0.6083239912986755,
-0.6833901405334473,
0.8063228726387024,
-0.12291174381971359,
0.4153170883655548,
-0.8789817690849304,
-0.6645086407661438,
-0.3732023239135742,
0.2736923098564148,
-0.407437801361084,
-0.3131060004234314,
0.9352008700370789,
0.8640275597572327,
0.2995198369026184,
0.27073588967323303,
0.25788435339927673,
0.5980063080787659,
0.40134209394454956,
0.10331219434738159,
0.9815453290939331,
-0.5644224882125854,
0.7444737553596497,
-0.26195985078811646,
-0.22967424988746643,
-0.2124944031238556,
-0.722111701965332,
-0.6439895033836365,
-0.5784282684326172,
-0.32025575637817383,
-0.6672787666320801,
0.29299119114875793,
0.6228004097938538,
0.4582105576992035,
-0.8540365695953369,
0.11696627736091614,
-0.10058419406414032,
0.47313401103019714,
-0.33929580450057983,
-0.2497348189353943,
0.5470408797264099,
-0.08777956664562225,
-0.23308759927749634,
0.42880433797836304,
0.2767595052719116,
0.049899231642484665,
0.028732087463140488,
0.19474872946739197,
-0.7695569396018982,
0.04561880975961685,
0.5823354721069336,
0.1335807889699936,
-0.8264349699020386,
-0.485796719789505,
-0.0484098382294178,
-0.0886031910777092,
-0.10341589152812958,
0.536300539970398,
-0.7236369252204895,
0.15552181005477905,
0.6806706190109253,
0.9047976732254028,
-0.10256273299455643,
0.24486373364925385,
0.5593863129615784,
-1.0570406913757324,
0.2505556046962738,
0.14768335223197937,
0.039319831877946854,
0.11986314505338669,
-0.6352130770683289,
0.425391286611557,
0.47264793515205383,
-0.41839101910591125,
-1.046386480331421,
0.4917801320552826,
-0.6013211011886597,
-0.8370473384857178,
1.0230669975280762,
-0.18645821511745453,
-0.5214508771896362,
-0.49616241455078125,
-0.28542661666870117,
0.1831330806016922,
-0.4629521369934082,
0.7521631121635437,
0.9506826400756836,
0.29140132665634155,
0.277281254529953,
-0.3153536319732666,
0.32958167791366577,
0.23910923302173615,
-0.6156498193740845,
0.15544824302196503,
0.2559449374675751,
0.08761969953775406,
0.4379946291446686,
0.12862564623355865,
-0.31223180890083313,
0.052498992532491684,
0.1373967081308365,
-0.4315279424190521,
0.033573199063539505,
-0.4349208176136017,
-0.39451125264167786,
0.7329294085502625,
-0.6452825665473938,
-0.6595520377159119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07682v1 | Auxiliary Tasks to Boost Biaffine Semantic Dependency Parsing | 2024-02-12T14:42:33 | 2024-02-12T14:42:33 | Marie Candito | cs.CL | cs.CL | The biaffine parser of Dozat and Manning (2017) was successfully extended to
semantic dependency parsing (SDP) (Dozat and Manning, 2018). Its performance on
graphs is surprisingly high given that, without the constraint of producing a
tree, all arcs for a given sentence are predicted independently from each other
(modulo a shared representation of tokens). To circumvent such an independence
of decision, while retaining the O(n^2) complexity and highly parallelizable
architecture, we propose to use simple auxiliary tasks that introduce some form
of interdependence between arcs. Experiments on the three English acyclic
datasets of SemEval 2015 task 18 (Oepen et al., 2015), and on French deep
syntactic cyclic graphs (Ribeyre et al., 2014) show modest but systematic
performance gains on a near state-of-the-art baseline using transformer-based
contextualized representations. This provides a simple and robust method to
boost SDP performance. | [
-0.5756955146789551,
-0.35493332147598267,
0.6276026964187622,
0.6262732744216919,
0.007777770981192589,
-0.16114740073680878,
-0.1571967452764511,
-0.8273034691810608,
0.3217625916004181,
0.4041174650192261,
-0.7744218707084656,
-0.3185563385486603,
-0.7667290568351746,
0.3795442581176758,
-0.14369510114192963,
0.7880710959434509,
-0.1662774384021759,
0.04798033460974693,
-0.39843499660491943,
-0.3443984389305115,
-0.4691883623600006,
-0.16062529385089874,
-0.4574674963951111,
-0.3291485607624054,
0.681384265422821,
0.6332240104675293,
0.6176526546478271,
0.589634895324707,
0.4565145969390869,
0.38304510712623596,
-0.03369005396962166,
0.20325206220149994,
-0.16349200904369354,
0.2760470509529114,
-0.7011630535125732,
-0.2633276581764221,
-0.21394076943397522,
-0.28957197070121765,
0.3472624123096466,
1.2194368839263916,
0.36164453625679016,
-0.024904968217015266,
0.1485111117362976,
0.702197253704071,
-0.636759877204895,
0.6616243124008179,
-0.7853531241416931,
-0.4854322075843811,
-0.1781950742006302,
0.02833106927573681,
-0.4385036528110504,
0.2644214630126953,
0.14922571182250977,
-0.42847153544425964,
0.4854784607887268,
-0.019777141511440277,
1.0356115102767944,
0.36508235335350037,
-0.6422045826911926,
-0.2355472445487976,
-0.6569469571113586,
0.26194414496421814,
-0.3853202164173126,
0.351076602935791,
0.47276872396469116,
0.1797250211238861,
-0.08438378572463989,
-1.1493611335754395,
-0.5391151309013367,
-0.04622673615813255,
-0.3311171233654022,
-0.055626031011343,
-0.1702551394701004,
0.37510594725608826,
0.3263883888721466,
0.45076102018356323,
-0.017054341733455658,
0.17067968845367432,
-0.2251775711774826,
0.004675900097936392,
0.3770550787448883,
0.20357558131217957,
0.23626792430877686,
-0.3281800150871277,
-0.39138200879096985,
-0.046179983764886856,
-0.6009315848350525,
0.36179304122924805,
0.22384443879127502,
0.40135276317596436,
-0.018704891204833984,
0.9526537656784058,
-0.5946677923202515,
0.4343433380126953,
0.1909327208995819,
0.5287050604820251,
0.31661272048950195,
-0.7568036317825317,
0.13722540438175201,
0.04754484444856644,
0.509696900844574,
0.18072320520877838,
0.08837975561618805,
-0.37204062938690186,
-0.1009279265999794,
0.5402839779853821,
0.14574626088142395,
-0.7285948395729065,
-0.7280666828155518,
0.15447834134101868,
-0.15321889519691467,
0.2477499097585678,
-0.0203706044703722,
-0.3732779026031494,
-0.01244635321199894,
-0.5933754444122314,
0.1644429713487625,
-0.595597505569458,
0.15752674639225006,
0.005073565989732742,
-0.19858141243457794,
-0.16374309360980988,
0.3199016749858856,
-1.1216378211975098,
0.48336169123649597,
0.590539813041687,
0.7535129189491272,
-0.18084120750427246,
-0.44015365839004517,
-0.7862807512283325,
0.4513148069381714,
0.04827151075005531,
1.2150332927703857,
-0.4547443389892578,
-0.06079836189746857,
-0.15958748757839203,
0.5493752360343933,
-0.18476462364196777,
-0.20335446298122406,
0.7924966216087341,
-0.2148544043302536,
-0.1204521656036377,
-0.5979370474815369,
-0.42677614092826843,
-0.2676598131656647,
0.08815384656190872,
-0.7901934385299683,
1.0024266242980957,
0.3863251805305481,
-0.9718542098999023,
0.4344722330570221,
-0.28410661220550537,
-0.6439028978347778,
0.12111341953277588,
-0.3720270097255707,
-0.0026439896319061518,
0.128655806183815,
0.4671110212802887,
0.3740547299385071,
-0.22594422101974487,
-0.05384077504277229,
-0.44133850932121277,
-0.06437797844409943,
-0.46395331621170044,
-0.18539878726005554,
0.8091381192207336,
-0.36511877179145813,
-0.4845476448535919,
0.20965279638767242,
-0.9166498780250549,
-0.114591583609581,
-0.21867364645004272,
-0.18239587545394897,
-0.5947185158729553,
0.11305088549852371,
0.025134125724434853,
0.42359820008277893,
0.16338860988616943,
-0.8506420254707336,
0.25871843099594116,
-0.6938551068305969,
0.28350210189819336,
0.7614511251449585,
0.07038296014070511,
0.3385201394557953,
-0.144093319773674,
0.11687222123146057,
0.11279256641864777,
-0.317048579454422,
-0.24898269772529602,
-0.5505791306495667,
-0.9102835059165955,
-0.5831984281539917,
0.1739937961101532,
0.41491538286209106,
-1.0253475904464722,
0.5890003442764282,
-0.38842520117759705,
-0.34532976150512695,
-0.31899750232696533,
0.2111440747976303,
0.12721993029117584,
0.4881010055541992,
0.568453311920166,
-0.22866585850715637,
-0.565729558467865,
-1.0470952987670898,
-0.07106934487819672,
-0.11438238620758057,
0.09994877129793167,
0.082115039229393,
0.3494461178779602,
-0.3353835940361023,
1.038750410079956,
-0.5169501900672913,
-0.43292978405952454,
-0.2661759555339813,
0.018575433641672134,
0.35196423530578613,
0.5121561288833618,
0.6464875936508179,
-0.5934596061706543,
-0.5802393555641174,
0.12204856425523758,
-0.3905101716518402,
-0.4019773006439209,
0.10223638266324997,
-0.2104760855436325,
-0.03869488835334778,
0.3518071174621582,
-1.0197328329086304,
0.4531542658805847,
0.3953326642513275,
-0.8027869462966919,
0.47929278016090393,
-0.18234936892986298,
-0.1413218080997467,
-0.756162703037262,
-0.024706942960619926,
-0.3471207320690155,
-0.5119015574455261,
-0.5098481774330139,
-0.2023748755455017,
-0.0616961345076561,
0.2183460146188736,
-0.3913944661617279,
0.20632657408714294,
-0.4072282314300537,
-0.09070014208555222,
-0.25051403045654297,
-0.27809444069862366,
0.3407910168170929,
0.7020904421806335,
0.14147333800792694,
0.5856002569198608,
0.4631110429763794,
-0.47030070424079895,
0.22658447921276093,
0.4032087028026581,
-0.055600591003894806,
0.3779101073741913,
-0.8655836582183838,
-0.09915772825479507,
-0.2301752120256424,
0.21012026071548462,
-1.1774532794952393,
-0.17591626942157745,
0.15578170120716095,
-0.14023567736148834,
0.08319176733493805,
-0.23156216740608215,
-0.6746332049369812,
-0.10006266087293625,
-0.20463833212852478,
0.4236006736755371,
-0.07103124260902405,
-0.879289984703064,
0.5848355293273926,
0.1050950288772583,
-0.2637328803539276,
-0.36213773488998413,
-0.5389583110809326,
-0.12405940890312195,
0.1808847188949585,
-0.9967182278633118,
0.6839374303817749,
0.40371325612068176,
-0.2336173802614212,
0.4151836633682251,
-0.11639730632305145,
0.19469141960144043,
-0.08457431942224503,
0.3843643367290497,
0.3881355822086334,
-0.11153838038444519,
-0.0027341535314917564,
0.22912158071994781,
-0.3824542760848999,
0.06761141866445541,
-0.19467046856880188,
0.6779961585998535,
-0.273523211479187,
-0.582941472530365,
-0.2956888675689697,
0.7009312510490417,
0.4947512447834015,
-0.09396594762802124,
0.5671642422676086,
0.38596799969673157,
-0.33859023451805115,
-0.15774892270565033,
-0.3228232264518738,
0.11626662313938141,
-0.5285589694976807,
0.25392434000968933,
-0.4723176658153534,
-0.7023362517356873,
0.42544350028038025,
-0.0741107240319252,
0.12190333753824234,
0.6008668541908264,
0.6555330157279968,
0.03509976714849472,
1.1328098773956299,
0.44481733441352844,
0.2323257476091385,
0.3749588429927826,
-0.40558508038520813,
0.15914705395698547,
-0.6702845692634583,
-0.1348435878753662,
-0.6061317920684814,
-0.2013951539993286,
-0.629831850528717,
-0.46516820788383484,
0.22518646717071533,
0.34160080552101135,
-0.04030556604266167,
0.5968618988990784,
-0.3413363993167877,
0.2601885497570038,
0.49063804745674133,
-0.05646231770515442,
0.3408465087413788,
-0.00645257206633687,
-0.26954448223114014,
0.2248900979757309,
-0.6780154705047607,
-0.2816299498081207,
0.7478082776069641,
0.1656351089477539,
0.2627808153629303,
0.05956822633743286,
0.6385919451713562,
0.17400969564914703,
-0.038098711520433426,
-0.7025048136711121,
0.4105440080165863,
-0.4312463402748108,
-0.13840851187705994,
-0.17106270790100098,
-0.25908416509628296,
-1.0178577899932861,
0.39866459369659424,
-0.05296824127435684,
-1.0189405679702759,
0.73878413438797,
0.007891631685197353,
0.05050390958786011,
0.007177474908530712,
-0.9475698471069336,
0.8303920030593872,
0.20918065309524536,
-0.6246808171272278,
-0.2578210234642029,
-0.6359399557113647,
0.13702994585037231,
0.5947240591049194,
-0.008947481401264668,
-0.46073678135871887,
0.04130307585000992,
0.36739760637283325,
-0.7726319432258606,
0.6943238377571106,
-0.23554383218288422,
0.34591570496559143,
0.23075537383556366,
-0.10915041714906693,
0.8295075297355652,
0.32915815711021423,
0.1373111456632614,
0.16646763682365417,
0.392055869102478,
-0.6333907842636108,
-0.44889208674430847,
0.8658409118652344,
-0.5883227586746216,
-0.5458269715309143,
-0.41860321164131165,
-0.6527577638626099,
-0.5777564644813538,
0.2422202229499817,
0.22123144567012787,
0.5007942318916321,
-0.0750046893954277,
0.11318207532167435,
0.14864225685596466,
0.4417606294155121,
0.8391236066818237,
0.009554795920848846,
-0.038960106670856476,
-0.3443165719509125,
0.7069545388221741,
0.0739295482635498,
0.3543314039707184,
0.13593778014183044,
-0.051361050456762314,
-0.30021461844444275,
-0.36416566371917725,
-0.6222877502441406,
0.341270387172699,
-0.888193666934967,
-0.22534368932247162,
-0.921164870262146,
-0.053345609456300735,
-0.5297812223434448,
-0.17705704271793365,
-0.3564337491989136,
-0.9985594749450684,
-0.1182374507188797,
-0.3103026747703552,
0.48262128233909607,
0.6102007627487183,
-0.10303991287946701,
0.18052907288074493,
-0.7026175260543823,
0.46329471468925476,
0.27227070927619934,
0.23877480626106262,
-0.07678814977407455,
0.3358032703399658,
-0.12240123003721237,
-0.080155149102211,
-0.31694671511650085,
-0.6919527053833008,
0.025577252730727196,
0.1918395459651947,
0.504048764705658,
0.4435131847858429,
0.18778552114963531,
0.6458179354667664,
-0.5890966653823853,
0.6540845036506653,
0.31998807191848755,
-0.8602132797241211,
0.2266162484884262,
-0.2557148337364197,
0.33478987216949463,
1.1141011714935303,
0.2706344425678253,
-0.27872443199157715,
-0.4110327661037445,
-0.5706861019134521,
-1.2017558813095093,
0.9159084558486938,
0.39448297023773193,
0.00006886314804432914,
-0.3213787078857422,
-0.050528109073638916,
0.18435324728488922,
-0.07240323722362518,
-0.476287305355072,
-0.1726049929857254,
-0.21185559034347534,
-0.2969582974910736,
0.09572326391935349,
-0.1810435652732849,
-0.01309316884726286,
-0.5366013050079346,
0.516701340675354,
-0.17339137196540833,
0.010086936876177788,
0.4954339265823364,
-0.018761366605758667,
0.23191866278648376,
0.06855779886245728,
-0.06301368772983551,
0.5836265087127686,
0.0030565038323402405,
0.5799922943115234,
0.041349299252033234,
-0.43206989765167236,
0.1506185382604599,
0.43233516812324524,
-0.20488575100898743,
0.23892736434936523,
0.7184985280036926,
0.8052101135253906,
0.19846367835998535,
-0.7131986618041992,
0.5699992179870605,
0.07490397989749908,
0.06405609101057053,
-0.31692805886268616,
-0.08861634880304337,
0.2676410675048828,
0.19391636550426483,
0.08539009094238281,
0.40693312883377075,
0.2007979303598404,
-0.6092324256896973,
0.362295001745224,
0.2098197638988495,
-0.49432700872421265,
-0.4096866846084595,
0.38189497590065,
0.24920134246349335,
-0.13374339044094086,
0.3927263617515564,
-0.2869313955307007,
-0.471382200717926,
0.44713354110717773,
0.5328413248062134,
0.7401823997497559,
0.04906906560063362,
0.053308017551898956,
0.16177910566329956,
0.09985096007585526,
0.07379862666130066,
0.3382241725921631,
-0.4315957725048065,
-0.7380143404006958,
-0.4587711989879608,
-0.4210892915725708,
-0.07071857154369354,
-0.4669612944126129,
-0.6241217255592346,
0.6294131278991699,
-0.3597929775714874,
0.1754360944032669,
0.22419531643390656,
-0.20663446187973022,
-0.9056718945503235,
-0.11186125874519348,
-0.16336917877197266,
0.9732418656349182,
-0.7885258197784424,
0.90487140417099,
0.7205316424369812,
-0.38039979338645935,
-0.6817235946655273,
0.03839810937643051,
-0.34981825947761536,
-0.5477945804595947,
0.5508674383163452,
0.47728824615478516,
-0.16405248641967773,
-0.08096997439861298,
0.14810533821582794,
-0.8287796378135681,
0.950698971748352,
0.3599424958229065,
-0.42549794912338257,
-0.47396114468574524,
0.38319385051727295,
0.49133357405662537,
-0.5069223642349243,
0.27439892292022705,
0.5898218154907227,
0.33900707960128784,
0.19564908742904663,
-0.7099034190177917,
0.23014473915100098,
-0.38496145606040955,
0.09784329682588577,
0.2762611210346222,
-0.4249163866043091,
0.7945826649665833,
0.10675369203090668,
-0.43051689863204956,
-0.12702862918376923,
0.875891387462616,
0.06319102644920349,
0.46919724345207214,
0.892059862613678,
0.6190829277038574,
0.5235574245452881,
0.06601878255605698,
0.9970377683639526,
-0.41917771100997925,
0.12903103232383728,
1.369950532913208,
-0.3083195388317108,
0.7129656076431274,
0.8647798895835876,
-0.19087010622024536,
0.706430971622467,
0.4867987036705017,
0.13729143142700195,
0.7031325101852417,
-0.17159828543663025,
-0.4665129780769348,
-0.3160589635372162,
-0.40202850103378296,
-0.20159389078617096,
0.5816947817802429,
0.35330134630203247,
-0.29396310448646545,
-0.6281169652938843,
0.06042863428592682,
-0.07448061555624008,
0.23485912382602692,
-0.2196967601776123,
0.7071548700332642,
-0.052471183240413666,
-0.7745846509933472,
0.374992311000824,
-0.03756558895111084,
0.19925977289676666,
-0.6519739031791687,
-0.28377166390419006,
0.21176965534687042,
0.31664642691612244,
-0.3069867789745331,
-0.699661135673523,
0.7694498896598816,
-0.349373996257782,
-0.4325224459171295,
-0.29849347472190857,
0.659622848033905,
-0.2726469039916992,
-0.6682528853416443,
0.6902813911437988,
0.299349844455719,
-0.3964747190475464,
0.05393502116203308,
-0.14244034886360168,
-0.15244603157043457,
-0.10655783861875534,
-0.09081049263477325,
0.19963818788528442,
0.5755887627601624,
-0.15071821212768555,
0.3734089136123657,
0.6447981595993042,
0.08001881092786789,
0.16508206725120544,
-0.09209761023521423,
1.3068022727966309,
-0.23136718571186066,
-0.626162052154541,
-0.6263117790222168,
0.4827406108379364,
-0.23584793508052826,
-0.4160119593143463,
0.7503556609153748,
0.5768049955368042,
1.0078520774841309,
0.13710924983024597,
0.6236850619316101,
-0.45831650495529175,
0.4080827832221985,
-0.6193990111351013,
0.12946194410324097,
-0.14677925407886505,
0.48391810059547424,
-0.1721097230911255,
-0.9608638286590576,
0.030714722350239754,
0.19359757006168365,
-0.3067886531352997,
-0.5329749584197998,
0.9262050986289978,
0.6426924467086792,
-0.2760341465473175,
0.23891058564186096,
-0.01605810411274433,
0.10734425485134125,
0.24935248494148254,
0.591019332408905,
0.8320109844207764,
-0.08658722788095474,
0.4435965120792389,
-0.8387235403060913,
-0.29049262404441833,
0.180312380194664,
-0.6370019316673279,
-0.9320184588432312,
-0.7486979961395264,
-0.13723504543304443,
-0.47731122374534607,
-0.15636207163333893,
1.1750309467315674,
0.48814332485198975,
-0.9067508578300476,
0.006722090765833855,
-0.5374749302864075,
0.19487716257572174,
-0.5133732557296753,
-0.228819340467453,
0.5718939900398254,
-0.6650295853614807,
-0.8071337938308716,
0.5222381949424744,
0.31362414360046387,
-0.4202795624732971,
-0.029410816729068756,
0.2190423309803009,
-0.6569380164146423,
-0.13691407442092896,
0.6042116284370422,
0.09928160905838013,
-0.6386001706123352,
-0.6945847868919373,
-0.21857580542564392,
0.05425242334604263,
0.1804339587688446,
1.1420620679855347,
-0.8125864267349243,
0.21926270425319672,
0.9717525243759155,
0.7405360341072083,
0.8121111989021301,
0.0626613050699234,
0.5921602249145508,
-0.7431363463401794,
0.4273661673069,
0.25244760513305664,
0.7851190567016602,
0.2549239993095398,
-0.45966729521751404,
0.5437677502632141,
0.6318156123161316,
-0.33219146728515625,
-0.6324259638786316,
0.43372011184692383,
-1.1931729316711426,
-0.25267109274864197,
1.0151605606079102,
-0.5301767587661743,
-0.1052388846874237,
-0.5913088321685791,
-0.30331355333328247,
0.11616453528404236,
-0.17457571625709534,
0.39125803112983704,
0.5953627228736877,
-0.5151938796043396,
-0.07268566638231277,
-0.09787867218255997,
0.3936017155647278,
0.5214982032775879,
-0.7201827764511108,
0.23226617276668549,
0.5693380832672119,
0.11137263476848602,
0.14421416819095612,
0.4914449155330658,
0.030397219583392143,
0.3187451660633087,
0.15071174502372742,
-0.1420365571975708,
-0.27129513025283813,
-0.37577030062675476,
0.03860580176115036,
0.30668190121650696,
-0.04640078544616699,
-0.27598822116851807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07681v1 | Large Language Models "Ad Referendum": How Good Are They at Machine Translation in the Legal Domain? | 2024-02-12T14:40:54 | 2024-02-12T14:40:54 | Vicent Briva-Iglesias, Joao Lucas Cavalheiro Camargo, Gokhan Dogru | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study evaluates the machine translation (MT) quality of two
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) against a tradition-al neural
machine translation (NMT) system across four language pairs in the legal
domain. It combines automatic evaluation met-rics (AEMs) and human evaluation
(HE) by professional transla-tors to assess translation ranking, fluency and
adequacy. The re-sults indicate that while Google Translate generally
outperforms LLMs in AEMs, human evaluators rate LLMs, especially GPT-4,
comparably or slightly better in terms of producing contextually adequate and
fluent translations. This discrepancy suggests LLMs' potential in handling
specialized legal terminology and context, highlighting the importance of human
evaluation methods in assessing MT quality. The study underscores the evolving
capabil-ities of LLMs in specialized domains and calls for reevaluation of
traditional AEMs to better capture the nuances of LLM-generated translations. | [
-0.19292618334293365,
-0.6862359046936035,
0.6194642186164856,
0.021101336926221848,
-0.6211695075035095,
0.33450740575790405,
-0.457339882850647,
-0.35290881991386414,
0.15297040343284607,
0.6443320512771606,
0.1424584984779358,
-0.5925121307373047,
-0.8425971865653992,
0.316724568605423,
-0.6399996280670166,
0.8405987620353699,
-0.22418735921382904,
0.6318444013595581,
-0.17688114941120148,
-0.38724130392074585,
-0.3272641897201538,
-0.7972636222839355,
-0.7302935719490051,
-0.42512813210487366,
0.3239942789077759,
-0.15588438510894775,
0.8780570030212402,
0.6053183674812317,
0.7105353474617004,
0.3325153589248657,
-0.2326745241880417,
0.08900044113397598,
-0.27601227164268494,
0.07311549782752991,
-0.07796227931976318,
-0.3992452621459961,
-0.767159640789032,
0.30839261412620544,
0.6858376264572144,
0.5712820887565613,
-0.2947104871273041,
0.16469451785087585,
-0.05590708181262016,
0.7682613134384155,
-0.46752533316612244,
-0.12265220284461975,
-0.7204923629760742,
0.03720377758145332,
-0.11788981407880783,
-0.19824041426181793,
-0.495198130607605,
-0.45853790640830994,
0.11339496821165085,
-0.292036235332489,
0.02809968963265419,
0.19764792919158936,
0.8846725821495056,
0.33200252056121826,
-0.8674119114875793,
-0.3484960198402405,
-0.6745744943618774,
0.6668004989624023,
-0.9602585434913635,
0.4938722848892212,
0.20644521713256836,
0.31299829483032227,
-0.31943464279174805,
-0.761929452419281,
-0.484453946352005,
-0.7480658888816833,
0.2770785093307495,
0.12682592868804932,
-0.14706282317638397,
0.0882657989859581,
0.03327798843383789,
0.3206160366535187,
-0.587790310382843,
0.42277175188064575,
-0.3390207588672638,
-0.30612319707870483,
0.7104805111885071,
0.308219850063324,
0.23578307032585144,
-0.07983440160751343,
-0.2101064920425415,
0.027330927550792694,
-1.0025638341903687,
-0.026612503454089165,
0.6119252443313599,
0.32170429825782776,
0.22813400626182556,
0.6454902291297913,
0.050886113196611404,
0.7393825054168701,
-0.1691027134656906,
-0.08511854708194733,
0.19728393852710724,
-0.450696736574173,
-0.3694198727607727,
-0.08790335059165955,
1.1439168453216553,
0.4849150478839874,
0.22808490693569183,
-0.2321101278066635,
-0.7083636522293091,
-0.10629379749298096,
0.2849350869655609,
-0.6881422400474548,
0.16747434437274933,
0.12734799087047577,
-0.6558020710945129,
-0.17673571407794952,
0.18101422488689423,
-0.48486021161079407,
-0.4009719491004944,
-0.7249776721000671,
0.4871523678302765,
-0.04175238311290741,
-0.08351080119609833,
0.48238784074783325,
0.07752534747123718,
0.20503629744052887,
0.37861794233322144,
-0.49758294224739075,
0.3327314853668213,
0.8724149465560913,
0.5975825190544128,
-0.3029670715332031,
-0.022993654012680054,
-0.4841519594192505,
-0.2040022760629654,
-0.5907739400863647,
0.4992653429508209,
-0.31936028599739075,
-0.2480141818523407,
0.26702895760536194,
-0.0465233139693737,
-0.10785474628210068,
-0.7916051745414734,
0.8280864357948303,
-1.0006427764892578,
0.2235446274280548,
-0.11427638679742813,
-0.41097646951675415,
-0.3520433008670807,
0.4231148958206177,
-0.700263500213623,
0.6373828053474426,
-0.10135858505964279,
-0.33405059576034546,
0.7178056240081787,
-0.6588899493217468,
-0.6741338968276978,
0.1888299435377121,
-0.09156865626573563,
-0.42263057827949524,
0.12042101472616196,
0.006201843731105328,
0.3435462415218353,
-0.6409307718276978,
0.4667614996433258,
-0.24177010357379913,
-0.24427522718906403,
0.437612920999527,
-0.5856748223304749,
0.7922982573509216,
0.4930133521556854,
-0.33774545788764954,
0.40034499764442444,
-0.4395235478878021,
-0.0691104382276535,
0.009630427695810795,
-0.7484521269798279,
-0.17406527698040009,
0.04587035998702049,
0.12502369284629822,
0.5800380110740662,
0.2367420643568039,
-0.4319370687007904,
0.13001561164855957,
-0.4717817008495331,
0.8913819193840027,
0.43340855836868286,
-0.07057022303342819,
0.2939809560775757,
0.0079434709623456,
0.7987762093544006,
-0.15968330204486847,
0.03742038831114769,
0.40167200565338135,
-0.6512484550476074,
-0.6591243743896484,
-0.09217967092990875,
0.8270041942596436,
0.5512374639511108,
-0.5289475917816162,
0.4576879143714905,
-0.678491473197937,
-0.3197934627532959,
-0.7887988686561584,
0.15585285425186157,
0.2585466206073761,
-0.07165440171957016,
0.07586732506752014,
-0.5652644038200378,
-0.24631667137145996,
-1.0184201002120972,
-0.2903611660003662,
-0.16396459937095642,
0.06908248364925385,
0.28932422399520874,
0.7473070621490479,
-0.3673679530620575,
0.7374855875968933,
0.2500901222229004,
-0.21360696852207184,
-0.09324894845485687,
0.272461861371994,
0.23228639364242554,
0.012342695146799088,
0.5106518268585205,
-0.8589208126068115,
-0.4711724817752838,
0.3225772976875305,
-0.4116533696651459,
-0.020421532914042473,
-0.06550280749797821,
0.21964257955551147,
0.3733680248260498,
0.23730535805225372,
-0.7436959147453308,
0.25332319736480713,
0.4616451561450958,
-0.3671809136867523,
0.6448494791984558,
-0.5026878118515015,
0.7581606507301331,
-0.9274658560752869,
0.30851978063583374,
-0.20650614798069,
-0.44072654843330383,
-0.3056887686252594,
0.3100923001766205,
0.07302819937467575,
0.11046148091554642,
-0.7010759115219116,
0.323703408241272,
-0.5110067129135132,
-0.5186193585395813,
-0.43340784311294556,
0.33885741233825684,
-0.06698676198720932,
-0.03459188714623451,
-0.3573567569255829,
1.089135766029358,
0.09505454450845718,
-0.5537545680999756,
0.8544905185699463,
0.2652612626552582,
-0.45494088530540466,
0.5277863144874573,
-0.4127632677555084,
0.2838205099105835,
0.11335714161396027,
0.22781401872634888,
-0.9043015837669373,
-0.20968739688396454,
0.2148333638906479,
-0.5816349387168884,
0.39521023631095886,
-0.1551484912633896,
-0.8416754007339478,
-0.527167797088623,
-0.08183054625988007,
0.16772611439228058,
0.4402559995651245,
-0.10040031373500824,
0.38487184047698975,
0.5460067987442017,
-0.053474970161914825,
-0.785423755645752,
-0.7095623016357422,
0.9245559573173523,
-0.3804616928100586,
-0.5854498147964478,
-0.08441931009292603,
0.3269781172275543,
-0.3901309370994568,
0.12465722858905792,
0.20401938259601593,
-0.23948927223682404,
0.23777391016483307,
-0.11392184346914291,
0.00505077326670289,
-0.48550111055374146,
-0.12585671246051788,
0.01825411431491375,
-0.004848053213208914,
0.4554250240325928,
-0.34224238991737366,
0.4210490882396698,
-0.20459319651126862,
-0.4457250237464905,
-0.39927202463150024,
0.1126917153596878,
1.0986696481704712,
-0.3429691195487976,
0.5192484855651855,
0.2778196334838867,
-0.36625155806541443,
0.19085483253002167,
-0.6104020476341248,
0.026141120120882988,
-0.35792598128318787,
0.4790511429309845,
-0.549247682094574,
-0.8845187425613403,
0.6596873998641968,
-0.09928859025239944,
0.14607393741607666,
0.9236170649528503,
0.8917369246482849,
0.061755597591400146,
1.1094388961791992,
0.20589208602905273,
-0.2861221730709076,
0.17734584212303162,
-0.16229228675365448,
0.3094889223575592,
-0.6135433912277222,
-0.08234234899282455,
-0.6215807199478149,
-0.31997838616371155,
-0.5835103988647461,
-0.3075812757015228,
0.288590669631958,
-0.02108708955347538,
-0.11575482040643692,
0.6057603359222412,
-0.18732112646102905,
0.26722171902656555,
0.440557599067688,
-0.06251548230648041,
0.4777020514011383,
0.14551350474357605,
-0.35445258021354675,
-0.21541869640350342,
-0.6143962740898132,
-1.0939860343933105,
1.2139036655426025,
0.5602545738220215,
0.4859466254711151,
0.2435254454612732,
0.35666540265083313,
0.4745027720928192,
0.5305945873260498,
-1.091457486152649,
0.6160567402839661,
-0.46036604046821594,
-0.8064638376235962,
-0.21231098473072052,
-0.5860990285873413,
-1.06609046459198,
0.34767359495162964,
-0.3039979934692383,
-0.3278783857822418,
-0.09669944643974304,
-0.07426772266626358,
-0.4556368589401245,
0.4371276795864105,
-0.269533634185791,
0.8424537777900696,
-0.5734379887580872,
-0.42354851961135864,
-0.6050627827644348,
-0.585961639881134,
0.2591209411621094,
-0.3899926543235779,
0.21460087597370148,
0.022707432508468628,
-0.3595038652420044,
0.8134608864784241,
-0.16033005714416504,
0.4487047791481018,
0.08938025683164597,
-0.29029834270477295,
0.3332001566886902,
0.2363351583480835,
0.36962899565696716,
-0.24649687111377716,
-0.37659338116645813,
0.11958188563585281,
0.05321463197469711,
-0.024477148428559303,
-0.5440745949745178,
0.6232017874717712,
-0.6746566891670227,
-0.6485449075698853,
-0.41172686219215393,
-0.40139877796173096,
0.07032960653305054,
0.28343307971954346,
0.2179933786392212,
0.2120029479265213,
-0.3752053380012512,
0.3928493857383728,
0.3717271387577057,
-0.19773779809474945,
0.02580101415514946,
0.7629038095474243,
-0.10702523589134216,
-0.8975239396095276,
0.7725273370742798,
0.14162804186344147,
0.19242118299007416,
0.18145939707756042,
0.19585411250591278,
-0.7113217115402222,
-0.9538913369178772,
-0.9601219296455383,
0.24263396859169006,
-0.7982510328292847,
-0.16254614293575287,
-0.4434160590171814,
-0.18389782309532166,
-0.37364864349365234,
0.07301739603281021,
-0.41770032048225403,
-0.3716878294944763,
-0.16515043377876282,
0.12000717967748642,
-0.011005950160324574,
1.083927035331726,
0.24538271129131317,
0.18762017786502838,
-0.7711166739463806,
0.16259250044822693,
0.050670918077230453,
0.24002625048160553,
-0.5976911783218384,
-1.084276556968689,
-0.10475858300924301,
0.14880600571632385,
-0.32518747448921204,
-0.6638985276222229,
0.396593302488327,
-0.25309133529663086,
0.6663166284561157,
0.4785858690738678,
-0.2652361989021301,
0.40490204095840454,
-0.6587302088737488,
0.906978964805603,
0.24122636020183563,
-0.8548468947410583,
-0.015457754023373127,
-0.4517028033733368,
-0.23398567736148834,
0.6622342467308044,
0.214173823595047,
-0.5672088861465454,
-0.388827383518219,
-0.37774044275283813,
-0.8688102960586548,
0.42205262184143066,
0.030833467841148376,
0.4535498321056366,
0.13088497519493103,
0.6159803867340088,
-0.02940288931131363,
0.5076659321784973,
-0.7538102865219116,
-0.004019399173557758,
0.4284754693508148,
-0.10233879089355469,
-0.0996575653553009,
-0.39710187911987305,
-0.06308913975954056,
-0.19575557112693787,
0.6937423944473267,
0.28468969464302063,
0.029381390661001205,
-0.07610409706830978,
-0.14669620990753174,
-0.25942882895469666,
0.5153682231903076,
0.9465187788009644,
0.9453113079071045,
-0.10390008985996246,
0.10597732663154602,
0.2583714425563812,
-0.4734005928039551,
0.624543309211731,
-0.11251243948936462,
-0.2893003225326538,
0.11362770199775696,
0.2713589668273926,
0.7158503532409668,
0.017774062231183052,
-0.3887876272201538,
0.659163773059845,
0.1355593502521515,
-0.5475893020629883,
-0.15369345247745514,
-0.20562773942947388,
-0.014956525526940823,
0.07980659604072571,
0.1831156611442566,
0.0838426947593689,
0.38019853830337524,
-0.35872340202331543,
0.1893041580915451,
0.5611259341239929,
-0.32710105180740356,
-0.2492029368877411,
0.9141377210617065,
0.5580026507377625,
-0.5593947768211365,
0.3578351140022278,
-0.2523645758628845,
-0.7974104881286621,
0.48810651898384094,
0.20315811038017273,
1.0150216817855835,
-0.1984238475561142,
-0.23210671544075012,
0.3746515214443207,
0.6527628898620605,
-0.4396575391292572,
0.029178211465477943,
0.3459979295730591,
-0.32805147767066956,
-0.7498169541358948,
-0.30888497829437256,
-0.49160388112068176,
0.3503664433956146,
-0.47104907035827637,
0.3199344873428345,
-0.13259805738925934,
-0.7455509305000305,
-0.4015026390552521,
0.16874708235263824,
-0.6248862743377686,
0.11544997245073318,
0.06934291124343872,
0.8752678632736206,
-0.8409573435783386,
0.7546350955963135,
0.9711838960647583,
-0.28047239780426025,
-0.23474682867527008,
-0.08428536355495453,
-0.1692044734954834,
-0.44738084077835083,
0.8236236572265625,
-0.06389547884464264,
-0.3900860548019409,
-0.06437825411558151,
-0.29502350091934204,
-0.44070565700531006,
0.7631332278251648,
0.699990451335907,
-0.7322011590003967,
0.22216330468654633,
0.5521070957183838,
0.7606144547462463,
-0.23636575043201447,
0.1677653044462204,
0.6304534077644348,
0.5505324006080627,
-0.19089938700199127,
-1.2670027017593384,
-0.13854768872261047,
0.04019786790013313,
-0.11164065450429916,
0.1892520934343338,
-0.4276532828807831,
0.45447635650634766,
-0.07606127113103867,
-0.22813931107521057,
0.10649272054433823,
0.4603072702884674,
0.023958252742886543,
0.3157448470592499,
0.5056542158126831,
0.6134100556373596,
0.42364397644996643,
0.001442077336832881,
1.0817170143127441,
-0.5169358253479004,
0.3432376980781555,
0.8187839984893799,
-0.38501036167144775,
1.0867886543273926,
0.5380972027778625,
-0.3587269186973572,
0.030920997262001038,
0.6924093961715698,
0.15993301570415497,
0.17041487991809845,
0.6435575485229492,
-0.19501982629299164,
-0.45501354336738586,
0.10919109731912613,
-0.15452460944652557,
0.35157936811447144,
0.3199048936367035,
-0.6590749621391296,
-0.042956843972206116,
-0.14164049923419952,
-0.16484637558460236,
0.29643985629081726,
-0.07855058461427689,
0.7458639144897461,
0.3796754479408264,
-0.8160136938095093,
0.48771125078201294,
0.5367722511291504,
0.478158175945282,
-0.28687557578086853,
-0.0007773901452310383,
-0.05272366851568222,
0.0849786028265953,
0.015785451978445053,
-0.9246177077293396,
0.14822976291179657,
0.1613311767578125,
0.09463918209075928,
-0.3927304446697235,
0.277983695268631,
-0.32180777192115784,
-0.36439311504364014,
0.47656306624412537,
0.6155692934989929,
0.5814168453216553,
0.007930856198072433,
-1.0380568504333496,
0.07065856456756592,
-0.3139590620994568,
-0.476929247379303,
0.06183565407991409,
0.4420751631259918,
-0.2773670554161072,
0.6328249573707581,
0.5716769099235535,
0.3527519702911377,
0.062077201902866364,
0.10527870059013367,
0.6557060480117798,
-0.6287081837654114,
-0.31756311655044556,
-0.9245550632476807,
0.2582981586456299,
0.05937584117054939,
-0.3837437331676483,
0.5708853602409363,
0.8020045161247253,
0.6010809540748596,
-0.0001588198938407004,
0.5519070625305176,
0.23197448253631592,
0.1828565150499344,
-0.613699197769165,
0.9497706294059753,
-0.5086329579353333,
0.26504769921302795,
0.01953946240246296,
-1.2138925790786743,
-0.4458257853984833,
0.49480730295181274,
-0.5184878706932068,
0.08504510670900345,
0.6255823969841003,
0.5703533887863159,
-0.2993038594722748,
-0.518543541431427,
0.5995564460754395,
0.2073945701122284,
0.33325618505477905,
0.37529101967811584,
1.0710220336914062,
-0.6055060029029846,
0.6197118759155273,
0.42732688784599304,
0.008545421063899994,
-0.3859575688838959,
-0.795068085193634,
-0.6748012900352478,
-0.38006484508514404,
-0.3033426105976105,
-0.5083876848220825,
0.04973004385828972,
1.0357780456542969,
0.5937643647193909,
-0.9080560207366943,
-0.4706677496433258,
0.28346890211105347,
-0.17409606277942657,
0.11798065900802612,
-0.11882362514734268,
0.3291281461715698,
-0.20819099247455597,
-0.7449734807014465,
0.4474949240684509,
0.20017454028129578,
0.015880132094025612,
-0.555331826210022,
-0.36960577964782715,
0.04060199484229088,
0.07551689445972443,
0.6951696872711182,
-0.17616458237171173,
-1.2540779113769531,
-0.11083221435546875,
-0.08645853400230408,
-0.7744224667549133,
0.14947877824306488,
0.9793820977210999,
-0.19852642714977264,
0.5278977751731873,
0.6981872916221619,
0.8250311017036438,
0.21842610836029053,
0.03027023747563362,
0.7708488702774048,
-0.08965320140123367,
0.07733836024999619,
0.3260467052459717,
0.5841982960700989,
0.27628058195114136,
-0.10322156548500061,
0.42406198382377625,
0.18522396683692932,
-0.7325699925422668,
-0.7227583527565002,
0.059899650514125824,
-0.8178966045379639,
-0.07412531971931458,
1.3616421222686768,
-0.21468977630138397,
-0.14029920101165771,
-0.2528270483016968,
-0.23669825494289398,
0.23959693312644958,
-0.2703889310359955,
0.7247000932693481,
0.9694273471832275,
0.38110098242759705,
0.17797748744487762,
-1.2073012590408325,
0.31620776653289795,
0.4315633177757263,
-0.5861541628837585,
-0.10646236687898636,
0.5915709733963013,
0.43350186944007874,
-0.0012217520270496607,
0.4342045187950134,
-0.35651400685310364,
0.37630143761634827,
-0.519329309463501,
0.241324782371521,
-0.09663019329309464,
-0.09441147744655609,
-0.7223411798477173,
-0.05755239352583885,
0.45133423805236816,
-0.09512238949537277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07658v1 | The Sound of Healthcare: Improving Medical Transcription ASR Accuracy with Large Language Models | 2024-02-12T14:01:12 | 2024-02-12T14:01:12 | Ayo Adedeji, Sarita Joshi, Brendan Doohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In the rapidly evolving landscape of medical documentation, transcribing
clinical dialogues accurately is increasingly paramount. This study explores
the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) to enhance the accuracy of
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems in medical transcription. Utilizing
the PriMock57 dataset, which encompasses a diverse range of primary care
consultations, we apply advanced LLMs to refine ASR-generated transcripts. Our
research is multifaceted, focusing on improvements in general Word Error Rate
(WER), Medical Concept WER (MC-WER) for the accurate transcription of essential
medical terms, and speaker diarization accuracy. Additionally, we assess the
role of LLM post-processing in improving semantic textual similarity, thereby
preserving the contextual integrity of clinical dialogues. Through a series of
experiments, we compare the efficacy of zero-shot and Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
prompting techniques in enhancing diarization and correction accuracy. Our
findings demonstrate that LLMs, particularly through CoT prompting, not only
improve the diarization accuracy of existing ASR systems but also achieve
state-of-the-art performance in this domain. This improvement extends to more
accurately capturing medical concepts and enhancing the overall semantic
coherence of the transcribed dialogues. These findings illustrate the dual role
of LLMs in augmenting ASR outputs and independently excelling in transcription
tasks, holding significant promise for transforming medical ASR systems and
leading to more accurate and reliable patient records in healthcare settings. | [
0.145459845662117,
-0.5152944922447205,
0.8557661771774292,
-0.14800964295864105,
-0.2392003983259201,
0.19245322048664093,
-0.43321385979652405,
-0.40475228428840637,
0.12101098895072937,
0.6663084626197815,
-0.15606588125228882,
-0.6259769201278687,
-0.7764827609062195,
0.31874486804008484,
-0.3977685868740082,
0.634753406047821,
0.09031272679567337,
0.6046910881996155,
-0.10699138045310974,
-0.10760722309350967,
-0.3439708650112152,
-0.7354275584220886,
-0.6794639229774475,
-0.34219664335250854,
0.5844293236732483,
0.0841534435749054,
0.5731176137924194,
0.6766469478607178,
0.6916661858558655,
0.31768277287483215,
-0.19388312101364136,
0.2093416005373001,
-0.17176984250545502,
0.286297082901001,
0.1458701640367508,
-0.3986864686012268,
-0.7336435914039612,
-0.31170037388801575,
0.7846470475196838,
0.7374846339225769,
-0.34430256485939026,
-0.036011938005685806,
0.033227529376745224,
0.49907732009887695,
-0.38283881545066833,
0.2584376335144043,
-0.5017356872558594,
-0.16908401250839233,
-0.08052687346935272,
-0.5142679214477539,
-0.34304484724998474,
-0.2352687269449234,
0.28442418575286865,
-0.4136016368865967,
0.14022667706012726,
-0.23379965126514435,
0.7303506135940552,
0.5429511666297913,
-0.17216582596302032,
-0.6256539821624756,
-0.9026708602905273,
0.426525354385376,
-0.9189742803573608,
0.7183581590652466,
0.3347105085849762,
0.02936347760260105,
-0.1680622398853302,
-0.7734599709510803,
-0.39071518182754517,
-0.22035057842731476,
0.036140307784080505,
0.23523403704166412,
-0.23641976714134216,
0.4689696133136749,
0.39541706442832947,
0.6661891341209412,
-0.2254958152770996,
0.20295847952365875,
-0.6630131006240845,
-0.19567470252513885,
0.5403104424476624,
0.26293519139289856,
0.4550616145133972,
-0.08723653107881546,
0.09447258710861206,
-0.08455649763345718,
-0.759562075138092,
-0.10627017170190811,
-0.16602952778339386,
0.35591524839401245,
-0.04783695563673973,
0.47315433621406555,
-0.017342226579785347,
0.684776246547699,
0.058377623558044434,
-0.7109394073486328,
0.42271915078163147,
-0.2702876627445221,
-0.41353294253349304,
0.3148247003555298,
0.8609050512313843,
0.3529692590236664,
0.042891740798950195,
-0.13989366590976715,
-0.1532372087240219,
0.2214592546224594,
0.5201573967933655,
-0.6470677852630615,
-0.1730213463306427,
0.4173851013183594,
-0.5154622793197632,
-0.04650669917464256,
0.06923038512468338,
-0.23752886056900024,
-0.42290979623794556,
-0.7366135120391846,
0.4077790081501007,
-0.4986407160758972,
-0.07615967094898224,
0.5551248788833618,
0.03766084462404251,
0.11083830893039703,
0.48832809925079346,
-0.5528830289840698,
0.49562689661979675,
0.8028957843780518,
0.8427637815475464,
0.014089121483266354,
0.1902836114168167,
-0.6008098125457764,
0.3194047808647156,
-0.49448737502098083,
0.6021752953529358,
-0.22561420500278473,
-0.7097303867340088,
0.13788729906082153,
-0.020429646596312523,
-0.050001487135887146,
-0.9608827233314514,
0.5637339949607849,
-0.10595583915710449,
-0.15041066706180573,
-0.3371827304363251,
-0.5342301726341248,
0.12542758882045746,
0.06467762589454651,
-0.587312638759613,
0.3822110891342163,
-0.09276922047138214,
-0.3094995617866516,
0.33923256397247314,
-0.8447760343551636,
-0.5651676058769226,
0.08568041771650314,
-0.3847360610961914,
-0.42567819356918335,
0.28581035137176514,
0.2789327800273895,
0.3613852262496948,
-0.4125390350818634,
0.24213506281375885,
0.31688204407691956,
-0.4693581759929657,
0.48930707573890686,
-0.4264566898345947,
0.5419177412986755,
0.20311596989631653,
-0.19808197021484375,
0.12690165638923645,
-0.6382558345794678,
-0.0994504988193512,
-0.1742018163204193,
-0.5214942097663879,
-0.15646480023860931,
-0.18107856810092926,
-0.09089779108762741,
-0.016225937753915787,
-0.08985437452793121,
-0.57224041223526,
0.10228758305311203,
-0.6653644442558289,
0.6004105806350708,
0.30059245228767395,
0.15485191345214844,
0.29772961139678955,
-0.6432211399078369,
0.5006998181343079,
0.03511648252606392,
0.18551231920719147,
-0.35623863339424133,
-0.44597190618515015,
-0.5311651825904846,
-0.6179162263870239,
0.5566934943199158,
0.47011798620224,
-0.3502698242664337,
0.38358524441719055,
-0.5253736972808838,
-0.2111607789993286,
-0.9860190749168396,
-0.01889226771891117,
0.4020470380783081,
0.6569082736968994,
0.3878030478954315,
-0.6534438133239746,
-0.74684077501297,
-0.5153011083602905,
-0.05819917470216751,
-0.4381822645664215,
-0.2756531536579132,
0.3524586260318756,
-0.09705875813961029,
-0.48166608810424805,
0.6654024720191956,
-0.21119634807109833,
-0.43159398436546326,
-0.043908778578042984,
-0.008092164993286133,
0.3144156038761139,
0.2800891697406769,
-0.12755537033081055,
-0.5306046009063721,
-0.3282201886177063,
-0.14044329524040222,
-0.4601881206035614,
-0.3396151661872864,
0.07292722165584564,
0.40770894289016724,
0.16781288385391235,
0.5364460349082947,
-0.6756784915924072,
0.329637736082077,
0.3450879156589508,
0.11509015411138535,
0.35291025042533875,
-0.4185045063495636,
0.32633504271507263,
-1.0065819025039673,
0.1584748923778534,
-0.4021018445491791,
-0.15822432935237885,
-0.7298225164413452,
-0.19297023117542267,
0.014516234397888184,
0.009629258885979652,
-0.32734572887420654,
0.2992316782474518,
-0.5351149439811707,
0.006054093595594168,
-0.22390684485435486,
-0.06767625361680984,
0.08229830116033554,
-0.15713509917259216,
0.015776552259922028,
0.7517919540405273,
0.5290853977203369,
-0.5841070413589478,
0.4604922831058502,
0.5668410062789917,
-0.3700374364852905,
0.6429929137229919,
-0.8144938945770264,
0.26161351799964905,
0.006696940399706364,
0.4661237597465515,
-0.8104015588760376,
-0.35301440954208374,
-0.07992354780435562,
-0.5129755735397339,
0.597896933555603,
-0.07085727900266647,
-0.577062726020813,
-0.44980746507644653,
0.06889104843139648,
0.2281443029642105,
0.7842149138450623,
-0.016097983345389366,
0.35797959566116333,
0.48122474551200867,
-0.5594536066055298,
-0.38159939646720886,
-0.7435507774353027,
0.39627397060394287,
0.12937097251415253,
-0.27061063051223755,
0.3645371198654175,
0.04656805470585823,
-0.4489601254463196,
-0.325634241104126,
-0.33656567335128784,
-0.11576899141073227,
-0.287041038274765,
0.4758160710334778,
0.4528709053993225,
-0.3330211043357849,
0.46233314275741577,
-0.19306199252605438,
-0.11147129535675049,
0.12812763452529907,
-0.40792903304100037,
0.5171523094177246,
0.1225992739200592,
-0.4153149724006653,
-0.8093594908714294,
0.23384179174900055,
0.9350172877311707,
-0.12091954052448273,
0.41855955123901367,
0.424437016248703,
-0.4168164134025574,
0.2537536025047302,
-0.9091955423355103,
-0.29792168736457825,
-0.3697400987148285,
0.19919343292713165,
-0.2496984452009201,
-0.895167887210846,
0.33592262864112854,
-0.006171629298478365,
0.008874911814928055,
0.2289796620607376,
0.6705217957496643,
-0.23582111299037933,
0.8207377195358276,
0.1441783905029297,
-0.06845676898956299,
0.14303390681743622,
-0.22072149813175201,
0.22463859617710114,
-1.0365583896636963,
-0.2621462941169739,
-0.4911836087703705,
0.020436042919754982,
-0.48052075505256653,
-0.8162975311279297,
0.794956386089325,
-0.3375982642173767,
-0.10839149355888367,
0.03311435133218765,
-0.5113919377326965,
0.048676662147045135,
0.4399995505809784,
0.491809219121933,
0.47487911581993103,
0.0550655759871006,
-0.07368979603052139,
-0.042114559561014175,
-0.5712276697158813,
-0.5099816918373108,
1.0850613117218018,
0.5607681274414062,
0.9268348813056946,
-0.07605093717575073,
0.6955558657646179,
0.03586369380354881,
0.13806328177452087,
-0.8693913221359253,
0.1673162281513214,
-0.5344706773757935,
-0.3292085826396942,
-0.38602909445762634,
-0.3392362892627716,
-0.7269479036331177,
-0.14250166714191437,
-0.13300761580467224,
-0.355892151594162,
0.07905211299657822,
0.22996839880943298,
-0.9738607406616211,
0.18199943006038666,
-0.15584230422973633,
0.4176870882511139,
-0.16841953992843628,
0.03728562965989113,
-0.1858321875333786,
-0.714139997959137,
-0.17561206221580505,
-0.05073144659399986,
0.252320259809494,
0.10149253159761429,
-0.21475017070770264,
0.5204370021820068,
-0.5729782581329346,
0.8075708150863647,
0.11027001589536667,
-0.43888700008392334,
0.17009268701076508,
-0.2145819365978241,
0.3359077572822571,
-0.1546764373779297,
-0.17979952692985535,
0.36519089341163635,
0.08643966168165207,
0.03843598812818527,
-0.49056476354599,
0.4107908010482788,
-0.6920108795166016,
-0.6568590402603149,
-0.19459618628025055,
-0.6721565127372742,
-0.3925512433052063,
-0.09995315968990326,
0.3353041708469391,
0.8083930015563965,
-0.3368513584136963,
0.32217270135879517,
0.8982025384902954,
-0.35530900955200195,
-0.09531664103269577,
0.5987293124198914,
0.07039400190114975,
-0.4959351122379303,
0.5317361950874329,
0.24535144865512848,
0.3903789222240448,
0.5003445148468018,
0.13298265635967255,
-0.5098487138748169,
-0.6901284456253052,
-0.4112212657928467,
0.45221850275993347,
-0.6797956824302673,
-0.21519537270069122,
-1.1619489192962646,
-0.5175649523735046,
-0.72676020860672,
-0.1565023511648178,
-0.2071661651134491,
-0.2387688010931015,
-0.3365282714366913,
-0.16333848237991333,
0.502727746963501,
0.693515419960022,
-0.16923952102661133,
0.3215067684650421,
-0.9487946033477783,
0.4537694454193115,
0.2575635313987732,
0.22650779783725739,
-0.30837997794151306,
-0.6861382722854614,
-0.008662293665111065,
0.0403243787586689,
0.00009182736539514735,
-0.568388819694519,
0.29336389899253845,
0.08316376060247421,
0.2801815867424011,
0.3625085949897766,
-0.16048191487789154,
0.8698161840438843,
-0.9607108235359192,
0.7764580845832825,
0.4740069508552551,
-1.0041131973266602,
0.5201438069343567,
-0.301426500082016,
0.5684477686882019,
0.6644867658615112,
0.006529936101287603,
-0.7336334586143494,
-0.4765249788761139,
-0.4709545075893402,
-0.6590214967727661,
0.3572775423526764,
-0.15981978178024292,
0.11828416585922241,
-0.011341012082993984,
0.2963933050632477,
-0.09180326014757156,
0.20691150426864624,
-0.15189890563488007,
0.007587991189211607,
0.16908922791481018,
-0.43970730900764465,
-0.13348495960235596,
-0.3042130768299103,
-0.22189195454120636,
-0.2852495014667511,
0.51054447889328,
-0.0762636587023735,
0.32798150181770325,
0.618074357509613,
0.07417402416467667,
-0.49536576867103577,
0.5221181511878967,
0.5852757692337036,
0.7333231568336487,
0.07118269801139832,
0.09207285940647125,
0.3220866620540619,
-0.7067518830299377,
0.30419209599494934,
-0.1573762148618698,
-0.09753116965293884,
0.40701591968536377,
0.37551581859588623,
0.8022690415382385,
0.40445423126220703,
-0.8458976149559021,
0.5597307085990906,
-0.02833799459040165,
-0.10986456274986267,
-0.2996445894241333,
0.14288295805454254,
0.1541629135608673,
0.08608512580394745,
0.09415119141340256,
0.032350290566682816,
0.3294488787651062,
-0.7100391387939453,
0.3325968086719513,
0.2714114487171173,
-0.6028599739074707,
-0.02923731505870819,
0.6529101133346558,
0.08483007550239563,
-0.5218586921691895,
0.5042367577552795,
0.6009719371795654,
-0.35488465428352356,
0.34918397665023804,
0.5056169033050537,
0.6906732320785522,
-0.5859969854354858,
0.02243448980152607,
0.25742775201797485,
0.10404365509748459,
-0.4168831408023834,
0.21271486580371857,
0.08997870981693268,
-0.4435544013977051,
-0.7016010284423828,
-0.5905903577804565,
-0.6606633067131042,
0.2137657105922699,
-0.7196546792984009,
0.37921789288520813,
-0.4820532500743866,
-0.39623504877090454,
0.12578153610229492,
-0.32887426018714905,
-0.5761712193489075,
0.40623512864112854,
0.31830456852912903,
0.6953215599060059,
-0.3867114782333374,
0.8326228857040405,
0.603771448135376,
-0.2025768905878067,
-1.0572216510772705,
0.09146284312009811,
0.16867665946483612,
-0.707025945186615,
0.4183618128299713,
-0.06739721447229385,
-0.209528386592865,
-0.22887393832206726,
-0.251149445772171,
-0.7146936655044556,
1.0442091226577759,
0.3853459656238556,
-1.1520956754684448,
-0.22787043452262878,
0.32747554779052734,
0.7146632671356201,
-0.3327823281288147,
0.17558705806732178,
0.5731990337371826,
0.23528917133808136,
0.3355042040348053,
-1.6847628355026245,
0.004482305608689785,
0.05668250843882561,
-0.04988745599985123,
0.14067919552326202,
-0.2734673321247101,
0.5961936116218567,
-0.32802391052246094,
-0.006631128489971161,
0.13782627880573273,
0.1391351968050003,
0.14918717741966248,
0.26598861813545227,
0.4568510949611664,
0.3043232262134552,
0.9650465846061707,
-0.06241438537836075,
1.121383786201477,
-0.19798065721988678,
-0.13770470023155212,
1.0387310981750488,
-0.6600956320762634,
0.7603954076766968,
0.42246922850608826,
-0.14787492156028748,
0.44160330295562744,
0.1429676115512848,
0.2656257748603821,
0.33149009943008423,
0.31524381041526794,
-0.5743279457092285,
-0.07062449306249619,
-0.2496238648891449,
-0.4085729122161865,
0.5164048075675964,
0.5988852381706238,
-0.7901446223258972,
0.3025274872779846,
0.12103860825300217,
-0.0020314629655331373,
0.13543766736984253,
-0.41132208704948425,
1.288815975189209,
0.5115002989768982,
-0.4670243561267853,
0.5806607007980347,
-0.3077709674835205,
0.3807571232318878,
-0.580297589302063,
-0.12801624834537506,
0.3411996066570282,
0.2786368727684021,
-0.22617892920970917,
-0.20743821561336517,
0.2634091079235077,
0.10579957813024521,
-0.31573936343193054,
-0.3351671099662781,
0.7023189663887024,
-0.6248019337654114,
-0.4491564631462097,
0.09908430278301239,
0.4020717442035675,
0.23665061593055725,
0.08527323603630066,
-0.4530795216560364,
0.5011956095695496,
-0.13679644465446472,
0.3796164095401764,
-0.0004961143713444471,
0.28721073269844055,
0.2269563525915146,
0.3375820517539978,
0.7576696276664734,
0.6795697212219238,
-0.12684078514575958,
0.4398577809333801,
0.6100630760192871,
-0.50351881980896,
-0.47361668944358826,
-0.8600808382034302,
0.430653840303421,
-0.04313096031546593,
-0.03125704452395439,
0.22725532948970795,
0.4607093930244446,
0.5081583857536316,
-0.10602154582738876,
0.8846018314361572,
0.2616354525089264,
0.9650728106498718,
-0.5551584959030151,
0.8684022426605225,
-0.24071075022220612,
0.13473312556743622,
-0.41795164346694946,
-0.476055771112442,
-0.5896021723747253,
0.6138731837272644,
-0.3929709792137146,
-0.22615939378738403,
0.6445929408073425,
0.8256980776786804,
0.05662987008690834,
0.00026012372109107673,
0.7202300429344177,
0.5576983094215393,
0.23184873163700104,
0.3665105104446411,
0.6956663131713867,
-0.4464839994907379,
0.2458210289478302,
0.10921992361545563,
-0.17502762377262115,
-0.25240427255630493,
-0.42581799626350403,
-0.6390150785446167,
-0.40106818079948425,
-0.47709906101226807,
-0.46188613772392273,
0.4411614239215851,
1.2447562217712402,
0.7187210321426392,
-0.8951762914657593,
-0.2010757178068161,
0.13439321517944336,
-0.3994159996509552,
-0.12946240603923798,
-0.0682428628206253,
0.39719149470329285,
-0.2942701280117035,
-0.5427178740501404,
0.5628390908241272,
0.7007647156715393,
0.02619291841983795,
0.05135170370340347,
-0.1632746458053589,
0.29827553033828735,
0.2496153861284256,
0.519562304019928,
0.006069633178412914,
-1.0666149854660034,
-0.13853704929351807,
0.2211478054523468,
-0.40533727407455444,
0.37761563062667847,
1.0677697658538818,
-0.508746862411499,
0.5818620324134827,
0.09388728439807892,
0.5948279500007629,
0.21603412926197052,
-0.015394850634038448,
0.7826327681541443,
-0.28783905506134033,
-0.11829940974712372,
0.4270707666873932,
0.37395089864730835,
0.5581953525543213,
-0.41545048356056213,
0.44370681047439575,
-0.041277334094047546,
-0.5155854821205139,
-0.8706802129745483,
-0.043478939682245255,
-0.7855464220046997,
0.07715579867362976,
1.1229913234710693,
-0.15641330182552338,
-0.11229763925075531,
-0.47701939940452576,
-0.5079011917114258,
0.45868954062461853,
-0.2622191905975342,
0.7429245114326477,
0.5274799466133118,
-0.13429823517799377,
-0.20809687674045563,
-0.590138852596283,
0.6705801486968994,
0.29962125420570374,
-0.5861512422561646,
-0.00855749100446701,
0.5969418883323669,
0.39972373843193054,
0.2677369713783264,
1.1160244941711426,
-0.6430849432945251,
0.5111339688301086,
-0.2693991959095001,
0.051528822630643845,
0.12493867427110672,
-0.16071093082427979,
-0.6788459420204163,
-0.007846633903682232,
0.27835017442703247,
-0.051567476242780685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07645v1 | Detecting the Clinical Features of Difficult-to-Treat Depression using Synthetic Data from Large Language Models | 2024-02-12T13:34:33 | 2024-02-12T13:34:33 | Isabelle Lorge, Dan W. Joyce, Niall Taylor, Alejo Nevado-Holgado, Andrea Cipriani, Andrey Kormilitzin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Difficult-to-treat depression (DTD) has been proposed as a broader and more
clinically comprehensive perspective on a person's depressive disorder where
despite treatment, they continue to experience significant burden. We sought to
develop a Large Language Model (LLM)-based tool capable of interrogating
routinely-collected, narrative (free-text) electronic health record (EHR) data
to locate published prognostic factors that capture the clinical syndrome of
DTD. In this work, we use LLM-generated synthetic data (GPT3.5) and a
Non-Maximum Suppression (NMS) algorithm to train a BERT-based span extraction
model. The resulting model is then able to extract and label spans related to a
variety of relevant positive and negative factors in real clinical data (i.e.
spans of text that increase or decrease the likelihood of a patient matching
the DTD syndrome). We show it is possible to obtain good overall performance
(0.70 F1 across polarity) on real clinical data on a set of as many as 20
different factors, and high performance (0.85 F1 with 0.95 precision) on a
subset of important DTD factors such as history of abuse, family history of
affective disorder, illness severity and suicidality by training the model
exclusively on synthetic data. Our results show promise for future healthcare
applications especially in applications where traditionally, highly
confidential medical data and human-expert annotation would normally be
required. | [
-0.4688647389411926,
-1.1197481155395508,
0.9534007906913757,
0.4631665349006653,
-0.3001503050327301,
0.09751419723033905,
-0.3419349193572998,
-0.439558207988739,
0.4636068344116211,
0.45108675956726074,
-0.7880390286445618,
-0.7291277647018433,
-0.9199215769767761,
0.43826979398727417,
-0.3508412539958954,
1.049985408782959,
-0.19930744171142578,
0.1872829645872116,
0.07403384149074554,
0.3710044026374817,
-0.3871667683124542,
-0.701261043548584,
-0.5930608510971069,
-0.4665800929069519,
0.461725115776062,
0.2665601968765259,
0.5545346140861511,
0.37824228405952454,
0.549988329410553,
0.17723558843135834,
-0.3508334457874298,
0.14466042816638947,
-0.38630151748657227,
0.13299299776554108,
0.05483490601181984,
-0.3034040629863739,
-0.6575137972831726,
-0.21477705240249634,
0.3101527988910675,
0.6231385469436646,
0.057465534657239914,
-0.1495290845632553,
0.16242475807666779,
0.3839932680130005,
-0.27522993087768555,
0.09496425092220306,
-0.2188621163368225,
0.29003530740737915,
-0.30270111560821533,
-0.01439833827316761,
-0.39975541830062866,
-0.35786399245262146,
0.06540856510400772,
-0.33951056003570557,
0.48734399676322937,
-0.49301666021347046,
0.7388211488723755,
0.29994502663612366,
-0.6197311878204346,
-0.2807033360004425,
-0.8367153406143188,
0.6372509002685547,
-0.7006142735481262,
0.20666424930095673,
0.7632558345794678,
0.25424548983573914,
-0.2805938124656677,
-0.37079334259033203,
-0.47561872005462646,
-0.2434822916984558,
-0.1980670988559723,
-0.0023203075397759676,
-0.14825858175754547,
0.1830115020275116,
0.44896596670150757,
0.41141197085380554,
-0.7132533192634583,
0.33151572942733765,
-0.2337469458580017,
-0.2907441258430481,
0.7085931301116943,
0.35260215401649475,
0.4257449209690094,
-0.4445529580116272,
-0.28281891345977783,
0.08396776765584946,
-0.47045597434043884,
-0.1175367459654808,
-0.1688774824142456,
0.2304101139307022,
-0.2758534252643585,
0.9293554425239563,
0.01564883068203926,
0.3868376314640045,
0.12220125645399094,
-0.03848204389214516,
0.1587090939283371,
0.09326935559511185,
-0.15770089626312256,
0.11040416359901428,
0.6967213749885559,
0.2625619173049927,
0.15099205076694489,
-0.20989668369293213,
-0.3402085304260254,
0.2722523808479309,
0.26843950152397156,
-0.5349443554878235,
-0.46228334307670593,
0.6904180645942688,
-0.5194775462150574,
-0.27562209963798523,
-0.5035792589187622,
-0.7446786165237427,
-0.6673242449760437,
-0.31617724895477295,
0.35204192996025085,
-0.7193374037742615,
-0.3954109847545624,
0.047406233847141266,
-0.040544625371694565,
-0.14804990589618683,
0.14573350548744202,
-0.5775728225708008,
0.16325797140598297,
0.6932306885719299,
1.0044081211090088,
-0.3634237051010132,
0.23174823820590973,
-0.6467586755752563,
-0.10528889298439026,
-0.2486460953950882,
0.7052674293518066,
-0.29494431614875793,
-0.34729132056236267,
0.17250637710094452,
0.20188741385936737,
-0.2391524612903595,
-0.6519919633865356,
0.8568043112754822,
-0.1935778707265854,
-0.046207696199417114,
0.016010455787181854,
-0.876789391040802,
0.34583237767219543,
0.2930913269519806,
-1.0155079364776611,
0.7531145215034485,
0.40969857573509216,
-0.7598146796226501,
0.12601207196712494,
-0.34061571955680847,
-0.45132699608802795,
0.14912532269954681,
0.17774489521980286,
-0.5692467093467712,
0.27181652188301086,
0.2446083426475525,
0.6836785078048706,
-0.2698749899864197,
0.576467752456665,
-0.4987882077693939,
-0.0633627250790596,
0.35493534803390503,
-0.25087276101112366,
0.5950096845626831,
0.09715546667575836,
-0.20646505057811737,
-0.04116203635931015,
-0.9761887788772583,
-0.19306179881095886,
0.16225355863571167,
-0.5380104780197144,
-0.571293830871582,
-0.04897269979119301,
0.3679075539112091,
0.32471963763237,
0.07050979882478714,
-0.7327383756637573,
0.08101455867290497,
-0.32345107197761536,
0.09719385951757431,
0.6094582080841064,
0.13140302896499634,
-0.12956902384757996,
-0.31719011068344116,
0.7486308813095093,
0.1490309238433838,
0.0721970647573471,
0.11698484420776367,
-0.4060441851615906,
-0.35561609268188477,
-0.8829883933067322,
0.27203837037086487,
0.5572811365127563,
-0.7109068632125854,
0.7971073985099792,
-0.18296626210212708,
-0.36504554748535156,
-0.5402657389640808,
-0.11217744648456573,
0.41224512457847595,
0.6764746308326721,
0.7509498596191406,
-0.08211539685726166,
-0.5259207487106323,
-1.0754001140594482,
-0.045047543942928314,
0.2413625419139862,
-0.3515060544013977,
0.002012975513935089,
0.35634660720825195,
-0.5103078484535217,
0.8299609422683716,
-0.7652941346168518,
-0.6009905338287354,
-0.6744462251663208,
0.3449127972126007,
0.25277236104011536,
0.272000253200531,
0.17175798118114471,
-0.41308099031448364,
-0.48696160316467285,
-0.013510635122656822,
-0.6222242712974548,
-0.4415665566921234,
-0.15924111008644104,
0.12071754783391953,
-0.02965753711760044,
0.363545298576355,
-0.7823630571365356,
0.4127395451068878,
0.4544219970703125,
-0.5431408286094666,
0.5483893156051636,
-0.36789670586586,
-0.268394410610199,
-0.9308146238327026,
0.12632960081100464,
0.4567863345146179,
-0.25188982486724854,
-0.6580026745796204,
-0.3350057005882263,
0.1254504770040512,
-0.21634049713611603,
-0.0825158953666687,
0.2203126847743988,
-0.12128064781427383,
0.3949289917945862,
-0.10480421036481857,
-0.08106380701065063,
-0.029669059440493584,
0.22330422699451447,
0.23545774817466736,
0.30718711018562317,
0.2548809051513672,
-0.3080812990665436,
0.1659187525510788,
0.3990882635116577,
-0.3130536377429962,
0.6697826385498047,
-0.5968226790428162,
-0.15494999289512634,
-0.20210686326026917,
0.2973744869232178,
-0.7676758766174316,
-0.36157724261283875,
0.11678878217935562,
-0.06600815057754517,
0.3484002947807312,
-0.08098019659519196,
-0.5158404111862183,
-0.4106579124927521,
-0.14367003738880157,
0.3420855700969696,
0.27749326825141907,
-0.22322984039783478,
0.47793954610824585,
0.24236705899238586,
-0.5439468026161194,
-0.005784700624644756,
-0.5915512442588806,
0.13996820151805878,
-0.3848295211791992,
-0.4934433698654175,
0.6790236234664917,
-0.03222130239009857,
-0.09422118961811066,
-0.12554512917995453,
0.06424505263566971,
-0.29717713594436646,
0.10992856323719025,
0.026290683075785637,
0.3771446943283081,
0.0023087256122380495,
0.41798463463783264,
0.3074142634868622,
-0.16522367298603058,
0.4069158136844635,
0.40369555354118347,
0.6656537652015686,
0.22512975335121155,
-0.1583419293165207,
-0.5853368043899536,
0.6287386417388916,
0.5229076147079468,
-0.008038107305765152,
0.7252334952354431,
0.4197756350040436,
-0.6552695035934448,
-0.42090341448783875,
-0.34861186146736145,
-0.2792442739009857,
-0.34597137570381165,
0.5114060640335083,
-0.32063955068588257,
-0.6413843035697937,
0.45183059573173523,
-0.2324964851140976,
-0.4155403971672058,
0.3745085895061493,
0.4512500762939453,
-0.1366010308265686,
1.3618638515472412,
0.43874090909957886,
0.0011726624798029661,
0.15857477486133575,
-0.14223961532115936,
0.21295350790023804,
-0.799343466758728,
-0.2660897672176361,
-0.23283758759498596,
-0.19376087188720703,
-0.4728131592273712,
-0.21252739429473877,
0.733986496925354,
0.1621028184890747,
-0.33732667565345764,
0.13427019119262695,
-0.3582947850227356,
-0.04960133135318756,
0.15985430777072906,
0.6964609622955322,
0.43023091554641724,
-0.17445136606693268,
0.04580027982592583,
-0.3884945213794708,
-0.15303635597229004,
-0.376606285572052,
1.1017379760742188,
0.6168274283409119,
0.6000417470932007,
0.0905529111623764,
0.7440282702445984,
0.5855023860931396,
0.37842270731925964,
-0.7385815382003784,
0.3547225296497345,
-0.3930302560329437,
-0.40751656889915466,
-0.1169491782784462,
-0.49552345275878906,
-0.9454637169837952,
0.01634618081152439,
-0.27146100997924805,
-0.497897207736969,
0.1698445826768875,
0.029495706781744957,
-0.37710368633270264,
0.009209085255861282,
-0.8657611608505249,
0.8105422854423523,
-0.3984068036079407,
0.047490399330854416,
-0.1870262324810028,
-0.6389061212539673,
0.4698348045349121,
-0.5748757719993591,
0.27697062492370605,
-0.1407693475484848,
0.30880147218704224,
0.44040971994400024,
-0.5701688528060913,
0.8831580877304077,
-0.264805406332016,
-0.34852465987205505,
-0.2105008065700531,
0.3033769428730011,
0.6062641739845276,
-0.005316445138305426,
0.011753750964999199,
0.0575411319732666,
0.08371396362781525,
-0.12173996865749359,
-0.48698726296424866,
0.5494158267974854,
-0.7317464351654053,
-0.4203772246837616,
-0.37576696276664734,
-0.4548999071121216,
-0.554259717464447,
0.09990890324115753,
0.13458435237407684,
0.2488987296819687,
-0.25267788767814636,
0.0018935009138658643,
0.6354483366012573,
-0.5619394779205322,
0.16841831803321838,
0.43255868554115295,
-0.03835742548108101,
-0.4975692927837372,
0.7039874792098999,
0.09319689124822617,
0.16396725177764893,
0.30671194195747375,
0.2814311981201172,
-0.3198401629924774,
-0.40037810802459717,
-0.1434321403503418,
0.5713354349136353,
-0.37621989846229553,
-0.27987340092658997,
-0.6045042276382446,
-0.35886648297309875,
-0.18080124258995056,
0.01643754541873932,
-0.2784635126590729,
-0.40830114483833313,
-0.49403733015060425,
-0.3210141658782959,
0.39506199955940247,
0.4840046763420105,
-0.0890866219997406,
0.12712262570858002,
-0.8484877347946167,
0.7376666069030762,
-0.035849519073963165,
0.4402408301830292,
-0.1595333069562912,
-0.2811451256275177,
-0.1609743982553482,
0.03967813774943352,
-0.33335402607917786,
-1.016230583190918,
0.8868507146835327,
0.2011924386024475,
0.2110881209373474,
0.3781028985977173,
0.3757917881011963,
0.5247874855995178,
-0.29104939103126526,
0.5985950231552124,
0.30939286947250366,
-0.8817785382270813,
0.7464772462844849,
-0.23303309082984924,
-0.022542420774698257,
0.14744167029857635,
0.6855745911598206,
-0.5520443320274353,
-0.41345688700675964,
-0.4220370352268219,
-0.9813547134399414,
0.8486654162406921,
0.18365241587162018,
-0.24672314524650574,
-0.32291123270988464,
0.3315618634223938,
0.11839351803064346,
-0.1556619107723236,
-0.7609714269638062,
-0.19400224089622498,
-0.08333755284547806,
-0.5143362283706665,
-0.14648036658763885,
-0.32084599137306213,
-0.32571104168891907,
-0.19034528732299805,
0.5737552046775818,
-0.08053725212812424,
0.33295556902885437,
0.5434008836746216,
-0.1309843361377716,
-0.21728897094726562,
0.3220732808113098,
0.2830354571342468,
0.1811899095773697,
-0.46736836433410645,
0.18224480748176575,
-0.21061694622039795,
-0.42620328068733215,
0.04771523177623749,
0.6304243803024292,
-0.07586529850959778,
0.13358092308044434,
0.4540887475013733,
0.7058205008506775,
-0.21818362176418304,
-0.9868722558021545,
0.6532709002494812,
0.1230970174074173,
-0.22100523114204407,
-0.512604832649231,
-0.2216772437095642,
-0.05939038470387459,
0.48829522728919983,
0.21448084712028503,
-0.3050990700721741,
0.12644104659557343,
-0.19345204532146454,
0.24441586434841156,
0.42519715428352356,
-0.40961912274360657,
-0.6020262837409973,
0.5729678273200989,
-0.03869161382317543,
-0.3132336735725403,
0.7627599239349365,
-0.04655492678284645,
-0.3366867005825043,
0.6249220967292786,
0.7827513813972473,
0.8655740022659302,
-0.15871311724185944,
0.5658774971961975,
0.1347201019525528,
0.006546416319906712,
-0.12551994621753693,
0.46168217062950134,
0.30924689769744873,
-0.5229774713516235,
-0.4440456032752991,
-0.628282368183136,
-0.12228739261627197,
0.6222798824310303,
-0.7463610768318176,
0.44497546553611755,
-0.4334995150566101,
-0.49555039405822754,
0.04675082489848137,
-0.20367299020290375,
-0.5850260853767395,
0.4087258577346802,
0.38237252831459045,
0.8019218444824219,
-1.0053889751434326,
0.7464815378189087,
0.43037524819374084,
-0.24860163033008575,
-0.556157648563385,
0.0010660969419404864,
0.15740244090557098,
-0.39328861236572266,
0.5361883044242859,
0.10328412801027298,
0.3068954050540924,
-0.05505598336458206,
-0.24573205411434174,
-0.5484319925308228,
0.8231137990951538,
0.3993685841560364,
-0.6662692427635193,
-0.1239987164735794,
0.5053545236587524,
0.917900025844574,
-0.10506287962198257,
0.18090428411960602,
0.7480578422546387,
0.37485644221305847,
-0.17030704021453857,
-1.1086591482162476,
0.24422845244407654,
-0.359605073928833,
-0.19606353342533112,
0.3081979751586914,
-0.22711531817913055,
0.8333724141120911,
-0.07995302230119705,
-0.11988360434770584,
0.005920041352510452,
-0.06852776557207108,
0.2358890026807785,
0.38310566544532776,
0.4282127618789673,
0.7962560653686523,
0.8042618036270142,
-0.05076100677251816,
1.0646865367889404,
-0.34180641174316406,
0.5233592987060547,
0.7324915528297424,
-0.3311689496040344,
0.7611395120620728,
0.23605437576770782,
-0.08574513345956802,
0.5341647863388062,
0.5528187155723572,
-0.05287548154592514,
0.6054539084434509,
0.23989750444889069,
-0.5350115895271301,
-0.483608603477478,
-0.2637650966644287,
-0.29310405254364014,
0.12908606231212616,
0.5408653616905212,
-0.6426556706428528,
-0.29199036955833435,
0.2686077952384949,
0.09296562522649765,
-0.1743418574333191,
-0.05630825459957123,
0.6987639665603638,
0.25995585322380066,
-0.43984127044677734,
0.835837721824646,
0.09758985787630081,
0.37463709712028503,
-0.5886850357055664,
-0.03011341765522957,
-0.30249521136283875,
0.37614133954048157,
-0.22915665805339813,
-0.6579422950744629,
0.49102336168289185,
0.227950781583786,
-0.3696597218513489,
-0.13726849853992462,
0.5277128219604492,
-0.4749612808227539,
-0.5615511536598206,
0.4427534341812134,
0.6452730298042297,
-0.1130569726228714,
-0.29469993710517883,
-0.43296200037002563,
-0.04839981719851494,
-0.14054712653160095,
-0.21570469439029694,
0.4487019181251526,
0.5774048566818237,
-0.22440138459205627,
0.6150868535041809,
0.5222148895263672,
0.5161294937133789,
-0.34761685132980347,
0.1492624580860138,
0.9456609487533569,
-0.8969863057136536,
-0.3662481904029846,
-0.6923283338546753,
0.4797547459602356,
-0.04746986925601959,
-0.2584342062473297,
0.2823082208633423,
0.35359665751457214,
0.35465502738952637,
-0.2718513607978821,
0.7849947214126587,
-0.07771093398332596,
0.9792143702507019,
-0.35393935441970825,
0.5777126550674438,
-0.47165003418922424,
0.33298707008361816,
-0.2423458695411682,
-0.5686139464378357,
-0.5600385069847107,
0.2811037003993988,
-0.37039056420326233,
-0.2576143741607666,
0.7273527383804321,
0.5914241671562195,
-0.05424151569604874,
-0.08821919560432434,
0.024003824219107628,
0.6612120866775513,
0.6604608297348022,
0.7324622869491577,
0.7085532546043396,
0.016234220936894417,
0.4201236367225647,
-0.37610116600990295,
-0.34921494126319885,
-0.05443175509572029,
-0.6751961708068848,
-0.7753864526748657,
-0.39519861340522766,
-0.4173745810985565,
-0.4450075030326843,
-0.07568324357271194,
1.0775128602981567,
0.2471858114004135,
-0.7648299336433411,
0.20014885067939758,
-0.07470379024744034,
-0.08115121722221375,
-0.4014279544353485,
-0.23812657594680786,
0.7249845862388611,
-0.14690428972244263,
-0.5023173093795776,
0.46691030263900757,
0.011459856294095516,
0.1260654330253601,
-0.10071125626564026,
0.1803472936153412,
0.037635792046785355,
-0.17738109827041626,
0.7878355383872986,
0.096814826130867,
-0.610863447189331,
-0.14926615357398987,
-0.04072093218564987,
-0.05738630145788193,
-0.02001744508743286,
0.6999304294586182,
-0.8146011829376221,
0.45190516114234924,
0.14971701800823212,
0.49330195784568787,
0.3646576702594757,
0.21293896436691284,
0.5605416893959045,
-0.7137433290481567,
-0.4209268391132355,
0.4163946509361267,
0.23188064992427826,
0.2873579263687134,
-0.5357470512390137,
0.20320317149162292,
0.29876086115837097,
-0.4137175381183624,
-0.7583274245262146,
-0.009400025941431522,
-0.9672135710716248,
-0.39131608605384827,
1.2320542335510254,
-0.17393867671489716,
0.15375424921512604,
-0.6551463007926941,
-0.35186612606048584,
0.19335980713367462,
-0.25325101613998413,
1.309875249862671,
0.5529202818870544,
-0.46998172998428345,
0.07418631762266159,
-0.40799251198768616,
0.656984806060791,
0.28722524642944336,
-0.6503292322158813,
0.13915643095970154,
0.6418694257736206,
0.23624470829963684,
-0.0626983791589737,
0.5332099199295044,
-0.09616849571466446,
0.021755550056695938,
-0.44463780522346497,
0.047637078911066055,
0.05736672505736351,
0.0016049109399318695,
-0.35338908433914185,
0.2958928942680359,
-0.20931649208068848,
0.1633920818567276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07625v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07625v2 | Autonomous Data Selection with Language Models for Mathematical Texts | 2024-02-12T13:09:21 | 2024-04-02T04:17:30 | Yifan Zhang, Yifan Luo, Yang Yuan, Andrew Chi-Chih Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To improve language models' proficiency in mathematical reasoning via
continual pretraining, we introduce a novel strategy that leverages base
language models for autonomous data selection. Departing from conventional
supervised fine-tuning or trained classifiers with human-annotated data, our
approach Autonomous Data Selection (AutoDS) utilizes meta-prompted language
models as zero-shot verifiers to evaluate and select high-quality mathematical
content autonomously. To demonstrate the efficacy of our method, we
continuously pretrained a 7B-parameter language model on our curated dataset,
achieving substantial improvements in downstream performance on the MATH,
GSM8K, and BIG-Bench Hard (BBH) tasks with a token amount reduced by orders of
magnitude compared to previous continual pretraining works. Our method
showcases a 2 times increase in pretraining token efficiency compared to
state-of-the-art baselines, underscoring the potential of our approach in
enhancing models' mathematical reasoning capabilities. The AutoMathText dataset
is available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/math-ai/AutoMathText. The code
is available at https://github.com/yifanzhang-pro/AutoMathText. | [
-0.2661399841308594,
-0.7470186352729797,
0.5684640407562256,
0.10315440595149994,
-0.3959418535232544,
0.1860055923461914,
-0.17156550288200378,
-0.22853368520736694,
-0.16680586338043213,
0.6456480622291565,
-0.5427076816558838,
-0.44298818707466125,
-0.40970006585121155,
0.2904006540775299,
-0.4412945806980133,
0.9354234933853149,
-0.23920230567455292,
0.08973848074674606,
-0.5209513902664185,
-0.046669647097587585,
-0.36809679865837097,
-0.4800652861595154,
-0.38241252303123474,
-0.44674065709114075,
0.26847973465919495,
0.2854338586330414,
0.7848180532455444,
1.2129513025283813,
0.5161929130554199,
0.29843148589134216,
0.5965229272842407,
-0.04270812124013901,
-0.16428938508033752,
0.35314446687698364,
-0.20157434046268463,
-0.4271407723426819,
-0.34988313913345337,
0.16695579886436462,
0.5211482644081116,
0.8134176135063171,
-0.032042279839515686,
0.23832307755947113,
-0.21317614614963531,
0.7049286365509033,
-0.66592937707901,
0.3694305717945099,
-0.6779542565345764,
-0.1574876755475998,
-0.37190520763397217,
0.19635321199893951,
-0.41635388135910034,
-0.48248153924942017,
0.1816280484199524,
-0.7007954716682434,
-0.1008269414305687,
-0.2148340791463852,
0.6068161725997925,
0.6950844526290894,
-0.2975441813468933,
-0.20834912359714508,
-0.7105706930160522,
0.7695639133453369,
-0.5080289840698242,
0.604241669178009,
0.7101505994796753,
0.29567283391952515,
0.3743007481098175,
-0.69889897108078,
-0.4754759967327118,
-0.509650707244873,
-0.02356976829469204,
0.14465484023094177,
-0.05170345678925514,
-0.06451540440320969,
0.24454137682914734,
0.2782462537288666,
-0.8148128986358643,
-0.1089695394039154,
-0.05096537247300148,
-0.1336749792098999,
0.8206617832183838,
0.09413542598485947,
0.2712262272834778,
0.026889298111200333,
0.10148941725492477,
-0.24298858642578125,
-0.8497335314750671,
-0.10495365411043167,
0.45839208364486694,
0.0786435604095459,
0.1604670286178589,
0.6136184334754944,
-0.3211764991283417,
1.0487159490585327,
-0.0024805963039398193,
0.18842022120952606,
0.18523097038269043,
-0.4441409707069397,
-0.23688144981861115,
-0.2834671437740326,
0.7594083547592163,
-0.33590391278266907,
0.719321608543396,
-0.11895909905433655,
-0.3570103049278259,
0.38654637336730957,
0.13029032945632935,
-0.7896417379379272,
-0.8732253313064575,
0.0028965238016098738,
-0.13456882536411285,
-0.19573375582695007,
-0.022592350840568542,
-0.5355488657951355,
0.2308550626039505,
-0.9563378691673279,
0.4123252332210541,
-0.44783613085746765,
-0.2394106537103653,
0.3206440508365631,
0.2994615435600281,
-0.4852060079574585,
0.17256003618240356,
-1.0566378831863403,
0.44145944714546204,
0.36398589611053467,
0.45844170451164246,
-0.21031822264194489,
-0.3638354241847992,
-0.6098456978797913,
0.07866550236940384,
-0.6036915183067322,
0.9568234086036682,
-0.769512414932251,
-0.4092249274253845,
-0.29592546820640564,
-0.4642990827560425,
-0.33472147583961487,
-0.5393412709236145,
0.2979878783226013,
-0.472209632396698,
0.2622621953487396,
-0.06726951152086258,
-0.49215370416641235,
-0.04861489310860634,
-0.03635643050074577,
-0.7140117287635803,
1.1150771379470825,
0.18940143287181854,
-0.3417882025241852,
0.4377525746822357,
-0.6000126004219055,
-0.5596914291381836,
0.09892352670431137,
-0.26030462980270386,
-0.5129098296165466,
-0.06191346421837807,
0.39446625113487244,
0.3287685513496399,
-0.17094182968139648,
0.428095281124115,
-0.5097275972366333,
0.04912107065320015,
0.003495746059343219,
-0.5846468210220337,
0.7365236878395081,
0.3597407639026642,
-0.34578707814216614,
0.15555353462696075,
-0.8411308526992798,
0.21200591325759888,
0.2545580565929413,
0.0015507674543187022,
-0.4409772455692291,
0.05066932737827301,
-0.17828747630119324,
0.33830392360687256,
0.33126598596572876,
-0.1729118376970291,
0.32645806670188904,
-0.5724009275436401,
0.15275321900844574,
0.7110311985015869,
-0.2937958538532257,
0.5876520276069641,
-0.325267493724823,
0.6614372134208679,
-0.11947019398212433,
0.1348857879638672,
-0.46176522970199585,
-0.1629035919904709,
-0.7380814552307129,
-0.31657639145851135,
0.5972298383712769,
0.69349604845047,
-0.9790757298469543,
0.6775496006011963,
-0.25864502787590027,
-0.5126062035560608,
-0.3964214324951172,
0.47301867604255676,
0.43228915333747864,
0.4358871877193451,
0.5027937889099121,
-0.05996868759393692,
-0.36374810338020325,
-0.5817450881004333,
-0.2467823475599289,
-0.08712618798017502,
0.1486009806394577,
0.17136818170547485,
0.5622103810310364,
-0.1952703297138214,
1.305855631828308,
-0.5794492959976196,
-0.0766005665063858,
-0.1576683521270752,
0.3170694410800934,
0.10076437145471573,
0.4878453314304352,
0.8023996949195862,
-0.6194007992744446,
-0.8491494059562683,
-0.14396509528160095,
-0.7736284136772156,
-0.42262154817581177,
-0.14680877327919006,
-0.2753060758113861,
0.20797303318977356,
0.3969973921775818,
-0.5613906979560852,
0.607701301574707,
0.26728859543800354,
-0.32442599534988403,
0.6570279598236084,
-0.29556766152381897,
-0.1565936952829361,
-0.6417549848556519,
0.24735106527805328,
-0.01848665624856949,
-0.43294063210487366,
-0.32238465547561646,
-0.15546520054340363,
0.22821998596191406,
0.015175266191363335,
0.0018118376610800624,
0.8914206624031067,
-0.5152785778045654,
0.07700043171644211,
-0.3104894757270813,
-0.1705605685710907,
-0.18978668749332428,
0.25334590673446655,
0.3383535146713257,
0.6964888572692871,
0.7698493003845215,
-0.7948505282402039,
0.5272639989852905,
0.25953856110572815,
-0.2521809935569763,
0.2794186472892761,
-0.6992756128311157,
0.07762833684682846,
0.07208282500505447,
0.335061639547348,
-0.7193588614463806,
-0.16906212270259857,
0.08854938298463821,
-0.4666081964969635,
0.05804252624511719,
-0.1502848118543625,
-0.8424034714698792,
-0.27385056018829346,
0.23537279665470123,
0.6231739521026611,
0.2645145654678345,
-0.40661564469337463,
0.6461730599403381,
0.39642563462257385,
-0.5692904591560364,
-0.3669096529483795,
-0.4019553065299988,
0.006523834075778723,
0.0728502944111824,
-0.34684547781944275,
0.10006491839885712,
-0.46172094345092773,
-0.31481143832206726,
0.05399370938539505,
-0.05962904915213585,
-0.1242172047495842,
0.26475265622138977,
-0.0025549386627972126,
0.5272608399391174,
-0.04214237630367279,
0.19167782366275787,
0.4207819402217865,
-0.701163649559021,
0.13777753710746765,
-0.748035728931427,
0.6011803150177002,
0.12895183265209198,
-0.49071818590164185,
-0.38798755407333374,
0.18915407359600067,
0.32970285415649414,
-0.7235149145126343,
0.3303668797016144,
0.21061955392360687,
-0.3350679278373718,
-0.3722083568572998,
-0.43713653087615967,
-0.34310126304626465,
-0.42068687081336975,
0.05867109075188637,
-0.4634401202201843,
-0.572462260723114,
0.270137220621109,
0.19802555441856384,
0.24089041352272034,
0.6441176533699036,
0.5514827370643616,
0.24202342331409454,
1.2603508234024048,
0.4815484285354614,
-0.2797495126724243,
0.5322009325027466,
-0.23766280710697174,
-0.0000011663897794278455,
-0.199102520942688,
0.20138126611709595,
-0.5194098949432373,
0.16601935029029846,
-0.1536303013563156,
-0.08849678933620453,
0.3594093918800354,
-0.18549266457557678,
-0.37072309851646423,
0.35501188039779663,
-0.4267019033432007,
0.7698032855987549,
0.37702786922454834,
-0.14100679755210876,
0.3718779683113098,
-0.07764364778995514,
-0.42232656478881836,
-0.13314370810985565,
-0.5413783192634583,
-0.2854852080345154,
1.3404730558395386,
0.12450454384088516,
0.8169680237770081,
-0.10479708015918732,
0.5824732184410095,
-0.029593439772725105,
0.555253267288208,
-0.5379070043563843,
0.44720548391342163,
-0.2917218506336212,
-0.6078236699104309,
-0.3843660354614258,
-0.7773818969726562,
-0.9024598598480225,
0.0069327279925346375,
-0.10636404901742935,
-0.44214314222335815,
-0.12349943071603775,
0.2811594605445862,
-0.6413760781288147,
-0.10259567201137543,
-0.632868766784668,
0.8546501994132996,
-0.5030825138092041,
-0.3174647390842438,
-0.251699835062027,
-0.5026574730873108,
0.17989130318164825,
-0.4611661732196808,
0.22417207062244415,
-0.003549854038283229,
0.1276201754808426,
0.4843127727508545,
-0.4299600422382355,
0.6494326591491699,
-0.21251465380191803,
-0.15270377695560455,
0.28883570432662964,
0.4456753134727478,
0.36988598108291626,
0.2417943775653839,
-0.12673142552375793,
0.11970265954732895,
0.099230095744133,
-0.2429734468460083,
-0.7270708084106445,
0.47289273142814636,
-0.6427386403083801,
-0.30281952023506165,
-0.4725182056427002,
-0.5390936136245728,
-0.3180750012397766,
0.4860321879386902,
0.19709782302379608,
0.5968143343925476,
0.19299520552158356,
0.33711475133895874,
0.6590248942375183,
0.09146542847156525,
0.4266557991504669,
0.387087345123291,
-0.5045062303543091,
-0.6028174161911011,
1.0013340711593628,
0.3316363990306854,
0.3375917375087738,
0.29618847370147705,
0.1454532891511917,
-0.6913719773292542,
-0.5536714792251587,
-0.6613888740539551,
0.2614486515522003,
-0.6126670837402344,
-0.36326146125793457,
-0.747261643409729,
-0.3611193299293518,
-0.633267343044281,
-0.004148981533944607,
-0.5045587420463562,
-0.4445604383945465,
-0.24723969399929047,
-0.13853426277637482,
0.20734073221683502,
0.5777285695075989,
-0.10004284977912903,
0.2975669503211975,
-0.757271409034729,
0.47743916511535645,
0.29827404022216797,
0.38870969414711,
-0.25917956233024597,
-0.588229775428772,
-0.3347560465335846,
0.18236970901489258,
-0.0880555808544159,
-0.45310091972351074,
0.6006157398223877,
0.18556199967861176,
0.7276301980018616,
0.20058004558086395,
0.08534007519483566,
0.5351371765136719,
-0.5225356817245483,
0.2437683492898941,
-0.0033920269925147295,
-1.1443461179733276,
0.586223840713501,
-0.5444316267967224,
0.4962467849254608,
0.768622100353241,
0.3568081855773926,
-0.07802189141511917,
-0.2668892741203308,
-0.6578092575073242,
-0.4868932068347931,
0.46595796942710876,
0.3829072415828705,
0.026497196406126022,
0.09495145827531815,
0.49930399656295776,
0.18394380807876587,
0.2691125273704529,
-0.7371847033500671,
-0.3010435402393341,
-0.42435815930366516,
-0.6277870535850525,
-0.2015083283185959,
0.13048779964447021,
0.1609164923429489,
-0.6565646529197693,
0.5879927277565002,
-0.5083988308906555,
-0.023622537031769753,
0.04713625833392143,
-0.42500337958335876,
-0.21250669658184052,
-0.3419807553291321,
0.38428404927253723,
0.9705187678337097,
0.15100359916687012,
-0.13948208093643188,
-0.03059147484600544,
-0.6879988312721252,
0.004996147472411394,
0.546311616897583,
-0.19808077812194824,
0.09604793041944504,
0.26726675033569336,
0.6270671486854553,
0.2539125084877014,
-0.6149699687957764,
0.2597993314266205,
-0.11302797496318817,
-0.31796175241470337,
-0.4938383996486664,
0.22035454213619232,
-0.38858702778816223,
-0.13919185101985931,
0.4617171883583069,
0.019907146692276,
-0.0853925347328186,
-0.22160376608371735,
0.5749054551124573,
0.4178773760795593,
0.011625009588897228,
-0.3946599066257477,
0.7600715160369873,
-0.004218275658786297,
-0.01495746336877346,
0.5979821681976318,
-0.1360100954771042,
-0.3757178485393524,
0.5434285402297974,
0.34340521693229675,
0.7902005314826965,
-0.5342048406600952,
0.2681431472301483,
0.41832491755485535,
0.1711903214454651,
-0.2270125448703766,
0.09049215167760849,
-0.25401756167411804,
-0.8005350232124329,
-0.6508049964904785,
-0.5793014168739319,
-0.32749849557876587,
0.04173820838332176,
-0.5209607481956482,
0.45557183027267456,
-0.6281893849372864,
0.10281763225793839,
0.050494078546762466,
0.30076614022254944,
-0.6137482523918152,
0.5703786015510559,
0.13497713208198547,
0.6871156096458435,
-0.6534400582313538,
1.1969623565673828,
0.46755146980285645,
-0.33986493945121765,
-0.6632351279258728,
-0.1305485963821411,
-0.06739147752523422,
-0.6815590262413025,
0.664452314376831,
-0.009946346282958984,
-0.0500042624771595,
0.48346787691116333,
-0.7235745191574097,
-1.0325379371643066,
0.8339733481407166,
0.5376646518707275,
-0.5190683007240295,
0.010230856947600842,
0.21991142630577087,
0.4741102457046509,
-0.4290090501308441,
0.4974047541618347,
0.4938458204269409,
0.47133710980415344,
0.3375697731971741,
-1.0281907320022583,
-0.36913031339645386,
-0.37782809138298035,
-0.25606924295425415,
0.21216003596782684,
-0.25228792428970337,
0.9114477634429932,
0.022994915023446083,
-0.0374608114361763,
0.13024938106536865,
0.7716807126998901,
0.41671013832092285,
0.24966493248939514,
0.7623491287231445,
0.7090550661087036,
0.6737012267112732,
0.030187182128429413,
0.8833652138710022,
-0.5801617503166199,
0.41259074211120605,
1.0870819091796875,
-0.5123758912086487,
0.7174336314201355,
-0.02178669348359108,
-0.037641480565071106,
0.6469356417655945,
0.6843429207801819,
-0.011246069334447384,
0.5312623381614685,
0.07351111620664597,
-0.2811463177204132,
-0.7432511448860168,
0.29062044620513916,
-0.26020702719688416,
0.4938677251338959,
0.4560754597187042,
-0.04554280266165733,
-0.5040087699890137,
0.05721220746636391,
-0.07461636513471603,
0.1967446357011795,
-0.017049359157681465,
0.7722396850585938,
0.07111173123121262,
-0.8344239592552185,
0.42315730452537537,
-0.17318567633628845,
0.2980809211730957,
-0.7682238817214966,
0.08000488579273224,
-0.14749863743782043,
0.14316976070404053,
0.060765303671360016,
-0.5742151141166687,
0.5779417753219604,
0.10790988802909851,
-0.08756791800260544,
-0.5314081907272339,
0.5967971682548523,
-0.5112812519073486,
-0.747527003288269,
0.07753005623817444,
0.721585214138031,
-0.15238554775714874,
-0.3748597800731659,
-0.9036316275596619,
-0.1370362788438797,
-0.1566341370344162,
-0.1787872016429901,
0.2294759452342987,
0.5486722588539124,
-0.1955414116382599,
0.872297465801239,
1.1637598276138306,
0.08014099299907684,
-0.12482353299856186,
0.1387636512517929,
1.0080021619796753,
-0.6482143402099609,
-0.7367470264434814,
-0.9670684933662415,
0.46086418628692627,
-0.012410811148583889,
-0.32045239210128784,
0.6862539052963257,
0.6761243939399719,
1.0075932741165161,
0.012822914868593216,
0.8894463181495667,
0.25276070833206177,
0.7000362873077393,
-0.7129829525947571,
0.8856476545333862,
-0.3362361788749695,
0.12442295998334885,
-0.22714552283287048,
-0.9254508018493652,
-0.6033157706260681,
0.9506857991218567,
-0.7722926735877991,
0.26700878143310547,
0.7268132567405701,
0.5002924203872681,
-0.2440975159406662,
-0.11879930645227432,
0.2554153800010681,
0.01263611763715744,
0.40204769372940063,
0.3636574149131775,
0.6874619126319885,
-0.1964787095785141,
0.4176574647426605,
-0.31173503398895264,
-0.2064477503299713,
0.0867994874715805,
-0.744286298751831,
-1.032005786895752,
-0.6835325360298157,
-0.3871906101703644,
-0.0013210729230195284,
-0.22262217104434967,
1.0495907068252563,
0.8535383343696594,
-0.7538720369338989,
-0.22060427069664001,
-0.4248237907886505,
0.09094000607728958,
0.09214334934949875,
-0.2148095667362213,
0.15102669596672058,
-0.6014639139175415,
-0.7254340052604675,
0.37839657068252563,
0.31543442606925964,
0.12377125769853592,
-0.35276883840560913,
0.10672005265951157,
-0.10118644684553146,
0.13408969342708588,
0.4159851372241974,
0.29128319025039673,
-0.30779123306274414,
0.15868860483169556,
0.2204044759273529,
-0.1952349990606308,
-0.044276125729084015,
0.8398586511611938,
-1.1211121082305908,
0.4302199184894562,
0.33954912424087524,
0.8785656690597534,
0.31031206250190735,
0.06368563324213028,
0.7005306482315063,
-0.24664083123207092,
0.1575821042060852,
0.48640918731689453,
0.2905236780643463,
0.11715450882911682,
-0.25103652477264404,
0.3719870448112488,
0.643197238445282,
-0.6504750847816467,
-0.7559648156166077,
0.19932036101818085,
-0.5388834476470947,
-0.2816159725189209,
1.1128507852554321,
-0.09984897077083588,
-0.29112207889556885,
-0.2524891793727875,
-0.05648467317223549,
-0.013076059520244598,
-0.1997901201248169,
0.8390467762947083,
0.7951647043228149,
0.20238693058490753,
-0.295061856508255,
-0.6426670551300049,
0.5922356247901917,
0.6722068190574646,
-1.1440213918685913,
0.0940493568778038,
0.6578822731971741,
0.1654721200466156,
-0.06108627840876579,
0.5066806674003601,
-0.07176724076271057,
0.2841780483722687,
-0.2476010024547577,
-0.18065650761127472,
-0.15018042922019958,
-0.7210899591445923,
-0.30064231157302856,
-0.2897520661354065,
-0.3113609254360199,
0.17640326917171478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07616v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07616v3 | Anchor-based Large Language Models | 2024-02-12T12:48:02 | 2024-06-01T04:52:17 | Jianhui Pang, Fanghua Ye, Derek Fai Wong, Xin He, Wanshun Chen, Longyue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) predominantly employ decoder-only transformer
architectures, necessitating the retention of keys/values information for
historical tokens to provide contextual information and avoid redundant
computation. However, the substantial size and parameter volume of these LLMs
require massive GPU memory. This memory demand increases with the length of the
input text, leading to an urgent need for more efficient methods of information
storage and processing. This study introduces Anchor-based LLMs (AnLLMs), which
utilize an innovative anchor-based self-attention network (AnSAN) and also an
anchor-based inference strategy. This approach enables LLMs to compress
sequence information into an anchor token, reducing the keys/values cache and
enhancing inference efficiency. Experiments on question-answering benchmarks
reveal that AnLLMs maintain similar accuracy levels while achieving up to 99%
keys/values cache reduction and up to 3.5 times faster inference. Despite a
minor compromise in accuracy, the substantial enhancements of AnLLMs employing
the AnSAN technique in resource utilization and computational efficiency
underscore their potential for practical LLM applications. | [
-0.25186973810195923,
-0.7213952541351318,
0.6897690892219543,
0.1943598836660385,
-0.18752698600292206,
0.18608307838439941,
-0.26955148577690125,
-0.2027532011270523,
0.21528469026088715,
0.3070376217365265,
-0.2649356722831726,
-0.611994206905365,
-0.3835189640522003,
0.15410926938056946,
-0.49692168831825256,
0.3663206696510315,
0.1248898133635521,
-0.07599303871393204,
-0.19983536005020142,
-0.23533190786838531,
-0.24729999899864197,
-0.5001202821731567,
-0.9501857757568359,
-0.07447809725999832,
0.41909581422805786,
0.36571651697158813,
1.0135456323623657,
1.4855082035064697,
0.3694564402103424,
0.27112939953804016,
-0.25570690631866455,
-0.07008980959653854,
-0.5295944809913635,
0.030110497027635574,
-0.3115023970603943,
-0.48328250646591187,
-0.5356872081756592,
-0.20657770335674286,
0.8274127840995789,
0.4760645925998688,
-0.09483952075242996,
0.2957504689693451,
-0.23253116011619568,
0.6364790201187134,
-0.8346386551856995,
0.2751193642616272,
-0.5795326828956604,
-0.09529676288366318,
-0.15036563575267792,
-0.10603450238704681,
-0.4376756250858307,
-0.2530950903892517,
0.07446750998497009,
-0.3596429228782654,
0.05824403092265129,
0.2203667163848877,
0.6927581429481506,
0.46460026502609253,
-0.1460651159286499,
-0.23084920644760132,
-0.47377559542655945,
0.7662310600280762,
-1.2117207050323486,
0.44631582498550415,
0.24796949326992035,
0.051690444350242615,
-0.18285515904426575,
-0.4903613030910492,
-0.38501739501953125,
-0.09155851602554321,
-0.10118553787469864,
-0.0930207297205925,
0.07318983227014542,
0.19825153052806854,
0.2420830875635147,
0.45535022020339966,
-0.4875941872596741,
0.2521638572216034,
-0.15041092038154602,
0.08486495912075043,
0.6899129748344421,
0.1605483442544937,
0.40456780791282654,
-0.2507578730583191,
-0.3621433973312378,
-0.04256083816289902,
-1.136123538017273,
-0.14538481831550598,
0.18079395592212677,
0.25351482629776,
-0.05886697396636009,
0.37461984157562256,
-0.11922699958086014,
0.6197816729545593,
0.16988343000411987,
-0.31832024455070496,
-0.013938624411821365,
-0.08265113085508347,
-0.2165534794330597,
0.24579520523548126,
0.7928422689437866,
0.04097030684351921,
0.373801589012146,
-0.3114241659641266,
0.02704019285738468,
-0.06959424167871475,
0.2968202829360962,
-0.7651225924491882,
-0.1537545919418335,
0.25718414783477783,
-0.608967661857605,
-0.02664615400135517,
-0.3201335668563843,
-0.7645397782325745,
-0.19014114141464233,
-0.20632636547088623,
0.30175185203552246,
-0.17070594429969788,
-0.1945122480392456,
0.06727682054042816,
0.2494249790906906,
0.4135928153991699,
0.2906849980354309,
-0.8737561106681824,
0.26837578415870667,
0.4226846694946289,
0.8985466957092285,
-0.6652339696884155,
-0.13089603185653687,
-0.34996509552001953,
0.5363371968269348,
-0.27333351969718933,
0.5264953970909119,
-0.7220751047134399,
-0.3419373035430908,
0.06040431186556816,
-0.07456065714359283,
-0.20341792702674866,
-0.34605294466018677,
0.35139521956443787,
-0.7715615630149841,
-0.1787356585264206,
-0.1293073296546936,
-0.693602979183197,
-0.4060634672641754,
0.17007705569267273,
-0.8644862174987793,
0.9720728397369385,
-0.374619722366333,
-0.48728224635124207,
-0.3435470759868622,
-0.4343184232711792,
-0.5519793629646301,
-0.001398327061906457,
-0.24514277279376984,
-0.35370922088623047,
0.38660719990730286,
0.515555202960968,
0.4810953438282013,
-0.65346360206604,
0.3207848370075226,
-0.36005499958992004,
-0.6248347163200378,
0.0935259535908699,
-0.6324640512466431,
0.2502102553844452,
0.16081960499286652,
-0.3824104368686676,
0.07823797315359116,
-0.7444411516189575,
-0.16284263134002686,
0.21568074822425842,
-0.48813360929489136,
-0.35037070512771606,
0.13880082964897156,
-0.2926545739173889,
0.1978391408920288,
0.3943847715854645,
-0.5266104936599731,
0.30690672993659973,
-0.36360257863998413,
0.5585793852806091,
0.5028913021087646,
-0.1223888248205185,
0.48817676305770874,
-0.018511725589632988,
0.44568586349487305,
-0.10755890607833862,
-0.06922949105501175,
-0.6267725229263306,
-0.31552255153656006,
-0.9679401516914368,
-0.27136844396591187,
0.17976568639278412,
0.5207310914993286,
-0.4570792019367218,
0.1248922273516655,
-0.4858437478542328,
-0.18568538129329681,
-0.6608991026878357,
0.2640654742717743,
0.4452959895133972,
0.5567241311073303,
0.5710217356681824,
-0.17648255825042725,
-0.29139596223831177,
-0.6872404217720032,
-0.18983767926692963,
-0.18573346734046936,
0.04270082712173462,
0.445858359336853,
0.2500084638595581,
0.060754384845495224,
1.0223523378372192,
-0.39066341519355774,
-0.14426599442958832,
-0.14422199130058289,
-0.08181435614824295,
0.39797183871269226,
0.3529622256755829,
0.17453987896442413,
-0.7474032640457153,
-0.4849291741847992,
-0.26361384987831116,
-0.843940258026123,
-0.031327761709690094,
-0.1319248378276825,
0.11359702795743942,
0.13365694880485535,
0.8225061297416687,
-0.8102726936340332,
0.5792726278305054,
0.7012119889259338,
-0.05230269208550453,
0.3993343114852905,
-0.30193910002708435,
-0.030481552705168724,
-0.9503795504570007,
0.0657212883234024,
-0.17763479053974152,
-0.17602889239788055,
-0.6171766519546509,
-0.17421621084213257,
0.40916872024536133,
-0.08014724403619766,
-0.46517980098724365,
0.8738037347793579,
-0.8551623225212097,
-0.27955320477485657,
-0.5244482159614563,
0.10526365041732788,
0.012742268852889538,
0.6033098697662354,
0.29039716720581055,
1.056261658668518,
0.5066043138504028,
-0.6930230259895325,
0.2266203761100769,
0.2571949064731598,
-0.035895854234695435,
0.13144361972808838,
-0.7198058366775513,
0.19022248685359955,
-0.26494482159614563,
0.12067319452762604,
-1.3372604846954346,
-0.12316989153623581,
-0.18118275701999664,
-0.22150659561157227,
0.6705647110939026,
-0.21858583390712738,
-0.3833577632904053,
-0.4073469042778015,
-0.37282097339630127,
0.7208216190338135,
0.4205026924610138,
-0.8391417860984802,
0.7222737073898315,
0.314335435628891,
-0.36261510848999023,
-0.6592679619789124,
-0.5336556434631348,
0.4643819332122803,
-0.44500085711479187,
-0.4410354495048523,
0.29939135909080505,
0.22831834852695465,
0.2006930112838745,
0.4037350118160248,
-0.11805079877376556,
0.15776310861110687,
0.04757934436202049,
0.1801658272743225,
0.21871443092823029,
-0.5254278779029846,
0.5749302506446838,
-0.010577620007097721,
-0.2636505365371704,
0.11046776175498962,
-0.34296169877052307,
0.48052793741226196,
-0.26190614700317383,
-0.46569451689720154,
-0.4663318693637848,
0.341916024684906,
0.8388407826423645,
-0.4844147264957428,
0.9695866107940674,
0.264721542596817,
-0.19683462381362915,
0.01049555279314518,
-1.0289665460586548,
-0.23356993496418,
-0.46644482016563416,
0.36253830790519714,
-0.3234633207321167,
-1.0967156887054443,
0.598656415939331,
-0.3792070150375366,
-0.14918255805969238,
0.45896273851394653,
0.6651711463928223,
0.021623779088258743,
0.9870896935462952,
0.1720610111951828,
-0.6191919445991516,
0.30366283655166626,
-0.039909727871418,
0.3814372718334198,
-1.0283318758010864,
0.1778544783592224,
-0.3555600345134735,
-0.20973452925682068,
-0.3189205825328827,
-0.7116615176200867,
0.23880760371685028,
0.11210842430591583,
-0.37761175632476807,
0.1983800083398819,
-0.21423101425170898,
0.3342169523239136,
0.44643551111221313,
-0.18909952044487,
0.47973790764808655,
-0.10064314305782318,
-0.1518016755580902,
0.18448880314826965,
-0.9261133074760437,
-0.5839552283287048,
1.2028486728668213,
0.6264020204544067,
1.3072572946548462,
-0.02807486429810524,
0.30128952860832214,
0.0951659232378006,
0.40238040685653687,
-0.5884270071983337,
0.472433477640152,
0.03525882214307785,
-0.5581119060516357,
-0.5949252247810364,
-0.19756831228733063,
-0.7301029562950134,
0.2651697099208832,
-0.007120312657207251,
-0.7658947110176086,
-0.04183804243803024,
0.3156059682369232,
-0.18779869377613068,
0.5382904410362244,
-0.5559024214744568,
0.7312487363815308,
-0.3257674276828766,
-0.6588568687438965,
-0.20191176235675812,
-0.6308531165122986,
0.18792511522769928,
0.0038125806022435427,
0.21315217018127441,
-0.27423587441444397,
-0.24064426124095917,
0.49427616596221924,
-0.2918834090232849,
0.8543806076049805,
0.11227159202098846,
-0.12084045261144638,
0.4702329635620117,
-0.10482360422611237,
0.8118975758552551,
0.15020053088665009,
-0.26933786273002625,
0.3301210105419159,
-0.38267239928245544,
-0.2869510352611542,
-0.6959553956985474,
0.8689253926277161,
-0.6095134019851685,
-0.8856332898139954,
-0.18985874950885773,
-0.7342857122421265,
-0.22072167694568634,
0.07277542352676392,
-0.1484941840171814,
0.4438094198703766,
0.13349483907222748,
0.47687023878097534,
0.8194788694381714,
-0.37795940041542053,
0.7654879093170166,
0.5204905271530151,
0.030929898843169212,
-0.43441063165664673,
0.686532735824585,
-0.037872154265642166,
0.27164995670318604,
0.585841178894043,
0.2878943085670471,
-0.7421841621398926,
-0.7177407741546631,
-0.6413537859916687,
0.5944384336471558,
-0.5684685111045837,
-0.3564552664756775,
-0.6053478121757507,
-0.38444894552230835,
-0.31862789392471313,
-0.106244295835495,
-0.7735958695411682,
-0.19682905077934265,
-0.15772858262062073,
-0.15731549263000488,
0.4132281243801117,
0.6577247381210327,
0.13771399855613708,
0.4845413863658905,
-0.8607298731803894,
0.2783482074737549,
0.2673407793045044,
0.4728820323944092,
0.48849546909332275,
-0.39004266262054443,
-0.3093337416648865,
-0.2569611966609955,
0.16611671447753906,
-0.9232214689254761,
0.410895973443985,
0.1919676661491394,
0.6000531315803528,
0.45873844623565674,
-0.0337173268198967,
0.6963180303573608,
-0.6979649066925049,
0.4709622263908386,
-0.03149484470486641,
-0.9472877979278564,
0.35922080278396606,
-0.2905189096927643,
0.6775582432746887,
0.44461706280708313,
0.4720034599304199,
-0.35381847620010376,
-0.3538563847541809,
-0.28472262620925903,
-0.9248072504997253,
0.569876492023468,
0.1656283736228943,
0.18513624370098114,
-0.2532975673675537,
0.7614264488220215,
-0.3639713227748871,
0.3505382835865021,
-0.5888118147850037,
-0.4585087299346924,
0.14691095054149628,
-0.44399094581604004,
-0.17275948822498322,
-0.583610475063324,
0.34964606165885925,
-0.07269249111413956,
0.6093860864639282,
-0.2706734538078308,
0.11772102862596512,
0.1914636790752411,
-0.2985071539878845,
0.035827841609716415,
0.31848469376564026,
0.30762407183647156,
0.6044227480888367,
-0.056340090930461884,
0.3209722340106964,
0.6028141975402832,
-0.48299387097358704,
0.3277680575847626,
-0.20709288120269775,
-0.30894535779953003,
-0.14386804401874542,
0.2612551748752594,
0.9574156999588013,
0.4853236675262451,
-0.5539165139198303,
0.3515785336494446,
-0.06840503215789795,
0.32939279079437256,
-0.03529857099056244,
-0.01944313384592533,
0.5862293243408203,
0.19905565679073334,
0.5451911687850952,
-0.6508584022521973,
0.09221033751964569,
-0.253280371427536,
0.18334724009037018,
0.4558190107345581,
-0.37337714433670044,
-0.15623342990875244,
0.808060348033905,
0.12558194994926453,
-0.22302858531475067,
0.5793957114219666,
0.07394875586032867,
-0.39645639061927795,
0.4848037660121918,
0.8282153010368347,
0.7417205572128296,
-0.7101845145225525,
-0.12023649364709854,
0.5188816785812378,
0.16425465047359467,
-0.15224313735961914,
-0.0009622247889637947,
-0.05694659799337387,
-0.5659098625183105,
-0.7908147573471069,
-0.9106578230857849,
-0.4153277277946472,
0.2980101704597473,
-0.5937047600746155,
-0.030011456459760666,
-0.34479600191116333,
-0.06804642081260681,
-0.5804538726806641,
-0.1634046882390976,
-0.4516015350818634,
0.3653452396392822,
0.26667898893356323,
0.9631067514419556,
-0.7625895738601685,
0.9221858978271484,
0.6419054865837097,
0.013856571167707443,
-0.805949866771698,
-0.129239022731781,
-0.09470520913600922,
-0.8123595118522644,
0.4910140633583069,
0.3330373764038086,
-0.25304749608039856,
0.21467429399490356,
-0.19976314902305603,
-1.541539192199707,
1.0729974508285522,
0.40200304985046387,
-0.5860759615898132,
-0.3719078600406647,
0.20499682426452637,
0.5193029642105103,
-0.48601019382476807,
0.37673884630203247,
0.6118063926696777,
0.2880978584289551,
0.4138183295726776,
-0.6777551770210266,
0.37933602929115295,
-0.17066362500190735,
0.44435665011405945,
0.25831338763237,
-0.7228763103485107,
0.732690691947937,
-0.20373329520225525,
-0.25554075837135315,
-0.08086222410202026,
0.9205084443092346,
0.3152441084384918,
-0.1231168881058693,
0.33586543798446655,
0.6278431415557861,
0.5323076248168945,
0.1376299113035202,
0.973345160484314,
-0.6667329668998718,
0.32614007592201233,
1.2806103229522705,
-0.11612973362207413,
1.1091804504394531,
0.40385812520980835,
-0.00606409041211009,
0.46217799186706543,
0.3156668543815613,
0.13534073531627655,
0.3496290147304535,
0.3487059772014618,
-0.2583262026309967,
-0.34206077456474304,
-0.04198523238301277,
-0.24432604014873505,
0.4470301866531372,
0.6319844722747803,
-0.2967573404312134,
-0.334968626499176,
-0.23183195292949677,
0.159173846244812,
-0.10677499324083328,
-0.4663582444190979,
0.6885655522346497,
0.26417791843414307,
-0.6412401795387268,
0.3869269788265228,
0.06005494296550751,
0.33603179454803467,
-0.47846561670303345,
0.01925390213727951,
-0.1905713528394699,
0.16804678738117218,
-0.013735002838075161,
-0.4901454746723175,
0.05936449393630028,
-0.043297845870256424,
-0.04871484264731407,
-0.16217747330665588,
0.9495465159416199,
-0.6369634866714478,
-0.3746322989463806,
0.3876395523548126,
0.39244574308395386,
0.0010044645750895143,
-0.16659067571163177,
-0.4952688217163086,
0.253452867269516,
-0.39173030853271484,
-0.5381659269332886,
0.3314369022846222,
0.18621115386486053,
-0.11468571424484253,
0.899969220161438,
0.5726088881492615,
0.11932146549224854,
0.3441134989261627,
-0.12077800184488297,
0.8060446381568909,
-0.837774395942688,
-0.6375467777252197,
-1.0490041971206665,
0.21956607699394226,
-0.08354155719280243,
0.06871715188026428,
0.9765790104866028,
0.6238665580749512,
0.36332783102989197,
-0.02708149142563343,
0.712334930896759,
0.5042004585266113,
0.4249870181083679,
-0.5983954071998596,
0.590757429599762,
-0.4578668773174286,
0.15788094699382782,
-0.1351768970489502,
-1.0021483898162842,
-0.25510483980178833,
0.6061338782310486,
-0.37812569737434387,
0.02064119279384613,
0.5510960221290588,
0.6277515888214111,
-0.0470903180539608,
-0.015072333626449108,
0.272114098072052,
0.35812562704086304,
0.3402203321456909,
0.7252537608146667,
0.584907591342926,
-0.4459971487522125,
0.43600329756736755,
0.10733605921268463,
-0.07253832370042801,
-0.3989502787590027,
-1.1083472967147827,
-1.1674240827560425,
-0.15528258681297302,
-0.2842785120010376,
-0.10202303528785706,
0.18650972843170166,
0.6059101223945618,
0.6407901644706726,
-0.9072583317756653,
-0.45520830154418945,
-0.11394544690847397,
0.23099800944328308,
0.26766929030418396,
-0.15492753684520721,
0.8737167716026306,
-0.5918383598327637,
-0.6498605012893677,
0.5492926836013794,
0.8690682649612427,
-0.006757256109267473,
-0.3931310176849365,
-0.12548241019248962,
-0.49694105982780457,
0.2522183656692505,
0.46563956141471863,
0.48241594433784485,
-0.7942198514938354,
-0.37087494134902954,
0.08184544742107391,
-0.15395082533359528,
0.26601606607437134,
0.4390883147716522,
-0.8587851524353027,
0.48414960503578186,
0.3820592164993286,
1.2199763059616089,
0.758820652961731,
0.3751280903816223,
0.8008042573928833,
-0.4680674374103546,
0.03383436053991318,
-0.09926799684762955,
0.27744078636169434,
0.4237441420555115,
-0.32554861903190613,
0.39866524934768677,
-0.061584506183862686,
-0.38832783699035645,
-0.5120075345039368,
0.009089136496186256,
-0.6134465336799622,
-0.1111401841044426,
1.2840321063995361,
-0.4052944779396057,
-0.5678369402885437,
-0.039581939578056335,
0.0036486696917563677,
0.2589842975139618,
-0.33142101764678955,
0.6652246713638306,
0.6217365264892578,
0.03912030905485153,
-0.31941065192222595,
-0.40216895937919617,
0.5335198044776917,
0.6145228743553162,
-0.8305215239524841,
-0.0011543779401108623,
0.14159706234931946,
0.1706237494945526,
0.1936132311820984,
0.5885047316551208,
-0.07552999258041382,
0.12834252417087555,
-0.24660806357860565,
-0.05680840462446213,
-0.08120283484458923,
-0.5360097885131836,
-0.4937454164028168,
0.454434335231781,
-0.02753562480211258,
-0.09766285866498947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07610v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07610v3 | Step-On-Feet Tuning: Scaling Self-Alignment of LLMs via Bootstrapping | 2024-02-12T12:30:42 | 2024-06-27T16:38:35 | Haoyu Wang, Guozheng Ma, Ziqiao Meng, Zeyu Qin, Li Shen, Zhong Zhang, Bingzhe Wu, Liu Liu, Yatao Bian, Tingyang Xu, Xueqian Wang, Peilin Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-alignment is an effective way to reduce the cost of human annotation
while ensuring promising model capability. However, most current methods
complete the data collection and training steps in a single round, which may
overlook the continuously improving ability of self-aligned models. This gives
rise to a key query: What if we do multi-time bootstrapping self-alignment?
Does this strategy enhance model performance or lead to rapid degradation? In
this paper, our pioneering exploration delves into the impact of bootstrapping
self-alignment on large language models. Our findings reveal that bootstrapping
self-alignment markedly surpasses the single-round approach, by guaranteeing
data diversity from in-context learning. To further exploit the capabilities of
bootstrapping, we investigate and adjust the training order of data, which
yields improved performance of the model. Drawing on these findings, we propose
Step-On-Feet Tuning (SOFT) which leverages model's continuously enhanced
few-shot ability to boost zero or one-shot performance. Based on easy-to-hard
training recipe, we propose SOFT+ which further boost self-alignment's
performance. Our experiments demonstrate the efficiency of SOFT (SOFT+) across
various classification and generation tasks, highlighting the potential of
bootstrapping self-alignment on continually enhancing model alignment
performance. | [
-0.10479449480772018,
-0.2968127727508545,
0.4678475856781006,
0.13605839014053345,
-0.35014235973358154,
0.36431506276130676,
-0.17048269510269165,
-0.5199611186981201,
0.06968004256486893,
0.32616564631462097,
-0.8271661400794983,
-0.20053650438785553,
-0.3921281099319458,
0.08953174203634262,
-0.39653879404067993,
1.0768492221832275,
0.11259551346302032,
0.26503971219062805,
-0.032255709171295166,
-0.529015839099884,
-0.2810388505458832,
-0.21047361195087433,
-0.4980515241622925,
-0.3530244827270508,
0.4076848328113556,
0.6551831364631653,
0.8153758645057678,
1.364439606666565,
0.5313386917114258,
0.3360879123210907,
0.08466704934835434,
0.06656304746866226,
-0.2816971242427826,
0.3013803958892822,
0.09995868057012558,
-0.5125348567962646,
-0.7087324261665344,
0.13640905916690826,
0.8917602300643921,
0.5626720786094666,
-0.26300355792045593,
0.4914526641368866,
0.05368863046169281,
0.8918565511703491,
-0.5005765557289124,
-0.3648871183395386,
-0.5877860188484192,
-0.003888479433953762,
-0.34467828273773193,
-0.2772527039051056,
-0.04455722123384476,
-0.0915984958410263,
-0.2469649612903595,
-0.5267990827560425,
0.46887660026550293,
0.023328328505158424,
0.5395135879516602,
0.563237190246582,
-0.24732768535614014,
0.05902286246418953,
-0.6738213300704956,
0.6969497799873352,
-0.8622248768806458,
0.46037203073501587,
0.013053868897259235,
0.2846633791923523,
-0.03473025932908058,
-0.4157939851284027,
-0.27269160747528076,
-0.10525394976139069,
-0.012926760129630566,
-0.3130246102809906,
0.3353452682495117,
-0.06561440229415894,
0.27456557750701904,
0.33629000186920166,
-0.4400613605976105,
0.3543756306171417,
-0.2342916876077652,
-0.2622324526309967,
0.7230167388916016,
0.230024054646492,
0.13414223492145538,
0.0009822312276810408,
-0.6495838165283203,
-0.07414116710424423,
-0.9740304946899414,
-0.0002774575259536505,
0.3752550184726715,
0.8099145293235779,
-0.1223820224404335,
0.31702563166618347,
-0.2883246839046478,
0.9168933629989624,
0.43059298396110535,
-0.44404512643814087,
0.24383331835269928,
-0.6215561628341675,
-0.12559911608695984,
0.23652082681655884,
0.6619169116020203,
0.20041018724441528,
0.16189426183700562,
-0.2574769854545593,
-0.38820430636405945,
-0.22499780356884003,
0.26688340306282043,
-0.9249712824821472,
0.05217611417174339,
0.2994143068790436,
-0.15343032777309418,
-0.4464024305343628,
-0.2630516588687897,
-0.7164223194122314,
-0.5594505071640015,
-0.6321098208427429,
0.5288495421409607,
-0.19952496886253357,
-0.321341872215271,
0.14588023722171783,
0.24203406274318695,
0.1940794140100479,
0.30899161100387573,
-1.2165275812149048,
0.3699662387371063,
0.7090327739715576,
1.050656795501709,
-0.22994039952754974,
-0.5585107803344727,
-0.8189525008201599,
-0.027484217658638954,
-0.5632553696632385,
0.5457192063331604,
-0.30011090636253357,
0.022561196237802505,
-0.10054369270801544,
-0.05716247856616974,
0.1439027041196823,
-0.41635775566101074,
0.011322284117341042,
-0.2537582218647003,
-0.05941122770309448,
-0.3123399615287781,
-0.44616463780403137,
0.2572105824947357,
0.15297536551952362,
-0.45277559757232666,
1.2094275951385498,
0.04969872534275055,
-0.5231969952583313,
0.7029426693916321,
-0.4983516335487366,
-0.6629692912101746,
0.07927234470844269,
-0.24398377537727356,
-0.5532717704772949,
0.1836426705121994,
0.3178633451461792,
0.7842797040939331,
-0.24806804955005646,
0.0889650508761406,
-0.22525131702423096,
-0.3675828278064728,
-0.04088849946856499,
-0.09030374139547348,
0.663282036781311,
0.06409808248281479,
-0.7496128678321838,
0.15481255948543549,
-1.1458543539047241,
0.06944400817155838,
0.12253157049417496,
-0.39885514974594116,
-0.18949642777442932,
-0.09187716990709305,
0.04234330356121063,
0.47125595808029175,
0.19543933868408203,
-0.4711231589317322,
0.5850878357887268,
-0.37500014901161194,
0.34384849667549133,
0.8892667293548584,
-0.3326004445552826,
0.7749714255332947,
-0.2666034400463104,
0.6331231594085693,
-0.10372594743967056,
0.13914309442043304,
-0.4220314621925354,
-0.16285927593708038,
-0.8694393038749695,
-0.28064969182014465,
0.6716016530990601,
0.26128292083740234,
-0.36371564865112305,
0.25753507018089294,
-0.3732951879501343,
-0.6146115660667419,
-1.1439989805221558,
0.5547155737876892,
0.4354550540447235,
0.5717602968215942,
0.5484873056411743,
-0.3773671090602875,
-0.17751267552375793,
-0.7486134767532349,
-0.3065910041332245,
-0.009217099286615849,
-0.07684177905321121,
0.061619631946086884,
0.2526152431964874,
0.18058957159519196,
0.9421643614768982,
-0.14569838345050812,
-0.23991818726062775,
-0.01528250053524971,
0.3257109820842743,
-0.14009761810302734,
0.7433686256408691,
0.45444098114967346,
-0.49351799488067627,
-0.3736404776573181,
-0.006689759436994791,
-0.48800867795944214,
-0.17488345503807068,
-0.512130856513977,
-0.13276809453964233,
0.3237191438674927,
0.5485753417015076,
-0.3005031645298004,
0.03990353271365166,
0.6436833739280701,
-0.33289745450019836,
0.3151402473449707,
-0.2755395174026489,
0.27127254009246826,
-0.960371196269989,
-0.12631842494010925,
0.1463327407836914,
-0.5149036645889282,
-0.5910274982452393,
0.11446405947208405,
0.5275946855545044,
0.11274348199367523,
-0.5203988552093506,
0.3791995942592621,
-0.7637443542480469,
-0.1544126719236374,
-0.2858821153640747,
0.19833114743232727,
-0.14243286848068237,
0.3763708472251892,
0.006562789902091026,
0.7880920171737671,
0.6800107955932617,
-0.6143004894256592,
0.11520320177078247,
-0.0819142758846283,
-0.44182050228118896,
0.5034923553466797,
-0.3126116991043091,
0.4481699466705322,
0.01708274707198143,
0.09074787050485611,
-1.0511709451675415,
0.015010123141109943,
-0.08738555014133453,
-0.12362145632505417,
0.9319084286689758,
-0.4790573716163635,
-0.6267936825752258,
0.013843842782080173,
-0.4458666145801544,
0.474514901638031,
0.20358885824680328,
-0.8784664273262024,
0.5539613366127014,
0.19246412813663483,
0.10021574795246124,
-0.5633595585823059,
-0.5573447942733765,
-0.04087553545832634,
-0.42831143736839294,
-0.6050229668617249,
0.4769004285335541,
-0.13799001276493073,
-0.006135020405054092,
-0.5569953918457031,
-0.4149574637413025,
0.3836710453033447,
0.15848135948181152,
0.15965484082698822,
0.1921147257089615,
-0.36708182096481323,
0.3313702642917633,
-0.0519726537168026,
-0.3168083429336548,
-0.27999451756477356,
-0.39051035046577454,
0.4572494626045227,
-0.2483195811510086,
-0.3063664138317108,
-0.3387898802757263,
0.09596262872219086,
0.8842747211456299,
-0.24014832079410553,
0.6289160847663879,
0.5908668637275696,
-0.18282248079776764,
-0.12177436798810959,
-0.829026997089386,
-0.2558046281337738,
-0.5607710480690002,
0.13947544991970062,
-0.33135277032852173,
-0.7488105893135071,
0.24625957012176514,
-0.3262505829334259,
0.21633785963058472,
0.3899311423301697,
0.5760611295700073,
-0.22954599559307098,
0.9208434820175171,
0.9660834670066833,
-0.3381786346435547,
0.49558326601982117,
0.030073119327425957,
-0.1292777955532074,
-0.7668231725692749,
-0.06357702612876892,
-0.6087750196456909,
-0.6115130186080933,
-0.8232773542404175,
-0.44125285744667053,
0.20108196139335632,
0.012615175917744637,
-0.38659706711769104,
0.5262455940246582,
-0.5898363590240479,
0.5242363214492798,
0.2425525039434433,
-0.01895049959421158,
0.3350889980792999,
-0.06338077783584595,
-0.021389679983258247,
-0.17125143110752106,
-0.9139484167098999,
-0.3526898920536041,
1.1068750619888306,
0.5200513005256653,
0.9600412845611572,
-0.08939235657453537,
0.7360284924507141,
0.011164144612848759,
0.25839799642562866,
-0.6395972371101379,
0.43787524104118347,
0.09784848242998123,
-0.7127572298049927,
-0.5120007395744324,
-0.346530020236969,
-0.6524182558059692,
0.36921972036361694,
-0.3690861165523529,
-0.5289415121078491,
0.07396049797534943,
0.4832611083984375,
-0.6628074645996094,
0.34622788429260254,
-0.5741796493530273,
0.7841212153434753,
-0.8230926394462585,
-0.6190485954284668,
-0.0836201012134552,
-1.0171650648117065,
0.11974960565567017,
-0.28096500039100647,
0.32481372356414795,
-0.26955294609069824,
-0.3390737473964691,
0.6954459547996521,
-0.22041067481040955,
0.8947598934173584,
-0.0829160138964653,
-0.1916750967502594,
-0.019548309966921806,
0.2893350422382355,
0.5471159815788269,
-0.2710648775100708,
-0.01903778687119484,
0.3937385082244873,
-0.02851230837404728,
-0.4406185448169708,
-0.5805166959762573,
0.66621994972229,
-0.5753083229064941,
-0.5332601070404053,
-0.3989070653915405,
-0.42648938298225403,
-0.4755760133266449,
-0.060643211007118225,
0.14071503281593323,
0.34621661901474,
0.15366867184638977,
0.14101289212703705,
0.28172025084495544,
0.4113590717315674,
0.6447044610977173,
0.7989147901535034,
-0.2598189115524292,
-0.32129979133605957,
0.9269033670425415,
0.3288514316082001,
0.6136429905891418,
0.2159746140241623,
0.3179730474948883,
-0.2729262113571167,
-0.5163663625717163,
-0.9255887269973755,
0.4220285713672638,
-0.54347825050354,
-0.4452613890171051,
-0.2504784166812897,
0.15540477633476257,
-0.4597766697406769,
-0.2737005054950714,
-0.7918357849121094,
-0.7091271877288818,
-0.27855512499809265,
-0.1278836578130722,
0.39034321904182434,
0.7969594597816467,
-0.10942954570055008,
0.40092799067497253,
-0.6748093962669373,
0.11098772287368774,
0.19795754551887512,
0.5970959663391113,
-0.280029833316803,
-0.7823192477226257,
-0.444465309381485,
-0.3289572298526764,
-0.19002483785152435,
-0.6938880681991577,
0.19098138809204102,
0.20533792674541473,
0.2681053578853607,
0.469573974609375,
-0.35211873054504395,
1.038559913635254,
-0.79266756772995,
0.627140998840332,
0.3233436942100525,
-0.8778441548347473,
0.5036515593528748,
-0.40474531054496765,
0.480765700340271,
0.8559131622314453,
0.4484090209007263,
-0.4534929692745209,
-0.1579408049583435,
-0.5608870983123779,
-0.9460480213165283,
0.7838732004165649,
0.06065281853079796,
0.002852846635505557,
0.4232093393802643,
0.6390803456306458,
0.23988288640975952,
0.2848026156425476,
-0.6997170448303223,
-0.3978383243083954,
-0.02820352464914322,
-0.08972298353910446,
-0.2748396694660187,
-0.056604478508234024,
-0.06579534709453583,
-0.5785605907440186,
0.8535799980163574,
-0.49861565232276917,
-0.2796176075935364,
-0.06675674021244049,
-0.05471700429916382,
-0.6704608201980591,
0.12997722625732422,
0.4823506474494934,
0.6960920095443726,
0.01530179101973772,
0.011752222664654255,
0.37955981492996216,
-0.14112107455730438,
0.28810369968414307,
-0.1843997985124588,
-0.11535946279764175,
-0.31735774874687195,
0.24857255816459656,
0.5971478223800659,
0.48467740416526794,
-0.28937670588493347,
0.35174429416656494,
0.18703143298625946,
0.0608835406601429,
0.2003241926431656,
0.15584799647331238,
0.09768470376729965,
0.37618860602378845,
0.3582494854927063,
0.1318751871585846,
-0.11519237607717514,
-0.5046839118003845,
0.21428963541984558,
0.5830330848693848,
-0.20067785680294037,
-0.26795414090156555,
0.5785518884658813,
0.19945822656154633,
-0.6682838201522827,
0.5356762409210205,
0.13486669957637787,
-0.3774520754814148,
0.45949751138687134,
0.7031534910202026,
0.8387775421142578,
-0.5353206992149353,
0.07714571803808212,
0.4801337420940399,
0.5322657227516174,
-0.39706167578697205,
-0.10036714375019073,
-0.394201397895813,
-0.5832458138465881,
-0.42387938499450684,
-0.8654776811599731,
-0.36985665559768677,
0.16684585809707642,
-0.6270147562026978,
0.43160659074783325,
-0.4441068470478058,
-0.05611855909228325,
-0.06771516799926758,
-0.020473090931773186,
-0.6005119681358337,
0.48803240060806274,
0.3553635776042938,
0.8544049859046936,
-1.0099990367889404,
0.8124496936798096,
0.4685383439064026,
-0.19717936217784882,
-0.6598960757255554,
0.2236226499080658,
0.2570353150367737,
-0.735161304473877,
0.1840721070766449,
0.30011236667633057,
-0.42232364416122437,
0.07351922988891602,
-0.7399002313613892,
-1.20969557762146,
1.2851442098617554,
0.5082329511642456,
-0.9782092571258545,
0.008240194991230965,
0.1488223522901535,
0.5919361114501953,
-0.5277827978134155,
-0.10159134864807129,
0.8914253115653992,
0.2841816544532776,
0.105097196996212,
-1.0053366422653198,
0.16696995496749878,
-0.054107435047626495,
-0.1289331614971161,
0.32069915533065796,
-0.8442236185073853,
0.5967638492584229,
-0.302170068025589,
-0.09434925764799118,
-0.07759831845760345,
0.7146764397621155,
0.11044210940599442,
0.010220360942184925,
0.6674813032150269,
0.4144037961959839,
0.7397017478942871,
0.028325064107775688,
0.8307063579559326,
-0.5529755353927612,
0.38429874181747437,
1.2509307861328125,
-0.1182311549782753,
0.8543494939804077,
0.672309398651123,
-0.3159530758857727,
0.42027294635772705,
0.6333410739898682,
0.04864523932337761,
0.2510639727115631,
0.14640942215919495,
-0.09451252967119217,
-0.6720101237297058,
0.34721481800079346,
-0.2559807002544403,
0.6161868572235107,
0.13091087341308594,
-0.14256195724010468,
-0.17231284081935883,
-0.22804418206214905,
-0.03903559222817421,
-0.18970654904842377,
-0.34463992714881897,
0.6293149590492249,
-0.102124884724617,
-0.7032435536384583,
0.5009272694587708,
0.0019675851799547672,
0.7764825224876404,
-0.7281768321990967,
0.0667693167924881,
-0.1998530775308609,
-0.0032763448543846607,
-0.313632071018219,
-0.46426984667778015,
-0.022028407081961632,
0.015703976154327393,
0.09326587617397308,
-0.6045195460319519,
0.6546881794929504,
-0.4411885738372803,
-0.723345160484314,
0.2775156497955322,
0.5709580779075623,
0.1481926590204239,
0.04679214209318161,
-0.8281940221786499,
0.010037533938884735,
-0.18574535846710205,
-0.3824331760406494,
0.7536004781723022,
0.2564217150211334,
0.21112920343875885,
0.7123467922210693,
0.5634693503379822,
0.07388278096914291,
0.17439548671245575,
0.014883925206959248,
0.7731039524078369,
-0.7566986680030823,
-0.29168421030044556,
-1.0252662897109985,
0.7605989575386047,
0.14800633490085602,
-0.3890102505683899,
0.644457221031189,
0.6408098936080933,
0.7012761831283569,
0.20786434412002563,
0.5052370429039001,
0.1281626969575882,
0.4041615128517151,
-0.5967200994491577,
0.806961715221405,
-0.9123756289482117,
0.22839395701885223,
-0.2343316525220871,
-0.6986827850341797,
-0.3319198191165924,
0.6215319037437439,
0.0670255646109581,
0.2730556130409241,
0.5336704254150391,
0.8587440252304077,
-0.13830839097499847,
-0.23834316432476044,
0.5004349946975708,
0.08724166452884674,
-0.007880360819399357,
0.0005798014462925494,
0.32753464579582214,
-0.43947330117225647,
0.41704657673835754,
-0.4594063460826874,
-0.26186540722846985,
-0.05722165107727051,
-1.2698817253112793,
-0.6181405782699585,
-0.680423378944397,
-0.5816437602043152,
-0.3628595471382141,
-0.13150526583194733,
1.2265015840530396,
1.0426796674728394,
-0.8200492858886719,
-0.3182962238788605,
0.038593266159296036,
-0.17421390116214752,
-0.26641976833343506,
-0.13346782326698303,
0.19623100757598877,
-0.7258973121643066,
-0.6050711274147034,
0.8255495429039001,
0.5631831288337708,
0.15498501062393188,
-0.5460307598114014,
0.002572386059910059,
-0.2791220247745514,
0.05693954601883888,
0.3580361604690552,
0.35413435101509094,
-0.5773885250091553,
-0.1491646021604538,
-0.0018719827057793736,
-0.20468293130397797,
0.5372011661529541,
1.0097544193267822,
-0.9695526361465454,
0.628110408782959,
0.051183294504880905,
0.6283707022666931,
0.7855055928230286,
0.27789023518562317,
0.5060773491859436,
-1.0439815521240234,
-0.09454528987407684,
0.010970263741910458,
0.3664413094520569,
0.6520786881446838,
-0.5316545367240906,
0.58919757604599,
0.09571057558059692,
-0.6329106092453003,
-0.6770286560058594,
0.07175227999687195,
-0.8363446593284607,
-0.055350322276353836,
1.257519245147705,
0.16860617697238922,
-0.1558525264263153,
0.11340941488742828,
-0.018199192360043526,
0.2360004037618637,
-0.18636773526668549,
0.9699297547340393,
0.6793125867843628,
-0.3401395082473755,
-0.017412224784493446,
-0.3910594880580902,
0.6399327516555786,
0.6164210438728333,
-0.7431917786598206,
0.30199527740478516,
0.4724813997745514,
0.7153447270393372,
0.32857248187065125,
0.7075403928756714,
-0.023824341595172882,
0.19972111284732819,
-0.1435229331254959,
-0.0009268713765777647,
0.042114511132240295,
-0.6728048324584961,
-0.8745641112327576,
0.2380513846874237,
0.15150214731693268,
-0.1715073138475418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07577v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07577v2 | Topic Modeling as Multi-Objective Contrastive Optimization | 2024-02-12T11:18:32 | 2024-03-09T05:35:21 | Thong Nguyen, Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Cong-Duy T Nguyen, See-Kiong Ng, Anh Tuan Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent representation learning approaches enhance neural topic models by
optimizing the weighted linear combination of the evidence lower bound (ELBO)
of the log-likelihood and the contrastive learning objective that contrasts
pairs of input documents. However, document-level contrastive learning might
capture low-level mutual information, such as word ratio, which disturbs topic
modeling. Moreover, there is a potential conflict between the ELBO loss that
memorizes input details for better reconstruction quality, and the contrastive
loss which attempts to learn topic representations that generalize among input
documents. To address these issues, we first introduce a novel contrastive
learning method oriented towards sets of topic vectors to capture useful
semantics that are shared among a set of input documents. Secondly, we
explicitly cast contrastive topic modeling as a gradient-based multi-objective
optimization problem, with the goal of achieving a Pareto stationary solution
that balances the trade-off between the ELBO and the contrastive objective.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that our framework consistently produces
higher-performing neural topic models in terms of topic coherence, topic
diversity, and downstream performance. | [
-0.6606747508049011,
-0.5771782994270325,
0.5571514368057251,
-0.002066295128315687,
-0.26822543144226074,
-0.14178091287612915,
-0.12594525516033173,
-0.045488592237234116,
0.3484251797199249,
0.4022276699542999,
-0.4112991392612457,
-0.4297865629196167,
-0.8770462870597839,
-0.43709030747413635,
-0.22862471640110016,
0.9740555286407471,
0.07981181889772415,
0.2638288140296936,
-0.343167781829834,
-0.16378282010555267,
-0.3416502773761749,
-0.3900375962257385,
-0.6377377510070801,
-0.5736138820648193,
0.5741528868675232,
0.35436391830444336,
0.05354701727628708,
0.5179024338722229,
0.6003537774085999,
0.2605631351470947,
-0.2944851219654083,
0.008450837805867195,
-0.6660078763961792,
0.03147821128368378,
-0.22259603440761566,
-0.4350648820400238,
-0.1284668743610382,
0.19374068081378937,
0.4216652810573578,
0.9103986024856567,
-0.35579219460487366,
-0.2532755732536316,
0.1965998113155365,
0.40601974725723267,
-0.7690624594688416,
-0.19920383393764496,
-0.8217025995254517,
0.13754862546920776,
0.1534339040517807,
-0.21253646910190582,
-0.2263321727514267,
0.17044663429260254,
0.25721490383148193,
-0.5928085446357727,
0.5498904585838318,
-0.24789415299892426,
1.1029280424118042,
0.32634711265563965,
-0.3702901005744934,
-0.37942758202552795,
-0.23323453962802887,
0.9830713868141174,
-0.5138670802116394,
0.11138702183961868,
0.4430343508720398,
-0.04814514145255089,
0.35026583075523376,
-0.5602341890335083,
-0.20420509576797485,
-0.1514730304479599,
-0.012564079836010933,
0.3939199447631836,
-0.11148552596569061,
0.17553775012493134,
-0.0849372148513794,
0.2760671377182007,
-0.3239184319972992,
-0.056014884263277054,
-0.3156406879425049,
-0.256845086812973,
0.19554637372493744,
0.15387001633644104,
-0.027206331491470337,
-0.20520982146263123,
-0.4289673864841461,
0.2707834243774414,
-0.32608312368392944,
-0.17149929702281952,
0.33346277475357056,
0.25066059827804565,
-0.11344918608665466,
0.3317118287086487,
0.011073312722146511,
0.43400493264198303,
0.1872800886631012,
0.06528769433498383,
0.07050864398479462,
-0.3403991460800171,
0.15718084573745728,
-0.14159908890724182,
0.3652220070362091,
0.4720207452774048,
-0.45590317249298096,
-0.06399649381637573,
-0.11019899696111679,
0.1641014963388443,
0.46032679080963135,
-0.9685282707214355,
-0.08658527582883835,
0.21757158637046814,
-0.8793546557426453,
-0.2282293289899826,
-0.018062114715576172,
-0.8606875538825989,
-0.27691981196403503,
-0.6354740858078003,
0.46659961342811584,
-0.4684378504753113,
-0.06878800690174103,
0.22137680649757385,
-0.20870783925056458,
0.03269615396857262,
0.667365550994873,
-0.883118212223053,
0.30265918374061584,
0.82872474193573,
0.9317387938499451,
-0.16404478251934052,
-0.39622634649276733,
-0.43428319692611694,
0.17589570581912994,
-0.3768678903579712,
0.5628793835639954,
-0.6092216968536377,
-0.5122226476669312,
-0.1840902864933014,
-0.4431901276111603,
-0.002316991100087762,
-0.32611575722694397,
0.4835939109325409,
-0.44024527072906494,
0.391443133354187,
-0.42094117403030396,
-0.7049443125724792,
-0.12610319256782532,
0.3534122109413147,
-0.5956305265426636,
0.6405696868896484,
-0.2242930382490158,
-0.8407568335533142,
0.1932229995727539,
-0.5529143810272217,
-0.13590367138385773,
-0.4569427967071533,
-0.21603801846504211,
-0.463318407535553,
0.4657650291919708,
0.020701279863715172,
0.5198844075202942,
-0.4649106562137604,
0.6323139667510986,
-0.2580939829349518,
-0.3257792592048645,
-0.10132382065057755,
-0.18496203422546387,
0.4194486439228058,
0.33807381987571716,
-0.049907103180885315,
0.2513431906700134,
-0.6627015471458435,
-0.6289834380149841,
-0.060377366840839386,
-0.2979656755924225,
-0.5689356327056885,
0.13736648857593536,
-0.1296822428703308,
0.21446582674980164,
0.45110347867012024,
-0.362089067697525,
-0.15044571459293365,
0.10681084543466568,
0.3517990708351135,
0.7574033737182617,
0.11668266355991364,
0.5653601288795471,
-0.4790082573890686,
0.1968303620815277,
0.23955437541007996,
-0.272053986787796,
-0.40071961283683777,
-0.3052394390106201,
-0.7972051501274109,
-0.3768042027950287,
0.32658371329307556,
0.21423205733299255,
-0.42372003197669983,
0.3649231493473053,
0.12528586387634277,
-0.41265931725502014,
-0.27003997564315796,
-0.17563176155090332,
0.36600062251091003,
0.9101418256759644,
0.3914451003074646,
-0.4189499318599701,
-0.09730321168899536,
-1.082922339439392,
0.09519189596176147,
0.07176852226257324,
0.1783481389284134,
0.5392691493034363,
0.5070685148239136,
-0.16704288125038147,
0.6164005994796753,
-0.8091762065887451,
-0.2810823619365692,
-0.10455935448408127,
0.8326550126075745,
0.2809377610683441,
0.5958362817764282,
0.7128303647041321,
-1.0583997964859009,
-0.40445488691329956,
-0.07093493640422821,
-0.6736084818840027,
-0.06906670331954956,
-0.19583961367607117,
-0.24039830267429352,
-0.2713908553123474,
0.6080393195152283,
-0.4342830777168274,
0.1886342316865921,
0.2697441875934601,
-0.05241438373923302,
0.27430352568626404,
-0.4773626923561096,
0.10181783884763718,
-1.252689003944397,
-0.0563422366976738,
0.2908787727355957,
0.18277065455913544,
-0.590595006942749,
0.04937043786048889,
0.06464321166276932,
-0.7127991914749146,
-0.26308879256248474,
0.4785820543766022,
-0.3332423269748688,
-0.07381510734558105,
-0.5395452380180359,
-0.014304080046713352,
0.2501591444015503,
0.5734673738479614,
0.15419906377792358,
0.7146838903427124,
0.7621042728424072,
-0.561644434928894,
-0.04579222947359085,
0.13085807859897614,
0.07658694684505463,
0.7155458331108093,
-0.7118433117866516,
-0.03246941789984703,
-0.6030756831169128,
0.0035896615590900183,
-0.8221541047096252,
-0.026883471757173538,
0.03498625010251999,
-0.22741256654262543,
0.6161267757415771,
0.07117769867181778,
0.170458123087883,
0.201094388961792,
-0.5534315705299377,
0.14273615181446075,
0.1690523624420166,
-0.39124321937561035,
0.7921785116195679,
0.29659777879714966,
-0.40711405873298645,
-0.9970512390136719,
-0.5017478466033936,
-0.040027931332588196,
-0.3357005715370178,
-0.41695505380630493,
1.002042531967163,
0.10941412299871445,
-0.019982002675533295,
0.3850686252117157,
-0.21862143278121948,
-0.14564231038093567,
0.18695729970932007,
-0.07806834578514099,
-0.13060683012008667,
-0.1359124481678009,
0.29845690727233887,
0.1858293116092682,
-0.32905855774879456,
-0.14066676795482635,
-0.1311555802822113,
0.7055510878562927,
-0.07958053052425385,
-0.48925063014030457,
-0.22735343873500824,
0.8028087019920349,
0.1337588131427765,
-0.5145285129547119,
0.7731097936630249,
0.6985130310058594,
-0.5781689882278442,
-0.127534881234169,
-0.4602971076965332,
-0.32966047525405884,
-0.3970540761947632,
0.7512021064758301,
-0.6059321165084839,
-0.5785155892372131,
0.7750829458236694,
-0.16536828875541687,
-0.07878757268190384,
0.46816837787628174,
0.35931581258773804,
-0.22659224271774292,
0.2385745346546173,
0.5915387868881226,
0.07478798180818558,
0.8146148920059204,
-0.5494757294654846,
-0.1417490690946579,
-0.8940026164054871,
-0.2956995964050293,
-0.7271004319190979,
-0.41314491629600525,
-0.3715481460094452,
-0.42037901282310486,
0.13988307118415833,
0.3016062378883362,
-0.12483391910791397,
0.08835965394973755,
-0.39314407110214233,
0.4165595769882202,
0.9884206056594849,
0.39401116967201233,
-0.049047134816646576,
0.16207408905029297,
-0.1492948830127716,
-0.3498189151287079,
-0.5771310329437256,
-0.4840458929538727,
1.1302803754806519,
0.14573675394058228,
0.8873668313026428,
-0.24460817873477936,
1.1339483261108398,
0.2691125273704529,
0.08969440311193466,
-0.44708916544914246,
0.5175527334213257,
-0.6923503279685974,
-0.5025392174720764,
-0.14194649457931519,
-0.4255041480064392,
-0.6960947513580322,
0.723214328289032,
-0.11125172674655914,
-0.6255720853805542,
0.6666239500045776,
0.08222834020853043,
0.0023789687547832727,
0.2567288279533386,
-0.5715973973274231,
0.8413236141204834,
-0.287136435508728,
-0.7991805076599121,
-0.5872076749801636,
-0.6415570378303528,
0.050972357392311096,
-0.08594177663326263,
-0.08651265501976013,
-0.1737964153289795,
-0.36165010929107666,
0.631313145160675,
-0.11636804044246674,
0.7465387582778931,
-0.250024676322937,
0.08881308883428574,
0.06892827898263931,
-0.29698702692985535,
-0.031068114563822746,
0.18522830307483673,
-0.32008323073387146,
0.22733984887599945,
-0.5868987441062927,
-0.6339411735534668,
-0.39298152923583984,
0.6101589798927307,
-0.9113868474960327,
-0.696740984916687,
-0.3866184651851654,
-0.4937554895877838,
0.05204795300960541,
0.17446587979793549,
0.3421088755130768,
0.48128387331962585,
-0.4944266378879547,
0.3505778908729553,
0.7076160907745361,
-0.3963850438594818,
0.4443683326244354,
0.18571700155735016,
0.18960019946098328,
-0.5596750974655151,
1.3321027755737305,
-0.015702055767178535,
0.048631735146045685,
0.7588173151016235,
0.17560894787311554,
-0.07170942425727844,
-0.9468305110931396,
0.17103050649166107,
0.21616914868354797,
-0.9727969169616699,
-0.031149176880717278,
-0.7471818923950195,
0.05158356577157974,
0.11072613298892975,
-0.4531989097595215,
-0.35445791482925415,
-0.1716436743736267,
-0.8720220923423767,
0.0200689397752285,
-0.4025508463382721,
0.2816387712955475,
-0.4448893070220947,
0.44404974579811096,
-0.5548208951950073,
0.7431056499481201,
0.3442244529724121,
0.033086519688367844,
-0.08651889860630035,
-0.2810501754283905,
-0.09827787429094315,
-0.16522537171840668,
-0.7306517362594604,
-0.9889247417449951,
0.3095027208328247,
0.29129862785339355,
0.9454367756843567,
0.45126286149024963,
-0.13401025533676147,
0.283945769071579,
-0.3799261748790741,
0.5035569071769714,
0.4053587317466736,
-1.0189130306243896,
0.6668440699577332,
-0.3254276514053345,
-0.06253926455974579,
0.609741747379303,
0.6388999223709106,
-0.4189281761646271,
-0.05744308605790138,
-0.38575711846351624,
-0.8747974038124084,
0.8126711845397949,
0.12671218812465668,
0.378515362739563,
0.003387186676263809,
0.43208062648773193,
0.3403288424015045,
0.6284868717193604,
-0.721762478351593,
-0.15036283433437347,
-0.47107231616973877,
-0.2786690890789032,
-0.020485928282141685,
-0.47856980562210083,
-0.2619445323944092,
0.1154383048415184,
0.611177921295166,
-0.28929880261421204,
0.4954903721809387,
0.007608857937157154,
-0.028369497507810593,
0.22761604189872742,
0.15301208198070526,
0.7766791582107544,
0.6582270264625549,
-0.4022826850414276,
0.19243860244750977,
-0.1482718288898468,
-0.09639778733253479,
0.19830350577831268,
0.6050129532814026,
-0.23621058464050293,
0.1567803919315338,
0.3890465199947357,
0.9901263117790222,
0.07289078831672668,
-0.09030589461326599,
0.3231717646121979,
-0.03764999657869339,
-0.36288219690322876,
0.47530683875083923,
-0.1006254255771637,
0.3447722792625427,
0.22775867581367493,
0.46609482169151306,
0.23852021992206573,
0.3151506185531616,
-0.3744988441467285,
0.2882508635520935,
0.4639919400215149,
-0.2752685546875,
0.03393317013978958,
0.6584233045578003,
0.5308692455291748,
-0.12048857659101486,
0.4092279076576233,
-0.05927358567714691,
-0.6051424145698547,
1.0021265745162964,
0.3226865828037262,
0.5868278741836548,
-0.1309470683336258,
0.30772989988327026,
0.34367141127586365,
0.08565715700387955,
0.09833568334579468,
0.24749068915843964,
-0.1593223214149475,
-0.7259462475776672,
-0.02909901551902294,
-0.401309609413147,
-0.6451979279518127,
0.11998208612203598,
-0.8338884711265564,
0.34607699513435364,
-0.19110138714313507,
-0.10917706042528152,
0.22647035121917725,
0.08456830680370331,
-0.24763989448547363,
0.3202817738056183,
-0.19179268181324005,
0.47994279861450195,
-0.6510030031204224,
0.3963735103607178,
0.641194224357605,
-0.5298311710357666,
0.032475683838129044,
0.27913129329681396,
-0.3565158545970917,
-0.5020707845687866,
0.7204575538635254,
0.2745644748210907,
0.01131886150687933,
-0.13163328170776367,
-0.3246413469314575,
-0.6218199729919434,
0.9661285281181335,
0.7248095273971558,
-0.5140365362167358,
-0.317043274641037,
-0.18546265363693237,
0.33196425437927246,
-0.47728750109672546,
0.04777507483959198,
-0.24945665895938873,
0.08581045269966125,
0.0623253658413887,
-0.27018287777900696,
-0.31556808948516846,
-0.09127059578895569,
0.1368430107831955,
0.1938716620206833,
-0.7994670271873474,
1.2235196828842163,
-0.09154462069272995,
0.269359827041626,
-0.1343861073255539,
0.6227179169654846,
0.3816409111022949,
0.5373172760009766,
0.12373141944408417,
0.7606279850006104,
0.7332484722137451,
-0.20289522409439087,
0.979017972946167,
-0.526883065700531,
0.654321014881134,
1.1211323738098145,
-0.2831025719642639,
0.44871047139167786,
0.5787173509597778,
0.13536997139453888,
-0.003229919821023941,
0.8650240302085876,
-0.06320168823003769,
1.0877341032028198,
0.21524299681186676,
-0.12041135877370834,
-0.21163786947727203,
-0.3067401945590973,
-0.7008134722709656,
0.20802107453346252,
0.4771305024623871,
-0.4875102639198303,
-0.39596542716026306,
0.0031917253509163857,
-0.4037233293056488,
0.2651153802871704,
-0.2962121367454529,
0.7651066184043884,
0.13763828575611115,
-0.45152875781059265,
0.21882270276546478,
0.2675025463104248,
0.8417342305183411,
-0.6213098764419556,
-0.0014024066040292382,
-0.48372378945350647,
0.11820794641971588,
0.1927662342786789,
-0.24620899558067322,
0.2785358726978302,
-0.5106273293495178,
-0.3629959523677826,
-0.23160339891910553,
0.9066818952560425,
-0.6052272319793701,
-0.4243146479129791,
0.5305217504501343,
0.5108213424682617,
-0.24180534482002258,
0.1385534703731537,
-0.8210053443908691,
0.028601521626114845,
-0.24500836431980133,
-0.178808331489563,
0.30413052439689636,
0.4313766658306122,
0.24658402800559998,
0.49590447545051575,
0.2607036232948303,
0.07205530256032944,
-0.14193175733089447,
-0.091897152364254,
0.826442301273346,
-0.5307191014289856,
-0.7667345404624939,
-0.7066006660461426,
0.3690227270126343,
-0.30107593536376953,
-0.2972501218318939,
0.10720935463905334,
0.4679117500782013,
0.7921817302703857,
-0.15084852278232574,
0.6172342300415039,
0.2996693551540375,
0.24313117563724518,
-0.6902487277984619,
0.4957500696182251,
-0.9868709444999695,
0.14203570783138275,
-0.3026098608970642,
-1.02476966381073,
-0.07138754427433014,
0.8412152528762817,
-0.2515398859977722,
0.2555248439311981,
0.767104983329773,
0.5076411962509155,
-0.31088176369667053,
-0.09038439393043518,
0.4832245111465454,
-0.3628893792629242,
0.25843918323516846,
0.6499668955802917,
0.8712236881256104,
-0.14252617955207825,
0.2398742288351059,
-0.3777671158313751,
-0.009552130475640297,
-0.3000226616859436,
-0.8922386169433594,
-0.9260717034339905,
-0.614685595035553,
-0.4578028917312622,
0.05777999386191368,
0.31728410720825195,
0.5743996500968933,
1.050765037536621,
-0.6149536371231079,
-0.2318068891763687,
-0.3863639533519745,
0.2532954216003418,
0.15052573382854462,
-0.1697293221950531,
0.5242509841918945,
-0.43340611457824707,
-0.8332479596138,
0.02913462184369564,
0.2856185734272003,
0.04006795212626457,
-0.05948182940483093,
-0.23595623672008514,
-0.458886057138443,
0.01003505103290081,
0.34029364585876465,
-0.05555247887969017,
-0.728996217250824,
0.23113568127155304,
-0.16930411756038666,
-0.31840765476226807,
0.22228430211544037,
1.0239359140396118,
-0.13328318297863007,
0.30410245060920715,
0.4714110493659973,
1.1941872835159302,
0.9716549515724182,
0.026149578392505646,
0.4923139214515686,
-0.8767778277397156,
0.31450918316841125,
0.12792600691318512,
0.6490752696990967,
0.3475698232650757,
-0.15395119786262512,
0.4996243715286255,
0.332561194896698,
-0.20313331484794617,
-0.5938825011253357,
0.32929566502571106,
-0.7334355711936951,
-0.7976059317588806,
0.7254903316497803,
-0.23820151388645172,
0.21723344922065735,
0.20480045676231384,
-0.37429267168045044,
0.23011350631713867,
-0.6727785468101501,
0.7312236428260803,
0.9486445188522339,
-0.2860333323478699,
-0.453340619802475,
-0.1784645915031433,
0.05818920210003853,
0.624301016330719,
-0.9361193180084229,
-0.3900880813598633,
0.6225096583366394,
-0.07713604718446732,
0.5472745299339294,
0.6207732558250427,
0.21264402568340302,
0.2723202109336853,
0.2217126190662384,
0.02834443934261799,
-0.09341607242822647,
-0.5911064147949219,
-0.4391866624355316,
0.6473758816719055,
-0.07140208035707474,
-0.33749842643737793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07543v1 | Show Me How It's Done: The Role of Explanations in Fine-Tuning Language Models | 2024-02-12T10:11:50 | 2024-02-12T10:11:50 | Mohamad Ballout, Ulf Krumnack, Gunther Heidemann, Kai-Uwe Kuehnberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Our research demonstrates the significant benefits of using fine-tuning with
explanations to enhance the performance of language models. Unlike prompting,
which maintains the model's parameters, fine-tuning allows the model to learn
and update its parameters during a training phase. In this study, we applied
fine-tuning to various sized language models using data that contained
explanations of the output rather than merely presenting the answers. We found
that even smaller language models with as few as 60 million parameters
benefited substantially from this approach. Interestingly, our results
indicated that the detailed explanations were more beneficial to smaller models
than larger ones, with the latter gaining nearly the same advantage from any
form of explanation, irrespective of its length. Additionally, we demonstrate
that the inclusion of explanations enables the models to solve tasks that they
were not able to solve without explanations. Lastly, we argue that despite the
challenging nature of adding explanations, samples that contain explanations
not only reduce the volume of data required for training but also promote a
more effective generalization by the model. In essence, our findings suggest
that fine-tuning with explanations significantly bolsters the performance of
large language models. | [
-0.5366597771644592,
-0.8370295166969299,
0.780244767665863,
-0.14030016958713531,
-0.2645050883293152,
-0.528328537940979,
-0.6796945333480835,
-0.21786166727542877,
-0.34632039070129395,
0.2626902461051941,
-0.5777264833450317,
-0.21125628054141998,
-0.4545590579509735,
-0.02218220755457878,
-0.38577529788017273,
1.0818589925765991,
0.0931842029094696,
0.2864639461040497,
-0.17835547029972076,
0.29797685146331787,
-0.6411627531051636,
0.03062126412987709,
-1.0472564697265625,
-0.6857819557189941,
0.885169506072998,
0.8988085985183716,
0.8823692798614502,
1.2382451295852661,
0.0916469395160675,
0.3136981129646301,
-0.08327646553516388,
0.30204322934150696,
-0.5972716808319092,
0.06797579675912857,
-0.31851714849472046,
-0.6217749118804932,
-0.20321135222911835,
-0.04169520363211632,
0.669053316116333,
1.2081842422485352,
-0.05060495063662529,
0.15280400216579437,
0.19020292162895203,
0.853062093257904,
-0.3591865301132202,
0.1928248256444931,
-0.39866217970848083,
-0.33474230766296387,
-0.166685551404953,
-0.4124668538570404,
-0.3717857301235199,
-0.19474342465400696,
0.0102531211450696,
-0.5064297914505005,
0.48902347683906555,
0.13188228011131287,
0.7926716804504395,
0.24386025965213776,
-0.19261707365512848,
-0.22388802468776703,
-0.9789511561393738,
0.9031134843826294,
-0.8674812912940979,
0.27190539240837097,
0.3543938398361206,
0.4424474835395813,
-0.26034724712371826,
-0.4347028434276581,
-0.32455697655677795,
-0.22180132567882538,
-0.25392624735832214,
-0.11700055003166199,
-0.01583685353398323,
0.3229597210884094,
0.4974149465560913,
0.506564199924469,
-0.519588828086853,
0.5942798852920532,
-0.5511298775672913,
-0.230085089802742,
0.6389560103416443,
0.31547293066978455,
0.18415823578834534,
0.2915310263633728,
0.35007917881011963,
-0.012989484705030918,
-0.8249830603599548,
0.29811975359916687,
0.49310049414634705,
0.6358282566070557,
-0.07291460037231445,
0.39770108461380005,
-0.5609883069992065,
1.0697697401046753,
0.0693741887807846,
0.11758226156234741,
-0.42025014758110046,
-0.2196541428565979,
-0.3339219391345978,
-0.16308017075061798,
0.591905951499939,
0.399269163608551,
0.6868986487388611,
-0.2297908216714859,
-0.1773194819688797,
-0.16578182578086853,
-0.047562092542648315,
-0.9686559438705444,
-0.2817491292953491,
0.18656472861766815,
-0.7259724736213684,
-0.18738581240177155,
-0.25287333130836487,
-0.8684108257293701,
-0.2667989432811737,
-0.7832242846488953,
0.4441539943218231,
-0.3144368529319763,
-0.2520713210105896,
0.482891708612442,
-0.3000827729701996,
0.1339348405599594,
0.606744647026062,
-1.5705982446670532,
0.34814971685409546,
0.7996644377708435,
0.5025176405906677,
0.1837025284767151,
-0.23431193828582764,
-0.6593880653381348,
-0.10113417357206345,
-0.5617927312850952,
0.6940011382102966,
-0.7022026181221008,
-0.06495524942874908,
0.06550973653793335,
0.04451519995927811,
0.05496220290660858,
-0.5961549282073975,
0.1912921667098999,
-0.26440057158470154,
0.2951299846172333,
-0.49545884132385254,
-0.6396663188934326,
-0.2511603534221649,
-0.06960640102624893,
-0.5282271504402161,
0.6953276991844177,
-0.3089200258255005,
-0.30761829018592834,
0.38503387570381165,
-0.6973908543586731,
-0.43431586027145386,
-0.14272958040237427,
0.1045711413025856,
-0.23317614197731018,
0.5294016003608704,
0.37501561641693115,
0.7349597811698914,
-0.39793890714645386,
0.05620592087507248,
-0.3243796229362488,
-0.495551198720932,
0.16333740949630737,
-0.46881160140037537,
0.542945384979248,
0.38925257325172424,
-0.16775435209274292,
0.11682534217834473,
-0.6201565861701965,
0.016066014766693115,
0.16614007949829102,
-0.29969626665115356,
-0.23089173436164856,
0.07997336983680725,
-0.30590054392814636,
-0.08609242737293243,
0.22075560688972473,
-0.22551515698432922,
0.16857224702835083,
-0.6998017430305481,
0.41867202520370483,
0.6434403657913208,
-0.04438702017068863,
0.6657391786575317,
-0.3041551113128662,
0.6401085257530212,
-0.25984036922454834,
0.17516030371189117,
-0.48188894987106323,
-0.33814194798469543,
-0.616210401058197,
0.09022507816553116,
0.6287883520126343,
-0.00858690682798624,
-0.1477455049753189,
-0.24021847546100616,
0.033852946013212204,
-0.39618876576423645,
-0.5283983945846558,
0.2213905155658722,
0.463473379611969,
0.42912566661834717,
0.14077505469322205,
0.23348073661327362,
-0.46844035387039185,
-1.0300627946853638,
-0.5696631669998169,
-0.0560847707092762,
-0.12379879504442215,
0.2152368575334549,
0.33965936303138733,
0.22729435563087463,
0.605966329574585,
-0.2593654990196228,
0.3591495156288147,
-0.33576279878616333,
0.09482144564390182,
0.11055023968219757,
0.5612244009971619,
0.46689584851264954,
-0.5644199848175049,
-0.409638375043869,
0.2284177988767624,
-0.36884716153144836,
-0.1584920585155487,
-0.22630508244037628,
0.14923711121082306,
-0.11905594915151596,
0.7506514191627502,
-0.3560590147972107,
0.09926024079322815,
0.34116536378860474,
-0.14995987713336945,
0.7114621996879578,
-0.5733962655067444,
0.0801815316081047,
-0.646763265132904,
-0.16528691351413727,
-0.0021793136838823557,
-0.505363941192627,
-0.6051045656204224,
0.06789541244506836,
-0.22007647156715393,
-0.133919820189476,
-0.08737601339817047,
0.5709523558616638,
-0.41162192821502686,
0.25038623809814453,
-0.3763805627822876,
0.27517008781433105,
0.015748172998428345,
0.41368094086647034,
-0.21697646379470825,
0.5659516453742981,
0.9883704781532288,
-0.8938565850257874,
0.16749919950962067,
-0.21894356608390808,
-0.1395537406206131,
0.09194040298461914,
-0.8833779096603394,
-0.03699624538421631,
-0.2691395878791809,
-0.36419081687927246,
-1.1830761432647705,
-0.45642921328544617,
0.008285591378808022,
-0.566969633102417,
0.45474034547805786,
-0.30002760887145996,
-0.5253655910491943,
-0.34256845712661743,
-0.09840209037065506,
-0.05011073127388954,
0.517361044883728,
-0.6265101432800293,
0.3441334068775177,
0.11506364494562149,
-0.05874183028936386,
-0.09830065816640854,
-0.48393383622169495,
-0.2886749804019928,
-0.6431542634963989,
-0.42467421293258667,
0.2498675435781479,
-0.2843177914619446,
-0.3662383258342743,
-0.21579426527023315,
-0.24531657993793488,
-0.1068369448184967,
0.621319591999054,
0.12551282346248627,
-0.19467787444591522,
-0.4260977506637573,
0.4686165750026703,
0.29585903882980347,
-0.3281155526638031,
0.14435498416423798,
-0.09795325249433517,
0.516175389289856,
-0.16440747678279877,
-0.06780298799276352,
-0.7413820028305054,
0.3997128903865814,
0.5235216021537781,
-0.22815687954425812,
1.0509438514709473,
0.4873860478401184,
-0.353353351354599,
-0.3184884488582611,
-0.38348597288131714,
-0.6642543077468872,
-0.47744041681289673,
0.23232777416706085,
-0.48530319333076477,
-0.9769583940505981,
0.6324734687805176,
-0.3046882450580597,
0.11001556366682053,
0.5256782174110413,
0.6499991416931152,
-0.17530372738838196,
1.9487040042877197,
0.8523640036582947,
-0.02622106485068798,
0.6492569446563721,
-0.02289346046745777,
0.37759044766426086,
-0.4135007858276367,
-0.09815840423107147,
-0.9783023595809937,
-0.3368810713291168,
-0.6955820322036743,
0.003019921248778701,
-0.12142563611268997,
0.6624639630317688,
-0.2656818628311157,
0.06111372262239456,
-0.469889760017395,
0.8199524879455566,
0.6100490689277649,
-0.07612624019384384,
0.27628108859062195,
-0.0636189877986908,
0.19150368869304657,
0.04443523287773132,
-0.7695339918136597,
-0.6894317269325256,
0.8071311712265015,
0.5484119057655334,
0.9266631007194519,
-0.08666984736919403,
0.6424899101257324,
-0.10234050452709198,
-0.07559020817279816,
-0.8380707502365112,
0.37540972232818604,
-0.30720797181129456,
-0.5380750298500061,
-0.6689356565475464,
-0.33273613452911377,
-0.9894383549690247,
0.27942192554473877,
-0.06868461519479752,
-0.8476800322532654,
-0.021231012418866158,
0.7885323762893677,
-0.5877956748008728,
-0.17940844595432281,
-1.1035300493240356,
1.0056909322738647,
-0.10665127635002136,
-0.1691359132528305,
-0.6634548306465149,
-0.2789538502693176,
0.19948641955852509,
0.1901259869337082,
0.31700199842453003,
0.023740533739328384,
0.23453065752983093,
0.777833878993988,
-0.5545366406440735,
0.8923134803771973,
-0.3520576059818268,
-0.060558196157217026,
-0.18313732743263245,
0.1333889663219452,
0.40220797061920166,
0.19294118881225586,
-0.28504979610443115,
-0.27182742953300476,
0.08159106969833374,
-0.38909122347831726,
-0.9441531300544739,
0.8606813549995422,
-0.3495576083660126,
-0.8629328608512878,
0.396281898021698,
-0.748987078666687,
-0.22351062297821045,
0.3183930814266205,
0.08292467147111893,
0.6271461248397827,
0.22286243736743927,
0.44033491611480713,
0.8638107180595398,
-0.2097439020872116,
0.39816156029701233,
0.7208545207977295,
-0.3092580735683441,
0.2599373757839203,
0.8003056645393372,
-0.02505873329937458,
0.39808833599090576,
0.1950642168521881,
0.7341341972351074,
-0.13776428997516632,
-0.9299354553222656,
-0.5768094658851624,
0.33051392436027527,
-0.5401890873908997,
0.10102128982543945,
-0.2689923346042633,
0.2915508449077606,
-0.25198397040367126,
-0.10112438350915909,
-0.2614968419075012,
-0.5276265144348145,
-0.2631494700908661,
-0.2765212953090668,
0.5629077553749084,
0.7796728014945984,
-0.19820261001586914,
0.6502985954284668,
-0.31961339712142944,
0.29091963171958923,
0.39651310443878174,
0.4597572386264801,
0.3558085262775421,
-0.6895754337310791,
-0.7723294496536255,
0.336538165807724,
-0.025006486102938652,
-0.6886159181594849,
0.17710746824741364,
0.4464249014854431,
0.6305898427963257,
0.5588953495025635,
-0.3513641059398651,
1.1833103895187378,
-0.6705853939056396,
0.7446681261062622,
-0.19096514582633972,
-0.9209060668945312,
0.8490814566612244,
-0.5174227952957153,
0.39949896931648254,
0.3180725574493408,
0.18229058384895325,
-0.433030903339386,
-0.6877329349517822,
-0.4718915820121765,
-0.6680578589439392,
0.9250730276107788,
-0.15130041539669037,
0.40415436029434204,
0.08302652090787888,
0.864033579826355,
0.15143311023712158,
-0.02023610845208168,
-0.5685265064239502,
-0.3863380551338196,
0.13698431849479675,
-0.16708986461162567,
-0.13503272831439972,
-0.3263060450553894,
-0.2540185749530792,
-0.425669401884079,
0.7709911465644836,
-0.2749953866004944,
0.10608750581741333,
-0.13241247832775116,
-0.08673946559429169,
-0.4284021258354187,
0.17648182809352875,
0.8530453443527222,
0.879452109336853,
0.21434363722801208,
0.24346236884593964,
0.15278969705104828,
0.21041527390480042,
-0.578179657459259,
0.2164238840341568,
0.19485482573509216,
-0.014048900455236435,
0.5341580510139465,
1.0073328018188477,
0.15593130886554718,
-0.6688964366912842,
0.13329270482063293,
-0.12848541140556335,
-0.16864590346813202,
0.2504177391529083,
0.422233521938324,
0.3292049467563629,
0.27748629450798035,
0.10640931129455566,
-0.1262700855731964,
0.18867705762386322,
-0.5402988195419312,
-0.08193598687648773,
0.5713916420936584,
-0.3526124060153961,
-0.39400094747543335,
0.7943062782287598,
-0.2596769332885742,
-0.3844967484474182,
0.20853225886821747,
0.22809119522571564,
-0.3099348843097687,
0.7188535332679749,
0.662286102771759,
0.2034684419631958,
-0.3184628188610077,
0.2769685983657837,
0.35287711024284363,
0.2656400501728058,
-0.34864258766174316,
0.16371619701385498,
-0.22748102247714996,
-0.5625840425491333,
-0.6618203520774841,
-0.572025716304779,
-0.30864420533180237,
0.3568589985370636,
-0.7931631803512573,
0.03005281463265419,
-0.39335110783576965,
0.4255078136920929,
0.7741298079490662,
-0.08630717545747757,
-0.6644027829170227,
0.48213860392570496,
0.11703792959451675,
0.9508630037307739,
-1.1046541929244995,
0.661494791507721,
0.4923352003097534,
-0.5461469292640686,
-1.3315460681915283,
-0.09059054404497147,
-0.2093094140291214,
-0.8377396464347839,
0.45771968364715576,
0.20454810559749603,
-0.08401855826377869,
0.02775299921631813,
-0.7778151631355286,
-0.7168907523155212,
0.4735061228275299,
0.7884865999221802,
-0.711908221244812,
0.24163997173309326,
0.053488101810216904,
0.950785219669342,
-0.23785945773124695,
0.09699543565511703,
0.7419930100440979,
0.5966795682907104,
-0.19540517032146454,
-0.8702362179756165,
0.03843773156404495,
-0.03519448637962341,
0.07136092334985733,
0.21516555547714233,
-0.20267513394355774,
0.7588182091712952,
-0.30635708570480347,
-0.07251767814159393,
0.1426457166671753,
0.513359010219574,
-0.25633227825164795,
0.027404583990573883,
0.4715560972690582,
0.19754107296466827,
0.8480302095413208,
-0.3191719055175781,
1.2525572776794434,
-0.16734416782855988,
0.4169151186943054,
0.9965705275535583,
0.3364979922771454,
0.5139405727386475,
0.6004100441932678,
0.04870103299617767,
0.5911572575569153,
0.9004480242729187,
0.17786788940429688,
0.5664395689964294,
0.2316858321428299,
0.1241116002202034,
-0.5744602680206299,
0.004199086222797632,
-0.2019180953502655,
0.2571569085121155,
0.3387013375759125,
-0.5128861665725708,
-0.45263272523880005,
0.34389209747314453,
-0.038862377405166626,
0.2673252820968628,
-0.6648647785186768,
0.8015555143356323,
0.09019187837839127,
-0.8531858325004578,
0.7467618584632874,
0.09131128340959549,
0.10075277090072632,
-0.36360618472099304,
-0.10967227071523666,
-0.20794014632701874,
0.3226794898509979,
-0.2458469718694687,
-0.6768273711204529,
0.4610290825366974,
-0.09202780574560165,
-0.6122173070907593,
-0.5836567878723145,
0.6054742932319641,
-0.689192533493042,
-0.22769877314567566,
0.10450350493192673,
0.3091305196285248,
0.35864895582199097,
-0.10868735611438751,
-0.6512358784675598,
-0.0946715921163559,
0.04768560081720352,
-0.18871040642261505,
0.2274295687675476,
0.7285650372505188,
-0.2217358499765396,
0.6982725858688354,
0.5113866925239563,
0.16168338060379028,
-0.1280229538679123,
0.46503737568855286,
0.6872571110725403,
-0.5523650050163269,
-0.31915900111198425,
-1.2213672399520874,
0.7319276332855225,
0.08350054919719696,
-0.10280562937259674,
0.791473388671875,
0.4736882150173187,
0.7450469136238098,
-0.3259941041469574,
0.4219282567501068,
0.17189425230026245,
0.7795518636703491,
-0.7230742573738098,
0.4311615824699402,
-0.8871233463287354,
0.3704295754432678,
0.0805336982011795,
-0.457685261964798,
-0.37174248695373535,
0.5938112735748291,
-0.5183010697364807,
0.08612456172704697,
0.5780791640281677,
1.000511646270752,
-0.13059625029563904,
0.06286004185676575,
0.37604305148124695,
0.5097642540931702,
0.2731221318244934,
0.04617001488804817,
0.48471635580062866,
-0.17564094066619873,
0.383798748254776,
-0.3354536294937134,
-0.20939792692661285,
-0.2267097383737564,
-0.825439989566803,
-0.9719387888908386,
-0.5529557466506958,
-0.3778381645679474,
-0.07751137018203735,
0.090948686003685,
0.5191020965576172,
1.0002819299697876,
-0.9730421304702759,
-0.23634205758571625,
-0.26887309551239014,
0.3676154315471649,
-0.5069950819015503,
-0.204154372215271,
0.11054215580224991,
-0.6385537981987,
-0.8963212370872498,
0.49158233404159546,
0.14064937829971313,
-0.13418500125408173,
-0.26675230264663696,
0.023990659043192863,
0.19655947387218475,
0.004751862958073616,
0.4162291884422302,
0.3038228750228882,
-0.8338714838027954,
-0.4773930311203003,
-0.18455460667610168,
0.3437403440475464,
-0.08718016743659973,
0.8710219860076904,
-0.5915065407752991,
0.5790157914161682,
0.4647723436355591,
0.43104544281959534,
0.5471816062927246,
-0.17856687307357788,
1.133522868156433,
-0.7476093173027039,
0.07390852272510529,
-0.2364789843559265,
0.43985626101493835,
0.36970260739326477,
-0.49369677901268005,
0.21856224536895752,
-0.5116333365440369,
-0.60170578956604,
-0.9438437223434448,
0.2023642659187317,
-0.7309244871139526,
-0.3152863085269928,
0.8677555918693542,
0.03170274943113327,
-0.12935101985931396,
-0.15288174152374268,
-0.28106021881103516,
0.41306889057159424,
-0.2719411849975586,
0.9058412313461304,
0.8631279468536377,
-0.151834174990654,
-0.48533886671066284,
-0.842435359954834,
0.8198790550231934,
0.6401509642601013,
-0.7325225472450256,
0.5151411294937134,
0.3875962197780609,
0.46233251690864563,
-0.16762539744377136,
0.1855679452419281,
-0.012016798369586468,
0.474052757024765,
-0.44203153252601624,
-0.43779700994491577,
-0.11841186136007309,
-0.4027285873889923,
-0.8862838745117188,
-0.1752583384513855,
0.4502665102481842,
-0.18244309723377228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07540v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07540v1 | PKG API: A Tool for Personal Knowledge Graph Management | 2024-02-12T10:09:16 | 2024-02-12T10:09:16 | Nolwenn Bernard, Ivica Kostric, Weronika Łajewska, Krisztian Balog, Petra Galuščáková, Vinay Setty, Martin G. Skjæveland | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Personal knowledge graphs (PKGs) offer individuals a way to store and
consolidate their fragmented personal data in a central place, improving
service personalization while maintaining full user control. Despite their
potential, practical PKG implementations with user-friendly interfaces remain
scarce. This work addresses this gap by proposing a complete solution to
represent, manage, and interface with PKGs. Our approach includes (1) a
user-facing PKG Client, enabling end-users to administer their personal data
easily via natural language statements, and (2) a service-oriented PKG API. To
tackle the complexity of representing these statements within a PKG, we present
an RDF-based PKG vocabulary that supports this, along with properties for
access rights and provenance. | [
-0.5334014296531677,
-0.3537379205226898,
0.34778714179992676,
0.37328672409057617,
0.00927171390503645,
0.5369560122489929,
-0.01401467900723219,
-0.42036905884742737,
0.27569806575775146,
0.7939249873161316,
-0.6716277599334717,
-0.9058146476745605,
-0.27550438046455383,
0.37541308999061584,
0.013980814255774021,
0.8097676038742065,
-0.08771223574876785,
-0.5015842318534851,
-0.4715249538421631,
-0.10078297555446625,
-0.5739095211029053,
-0.25074052810668945,
-0.321755588054657,
-0.6595656275749207,
0.649851381778717,
0.6589255332946777,
0.7231523394584656,
0.6751745939254761,
0.24684295058250427,
0.24874813854694366,
0.013975577428936958,
0.14054137468338013,
-0.23281121253967285,
0.5220520496368408,
-0.21811649203300476,
-0.22775785624980927,
-0.4409954249858856,
-0.2161293923854828,
0.0715547502040863,
0.9770411252975464,
-0.14410872757434845,
0.10627780854701996,
-0.13904523849487305,
0.7115579843521118,
-0.43516531586647034,
0.5019242167472839,
0.10403790324926376,
0.22372545301914215,
-0.22173409163951874,
0.05008562654256821,
-0.3631661534309387,
-0.3455334007740021,
0.6058107018470764,
-1.0751897096633911,
-0.1690591722726822,
0.3411659300327301,
0.56219881772995,
0.04825485497713089,
-0.5013977289199829,
-0.39667531847953796,
-0.5328797698020935,
0.21107541024684906,
-0.3637462258338928,
0.2817193865776062,
0.7537683844566345,
0.7856277823448181,
-0.3814674913883209,
-1.1246891021728516,
-0.355769544839859,
0.13310134410858154,
-0.5944741368293762,
0.05868864431977272,
-0.13331952691078186,
0.18189765512943268,
-0.23041333258152008,
0.4095328152179718,
-0.6454036831855774,
-0.08770782500505447,
0.06110221892595291,
-0.3845672607421875,
0.5263397693634033,
0.43505093455314636,
0.2624965310096741,
-0.29884207248687744,
-0.5993590354919434,
0.2829780876636505,
-0.6205722093582153,
-0.13697423040866852,
0.67616206407547,
0.40085482597351074,
-0.00842229649424553,
0.7359398603439331,
-0.9017333984375,
1.041691780090332,
-0.2016720175743103,
0.033787790685892105,
0.19336462020874023,
-0.2128409743309021,
-0.19818370044231415,
0.17013369500637054,
0.7354589700698853,
0.23528015613555908,
-0.018553629517555237,
-0.594685435295105,
0.01659698784351349,
-0.8102520704269409,
0.22792303562164307,
-0.6128345131874084,
-0.7445651292800903,
0.38315603137016296,
-0.3693731129169464,
-0.2986897826194763,
0.07674755156040192,
-0.49940794706344604,
-0.9577891826629639,
-0.5973756909370422,
0.08218255639076233,
-0.6264088153839111,
-0.061007656157016754,
0.05192070081830025,
-0.30084216594696045,
-0.09061914682388306,
0.5120884776115417,
-0.5252371430397034,
0.44513702392578125,
0.6607165336608887,
0.7689704298973083,
0.181526318192482,
-0.10180787742137909,
0.026053087785840034,
0.7794535756111145,
0.15810909867286682,
0.8759887218475342,
-0.4077938497066498,
-0.28534409403800964,
0.055443912744522095,
0.11562113463878632,
0.3812643587589264,
-0.6439880728721619,
0.23070620000362396,
-0.6625964045524597,
0.2825624346733093,
-0.7002003788948059,
-0.9922975301742554,
-0.1101689487695694,
0.23215846717357635,
-0.5062854290008545,
0.7125672698020935,
0.5176202058792114,
-0.8468860983848572,
0.33443695306777954,
-0.7683852314949036,
-0.4549397826194763,
0.7688548564910889,
-0.21394836902618408,
-0.261743426322937,
-0.4139469563961029,
-0.22219136357307434,
0.48859915137290955,
-0.12009153515100479,
-0.24162696301937103,
-0.4851228892803192,
-0.1091824322938919,
0.17726878821849823,
0.35069942474365234,
0.779140293598175,
0.4723236858844757,
0.1549462378025055,
-0.09310905635356903,
-0.8110542297363281,
-0.21096329391002655,
0.12242869287729263,
-0.520980954170227,
-0.6870102882385254,
-0.0183700043708086,
-0.05844852328300476,
-0.2159244865179062,
0.8528239130973816,
-0.48134592175483704,
0.5263487696647644,
-0.2525329887866974,
0.5614113807678223,
0.8003820180892944,
-0.08283806592226028,
0.5201466083526611,
0.07065477222204208,
0.2761712074279785,
0.16566482186317444,
0.21862803399562836,
-0.18617139756679535,
-0.640470564365387,
-0.02201271243393421,
-0.3306426405906677,
-0.050761185586452484,
0.4035146236419678,
-0.7464161515235901,
0.6724367141723633,
-0.24033217132091522,
-0.20474660396575928,
0.21237878501415253,
0.4711169898509979,
0.20002710819244385,
1.004480004310608,
0.11774962395429611,
-0.09641984105110168,
-0.29419809579849243,
-1.0314898490905762,
-0.15309874713420868,
-0.3440573513507843,
-0.40297579765319824,
0.6530954241752625,
0.19782397150993347,
-0.3815886676311493,
1.7411564588546753,
-1.1210609674453735,
-0.45730483531951904,
0.04038218408823013,
0.2914142310619354,
0.030785275623202324,
-0.01996719092130661,
0.3453795611858368,
-1.0080267190933228,
-0.6673624515533447,
0.42850396037101746,
-0.8100356459617615,
-0.40643101930618286,
0.48895469307899475,
-0.4030248522758484,
-0.15148279070854187,
-0.1357499659061432,
-0.7210897207260132,
0.17991113662719727,
0.11207202076911926,
-0.9601002335548401,
0.9278779625892639,
-0.2534962296485901,
-0.008338786661624908,
-0.8748544454574585,
0.09960215538740158,
-0.0921914204955101,
-0.5843152403831482,
-0.6837630271911621,
-0.210224911570549,
-0.0042650215327739716,
-0.29780998826026917,
-0.256531685590744,
0.9086399078369141,
-0.008350761607289314,
-0.16210594773292542,
-0.03938334062695503,
-0.029168881475925446,
0.06661385297775269,
0.18086592853069305,
-0.1581682562828064,
0.7133631706237793,
0.1430043876171112,
-0.48954835534095764,
0.6795193552970886,
0.8299317955970764,
-0.03212679922580719,
0.8842071890830994,
-0.3616254925727844,
0.1324855089187622,
-0.2109830379486084,
0.11347681283950806,
-0.9109241962432861,
-0.8521587252616882,
0.85959792137146,
-0.20280365645885468,
0.13777567446231842,
-0.40726155042648315,
-0.5344790816307068,
-0.36194470524787903,
0.0029228765051811934,
-0.19380000233650208,
0.19038406014442444,
-0.6433605551719666,
0.8641237616539001,
0.2822193205356598,
-0.1942548006772995,
-0.4224436283111572,
-0.4353509247303009,
0.3086282014846802,
-0.2207016944885254,
-0.7748276591300964,
0.42761147022247314,
0.1656530797481537,
-0.3178318440914154,
0.460112988948822,
-0.2595963180065155,
-0.4183105230331421,
-0.32749417424201965,
0.32188498973846436,
-0.2256108820438385,
0.0002949167974293232,
0.4434429407119751,
-0.1352645307779312,
-0.2446439266204834,
-0.20315273106098175,
-0.7070438861846924,
0.38430166244506836,
0.04527696967124939,
-0.029659684747457504,
-0.14044857025146484,
0.2020270973443985,
0.4105752408504486,
-0.08328433334827423,
0.5485599637031555,
0.4007613956928253,
-0.3594386577606201,
-0.19593825936317444,
-0.3780985474586487,
0.2928371727466583,
-0.5880396366119385,
0.03220031037926674,
-0.42316821217536926,
-0.8734572529792786,
0.8661911487579346,
-0.31215861439704895,
-0.02038753777742386,
-0.33320608735084534,
0.34116923809051514,
-0.5616315603256226,
0.5183759927749634,
0.2563355565071106,
0.153718039393425,
0.3970833122730255,
-0.004866293165832758,
0.3516327142715454,
-0.6647742986679077,
-0.5463775992393494,
-0.3431445360183716,
-0.3264005482196808,
-0.08675984293222427,
-0.0728069394826889,
0.2235184609889984,
0.3319065272808075,
-0.6686216592788696,
0.4905788004398346,
-0.7797215580940247,
0.3541193902492523,
0.3848418891429901,
0.27810677886009216,
0.428007572889328,
0.053228043019771576,
0.1509750336408615,
0.018680525943636894,
-0.3853321969509125,
-0.7734525799751282,
0.9650837182998657,
0.21239736676216125,
1.0300395488739014,
0.14997360110282898,
0.9020116925239563,
0.4696793556213379,
0.22169794142246246,
-0.5581251978874207,
0.42382821440696716,
-0.37600529193878174,
-0.44872331619262695,
-0.2889280319213867,
-0.6416459679603577,
-0.8416645526885986,
-0.07334943115711212,
0.23788416385650635,
-1.039242148399353,
0.26444247364997864,
0.3346584737300873,
-0.3257770538330078,
0.024764813482761383,
-1.2371593713760376,
1.115997076034546,
-0.19305790960788727,
-0.22783543169498444,
0.1932908147573471,
-0.5503731369972229,
0.28701356053352356,
0.3177033066749573,
0.05358723923563957,
-0.15203523635864258,
-0.12674455344676971,
0.7693368196487427,
-1.067100167274475,
0.792368471622467,
-0.613260805606842,
0.31322500109672546,
0.40106436610221863,
0.08384240418672562,
0.5556401014328003,
0.1702757328748703,
0.3795315623283386,
-0.08428798615932465,
0.35663771629333496,
-0.5540876984596252,
-0.7201047539710999,
0.5757090449333191,
-0.8656157851219177,
-0.28222712874412537,
-0.09890802949666977,
-0.5460544228553772,
-0.23867112398147583,
0.38560205698013306,
-0.3073473870754242,
0.23980695009231567,
0.08591264486312866,
0.15667301416397095,
0.6692915558815002,
-0.5463247299194336,
0.08759154379367828,
0.38482263684272766,
-0.4986424446105957,
-0.4313433766365051,
0.9952147006988525,
0.3491097390651703,
-0.013263351283967495,
0.4951200485229492,
0.5330623984336853,
-0.7287608981132507,
-0.198012575507164,
-0.028186775743961334,
0.1559073030948639,
-0.9240278005599976,
-0.30863744020462036,
-0.5545092821121216,
0.4497929513454437,
-0.4474611282348633,
-0.19737938046455383,
-0.11241482198238373,
-0.39517804980278015,
-0.2081259787082672,
0.012617343105375767,
0.7313020825386047,
0.7172439098358154,
0.36863937973976135,
0.6414463520050049,
-0.4093579649925232,
0.36945170164108276,
0.6329976916313171,
0.9091300964355469,
-0.20316937565803528,
0.2437416911125183,
-0.27098584175109863,
-0.20736460387706757,
-0.0600411556661129,
-1.069231390953064,
0.13124343752861023,
-0.1644071638584137,
0.26030150055885315,
0.5534127950668335,
0.23691095411777496,
0.4812609553337097,
-0.17989172041416168,
0.5308067202568054,
0.2523197829723358,
-0.4702155888080597,
0.3541741967201233,
-0.5234054923057556,
0.1599995344877243,
0.47326165437698364,
0.30736640095710754,
-0.8036933541297913,
-0.15897493064403534,
-0.2514927387237549,
-0.9114029407501221,
0.7125922441482544,
-0.11068720370531082,
-0.09868263453245163,
0.06559257209300995,
0.7053855061531067,
0.2605627179145813,
0.3427559733390808,
-0.19640672206878662,
-0.6170117855072021,
-0.5732827186584473,
-0.4398839473724365,
0.44186896085739136,
-0.06514472514390945,
-0.44271597266197205,
-0.06921272724866867,
0.37788254022598267,
-0.3374154567718506,
0.30722126364707947,
0.1691681444644928,
0.06092019006609917,
0.3520281910896301,
0.1419209986925125,
-0.1250016689300537,
0.8679125308990479,
-0.41785532236099243,
0.41009455919265747,
-0.43264949321746826,
-0.5120201110839844,
0.17730377614498138,
0.18567107617855072,
-0.46507641673088074,
-0.189055398106575,
0.06052294000983238,
0.3839002847671509,
0.37044790387153625,
-0.6540383100509644,
0.4260807931423187,
-0.2269800454378128,
0.03809051960706711,
-0.4840347468852997,
-0.16632011532783508,
0.527787446975708,
0.07766029983758926,
0.5249518752098083,
-0.17240673303604126,
-0.0027301074005663395,
-0.16109898686408997,
0.303969144821167,
-0.0618925467133522,
-0.18563121557235718,
-0.14527404308319092,
0.6574223637580872,
0.1284075677394867,
-0.4993215501308441,
0.48790740966796875,
-0.6122509837150574,
-0.2894629240036011,
0.24847246706485748,
0.39261195063591003,
0.6530461311340332,
0.18864256143569946,
0.6001990437507629,
-0.1544121652841568,
-0.08562763035297394,
0.18624261021614075,
-0.02416122704744339,
-0.27507147192955017,
-0.6142681241035461,
-0.24278321862220764,
-0.7195481657981873,
-0.4277496039867401,
-0.1473081260919571,
-0.40694352984428406,
0.18868672847747803,
-0.6528262495994568,
0.012079183012247086,
0.009467950090765953,
0.1812593936920166,
-0.8362497091293335,
0.05899599567055702,
-0.01563342846930027,
1.1815886497497559,
-0.5942680239677429,
0.49726659059524536,
1.0880472660064697,
-0.6038805842399597,
-0.6825437545776367,
-0.5532160997390747,
0.11476254463195801,
-0.5437959432601929,
0.767993688583374,
-0.36670368909835815,
0.29425710439682007,
-0.12393597513437271,
-0.2419426441192627,
-0.40559181571006775,
1.4369198083877563,
0.43072041869163513,
-0.3603745400905609,
-0.05837881565093994,
0.5864484310150146,
0.36623021960258484,
-0.2112806886434555,
-0.02956855483353138,
0.574673056602478,
0.9112815856933594,
0.22398404777050018,
-0.34754374623298645,
0.12191404402256012,
0.24718165397644043,
-0.06473478674888611,
-0.07292620837688446,
-0.4166696071624756,
0.5251557230949402,
0.5402923822402954,
-0.1811864972114563,
-0.40856263041496277,
0.44580724835395813,
-0.009708289988338947,
0.3841167390346527,
0.226957306265831,
0.7681454420089722,
0.933872401714325,
-0.31729191541671753,
1.2875261306762695,
-0.5058550834655762,
0.31631922721862793,
1.074600100517273,
-0.2751598656177521,
0.16615723073482513,
0.459492027759552,
-0.5425409078598022,
0.2912319600582123,
0.6426994204521179,
0.46751150488853455,
0.5196356177330017,
-0.21225863695144653,
-0.6948227882385254,
-0.15016470849514008,
-0.06693179905414581,
-0.018987741321325302,
0.04899249225854874,
0.10212214291095734,
-0.13972467184066772,
-0.4950905442237854,
-0.12935079634189606,
-0.023203708231449127,
0.14676381647586823,
-0.14868293702602386,
0.7442567944526672,
0.07205935567617416,
0.10927429795265198,
-0.16798712313175201,
-0.0071844845078885555,
0.3085921108722687,
-0.6383780837059021,
0.019626840949058533,
-0.15618637204170227,
-0.13337738811969757,
-0.6151137351989746,
-1.056355595588684,
0.47978129982948303,
-0.3345758616924286,
-0.2128155380487442,
-0.4654960334300995,
1.1350116729736328,
-0.23784036934375763,
-0.05869306996464729,
0.25371041893959045,
0.3748193383216858,
-0.13777026534080505,
0.019999947398900986,
-0.5046823024749756,
-0.16911597549915314,
-0.3971420228481293,
-0.5475901365280151,
0.45701515674591064,
0.5114557147026062,
0.09875476360321045,
0.8769804239273071,
0.4077981114387512,
0.1921779364347458,
0.3189488351345062,
0.06392422318458557,
0.6603218913078308,
-0.42465364933013916,
-0.7159414291381836,
-0.47428959608078003,
0.3939156234264374,
-0.27875202894210815,
-0.23775102198123932,
0.7093234062194824,
0.6602559089660645,
0.6058976650238037,
-0.04014146700501442,
1.1424121856689453,
-0.6428866386413574,
0.5708999633789062,
0.040872879326343536,
0.7572268843650818,
0.020536236464977264,
0.12728159129619598,
0.04078436270356178,
-0.573397159576416,
-0.3971712291240692,
0.5669996738433838,
-0.6446384787559509,
-0.38613834977149963,
0.12869517505168915,
0.7464937567710876,
0.033011436462402344,
0.07476168870925903,
0.14957433938980103,
0.26004141569137573,
0.6697853207588196,
0.2959910035133362,
0.7248044610023499,
0.05941257253289223,
0.49718180298805237,
-0.4670378863811493,
-0.17751070857048035,
-0.08852437883615494,
-0.7309040427207947,
-0.6597418189048767,
-0.5712312459945679,
-0.2663210332393646,
-0.21053671836853027,
-0.0319063737988472,
0.9978697299957275,
0.6826520562171936,
-0.4869678318500519,
-0.09954769164323807,
-0.19302353262901306,
0.48848825693130493,
-0.038044802844524384,
-0.3035547435283661,
0.3147261440753937,
-0.28900498151779175,
-0.21707333624362946,
0.06369197368621826,
0.591151773929596,
-0.1713186651468277,
-0.3479249179363251,
-0.4943794012069702,
0.1680033653974533,
-0.5349459052085876,
0.593600332736969,
0.72483891248703,
-0.5140678286552429,
-0.6154983043670654,
-0.18388670682907104,
0.060258474200963974,
0.05977674201130867,
1.0919393301010132,
-0.6919607520103455,
0.9175812005996704,
0.6428049206733704,
0.8920682668685913,
0.5396798253059387,
0.1744774430990219,
0.5326668620109558,
-1.0738193988800049,
-0.2205517441034317,
0.108755923807621,
0.1951313614845276,
0.217012420296669,
-0.6194102764129639,
0.21661950647830963,
0.38954153656959534,
-0.516280472278595,
-0.6002417802810669,
0.3125993013381958,
-0.8890801072120667,
-0.45983707904815674,
0.7550671696662903,
-0.5294843316078186,
-0.3697371482849121,
-0.695712685585022,
-0.22537797689437866,
0.1488298624753952,
-0.46466487646102905,
0.7043908834457397,
0.8733211755752563,
-0.6496486663818359,
-0.06764638423919678,
-0.5057970881462097,
0.45717063546180725,
-0.33293765783309937,
-1.033874273300171,
0.49817171692848206,
0.6170924305915833,
0.570724368095398,
0.23670636117458344,
0.940665066242218,
-0.08291352540254593,
-0.10076994448900223,
-0.17183217406272888,
0.0683990865945816,
-0.6541646122932434,
-0.08323618024587631,
0.00025597790954634547,
0.3660571575164795,
0.007054501678794622,
0.10885581374168396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07536v1 | BreakGPT: A Large Language Model with Multi-stage Structure for Financial Breakout Detection | 2024-02-12T10:04:07 | 2024-02-12T10:04:07 | Kang Zhang, Osamu Yoshie, Weiran Huang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Trading range breakout (TRB) is a key method in the technical analysis of
financial trading, widely employed by traders in financial markets such as
stocks, futures, and foreign exchange. However, distinguishing between true and
false breakout and providing the correct rationale cause significant challenges
to investors. Recently, large language models have achieved success in various
downstream applications, but their effectiveness in the domain of financial
breakout detection has been subpar. The reason is that the unique data and
specific knowledge are required in breakout detection. To address these issues,
we introduce BreakGPT, the first large language model for financial breakout
detection. Furthermore, we have developed a novel framework for large language
models, namely multi-stage structure, effectively reducing mistakes in
downstream applications. Experimental results indicate that compared to
GPT-3.5, BreakGPT improves the accuracy of answers and rational by 44%, with
the multi-stage structure contributing 17.6% to the improvement. Additionally,
it outperforms ChatGPT-4 by 42.07%. Our Code is publicly available:
https://github.com/Neviim96/BreakGPT | [
-0.14492565393447876,
-1.2040677070617676,
0.29156389832496643,
0.5313984155654907,
-0.1611676961183548,
0.5810918211936951,
-0.04281840845942497,
-0.6260123252868652,
-0.02749406360089779,
0.21969828009605408,
-0.42193639278411865,
-0.6631858944892883,
-0.8940070271492004,
-0.4522702097892761,
-0.8084294199943542,
1.05776846408844,
0.06142391264438629,
-0.3141825199127197,
0.7374735474586487,
0.2783500850200653,
-0.5018501877784729,
-0.3604612350463867,
-1.1934078931808472,
-0.1552676558494568,
0.3874589204788208,
0.07312843948602676,
0.5276502370834351,
0.5436747670173645,
0.7448565363883972,
0.2626790702342987,
-0.2628125548362732,
-0.22853755950927734,
-0.15518440306186676,
-0.020743751898407936,
-0.09838272631168365,
-0.18819153308868408,
-0.373055100440979,
-0.3839108943939209,
0.470121830701828,
0.3536575138568878,
-0.46249791979789734,
-0.16644902527332306,
-0.010934068821370602,
0.5662077069282532,
-0.3513302206993103,
0.7553104758262634,
-0.46230632066726685,
-0.10803532600402832,
-0.5715060830116272,
0.038010627031326294,
-0.7684088349342346,
-0.3961799144744873,
0.13287346065044403,
-0.029792647808790207,
0.05908722057938576,
-0.26777034997940063,
0.711554229259491,
-0.06281162798404694,
-0.8379743695259094,
-0.26841339468955994,
-0.6999797224998474,
0.4615783393383026,
-0.8065115213394165,
0.41628676652908325,
-0.08642209321260452,
0.4712875187397003,
-0.23207511007785797,
-0.7995684742927551,
-0.2716083228588104,
-0.39929085969924927,
0.09344211220741272,
-0.12434156239032745,
-0.35636621713638306,
-0.14726266264915466,
0.16012024879455566,
0.10141099244356155,
-0.5710657238960266,
0.025920014828443527,
-0.4122615456581116,
-0.18205538392066956,
0.07557014375925064,
0.05719674378633499,
0.42649558186531067,
0.026303980499505997,
-0.6360056400299072,
-0.051370199769735336,
-0.797767698764801,
-0.1980934888124466,
0.23120233416557312,
0.8216022849082947,
-0.149605393409729,
0.2409989833831787,
-0.11355119943618774,
0.7152974605560303,
0.009681164287030697,
-0.3676077425479889,
0.317542165517807,
-0.3123915195465088,
0.028816895559430122,
0.11516676843166351,
0.6218505501747131,
-0.10134395211935043,
0.12654124200344086,
0.1423417180776596,
-0.2999591827392578,
-0.18143445253372192,
0.023254601284861565,
-0.9229623079299927,
-0.26247072219848633,
-0.0009662722586654127,
-0.3042774200439453,
-0.32823076844215393,
0.19733582437038422,
-0.777876615524292,
-0.2258635014295578,
-0.00765301613137126,
0.23233775794506073,
-0.8563122749328613,
-0.5354833602905273,
0.13916517794132233,
-0.006335187703371048,
0.35994213819503784,
0.10467611253261566,
-0.678142249584198,
0.331100732088089,
0.9171538352966309,
1.207321286201477,
0.17746207118034363,
-0.38417330384254456,
-0.9368492960929871,
0.17648093402385712,
-0.15244093537330627,
0.9529618620872498,
-0.610431432723999,
-0.22883489727973938,
-0.27515819668769836,
-0.42104268074035645,
-0.33905360102653503,
-0.3297102153301239,
0.21669244766235352,
-0.5001135468482971,
-0.04553379863500595,
0.13449688255786896,
-0.512231171131134,
-0.21520718932151794,
0.41071027517318726,
-0.7787514925003052,
0.6938512325286865,
0.26958316564559937,
-0.8733973503112793,
0.4652150273323059,
-1.2887033224105835,
-0.6795775294303894,
0.3957960307598114,
0.02851247228682041,
-0.42102503776550293,
-0.3002084791660309,
0.21283859014511108,
0.003542577615007758,
-0.1216861754655838,
0.3496935963630676,
-0.2648829519748688,
-0.1052262932062149,
0.5524762272834778,
-0.5490180850028992,
0.5705912113189697,
0.126983180642128,
-0.8962299823760986,
0.22812965512275696,
-0.7903715372085571,
-0.034221068024635315,
0.03362652286887169,
-0.270170658826828,
-0.2400471419095993,
0.14466266334056854,
0.4680710434913635,
0.3889285624027252,
0.09926114231348038,
-0.3626674711704254,
0.18874713778495789,
-0.2563331425189972,
0.6652166247367859,
0.8642362952232361,
0.057627204805612564,
-0.279570609331131,
-0.05687714368104935,
0.6297304034233093,
0.44326311349868774,
0.060383010655641556,
-0.2602669596672058,
-0.5378565192222595,
-0.3094402253627777,
-0.4609149992465973,
0.5000936388969421,
0.7031130790710449,
-0.47079527378082275,
0.439197838306427,
0.0109108230099082,
-0.5015791058540344,
0.13550187647342682,
0.0021288285497576,
0.3214762508869171,
0.42467832565307617,
0.3835357427597046,
-0.21082358062267303,
-0.47752195596694946,
-0.7824054956436157,
-0.44708433747291565,
-0.10164863616228104,
0.10134511440992355,
-0.26005086302757263,
0.49231794476509094,
-0.22697757184505463,
0.7589390873908997,
-0.7784700393676758,
-0.19749346375465393,
-0.7350444197654724,
0.39073583483695984,
0.5842762589454651,
0.3493238389492035,
0.6932346820831299,
-0.9510901570320129,
-0.7177284359931946,
0.2013414204120636,
-0.234433114528656,
0.08348885923624039,
-0.24901802837848663,
-0.02922150492668152,
0.021999038755893707,
0.31323331594467163,
-0.6182200908660889,
0.7266046404838562,
0.5385766625404358,
-0.88691246509552,
0.6560388207435608,
-0.013070077635347843,
-0.056049514561891556,
-1.0975784063339233,
0.1267455816268921,
0.4129410684108734,
-0.40077799558639526,
-0.8397976756095886,
0.10848250240087509,
0.040499620139598846,
0.15079642832279205,
-0.2497921735048294,
0.33147263526916504,
-0.05868939682841301,
-0.05854012817144394,
-0.4786987900733948,
0.1610923558473587,
-0.41968467831611633,
0.26710015535354614,
0.07799238711595535,
0.7738736867904663,
0.568644106388092,
-0.30211058259010315,
0.3034183084964752,
0.23143038153648376,
-0.637493908405304,
0.45679184794425964,
-0.7507887482643127,
0.14134922623634338,
0.38371437788009644,
0.3655179738998413,
-0.9297277331352234,
-0.0004318327992223203,
0.39505794644355774,
-0.10759590566158295,
0.21726740896701813,
-0.3739544749259949,
-0.44004952907562256,
-0.3925701379776001,
0.11585565656423569,
0.382869690656662,
0.2759961187839508,
-0.5171289443969727,
0.4413544535636902,
0.0046097529120743275,
-0.44714242219924927,
-0.641285240650177,
-0.5038326978683472,
0.18486759066581726,
-0.26524147391319275,
-0.83946692943573,
-0.009786740876734257,
-0.06686805188655853,
-0.28273940086364746,
-0.292245477437973,
-0.2604934275150299,
-0.1400740146636963,
0.0526190921664238,
-0.017299937084317207,
0.5202962756156921,
-0.16459974646568298,
-0.06293143332004547,
-0.3972737491130829,
-0.37873750925064087,
-0.11853494495153427,
-0.6673073768615723,
0.9921067953109741,
-0.46500730514526367,
-0.3346875011920929,
-0.1711009293794632,
0.21227361261844635,
0.6348295211791992,
-0.3817966878414154,
1.0896549224853516,
0.5739607214927673,
-0.2579125463962555,
-0.21278086304664612,
-0.2882726788520813,
0.16410112380981445,
-0.5121272206306458,
0.40731528401374817,
-0.6409802436828613,
-0.8863608241081238,
0.6481810808181763,
0.11092100292444229,
-0.14749272167682648,
0.5560699105262756,
0.7974032163619995,
0.6062888503074646,
0.7312824130058289,
0.6089406609535217,
-0.11430927366018295,
0.6501009464263916,
0.17424148321151733,
0.6466697454452515,
-0.3117985129356384,
-0.3323654532432556,
-0.4540253281593323,
-0.24347473680973053,
-0.30997923016548157,
-0.28397852182388306,
0.29489248991012573,
-0.04518602415919304,
-0.3299501836299896,
0.49083656072616577,
-0.23244938254356384,
0.5799860954284668,
0.5168488621711731,
0.24442501366138458,
0.4203416109085083,
-0.268355131149292,
-0.13353893160820007,
0.04542455077171326,
-0.2606748342514038,
-0.0533166266977787,
1.1074507236480713,
0.6435074210166931,
0.826330304145813,
0.1390000432729721,
0.5040648579597473,
0.3399219512939453,
0.39870333671569824,
-0.5923452973365784,
0.29423055052757263,
-0.29052627086639404,
-0.6437660455703735,
-0.3060424029827118,
-0.9593589305877686,
-0.5659880638122559,
0.22262415289878845,
0.35863402485847473,
-0.9203858971595764,
0.07257793098688126,
-0.0800417885184288,
-0.27219533920288086,
0.4454515874385834,
-0.6297147870063782,
1.1291320323944092,
-0.22401033341884613,
0.011722489260137081,
-0.021723749116063118,
-0.49219968914985657,
0.623214602470398,
-0.3667386472225189,
0.5171681046485901,
-0.0702424943447113,
0.34018459916114807,
0.6102247834205627,
-0.7369658946990967,
0.920356035232544,
-0.25941547751426697,
-0.5087984204292297,
0.41905099153518677,
0.18468454480171204,
1.0035499334335327,
0.11493492126464844,
0.29108500480651855,
-0.11452721804380417,
-0.013759518042206764,
-0.4943418502807617,
-0.3681700825691223,
0.4312478005886078,
-0.18741212785243988,
-0.03843306750059128,
-0.4617357552051544,
-0.7179637551307678,
-0.18625585734844208,
0.35317331552505493,
0.015285564586520195,
0.4695413112640381,
-0.001435504062101245,
0.2970675230026245,
0.13126103579998016,
-0.017392944544553757,
0.33830365538597107,
0.5257852673530579,
-0.5608195662498474,
-0.19902241230010986,
0.7491274476051331,
-0.2146598845720291,
0.4092860221862793,
0.2962488532066345,
0.22664232552051544,
-0.4634639620780945,
-0.6944871544837952,
0.055174704641103745,
0.059622496366500854,
-0.8053179383277893,
-0.11281902343034744,
-0.4064512550830841,
-0.42543232440948486,
-0.5020719170570374,
0.21526865661144257,
-0.5479956865310669,
-0.3114946186542511,
0.3573155999183655,
-0.5833109021186829,
0.47863686084747314,
0.7285583019256592,
-0.3490491211414337,
0.29064661264419556,
-1.1125437021255493,
0.31486085057258606,
0.24305808544158936,
0.43381157517433167,
-0.1288696974515915,
-0.3543736934661865,
-0.4263744354248047,
0.026769250631332397,
-0.23526908457279205,
-0.8055020570755005,
0.619035005569458,
0.0655498281121254,
0.19512014091014862,
0.7166692614555359,
-0.3201480805873871,
0.6588418483734131,
-0.2633461356163025,
0.24895960092544556,
0.43477779626846313,
-1.3730343580245972,
0.5252209901809692,
-0.5595235228538513,
0.40239042043685913,
0.2783968448638916,
0.09714032709598541,
-1.0988739728927612,
-0.6479891538619995,
-0.49198198318481445,
-1.1320791244506836,
0.6586394906044006,
0.23645269870758057,
-0.22853337228298187,
-0.133640319108963,
0.14054912328720093,
0.20560109615325928,
0.32602831721305847,
-1.16558837890625,
0.032114796340465546,
-0.14882250130176544,
-0.18423663079738617,
0.1984846442937851,
-0.13595189154148102,
-0.17930205166339874,
0.08213057368993759,
0.38749927282333374,
-0.17057745158672333,
-0.032911140471696854,
-0.3372837007045746,
0.02043296955525875,
-0.04523139074444771,
0.43582889437675476,
0.4814699590206146,
1.171924114227295,
-0.3404895067214966,
0.00441401731222868,
-0.140492781996727,
-0.777277946472168,
0.15103371441364288,
0.2949424386024475,
-0.16464251279830933,
-0.1289413720369339,
0.6545649766921997,
0.6579073667526245,
0.2975650429725647,
-0.9571694135665894,
0.41326624155044556,
0.04509574547410011,
-0.2653663158416748,
-0.2506772577762604,
0.01951228827238083,
0.006727735511958599,
0.6406774520874023,
0.5991826057434082,
-0.006486896425485611,
0.13786198198795319,
-0.7585289478302002,
0.6245907545089722,
0.14500519633293152,
-0.29948726296424866,
-0.17805258929729462,
0.6390829682350159,
-0.06355328857898712,
-0.07205599546432495,
0.9951916933059692,
-0.15351396799087524,
-0.8810870051383972,
0.7977442741394043,
0.8749690055847168,
1.0557233095169067,
-0.3658566474914551,
0.4910458028316498,
-0.0900702178478241,
0.5376989245414734,
-0.3012116551399231,
0.25320297479629517,
0.535936176776886,
-0.7701610326766968,
-0.8551658987998962,
-0.5813303589820862,
-0.29843243956565857,
0.12485623359680176,
-0.48166847229003906,
0.22743891179561615,
-0.655620813369751,
-0.03559264913201332,
0.1034163385629654,
-0.37768813967704773,
-0.27866050601005554,
0.08011025190353394,
0.3057202994823456,
1.0595200061798096,
-0.6457210183143616,
0.8863128423690796,
0.1398341953754425,
-0.41119787096977234,
-0.9165552854537964,
0.04440371319651604,
0.07844239473342896,
-0.5588086247444153,
1.067803144454956,
0.40302538871765137,
-0.08565177023410797,
-0.15728746354579926,
-0.3949229121208191,
-0.8073248267173767,
0.8399157524108887,
0.25548750162124634,
-0.8455275297164917,
-0.2982148230075836,
0.10078968107700348,
0.26511844992637634,
-0.44460931420326233,
0.1656898558139801,
0.9601437449455261,
0.8361612558364868,
0.7391413450241089,
-0.9242761731147766,
-0.026952644810080528,
-0.04332501441240311,
-0.2057524025440216,
0.8954921960830688,
-0.6188183426856995,
1.1640814542770386,
-0.13484913110733032,
-0.07606124132871628,
-0.15894295275211334,
0.3027587831020355,
0.42233484983444214,
0.3122660517692566,
0.6486599445343018,
0.6544675230979919,
0.5175479650497437,
-0.46611905097961426,
0.8477818369865417,
-0.5066830515861511,
0.7255343794822693,
1.2069995403289795,
-0.3545660674571991,
0.8585047125816345,
-0.06677799671888351,
-0.35159292817115784,
0.7765960693359375,
0.5509696006774902,
-0.16129523515701294,
0.511261522769928,
0.2633332312107086,
-0.34509527683258057,
-0.3484058976173401,
0.5677719712257385,
-0.5222843885421753,
0.4595656096935272,
0.38225623965263367,
-0.2744561433792114,
-0.37981143593788147,
0.035309720784425735,
0.2185986340045929,
-0.4763568341732025,
-0.14059627056121826,
0.3816044330596924,
0.15075770020484924,
-0.2455696314573288,
0.12992751598358154,
0.2985944151878357,
0.26440516114234924,
-1.0064928531646729,
0.17674238979816437,
-0.3349132239818573,
0.5709618330001831,
0.0009169711265712976,
-0.5661172270774841,
0.5055010318756104,
0.18502114713191986,
0.21045324206352234,
-0.07268606126308441,
0.7579858303070068,
-0.3841346204280853,
-0.7060267329216003,
0.5483431816101074,
0.3291006088256836,
-0.1559867113828659,
-0.5467368960380554,
-0.7664967179298401,
-0.165349081158638,
0.028667282313108444,
-0.4433351755142212,
0.20394715666770935,
0.47269418835639954,
0.11974567174911499,
0.8600550293922424,
0.9672411680221558,
-0.15807291865348816,
0.07670043408870697,
0.28386107087135315,
0.7955209016799927,
-1.1528078317642212,
-0.9980247020721436,
-1.2224680185317993,
0.49223190546035767,
0.05944482609629631,
0.002143848454579711,
0.6995661854743958,
0.7019686698913574,
0.5058765411376953,
0.07099200785160065,
0.8403048515319824,
-0.17677979171276093,
0.4742739796638489,
-0.6537681818008423,
0.39455828070640564,
-0.011097691021859646,
0.5492802262306213,
-0.5405506491661072,
-1.071110725402832,
-0.44301003217697144,
0.4742264151573181,
-0.4885919690132141,
0.19304798543453217,
1.0064468383789062,
0.3342911899089813,
-0.12299817055463791,
0.20908966660499573,
0.0782700777053833,
0.5076727271080017,
0.7159615159034729,
0.8522971868515015,
0.8447375297546387,
-0.15161848068237305,
1.092079520225525,
0.034022845327854156,
-0.26217782497406006,
-0.2184077799320221,
-0.8045867681503296,
-0.8967609405517578,
-0.06300609558820724,
-0.45065268874168396,
-0.5025539994239807,
-0.09341571480035782,
0.8160901069641113,
0.4842192530632019,
-0.7335458993911743,
-0.47288134694099426,
-0.2995609641075134,
0.035822708159685135,
-0.5569296479225159,
-0.2643883228302002,
0.3290562033653259,
-0.46069177985191345,
-0.4682312309741974,
0.740311324596405,
0.7315621972084045,
0.17592491209506989,
-0.06626078486442566,
0.1394834965467453,
-0.2113139033317566,
0.0337081216275692,
0.6124741435050964,
0.24274404346942902,
-0.040450744330883026,
-0.3260349929332733,
-0.17571204900741577,
0.1702207624912262,
0.3301450312137604,
0.9581939578056335,
-0.30197447538375854,
0.025470003485679626,
0.16967269778251648,
0.5001576542854309,
0.8292346000671387,
0.06013095751404762,
0.6639193892478943,
-0.584743320941925,
0.28374263644218445,
0.024769103154540062,
0.34610432386398315,
-0.03935178741812706,
-0.25939953327178955,
0.6260626912117004,
0.4426426887512207,
-0.2328261435031891,
-0.6263566613197327,
0.28634321689605713,
-0.9510809183120728,
-0.4070510268211365,
0.8330679535865784,
-0.21192428469657898,
-0.23365053534507751,
-0.02769659459590912,
-0.03632840886712074,
-0.0806623324751854,
-0.5325775742530823,
0.8511089086532593,
0.993120551109314,
0.11878547817468643,
-0.3435002267360687,
-0.5451162457466125,
0.10541407763957977,
-0.1050494909286499,
-1.0469292402267456,
0.139200359582901,
0.4151722192764282,
0.42650729417800903,
0.19514629244804382,
0.5626890063285828,
-0.21843837201595306,
0.3062115013599396,
0.2375815510749817,
-0.20443940162658691,
-0.012608513236045837,
-0.48423296213150024,
0.005833358503878117,
0.5419842600822449,
0.1051328107714653,
-0.07310876250267029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07519v1 | MAFIA: Multi-Adapter Fused Inclusive LanguAge Models | 2024-02-12T09:41:00 | 2024-02-12T09:41:00 | Prachi Jain, Ashutosh Sathe, Varun Gumma, Kabir Ahuja, Sunayana Sitaram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) are widely used in NLP for various tasks.
Recent studies have identified various biases that such models exhibit and have
proposed methods to correct these biases. However, most of the works address a
limited set of bias dimensions independently such as gender, race, or religion.
Moreover, the methods typically involve finetuning the full model to maintain
the performance on the downstream task. In this work, we aim to modularly
debias a pretrained language model across multiple dimensions. Previous works
extensively explored debiasing PLMs using limited US-centric counterfactual
data augmentation (CDA). We use structured knowledge and a large generative
model to build a diverse CDA across multiple bias dimensions in a
semi-automated way. We highlight how existing debiasing methods do not consider
interactions between multiple societal biases and propose a debiasing model
that exploits the synergy amongst various societal biases and enables
multi-bias debiasing simultaneously. An extensive evaluation on multiple tasks
and languages demonstrates the efficacy of our approach. | [
-0.4577969014644623,
-0.7850812673568726,
0.366157203912735,
0.2889866828918457,
-0.34135180711746216,
0.15129373967647552,
-0.09147224575281143,
-0.17907579243183136,
0.37220263481140137,
0.6303359270095825,
-0.5619680285453796,
-0.3814277946949005,
-0.5200285315513611,
-0.04909166693687439,
-0.1765253245830536,
1.0839051008224487,
0.4595293700695038,
0.468479186296463,
-0.022031456232070923,
-0.25453099608421326,
-0.593971848487854,
-0.7051391005516052,
-0.2336031049489975,
-0.19161446392536163,
0.24666713178157806,
0.4304119944572449,
0.9050239324569702,
0.08969664573669434,
0.22334183752536774,
0.37758105993270874,
0.26241737604141235,
0.13684004545211792,
-0.409347265958786,
-0.009311674162745476,
-0.5301086902618408,
-0.14485777914524078,
-0.6082496643066406,
0.21890223026275635,
0.24453678727149963,
0.6142587661743164,
-0.3936766982078552,
0.17028464376926422,
0.04367411881685257,
0.4037279784679413,
-0.7502427101135254,
-0.22411219775676727,
-0.9381667375564575,
-0.2607042193412781,
-0.04420206695795059,
0.32183149456977844,
-0.12013136595487595,
-0.4685229957103729,
0.06889356672763824,
-0.5791952013969421,
0.06069617718458176,
-0.20387816429138184,
0.15751078724861145,
0.3618277609348297,
-0.6239891052246094,
-0.4463602602481842,
-0.8664056062698364,
0.8184815645217896,
-0.6881128549575806,
0.09160403162240982,
0.3582770824432373,
0.18433226644992828,
0.005191690754145384,
-0.37442547082901,
-0.9284245371818542,
0.10655487328767776,
-0.07563772797584534,
0.09164255112409592,
-0.024289388209581375,
0.05684060975909233,
-0.03756679594516754,
0.3402278423309326,
-0.2818489968776703,
0.2901681065559387,
-0.2658299207687378,
-0.05010919272899628,
0.5395354628562927,
0.022796262055635452,
0.4614752233028412,
-0.025689423084259033,
-0.6380389928817749,
0.017785239964723587,
-0.5692518353462219,
-0.0935511440038681,
0.6694665551185608,
0.30524519085884094,
-0.21101723611354828,
0.33201533555984497,
-0.1678019016981125,
0.6704680919647217,
0.01940053328871727,
-0.16884230077266693,
0.4722687005996704,
-0.3452756106853485,
-0.39040607213974,
-0.16214172542095184,
0.7842827439308167,
0.2592400908470154,
0.10062552988529205,
-0.09674104303121567,
-0.1143745705485344,
0.24884983897209167,
0.5950272679328918,
-0.576524555683136,
0.03108677826821804,
0.3423788249492645,
-0.31790992617607117,
-0.1435931921005249,
-0.14588280022144318,
-1.0780915021896362,
-0.646582305431366,
-0.2448607236146927,
0.576033890247345,
-0.3472537696361542,
-0.2275678962469101,
0.20250630378723145,
-0.09884148836135864,
0.07974780350923538,
0.06297282874584198,
-0.883644700050354,
-0.12489401549100876,
0.39957594871520996,
0.5976861119270325,
0.19162072241306305,
-0.254563570022583,
-0.3775947391986847,
0.3190171718597412,
0.016070732846856117,
0.6532531976699829,
-0.8411527276039124,
-0.43398669362068176,
-0.021280670538544655,
-0.2452695071697235,
-0.14672401547431946,
-0.41100338101387024,
0.6001506447792053,
-0.4459245800971985,
0.2593691051006317,
-0.10272663086652756,
-0.15614815056324005,
-0.4107806086540222,
0.3219761252403259,
-0.6502344608306885,
0.691407322883606,
0.08378923684358597,
-0.5922865867614746,
0.5144709944725037,
-0.5768406391143799,
-0.4397655427455902,
-0.07937129586935043,
0.0255262553691864,
-0.45620182156562805,
0.2672910988330841,
0.4278774559497833,
0.194426029920578,
-0.24605287611484528,
0.8990327715873718,
-0.8274873495101929,
-0.12982288002967834,
0.014984728768467903,
-0.3672100007534027,
1.1969671249389648,
0.1438484638929367,
-0.3076927363872528,
0.3752706050872803,
-0.9879603385925293,
-0.29481327533721924,
-0.44039544463157654,
-0.16053852438926697,
-0.6928688883781433,
0.15905237197875977,
-0.03514132648706436,
0.7586096525192261,
0.18197646737098694,
-0.4802478551864624,
0.3762516975402832,
-0.23657456040382385,
0.2226874828338623,
0.7454090118408203,
-0.36252036690711975,
0.5325068235397339,
-0.2103746235370636,
0.47930702567100525,
0.2976592183113098,
0.45201942324638367,
-0.02144785039126873,
-0.178680419921875,
-0.8317698836326599,
-0.7625771164894104,
0.09357909113168716,
0.8061004281044006,
-1.050814151763916,
0.7873883843421936,
-0.14587116241455078,
-0.5589428544044495,
-0.6676052808761597,
0.19459541141986847,
0.2401677966117859,
0.32065239548683167,
0.42893221974372864,
-0.5641120076179504,
-0.7816667556762695,
-1.15402090549469,
-0.3117963373661041,
0.04509194195270538,
-0.28286322951316833,
0.04835067689418793,
0.4690142571926117,
-0.4035850763320923,
0.8219011425971985,
-0.156869038939476,
-0.630748987197876,
-0.32779455184936523,
0.16045697033405304,
0.3515411615371704,
0.6077017188072205,
0.7212259769439697,
-0.5577682852745056,
-0.2008492797613144,
-0.38798433542251587,
-0.5015075206756592,
-0.22965486347675323,
-0.19520758092403412,
-0.03624040633440018,
0.0025983203668147326,
0.010038149543106556,
-0.34586694836616516,
0.3070828318595886,
0.8293396234512329,
-0.5667247176170349,
0.33331531286239624,
-0.31362196803092957,
0.20339500904083252,
-1.242417812347412,
-0.11169513314962387,
-0.10210113972425461,
-0.09557218104600906,
-0.8812311887741089,
0.11301830410957336,
-0.14553387463092804,
0.12295237183570862,
-0.14311054348945618,
0.34705787897109985,
-0.38019588589668274,
-0.05905701592564583,
-0.2922322750091553,
0.0956672951579094,
-0.016971904784440994,
0.5237947106361389,
0.007606000639498234,
0.5108823776245117,
0.8813053965568542,
-0.5456297993659973,
0.3023775815963745,
0.22178316116333008,
-0.5092987418174744,
0.5300476551055908,
-0.5654712915420532,
0.21494244039058685,
-0.2382572591304779,
0.22420218586921692,
-0.9405407309532166,
0.11895114183425903,
0.035726938396692276,
-0.07956184446811676,
-0.10288885235786438,
-0.08368001878261566,
-0.5255534648895264,
-0.23185443878173828,
-0.4016936123371124,
0.4317481517791748,
0.4360443651676178,
-0.5172491073608398,
0.8819823861122131,
0.8436737060546875,
-0.11047187447547913,
-0.666343629360199,
-0.49895378947257996,
0.026532460004091263,
-0.41448864340782166,
-0.7427785396575928,
0.2774222791194916,
-0.15582522749900818,
-0.4294503927230835,
-0.5034000873565674,
0.07335107028484344,
-0.35478219389915466,
0.2304908037185669,
0.2558133006095886,
0.3915124535560608,
0.24238158762454987,
0.0005995091632939875,
0.06933533400297165,
0.13349883258342743,
-0.19545480608940125,
-0.36830148100852966,
0.5380620956420898,
0.09227053821086884,
-0.31020018458366394,
0.079311303794384,
0.5179705023765564,
0.5457033514976501,
-0.36245861649513245,
1.001273512840271,
0.5983673334121704,
-0.08710125088691711,
-0.16132225096225739,
-0.7968971729278564,
-0.12217960506677628,
-0.4334720969200134,
0.26243695616722107,
-0.20413805544376373,
-0.9073167443275452,
0.9465808272361755,
0.21274997293949127,
0.0756765604019165,
0.12389768660068512,
0.8475250601768494,
0.31365057826042175,
0.7869908213615417,
0.6196576356887817,
-0.1456119269132614,
0.4238192141056061,
0.1413479745388031,
0.40685784816741943,
-0.5031315088272095,
-0.22424645721912384,
-0.6075000166893005,
-0.45005494356155396,
-0.6306642889976501,
-0.6310227513313293,
0.5240557789802551,
0.31444641947746277,
-0.04471924901008606,
0.07586485892534256,
-0.04192059487104416,
0.38775765895843506,
0.8079112768173218,
0.0793519914150238,
0.27734503149986267,
-0.21133609116077423,
-0.15195605158805847,
0.24670681357383728,
-0.6362534761428833,
-0.3543028235435486,
1.0034523010253906,
0.1215595081448555,
0.7413734793663025,
0.3728412389755249,
0.42337214946746826,
0.14928734302520752,
0.4464496374130249,
-0.38940706849098206,
0.2999216914176941,
-0.5000007152557373,
-0.9776751399040222,
-0.2317475527524948,
-0.18709474802017212,
-0.4065561294555664,
0.6520200371742249,
-0.3809404969215393,
-0.5639177560806274,
0.5945868492126465,
0.10776282101869583,
-0.5793485045433044,
0.31217050552368164,
-0.7153481245040894,
0.7533859610557556,
-0.016682753339409828,
-0.4545045793056488,
-0.37040606141090393,
-0.6073427796363831,
0.6671242117881775,
-0.3145051598548889,
0.8220541477203369,
-0.16765670478343964,
0.1592492312192917,
0.32932722568511963,
-0.4585133492946625,
1.16512131690979,
-0.31330806016921997,
-0.2675063908100128,
0.2695035934448242,
-0.02781272493302822,
0.36882951855659485,
0.29190024733543396,
-0.2606968879699707,
0.457863450050354,
-0.2921300530433655,
-0.3867316246032715,
-0.4158986508846283,
0.6365400552749634,
-0.6597504019737244,
-0.8295173048973083,
-0.15325917303562164,
-0.8745049834251404,
-0.32337117195129395,
0.17386651039123535,
-0.24631665647029877,
0.49798184633255005,
-0.23690247535705566,
0.12848545610904694,
0.42485734820365906,
-0.48586151003837585,
0.7044252157211304,
0.8242809176445007,
-0.04275341331958771,
-0.4040960967540741,
0.39470958709716797,
-0.13999627530574799,
0.24616330862045288,
0.10464184731245041,
0.08208250999450684,
-0.24825136363506317,
-0.512218177318573,
-0.48369768261909485,
-0.30900558829307556,
-0.40908005833625793,
-0.15724675357341766,
-0.6853070855140686,
0.19513724744319916,
-0.6731321215629578,
-0.02271556667983532,
-0.3392444849014282,
-0.4071045219898224,
-0.008832219056785107,
-0.04453933984041214,
0.055610548704862595,
0.5926701426506042,
-0.39387550950050354,
0.595349907875061,
-0.904443621635437,
0.5824333429336548,
0.5658291578292847,
0.47282499074935913,
-0.34230026602745056,
-0.647453248500824,
-0.11132056266069412,
0.12624001502990723,
-0.2654248774051666,
-1.1168180704116821,
0.4781559407711029,
0.18866413831710815,
0.5958587527275085,
0.4140508770942688,
0.1842247098684311,
0.6039158701896667,
-0.4400547444820404,
0.6722062826156616,
0.14536815881729126,
-1.2016878128051758,
0.30415308475494385,
-0.5260996222496033,
0.19753560423851013,
0.7058240175247192,
0.303296834230423,
-0.23189662396907806,
-0.5204477906227112,
-0.3163786232471466,
-0.7309861779212952,
0.6955307722091675,
0.0028195043560117483,
0.4192388951778412,
-0.19232597947120667,
-0.018214348703622818,
0.37209656834602356,
0.33623725175857544,
-1.0827999114990234,
-0.22564983367919922,
-0.37504419684410095,
-0.14972324669361115,
-0.03198966383934021,
-0.480590283870697,
-0.08569880574941635,
-0.2638852298259735,
0.8205068707466125,
-0.0955546647310257,
-0.48852264881134033,
0.04520720615983009,
-0.3360479176044464,
0.4359751045703888,
0.7418266534805298,
0.554831862449646,
0.8286529779434204,
-0.033979061990976334,
0.1020769402384758,
0.13568243384361267,
-0.4353747069835663,
0.18370574712753296,
0.2673995792865753,
-0.3338835537433624,
-0.19965361058712006,
0.14967294037342072,
0.8104481101036072,
0.14502638578414917,
-0.570023775100708,
0.45898449420928955,
0.10145344585180283,
0.05640393868088722,
-0.24215862154960632,
-0.02440277487039566,
-0.024153832346200943,
0.35262811183929443,
0.29105597734451294,
0.15913450717926025,
0.26482677459716797,
-0.7395094037055969,
0.15312528610229492,
0.7162581086158752,
-0.47229093313217163,
-0.36311784386634827,
0.43415367603302,
0.6286842226982117,
0.04413922503590584,
0.41379454731941223,
-0.43640369176864624,
-0.65328049659729,
0.401150643825531,
0.4506623148918152,
0.8888288736343384,
-0.8373266458511353,
0.32777875661849976,
0.3460433781147003,
0.5782209634780884,
0.012299776077270508,
0.19139432907104492,
0.13936671614646912,
-1.0589083433151245,
-0.6435139775276184,
-0.8042761087417603,
0.17232577502727509,
0.12382879853248596,
-0.5391278862953186,
0.2952980101108551,
-0.23578235507011414,
0.04605667665600777,
-0.21243950724601746,
-0.26054826378822327,
-0.5531880855560303,
0.2007656842470169,
0.08687712252140045,
0.6277921199798584,
-1.0237350463867188,
1.2368967533111572,
0.5871110558509827,
-0.30241647362709045,
-0.34290969371795654,
-0.2188951075077057,
0.003257306292653084,
-0.8942806720733643,
0.436383992433548,
0.14726139605045319,
-0.11897079646587372,
-0.08080092072486877,
-0.21527548134326935,
-0.5969353914260864,
0.7829602360725403,
0.3000342547893524,
-0.7621747255325317,
-0.0035708933137357235,
0.09864909201860428,
0.5181240439414978,
-0.6892613172531128,
0.4648021459579468,
0.6635870337486267,
0.455160915851593,
0.03337715566158295,
-1.0422571897506714,
-0.010358132421970367,
-0.10007289797067642,
-0.10800425708293915,
0.05612509325146675,
-0.5229662656784058,
1.034558892250061,
-0.2835540175437927,
-0.04509791359305382,
-0.26485830545425415,
0.22372065484523773,
0.21356894075870514,
0.16452093422412872,
0.8431084156036377,
0.7313376069068909,
0.5207827091217041,
0.18205316364765167,
0.8831275105476379,
-0.3597131371498108,
0.231496199965477,
1.385221242904663,
-0.5496281385421753,
0.27492260932922363,
0.44722780585289,
-0.10007699579000473,
0.8050791025161743,
0.2298419177532196,
0.06731131672859192,
0.6209778785705566,
0.2424589842557907,
-0.3331165909767151,
-0.5284515619277954,
-0.13834984600543976,
-0.19176065921783447,
0.8881683349609375,
0.31420832872390747,
-0.30405789613723755,
-0.3374241292476654,
0.14819718897342682,
-0.10805393755435944,
0.1564980000257492,
-0.4620175063610077,
0.9462180137634277,
-0.21095581352710724,
-0.7786127924919128,
0.05255017802119255,
0.15139111876487732,
1.0278658866882324,
-0.6686171889305115,
0.14225944876670837,
-0.362201988697052,
0.1941455751657486,
-0.02925250492990017,
-0.29652372002601624,
0.6100286841392517,
-0.0852745845913887,
-0.4209807515144348,
-0.2765001356601715,
0.7538519501686096,
-0.7049061059951782,
-0.5749513506889343,
0.41367605328559875,
0.6383868455886841,
-0.22456489503383636,
-0.2325456142425537,
-0.5755681991577148,
-0.11159402132034302,
0.1547657549381256,
0.019910549744963646,
0.20834144949913025,
0.19837690889835358,
-0.046623777598142624,
0.5319966077804565,
0.6082373261451721,
-0.08590154349803925,
0.12279874086380005,
0.3354739844799042,
0.9433600902557373,
-0.5623407959938049,
-0.658930778503418,
-1.207061529159546,
0.6265285611152649,
-0.1342955380678177,
-0.15595486760139465,
0.8768237233161926,
0.46945247054100037,
0.6631998419761658,
-0.18932288885116577,
0.7922630310058594,
-0.1937636137008667,
0.427097886800766,
-0.4349433481693268,
0.6575913429260254,
-0.30213528871536255,
0.40163055062294006,
-0.23341147601604462,
-0.8714778423309326,
-0.07531053572893143,
0.3613375425338745,
-0.24466370046138763,
0.03967057913541794,
0.3007000982761383,
0.7826732397079468,
-0.0761258453130722,
0.1197088435292244,
0.418279230594635,
0.2301149219274521,
0.20256835222244263,
0.6681708097457886,
0.6588754057884216,
-0.10632707923650742,
0.3403686285018921,
-0.12887859344482422,
-0.41197583079338074,
0.11186597496271133,
-0.9522777795791626,
-1.1024519205093384,
-0.5501428842544556,
-0.019299713894724846,
-0.03126489743590355,
-0.12233191728591919,
0.6703240871429443,
0.8450860381126404,
-0.8278459310531616,
-0.05699789151549339,
0.2204534113407135,
0.5025375485420227,
-0.003012018743902445,
-0.16681699454784393,
-0.0509929284453392,
-0.35675036907196045,
-0.8640101552009583,
0.42719098925590515,
0.3302749693393707,
-0.1860833615064621,
-0.549679696559906,
0.2174525111913681,
-0.4814242124557495,
0.20206008851528168,
0.6731030344963074,
-0.3447662889957428,
-0.4951917231082916,
-0.35330986976623535,
-0.4511082172393799,
0.10461030900478363,
-0.14444448053836823,
1.1548188924789429,
-0.9867380857467651,
0.5733535289764404,
0.4783358871936798,
0.3961770236492157,
0.057150181382894516,
0.035235445946455,
0.8624378442764282,
-0.9578021764755249,
0.5200194716453552,
-0.015739012509584427,
0.41351819038391113,
0.2883114516735077,
-0.15733635425567627,
0.3394024968147278,
0.10283089429140091,
-0.4356701970100403,
-0.5596102476119995,
0.5087833404541016,
-0.6787359118461609,
-0.5843265652656555,
0.9743115305900574,
-0.22028201818466187,
0.19045229256153107,
-0.604979932308197,
0.12574021518230438,
0.18388570845127106,
-0.14851567149162292,
1.1210834980010986,
0.6814190149307251,
0.2941296696662903,
0.20889315009117126,
-0.3276863694190979,
0.3734845519065857,
0.34796836972236633,
-1.0115771293640137,
-0.0047727650962769985,
0.882375180721283,
0.3295464813709259,
0.2959488332271576,
0.6880959272384644,
-0.04440551623702049,
-0.16318441927433014,
-0.010972308926284313,
0.3235207200050354,
-0.14203783869743347,
-0.2761857211589813,
-0.5153336524963379,
0.2169368863105774,
-0.5085176229476929,
-0.05560678616166115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07513v1 | The Balancing Act: Unmasking and Alleviating ASR Biases in Portuguese | 2024-02-12T09:35:13 | 2024-02-12T09:35:13 | Ajinkya Kulkarni, Anna Tokareva, Rameez Qureshi, Miguel Couceiro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | In the field of spoken language understanding, systems like Whisper and
Multilingual Massive Speech (MMS) have shown state-of-the-art performances.
This study is dedicated to a comprehensive exploration of the Whisper and MMS
systems, with a focus on assessing biases in automatic speech recognition (ASR)
inherent to casual conversation speech specific to the Portuguese language. Our
investigation encompasses various categories, including gender, age, skin tone
color, and geo-location. Alongside traditional ASR evaluation metrics such as
Word Error Rate (WER), we have incorporated p-value statistical significance
for gender bias analysis. Furthermore, we extensively examine the impact of
data distribution and empirically show that oversampling techniques alleviate
such stereotypical biases. This research represents a pioneering effort in
quantifying biases in the Portuguese language context through the application
of MMS and Whisper, contributing to a better understanding of ASR systems'
performance in multilingual settings. | [
-0.3630416989326477,
-0.5131384134292603,
-0.1564277708530426,
0.5987333059310913,
-0.2113829255104065,
0.3127128481864929,
-0.23882678151130676,
-0.42952483892440796,
0.3311917185783386,
0.54350745677948,
-0.44052231311798096,
-0.0976376160979271,
-0.9629725217819214,
0.02131013013422489,
-0.5181769728660583,
1.0577179193496704,
0.1679200828075409,
0.6792244911193848,
-0.09361159801483154,
-0.5388025045394897,
-0.5069319605827332,
-0.3846453130245209,
-0.7772595286369324,
-0.5582945346832275,
0.0618898905813694,
0.022969869896769524,
0.5918765068054199,
0.3692774176597595,
0.28200575709342957,
0.33219003677368164,
-0.313609778881073,
-0.028333229944109917,
-0.44027096033096313,
-0.1281847357749939,
-0.2522209882736206,
-0.17431052029132843,
-0.13936150074005127,
-0.14183641970157623,
0.9463347792625427,
0.7865106463432312,
-0.5002025365829468,
0.2242491990327835,
0.24744237959384918,
0.6718363165855408,
-0.6261836886405945,
0.25674328207969666,
-0.4893380105495453,
-0.08129967004060745,
-0.4342656135559082,
-0.08896581083536148,
0.11292363703250885,
-0.1557629257440567,
0.3357465863227844,
-0.3263576030731201,
0.22059275209903717,
-0.23667651414871216,
0.5978488326072693,
0.535153329372406,
-0.654522180557251,
-0.5942938923835754,
-0.7478329539299011,
0.7127578258514404,
-0.07514869421720505,
0.5940934419631958,
0.1254013329744339,
0.3854176104068756,
0.2147514671087265,
-0.057483963668346405,
-0.3649025559425354,
0.05239253491163254,
-0.04562421515583992,
0.07146232575178146,
-0.6220892667770386,
-0.0620320588350296,
0.2879425585269928,
0.3189830780029297,
-0.3262590169906616,
0.12324932217597961,
-0.8867629766464233,
-0.41031306982040405,
0.5737156867980957,
-0.18153968453407288,
0.40971148014068604,
-0.03856383264064789,
-0.3179200291633606,
0.08223656564950943,
-0.6629133820533752,
0.284511536359787,
0.6690648198127747,
0.3314965069293976,
-0.20653294026851654,
0.5097728967666626,
-0.1648702621459961,
0.7343552708625793,
-0.13754959404468536,
-0.025030022487044334,
0.3552558124065399,
-0.1907893866300583,
-0.158495232462883,
0.4071575403213501,
0.6534445285797119,
0.4303974211215973,
0.3820952773094177,
0.01743553951382637,
-0.21592319011688232,
0.6412069201469421,
0.16679826378822327,
-0.5360918045043945,
0.2545592486858368,
0.013608795590698719,
-0.24429962038993835,
-0.09539534151554108,
0.09322649240493774,
-0.7868605852127075,
-0.4645763039588928,
-0.2957494854927063,
0.538770854473114,
-0.06363335251808167,
-0.32798388600349426,
0.23840518295764923,
-0.45634764432907104,
0.1762312650680542,
0.04864209145307541,
-0.5990997552871704,
0.6405154466629028,
0.42867669463157654,
0.4520941376686096,
-0.19317269325256348,
-0.14257939159870148,
-0.4970322251319885,
0.18547199666500092,
0.010870722122490406,
0.6689910888671875,
-0.253523051738739,
-0.7354733347892761,
0.05999167636036873,
-0.1569078266620636,
-0.12759672105312347,
-0.5463718771934509,
1.0199615955352783,
-0.15204176306724548,
0.281486451625824,
-0.5756867527961731,
-0.2225446254014969,
0.01839173026382923,
-0.05497591570019722,
-0.3162919580936432,
0.8889789581298828,
-0.24259650707244873,
-0.7934922575950623,
0.6421719193458557,
-0.7149548530578613,
-0.6327369213104248,
-0.15749117732048035,
-0.4015084207057953,
-0.3198924660682678,
-0.14389154314994812,
0.33475959300994873,
0.001904244301840663,
-0.31086307764053345,
0.27018940448760986,
0.20344772934913635,
-0.45174819231033325,
0.2696576416492462,
-0.4977840483188629,
1.0358550548553467,
0.2202294021844864,
-0.4576820433139801,
0.10226184874773026,
-0.547018826007843,
-0.29299500584602356,
-0.03483828529715538,
-0.1710948497056961,
-0.32220709323883057,
0.18021999299526215,
-0.05093633756041527,
0.20558927953243256,
0.22836562991142273,
-0.8697770237922668,
-0.10902675241231918,
-0.43695199489593506,
0.5539914965629578,
0.49111998081207275,
-0.3975830376148224,
0.6074849963188171,
-0.2727586328983307,
0.40739819407463074,
0.12364894896745682,
0.1827399581670761,
-0.20447611808776855,
-0.4727090895175934,
-0.8662921786308289,
-0.4912221431732178,
0.34537386894226074,
0.742727518081665,
-0.6067572236061096,
0.14396770298480988,
-0.2790627181529999,
-0.24585339426994324,
-1.0025811195373535,
0.10456322133541107,
0.8623493909835815,
0.49201154708862305,
0.2490679919719696,
-0.5302666425704956,
-0.6744976043701172,
-1.0537161827087402,
-0.5273628234863281,
0.0034833054523915052,
-0.285628080368042,
0.32720044255256653,
0.14987024664878845,
-0.38894522190093994,
0.868054986000061,
-0.2813797891139984,
-0.824271559715271,
0.06304573267698288,
0.18042175471782684,
0.07529599219560623,
0.4921035170555115,
0.5540258884429932,
-0.7366539835929871,
-0.16685518622398376,
-0.28481975197792053,
-0.3262656629085541,
-0.6421682238578796,
0.521440863609314,
0.34933385252952576,
0.4882526993751526,
0.5628441572189331,
-0.3331747055053711,
0.3102801740169525,
0.6247130036354065,
-0.5878027677536011,
0.12465733289718628,
-0.25240448117256165,
0.25623637437820435,
-0.45648303627967834,
0.02074592001736164,
0.11228515952825546,
-0.008264911361038685,
-0.6384376883506775,
-0.11594643443822861,
-0.11994507908821106,
-0.030309055000543594,
-0.20642437040805817,
0.571174681186676,
-0.731258749961853,
-0.5193403363227844,
-0.18119323253631592,
-0.009716687723994255,
-0.13990412652492523,
0.05267934873700142,
0.06808845698833466,
0.6551305651664734,
0.8147872686386108,
-0.391823410987854,
-0.076881542801857,
0.10461356490850449,
-0.20033146440982819,
0.8379123210906982,
-0.7915302515029907,
0.05931501090526581,
-0.3917386531829834,
0.28891700506210327,
-1.2033859491348267,
0.16422735154628754,
0.12732216715812683,
-0.756601870059967,
0.42080479860305786,
-0.38662174344062805,
-0.13430988788604736,
-0.5986935496330261,
-0.2077312171459198,
0.20812758803367615,
0.42911458015441895,
-0.352421373128891,
0.7570427060127258,
0.9529203772544861,
-0.06944283097982407,
-0.9360188841819763,
-0.49475881457328796,
0.010777856223285198,
-0.40823814272880554,
-0.5664014220237732,
0.06376475095748901,
0.10895534604787827,
-0.6353393197059631,
-0.39909303188323975,
-0.23392155766487122,
-0.19737748801708221,
-0.09178983420133591,
0.46279457211494446,
0.008915210142731667,
-0.031922779977321625,
-0.2223426103591919,
0.09653983265161514,
-0.22877271473407745,
0.15476645529270172,
-0.23951739072799683,
0.5581039190292358,
-0.05493215471506119,
-0.4071226119995117,
-0.28023743629455566,
0.40238839387893677,
0.6597848534584045,
-0.2797636091709137,
0.41186222434043884,
0.7085302472114563,
-0.19796782732009888,
0.018593905493617058,
-0.8515799641609192,
-0.005696066655218601,
-0.4470980763435364,
-0.12385676056146622,
-0.31651484966278076,
-0.9229189157485962,
0.7526776790618896,
0.4383089542388916,
-0.05122269690036774,
0.38925719261169434,
0.5234259366989136,
-0.02153654582798481,
0.9665569067001343,
0.5034652948379517,
-0.48169052600860596,
0.5363770723342896,
0.16130661964416504,
-0.0794130340218544,
-0.5844577550888062,
-0.21095938980579376,
-0.8867608904838562,
-0.27562081813812256,
-0.8554350733757019,
-0.6605587601661682,
0.589719831943512,
-0.3333958089351654,
-0.16276444494724274,
-0.133207768201828,
-0.5658278465270996,
0.49405229091644287,
0.6043286323547363,
-0.09323440492153168,
0.32487261295318604,
-0.07890227437019348,
0.045943185687065125,
-0.0530390702188015,
-0.5405620336532593,
-0.3347759246826172,
1.0905715227127075,
0.2800696790218353,
0.5504897832870483,
0.1837378889322281,
0.26874637603759766,
0.3565427362918854,
0.06303194165229797,
-0.5523641705513,
0.16980807483196259,
-0.33811795711517334,
-0.6759018898010254,
-0.465770959854126,
-0.4764938950538635,
-1.18245267868042,
0.6202580332756042,
-0.16805499792099,
-0.6097772717475891,
0.21942824125289917,
0.2809413969516754,
-0.28507500886917114,
-0.07262866199016571,
-0.8373469710350037,
0.5696781277656555,
0.0296364463865757,
-0.2243025004863739,
-0.18919631838798523,
-0.8088864684104919,
0.3293798267841339,
0.25443267822265625,
0.49455222487449646,
-0.05243496596813202,
-0.05947915464639664,
0.9344273805618286,
-0.024986976757645607,
0.7017262578010559,
-0.4474307596683502,
-0.2645200490951538,
0.2491639256477356,
-0.010279599577188492,
0.16482342779636383,
-0.22014062106609344,
0.058231573551893234,
0.7638907432556152,
0.03388593718409538,
-0.4361441433429718,
-0.33150020241737366,
0.5503537058830261,
-0.9962881803512573,
-0.36228370666503906,
-0.5621111392974854,
-0.25355473160743713,
-0.2090340256690979,
0.07878850400447845,
0.2373562604188919,
0.3465481400489807,
-0.5881639719009399,
-0.08935649693012238,
0.7320741415023804,
-0.1648486852645874,
0.23034340143203735,
1.1846399307250977,
-0.0978168174624443,
-0.3461497724056244,
0.7442941665649414,
0.5668802857398987,
0.1211097463965416,
0.25168418884277344,
0.3621567487716675,
-0.5286654233932495,
-0.3801375925540924,
-0.6954451203346252,
0.009795408695936203,
-0.26548391580581665,
0.10731607675552368,
-1.0300021171569824,
-0.05776561424136162,
-0.550881564617157,
-0.0577658973634243,
-0.39062878489494324,
-0.5544037222862244,
0.10125283896923065,
-0.028287045657634735,
0.14686094224452972,
0.5610122680664062,
-0.179015651345253,
0.6584497690200806,
-0.4137885272502899,
0.4584440588951111,
0.3919079303741455,
0.09368337690830231,
-0.349189817905426,
-0.5848891139030457,
0.2744758427143097,
0.20147870481014252,
-0.1790468990802765,
-0.7591785788536072,
0.3177761435508728,
0.14163978397846222,
0.6700484156608582,
0.6089398264884949,
-0.2144494205713272,
0.5028071403503418,
-0.5596931576728821,
0.6511451601982117,
0.07353458553552628,
-1.2575023174285889,
0.6149474382400513,
-0.7952167987823486,
0.19347453117370605,
0.3713838458061218,
0.12483929097652435,
-0.6009427905082703,
-0.39421236515045166,
-0.9466204047203064,
-0.8534218072891235,
0.734121561050415,
0.41648319363594055,
-0.03695078194141388,
0.2967718541622162,
0.05764548107981682,
-0.15157870948314667,
0.6360305547714233,
-0.5405767560005188,
-0.3272438645362854,
-0.17484204471111298,
0.0940931886434555,
-0.3816892206668854,
-0.2873362898826599,
-0.5107153058052063,
-0.3165152370929718,
0.4229183793067932,
-0.20989137887954712,
0.21706074476242065,
0.05310799926519394,
-0.2250368595123291,
-0.3764355778694153,
0.3838917315006256,
0.7726537585258484,
0.6163600087165833,
-0.06252118945121765,
0.15549395978450775,
0.4029024839401245,
-0.4741336405277252,
-0.05304764583706856,
0.23010748624801636,
-0.2842744290828705,
0.12765610218048096,
0.11585893481969833,
0.732724666595459,
0.3034485876560211,
-0.8293694853782654,
0.7281380295753479,
0.04906990006566048,
0.21954476833343506,
-0.2560623288154602,
-0.02393556945025921,
0.02900220826268196,
-0.011130238883197308,
0.40309423208236694,
0.16038395464420319,
0.41071537137031555,
-0.6630251407623291,
0.13173243403434753,
0.6890541911125183,
-0.7499392032623291,
-0.23596739768981934,
0.5157088041305542,
0.6046299934387207,
-0.2040342092514038,
0.18527090549468994,
-0.08561183512210846,
-0.7937206625938416,
0.6285709142684937,
0.35122501850128174,
0.6226160526275635,
-0.7762997150421143,
0.02431284263730049,
0.2887101471424103,
0.7408536672592163,
-0.09266392141580582,
0.46238598227500916,
-0.31911006569862366,
-1.0269558429718018,
-0.12168725579977036,
-0.667842447757721,
-0.3941437005996704,
-0.5259156823158264,
-0.9032095670700073,
0.36208420991897583,
-0.13506866991519928,
-0.09140621870756149,
0.067074716091156,
0.0008160446886904538,
-0.44125810265541077,
0.19294631481170654,
0.23159009218215942,
0.5211203694343567,
-1.2547656297683716,
0.6062143445014954,
0.609554648399353,
-0.052363794296979904,
-0.26907971501350403,
-0.278864324092865,
0.5166288018226624,
-1.1968963146209717,
0.5481867790222168,
-0.0371062271296978,
-0.46301254630088806,
-0.2797527611255646,
-0.15177813172340393,
-0.7332936525344849,
0.6746488213539124,
0.43976202607154846,
-0.34573590755462646,
0.3349137008190155,
0.2235373556613922,
0.6968997120857239,
-0.11398249119520187,
0.4836381673812866,
0.9810550212860107,
0.5534161925315857,
0.22641827166080475,
-1.5956251621246338,
-0.38870927691459656,
-0.13140732049942017,
-0.2892903685569763,
0.4998877942562103,
-0.8472740054130554,
0.7671859860420227,
-0.005343934055417776,
-0.053909529000520706,
-0.40359827876091003,
0.3805721700191498,
0.19524265825748444,
0.520338237285614,
0.6322856545448303,
0.478369802236557,
0.6767815947532654,
-0.3950132131576538,
0.894931435585022,
0.06986518204212189,
-0.046857040375471115,
1.0316671133041382,
-0.4539908468723297,
0.49589380621910095,
0.47341734170913696,
-0.32967114448547363,
0.05683116242289543,
0.23753474652767181,
0.20393157005310059,
0.12498269975185394,
0.32608887553215027,
-0.2091691792011261,
0.13779611885547638,
-0.48437342047691345,
-0.3589719533920288,
0.8886123299598694,
0.6494234204292297,
-0.11690273880958557,
-0.18476450443267822,
0.08892533928155899,
0.33145254850387573,
0.025284459814429283,
-0.49555057287216187,
0.9366974234580994,
0.018270332366228104,
-0.6103240251541138,
0.2731333374977112,
-0.07688060402870178,
1.0471341609954834,
-0.7018413543701172,
0.40300750732421875,
0.04709033668041229,
0.15823979675769806,
-0.15239423513412476,
-0.7651360034942627,
0.6321519017219543,
0.07109508663415909,
-0.23114460706710815,
-0.6341221928596497,
0.8051649928092957,
-0.5277848839759827,
-0.39189982414245605,
0.4959695041179657,
0.5687661170959473,
0.16823802888393402,
-0.2562417984008789,
-0.6520968079566956,
0.3265075981616974,
0.04886162281036377,
0.243075892329216,
0.25387096405029297,
0.4056520462036133,
-0.25088587403297424,
0.7932402491569519,
0.4804621934890747,
0.26727402210235596,
0.1735517978668213,
0.3098376989364624,
0.6642597317695618,
-0.35050347447395325,
-0.8306924700737,
-0.7502291798591614,
0.3828602433204651,
-0.17488951981067657,
-0.47083643078804016,
0.9691333174705505,
0.6201896667480469,
0.6607360243797302,
0.2944604158401489,
0.3660086989402771,
0.13225825130939484,
0.8484045267105103,
-0.2813189923763275,
0.9705697298049927,
-0.17420664429664612,
0.10013315826654434,
-0.7353698015213013,
-0.6041989326477051,
-0.007092462386935949,
0.6325895190238953,
-0.26514989137649536,
-0.04504246637225151,
0.16332374513149261,
0.8019335865974426,
0.13878057897090912,
0.2185077965259552,
0.206907257437706,
0.2852693796157837,
-0.07150999456644058,
0.1677018254995346,
1.0115402936935425,
-0.4277504086494446,
0.341033399105072,
0.18452423810958862,
-0.4065942168235779,
0.0010944218374788761,
-0.6411254405975342,
-0.6882383823394775,
-0.4404304027557373,
-0.33373352885246277,
-0.23101280629634857,
0.2587483823299408,
0.697675347328186,
0.5854672193527222,
-0.771323025226593,
-0.6911976337432861,
0.44967302680015564,
0.34676608443260193,
-0.3086779713630676,
-0.15565913915634155,
0.05594749003648758,
0.16772910952568054,
-0.7928082346916199,
0.485063761472702,
0.10211873054504395,
-0.10176888853311539,
-0.23625552654266357,
-0.024149149656295776,
0.09711561352014542,
0.13610273599624634,
0.6220229864120483,
0.3270358145236969,
-0.560759425163269,
0.0032486233394593,
-0.21177764236927032,
0.21428275108337402,
0.05086102336645126,
1.052819848060608,
-0.7297673225402832,
0.5334095358848572,
0.42475399374961853,
0.21702608466148376,
0.384979248046875,
-0.06754634529352188,
0.7040665745735168,
-0.7982524037361145,
0.45604175329208374,
0.19224722683429718,
0.47907501459121704,
0.38610199093818665,
-0.1348167061805725,
0.47927650809288025,
0.21338869631290436,
-0.3756534457206726,
-0.9961630702018738,
-0.058280862867832184,
-1.1513428688049316,
-0.1321360021829605,
1.260489821434021,
0.33634084463119507,
0.1213095486164093,
-0.3839562237262726,
-0.4599495530128479,
0.27306532859802246,
-0.6766623854637146,
0.8065890669822693,
0.6810948252677917,
-0.026359735056757927,
0.22284655272960663,
-0.5845397710800171,
0.5049231648445129,
0.41566070914268494,
-0.39092275500297546,
-0.01533515378832817,
0.6386664509773254,
0.47776973247528076,
0.36161500215530396,
0.8759286403656006,
-0.1975071281194687,
0.07564885914325714,
-0.1762496381998062,
0.05918995290994644,
0.3339885175228119,
-0.11531837284564972,
-0.7598301768302917,
0.14451703429222107,
-0.36681753396987915,
-0.27749016880989075
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.