id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10790v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10790v2 | In Search of Needles in a 11M Haystack: Recurrent Memory Finds What LLMs Miss | 2024-02-16T16:15:01 | 2024-02-21T03:07:42 | Yuri Kuratov, Aydar Bulatov, Petr Anokhin, Dmitry Sorokin, Artyom Sorokin, Mikhail Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper addresses the challenge of processing long documents using
generative transformer models. To evaluate different approaches, we introduce
BABILong, a new benchmark designed to assess model capabilities in extracting
and processing distributed facts within extensive texts. Our evaluation, which
includes benchmarks for GPT-4 and RAG, reveals that common methods are
effective only for sequences up to $10^4$ elements. In contrast, fine-tuning
GPT-2 with recurrent memory augmentations enables it to handle tasks involving
up to $11\times 10^6$ elements. This achievement marks a substantial leap, as
it is by far the longest input processed by any neural network model to date,
demonstrating a significant improvement in the processing capabilities for long
sequences. | [
-0.2413475066423416,
-0.6942232847213745,
0.890343427658081,
0.02675405517220497,
-0.5069985389709473,
0.024423111230134964,
-0.21776767075061798,
-0.48781445622444153,
-0.14943742752075195,
0.46439987421035767,
-0.3627462387084961,
-0.3235912621021271,
-1.0515097379684448,
0.44928595423698425,
-0.79278564453125,
1.0031211376190186,
-0.02368123270571232,
-0.34848570823669434,
0.17632541060447693,
-0.3313121497631073,
-0.5015866756439209,
-0.3768898844718933,
-0.4767114520072937,
-0.43354305624961853,
0.8578896522521973,
0.03015921823680401,
0.6812043190002441,
0.6950720548629761,
0.7250989079475403,
0.2619715631008148,
-0.5821786522865295,
0.5971831679344177,
-0.5594277381896973,
0.2687976658344269,
-0.33210161328315735,
-0.39335960149765015,
-0.30395248532295227,
0.06526786088943481,
0.8380172848701477,
0.647320032119751,
-0.22616033256053925,
0.1844220608472824,
-0.17520824074745178,
0.8825803995132446,
-0.2705402076244354,
-0.1260298788547516,
-0.642848551273346,
-0.037285782396793365,
-0.3504170775413513,
-0.03465019538998604,
-0.5489481091499329,
-0.3661256432533264,
0.175906702876091,
-0.3381153345108032,
0.6592960357666016,
-0.20567587018013,
1.0641721487045288,
0.2230978161096573,
-0.43406742811203003,
-0.42416176199913025,
-0.7859076857566833,
0.6663663387298584,
-0.539574384689331,
0.17123445868492126,
0.36931097507476807,
0.23301802575588226,
-0.263654500246048,
-1.1491767168045044,
-0.4061616063117981,
0.00928489863872528,
-0.22795416414737701,
0.1497415453195572,
-0.3816605806350708,
-0.2332979440689087,
0.8204383254051208,
0.605223536491394,
-0.7714724540710449,
-0.0919223427772522,
-0.6965211629867554,
0.2800804078578949,
0.49296799302101135,
0.05277743935585022,
-0.059447161853313446,
-0.2649383246898651,
-0.32855063676834106,
0.11067511141300201,
-0.47035178542137146,
-0.45595282316207886,
0.19548799097537994,
-0.2021554708480835,
0.03608362749218941,
0.6016576290130615,
0.004824677482247353,
0.6623759865760803,
0.03180566057562828,
0.13738104701042175,
0.11022087931632996,
-0.14340625703334808,
-0.256365031003952,
-0.11705157160758972,
0.5844699144363403,
0.08492162823677063,
0.03775039315223694,
-0.1949395090341568,
-0.3327403962612152,
-0.010137989185750484,
0.5253291726112366,
-1.076805591583252,
-0.35880953073501587,
-0.19648773968219757,
-0.6575856804847717,
-0.048649393022060394,
0.11012095212936401,
-0.8366517424583435,
-0.5373941659927368,
-0.15652750432491302,
0.40726757049560547,
-0.7453339695930481,
0.0015413706423714757,
0.12282569706439972,
-0.46512317657470703,
0.002702725352719426,
0.26407164335250854,
-0.8476606607437134,
0.10120335966348648,
0.7631253600120544,
1.4435468912124634,
-0.2388657033443451,
-0.26461514830589294,
-0.49031391739845276,
0.06764911860227585,
-0.5676941871643066,
0.9024272561073303,
-0.4582487940788269,
-0.563963770866394,
-0.29255399107933044,
0.2821231186389923,
-0.03465494140982628,
-0.7560641169548035,
0.5482432246208191,
-0.5700777173042297,
0.19932639598846436,
-0.11631902307271957,
-0.6894504427909851,
-0.4985297620296478,
-0.041006870567798615,
-0.9862799644470215,
1.1651347875595093,
0.598227858543396,
-0.5224321484565735,
0.08426499366760254,
-0.42067986726760864,
-0.7024529576301575,
0.005282445345073938,
-0.08310119807720184,
-0.7760776281356812,
0.48994749784469604,
0.011605000123381615,
0.4702758491039276,
-0.8127825260162354,
0.44190776348114014,
-0.010390120558440685,
-0.9117693901062012,
0.30456531047821045,
-0.8910609483718872,
0.7944961190223694,
0.2650594711303711,
-0.559163510799408,
0.005257840733975172,
-0.8196324110031128,
-0.4681225121021271,
0.01767708919942379,
-0.5817300081253052,
-0.0891089141368866,
-0.1536877453327179,
-0.1468639224767685,
-0.09117601066827774,
0.18563011288642883,
-0.42040205001831055,
0.34597811102867126,
-0.3032839596271515,
0.6299074292182922,
0.7778519988059998,
-0.289258748292923,
0.1887677013874054,
-0.5759857296943665,
0.36954551935195923,
0.214817613363266,
-0.23655880987644196,
-0.7497426867485046,
-0.4477238655090332,
-0.7843810319900513,
-0.26385337114334106,
0.3122812509536743,
0.16745048761367798,
-0.6590591669082642,
0.4723763167858124,
-0.31921327114105225,
-0.7948030233383179,
-0.5664242506027222,
0.04138023406267166,
0.09072410315275192,
0.3471721112728119,
0.6101361513137817,
-0.6001690626144409,
-0.5066980123519897,
-0.8413817286491394,
-0.10723620653152466,
0.09942532330751419,
-0.33225926756858826,
0.2514810562133789,
0.35126960277557373,
-0.5942997336387634,
0.5622100234031677,
-0.42520588636398315,
-0.1873001605272293,
-0.15722283720970154,
0.7172335386276245,
0.8536406755447388,
0.22543564438819885,
0.31906142830848694,
-0.7551676630973816,
-0.3315189480781555,
0.176829531788826,
-0.9060419797897339,
0.08102401345968246,
-0.3967088758945465,
0.21531324088573456,
0.5421290397644043,
0.30775997042655945,
-1.1730440855026245,
0.6371551752090454,
0.4347602128982544,
-0.1500488966703415,
0.34475645422935486,
-0.383801132440567,
0.04070717468857765,
-0.9718112349510193,
0.3212828040122986,
-0.0929088145494461,
-0.2504573166370392,
-0.3238380253314972,
-0.04033603519201279,
0.4327201545238495,
-0.16086946427822113,
-0.03867156058549881,
0.2463947981595993,
-0.8123595118522644,
-0.18152284622192383,
-0.539277970790863,
-0.09425288438796997,
0.04503632336854935,
0.20206566154956818,
0.03616983816027641,
0.9835995435714722,
0.374101847410202,
-0.41553956270217896,
0.7192065119743347,
-0.04989556223154068,
-0.7874813675880432,
0.310995876789093,
-0.6138654947280884,
0.24677929282188416,
-0.2514365017414093,
0.33309343457221985,
-0.867076575756073,
0.004624254535883665,
-0.22466765344142914,
-0.352499395608902,
0.45341038703918457,
-0.2912243604660034,
-0.4362122118473053,
-0.5074229836463928,
-0.07147736102342606,
0.3982910215854645,
0.8322307467460632,
-0.6318045258522034,
0.8379456996917725,
0.0069566951133310795,
-0.04585934057831764,
-0.5743021368980408,
-0.4536453187465668,
0.19692854583263397,
-0.44032400846481323,
-0.35217252373695374,
0.521426260471344,
0.17292962968349457,
0.2672548294067383,
-0.08991657942533493,
-0.1526719033718109,
0.203389510512352,
0.02751011960208416,
0.29794320464134216,
0.21607479453086853,
-0.336386501789093,
0.08288288116455078,
-0.19375647604465485,
-0.397405207157135,
-0.015988394618034363,
-0.22778381407260895,
0.6699870228767395,
0.015263307839632034,
0.012509438209235668,
-0.12507076561450958,
0.3731130361557007,
0.5624825358390808,
-0.05313514918088913,
0.5763668417930603,
0.7310261130332947,
-0.3017658293247223,
-0.32223474979400635,
-0.6623537540435791,
0.041215527802705765,
-0.4885674715042114,
0.5069758296012878,
-0.39966872334480286,
-0.8909682631492615,
0.44965216517448425,
-0.5095243453979492,
-0.235549196600914,
0.49873602390289307,
0.5161018967628479,
-0.046635814011096954,
0.5628944635391235,
0.4117312431335449,
-0.2899947464466095,
0.1724795550107956,
-0.3746875822544098,
0.3838440477848053,
-0.8150808215141296,
-0.015399342402815819,
-0.18537262082099915,
-0.40184485912323,
-0.7363130450248718,
-0.7119587063789368,
0.438233345746994,
0.061798226088285446,
-0.22278903424739838,
0.6996028423309326,
-0.6942691802978516,
0.434758722782135,
0.6587382555007935,
0.15667948126792908,
0.16402417421340942,
-0.17638325691223145,
0.08674950152635574,
0.2707241475582123,
-0.5536431670188904,
-0.26459088921546936,
0.9274978637695312,
0.4125141203403473,
0.8279954791069031,
0.12153469771146774,
0.46806401014328003,
0.09245841950178146,
0.3803398013114929,
-0.843737781047821,
0.49864625930786133,
-0.5646719932556152,
-0.565468966960907,
-0.5071656703948975,
-0.369375616312027,
-1.2851371765136719,
0.06994111835956573,
0.23691251873970032,
-0.3690475821495056,
0.11459515243768692,
-0.258104532957077,
-0.27068963646888733,
0.4702250063419342,
-0.2979978919029236,
0.5680575966835022,
-0.06161024793982506,
-0.3335898816585541,
-0.41721847653388977,
-0.7084344625473022,
0.30833807587623596,
-0.14622974395751953,
-0.15960390865802765,
-0.11701811850070953,
0.1638156920671463,
0.6299931406974792,
-0.13264194130897522,
0.4671676456928253,
0.16267246007919312,
0.13968537747859955,
0.3619304895401001,
0.10861362516880035,
0.5718676447868347,
-0.26230621337890625,
-0.3092622756958008,
0.5333887934684753,
-0.10406652837991714,
-0.2511938512325287,
-0.45144185423851013,
0.5924281477928162,
-0.544123649597168,
-0.6598405241966248,
-0.8113123774528503,
-0.38580265641212463,
0.2737230956554413,
0.14337585866451263,
0.5110958218574524,
0.4323572516441345,
0.08277089893817902,
0.6054534912109375,
0.8068456649780273,
-0.2564755380153656,
0.7646975517272949,
0.3747657239437103,
0.004556391388177872,
-0.3283892571926117,
0.6695996522903442,
0.41365617513656616,
-0.05568433180451393,
0.30855056643486023,
0.2003621906042099,
-0.15073753893375397,
-0.5243833065032959,
-0.723659098148346,
0.41361722350120544,
-0.5900370478630066,
-0.6287683844566345,
-0.6247063279151917,
-0.6572125554084778,
-0.15724490582942963,
0.13479851186275482,
-0.44016405940055847,
-0.20947673916816711,
-0.28801795840263367,
-0.2622838318347931,
0.6550046801567078,
1.0182524919509888,
-0.06503745913505554,
0.3087362051010132,
-1.0018757581710815,
0.46688100695610046,
0.22336828708648682,
0.5446074604988098,
0.2964172065258026,
-0.8274984955787659,
-0.5414361953735352,
-0.39964431524276733,
-0.5426324009895325,
-0.761169970035553,
0.44262081384658813,
-0.1797875612974167,
0.2626955211162567,
0.1439007669687271,
-0.2283458560705185,
0.8224528431892395,
-0.8209958076477051,
0.7405588626861572,
0.11560822278261185,
-0.7588852047920227,
0.3329840302467346,
-0.4428158402442932,
0.40761685371398926,
0.17674031853675842,
0.608108401298523,
-0.7824314832687378,
0.1135256215929985,
-0.6936877965927124,
-0.8402767777442932,
0.6075108647346497,
0.17059069871902466,
0.1535079926252365,
-0.3931238353252411,
0.44917550683021545,
0.36949482560157776,
-0.025599991902709007,
-0.38771846890449524,
-0.12082351744174957,
-0.06703067570924759,
-0.08339802175760269,
-0.11283940076828003,
-0.6427989602088928,
0.15752242505550385,
-0.0723738968372345,
0.500944972038269,
0.17915204167366028,
0.4537820518016815,
0.23026373982429504,
0.028794098645448685,
-0.10360131412744522,
0.024646852165460587,
0.5784145593643188,
0.8277631998062134,
-0.20432552695274353,
0.36507394909858704,
0.2049810290336609,
-0.5191088914871216,
0.12422357499599457,
0.3487485945224762,
-0.19003120064735413,
0.5052748322486877,
0.4104978144168854,
0.7733412384986877,
0.15384893119335175,
-0.494422048330307,
0.28946107625961304,
0.05071301385760307,
-0.04402146488428116,
-0.4836219847202301,
0.05877390503883362,
0.2861950993537903,
0.12061183899641037,
0.5708004236221313,
-0.1341751515865326,
0.17625214159488678,
-0.7671190500259399,
0.5267550349235535,
0.2329081892967224,
-0.22879940271377563,
-0.2991538643836975,
0.55306077003479,
-0.004592848010361195,
-0.49020904302597046,
0.9974161982536316,
-0.023890314623713493,
-0.34135308861732483,
0.5966127514839172,
0.6322891116142273,
0.764220118522644,
-0.33943960070610046,
-0.009010645560920238,
0.6078779697418213,
0.052490267902612686,
-0.48490095138549805,
-0.0911029651761055,
-0.0339997373521328,
-0.5241656303405762,
-0.41817501187324524,
-0.5897995233535767,
-0.14910836517810822,
0.46792325377464294,
-0.6370317935943604,
0.392363041639328,
-0.3805966079235077,
-0.20110264420509338,
0.2135508954524994,
-0.1574835628271103,
-0.5708450078964233,
0.2442525178194046,
-0.14655502140522003,
0.7537477612495422,
-0.4853334426879883,
1.0381637811660767,
0.2705088257789612,
-0.2875839173793793,
-0.6271039843559265,
-0.31247478723526,
-0.24907688796520233,
-0.6842969655990601,
0.49398133158683777,
0.5848802328109741,
0.07158191502094269,
-0.2044893056154251,
-0.15142054855823517,
-0.8265529274940491,
1.2984620332717896,
0.06107879430055618,
-0.925457239151001,
-0.23306912183761597,
0.03136780485510826,
0.5567732453346252,
-0.04713038355112076,
0.44663742184638977,
0.9749502539634705,
0.3664872348308563,
-0.019659409299492836,
-0.8316531777381897,
0.04427232965826988,
-0.20068688690662384,
0.07931182533502579,
0.5297636985778809,
-0.8018232583999634,
0.9615823030471802,
0.036135777831077576,
-0.36078813672065735,
0.5394222736358643,
0.6228535771369934,
0.34747108817100525,
0.5788220763206482,
0.2196851223707199,
0.734505832195282,
0.8550418615341187,
0.036981042474508286,
1.0172544717788696,
-0.015624264255166054,
0.32139143347740173,
1.0547603368759155,
-0.24783436954021454,
0.5715687870979309,
0.3126232624053955,
-0.3051028251647949,
0.6175684928894043,
0.6810586452484131,
-0.3087890148162842,
0.45262283086776733,
0.30408164858818054,
-0.44900521636009216,
0.030568895861506462,
0.16149382293224335,
-0.305054634809494,
0.28887611627578735,
0.305128276348114,
-0.68927001953125,
-0.15527665615081787,
-0.23870159685611725,
0.013455166481435299,
0.2560877203941345,
-0.10169696807861328,
0.8931881189346313,
0.3715064823627472,
-0.8242207765579224,
0.5326449871063232,
0.18169747292995453,
0.7497656941413879,
-0.36924514174461365,
-0.27460041642189026,
-0.5450690984725952,
0.24142660200595856,
0.03723615035414696,
-0.7813723087310791,
0.4794255495071411,
0.10128402709960938,
-0.41007155179977417,
-0.044706083834171295,
0.7605593204498291,
-0.3662962317466736,
-0.5708255767822266,
0.35254210233688354,
0.2084430456161499,
0.33730801939964294,
0.009039655327796936,
-0.29717230796813965,
-0.06943751126527786,
-0.11938709765672684,
-0.4033176898956299,
0.2364775836467743,
0.9410404562950134,
-0.065116748213768,
0.5290830731391907,
0.49854984879493713,
0.16651654243469238,
-0.047697123140096664,
0.02445143088698387,
0.7823495268821716,
-1.092076063156128,
-0.08540476858615875,
-1.0805209875106812,
0.2542695701122284,
-0.1303965300321579,
-0.2988126277923584,
0.4725062847137451,
0.9443907737731934,
0.8479301333427429,
-0.2277107685804367,
0.67667555809021,
0.10207804292440414,
0.9083146452903748,
-0.46124398708343506,
0.6499142050743103,
-0.20442910492420197,
0.2381831258535385,
0.1592361181974411,
-1.0472421646118164,
-0.12996625900268555,
0.8502441048622131,
-0.05029468983411789,
-0.006335812620818615,
0.8775275945663452,
0.7035490274429321,
-0.14846467971801758,
0.08983274549245834,
0.4423077404499054,
0.057510606944561005,
0.2744523286819458,
0.6826993823051453,
0.8771701455116272,
-0.6700149774551392,
0.3995443284511566,
-0.12589110434055328,
0.01895165629684925,
-0.04358833283185959,
-0.9316087961196899,
-0.9735198616981506,
-0.6252367496490479,
0.16722938418388367,
-0.2572396695613861,
0.2590971291065216,
0.5817442536354065,
0.5595283508300781,
-0.49920654296875,
-0.23847678303718567,
-0.1932876855134964,
0.13056786358356476,
-0.2831573188304901,
-0.19281643629074097,
0.6106261014938354,
-0.23309224843978882,
-0.6553433537483215,
0.48163771629333496,
0.42985135316848755,
0.05432748794555664,
0.1114661768078804,
0.105752132833004,
-0.09806221723556519,
-0.025632699951529503,
0.6653295159339905,
-0.06792076677083969,
-0.5425786972045898,
-0.3604309558868408,
-0.013746094889938831,
0.050461992621421814,
0.2567252218723297,
0.922084391117096,
-0.8987605571746826,
0.4044433534145355,
0.32720673084259033,
0.8298650979995728,
1.031691312789917,
0.2899729013442993,
0.580477237701416,
-0.43114665150642395,
0.050782959908246994,
0.32731589674949646,
0.2616766393184662,
0.44230547547340393,
-0.4126136302947998,
1.050943374633789,
0.3169925808906555,
-0.855206310749054,
-0.789368212223053,
-0.05035140737891197,
-1.0183359384536743,
-0.49797049164772034,
1.0532686710357666,
-0.3397504687309265,
-0.10863571614027023,
0.051742423325777054,
-0.08719569444656372,
0.5146255493164062,
-0.1666460484266281,
1.128350019454956,
0.7842904329299927,
-0.15415522456169128,
-0.4183792769908905,
-0.36909714341163635,
0.4509575068950653,
0.4774142801761627,
-0.35762926936149597,
0.2066163271665573,
0.37580087780952454,
0.13992835581302643,
0.26312121748924255,
0.444525808095932,
-0.22209452092647552,
0.5330619215965271,
0.017782067880034447,
-0.3612620234489441,
-0.09135181456804276,
-0.5146909952163696,
-0.4567963480949402,
0.043496258556842804,
-0.08502287417650223,
0.11119009554386139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10787v1 | EdgeQAT: Entropy and Distribution Guided Quantization-Aware Training for the Acceleration of Lightweight LLMs on the Edge | 2024-02-16T16:10:38 | 2024-02-16T16:10:38 | Xuan Shen, Zhenglun Kong, Changdi Yang, Zhaoyang Han, Lei Lu, Peiyan Dong, Cheng Lyu, Chih-hsiang Li, Xuehang Guo, Zhihao Shu, Wei Niu, Miriam Leeser, Pu Zhao, Yanzhi Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the remarkable strides of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various
fields, the wide applications of LLMs on edge devices are limited due to their
massive parameters and computations. To address this, quantization is commonly
adopted to generate lightweight LLMs with efficient computations and fast
inference. However, Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) methods dramatically
degrade in quality when quantizing weights, activations, and KV cache together
to below 8 bits. Besides, many Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) works quantize
model weights, leaving the activations untouched, which do not fully exploit
the potential of quantization for inference acceleration on the edge. In this
paper, we propose EdgeQAT, the Entropy and Distribution Guided QAT for the
optimization of lightweight LLMs to achieve inference acceleration on Edge
devices. We first identify that the performance drop of quantization primarily
stems from the information distortion in quantized attention maps, demonstrated
by the different distributions in quantized query and key of the self-attention
mechanism. Then, the entropy and distribution guided QAT is proposed to
mitigate the information distortion. Moreover, we design a token
importance-aware adaptive method to dynamically quantize the tokens with
different bit widths for further optimization and acceleration. Our extensive
experiments verify the substantial improvements with our framework across
various datasets. Furthermore, we achieve an on-device speedup of up to 2.37x
compared with its FP16 counterparts across multiple edge devices, signaling a
groundbreaking advancement. | [
-0.1831642985343933,
-0.6245107054710388,
0.46314966678619385,
0.018367065116763115,
-0.5968503952026367,
-0.023341571912169456,
0.07181096822023392,
-0.1631494164466858,
0.1611979752779007,
0.1361910104751587,
-0.5019849538803101,
-0.4706098139286041,
-0.6522712707519531,
-0.4101724922657013,
-0.21521998941898346,
0.7593380212783813,
0.023013053461909294,
0.0424685962498188,
-0.21961693465709686,
-0.4096531569957733,
-0.07004842907190323,
-0.18058063089847565,
-0.8791423439979553,
-0.05951046198606491,
0.13969045877456665,
0.17120447754859924,
0.7573610544204712,
0.8654439449310303,
0.38344064354896545,
0.2327307015657425,
-0.11655508726835251,
-0.14861875772476196,
-0.38106492161750793,
0.27002254128456116,
0.2399258315563202,
-0.4165138900279999,
-0.6676236391067505,
-0.5665589570999146,
0.5781364440917969,
0.21945388615131378,
-0.11152239143848419,
0.2969702482223511,
0.09170865267515182,
0.7572729587554932,
-0.947287917137146,
-0.3359583914279938,
-0.5178344249725342,
-0.0522347018122673,
-0.23277558386325836,
-0.14251211285591125,
0.06864164024591446,
-0.3989182114601135,
0.0564359575510025,
-0.6293907165527344,
-0.01982753723859787,
-0.039518654346466064,
0.35256335139274597,
0.7128069400787354,
-0.6080484986305237,
-0.023648979142308235,
-0.46355822682380676,
0.5967472791671753,
-0.5782447457313538,
0.9701092839241028,
0.08256904035806656,
0.08273997902870178,
0.09373348951339722,
-1.11878502368927,
-0.25099819898605347,
0.29795408248901367,
0.7156426906585693,
0.17043252289295197,
-0.24883216619491577,
0.3231271505355835,
0.08550828695297241,
0.2959499955177307,
-0.6407609581947327,
0.22132480144500732,
0.09215199947357178,
-0.291249543428421,
0.346287339925766,
0.037450846284627914,
0.22343331575393677,
0.29490694403648376,
-0.5934287309646606,
-0.2705027461051941,
-0.9289261102676392,
0.1979154348373413,
0.22197450697422028,
-0.10022446513175964,
-0.07173065096139908,
0.05851541832089424,
-0.6379519104957581,
0.5043931007385254,
0.0962669774889946,
-0.248488187789917,
0.28180789947509766,
-0.19452974200248718,
-0.11556496471166611,
0.41062411665916443,
0.7279135584831238,
0.30273374915122986,
-0.2572077810764313,
0.05103269964456558,
-0.368685245513916,
-0.4117666482925415,
-0.2885020077228546,
-1.2972990274429321,
-0.2870684862136841,
0.42524299025535583,
-0.4748561680316925,
0.09359554201364517,
-0.4133043587207794,
-0.5388941764831543,
-0.3917444050312042,
0.13262061774730682,
0.77168869972229,
-0.4744473397731781,
-0.37028631567955017,
0.16755475103855133,
-0.34107705950737,
0.3071337938308716,
0.2732735276222229,
-1.015531063079834,
0.23255811631679535,
0.5446365475654602,
0.9601153135299683,
-0.0881328135728836,
0.04580869525671005,
-0.7048736214637756,
0.09128092974424362,
-0.16754689812660217,
0.6740952730178833,
-0.3599151074886322,
-0.09678402543067932,
-0.14208568632602692,
-0.4653345048427582,
0.13911570608615875,
-0.26733654737472534,
0.8203296661376953,
-0.6320269107818604,
-0.30081793665885925,
-0.2271360605955124,
-0.4902936518192291,
-0.08375122398138046,
0.05256085842847824,
-0.5749427080154419,
1.2157727479934692,
0.015896957367658615,
-0.9462809562683105,
0.5265530943870544,
-0.7188392877578735,
-0.33470502495765686,
0.2901456356048584,
0.018647942692041397,
-0.5897385478019714,
0.2794255018234253,
0.4843656122684479,
0.3337273597717285,
-0.21819642186164856,
0.04750853404402733,
-0.40425905585289,
-0.5114243030548096,
0.042794596403837204,
-0.6021522879600525,
0.7496656775474548,
0.19248948991298676,
-0.6435468196868896,
0.19241149723529816,
-0.6743814945220947,
0.37505319714546204,
-0.05207144096493721,
-0.1473727971315384,
-0.6565296053886414,
0.05860964581370354,
-0.12033338099718094,
-0.0075243026949465275,
0.3114951550960541,
-0.47531235218048096,
0.09888449311256409,
-0.18391528725624084,
0.6453054547309875,
0.8721751570701599,
0.03057209588587284,
0.5021249055862427,
0.12077031284570694,
0.5602084994316101,
-0.13597416877746582,
0.2597620487213135,
0.030049992725253105,
-0.3470318019390106,
-0.5512053370475769,
-0.5943348407745361,
0.5710367560386658,
0.5392910242080688,
-0.9810096621513367,
0.1968381106853485,
-0.5614851117134094,
-0.3974253535270691,
-0.7159865498542786,
0.17460428178310394,
0.09744523465633392,
0.17617590725421906,
0.1979767382144928,
-0.11338232457637787,
-0.23853029310703278,
-0.6183932423591614,
-0.5712165832519531,
-0.07066885381937027,
-0.24913792312145233,
0.02592066489160061,
0.16658347845077515,
-0.20997260510921478,
0.808623194694519,
-0.27279844880104065,
0.019545868039131165,
-0.08672939985990524,
0.09830562770366669,
-0.2844744324684143,
0.5404403209686279,
0.2907413840293884,
-0.802209734916687,
-0.23344416916370392,
-0.12222705036401749,
-0.28226494789123535,
-0.298074334859848,
0.024216147139668465,
-0.190410777926445,
-0.2136564999818802,
0.47239288687705994,
-0.5285034775733948,
0.2885195016860962,
0.6492298245429993,
-0.14923100173473358,
0.1881258189678192,
0.13169558346271515,
-0.044196028262376785,
-1.1631238460540771,
-0.3388139307498932,
-0.04453439265489578,
-0.4431382715702057,
-0.4291001856327057,
-0.022766372188925743,
0.27732500433921814,
-0.044144611805677414,
-0.6365566253662109,
0.7470489740371704,
-0.3835460841655731,
-0.14949625730514526,
-0.32928404211997986,
0.09195435792207718,
-0.020325971767306328,
0.405775249004364,
-0.06270010769367218,
0.7900648713111877,
0.8956028819084167,
-0.8410447835922241,
0.2987229526042938,
-0.14534595608711243,
-0.05791734158992767,
0.7612911462783813,
-0.6164015531539917,
-0.03380460664629936,
0.1076572835445404,
0.11356159299612045,
-0.7943564057350159,
0.17159883677959442,
0.07898251712322235,
-0.3395079970359802,
-0.061074450612068176,
-0.2331952154636383,
-0.5970157980918884,
-0.0054611279629170895,
-0.6069095134735107,
0.8596736788749695,
0.8187813758850098,
-0.6934359669685364,
0.7494185566902161,
0.18419249355793,
-0.036827314645051956,
-0.49326473474502563,
-0.5882763266563416,
-0.12715820968151093,
-0.6160171627998352,
-0.7034773230552673,
0.438870906829834,
-0.08005578070878983,
-0.17807146906852722,
-0.10169294476509094,
-0.3913362920284271,
-0.0884757861495018,
0.3372865617275238,
0.2593468427658081,
-0.5451357960700989,
-0.24742034077644348,
0.5442025661468506,
0.4519149363040924,
0.01791946217417717,
0.005430025514215231,
-0.9396467804908752,
0.33595216274261475,
-0.22304096817970276,
-0.33866533637046814,
-0.6284836530685425,
-0.06801533699035645,
0.31868666410446167,
-0.23487740755081177,
0.32652974128723145,
1.1979341506958008,
-0.41432297229766846,
-0.2762579023838043,
-0.34890371561050415,
-0.32821542024612427,
-0.6044690012931824,
0.38832515478134155,
-0.5571771264076233,
-0.9657880067825317,
0.5161474347114563,
-0.566218376159668,
-0.1012609675526619,
0.43519967794418335,
0.6030867695808411,
-0.06535658985376358,
1.0007519721984863,
0.643329381942749,
0.12042905390262604,
0.929649293422699,
-0.22529159486293793,
0.009337157011032104,
-1.0318952798843384,
0.18066687881946564,
-0.18144884705543518,
-0.5071308016777039,
-0.6633890271186829,
-0.3208274245262146,
0.6229912638664246,
0.21492771804332733,
-0.24062767624855042,
-0.1251729130744934,
-0.5415977835655212,
0.2634218633174896,
0.8304904699325562,
0.3071533143520355,
0.20987336337566376,
0.02287072315812111,
-0.0029440263751894236,
0.06823967397212982,
-0.9228728413581848,
0.018858499825000763,
1.1269193887710571,
0.3512329161167145,
1.0015922784805298,
0.030881278216838837,
0.7521913647651672,
0.4174938201904297,
-0.03437301144003868,
-0.709511935710907,
0.4833219647407532,
0.18673978745937347,
-0.135016068816185,
-0.4053008258342743,
-0.6391996145248413,
-0.7261953949928284,
0.18670833110809326,
0.21244491636753082,
-0.5771015286445618,
0.2944435775279999,
0.20664666593074799,
-0.38159993290901184,
0.316672682762146,
-0.664981484413147,
0.9858472347259521,
-0.5531051158905029,
-0.40760016441345215,
-0.1598130464553833,
-0.5309709310531616,
0.2790098786354065,
0.0898035392165184,
-0.061675675213336945,
-0.17326262593269348,
-0.4328332543373108,
1.0838998556137085,
-0.679588794708252,
0.7004615068435669,
-0.4165073037147522,
-0.09946180135011673,
0.5160943865776062,
0.08216803520917892,
0.7109063267707825,
0.24362437427043915,
0.052274078130722046,
0.031530991196632385,
-0.03416365757584572,
-0.6440742611885071,
-0.6751815676689148,
0.4564912021160126,
-0.680306613445282,
-0.526749849319458,
-0.10246231406927109,
-0.5184721350669861,
-0.17354506254196167,
0.277445912361145,
0.35802847146987915,
0.604074239730835,
0.0638260617852211,
0.1993015855550766,
0.9614624381065369,
0.12141522020101547,
0.5918181538581848,
0.2366636097431183,
0.18720009922981262,
-0.5186263918876648,
1.0917315483093262,
0.09812074154615402,
0.5192047953605652,
0.49140045046806335,
0.28382566571235657,
-0.4941892921924591,
-1.0385468006134033,
-0.7290449738502502,
-0.2757408618927002,
-0.7507302165031433,
-0.45234426856040955,
-0.7966506481170654,
0.1191352978348732,
-0.3972202241420746,
-0.026766454800963402,
-0.6066346764564514,
-0.724557101726532,
-0.19635820388793945,
-0.12258360534906387,
0.915267825126648,
0.24408327043056488,
-0.2506231367588043,
1.1001341342926025,
-0.5015766620635986,
0.18390923738479614,
0.4431941509246826,
0.32290565967559814,
-0.10924738645553589,
-0.7247240543365479,
-0.4767341911792755,
0.22047188878059387,
-0.4882735311985016,
-0.5596007704734802,
0.1332705169916153,
0.5177472233772278,
0.2509922385215759,
0.6804520487785339,
0.3450664281845093,
0.721694827079773,
-0.059246182441711426,
0.6163857579231262,
-0.01098368875682354,
-1.2261532545089722,
0.3947189152240753,
-0.14319691061973572,
0.497100293636322,
0.4573093354701996,
0.32717397809028625,
-0.4194734990596771,
-0.3138952851295471,
-0.6152362823486328,
-1.0069148540496826,
0.21518400311470032,
0.01485341228544712,
0.13225971162319183,
0.3725323975086212,
0.3188173472881317,
-0.03670111298561096,
0.16773727536201477,
-0.6425381302833557,
0.04641304910182953,
-0.30922815203666687,
-0.435403048992157,
0.5243385434150696,
-0.139741912484169,
0.10543835908174515,
-0.01509198360145092,
0.5834599137306213,
-0.46376922726631165,
0.284401535987854,
0.36358243227005005,
-0.2582451403141022,
0.06217275559902191,
0.09218789637088776,
0.3551503121852875,
0.48628127574920654,
-0.10098160803318024,
0.29613861441612244,
0.2914820909500122,
-0.6866539120674133,
0.14629267156124115,
0.1971902996301651,
-0.2209894359111786,
-0.125456765294075,
0.1221035048365593,
1.0731161832809448,
-0.04399227350950241,
-0.6278774738311768,
0.5365251302719116,
-0.18103483319282532,
0.03616306930780411,
0.0015026056207716465,
-0.014703712426126003,
0.08831844478845596,
0.5234772562980652,
0.6876241564750671,
-0.2655322849750519,
0.5752725005149841,
-0.2119879126548767,
0.3273267149925232,
0.7914939522743225,
-0.4508461654186249,
-0.33077025413513184,
0.8303878903388977,
0.24612440168857574,
-0.13590937852859497,
0.39675262570381165,
-0.44850853085517883,
-0.5946345925331116,
0.5063717365264893,
0.36878347396850586,
1.2000852823257446,
-0.33496010303497314,
-0.0515383705496788,
-0.05936732515692711,
0.42156630754470825,
0.034938521683216095,
0.4330754578113556,
-0.35942763090133667,
-0.5541773438453674,
-0.3918003737926483,
-0.6059677600860596,
-0.31101882457733154,
-0.2782842814922333,
-0.346438467502594,
0.09835245460271835,
-0.3082258105278015,
-0.2712076008319855,
-0.5798875093460083,
-0.038504764437675476,
-0.6547723412513733,
0.37593427300453186,
-0.01208591740578413,
0.6871746182441711,
-0.7174977660179138,
0.7270071506500244,
0.3646388649940491,
0.19422434270381927,
-0.4999237656593323,
0.22421815991401672,
-0.310808002948761,
-0.9538125395774841,
0.44060543179512024,
0.029079120606184006,
-0.11240612715482712,
0.5333701372146606,
-0.42211633920669556,
-0.9618656635284424,
1.4093618392944336,
0.254610538482666,
-0.2555609345436096,
0.23846589028835297,
0.11064261943101883,
0.3545720875263214,
-0.1813586801290512,
0.5582555532455444,
0.22839874029159546,
0.181715726852417,
0.11197581887245178,
-0.6009328365325928,
0.24438297748565674,
0.10305336117744446,
0.08141826093196869,
0.38537535071372986,
-0.736535906791687,
0.6663488149642944,
-0.1636742353439331,
-0.2382338047027588,
-0.13718178868293762,
0.8143496513366699,
0.2473919689655304,
0.4628376364707947,
0.43560850620269775,
0.7998802661895752,
0.7241726517677307,
0.012182289734482765,
0.801665723323822,
-0.3586879074573517,
0.1453067660331726,
0.6495957970619202,
-0.031477805227041245,
0.7109290361404419,
0.45378342270851135,
0.05216708406805992,
0.24152223765850067,
1.1317323446273804,
0.49997642636299133,
0.6923406720161438,
0.20134945213794708,
-0.5052511692047119,
-0.14081312716007233,
-0.22671201825141907,
-0.40479180216789246,
0.11208837479352951,
0.49166521430015564,
-0.11146830022335052,
-0.1844625324010849,
0.29430997371673584,
-0.15402725338935852,
-0.6103200316429138,
-0.6717052459716797,
0.690178394317627,
0.16912992298603058,
-0.02475878968834877,
0.7858260869979858,
0.1513550877571106,
0.6925824284553528,
-0.42405226826667786,
0.16622093319892883,
-0.3464585244655609,
0.06974926590919495,
-0.1876334398984909,
-0.4689490497112274,
-0.2030806839466095,
-0.32131433486938477,
0.23843106627464294,
-0.2990610599517822,
0.7611315250396729,
-0.18595416843891144,
-0.4529416561126709,
-0.08569911867380142,
0.6237958669662476,
0.16370481252670288,
-0.4723571240901947,
-0.6566742658615112,
0.29596632719039917,
-0.12113873660564423,
-0.5897803902626038,
0.5452662706375122,
0.955635666847229,
-0.21661663055419922,
1.028354525566101,
0.5442220568656921,
-0.14669066667556763,
0.4764137864112854,
-0.2901589274406433,
0.924872875213623,
-0.5266965627670288,
-0.6560137867927551,
-1.0159201622009277,
0.3945198655128479,
0.22617611289024353,
-0.3683820068836212,
0.6336876749992371,
0.5371237397193909,
0.5470571517944336,
0.46488577127456665,
0.7330144643783569,
0.022395014762878418,
-0.1070171594619751,
-0.7513285875320435,
0.4057590961456299,
-0.7808694243431091,
0.20072191953659058,
0.06226785108447075,
-0.9517133235931396,
-0.07995067536830902,
0.15224102139472961,
-0.13195393979549408,
0.2265070676803589,
0.5380534529685974,
0.44537070393562317,
-0.09989286959171295,
-0.24614715576171875,
0.27791234850883484,
0.0512143075466156,
0.22146286070346832,
0.6859532594680786,
0.5262587070465088,
-0.7030922174453735,
0.7214031219482422,
-0.11406536400318146,
-0.19093380868434906,
-0.33446091413497925,
-0.7658745646476746,
-0.5826737284660339,
-0.45022302865982056,
-0.5181158185005188,
-0.16064336895942688,
0.4197123646736145,
0.6194870471954346,
0.8021082878112793,
-0.1981596201658249,
0.1521548479795456,
-0.3016369044780731,
0.37815576791763306,
-0.3923764228820801,
-0.2305850386619568,
0.6496938467025757,
-0.16016700863838196,
-0.6459879875183105,
0.21983297169208527,
0.24489471316337585,
0.20372067391872406,
-0.16373027861118317,
-0.17243361473083496,
0.2833790183067322,
-0.07374497503042221,
0.3976069390773773,
0.21021655201911926,
-0.3852156698703766,
-0.061475154012441635,
-0.06153643876314163,
-0.08548703789710999,
0.1759500652551651,
0.6829103231430054,
-1.0111485719680786,
0.33456361293792725,
0.6336550712585449,
0.942029595375061,
0.4950512647628784,
0.30119937658309937,
0.42654505372047424,
-0.7392327785491943,
0.20421981811523438,
0.43683451414108276,
0.107913076877594,
0.2585607171058655,
-0.42460712790489197,
0.2593614161014557,
0.26365160942077637,
-0.6737390756607056,
-1.0138057470321655,
0.2521507740020752,
-0.8374332189559937,
-0.07469258457422256,
1.1210414171218872,
0.06692510098218918,
-0.5265495777130127,
0.2040330320596695,
0.1652332991361618,
0.21774634718894958,
-0.6060604453086853,
0.4632885158061981,
0.16450047492980957,
-0.20409591495990753,
-0.6495697498321533,
-0.6046728491783142,
0.7214744091033936,
0.5777075290679932,
-0.6696299910545349,
-0.0035980541724711657,
-0.0034776763059198856,
0.2598888576030731,
-0.2991344630718231,
0.7386369705200195,
0.3326607942581177,
0.39291852712631226,
0.23312747478485107,
0.4887992739677429,
0.1610969752073288,
-0.006186637561768293,
-0.39904698729515076,
-0.10461308062076569,
0.3871322274208069,
-0.48715782165527344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10779v1 | A Condensed Transition Graph Framework for Zero-shot Link Prediction with Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T16:02:33 | 2024-02-16T16:02:33 | Mingchen Li, Chen Ling, Rui Zhang, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot link prediction (ZSLP) on knowledge graphs aims at automatically
identifying relations between given entities. Existing methods primarily employ
auxiliary information to predict tail entity given head entity and its
relation, yet face challenges due to the occasional unavailability of such
detailed information and the inherent simplicity of predicting tail entities
based on semantic similarities. Even though Large Language Models (LLMs) offer
a promising solution to predict unobserved relations between the head and tail
entity in a zero-shot manner, their performance is still restricted due to the
inability to leverage all the (exponentially many) paths' information between
two entities, which are critical in collectively indicating their relation
types. To address this, in this work, we introduce a Condensed Transition Graph
Framework for Zero-Shot Link Prediction (CTLP), which encodes all the paths'
information in linear time complexity to predict unseen relations between
entities, attaining both efficiency and information preservation. Specifically,
we design a condensed transition graph encoder with theoretical guarantees on
its coverage, expressiveness, and efficiency. It is learned by a transition
graph contrastive learning strategy. Subsequently, we design a soft instruction
tuning to learn and map the all-path embedding to the input of LLMs.
Experimental results show that our proposed CTLP method achieves
state-of-the-art performance on three standard ZSLP datasets | [
0.005171619821339846,
-0.4829730987548828,
0.7047070264816284,
-0.29207301139831543,
-0.42935773730278015,
0.1675623059272766,
-0.31077200174331665,
-0.5001644492149353,
0.09486046433448792,
0.41205647587776184,
-0.7953421473503113,
-0.9334065914154053,
-0.3703099489212036,
-0.162194162607193,
-0.09776608645915985,
0.9031147956848145,
0.1593068391084671,
-0.09131329506635666,
0.3148505687713623,
-0.00908171758055687,
-0.1950995773077011,
-0.06990400701761246,
-0.4891033470630646,
-0.5553900003433228,
0.4590305685997009,
0.18944835662841797,
0.6473080515861511,
0.7970485687255859,
0.010210356675088406,
0.1288595199584961,
-0.08766799420118332,
0.11685460805892944,
-0.6736017465591431,
0.3185330033302307,
-0.1283038705587387,
-0.39871951937675476,
-0.25576648116111755,
-0.4575750231742859,
0.7175273895263672,
0.9220320582389832,
-0.025724053382873535,
0.07057785242795944,
0.05187173932790756,
0.5648849606513977,
-0.8546992540359497,
0.539880633354187,
-1.0471484661102295,
0.3609023094177246,
-0.2808566987514496,
-0.2919175922870636,
-0.7398255467414856,
-0.032701876014471054,
-0.016639942303299904,
-0.4858047664165497,
0.20937073230743408,
0.07129065692424774,
0.7670611143112183,
0.0019412084948271513,
-0.574942946434021,
0.012492731213569641,
-0.8487921357154846,
0.4402436316013336,
-0.6449511647224426,
0.6886884570121765,
-0.18617141246795654,
0.34018778800964355,
-0.35336315631866455,
-0.5509521961212158,
-0.4049813151359558,
-0.18862569332122803,
0.015652446076273918,
0.11376561224460602,
-0.008569168858230114,
0.5103734135627747,
0.11955331265926361,
0.06444346904754639,
-0.6540220379829407,
0.06351617723703384,
-0.3015075623989105,
-0.10768965631723404,
0.24624919891357422,
0.3497893810272217,
0.1828755885362625,
0.0887603834271431,
-0.189901202917099,
0.004933500196784735,
-0.8441455960273743,
-0.18946704268455505,
0.13292185962200165,
0.7334222793579102,
-0.22489438951015472,
0.45888689160346985,
-0.22901581227779388,
1.00514817237854,
0.27385181188583374,
-0.05650439113378525,
0.3200433850288391,
0.018747663125395775,
-0.2954614758491516,
0.302386075258255,
0.817348837852478,
0.2635563910007477,
0.2515828013420105,
-0.5795093178749084,
0.18583498895168304,
0.14892490208148956,
-0.18097881972789764,
-0.9520409107208252,
-0.13260796666145325,
0.06380210816860199,
-0.04524829611182213,
0.05643027275800705,
-0.12560617923736572,
-0.4409719407558441,
-0.22247841954231262,
0.00787668488919735,
0.09565972536802292,
-0.7976028919219971,
-0.18527399003505707,
0.367343544960022,
0.018652142956852913,
0.3883498013019562,
0.4520021677017212,
-0.6807272434234619,
0.3515721559524536,
0.5917800068855286,
1.0218632221221924,
0.15973497927188873,
-0.3438827097415924,
-0.6577800512313843,
0.8741543292999268,
-0.417030930519104,
0.47423335909843445,
-0.6986719965934753,
-0.28287941217422485,
0.2877956032752991,
-0.064519003033638,
-0.1924808770418167,
0.04558931663632393,
0.43217432498931885,
-0.5946857929229736,
-0.3080509603023529,
0.24646496772766113,
-0.8684207797050476,
-0.10165403038263321,
0.25656718015670776,
-0.7568396925926208,
0.2049894779920578,
0.05869530513882637,
-0.8438252806663513,
0.06722523272037506,
-0.35865023732185364,
-0.601177990436554,
0.22397442162036896,
-0.4002271890640259,
-0.3053557872772217,
-0.1349404901266098,
-0.11641670018434525,
0.42306870222091675,
-0.30002284049987793,
0.09641946107149124,
-0.7473094463348389,
-0.4075549244880676,
-0.13294647634029388,
-0.05123990401625633,
0.6455553770065308,
0.07051821798086166,
-0.062168918550014496,
0.012407909147441387,
-0.7357476949691772,
0.16009727120399475,
0.08627413958311081,
-0.16304968297481537,
-0.21439428627490997,
-0.04080552980303764,
-0.3250466287136078,
0.4020150899887085,
0.1994878351688385,
-0.8147104382514954,
0.2737899422645569,
-0.46962234377861023,
0.3679715692996979,
0.7306661009788513,
0.10547132790088654,
0.679700493812561,
0.1344989538192749,
0.5244983434677124,
0.2537493407726288,
0.0049977716989815235,
-0.3048705756664276,
-0.4069027304649353,
-0.7177584171295166,
0.4528959095478058,
0.2768378257751465,
0.23914067447185516,
-0.858972430229187,
0.383227676153183,
-0.4255780577659607,
-0.583563506603241,
-0.2775636911392212,
0.11914428323507309,
0.46979424357414246,
0.937657356262207,
0.38209301233291626,
-0.14811429381370544,
-0.44368672370910645,
-0.6005964279174805,
0.051295168697834015,
-0.2750608026981354,
-0.06991703808307648,
0.39573028683662415,
0.17325130105018616,
0.09854690730571747,
0.7386100888252258,
-1.075069785118103,
-0.43770453333854675,
-0.4009312093257904,
0.06662433594465256,
0.3606625199317932,
0.3404497504234314,
0.39186975359916687,
-0.4257802665233612,
-0.6279350519180298,
-0.08631648123264313,
-0.5159831047058105,
0.3139389455318451,
-0.06687860190868378,
-0.26167595386505127,
0.00143421592656523,
0.4221813678741455,
-0.669695258140564,
0.04606756195425987,
0.46670132875442505,
-0.35009926557540894,
0.4642177224159241,
-0.10204865038394928,
-0.25957897305488586,
-0.7325027585029602,
-0.05236874148249626,
0.2729170322418213,
-0.02676921710371971,
-0.7653021216392517,
-0.005093049257993698,
0.32495319843292236,
-0.3484128415584564,
-0.5579851865768433,
0.451387882232666,
-0.49467650055885315,
0.007441815920174122,
0.2074929028749466,
0.16885240375995636,
-0.0800517275929451,
0.7156209349632263,
0.4251037538051605,
0.3705914616584778,
0.6324529051780701,
-0.45633766055107117,
-0.09303785860538483,
0.2716589570045471,
0.010620996356010437,
0.3879368305206299,
-0.5488801002502441,
0.2868998944759369,
-0.355373352766037,
0.5119174718856812,
-0.764534592628479,
0.158131405711174,
0.17488455772399902,
-0.504602313041687,
0.6978491544723511,
-0.6103613972663879,
-0.4483441114425659,
-0.08105004578828812,
-0.4377400875091553,
0.2785186171531677,
0.4816003441810608,
0.04991725832223892,
0.7000973224639893,
0.0770483985543251,
0.4195619821548462,
-0.6325165033340454,
-0.45029470324516296,
0.029493143782019615,
0.2830978035926819,
-0.6909648180007935,
0.505997359752655,
-0.22112596035003662,
0.4925213158130646,
0.2796039879322052,
-0.12626878917217255,
-0.3077183663845062,
-0.17163141071796417,
0.48299098014831543,
0.3994196057319641,
-0.4065985083580017,
0.20980976521968842,
-0.030764885246753693,
-0.2657971680164337,
-0.2220078557729721,
-0.41036275029182434,
0.8601372241973877,
-0.09939361363649368,
-0.3603622615337372,
-0.03747168555855751,
-0.1752418428659439,
0.3842391073703766,
-0.09969210624694824,
0.8124091625213623,
0.5492558479309082,
-0.2362036108970642,
-0.43296924233436584,
-0.10103651136159897,
0.007569473702460527,
-0.44540736079216003,
0.46549609303474426,
-0.3108872175216675,
-0.7925776243209839,
0.33431169390678406,
-0.1485249549150467,
-0.05778537690639496,
0.36708688735961914,
0.1480119228363037,
0.21735186874866486,
0.7268925905227661,
0.7522128224372864,
-0.12465613335371017,
0.2941594421863556,
-0.5841584205627441,
0.1952665150165558,
-0.9574414491653442,
-0.5426886677742004,
-0.35183238983154297,
-0.07952295988798141,
-0.6098412275314331,
-0.2879895865917206,
0.34649890661239624,
0.21104304492473602,
-0.5677276253700256,
0.5926759243011475,
-0.29244884848594666,
0.402761846780777,
0.2170335203409195,
0.2873281240463257,
0.2445121556520462,
-0.19110724329948425,
-0.150392547249794,
-0.07516835629940033,
-0.735358476638794,
0.1613212674856186,
1.16464364528656,
0.1722853183746338,
0.9424336552619934,
-0.019080085679888725,
0.8340523838996887,
0.10433504730463028,
-0.17383456230163574,
-0.8597003221511841,
0.6443495750427246,
-0.3937237560749054,
-0.20891714096069336,
-0.3185018301010132,
-0.3520965576171875,
-0.916957437992096,
-0.08226583153009415,
-0.3736667335033417,
-0.6333465576171875,
0.07690165936946869,
0.14152078330516815,
-0.35124167799949646,
0.547655463218689,
-0.21299998462200165,
0.44803982973098755,
0.06412514299154282,
-0.4723570942878723,
-0.07361043244600296,
-0.9288556575775146,
0.43931812047958374,
0.1696052849292755,
-0.07022285461425781,
-0.2539873421192169,
0.05533319711685181,
0.5393385887145996,
-0.20068907737731934,
0.7844386100769043,
-0.032717250287532806,
0.11193905770778656,
0.05124576762318611,
0.5151214599609375,
0.37835246324539185,
-0.2943899929523468,
-0.28686052560806274,
0.20227263867855072,
-0.36623698472976685,
-0.10861513763666153,
-0.7498154640197754,
0.7026053667068481,
-0.6772186160087585,
-0.30689913034439087,
-0.1479753702878952,
-0.35980531573295593,
-0.4362882673740387,
0.3654637634754181,
0.05147309973835945,
0.4833478331565857,
-0.03334756940603256,
0.2434699684381485,
0.6819364428520203,
-0.065941721200943,
0.3899974822998047,
0.790536642074585,
0.1400729864835739,
-0.35054779052734375,
0.7380672097206116,
0.2256261557340622,
0.28299611806869507,
0.6947969794273376,
0.0400095097720623,
-0.5222643613815308,
-0.47233524918556213,
-0.5334410667419434,
0.40760913491249084,
-0.7679731845855713,
-0.5458825826644897,
-0.4515795409679413,
-0.7319814562797546,
-0.4952947497367859,
-0.33797308802604675,
-0.36706459522247314,
-0.2984578609466553,
-0.22710062563419342,
-0.09978306293487549,
0.060434404760599136,
0.46158209443092346,
-0.008830508217215538,
0.07397513091564178,
-0.7907124757766724,
0.20358963310718536,
0.040693581104278564,
0.56146240234375,
0.28461700677871704,
-0.3303946852684021,
-0.07414241880178452,
-0.127339169383049,
-0.29629841446876526,
-0.9986663460731506,
0.1597609668970108,
0.6063541769981384,
0.34991058707237244,
0.6600224375724792,
0.5063444972038269,
0.6485140919685364,
-0.9333462715148926,
0.5476731657981873,
0.6811857223510742,
-0.8536896109580994,
0.6189841628074646,
-0.23313301801681519,
0.1903369128704071,
0.4805029630661011,
0.4572000205516815,
-0.4971841275691986,
-0.2998628616333008,
-0.6845299601554871,
-0.8148689270019531,
0.61861652135849,
0.14067459106445312,
0.1292549967765808,
-0.12117946147918701,
0.3542969822883606,
-0.1544896960258484,
0.3686386048793793,
-0.6509671211242676,
-0.3842400014400482,
-0.011419057846069336,
-0.2566770315170288,
0.13329271972179413,
-0.17744702100753784,
0.11926452815532684,
0.028052907437086105,
0.4576376676559448,
-0.22229158878326416,
0.0009650798747316003,
-0.005941316485404968,
-0.06905830651521683,
-0.41348397731781006,
0.33191177248954773,
0.2116720825433731,
0.7250155210494995,
-0.5717443227767944,
0.3305462896823883,
-0.02689024992287159,
-0.22491410374641418,
0.34085774421691895,
-0.121566541492939,
-0.6199653744697571,
0.15904486179351807,
0.5292662978172302,
0.8918735384941101,
0.4009060263633728,
-0.5311824679374695,
0.6495280861854553,
0.3767687678337097,
0.030683057382702827,
-0.23790818452835083,
0.24688349664211273,
0.20778712630271912,
0.08785015344619751,
0.19575144350528717,
-0.37861624360084534,
0.1471128910779953,
-0.7152920365333557,
0.22895008325576782,
0.4724048376083374,
-0.7226051092147827,
-0.4177215099334717,
0.5690908432006836,
0.19458776712417603,
-0.23335693776607513,
0.6072531342506409,
-0.2968372404575348,
-0.4104376435279846,
0.5131166577339172,
0.7866338491439819,
0.8280822038650513,
-0.3023916482925415,
0.5369634032249451,
0.537869930267334,
0.12657110393047333,
0.2171093374490738,
-0.0960526093840599,
-0.09665299952030182,
-0.8728774785995483,
-0.38221028447151184,
-0.7614198923110962,
-0.40949928760528564,
0.312121719121933,
-0.5794281959533691,
0.551190197467804,
-0.7680709958076477,
0.16202567517757416,
-0.045251451432704926,
0.05533613637089729,
-0.6942074298858643,
0.11888110637664795,
0.3064582347869873,
1.044610619544983,
-0.942611813545227,
1.034417986869812,
0.3502123951911926,
-0.7000204920768738,
-0.744773268699646,
0.007475054357200861,
-0.2052946537733078,
-0.9115456342697144,
0.8281114101409912,
0.06461246311664581,
-0.39643630385398865,
0.05672185495495796,
-0.5279715657234192,
-0.6619341969490051,
1.1738381385803223,
0.6791154742240906,
-0.7932659387588501,
-0.4952482283115387,
0.18977391719818115,
0.36640438437461853,
-0.46578580141067505,
0.24445801973342896,
0.22392700612545013,
0.11545244604349136,
0.7104615569114685,
-0.5992400050163269,
0.4297315180301666,
0.08628822863101959,
0.10619782656431198,
0.3921135365962982,
-0.6288953423500061,
0.923467218875885,
-0.3601438105106354,
-0.4302043914794922,
-0.3106966018676758,
0.5320482850074768,
0.27509188652038574,
0.1243843138217926,
0.48963284492492676,
0.4452657997608185,
0.26063594222068787,
0.2602495551109314,
0.48441022634506226,
-0.8326842784881592,
0.43720224499702454,
1.497989296913147,
-0.48814406991004944,
0.901201605796814,
0.07920508086681366,
-0.07080229371786118,
0.8216106295585632,
0.38656681776046753,
-0.12358376383781433,
0.7070888876914978,
0.15688057243824005,
-0.1994306594133377,
-0.4432433843612671,
-0.305430144071579,
-0.3976978659629822,
0.27510398626327515,
0.43381065130233765,
-0.4636901021003723,
-0.7952202558517456,
-0.645404040813446,
0.14222227036952972,
-0.19173987209796906,
-0.3926846981048584,
0.5704596638679504,
-0.02396770380437374,
-0.13366667926311493,
0.4417725205421448,
-0.04887862130999565,
0.41441965103149414,
-0.9602070450782776,
-0.3111114799976349,
0.06423650681972504,
-0.03765188902616501,
-0.16510918736457825,
-1.1849613189697266,
0.07313326746225357,
-0.5465502738952637,
0.09674684703350067,
0.31411829590797424,
0.9111613631248474,
-0.7206704020500183,
-0.28205662965774536,
0.595022976398468,
0.345548152923584,
-0.12948854267597198,
0.17921020090579987,
-0.6682230234146118,
-0.04213939234614372,
-0.06239648908376694,
0.11079135537147522,
0.4105735123157501,
0.4479219615459442,
0.30976977944374084,
0.7279019951820374,
0.44877153635025024,
0.4411705732345581,
-0.09516455233097076,
-0.05646020546555519,
0.9761908650398254,
-0.713381290435791,
-0.4962271749973297,
-0.901938796043396,
0.3063811659812927,
-0.13785769045352936,
0.017888640984892845,
0.3635907769203186,
0.6256505250930786,
0.679654598236084,
0.05776115879416466,
0.701559841632843,
0.09285891801118851,
0.04077131673693657,
-0.7202063202857971,
0.4784935712814331,
-0.29018497467041016,
-0.08457209169864655,
-0.31869494915008545,
-0.8197110891342163,
-0.2066047340631485,
0.1276126205921173,
0.04160580039024353,
-0.11008148640394211,
0.6195551156997681,
0.5465186238288879,
-0.22612766921520233,
-0.4214286506175995,
0.6234153509140015,
0.38741907477378845,
0.22115406394004822,
1.1593830585479736,
0.12639042735099792,
-0.1700945943593979,
0.8170881867408752,
-0.3690354526042938,
0.05554799363017082,
-0.18584942817687988,
-1.0992896556854248,
-0.8272919058799744,
-0.6564502716064453,
-0.3018698990345001,
-0.4064562916755676,
0.24879620969295502,
0.7318971753120422,
0.689689040184021,
-0.46820950508117676,
-0.281071275472641,
-0.1985694020986557,
0.1236632838845253,
0.24590717256069183,
-0.1869233250617981,
0.5102527737617493,
-0.2790515124797821,
-0.3745686411857605,
0.23380661010742188,
0.6052159667015076,
0.0614207461476326,
-0.4415225684642792,
-0.27693188190460205,
0.02145632915198803,
0.004668016918003559,
0.540462076663971,
0.4952564835548401,
-0.5399261713027954,
-0.28621944785118103,
-0.11119917780160904,
0.17966902256011963,
0.1312488168478012,
0.7638108730316162,
-0.6505401730537415,
0.36915677785873413,
0.4169481098651886,
0.38044849038124084,
0.755102813243866,
-0.3048126995563507,
0.6116635799407959,
-0.7291626930236816,
0.22497768700122833,
0.2810913920402527,
0.5152572393417358,
0.22386434674263,
-0.3800496459007263,
0.6778801083564758,
0.12839974462985992,
-0.06839976459741592,
-0.6000738739967346,
0.7235028743743896,
-0.9955279231071472,
-0.3014377951622009,
1.1165943145751953,
-0.5199113488197327,
-0.49225616455078125,
-0.1472364217042923,
0.23193883895874023,
0.5073744654655457,
-0.6078853011131287,
0.46864205598831177,
0.10589691251516342,
-0.4079363942146301,
-0.25804147124290466,
-0.2786126136779785,
0.34200891852378845,
-0.2809620499610901,
-0.39132431149482727,
0.1204913929104805,
0.5028242468833923,
0.45774707198143005,
0.2642170786857605,
0.7676566243171692,
0.14504365622997284,
-0.0024080309085547924,
-0.01518926490098238,
0.027863139286637306,
-0.4152206778526306,
-0.40802767872810364,
-0.07234261184930801,
0.4402478337287903,
0.14288297295570374,
-0.16639190912246704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10772v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10772v1 | Enhancing ESG Impact Type Identification through Early Fusion and Multilingual Models | 2024-02-16T15:54:24 | 2024-02-16T15:54:24 | Hariram Veeramani, Surendrabikram Thapa, Usman Naseem | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the evolving landscape of Environmental, Social, and Corporate Governance
(ESG) impact assessment, the ML-ESG-2 shared task proposes identifying ESG
impact types. To address this challenge, we present a comprehensive system
leveraging ensemble learning techniques, capitalizing on early and late fusion
approaches. Our approach employs four distinct models: mBERT, FlauBERT-base,
ALBERT-base-v2, and a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) incorporating Latent
Semantic Analysis (LSA) and Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (TF-IDF)
features. Through extensive experimentation, we find that our early fusion
ensemble approach, featuring the integration of LSA, TF-IDF, mBERT,
FlauBERT-base, and ALBERT-base-v2, delivers the best performance. Our system
offers a comprehensive ESG impact type identification solution, contributing to
the responsible and sustainable decision-making processes vital in today's
financial and corporate governance landscape. | [
-0.5455761551856995,
-0.6738256812095642,
0.3506571054458618,
0.11259013414382935,
-0.20134274661540985,
0.6298660039901733,
0.03074389323592186,
-0.7847819328308105,
0.329092800617218,
0.6084935069084167,
-0.44500985741615295,
-0.3594319522380829,
-0.937160313129425,
-0.08435092121362686,
-0.37829121947288513,
1.2792378664016724,
0.22950363159179688,
-0.04027857631444931,
0.021311046555638313,
-0.046929653733968735,
-0.08452758193016052,
-0.3637097179889679,
-0.4932272434234619,
-0.3076935410499573,
0.5986294150352478,
0.2025056630373001,
0.2749505043029785,
0.06179753318428993,
0.3613259792327881,
0.27907055616378784,
-0.37040650844573975,
0.27692243456840515,
-0.6613404750823975,
-0.40808814764022827,
-0.04326419159770012,
-0.04459872469305992,
-0.15665709972381592,
-0.004468022845685482,
0.5989326238632202,
0.40289056301116943,
-0.30125707387924194,
0.33957812190055847,
0.36558178067207336,
0.2225775271654129,
-0.8622604608535767,
0.38162761926651,
-0.596102237701416,
0.20078466832637787,
-0.3227916955947876,
-0.06168178841471672,
-0.44675561785697937,
0.14446289837360382,
0.4800526797771454,
-0.6290311217308044,
-0.2230120599269867,
0.08568186312913895,
0.7569396495819092,
0.12094125896692276,
-0.6812456250190735,
-0.2271318882703781,
-0.617100179195404,
0.6455473899841309,
-0.14167030155658722,
0.4674135446548462,
-0.04933103546500206,
0.17261488735675812,
-0.06121461093425751,
-0.7941191792488098,
-0.2535608410835266,
0.37231460213661194,
-0.2682923376560211,
0.3546237051486969,
-0.13073590397834778,
0.19150987267494202,
-0.10899530351161957,
0.2651199996471405,
-0.475366473197937,
0.3347715437412262,
-0.7485296130180359,
-0.5242972373962402,
0.5549659132957458,
-0.17582499980926514,
0.0005792556330561638,
-0.1627988964319229,
-0.6327848434448242,
-0.14373326301574707,
-0.7879185676574707,
0.02667650394141674,
0.5475399494171143,
0.4107652008533478,
-0.233927920460701,
0.359732061624527,
0.011546848341822624,
0.4588978886604309,
0.28641897439956665,
0.11623935401439667,
0.2958128750324249,
-0.21705526113510132,
-0.24246232211589813,
0.3632110059261322,
0.3807939887046814,
0.013665902428328991,
-0.31667113304138184,
-0.030749592930078506,
-0.3707122802734375,
-0.15320388972759247,
0.1988404244184494,
-0.6373851299285889,
-0.07003647089004517,
0.16468048095703125,
-0.6369518041610718,
-0.5113257765769958,
0.3106676936149597,
-1.0224412679672241,
-0.6880857348442078,
-0.39712491631507874,
0.8543859124183655,
-0.12026173621416092,
-0.3789411187171936,
-0.1003987267613411,
-0.2961399555206299,
0.6322187185287476,
0.24147900938987732,
-0.8382010459899902,
0.12923893332481384,
0.8906728029251099,
0.7251887917518616,
-0.1603538990020752,
-0.13080692291259766,
-0.8020672798156738,
0.46307173371315,
0.29423075914382935,
1.185543417930603,
-0.7656375169754028,
-0.8666713833808899,
0.05644701421260834,
-0.010085360147058964,
0.048551760613918304,
-0.40000832080841064,
0.5893539786338806,
-0.4457074999809265,
0.19925102591514587,
-0.22218646109104156,
-0.4521263837814331,
-0.41743528842926025,
-0.10903719067573547,
-0.6451169848442078,
1.1514735221862793,
-0.05680909752845764,
-0.5972017049789429,
0.7202105522155762,
-0.820608913898468,
-0.47688522934913635,
0.5093193650245667,
-0.4823545813560486,
-0.3327888250350952,
0.1967509686946869,
0.09848842769861221,
0.5557447075843811,
-0.1489390730857849,
0.10635621100664139,
-0.3348735272884369,
-0.13655239343643188,
-0.6915504932403564,
-0.22164173424243927,
0.568730354309082,
0.16478246450424194,
-0.0875147134065628,
0.26297464966773987,
-1.0747419595718384,
0.014329780824482441,
-0.10939295589923859,
-0.15108293294906616,
-0.30382758378982544,
0.35671475529670715,
0.3460429310798645,
0.2181243747472763,
0.5387498140335083,
-0.2417810708284378,
-0.015196339227259159,
0.08020328730344772,
0.33271342515945435,
1.0988359451293945,
0.27181991934776306,
0.27617111802101135,
-0.06089501455426216,
0.25002720952033997,
-0.038384344428777695,
0.2685474157333374,
0.007546020671725273,
-0.6088821887969971,
-0.2219124734401703,
-0.3732571303844452,
0.0575440414249897,
0.7941750288009644,
-0.538084089756012,
0.5210355520248413,
-0.2871531546115875,
-0.9954090714454651,
-0.20653867721557617,
-0.06414444744586945,
0.32301774621009827,
0.22401484847068787,
0.3010616600513458,
-0.18198871612548828,
-0.6374869346618652,
-1.1327321529388428,
-0.6113951802253723,
-0.4652445316314697,
-0.18386274576187134,
0.4458537697792053,
0.7272148728370667,
-0.08436935395002365,
0.8489641547203064,
-0.3954123854637146,
-0.19218184053897858,
0.008231448009610176,
0.4865157902240753,
0.1741710901260376,
0.20242702960968018,
0.40805584192276,
-1.0882407426834106,
-0.1974410116672516,
0.18739159405231476,
-0.4056147336959839,
-0.03146170824766159,
0.0003900484007317573,
0.025487370789051056,
-0.22859297692775726,
0.21877504885196686,
-0.09181804209947586,
-0.03571251034736633,
0.7634621262550354,
-0.4894019067287445,
0.25526928901672363,
-0.03846466913819313,
0.1694893091917038,
-0.9402832984924316,
0.12771275639533997,
0.19229112565517426,
0.18749889731407166,
-0.753284215927124,
-0.26159197092056274,
0.18327726423740387,
-0.11049628257751465,
-0.7763486504554749,
0.49621105194091797,
-0.23078005015850067,
-0.5063753128051758,
0.2303711473941803,
-0.15600839257240295,
0.02076164074242115,
0.24154821038246155,
0.15589989721775055,
0.6091465950012207,
0.3953359127044678,
-0.6618722677230835,
0.03050808049738407,
0.294776976108551,
-0.5256563425064087,
0.7097907066345215,
-0.7320736646652222,
0.28234171867370605,
-0.27395299077033997,
0.4310537874698639,
-0.7937047481536865,
-0.3801138699054718,
-0.08069044351577759,
-0.14549483358860016,
0.37758776545524597,
-0.3408493101596832,
-0.48885229229927063,
-0.24549534916877747,
-0.2675735652446747,
0.04168255627155304,
0.2159447968006134,
-0.6832566261291504,
1.2856069803237915,
0.8038604855537415,
-0.235170379281044,
-0.705298662185669,
-0.5562811493873596,
-0.11500289291143417,
-0.49043262004852295,
-0.8249050378799438,
0.6561469435691833,
0.42644307017326355,
-0.1477607637643814,
-0.09469358623027802,
-0.16239289939403534,
-0.05713992565870285,
0.40390950441360474,
0.20556208491325378,
0.3605777323246002,
0.11053413897752762,
0.07205668836832047,
0.18971265852451324,
0.027298621833324432,
-0.3053278625011444,
-0.05869284272193909,
0.46762117743492126,
-0.5252561569213867,
-0.2694271504878998,
0.16469956934452057,
0.407524049282074,
0.695703387260437,
-0.6551321744918823,
0.7907463312149048,
0.9086995124816895,
-0.6294695734977722,
0.015750357881188393,
-0.46954527497291565,
-0.12444088608026505,
-0.5124178528785706,
0.7549613118171692,
-0.2843152582645416,
-0.8797299265861511,
0.847652792930603,
-0.28327906131744385,
0.263350248336792,
0.9922426342964172,
0.5150384902954102,
0.0836838111281395,
0.8012440204620361,
0.5810168981552124,
-0.08786450326442719,
0.7036421298980713,
-0.17022892832756042,
0.09529732912778854,
-0.7718169689178467,
-0.5515991449356079,
-0.3847448527812958,
-0.14310839772224426,
-0.6807984113693237,
-0.0695897787809372,
0.7970250844955444,
0.0856638178229332,
-0.26845675706863403,
0.23380404710769653,
-0.39013051986694336,
0.35589390993118286,
0.3092905282974243,
0.02972552739083767,
-0.047501347959041595,
0.027701610699295998,
0.09270516037940979,
0.3783264756202698,
-0.46951836347579956,
-0.6587816476821899,
1.0963680744171143,
0.4787537455558777,
0.6571190357208252,
0.36172348260879517,
0.8932514786720276,
0.5917624831199646,
0.4263652563095093,
-0.5856728553771973,
0.31746476888656616,
-0.35553550720214844,
-0.7612758874893188,
-0.2161240428686142,
-0.2756315767765045,
-0.6868085265159607,
0.48078957200050354,
-0.6626619100570679,
-0.9326910972595215,
0.24316632747650146,
-0.062006622552871704,
-0.913635790348053,
0.14434540271759033,
-0.8737812042236328,
0.6908595561981201,
-0.4449509382247925,
-0.27532467246055603,
-0.2746364176273346,
-0.5752058029174805,
0.2500426173210144,
-0.30132827162742615,
0.42346224188804626,
-0.06100893393158913,
-0.1329621970653534,
0.8916507959365845,
0.06335068494081497,
1.0566184520721436,
-0.4009754955768585,
-0.276654988527298,
0.33363914489746094,
-0.4477197229862213,
0.9905292987823486,
0.05385658144950867,
0.030516624450683594,
0.4171621799468994,
0.03334107995033264,
-0.17977868020534515,
-0.3962171673774719,
0.5445464849472046,
-0.8520147204399109,
-0.2911153733730316,
-0.26752516627311707,
0.02444586530327797,
-0.23065926134586334,
0.13409341871738434,
0.2608288526535034,
0.25575900077819824,
-0.5021553635597229,
0.20107150077819824,
0.49465104937553406,
-0.1906164437532425,
0.37689557671546936,
0.6068675518035889,
-0.14253181219100952,
-0.6334009766578674,
0.8704356551170349,
0.38871392607688904,
0.11035878956317902,
0.05901992693543434,
0.1469678431749344,
-0.4823383390903473,
-0.3309793472290039,
-0.3468054234981537,
-0.13602790236473083,
-0.7489626407623291,
-0.07231856137514114,
-0.8400804400444031,
-0.10992569476366043,
-0.3643677830696106,
-0.0749254822731018,
-0.3095741868019104,
-0.06239955127239227,
-0.4094615578651428,
-0.23807847499847412,
0.24442251026630402,
0.7489963173866272,
-0.08229400962591171,
0.5028921961784363,
-1.1731352806091309,
0.11225532740354538,
0.4080865979194641,
0.4742578864097595,
-0.46897926926612854,
-0.3577392101287842,
-0.13550515472888947,
-0.31614217162132263,
-0.3788925111293793,
-0.9440882802009583,
0.09301883727312088,
0.5763064622879028,
0.8744233250617981,
0.7481105923652649,
-0.3178006112575531,
0.256082147359848,
-0.441006064414978,
1.0168641805648804,
0.09758152067661285,
-1.013789176940918,
0.3912333548069,
-0.3524402379989624,
-0.15646050870418549,
0.6225529909133911,
0.3558221757411957,
-0.6306731104850769,
0.12418660521507263,
-0.7446503639221191,
-1.003010869026184,
0.4502209424972534,
0.06577883660793304,
-0.18140242993831635,
-0.026888281106948853,
0.07957912981510162,
0.21447838842868805,
0.12050691246986389,
-0.5685763955116272,
-0.16118945181369781,
0.08821125328540802,
0.0009130156831815839,
-0.09563322365283966,
-0.19802847504615784,
-0.16771173477172852,
0.1646014302968979,
0.8974327445030212,
-0.0861680805683136,
0.1707516461610794,
-0.08245836198329926,
-0.1424868255853653,
0.10316002368927002,
0.23938202857971191,
0.7153013944625854,
0.09138082712888718,
-0.20666292309761047,
0.01692674309015274,
0.40028446912765503,
-0.41042304039001465,
-0.06493422389030457,
0.2867002785205841,
-0.03399889916181564,
-0.24648112058639526,
0.42775940895080566,
0.7988908886909485,
0.2978250980377197,
-0.5109126567840576,
0.3222000300884247,
0.3173615634441376,
-0.2080966830253601,
-0.36071640253067017,
-0.2375003695487976,
-0.13706478476524353,
0.3861340582370758,
0.6832597255706787,
0.04382455348968506,
0.32650554180145264,
-0.4862162172794342,
0.45192205905914307,
0.25062569975852966,
-0.43617719411849976,
-0.24083511531352997,
0.2871073782444,
0.6442267298698425,
-0.01822500117123127,
0.221669003367424,
-0.12347995489835739,
-0.8525535464286804,
0.8429673910140991,
0.33598849177360535,
1.059268593788147,
-0.45560649037361145,
0.0705338642001152,
0.3491532504558563,
0.40474453568458557,
-0.2546871602535248,
0.3939964473247528,
0.17962853610515594,
-0.8150069713592529,
-0.44600579142570496,
-0.6323286294937134,
-0.2954632043838501,
0.1665440946817398,
-0.7491787672042847,
0.6494805216789246,
-0.48067766427993774,
-0.016803748905658722,
0.2596186399459839,
0.003031653817743063,
-0.7474071383476257,
-0.03348736837506294,
0.6612986326217651,
0.582812488079071,
-1.2575775384902954,
0.34951052069664,
0.7773643732070923,
-0.2446601390838623,
-0.4459975063800812,
-0.32442668080329895,
0.5533544421195984,
-1.022378921508789,
0.5324774980545044,
0.37559273838996887,
-0.27235540747642517,
0.18370653688907623,
-0.24629385769367218,
-1.0225950479507446,
1.2717186212539673,
-0.04126108065247536,
-0.7093480825424194,
-0.05911910906434059,
-0.13599355518817902,
0.30236226320266724,
-0.4000118374824524,
0.3312431573867798,
0.5635597705841064,
0.8766854405403137,
0.0007733694510534406,
-0.9918171167373657,
-0.397019624710083,
-0.1099623292684555,
-0.20002971589565277,
0.5689141154289246,
-0.8633332848548889,
0.5167890787124634,
-0.05152882635593414,
-0.4573929011821747,
-0.5129261016845703,
0.6768344640731812,
0.14138589799404144,
0.21456880867481232,
0.8137180209159851,
0.5251088738441467,
0.9308110475540161,
-0.011227862909436226,
1.0914486646652222,
-0.5681617856025696,
0.6118685007095337,
1.0684837102890015,
-0.2983011305332184,
0.9037389159202576,
0.5775560736656189,
-0.247187077999115,
0.1470591425895691,
1.0531831979751587,
-0.30327120423316956,
0.7499058246612549,
0.36578187346458435,
-0.5136051177978516,
-0.18780343234539032,
-0.3155691623687744,
-0.28827041387557983,
0.7878758311271667,
0.8412526845932007,
-0.49672314524650574,
-0.3034343421459198,
0.0068743349984288216,
-0.23297126591205597,
-0.44321438670158386,
-0.5988285541534424,
0.7936630845069885,
-0.1544700264930725,
-0.29790958762168884,
-0.18152537941932678,
0.01930977776646614,
0.8503057360649109,
-0.5577442646026611,
-0.042877424508333206,
0.25378087162971497,
-0.24596776068210602,
-0.43944767117500305,
-0.8497135639190674,
0.33661437034606934,
-0.05388456955552101,
0.16087083518505096,
-0.12234925478696823,
0.7703255414962769,
-0.4421844780445099,
-0.4741881191730499,
0.6131361126899719,
0.5586327314376831,
-0.05477942153811455,
-0.1979125589132309,
-0.3884522318840027,
-0.06432673335075378,
-0.2466045618057251,
-0.37661218643188477,
0.08327578008174896,
0.16919797658920288,
0.06524943560361862,
0.15740671753883362,
0.3969102203845978,
-0.2706591486930847,
-0.02338619902729988,
0.03608311340212822,
0.5828278064727783,
-0.24808768928050995,
-0.41279855370521545,
-0.6593811511993408,
0.48151645064353943,
-0.20621198415756226,
-0.4155179560184479,
0.30658459663391113,
0.6869374513626099,
0.7688573598861694,
0.10821563005447388,
1.0177453756332397,
-0.29426246881484985,
0.16069790720939636,
-0.4937395453453064,
0.7967209219932556,
-0.4896986186504364,
0.21178306639194489,
-0.3929060399532318,
-0.9671794176101685,
-0.11989065259695053,
0.265882283449173,
-0.2906576991081238,
-0.03077319823205471,
0.3189830183982849,
0.649074137210846,
-0.12910176813602448,
0.16141222417354584,
0.32236775755882263,
0.10903636366128922,
0.468702107667923,
0.40240615606307983,
0.7542744874954224,
-0.2749820053577423,
0.6114163994789124,
0.08601213246583939,
-0.3611436188220978,
-0.18483984470367432,
-1.000888466835022,
-0.4203765392303467,
-0.6208302974700928,
-0.26368823647499084,
-0.29566505551338196,
-0.08292064815759659,
1.1065566539764404,
0.5791791677474976,
-0.6369953155517578,
0.20256586372852325,
0.2434738129377365,
-0.1833636611700058,
-0.07606378197669983,
-0.1915317177772522,
0.506011426448822,
0.10772787779569626,
-0.5011269450187683,
0.5108054280281067,
0.5952051877975464,
0.07966113835573196,
-0.21906141936779022,
-0.11182460933923721,
-0.15060363709926605,
0.1545635461807251,
0.8562431335449219,
0.2417166531085968,
-0.7354287505149841,
-0.9002017378807068,
-0.2802342176437378,
0.1482655107975006,
-0.2616407573223114,
0.604134738445282,
-0.4246608316898346,
0.21221959590911865,
0.3729863464832306,
0.8514923453330994,
0.3793753683567047,
-0.3520142138004303,
0.4187999665737152,
-0.5504178404808044,
-0.01288894284516573,
0.19577988982200623,
0.5803792476654053,
-0.10866984724998474,
-0.5996852517127991,
0.6497235894203186,
0.3098331093788147,
-0.29602792859077454,
-0.5660424828529358,
0.39229947328567505,
-0.9874715209007263,
-0.0019223425770178437,
1.2215299606323242,
-0.1279560923576355,
0.016967862844467163,
-0.11909693479537964,
-0.04604620486497879,
0.12164449691772461,
-0.5030238032341003,
0.7748425006866455,
1.0861668586730957,
-0.06633517146110535,
-0.127318874001503,
-0.06868287920951843,
0.3135453760623932,
0.2585306167602539,
-0.930718719959259,
-0.20876285433769226,
0.4358036518096924,
-0.011731613427400589,
0.3747676610946655,
0.21186847984790802,
-0.24017278850078583,
0.12443337589502335,
0.010932586155831814,
0.20425160229206085,
0.13719752430915833,
-0.3840816617012024,
-0.5188916921615601,
0.3704751431941986,
-0.40448853373527527,
0.038196321576833725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10770v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10770v3 | How Reliable Are Automatic Evaluation Methods for Instruction-Tuned LLMs? | 2024-02-16T15:48:33 | 2024-07-02T11:46:09 | Ehsan Doostmohammadi, Oskar Holmström, Marco Kuhlmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Work on instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) has used automatic
methods based on text overlap and LLM judgments as cost-effective alternatives
to human evaluation. In this paper, we perform a meta-evaluation of such
methods and assess their reliability across a broad range of tasks. We observe
that while automatic evaluation methods can approximate human ratings under
specific conditions, their validity is highly context-dependent. Specifically,
the simple ROUGE-L metric correlates well with human ratings for short-answer
English tasks but is unreliable in free-form generation tasks and cross-lingual
transfer. The effectiveness of the more advanced method of using GPT-4 as a
judge diminishes significantly if reference answers are not included in the
prompt, which is the scenario where this method has the potential to provide
the most value compared to other metrics. Our findings enhance the
understanding of how automatic methods should be applied and interpreted when
developing and evaluating instruction-tuned LLMs. | [
-0.23076437413692474,
-0.7056407928466797,
0.8134483695030212,
0.2943059802055359,
-0.1800507754087448,
0.109641432762146,
-0.4361385107040405,
-0.4694386124610901,
-0.15474659204483032,
0.11129529029130936,
-0.3716701865196228,
-0.33948400616645813,
-0.5946062207221985,
0.39495325088500977,
-0.42897549271583557,
0.8639911413192749,
-0.26810160279273987,
0.16642068326473236,
-0.3792858123779297,
-0.06371143460273743,
-0.5178187489509583,
-0.32857826352119446,
-0.4572179317474365,
-0.28370484709739685,
0.36157697439193726,
0.5256917476654053,
0.6844858527183533,
0.8421173095703125,
0.5796035528182983,
0.3814581632614136,
0.16441695392131805,
0.4710512161254883,
-0.18700845539569855,
-0.07484624534845352,
-0.17372263967990875,
-0.29055410623550415,
-0.6060563325881958,
0.34078219532966614,
0.6411276459693909,
0.553749144077301,
-0.15670636296272278,
0.27996763586997986,
0.5092161893844604,
0.576391875743866,
-0.7935868501663208,
0.08304925262928009,
-0.5984718203544617,
-0.06028233468532562,
-0.10791303217411041,
-0.187127947807312,
-0.5228472352027893,
-0.4346560835838318,
0.18078160285949707,
-0.357219934463501,
-0.0055734580382704735,
-0.23574991524219513,
0.6553720235824585,
0.54915851354599,
-0.5805701613426208,
-0.5859402418136597,
-0.8813244104385376,
0.7340003848075867,
-0.562101423740387,
0.2664875388145447,
0.6420852541923523,
0.46190428733825684,
-0.03132878616452217,
-0.6441448926925659,
-0.31907588243484497,
-0.5663487315177917,
-0.3887077271938324,
0.22503891587257385,
-0.026502151042222977,
0.16588641703128815,
0.37428349256515503,
0.2464832067489624,
-0.38195738196372986,
0.1880238950252533,
-0.24837841093540192,
-0.31662455201148987,
0.6047848463058472,
0.3335409164428711,
0.41429004073143005,
-0.36417317390441895,
-0.25936129689216614,
0.16443030536174774,
-0.6513993740081787,
0.02898462675511837,
0.6348497271537781,
-0.004771263338625431,
0.098060242831707,
0.4777728319168091,
-0.08291852474212646,
1.0409133434295654,
0.2769796848297119,
-0.23635321855545044,
0.016557777300477028,
-0.5092334747314453,
-0.12994322180747986,
-0.39778149127960205,
0.7877377867698669,
0.5007610321044922,
0.4022221863269806,
-0.4620097875595093,
-0.389841228723526,
-0.15793552994728088,
0.40154948830604553,
-0.5627233982086182,
-0.041302863508462906,
-0.02825036644935608,
-0.004364009015262127,
-0.007558876182883978,
0.20502270758152008,
-0.5641950964927673,
0.17968231439590454,
-0.39608684182167053,
0.6678491830825806,
-0.15412889420986176,
0.3410601019859314,
-0.1965629756450653,
0.02597751095890999,
0.1933126449584961,
0.38157400488853455,
-0.885426938533783,
0.38701048493385315,
0.49006375670433044,
0.7437365055084229,
-0.5459946393966675,
-0.5136508941650391,
-0.9815989136695862,
-0.09414385259151459,
-0.31667792797088623,
0.818761944770813,
-0.5449702143669128,
-0.3441276252269745,
-0.14902234077453613,
0.39264044165611267,
-0.3521566390991211,
-0.5764053463935852,
0.6663708090782166,
-0.5320330858230591,
0.3431030809879303,
-0.2184024602174759,
-0.7479478120803833,
0.0922737643122673,
0.11297476291656494,
-0.8030178546905518,
0.9002494812011719,
0.22414731979370117,
-0.47121500968933105,
0.33328622579574585,
-0.37204059958457947,
-0.5726114511489868,
-0.06439138203859329,
0.027279110625386238,
-0.28869494795799255,
-0.05322515219449997,
0.18035872280597687,
0.2832965552806854,
-0.24252921342849731,
0.1733415573835373,
-0.09771121293306351,
-0.8467937707901001,
0.27864721417427063,
-0.9839746356010437,
0.482021689414978,
-0.12683703005313873,
-0.7764535546302795,
-0.025552010163664818,
-0.6864066123962402,
0.4101339876651764,
-0.2565552294254303,
-0.5224062204360962,
-0.16990870237350464,
-0.04747981205582619,
-0.23723246157169342,
0.04158792644739151,
0.2650304138660431,
-0.1628803014755249,
0.041394494473934174,
-0.27793484926223755,
0.2548151910305023,
0.8188154697418213,
-0.04222767800092697,
0.4242309629917145,
-0.33784008026123047,
0.7251729965209961,
-0.46297749876976013,
0.06697386503219604,
-0.2278285026550293,
-0.4051609933376312,
-0.762703537940979,
-0.14788086712360382,
0.4286045730113983,
0.758389413356781,
-0.5195459127426147,
0.6127279996871948,
-0.08447368443012238,
-0.4871818423271179,
-0.42499929666519165,
0.37537840008735657,
0.5870386362075806,
0.3722088038921356,
0.510664165019989,
-0.20670512318611145,
-0.3189283013343811,
-0.8432053327560425,
-0.5984131097793579,
0.05331283062696457,
-0.11148300021886826,
0.374122679233551,
0.4558500349521637,
-0.35296550393104553,
0.9412192702293396,
-0.11609659343957901,
0.3264628052711487,
0.03369979187846184,
0.1966516077518463,
0.07250267267227173,
0.1022067442536354,
0.3499106168746948,
-0.2081838846206665,
-0.823561429977417,
-0.3092976212501526,
-0.5530189275741577,
-0.454296737909317,
-0.02357328310608864,
0.08164242655038834,
0.5414588451385498,
0.21051669120788574,
-0.5489732027053833,
0.5201444625854492,
0.6292775273323059,
-0.12409481406211853,
0.8195460438728333,
-0.3090728223323822,
0.4390081465244293,
-0.5799806118011475,
0.05065454542636871,
-0.02272649109363556,
-0.4084281027317047,
-0.38732829689979553,
-0.08771853148937225,
0.2699194848537445,
0.3498495817184448,
-0.33700838685035706,
0.844340443611145,
-0.5410371422767639,
-0.28077107667922974,
-0.5020291209220886,
0.43158817291259766,
-0.03495918586850166,
0.22692754864692688,
-0.2744600474834442,
1.0433439016342163,
0.20716580748558044,
-0.6618496775627136,
0.48131105303764343,
-0.23250947892665863,
-0.6500641107559204,
0.6862727403640747,
-0.7210114598274231,
0.5011870265007019,
0.29305118322372437,
0.3660927712917328,
-0.9031129479408264,
-0.31450557708740234,
0.2925410568714142,
-0.041019830852746964,
0.30923768877983093,
-0.1422223448753357,
-0.4189291298389435,
-0.274177610874176,
-0.21654926240444183,
0.3481561541557312,
0.4626864492893219,
-0.6829807162284851,
0.30595487356185913,
0.030230583623051643,
-0.025267895311117172,
-0.7830111384391785,
-0.46985623240470886,
0.07957344502210617,
-0.16412797570228577,
-0.43108195066452026,
0.2511988878250122,
-0.19766908884048462,
-0.368008017539978,
0.057119518518447876,
-0.44022229313850403,
-0.05258077010512352,
0.1523699164390564,
0.12003235518932343,
0.1673731654882431,
-0.06722652167081833,
0.075228750705719,
0.03880728408694267,
-0.1434977948665619,
0.08166824281215668,
-0.04726957902312279,
0.20545260608196259,
-0.3086547553539276,
-0.7773415446281433,
-0.43489736318588257,
0.031426381319761276,
0.5736793875694275,
0.06228404864668846,
0.3801631033420563,
0.5568181276321411,
-0.16304470598697662,
-0.2735758423805237,
-0.5736556649208069,
-0.15766622126102448,
-0.48264870047569275,
0.3442319333553314,
-0.16904503107070923,
-0.642346978187561,
0.2788059115409851,
0.12811541557312012,
0.14863446354866028,
0.5085412859916687,
0.4455937147140503,
-0.25028127431869507,
0.8730385303497314,
0.317213237285614,
0.031745754182338715,
0.10794893652200699,
0.05821602791547775,
-0.14411449432373047,
-0.8027923703193665,
0.08782386779785156,
-0.39820027351379395,
-0.3273981511592865,
-0.4448164701461792,
-0.493325412273407,
0.3847370743751526,
0.09506464749574661,
-0.12801389396190643,
0.29555556178092957,
-0.2567515969276428,
0.7306221127510071,
0.34170597791671753,
0.05185535177588463,
0.5160769820213318,
-0.11431573331356049,
-0.08231862634420395,
-0.023247700184583664,
-0.5868104696273804,
-0.8569884300231934,
1.079440951347351,
0.27921879291534424,
0.7496311664581299,
-0.01857028156518936,
0.5138658285140991,
0.3699856400489807,
0.6316379904747009,
-0.9190793633460999,
0.6022040247917175,
-0.19778798520565033,
-0.462404727935791,
-0.6256289482116699,
-0.4548127353191376,
-0.8265451192855835,
0.2427973449230194,
0.07236713916063309,
-0.6246469020843506,
-0.34739965200424194,
0.16842320561408997,
-0.2840628921985626,
0.11450943350791931,
-0.757724940776825,
0.6833337545394897,
-0.7331541776657104,
-0.5320819616317749,
-0.19638176262378693,
-0.47868579626083374,
0.3066965937614441,
-0.347141295671463,
0.15886303782463074,
0.12012246996164322,
-0.22336821258068085,
0.7996115684509277,
-0.49973437190055847,
0.8638775944709778,
0.0347534604370594,
-0.33774423599243164,
0.32806289196014404,
-0.072626031935215,
0.521639347076416,
-0.05830968916416168,
-0.095665842294693,
0.1208556517958641,
-0.030501702800393105,
-0.21455998718738556,
-1.0009429454803467,
0.585477888584137,
-0.714462161064148,
-0.828437089920044,
-0.36601245403289795,
-0.39408206939697266,
-0.41123610734939575,
0.12458189576864243,
0.3397374451160431,
0.49398288130760193,
-0.16651223599910736,
0.056279100477695465,
0.21195633709430695,
-0.1536891907453537,
0.445467084646225,
0.6856266260147095,
0.15321439504623413,
-0.5588299036026001,
0.6553324460983276,
0.2542080581188202,
0.49186035990715027,
0.24629874527454376,
0.2524755895137787,
-0.17295558750629425,
-0.1604127287864685,
-0.8327210545539856,
0.087284617125988,
-0.9541462659835815,
-0.17292307317256927,
-0.2838541269302368,
-0.26668673753738403,
0.11884880065917969,
-0.0664464458823204,
-0.31414875388145447,
-0.38191646337509155,
-0.11149613559246063,
-0.17393328249454498,
0.006520239170640707,
0.9540792107582092,
0.0015006386674940586,
0.14843890070915222,
-0.9632576107978821,
0.17989034950733185,
0.6586721539497375,
0.3785597085952759,
-0.04703463613986969,
-0.814162015914917,
-0.4679430425167084,
0.186471626162529,
-0.24345603585243225,
-0.8962321281433105,
-0.20866142213344574,
0.27384546399116516,
0.8487591743469238,
0.17960599064826965,
-0.13170631229877472,
0.5995689630508423,
-0.7974292039871216,
0.68937748670578,
-0.3303541839122772,
-1.0956709384918213,
0.2626221776008606,
-0.09351839870214462,
0.40937507152557373,
0.5740915536880493,
0.42131921648979187,
-0.2374892234802246,
-0.5570825934410095,
-0.34659481048583984,
-0.7566750049591064,
0.6423020958900452,
0.03942800685763359,
0.0752226933836937,
-0.14087606966495514,
0.5844960808753967,
0.15878376364707947,
-0.023332897573709488,
-0.6560729742050171,
-0.23974841833114624,
0.040226880460977554,
-0.18452110886573792,
-0.12555170059204102,
-0.21724829077720642,
-0.05342704802751541,
-0.324256956577301,
0.5466945767402649,
-0.16026045382022858,
0.09416548162698746,
-0.14026713371276855,
-0.32686764001846313,
-0.2799980640411377,
0.4389340281486511,
0.8331722021102905,
0.9988433718681335,
-0.08134598284959793,
0.09497004747390747,
0.4969283938407898,
-0.42883753776550293,
0.4735944867134094,
-0.14759626984596252,
-0.13686199486255646,
0.16995257139205933,
0.7209280729293823,
0.8017127513885498,
0.5084613561630249,
-0.529163658618927,
0.5163635015487671,
-0.013897615484893322,
-0.1598893702030182,
-0.18169176578521729,
0.33322107791900635,
-0.08697681128978729,
0.11225701868534088,
0.09231836348772049,
0.00884306337684393,
0.0634009912610054,
-0.5238087773323059,
0.44174253940582275,
0.6013827323913574,
-0.370121568441391,
-0.2958039939403534,
0.39367642998695374,
0.39677801728248596,
-0.48924341797828674,
0.5955043435096741,
-0.152488574385643,
-0.6063327789306641,
0.6473545432090759,
0.42865872383117676,
1.1037442684173584,
-0.31755977869033813,
0.2203235924243927,
0.3320647180080414,
0.6423501372337341,
-0.29312679171562195,
-0.159505233168602,
-0.1401677429676056,
-0.47199133038520813,
-0.7838062644004822,
-0.5078200101852417,
-0.7377047538757324,
0.09325216710567474,
-0.5942168235778809,
0.31562355160713196,
-0.0639648586511612,
-0.36508044600486755,
-0.5689958333969116,
-0.05240505561232567,
-0.6839737892150879,
0.21475501358509064,
-0.10552970319986343,
0.873880922794342,
-0.8771314024925232,
0.6895063519477844,
0.6458346247673035,
0.019539622589945793,
-0.9988266825675964,
0.5105786919593811,
-0.09250809997320175,
-0.749362051486969,
0.6888707876205444,
0.30196112394332886,
-0.6798394322395325,
-0.306328684091568,
-0.10887285321950912,
-0.8579535484313965,
1.0348740816116333,
0.41930893063545227,
-0.7300058603286743,
-0.08909383416175842,
0.04492177441716194,
0.7112790942192078,
-0.1528942734003067,
0.7840964794158936,
0.8028963804244995,
0.800022542476654,
0.06502406299114227,
-1.371989369392395,
0.09940598905086517,
-0.07675743103027344,
-0.39267271757125854,
-0.022861652076244354,
-0.6011521220207214,
0.43216264247894287,
-0.321147084236145,
-0.26404017210006714,
0.1882728934288025,
0.23810884356498718,
0.06830930709838867,
0.2711842656135559,
0.8196107149124146,
0.3933168649673462,
0.8953244090080261,
-0.04127679020166397,
0.9496989846229553,
-0.5678707361221313,
0.4330118000507355,
1.078913688659668,
-0.23667331039905548,
0.6656243205070496,
0.09729763865470886,
-0.27366212010383606,
0.5476203560829163,
0.5433788299560547,
-0.048397064208984375,
0.3160640299320221,
0.18239113688468933,
-0.034501757472753525,
-0.18719781935214996,
0.5376027226448059,
-0.06527773290872574,
0.4848908483982086,
0.12991763651371002,
-0.25137490034103394,
-0.12340889126062393,
-0.21107128262519836,
-0.08157423138618469,
-0.07653727382421494,
-0.11527480185031891,
0.7270199656486511,
0.0758739709854126,
-1.0614882707595825,
0.7904480695724487,
0.04057200625538826,
0.5401939749717712,
-0.4241592288017273,
-0.010566342622041702,
-0.3023906350135803,
0.016266480088233948,
-0.32199618220329285,
-0.6640637516975403,
0.2923069894313812,
0.3037501871585846,
-0.08955557644367218,
-0.1631752997636795,
0.5480201840400696,
-0.4334928095340729,
-0.34407955408096313,
0.1927081197500229,
0.6612499356269836,
0.1360270082950592,
0.3645641803741455,
-0.4572333097457886,
-0.20509763062000275,
-0.1613900512456894,
-0.3415990173816681,
0.19388744235038757,
0.2697955071926117,
-0.026582444086670876,
0.5783872008323669,
0.11670150607824326,
0.07035531103610992,
-0.1332622766494751,
-0.02400490641593933,
0.4137822687625885,
-0.5876566767692566,
-0.15341129899024963,
-1.1679397821426392,
0.4779214560985565,
0.04152102768421173,
-0.08484384417533875,
0.9646966457366943,
0.38267138600349426,
0.7639604806900024,
0.05762407183647156,
0.9297330379486084,
0.3350087106227875,
0.3411327302455902,
-0.809005618095398,
0.5259440541267395,
-0.5615076422691345,
0.5864437818527222,
-0.3892313838005066,
-1.2278590202331543,
0.04469183832406998,
0.577669620513916,
-0.4986326992511749,
0.49023762345314026,
1.0426812171936035,
0.4794996678829193,
-0.17066290974617004,
-0.14389406144618988,
0.24858126044273376,
-0.10819317400455475,
0.1141524687409401,
0.38041946291923523,
1.0640685558319092,
-0.2276677042245865,
0.594892144203186,
-0.10400646924972534,
-0.44641372561454773,
-0.2793881595134735,
-0.9390947222709656,
-0.8599749207496643,
-0.2327129989862442,
-0.1602572500705719,
-0.19107146561145782,
0.13219106197357178,
0.759897768497467,
0.539164662361145,
-0.5713493227958679,
-0.3333262801170349,
0.24163872003555298,
0.3440248668193817,
-0.24540096521377563,
-0.22629375755786896,
0.5122731328010559,
-0.6639034748077393,
-0.9032504558563232,
0.5568845868110657,
0.36763685941696167,
-0.21371901035308838,
-0.42768341302871704,
-0.15853917598724365,
0.3681305944919586,
0.22804048657417297,
0.5146270394325256,
0.1309492439031601,
-0.7954907417297363,
-0.5782748460769653,
0.1852741837501526,
-0.4302566349506378,
-0.16941705346107483,
0.7385590672492981,
-0.5664461255073547,
0.33740073442459106,
0.2989982068538666,
0.7477604150772095,
0.07228226959705353,
0.375764936208725,
0.7149154543876648,
-0.5298573970794678,
-0.3002754747867584,
0.035165559500455856,
0.29710713028907776,
0.323164701461792,
-0.15120601654052734,
0.5488901138305664,
0.2581988573074341,
-0.888085126876831,
-0.6010847091674805,
0.15025387704372406,
-0.5148671269416809,
0.03961482644081116,
1.4314119815826416,
-0.24364149570465088,
-0.019051993265748024,
-0.052640125155448914,
0.04178289324045181,
-0.0016688616015017033,
-0.05523623153567314,
0.8635214567184448,
1.0023717880249023,
-0.3925182521343231,
-0.012835001572966576,
-0.7375615239143372,
0.5319597721099854,
0.4560840427875519,
-0.8989232778549194,
-0.05557401478290558,
0.5072791576385498,
0.4802691340446472,
0.09082405269145966,
0.538740336894989,
0.11365001648664474,
0.48742708563804626,
-0.433976411819458,
-0.3466317355632782,
0.02353169023990631,
-0.5111663937568665,
-0.31129229068756104,
-0.1896694451570511,
0.1916448026895523,
-0.010718677192926407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10769v1 | Distillation Enhanced Generative Retrieval | 2024-02-16T15:48:24 | 2024-02-16T15:48:24 | Yongqi Li, Zhen Zhang, Wenjie Wang, Liqiang Nie, Wenjie Li, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Generative retrieval is a promising new paradigm in text retrieval that
generates identifier strings of relevant passages as the retrieval target. This
paradigm leverages powerful generative language models, distinct from
traditional sparse or dense retrieval methods. In this work, we identify a
viable direction to further enhance generative retrieval via distillation and
propose a feasible framework, named DGR. DGR utilizes sophisticated ranking
models, such as the cross-encoder, in a teacher role to supply a passage rank
list, which captures the varying relevance degrees of passages instead of
binary hard labels; subsequently, DGR employs a specially designed distilled
RankNet loss to optimize the generative retrieval model, considering the
passage rank order provided by the teacher model as labels. This framework only
requires an additional distillation step to enhance current generative
retrieval systems and does not add any burden to the inference stage. We
conduct experiments on four public datasets, and the results indicate that DGR
achieves state-of-the-art performance among the generative retrieval methods.
Additionally, DGR demonstrates exceptional robustness and generalizability with
various teacher models and distillation losses. | [
-0.18926116824150085,
-0.573164165019989,
0.7331451177597046,
0.022753335535526276,
-0.3800874650478363,
0.3922654390335083,
-0.15504910051822662,
0.018605578690767288,
-0.144602969288826,
0.3105447292327881,
0.01146252453327179,
-0.44294920563697815,
-1.0427632331848145,
0.3336052894592285,
-0.8310950398445129,
1.100174069404602,
0.24336093664169312,
0.05068781599402428,
-0.34789207577705383,
0.28716379404067993,
-0.2746480405330658,
-0.5728796124458313,
-0.5186088681221008,
-0.5247195959091187,
0.5642837285995483,
0.046200551092624664,
0.5285965800285339,
0.5469359159469604,
0.6753243803977966,
0.31580448150634766,
-0.6618732213973999,
-0.11034298688173294,
-0.8515083193778992,
0.41635948419570923,
-0.10614493489265442,
-0.5261769890785217,
-0.2933938205242157,
0.04660295695066452,
0.6284123063087463,
0.7042791247367859,
-0.5195723176002502,
-0.15174159407615662,
0.4502164423465729,
0.8770145177841187,
-0.6332018971443176,
0.10898461192846298,
-0.9134227633476257,
0.12921227514743805,
-0.360460489988327,
-0.18390709161758423,
-0.5314556360244751,
-0.5749251842498779,
0.2448377013206482,
-0.3798881471157074,
0.42987921833992004,
-0.20067088305950165,
0.45152029395103455,
0.37116163969039917,
-0.4559009075164795,
-0.23141752183437347,
-0.7436359524726868,
0.501182496547699,
-0.46166834235191345,
0.2706344425678253,
0.4123916029930115,
0.6438890099525452,
-0.13889634609222412,
-1.2676056623458862,
-0.605003833770752,
-0.1871948540210724,
-0.2215694785118103,
0.3329116404056549,
-0.07223887741565704,
0.2425113022327423,
0.14764806628227234,
0.9754828214645386,
-0.3850789964199066,
-0.22504492104053497,
-0.2677406966686249,
0.29502400755882263,
0.5028415322303772,
0.0582304410636425,
-0.030745074152946472,
-0.14096146821975708,
-0.5158027410507202,
-0.25513920187950134,
-0.417837917804718,
-0.2816591262817383,
0.4183908998966217,
0.3144248425960541,
0.42826223373413086,
0.3054368197917938,
-0.18478049337863922,
0.9456854462623596,
0.3056686520576477,
-0.11548768728971481,
0.09177899360656738,
-0.3752991855144501,
-0.055931445211172104,
0.22788026928901672,
0.4521920382976532,
0.1764879822731018,
-0.20072771608829498,
-0.15867750346660614,
-0.35905736684799194,
-0.3898616433143616,
0.3303695023059845,
-1.0422425270080566,
-0.5804411172866821,
-0.21918368339538574,
-0.5751431584358215,
-0.5811887979507446,
0.23227456212043762,
-0.9456163644790649,
-0.4268464148044586,
-0.29857081174850464,
0.46274033188819885,
-0.24001356959342957,
-0.2996654808521271,
0.044801048934459686,
-0.5836299061775208,
-0.165420800447464,
0.3767679035663605,
-1.2140864133834839,
0.25410589575767517,
0.6583000421524048,
1.0030488967895508,
-0.3639620840549469,
0.14201681315898895,
-0.32209834456443787,
0.093382328748703,
-0.03451767563819885,
0.36036625504493713,
-0.9221605062484741,
-0.6255881786346436,
-0.27302631735801697,
-0.24955053627490997,
0.07109129428863525,
-0.739176869392395,
0.5242268443107605,
-0.7700682878494263,
0.03385922685265541,
-0.2343090921640396,
-0.48869526386260986,
-0.1761607974767685,
0.10573584586381912,
-0.9033496379852295,
1.2282267808914185,
0.10546936094760895,
-0.7264788150787354,
0.4340759217739105,
-0.22090405225753784,
-0.2583566904067993,
0.42184513807296753,
-0.2522468864917755,
-0.26859983801841736,
0.23975177109241486,
0.17617328464984894,
0.23623774945735931,
-0.4392177164554596,
0.599439263343811,
0.02202645130455494,
-0.6121670603752136,
-0.11476139724254608,
-0.8466606736183167,
0.637134850025177,
0.39185830950737,
-0.2393902838230133,
-0.498304158449173,
-0.640877366065979,
-0.06393168121576309,
-0.06215343996882439,
-0.850293755531311,
-0.7552415728569031,
0.022315287962555885,
0.0577608086168766,
-0.11680500209331512,
0.15127849578857422,
-0.6030369400978088,
0.50493985414505,
-0.012093123979866505,
0.40299898386001587,
0.5482866168022156,
-0.002944850828498602,
0.4416361451148987,
-0.043880119919776917,
0.4713502824306488,
-0.019379300996661186,
0.04899038374423981,
0.12533099949359894,
-0.5525710582733154,
-0.43888840079307556,
-0.4244990646839142,
0.6544436812400818,
0.2522377073764801,
-1.0569840669631958,
0.39139464497566223,
-0.48526886105537415,
-0.40980908274650574,
-0.7086110711097717,
0.06176179647445679,
0.40168991684913635,
0.5743228793144226,
0.5471289157867432,
-0.11380700021982193,
-0.41184133291244507,
-0.47765058279037476,
-0.04261375963687897,
-0.25396814942359924,
-0.1298864185810089,
0.05422673746943474,
0.3453165888786316,
0.03402680158615112,
0.9252249002456665,
-0.924862802028656,
-0.25626277923583984,
-0.4274021089076996,
0.1746179163455963,
0.402323454618454,
0.2892872989177704,
0.6448391079902649,
-1.2568950653076172,
-0.7615455985069275,
0.018540579825639725,
-0.5015923976898193,
0.004993794020265341,
0.1889168918132782,
-0.3109922409057617,
-0.3754921853542328,
0.42089200019836426,
-0.11222701519727707,
0.35589489340782166,
0.4430350959300995,
-0.08522450923919678,
0.0013376700226217508,
-0.3473317325115204,
0.3544045686721802,
-1.102281928062439,
0.1685093194246292,
-0.23303841054439545,
-0.14548160135746002,
-0.5626905560493469,
-0.0731496587395668,
0.0036715054884552956,
-0.13716188073158264,
-0.0919385775923729,
0.16718590259552002,
-0.42075425386428833,
0.22447648644447327,
-0.39766618609428406,
0.023912915959954262,
0.3729638457298279,
0.06830157339572906,
0.014788211323320866,
0.861442506313324,
0.46500417590141296,
-0.6025509834289551,
0.4249487817287445,
0.4315549433231354,
-0.33217093348503113,
0.48087871074676514,
-0.7417397499084473,
0.07738210260868073,
-0.6947264671325684,
0.4222832918167114,
-1.0576422214508057,
0.15483251214027405,
-0.02062566764652729,
-0.27837225794792175,
0.7082544565200806,
-0.46645551919937134,
-0.3473663330078125,
-0.3258616626262665,
-0.14748671650886536,
0.33511337637901306,
0.688552737236023,
-0.8638611435890198,
0.28134867548942566,
0.2419758141040802,
-0.21953213214874268,
-0.6146509051322937,
-0.6694599986076355,
0.28537434339523315,
-0.26307764649391174,
-0.008137835189700127,
0.8729124069213867,
0.10349425673484802,
-0.02330564521253109,
-0.0742378681898117,
-0.20844370126724243,
-0.13699518144130707,
0.18162429332733154,
-0.17664404213428497,
0.09933288395404816,
0.206255704164505,
0.28265178203582764,
0.22767513990402222,
-0.15206843614578247,
-0.36046847701072693,
-0.35140180587768555,
0.31887200474739075,
0.3247511684894562,
-0.1820220947265625,
-0.010689627379179,
0.49704521894454956,
0.37966522574424744,
-0.2360430508852005,
0.6523152589797974,
0.3794008195400238,
-0.2044256627559662,
-0.23264694213867188,
-0.3466697633266449,
-0.27718237042427063,
-0.5179254412651062,
0.34667304158210754,
-0.506616473197937,
-0.6822914481163025,
0.27207428216934204,
-0.054533593356609344,
-0.25809863209724426,
0.26777997612953186,
0.29236751794815063,
-0.003997079096734524,
0.9651097655296326,
0.5722525715827942,
-0.07322970777750015,
0.6449970602989197,
-0.3645593225955963,
0.1404232680797577,
-0.8025379776954651,
-0.5243463516235352,
-0.5836958885192871,
-0.44917523860931396,
-0.6630372405052185,
-0.41954556107521057,
0.6085906028747559,
0.4166449010372162,
0.25497210025787354,
0.34270745515823364,
-0.9956790208816528,
0.5259690284729004,
0.5672508478164673,
0.26644331216812134,
0.6541851758956909,
0.22209706902503967,
-0.34976133704185486,
-0.0009468995267525315,
-0.7000914216041565,
-0.5556527972221375,
1.0094345808029175,
0.10386978089809418,
1.0661437511444092,
0.3560401201248169,
1.1249537467956543,
0.33528420329093933,
0.3646478056907654,
-0.49943095445632935,
0.4165548086166382,
-0.5209853053092957,
-0.8040066957473755,
-0.3373833894729614,
-0.5394546389579773,
-0.9924509525299072,
0.7128129005432129,
0.08681245148181915,
-0.3933198153972626,
0.26539263129234314,
0.04463821277022362,
-0.22617925703525543,
0.15907904505729675,
-0.5319122076034546,
0.6785227656364441,
-0.2603871524333954,
-0.23737798631191254,
-0.03462105616927147,
-0.5148165225982666,
0.09114738553762436,
0.06259716302156448,
-0.4397833049297333,
0.1337158977985382,
0.03163985162973404,
0.4164882004261017,
-0.432498961687088,
0.5834358334541321,
-0.44525444507598877,
-0.20042207837104797,
0.4017007648944855,
-0.253786563873291,
0.4139101505279541,
0.11318996548652649,
-0.46454304456710815,
-0.013330941088497639,
-0.10867497324943542,
-0.1185419112443924,
-0.8440077304840088,
0.8150209784507751,
-0.42757055163383484,
-0.8783944249153137,
-0.5321863889694214,
0.007329144980758429,
0.11446093767881393,
0.14929138123989105,
0.3248395621776581,
0.28297969698905945,
-0.15465837717056274,
0.4951489567756653,
0.8009696006774902,
-0.01940324530005455,
0.5011446475982666,
0.2895691990852356,
-0.09808000177145004,
-0.3836923837661743,
0.8826113939285278,
0.22605516016483307,
0.3165977895259857,
0.7846574187278748,
0.19801950454711914,
-0.6988470554351807,
-0.9056618809700012,
-0.6151041984558105,
-0.27437692880630493,
-0.7616914510726929,
-0.36988046765327454,
-0.6859936714172363,
-0.2909644842147827,
-0.3671818971633911,
0.33499953150749207,
-0.10251561552286148,
-0.33420661091804504,
-0.41251271963119507,
-0.35451218485832214,
0.6796940565109253,
0.6909668445587158,
0.17076198756694794,
-0.03385913372039795,
-0.8950580358505249,
0.26546189188957214,
0.4598301351070404,
0.47706443071365356,
0.31475186347961426,
-0.5868216753005981,
-0.04669782519340515,
-0.009368649683892727,
-0.500592827796936,
-0.9633804559707642,
0.3136895000934601,
0.5826519131660461,
0.8789292573928833,
0.16629526019096375,
0.32160240411758423,
0.7623209357261658,
-0.5571449995040894,
0.6550471782684326,
0.10976589471101761,
-0.6905479431152344,
0.6607267260551453,
-0.2429610937833786,
0.19734352827072144,
0.9878474473953247,
0.631488561630249,
-0.4004134237766266,
-0.236638605594635,
-0.11812993139028549,
-1.035910964012146,
0.4395723044872284,
0.460987389087677,
0.28757181763648987,
-0.32911357283592224,
0.5594195127487183,
0.4653867483139038,
0.4187776446342468,
-0.6130059361457825,
-0.404575377702713,
-0.3078625500202179,
-0.30393296480178833,
-0.1609274446964264,
-0.1861894130706787,
0.026863686740398407,
-0.4235696792602539,
0.39612773060798645,
-0.014291803352534771,
0.06471974402666092,
0.33230409026145935,
0.017097461968660355,
0.3665948510169983,
0.31390300393104553,
-0.0173447635024786,
0.43799182772636414,
-0.3220578134059906,
0.37327075004577637,
-0.05070291459560394,
-0.8483694791793823,
0.5167204141616821,
0.42384159564971924,
-0.439492791891098,
0.3151765763759613,
-0.00366665399633348,
0.6759883165359497,
0.025828935205936432,
-0.18914437294006348,
0.46718499064445496,
-0.06021812930703163,
-0.041417624801397324,
-0.08677884191274643,
0.12193667888641357,
-0.039634160697460175,
0.25910136103630066,
0.9188806414604187,
-0.43560734391212463,
0.7346011400222778,
-0.49581536650657654,
0.3914461135864258,
0.252249151468277,
-0.3088589012622833,
-0.11060188710689545,
0.8498975038528442,
0.4379306137561798,
0.09371001273393631,
0.7431187033653259,
-0.23776555061340332,
-0.44982025027275085,
0.389752060174942,
0.5654390454292297,
0.9108643531799316,
-0.11244411021471024,
0.37419813871383667,
0.49421969056129456,
-0.07820354402065277,
-0.40498924255371094,
0.1661788672208786,
-0.5131433010101318,
-0.22590327262878418,
-0.1515330821275711,
-0.9404574632644653,
-0.13723622262477875,
-0.09686188399791718,
-0.8974529504776001,
-0.006386505905538797,
0.037675946950912476,
-0.5202961564064026,
-0.07002566754817963,
-0.1575320065021515,
-0.3384237587451935,
0.08577309548854828,
0.15769578516483307,
0.6333461403846741,
-0.5187504887580872,
0.7988560199737549,
0.564933180809021,
-0.5287111401557922,
-0.3655509352684021,
0.24782077968120575,
-0.2382616400718689,
-0.27754196524620056,
1.01486337184906,
0.05129369720816612,
-0.04059676453471184,
0.3807418942451477,
-0.009388006292283535,
-0.9001163244247437,
1.535090684890747,
0.342623770236969,
-0.8614298701286316,
-0.16090553998947144,
0.007311608642339706,
0.7265480756759644,
-0.041031613945961,
0.46647006273269653,
0.502547025680542,
0.38610774278640747,
0.5387988686561584,
-0.875554084777832,
0.13006475567817688,
-0.2586977481842041,
0.6873031258583069,
0.3436222970485687,
-0.47144705057144165,
0.775368332862854,
-0.035655662417411804,
-0.425559401512146,
0.0422307550907135,
0.5066182017326355,
0.04588273540139198,
0.29490575194358826,
0.21718624234199524,
0.7161465287208557,
0.7207791805267334,
-0.3930705189704895,
1.0730340480804443,
-0.08294986188411713,
0.29784467816352844,
0.8967679738998413,
-0.18533141911029816,
0.8022207021713257,
0.601061224937439,
-0.4143812656402588,
0.37645673751831055,
0.39737552404403687,
-0.0025695175863802433,
1.1856456995010376,
0.44731372594833374,
-0.6830810308456421,
-0.09041190147399902,
-0.12017303705215454,
-0.6228170990943909,
0.41366106271743774,
0.07936714589595795,
-0.6973141431808472,
-0.34649187326431274,
0.14438697695732117,
-0.3685920238494873,
0.27998843789100647,
-0.1694248914718628,
0.9300615191459656,
0.1049492135643959,
-0.8365659713745117,
0.80326247215271,
-0.15963305532932281,
0.7721655368804932,
-0.3092092275619507,
-0.47188907861709595,
-0.33823493123054504,
0.2668728232383728,
-0.13011440634727478,
-0.6457288861274719,
0.07794797420501709,
0.05109220743179321,
-0.25186654925346375,
-0.6016098260879517,
0.5493470430374146,
-0.8580279350280762,
-0.43331801891326904,
0.2774750590324402,
0.3363524079322815,
0.11410735547542572,
0.03049382008612156,
-0.4733104705810547,
-0.12022937834262848,
-0.056898701936006546,
-0.2214355617761612,
0.4787198007106781,
0.4989786148071289,
0.2891198694705963,
0.33790141344070435,
0.3793262541294098,
-0.04265371710062027,
0.021974893286824226,
0.47632846236228943,
1.116664171218872,
-0.40238264203071594,
-0.3564474284648895,
-0.9317479133605957,
0.4827736020088196,
-0.3014548718929291,
0.024189719930291176,
0.8289300203323364,
0.5609045624732971,
0.8811612725257874,
-0.045725781470537186,
0.8580815196037292,
-0.19821175932884216,
0.24753957986831665,
-0.42533743381500244,
0.873113751411438,
-0.5012757778167725,
0.30118241906166077,
-0.28192976117134094,
-1.0328869819641113,
-0.03577231988310814,
0.5734955668449402,
-0.16328875720500946,
0.20932285487651825,
0.395073264837265,
0.7030696272850037,
0.0003408157208468765,
-0.2650764286518097,
0.37654364109039307,
-0.30561745166778564,
0.3748753070831299,
0.37590500712394714,
0.8778719902038574,
-0.5797694325447083,
0.718146562576294,
-0.025776630267500877,
-0.2586887776851654,
-0.3191893696784973,
-0.7626221776008606,
-0.7482964992523193,
-0.6988493204116821,
-0.2628536820411682,
-0.07016852498054504,
0.3629533350467682,
0.48840761184692383,
0.5649954080581665,
-0.5444584488868713,
0.21819433569908142,
-0.3410583436489105,
0.026085106655955315,
-0.29093611240386963,
-0.2508629560470581,
0.0969766154885292,
-0.32706940174102783,
-1.1465625762939453,
0.35071060061454773,
0.10626022517681122,
0.36040204763412476,
-0.24859747290611267,
-0.029089147225022316,
-0.2552894949913025,
-0.3518214225769043,
0.599614143371582,
-0.22778762876987457,
-0.5041062235832214,
-0.09481510519981384,
0.0005312895518727601,
-0.2837737500667572,
-0.026143865659832954,
0.8864215612411499,
-0.7397860288619995,
0.7429969906806946,
0.828765332698822,
0.6629554629325867,
0.7225235104560852,
0.37204697728157043,
0.6307578682899475,
-0.8093857765197754,
-0.04423724114894867,
0.5527750253677368,
0.04449253901839256,
0.34667715430259705,
-0.47617894411087036,
0.43307986855506897,
0.12935879826545715,
-0.3233017027378082,
-0.7979239225387573,
0.08950700610876083,
-0.5860199928283691,
-0.22798727452754974,
1.0463175773620605,
-0.33964332938194275,
0.2086976021528244,
-0.05165955424308777,
-0.1675301492214203,
0.3026401996612549,
-0.4470161199569702,
0.9874865412712097,
0.6416732668876648,
0.12761244177818298,
-0.06543132662773132,
-0.32941606640815735,
0.5979560613632202,
0.19310636818408966,
-0.5227696299552917,
-0.008436862379312515,
0.5512595176696777,
0.025546101853251457,
0.06317514181137085,
0.6004429459571838,
-0.4069758653640747,
-0.1658484786748886,
0.16674461960792542,
-0.2064206451177597,
-0.16793642938137054,
-0.4508765637874603,
-0.3755054175853729,
0.2296554148197174,
0.22248074412345886,
-0.3470616042613983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10767v1 | Inference to the Best Explanation in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T15:41:23 | 2024-02-16T15:41:23 | Dhairya Dalal, Marco Valentino, André Freitas, Paul Buitelaar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have found success in real-world
applications, their underlying explanatory process is still poorly understood.
This paper proposes IBE-Eval, a framework inspired by philosophical accounts on
Inference to the Best Explanation (IBE) to advance the interpretation and
evaluation of LLMs' explanations. IBE-Eval estimates the plausibility of
natural language explanations through a combination of explicit logical and
linguistic features including: consistency, parsimony, coherence, and
uncertainty. Extensive experiments are conducted on Causal Question Answering
(CQA), where \textit{IBE-Eval} is tasked to select the most plausible causal
explanation amongst competing ones generated by LLMs (i.e., GPT 3.5 and Llama
2). The experiments reveal that IBE-Eval can successfully identify the best
explanation with up to 77\% accuracy ($\approx 27\%$ above random), improving
upon a GPT 3.5-as-a-Judge baseline ($\approx+17\%$) while being intrinsically
more efficient and interpretable. Additional analyses suggest that, despite
model-specific variances, LLM-generated explanations tend to conform to IBE
criteria and that IBE-Eval is significantly correlated with human judgment,
opening up opportunities for future development of automated explanation
verification tools. | [
-0.495962530374527,
-0.921231746673584,
1.0353947877883911,
0.27599313855171204,
-0.0875902995467186,
-0.13272137939929962,
-0.42173194885253906,
-0.4613593518733978,
-0.18053801357746124,
0.23084349930286407,
-0.35871297121047974,
-0.36957696080207825,
-0.5901837348937988,
0.13813893496990204,
-0.549698531627655,
0.912234902381897,
-0.05207265540957451,
0.009173453785479069,
-0.2298363447189331,
0.14941534399986267,
-0.2619718015193939,
-0.13445870578289032,
-0.7386375069618225,
-0.5658518075942993,
0.6785612106323242,
0.15355953574180603,
0.7079464793205261,
0.6771764755249023,
0.3715881109237671,
0.241238534450531,
-0.12978945672512054,
0.05287785083055496,
-0.4724920094013214,
-0.1275993436574936,
-0.6949616074562073,
-0.614496111869812,
-0.19641703367233276,
-0.08759741485118866,
0.4966767728328705,
0.8399054408073425,
-0.27267518639564514,
-0.036378443241119385,
0.02325313352048397,
0.5223133563995361,
-0.6489631533622742,
0.07695671170949936,
-0.590971827507019,
-0.3089655637741089,
0.14312389492988586,
-0.08582039177417755,
-0.7041877508163452,
-0.5147950649261475,
0.14608468115329742,
-0.3788911700248718,
0.05617622658610344,
0.36466479301452637,
1.0232073068618774,
0.09917180240154266,
-0.5113341808319092,
-0.29399439692497253,
-0.9181081652641296,
0.7311075329780579,
-0.8657516837120056,
0.4466034770011902,
0.3201660215854645,
0.5187771320343018,
-0.27152130007743835,
-0.735930323600769,
-0.7858986258506775,
-0.35841354727745056,
-0.06562602519989014,
0.20879797637462616,
-0.23909905552864075,
0.34180155396461487,
0.17945997416973114,
0.34667351841926575,
-0.604572057723999,
0.3645663857460022,
-0.08550684154033661,
-0.16283400356769562,
0.751545250415802,
-0.07319045066833496,
0.299387127161026,
0.017709488049149513,
-0.5317605137825012,
0.1343364417552948,
-0.8854722380638123,
0.07539532333612442,
0.1311333030462265,
-0.2614167332649231,
0.004807449411600828,
0.42359215021133423,
-0.11165913939476013,
0.6437658667564392,
0.07953275740146637,
-0.02772424928843975,
-0.33507272601127625,
-0.039956122636795044,
-0.43359681963920593,
0.026090089231729507,
0.7969735264778137,
0.3082737326622009,
0.2479974925518036,
-0.26341891288757324,
-0.3221697211265564,
0.17576050758361816,
-0.07357128709554672,
-0.6621285080909729,
-0.07988986372947693,
0.4078443944454193,
-0.43355220556259155,
-0.12844716012477875,
0.02261214144527912,
-0.710858166217804,
-0.36830934882164,
-0.6342868208885193,
0.476654052734375,
-0.4226531982421875,
-0.1758425533771515,
0.15061257779598236,
0.00924603920429945,
0.3202373683452606,
0.38496387004852295,
-0.7986447215080261,
0.24138793349266052,
0.8333161473274231,
0.4916798174381256,
-0.049080733209848404,
-0.2772853672504425,
-0.5808243155479431,
0.19616132974624634,
-0.5645235776901245,
1.0640227794647217,
-0.694444477558136,
-0.0149003891274333,
-0.2465522140264511,
-0.2029641568660736,
-0.06966443359851837,
-0.4327252507209778,
0.7324454188346863,
-0.6253253817558289,
0.2618134021759033,
-0.23834197223186493,
-0.9051561951637268,
-0.5280650854110718,
-0.14148034155368805,
-0.33734050393104553,
0.8796693086624146,
-0.15426090359687805,
-0.41152751445770264,
0.3639281690120697,
-0.8493965864181519,
-0.14530466496944427,
-0.006702241022139788,
0.056350499391555786,
0.06409549713134766,
0.47550708055496216,
0.35122179985046387,
0.415193647146225,
-0.7495632767677307,
0.931725263595581,
-0.4282858669757843,
-0.18320076167583466,
0.5069838762283325,
-0.8958369493484497,
0.7982607483863831,
0.3931443691253662,
-0.3466537296772003,
-0.07057065516710281,
-0.6292427778244019,
-0.013526820577681065,
0.0809476375579834,
-0.040439121425151825,
-0.2993735373020172,
0.223656564950943,
-0.27481594681739807,
0.009941945783793926,
0.10378807783126831,
-0.47716280817985535,
-0.154374361038208,
-0.5597224235534668,
0.14553432166576385,
0.897284746170044,
0.04709172993898392,
0.3360360562801361,
-0.11784815043210983,
0.5447186231613159,
-0.3120609223842621,
0.12825219333171844,
-0.20390909910202026,
-0.2688053250312805,
-0.26141148805618286,
-0.4278121292591095,
0.17333678901195526,
0.43049943447113037,
-0.5408516526222229,
0.36149945855140686,
-0.22113381326198578,
-0.37940412759780884,
-0.44679564237594604,
0.18991507589817047,
0.5484352111816406,
0.5750162601470947,
0.13624736666679382,
0.11546051502227783,
-0.36723029613494873,
-1.1967012882232666,
-0.6339811086654663,
-0.5029170513153076,
-0.22904090583324432,
0.13364796340465546,
0.5675610899925232,
-0.13225200772285461,
1.1863653659820557,
-0.3254120647907257,
0.6008414626121521,
-0.43144237995147705,
0.25078901648521423,
0.3844720125198364,
0.11277006566524506,
0.4833211898803711,
-0.8629158735275269,
-0.4262513816356659,
0.04482061788439751,
-0.7100825309753418,
-0.6574549078941345,
-0.2568025588989258,
-0.3789636194705963,
-0.10496939718723297,
0.18706905841827393,
-0.35328638553619385,
0.2162408083677292,
0.44723865389823914,
-0.2752262055873871,
0.8019686937332153,
-0.16860239207744598,
0.024433858692646027,
-0.7911090850830078,
0.03685440123081207,
0.11756581813097,
-0.2677631676197052,
-0.6703968048095703,
0.2606676518917084,
0.045520324259996414,
0.24537065625190735,
-0.24318872392177582,
0.8821730017662048,
-0.34588971734046936,
0.03866588696837425,
-0.2890155613422394,
0.48226913809776306,
0.24841175973415375,
0.30158868432044983,
0.07828940451145172,
0.5435720086097717,
0.6677879691123962,
-0.5665631890296936,
0.3589128255844116,
0.01264798641204834,
-0.3590110242366791,
0.5705727338790894,
-0.5896422863006592,
-0.11786220222711563,
-0.40460866689682007,
0.31867921352386475,
-1.0977998971939087,
-0.5708147287368774,
-0.0235908143222332,
-0.3859289586544037,
0.19963926076889038,
0.05496234819293022,
-0.3175630271434784,
-0.40433186292648315,
-0.0810927301645279,
0.21281829476356506,
0.4257865250110626,
-0.9786362051963806,
0.7902002334594727,
0.11081622540950775,
-0.1453341245651245,
-0.5174853205680847,
-0.5423016548156738,
0.14390015602111816,
-0.35798004269599915,
-0.7061353921890259,
-0.08643762022256851,
-0.24910826981067657,
-0.7601227760314941,
-0.20152345299720764,
-0.21368950605392456,
-0.23279432952404022,
0.37054669857025146,
-0.03801238536834717,
0.367345929145813,
-0.5856302380561829,
0.17875909805297852,
0.14664913713932037,
-0.14201706647872925,
0.321236252784729,
-0.08909875899553299,
0.1994394212961197,
-0.27250105142593384,
-0.5146369934082031,
-0.5192699432373047,
0.3116724193096161,
0.5542070269584656,
-0.042821355164051056,
0.9606236219406128,
0.19123242795467377,
-0.32741937041282654,
-0.2250428944826126,
-0.700600802898407,
-0.22713463008403778,
-0.43594610691070557,
0.14562922716140747,
-0.3935530185699463,
-0.42390328645706177,
0.6595845222473145,
-0.14798428118228912,
0.08770755678415298,
0.46498268842697144,
0.5094642639160156,
0.02375844493508339,
1.206677794456482,
0.2467089593410492,
0.07918372005224228,
0.32674410939216614,
0.050714876502752304,
0.689419686794281,
-0.8770653605461121,
-0.11913561075925827,
-0.47045254707336426,
-0.04501895606517792,
-0.36444291472435,
-0.2637879252433777,
0.28919678926467896,
0.40919527411460876,
-0.22567404806613922,
-0.035633962601423264,
-0.15396495163440704,
0.8165476322174072,
0.32481229305267334,
-0.057209987193346024,
0.2934914827346802,
-0.16703134775161743,
-0.08639492094516754,
0.2718263268470764,
-0.48279958963394165,
-0.8791653513908386,
0.7396408319473267,
0.3961951434612274,
0.8748716115951538,
0.21081608533859253,
0.5277705192565918,
0.03310362622141838,
0.7314878106117249,
-0.5694600343704224,
0.5201238393783569,
0.2237645536661148,
-0.7953737378120422,
-0.2821798026561737,
-0.32596832513809204,
-0.8565835952758789,
0.5277429819107056,
-0.04257362708449364,
-1.1921182870864868,
0.04717155173420906,
0.3931327164173126,
-0.23275348544120789,
0.23917624354362488,
-0.9845668077468872,
0.8167043924331665,
-0.42776209115982056,
-0.6216106414794922,
-0.21817950904369354,
-0.5415511727333069,
0.6649985313415527,
-0.11514659970998764,
0.5288734436035156,
-0.059894587844610214,
0.029296405613422394,
0.46553024649620056,
-0.29866981506347656,
0.6409183144569397,
-0.23136506974697113,
-0.41383013129234314,
0.4025982916355133,
0.18216504156589508,
0.6737346053123474,
0.13341957330703735,
-0.339469850063324,
0.12191437929868698,
-0.07435661554336548,
-0.3631187975406647,
-0.9886723160743713,
0.5259434580802917,
-0.3978870213031769,
-0.817208468914032,
-0.12519752979278564,
-0.4565063416957855,
-0.21175867319107056,
-0.12401700764894485,
0.1559455543756485,
0.5911370515823364,
-0.08033209294080734,
0.24162541329860687,
0.652019739151001,
-0.5961858630180359,
0.314754456281662,
0.7817222476005554,
-0.4669209420681,
-0.08431444317102432,
0.8225258588790894,
-0.31782013177871704,
0.4614710211753845,
0.6951429843902588,
0.775202214717865,
-0.5839855074882507,
-0.6768378019332886,
-0.41118934750556946,
0.33485859632492065,
-0.7568766474723816,
0.09824267774820328,
-0.4863857626914978,
-0.010341227054595947,
-0.1022912934422493,
-0.39671599864959717,
-0.1910516321659088,
-0.13671229779720306,
0.08820222318172455,
-0.4265981614589691,
0.09932570904493332,
0.6916976571083069,
-0.20973286032676697,
0.41443878412246704,
-0.5508513450622559,
0.4122101366519928,
0.13415439426898956,
0.2698444128036499,
0.2281780242919922,
-0.5609996914863586,
-0.09504342079162598,
0.28529807925224304,
-0.0946052223443985,
-0.9504346251487732,
0.30890679359436035,
0.23032386600971222,
0.6368327736854553,
0.7906224727630615,
0.006229465827345848,
0.8335809707641602,
-0.40925562381744385,
0.8617373704910278,
0.2884823977947235,
-1.0877342224121094,
0.5801202654838562,
-0.32023224234580994,
0.10283093899488449,
0.20410069823265076,
0.21494992077350616,
-0.5833461880683899,
-0.8491608500480652,
-0.6375781297683716,
-0.9796032905578613,
0.4710555970668793,
0.15516023337841034,
-0.1629660278558731,
-0.21906082332134247,
0.4693019688129425,
0.5297791361808777,
-0.030627315863966942,
-0.9153941869735718,
0.07066549360752106,
0.3836202621459961,
-0.4454091191291809,
-0.012914502061903477,
-0.22610975801944733,
0.03729639947414398,
-0.028700824826955795,
0.8009831309318542,
-0.215690478682518,
0.419066458940506,
0.16031046211719513,
-0.2903500497341156,
-0.1092061772942543,
0.3649168908596039,
0.6147898435592651,
1.2292410135269165,
0.1831490695476532,
0.4019602835178375,
0.23562170565128326,
0.033118270337581635,
-0.06276477128267288,
-0.043664731085300446,
-0.017757127061486244,
-0.19028174877166748,
0.8664350509643555,
0.954788327217102,
0.06936647742986679,
-0.9112610220909119,
0.5050109624862671,
-0.02065637707710266,
0.0638769343495369,
-0.21623030304908752,
0.2006286233663559,
0.14827458560466766,
0.30152082443237305,
0.5294721722602844,
-0.2552933990955353,
0.26592332124710083,
-0.552739679813385,
0.06973466277122498,
0.5483423471450806,
0.11687225103378296,
-0.4930657148361206,
0.9135757088661194,
-0.06350991874933243,
-0.19401812553405762,
0.035694848746061325,
0.004155687987804413,
-0.5061448812484741,
0.7960047721862793,
0.5009449124336243,
0.7836688160896301,
-0.3834369480609894,
0.2460399717092514,
0.2740834355354309,
0.10247860103845596,
-0.23951110243797302,
0.1103692501783371,
0.07780782133340836,
-0.6595900058746338,
-0.8286132216453552,
-0.8270208239555359,
-0.4137151837348938,
0.07621578872203827,
-0.7811605334281921,
-0.0014996030367910862,
-0.012002716772258282,
0.4491194188594818,
0.2007198929786682,
-0.4319121539592743,
-0.562542736530304,
0.2414308786392212,
0.13372544944286346,
0.9585958123207092,
-1.052029013633728,
0.475324809551239,
0.3806694746017456,
-0.18314389884471893,
-1.062751293182373,
0.041716720908880234,
0.025890961289405823,
-1.0191928148269653,
0.7407336235046387,
0.0010564950061962008,
-0.14664362370967865,
-0.13178640604019165,
-0.8038214445114136,
-0.7889248132705688,
0.7706499695777893,
0.7688397765159607,
-0.7717638611793518,
0.2335767149925232,
-0.1355748474597931,
0.6797966361045837,
-0.21678391098976135,
0.6812851428985596,
0.6881544589996338,
0.7186734676361084,
0.10559741407632828,
-0.7981751561164856,
0.022426990792155266,
0.13231076300144196,
0.08604460209608078,
0.26697859168052673,
-0.4182032346725464,
0.20508016645908356,
-0.3157517910003662,
-0.09974505752325058,
0.09046101570129395,
0.6883172392845154,
0.07535384595394135,
0.581892192363739,
0.36275002360343933,
0.2878291606903076,
1.0524637699127197,
-0.15126816928386688,
1.5345638990402222,
-0.39552706480026245,
0.42639362812042236,
1.0293693542480469,
-0.21092760562896729,
0.7166057229042053,
0.49792495369911194,
-0.20302142202854156,
0.669057309627533,
0.8617693185806274,
0.4046155512332916,
0.4228307604789734,
0.13511373102664948,
-0.45268139243125916,
-0.3714563548564911,
-0.048884667456150055,
0.19179020822048187,
0.3654167056083679,
0.3062851130962372,
-0.5070276260375977,
-0.3111414909362793,
0.19460216164588928,
-0.004203531891107559,
0.04784118011593819,
-0.32342833280563354,
0.7223455309867859,
0.18766948580741882,
-0.9820073843002319,
0.5245705246925354,
-0.16418001055717468,
-0.026750676333904266,
-0.5720694065093994,
-0.01990833692252636,
-0.3393036127090454,
0.23425708711147308,
-0.07407576590776443,
-0.9527896046638489,
0.1003563180565834,
0.2496333122253418,
-0.022207111120224,
-0.30195459723472595,
0.6070859432220459,
-0.41795629262924194,
-0.35882169008255005,
0.3343535363674164,
0.48151856660842896,
0.4307113587856293,
0.09841445088386536,
-0.3836042881011963,
-0.16995465755462646,
0.05713718757033348,
-0.600408136844635,
0.16863255202770233,
0.687268078327179,
-0.1836566925048828,
0.9022862911224365,
0.51920086145401,
0.10919516533613205,
0.03672461211681366,
-0.03381606563925743,
0.5150653719902039,
-0.5495505332946777,
-0.41848787665367126,
-1.262215495109558,
0.5701972842216492,
0.05293601378798485,
0.05468400940299034,
0.4872819483280182,
0.5028496384620667,
0.41946741938591003,
0.09133627265691757,
0.8379616141319275,
-0.09625981748104095,
0.3464711308479309,
-0.7743760943412781,
0.19773831963539124,
-0.5509305000305176,
0.5121139883995056,
-0.05748722702264786,
-0.9837556481361389,
-0.17290174961090088,
0.7520198822021484,
-0.5745177865028381,
-0.061749111860990524,
0.9793335199356079,
0.7501720786094666,
-0.22260107100009918,
0.314050555229187,
0.34394311904907227,
0.71959388256073,
0.530989944934845,
0.552322268486023,
0.9135208129882812,
0.10492803156375885,
0.30496835708618164,
0.08970189094543457,
-0.4230232238769531,
-0.21286089718341827,
-1.122087001800537,
-0.6716544032096863,
-0.180327370762825,
-0.3170492649078369,
-0.16407647728919983,
-0.026598477736115456,
0.9481319189071655,
0.35507839918136597,
-0.8150744438171387,
-0.05549737811088562,
-0.3073449432849884,
0.44356951117515564,
-0.4100998044013977,
-0.2870393395423889,
0.40381762385368347,
-0.22639420628547668,
-0.7659540176391602,
0.47479718923568726,
0.41821032762527466,
-0.36762964725494385,
-0.1428442895412445,
-0.1816202700138092,
-0.006371550261974335,
0.5107796788215637,
0.6956053972244263,
0.1693381369113922,
-1.1350198984146118,
-0.6913431882858276,
-0.2951832413673401,
0.17746947705745697,
0.0374939851462841,
0.629470705986023,
-0.5428283214569092,
0.5256950259208679,
0.38090211153030396,
0.7325326800346375,
0.209054633975029,
0.11137755960226059,
0.8311784267425537,
-0.3267907500267029,
-0.2852061688899994,
0.15123742818832397,
0.5650616884231567,
0.0937206968665123,
-0.22530433535575867,
0.5999771356582642,
-0.015971340239048004,
-0.5732291340827942,
-0.9607470035552979,
0.3389758765697479,
-0.8327280879020691,
-0.3813994824886322,
1.377651333808899,
-0.2652447521686554,
-0.4531078636646271,
-0.012293798848986626,
-0.3155313730239868,
0.012591424398124218,
-0.35576891899108887,
0.8328497409820557,
0.979314386844635,
-0.390683114528656,
-0.26250603795051575,
-0.7450898289680481,
-0.03204689919948578,
0.4019749164581299,
-0.9288948774337769,
0.28423967957496643,
0.6225350499153137,
0.2250276803970337,
-0.008889404125511646,
0.2235603928565979,
0.19627144932746887,
0.2826121747493744,
-0.20089544355869293,
-0.144583597779274,
0.2067924588918686,
-0.21102501451969147,
-0.32593420147895813,
0.08562996983528137,
0.3245953619480133,
0.2091890424489975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10753v1 | ToolSword: Unveiling Safety Issues of Large Language Models in Tool Learning Across Three Stages | 2024-02-16T15:19:46 | 2024-02-16T15:19:46 | Junjie Ye, Sixian Li, Guanyu Li, Caishuang Huang, Songyang Gao, Yilong Wu, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool learning is widely acknowledged as a foundational approach or deploying
large language models (LLMs) in real-world scenarios. While current research
primarily emphasizes leveraging tools to augment LLMs, it frequently neglects
emerging safety considerations tied to their application. To fill this gap, we
present $ToolSword$, a comprehensive framework dedicated to meticulously
investigating safety issues linked to LLMs in tool learning. Specifically,
ToolSword delineates six safety scenarios for LLMs in tool learning,
encompassing $malicious$ $queries$ and $jailbreak$ $attacks$ in the input
stage, $noisy$ $misdirection$ and $risky$ $cues$ in the execution stage, and
$harmful$ $feedback$ and $error$ $conflicts$ in the output stage. Experiments
conducted on 11 open-source and closed-source LLMs reveal enduring safety
challenges in tool learning, such as handling harmful queries, employing risky
tools, and delivering detrimental feedback, which even GPT-4 is susceptible to.
Moreover, we conduct further studies with the aim of fostering research on tool
learning safety. The data is released in
https://github.com/Junjie-Ye/ToolSword. | [
0.01294343825429678,
-0.7763491272926331,
0.5596182346343994,
0.0032125136349350214,
-0.38260704278945923,
0.25794288516044617,
-0.03586389124393463,
-0.4352879524230957,
-0.6318158507347107,
0.624957799911499,
-0.40712881088256836,
-0.7983875870704651,
-0.6162368059158325,
-0.03390507772564888,
-0.7417708039283752,
1.0462017059326172,
-0.15875867009162903,
0.11287453770637512,
0.0020846568513661623,
0.13173942267894745,
-0.5661731958389282,
-0.6330167651176453,
-0.7180712223052979,
-0.0079042324796319,
0.6769373416900635,
0.3395065367221832,
0.4484512209892273,
0.6353421211242676,
0.48013830184936523,
0.3157441318035126,
-0.05720759183168411,
-0.27287209033966064,
-0.4944535791873932,
0.4146462082862854,
-0.1557455062866211,
-0.6395604610443115,
-0.33878931403160095,
0.2732061445713043,
0.3320848047733307,
0.6249713897705078,
-0.22817116975784302,
-0.16291168332099915,
0.30485039949417114,
0.06729183346033096,
-0.6061970591545105,
-0.016614865511655807,
-0.8848170042037964,
0.04023796692490578,
-0.3598194718360901,
-0.10681819915771484,
-0.510793924331665,
-0.4841422438621521,
0.02669329009950161,
-0.42138177156448364,
0.12358531355857849,
-0.0130968252196908,
0.5086950063705444,
0.17723047733306885,
-0.4796582758426666,
-0.36665812134742737,
-0.2731753885746002,
0.7311860918998718,
-0.7916334867477417,
0.3398362994194031,
0.45626476407051086,
0.4805185794830322,
-0.49926453828811646,
-0.8159113526344299,
-0.43036219477653503,
-0.07478733360767365,
0.2541762590408325,
-0.16878825426101685,
0.32760849595069885,
0.18746711313724518,
0.587469756603241,
0.06542158126831055,
-0.3392386734485626,
0.47074559330940247,
-0.6978012323379517,
-0.36556559801101685,
0.7157880663871765,
0.24999994039535522,
0.2704816162586212,
0.04278244450688362,
-0.28372544050216675,
-0.37909191846847534,
-1.0026274919509888,
-0.2992064654827118,
0.6417717933654785,
0.32174187898635864,
-0.4372562766075134,
0.24686817824840546,
0.2869565188884735,
0.5545052289962769,
-0.39711397886276245,
-0.5107879638671875,
0.4381234645843506,
-0.24126707017421722,
-0.17433130741119385,
0.0802503302693367,
0.8656856417655945,
0.4577574133872986,
0.05498168244957924,
-0.39885199069976807,
-0.30426955223083496,
-0.25918689370155334,
0.5067135095596313,
-0.8322343826293945,
-0.2590571641921997,
0.24452921748161316,
-0.054903797805309296,
-0.8367200493812561,
-0.17567144334316254,
-0.4791669547557831,
-0.9160961508750916,
0.13835062086582184,
0.5102482438087463,
-0.29993030428886414,
-0.38426461815834045,
0.013340713456273079,
-0.005744731053709984,
0.4898468852043152,
0.16208405792713165,
-0.4170226454734802,
0.05710314214229584,
0.7698888182640076,
0.8436653017997742,
-0.27066054940223694,
-0.45477765798568726,
-0.7417920827865601,
0.17648106813430786,
-0.4100625813007355,
0.3002914488315582,
-0.2619660496711731,
-0.9079499244689941,
0.18712203204631805,
0.34735947847366333,
0.1775614619255066,
-0.37976232171058655,
0.42724525928497314,
-0.38820576667785645,
0.2123054713010788,
-0.18412895500659943,
-0.3293001353740692,
-0.3733687698841095,
0.22453150153160095,
-0.6618664264678955,
0.8961685299873352,
-0.2056000977754593,
-0.8512788414955139,
0.6800651550292969,
-0.4893347918987274,
-0.6437227725982666,
-0.0982893705368042,
-0.30498531460762024,
-0.5451875925064087,
-0.00034947533276863396,
-0.28413552045822144,
0.6329326629638672,
-0.11081767082214355,
0.3165675103664398,
-0.6087131500244141,
-0.17012187838554382,
0.15459217131137848,
-0.33366405963897705,
0.8091745972633362,
0.07926028966903687,
-0.4069388508796692,
0.394348680973053,
-0.44872504472732544,
-0.3207472264766693,
0.2864919900894165,
-0.3362085819244385,
-0.1968158781528473,
0.12661075592041016,
0.07695060968399048,
0.4617665708065033,
0.03799173980951309,
-0.7901756167411804,
-0.08605394512414932,
-0.5678562521934509,
0.43633607029914856,
0.8605157136917114,
-0.02642620913684368,
0.22542868554592133,
0.14567391574382782,
0.5824627876281738,
0.21275171637535095,
0.32324326038360596,
-0.14731115102767944,
-0.08405930548906326,
-0.3089897036552429,
0.4269079267978668,
0.28607887029647827,
0.5333833694458008,
-0.8068614602088928,
0.027610568329691887,
0.1535094678401947,
-0.5006740093231201,
-0.13736982643604279,
0.3531498908996582,
0.6016857028007507,
0.3279864192008972,
0.059792615473270416,
-0.35414281487464905,
-0.3885193169116974,
-0.6733439564704895,
-0.37895864248275757,
-0.14017008244991302,
0.020501693710684776,
0.021240882575511932,
0.3865777552127838,
-0.04578312858939171,
0.582859456539154,
-0.4280799925327301,
-0.13719956576824188,
-0.3691765069961548,
0.03477567434310913,
-0.14408418536186218,
0.5515686869621277,
0.5473827719688416,
-0.7240442633628845,
-0.21685068309307098,
-0.09091579169034958,
-0.6603870391845703,
0.23675163090229034,
0.011821780353784561,
0.08207902312278748,
0.2993825674057007,
1.1367263793945312,
-0.2436162829399109,
0.3030802309513092,
0.447319895029068,
-0.0892181470990181,
0.5589876174926758,
0.05243346467614174,
-0.5551416873931885,
-1.3857853412628174,
-0.013899419456720352,
0.0010409170063212514,
-0.21934720873832703,
-0.45638811588287354,
0.22536136209964752,
0.18547846376895905,
-0.06167475879192352,
-0.9151352643966675,
0.39349430799484253,
-0.3586715757846832,
0.07846920937299728,
-0.3376799523830414,
0.3306112289428711,
-0.33480170369148254,
0.0332479290664196,
-0.2605822682380676,
1.054924726486206,
0.6309900879859924,
-0.2792142629623413,
0.22846615314483643,
-0.1806689202785492,
-0.23390263319015503,
0.161862313747406,
-0.851135790348053,
0.26143574714660645,
0.25361743569374084,
-0.07852249592542648,
-0.599682092666626,
-0.4382774531841278,
0.20188504457473755,
-0.308440238237381,
0.3627738058567047,
-0.1539854109287262,
-1.0627864599227905,
-0.22518841922283173,
-0.3902469873428345,
-0.01952178217470646,
0.38362133502960205,
-0.2529265880584717,
0.41419804096221924,
0.7594509720802307,
-0.30738863348960876,
-0.7162028551101685,
-0.19576716423034668,
0.10258623957633972,
-0.481751948595047,
-0.15072792768478394,
-0.3358789086341858,
-0.013304912485182285,
-0.2191094011068344,
-0.294466108083725,
-0.375409334897995,
0.06627204269170761,
0.8174341917037964,
0.45262497663497925,
0.22725410759449005,
0.3719395697116852,
0.31611335277557373,
0.13896958529949188,
-0.04279780387878418,
0.6571705341339111,
0.12325779348611832,
0.4519844055175781,
-0.13875465095043182,
-0.4258042871952057,
0.35473063588142395,
0.09582730382680893,
0.49087294936180115,
-0.1859503984451294,
0.5349109172821045,
0.9090684652328491,
-0.37400999665260315,
-0.31676045060157776,
-0.4824042022228241,
-0.3424239456653595,
-0.5567558407783508,
0.5780970454216003,
-0.22408874332904816,
-1.0201815366744995,
0.33171534538269043,
-0.3950081169605255,
0.6932116746902466,
0.08329498767852783,
0.46477895975112915,
-0.113558828830719,
1.1861063241958618,
0.9681744575500488,
-0.07554955035448074,
0.3199397325515747,
-0.055644433945417404,
0.2907237410545349,
-0.5810930132865906,
-0.42065951228141785,
-0.43268483877182007,
-0.0968938022851944,
-0.5316880345344543,
-0.39914414286613464,
0.6085488200187683,
0.1742829531431198,
-0.03592636436223984,
0.33019185066223145,
-0.13832242786884308,
0.5869203209877014,
0.4353674352169037,
-0.12672367691993713,
0.09689580649137497,
-0.15935105085372925,
-0.7046464681625366,
0.20185069739818573,
-0.5284443497657776,
-0.5338007211685181,
1.2662144899368286,
0.46399441361427307,
0.9172574281692505,
0.10213711112737656,
0.9283987879753113,
-0.006387532688677311,
0.24398429691791534,
-0.8056183457374573,
0.7689074873924255,
0.20955021679401398,
-0.7106556296348572,
-0.2487284243106842,
-0.1306699514389038,
-0.9895126223564148,
0.16995064914226532,
-0.2055215835571289,
-0.6955243349075317,
-0.2885523736476898,
0.10020075738430023,
-0.17537172138690948,
0.41751205921173096,
-0.7276886105537415,
0.9799067974090576,
-0.6212475895881653,
-0.6755074858665466,
-0.2892819046974182,
-1.1034117937088013,
0.43424174189567566,
-0.40009862184524536,
0.40583357214927673,
-0.17765390872955322,
0.0068041300401091576,
0.8418239951133728,
-0.15400880575180054,
1.1565040349960327,
-0.1404009908437729,
-0.35890501737594604,
-0.01695641130208969,
0.36983516812324524,
0.4812297821044922,
-0.04894573614001274,
0.10038276761770248,
0.024414444342255592,
0.28296393156051636,
-0.11794949322938919,
-0.10668647289276123,
0.689524233341217,
-0.5152112245559692,
-0.7393200993537903,
-0.5382266640663147,
-0.6956894993782043,
-0.3352964222431183,
0.6041308045387268,
0.015184557065367699,
0.4404783546924591,
-0.008580273948609829,
0.20240230858325958,
0.7546300292015076,
-0.519768238067627,
0.5521487593650818,
0.4075641930103302,
-0.43650108575820923,
0.015243262983858585,
0.9790527820587158,
-0.03252897784113884,
0.341647744178772,
-0.36913439631462097,
-0.03373795747756958,
-0.17400625348091125,
-1.093262791633606,
-0.2690977454185486,
0.2802390456199646,
-0.784152090549469,
-0.24014076590538025,
-0.5693390369415283,
-0.13605549931526184,
-0.07304190844297409,
-0.07952030748128891,
-0.15266355872154236,
-0.006956210359930992,
-0.12256211042404175,
-0.5216345191001892,
0.3609923720359802,
0.9140707850456238,
-0.02697209268808365,
0.34942638874053955,
-0.8659110069274902,
-0.126959890127182,
0.026342028751969337,
0.5842556953430176,
-0.19057528674602509,
0.03535737097263336,
-0.4948696196079254,
-0.35361114144325256,
-0.6457101702690125,
-0.8453801274299622,
0.18236054480075836,
-0.12458570301532745,
0.6752700805664062,
0.39282238483428955,
0.2168106883764267,
0.24140837788581848,
-0.544710099697113,
0.7247865200042725,
0.30811789631843567,
-0.6618595719337463,
0.6994318962097168,
-0.4363410174846649,
0.10788078606128693,
0.6173458099365234,
0.5665030479431152,
-0.4855410158634186,
-0.5944478511810303,
-0.6354232430458069,
-1.1769474744796753,
0.6112725138664246,
-0.2182697057723999,
0.13489191234111786,
-0.18187199532985687,
0.09223847091197968,
0.4105328321456909,
0.3477461040019989,
-0.7043124437332153,
0.026250483468174934,
0.08453691005706787,
-0.02045297436416149,
0.060947902500629425,
-0.09150411188602448,
-0.5099112391471863,
0.05818070471286774,
0.5530286431312561,
-0.17872831225395203,
-0.25245457887649536,
-0.4573041796684265,
-0.46473756432533264,
-0.08574720472097397,
0.3328946530818939,
0.36095327138900757,
0.7183043360710144,
-0.14909881353378296,
0.3000752627849579,
0.36313730478286743,
-0.6806281208992004,
-0.0003494719276204705,
0.06741157174110413,
0.03460587561130524,
-0.23967812955379486,
0.3659183382987976,
0.6514562368392944,
0.3352108299732208,
-0.9151403307914734,
0.6249713897705078,
-0.012386932037770748,
-0.2043515145778656,
-0.43491131067276,
0.3619249761104584,
0.27589690685272217,
0.0482000894844532,
0.16686351597309113,
-0.2709024250507355,
0.2441776692867279,
-0.5138010382652283,
0.17041385173797607,
0.5041956305503845,
-0.6161891222000122,
-0.42310482263565063,
0.6386001706123352,
0.48616254329681396,
-0.18510128557682037,
0.2877415716648102,
-0.24050545692443848,
-0.4894281327724457,
0.3081846237182617,
0.3141685426235199,
0.9752055406570435,
-0.13510310649871826,
-0.027926666662096977,
0.224295973777771,
0.6637818813323975,
-0.08878378570079803,
0.34095194935798645,
0.10683275759220123,
-0.4105074405670166,
-0.4930444657802582,
-0.619693398475647,
-0.44977304339408875,
0.2690306007862091,
-0.4809624254703522,
0.2406550645828247,
-0.664859414100647,
-0.2025863379240036,
-0.2719162106513977,
-0.20752006769180298,
-0.47475042939186096,
-0.015464240685105324,
-0.003424047026783228,
1.0134422779083252,
-0.920344352722168,
0.8981504440307617,
0.7967236042022705,
-0.3423202335834503,
-1.033255696296692,
0.05027417093515396,
0.6188609004020691,
-0.6773535013198853,
0.6042609214782715,
0.33358263969421387,
-0.39021098613739014,
0.035381242632865906,
-0.7732264399528503,
-0.497158944606781,
1.129945158958435,
0.2285938858985901,
-0.6156294941902161,
-0.24769209325313568,
-0.06055544689297676,
0.14291591942310333,
0.10108261555433273,
-0.12244000285863876,
0.7199587821960449,
0.1473497748374939,
-0.11463887989521027,
-1.217760443687439,
0.08831795305013657,
-0.06866041570901871,
-0.20284917950630188,
0.3526991009712219,
-0.062222082167863846,
0.4819857180118561,
-0.37906959652900696,
-0.3941342830657959,
-0.14985649287700653,
0.11966589838266373,
0.2637469172477722,
0.25403523445129395,
0.5897573232650757,
0.5550565719604492,
0.33582818508148193,
-0.2258896678686142,
1.0259000062942505,
-0.23083774745464325,
0.09279108792543411,
1.0865768194198608,
-0.3432071805000305,
0.8289150595664978,
0.5677393078804016,
-0.16713736951351166,
0.15501254796981812,
0.7764158844947815,
0.21551628410816193,
0.32226577401161194,
0.2670125365257263,
-0.1446656733751297,
-0.33526545763015747,
0.11171385645866394,
-0.4248434007167816,
0.4802080988883972,
0.5613162517547607,
-0.4184897541999817,
-0.4353162348270416,
0.2423284649848938,
0.44656237959861755,
-0.21717537939548492,
-0.07112936675548553,
1.0026648044586182,
0.32583948969841003,
-0.19766248762607574,
0.3406349718570709,
-0.05759362876415253,
0.6078490018844604,
-0.5178205966949463,
-0.23254692554473877,
0.12217112630605698,
0.2056727111339569,
-0.036103732883930206,
-1.0528762340545654,
0.19421590864658356,
-0.08367413282394409,
0.4692842364311218,
0.07177379727363586,
0.7192966341972351,
-0.10930624604225159,
-0.35388487577438354,
0.39303818345069885,
0.46575987339019775,
0.20893271267414093,
0.2288505882024765,
-0.6995877027511597,
0.38066214323043823,
-0.27563995122909546,
-0.009983757510781288,
0.5842829346656799,
0.38953256607055664,
-0.18132175505161285,
0.8045811057090759,
0.515312135219574,
0.14238737523555756,
0.23749367892742157,
0.020633460953831673,
1.0334168672561646,
-0.4391482174396515,
-0.3657621741294861,
-0.6632494330406189,
0.5467559695243835,
-0.2924301326274872,
-0.1514796018600464,
1.0290659666061401,
0.386745423078537,
1.10292387008667,
0.08288080245256424,
0.9058957099914551,
-0.06254483759403229,
0.5821989178657532,
-0.5273413062095642,
0.9462926387786865,
-0.5034000873565674,
0.4482395648956299,
-0.4709484875202179,
-0.7167413234710693,
-0.408042311668396,
0.3567502200603485,
-0.5955159068107605,
0.08349522203207016,
0.7319172024726868,
0.6758983731269836,
-0.04643184691667557,
-0.15070609748363495,
0.29761072993278503,
0.3223220109939575,
0.3997260630130768,
0.19828449189662933,
0.6538497805595398,
-0.24701358377933502,
0.7669433951377869,
-0.2598620057106018,
0.05734393745660782,
-0.2838163673877716,
-0.8995388150215149,
-1.0244745016098022,
-0.5708315372467041,
-0.13597343862056732,
-0.4663677215576172,
0.23880742490291595,
0.8546916842460632,
0.48577767610549927,
-0.5775302648544312,
-0.4120147228240967,
-0.04913824051618576,
0.1910395324230194,
0.12597151100635529,
-0.12889747321605682,
0.16996902227401733,
-0.43185245990753174,
-0.4650169312953949,
0.4500282406806946,
0.1700017750263214,
-0.048927195370197296,
-0.38881027698516846,
-0.014428695663809776,
0.011423102580010891,
-0.37477973103523254,
0.626357913017273,
0.2449156939983368,
-0.7323945164680481,
-0.46943333745002747,
-0.12897086143493652,
0.06926223635673523,
-0.37452200055122375,
0.7947728633880615,
-0.6452603936195374,
0.5498514175415039,
0.18334034085273743,
0.6897262930870056,
0.2607889473438263,
-0.42695000767707825,
0.7360709309577942,
-0.9500995874404907,
0.12478593736886978,
0.23358039557933807,
0.3243601620197296,
0.46321219205856323,
-0.13781990110874176,
0.6077466607093811,
0.06517480313777924,
-0.46964260935783386,
-1.2103614807128906,
0.551943302154541,
-0.7695611119270325,
-0.3023994565010071,
1.0898079872131348,
-0.1011924296617508,
0.15040139853954315,
-0.5487222075462341,
-0.17833103239536285,
0.30806922912597656,
-0.1447732150554657,
0.7153369188308716,
0.5232561230659485,
0.2327592521905899,
-0.29525765776634216,
-1.0539354085922241,
0.6646502614021301,
0.08752273768186569,
-0.7248818874359131,
0.197274312376976,
0.599833607673645,
0.7055172920227051,
0.010834689252078533,
0.009736618027091026,
-0.4573417603969574,
0.411207914352417,
-0.10595295578241348,
0.08536341786384583,
-0.25927403569221497,
-0.3880566954612732,
-0.20543889701366425,
0.20415423810482025,
0.6353674530982971,
-0.05033743008971214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10744v1 | GenRES: Rethinking Evaluation for Generative Relation Extraction in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T15:01:24 | 2024-02-16T15:01:24 | Pengcheng Jiang, Jiacheng Lin, Zifeng Wang, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The field of relation extraction (RE) is experiencing a notable shift towards
generative relation extraction (GRE), leveraging the capabilities of large
language models (LLMs). However, we discovered that traditional relation
extraction (RE) metrics like precision and recall fall short in evaluating GRE
methods. This shortfall arises because these metrics rely on exact matching
with human-annotated reference relations, while GRE methods often produce
diverse and semantically accurate relations that differ from the references. To
fill this gap, we introduce GenRES for a multi-dimensional assessment in terms
of the topic similarity, uniqueness, granularity, factualness, and completeness
of the GRE results. With GenRES, we empirically identified that (1)
precision/recall fails to justify the performance of GRE methods; (2)
human-annotated referential relations can be incomplete; (3) prompting LLMs
with a fixed set of relations or entities can cause hallucinations. Next, we
conducted a human evaluation of GRE methods that shows GenRES is consistent
with human preferences for RE quality. Last, we made a comprehensive evaluation
of fourteen leading LLMs using GenRES across document, bag, and sentence level
RE datasets, respectively, to set the benchmark for future research in GRE | [
-0.5558703541755676,
-0.5118023753166199,
0.6122729778289795,
0.14457324147224426,
-0.19848155975341797,
0.22967743873596191,
-0.523198664188385,
-0.5370507836341858,
0.4155847728252411,
0.5464561581611633,
-0.48237094283103943,
-0.7607433795928955,
-0.7741189002990723,
0.24087508022785187,
-0.4022253751754761,
1.2642123699188232,
0.05508098378777504,
-0.47920721769332886,
-0.6622654795646667,
-0.17708829045295715,
-0.41102832555770874,
-0.3865084648132324,
-0.43036940693855286,
-0.26285287737846375,
0.6495859026908875,
-0.10845418274402618,
0.5971364974975586,
0.46125999093055725,
0.8587618470191956,
0.24928387999534607,
-0.03883333504199982,
-0.02976442687213421,
-0.6177246570587158,
0.33005234599113464,
-0.12312574684619904,
-0.27545034885406494,
-0.3492657244205475,
0.1427375078201294,
0.46768102049827576,
0.7871414422988892,
-0.1521255075931549,
0.4169601500034332,
-0.21446339786052704,
0.5814075469970703,
-0.8429384827613831,
0.13417375087738037,
-0.7157442569732666,
0.1108829528093338,
-0.29206401109695435,
-0.325080931186676,
-0.4945133924484253,
-0.26199546456336975,
0.22558091580867767,
-0.526755154132843,
0.557779848575592,
0.0653030201792717,
1.1860278844833374,
0.10476375371217728,
-0.30646276473999023,
-0.31648027896881104,
-1.0769506692886353,
0.4916357696056366,
-0.38047564029693604,
0.6795415878295898,
0.4909141957759857,
0.27385032176971436,
-0.07535380870103836,
-0.9519727230072021,
-0.29868558049201965,
-0.45167601108551025,
-0.00028046671650372446,
0.19078530371189117,
-0.17729194462299347,
-0.03965708985924721,
0.555173397064209,
0.7942299246788025,
-0.42247432470321655,
-0.02792702242732048,
-0.2969481647014618,
-0.13866733014583588,
0.7630895972251892,
0.2127816081047058,
0.385574072599411,
-0.3904407322406769,
-0.3878127336502075,
0.10947690159082413,
-0.7482498288154602,
0.013106144033372402,
0.33538544178009033,
-0.06914706528186798,
0.27755501866340637,
0.3959103226661682,
-0.08645947277545929,
0.7397435307502747,
-0.09667365998029709,
-0.441670686006546,
0.16115447878837585,
-0.3710070848464966,
-0.11601927876472473,
-0.48595401644706726,
1.252835988998413,
0.4365318715572357,
0.2986789345741272,
-0.7318297028541565,
-0.16635854542255402,
0.0849667340517044,
0.5578994154930115,
-0.4503290057182312,
-0.39315205812454224,
0.07053817063570023,
-0.4173729717731476,
-0.17620588839054108,
0.15132847428321838,
-1.0480685234069824,
-0.44707190990448,
-0.41032397747039795,
0.19454750418663025,
-0.39140546321868896,
-0.1997821033000946,
0.03137090057134628,
-0.28173133730888367,
0.014461793005466461,
0.12377357482910156,
-1.084598183631897,
0.42768874764442444,
0.8607133030891418,
0.8331320881843567,
-0.21173547208309174,
-0.19769364595413208,
-0.3585633933544159,
0.06859815865755081,
-0.27741172909736633,
0.9265007972717285,
-0.7071244120597839,
-0.6789347529411316,
-0.18072442710399628,
-0.07881015539169312,
-0.05574893578886986,
-0.682413637638092,
0.7944110035896301,
-0.5314061641693115,
0.17720013856887817,
-0.38908475637435913,
-0.42246413230895996,
-0.14285488426685333,
0.10869179666042328,
-0.9016957879066467,
0.9679595232009888,
0.20884115993976593,
-0.5897293090820312,
0.683775782585144,
-0.22589130699634552,
-0.252302348613739,
0.1437281370162964,
-0.44231563806533813,
-0.29507800936698914,
0.16672615706920624,
0.11818484216928482,
0.47903603315353394,
-0.6747558116912842,
0.5377432703971863,
-0.38010862469673157,
-0.38398560881614685,
0.19085896015167236,
-0.19489207863807678,
0.4709915816783905,
0.231215700507164,
0.008111199364066124,
0.17700764536857605,
-0.7983519434928894,
-0.22988614439964294,
0.0006106063374318182,
0.013916904106736183,
-0.5487893223762512,
0.22385141253471375,
0.14638051390647888,
0.19290971755981445,
-0.1892690509557724,
-0.5481171011924744,
0.14341817796230316,
-0.34389635920524597,
0.446095734834671,
0.32523661851882935,
0.2493305802345276,
0.38644084334373474,
-0.3582589328289032,
0.8498632907867432,
-0.37816524505615234,
-0.2989136874675751,
-0.056159619241952896,
-0.13397587835788727,
-0.23348379135131836,
-0.3791559934616089,
0.6080684661865234,
0.3913756310939789,
-0.44727420806884766,
0.6811297535896301,
-0.6587924957275391,
-0.6522029638290405,
-0.5917216539382935,
0.0650445893406868,
0.10230784118175507,
0.18033713102340698,
0.13408803939819336,
-0.6480444073677063,
-0.46312111616134644,
-0.860232949256897,
-0.31490471959114075,
-0.14542093873023987,
-0.232982337474823,
0.22494018077850342,
0.3754366338253021,
-0.08890514075756073,
1.3104453086853027,
-0.8127502202987671,
-0.28916409611701965,
-0.211624875664711,
0.21465721726417542,
-0.09688296914100647,
0.08772867172956467,
0.5845771431922913,
-0.684855580329895,
-0.23730866611003876,
0.0014015398919582367,
-0.9288161396980286,
-0.06889568269252777,
-0.13650697469711304,
0.1548520177602768,
-0.0640287771821022,
0.3885479271411896,
-0.6648842692375183,
0.19678354263305664,
0.25725311040878296,
-0.03383839875459671,
0.7642306089401245,
0.23366907238960266,
0.2421286404132843,
-1.011269211769104,
0.16545416414737701,
0.25927138328552246,
0.008636749349534512,
-0.33440878987312317,
0.2149401605129242,
-0.1852097362279892,
-0.18477469682693481,
0.2399480640888214,
0.4215158522129059,
-0.5966036319732666,
-0.31487902998924255,
-0.05024382099509239,
0.5240004062652588,
0.24979647994041443,
0.15540574491024017,
0.034479327499866486,
0.6689844131469727,
0.3414667546749115,
-0.1842922568321228,
0.48091185092926025,
0.13069479167461395,
-0.6271131634712219,
0.47056618332862854,
-0.4142661690711975,
0.2890501022338867,
-0.3856748044490814,
0.3863205313682556,
-0.9236981272697449,
-0.20294620096683502,
0.211432546377182,
-0.3833611011505127,
0.3858470022678375,
-0.20708143711090088,
-0.42093566060066223,
-0.11510124802589417,
-0.3637402355670929,
0.3226708769798279,
0.48478439450263977,
-0.14479701220989227,
0.5763540863990784,
0.3808630108833313,
-0.3996395170688629,
-0.7337415218353271,
-0.1969028264284134,
0.26321396231651306,
-0.6655001640319824,
-0.5327038764953613,
0.41972091794013977,
0.18992845714092255,
-0.6217888593673706,
0.2860724627971649,
-0.23166371881961823,
-0.1705024391412735,
0.14048542082309723,
0.16875387728214264,
0.1099230945110321,
-0.16346175968647003,
0.32515817880630493,
-0.13182270526885986,
-0.0018520535668358207,
0.2502182424068451,
0.14456748962402344,
0.4943099617958069,
0.025117773562669754,
-0.036323972046375275,
-0.11675388365983963,
0.24057084321975708,
0.6385381817817688,
-0.5480381846427917,
0.3333899974822998,
0.7054883241653442,
-0.4460107088088989,
-0.04808768630027771,
-0.6512624621391296,
-0.1149006262421608,
-0.3329087197780609,
0.6500838994979858,
-0.7331485748291016,
-0.8665507435798645,
0.6997920274734497,
0.009558710269629955,
0.04112526401877403,
0.6875444650650024,
0.2805461585521698,
0.012980354949831963,
0.12900781631469727,
0.5046579241752625,
-0.10036811232566833,
0.2814302444458008,
-0.25009608268737793,
0.4679657816886902,
-1.147923469543457,
-0.35955724120140076,
-0.6133692860603333,
-0.05455246940255165,
-0.586452841758728,
-0.11283113062381744,
0.15801356732845306,
0.28419479727745056,
0.19397076964378357,
0.4315468966960907,
-0.15407465398311615,
0.5306466221809387,
-0.06235337629914284,
-0.3125298321247101,
0.5405325889587402,
0.18750326335430145,
0.37513431906700134,
-0.4269179403781891,
-0.4229505956172943,
-0.738676905632019,
1.1787201166152954,
0.3877689838409424,
0.6932860016822815,
0.0795564129948616,
0.8068566918373108,
0.170289546251297,
0.6232077479362488,
-1.2975598573684692,
0.43419498205184937,
-0.2977210581302643,
-0.5970008373260498,
-0.2968943119049072,
-0.42561593651771545,
-1.1098707914352417,
0.6418427228927612,
-0.3729284703731537,
-1.1178665161132812,
0.15163742005825043,
-0.3451666533946991,
-0.5606375932693481,
0.3075459599494934,
-0.46908971667289734,
0.7752118110656738,
0.24702569842338562,
-0.34985822439193726,
0.05218305438756943,
-0.6282811760902405,
0.6100372672080994,
-0.16155198216438293,
0.2390616238117218,
-0.2695557177066803,
0.16065555810928345,
0.9514973759651184,
0.24528004229068756,
0.499527245759964,
0.3500484824180603,
-0.3514566421508789,
0.23486287891864777,
0.3579367399215698,
0.04320194199681282,
0.3138944208621979,
-0.08168826252222061,
0.19772523641586304,
0.18931180238723755,
0.012532212771475315,
-0.9911729097366333,
0.6735373735427856,
-0.5686190724372864,
-0.7051964402198792,
-0.4586995542049408,
-0.6446772813796997,
-0.48854386806488037,
0.08153169602155685,
0.42386138439178467,
0.7636886239051819,
-0.6297727823257446,
0.20711487531661987,
0.3501001000404358,
0.02617376483976841,
0.2681299149990082,
0.15249015390872955,
-0.4316374957561493,
-0.616838276386261,
0.9469656348228455,
0.22868967056274414,
0.42106062173843384,
0.33225345611572266,
-0.19490498304367065,
-0.3384628891944885,
-0.40714672207832336,
-0.3534969985485077,
0.3365062177181244,
-0.6879969835281372,
0.09079418331384659,
-0.9130467176437378,
-0.09908881038427353,
-0.42067867517471313,
0.014033656567335129,
-0.1794510781764984,
-0.03891301900148392,
-0.14278583228588104,
-0.10170131176710129,
0.13457468152046204,
0.7609702944755554,
0.33793389797210693,
0.07406381517648697,
-0.9377257823944092,
0.28702807426452637,
0.007620250806212425,
0.37200501561164856,
0.00022128602722659707,
-0.47928693890571594,
0.056329451501369476,
-0.42944976687431335,
-0.36436742544174194,
-0.9827439188957214,
0.16326108574867249,
0.10875730216503143,
0.384033739566803,
0.3536505103111267,
-0.18692338466644287,
0.6291713714599609,
-0.565048336982727,
0.7383542060852051,
0.07996626943349838,
-0.7317929267883301,
0.16016608476638794,
-0.42048412561416626,
-0.12740342319011688,
0.8626962304115295,
0.5334927439689636,
-0.8668833374977112,
-0.2627841532230377,
-0.9060825705528259,
-0.8977939486503601,
0.40940216183662415,
0.12623493373394012,
0.10148599743843079,
-0.12589137256145477,
0.6045677065849304,
0.30686119198799133,
0.39171645045280457,
-0.7293559908866882,
-0.23406103253364563,
0.3547581732273102,
-0.11598776280879974,
-0.31649893522262573,
-0.5013138651847839,
-0.09823895990848541,
-0.03728029131889343,
0.14388813078403473,
0.23934616148471832,
0.4135640561580658,
0.08448705077171326,
0.15965577960014343,
-0.16025763750076294,
0.5396571159362793,
0.3361080288887024,
0.9757559299468994,
-0.4886014759540558,
0.13759729266166687,
-0.23343782126903534,
-0.3687896430492401,
0.11841755360364914,
0.10911605507135391,
-0.15723299980163574,
0.09144550561904907,
0.7764721512794495,
0.82411789894104,
0.13311722874641418,
-0.4981774389743805,
0.32012245059013367,
0.18840384483337402,
-0.11339003592729568,
-0.3341393768787384,
-0.10564517229795456,
0.17520172894001007,
-0.24052542448043823,
0.058547839522361755,
0.07206469774246216,
0.3923819661140442,
-0.8019082546234131,
0.3250296711921692,
0.45352205634117126,
-0.5473494529724121,
-0.3875108063220978,
0.4979056119918823,
0.06814656406641006,
-0.3900934159755707,
0.5975916981697083,
-0.2848297655582428,
-0.16449938714504242,
0.6472480893135071,
0.5647489428520203,
1.1851890087127686,
0.07842598855495453,
0.3518231213092804,
0.5187326073646545,
0.5120015144348145,
-0.06765166670084,
-0.28068095445632935,
-0.008761204779148102,
-0.7992069721221924,
-0.8453400135040283,
-0.7834433913230896,
-0.1308087557554245,
0.4051995277404785,
-0.9626742005348206,
0.17597655951976776,
-0.21223266422748566,
-0.12199350446462631,
0.08051851391792297,
-0.07981027662754059,
-0.2980820834636688,
0.20846210420131683,
-0.24405533075332642,
0.5634623169898987,
-0.9646291732788086,
0.5665398240089417,
0.7854843139648438,
-0.5632272958755493,
-0.5793999433517456,
0.4971580505371094,
-0.09858716279268265,
-0.13953232765197754,
0.5804489254951477,
0.01717142015695572,
-0.22694963216781616,
0.09183749556541443,
-0.16552571952342987,
-0.8369061350822449,
0.8981921672821045,
0.23125497996807098,
-0.573258638381958,
0.12114053219556808,
-0.39570626616477966,
0.829152524471283,
-0.3880276083946228,
0.22489668428897858,
0.8067328333854675,
0.13785320520401,
0.019505195319652557,
-0.8821385502815247,
-0.007894894108176231,
-0.10824321955442429,
0.025355633348226547,
0.6716212034225464,
-0.46401283144950867,
0.4105992317199707,
-0.12185898423194885,
-0.4893476068973541,
-0.0651678591966629,
0.7021684050559998,
0.15157923102378845,
0.43169862031936646,
0.3993336856365204,
0.7301231622695923,
0.6399919986724854,
-0.25946083664894104,
1.2342785596847534,
0.18993084132671356,
0.6714434623718262,
1.236824631690979,
-0.5572937726974487,
0.8298253417015076,
0.3688889741897583,
-0.5850203633308411,
0.5994885563850403,
0.8542068600654602,
-0.13297027349472046,
0.2953792214393616,
0.2968882918357849,
-0.32843565940856934,
-0.31511765718460083,
-0.15237168967723846,
-0.3686407804489136,
0.5145547389984131,
0.357229620218277,
-0.38561874628067017,
-0.3177415430545807,
-0.16258832812309265,
0.01189364306628704,
0.479445219039917,
0.1186886876821518,
0.8157782554626465,
0.2713783383369446,
-0.6448816657066345,
0.3368300497531891,
-0.01915401965379715,
0.4185413420200348,
-0.48795291781425476,
0.007303874474018812,
-0.07411658018827438,
-0.33941376209259033,
-0.24855677783489227,
-0.6534961462020874,
0.3764263391494751,
-0.11379119753837585,
-0.44963663816452026,
0.26164525747299194,
0.6154554486274719,
-0.5862413048744202,
-0.4077697992324829,
0.31769245862960815,
0.538361132144928,
0.16784879565238953,
0.05130741372704506,
-0.29951930046081543,
0.03269065171480179,
-0.11560206115245819,
-0.04761549085378647,
0.4001758098602295,
0.4255601763725281,
-0.17626717686653137,
0.6667762994766235,
0.4266963601112366,
0.23299020528793335,
-0.35158687829971313,
0.14928846061229706,
0.4324408173561096,
-0.7202883958816528,
-0.16566692292690277,
-0.954845130443573,
0.19874408841133118,
-0.01661701127886772,
-0.48874858021736145,
0.6981765031814575,
0.5475039482116699,
0.7777206897735596,
-0.23889923095703125,
0.8269846439361572,
-0.4092085361480713,
0.2181309163570404,
-0.5108246207237244,
0.4796817898750305,
-0.5128056406974792,
0.3150123655796051,
-0.559999942779541,
-1.2460236549377441,
-0.4710260331630707,
0.45728129148483276,
-0.6511176824569702,
0.17444780468940735,
1.0764278173446655,
0.551788330078125,
0.03816989064216614,
0.046328671276569366,
0.3157859146595001,
-0.0737370103597641,
0.3270920217037201,
0.42526131868362427,
0.973300039768219,
-0.40342360734939575,
0.21110296249389648,
-0.22669009864330292,
-0.16372263431549072,
0.20760679244995117,
-0.8087477684020996,
-0.6676742434501648,
-0.7287307977676392,
-0.43409210443496704,
-0.15206295251846313,
-0.19967223703861237,
1.007899284362793,
0.09493699669837952,
-0.4541016221046448,
-0.38280221819877625,
0.3082255721092224,
0.168788343667984,
-0.2599932849407196,
-0.2794976532459259,
0.46381083130836487,
-0.3426494598388672,
-0.8499274253845215,
0.2459815889596939,
0.4332146942615509,
-0.3059380352497101,
-0.3460479974746704,
0.37937238812446594,
-0.049354832619428635,
-0.43226608633995056,
0.8080224394798279,
0.07375524193048477,
-1.1066631078720093,
-0.3981495201587677,
-0.13654133677482605,
0.0018063903553411365,
0.08006154000759125,
1.0062743425369263,
-0.4722747802734375,
0.5703548192977905,
0.503025472164154,
0.6551474332809448,
0.17450951039791107,
0.35120654106140137,
0.6371417045593262,
-0.47215577960014343,
-0.15487077832221985,
0.19318996369838715,
0.2541223168373108,
0.23201008141040802,
-0.3311683237552643,
0.7335556149482727,
0.527651309967041,
-0.5641385316848755,
-0.8259196877479553,
0.4098407030105591,
-1.1092371940612793,
-0.16149581968784332,
1.2957652807235718,
-0.2699723541736603,
0.09502725303173065,
-0.3348347246646881,
-0.20749109983444214,
-0.07952084392309189,
-0.06269963085651398,
0.9235759377479553,
1.0436726808547974,
-0.0702531561255455,
-0.02772483602166176,
-0.8165678381919861,
0.568092942237854,
0.30070120096206665,
-0.648213803768158,
0.1290508657693863,
0.7172470688819885,
0.48615673184394836,
0.5373817086219788,
0.6945495009422302,
-0.4427202343940735,
0.07183630764484406,
-0.12750045955181122,
0.34679684042930603,
0.17201916873455048,
-0.5337417125701904,
-0.25509384274482727,
0.5973162651062012,
0.40243226289749146,
0.13581781089305878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10743v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10743v1 | Construction of a Syntactic Analysis Map for Yi Shui School through Text Mining and Natural Language Processing Research | 2024-02-16T14:59:55 | 2024-02-16T14:59:55 | Hanqing Zhao, Yuehan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity and relationship extraction is a crucial component in natural language
processing tasks such as knowledge graph construction, question answering
system design, and semantic analysis. Most of the information of the Yishui
school of traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is stored in the form of
unstructured classical Chinese text. The key information extraction of TCM
texts plays an important role in mining and studying the academic schools of
TCM. In order to solve these problems efficiently using artificial intelligence
methods, this study constructs a word segmentation and entity relationship
extraction model based on conditional random fields under the framework of
natural language processing technology to identify and extract the entity
relationship of traditional Chinese medicine texts, and uses the common
weighting technology of TF-IDF information retrieval and data mining to extract
important key entity information in different ancient books. The dependency
syntactic parser based on neural network is used to analyze the grammatical
relationship between entities in each ancient book article, and it is
represented as a tree structure visualization, which lays the foundation for
the next construction of the knowledge graph of Yishui school and the use of
artificial intelligence methods to carry out the research of TCM academic
schools. | [
-0.009980530478060246,
-1.1143767833709717,
0.6309722661972046,
-0.42762404680252075,
-0.3731783330440521,
-0.07616987079381943,
-0.23349258303642273,
-0.6138359308242798,
0.16787806153297424,
0.5510608553886414,
-0.41652020812034607,
-0.8872430920600891,
-0.3629954755306244,
-0.014846955426037312,
-0.22331096231937408,
0.7724477052688599,
-0.04096131771802902,
0.30586478114128113,
0.05421406403183937,
-0.2629583775997162,
-0.3865010142326355,
-0.20317788422107697,
-0.9301350712776184,
-0.024449756368994713,
0.17250052094459534,
0.09664057195186615,
0.5647069811820984,
0.8963242769241333,
0.6793743371963501,
0.5256733298301697,
-0.056106086820364,
-0.142376109957695,
0.10894075781106949,
0.2305430918931961,
-0.2431284785270691,
-0.6248945593833923,
-0.5166170597076416,
-0.11851590126752853,
0.9340180158615112,
0.5243045091629028,
-0.13121706247329712,
0.13620948791503906,
-0.1561555564403534,
0.4723505973815918,
-0.2643907964229584,
0.4914607107639313,
-0.47967246174812317,
0.09276212751865387,
-0.6569364070892334,
-0.25587835907936096,
-0.18595623970031738,
-0.4945163130760193,
0.542726993560791,
-0.6157439351081848,
0.11283747106790543,
0.19809336960315704,
1.2833855152130127,
-0.05637863650918007,
-0.5172575116157532,
-0.2891964614391327,
-0.3963918685913086,
0.6538059115409851,
-0.9262726306915283,
0.13852033019065857,
0.10393316298723221,
0.18654927611351013,
-0.4160204827785492,
-0.8416150808334351,
-0.749337911605835,
0.0865272581577301,
-0.30027562379837036,
0.02269107662141323,
0.05259574577212334,
0.262058824300766,
0.13838490843772888,
0.4691382944583893,
-0.5410423874855042,
-0.12456454336643219,
-0.5280850529670715,
-0.025536399334669113,
0.5253735184669495,
0.2582969665527344,
1.1973241567611694,
-0.5865396857261658,
-0.36318662762641907,
-0.13925665616989136,
-0.1970462203025818,
0.26015704870224,
0.1553288698196411,
0.14141033589839935,
-0.07510792464017868,
0.35491132736206055,
0.023777930065989494,
0.8848145008087158,
-0.23349614441394806,
-0.5410133004188538,
0.07432560622692108,
-0.612233579158783,
-0.43117332458496094,
0.21273554861545563,
1.1120611429214478,
0.17136834561824799,
0.4103189706802368,
-0.28909578919410706,
-0.047962840646505356,
0.16286517679691315,
0.22028356790542603,
-0.6385886669158936,
-0.38197043538093567,
0.01480353344231844,
-0.7105883359909058,
-0.26976314187049866,
-0.0358428880572319,
-0.7593033909797668,
0.014182157814502716,
-0.2199810892343521,
0.10670621693134308,
-0.9548189043998718,
-0.4168832302093506,
-0.299416184425354,
-0.17829932272434235,
0.20710693299770355,
-0.0247043389827013,
-0.7074980735778809,
0.5357250571250916,
0.48862212896347046,
0.8913196325302124,
-0.33926668763160706,
-0.15060460567474365,
0.0014298086753115058,
0.3085824251174927,
-0.10722801834344864,
0.629755437374115,
-0.6062930226325989,
-0.21343094110488892,
0.10654895007610321,
-0.02055165357887745,
-0.4610999524593353,
-0.46826061606407166,
0.93829345703125,
-0.6774163246154785,
0.2853895425796509,
-0.07560055702924728,
-0.75925612449646,
-0.8129533529281616,
0.27763092517852783,
-0.855289876461029,
0.6789969205856323,
0.4350413680076599,
-0.8353070020675659,
0.2243920862674713,
-0.4815232455730438,
-0.4680854082107544,
0.538038432598114,
-0.3639323115348816,
-0.46677330136299133,
-0.19331398606300354,
0.16475506126880646,
-0.0021880236454308033,
-0.3917596638202667,
0.6480199098587036,
-0.11072048544883728,
-0.2622138261795044,
0.14042174816131592,
0.1134023368358612,
1.2332510948181152,
0.2142968624830246,
-0.39207279682159424,
0.09500551968812943,
-0.9573557376861572,
0.5219098329544067,
0.2433243840932846,
-0.21460053324699402,
-0.9697075486183167,
0.3134527802467346,
0.22744230926036835,
0.2617579698562622,
0.09607875347137451,
-0.32293328642845154,
0.39976251125335693,
-0.7575670480728149,
0.2604743540287018,
0.29020220041275024,
0.43427208065986633,
0.5507791042327881,
-0.21315720677375793,
0.49431943893432617,
0.24437353014945984,
-0.2711770236492157,
-0.12806002795696259,
-0.3018719255924225,
-0.7499806880950928,
-0.030605515465140343,
0.4630928039550781,
0.4833793044090271,
-0.7935047745704651,
0.5461329221725464,
-0.3136470913887024,
-0.2499488741159439,
-0.6603772044181824,
-0.03397858142852783,
0.235669806599617,
0.7932420969009399,
0.37479710578918457,
-0.1792522668838501,
-0.5550497174263,
-0.8867198824882507,
-0.26735183596611023,
-0.3619846999645233,
0.3529598116874695,
-0.2070259302854538,
0.33679109811782837,
0.06494084745645523,
0.9513014554977417,
-0.6456378102302551,
-0.5830259919166565,
-0.5473109483718872,
0.15532460808753967,
0.04957862198352814,
0.2567240595817566,
0.7600727677345276,
-0.9771063923835754,
-0.42040643095970154,
0.06525268405675888,
-0.778744101524353,
-0.09764967113733292,
-0.11363095045089722,
-0.2871842384338379,
0.008224083110690117,
0.034710291773080826,
-0.6134633421897888,
0.5378298163414001,
0.13827799260616302,
-0.4448471963405609,
0.31617459654808044,
-0.021374918520450592,
0.41061121225357056,
-1.1630923748016357,
0.05499621853232384,
0.43464359641075134,
0.18343932926654816,
-0.7242759466171265,
0.42781707644462585,
0.11971987783908844,
0.025468114763498306,
-0.12232303619384766,
0.44274935126304626,
-0.6977161765098572,
0.34552448987960815,
-0.4322573244571686,
0.31862273812294006,
-0.1682223081588745,
0.5312365293502808,
0.3482544422149658,
0.21260912716388702,
0.4940059781074524,
-0.4784397780895233,
0.047149818390607834,
0.05280112847685814,
-0.20763684809207916,
0.2806868553161621,
-0.31031563878059387,
-0.1835477650165558,
0.2555846571922302,
-0.23408348858356476,
-0.5323463082313538,
-0.019056713208556175,
0.6887512803077698,
-0.2048102766275406,
0.32939472794532776,
-0.051827795803546906,
-0.5176756381988525,
-0.17296718060970306,
-0.15480278432369232,
0.45710548758506775,
0.1880558729171753,
-0.22382324934005737,
0.834709107875824,
0.7071196436882019,
-0.2257721871137619,
-0.04899478331208229,
-0.27914589643478394,
-0.14375090599060059,
-0.23329459130764008,
-0.9160112738609314,
0.5800223350524902,
0.04797843471169472,
-0.509509801864624,
0.5511108040809631,
-0.1393224149942398,
-0.5264992117881775,
0.1815081089735031,
0.34797853231430054,
0.89495849609375,
-0.5306945443153381,
-0.00792286079376936,
0.19166401028633118,
0.143117755651474,
0.363481730222702,
-0.22705727815628052,
0.33051159977912903,
0.15435335040092468,
0.008943518623709679,
-0.5346189737319946,
0.20991508662700653,
0.19191701710224152,
-0.35681024193763733,
0.6141142845153809,
0.32701241970062256,
-0.8384904861450195,
-0.4343346357345581,
-0.2023419290781021,
0.11146741360425949,
-0.44926321506500244,
0.3927391469478607,
-0.2296411693096161,
-0.3813001215457916,
0.1436978131532669,
0.07899810373783112,
0.03589600324630737,
0.7450904250144958,
0.35992947220802307,
0.19652900099754333,
0.6188271045684814,
0.6088163256645203,
-0.40445274114608765,
0.335408478975296,
-0.19299210608005524,
0.32279086112976074,
-0.4620557129383087,
-0.3721736967563629,
-0.46863630414009094,
-0.4767959713935852,
-0.6195929646492004,
0.04135335236787796,
0.22236603498458862,
-0.107728973031044,
0.2872028052806854,
0.2967919409275055,
-0.6451907753944397,
0.18567433953285217,
0.6821209788322449,
-0.17373380064964294,
0.3300085961818695,
0.16075389087200165,
-0.21113918721675873,
-0.18475341796875,
-0.2450120747089386,
-0.44420158863067627,
0.6935180425643921,
0.12381897121667862,
0.2542368471622467,
-0.09398724138736725,
0.8639596700668335,
-0.1410471647977829,
0.15419359505176544,
-0.9233883023262024,
0.7429720163345337,
-0.14200140535831451,
-0.563923716545105,
-0.40954434871673584,
-0.48515740036964417,
-0.8025928735733032,
0.2704826295375824,
-0.365721732378006,
-0.8032762408256531,
0.049011580646038055,
-0.4228561520576477,
-0.46743080019950867,
0.4657411277294159,
-0.8090095520019531,
0.5924506783485413,
-0.2821162939071655,
-0.06464436650276184,
-0.056778162717819214,
-0.5945698618888855,
0.48822325468063354,
0.008713209070265293,
0.18774724006652832,
0.22228722274303436,
0.4462509751319885,
1.1201332807540894,
-0.34742486476898193,
0.3794461190700531,
-0.08312827348709106,
0.20780129730701447,
0.7353603839874268,
0.05238506942987442,
0.08004657924175262,
-0.02870502881705761,
-0.18694058060646057,
0.10233386605978012,
0.34410035610198975,
0.06452307850122452,
-0.5637878775596619,
0.6938422918319702,
-0.6494529843330383,
-0.5766257643699646,
-0.867763876914978,
-0.5539159774780273,
0.10459943115711212,
0.6337400078773499,
0.07091698050498962,
0.18197552859783173,
-0.11486297845840454,
-0.3047344982624054,
0.3485504686832428,
-0.044432077556848526,
0.5702614784240723,
0.603181779384613,
0.032635126262903214,
-0.2770724892616272,
0.8488560318946838,
0.5778546929359436,
-0.4103787839412689,
0.4302966594696045,
0.23367054760456085,
0.07768464833498001,
-0.8697331547737122,
-0.2655889689922333,
0.2142496556043625,
-0.2936558425426483,
-0.1856425255537033,
-0.615222692489624,
-0.9107401371002197,
-0.5896016359329224,
0.16336697340011597,
0.1610088348388672,
-0.11200036108493805,
-0.2906153202056885,
-0.0057642459869384766,
-0.085061214864254,
0.59059739112854,
0.6287211179733276,
0.4936216175556183,
-0.9833243489265442,
0.44275763630867004,
-0.19955076277256012,
-0.09015893936157227,
0.0841069445014,
-0.038376957178115845,
-0.351603627204895,
-0.15992918610572815,
-0.5551042556762695,
-1.265156626701355,
0.8164169192314148,
0.13722150027751923,
0.56565922498703,
0.7396731376647949,
-0.05838131532073021,
0.7157503962516785,
-0.4547802805900574,
0.6102538704872131,
0.18580235540866852,
-0.6563764810562134,
0.5904182195663452,
-0.1346975713968277,
0.19884517788887024,
0.4418444335460663,
0.18517747521400452,
-0.4866984784603119,
-0.5174949765205383,
-0.8425366282463074,
-0.8971788883209229,
0.9809756278991699,
0.08337127417325974,
-0.49005556106567383,
-0.09412586688995361,
0.649515688419342,
-0.07322102785110474,
-0.08306460827589035,
-1.0053507089614868,
-0.6333318948745728,
0.2643078863620758,
-0.5981802940368652,
0.42385247349739075,
-0.27014273405075073,
0.07936645299196243,
-0.23497119545936584,
0.6432183384895325,
0.3166740834712982,
-0.26041436195373535,
-0.014141065999865532,
-0.20589731633663177,
-0.3294571042060852,
0.4249497652053833,
-0.130551278591156,
0.4332752823829651,
-0.10802552849054337,
0.11566628515720367,
0.00576896732673049,
-0.7496386766433716,
-0.0784321054816246,
0.4597919285297394,
-0.6897801160812378,
0.11564917862415314,
0.5335709452629089,
0.5469781160354614,
0.22726425528526306,
-0.4572823643684387,
0.3522511422634125,
-0.007163320202380419,
0.06812958419322968,
-0.5163182020187378,
0.514650285243988,
0.12555460631847382,
0.2695286273956299,
0.415619432926178,
-0.09387753903865814,
0.5295499563217163,
-0.5513834357261658,
0.25114506483078003,
0.34631112217903137,
0.007670341990888119,
-0.48591259121894836,
0.4559709429740906,
-0.23935295641422272,
-0.43821021914482117,
0.946122407913208,
-0.1596587598323822,
-0.6227769255638123,
0.7730767130851746,
0.6597007513046265,
0.7087956070899963,
-0.3002209961414337,
0.4012482464313507,
0.6655759215354919,
0.1247217059135437,
0.07451693713665009,
0.14259938895702362,
0.006092967931181192,
-0.4092246890068054,
-0.08827511966228485,
-0.8397447466850281,
0.1771576851606369,
0.23036600649356842,
-0.587063729763031,
0.6081590056419373,
-0.3404848873615265,
-0.24358396232128143,
0.21316716074943542,
0.5241315960884094,
-0.7118222117424011,
0.6888039708137512,
0.06617438048124313,
0.5482404828071594,
-0.5266653895378113,
1.24701988697052,
0.8327509760856628,
-0.45392343401908875,
-1.344034194946289,
0.15939760208129883,
0.03938960283994675,
-0.6534942388534546,
0.8806562423706055,
-0.0897279605269432,
0.18784750998020172,
-0.10607127100229263,
-0.30253639817237854,
-0.8075873255729675,
1.223891019821167,
-0.0018463716842234135,
-0.9307369589805603,
-0.6530879735946655,
0.027378028258681297,
0.7386813759803772,
-0.2277848720550537,
0.3544441759586334,
0.6568019986152649,
0.48824343085289,
-0.23492801189422607,
-0.283017635345459,
0.3051872253417969,
-0.4196576178073883,
-0.12268199026584625,
0.5350595712661743,
-0.39265912771224976,
0.6552949547767639,
-0.0677940621972084,
-0.8381556272506714,
0.11942533403635025,
0.7687251567840576,
0.1818332076072693,
0.6189886331558228,
0.4899727404117584,
0.7587305307388306,
0.5799881815910339,
-0.10834629088640213,
0.675584614276886,
-0.40712809562683105,
0.04621897265315056,
1.024186611175537,
-0.09180054068565369,
0.6630821228027344,
0.5063292980194092,
-0.08857079595327377,
0.7951828241348267,
0.6408862471580505,
-0.35726335644721985,
0.5370913743972778,
0.19750572741031647,
-0.2545986771583557,
0.1198030561208725,
-0.10024961829185486,
-0.3245087265968323,
0.41939839720726013,
0.334501713514328,
-0.6600849032402039,
-0.3055611252784729,
-0.27777934074401855,
0.020045043900609016,
0.06243088096380234,
-0.13363522291183472,
0.6560958623886108,
0.3630742132663727,
-0.8459532260894775,
-0.09166406095027924,
0.4037207067012787,
0.13629762828350067,
-0.7081000208854675,
-0.2197725623846054,
0.024011267349123955,
-0.1719355434179306,
-0.1920802742242813,
-0.4296179711818695,
0.05259667709469795,
-0.2742820084095001,
-0.15058571100234985,
0.19519758224487305,
1.0129858255386353,
-0.7174224257469177,
-0.6552640795707703,
0.39127877354621887,
0.5500338077545166,
-0.15399575233459473,
0.5040192008018494,
-0.6389391422271729,
-0.1644018143415451,
-0.017284175381064415,
-0.42346784472465515,
0.3737976849079132,
0.7814856767654419,
-0.25983911752700806,
0.4165923595428467,
0.6145870685577393,
0.7726888656616211,
-0.150056391954422,
0.07505448907613754,
0.767096757888794,
-0.8198056817054749,
-0.5947849750518799,
-1.0588029623031616,
0.2298305779695511,
-0.16869156062602997,
-0.36080121994018555,
0.6471078395843506,
0.39912518858909607,
0.4155539572238922,
0.25639015436172485,
0.6661778092384338,
-0.17959091067314148,
0.23840190470218658,
-0.5131030082702637,
1.166001319885254,
-0.4672662913799286,
0.23470796644687653,
-0.4229075014591217,
-0.7410208582878113,
-0.1837579309940338,
0.4716911315917969,
-0.40262797474861145,
-0.1914348304271698,
1.0868700742721558,
0.30538102984428406,
0.13028374314308167,
0.24691013991832733,
0.08239978551864624,
0.15712900459766388,
0.09718835353851318,
0.5221174955368042,
0.3633580803871155,
-0.4197453558444977,
0.4726867377758026,
-0.4523546099662781,
-0.22244343161582947,
0.26694732904434204,
-0.355836421251297,
-0.8410522937774658,
-0.8420757055282593,
-0.46896132826805115,
-0.17624467611312866,
0.17591433227062225,
0.7512164115905762,
0.22709910571575165,
-0.8554240465164185,
-0.19744829833507538,
0.08793600648641586,
0.3667384386062622,
-0.2943211793899536,
-0.38495784997940063,
0.9614541530609131,
-0.3471098840236664,
-0.8586029410362244,
0.2860545217990875,
0.3894486427307129,
-0.08640272915363312,
0.06771724671125412,
0.1472894251346588,
-0.44794583320617676,
-0.30493301153182983,
0.029071912169456482,
0.13710404932498932,
-0.5035085082054138,
-0.0721563845872879,
0.040717802941799164,
-0.3357163369655609,
0.18225286900997162,
0.8578215837478638,
-0.587534487247467,
0.5868516564369202,
0.4940696358680725,
0.5505114197731018,
0.1016094833612442,
-0.051451634615659714,
0.4861680567264557,
-0.14186285436153412,
-0.13977235555648804,
0.157818004488945,
0.5182209014892578,
0.03135797381401062,
-0.40923112630844116,
0.511705219745636,
0.3965991735458374,
-0.38936856389045715,
-0.49732959270477295,
-0.30735069513320923,
-1.1360068321228027,
-0.37846481800079346,
1.005468726158142,
-0.27413803339004517,
-0.7206683158874512,
-0.17502950131893158,
-0.31336677074432373,
0.9592929482460022,
-0.19429877400398254,
0.9983299374580383,
0.8667962551116943,
0.12925118207931519,
-0.11172351986169815,
-0.5359229445457458,
0.391307532787323,
0.22840197384357452,
-0.918010413646698,
-0.5966736078262329,
0.25970545411109924,
0.4791608154773712,
0.26270291209220886,
0.7380954027175903,
-0.2854865491390228,
-0.009822456166148186,
-0.11427941918373108,
0.17517662048339844,
0.11549405753612518,
-0.021493447944521904,
0.128557026386261,
0.5351653695106506,
-0.18102847039699554,
-0.27504226565361023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10738v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10738v2 | Let's Learn Step by Step: Enhancing In-Context Learning Ability with Curriculum Learning | 2024-02-16T14:55:33 | 2024-06-16T13:26:10 | Yinpeng Liu, Jiawei Liu, Xiang Shi, Qikai Cheng, Yong Huang, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Demonstration ordering, which is an important strategy for in-context
learning (ICL), can significantly affects the performance of large language
models (LLMs). However, most of the current approaches of ordering require high
computational costs to introduce the priori knowledge. In this paper, inspired
by the human learning process, we propose a simple but effective demonstration
ordering method for ICL, named the few-shot In-Context Curriculum Learning
(ICCL). The ICCL implies gradually increasing the complexity of prompt
demonstrations during the inference process. The difficulty can be assessed by
human experts or LLMs-driven metrics, such as perplexity. Then we design
extensive experiments to discuss the effectiveness of the ICCL at both
corpus-level and instance-level. Moreover, we also investigate the formation
mechanism of LLM's ICCL capability. Experimental results demonstrate that ICCL,
developed during the instruction-tuning stage, is effective for representative
open-source LLMs. To facilitate further research and applications by other
scholars, we make the code publicly available. | [
-0.46626394987106323,
-0.64584881067276,
0.5369596481323242,
0.14357827603816986,
-0.2706569731235504,
0.10007362067699432,
-0.2021207958459854,
-0.28586822748184204,
-0.5184760689735413,
0.3889516592025757,
-0.4945653975009918,
-0.7670495510101318,
-0.3880147337913513,
0.034067947417497635,
-0.3097572922706604,
0.811469316482544,
0.24089905619621277,
0.1509174108505249,
-0.22201715409755707,
-0.2258490025997162,
-0.08641479164361954,
-0.20088662207126617,
-0.6119787693023682,
-0.33507856726646423,
0.3713953197002411,
0.9808220863342285,
0.23216809332370758,
0.765133261680603,
0.29790830612182617,
0.25347083806991577,
-0.12393229454755783,
0.1781102418899536,
-0.50761878490448,
-0.12078522145748138,
-0.1479673981666565,
-0.5121577382087708,
-0.00682660611346364,
0.04098192974925041,
0.648557186126709,
0.7823858261108398,
-0.03039485216140747,
0.16780053079128265,
0.31752076745033264,
0.5049927234649658,
-0.7036747932434082,
0.22064150869846344,
-0.5938618183135986,
-0.1305018663406372,
-0.15995940566062927,
-0.02344868890941143,
-0.891273558139801,
-0.23415906727313995,
0.39643800258636475,
-0.26494792103767395,
0.020042572170495987,
0.24617615342140198,
0.3302074074745178,
0.023817118257284164,
-0.40383100509643555,
-0.20773790776729584,
-0.367063045501709,
0.9320414066314697,
-0.6153387427330017,
0.24598555266857147,
0.33479639887809753,
0.4640616178512573,
-0.3442673683166504,
-0.8885700702667236,
-0.4970070421695709,
-0.357058048248291,
-0.08029436320066452,
0.12270834296941757,
0.23776888847351074,
0.0546477846801281,
0.461315780878067,
-0.0900600329041481,
-0.5215364098548889,
0.48263102769851685,
-0.33729180693626404,
0.06949671357870102,
0.2623462378978729,
0.16636928915977478,
0.1641402691602707,
-0.175737664103508,
-0.559518575668335,
-0.2563827931880951,
-1.071782112121582,
0.3051995635032654,
-0.035985663533210754,
0.5540712475776672,
-0.29336845874786377,
0.3926609456539154,
-0.36368367075920105,
0.4851793944835663,
0.15876628458499908,
-0.2748551368713379,
-0.0024932834785431623,
-0.0400254987180233,
-0.26037684082984924,
0.25663402676582336,
0.5237733125686646,
-0.12237721681594849,
-0.33563360571861267,
0.22394944727420807,
-0.05037418380379677,
-0.19354762136936188,
0.16730386018753052,
-1.0523446798324585,
0.0861339420080185,
0.06660478562116623,
-0.24784733355045319,
-0.2006889134645462,
-0.011726164259016514,
-0.5438954830169678,
-0.29771995544433594,
-0.3074612617492676,
0.589635968208313,
-0.673992395401001,
0.23872950673103333,
-0.17613156139850616,
0.3443368375301361,
0.3600479066371918,
0.46176084876060486,
-0.7999000549316406,
0.4766213893890381,
0.724053680896759,
0.7725298404693604,
-0.24766767024993896,
-0.4075283706188202,
-0.7689568400382996,
0.03795154392719269,
-0.39208799600601196,
0.6278420090675354,
-0.2961578965187073,
-0.3965892195701599,
0.07605785876512527,
-0.4145098328590393,
0.22040514647960663,
-0.4901476800441742,
0.32610440254211426,
-0.5660098791122437,
0.0925159603357315,
-0.1577029973268509,
-0.8196539878845215,
-0.14285162091255188,
0.14451748132705688,
-0.2283276915550232,
0.6981791257858276,
-0.14672234654426575,
-0.6113237738609314,
0.45998868346214294,
-0.7412116527557373,
-0.4424734115600586,
0.26465505361557007,
-0.4889298379421234,
-0.38403284549713135,
-0.040398359298706055,
0.23801131546497345,
0.726963460445404,
-0.04990130662918091,
-0.0592653751373291,
-0.06545623391866684,
-0.6374295353889465,
0.1909521520137787,
-0.3795202076435089,
0.9534295797348022,
0.18963998556137085,
-0.6368942856788635,
0.14319412410259247,
-0.663913369178772,
0.02356942929327488,
-0.10642792284488678,
-0.3541538715362549,
-0.16570952534675598,
0.1376468390226364,
-0.3192957043647766,
0.20954439043998718,
-0.15452170372009277,
-0.204508975148201,
0.19563007354736328,
-0.6389983892440796,
0.12744097411632538,
0.6635534763336182,
0.059964071959257126,
0.776333749294281,
-0.18913915753364563,
0.3567754328250885,
-0.009759752079844475,
0.14669524133205414,
-0.43650931119918823,
-0.4036696255207062,
-0.7836657762527466,
-0.3468019962310791,
0.027924034744501114,
0.386999249458313,
-0.6310633420944214,
0.06803648918867111,
-0.004317890387028456,
-0.4370427131652832,
-0.24770963191986084,
0.27573323249816895,
0.7566437721252441,
0.643121600151062,
0.4877163767814636,
-0.2255246937274933,
-0.22683821618556976,
-0.6730763912200928,
0.1292894184589386,
-0.3089215159416199,
-0.1580725610256195,
0.17807035148143768,
0.43890297412872314,
0.1578516811132431,
0.8659681677818298,
-0.47221827507019043,
-0.13040205836296082,
-0.42140108346939087,
0.5390849709510803,
0.17905400693416595,
0.3565462827682495,
0.40593618154525757,
-0.5671044588088989,
-0.548340916633606,
-0.0016547776758670807,
-0.5243489742279053,
-0.017183881253004074,
0.012401985004544258,
-0.1400943100452423,
0.26756948232650757,
0.7950339913368225,
-0.13626231253147125,
0.5266821384429932,
0.18353360891342163,
0.2166329324245453,
0.5727874040603638,
-0.3485187888145447,
-0.04024331644177437,
-0.8354070782661438,
-0.6083346009254456,
-0.12031004577875137,
-0.17095740139484406,
-0.44729357957839966,
0.3122098743915558,
0.38897886872291565,
-0.025942165404558182,
-0.9310323596000671,
0.5164976119995117,
-0.5040284991264343,
-0.05194531008601189,
-0.23142407834529877,
0.18970602750778198,
-0.34947291016578674,
0.5174992084503174,
0.12118165194988251,
0.8962520360946655,
0.6587491631507874,
-0.8022355437278748,
-0.41044360399246216,
0.2563124895095825,
-0.9313395619392395,
0.6045036911964417,
-0.12249631434679031,
0.11459952592849731,
-0.13261926174163818,
0.2936824560165405,
-1.1461012363433838,
-0.30153727531433105,
-0.021164029836654663,
-0.07790093868970871,
0.45184943079948425,
-0.281708300113678,
-0.3410622775554657,
-0.021423732861876488,
-0.1815488636493683,
0.2258942723274231,
0.6114146709442139,
-0.9784362316131592,
0.2074761986732483,
-0.08015777170658112,
0.08524513989686966,
-0.4796873927116394,
-0.4883487820625305,
-0.008600800298154354,
-0.19811716675758362,
-0.31739696860313416,
0.4385139048099518,
-0.43315669894218445,
-0.43452608585357666,
-0.582388162612915,
0.06955908983945847,
-0.09774351119995117,
0.10538815706968307,
0.3265765309333801,
-0.017839347943663597,
-0.4192747175693512,
0.2942679226398468,
0.3191729485988617,
-0.06702619045972824,
-0.20303259789943695,
-0.1524023711681366,
0.25386279821395874,
-0.2506565749645233,
-0.6348967552185059,
-0.6541418433189392,
0.353241503238678,
0.4987636208534241,
-0.04294878616929054,
0.6145778894424438,
0.2723885178565979,
-0.11916059255599976,
-0.6618452072143555,
-0.3537478446960449,
-0.3023369610309601,
-0.5495215654373169,
0.3626171052455902,
-0.3405188322067261,
-0.6723078489303589,
0.059051018208265305,
-0.4641275107860565,
0.3110392987728119,
-0.17724135518074036,
0.4099445343017578,
-0.25187140703201294,
1.0478229522705078,
0.6818403601646423,
0.018195321783423424,
0.6383858323097229,
-0.34689202904701233,
-0.05698532611131668,
-0.6330199241638184,
-0.018012529239058495,
-0.43168002367019653,
-0.17200195789337158,
-0.36273083090782166,
-0.4770036041736603,
0.5476585030555725,
0.4183639585971832,
-0.5722575783729553,
0.328308641910553,
-0.17187102138996124,
0.9092887043952942,
0.5214002132415771,
0.5108218789100647,
0.4068737328052521,
0.08181922137737274,
-0.516693651676178,
-0.09858140349388123,
-0.671278715133667,
-0.6738123893737793,
0.7806528210639954,
-0.04189214110374451,
0.6959632635116577,
0.3014586865901947,
1.115246295928955,
-0.034914739429950714,
0.6046297550201416,
-0.7517273426055908,
0.7886711359024048,
-0.10843178629875183,
-0.22876809537410736,
-0.4239332377910614,
0.06000172719359398,
-0.6682582497596741,
0.3040168583393097,
-0.24593600630760193,
-0.9310138821601868,
-0.04187821224331856,
0.025497449561953545,
-0.40010130405426025,
0.09371110051870346,
-0.843285322189331,
0.5845014452934265,
-0.32907834649086,
-0.6541057825088501,
-0.4503489136695862,
-0.8998284339904785,
0.27128836512565613,
0.13128481805324554,
0.3281662166118622,
0.2246997356414795,
-0.07481300085783005,
0.45175138115882874,
-0.44066593050956726,
1.048413872718811,
0.039307255297899246,
0.07697715610265732,
0.38683298230171204,
0.39496394991874695,
0.5281902551651001,
0.12385854870080948,
-0.2334112524986267,
-0.17051881551742554,
-0.5549430251121521,
-0.37871235609054565,
-0.6246011853218079,
0.6492027044296265,
-0.6174789071083069,
-0.7800803780555725,
-0.032140668481588364,
-0.3903900682926178,
-0.28594058752059937,
0.02697499468922615,
0.34432992339134216,
0.6767691969871521,
-0.0838712751865387,
0.19247667491436005,
0.7022001147270203,
-0.23990148305892944,
0.7917690277099609,
0.5280777215957642,
-0.13200967013835907,
-0.14401227235794067,
0.8264312148094177,
0.13466010987758636,
0.6792088150978088,
0.6076048612594604,
0.4460005760192871,
-0.06608536094427109,
-0.8499041199684143,
-0.39808571338653564,
0.02060122974216938,
-0.9655009508132935,
-0.1040700301527977,
-0.5278040766716003,
-0.05162368714809418,
-0.24569560587406158,
-0.660891592502594,
-0.2994840145111084,
-0.06786201149225235,
-0.44433489441871643,
-0.19358712434768677,
0.07540852576494217,
0.7799897789955139,
0.2079637348651886,
0.5738070011138916,
-0.4498075544834137,
0.05525951087474823,
0.594420313835144,
0.16393586993217468,
0.14548730850219727,
-0.5735997557640076,
-0.15221725404262543,
-0.11551982164382935,
-0.5216185450553894,
-0.5443122386932373,
0.23389287292957306,
0.2148139774799347,
0.5109817385673523,
0.8811047673225403,
0.1679992973804474,
1.0613154172897339,
-0.716471791267395,
0.697093665599823,
0.108941949903965,
-1.0098483562469482,
0.5757139325141907,
-0.06832098215818405,
0.36879974603652954,
0.5888667702674866,
0.4234686493873596,
-0.07780502736568451,
-0.5205519199371338,
-0.540514349937439,
-0.8533326387405396,
1.003369927406311,
0.17611028254032135,
0.18962417542934418,
-0.10325556248426437,
0.24554111063480377,
0.26662951707839966,
-0.0668795257806778,
-0.6101921796798706,
-0.3332594037055969,
0.06177685037255287,
-0.012803488411009312,
0.04178961366415024,
-0.2258376181125641,
0.001021348056383431,
-0.3884948492050171,
0.6432680487632751,
-0.44051751494407654,
-0.11152656376361847,
-0.006042600609362125,
-0.4327077865600586,
0.18632785975933075,
0.45850446820259094,
0.8399271368980408,
0.8975773453712463,
-0.17483343183994293,
0.25181230902671814,
0.47624310851097107,
-0.09798233956098557,
0.06808329373598099,
-0.42629796266555786,
-0.002592432778328657,
-0.46481597423553467,
0.5873461961746216,
0.6265925168991089,
0.6489621996879578,
-0.7346729040145874,
0.7658267617225647,
0.05949007719755173,
-0.020002419129014015,
-0.20674237608909607,
0.1607648730278015,
0.03693980351090431,
0.6360638737678528,
0.4524095356464386,
-0.278626948595047,
0.07919444143772125,
-0.6030107736587524,
0.5099906921386719,
0.2440030425786972,
-0.4449303150177002,
-0.03347737342119217,
0.44054362177848816,
-0.015026317909359932,
-0.46214544773101807,
0.6553767919540405,
-0.3591849207878113,
-0.36649999022483826,
0.6818519234657288,
0.9686670303344727,
0.5530095100402832,
-0.07945679873228073,
0.40690451860427856,
0.4510663151741028,
0.05355408042669296,
-0.31559038162231445,
-0.1459193378686905,
-0.36137303709983826,
-0.5577897429466248,
-0.4279956817626953,
-0.4360669255256653,
-0.7298595905303955,
-0.22492048144340515,
-0.5268325209617615,
0.6493071913719177,
-0.6505462527275085,
0.2655896842479706,
-0.10109366476535797,
-0.06019694730639458,
-0.5822783708572388,
0.005390842445194721,
0.2370128035545349,
0.8613842725753784,
-0.6727119088172913,
0.9093860387802124,
0.4536883234977722,
-0.44359782338142395,
-0.7436725497245789,
0.21520188450813293,
0.22006924450397491,
-0.6608917117118835,
1.0983457565307617,
0.35717275738716125,
-0.10870324075222015,
0.22895044088363647,
-1.0245237350463867,
-0.5845355987548828,
1.1348469257354736,
0.37078002095222473,
-0.5128903985023499,
0.24445663392543793,
-0.2372068613767624,
0.47205477952957153,
-0.6135464906692505,
0.5295408964157104,
0.1680433750152588,
0.19411782920360565,
0.3637600839138031,
-0.3607329726219177,
-0.10495222359895706,
0.4810467064380646,
-0.12059950828552246,
-0.14980366826057434,
-0.5417346954345703,
0.5758163928985596,
-0.6200761795043945,
-0.34750697016716003,
0.21236461400985718,
0.9826231598854065,
0.3987008333206177,
0.3205598294734955,
0.51407390832901,
0.13812774419784546,
0.6190505027770996,
0.13404032588005066,
1.15285062789917,
0.17114728689193726,
0.1381300836801529,
1.3394250869750977,
-0.4079696238040924,
1.0707844495773315,
0.5282943248748779,
-0.3607933819293976,
0.6945390701293945,
0.5182653069496155,
0.46478503942489624,
0.5659767389297485,
0.32047340273857117,
-0.5001813173294067,
-0.4923807978630066,
-0.0016552391462028027,
0.06771459430456161,
0.363070011138916,
0.4517970681190491,
-0.06060241907835007,
-0.4244854152202606,
0.24128195643424988,
-0.11489575356245041,
0.17152158915996552,
-0.21539412438869476,
0.8318573236465454,
0.26398441195487976,
-0.4428575932979584,
0.5547720789909363,
-0.30574190616607666,
0.5735004544258118,
-0.5701286196708679,
-0.3520846366882324,
-0.29309409856796265,
-0.021696964278817177,
-0.05565466359257698,
-0.5860376954078674,
-0.20044149458408356,
-0.09936606138944626,
-0.090343177318573,
-0.3431773781776428,
0.18702004849910736,
-0.30001071095466614,
-0.3237226605415344,
0.40293240547180176,
0.3332809805870056,
0.3378185033798218,
0.2795160114765167,
-0.38845035433769226,
-0.35523760318756104,
-0.2879965305328369,
-0.2240070253610611,
0.7604648470878601,
0.1834343820810318,
-0.45998716354370117,
0.7458539605140686,
0.47438499331474304,
-0.3350837230682373,
0.09365801513195038,
0.12476200610399246,
0.5808037519454956,
-0.40950366854667664,
-0.3232230246067047,
-0.8686463236808777,
0.5775087475776672,
-0.00807433482259512,
-0.10120626538991928,
0.5254988670349121,
0.37548887729644775,
1.1383951902389526,
0.033001434057950974,
0.5460145473480225,
0.008207711391150951,
0.22939777374267578,
-0.5775997042655945,
0.587700366973877,
-0.5287871956825256,
0.4497687518596649,
-0.3445904552936554,
-0.5103381276130676,
-0.7173195481300354,
0.45105817914009094,
-0.1837843954563141,
-0.30341458320617676,
0.9561699032783508,
1.0015536546707153,
-0.2040611207485199,
0.027275225147604942,
0.6535731554031372,
0.2507074177265167,
0.3058391213417053,
0.2678627669811249,
0.8042771816253662,
-0.16265171766281128,
0.5928122997283936,
-0.6175495386123657,
-0.3474687933921814,
-0.14690905809402466,
-1.060411810874939,
-1.013054609298706,
-0.47451433539390564,
-0.3378210961818695,
-0.11937011033296585,
0.011263517662882805,
1.46963369846344,
0.7605670690536499,
-0.7505711317062378,
-0.5480239391326904,
-0.16461344063282013,
0.4854888617992401,
-0.5180756449699402,
-0.1466839611530304,
0.6031703948974609,
-0.5844743251800537,
-0.9174171090126038,
0.761137068271637,
0.2854141592979431,
-0.06363940238952637,
-0.00532615277916193,
-0.14422205090522766,
-0.3619033396244049,
-0.09591372311115265,
0.8791618943214417,
0.24426907300949097,
-0.8399550914764404,
-0.3797633945941925,
-0.2880310118198395,
-0.19337961077690125,
0.18638823926448822,
0.9165693521499634,
-0.8503257036209106,
0.5654748678207397,
0.5052869915962219,
0.6950996518135071,
0.5354518890380859,
-0.19076448678970337,
0.23119843006134033,
-1.0175766944885254,
0.1526184380054474,
-0.12189766019582748,
0.3305748701095581,
-0.027849746868014336,
-0.1445457488298416,
0.37469372153282166,
-0.022004686295986176,
-0.4143914580345154,
-0.6162467002868652,
0.3331969678401947,
-0.9875480532646179,
-0.29729747772216797,
0.8905129432678223,
-0.17268025875091553,
-0.17597965896129608,
-0.11745111644268036,
-0.3854069113731384,
0.23381249606609344,
-0.4451107084751129,
0.8092759251594543,
0.35880565643310547,
-0.40528449416160583,
-0.11319714784622192,
-0.3759867548942566,
0.28243589401245117,
0.2587023079395294,
-0.7788753509521484,
-0.12849992513656616,
0.3424402177333832,
0.2599635124206543,
-0.010644380934536457,
0.49148210883140564,
-0.09768358618021011,
0.22769255936145782,
-0.34251412749290466,
-0.1497599333524704,
0.06288930028676987,
-0.48807695508003235,
-0.43099144101142883,
0.375654935836792,
0.2119181752204895,
-0.023681428283452988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10735v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10735v2 | Assessing the Reasoning Abilities of ChatGPT in the Context of Claim Verification | 2024-02-16T14:52:05 | 2024-03-20T19:14:54 | John Dougrez-Lewis, Mahmud Elahi Akhter, Yulan He, Maria Liakata | cs.CL | cs.CL | The reasoning capabilities of LLMs are currently hotly debated. We examine
the issue from the perspective of claim/rumour verification. We propose the
first logical reasoning framework designed to break down any claim or rumour
paired with evidence into the atomic reasoning steps necessary for
verification. Based on our framework, we curate two annotated collections of
such claim/evidence pairs: a synthetic dataset from Wikipedia and a real-world
set stemming from rumours circulating on Twitter. We use them to evaluate the
reasoning capabilities of GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4 (hereinafter referred to as
ChatGPT) within the context of our framework, providing a thorough analysis.
Our results show that ChatGPT struggles in abductive reasoning, although this
can be somewhat mitigated by using manual Chain of Thought (CoT) as opposed to
Zero-Shot (ZS) and ZS CoT approaches. Our study contributes to the growing body
of research suggesting that ChatGPT's reasoning processes are unlikely to
mirror human-like reasoning, and that LLMs need to be more rigorously evaluated
to distinguish between hype and actual capabilities, especially in high-stakes
real-world tasks such as claim verification. | [
-0.4745459258556366,
-0.692826509475708,
0.685496985912323,
-0.08552123606204987,
-0.20416231453418732,
0.33839285373687744,
-0.26310044527053833,
-0.585702657699585,
-0.04868127033114433,
0.31872355937957764,
-0.6227428913116455,
-0.2218182235956192,
-0.6793617606163025,
0.11537715047597885,
-0.3646160364151001,
1.108416199684143,
-0.15689696371555328,
-0.35915520787239075,
-0.14763371646404266,
0.13307610154151917,
-0.44406062364578247,
-0.5907310843467712,
-0.4767148792743683,
-0.2849434018135071,
0.4770720899105072,
0.30925995111465454,
0.786489725112915,
0.24302692711353302,
0.5300062894821167,
0.2210543304681778,
-0.12464726716279984,
0.43441322445869446,
-0.5073059797286987,
0.1341947615146637,
-0.22072191536426544,
-0.6016959547996521,
-0.3756864070892334,
0.14959076046943665,
0.36214086413383484,
0.2502589523792267,
-0.2267875075340271,
0.1459440290927887,
-0.04961249232292175,
0.5098877549171448,
-0.5197181105613708,
0.27119362354278564,
-1.1000890731811523,
0.06156914681196213,
-0.2649618983268738,
-0.17052629590034485,
-0.39989539980888367,
-0.3068574368953705,
0.3623403310775757,
-0.30910953879356384,
0.2598850727081299,
0.3248549699783325,
1.009333610534668,
0.1845751702785492,
-0.2840301990509033,
-0.378474622964859,
-0.6771368384361267,
0.3042238652706146,
-0.5437222719192505,
0.2174742966890335,
0.3372127413749695,
0.6975379586219788,
-0.15766051411628723,
-0.6452763080596924,
-0.5321184396743774,
-0.45337292551994324,
-0.12343794852495193,
0.15175658464431763,
-0.13158516585826874,
0.12761108577251434,
0.6067696809768677,
0.5197106003761292,
-0.6816696524620056,
-0.14506594836711884,
-0.5649399161338806,
-0.7198204398155212,
0.48336243629455566,
-0.1535210758447647,
0.2981679141521454,
-0.10945599526166916,
-0.674653172492981,
0.335542768239975,
-1.016319751739502,
-0.3192155361175537,
0.19794346392154694,
-0.016003375872969627,
-0.04048023745417595,
0.7151694297790527,
-0.3201737403869629,
0.3006543219089508,
-0.22202835977077484,
-0.14198511838912964,
-0.10653913766145706,
-0.2893330156803131,
-0.3064647316932678,
0.343795508146286,
0.6736910939216614,
0.26540741324424744,
0.34646984934806824,
-0.4068215787410736,
-0.26838418841362,
0.323189377784729,
0.16771921515464783,
-0.7694013118743896,
-0.15502315759658813,
0.22596457600593567,
-0.18307162821292877,
-0.2977626919746399,
0.01798352785408497,
-0.35310953855514526,
-0.5094413757324219,
-0.038917701691389084,
0.4941862225532532,
-0.5291404128074646,
-0.5027609467506409,
0.27896252274513245,
-0.29473984241485596,
0.3739287853240967,
0.5628161430358887,
-0.5198352932929993,
0.20829612016677856,
1.0305328369140625,
0.6661660075187683,
0.001237354357726872,
-0.20888912677764893,
-0.0988411009311676,
0.04184726998209953,
-0.3343783915042877,
1.346382737159729,
-0.13003653287887573,
-0.08511921018362045,
-0.1115199401974678,
-0.2845713496208191,
-0.0809343010187149,
-0.419006884098053,
0.8674412965774536,
-0.5184455513954163,
0.29544776678085327,
-0.5633012056350708,
-0.6769221425056458,
-0.189902201294899,
0.7965801358222961,
-0.4182779788970947,
0.7765597701072693,
0.06400196999311447,
-0.8796257376670837,
0.5448042154312134,
-0.5116060972213745,
-0.30184200406074524,
0.15503594279289246,
-0.4605831205844879,
-0.06887447088956833,
-0.13564154505729675,
0.15993192791938782,
0.18097473680973053,
-0.6623040437698364,
0.15567146241664886,
-0.2953996956348419,
-0.3522348403930664,
0.5550281405448914,
-0.8394711017608643,
0.6351435780525208,
0.35313495993614197,
-0.5000190138816833,
-0.2012384533882141,
-0.43653494119644165,
0.07644204050302505,
0.07642977684736252,
-0.07082170993089676,
0.3473846912384033,
0.22336789965629578,
-0.6183062195777893,
0.2392699420452118,
0.04216229170560837,
-0.5574411749839783,
0.36892572045326233,
-0.3091354966163635,
0.4841499328613281,
0.6835284233093262,
0.06501366198062897,
-0.0014156148536130786,
-0.6439530253410339,
0.5036109089851379,
-0.1063784509897232,
-0.0626218393445015,
-0.10759805142879486,
-0.618384599685669,
-0.7015736103057861,
-0.3121882975101471,
0.30150657892227173,
0.6266570091247559,
-0.7887462973594666,
0.06190621107816696,
-0.22691407799720764,
-0.5290483832359314,
-0.3043002188205719,
-0.09713315218687057,
0.2366112768650055,
0.644766092300415,
0.24546384811401367,
0.09371466189622879,
-0.47419753670692444,
-0.9355195164680481,
-0.42757871747016907,
-0.7849020957946777,
-0.12030254304409027,
0.1126880943775177,
0.32073265314102173,
0.019610755145549774,
1.0881892442703247,
-0.35307347774505615,
-0.017293071374297142,
-0.30537572503089905,
0.2541370987892151,
0.10645288974046707,
0.13671520352363586,
0.36634957790374756,
-0.6026150584220886,
-0.11535053700208664,
-0.02211647294461727,
-0.9231787323951721,
-0.16601599752902985,
-0.1612892597913742,
-0.19210630655288696,
0.2746133506298065,
0.08820006251335144,
-1.127984642982483,
0.6377446055412292,
0.05256669223308563,
-0.41672804951667786,
0.9182459712028503,
0.13457174599170685,
0.29358768463134766,
-0.4399503171443939,
-0.3497605621814728,
-0.14584878087043762,
-0.24884814023971558,
-0.27657702565193176,
-0.07459287345409393,
-0.16635842621326447,
0.09266158938407898,
-0.380409300327301,
0.29794567823410034,
-0.45148634910583496,
-0.07836513221263885,
-0.46933233737945557,
0.3330274522304535,
-0.02082647755742073,
0.24107028543949127,
0.03290444612503052,
0.7886236310005188,
0.5874589681625366,
-0.5037397146224976,
0.4241349697113037,
0.008700724691152573,
-0.4255490303039551,
0.6837798357009888,
-0.4822582006454468,
0.09121853858232498,
0.0654626339673996,
0.5513660311698914,
-1.1358046531677246,
-0.10596559941768646,
0.4985368847846985,
-0.6829702258110046,
-0.1056913211941719,
-0.32661473751068115,
-0.7187421321868896,
-0.5000336766242981,
-0.11954902112483978,
0.019809219986200333,
0.739385724067688,
-0.4728328585624695,
0.6095848083496094,
0.18731153011322021,
0.0042159766890108585,
-0.4373701512813568,
-0.5202069282531738,
0.2401912957429886,
-0.44174447655677795,
-0.8559316992759705,
0.22461533546447754,
0.21387441456317902,
-0.6437334418296814,
-0.04021777585148811,
-0.507270336151123,
-0.013984189368784428,
-0.05992816761136055,
0.14362891018390656,
0.41333311796188354,
-0.40614449977874756,
0.05903926491737366,
-0.2008318305015564,
-0.33272498846054077,
0.46326568722724915,
-0.3008560240268707,
0.19787731766700745,
-0.528764545917511,
-0.6592418551445007,
-0.20342621207237244,
-0.16205994784832,
0.5134714245796204,
-0.0371272936463356,
0.4334007203578949,
0.704760730266571,
-0.4592428505420685,
-0.2064647227525711,
-0.955906093120575,
-0.18945646286010742,
-0.44020217657089233,
0.0635421872138977,
-0.5099166035652161,
-0.8028984069824219,
0.5330587029457092,
-0.1758643388748169,
0.13313081860542297,
0.6657155752182007,
0.7450667023658752,
-0.055813707411289215,
0.688254714012146,
0.08806426078081131,
0.08612461388111115,
-0.3308575451374054,
-0.1106509193778038,
0.27465227246284485,
-0.6687800884246826,
-0.162409245967865,
-0.3302936851978302,
-0.15023507177829742,
-0.44459646940231323,
-0.6329739093780518,
0.19264857470989227,
0.08789578080177307,
-0.2895520031452179,
0.24545952677726746,
-0.3881840705871582,
0.5362482666969299,
0.09173161536455154,
0.23640510439872742,
0.5459300875663757,
-0.1250901073217392,
-0.15277591347694397,
0.19487805664539337,
-0.6796704530715942,
-0.7593546509742737,
0.9220914244651794,
0.5118311643600464,
0.5722195506095886,
0.2783861756324768,
0.42604315280914307,
0.44177958369255066,
0.7125374674797058,
-0.8547582030296326,
0.7804497480392456,
0.5249120593070984,
-0.9552982449531555,
-0.10187704861164093,
-0.5375818610191345,
-0.42494499683380127,
0.5644755363464355,
-0.19261741638183594,
-0.9716055393218994,
-0.2516898512840271,
0.053606897592544556,
-0.36186593770980835,
0.578784704208374,
-0.6897387504577637,
0.5242881774902344,
-0.4276581406593323,
-0.39294734597206116,
-0.3769165873527527,
-0.5591109395027161,
0.6973006129264832,
0.19262835383415222,
0.15883156657218933,
-0.6107763648033142,
0.07349661737680435,
0.5573267936706543,
-0.6580092906951904,
0.7121326923370361,
-0.23568665981292725,
-0.4160884916782379,
0.8834095597267151,
0.31092387437820435,
0.5125951766967773,
0.2796592116355896,
-0.10940860956907272,
0.17840175330638885,
0.12118406593799591,
-0.21185532212257385,
-0.6439992189407349,
0.3244956433773041,
-0.47978994250297546,
-0.8713085651397705,
-0.5991313457489014,
-0.3619631230831146,
-0.3995622396469116,
0.07033739984035492,
0.3342246115207672,
0.1666879653930664,
-0.26625922322273254,
-0.0550558902323246,
0.6360111832618713,
0.03226325660943985,
0.11380984634160995,
0.44110581278800964,
-0.3657430410385132,
-0.3211612105369568,
0.7757278084754944,
0.11847009509801865,
0.4341667592525482,
0.14314977824687958,
0.32902881503105164,
-0.3965173363685608,
-0.6197680234909058,
-0.4066898822784424,
0.04484870657324791,
-0.8111221194267273,
-0.24604278802871704,
-0.3369319438934326,
-0.5819339752197266,
-0.09971694648265839,
0.008729037828743458,
-0.5278832316398621,
-0.5931420922279358,
0.4521271884441376,
-0.27831584215164185,
0.44697949290275574,
0.6266429424285889,
-0.0791521817445755,
0.05113614350557327,
-0.5335065722465515,
0.4630030691623688,
0.2690492272377014,
0.222834050655365,
-0.2534883916378021,
-0.47258251905441284,
0.08064252883195877,
0.22399312257766724,
-0.24659012258052826,
-0.7852858304977417,
-0.09669045358896255,
-0.223356232047081,
0.6570897102355957,
0.5144781470298767,
0.16581955552101135,
0.6279851794242859,
-0.41767385601997375,
0.7796204090118408,
0.053535718470811844,
-0.60554039478302,
0.4417847692966461,
-0.48225459456443787,
-0.23047691583633423,
0.4076724648475647,
0.3371870815753937,
-0.3896433115005493,
-0.37521395087242126,
-0.9330491423606873,
-0.5001090168952942,
0.34441179037094116,
0.47266456484794617,
-0.36464110016822815,
0.002912662923336029,
0.3192586302757263,
0.1793190985918045,
0.020548425614833832,
-0.6146523356437683,
-0.08803267776966095,
0.08556968718767166,
0.1806555986404419,
0.5007625222206116,
-0.388750821352005,
-0.32043978571891785,
-0.1672411561012268,
0.6274858713150024,
-0.09498701244592667,
0.4858696758747101,
0.2756834924221039,
-0.17592428624629974,
0.19483524560928345,
0.39929279685020447,
0.38484829664230347,
0.9683691263198853,
-0.299953430891037,
0.31940096616744995,
0.29595956206321716,
-0.3200950622558594,
0.21954606473445892,
0.20183375477790833,
-0.039047129452228546,
-0.10725101083517075,
0.4165191054344177,
0.5676827430725098,
0.1579786241054535,
-0.6532309651374817,
0.6091753840446472,
-0.1692345142364502,
-0.5087110996246338,
-0.40654468536376953,
0.1958431601524353,
-0.00013525382382795215,
0.2711588442325592,
0.3757118880748749,
0.23996682465076447,
-0.019750157371163368,
-0.5089561343193054,
0.26678207516670227,
0.3190496861934662,
-0.10890481621026993,
-0.22407230734825134,
0.4880622327327728,
0.0714215636253357,
-0.043902844190597534,
0.644821286201477,
-0.46246537566185,
-0.7433611750602722,
0.5935184359550476,
0.4737718403339386,
0.8339280486106873,
0.3655332624912262,
0.3121274411678314,
0.21604037284851074,
0.7001228332519531,
-0.2616410553455353,
0.05395285785198212,
-0.1711684912443161,
-0.9947255849838257,
-0.5403212904930115,
-0.07649600505828857,
-0.7912804484367371,
-0.03425862640142441,
-0.2535921037197113,
0.4263003468513489,
-0.4312494099140167,
-0.043242160230875015,
-0.16367028653621674,
-0.011366225779056549,
-0.4835067391395569,
-0.056213755160570145,
0.5199098587036133,
1.0376129150390625,
-0.5184642672538757,
0.547548234462738,
0.2945108115673065,
-0.39787155389785767,
-0.8437453508377075,
0.2650199830532074,
0.47657251358032227,
-1.1251919269561768,
0.5726993083953857,
0.36275917291641235,
-0.3366307318210602,
-0.20878911018371582,
-0.5497464537620544,
-0.6437256336212158,
1.1385300159454346,
0.6262521743774414,
-0.25059396028518677,
-0.03671247884631157,
0.15765231847763062,
0.19708773493766785,
-0.21598441898822784,
0.556154727935791,
0.6315507888793945,
0.4985191524028778,
0.561941921710968,
-1.1364606618881226,
0.1353442668914795,
0.03509966656565666,
-0.3855908215045929,
-0.17561350762844086,
-0.6579523086547852,
0.5410987138748169,
-0.4989740550518036,
-0.48378485441207886,
-0.09223535656929016,
0.7081459760665894,
0.7220249772071838,
0.19936113059520721,
0.5570089817047119,
0.6501618027687073,
0.968705415725708,
-0.3448651432991028,
1.009929895401001,
-0.24910788238048553,
0.28752705454826355,
1.0063085556030273,
-0.5034608244895935,
0.6575462818145752,
0.1642465889453888,
-0.533530056476593,
0.545386552810669,
0.7205912470817566,
0.08508403599262238,
0.20208755135536194,
0.46556371450424194,
-0.42706939578056335,
-0.3279121518135071,
0.17076465487480164,
-0.5193824768066406,
0.49131298065185547,
0.7014936208724976,
-0.030196117237210274,
-0.5435387492179871,
-0.37089627981185913,
0.22729790210723877,
-0.3872593343257904,
-0.20848126709461212,
0.5678393840789795,
0.09999898821115494,
-0.8885396122932434,
0.664055585861206,
-0.16333438456058502,
0.4988550543785095,
-0.5257656574249268,
-0.11356962472200394,
-0.043908458203077316,
0.10599734634160995,
-0.27198800444602966,
-0.8665168285369873,
0.3116208016872406,
0.2110573798418045,
0.3158361315727234,
-0.2093578279018402,
1.2511085271835327,
-0.09282081574201584,
-0.29607173800468445,
-0.130537748336792,
0.786347508430481,
0.37791886925697327,
-0.31539207696914673,
-0.6606941819190979,
0.017801174893975258,
0.03992181643843651,
-0.2606900930404663,
0.15184147655963898,
0.8500909209251404,
0.1511337161064148,
0.8789600729942322,
0.6247190237045288,
0.21606111526489258,
-0.12435006350278854,
-0.007534232921898365,
0.9434838891029358,
-0.6080430150032043,
-0.2619785666465759,
-1.1333588361740112,
0.3640497326850891,
-0.07833541184663773,
0.009456398896872997,
0.8548807501792908,
0.6006510853767395,
0.5352068543434143,
0.334709495306015,
1.0892153978347778,
-0.3305807411670685,
0.5323649644851685,
-0.6831573247909546,
0.7028932571411133,
0.06784151494503021,
0.6616168022155762,
-0.0779152661561966,
-0.6518744826316833,
-0.053269367665052414,
0.7298504710197449,
-0.5518300533294678,
0.0025660828687250614,
0.9924995303153992,
0.763258695602417,
0.11740706115961075,
0.5786109566688538,
0.045066915452480316,
0.2805766761302948,
0.39322420954704285,
0.7202167510986328,
1.4143147468566895,
-0.2502577006816864,
0.7200931310653687,
-0.12839166820049286,
-0.342227965593338,
0.076758973300457,
-1.25375235080719,
-0.8779547810554504,
-0.09753131866455078,
-0.550815761089325,
-0.7054019570350647,
0.07632065564393997,
0.8236575126647949,
0.49900418519973755,
-0.4004271924495697,
0.009643541648983955,
-0.20783545076847076,
0.3280860185623169,
-0.2134488970041275,
-0.2467738687992096,
0.2322595715522766,
-0.4089953303337097,
-0.0035560184624046087,
0.31454703211784363,
0.35065028071403503,
-0.19435636699199677,
-0.38458409905433655,
-0.07542441040277481,
-0.015297173522412777,
0.02452724799513817,
0.6912363171577454,
0.4128009080886841,
-0.8197029829025269,
-0.4964595437049866,
-0.24506013095378876,
0.024981467053294182,
0.1782107651233673,
0.8111083507537842,
-1.035760521888733,
0.01795586757361889,
0.3301049768924713,
0.7591692209243774,
0.3865247070789337,
0.019069330766797066,
0.5854633450508118,
-0.2633735239505768,
0.005200123880058527,
0.29820898175239563,
0.5327739119529724,
0.0580240860581398,
-0.3004487454891205,
0.8061152696609497,
0.6174650192260742,
-0.5809077024459839,
-0.7750820517539978,
0.20165832340717316,
-1.0777320861816406,
-0.03032347746193409,
1.264432430267334,
-0.17694605886936188,
-0.12832383811473846,
-0.11821991205215454,
-0.36803364753723145,
-0.06411196291446686,
-0.16906975209712982,
0.8808239698410034,
1.0949302911758423,
-0.4366688132286072,
-0.149606853723526,
-0.7948634028434753,
0.5060118436813354,
0.09050002694129944,
-0.8114995360374451,
0.3995094895362854,
0.5159106254577637,
0.2988322675228119,
0.08277814835309982,
0.9581863880157471,
-0.36138916015625,
0.24657268822193146,
0.25754672288894653,
-0.2431098222732544,
-0.07076208293437958,
-0.11567123979330063,
0.28190878033638,
0.16118787229061127,
0.1815139204263687,
0.08425956219434738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04261v1 | A Novel BERT-based Classifier to Detect Political Leaning of YouTube Videos based on their Titles | 2024-02-16T14:44:30 | 2024-02-16T14:44:30 | Nouar AlDahoul, Talal Rahwan, Yasir Zaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A quarter of US adults regularly get their news from YouTube. Yet, despite
the massive political content available on the platform, to date no classifier
has been proposed to identify the political leaning of YouTube videos. To fill
this gap, we propose a novel classifier based on Bert -- a language model from
Google -- to classify YouTube videos merely based on their titles into six
categories, namely: Far Left, Left, Center, Anti-Woke, Right, and Far Right. We
used a public dataset of 10 million YouTube video titles (under various
categories) to train and validate the proposed classifier. We compare the
classifier against several alternatives that we trained on the same dataset,
revealing that our classifier achieves the highest accuracy (75%) and the
highest F1 score (77%). To further validate the classification performance, we
collect videos from YouTube channels of numerous prominent news agencies, such
as Fox News and New York Times, which have widely known political leanings, and
apply our classifier to their video titles. For the vast majority of cases, the
predicted political leaning matches that of the news agency. | [
-0.6631543040275574,
-0.5513588190078735,
0.23694497346878052,
0.07221899926662445,
-0.6080124974250793,
0.4429699182510376,
-0.634366512298584,
0.22184158861637115,
0.4092537462711334,
0.2439170926809311,
-0.43978002667427063,
-0.3628842234611511,
-0.8031632900238037,
-0.28995707631111145,
-0.7364760637283325,
1.2357642650604248,
0.8467205762863159,
0.2233581840991974,
0.21762710809707642,
0.020100845023989677,
0.22570884227752686,
-0.2282084822654724,
-0.32685932517051697,
-0.2767293453216553,
0.39684200286865234,
0.4154059588909149,
0.760307252407074,
0.5157198309898376,
0.1484622061252594,
0.28607678413391113,
0.017429806292057037,
-0.13950945436954498,
-0.4575071632862091,
-0.5565516352653503,
-0.2513180077075958,
-0.3434407413005829,
0.12814873456954956,
0.06502164155244827,
0.4211716949939728,
-0.06307458132505417,
-0.08522859960794449,
0.1871919333934784,
-0.18879787623882294,
0.7031034231185913,
-0.4542270004749298,
-0.0547964945435524,
-1.2078675031661987,
0.21098294854164124,
-0.14085260033607483,
-0.13400204479694366,
-0.5265315771102905,
-0.8618260025978088,
0.2596793472766876,
-0.012764734216034412,
0.574954628944397,
-0.22966161370277405,
0.9802053570747375,
0.12511882185935974,
-0.25898876786231995,
-0.2056763768196106,
-0.5983633995056152,
0.9040104150772095,
-0.6690133810043335,
0.6645179986953735,
0.07476136088371277,
0.4741971790790558,
0.14056745171546936,
-0.08283108472824097,
-0.8222975134849548,
0.1479039192199707,
0.6439778208732605,
-0.14946772158145905,
-0.2011764645576477,
-0.1685194969177246,
-0.24474959075450897,
0.26428407430648804,
-0.41072577238082886,
0.0031281791161745787,
-0.4177904725074768,
-0.2249639928340912,
0.5344393253326416,
-0.5312522649765015,
0.3999476432800293,
-0.7443006634712219,
-0.4512583911418915,
-0.15473000705242157,
-0.4069085121154785,
0.44365987181663513,
0.8151106238365173,
0.6315996050834656,
0.31618618965148926,
0.6107825636863708,
0.10753858089447021,
0.6411854028701782,
0.5047368407249451,
-0.17027468979358673,
0.13590672612190247,
0.23284079134464264,
-0.45509645342826843,
0.5610037446022034,
0.8733498454093933,
0.7382820248603821,
0.5753700137138367,
0.05605233833193779,
0.06820304691791534,
0.15292955935001373,
0.4942842721939087,
-0.5864431262016296,
-0.5344934463500977,
0.10890398919582367,
-0.4419174790382385,
-0.437406986951828,
0.32762494683265686,
-0.7483500242233276,
-0.7834934592247009,
-0.2347370684146881,
0.28922441601753235,
-0.4578850567340851,
-0.3663842976093292,
-0.035096704959869385,
-0.049243345856666565,
0.4717596173286438,
0.5426616072654724,
-0.7860638499259949,
-0.20057551562786102,
1.1053372621536255,
0.8379143476486206,
-0.12696769833564758,
0.22434300184249878,
-0.5634164810180664,
-0.2441151887178421,
-0.39895114302635193,
0.7292284369468689,
-0.6724116206169128,
0.4619201719760895,
0.3782505393028259,
0.0764649286866188,
0.49611520767211914,
-0.2929556667804718,
0.4684699475765228,
-0.779336154460907,
0.3004657030105591,
-0.3580213785171509,
-0.7208506464958191,
-0.29979807138442993,
0.4136156439781189,
-0.7932388782501221,
0.5301992893218994,
-0.4258929193019867,
-0.8693755865097046,
0.6787558197975159,
-0.40464743971824646,
-0.22303037345409393,
-0.28355973958969116,
-0.3994726538658142,
-0.563217043876648,
-0.18391932547092438,
0.24507375061511993,
0.5907270908355713,
0.08389903604984283,
0.7562589049339294,
-0.3239997625350952,
-0.03674996271729469,
0.19206860661506653,
-0.3730543255805969,
1.0121088027954102,
-0.03801963850855827,
-0.3929983973503113,
0.14416295289993286,
-0.5599061846733093,
0.11420909315347672,
-0.3816874623298645,
-0.047316499054431915,
-0.33948346972465515,
0.3144086003303528,
0.09444846957921982,
0.2894704043865204,
0.22166825830936432,
-1.0415397882461548,
-0.053954120725393295,
0.08721879124641418,
0.40958014130592346,
1.249306082725525,
-0.4463983178138733,
0.5169066786766052,
-0.0487552210688591,
0.21437430381774902,
-0.25997012853622437,
0.181895911693573,
0.6165398359298706,
-0.8191350698471069,
-0.6172377467155457,
-0.23381097614765167,
0.46307265758514404,
0.5960018634796143,
-0.48191145062446594,
0.7997923493385315,
-0.4558231830596924,
-0.6090487837791443,
-0.27095910906791687,
0.13992317020893097,
-0.03815388306975365,
0.2932582199573517,
0.37106549739837646,
0.09673242270946503,
-0.5836132764816284,
-1.0035324096679688,
-0.2552904784679413,
-0.4886683523654938,
-0.17691588401794434,
0.3126736879348755,
0.3234025239944458,
0.07635337114334106,
1.0830214023590088,
-0.11457598209381104,
-0.4476720690727234,
-0.09413184225559235,
0.44310876727104187,
0.26918724179267883,
-0.06421610713005066,
0.2614273428916931,
-1.2020183801651,
-0.46417236328125,
0.056675128638744354,
-0.3479151427745819,
0.17384907603263855,
-0.17123806476593018,
-0.01387700717896223,
-0.06536722928285599,
0.16559544205665588,
0.03459683060646057,
0.0026416254695504904,
0.5683930516242981,
-0.17783290147781372,
0.14206892251968384,
0.18476171791553497,
0.07995793968439102,
-0.8094204068183899,
-0.46996039152145386,
0.23412081599235535,
-0.20720884203910828,
-0.4024893641471863,
-0.6676317453384399,
0.19816341996192932,
0.15181304514408112,
-0.7814866304397583,
-0.037830110639333725,
0.28092366456985474,
-0.056626468896865845,
-0.08602464199066162,
-0.03133014962077141,
-0.6552258729934692,
0.24054205417633057,
0.42567092180252075,
0.45204442739486694,
0.4382841885089874,
-0.41281670331954956,
0.6608457565307617,
0.10181806236505508,
-0.7216113209724426,
0.5035827159881592,
-0.15103697776794434,
-0.07594706118106842,
-0.29228150844573975,
0.2077687531709671,
-1.2690436840057373,
-0.3109642565250397,
-0.2521614134311676,
-0.8135192394256592,
-0.03157295659184456,
-0.42913052439689636,
-0.39045247435569763,
-0.3187599778175354,
-0.5489050149917603,
-0.25634101033210754,
0.4441204369068146,
-0.6675522327423096,
0.5318432450294495,
0.7343360781669617,
-0.1255774348974228,
-0.9633869528770447,
-0.43388301134109497,
0.022908760234713554,
-0.27923059463500977,
-0.5948362946510315,
0.22239193320274353,
0.1637960523366928,
0.1769864559173584,
0.4074876010417938,
-0.22792215645313263,
-0.544364333152771,
-0.4611733555793762,
0.02342262864112854,
-0.09036125987768173,
-0.11499206721782684,
0.3695581257343292,
-0.06630408018827438,
0.36372339725494385,
0.16307911276817322,
-0.16725613176822662,
0.5318775773048401,
-0.2916856110095978,
-0.058986760675907135,
-0.5447053909301758,
0.2265474647283554,
0.7530303597450256,
-0.2812868058681488,
0.21988098323345184,
0.9578903317451477,
-0.34560173749923706,
-0.4436136782169342,
-0.6747130155563354,
-0.1095428466796875,
-0.44363346695899963,
0.5499846339225769,
0.29415735602378845,
-0.4942689538002014,
0.4886420667171478,
0.40974146127700806,
0.15604324638843536,
0.1832013726234436,
0.7047714591026306,
-0.13258273899555206,
0.9620736241340637,
0.6113765835762024,
-0.5344619154930115,
0.8428350687026978,
-0.5107955932617188,
0.26102545857429504,
-0.18392682075500488,
-0.17732416093349457,
-0.3671899735927582,
-0.7068024277687073,
-0.7526650428771973,
-0.36617109179496765,
0.09484289586544037,
-0.6998080611228943,
-0.5146961212158203,
0.42351749539375305,
-0.6768062114715576,
0.6236749887466431,
0.5667519569396973,
0.19678343832492828,
-0.05913414806127548,
0.31211113929748535,
0.30148065090179443,
-0.3456357419490814,
-0.5392497777938843,
-0.5108116269111633,
1.1654595136642456,
0.4152431786060333,
0.9238133430480957,
0.32166382670402527,
0.8832936882972717,
0.8712674379348755,
0.5762677788734436,
-1.0242739915847778,
0.6369187831878662,
-0.7413665652275085,
-0.7981923222541809,
-0.5231180787086487,
-0.2530580759048462,
-0.7314843535423279,
-0.2376377135515213,
-0.04120924323797226,
-0.3777780830860138,
0.04743608832359314,
-0.1557452231645584,
-0.4045656621456146,
0.9811835289001465,
-0.2722535729408264,
0.7265352606773376,
-0.6130874156951904,
-0.3336952328681946,
-0.14647839963436127,
-0.6458634734153748,
0.31595760583877563,
0.05046195909380913,
0.4116789996623993,
-0.2221733033657074,
-0.09491892904043198,
1.0238553285598755,
-0.19407004117965698,
0.7020188570022583,
-0.5367255210876465,
-0.0771622508764267,
0.273226261138916,
-0.4616507589817047,
0.004114291165024042,
0.11941669881343842,
0.16052807867527008,
-0.12107835710048676,
-0.37570616602897644,
-0.17741593718528748,
-0.4559851288795471,
0.7248005867004395,
-0.9894610643386841,
-0.390455037355423,
-0.5792509913444519,
-0.16922253370285034,
-0.18163609504699707,
0.15594923496246338,
0.306733101606369,
-0.030828256160020828,
-0.18019990622997284,
0.8927522897720337,
1.0896313190460205,
-0.08478271216154099,
0.3949755132198334,
0.12650825083255768,
-0.11102216690778732,
-0.7756910920143127,
1.168297290802002,
0.16463671624660492,
-0.06041999161243439,
0.55370032787323,
0.35200247168540955,
-0.6416001319885254,
-0.3518017828464508,
-0.508888840675354,
0.01030662003904581,
-0.579725444316864,
-0.31758326292037964,
-0.2959488034248352,
-0.3821793496608734,
0.027922727167606354,
-0.3007599115371704,
-0.6495182514190674,
-0.1586441546678543,
-0.1453162282705307,
-0.06818114221096039,
0.2518922984600067,
0.5008906722068787,
0.0676603615283966,
0.14234507083892822,
-0.3861982226371765,
0.4643186926841736,
0.8880636096000671,
0.5292882919311523,
-0.40897336602211,
-0.4846924841403961,
0.18503932654857635,
0.07285373657941818,
-0.44993284344673157,
-1.1141846179962158,
0.2571306526660919,
0.42974069714546204,
0.40143099427223206,
0.8608507513999939,
0.30296793580055237,
0.43706125020980835,
-0.6306018233299255,
0.9192776679992676,
0.3025414049625397,
-0.8571183681488037,
0.5818898677825928,
-0.326941579580307,
-0.44798848032951355,
0.4634712040424347,
0.7056106925010681,
-0.04006548598408699,
-0.5403977036476135,
-0.6386058926582336,
-0.3973633050918579,
0.3319246470928192,
0.2273223102092743,
0.4826091527938843,
-0.14255590736865997,
-0.15819686651229858,
0.2825722098350525,
0.35767775774002075,
-0.9399294257164001,
-0.0963267907500267,
-0.5515229105949402,
-0.2397785782814026,
0.010090244933962822,
0.09604109078645706,
0.006587829440832138,
-0.24034881591796875,
0.6792900562286377,
-0.20173855125904083,
0.3020860552787781,
-0.04768379032611847,
0.08691864460706711,
-0.10633522272109985,
0.3890153467655182,
0.5140713453292847,
0.48621854186058044,
-0.8139368891716003,
0.024474577978253365,
-0.41866204142570496,
-0.37157389521598816,
0.3588305711746216,
-0.10043055564165115,
-0.3576541543006897,
0.5275899767875671,
-0.1441878080368042,
0.36443066596984863,
0.002263170899823308,
-0.5696447491645813,
0.6651982665061951,
-0.1082739606499672,
-0.1441749781370163,
-0.6361768841743469,
-0.1706027239561081,
0.043834343552589417,
0.25116702914237976,
0.5842636823654175,
0.11590825766324997,
0.14865246415138245,
-0.8360568881034851,
0.5994272828102112,
0.8805831074714661,
-0.3844175934791565,
-0.139475017786026,
0.5507116317749023,
0.486662894487381,
-0.5274789333343506,
0.2787800431251526,
-0.3200311064720154,
-0.9873377084732056,
0.6953641176223755,
0.12795722484588623,
0.8836695551872253,
-0.2793700397014618,
0.7211096882820129,
0.35884588956832886,
0.2659966051578522,
-0.2056363970041275,
0.24995718896389008,
0.008711818605661392,
-0.8106176257133484,
-0.45237627625465393,
-0.5036095976829529,
-0.5325522422790527,
0.5241215229034424,
-0.8008167147636414,
0.6151207685470581,
-0.6771368384361267,
-0.5489079356193542,
0.37647494673728943,
0.31065356731414795,
-0.29926061630249023,
0.3284634053707123,
0.6357020139694214,
0.8000535368919373,
-1.2596997022628784,
0.933630108833313,
0.8510149121284485,
0.10479262471199036,
-0.20431110262870789,
0.10939624160528183,
0.08394930511713028,
-0.560008704662323,
0.5174399614334106,
0.2631593346595764,
-0.29557913541793823,
-0.30961233377456665,
-0.5780150890350342,
-0.35512834787368774,
0.5699248909950256,
0.3116362690925598,
-0.5141226649284363,
-0.28990039229393005,
0.09199967980384827,
0.37434229254722595,
-0.4863997995853424,
-0.1742233783006668,
-0.04405857250094414,
0.3590375781059265,
-0.06850314885377884,
-0.737619161605835,
-0.5686139464378357,
-0.12528830766677856,
-0.32505035400390625,
0.3775540590286255,
-0.7326805591583252,
0.9543383717536926,
-0.09964446723461151,
0.1231786236166954,
-0.17019079625606537,
0.6425700187683105,
-0.018263716250658035,
0.4855809807777405,
1.0326260328292847,
0.4537470042705536,
0.7379541993141174,
-0.15820984542369843,
0.4967137277126312,
-0.25621551275253296,
0.7306194305419922,
0.7948190569877625,
0.28913378715515137,
1.0700314044952393,
0.3106735050678253,
-0.36299777030944824,
0.8751089572906494,
0.5904092788696289,
-0.31407517194747925,
0.8720809817314148,
0.2381291687488556,
-0.1781361848115921,
-0.6296558976173401,
0.10161716490983963,
-0.18636538088321686,
0.5937500596046448,
0.43348193168640137,
-0.4988550543785095,
-0.22680076956748962,
0.12325628101825714,
0.02421141229569912,
0.2628140449523926,
-0.39269620180130005,
0.43154361844062805,
-0.438226580619812,
-0.6708970069885254,
0.497013658285141,
-0.32916292548179626,
0.8407455682754517,
-0.4563387930393219,
0.28543856739997864,
0.2033872753381729,
0.3055473566055298,
-0.31864631175994873,
-1.1883130073547363,
0.01767909713089466,
0.46088963747024536,
-0.1711536943912506,
-0.16145077347755432,
0.2704636752605438,
-0.6345294713973999,
-0.5118499994277954,
0.18510118126869202,
0.22357764840126038,
0.04665076360106468,
-0.13520024716854095,
-0.7422758936882019,
0.11572172492742538,
0.19316649436950684,
0.13952112197875977,
0.20134377479553223,
0.5439273118972778,
0.10660935938358307,
0.6712186336517334,
0.5932732820510864,
0.08365067839622498,
0.21076300740242004,
-0.19927245378494263,
0.7915372848510742,
-0.6651093363761902,
-0.5838229656219482,
-0.7939785122871399,
0.2916256785392761,
-0.41428324580192566,
-0.03006584942340851,
0.626213014125824,
0.7825606465339661,
0.8737497329711914,
-0.2232198417186737,
0.8965583443641663,
-0.3664225935935974,
0.36683568358421326,
-0.334246426820755,
0.7229727506637573,
-0.6341946125030518,
-0.1764208972454071,
-0.3002493381500244,
-0.5815958380699158,
-0.31700795888900757,
1.0438073873519897,
-0.3315770924091339,
-0.21906349062919617,
0.23086969554424286,
0.5375708341598511,
-0.37942031025886536,
0.18656326830387115,
0.03717642277479172,
0.018900595605373383,
0.5809367895126343,
0.6047662496566772,
0.7910524010658264,
0.042574211955070496,
0.8901034593582153,
-0.7484298348426819,
-0.2906395494937897,
-0.5109027028083801,
-1.1568771600723267,
-1.199879765510559,
-0.7080709338188171,
-0.4067627191543579,
-0.39713653922080994,
0.03131963312625885,
0.8976025581359863,
1.049996256828308,
-0.9703604578971863,
-0.2699255645275116,
0.0041514248587191105,
0.3129810690879822,
-0.07364118099212646,
-0.29720520973205566,
0.338455468416214,
-0.09816360473632812,
-0.9149968028068542,
-0.12915492057800293,
-0.01364755630493164,
-0.44051921367645264,
-0.4836837351322174,
0.09362784773111343,
-0.4613508880138397,
0.1803576648235321,
0.5697353482246399,
0.41872209310531616,
-1.2814165353775024,
-0.7401003837585449,
0.26135528087615967,
0.15638527274131775,
0.2536605894565582,
0.8407835960388184,
-0.5777288675308228,
0.6070380806922913,
0.6067948341369629,
0.6908586621284485,
0.2642495334148407,
0.39854201674461365,
0.12273042649030685,
-0.7511760592460632,
-0.1216195747256279,
0.5667700171470642,
0.11288366466760635,
0.5674855709075928,
-0.053320109844207764,
0.09339741617441177,
0.07130797207355499,
-0.5539433360099792,
-0.7598123550415039,
0.17171207070350647,
-1.2731682062149048,
0.03361876308917999,
1.0683856010437012,
0.056150879710912704,
-0.1781102567911148,
0.009728875942528248,
-0.20350103080272675,
0.24418945610523224,
-0.8317855596542358,
1.0333436727523804,
0.8511919975280762,
-0.055185526609420776,
-0.31723257899284363,
-0.5969205498695374,
0.6406844854354858,
0.11599547415971756,
-0.29903921484947205,
-0.0718250572681427,
0.3653070628643036,
0.560133159160614,
0.5933366417884827,
0.13743332028388977,
0.18340647220611572,
0.5505980849266052,
-0.7056335210800171,
-0.28531524538993835,
0.28124967217445374,
-0.4161943793296814,
-0.09723757952451706,
0.41322025656700134,
-0.4918040633201599,
-0.5144351124763489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10992v1 | "Understanding AI": Semantic Grounding in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T14:23:55 | 2024-02-16T14:23:55 | Holger Lyre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Do LLMs understand the meaning of the texts they generate? Do they possess a
semantic grounding? And how could we understand whether and what they
understand? I start the paper with the observation that we have recently
witnessed a generative turn in AI, since generative models, including LLMs, are
key for self-supervised learning. To assess the question of semantic grounding,
I distinguish and discuss five methodological ways. The most promising way is
to apply core assumptions of theories of meaning in philosophy of mind and
language to LLMs. Grounding proves to be a gradual affair with a
three-dimensional distinction between functional, social and causal grounding.
LLMs show basic evidence in all three dimensions. A strong argument is that
LLMs develop world models. Hence, LLMs are neither stochastic parrots nor
semantic zombies, but already understand the language they generate, at least
in an elementary sense. | [
-0.36776968836784363,
-0.8058589696884155,
0.9356436133384705,
0.05300777032971382,
-0.273004412651062,
-0.007980559952557087,
-0.15424467623233795,
-0.34843960404396057,
-0.15106426179409027,
0.643424391746521,
-0.5084559321403503,
-0.4331817626953125,
-0.8307273387908936,
0.05281153693795204,
-0.611045777797699,
0.8496378064155579,
0.15030530095100403,
0.13360129296779633,
-0.661567747592926,
-0.17300966382026672,
-0.17036594450473785,
-0.5243694186210632,
-0.64447420835495,
-0.620201587677002,
0.24642710387706757,
0.1827886402606964,
0.6989892721176147,
0.9555306434631348,
0.4594687819480896,
0.36547309160232544,
-0.1695806384086609,
-0.16485431790351868,
-0.4488081634044647,
0.15864473581314087,
-0.11649016290903091,
-0.9471640586853027,
-0.05429759621620178,
0.38276514410972595,
0.5553830862045288,
1.075249433517456,
0.24699272215366364,
-0.07131971418857574,
-0.040750227868556976,
0.7922021150588989,
-0.290447860956192,
0.28389909863471985,
-0.6823888421058655,
0.23910030722618103,
0.1342271864414215,
-0.16321609914302826,
-0.2651406228542328,
0.09912222623825073,
-0.0992337167263031,
-0.4821447730064392,
0.1862637847661972,
0.15504351258277893,
0.6230272054672241,
0.5209077596664429,
-0.49079352617263794,
-0.396685928106308,
-0.6104904413223267,
0.7554641366004944,
-0.4424401819705963,
0.3680655360221863,
0.5057393312454224,
0.15533094108104706,
-0.2190360426902771,
-0.5932148098945618,
-0.7728275060653687,
-0.5383081436157227,
0.01846645027399063,
0.18851540982723236,
0.16929592192173004,
0.1534043848514557,
0.2882274389266968,
0.6958566904067993,
-0.24548637866973877,
0.2743518650531769,
-0.35428130626678467,
0.1175626590847969,
0.5780746936798096,
-0.08915633708238602,
0.6428958177566528,
-0.019790105521678925,
-0.49360406398773193,
0.14648279547691345,
-0.7520296573638916,
-0.3135909140110016,
0.2094603180885315,
0.07408503443002701,
-0.19955942034721375,
0.7029853463172913,
-0.14149846136569977,
0.6633967161178589,
-0.04823180288076401,
-0.23175235092639923,
-0.11231987178325653,
-0.16691966354846954,
-0.39317694306373596,
-0.10372157394886017,
0.5010523796081543,
0.2651475965976715,
0.48543548583984375,
-0.6278040409088135,
-0.09123361855745316,
0.31223997473716736,
0.31060919165611267,
-0.3275437355041504,
-0.02773260697722435,
0.34005245566368103,
-0.650726854801178,
-0.40350398421287537,
-0.09111463278532028,
0.06802090257406235,
-0.37973496317863464,
-0.6911497712135315,
0.2290986329317093,
-0.5542578101158142,
-0.3052316904067993,
0.049582935869693756,
-0.16793552041053772,
0.8892988562583923,
0.4384503960609436,
-0.8991372585296631,
0.3846241533756256,
0.9319097995758057,
0.5828852653503418,
-0.11894157528877258,
-0.6134185194969177,
-0.12777265906333923,
0.31219643354415894,
-0.6103604435920715,
0.824002742767334,
-0.3281792104244232,
-0.3212296664714813,
-0.07058250159025192,
-0.15531133115291595,
0.15796621143817902,
-0.5018047094345093,
0.3372144401073456,
-0.5373698472976685,
0.30940860509872437,
-0.2532998025417328,
-0.6763257384300232,
-0.33334842324256897,
0.4029543697834015,
-0.32833370566368103,
0.6621527671813965,
-0.3323008418083191,
-0.5077459812164307,
0.281453937292099,
-0.5449402928352356,
-0.3731500804424286,
0.12634499371051788,
-0.37127798795700073,
0.2047530561685562,
0.48109349608421326,
0.015644840896129608,
0.6477530002593994,
-0.3828466534614563,
0.4382288157939911,
-0.2187577188014984,
-0.09738155454397202,
0.28926628828048706,
-0.3730790317058563,
0.8177674412727356,
0.25390639901161194,
-0.26883602142333984,
-0.10182134807109833,
-0.843008816242218,
-0.05705959349870682,
0.3215889632701874,
-0.13535036146640778,
-0.29215458035469055,
0.4417732357978821,
-0.3429599106311798,
0.3467988073825836,
0.17122405767440796,
-0.20026874542236328,
0.06655620783567429,
-0.5367240905761719,
0.6711245179176331,
0.5743752717971802,
-0.27528145909309387,
0.5630245208740234,
-0.17826344072818756,
0.10368325561285019,
0.16525360941886902,
-0.29064077138900757,
-0.33671608567237854,
-0.3989918529987335,
-1.2107205390930176,
0.0844380110502243,
0.1252102553844452,
0.49365535378456116,
-0.4152390956878662,
0.701953113079071,
0.0030815782956779003,
-0.255474716424942,
-0.4823445677757263,
0.21433275938034058,
0.26374897360801697,
0.35448795557022095,
0.35652533173561096,
0.047457195818424225,
-0.14101245999336243,
-0.8763935565948486,
-0.2419360727071762,
-0.3479378819465637,
-0.11265463382005692,
0.3372719883918762,
0.7587021589279175,
-0.4437367916107178,
0.8357694149017334,
-0.24443957209587097,
-0.01588769443333149,
-0.32789233326911926,
0.19862540066242218,
-0.0358416885137558,
0.40828511118888855,
0.34508323669433594,
-0.8739088177680969,
0.003438676008954644,
-0.05969228968024254,
-1.3759267330169678,
-0.003126661293208599,
-0.16128067672252655,
-0.09438233822584152,
-0.08824310451745987,
0.7121382355690002,
-0.7906851172447205,
0.3186901807785034,
0.28719303011894226,
-0.2555961310863495,
0.11589644104242325,
-0.3222265839576721,
-0.1919880360364914,
-0.9258906841278076,
-0.26771625876426697,
-0.12210038304328918,
-0.3201439678668976,
-0.697458028793335,
0.3505367040634155,
-0.2876470685005188,
-0.06836311519145966,
-0.2811594605445862,
0.43659576773643494,
-0.5740089416503906,
-0.3812578022480011,
-0.5299425721168518,
0.5902581214904785,
-0.03480024263262749,
0.1347123682498932,
0.19299426674842834,
0.5653719902038574,
0.49189215898513794,
-0.7844972014427185,
0.5268607139587402,
0.026571694761514664,
-0.25775066018104553,
0.576369047164917,
-0.5600697994232178,
0.26842907071113586,
-0.5302534699440002,
0.25550779700279236,
-1.0145257711410522,
-0.16521145403385162,
0.23442460596561432,
-0.6349937915802002,
-0.1630980372428894,
-0.08614630997180939,
-0.3785303831100464,
-0.157297283411026,
0.11581498384475708,
0.32247331738471985,
0.5187321901321411,
-0.4561205208301544,
0.5865328907966614,
0.4912404417991638,
0.2363794595003128,
-0.2460346519947052,
-0.751997172832489,
0.4193641245365143,
-0.46521955728530884,
-0.6351253390312195,
0.3412850797176361,
0.10539611428976059,
-0.9433233737945557,
0.0394909493625164,
0.06279213726520538,
0.05358182266354561,
0.5793073773384094,
0.3438401520252228,
-0.2890060245990753,
-0.3159884214401245,
0.25989988446235657,
-0.17981719970703125,
-0.5167402029037476,
0.5229187607765198,
-0.6822824478149414,
0.4645718038082123,
-0.08356886357069016,
-0.3797153830528259,
-0.37337663769721985,
0.29021966457366943,
0.6364408135414124,
-0.16562628746032715,
0.740489661693573,
0.32220277190208435,
-0.5255122780799866,
-0.2061462253332138,
-0.45590460300445557,
-0.06946032494306564,
-0.3987044095993042,
0.04414144530892372,
-0.535338819026947,
-0.689487874507904,
0.5586264729499817,
-0.24118325114250183,
-0.1681489497423172,
0.8216288685798645,
0.8249109983444214,
-0.39909258484840393,
0.8832870125770569,
0.9617356657981873,
-0.15387877821922302,
0.0670921579003334,
-0.47854480147361755,
0.17324504256248474,
-0.6166101694107056,
-0.18086285889148712,
-0.531832218170166,
-0.03899397701025009,
-0.6797718405723572,
-0.427521288394928,
0.18996955454349518,
0.42046332359313965,
-0.1573515683412552,
-0.2507443130016327,
-0.11614032089710236,
0.501593828201294,
0.5621837377548218,
-0.10388226807117462,
0.18568725883960724,
-0.09937576204538345,
0.008852280676364899,
0.2402908205986023,
-0.44756603240966797,
-0.8331627249717712,
0.7563754916191101,
0.5170959830284119,
0.8156978487968445,
0.0077975112944841385,
0.5553264021873474,
0.20386917889118195,
0.19089221954345703,
-0.8349927067756653,
0.5001980066299438,
0.08253510296344757,
-0.42676910758018494,
-0.27809128165245056,
0.030331533402204514,
-0.6682811975479126,
0.4862867295742035,
-0.24548792839050293,
-0.5049194693565369,
-0.2498798668384552,
-0.008673618547618389,
0.09045127779245377,
0.3116372525691986,
-0.3808070421218872,
0.8234961032867432,
-0.533392071723938,
0.021986210718750954,
-0.4445393681526184,
-0.8741508722305298,
0.45795953273773193,
0.20480333268642426,
0.4171171486377716,
-0.32081735134124756,
-0.12853184342384338,
0.7739801406860352,
-0.23728908598423004,
0.8553076386451721,
-0.059159599244594574,
-0.4529353082180023,
0.27686893939971924,
-0.15853583812713623,
0.15652544796466827,
0.11204338818788528,
0.05471406877040863,
0.2008715271949768,
-0.13660390675067902,
-0.5696542859077454,
-0.8244681358337402,
0.5258138179779053,
-1.1112971305847168,
-0.8079766631126404,
-0.35782989859580994,
-0.48931777477264404,
-0.1281822919845581,
0.25136587023735046,
0.19670608639717102,
0.1655593067407608,
-0.34585973620414734,
0.051212992519140244,
0.7649158835411072,
-0.13129769265651703,
0.1678147315979004,
0.3167731463909149,
-0.2388000637292862,
-0.12938658893108368,
0.7703065276145935,
-0.065854012966156,
0.24369454383850098,
0.5601061582565308,
0.24028900265693665,
-0.19478654861450195,
-0.659200131893158,
-0.42356881499290466,
0.2925402522087097,
-1.089033842086792,
0.3331371247768402,
-0.744093120098114,
-0.2891788184642792,
-0.2556532919406891,
-0.24630780518054962,
-0.08073198050260544,
-0.1542734056711197,
-0.48974958062171936,
-0.3674982488155365,
0.19206562638282776,
1.1544286012649536,
0.08089298754930496,
0.5088621973991394,
-0.5181900858879089,
0.4994813799858093,
0.32073208689689636,
0.003992539830505848,
-0.19811828434467316,
-0.40288376808166504,
-0.12279635667800903,
0.2342865914106369,
-0.12863197922706604,
-0.9352673888206482,
0.10888084024190903,
0.07367285341024399,
0.559268057346344,
0.5505867600440979,
-0.1515786349773407,
0.5126453042030334,
-0.6218261122703552,
0.9463826417922974,
-0.17537468671798706,
-1.0762052536010742,
0.6314997673034668,
-0.4361502230167389,
-0.039792250841856,
0.29444873332977295,
0.42828938364982605,
-0.615702748298645,
-0.6016242504119873,
-0.802814245223999,
-0.5939443111419678,
0.34252235293388367,
0.07657984644174576,
0.6213722825050354,
-0.2520047426223755,
0.7915077209472656,
0.03438722714781761,
0.2055855244398117,
-0.9973773956298828,
-0.4119510054588318,
-0.12530069053173065,
-0.18550315499305725,
-0.5225291848182678,
-0.5476703643798828,
-0.22554244101047516,
-0.07668444514274597,
0.2622435390949249,
-0.30933240056037903,
0.41001996397972107,
-0.07090789079666138,
-0.400777667760849,
0.04644521325826645,
0.04153859615325928,
0.4856818616390228,
0.8909295797348022,
0.1594141572713852,
0.5541893839836121,
0.09228409081697464,
-0.01678638346493244,
0.253898948431015,
-0.41248437762260437,
-0.03287181258201599,
-0.3665512502193451,
0.8068816661834717,
0.7974089980125427,
-0.03338860720396042,
-0.3500225245952606,
0.38002172112464905,
0.003945763222873211,
-0.21115146577358246,
-0.5336939096450806,
0.27514222264289856,
0.057205796241760254,
0.15810182690620422,
0.26809823513031006,
-0.3869759142398834,
0.044418737292289734,
-0.6920567154884338,
0.042112525552511215,
0.6066917181015015,
-0.1280909776687622,
-0.36909961700439453,
0.5351312160491943,
0.1580311805009842,
-0.33497676253318787,
0.6470748782157898,
0.03237413614988327,
-0.5870240330696106,
0.7932312488555908,
0.8828127384185791,
0.9527899026870728,
0.12821178138256073,
-0.06289590895175934,
-0.17636126279830933,
0.3984932005405426,
0.0610167495906353,
0.06507746875286102,
-0.3719877004623413,
-1.174678087234497,
-0.41583654284477234,
-0.5052176713943481,
-0.5659521222114563,
0.11668280512094498,
-0.6497182846069336,
0.10484698414802551,
-0.31526705622673035,
0.29855337738990784,
0.14685477316379547,
-0.05240533500909805,
-0.43549808859825134,
0.525203287601471,
0.4393492043018341,
0.7679135799407959,
-1.1161826848983765,
0.6873932480812073,
0.7680196166038513,
-0.2951469421386719,
-0.2674987018108368,
0.3567999005317688,
-0.22252236306667328,
-1.1508396863937378,
1.086734414100647,
0.35710760951042175,
-0.22714532911777496,
0.41497787833213806,
-0.9491801857948303,
-0.9131686687469482,
0.8235982656478882,
0.16360999643802643,
0.09028509259223938,
-0.024847283959388733,
0.13251464068889618,
0.4274674654006958,
-0.4482031464576721,
0.2520037889480591,
0.5665841698646545,
0.4147554934024811,
-0.12286269664764404,
-0.2940787374973297,
-0.2838941514492035,
-0.08369158953428268,
0.14310435950756073,
-0.08286074548959732,
-0.5433715581893921,
0.759907066822052,
-0.15680544078350067,
-0.2585366666316986,
-0.050619639456272125,
1.0581364631652832,
-0.05012902244925499,
0.2571514844894409,
0.24153053760528564,
0.8201462030410767,
0.601564884185791,
-0.11583758890628815,
1.0513228178024292,
-0.5743699073791504,
0.26287299394607544,
0.6187434196472168,
-0.14378289878368378,
0.49313950538635254,
0.31596696376800537,
-0.3414159417152405,
0.4061422348022461,
0.6596341729164124,
0.2966899275779724,
0.3473424017429352,
0.43609270453453064,
-0.16194258630275726,
-0.543802797794342,
0.06642268598079681,
-0.215974822640419,
0.7772655487060547,
0.608833372592926,
-0.2923663556575775,
-0.28777632117271423,
0.2411109060049057,
-0.06046849861741066,
0.19893401861190796,
-0.35414010286331177,
1.273229718208313,
0.3545916676521301,
-0.5947979092597961,
0.49842941761016846,
0.3174019455909729,
0.2196132242679596,
-0.13336274027824402,
0.004144382197409868,
-0.2290698140859604,
0.03568580374121666,
-0.00015794066712260246,
-0.6796096563339233,
0.31215372681617737,
-0.07058250904083252,
-0.4297957718372345,
-0.3750747740268707,
0.7260390520095825,
-0.14973151683807373,
-0.44403454661369324,
0.4062750041484833,
0.8490605354309082,
0.5112351775169373,
0.29361987113952637,
-0.7744635343551636,
0.03595690429210663,
-0.3726869523525238,
-0.03583887591958046,
0.29284003376960754,
0.7238725423812866,
-0.11348000913858414,
0.889473021030426,
0.5415781140327454,
0.011378421448171139,
-0.008847707882523537,
-0.1277981996536255,
0.6682845950126648,
-0.9710977077484131,
-0.37531009316444397,
-1.2807042598724365,
0.27397432923316956,
0.2545768618583679,
-0.12380749732255936,
0.7287411689758301,
0.24489401280879974,
0.8088000416755676,
0.1619671881198883,
0.8106695413589478,
0.034881457686424255,
0.06895492225885391,
-0.8504033088684082,
0.41889718174934387,
-0.5154046416282654,
0.015095105394721031,
0.039602842181921005,
-0.7092761993408203,
-0.4612249433994293,
1.0209696292877197,
-0.587601900100708,
0.11441487073898315,
0.4767734110355377,
0.16043506562709808,
0.11718197166919708,
-0.1164199635386467,
0.5577738285064697,
0.36313655972480774,
0.32328158617019653,
0.06387075036764145,
1.3472729921340942,
-0.13277438282966614,
-0.2625012695789337,
0.0114131486043334,
-0.26017701625823975,
0.15702517330646515,
-0.8107618093490601,
-0.9630162715911865,
-0.5144042372703552,
-0.11209624260663986,
-0.2185671031475067,
0.006225058808922768,
0.8492340445518494,
0.5782796740531921,
-0.5948650240898132,
-0.4018072187900543,
-0.5529775023460388,
0.43866121768951416,
0.031850866973400116,
-0.1494046449661255,
0.2618664503097534,
-0.9516351222991943,
-0.6288219690322876,
0.3605237603187561,
0.39900287985801697,
0.13597215712070465,
-0.6386463046073914,
0.006716178730130196,
0.1030881479382515,
0.09935414791107178,
0.7567130923271179,
0.03695632889866829,
-1.1674623489379883,
-0.4395551085472107,
-0.28437328338623047,
-0.08135001361370087,
0.03385822847485542,
0.6218182444572449,
-0.8809468746185303,
0.06093483790755272,
0.31195250153541565,
0.7686858773231506,
0.12373731285333633,
0.08800742775201797,
0.6008031964302063,
-0.22552496194839478,
0.3620690703392029,
0.0652041956782341,
0.36965036392211914,
0.24037472903728485,
-0.30397605895996094,
0.4596159756183624,
0.5426202416419983,
-0.6129428744316101,
-0.75963294506073,
0.3227468430995941,
-0.45306986570358276,
-0.2940759062767029,
1.142870545387268,
-0.01709865964949131,
-0.3571493923664093,
-0.09941740334033966,
0.07764150947332382,
0.16173255443572998,
0.450053334236145,
0.5816303491592407,
0.7474206686019897,
-0.20445826649665833,
-0.13866552710533142,
-0.7479122281074524,
0.4611719250679016,
0.34334832429885864,
-0.8832229971885681,
0.06192789599299431,
0.5114293098449707,
0.3060624301433563,
0.21072496473789215,
0.7537950277328491,
0.21004927158355713,
0.0028025880455970764,
-0.11786836385726929,
-0.010159637778997421,
0.37120500206947327,
-0.47707390785217285,
-0.43394365906715393,
0.011339081451296806,
0.4252914488315582,
-0.12780535221099854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10712v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10712v2 | An Empirical Study on Cross-lingual Vocabulary Adaptation for Efficient Language Model Inference | 2024-02-16T14:15:15 | 2024-06-17T12:00:02 | Atsuki Yamaguchi, Aline Villavicencio, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The development of state-of-the-art generative large language models (LLMs)
disproportionately relies on English-centric tokenizers, vocabulary and
pre-training data. Despite the fact that some LLMs have multilingual
capabilities, recent studies have shown that their inference efficiency
deteriorates when generating text in languages other than English. This results
in increased inference time and costs. Cross-lingual vocabulary adaptation
(CVA) methods have been proposed for adapting models to a target language
aiming to improve downstream performance. However, the effectiveness of these
methods on increasing inference efficiency of generative LLMs has yet to be
explored. In this paper, we perform an empirical study of five CVA methods on
four generative LLMs (including monolingual and multilingual models) across
four typologically-diverse languages and four natural language understanding
tasks. We find that CVA substantially contributes to LLM inference speedups of
up to 271.5\%. We also show that adapting LLMs that have been pre-trained on
more balanced multilingual data results in downstream performance comparable to
the original models. | [
-0.23633238673210144,
-0.6176841855049133,
0.3998250365257263,
0.5259039402008057,
-0.31432852149009705,
0.07162763923406601,
-0.35699161887168884,
-0.5003429651260376,
0.08844929188489914,
0.38319748640060425,
-0.2910551130771637,
-0.46209439635276794,
-0.38731348514556885,
0.16408272087574005,
-0.08477471768856049,
0.6019721031188965,
0.05016876012086868,
0.4188383221626282,
-0.186564639210701,
-0.19150155782699585,
-0.5289433002471924,
-0.6724609136581421,
-0.5578974485397339,
-0.259674608707428,
0.5145273208618164,
-0.021241728216409683,
0.3492893576622009,
0.3685854375362396,
0.057435981929302216,
0.3311620056629181,
-0.050628695636987686,
0.18648718297481537,
-0.5633184909820557,
-0.24716529250144958,
-0.43105819821357727,
-0.8510394096374512,
-0.31998172402381897,
-0.34709906578063965,
0.7615712881088257,
0.7716595530509949,
-0.039959147572517395,
-0.05453207716345787,
0.0996590107679367,
0.5529003739356995,
-0.9013688564300537,
0.013585250824689865,
-0.9433344006538391,
0.16449834406375885,
-0.24230137467384338,
-0.35235902667045593,
-0.6899108290672302,
0.10475920140743256,
0.3272915780544281,
-1.0848958492279053,
0.21562305092811584,
0.12768709659576416,
0.6377188563346863,
-0.016888609156012535,
-0.22959160804748535,
-0.31908950209617615,
-0.5763584971427917,
1.0588011741638184,
-0.6611594557762146,
0.668321430683136,
0.013956638984382153,
0.07915960997343063,
-0.08725395053625107,
-0.5433726906776428,
-0.4593139886856079,
-0.04679393768310547,
0.07370606064796448,
0.359527051448822,
-0.27779945731163025,
-0.03711364418268204,
0.0571041963994503,
0.16739369928836823,
-0.49096164107322693,
0.7421961426734924,
-0.1768067628145218,
-0.14443424344062805,
0.4634341597557068,
-0.09303858876228333,
0.27690330147743225,
-0.29502665996551514,
-0.5559477210044861,
-0.17768406867980957,
-0.72858065366745,
0.005499501246958971,
0.2566869556903839,
0.47414907813072205,
-0.430040180683136,
0.41492876410484314,
0.161878764629364,
0.8593276143074036,
-0.16630184650421143,
-0.20485365390777588,
0.3372766673564911,
-0.6618187427520752,
-0.2650124132633209,
-0.07864349335432053,
0.5359572768211365,
0.25318607687950134,
0.6559445261955261,
-0.4009130597114563,
0.026359528303146362,
-0.08562853187322617,
0.11748000979423523,
-0.6571372151374817,
-0.02405151166021824,
-0.06257935613393784,
-0.32059869170188904,
0.17654742300510406,
-0.2898312509059906,
-0.6897925138473511,
-0.18594712018966675,
-0.23069579899311066,
0.40093615651130676,
-0.5107420682907104,
-0.22502610087394714,
0.1091199666261673,
-0.2824772298336029,
0.5890723466873169,
0.362511545419693,
-0.8285300135612488,
0.02305545099079609,
0.693215548992157,
0.9740583896636963,
-0.46125203371047974,
-0.5590637922286987,
-0.6521251797676086,
0.08979415893554688,
-0.6479703783988953,
0.8594956994056702,
-0.3192596137523651,
-0.37795495986938477,
-0.006958208046853542,
0.044618021696805954,
-0.4902056157588959,
-0.5200244784355164,
0.3361998200416565,
-0.7347384095191956,
0.12922579050064087,
-0.2849966287612915,
-0.4369901716709137,
-0.2919725477695465,
0.07981612533330917,
-0.711482584476471,
0.7070941925048828,
0.025703897699713707,
-0.6665517091751099,
0.7609005570411682,
-0.4214283525943756,
-0.5753401517868042,
0.07908642292022705,
0.05051642283797264,
-0.05905028432607651,
0.35406509041786194,
0.4936623275279999,
0.5166002511978149,
-0.5243757367134094,
0.0403861328959465,
-0.31770947575569153,
-0.18880780041217804,
0.12557891011238098,
-0.5123048424720764,
0.874587893486023,
0.07808467745780945,
0.06281234323978424,
0.03012726828455925,
-0.6442022919654846,
-0.16878841817378998,
-0.012873057276010513,
-0.33319467306137085,
-0.8873811960220337,
0.0007221426931209862,
0.052554309368133545,
0.14184388518333435,
-0.052137356251478195,
-0.2959485352039337,
-0.14721611142158508,
-0.4817323684692383,
0.13221409916877747,
0.8655911087989807,
-0.3082047998905182,
0.42410174012184143,
-0.25942912697792053,
0.7099846005439758,
0.21433618664741516,
-0.3139241635799408,
0.04927348718047142,
-0.2721625864505768,
-0.8674368262290955,
-0.6660482287406921,
0.5939674973487854,
0.6171388626098633,
-1.1785045862197876,
0.15945620834827423,
-0.6230771541595459,
-0.3887362778186798,
-0.5071265697479248,
0.28870174288749695,
0.4665363132953644,
0.24614711105823517,
0.2510824501514435,
-0.5267658233642578,
-0.3211565613746643,
-0.7322639226913452,
-0.6293026804924011,
-0.271134614944458,
-0.2136765718460083,
0.30419546365737915,
0.3794315755367279,
0.0908929780125618,
0.6486372947692871,
-0.02583226002752781,
0.16825327277183533,
-0.4834771156311035,
0.1416609287261963,
-0.04840286076068878,
0.08301127701997757,
1.0046806335449219,
-0.6763865351676941,
-0.5605690479278564,
0.2135205864906311,
-0.5490312576293945,
-0.2769976258277893,
-0.40173858404159546,
-0.3983802795410156,
0.49493715167045593,
0.2866554260253906,
-0.3438693583011627,
0.07948370277881622,
1.0546770095825195,
-0.2542096972465515,
0.3935329020023346,
-0.3707272708415985,
-0.027687877416610718,
-1.1316055059432983,
-0.14337694644927979,
0.13384942710399628,
-0.1408597230911255,
-0.7514928579330444,
-0.017318105325102806,
0.10476057231426239,
0.3350818455219269,
-0.5504692792892456,
0.7051685452461243,
-0.8498402237892151,
-0.33360016345977783,
0.058942168951034546,
0.22294709086418152,
0.0033082962036132812,
0.38197821378707886,
0.3407408893108368,
0.9199415445327759,
0.5934992432594299,
-0.7928688526153564,
-0.1540302336215973,
-0.034435950219631195,
-0.45110848546028137,
0.5072150826454163,
-0.3678945302963257,
-0.19408081471920013,
-0.24604785442352295,
0.09849519282579422,
-0.7711343765258789,
0.15562081336975098,
-0.1252671331167221,
-0.10979326069355011,
0.352385014295578,
-0.17922692000865936,
-0.17675162851810455,
0.08464254438877106,
-0.21124394237995148,
0.4015657901763916,
0.33476120233535767,
-0.8755646347999573,
1.0827503204345703,
0.29960209131240845,
-0.16406042873859406,
-0.5173701643943787,
-0.8690352439880371,
0.08063838630914688,
-0.2826043665409088,
-0.6103468537330627,
0.4102919101715088,
0.06973734498023987,
-0.3464832901954651,
-0.22329863905906677,
0.062385194003582,
0.10232964158058167,
0.26107603311538696,
-0.20247143507003784,
0.19862177968025208,
-0.36559244990348816,
0.25469762086868286,
0.05028102919459343,
0.1692153364419937,
0.13161532580852509,
-0.1738826036453247,
0.5334162712097168,
0.0793721079826355,
-0.27022162079811096,
-0.09973461180925369,
0.16934053599834442,
0.5560120344161987,
-0.2645569443702698,
0.9630218744277954,
0.5433849096298218,
-0.13370689749717712,
-0.5378438234329224,
-0.480216920375824,
0.04604497179389,
-0.3776194751262665,
0.6358689069747925,
-0.7421827912330627,
-0.6152093410491943,
0.5863578915596008,
0.02950281836092472,
0.1877414733171463,
0.5012031197547913,
0.7146851420402527,
0.3669581115245819,
0.4662855565547943,
0.5179404020309448,
-0.12038879841566086,
0.5000704526901245,
-0.030500998720526695,
0.2083526998758316,
-0.6655756235122681,
-0.05594401806592941,
-0.466915488243103,
0.1225031167268753,
-0.9943114519119263,
-1.0000642538070679,
0.22295843064785004,
0.08795087784528732,
0.32879510521888733,
0.1485014706850052,
0.1439364105463028,
0.052339229732751846,
0.3934605121612549,
-0.14685319364070892,
0.49365681409835815,
0.34354013204574585,
-0.12151192128658295,
0.03994515538215637,
-1.2472262382507324,
-0.14584143459796906,
1.1291508674621582,
0.2474658042192459,
0.7100376486778259,
0.28386640548706055,
0.33014023303985596,
-0.10878323018550873,
0.6527404189109802,
-0.7364279627799988,
0.224791020154953,
-0.5764663219451904,
-0.47537097334861755,
-0.17897097766399384,
-0.5538193583488464,
-0.8806665539741516,
0.6972945928573608,
-0.2285403460264206,
-0.4070853888988495,
0.30695927143096924,
0.04941853508353233,
-0.04335261508822441,
0.285515695810318,
-0.7985172867774963,
0.8004614114761353,
-0.3974915146827698,
-0.3174006938934326,
-0.24509166181087494,
-0.16971009969711304,
0.461317777633667,
-0.6417674422264099,
0.4515238404273987,
-0.042453162372112274,
-0.1501874178647995,
0.7575608491897583,
-0.25624457001686096,
0.7555517554283142,
-0.07218232750892639,
-0.382581889629364,
0.12075360119342804,
-0.32081112265586853,
0.4255897104740143,
-0.12502075731754303,
-0.24758847057819366,
0.6257940530776978,
-0.02590613253414631,
-0.5604099035263062,
-0.5633135437965393,
0.5431190133094788,
-0.7519479990005493,
-0.5749556422233582,
-0.34460657835006714,
-0.8284246325492859,
-0.34679022431373596,
-0.10723622143268585,
0.2943863868713379,
0.2188580483198166,
-0.37661927938461304,
0.13206520676612854,
0.40316441655158997,
-0.6201598048210144,
0.39014673233032227,
0.6966249346733093,
-0.11002004891633987,
-0.11424844712018967,
0.7529942989349365,
0.35641613602638245,
0.6804092526435852,
0.694420576095581,
0.19697944819927216,
-0.23762676119804382,
-0.7509578466415405,
-0.6781152486801147,
0.30719318985939026,
-0.6266556978225708,
0.24269600212574005,
-0.7455999255180359,
0.05094608664512634,
-0.44499990344047546,
-0.22593773901462555,
-0.3108175992965698,
-0.2238282561302185,
-0.3055866062641144,
-0.00892122182995081,
0.48152920603752136,
0.16123521327972412,
0.02013344131410122,
0.1468348503112793,
-0.6589483022689819,
0.396095871925354,
0.23209066689014435,
-0.08948294073343277,
0.10144468396902084,
-0.7972691059112549,
-0.1408463418483734,
-0.01899428479373455,
0.20449760556221008,
-0.5397724509239197,
0.4448666274547577,
0.5362840890884399,
0.628672182559967,
0.08026844263076782,
-0.2117261290550232,
1.007380723953247,
-0.4226987659931183,
0.6617720723152161,
0.11737764626741409,
-0.924933671951294,
-0.13845494389533997,
-0.10849961638450623,
0.3838970959186554,
0.1277087926864624,
0.45839449763298035,
-0.49383941292762756,
-0.1686515510082245,
0.021096795797348022,
-0.8478225469589233,
0.47410133481025696,
-0.0944291204214096,
0.31596726179122925,
0.07246153056621552,
0.1888057291507721,
0.32184261083602905,
-0.15535879135131836,
-0.6074962615966797,
-0.037134818732738495,
-0.09324082732200623,
-0.03895844891667366,
-0.5359982252120972,
-0.06797054409980774,
0.19346143305301666,
-0.15426774322986603,
0.7173535823822021,
-0.53960782289505,
-0.10284659266471863,
-0.003651811508461833,
-0.4711947441101074,
0.24350491166114807,
0.36699435114860535,
0.35648274421691895,
0.8244574069976807,
0.22485335171222687,
-0.05855153501033783,
0.6811290979385376,
-0.35058537125587463,
0.0053554982878267765,
0.22973506152629852,
-0.12302668392658234,
0.06126606836915016,
0.6932076811790466,
0.945997416973114,
0.2648768723011017,
-0.7358791828155518,
0.24509234726428986,
-0.1816309541463852,
-0.09039519727230072,
-0.19760604202747345,
0.043257132172584534,
0.35246458649635315,
0.10102244466543198,
0.2859003245830536,
-0.3398241698741913,
-0.12087693065404892,
-0.5763067007064819,
-0.2337302565574646,
0.6582207083702087,
-0.011907247826457024,
-0.21320059895515442,
0.38318750262260437,
0.10021055489778519,
0.03075312077999115,
0.30469098687171936,
-0.020408084616065025,
-0.34173545241355896,
0.46907681226730347,
0.5562633872032166,
0.8540173768997192,
-0.1973610371351242,
0.16040147840976715,
0.16030831634998322,
0.301025927066803,
0.077061228454113,
0.2538636326789856,
0.03294070437550545,
-1.0418504476547241,
-0.8553982377052307,
-0.9268305897712708,
-0.23796725273132324,
0.0013342053862288594,
-0.6085925102233887,
-0.013408524915575981,
-0.08070438355207443,
0.07191707193851471,
0.2643183171749115,
-0.14153024554252625,
-0.778832197189331,
0.07336928695440292,
0.036801353096961975,
1.1773849725723267,
-0.9617400169372559,
0.6951795816421509,
0.5821959972381592,
0.10642479360103607,
-0.6948238611221313,
-0.02469276636838913,
-0.17197410762310028,
-0.9237695932388306,
0.6800547242164612,
-0.037965912371873856,
-0.3261418342590332,
0.04003462940454483,
0.009748866781592369,
-0.7535214424133301,
0.9122796058654785,
0.46011483669281006,
-0.708182156085968,
-0.07568500936031342,
0.1652916967868805,
0.6793355941772461,
-0.4407719075679779,
0.12335919588804245,
0.5958438515663147,
0.38117554783821106,
-0.1260444074869156,
-0.8615424633026123,
-0.08403351902961731,
-0.11861637234687805,
0.4919804632663727,
0.08805715292692184,
-0.47958025336265564,
0.7058951258659363,
-0.08587037026882172,
-0.14068730175495148,
0.10533217340707779,
0.8163971900939941,
0.432143896818161,
0.1487395018339157,
0.7847936153411865,
0.5564749836921692,
0.6591383218765259,
0.061400849372148514,
1.1384576559066772,
-0.40919458866119385,
0.01532179769128561,
0.9435889720916748,
-0.31902197003364563,
0.7935871481895447,
0.6946752667427063,
-0.07381640374660492,
0.6353557705879211,
0.5325999855995178,
0.08888289332389832,
0.3712671101093292,
0.21245960891246796,
-0.2859474718570709,
-0.39572352170944214,
-0.2680017352104187,
-0.16337639093399048,
0.7999953031539917,
0.5302603840827942,
-0.498104453086853,
-0.09888575226068497,
0.024958519265055656,
-0.00807357020676136,
-0.11895907670259476,
-0.4475540220737457,
0.6855219602584839,
0.06509575247764587,
-0.929611086845398,
0.8024081587791443,
0.10511474311351776,
0.8262092471122742,
-0.6071622371673584,
0.26165682077407837,
-0.09953959286212921,
0.1562546193599701,
0.013415603898465633,
-0.258748322725296,
-0.047032471746206284,
0.1787305772304535,
-0.08777301013469696,
-0.030758515000343323,
0.4828031063079834,
-0.4180082678794861,
-0.7134391665458679,
0.7278852462768555,
0.869724452495575,
0.21851301193237305,
0.16991688311100006,
-0.5863556265830994,
-0.0529671311378479,
-0.10311259329319,
-0.39941301941871643,
0.3428822457790375,
0.5210235714912415,
-0.3387967348098755,
0.4714326560497284,
0.7920756936073303,
0.4012008309364319,
0.36974838376045227,
0.3844200670719147,
0.6003711223602295,
-0.41733258962631226,
-0.4100242257118225,
-0.6678644418716431,
0.3422829806804657,
0.08977213501930237,
-0.3432513475418091,
0.9588639736175537,
0.4011557698249817,
1.2714561223983765,
-0.13775932788848877,
0.8569157123565674,
0.17942164838314056,
0.2379423826932907,
-1.0562986135482788,
0.4433554708957672,
-0.8187042474746704,
0.18980969488620758,
-0.19303515553474426,
-0.7831499576568604,
-0.10588771849870682,
0.30800777673721313,
-0.44255974888801575,
0.33995339274406433,
0.5584412217140198,
0.8002772331237793,
-0.1576806753873825,
-0.258108913898468,
0.45873716473579407,
0.2798275351524353,
0.1588553488254547,
0.55256187915802,
0.4933638274669647,
-0.22497917711734772,
0.2496519535779953,
-0.2933284044265747,
-0.19525252282619476,
-0.10449231415987015,
-1.0753049850463867,
-0.9233905076980591,
-0.25045233964920044,
-0.17744088172912598,
-0.078920379281044,
0.2180902063846588,
0.5550423264503479,
0.7311627864837646,
-0.7810764312744141,
-0.33105120062828064,
-0.1610066443681717,
0.11871795356273651,
-0.22763754427433014,
-0.19777242839336395,
0.3357737958431244,
-0.4765982925891876,
-0.9521133899688721,
0.4530644714832306,
0.26660430431365967,
-0.1196194514632225,
-0.29772767424583435,
-0.17579995095729828,
-0.30117934942245483,
0.3057708442211151,
0.8577514290809631,
0.11259223520755768,
-0.8251547813415527,
-0.16189561784267426,
-0.018981680274009705,
0.03594318777322769,
0.0652858316898346,
0.7908552289009094,
-0.6060582995414734,
0.6471524834632874,
0.6978890299797058,
0.8609545230865479,
0.5261396169662476,
-0.011214789003133774,
0.8972260355949402,
-0.5554038882255554,
0.25089001655578613,
-0.12177061289548874,
0.4129239320755005,
0.4967850148677826,
-0.05773612856864929,
0.2907637059688568,
0.24880985915660858,
-0.15940065681934357,
-0.6767889261245728,
0.11510742455720901,
-0.665570855140686,
-0.5040245056152344,
1.1923747062683105,
-0.4098873734474182,
-0.40797001123428345,
-0.17882154881954193,
0.23356255888938904,
0.3357110917568207,
0.045844703912734985,
0.4877835512161255,
0.6740291118621826,
0.11176501959562302,
-0.13024483621120453,
-0.5126563310623169,
0.2088516652584076,
0.7616273164749146,
-1.037918210029602,
0.13638842105865479,
0.2826016843318939,
0.38045307993888855,
0.12294614315032959,
0.4344874620437622,
0.11632560193538666,
0.2600412368774414,
0.017929475754499435,
0.07569226622581482,
0.3128240704536438,
-0.27902552485466003,
-0.5438662171363831,
-0.013778050430119038,
0.17050638794898987,
0.09561420232057571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10699v1 | Rethinking Human-like Translation Strategy: Integrating Drift-Diffusion Model with Large Language Models for Machine Translation | 2024-02-16T14:00:56 | 2024-02-16T14:00:56 | Hongbin Na, Zimu Wang, Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Tong Chen, Wei Wang, Tao Shen, Ling Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated promising potential in various
downstream tasks, including machine translation. However, prior work on
LLM-based machine translation has mainly focused on better utilizing training
data, demonstrations, or pre-defined and universal knowledge to improve
performance, with a lack of consideration of decision-making like human
translators. In this paper, we incorporate Thinker with the Drift-Diffusion
Model (Thinker-DDM) to address this issue. We then redefine the Drift-Diffusion
process to emulate human translators' dynamic decision-making under constrained
resources. We conduct extensive experiments under the high-resource,
low-resource, and commonsense translation settings using the WMT22 and CommonMT
datasets, in which Thinker-DDM outperforms baselines in the first two
scenarios. We also perform additional analysis and evaluation on commonsense
translation to illustrate the high effectiveness and efficacy of the proposed
method. | [
-0.3679105341434479,
-0.630986750125885,
0.7639780640602112,
-0.03164466843008995,
-0.5741769075393677,
0.23152199387550354,
-0.5266176462173462,
-0.15071779489517212,
0.16701364517211914,
0.464709997177124,
-0.6165047287940979,
-0.36031219363212585,
-0.5961284637451172,
0.35392868518829346,
-0.39505186676979065,
0.9984660148620605,
-0.3688203990459442,
-0.03242630884051323,
0.05722476541996002,
-0.16115030646324158,
-0.48416197299957275,
-0.18815568089485168,
-0.6042377352714539,
-0.6344807744026184,
0.4462743401527405,
0.2564261853694916,
0.9965912699699402,
0.6326536536216736,
0.44658756256103516,
0.21636347472667694,
-0.4340746998786926,
-0.06212560459971428,
-0.4930093288421631,
0.0949811190366745,
-0.2894372045993805,
-0.6738814115524292,
-0.5801684856414795,
0.23126497864723206,
0.5434511303901672,
0.3837611973285675,
-0.4798145890235901,
0.09972607344388962,
-0.09476141631603241,
0.6213006973266602,
-0.30913087725639343,
-0.30073586106300354,
-0.7172070145606995,
0.22475619614124298,
-0.19273875653743744,
0.0690765455365181,
-0.37055566906929016,
-0.260475218296051,
0.2869429886341095,
-0.5268397927284241,
0.38808712363243103,
0.24675266444683075,
0.32398492097854614,
0.5497936606407166,
-0.45061194896698,
-0.1247183308005333,
-0.7463942170143127,
0.9639508724212646,
-0.9373186826705933,
0.44686397910118103,
0.13871900737285614,
0.19186186790466309,
-0.2058495730161667,
-0.33973178267478943,
-0.859342098236084,
-0.02991866134107113,
0.09382834285497665,
0.13307319581508636,
-0.14273189008235931,
-0.3083801567554474,
-0.011222201399505138,
0.19652821123600006,
-0.3098076581954956,
0.27939796447753906,
-0.12351556867361069,
-0.03764626383781433,
0.7481946349143982,
0.1923707276582718,
0.2825782299041748,
-0.19945091009140015,
-0.5204796195030212,
-0.20986296236515045,
-0.5175564289093018,
-0.40448030829429626,
-0.11895950883626938,
0.2143540382385254,
-0.26425057649612427,
0.45622819662094116,
-0.2703745365142822,
0.5726768374443054,
0.13554580509662628,
-0.008168159052729607,
0.4239702522754669,
-0.24453817307949066,
-0.21747823059558868,
-0.10868116468191147,
0.8624048829078674,
0.643156886100769,
0.2532461881637573,
-0.35158035159111023,
-0.5161423087120056,
-0.17859670519828796,
0.40594711899757385,
-0.6686909198760986,
-0.0867636650800705,
0.16723670065402985,
-0.5450215339660645,
-0.4965563118457794,
-0.5099095702171326,
-1.0504708290100098,
-0.32150009274482727,
-0.38649868965148926,
0.2382792830467224,
-0.24982193112373352,
-0.5653029084205627,
0.19776038825511932,
-0.021073611453175545,
0.30095064640045166,
0.44833818078041077,
-0.7935898900032043,
0.17368073761463165,
0.43864259123802185,
0.9929848313331604,
-0.7245368957519531,
-0.3129887878894806,
-0.3010471761226654,
0.192261204123497,
-0.3877391815185547,
0.7007073760032654,
-0.39646872878074646,
-0.575120747089386,
-0.2151878923177719,
-0.30596619844436646,
-0.06192896515130997,
-0.7349007725715637,
0.6545531749725342,
-0.6892426609992981,
0.24496540427207947,
-0.2517402172088623,
-0.39130035042762756,
-0.039636701345443726,
0.3667433261871338,
-0.588371753692627,
0.564575731754303,
0.05844074487686157,
-0.5537365078926086,
0.4802902638912201,
-0.8789002895355225,
-0.530193030834198,
0.19886414706707,
0.011529718525707722,
-0.3667849898338318,
0.2557903230190277,
0.1365021914243698,
0.3964872658252716,
-0.47410866618156433,
0.2530464231967926,
-0.13643652200698853,
-0.18041202425956726,
0.5968014597892761,
-0.5083667635917664,
0.5275212526321411,
0.559371829032898,
-0.2762230932712555,
0.052774958312511444,
-0.15995143353939056,
-0.017333639785647392,
0.268665611743927,
-0.6197541952133179,
-0.1870923489332199,
0.11172842979431152,
0.16863660514354706,
0.5389629602432251,
-0.05686846375465393,
-0.47541502118110657,
0.22898384928703308,
-0.3707221746444702,
0.7377063632011414,
0.4611329138278961,
-0.06574701517820358,
0.8982990980148315,
-0.2447216808795929,
0.7422849535942078,
0.0375395230948925,
-0.04607035592198372,
0.2786780595779419,
-0.38234850764274597,
-0.7327635884284973,
-0.09835987538099289,
0.17553196847438812,
0.7531000971794128,
-0.6970080137252808,
-0.028597701340913773,
-0.5646350383758545,
-0.13566258549690247,
-1.038380742073059,
0.32898133993148804,
0.31135791540145874,
0.4807082414627075,
0.6185588836669922,
-0.25727009773254395,
-0.2768564820289612,
-0.719214141368866,
-0.2810204029083252,
0.0930652916431427,
-0.013054165989160538,
-0.1430852711200714,
0.2916876971721649,
-0.7464101910591125,
0.73817378282547,
-0.6154069304466248,
-0.11527775228023529,
-0.5830884575843811,
0.02652079612016678,
0.27567732334136963,
0.39642322063446045,
0.0463847815990448,
-1.0239806175231934,
-0.4663209021091461,
0.07152760773897171,
-0.49402913451194763,
-0.06956781446933746,
-0.20098307728767395,
-0.2973495125770569,
0.19218695163726807,
0.6236620545387268,
-0.9165661334991455,
0.287288635969162,
0.5037867426872253,
-0.021899089217185974,
0.26052388548851013,
-0.36693844199180603,
0.09769388288259506,
-1.2906826734542847,
-0.03829365596175194,
0.13475880026817322,
-0.37877142429351807,
-0.603841245174408,
0.35578104853630066,
0.12930598855018616,
-0.06078040972352028,
-0.7975755333900452,
0.5337939262390137,
-0.36265140771865845,
0.08840535581111908,
-0.39966756105422974,
0.3932751715183258,
-0.321250319480896,
0.19134555757045746,
0.027746692299842834,
0.8830669522285461,
0.03531459718942642,
-0.570807933807373,
0.18246589601039886,
0.34213778376579285,
-0.24241523444652557,
0.6972187161445618,
-0.6062474250793457,
0.20785266160964966,
-0.15037918090820312,
0.4822384715080261,
-0.7280940413475037,
-0.2252884805202484,
0.2795174717903137,
-0.13216811418533325,
0.4196535348892212,
-0.11270066350698471,
-0.5248011350631714,
-0.3848980963230133,
-0.1086181029677391,
0.4307715892791748,
0.8833653926849365,
-0.12047147750854492,
0.488729327917099,
0.29492950439453125,
-0.19095508754253387,
-0.08993352204561234,
-0.8863901495933533,
0.47575679421424866,
-0.6079696416854858,
-0.4399615228176117,
0.6425138711929321,
-0.170937180519104,
-0.36637669801712036,
-0.24090096354484558,
-0.03921252861618996,
0.08536814153194427,
0.2281530648469925,
-0.24939371645450592,
0.3487592041492462,
0.15489766001701355,
-0.12951216101646423,
-0.02326798625290394,
-0.3827291429042816,
-0.031935155391693115,
-0.5228503346443176,
0.5230364203453064,
0.1617407351732254,
-0.1746942549943924,
-0.4299992322921753,
0.2369714230298996,
0.7886942028999329,
-0.2592979669570923,
0.539136528968811,
0.6966673135757446,
0.08446585386991501,
-0.34612712264060974,
-0.4842042624950409,
-0.08442992717027664,
-0.40724003314971924,
0.5835311412811279,
-0.3741110563278198,
-0.7089202404022217,
0.3570559620857239,
-0.45743682980537415,
0.21658678352832794,
0.35993054509162903,
0.8755119442939758,
-0.5774350166320801,
0.96507728099823,
0.38542890548706055,
-0.13007690012454987,
0.3440157175064087,
-0.28759339451789856,
0.07299340516328812,
-1.1163345575332642,
-0.09804486483335495,
0.040250733494758606,
-0.8779095411300659,
-0.6019238829612732,
-0.8176538348197937,
0.27948781847953796,
-0.018340790644288063,
0.05106787011027336,
0.386494517326355,
-0.21308037638664246,
0.42728137969970703,
0.2750309705734253,
0.03108082339167595,
0.4784187078475952,
-0.14559513330459595,
-0.2728178799152374,
-0.130360409617424,
-0.7120736837387085,
-0.6751141548156738,
1.042506217956543,
0.23447060585021973,
0.6467323303222656,
0.365067720413208,
0.7348440289497375,
0.5649189352989197,
0.5618852972984314,
-0.6868147850036621,
0.6188181638717651,
-0.1461031287908554,
-0.5410744547843933,
-0.23600225150585175,
-0.4908321797847748,
-0.906520426273346,
0.5677475929260254,
-0.16356685757637024,
-0.09334895759820938,
-0.23717373609542847,
0.19830933213233948,
-0.08757053315639496,
0.3803868591785431,
-0.6991332173347473,
0.7119093537330627,
-0.29227784276008606,
-0.04862046614289284,
-0.6301999688148499,
-0.6472050547599792,
0.23904532194137573,
-0.40667444467544556,
0.3722936511039734,
-0.028175005689263344,
-0.5076685547828674,
0.46320632100105286,
-0.039754822850227356,
0.7282325029373169,
-0.0062780012376606464,
-0.44569191336631775,
0.15152707695960999,
0.33454006910324097,
0.6820947527885437,
-0.25544753670692444,
-0.2376542091369629,
-0.06496042013168335,
-0.4954526424407959,
-0.5263042449951172,
-0.5353243350982666,
0.43751707673072815,
-0.7089903950691223,
-0.7349492311477661,
0.035276416689157486,
-0.592715322971344,
-0.011805130168795586,
0.28392452001571655,
0.44994091987609863,
-0.06502200663089752,
-0.3979499042034149,
-0.14685069024562836,
0.7928187847137451,
0.06963957101106644,
0.5314406156539917,
0.7447080016136169,
-0.3153570890426636,
-0.43942737579345703,
0.8231569528579712,
-0.03225705400109291,
0.6530026793479919,
0.5594308376312256,
0.2194412648677826,
-0.30325332283973694,
-0.809403121471405,
-0.9377188682556152,
0.30913016200065613,
-0.3056483864784241,
-0.013442350551486015,
-0.5272072553634644,
0.14770099520683289,
-0.02349996566772461,
-0.2501472532749176,
-0.3461857736110687,
-0.22680673003196716,
-0.27875521779060364,
-0.02086552605032921,
0.005412951111793518,
0.6265134811401367,
0.2401021271944046,
0.3221991956233978,
-0.5893327593803406,
0.2741831839084625,
0.28221258521080017,
0.10354667156934738,
0.2162144035100937,
-0.7976394295692444,
-0.4599079489707947,
0.3107524514198303,
-0.5395086407661438,
-0.8697261810302734,
0.5220987200737,
-0.11254912614822388,
0.6311774253845215,
0.19232754409313202,
-0.07166439294815063,
0.3722863495349884,
-0.7336413860321045,
0.42053577303886414,
0.202151820063591,
-0.7850298881530762,
0.4475351870059967,
-0.5076901316642761,
0.5485638380050659,
0.49620941281318665,
0.20160968601703644,
-0.7933397889137268,
-0.4004012942314148,
-0.3325256109237671,
-0.586575448513031,
0.47535085678100586,
0.24506253004074097,
0.2289460003376007,
-0.007702673319727182,
0.3597889542579651,
-0.011637399904429913,
0.16510097682476044,
-0.5827094316482544,
0.04961095005273819,
0.04677433893084526,
-0.22209614515304565,
-0.2293768674135208,
0.048036959022283554,
0.12283050268888474,
-0.18174847960472107,
0.45349937677383423,
0.13655593991279602,
-0.01787521131336689,
0.025996459648013115,
-0.41308170557022095,
-0.24383901059627533,
0.6436699032783508,
0.5854699015617371,
0.4484875202178955,
-0.18352685868740082,
0.08745525032281876,
0.6740074157714844,
-0.32594814896583557,
0.5969018936157227,
-0.26914912462234497,
-0.6039009690284729,
-0.21452802419662476,
0.21953681111335754,
0.5305060148239136,
0.3631425201892853,
-0.6583938002586365,
0.2461676150560379,
0.2700359523296356,
-0.26646262407302856,
0.011079122312366962,
0.26874837279319763,
0.5026349425315857,
0.27683261036872864,
0.22776183485984802,
0.376238614320755,
-0.15569402277469635,
-0.30728834867477417,
-0.025422904640436172,
0.19984324276447296,
-0.45824041962623596,
-0.5607525706291199,
0.7714335918426514,
0.6839942932128906,
-0.6676015257835388,
0.6887863278388977,
-0.5626339316368103,
-0.6975798010826111,
0.16030922532081604,
0.6875921487808228,
1.0873439311981201,
-0.23208892345428467,
0.2727636992931366,
-0.006712541449815035,
0.304631769657135,
-0.42591720819473267,
-0.002763103460893035,
-0.03980694338679314,
-0.7353978157043457,
-0.8017184138298035,
-0.31032609939575195,
-0.29869669675827026,
-0.1455293446779251,
-0.6499044895172119,
0.2536314129829407,
-0.07134544849395752,
-0.4451894164085388,
-0.29373228549957275,
-0.13184870779514313,
-0.7784994840621948,
0.036180537194013596,
0.20798344910144806,
1.0532087087631226,
-0.7964586615562439,
0.9263038635253906,
0.9105338454246521,
-0.3425297737121582,
-0.09694649279117584,
0.408433735370636,
0.1467769891023636,
-0.5949656367301941,
0.583516001701355,
-0.2292085438966751,
-0.2590711712837219,
0.2772999107837677,
-0.3940644860267639,
-0.82471764087677,
1.2212324142456055,
0.22904931008815765,
-0.7355477809906006,
-0.08511500060558319,
-0.08061160892248154,
0.5974354147911072,
-0.3026883900165558,
-0.2695867419242859,
0.7205436825752258,
0.3770081400871277,
-0.04309876263141632,
-0.8794617056846619,
0.01626288890838623,
0.014467945322394371,
0.24745769798755646,
0.5232945680618286,
-0.8058869242668152,
0.594336986541748,
-0.46066343784332275,
-0.43249088525772095,
-0.12135686725378036,
0.6210365891456604,
-0.025085100904107094,
0.14222285151481628,
0.6318146586418152,
0.9159627556800842,
0.6763216257095337,
0.561237096786499,
1.0896133184432983,
0.24777762591838837,
0.19381090998649597,
0.9990816116333008,
-0.36947527527809143,
1.2501006126403809,
0.5522298812866211,
-0.44901761412620544,
0.5691503286361694,
0.26268959045410156,
0.1967114359140396,
0.6946704983711243,
0.2531189024448395,
-0.2700534760951996,
-0.35098356008529663,
0.09889476746320724,
-0.09146048128604889,
0.2708051800727844,
0.20635274052619934,
-0.3236011266708374,
-0.09041350334882736,
-0.0492616705596447,
0.357207328081131,
0.2547096610069275,
-0.1211167573928833,
0.8591901063919067,
0.1469571888446808,
-0.7837583422660828,
0.6953423619270325,
0.3522704243659973,
0.991795003414154,
-0.1493104249238968,
0.2802450358867645,
-0.3305552005767822,
0.13987328112125397,
0.15729990601539612,
-0.9491907358169556,
0.2925770580768585,
0.2458423674106598,
-0.5523018836975098,
-0.6353142261505127,
0.34471696615219116,
-0.5333676338195801,
-0.4808109998703003,
0.16821949183940887,
0.8816525936126709,
0.10756462067365646,
0.024621546268463135,
-0.7734372019767761,
-0.00655399588868022,
0.4728385806083679,
-0.042177822440862656,
0.4672568738460541,
0.507872998714447,
-0.0516178272664547,
1.088243007659912,
0.6106353402137756,
0.2876048684120178,
-0.16430716216564178,
0.07333023101091385,
0.730973482131958,
-0.8972986340522766,
-0.43624168634414673,
-1.1098037958145142,
0.29429250955581665,
0.001681711757555604,
-0.3868420422077179,
0.6956528425216675,
0.34194275736808777,
0.7874757051467896,
-0.014614902436733246,
0.6628667116165161,
0.09924814850091934,
0.46206560730934143,
-0.37843942642211914,
0.7875961065292358,
-0.36762943863868713,
0.28178316354751587,
-0.2988851070404053,
-1.0809446573257446,
0.007971496321260929,
0.430059552192688,
-0.37582188844680786,
-0.040623728185892105,
0.4181191027164459,
0.6858463287353516,
-0.17312665283679962,
-0.08327628672122955,
0.1466505527496338,
0.17090435326099396,
0.4596063792705536,
0.642213761806488,
0.9147059917449951,
-0.10864555835723877,
0.746456503868103,
0.21356792747974396,
-0.16007335484027863,
-0.2961325943470001,
-1.04158353805542,
-0.7691962718963623,
-0.41431164741516113,
-0.3721345365047455,
-0.03989965468645096,
-0.2815350592136383,
1.120235562324524,
0.7136478424072266,
-0.4888212978839874,
-0.24448871612548828,
-0.13965637981891632,
0.1188596859574318,
-0.16258975863456726,
-0.14507630467414856,
0.02202734723687172,
-0.31649014353752136,
-0.6619443297386169,
0.40797534584999084,
0.06517252326011658,
0.31222572922706604,
-0.4927511215209961,
-0.48265472054481506,
-0.11344646662473679,
0.005321078468114138,
0.5864900946617126,
-0.09347996860742569,
-0.9585606455802917,
0.2555354833602905,
-0.01620146632194519,
-0.30826160311698914,
-0.08553414791822433,
0.7767066955566406,
-0.8500999212265015,
0.5009795427322388,
0.36418282985687256,
0.6918442249298096,
0.5242611765861511,
0.1183096319437027,
0.8069248795509338,
-0.3421889841556549,
0.03209373727440834,
0.2467833161354065,
0.033149655908346176,
0.5635639429092407,
0.04652479663491249,
0.3918650150299072,
0.17885839939117432,
-0.4498836100101471,
-0.4760502874851227,
0.3163108229637146,
-0.5664663314819336,
-0.2581503987312317,
1.1968973875045776,
0.15451256930828094,
-0.12609705328941345,
-0.11443480104207993,
-0.1964176446199417,
0.1820090264081955,
-0.5224485993385315,
0.9721800088882446,
0.647757887840271,
0.16220484673976898,
-0.14357195794582367,
-0.6785168647766113,
0.3753874897956848,
0.4907788336277008,
-0.5894721746444702,
0.2189698964357376,
0.24437366425991058,
0.3680936098098755,
0.05353645980358124,
0.6545088291168213,
0.12351234257221222,
-0.021433888003230095,
-0.39640310406684875,
-0.10849186033010483,
0.12948384881019592,
0.10285960137844086,
-0.22511903941631317,
-0.32172343134880066,
0.10915056616067886,
-0.13109886646270752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10693v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10693v3 | Exploring Precision and Recall to assess the quality and diversity of LLMs | 2024-02-16T13:53:26 | 2024-06-04T11:33:27 | Florian Le Bronnec, Alexandre Verine, Benjamin Negrevergne, Yann Chevaleyre, Alexandre Allauzen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce a novel evaluation framework for Large Language Models (LLMs)
such as \textsc{Llama-2} and \textsc{Mistral}, focusing on importing Precision
and Recall metrics from image generation to text generation. This approach
allows for a nuanced assessment of the quality and diversity of generated text
without the need for aligned corpora. By conducting a comprehensive evaluation
of state-of-the-art language models, the study reveals new insights into their
performance on open-ended generation tasks, which are not adequately captured
by traditional benchmarks. The findings highlight a trade-off between the
quality and diversity of generated samples, particularly when models are
fine-tuned on instruction dataset or with human feedback. This work extends the
toolkit for distribution-based NLP evaluation, offering insights into the
practical capabilities and challenges that current LLMs face in generating
diverse and high-quality text. We release our code and data. | [
-0.3428120017051697,
-0.4264911413192749,
0.25993555784225464,
0.1000606119632721,
-0.12913767993450165,
0.0022296812385320663,
-0.42450496554374695,
-0.37005510926246643,
-0.15125389397144318,
0.5450498461723328,
-0.29921984672546387,
-0.8129287362098694,
-0.734013557434082,
0.2832818031311035,
-0.6907130479812622,
0.7407426834106445,
-0.061948973685503006,
-0.23493033647537231,
-0.1439826935529709,
-0.24750660359859467,
-0.4325345456600189,
-0.48364415764808655,
-0.2878965735435486,
-0.25624600052833557,
0.1926572620868683,
0.3378903269767761,
0.7491308450698853,
0.7009960412979126,
0.6534773111343384,
0.22493183612823486,
-0.19773204624652863,
0.35971033573150635,
-0.836952269077301,
0.1160578727722168,
-0.2256530523300171,
-0.32902997732162476,
-0.3251970410346985,
-0.21520814299583435,
1.0162756443023682,
0.6321672797203064,
-0.19367682933807373,
0.3103078305721283,
0.14250290393829346,
0.6893121600151062,
-0.7950206398963928,
-0.21625784039497375,
-0.9494744539260864,
0.032543156296014786,
-0.09451965987682343,
-0.12660235166549683,
-0.4894392192363739,
-0.5275686383247375,
0.10018199682235718,
-0.3861551582813263,
0.39552000164985657,
-0.07119128108024597,
0.9347119927406311,
0.08277257531881332,
-0.3118181526660919,
-0.5198130011558533,
-0.8324242830276489,
0.9427738785743713,
-0.637496829032898,
0.1998208463191986,
0.10002211481332779,
0.37885624170303345,
-0.18446658551692963,
-0.8167310357093811,
-0.5388654470443726,
-0.003185448469594121,
0.2902098298072815,
0.10873008519411087,
-0.263910174369812,
-0.23349618911743164,
0.06389447301626205,
0.7607911825180054,
-0.3132001757621765,
0.45178553462028503,
-0.27666640281677246,
0.03067777492105961,
0.8034351468086243,
0.346439927816391,
0.18502970039844513,
-0.05015672743320465,
-0.1608109027147293,
-0.3295210599899292,
-0.7718979716300964,
-0.1468530148267746,
0.3724619448184967,
0.2073771357536316,
0.01734728366136551,
0.7513418197631836,
-0.11699532717466354,
0.5323618054389954,
-0.20100821554660797,
-0.24021723866462708,
0.35322386026382446,
-0.42393726110458374,
-0.22855904698371887,
-0.40860745310783386,
1.0190560817718506,
0.5190576314926147,
0.3406970500946045,
-0.010854524560272694,
-0.4525068402290344,
-0.2461404651403427,
0.31668251752853394,
-0.6872835755348206,
0.0471419133245945,
-0.06421826034784317,
-0.6146509051322937,
-0.3020932078361511,
0.1507287472486496,
-0.8756627440452576,
-0.18612775206565857,
-0.10274104028940201,
0.22825594246387482,
-0.40099942684173584,
-0.2217799425125122,
0.32610055804252625,
-0.19059742987155914,
0.09888578951358795,
0.20599842071533203,
-1.173149585723877,
0.35040032863616943,
0.6829538941383362,
0.7141615748405457,
-0.6307756304740906,
-0.31239718198776245,
-0.17379102110862732,
0.0368657186627388,
-0.5943960547447205,
0.7150846719741821,
-0.25597161054611206,
-0.6137489080429077,
0.1840219348669052,
-0.38001158833503723,
0.2783270478248596,
-1.0198991298675537,
0.5928611755371094,
-0.4402391016483307,
-0.11301161348819733,
-0.40178272128105164,
-0.605567216873169,
-0.19894146919250488,
0.283368319272995,
-0.8367586135864258,
1.395932674407959,
0.29049527645111084,
-0.5972087383270264,
0.6189920902252197,
-0.15421374142169952,
-0.2649175226688385,
0.2676580548286438,
-0.29268699884414673,
-0.4262179732322693,
0.28806430101394653,
0.21642997860908508,
0.48381125926971436,
-0.533802330493927,
0.47096896171569824,
-0.28650110960006714,
-0.3545056879520416,
0.2720370292663574,
-0.648043692111969,
0.45548954606056213,
0.2074367254972458,
-0.3107339143753052,
0.031307149678468704,
-0.7414422035217285,
0.0013560218503698707,
0.0827142670750618,
-0.48637375235557556,
-0.16866451501846313,
-0.0927845761179924,
0.057304807007312775,
0.042969781905412674,
0.30108028650283813,
-0.19059325754642487,
-0.05462320148944855,
-0.24014998972415924,
0.19613252580165863,
0.6198151111602783,
-0.04691010341048241,
0.49866217374801636,
-0.4523710608482361,
0.4553300440311432,
-0.24083895981311798,
0.05591529235243797,
-0.4225742518901825,
-0.4450881779193878,
-0.6573178172111511,
-0.4118202030658722,
0.16808772087097168,
0.5244908928871155,
-0.29107925295829773,
0.7506271600723267,
-0.45611000061035156,
-0.7345182299613953,
-0.43238431215286255,
0.37495627999305725,
0.23460906744003296,
0.3006850481033325,
0.021097930148243904,
-0.5806388854980469,
-0.3527056574821472,
-0.904717206954956,
0.016996068879961967,
-0.04623491317033768,
-0.17528952658176422,
0.35188278555870056,
0.4347490966320038,
-0.3112775683403015,
1.0124456882476807,
-0.294853538274765,
0.09912991523742676,
-0.30420586466789246,
0.16823710501194,
0.15138526260852814,
0.2591807544231415,
0.6270704865455627,
-0.5900663137435913,
-0.1430215686559677,
-0.04332699626684189,
-0.9159412980079651,
-0.15486964583396912,
-0.11311904340982437,
-0.23993127048015594,
0.29169762134552,
0.3157338798046112,
-0.5562283992767334,
0.3927738666534424,
0.6904565691947937,
0.05778932943940163,
0.7806819677352905,
-0.13771502673625946,
0.3391128480434418,
-1.1408390998840332,
0.3220893144607544,
-0.239495649933815,
-0.0074796839617192745,
-0.3862971365451813,
0.15195849537849426,
0.18609830737113953,
0.04950534924864769,
-0.4569256901741028,
0.5593123435974121,
-0.49590763449668884,
-0.49351900815963745,
-0.03731910511851311,
0.1582835167646408,
0.11688365042209625,
-0.04544787108898163,
0.038954876363277435,
0.8486950397491455,
0.2217056155204773,
-0.6018233299255371,
0.1812160462141037,
0.17092449963092804,
-0.7229394316673279,
0.49372830986976624,
-0.6364991068840027,
-0.0851973220705986,
0.025982113555073738,
-0.040244970470666885,
-1.1092112064361572,
-0.1932811290025711,
-0.13911950588226318,
-0.3529992997646332,
0.3154803216457367,
0.21799542009830475,
-0.8347687721252441,
-0.4184732735157013,
-0.21835264563560486,
0.36780938506126404,
0.8377795219421387,
-0.5015396475791931,
0.1604977697134018,
0.25963225960731506,
-0.2825555205345154,
-0.8538566827774048,
-0.5657482147216797,
0.07897108793258667,
-0.17848564684391022,
-0.43917712569236755,
0.16475436091423035,
0.0080413231626153,
-0.3405124843120575,
-0.1871732622385025,
0.11671508848667145,
0.12391258031129837,
0.2468900829553604,
0.07769507169723511,
0.17656917870044708,
-0.2678981125354767,
0.3140462338924408,
0.25124263763427734,
0.21152861416339874,
-0.08818168193101883,
-0.2824983596801758,
0.5049134492874146,
-0.132765531539917,
-0.5620368719100952,
-0.1677030324935913,
0.2595595717430115,
0.34259137511253357,
-0.16725276410579681,
0.46838974952697754,
0.44998615980148315,
-0.4050501883029938,
-0.26554062962532043,
-0.5957714915275574,
-0.034385401755571365,
-0.4609808027744293,
0.6257933974266052,
-0.18880484998226166,
-1.0162489414215088,
0.5352281928062439,
-0.09788817167282104,
0.3455639183521271,
0.6392289400100708,
0.8930193781852722,
0.016598893329501152,
0.5517904162406921,
0.5594124794006348,
0.14918091893196106,
0.2874888479709625,
-0.16322165727615356,
-0.0024664297234266996,
-0.5130311250686646,
-0.18128512799739838,
-0.5222715139389038,
-0.25836077332496643,
-0.34140250086784363,
-0.5843673944473267,
0.17026248574256897,
0.48670756816864014,
-0.2771315574645996,
0.10188865661621094,
-0.5180796980857849,
0.5991082191467285,
0.5278380513191223,
-0.21212489902973175,
0.5164510011672974,
0.3678925037384033,
-0.04393966495990753,
-0.21691878139972687,
-0.5358757376670837,
-1.0367581844329834,
1.4161717891693115,
0.38657233119010925,
0.6589452028274536,
0.06504148244857788,
0.9057639241218567,
0.21247053146362305,
0.5247851014137268,
-0.7436509728431702,
0.4795284867286682,
-0.5056110620498657,
-0.4741581082344055,
-0.37790101766586304,
-0.5338325500488281,
-1.0215173959732056,
0.10275428742170334,
-0.3884764611721039,
-0.6310713887214661,
-0.14564380049705505,
-0.03903161361813545,
-0.24509727954864502,
0.4935407340526581,
-0.41844654083251953,
0.6182168126106262,
-0.1708817034959793,
-0.08277325332164764,
-0.10826509445905685,
-0.31717604398727417,
0.7123334407806396,
-0.27179673314094543,
0.053359270095825195,
-0.2887136936187744,
-0.147331103682518,
0.517776608467102,
0.08796774595975876,
0.7492450475692749,
0.3201524019241333,
-0.39844080805778503,
0.5504370927810669,
0.3558953106403351,
0.05047056823968887,
-0.06693271547555923,
-0.45461419224739075,
0.44253063201904297,
-0.23185424506664276,
-0.16135258972644806,
-0.5759657621383667,
0.6485689878463745,
-0.8192480206489563,
-0.1779176890850067,
0.0736783966422081,
-0.7460361123085022,
0.1629808247089386,
0.28427812457084656,
0.4514414072036743,
0.33032387495040894,
-0.5311463475227356,
0.07936765998601913,
0.7062212824821472,
-0.5675489902496338,
0.4192862808704376,
0.14859792590141296,
-0.2662177085876465,
-0.7201353311538696,
0.7598634958267212,
0.1235584244132042,
0.623052179813385,
0.5161746740341187,
-0.008886735886335373,
-0.34255775809288025,
-0.7389712929725647,
-0.6389978528022766,
0.2295839786529541,
-0.9845740795135498,
-0.28326451778411865,
-0.6193414926528931,
-0.2111632376909256,
-0.39100924134254456,
-0.22791552543640137,
-0.48875489830970764,
-0.5291834473609924,
-0.586836040019989,
-0.01623612828552723,
0.2555602192878723,
1.138812780380249,
-0.040033966302871704,
0.4269965589046478,
-0.9399361610412598,
0.2041960060596466,
0.20275266468524933,
0.37587904930114746,
0.07407937198877335,
-0.5338066816329956,
-0.0961088016629219,
-0.08542538434267044,
-0.600528359413147,
-0.7401813864707947,
0.5862930417060852,
0.26898765563964844,
0.6888976097106934,
0.1887861043214798,
-0.13141174614429474,
0.2510332465171814,
-0.4185457229614258,
0.9935479760169983,
0.27771371603012085,
-1.0415072441101074,
0.3863725960254669,
-0.23119162023067474,
0.38946813344955444,
0.5827003717422485,
0.2615576684474945,
-0.4590672254562378,
-0.42737987637519836,
-0.5937099456787109,
-0.9447280764579773,
0.33313778042793274,
0.1953454166650772,
0.24010179936885834,
-0.287494421005249,
0.49124860763549805,
0.4364490211009979,
0.3171948492527008,
-0.4907103180885315,
-0.14379526674747467,
-0.05410770699381828,
-0.5597397685050964,
-0.277098149061203,
-0.40494588017463684,
-0.015569291077554226,
0.16102786362171173,
0.2613750398159027,
-0.0551496259868145,
0.07834716141223907,
0.025779958814382553,
-0.12570609152317047,
0.048211585730314255,
0.3130462169647217,
0.6671079397201538,
0.671577513217926,
-0.16364091634750366,
0.10118579119443893,
0.31017646193504333,
-0.5331255197525024,
0.14540144801139832,
-0.2660713195800781,
-0.3594007194042206,
0.15701152384281158,
0.43978753685951233,
0.5847606658935547,
0.12886416912078857,
-0.9130569696426392,
0.5107768774032593,
-0.012432844378054142,
-0.2705845832824707,
-0.06048212945461273,
0.01894919015467167,
0.09791308641433716,
-0.03182045370340347,
0.4017380475997925,
-0.031891610473394394,
0.2663211226463318,
-0.15698224306106567,
0.4420835077762604,
0.4566541016101837,
-0.14011222124099731,
-0.15512941777706146,
0.3538871109485626,
0.13371625542640686,
-0.3503064215183258,
0.8060845136642456,
-0.2627337872982025,
-0.20556752383708954,
0.7481182813644409,
0.5823380351066589,
0.8339444994926453,
-0.02162349596619606,
0.18185466527938843,
0.6494984030723572,
0.45077937841415405,
-0.4278898239135742,
0.2906440198421478,
0.1504119336605072,
-0.8179038763046265,
-0.3366346061229706,
-0.6362332105636597,
-0.44905921816825867,
-0.007186259608715773,
-0.7807013988494873,
0.3822469711303711,
-0.48377060890197754,
-0.336555153131485,
-0.3995129466056824,
-0.35290583968162537,
-0.617710530757904,
0.09691505879163742,
0.27666524052619934,
0.9946238398551941,
-0.8547360897064209,
0.5243650674819946,
0.2888332009315491,
-0.09226368367671967,
-0.6886479258537292,
-0.15917885303497314,
-0.2010185867547989,
-0.8134320974349976,
0.6520357131958008,
0.27937042713165283,
-0.07993113994598389,
-0.1603306084871292,
-0.4745306372642517,
-0.8386785984039307,
1.211125373840332,
0.5279439091682434,
-0.6723673343658447,
0.22997821867465973,
0.26445290446281433,
0.6834701895713806,
-0.4279172718524933,
0.39736294746398926,
0.7199746370315552,
0.002063216408714652,
0.14252598583698273,
-1.0377752780914307,
-0.10212108492851257,
-0.20574618875980377,
0.3932678699493408,
0.1428598016500473,
-0.3456616997718811,
0.7886918187141418,
-0.3276856541633606,
-0.4482073485851288,
0.3359307050704956,
0.7372211217880249,
0.6555632948875427,
0.2021394968032837,
0.1725948005914688,
0.6754640340805054,
0.9734350442886353,
0.04516371339559555,
1.099785327911377,
0.025578705593943596,
0.34189143776893616,
1.1683170795440674,
-0.3803042471408844,
1.1330939531326294,
0.3935151994228363,
-0.1712673455476761,
0.29722872376441956,
0.539169430732727,
-0.1158173680305481,
0.26729393005371094,
0.4606132209300995,
-0.20553401112556458,
-0.07101593166589737,
-0.11163840442895889,
-0.2608572244644165,
0.27578437328338623,
0.45839235186576843,
-0.5898153185844421,
-0.20689071714878082,
-0.316250205039978,
-0.25479263067245483,
0.37032613158226013,
-0.10604508966207504,
0.7980009913444519,
0.03153524920344353,
-0.691600501537323,
0.8594323396682739,
-0.020898593589663506,
0.9061574339866638,
-0.30943915247917175,
0.057247355580329895,
-0.26802101731300354,
0.13258133828639984,
0.012121510691940784,
-1.1865864992141724,
0.38262826204299927,
-0.007556087337434292,
-0.35378497838974,
-0.10800975561141968,
0.4491865634918213,
-0.3592926859855652,
-0.5474395751953125,
0.2346964329481125,
0.33600348234176636,
0.33495527505874634,
0.24325047433376312,
-0.5150377154350281,
0.24593712389469147,
-0.0647336021065712,
-0.13933825492858887,
0.1375565230846405,
0.6049121022224426,
-0.08084797859191895,
0.6325425505638123,
0.37413153052330017,
0.07432150095701218,
0.33228522539138794,
0.23824605345726013,
0.3482019305229187,
-0.4860055446624756,
-0.04693363979458809,
-0.9215669631958008,
0.3652288317680359,
-0.018473520874977112,
-0.613322377204895,
0.551393985748291,
0.6073621511459351,
0.897890031337738,
-0.17826175689697266,
0.9217084050178528,
0.15776489675045013,
0.37698253989219666,
-0.441300630569458,
0.6585130095481873,
-0.46685972809791565,
0.237901508808136,
-0.4243146479129791,
-1.0056390762329102,
-0.44658446311950684,
0.3758573532104492,
-0.11992412805557251,
0.045771077275276184,
0.5148954391479492,
0.8885554671287537,
-0.048905253410339355,
0.0003912633110303432,
0.46892720460891724,
-0.1710127890110016,
0.3792855739593506,
0.6824973225593567,
1.0642013549804688,
-0.6471325159072876,
0.6893173456192017,
-0.006813456304371357,
-0.30943676829338074,
-0.15450803935527802,
-1.0207338333129883,
-0.7799887657165527,
-0.5150424838066101,
-0.1305263489484787,
-0.21543875336647034,
-0.1248459592461586,
0.7289524078369141,
0.6095275282859802,
-0.5540860295295715,
-0.49597713351249695,
-0.0655703991651535,
-0.009151187725365162,
-0.15096355974674225,
-0.17614036798477173,
0.24265681207180023,
-0.3939951956272125,
-0.758966326713562,
0.036574654281139374,
0.3460082709789276,
0.3894190490245819,
-0.3242330849170685,
-0.23215490579605103,
0.22115054726600647,
-0.05408775433897972,
0.5905914306640625,
0.023849163204431534,
-0.7946255207061768,
0.007844146341085434,
0.15643131732940674,
-0.43158701062202454,
0.05752760171890259,
0.64338219165802,
-0.372254878282547,
0.40659141540527344,
0.6073020696640015,
0.8467341661453247,
0.383539617061615,
-0.1138601005077362,
0.8119859099388123,
-0.6850246787071228,
-0.0036724696401506662,
0.1828465312719345,
0.15545931458473206,
0.6427944302558899,
-0.22034329175949097,
0.3628045916557312,
0.06746243685483932,
-0.5655815601348877,
-0.8563175797462463,
0.3647593855857849,
-0.8223087191581726,
-0.090060755610466,
1.3268771171569824,
-0.27009329199790955,
0.0006917697610333562,
0.1905992180109024,
-0.21621176600456238,
0.23677942156791687,
-0.25522974133491516,
0.7795340418815613,
0.6870697140693665,
0.39349445700645447,
-0.22583703696727753,
-0.4560057818889618,
0.2630295157432556,
0.4388509690761566,
-0.9073276519775391,
0.09011642634868622,
0.5714737772941589,
0.2772710919380188,
0.09641456604003906,
0.5577186942100525,
-0.36908113956451416,
0.2118082046508789,
0.017747795209288597,
0.537527322769165,
0.2996188998222351,
-0.2592787742614746,
-0.4913027882575989,
0.1912921965122223,
0.3200315833091736,
0.1368585228919983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10691v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10691v2 | Python is Not Always the Best Choice: Embracing Multilingual Program of Thoughts | 2024-02-16T13:48:06 | 2024-06-16T12:29:50 | Xianzhen Luo, Qingfu Zhu, Zhiming Zhang, Libo Qin, Xuanyu Zhang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Program of Thoughts (PoT) is an approach characterized by its executable
intermediate steps, which ensure the accuracy of the logical calculations in
the reasoning process. Currently, PoT primarily uses Python. However, relying
solely on a single language may result in suboptimal solutions and overlook the
potential benefits of other programming languages. In this paper, we conduct
comprehensive experiments on the programming languages used in PoT and find
that no single language consistently delivers optimal performance across all
tasks and models. The effectiveness of each language varies depending on the
specific scenarios. Inspired by this, we propose a task and model agnostic
approach called MultiPoT, which harnesses strength and diversity from various
languages. Experimental results reveal that it significantly outperforms Python
Self-Consistency. Furthermore, it achieves comparable or superior performance
compared to the best monolingual PoT in almost all tasks across all models. In
particular, MultiPoT achieves more than 4.6% improvement on average on ChatGPT
(gpt-3.5-turbo-0701). | [
-0.11430846899747849,
-0.7189961671829224,
0.5126948952674866,
0.9342672228813171,
0.04858429729938507,
0.16368012130260468,
-0.6470444202423096,
-0.2005244642496109,
0.011846228502690792,
0.03418916463851929,
-0.35998234152793884,
-0.11367017030715942,
-0.6542595028877258,
0.3796009123325348,
-0.017714373767375946,
0.7098382115364075,
0.010654903016984463,
0.09139258414506912,
-0.0010734011884778738,
-0.21369044482707977,
-0.5474466681480408,
-0.35890650749206543,
-0.4869552254676819,
-0.7471137046813965,
0.45064711570739746,
0.4162570834159851,
0.5193842053413391,
0.18365223705768585,
0.6306392550468445,
0.3742402493953705,
0.5862730145454407,
0.19399626553058624,
-0.16926510632038116,
0.09030213952064514,
-0.1790664941072464,
-0.6577011942863464,
-0.05627213418483734,
0.009940179996192455,
0.21341519057750702,
0.30133432149887085,
-0.2840256094932556,
0.09814896434545517,
0.027232425287365913,
0.545376718044281,
-0.9128000736236572,
0.3696676194667816,
-0.7379584312438965,
0.17920882999897003,
-0.1166502982378006,
-0.43119198083877563,
-0.6762293577194214,
-0.1247255876660347,
-0.10539538413286209,
-0.6767247915267944,
-0.21435095369815826,
-0.18515516817569733,
0.42919743061065674,
0.4636196792125702,
-0.12194439023733139,
-0.2453116923570633,
-0.8679189682006836,
1.0817824602127075,
-0.6480385065078735,
0.35071226954460144,
0.20544345676898956,
0.2565099000930786,
-0.3315713405609131,
-0.34259605407714844,
-0.7708117961883545,
-0.18065302073955536,
0.11396953463554382,
0.2646365463733673,
-0.23822352290153503,
0.05718762427568436,
0.26116806268692017,
0.3280300796031952,
-0.6394389271736145,
-0.2508885860443115,
-0.26366207003593445,
-0.02432583086192608,
0.4503868520259857,
0.04260767623782158,
0.40202710032463074,
-0.22942042350769043,
-0.1878526359796524,
-0.0800095871090889,
-0.4791407883167267,
0.2662176489830017,
0.39648503065109253,
0.48982882499694824,
-0.029862331226468086,
0.7017303705215454,
-0.1921616643667221,
0.8742190003395081,
-0.2571500539779663,
-0.4521470069885254,
0.09484436362981796,
-0.3231102526187897,
-0.36777448654174805,
-0.15233400464057922,
1.102880597114563,
0.06745228916406631,
0.4067695438861847,
-0.29115960001945496,
0.24153363704681396,
0.6726694703102112,
0.25778236985206604,
-0.4964737892150879,
-0.724224328994751,
0.6575607061386108,
-0.1644749492406845,
-0.03493909165263176,
-0.28328657150268555,
-0.23022091388702393,
-0.42076876759529114,
-0.4430728256702423,
0.3010529577732086,
-0.8803814649581909,
-0.5879910588264465,
0.1563507616519928,
-0.12456898391246796,
-0.031210951507091522,
0.26390692591667175,
-0.8761797547340393,
0.23500345647335052,
0.7012430429458618,
0.9964881539344788,
-0.41558557748794556,
-0.8617110252380371,
-0.3347679078578949,
0.06325671821832657,
-0.49348652362823486,
0.9971539378166199,
-0.6284637451171875,
-0.06021548807621002,
-0.5341348648071289,
-0.4280557334423065,
-0.21833330392837524,
-0.269796758890152,
0.1882469803094864,
0.1517392247915268,
0.25446462631225586,
-0.48205894231796265,
-0.43536558747291565,
-0.027667131274938583,
0.417991042137146,
-0.3926699459552765,
1.0368828773498535,
0.004791748709976673,
-0.9844473004341125,
0.8168820142745972,
-1.063051700592041,
-0.5106339454650879,
0.01253829337656498,
-0.37203237414360046,
-0.21932794153690338,
-0.07316846400499344,
0.07918287813663483,
0.21321529150009155,
-0.008173462003469467,
0.26717448234558105,
-0.3104031980037689,
-0.6044905185699463,
0.07621733844280243,
-0.6175158023834229,
1.1145668029785156,
0.4710122346878052,
-0.43026259541511536,
0.45250824093818665,
-0.4784626066684723,
0.33194682002067566,
0.11518753319978714,
-0.3712815046310425,
-0.3410196304321289,
0.043857719749212265,
0.10614654421806335,
0.2522517144680023,
-0.07616885006427765,
-0.7320302724838257,
0.5998215675354004,
-0.3253616392612457,
0.7359887957572937,
0.6066899299621582,
-0.4454154372215271,
0.2931089401245117,
-0.06141860783100128,
0.47778692841529846,
0.04017099738121033,
0.08928527683019638,
-0.21067273616790771,
-0.6095965504646301,
-0.7061198353767395,
-0.41481566429138184,
0.33278605341911316,
0.8569934368133545,
-0.7254825234413147,
0.06909163296222687,
0.003626207821071148,
-0.5143348574638367,
-0.7632467150688171,
0.23328767716884613,
0.14373672008514404,
0.002070675604045391,
0.1956571489572525,
-0.07350039482116699,
-0.5148983001708984,
-0.96158766746521,
-0.5416095852851868,
-0.3159918785095215,
0.2187843769788742,
0.07180650532245636,
0.3478982448577881,
-0.02822038158774376,
0.8076614737510681,
-0.4536479711532593,
-0.044870179146528244,
-0.6378324627876282,
0.26928654313087463,
0.4227716028690338,
0.49939361214637756,
0.4499295651912689,
-0.6737017035484314,
-1.0433765649795532,
0.32464393973350525,
-0.8384995460510254,
0.14953476190567017,
-0.3017657697200775,
-0.18023379147052765,
0.25617876648902893,
-0.21270214021205902,
-0.7550488114356995,
0.3056076765060425,
0.5380169153213501,
-0.012670253403484821,
0.7489081025123596,
-0.5638278126716614,
0.26353493332862854,
-0.8663372993469238,
0.14880912005901337,
-0.056744534522295,
-0.2194485068321228,
-0.6696152091026306,
0.17386256158351898,
0.37391167879104614,
0.01923593133687973,
-0.43291130661964417,
0.28375741839408875,
-0.4762604236602783,
0.17987549304962158,
-0.6160143613815308,
-0.32347923517227173,
-0.10680056363344193,
0.6085464954376221,
0.14506575465202332,
1.1746323108673096,
1.1215118169784546,
-0.5363203883171082,
0.647453248500824,
-0.12022639811038971,
-0.23750722408294678,
0.3963356912136078,
-0.4852672219276428,
0.2650819420814514,
0.038456663489341736,
-0.15746912360191345,
-0.8879128098487854,
-0.039110153913497925,
0.29875648021698,
-0.3721424639225006,
0.22781454026699066,
0.2639947533607483,
-0.5406889915466309,
-0.6077782511711121,
-0.0677497461438179,
0.1481878161430359,
0.026766091585159302,
-0.3073031008243561,
0.4894786477088928,
0.39244088530540466,
-0.04360980913043022,
-1.2347592115402222,
-0.6361286044120789,
0.29767125844955444,
-0.32348886132240295,
-0.3799625635147095,
-0.0969943031668663,
-0.10774827748537064,
-0.41593214869499207,
-0.18107907474040985,
-0.012300261296331882,
-0.01697847619652748,
-0.1558389961719513,
0.11320125311613083,
-0.09197316318750381,
0.15117979049682617,
0.030666658654808998,
-0.23723356425762177,
-0.1856725662946701,
-0.19755002856254578,
-0.48541659116744995,
0.753908097743988,
-0.5186120867729187,
-0.37989798188209534,
-0.28169161081314087,
0.6079022884368896,
0.6971408128738403,
-0.3868918716907501,
0.5698346495628357,
0.40549394488334656,
-0.15181545913219452,
-0.38222822546958923,
-0.5023389458656311,
0.1577891856431961,
-0.4682723879814148,
0.3571705222129822,
-0.7954756021499634,
-0.21982036530971527,
0.3881004750728607,
0.1697692573070526,
0.20845109224319458,
-0.1605609953403473,
0.8073718547821045,
-0.03303689882159233,
0.7507963180541992,
0.9336732029914856,
-0.2456284463405609,
0.35901033878326416,
-0.21022894978523254,
0.47704946994781494,
-0.5572373270988464,
0.044377170503139496,
-0.24916769564151764,
-0.12260860204696655,
-0.49504998326301575,
-0.4371586740016937,
0.44814425706863403,
-0.32910141348838806,
-0.04438402131199837,
0.8303634524345398,
-0.8021312952041626,
0.670381486415863,
0.9622547030448914,
0.029003001749515533,
0.3842471241950989,
-0.1192704513669014,
-0.19790853559970856,
-0.06195341423153877,
-1.0620774030685425,
-0.4323503375053406,
1.3920378684997559,
-0.12869560718536377,
0.7261999249458313,
-0.10312943905591965,
0.5997753143310547,
0.21458666026592255,
0.33980488777160645,
-0.7230840921401978,
0.308346688747406,
0.0731959417462349,
-0.6698245406150818,
-0.7123036980628967,
-0.34545019268989563,
-1.0542296171188354,
0.8003471493721008,
-0.03182892128825188,
-0.7689923048019409,
-0.3246001899242401,
0.13146217167377472,
-0.3657647371292114,
0.4155929684638977,
-0.9766104221343994,
1.1759387254714966,
-0.3778931796550751,
-0.5347568988800049,
-0.334195613861084,
-0.4334524869918823,
0.35983920097351074,
-0.000173232561792247,
0.06860862672328949,
-0.10649089515209198,
0.38926494121551514,
0.12492343783378601,
-0.13421228528022766,
0.3013542890548706,
0.0249006524682045,
-0.011397561989724636,
0.4008682668209076,
0.007186333183199167,
0.24847303330898285,
0.013340501114726067,
-0.19287216663360596,
0.23189720511436462,
0.1349269300699234,
-0.6043179631233215,
-0.5736719369888306,
0.7642660737037659,
-0.810114860534668,
-0.7077637314796448,
-0.6353636384010315,
-1.0408638715744019,
-0.15888862311840057,
0.47684067487716675,
0.37882059812545776,
0.016173139214515686,
-0.13108861446380615,
-0.13393160700798035,
0.24337297677993774,
-0.38479670882225037,
0.5152125954627991,
0.2883182764053345,
-0.2274719923734665,
-0.08615977317094803,
0.8654555082321167,
0.1426485925912857,
0.2986854016780853,
0.3688560426235199,
0.2967015504837036,
-0.2743246257305145,
-0.27750635147094727,
-0.780276894569397,
0.03607344254851341,
-0.6398743391036987,
0.02453618496656418,
-0.886643648147583,
0.2541567087173462,
-0.6179808378219604,
0.02016511745750904,
-0.7401119470596313,
-0.28122130036354065,
0.462379515171051,
0.12918531894683838,
0.06965223699808121,
0.3802100718021393,
-0.057499006390571594,
-0.08037403225898743,
-0.21283094584941864,
0.5016084909439087,
0.20170362293720245,
0.3471492528915405,
-0.20516414940357208,
0.22111298143863678,
0.0009771735640242696,
0.15946078300476074,
-0.6278485655784607,
-0.9894749522209167,
0.26613807678222656,
0.1939650923013687,
0.6515055298805237,
0.287527471780777,
0.1658453643321991,
0.846767783164978,
-0.5718332529067993,
0.5760393738746643,
0.4037667512893677,
-0.9167513847351074,
0.7183752059936523,
-0.3356391191482544,
0.6156222224235535,
0.5407772064208984,
0.13296593725681305,
-0.6773097515106201,
-0.8190304636955261,
-0.3596637547016144,
-0.520473301410675,
0.6067953705787659,
0.5812329053878784,
-0.09288928657770157,
0.12094883620738983,
-0.18067024648189545,
0.5460272431373596,
0.5171715021133423,
-1.1273486614227295,
-0.380129873752594,
-0.5070845484733582,
0.08432044833898544,
-0.11900585889816284,
0.4859315752983093,
-0.026781827211380005,
-0.3912421762943268,
0.5192910432815552,
-0.17165926098823547,
0.3837163746356964,
0.0005314071313478053,
0.004403159487992525,
-0.24807730317115784,
0.48682910203933716,
0.3351277709007263,
1.0730984210968018,
0.09618061780929565,
0.2765917181968689,
0.08448958396911621,
-0.3962116539478302,
0.23459990322589874,
-0.35439690947532654,
-0.27298200130462646,
-0.037899199873209,
0.1325262039899826,
0.6012440919876099,
-0.2238105833530426,
-0.6656057834625244,
0.34739816188812256,
-0.043136999011039734,
0.14914974570274353,
-0.4057316184043884,
0.4103916883468628,
0.2474752962589264,
0.13642068207263947,
0.09378006309270859,
0.42260196805000305,
0.30276817083358765,
-0.844094455242157,
-0.036873240023851395,
0.6605806946754456,
0.07977426052093506,
-0.12446329742670059,
0.6914435029029846,
-0.02843603491783142,
-0.3344985246658325,
0.7501652836799622,
-0.3483726978302002,
-0.6451299786567688,
0.5567778944969177,
0.7265504002571106,
0.6920382380485535,
-0.2229599505662918,
0.28800299763679504,
0.3154725432395935,
0.5225169658660889,
-0.0913248211145401,
0.6766129732131958,
-0.17576995491981506,
-0.7048923969268799,
-0.8221855759620667,
-0.35133907198905945,
-0.5212191939353943,
0.11925778537988663,
-0.05181412026286125,
0.31836190819740295,
-0.13388262689113617,
-0.22408606112003326,
-0.11053545027971268,
0.09279749542474747,
-0.5827153325080872,
0.042286328971385956,
0.11102600395679474,
0.659106433391571,
-0.849242627620697,
1.353657603263855,
0.8547031879425049,
-0.19686460494995117,
-0.9607582092285156,
-0.3398056626319885,
-0.23043113946914673,
-0.43555518984794617,
0.3493984639644623,
0.2585965096950531,
-0.15870963037014008,
-0.2588435411453247,
-0.2753501534461975,
-0.6404768824577332,
0.6134187579154968,
0.6421754360198975,
-0.16056931018829346,
0.2647330164909363,
0.4255482256412506,
0.3984404504299164,
-0.09702111780643463,
0.46288079023361206,
0.4776611626148224,
0.741642415523529,
-0.10542798042297363,
-1.2949368953704834,
-0.3345973491668701,
-0.6162839531898499,
-0.24704018235206604,
0.26421433687210083,
-0.8599916100502014,
1.0961642265319824,
-0.51430743932724,
-0.22320528328418732,
-0.1922907680273056,
0.5971500873565674,
0.4820784628391266,
0.2854735553264618,
0.3465579152107239,
0.43107008934020996,
0.8740390539169312,
-0.25807976722717285,
1.125282645225525,
-0.5860905647277832,
0.3376008868217468,
1.0232664346694946,
-0.17095519602298737,
0.6629632711410522,
0.6860952973365784,
-0.6597638726234436,
0.2150280773639679,
0.563525378704071,
-0.024937989190220833,
0.5163494348526001,
0.24503912031650543,
-0.01598801091313362,
-0.41939371824264526,
0.3859107494354248,
-0.3806707561016083,
0.6498429775238037,
0.12572446465492249,
0.15125074982643127,
0.010884524323046207,
0.27678120136260986,
-0.10147014260292053,
0.06671471893787384,
0.020981887355446815,
0.28953561186790466,
0.01670299470424652,
-1.199118971824646,
0.5739471316337585,
-0.06838728487491608,
0.8447079658508301,
-0.665478527545929,
-0.0923282653093338,
-0.027030404657125473,
0.5601533055305481,
-0.11024032533168793,
-0.6699755787849426,
0.3011486828327179,
-0.0670824944972992,
-0.06622565537691116,
-0.2374570667743683,
0.6997753381729126,
-0.4513009786605835,
-0.7765748500823975,
0.11422047764062881,
0.5565568208694458,
0.342043936252594,
-0.4184240698814392,
-0.833602249622345,
-0.04382249712944031,
-0.09811795502901077,
-0.16175305843353271,
0.1221323311328888,
0.5904307961463928,
0.1874491572380066,
1.2449871301651,
0.5837752819061279,
0.63411545753479,
0.1308446079492569,
-0.22219699621200562,
0.536704957485199,
-0.30877164006233215,
-0.8575392365455627,
-1.0204988718032837,
0.3733709454536438,
-0.05802646279335022,
-0.3633759021759033,
1.2019286155700684,
0.7217520475387573,
0.9384070634841919,
-0.23623499274253845,
1.1954649686813354,
-0.3077055513858795,
0.18739955127239227,
-0.09794889390468597,
0.6439582705497742,
-0.5590628385543823,
0.0323822908103466,
-0.7146113514900208,
-1.1270807981491089,
-0.2425534427165985,
1.0987279415130615,
-0.3104678988456726,
-0.24991296231746674,
0.9394665956497192,
0.4069666266441345,
-0.18027614057064056,
0.10857697576284409,
0.43698424100875854,
-0.24370625615119934,
0.34185078740119934,
0.9198862314224243,
0.7986229062080383,
-0.21617910265922546,
0.4261854290962219,
-0.5243910551071167,
-0.37511393427848816,
0.2435745745897293,
-0.800470232963562,
-0.8546448349952698,
-0.40676259994506836,
-0.255400151014328,
-0.02964814379811287,
-0.0006322039989754558,
1.0175702571868896,
0.7948644757270813,
-0.9320414066314697,
-0.7033670544624329,
-0.23733532428741455,
0.015615545213222504,
-0.8739866018295288,
-0.13868564367294312,
0.2052069902420044,
-0.6860305666923523,
-1.0765910148620605,
0.303550660610199,
0.6269689202308655,
-0.5416876673698425,
-0.5388765931129456,
-0.17326824367046356,
-0.24026983976364136,
-0.08912830799818039,
0.6143704056739807,
0.29262015223503113,
-0.9121565222740173,
-0.08875735849142075,
0.36690470576286316,
-0.0863252580165863,
0.4207768142223358,
1.063492774963379,
-0.5447391867637634,
0.8126959204673767,
0.4296777546405792,
0.26696673035621643,
0.23906953632831573,
-0.06941492110490799,
0.7862911820411682,
-0.1944226771593094,
0.47610384225845337,
0.19709089398384094,
0.58939528465271,
0.3270244896411896,
-0.4294750988483429,
0.570940375328064,
0.06269948184490204,
-0.563136875629425,
-0.7492361068725586,
0.29545798897743225,
-0.8493693470954895,
-0.7087780833244324,
1.1714386940002441,
-0.3417566120624542,
-0.08006281405687332,
-0.38456907868385315,
-0.41561707854270935,
0.3418571650981903,
-0.28544557094573975,
1.0989234447479248,
1.1063238382339478,
-0.6436217427253723,
-0.12783445417881012,
-0.49391472339630127,
0.2458188235759735,
0.5822437405586243,
-0.5590924620628357,
0.3669573664665222,
0.23026804625988007,
0.28955549001693726,
0.456428200006485,
0.926226019859314,
0.14699986577033997,
0.09689876437187195,
0.3678925633430481,
0.13852941989898682,
-0.14284589886665344,
-0.7102746367454529,
0.3069886863231659,
0.3604017198085785,
0.05872264504432678,
-0.13131186366081238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10689v2 | Multi-Cultural Commonsense Knowledge Distillation | 2024-02-16T13:46:38 | 2024-04-17T14:12:07 | Tuan-Phong Nguyen, Simon Razniewski, Gerhard Weikum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent progress, large language models (LLMs) still face the
challenge of appropriately reacting to the intricacies of social and cultural
conventions. This paper presents MANGO, a methodology for distilling
high-accuracy, high-recall assertions of cultural knowledge. We judiciously and
iteratively prompt LLMs for this purpose from two entry points, concepts and
cultures. Outputs are consolidated via clustering and generative summarization.
Running the MANGO method with GPT-3.5 as underlying LLM yields 167K
high-accuracy assertions for 30K concepts and 11K cultures, surpassing prior
resources by a large margin. For extrinsic evaluation, we explore augmenting
dialogue systems with cultural knowledge assertions. We find that adding
knowledge from MANGO improves the overall quality, specificity, and cultural
sensitivity of dialogue responses, as judged by human annotators. Data and code
are available for download. | [
-0.38019657135009766,
-0.8250533938407898,
0.3757926821708679,
0.13380694389343262,
-0.23664726316928864,
0.47932514548301697,
-0.44830507040023804,
-0.12803377211093903,
0.339657187461853,
0.5102879405021667,
-0.20976440608501434,
-0.33828091621398926,
-0.6873080730438232,
0.10920675843954086,
-0.19826431572437286,
0.7688453197479248,
0.04936744645237923,
-0.41420790553092957,
-0.07766590267419815,
-0.46351158618927,
-0.6696555018424988,
-0.5655028820037842,
-0.41676828265190125,
-0.3451833426952362,
0.21964243054389954,
0.7181332111358643,
0.5591024160385132,
0.24498014152050018,
0.12039220333099365,
0.35751932859420776,
-0.28190356492996216,
0.5897518992424011,
-0.5276590585708618,
0.27552515268325806,
-0.24220769107341766,
-0.533420741558075,
-0.16305001080036163,
0.1427449882030487,
0.07745034992694855,
0.3979324698448181,
-0.4315722584724426,
0.39570748805999756,
0.22081811726093292,
0.5430706143379211,
-0.558103621006012,
0.3304663896560669,
-0.8667553663253784,
0.04086431488394737,
-0.1604120135307312,
-0.01162355300039053,
-0.37345242500305176,
-0.5950445532798767,
0.01235945150256157,
-0.5510100722312927,
-0.15891802310943604,
-0.06440814584493637,
0.6366885304450989,
0.3579006791114807,
-0.6750269532203674,
-0.12904730439186096,
-0.7444628477096558,
1.0086206197738647,
-0.5579356551170349,
0.11189146339893341,
0.6031039357185364,
0.6514148712158203,
-0.028300868347287178,
-0.6450293660163879,
-0.7697257995605469,
0.0556468591094017,
0.08009741455316544,
0.21610480546951294,
-0.08642154186964035,
-0.2321578562259674,
0.2632971405982971,
0.3133562505245209,
-0.007882386445999146,
0.029338529333472252,
-0.5398767590522766,
-0.16142094135284424,
0.6613667011260986,
0.1079714223742485,
0.1817009299993515,
-0.2972169518470764,
-0.23424960672855377,
0.2044457346200943,
-0.8011021614074707,
-0.15200300514698029,
-0.09331702440977097,
-0.0745120644569397,
-0.12074102461338043,
0.6000314950942993,
-0.4736601412296295,
0.47604426741600037,
0.03982048109173775,
-0.7096796035766602,
0.17677007615566254,
-0.4564270079135895,
-0.1119745597243309,
-0.08931922912597656,
0.7413489818572998,
0.6945115327835083,
0.44335803389549255,
0.36518192291259766,
0.1999366730451584,
-0.12939998507499695,
-0.16498327255249023,
-0.614998996257782,
-0.290708065032959,
0.3240055441856384,
-0.314532071352005,
-0.2284967005252838,
-0.30765414237976074,
-0.69756019115448,
-0.8622299432754517,
-0.321296751499176,
0.06847171485424042,
-0.48719048500061035,
-0.4749181568622589,
-0.32037317752838135,
-0.5394962430000305,
0.22644773125648499,
0.3405623435974121,
-0.7707133293151855,
0.005429258104413748,
0.5859776139259338,
0.7977348566055298,
-0.04339748993515968,
-0.1607566773891449,
-0.3425479531288147,
0.3130865693092346,
-0.5290490984916687,
0.46983668208122253,
-0.5461024045944214,
-0.5024954080581665,
-0.2673570215702057,
-0.20401595532894135,
0.19511906802654266,
-0.851616621017456,
0.676745593547821,
-0.10329705476760864,
-0.05538148805499077,
-0.5942607522010803,
-0.24017789959907532,
-0.2998097240924835,
0.3931536376476288,
-0.412860244512558,
0.9257415533065796,
0.08964835107326508,
-0.5077139735221863,
0.42660531401634216,
-0.582733690738678,
-0.5898485779762268,
0.22953252494335175,
-0.2934426963329315,
0.0758606493473053,
0.3863355815410614,
0.5096530914306641,
0.5174386501312256,
-0.5570387244224548,
0.642156183719635,
-0.23717144131660461,
-0.26878440380096436,
0.43297237157821655,
-0.7574328184127808,
0.925333559513092,
0.8627066016197205,
-0.09790615737438202,
-0.2110716998577118,
-0.5869825482368469,
-0.3128345310688019,
0.21881137788295746,
-0.23928767442703247,
-0.6144726872444153,
-0.08157588541507721,
-0.6866280436515808,
0.15689194202423096,
0.10379195213317871,
-0.5686751008033752,
0.08146275579929352,
0.06397301703691483,
0.7800140380859375,
0.6672695875167847,
-0.07045202702283859,
0.10673479735851288,
-0.43013668060302734,
0.26345449686050415,
0.2820555865764618,
0.14714981615543365,
-0.39155226945877075,
-0.7190541625022888,
-0.543030321598053,
-0.3783476650714874,
-0.10625330358743668,
0.5209161043167114,
-1.1601874828338623,
0.2899826467037201,
-0.3547215163707733,
-0.6672758460044861,
-0.4270617961883545,
0.2893354892730713,
0.0754188671708107,
0.6846715807914734,
0.136090949177742,
-0.3929213583469391,
-0.41926679015159607,
-0.7280430793762207,
-0.27824705839157104,
-0.21397967636585236,
0.08523780107498169,
0.27757641673088074,
0.19452746212482452,
0.1631837785243988,
1.073603630065918,
-0.6926451325416565,
-0.05422994866967201,
-0.35849666595458984,
0.3191603124141693,
0.2860322892665863,
0.21353548765182495,
0.326114296913147,
-0.6923426985740662,
-0.7468799352645874,
0.15158715844154358,
-0.8538684844970703,
-0.05858009681105614,
0.4499424993991852,
0.09009634703397751,
0.28242817521095276,
0.3095766305923462,
-0.43055465817451477,
0.1484629511833191,
0.3826557397842407,
0.05196090787649155,
0.5522773861885071,
-0.0643094927072525,
0.5918998122215271,
-1.430593490600586,
-0.19324424862861633,
0.06500108540058136,
-0.04306286573410034,
-0.47651782631874084,
0.0020783180370926857,
0.09916055202484131,
-0.24327394366264343,
-0.4455202519893646,
0.5379734039306641,
-0.2380296289920807,
0.36438438296318054,
-0.028604133054614067,
0.13660293817520142,
0.1612740308046341,
0.4266687035560608,
0.2614205777645111,
0.6453526020050049,
0.23275895416736603,
-0.5422221422195435,
0.774081826210022,
0.19419443607330322,
-0.7697544693946838,
1.240290641784668,
-0.3333163857460022,
0.08088736981153488,
-0.30641642212867737,
0.43141117691993713,
-1.1203770637512207,
-0.3496972620487213,
-0.12335626780986786,
-0.2932892441749573,
-0.13491031527519226,
-0.47438353300094604,
-0.3971141576766968,
-0.6345365643501282,
-0.2038165181875229,
0.3163498044013977,
0.8807492852210999,
-0.6581483483314514,
0.6204482316970825,
0.5188644528388977,
-0.6793488264083862,
-0.9463950991630554,
-0.8635218739509583,
0.32644370198249817,
-0.7949442863464355,
-0.546105682849884,
-0.4058392345905304,
0.01066930964589119,
-0.5433698296546936,
-0.4034979045391083,
0.020867735147476196,
-0.2445925623178482,
0.38484421372413635,
0.06280601769685745,
0.16312259435653687,
-0.04963778331875801,
0.14881259202957153,
0.11347729712724686,
0.14979878067970276,
0.007775490637868643,
-0.4773036241531372,
0.446271151304245,
0.10399109870195389,
-0.4074443578720093,
-0.23781442642211914,
0.15295031666755676,
0.7012137174606323,
-0.46095678210258484,
0.6254982352256775,
0.537967324256897,
-0.23408915102481842,
0.16967938840389252,
-1.0345498323440552,
0.025685744360089302,
-0.4628746509552002,
0.38319823145866394,
-0.5877704620361328,
-0.7026273608207703,
0.5814109444618225,
-0.3517182171344757,
0.11357124149799347,
0.38018104434013367,
0.48063862323760986,
-0.07618338614702225,
0.7017835974693298,
0.1353219747543335,
-0.11423690617084503,
0.20140710473060608,
-0.1645534485578537,
0.38591524958610535,
-0.715003490447998,
-0.18496374785900116,
-0.5927633047103882,
-0.3215756118297577,
-0.3179422914981842,
-0.7959096431732178,
0.49480974674224854,
-0.02630467154085636,
-0.2935848534107208,
0.00482939463108778,
-0.17191454768180847,
0.9452290534973145,
0.4641095995903015,
-0.21762558817863464,
0.8530596494674683,
0.060946185141801834,
-0.2408735603094101,
-0.023216405883431435,
-0.6849981546401978,
-0.32661154866218567,
1.1825674772262573,
0.37132635712623596,
0.8880842924118042,
0.5056083798408508,
0.7313407063484192,
0.09238442778587341,
0.6372692584991455,
-0.5576834678649902,
0.33265912532806396,
-0.2907393276691437,
-0.6354501843452454,
-0.30710479617118835,
-0.5099040865898132,
-0.4501151442527771,
0.3155810832977295,
-0.008313821628689766,
-0.8703011274337769,
0.04066527262330055,
0.18454501032829285,
-0.4828922152519226,
0.2490910291671753,
-1.0112407207489014,
0.6127650737762451,
-0.11594060063362122,
-0.3372228443622589,
-0.29436033964157104,
-0.5369295477867126,
0.9921923875808716,
-0.28161686658859253,
0.69571852684021,
-0.4527522623538971,
0.27680838108062744,
0.6301738023757935,
-0.5113792419433594,
0.9929962158203125,
-0.29742515087127686,
-0.36915645003318787,
0.6025916934013367,
0.15401722490787506,
0.4640956521034241,
0.03263970464468002,
-0.11385165899991989,
-0.006988564971834421,
0.1459706723690033,
-0.34319961071014404,
-0.6105380654335022,
0.7075970768928528,
-0.7185516357421875,
-0.7432884573936462,
-0.07380882650613785,
-0.5864124894142151,
-0.24838916957378387,
-0.03635456785559654,
0.08321286737918854,
0.3250598907470703,
-0.3357957899570465,
0.17144763469696045,
0.7521123290061951,
-0.5163660645484924,
0.28336867690086365,
0.40920743346214294,
-0.3358957767486572,
-0.34951746463775635,
1.0000284910202026,
0.24275441467761993,
0.4892275631427765,
0.09639618545770645,
0.4807424247264862,
-0.6256799697875977,
-0.36551159620285034,
-0.5105363130569458,
-0.0869065597653389,
-0.9128071665763855,
-0.20783641934394836,
-0.5479329824447632,
0.017745228484272957,
-0.5100549459457397,
-0.013644465245306492,
-0.29879897832870483,
-0.7113285660743713,
0.33238378167152405,
-0.2540621757507324,
0.6036760210990906,
0.7594157457351685,
-0.19348593056201935,
0.1589687317609787,
-0.9971216917037964,
0.37980568408966064,
0.4644218683242798,
0.20845599472522736,
0.059627097100019455,
-0.517524778842926,
-0.11722981929779053,
0.3020825982093811,
-0.3284069299697876,
-0.7914279103279114,
0.3705630302429199,
0.19238941371440887,
0.6312345266342163,
0.4197675883769989,
0.2981705963611603,
0.7804983258247375,
-0.12290391325950623,
0.9959093332290649,
0.36133792996406555,
-0.8489882349967957,
0.61830735206604,
-0.13955499231815338,
0.3881371021270752,
0.6110260486602783,
0.45680102705955505,
-0.9183087348937988,
-0.6124629974365234,
-0.3478264808654785,
-0.6671575903892517,
0.3144538104534149,
-0.29721370339393616,
0.3692801892757416,
-0.29442062973976135,
-0.04656276851892471,
0.32790496945381165,
0.13518881797790527,
-0.4529479444026947,
-0.08829932659864426,
-0.19944165647029877,
-0.326330304145813,
-0.24832475185394287,
-0.22502756118774414,
-0.48359906673431396,
-0.4275394082069397,
0.4936283528804779,
-0.24353323876857758,
-0.45789244771003723,
-0.0463995561003685,
-0.45644837617874146,
0.3016945421695709,
0.5714147686958313,
0.35101667046546936,
0.7771508097648621,
0.13383863866329193,
0.3684181571006775,
0.4544837474822998,
-0.3308052122592926,
0.5303612947463989,
-0.05752082169055939,
0.09562923014163971,
-0.3341066837310791,
-0.10705672204494476,
0.4420924782752991,
-0.09927044808864594,
-0.537530243396759,
0.3148317337036133,
-0.2444731891155243,
0.05316746607422829,
-0.12942111492156982,
-0.012070700526237488,
0.39299505949020386,
0.07682748883962631,
0.348773717880249,
-0.14427988231182098,
-0.0789240300655365,
-0.7834078669548035,
0.05402851477265358,
0.2279042750597,
-0.16621604561805725,
0.2064257264137268,
0.4826282262802124,
0.6937314867973328,
0.1282019466161728,
0.8104497790336609,
-0.25853192806243896,
-0.3617352545261383,
0.520028293132782,
0.3271227180957794,
0.5021058917045593,
-0.42776384949684143,
0.413692831993103,
0.42767706513404846,
0.1442147046327591,
-0.09552863985300064,
0.10629386454820633,
-0.22717168927192688,
-0.8860601186752319,
-0.7938498258590698,
-0.6794277429580688,
-0.3469909131526947,
-0.15627223253250122,
-0.3490449786186218,
0.0875604972243309,
-0.2133612334728241,
0.040368687361478806,
-0.20019076764583588,
0.01991543360054493,
-0.5831302404403687,
-0.04250488430261612,
0.02265487052500248,
0.9929726123809814,
-1.0666671991348267,
1.0599639415740967,
0.2373778373003006,
-0.3917074501514435,
-0.8324989676475525,
-0.23056945204734802,
0.4339221119880676,
-1.001625895500183,
0.5663788914680481,
-0.10095338523387909,
0.14069844782352448,
-0.10969361662864685,
-0.37374192476272583,
-0.7204964756965637,
1.1430500745773315,
0.2384413331747055,
-0.4668175280094147,
0.5012661814689636,
0.19589567184448242,
0.32211044430732727,
-0.1524536907672882,
0.40738922357559204,
1.0528340339660645,
0.4851215183734894,
0.5361390113830566,
-1.202377200126648,
0.014305694960057735,
-0.18287093937397003,
-0.09284400939941406,
0.0783037319779396,
-0.6894123554229736,
0.5775209069252014,
-0.38098692893981934,
-0.12900114059448242,
0.014972756616771221,
0.6417673230171204,
0.49834951758384705,
0.230988010764122,
0.2323049008846283,
0.5184329748153687,
1.322166919708252,
-0.28583255410194397,
0.8992864489555359,
-0.0847286656498909,
-0.020494144409894943,
1.3204231262207031,
-0.4928310513496399,
0.6486976742744446,
0.4062512516975403,
-0.23495197296142578,
0.42002761363983154,
0.5760765671730042,
0.24668152630329132,
0.1529267281293869,
0.3089011609554291,
-0.35338684916496277,
0.1930496245622635,
-0.536245584487915,
-0.3187001049518585,
0.6372549533843994,
0.6458654403686523,
-0.10827304422855377,
-0.018290990963578224,
0.04590842127799988,
0.29018840193748474,
0.23435623943805695,
-0.33344680070877075,
0.9982154965400696,
0.15042291581630707,
-1.2016819715499878,
0.7537218332290649,
-0.16743658483028412,
0.8215959072113037,
-0.42272865772247314,
-0.023214496672153473,
-0.6592075824737549,
-0.12675562500953674,
-0.15575729310512543,
-0.9288854598999023,
0.41321805119514465,
0.0630863830447197,
0.23530513048171997,
-0.0847591832280159,
0.6223273873329163,
-0.6464035511016846,
-0.24119926989078522,
-0.2287786602973938,
0.7040389776229858,
0.3026694059371948,
-0.11171836405992508,
-0.23929250240325928,
0.05994868278503418,
0.020556291565299034,
0.23976364731788635,
0.03816567733883858,
0.6120493412017822,
-0.28406623005867004,
0.6132398843765259,
0.31070834398269653,
-0.07215002924203873,
0.056079279631376266,
0.0730363205075264,
0.3629283905029297,
-0.5626137256622314,
-0.3524203896522522,
-0.9689992070198059,
0.5035429000854492,
-0.4888351559638977,
-0.018205543980002403,
0.6757801175117493,
0.4632980525493622,
0.7139087319374084,
0.10079043358564377,
1.2123029232025146,
-0.18229560554027557,
0.37910380959510803,
-0.4658709466457367,
0.7114951014518738,
-0.28739163279533386,
0.37648501992225647,
-0.08444271981716156,
-0.9295625686645508,
0.1710745096206665,
0.2595421373844147,
-0.2835089862346649,
-0.047353945672512054,
0.6524264216423035,
0.5975404977798462,
-0.04343748465180397,
0.36252647638320923,
0.3336585760116577,
0.47744885087013245,
0.45488983392715454,
0.5933825373649597,
1.2779698371887207,
0.21274638175964355,
0.5119249820709229,
-0.33338040113449097,
-0.49049660563468933,
-0.017712634056806564,
-0.9946067333221436,
-0.5233270525932312,
-0.6619201898574829,
-0.3133205771446228,
-0.28996968269348145,
-0.17324770987033844,
0.9009953737258911,
0.6499757766723633,
-0.5952473878860474,
-0.3903498351573944,
0.49221885204315186,
0.49899694323539734,
-0.32702383399009705,
-0.19768764078617096,
0.03599613904953003,
-0.19205603003501892,
-0.7337587475776672,
0.24823394417762756,
0.31259024143218994,
0.05738874524831772,
-0.12751492857933044,
-0.11596385389566422,
0.11782462894916534,
0.22326239943504333,
0.8671301603317261,
0.21099188923835754,
-0.7923553586006165,
-0.2837238013744354,
-0.3883698880672455,
0.21173110604286194,
0.04107825458049774,
0.7579904198646545,
-0.6461960077285767,
0.5018648505210876,
0.3911108374595642,
0.3822290003299713,
0.5162319540977478,
0.016515592113137245,
0.8758060336112976,
-0.971261203289032,
0.17651312053203583,
-0.08812157809734344,
0.5682181119918823,
0.4038397967815399,
-0.04892842471599579,
0.5460089445114136,
0.16369205713272095,
-0.2711714506149292,
-0.5453140139579773,
0.46963584423065186,
-0.5893793106079102,
-0.4395216703414917,
1.0084435939788818,
-0.3857743442058563,
-0.11995622515678406,
-0.5507387518882751,
-0.4041057229042053,
0.04040427505970001,
-0.25992488861083984,
0.8143224716186523,
0.963226318359375,
0.12929396331310272,
-0.18123359978199005,
-0.2941972613334656,
0.43745386600494385,
0.2650308310985565,
-0.8444167971611023,
0.36816343665122986,
0.5299609899520874,
0.49076610803604126,
0.2948848307132721,
0.8332750201225281,
-0.22031623125076294,
0.08918223530054092,
-0.13894067704677582,
-0.20331072807312012,
-0.03042486496269703,
-0.14630134403705597,
-0.06825094670057297,
0.18685169517993927,
0.5271242260932922,
0.11480257660150528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10688v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10688v2 | Towards Uncovering How Large Language Model Works: An Explainability Perspective | 2024-02-16T13:46:06 | 2024-04-15T18:43:12 | Haiyan Zhao, Fan Yang, Bo Shen, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Mengnan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have led to breakthroughs in language tasks, yet
the internal mechanisms that enable their remarkable generalization and
reasoning abilities remain opaque. This lack of transparency presents
challenges such as hallucinations, toxicity, and misalignment with human
values, hindering the safe and beneficial deployment of LLMs. This paper aims
to uncover the mechanisms underlying LLM functionality through the lens of
explainability. First, we review how knowledge is architecturally composed
within LLMs and encoded in their internal parameters via mechanistic
interpretability techniques. Then, we summarize how knowledge is embedded in
LLM representations by leveraging probing techniques and representation
engineering. Additionally, we investigate the training dynamics through a
mechanistic perspective to explain phenomena such as grokking and memorization.
Lastly, we explore how the insights gained from these explanations can enhance
LLM performance through model editing, improve efficiency through pruning, and
better align with human values. | [
-0.2101866602897644,
-0.7080442309379578,
1.030820608139038,
-0.10218911617994308,
-0.11397358030080795,
0.08115369081497192,
-0.3748583197593689,
-0.44272032380104065,
-0.17988941073417664,
0.41831308603286743,
-0.5656412839889526,
-0.29101184010505676,
-0.669538676738739,
-0.20199522376060486,
-0.3629263937473297,
0.8541920781135559,
-0.1453692466020584,
0.02770831435918808,
-0.18866278231143951,
-0.14235538244247437,
-0.26361212134361267,
-0.6629538536071777,
-0.546054482460022,
-0.7198649048805237,
0.41357550024986267,
0.2727029025554657,
0.7866746187210083,
0.9646112322807312,
0.11019407957792282,
0.3137477934360504,
-0.45813027024269104,
-0.08046766370534897,
-0.6191636919975281,
0.019103413447737694,
-0.29589661955833435,
-0.9036124348640442,
-0.21058134734630585,
-0.08878552913665771,
0.7908328771591187,
0.8994568586349487,
-0.21697470545768738,
-0.1335163563489914,
0.2728039026260376,
0.636681079864502,
-0.31739404797554016,
0.33337828516960144,
-0.6828444600105286,
-0.16141420602798462,
-0.13554908335208893,
-0.22548280656337738,
-0.2998354136943817,
-0.07726926356554031,
0.17183524370193481,
-0.47624170780181885,
0.13991254568099976,
0.03681321442127228,
0.5843087434768677,
0.16333651542663574,
-0.2754703760147095,
-0.6614898443222046,
-0.7836683392524719,
0.7713996171951294,
-0.8004756569862366,
0.4576365351676941,
0.20275066792964935,
0.46990469098091125,
-0.18542422354221344,
-0.4442290961742401,
-0.5180713534355164,
-0.38118061423301697,
-0.19295158982276917,
-0.2841842770576477,
0.0032907852437347174,
0.2957754135131836,
0.19255928695201874,
0.5697538256645203,
-0.5638316869735718,
0.311062753200531,
-0.1844988763332367,
-0.18126533925533295,
0.3494037389755249,
0.15851987898349762,
0.5351672172546387,
-0.020512724295258522,
-0.08597145974636078,
0.053318049758672714,
-0.8503508567810059,
0.08513234555721283,
0.5260745882987976,
0.006153253372758627,
0.02110624685883522,
0.5239565372467041,
-0.007926490157842636,
0.4970639646053314,
-0.21181620657444,
-0.22538359463214874,
-0.07289352267980576,
-0.04671158269047737,
-0.2678232491016388,
-0.07477663457393646,
0.49893704056739807,
0.0852290540933609,
0.37445566058158875,
-0.32698482275009155,
-0.20891690254211426,
-0.21600204706192017,
0.29116663336753845,
-0.6996116042137146,
0.03436939790844917,
0.31968656182289124,
-0.6933615207672119,
-0.2698090374469757,
-0.17007118463516235,
-0.3739151060581207,
-0.5352900624275208,
-0.49893322587013245,
0.3904576599597931,
-0.6100391149520874,
-0.4650164246559143,
0.26052358746528625,
-0.08907144516706467,
0.3238673508167267,
0.3905778229236603,
-1.263649582862854,
0.19458618760108948,
0.9742767214775085,
0.6694708466529846,
0.0919911339879036,
-0.3807816803455353,
-0.0085254842415452,
0.324527382850647,
-0.2654002010822296,
0.34952327609062195,
-0.5023372769355774,
-0.12164179235696793,
-0.045007698237895966,
0.13338841497898102,
-0.1207788810133934,
-0.6973509788513184,
0.17949187755584717,
-0.5205647349357605,
-0.07554958015680313,
-0.22777245938777924,
-0.7388126850128174,
-0.5414959788322449,
0.258348673582077,
-0.5982699394226074,
0.48147934675216675,
-0.08696896582841873,
-0.626501739025116,
0.07850182801485062,
-0.6385731101036072,
-0.11228432506322861,
-0.0035064630210399628,
-0.12889769673347473,
-0.03820936009287834,
0.5128533244132996,
-0.04396717995405197,
0.6355642080307007,
-0.25427353382110596,
0.35348206758499146,
-0.22504521906375885,
-0.38390517234802246,
0.45548656582832336,
-0.558312177658081,
0.7376490831375122,
0.31155478954315186,
-0.15287372469902039,
0.16894492506980896,
-0.5459167957305908,
-0.24309208989143372,
0.2746542692184448,
-0.340486615896225,
-0.2902379333972931,
0.010179135948419571,
-0.4551045596599579,
0.06431355327367783,
0.20197248458862305,
-0.12010899186134338,
0.1350666582584381,
-0.5287522077560425,
0.7159965634346008,
0.7496049404144287,
-0.08570532500743866,
0.7715751528739929,
-0.10454223304986954,
0.6282673478126526,
0.017965221777558327,
0.15958622097969055,
-0.47020402550697327,
-0.21766002476215363,
-0.5182164907455444,
-0.0393991656601429,
-0.0335099957883358,
0.22263765335083008,
-0.4313960075378418,
0.0170929953455925,
-0.11065299063920975,
-0.33898526430130005,
-0.5365791320800781,
0.41455674171447754,
0.41243380308151245,
0.5024375915527344,
0.021259909495711327,
0.055395640432834625,
-0.34809765219688416,
-1.1496365070343018,
-0.43842172622680664,
-0.26364243030548096,
-0.09044016897678375,
0.14417970180511475,
0.503816545009613,
-0.2696516811847687,
0.547273576259613,
-0.21887455880641937,
0.24938662350177765,
-0.5518234372138977,
0.1391136199235916,
0.3076748251914978,
0.31433770060539246,
0.2666838467121124,
-0.5760221481323242,
0.02262946590781212,
0.12196711450815201,
-1.0098437070846558,
-0.10573551058769226,
-0.16189797222614288,
0.10535398125648499,
0.11377675831317902,
0.7317714691162109,
-0.5673500895500183,
0.2624363303184509,
0.4206600785255432,
-0.2291797697544098,
0.7572770714759827,
-0.5501294732093811,
-0.05603436753153801,
-0.6512778401374817,
-0.1263534426689148,
-0.18930096924304962,
-0.23732052743434906,
-0.6019226908683777,
0.4124946892261505,
0.061806634068489075,
-0.04497740790247917,
-0.2605381906032562,
0.44429370760917664,
-0.7405107617378235,
-0.19316761195659637,
-0.41856157779693604,
0.16283971071243286,
0.12619757652282715,
0.3848389983177185,
-0.2500864565372467,
0.5974578261375427,
0.6174218058586121,
-0.6201527714729309,
0.2180577665567398,
-0.08762837946414948,
-0.45243412256240845,
0.2909873425960541,
-0.7828998565673828,
-0.05271712318062782,
-0.4618223011493683,
0.11705418676137924,
-0.9218522906303406,
-0.32080748677253723,
0.06638393551111221,
-0.29477810859680176,
0.3946881890296936,
-0.224388986825943,
-0.6893275380134583,
-0.11625807732343674,
-0.15619759261608124,
0.2994192838668823,
0.5346670746803284,
-0.6026042103767395,
0.6475582718849182,
0.43263232707977295,
-0.12156317383050919,
-0.44532546401023865,
-0.6622099280357361,
0.12395737320184708,
-0.5424907803535461,
-0.7675423622131348,
0.11262661218643188,
-0.18752916157245636,
-0.7084863781929016,
-0.17832107841968536,
-0.14346523582935333,
-0.06641510874032974,
0.467769056558609,
0.3577275276184082,
-0.021465197205543518,
-0.334504634141922,
0.46674174070358276,
0.05404946953058243,
-0.1812586784362793,
0.4537644684314728,
-0.302828311920166,
0.5537782311439514,
-0.2500731945037842,
-0.5698018670082092,
-0.5054821968078613,
0.21832318603992462,
0.6867884397506714,
-0.016294462606310844,
1.0315741300582886,
0.33011096715927124,
-0.2929117977619171,
-0.42700517177581787,
-0.4991316497325897,
-0.34004923701286316,
-0.4768320620059967,
0.48612117767333984,
-0.49008455872535706,
-0.983587920665741,
0.778724730014801,
-0.24503564834594727,
-0.07577850669622421,
0.2732482850551605,
0.6562042832374573,
-0.05768630653619766,
1.0069948434829712,
0.6835521459579468,
0.07780098915100098,
0.31362247467041016,
-0.14557798206806183,
0.4447363615036011,
-0.6315381526947021,
-0.4288061857223511,
-0.34818732738494873,
-0.17281121015548706,
-0.377829909324646,
-0.4942206144332886,
0.17402654886245728,
0.6045345664024353,
-0.10743389278650284,
0.0733417272567749,
-0.2319955974817276,
0.7073227763175964,
0.3571038544178009,
-0.03910437598824501,
0.5197678208351135,
-0.27635061740875244,
-0.16556842625141144,
0.05564364418387413,
-0.6290313005447388,
-0.8269166350364685,
0.7760404944419861,
0.8925546407699585,
1.051648497581482,
0.13481351733207703,
0.5306888818740845,
-0.09383654594421387,
0.10596604645252228,
-0.7753071188926697,
0.5208094716072083,
0.11425046622753143,
-0.6364777684211731,
-0.4530183970928192,
-0.20845524966716766,
-0.6074562072753906,
0.4331361949443817,
-0.09562639892101288,
-0.9249348044395447,
-0.1574544906616211,
0.32566845417022705,
0.10894707590341568,
0.44214001297950745,
-0.9716304540634155,
0.7014255523681641,
-0.34454572200775146,
-0.3118734061717987,
-0.4863629937171936,
-0.5910273790359497,
0.5498406887054443,
-0.07365141063928604,
0.48718729615211487,
0.033364396542310715,
0.07349599897861481,
0.5526503920555115,
-0.3933168947696686,
0.9025956392288208,
-0.106963612139225,
-0.5305825471878052,
0.0371008962392807,
0.211603581905365,
0.4549497365951538,
-0.022345246747136116,
-0.0863272026181221,
0.13228532671928406,
-0.13676594197750092,
-0.2571466863155365,
-0.9595655798912048,
0.7773149609565735,
-0.5291001796722412,
-0.8641770482063293,
0.16076409816741943,
-0.8912680149078369,
-0.18749669194221497,
0.008203238248825073,
0.057190604507923126,
0.3884081244468689,
-0.07296357303857803,
0.15626320242881775,
1.0462334156036377,
-0.5137948393821716,
0.43264293670654297,
0.4161829650402069,
-0.5200409889221191,
0.25577113032341003,
0.8759162425994873,
0.13537506759166718,
0.3644793629646301,
0.43766075372695923,
0.33204060792922974,
-0.4155902862548828,
-0.8538453578948975,
-0.2158433347940445,
0.4626016616821289,
-0.9678322672843933,
0.49088022112846375,
-0.49890658259391785,
-0.1771058738231659,
-0.1420518457889557,
-0.20335796475410461,
-0.17702580988407135,
-0.3614324927330017,
-0.23346073925495148,
-0.4686703085899353,
0.06358347088098526,
1.2503316402435303,
-0.08508644253015518,
0.528566300868988,
-0.5439001321792603,
0.2015218585729599,
0.37637636065483093,
0.5127690434455872,
0.4691586196422577,
-0.6557363867759705,
-0.43399578332901,
0.030970752239227295,
-0.04310851916670799,
-0.7796361446380615,
0.14009110629558563,
-0.10949451476335526,
0.8231409788131714,
0.6783338189125061,
-0.42122209072113037,
0.563346803188324,
-0.4823762774467468,
0.6007519364356995,
-0.015447566285729408,
-1.1902817487716675,
0.46903377771377563,
-0.4512166678905487,
0.14922532439231873,
0.17879697680473328,
0.35098934173583984,
-0.40178847312927246,
-0.5915296077728271,
-0.5443942546844482,
-0.9016616940498352,
0.6088457107543945,
0.013065909966826439,
0.22878925502300262,
0.33016738295555115,
0.6835716962814331,
0.3644852936267853,
0.12683245539665222,
-0.8463067412376404,
-0.16451887786388397,
-0.05515338480472565,
-0.1402033418416977,
-0.16023489832878113,
-0.6790551543235779,
-0.13115479052066803,
-0.13423509895801544,
0.5573984980583191,
0.039659127593040466,
0.1508869230747223,
-0.11246649920940399,
-0.5329909920692444,
0.09782172739505768,
0.47938358783721924,
0.7201594114303589,
1.0937554836273193,
-0.1303039789199829,
0.4704916179180145,
-0.05104108154773712,
-0.06375613808631897,
0.0000613808078924194,
-0.18776072561740875,
0.1555469036102295,
-0.21027225255966187,
0.8015685677528381,
0.8362299799919128,
0.2550104558467865,
-0.7312189936637878,
0.2408190667629242,
0.11065954715013504,
-0.27492091059684753,
-0.13221962749958038,
0.25633370876312256,
0.4951370060443878,
0.5456599593162537,
0.34642407298088074,
-0.47426366806030273,
0.1370256096124649,
-0.8970706462860107,
-0.09933121502399445,
0.588188111782074,
-0.3252435028553009,
-0.5527153611183167,
0.7380462884902954,
-0.13112451136112213,
-0.23117585480213165,
0.3139359652996063,
0.03329731151461601,
-0.49577590823173523,
0.5817055702209473,
0.5171903967857361,
0.5889623761177063,
-0.2730562388896942,
0.2450493574142456,
0.08453132957220078,
0.567980945110321,
-0.06684067100286484,
-0.06138966605067253,
-0.0075422124937176704,
-0.7268393039703369,
-0.555314838886261,
-0.5268691778182983,
-0.4896073341369629,
0.3913385570049286,
-0.6270915269851685,
-0.1928413361310959,
-0.3613758981227875,
0.5292982459068298,
0.19599135220050812,
-0.3620462715625763,
-0.40802037715911865,
0.09597832709550858,
0.16401775181293488,
0.8918301463127136,
-1.0064586400985718,
0.6695612668991089,
0.499600350856781,
-0.36278659105300903,
-0.9020419120788574,
0.022197775542736053,
0.09741988778114319,
-1.2861932516098022,
0.5727974772453308,
0.264506459236145,
-0.06188713759183884,
-0.19112028181552887,
-0.7422806620597839,
-0.5234090089797974,
1.0342025756835938,
0.7513322830200195,
-0.5498039126396179,
-0.08341313153505325,
0.2139110267162323,
0.6326426267623901,
-0.32729572057724,
0.25997504591941833,
0.7382170557975769,
0.6345170140266418,
0.04348169267177582,
-0.6605678796768188,
0.20570075511932373,
-0.08079439401626587,
0.008343358524143696,
0.01679924689233303,
-0.3038693368434906,
0.7144078612327576,
-0.4369215965270996,
-0.18066176772117615,
-0.1905171275138855,
0.37913644313812256,
0.18792450428009033,
0.2558429539203644,
0.37826865911483765,
0.4484085142612457,
0.9274086952209473,
0.02034866251051426,
1.25864839553833,
-0.16504928469657898,
0.12958306074142456,
0.9356744289398193,
-0.02861478365957737,
0.4245174825191498,
0.646479606628418,
-0.051034823060035706,
0.5361258387565613,
0.4196096658706665,
0.2514244318008423,
0.3366680145263672,
0.5453722476959229,
-0.2079658806324005,
-0.2152242213487625,
-0.06266205757856369,
-0.11568097770214081,
0.47477099299430847,
0.4253097474575043,
-0.6743679642677307,
-0.28684166073799133,
0.1246272400021553,
0.1297033727169037,
0.012258230708539486,
-0.4758496880531311,
0.8744357824325562,
0.18788404762744904,
-0.4528331160545349,
0.49474647641181946,
-0.1417098194360733,
0.33450615406036377,
-0.603550136089325,
-0.14403191208839417,
0.009583442471921444,
0.11913533508777618,
-0.15689359605312347,
-1.0075275897979736,
0.4557626247406006,
-0.3134384751319885,
-0.46512001752853394,
-0.4096689522266388,
0.7161382436752319,
-0.4234676957130432,
-0.052456874400377274,
0.46863293647766113,
0.6511815786361694,
0.34867051243782043,
-0.2481984794139862,
-0.4455134868621826,
0.25115150213241577,
0.05285901948809624,
-0.30352717638015747,
0.50868821144104,
0.8502803444862366,
-0.034903328865766525,
1.0671861171722412,
0.4364992380142212,
0.1324896216392517,
-0.03642270341515541,
0.12600062787532806,
0.8066602349281311,
-0.8187612295150757,
-0.29462727904319763,
-1.1823315620422363,
0.5888075828552246,
0.2001505047082901,
0.12337419390678406,
0.7113378047943115,
0.17568986117839813,
0.46132996678352356,
-0.0803881585597992,
0.7448023557662964,
0.30221542716026306,
0.33146390318870544,
-0.726699948310852,
0.9294840693473816,
-0.466074138879776,
0.6391238570213318,
-0.013584911823272705,
-0.7229519486427307,
-0.21620745956897736,
0.46077603101730347,
-0.3752812147140503,
-0.04303678125143051,
0.7241896986961365,
0.7773408889770508,
-0.0710718110203743,
0.026648053899407387,
0.5496013164520264,
0.7359852194786072,
0.36790308356285095,
0.4664922058582306,
0.9902052879333496,
0.14701616764068604,
0.5687587857246399,
-0.016083791851997375,
-0.2521568536758423,
-0.21264779567718506,
-0.9869815707206726,
-0.9518195986747742,
-0.6232743859291077,
-0.021189002320170403,
-0.21537932753562927,
0.04382709786295891,
0.3667702078819275,
0.7347570657730103,
-0.6116282939910889,
-0.2715405225753784,
-0.32955554127693176,
0.5475342869758606,
0.12624491751194,
-0.24551530182361603,
0.2559645473957062,
-0.34024977684020996,
-0.45566537976264954,
0.45126184821128845,
0.34645405411720276,
0.13607671856880188,
-0.4980906844139099,
-0.20340414345264435,
0.1983504742383957,
0.09272763133049011,
0.531495988368988,
0.2192447930574417,
-0.905075192451477,
-0.140009343624115,
-0.33529749512672424,
0.23789145052433014,
-0.14433731138706207,
0.8721446394920349,
-0.5527685284614563,
0.444850355386734,
0.37674516439437866,
0.6568827033042908,
0.27908769249916077,
-0.25480949878692627,
0.8633542060852051,
-0.45398274064064026,
0.007790951523929834,
-0.06560761481523514,
0.5983642935752869,
0.4047924876213074,
-0.4047289788722992,
0.49238312244415283,
-0.09292303025722504,
-0.6732233166694641,
-0.8412010669708252,
0.3690468966960907,
-0.7851829528808594,
-0.49833300709724426,
1.0367116928100586,
-0.23119515180587769,
-0.24867498874664307,
-0.24914586544036865,
-0.07089582830667496,
0.14456410706043243,
-0.08945436775684357,
0.7578198909759521,
0.9059827923774719,
-0.10514280945062637,
-0.43051961064338684,
-0.7759086489677429,
0.3865697979927063,
0.1784060299396515,
-0.835090160369873,
0.3988681435585022,
0.40632641315460205,
0.5308618545532227,
0.06392934918403625,
0.4019676446914673,
-0.2118617296218872,
-0.08520760387182236,
-0.1584767997264862,
-0.03584153205156326,
-0.20574316382408142,
-0.19346092641353607,
-0.7295129299163818,
0.2594091594219208,
0.3118084669113159,
0.12655287981033325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10685v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10685v2 | LongHeads: Multi-Head Attention is Secretly a Long Context Processor | 2024-02-16T13:39:34 | 2024-03-25T11:50:32 | Yi Lu, Xin Zhou, Wei He, Jun Zhao, Tao Ji, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in numerous
domains but often struggle to process lengthy inputs effectively and
efficiently due to limited length generalization and attention's quadratic
computational demands. Many sought to mitigate this by restricting the
attention window within the pre-trained length. However, these methods
introduce new issues such as ignoring the middle context and requiring
additional training. To address these problems, we propose LongHeads, a
training-free framework that enhances LLM's long context ability by unlocking
multi-head attention's untapped potential. Instead of allowing each head to
attend to the full sentence, which struggles with generalizing to longer
sequences due to out-of-distribution (OOD) issues, we allow each head to
process in-distribution length by selecting and attending to important context
chunks. To this end, we propose a chunk selection strategy that relies on the
inherent correlation between the query and the key representations, efficiently
distributing context chunks to different heads. In this way, each head ensures
it can effectively process attended tokens within the trained length, while
different heads in different layers can collectively process longer contexts.
LongHeads works efficiently in linear time, fits seamlessly with many LLMs that
use relative positional encoding. LongHeads achieves 100% accuracy at the 128k
length on passkey retrieval task, verifying LongHeads's efficacy in extending
the usable context window for existing models. We release our code at
https://github.com/LuLuLuyi/LongHeads . | [
-0.5441778898239136,
-0.6634792685508728,
0.8552447557449341,
0.6104369759559631,
-0.5893203020095825,
-0.0006102456245571375,
-0.7369003891944885,
-0.6606673002243042,
0.40984463691711426,
0.5460414886474609,
-0.868240475654602,
-0.18944334983825684,
-0.7127753496170044,
0.16982696950435638,
-0.3022681474685669,
0.724891185760498,
0.25160786509513855,
-0.4546113610267639,
-0.2893264591693878,
-0.10759937763214111,
-0.5564376711845398,
-0.3668747842311859,
-0.7709367275238037,
-0.24960948526859283,
0.8210296630859375,
0.20408374071121216,
0.41679367423057556,
0.9535030126571655,
0.4430800974369049,
0.21052765846252441,
-0.18991288542747498,
0.1873798817396164,
-0.7334152460098267,
0.37148115038871765,
-0.3990078568458557,
-0.03743463754653931,
-0.667043149471283,
-0.36169034242630005,
0.6413913369178772,
0.6706315279006958,
0.2165539562702179,
0.1385943591594696,
0.24146156013011932,
0.9720125794410706,
-0.8966107964515686,
0.1742681860923767,
-0.6121030449867249,
0.02643193118274212,
-0.6553551554679871,
-0.4257035553455353,
-0.4173111617565155,
0.3163692355155945,
0.2727019190788269,
-0.42220211029052734,
-0.28069329261779785,
-0.06054436042904854,
0.25826382637023926,
0.4347163140773773,
-0.4119918644428253,
-0.12492705136537552,
-0.259897917509079,
1.0146899223327637,
-0.336166650056839,
0.616287350654602,
0.2446342557668686,
0.4642399549484253,
-0.1603786200284958,
-0.617587685585022,
-0.36363306641578674,
0.2756103277206421,
0.14330145716667175,
-0.04617828130722046,
0.02052583172917366,
0.2962155342102051,
0.04588601738214493,
0.225176140666008,
-0.49185943603515625,
0.04955092817544937,
-0.19946402311325073,
-0.028405092656612396,
0.33808454871177673,
-0.19503135979175568,
-0.13166554272174835,
0.06065302714705467,
-0.43582236766815186,
0.06456659734249115,
-0.9134227633476257,
0.1314374953508377,
0.14814946055412292,
0.6805854439735413,
-0.15128645300865173,
0.4408894181251526,
-0.5338430404663086,
1.142729640007019,
0.3500005602836609,
-0.29303377866744995,
0.19983193278312683,
0.06430162489414215,
-0.4299168586730957,
0.03103180229663849,
0.6482110619544983,
0.2273169904947281,
0.26001736521720886,
-0.35696887969970703,
-0.1308409869670868,
-0.26050886511802673,
0.25219279527664185,
-0.9669426679611206,
0.37417149543762207,
0.6439443230628967,
-0.10155004262924194,
-0.07609761506319046,
-0.2852102518081665,
-0.6197735071182251,
-0.2257252037525177,
-0.43739140033721924,
0.21845874190330505,
-0.26267585158348083,
-0.1387583464384079,
0.24954944849014282,
-0.09485027194023132,
0.11797137558460236,
0.11661772429943085,
-0.9647510647773743,
-0.1327580213546753,
0.9484280347824097,
0.9765596985816956,
-0.6114116907119751,
-0.5198950171470642,
-0.7056003212928772,
0.4905640780925751,
-0.09410952031612396,
0.724655270576477,
-0.4596031606197357,
-0.0341237373650074,
0.03586553782224655,
0.08626710623502731,
0.05811000242829323,
-0.5758287906646729,
0.15331286191940308,
-0.6848937273025513,
-0.2956029772758484,
-0.14958922564983368,
-0.3974270820617676,
-0.08285782486200333,
0.2686837315559387,
-0.46314337849617004,
0.5029965043067932,
0.3495732247829437,
-0.8063167333602905,
0.19334761798381805,
-0.7854334712028503,
-0.6049433350563049,
0.19710877537727356,
-0.2888758182525635,
-0.1974828541278839,
0.0213181022554636,
0.35472390055656433,
0.7932683825492859,
-0.13515913486480713,
0.3027426302433014,
-0.4774441719055176,
-0.5178313851356506,
-0.0680529922246933,
-0.08677266538143158,
0.9300322532653809,
-0.04441596940159798,
-0.4505542814731598,
0.5328219532966614,
-0.3900875151157379,
-0.0112276840955019,
0.09624064713716507,
-0.33782583475112915,
-0.22692985832691193,
-0.1735456883907318,
0.06839077919721603,
0.2086324393749237,
0.0680028647184372,
-0.3358302712440491,
0.10124912858009338,
-0.3561437427997589,
0.6510007381439209,
0.7300853133201599,
-0.03278964385390282,
0.3518953323364258,
-0.15814203023910522,
0.3868200182914734,
0.26054847240448,
-0.13936567306518555,
-0.36597752571105957,
-0.14254909753799438,
-0.5677011013031006,
-0.6327344179153442,
-0.006172380410134792,
0.11977275460958481,
-0.7258015871047974,
0.6210602521896362,
-0.621717095375061,
0.005727045238018036,
-0.2481563687324524,
0.22030428051948547,
0.40010184049606323,
0.35425400733947754,
0.24040648341178894,
-0.511367678642273,
-0.5593228340148926,
-0.9507332444190979,
-0.2393580824136734,
0.3083012104034424,
-0.09813310950994492,
0.18777887523174286,
0.3221083879470825,
-0.37990275025367737,
1.308696985244751,
-0.5198611617088318,
-0.5692334175109863,
-0.3417254686355591,
-0.3104691803455353,
0.23008793592453003,
0.35665163397789,
0.44200342893600464,
-0.5155482888221741,
-0.45396292209625244,
-0.24218864738941193,
-0.711374819278717,
0.2405933290719986,
-0.074239581823349,
-0.5028014183044434,
-0.11040687561035156,
0.4575696885585785,
-0.9417779445648193,
0.13025596737861633,
0.5673215389251709,
-0.13570813834667206,
0.3707164227962494,
0.2527478039264679,
-0.2981281578540802,
-0.8260801434516907,
0.14207936823368073,
-0.030622517690062523,
-0.7570523619651794,
-0.5331385135650635,
0.45824775099754333,
0.44893428683280945,
-0.11420655250549316,
-0.8522499799728394,
0.6952136754989624,
-0.6759302616119385,
-0.0639551505446434,
-0.5577498078346252,
0.19457823038101196,
-0.07755192369222641,
0.8728806972503662,
0.22939163446426392,
0.897966742515564,
0.845009982585907,
-0.834228515625,
0.34579455852508545,
0.12092318385839462,
-0.394467830657959,
0.9638413786888123,
-0.4622330963611603,
0.5252189636230469,
-0.3091495633125305,
0.4511139988899231,
-0.5136116743087769,
-0.5843883156776428,
0.12639904022216797,
-0.26784077286720276,
0.5957323908805847,
-0.20952200889587402,
-0.161003977060318,
-0.4672372043132782,
-0.5040901303291321,
0.6132091283798218,
0.04755975678563118,
-0.570000171661377,
0.23891441524028778,
0.6579229831695557,
-0.15124480426311493,
-0.904833972454071,
-0.787972092628479,
0.19612830877304077,
-0.29006487131118774,
-0.5826640129089355,
0.4000188708305359,
-0.3401809632778168,
0.009275263175368309,
-0.4012640416622162,
-0.12942612171173096,
-0.2571569085121155,
-0.11197516322135925,
0.07099740952253342,
-0.3120197355747223,
-0.1259932965040207,
0.027558403089642525,
0.24213990569114685,
0.03915224224328995,
0.06875792890787125,
-0.5878534317016602,
0.6102058291435242,
0.2225061058998108,
-0.08691572397947311,
-0.2499500811100006,
0.4385251998901367,
0.8788911700248718,
-0.3913652300834656,
0.4579000473022461,
0.41675448417663574,
-0.30172353982925415,
-0.36784064769744873,
-0.3902971148490906,
-0.21040765941143036,
-0.5086013674736023,
0.7285635471343994,
-0.3501284420490265,
-1.2371447086334229,
0.11066041141748428,
0.14033561944961548,
0.08609846234321594,
-0.012936972081661224,
0.5913376212120056,
0.29204341769218445,
0.5383815169334412,
0.6388642191886902,
-0.33506637811660767,
0.4250441789627075,
-0.1165822222828865,
0.09902572631835938,
-1.2729566097259521,
0.09092246741056442,
0.08042952418327332,
-0.25762316584587097,
-0.014443749561905861,
-0.5558843016624451,
0.39581674337387085,
-0.0779038518667221,
-0.018116498365998268,
0.3419112265110016,
-0.5699845552444458,
0.7434437870979309,
0.42026063799858093,
0.18466730415821075,
-0.10371767729520798,
-0.12488666921854019,
0.2408018708229065,
0.20126768946647644,
-0.14785733819007874,
0.04076084494590759,
1.215605616569519,
0.4944547414779663,
0.4101327955722809,
0.035683635622262955,
0.575935959815979,
0.15569712221622467,
-0.13103441894054413,
-1.1167277097702026,
0.5650503039360046,
0.14083720743656158,
-0.7424561381340027,
-0.6019585132598877,
-0.3401252031326294,
-0.9571996331214905,
0.4864825904369354,
0.3673507869243622,
-0.6445052623748779,
-0.08947020024061203,
0.11612802743911743,
-0.8889890909194946,
0.1691773235797882,
-0.19149050116539001,
0.8717607855796814,
-0.17442478239536285,
-0.5422295331954956,
-0.24426910281181335,
-0.8549000024795532,
0.40649038553237915,
-0.28870299458503723,
0.12015372514724731,
-0.3312704265117645,
-0.021956579759716988,
0.8308524489402771,
0.11058249324560165,
0.7240273356437683,
-0.14602863788604736,
-0.037637002766132355,
0.3277507722377777,
-0.15884801745414734,
0.4372771978378296,
0.21810263395309448,
0.3689560890197754,
0.20646224915981293,
-0.3757614493370056,
-0.3668186664581299,
-0.2007751166820526,
0.8482997417449951,
-0.44708091020584106,
-0.6928291320800781,
-0.3860915005207062,
-0.8612716794013977,
-0.49954184889793396,
0.6194891333580017,
0.054606325924396515,
0.31949689984321594,
0.0880100205540657,
0.575844407081604,
0.6036545038223267,
0.08792929351329803,
0.6840780377388,
0.09019003063440323,
-0.34912577271461487,
-0.5063512325286865,
0.4984838664531708,
-0.025309568271040916,
0.2513614296913147,
0.51614910364151,
0.07371920347213745,
-0.19212846457958221,
-0.5093597769737244,
-0.5832868218421936,
0.31226781010627747,
-0.7215496897697449,
-0.34133535623550415,
-0.8239365816116333,
-0.13917715847492218,
-0.5974099040031433,
-0.008946790359914303,
-0.4458365738391876,
-0.15394169092178345,
-0.16832739114761353,
0.08493849635124207,
0.13192813098430634,
0.34303712844848633,
0.13633710145950317,
0.6921408176422119,
-0.4288158118724823,
0.45572012662887573,
0.6274895071983337,
0.4973689913749695,
0.15600009262561798,
-0.43491387367248535,
-0.4099394381046295,
-0.11098739504814148,
-0.4323217272758484,
-0.7171505689620972,
0.42386049032211304,
0.1256415843963623,
0.07686664909124374,
0.7044550776481628,
-0.12038557976484299,
1.011297583580017,
-0.8017342686653137,
0.4180310070514679,
0.23964296281337738,
-0.8480011820793152,
0.17424842715263367,
-0.5799448490142822,
0.8144322037696838,
0.6608130931854248,
0.2720990478992462,
-0.630553126335144,
-0.36260777711868286,
-0.004660474136471748,
-0.9851023554801941,
0.8568642735481262,
0.09912505000829697,
0.026744456961750984,
-0.1831541210412979,
0.23284125328063965,
0.17546148598194122,
0.4963378310203552,
-0.6427635550498962,
-0.19072963297367096,
0.08462744951248169,
-0.01212017610669136,
0.07804490625858307,
-0.4485951066017151,
-0.13230371475219727,
-0.20388007164001465,
0.4691983461380005,
-0.3722062408924103,
0.48579689860343933,
0.10248082131147385,
-0.36989569664001465,
-0.18343202769756317,
0.215582013130188,
0.7640433311462402,
1.2456746101379395,
-0.39171460270881653,
0.2349982112646103,
-0.06210954114794731,
-0.42030343413352966,
-0.14258849620819092,
-0.11121144890785217,
-0.019483176991343498,
-0.026188993826508522,
0.25308310985565186,
0.7554160952568054,
0.352557510137558,
-0.6237345933914185,
0.6994921565055847,
0.2338683307170868,
0.1703173965215683,
-0.6217448711395264,
-0.33361709117889404,
0.4554077088832855,
0.2210385799407959,
0.5184934139251709,
-0.06071233004331589,
0.17253883183002472,
-0.49682965874671936,
0.2955074608325958,
0.5860525965690613,
-0.53901207447052,
-0.3383581042289734,
0.3973081707954407,
0.31142449378967285,
-0.13440555334091187,
0.4410533607006073,
-0.09046228229999542,
-0.3881467282772064,
0.3505513370037079,
0.6076727509498596,
0.9871337413787842,
-0.034017037600278854,
-0.36433425545692444,
0.06360770761966705,
0.017570186406373978,
-0.1322258859872818,
0.026401296257972717,
-0.24826407432556152,
-0.37918326258659363,
-0.756094217300415,
-0.6452931761741638,
-0.2880517840385437,
0.5784372091293335,
-0.6136236190795898,
0.29771700501441956,
-0.4364944398403168,
-0.3469911813735962,
-0.09275894612073898,
-0.2770228683948517,
-0.5823096632957458,
0.21428845822811127,
0.4293575584888458,
0.7171045541763306,
-0.24626533687114716,
1.033390760421753,
0.2913501262664795,
0.064101442694664,
-0.14662688970565796,
0.11321700364351273,
0.10301174223423004,
-0.7163571119308472,
0.4630770683288574,
0.8701356649398804,
-0.2288377285003662,
-0.020349128171801567,
-0.3634003698825836,
-1.0165401697158813,
0.9572194218635559,
0.5144854784011841,
-0.9310665130615234,
-0.42199617624282837,
0.060402169823646545,
-0.059593696147203445,
-0.4217078983783722,
0.2547925114631653,
0.5789119601249695,
0.25574061274528503,
-0.027593713253736496,
-1.0366320610046387,
-0.04562139883637428,
0.38758668303489685,
-0.04824007302522659,
0.2664581537246704,
-0.9138059020042419,
0.9033904671669006,
-0.10385963320732117,
-0.20347127318382263,
-0.2554643750190735,
0.9057968258857727,
0.476919949054718,
0.12361575663089752,
0.6923296451568604,
0.3506552278995514,
0.4627384543418884,
0.20905551314353943,
0.7959333658218384,
-0.5581161379814148,
0.31539517641067505,
1.1005749702453613,
-0.24199728667736053,
0.8727050423622131,
0.9648398160934448,
-0.05224398523569107,
0.21371497213840485,
0.45547381043434143,
0.6370960474014282,
0.7918392419815063,
0.2730165421962738,
-0.2337336391210556,
-0.24674618244171143,
0.10752391815185547,
-0.30305513739585876,
0.43703290820121765,
0.14944936335086823,
-0.21621958911418915,
-0.163581982254982,
0.1553555130958557,
0.23967020213603973,
-0.27711209654808044,
-0.4211505353450775,
0.4188285768032074,
0.4435916543006897,
-0.7817617058753967,
0.6439833641052246,
-0.016015779227018356,
1.1906944513320923,
-0.7828118801116943,
0.3596816956996918,
-0.12464407831430435,
0.42342913150787354,
-0.021904464811086655,
-0.5796653628349304,
0.2856529653072357,
-0.16077038645744324,
-0.28235873579978943,
-0.29577502608299255,
0.448501855134964,
-0.6006160974502563,
-0.0990072637796402,
0.4422778785228729,
0.28653833270072937,
0.1395978331565857,
-0.9163639545440674,
-0.4029653072357178,
0.3266841173171997,
-0.09567832946777344,
-0.47654294967651367,
0.5972002744674683,
0.41873207688331604,
-0.00836181640625,
0.5917947292327881,
0.43603432178497314,
0.20595543086528778,
-0.07120566070079803,
-0.14372076094150543,
0.7949376106262207,
-0.7903109192848206,
-0.8128113746643066,
-1.098090410232544,
0.27149397134780884,
-0.1327855885028839,
-0.3196200728416443,
0.4806172847747803,
0.5710954666137695,
0.9950964450836182,
-0.27649709582328796,
0.6624419689178467,
0.13379035890102386,
0.6166479587554932,
-0.2820216119289398,
0.8655609488487244,
-0.5302025079727173,
-0.3327614665031433,
0.0941988155245781,
-1.0786798000335693,
-0.38590219616889954,
0.4140962064266205,
-0.04212414100766182,
0.014770586974918842,
0.8672407269477844,
0.2917259931564331,
-0.3964817523956299,
-0.3922779858112335,
0.4783572852611542,
-0.12001056224107742,
0.28329071402549744,
0.9956589937210083,
0.3991374373435974,
0.05665329843759537,
0.37280985713005066,
-0.3549147844314575,
-0.17551329731941223,
-0.33894017338752747,
-0.9147082567214966,
-1.1770379543304443,
-0.3021286427974701,
-0.13042879104614258,
0.024555101990699768,
0.3005131781101227,
1.1511552333831787,
1.1661674976348877,
-0.6506248116493225,
-0.5843403935432434,
0.2661222517490387,
-0.19876621663570404,
-0.306883305311203,
-0.1750570684671402,
0.43159931898117065,
-0.4954134523868561,
-0.7983104586601257,
0.8394827246665955,
0.6871533989906311,
-0.2569420635700226,
-0.348227858543396,
0.0024687566328793764,
-0.017209554091095924,
-0.027810202911496162,
1.0928279161453247,
0.25493884086608887,
-0.7543100714683533,
-0.41082096099853516,
-0.04180899262428284,
-0.1294383704662323,
0.28284576535224915,
0.7279160022735596,
-0.7826411724090576,
0.3417094647884369,
0.22556689381599426,
0.9054180383682251,
0.39767059683799744,
-0.09449204802513123,
0.34267351031303406,
-1.0701384544372559,
0.5837833285331726,
0.31196221709251404,
0.35904449224472046,
0.4916369616985321,
-0.4672379791736603,
0.375188946723938,
0.06668510288000107,
-0.5213465690612793,
-0.9436682462692261,
0.34915661811828613,
-1.2092818021774292,
-0.4122958779335022,
1.233922004699707,
-0.09932860732078552,
-0.6930110454559326,
0.07368728518486023,
0.06833254545927048,
0.24020080268383026,
-0.5180832743644714,
0.5816835761070251,
0.5666800141334534,
-0.06756483018398285,
-0.0332534983754158,
-0.5456474423408508,
0.5695239901542664,
0.3503130376338959,
-0.6020849943161011,
0.4502684473991394,
0.27946653962135315,
0.22683297097682953,
0.19829091429710388,
0.7561338543891907,
-0.060818061232566833,
0.17173601686954498,
-0.5420892834663391,
-0.030750280246138573,
-0.3530561625957489,
-0.7719364166259766,
-0.3471377193927765,
0.36402422189712524,
-0.0038579378742724657,
-0.2665866017341614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10675v1 | German Text Simplification: Finetuning Large Language Models with Semi-Synthetic Data | 2024-02-16T13:28:44 | 2024-02-16T13:28:44 | Lars Klöser, Mika Beele, Jan-Niklas Schagen, Bodo Kraft | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This study pioneers the use of synthetically generated data for training
generative models in document-level text simplification of German texts. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach with real-world online texts.
Addressing the challenge of data scarcity in language simplification, we
crawled professionally simplified German texts and synthesized a corpus using
GPT-4. We finetune Large Language Models with up to 13 billion parameters on
this data and evaluate their performance. This paper employs various
methodologies for evaluation and demonstrates the limitations of currently used
rule-based metrics. Both automatic and manual evaluations reveal that our
models can significantly simplify real-world online texts, indicating the
potential of synthetic data in improving text simplification. | [
-0.3017185926437378,
-1.0143498182296753,
0.797508180141449,
0.09346333891153336,
-0.43641361594200134,
-0.1358570009469986,
-0.2912841737270355,
-0.4666360020637512,
-0.10478705167770386,
0.19770722091197968,
-0.7127181887626648,
-0.5642209053039551,
-0.24704141914844513,
0.5939415097236633,
-0.5580632090568542,
1.1145330667495728,
-0.2141965925693512,
0.34575513005256653,
-0.14342118799686432,
0.22661109268665314,
0.09910087287425995,
-0.6909024715423584,
-0.44494059681892395,
-0.43813884258270264,
0.2897937595844269,
0.31136444211006165,
0.7418422698974609,
0.8353001475334167,
0.4468939006328583,
0.36606788635253906,
-0.3202285170555115,
0.24465925991535187,
-0.7449986934661865,
-0.10499319434165955,
0.014658519998192787,
-0.26405057311058044,
-0.3564088046550751,
0.017332399263978004,
0.8033081293106079,
1.001265525817871,
-0.06540698558092117,
0.04313617944717407,
-0.10353147238492966,
0.4181976914405823,
-0.21277903020381927,
0.46377992630004883,
-0.3136453926563263,
0.11858120560646057,
-0.05814427509903908,
-0.15336404740810394,
-0.31944960355758667,
-0.5910777449607849,
0.063337542116642,
-0.8457903265953064,
0.7436801195144653,
-0.053664397448301315,
0.9468980431556702,
0.15684263408184052,
-0.4322509169578552,
-0.3716009557247162,
-1.2381269931793213,
0.7816312909126282,
-0.8300841450691223,
0.2959640920162201,
0.06847037374973297,
0.2561738193035126,
-0.06801237165927887,
-1.1106467247009277,
-0.6546710729598999,
-0.28546369075775146,
-0.33413299918174744,
0.12051752209663391,
-0.15921427309513092,
0.2654917538166046,
0.5599101781845093,
0.5857980847358704,
-0.5182337760925293,
-0.1761368215084076,
-0.867986798286438,
-0.24930672347545624,
0.6673754453659058,
0.05048603191971779,
0.36337360739707947,
-0.119998998939991,
-0.1419355869293213,
-0.19955673813819885,
-0.7311515808105469,
-0.51458340883255,
0.5728655457496643,
0.2862408757209778,
-0.03874870762228966,
0.6264990568161011,
-0.4723461866378784,
0.4917013347148895,
-0.18649506568908691,
-0.11362484097480774,
0.38169506192207336,
-0.6195586919784546,
-0.3179810643196106,
-0.002558306558057666,
0.6615803837776184,
0.38318488001823425,
0.3768056333065033,
-0.36757591366767883,
-0.39067715406417847,
0.08686435222625732,
0.1507083624601364,
-0.9726748466491699,
-0.12089135497808456,
0.1354251354932785,
-0.36644598841667175,
-0.3116653561592102,
0.19743406772613525,
-0.6503559350967407,
-0.09078722447156906,
-0.651707112789154,
0.36207878589630127,
-0.3882327377796173,
0.07647019624710083,
0.3399042785167694,
-0.4579264223575592,
0.029302163049578667,
0.5497470498085022,
-0.6617488861083984,
0.25345996022224426,
0.5411600470542908,
0.7459664344787598,
-0.06475107371807098,
-0.24639859795570374,
-0.057628046721220016,
0.27120348811149597,
-0.4800248444080353,
0.517974317073822,
-0.23024393618106842,
-0.3511562645435333,
0.08083615452051163,
-0.01408210676163435,
0.342247873544693,
-0.6697197556495667,
1.0867911577224731,
-0.3033815026283264,
0.4177105128765106,
0.17647698521614075,
-0.8414883017539978,
-0.1429467350244522,
0.11321509629487991,
-0.9933971762657166,
1.0775272846221924,
0.17869932949543,
-0.669067919254303,
0.21242134273052216,
-0.5254919528961182,
-0.6689393520355225,
0.08199402689933777,
0.10926959663629532,
-0.5302303433418274,
0.2104630470275879,
0.11422450840473175,
0.49689871072769165,
-0.4794154167175293,
0.4356178641319275,
-0.1871894896030426,
-0.45177507400512695,
-0.0675884261727333,
-0.6481819152832031,
0.4395934045314789,
0.47774580121040344,
-0.22293710708618164,
-0.07994619011878967,
-0.9595088958740234,
0.11650228500366211,
0.1591057926416397,
-0.5248498916625977,
-0.4164755046367645,
-0.24011604487895966,
0.48558226227760315,
0.24729947745800018,
0.18610626459121704,
-0.5840075016021729,
0.14826159179210663,
-0.6033921241760254,
0.4539637565612793,
0.2554415762424469,
0.10600543022155762,
0.47230270504951477,
-0.39147210121154785,
0.5443669557571411,
-0.20200733840465546,
0.0693904384970665,
-0.07281464338302612,
-0.24215589463710785,
-0.8180476427078247,
-0.3273056149482727,
0.7016188502311707,
0.44354918599128723,
-0.693678081035614,
0.3202207684516907,
-0.5951082706451416,
-0.7463980317115784,
-0.5677651762962341,
0.05029169097542763,
0.3121604919433594,
0.15555845201015472,
0.41043922305107117,
0.03900489956140518,
-0.624897837638855,
-1.094957947731018,
-0.3467058539390564,
0.26235172152519226,
-0.3960312306880951,
-0.1597229242324829,
0.3771169185638428,
-0.3703781068325043,
0.8135531544685364,
-0.45096421241760254,
-0.16409045457839966,
-0.47351697087287903,
0.43669161200523376,
-0.11413586139678955,
0.49856674671173096,
0.38171669840812683,
-1.0606638193130493,
-0.4674246609210968,
-0.09387759864330292,
-0.8068020939826965,
-0.1540507972240448,
-0.24919012188911438,
0.3264455497264862,
0.14370578527450562,
0.9259210824966431,
-0.7292529940605164,
0.22679011523723602,
0.5288960933685303,
0.024217287078499794,
0.23899824917316437,
-0.6148108839988708,
-0.0327417366206646,
-0.9570841193199158,
0.061933066695928574,
0.21187274158000946,
-0.5595119595527649,
-1.0682467222213745,
0.2605367600917816,
0.15541476011276245,
-0.2877529561519623,
-0.5421569347381592,
0.6520200967788696,
-0.5121721029281616,
0.1871795356273651,
-0.026940302923321724,
-0.008519581519067287,
-0.22016409039497375,
0.3394862115383148,
-0.059117622673511505,
0.7194765210151672,
0.08371428400278091,
-0.5335580110549927,
0.3381953835487366,
0.08991092443466187,
-0.32371434569358826,
0.01692773588001728,
-0.6883127689361572,
-0.15929074585437775,
-0.32039502263069153,
0.5014386773109436,
-0.8926846385002136,
-0.6870561242103577,
-0.07199433445930481,
-0.04977849870920181,
0.18234054744243622,
-0.07293253391981125,
-0.8937999606132507,
-0.15388938784599304,
-0.3015291690826416,
0.6034095287322998,
0.6482290625572205,
-0.39528822898864746,
0.6201938390731812,
0.24184316396713257,
-0.376766562461853,
0.2221205234527588,
-0.6340246200561523,
0.01814681850373745,
-0.35051190853118896,
-0.5188114047050476,
0.7206135392189026,
-0.18573632836341858,
-0.20021529495716095,
-0.21931755542755127,
-0.02238468825817108,
-0.01375417411327362,
-0.10294263064861298,
-0.02984006702899933,
0.27093225717544556,
0.17574991285800934,
0.11527910083532333,
0.26450666785240173,
-0.07316026091575623,
-0.13477195799350739,
-0.05003584176301956,
0.6578689813613892,
0.04169565439224243,
-0.10193045437335968,
-0.6037538647651672,
0.4878554344177246,
0.522887647151947,
0.28193119168281555,
0.5876879096031189,
0.4940541088581085,
-0.45829179883003235,
-0.43386396765708923,
-0.35486164689064026,
-0.3443663716316223,
-0.48596298694610596,
0.12522566318511963,
-0.48209622502326965,
-0.8517442941665649,
0.4926130473613739,
-0.6130349636077881,
-0.1696198731660843,
0.805147111415863,
0.5645202398300171,
-0.09963800013065338,
1.1331075429916382,
0.6735785007476807,
0.3598741590976715,
0.26767849922180176,
-0.22993552684783936,
0.3778217136859894,
0.02047033980488777,
-0.1660972386598587,
-0.4439718425273895,
-0.003607014426961541,
-1.0819222927093506,
-0.30469948053359985,
0.44448912143707275,
0.2680743932723999,
-0.058931488543748856,
0.21094124019145966,
-0.3086705803871155,
0.5383621454238892,
0.6029765009880066,
0.1408873051404953,
0.4322744309902191,
0.20368890464305878,
-0.10680680721998215,
-0.0387641005218029,
-0.5813442468643188,
-0.6683870553970337,
1.017234444618225,
0.3296703100204468,
0.6425241827964783,
-0.11892423778772354,
0.7383264899253845,
0.2845156490802765,
0.16360917687416077,
-0.657953143119812,
0.5248727202415466,
-0.17248263955116272,
-0.6979811787605286,
-0.3385706841945648,
-0.6527306437492371,
-0.6809946894645691,
-0.01868346333503723,
-0.19142070412635803,
-0.08780576288700104,
-0.34000810980796814,
0.17592045664787292,
-0.050730202347040176,
-0.12348005175590515,
-1.2137691974639893,
0.6820815801620483,
0.22922809422016144,
-0.0893077477812767,
-0.19129467010498047,
-0.47333693504333496,
0.2098580151796341,
-0.6560395956039429,
0.32566457986831665,
0.11464860290288925,
-0.004007043316960335,
0.5668185353279114,
-0.7585070729255676,
0.8871292471885681,
0.1563977748155594,
-0.22317847609519958,
0.19813695549964905,
-0.000902038998901844,
0.9277202486991882,
-0.25674545764923096,
-0.05206318944692612,
0.1659059226512909,
0.03945663571357727,
-0.45929959416389465,
-0.5321905016899109,
0.6233513355255127,
-0.6357061862945557,
-0.4701009690761566,
-0.23295575380325317,
-0.4969232678413391,
-0.15479131042957306,
0.4293627142906189,
0.32057151198387146,
0.30579671263694763,
-0.4160764217376709,
0.19199028611183167,
0.29504695534706116,
-0.06074794381856918,
0.30082130432128906,
0.2740896940231323,
-0.006051589734852314,
-0.281244158744812,
0.8715077042579651,
0.260799378156662,
0.4302031099796295,
0.2102467566728592,
0.10504825413227081,
-0.45475301146507263,
-0.5688885450363159,
-0.4017237424850464,
0.3773980736732483,
-0.8844980001449585,
-0.011437786743044853,
-0.5538747310638428,
-0.3499402105808258,
-0.32914412021636963,
-0.1801430732011795,
-0.1212194636464119,
-0.9011480808258057,
-0.23034663498401642,
-0.3822568356990814,
0.14489147067070007,
0.8512080311775208,
0.03887154534459114,
0.5033562779426575,
-0.7274805903434753,
0.4382838010787964,
0.09784184396266937,
0.18805277347564697,
-0.3006683886051178,
-0.2985488772392273,
-0.08067147433757782,
0.11673759669065475,
-0.20669858157634735,
-0.7394707202911377,
0.626800000667572,
0.09527631849050522,
0.4257870614528656,
0.11811868101358414,
0.1231958195567131,
0.48109889030456543,
-0.7655760049819946,
0.5303785800933838,
0.06392694264650345,
-1.026071310043335,
0.25599032640457153,
-0.8100213408470154,
0.2864120304584503,
0.31623730063438416,
0.5751997232437134,
-0.480166494846344,
-0.565020740032196,
-0.9904305338859558,
-0.9947012066841125,
0.7383496761322021,
0.6240075826644897,
0.4404744505882263,
0.3498610258102417,
0.4670604467391968,
0.1777174472808838,
0.24564683437347412,
-0.7812593579292297,
-0.3371918797492981,
0.07635913044214249,
-0.6247540712356567,
-0.1164681538939476,
-0.2862747311592102,
-0.1383027583360672,
-0.3352249264717102,
0.7814379334449768,
-0.057572267949581146,
0.1023460403084755,
0.051079731434583664,
0.06077834218740463,
0.06383051723241806,
0.3810414969921112,
0.6969666481018066,
0.5425800085067749,
0.013242768123745918,
0.11753854155540466,
0.4555906355381012,
-0.28209188580513,
0.2564283013343811,
0.3844490647315979,
-0.7767716646194458,
0.4116455912590027,
0.38024553656578064,
0.6733038425445557,
0.11393130570650101,
-0.7213199734687805,
0.2880784571170807,
0.04214392229914665,
-0.4678976237773895,
-0.3753969967365265,
0.06286823749542236,
0.2126632034778595,
-0.1031997948884964,
0.3123563230037689,
-0.03910689055919647,
0.360795795917511,
-0.6172722578048706,
0.14787617325782776,
0.07195866107940674,
-0.05621678754687309,
-0.3547488749027252,
0.45423972606658936,
0.011350415647029877,
-0.16929304599761963,
0.22501662373542786,
-0.37486863136291504,
-0.4328615069389343,
0.4853980243206024,
0.572330117225647,
0.5290254950523376,
-0.10779076814651489,
0.30377665162086487,
0.4493701756000519,
0.14232684671878815,
-0.5156930685043335,
0.24223268032073975,
0.2014041543006897,
-0.4533814489841461,
-0.39612939953804016,
-0.8136835098266602,
-0.3165629804134369,
0.46205011010169983,
-0.24798008799552917,
0.5662707686424255,
-0.4373374581336975,
-0.053865090012550354,
0.4563412666320801,
-0.0685308501124382,
-0.6185410022735596,
0.4750373065471649,
-0.04854267090559006,
0.7174582481384277,
-1.034612774848938,
0.8290466070175171,
0.5996015071868896,
-0.5972749590873718,
-0.932914674282074,
0.2163015455007553,
0.019026542082428932,
-0.3127099871635437,
0.5176392793655396,
0.13702787458896637,
-0.05442577227950096,
0.39679279923439026,
-0.5551515817642212,
-0.6541998386383057,
0.748885452747345,
0.5251340270042419,
-0.4370366930961609,
-0.2990800142288208,
0.5246096253395081,
0.9794567823410034,
-0.09136339277029037,
0.1963586062192917,
0.5477855205535889,
0.6251165270805359,
0.16716526448726654,
-0.8685868978500366,
0.07428831607103348,
-0.19710242748260498,
0.07903316617012024,
0.2884528338909149,
-0.3716873526573181,
0.8304689526557922,
0.1065201386809349,
-0.6332293152809143,
0.08988438546657562,
0.4785575270652771,
-0.20536436140537262,
0.12247756868600845,
0.30792590975761414,
0.4722684323787689,
0.7245591878890991,
-0.23998510837554932,
1.2100772857666016,
-0.16006454825401306,
0.6257808208465576,
0.8412386178970337,
0.01069063600152731,
0.5921122431755066,
0.45735132694244385,
-0.11543416976928711,
0.23668594658374786,
0.57789146900177,
-0.15493503212928772,
0.45374584197998047,
0.39222753047943115,
-0.3997253477573395,
-0.286619633436203,
-0.07802402973175049,
0.039294444024562836,
0.3386998474597931,
0.14232811331748962,
-0.3379852771759033,
-0.6097772717475891,
0.0562669076025486,
0.189544215798378,
0.20974433422088623,
-0.1904175877571106,
0.9459583759307861,
-0.12139219790697098,
-0.632179319858551,
0.7398484945297241,
0.5487329959869385,
0.5182361602783203,
-0.5045796036720276,
-0.06704401224851608,
-0.2845211923122406,
0.5183343887329102,
-0.08101372420787811,
-0.4723186194896698,
0.27045726776123047,
0.23543968796730042,
-0.18992900848388672,
-0.501470685005188,
0.5803362131118774,
-0.6611101627349854,
-0.7124492526054382,
0.0882548913359642,
0.5447717905044556,
0.2814803719520569,
-0.031386807560920715,
-0.402619332075119,
-0.13809144496917725,
0.20783501863479614,
-0.19553160667419434,
0.2083740234375,
0.6751675605773926,
-0.31056177616119385,
0.6753312349319458,
0.8662617206573486,
0.12499970942735672,
0.10145625472068787,
0.050535596907138824,
1.0683422088623047,
-0.6569114923477173,
-0.5472800731658936,
-0.8235103487968445,
0.28174465894699097,
-0.27793627977371216,
-0.10865584760904312,
0.834510087966919,
0.9257772564888,
1.218749761581421,
-0.36307236552238464,
1.0653871297836304,
0.11870089173316956,
0.700691819190979,
-0.5989471077919006,
0.6853347420692444,
-0.5686840415000916,
0.04049907624721527,
-0.1313106119632721,
-0.8803685903549194,
-0.5170053839683533,
0.3092348575592041,
-0.24066205322742462,
0.19192977249622345,
0.6843158006668091,
0.7834533452987671,
-0.4926818013191223,
0.03299853205680847,
0.4083801209926605,
0.1516241878271103,
0.3287488520145416,
-0.028768150135874748,
0.49437186121940613,
-0.5282461047172546,
0.7697927355766296,
-0.33517295122146606,
-0.005182753317058086,
-0.17968058586120605,
-0.8284715414047241,
-0.7812825441360474,
-0.6819019913673401,
-0.27949008345603943,
-0.0645609200000763,
-0.03836018964648247,
0.8088141083717346,
0.5908910632133484,
-0.8079518675804138,
0.03989569842815399,
-0.5372220873832703,
-0.31823113560676575,
-0.008260907605290413,
-0.21307486295700073,
0.38440802693367004,
-0.45962658524513245,
-1.1679177284240723,
0.4041668176651001,
-0.17116981744766235,
0.7101666927337646,
-0.24458669126033783,
-0.055609673261642456,
0.07160961627960205,
0.3272581696510315,
0.5277153253555298,
0.029155677184462547,
-0.6516063213348389,
-0.036894723773002625,
-0.25518953800201416,
-0.47836557030677795,
-0.06199837476015091,
0.8611183762550354,
-0.5547938346862793,
0.3556181490421295,
0.6602157354354858,
0.37889188528060913,
0.6571828722953796,
0.31311994791030884,
0.8908646106719971,
-1.0095446109771729,
0.38967517018318176,
0.11785575747489929,
0.1416771411895752,
0.5475804209709167,
-0.16080451011657715,
0.5750597715377808,
0.3098899722099304,
-0.19014979898929596,
-0.7730903625488281,
0.031699519604444504,
-0.7274330258369446,
-0.41805702447891235,
1.428059458732605,
-0.04160935431718826,
-0.13921430706977844,
-0.0378001444041729,
-0.32609033584594727,
0.47792690992355347,
-0.23047219216823578,
0.7181218266487122,
0.8042302131652832,
0.3188526928424835,
0.03687768429517746,
-0.785057008266449,
1.0890026092529297,
0.3162783682346344,
-1.1265687942504883,
0.299606055021286,
0.8186739087104797,
0.19155648350715637,
0.15410256385803223,
0.2181803435087204,
0.045952487736940384,
0.06478802859783173,
0.04159315675497055,
0.09901696443557739,
0.0006689740112051368,
-0.2715598940849304,
-0.4831344485282898,
0.23951637744903564,
-0.19952064752578735,
0.43092742562294006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10671v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10671v3 | Decomposition for Enhancing Attention: Improving LLM-based Text-to-SQL through Workflow Paradigm | 2024-02-16T13:24:05 | 2024-07-03T04:45:29 | Yuanzhen Xie, Xinzhou Jin, Tao Xie, MingXiong Lin, Liang Chen, Chenyun Yu, Lei Cheng, ChengXiang Zhuo, Bo Hu, Zang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning of large-language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable
success in the field of natural language processing, while extensive case
studies reveal that the single-step chain-of-thought prompting approach faces
challenges such as attention diffusion and inadequate performance in complex
tasks like text-to-SQL. To improve the contextual learning capabilities of LLMs
in text-to-SQL, a workflow paradigm method is proposed, aiming to enhance the
attention and problem-solving scope of LLMs through decomposition.
Specifically, the information determination module for eliminating redundant
information and the brand-new prompt structure based on problem classification
greatly enhance the model's attention. Additionally, the inclusion of
self-correction and active learning modules greatly expands the problem-solving
scope of LLMs, hence improving the upper limit of LLM-based approaches.
Extensive experiments conducted on three datasets demonstrate that our approach
outperforms other methods by a significant margin. About 2-3 percentage point
improvements compared to the existing baseline on the Spider Dev,
Spider-Realistic, and Bird Dev datasets and new SOTA results on the Spider Test
dataset are achieved. Our code is available on GitHub:
\url{https://github.com/FlyingFeather/DEA-SQL}. | [
-0.11095689982175827,
-0.9445221424102783,
0.5722855925559998,
0.171414315700531,
-0.3772999942302704,
0.13706929981708527,
-0.45552894473075867,
-0.2561199963092804,
0.16102567315101624,
0.714110791683197,
-0.7369722127914429,
-0.5093533396720886,
-0.2826809585094452,
0.4299167990684509,
-0.41220298409461975,
0.7378827929496765,
-0.007019019685685635,
-0.027482569217681885,
-0.30856552720069885,
0.030744578689336777,
-0.6459337472915649,
-0.4174559712409973,
-0.679851233959198,
-0.08566875010728836,
0.4876216948032379,
0.37893301248550415,
-0.027271484956145287,
0.8358346819877625,
0.6716369986534119,
0.21581603586673737,
-0.49646908044815063,
0.27196821570396423,
-0.6748470067977905,
0.4341528117656708,
-0.5307343602180481,
-0.5092345476150513,
-0.476348876953125,
-0.42105376720428467,
0.676020085811615,
0.7753394246101379,
-0.2914367616176605,
0.31927046179771423,
0.3173848092556,
1.1405893564224243,
-0.878990113735199,
0.2548525631427765,
-0.5992385149002075,
0.026990316808223724,
-0.2094336450099945,
-0.3499104976654053,
-0.6417676210403442,
0.11423793435096741,
0.14340537786483765,
-0.3633383512496948,
0.04760957881808281,
0.14215509593486786,
0.39167270064353943,
0.637309193611145,
-0.39839649200439453,
0.11578059941530228,
-0.7000201940536499,
0.6038520336151123,
-0.6814223527908325,
0.2748737633228302,
0.033423248678445816,
0.21987797319889069,
-0.3454371690750122,
-0.562647819519043,
-0.46859559416770935,
0.1856279820203781,
0.16140882670879364,
0.12169571965932846,
-0.10854460299015045,
0.0021750712767243385,
0.32993873953819275,
0.4199521243572235,
-0.49599316716194153,
-0.031720347702503204,
-0.24774612486362457,
0.0725112333893776,
0.4561035931110382,
0.3566925823688507,
-0.06866076588630676,
-0.14029854536056519,
-0.3381359875202179,
0.21944764256477356,
-0.7540664076805115,
-0.21585461497306824,
-0.28573399782180786,
0.5106139779090881,
0.10371606796979904,
0.6246355175971985,
-0.5481503009796143,
0.9755631685256958,
0.16928806900978088,
-0.17767490446567535,
0.2938486635684967,
-0.38114291429519653,
-0.7093250155448914,
-0.21665549278259277,
0.45728281140327454,
0.24777907133102417,
-0.08554088324308395,
-0.3586568832397461,
-0.2749430239200592,
-0.0035092285834252834,
0.328355610370636,
-0.776832640171051,
0.14087754487991333,
0.37074044346809387,
-0.5095213651657104,
-0.2007632851600647,
-0.44971251487731934,
-0.6331453323364258,
-0.5743847489356995,
-0.6602635383605957,
0.23036056756973267,
-0.23907384276390076,
-0.2063031643629074,
-0.06933733075857162,
0.06559174507856369,
0.1793460100889206,
0.5511573553085327,
-0.584388792514801,
0.17136821150779724,
0.6155959367752075,
0.7927336096763611,
-0.7607448101043701,
0.10451836884021759,
-0.5895729064941406,
0.4365946054458618,
-0.35668474435806274,
0.9855149984359741,
-0.5116998553276062,
0.1569484919309616,
0.06065882369875908,
0.009913555346429348,
-0.2777974307537079,
-0.918717086315155,
0.39552345871925354,
-0.6651456356048584,
0.1862427145242691,
-0.10563745349645615,
-0.6867274045944214,
-0.2777491807937622,
0.5201855301856995,
-0.5264855623245239,
1.0490142107009888,
0.21841174364089966,
-0.7831262350082397,
0.2792094349861145,
-1.1171553134918213,
-0.5499425530433655,
0.22485113143920898,
-0.011832913383841515,
-0.21375159919261932,
0.02472790516912937,
0.08748546987771988,
0.6862130761146545,
-0.5407886505126953,
0.22265447676181793,
-0.13791562616825104,
-0.3511229157447815,
0.08368854969739914,
0.09171693027019501,
0.691625714302063,
0.21050310134887695,
-0.48256996273994446,
0.3060665428638458,
-0.922879695892334,
-0.11513256281614304,
0.14333580434322357,
-0.39833196997642517,
-0.13018937408924103,
0.006730637513101101,
-0.058543749153614044,
0.20391830801963806,
-0.0013461523922160268,
-0.2352573275566101,
0.0006480309530161321,
-0.8860986232757568,
0.4743666350841522,
0.597326934337616,
0.36715003848075867,
0.7160667181015015,
0.0015304292319342494,
0.5036236643791199,
0.3100968301296234,
-0.0019501816714182496,
-0.1768512725830078,
0.01761074736714363,
-0.9739764332771301,
-0.43902063369750977,
0.13434603810310364,
0.6226122379302979,
-0.7729340195655823,
0.43570825457572937,
-0.07522828876972198,
-0.11652588844299316,
-0.19484089314937592,
0.23990829288959503,
0.29953593015670776,
0.8131011128425598,
0.3456309735774994,
-0.37199828028678894,
-0.6280282139778137,
-0.6862713694572449,
-0.2942785918712616,
0.12246019393205643,
-0.06453230232000351,
0.21962504088878632,
0.41663858294487,
-0.3720548152923584,
0.8978145718574524,
-0.5605860948562622,
-0.7816053032875061,
-0.4043766260147095,
-0.2126525640487671,
0.26802557706832886,
0.1494995504617691,
0.07707669585943222,
-0.6794261932373047,
-0.527896523475647,
-0.3043290376663208,
-0.5424565672874451,
0.12042637914419174,
0.17919215559959412,
-0.26895982027053833,
0.6593315005302429,
0.444430947303772,
-0.5411362051963806,
0.47349897027015686,
-0.04709271714091301,
-0.2893063724040985,
0.3397214114665985,
0.11231917142868042,
-0.12113671749830246,
-1.1589354276657104,
0.23849862813949585,
0.030445178970694542,
-0.14493431150913239,
-0.6338695883750916,
0.05168095976114273,
0.048767976462841034,
-0.06419443339109421,
-0.48596224188804626,
0.44597476720809937,
-0.7143288254737854,
-0.11895385384559631,
-0.38023993372917175,
0.39169812202453613,
-0.2841067910194397,
0.7378908395767212,
0.12476196885108948,
0.7403224110603333,
0.7983953952789307,
-0.9139629006385803,
0.2879234850406647,
0.18008293211460114,
-0.2747425138950348,
0.7084542512893677,
-0.27866601943969727,
0.11106955260038376,
-0.33867138624191284,
0.16736535727977753,
-1.135880470275879,
-0.34702029824256897,
0.464613676071167,
-0.25125041604042053,
0.40663522481918335,
-0.13521228730678558,
-0.6328089237213135,
-0.02258608303964138,
-0.3630048334598541,
0.10183995217084885,
0.3804558217525482,
-0.42801138758659363,
0.697231113910675,
0.48918139934539795,
-0.12192844599485397,
-0.5618337988853455,
-0.6388571262359619,
0.23193109035491943,
-0.3249359726905823,
-0.3309165835380554,
0.38321608304977417,
-0.0881633386015892,
-0.33702516555786133,
-0.1793181151151657,
-0.2401699274778366,
-0.21594402194023132,
-0.04277294501662254,
0.01988174021244049,
0.19102831184864044,
0.08844007551670074,
0.43468472361564636,
-0.17422784864902496,
-0.17991195619106293,
0.18819665908813477,
-0.41380035877227783,
0.35473933815956116,
0.33501341938972473,
0.21121203899383545,
-0.41301053762435913,
0.3306134045124054,
0.49867409467697144,
-0.49308905005455017,
0.7288340330123901,
0.433587908744812,
-0.48464643955230713,
-0.682790219783783,
-0.44801950454711914,
-0.30118927359580994,
-0.4205758571624756,
0.3802502453327179,
-0.053453244268894196,
-0.9030870199203491,
0.23376333713531494,
-0.3583560883998871,
0.12766940891742706,
0.19415152072906494,
0.8025242686271667,
-0.2300640493631363,
0.756294310092926,
0.8992691040039062,
-0.020242908969521523,
0.7043591141700745,
-0.3175187110900879,
0.24855680763721466,
-1.1888103485107422,
-0.37909504771232605,
-0.4604613482952118,
-0.025693237781524658,
-0.09455353766679764,
-0.7204008102416992,
0.32503417134284973,
-0.21934519708156586,
-0.22674456238746643,
0.1687755584716797,
-0.8404154181480408,
0.4541440010070801,
-0.026735886931419373,
0.2934449017047882,
0.3508625328540802,
0.18908891081809998,
-0.04741353169083595,
-0.006319043692201376,
-0.7476024627685547,
-0.4126725494861603,
1.1401054859161377,
0.17630694806575775,
0.6522055864334106,
0.1059214398264885,
0.7888637185096741,
0.3280849754810333,
0.415060430765152,
-0.9457401633262634,
0.7418179512023926,
0.11999619007110596,
-0.4302433133125305,
-0.4370286762714386,
-0.46356621384620667,
-0.8578795194625854,
0.3765963912010193,
0.04104200378060341,
-0.9172021746635437,
-0.048171646893024445,
0.18229161202907562,
-0.12585102021694183,
-0.06098756566643715,
-0.6415387988090515,
0.8486667275428772,
0.20520974695682526,
-0.772312581539154,
-0.29172131419181824,
-0.575510561466217,
0.3261326551437378,
-0.053171850740909576,
0.2217453271150589,
-0.09380979835987091,
-0.38290080428123474,
0.9144289493560791,
-0.5177712440490723,
0.9140051007270813,
-0.17037780582904816,
-0.48368459939956665,
0.3475402295589447,
-0.09239138662815094,
0.7207664251327515,
0.015381213277578354,
-0.09421883523464203,
-0.2547042965888977,
-0.3648942708969116,
-0.1390547752380371,
-0.6089956760406494,
0.412585586309433,
-0.1523483246564865,
-0.646346390247345,
-0.29289934039115906,
-0.6134719848632812,
-0.3717274069786072,
0.24787580966949463,
-0.05242164805531502,
0.38873445987701416,
0.13788031041622162,
0.19371330738067627,
0.9467684030532837,
0.35549432039260864,
0.7610486745834351,
0.6512739062309265,
-0.08837515860795975,
-0.38273248076438904,
0.4660303294658661,
0.13609708845615387,
0.07129506766796112,
0.7311496734619141,
-0.15895593166351318,
-0.5529821515083313,
-0.7344586849212646,
-0.21002677083015442,
0.268988698720932,
-0.9174541234970093,
-0.47585731744766235,
-0.726536214351654,
0.08479410409927368,
-0.22253401577472687,
0.2584570646286011,
-0.08439099043607712,
-0.17534790933132172,
-0.5212065577507019,
0.19574563205242157,
0.2812393605709076,
0.3814699053764343,
0.52916419506073,
0.10959161072969437,
-0.4596411883831024,
0.2701621651649475,
0.08081156760454178,
0.38335132598876953,
0.20624323189258575,
-0.7188373804092407,
-0.38495713472366333,
-0.2936132848262787,
-0.2116185575723648,
-0.977433979511261,
0.34677210450172424,
0.15401318669319153,
0.44878697395324707,
0.06636962294578552,
0.2178410142660141,
0.7458028197288513,
-0.349299818277359,
0.4812411367893219,
-0.022620422765612602,
-1.0300772190093994,
0.7467865347862244,
-0.267190158367157,
0.43827614188194275,
0.5347910523414612,
0.0942896381020546,
-0.14551615715026855,
-0.49840888381004333,
-0.46673890948295593,
-0.8536695837974548,
0.9894767999649048,
0.2948898673057556,
-0.2579181492328644,
0.20389631390571594,
0.5823354721069336,
-0.2234276831150055,
0.2887133061885834,
-0.8053417205810547,
-0.2750474214553833,
0.461837500333786,
-0.17614322900772095,
-0.07648744434118271,
-0.34616124629974365,
-0.05434132367372513,
-0.3557300567626953,
0.5978888273239136,
-0.38108739256858826,
0.34634119272232056,
0.24002526700496674,
-0.3869246542453766,
-0.06819028407335281,
0.42803266644477844,
0.376615047454834,
0.9399640560150146,
-0.05013546347618103,
0.14795824885368347,
0.422210693359375,
-0.2818484902381897,
0.11887562274932861,
-0.26724207401275635,
-0.10070503503084183,
-0.20782208442687988,
0.2738765478134155,
0.46019676327705383,
0.1611088514328003,
-0.8322724103927612,
0.42070451378822327,
-0.03844735771417618,
-0.12315642833709717,
-0.14871306717395782,
0.4053342044353485,
0.26838070154190063,
0.38914749026298523,
0.47985216975212097,
0.0895393043756485,
0.5716618895530701,
-0.5506823062896729,
0.041022684425115585,
0.2551439702510834,
-0.30731162428855896,
-0.014849051833152771,
0.42048969864845276,
0.29759347438812256,
-0.3445080518722534,
0.18566854298114777,
-0.227119579911232,
-0.4344105124473572,
0.5761332511901855,
0.805347740650177,
0.964980959892273,
-0.12329762428998947,
-0.09700427204370499,
0.4073616862297058,
0.17089435458183289,
0.006378590129315853,
0.6131154298782349,
-0.46362316608428955,
-0.30118584632873535,
-0.6548504829406738,
-0.43019339442253113,
-0.3971680998802185,
0.060122206807136536,
-0.4385555684566498,
0.2661524713039398,
-0.39672479033470154,
-0.12064612656831741,
-0.051157183945178986,
0.031295258551836014,
-0.424104779958725,
0.25315603613853455,
-0.08084400743246078,
0.8647375106811523,
-0.47589191794395447,
0.7277156114578247,
0.9671552181243896,
-0.2629008889198303,
-0.5762050151824951,
0.3855675458908081,
-0.21122895181179047,
-0.24843280017375946,
0.764553964138031,
0.34709110856056213,
-0.14684967696666718,
0.1364842802286148,
-0.4901670515537262,
-0.9222903251647949,
1.0033520460128784,
0.464643657207489,
-0.6480117440223694,
0.23494169116020203,
-0.05748680979013443,
0.6276406645774841,
-0.6024743914604187,
0.13301455974578857,
0.5788846015930176,
0.35861071944236755,
0.13745848834514618,
-0.6747689843177795,
0.28287312388420105,
-0.08015724271535873,
0.25576186180114746,
0.3235931098461151,
-0.6474593281745911,
0.48298633098602295,
-0.3358979821205139,
-0.4775444269180298,
-0.43133544921875,
0.5911505818367004,
0.11251207441091537,
0.1907457411289215,
0.5229467153549194,
0.3922925591468811,
0.6852178573608398,
0.04020888730883598,
0.553584098815918,
-0.17325663566589355,
0.33682891726493835,
1.0518946647644043,
-0.5729650855064392,
1.0731819868087769,
0.7201021909713745,
-0.115816131234169,
0.5389265418052673,
0.6051098108291626,
0.2146858125925064,
0.6567192077636719,
0.36130544543266296,
-0.13934394717216492,
-0.215647354722023,
-0.20459981262683868,
0.02307194471359253,
0.36727872490882874,
0.351019948720932,
-0.27407580614089966,
-0.24243853986263275,
0.16938669979572296,
-0.07586115598678589,
0.13252140581607819,
-0.38622546195983887,
1.2448338270187378,
-0.0629175528883934,
-0.7642295360565186,
0.9892092347145081,
-0.049467939883470535,
0.5763220191001892,
-0.21630029380321503,
-0.13848209381103516,
-0.2545190155506134,
0.5076180696487427,
-0.44609493017196655,
-0.5608711838722229,
0.3526022136211395,
0.206660658121109,
-0.5027427077293396,
-0.19736242294311523,
0.7698525190353394,
-0.5823938250541687,
-0.11907060444355011,
0.35332557559013367,
0.30788668990135193,
0.03245774284005165,
-0.26275238394737244,
-0.5875939130783081,
0.1818203181028366,
0.034891024231910706,
-0.2961656153202057,
0.2270948588848114,
0.4645557105541229,
0.022005833685398102,
0.826791524887085,
0.43369144201278687,
-0.17187370359897614,
-0.2998027503490448,
0.07790165394544601,
0.9648610353469849,
-0.7213301062583923,
-0.6751229166984558,
-0.9851436614990234,
0.5775129199028015,
-0.3071475625038147,
-0.01462614070624113,
0.6401902437210083,
0.7738521695137024,
0.5885049104690552,
-0.22328312695026398,
0.5504586100578308,
-0.058066099882125854,
0.7632753849029541,
-0.48421409726142883,
0.5018333792686462,
-0.6352687478065491,
0.4273677468299866,
-0.3436812162399292,
-1.0548738241195679,
-0.4740103483200073,
0.39388734102249146,
-0.06441690027713776,
0.05157594382762909,
1.0664490461349487,
0.8004561066627502,
0.29085609316825867,
-0.2904590964317322,
0.1088581457734108,
0.17506061494350433,
0.041846804320812225,
0.7486572265625,
0.7613284587860107,
-0.3485621213912964,
0.5140806436538696,
-0.06323479861021042,
-0.4449479579925537,
-0.45280081033706665,
-0.841202974319458,
-1.2630348205566406,
-0.6163882613182068,
-0.5419213175773621,
-0.19351142644882202,
0.07186190783977509,
0.9019933342933655,
0.7036965489387512,
-0.5573711395263672,
-0.2583484947681427,
-0.23022466897964478,
0.24612106382846832,
-0.4096294939517975,
-0.2582847476005554,
0.5030377507209778,
-0.9285354614257812,
-0.5562188029289246,
0.4021522104740143,
0.855195939540863,
-0.21953696012496948,
-0.1577715277671814,
0.08424565941095352,
-0.19642862677574158,
0.03510023280978203,
1.0202126502990723,
-0.13160978257656097,
-0.6173447966575623,
0.19356033205986023,
0.1387905776500702,
-0.15175727009773254,
0.265252023935318,
0.6914699077606201,
-0.8559665083885193,
0.3222038745880127,
0.5769833326339722,
0.6663511395454407,
0.5666708946228027,
-0.11798298358917236,
0.4399121403694153,
-0.7816756367683411,
0.11412349343299866,
0.3793748617172241,
0.2748010456562042,
0.21487221121788025,
-0.6552814245223999,
0.8335598111152649,
0.24200285971164703,
-0.24996139109134674,
-0.9902805685997009,
0.05781255662441254,
-1.0774503946304321,
-0.13660643994808197,
1.1981074810028076,
0.08688213676214218,
-0.702100396156311,
-0.24001643061637878,
-0.3327557444572449,
0.3043225109577179,
-0.3634602129459381,
0.8719072937965393,
0.4062991738319397,
-0.2574092745780945,
-0.2992674708366394,
-0.2785108983516693,
0.6346368789672852,
0.62422114610672,
-1.3763941526412964,
0.7166143655776978,
0.5235956311225891,
0.3332556188106537,
0.011738428846001625,
0.6268472075462341,
-0.25911203026771545,
0.3096015751361847,
-0.4506478011608124,
0.006713197100907564,
-0.053902767598629,
-0.4699079394340515,
-0.4660155475139618,
0.21127161383628845,
-0.03395339101552963,
-0.17475304007530212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10670v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10670v2 | OpenFMNav: Towards Open-Set Zero-Shot Object Navigation via Vision-Language Foundation Models | 2024-02-16T13:21:33 | 2024-03-25T02:52:43 | Yuxuan Kuang, Hai Lin, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.RO | Object navigation (ObjectNav) requires an agent to navigate through unseen
environments to find queried objects. Many previous methods attempted to solve
this task by relying on supervised or reinforcement learning, where they are
trained on limited household datasets with close-set objects. However, two key
challenges are unsolved: understanding free-form natural language instructions
that demand open-set objects, and generalizing to new environments in a
zero-shot manner. Aiming to solve the two challenges, in this paper, we propose
OpenFMNav, an Open-set Foundation Model based framework for zero-shot object
Navigation. We first unleash the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs) to extract proposed objects from natural language instructions that meet
the user's demand. We then leverage the generalizability of large vision
language models (VLMs) to actively discover and detect candidate objects from
the scene, building a Versatile Semantic Score Map (VSSM). Then, by conducting
common sense reasoning on VSSM, our method can perform effective
language-guided exploration and exploitation of the scene and finally reach the
goal. By leveraging the reasoning and generalizing abilities of foundation
models, our method can understand free-form human instructions and perform
effective open-set zero-shot navigation in diverse environments. Extensive
experiments on the HM3D ObjectNav benchmark show that our method surpasses all
the strong baselines on all metrics, proving our method's effectiveness.
Furthermore, we perform real robot demonstrations to validate our method's
open-set-ness and generalizability to real-world environments. | [
-0.26067909598350525,
-0.7888749241828918,
0.5585016012191772,
-0.2644117772579193,
-0.3335255980491638,
-0.14789961278438568,
-0.32616692781448364,
-0.2546966075897217,
-0.11798544973134995,
0.8213651180267334,
-0.6461464166641235,
-1.0474400520324707,
-0.27824732661247253,
-0.38240042328834534,
-0.2043481171131134,
0.5392976999282837,
-0.23149044811725616,
-0.3817514479160309,
-0.3743044137954712,
-0.34951138496398926,
-0.4435507357120514,
-0.3299099802970886,
0.024414068087935448,
-0.17877386510372162,
0.39997604489326477,
0.6997736096382141,
0.8802522420883179,
0.8689776062965393,
0.5850571990013123,
0.09125497937202454,
0.03582363575696945,
0.12019176781177521,
-0.5994229316711426,
0.11728446930646896,
-0.5270317196846008,
-0.48831427097320557,
-0.08259902894496918,
-0.18621760606765747,
0.3527999818325043,
0.7220549583435059,
-0.1569184511899948,
0.180850088596344,
-0.3933134973049164,
0.6843504309654236,
-0.98526930809021,
0.3511987328529358,
-0.3782770037651062,
0.4099234640598297,
-0.10083939880132675,
-0.1931002140045166,
-0.31475967168807983,
0.03747956082224846,
0.22687745094299316,
-0.804142415523529,
0.10987730324268341,
0.027252530679106712,
0.9026535153388977,
0.4186849892139435,
-0.3265741467475891,
0.027500728145241737,
-0.9580106139183044,
1.0537456274032593,
-0.34284573793411255,
0.5218736529350281,
0.18949396908283234,
0.680183470249176,
-0.3709033727645874,
-0.35638269782066345,
-0.3491979241371155,
-0.3795599341392517,
0.33429354429244995,
-0.03583250194787979,
-0.17904561758041382,
0.03263723477721214,
0.011806104332208633,
0.18980957567691803,
-0.6473838686943054,
-0.09801007062196732,
-0.21129176020622253,
0.05907838046550751,
0.35978686809539795,
0.05450349673628807,
0.32515397667884827,
0.18226829171180725,
-0.5546379685401917,
-0.24191130697727203,
-0.7790030837059021,
0.40306103229522705,
0.032963093370199203,
0.677638590335846,
0.00716496491804719,
1.025728464126587,
-0.9019589424133301,
1.2270803451538086,
-0.43787264823913574,
-0.006745494436472654,
0.1793920397758484,
-0.24947431683540344,
-0.4486788511276245,
0.10855179280042648,
0.4187215268611908,
0.5788018107414246,
0.7247025966644287,
-0.3434186279773712,
-0.2113383710384369,
0.08630120009183884,
0.2564413845539093,
-0.679664671421051,
-0.08743021637201309,
0.23971065878868103,
-0.3627456724643707,
-0.42405954003334045,
0.21394909918308258,
-0.5351445078849792,
-0.24648727476596832,
-0.3230236768722534,
0.5920352935791016,
-0.251505970954895,
-0.4293847680091858,
0.7395371794700623,
-0.10293430089950562,
0.5290271639823914,
0.5527163147926331,
-0.5103841423988342,
0.1101507842540741,
0.6006550192832947,
0.7851605415344238,
0.18306536972522736,
-0.10683443397283554,
-0.8992779850959778,
0.31238067150115967,
-0.5945401191711426,
0.6974995732307434,
-0.7931261658668518,
-0.4172554314136505,
-0.03148239105939865,
-0.12095802277326584,
0.08765330165624619,
-0.30037444829940796,
0.04993642494082451,
-0.11474881321191788,
0.14650887250900269,
-0.018234504386782646,
-0.10607009381055832,
-0.6024742722511292,
0.6682220101356506,
-0.2895703911781311,
0.8798642158508301,
0.11353576183319092,
-0.10661984235048294,
0.2848127782344818,
-0.9846112728118896,
-0.45975837111473083,
-0.0930417850613594,
-0.29482731223106384,
-0.028967414051294327,
0.16400066018104553,
0.3844741880893707,
0.6191948056221008,
-0.13092723488807678,
0.032117851078510284,
-0.3267787992954254,
-0.5622243285179138,
-0.17677578330039978,
-0.1591351181268692,
0.6658360362052917,
-0.08674996346235275,
-0.4598350524902344,
0.19203177094459534,
-0.5745417475700378,
-0.10320490598678589,
0.3840431272983551,
-0.31950661540031433,
-0.3237980008125305,
0.28675347566604614,
-0.3714431822299957,
0.31409358978271484,
0.030633218586444855,
-0.7574878334999084,
0.3489978015422821,
-0.6475253701210022,
-0.14697207510471344,
0.4545595943927765,
0.16850531101226807,
0.6597165465354919,
-0.16778728365898132,
0.6058598756790161,
0.17882086336612701,
0.2778032422065735,
-0.5701601505279541,
-0.85965895652771,
-0.7134515047073364,
-0.08428545296192169,
-0.11786104738712311,
0.5540286302566528,
-0.866543710231781,
0.16964717209339142,
-0.20030872523784637,
-0.3475697934627533,
-0.43123704195022583,
0.06747667491436005,
0.6090032458305359,
0.7625678777694702,
0.6427149176597595,
-0.18579407036304474,
-0.2554478645324707,
-0.5584445595741272,
0.10025747120380402,
-0.017899392172694206,
-0.20338234305381775,
0.5060545206069946,
0.601344108581543,
0.06789910793304443,
1.1075823307037354,
-0.7275213599205017,
-0.6301971673965454,
0.0024969179648905993,
-0.2673543393611908,
0.017435668036341667,
0.42234474420547485,
0.5457746386528015,
-0.8350474238395691,
-0.00004181916665402241,
0.318098783493042,
-1.1537169218063354,
0.3032311499118805,
0.09339984506368637,
-0.4385277330875397,
0.13902129232883453,
0.4996618628501892,
-0.47486281394958496,
0.9835186004638672,
0.09750743210315704,
-0.3717246949672699,
0.15525387227535248,
-0.012330258265137672,
0.027367958799004555,
-0.6772633790969849,
0.1439846009016037,
0.07771921902894974,
-0.2199227511882782,
-0.6857385039329529,
0.5976433753967285,
-0.2753634452819824,
-0.20981331169605255,
-0.9678412079811096,
0.668658971786499,
-0.5322343707084656,
-0.3309735357761383,
-0.12784072756767273,
0.39701905846595764,
-0.014150889590382576,
0.8480240106582642,
0.28080570697784424,
0.1875266581773758,
0.7558483481407166,
-0.6399073004722595,
0.35725146532058716,
0.2542244791984558,
-0.3089584410190582,
0.6898059844970703,
-0.3084504306316376,
-0.034423861652612686,
-0.4082823097705841,
0.20977593958377838,
-0.6983984708786011,
-0.007362729404121637,
0.6505239009857178,
-0.4889427125453949,
-0.05508405342698097,
-0.3775840401649475,
-0.2651909589767456,
-0.21335512399673462,
-0.1345619112253189,
0.023802850395441055,
0.37051576375961304,
-0.566580057144165,
0.7702294588088989,
0.07317490875720978,
0.49874141812324524,
-1.01214599609375,
-0.6201910376548767,
-0.040636833757162094,
0.3558144271373749,
-0.57872474193573,
-0.1185992881655693,
-0.09955106675624847,
-0.21868687868118286,
0.16414254903793335,
-0.517937421798706,
0.03619270399212837,
0.3492589592933655,
0.5436382293701172,
0.422113835811615,
-0.6004589796066284,
0.011703671887516975,
-0.297906756401062,
-0.14754635095596313,
-0.184217631816864,
-0.581188976764679,
0.5164077281951904,
-0.36077478528022766,
-0.6600003838539124,
0.05823570489883423,
0.1763685941696167,
0.3966445028781891,
-0.7069255113601685,
0.5180494785308838,
0.24800966680049896,
-0.545322835445404,
-0.2691134810447693,
-0.06836376339197159,
0.0649777352809906,
-0.40520477294921875,
0.20452749729156494,
-0.6029934287071228,
-0.8814213871955872,
0.12500536441802979,
-0.14249606430530548,
0.4278610348701477,
0.08264316618442535,
0.4459283649921417,
-0.05436686798930168,
0.8288069367408752,
0.6653929352760315,
0.3120567798614502,
0.2279060333967209,
-0.5604903697967529,
0.13851304352283478,
-0.5590909719467163,
-0.729654848575592,
-0.4536856412887573,
-0.47885701060295105,
0.2792469561100006,
-0.9853860139846802,
0.08342333137989044,
0.34409061074256897,
-0.18468186259269714,
0.3616091310977936,
-0.6054201722145081,
0.9040676355361938,
0.5148058533668518,
0.28998303413391113,
0.4150015413761139,
0.014838590286672115,
-0.5663012862205505,
0.38351553678512573,
-0.5862409472465515,
-0.34038859605789185,
1.2163810729980469,
0.09991082549095154,
0.4821842312812805,
0.20203812420368195,
0.7203111052513123,
0.1414516121149063,
0.18456920981407166,
-1.1107702255249023,
0.8899552822113037,
-0.03296947851777077,
-0.6844959259033203,
-0.5335397124290466,
-0.2665340006351471,
-0.797577977180481,
0.49825721979141235,
-0.12883953750133514,
-0.8274046778678894,
0.22462917864322662,
0.10461488366127014,
-0.16406595706939697,
0.5252088308334351,
-0.35540011525154114,
1.1117275953292847,
-0.20643579959869385,
-0.20594651997089386,
0.01405163761228323,
-0.8231551051139832,
0.5221511125564575,
0.19958356022834778,
-0.06694471091032028,
-0.48580920696258545,
-0.2940014898777008,
0.18850953876972198,
-0.3391733169555664,
0.7340736985206604,
-0.5807887315750122,
0.007098338566720486,
0.3954801559448242,
0.4708305895328522,
0.15638287365436554,
-0.24522614479064941,
0.18690383434295654,
0.3623129427433014,
-0.39419025182724,
-0.4368487298488617,
-0.5728709101676941,
0.5845732688903809,
-0.39070314168930054,
-0.3062857389450073,
-0.34542056918144226,
-0.2527245283126831,
-0.21519415080547333,
0.2565253674983978,
-0.06976127624511719,
0.3888108730316162,
-0.47165119647979736,
0.44434458017349243,
0.8006149530410767,
-0.2595933973789215,
0.5055317282676697,
0.8327997922897339,
-0.6989292502403259,
0.17996780574321747,
1.062501311302185,
-0.0870472714304924,
0.08832371234893799,
0.8118045926094055,
0.10948992520570755,
-0.18685711920261383,
-0.4847172200679779,
-0.8998681306838989,
-0.10413790494203568,
-0.6174488067626953,
-0.40179359912872314,
-0.3531389832496643,
-0.07062540203332901,
0.002238188637420535,
-0.45586755871772766,
-0.4184683561325073,
-0.3692849576473236,
-0.4437751770019531,
-0.08984082192182541,
0.20160681009292603,
0.3773016333580017,
-0.004179151728749275,
0.1548748016357422,
-0.5521173477172852,
0.6814849972724915,
0.17960678040981293,
0.582122266292572,
-0.010281425900757313,
-0.1809854805469513,
-0.12212209403514862,
0.2874598503112793,
0.0602412074804306,
-0.617806613445282,
0.03438320383429527,
0.058714188635349274,
0.6611037254333496,
0.6754364967346191,
0.2914905846118927,
0.4976508617401123,
-0.4035160541534424,
0.6379557251930237,
0.20067018270492554,
-0.6999481320381165,
0.8619838356971741,
-0.49816134572029114,
0.5348617434501648,
0.3877812922000885,
0.34246426820755005,
-0.4158320724964142,
-0.15144363045692444,
-0.24412159621715546,
-0.5939011573791504,
0.8311334252357483,
0.25717175006866455,
-0.26818087697029114,
0.07912556082010269,
0.19193294644355774,
-0.2406800389289856,
0.35704275965690613,
-0.4083332121372223,
0.03769087791442871,
-0.4893765449523926,
-0.2489151507616043,
-0.14756694436073303,
0.3397120535373688,
-0.24883781373500824,
-0.023049715906381607,
0.40015140175819397,
-0.4478578269481659,
0.1337423026561737,
0.17766381800174713,
-0.4077816605567932,
-0.40913668274879456,
0.030862940475344658,
0.884118378162384,
0.32711005210876465,
-0.6428460478782654,
-0.1685405671596527,
-0.2938590347766876,
-0.18009592592716217,
0.23082788288593292,
-0.05693812668323517,
-0.2588767111301422,
-0.03290087729692459,
0.11079837381839752,
0.7879312634468079,
0.546863317489624,
-0.9327723979949951,
0.9134693145751953,
0.18612921237945557,
-0.48849865794181824,
-0.08738133311271667,
0.41346025466918945,
-0.0007353945984505117,
0.23563358187675476,
0.18414069712162018,
0.47814980149269104,
-0.15175309777259827,
-0.5196442604064941,
0.22298705577850342,
0.4630270004272461,
-0.6906251311302185,
-0.08480317890644073,
0.6964190602302551,
0.185256689786911,
-0.4656035900115967,
0.5383701324462891,
-0.04846480116248131,
-0.12312107533216476,
0.7504698038101196,
0.18141573667526245,
0.8204325437545776,
-0.2448142021894455,
0.4780653715133667,
0.11141655594110489,
0.5153889060020447,
-0.3808962404727936,
0.40244320034980774,
-0.3594565987586975,
-0.7563729882240295,
-0.3536893427371979,
-0.7161744236946106,
-0.6505829095840454,
-0.20137059688568115,
-0.574518620967865,
0.17118655145168304,
-0.7177955508232117,
0.3432590067386627,
-0.3447158932685852,
-0.4658632278442383,
-0.7413489818572998,
0.2920997142791748,
0.24356114864349365,
1.1185133457183838,
-0.4418931305408478,
0.8013750314712524,
0.8137815594673157,
-0.600283145904541,
-0.4287604093551636,
-0.10596116632223129,
0.27706605195999146,
-1.0386695861816406,
0.4119602143764496,
0.4992421567440033,
-0.5696528553962708,
0.024811938405036926,
-0.6693991422653198,
-0.8068901896476746,
1.111161231994629,
0.20178896188735962,
-0.39199912548065186,
-0.2457975149154663,
0.1488761156797409,
0.32748931646347046,
-0.6477816104888916,
-0.11816436797380447,
0.2939322590827942,
0.4859377145767212,
0.4358348250389099,
-0.5008549094200134,
-0.05959596484899521,
-0.03237483277916908,
-0.036181893199682236,
0.4684504270553589,
-0.37776872515678406,
0.5946698188781738,
-0.568193793296814,
-0.1441093236207962,
0.0745048001408577,
0.45704391598701477,
0.11691217124462128,
0.4464706480503082,
0.5335637927055359,
0.7398830056190491,
0.35755667090415955,
-0.11999660730361938,
0.8101343512535095,
-0.013817721046507359,
0.12405528128147125,
1.1821963787078857,
-0.5466641187667847,
1.1742032766342163,
0.2887701392173767,
0.3570527732372284,
0.5697243213653564,
0.0855436846613884,
-0.04154261201620102,
0.6653425693511963,
0.36493587493896484,
-0.26838406920433044,
-0.38015177845954895,
-0.1300509124994278,
-0.05402672290802002,
0.840362548828125,
0.3093276917934418,
-0.13677100837230682,
-0.6630182266235352,
0.4382067620754242,
-0.1902252435684204,
0.1634284108877182,
-0.43485355377197266,
0.5990710854530334,
-0.1652386486530304,
-0.5215796232223511,
0.4429532289505005,
0.14659017324447632,
0.31133604049682617,
-0.6109951734542847,
-0.38312411308288574,
-0.16847890615463257,
0.1927838772535324,
0.00038664095336571336,
-0.8724231123924255,
0.16659168899059296,
0.06743048876523972,
0.03512566536664963,
-0.20760437846183777,
0.8341427445411682,
-0.29267486929893494,
-0.25372084975242615,
0.3256109356880188,
0.6903495788574219,
0.21567396819591522,
-0.46041256189346313,
-0.3992171883583069,
-0.19797170162200928,
0.16799260675907135,
-0.3196624517440796,
0.33421462774276733,
0.18026144802570343,
-0.13159318268299103,
0.9633377194404602,
0.887321412563324,
-0.22101172804832458,
0.004562863148748875,
-0.20475834608078003,
0.7326523065567017,
-0.8079876899719238,
-0.325490802526474,
-0.5480657815933228,
0.7106682658195496,
0.1576162725687027,
-0.1971079260110855,
0.3100339472293854,
0.576058566570282,
1.1349655389785767,
-0.21493999660015106,
0.41932427883148193,
0.25087931752204895,
0.3561192750930786,
-0.5867573618888855,
0.5621026158332825,
-0.6941418647766113,
0.0380854606628418,
-0.0030760271474719048,
-1.0361565351486206,
-0.6549647450447083,
0.8360755443572998,
-0.06743323802947998,
-0.24797238409519196,
0.3158167600631714,
0.8720295429229736,
-0.3980272710323334,
-0.2750256061553955,
0.6732906699180603,
-0.08786556869745255,
0.24055682122707367,
0.7442767024040222,
0.6335635781288147,
-0.12306434661149979,
1.081106424331665,
-0.24353158473968506,
-0.23683422803878784,
-0.4622493088245392,
-0.885267436504364,
-0.9306290745735168,
-0.1726684719324112,
-0.23760905861854553,
-0.09362951666116714,
0.24407674372196198,
0.7279647588729858,
0.8028661012649536,
-0.49881839752197266,
-0.27204805612564087,
-0.21417813003063202,
0.200361430644989,
-0.32730939984321594,
-0.2313438355922699,
-0.13566508889198303,
0.12751197814941406,
-0.38865482807159424,
0.9830690622329712,
0.767628014087677,
0.16997644305229187,
-0.4810672104358673,
-0.31882786750793457,
-0.4840121269226074,
0.22535736858844757,
0.512587308883667,
0.8262090682983398,
-0.8376933336257935,
-0.40961790084838867,
0.15262269973754883,
0.1313779056072235,
0.2842312157154083,
0.6906017661094666,
-1.3019214868545532,
0.8840005993843079,
0.252873957157135,
0.5463916659355164,
0.49441590905189514,
-0.1317942589521408,
0.5407110452651978,
-0.9962789416313171,
0.3229307234287262,
0.1802792102098465,
0.2774178087711334,
0.2661462426185608,
-0.022111639380455017,
0.8358299732208252,
0.20994940400123596,
-0.07889115065336227,
-0.7860845923423767,
0.4094875454902649,
-1.1668670177459717,
-0.5115996599197388,
0.7645818591117859,
-0.2506936490535736,
-0.45993271470069885,
-0.06278382241725922,
-0.23228538036346436,
0.04156842455267906,
-0.4557684659957886,
0.24285311996936798,
0.371062695980072,
0.020319130271673203,
-0.27856209874153137,
-0.5860032439231873,
0.0834583267569542,
-0.016063837334513664,
-0.6633997559547424,
-0.13226492702960968,
0.684901773929596,
0.11688023060560226,
0.17969107627868652,
0.5230304598808289,
0.0061408053152263165,
0.4779493808746338,
-0.024190839380025864,
0.10173644870519638,
-0.7276567220687866,
-0.8581122756004333,
-0.3702166676521301,
0.4625934362411499,
-0.35148268938064575,
-0.7781581878662109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10669v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10669v4 | Humans or LLMs as the Judge? A Study on Judgement Biases | 2024-02-16T13:21:06 | 2024-06-16T12:30:34 | Guiming Hardy Chen, Shunian Chen, Ziche Liu, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adopting human and large language models (LLM) as judges (a.k.a human- and
LLM-as-a-judge) for evaluating the performance of LLMs has recently gained
attention. Nonetheless, this approach concurrently introduces potential biases
from human and LLMs, questioning the reliability of the evaluation results. In
this paper, we propose a novel framework that is free from referencing
groundtruth annotations for investigating Misinformation Oversight Bias, Gender
Bias, Authority Bias and Beauty Bias on LLM and human judges. We curate a
dataset referring to the revised Bloom's Taxonomy and conduct thousands of
evaluations. Results show that human and LLM judges are vulnerable to
perturbations to various degrees, and that even the cutting-edge judges possess
considerable biases. We further exploit these biases to conduct attacks on LLM
judges. We hope that our work can notify the community of the bias and
vulnerability of human- and LLM-as-a-judge, as well as the urgency of
developing robust evaluation systems. | [
-0.2685920000076294,
-0.32099097967147827,
0.5590820908546448,
0.19491681456565857,
0.01629875786602497,
-0.012953056022524834,
-0.29421234130859375,
-0.5734584927558899,
0.009366778656840324,
0.7344855666160583,
-0.47768139839172363,
-0.4362432062625885,
-0.6577922105789185,
0.1724829524755478,
-0.3424689471721649,
0.8682550191879272,
0.36970072984695435,
0.5351881980895996,
-0.3861373960971832,
-0.13802680373191833,
-0.3830936849117279,
-0.7409830689430237,
-0.0634770616889,
-0.4122089445590973,
0.6954444646835327,
0.40755555033683777,
0.8562232851982117,
0.13762037456035614,
0.7424658536911011,
0.0950302705168724,
-0.2562463581562042,
-0.10145361721515656,
-0.32304802536964417,
-0.1014934629201889,
-0.7302945256233215,
-0.7551137804985046,
-0.4513304531574249,
0.5160508751869202,
0.26945170760154724,
0.7390682101249695,
-0.11079167574644089,
0.3648495674133301,
-0.14136815071105957,
0.7614209651947021,
-0.890592634677887,
-0.18552809953689575,
-0.8028678297996521,
0.21867233514785767,
-0.33610156178474426,
-0.1851610690355301,
-0.5335580110549927,
-0.3094058632850647,
0.0463281124830246,
-0.29735785722732544,
0.1693461686372757,
0.20545397698879242,
0.7340618371963501,
0.2272006720304489,
-0.42126062512397766,
-0.0946958065032959,
-0.6238594651222229,
0.8190523386001587,
-0.5522675514221191,
0.3010048270225525,
0.4634861946105957,
0.4207213819026947,
-0.10833021998405457,
-0.2909255921840668,
-0.49531444907188416,
-0.44955089688301086,
-0.23270829021930695,
0.15672768652439117,
-0.08652249723672867,
-0.12743604183197021,
0.2686540484428406,
0.46605366468429565,
-0.16844668984413147,
0.3026149570941925,
0.034562528133392334,
-0.1917746365070343,
0.8576825857162476,
-0.0003102171467617154,
0.19224093854427338,
-0.5171337127685547,
-0.4421577751636505,
-0.04701610282063484,
-0.7759989500045776,
-0.3201729953289032,
0.561336874961853,
0.5434121489524841,
0.12558023631572723,
0.5060398578643799,
-0.05519820749759674,
0.3866836130619049,
-0.11977919936180115,
-0.0690014511346817,
0.07583664357662201,
-0.010550115257501602,
-0.22078970074653625,
-0.2900175154209137,
0.818108320236206,
0.703736424446106,
0.4257807433605194,
-0.4002631604671478,
-0.3132816255092621,
0.32794812321662903,
0.5580771565437317,
-0.4190562963485718,
0.19742196798324585,
-0.06267476081848145,
-0.5288713574409485,
-0.844322681427002,
0.43438318371772766,
-1.2431859970092773,
-0.902890682220459,
-0.19348806142807007,
0.5063605904579163,
0.024447046220302582,
-0.23573821783065796,
-0.08674865961074829,
-0.06994001567363739,
0.38293641805648804,
0.4215903878211975,
-0.7267746329307556,
0.548439085483551,
0.6189923882484436,
0.34064099192619324,
-0.2123211920261383,
-0.2967487871646881,
-0.4659729599952698,
-0.1197783574461937,
-0.2849619388580322,
0.6304503083229065,
-0.566361665725708,
-0.5585209131240845,
0.0074012973345816135,
-0.22371359169483185,
0.09868228435516357,
-0.6592667102813721,
1.0362368822097778,
-0.6945710182189941,
0.0799952819943428,
-0.6188009977340698,
-0.2819204032421112,
-0.02744223363697529,
0.24407917261123657,
-0.6012917160987854,
0.8209996819496155,
0.03452380746603012,
-1.011689305305481,
0.7764265537261963,
-0.796085000038147,
-0.2339322566986084,
-0.0431777648627758,
-0.49685367941856384,
-0.35208064317703247,
0.08379373699426651,
0.4677758812904358,
0.16889405250549316,
-0.3850647807121277,
0.42880454659461975,
-0.5079408288002014,
-0.4037344753742218,
0.26649603247642517,
-0.5459641218185425,
0.7281319499015808,
0.22969160974025726,
-0.491430401802063,
0.29637542366981506,
-0.7063905596733093,
-0.2733469605445862,
0.18982939422130585,
-0.38307344913482666,
-0.1046038344502449,
0.31619879603385925,
0.3133990466594696,
0.10518548637628555,
-0.19821476936340332,
-0.31092891097068787,
0.07966851443052292,
-0.21641956269741058,
0.46419528126716614,
1.0670539140701294,
-0.059889789670705795,
0.3897720277309418,
-0.5072612166404724,
0.41502586007118225,
-0.06863803416490555,
0.1962815672159195,
-0.14951638877391815,
-0.27521759271621704,
-0.7205256819725037,
0.036051008850336075,
0.4385772943496704,
0.5024027824401855,
-0.19605976343154907,
0.38406333327293396,
-0.4194034934043884,
-0.616627037525177,
-0.49366697669029236,
0.15026789903640747,
0.2804916501045227,
0.3623197376728058,
0.12490807473659515,
-0.5623063445091248,
-0.4048800468444824,
-1.1103718280792236,
-1.010711431503296,
-0.40161603689193726,
-0.07572515308856964,
0.48023760318756104,
0.6800407767295837,
-0.34697672724723816,
1.3205180168151855,
-0.00013144810509402305,
-0.18359486758708954,
0.09861254692077637,
-0.026196034625172615,
0.07926326245069504,
0.43130114674568176,
0.7333418130874634,
-0.804108202457428,
0.19018931686878204,
-0.31560617685317993,
-0.6709378361701965,
-0.30913543701171875,
0.11713298410177231,
-0.40255358815193176,
0.04737177863717079,
0.1284080296754837,
-0.5416873693466187,
0.5983986854553223,
0.09984472393989563,
-0.577139139175415,
1.0191550254821777,
0.3468773663043976,
0.2240283489227295,
-0.6086347699165344,
0.13958203792572021,
0.19769741594791412,
-0.35064321756362915,
-0.3926744759082794,
0.4115079641342163,
-0.04607861861586571,
0.2677437663078308,
-0.3620314598083496,
0.5023443102836609,
-0.25117772817611694,
-0.3391243815422058,
-0.11298947781324387,
0.1784086972475052,
0.031972549855709076,
0.21130242943763733,
-0.10551774501800537,
0.49600404500961304,
0.257710725069046,
-0.5438287258148193,
0.2853223979473114,
0.2663690745830536,
-0.38703832030296326,
0.8680115342140198,
-0.17086070775985718,
0.3860096335411072,
-0.12845343351364136,
0.33060818910598755,
-0.631625235080719,
-0.42192181944847107,
0.41261324286460876,
-0.3661287724971771,
0.160060852766037,
-0.28922685980796814,
-0.7614971399307251,
-0.5875080227851868,
-0.4857126772403717,
0.09269071370363235,
0.23803313076496124,
-0.678112268447876,
0.5631815195083618,
0.33146369457244873,
0.18012289702892303,
-0.6147716641426086,
-0.7895317077636719,
0.4826352298259735,
-0.5133728981018066,
-0.6873847842216492,
0.15086360275745392,
0.014981408603489399,
-0.8832492828369141,
-0.2832677960395813,
-0.10427172482013702,
0.1825062334537506,
0.3819165527820587,
0.3894445300102234,
0.0703616812825203,
-0.010182521305978298,
0.1480511575937271,
-0.4872111678123474,
0.20605534315109253,
0.3095235526561737,
-0.08072818070650101,
0.28356894850730896,
-0.15886349976062775,
-0.8282151818275452,
-0.4426268935203552,
0.08648504316806793,
0.7101529240608215,
-0.14779651165008545,
0.4045807421207428,
0.22559992969036102,
-0.34552332758903503,
-0.0037564849480986595,
-0.9454371333122253,
-0.28753945231437683,
-0.36282265186309814,
0.35088610649108887,
-0.1894446164369583,
-0.7211301326751709,
0.2503339350223541,
0.014269416220486164,
0.19320587813854218,
0.6098446249961853,
0.8183781504631042,
-0.03671567142009735,
0.5266465544700623,
0.6841594576835632,
-0.49147093296051025,
0.3999461829662323,
0.10362192988395691,
-0.1810338944196701,
-0.7073746919631958,
-0.20941178500652313,
-0.5721404552459717,
-0.42351529002189636,
-0.4480075240135193,
-0.5012462139129639,
0.0066184988245368,
0.14717616140842438,
-0.3184526562690735,
-0.14461977779865265,
-0.3400115966796875,
0.3380758762359619,
0.5223548412322998,
0.18183648586273193,
0.5392584800720215,
-0.04237820580601692,
-0.3358777165412903,
-0.12924708425998688,
-0.3694799244403839,
-1.1937934160232544,
1.412057638168335,
0.6058059334754944,
0.8519580364227295,
0.18187084794044495,
0.4033990204334259,
0.6569769978523254,
0.6475653648376465,
-0.6544228792190552,
0.41065821051597595,
0.18581292033195496,
-0.8592246770858765,
-0.0009058584691956639,
-0.3088480532169342,
-0.4145868718624115,
0.7225779294967651,
-0.18806840479373932,
-0.9440586566925049,
0.34303081035614014,
-0.01648864336311817,
-0.2652565538883209,
0.4771312475204468,
-0.5630273818969727,
0.5814808011054993,
-0.6198881268501282,
-0.5586226582527161,
-0.15042202174663544,
-0.7615100741386414,
0.49080777168273926,
-0.04655034467577934,
0.644294798374176,
-0.26224812865257263,
0.19478976726531982,
0.8353544473648071,
-0.39341530203819275,
1.0410397052764893,
-0.3188598155975342,
-0.2336426079273224,
0.09975651651620865,
0.11158669739961624,
0.28425222635269165,
0.235369473695755,
-0.27895882725715637,
0.14644794166088104,
-0.27952811121940613,
-0.22489218413829803,
-0.4557417631149292,
0.42753925919532776,
-0.84379643201828,
-0.7340629696846008,
-0.6249833106994629,
-0.20836877822875977,
-0.6126683950424194,
-0.02304430864751339,
-0.01990538276731968,
-0.16906479001045227,
-0.38939061760902405,
-0.31147176027297974,
0.21865017712116241,
-0.07636581361293793,
0.13476994633674622,
0.7001951336860657,
-0.49048206210136414,
-0.4166284501552582,
0.37240102887153625,
-0.155779629945755,
0.11763990670442581,
0.19195856153964996,
0.13964644074440002,
0.023005411028862,
-0.40155932307243347,
-0.3467077314853668,
0.13943256437778473,
-0.7028886675834656,
-0.013602027669548988,
-0.30080604553222656,
-0.08096282929182053,
-0.179284930229187,
0.15418854355812073,
-0.26091113686561584,
-0.1757148951292038,
-0.42367419600486755,
-0.13889019191265106,
0.31484052538871765,
0.8373435139656067,
0.12364077568054199,
0.41898030042648315,
-0.32902291417121887,
0.18302810192108154,
0.45616066455841064,
0.5301811695098877,
0.021763306111097336,
-0.6016858220100403,
0.14596541225910187,
0.0791572630405426,
-0.5894132256507874,
-0.8895982503890991,
0.021834028884768486,
-0.056987106800079346,
0.7482017874717712,
0.7117716670036316,
-0.22224898636341095,
0.6036027073860168,
-0.6051338315010071,
0.7419885993003845,
0.03868098184466362,
-0.9260438084602356,
0.6657231450080872,
-0.32432347536087036,
-0.24356432259082794,
0.6987791061401367,
-0.015333937481045723,
-0.6702598333358765,
-0.3909966051578522,
-0.5468292832374573,
-0.6883189082145691,
1.0080925226211548,
0.19288593530654907,
0.12779036164283752,
0.1013757586479187,
0.5698128342628479,
0.2437160760164261,
0.4718768298625946,
-0.8989812731742859,
-0.07716947793960571,
0.006130648776888847,
0.2980465590953827,
-0.04594862461090088,
-0.6021668910980225,
-0.33044788241386414,
-0.18769513070583344,
0.5184980034828186,
-0.06356190145015717,
0.05264006182551384,
0.3565642535686493,
-0.4614066183567047,
-0.30035409331321716,
0.5368445515632629,
0.37066373229026794,
0.7650138139724731,
-0.29287996888160706,
0.23035915195941925,
0.12471704185009003,
-0.19822777807712555,
0.006594697013497353,
-0.30411213636398315,
-0.23659855127334595,
-0.20833539962768555,
0.5307970643043518,
0.7330390214920044,
0.36306849122047424,
-0.8415099382400513,
0.6229282021522522,
0.09368400275707245,
-0.14483670890331268,
-0.3261268138885498,
-0.16998498141765594,
0.14531442523002625,
0.23378391563892365,
0.4927557110786438,
0.3813364803791046,
0.026027262210845947,
-0.611146867275238,
0.3533368706703186,
0.4722197353839874,
-0.5361059904098511,
-0.3244383931159973,
0.8624135851860046,
0.2265302687883377,
-0.2451404482126236,
0.30798059701919556,
-0.0982329249382019,
-0.6018256545066833,
0.2456243485212326,
0.11271286010742188,
0.7475411295890808,
0.07975272834300995,
-0.088142991065979,
-0.09017135202884674,
0.5986692905426025,
-0.245645210146904,
0.07341497391462326,
0.030089860782027245,
-0.8823321461677551,
-0.09448911994695663,
-0.9284101128578186,
-0.5948286652565002,
-0.002131891902536154,
-0.6800854206085205,
0.39757317304611206,
-0.5164898633956909,
-0.519808828830719,
-0.17431548237800598,
-0.00038758089067414403,
-0.5829891562461853,
0.06963303685188293,
0.5734382271766663,
1.1986653804779053,
-0.7630460262298584,
0.2742319405078888,
0.7976173162460327,
-0.411045640707016,
-0.34429657459259033,
0.38398319482803345,
0.29842889308929443,
-0.6533781886100769,
0.7765326499938965,
0.2429107129573822,
-0.04828447848558426,
-0.5791308879852295,
-0.5937281250953674,
-0.5166872143745422,
1.0407564640045166,
0.6831591725349426,
-0.703157901763916,
-0.08861102163791656,
0.07362096756696701,
0.43989208340644836,
-0.36461567878723145,
0.5661776065826416,
0.9791191816329956,
0.7283002138137817,
-0.0227371659129858,
-1.1639291048049927,
-0.1956930309534073,
-0.2591782212257385,
0.15177232027053833,
-0.40781930088996887,
-0.9310713410377502,
0.6854044198989868,
-0.16315367817878723,
-0.07972662895917892,
0.05596930906176567,
0.5146109461784363,
0.337891161441803,
0.23218117654323578,
0.508053719997406,
0.7383536696434021,
0.8426277041435242,
-0.1665097326040268,
0.986995279788971,
-0.044975824654102325,
0.47562476992607117,
1.00898277759552,
-0.5565212368965149,
0.7021053433418274,
0.5653396248817444,
-0.7530808448791504,
0.4900769293308258,
0.7405082583427429,
-0.3102978765964508,
0.27656567096710205,
0.6799951791763306,
-0.11671040952205658,
-0.3206707537174225,
-0.04169773310422897,
-0.008398215286433697,
0.5128828883171082,
0.1844334751367569,
-0.5240895748138428,
-0.35331735014915466,
-0.19002777338027954,
0.1477181613445282,
0.4321609139442444,
-0.5388236045837402,
0.5002723932266235,
0.24272237718105316,
-0.3631064295768738,
0.01775675266981125,
0.42165178060531616,
1.061627984046936,
-0.1906522959470749,
0.2662602663040161,
0.007559105288237333,
-0.016462186351418495,
-0.5366611480712891,
-0.42733877897262573,
0.11873020976781845,
0.33551740646362305,
-0.35361358523368835,
-0.05848746374249458,
0.6835050582885742,
0.25966677069664,
-0.7595909237861633,
0.5266625881195068,
0.5939027070999146,
0.1611459106206894,
-0.28910407423973083,
-0.584185004234314,
-0.01270360592752695,
-0.20598500967025757,
-0.38832736015319824,
0.27152878046035767,
0.11039010435342789,
-0.425346702337265,
0.8311237096786499,
0.5192856192588806,
0.21249784529209137,
0.16533030569553375,
0.5777167677879333,
0.8000422120094299,
-0.9096795320510864,
-0.3437446057796478,
-1.191311240196228,
0.16132323443889618,
-0.07860977947711945,
0.004344416782259941,
0.6772003173828125,
0.5550258159637451,
0.5662815570831299,
0.09616050124168396,
0.8705582618713379,
0.12980450689792633,
0.6599658727645874,
-0.3298438489437103,
1.1361122131347656,
-0.45883849263191223,
0.526900589466095,
-0.5959809422492981,
-0.7443305850028992,
-0.29320308566093445,
0.5193142890930176,
-0.48813948035240173,
0.5018566846847534,
0.2306610345840454,
0.6404504776000977,
0.1474246382713318,
0.22567158937454224,
0.23452891409397125,
0.2455541342496872,
0.37656670808792114,
0.3008863627910614,
1.0461156368255615,
-0.20461268723011017,
0.28526052832603455,
-0.035827696323394775,
-0.166206955909729,
-0.5705960392951965,
-0.8141613602638245,
-0.9099686741828918,
0.18437722325325012,
-0.09635496884584427,
-0.10511381179094315,
-0.0048200939781963825,
0.9387190937995911,
0.6356340646743774,
-0.8164770007133484,
-0.3461751341819763,
0.05378681793808937,
0.23885685205459595,
0.04429146274924278,
-0.27870482206344604,
0.23632977902889252,
-0.2471269816160202,
-0.5769855976104736,
0.308578222990036,
0.15863142907619476,
-0.37040212750434875,
-0.5586324334144592,
-0.09154253453016281,
-0.01876591518521309,
0.041399892419576645,
0.4081123173236847,
-0.21131253242492676,
-1.14234459400177,
-0.46654659509658813,
-0.46720197796821594,
-0.09753461182117462,
0.182630255818367,
0.6536844372749329,
-0.8950368165969849,
0.3278379440307617,
-0.16700045764446259,
0.3943564295768738,
-0.006536864675581455,
0.2454279214143753,
0.4667360484600067,
-0.5751169919967651,
0.04937908425927162,
0.4378146231174469,
0.45662686228752136,
0.3814220130443573,
-0.18697725236415863,
0.44726645946502686,
0.5730288028717041,
-0.37883880734443665,
-1.0126755237579346,
0.2891857922077179,
-0.883787214756012,
-0.01188116054981947,
1.1865627765655518,
0.13068993389606476,
-0.21685689687728882,
0.23357784748077393,
-0.13607989251613617,
-0.17486010491847992,
-0.35786378383636475,
0.9100843667984009,
1.0846854448318481,
0.018027065321803093,
0.2000589221715927,
-0.7663881778717041,
0.2793167233467102,
0.4079882800579071,
-0.6891949772834778,
0.14541059732437134,
0.3374561667442322,
0.5928747653961182,
0.2839454114437103,
0.5233269333839417,
-0.5764672756195068,
0.26155924797058105,
-0.11524579674005508,
0.3533940315246582,
0.1779937595129013,
-0.043601542711257935,
-0.5016215443611145,
0.11478705704212189,
0.4147619903087616,
0.2645604908466339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10666v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10666v2 | Multi-Hop Table Retrieval for Open-Domain Text-to-SQL | 2024-02-16T13:14:35 | 2024-06-19T15:19:16 | Xuanliang Zhang, Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-domain text-to-SQL is an important task that retrieves question-relevant
tables from massive databases and then generates SQL. However, existing
retrieval methods that retrieve in a single hop do not pay attention to the
text-to-SQL challenge of schema linking, which is aligning the entities in the
question with table entities, reflected in two aspects: similar irrelevant
entity and domain mismatch entity. Therefore, we propose our method, the
multi-hop table retrieval with rewrite and beam search (Murre). To reduce the
effect of the similar irrelevant entity, our method focuses on unretrieved
entities at each hop and considers the low-ranked tables by beam search. To
alleviate the limitation of domain mismatch entity, Murre rewrites the question
based on retrieved tables in multiple hops, decreasing the domain gap with
relevant tables. We conduct experiments on SpiderUnion and BirdUnion+, reaching
new state-of-the-art results with an average improvement of 6.38%. | [
-0.24922943115234375,
-1.1429728269577026,
0.5902547836303711,
-0.006424219347536564,
-0.14403767883777618,
0.03932346776127815,
0.21426662802696228,
-0.4628235995769501,
0.5678257346153259,
0.526696503162384,
-0.4468923807144165,
-0.2699538767337799,
-0.4286820590496063,
0.08052680641412735,
-0.24828249216079712,
0.9818808436393738,
0.12098705768585205,
-0.1720917522907257,
-0.09912007302045822,
-0.31535160541534424,
-0.42311930656433105,
-0.4527870714664459,
-0.5019157528877258,
-0.06951815634965897,
0.6671510338783264,
0.5565182566642761,
0.899503231048584,
0.531093418598175,
0.8376359343528748,
0.16856780648231506,
-0.2178579419851303,
0.30711856484413147,
-0.4691672623157501,
0.28536781668663025,
-0.43964579701423645,
-0.15132059156894684,
-0.811464786529541,
-0.20135337114334106,
0.6670207381248474,
0.9194144606590271,
-0.08776048570871353,
0.08924556523561478,
-0.034072063863277435,
1.0145553350448608,
-0.7413910627365112,
0.06658408045768738,
-0.788265585899353,
0.04668324440717697,
-0.7276994585990906,
-0.6038103103637695,
-0.7158674001693726,
-0.35832616686820984,
0.05298401415348053,
-0.6595371961593628,
0.36102092266082764,
0.6218846440315247,
0.6106219291687012,
0.028427397832274437,
-0.9394851326942444,
-0.13080082833766937,
-0.7001874446868896,
0.3818623125553131,
-0.2834581434726715,
0.8233824372291565,
0.10110044479370117,
0.2577988803386688,
-0.5645728707313538,
-0.7868781089782715,
-0.43066301941871643,
-0.13344992697238922,
-0.39689019322395325,
0.020573092624545097,
-0.017061619088053703,
-0.1976633369922638,
0.2513912320137024,
0.2528280019760132,
-0.9466062188148499,
-0.4108591079711914,
-0.3080606162548065,
-0.25513404607772827,
0.49207621812820435,
0.1205017939209938,
-0.14336657524108887,
-0.0353529155254364,
-0.6044104099273682,
-0.141544371843338,
-0.7380568385124207,
-0.2327549010515213,
0.010554159991443157,
0.7224676609039307,
0.5395022630691528,
0.8036596775054932,
-0.3608866333961487,
0.7812007069587708,
-0.09335155040025711,
0.056495871394872665,
0.41739657521247864,
-0.5400506854057312,
-0.02144213393330574,
-0.023697378113865852,
0.6028913259506226,
0.024487050250172615,
-0.08732033520936966,
-0.44195982813835144,
0.16619135439395905,
-0.23343007266521454,
0.20599982142448425,
-0.5772569179534912,
-0.010707913897931576,
0.2312447726726532,
-0.6591510772705078,
0.09678508341312408,
0.023109324276447296,
-1.1397289037704468,
-0.2816910445690155,
0.08212211728096008,
0.6542119979858398,
-0.5664393305778503,
-0.3143426179885864,
-0.1629570722579956,
-0.21693478524684906,
0.13699981570243835,
0.4127494692802429,
-0.49579906463623047,
0.19708071649074554,
0.5859308242797852,
1.0236071348190308,
-0.3824761211872101,
-0.6780080199241638,
-0.948719322681427,
0.5340531468391418,
-0.2523784339427948,
0.8887868523597717,
-0.525191068649292,
-0.44386738538742065,
-0.09910466521978378,
-0.02546023763716221,
-0.3124682903289795,
-0.3728792369365692,
0.5924721360206604,
-0.8056581616401672,
0.13896729052066803,
-0.07753225415945053,
-0.649208664894104,
0.04785802960395813,
0.06173316016793251,
-0.8692516684532166,
0.7115430235862732,
0.022062961012125015,
-0.8831208348274231,
0.4363224506378174,
-0.8217423558235168,
-0.7239798307418823,
0.07742149382829666,
-0.10260003805160522,
-0.5939558744430542,
0.10749486088752747,
0.18619845807552338,
0.13464079797267914,
-0.23549818992614746,
0.053539786487817764,
-0.34019047021865845,
-0.3403306305408478,
-0.29781392216682434,
-0.17472432553768158,
0.6074916124343872,
0.22028830647468567,
-0.11088591814041138,
-0.049993887543678284,
-0.5572783946990967,
0.19592136144638062,
0.3622364401817322,
-0.6338509321212769,
-0.5262342691421509,
0.2567657232284546,
-0.15847115218639374,
0.13803301751613617,
-0.11638136208057404,
-0.6150593161582947,
0.46338021755218506,
-0.2937897741794586,
0.04518771544098854,
0.26624011993408203,
0.12329090386629105,
0.4897692799568176,
-0.43928518891334534,
0.18810681998729706,
0.1895407885313034,
0.03138919174671173,
-0.2334163784980774,
-0.6086112260818481,
-0.4651152789592743,
-0.07716811448335648,
-0.016245253384113312,
0.33829522132873535,
-0.7305437326431274,
-0.07602148503065109,
-0.39688795804977417,
-0.5224024653434753,
-0.5873250961303711,
-0.34280747175216675,
0.3125835359096527,
0.5649386048316956,
0.9095920920372009,
-0.15242710709571838,
-0.19262458384037018,
-0.6756945252418518,
-0.6745365262031555,
0.14723756909370422,
0.2242601066827774,
0.47869089245796204,
0.5519145131111145,
-0.04813738539814949,
0.7972317337989807,
-0.7590625882148743,
-0.7231935858726501,
0.169475719332695,
0.0006403591833077371,
0.22302544116973877,
0.47551608085632324,
0.4271155893802643,
-0.9016906023025513,
-0.680466890335083,
0.005813452415168285,
-0.5276086926460266,
0.4991675615310669,
0.11591919511556625,
-0.35825294256210327,
0.3257637917995453,
0.6041152477264404,
-0.8480423092842102,
0.5203474760055542,
0.14411406219005585,
-0.5105910301208496,
0.5284445881843567,
-0.05058685317635536,
0.644128143787384,
-0.9417627453804016,
0.31278523802757263,
-0.4629993438720703,
-0.1292937844991684,
-0.6983834505081177,
0.26397624611854553,
0.3041655421257019,
-0.43308258056640625,
-0.5547046065330505,
0.31848594546318054,
-0.6699369549751282,
-0.10370948165655136,
-0.01802315004169941,
0.5990742444992065,
0.13475704193115234,
0.4152003228664398,
0.057931866496801376,
0.9431759119033813,
0.47846728563308716,
-0.7777284979820251,
0.25083157420158386,
0.7263525128364563,
0.026869580149650574,
0.7282204627990723,
-0.40814799070358276,
0.35890552401542664,
-0.14905598759651184,
0.43089932203292847,
-0.9264760613441467,
-0.10831570625305176,
0.22631563246250153,
-0.5191489458084106,
0.34763675928115845,
-0.35511061549186707,
-0.2145785391330719,
-0.29451805353164673,
-0.3415678143501282,
0.5186668634414673,
-0.25894272327423096,
-0.6816681027412415,
0.6858931183815002,
0.2364571988582611,
0.04040927067399025,
-0.9441962838172913,
-0.5662295818328857,
0.05015246197581291,
-0.07071416825056076,
-0.6970954537391663,
0.7035285830497742,
0.04982653632760048,
0.12932226061820984,
-0.00016732355288695544,
-0.3347422182559967,
-0.1426190286874771,
-0.24484142661094666,
-0.08616214990615845,
0.25697052478790283,
-0.3564087152481079,
0.2828771471977234,
0.08138244599103928,
-0.24478685855865479,
-0.1915023922920227,
-0.3618461489677429,
0.6150887608528137,
-0.07123357057571411,
-0.5221152305603027,
-0.15444554388523102,
0.8318942189216614,
0.5821998715400696,
-0.7267233729362488,
0.9657769203186035,
0.16658280789852142,
-0.25979140400886536,
-0.06927528232336044,
-0.36876991391181946,
-0.2534131109714508,
-0.4041748642921448,
0.4222010672092438,
-0.8830826282501221,
-1.0255961418151855,
0.1947891265153885,
-0.28458118438720703,
0.08215630054473877,
0.5822440385818481,
0.1963498741388321,
-0.12241644412279129,
0.6544013023376465,
0.5804940462112427,
0.08432243019342422,
0.13329370319843292,
0.018616829067468643,
0.46859270334243774,
-0.8162180781364441,
-0.39770612120628357,
-1.077860951423645,
-0.032040830701589584,
-0.4480644166469574,
-0.4027027487754822,
0.28718051314353943,
-0.06119865924119949,
-0.301114946603775,
0.8362157344818115,
-0.5530909895896912,
0.460618793964386,
0.6037291884422302,
0.060588590800762177,
0.872826874256134,
0.022308915853500366,
-0.35100263357162476,
-0.050729215145111084,
-0.5527347326278687,
0.08118537068367004,
1.1243730783462524,
-0.2109314203262329,
0.9785958528518677,
0.53464275598526,
0.6354684233665466,
0.26757359504699707,
0.045989491045475006,
-0.5511690378189087,
0.3639322817325592,
0.13140124082565308,
-1.0795824527740479,
-0.5101359486579895,
-0.8291630148887634,
-1.0280587673187256,
0.6814707517623901,
-0.3108042776584625,
-0.735995352268219,
0.1409081369638443,
0.14150021970272064,
0.13106638193130493,
0.4039573073387146,
-0.5495441555976868,
0.9294329881668091,
-0.05289212614297867,
-0.30111414194107056,
-0.3106408417224884,
-0.8204036951065063,
0.38731080293655396,
-0.33349964022636414,
0.15209773182868958,
0.009298838675022125,
0.09660368412733078,
0.54958575963974,
-0.42203283309936523,
-0.0364045687019825,
-0.06358909606933594,
0.1603962928056717,
0.1907208263874054,
0.48702624440193176,
0.6895677447319031,
-0.017702016979455948,
-0.2240528166294098,
0.152786523103714,
-0.10812616348266602,
-0.22262130677700043,
-0.4648764133453369,
0.6656965613365173,
-0.2697829306125641,
-0.4935514032840729,
-0.693403959274292,
-0.47462907433509827,
-0.2611214220523834,
0.5487980842590332,
0.14982064068317413,
0.1699381023645401,
-0.20107510685920715,
0.40818077325820923,
0.383165568113327,
0.05950230732560158,
0.3058326244354248,
0.6511461734771729,
-0.3020777106285095,
-0.18686269223690033,
0.5608484148979187,
-0.0012168079847469926,
0.28873172402381897,
0.698928952217102,
-0.08444379270076752,
-0.5242258906364441,
-0.2815956175327301,
-0.49375298619270325,
0.43942269682884216,
-0.38631170988082886,
-0.6626105308532715,
-0.6613456010818481,
-0.04390124976634979,
-0.5217611193656921,
0.01703675091266632,
-0.5692344903945923,
-0.48981112241744995,
0.05786941945552826,
0.21102385222911835,
0.3448520302772522,
0.2508549094200134,
0.21006114780902863,
0.23355750739574432,
-0.9918765425682068,
0.24563825130462646,
-0.18456442654132843,
0.7733592987060547,
0.13255269825458527,
-0.5194602608680725,
-0.23342521488666534,
-0.17319822311401367,
-0.44629430770874023,
-1.1229890584945679,
-0.0397738516330719,
0.5826413035392761,
0.5805128216743469,
0.24085313081741333,
0.22885289788246155,
0.8967167735099792,
-0.9038599133491516,
0.2553110122680664,
0.19891133904457092,
-0.9396011829376221,
0.881926953792572,
-0.14102977514266968,
-0.186226487159729,
0.5620344281196594,
0.7725344896316528,
-0.564488410949707,
-0.2518073320388794,
-0.4330718517303467,
-0.8257666230201721,
0.9121310710906982,
0.5180047154426575,
-0.3547939956188202,
0.05068822205066681,
0.37353211641311646,
-0.0855257511138916,
0.1530442237854004,
-0.6662198305130005,
-0.57474285364151,
0.07209856808185577,
0.5116434097290039,
0.12367869913578033,
-0.06930933892726898,
0.06136494129896164,
0.16501390933990479,
0.6257672905921936,
-0.07343120127916336,
0.4630826413631439,
0.26600563526153564,
-0.14217166602611542,
-0.38638249039649963,
0.3166993260383606,
0.05351864546537399,
0.5979259610176086,
-0.4281054139137268,
-0.04229419678449631,
0.022216016426682472,
-0.34790438413619995,
0.10030240565538406,
0.16928386688232422,
-0.16572825610637665,
0.21112476289272308,
0.22666007280349731,
0.31971028447151184,
-0.19295237958431244,
-0.4175122380256653,
0.6222003698348999,
-0.007736604660749435,
-0.18793241679668427,
0.1626070886850357,
0.04234813526272774,
0.16764448583126068,
0.23076751828193665,
0.5063449144363403,
0.24196214973926544,
0.33857595920562744,
-0.5559558868408203,
0.689215362071991,
0.6569654941558838,
-0.3213769495487213,
0.21846523880958557,
1.0168101787567139,
0.08779506385326385,
-0.6225453615188599,
0.8340043425559998,
-0.08882603794336319,
-0.1241123303771019,
0.18239320814609528,
0.827678382396698,
0.4794389605522156,
-0.4607115685939789,
-0.006508507300168276,
0.42214491963386536,
0.40817990899086,
0.13519282639026642,
0.32309508323669434,
0.1364530473947525,
-0.4789874255657196,
-0.4328382611274719,
-0.38235700130462646,
-0.47702181339263916,
-0.21492427587509155,
-0.5136789679527283,
0.3233356177806854,
0.06247812882065773,
-0.18912243843078613,
0.14502424001693726,
-0.10672055929899216,
-0.20871257781982422,
-0.09106282889842987,
-0.43554311990737915,
1.0795038938522339,
-0.5747134685516357,
0.7903602719306946,
0.5483044385910034,
-0.7074618935585022,
-0.7726794481277466,
0.016426654532551765,
0.14759306609630585,
-0.2939154803752899,
0.2543337643146515,
-0.09983901679515839,
-0.26616722345352173,
0.04531098157167435,
-0.1198497861623764,
-1.1172488927841187,
1.0417271852493286,
0.17905117571353912,
-0.2780224680900574,
-0.09476857632398605,
0.18941840529441833,
0.22226950526237488,
-0.2348480224609375,
0.34795814752578735,
0.5398898124694824,
0.42612022161483765,
0.10614252090454102,
-1.0085182189941406,
0.06529676914215088,
-0.022571370005607605,
-0.12522010505199432,
0.7659435272216797,
-0.7004169225692749,
1.016233205795288,
-0.32171931862831116,
-0.2838655710220337,
-0.25862398743629456,
0.8739979863166809,
0.30276861786842346,
0.5474923849105835,
0.46403729915618896,
0.451339453458786,
0.6755667924880981,
-0.08210135251283646,
0.5387088060379028,
0.015633072704076767,
0.8415448069572449,
1.3176301717758179,
-0.6759219169616699,
1.0171502828598022,
0.6141396760940552,
-0.3309980034828186,
0.1341814398765564,
0.2460089474916458,
0.176408052444458,
0.6315916776657104,
0.02041984349489212,
0.038615066558122635,
0.10465334355831146,
0.12631358206272125,
-0.6197927594184875,
0.47137686610221863,
0.1498420685529709,
0.023289619013667107,
-0.7237840294837952,
-0.07275567203760147,
0.15775726735591888,
-0.09455461800098419,
-0.05149522051215172,
0.5794447064399719,
-0.10341141372919083,
-0.5284006595611572,
0.2848981022834778,
0.07328617572784424,
0.40677282214164734,
-0.6907824873924255,
-0.11675106734037399,
-0.5114935040473938,
0.2684953510761261,
-0.32692521810531616,
-0.5888617634773254,
0.6059712767601013,
-0.3075878918170929,
-0.05373600125312805,
0.2099539339542389,
0.6556223630905151,
-0.444888710975647,
0.05291172116994858,
0.6506443023681641,
0.835660457611084,
0.2956082820892334,
-0.5013840794563293,
-0.6149642467498779,
-0.1989833116531372,
0.06399808079004288,
-0.4204150438308716,
0.22566010057926178,
0.517919659614563,
0.03976645693182945,
0.685498058795929,
0.69511479139328,
-0.13252244889736176,
0.1590793877840042,
-0.10633552074432373,
0.947917640209198,
-0.7054725885391235,
-0.33883318305015564,
-0.6321461796760559,
0.251743346452713,
-0.029200850054621696,
-0.3083895146846771,
0.6837224960327148,
1.180993914604187,
0.8027448654174805,
-0.24913950264453888,
0.2482711523771286,
-0.32838138937950134,
0.8437362909317017,
-0.33853667974472046,
0.762721598148346,
-0.9773398041725159,
-0.04238343611359596,
-0.6251236796379089,
-1.3729326725006104,
-0.5319216251373291,
0.44749915599823,
0.38375648856163025,
-0.054294403642416,
1.2219502925872803,
0.9909117221832275,
-0.2958438992500305,
0.06720593571662903,
0.2250414490699768,
0.013722722418606281,
0.5036476254463196,
0.5799127221107483,
0.5658809542655945,
-0.7386091947555542,
1.0914217233657837,
0.09150290489196777,
-0.2085672914981842,
-0.5150877833366394,
-0.6812848448753357,
-0.46251413226127625,
-0.5790190696716309,
-0.2474208027124405,
-0.5386717319488525,
0.1303318589925766,
0.735053300857544,
0.4821299910545349,
-0.7623438239097595,
-0.1462126523256302,
0.24613580107688904,
0.21739396452903748,
-0.4558406174182892,
-0.18563023209571838,
0.8574004173278809,
-0.504788875579834,
-0.49423858523368835,
0.6017683148384094,
0.604069173336029,
-0.26514747738838196,
0.34905096888542175,
0.0952405110001564,
-0.863163411617279,
-0.11717000603675842,
0.6720108985900879,
0.08611219376325607,
-0.28891512751579285,
-0.4185909330844879,
0.17310312390327454,
-0.1812872588634491,
0.283647745847702,
0.960939347743988,
-0.6664851307868958,
0.1511823683977127,
0.3940989077091217,
0.6580715179443359,
0.7457168698310852,
0.13269631564617157,
-0.02741914801299572,
-0.7367568612098694,
-0.11086253821849823,
0.37616124749183655,
0.369650661945343,
-0.1495089828968048,
-0.3034929037094116,
0.8269568085670471,
0.4104265570640564,
-0.7801966071128845,
-0.4170033633708954,
0.36283424496650696,
-0.936865508556366,
-0.27686354517936707,
0.6689490675926208,
0.07247796654701233,
0.026413025334477425,
-0.29222622513771057,
-0.14677543938159943,
0.22438964247703552,
-0.2428743988275528,
0.4905797243118286,
0.3639821410179138,
-0.43379664421081543,
0.17131029069423676,
-0.3615432679653168,
0.44448015093803406,
0.4251540005207062,
-0.7403050661087036,
0.3368934392929077,
0.5708023905754089,
0.04163222759962082,
0.3683469593524933,
0.8829047083854675,
-0.24520444869995117,
0.19040663540363312,
0.24566669762134552,
-0.15854637324810028,
-0.020526140928268433,
-0.7569981813430786,
0.24061961472034454,
0.36111170053482056,
-0.15938052535057068,
-0.30848896503448486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10663v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10663v3 | Improving Demonstration Diversity by Human-Free Fusing for Text-to-SQL | 2024-02-16T13:13:18 | 2024-06-26T06:54:35 | Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Xuanliang Zhang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Currently, the in-context learning method based on large language models
(LLMs) has become the mainstream of text-to-SQL research. Previous works have
discussed how to select demonstrations related to the user question from a
human-labeled demonstration pool. However, human labeling suffers from the
limitations of insufficient diversity and high labeling overhead. Therefore, in
this paper, we discuss how to measure and improve the diversity of the
demonstrations for text-to-SQL. We present a metric to measure the diversity of
the demonstrations and analyze the insufficient of the existing labeled data by
experiments. Based on the above discovery, we propose fusing iteratively for
demonstrations (Fused) to build a high-diversity demonstration pool through
human-free multiple-iteration synthesis, improving diversity and lowering label
cost. Our method achieves an average improvement of 3.2% and 5.0% with and
without human labeling on several mainstream datasets, which proves the
effectiveness of Fused. | [
-0.6091143488883972,
-0.5729816555976868,
-0.03841790184378624,
0.3701576888561249,
-0.4020213484764099,
0.2617415189743042,
-0.29052793979644775,
-0.29591208696365356,
0.11193054169416428,
0.33101963996887207,
-0.593515932559967,
-0.7509853839874268,
-0.2667004466056824,
0.18077252805233002,
-0.833699643611908,
1.1101092100143433,
0.048603516072034836,
-0.23102062940597534,
-0.5499566793441772,
-0.3785131871700287,
-0.4635462164878845,
-0.19756823778152466,
-0.19455480575561523,
-0.2914882302284241,
0.24164564907550812,
0.7745712995529175,
0.43741530179977417,
0.47661834955215454,
-0.08248857408761978,
0.3309171497821808,
-0.10405901074409485,
0.42898663878440857,
-0.7371457815170288,
0.0365445539355278,
-0.37345072627067566,
-0.3918061852455139,
-0.03976985067129135,
-0.0074925911612808704,
0.9839499592781067,
0.7935190796852112,
0.06849661469459534,
-0.07069410383701324,
0.2592848539352417,
0.633387565612793,
-0.5512715578079224,
-0.34512656927108765,
-0.7326035499572754,
0.048249661922454834,
-0.13779965043067932,
0.11381131410598755,
-0.5744727849960327,
-0.2989793121814728,
0.019673755392432213,
-0.37946248054504395,
0.4717305898666382,
0.18829205632209778,
0.5405126810073853,
0.004929716233164072,
-0.5637940168380737,
0.18885958194732666,
-0.848933219909668,
1.2082525491714478,
-0.4162657558917999,
0.3783867359161377,
0.028164518997073174,
0.44147342443466187,
-0.28318873047828674,
-0.4634106457233429,
-0.6083277463912964,
-0.11587272584438324,
-0.15256166458129883,
0.07031510770320892,
-0.12398304045200348,
-0.2759571373462677,
0.15361475944519043,
0.4488230347633362,
-0.3720719516277313,
0.3042928874492645,
-0.21249963343143463,
-0.3227428197860718,
1.0493544340133667,
0.21520136296749115,
0.24351319670677185,
-0.10923624783754349,
-0.6250815391540527,
-0.38344722986221313,
-0.5359255075454712,
-0.10036609321832657,
0.19761234521865845,
0.22971726953983307,
-0.08138516545295715,
0.559863269329071,
-0.47488903999328613,
0.69417804479599,
-0.3307870030403137,
-0.029487404972314835,
0.25932905077934265,
-0.6759143471717834,
-0.3543972671031952,
-0.2662353217601776,
0.7721162438392639,
0.2277931272983551,
-0.4314921796321869,
-0.35177284479141235,
-0.07828447222709656,
0.037318192422389984,
-0.06582573801279068,
-0.773737907409668,
-0.13149990141391754,
0.2053040862083435,
-0.43956610560417175,
-0.027388181537389755,
0.11094647645950317,
-1.125970482826233,
-0.5233842134475708,
-0.0850597470998764,
0.4637914299964905,
-0.393665611743927,
-0.3506539463996887,
-0.20653128623962402,
-0.5377840995788574,
0.22933329641819,
0.39950302243232727,
-0.6399379372596741,
0.42362505197525024,
0.49832019209861755,
0.6624330878257751,
-0.7222108244895935,
-0.45265278220176697,
-0.3904936909675598,
0.256808340549469,
-0.15287476778030396,
0.9598714709281921,
-0.07887814939022064,
-0.7800405621528625,
-0.32399338483810425,
-0.1697116643190384,
-0.1558353453874588,
-0.7857120037078857,
0.29713577032089233,
0.012894777581095695,
0.5165941715240479,
-0.34490883350372314,
-0.9597128033638,
-0.09247181564569473,
0.12454237043857574,
-0.5039006471633911,
0.8843873739242554,
0.26622724533081055,
-0.4707595705986023,
0.5531942248344421,
-0.7299821376800537,
-0.5487655997276306,
0.1948375403881073,
-0.438952773809433,
-0.7209637761116028,
-0.10800047963857651,
0.4234217703342438,
0.17579303681850433,
-0.3166481852531433,
0.32516562938690186,
-0.1534470021724701,
-0.8083921074867249,
0.4327097535133362,
-0.2757232189178467,
0.8893130421638489,
0.09737115353345871,
-0.6526002883911133,
0.5131941437721252,
-0.7968227863311768,
-0.12721993029117584,
-0.0739334225654602,
-0.3443832993507385,
-0.05666152015328407,
0.22717250883579254,
-0.042335547506809235,
0.05765749514102936,
-0.36549806594848633,
-0.2928379476070404,
0.0930846706032753,
-0.7453150153160095,
-0.08176161348819733,
0.6174430251121521,
0.11051737517118454,
0.5303077101707458,
-0.5284336805343628,
0.33899766206741333,
-0.02533767931163311,
0.14098569750785828,
-0.1992933303117752,
-0.5997989177703857,
-0.9235942363739014,
-0.6118003726005554,
-0.00603890884667635,
0.2741057574748993,
-0.6968055367469788,
0.6943299770355225,
-0.13207857310771942,
-0.48961707949638367,
-0.3868088126182556,
0.4569075107574463,
0.2594935894012451,
0.49686965346336365,
0.44590190052986145,
-0.33175230026245117,
-0.4509313404560089,
-0.9497212171554565,
-0.519008219242096,
-0.05939207226037979,
-0.28772953152656555,
0.2819886803627014,
0.5198289155960083,
-0.30321264266967773,
1.1664137840270996,
-0.1797635406255722,
-0.39458712935447693,
-0.291969358921051,
0.2790777087211609,
0.07938297092914581,
0.4653351604938507,
0.48836225271224976,
-0.625249981880188,
-0.4093039631843567,
-0.061418987810611725,
-0.5255370140075684,
0.15615615248680115,
-0.10835476964712143,
-0.18012230098247528,
0.31001636385917664,
0.20906122028827667,
-0.020495349541306496,
0.4783218801021576,
0.45583322644233704,
-0.2808176279067993,
0.3539934456348419,
0.03811322897672653,
0.38999590277671814,
-1.0343971252441406,
-0.28774312138557434,
-0.06256821751594543,
0.11893410235643387,
-0.44769880175590515,
-0.09263230860233307,
0.05901950225234032,
-0.19354771077632904,
-0.5973547101020813,
0.531608521938324,
-0.5019122958183289,
-0.18274880945682526,
-0.13836170732975006,
0.3008435070514679,
-0.14103995263576508,
0.27316272258758545,
-0.143746018409729,
0.8901716470718384,
0.4854719638824463,
-0.6523447632789612,
0.43089330196380615,
0.3318628668785095,
-0.5549098253250122,
0.5943788886070251,
-0.2981717884540558,
0.04649481922388077,
-0.016989830881357193,
0.3972850739955902,
-1.464266300201416,
-0.4605744183063507,
-0.12353716045618057,
-0.1679868996143341,
-0.12698054313659668,
0.12873022258281708,
-0.39628440141677856,
-0.3768441081047058,
-0.6506500840187073,
0.11830418556928635,
0.8108252882957458,
-0.9762052893638611,
0.5392692685127258,
0.07811973989009857,
0.17691008746623993,
-0.38530564308166504,
-0.5155088305473328,
0.17940200865268707,
-0.3194565773010254,
-0.913486659526825,
0.5816206932067871,
-0.07479757815599442,
-0.12116378545761108,
-0.49099382758140564,
-0.06086558848619461,
-0.1570180058479309,
0.09759239107370377,
0.1802794486284256,
0.19656603038311005,
-0.1014469787478447,
0.4959395229816437,
0.46352094411849976,
0.18120722472667694,
-0.1775970458984375,
-0.06993651390075684,
0.2454833835363388,
-0.06674651801586151,
-0.6528940796852112,
-0.5635472536087036,
0.6749022603034973,
-0.00778220547363162,
-0.05272015556693077,
0.7385176420211792,
0.5564187169075012,
-0.1901405304670334,
-0.45335420966148376,
-0.5079296231269836,
-0.22670488059520721,
-0.5195400714874268,
0.48488810658454895,
0.06737253814935684,
-1.0930101871490479,
0.27049335837364197,
-0.4226313531398773,
0.35470736026763916,
0.4742787778377533,
0.5038101673126221,
-0.24595557153224945,
0.9494224786758423,
0.4147135317325592,
0.15624938905239105,
0.44652867317199707,
-0.15024825930595398,
-0.08165835589170456,
-0.3238484263420105,
-0.40394729375839233,
-0.8172720074653625,
-0.4870341718196869,
-0.14284326136112213,
-0.6084017157554626,
0.5331941843032837,
0.14646582305431366,
-0.16220854222774506,
0.1147504523396492,
-0.6104044318199158,
0.6988224387168884,
0.43126145005226135,
0.33554959297180176,
0.5273146033287048,
0.44328054785728455,
0.16946567595005035,
-0.25630974769592285,
-0.48579171299934387,
-0.3087496757507324,
0.8663681149482727,
0.07021734863519669,
0.7288840413093567,
0.2915286719799042,
0.9884728789329529,
0.16218622028827667,
0.6247907280921936,
-0.508890688419342,
0.7227086424827576,
-0.3047131896018982,
-0.4348694682121277,
-0.4505649507045746,
-0.5338470339775085,
-0.8823553323745728,
0.4823746383190155,
-0.4800499975681305,
-0.8940837979316711,
0.08765178918838501,
0.317465215921402,
0.18430186808109283,
0.16488634049892426,
-0.8282252550125122,
0.8400242924690247,
-0.28997913002967834,
-0.2727336287498474,
-0.32605382800102234,
-0.4703826308250427,
0.46889954805374146,
0.08993812650442123,
0.3079332113265991,
0.13606886565685272,
-0.02484431304037571,
1.016114354133606,
-0.4597873389720917,
1.004227638244629,
-0.13643254339694977,
-0.2706146538257599,
0.41246268153190613,
-0.1520027369260788,
0.3974723815917969,
-0.25388363003730774,
-0.1933489888906479,
-0.33055394887924194,
-0.7559356689453125,
-0.4676510989665985,
-0.610323429107666,
0.6930913925170898,
-0.5808895826339722,
-0.5716124176979065,
0.34917017817497253,
-0.573975145816803,
-0.5328759551048279,
-0.24251976609230042,
0.29223281145095825,
0.11945944279432297,
-0.40409016609191895,
0.4881993532180786,
0.7365138530731201,
-0.39966216683387756,
0.46779975295066833,
0.10649579018354416,
-0.28137293457984924,
-0.48604413866996765,
1.1026257276535034,
-0.12759333848953247,
0.4647093713283539,
0.2559014856815338,
0.3848873972892761,
-0.5364477634429932,
-0.4972945749759674,
-0.5700806975364685,
0.1518552601337433,
-0.8282143473625183,
-0.022833064198493958,
-0.7938816547393799,
0.16664007306098938,
-0.4381040036678314,
-0.14154267311096191,
-0.1355108767747879,
-0.6308737397193909,
-0.41375282406806946,
-0.09369940310716629,
0.536439061164856,
0.4427700340747833,
0.4402243494987488,
0.644989550113678,
-0.644245445728302,
0.22951695322990417,
0.7004666924476624,
0.42988452315330505,
0.03531341999769211,
-0.49815183877944946,
-0.03824397549033165,
-0.031743813306093216,
-0.5981661081314087,
-1.1291052103042603,
0.039686016738414764,
0.5145248770713806,
0.8103457689285278,
0.32403096556663513,
0.14433696866035461,
0.7762885689735413,
0.15531352162361145,
1.0434887409210205,
0.42725715041160583,
-1.2149587869644165,
0.8855744004249573,
-0.1706031858921051,
-0.04958515614271164,
0.3775990903377533,
0.2740248143672943,
-0.24952970445156097,
-0.6264402866363525,
-0.5457608103752136,
-1.0423449277877808,
0.6151049733161926,
0.23568060994148254,
0.08933737874031067,
0.18479104340076447,
-0.19051943719387054,
0.4021187424659729,
0.0032251006923615932,
-0.7348960638046265,
-0.24858374893665314,
-0.1587800681591034,
-0.13656195998191833,
-0.057998642325401306,
0.12306638807058334,
-0.38937029242515564,
-0.7201500535011292,
0.5890020728111267,
-0.2853485941886902,
-0.056321706622838974,
-0.15302494168281555,
-0.1676914244890213,
0.1783524453639984,
0.731726348400116,
0.4194609224796295,
0.5057677030563354,
0.1232711523771286,
-0.057097554206848145,
0.5806961059570312,
0.12675102055072784,
0.22740669548511505,
-0.035791657865047455,
-0.18612737953662872,
0.12578658759593964,
0.24605870246887207,
0.9411754012107849,
0.14371906220912933,
-0.8520581722259521,
0.6204982399940491,
0.06866708397865295,
-0.34841737151145935,
0.21112218499183655,
0.5777894854545593,
0.31117507815361023,
0.06624352931976318,
0.339732825756073,
-0.1741814762353897,
0.21183709800243378,
-0.4314643442630768,
0.4393652081489563,
0.5487735271453857,
-0.38178279995918274,
0.22980311512947083,
0.5328880548477173,
0.6047739386558533,
-0.33978697657585144,
0.7866987586021423,
-0.03599381819367409,
-0.25884678959846497,
0.6471486687660217,
0.7684787511825562,
0.6450904607772827,
-0.17801755666732788,
0.348125159740448,
0.36181458830833435,
0.18394577503204346,
-0.18059739470481873,
0.16363441944122314,
-0.31306397914886475,
-0.4831487834453583,
-0.2335190325975418,
-0.20696857571601868,
-0.5599156618118286,
-0.37146246433258057,
-0.4528140127658844,
0.5410664677619934,
-0.24901069700717926,
0.10404953360557556,
-0.09485124796628952,
-0.17176103591918945,
-0.25513920187950134,
0.16315989196300507,
-0.2522035837173462,
0.9419717788696289,
-1.174157738685608,
0.6564735770225525,
0.4614851474761963,
-0.2631344497203827,
-0.5749590396881104,
-0.25405699014663696,
-0.0661197081208229,
-0.3342840373516083,
0.2354596108198166,
0.29766330122947693,
0.07906272262334824,
-0.15150508284568787,
-0.7809881567955017,
-0.1993332803249359,
1.1346898078918457,
0.4565735161304474,
-0.47360944747924805,
0.3819580376148224,
0.12492218613624573,
0.4462326467037201,
-0.5936224460601807,
0.14117568731307983,
0.499212384223938,
0.36587926745414734,
0.26546698808670044,
-0.6275588870048523,
-0.07950837165117264,
-0.11862258613109589,
0.05470260977745056,
0.17192313075065613,
-0.4131501019001007,
0.8157640099525452,
-0.37816953659057617,
-0.38049426674842834,
0.15221203863620758,
0.910341739654541,
0.4796062409877777,
0.5571785569190979,
0.8129285573959351,
0.1592743992805481,
0.9602861404418945,
-0.14840833842754364,
1.0069375038146973,
0.6835580468177795,
0.4778667986392975,
1.0521818399429321,
-0.47768735885620117,
0.7402304410934448,
0.6246408820152283,
-0.4860045313835144,
0.7531387805938721,
0.28882867097854614,
-0.22390039265155792,
0.09222271293401718,
0.4065499007701874,
-0.6771894097328186,
-0.47589021921157837,
-0.04667225852608681,
-0.33697596192359924,
0.17131182551383972,
0.2945531904697418,
-0.39354178309440613,
-0.3505769968032837,
0.19422830641269684,
-0.3751775920391083,
0.40615561604499817,
0.07850281894207001,
1.0287078619003296,
-0.30658844113349915,
-0.6092473268508911,
0.8276685476303101,
-0.16366823017597198,
0.9405761957168579,
-0.41434067487716675,
-0.08136538416147232,
-0.3448048532009125,
0.055922023952007294,
-0.42982348799705505,
-0.7574673891067505,
0.28973957896232605,
-0.0055818380787968636,
-0.13893640041351318,
-0.0653003677725792,
0.6097773313522339,
-0.6100538969039917,
-0.30121758580207825,
0.28803685307502747,
0.33729881048202515,
0.3617106080055237,
0.07140035182237625,
-0.3379937410354614,
0.011255921795964241,
0.3600699007511139,
0.14852799475193024,
0.5589787364006042,
0.010201930068433285,
-0.4142822027206421,
0.5229537487030029,
0.4363073706626892,
-0.346428781747818,
0.1258944422006607,
0.3326752483844757,
0.9166746139526367,
-0.7151088118553162,
-0.4534410238265991,
-0.8808989524841309,
0.706544041633606,
-0.6621474623680115,
-0.1140030100941658,
0.7366445064544678,
0.7679018974304199,
0.7503682374954224,
-0.15101534128189087,
0.6999890804290771,
0.06008913740515709,
0.7004019021987915,
-0.16567058861255646,
0.7190489172935486,
-0.7072707414627075,
0.415962815284729,
-0.3242139220237732,
-0.8309445977210999,
-0.18185828626155853,
0.3733392655849457,
0.40886789560317993,
0.030634630471467972,
0.569490909576416,
0.8706061840057373,
-0.1102266013622284,
0.4676823914051056,
0.2369082123041153,
0.012494469061493874,
0.45133429765701294,
0.5926187634468079,
0.9331949949264526,
-0.4414328336715698,
0.8534125089645386,
-0.30026060342788696,
-0.6986647844314575,
-0.026585860177874565,
-1.0083264112472534,
-0.9828889966011047,
-0.46566978096961975,
-0.5523861050605774,
-0.39040476083755493,
-0.18143659830093384,
0.957082211971283,
0.6629810929298401,
-0.8670601844787598,
-0.6686984896659851,
0.12314199656248093,
0.4176511764526367,
-0.5598949790000916,
-0.23149473965168,
0.23306256532669067,
-0.26977109909057617,
-0.6054076552391052,
0.5902766585350037,
0.16252869367599487,
0.15187324583530426,
-0.08027259260416031,
-0.0907629206776619,
-0.06653992086648941,
-0.16868531703948975,
0.7092936038970947,
0.21384282410144806,
-0.594793438911438,
-0.1284908950328827,
-0.1998448669910431,
0.16473527252674103,
0.15416280925273895,
0.8471676111221313,
-0.8593952655792236,
0.3725678324699402,
0.48796895146369934,
0.834951639175415,
0.5477304458618164,
0.05260194465517998,
0.5781312584877014,
-1.393046259880066,
0.11589384824037552,
0.14579173922538757,
0.1785990595817566,
0.4384549856185913,
-0.15388339757919312,
0.3995814621448517,
0.4987827241420746,
-0.2800678014755249,
-0.6958662271499634,
0.2977403998374939,
-0.9920046329498291,
-0.35133102536201477,
1.0060758590698242,
0.08902596682310104,
-0.0679236575961113,
-0.26212361454963684,
-0.4029894173145294,
0.24204444885253906,
-0.28932154178619385,
0.9034915566444397,
0.34732821583747864,
-0.41374170780181885,
-0.1448114663362503,
0.19601629674434662,
0.3042096495628357,
0.49322208762168884,
-1.3882017135620117,
0.28214365243911743,
0.6615554690361023,
0.21308627724647522,
-0.08139856159687042,
0.5879179239273071,
-0.14427293837070465,
0.3408649265766144,
-0.16256600618362427,
-0.03026803769171238,
0.18201473355293274,
-0.11020848155021667,
-0.24922235310077667,
0.32450801134109497,
-0.1388445943593979,
-0.09450741857290268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10662v1 | Fine Tuning Named Entity Extraction Models for the Fantasy Domain | 2024-02-16T13:11:13 | 2024-02-16T13:11:13 | Aravinth Sivaganeshan, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a sequence classification Natural Language
Processing task where entities are identified in the text and classified into
predefined categories. It acts as a foundation for most information extraction
systems. Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) is an open-ended tabletop fantasy game with
its own diverse lore. DnD entities are domain-specific and are thus
unrecognizable by even the state-of-the-art off-the-shelf NER systems as the
NER systems are trained on general data for pre-defined categories such as:
person (PERS), location (LOC), organization (ORG), and miscellaneous (MISC).
For meaningful extraction of information from fantasy text, the entities need
to be classified into domain-specific entity categories as well as the models
be fine-tuned on a domain-relevant corpus. This work uses available lore of
monsters in the D&D domain to fine-tune Trankit, which is a prolific NER
framework that uses a pre-trained model for NER. Upon this training, the system
acquires the ability to extract monster names from relevant domain documents
under a novel NER tag. This work compares the accuracy of the monster name
identification against; the zero-shot Trankit model and two FLAIR models. The
fine-tuned Trankit model achieves an 87.86% F1 score surpassing all the other
considered models. | [
-0.7288859486579895,
-0.7443779706954956,
0.2591759264469147,
-0.22960782051086426,
-0.16035737097263336,
0.14597029983997345,
-0.10797684639692307,
-0.9123511910438538,
0.2555374205112457,
0.8594338893890381,
-0.7258293628692627,
-0.4847237169742584,
-0.5076262950897217,
0.6297100782394409,
-0.24986028671264648,
1.2916717529296875,
0.0655658096075058,
-0.17250828444957733,
0.005139607470482588,
-0.012774931266903877,
-0.5465851426124573,
-0.3312104642391205,
-1.0676969289779663,
-0.23433193564414978,
0.6249750852584839,
0.12364319711923599,
0.6009947061538696,
0.9551647901535034,
0.9269872307777405,
0.24374555051326752,
-0.1629960536956787,
0.4917038381099701,
-0.8213803768157959,
0.3317331075668335,
-0.6067872047424316,
0.013901902362704277,
-0.7063237428665161,
-0.3078118562698364,
0.4412138760089874,
0.30004578828811646,
-0.09244666993618011,
0.2032431960105896,
0.14362689852714539,
0.29604968428611755,
-0.6374779939651489,
0.023131640627980232,
-0.7349922060966492,
0.08458023518323898,
-0.29951179027557373,
-0.35599470138549805,
-0.25358039140701294,
-0.47342607378959656,
0.45644235610961914,
-1.0382996797561646,
0.5884102582931519,
0.18072672188282013,
1.258150339126587,
0.23545657098293304,
-0.20896074175834656,
-0.32990702986717224,
-0.9533241391181946,
0.7985616326332092,
-0.7034680843353271,
0.46579039096832275,
0.3419409990310669,
0.4462468922138214,
-0.2523868978023529,
-0.6881090998649597,
-0.8294225335121155,
0.031105399131774902,
-0.18753860890865326,
-0.33439722657203674,
-0.2960989773273468,
0.11242450028657913,
0.5941635370254517,
0.349017471075058,
-0.44054821133613586,
0.28947246074676514,
-0.4231896996498108,
-0.1691720336675644,
0.8602744340896606,
0.5032746195793152,
0.3979032635688782,
-0.13006342947483063,
-0.3450183570384979,
-0.21854981780052185,
-0.7029957175254822,
-0.20297487080097198,
0.4478432834148407,
0.3944344222545624,
0.2295452356338501,
0.4980982840061188,
-0.21797046065330505,
0.8364231586456299,
0.6650286912918091,
-0.6001042723655701,
0.13035094738006592,
0.0905173197388649,
-0.39937159419059753,
0.24572229385375977,
0.5579224824905396,
0.399728000164032,
0.31863898038864136,
-0.4801563620567322,
-0.6146409511566162,
-0.04296749830245972,
0.4608500003814697,
-0.9610938429832458,
-0.36522814631462097,
-0.11498936265707016,
-0.6265465617179871,
-0.36164355278015137,
-0.08165957778692245,
-1.099600911140442,
-0.7077202200889587,
-0.47525134682655334,
0.6514649987220764,
-0.5754199028015137,
-0.4802618622779846,
0.12202637642621994,
-0.17800453305244446,
0.3062025010585785,
0.5488177537918091,
-0.9103515148162842,
0.37361857295036316,
0.8516006469726562,
0.6396430730819702,
-0.6255814433097839,
-0.09000170230865479,
-0.4471290111541748,
0.24285346269607544,
-0.22443245351314545,
0.985504150390625,
-0.7234643697738647,
-0.5412371754646301,
-0.3804472088813782,
0.3851221203804016,
-0.05106151103973389,
-0.7554616332054138,
0.6868725419044495,
-0.8178285360336304,
0.05412222817540169,
-0.048260197043418884,
-0.7337599992752075,
-0.5405144095420837,
0.4137733578681946,
-1.0339399576187134,
0.5764533281326294,
0.023877624422311783,
-0.7831025123596191,
0.5409839749336243,
-0.49583110213279724,
-0.34626150131225586,
0.45386451482772827,
0.04692130163311958,
-0.17113614082336426,
0.20168128609657288,
0.10281436890363693,
0.4658573269844055,
-0.6036323308944702,
0.20399132370948792,
-0.2868354618549347,
-0.30211731791496277,
0.10914984345436096,
-0.23225250840187073,
0.5080698132514954,
0.20317992568016052,
-0.16857390105724335,
-0.3490664064884186,
-0.8269405961036682,
0.2909311056137085,
-0.1088966578245163,
-0.121683269739151,
-0.8152164220809937,
0.03550782427191734,
0.0679553747177124,
0.12556932866573334,
-0.1547347605228424,
-0.4708864390850067,
0.28990691900253296,
-0.5686668753623962,
-0.04610362648963928,
0.4898189306259155,
0.2874598801136017,
0.44503992795944214,
-0.26657429337501526,
0.6308631300926208,
-0.12405240535736084,
-0.11052772402763367,
0.08664321154356003,
-0.1798986941576004,
-0.6343703269958496,
-0.49167802929878235,
0.651909351348877,
0.3876124918460846,
-1.0701560974121094,
0.40829190611839294,
-0.47153520584106445,
-0.7002259492874146,
-0.5912445187568665,
-0.3250272274017334,
0.3018265664577484,
0.7095420956611633,
0.3919755816459656,
-0.3159565329551697,
-0.5407681465148926,
-0.843967854976654,
-0.3473133444786072,
0.05941310524940491,
-0.0001433964935131371,
0.42807912826538086,
0.44659414887428284,
-0.4250653088092804,
1.1234241724014282,
-0.6886369585990906,
-0.3805544078350067,
-0.21497441828250885,
0.16866035759449005,
0.3711434602737427,
0.5180838704109192,
0.42804351449012756,
-1.0227159261703491,
-0.5437077879905701,
0.3550349771976471,
-0.561478853225708,
0.009087088517844677,
0.06646737456321716,
-0.08048567920923233,
-0.16286543011665344,
0.16175125539302826,
-0.5391092896461487,
0.6105237007141113,
0.17440229654312134,
-0.23987770080566406,
0.6069096922874451,
0.02950764261186123,
0.32345151901245117,
-1.0706347227096558,
0.23056884109973907,
0.1369331330060959,
-0.18601953983306885,
-0.7808130979537964,
-0.03855982795357704,
-0.11494718492031097,
0.08397849649190903,
-0.3476104736328125,
0.9984059929847717,
-0.7151563763618469,
0.2424522489309311,
-0.33095410466194153,
-0.13683108985424042,
0.07267281413078308,
0.23799310624599457,
0.36353829503059387,
0.6887500286102295,
0.5674660801887512,
-1.2572206258773804,
0.5096436738967896,
0.10676378011703491,
-0.3523005545139313,
0.9917100667953491,
-0.6864068508148193,
0.3152957856655121,
-0.04224148392677307,
-0.1753256469964981,
-0.3173016905784607,
-0.34001755714416504,
0.2962324023246765,
-0.3292379379272461,
0.7417929172515869,
-0.3152472972869873,
-0.26240524649620056,
-0.18378622829914093,
0.13689230382442474,
0.4142776131629944,
0.32784947752952576,
-0.6425840258598328,
0.6795167922973633,
0.7776243686676025,
0.0416048988699913,
-0.6626724004745483,
-0.1778261959552765,
-0.0529024675488472,
-0.5257638096809387,
-0.24121783673763275,
0.733100950717926,
0.0857888013124466,
-0.2210538238286972,
0.19871050119400024,
-0.22587454319000244,
-0.5715469121932983,
-0.02497836947441101,
0.15892226994037628,
0.24675750732421875,
-0.37904345989227295,
0.005629128310829401,
0.04689431190490723,
-0.24156087636947632,
-0.20259657502174377,
-0.10841046273708344,
0.28584715723991394,
0.23160819709300995,
-0.08006533980369568,
-0.5182615518569946,
0.0558612160384655,
0.48671355843544006,
-0.15872392058372498,
0.5293439030647278,
0.41101476550102234,
-0.8225897550582886,
-0.5842597484588623,
-0.6276002526283264,
-0.25892314314842224,
-0.4509824216365814,
0.36028891801834106,
-0.6447888016700745,
-0.8271774649620056,
0.5058720707893372,
-0.2762996256351471,
0.007942941039800644,
0.8893253207206726,
0.0568217895925045,
0.11775364726781845,
0.9429454207420349,
0.9646586179733276,
0.09724702686071396,
0.08681673556566238,
-0.28183671832084656,
0.2398471236228943,
-0.8513361811637878,
-0.3533198833465576,
-0.6501527428627014,
-0.6023856401443481,
-0.725658655166626,
-0.2518494427204132,
0.07116378843784332,
0.19241264462471008,
0.018509648740291595,
0.7660502195358276,
-0.6549601554870605,
0.8415091633796692,
0.14903350174427032,
-0.14128661155700684,
0.28934445977211,
0.26663216948509216,
0.06406601518392563,
-0.32251057028770447,
-0.11578097939491272,
-0.6293511390686035,
0.7530786395072937,
0.17197257280349731,
1.071329116821289,
0.13286277651786804,
0.7037809491157532,
0.4328915774822235,
0.12265980243682861,
-0.7642513513565063,
0.4076225757598877,
-0.37420782446861267,
-0.863549530506134,
-0.31432899832725525,
-0.42695489525794983,
-0.894910454750061,
-0.006516966503113508,
-0.40066802501678467,
-0.8722435832023621,
0.7295442819595337,
-0.10322616994380951,
-0.673613965511322,
0.6010235548019409,
-0.2665775716304779,
0.7042240500450134,
0.05034889280796051,
-0.14632967114448547,
-0.004200262017548084,
-0.40058138966560364,
0.2976689338684082,
-0.2693592309951782,
-0.24693793058395386,
-0.10575618594884872,
0.0671100839972496,
0.6938692331314087,
-0.117652527987957,
0.49514126777648926,
0.036365095525979996,
-0.2709413766860962,
0.22180621325969696,
0.5597222447395325,
0.5087618827819824,
0.13738207519054413,
-0.26501137018203735,
0.414045125246048,
0.22750334441661835,
0.3120790421962738,
-0.6249914765357971,
0.7342103719711304,
-0.6494191288948059,
-0.2715074121952057,
-0.40957459807395935,
-0.14098121225833893,
-0.12179024517536163,
0.3586336076259613,
0.5901557207107544,
0.6193642020225525,
-0.5454798340797424,
0.10642006993293762,
1.129347324371338,
-0.18573051691055298,
0.31777283549308777,
0.6696539521217346,
-0.07634942978620529,
-0.6128770112991333,
1.0098192691802979,
0.07783888280391693,
-0.028026824817061424,
0.6273194551467896,
-0.3064366281032562,
-0.2759037911891937,
-0.33394479751586914,
-0.5406611561775208,
0.2787398397922516,
-0.4813229739665985,
-0.6616063117980957,
-0.9573980569839478,
-0.6402230858802795,
-0.25924596190452576,
0.051927600055933,
-0.16756406426429749,
-0.3130071759223938,
-0.691761314868927,
-0.027579069137573242,
0.4002484679222107,
0.9524205327033997,
0.02283579669892788,
0.37686827778816223,
-0.9554750323295593,
0.49317076802253723,
0.11896619945764542,
0.4051755368709564,
-0.006669874768704176,
-0.6419910788536072,
0.06284690648317337,
0.004275023937225342,
-0.1444271206855774,
-1.1228845119476318,
0.8515086770057678,
0.35925573110580444,
0.5423685908317566,
0.6184127926826477,
-0.003494111355394125,
1.1443911790847778,
-0.5483020544052124,
0.40726497769355774,
0.1346670389175415,
-0.6872738003730774,
0.40664753317832947,
-0.18962937593460083,
-0.259059876203537,
0.6937815546989441,
0.47606346011161804,
-0.7498712539672852,
0.09675788879394531,
-0.6449839472770691,
-0.4300838112831116,
1.1092959642410278,
-0.007830231450498104,
0.0578257218003273,
-0.014115279540419579,
0.71974778175354,
0.7154207825660706,
0.2488568276166916,
-0.581123948097229,
-0.2604139447212219,
0.389037549495697,
-0.0772121250629425,
-0.05968427285552025,
-0.33955225348472595,
0.3315403461456299,
-0.3016298711299896,
0.7599824666976929,
0.11335349082946777,
0.09969107061624527,
0.12072296440601349,
-0.09497092664241791,
-0.21243934333324432,
0.059345826506614685,
0.19649891555309296,
0.5429904460906982,
-0.00252451840788126,
0.056976381689310074,
0.31133750081062317,
-0.840478777885437,
0.051523156464099884,
0.04368164762854576,
-0.4867759048938751,
0.30596429109573364,
0.23224754631519318,
0.9151952266693115,
0.04818417876958847,
-0.33707597851753235,
0.2217860221862793,
-0.2764970660209656,
-0.004192122723907232,
-0.010082349181175232,
0.4254545271396637,
-0.5117775797843933,
0.2537895441055298,
0.23710130155086517,
0.20818376541137695,
0.47521719336509705,
-0.07408840209245682,
0.1755453646183014,
0.3406181037425995,
-0.5406431555747986,
-0.5758258104324341,
0.375625878572464,
0.15187472105026245,
-0.49428144097328186,
0.7101848721504211,
-0.5219437479972839,
-0.39929720759391785,
0.7137281894683838,
0.7704948782920837,
1.3486050367355347,
-0.32216551899909973,
0.3422437310218811,
0.7401138544082642,
0.37749868631362915,
-0.23001344501972198,
0.12566812336444855,
0.1125035360455513,
-0.6872007846832275,
-0.26374751329421997,
-1.070707082748413,
-0.14208021759986877,
0.3674052059650421,
-0.5761663317680359,
0.6628342270851135,
-0.3109114170074463,
-0.3877464234828949,
0.16430117189884186,
0.2093140184879303,
-0.9526177644729614,
0.35018420219421387,
0.08013279736042023,
0.7653872966766357,
-0.4913177490234375,
0.6650561094284058,
0.7921541333198547,
-0.13002289831638336,
-1.0053571462631226,
0.030464980751276016,
-0.10509324818849564,
-0.2634675204753876,
0.8517353534698486,
0.0956275686621666,
-0.0979209691286087,
0.3811337947845459,
-0.5220147967338562,
-1.223129391670227,
0.9731997847557068,
0.23383240401744843,
-0.8374783396720886,
-0.2520742416381836,
-0.15773983299732208,
0.6486562490463257,
-0.4660470187664032,
0.2353903204202652,
0.42890599370002747,
0.40285617113113403,
0.1556941121816635,
-1.1037471294403076,
-0.14839844405651093,
-0.1426796019077301,
0.08502322435379028,
0.4675034284591675,
-0.02627534046769142,
0.8417211174964905,
-0.20820818841457367,
-0.6240500807762146,
-0.01063940953463316,
0.6791811585426331,
0.09286375343799591,
0.41916823387145996,
0.6046987771987915,
0.7248361706733704,
0.8803281784057617,
-0.21021056175231934,
0.7948375344276428,
-0.05059720575809479,
0.349068284034729,
1.1337709426879883,
-0.5522842407226562,
0.584230363368988,
0.07478555291891098,
0.12456817924976349,
0.5280787348747253,
0.7321762442588806,
-0.24804456532001495,
0.8624792695045471,
0.10926542431116104,
-0.176921084523201,
-0.28129738569259644,
-0.31402087211608887,
-0.5208175778388977,
0.5402199625968933,
0.38690438866615295,
-0.24041961133480072,
-0.16050785779953003,
-0.008530523627996445,
-0.037872180342674255,
-0.2634596824645996,
-0.5044601559638977,
1.2232458591461182,
0.03835207223892212,
-0.6850780844688416,
0.26977360248565674,
0.1634964793920517,
0.7159438729286194,
-0.5031871199607849,
-0.31019312143325806,
-0.10552285611629486,
0.3625158667564392,
-0.2744351029396057,
-0.43968865275382996,
0.2891463339328766,
0.29537543654441833,
-0.4009668231010437,
0.013155573047697544,
1.1215070486068726,
-0.38783663511276245,
-0.48360729217529297,
0.19635753333568573,
0.5299531817436218,
0.16257089376449585,
0.018684010952711105,
-0.5399620532989502,
-0.21286411583423615,
-0.1406305581331253,
0.03238315507769585,
0.14588294923305511,
1.09726083278656,
-0.04561780393123627,
0.4243454039096832,
0.5974047780036926,
0.28938397765159607,
-0.1863701194524765,
-0.2376440316438675,
0.7596076726913452,
-0.6550186276435852,
-0.5024798512458801,
-1.063007116317749,
0.07414398342370987,
-0.2825530469417572,
-0.5636112093925476,
0.7561371326446533,
0.569922149181366,
0.8578194379806519,
-0.1937553584575653,
0.35452836751937866,
-0.323318213224411,
0.6979246735572815,
-0.2363450527191162,
0.9664394855499268,
-0.5633367300033569,
0.024157971143722534,
-0.5070832371711731,
-1.2253227233886719,
-0.14809301495552063,
0.5453162789344788,
-0.12108948826789856,
-0.040199365466833115,
0.512124240398407,
0.8521866202354431,
-0.22916853427886963,
0.17037449777126312,
0.2915726900100708,
0.062213294208049774,
0.0880846306681633,
0.30327537655830383,
0.9384961128234863,
-0.28908246755599976,
0.17091034352779388,
-0.3142158091068268,
0.06176670268177986,
-0.07999657094478607,
-0.9846584796905518,
-0.9102239012718201,
-0.5094968676567078,
-0.5301669836044312,
-0.29183414578437805,
0.18670149147510529,
0.6778579950332642,
0.7625340819358826,
-1.0311858654022217,
-0.03086169622838497,
0.26850876212120056,
0.20845045149326324,
-0.34511059522628784,
-0.2984656095504761,
0.24745038151741028,
0.009776935912668705,
-0.686950147151947,
0.23284141719341278,
0.27531173825263977,
0.12408130615949631,
0.034850385040044785,
-0.11797170341014862,
0.06481080502271652,
-0.02933044731616974,
0.3046696186065674,
0.32812896370887756,
-0.6270797848701477,
-0.28962472081184387,
0.3264511823654175,
-0.22042977809906006,
-0.19285978376865387,
0.6380807757377625,
-0.9285314083099365,
0.5107553005218506,
0.5187936425209045,
0.624686598777771,
0.14430631697177887,
-0.00756790628656745,
0.5436195731163025,
-0.5010029673576355,
-0.37827423214912415,
0.48741018772125244,
0.0016975917387753725,
0.3195587992668152,
-0.6141667366027832,
0.6372495889663696,
0.2501092553138733,
-0.46394798159599304,
-0.9801247715950012,
-0.17072339355945587,
-0.6769726276397705,
-0.044720690697431564,
1.1623549461364746,
0.12928856909275055,
-0.2785235047340393,
-0.21153287589550018,
-0.2238718867301941,
0.279951810836792,
-0.15557344257831573,
0.6243134140968323,
0.581355631351471,
0.11107397079467773,
0.17921753227710724,
-0.4742048978805542,
0.9685916304588318,
-0.3558589816093445,
-0.782638430595398,
-0.0733366459608078,
0.586145281791687,
0.3582535684108734,
0.28911861777305603,
0.5084866285324097,
-0.03395376726984978,
0.1396445780992508,
-0.28943896293640137,
0.22356972098350525,
0.16922946274280548,
-0.6102568507194519,
-0.39305633306503296,
0.12769295275211334,
-0.4773167073726654,
0.03528039529919624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10659v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10659v3 | Network Formation and Dynamics Among Multi-LLMs | 2024-02-16T13:10:14 | 2024-06-02T13:50:14 | Marios Papachristou, Yuan Yuan | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA | Social networks shape opinions, behaviors, and information dissemination in
human societies. As large language models (LLMs) increasingly integrate into
social and professional environments, understanding their behavior within the
context of social interactions and networks becomes essential. Our study
analyzes LLMs' network formation behavior to examine whether the dynamics of
multiple LLMs are similar to or different from human social dynamics. We
observe that LLMs exhibit key social network principles, including preferential
attachment, triadic closure, homophily, community structure, and the
small-world phenomenon, when asked about their preferences in network
formation. We also investigate LLMs' decision-making based on real-world
networks, revealing that triadic closure and homophily have a stronger
influence than preferential attachment and that LLMs perform well in network
formation predictions. Overall, our study opens up new possibilities for using
LLMs in network science research and helps develop socially aware LLMs by
shedding light on their social interaction behaviors and exploring their
impacts on social dynamics. | [
-0.48653659224510193,
-0.9020951986312866,
0.42035868763923645,
0.17836734652519226,
0.07293897122144699,
0.17840906977653503,
-0.2450753003358841,
-0.35668283700942993,
0.7699540853500366,
0.4467734694480896,
-0.6278826594352722,
-0.22631783783435822,
-0.28898024559020996,
0.2772213816642761,
-0.2407970130443573,
0.7718234062194824,
0.24899795651435852,
0.10260695964097977,
-0.14630649983882904,
-0.2158837467432022,
-0.23358812928199768,
-0.7839242219924927,
-0.8653280138969421,
-0.7195967435836792,
0.9460417628288269,
0.28964856266975403,
0.6493191719055176,
0.6478788256645203,
0.5333465933799744,
0.4065714478492737,
-0.30929985642433167,
0.24718348681926727,
-0.7833900451660156,
0.12158025801181793,
-0.1066913902759552,
-0.41296374797821045,
-0.4615039527416229,
0.013978849165141582,
0.8843017220497131,
0.7940649390220642,
-0.11535120755434036,
0.15128600597381592,
0.35486045479774475,
0.9032900333404541,
-0.03533339127898216,
0.09138695895671844,
-0.45995238423347473,
0.10963048785924911,
-0.3420025706291199,
-0.21952873468399048,
-0.22110840678215027,
-0.5199686288833618,
0.32674047350883484,
-0.2367483228445053,
0.13743631541728973,
0.27047187089920044,
0.6424137353897095,
-0.3320092558860779,
-0.9108900427818298,
-0.11078490316867828,
-0.5262488126754761,
0.2541213929653168,
-0.22676773369312286,
0.1598413586616516,
-0.02536287158727646,
0.3259601891040802,
-0.5556844472885132,
-0.517615556716919,
-0.4901650846004486,
-0.01752958446741104,
0.09931530058383942,
-0.2142392098903656,
0.33164045214653015,
0.26192915439605713,
0.13636592030525208,
0.04408054053783417,
-0.2618202269077301,
0.20908938348293304,
-0.7231636643409729,
0.13379190862178802,
0.44424009323120117,
0.4233955144882202,
0.2834283113479614,
-0.17678873240947723,
-0.27938202023506165,
0.2273653745651245,
-0.9155540466308594,
0.07494693249464035,
0.44389569759368896,
0.44679874181747437,
-0.27856066823005676,
0.68751460313797,
0.04987335950136185,
0.3242778778076172,
-0.08891475200653076,
-0.1841626763343811,
0.22691699862480164,
-0.3480061888694763,
-0.2519051134586334,
0.018621429800987244,
0.8742491602897644,
0.5235177874565125,
0.761965274810791,
0.1474641114473343,
0.08171001821756363,
-0.016651488840579987,
0.09279059618711472,
-0.5627378225326538,
0.19648240506649017,
-0.17950767278671265,
-0.9607241749763489,
-0.5614370107650757,
0.14198936522006989,
-0.3983456492424011,
-0.6555516719818115,
-0.41572609543800354,
0.10315939784049988,
-0.07031158357858658,
-0.6837752461433411,
0.009617173112928867,
-0.17352019250392914,
0.24112114310264587,
0.3729870021343231,
-0.5540627241134644,
0.6981551647186279,
0.559573769569397,
1.1934771537780762,
-0.2178126573562622,
-0.7363753914833069,
-0.07635258883237839,
0.2722741365432739,
-0.28720593452453613,
0.4909951686859131,
-0.323635458946228,
-0.36802810430526733,
0.26479217410087585,
0.24477031826972961,
-0.16312548518180847,
-0.3498168885707855,
-0.08114653825759888,
-0.6864495277404785,
-0.3363860547542572,
-0.4530019462108612,
-0.543027400970459,
-0.15030057728290558,
0.27267980575561523,
-0.6755515933036804,
0.5854329466819763,
-0.41878417134284973,
-0.7426823973655701,
0.16846482455730438,
-0.9373461604118347,
-0.3459527790546417,
-0.19177159667015076,
-0.26730814576148987,
0.11618143320083618,
0.15184184908866882,
-0.59625244140625,
0.7139906287193298,
-0.18833932280540466,
0.24104031920433044,
-0.850965678691864,
-0.16166582703590393,
0.53212970495224,
-0.17853675782680511,
0.6578339338302612,
0.012248505838215351,
0.0831984281539917,
0.11468519270420074,
-0.37446191906929016,
-0.4557558000087738,
0.20257577300071716,
-0.3473452031612396,
-0.21349912881851196,
0.320322722196579,
-0.47472891211509705,
0.31674903631210327,
-0.10736209899187088,
-0.28896066546440125,
0.5680010914802551,
-0.26336798071861267,
0.5975181460380554,
0.844394326210022,
0.39267563819885254,
0.35806477069854736,
-0.5160603523254395,
0.3739485740661621,
0.14799629151821136,
0.2007385492324829,
0.1216697096824646,
-0.5681635141372681,
-0.7102484703063965,
0.1956128180027008,
-0.12959973514080048,
0.1949014663696289,
-0.4733441174030304,
-0.19904564321041107,
-0.3480078876018524,
-0.32106173038482666,
0.0012464250903576612,
0.22093892097473145,
0.3722091615200043,
0.10141606628894806,
-0.10842955112457275,
-0.1670796126127243,
-0.5184498429298401,
-0.8689931631088257,
0.05539356917142868,
-0.22555293142795563,
0.6083884239196777,
0.43473753333091736,
0.5298349857330322,
-0.402052640914917,
0.8814234733581543,
-0.4790688157081604,
-0.18957598507404327,
-0.23947346210479736,
-0.135367289185524,
0.2984902858734131,
0.029893919825553894,
0.60284823179245,
-0.561356246471405,
-0.431497722864151,
-0.09010834991931915,
-0.676858127117157,
0.2027069330215454,
0.22062112390995026,
-0.1146165132522583,
-0.008925163187086582,
0.641792893409729,
-0.45559340715408325,
0.14776305854320526,
0.7675055861473083,
-0.2969982922077179,
0.7027450203895569,
-0.03647227957844734,
0.06394922733306885,
-1.2095251083374023,
-0.5078961253166199,
0.17554520070552826,
-0.07698418945074081,
-0.7530896663665771,
-0.1923505663871765,
-0.4207550883293152,
0.14179717004299164,
-0.6430526375770569,
0.429066926240921,
-0.8002169132232666,
-0.36837443709373474,
-0.09942976385354996,
0.37452924251556396,
-0.2286490499973297,
0.19551829993724823,
-0.15491381287574768,
0.6434748768806458,
0.8597956895828247,
-0.8932920694351196,
0.42339473962783813,
0.15335147082805634,
-0.22418920695781708,
0.08537506312131882,
-0.7152157425880432,
-0.03581993654370308,
-0.07320787757635117,
0.3199518322944641,
-1.0900062322616577,
-0.3124619126319885,
-0.007089745253324509,
-0.2105962485074997,
0.04255741834640503,
-0.29495692253112793,
-0.6807564496994019,
-0.30889540910720825,
-0.4482479393482208,
0.35310226678848267,
0.11135990172624588,
-0.35378432273864746,
0.25223806500434875,
0.7301681041717529,
0.04985494166612625,
-0.29113200306892395,
-0.8031457662582397,
0.09906687587499619,
-0.2791843116283417,
-1.0761862993240356,
0.05120664834976196,
-0.0522787868976593,
-0.5932278037071228,
-0.31930363178253174,
0.25872528553009033,
-0.06500855088233948,
0.12525641918182373,
0.5294971466064453,
0.06377875059843063,
-0.338486909866333,
0.19813136756420135,
0.11974719166755676,
0.32945719361305237,
0.27137207984924316,
0.047006167471408844,
0.7526867985725403,
-0.4632301926612854,
-0.3401094973087311,
-0.21886835992336273,
-0.006391589529812336,
0.879008948802948,
0.007489223964512348,
0.9959717988967896,
0.2337125986814499,
-0.10585684329271317,
-0.11152145266532898,
-0.39148059487342834,
-0.4160720407962799,
-0.5640286207199097,
0.13599735498428345,
-0.4482320249080658,
-1.1655584573745728,
0.7655770182609558,
-0.4276118874549866,
-0.20023812353610992,
0.08042902499437332,
0.6613501906394958,
-0.21798035502433777,
0.795910656452179,
0.5051891803741455,
0.035787444561719894,
0.4631167948246002,
-0.24134595692157745,
0.0054994011297822,
-1.1477371454238892,
-0.21656224131584167,
-0.1911359429359436,
-0.42078375816345215,
-0.7834035754203796,
-0.3253391683101654,
0.4745381474494934,
0.1677483469247818,
-0.09234938770532608,
0.1018928587436676,
-0.1855967789888382,
0.45365720987319946,
0.10637949407100677,
0.10050994157791138,
0.13498862087726593,
-0.03734610602259636,
-0.4418432414531708,
0.2867087423801422,
-0.6029340028762817,
-0.7097664475440979,
0.9581871032714844,
0.3628884553909302,
0.7488763332366943,
0.7895901799201965,
0.7904959917068481,
0.2750711441040039,
0.2736835181713104,
-0.5465686321258545,
0.7030415534973145,
0.08359750360250473,
-0.3851337134838104,
-0.35602685809135437,
-0.2643696367740631,
-1.3220728635787964,
0.18697258830070496,
-0.5191793441772461,
-0.9297934770584106,
0.1070556491613388,
0.1677333414554596,
-0.14168286323547363,
0.22676314413547516,
-0.3437640964984894,
0.38204577565193176,
0.03334813565015793,
-0.2570662498474121,
-0.2894212305545807,
-0.8661826252937317,
0.634685754776001,
0.020630497485399246,
0.5277826189994812,
-0.41768527030944824,
-0.06310000270605087,
0.47616878151893616,
-0.23671114444732666,
1.1337339878082275,
0.1620255559682846,
-0.06906215101480484,
0.43567895889282227,
0.278001606464386,
0.4629387855529785,
0.13017579913139343,
-0.13525402545928955,
0.26643091440200806,
-0.07899922132492065,
0.26082491874694824,
-0.37729766964912415,
0.8656819462776184,
-0.982677698135376,
-0.5871177911758423,
-0.1503889560699463,
-0.2574464678764343,
0.044336337596178055,
0.2254163920879364,
-0.06872833520174026,
0.6272547841072083,
-0.4451015889644623,
0.2329718917608261,
0.7127941846847534,
0.17455315589904785,
0.6373481154441833,
0.34018799662590027,
-0.7835134267807007,
-0.345049649477005,
0.6696942448616028,
0.25687375664711,
0.6346890330314636,
0.07301901280879974,
0.47186365723609924,
-0.20494583249092102,
-0.4173787236213684,
-0.12555868923664093,
0.6257826685905457,
-0.49452629685401917,
0.013984101824462414,
-0.6412853002548218,
-0.24614973366260529,
-0.4703161120414734,
-0.07233510166406631,
-0.08747127652168274,
-0.3734849989414215,
-0.2617497444152832,
-0.051221780478954315,
0.335489422082901,
1.025207281112671,
-0.08713053166866302,
0.4447634220123291,
-0.8558383584022522,
0.13746993243694305,
0.23873507976531982,
0.3647700846195221,
0.08926001936197281,
-0.12055940181016922,
-0.2797929644584656,
-0.18227465450763702,
-0.24218907952308655,
-1.3208224773406982,
-0.0065150633454322815,
0.48911282420158386,
0.4859744608402252,
0.8173727989196777,
-0.19616639614105225,
0.4007643163204193,
-0.6065235733985901,
0.8557592630386353,
0.34606242179870605,
-0.7540110349655151,
0.35205864906311035,
-0.771461009979248,
-0.16236749291419983,
0.2894652485847473,
0.22772476077079773,
-0.7637714147567749,
-0.2691348195075989,
-0.46413111686706543,
-0.4782874286174774,
0.6482620239257812,
0.2032516896724701,
0.2904279828071594,
-0.1937536597251892,
0.6082514524459839,
-0.46334195137023926,
0.36697784066200256,
-0.9551039934158325,
-0.7351354956626892,
0.2271440327167511,
0.3140490651130676,
0.19317205250263214,
-0.375153124332428,
-0.3055143654346466,
-0.14297939836978912,
0.21182918548583984,
-0.24920660257339478,
0.1713160276412964,
-0.05946190282702446,
0.28173187375068665,
-0.1850959062576294,
0.06707414239645004,
0.8659585118293762,
0.6706119775772095,
-0.05490853637456894,
0.36988940834999084,
0.1315000355243683,
-0.2562287449836731,
0.41703519225120544,
-0.7685575485229492,
0.12766507267951965,
-0.18945303559303284,
0.11668704450130463,
0.5924054384231567,
0.11239064484834671,
-0.15219679474830627,
0.6017440557479858,
-0.24592852592468262,
-0.38631826639175415,
-0.17749860882759094,
0.315184623003006,
0.6073399782180786,
0.39570629596710205,
-0.04569682106375694,
0.06004320830106735,
0.057977139949798584,
-0.778664231300354,
0.050572846084833145,
0.469226598739624,
-0.15798158943653107,
-0.4706772267818451,
0.1074938178062439,
0.44867217540740967,
-0.5389960408210754,
0.35186928510665894,
-0.24380691349506378,
-0.4931180775165558,
0.6841400861740112,
0.6145703196525574,
0.752202033996582,
-0.2952505648136139,
0.2831422984600067,
0.07040935009717941,
0.4371585249900818,
-0.23081456124782562,
0.270161896944046,
0.2967517077922821,
-1.1952606439590454,
-0.2241801619529724,
-0.412275105714798,
-0.27210843563079834,
-0.2242819219827652,
-0.519179105758667,
0.5387110710144043,
-0.5196061134338379,
-0.6036039590835571,
-0.06838413327932358,
-0.10967080295085907,
-0.42896345257759094,
-0.16752217710018158,
0.012316390872001648,
0.6820033192634583,
-0.7493273615837097,
0.8073984980583191,
0.8715266585350037,
-0.17564018070697784,
-0.895275354385376,
-0.16284671425819397,
0.5856820344924927,
-0.6492932438850403,
0.8384198546409607,
0.32329675555229187,
-0.6113857626914978,
-0.016985895112156868,
-0.4363325536251068,
-1.2115042209625244,
1.1273986101150513,
0.20703689754009247,
-0.4896905720233917,
0.01618042215704918,
0.06837715208530426,
0.4658398926258087,
-0.6452217698097229,
0.08975423127412796,
0.07888077199459076,
0.41057783365249634,
0.08322461694478989,
-0.8896738290786743,
0.0837329626083374,
-0.09667178988456726,
0.15060479938983917,
0.4529571831226349,
-1.247044563293457,
0.9500302672386169,
-0.3720250427722931,
-0.3055258095264435,
-0.21487316489219666,
0.5066319704055786,
0.40800729393959045,
0.20456410944461823,
0.4210682511329651,
-0.05398009344935417,
0.6643965840339661,
0.28223860263824463,
0.6582435965538025,
-0.592954695224762,
0.2268381416797638,
0.9145289063453674,
-0.4158196449279785,
0.5607321858406067,
0.4648975133895874,
-0.10140415281057358,
0.6287876963615417,
0.7334733605384827,
0.09386608004570007,
0.08221609145402908,
0.5343566536903381,
0.0162485521286726,
0.05325079709291458,
-0.2510767877101898,
-0.3208378255367279,
0.48115959763526917,
0.4122617840766907,
-0.35360729694366455,
0.15539544820785522,
-0.20232871174812317,
0.08948977291584015,
-0.3370320796966553,
-0.4197894334793091,
0.7330257296562195,
0.32336628437042236,
-0.35030779242515564,
0.07965964823961258,
-0.08217638731002808,
0.4923749268054962,
-0.5775343775749207,
0.08935979008674622,
0.09659324586391449,
-0.062415145337581635,
-0.40743547677993774,
-0.8815134167671204,
0.2512799799442291,
-0.37516164779663086,
-0.33727744221687317,
0.04474497586488724,
0.6887038350105286,
-0.2795014977455139,
-0.03944360464811325,
0.5637622475624084,
0.7234923243522644,
0.44384336471557617,
0.40379586815834045,
-0.6082582473754883,
0.1833309382200241,
-0.13105091452598572,
-0.39281824231147766,
0.5151727795600891,
0.6895653605461121,
-0.02020685002207756,
0.7845174074172974,
0.7226126194000244,
0.3781140148639679,
0.2717980146408081,
0.2942033112049103,
0.8155835866928101,
-0.42184966802597046,
-0.09100279957056046,
-1.0968763828277588,
0.22036120295524597,
-0.225253164768219,
-0.34772297739982605,
0.9102359414100647,
0.2354995310306549,
0.4783453643321991,
0.3340570628643036,
0.49113476276397705,
0.165169820189476,
0.04836611822247505,
-0.4576922059059143,
0.7100693583488464,
-0.49982553720474243,
0.35704347491264343,
-0.4814869463443756,
-0.891620934009552,
-0.06689529865980148,
0.3635571300983429,
0.057883765548467636,
-0.02542051672935486,
0.7508312463760376,
0.8837810158729553,
0.1361970156431198,
-0.00013169589510653168,
0.20620283484458923,
0.25035956501960754,
0.3645918369293213,
-0.031004546210169792,
0.9774049520492554,
0.0938812643289566,
0.3789117932319641,
0.08098923414945602,
-0.16299647092819214,
-0.18625898659229279,
-0.9961718320846558,
-1.101759910583496,
-0.4405762553215027,
-0.24896951019763947,
-0.44303998351097107,
-0.28797343373298645,
1.238383412361145,
0.5828815698623657,
-0.2661193609237671,
-0.88158118724823,
-0.013738886453211308,
0.4232689142227173,
0.07084839046001434,
-0.2839351296424866,
0.037786372005939484,
-0.2895486056804657,
-0.17615853250026703,
0.3650806248188019,
0.4431847631931305,
0.1732495129108429,
-0.47843340039253235,
-0.2657191753387451,
-0.4444770812988281,
0.359130859375,
0.7685879468917847,
0.0849236249923706,
-0.6275654435157776,
-0.18661895394325256,
-0.0969928503036499,
-0.24384860694408417,
0.12528817355632782,
1.0063124895095825,
-0.1037716493010521,
0.2670536935329437,
0.41724056005477905,
0.17259329557418823,
0.15560796856880188,
-0.24338117241859436,
0.6104815602302551,
-0.7107869386672974,
-0.227148175239563,
-0.26431602239608765,
0.5030480623245239,
0.1234486773610115,
-0.22310586273670197,
0.5151475071907043,
0.4076422154903412,
-0.7857456803321838,
-0.7846224308013916,
0.4713018536567688,
-0.6486615538597107,
-0.14885275065898895,
1.4404538869857788,
0.2007979154586792,
-0.23882630467414856,
-0.13403387367725372,
-0.18596093356609344,
0.2691676616668701,
-0.46746715903282166,
0.35060998797416687,
0.6166478395462036,
-0.6405046582221985,
-0.15035687386989594,
-0.24873359501361847,
0.4564047157764435,
-0.15074636042118073,
-0.6661341190338135,
-0.06461311131715775,
0.4581499993801117,
0.2702478766441345,
0.3246748149394989,
0.7588185667991638,
0.2725842595100403,
-0.24657127261161804,
-0.3671027421951294,
-0.18943598866462708,
-0.03677608072757721,
-0.5324626564979553,
-0.1770028918981552,
0.34153810143470764,
0.2461393177509308,
0.12530659139156342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10654v1 | Enhancing Numerical Reasoning with the Guidance of Reliable Reasoning Processes | 2024-02-16T13:02:11 | 2024-02-16T13:02:11 | Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Xuanliang Zhang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerical reasoning is an essential ability for NLP systems to handle numeric
information. Recent research indicates that fine-tuning a small-scale model to
learn generating reasoning processes alongside answers can significantly
enhance performance. However, current methods have the limitation that most
methods generate reasoning processes with large language models (LLMs), which
are "unreliable" since such processes could contain information unrelated to
the answer. To address this limitation, we introduce Enhancing NumeriCal
reasOning with Reliable procEsses (Encore), which derives the reliable
reasoning process by decomposing the answer formula, ensuring which fully
supports the answer. Nevertheless, models could lack enough data to learn the
reasoning process generation adequately, since our method generates only one
single reasoning process for one formula. To overcome this difficulty, we
present a series of pre-training tasks to help models learn the reasoning
process generation with synthesized data. The experiments show that Encore
yields improvement on all five experimental datasets with an average of 1.8%,
proving the effectiveness of our method. | [
-0.26620399951934814,
-0.6309748291969299,
0.7801244258880615,
0.4232825040817261,
-0.2511865198612213,
0.0814167782664299,
-0.1467362642288208,
-0.24034011363983154,
0.027678005397319794,
0.8402082920074463,
-0.5313961505889893,
-0.3002389967441559,
-0.49215346574783325,
0.29419422149658203,
-0.042821720242500305,
0.8343991637229919,
0.10771626979112625,
0.14851295948028564,
-0.49357327818870544,
0.02519003301858902,
-0.3636535108089447,
-0.49723953008651733,
-0.9095060229301453,
-0.49865105748176575,
0.3214251399040222,
0.5599536299705505,
0.7305126190185547,
0.5819143056869507,
0.6203005313873291,
0.255765825510025,
-0.1632876992225647,
0.7560925483703613,
-0.5770115852355957,
0.5179497003555298,
-0.27131712436676025,
-0.35455480217933655,
-0.5164777636528015,
-0.43298017978668213,
0.6878788471221924,
0.7555346488952637,
-0.2199201136827469,
0.10018270462751389,
0.15479658544063568,
0.7836508750915527,
-0.525621771812439,
0.20490345358848572,
-0.9252222776412964,
-0.017539948225021362,
0.14151166379451752,
-0.5408530235290527,
-0.6734339594841003,
-0.686127781867981,
-0.2425699383020401,
-0.7051408886909485,
-0.06390642374753952,
-0.11985248327255249,
0.374683678150177,
0.6939811706542969,
0.04281829670071602,
0.1035744920372963,
-0.83061283826828,
0.8066116571426392,
-0.9027751088142395,
0.03210628032684326,
0.40628936886787415,
0.10772741585969925,
-0.43724384903907776,
-0.7968463897705078,
-0.3333008587360382,
-0.19363680481910706,
0.1745816320180893,
-0.011170848272740841,
-0.002653907984495163,
0.14456404745578766,
0.9110782146453857,
-0.20253846049308777,
-0.3785872161388397,
-0.20529994368553162,
-0.29339084029197693,
-0.2207496464252472,
0.7836747765541077,
0.21328651905059814,
0.17194746434688568,
-0.024870596826076508,
-0.1115618348121643,
-0.14800170063972473,
-0.8230016231536865,
-0.1681397557258606,
0.17657753825187683,
0.4429096281528473,
0.45354315638542175,
0.5964418053627014,
-0.1584867238998413,
0.6041982769966125,
-0.24479568004608154,
-0.16564078629016876,
0.42761141061782837,
-0.2011871635913849,
-0.11192125082015991,
0.166171133518219,
0.4965478479862213,
0.017613619565963745,
0.28061190247535706,
-0.11710751056671143,
-0.270381361246109,
0.07334800809621811,
0.573051393032074,
-0.7367802262306213,
-0.2478373497724533,
0.21875017881393433,
-0.08130055665969849,
-0.12156014889478683,
0.015348333865404129,
-0.2814475893974304,
-0.02273760735988617,
-0.6491323113441467,
0.3508126735687256,
-0.6320853233337402,
-0.3990797996520996,
0.2997658848762512,
-0.2289261370897293,
-0.11483227461576462,
0.43154412508010864,
-0.6706209778785706,
0.18185190856456757,
0.9602213501930237,
0.5224143862724304,
-0.02932562492787838,
-0.11838927865028381,
-1.0660613775253296,
-0.008769058622419834,
-0.6758701801300049,
0.9095951914787292,
-0.7750548124313354,
-0.3799039423465729,
-0.33465030789375305,
-0.1961660087108612,
0.09344733506441116,
-0.7293774485588074,
1.0697788000106812,
-0.4714745879173279,
-0.4122903645038605,
-0.46596238017082214,
-0.5676659941673279,
-0.13420653343200684,
0.18534088134765625,
-0.4544578194618225,
1.279392957687378,
-0.18586622178554535,
-0.6531567573547363,
0.24511533975601196,
-0.7971526384353638,
-0.3188113570213318,
0.02448323555290699,
0.03725535422563553,
-0.44994500279426575,
0.32943177223205566,
0.5301773548126221,
0.27114227414131165,
0.03668268397450447,
0.41088658571243286,
-0.6390497088432312,
-0.2458503395318985,
0.12134583294391632,
-0.5543098449707031,
0.5481401085853577,
0.21092097461223602,
-0.1165488138794899,
0.07659782469272614,
-1.0656076669692993,
0.4929705560207367,
-0.03095080889761448,
-0.1710710972547531,
-0.18485493957996368,
0.01506047323346138,
-0.6068150401115417,
0.1513998657464981,
-0.025326883420348167,
-0.3268299102783203,
0.22671550512313843,
-0.5466843247413635,
0.10223007202148438,
0.6012172102928162,
0.39886409044265747,
0.4227202236652374,
-0.2733425199985504,
0.7737686038017273,
-0.05361756309866905,
-0.1301078051328659,
-0.47004446387290955,
-0.5101155638694763,
-0.6705086827278137,
0.20244313776493073,
0.16914215683937073,
0.5975853800773621,
-1.1375486850738525,
0.13136425614356995,
-0.1845269650220871,
-0.4675532877445221,
-0.09240780770778656,
0.09742289036512375,
0.3534327447414398,
0.8237972259521484,
0.4858101010322571,
0.16874028742313385,
-0.8696495294570923,
-0.5796700716018677,
-0.336769700050354,
-0.16997095942497253,
-0.11114560067653656,
0.17216376960277557,
0.4535762369632721,
0.018059927970170975,
0.7086625099182129,
-0.4774787127971649,
0.30469563603401184,
-0.1080247238278389,
0.46956712007522583,
0.3843599557876587,
0.5521619319915771,
0.3002501428127289,
-0.5285938382148743,
-0.4051101803779602,
-0.05978125333786011,
-0.9184214472770691,
-0.260936975479126,
-0.15042196214199066,
-0.2997848391532898,
0.22818288207054138,
0.5004501938819885,
-0.2756931781768799,
0.36931896209716797,
0.31342363357543945,
-0.11619309335947037,
0.8251287341117859,
-0.5080278515815735,
0.023469706997275352,
-0.6317578554153442,
-0.02265876904129982,
0.045565005391836166,
-0.33850350975990295,
-0.4510233998298645,
-0.024951890110969543,
-0.2478136122226715,
-0.20190271735191345,
-0.39916616678237915,
0.3796437084674835,
-0.4212481379508972,
-0.0668303593993187,
-0.4530711770057678,
-0.05275276303291321,
0.13079281151294708,
0.12209077924489975,
0.5350549817085266,
0.8426187634468079,
0.6328908205032349,
-0.7049016356468201,
0.23410318791866302,
0.17226296663284302,
-0.3466368019580841,
0.22713825106620789,
-0.8338114619255066,
0.26731076836586,
-0.2140892595052719,
0.08559982478618622,
-0.7583487033843994,
-0.23833227157592773,
-0.0037707951851189137,
-0.5965369939804077,
0.12615197896957397,
-0.2999117076396942,
-0.5027218461036682,
-0.38341954350471497,
0.053481921553611755,
0.07490383088588715,
0.6043559312820435,
-0.623795747756958,
0.8354529142379761,
0.19907520711421967,
-0.567815363407135,
-0.7918867468833923,
-0.43090689182281494,
0.05030466988682747,
-0.22785712778568268,
-0.8491318821907043,
0.16287586092948914,
0.07316040992736816,
-0.36295783519744873,
-0.06158711016178131,
-0.15624211728572845,
-0.14092133939266205,
0.06916852295398712,
0.1242181807756424,
0.11351702362298965,
-0.21359609067440033,
0.41713377833366394,
0.4146709442138672,
-0.4793240427970886,
0.43975141644477844,
-0.3181134760379791,
0.15199309587478638,
-0.16217637062072754,
-0.2748141288757324,
-0.336102694272995,
0.2029285728931427,
0.5124239325523376,
-0.23229113221168518,
0.8565681576728821,
0.5511068105697632,
-0.42432141304016113,
-0.5216913819313049,
-0.40027347207069397,
-0.6186822056770325,
-0.44160494208335876,
0.09487555176019669,
-0.508309006690979,
-0.5297319293022156,
0.5303338766098022,
-0.34662702679634094,
0.12765513360500336,
0.4692055881023407,
0.1672249734401703,
0.06803509593009949,
1.4091016054153442,
0.3105163872241974,
0.4667699635028839,
-0.03503508120775223,
-0.2102864533662796,
0.03478902205824852,
-0.7575567960739136,
-0.4067762792110443,
-0.6645140051841736,
0.04172947630286217,
0.017944589257240295,
-0.5202985405921936,
0.5324193835258484,
0.36971914768218994,
-0.2601327896118164,
0.1108037531375885,
-0.7835342288017273,
0.6788873672485352,
0.5289246439933777,
0.1726304292678833,
0.3216508626937866,
0.2649380564689636,
-0.20070549845695496,
-0.3700614273548126,
-0.9158872961997986,
-0.6946980357170105,
1.0080355405807495,
0.2270107865333557,
0.7861434817314148,
-0.121579609811306,
0.6739629507064819,
0.088003009557724,
0.3655337691307068,
-0.2761940658092499,
0.546834409236908,
-0.1344657689332962,
-0.24581769108772278,
-0.3186231851577759,
-0.7931016087532043,
-0.5289656519889832,
0.18728742003440857,
-0.5078645348548889,
-0.5173172950744629,
-0.036005981266498566,
0.45279672741889954,
-0.5892053246498108,
0.2615981698036194,
-0.537026584148407,
0.658771276473999,
-0.4647332429885864,
-0.7954171299934387,
-0.18396663665771484,
-0.39921998977661133,
0.43397632241249084,
-0.08358307182788849,
0.07448716461658478,
-0.06996431201696396,
0.2763690948486328,
0.5580881237983704,
-0.8058817982673645,
0.6069366931915283,
-0.3819052577018738,
-0.06993736326694489,
0.5462536811828613,
0.147909015417099,
0.7603753209114075,
0.35930654406547546,
-0.5799817442893982,
-0.018763551488518715,
-0.07203418761491776,
-0.2166389673948288,
-0.9189557433128357,
0.5945536494255066,
-0.3084351420402527,
-0.599198043346405,
-0.3524671494960785,
-0.46146318316459656,
-0.2635117173194885,
0.06760666519403458,
0.02015310525894165,
0.426917165517807,
0.27977073192596436,
0.4070596396923065,
0.8410850763320923,
-0.19872017204761505,
0.1863478571176529,
0.12175889313220978,
-0.2966410219669342,
-0.6376824378967285,
0.734407901763916,
-0.0049242889508605,
0.2077757567167282,
0.19575808942317963,
0.2219075709581375,
-0.7267693281173706,
-0.64268958568573,
-0.24639008939266205,
0.06864121556282043,
-0.6972446441650391,
-0.29889243841171265,
-0.6935875415802002,
-0.27472856640815735,
-0.3625815808773041,
-0.029790759086608887,
-0.5150831937789917,
-0.7390403151512146,
-0.35771363973617554,
-0.20621487498283386,
0.46752360463142395,
0.3711126744747162,
-0.4894886314868927,
0.021100785583257675,
-1.1803557872772217,
0.38697350025177,
0.19747616350650787,
0.2218179702758789,
0.06549141556024551,
-0.7104182243347168,
0.07778792828321457,
0.3763220012187958,
-0.21613560616970062,
-0.4848611652851105,
0.5517781972885132,
0.3247779309749603,
0.6656877994537354,
0.3783929944038391,
0.21464696526527405,
0.7683770060539246,
-0.6126506328582764,
0.7129788398742676,
0.01239858753979206,
-0.7916005253791809,
0.8109805583953857,
-0.43496158719062805,
0.39492371678352356,
0.5241367220878601,
0.44340139627456665,
0.0908706933259964,
-0.2547808587551117,
-0.7435973286628723,
-0.8384426832199097,
0.6359131932258606,
0.2870616614818573,
0.09257033467292786,
-0.29256707429885864,
0.716931939125061,
0.1322144865989685,
0.04264378920197487,
-0.49378296732902527,
0.053252212703228,
-0.0897332951426506,
0.15046681463718414,
0.23817779123783112,
-0.27027595043182373,
-0.029424559324979782,
-0.4552963972091675,
1.1228517293930054,
-0.3439805507659912,
-0.13248522579669952,
0.0950770303606987,
0.3417813181877136,
0.013199534267187119,
0.06149210408329964,
0.7119513154029846,
0.9606116414070129,
-0.09407398104667664,
0.07881871610879898,
0.2707039415836334,
-0.16797582805156708,
-0.05330616235733032,
-0.016139797866344452,
-0.09706498682498932,
0.07818453013896942,
0.2162516564130783,
0.750515878200531,
0.1241379976272583,
-0.6953654289245605,
0.020436815917491913,
-0.0560922808945179,
-0.3579804301261902,
-0.619779646396637,
0.43163755536079407,
0.11576975136995316,
0.16432124376296997,
0.44229254126548767,
0.4329705536365509,
0.03109312430024147,
-0.09020610898733139,
0.4527375102043152,
0.31106331944465637,
-0.13751821219921112,
-0.0167370717972517,
0.8118495941162109,
0.12597428262233734,
-0.1977049559354782,
0.9330748915672302,
-0.42383435368537903,
-0.5046529769897461,
0.7162365317344666,
0.7067434787750244,
0.697397768497467,
-0.058851152658462524,
0.38568025827407837,
0.9094794988632202,
0.19607803225517273,
-0.7720824480056763,
0.5635109543800354,
-0.010997761972248554,
-0.7545651197433472,
-1.0702110528945923,
-0.6444852352142334,
-0.6443024277687073,
-0.04437332972884178,
-0.6721087098121643,
0.16338667273521423,
-0.3601306974887848,
-0.2967884838581085,
-0.057116687297821045,
-0.41251689195632935,
-0.2881956100463867,
0.28638896346092224,
0.03683933988213539,
0.899509847164154,
-0.7918363809585571,
0.5195221304893494,
0.49469679594039917,
-0.3807615041732788,
-1.0240676403045654,
-0.45456796884536743,
-0.31344476342201233,
-0.4154120087623596,
0.8160250782966614,
0.02884681709110737,
-0.3215878903865814,
-0.14145396649837494,
-0.6837235689163208,
-0.9311790466308594,
0.3979068100452423,
0.8051386475563049,
-0.4716007709503174,
0.17603428661823273,
0.04507755488157272,
0.6390324831008911,
-0.4067327678203583,
0.3263608515262604,
0.45299655199050903,
0.5902844071388245,
0.6196925044059753,
-0.5800583362579346,
-0.12921984493732452,
-0.3165673017501831,
-0.04426492005586624,
0.12193205952644348,
0.044671788811683655,
0.3803226351737976,
-0.6680380702018738,
-0.13772806525230408,
0.06347988545894623,
0.7314311265945435,
0.8127000331878662,
0.32786354422569275,
0.3665952682495117,
0.8848524689674377,
0.9486904740333557,
-0.3800165355205536,
1.0723477602005005,
-0.32730576395988464,
0.03449198976159096,
1.4268280267715454,
-0.31788331270217896,
1.058516502380371,
0.2265883982181549,
-0.07452534884214401,
0.5927364230155945,
0.3525690734386444,
0.12606339156627655,
0.1663491278886795,
0.13669241964817047,
-0.36047789454460144,
-0.8909854292869568,
-0.025920631363987923,
-0.3656019866466522,
0.29729992151260376,
0.6181582808494568,
-0.44993656873703003,
-0.13571760058403015,
-0.09485572576522827,
-0.10428764671087265,
0.4698536694049835,
-0.45180743932724,
0.6053348779678345,
0.22358964383602142,
-1.0685220956802368,
0.691153883934021,
-0.3303149938583374,
0.09409592300653458,
-0.630748450756073,
-0.5855387449264526,
0.02523433044552803,
0.2002456933259964,
-0.4726865589618683,
-0.7837060689926147,
0.7087839841842651,
-0.009761830791831017,
-0.18708278238773346,
-0.43226003646850586,
0.8696775436401367,
-0.30399784445762634,
-0.9102227091789246,
-0.0725674256682396,
0.2791648507118225,
0.3643070161342621,
-0.2345714420080185,
-0.5599070191383362,
0.06810632348060608,
0.10485796630382538,
-0.046055641025304794,
-0.1440775841474533,
0.5038629770278931,
0.1239473968744278,
0.9255879521369934,
0.9309311509132385,
0.31737712025642395,
0.051276158541440964,
0.26882609724998474,
0.7092083096504211,
-0.4671469032764435,
-0.23270782828330994,
-0.8200869560241699,
0.758743405342102,
-0.4436086416244507,
-0.06911906599998474,
0.7107625603675842,
0.49901247024536133,
0.570423424243927,
-0.08866541087627411,
0.8266133069992065,
0.4661485552787781,
0.6906408667564392,
-0.7355809211730957,
0.30854296684265137,
-0.2906087338924408,
0.6338615417480469,
-0.12596389651298523,
-1.2254384756088257,
-0.6139717102050781,
0.8314088582992554,
-0.31225380301475525,
0.11839831620454788,
0.505413293838501,
0.6984766125679016,
0.07142320275306702,
0.2723004221916199,
0.17733275890350342,
0.16206690669059753,
0.3461849093437195,
0.4505888819694519,
0.7863121032714844,
-0.1508730798959732,
0.4328822195529938,
-0.2936571538448334,
-0.13800093531608582,
0.15462371706962585,
-1.3694640398025513,
-0.5310289859771729,
-0.05927671119570732,
-0.5062245726585388,
-0.5423737168312073,
0.02218729630112648,
0.8396440148353577,
0.651857316493988,
-0.5439336895942688,
0.2942061126232147,
-0.46807661652565,
0.21068404614925385,
-0.4636180102825165,
-0.25088346004486084,
0.22465507686138153,
-0.7523276209831238,
-0.4902339577674866,
0.6691471338272095,
0.4644097089767456,
-0.23266758024692535,
-0.1430414617061615,
-0.1186135783791542,
0.25977593660354614,
0.15229156613349915,
0.5229215025901794,
0.5996747016906738,
-0.4792293608188629,
-0.24633541703224182,
0.18070575594902039,
0.5751305222511292,
0.14084886014461517,
0.6234975457191467,
-0.8660001158714294,
0.5758628249168396,
0.6930428147315979,
0.7976504564285278,
0.5181964635848999,
0.4796221852302551,
0.7391496300697327,
-0.6014735102653503,
-0.10529080033302307,
0.5079243183135986,
0.4339534044265747,
0.38831233978271484,
-0.18650764226913452,
0.7036141157150269,
-0.05927566811442375,
-0.8061732649803162,
-0.9769355654716492,
0.2143264263868332,
-0.7494074106216431,
-0.06942231208086014,
1.205030083656311,
-0.1767529994249344,
-0.12830467522144318,
-0.022110939025878906,
-0.15223899483680725,
-0.032265469431877136,
-0.40871742367744446,
0.6836804747581482,
0.4344482421875,
-0.5176210999488831,
-0.28377121686935425,
-0.2298346906900406,
0.5049899816513062,
0.4347805082798004,
-0.9334563612937927,
0.011191119439899921,
0.4452493190765381,
0.13278800249099731,
0.3798061013221741,
0.5343086123466492,
-0.31277862191200256,
0.2635210156440735,
0.32933667302131653,
-0.14070896804332733,
-0.2466997504234314,
-0.5522259473800659,
-0.14684168994426727,
0.33453211188316345,
0.1180894523859024,
0.3686557114124298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10646v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10646v2 | AbsInstruct: Eliciting Abstraction Ability from LLMs through Explanation Tuning with Plausibility Estimation | 2024-02-16T12:47:11 | 2024-06-17T16:39:02 | Zhaowei Wang, Wei Fan, Qing Zong, Hongming Zhang, Sehyun Choi, Tianqing Fang, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Ginny Y. Wong, Simon See | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abstraction ability is crucial in human intelligence, which can also benefit
various tasks in NLP study. Existing work shows that LLMs are deficient in
abstract ability, and how to improve it remains unexplored. In this work, we
design the framework AbsInstruct to enhance LLMs' abstraction ability through
instruction tuning. The framework builds instructions with in-depth
explanations to assist LLMs in capturing the underlying rationale of
abstraction. Meanwhile, we introduce a plausibility estimator to select
instructions that are more consistent with the abstraction knowledge of LLMs to
be aligned. Then, our framework combines abstraction instructions with
general-purpose ones to build a hybrid dataset. Extensive experiments and
analyses demonstrate that our framework can considerably enhance LLMs'
abstraction ability with strong generalization performance while maintaining
their general instruction-following abilities. | [
-0.24165286123752594,
-0.5746079683303833,
0.5796461701393127,
0.09026087075471878,
-0.16369764506816864,
0.22406050562858582,
-0.11005615442991257,
-0.35662737488746643,
0.1309635490179062,
0.2449006587266922,
-0.7211219072341919,
-0.6310499310493469,
-0.39771896600723267,
-0.06928841769695282,
-0.4872482717037201,
0.8441751599311829,
-0.11410146951675415,
-0.13612975180149078,
-0.75352942943573,
0.1351495087146759,
-0.38494592905044556,
0.021780075505375862,
-0.2991120517253876,
-0.5811804533004761,
-0.08759117871522903,
0.51273512840271,
0.4856189489364624,
0.948399007320404,
0.243528351187706,
0.38130342960357666,
-0.03881992772221565,
0.4343777894973755,
-0.214084193110466,
-0.13739177584648132,
-0.4534894526004791,
-0.6724911332130432,
-0.6728451251983643,
-0.3658641278743744,
0.507631242275238,
0.8147639036178589,
0.00180137122515589,
0.10707591474056244,
0.26476413011550903,
0.7037792801856995,
-0.843059778213501,
0.200545534491539,
-0.5859853029251099,
0.003754896577447653,
-0.007880113087594509,
-0.26348409056663513,
-0.39398667216300964,
-0.1709986925125122,
0.026358097791671753,
-0.7056819796562195,
0.21544580161571503,
0.0713738426566124,
0.47427141666412354,
0.4452384114265442,
-0.2139710932970047,
-0.24789118766784668,
-0.5441011190414429,
0.6898049712181091,
-0.7831820249557495,
0.09272856265306473,
0.4714767634868622,
0.07072007656097412,
-0.24316120147705078,
-0.6983384490013123,
-0.20746813714504242,
0.037988174706697464,
-0.16281765699386597,
0.3399980366230011,
-0.012511528097093105,
0.4605247676372528,
0.09353036433458328,
0.7156780958175659,
-0.4442450702190399,
0.39230629801750183,
-0.20487500727176666,
-0.43357837200164795,
0.6981480121612549,
0.21872027218341827,
0.3416910469532013,
0.14311069250106812,
-0.4496273994445801,
0.41973263025283813,
-0.676420271396637,
-0.036774780601263046,
0.46349525451660156,
-0.0054861619137227535,
-0.23608803749084473,
0.6868640780448914,
-0.23487287759780884,
0.8868395090103149,
0.18082748353481293,
0.023460058495402336,
0.27275264263153076,
-0.3632090985774994,
-0.19911587238311768,
0.24859057366847992,
0.3867320716381073,
0.1167929545044899,
0.1912156194448471,
-0.3642212748527527,
-0.29156631231307983,
0.09092611074447632,
0.2736071050167084,
-0.7041085362434387,
-0.30504944920539856,
0.5451062917709351,
-0.442234605550766,
0.08910591155290604,
0.23650825023651123,
-0.5659931302070618,
-0.3351157307624817,
-0.6306117177009583,
0.48569339513778687,
-0.7398971319198608,
-0.39837560057640076,
0.39225825667381287,
-0.10099741071462631,
0.29041460156440735,
0.22170332074165344,
-1.0658823251724243,
0.46189528703689575,
0.851673424243927,
0.80577552318573,
-0.3742012679576874,
-0.2071513533592224,
-0.41890379786491394,
0.33917856216430664,
-0.2037256360054016,
1.074284315109253,
-0.5482128858566284,
-0.3318835198879242,
-0.21747741103172302,
-0.18124452233314514,
-0.2991158068180084,
-0.6449194550514221,
0.5948675870895386,
-0.20281124114990234,
-0.0194043330848217,
0.10805324465036392,
-1.0527410507202148,
-0.40674886107444763,
-0.23833785951137543,
-0.4216919243335724,
0.7789822816848755,
0.1656339168548584,
-0.6507839560508728,
-0.049515124410390854,
-0.9164228439331055,
-0.6894020438194275,
0.25724050402641296,
-0.30291491746902466,
-0.3557906746864319,
0.48714515566825867,
0.2887156307697296,
0.3389922082424164,
-0.06897451728582382,
-0.02773251384496689,
-0.008674634620547295,
-0.7617636322975159,
0.18441693484783173,
-0.28451383113861084,
0.967939555644989,
-0.1421719342470169,
-0.3572942018508911,
0.16855613887310028,
-0.7790238261222839,
0.18309235572814941,
-0.268028199672699,
-0.27887484431266785,
-0.19591552019119263,
0.17341399192810059,
-0.6822141408920288,
-0.23478934168815613,
0.3336603343486786,
-0.3857591152191162,
-0.10561597347259521,
-0.9245198965072632,
0.22095759212970734,
0.8887690901756287,
0.16269798576831818,
0.7305383682250977,
-0.5321643352508545,
0.6416347622871399,
-0.07261907309293747,
-0.08805257827043533,
-0.18054497241973877,
-0.481256365776062,
-0.6923260688781738,
-0.6824110150337219,
0.18176791071891785,
0.7903810739517212,
-0.5982503294944763,
0.831493079662323,
-0.08833561837673187,
-0.22976206243038177,
-0.7249152064323425,
0.5425727367401123,
0.543856143951416,
0.6834682822227478,
0.5356475114822388,
-0.17188364267349243,
-0.6716640591621399,
-1.1782103776931763,
-0.26470136642456055,
0.008359026163816452,
-0.5335723757743835,
-0.07951129972934723,
0.5994291305541992,
-0.00009239988139597699,
1.0199280977249146,
-0.25848090648651123,
-0.16678129136562347,
-0.1714448481798172,
0.21192635595798492,
0.2102980762720108,
0.4505111277103424,
0.36421695351600647,
-0.5208725929260254,
-0.08096875250339508,
-0.06537970900535583,
-0.8365238308906555,
-0.3310900032520294,
-0.07402294129133224,
-0.279435932636261,
0.026665423065423965,
0.49168622493743896,
-0.4381304383277893,
0.5238620042800903,
0.3400645852088928,
-0.1896543651819229,
0.6914275884628296,
-0.21910029649734497,
-0.13688740134239197,
-0.9320672154426575,
-0.0996314138174057,
-0.011936037801206112,
0.007433612365275621,
-0.4331374764442444,
-0.057973768562078476,
-0.01917951926589012,
0.2421189397573471,
-0.41981199383735657,
0.3896039128303528,
-0.6365584135055542,
-0.2315150946378708,
-0.39046117663383484,
0.02026504836976528,
0.01090636570006609,
0.48798927664756775,
0.17159131169319153,
0.7819139361381531,
0.7660353779792786,
-0.7932571172714233,
0.20925749838352203,
0.2824886739253998,
-0.7369483113288879,
0.7189354300498962,
-0.8651971220970154,
0.04076239466667175,
-0.15942220389842987,
-0.0780988335609436,
-1.040819525718689,
-0.39140644669532776,
0.19125494360923767,
-0.20902332663536072,
0.21658621728420258,
-0.18938446044921875,
-0.3618834614753723,
0.028746221214532852,
-0.2700003981590271,
0.08022269606590271,
0.417117714881897,
-0.4942288100719452,
1.1390588283538818,
0.1623082458972931,
-0.1528371274471283,
-0.5577455759048462,
-0.7915865182876587,
-0.2961025536060333,
-0.15647217631340027,
-0.48621436953544617,
0.8037427663803101,
-0.2847846448421478,
-0.3206625282764435,
0.116737000644207,
-0.27362537384033203,
0.033637795597314835,
0.2489416003227234,
0.42135709524154663,
0.25939303636550903,
-0.34630900621414185,
0.03823329880833626,
0.5719864368438721,
-0.2334512621164322,
0.29733145236968994,
-0.06278815865516663,
0.23404262959957123,
-0.1954183578491211,
-0.7399556636810303,
-0.8995751142501831,
0.22302258014678955,
0.35865768790245056,
-0.2468336969614029,
0.6381518840789795,
0.2045697420835495,
-0.13600169122219086,
-0.48509061336517334,
-0.09522196650505066,
-0.3590208888053894,
-0.5432493090629578,
0.49204859137535095,
-0.32601359486579895,
-0.46999838948249817,
0.4586293697357178,
-0.4303017556667328,
0.5393404364585876,
0.019619513303041458,
0.4576368033885956,
-0.2643657326698303,
0.8761499524116516,
0.37741637229919434,
0.25080209970474243,
0.3674790859222412,
-0.380342960357666,
-0.1114283949136734,
-0.8882715702056885,
-0.3078480064868927,
-0.20484291017055511,
-0.6308200359344482,
-0.04599570110440254,
-0.2632947862148285,
0.1771649867296219,
0.20533937215805054,
-0.39072364568710327,
0.004972696769982576,
-0.5307966470718384,
0.7254014611244202,
0.4773160517215729,
0.427801251411438,
0.4924204349517822,
0.2682962119579315,
-0.0915389433503151,
-0.07151871174573898,
-0.7060936689376831,
-0.38831669092178345,
0.8498178720474243,
0.3252668082714081,
0.5835500359535217,
0.25725385546684265,
0.5958525538444519,
0.173479825258255,
0.4469737112522125,
-0.8970721364021301,
0.6904667019844055,
-0.21778234839439392,
-0.4532056450843811,
0.030194459483027458,
-0.3014217019081116,
-0.5040743350982666,
0.17628687620162964,
-0.37907513976097107,
-0.7249265909194946,
0.024454761296510696,
0.401355504989624,
-0.22044357657432556,
0.16898082196712494,
-0.7898658514022827,
0.4804776906967163,
-0.5616948008537292,
-0.3387426733970642,
-0.16211923956871033,
-0.5088061094284058,
0.5592034459114075,
0.026827743276953697,
0.17002901434898376,
-0.09997134655714035,
-0.4483286738395691,
0.6183651089668274,
-0.37271368503570557,
1.209531545639038,
-0.10003127157688141,
-0.14253388345241547,
0.1734291911125183,
0.12312847375869751,
0.2928617298603058,
0.04844171553850174,
-0.431476891040802,
0.10520127415657043,
-0.4071202278137207,
-0.34818562865257263,
-0.860522985458374,
0.5715586543083191,
-0.6098679304122925,
-0.7659220695495605,
0.08695200830698013,
-0.8597100377082825,
-0.43972936272621155,
0.03906923532485962,
0.4304952323436737,
0.38499608635902405,
0.036478787660598755,
0.1388748288154602,
0.862687349319458,
0.028817452490329742,
0.43385010957717896,
0.4481821358203888,
0.16602341830730438,
-0.42231398820877075,
0.8523304462432861,
-0.07230693846940994,
0.36740627884864807,
0.600957989692688,
0.14482234418392181,
-0.41285276412963867,
-0.9464330673217773,
-0.4280279576778412,
0.202346533536911,
-0.6959125995635986,
-0.29860153794288635,
-0.16105122864246368,
-0.31974321603775024,
0.030770910903811455,
-0.4193226397037506,
-0.33613646030426025,
-0.450055330991745,
-0.3173336386680603,
-0.4892481565475464,
0.4304240942001343,
0.4606735408306122,
-0.0636838972568512,
0.39341211318969727,
-0.4040057957172394,
0.36513152718544006,
0.16375161707401276,
0.35475021600723267,
0.0445181243121624,
-0.8448086977005005,
-0.20062851905822754,
0.2097213864326477,
-0.08918607980012894,
-0.7193769216537476,
-0.07036419957876205,
0.4953114092350006,
0.9958576560020447,
0.7033374309539795,
0.293856680393219,
0.6914528608322144,
-0.2167128324508667,
0.30759111046791077,
0.0573093518614769,
-1.1675105094909668,
0.6316536068916321,
0.023103438317775726,
0.35728564858436584,
0.5490828156471252,
0.36106690764427185,
0.31363433599472046,
-0.49382027983665466,
-0.4787927269935608,
-1.0700873136520386,
0.6129845380783081,
0.3055429458618164,
0.052546314895153046,
0.290911465883255,
0.5434846878051758,
0.3008013665676117,
0.2008381336927414,
-0.4981217384338379,
-0.31660065054893494,
-0.1679699718952179,
-0.5817841291427612,
0.3065798878669739,
-0.14399108290672302,
-0.37295836210250854,
-0.2947324216365814,
0.6696004271507263,
-0.16361437737941742,
0.21164275705814362,
-0.12169443070888519,
-0.20421983301639557,
0.11528464406728745,
0.11931904405355453,
0.507436215877533,
1.0348906517028809,
-0.1540900617837906,
0.14136001467704773,
0.1690499633550644,
-0.3876613974571228,
0.11063288897275925,
0.09861074388027191,
-0.30145344138145447,
-0.1657174825668335,
0.7813446521759033,
0.6806154251098633,
0.3207831382751465,
-0.6991108655929565,
0.3066423535346985,
0.20961079001426697,
-0.4842968285083771,
-0.36794009804725647,
0.5134074687957764,
0.35563838481903076,
0.12419058382511139,
0.45112213492393494,
0.05583451688289642,
0.07460108399391174,
-0.20852582156658173,
0.31773641705513,
0.3995770514011383,
-0.059204015880823135,
-0.30202117562294006,
0.6440079212188721,
0.389853835105896,
-0.37830641865730286,
0.5926268100738525,
-0.07051415741443634,
-0.089879110455513,
0.6980754733085632,
0.6440433263778687,
0.8019052743911743,
-0.2948692739009857,
0.30813318490982056,
0.08851911872625351,
0.18498970568180084,
0.022463936358690262,
0.2892378270626068,
-0.2703075110912323,
-0.9004427194595337,
-0.8357962965965271,
-0.6005105972290039,
-0.3894440233707428,
0.11524265259504318,
-0.7188174724578857,
0.010126124136149883,
-0.6121290326118469,
0.29109126329421997,
-0.026938777416944504,
-0.22835075855255127,
-0.3144516944885254,
-0.04305047541856766,
-0.2133771777153015,
0.9359327554702759,
-1.0551573038101196,
0.3742884397506714,
0.8271242380142212,
-0.2870137691497803,
-0.4370113015174866,
-0.016185780987143517,
0.1456243395805359,
-0.768129289150238,
0.4846712350845337,
0.2261226773262024,
-0.4577549993991852,
0.20892341434955597,
-0.5705466866493225,
-0.5108398795127869,
1.225298285484314,
0.8408387899398804,
-0.44207924604415894,
0.18280448019504547,
-0.06486885249614716,
0.41711872816085815,
-0.6016226410865784,
0.16422006487846375,
0.6501837968826294,
0.49670490622520447,
0.16129186749458313,
-0.5173822641372681,
0.07605281472206116,
-0.15561753511428833,
-0.028006600216031075,
0.08062949776649475,
-0.12322089076042175,
0.33363035321235657,
-0.39963388442993164,
-0.408110111951828,
0.24296732246875763,
0.948157787322998,
0.5440394878387451,
0.3579157292842865,
0.5033097863197327,
0.5242549180984497,
0.6980945467948914,
0.06320465356111526,
0.8723136186599731,
-0.4016859531402588,
-0.2696342170238495,
1.3098814487457275,
0.01570608839392662,
0.685318648815155,
0.3699905574321747,
-0.03888256475329399,
0.8915625810623169,
0.5233355760574341,
0.18644198775291443,
0.5321885943412781,
0.09962698072195053,
-0.5714166164398193,
-0.334661602973938,
0.024642447009682655,
-0.13675779104232788,
0.5925348401069641,
0.7189568281173706,
-0.5118961334228516,
-0.11910900473594666,
-0.1946088969707489,
-0.11677908152341843,
0.40879979729652405,
-0.6128726005554199,
0.7914870381355286,
0.0614309124648571,
-0.502705991268158,
0.5147711038589478,
-0.05056789144873619,
0.6401306986808777,
-0.6826989054679871,
-0.20902122557163239,
-0.2716033160686493,
0.26099491119384766,
-0.7177541851997375,
-0.849667489528656,
0.451224148273468,
-0.3972479999065399,
-0.20232437551021576,
-0.07392387837171555,
0.5624861717224121,
-0.284403532743454,
-0.5118024349212646,
0.10353025794029236,
0.6100150942802429,
0.2591220736503601,
0.1769213229417801,
-0.7702648639678955,
-0.13642455637454987,
0.11218176782131195,
-0.08375562727451324,
0.3027553856372833,
0.3606107234954834,
0.10425905138254166,
0.7596963047981262,
0.4578888714313507,
0.1411345899105072,
-0.35008013248443604,
-0.08260548114776611,
0.704986572265625,
-0.25190943479537964,
-0.2475450336933136,
-0.8870935440063477,
0.8338006138801575,
-0.24456608295440674,
-0.18074682354927063,
0.6709019541740417,
0.6383388042449951,
0.5986689925193787,
-0.1256047636270523,
0.894204318523407,
0.022469570860266685,
0.36830148100852966,
-0.8912035226821899,
0.344512403011322,
-0.34730663895606995,
0.7282120585441589,
0.07554206997156143,
-0.7928684949874878,
-0.24619118869304657,
0.6947606801986694,
-0.399693101644516,
0.04119042307138443,
0.44865795969963074,
1.0517035722732544,
-0.36211660504341125,
0.11095091700553894,
0.06815452128648758,
0.15362420678138733,
-0.09142165631055832,
0.5628212690353394,
0.6342907547950745,
0.027973037213087082,
0.4321865439414978,
-0.35027360916137695,
-0.5147801041603088,
0.055124927312135696,
-0.984483003616333,
-1.048162817955017,
-0.3105050027370453,
-0.48212701082229614,
-0.14128483831882477,
0.07494114339351654,
0.6676518321037292,
0.6067478060722351,
-0.8918620347976685,
-0.2794998288154602,
-0.49841779470443726,
0.4022987484931946,
-0.7025289535522461,
-0.24916215240955353,
0.5993897318840027,
-0.1695060282945633,
-0.7453784346580505,
0.6975995302200317,
0.4299866259098053,
0.04164576902985573,
-0.22617313265800476,
-0.10559303313493729,
-0.19588857889175415,
0.003831901354715228,
0.517826497554779,
0.4714362919330597,
-0.570268452167511,
-0.06036053225398064,
-0.15956759452819824,
0.40802353620529175,
-0.05324118584394455,
0.8181454539299011,
-0.6804004907608032,
0.2888983190059662,
0.4191645085811615,
0.8257396817207336,
0.12503370642662048,
0.45378315448760986,
0.862309455871582,
-1.0321592092514038,
0.16152821481227875,
0.29359644651412964,
0.4379374384880066,
0.3687679171562195,
-0.4529459476470947,
0.5547667741775513,
0.07527211308479309,
-0.3479386866092682,
-0.5592921376228333,
0.5475156307220459,
-0.726935863494873,
-0.5696108937263489,
0.9431596994400024,
-0.18926602602005005,
-0.25532931089401245,
-0.6024300456047058,
0.011316266842186451,
-0.0801357850432396,
-0.24802257120609283,
0.7986836433410645,
0.378086656332016,
-0.9057467579841614,
-0.36829888820648193,
-0.39971646666526794,
0.4137929677963257,
0.4212232232093811,
-0.9011836647987366,
-0.025455648079514503,
0.49196434020996094,
0.3090205788612366,
0.09338922053575516,
0.4325788915157318,
-0.07321559637784958,
0.34908708930015564,
0.06090010330080986,
-0.0377822108566761,
-0.5097925662994385,
-0.12408105283975601,
-0.10592665523290634,
0.13219912350177765,
-0.0781463161110878,
-0.335825651884079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10645v1 | Can Separators Improve Chain-of-Thought Prompting? | 2024-02-16T12:46:16 | 2024-02-16T12:46:16 | Yoonjeong Park, Hyunjin Kim, Chanyeol Choi, Junseong Kim, Jy-yong Sohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting is a simple and effective method for
improving the reasoning capabilities of Large language models (LLMs). The basic
idea of CoT is to let LLMs break down their thought processes step-by-step by
putting exemplars in the input prompt. However, the densely structured prompt
exemplars of CoT may cause the cognitive overload of LLMs. Inspired by human
cognition, we introduce CoT-Sep, a novel method that strategically employs
separators at the end of each exemplar in CoT prompting. These separators are
designed to help the LLMs understand their thought processes better while
reasoning. It turns out that CoT-Sep significantly improves the LLMs'
performances on complex reasoning tasks (e.g., GSM-8K, AQuA, CSQA), compared
with the vanilla CoT, which does not use separators. We also study the effects
of the type and the location of separators tested on multiple LLMs, including
GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and LLaMA-2 7B. Interestingly, the type/location of
separators should be chosen appropriately to boost the reasoning capability of
CoT. | [
-0.8312956094741821,
-0.9333204030990601,
0.8200292587280273,
-0.007324848789721727,
-0.6171959042549133,
0.506759762763977,
-0.36466601490974426,
-0.5410311222076416,
0.23420710861682892,
0.47570765018463135,
-0.309339314699173,
-0.22498942911624908,
-0.5239258408546448,
0.30318552255630493,
-0.32899412512779236,
1.009313941001892,
-0.15458087623119354,
-0.046013083308935165,
0.039785321801900864,
0.13445143401622772,
-0.7170755863189697,
-0.6947752237319946,
-0.7637097835540771,
-0.17978830635547638,
0.784213662147522,
0.31170767545700073,
0.4525800943374634,
0.41466811299324036,
0.4447774291038513,
0.31252172589302063,
-0.6630129814147949,
0.5415685176849365,
-0.3171193301677704,
0.4134642481803894,
-0.42733290791511536,
-0.6878651976585388,
-0.21822282671928406,
-0.20646502077579498,
0.4817488193511963,
0.5338214635848999,
-0.17293015122413635,
-0.14567184448242188,
0.030641892924904823,
0.823584794998169,
-0.8875266909599304,
-0.17416319251060486,
-0.5913439989089966,
-0.05513577163219452,
-0.09716013073921204,
-0.16494859755039215,
-0.6084670424461365,
-0.36959710717201233,
0.16456389427185059,
-0.2095380276441574,
0.09907294064760208,
0.15094874799251556,
0.5295243263244629,
0.21429698169231415,
-0.3305583894252777,
-0.22210507094860077,
-0.7697631120681763,
0.6362190246582031,
-0.3039712607860565,
0.24490833282470703,
0.06228550896048546,
0.4155687987804413,
-0.39475709199905396,
-0.525282084941864,
-0.685748279094696,
0.0889035239815712,
-0.014773405157029629,
-0.061840128153562546,
0.15523391962051392,
0.24674129486083984,
0.6078886389732361,
0.2206580489873886,
-0.07209651172161102,
-0.09344339370727539,
-0.800571084022522,
-0.08866386860609055,
0.36522749066352844,
0.24109677970409393,
0.44644445180892944,
0.11581474542617798,
-0.5293799042701721,
-0.003601298201829195,
-0.8580471277236938,
0.25752273201942444,
0.09273908287286758,
0.2690857946872711,
0.2014053612947464,
0.27005070447921753,
-0.043990299105644226,
0.7668721675872803,
0.22000940144062042,
-0.275533527135849,
-0.10777583718299866,
-0.2216709703207016,
-0.154495969414711,
0.3219478130340576,
0.6501091122627258,
0.2146080583333969,
0.31554365158081055,
0.14856697618961334,
-0.31977957487106323,
0.0803404301404953,
0.1416884958744049,
-0.6844977736473083,
-0.39857593178749084,
0.24700909852981567,
-0.26491326093673706,
-0.25061899423599243,
0.10193948447704315,
-0.7169203162193298,
-0.44941189885139465,
-0.43983015418052673,
0.18656213581562042,
-0.3291400969028473,
-0.2587875723838806,
0.13735787570476532,
-0.32808929681777954,
0.2465670257806778,
0.5361464023590088,
-0.8475679755210876,
0.42628607153892517,
0.5855619311332703,
0.7372880578041077,
-0.28420326113700867,
-0.23729592561721802,
-0.8510023355484009,
0.08464501798152924,
-0.3662790358066559,
1.2619798183441162,
-0.7860221266746521,
-0.3272634744644165,
-0.27598243951797485,
-0.09663025289773941,
-0.28578463196754456,
-0.7070831656455994,
0.46308469772338867,
-0.5288482308387756,
0.20279622077941895,
-0.9673927426338196,
-0.410368412733078,
-0.19071364402770996,
0.3168848156929016,
-0.8763730525970459,
0.8096473217010498,
-0.17605163156986237,
-0.5812276005744934,
0.4347652196884155,
-0.5834041833877563,
-0.4131739139556885,
-0.11972338706254959,
-0.48504048585891724,
0.03992259129881859,
0.05264408513903618,
0.660810112953186,
0.003709181910380721,
-0.6539092063903809,
0.22413860261440277,
-0.235409677028656,
-0.3344874382019043,
0.5014575719833374,
-0.3579631745815277,
0.7278158068656921,
0.19350697100162506,
-0.2514776885509491,
0.16350466012954712,
-0.4931410551071167,
0.13002029061317444,
-0.27497515082359314,
-0.20920148491859436,
-0.24385926127433777,
-0.04461770877242088,
-0.43514302372932434,
0.6722899675369263,
-0.06434998661279678,
-0.4753361940383911,
0.15425631403923035,
-0.14428472518920898,
0.43109849095344543,
0.853018581867218,
0.1655782163143158,
0.45000338554382324,
-0.31900545954704285,
0.7812408804893494,
0.30876120924949646,
0.11909245699644089,
-0.13231933116912842,
-0.6099464893341064,
-0.7662818431854248,
-0.6704290509223938,
0.22008833289146423,
0.37433040142059326,
-0.734737753868103,
0.5381857752799988,
0.3200652003288269,
-0.27245670557022095,
-0.37171056866645813,
0.0753779411315918,
0.44311946630477905,
0.5599921941757202,
0.47775891423225403,
-0.30763548612594604,
-0.5696483850479126,
-0.3918922245502472,
-0.09082610160112381,
-0.15473726391792297,
0.20657995343208313,
-0.2681027948856354,
0.3774060010910034,
0.2566004991531372,
0.9856163263320923,
-0.6742255687713623,
0.03601713478565216,
-0.5107017755508423,
-0.09030619263648987,
0.11358171701431274,
0.22183075547218323,
0.18360714614391327,
-0.4829067587852478,
-0.21602599322795868,
-0.09753163158893585,
-0.5337960124015808,
-0.1965004950761795,
-0.26930510997772217,
-0.686730682849884,
0.01604020968079567,
0.4965253472328186,
-0.9204171895980835,
0.46019935607910156,
0.13967488706111908,
-0.3297983705997467,
0.9715810418128967,
-0.19430376589298248,
0.03421597182750702,
-0.8932898640632629,
-0.09274933487176895,
-0.46007174253463745,
-0.11967668682336807,
-0.5155039429664612,
-0.14478690922260284,
0.04822942242026329,
0.15722563862800598,
-0.6210383176803589,
0.3288135826587677,
-0.5846439599990845,
0.010752540081739426,
-0.4012601673603058,
0.36498257517814636,
0.4402174949645996,
0.2755197584629059,
0.10448809713125229,
0.9156248569488525,
0.6233619451522827,
-0.6937370300292969,
0.14103378355503082,
0.3769468367099762,
-0.24429848790168762,
0.4019734859466553,
-0.4801480770111084,
0.3025497794151306,
-0.24292689561843872,
0.7925931215286255,
-1.0131782293319702,
0.01007920689880848,
0.14652568101882935,
0.056088075041770935,
-0.10328200459480286,
-0.034600209444761276,
-0.4050776958465576,
-0.43612951040267944,
-0.4224475026130676,
0.5856738090515137,
0.42734718322753906,
-0.9514809250831604,
0.5045185089111328,
0.24146009981632233,
-0.008873832412064075,
-0.5169820189476013,
-0.5980153679847717,
0.03792337328195572,
-0.3373243808746338,
-0.36688828468322754,
0.025164902210235596,
-0.02673405408859253,
-0.34254929423332214,
-0.3010983467102051,
-0.28155481815338135,
0.028618304058909416,
-0.05850263684988022,
0.026722028851509094,
0.48072201013565063,
0.006543581373989582,
0.25759491324424744,
0.39534658193588257,
-0.1669507920742035,
0.3002309799194336,
-0.37507039308547974,
0.7620622515678406,
-0.19659367203712463,
-0.2880326509475708,
-0.3445122539997101,
0.22299844026565552,
0.5817670226097107,
-0.48424282670021057,
0.9178102016448975,
0.30291947722435,
-0.15160971879959106,
-0.27212050557136536,
-0.8135493993759155,
-0.18052630126476288,
-0.5091325640678406,
-0.3087673485279083,
-0.543775737285614,
-0.9061651229858398,
0.6482971906661987,
-0.2729223072528839,
-0.18267491459846497,
0.11838512867689133,
0.5036856532096863,
-0.10630275309085846,
1.0129746198654175,
0.20585337281227112,
-0.0384039469063282,
0.45480871200561523,
-0.2730959355831146,
0.6161685585975647,
-1.3604105710983276,
-0.24095392227172852,
-0.2953363358974457,
-0.5115028619766235,
-0.4371489882469177,
-0.5905809998512268,
0.18026107549667358,
0.5619304180145264,
-0.23714159429073334,
0.08254804462194443,
-0.8210830688476562,
1.1363916397094727,
0.24517834186553955,
0.19167044758796692,
0.3397670090198517,
-0.03753335773944855,
-0.5735867023468018,
0.38033774495124817,
-0.5650884509086609,
-0.5631439089775085,
0.6632130146026611,
-0.019534602761268616,
0.8138388395309448,
0.025195663794875145,
0.8722831010818481,
-0.044733740389347076,
0.17697714269161224,
-0.621173083782196,
0.7370090484619141,
0.07752091437578201,
-0.499662309885025,
-0.10400506854057312,
-0.384051114320755,
-0.9122505784034729,
0.4719351828098297,
0.07889264076948166,
-1.0059677362442017,
0.45475587248802185,
0.025834884494543076,
-0.6514375805854797,
0.5909972786903381,
-0.740847110748291,
0.4326127767562866,
-0.3147808015346527,
-0.15842494368553162,
-0.08993358910083771,
-0.6472111344337463,
0.2824098467826843,
-0.042472124099731445,
-0.01949724182486534,
-0.07160946726799011,
-0.1604335457086563,
0.7278302907943726,
-0.8571288585662842,
0.7293080687522888,
-0.1434684544801712,
-0.19394242763519287,
0.8554765582084656,
0.19429579377174377,
0.649551272392273,
-0.21010714769363403,
-0.05329370126128197,
-0.18603461980819702,
-0.11818563938140869,
-0.1985984742641449,
-0.874356210231781,
0.42831870913505554,
-0.6426199078559875,
-0.7809171676635742,
-0.26124054193496704,
-0.5734601616859436,
-0.039627742022275925,
0.04398495331406593,
0.2940889894962311,
0.49508339166641235,
0.37545502185821533,
-0.062260884791612625,
0.5635783076286316,
-0.055065784603357315,
0.45001375675201416,
0.1401098072528839,
-0.300106018781662,
-0.8361719250679016,
0.5768325328826904,
0.15913181006908417,
0.6276664733886719,
0.299669474363327,
0.34320932626724243,
-0.5165572166442871,
-0.3163670003414154,
-0.3649905025959015,
0.2663079798221588,
-0.987836480140686,
-0.22094707190990448,
-0.7418252825737,
-0.20665110647678375,
0.0054227435030043125,
-0.4351968765258789,
-0.025768805295228958,
-0.7396687865257263,
-0.050838571041822433,
-0.5360112190246582,
0.514100968837738,
0.7654291391372681,
0.08396115899085999,
0.16742266714572906,
-0.7253527045249939,
0.1782313585281372,
0.4208208918571472,
0.1029256135225296,
0.18392175436019897,
-0.23044438660144806,
0.011077811941504478,
-0.12505054473876953,
-0.3509078621864319,
-0.6798790693283081,
0.1385059505701065,
-0.2863772511482239,
0.3955020606517792,
0.5763034820556641,
0.23133845627307892,
1.1153613328933716,
-0.33087459206581116,
0.8220230937004089,
0.4062514901161194,
-1.02752685546875,
0.693632185459137,
-0.2333420217037201,
0.49066609144210815,
0.6681492328643799,
0.029334656894207,
-0.3768061101436615,
-0.7929266095161438,
-0.42081964015960693,
-0.8458842039108276,
0.6846908926963806,
0.2509942352771759,
-0.41995152831077576,
-0.552643358707428,
0.26089373230934143,
0.1188584715127945,
0.08821163326501846,
-0.31723538041114807,
0.17079955339431763,
0.4203653633594513,
-0.06918861716985703,
0.36429160833358765,
-0.2215135544538498,
-0.14424681663513184,
-0.25818684697151184,
0.389700710773468,
-0.0035024299286305904,
0.10250650346279144,
0.4134032130241394,
-0.20847833156585693,
-0.13318444788455963,
0.36734089255332947,
0.5489585995674133,
0.773090124130249,
0.09862160682678223,
0.5601999163627625,
0.6302711367607117,
-0.41964882612228394,
0.4881739914417267,
-0.33903422951698303,
-0.18450284004211426,
-0.26744216680526733,
0.20268826186656952,
0.5867727994918823,
-0.21456080675125122,
-0.6893898844718933,
0.12499456107616425,
-0.28052741289138794,
0.06814388930797577,
0.034393541514873505,
0.39032700657844543,
0.04712899029254913,
0.2901325523853302,
0.06561443209648132,
0.24570783972740173,
0.07696643471717834,
-0.4140617847442627,
0.010983173735439777,
0.019981516525149345,
-0.3164908289909363,
-0.1761840432882309,
0.5040060877799988,
0.47217637300491333,
-0.34419602155685425,
0.4723360538482666,
-0.15262770652770996,
-0.811336874961853,
0.7529837489128113,
0.8253894448280334,
1.002403974533081,
-0.19783170521259308,
0.049864862114191055,
0.23801781237125397,
0.3162462115287781,
-0.4093359410762787,
0.4160352349281311,
-0.5333309769630432,
-0.6897602677345276,
-0.6625252366065979,
-0.2754650413990021,
-0.5439682602882385,
-0.2207043468952179,
-0.6198241710662842,
0.3723870515823364,
-0.6452585458755493,
-0.3296529948711395,
-0.3924616873264313,
-0.12483466416597366,
-0.5385082960128784,
0.12438417226076126,
0.4120376408100128,
0.9459735751152039,
-0.6303814053535461,
0.7021832466125488,
0.5779971480369568,
-0.39154306054115295,
-1.0492439270019531,
0.1394125074148178,
-0.04376423731446266,
-0.16492223739624023,
0.5232993960380554,
0.5865514278411865,
-0.6013363003730774,
-0.411112904548645,
-0.39513564109802246,
-0.9410203099250793,
1.0330049991607666,
0.32282599806785583,
-0.7427161931991577,
0.15664063394069672,
0.2516742944717407,
0.6270197629928589,
-0.45040348172187805,
0.7277864217758179,
0.8276817202568054,
0.2934282720088959,
0.02628450281918049,
-0.7907757759094238,
0.4262292683124542,
-0.1356368064880371,
0.14347834885120392,
0.6175373792648315,
-0.7496146559715271,
0.8339653611183167,
-0.4741494357585907,
-0.170548215508461,
-0.015326528809964657,
0.42943626642227173,
0.8936081528663635,
0.15380993485450745,
0.8099977970123291,
0.474124550819397,
1.2921346426010132,
0.017314907163381577,
0.8144091367721558,
-0.247395858168602,
0.06892723590135574,
1.3260687589645386,
-0.6239974498748779,
0.8415799736976624,
0.6422788500785828,
0.0393519401550293,
0.9398380517959595,
0.3539649248123169,
0.5193026661872864,
0.30657216906547546,
0.3497322201728821,
-0.5570750832557678,
-0.3286453187465668,
-0.10156840085983276,
-0.27496081590652466,
0.17538981139659882,
0.48526424169540405,
-0.2838013768196106,
-0.141355499625206,
0.11721903085708618,
0.12591855227947235,
-0.23486025631427765,
-0.09656640142202377,
0.8328149318695068,
0.2892352342605591,
-0.9717212319374084,
0.748236894607544,
-0.5822126865386963,
0.21229329705238342,
-0.2960550785064697,
0.025194087997078896,
-0.1351729780435562,
0.2544149160385132,
-0.2863284647464752,
-1.0046995878219604,
0.13720421493053436,
0.25499802827835083,
-0.06347449123859406,
-0.1882789134979248,
0.8286498188972473,
-0.5075974464416504,
-0.36978796124458313,
0.5778658986091614,
0.5042718052864075,
0.22915522754192352,
-0.12047675997018814,
-0.3987935483455658,
0.2015577256679535,
-0.04725320637226105,
-0.23670588433742523,
0.1716803014278412,
0.8456569314002991,
-0.3914509415626526,
0.7379963994026184,
0.8925865888595581,
0.06550154089927673,
-0.12532958388328552,
0.5069509744644165,
1.3046562671661377,
-0.986026406288147,
-0.618927538394928,
-1.0878880023956299,
0.549400269985199,
-0.3239940404891968,
-0.23300054669380188,
0.36586567759513855,
0.5408603549003601,
0.6637758016586304,
0.21032962203025818,
0.7911539077758789,
-0.11441528052091599,
0.11136632412672043,
-0.5223684310913086,
0.39315080642700195,
0.04576814919710159,
0.6201245188713074,
-0.25718772411346436,
-0.981620728969574,
-0.24717675149440765,
0.46955135464668274,
-0.5978638529777527,
-0.06111231818795204,
1.2465707063674927,
0.7962696552276611,
0.2056964784860611,
0.49162280559539795,
0.1895257532596588,
0.0779304951429367,
0.6881972551345825,
0.5383676886558533,
1.4677574634552002,
-0.04655420780181885,
0.678950846195221,
-0.2596796154975891,
-0.1808588206768036,
0.07423499971628189,
-0.5016741752624512,
-1.2135316133499146,
-0.20331871509552002,
-0.24399039149284363,
-0.2900683283805847,
0.05912423133850098,
1.349319577217102,
0.47992515563964844,
-0.6712732315063477,
-0.2120971828699112,
-0.4407336413860321,
0.35122859477996826,
-0.2625068128108978,
-0.20227859914302826,
0.26011812686920166,
-0.6216238737106323,
-0.24608804285526276,
0.29353347420692444,
0.46668946743011475,
-0.2404565066099167,
-0.07395472377538681,
0.10592454671859741,
-0.22959108650684357,
0.14972655475139618,
0.8437812328338623,
-0.12765957415103912,
-0.855793833732605,
-0.40551021695137024,
-0.1810750812292099,
0.12733131647109985,
0.2258334457874298,
0.99723219871521,
-1.049767017364502,
0.593361496925354,
0.8481581807136536,
0.283777117729187,
0.36584487557411194,
0.2778123915195465,
0.6798515319824219,
-0.43284469842910767,
0.15845170617103577,
0.13226592540740967,
0.518516480922699,
0.1343681961297989,
-0.5119835138320923,
0.4456777274608612,
-0.042185746133327484,
-0.6528990268707275,
-0.6361420750617981,
0.2895960211753845,
-0.9213286638259888,
-0.15009267628192902,
1.2214471101760864,
-0.02465064451098442,
-0.623103678226471,
-0.2587665915489197,
-0.7911564111709595,
0.08496087044477463,
-0.6728538274765015,
0.9066566824913025,
0.8158281445503235,
-0.3245653212070465,
-0.23587088286876678,
-0.01821749471127987,
0.27487653493881226,
0.45057496428489685,
-1.207971215248108,
0.2380971908569336,
0.1742384135723114,
0.10487087815999985,
0.271590918302536,
0.6351154446601868,
-0.24510444700717926,
0.4317561984062195,
-0.0660468190908432,
-0.046177156269550323,
0.233985036611557,
-0.5499773025512695,
-0.14842654764652252,
0.0036717639304697514,
0.05716399848461151,
-0.18931204080581665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10644v2 | Linear Transformers with Learnable Kernel Functions are Better In-Context Models | 2024-02-16T12:44:15 | 2024-06-05T14:13:22 | Yaroslav Aksenov, Nikita Balagansky, Sofia Maria Lo Cicero Vaina, Boris Shaposhnikov, Alexey Gorbatovski, Daniil Gavrilov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Advancing the frontier of subquadratic architectures for Language Models
(LMs) is crucial in the rapidly evolving field of natural language processing.
Current innovations, including State Space Models, were initially celebrated
for surpassing Transformer performance on language modeling tasks. However,
these models have revealed deficiencies in essential In-Context Learning
capabilities - a domain where the Transformer traditionally shines. The Based
model emerged as a hybrid solution, blending a Linear Transformer with a kernel
inspired by the Taylor expansion of exponential functions, augmented by
convolutional networks. Mirroring the Transformer's in-context adeptness, it
became a strong contender in the field. In our work, we present a singular,
elegant alteration to the Based kernel that amplifies its In-Context Learning
abilities evaluated with the Multi-Query Associative Recall task and overall
language modeling process, as demonstrated on the Pile dataset. | [
-0.22127765417099,
-0.6842712163925171,
0.3739514946937561,
-0.061218854039907455,
-0.025028081610798836,
0.08405736833810806,
-0.1600644439458847,
-0.39330974221229553,
0.2633921802043915,
0.19414696097373962,
-0.13117733597755432,
-0.06616504490375519,
-0.5846686959266663,
0.000017689466403680854,
-0.8284507989883423,
0.9381563067436218,
0.1421041339635849,
-0.06444629281759262,
-0.5021287798881531,
-0.35391414165496826,
-0.2963904142379761,
-0.5305351614952087,
-0.3626278042793274,
-0.5178771018981934,
0.21324308216571808,
0.07090821117162704,
0.8428372144699097,
0.22904391586780548,
0.17538490891456604,
0.2940143644809723,
-0.14936530590057373,
-0.002351653529331088,
-0.522089421749115,
0.14797520637512207,
-0.0027484439779073,
-0.3563675582408905,
-0.3345791697502136,
-0.26798081398010254,
0.6876795887947083,
0.9266493320465088,
-0.29340341687202454,
-0.1609249711036682,
0.17381209135055542,
0.583696722984314,
-0.594914972782135,
0.15161237120628357,
-0.867755651473999,
-0.037884052842855453,
0.07326386123895645,
-0.12914763391017914,
-0.7544307708740234,
-0.20554213225841522,
0.2675386071205139,
-0.668589174747467,
0.24029594659805298,
-0.07573648542165756,
0.6770113110542297,
0.21445365250110626,
-0.38557010889053345,
-0.3979499042034149,
-0.9272412061691284,
0.784005343914032,
-0.6305489540100098,
0.816992998123169,
0.017818428575992584,
0.45995450019836426,
-0.27788469195365906,
-0.9768142104148865,
-0.6288198232650757,
-0.2903505563735962,
-0.370538592338562,
0.08775461465120316,
-0.20691634714603424,
-0.13467352092266083,
0.10940128564834595,
0.5750765204429626,
-0.22586959600448608,
0.1442040205001831,
-0.41848766803741455,
-0.23824603855609894,
0.16850478947162628,
0.035911574959754944,
0.1381133645772934,
-0.1784781962633133,
-0.5530453324317932,
-0.14557529985904694,
-0.7602632641792297,
0.4734399914741516,
0.04071618616580963,
0.40029963850975037,
-0.11643525213003159,
0.30420875549316406,
-0.0687207579612732,
0.6240121126174927,
0.0982530489563942,
-0.05339328944683075,
0.15882942080497742,
-0.0212444756180048,
-0.26405391097068787,
-0.2145582139492035,
0.4016556441783905,
-0.1300346851348877,
-0.012657335959374905,
-0.21095158159732819,
-0.50033038854599,
0.1259383261203766,
0.47492241859436035,
-0.49238452315330505,
-0.44347846508026123,
0.18031302094459534,
-0.3909724950790405,
0.059669915586709976,
0.0011544323060661554,
-0.4663933217525482,
-0.3095061779022217,
-0.31824159622192383,
0.5287133455276489,
-0.6342725157737732,
-0.15309788286685944,
0.08545593172311783,
0.05297597497701645,
0.30144402384757996,
0.2596445381641388,
-0.9162308573722839,
0.5139345526695251,
0.7196984887123108,
0.7482823133468628,
-0.10281568765640259,
0.14528068900108337,
-0.6399301290512085,
-0.12380935996770859,
-0.34807467460632324,
0.7013968825340271,
-0.737223744392395,
-0.5965518355369568,
0.24329647421836853,
-0.20228031277656555,
-0.1579391360282898,
-0.6235160231590271,
0.5828394889831543,
-0.7731186747550964,
0.4074651598930359,
-0.20875516533851624,
-0.6662166714668274,
-0.27588289976119995,
-0.016460178419947624,
-0.8165712952613831,
1.3256703615188599,
0.3385532796382904,
-0.5240635275840759,
0.41882142424583435,
-0.7730860114097595,
-0.5308361649513245,
0.5410398244857788,
-0.18149082362651825,
-0.4717462956905365,
0.1664930135011673,
0.24568848311901093,
0.4822690486907959,
0.041218601167201996,
0.39590224623680115,
-0.18057698011398315,
-0.3299233913421631,
0.0792645737528801,
-0.09134534746408463,
0.7454541921615601,
-0.007246048655360937,
-0.1275414228439331,
0.26285722851753235,
-0.7457376718521118,
-0.289052814245224,
-0.1215323731303215,
-0.3223952353000641,
-0.6695197224617004,
0.2422035187482834,
-0.0016542237717658281,
0.18224963545799255,
0.12288033217191696,
-0.6153645515441895,
-0.07890042662620544,
-0.531661331653595,
0.46084168553352356,
0.4803670048713684,
-0.3542037904262543,
0.9175518751144409,
-0.20530809462070465,
0.49749496579170227,
0.045722343027591705,
0.03633437305688858,
-0.4733654260635376,
-0.3837217688560486,
-0.9645789861679077,
-0.4625515639781952,
0.141480952501297,
0.4712376296520233,
-1.0119556188583374,
0.30025604367256165,
-0.3922325074672699,
-0.5046991109848022,
-0.46558502316474915,
-0.06763672083616257,
0.244382843375206,
0.8435781002044678,
0.6106159090995789,
-0.16051948070526123,
-0.401543527841568,
-1.0800527334213257,
-0.19565030932426453,
0.04439789801836014,
-0.001457904581911862,
0.43079379200935364,
0.4350496530532837,
-0.20282723009586334,
1.2368844747543335,
-0.21848636865615845,
-0.29220178723335266,
-0.4883686304092407,
-0.1239871233701706,
0.37273961305618286,
0.361644446849823,
0.45658954977989197,
-0.920117199420929,
-0.42757928371429443,
0.14113198220729828,
-0.7120264172554016,
0.0683574378490448,
0.07703790813684464,
0.1432136744260788,
0.2794465124607086,
0.5886768102645874,
-0.640837550163269,
0.20908020436763763,
0.42697393894195557,
-0.1624445766210556,
0.3921000361442566,
-0.28367865085601807,
-0.1910286545753479,
-1.0408474206924438,
0.08965976536273956,
0.05234856531023979,
-0.3064233958721161,
-0.9009265303611755,
0.16002273559570312,
0.4938349425792694,
-0.01007081288844347,
-0.53310227394104,
0.4602077007293701,
-0.21263407170772552,
-0.113991878926754,
-0.14700019359588623,
0.035656899213790894,
-0.24019990861415863,
0.5176094174385071,
-0.1307978332042694,
0.7757177948951721,
0.6822221875190735,
-0.688713788986206,
0.15474016964435577,
0.2821372151374817,
-0.45689094066619873,
0.35798463225364685,
-0.5768808722496033,
0.13847537338733673,
-0.4534716308116913,
0.6400179862976074,
-1.0551737546920776,
-0.09870004653930664,
-0.1876477748155594,
-0.04559743404388428,
0.20409633219242096,
0.05335946008563042,
-0.4589148461818695,
-0.24750511348247528,
-0.058251071721315384,
0.5132041573524475,
0.5534833073616028,
-0.7604881525039673,
1.0059523582458496,
0.4897138178348541,
-0.040528345853090286,
-0.4494572579860687,
-0.23414823412895203,
-0.04110627621412277,
-0.25967177748680115,
-0.44023898243904114,
0.4936126470565796,
0.1964322030544281,
-0.17382270097732544,
-0.12630341947078705,
-0.09039871394634247,
-0.0052454727701842785,
-0.05881554260849953,
-0.025808608159422874,
0.30923226475715637,
-0.27482008934020996,
0.21841152012348175,
-0.05420802906155586,
-0.2351418137550354,
-0.09491820633411407,
-0.42916256189346313,
0.4628990888595581,
-0.3237544298171997,
0.0003402531147003174,
-0.2626062333583832,
0.22148260474205017,
0.6108922958374023,
-0.2583789527416229,
0.7859951257705688,
0.2248879373073578,
-0.5306637287139893,
-0.5779443979263306,
-0.21163785457611084,
-0.389344722032547,
-0.5052937865257263,
0.4089363217353821,
-0.42221125960350037,
-1.2083534002304077,
0.49520665407180786,
-0.048740264028310776,
0.15246926248073578,
0.5727807879447937,
0.38719385862350464,
-0.19870613515377045,
0.5675376057624817,
0.9000168442726135,
0.028444189578294754,
0.521462082862854,
-0.24716787040233612,
0.41874876618385315,
-0.836059033870697,
-0.3984140455722809,
-0.34305068850517273,
-0.41875767707824707,
-0.5758159756660461,
-0.2006721943616867,
0.7360183596611023,
-0.24471162259578705,
0.0719246044754982,
0.7416144609451294,
-0.23344777524471283,
0.24644775688648224,
0.4299427270889282,
0.09987363964319229,
0.12304636090993881,
-0.10382842272520065,
-0.47021839022636414,
-0.09460136294364929,
-0.9832643270492554,
-0.39719852805137634,
0.7953703999519348,
0.49334120750427246,
0.6941288113594055,
0.004827444441616535,
0.21157433092594147,
0.17520493268966675,
0.4306391477584839,
-0.7627069354057312,
0.4749099016189575,
-0.4905846416950226,
-0.30790120363235474,
-0.2846602201461792,
-0.2824872136116028,
-0.80510413646698,
0.5655683279037476,
-0.35645344853401184,
-0.6688782572746277,
0.25499939918518066,
0.3815332353115082,
-0.519681990146637,
0.41103050112724304,
-0.7785162925720215,
0.7177037000656128,
0.022902363911271095,
-0.09019572287797928,
-0.2181187868118286,
-0.4978775680065155,
0.324411541223526,
-0.14649172127246857,
0.457332581281662,
0.2774783670902252,
-0.029384823516011238,
0.41566604375839233,
-0.2932911515235901,
0.7694181799888611,
-0.20370768010616302,
-0.34459930658340454,
0.14401137828826904,
0.36762404441833496,
0.5992477536201477,
-0.1539752334356308,
-0.06607739627361298,
0.08669248223304749,
-0.21955864131450653,
-0.25204959511756897,
-0.7711842060089111,
0.6229647397994995,
-0.44782328605651855,
-0.46197444200515747,
-0.0008862167596817017,
-0.728670060634613,
-0.3289644718170166,
0.030283190310001373,
0.18870048224925995,
0.8927937150001526,
-0.07512976974248886,
0.5779247879981995,
0.7502266764640808,
-0.2884092330932617,
0.719472348690033,
0.22338151931762695,
-0.2167171686887741,
-0.17312315106391907,
0.6838771104812622,
0.028995677828788757,
0.35387206077575684,
0.8661787509918213,
0.2168767750263214,
-0.4739311933517456,
-0.2036789506673813,
-0.2358494997024536,
-0.10767024755477905,
-0.8195006847381592,
-0.03753378987312317,
-0.8150466680526733,
-0.30400124192237854,
-0.15441814064979553,
-0.17397205531597137,
-0.40178462862968445,
-0.6152529716491699,
0.08110927790403366,
-0.07051361352205276,
0.16055040061473846,
0.8606300354003906,
0.4153245687484741,
0.4186776876449585,
-0.5089223384857178,
0.2031252235174179,
0.44043025374412537,
0.4755064845085144,
0.19063442945480347,
-0.6421031355857849,
-0.33186957240104675,
-0.08273004740476608,
-0.32628127932548523,
-0.4837205111980438,
0.3616127669811249,
0.42087966203689575,
0.5474451780319214,
0.07576576620340347,
-0.12205076217651367,
0.5391623973846436,
-0.6661102175712585,
0.6270532608032227,
0.016622746363282204,
-0.9287545680999756,
0.24604550004005432,
-0.25678327679634094,
0.42934706807136536,
0.10696496069431305,
0.2675479054450989,
-0.5880182981491089,
-0.4737495481967926,
-0.5317072868347168,
-0.9852038621902466,
0.6097713708877563,
0.3519339859485626,
0.3564111590385437,
0.10650907456874847,
0.18839654326438904,
0.4941527247428894,
-0.028444232419133186,
-0.9772651195526123,
-0.1927524209022522,
-0.328041672706604,
-0.11761211603879929,
-0.17460326850414276,
-0.12001708149909973,
0.3423803746700287,
-0.4386397898197174,
0.733033299446106,
-0.17302604019641876,
0.14977484941482544,
0.09618139266967773,
-0.3108896315097809,
-0.17028678953647614,
0.30419549345970154,
0.6210572719573975,
0.6494912505149841,
0.04032191261649132,
0.3777425289154053,
0.4065045416355133,
-0.23201268911361694,
-0.21633026003837585,
0.0543118380010128,
-0.18497507274150848,
0.169308140873909,
0.29452547430992126,
0.7531021237373352,
0.7536053657531738,
-0.49506622552871704,
0.3831588327884674,
0.1297951191663742,
-0.033013902604579926,
-0.3371257483959198,
0.1124543771147728,
0.07859086245298386,
0.12431424856185913,
0.7941809892654419,
0.24802254140377045,
0.2027759701013565,
-0.33008891344070435,
0.5189443826675415,
0.6284050941467285,
-0.6122931241989136,
-0.42472323775291443,
0.6915144324302673,
0.21772444248199463,
-0.5431411862373352,
0.32740479707717896,
0.14768700301647186,
-0.6016343235969543,
0.2960512042045593,
0.7520307898521423,
0.754652202129364,
-0.15492083132266998,
0.025173665955662727,
0.33667492866516113,
0.28251850605010986,
0.03851350024342537,
-0.02886228635907173,
-0.2859300374984741,
-0.8359628319740295,
-0.3774145841598511,
-0.762876570224762,
-0.17737483978271484,
0.21921759843826294,
-0.4448036253452301,
0.21006333827972412,
-0.3129655718803406,
0.13789469003677368,
-0.013680548407137394,
-0.49301570653915405,
-0.3676561117172241,
0.2805635929107666,
0.03678978607058525,
1.003259301185608,
-0.6967199444770813,
1.044611930847168,
0.6994427442550659,
0.0714777335524559,
-0.46962207555770874,
-0.0773383304476738,
-0.44333046674728394,
-0.6709275245666504,
0.5414949059486389,
0.16582973301410675,
-0.16859464347362518,
0.00170384522061795,
-0.4335560202598572,
-0.8113904595375061,
0.8646146655082703,
0.2992841601371765,
-0.6280748248100281,
0.20841403305530548,
0.12024317681789398,
0.6855997443199158,
-0.5162843465805054,
0.19142210483551025,
0.34960606694221497,
-0.11448755115270615,
0.1071111261844635,
-0.9984500408172607,
-0.1374509185552597,
-0.12578663229942322,
0.16265247762203217,
0.7040634751319885,
-0.32268932461738586,
0.8926443457603455,
0.04514547437429428,
-0.27971604466438293,
-0.03474615514278412,
0.947002112865448,
0.05757932737469673,
-0.006177970673888922,
0.6972176432609558,
0.6824479699134827,
0.4863509237766266,
-0.06308969855308533,
1.1937202215194702,
-0.1645861566066742,
0.4499889612197876,
0.9390718340873718,
-0.07970931380987167,
1.1801737546920776,
0.48171699047088623,
-0.06297751516103745,
0.8254399299621582,
0.07738185673952103,
0.45351624488830566,
0.5888429880142212,
-0.1481066793203354,
-0.3416343629360199,
-0.3509686291217804,
0.10709980875253677,
-0.09563392400741577,
0.41903427243232727,
0.5878595113754272,
-0.2550176978111267,
-0.5870741009712219,
-0.05378381162881851,
-0.18460479378700256,
0.44473007321357727,
-0.25525519251823425,
0.6289240717887878,
0.31619992852211,
-0.5769584774971008,
0.4622456729412079,
0.013639538548886776,
0.7916057109832764,
-0.48930472135543823,
-0.04312307760119438,
-0.23377525806427002,
0.2586594521999359,
-0.11802008748054504,
-0.588994026184082,
0.3817813992500305,
-0.23051711916923523,
-0.1101304218173027,
-0.5754353404045105,
0.6072743535041809,
-0.5489444136619568,
-0.46990954875946045,
0.41436901688575745,
0.3051978051662445,
-0.23184692859649658,
0.3008149266242981,
-0.4013920724391937,
-0.2009364515542984,
-0.33277854323387146,
0.14288096129894257,
0.05503186210989952,
0.09661830961704254,
-0.21408744156360626,
0.7509407997131348,
0.6553570032119751,
-0.28656697273254395,
0.18463808298110962,
0.10011252760887146,
0.7678491473197937,
-0.4642084836959839,
-0.6734246015548706,
-0.7782037258148193,
0.6620295643806458,
0.1401127725839615,
-0.22282403707504272,
0.5641545653343201,
0.7263584136962891,
0.941091001033783,
-0.15916544198989868,
0.6056956648826599,
-0.2127065509557724,
0.5965391397476196,
-0.40838387608528137,
0.6286563277244568,
-0.5035458207130432,
0.21763962507247925,
-0.1663336157798767,
-0.9359084963798523,
-0.2880496382713318,
0.5482441186904907,
-0.2788928151130676,
0.12764635682106018,
0.6436219215393066,
0.735826849937439,
-0.3439770042896271,
0.16426193714141846,
0.5471205711364746,
0.3910152018070221,
0.31357529759407043,
0.6780415177345276,
0.9232343435287476,
-0.647601306438446,
0.2073901891708374,
-0.24659894406795502,
-0.4007999002933502,
-0.07794537395238876,
-0.9410291910171509,
-0.7781765460968018,
-0.9659562706947327,
0.0378342904150486,
-0.06924118101596832,
-0.20040984451770782,
0.8683133721351624,
0.7106127142906189,
-1.1242753267288208,
-0.3612111210823059,
-0.17744942009449005,
-0.022369343787431717,
-0.2124359905719757,
-0.2501218914985657,
0.2718474566936493,
-0.5222745537757874,
-0.6618412137031555,
0.5389046669006348,
0.571717381477356,
-0.24545492231845856,
-0.16592849791049957,
-0.1690664291381836,
-0.1908796727657318,
0.088358074426651,
1.0023783445358276,
0.1963633894920349,
-0.8241329789161682,
-0.3024130165576935,
0.17768341302871704,
-0.0955250933766365,
0.15986473858356476,
0.8106776475906372,
-1.2731627225875854,
0.6029746532440186,
0.2314586043357849,
0.777343213558197,
0.2770613729953766,
-0.1535010188817978,
0.677319347858429,
-0.7399885058403015,
0.24521249532699585,
0.22511868178844452,
0.6587564945220947,
0.5255230069160461,
-0.29637542366981506,
0.0924932211637497,
0.18365561962127686,
-0.22606822848320007,
-0.6005058288574219,
0.27503859996795654,
-0.8169698119163513,
-0.15570427477359772,
1.1269077062606812,
0.2321353703737259,
-0.09326580166816711,
-0.20201723277568817,
-0.06225259602069855,
0.09770424664020538,
-0.343119353055954,
0.9997304677963257,
0.49472957849502563,
-0.03615904971957207,
-0.11245758831501007,
-0.4141990542411804,
0.4723268449306488,
0.622455358505249,
-0.5458076596260071,
-0.1933213174343109,
0.23229356110095978,
0.07006698846817017,
0.21356289088726044,
0.2772212624549866,
-0.14242176711559296,
0.2260313630104065,
-0.3794911205768585,
-0.20588581264019012,
0.2074556201696396,
-0.5176507830619812,
-0.43193989992141724,
0.41283607482910156,
-0.21080291271209717,
-0.08616750687360764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10643v1 | `Keep it Together': Enforcing Cohesion in Extractive Summaries by Simulating Human Memory | 2024-02-16T12:43:26 | 2024-02-16T12:43:26 | Ronald Cardenas, Matthias Galle, Shay B. Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Extractive summaries are usually presented as lists of sentences with no
expected cohesion between them. In this paper, we aim to enforce cohesion
whilst controlling for informativeness and redundancy in summaries, in cases
where the input exhibits high redundancy. The pipeline controls for redundancy
in long inputs as it is consumed, and balances informativeness and cohesion
during sentence selection. Our sentence selector simulates human memory to keep
track of topics --modeled as lexical chains--, enforcing cohesive ties between
noun phrases. Across a variety of domains, our experiments revealed that it is
possible to extract highly cohesive summaries that nevertheless read as
informative to humans as summaries extracted by only accounting for
informativeness or redundancy. The extracted summaries exhibit smooth topic
transitions between sentences as signaled by lexical chains, with chains
spanning adjacent or near-adjacent sentences. | [
-0.5424128174781799,
-0.8383653163909912,
0.3461131453514099,
0.3165073096752167,
-0.45989418029785156,
0.17830686271190643,
-0.1774083375930786,
-0.27539101243019104,
0.9326514005661011,
0.43088987469673157,
-0.6634123921394348,
-0.2920798659324646,
-0.4919535517692566,
0.1780528575181961,
-0.4138084650039673,
1.4527093172073364,
-0.028075695037841797,
-0.6534788012504578,
-0.7830952405929565,
-0.23185332119464874,
-0.41598448157310486,
-0.46127018332481384,
-0.17928601801395416,
-0.37728503346443176,
0.6168193221092224,
0.5839999914169312,
0.9821752309799194,
0.9538093209266663,
0.7935471534729004,
0.2428453117609024,
-0.2900686264038086,
0.22085298597812653,
-0.643132209777832,
0.39283686876296997,
-0.4140932261943817,
-0.27934572100639343,
-0.3385726809501648,
-0.18414442241191864,
0.46628397703170776,
0.6103825569152832,
-0.35182541608810425,
-0.06934601068496704,
0.2786600887775421,
0.6789827942848206,
-0.5948923230171204,
-0.009058339521288872,
-0.22390355169773102,
-0.12035544216632843,
-0.10551649332046509,
-0.27241000533103943,
-0.07969605177640915,
-0.37890228629112244,
0.33550459146499634,
-0.4379269480705261,
0.14766639471054077,
0.09194394201040268,
1.3048393726348877,
0.2976813018321991,
-0.09058552235364914,
-0.2916801869869232,
-0.4790967106819153,
0.5010746717453003,
-0.14113643765449524,
0.06713434308767319,
0.5856426358222961,
-0.21281710267066956,
-0.08390498161315918,
-0.5817047953605652,
-0.2295403629541397,
0.11625302582979202,
-0.14432989060878754,
0.4569539725780487,
0.03375949710607529,
-0.15228617191314697,
-0.191212996840477,
0.15590953826904297,
-0.627148449420929,
-0.34887996315956116,
-0.8205766081809998,
-0.05599347874522209,
0.815216064453125,
-0.010956230573356152,
0.82925945520401,
-0.04427652806043625,
-0.5501206517219543,
0.02348247729241848,
-0.4564245045185089,
-0.1982048749923706,
-0.015531478449702263,
0.162923663854599,
-0.0872299075126648,
0.7326425909996033,
-0.05418752506375313,
0.18922516703605652,
0.14293237030506134,
-0.08536522090435028,
0.023890480399131775,
-0.49732816219329834,
0.01647060550749302,
0.44856172800064087,
0.8320923447608948,
0.6898512244224548,
0.4270760416984558,
-0.4431891441345215,
0.202614426612854,
0.2838432490825653,
0.5833421349525452,
-0.48488447070121765,
-0.5247711539268494,
0.3131071627140045,
-0.5133684873580933,
-0.1787828803062439,
0.20715199410915375,
-0.7087967395782471,
0.10257194936275482,
-0.2858361005783081,
0.3330608904361725,
-0.5405387878417969,
-0.16754381358623505,
-0.01400020718574524,
-0.6009059548377991,
-0.18852129578590393,
0.2292328029870987,
-1.0387927293777466,
0.7458704113960266,
0.8128665685653687,
1.240810751914978,
-0.6620118021965027,
-0.8010820150375366,
-0.5923261046409607,
0.4641854465007782,
-0.0007443786598742008,
0.8332480192184448,
-0.3290242552757263,
0.005957976449280977,
-0.35008716583251953,
0.04333515837788582,
-0.016744688153266907,
-0.48826706409454346,
0.15368619561195374,
-0.4286916255950928,
0.3021238148212433,
-0.40728509426116943,
-0.6296433210372925,
-0.18373019993305206,
0.3217800259590149,
-0.6889708638191223,
0.5725405812263489,
-0.04720982536673546,
-0.8541960716247559,
0.2760109305381775,
-0.1648353785276413,
-0.5082736015319824,
-0.33553266525268555,
-0.09940291196107864,
-0.4769514203071594,
0.3342224359512329,
-0.22318892180919647,
0.002781453775241971,
0.07888844609260559,
0.41142165660858154,
-0.38172703981399536,
-0.468645840883255,
0.07876361161470413,
0.0204110499471426,
0.5346227884292603,
0.32915034890174866,
0.2549992799758911,
0.21302473545074463,
-0.3673926889896393,
-0.4613094925880432,
-0.16716749966144562,
-0.18938423693180084,
-0.5410586595535278,
0.1022757738828659,
-0.31067830324172974,
0.3535425662994385,
0.24719542264938354,
-0.3048643469810486,
0.2824861705303192,
-0.02074805088341236,
0.2716674506664276,
0.3979935348033905,
0.3676091432571411,
0.5843677520751953,
-0.7849236726760864,
0.43352943658828735,
0.3219945430755615,
-0.38201451301574707,
-0.38928738236427307,
-0.33094143867492676,
-0.5064578056335449,
-0.21471752226352692,
0.31723079085350037,
0.6446269154548645,
-0.32266178727149963,
0.5796041488647461,
-0.17219071090221405,
-0.24062003195285797,
-0.12623411417007446,
0.14492642879486084,
0.13150611519813538,
0.2848530411720276,
0.3442045748233795,
-0.6051313281059265,
-0.5855090022087097,
-0.7722513675689697,
-0.1230286955833435,
-0.1391465961933136,
0.1517046093940735,
-0.4386821687221527,
0.6208209991455078,
0.10259050875902176,
1.2315574884414673,
-0.6057385206222534,
-0.20801150798797607,
-0.38838598132133484,
0.33534806966781616,
0.008483940735459328,
0.6256906986236572,
0.2500632703304291,
-0.7767001986503601,
-0.14007480442523956,
-0.34630438685417175,
-0.9763704538345337,
-0.04885474219918251,
-0.549060583114624,
-0.4643096625804901,
-0.08464360237121582,
0.5727515816688538,
-0.8333642482757568,
0.503811240196228,
0.3554699718952179,
-0.6195988655090332,
0.3926214873790741,
-0.6677212715148926,
-0.17247146368026733,
-1.2293111085891724,
-0.11116673797369003,
-0.010355032049119473,
-0.36608535051345825,
-0.34566372632980347,
-0.08148062229156494,
-0.012944689020514488,
-0.010372499004006386,
-0.12118060141801834,
0.293119877576828,
-0.5784336924552917,
-0.038974929600954056,
-0.1383354812860489,
0.4069055914878845,
0.2485806792974472,
0.5453371405601501,
0.2268722504377365,
0.6669650077819824,
0.13437309861183167,
-0.8114288449287415,
-0.054112184792757034,
0.7025455236434937,
0.14885137975215912,
0.5429210662841797,
-0.7242546677589417,
-0.18991804122924805,
-0.39158207178115845,
-0.0771663635969162,
-0.934950053691864,
-0.36389821767807007,
-0.15985658764839172,
-0.14171409606933594,
0.19828827679157257,
0.1535547375679016,
-0.2935104966163635,
0.16160666942596436,
-0.5547904968261719,
0.06779894232749939,
0.4573982059955597,
-0.3263365626335144,
0.5168688893318176,
0.7102265357971191,
-0.609455943107605,
-0.41485050320625305,
-0.621377170085907,
0.15542910993099213,
-0.44942834973335266,
-0.6599781513214111,
0.37321725487709045,
-0.13643141090869904,
-0.5667458176612854,
0.29486513137817383,
-0.33056503534317017,
-0.4375778138637543,
0.3551166355609894,
0.39881622791290283,
0.42672282457351685,
0.1744585484266281,
0.36769482493400574,
0.33173051476478577,
0.07521951198577881,
0.029150931164622307,
-0.3149246275424957,
0.4595271348953247,
-0.002837340347468853,
-0.02946583740413189,
-0.4883368909358978,
0.7427036762237549,
0.7313418388366699,
0.03768331557512283,
0.6851894855499268,
0.13735324144363403,
-0.2568596601486206,
0.03125310689210892,
-0.19219130277633667,
-0.27412131428718567,
-0.4261498749256134,
0.2561284601688385,
-0.3698873519897461,
-0.7018648386001587,
0.605208158493042,
-0.0428195483982563,
0.1570548415184021,
0.44793105125427246,
0.2520964443683624,
-0.5332497358322144,
0.33022019267082214,
0.6956209540367126,
-0.22992222011089325,
0.29532840847969055,
0.07592634111642838,
-0.15814125537872314,
-0.48749005794525146,
-0.030955005437135696,
-0.1608928143978119,
-0.48512691259384155,
-0.3432367742061615,
-0.155331090092659,
-0.02997487038373947,
0.7252058386802673,
0.07242407649755478,
0.47065970301628113,
-0.45414021611213684,
0.8190047740936279,
0.3157426714897156,
0.24568848311901093,
0.3917190134525299,
0.11645711958408356,
-0.0072697848081588745,
-0.05011804401874542,
-0.4790179133415222,
-0.5829381942749023,
0.3814537823200226,
0.06573150306940079,
0.8145700097084045,
0.27952298521995544,
1.2107232809066772,
0.44942420721054077,
-0.01022004522383213,
-0.3624397814273834,
0.5070739388465881,
-0.08289451152086258,
-0.21965816617012024,
-0.32609596848487854,
-0.3511098325252533,
-1.0622611045837402,
0.2326510101556778,
-0.12011419236660004,
-1.0209217071533203,
0.08747164905071259,
0.1884181648492813,
-0.36154380440711975,
0.20273852348327637,
-0.6612938046455383,
0.6972171664237976,
-0.18033021688461304,
-0.6778551936149597,
-0.17910271883010864,
-0.7630351185798645,
0.2518967092037201,
0.18733085691928864,
-0.06522819399833679,
-0.08021334558725357,
-0.1353251338005066,
0.776147723197937,
-0.601158082485199,
0.8634718060493469,
0.38435807824134827,
0.004889140371233225,
0.49162575602531433,
0.2354690432548523,
0.27390342950820923,
-0.1266988068819046,
0.19623947143554688,
0.06745349615812302,
0.07895774394273758,
-0.513154149055481,
-0.47507819533348083,
0.30684563517570496,
-0.7503777742385864,
-0.7163273692131042,
-0.4498372972011566,
-0.7714598774909973,
0.3381992280483246,
0.1909707933664322,
0.32824403047561646,
0.3101479411125183,
-0.42668846249580383,
0.06482899188995361,
0.6430405378341675,
0.24354732036590576,
0.6878082156181335,
-0.328660786151886,
-0.3241052031517029,
-0.4925946891307831,
1.0740630626678467,
0.21993812918663025,
0.4544083774089813,
0.41275060176849365,
0.3807731866836548,
-0.1743077039718628,
-0.38466018438339233,
-0.09771299362182617,
0.4169679284095764,
-0.29662975668907166,
0.03958569094538689,
-1.060685634613037,
-0.2116401642560959,
-0.10802330821752548,
-0.44630077481269836,
-0.23755952715873718,
-0.8056325912475586,
-0.3316318392753601,
-0.09401411563158035,
0.38910603523254395,
0.7620557546615601,
-0.22369186580181122,
0.047818709164857864,
-1.0776079893112183,
0.5020906329154968,
0.24140530824661255,
0.04427766427397728,
-0.3107404410839081,
-0.3267839550971985,
-0.18010202050209045,
-0.38493070006370544,
-0.3709074854850769,
-0.7915533185005188,
0.6606418490409851,
0.24878963828086853,
0.09417983889579773,
0.4209330081939697,
0.26761892437934875,
0.8159176707267761,
-0.20252564549446106,
0.6305645108222961,
0.3639395236968994,
-0.7836660742759705,
0.5765866637229919,
-0.6476742625236511,
0.6310064792633057,
0.969955563545227,
0.28658729791641235,
-0.5640197992324829,
-0.748944878578186,
-0.7672126889228821,
-0.9083817601203918,
0.39004597067832947,
0.32979679107666016,
-0.20277678966522217,
-0.24982917308807373,
0.3915518522262573,
0.15883366763591766,
0.24789324402809143,
-0.2949124872684479,
0.06156383454799652,
-0.03253721073269844,
-0.495603084564209,
0.1043832078576088,
-0.41369137167930603,
-0.35267481207847595,
0.19720715284347534,
0.2076629102230072,
0.11908310651779175,
0.01586589403450489,
0.3585425317287445,
-0.3399234712123871,
0.13775606453418732,
0.18466193974018097,
0.8956795930862427,
0.6855679750442505,
-0.5370022654533386,
0.5139610171318054,
0.04652167856693268,
-0.8122588396072388,
0.2058165818452835,
-0.21008045971393585,
-0.42266014218330383,
0.09838993102312088,
0.3597240746021271,
0.396728515625,
0.1614098697900772,
-0.5244382619857788,
0.250998318195343,
-0.31340518593788147,
-0.2363467961549759,
-0.2875177562236786,
0.25482168793678284,
0.39537692070007324,
0.18997521698474884,
-0.020712265744805336,
0.43378207087516785,
-0.31516262888908386,
-0.8387354016304016,
0.7342763543128967,
0.07207824289798737,
-0.3945288360118866,
-0.47907885909080505,
0.6665506958961487,
0.19335122406482697,
-0.5205157399177551,
0.7053924798965454,
-0.3472447991371155,
-0.5539263486862183,
0.64496248960495,
0.6191381812095642,
0.785409152507782,
0.1625239998102188,
-0.002069246256724,
0.4499910771846771,
0.1946428269147873,
-0.6376106142997742,
0.43508508801460266,
-0.33051154017448425,
-0.7367261648178101,
-0.2674699127674103,
-0.1368819922208786,
-0.6853840351104736,
-0.4865703880786896,
-0.8567088842391968,
0.1891869306564331,
-0.3138996958732605,
0.008315985091030598,
-0.37807008624076843,
-0.13890928030014038,
-0.026498878374695778,
0.1493137627840042,
-0.04317894205451012,
0.9296067953109741,
-0.8372485041618347,
0.8215580582618713,
0.2973824739456177,
-0.654151439666748,
-0.38259294629096985,
0.21615490317344666,
0.29034361243247986,
-0.07090243697166443,
0.5352628231048584,
0.29393693804740906,
-0.032566267997026443,
-0.33802223205566406,
-0.32846999168395996,
-1.0468469858169556,
1.2401692867279053,
0.3669191598892212,
-0.53123539686203,
-0.14691627025604248,
-0.40887972712516785,
0.36408618092536926,
-0.4561316668987274,
0.12686105072498322,
0.6016893982887268,
0.24038244783878326,
0.09271184355020523,
-0.7166696190834045,
-0.02091936394572258,
-0.44988706707954407,
-0.5386646389961243,
0.3810565173625946,
-0.8666017651557922,
0.7618212103843689,
-0.4490780532360077,
-0.5120618939399719,
0.06451699882745743,
0.9199857115745544,
0.6634576320648193,
0.4266240894794464,
0.34996360540390015,
0.7281963229179382,
1.083687424659729,
-0.1617484837770462,
1.017436146736145,
-0.14008738100528717,
0.23671317100524902,
1.8414405584335327,
-0.3692205250263214,
0.9108933210372925,
0.5599814653396606,
0.18452511727809906,
0.5313249230384827,
0.44976648688316345,
-0.04056109860539436,
0.6885092258453369,
0.07678943872451782,
-0.04602089151740074,
0.03826867789030075,
-0.30543071031570435,
-0.03411263972520828,
0.6469603776931763,
0.1032177060842514,
-0.08097486943006516,
-0.12021378427743912,
-0.48871493339538574,
0.18868044018745422,
0.1619376838207245,
-0.08955966681241989,
0.92091304063797,
0.06806478649377823,
-1.106260895729065,
0.20053374767303467,
-0.6901639699935913,
0.5225425958633423,
-0.5841923952102661,
-0.11888685077428818,
-0.14781484007835388,
0.1551971584558487,
-0.27420005202293396,
-0.7469660043716431,
0.6730871200561523,
-0.1321059912443161,
-0.4506840407848358,
-0.15969274938106537,
0.8157609105110168,
-0.9384298920631409,
-0.2047942578792572,
0.31595227122306824,
0.471342533826828,
0.18149472773075104,
0.24621102213859558,
-0.09811673313379288,
0.08795904368162155,
0.053134068846702576,
-0.1434187889099121,
0.6210920810699463,
0.6651462912559509,
-0.11160755902528763,
0.4850888252258301,
0.4775395095348358,
0.32067424058914185,
-0.3012298345565796,
-0.1272924542427063,
0.8482868671417236,
-1.0608630180358887,
-0.7332044839859009,
-1.173993468284607,
0.5559653639793396,
-0.6331297755241394,
-0.41828641295433044,
0.6746331453323364,
0.6466385722160339,
0.4612318277359009,
0.15397711098194122,
0.579064130783081,
0.07745915651321411,
-0.04217219352722168,
-0.3826944828033447,
0.9064388871192932,
-0.25976788997650146,
0.1552596092224121,
-0.24552686512470245,
-0.8525869250297546,
-0.322735995054245,
0.5426857471466064,
0.2148474007844925,
-0.4398983120918274,
0.967090904712677,
0.4315239489078522,
-0.1389394998550415,
0.21284262835979462,
0.2775494158267975,
-0.18191002309322357,
0.004250235855579376,
0.3896402418613434,
0.7459717988967896,
-0.07604803144931793,
0.5102149844169617,
-0.21817947924137115,
-0.08762892335653305,
0.05940971150994301,
-0.950677216053009,
-0.9950420260429382,
-0.43049466609954834,
-0.5850623846054077,
-0.5023810863494873,
-0.09844709187746048,
0.9844350814819336,
0.7164193987846375,
-0.6055123209953308,
-0.5266826152801514,
-0.3749889135360718,
0.3000134229660034,
-0.4711359143257141,
-0.2714676856994629,
0.3393852710723877,
-0.3606015741825104,
-0.3637695610523224,
0.1418582946062088,
0.7554091811180115,
0.03706881031394005,
0.030754828825592995,
0.14449799060821533,
-0.4531584680080414,
-0.059839654713869095,
0.3209826946258545,
0.43456050753593445,
-0.3526822626590729,
-0.2834073603153229,
-0.27159518003463745,
-0.0926407128572464,
0.2359420508146286,
0.9006395936012268,
-0.6574981212615967,
0.44057318568229675,
0.6960009336471558,
0.6419782042503357,
0.6157042980194092,
0.3861512839794159,
1.0293292999267578,
-0.8268621563911438,
0.1355000138282776,
-0.14737699925899506,
0.38205915689468384,
0.039851732552051544,
-0.5394444465637207,
0.8323217630386353,
0.09852535277605057,
-0.6418797373771667,
-0.37735989689826965,
0.08456089347600937,
-1.1720952987670898,
-0.3949292302131653,
0.6230778694152832,
-0.32714176177978516,
-0.39873409271240234,
-0.46251142024993896,
-0.07085578888654709,
0.417969286441803,
-0.6306426525115967,
1.0938245058059692,
0.8197141289710999,
-0.3054921329021454,
-0.32826370000839233,
0.00012809292820747942,
0.3643699884414673,
0.36986610293388367,
-1.0821506977081299,
0.17754973471164703,
0.4380469024181366,
0.15640439093112946,
0.6441152095794678,
0.5330771207809448,
0.24225594103336334,
0.42014288902282715,
0.10560361295938492,
-0.12625561654567719,
0.03174008056521416,
-0.5124481320381165,
-0.34787359833717346,
0.7043763399124146,
-0.34989187121391296,
-0.2699034512042999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10639v2 | Generalizability of Mixture of Domain-Specific Adapters from the Lens of Signed Weight Directions and its Application to Effective Model Pruning | 2024-02-16T12:39:10 | 2024-06-06T04:52:09 | Tuc Nguyen, Thai Le | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods based on adapters have been
proposed as a streamlined approach to incorporate not only a single specialized
knowledge into existing Pre-Trained Language Models (PLMs) but also multiple of
them at once. Recent works such as AdapterSoup propose to mix not all but only
a selective sub-set of domain-specific adapters during inference via model
weight averaging to optimize performance on novel, unseen domains with
excellent computational efficiency. However, the essential generalizability of
this emerging weight-space adapter mixing mechanism on \textit{unseen,
in-domain examples} remains unexplored. Thus, in this study, we conduct a
comprehensive analysis to elucidate the generalizability of domain-specific
adapter mixtures in in-domain evaluation. We also provide investigations into
the inner workings of the mixture of domain-specific adapters by analyzing
their weight signs, yielding critical analysis on the negative correlation
between their fraction of weight sign difference and their mixtures'
generalizability. | [
-0.5682626962661743,
-0.5091085433959961,
0.37304332852363586,
0.3873961567878723,
-0.40062081813812256,
-0.12997980415821075,
-0.23856084048748016,
-0.3193276524543762,
-0.02822568081319332,
0.37749531865119934,
-0.45778560638427734,
-0.29360371828079224,
-0.6652620434761047,
-0.06132672354578972,
-0.28798580169677734,
0.8818895220756531,
-0.13986970484256744,
0.1397572159767151,
-0.1664847731590271,
-0.5890488028526306,
-0.6434243321418762,
-0.5625247955322266,
-0.2976091802120209,
-0.2701665759086609,
0.173781618475914,
0.2052277773618698,
0.6133975386619568,
0.14972302317619324,
0.7089661955833435,
0.2676764130592346,
-0.08443957567214966,
0.2296135425567627,
-0.5477911829948425,
-0.036052703857421875,
-0.3828008770942688,
-0.41801804304122925,
-0.649445116519928,
0.03643583506345749,
0.7197704911231995,
0.9269477128982544,
-0.25108054280281067,
-0.020762214437127113,
0.2851903438568115,
0.4336307644844055,
-0.8211056590080261,
-0.32218137383461,
-0.9725348353385925,
-0.04279809445142746,
-0.1389741599559784,
-0.2370142936706543,
-0.2611691951751709,
0.04155028238892555,
0.20162951946258545,
-0.7815816402435303,
0.40372708439826965,
0.06225116550922394,
0.7935415506362915,
0.08861126750707626,
-0.2797316610813141,
-0.1797540932893753,
-1.0245161056518555,
1.1973994970321655,
-0.9004476070404053,
0.33417046070098877,
0.05613817647099495,
0.49182215332984924,
-0.26303690671920776,
-0.6425963044166565,
-0.6527906060218811,
0.2194156050682068,
0.09437830746173859,
0.09799256920814514,
-0.03712308406829834,
0.3659355342388153,
-0.08049359172582626,
0.6188152432441711,
-0.5164433717727661,
-0.07812687754631042,
-0.0660884827375412,
-0.07337862253189087,
0.475239098072052,
-0.0017044158885255456,
0.5659576058387756,
0.57883220911026,
-0.23498272895812988,
-0.004542884416878223,
-0.684586226940155,
-0.23561625182628632,
0.22143788635730743,
0.07392574101686478,
-0.20598860085010529,
0.5233001708984375,
-0.1851990669965744,
1.2578275203704834,
0.29677075147628784,
-0.054886385798454285,
0.012286211363971233,
-0.534174919128418,
-0.4833531379699707,
-0.6601372957229614,
0.3769519031047821,
0.4500349760055542,
0.6343312859535217,
-0.3775688409805298,
-0.2474536895751953,
0.08471965044736862,
0.18070444464683533,
-0.9368658065795898,
-0.4340657591819763,
0.2522171437740326,
-0.6043943762779236,
-0.08035165816545486,
0.19097259640693665,
-0.3331397771835327,
-0.258764386177063,
-0.3341597616672516,
0.6747015118598938,
-0.3523305058479309,
-0.4393654465675354,
0.5535295605659485,
-0.4530225396156311,
0.45533469319343567,
0.272596538066864,
-0.7322378158569336,
0.5069689154624939,
0.7399832010269165,
0.6484327912330627,
-0.42903175950050354,
-0.2567654550075531,
-0.28166645765304565,
0.013082594610750675,
-0.11119184643030167,
0.6919950842857361,
-0.8315265774726868,
-0.40880805253982544,
-0.04488976299762726,
0.09896280616521835,
-0.684858500957489,
-1.1294792890548706,
0.5183665752410889,
-0.7223879098892212,
0.028764892369508743,
0.012055465020239353,
-0.8083893656730652,
-0.257353276014328,
0.05424749478697777,
-0.2779904901981354,
0.49840444326400757,
0.3903760612010956,
-0.3865402936935425,
0.6466020345687866,
-0.16842281818389893,
-0.5240471959114075,
0.04438076540827751,
-0.14570742845535278,
-0.37065333127975464,
0.48703762888908386,
-0.012004442512989044,
0.38627126812934875,
-0.31729140877723694,
0.42038455605506897,
-0.5837500691413879,
-0.4995341897010803,
0.44455263018608093,
-0.09606520086526871,
0.7796126008033752,
0.14428935945034027,
-0.06918888539075851,
0.1612435132265091,
-0.987795352935791,
-0.09184475243091583,
0.18714198470115662,
-0.2706705331802368,
-0.6638297438621521,
0.049648433923721313,
-0.1434066891670227,
0.18202762305736542,
-0.01641191728413105,
-0.296297550201416,
0.1702372133731842,
-0.21784456074237823,
0.23728865385055542,
0.5334413051605225,
0.38361093401908875,
0.6697915196418762,
-0.34787869453430176,
0.5988308787345886,
0.3004070520401001,
0.128687784075737,
0.06009181961417198,
-0.6356682181358337,
-0.8726394176483154,
-0.24296621978282928,
0.4992486536502838,
0.2393062710762024,
-0.5821709036827087,
0.6838380098342896,
-0.01856360025703907,
-0.5226972699165344,
-0.4050144851207733,
0.29209303855895996,
0.30759677290916443,
0.3845628798007965,
0.3347264528274536,
-0.5311062932014465,
-0.22992242872714996,
-0.8222942352294922,
-0.6791287064552307,
0.3055259883403778,
-0.1897859424352646,
0.2704528272151947,
0.3293609917163849,
-0.10581062734127045,
0.8993671536445618,
-0.5206416845321655,
-0.10003054887056351,
-0.3078135848045349,
-0.1361485719680786,
0.1739083230495453,
0.7042516469955444,
1.0377659797668457,
-0.8570927977561951,
-0.6779593825340271,
0.040479131042957306,
-0.592851459980011,
-0.1418514996767044,
-0.09536784142255783,
-0.1885189414024353,
-0.616382896900177,
-0.08483682572841644,
-0.3003414273262024,
0.2189679592847824,
0.7355257272720337,
-0.3197586238384247,
0.5094888806343079,
-0.31390100717544556,
-0.07810135185718536,
-0.6391420960426331,
-0.14925001561641693,
0.42238524556159973,
-0.05767609551548958,
-1.114393949508667,
0.27434155344963074,
0.046985212713479996,
-0.012124323286116123,
-0.40575745701789856,
0.5080289840698242,
-0.3930521011352539,
0.03954099863767624,
-0.4064997732639313,
0.07526635378599167,
0.06965602934360504,
0.5076562762260437,
-0.048716600984334946,
0.7325459122657776,
0.7878840565681458,
-1.084335207939148,
-0.151555597782135,
-0.0594397708773613,
-0.1551661491394043,
0.6054315567016602,
-0.7713165283203125,
-0.005831919610500336,
-0.09139253199100494,
0.035357408225536346,
-1.0227707624435425,
0.1258971095085144,
0.4403459429740906,
-0.07647323608398438,
0.3450965881347656,
-0.35632088780403137,
-0.012770120054483414,
-0.022443510591983795,
-0.20025119185447693,
0.6287328004837036,
0.38648006319999695,
-0.371021568775177,
0.8280194997787476,
0.4521000385284424,
0.02114066109061241,
-0.175557941198349,
-0.432826429605484,
-0.3605947494506836,
-0.4336118996143341,
-0.6730817556381226,
0.4769883155822754,
-0.6058818101882935,
-0.3635910749435425,
-0.25840601325035095,
-0.456122487783432,
-0.4297172427177429,
0.21002641320228577,
0.04683217033743858,
0.14202819764614105,
-0.2384321391582489,
-0.5952030420303345,
0.343298077583313,
0.05935731157660484,
-0.19122406840324402,
-0.5558480024337769,
0.43182551860809326,
0.12181916832923889,
-0.6034975051879883,
-0.3671993315219879,
-0.0037795957177877426,
0.4076792895793915,
-0.08807449042797089,
0.7568590641021729,
0.3909437656402588,
-0.34121954441070557,
-0.43299564719200134,
-0.41334205865859985,
-0.060883551836013794,
-0.5269840359687805,
0.29376643896102905,
-0.5405386686325073,
-0.7010406255722046,
0.6415979862213135,
-0.2309310883283615,
0.11323903501033783,
0.4820634424686432,
0.325816810131073,
0.22209790349006653,
0.9400372505187988,
0.5801027417182922,
-0.06455328315496445,
0.36813995242118835,
-0.13452431559562683,
0.1988394856452942,
-0.8622210621833801,
0.16381442546844482,
-0.5471906065940857,
-0.4691683351993561,
-0.40337881445884705,
-0.4824018180370331,
-0.021195968613028526,
0.11744267493486404,
0.048026736825704575,
0.3021722137928009,
-0.5153555870056152,
0.5667514204978943,
0.22150470316410065,
-0.25082114338874817,
0.33274155855178833,
0.15405741333961487,
-0.19176441431045532,
-0.13056184351444244,
-0.6974956393241882,
-0.0789589136838913,
1.017629623413086,
0.24287381768226624,
0.5014026165008545,
0.018189264461398125,
0.32874569296836853,
0.1899908185005188,
0.24779388308525085,
-0.7658531665802002,
0.5035143494606018,
-0.49110859632492065,
-0.5108820199966431,
0.1331913024187088,
-0.3368760347366333,
-0.6125597953796387,
0.7621766924858093,
-0.08861558139324188,
-0.5001178979873657,
0.7781810760498047,
0.16929009556770325,
-0.21510757505893707,
0.17012250423431396,
-0.8887805342674255,
0.7883924245834351,
-0.1335507333278656,
0.059287551790475845,
-0.3358326256275177,
-0.38230809569358826,
0.3097321391105652,
-0.2660581171512604,
0.18605303764343262,
-0.040486134588718414,
0.1729213446378708,
0.7744718194007874,
-0.2948612570762634,
0.642263650894165,
-0.5778716802597046,
-0.23099491000175476,
0.5000077486038208,
0.22094343602657318,
0.2936463952064514,
-0.16304108500480652,
0.1000739336013794,
0.3568848669528961,
-0.1386098712682724,
-0.38461557030677795,
-0.7012210488319397,
0.5756363272666931,
-0.7970857620239258,
-0.4653511941432953,
-0.027837233617901802,
-0.5692256689071655,
-0.49669432640075684,
0.27792197465896606,
-0.018906721845269203,
0.48202866315841675,
0.028078243136405945,
0.13699492812156677,
0.768234133720398,
-0.19887393712997437,
0.11335450410842896,
0.966927170753479,
-0.15697632730007172,
-0.3549528121948242,
1.4729833602905273,
0.007225273177027702,
0.3490086793899536,
0.48919036984443665,
0.12809929251670837,
0.35177144408226013,
-1.0648635625839233,
-0.2367008775472641,
0.44253408908843994,
-0.4436570405960083,
-0.12395244091749191,
-0.23396101593971252,
-0.13760250806808472,
-0.07449283450841904,
-0.18194317817687988,
-0.10319588333368301,
-0.5468910336494446,
-0.20442478358745575,
0.175820454955101,
-0.2344476729631424,
0.5977318286895752,
0.42261046171188354,
0.9204570651054382,
-0.5651521682739258,
0.46101120114326477,
0.2900470197200775,
0.44909369945526123,
0.06048302724957466,
-0.7123258113861084,
-0.21840958297252655,
0.1325104832649231,
-0.25854748487472534,
-0.7479770183563232,
0.18350978195667267,
0.5704508423805237,
0.633147656917572,
0.9190977811813354,
-0.1886933445930481,
0.7571521401405334,
-0.16335928440093994,
0.7041319608688354,
0.0018627623794600368,
-0.7842633724212646,
0.1681929975748062,
-0.38046571612358093,
0.043925266712903976,
0.5581346154212952,
0.134495809674263,
-0.2897634208202362,
-0.49405407905578613,
-0.49488741159439087,
-0.917664110660553,
0.6356143951416016,
0.17501917481422424,
0.011065129190683365,
0.34199827909469604,
0.4870975911617279,
0.3141774833202362,
0.26501360535621643,
-0.4127858579158783,
-0.41170933842658997,
0.09678637236356735,
-0.1969861388206482,
0.09672790765762329,
-0.27962183952331543,
-0.23203635215759277,
-0.38601812720298767,
0.6787366271018982,
-0.12185677886009216,
0.08357153087854385,
-0.17590337991714478,
-0.4502128064632416,
-0.028972698375582695,
0.14002880454063416,
0.7350716590881348,
0.8944303393363953,
-0.36733362078666687,
0.06377968192100525,
0.08957741409540176,
-0.59222412109375,
0.06177027150988579,
0.02111281082034111,
-0.35927286744117737,
-0.09010563045740128,
0.11916498094797134,
0.6117309331893921,
0.12620753049850464,
-0.5386231541633606,
0.4420938193798065,
-0.268027126789093,
-0.2250349521636963,
0.0697454884648323,
0.44404104351997375,
-0.07117702811956406,
-0.06937088817358017,
0.4514558017253876,
0.4368240535259247,
0.18692249059677124,
-0.13991568982601166,
0.051235053688287735,
0.706731915473938,
-0.3606546223163605,
-0.7801284193992615,
0.47356805205345154,
0.3146718144416809,
0.014309531077742577,
0.227857306599617,
-0.17017848789691925,
-0.20541459321975708,
0.522364616394043,
0.7320745587348938,
0.9397990107536316,
-0.23032957315444946,
-0.07451435178518295,
-0.08998794108629227,
0.13535158336162567,
0.15083910524845123,
0.052702486515045166,
-0.17720475792884827,
-1.1667170524597168,
-0.5138936042785645,
-0.6723764538764954,
-0.3214617669582367,
-0.0047196582891047,
-0.5273028612136841,
0.05422917753458023,
-0.5780455470085144,
-0.23084929585456848,
0.047539301216602325,
-0.25356701016426086,
-0.6678081750869751,
0.4839293658733368,
-0.14934325218200684,
0.9074503183364868,
-1.015132188796997,
0.8118414878845215,
1.0280535221099854,
-0.16690118610858917,
-0.6074406504631042,
0.2225453406572342,
-0.22373749315738678,
-0.9100703001022339,
0.2326710969209671,
-0.20999017357826233,
-0.027358317747712135,
-0.10254094004631042,
-0.35197290778160095,
-0.5278010368347168,
0.8600775003433228,
0.3224656283855438,
-0.5332125425338745,
-0.03730892390012741,
0.3713487386703491,
0.3472551107406616,
-0.46298420429229736,
0.19952355325222015,
0.7512316703796387,
0.5740802884101868,
-0.012039144523441792,
-0.773282527923584,
0.036299072206020355,
-0.2718437910079956,
0.058993734419345856,
0.02526175044476986,
-0.6166607141494751,
0.7476947903633118,
0.3770633935928345,
-0.17707493901252747,
-0.09145111590623856,
0.6524710059165955,
0.20002178847789764,
0.2811513841152191,
0.6114245057106018,
0.5512896180152893,
0.6258584260940552,
0.057502422481775284,
0.8215606808662415,
-0.6888232827186584,
0.34736859798431396,
0.9508288502693176,
-0.3102979362010956,
0.34018924832344055,
0.4039411246776581,
-0.45604926347732544,
0.3567679822444916,
0.15605062246322632,
0.008849114179611206,
0.45398226380348206,
0.11310163885354996,
-0.3170955777168274,
-0.2806009352207184,
-0.010931916534900665,
-0.32321590185165405,
0.054075874388217926,
0.4883847236633301,
-0.22366324067115784,
-0.11971856653690338,
-0.19065551459789276,
-0.2621247172355652,
-0.2407817244529724,
-0.22730165719985962,
0.8271545767784119,
0.35001036524772644,
-0.55268794298172,
0.631010890007019,
0.19726724922657013,
1.0078003406524658,
-0.8792505264282227,
0.0830744281411171,
-0.06814409792423248,
0.41366711258888245,
-0.29715850949287415,
-0.5593865513801575,
0.27599629759788513,
-0.4265289604663849,
-0.18068140745162964,
-0.06603248417377472,
1.255316138267517,
-0.3367824852466583,
-0.20925647020339966,
0.33423396944999695,
0.4618077576160431,
-0.18670201301574707,
-0.3433741331100464,
-0.4814373552799225,
0.013108916580677032,
0.0933615118265152,
-0.07026954740285873,
0.8046586513519287,
0.29969286918640137,
0.1423596739768982,
0.5271617770195007,
0.40664932131767273,
0.33082422614097595,
0.09449023008346558,
0.2503046989440918,
0.9291651844978333,
-0.29532378911972046,
-0.2600141167640686,
-0.6402263045310974,
0.5980421900749207,
0.09249712526798248,
-0.212376669049263,
0.9728932976722717,
0.4096299409866333,
0.7886226773262024,
-0.28524455428123474,
0.9845128059387207,
0.031319510191679,
0.14511695504188538,
-0.2591404616832733,
0.5958114266395569,
-0.5667043328285217,
0.1130785271525383,
-0.23121000826358795,
-1.1937733888626099,
-0.394196480512619,
0.4314557611942291,
-0.2625470757484436,
0.19245673716068268,
0.47766292095184326,
0.5945600271224976,
-0.4312654733657837,
-0.02493441291153431,
0.28921300172805786,
-0.06547810882329941,
0.299710750579834,
0.12363895773887634,
0.37718716263771057,
-0.29267290234565735,
0.3062836527824402,
-0.2590063214302063,
-0.2107202261686325,
-0.1972709596157074,
-0.6798920631408691,
-0.7155534029006958,
-0.501154899597168,
-0.47824230790138245,
-0.15763425827026367,
-0.005827474873512983,
0.4466438889503479,
0.7070325613021851,
-1.1471149921417236,
-0.37703800201416016,
-0.13484619557857513,
0.11300911009311676,
-0.5004557371139526,
-0.283507764339447,
0.0335957407951355,
-0.10720577836036682,
-0.6123752593994141,
0.48299479484558105,
0.2817366123199463,
0.14685411751270294,
-0.1117517352104187,
-0.18921808898448944,
0.1776324212551117,
0.3865850865840912,
0.46870627999305725,
0.37177348136901855,
-0.3992672264575958,
0.019470222294330597,
-0.24340862035751343,
0.41745904088020325,
0.03223509341478348,
1.1939669847488403,
-0.49360984563827515,
0.49117663502693176,
0.5631105303764343,
0.4887288212776184,
0.20795710384845734,
0.3550838232040405,
0.8723775148391724,
-0.8999584913253784,
0.2926863133907318,
0.07231263816356659,
0.6115145087242126,
0.17340506613254547,
0.06891728192567825,
0.2584519684314728,
0.43691393733024597,
-0.6029619574546814,
-0.5337151885032654,
0.228995218873024,
-1.1117122173309326,
-0.2527507245540619,
1.2092653512954712,
-0.05650501325726509,
-0.05335662513971329,
-0.01900908723473549,
-0.17115913331508636,
0.035904452204704285,
-0.3109718859195709,
0.38249385356903076,
0.5214729905128479,
-0.12478570640087128,
0.31344565749168396,
-0.22446660697460175,
0.278295636177063,
0.5100821256637573,
-0.47413429617881775,
-0.023195907473564148,
0.3095400631427765,
0.6467829942703247,
0.057144537568092346,
0.6538283824920654,
0.20334383845329285,
-0.1675310879945755,
-0.2745281159877777,
-0.2545841634273529,
0.11644355207681656,
-0.390051931142807,
-0.5409027934074402,
0.22982703149318695,
0.4548459053039551,
-0.11245562136173248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10631v1 | BitDistiller: Unleashing the Potential of Sub-4-Bit LLMs via Self-Distillation | 2024-02-16T12:27:15 | 2024-02-16T12:27:15 | Dayou Du, Yijia Zhang, Shijie Cao, Jiaqi Guo, Ting Cao, Xiaowen Chu, Ningyi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The upscaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) has yielded impressive advances
in natural language processing, yet it also poses significant deployment
challenges. Weight quantization has emerged as a widely embraced solution to
reduce memory and computational demands. This paper introduces BitDistiller, a
framework that synergizes Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) with Knowledge
Distillation (KD) to boost the performance of LLMs at ultra-low precisions
(sub-4-bit). Specifically, BitDistiller first incorporates a tailored
asymmetric quantization and clipping technique to maximally preserve the
fidelity of quantized weights, and then proposes a novel Confidence-Aware
Kullback-Leibler Divergence (CAKLD) objective, which is employed in a
self-distillation manner to enable faster convergence and superior model
performance. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that BitDistiller significantly
surpasses existing methods in both 3-bit and 2-bit configurations on general
language understanding and complex reasoning benchmarks. Notably, BitDistiller
is shown to be more cost-effective, demanding fewer data and training
resources. The code is available at https://github.com/DD-DuDa/BitDistiller. | [
-0.13638082146644592,
-0.48049402236938477,
0.7015741467475891,
0.3390384614467621,
-0.45985284447669983,
0.45943957567214966,
-0.14786049723625183,
-0.0117223234847188,
0.08815435320138931,
0.2499019205570221,
-0.15261544287204742,
-0.29085806012153625,
-0.7469642758369446,
0.0234959926456213,
-0.5057688355445862,
0.7735792994499207,
-0.11592317372560501,
-0.052571721374988556,
-0.324138343334198,
0.012146138586103916,
-0.3750956356525421,
-0.48640039563179016,
-0.53792804479599,
-0.39772751927375793,
-0.0037430240772664547,
0.3109022378921509,
0.4863969087600708,
0.5742228031158447,
0.2264518290758133,
0.347154825925827,
-0.0922950878739357,
-0.20518618822097778,
-0.2988971769809723,
0.257523775100708,
-0.0009102547192014754,
-0.7036346793174744,
-0.1531199961900711,
-0.016194116324186325,
0.4780811369419098,
0.37314197421073914,
-0.5918149352073669,
0.044213563203811646,
0.11249113827943802,
0.9066342115402222,
-0.8431655764579773,
-0.019678205251693726,
-0.5666154026985168,
-0.11465001851320267,
-0.17109297215938568,
0.10356806963682175,
0.020771915093064308,
-0.4185056984424591,
0.050391312688589096,
-0.4898229241371155,
0.2720179557800293,
-0.15689986944198608,
0.4656187891960144,
0.5606041550636292,
-0.33013445138931274,
-0.3832840621471405,
-0.778695285320282,
0.9292294383049011,
-0.8356478214263916,
0.5111207365989685,
0.31488433480262756,
0.3215111494064331,
0.13770321011543274,
-0.8314417004585266,
-0.7304150462150574,
0.250461608171463,
0.19531941413879395,
-0.03148613125085831,
-0.48825058341026306,
0.17344124615192413,
-0.011118415743112564,
0.8568601012229919,
-0.3111761808395386,
-0.06441988795995712,
-0.3222590982913971,
-0.256287544965744,
0.32431480288505554,
0.022253060713410378,
-0.22037579119205475,
0.009875573217868805,
-0.3329339325428009,
-0.213604137301445,
-0.47331511974334717,
-0.018907522782683372,
0.20584283769130707,
-0.08561845123767853,
-0.08031312376260757,
0.39663729071617126,
-0.3793924152851105,
0.42970365285873413,
0.4526703357696533,
-0.2796698212623596,
-0.02460772544145584,
-0.43012407422065735,
-0.40850183367729187,
0.4018278121948242,
0.843916654586792,
0.23605774343013763,
0.051643021404743195,
0.11087509244680405,
-0.3627883195877075,
0.10784914344549179,
0.06828447431325912,
-1.3300330638885498,
-0.7479772567749023,
0.23804090917110443,
-0.0551685206592083,
-0.3355017304420471,
-0.2626630961894989,
-0.5328413248062134,
-0.41944557428359985,
-0.15801487863063812,
0.5440796613693237,
-0.5425073504447937,
-0.1223568394780159,
0.47546589374542236,
-0.18427839875221252,
-0.052048783749341965,
0.09558769315481186,
-0.9444701075553894,
0.2891898453235626,
0.5101447105407715,
0.940418004989624,
-0.013588241301476955,
0.15931889414787292,
-0.26463910937309265,
0.19337421655654907,
-0.3939700424671173,
0.4863050580024719,
-0.1600191295146942,
-0.4233224093914032,
-0.37851619720458984,
-0.3640996217727661,
0.3036310076713562,
-0.6096925735473633,
0.45445021986961365,
-0.6463857293128967,
-0.017522193491458893,
-0.17004677653312683,
-0.646158754825592,
-0.04727896675467491,
0.1995602548122406,
-0.6918050050735474,
1.067334532737732,
0.18196505308151245,
-0.6620259881019592,
0.46185222268104553,
-0.3222111165523529,
-0.3344980776309967,
0.29946210980415344,
-0.3277256488800049,
-0.5686155557632446,
0.5184645652770996,
0.236073300242424,
0.32206666469573975,
-0.4917084276676178,
0.3624500036239624,
-0.0719439759850502,
-0.2855597138404846,
0.1559559404850006,
-0.6609643697738647,
0.6861222982406616,
0.2219960242509842,
-0.2154977023601532,
-0.13093435764312744,
-0.7692075371742249,
0.07724688202142715,
0.1380787342786789,
-0.5153947472572327,
-0.7108978629112244,
-0.33238497376441956,
-0.2748704254627228,
0.07558726519346237,
0.3893742859363556,
-0.7622585892677307,
-0.012951526790857315,
-0.4528561234474182,
0.6075834631919861,
0.7375341057777405,
-0.03510375693440437,
0.5541426539421082,
-0.027002325281500816,
0.5666243433952332,
0.21274727582931519,
0.027939675375819206,
-0.07013668119907379,
-0.09247854351997375,
-0.8442953824996948,
-0.6098823547363281,
0.6617349982261658,
0.23457245528697968,
-1.0366374254226685,
0.5701309442520142,
-0.2871510684490204,
-0.40562525391578674,
-1.0541386604309082,
0.30200496315956116,
0.3943564295768738,
0.2200586348772049,
0.3449428081512451,
-0.1514473557472229,
-0.4646422266960144,
-0.7128593325614929,
-0.05075175315141678,
-0.023689547553658485,
-0.13299447298049927,
-0.389595627784729,
0.2274317741394043,
-0.03811212629079819,
1.1399791240692139,
-0.5293639898300171,
-0.4209398925304413,
-0.3095380663871765,
0.3335878551006317,
0.17445708811283112,
0.4018012285232544,
0.25655943155288696,
-0.76313716173172,
-0.6346253752708435,
-0.16382086277008057,
-0.5420201420783997,
-0.12161897122859955,
0.07913099229335785,
0.09077326208353043,
0.360645055770874,
0.5642224550247192,
-0.5269373059272766,
0.36704981327056885,
0.9415784478187561,
-0.1498008817434311,
0.5212157964706421,
-0.49946123361587524,
0.04333017021417618,
-1.1913363933563232,
-0.29305365681648254,
-0.03117981366813183,
-0.34962257742881775,
-0.4846888482570648,
-0.2222491055727005,
0.306837797164917,
0.21125207841396332,
-0.288456529378891,
0.16295722126960754,
-0.5322486758232117,
0.2262725830078125,
-0.5421650409698486,
0.058669496327638626,
0.3611679673194885,
-0.010998583398759365,
-0.11195701360702515,
0.8852935433387756,
0.49010980129241943,
-0.5548579692840576,
0.5350900292396545,
-0.08558513224124908,
-0.4212241470813751,
0.6726138591766357,
-0.8748730421066284,
-0.03901815786957741,
0.03085216134786606,
0.07688694447278976,
-0.9739986062049866,
0.22703401744365692,
-0.2017713487148285,
-0.21891868114471436,
0.2945047616958618,
-0.21937093138694763,
-0.5494909882545471,
-0.43614235520362854,
-0.7316438555717468,
0.6163254380226135,
0.5593198537826538,
-0.5501975417137146,
0.6445967555046082,
0.38747408986091614,
-0.005677150562405586,
-0.26537251472473145,
-0.8823754191398621,
-0.006890844088047743,
-0.3981020152568817,
-0.1414235234260559,
0.3788761496543884,
-0.32867538928985596,
-0.19875244796276093,
-0.0020563469734042883,
-0.5665091276168823,
0.036559369415044785,
0.00054581044241786,
0.08144927024841309,
0.08716074377298355,
0.035574160516262054,
0.15794847905635834,
0.35458728671073914,
-0.3442845642566681,
0.004598373081535101,
-0.7089115381240845,
0.5306739211082458,
-0.15606117248535156,
-0.19993019104003906,
-0.47359341382980347,
-0.05876116827130318,
0.2686977982521057,
-0.04913625866174698,
0.5676580667495728,
0.5158460736274719,
-0.16059421002864838,
-0.18661777675151825,
-0.6156762838363647,
-0.2548084259033203,
-0.5711964964866638,
0.22304290533065796,
-0.6265749335289001,
-1.233386754989624,
0.03264418989419937,
-0.1917753368616104,
-0.21597473323345184,
0.09457328170537949,
0.6634410619735718,
-0.18542617559432983,
0.5799737572669983,
0.9339241981506348,
-0.20912037789821625,
0.20992150902748108,
-0.342408686876297,
0.44565144181251526,
-0.6829902529716492,
0.1679411232471466,
-0.1318119764328003,
-0.3674260377883911,
-0.6431443095207214,
-0.6154171228408813,
0.449828565120697,
0.4594220221042633,
0.09526736289262772,
0.340439110994339,
-0.4813753366470337,
0.854956328868866,
0.6747456192970276,
-0.30845212936401367,
0.5488492250442505,
-0.15551714599132538,
-0.20166023075580597,
-0.14231964945793152,
-0.6742498278617859,
-0.23208829760551453,
0.9667287468910217,
0.20153380930423737,
1.1689510345458984,
0.058505408465862274,
0.8928259611129761,
0.35628968477249146,
-0.181732639670372,
-0.8037559390068054,
0.36386942863464355,
-0.10731440782546997,
-0.3890437185764313,
-0.48804739117622375,
-0.5097113251686096,
-0.7090749144554138,
0.4025621712207794,
0.08229946345090866,
-0.4230429232120514,
0.2870946228504181,
0.3652278184890747,
-0.7820834517478943,
0.2809651792049408,
-0.6961787939071655,
0.6843143701553345,
-0.05554274842143059,
-0.09389831870794296,
-0.22360533475875854,
-0.4645991325378418,
0.37754303216934204,
-0.39388617873191833,
0.19195188581943512,
-0.11970918625593185,
-0.1680241972208023,
0.665682852268219,
-0.39557206630706787,
0.7649544477462769,
-0.12520360946655273,
-0.5781540274620056,
0.35730230808258057,
0.5394980907440186,
0.3915897309780121,
0.10348014533519745,
0.1229955330491066,
0.3356631398200989,
0.3796101212501526,
-0.266406774520874,
-0.6530475616455078,
0.73969966173172,
-0.5160447359085083,
-0.5058022141456604,
-0.3659111559391022,
-0.494552880525589,
-0.05248405784368515,
0.18766075372695923,
0.17527726292610168,
0.26873961091041565,
0.11137368530035019,
0.2664377987384796,
0.7936625480651855,
0.09022997319698334,
0.6260284185409546,
0.5754035115242004,
-0.19437247514724731,
-0.614988386631012,
0.9897825121879578,
0.055756036192178726,
0.48853716254234314,
0.47262096405029297,
0.38596490025520325,
-0.4177938997745514,
-0.60318922996521,
-0.29902511835098267,
0.1461283415555954,
-0.48369425535202026,
-0.5776780843734741,
-0.6112663745880127,
-0.17915847897529602,
-0.4770561456680298,
-0.03771955147385597,
-0.7739334106445312,
-0.6837371587753296,
-0.0862388014793396,
-0.20184291899204254,
0.43981194496154785,
0.6378797888755798,
-0.3685888946056366,
0.6668766140937805,
-0.6026941537857056,
0.28202348947525024,
0.5644022226333618,
0.39207711815834045,
-0.20136409997940063,
-0.5413768291473389,
-0.4871211647987366,
0.054659806191921234,
-0.31826651096343994,
-0.3802604377269745,
0.4006037712097168,
0.21252749860286713,
0.013279270380735397,
0.38710322976112366,
0.3002553880214691,
0.6123050451278687,
-0.24890801310539246,
0.5528574585914612,
0.286265105009079,
-1.0873771905899048,
0.4644986391067505,
0.21548806130886078,
0.5317440629005432,
0.8093374967575073,
0.5238890647888184,
-0.4600522220134735,
-0.4341908097267151,
-0.3363974988460541,
-0.879056990146637,
0.5421583652496338,
0.16811610758304596,
0.08071175217628479,
0.017854781821370125,
0.17936526238918304,
0.04350512847304344,
0.3921985328197479,
-0.5810588598251343,
-0.21443068981170654,
-0.06161365658044815,
-0.47151997685432434,
-0.10121533274650574,
-0.5335224270820618,
0.16877149045467377,
-0.3192576766014099,
0.7282726764678955,
-0.28076237440109253,
-0.15413053333759308,
0.13682329654693604,
-0.2347078025341034,
-0.02381710521876812,
0.4164624810218811,
0.1261892020702362,
0.31399106979370117,
-0.17780311405658722,
0.5912656188011169,
0.07444925606250763,
-0.6169321537017822,
0.42756664752960205,
0.19756141304969788,
-0.17288661003112793,
-0.3018665313720703,
0.06840759515762329,
0.5663526058197021,
0.2654520273208618,
-0.5679812431335449,
0.6731455326080322,
-0.32254350185394287,
-0.2185600996017456,
-0.0006807661848142743,
-0.02768685854971409,
0.1891767382621765,
0.4817539155483246,
0.25653550028800964,
-0.4518933892250061,
0.37601640820503235,
-0.19721856713294983,
0.1927671581506729,
0.32186347246170044,
-0.43237239122390747,
-0.4047413468360901,
0.5651807188987732,
0.08634477108716965,
0.13815157115459442,
0.39503294229507446,
-0.5780200958251953,
-0.463418573141098,
0.059910234063863754,
0.5655834674835205,
0.787525475025177,
-0.3661341369152069,
0.06243366375565529,
0.05023038759827614,
0.16563184559345245,
-0.056184787303209305,
0.25038522481918335,
-0.43523526191711426,
-0.8372103571891785,
-0.5670186877250671,
-1.0348737239837646,
-0.14023767411708832,
-0.09252667427062988,
-0.5362725257873535,
-0.044455669820308685,
-0.36519190669059753,
-0.23504813015460968,
-0.07836741209030151,
0.006342756561934948,
-0.21938015520572662,
0.010275954380631447,
0.16149401664733887,
0.6939631700515747,
-0.5333192944526672,
1.0437078475952148,
0.49452975392341614,
-0.1483890265226364,
-0.4863154888153076,
0.12258166819810867,
-0.0839717835187912,
-0.658772349357605,
0.419224351644516,
0.04783032834529877,
-0.28888940811157227,
0.48359444737434387,
-0.28029152750968933,
-0.7272973656654358,
1.299984335899353,
0.38891851902008057,
-0.8397287726402283,
0.026844028383493423,
0.33500778675079346,
0.36234426498413086,
0.10883715748786926,
0.06731612980365753,
1.1443220376968384,
0.10900592803955078,
0.2612019181251526,
-0.8832182288169861,
0.10336535423994064,
0.10676209628582001,
0.390700101852417,
0.49075841903686523,
-0.5951604247093201,
0.7632229924201965,
-0.2381129413843155,
-0.22094407677650452,
-0.11883338540792465,
0.8728168606758118,
0.42984738945961,
-0.03247709944844246,
0.5083709359169006,
0.9228781461715698,
0.6293953061103821,
-0.01735927164554596,
0.7050073742866516,
-0.4079429805278778,
0.339854896068573,
1.214533805847168,
-0.19169685244560242,
0.6086443662643433,
0.7839810252189636,
-0.5558785200119019,
0.5006067156791687,
0.11718238890171051,
0.34983113408088684,
0.762340784072876,
0.327193945646286,
-0.5459083318710327,
-0.1923055350780487,
-0.04210183769464493,
-0.036157093942165375,
0.4031296968460083,
0.10574083775281906,
0.059658050537109375,
-0.3383272588253021,
0.09473834186792374,
-0.04049616679549217,
0.1100456640124321,
-0.07002125680446625,
0.8568461537361145,
0.29819968342781067,
-0.19311663508415222,
0.6911195516586304,
0.11566867679357529,
1.079715609550476,
-0.5299846529960632,
0.008847448974847794,
-0.32890650629997253,
0.4347286522388458,
0.19512197375297546,
-0.8066667318344116,
0.19499719142913818,
-0.09421512484550476,
-0.08314754068851471,
-0.31022191047668457,
0.674036979675293,
-0.5790517926216125,
-0.5160907506942749,
0.13041812181472778,
0.40090760588645935,
-0.09507417678833008,
-0.4641035199165344,
-0.4840865731239319,
0.13129523396492004,
-0.01937038265168667,
-0.10538642108440399,
0.26127368211746216,
1.00226891040802,
0.18557657301425934,
0.7610558867454529,
0.45642009377479553,
0.26120495796203613,
0.08902178704738617,
0.13724364340305328,
0.9480023384094238,
-0.6284664869308472,
-0.5740637183189392,
-1.2347021102905273,
0.13596902787685394,
0.06869424879550934,
0.11601349711418152,
0.9351174831390381,
0.7567523121833801,
0.7823814153671265,
0.1319071352481842,
0.7017839550971985,
-0.1568945050239563,
0.2991103231906891,
-0.4577931761741638,
0.661555826663971,
-0.2615695595741272,
0.20309694111347198,
0.06865771114826202,
-0.5868028402328491,
-0.08203878253698349,
0.4632872939109802,
-0.1670902520418167,
0.0018278165953233838,
0.5356466770172119,
0.5686185359954834,
0.06306251138448715,
-0.0906013622879982,
0.6014030575752258,
0.16813337802886963,
0.36252933740615845,
0.5435935258865356,
0.7743796110153198,
-0.5144705772399902,
0.5158941745758057,
-0.6715875267982483,
-0.3344970941543579,
0.016969794407486916,
-0.9511191844940186,
-0.8266319632530212,
-0.5884865522384644,
-0.30526939034461975,
0.04001590609550476,
0.0028186417184770107,
0.8675104379653931,
0.7955834865570068,
-0.7462242841720581,
-0.26431500911712646,
-0.25872817635536194,
-0.04193003103137016,
0.07661785930395126,
-0.24266408383846283,
0.1622275561094284,
-0.3355056643486023,
-0.5708697438240051,
0.3056563138961792,
0.429899662733078,
0.4498952627182007,
-0.4741430878639221,
-0.029927825555205345,
-0.01124056987464428,
0.19484330713748932,
0.6223241686820984,
-0.11332947760820389,
-0.3709409236907959,
0.19778959453105927,
-0.42669877409935,
-0.054576314985752106,
-0.016095226630568504,
0.8035467267036438,
-1.0556501150131226,
0.4698754549026489,
0.12119144946336746,
0.6340099573135376,
0.6340503096580505,
0.18445824086666107,
0.4671300947666168,
-1.0057998895645142,
0.08500830829143524,
0.16172245144844055,
0.19560866057872772,
0.4190565049648285,
-0.3019077777862549,
0.3387581706047058,
0.3166080117225647,
-0.44499534368515015,
-0.695391833782196,
-0.01671905443072319,
-0.5867363214492798,
-0.28360387682914734,
0.8910462856292725,
0.03366115689277649,
-0.3054417073726654,
0.0470244362950325,
-0.15270042419433594,
0.15005922317504883,
-0.5720160007476807,
0.8691322803497314,
0.6435413360595703,
0.04638953134417534,
-0.29103776812553406,
-0.24494056403636932,
0.5936924815177917,
0.2748642563819885,
-0.6272079348564148,
0.40351012349128723,
0.31225937604904175,
0.33537757396698,
0.0899287611246109,
0.8701685070991516,
-0.0304473377764225,
-0.06206495687365532,
-0.04534315690398216,
0.3779282867908478,
-0.031187081709504128,
-0.3218647837638855,
-0.5421777963638306,
-0.1951725333929062,
0.2472529113292694,
-0.2530977129936218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10618v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10618v2 | Enhancing Role-playing Systems through Aggressive Queries: Evaluation and Improvement | 2024-02-16T12:12:05 | 2024-06-15T13:51:38 | Yihong Tang, Jiao Ou, Che Liu, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has propelled dialogue generation
into new realms, particularly in the field of role-playing systems (RPSs).
While enhanced with ordinary role-relevant training dialogues, existing
LLM-based RPSs still struggle to align with roles when handling intricate and
trapped queries in boundary scenarios. In this paper, we design the Modular
ORchestrated Trap-setting Interaction SystEm (MORTISE) to benchmark and improve
the role-playing LLMs' performance. MORTISE can produce highly role-relevant
aggressive queries through the collaborative effort of multiple LLM-based
modules, and formulate corresponding responses to create an adversarial
training dataset via a consistent response generator. We select 190 Chinese and
English roles to construct aggressive queries to benchmark existing
role-playing LLMs. Through comprehensive evaluation, we find that existing
models exhibit a general deficiency in role alignment capabilities. We further
select 180 of the roles to collect an adversarial training dataset (named
RoleAD) and retain the other 10 roles for testing. Experiments on models
improved by RoleAD indicate that our adversarial dataset ameliorates this
deficiency, with the improvements demonstrating a degree of generalizability in
ordinary scenarios. | [
-0.17372404038906097,
-0.7050544619560242,
0.030508624389767647,
0.19040179252624512,
-0.07603137195110321,
0.06684844940900803,
-0.2018868774175644,
-0.34616604447364807,
0.05326287820935249,
0.734062910079956,
-0.5833898186683655,
-0.5399476289749146,
-0.4682880938053131,
0.04577285423874855,
0.002495540538802743,
0.9090414643287659,
0.3093540668487549,
0.31518155336380005,
-0.11853605508804321,
-0.15498881042003632,
-0.765061616897583,
-0.3659096956253052,
-1.022270917892456,
-0.17023099958896637,
0.22523392736911774,
-0.05608205869793892,
0.9866021871566772,
0.4565008878707886,
0.5891212224960327,
0.3240254521369934,
0.054486069828271866,
0.5604375600814819,
-0.7474575638771057,
0.5406349897384644,
-0.2602549195289612,
-0.5448601841926575,
-0.7438207864761353,
-0.17544741928577423,
0.5655625462532043,
0.2617495059967041,
-0.33611035346984863,
-0.2035977691411972,
0.07409472018480301,
0.23832568526268005,
-0.6374353766441345,
0.31471240520477295,
-0.7671919465065002,
0.17015255987644196,
-0.06078050285577774,
-0.15508465468883514,
-0.583495020866394,
-0.17965753376483917,
0.1353207677602768,
-0.6856961846351624,
-0.022121379151940346,
-0.030646082013845444,
0.6260004639625549,
0.27432888746261597,
-0.3100959062576294,
-0.19471558928489685,
-0.5930899381637573,
0.6416531205177307,
-0.9511117935180664,
0.0985674262046814,
0.3727879226207733,
0.31506970524787903,
-0.5546517372131348,
-0.1101011112332344,
0.1379375159740448,
-0.10441246628761292,
-0.1872222125530243,
0.23454754054546356,
0.14937786757946014,
0.25336238741874695,
0.37960734963417053,
0.0468856580555439,
-0.667527437210083,
0.2222556322813034,
-0.2237434685230255,
-0.19049771130084991,
1.2125895023345947,
0.5206215977668762,
0.3864031732082367,
-0.12363699823617935,
-0.3384943902492523,
-0.14280597865581512,
-0.6532701253890991,
0.3936511278152466,
0.5589812397956848,
0.4826134145259857,
0.11061331629753113,
0.5551481246948242,
0.0680088922381401,
0.811539351940155,
0.1768072247505188,
0.1219189465045929,
-0.3468573987483978,
0.09333565831184387,
-0.20230606198310852,
-0.15690775215625763,
0.6993454098701477,
0.5015333890914917,
0.3676987290382385,
-0.11636147648096085,
-0.4869980812072754,
0.11294816434383392,
0.748046338558197,
-0.6067711114883423,
-0.02498648129403591,
0.17643138766288757,
-0.14522500336170197,
-0.4993184208869934,
0.15960194170475006,
-0.7690690755844116,
-0.7182840704917908,
0.053132131695747375,
0.6327430009841919,
-0.4269002377986908,
-0.15923826396465302,
0.14679615199565887,
-0.06558090448379517,
0.40052950382232666,
0.19031229615211487,
-0.8311852812767029,
0.5301946997642517,
0.9026976227760315,
0.5650071501731873,
-0.2689240574836731,
-0.02419821172952652,
-0.8549708127975464,
0.25254812836647034,
-0.5993657112121582,
0.6168277859687805,
-0.7771439552307129,
-0.7299837470054626,
0.1851634830236435,
0.022154562175273895,
-0.3583287298679352,
-0.9271870255470276,
0.4821748435497284,
-0.7569151520729065,
-0.013294660486280918,
-0.06172783672809601,
-0.34260520339012146,
0.3077911138534546,
0.5923603177070618,
-0.5915383696556091,
1.008474588394165,
-0.1809845268726349,
-0.38775190711021423,
0.16674277186393738,
-0.6187982559204102,
-0.35020408034324646,
0.06696389615535736,
-0.4460112452507019,
-0.44122278690338135,
0.08228643983602524,
0.4544665515422821,
0.3633006513118744,
-0.18922856450080872,
0.3898685574531555,
-0.2318846434354782,
-0.9069206714630127,
0.23130834102630615,
-0.0506926067173481,
0.8144769072532654,
-0.032845403999090195,
-0.3108788728713989,
0.17731058597564697,
-0.20693914592266083,
0.014398838393390179,
0.05762088671326637,
-0.2979389727115631,
-0.38043931126594543,
0.3620247542858124,
-0.6798645853996277,
0.07810287922620773,
-0.08150435984134674,
-0.19388312101364136,
0.5461381673812866,
-0.4334567189216614,
0.06211384758353233,
0.8185527920722961,
-0.0015168330864980817,
0.38723984360694885,
-0.3417211174964905,
0.8725149035453796,
-0.10733061283826828,
0.3223298490047455,
-0.01794283092021942,
-0.3602967858314514,
-0.36637258529663086,
-0.26922041177749634,
0.1848873347043991,
0.7952994108200073,
-0.8673253059387207,
0.5253320336341858,
-0.26390692591667175,
-0.2677844762802124,
-0.4107470214366913,
-0.051917530596256256,
0.5910670757293701,
0.08911341428756714,
0.18330006301403046,
-0.6208961009979248,
-0.486341267824173,
-0.8628559112548828,
-0.41678693890571594,
-0.24914109706878662,
-0.0732702687382698,
0.7748737931251526,
0.08090130239725113,
-0.001787229673936963,
0.5808097720146179,
-0.5300394892692566,
-0.2862490117549896,
-0.14186152815818787,
0.017286479473114014,
-0.05981309339404106,
0.41148853302001953,
0.26558423042297363,
-0.5636684894561768,
-0.5115893483161926,
-0.28247374296188354,
-0.7749159932136536,
-0.28646591305732727,
0.0538954883813858,
-0.4619300663471222,
0.041967712342739105,
0.5272782444953918,
-0.6078255772590637,
0.38210177421569824,
0.44058775901794434,
-0.13322797417640686,
0.6064944863319397,
0.3318808674812317,
0.337836891412735,
-0.909481942653656,
0.10817791521549225,
-0.23132085800170898,
-0.056872352957725525,
-0.6199738383293152,
0.38714030385017395,
-0.07423226535320282,
-0.4083653390407562,
-0.15766113996505737,
0.36152857542037964,
-0.6392961144447327,
-0.19749730825424194,
-0.18912793695926666,
0.44840872287750244,
-0.06774138659238815,
0.46919888257980347,
-0.09694045037031174,
0.9910401105880737,
0.596467137336731,
-0.5458994507789612,
0.39961910247802734,
0.44465357065200806,
-0.23511052131652832,
0.572650671005249,
-0.5448339581489563,
0.054185230284929276,
0.000941262289416045,
0.5209453105926514,
-1.0770933628082275,
-0.2604334056377411,
0.11565861850976944,
-0.3120117485523224,
0.5904545187950134,
-0.6277422904968262,
-0.1628071367740631,
-0.20458364486694336,
-0.5076141357421875,
0.4815771281719208,
0.5598296523094177,
-0.15522657334804535,
0.645433783531189,
0.4646220803260803,
-0.1574033945798874,
-1.1592646837234497,
-0.26717889308929443,
0.17099300026893616,
-0.3354230225086212,
-0.7285094857215881,
0.23237137496471405,
0.09073644876480103,
-0.18042616546154022,
-0.23183374106884003,
-0.2641284465789795,
-0.08465149253606796,
0.08287777006626129,
0.0615377277135849,
0.2723429203033447,
-0.2787725627422333,
0.16534247994422913,
-0.0647348091006279,
0.07187361270189285,
0.2907560169696808,
0.09605209529399872,
0.4957686960697174,
0.2337745875120163,
-0.3733499050140381,
-0.10653817653656006,
0.33860427141189575,
0.4279228746891022,
-0.47758254408836365,
0.42310619354248047,
0.28314584493637085,
-0.13485150039196014,
-0.5038502216339111,
-0.49782460927963257,
-0.28492146730422974,
-0.4987759292125702,
0.31446826457977295,
-0.28363707661628723,
-0.8878433108329773,
0.8416339755058289,
-0.10577745735645294,
0.27670732140541077,
0.20303575694561005,
-0.002570447977632284,
0.17144840955734253,
1.3194819688796997,
0.33129215240478516,
-0.001155023230239749,
0.4563278555870056,
-0.22265854477882385,
0.11618167161941528,
-1.184609293937683,
-0.1284029483795166,
-0.29894885420799255,
-0.451381117105484,
-0.4816266596317291,
-0.5333094000816345,
0.6139569282531738,
0.07683945447206497,
-0.2148686945438385,
0.3850991427898407,
-0.3849889934062958,
0.38189247250556946,
-0.05428958311676979,
0.23082152009010315,
0.01744256354868412,
-0.29105159640312195,
-0.10255055874586105,
-0.13663721084594727,
-0.7950477004051208,
-0.5103610157966614,
0.8979313373565674,
0.06495990604162216,
1.0510820150375366,
0.47911152243614197,
0.5704691410064697,
0.18386094272136688,
0.4089644253253937,
-0.7503675222396851,
0.8629682064056396,
-0.28692349791526794,
-0.8119614720344543,
-0.40908703207969666,
-0.24032320082187653,
-0.983198344707489,
0.3652874827384949,
-0.313493937253952,
-0.7845015525817871,
0.08469769358634949,
0.10156332701444626,
-0.658175528049469,
0.2381891906261444,
-0.3443131446838379,
0.7549540996551514,
-0.16057880222797394,
-0.7974939346313477,
-0.00246579572558403,
-0.6378905177116394,
0.6789247393608093,
0.27937737107276917,
-0.059270359575748444,
0.02812681905925274,
-0.031202491372823715,
0.4006415009498596,
-0.09277714788913727,
1.187321662902832,
-0.40380603075027466,
-0.3831053078174591,
0.3907187879085541,
0.5098665356636047,
0.7707687616348267,
0.23705323040485382,
-0.4924386441707611,
-0.3368324935436249,
-0.1943659782409668,
-0.2550640404224396,
-0.7200269103050232,
0.799111008644104,
-0.6102726459503174,
-1.1780433654785156,
-0.17351771891117096,
-0.622490406036377,
-0.49452897906303406,
-0.08116918802261353,
-0.14536969363689423,
0.6352524757385254,
-0.6963962316513062,
0.2727244794368744,
0.9612276554107666,
-0.3504016399383545,
0.17065496742725372,
0.5267998576164246,
-0.16717496514320374,
-0.1656738519668579,
0.5063427686691284,
0.08695369958877563,
0.31804201006889343,
0.22390873730182648,
-0.11036339402198792,
-0.17469874024391174,
-0.3174359202384949,
-0.582000195980072,
-0.07107482105493546,
-0.18708781898021698,
-0.4981810748577118,
-0.6935654282569885,
-0.4306401312351227,
-0.6720978021621704,
-0.10591864585876465,
-0.23153512179851532,
-0.11695832759141922,
0.14784252643585205,
0.015509402379393578,
0.00025726566673256457,
0.5987673401832581,
-0.0630817636847496,
0.3166048526763916,
-0.8055975437164307,
0.05882414057850838,
0.37603330612182617,
0.5769379734992981,
0.05788039788603783,
-0.5540984272956848,
-0.27007895708084106,
-0.1454283893108368,
-0.3855632245540619,
-0.9806239604949951,
0.16930091381072998,
0.16173049807548523,
0.7896486520767212,
0.4373176097869873,
0.13477645814418793,
0.7965026497840881,
-0.5575565695762634,
1.0080878734588623,
-0.54169762134552,
-0.756980299949646,
0.5437220931053162,
-0.8065780997276306,
0.17092840373516083,
0.4271286427974701,
0.276176780462265,
-0.4103488326072693,
-0.3439941108226776,
-0.5369014739990234,
-0.7530512809753418,
1.0778952836990356,
0.10890904814004898,
0.22960194945335388,
-0.07097308337688446,
0.4360409677028656,
-0.14514052867889404,
0.1788402646780014,
-0.42757102847099304,
0.1183992549777031,
0.05579197406768799,
0.02524445205926895,
-0.07423390448093414,
-0.13759519159793854,
-0.574144184589386,
0.10122876614332199,
0.8110151290893555,
-0.05561121180653572,
0.15014390647411346,
0.07420419156551361,
0.06448190659284592,
-0.2575991153717041,
0.2560998797416687,
0.5924854874610901,
0.3209323585033417,
-0.23187285661697388,
-0.038473960012197495,
0.26067596673965454,
-0.15744513273239136,
0.06811774522066116,
0.08098357170820236,
0.04990415275096893,
-0.3471221923828125,
0.3814563751220703,
0.5232720375061035,
0.45444241166114807,
-0.8239043951034546,
0.6128478646278381,
0.013929751701653004,
0.09377766400575638,
0.01724729873239994,
0.5892474055290222,
0.12879833579063416,
0.251889169216156,
0.06182418018579483,
-0.25680556893348694,
0.25229865312576294,
-0.6398181915283203,
0.3404620289802551,
0.8770411610603333,
-0.3982618451118469,
-0.1652652472257614,
0.4153304100036621,
0.4662424921989441,
-0.6059194803237915,
0.5444028973579407,
-0.03580480441451073,
-0.5907566547393799,
0.6779351830482483,
0.5359438061714172,
0.763481855392456,
-0.7883435487747192,
0.29992029070854187,
0.4128957986831665,
0.466993510723114,
-0.06761224567890167,
0.2713538408279419,
-0.03627323731780052,
-0.7307011485099792,
-0.45300307869911194,
-0.18063561618328094,
-0.31585806608200073,
0.23666588962078094,
-0.917007327079773,
0.3127857744693756,
-0.4524611532688141,
-0.2476305365562439,
-0.4246561825275421,
0.22969751060009003,
-0.29995059967041016,
0.07887039333581924,
-0.23716922104358673,
0.7171366810798645,
-0.7563778758049011,
0.2561774253845215,
0.8095982074737549,
-0.06823620945215225,
-0.53471440076828,
0.011536742560565472,
0.07948196679353714,
-0.8494975566864014,
0.3438676595687866,
0.08092526346445084,
-0.21225546300411224,
-0.12907342612743378,
-0.81240314245224,
-0.5506750345230103,
1.0090358257293701,
-0.02575908601284027,
-0.3165692090988159,
0.06510557234287262,
-0.04561614990234375,
0.7756908535957336,
-0.5908896327018738,
0.23585431277751923,
0.4373033940792084,
0.36805999279022217,
-0.15665827691555023,
-0.7131931185722351,
0.13727553188800812,
-0.36011141538619995,
-0.014568711631000042,
0.3293885290622711,
-0.884848952293396,
0.4729624390602112,
-0.04755280911922455,
-0.3917829990386963,
0.19636590778827667,
0.3285134732723236,
0.2849976122379303,
0.15427717566490173,
0.6749421954154968,
0.4723471403121948,
0.16937828063964844,
-0.11850200593471527,
0.7554897665977478,
-0.2051466852426529,
-0.11922804266214371,
1.1863679885864258,
-0.743299126625061,
0.6442356109619141,
0.08426910638809204,
0.1610313355922699,
0.2622857987880707,
0.48793554306030273,
-0.024586841464042664,
0.3256593644618988,
0.6882345676422119,
-0.32217100262641907,
-0.5993884205818176,
-0.06523822993040085,
-0.16040043532848358,
0.5408301949501038,
0.5632938146591187,
-0.0809292271733284,
-0.2783842086791992,
-0.3434814512729645,
-0.10065820068120956,
0.30346521735191345,
0.021100729703903198,
1.0196059942245483,
-0.04662010818719864,
-0.9950870275497437,
0.2072746306657791,
0.023411042988300323,
0.5700418949127197,
-0.8692871332168579,
-0.17428375780582428,
-0.34880632162094116,
0.13653594255447388,
-0.15318308770656586,
-0.560927152633667,
0.17783860862255096,
0.012372398748993874,
0.14603738486766815,
0.1751057356595993,
0.6587521433830261,
-0.5020033717155457,
-0.07811697572469711,
0.4689798355102539,
0.471299409866333,
0.1844625174999237,
0.24469609558582306,
-0.8911488056182861,
0.33930811285972595,
-0.14753761887550354,
-0.23365826904773712,
0.3381918966770172,
0.47659409046173096,
-0.376829594373703,
0.4680348038673401,
0.38000231981277466,
0.035580284893512726,
0.01014100294560194,
0.0753607526421547,
1.059441089630127,
-0.5033106207847595,
-0.3313780725002289,
-0.5078522562980652,
0.6494400501251221,
-0.32190701365470886,
-0.2411881983280182,
0.550151526927948,
0.5864660739898682,
0.6018730401992798,
-0.0008573344093747437,
0.6046165227890015,
0.05300057679414749,
0.1558283269405365,
-0.385168194770813,
0.424717515707016,
-0.3560529351234436,
0.5221480131149292,
-0.16954830288887024,
-0.9423872232437134,
-0.23203015327453613,
0.5172421932220459,
-0.26488545536994934,
0.2664758563041687,
0.2606012523174286,
1.256717562675476,
-0.30560970306396484,
-0.2104506939649582,
0.602924108505249,
0.2643735110759735,
0.5243498086929321,
0.4980112910270691,
0.9869381189346313,
-0.6507242918014526,
0.46958643198013306,
0.20417417585849762,
-0.41792964935302734,
-0.3143596947193146,
-0.7258003950119019,
-0.9504826068878174,
-0.17297782003879547,
-0.048987358808517456,
-0.26903897523880005,
0.5262014865875244,
0.7863753437995911,
0.630903422832489,
-0.5594387650489807,
-0.5632206201553345,
0.4141397476196289,
-0.1323583424091339,
-0.45215219259262085,
-0.3125894367694855,
0.20695988833904266,
-0.5646263360977173,
-0.7949760556221008,
0.7825770974159241,
0.2271975576877594,
-0.2903749942779541,
-0.3617786765098572,
0.11414901912212372,
-0.28549662232398987,
0.667026162147522,
0.5324988961219788,
0.25999677181243896,
-0.5811280608177185,
-0.38597631454467773,
0.19984431564807892,
-0.22265467047691345,
-0.14195270836353302,
1.1869832277297974,
-0.40373292565345764,
0.5088329911231995,
0.33992359042167664,
0.7630059719085693,
0.053846728056669235,
0.4365725815296173,
1.0137869119644165,
-0.7929790616035461,
-0.10907077044248581,
0.3784443140029907,
-0.017329882830381393,
0.2768215239048004,
-0.7334074974060059,
0.75062096118927,
-0.3266065716743469,
-0.7023008465766907,
-0.88470059633255,
0.40937021374702454,
-0.8029648661613464,
-0.1854032427072525,
1.100639820098877,
-0.38820740580558777,
0.05817672610282898,
-0.15592604875564575,
-0.2679523825645447,
0.17608556151390076,
-0.37720784544944763,
1.0272724628448486,
0.8415541648864746,
-0.3329840302467346,
0.20475398004055023,
-0.4551723599433899,
0.8160017132759094,
0.7144650220870972,
-0.5063322186470032,
0.40232372283935547,
0.7216989994049072,
-0.04986026883125305,
0.055849846452474594,
0.5244083404541016,
-0.4740177094936371,
0.10524963587522507,
-0.17721402645111084,
-0.10497714579105377,
0.033953707665205,
-0.4147425889968872,
-0.37194162607192993,
0.03557582572102547,
-0.21416763961315155,
0.04233330115675926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10614v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10614v2 | Can LLMs Speak For Diverse People? Tuning LLMs via Debate to Generate Controllable Controversial Statements | 2024-02-16T12:00:34 | 2024-06-07T20:19:09 | Ming Li, Jiuhai Chen, Lichang Chen, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Making LLMs speak for different, especially minority groups of people, and
generate statements supporting their diverse or even controversial perspectives
is critical to creating an inclusive environment. However, existing LLMs lack
sufficient controllability to the stance of their generated content, which
often contains inconsistent, neutral, or biased statements. In this paper, we
improve the controllability of LLMs in generating statements supporting an
argument the user defined in the prompt. We find that multi-round debates
between two LLMs with opposite stances generate higher-quality and more salient
statements for each, which are important training data to improve the
controllability of LLMs. Motivated by this, we develop a novel debate & tuning
(DEBATUNE) pipeline finetuning LLMs to generate the statements obtained via
debate. To examine DEBATUNE, we curate the largest dataset of debate topics so
far, which covers 710 controversial topics and corresponding arguments for each
topic. Evaluations by the GPT-4 judge with a novel controversy controllability
metric show that LLMs' capability of generating diverse perspectives is
significantly improved by DEBATUNE. Moreover, such controllability can be
generalized to unseen topics, generating high-quality statements supporting
controversial arguments. | [
-0.7941843867301941,
-0.5633652806282043,
0.12417707592248917,
0.25456565618515015,
-0.5275545120239258,
0.45965540409088135,
-0.3601277768611908,
-0.2668350636959076,
0.3535168170928955,
0.3961560130119324,
-0.4280778765678406,
-0.45065662264823914,
-0.832581102848053,
0.02507578767836094,
-0.14267738163471222,
1.1214927434921265,
-0.08466741442680359,
0.05748917907476425,
0.2187509834766388,
-0.4785435199737549,
-0.5719798803329468,
-0.30620837211608887,
-0.40873852372169495,
-0.3272647261619568,
0.9536339044570923,
0.5851202607154846,
0.865909218788147,
0.4250238239765167,
0.3193623125553131,
0.3002013862133026,
-0.39245808124542236,
0.47003173828125,
-0.7660025954246521,
0.3975115716457367,
-0.7068706750869751,
-0.5187550783157349,
-0.037698712199926376,
0.0680888220667839,
0.4822200834751129,
0.39476829767227173,
-0.18479877710342407,
-0.15807510912418365,
0.17312070727348328,
0.36198392510414124,
-0.4298610985279083,
-0.5327482223510742,
-1.2602424621582031,
0.3007749319076538,
-0.5850955247879028,
-0.22380061447620392,
-0.11816349625587463,
-0.47886064648628235,
-0.3294549882411957,
-0.5036624073982239,
0.2747611403465271,
0.19884073734283447,
0.7746960520744324,
0.4440876543521881,
-0.5823127627372742,
-0.28850609064102173,
-0.7408290505409241,
0.5943195223808289,
-0.8193996548652649,
0.052184052765369415,
-0.03508444502949715,
0.32584187388420105,
-0.2779032588005066,
-0.36135226488113403,
-0.6115060448646545,
0.18715360760688782,
0.23861481249332428,
0.1739492267370224,
-0.22169621288776398,
-0.021245213225483894,
0.2760182321071625,
0.3028799593448639,
-0.21411095559597015,
0.7195973992347717,
-0.2796265780925751,
-0.3617016077041626,
0.7220426201820374,
0.28396356105804443,
-0.0875929445028305,
-0.3513471186161041,
-0.26198166608810425,
0.22519788146018982,
-0.6638056635856628,
0.00020502151164691895,
0.8932558298110962,
0.18952448666095734,
0.03241578862071037,
0.5334732532501221,
-0.35581105947494507,
0.5768141746520996,
0.39106011390686035,
-0.04541775584220886,
-0.04403727874159813,
-0.04665041342377663,
-0.2619531750679016,
0.008460656739771366,
0.7247638702392578,
0.5632617473602295,
-0.028958534821867943,
-0.02406155876815319,
0.011430750600993633,
-0.03493857383728027,
0.1864282339811325,
-0.7674371600151062,
-0.3477514088153839,
0.24157139658927917,
-0.20547203719615936,
-0.3761511445045471,
-0.024772511795163155,
-0.8666284680366516,
-0.9699742197990417,
-0.44079625606536865,
-0.09233646839857101,
-0.09248936921358109,
-0.3568449020385742,
-0.058019500225782394,
-0.19515277445316315,
0.11723814904689789,
0.7255150675773621,
-0.897602379322052,
0.13783623278141022,
0.6185102462768555,
0.5981463193893433,
-0.7042924165725708,
0.1898273378610611,
-0.6167001724243164,
0.2563353478908539,
-0.22998112440109253,
0.6182451844215393,
-0.7660425305366516,
-0.44139227271080017,
-0.35490861535072327,
-0.2928204834461212,
0.278472363948822,
-0.8178176879882812,
0.5638332962989807,
-0.4357288181781769,
0.1798834204673767,
-0.5514339804649353,
-0.5020076632499695,
0.2649955153465271,
0.42211344838142395,
-0.4495467245578766,
0.3167988359928131,
-0.03920000046491623,
-0.9052672982215881,
0.6505241990089417,
-0.4993765652179718,
-0.17077136039733887,
0.2188480645418167,
-0.7967073917388916,
-0.44779422879219055,
0.025369049981236458,
0.1822715699672699,
0.02805335633456707,
-0.05281520262360573,
0.4429570734500885,
-0.3602478802204132,
-0.2205052673816681,
0.5191633105278015,
-0.4916589558124542,
0.6739121675491333,
0.4269363284111023,
-0.5642114877700806,
0.1854000836610794,
-0.44720742106437683,
-0.14863738417625427,
-0.17346873879432678,
-0.5215917825698853,
-0.04919023811817169,
0.11831706017255783,
-0.17053963243961334,
0.15061193704605103,
-0.13798099756240845,
-0.5832303762435913,
0.36232057213783264,
-0.2061421126127243,
0.44147661328315735,
1.068796992301941,
0.019393254071474075,
0.2829474210739136,
-0.3313334882259369,
0.7151859998703003,
0.32052934169769287,
-0.09277845919132233,
0.2202623039484024,
-0.41137996315956116,
-0.8231081962585449,
-0.27435052394866943,
0.19966872036457062,
0.5325322151184082,
-0.5685545802116394,
0.18416500091552734,
0.1598435342311859,
-0.3777093291282654,
-0.6216394901275635,
0.500193178653717,
0.1201661080121994,
0.6048440933227539,
0.3200538456439972,
-0.01691724732518196,
-0.6081331968307495,
-0.9897577166557312,
-0.5891829133033752,
0.045766524970531464,
0.054677564650774,
0.5751301646232605,
0.07514675706624985,
-0.09646237641572952,
0.7883637547492981,
-0.2576060891151428,
0.1301240772008896,
-0.18132327497005463,
0.4472736716270447,
0.10714247077703476,
0.47848811745643616,
0.30785778164863586,
-0.8221406936645508,
-0.4574664533138275,
-0.1308714747428894,
-0.39552929997444153,
-0.3492901921272278,
-0.2940582036972046,
-0.47082439064979553,
0.10200554132461548,
0.24471482634544373,
-0.380675345659256,
0.05884360149502754,
0.28131377696990967,
-0.4181813597679138,
0.3882347643375397,
0.3086594343185425,
0.22343526780605316,
-1.0950207710266113,
-0.4158678948879242,
-0.10933486372232437,
-0.32891684770584106,
-0.05773196741938591,
-0.1858651340007782,
-0.15509319305419922,
0.07817661762237549,
-0.6819168329238892,
0.35893023014068604,
-0.2509804666042328,
0.45996394753456116,
-0.22838903963565826,
0.2702322006225586,
-0.10997554659843445,
0.3029758334159851,
-0.2005399912595749,
0.3378254771232605,
0.47616833448410034,
-0.5927115678787231,
0.5449097156524658,
0.44204485416412354,
-0.22973033785820007,
0.8896864652633667,
-0.4253872036933899,
0.1414790153503418,
-0.12507152557373047,
0.23957936465740204,
-1.1361825466156006,
-0.30625253915786743,
0.4345910847187042,
-0.13825443387031555,
0.4409351646900177,
-0.15200287103652954,
-0.08554049581289291,
-0.3834596872329712,
-0.2903937101364136,
0.13696137070655823,
0.3735767900943756,
-0.4741174280643463,
0.14218559861183167,
0.5275484919548035,
-0.3957007825374603,
-0.6598449945449829,
-0.817952036857605,
0.3535343408584595,
-0.6285089254379272,
-0.43361976742744446,
0.3187577426433563,
-0.21709054708480835,
-0.5060201287269592,
-0.2463350147008896,
-0.29267317056655884,
0.2741618752479553,
0.21393561363220215,
0.27015841007232666,
-0.14337682723999023,
0.03009059466421604,
0.3816838562488556,
0.6292731165885925,
0.017665712162852287,
-0.08539091795682907,
-0.05533133074641228,
0.34484535455703735,
-0.04815792292356491,
-0.640545666217804,
-0.06455297023057938,
0.5486868619918823,
0.12735587358474731,
0.03504135087132454,
0.33778685331344604,
0.42098742723464966,
0.08295965939760208,
-0.45864158868789673,
-0.5873881578445435,
-0.06085684895515442,
-0.4919227361679077,
0.3084694445133209,
-0.20211045444011688,
-1.4327681064605713,
0.41979366540908813,
-0.32639938592910767,
0.4930812120437622,
0.4489818215370178,
0.9514458179473877,
-0.3183533251285553,
0.7486699223518372,
0.24963422119617462,
0.05921049788594246,
0.28634124994277954,
0.15352414548397064,
-0.01182575337588787,
-0.5546783208847046,
-0.219020813703537,
-0.5770328044891357,
-1.156471610069275,
-0.7365235090255737,
-0.3798307478427887,
0.2915753126144409,
0.20736348628997803,
-0.3458148241043091,
-0.2029520720243454,
-0.7432385683059692,
0.6586220264434814,
0.17930637300014496,
0.04691952466964722,
0.5035992860794067,
0.13660213351249695,
-0.24722211062908173,
-0.5977132320404053,
-0.38324251770973206,
-0.6021957397460938,
0.7085025906562805,
0.3705902099609375,
1.1245315074920654,
0.38990142941474915,
0.8487313985824585,
0.4629122018814087,
0.6375622153282166,
-0.6711425185203552,
0.4185401201248169,
-0.019248630851507187,
-0.6921098232269287,
-0.16038797795772552,
-0.6189996004104614,
-0.7675964832305908,
0.6082019805908203,
-0.21660514175891876,
-0.7013938426971436,
0.20382268726825714,
0.3862478733062744,
-0.16015246510505676,
0.6523988842964172,
-0.27726590633392334,
0.5632718801498413,
-0.3830602765083313,
-0.39395448565483093,
-0.17656363546848297,
-0.5290948748588562,
0.5253251194953918,
-0.04782787337899208,
0.048208851367235184,
-0.4247637987136841,
-0.11393635720014572,
0.6823434233665466,
-0.3062116503715515,
0.9543818235397339,
-0.3046242296695709,
-0.49687662720680237,
0.2683769762516022,
0.1617773175239563,
0.19502055644989014,
0.5041966438293457,
-0.2229541391134262,
0.21141859889030457,
-0.6401711106300354,
-0.22059141099452972,
-0.39562278985977173,
0.8496056795120239,
-0.9344937801361084,
-1.2001570463180542,
-0.08990270644426346,
-0.5953694581985474,
-0.2790754437446594,
0.10096003860235214,
0.4295359253883362,
0.05634574592113495,
-0.20935450494289398,
0.17616605758666992,
0.8178375959396362,
-0.08298273384571075,
0.3511955738067627,
0.4559820890426636,
-0.13641493022441864,
-0.5744870901107788,
0.7093159556388855,
0.13902968168258667,
0.18465083837509155,
0.18039743602275848,
0.2051766961812973,
-0.30147886276245117,
-0.6662728190422058,
-0.4836380183696747,
-0.08816957473754883,
-0.7170730233192444,
-0.5032103657722473,
-0.791671097278595,
-0.02933249995112419,
0.01802898198366165,
-0.18937908113002777,
-0.22150732576847076,
-0.9887740015983582,
-0.27083948254585266,
-0.3200934827327728,
0.35126617550849915,
0.4070003628730774,
-0.08390400558710098,
0.3668491244316101,
-0.41418835520744324,
0.4775148332118988,
0.5644298791885376,
0.18518628180027008,
-0.5278163552284241,
-0.7251461148262024,
0.1321582794189453,
0.10760705918073654,
-1.0829029083251953,
-0.9637852907180786,
0.0679655596613884,
0.07751989364624023,
0.7617450952529907,
0.4599987864494324,
0.2109079509973526,
0.46084991097450256,
-0.2572774589061737,
0.8164847493171692,
0.35524290800094604,
-0.9653889536857605,
0.8011968731880188,
-0.3854687213897705,
0.08173183351755142,
0.48464235663414,
0.30344220995903015,
-0.3949149250984192,
-1.0590869188308716,
-0.487635999917984,
-0.8368557095527649,
0.6437816023826599,
0.16907989978790283,
0.37012895941734314,
0.049133215099573135,
0.12171313911676407,
0.609947681427002,
0.5317361950874329,
-0.7478154301643372,
-0.24131900072097778,
-0.5730915665626526,
-0.08325870335102081,
0.3103347718715668,
-0.11770562827587128,
-0.8871123194694519,
-0.3641422390937805,
0.3742033541202545,
-0.14597375690937042,
-0.2576892375946045,
0.0049594552256166935,
0.15902316570281982,
-0.29076141119003296,
0.7601237297058105,
0.5998889803886414,
0.6905929446220398,
0.05325765907764435,
0.46271637082099915,
0.07275838404893875,
-0.17274849116802216,
0.3987464904785156,
0.09652306884527206,
-0.34107744693756104,
0.011420125141739845,
-0.22401317954063416,
1.0584408044815063,
-0.2361781895160675,
-0.2580311894416809,
0.10571330040693283,
-0.15242506563663483,
-0.43299639225006104,
0.2645185887813568,
0.5022854208946228,
0.44153180718421936,
0.5040128231048584,
0.040100786834955215,
0.3696133494377136,
-0.06709380447864532,
-0.060065362602472305,
0.08238096535205841,
0.5141977071762085,
-0.1765964776277542,
0.10180091112852097,
1.093104600906372,
0.6834832429885864,
-0.18799778819084167,
0.32665982842445374,
-0.15876975655555725,
-0.22572749853134155,
0.5364811420440674,
0.4587118923664093,
0.7614062428474426,
-0.07090818881988525,
0.4657887816429138,
0.13134883344173431,
0.25705480575561523,
0.39117515087127686,
0.2778313457965851,
-0.277882844209671,
-0.9253929257392883,
-0.19758151471614838,
-0.44327229261398315,
-0.9618491530418396,
0.1979772299528122,
-0.4443797171115875,
0.15052920579910278,
-0.8661612272262573,
-0.3535041809082031,
-0.027696656063199043,
0.020464062690734863,
-0.39644676446914673,
-0.016678238287568092,
0.37156063318252563,
0.8590694069862366,
-0.693615198135376,
0.4946228265762329,
0.5868752002716064,
-0.10157648473978043,
-0.4115518629550934,
0.02785109169781208,
0.0662202462553978,
-0.3569246828556061,
0.47324854135513306,
0.0897960215806961,
-0.18988634645938873,
-0.2978794574737549,
-0.977921187877655,
-0.31599512696266174,
0.9072821140289307,
0.8330036997795105,
-1.0275685787200928,
0.48701515793800354,
0.19464439153671265,
0.17810393869876862,
-0.3027510941028595,
0.09474299848079681,
0.31754785776138306,
0.6336941719055176,
0.42022940516471863,
-0.646134078502655,
0.0783662274479866,
-0.16218897700309753,
-0.1454470306634903,
-0.02254590578377247,
-1.0628575086593628,
0.9747632145881653,
-0.24244527518749237,
0.010909700766205788,
-0.3972841501235962,
0.7611770033836365,
0.589874804019928,
0.3074829876422882,
0.4878480136394501,
0.42710161209106445,
1.3470349311828613,
-0.24936650693416595,
0.6650076508522034,
0.07155715674161911,
0.12635666131973267,
1.284485101699829,
-0.38561245799064636,
0.2986869513988495,
0.4692750573158264,
-0.0001693172234809026,
0.3834621012210846,
0.7406819462776184,
-0.11294745653867722,
0.31600484251976013,
0.6722785234451294,
-0.34539276361465454,
-0.4957610070705414,
-0.07399003952741623,
-0.48172527551651,
0.2781255543231964,
0.3482849597930908,
-0.09154444932937622,
-0.2501392960548401,
-0.10833925008773804,
0.25633513927459717,
0.4046030044555664,
-0.2408304661512375,
0.630573570728302,
0.11713484674692154,
-0.4920349717140198,
0.7426513433456421,
0.12447583675384521,
0.9397767186164856,
-0.5200954675674438,
0.17258279025554657,
-0.5145735144615173,
0.033874399960041046,
-0.4424886405467987,
-0.7755822539329529,
0.23071269690990448,
0.17144377529621124,
-0.11204914003610611,
-0.36626875400543213,
0.5597009658813477,
-0.5327848792076111,
-0.2981780767440796,
-0.087744802236557,
0.4491133391857147,
0.1543388068675995,
0.28222161531448364,
-0.7479291558265686,
0.1618209034204483,
0.28260594606399536,
-0.40118977427482605,
0.19552278518676758,
0.6631613969802856,
-0.13695128262043,
0.4658605754375458,
0.24244986474514008,
0.2562271058559418,
0.14873981475830078,
0.29983386397361755,
1.3282289505004883,
-0.5992522835731506,
-0.4107270836830139,
-0.912810206413269,
0.5622147917747498,
-0.4538348615169525,
-0.6101986765861511,
0.7791584730148315,
0.4003508687019348,
0.7903124690055847,
0.16773849725723267,
1.002784013748169,
-0.04665272310376167,
0.5256049036979675,
-0.4825498163700104,
0.6652635335922241,
-0.5450387001037598,
0.2062845379114151,
-0.13877356052398682,
-0.6237823367118835,
-0.11527873575687408,
0.4710384011268616,
-0.05087697505950928,
-0.05287866294384003,
0.3031904399394989,
0.7889817357063293,
-0.26487109065055847,
0.19497403502464294,
0.20421689748764038,
0.43234366178512573,
0.8611907958984375,
0.6006610989570618,
1.0744837522506714,
0.26350757479667664,
0.5228469371795654,
0.19436492025852203,
-0.2195868194103241,
-0.08060454577207565,
-1.0781633853912354,
-0.8852894902229309,
0.169817715883255,
-0.5676161050796509,
-0.26030072569847107,
-0.2560558021068573,
0.8807616233825684,
0.4192329943180084,
-0.9466942548751831,
-0.03747504577040672,
-0.12795978784561157,
0.6006946563720703,
0.14031337201595306,
-0.22010396420955658,
-0.11807061731815338,
-0.25476837158203125,
-0.8185964822769165,
0.3233332633972168,
0.2516925632953644,
-0.1076466292142868,
-0.33966711163520813,
-0.2783893048763275,
0.05311493203043938,
0.2047835886478424,
0.25680413842201233,
0.38806387782096863,
-0.7309659123420715,
-0.16033779084682465,
-0.463516503572464,
-0.19735465943813324,
0.2524234652519226,
0.9788253307342529,
-0.5239624381065369,
0.5448395013809204,
0.32196712493896484,
0.6491116881370544,
0.4853304326534271,
0.21004994213581085,
0.39223042130470276,
-0.8274503946304321,
0.3077663779258728,
0.5359894037246704,
0.27248820662498474,
0.4554944336414337,
-0.40413951873779297,
0.14858824014663696,
0.3465200662612915,
-0.48288920521736145,
-0.5280598402023315,
0.5840517282485962,
-1.1377947330474854,
-0.21818511188030243,
1.2080914974212646,
-0.061783406883478165,
0.37643101811408997,
-0.18384751677513123,
-0.675642728805542,
0.18685109913349152,
-0.5476773977279663,
0.9952251315116882,
0.7417951822280884,
-0.3439708650112152,
-0.0475766658782959,
-0.1905377209186554,
0.5659664273262024,
0.6448143720626831,
-0.8325657844543457,
0.1246461272239685,
0.6022338271141052,
0.3346605598926544,
-0.05661787837743759,
0.7679177522659302,
-0.15116995573043823,
-0.14986741542816162,
-0.22189699113368988,
-0.28303176164627075,
-0.24187394976615906,
-0.11860250681638718,
-0.1063465103507042,
0.2269809991121292,
0.050902750343084335,
-0.03713914752006531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10612v1 | Retrieve Only When It Needs: Adaptive Retrieval Augmentation for Hallucination Mitigation in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T11:55:40 | 2024-02-16T11:55:40 | Hanxing Ding, Liang Pang, Zihao Wei, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucinations pose a significant challenge for the practical implementation
of large language models (LLMs). The utilization of parametric knowledge in
generating factual content is constrained by the limited knowledge of LLMs,
potentially resulting in internal hallucinations. While incorporating external
information can help fill knowledge gaps, it also introduces the risk of
irrelevant information, thereby increasing the likelihood of external
hallucinations. A careful and balanced integration of the parametric knowledge
within LLMs with external information is crucial to alleviate hallucinations.
In this study, we present Rowen, a novel approach that enhances LLMs with a
selective retrieval augmentation process tailored to address hallucinated
outputs. This process is governed by a multilingual semantic-aware detection
module, which evaluates the consistency of the perturbed responses across
various languages for the same queries. Upon detecting inconsistencies
indicative of hallucinations, Rowen activates the retrieval of external
information to rectify the model outputs. Rowen adeptly harmonizes the
intrinsic parameters in LLMs with external knowledge sources, effectively
mitigating hallucinations by ensuring a balanced integration of internal
reasoning and external evidence. Through a comprehensive empirical analysis, we
demonstrate that Rowen surpasses the current state-of-the-art in both detecting
and mitigating hallucinated content within the outputs of LLMs. | [
-0.3540969789028168,
-0.7128084897994995,
0.6372638940811157,
0.44976499676704407,
-0.10473281145095825,
-0.3088368773460388,
-0.5416976809501648,
-0.5760298371315002,
0.557450532913208,
0.744167149066925,
-0.3721311092376709,
-0.3813275992870331,
-0.40058982372283936,
0.20952385663986206,
-0.25387781858444214,
0.7253267168998718,
0.14241859316825867,
0.2134673297405243,
-0.1733337640762329,
-0.19252465665340424,
-0.5953859686851501,
-0.4365001618862152,
-0.5392251014709473,
-0.26127469539642334,
0.7854101061820984,
0.02817283384501934,
0.787529706954956,
0.33312538266181946,
0.4148580729961395,
0.2895282804965973,
-0.05436855927109718,
0.6422259211540222,
-0.6746547818183899,
0.47897347807884216,
-0.18396314978599548,
-0.1326953023672104,
-0.1500130295753479,
-0.5571512579917908,
0.6445003151893616,
0.6881548166275024,
-0.32627689838409424,
-0.291782021522522,
0.19510246813297272,
0.5994396805763245,
-0.9234331250190735,
-0.043578967452049255,
-1.0926275253295898,
0.10113781690597534,
-0.058149151504039764,
-0.36266809701919556,
-0.6144033670425415,
-0.20599359273910522,
-0.013941943645477295,
-0.5542854070663452,
0.18119701743125916,
-0.056573789566755295,
0.4743008315563202,
0.43479230999946594,
-0.33602267503738403,
-0.42244380712509155,
-0.5744438171386719,
0.7451724410057068,
-0.5130655765533447,
0.6388273239135742,
0.48528099060058594,
0.19474007189273834,
-0.34334802627563477,
-0.6204855442047119,
-0.49642127752304077,
-0.5989044308662415,
-0.22767962515354156,
0.13151434063911438,
0.07209166139364243,
0.054949745535850525,
0.26721784472465515,
0.1408274918794632,
-0.603827178478241,
-0.06612589955329895,
-0.3442038893699646,
-0.5775232911109924,
0.5653871893882751,
0.13091866672039032,
0.19566094875335693,
-0.28685465455055237,
-0.2741531431674957,
0.038972459733486176,
-0.5553525686264038,
-0.38484132289886475,
0.40698859095573425,
0.4132368266582489,
0.45190349221229553,
0.7324126362800598,
-0.006399768870323896,
0.5419096946716309,
-0.029889410361647606,
0.20273858308792114,
0.21947823464870453,
-0.1368313729763031,
-0.05579235404729843,
0.3898356854915619,
0.580374002456665,
0.13397639989852905,
-0.07946043461561203,
-0.5506201982498169,
-0.41547828912734985,
-0.024050092324614525,
0.5299900770187378,
-0.5551391243934631,
-0.3087632954120636,
0.39088210463523865,
-0.2678079903125763,
-0.047010503709316254,
-0.0074167679995298386,
-0.6959097981452942,
-1.0119861364364624,
-0.4224089980125427,
0.6767666935920715,
-0.5500352382659912,
-0.45172369480133057,
0.23325957357883453,
-0.1316479593515396,
0.24051831662654877,
0.3080434799194336,
-0.6561866998672485,
0.06268250197172165,
0.4631401300430298,
0.9055390357971191,
-0.5548095703125,
-0.3395644426345825,
-0.7633450627326965,
0.4704422056674957,
-0.5213454961776733,
0.8079655766487122,
-0.4180702567100525,
-0.19438284635543823,
0.22462955117225647,
0.1365995556116104,
0.014013698324561119,
-0.8244197368621826,
0.5761209726333618,
-0.7195139527320862,
-0.0025980500504374504,
-0.3436586856842041,
-0.47831761837005615,
-0.06989815086126328,
0.14438344538211823,
-0.8342587351799011,
1.0420830249786377,
0.06767837703227997,
-0.8555959463119507,
0.13975569605827332,
-0.30384668707847595,
-0.5554699897766113,
-0.004752703011035919,
-0.015905773267149925,
-0.14468029141426086,
0.309732049703598,
0.2683029770851135,
0.1997891664505005,
-0.0484444722533226,
0.38092485070228577,
-0.39281779527664185,
-0.4331654906272888,
0.13535480201244354,
-0.3849577009677887,
0.6456640958786011,
0.03597334027290344,
-0.12720905244350433,
0.5071913003921509,
-0.763496994972229,
0.018005402758717537,
-0.011670080944895744,
-0.16768069565296173,
-0.47834691405296326,
-0.020940376445651054,
0.1653892695903778,
0.10632841289043427,
0.32024243474006653,
-0.30015966296195984,
-0.06899755448102951,
-0.5222116708755493,
-0.0692485049366951,
0.8512018322944641,
0.013189769349992275,
0.4144623875617981,
-0.5054091811180115,
0.2485101968050003,
-0.010431540198624134,
0.09323836117982864,
-0.010483140125870705,
-0.09699507057666779,
-0.9431686997413635,
-0.25932586193084717,
-0.1299397498369217,
0.5899074077606201,
-1.1078402996063232,
0.575916051864624,
-0.08151406794786453,
-0.18130801618099213,
-0.6009235978126526,
0.16541513800621033,
0.066543810069561,
0.4037933349609375,
0.6286510825157166,
0.20566315948963165,
-0.8778433203697205,
-0.8378772735595703,
-0.29310035705566406,
-0.10190107673406601,
-0.3318280875682831,
0.16384807229042053,
0.253023624420166,
-0.26656126976013184,
0.44061779975891113,
-0.30680036544799805,
-0.7475075721740723,
-0.2422582507133484,
-0.02111009508371353,
0.11470366269350052,
0.21321812272071838,
0.19452379643917084,
-0.7475115656852722,
-0.39725449681282043,
0.3557070791721344,
-1.0421085357666016,
-0.22498232126235962,
-0.3759608566761017,
-0.28315484523773193,
0.20734132826328278,
0.4333685040473938,
-0.6961672902107239,
0.3162187933921814,
0.13813315331935883,
-0.14772720634937286,
0.608203649520874,
-0.4210246205329895,
0.03102898597717285,
-0.9035763144493103,
-0.26362964510917664,
-0.30196669697761536,
-0.12060868740081787,
-0.4221734404563904,
0.09334218502044678,
0.17655445635318756,
0.24851903319358826,
-0.1979461908340454,
0.6579879522323608,
-0.4402247369289398,
0.024294249713420868,
-0.5502945780754089,
0.44236618280410767,
0.03729555383324623,
0.22364261746406555,
0.20069162547588348,
0.6467189788818359,
0.5099745988845825,
-0.6162030696868896,
0.5584568381309509,
0.21358653903007507,
-0.26143425703048706,
0.4476446509361267,
-0.35405492782592773,
0.19290730357170105,
-0.44852909445762634,
0.049169231206178665,
-0.8574604392051697,
-0.27603065967559814,
0.18338431417942047,
-0.2808789014816284,
0.22455012798309326,
0.20010815560817719,
-0.2337791621685028,
-0.19342674314975739,
-0.5186938047409058,
-0.04791760444641113,
0.14770767092704773,
-0.8873713612556458,
1.1939420700073242,
0.2944828271865845,
-0.058720629662275314,
-0.5586700439453125,
-0.6354278922080994,
0.3234713077545166,
-0.12511298060417175,
-0.7195168733596802,
0.5408395528793335,
-0.23914344608783722,
-0.11531036347150803,
-0.17179901897907257,
-0.1467711478471756,
0.09569186717271805,
-0.28543075919151306,
-0.0938715934753418,
0.24077238142490387,
-0.2479066401720047,
0.17647482454776764,
0.06597855687141418,
0.030282024294137955,
0.16169406473636627,
-0.4127567410469055,
0.5444716811180115,
0.3183445930480957,
-0.3258156478404999,
-0.3525640070438385,
0.4965224266052246,
0.4926130473613739,
0.12040635198354721,
1.1177213191986084,
0.8335815072059631,
-0.6240143775939941,
-0.356999933719635,
-1.0295244455337524,
-0.5396819114685059,
-0.46734461188316345,
0.6762336492538452,
-0.5508430600166321,
-0.5260776281356812,
0.8023955821990967,
0.27653470635414124,
-0.22042620182037354,
0.2577458918094635,
0.607128918170929,
0.10403379052877426,
1.0224170684814453,
0.2188730090856552,
0.09926682710647583,
0.3704127073287964,
0.06761635094881058,
0.2543931007385254,
-1.1797311305999756,
-0.5258599519729614,
-0.29878348112106323,
-0.043722204864025116,
-0.39466792345046997,
-0.36324870586395264,
0.36797621846199036,
-0.10105638206005096,
-0.11060909926891327,
0.07953694462776184,
-0.4340178370475769,
0.5378128290176392,
0.29792943596839905,
0.6073543429374695,
0.36141085624694824,
0.05804832652211189,
-0.21430818736553192,
-0.21021191775798798,
-0.610531210899353,
-0.22232328355312347,
0.9219719767570496,
-0.005627887323498726,
0.8714244365692139,
0.16126038134098053,
0.4440649449825287,
0.4903103709220886,
0.3763141334056854,
-0.7033035755157471,
0.5393773913383484,
0.020178157836198807,
-0.4883292317390442,
-0.3897588849067688,
-0.6395310759544373,
-0.7340070009231567,
0.682113528251648,
-0.21174797415733337,
-0.7975796461105347,
0.29916253685951233,
-0.03429713472723961,
-0.23300239443778992,
0.2466048151254654,
-0.5420783162117004,
0.5397334098815918,
-0.24673104286193848,
-0.7754959464073181,
-0.26812824606895447,
-0.4115085303783417,
0.36832135915756226,
-0.3477303981781006,
0.006835675798356533,
0.10751238465309143,
-0.08492285758256912,
0.4674617350101471,
0.0011579639976844192,
0.6525628566741943,
-0.2656632363796234,
-0.2908046543598175,
0.05751916766166687,
0.3020595610141754,
0.9548919796943665,
0.06712383776903152,
-0.41782432794570923,
0.04447484761476517,
-0.08713142573833466,
-0.2325061857700348,
-0.7972308397293091,
0.9418436884880066,
-0.4988050162792206,
-0.9240142703056335,
-0.36207714676856995,
-0.9089969992637634,
-0.27165982127189636,
-0.08549067378044128,
0.15886670351028442,
-0.01465062890201807,
-0.06082801893353462,
0.32979321479797363,
0.7296429872512817,
-0.40257206559181213,
0.2252844125032425,
0.5327013731002808,
-0.5395165681838989,
-0.6488908529281616,
0.8800874352455139,
0.19365139305591583,
-0.022573165595531464,
0.19576036930084229,
0.24473977088928223,
-0.5728585124015808,
-0.6542069911956787,
-0.18184250593185425,
0.3055417537689209,
-0.9848982095718384,
-0.2731480300426483,
-0.8752989768981934,
-0.4133424758911133,
-0.5704210996627808,
0.11154280602931976,
-0.2776404619216919,
-0.13075454533100128,
-0.1536133885383606,
-0.09303256124258041,
0.3008497357368469,
0.4912089407444,
-0.09003262966871262,
0.0757221207022667,
-0.6523500680923462,
0.6263160705566406,
0.17130310833454132,
0.2069953829050064,
0.21522873640060425,
-0.7856996655464172,
-0.24219383299350739,
-0.00841644499450922,
-0.0717167779803276,
-0.8247272968292236,
0.41017621755599976,
0.11476176232099533,
0.7087222933769226,
0.4331533908843994,
0.38550740480422974,
0.8537312150001526,
-0.36891645193099976,
0.5796322822570801,
0.03805806115269661,
-0.798259437084198,
0.37625566124916077,
-0.24916166067123413,
0.07971092313528061,
0.31499192118644714,
0.37587007880210876,
-0.4649108946323395,
-0.5241475105285645,
-0.02065577358007431,
-1.0147017240524292,
0.6218714118003845,
0.21264490485191345,
0.3139258921146393,
-0.10449633747339249,
0.4187990128993988,
0.1688947230577469,
-0.007404362317174673,
-0.9621450304985046,
0.16534793376922607,
-0.014773700386285782,
-0.22005483508110046,
0.4701489210128784,
-0.3172399699687958,
-0.17215652763843536,
-0.376608282327652,
0.9423620104789734,
-0.03349864110350609,
0.11048077791929245,
0.25367987155914307,
-0.47958990931510925,
0.004490841180086136,
-0.2624703049659729,
0.4539892375469208,
0.641943097114563,
-0.1512472927570343,
0.24831132590770721,
0.4881856143474579,
-0.4276407063007355,
-0.05150895565748215,
-0.005448803771287203,
-0.16203859448432922,
-0.017264872789382935,
0.4667145013809204,
0.842428982257843,
0.04093208163976669,
-0.5924934148788452,
0.3196621239185333,
0.08593277633190155,
0.08033248782157898,
-0.54684978723526,
0.08768661320209503,
-0.17972205579280853,
0.5243262648582458,
0.5548558831214905,
-0.009779000654816628,
0.17798446118831635,
-0.1382371187210083,
0.39010345935821533,
0.5373006463050842,
-0.4170295298099518,
-0.17666305601596832,
0.6460652947425842,
-0.22823533415794373,
-0.1894686371088028,
0.5911749005317688,
-0.05997558310627937,
-0.3434976637363434,
0.2382293939590454,
0.8426077961921692,
0.9100480675697327,
-0.5038002133369446,
0.06186191737651825,
0.3319081664085388,
0.45922043919563293,
-0.1991836130619049,
0.27447226643562317,
0.09549824893474579,
-1.0169777870178223,
-0.43629980087280273,
-0.6450828909873962,
-0.029265521094202995,
0.30238285660743713,
-0.5914955735206604,
0.3450794816017151,
-0.14233145117759705,
-0.15126721560955048,
-0.18409618735313416,
-0.4830053746700287,
-0.24422186613082886,
-0.1467835009098053,
0.03935595229268074,
0.6282646059989929,
-0.58455491065979,
0.8100513219833374,
0.3033319115638733,
-0.5209804773330688,
-0.31234633922576904,
0.2605940103530884,
-0.21353620290756226,
-0.6017736196517944,
0.42709171772003174,
0.062377624213695526,
-0.2749708294868469,
-0.1575317531824112,
-0.18906642496585846,
-0.6786355376243591,
0.6660527586936951,
0.6925999522209167,
-0.32461628317832947,
-0.11521261185407639,
0.08117581158876419,
0.3768998980522156,
-0.2933705449104309,
0.2017897069454193,
0.5275135040283203,
0.7368324398994446,
0.4239121973514557,
-0.5526769161224365,
0.1936732828617096,
-0.13155288994312286,
0.23327955603599548,
0.04111797362565994,
-0.2567863166332245,
0.4682300388813019,
-0.155796080827713,
-0.08307482302188873,
0.13549809157848358,
0.7913140654563904,
0.3096790909767151,
0.15340188145637512,
0.48666998744010925,
0.23557575047016144,
1.0908869504928589,
0.07175571471452713,
1.0060731172561646,
-0.2673366963863373,
0.08334419131278992,
1.2188481092453003,
-0.6948148012161255,
0.804161548614502,
0.7301068305969238,
0.010260307230055332,
0.19973312318325043,
0.4743436872959137,
0.12292154133319855,
0.6276980042457581,
0.21862202882766724,
-0.49649038910865784,
-0.3123630881309509,
-0.32788240909576416,
-0.39612215757369995,
0.2590045630931854,
0.37087947130203247,
-0.20074087381362915,
0.09619227051734924,
0.5908326506614685,
-0.20062780380249023,
0.1364937424659729,
-0.1754346638917923,
0.9113397002220154,
-0.11013081669807434,
-0.6487540602684021,
0.756504237651825,
-0.23309046030044556,
0.5787443518638611,
-0.6732144951820374,
-0.09932547062635422,
-0.37106871604919434,
0.3547307252883911,
-0.3333517909049988,
-0.4344864785671234,
0.6241016983985901,
-0.35749486088752747,
-0.2525405287742615,
0.08264566212892532,
0.8048127293586731,
-0.6905889511108398,
-0.6081272959709167,
0.9304695129394531,
0.3206857144832611,
0.0166859719902277,
-0.5527722239494324,
-0.258433997631073,
0.3142453134059906,
-0.005969855934381485,
-0.18539313971996307,
0.22466005384922028,
0.7210849523544312,
0.009934604167938232,
0.6431169509887695,
0.6463478803634644,
0.3852464556694031,
0.10917289555072784,
0.4409678280353546,
0.9963718056678772,
-0.5686107277870178,
-0.2872062921524048,
-0.7840542197227478,
0.3857870101928711,
-0.2836110591888428,
0.2464580237865448,
0.7422327399253845,
0.6528013944625854,
0.6281712651252747,
-0.20970095694065094,
0.5609641671180725,
0.30160093307495117,
0.25751686096191406,
-0.7470240592956543,
0.8838039636611938,
-0.6285479068756104,
0.5986411571502686,
-0.09014378488063812,
-1.2080614566802979,
-0.5770485997200012,
0.9579132795333862,
-0.24582937359809875,
0.08497576415538788,
0.8151605129241943,
1.2419016361236572,
0.012327563017606735,
0.07830928266048431,
0.6217814087867737,
0.4411303699016571,
0.11466081440448761,
0.37331274151802063,
1.1194177865982056,
-0.30937737226486206,
0.6294455528259277,
-0.01572531647980213,
-0.011754472739994526,
-0.09670554846525192,
-0.6747053861618042,
-0.8255677223205566,
-0.648502767086029,
-0.2036719024181366,
-0.6835594773292542,
0.22830364108085632,
0.9743058085441589,
0.565443217754364,
-1.131129503250122,
-0.16835200786590576,
0.09803840517997742,
0.3259589374065399,
-0.0724375918507576,
-0.2922276556491852,
0.5391047596931458,
-0.6252615451812744,
-0.520658552646637,
0.5781162977218628,
0.41146227717399597,
-0.20823636651039124,
-0.45190557837486267,
-0.23597365617752075,
-0.19006502628326416,
0.15879450738430023,
0.7593465447425842,
-0.3098137378692627,
-0.934565544128418,
-0.3247676491737366,
0.26925379037857056,
0.005654004402458668,
0.11869250982999802,
0.7923702597618103,
-0.7786679863929749,
0.5522114634513855,
0.4563085734844208,
0.8331300616264343,
0.47454947233200073,
-0.44010767340660095,
0.43471086025238037,
-0.7671335935592651,
0.43917182087898254,
0.31939324736595154,
0.3715335428714752,
0.44148069620132446,
-0.6649788618087769,
0.40429210662841797,
0.05188135430216789,
-0.2663789689540863,
-0.9101628661155701,
0.13038557767868042,
-0.6583695411682129,
-0.3468611538410187,
1.0757726430892944,
0.07636551558971405,
-0.12630054354667664,
-0.2900641858577728,
-0.5007787346839905,
0.16021493077278137,
-0.16370469331741333,
1.3320449590682983,
0.8329094052314758,
-0.02675842121243477,
-0.2730149030685425,
-0.5269306898117065,
0.35489422082901,
0.3382154703140259,
-0.7343364953994751,
0.3587842881679535,
0.5129250288009644,
-0.1499634087085724,
0.1622549146413803,
0.24045218527317047,
-0.10624510049819946,
0.09940207004547119,
-0.16509434580802917,
0.07528960704803467,
0.05700991675257683,
-0.4937038719654083,
-0.23834848403930664,
0.272428959608078,
-0.20269635319709778,
0.09877721220254898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10601v1 | Jailbreaking Proprietary Large Language Models using Word Substitution Cipher | 2024-02-16T11:37:05 | 2024-02-16T11:37:05 | Divij Handa, Advait Chirmule, Bimal Gajera, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are aligned to moral and ethical guidelines but
remain susceptible to creative prompts called Jailbreak that can bypass the
alignment process. However, most jailbreaking prompts contain harmful questions
in the natural language (mainly English), which can be detected by the LLM
themselves. In this paper, we present jailbreaking prompts encoded using
cryptographic techniques. We first present a pilot study on the
state-of-the-art LLM, GPT-4, in decoding several safe sentences that have been
encrypted using various cryptographic techniques and find that a
straightforward word substitution cipher can be decoded most effectively.
Motivated by this result, we use this encoding technique for writing
jailbreaking prompts. We present a mapping of unsafe words with safe words and
ask the unsafe question using these mapped words. Experimental results show an
attack success rate (up to 59.42%) of our proposed jailbreaking approach on
state-of-the-art proprietary models including ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Gemini-Pro.
Additionally, we discuss the over-defensiveness of these models. We believe
that our work will encourage further research in making these LLMs more robust
while maintaining their decoding capabilities. | [
-0.22629882395267487,
-0.9951834678649902,
0.8041871190071106,
-0.02424032799899578,
-0.5652552843093872,
0.21338213980197906,
-0.11982610821723938,
-0.55917888879776,
0.21324630081653595,
0.8384624719619751,
-0.5233880877494812,
-0.502177894115448,
-0.7888918519020081,
0.33095720410346985,
-0.18105937540531158,
0.867974042892456,
-0.3197669982910156,
0.37559664249420166,
0.21558061242103577,
-0.06650114804506302,
-0.8445171117782593,
-0.831706166267395,
-0.4333590865135193,
-0.008438484743237495,
0.2259185016155243,
0.20672903954982758,
0.6747285723686218,
0.5025187134742737,
0.46329450607299805,
0.3214758634567261,
-0.2721530497074127,
0.01954376883804798,
-0.3876109719276428,
0.250870019197464,
-0.23405718803405762,
-0.44453221559524536,
-0.19225433468818665,
0.12257630378007889,
0.19194670021533966,
0.11323108524084091,
-0.13316567242145538,
-0.16212502121925354,
-0.13464391231536865,
0.5246274471282959,
-0.49939191341400146,
0.14763621985912323,
-1.0853691101074219,
-0.03373594954609871,
-0.2883971333503723,
-0.12420511245727539,
-0.43752697110176086,
-0.6157143115997314,
-0.07023338228464127,
-0.388374924659729,
-0.20461638271808624,
0.2701636254787445,
0.3458898961544037,
-0.05244150757789612,
-0.040265414863824844,
-0.7953911423683167,
-0.37696754932403564,
0.7380303144454956,
-0.8462895750999451,
0.15911130607128143,
0.5860633254051208,
0.24695536494255066,
-0.37529268860816956,
-0.46612459421157837,
-0.4869998097419739,
-0.5626709461212158,
0.2577526867389679,
-0.1524370014667511,
-0.21000473201274872,
0.12421299517154694,
0.15580463409423828,
0.14924390614032745,
-0.4349396526813507,
0.3557206392288208,
-0.41201332211494446,
-0.3347504436969757,
0.40495172142982483,
0.2362004965543747,
0.7124684453010559,
-0.2856219708919525,
-0.24008116126060486,
-0.13447967171669006,
-1.1082229614257812,
-0.17385926842689514,
0.6929387450218201,
0.2767726480960846,
-0.011034823022782803,
0.68848717212677,
0.32785212993621826,
0.5464527606964111,
-0.13281629979610443,
-0.1265878975391388,
0.05461449176073074,
-0.24436520040035248,
0.017329882830381393,
0.250434011220932,
0.8405329585075378,
0.501131534576416,
0.4490235447883606,
-0.22077786922454834,
-0.2537935674190521,
0.04905347898602486,
0.18791423738002777,
-0.7259112000465393,
0.019907798618078232,
0.27636218070983887,
-0.29346781969070435,
-0.53383469581604,
0.008011512458324432,
-0.5606958866119385,
-0.7343735694885254,
0.15495158731937408,
0.2996368110179901,
-0.8440719842910767,
0.10149706900119781,
0.3399924337863922,
-0.13885197043418884,
0.38413965702056885,
0.20312699675559998,
-1.0011556148529053,
0.17684775590896606,
0.8735227584838867,
0.8218599557876587,
-0.008856400847434998,
-0.12132884562015533,
-0.4502086341381073,
0.15945883095264435,
-0.1715247631072998,
0.3971799612045288,
-0.5161321759223938,
-0.7881859540939331,
-0.006534563843160868,
-0.006740671116858721,
0.147997185587883,
-0.45500579476356506,
0.6264809966087341,
-0.7001059055328369,
0.008080909959971905,
-0.3907445967197418,
-0.7829163074493408,
-0.10603942722082138,
0.5158809423446655,
-0.7975899577140808,
0.3015393316745758,
-0.2428198605775833,
-0.8430019617080688,
-0.02775239758193493,
-0.4151860475540161,
-0.32593387365341187,
0.07710777968168259,
-0.11210577934980392,
-0.34113943576812744,
-0.0006089139496907592,
0.449815958738327,
0.29631245136260986,
-0.14421629905700684,
0.27089518308639526,
-0.3706744313240051,
-0.4289766848087311,
0.6558375954627991,
-0.5742549896240234,
0.8058512210845947,
0.34862279891967773,
-0.3695966303348541,
-0.05474881827831268,
-0.43045860528945923,
-0.20314815640449524,
0.38576799631118774,
-0.17129099369049072,
-0.4401038885116577,
-0.029311897233128548,
-0.06761489808559418,
-0.0713394433259964,
0.5098908543586731,
-0.7568576335906982,
0.3479056656360626,
-0.4375828206539154,
0.8748365044593811,
0.892555832862854,
0.13343407213687897,
0.2814193665981293,
-0.1414615362882614,
0.6954967379570007,
-0.149753600358963,
0.14400993287563324,
-0.2286337912082672,
-0.6361944079399109,
0.019786352291703224,
-0.19875378906726837,
0.0932399109005928,
0.8451237678527832,
-0.5529721975326538,
0.29452967643737793,
0.16722244024276733,
-0.3819982409477234,
-0.4797777831554413,
0.16451311111450195,
0.319008469581604,
0.41100984811782837,
0.4671109616756439,
0.07160811871290207,
-0.5828527808189392,
-0.6519421935081482,
-0.631342887878418,
-0.20986725389957428,
0.17839109897613525,
0.10629385709762573,
0.5360430479049683,
-0.29464444518089294,
0.5743471384048462,
-0.42886123061180115,
0.13395699858665466,
-0.5473694801330566,
0.05754348263144493,
0.3565042316913605,
0.5305862426757812,
0.39949700236320496,
-0.5052656531333923,
-0.28566038608551025,
-0.4139786958694458,
-0.5527908802032471,
-0.061804093420505524,
-0.1527506560087204,
0.16879776120185852,
-0.04720940813422203,
0.6859206557273865,
-0.7720467448234558,
0.23645205795764923,
0.5999258160591125,
-0.45448029041290283,
0.8859090209007263,
-0.31169232726097107,
0.150460883975029,
-1.1616445779800415,
-0.30563852190971375,
-0.17705731093883514,
-0.22206555306911469,
-0.7118938565254211,
0.4694618880748749,
0.18551428616046906,
-0.18024730682373047,
-0.4515720307826996,
0.34182748198509216,
-0.6146657466888428,
0.27515238523483276,
-0.29969000816345215,
0.18548664450645447,
-0.2984883189201355,
-0.08236099779605865,
-0.09163792431354523,
0.8808990716934204,
0.44123080372810364,
0.018628517165780067,
0.4737594723701477,
0.564847469329834,
-0.44978323578834534,
0.06607397645711899,
-0.8220109939575195,
0.5148186683654785,
-0.10414663702249527,
0.23654669523239136,
-0.7756932973861694,
-0.12000518292188644,
0.35923993587493896,
-0.23364990949630737,
0.17989398539066315,
-0.24025970697402954,
-0.6921939849853516,
-0.28435373306274414,
-0.6792548298835754,
0.2987654209136963,
0.6423870921134949,
-0.5622765421867371,
0.018729062750935555,
0.2521957457065582,
-0.15680517256259918,
-0.5604619383811951,
-0.7104383111000061,
0.41548091173171997,
-0.4602070152759552,
-0.7041005492210388,
0.28595873713493347,
-0.07266633212566376,
-0.32329750061035156,
-0.317205011844635,
0.08357135951519012,
0.13331016898155212,
0.1709355115890503,
0.251414030790329,
0.6755545139312744,
0.028026064857840538,
-0.48964932560920715,
0.055016789585351944,
-0.014180018566548824,
0.2380441427230835,
-0.18916355073451996,
0.6633903384208679,
-0.23302994668483734,
-0.281838983297348,
-0.4588666260242462,
0.3928428590297699,
0.7206419706344604,
-0.29522931575775146,
1.0087209939956665,
0.08606063574552536,
-0.3416078984737396,
-0.062409646809101105,
-0.6106046438217163,
-0.17836503684520721,
-0.5888447761535645,
0.06912606209516525,
-0.21528726816177368,
-1.2572591304779053,
0.6431722640991211,
-0.09416336566209793,
-0.06994946300983429,
-0.26158538460731506,
0.4535871744155884,
0.1597757339477539,
0.9313317537307739,
0.31707850098609924,
-0.4053076505661011,
0.39441177248954773,
0.0953521877527237,
0.4067228436470032,
-0.597895622253418,
-0.03425658866763115,
-0.44702211022377014,
-0.005081152077764273,
-0.7133525609970093,
-0.4371581971645355,
0.35096994042396545,
0.3049296438694,
-0.11005296558141708,
0.5131540894508362,
-0.32686445116996765,
0.6075025796890259,
0.1731245070695877,
0.13866952061653137,
0.3420288860797882,
-0.24063853919506073,
-0.12825468182563782,
-0.1348283290863037,
-0.17096000909805298,
-0.6361275315284729,
1.121429443359375,
0.49129030108451843,
1.0240211486816406,
-0.03847529739141464,
0.9907070994377136,
0.044177304953336716,
0.0038621400017291307,
-0.6886704564094543,
0.6414942741394043,
-0.10148365050554276,
-0.6209593415260315,
-0.19896477460861206,
-0.43693944811820984,
-0.7913100719451904,
0.0033561531454324722,
-0.20942790806293488,
-1.1479583978652954,
-0.25004372000694275,
-0.023668136447668076,
-0.3203917145729065,
0.5996857285499573,
-0.5566652417182922,
0.6882293820381165,
-0.325964093208313,
0.07789182662963867,
-0.11081115901470184,
-0.5315986275672913,
0.6336348056793213,
-0.18097564578056335,
0.4221418797969818,
0.08950354903936386,
0.11579464375972748,
0.6119964718818665,
-0.748668372631073,
0.8058987259864807,
-0.16863591969013214,
-0.2577803134918213,
0.304995059967041,
0.31476694345474243,
1.0575942993164062,
0.20230317115783691,
-0.1685202568769455,
0.09008315205574036,
-0.052395787090063095,
-0.028673836961388588,
-0.4853825867176056,
0.7494280934333801,
-0.5914524793624878,
-0.9337328672409058,
-0.3157244622707367,
-0.6004645824432373,
-0.34290266036987305,
0.17143334448337555,
0.4780157208442688,
0.29653656482696533,
-0.1699112206697464,
-0.11124812066555023,
0.6487762928009033,
-0.6262233853340149,
0.35096219182014465,
0.232421875,
-0.1407517045736313,
-0.4643368721008301,
0.6043701171875,
0.0077501158230006695,
0.25781092047691345,
0.09279818832874298,
0.36144042015075684,
-0.384794145822525,
-1.1129536628723145,
-0.32713449001312256,
0.2963801920413971,
-0.5918296575546265,
-0.21656754612922668,
-0.4131910502910614,
-0.19280917942523956,
-0.45821475982666016,
-0.5288586616516113,
-0.25724101066589355,
-0.2915361523628235,
-0.1658104509115219,
-0.4169788956642151,
0.501335084438324,
0.5657129883766174,
0.005942212417721748,
0.1677422672510147,
-1.1197601556777954,
0.3784677982330322,
0.16869638860225677,
0.0826224535703659,
-0.2909995913505554,
-0.3984178602695465,
0.1494944989681244,
-0.13347412645816803,
-0.07345090806484222,
-1.356204867362976,
0.34177714586257935,
-0.40963637828826904,
0.37233057618141174,
0.3469088077545166,
0.1190190240740776,
0.5506453514099121,
-0.866678774356842,
0.7876608371734619,
0.42645755410194397,
-1.2470301389694214,
0.534186601638794,
-0.5784011483192444,
0.07182923704385757,
0.7336247563362122,
0.1484425961971283,
-0.650448739528656,
-0.7933071851730347,
-0.2964155375957489,
-0.8010357618331909,
0.3358461260795593,
0.10797809809446335,
0.5059163570404053,
-0.19984965026378632,
0.5486318469047546,
0.3594864010810852,
0.07373055070638657,
-0.7568376660346985,
-0.15212294459342957,
-0.17355816066265106,
-0.20541734993457794,
0.2508937418460846,
-0.40240609645843506,
-0.1068195328116417,
-0.13710930943489075,
0.42468106746673584,
0.24295176565647125,
0.09358067065477371,
-0.010763686150312424,
-0.1502060890197754,
0.22977451980113983,
0.6816340684890747,
0.5281862616539001,
0.4015582799911499,
-0.20163024961948395,
-0.00009459810826228932,
0.20159028470516205,
-0.7880145907402039,
0.3145473301410675,
0.005022003781050444,
-0.32726550102233887,
-0.1491233855485916,
0.3493049740791321,
0.6527630090713501,
0.055949866771698,
-0.7402954697608948,
0.5664328336715698,
-0.1170988529920578,
-0.20538194477558136,
-0.38088276982307434,
0.1120409220457077,
0.14166319370269775,
0.15416350960731506,
0.06763502210378647,
-0.2795841097831726,
0.10753905773162842,
-0.7397342920303345,
0.04438098520040512,
0.7161120176315308,
-0.06950938701629639,
-0.21747419238090515,
0.7779169082641602,
0.06985612958669662,
-0.2172788679599762,
0.6853846907615662,
-0.29036879539489746,
-0.6605125665664673,
0.4863835573196411,
0.9845459461212158,
0.8614459037780762,
-0.2830915153026581,
0.33247366547584534,
0.19976146519184113,
0.7112510800361633,
-0.41114911437034607,
0.4612575173377991,
0.2857757806777954,
-0.9123553037643433,
-0.41824638843536377,
-0.4524298906326294,
-0.5986841320991516,
0.3802489638328552,
-0.5737430453300476,
0.19418470561504364,
-0.8902492523193359,
0.0187530517578125,
-0.4178880453109741,
-0.3768337070941925,
-0.12094329297542572,
-0.044941555708646774,
0.45259445905685425,
1.0948858261108398,
-0.4509739875793457,
0.8005958795547485,
0.5090639591217041,
0.04275090992450714,
-0.9915167689323425,
-0.06560943275690079,
0.1465296447277069,
-0.9489792585372925,
0.2857092320919037,
0.3931598961353302,
-0.08170905709266663,
-0.2457074373960495,
-0.8556759357452393,
-0.6658905744552612,
0.9376261830329895,
0.4925917088985443,
-0.8288861513137817,
-0.22769027948379517,
0.32300448417663574,
0.16630052030086517,
-0.19315744936466217,
-0.16390946507453918,
0.8320481777191162,
0.6652295589447021,
-0.15852655470371246,
-0.6317074298858643,
0.4727846682071686,
-0.04309071972966194,
-0.0770503357052803,
0.3203570544719696,
-0.20349986851215363,
0.7961328029632568,
-0.39915844798088074,
-0.07862678915262222,
0.5397819876670837,
0.35649576783180237,
0.7642523646354675,
0.10053219646215439,
0.40313926339149475,
0.6011021733283997,
0.7751586437225342,
-0.117209792137146,
0.879288911819458,
-0.4288877844810486,
0.22036553919315338,
0.8642045855522156,
-0.26300832629203796,
0.6475110650062561,
0.7074291706085205,
0.1297629028558731,
0.5034202337265015,
0.22615914046764374,
-0.25674116611480713,
0.6030084490776062,
0.5228679776191711,
-0.30179500579833984,
-0.06686682254076004,
0.3964728116989136,
-0.33729490637779236,
0.48704448342323303,
0.49378472566604614,
-0.3604434132575989,
-0.1217380240559578,
0.26550155878067017,
0.5655441284179688,
0.03256949037313461,
-0.46105948090553284,
0.6333187222480774,
0.3195938467979431,
-0.3662869334220886,
0.5702076554298401,
0.46656161546707153,
0.8474739193916321,
-0.7250440120697021,
0.14173784852027893,
0.00585912074893713,
-0.16809219121932983,
-0.011038657277822495,
-0.7722043395042419,
0.1929577887058258,
0.4978691041469574,
0.3660346269607544,
-0.30040284991264343,
0.7311928272247314,
-0.11747734248638153,
-0.2928721010684967,
0.28608956933021545,
0.23059146106243134,
0.031759943813085556,
-0.09555265307426453,
-0.6670552492141724,
0.3126189708709717,
-0.04810534045100212,
-0.26851627230644226,
0.2646888196468353,
0.09868130087852478,
0.03752945363521576,
0.5889917612075806,
0.6926544308662415,
0.23228229582309723,
0.15186002850532532,
-0.13048504292964935,
0.9091853499412537,
-1.0147303342819214,
-0.7557762265205383,
-1.241331934928894,
0.32580137252807617,
-0.01492774672806263,
-0.07481171190738678,
0.9342525601387024,
0.17425036430358887,
0.49960508942604065,
-0.06086874008178711,
0.9561537504196167,
0.178079292178154,
0.0001717279083095491,
-1.0410008430480957,
0.8973815441131592,
0.01258893869817257,
0.5601443648338318,
-0.47916263341903687,
-0.7887914180755615,
-0.0972290188074112,
0.3511877655982971,
-0.585100531578064,
-0.23314514756202698,
0.7551156878471375,
0.704763650894165,
0.20695963501930237,
0.4224984645843506,
0.2511656582355499,
0.25533899664878845,
0.4714924693107605,
0.5825659036636353,
0.9737400412559509,
-0.20542436838150024,
0.5078489184379578,
-0.07724367827177048,
-0.21073760092258453,
0.10692020505666733,
-0.8293657898902893,
-1.0072962045669556,
-0.2625477910041809,
-0.021434616297483444,
-0.493790864944458,
0.22121746838092804,
0.8256969451904297,
0.15795235335826874,
-0.7939474582672119,
-0.05766701325774193,
-0.42950892448425293,
0.12360192090272903,
0.15901890397071838,
-0.13429448008537292,
0.11027814447879791,
-0.0810510441660881,
-0.40617337822914124,
0.8925514221191406,
0.25533637404441833,
0.2120276391506195,
-0.20682531595230103,
-0.012532848864793777,
0.217035710811615,
0.3684957027435303,
0.32023105025291443,
0.2199060022830963,
-0.6214286088943481,
-0.459642618894577,
-0.04905104264616966,
-0.0548853762447834,
-0.08875714242458344,
1.0236966609954834,
-0.3202212154865265,
0.18551163375377655,
0.46685200929641724,
0.7169368267059326,
0.30738213658332825,
0.05495524778962135,
0.6145106554031372,
-0.37590569257736206,
0.21372438967227936,
0.3205431401729584,
0.7838411331176758,
0.46888303756713867,
-0.580569863319397,
0.08430615067481995,
0.21694375574588776,
-0.5116418600082397,
-0.7426438331604004,
0.577233612537384,
-0.8532657027244568,
-0.5713363289833069,
1.2091283798217773,
-0.2871112823486328,
-0.39040425419807434,
-0.16642546653747559,
-0.34197700023651123,
-0.06246407330036163,
-0.4091619849205017,
0.8266032338142395,
0.9341452717781067,
0.07561035454273224,
-0.10744011402130127,
-0.4598563015460968,
0.3340708911418915,
0.2341504544019699,
-0.7992090582847595,
0.15068018436431885,
0.4215114116668701,
0.5516591668128967,
0.010173880495131016,
0.42805302143096924,
-0.6874890923500061,
0.2543368637561798,
-0.001006753882393241,
-0.3309803009033203,
-0.3946665823459625,
0.05772552266716957,
-0.6119672656059265,
0.13653908669948578,
0.13149306178092957,
-0.04035159945487976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10597v1 | Efficiency at Scale: Investigating the Performance of Diminutive Language Models in Clinical Tasks | 2024-02-16T11:30:11 | 2024-02-16T11:30:11 | Niall Taylor, Upamanyu Ghose, Omid Rohanian, Mohammadmahdi Nouriborji, Andrey Kormilitzin, David Clifton, Alejo Nevado-Holgado | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The entry of large language models (LLMs) into research and commercial spaces
has led to a trend of ever-larger models, with initial promises of
generalisability, followed by a widespread desire to downsize and create
specialised models without the need for complete fine-tuning, using Parameter
Efficient Fine-tuning (PEFT) methods. We present an investigation into the
suitability of different PEFT methods to clinical decision-making tasks, across
a range of model sizes, including extremely small models with as few as $25$
million parameters.
Our analysis shows that the performance of most PEFT approaches varies
significantly from one task to another, with the exception of LoRA, which
maintains relatively high performance across all model sizes and tasks,
typically approaching or matching full fine-tuned performance. The
effectiveness of PEFT methods in the clinical domain is evident, particularly
for specialised models which can operate on low-cost, in-house computing
infrastructure. The advantages of these models, in terms of speed and reduced
training costs, dramatically outweighs any performance gain from large
foundation LLMs. Furthermore, we highlight how domain-specific pre-training
interacts with PEFT methods and model size, and discuss how these factors
interplay to provide the best efficiency-performance trade-off. Full code
available at: tbd. | [
-0.13007457554340363,
-0.8115390539169312,
0.8005959987640381,
0.16740405559539795,
-0.13731655478477478,
-0.22645026445388794,
-0.5147720575332642,
-0.400644987821579,
0.0002476441441103816,
0.5744429230690002,
-0.18643969297409058,
-0.1484529823064804,
-0.7719020843505859,
0.12430483102798462,
-0.2994373142719269,
0.5264331102371216,
-0.0005231582326814532,
0.2968602776527405,
-0.13160070776939392,
0.031932346522808075,
-0.04183575138449669,
-0.4997410774230957,
-1.0709344148635864,
-0.5537264943122864,
0.46866101026535034,
0.5182443261146545,
0.8596045970916748,
0.8104604482650757,
1.049485683441162,
0.274021178483963,
-0.07293431460857391,
0.07796373963356018,
-0.600245475769043,
-0.23230545222759247,
-0.07072275131940842,
-0.44891342520713806,
-0.9409342408180237,
0.0056290896609425545,
0.5308358073234558,
1.2767235040664673,
-0.3524186909198761,
0.014255337417125702,
-0.09560920298099518,
0.7931262850761414,
-0.6915308237075806,
0.033568672835826874,
-0.5340182781219482,
-0.11032071709632874,
-0.11605924367904663,
0.09854153543710709,
-0.3897341191768646,
-0.10208103060722351,
0.28427383303642273,
-0.44901004433631897,
0.19516202807426453,
-0.07193400710821152,
0.5710951685905457,
0.3499777913093567,
-0.36941206455230713,
-0.32006099820137024,
-0.7157070636749268,
0.8309122920036316,
-0.7800874710083008,
0.4581948220729828,
0.6496224999427795,
0.1786220520734787,
0.10346119105815887,
-1.0303071737289429,
-0.02813945896923542,
-0.40983846783638,
-0.252826988697052,
-0.3185533881187439,
-0.43275266885757446,
0.5291750431060791,
0.43335723876953125,
0.39255228638648987,
-0.31399306654930115,
0.4221758246421814,
-0.3156193792819977,
-0.05348588153719902,
0.5985344052314758,
0.35607391595840454,
0.11156772822141647,
0.2582380175590515,
0.2425689399242401,
0.1291290819644928,
-0.8660168647766113,
-0.14490288496017456,
-0.10142849385738373,
0.46735188364982605,
-0.0577387772500515,
0.5468344688415527,
-0.2681137025356293,
0.8181939721107483,
0.2954470217227936,
-0.4199216663837433,
-0.15114565193653107,
-0.2990413308143616,
-0.5103154182434082,
-0.17062583565711975,
0.6673870086669922,
0.23080821335315704,
0.20962020754814148,
-0.24832569062709808,
-0.16100406646728516,
-0.015248685143887997,
0.46408146619796753,
-1.0120433568954468,
-0.42194250226020813,
0.18532122671604156,
-0.5995473265647888,
-0.2888984978199005,
-0.6085581183433533,
-0.4643706679344177,
-0.1835745871067047,
-0.36648792028427124,
0.5347174406051636,
-0.44950243830680847,
0.025594377890229225,
0.41121023893356323,
0.3176112473011017,
-0.14557085931301117,
0.6309085488319397,
-0.9177153706550598,
0.5654747486114502,
0.4217888116836548,
0.7462823390960693,
-0.07031705975532532,
0.0035642441362142563,
-0.7227690815925598,
-0.1960352659225464,
-0.4124344289302826,
0.5932289958000183,
-0.46956387162208557,
-0.5633134841918945,
-0.14495307207107544,
-0.0839344710111618,
-0.45173025131225586,
-0.667007327079773,
0.737830400466919,
-0.19568367302417755,
-0.19981789588928223,
-0.21776023507118225,
-0.4398735463619232,
0.29802465438842773,
-0.07691128551959991,
-0.5525556206703186,
0.6042085886001587,
0.38324806094169617,
-0.492082417011261,
0.4819013476371765,
-0.6069684624671936,
-0.6539108157157898,
0.07473411411046982,
-0.11970241367816925,
-0.44263821840286255,
0.47543078660964966,
0.08771258592605591,
0.6881861090660095,
-0.5313403606414795,
0.1835544854402542,
-0.20493480563163757,
-0.3836541473865509,
-0.05001506954431534,
-0.17272470891475677,
0.3369865417480469,
0.4867630898952484,
-0.22547978162765503,
-0.1587468683719635,
-0.8246671557426453,
0.02366994321346283,
0.0933961421251297,
-0.347231924533844,
-0.4188023507595062,
-0.07298695296049118,
-0.050108652561903,
-0.029742376878857613,
0.3631216883659363,
-0.3580607771873474,
0.10170618444681168,
-0.36276111006736755,
0.6691970229148865,
0.20151589810848236,
-0.2143128514289856,
0.3946702778339386,
-0.322725385427475,
0.63579922914505,
-0.4916440546512604,
0.4830263555049896,
0.20719897747039795,
-0.2185361683368683,
-0.6180534958839417,
-0.6281535625457764,
0.5007144212722778,
0.04963656887412071,
-0.28051990270614624,
-0.06540820747613907,
-0.03390843793749809,
-0.5633410215377808,
-0.5364895462989807,
0.053824856877326965,
0.491545706987381,
0.43479350209236145,
0.11536121368408203,
-0.15004941821098328,
-0.006065265275537968,
-1.2680772542953491,
-0.3082418143749237,
-0.11426352709531784,
0.09971968829631805,
0.5368099212646484,
0.4853779077529907,
-0.15694163739681244,
0.6159053444862366,
-0.459546834230423,
-0.19126614928245544,
-0.34137779474258423,
-0.005682977382093668,
0.2824692726135254,
0.5054606199264526,
0.7292878031730652,
-0.7408490777015686,
-0.71055006980896,
0.2339565008878708,
-0.2800252139568329,
-0.32096055150032043,
-0.00396540854126215,
0.18779002130031586,
0.035268139094114304,
0.501865565776825,
-0.5654144883155823,
0.2825423777103424,
0.5058521032333374,
-0.22769491374492645,
0.4541154205799103,
-0.8446506261825562,
0.33348554372787476,
-0.3060673475265503,
0.29057198762893677,
-0.12836039066314697,
-0.462444007396698,
-0.8269222974777222,
0.004711393732577562,
0.34718000888824463,
0.023619841784238815,
-0.3556584417819977,
0.3203119933605194,
-0.3956749439239502,
0.2426096349954605,
-0.27901437878608704,
0.04664115980267525,
-0.055516261607408524,
0.2924407720565796,
0.05102207139134407,
0.920064389705658,
0.4499184787273407,
-0.4609737694263458,
-0.18820743262767792,
0.03958051651716232,
-0.3079477548599243,
0.45776715874671936,
-0.8705123662948608,
0.06868971884250641,
0.19356302917003632,
-0.3285747170448303,
-0.9233291149139404,
-0.3892020881175995,
-0.30400216579437256,
-0.02337775193154812,
0.5733176469802856,
-0.00834072008728981,
-0.6237044930458069,
-0.3530164957046509,
-0.19092212617397308,
0.32275620102882385,
0.5865471959114075,
-0.3161928653717041,
0.4532998502254486,
0.4723529815673828,
-0.4254593551158905,
-0.1799018383026123,
-0.604975700378418,
-0.11818493157625198,
-0.376963347196579,
-0.44077014923095703,
0.4425531029701233,
-0.1052609384059906,
-0.46170902252197266,
-0.37199726700782776,
-0.11866895854473114,
-0.18712256848812103,
0.20945709943771362,
0.030267814174294472,
-0.18447059392929077,
-0.24012000858783722,
0.25549057126045227,
0.3591679334640503,
0.1685146540403366,
0.07619678229093552,
0.10556302219629288,
0.40044060349464417,
-0.298625111579895,
-0.3613303601741791,
-0.45693275332450867,
0.3405798375606537,
0.8032730221748352,
0.00569490110501647,
0.8311006426811218,
0.1842898726463318,
-0.4518553912639618,
-0.1716695874929428,
-0.6107962131500244,
0.006182848941534758,
-0.44582152366638184,
0.5715468525886536,
-0.4018414318561554,
-0.8457359671592712,
0.37725144624710083,
-0.38836371898651123,
-0.04624874144792557,
0.5126577615737915,
0.7968252897262573,
0.10428203642368317,
1.2061353921890259,
0.8226156234741211,
0.37126991152763367,
0.3213675320148468,
-0.12541913986206055,
0.22396261990070343,
-0.567224383354187,
-0.04389088973402977,
-0.6934732794761658,
-0.15720774233341217,
-0.3601481020450592,
-0.49603015184402466,
0.5976144671440125,
0.3044949471950531,
-0.3426869213581085,
0.19356228411197662,
-0.4599131643772125,
0.49100834131240845,
0.255787193775177,
0.22552232444286346,
0.5163412690162659,
-0.15865395963191986,
0.016177069395780563,
-0.004740394186228514,
-1.0638623237609863,
-0.4964808225631714,
1.4788424968719482,
0.4784282445907593,
0.8022708296775818,
-0.04101511090993881,
0.5129355192184448,
0.18956169486045837,
0.3926946818828583,
-0.7579386830329895,
0.34155648946762085,
-0.5985819697380066,
-0.2865707576274872,
-0.40135324001312256,
-0.24310386180877686,
-1.036810278892517,
0.2387249767780304,
-0.1270664781332016,
-0.8280385732650757,
0.24527281522750854,
0.2599572241306305,
-0.8164260983467102,
0.17275689542293549,
-0.8816183805465698,
0.8437981605529785,
-0.33073216676712036,
-0.3993285894393921,
-0.42028263211250305,
-0.5613261461257935,
0.10588430613279343,
-0.7715926170349121,
0.19939200580120087,
-0.04468095675110817,
-0.3375752866268158,
0.8131242394447327,
-0.611876904964447,
0.7065833210945129,
0.010018110275268555,
-0.12915553152561188,
-0.14072786271572113,
0.11033450067043304,
0.4919341802597046,
0.08017192780971527,
-0.17299410700798035,
0.1382797807455063,
0.37912192940711975,
-0.4036579728126526,
-0.45097124576568604,
0.7372645735740662,
-0.7152396440505981,
-0.4356909394264221,
0.015559342689812183,
-0.5008453726768494,
-0.6502214074134827,
0.17657724022865295,
0.42388349771499634,
0.5481560826301575,
-0.2909350097179413,
0.3365783095359802,
0.7063229084014893,
-0.16619780659675598,
0.06739654392004013,
0.5994960069656372,
0.007281519006937742,
-0.1183273047208786,
0.4148847460746765,
0.23368263244628906,
0.5618549585342407,
0.43630099296569824,
0.35871878266334534,
-0.17968373000621796,
-1.0996630191802979,
-0.02941817417740822,
0.5174785852432251,
-0.5059338808059692,
-0.03955628722906113,
-0.6474314332008362,
0.02093292400240898,
-0.33275869488716125,
-0.4042871296405792,
-0.704943835735321,
-0.5610315799713135,
-0.23034293949604034,
0.2149829864501953,
0.23400211334228516,
0.6120284199714661,
-0.11040783673524857,
0.7782710790634155,
-0.4935794770717621,
0.14305950701236725,
0.17753133177757263,
0.45485249161720276,
-0.11903529614210129,
-0.6381680965423584,
-0.4618166387081146,
-0.20671257376670837,
-0.2820584177970886,
-0.5068824291229248,
0.5098568797111511,
0.3179234564304352,
0.5450204014778137,
0.5352221727371216,
-0.03567205369472504,
0.6322913765907288,
-0.4719048738479614,
0.527123749256134,
0.34366360306739807,
-0.8658652305603027,
0.5296317934989929,
-0.5106692314147949,
0.06790921092033386,
0.7414954900741577,
0.3426271378993988,
-0.09394281357526779,
-0.11188612133264542,
-0.6661562919616699,
-0.7074594497680664,
0.7100017070770264,
0.21450385451316833,
-0.08667264878749847,
0.03110096976161003,
0.6581173539161682,
0.31940513849258423,
0.30516403913497925,
-0.16627247631549835,
-0.10407399386167526,
0.5175637006759644,
-0.09027218818664551,
-0.2766575515270233,
-0.13326412439346313,
-0.32027173042297363,
-0.44853296875953674,
0.35756298899650574,
-0.36242735385894775,
0.3342221975326538,
0.3686877191066742,
0.000467003439553082,
-0.3100927770137787,
0.14528879523277283,
0.511145293712616,
0.9535027146339417,
-0.20975160598754883,
-0.08814793080091476,
0.33291056752204895,
-0.5724942088127136,
-0.1574922651052475,
0.07221946120262146,
0.3024332821369171,
-0.15643559396266937,
0.4888841211795807,
0.6776282787322998,
0.309493750333786,
-1.0199543237686157,
0.5116831064224243,
-0.12685103714466095,
-0.41846054792404175,
0.02409263886511326,
0.17531974613666534,
0.0042642648331820965,
0.3858816921710968,
-0.1327158361673355,
-0.011776406317949295,
0.28561943769454956,
-0.34522745013237,
0.03194063529372215,
0.46260619163513184,
-0.1775115579366684,
-0.2580752670764923,
0.7465915083885193,
0.12947478890419006,
-0.4726501703262329,
0.5547398328781128,
0.2799922227859497,
0.04261763393878937,
0.6371647715568542,
0.43910378217697144,
0.5998917818069458,
-0.0006348238093778491,
0.17510788142681122,
0.04400141164660454,
0.21809925138950348,
-0.32829803228378296,
0.11569257080554962,
-0.005849132314324379,
-0.41580891609191895,
-0.5142543911933899,
-0.6661414504051208,
-0.5527570247650146,
0.4277244508266449,
-0.7347576022148132,
0.15002663433551788,
-0.6334026455879211,
-0.4989354610443115,
0.13551585376262665,
0.14006994664669037,
-0.9491320848464966,
0.28694504499435425,
0.14325205981731415,
1.1670421361923218,
-0.5205130577087402,
0.8216570019721985,
0.7256311774253845,
-0.02011970430612564,
-0.9066781401634216,
-0.22702035307884216,
-0.2586929500102997,
-0.8912674188613892,
0.6309112310409546,
-0.2677472233772278,
-0.09395525604486465,
-0.09300072491168976,
-0.40532150864601135,
-0.7192628383636475,
0.9622702598571777,
0.7247227430343628,
-0.8672460913658142,
-0.3667636513710022,
0.2181035578250885,
0.8176705241203308,
-0.46118152141571045,
0.27813720703125,
1.2575480937957764,
0.23853261768817902,
-0.1787579208612442,
-1.5772610902786255,
-0.04499850422143936,
0.018002662807703018,
-0.12293246388435364,
0.31153640151023865,
-0.8481764793395996,
0.982062816619873,
-0.4275825023651123,
0.18203994631767273,
0.3069114685058594,
-0.13762667775154114,
0.08861533552408218,
0.2511225640773773,
0.3767126798629761,
0.3900245130062103,
0.8803809285163879,
-0.10809675604104996,
1.188679814338684,
-0.4962376356124878,
0.5718382000923157,
0.6501452326774597,
-0.2923711836338043,
0.6453001499176025,
0.5775356292724609,
-0.6801074147224426,
-0.03367846459150314,
0.6251554489135742,
0.23060862720012665,
0.504935622215271,
0.16174626350402832,
-0.020936327055096626,
-0.6087659001350403,
-0.0221922118216753,
-0.26404038071632385,
0.41250231862068176,
0.45534467697143555,
-0.6098204255104065,
-0.12072164565324783,
-0.02271706610918045,
0.02461981400847435,
0.01584658771753311,
-0.5607331991195679,
0.5886462926864624,
0.3256097435951233,
-0.5766622424125671,
0.7437350749969482,
-0.01808004081249237,
0.29638636112213135,
-0.8981239795684814,
0.21426396071910858,
-0.22291459143161774,
0.48971670866012573,
-0.0762878879904747,
-0.2615070044994354,
0.23516446352005005,
-0.10302194207906723,
0.0030673628207296133,
-0.28537580370903015,
0.6776589751243591,
-0.12124855071306229,
-0.38719338178634644,
0.2669106423854828,
0.7560355067253113,
0.23708976805210114,
-0.16621007025241852,
-0.6957571506500244,
0.052231576293706894,
-0.20586387813091278,
-0.359520822763443,
0.6757252216339111,
0.3914856016635895,
-0.04220281541347504,
0.6306412816047668,
0.3050953149795532,
0.4906674325466156,
-0.34363219141960144,
0.1775774359703064,
0.7246548533439636,
-0.48364681005477905,
-0.44406911730766296,
-0.777509331703186,
0.04948555678129196,
0.022145457565784454,
-0.3955425024032593,
0.45357224345207214,
0.3607140779495239,
0.5133718848228455,
-0.05990629643201828,
0.524825394153595,
0.10075240582227707,
0.4259563088417053,
-0.4939897656440735,
0.6376842856407166,
-0.9444259405136108,
0.29213622212409973,
-0.34873276948928833,
-0.39744246006011963,
-0.47937560081481934,
0.5919812917709351,
-0.6664835214614868,
0.039157070219516754,
0.7469373941421509,
0.5900851488113403,
-0.09865844994783401,
0.10886694490909576,
0.7429991960525513,
0.17699211835861206,
0.21429681777954102,
0.7508683800697327,
0.4557477831840515,
-0.12636440992355347,
0.09122785925865173,
-0.36023563146591187,
-0.5657635927200317,
-0.3233301341533661,
-0.7350803017616272,
-0.8183655142784119,
-0.22925548255443573,
-0.5082052946090698,
0.03234072029590607,
0.10834336280822754,
0.9053753614425659,
1.0833085775375366,
-0.6634763479232788,
-0.22794166207313538,
0.0006655043107457459,
-0.2927069365978241,
-0.31170397996902466,
-0.06288763880729675,
0.7135688662528992,
-0.36543145775794983,
-0.8088852167129517,
0.2879915237426758,
0.36988598108291626,
-0.13651268184185028,
-0.01978262886404991,
0.0352310836315155,
0.1490733027458191,
0.28935518860816956,
0.7048927545547485,
0.044863756746053696,
-0.5443217754364014,
0.09970767796039581,
-0.015365388244390488,
-0.11816536635160446,
0.0735025405883789,
1.0311610698699951,
-0.611781656742096,
0.30524492263793945,
0.21338580548763275,
0.6285513639450073,
0.4546615183353424,
-0.12185313552618027,
0.605102002620697,
-0.29359596967697144,
-0.09018228948116302,
0.32689109444618225,
0.5563777089118958,
0.14295624196529388,
-0.5085723400115967,
0.6305599212646484,
0.136193186044693,
-0.8862761855125427,
-0.9730117321014404,
-0.06267047673463821,
-0.9397594928741455,
-0.44221848249435425,
1.029895305633545,
-0.11904940009117126,
-0.02335949055850506,
-0.056337423622608185,
-0.31429269909858704,
-0.15096578001976013,
-0.20151470601558685,
0.6437577605247498,
0.5315991640090942,
-0.8016019463539124,
0.11429917812347412,
-0.6344955563545227,
0.7086983919143677,
0.590636670589447,
-0.6783139705657959,
0.2753934860229492,
0.3458864986896515,
0.3993279039859772,
0.10427627712488174,
0.9085073471069336,
-0.2005869746208191,
0.26676589250564575,
-0.02897047810256481,
-0.4014907479286194,
0.06620464473962784,
-0.3718114197254181,
-0.5247023701667786,
0.33530381321907043,
0.4287421405315399,
0.2810647189617157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10588v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10588v4 | Do Llamas Work in English? On the Latent Language of Multilingual Transformers | 2024-02-16T11:21:28 | 2024-06-08T11:15:14 | Chris Wendler, Veniamin Veselovsky, Giovanni Monea, Robert West | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | We ask whether multilingual language models trained on unbalanced,
English-dominated corpora use English as an internal pivot language -- a
question of key importance for understanding how language models function and
the origins of linguistic bias. Focusing on the Llama-2 family of transformer
models, our study uses carefully constructed non-English prompts with a unique
correct single-token continuation. From layer to layer, transformers gradually
map an input embedding of the final prompt token to an output embedding from
which next-token probabilities are computed. Tracking intermediate embeddings
through their high-dimensional space reveals three distinct phases, whereby
intermediate embeddings (1) start far away from output token embeddings; (2)
already allow for decoding a semantically correct next token in the middle
layers, but give higher probability to its version in English than in the input
language; (3) finally move into an input-language-specific region of the
embedding space. We cast these results into a conceptual model where the three
phases operate in "input space", "concept space", and "output space",
respectively. Crucially, our evidence suggests that the abstract "concept
space" lies closer to English than to other languages, which may have important
consequences regarding the biases held by multilingual language models. | [
-0.08037788420915604,
-0.5266314148902893,
0.5687700510025024,
0.301960825920105,
-0.23319965600967407,
0.4677466154098511,
-0.1423710584640503,
-0.4041793644428253,
0.3251279592514038,
0.31157174706459045,
-0.3714635968208313,
-0.14968790113925934,
-0.7177650928497314,
0.3595926761627197,
-0.5208057165145874,
1.0164515972137451,
-0.1783466339111328,
0.15494811534881592,
-0.23972631990909576,
-0.034602630883455276,
-0.4570614993572235,
-0.5323354005813599,
-0.4598553478717804,
-0.4971485137939453,
0.535703182220459,
0.6477938294410706,
0.852278470993042,
0.44829675555229187,
0.2780402898788452,
0.2960801124572754,
-0.163313627243042,
-0.06384392082691193,
-0.20022746920585632,
0.2327783703804016,
-0.05848660320043564,
-1.0094138383865356,
-0.0022014761343598366,
0.12595325708389282,
0.48980122804641724,
0.8952596783638,
-0.2189098596572876,
0.11492755264043808,
0.08936000615358353,
0.14811545610427856,
-0.3961655795574188,
0.16861769556999207,
-0.7921845316886902,
0.1944894790649414,
-0.31223610043525696,
-0.19559495151042938,
-0.46061643958091736,
0.03150206059217453,
-0.186296746134758,
-0.3146176338195801,
0.04189694672822952,
0.11346905678510666,
0.839021623134613,
0.3998118042945862,
-0.8119931221008301,
-0.3402281701564789,
-0.6814315915107727,
0.9017316699028015,
-0.6264933943748474,
0.40691882371902466,
0.42320704460144043,
0.1515071541070938,
-0.0015156654408201575,
-0.5151283740997314,
-0.7816238403320312,
-0.31577953696250916,
-0.34510695934295654,
0.1293494701385498,
-0.35870125889778137,
-0.3143549859523773,
-0.07054819911718369,
0.2541298270225525,
-0.4330885112285614,
0.4655022919178009,
-0.586371660232544,
-0.02185138687491417,
0.49695372581481934,
-0.02096562273800373,
0.3637206554412842,
-0.1085842177271843,
-0.2966705858707428,
0.12858940660953522,
-0.8880454897880554,
0.12435951828956604,
0.572062075138092,
0.29979029297828674,
-0.3522593379020691,
0.87193763256073,
0.4215772747993469,
0.28858640789985657,
0.1932997852563858,
-0.5543331503868103,
0.27789735794067383,
-0.07956969738006592,
0.26718220114707947,
0.05415967106819153,
0.7012364268302917,
0.2584720849990845,
0.3468434810638428,
-0.3381594121456146,
-0.2584850788116455,
0.3076052963733673,
0.16250303387641907,
-0.29676350951194763,
0.1271122545003891,
0.20146991312503815,
-0.22591803967952728,
-0.2784249186515808,
-0.1337820440530777,
-0.42054376006126404,
-0.16228528320789337,
-0.06470683962106705,
0.03327857702970505,
-0.04598454385995865,
-0.34009942412376404,
-0.0032570851035416126,
0.11081865429878235,
0.2736305594444275,
-0.14643283188343048,
-0.9371213316917419,
0.22259891033172607,
0.6290268898010254,
0.6084827184677124,
-0.5652617812156677,
-0.6743891835212708,
-0.24372002482414246,
0.38107994198799133,
-0.43920913338661194,
1.1153943538665771,
-1.012211799621582,
-0.4247124195098877,
0.327441543340683,
0.37150996923446655,
-0.08320117741823196,
-0.39047619700431824,
0.41484078764915466,
-0.4594752788543701,
0.5622698664665222,
-0.040058474987745285,
-0.22721777856349945,
-0.14022469520568848,
0.024756915867328644,
-0.5697369575500488,
1.2120827436447144,
-0.30982598662376404,
-0.7779761552810669,
0.3245960474014282,
-0.49657854437828064,
-0.810729444026947,
-0.1665685921907425,
-0.34104928374290466,
-0.05380202829837799,
0.22251221537590027,
0.19445276260375977,
0.5099344849586487,
-0.3137977421283722,
0.34917938709259033,
0.13606785237789154,
-0.3314734995365143,
0.4052850008010864,
-0.6146135330200195,
0.616976797580719,
-0.04874695837497711,
-0.5159505605697632,
-0.21806229650974274,
-0.6398960947990417,
-0.49525684118270874,
0.5183609127998352,
-0.3085004389286041,
-0.4236471354961395,
0.20917457342147827,
-0.1712215542793274,
0.27029114961624146,
0.23576503992080688,
-0.7646654844284058,
0.27556684613227844,
-0.4097389280796051,
0.709623396396637,
0.5724597573280334,
-0.26511150598526,
0.7255951762199402,
-0.004171517677605152,
0.7997531294822693,
0.35463592410087585,
-0.22535134851932526,
-0.5683626532554626,
-0.8657530546188354,
-0.8656718134880066,
-0.02903755195438862,
0.07004387676715851,
0.7335922122001648,
-0.5630484223365784,
0.1290690004825592,
-0.04675143212080002,
-0.329567015171051,
-0.727952241897583,
-0.06857891380786896,
0.112981416285038,
0.408946692943573,
0.17753717303276062,
-0.029543157666921616,
-0.2987578511238098,
-1.4013863801956177,
-0.07199794054031372,
-0.313998818397522,
0.0778193399310112,
-0.0641835406422615,
0.6055627465248108,
-0.20738279819488525,
0.698704183101654,
-0.2875204086303711,
-0.09512452036142349,
-0.35025909543037415,
-0.1025778278708458,
0.3503251373767853,
0.016794325783848763,
0.5160967111587524,
-0.6606804132461548,
-0.30925753712654114,
0.1326523870229721,
-0.6677278280258179,
-0.21923255920410156,
-0.11119929701089859,
0.0914146825671196,
0.22452275454998016,
0.4165953993797302,
-0.7553107142448425,
0.29247501492500305,
0.9541759490966797,
-0.3578161895275116,
0.2191094309091568,
-0.013542077504098415,
-0.09693245589733124,
-1.2992786169052124,
-0.1856740415096283,
-0.2972014844417572,
-0.03590019419789314,
-0.618436336517334,
0.005358076188713312,
0.07932916283607483,
0.019776908680796623,
-0.5236372351646423,
0.5734677314758301,
-0.3132392466068268,
-0.24335847795009613,
-0.35923105478286743,
0.28835827112197876,
0.10899844020605087,
0.5137036442756653,
0.024361221119761467,
1.1344332695007324,
0.3590024411678314,
-0.5219563841819763,
-0.04327293857932091,
0.08451423794031143,
-0.09821558743715286,
0.47612807154655457,
-0.7151673436164856,
0.24043035507202148,
-0.312185138463974,
0.19853967428207397,
-1.310564398765564,
0.2189510613679886,
0.15944786369800568,
-0.21121598780155182,
0.42571866512298584,
0.018498459830880165,
-0.4792686998844147,
-0.4090938866138458,
-0.09265196323394775,
0.4420872926712036,
0.2675187587738037,
-0.514658510684967,
0.47085073590278625,
0.6844428777694702,
-0.27605199813842773,
-0.8358147144317627,
-1.185390591621399,
0.04326458275318146,
-0.14989395439624786,
-0.5300458669662476,
0.48619717359542847,
0.008607876487076283,
-0.5144264698028564,
-0.007723259273916483,
-0.011149907484650612,
-0.1661175936460495,
0.07212928682565689,
0.18280434608459473,
0.20715533196926117,
-0.23238982260227203,
0.022179214283823967,
0.39687103033065796,
-0.13014960289001465,
-0.005086726043373346,
-0.290398508310318,
0.613375723361969,
0.08722352236509323,
-0.6210872530937195,
-0.16965577006340027,
0.5541929006576538,
0.6479482054710388,
-0.31186771392822266,
0.7720640301704407,
0.37524494528770447,
-0.3927456736564636,
0.0025447788648307323,
-0.5066777467727661,
-0.10003304481506348,
-0.43956631422042847,
0.6646804809570312,
-0.49953505396842957,
-0.9976399540901184,
0.6099407076835632,
0.31706368923187256,
0.3267488479614258,
0.7578532695770264,
0.9254405498504639,
-0.15981611609458923,
0.9466068744659424,
0.8862612843513489,
-0.011691922321915627,
0.07745242863893509,
-0.2107648253440857,
0.529574990272522,
-0.798660397529602,
-0.35671499371528625,
-0.5931844115257263,
-0.3275022506713867,
-0.6650217771530151,
-0.4387867748737335,
0.2949039041996002,
-0.09164735674858093,
-0.15649199485778809,
0.33920004963874817,
-0.27567821741104126,
0.654579758644104,
0.270282119512558,
-0.5610538721084595,
0.3509048521518707,
0.24361473321914673,
-0.3880409300327301,
-0.30398866534233093,
-0.7105486989021301,
-0.8328572511672974,
1.035462498664856,
0.4263652563095093,
0.4439046382904053,
0.1273997575044632,
0.40614867210388184,
0.014879104681313038,
0.2430770844221115,
-0.693382978439331,
0.18099841475486755,
-0.08120482414960861,
-0.5897517800331116,
-0.03231525048613548,
0.2721377909183502,
-1.246845006942749,
0.48660844564437866,
0.04316651076078415,
-0.5779836773872375,
0.10895708203315735,
-0.12475830316543579,
0.08947496116161346,
0.6237412691116333,
-0.65721195936203,
0.41995394229888916,
-0.4879065155982971,
-0.17193906009197235,
-0.2830897569656372,
-0.365193247795105,
0.4100816547870636,
-0.3114079236984253,
0.7117329239845276,
-0.17737188935279846,
-0.3646402657032013,
0.768192708492279,
-0.10731352865695953,
0.9447187185287476,
0.10235491394996643,
-0.713446319103241,
0.23580268025398254,
0.22461284697055817,
0.4397938549518585,
0.06663113832473755,
0.014216764830052853,
0.5900565981864929,
-0.06194591149687767,
-0.39514705538749695,
-0.3599134385585785,
0.42284277081489563,
-0.9514521956443787,
-0.6174694299697876,
-0.47201865911483765,
-0.5654701590538025,
-0.2509134113788605,
-0.007475524675101042,
0.38548120856285095,
-0.03491944447159767,
0.0844571441411972,
-0.030879704281687737,
0.036379653960466385,
-0.3204040825366974,
0.6648101806640625,
0.7011725902557373,
-0.3552587628364563,
-0.012956921011209488,
0.5720112323760986,
0.12825068831443787,
0.0918869599699974,
0.5578715801239014,
0.16705510020256042,
-0.19700801372528076,
-0.07621483504772186,
-0.49941810965538025,
0.4975201189517975,
-0.758933961391449,
-0.11005992442369461,
-0.5995643734931946,
-0.0657113566994667,
-0.04769103601574898,
-0.1043163612484932,
-0.44389641284942627,
-0.49243882298469543,
-0.17718853056430817,
-0.3606247007846832,
0.010971157811582088,
1.2161670923233032,
0.21105356514453888,
0.42846643924713135,
-0.5213261246681213,
0.15427672863006592,
0.3657127618789673,
0.0203506201505661,
-0.004175574518740177,
-0.8630916476249695,
-0.3581044673919678,
0.13833099603652954,
-0.32642990350723267,
-1.1204071044921875,
0.27562201023101807,
0.17022135853767395,
0.7640967965126038,
0.22194145619869232,
-0.5122731924057007,
0.4512946605682373,
-0.9914724230766296,
1.1950262784957886,
0.11317022889852524,
-0.765881359577179,
0.306983083486557,
-0.07220373302698135,
0.08232244104146957,
0.18080367147922516,
0.4544036090373993,
-0.7438691258430481,
-0.6142218708992004,
-0.45067963004112244,
-0.9136540293693542,
0.531030535697937,
0.12836647033691406,
0.571601390838623,
-0.39642560482025146,
0.16285938024520874,
0.4763451814651489,
0.39457353949546814,
-0.9998027086257935,
-0.6167452335357666,
-0.10549730062484741,
-0.10228285938501358,
-0.2226341813802719,
-0.39664945006370544,
0.04085288941860199,
-0.11748942732810974,
0.44782403111457825,
-0.17981381714344025,
0.4834599792957306,
-0.21409955620765686,
-0.3504631221294403,
-0.15412530303001404,
0.3800642490386963,
0.7149146199226379,
0.6395924687385559,
0.4057246744632721,
0.32531312108039856,
0.27356022596359253,
-0.5151981115341187,
0.4218345880508423,
-0.18464981019496918,
-0.2417253702878952,
0.15701338648796082,
0.6156246662139893,
0.7997351288795471,
0.4318426847457886,
-0.42023229598999023,
0.5781571865081787,
-0.02319679968059063,
0.06925306469202042,
-0.5371054410934448,
-0.3920886218547821,
0.20934061706066132,
0.3220646381378174,
0.7068922519683838,
-0.109084352850914,
-0.15831847488880157,
-0.5558634400367737,
-0.07708059251308441,
0.3870919346809387,
0.020708754658699036,
-0.8069500923156738,
0.8694853782653809,
0.08027344197034836,
-0.44155585765838623,
0.3238722085952759,
-0.14064106345176697,
-0.7274311780929565,
0.5725415349006653,
0.9338923692703247,
0.8329722285270691,
-0.30909669399261475,
0.21577854454517365,
0.08951427042484283,
0.7251490354537964,
0.1897609531879425,
0.23574715852737427,
0.2323065847158432,
-1.0664352178573608,
-0.8220000863075256,
-0.6205816864967346,
-0.42598623037338257,
0.04028678685426712,
-0.3304038941860199,
0.27243417501449585,
-0.06793126463890076,
-0.050481703132390976,
-0.17395786941051483,
-0.4380122721195221,
-0.8557431697845459,
-0.04528600350022316,
0.5430632829666138,
0.6257609724998474,
-1.118026852607727,
0.816985547542572,
0.9366973042488098,
-0.5178377628326416,
-0.8610044121742249,
0.17247775197029114,
-0.053787507116794586,
-1.196279764175415,
0.8473606705665588,
0.14457863569259644,
-0.15520545840263367,
-0.19965538382530212,
-0.5731210708618164,
-1.2688223123550415,
0.920805037021637,
0.5505337119102478,
-0.38798195123672485,
-0.08356617391109467,
0.5123912692070007,
0.510555624961853,
-0.6630199551582336,
0.4956907033920288,
0.5333387851715088,
0.42437973618507385,
-0.2019611895084381,
-0.9912838935852051,
-0.33844414353370667,
-0.41219693422317505,
-0.07846876978874207,
-0.023266157135367393,
-0.652500569820404,
1.111958384513855,
-0.11705488711595535,
-0.11860890686511993,
-0.2813873589038849,
0.6890692710876465,
0.17881260812282562,
-0.13502183556556702,
0.35223281383514404,
0.36196815967559814,
0.8364173173904419,
-0.08842457085847855,
1.143358588218689,
-0.789244532585144,
-0.00923295971006155,
0.8209767937660217,
-0.533206582069397,
1.0985565185546875,
0.7247022390365601,
-0.5049757361412048,
1.0556964874267578,
0.5476826429367065,
0.1965685933828354,
0.39443886280059814,
-0.12361182272434235,
0.1257728487253189,
0.10034260153770447,
-0.30182579159736633,
-0.15231367945671082,
0.7486332058906555,
0.3610336482524872,
-0.1583913266658783,
0.08001439273357391,
0.12748874723911285,
0.36153513193130493,
-0.09564897418022156,
-0.08306960761547089,
0.5172716975212097,
0.1554667353630066,
-0.6228928565979004,
0.41546323895454407,
0.27739110589027405,
0.9899494647979736,
-0.4789353311061859,
0.24997387826442719,
-0.5959205031394958,
-0.21277578175067902,
-0.35596758127212524,
-0.9530501961708069,
0.3171088695526123,
0.16688813269138336,
-0.1259528547525406,
-0.2108539640903473,
0.35091572999954224,
-0.6606037616729736,
-0.7174057364463806,
0.41184261441230774,
0.6458410024642944,
0.32561272382736206,
0.33461156487464905,
-0.40446725487709045,
-0.08161377161741257,
0.040583763271570206,
-0.33772459626197815,
0.12873095273971558,
0.3714531362056732,
-0.2928222715854645,
0.48480942845344543,
0.4486880898475647,
0.27574223279953003,
0.31221482157707214,
0.27859392762184143,
0.5651710629463196,
-0.4226919114589691,
-0.48410674929618835,
-0.777477502822876,
0.7620632648468018,
0.3169573247432709,
-0.34005147218704224,
0.6220089793205261,
0.5519677996635437,
1.0859826803207397,
0.07057394087314606,
0.7523968815803528,
0.24910946190357208,
0.3764321804046631,
-0.456180602312088,
0.3747900724411011,
-0.7862340211868286,
0.2606393098831177,
-0.19078852236270905,
-1.219457983970642,
-0.19213643670082092,
0.7526955604553223,
-0.2343442738056183,
-0.13161922991275787,
1.0562225580215454,
0.49440866708755493,
-0.02934487909078598,
-0.18288426101207733,
0.20135831832885742,
0.2026538848876953,
0.17901670932769775,
0.3185555338859558,
0.9556950330734253,
-0.46218717098236084,
0.48576971888542175,
-0.28679022192955017,
0.13871636986732483,
0.21009188890457153,
-0.7036622762680054,
-0.7357522249221802,
-0.6600923538208008,
-0.17266017198562622,
-0.025287412106990814,
-0.33320072293281555,
0.7366458177566528,
0.41228756308555603,
-0.8412002921104431,
-0.5584288835525513,
0.47954028844833374,
0.11508163064718246,
0.1397000253200531,
-0.16910994052886963,
0.27351874113082886,
-0.29205086827278137,
-0.8911112546920776,
0.600025475025177,
0.48040109872817993,
0.03564371541142464,
-0.6285943388938904,
-0.055553995072841644,
-0.21855252981185913,
0.05024353787302971,
0.6820738315582275,
-0.13222317397594452,
-1.0767446756362915,
-0.21435944736003876,
0.3163039982318878,
-0.19261226058006287,
0.2029494047164917,
0.7143452763557434,
-0.768804132938385,
-0.03795692324638367,
-0.005226658191531897,
0.4830397367477417,
0.3085094392299652,
-0.5208578109741211,
0.6420902013778687,
-1.0040476322174072,
0.8719008564949036,
0.05418805778026581,
0.6778532862663269,
0.5645359754562378,
-0.21354131400585175,
0.5140072107315063,
0.20024549961090088,
-0.30006977915763855,
-0.7924940586090088,
0.256175696849823,
-0.36096957325935364,
-0.17830321192741394,
1.4080524444580078,
0.2481478601694107,
-0.28590402007102966,
0.0320449098944664,
-0.13659492135047913,
0.17853394150733948,
-0.19194746017456055,
0.5281192064285278,
0.8466908931732178,
0.19730523228645325,
-0.2291320413351059,
-0.5547875761985779,
0.08752251416444778,
0.5706257224082947,
-0.4100490212440491,
-0.335650235414505,
0.021571535617113113,
0.08188773691654205,
0.3733695447444916,
0.45039603114128113,
-0.031511805951595306,
-0.12603232264518738,
-0.17165398597717285,
0.14273826777935028,
0.29427385330200195,
-0.3908129930496216,
-0.4872795641422272,
0.02991822175681591,
0.2943125069141388,
-0.0515235997736454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10586v2 | Threads of Subtlety: Detecting Machine-Generated Texts Through Discourse Motifs | 2024-02-16T11:20:30 | 2024-06-06T20:04:52 | Zae Myung Kim, Kwang Hee Lee, Preston Zhu, Vipul Raheja, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the advent of large language models (LLM), the line between
human-crafted and machine-generated texts has become increasingly blurred. This
paper delves into the inquiry of identifying discernible and unique linguistic
properties in texts that were written by humans, particularly uncovering the
underlying discourse structures of texts beyond their surface structures.
Introducing a novel methodology, we leverage hierarchical parse trees and
recursive hypergraphs to unveil distinctive discourse patterns in texts
produced by both LLMs and humans. Empirical findings demonstrate that, although
both LLMs and humans generate distinct discourse patterns influenced by
specific domains, human-written texts exhibit more structural variability,
reflecting the nuanced nature of human writing in different domains. Notably,
incorporating hierarchical discourse features enhances binary classifiers'
overall performance in distinguishing between human-written and
machine-generated texts, even on out-of-distribution and paraphrased samples.
This underscores the significance of incorporating hierarchical discourse
features in the analysis of text patterns. The code and dataset are available
at https://github.com/minnesotanlp/threads-of-subtlety. | [
-0.0827130600810051,
-1.0332618951797485,
0.7617629170417786,
0.06156696379184723,
-0.23900555074214935,
0.5713666081428528,
0.1006712019443512,
-0.5400720834732056,
0.13661031424999237,
0.723736047744751,
-0.48200881481170654,
-0.6020867824554443,
-0.5350853204727173,
0.2048618197441101,
-0.5048179626464844,
0.997818648815155,
0.14860668778419495,
-0.27047649025917053,
-0.14635369181632996,
-0.11898799985647202,
0.06186196580529213,
-0.5609538555145264,
-0.17273440957069397,
-0.472560852766037,
0.8430248498916626,
0.03918321430683136,
0.7192521095275879,
0.980273425579071,
0.543699324131012,
0.34124818444252014,
-0.3784232437610626,
0.4441305994987488,
-0.2569916248321533,
0.35227838158607483,
-0.20762668550014496,
-0.4081606864929199,
-0.09935519099235535,
-0.10984840244054794,
0.880878746509552,
0.8383249044418335,
0.3857097327709198,
0.2909906506538391,
0.6578001976013184,
0.5544742941856384,
-0.4522656202316284,
0.07549503445625305,
-0.6822776198387146,
0.06056244671344757,
-0.7813607454299927,
-0.5476269721984863,
-0.5347093343734741,
-0.3281107246875763,
-0.03177395090460777,
-0.20988117158412933,
0.36134257912635803,
0.25128379464149475,
1.027276873588562,
0.18868182599544525,
-0.3900132477283478,
-0.5666464567184448,
-0.9061013460159302,
0.8529954552650452,
-0.539151132106781,
-0.12011764943599701,
0.1104830950498581,
-0.050082333385944366,
-0.20457766950130463,
-0.7521647214889526,
-0.27846193313598633,
-0.16576609015464783,
-0.4040241241455078,
-0.23496749997138977,
-0.16451334953308105,
-0.12176188081502914,
0.36868834495544434,
0.3325325846672058,
-0.48577970266342163,
-0.020238004624843597,
0.10087821632623672,
-0.21124261617660522,
0.42632797360420227,
0.4249577820301056,
0.4668751657009125,
-0.4135732650756836,
-0.1344965249300003,
0.2867695391178131,
-0.7045140266418457,
0.11452235281467438,
0.5684301853179932,
0.18437060713768005,
-0.04991183429956436,
0.4378357529640198,
0.19432999193668365,
0.3608954846858978,
0.0642169937491417,
-0.46285513043403625,
-0.06833334267139435,
-0.2571439743041992,
0.06626182049512863,
-0.05910216644406319,
0.9962322115898132,
-0.10211443156003952,
0.1717587262392044,
-0.10073596984148026,
-0.2562442421913147,
-0.0672837346792221,
0.09613313525915146,
-0.5682327151298523,
-0.2732805013656616,
-0.2389436960220337,
-0.7275229096412659,
-0.8412801027297974,
0.09007060527801514,
-0.37576010823249817,
-0.8019750714302063,
-0.34603771567344666,
-0.19868479669094086,
-0.28473326563835144,
-0.20693106949329376,
-0.1402702033519745,
-0.3573538661003113,
0.31455928087234497,
0.0661192461848259,
-0.7685251832008362,
0.4215192496776581,
0.965724766254425,
0.7629680633544922,
-0.17770962417125702,
-0.2423018366098404,
-0.06117073819041252,
0.2974317967891693,
-0.4765412509441376,
0.8317216634750366,
-0.7570534944534302,
-0.19315627217292786,
-0.1348063051700592,
-0.21868488192558289,
0.19103719294071198,
-0.6359058022499084,
0.7953224182128906,
-0.1783745139837265,
0.04136577993631363,
-0.2960859537124634,
-0.42712971568107605,
0.10048359632492065,
0.05760602653026581,
-0.6469720602035522,
1.2235583066940308,
0.1091521680355072,
-1.42400062084198,
0.2514680027961731,
-0.26797887682914734,
-0.5629266500473022,
0.16844452917575836,
-0.644749104976654,
-0.6189417839050293,
0.2908508777618408,
0.03326806053519249,
0.4212534725666046,
-0.45138785243034363,
0.6047951579093933,
-0.21190708875656128,
-0.5408973097801208,
0.6508888602256775,
-0.6886207461357117,
0.8377947211265564,
0.12098543345928192,
-0.5635426640510559,
0.06314171105623245,
-0.8384387493133545,
-0.19037988781929016,
0.037991248071193695,
-0.3366396725177765,
-0.4536379277706146,
0.28859302401542664,
0.026940062642097473,
0.08588852733373642,
0.2200765460729599,
-0.3103794455528259,
0.0836411789059639,
-0.3549548089504242,
0.6020987629890442,
0.8710882067680359,
0.18354466557502747,
0.3917323648929596,
-0.6464737057685852,
0.41157761216163635,
0.38570636510849,
-0.018808120861649513,
-0.4945485293865204,
-0.7977228164672852,
-0.660706102848053,
-0.36430466175079346,
0.3023277521133423,
0.5187192559242249,
-0.7937498688697815,
0.5711338520050049,
-0.17844781279563904,
-0.31867557764053345,
-0.6261910200119019,
0.1478184461593628,
0.7457815408706665,
0.24340097606182098,
-0.25542905926704407,
-0.36317622661590576,
-0.6766476631164551,
-0.8958573937416077,
-0.704533040523529,
-0.26732107996940613,
-0.15320457518100739,
0.5324855446815491,
0.5777409672737122,
-0.2703666090965271,
1.0965098142623901,
-0.5011542439460754,
0.17672112584114075,
-0.05027295649051666,
0.700910747051239,
-0.014408566989004612,
0.33341675996780396,
0.4490172266960144,
-0.5095037221908569,
-0.5252422094345093,
0.2440946251153946,
-0.8969781398773193,
-0.29936063289642334,
-0.46658700704574585,
-0.10539256036281586,
0.09307760000228882,
0.6525541543960571,
-0.4848838448524475,
0.22699446976184845,
0.17715702950954437,
-0.21103356778621674,
0.543395459651947,
0.10110637545585632,
-0.08116356283426285,
-0.9726485013961792,
0.24446555972099304,
-0.1999761462211609,
-0.3197593092918396,
-0.3524264395236969,
0.14711402356624603,
-0.14051301777362823,
0.06518009305000305,
-0.17440059781074524,
0.42499077320098877,
-0.5773044228553772,
-0.13290588557720184,
-0.03889058157801628,
0.010177640244364738,
0.14868494868278503,
0.5139157176017761,
-0.29201772809028625,
0.6514707803726196,
0.3188230097293854,
-0.36103555560112,
-0.23264093697071075,
-0.20314016938209534,
-0.2890840470790863,
0.5279228091239929,
-0.5283412337303162,
0.42642322182655334,
-0.1823759526014328,
0.10109950602054596,
-1.15083646774292,
-0.3498050272464752,
0.3083306550979614,
-0.4433274269104004,
0.283647745847702,
-0.13317880034446716,
-0.7090856432914734,
-0.2880861163139343,
-0.5955471992492676,
0.32650530338287354,
0.418557733297348,
-0.11622975766658783,
0.40413689613342285,
0.5948056578636169,
-0.35597774386405945,
-0.4933505356311798,
-0.7088264226913452,
0.3486729562282562,
-0.2015267163515091,
-0.6048541069030762,
0.2563427686691284,
0.018620910122990608,
-0.41682669520378113,
-0.22949060797691345,
0.17061041295528412,
-0.3420272469520569,
0.31332913041114807,
0.4598971903324127,
0.07007835805416107,
-0.3972196578979492,
-0.04877122491598129,
0.42299655079841614,
0.04015427455306053,
0.20164057612419128,
-0.3963415324687958,
0.48745739459991455,
-0.033621106296777725,
-0.28808990120887756,
-0.5638543367385864,
0.4844951927661896,
0.7015731930732727,
0.12339488416910172,
0.4546245038509369,
0.6538543701171875,
-0.17869725823402405,
-0.11112606525421143,
-0.3849434554576874,
-0.2129494845867157,
-0.5114951133728027,
-0.048130400478839874,
-0.4122920334339142,
-1.0349676609039307,
0.42798376083374023,
-0.3890377879142761,
-0.030184095725417137,
0.3084169924259186,
0.47086718678474426,
-0.3689603805541992,
1.1601868867874146,
0.643473207950592,
-0.23771175742149353,
0.31920766830444336,
0.17716901004314423,
0.19114544987678528,
-0.8280196785926819,
0.06434458494186401,
-0.8659294843673706,
-0.4371967017650604,
-0.9955594539642334,
-0.45110225677490234,
0.047263529151678085,
-0.1152491644024849,
-0.13207104802131653,
-0.038500379770994186,
-0.8000950217247009,
0.7791749238967896,
0.5705873966217041,
0.04842749610543251,
0.37816321849823,
0.008726929314434528,
-0.47850659489631653,
-0.306311696767807,
-0.36591947078704834,
-0.9986199140548706,
0.8954423069953918,
0.42659226059913635,
0.4972771406173706,
-0.211809441447258,
0.9255213737487793,
0.5023260116577148,
0.12090171873569489,
-0.5907657146453857,
0.6079484820365906,
-0.08642534166574478,
-0.28274697065353394,
0.03587398678064346,
-0.4988217055797577,
-1.239288091659546,
0.14574694633483887,
-0.014103961177170277,
-0.5172515511512756,
0.013052199967205524,
-0.03854017332196236,
-0.04601529613137245,
0.37630656361579895,
-0.4394488036632538,
0.5081446766853333,
0.045892439782619476,
-0.2582230269908905,
0.3437747061252594,
-0.7465506792068481,
0.40355199575424194,
-0.005679766181856394,
0.3270709812641144,
0.02754323184490204,
-0.19527782499790192,
0.5387549996376038,
-0.012796665541827679,
1.372950792312622,
0.25457099080085754,
-0.41413721442222595,
0.5631964802742004,
0.30826959013938904,
0.5678561329841614,
-0.10675445199012756,
0.262615442276001,
0.21254940330982208,
-0.6028474569320679,
-0.371450811624527,
-0.17505696415901184,
0.724015474319458,
-0.7220404744148254,
-0.47655749320983887,
-0.30252915620803833,
-0.5969066023826599,
0.18487954139709473,
0.41995811462402344,
0.38485845923423767,
0.36799949407577515,
-0.42164289951324463,
0.016375374048948288,
0.8891663551330566,
-0.1646518111228943,
0.5769029855728149,
0.15986256301403046,
-0.08359512686729431,
-0.16825023293495178,
1.0060838460922241,
-0.03515619784593582,
-0.05146634578704834,
0.5754778385162354,
0.43789157271385193,
0.1352595090866089,
-0.5726249814033508,
-0.3800601661205292,
0.3378956615924835,
-0.46641844511032104,
-0.028550272807478905,
-0.7458562254905701,
-0.4908216893672943,
-0.24276913702487946,
-0.2807585597038269,
-0.0004563857219181955,
-0.5120938420295715,
-0.49018001556396484,
0.07714179158210754,
-0.09543146193027496,
1.164366364479065,
0.3190566897392273,
0.2647875249385834,
-0.7327327728271484,
0.32008838653564453,
0.3014346659183502,
-0.18085318803787231,
-0.05507194995880127,
-0.42119666934013367,
0.09954135864973068,
-0.16976143419742584,
-0.6989341974258423,
-0.7067128419876099,
0.3234489858150482,
-0.0548148974776268,
0.17363515496253967,
0.5481066107749939,
-0.17131294310092926,
0.39622119069099426,
-0.6990178823471069,
0.8639719486236572,
0.0725792795419693,
-1.074779987335205,
0.551267147064209,
-0.8052571415901184,
0.5698520541191101,
0.1805427372455597,
0.28893575072288513,
-0.3741387724876404,
-1.0483427047729492,
-0.7729315757751465,
-0.6898089647293091,
0.4830440580844879,
0.5184642672538757,
0.2379344403743744,
-0.09352944046258926,
0.388802707195282,
0.18446390330791473,
0.3722973167896271,
-0.7060459852218628,
-0.2545783817768097,
0.33570626378059387,
-0.27725106477737427,
0.3543722927570343,
-0.5373750925064087,
-0.15198451280593872,
-0.11002952605485916,
0.020592670887708664,
-0.17210179567337036,
0.11079316586256027,
0.02331610582768917,
-0.061401963233947754,
-0.12668736279010773,
0.32730892300605774,
0.6198332905769348,
0.4943143427371979,
0.1592566817998886,
0.5471394658088684,
-0.20380130410194397,
-0.6218882203102112,
-0.005258692894130945,
-0.43452805280685425,
-0.7237550020217896,
0.42968064546585083,
0.7168222665786743,
0.5673264861106873,
0.5734265446662903,
-0.29631227254867554,
0.30456212162971497,
0.014126915484666824,
-0.17352943122386932,
0.03162504360079765,
0.04343004897236824,
0.2477501779794693,
0.2879195511341095,
0.18799084424972534,
0.5019847750663757,
0.4493968188762665,
-0.6889107823371887,
0.13611893355846405,
0.30001553893089294,
-0.4401952028274536,
-0.6565564274787903,
0.2969411015510559,
0.2521700859069824,
-0.5175944566726685,
0.21600550413131714,
-0.3747982382774353,
-0.4004693627357483,
0.3919517397880554,
0.4261530339717865,
1.179909110069275,
-0.1579754799604416,
0.4332756996154785,
0.029290081933140755,
0.3907518684864044,
0.18121500313282013,
0.20905213057994843,
-0.3193281292915344,
-0.4827990233898163,
-0.24754543602466583,
-0.5916760563850403,
-0.3709963858127594,
-0.10892346501350403,
-0.4576634168624878,
0.26745498180389404,
-0.648610532283783,
-0.1942753940820694,
0.40009814500808716,
-0.09676652401685715,
-0.15439152717590332,
-0.42122215032577515,
0.31922125816345215,
0.18965646624565125,
-0.7388724088668823,
0.7815232276916504,
0.46894240379333496,
-0.011794055812060833,
-0.4322827160358429,
0.27820923924446106,
0.2883176803588867,
-0.505729615688324,
0.45835405588150024,
0.23555387556552887,
-0.4025382697582245,
-0.14418555796146393,
-0.7899783849716187,
-0.6009936332702637,
0.9599944949150085,
0.4926328957080841,
-0.5716919302940369,
-0.20854361355304718,
0.633230447769165,
0.5777864456176758,
-0.26734837889671326,
0.12256287038326263,
0.7178456783294678,
0.3556268513202667,
-0.009047840721905231,
-0.7206156253814697,
0.0698290690779686,
-0.1157521903514862,
0.2516465187072754,
0.376099169254303,
-0.4302773177623749,
1.0619885921478271,
0.010537364520132542,
-0.4897453486919403,
0.11576790362596512,
0.43631377816200256,
0.3172646760940552,
0.45063382387161255,
0.0632636770606041,
0.2818259596824646,
1.1829248666763306,
-0.03243876248598099,
0.9474002718925476,
-0.23647113144397736,
0.1443711817264557,
1.0906977653503418,
-0.31312692165374756,
0.5180729627609253,
0.4685412347316742,
-0.08614490181207657,
0.9210079908370972,
0.21973125636577606,
0.317351371049881,
0.12188167124986649,
0.43988585472106934,
-0.34613826870918274,
-0.009037251584231853,
-0.2576940953731537,
-0.050157953053712845,
0.29789063334465027,
0.3391702175140381,
-0.4995695650577545,
-0.1470128446817398,
-0.2386903613805771,
0.3407011926174164,
0.31354185938835144,
-0.11696608364582062,
1.0077619552612305,
0.3253006339073181,
-0.5559406280517578,
0.4921351969242096,
0.01683644950389862,
0.731198251247406,
-0.2707246243953705,
-0.03556521236896515,
-0.08898203819990158,
0.23936022818088531,
-0.25266724824905396,
-0.8893589973449707,
0.3802538812160492,
0.12463745474815369,
-0.40456143021583557,
-0.4092864692211151,
1.0622278451919556,
-0.1797019988298416,
-0.5684219002723694,
0.01227414421737194,
0.5667071342468262,
0.12897120416164398,
-0.15098081529140472,
-0.8298904895782471,
0.09570103883743286,
-0.05129902809858322,
-0.09007824212312698,
0.3336821496486664,
1.1705021858215332,
-0.2710496187210083,
0.3696856200695038,
0.7260050773620605,
-0.11751805245876312,
0.07259566336870193,
0.25609463453292847,
0.9411675333976746,
-0.9037952423095703,
-0.286373108625412,
-1.1838494539260864,
0.4766267240047455,
-0.27822113037109375,
-0.44972532987594604,
0.8048579096794128,
0.5361624360084534,
0.4187563955783844,
-0.013249799609184265,
0.685468316078186,
0.22839385271072388,
0.5432819724082947,
-0.2842249572277069,
0.8197591304779053,
-0.030970558524131775,
0.43870025873184204,
-0.5538386702537537,
-0.5612519979476929,
-0.2691464424133301,
0.29145896434783936,
0.169472798705101,
-0.1108960211277008,
0.8330163955688477,
0.788291335105896,
0.04905710741877556,
0.14189398288726807,
0.3154110610485077,
0.2548367381095886,
0.19505348801612854,
0.3060082197189331,
1.218660593032837,
-0.32427242398262024,
0.44043129682540894,
-0.04149721562862396,
-0.1569037288427353,
-0.11798729002475739,
-0.7620941400527954,
-1.2518810033798218,
-0.6048049330711365,
-0.40749794244766235,
-0.03308117389678955,
-0.1404166966676712,
0.26868894696235657,
0.4641370475292206,
-0.5713759660720825,
-0.3654196262359619,
-0.4235767424106598,
0.4959888458251953,
-0.06132684275507927,
-0.29402023553848267,
0.21205902099609375,
-0.5031644105911255,
-0.5710662007331848,
0.036915719509124756,
0.659544825553894,
0.0174228698015213,
-0.41714656352996826,
0.13951312005519867,
-0.17713594436645508,
0.5301541090011597,
0.6835317015647888,
-0.144644632935524,
-0.74358731508255,
-0.2337215542793274,
0.07372572273015976,
-0.5627793669700623,
0.12551084160804749,
1.4669996500015259,
-0.6470906734466553,
0.034623198211193085,
0.6156325936317444,
0.40296873450279236,
0.1268972009420395,
-0.2109859585762024,
0.27806800603866577,
-1.3229634761810303,
0.12150955945253372,
0.4707471430301666,
0.17114806175231934,
0.3642750084400177,
-0.43908143043518066,
0.28120043873786926,
0.42404913902282715,
-0.5373456478118896,
-0.973135232925415,
0.31298843026161194,
-0.7481477856636047,
-0.562200129032135,
0.9865543842315674,
-0.2176283746957779,
-0.47269076108932495,
-0.5653115510940552,
-0.544399082660675,
0.05238882824778557,
-0.1970205008983612,
0.8477749824523926,
0.6766083836555481,
0.05933386832475662,
-0.11145716160535812,
-0.16226191818714142,
0.585020124912262,
0.14471301436424255,
-0.791996955871582,
0.232111856341362,
0.37144792079925537,
-0.02354118414223194,
0.3785775899887085,
0.7084001898765564,
-0.21291589736938477,
0.0651380643248558,
0.20163066685199738,
-0.3574571907520294,
0.3469676077365875,
-0.45797958970069885,
-0.12521012127399445,
0.36401885747909546,
0.1811670958995819,
0.1000048816204071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10573v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10573v2 | LinkNER: Linking Local Named Entity Recognition Models to Large Language Models using Uncertainty | 2024-02-16T11:02:29 | 2024-02-27T15:08:02 | Zhen Zhang, Yuhua Zhao, Hang Gao, Mengting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Named Entity Recognition (NER) serves as a fundamental task in natural
language understanding, bearing direct implications for web content analysis,
search engines, and information retrieval systems. Fine-tuned NER models
exhibit satisfactory performance on standard NER benchmarks. However, due to
limited fine-tuning data and lack of knowledge, it performs poorly on unseen
entity recognition. As a result, the usability and reliability of NER models in
web-related applications are compromised. Instead, Large Language Models (LLMs)
like GPT-4 possess extensive external knowledge, but research indicates that
they lack specialty for NER tasks. Furthermore, non-public and large-scale
weights make tuning LLMs difficult. To address these challenges, we propose a
framework that combines small fine-tuned models with LLMs (LinkNER) and an
uncertainty-based linking strategy called RDC that enables fine-tuned models to
complement black-box LLMs, achieving better performance. We experiment with
both standard NER test sets and noisy social media datasets. LinkNER enhances
NER task performance, notably surpassing SOTA models in robustness tests. We
also quantitatively analyze the influence of key components like uncertainty
estimation methods, LLMs, and in-context learning on diverse NER tasks,
offering specific web-related recommendations. | [
-0.499368280172348,
-0.7727123498916626,
0.5821830034255981,
-0.2167229801416397,
-0.14308635890483856,
0.01893371157348156,
-0.43286246061325073,
-0.7665494084358215,
0.14470048248767853,
0.24940139055252075,
-0.3741972744464874,
-0.3500533103942871,
-0.7404053807258606,
0.5358560085296631,
-0.27400457859039307,
1.0519013404846191,
-0.12635871767997742,
-0.031071513891220093,
-0.18778939545154572,
0.0510970838367939,
-0.1335853785276413,
-0.2113606333732605,
-1.0537018775939941,
-0.1332044154405594,
0.7821747660636902,
0.2797619700431824,
0.867833137512207,
0.5672833919525146,
0.8678975105285645,
0.28570106625556946,
-0.10169395059347153,
0.16967065632343292,
-0.538977324962616,
0.2663252055644989,
-0.39963722229003906,
-0.3815118074417114,
-0.36504149436950684,
-0.3737964928150177,
0.6566899418830872,
0.5918892025947571,
-0.028920581564307213,
0.07092782109975815,
0.0033942239824682474,
0.3774997591972351,
-0.6889404058456421,
0.0942404568195343,
-0.8905878067016602,
-0.4010993540287018,
-0.18674640357494354,
0.02729954570531845,
-0.11728686094284058,
-0.34794679284095764,
0.23195970058441162,
-0.5717056393623352,
0.44808706641197205,
0.28047430515289307,
1.1906335353851318,
0.44852787256240845,
-0.3541995584964752,
-0.20221181213855743,
-0.9656415581703186,
0.6231827735900879,
-0.7042490243911743,
0.6840674877166748,
0.6459456086158752,
0.3231496214866638,
-0.3902616798877716,
-0.5719206929206848,
-0.6992470622062683,
0.03829401731491089,
0.17667235434055328,
-0.3248882293701172,
-0.4365054666996002,
0.026993224397301674,
0.2552180886268616,
0.19139143824577332,
-0.4037426710128784,
0.18002833425998688,
-0.31564903259277344,
-0.19055549800395966,
0.36386385560035706,
-0.012844325974583626,
0.14512187242507935,
-0.10468309372663498,
-0.20442911982536316,
0.1180519089102745,
-0.8558400273323059,
-0.20219393074512482,
0.4365341365337372,
0.6219361424446106,
-0.093610018491745,
0.42381057143211365,
-0.4347996115684509,
0.7544742226600647,
0.32896527647972107,
-0.05395617336034775,
-0.030241813510656357,
-0.18319468200206757,
-0.1162484735250473,
0.08491922914981842,
0.8695430755615234,
0.0778384655714035,
0.0431695282459259,
-0.3492389917373657,
-0.3347996175289154,
-0.08517590165138245,
0.1237330436706543,
-0.8825022578239441,
-0.3596106767654419,
0.12018854916095734,
-0.0956968441605568,
-0.15680493414402008,
-0.029770502820611,
-0.6752856373786926,
-0.3279174268245697,
-0.38654446601867676,
0.608626127243042,
-0.5356289744377136,
-0.07653740793466568,
-0.0028112952131778,
0.3386369049549103,
0.024123314768075943,
0.46646803617477417,
-0.7532497644424438,
0.42404070496559143,
0.621717095375061,
0.7231498956680298,
-0.09655651450157166,
-0.16859346628189087,
-0.6671259999275208,
0.28009480237960815,
-0.12375068664550781,
0.8000165224075317,
-0.5913235545158386,
0.06794475764036179,
-0.13691847026348114,
-0.035130251199007034,
0.10920487344264984,
-0.3627704381942749,
0.32691624760627747,
-0.9031805396080017,
-0.051251914352178574,
-0.3209817111492157,
-0.604181706905365,
0.028298096731305122,
0.1979128122329712,
-0.9607254266738892,
0.8619112968444824,
-0.020692387595772743,
-1.0517802238464355,
0.5027116537094116,
-0.25210943818092346,
-0.4944824278354645,
0.040817439556121826,
-0.15314900875091553,
-0.453833669424057,
0.17116379737854004,
0.26856285333633423,
0.5831480026245117,
-0.5656589865684509,
0.2544510066509247,
-0.5027392506599426,
-0.3640778660774231,
0.20946401357650757,
-0.3764480650424957,
0.23232752084732056,
0.07435981929302216,
-0.3076794743537903,
0.030779661610722542,
-0.7543715238571167,
-0.012191478163003922,
-0.09285720437765121,
-0.24326857924461365,
-0.5381999611854553,
0.055461589246988297,
0.019326886162161827,
0.2107553333044052,
0.2581070363521576,
-0.29300186038017273,
-0.19246065616607666,
-0.34129905700683594,
0.4384976923465729,
0.5511845350265503,
0.07180001586675644,
0.4560890793800354,
-0.10517054796218872,
0.4086352288722992,
-0.17564702033996582,
-0.11786426603794098,
0.36449795961380005,
-0.4121781289577484,
-0.9747167229652405,
-0.05161776393651962,
0.6489637494087219,
0.1858234852552414,
-0.7516223788261414,
0.3605177700519562,
-0.6336609125137329,
-0.4514501988887787,
-0.4281165599822998,
0.11081452667713165,
0.23170427978038788,
0.2832951545715332,
0.45237621665000916,
-0.15796604752540588,
-0.560604453086853,
-0.6099867820739746,
-0.18695782124996185,
-0.12565991282463074,
-0.249678835272789,
0.2863301634788513,
0.641655683517456,
-0.29192277789115906,
0.9306431412696838,
-0.2966865301132202,
-0.33099713921546936,
-0.17989550530910492,
0.34118545055389404,
0.11706577241420746,
0.19122262299060822,
-0.02281690575182438,
-0.9873266816139221,
-0.4563972055912018,
0.06547881662845612,
-0.42638885974884033,
0.170416921377182,
-0.008022760972380638,
0.11086840182542801,
0.05835450813174248,
0.475180983543396,
-0.5759590268135071,
0.2797792851924896,
0.5296016335487366,
-0.09303849190473557,
0.40020644664764404,
-0.2282784879207611,
0.02215409278869629,
-1.097058653831482,
-0.20395295321941376,
0.3125436007976532,
-0.1950329691171646,
-0.4905601441860199,
-0.020544910803437233,
0.05203932523727417,
0.08972466737031937,
-0.22185376286506653,
0.5781099796295166,
-0.7480787038803101,
-0.034074243158102036,
-0.17218662798404694,
0.21498146653175354,
-0.2149137705564499,
-0.015603111125528812,
0.085439033806324,
0.7926284074783325,
0.4398764967918396,
-0.7349820733070374,
0.10497740656137466,
0.09194810688495636,
-0.3680232763290405,
0.6991045475006104,
-0.7280173897743225,
0.11926118284463882,
-0.06371491402387619,
-0.04060175642371178,
-0.44239333271980286,
-0.5608325600624084,
0.08441908657550812,
-0.3510577380657196,
0.6071904897689819,
-0.18098171055316925,
-0.5217208862304688,
-0.15824998915195465,
0.13410906493663788,
0.3825879693031311,
0.14618238806724548,
-0.3927941620349884,
0.678595781326294,
0.4201264977455139,
-0.21675823628902435,
-0.40263670682907104,
-0.4304904639720917,
0.19702915847301483,
-0.26331236958503723,
-0.3845731317996979,
0.44919395446777344,
0.1005537137389183,
-0.18351149559020996,
0.1376626342535019,
-0.5610874891281128,
-0.45482853055000305,
-0.0667712464928627,
0.4029224216938019,
0.12554006278514862,
-0.21547064185142517,
0.1815536916255951,
-0.10941315442323685,
-0.1622554510831833,
-0.016472911462187767,
-0.20354679226875305,
0.22772720456123352,
-0.26554763317108154,
-0.3683743476867676,
-0.2629588842391968,
-0.017988234758377075,
0.21086494624614716,
-0.25143879652023315,
0.6705037355422974,
0.7553289532661438,
-0.5918261408805847,
-0.14987929165363312,
-0.7406121492385864,
-0.28771352767944336,
-0.45151057839393616,
0.2808847725391388,
-0.6307721734046936,
-1.3442456722259521,
0.4182719588279724,
-0.16859771311283112,
-0.5647026300430298,
0.251037061214447,
0.3430074155330658,
-0.13515324890613556,
0.5121253132820129,
0.7813224196434021,
-0.2711682915687561,
0.4082461893558502,
0.12709654867649078,
0.5546182990074158,
-0.7458299994468689,
-0.0200392734259367,
-0.61258864402771,
-0.28707870841026306,
-0.743259072303772,
-0.731369137763977,
0.07742337882518768,
0.20621387660503387,
-0.3407287001609802,
0.636605978012085,
-0.27110394835472107,
0.5289943814277649,
0.5784056186676025,
0.17588499188423157,
0.4508592188358307,
0.10794389247894287,
-0.046684425324201584,
-0.1751583367586136,
-0.5153149962425232,
-0.4747963547706604,
1.0350202322006226,
0.18542024493217468,
1.0506778955459595,
0.28253796696662903,
0.7922722101211548,
-0.041408948600292206,
0.0000514030471094884,
-0.5198595523834229,
0.4104097783565521,
0.14479725062847137,
-0.717694878578186,
-0.4587247669696808,
-0.6293919086456299,
-0.9208147525787354,
-0.11970158666372299,
-0.4545232653617859,
-1.001521110534668,
0.41147860884666443,
0.03499111905694008,
-0.3834572732448578,
0.49693402647972107,
-0.26359522342681885,
0.6525867581367493,
-0.13040821254253387,
-0.5169875621795654,
0.010092669166624546,
-0.7739289402961731,
0.07688447088003159,
-0.33322685956954956,
0.21783946454524994,
-0.20208494365215302,
-0.11804937571287155,
0.4407219886779785,
-0.04212505742907524,
0.7637443542480469,
0.3486812114715576,
-0.049420908093452454,
0.09819139540195465,
0.31741344928741455,
0.9870918393135071,
0.23502357304096222,
-0.1715119481086731,
0.4602092206478119,
-0.23725654184818268,
-0.03391114994883537,
-0.5921162366867065,
0.8766424655914307,
-0.6102991104125977,
-0.3222290575504303,
-0.4623038172721863,
-0.5599814057350159,
-0.19375072419643402,
0.4457482099533081,
0.34360983967781067,
0.1652025431394577,
-0.19745701551437378,
0.23822326958179474,
0.8556336760520935,
0.023620128631591797,
0.26114243268966675,
0.37028273940086365,
0.23385939002037048,
-0.4813825786113739,
0.8810594081878662,
-0.02201981097459793,
0.28372588753700256,
0.9197002053260803,
-0.12230552732944489,
-0.23649567365646362,
-0.7895057201385498,
0.08099839836359024,
0.1723746657371521,
-0.5579797625541687,
-0.438689261674881,
-0.6476947069168091,
-0.11737851798534393,
-0.20872104167938232,
-0.07211662828922272,
-0.3947594463825226,
-0.2452537566423416,
-0.45925772190093994,
-0.11172671616077423,
0.5233080983161926,
0.7050573825836182,
-0.019800521433353424,
0.2726157307624817,
-0.43094319105148315,
0.4343423545360565,
0.2751622796058655,
0.6546697616577148,
-0.272840291261673,
-0.2822439670562744,
-0.2226460576057434,
0.04801682010293007,
0.20713430643081665,
-0.7627416253089905,
0.23432451486587524,
0.22207698225975037,
0.1787799596786499,
0.5102102160453796,
0.3458145260810852,
0.8926941156387329,
-0.6021732687950134,
0.2417566329240799,
0.1345767080783844,
-0.8303200602531433,
0.5353469848632812,
-0.5014123916625977,
-0.0024308753199875355,
0.8347851634025574,
0.6797388195991516,
-0.20709426701068878,
-0.3077850043773651,
-0.4909973740577698,
-1.0160988569259644,
0.39672723412513733,
0.34570038318634033,
-0.023097475990653038,
-0.14127087593078613,
0.3307705819606781,
-0.1318567991256714,
0.21877647936344147,
-0.8184823989868164,
-0.12880505621433258,
0.2593500018119812,
-0.16420648992061615,
-0.0621495321393013,
-0.35606664419174194,
0.05246914178133011,
-0.09385398030281067,
0.7486047148704529,
-0.17708855867385864,
0.2351764738559723,
0.0957956612110138,
-0.2590380609035492,
-0.28358006477355957,
0.4647943079471588,
0.11082950234413147,
0.5893287062644958,
-0.3508061170578003,
0.27996426820755005,
0.33612364530563354,
-0.3051767945289612,
0.09893789887428284,
0.3371666371822357,
-0.35292160511016846,
0.0793834924697876,
0.24623331427574158,
0.806958019733429,
0.693813681602478,
-0.32584184408187866,
0.27994388341903687,
-0.17160670459270477,
0.09107061475515366,
-0.2474510669708252,
-0.05128300562500954,
0.21578551828861237,
0.33630552887916565,
0.14452984929084778,
0.09553451836109161,
0.05207359418272972,
-0.030672816559672356,
0.3322261571884155,
0.5055067539215088,
-0.6997137665748596,
-0.27331510186195374,
0.8186762928962708,
-0.08093705028295517,
-0.21618106961250305,
0.4662984609603882,
-0.422839492559433,
-0.24021925032138824,
0.3267011344432831,
0.6985764503479004,
0.779029369354248,
-0.19600333273410797,
0.04448336362838745,
0.527104377746582,
0.4265434145927429,
-0.2788480818271637,
0.11594178527593613,
0.03606763482093811,
-0.788255512714386,
-0.37411224842071533,
-0.7763583064079285,
-0.5019713044166565,
0.09638726711273193,
-0.7040842175483704,
0.36723464727401733,
-0.42744776606559753,
-0.4051591753959656,
0.07676991075277328,
0.01734856702387333,
-0.9110221266746521,
0.23681068420410156,
-0.023023370653390884,
0.5863593816757202,
-0.5592348575592041,
0.8417097926139832,
0.7425718903541565,
-0.602977991104126,
-1.057307243347168,
0.20516373217105865,
0.09517823159694672,
-0.2671900689601898,
0.7674524784088135,
0.002436860930174589,
-0.20405153930187225,
0.23304133117198944,
-0.1843539923429489,
-1.3249666690826416,
1.085350513458252,
0.3799035847187042,
-0.7489274740219116,
-0.2744833827018738,
0.09152940660715103,
0.382307231426239,
-0.2020246386528015,
0.4051071107387543,
0.21346530318260193,
0.4587042033672333,
0.22426724433898926,
-0.8905653953552246,
0.3800896406173706,
0.05895664170384407,
0.2723943591117859,
0.4041171073913574,
-0.39171722531318665,
0.8366442322731018,
-0.4787375330924988,
-0.27641090750694275,
-0.03446587547659874,
0.7931050062179565,
0.09833870083093643,
0.045649342238903046,
0.3153120279312134,
0.5658112168312073,
0.9832926988601685,
-0.1298501044511795,
0.8344600200653076,
-0.2883859872817993,
0.47397974133491516,
1.5362130403518677,
-0.42699506878852844,
1.218808889389038,
0.4877048432826996,
-0.3516073524951935,
0.46182605624198914,
0.6093694567680359,
-0.2127692848443985,
0.41381481289863586,
0.20578044652938843,
-0.44067901372909546,
-0.40741443634033203,
-0.11875887215137482,
-0.24289706349372864,
0.40546178817749023,
0.2158142328262329,
-0.17075912654399872,
-0.2591157853603363,
-0.3682873547077179,
0.002200811170041561,
-0.08790647238492966,
-0.2096715271472931,
0.7240608334541321,
0.21605880558490753,
-0.1906214952468872,
0.3093664050102234,
-0.06450767815113068,
0.8244566917419434,
-0.5166986584663391,
0.05991606041789055,
-0.0036404924467206,
0.11399170011281967,
-0.1256975680589676,
-0.29798027873039246,
0.18030598759651184,
-0.0311699528247118,
-0.30611851811408997,
0.15989960730075836,
0.9588107466697693,
-0.40170079469680786,
-0.6123480796813965,
0.3615444600582123,
0.46072742342948914,
0.12268960475921631,
-0.35492822527885437,
-0.45706623792648315,
0.033275503665208817,
-0.2012740969657898,
-0.10308697074651718,
0.5321510434150696,
0.7825977802276611,
-0.021116996183991432,
0.9357161521911621,
0.7662485241889954,
0.3463640511035919,
-0.17142271995544434,
-0.020270511507987976,
0.6212025880813599,
-0.6897328495979309,
-0.19814372062683105,
-0.792912483215332,
0.16110868752002716,
0.014200742356479168,
-0.08712904900312424,
0.8158632516860962,
0.47814157605171204,
1.1327524185180664,
0.11179197579622269,
0.5557478070259094,
-0.1660814881324768,
0.26345449686050415,
-0.3309806287288666,
0.7891940474510193,
-0.4502021074295044,
0.22228431701660156,
-0.5153852701187134,
-0.907193124294281,
-0.5307241678237915,
0.7558625936508179,
-0.48626649379730225,
0.09491206705570221,
0.7208160161972046,
0.8351701498031616,
-0.22801473736763,
-0.09368637204170227,
0.3945021331310272,
0.17552435398101807,
0.04096217453479767,
0.4874557554721832,
0.4951912462711334,
-0.5856444835662842,
0.6552222967147827,
-0.3029758930206299,
0.21548312902450562,
-0.14773058891296387,
-1.0464787483215332,
-0.9566013813018799,
-0.5020530819892883,
-0.505646288394928,
-0.2929728329181671,
0.3087995648384094,
0.874049961566925,
0.7184138894081116,
-0.9566773772239685,
0.04919952154159546,
-0.28206056356430054,
0.3323235511779785,
-0.09502356499433517,
-0.17144905030727386,
0.31117886304855347,
-0.18160411715507507,
-0.7169203758239746,
0.2458314299583435,
0.18433645367622375,
0.06622868776321411,
0.1508263796567917,
-0.11021563410758972,
-0.27503472566604614,
-0.27727335691452026,
0.21617981791496277,
0.23052218556404114,
-0.9893758296966553,
-0.4157131612300873,
-0.14262081682682037,
-0.06677788496017456,
-0.07689607888460159,
0.3723185956478119,
-0.6441393494606018,
0.3394540548324585,
0.25453001260757446,
0.8400256633758545,
0.46069106459617615,
-0.0690152496099472,
0.6626062989234924,
-0.5730137825012207,
-0.28018659353256226,
0.23175694048404694,
0.48444196581840515,
0.4459388256072998,
-0.4705904424190521,
0.5100106000900269,
-0.05667254701256752,
-0.5924813747406006,
-0.6277258992195129,
0.25961700081825256,
-0.7897179126739502,
-0.05557217821478844,
1.2219929695129395,
-0.059909287840127945,
-0.0519171804189682,
-0.2233676165342331,
0.31692612171173096,
0.3909855782985687,
-0.4827231764793396,
0.6339108347892761,
0.5504045486450195,
0.07624422013759613,
-0.22309766709804535,
-0.7319886088371277,
0.49636316299438477,
0.003422495210543275,
-0.7286126613616943,
-0.15350276231765747,
0.5234912037849426,
0.6277682185173035,
0.09891045093536377,
0.4341505765914917,
0.19317424297332764,
-0.11952777951955795,
-0.013291468843817711,
0.20790249109268188,
0.01166012417525053,
-0.39459049701690674,
-0.3122180998325348,
0.11518271267414093,
0.196559876203537,
0.14423412084579468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10571v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10571v2 | Direct Preference Optimization with an Offset | 2024-02-16T10:55:38 | 2024-06-06T12:02:37 | Afra Amini, Tim Vieira, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Direct preference optimization (DPO) is a successful fine-tuning strategy for
aligning large language models with human preferences without the need to train
a reward model or employ reinforcement learning. DPO, as originally formulated,
relies on binary preference data and fine-tunes a language model to increase
the likelihood of a preferred response over a dispreferred response. However,
not all preference pairs are equal. Sometimes, the preferred response is only
slightly better than the dispreferred one. In other cases, the preference is
much stronger. For instance, if a response contains harmful or toxic content,
the annotator will have a strong preference for that response. In this paper,
we propose a generalization of DPO, termed DPO with an offset (ODPO), that does
not treat every preference pair equally during fine-tuning. Intuitively, ODPO
requires the difference between the likelihood of the preferred and
dispreferred response to be greater than an offset value. The offset is
determined based on the extent to which one response is preferred over another.
Our experiments on various tasks suggest that ODPO significantly outperforms
DPO in aligning language models, especially when the number of preference pairs
is limited. | [
-0.5153157114982605,
-0.5293995141983032,
0.44561266899108887,
0.27934837341308594,
-0.32877421379089355,
-0.03227526694536209,
-0.21522033214569092,
-0.4002837538719177,
0.16030184924602509,
0.4106459617614746,
-0.6093430519104004,
-0.14071902632713318,
-0.7237467765808105,
0.2806701958179474,
0.4578411877155304,
0.5948583483695984,
0.01739342324435711,
-0.09389752149581909,
0.062124766409397125,
-0.05083555355668068,
-0.6815849542617798,
-0.22661101818084717,
-0.6058347225189209,
-0.40869808197021484,
0.48624274134635925,
0.7234926223754883,
0.8969002962112427,
1.190503716468811,
0.4414382576942444,
0.2817801237106323,
-0.11923260986804962,
0.28257644176483154,
-0.5566020011901855,
0.033329080790281296,
-0.13746242225170135,
-0.28162235021591187,
-0.5343960523605347,
-0.06535953283309937,
0.3968859910964966,
0.9810023307800293,
-0.018631039187312126,
-0.3230297267436981,
-0.09563197940587997,
1.103730320930481,
-1.0922741889953613,
-0.32528743147850037,
-0.6759857535362244,
-0.010936214588582516,
0.16048485040664673,
-0.09180823713541031,
-0.15238139033317566,
-0.5836760997772217,
0.2971768379211426,
-0.8019534945487976,
-0.27432817220687866,
0.008208630606532097,
0.6455344557762146,
0.5401180982589722,
-0.45667269825935364,
-0.18157939612865448,
-0.8217180371284485,
1.0391802787780762,
-0.4852311313152313,
0.04693487659096718,
0.3598625957965851,
0.10189899802207947,
-0.36015525460243225,
0.019897950813174248,
-0.7196808457374573,
0.03496222198009491,
-0.029687980189919472,
0.006812329404056072,
-0.017354760318994522,
0.231512650847435,
0.018078146502375603,
0.3484790325164795,
-0.25421714782714844,
0.6096551418304443,
0.13440938293933868,
0.16120180487632751,
0.6083166003227234,
-0.005248145200312138,
0.06022801995277405,
-0.0844251960515976,
-0.7269880175590515,
-0.12903659045696259,
-0.5498113036155701,
0.28624293208122253,
0.7697356343269348,
0.23490434885025024,
0.3370206952095032,
0.34668466448783875,
-0.3992810547351837,
1.000099778175354,
0.7066167593002319,
-0.1027248278260231,
0.11371908336877823,
0.009471901692450047,
-0.1375247687101364,
0.3117966651916504,
0.8544038534164429,
0.6673149466514587,
0.259255975484848,
-0.053861215710639954,
-0.18044613301753998,
0.12314401566982269,
0.2367541790008545,
-0.703008234500885,
0.21335771679878235,
0.32394248247146606,
-0.0819835439324379,
-0.528167724609375,
-0.06507012248039246,
-0.9474998116493225,
-0.2755429744720459,
-0.44090965390205383,
0.19425147771835327,
-0.3566801846027374,
-0.20477820932865143,
0.5422394275665283,
-0.12631474435329437,
-0.10146275907754898,
0.1380118876695633,
-1.479637622833252,
0.3755466938018799,
1.0631730556488037,
0.6665067672729492,
-0.4539581537246704,
-0.17771025002002716,
-0.6157550811767578,
0.13551144301891327,
-0.3675333857536316,
0.6912915706634521,
-0.9318683743476868,
-0.572457492351532,
-0.020154885947704315,
-0.20001816749572754,
0.11433570086956024,
-0.4373159408569336,
1.0640783309936523,
-0.5852953195571899,
0.20722484588623047,
-0.4365578889846802,
-0.5874438285827637,
0.16857856512069702,
-0.027573777362704277,
-0.5773255228996277,
0.9859933853149414,
-0.1357390433549881,
-0.8472844362258911,
0.6387673020362854,
-0.4044102132320404,
-0.23672521114349365,
-0.2286238968372345,
-0.2241581231355667,
-0.27640199661254883,
0.23438800871372223,
0.15856918692588806,
0.07039094716310501,
-0.0798402950167656,
0.2684592604637146,
-0.5835615992546082,
-0.5312729477882385,
0.10012282431125641,
0.05214862897992134,
0.6075543761253357,
0.1973303258419037,
-0.4253401458263397,
0.18240338563919067,
-0.8775275349617004,
-0.17468804121017456,
0.15695567429065704,
-0.3348207473754883,
-1.0726983547210693,
0.3670080006122589,
-0.5799635052680969,
0.12297871708869934,
0.26563024520874023,
-0.8195362687110901,
0.6458038091659546,
-0.5894415974617004,
0.37763383984565735,
1.2138720750808716,
-0.18126173317432404,
0.8346818089485168,
-0.2797180414199829,
0.2307555228471756,
-0.2226390540599823,
0.18903212249279022,
0.38328465819358826,
-0.18971210718154907,
-0.5554381608963013,
-0.32614314556121826,
0.07124704122543335,
0.37920817732810974,
-0.3792145848274231,
1.1468549966812134,
-0.3704782724380493,
-0.1483229547739029,
-0.3503933250904083,
0.038371000438928604,
0.37376412749290466,
0.8837984800338745,
0.15912580490112305,
-0.26646825671195984,
-0.3772856891155243,
-1.0796778202056885,
-0.027574962005019188,
-0.057403385639190674,
0.06696709990501404,
0.39505690336227417,
0.007766544818878174,
0.1447821855545044,
1.0758663415908813,
-0.9983513355255127,
-0.1340792030096054,
0.1069640964269638,
-0.15988382697105408,
0.26576995849609375,
0.5116519331932068,
0.6304500102996826,
-0.98477703332901,
-0.7085037231445312,
0.02172970585525036,
-0.18316581845283508,
-0.1882646083831787,
0.2065119445323944,
-0.6746580004692078,
0.13983559608459473,
-0.0996294692158699,
-0.23453514277935028,
-0.08887677639722824,
0.6145000457763672,
-0.15777716040611267,
0.23321615159511566,
-0.2089054435491562,
0.06728557497262955,
-0.8354132771492004,
0.25274017453193665,
-0.21106292307376862,
0.15792527794837952,
-0.6857113838195801,
-0.2041158378124237,
0.1595388650894165,
-0.030631348490715027,
-0.2612270414829254,
0.7317410111427307,
-0.31182393431663513,
0.2449624240398407,
-0.49720999598503113,
0.02116304822266102,
0.11693970113992691,
0.5166054368019104,
0.4281798303127289,
0.6076523065567017,
0.4927900433540344,
-0.777883768081665,
0.26620346307754517,
0.33995044231414795,
-0.048863109201192856,
0.6391417980194092,
-0.6814684271812439,
0.6331888437271118,
-0.17781801521778107,
0.00449217576533556,
-1.221386194229126,
-0.10355837643146515,
0.30128589272499084,
-0.0812937542796135,
0.48477041721343994,
-0.22426271438598633,
-0.07567092031240463,
-0.38725852966308594,
-0.5803734660148621,
0.5013704895973206,
0.3657386600971222,
-0.5985148549079895,
0.01105646975338459,
0.3293660581111908,
-0.07422856241464615,
-1.1707926988601685,
-0.0834730714559555,
-0.5166991949081421,
-0.30497369170188904,
-0.42164087295532227,
0.6189754009246826,
-0.05001353099942207,
-0.25500932335853577,
-0.20353877544403076,
-0.4410681426525116,
0.03808482363820076,
0.07806918770074844,
0.16170500218868256,
0.2698238492012024,
0.18455004692077637,
0.2510109543800354,
0.2282847911119461,
-0.3496164083480835,
-0.37568196654319763,
-0.27334925532341003,
0.7360477447509766,
0.29276618361473083,
-0.13010179996490479,
-0.10239503532648087,
0.466285765171051,
0.336042582988739,
-0.18547144532203674,
0.3605818748474121,
-0.024039587005972862,
-0.13704383373260498,
0.002354951575398445,
-0.45943331718444824,
-0.10382096469402313,
-0.5454828143119812,
0.1650628298521042,
-0.4703156054019928,
-0.4737261235713959,
0.16786639392375946,
0.07518523931503296,
0.10580376535654068,
0.2853569984436035,
0.23610630631446838,
0.1774955838918686,
1.0814626216888428,
0.7633731961250305,
-0.3641887903213501,
0.8345863223075867,
0.21841447055339813,
-0.15871742367744446,
-0.7581215500831604,
0.23829708993434906,
-0.6746587753295898,
-0.736344575881958,
-0.68759685754776,
-0.010270192287862301,
0.03290018066763878,
0.18064287304878235,
-0.448538601398468,
0.21542897820472717,
-0.8958930969238281,
0.4979918897151947,
0.8124228715896606,
0.2746013104915619,
0.46770790219306946,
0.06572167575359344,
-0.15479132533073425,
-0.14607486128807068,
-0.4231986403465271,
-0.4764837324619293,
0.9646754264831543,
0.18968698382377625,
0.6665802001953125,
-0.05354183539748192,
0.7902923822402954,
0.09445959329605103,
-0.0840054452419281,
-0.8753580451011658,
0.2839595675468445,
-0.4630265533924103,
-0.6810879707336426,
-0.529956042766571,
-0.36208173632621765,
-0.9631584286689758,
0.15764576196670532,
0.05328288674354553,
-0.7461963295936584,
0.7935873866081238,
0.326236754655838,
-0.42542803287506104,
0.15424321591854095,
-0.7217267751693726,
0.7824645042419434,
-0.5277913808822632,
-0.6636815071105957,
-0.020941050723195076,
-0.6785564422607422,
0.05433998629450798,
0.083378866314888,
0.06826909631490707,
-0.5270777940750122,
-0.41099560260772705,
0.34627413749694824,
-0.16948118805885315,
0.731826901435852,
-0.3286258280277252,
-0.0965699777007103,
-0.15969917178153992,
0.07222320139408112,
0.669775664806366,
-0.05471547320485115,
-0.5375216603279114,
-0.13390429317951202,
-0.2140299677848816,
-0.5391092300415039,
-0.47737306356430054,
0.9570571780204773,
-0.9488803744316101,
-0.7642613053321838,
-0.4101420044898987,
-0.3428247272968292,
-0.4363272488117218,
0.42144107818603516,
0.18340373039245605,
-0.12388195842504501,
-0.2894992530345917,
-0.30953940749168396,
0.44151124358177185,
-0.27689215540885925,
0.44635969400405884,
0.5712769031524658,
0.062103353440761566,
-0.5577986240386963,
0.5439628958702087,
-0.2447713166475296,
0.7012231945991516,
0.8430228233337402,
0.6161900162696838,
-0.2230074405670166,
-0.3942611515522003,
-0.5684147477149963,
0.1213311031460762,
-0.3954976201057434,
-0.034277915954589844,
-0.3866844177246094,
0.4738200604915619,
-0.3380483090877533,
-0.3783084452152252,
-0.513918399810791,
-0.4167816936969757,
-0.04938158020377159,
-0.004776217509061098,
0.29160982370376587,
0.24075879156589508,
-0.10730142891407013,
0.16700415313243866,
-0.32785332202911377,
0.4150254428386688,
0.4915028512477875,
0.7251042723655701,
-0.25445568561553955,
-0.31170913577079773,
0.3075510859489441,
0.315768301486969,
-0.517275869846344,
-0.796242356300354,
0.275166779756546,
0.18246546387672424,
0.6534991264343262,
0.6832612156867981,
0.5230587720870972,
0.6484443545341492,
-0.5423547625541687,
0.26038116216659546,
0.24285627901554108,
-0.8592742085456848,
0.728234589099884,
-0.42915835976600647,
0.1036650687456131,
0.8782588243484497,
0.8590457439422607,
-0.5476080775260925,
0.06965047866106033,
-0.2609294056892395,
-0.8442668914794922,
0.7631915807723999,
0.009576194919645786,
0.32523617148399353,
-0.08900322765111923,
0.5740108489990234,
0.4879020154476166,
0.2964794337749481,
-0.3975038528442383,
-0.4015670120716095,
-0.10724015533924103,
0.08606335520744324,
-0.10482914000749588,
-0.43013861775398254,
-0.3978780508041382,
-0.016799377277493477,
0.46424558758735657,
-0.17880398035049438,
0.22502748668193817,
0.17937138676643372,
0.29677075147628784,
-0.5129916667938232,
0.2720966339111328,
0.7156534790992737,
0.5617643594741821,
-0.7673385739326477,
0.008920724503695965,
-0.32024818658828735,
-0.4530002474784851,
0.37180450558662415,
0.25587546825408936,
-0.32924753427505493,
-0.26644134521484375,
-0.12809540331363678,
0.9402317404747009,
0.07896044850349426,
-0.42281168699264526,
0.4125842750072479,
0.05802811682224274,
0.015312687493860722,
0.1873479187488556,
0.09057644009590149,
-0.24618668854236603,
-0.17939746379852295,
0.3401297926902771,
-0.027042288333177567,
0.267342209815979,
-0.5520050525665283,
0.02962832897901535,
0.49702689051628113,
-0.5415180325508118,
-0.1907288283109665,
0.5065843462944031,
0.5496532320976257,
-0.3160477876663208,
0.26262611150741577,
-0.008888736367225647,
-0.35150009393692017,
0.6259164810180664,
0.4558672606945038,
0.7710450291633606,
-0.2907838225364685,
-0.01911771111190319,
0.45897161960601807,
-0.10211870819330215,
-0.00909356027841568,
0.0023986867163330317,
-0.14689026772975922,
-1.0864273309707642,
-0.45066457986831665,
-0.6348264813423157,
-0.5313562750816345,
-0.09239540249109268,
-0.8793403506278992,
0.49157291650772095,
-0.480160117149353,
-0.16214509308338165,
0.3157716691493988,
0.06737308949232101,
-0.4805105924606323,
0.10449955612421036,
-0.0384889617562294,
0.6273960471153259,
-0.7364283800125122,
0.8299633860588074,
0.8113489151000977,
-0.12642523646354675,
-0.44714829325675964,
0.15760347247123718,
-0.13188664615154266,
-1.236879825592041,
0.7070056200027466,
0.08907688409090042,
-0.05762511119246483,
-0.006149818189442158,
-0.08211830258369446,
-0.891097903251648,
0.7051628828048706,
0.5298358201980591,
-0.8270268440246582,
-0.0062990374863147736,
0.06926614046096802,
0.4224204123020172,
-0.23631422221660614,
0.1307380050420761,
0.660473644733429,
0.35340332984924316,
0.29807424545288086,
-1.0726826190948486,
0.19374899566173553,
0.06421453505754471,
0.07371930032968521,
0.5632825493812561,
-0.861043393611908,
0.5135019421577454,
-0.11010684072971344,
-0.10651935636997223,
-0.044892873615026474,
0.03559653088450432,
0.16296659409999847,
0.002547199372202158,
0.8134651780128479,
0.5224508047103882,
0.45482712984085083,
-0.13267460465431213,
1.1422275304794312,
-0.27426448464393616,
0.24580518901348114,
1.1979408264160156,
-0.4529081881046295,
0.8146257996559143,
0.8161258697509766,
-0.28138136863708496,
0.05909425765275955,
0.7795935273170471,
0.3607887625694275,
1.0075827836990356,
0.17496086657047272,
-0.14412271976470947,
-0.1651625633239746,
-0.16253423690795898,
-0.42257246375083923,
0.5182138681411743,
-0.01199520006775856,
-0.3403036594390869,
0.05063266307115555,
-0.22616584599018097,
-0.01779671013355255,
0.37462544441223145,
-0.19960002601146698,
0.9829798340797424,
-0.20952416956424713,
-1.1751030683517456,
0.7648116946220398,
-0.24874147772789001,
0.8181759715080261,
-0.5566401481628418,
0.15584571659564972,
-0.5037335157394409,
0.4827473759651184,
-0.1196569874882698,
-0.7654867172241211,
0.2530195415019989,
-0.332283079624176,
-0.22471140325069427,
-0.3130291998386383,
0.512019693851471,
-0.20858493447303772,
-0.3049874007701874,
0.45060423016548157,
-0.07189740240573883,
-0.44051605463027954,
-0.18237124383449554,
-0.4000493586063385,
0.07628321647644043,
0.04194300249218941,
-0.27208736538887024,
0.40236279368400574,
0.5081962943077087,
0.19078688323497772,
0.4828520119190216,
0.5574796795845032,
0.21951083838939667,
-0.18636269867420197,
-0.1798919141292572,
0.9342028498649597,
-0.3030707538127899,
-0.6029183864593506,
-1.1097078323364258,
0.4114479720592499,
-0.2085610181093216,
-0.4813637435436249,
0.5220098495483398,
0.556588888168335,
0.6881917119026184,
-0.08269047737121582,
0.630321741104126,
-0.10299164801836014,
0.4698004722595215,
-0.33647310733795166,
0.053274936974048615,
-0.5777818560600281,
0.18549489974975586,
-0.5951681137084961,
-1.0556607246398926,
-0.303548663854599,
0.7127846479415894,
-0.7636013031005859,
-0.27976199984550476,
0.3531222939491272,
0.5702155828475952,
0.0052886041812598705,
-0.2502712607383728,
0.25589850544929504,
-0.19676272571086884,
0.20912115275859833,
0.6904932856559753,
0.6266463398933411,
-0.0051878285594284534,
0.45723581314086914,
-0.7125442624092102,
-0.5560238361358643,
-0.3214598000049591,
-1.2007501125335693,
-0.5169528722763062,
-0.20583364367485046,
-0.10929641127586365,
-0.042512789368629456,
0.16635729372501373,
0.9209578633308411,
0.7243577837944031,
-0.6989007592201233,
-0.1629224717617035,
-0.3204149007797241,
0.3332644999027252,
-0.430278480052948,
-0.15407994389533997,
0.2440844178199768,
-0.2752985954284668,
-1.345451831817627,
-0.0057412972673773766,
0.3239924907684326,
0.07812675833702087,
0.05424991250038147,
-0.09754963219165802,
-0.2490241378545761,
-0.015843698754906654,
0.2499019056558609,
0.39700847864151,
-0.6234601736068726,
-0.5356701612472534,
0.26343879103660583,
-0.12272252142429352,
0.41112667322158813,
0.7068695425987244,
-0.3238146901130676,
0.90630704164505,
0.4742739796638489,
0.4513523280620575,
0.4059600234031677,
0.27760979533195496,
1.0082262754440308,
-0.9344555735588074,
0.5310052037239075,
0.29529881477355957,
0.15372183918952942,
0.10155344754457474,
-0.5845065712928772,
0.36192357540130615,
0.10689418762922287,
-0.6314708590507507,
-0.6248129606246948,
0.49494218826293945,
-1.2218830585479736,
-0.2507219910621643,
1.3883670568466187,
0.03334985300898552,
0.059531453996896744,
0.2039247453212738,
-0.48852723836898804,
0.12217658013105392,
-0.851395845413208,
1.051939606666565,
0.5946424603462219,
-0.3017849922180176,
0.2692823112010956,
-0.19670966267585754,
0.6121611595153809,
0.6256624460220337,
-0.43631356954574585,
0.04908030107617378,
0.45269110798835754,
0.38454967737197876,
0.2401096671819687,
0.5896008610725403,
0.2032255381345749,
-0.0011332165449857712,
-0.10614214092493057,
0.1189296618103981,
-0.1339138299226761,
0.10232015699148178,
-0.36717766523361206,
0.01754811406135559,
0.3118865191936493,
-0.8031879663467407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10567v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10567v4 | InSaAF: Incorporating Safety through Accuracy and Fairness | Are LLMs ready for the Indian Legal Domain? | 2024-02-16T10:54:10 | 2024-06-17T17:46:07 | Yogesh Tripathi, Raghav Donakanti, Sahil Girhepuje, Ishan Kavathekar, Bhaskara Hanuma Vedula, Gokul S Krishnan, Shreya Goyal, Anmol Goel, Balaraman Ravindran, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in language technology and Artificial Intelligence have
resulted in numerous Language Models being proposed to perform various tasks in
the legal domain ranging from predicting judgments to generating summaries.
Despite their immense potential, these models have been proven to learn and
exhibit societal biases and make unfair predictions. In this study, we explore
the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform legal tasks in the
Indian landscape when social factors are involved. We present a novel metric,
$\beta$-weighted $\textit{Legal Safety Score ($LSS_{\beta}$)}$, which
encapsulates both the fairness and accuracy aspects of the LLM. We assess LLMs'
safety by considering its performance in the $\textit{Binary Statutory
Reasoning}$ task and its fairness exhibition with respect to various axes of
disparities in the Indian society. Task performance and fairness scores of
LLaMA and LLaMA--2 models indicate that the proposed $LSS_{\beta}$ metric can
effectively determine the readiness of a model for safe usage in the legal
sector. We also propose finetuning pipelines, utilising specialised legal
datasets, as a potential method to mitigate bias and improve model safety. The
finetuning procedures on LLaMA and LLaMA--2 models increase the $LSS_{\beta}$,
improving their usability in the Indian legal domain. Our code is publicly
released. | [
0.08105476200580597,
-0.5355042815208435,
0.4876440465450287,
0.3218128979206085,
-0.49505239725112915,
0.11421661078929901,
-0.0601874440908432,
-0.5631276369094849,
-0.19155269861221313,
0.3995359539985657,
0.08665762096643448,
-0.5613676309585571,
-0.7541062235832214,
-0.02561958320438862,
-0.7532317042350769,
0.8721128106117249,
0.18202458322048187,
0.2017948031425476,
-0.3353663980960846,
-0.33325833082199097,
-0.6141029000282288,
-0.7487532496452332,
-0.4740765392780304,
-0.3476831316947937,
0.06212267279624939,
0.11051362007856369,
0.7812619209289551,
0.7645936012268066,
0.5594948530197144,
0.2734907269477844,
-0.18761484324932098,
-0.2089412808418274,
-0.19888605177402496,
0.23300234973430634,
-0.30096885561943054,
-0.7237909436225891,
-0.4376288652420044,
-0.01765885204076767,
0.7145989537239075,
0.4558297395706177,
-0.6227155327796936,
0.1747579127550125,
0.038096390664577484,
0.5158618688583374,
-0.6978120803833008,
0.3109531104564667,
-0.7115404605865479,
-0.08120870590209961,
-0.37501102685928345,
0.050656482577323914,
-0.2692145109176636,
-0.5827022790908813,
-0.355548620223999,
-0.2457669973373413,
-0.2374207228422165,
0.3763507604598999,
0.837300717830658,
0.685344398021698,
-0.558840811252594,
-0.41233739256858826,
-0.460772842168808,
0.6650063395500183,
-0.9102292656898499,
0.22327858209609985,
0.46011361479759216,
0.6120983362197876,
-0.16145092248916626,
-0.5944694876670837,
-0.5001394152641296,
-0.2619435787200928,
0.08570206165313721,
-0.14066381752490997,
0.04494389146566391,
0.03473373129963875,
0.29041481018066406,
0.1056155115365982,
0.004857468418776989,
0.4276443421840668,
-0.4060676693916321,
-0.29738134145736694,
0.9773995280265808,
0.3267183005809784,
0.29207950830459595,
-0.2527366578578949,
-0.022905927151441574,
0.11439088732004166,
-0.8751990795135498,
0.21284113824367523,
0.5638774037361145,
0.46729522943496704,
-0.4713677763938904,
0.6361995935440063,
-0.18102949857711792,
0.35333117842674255,
-0.024285629391670227,
-0.4312645196914673,
0.2133479118347168,
-0.05909018963575363,
-0.29436352849006653,
0.29299360513687134,
0.6943065524101257,
0.38062116503715515,
0.6417433023452759,
-0.03817174956202507,
-0.49309417605400085,
0.176508828997612,
0.028264086693525314,
-0.7183921337127686,
0.4371755123138428,
0.1441245675086975,
-0.6600298285484314,
-0.45461398363113403,
-0.1744888871908188,
-0.4965168237686157,
-0.6483505368232727,
-0.5089575052261353,
0.2536464333534241,
-0.16117998957633972,
-0.2827877998352051,
0.024120835587382317,
0.29009294509887695,
0.6671485304832458,
0.11740399897098541,
-0.7730496525764465,
0.2496282011270523,
1.004859447479248,
0.6937661170959473,
0.20448246598243713,
0.11389981210231781,
-0.8864725232124329,
0.29896435141563416,
-0.27740588784217834,
0.5879738330841064,
-0.6209432482719421,
-0.5374040007591248,
0.30956345796585083,
-0.275979220867157,
0.29893526434898376,
-0.32335615158081055,
0.6244229078292847,
-0.5613601803779602,
-0.4029186964035034,
-0.30932947993278503,
-0.4254322052001953,
-0.2887493968009949,
0.22479240596294403,
-0.22049762308597565,
0.611701250076294,
-0.2627967596054077,
-0.6980680227279663,
0.8322198987007141,
-0.6959243416786194,
-0.6552864909172058,
0.08996985852718353,
-0.49843841791152954,
-0.2941622734069824,
-0.05001640319824219,
0.06660399585962296,
0.5575860738754272,
-0.38138604164123535,
0.6250033974647522,
-0.6930198073387146,
-0.5689918994903564,
0.2248685657978058,
-0.46927735209465027,
1.0296401977539062,
0.4476207494735718,
-0.24082934856414795,
0.06900057941675186,
-0.6023698449134827,
-0.11208034306764603,
-0.21106784045696259,
-0.40118440985679626,
-0.3409980833530426,
0.0970919132232666,
-0.09517161548137665,
0.4332788288593292,
0.08779889345169067,
-0.6479751467704773,
-0.44954222440719604,
-0.3727993965148926,
0.4559735059738159,
1.0903671979904175,
-0.19476884603500366,
0.5397297739982605,
-0.1843932867050171,
0.512143611907959,
-0.24788334965705872,
0.3720783293247223,
0.38574832677841187,
-0.44180187582969666,
-0.5773935914039612,
-0.3713390827178955,
0.7511069178581238,
0.771792471408844,
-0.23074379563331604,
0.2549505829811096,
-0.39612144231796265,
-0.30895915627479553,
-0.6689717173576355,
0.10092762112617493,
0.4822310209274292,
0.35612741112709045,
-0.2737594544887543,
-0.20914839208126068,
-0.25770696997642517,
-0.8047439455986023,
-0.41148480772972107,
-0.24207067489624023,
0.18232333660125732,
0.06847959756851196,
0.4579082727432251,
-0.11356573551893234,
0.9770624041557312,
-0.021836010739207268,
-0.33405229449272156,
0.09461187571287155,
-0.21067014336585999,
0.18268842995166779,
0.33229273557662964,
0.5520989298820496,
-0.9420561790466309,
-0.4879474639892578,
0.015925375744700432,
-1.2485716342926025,
-0.2120642066001892,
0.2836343050003052,
-0.07682865858078003,
0.37042853236198425,
0.7187231779098511,
-0.5684674382209778,
0.5500739812850952,
0.07265856862068176,
-0.5170855522155762,
0.33711037039756775,
-0.176717609167099,
0.13970766961574554,
-0.883841335773468,
-0.18148748576641083,
0.1353573203086853,
-0.41081419587135315,
-0.3159875273704529,
0.47723710536956787,
0.05665306746959686,
0.007684832438826561,
-0.9369168281555176,
0.7227789759635925,
-0.20397977530956268,
-0.25068017840385437,
-0.30284199118614197,
-0.030067643150687218,
-0.5729175806045532,
0.16249732673168182,
-0.3941732943058014,
0.7571143507957458,
0.8066027760505676,
-0.5733602643013,
-0.0639786422252655,
0.0575619637966156,
-0.19030159711837769,
0.9374701380729675,
-0.6638732552528381,
-0.01562623120844364,
-0.3517613708972931,
-0.0980663001537323,
-0.4248623847961426,
-0.46376755833625793,
0.1921827644109726,
-0.27905458211898804,
0.25247469544410706,
-0.3364403247833252,
-0.755787193775177,
-0.07840325683355331,
-0.09977087378501892,
0.20290814340114594,
0.9220322370529175,
-0.22626742720603943,
0.8925667405128479,
0.9948703646659851,
-0.1008579209446907,
-0.9491800665855408,
-0.9352965354919434,
0.03380243480205536,
-0.5885370969772339,
-0.6815252900123596,
-0.24922089278697968,
0.11229652166366577,
-0.8343178033828735,
0.01263485662639141,
0.010239815339446068,
0.0713878944516182,
0.08167300373315811,
0.8890952467918396,
0.17238502204418182,
0.23367641866207123,
0.0481276698410511,
0.30402296781539917,
-0.13683810830116272,
0.32293346524238586,
0.249730184674263,
0.20505402982234955,
-0.3410179316997528,
-0.5625742673873901,
-0.23796547949314117,
0.3214079737663269,
0.5551976561546326,
-0.2081308513879776,
0.6041857004165649,
0.3310602009296417,
-0.7658592462539673,
0.12337537854909897,
-0.7099067568778992,
0.119283027946949,
-0.5311873555183411,
0.10987787693738937,
-0.13237054646015167,
-0.9943516850471497,
0.5579227209091187,
0.09107725322246552,
0.35253313183784485,
0.4227549731731415,
0.6698391437530518,
-0.09153290092945099,
0.9461519718170166,
0.8737930655479431,
0.06037890911102295,
0.1611558049917221,
0.21515247225761414,
0.4957105219364166,
-0.44458550214767456,
-0.40977343916893005,
-0.6804447174072266,
-0.037368785589933395,
-0.7712187767028809,
-0.21114903688430786,
0.5928956270217896,
-0.05772178992629051,
-0.6482360363006592,
-0.20588144659996033,
-0.24770523607730865,
0.6408281326293945,
0.5427625179290771,
0.03430531173944473,
0.3983490467071533,
0.21792441606521606,
-0.19051791727542877,
0.007793148048222065,
-0.3734075725078583,
-0.9186321496963501,
1.347712516784668,
0.4770814776420593,
0.8100277781486511,
0.0874147117137909,
0.7379247546195984,
0.5896385908126831,
0.6437311172485352,
-0.5263035893440247,
0.7843246459960938,
-0.4874916076660156,
-0.7969894409179688,
-0.1920391321182251,
-0.19318094849586487,
-0.5648483037948608,
0.1312519758939743,
-0.44272473454475403,
-0.46600618958473206,
0.1597154289484024,
0.1250496208667755,
-0.49758583307266235,
0.29186660051345825,
-0.6336643099784851,
0.3046981990337372,
-0.3483963906764984,
-0.396541029214859,
-0.5471869111061096,
-0.7630947232246399,
0.6198896169662476,
-0.30482059717178345,
0.7561036348342896,
-0.5876521468162537,
-0.07523421943187714,
0.6783753633499146,
-0.5584522485733032,
0.8561570644378662,
-0.3798845708370209,
0.08516116440296173,
0.5622893571853638,
0.14501823484897614,
0.33947888016700745,
0.2762787640094757,
-0.5040161609649658,
0.4232528507709503,
-0.012113412842154503,
-0.32491153478622437,
-0.23889696598052979,
0.8158063292503357,
-0.6133288145065308,
-0.6930097341537476,
-0.8123944997787476,
-0.5823436975479126,
-0.17943669855594635,
0.22003485262393951,
-0.26185959577560425,
0.06996528804302216,
0.21610739827156067,
0.05128440260887146,
0.49294358491897583,
0.019622087478637695,
0.7547986507415771,
0.5048031210899353,
-0.029915930703282356,
-0.05320267379283905,
0.5012492537498474,
0.16640321910381317,
-0.02008247748017311,
-0.08004069328308105,
-0.030407341197133064,
-0.6868454217910767,
-0.7818353772163391,
-0.23396429419517517,
0.2225319743156433,
-1.0785444974899292,
-0.4502016007900238,
-0.6082815527915955,
-0.37890034914016724,
-0.17033696174621582,
-0.1869734674692154,
-0.0748024731874466,
-0.22438956797122955,
0.13511377573013306,
-0.141241192817688,
0.43521052598953247,
0.8123620748519897,
-0.3575025796890259,
0.06810135394334793,
-0.672538697719574,
0.0428072065114975,
0.43998685479164124,
0.6721404194831848,
-0.12403351813554764,
-0.5991685390472412,
0.09976121783256531,
0.03917369619011879,
0.0858081579208374,
-0.2391130030155182,
0.13818643987178802,
-0.19944319128990173,
0.6619081497192383,
0.15814395248889923,
0.02906016819179058,
0.3654027581214905,
-0.5699513554573059,
0.5213857889175415,
0.1926548033952713,
-0.8642295002937317,
0.3532542884349823,
-0.3263128101825714,
-0.21800827980041504,
0.5844653844833374,
0.2144508957862854,
-0.16648058593273163,
-0.5040884017944336,
-0.17232029139995575,
-0.7556829452514648,
0.3151753544807434,
0.23485028743743896,
0.45847269892692566,
0.11800286918878555,
0.6380274891853333,
0.18896260857582092,
0.18245038390159607,
-0.7759875655174255,
0.21190975606441498,
0.10392056405544281,
-0.39059895277023315,
0.32518234848976135,
-0.1167210042476654,
-0.17998719215393066,
-0.1776341199874878,
0.5612960457801819,
0.05563421547412872,
-0.1928642988204956,
-0.15538832545280457,
-0.1581987887620926,
-0.05610625073313713,
0.4199061393737793,
0.26159635186195374,
0.7425661087036133,
-0.1392235904932022,
-0.12396837025880814,
0.3321020007133484,
-0.5928734540939331,
0.4451631009578705,
0.09182381629943848,
-0.3274640738964081,
-0.367655485868454,
0.05596347898244858,
0.34517866373062134,
-0.08201585710048676,
-0.8020486235618591,
0.44987526535987854,
-0.1388287991285324,
0.00708769541233778,
-0.5120515823364258,
0.25632649660110474,
-0.009536746889352798,
0.462027907371521,
0.3042321503162384,
0.26604384183883667,
0.13795875012874603,
-0.46159520745277405,
0.004734822083264589,
0.5020155906677246,
-0.3697487711906433,
0.2312328815460205,
1.0841025114059448,
0.44037503004074097,
-0.5336494445800781,
0.457194447517395,
-0.2873513400554657,
-0.06980922818183899,
0.5643555521965027,
0.10964999347925186,
0.6276207566261292,
0.15037788450717926,
-0.1941617876291275,
0.1692771017551422,
0.37008532881736755,
-0.3336798846721649,
0.17314413189888,
0.3009395897388458,
-0.3679613471031189,
-0.4799128770828247,
-0.9484699964523315,
-0.12166242301464081,
-0.3264400362968445,
-0.1849685162305832,
0.38775211572647095,
-0.7182515859603882,
-0.426234632730484,
-0.4216953217983246,
-0.24257926642894745,
-0.7230120897293091,
0.29353538155555725,
0.3056505024433136,
0.9222861528396606,
-0.8771592378616333,
0.5755773782730103,
0.4960099458694458,
-0.5251309871673584,
-0.8664512634277344,
0.03399033099412918,
0.13061539828777313,
-0.739856481552124,
0.6142232418060303,
0.006364172324538231,
-0.26982954144477844,
-0.42936187982559204,
-0.6215906143188477,
-0.7308822870254517,
1.10919189453125,
0.7237313389778137,
-0.8007614612579346,
-0.03965235874056816,
0.3889685571193695,
0.5478765368461609,
-0.386368989944458,
0.002437006216496229,
0.6705325841903687,
0.28755298256874084,
-0.20877262949943542,
-1.1056026220321655,
0.2587586045265198,
-0.17497912049293518,
0.12781472504138947,
-0.03295254334807396,
-0.7356299757957458,
0.6958407759666443,
-0.4017583131790161,
-0.08830083906650543,
-0.2097688764333725,
0.6997358798980713,
0.656668484210968,
0.43452998995780945,
0.7193945050239563,
0.506244957447052,
0.811115026473999,
-0.1783902943134308,
1.3719301223754883,
-0.22019754350185394,
0.0019394556293264031,
0.7835403084754944,
-0.5532392263412476,
0.8028119802474976,
0.42553645372390747,
-0.18663428723812103,
0.31059157848358154,
0.5743012428283691,
0.30507925152778625,
0.43410709500312805,
0.21911925077438354,
-0.13321994245052338,
-0.48786646127700806,
-0.27324384450912476,
-0.30381718277931213,
0.6558763980865479,
0.3608487546443939,
-0.06964915245771408,
-0.02351839281618595,
-0.021092483773827553,
0.1912572681903839,
0.4297338128089905,
-0.6254125833511353,
0.43570640683174133,
0.49381500482559204,
-0.509358286857605,
0.16374006867408752,
0.12940388917922974,
0.9718160033226013,
-0.3711594045162201,
-0.04553782939910889,
-0.23645998537540436,
0.12725065648555756,
-0.18615274131298065,
-1.2196145057678223,
0.3774203360080719,
0.274223268032074,
0.01805284433066845,
-0.030719462782144547,
0.8406690359115601,
-0.09346699714660645,
-0.6931698322296143,
0.3313097357749939,
0.3381466865539551,
0.19845229387283325,
0.251679927110672,
-0.5775875449180603,
0.1302964836359024,
-0.410396009683609,
0.3856090307235718,
0.44225138425827026,
0.3840380609035492,
-0.553992509841919,
0.963572084903717,
0.4487510919570923,
0.09632258117198944,
0.3650801181793213,
0.1927247941493988,
0.4860728681087494,
-0.41324105858802795,
-0.7987207174301147,
-0.8181636929512024,
0.6384756565093994,
-0.30141356587409973,
0.05452900752425194,
0.4615858197212219,
0.2985791265964508,
0.6620897650718689,
0.04453624412417412,
0.7858403325080872,
-0.2520117163658142,
0.3237302005290985,
-0.6296688914299011,
1.1668809652328491,
-0.4810203015804291,
0.41743236780166626,
-0.08617924153804779,
-0.8208236694335938,
-0.3017875552177429,
0.1725877970457077,
-0.2290172129869461,
0.22545188665390015,
0.28411200642585754,
0.914095401763916,
-0.14248134195804596,
-0.048565030097961426,
0.18587101995944977,
-0.016722919419407845,
0.35755518078804016,
0.4025864601135254,
0.625430703163147,
-0.3044234812259674,
0.6849969029426575,
-0.06973954290151596,
-0.2307741343975067,
-0.1414669007062912,
-1.105697751045227,
-0.9020347595214844,
-0.13545802235603333,
-0.22028443217277527,
-0.4126319885253906,
0.4275265038013458,
0.9266891479492188,
0.944115400314331,
-0.832834780216217,
-0.4129662811756134,
0.19582797586917877,
0.06820185482501984,
0.3572019636631012,
-0.16709169745445251,
0.21844938397407532,
-0.29397669434547424,
-0.5339248776435852,
-0.10553781688213348,
0.3377373516559601,
-0.033645760267972946,
-0.13905936479568481,
-0.3868073523044586,
-0.2050926238298416,
0.2488846778869629,
0.6602911949157715,
0.23865492641925812,
-0.6671019792556763,
-0.4288395345211029,
-0.5178820490837097,
-0.19372013211250305,
-0.17695504426956177,
0.5698165893554688,
-0.4491956830024719,
0.25531238317489624,
0.2711027264595032,
0.604049026966095,
0.21405036747455597,
-0.20974436402320862,
0.4586581289768219,
-0.5444113612174988,
0.44464775919914246,
0.17561495304107666,
0.6544124484062195,
0.5456402897834778,
-0.5396199226379395,
0.750120222568512,
-0.02186514623463154,
-0.6235830187797546,
-0.9454723000526428,
-0.05067562684416771,
-0.7042580246925354,
-0.031801629811525345,
1.2804213762283325,
0.05167485028505325,
-0.3017370402812958,
-0.10781881958246231,
0.02296227589249611,
0.43603262305259705,
-0.5304936766624451,
0.991797924041748,
0.5889011025428772,
0.11968636512756348,
0.19832782447338104,
-0.7283498048782349,
0.5323140025138855,
0.29873642325401306,
-0.85821932554245,
-0.23405520617961884,
0.427705854177475,
0.7389832139015198,
-0.05800045281648636,
0.7781868577003479,
-0.528260350227356,
0.5088995099067688,
-0.08553474396467209,
-0.17989440262317657,
-0.09998686611652374,
-0.06787682324647903,
-0.4657609462738037,
0.2634970545768738,
0.2689523696899414,
-0.002869422547519207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10558v1 | Neural paraphrasing by automatically crawled and aligned sentence pairs | 2024-02-16T10:40:38 | 2024-02-16T10:40:38 | Achille Globo, Antonio Trevisi, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Maggini, Stefano Melacci | cs.CL | cs.CL | Paraphrasing is the task of re-writing an input text using other words,
without altering the meaning of the original content. Conversational systems
can exploit automatic paraphrasing to make the conversation more natural, e.g.,
talking about a certain topic using different paraphrases in different time
instants. Recently, the task of automatically generating paraphrases has been
approached in the context of Natural Language Generation (NLG). While many
existing systems simply consist in rule-based models, the recent success of the
Deep Neural Networks in several NLG tasks naturally suggests the possibility of
exploiting such networks for generating paraphrases. However, the main obstacle
toward neural-network-based paraphrasing is the lack of large datasets with
aligned pairs of sentences and paraphrases, that are needed to efficiently
train the neural models. In this paper we present a method for the automatic
generation of large aligned corpora, that is based on the assumption that news
and blog websites talk about the same events using different narrative styles.
We propose a similarity search procedure with linguistic constraints that,
given a reference sentence, is able to locate the most similar candidate
paraphrases out from millions of indexed sentences. The data generation process
is evaluated in the case of the Italian language, performing experiments using
pointer-based deep neural architectures. | [
-0.149672731757164,
-0.650230348110199,
0.6120368838310242,
0.17998823523521423,
-0.48155122995376587,
-0.23544621467590332,
-0.11882302165031433,
-0.08440110832452774,
0.4533439874649048,
0.479169636964798,
-0.5335997343063354,
-0.598917543888092,
-0.14190468192100525,
0.3238334059715271,
-0.7293046712875366,
0.9759092926979065,
-0.04405168816447258,
0.03881479427218437,
-0.3787049353122711,
-0.1795131415128708,
-0.1304098516702652,
-0.3361193835735321,
-0.5520408749580383,
-0.11069342494010925,
0.4921126663684845,
0.09389811009168625,
0.8841294050216675,
0.9448482394218445,
0.6278538107872009,
0.31374236941337585,
-0.0512395054101944,
0.3797180950641632,
-0.17035658657550812,
0.4491949677467346,
-0.2816857695579529,
-0.19374167919158936,
0.08903425186872482,
-0.08613700419664383,
0.6726025342941284,
0.6252102851867676,
-0.09454850852489471,
0.10390748083591461,
0.3672182559967041,
0.433551549911499,
-0.47144439816474915,
-0.0020678192377090454,
-0.8094885945320129,
0.15469567477703094,
-0.025461746379733086,
-0.46896588802337646,
-0.04769410192966461,
-0.7768846750259399,
0.16689060628414154,
-0.5410030484199524,
0.38004618883132935,
0.0007991495076566935,
0.848642110824585,
0.29346969723701477,
0.016037030145525932,
-0.5972000360488892,
-0.21712107956409454,
0.5370618104934692,
-1.0057344436645508,
0.05085499957203865,
0.09711458534002304,
-0.2065405547618866,
-0.14071814715862274,
-1.0149686336517334,
-0.6273188591003418,
-0.2503647208213806,
-0.329618364572525,
-0.18166576325893402,
0.08363419771194458,
-0.23910865187644958,
-0.005655854474753141,
-0.0363566093146801,
-0.7511561512947083,
-0.13237223029136658,
-0.2680104076862335,
-0.02497049607336521,
0.5280870795249939,
0.19182534515857697,
0.3907832205295563,
-0.6164130568504333,
-0.4854390621185303,
-0.11632803827524185,
-0.6956775784492493,
-0.35964855551719666,
0.5425660014152527,
0.19322222471237183,
0.31143710017204285,
0.5565623044967651,
-0.3994378447532654,
0.7101208567619324,
0.19087079167366028,
0.13486500084400177,
0.20591583847999573,
-0.5713567137718201,
-0.05010583996772766,
0.34558171033859253,
1.0835531949996948,
0.7889664173126221,
0.36382433772087097,
-0.4725809097290039,
-0.060464516282081604,
-0.053926870226860046,
0.38558900356292725,
-0.49232393503189087,
-0.1617441028356552,
-0.26309528946876526,
-0.44627639651298523,
-0.3968701958656311,
-0.021555814892053604,
-1.1083221435546875,
-0.06864258646965027,
-0.5719080567359924,
0.3387118875980377,
-0.5449397563934326,
0.3690450191497803,
-0.1271144151687622,
-0.30222076177597046,
0.35592687129974365,
-0.3144264221191406,
-0.7113937139511108,
0.30706363916397095,
0.815701425075531,
1.009806513786316,
-0.3150154948234558,
-0.5583683848381042,
-0.6414573192596436,
0.2820223271846771,
-0.3200822174549103,
0.6306344866752625,
-0.5470044612884521,
0.01629532128572464,
0.11761785298585892,
-0.23772959411144257,
-0.311075896024704,
-0.47773295640945435,
0.6782655119895935,
-0.5331753492355347,
0.3330318033695221,
-0.022274304181337357,
-0.6559216976165771,
0.14500290155410767,
0.2797020971775055,
-0.360789954662323,
0.8342773914337158,
-0.3974893391132355,
-0.8269453644752502,
-0.09863800555467606,
-0.25436803698539734,
-0.5680450201034546,
-0.040213409811258316,
-0.3223859965801239,
-0.40895938873291016,
0.14145691692829132,
0.38541197776794434,
0.5700460076332092,
-0.2102316915988922,
0.6128070950508118,
-0.23813271522521973,
-0.2432943433523178,
0.14086253941059113,
-0.20258396863937378,
0.8245717287063599,
0.2545739710330963,
-0.6240296959877014,
-0.1163041740655899,
-0.7204543948173523,
0.09255889058113098,
0.0030197883024811745,
-0.15622471272945404,
-0.635922372341156,
0.1321195811033249,
-0.10096631199121475,
0.22311274707317352,
0.46468743681907654,
-0.4489418864250183,
-0.11731438338756561,
-0.5666477680206299,
0.740600049495697,
0.4301063120365143,
0.29960328340530396,
0.44186052680015564,
-0.4618057310581207,
0.30295801162719727,
-0.193135067820549,
-0.14265961945056915,
-0.18054814636707306,
-0.211323082447052,
-0.5434877872467041,
0.4259553849697113,
0.2638213634490967,
0.46492645144462585,
-0.6760448217391968,
0.6628438234329224,
-0.6068226099014282,
-0.3858690857887268,
-0.6232550144195557,
0.4962548613548279,
0.4926376938819885,
0.8213598728179932,
0.42159774899482727,
0.006840563844889402,
-0.5269732475280762,
-1.0791199207305908,
-0.3453655540943146,
0.16011154651641846,
0.04149927571415901,
-0.057461753487586975,
0.15188808739185333,
0.2175177037715912,
0.7097720503807068,
-0.4137318432331085,
-0.11872489005327225,
0.06554144620895386,
0.2455606460571289,
-0.0932183489203453,
0.597843587398529,
0.4291749596595764,
-1.1081851720809937,
-0.560440182685852,
-0.1674584001302719,
-0.9930683970451355,
-0.09028857201337814,
-0.3545744717121124,
-0.21952039003372192,
-0.08911166340112686,
1.2058781385421753,
-0.7229604125022888,
0.06829679757356644,
0.3643830120563507,
0.07325012981891632,
0.30778414011001587,
-0.2659838795661926,
0.019266722723841667,
-1.5408178567886353,
0.1722157597541809,
0.11349205672740936,
-0.06189827248454094,
-0.278043657541275,
0.44550102949142456,
-0.07154994457960129,
-0.10379868745803833,
-0.37342503666877747,
0.2356913536787033,
-0.5645782947540283,
-0.012450573965907097,
-0.4498284161090851,
0.6179425716400146,
0.09903880208730698,
0.5517357587814331,
0.10661273449659348,
0.6613448858261108,
0.4261727035045624,
-0.5120978355407715,
0.5798462629318237,
0.5305171608924866,
-0.3546178638935089,
0.5154313445091248,
-0.6440666317939758,
0.1402975171804428,
-0.2134701907634735,
0.19974897801876068,
-0.9101958274841309,
-0.05081413686275482,
0.08328977227210999,
-0.404740571975708,
-0.05375871807336807,
0.04188910126686096,
-0.4153697192668915,
-0.11261703073978424,
-0.28937825560569763,
0.29720768332481384,
0.4101150631904602,
-0.5326212644577026,
0.16657312214374542,
0.09500103443861008,
-0.6397749185562134,
-0.4900645315647125,
-0.5106489658355713,
0.6704447269439697,
-0.6186296939849854,
-0.5033735632896423,
0.5110356211662292,
0.07101570814847946,
-0.25809726119041443,
0.09580807387828827,
0.16179333627223969,
-0.06613563001155853,
-0.04568079113960266,
0.001630914630368352,
0.06495598703622818,
-0.3887283205986023,
0.13725495338439941,
-0.020606908947229385,
0.11786635965108871,
0.18320170044898987,
-0.4926387369632721,
0.764644980430603,
0.014101761393249035,
-0.12279365956783295,
-0.5646318197250366,
0.6850136518478394,
0.5385355949401855,
-0.36047980189323425,
0.5243045687675476,
0.46246612071990967,
-0.2712084650993347,
0.03330456465482712,
-0.42512691020965576,
-0.10646269470453262,
-0.45698726177215576,
0.09185795485973358,
-0.24639561772346497,
-0.30583685636520386,
0.24090318381786346,
0.10823892056941986,
0.08678155392408371,
0.5059213638305664,
0.4093737304210663,
-0.24814248085021973,
0.8232743144035339,
0.08538183569908142,
-0.06284690648317337,
0.24412797391414642,
0.1399988830089569,
0.18036328256130219,
-0.6852743029594421,
-0.2173110842704773,
-0.5352329611778259,
-0.8338539004325867,
-0.5701176524162292,
-0.21947157382965088,
0.1327691376209259,
-0.026805194094777107,
0.11419084668159485,
0.6199586987495422,
-0.5723649859428406,
0.45059800148010254,
1.1821881532669067,
0.28953737020492554,
0.2469431310892105,
0.0693860650062561,
-0.28144073486328125,
0.05297042056918144,
-0.6340182423591614,
-0.6213003993034363,
0.9807714819908142,
-0.3783405125141144,
0.48794886469841003,
-0.3113407492637634,
1.0994387865066528,
0.02741638757288456,
-0.24544095993041992,
-0.4759375751018524,
0.7234048247337341,
-0.25870367884635925,
-0.27205199003219604,
-0.14402160048484802,
-0.3163163959980011,
-0.9243999719619751,
-0.3202042579650879,
-0.013592943549156189,
-0.5341408848762512,
0.21890667080879211,
-0.03856474533677101,
-0.5834541320800781,
0.17183013260364532,
-0.4666222333908081,
0.7639433741569519,
-0.18294823169708252,
-0.34226563572883606,
-0.13287627696990967,
-1.021680235862732,
-0.04100119695067406,
0.05614355579018593,
-0.3197910189628601,
0.17877553403377533,
-0.07482627779245377,
0.880996823310852,
-0.2335284799337387,
0.6551847457885742,
0.09394573420286179,
0.2403305023908615,
0.5524819493293762,
0.0885029062628746,
0.4428873658180237,
-0.06023570895195007,
-0.21581096947193146,
-0.16908349096775055,
-0.07142714411020279,
-0.2924019396305084,
-0.5300271511077881,
1.1561466455459595,
-0.36428889632225037,
-0.6560077667236328,
-0.09331560134887695,
-0.5625135898590088,
-0.1698007434606552,
0.17080684006214142,
0.562824547290802,
0.4095076322555542,
-0.34468016028404236,
0.45269185304641724,
0.4787745475769043,
0.07748009264469147,
0.7910829186439514,
-0.15226949751377106,
0.28345659375190735,
-0.4070425033569336,
0.7744036912918091,
-0.20740260183811188,
0.13102205097675323,
0.6125398874282837,
0.03653207793831825,
-0.25251156091690063,
-0.6577916145324707,
-0.2807360291481018,
0.21923834085464478,
-0.3028879463672638,
-0.43016085028648376,
-0.7919796705245972,
-0.3047191798686981,
-0.6414211988449097,
-0.4064067304134369,
-0.11215084046125412,
-0.4523492753505707,
-0.34624096751213074,
-0.1217506155371666,
0.166337788105011,
0.3507149815559387,
-0.09656449407339096,
0.45047691464424133,
-0.8547999262809753,
0.4355297088623047,
0.32489264011383057,
-0.04708420857787132,
-0.11535977572202682,
-0.21720176935195923,
-0.0034849857911467552,
0.35257643461227417,
-0.5411980152130127,
-0.8252276182174683,
0.6846577525138855,
0.28101521730422974,
0.3493199348449707,
0.3547753095626831,
0.004654802847653627,
0.735509991645813,
-0.9146178364753723,
0.5625088214874268,
0.16951125860214233,
-0.8002315759658813,
0.5867800116539001,
-0.5554578304290771,
0.09792496263980865,
0.8305069208145142,
0.6514538526535034,
-0.4769195020198822,
-0.40364640951156616,
-0.8557136654853821,
-0.8187305331230164,
0.27588212490081787,
0.2503051161766052,
0.34855273365974426,
-0.44692936539649963,
0.5740197896957397,
0.11728958785533905,
0.33599674701690674,
-0.7638652324676514,
0.05087526515126228,
-0.020205922424793243,
-0.7712121605873108,
-0.24562601745128632,
0.08841294050216675,
-0.2550923526287079,
0.055979859083890915,
0.45420512557029724,
-0.14509430527687073,
0.18406854569911957,
0.4188651442527771,
-0.23205886781215668,
0.076795794069767,
0.10509751737117767,
0.36212360858917236,
0.6182603240013123,
0.06823303550481796,
0.3090479075908661,
0.04319947585463524,
0.08193069696426392,
0.10240661352872849,
0.44591307640075684,
-0.3690348267555237,
0.4075417220592499,
0.1834188997745514,
0.6317010521888733,
0.3731018602848053,
-0.7620862126350403,
0.410532683134079,
0.24132809042930603,
-0.3045511841773987,
-0.19635732471942902,
0.00821868795901537,
0.5150083899497986,
0.46144941449165344,
0.26849129796028137,
0.07920914143323898,
0.23580533266067505,
-0.56913822889328,
0.5774843096733093,
0.39708179235458374,
-0.23654693365097046,
-0.13048450648784637,
0.6985928416252136,
0.08502502739429474,
-0.7167934775352478,
0.8413936495780945,
0.026060201227664948,
-0.36996838450431824,
0.6276454925537109,
0.6311370730400085,
0.8364676833152771,
-0.10401599854230881,
0.2749894857406616,
0.3337719440460205,
-0.09016045182943344,
-0.21832281351089478,
-0.22943592071533203,
-0.04729347303509712,
-0.5217553377151489,
-0.2444188892841339,
-0.759490966796875,
-0.04352479428052902,
0.14984044432640076,
-0.7093112468719482,
0.2496056854724884,
-0.39390042424201965,
0.15731604397296906,
0.13810759782791138,
-0.4196222126483917,
-0.38684600591659546,
0.19415970146656036,
0.31346479058265686,
0.5862581729888916,
-0.6993857622146606,
0.5457223057746887,
0.6932254433631897,
-0.16052879393100739,
-0.5672856569290161,
0.3479384183883667,
-0.34536948800086975,
-0.9307205677032471,
0.6306658387184143,
0.23483403027057648,
0.09900365769863129,
0.12246745079755783,
-0.3997204601764679,
-0.6924278140068054,
0.9399365782737732,
0.36941343545913696,
-0.5746321678161621,
-0.905167281627655,
0.14643844962120056,
0.7780236005783081,
-0.4063054621219635,
-0.3328149914741516,
0.3863888680934906,
0.19111144542694092,
-0.08497779816389084,
-0.7441931366920471,
0.06792622804641724,
-0.2210683375597,
-0.10718435794115067,
0.261636883020401,
-0.5738821625709534,
0.700366199016571,
0.17593412101268768,
0.15236258506774902,
0.44218719005584717,
0.703881025314331,
-0.05878867954015732,
0.3006143271923065,
0.3757345676422119,
0.8153208494186401,
0.3493465185165405,
0.16983886063098907,
0.7615492939949036,
-0.5090532898902893,
0.169134721159935,
1.3352974653244019,
-0.1973581314086914,
0.9597625732421875,
0.6277180314064026,
0.3386293649673462,
0.47334641218185425,
0.3186393082141876,
-0.12074176967144012,
0.6966734528541565,
0.08810550719499588,
-0.19456493854522705,
-0.2846730351448059,
0.05755707994103432,
-0.07122448831796646,
0.5968651175498962,
0.1786009669303894,
-0.8269081115722656,
-0.5500125288963318,
0.0014629388460889459,
-0.02588510513305664,
0.6441697478294373,
-0.22208209335803986,
1.0319576263427734,
0.11882811039686203,
-1.2691402435302734,
0.46452993154525757,
-0.11074231564998627,
0.44204363226890564,
-0.34763145446777344,
0.06902533024549484,
-0.25039926171302795,
0.1422463208436966,
0.017131244763731956,
-0.6408689022064209,
0.5906398892402649,
0.03862634673714638,
0.08641017228364944,
-0.4934305250644684,
0.4183870851993561,
-0.5773011445999146,
-0.5531248450279236,
0.20223698019981384,
0.47598567605018616,
0.027508212253451347,
-0.11847923696041107,
-0.7637864947319031,
-0.494607537984848,
0.2258661687374115,
-0.11994669586420059,
0.2991161346435547,
0.4673827588558197,
0.1122179850935936,
0.4311300814151764,
0.4375949501991272,
-0.0008179442374967039,
0.4156355857849121,
-0.4071323871612549,
0.6539444923400879,
-0.6725322008132935,
-0.550568699836731,
-1.0566058158874512,
-0.015856431797146797,
-0.36078891158103943,
-0.4075583517551422,
0.7420923709869385,
0.7135375142097473,
0.4972979426383972,
0.1158728376030922,
0.530937671661377,
-0.0646023377776146,
0.550443172454834,
-0.5477882027626038,
0.45733290910720825,
-0.3756420314311981,
-0.22637489438056946,
-0.250550776720047,
-1.1063164472579956,
-0.15250352025032043,
0.7743644714355469,
-0.20394140481948853,
-0.3211972415447235,
0.746842622756958,
0.8841526508331299,
-0.28871092200279236,
0.08676797151565552,
-0.04028404504060745,
0.0024049694184213877,
-0.024700520560145378,
0.5739239454269409,
0.6035738587379456,
-0.4848977029323578,
1.025377631187439,
-0.26354631781578064,
0.28653043508529663,
-0.15010854601860046,
-0.778672993183136,
-0.7155753374099731,
-0.7773740887641907,
-0.4406747817993164,
-0.2647944688796997,
0.5137816071510315,
0.7521171569824219,
0.2804604768753052,
-0.6338886022567749,
-0.03153685852885246,
-0.6494227051734924,
-0.09997517615556717,
-0.1398404836654663,
-0.22516368329524994,
0.5287632346153259,
-0.6643887162208557,
-1.087387204170227,
0.5455039143562317,
0.01826709508895874,
-0.1998235434293747,
0.07336195558309555,
0.3077068626880646,
-0.8475979566574097,
-0.09631720185279846,
-0.059437528252601624,
0.18338888883590698,
-0.34441184997558594,
-0.2748112678527832,
-0.04589236527681351,
-0.3773742616176605,
0.2435927540063858,
0.7591963410377502,
-0.7629493474960327,
-0.05046675354242325,
0.5032445192337036,
0.9211222529411316,
0.32392483949661255,
0.2906021177768707,
0.9125232696533203,
-0.8926444053649902,
0.03701711446046829,
0.44531485438346863,
0.3837178349494934,
0.45133739709854126,
-0.1556193232536316,
0.14401784539222717,
0.08243605494499207,
-0.6099495887756348,
-0.4424688518047333,
-0.03267984092235565,
-0.8906883597373962,
-0.33855563402175903,
1.3042658567428589,
-0.19364283978939056,
-0.12218999117612839,
0.18434551358222961,
-0.13917550444602966,
0.4524669647216797,
-0.04115581884980202,
0.8361536860466003,
0.5886505842208862,
0.16175086796283722,
0.3160804510116577,
-0.15113455057144165,
0.4860624670982361,
0.7161431908607483,
-0.5669698119163513,
-0.04479062929749489,
0.48344141244888306,
0.3202861249446869,
0.4381124973297119,
-0.07058361172676086,
0.022551747038960457,
0.25620681047439575,
-0.05690470710396767,
-0.19596411287784576,
0.06880450993776321,
-0.14414501190185547,
-0.13255389034748077,
0.5893092751502991,
-0.511925458908081,
-0.37958598136901855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10555v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10555v2 | SPAR: Personalized Content-Based Recommendation via Long Engagement Attention | 2024-02-16T10:36:38 | 2024-05-22T02:44:40 | Chiyu Zhang, Yifei Sun, Jun Chen, Jie Lei, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Sinong Wang, Rong Jin, Sem Park, Ning Yao, Bo Long | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Leveraging users' long engagement histories is essential for personalized
content recommendations. The success of pretrained language models (PLMs) in
NLP has led to their use in encoding user histories and candidate items,
framing content recommendations as textual semantic matching tasks. However,
existing works still struggle with processing very long user historical text
and insufficient user-item interaction. In this paper, we introduce a
content-based recommendation framework, SPAR, which effectively tackles the
challenges of holistic user interest extraction from the long user engagement
history. It achieves so by leveraging PLM, poly-attention layers and attention
sparsity mechanisms to encode user's history in a session-based manner. The
user and item side features are sufficiently fused for engagement prediction
while maintaining standalone representations for both sides, which is efficient
for practical model deployment. Moreover, we enhance user profiling by
exploiting large language model (LLM) to extract global interests from user
engagement history. Extensive experiments on two benchmark datasets demonstrate
that our framework outperforms existing state-of-the-art (SoTA) methods. | [
-0.517487108707428,
-0.6081897020339966,
0.5920192003250122,
0.10956590622663498,
-0.13034206628799438,
-0.03453795239329338,
-0.2653225362300873,
-0.04484579712152481,
0.4521431624889374,
0.9749014377593994,
-0.7353098392486572,
-0.6597078442573547,
-0.31589213013648987,
-0.18035168945789337,
-0.260916531085968,
1.395623803138733,
0.01454094611108303,
-0.46002206206321716,
-0.23588861525058746,
-0.2192021906375885,
-0.9119155406951904,
-0.6953808069229126,
-0.66937655210495,
-0.2621771991252899,
0.9135611057281494,
0.2999171316623688,
0.5330492854118347,
0.3910920321941376,
0.2793448269367218,
0.20835450291633606,
-0.26318326592445374,
0.32375678420066833,
-0.9274156093597412,
0.2562738358974457,
-0.4003278315067291,
-0.020573310554027557,
-0.3003106415271759,
-0.297126442193985,
0.31181421875953674,
0.42382434010505676,
-0.166561096906662,
0.05212623253464699,
0.12935557961463928,
0.9132899045944214,
-0.48926612734794617,
-0.15855255722999573,
-0.23678357899188995,
0.017622845247387886,
-0.32174888253211975,
-0.3873191475868225,
-0.5501328706741333,
-0.17206665873527527,
0.48118337988853455,
-0.6088021993637085,
0.2288637012243271,
0.2741737961769104,
0.529077410697937,
-0.06795702129602432,
-0.4869690239429474,
-0.2682117521762848,
-0.8752022385597229,
0.7810359597206116,
-0.2843594551086426,
0.5414197444915771,
0.797914445400238,
0.2553372383117676,
-0.46031415462493896,
-0.5349873304367065,
-0.17094530165195465,
-0.2570030391216278,
-0.0607423298060894,
-0.09949062764644623,
-0.13152240216732025,
-0.11593954265117645,
0.2025318145751953,
0.3062002956867218,
-0.7682616114616394,
-0.229845330119133,
-0.08035431057214737,
0.16426624357700348,
0.5818542242050171,
0.09877364337444305,
0.2722446322441101,
0.2671022415161133,
-0.7257940173149109,
0.007156459614634514,
-0.6330779194831848,
0.17889763414859772,
0.3714802861213684,
0.09420585632324219,
-0.1991916298866272,
0.7018888592720032,
-0.16503272950649261,
0.5576347708702087,
0.5396897792816162,
0.15894587337970734,
-0.04552009329199791,
-0.2764165997505188,
0.03802131116390228,
0.15852253139019012,
0.7594446539878845,
0.35177022218704224,
0.4582832157611847,
-0.4023185968399048,
0.05912778526544571,
-0.24299226701259613,
0.22044895589351654,
-0.786541223526001,
-0.0060716066509485245,
0.08348874747753143,
-0.2932770550251007,
0.3072851896286011,
0.3185352087020874,
-0.767876923084259,
-0.6914129853248596,
-0.05507033318281174,
0.19974376261234283,
-0.4046838879585266,
-0.13571709394454956,
0.43328332901000977,
0.14814740419387817,
-0.3270440101623535,
0.10803042352199554,
-1.0009851455688477,
0.480953574180603,
0.9151710867881775,
0.7865943312644958,
-0.5465143918991089,
-0.30189526081085205,
-0.8695802688598633,
0.4169504940509796,
0.03898262232542038,
0.9174186587333679,
-0.8531543612480164,
-0.3987976014614105,
0.3351675570011139,
0.19607830047607422,
0.19850613176822662,
-0.40337511897087097,
0.37241971492767334,
-0.8827716112136841,
0.28898894786834717,
-0.253130167722702,
-0.6697794795036316,
-0.22563967108726501,
0.03947813808917999,
-0.6065989136695862,
1.249766230583191,
0.3205159604549408,
-0.5696715712547302,
0.4767686128616333,
-0.8100978136062622,
-0.5979074239730835,
0.3448660969734192,
0.15755806863307953,
-0.3412133455276489,
-0.010015052743256092,
0.21591132879257202,
0.624789834022522,
-0.16170397400856018,
0.7139449715614319,
-0.5637339949607849,
-0.6127695441246033,
-0.005044881720095873,
-0.07511565834283829,
-0.021173512563109398,
0.0019832055550068617,
-0.18615777790546417,
0.42925694584846497,
-0.4429246187210083,
-0.6192137002944946,
-0.08647747337818146,
-0.17821857333183289,
-0.6335561275482178,
0.20698918402194977,
0.24226531386375427,
0.1102178767323494,
0.40801766514778137,
-0.43086108565330505,
0.04387235641479492,
-0.780316174030304,
0.2454083412885666,
0.7251440286636353,
0.32735681533813477,
0.6123799681663513,
-0.22214822471141815,
0.4562409818172455,
-0.019617488607764244,
-0.24123123288154602,
-0.5900680422782898,
-0.06835446506738663,
-0.511649489402771,
-0.08258693665266037,
0.2345166951417923,
0.1254291832447052,
-0.08810745179653168,
0.9071003198623657,
-0.3215736448764801,
-0.1312820464372635,
-0.15085138380527496,
0.5518930554389954,
0.08625615388154984,
0.06758502125740051,
0.3577130436897278,
-0.5597407817840576,
-0.559628427028656,
-0.4533550441265106,
-0.21128374338150024,
-0.018431996926665306,
-0.09457501769065857,
0.8100948333740234,
-0.04862833023071289,
-0.5882008075714111,
1.0962179899215698,
-0.550446093082428,
-0.8018162846565247,
-0.4720991551876068,
0.03578844293951988,
0.4010986387729645,
0.15492196381092072,
0.20990976691246033,
-0.6879467368125916,
-0.7803264856338501,
0.15885737538337708,
-0.2599552273750305,
0.21444135904312134,
-0.4023820757865906,
-0.3974205255508423,
-0.03187847509980202,
0.19763128459453583,
-0.4396604597568512,
0.44255250692367554,
0.36599001288414,
-0.7283769845962524,
-0.06753994524478912,
-0.2236034870147705,
0.12280261516571045,
-1.221428394317627,
0.1267743557691574,
0.6944652795791626,
-0.46389254927635193,
-0.35794055461883545,
-0.6269261240959167,
-0.07806066423654556,
-0.2710452377796173,
-0.29101601243019104,
1.1158802509307861,
-0.2219855934381485,
0.08643811196088791,
-0.29498952627182007,
-0.01063177827745676,
-0.10658476501703262,
0.602645993232727,
0.3199034333229065,
0.4275503158569336,
0.0994773730635643,
-0.5532311201095581,
0.12950696051120758,
0.47054386138916016,
-0.2563762366771698,
0.4061460793018341,
-0.6924258470535278,
0.4029797315597534,
0.0806293785572052,
0.2906944453716278,
-1.1183838844299316,
-0.14726343750953674,
0.056478578597307205,
-0.08716642111539841,
0.08767830580472946,
-0.5739811658859253,
-0.30144262313842773,
0.024344448000192642,
-0.5206868052482605,
0.354621559381485,
0.21474069356918335,
-0.5407863259315491,
0.8126412034034729,
0.41618049144744873,
-0.3863683342933655,
-0.47620436549186707,
-0.003259670687839389,
0.16236019134521484,
-0.26130029559135437,
-0.5316665172576904,
0.6678351163864136,
-0.40805211663246155,
0.30163225531578064,
-0.0036913971416652203,
-0.14539913833141327,
0.03929521143436432,
-0.1259150207042694,
0.6347240805625916,
0.19152596592903137,
-0.153172105550766,
0.061048489063978195,
-0.13941940665245056,
-0.34240198135375977,
-0.3326476514339447,
0.1370871514081955,
1.005048394203186,
0.12656733393669128,
-0.3549302816390991,
-0.5773382186889648,
0.6222984790802002,
0.43005892634391785,
-0.38642793893814087,
0.5418475866317749,
1.0065430402755737,
-0.15561023354530334,
-0.036930713802576065,
-1.1304060220718384,
-0.1829497218132019,
-0.481068879365921,
0.5987113118171692,
-0.07398699223995209,
-1.501873254776001,
0.2557809054851532,
-0.09406478703022003,
0.07050026953220367,
0.23534710705280304,
0.7664476633071899,
-0.22461825609207153,
1.041283369064331,
0.8069366216659546,
-0.5782486796379089,
0.9959813356399536,
-0.07695595920085907,
0.08752306550741196,
-0.8362973928451538,
-0.17953167855739594,
-0.03100631572306156,
-0.24817794561386108,
-0.19929075241088867,
0.08189837634563446,
0.05024506524205208,
-0.054654311388731,
-0.2928483784198761,
0.138977512717247,
-0.3270702362060547,
0.489871621131897,
0.4410305619239807,
0.19432587921619415,
-0.01810917817056179,
-0.11006410419940948,
0.49464449286460876,
-0.2550589144229889,
-0.37836211919784546,
-0.21903552114963531,
0.8660131096839905,
0.3746188282966614,
0.9345777034759521,
0.05701890215277672,
0.6480308175086975,
0.9464873671531677,
0.09958954155445099,
-0.8528703451156616,
0.4055432975292206,
-0.19339950382709503,
-0.3709879219532013,
-0.2880276143550873,
-0.06183222681283951,
-1.2831406593322754,
-0.22315576672554016,
-0.3180420696735382,
-0.7547493577003479,
-0.007167011499404907,
0.2352912425994873,
-0.6251693964004517,
-0.04536067694425583,
-0.5488598346710205,
1.113234043121338,
-0.39488741755485535,
-0.6808241605758667,
-0.29545435309410095,
-0.3650605082511902,
-0.07304135710000992,
0.03019964136183262,
0.037212617695331573,
-0.22847217321395874,
0.13178007304668427,
0.7377352118492126,
0.16018633544445038,
0.9422135949134827,
-0.23646512627601624,
0.3601645529270172,
0.009162436239421368,
0.3495977818965912,
0.8214601278305054,
0.2704836130142212,
0.09931100159883499,
-0.09625821560621262,
-0.18470428884029388,
0.04887041822075844,
-0.37757161259651184,
0.9945486187934875,
-0.5320038199424744,
-0.7304688096046448,
-0.5154868960380554,
-0.3867320120334625,
-0.12453141063451767,
0.34920451045036316,
-0.272914320230484,
0.30604490637779236,
-0.5602830052375793,
0.6178286075592041,
0.8386825323104858,
-0.047054193913936615,
0.3992525637149811,
0.4833773672580719,
-0.14594024419784546,
-0.5580950975418091,
1.0349596738815308,
-0.2821897268295288,
-0.48031747341156006,
0.4051178991794586,
0.16604386270046234,
-0.4981466829776764,
-0.48759666085243225,
-0.38908153772354126,
0.3979935646057129,
-0.168937548995018,
-0.050861988216638565,
-0.8979811072349548,
0.27085646986961365,
-0.3101195991039276,
-0.43101322650909424,
-0.18786300718784332,
0.4733331501483917,
-0.6616315245628357,
0.17343147099018097,
0.2983182668685913,
0.6598736047744751,
0.5157070755958557,
0.30729883909225464,
-0.6650850772857666,
0.541700541973114,
0.11868931353092194,
0.5654966831207275,
-0.22612230479717255,
-0.44600412249565125,
-0.6746432185173035,
-0.3584665358066559,
-0.263283371925354,
-0.6149021983146667,
0.6265223622322083,
0.3235303461551666,
0.7424147725105286,
0.6523188352584839,
0.20947399735450745,
0.6117463707923889,
-0.6761349439620972,
0.7473302483558655,
0.22633203864097595,
-0.6850786209106445,
0.5364142656326294,
-0.31425103545188904,
0.37468963861465454,
0.6530872583389282,
0.6512184143066406,
-0.8924791216850281,
0.16708680987358093,
-0.2521531581878662,
-1.002211332321167,
0.638437807559967,
-0.4712710380554199,
0.2894786596298218,
-0.0002850135206244886,
0.46761804819107056,
0.36278268694877625,
-0.13079659640789032,
-0.6294122338294983,
0.12872861325740814,
0.16058196127414703,
-0.3928550183773041,
-0.31856340169906616,
-0.7370542883872986,
0.01002643071115017,
0.2603953778743744,
0.7090270519256592,
-0.10653885453939438,
-0.2156601846218109,
0.14467748999595642,
-0.31647443771362305,
-0.24578285217285156,
0.1967824250459671,
0.2793208062648773,
0.6872066259384155,
-0.34289318323135376,
-0.27950337529182434,
0.009694586507976055,
-0.20914000272750854,
0.10861419141292572,
0.18283230066299438,
0.17071762681007385,
-0.13867174088954926,
-0.12217213958501816,
0.6962088942527771,
0.6439129710197449,
-0.8336259722709656,
0.7795552611351013,
-0.29776784777641296,
0.225071519613266,
-0.6833032369613647,
0.06791628152132034,
0.24127401411533356,
0.2501932978630066,
0.25495782494544983,
-0.21896415948867798,
0.19760355353355408,
-0.44554561376571655,
0.22928272187709808,
0.45665210485458374,
-0.8702525496482849,
-0.31672993302345276,
0.37829306721687317,
0.37075331807136536,
-0.4893256723880768,
0.1691180169582367,
0.31997910141944885,
-0.151031956076622,
-0.2319226711988449,
0.5522348880767822,
0.8501275181770325,
-0.1539393812417984,
0.07490713149309158,
0.17573003470897675,
-0.3808317184448242,
-0.28908640146255493,
-0.2897067964076996,
-0.413803368806839,
-0.45044153928756714,
-0.5690977573394775,
-0.6558837890625,
-0.3754674196243286,
0.22795946896076202,
-0.7912593483924866,
0.5317435264587402,
-0.45657259225845337,
-0.3947845995426178,
0.09487054497003555,
0.1558343470096588,
-0.6407347917556763,
-0.07452122122049332,
0.1629202514886856,
0.5126152634620667,
-0.7845596075057983,
0.6012865900993347,
0.6889205574989319,
-0.09336314350366592,
-0.043785758316516876,
-0.18759427964687347,
-0.18427138030529022,
-0.2791682481765747,
0.35904592275619507,
0.20047803223133087,
-0.25917088985443115,
-0.0073988777585327625,
-0.1055087149143219,
-0.8257961273193359,
0.8657733798027039,
0.3579569458961487,
-0.6392181515693665,
-0.02339410036802292,
-0.060945577919483185,
0.5337072610855103,
-0.5212084650993347,
0.1602562814950943,
0.2750313878059387,
0.09470164775848389,
0.08207471668720245,
-0.44530436396598816,
-0.09885213524103165,
-0.12531137466430664,
0.04534541815519333,
0.3260097801685333,
-0.6617724895477295,
0.1166425570845604,
-0.0312831811606884,
-0.2855534255504608,
-0.07421483844518661,
0.9810826182365417,
0.3479359447956085,
0.5936347842216492,
0.5490939617156982,
0.30843794345855713,
0.13500568270683289,
0.24853962659835815,
1.042236566543579,
-0.3633519113063812,
0.1952936351299286,
1.1797528266906738,
-0.7110400795936584,
1.0126694440841675,
0.48323389887809753,
-0.04494543373584747,
0.6114506125450134,
0.8836454153060913,
-0.13046973943710327,
0.8319868445396423,
-0.10708726942539215,
-0.20771828293800354,
-0.3253038823604584,
-0.24313399195671082,
-0.27349868416786194,
0.09883500635623932,
0.25397008657455444,
-0.4237285256385803,
0.12603837251663208,
-0.04255286231637001,
0.08289094269275665,
0.17497587203979492,
-0.1775544285774231,
1.270089864730835,
-0.14358480274677277,
-0.8651788830757141,
0.15957951545715332,
-0.09272605925798416,
1.1006580591201782,
-0.9200241565704346,
-0.2621432840824127,
-0.293843537569046,
0.16685864329338074,
-0.1468636840581894,
-0.7308713793754578,
-0.166936457157135,
0.12438154220581055,
-0.5539702773094177,
-0.2133329212665558,
0.9435694217681885,
-0.6082592606544495,
-0.16810400784015656,
0.3191041946411133,
0.27423471212387085,
-0.16282060742378235,
-0.21193765103816986,
-0.41737931966781616,
0.03923168033361435,
0.18527533113956451,
-0.3989273011684418,
0.6840631365776062,
0.11107409745454788,
0.012696406804025173,
0.6933874487876892,
0.8385140895843506,
0.026594847440719604,
-0.33302804827690125,
0.030008943751454353,
0.7138305902481079,
-0.9214761257171631,
-0.743558943271637,
-0.9684763550758362,
0.4653629660606384,
0.115598164498806,
-0.5104074478149414,
0.433575838804245,
0.7883325219154358,
0.8534987568855286,
0.12083656340837479,
0.7298072576522827,
0.4059160053730011,
0.5857711434364319,
-0.26360973715782166,
0.48606985807418823,
-0.4199923872947693,
0.4188748598098755,
0.013667422346770763,
-0.9725627303123474,
-0.08014526218175888,
0.24032878875732422,
-0.34090062975883484,
0.23084475100040436,
0.21423834562301636,
0.5860072374343872,
-0.3280866742134094,
-0.23224833607673645,
0.39800384640693665,
-0.17111216485500336,
0.19565831124782562,
0.603529691696167,
0.7491060495376587,
0.17411044239997864,
0.3554094433784485,
-0.15756113827228546,
-0.07884195446968079,
-0.6531454920768738,
-0.7379343509674072,
-1.1205065250396729,
-0.7536104917526245,
-0.24531246721744537,
-0.39291903376579285,
0.45292818546295166,
1.31890869140625,
0.8732004165649414,
-0.8273513913154602,
-0.43705880641937256,
0.4007900357246399,
-0.09067760407924652,
-0.05981871113181114,
-0.19512072205543518,
0.7415058016777039,
0.04578806832432747,
-0.5770398378372192,
0.6465557813644409,
0.6145694851875305,
-0.019704319536685944,
-0.43451303243637085,
-0.2733013927936554,
-0.18355301022529602,
-0.23893947899341583,
0.6676948666572571,
0.4955586791038513,
-0.7886655926704407,
-0.1606139987707138,
0.08189402520656586,
0.016051186248660088,
0.1767638623714447,
0.9865019917488098,
-0.785570502281189,
0.4655539095401764,
0.2581600844860077,
0.8327100872993469,
1.1279244422912598,
0.26623794436454773,
0.7782440185546875,
-0.7190453410148621,
-0.1026587039232254,
0.3804234564304352,
0.3774441182613373,
0.3558911085128784,
-0.8077396154403687,
0.38294440507888794,
-0.19622203707695007,
-0.5835069417953491,
-0.8426603078842163,
-0.13898006081581116,
-1.4236266613006592,
0.23071661591529846,
1.3853037357330322,
-0.4984338879585266,
-0.124665766954422,
-0.37645262479782104,
-0.5084513425827026,
0.06021248921751976,
-0.8723207116127014,
0.8697035908699036,
0.5031331777572632,
-0.18993186950683594,
-0.19585706293582916,
-0.37610334157943726,
0.35669273138046265,
0.46052122116088867,
-0.4310017228126526,
0.3204192817211151,
0.4034661650657654,
0.2477690875530243,
-0.1711990088224411,
0.5160943269729614,
0.11663667112588882,
0.30413562059402466,
-0.649124264717102,
0.041561782360076904,
-0.2553876042366028,
-0.34199708700180054,
-0.20680062472820282,
0.4036239683628082,
-0.013370206579566002,
0.2438860386610031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10554v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10554v2 | Disordered-DABS: A Benchmark for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization in Disordered Texts | 2024-02-16T10:35:18 | 2024-06-17T20:06:04 | Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based summarization has seen significant advancements, especially in
structured text. Yet, summarizing disordered, large-scale texts, like those
found in social media and customer feedback, remains a significant challenge.
Current research largely targets predefined aspects within structured texts,
neglecting the complexities of dynamic and disordered environments. Addressing
this gap, we introduce Disordered-DABS, a novel benchmark for dynamic
aspect-based summarization tailored to unstructured text. Developed by adapting
existing datasets for cost-efficiency and scalability, our comprehensive
experiments and detailed human evaluations reveal that Disordered-DABS poses
unique challenges to contemporary summarization models, including
state-of-the-art language models such as GPT-3.5. | [
-0.2157658040523529,
-1.1443469524383545,
0.6487041115760803,
0.3391513526439667,
-0.3612205982208252,
0.652060329914093,
0.2028064876794815,
-0.373465359210968,
0.6682734489440918,
0.26255303621292114,
-0.4713028073310852,
-0.6019940376281738,
-0.48504915833473206,
-0.052481796592473984,
-0.6219454407691956,
1.2742905616760254,
-0.09266538918018341,
-0.3659687340259552,
-0.43395179510116577,
-0.037793971598148346,
-0.25997138023376465,
-0.7727013230323792,
-0.3922650218009949,
0.07708685845136642,
0.4402996897697449,
0.1625629961490631,
0.8100246787071228,
0.5566601753234863,
0.8527558445930481,
0.30872589349746704,
-0.49446210265159607,
0.241242453455925,
-0.3663897216320038,
0.8612369298934937,
0.08016108721494675,
-0.16807599365711212,
-1.3664196729660034,
-0.04768858850002289,
0.7415226697921753,
1.116199016571045,
-0.3461155593395233,
-0.10389683395624161,
0.19367557764053345,
0.8069671988487244,
-0.5338496565818787,
0.16376827657222748,
-0.43917959928512573,
-0.019306758418679237,
-0.18731175363063812,
-0.18883965909481049,
0.11277349293231964,
-0.3150953948497772,
-0.022579379379749298,
-0.548370361328125,
0.43546316027641296,
-0.29214152693748474,
0.695666491985321,
0.30035313963890076,
-0.7580018043518066,
-0.2836105227470398,
-0.769070029258728,
0.4023783802986145,
-0.5670722723007202,
0.15275262296199799,
0.3591441214084625,
0.13331963121891022,
-0.3630765974521637,
-0.8864922523498535,
-0.27705317735671997,
0.14394760131835938,
0.12544623017311096,
0.27223098278045654,
0.0022242472041398287,
0.027045270428061485,
-0.027840454131364822,
0.7659726142883301,
-0.40631720423698425,
0.1825755387544632,
0.05491156503558159,
0.014177677221596241,
0.8071596026420593,
0.5491070747375488,
0.08637186139822006,
-0.16131237149238586,
-0.11491546779870987,
-0.09031695127487183,
-0.004407255444675684,
-0.06923782825469971,
0.4172284007072449,
0.19095823168754578,
-0.5068038702011108,
0.25015074014663696,
-0.42466774582862854,
0.451468288898468,
0.33707395195961,
-0.08084715902805328,
0.3993609845638275,
-0.2763775885105133,
0.034860845655202866,
-0.12747296690940857,
0.5433157086372375,
0.7703496813774109,
-0.3799886703491211,
-0.3576464354991913,
-0.3953309655189514,
-0.40056857466697693,
0.30029723048210144,
-0.9385471343994141,
-0.6693711876869202,
0.6754021048545837,
-0.5719584226608276,
-0.5930912494659424,
-0.006349275819957256,
-1.1750922203063965,
-0.893318235874176,
0.2261342853307724,
0.1934008002281189,
-0.2260461002588272,
-0.47365328669548035,
-0.2336314618587494,
-0.3843355178833008,
-0.4101836681365967,
0.3792558014392853,
-0.95824134349823,
0.33376023173332214,
0.7760816812515259,
1.1315412521362305,
-0.6189874410629272,
-0.388342946767807,
-0.29707759618759155,
0.1842118352651596,
-0.3822149932384491,
1.2170048952102661,
-0.43276894092559814,
-0.3598458766937256,
-0.2896508276462555,
-0.18574856221675873,
0.28812849521636963,
-0.6902825832366943,
0.4317074716091156,
-0.37897711992263794,
-0.00674125412479043,
-0.3305372893810272,
-0.35109183192253113,
-0.20719829201698303,
0.37132859230041504,
-0.4679737389087677,
0.9496029615402222,
0.33347615599632263,
-0.7077361345291138,
0.697400689125061,
-0.38329386711120605,
-0.7461596131324768,
0.0937815010547638,
-0.06774130463600159,
-0.661226749420166,
0.48450446128845215,
0.07261081039905548,
0.5488833785057068,
-0.03737647086381912,
0.4470175802707672,
-0.8245800137519836,
-0.11344743520021439,
0.5113718509674072,
-0.735746443271637,
0.289152055978775,
0.28351977467536926,
-0.05547372251749039,
0.28922733664512634,
-1.1183421611785889,
-0.11123126745223999,
0.23267659544944763,
-0.43394166231155396,
-0.6204299926757812,
0.4509808123111725,
0.24847270548343658,
-0.09777088463306427,
0.38003021478652954,
-0.23684343695640564,
0.3742086589336395,
-0.39577409625053406,
0.4109167456626892,
0.5697766542434692,
0.2869228422641754,
0.36341580748558044,
-0.3780032992362976,
0.3919025957584381,
0.41968661546707153,
-0.05417369306087494,
-0.3900877833366394,
-0.25585365295410156,
-0.22540076076984406,
-0.7268149256706238,
0.17204807698726654,
0.276844322681427,
-0.43970945477485657,
0.4437391459941864,
-0.19079332053661346,
-0.6593565344810486,
-0.09562446922063828,
-0.26847416162490845,
-0.005294350907206535,
0.2159118503332138,
0.3856017589569092,
-0.580836296081543,
-0.04954909905791283,
-0.7192763686180115,
-0.2814897298812866,
0.10940594971179962,
-0.21286234259605408,
-0.03470955416560173,
0.2780371308326721,
-0.2180831879377365,
0.7513357400894165,
-0.5828796625137329,
-0.31043002009391785,
-0.15522874891757965,
0.46346530318260193,
-0.0009158648899756372,
0.2695952355861664,
0.6146149635314941,
-0.8434165716171265,
-0.3765774667263031,
-0.22217442095279694,
-0.5933381915092468,
-0.2504179775714874,
-0.23717239499092102,
0.3640093505382538,
0.2714807689189911,
0.4632898271083832,
-0.23237979412078857,
0.4831402897834778,
0.7361630797386169,
-0.7007277011871338,
0.3717383146286011,
-0.7337455153465271,
0.5307110548019409,
-1.2266204357147217,
-0.09168216586112976,
-0.36000460386276245,
-0.30633631348609924,
-0.38980481028556824,
-0.08179139345884323,
0.23226937651634216,
-0.14859020709991455,
0.025709187611937523,
0.21055056154727936,
-0.7147706747055054,
-0.004893307574093342,
-0.5721647143363953,
0.08144114166498184,
-0.08160006254911423,
0.3410252034664154,
-0.38171839714050293,
0.5385043621063232,
0.6156764030456543,
-0.7252483367919922,
0.47934192419052124,
-0.10486114770174026,
-0.21181952953338623,
0.7557741403579712,
-0.4324894845485687,
0.07373684644699097,
-0.27624571323394775,
0.37314265966415405,
-0.8403311371803284,
-0.5545769333839417,
-0.08747556060552597,
-0.015563935972750187,
0.3195473849773407,
-0.03380301967263222,
-0.3356815278530121,
-0.248282790184021,
-0.5715593695640564,
0.6806102991104126,
0.30499714612960815,
-0.26745814085006714,
0.811789333820343,
0.8515967726707458,
-0.33896687626838684,
-0.15579786896705627,
-0.6674578785896301,
0.4020407199859619,
-0.30215081572532654,
-0.25941506028175354,
0.8934077620506287,
-0.18939845263957977,
-0.3725888133049011,
0.13416063785552979,
-0.687879204750061,
-0.3688458502292633,
0.4044048488140106,
0.35656502842903137,
-0.21634283661842346,
0.06999295949935913,
-0.3824176788330078,
0.44787758588790894,
0.030724424868822098,
0.08675075322389603,
0.12510554492473602,
0.5665285587310791,
-0.09201934188604355,
-0.3670327067375183,
-0.371964693069458,
0.6389788389205933,
0.8269674181938171,
-0.058961864560842514,
0.511903703212738,
0.15534628927707672,
-0.3986801207065582,
-0.2369306981563568,
-0.2998169958591461,
0.07684407383203506,
-0.49235934019088745,
0.9228453636169434,
-0.281982421875,
-0.45355746150016785,
1.0173306465148926,
0.1405191868543625,
0.16891811788082123,
0.19964799284934998,
0.6892626881599426,
-0.31971144676208496,
1.042108178138733,
0.6519733667373657,
0.13392719626426697,
0.4634755551815033,
0.1796083003282547,
0.19457228481769562,
-0.32142096757888794,
-0.28306853771209717,
-0.21902084350585938,
-0.6577046513557434,
-0.7268276214599609,
-0.2634025514125824,
0.502555251121521,
0.12692122161388397,
0.2152102291584015,
-0.09855899959802628,
-0.33913710713386536,
0.5645378232002258,
0.3125573396682739,
0.12549026310443878,
0.5083800554275513,
-0.21358875930309296,
0.24429357051849365,
0.15122486650943756,
-0.34814751148223877,
-0.40722930431365967,
0.9308167099952698,
0.2797490954399109,
0.7494782209396362,
0.43266913294792175,
0.6972923278808594,
0.5073340535163879,
0.05891184136271477,
-0.740588366985321,
0.5578879714012146,
-0.28036317229270935,
-0.4722862243652344,
-0.07382992655038834,
-0.5554141402244568,
-0.971625804901123,
0.20825524628162384,
-0.16119806468486786,
-0.7938723564147949,
0.32702741026878357,
0.42798447608947754,
-0.4175073504447937,
0.49970608949661255,
-0.6261671185493469,
0.7182474732398987,
-0.183822900056839,
-0.07333099842071533,
-0.38539448380470276,
-0.3311024010181427,
0.04473751410841942,
-0.3567472994327545,
0.36058980226516724,
-0.2778879404067993,
-0.2287079393863678,
0.8463233709335327,
-0.5770755410194397,
0.6440374851226807,
-0.16337846219539642,
-0.293577641248703,
0.0856441780924797,
0.4576866328716278,
0.3296719193458557,
0.2462940812110901,
0.18186919391155243,
0.17857465147972107,
0.48215869069099426,
-0.6028805375099182,
-0.5983928442001343,
0.8214426636695862,
-0.31930989027023315,
-0.38192275166511536,
-0.753035843372345,
-1.064009189605713,
-0.4249715507030487,
0.2575145661830902,
0.08489290624856949,
0.667289674282074,
-0.4048948585987091,
0.23469966650009155,
0.3744855523109436,
-0.1001606285572052,
0.86932772397995,
0.6788107752799988,
-0.3368862569332123,
-0.40805086493492126,
0.807791531085968,
0.291429340839386,
0.09853048622608185,
0.21671846508979797,
-0.06955331563949585,
0.11726085841655731,
-1.0929161310195923,
-0.22448360919952393,
-0.10613701492547989,
-0.443439245223999,
-0.11484026163816452,
-0.8342201113700867,
-0.01736837439239025,
-0.5131458640098572,
-0.19616051018238068,
-0.734438419342041,
-0.43283388018608093,
-0.10606669634580612,
-0.01303609274327755,
0.11179357022047043,
0.9332608580589294,
-0.1889810711145401,
-0.03992539644241333,
-0.684014618396759,
0.49891018867492676,
0.02813185378909111,
0.7877948880195618,
0.0929267480969429,
-0.4714597761631012,
-0.2342132329940796,
0.012606292963027954,
-0.5496236085891724,
-0.9824947714805603,
0.3718969523906708,
0.03508959710597992,
0.26822131872177124,
0.3659919798374176,
0.4287928640842438,
0.551104724407196,
-0.21260744333267212,
0.8099286556243896,
-0.13500559329986572,
-0.48207518458366394,
0.3601098358631134,
-0.6734818816184998,
0.34653952717781067,
0.5065135359764099,
0.24018429219722748,
-0.47194722294807434,
-0.748388946056366,
-0.5434808135032654,
-1.4052708148956299,
0.5557394623756409,
0.05677390098571777,
0.19857296347618103,
-0.048183608800172806,
0.37055733799934387,
0.3336993157863617,
0.21092727780342102,
-0.37545180320739746,
-0.38511353731155396,
-0.14251117408275604,
-0.3388243019580841,
-0.014571832492947578,
-0.601956844329834,
0.03786766529083252,
-0.1134314313530922,
0.4019268751144409,
0.21429002285003662,
0.016915632411837578,
0.12154578417539597,
-0.02085256390273571,
0.05627348646521568,
0.23715977370738983,
0.5805909633636475,
0.6318582892417908,
-0.7265640497207642,
0.16675984859466553,
-0.08195441961288452,
-1.0877882242202759,
0.08753930777311325,
0.41996127367019653,
-0.4196453094482422,
-0.29664331674575806,
0.1971225142478943,
0.5591439604759216,
0.07731287181377411,
-0.5979459881782532,
0.4832850396633148,
-0.2211504578590393,
-0.0488421693444252,
-0.0717376247048378,
0.009640614502131939,
-0.3406149744987488,
0.2747856378555298,
0.5786882638931274,
0.18347300589084625,
0.23782186210155487,
-0.6966904997825623,
0.14993131160736084,
0.22285643219947815,
-0.4750683009624481,
-0.5870609879493713,
0.882964015007019,
0.5025539994239807,
-0.48373880982398987,
0.2862035632133484,
-0.5729970335960388,
-0.16521701216697693,
0.47164517641067505,
0.44504618644714355,
1.0958343744277954,
0.04313695803284645,
0.15434107184410095,
-0.18194599449634552,
0.12314732372760773,
0.08472654968500137,
0.28354188799858093,
-0.18196870386600494,
-0.3324214220046997,
-0.18867790699005127,
-0.6584768295288086,
-0.5478172898292542,
0.15482324361801147,
-0.8646901249885559,
0.03536108881235123,
-0.3676939904689789,
-0.3164382874965668,
0.07939121872186661,
-0.19429215788841248,
-0.08665375411510468,
0.07511576265096664,
-0.15658310055732727,
0.4421542286872864,
-0.6668763756752014,
0.49764201045036316,
1.0847073793411255,
-0.31018370389938354,
-0.2245962768793106,
0.6228576898574829,
0.2852455675601959,
-0.1644376516342163,
-0.1081632748246193,
-0.07796431332826614,
0.08872710168361664,
-0.02084832265973091,
-0.04752010852098465,
-0.8578765988349915,
0.8775503635406494,
-0.02191844768822193,
-0.30011457204818726,
-0.17750254273414612,
-0.0839577466249466,
0.638491153717041,
0.11331935226917267,
0.2606522738933563,
0.566810131072998,
0.09349724650382996,
-0.23850710690021515,
-0.9110473990440369,
0.029752718284726143,
-0.3666277825832367,
-0.2834683358669281,
0.35122373700141907,
-0.7323824763298035,
0.7415990233421326,
-0.13477125763893127,
-0.24009494483470917,
-0.14704422652721405,
1.0145684480667114,
-0.16188935935497284,
0.6473084092140198,
0.4674527943134308,
0.3126625120639801,
0.9303336143493652,
-0.11048828065395355,
0.8227753639221191,
-0.17310085892677307,
0.29014113545417786,
1.1752381324768066,
-0.20361432433128357,
0.579791784286499,
0.18510274589061737,
-0.17682945728302002,
0.43463948369026184,
0.6917100548744202,
0.09312672913074493,
0.7542720437049866,
-0.11991559714078903,
-0.1191948875784874,
0.0021492030937224627,
0.24481907486915588,
-0.46652793884277344,
0.46544575691223145,
0.27327343821525574,
0.1103053167462349,
-0.2803899645805359,
-0.015312430448830128,
0.14383582770824432,
0.2159014195203781,
-0.290991872549057,
0.9263830780982971,
-0.09748174995183945,
-0.4769829511642456,
0.4056432247161865,
0.10598094761371613,
0.9517360925674438,
-0.3272888660430908,
0.43502286076545715,
-0.6623595356941223,
0.280038058757782,
-0.1757463812828064,
-0.8892499804496765,
0.7824870944023132,
0.19854040443897247,
-0.6324018836021423,
-0.3951275050640106,
0.24703344702720642,
-0.3706090450286865,
-0.334669291973114,
-0.03077428787946701,
0.2142699658870697,
0.10088195651769638,
-0.40660521388053894,
-0.44286048412323,
-0.023472631350159645,
-0.259636253118515,
-0.5239236950874329,
0.7172417640686035,
0.7916227579116821,
-0.11304658651351929,
0.6819036602973938,
0.048816826194524765,
0.04491109400987625,
-0.3886868357658386,
0.15363246202468872,
0.7562771439552307,
-0.9140941500663757,
-0.8555907607078552,
-0.7042135000228882,
0.5293536186218262,
-0.1158713847398758,
-0.5072884559631348,
0.7294510006904602,
0.8364571928977966,
0.5564802885055542,
0.24453258514404297,
0.567485511302948,
-0.2807680070400238,
0.5724974870681763,
-0.2566421627998352,
1.2527626752853394,
-0.8435356020927429,
0.44487234950065613,
-0.4497007429599762,
-0.8743031620979309,
-0.2605740427970886,
0.0652119517326355,
-0.06592702865600586,
0.13246269524097443,
0.8878182768821716,
0.5521146655082703,
-0.13030974566936493,
-0.046560727059841156,
0.14500656723976135,
0.5962167978286743,
0.5121490955352783,
0.12164392322301865,
0.5885072350502014,
-0.21472987532615662,
0.6117426156997681,
-0.3818349838256836,
-0.6663795709609985,
-0.1836109161376953,
-1.1565711498260498,
-0.8601464033126831,
-1.0204583406448364,
-0.7844521999359131,
-0.5077589750289917,
0.040078070014715195,
0.6392005681991577,
0.2912839949131012,
-0.8558517694473267,
-0.02372201904654503,
-0.001520815072581172,
-0.02773286961019039,
-0.5273473858833313,
-0.20194467902183533,
0.4336276650428772,
0.03815259411931038,
-0.7432653903961182,
0.4339428246021271,
0.6038773059844971,
0.41321200132369995,
-0.011054834350943565,
0.5220916867256165,
0.251028448343277,
0.031131254509091377,
0.5774821639060974,
0.04397846758365631,
-0.43186357617378235,
-0.010082488879561424,
-0.2194133847951889,
-0.14295700192451477,
-0.005276429932564497,
0.7079380750656128,
-0.48756495118141174,
0.23462755978107452,
0.5593277215957642,
0.4167104661464691,
0.47947150468826294,
0.1801033467054367,
0.5108945369720459,
-0.5617325305938721,
0.17741759121418,
0.3117952346801758,
0.01510899979621172,
0.17685715854167938,
-0.26573410630226135,
-0.03478920832276344,
0.4695160388946533,
-0.5834997296333313,
-1.2197630405426025,
-0.020646821707487106,
-1.3231115341186523,
-0.5238473415374756,
0.9934536218643188,
0.10382117331027985,
-0.042648304253816605,
-0.3217974007129669,
0.04392236843705177,
0.11416410654783249,
-0.47125667333602905,
1.3419510126113892,
0.541155219078064,
-0.1326816976070404,
0.2933458685874939,
-0.040951646864414215,
0.5847436785697937,
0.3901115953922272,
-0.9404618740081787,
0.6050437688827515,
0.6831989288330078,
0.17014364898204803,
-0.24440763890743256,
0.8147587180137634,
0.023410076275467873,
0.02463560551404953,
0.2042209953069687,
-0.17691214382648468,
-0.23093758523464203,
-0.31770753860473633,
-0.2505543828010559,
0.5788918137550354,
-0.1728830188512802,
0.041726380586624146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10553v1 | A novel integrated industrial approach with cobots in the age of industry 4.0 through conversational interaction and computer vision | 2024-02-16T10:35:01 | 2024-02-16T10:35:01 | Andrea Pazienza, Nicola Macchiarulo, Felice Vitulano, Antonio Fiorentini, Marco Cammisa, Leonardo Rigutini, Ernesto Di Iorio, Achille Globo, Antonio Trevisi | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | From robots that replace workers to robots that serve as helpful colleagues,
the field of robotic automation is experiencing a new trend that represents a
huge challenge for component manufacturers. The contribution starts from an
innovative vision that sees an ever closer collaboration between Cobot, able to
do a specific physical job with precision, the AI world, able to analyze
information and support the decision-making process, and the man able to have a
strategic vision of the future. | [
-0.6218111515045166,
-0.6087705492973328,
0.835135817527771,
-0.07382849603891373,
-0.04972109571099281,
0.41273537278175354,
0.5043987035751343,
-0.9499284029006958,
0.37738722562789917,
0.5443738102912903,
-1.1854350566864014,
-0.2210153043270111,
-0.13548196852207184,
0.05153404548764229,
-0.24521073698997498,
0.48701706528663635,
-0.07258284091949463,
-0.4134354293346405,
-0.37417054176330566,
0.017389293760061264,
-0.8791682720184326,
-0.6606144905090332,
-0.5563552975654602,
-0.4672958552837372,
0.21351489424705505,
0.38732272386550903,
0.7119515538215637,
0.25280845165252686,
0.9845494031906128,
0.5470402240753174,
0.5106409788131714,
0.05803966894745827,
-0.06325384229421616,
-0.004607025068253279,
-0.3557298183441162,
-0.49109822511672974,
-0.8371394872665405,
0.18127915263175964,
-0.15627683699131012,
0.874055027961731,
0.16637398302555084,
0.0019377871649339795,
-0.031962569802999496,
0.3866175413131714,
-0.2566128075122833,
0.5259382724761963,
-0.4537271559238434,
0.39424359798431396,
0.1182289570569992,
-0.5444368124008179,
-0.12841597199440002,
-0.19199822843074799,
-0.012177767232060432,
-0.783911943435669,
0.17415402829647064,
0.12234554439783096,
1.0104048252105713,
0.4622995853424072,
-0.14530450105667114,
0.02573338896036148,
-1.1587656736373901,
0.7030777931213379,
-0.35266199707984924,
0.27281245589256287,
-0.09914922714233398,
0.8205673694610596,
-0.39909374713897705,
-1.0539536476135254,
-0.7057836055755615,
0.28743699193000793,
0.25629922747612,
0.5448101162910461,
-0.22708046436309814,
0.2946626842021942,
-0.19758014380931854,
0.27893033623695374,
-0.10407382249832153,
0.32370615005493164,
-0.6667978763580322,
-0.39695820212364197,
0.706417441368103,
0.3232344686985016,
0.3037807047367096,
0.1705746352672577,
-0.7783846259117126,
0.009995699860155582,
-0.13188189268112183,
-0.14056558907032013,
0.5147348642349243,
0.11757795512676239,
-0.1637222319841385,
0.21094295382499695,
-0.6132514476776123,
0.5446921586990356,
0.187192901968956,
0.09694340080022812,
0.6502258777618408,
-0.6916117072105408,
-0.28078213334083557,
-0.07371065765619278,
0.823180615901947,
0.7070777416229248,
-0.22772236168384552,
0.03271864727139473,
0.08561264723539352,
0.32338976860046387,
0.5218260288238525,
-0.09295075386762619,
-0.3116123080253601,
0.4512771666049957,
-0.19897279143333435,
-0.1756696254014969,
0.21034088730812073,
-0.8075205087661743,
-0.1790304034948349,
-0.6101622581481934,
0.5031480193138123,
0.22796131670475006,
-0.1013902798295021,
0.20324839651584625,
-0.6032818555831909,
0.6026989221572876,
0.8758531808853149,
-0.7243729829788208,
0.042683690786361694,
0.9219769239425659,
0.7855152487754822,
-0.011796612292528152,
-0.003483033971861005,
-0.23754377663135529,
0.48286667466163635,
-0.5108568668365479,
0.8317466974258423,
-0.24671369791030884,
-0.2682889401912689,
-0.25362178683280945,
0.2463558167219162,
0.36007317900657654,
-0.6467390656471252,
0.07447842508554459,
-0.5028748512268066,
0.4152924120426178,
0.26485785841941833,
0.18467237055301666,
-0.5640851259231567,
0.5760701894760132,
-0.8460778594017029,
0.5467754006385803,
0.19305755198001862,
-0.2884264290332794,
0.4467501640319824,
-0.9161702990531921,
-0.19834455847740173,
0.6140375137329102,
-0.8235279321670532,
-0.46068131923675537,
-0.3707486391067505,
-0.2387833148241043,
0.5525902509689331,
0.06607662886381149,
0.08684178441762924,
-0.6126752495765686,
0.145229309797287,
0.17250633239746094,
-0.29657289385795593,
0.7038796544075012,
0.10023960471153259,
-0.4277123808860779,
0.35703352093696594,
-0.5646002292633057,
-0.18377043306827545,
-0.20753508806228638,
0.24817940592765808,
0.06776481121778488,
-0.22586309909820557,
-0.24905161559581757,
0.6014909148216248,
0.8749263882637024,
-0.6068533062934875,
0.014702852815389633,
-0.5383086800575256,
0.3846484422683716,
0.8436252474784851,
0.3469938039779663,
0.6570324897766113,
-0.3291730284690857,
0.7427909970283508,
-0.07841350883245468,
0.675279438495636,
-0.24456074833869934,
-0.47219476103782654,
-1.0304806232452393,
-0.21126143634319305,
-0.5061861276626587,
0.4148947596549988,
-0.9700413346290588,
0.6922814846038818,
0.14643292129039764,
-0.4251044690608978,
-0.2939351499080658,
-0.12757360935211182,
-0.08874023705720901,
0.5642342567443848,
0.19533473253250122,
-0.9834035038948059,
-0.5956131219863892,
-1.0741981267929077,
0.20522738993167877,
-0.054259903728961945,
-0.2142823189496994,
0.19429846107959747,
0.313850998878479,
-0.44635018706321716,
0.9323110580444336,
-0.37612396478652954,
-0.589298665523529,
-0.34447821974754333,
0.16594642400741577,
0.7461208701133728,
0.5007345080375671,
0.12967725098133087,
-0.9735860824584961,
-0.3219660520553589,
0.6236838102340698,
-1.1692612171173096,
0.3646407127380371,
-0.10428968071937561,
-0.18805758655071259,
0.30036434531211853,
0.955868661403656,
-0.5269334316253662,
0.6107896566390991,
0.3899371922016144,
0.06966841965913773,
0.32650619745254517,
-0.2522207498550415,
0.17564637959003448,
-1.082509994506836,
0.0931190475821495,
-0.03891925886273384,
-0.1381656676530838,
-0.7808727025985718,
-0.035681456327438354,
-0.7052470445632935,
-0.22212567925453186,
-0.5729683041572571,
0.10062863677740097,
-0.3320837914943695,
-0.4102003872394562,
-0.17391754686832428,
0.2701887786388397,
0.2971721589565277,
0.6170520186424255,
-0.09164638817310333,
0.5151551365852356,
0.05498648062348366,
-0.6903718113899231,
1.035554051399231,
0.5485733151435852,
-0.28364038467407227,
0.7367652058601379,
-0.5491930246353149,
0.27241331338882446,
0.21802474558353424,
0.4500843286514282,
-0.8041074872016907,
-0.4603715240955353,
0.6351248621940613,
-0.6010246276855469,
-0.2204524129629135,
0.7542096376419067,
-0.42841073870658875,
-0.8477494716644287,
-0.24118487536907196,
0.2589225172996521,
0.17655257880687714,
-0.25541797280311584,
0.9935856461524963,
0.5575388669967651,
-0.4853913187980652,
-0.29121771454811096,
-0.7932394742965698,
0.3361826241016388,
-0.16290883719921112,
-0.6989453434944153,
0.4707205593585968,
-0.0518479198217392,
-0.41673120856285095,
-0.24986234307289124,
-0.12991832196712494,
-0.31180906295776367,
0.10457857698202133,
-0.008777693845331669,
0.6976526379585266,
0.21364568173885345,
-0.22967210412025452,
-0.1115204468369484,
-0.6285502910614014,
0.33731845021247864,
0.013212967664003372,
0.8109331727027893,
0.12002378702163696,
-0.4114726185798645,
-1.4894111156463623,
0.30681416392326355,
0.7091751098632812,
-0.044162899255752563,
0.11127021163702011,
0.20476584136486053,
-0.3433466851711273,
0.007053948473185301,
-0.1723962128162384,
-0.36146947741508484,
-0.6821175217628479,
0.534407913684845,
-0.38023316860198975,
-0.42141416668891907,
0.4070304334163666,
-0.440926730632782,
0.06684613227844238,
0.5213353633880615,
0.7565833926200867,
-0.4373362958431244,
0.853989839553833,
0.9715321660041809,
0.11273494362831116,
0.3136065900325775,
-0.426881343126297,
0.7895134091377258,
-0.4926782548427582,
-1.065170407295227,
-0.4847797453403473,
-0.5110002160072327,
-0.6950302720069885,
-0.3089006543159485,
0.6222843527793884,
-0.46589648723602295,
-0.43822216987609863,
0.47109904885292053,
-0.6846530437469482,
0.040490660816431046,
0.9803699254989624,
0.27433669567108154,
0.5352612137794495,
-0.678533136844635,
0.3673290014266968,
0.24105484783649445,
-0.7648892402648926,
-0.5626243352890015,
0.18650555610656738,
0.41483569145202637,
0.3491530120372772,
-0.17550265789031982,
0.3635724186897278,
0.44731906056404114,
-0.3846750855445862,
-1.059197187423706,
0.8363624215126038,
0.33699697256088257,
-0.7795315384864807,
-0.2366551011800766,
0.19947469234466553,
-0.9680923223495483,
-0.32725122570991516,
-0.017830733209848404,
-0.5313482284545898,
0.5144577622413635,
0.3715614378452301,
-0.47995898127555847,
0.20477937161922455,
-0.7752426266670227,
1.1010183095932007,
-0.47120699286460876,
-0.2080155909061432,
-0.48173001408576965,
-0.9973084926605225,
-0.0017866012640297413,
-0.14745689928531647,
0.4930794835090637,
-0.3185746371746063,
-0.08752680569887161,
0.5676254034042358,
-0.4499453604221344,
0.9676355123519897,
0.016491428017616272,
-0.04066711664199829,
0.38607487082481384,
-0.2914769649505615,
0.16545042395591736,
-0.5687932372093201,
-0.01846528798341751,
0.6002166271209717,
-0.28620702028274536,
-0.11651599407196045,
-0.6008375287055969,
0.13640649616718292,
-0.6096369028091431,
-0.4526826739311218,
-0.8370203971862793,
-0.7070044875144958,
-0.2412092238664627,
0.32820627093315125,
0.18412117660045624,
0.07481706142425537,
-0.2632702589035034,
0.20958483219146729,
-0.025739531964063644,
-0.4734676778316498,
0.7849774360656738,
-0.029442215338349342,
0.1905030757188797,
-0.2665597200393677,
0.6856334805488586,
-0.15288253128528595,
0.3613487482070923,
0.5959730744361877,
-0.2454661726951599,
0.035052426159381866,
-0.06740761548280716,
-0.37432047724723816,
-0.355535626411438,
-0.7009907960891724,
-0.34668266773223877,
-0.49221429228782654,
-0.273576945066452,
-0.08367867767810822,
-0.6896435022354126,
-0.34428074955940247,
-0.24958789348602295,
-0.35919445753097534,
0.1002388447523117,
0.24572573602199554,
0.923089325428009,
0.10087592154741287,
0.34945032000541687,
-0.6025800108909607,
0.09739832580089569,
0.47271624207496643,
0.25759026408195496,
-0.19053982198238373,
0.14392460882663727,
-0.41430580615997314,
-0.03921058773994446,
-0.6232163906097412,
-0.23152050375938416,
0.45743706822395325,
-0.18584756553173065,
0.6234970092773438,
0.43887585401535034,
0.050413668155670166,
0.3941326439380646,
-0.504747211933136,
0.9061456918716431,
0.7633095979690552,
-0.9409104585647583,
0.36906981468200684,
-0.5498830676078796,
0.32397204637527466,
0.3003884553909302,
0.4093017280101776,
-0.42699968814849854,
-0.3068506717681885,
-0.8046504855155945,
-1.0182725191116333,
0.59175044298172,
-0.15314260125160217,
0.06181295961141586,
0.4942842423915863,
-0.12938714027404785,
0.35348647832870483,
0.378873735666275,
-0.3858395516872406,
0.06142611801624298,
0.002259620698168874,
-0.4859602153301239,
0.03506891429424286,
0.3642805218696594,
-0.1643534153699875,
-0.0202969778329134,
0.29769977927207947,
-0.11630883812904358,
0.8875839114189148,
-0.2192918062210083,
0.6195173859596252,
-0.05127458646893501,
0.003048586891964078,
0.1395452618598938,
0.5786777138710022,
-0.09670528024435043,
-0.04440683126449585,
0.0676262229681015,
-0.3318479359149933,
0.013782838359475136,
-0.32352447509765625,
0.32873764634132385,
-0.2824765145778656,
0.2641246020793915,
0.4341637194156647,
-0.09726739674806595,
-0.29242047667503357,
0.36871662735939026,
0.3801756203174591,
-0.35040387511253357,
-0.7722231149673462,
0.27062880992889404,
-0.20642833411693573,
0.7909017205238342,
0.5101298689842224,
0.551363468170166,
0.40604355931282043,
-0.8864908814430237,
0.4563414454460144,
0.41875678300857544,
-0.68107008934021,
-0.6838193535804749,
1.0199593305587769,
0.7832716703414917,
-0.688667356967926,
0.11547085642814636,
-0.13853807747364044,
-0.672655463218689,
0.954585611820221,
0.19848106801509857,
0.8105691075325012,
-0.0037538085598498583,
0.04759020730853081,
0.11237175762653351,
0.22273240983486176,
0.1436249315738678,
0.19158542156219482,
0.10373912006616592,
-0.8632055521011353,
-0.4269040822982788,
-0.0488516204059124,
-1.1894668340682983,
-0.023183323442935944,
-0.270027756690979,
0.6540008783340454,
-0.729874312877655,
0.12800878286361694,
0.09988377243280411,
-0.12223293632268906,
-0.7794520854949951,
0.672640860080719,
-0.1138598620891571,
0.11197184771299362,
-0.7465121746063232,
0.42621225118637085,
0.4037477374076843,
-0.6872372627258301,
-0.2669004797935486,
-0.16140225529670715,
-0.0971384048461914,
-0.9798781871795654,
0.826840341091156,
0.40193232893943787,
-0.4586030840873718,
0.03399505466222763,
-0.6794359683990479,
-0.5615677237510681,
1.142047643661499,
0.042785804718732834,
-0.6938057541847229,
-0.03179021179676056,
0.19518180191516876,
0.3833996057510376,
-0.3005490005016327,
-0.07990072667598724,
0.25585320591926575,
0.44186922907829285,
0.15887776017189026,
-0.9085975885391235,
-0.13825346529483795,
-0.23752976953983307,
-0.17681199312210083,
0.280224084854126,
-1.0725407600402832,
0.5932087302207947,
0.3351503014564514,
-0.0672602429986,
-0.035527877509593964,
0.8710658550262451,
-0.049251917749643326,
0.9629889130592346,
0.47125712037086487,
0.2272263616323471,
0.5071687698364258,
0.03583170101046562,
0.6104080080986023,
-0.24750980734825134,
-0.06846075505018234,
0.8900711536407471,
-0.2028941959142685,
0.5639886856079102,
0.39378464221954346,
-0.21269485354423523,
0.922564685344696,
0.34463611245155334,
-0.15984712541103363,
0.476318895816803,
-0.4350634515285492,
-0.5477792024612427,
0.04307923465967178,
-0.14187271893024445,
-0.09408015012741089,
1.0222671031951904,
0.30212265253067017,
0.19869691133499146,
0.4242766499519348,
0.2430805265903473,
-0.21548990905284882,
0.2576441764831543,
-0.3669494092464447,
0.8140058517456055,
-0.16142241656780243,
-0.3225705027580261,
-0.15054543316364288,
-0.4368951618671417,
0.6007833480834961,
-0.1262488216161728,
-0.4136865437030792,
0.1359819918870926,
0.466116338968277,
-0.19947554171085358,
-0.7807109951972961,
0.6941738724708557,
-0.5676507949829102,
-0.018449800089001656,
-0.3617711365222931,
0.6756761074066162,
0.11643382161855698,
-0.32090815901756287,
0.2080540955066681,
0.2975134551525116,
0.26413586735725403,
0.2157374769449234,
-0.36150091886520386,
0.17651140689849854,
0.0351056344807148,
0.43312692642211914,
-0.14139407873153687,
0.5934060215950012,
-0.07769079506397247,
0.6706023812294006,
0.16047576069831848,
-0.5015074014663696,
-0.38484567403793335,
-0.28087401390075684,
0.6675413846969604,
-0.9016216397285461,
-0.45621567964553833,
-0.43616530299186707,
0.7145771980285645,
-0.36867162585258484,
0.031305957585573196,
0.8639808297157288,
0.5298831462860107,
1.245063304901123,
0.02453293278813362,
1.1934363842010498,
-0.18578539788722992,
0.38522475957870483,
-0.1267170011997223,
0.3910692036151886,
-0.6158021688461304,
-0.13185693323612213,
-0.4635094702243805,
-0.5776982307434082,
-0.5380241870880127,
0.6615982055664062,
-0.23321717977523804,
0.2654586136341095,
0.5377760529518127,
0.5681702494621277,
0.02368914522230625,
-0.1484997421503067,
0.48954299092292786,
0.04543246328830719,
0.603839635848999,
0.34934496879577637,
0.6621591448783875,
-0.45670342445373535,
0.46110206842422485,
-0.12022331357002258,
-0.47205936908721924,
-0.490664005279541,
-0.8661983609199524,
-0.308310329914093,
-0.6698510050773621,
-0.18189667165279388,
0.012774967588484287,
-0.3153386116027832,
0.8492752909660339,
0.6103430390357971,
-0.6751098036766052,
-0.4221152663230896,
-0.5414941310882568,
-0.38300198316574097,
-0.42704638838768005,
-0.18015025556087494,
-0.1256200224161148,
-0.22561071813106537,
-1.0829988718032837,
0.27445846796035767,
0.9546585083007812,
-0.21949847042560577,
-0.5883538126945496,
0.11693645268678665,
-0.22020003199577332,
0.16995827853679657,
0.7003578543663025,
0.22863447666168213,
-0.3522695004940033,
-0.5432599782943726,
0.04251350462436676,
0.27674639225006104,
0.36437490582466125,
0.11991383135318756,
-0.7591181397438049,
0.7660757303237915,
0.46441659331321716,
0.6338426470756531,
0.3814486861228943,
-0.026551945134997368,
1.1343883275985718,
-0.4231211543083191,
0.5455383062362671,
0.34697723388671875,
0.08147821575403214,
0.4479556381702423,
-0.3861719071865082,
0.5869978070259094,
0.45174527168273926,
-0.6890317797660828,
-0.29477035999298096,
0.629185140132904,
-1.3366440534591675,
0.016998276114463806,
0.3236747682094574,
0.2519278824329376,
-0.3121374845504761,
-0.6331924796104431,
-0.2714375853538513,
0.6387868523597717,
-0.3088875412940979,
0.8606517910957336,
0.36110275983810425,
-0.5662601590156555,
0.056860025972127914,
-0.6510006189346313,
-0.057889096438884735,
0.1517740935087204,
-1.192246437072754,
-0.5986546874046326,
0.6087968349456787,
-0.5739423632621765,
0.5761403441429138,
0.5412073731422424,
-0.0446099191904068,
0.18773484230041504,
0.39481160044670105,
0.7172057628631592,
0.34452924132347107,
-0.5348516702651978,
-0.1313815414905548,
0.07022928446531296,
0.0941576287150383,
-0.7898852229118347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10552v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10552v3 | Conversational SimulMT: Efficient Simultaneous Translation with Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T10:32:16 | 2024-06-21T07:18:13 | Minghan Wang, Thuy-Trang Vu, Yuxia Wang, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous machine translation (SimulMT) presents a challenging trade-off
between translation quality and latency. Recent studies have shown that LLMs
can achieve good performance in SimulMT tasks. However, this often comes at the
expense of high inference cost and latency. In this paper, we propose a
conversational SimulMT framework to enhance the inference efficiency of
LLM-based SimulMT through multi-turn-dialogue-based decoding. Our experiments
with Llama2-7b-chat on two SimulMT benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of
LLM in translation quality while achieving comparable computational latency to
specialized SimulMT models. | [
-0.08513126522302628,
-0.7753386497497559,
0.6087294220924377,
0.6647672653198242,
-0.6882193684577942,
0.4882641136646271,
-0.18424925208091736,
-0.401751846075058,
0.1947992742061615,
0.7478684782981873,
-0.5569016933441162,
-0.405947744846344,
-0.5340726971626282,
0.13127997517585754,
-0.30809274315834045,
0.5038601756095886,
0.10948622226715088,
0.43656599521636963,
-0.30917006731033325,
-0.040669385343790054,
-0.3879733979701996,
-0.6995777487754822,
-0.6929709911346436,
-0.367402583360672,
0.3218870460987091,
0.2957845628261566,
0.930310070514679,
0.514960765838623,
0.45396432280540466,
0.28587013483047485,
-0.052414171397686005,
0.6145783066749573,
-0.5784448385238647,
0.23412330448627472,
0.41022178530693054,
-0.7708625197410583,
-0.5641264915466309,
-0.3412317931652069,
0.5962835550308228,
0.7378743290901184,
-0.15195110440254211,
-0.2265838086605072,
-0.052022285759449005,
0.45117446780204773,
-0.157157763838768,
0.3991195261478424,
-0.4545428156852722,
-0.21403980255126953,
-0.08501071482896805,
-0.4697221517562866,
-0.7032228112220764,
-0.5257074236869812,
-0.3079321086406708,
-0.4084773659706116,
0.05975843966007233,
0.31278324127197266,
0.5151361227035522,
0.5602055788040161,
-0.48610252141952515,
-0.1000300794839859,
-0.7329300045967102,
0.9209398627281189,
-0.9796189069747925,
0.560698926448822,
0.12089360505342484,
0.4191141724586487,
-0.5239105820655823,
-0.6513542532920837,
-0.5274028182029724,
-0.20048311352729797,
-0.10240781307220459,
0.34394773840904236,
-0.07176341861486435,
0.2351728230714798,
0.09900416433811188,
0.48278480768203735,
-0.5254772305488586,
-0.0990619882941246,
0.06081554666161537,
-0.023092105984687805,
0.474091500043869,
0.3924179971218109,
0.12368524074554443,
-0.02104458585381508,
-0.3530154824256897,
-0.11073014885187149,
-0.5173887610435486,
-0.20746973156929016,
0.44855913519859314,
0.2535914480686188,
-0.17753542959690094,
0.6024280190467834,
-0.2610067129135132,
0.3612214922904968,
-0.23053640127182007,
-0.4232942461967468,
0.28075018525123596,
-0.5140471458435059,
-0.11567189544439316,
0.0062486594542860985,
0.8059365749359131,
0.4481012225151062,
-0.09141061455011368,
-0.3168034851551056,
-0.029479438439011574,
-0.0011668787337839603,
0.11964830756187439,
-1.0356059074401855,
0.01827402226626873,
0.4247722625732422,
-0.38222602009773254,
-0.050122469663619995,
-0.04290730878710747,
-0.6508662700653076,
-0.07135991752147675,
-0.14580725133419037,
0.019240159541368484,
-0.5523721575737,
-0.26289102435112,
0.4470326006412506,
0.1305994838476181,
0.22528527677059174,
0.7055969834327698,
-0.4600067734718323,
0.3860528767108917,
0.5905157327651978,
1.0502634048461914,
-0.47722935676574707,
-0.0799492746591568,
-0.6477025151252747,
0.2635727822780609,
-0.273292601108551,
0.6938176155090332,
-0.4071078598499298,
-0.595198929309845,
-0.2406916469335556,
-0.35559454560279846,
-0.29730525612831116,
-0.5416996479034424,
0.4775291383266449,
-0.4301087260246277,
-0.09729152917861938,
0.020356858149170876,
-0.43128344416618347,
-0.26700735092163086,
0.16724413633346558,
-0.5917609333992004,
0.9420132637023926,
-0.303634911775589,
-0.6153514385223389,
-0.2186969816684723,
-0.5307906270027161,
-0.6699823141098022,
0.1425732523202896,
-0.09260100871324539,
-0.3322676122188568,
0.28112322092056274,
0.43296724557876587,
0.38992905616760254,
-0.5828083157539368,
0.44693687558174133,
-0.236016646027565,
-0.5440643429756165,
0.6790720224380493,
-0.8621568083763123,
0.5069385766983032,
0.44948136806488037,
0.0053892722353339195,
-0.08462898433208466,
-0.5906188488006592,
0.0425012931227684,
0.14272066950798035,
-0.504921555519104,
0.14792752265930176,
0.034756921231746674,
0.0599578358232975,
0.1855974793434143,
0.10577722638845444,
-0.3608660399913788,
0.286773681640625,
-0.4810847043991089,
0.17803214490413666,
0.2907910943031311,
-0.03092113509774208,
0.183476060628891,
-0.4814547598361969,
0.5110391974449158,
0.40479904413223267,
-0.09171903878450394,
-0.32926440238952637,
-0.6015706062316895,
-1.1689411401748657,
-0.5738770961761475,
0.18944036960601807,
0.686826765537262,
-1.1028797626495361,
0.005518670193850994,
-0.3790641725063324,
-0.378211110830307,
-0.870690107345581,
0.09696948528289795,
0.3862103819847107,
-0.057661958038806915,
0.5185480713844299,
-0.2657029628753662,
-0.38047024607658386,
-0.717331051826477,
-0.37417852878570557,
-0.1648261398077011,
0.1372147798538208,
0.5440422892570496,
0.005638114642351866,
-0.22855502367019653,
0.5917654633522034,
-0.38258519768714905,
0.02575927972793579,
-0.5814869403839111,
0.3547053337097168,
0.3960784077644348,
0.4179134964942932,
0.18689681589603424,
-0.725740909576416,
-0.33640196919441223,
0.05524571239948273,
-0.7192308306694031,
-0.37838003039360046,
-0.44732365012168884,
-0.28226718306541443,
0.12707531452178955,
0.6714121699333191,
-0.6837936043739319,
0.35986506938934326,
0.7409264445304871,
0.14166004955768585,
0.38012099266052246,
-0.20204703509807587,
0.379646360874176,
-1.2860451936721802,
-0.1315491795539856,
-0.5766019821166992,
-0.5554456114768982,
-0.7188801765441895,
-0.1888585239648819,
-0.01865288056433201,
0.26398420333862305,
-0.6332880854606628,
0.30293768644332886,
-0.4987430274486542,
-0.27374595403671265,
-0.14136464893817902,
0.004099099896848202,
-0.01348301861435175,
0.6401230692863464,
0.11284000426530838,
1.1931253671646118,
0.03987739980220795,
-0.5103127360343933,
0.22782669961452484,
0.3170422613620758,
-0.08361716568470001,
0.5854292511940002,
-0.5369812250137329,
0.18712648749351501,
0.22465263307094574,
0.5299723744392395,
-1.095293402671814,
-0.36084356904029846,
0.1388462632894516,
-0.33714234828948975,
0.2751273214817047,
-0.23543322086334229,
-0.7591979503631592,
-0.11430045962333679,
-0.09582728147506714,
0.5726003050804138,
0.5338202714920044,
-0.6431776285171509,
0.7047596573829651,
-0.004598229192197323,
-0.2516076862812042,
-0.4130554795265198,
-0.829099714756012,
0.4311506748199463,
-0.09286878257989883,
-0.836346447467804,
0.1245584785938263,
-0.16591480374336243,
-0.038303475826978683,
-0.5029140710830688,
-0.03119020164012909,
0.08200693875551224,
0.03449404239654541,
0.49339959025382996,
-0.06387432664632797,
-0.23451736569404602,
-0.1531105637550354,
0.3783891499042511,
-0.2653963565826416,
-0.01685546524822712,
-0.15085355937480927,
0.8032980561256409,
-0.18657825887203217,
-0.7703417539596558,
-0.5414445996284485,
0.578991174697876,
0.7272002100944519,
0.08192557096481323,
0.8205713033676147,
0.5009894967079163,
0.0992332473397255,
-0.08492042869329453,
-0.8653472661972046,
-0.1356649398803711,
-0.4368041157722473,
0.2542255222797394,
-0.6327707767486572,
-0.8115279674530029,
0.4291890859603882,
-0.5813387632369995,
-0.11548931151628494,
0.0022308137267827988,
0.8540038466453552,
-0.12218202650547028,
1.1898716688156128,
0.2658001482486725,
0.4062940776348114,
0.32584303617477417,
-0.04996047914028168,
0.27577781677246094,
-0.7561400532722473,
-0.27265509963035583,
-0.34805575013160706,
0.03571009635925293,
-0.4556889533996582,
-0.9253654479980469,
0.3446684777736664,
0.2213371992111206,
0.09795286506414413,
0.19530339539051056,
0.13557885587215424,
0.30023640394210815,
0.6180599331855774,
0.27481377124786377,
0.8439733386039734,
0.16990789771080017,
-0.288541316986084,
-0.08341219276189804,
-0.8301228284835815,
-0.6014546155929565,
0.6860636472702026,
0.34450793266296387,
0.9494645595550537,
0.37309783697128296,
0.620220959186554,
-0.07218511402606964,
0.18463410437107086,
-0.7876123189926147,
0.6489346623420715,
-0.010304157622158527,
-0.3572153151035309,
0.08901636302471161,
-0.6673767566680908,
-0.733146071434021,
0.5696439146995544,
-0.023825427517294884,
-0.47541600465774536,
-0.2227775901556015,
0.133738711476326,
0.05849222093820572,
0.25342994928359985,
-0.5469045042991638,
0.5525339841842651,
-0.38886475563049316,
-0.3634818196296692,
-0.3904952108860016,
-0.6481149792671204,
0.48186996579170227,
-0.14603078365325928,
0.14366236329078674,
-0.3661380708217621,
0.013704243116080761,
0.3579958379268646,
-0.3924300968647003,
0.7736217975616455,
0.20407924056053162,
0.05593792349100113,
-0.03287447243928909,
0.2692277431488037,
0.4229027330875397,
0.2343839854001999,
-0.13781806826591492,
0.42805349826812744,
0.04368944838643074,
-0.44980522990226746,
-0.5557554364204407,
0.45957931876182556,
-0.8018569946289062,
-0.5817407965660095,
-0.38029974699020386,
-0.9998038411140442,
-0.35377827286720276,
0.049112945795059204,
0.18802115321159363,
0.22770078480243683,
-0.27947691082954407,
0.1448518931865692,
0.4918244481086731,
-0.2870255410671234,
0.30351492762565613,
0.3469002842903137,
-0.42599546909332275,
-0.4779663681983948,
0.7800248861312866,
-0.1739814430475235,
0.6585937738418579,
0.4549924433231354,
-0.12777584791183472,
-0.3717842996120453,
-0.6900240182876587,
-0.7281347513198853,
0.4759596884250641,
-0.6554913520812988,
-0.32153451442718506,
-1.03557288646698,
-0.1749931275844574,
-0.20259013772010803,
-0.03742280229926109,
-0.6915684938430786,
-0.3872624635696411,
-0.19167673587799072,
0.2952907979488373,
0.28247135877609253,
0.5765005350112915,
0.05243866518139839,
0.8116280436515808,
-0.8434205055236816,
0.49830010533332825,
0.0841025859117508,
0.06588393449783325,
-0.23236405849456787,
-0.4881322979927063,
-0.11704778671264648,
0.20785222947597504,
-0.05124887079000473,
-0.7357210516929626,
0.5795325040817261,
-0.09803832322359085,
0.46799686551094055,
0.17819124460220337,
0.08818484842777252,
0.8270291090011597,
-0.44575053453445435,
0.6122421026229858,
0.37151381373405457,
-0.9857037663459778,
0.15384799242019653,
-0.17649994790554047,
0.5623665452003479,
0.44426649808883667,
0.04968305677175522,
-0.6703653931617737,
-0.5256683230400085,
-0.3247148096561432,
-0.7048253417015076,
0.9747675657272339,
0.6580449342727661,
0.1605147123336792,
-0.016208309680223465,
0.1521446257829666,
0.17794102430343628,
0.3201504647731781,
-0.4167065918445587,
-0.32528701424598694,
-0.08062786608934402,
-0.28484073281288147,
0.038333818316459656,
-0.49336516857147217,
0.015574241057038307,
-0.031744737178087234,
0.7330000996589661,
-0.31174159049987793,
0.4372994005680084,
-0.059017058461904526,
-0.306219220161438,
0.2114015370607376,
0.40272554755210876,
0.44086918234825134,
0.2593717873096466,
-0.22295436263084412,
0.28340277075767517,
0.5052496194839478,
-0.4284047782421112,
0.3222077190876007,
0.040985219180583954,
-0.05352785065770149,
0.1394294649362564,
0.2857576906681061,
1.022063136100769,
0.39789631962776184,
-0.48313337564468384,
0.48384103178977966,
-0.3546462953090668,
0.017957009375095367,
0.12009337544441223,
0.18928369879722595,
0.48333796858787537,
0.4632924497127533,
0.20969054102897644,
-0.048834580928087234,
0.13353665173053741,
-0.14045748114585876,
-0.09235098958015442,
0.2818688154220581,
-0.03698866441845894,
-0.05466168746352196,
0.6077550053596497,
0.28976181149482727,
-0.39235758781433105,
0.5193494558334351,
-0.042916636914014816,
-0.5272979140281677,
0.341106116771698,
0.7129063606262207,
0.732202410697937,
-0.2629110515117645,
0.08498203754425049,
0.13351574540138245,
0.12429167330265045,
-0.2941710352897644,
0.3050532341003418,
-0.1244397833943367,
-0.5291011333465576,
-0.7503426671028137,
-0.7449427247047424,
-0.9335521459579468,
-0.113113634288311,
-0.6025065779685974,
0.14879310131072998,
-0.018967725336551666,
0.0023487317375838757,
-0.3998650908470154,
-0.26372161507606506,
-0.46181347966194153,
-0.04910264536738396,
0.036402422934770584,
0.6440386772155762,
-0.4209561049938202,
0.962832510471344,
0.35038208961486816,
-0.1091097891330719,
-0.5073989033699036,
-0.026092061772942543,
-0.14203380048274994,
-0.7126001119613647,
0.38097459077835083,
0.31047093868255615,
-0.715701699256897,
0.21830444037914276,
-0.4395391345024109,
-0.6573548316955566,
1.0771862268447876,
0.799178957939148,
-0.6648951172828674,
0.20398195087909698,
0.7198259830474854,
0.3299264907836914,
-0.39444467425346375,
0.4428887963294983,
0.7756767272949219,
0.3344903886318207,
0.6016666889190674,
-0.8794612884521484,
-0.09878462553024292,
-0.10408561676740646,
0.1484486311674118,
0.061105817556381226,
-0.7570309042930603,
0.5345430970191956,
-0.1256025731563568,
-0.40773260593414307,
0.2110356241464615,
0.7608287930488586,
0.19519862532615662,
0.2377549260854721,
0.29942581057548523,
0.28156381845474243,
0.46664702892303467,
-0.16988809406757355,
1.1591874361038208,
-0.21077460050582886,
0.24311482906341553,
1.163881778717041,
-0.0960666760802269,
0.8907167315483093,
0.7290365099906921,
-0.269503653049469,
0.04490669444203377,
0.4350357949733734,
0.4464408755302429,
0.3798693120479584,
0.0720323994755745,
-0.44816672801971436,
-0.7706979513168335,
-0.1905583292245865,
-0.385557621717453,
0.3459523022174835,
0.5002431273460388,
0.000788906414527446,
-0.08031413704156876,
-0.18698996305465698,
0.21654364466667175,
-0.07367859035730362,
0.2213866114616394,
0.8912152051925659,
0.3270827829837799,
-0.5410315990447998,
0.6087680459022522,
0.07278519123792648,
0.5145610570907593,
-0.377794474363327,
-0.1375080943107605,
-0.6935559511184692,
0.20303918421268463,
-0.015258408151566982,
-0.45123836398124695,
0.16755232214927673,
-0.19312140345573425,
0.06554167717695236,
-0.1747831553220749,
0.36649975180625916,
-0.784077525138855,
-0.5524005889892578,
0.4149760901927948,
1.0153980255126953,
0.6410976052284241,
-0.05813383311033249,
-0.6574291586875916,
0.5524054169654846,
0.027035027742385864,
-0.3201049864292145,
0.05232013761997223,
0.4979110062122345,
0.06436166912317276,
0.7511399388313293,
0.8811017274856567,
-0.03984375298023224,
0.20351320505142212,
0.295617938041687,
0.9038445353507996,
-0.5761207342147827,
-0.5367815494537354,
-0.8451188206672668,
0.2666255831718445,
-0.11779039353132248,
0.08966971188783646,
0.7290546894073486,
0.5636494159698486,
0.5525700449943542,
0.10096748173236847,
0.6353476643562317,
0.40827319025993347,
0.2619529366493225,
-0.7986592650413513,
0.37667396664619446,
-0.5083888173103333,
0.5399134755134583,
-0.1570751667022705,
-0.9501270055770874,
-0.4689812660217285,
0.5396437644958496,
-0.09623634070158005,
-0.05703604221343994,
0.7613158226013184,
0.9527289867401123,
-0.3316181004047394,
0.1383669674396515,
0.6829370260238647,
0.2636939287185669,
0.6006094217300415,
0.7314633131027222,
1.0569450855255127,
-0.5127605199813843,
0.7574477195739746,
-0.0813116803765297,
-0.029990138486027718,
-0.7122019529342651,
-0.9055251479148865,
-1.1040022373199463,
-0.18246106803417206,
-0.236075758934021,
-0.4442206621170044,
0.18967844545841217,
0.99144446849823,
0.7247224450111389,
-0.7034669518470764,
-0.38956940174102783,
0.039109863340854645,
0.14993493258953094,
-0.23995400965213776,
-0.12817531824111938,
0.11332657188177109,
-0.4452070891857147,
-1.047961950302124,
0.5865287780761719,
0.542275071144104,
0.16339506208896637,
-0.04576347768306732,
-0.4557177424430847,
-0.23401904106140137,
0.48625805974006653,
0.531545877456665,
-0.1929054707288742,
-0.9199028611183167,
0.08492843806743622,
-0.07091014832258224,
-0.35488831996917725,
0.3313818573951721,
0.9036144614219666,
-0.48832976818084717,
0.4462805390357971,
0.2692374885082245,
0.9223753213882446,
1.0717984437942505,
0.13888253271579742,
0.6312975287437439,
-0.6333547234535217,
0.38228967785835266,
0.08553951233625412,
0.2849716246128082,
0.5262676477432251,
-0.25146621465682983,
0.5796205401420593,
0.218262180685997,
-0.33840858936309814,
-0.7289214134216309,
0.21558472514152527,
-1.2814263105392456,
-0.0832323282957077,
1.3180019855499268,
-0.23442111909389496,
-0.17334401607513428,
-0.307692289352417,
-0.6378178596496582,
0.4068146347999573,
-0.4964495301246643,
0.17793427407741547,
0.5301924347877502,
-0.2708977162837982,
-0.37454667687416077,
-0.673429012298584,
0.25895199179649353,
0.7131900191307068,
-1.0581632852554321,
0.07112714648246765,
0.4209367334842682,
-0.12106512486934662,
-0.055621612817049026,
0.5615085959434509,
-0.043665193021297455,
0.1128465011715889,
0.2034672647714615,
-0.06496685743331909,
-0.38877367973327637,
-0.24403178691864014,
-0.20035602152347565,
0.15598924458026886,
0.07145939022302628,
-0.13498146831989288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10543v1 | Strong hallucinations from negation and how to fix them | 2024-02-16T10:11:20 | 2024-02-16T10:11:20 | Nicholas Asher, Swarnadeep Bhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Despite great performance on many tasks, language models (LMs) still struggle
with reasoning, sometimes providing responses that cannot possibly be true
because they stem from logical incoherence. We call such responses
\textit{strong hallucinations} and prove that they follow from an LM's
computation of its internal representations for logical operators and outputs
from those representations. Focusing on negation, we provide a novel solution
in which negation is treated not as another element of a latent representation,
but as \textit{an operation over an LM's latent representations that constrains
how they may evolve}. We show that our approach improves model performance in
cloze prompting and natural language inference tasks with negation without
requiring training on sparse negative data. | [
-0.3900676965713501,
-1.091819167137146,
0.7689962983131409,
-0.10647980123758316,
-0.20411738753318787,
-0.31097733974456787,
-0.274078369140625,
-0.6489459872245789,
0.45478296279907227,
0.943432629108429,
-0.5584383010864258,
-0.1632310003042221,
-0.7565485239028931,
0.14679524302482605,
-0.43568384647369385,
0.9217174649238586,
0.4008500576019287,
0.2812754213809967,
-0.05966924875974655,
-0.09886284172534943,
-0.8754783272743225,
-0.8498203754425049,
-0.46031975746154785,
-0.5993039608001709,
0.4177163541316986,
0.27911272644996643,
1.1745749711990356,
0.19687479734420776,
0.24352121353149414,
0.2995929419994354,
-0.007089162711054087,
0.23036375641822815,
-0.5373488664627075,
0.48572275042533875,
-0.3815227746963501,
-0.49060508608818054,
-0.16449971497058868,
-0.29098206758499146,
0.2074928730726242,
1.020081639289856,
-0.1436690092086792,
-0.42113980650901794,
-0.0029660111758857965,
0.4342826008796692,
-0.32004040479660034,
-0.11688878387212753,
-0.9234500527381897,
0.25951752066612244,
0.07390731573104858,
-0.171686589717865,
-0.6568036079406738,
-0.28003063797950745,
0.13543720543384552,
-0.2669132351875305,
0.20903874933719635,
-0.15379191935062408,
1.0093309879302979,
0.5068364143371582,
-0.41826000809669495,
-0.4985292851924896,
-0.8103501200675964,
0.7438288331031799,
-0.8377076387405396,
0.3582158088684082,
0.5006622672080994,
0.20072230696678162,
-0.5520116090774536,
-0.3869664669036865,
-0.6263936758041382,
-0.5909833312034607,
-0.24197852611541748,
-0.3562794327735901,
0.04979552701115608,
0.153560072183609,
0.5256061553955078,
0.22696632146835327,
-0.42388302087783813,
0.11047669500112534,
-0.35286015272140503,
-0.45738619565963745,
0.45671185851097107,
0.2195543646812439,
0.33890393376350403,
-0.1722879707813263,
-0.06194585934281349,
0.047348398715257645,
-0.671245813369751,
-0.41516175866127014,
0.4819469153881073,
0.35976096987724304,
0.30389404296875,
0.7999776601791382,
0.16339044272899628,
0.8342956304550171,
0.2071448415517807,
0.13938188552856445,
0.265522301197052,
0.12052128463983536,
-0.19730402529239655,
0.18311436474323273,
0.2590251863002777,
0.05298377200961113,
0.3771931231021881,
-0.42440399527549744,
-0.4045761227607727,
0.6074061393737793,
0.5096057057380676,
-0.5986596345901489,
-0.4646521508693695,
0.2923583686351776,
-0.39985886216163635,
-0.0115067008882761,
-0.14140096306800842,
-0.6894369721412659,
-1.0650110244750977,
-0.5803265571594238,
0.8065093755722046,
-0.4375190734863281,
-0.2906780540943146,
0.25837820768356323,
-0.03613919019699097,
0.0684351995587349,
0.3982507288455963,
-0.8861791491508484,
0.4975772500038147,
0.4185546040534973,
0.5298269987106323,
0.19366885721683502,
-0.08322392404079437,
-0.8591998815536499,
-0.3256071209907532,
-0.5801683068275452,
0.6641576886177063,
-0.7114277482032776,
-0.15286418795585632,
-0.13075821101665497,
0.1968468576669693,
0.052282609045505524,
-1.0501108169555664,
0.36432045698165894,
-0.25961217284202576,
0.22787196934223175,
-0.17193320393562317,
-0.5425693392753601,
-0.4014725685119629,
-0.02629069797694683,
-0.6815124750137329,
0.7333835959434509,
-0.01689610816538334,
-0.4017292261123657,
0.07973837107419968,
-0.29431837797164917,
-0.6017155051231384,
-0.06458339095115662,
-0.2571706473827362,
-0.2643883526325226,
0.5835596919059753,
0.09224813431501389,
0.4817575216293335,
0.045775044709444046,
0.41007447242736816,
-0.38169941306114197,
-0.3894178867340088,
0.3563151955604553,
-0.043603040277957916,
0.8512514233589172,
-0.08514401316642761,
-0.5949702262878418,
0.546863317489624,
-0.6439259052276611,
-0.2388322502374649,
0.30999937653541565,
0.37577304244041443,
-0.4415854513645172,
0.23397140204906464,
-0.48205652832984924,
0.19655582308769226,
0.08175953477621078,
-0.25430312752723694,
0.2916455864906311,
-0.6484555602073669,
0.36762332916259766,
0.8683249354362488,
0.10403064638376236,
0.5454822778701782,
-0.11812052130699158,
0.25810667872428894,
0.13606776297092438,
-0.16489720344543457,
-0.03675178065896034,
-0.4859706163406372,
-1.0633679628372192,
0.05413037911057472,
-0.14656203985214233,
0.28216129541397095,
-0.7598397731781006,
0.24752572178840637,
0.34316486120224,
-0.35000699758529663,
-0.3535098433494568,
0.3010469675064087,
0.05682236701250076,
0.7757275104522705,
0.5796999931335449,
-0.08307279646396637,
-0.634681761264801,
-0.9133996367454529,
-0.1885068267583847,
-0.12903958559036255,
0.05910992994904518,
0.09619428962469101,
0.632892370223999,
-0.5099074840545654,
0.34411975741386414,
-0.44546908140182495,
-0.2783932387828827,
-0.2608603537082672,
0.3273286819458008,
0.4433300793170929,
0.30100002884864807,
0.2122594714164734,
-0.5980604887008667,
0.09444449096918106,
-0.2311030924320221,
-0.9581574201583862,
-0.2076282501220703,
-0.3440430164337158,
0.041166696697473526,
0.4279707074165344,
0.5925083756446838,
-0.6193979382514954,
0.5206624865531921,
0.3441591262817383,
-0.5523704290390015,
0.7370373606681824,
-0.11431840807199478,
-0.10860855877399445,
-0.4902968108654022,
-0.361096054315567,
-0.28590887784957886,
-0.11472238600254059,
-0.6202215552330017,
0.13319097459316254,
-0.24746668338775635,
-0.15035347640514374,
-0.16570721566677094,
0.4389677047729492,
-0.46668675541877747,
0.1992989033460617,
-0.43864768743515015,
0.11790652573108673,
-0.17298159003257751,
0.4511650502681732,
0.2874842882156372,
0.23194387555122375,
0.8771125078201294,
-0.90056312084198,
0.3265342116355896,
0.0406176932156086,
0.07488000392913818,
0.3108551502227783,
-0.6851361989974976,
0.2997032105922699,
-0.5243387818336487,
0.02385249361395836,
-0.6484078764915466,
-0.4126267433166504,
0.36927494406700134,
-0.31123557686805725,
0.1425512135028839,
0.06413554400205612,
-0.5611705780029297,
-0.27554699778556824,
-0.09362830221652985,
0.10123029351234436,
0.47970688343048096,
-0.6269935369491577,
0.5915133953094482,
0.23594127595424652,
0.18434852361679077,
-0.32195723056793213,
-0.7752437591552734,
0.2837758958339691,
-0.2513437569141388,
-0.502877950668335,
0.19615797698497772,
-0.20601972937583923,
-0.650205671787262,
0.14642630517482758,
-0.11272750049829483,
-0.07618024200201035,
0.11465400457382202,
0.3652336597442627,
0.06338196247816086,
-0.21729421615600586,
0.3789794147014618,
-0.07139255106449127,
-0.07711239159107208,
0.22527343034744263,
-0.1801883429288864,
0.7886132001876831,
-0.062047168612480164,
-0.3879486620426178,
-0.392493337392807,
0.2792394459247589,
0.5123997330665588,
-0.056368496268987656,
0.8953156471252441,
0.3958436846733093,
-0.9284127354621887,
-0.5947169065475464,
-0.5021324157714844,
-1.1080683469772339,
-0.4114358723163605,
0.2100243717432022,
-0.32486048340797424,
-0.8505164384841919,
0.6917431950569153,
0.38621634244918823,
-0.2669885456562042,
0.45221105217933655,
0.47382330894470215,
0.06175237521529198,
1.1279611587524414,
0.28709250688552856,
0.3832213878631592,
0.20223204791545868,
-0.05203007906675339,
0.6087868809700012,
-0.33134394884109497,
-0.31571871042251587,
-0.44651898741722107,
-0.14967039227485657,
-0.45743614435195923,
-0.2980971932411194,
0.13048623502254486,
0.294808030128479,
-0.12950663268566132,
0.3681776523590088,
-0.7108434438705444,
0.4248996376991272,
0.15575334429740906,
0.14839869737625122,
0.0585196428000927,
-0.03460772708058357,
0.016545811668038368,
-0.3764083981513977,
-0.5787740349769592,
-0.6065302491188049,
0.7544503808021545,
0.40069350600242615,
0.8584014773368835,
0.2041459083557129,
0.7078757286071777,
0.18683069944381714,
0.14258094131946564,
-0.6847571134567261,
0.8582383990287781,
-0.007335463538765907,
-0.6531694531440735,
-0.3010176122188568,
-0.47153186798095703,
-0.7773281335830688,
0.4450334310531616,
-0.47838008403778076,
-1.0654211044311523,
0.21051017940044403,
0.09594662487506866,
-0.21060708165168762,
0.3186437785625458,
-0.8085638880729675,
0.7805845141410828,
-0.22124797105789185,
-0.6186711192131042,
-0.3640683889389038,
-0.3814880847930908,
0.582146167755127,
0.17416535317897797,
-0.04946410655975342,
-0.0021282110828906298,
0.19928856194019318,
0.5763288736343384,
-0.6866130828857422,
0.9399390816688538,
-0.31947463750839233,
-0.2613292932510376,
0.5110203623771667,
0.4699806571006775,
0.6281145215034485,
0.1703687608242035,
-0.20219795405864716,
0.05702152103185654,
-0.3802735209465027,
-0.40918588638305664,
-0.9140075445175171,
0.6847633719444275,
-0.4429442882537842,
-0.7643435597419739,
-0.5889386534690857,
-0.41829362511634827,
-0.2014305293560028,
0.1949455291032791,
0.34237539768218994,
0.5501124858856201,
0.23894661664962769,
0.07666482031345367,
0.8874440789222717,
-0.26171940565109253,
0.29835793375968933,
0.056529298424720764,
-0.47048419713974,
-0.15415793657302856,
0.8119956254959106,
0.3887336254119873,
0.1948930025100708,
-0.006297717336565256,
0.16690485179424286,
-0.3779922127723694,
-0.5953787565231323,
-0.17103952169418335,
0.3086112439632416,
-0.9369022846221924,
-0.08091408759355545,
-0.6969142556190491,
-0.2874346673488617,
-0.3187299072742462,
-0.13561224937438965,
-0.19726668298244476,
-0.3360496163368225,
-0.4771493673324585,
-0.1436094045639038,
0.15833903849124908,
0.9823780655860901,
-0.023125827312469482,
0.059595074504613876,
-0.3517940640449524,
0.7204447388648987,
0.5036064982414246,
0.10213301330804825,
0.3594807982444763,
-0.483196496963501,
-0.12301294505596161,
-0.022004099562764168,
-0.17388591170310974,
-1.3288018703460693,
0.4369306266307831,
-0.20631949603557587,
0.422187864780426,
0.386037677526474,
0.13443413376808167,
0.8592919111251831,
-0.2163519710302353,
0.8366838097572327,
0.1579577624797821,
-1.1049197912216187,
0.43809932470321655,
-0.16875918209552765,
0.22867624461650848,
0.3326983153820038,
0.220182865858078,
-0.2724713981151581,
-0.738924503326416,
-0.534351110458374,
-0.832906186580658,
0.3162537217140198,
0.20342804491519928,
0.29505839943885803,
-0.2782726287841797,
0.276713103055954,
0.33778247237205505,
0.16812272369861603,
-1.0132876634597778,
-0.036600153893232346,
-0.4235849380493164,
0.1792513132095337,
0.014466239139437675,
-0.3772602379322052,
0.029734117910265923,
-0.32104286551475525,
0.7663143277168274,
-0.05067649856209755,
0.37833642959594727,
0.3640802502632141,
-0.5142208933830261,
-0.010508483275771141,
0.1714804321527481,
0.6208676695823669,
0.6439257860183716,
-0.12350211292505264,
0.610219419002533,
0.2353193461894989,
0.08118371665477753,
-0.012537002563476562,
-0.14756672084331512,
0.1006515845656395,
0.05600399151444435,
0.6178006529808044,
0.8048176765441895,
0.04870383441448212,
-0.6968945860862732,
0.31665951013565063,
0.12646467983722687,
-0.0494639128446579,
-0.3288330137729645,
0.21711939573287964,
-0.07287397235631943,
0.0692310780286789,
0.436849981546402,
0.11958499252796173,
0.1703099012374878,
-0.7256848812103271,
0.22386842966079712,
0.43073636293411255,
-0.5400177240371704,
-0.3630756735801697,
0.6085343956947327,
-0.16989660263061523,
-0.3503779172897339,
0.7640856504440308,
-0.5018287897109985,
-0.7165541052818298,
0.5275856256484985,
0.8026939630508423,
0.9450308680534363,
-0.03679479658603668,
0.1993105262517929,
0.4561047852039337,
0.546746551990509,
-0.007020534016191959,
0.3828060030937195,
0.199138343334198,
-0.7928389310836792,
-0.39130279421806335,
-0.27737611532211304,
-0.3103291392326355,
0.4734160602092743,
-0.28551843762397766,
0.3702465891838074,
-0.6981239914894104,
-0.1609739065170288,
-0.1358325034379959,
-0.2352987825870514,
-0.47948572039604187,
0.2766703963279724,
0.33206674456596375,
0.49232926964759827,
-0.7520542740821838,
0.613328754901886,
0.4621034860610962,
-0.560383141040802,
-0.5824283957481384,
0.04934048280119896,
-0.1539052128791809,
-0.3550718128681183,
0.5314183235168457,
0.33523401618003845,
-0.3022385239601135,
-0.3468133509159088,
-0.8519947528839111,
-0.432595431804657,
0.25392040610313416,
0.6213705539703369,
-0.5119075775146484,
0.15587826073169708,
-0.05487564206123352,
0.6375104784965515,
-0.30223631858825684,
0.16860182583332062,
0.19900278747081757,
0.5938745737075806,
-0.3008418381214142,
-0.6392503380775452,
0.277732789516449,
-0.06856926530599594,
-0.40563806891441345,
0.24488289654254913,
-0.1382492482662201,
0.920171856880188,
-0.45891278982162476,
-0.2139713317155838,
0.04914075508713722,
0.7707400918006897,
-0.004309794399887323,
0.23080050945281982,
0.5260446071624756,
0.6533772945404053,
1.1199499368667603,
-0.13503721356391907,
0.7887979745864868,
-0.045500051230192184,
0.07018596678972244,
1.3011267185211182,
-0.3454224169254303,
0.6211705207824707,
0.7004581689834595,
0.45430517196655273,
0.7935848236083984,
0.3381778299808502,
0.020725920796394348,
0.26332414150238037,
0.3636951744556427,
-0.06680209189653397,
-0.5696603059768677,
-0.2500753402709961,
-0.444973349571228,
0.29102590680122375,
0.4617605209350586,
-0.20092007517814636,
-0.2580612301826477,
0.18824075162410736,
0.11912642419338226,
0.532034695148468,
-0.30086851119995117,
0.6943256258964539,
0.2161450982093811,
-0.7898082137107849,
0.9267961382865906,
-0.16372224688529968,
0.47220319509506226,
-0.5042621493339539,
-0.5268230438232422,
-0.09373036026954651,
0.16724154353141785,
-0.5737890005111694,
-0.48279261589050293,
0.6668969988822937,
-0.26371878385543823,
-0.11616730690002441,
-0.18765173852443695,
0.83095782995224,
-0.31336018443107605,
-0.2741353213787079,
0.6754637956619263,
0.1884237825870514,
0.2406696379184723,
-0.08465272933244705,
-0.3350123167037964,
0.20747503638267517,
-0.08821927756071091,
-0.02893669530749321,
-0.03821147233247757,
0.42699840664863586,
-0.3418872356414795,
0.5807759165763855,
0.5339979529380798,
0.06032717227935791,
0.2368340641260147,
0.15199516713619232,
0.6715012192726135,
-0.9438092112541199,
-0.32133468985557556,
-1.0352129936218262,
0.4817839562892914,
0.0007948496495373547,
-0.26257845759391785,
0.6865452527999878,
0.3240797519683838,
0.5866186618804932,
-0.15775039792060852,
0.5393336415290833,
0.042464520782232285,
0.15825936198234558,
-0.5766904950141907,
0.609592854976654,
-0.5340438485145569,
0.2553679049015045,
-0.23121826350688934,
-1.0418847799301147,
-0.5690470933914185,
0.8589819669723511,
-0.6300536394119263,
-0.15594235062599182,
0.8881230354309082,
1.0764364004135132,
0.050783149898052216,
0.057234399020671844,
0.40084099769592285,
0.7894971966743469,
0.11403815448284149,
0.7063405513763428,
0.9481939077377319,
-0.2520099878311157,
0.09930466115474701,
-0.26435649394989014,
0.13079342246055603,
-0.29269886016845703,
-0.8576996922492981,
-1.1760962009429932,
-0.5720738172531128,
-0.4518395960330963,
-0.808459460735321,
0.016835205256938934,
0.8754389882087708,
0.6330134868621826,
-0.9793846607208252,
-0.1602720469236374,
-0.3579176366329193,
0.6315107941627502,
-0.2412264049053192,
-0.28712162375450134,
0.16160209476947784,
-0.5170149803161621,
-0.4174443781375885,
0.47668907046318054,
0.18636561930179596,
0.1540978103876114,
-0.5482227802276611,
-0.37133151292800903,
0.04246169328689575,
0.35349494218826294,
0.5229741930961609,
0.10056780278682709,
-0.844214916229248,
-0.2969993054866791,
-0.0015357241500169039,
-0.04238681122660637,
0.037500571459531784,
0.5484970808029175,
-0.9807685613632202,
0.5706012845039368,
0.4928301274776459,
0.5197324752807617,
0.49293410778045654,
-0.47743409872055054,
0.4483550488948822,
-0.19661912322044373,
0.29631391167640686,
0.6579009294509888,
0.28555577993392944,
0.5244900584220886,
-0.3209749162197113,
0.28854280710220337,
0.25784382224082947,
-0.2431122064590454,
-1.1058201789855957,
0.49175703525543213,
-0.5865336656570435,
-0.6067442297935486,
0.8737984299659729,
0.41364818811416626,
-0.17901290953159332,
-0.14593911170959473,
-0.2884497344493866,
0.06180517002940178,
-0.19765618443489075,
0.8531678318977356,
0.8600110411643982,
-0.25604578852653503,
-0.07889288663864136,
-0.5630579590797424,
0.4170704483985901,
0.783513069152832,
-0.50429368019104,
-0.06944715231657028,
0.6351258158683777,
-0.05543987452983856,
0.2825357913970947,
0.32938408851623535,
-0.11633367836475372,
0.13036389648914337,
0.05133478343486786,
0.005204713903367519,
0.13912014663219452,
-0.6569417715072632,
-0.5276206731796265,
0.476723849773407,
0.17278602719306946,
0.1811126321554184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10532v1 | Properties and Challenges of LLM-Generated Explanations | 2024-02-16T09:37:54 | 2024-02-16T09:37:54 | Jenny Kunz, Marco Kuhlmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | The self-rationalising capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been
explored in restricted settings, using task/specific data sets. However,
current LLMs do not (only) rely on specifically annotated data; nonetheless,
they frequently explain their outputs. The properties of the generated
explanations are influenced by the pre-training corpus and by the target data
used for instruction fine-tuning. As the pre-training corpus includes a large
amount of human-written explanations "in the wild", we hypothesise that LLMs
adopt common properties of human explanations. By analysing the outputs for a
multi-domain instruction fine-tuning data set, we find that generated
explanations show selectivity and contain illustrative elements, but less
frequently are subjective or misleading. We discuss reasons and consequences of
the properties' presence or absence. In particular, we outline positive and
negative implications depending on the goals and user groups of the
self-rationalising system. | [
-0.5773179531097412,
-0.7916440963745117,
0.6264823079109192,
0.07756096124649048,
-0.07232686877250671,
-0.2768155634403229,
-0.5013971328735352,
-0.2728189527988434,
-0.0729329064488411,
0.6130436062812805,
-0.8086407780647278,
-0.32864436507225037,
-0.474592924118042,
0.3214986324310303,
-0.24323667585849762,
1.073586106300354,
-0.26127955317497253,
-0.1262878030538559,
-0.35211166739463806,
-0.050301238894462585,
-0.4532918334007263,
-0.8668315410614014,
-0.24985575675964355,
-0.47923406958580017,
0.8118280172348022,
0.740648627281189,
0.7867353558540344,
0.8594991564750671,
0.10179658234119415,
0.3292834460735321,
0.28497347235679626,
0.24049723148345947,
-0.4887962341308594,
0.24875640869140625,
-0.2839432656764984,
-0.44596874713897705,
-0.2998441159725189,
0.336820513010025,
0.6078334450721741,
0.8891043066978455,
0.14534635841846466,
0.02721237577497959,
0.2818969488143921,
0.6920925378799438,
-0.4468749165534973,
-0.08329997956752777,
-0.6802526116371155,
0.0812745913863182,
-0.20488448441028595,
-0.4561213254928589,
-0.3436557650566101,
-0.026404686272144318,
0.10256784409284592,
-0.6252009272575378,
0.7397467494010925,
0.11221812665462494,
0.8315441012382507,
0.3223264813423157,
-0.4814535081386566,
-0.6415003538131714,
-1.030616283416748,
1.010502815246582,
-0.5919653177261353,
0.07450675219297409,
0.3866715133190155,
0.383583664894104,
-0.2835868299007416,
-0.42616724967956543,
-0.46114155650138855,
-0.07772747427225113,
-0.32714006304740906,
-0.005642388481646776,
0.10513376444578171,
0.17744159698486328,
0.3812074065208435,
0.3990946114063263,
-0.32416507601737976,
0.49169135093688965,
-0.5060743689537048,
-0.35685616731643677,
0.8344162702560425,
0.3213968873023987,
0.007815320044755936,
-0.1316109597682953,
-0.22247807681560516,
0.15495885908603668,
-1.1544113159179688,
-0.0008176746196113527,
0.5638008117675781,
0.2954901158809662,
0.08010420948266983,
0.5935922861099243,
-0.20762793719768524,
0.802908182144165,
0.044517431408166885,
-0.10111171007156372,
-0.1399761140346527,
-0.30190715193748474,
-0.2507978677749634,
0.114091657102108,
0.6908419132232666,
0.24925056099891663,
0.6180140376091003,
-0.2351132333278656,
-0.32291531562805176,
0.007316134870052338,
-0.006004441529512405,
-0.745453417301178,
-0.13325364887714386,
0.4075509309768677,
-0.31600522994995117,
-0.09638642519712448,
-0.11748218536376953,
-0.5219547152519226,
-0.30650976300239563,
-0.7510414719581604,
0.24795551598072052,
-0.1764746904373169,
-0.16224995255470276,
0.16707347333431244,
-0.02555251121520996,
0.25333085656166077,
0.580205500125885,
-1.360558271408081,
0.0973447635769844,
0.4725658893585205,
0.21746724843978882,
-0.3784646689891815,
-0.44005507230758667,
-0.3651662766933441,
0.16406969726085663,
-0.17132580280303955,
0.8007477521896362,
-0.3817763328552246,
-0.23880217969417572,
-0.06364239007234573,
0.01109215710312128,
-0.026035919785499573,
-0.7156282067298889,
0.0590457022190094,
-0.29091283679008484,
0.33949002623558044,
-0.568827748298645,
-0.6953386664390564,
-0.12197095155715942,
-0.06766105443239212,
-0.40367335081100464,
0.6384778022766113,
-0.11512845009565353,
-0.47783148288726807,
0.6061500906944275,
-0.5638552308082581,
-0.5325770378112793,
-0.09961865097284317,
-0.1988351047039032,
-0.04245135933160782,
0.19883006811141968,
0.20104394853115082,
0.7745974063873291,
-0.24413694441318512,
0.39972588419914246,
-0.2782568037509918,
-0.338358998298645,
0.6593413352966309,
-0.8376134037971497,
0.5054311752319336,
0.49974313378334045,
-0.3134102523326874,
0.08468607068061829,
-0.8138730525970459,
-0.20729395747184753,
0.2770439684391022,
-0.34124183654785156,
0.0069608138874173164,
0.12562982738018036,
-0.47243496775627136,
0.16531729698181152,
0.4897990822792053,
-0.2043498307466507,
-0.011290187947452068,
-0.06555043160915375,
0.5388332009315491,
0.94698166847229,
0.06841640174388885,
0.3931262195110321,
-0.2869660556316376,
0.788126528263092,
0.21398071944713593,
0.11935676634311676,
-0.5206583142280579,
-0.23301519453525543,
-0.5901823043823242,
-0.21177679300308228,
0.1838812679052353,
0.17087233066558838,
-0.1229160726070404,
-0.006448098458349705,
0.05552398040890694,
-0.1693621277809143,
-0.552544891834259,
0.5069341659545898,
0.37052151560783386,
0.3686055839061737,
0.12054084986448288,
0.20925284922122955,
-0.4935135245323181,
-1.0758508443832397,
-0.33611631393432617,
0.27804943919181824,
-0.04487936198711395,
0.4553605020046234,
0.25442925095558167,
-0.3177213966846466,
0.8767523169517517,
-0.29462504386901855,
0.07446567714214325,
-0.30872443318367004,
0.11213761568069458,
0.08039826899766922,
0.37799492478370667,
0.2806815207004547,
-0.5920889377593994,
-0.08997153490781784,
-0.27080753445625305,
-0.8349162340164185,
-0.349027544260025,
-0.592166543006897,
0.04407505318522453,
0.2543815076351166,
0.5314142107963562,
-0.5683324933052063,
0.30624446272850037,
0.48435837030410767,
-0.05790875479578972,
0.8887476325035095,
-0.4290981590747833,
-0.08787114918231964,
-0.8045406937599182,
-0.2513785660266876,
0.08528445661067963,
-0.106402687728405,
-0.3427731394767761,
-0.035417329519987106,
-0.31156185269355774,
0.013999908231198788,
-0.36267486214637756,
0.4967324137687683,
-0.5796642899513245,
-0.2366754561662674,
-0.10208345204591751,
0.6078203320503235,
0.35346877574920654,
0.5028062462806702,
-0.07688608020544052,
0.8770448565483093,
0.4648391902446747,
-0.926199197769165,
0.25230205059051514,
-0.05994236096739769,
0.12399845570325851,
0.19072546064853668,
-0.740481972694397,
0.046164270490407944,
-0.1713629961013794,
-0.16127631068229675,
-1.092652440071106,
-0.6670769453048706,
0.10400855541229248,
-0.36823830008506775,
0.28207775950431824,
-0.19002611935138702,
-0.49858060479164124,
-0.34014126658439636,
-0.1141512468457222,
0.21566884219646454,
0.36440277099609375,
-0.731817901134491,
0.41153013706207275,
0.12444635480642319,
0.1449325531721115,
-0.5136582851409912,
-0.6348170638084412,
-0.08592796325683594,
-0.48097166419029236,
-0.5600648522377014,
0.21333277225494385,
-0.3014656901359558,
-0.4770433008670807,
-0.1572791039943695,
-0.16816148161888123,
0.07014834135770798,
0.46593207120895386,
0.5364056825637817,
0.1260356605052948,
-0.4035685062408447,
0.313050240278244,
0.2794930934906006,
-0.03906955569982529,
0.39653533697128296,
0.07018772512674332,
0.2441248744726181,
-0.14307379722595215,
-0.4387560188770294,
-0.39405733346939087,
0.34649235010147095,
0.4971485137939453,
-0.07976001501083374,
0.7920354008674622,
0.2885814309120178,
-0.14069126546382904,
-0.47827520966529846,
-0.40123251080513,
-0.39590445160865784,
-0.5266947150230408,
0.03434247896075249,
-0.47533726692199707,
-0.9653329253196716,
0.7170080542564392,
-0.13229192793369293,
0.14016848802566528,
0.6615535616874695,
0.7112446427345276,
-0.22440016269683838,
1.1722444295883179,
0.1944183111190796,
0.3826279044151306,
0.15141640603542328,
-0.05110253393650055,
0.2761021554470062,
-0.6061694025993347,
-0.3045555055141449,
-0.4920803904533386,
-0.1470220535993576,
-0.811224102973938,
0.07040812075138092,
0.004398371558636427,
0.3750544488430023,
-0.1821577250957489,
-0.00789122749119997,
-0.6799606084823608,
0.5511784553527832,
0.6942552328109741,
-0.18411876261234283,
0.20485585927963257,
0.07819494605064392,
-0.11294853687286377,
-0.013350194320082664,
-0.7483236789703369,
-0.8660204410552979,
1.1355589628219604,
0.33974194526672363,
0.9780922532081604,
-0.07379157096147537,
0.8636427521705627,
0.24342405796051025,
0.43499860167503357,
-0.7307351231575012,
0.5197507739067078,
-0.02452903613448143,
-0.8318745493888855,
-0.47533679008483887,
-0.35095757246017456,
-1.2377252578735352,
0.21884272992610931,
-0.25877660512924194,
-0.5660388469696045,
-0.16338184475898743,
0.5586920976638794,
-0.4522583782672882,
-0.008485013619065285,
-1.0757126808166504,
0.8799893260002136,
-0.4640044867992401,
-0.46882596611976624,
-0.18487118184566498,
-0.33023494482040405,
0.5028179287910461,
-0.0783207044005394,
0.1340760886669159,
-0.183883398771286,
0.3122885525226593,
0.6917506456375122,
-0.34151872992515564,
1.0393513441085815,
-0.2045162469148636,
-0.21497642993927002,
0.39276590943336487,
0.13026702404022217,
0.11962713301181793,
0.03092600591480732,
-0.11296048760414124,
0.027120931074023247,
-0.14181457459926605,
-0.456415593624115,
-0.5658184885978699,
0.829331636428833,
-0.8977896571159363,
-1.2803399562835693,
-0.16994687914848328,
-0.5508394837379456,
-0.163508340716362,
0.19814205169677734,
0.2030636966228485,
0.7422215938568115,
-0.03465268015861511,
0.14149166643619537,
0.747321605682373,
-0.538641095161438,
0.3159429132938385,
0.5632262229919434,
-0.37640470266342163,
-0.03465820848941803,
0.9627830386161804,
0.22169749438762665,
0.4042958915233612,
-0.048047591000795364,
0.309306263923645,
-0.27976194024086,
-0.6822530627250671,
-0.5689303278923035,
0.32141074538230896,
-0.9159792065620422,
0.04275842756032944,
-0.3070937395095825,
-0.17512749135494232,
-0.20618949830532074,
-0.3431020975112915,
-0.03167383745312691,
-0.42322760820388794,
-0.7678083777427673,
-0.23172256350517273,
0.29445213079452515,
1.1561888456344604,
-0.13549697399139404,
0.3860471844673157,
-0.5813944339752197,
0.3953935205936432,
0.506644606590271,
0.18769219517707825,
0.04817324876785278,
-0.6054341793060303,
-0.4042958915233612,
0.2670130431652069,
-0.3539733588695526,
-0.6807775497436523,
0.12221746891736984,
0.13791126012802124,
0.6295397877693176,
0.645003616809845,
-0.1339312344789505,
0.5418567061424255,
-0.3810034990310669,
0.8693092465400696,
-0.10458407551050186,
-0.7400166392326355,
0.6002940535545349,
-0.4181981682777405,
0.2862681448459625,
0.30542126297950745,
0.39965322613716125,
-0.09926901012659073,
-0.538151204586029,
-0.5247904658317566,
-0.5120181441307068,
0.7480903267860413,
-0.10286596417427063,
0.3154171109199524,
-0.17090973258018494,
0.7320675849914551,
0.4872589111328125,
-0.0038727540522813797,
-0.674799919128418,
-0.3215685188770294,
-0.325415700674057,
-0.08509427309036255,
0.004890097305178642,
-0.3901114761829376,
-0.17636333405971527,
-0.08109262585639954,
0.49884849786758423,
-0.17860551178455353,
0.1763189733028412,
0.20909997820854187,
-0.16299018263816833,
-0.26055091619491577,
0.3684438169002533,
0.9698494076728821,
0.8665951490402222,
-0.019541246816515923,
0.2409472018480301,
-0.05440102517604828,
0.0859484076499939,
-0.03915097191929817,
0.1184675469994545,
0.11855645477771759,
-0.16959542036056519,
0.5775105953216553,
0.8059941530227661,
0.04940802603960037,
-0.538777768611908,
0.2552258372306824,
0.01675446704030037,
-0.3422650992870331,
-0.341880202293396,
0.4693666398525238,
0.17683272063732147,
-0.06744635850191116,
0.43617746233940125,
0.0290873683989048,
-0.06761519610881805,
-0.5006000399589539,
-0.13276968896389008,
0.4641698896884918,
-0.02194339595735073,
-0.6509091854095459,
0.7257636785507202,
0.04751848801970482,
-0.22119717299938202,
0.38474979996681213,
-0.20488768815994263,
-0.39496055245399475,
0.5349884629249573,
0.585062563419342,
0.5665650963783264,
-0.08599276840686798,
0.30362915992736816,
0.13493265211582184,
0.27270594239234924,
0.21141310036182404,
0.07559004426002502,
-0.2863011956214905,
-0.9298866391181946,
-0.6350798606872559,
-0.5135654807090759,
-0.5982922911643982,
0.3053246736526489,
-0.5948628187179565,
0.06404589116573334,
-0.48801499605178833,
0.06002026051282883,
0.2863159477710724,
-0.23652993142604828,
-0.9171602129936218,
0.3605797588825226,
0.23205457627773285,
0.5670831799507141,
-0.807788610458374,
0.7360718846321106,
0.41338011622428894,
-0.46370598673820496,
-1.0001736879348755,
-0.13154013454914093,
-0.18664081394672394,
-1.0300078392028809,
0.7958075404167175,
0.1774033010005951,
-0.2085186392068863,
-0.20279307663440704,
-0.6414151191711426,
-0.6746979355812073,
0.7856952548027039,
0.5997246503829956,
-0.537457287311554,
0.026822634041309357,
0.5189946293830872,
0.754874587059021,
-0.402240514755249,
-0.08420873433351517,
0.559539258480072,
0.5276031494140625,
-0.17411674559116364,
-0.5059505701065063,
0.08215471357107162,
0.2029406577348709,
-0.3053721487522125,
-0.0705263763666153,
-0.44536441564559937,
0.7517061233520508,
-0.3887741267681122,
-0.1787036508321762,
-0.2833606004714966,
0.6276285648345947,
0.20375676453113556,
0.28411075472831726,
0.21599261462688446,
0.2904282212257385,
0.7167579531669617,
-0.14377254247665405,
1.2347468137741089,
-0.3315768241882324,
0.03865595534443855,
1.0649398565292358,
-0.20773564279079437,
0.33460733294487,
0.5041654706001282,
-0.027860304340720177,
0.544856607913971,
0.8545963168144226,
0.1297210454940796,
0.23021817207336426,
0.4404226541519165,
-0.13514436781406403,
-0.4069579541683197,
-0.04884934052824974,
-0.05521421879529953,
0.5720789432525635,
0.5181339979171753,
-0.48431071639060974,
-0.14426453411579132,
-0.03962405398488045,
-0.1455848664045334,
0.12845322489738464,
-0.4035170376300812,
0.7108479142189026,
0.1857813447713852,
-1.0221681594848633,
0.9161635041236877,
-0.1749723255634308,
0.37234243750572205,
-0.37042269110679626,
-0.02755133807659149,
-0.30266642570495605,
0.10667047649621964,
-0.32893073558807373,
-0.845375657081604,
0.261315256357193,
-0.10398218780755997,
-0.3240598440170288,
-0.6092938184738159,
0.7236515879631042,
-0.43289461731910706,
-0.08314736932516098,
0.12489002197980881,
0.7147399187088013,
0.3690163493156433,
0.08470213413238525,
-0.546807587146759,
0.011470075696706772,
0.12872494757175446,
-0.47925665974617004,
0.4186449348926544,
0.9354203939437866,
-0.08718439191579819,
0.5563024878501892,
0.42586591839790344,
0.01706082746386528,
0.07502072304487228,
0.13239620625972748,
0.727691650390625,
-0.6525336503982544,
0.029320407658815384,
-0.9615840315818787,
0.31858503818511963,
0.2030242532491684,
-0.4366743862628937,
0.8805632591247559,
0.346013605594635,
0.6809941530227661,
-0.06196469068527222,
0.8076950311660767,
0.3878289759159088,
0.3587300777435303,
-0.7548262476921082,
0.4141760468482971,
-0.520729124546051,
0.5041195154190063,
0.13149578869342804,
-0.883222222328186,
-0.04802057147026062,
0.30274733901023865,
-0.3556845486164093,
0.18763917684555054,
0.5538893938064575,
0.823039710521698,
-0.07744434475898743,
0.1114393025636673,
0.49109581112861633,
0.3024892508983612,
0.11713922023773193,
0.25473925471305847,
0.9270884990692139,
0.12499108165502548,
0.3719826936721802,
-0.16927586495876312,
-0.01136221457272768,
-0.22354520857334137,
-1.0000931024551392,
-1.1976873874664307,
-0.5054424405097961,
-0.3023587465286255,
-0.1915159821510315,
-0.21432995796203613,
0.7418400645256042,
0.6350903511047363,
-0.9323049187660217,
-0.060172464698553085,
-0.06607994437217712,
0.34645113348960876,
0.11633337289094925,
-0.23803505301475525,
0.21270771324634552,
-0.46153154969215393,
-0.40309351682662964,
0.3701897859573364,
0.12865525484085083,
0.19361694157123566,
-0.7019864320755005,
-0.21195164322853088,
0.40657782554626465,
0.2756285071372986,
0.570899486541748,
0.34429436922073364,
-0.9820913672447205,
-0.45521780848503113,
0.06762506812810898,
-0.02899743802845478,
0.15017400681972504,
0.8682746887207031,
-0.8005378842353821,
0.32832056283950806,
0.09293867647647858,
0.47482427954673767,
0.3803369104862213,
-0.10669774562120438,
0.7784315347671509,
-0.6730059385299683,
-0.10232827812433243,
-0.0873505249619484,
0.489285409450531,
0.5366845726966858,
-0.5178868174552917,
0.2459215670824051,
0.05778565630316734,
-0.6356130838394165,
-0.7532293200492859,
0.16528213024139404,
-0.6260549426078796,
-0.30430319905281067,
1.2985754013061523,
-0.3284371793270111,
-0.1457776129245758,
-0.08222535252571106,
-0.2349669188261032,
0.26827144622802734,
-0.21777045726776123,
0.8798933029174805,
0.8008710741996765,
-0.26520636677742004,
-0.1324455291032791,
-0.48800718784332275,
0.5471696257591248,
0.4783582091331482,
-0.84400874376297,
0.4635029733181,
0.6966076493263245,
0.298247754573822,
0.003924661781638861,
0.3355114758014679,
-0.04909566044807434,
0.29991433024406433,
-0.3158073425292969,
0.020817942917346954,
-0.19830787181854248,
-0.45729103684425354,
-0.41707703471183777,
0.0756705105304718,
0.40351733565330505,
0.09880061447620392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10528v2 | Can We Verify Step by Step for Incorrect Answer Detection? | 2024-02-16T09:29:50 | 2024-06-15T16:53:58 | Xin Xu, Shizhe Diao, Can Yang, Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has marked a significant advancement in
enhancing the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Previous
studies have developed various extensions of CoT, which focus primarily on
enhancing end-task performance. In addition, there has been research on
assessing the quality of reasoning chains in CoT. This raises an intriguing
question: Is it possible to predict the accuracy of LLM outputs by scrutinizing
the reasoning chains they generate? To answer this research question, we
introduce a benchmark, R2PE, designed specifically to explore the relationship
between reasoning chains and performance in various reasoning tasks spanning
five different domains. This benchmark aims to measure the falsehood of the
final output of LLMs based on the reasoning steps. To make full use of
information in multiple reasoning chains, we propose the process discernibility
score (PDS) framework that beats the answer-checking baseline by a large
margin. Concretely, this resulted in an average of $5.1\%$ increase in the F1
score and $2.97\%$ improvement in AUC-PR across all 45 subsets within R2PE. We
further demonstrate our PDS's efficacy in advancing open-domain QA accuracy.
Data and code are available at https://github.com/XinXU-USTC/R2PE. | [
-0.35255953669548035,
-0.9497261047363281,
0.8828554153442383,
0.0655379369854927,
0.06087556853890419,
0.2582598328590393,
0.08377925306558609,
-0.6610347628593445,
-0.26670870184898376,
0.5270949602127075,
-0.549625813961029,
-0.5440577268600464,
-0.6338843703269958,
0.15801696479320526,
-0.3095608949661255,
0.641258955001831,
-0.4712628722190857,
-0.17524662613868713,
-0.30861425399780273,
-0.07653108984231949,
-0.33654752373695374,
-0.31292545795440674,
-0.6989486813545227,
-0.5908995866775513,
0.3309682011604309,
0.3371143043041229,
0.6005566120147705,
0.5201690793037415,
0.24966201186180115,
0.1589561253786087,
-0.10708275437355042,
0.7700658440589905,
-0.2583870589733124,
0.17671184241771698,
-0.6526286602020264,
-0.6088797450065613,
-0.6362963914871216,
0.15118290483951569,
0.3083043694496155,
0.40481036901474,
-0.06203557550907135,
0.3241189420223236,
0.16915564239025116,
0.9239948987960815,
-0.8456364274024963,
-0.06042681634426117,
-0.6479365825653076,
-0.08528590947389603,
0.0772353857755661,
-0.39764806628227234,
-0.8598718643188477,
-0.4568025767803192,
-0.09353691339492798,
-0.33162927627563477,
0.4353930354118347,
0.2088332623243332,
0.7037474513053894,
0.24414759874343872,
-0.35734739899635315,
-0.39285603165626526,
-0.741587221622467,
0.5217418670654297,
-0.48171502351760864,
0.3589518964290619,
0.6033598780632019,
0.2133338302373886,
-0.40107297897338867,
-0.6018649339675903,
-0.6528388261795044,
0.10560192912817001,
0.04426874592900276,
0.02141657844185829,
-0.2072206735610962,
0.011587371118366718,
0.6162676215171814,
0.28023070096969604,
-0.6107446551322937,
-0.1615968942642212,
-0.19823062419891357,
-0.27159157395362854,
0.5742948055267334,
0.007334759924560785,
0.18637651205062866,
0.26911619305610657,
-0.5010291934013367,
-0.16230453550815582,
-0.7135701179504395,
0.19276586174964905,
0.384713351726532,
0.16053542494773865,
0.14412885904312134,
0.7017525434494019,
-0.2827101945877075,
0.5287235379219055,
0.12375526130199432,
-0.011162412352859974,
0.26514849066734314,
-0.4798166751861572,
-0.1609039306640625,
-0.11294014006853104,
0.6351609826087952,
0.3381973206996918,
0.3448750674724579,
0.021932661533355713,
-0.3367471992969513,
0.16133560240268707,
0.4382918179035187,
-0.5724652409553528,
-0.4566125273704529,
0.5079314112663269,
-0.04698503762483597,
0.02572297304868698,
0.08743879199028015,
-0.5171069502830505,
-0.5020759105682373,
-0.010809765197336674,
0.36204928159713745,
-0.3904767334461212,
-0.41294345259666443,
-0.010806497186422348,
-0.00873288419097662,
0.11597178131341934,
0.554595947265625,
-0.25339144468307495,
0.6336918473243713,
0.9534618258476257,
0.9095405340194702,
-0.1905650943517685,
-0.42771074175834656,
-0.9586672186851501,
-0.28520211577415466,
-0.8931626081466675,
1.0580779314041138,
-0.2760545313358307,
-0.06410684436559677,
-0.22647352516651154,
-0.08119551837444305,
-0.09547740966081619,
-0.8416131138801575,
0.5446679592132568,
-0.6035633683204651,
-0.1933296173810959,
-0.6051192879676819,
-0.6436200141906738,
-0.12955577671527863,
0.3864753246307373,
-0.5550022721290588,
1.446584701538086,
0.047428570687770844,
-0.697495698928833,
0.2888369560241699,
-0.23027265071868896,
-0.26187649369239807,
-0.29558494687080383,
-0.21426984667778015,
-0.3902699649333954,
-0.0217443760484457,
0.2586958110332489,
0.1963982880115509,
-0.3574199378490448,
0.04755972698330879,
-0.2965991497039795,
-0.5312844514846802,
0.4904952347278595,
-0.4879845976829529,
0.6151244044303894,
-0.048193249851465225,
-0.5452847480773926,
-0.01505175419151783,
-0.8292946815490723,
0.5622984766960144,
-0.2625909149646759,
-0.2881125211715698,
-0.09983590990304947,
-0.025110751390457153,
-0.6030277609825134,
0.6364907622337341,
-0.11597619950771332,
-0.5541309118270874,
-0.09247741848230362,
-0.19417692720890045,
0.04204192012548447,
0.9562828540802002,
0.1457304060459137,
0.07338161766529083,
-0.3241441249847412,
0.6555132269859314,
0.15343575179576874,
-0.12177413702011108,
0.06598430871963501,
-0.8451932668685913,
-0.7231332063674927,
-0.06397075951099396,
0.21217814087867737,
0.699322521686554,
-0.745904266834259,
0.5589748620986938,
0.047117672860622406,
-0.5468695759773254,
-0.36393946409225464,
0.16062910854816437,
0.7472828030586243,
0.6253247261047363,
0.45596301555633545,
-0.6145431995391846,
-0.40767818689346313,
-0.6241951584815979,
-0.47003915905952454,
-0.6396967172622681,
-0.11332963407039642,
0.15265944600105286,
0.5918651223182678,
0.0726761445403099,
0.6541460156440735,
-0.41605108976364136,
0.08474058657884598,
-0.0741809830069542,
0.2745797038078308,
0.2816784977912903,
0.3713511824607849,
-0.10321013629436493,
-0.3215283751487732,
-0.3209272623062134,
-0.02489713579416275,
-0.6351904273033142,
-0.08902749419212341,
0.0498257651925087,
-0.2849794328212738,
0.4577554166316986,
0.34910842776298523,
-0.3714311122894287,
0.6402391195297241,
0.5295156836509705,
-0.5788399577140808,
0.8303415179252625,
-0.4246738851070404,
0.4390621483325958,
-0.3765053153038025,
0.1673831343650818,
0.20455996692180634,
-0.35336172580718994,
-0.4383428692817688,
0.06556299328804016,
0.3246113359928131,
0.22435499727725983,
-0.32254958152770996,
0.26456892490386963,
-0.2252461463212967,
-0.4626856744289398,
-0.235139861702919,
0.24739140272140503,
0.2417067438364029,
0.5557658076286316,
0.08767787367105484,
1.1198465824127197,
0.3326694071292877,
-0.6958296895027161,
0.18450066447257996,
0.03496960923075676,
-0.5499081611633301,
0.7092966437339783,
-0.5967459678649902,
0.38504454493522644,
0.10241737216711044,
0.5655951499938965,
-1.2956418991088867,
0.0710800364613533,
0.31874778866767883,
-0.4961414635181427,
-0.05799763277173042,
-0.1381160020828247,
-0.6578254103660583,
-0.408488929271698,
-0.1795402616262436,
0.29454341530799866,
0.4052123427391052,
-0.6793453097343445,
0.449493944644928,
0.08130095899105072,
0.112306609749794,
-0.6652753353118896,
-0.5718094110488892,
-0.22377558052539825,
0.311033695936203,
-0.5801335573196411,
-0.007618999574333429,
-0.10800953209400177,
-0.17145277559757233,
-0.267774760723114,
-0.5957516431808472,
-0.29050344228744507,
0.010715298354625702,
0.25460705161094666,
0.16263768076896667,
-0.1271285116672516,
0.14326193928718567,
-0.06382223963737488,
-0.2635902166366577,
0.4773530066013336,
-0.12055869400501251,
0.428166002035141,
-0.240732342004776,
-0.5411162972450256,
-0.5358749032020569,
0.03742724657058716,
0.6204611659049988,
-0.24006061255931854,
0.45877063274383545,
0.3134509325027466,
-0.45993372797966003,
-0.4516494870185852,
-0.46953636407852173,
-0.10198429226875305,
-0.4005274474620819,
0.02021930180490017,
-0.7435358762741089,
-0.29342547059059143,
0.5712942481040955,
-0.31339049339294434,
-0.07607179135084152,
0.3233448565006256,
0.2001829743385315,
0.0881471112370491,
1.111939787864685,
0.16024252772331238,
0.5697261691093445,
-0.14886708557605743,
-0.29761677980422974,
0.4749317467212677,
-1.0143803358078003,
-0.33637794852256775,
-0.5770427584648132,
-0.018885565921664238,
-0.6037454605102539,
-0.9373522400856018,
0.441567987203598,
0.53042072057724,
-0.28716859221458435,
0.29718026518821716,
-0.4067821800708771,
0.5784012079238892,
0.4228343069553375,
0.4156811237335205,
0.5195029973983765,
-0.21252118051052094,
-0.47021862864494324,
0.2555570900440216,
-0.5559915900230408,
-0.7344300150871277,
1.0333644151687622,
0.5237108469009399,
0.5832851529121399,
0.01586693711578846,
0.49943557381629944,
0.46831950545310974,
0.012132268399000168,
-0.5318224430084229,
0.6957618594169617,
0.13158012926578522,
-0.4623357951641083,
-0.3010777533054352,
-0.27003055810928345,
-0.3992202877998352,
0.3267625570297241,
0.003482645843178034,
-0.766316831111908,
0.16213063895702362,
0.3097318708896637,
-0.22466206550598145,
0.3785921335220337,
-0.45385220646858215,
0.8036056160926819,
-0.10001973062753677,
-0.7431710362434387,
-0.3032161593437195,
-0.5703749656677246,
0.3343205153942108,
0.10347509384155273,
0.30375465750694275,
-0.25090116262435913,
-0.05423172190785408,
0.6309467554092407,
-0.6327476501464844,
0.7026114463806152,
-0.05243084579706192,
-0.48195257782936096,
0.6057471036911011,
0.38309910893440247,
0.917495608329773,
0.05712605267763138,
-0.3160954713821411,
0.0868731290102005,
0.01846516691148281,
-0.45638322830200195,
-0.7579143047332764,
0.7183921933174133,
-0.4860915541648865,
-0.4828651547431946,
-0.6649417281150818,
-0.12049893289804459,
-0.45613110065460205,
0.05093853175640106,
0.0640144869685173,
0.3474658727645874,
0.1734943389892578,
-0.4350680112838745,
0.9827655553817749,
-0.0790383443236351,
0.005618472117930651,
0.4480801224708557,
-0.16090644896030426,
-0.28947538137435913,
0.7137706875801086,
-0.06336252391338348,
0.5344716906547546,
0.2742570638656616,
0.06102969869971275,
-0.46762552857398987,
-0.45509710907936096,
-0.690215528011322,
0.1870984584093094,
-1.0443215370178223,
-0.15992167592048645,
-0.48736515641212463,
-0.15522262454032898,
-0.1195397600531578,
0.16854099929332733,
-0.6136414408683777,
-0.3383864164352417,
-0.05465409532189369,
-0.31701919436454773,
0.16678625345230103,
0.8645943403244019,
-0.11186836659908295,
-0.389566034078598,
-0.40704652667045593,
0.4788348972797394,
0.2575387954711914,
0.5867462158203125,
0.11791818588972092,
-0.3016600012779236,
0.1530812829732895,
0.1838531494140625,
-0.4304688572883606,
-0.6667167544364929,
-0.18945243954658508,
-0.09139320254325867,
0.43072471022605896,
0.09825125336647034,
0.2792503237724304,
0.7002284526824951,
-0.36241215467453003,
0.8272790312767029,
0.19027946889400482,
-1.110247015953064,
0.8502210974693298,
0.1692921668291092,
0.10768064856529236,
0.40588000416755676,
0.3369276821613312,
-0.23131372034549713,
-0.631502628326416,
-0.6787856817245483,
-0.7383377552032471,
0.6387025117874146,
0.1658887416124344,
-0.47309887409210205,
-0.2025900036096573,
0.40356534719467163,
0.24054431915283203,
-0.10134094208478928,
-0.3925315737724304,
-0.38430264592170715,
0.2036510407924652,
0.15299105644226074,
0.17386206984519958,
-0.22758160531520844,
0.006919288542121649,
0.06497134268283844,
0.9381613731384277,
-0.3830295205116272,
0.16506625711917877,
0.6647297143936157,
0.11067637801170349,
-0.5984224081039429,
0.3173748850822449,
0.41539549827575684,
1.3215365409851074,
-0.16368389129638672,
0.5059359073638916,
0.21755322813987732,
-0.3323177099227905,
0.32132846117019653,
-0.37048232555389404,
-0.022214563563466072,
-0.0062418244779109955,
0.5746240019798279,
0.50324946641922,
-0.08153273165225983,
-0.785618007183075,
0.5377904772758484,
-0.05626687780022621,
-0.14716163277626038,
-0.12329593300819397,
0.25927895307540894,
-0.2080381214618683,
0.2817763686180115,
0.2299201637506485,
0.42160776257514954,
0.07953018695116043,
-0.7210785746574402,
0.3464968502521515,
0.15160465240478516,
-0.44731634855270386,
-0.18867474794387817,
0.42357996106147766,
0.15711914002895355,
-0.34931254386901855,
0.6078661680221558,
-0.24854247272014618,
-0.5313894152641296,
0.6173951029777527,
0.46441423892974854,
0.6333236694335938,
-0.13961651921272278,
0.3781825304031372,
0.631923496723175,
0.2346470206975937,
-0.33362993597984314,
0.5242830514907837,
-0.17576618492603302,
-0.6544138193130493,
-0.5563202500343323,
-0.3447178304195404,
-0.6732734441757202,
0.054865334182977676,
-0.8390121459960938,
0.11261220276355743,
-0.5661291480064392,
-0.062010105699300766,
0.03072734735906124,
0.18129383027553558,
-0.553437352180481,
0.48054853081703186,
-0.12501750886440277,
0.9959017038345337,
-0.906300961971283,
0.8877222537994385,
0.541298508644104,
-0.1999502182006836,
-0.8054497838020325,
0.14041486382484436,
-0.06425606459379196,
-0.6985430717468262,
0.46881070733070374,
0.2456047385931015,
-0.5836417078971863,
-0.37562504410743713,
-0.19846674799919128,
-0.6172335147857666,
1.0377182960510254,
0.1149275004863739,
-0.6852826476097107,
0.12754406034946442,
0.03738603740930557,
0.6608273983001709,
-0.2900311052799225,
0.41617125272750854,
0.7783581614494324,
0.2748633325099945,
0.20909124612808228,
-1.034197211265564,
0.4480955898761749,
-0.06596297025680542,
-0.003952880389988422,
0.29959431290626526,
-0.1712387651205063,
0.6037967205047607,
-0.5721787810325623,
-0.3342211842536926,
0.13336670398712158,
0.43353259563446045,
0.7659211158752441,
0.5854410529136658,
0.602609395980835,
0.5313714146614075,
1.0407060384750366,
-0.05687050148844719,
1.0050363540649414,
-0.11307370662689209,
0.23518095910549164,
1.313329815864563,
-0.43315398693084717,
1.1350035667419434,
0.5422123074531555,
-0.5902407169342041,
0.8548246622085571,
0.49759262800216675,
0.45060446858406067,
0.3490217924118042,
0.466523677110672,
-0.15811723470687866,
-0.4314674437046051,
0.06763018667697906,
-0.16479045152664185,
0.07766947150230408,
0.4147688150405884,
-0.4139142632484436,
0.006626754067838192,
-0.4486248791217804,
-0.21375253796577454,
0.5117291808128357,
-0.21020153164863586,
0.6205397248268127,
-0.053561028093099594,
-1.0991754531860352,
0.8546260595321655,
-0.235428586602211,
0.24592316150665283,
-0.2558707296848297,
-0.40544405579566956,
-0.0475865937769413,
0.3606621026992798,
-0.2261073738336563,
-1.2034393548965454,
0.285801500082016,
0.05729394406080246,
-0.23240633308887482,
-0.1819113940000534,
0.6325816512107849,
-0.19709338247776031,
-0.3790092170238495,
0.4649016261100769,
0.7295185327529907,
0.225004181265831,
-0.09054898470640182,
-0.6733761429786682,
0.17312325537204742,
-0.06219026446342468,
-0.07356791198253632,
0.03690901771187782,
0.42226529121398926,
-0.23638321459293365,
0.8345662355422974,
0.5122140049934387,
0.10583925247192383,
-0.0350637249648571,
0.0907776951789856,
0.588433563709259,
-0.44905468821525574,
-0.3518020510673523,
-0.6282060146331787,
0.3315296173095703,
-0.12012364715337753,
-0.39139896631240845,
0.5283325910568237,
0.6259938478469849,
1.0821951627731323,
0.1405668556690216,
0.742785632610321,
0.05668218433856964,
0.766115128993988,
-0.5632084012031555,
0.11171411722898483,
-0.21573567390441895,
0.6275597810745239,
-0.3204570412635803,
-0.7223107218742371,
-0.08283291012048721,
0.6097466349601746,
-0.23420631885528564,
-0.1097162589430809,
1.1516684293746948,
1.006067156791687,
0.08394543826580048,
0.1788795441389084,
0.1319940835237503,
0.18691451847553253,
0.33057844638824463,
0.7003501653671265,
0.731468677520752,
-0.8552079796791077,
0.4954392910003662,
-0.5389676690101624,
-0.3743392527103424,
0.07270191609859467,
-0.8976150155067444,
-0.860947847366333,
-0.454527348279953,
-0.8118346333503723,
-0.9391904473304749,
0.36361414194107056,
0.5860875844955444,
0.4569733738899231,
-0.9692142009735107,
-0.18274043500423431,
-0.6821945905685425,
0.45653411746025085,
-0.9348563551902771,
-0.19676345586776733,
0.313294917345047,
-0.16693750023841858,
-0.4209297001361847,
0.44071680307388306,
0.3460352122783661,
-0.14672324061393738,
-0.16612718999385834,
-0.22806566953659058,
-0.4243251383304596,
0.14875571429729462,
0.43578633666038513,
0.23642310500144958,
-1.0888231992721558,
-0.6398060321807861,
-0.15371228754520416,
-0.030938444659113884,
0.09938997775316238,
0.9008185267448425,
-0.8890638947486877,
0.4117286205291748,
0.6814895272254944,
0.27704089879989624,
0.4028310179710388,
0.13117769360542297,
0.7407631874084473,
-0.6204842329025269,
-0.5699965953826904,
0.07017911225557327,
0.2854384481906891,
0.2227160483598709,
-0.3559936285018921,
0.8753300309181213,
0.10869268327951431,
-0.6244508028030396,
-0.7869810461997986,
0.3371666371822357,
-0.892959475517273,
-0.2198619544506073,
1.107530951499939,
-0.5420185327529907,
-0.20470112562179565,
-0.3285084068775177,
-0.1816733181476593,
0.11123275756835938,
-0.3147856593132019,
0.6640667915344238,
0.5906176567077637,
-0.5524804592132568,
-0.066651850938797,
-0.32721635699272156,
0.355652391910553,
0.24817125499248505,
-0.8610126972198486,
0.533772349357605,
0.4195592403411865,
0.47619691491127014,
0.44950413703918457,
0.7860696911811829,
-0.05733814835548401,
0.6956706643104553,
0.03855716437101364,
-0.3109763562679291,
0.06003560125827789,
-0.44155222177505493,
-0.05295426771044731,
0.2741129696369171,
0.35425323247909546,
-0.19468221068382263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10527v1 | Zero-shot sampling of adversarial entities in biomedical question answering | 2024-02-16T09:29:38 | 2024-02-16T09:29:38 | R. Patrick Xian, Alex J. Lee, Vincent Wang, Qiming Cui, Russell Ro, Reza Abbasi-Asl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, stat.AP | The increasing depth of parametric domain knowledge in large language models
(LLMs) is fueling their rapid deployment in real-world applications. In
high-stakes and knowledge-intensive tasks, understanding model vulnerabilities
is essential for quantifying the trustworthiness of model predictions and
regulating their use. The recent discovery of named entities as adversarial
examples in natural language processing tasks raises questions about their
potential guises in other settings. Here, we propose a powerscaled
distance-weighted sampling scheme in embedding space to discover diverse
adversarial entities as distractors. We demonstrate its advantage over random
sampling in adversarial question answering on biomedical topics. Our approach
enables the exploration of different regions on the attack surface, which
reveals two regimes of adversarial entities that markedly differ in their
characteristics. Moreover, we show that the attacks successfully manipulate
token-wise Shapley value explanations, which become deceptive in the
adversarial setting. Our investigations illustrate the brittleness of domain
knowledge in LLMs and reveal a shortcoming of standard evaluations for
high-capacity models. | [
-0.27193403244018555,
-1.1044186353683472,
0.9289535284042358,
-0.3790617883205414,
0.032598789781332016,
-0.04813729599118233,
0.00044287260971032083,
-0.298539936542511,
0.27529892325401306,
0.6777172684669495,
-0.4248266816139221,
-0.3835323750972748,
-0.7762584686279297,
-0.15597254037857056,
-0.3752913177013397,
1.11638343334198,
0.10096729546785355,
0.1963154673576355,
-0.4828231930732727,
-0.3327367305755615,
-0.02104082517325878,
-0.5220199227333069,
-0.544305145740509,
-0.20776338875293732,
0.7972683310508728,
-0.20583568513393402,
0.7703696489334106,
0.52360600233078,
0.5499536991119385,
0.16964416205883026,
-0.17659974098205566,
0.12524206936359406,
-0.44278964400291443,
0.3370921015739441,
-0.2926083505153656,
-0.6198058724403381,
-0.22598019242286682,
0.0802973285317421,
0.34816619753837585,
0.9930568933486938,
0.004488667007535696,
0.0023147198371589184,
-0.29484719038009644,
0.3347839415073395,
-0.8520875573158264,
-0.23268848657608032,
-0.8730558753013611,
0.077946238219738,
-0.3116554021835327,
-0.28143277764320374,
-0.4027527868747711,
0.047533486038446426,
0.18949949741363525,
-0.670339822769165,
0.4592351019382477,
0.0009239348582923412,
0.9928544759750366,
0.5961231589317322,
-0.18550392985343933,
-0.294115275144577,
-0.48235002160072327,
0.9086890816688538,
-0.4249119460582733,
0.025591189041733742,
0.36243051290512085,
0.31866490840911865,
-0.16673758625984192,
-0.49997571110725403,
-0.38006463646888733,
-0.25328996777534485,
0.07834078371524811,
-0.1133655235171318,
-0.513228714466095,
0.09251487255096436,
0.1970500648021698,
0.04107291251420975,
-0.5805057883262634,
-0.022153306752443314,
-0.4800161123275757,
-0.15718451142311096,
0.48025551438331604,
-0.0341360904276371,
0.3287166655063629,
-0.03599611297249794,
-0.5305871963500977,
-0.0272428710013628,
-0.7632814645767212,
-0.2643730044364929,
0.2606385350227356,
0.15805384516716003,
0.16981230676174164,
0.4351540207862854,
0.10791822522878647,
0.7834303379058838,
0.12592321634292603,
0.19780880212783813,
-0.08862321078777313,
-0.11739079654216766,
-0.37377509474754333,
-0.19893774390220642,
0.6168785691261292,
-0.005139071494340897,
0.09693305939435959,
-0.5399483442306519,
0.15426906943321228,
-0.45224127173423767,
0.689455509185791,
-0.8279578685760498,
-0.2175883799791336,
0.47415968775749207,
-0.11426785588264465,
-0.398482084274292,
-0.21934638917446136,
-0.6624830961227417,
-0.6290174722671509,
0.23941536247730255,
0.4034253656864166,
-0.7313225865364075,
0.10024455189704895,
-0.008424932137131691,
-0.3178836703300476,
0.11407847702503204,
0.21728312969207764,
-0.516127347946167,
0.08139839768409729,
0.4975842237472534,
0.6052266359329224,
-0.03236550837755203,
-0.22412075102329254,
-0.6281936764717102,
0.09017249196767807,
-0.2238437831401825,
0.6466856002807617,
-0.3448987603187561,
-0.4263969659805298,
-0.1827777922153473,
-0.1751338690519333,
-0.1268465518951416,
-0.5947746634483337,
0.32531630992889404,
-0.8558310270309448,
0.047187600284814835,
-0.45557916164398193,
-0.5447452664375305,
-0.23981188237667084,
0.48356902599334717,
-0.6752219796180725,
0.614352285861969,
0.29611870646476746,
-0.9608907699584961,
0.3339878022670746,
-0.4629236161708832,
-0.3051660358905792,
0.249874085187912,
-0.2703057527542114,
-0.48226219415664673,
0.035821326076984406,
0.4412460923194885,
0.6554478406906128,
-0.01446867547929287,
0.1497536450624466,
-0.7856898903846741,
-0.18111909925937653,
0.5779086947441101,
-0.4574050009250641,
1.0303406715393066,
0.23321102559566498,
-0.19708788394927979,
-0.07550406455993652,
-0.6149085760116577,
0.022467341274023056,
0.36662569642066956,
0.17589573562145233,
-0.6969662308692932,
-0.1449655443429947,
-0.3100428283214569,
0.03545614331960678,
0.10527527332305908,
-0.6753830313682556,
0.044158175587654114,
-0.4963020086288452,
0.25204184651374817,
0.4090792238712311,
0.4567870497703552,
0.39225319027900696,
-0.3888857364654541,
0.7403522729873657,
0.1419399082660675,
-0.05682175233960152,
0.009860135614871979,
-0.28004488348960876,
-0.23959873616695404,
-0.5792266130447388,
0.26722660660743713,
0.3869780898094177,
-1.1544452905654907,
0.176295667886734,
-0.11749856173992157,
-0.5713863968849182,
-0.6566274166107178,
-0.010203768499195576,
0.5328534245491028,
0.4953450858592987,
0.7491424679756165,
0.10853782296180725,
-0.1817471981048584,
-0.8393509984016418,
-0.3142217695713043,
-0.0407152883708477,
-0.40891602635383606,
0.6021010279655457,
0.7102900147438049,
0.048750534653663635,
0.7538011074066162,
-0.6372124552726746,
-0.12095223367214203,
-0.1506587415933609,
-0.08119542896747589,
-0.3275522291660309,
0.11370599269866943,
0.7347211241722107,
-0.8702638149261475,
0.0865376740694046,
-0.6845676898956299,
-0.7925879955291748,
0.06459726393222809,
-0.20217087864875793,
-0.2250225991010666,
-0.3459470570087433,
0.4524567127227783,
-0.7768200039863586,
0.15608593821525574,
0.48155805468559265,
-0.14310942590236664,
0.38400328159332275,
-0.1866852343082428,
0.0712474063038826,
-1.148012638092041,
0.24648165702819824,
-0.031317297369241714,
-0.1865774393081665,
-0.8092211484909058,
0.5882434248924255,
0.02120641991496086,
-0.049754396080970764,
-0.6986730694770813,
0.6465367078781128,
-0.4334462285041809,
0.18511712551116943,
-0.11406335234642029,
0.42548781633377075,
0.316202312707901,
0.21916449069976807,
-0.06481568515300751,
0.5646212100982666,
0.5517255663871765,
-0.5809755325317383,
0.2994024455547333,
0.2230607122182846,
0.005550398025661707,
0.796366274356842,
-0.751008152961731,
0.10158100724220276,
-0.3571566641330719,
0.3346501886844635,
-0.7049774527549744,
-0.2717207074165344,
0.05446475371718407,
-0.745481550693512,
0.492321252822876,
-0.12363797426223755,
-0.2402023822069168,
-0.15611520409584045,
-0.35916030406951904,
0.533454418182373,
0.2859272360801697,
-0.3265096843242645,
0.20975476503372192,
0.6727756857872009,
-0.007529507856816053,
-0.7415299415588379,
-0.8751195669174194,
-0.09324941039085388,
-0.2317412942647934,
-0.38504722714424133,
0.3777009844779968,
0.13485346734523773,
-0.4666885435581207,
0.11634109914302826,
0.06918720155954361,
-0.17963002622127533,
0.3319782018661499,
0.3942902684211731,
0.23804622888565063,
-0.01262135710567236,
0.1609816551208496,
-0.2863906919956207,
0.21925783157348633,
0.14246173202991486,
-0.3067261874675751,
0.3543834090232849,
0.2699226438999176,
-0.8043265342712402,
0.05581040680408478,
0.22044216096401215,
0.5361121892929077,
-0.19948677718639374,
0.8975043296813965,
0.4682767391204834,
-0.6940057873725891,
-0.32127660512924194,
-0.4046610891819,
-0.2575930655002594,
-0.39499765634536743,
0.7130769491195679,
-0.17063008248806,
-0.8292977213859558,
0.5134140253067017,
0.2888464629650116,
-0.0969872772693634,
0.44151708483695984,
0.6614494919776917,
0.04204786196351051,
0.6392397284507751,
0.2741663455963135,
-0.1316651850938797,
0.04675450921058655,
-0.25926241278648376,
0.24304433166980743,
-0.842989981174469,
-0.2923380732536316,
-0.3878856897354126,
-0.1804313063621521,
-0.1495029330253601,
-0.9016748070716858,
0.5165083408355713,
-0.006701276171952486,
0.09305883198976517,
0.25081953406333923,
-0.3641808331012726,
0.3449845314025879,
0.42282694578170776,
0.2762436866760254,
-0.16745077073574066,
0.014825493097305298,
-0.15440534055233002,
0.050289981067180634,
-0.6075867414474487,
-0.22014471888542175,
1.1750127077102661,
0.3295629918575287,
0.7663435339927673,
-0.14291732013225555,
0.6750768423080444,
-0.02304849959909916,
0.208039790391922,
-0.6799091100692749,
0.3467254936695099,
-0.05432230979204178,
-0.9082236886024475,
-0.3445320725440979,
-0.5143342614173889,
-1.0918668508529663,
0.11615070700645447,
0.15242789685726166,
-0.6933576464653015,
0.0958598256111145,
-0.05802220106124878,
-0.9962409734725952,
0.7182070016860962,
-0.2202516496181488,
0.5044018626213074,
0.034397806972265244,
-0.17723707854747772,
0.11831717193126678,
-0.5515496730804443,
0.32284805178642273,
0.04135947301983833,
0.19601310789585114,
-0.09039256721735,
-0.0482071153819561,
0.5669254660606384,
-0.3198009133338928,
0.6470373868942261,
-0.36974987387657166,
-0.054428581148386,
0.4713405966758728,
0.19520726799964905,
0.2431686669588089,
0.20611922442913055,
-0.2498256266117096,
0.18043793737888336,
0.09633874148130417,
-0.7797167301177979,
-0.5622249841690063,
0.7331632375717163,
-0.5248976349830627,
-0.46234196424484253,
-0.31820204854011536,
-0.8533366918563843,
-0.4951578974723816,
-0.019866468384861946,
0.39817532896995544,
0.2383510023355484,
-0.3585022985935211,
0.42362740635871887,
1.052985668182373,
-0.38991427421569824,
0.18748264014720917,
0.5997819304466248,
0.3350011706352234,
-0.2807769477367401,
0.7528563737869263,
0.0824958011507988,
0.4565941095352173,
0.6091029644012451,
-0.33456170558929443,
-0.23169496655464172,
-0.6905183792114258,
-0.6801802515983582,
0.07283052802085876,
-0.4218706786632538,
-0.3779314160346985,
-0.7886611819267273,
-0.26193687319755554,
-0.41690078377723694,
-0.3026030957698822,
-0.30446311831474304,
-0.3407035171985626,
-0.27689996361732483,
-0.16436538100242615,
0.31601041555404663,
0.3223308026790619,
0.1927531361579895,
-0.04170546680688858,
-0.6943257451057434,
0.3701103925704956,
0.3396916389465332,
-0.05092751979827881,
-0.18778719007968903,
-0.5688096284866333,
-0.13733041286468506,
0.33902162313461304,
-0.2770666778087616,
-1.1894890069961548,
0.4938865005970001,
0.06303193420171738,
0.6307415962219238,
0.3466394543647766,
0.14719492197036743,
0.4928188621997833,
-0.4581810235977173,
0.912865161895752,
-0.18029239773750305,
-0.3733246922492981,
0.4450683891773224,
-0.23731061816215515,
0.2697550058364868,
0.618582546710968,
0.625786542892456,
-0.35272374749183655,
-0.7118591070175171,
-0.9708521962165833,
-0.8043574094772339,
0.42692556977272034,
0.23402321338653564,
0.05637192353606224,
-0.14083215594291687,
0.5875211954116821,
-0.23457202315330505,
0.12152737379074097,
-0.31770089268684387,
-0.4814370572566986,
0.13210804760456085,
-0.0974477082490921,
0.07082980126142502,
-0.017766598612070084,
-0.6024620532989502,
0.20784078538417816,
0.6991428732872009,
-0.18880128860473633,
0.2684665620326996,
0.43626314401626587,
-0.2706286907196045,
-0.06658008694648743,
0.33038705587387085,
0.33278894424438477,
0.31781935691833496,
-0.08377839624881744,
0.287164568901062,
0.36692705750465393,
-0.44317254424095154,
0.09942427277565002,
0.6315452456474304,
-0.38241317868232727,
-0.05972256511449814,
0.47075122594833374,
0.43539026379585266,
0.1755519062280655,
-0.8496696352958679,
0.7689492106437683,
0.034014999866485596,
-0.21837906539440155,
-0.09822206199169159,
-0.06288028508424759,
0.09185791015625,
0.19600924849510193,
0.39021041989326477,
0.06716354936361313,
0.22585733234882355,
-0.39549317955970764,
0.5065616369247437,
0.9008121490478516,
-0.7988753318786621,
-0.22748249769210815,
0.7813071608543396,
-0.2506137192249298,
0.04002466797828674,
0.2948148250579834,
-0.31449443101882935,
-0.36225664615631104,
0.8142774105072021,
0.2576175928115845,
0.6920597553253174,
-0.16719447076320648,
0.2856850028038025,
0.013858195394277573,
0.21659956872463226,
0.3389730453491211,
0.05604792758822441,
0.11614673584699631,
-0.6879969239234924,
-0.10109719634056091,
-0.7145653367042542,
-0.520523726940155,
0.46301567554473877,
-0.8429030179977417,
-0.17557010054588318,
-0.4832907021045685,
-0.1521860510110855,
0.4053342938423157,
0.06853276491165161,
-0.5212661027908325,
0.26637277007102966,
0.2761152982711792,
0.6792768239974976,
-0.53892982006073,
0.7680830955505371,
0.6457380652427673,
-0.500491738319397,
-0.6333061456680298,
0.1505047231912613,
0.12422910332679749,
-1.012865662574768,
0.5121366381645203,
-0.15749333798885345,
0.06580813974142075,
-0.3318926692008972,
-0.5975143909454346,
-0.8269060850143433,
1.0325672626495361,
0.39368778467178345,
-0.1646505892276764,
-0.31870225071907043,
-0.0016715740785002708,
0.5991647839546204,
0.06111351028084755,
0.27041131258010864,
0.3725980222225189,
0.02633286640048027,
0.0522940494120121,
-0.539230465888977,
0.3169156312942505,
-0.1338755488395691,
-0.21061459183692932,
0.11594392359256744,
-0.6197770237922668,
0.736355185508728,
-0.5284926295280457,
-0.06694942712783813,
0.12948475778102875,
0.5306980013847351,
0.6058765649795532,
0.21708089113235474,
0.332243412733078,
0.6218571662902832,
0.8450674414634705,
0.021017814055085182,
1.2352969646453857,
-0.4757015109062195,
0.27121952176094055,
0.870322048664093,
-0.2035522162914276,
0.5481375455856323,
0.630246639251709,
-0.313770592212677,
0.2406051903963089,
0.37417227029800415,
-0.22825311124324799,
0.372314453125,
0.4496591091156006,
-0.36693036556243896,
-0.11390192061662674,
-0.15273694694042206,
-0.26878833770751953,
0.24080489575862885,
0.5104773044586182,
-0.4507931172847748,
-0.4896259009838104,
0.13494408130645752,
0.38988393545150757,
-0.0814364030957222,
-0.06794919818639755,
0.5261184573173523,
0.1687302142381668,
-0.5141520500183105,
0.5347827672958374,
0.11321031302213669,
0.5495749115943909,
-0.679527997970581,
0.11312231421470642,
0.04981908202171326,
0.17265532910823822,
0.07804691791534424,
-0.6330620646476746,
0.26126983761787415,
0.01899263635277748,
-0.10564553737640381,
-0.16016459465026855,
0.663828432559967,
-0.4517374634742737,
-0.31702107191085815,
0.18065617978572845,
0.5105583667755127,
0.18690171837806702,
-0.5155781507492065,
-0.7618994116783142,
-0.6211093068122864,
-0.2109117954969406,
-0.37940481305122375,
0.6270853281021118,
0.46394795179367065,
0.18112783133983612,
0.7889309525489807,
0.5483177304267883,
0.4302728772163391,
-0.09046218544244766,
0.03491249307990074,
0.7526432871818542,
-0.2862258851528168,
-0.18178285658359528,
-0.9266707897186279,
0.034850895404815674,
-0.12226390093564987,
-0.14212077856063843,
0.9489583373069763,
0.46155211329460144,
0.6682354211807251,
0.09431817382574081,
0.706027626991272,
0.030486924573779106,
0.5135287642478943,
-0.2560822367668152,
1.0542707443237305,
-0.541534423828125,
0.16668826341629028,
0.03392376750707626,
-0.14772577583789825,
-0.34239983558654785,
0.1263025403022766,
-0.5257810950279236,
0.06178293377161026,
0.6550998687744141,
0.7957838773727417,
0.10442911088466644,
-0.20929180085659027,
0.6062116026878357,
0.16955402493476868,
0.39376887679100037,
0.7067095041275024,
0.42719441652297974,
-0.47038307785987854,
0.7438960671424866,
-0.36187654733657837,
-0.09156373888254166,
-0.14320501685142517,
-0.5604954957962036,
-0.8812138438224792,
-0.28803157806396484,
-0.3117826282978058,
-0.5143747329711914,
0.3331615924835205,
0.5053419470787048,
0.8821789026260376,
-0.9118367433547974,
0.6713985204696655,
0.2177909016609192,
0.11830706894397736,
-0.03683342784643173,
-0.2858463525772095,
0.45437508821487427,
-0.28400033712387085,
-0.6640428304672241,
0.44612863659858704,
0.2662181556224823,
0.049905262887477875,
-0.5185884237289429,
0.40471139550209045,
-0.18958885967731476,
0.46776458621025085,
0.17636117339134216,
0.35317662358283997,
-0.6167786121368408,
-0.16202162206172943,
0.20094771683216095,
-0.3756229877471924,
-0.3005598783493042,
0.6979939937591553,
-0.832107663154602,
0.3031119406223297,
0.23728585243225098,
0.883544921875,
0.18309630453586578,
0.10933876037597656,
0.32542985677719116,
-1.1162952184677124,
0.14530789852142334,
0.6252802610397339,
0.36298903822898865,
0.4829219877719879,
-0.683978259563446,
0.09146668016910553,
0.3240594267845154,
-0.4694749414920807,
-0.7765357494354248,
0.2086559385061264,
-0.6938842535018921,
-0.6534069180488586,
1.2605793476104736,
-0.47880029678344727,
-0.3408038020133972,
-0.08815222233533859,
0.16236184537410736,
0.2178516536951065,
-0.028971491381525993,
0.7775344848632812,
0.6480029821395874,
-0.03299108147621155,
0.3339577615261078,
-0.7808659076690674,
0.6361615061759949,
0.4822429418563843,
-0.8286788463592529,
-0.029430337250232697,
0.23097141087055206,
0.4673280417919159,
0.3315320312976837,
0.635278046131134,
-0.32852262258529663,
0.2353750318288803,
0.2850184440612793,
-0.1285238116979599,
-0.19479073584079742,
-0.17146389186382294,
-0.3887721300125122,
0.6534578204154968,
-0.23622263967990875,
-0.22324375808238983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10524v1 | LLM Comparator: Visual Analytics for Side-by-Side Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T09:14:49 | 2024-02-16T09:14:49 | Minsuk Kahng, Ian Tenney, Mahima Pushkarna, Michael Xieyang Liu, James Wexler, Emily Reif, Krystal Kallarackal, Minsuk Chang, Michael Terry, Lucas Dixon | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Automatic side-by-side evaluation has emerged as a promising approach to
evaluating the quality of responses from large language models (LLMs). However,
analyzing the results from this evaluation approach raises scalability and
interpretability challenges. In this paper, we present LLM Comparator, a novel
visual analytics tool for interactively analyzing results from automatic
side-by-side evaluation. The tool supports interactive workflows for users to
understand when and why a model performs better or worse than a baseline model,
and how the responses from two models are qualitatively different. We
iteratively designed and developed the tool by closely working with researchers
and engineers at a large technology company. This paper details the user
challenges we identified, the design and development of the tool, and an
observational study with participants who regularly evaluate their models. | [
-0.5794829726219177,
-0.7638715505599976,
0.6357696652412415,
0.45536068081855774,
-0.477640300989151,
0.3728921115398407,
-0.1848510205745697,
-0.4313492476940155,
0.22931653261184692,
0.24913686513900757,
-0.6363108158111572,
-0.6135557293891907,
-0.7353178858757019,
-0.0556240938603878,
-0.5558893084526062,
0.581199586391449,
-0.05381091684103012,
0.222428098320961,
-0.823708176612854,
-0.33760249614715576,
-0.7180267572402954,
-0.30333635210990906,
-0.9687056541442871,
-0.4104408025741577,
0.32384613156318665,
0.3658277988433838,
1.098964810371399,
0.3692220151424408,
0.8290993571281433,
0.5027188658714294,
0.1689552217721939,
-0.33694320917129517,
-0.5856680870056152,
0.34270310401916504,
0.007960287854075432,
-0.27876701951026917,
-0.5539092421531677,
-0.08320774883031845,
0.4561775326728821,
0.6126758456230164,
0.10514736920595169,
0.5397537350654602,
0.27026474475860596,
0.6028648614883423,
-0.2992529571056366,
0.48777520656585693,
-0.2742340564727783,
0.13898441195487976,
-0.08783756196498871,
-0.3172151446342468,
-0.22904153168201447,
-0.4503452777862549,
-0.05224400386214256,
-0.43678978085517883,
-0.18041108548641205,
0.2058131843805313,
0.5808469653129578,
0.5726196765899658,
-0.3741973340511322,
-0.14923591911792755,
-0.1702168732881546,
0.8026208877563477,
-0.7263779640197754,
0.385168194770813,
-0.28718939423561096,
0.8211480379104614,
-0.03669530898332596,
-0.7895141839981079,
-0.6038534045219421,
-0.28927427530288696,
-0.25947487354278564,
0.25931796431541443,
-0.6792975664138794,
-0.2728668451309204,
0.2776668071746826,
0.44655266404151917,
-0.8663396239280701,
0.4742524027824402,
-0.015892988070845604,
0.018168853595852852,
0.862402081489563,
0.5752495527267456,
0.5567910671234131,
-0.14573970437049866,
-0.21357914805412292,
-0.22820135951042175,
-0.36174899339675903,
0.1855163425207138,
0.3820134401321411,
-0.05366917699575424,
-0.409790575504303,
0.7201189398765564,
-0.38553789258003235,
0.7379711270332336,
-0.07333879172801971,
0.18509447574615479,
0.377201110124588,
-0.1280813217163086,
-0.26279425621032715,
-0.3268778324127197,
1.0257952213287354,
0.7254196405410767,
0.07269115746021271,
0.12782451510429382,
-0.4401266872882843,
0.004118192940950394,
-0.013625397346913815,
-0.946329653263092,
-0.40343430638313293,
0.2568635940551758,
-0.7105022072792053,
-0.35676947236061096,
-0.281410813331604,
-0.935137152671814,
-0.7280104160308838,
-0.35991647839546204,
0.6093223690986633,
0.31125304102897644,
-0.22282780706882477,
-0.161185160279274,
-0.2057221680879593,
-0.1013808399438858,
0.5288828015327454,
-0.4474870264530182,
0.2372596114873886,
0.710290789604187,
0.8176856637001038,
-0.5276257395744324,
-0.30765673518180847,
-0.9370768666267395,
-0.396212637424469,
0.006160170771181583,
1.045129418373108,
-0.6822842359542847,
-0.5168266296386719,
-0.18371900916099548,
-0.3119189739227295,
0.15948744118213654,
-0.6969043612480164,
0.18582814931869507,
-0.462492972612381,
-0.04896439611911774,
-0.14960820972919464,
-0.45627355575561523,
0.17116712033748627,
0.22735919058322906,
-0.948226273059845,
0.9376714825630188,
0.00010582426330074668,
-1.0816758871078491,
0.5196667313575745,
-0.5455604195594788,
0.022780878469347954,
0.3794226348400116,
-0.7120857834815979,
-0.5550030469894409,
0.1536671221256256,
0.29824182391166687,
0.44864392280578613,
-0.5536037683486938,
0.13094034790992737,
-0.7470256686210632,
-0.3268657624721527,
0.3281400501728058,
-0.4231002628803253,
0.8649366497993469,
0.2135230153799057,
-0.1951988935470581,
0.7608838081359863,
-0.8824670910835266,
0.16982507705688477,
0.23518218100070953,
-0.2485983520746231,
-0.1372976303100586,
0.025564078241586685,
0.04072332754731178,
0.25430387258529663,
0.5142460465431213,
-0.27203384041786194,
0.09118594974279404,
0.03387121483683586,
0.20671139657497406,
0.4987589120864868,
-0.036726534366607666,
0.23699969053268433,
-0.12146661430597305,
0.8670791387557983,
-0.2523137927055359,
0.338135689496994,
0.29228267073631287,
-0.43739795684814453,
-0.9111267328262329,
-0.3092392683029175,
0.11209015548229218,
0.3941223621368408,
-0.9338918924331665,
0.27012911438941956,
-0.5035498738288879,
-0.594612717628479,
-0.5444629192352295,
0.2586343288421631,
0.20144028961658478,
0.298528790473938,
0.16505727171897888,
-0.37821757793426514,
-0.397812157869339,
-1.086759090423584,
-0.44879695773124695,
-0.18020831048488617,
-0.29642337560653687,
0.04447667673230171,
0.44110268354415894,
-0.13232573866844177,
0.7978991270065308,
-0.39761075377464294,
0.09097267687320709,
-0.3543788492679596,
0.5293017029762268,
0.17450402677059174,
0.11620223522186279,
0.3786146640777588,
-0.5802749395370483,
-0.6250113844871521,
0.11750395596027374,
-0.8294298052787781,
-0.6262363791465759,
0.0904933288693428,
0.09049791842699051,
-0.03777368739247322,
0.7091333866119385,
-0.2767103612422943,
0.4698147177696228,
0.9110330939292908,
-0.18434303998947144,
0.4627399444580078,
-0.13622352480888367,
0.3239296078681946,
-0.769875168800354,
0.19040447473526,
-0.041925959289073944,
-0.2406429499387741,
-0.2187161147594452,
0.21978162229061127,
-0.08132666349411011,
-0.26364627480506897,
-0.33815163373947144,
0.6995316743850708,
-0.4657624661922455,
-0.46564382314682007,
-0.3241823613643646,
0.2831583023071289,
0.01641697622835636,
0.15844784677028656,
-0.03251061588525772,
0.7416882514953613,
0.3347446322441101,
-0.08621615171432495,
0.7796261310577393,
0.18677322566509247,
-0.7365303635597229,
0.7052056789398193,
-0.8737956285476685,
0.15577596426010132,
0.1974238008260727,
0.05902129411697388,
-1.0573093891143799,
-0.008658594451844692,
0.014849905855953693,
-0.44007962942123413,
-0.0757068395614624,
-0.17846553027629852,
-0.6271175146102905,
-0.5099868178367615,
-0.49707338213920593,
0.4043850898742676,
0.3152482509613037,
-0.7675818204879761,
0.7754974961280823,
0.40650472044944763,
-0.4988027513027191,
-0.22989477217197418,
-0.6292792558670044,
0.2319987416267395,
-0.40210506319999695,
-0.9612303972244263,
-0.211891308426857,
-0.414845734834671,
-0.8194991946220398,
-0.06865359097719193,
-0.1715991497039795,
-0.10261846333742142,
0.12753646075725555,
0.45684799551963806,
0.2778606712818146,
-0.1399710476398468,
-0.22940999269485474,
-0.014742565341293812,
-0.2902541756629944,
0.3163352906703949,
0.3354548215866089,
0.3521154224872589,
-0.18771600723266602,
-0.551452100276947,
-0.3744262754917145,
0.29743173718452454,
0.4333164393901825,
-0.18325771391391754,
0.4042801260948181,
0.3299647867679596,
-0.040797118097543716,
-0.18655405938625336,
-0.6078512072563171,
0.21082259714603424,
-0.5261235237121582,
0.226997509598732,
-0.6440528035163879,
-0.7409651875495911,
0.5722050070762634,
0.0431547611951828,
0.018090801313519478,
0.40153563022613525,
0.8375945091247559,
0.15562979876995087,
1.3895920515060425,
0.7256747484207153,
0.07341617345809937,
0.3818603456020355,
-0.18366128206253052,
0.24662849307060242,
-0.2837862968444824,
-0.26764988899230957,
-0.41326287388801575,
-0.3175169825553894,
-0.47310638427734375,
-0.2954941987991333,
0.6173708438873291,
-0.12748746573925018,
0.040750652551651,
0.1030803844332695,
-0.2427445650100708,
0.531909167766571,
0.3405103385448456,
-0.28803005814552307,
0.6569851040840149,
-0.10424671322107315,
-0.04462776333093643,
-0.04953598976135254,
-0.4700532853603363,
-0.4442809522151947,
0.6227084994316101,
0.35213130712509155,
0.892875075340271,
0.03258305415511131,
0.6318494081497192,
0.45433908700942993,
0.47486191987991333,
-0.963753342628479,
0.7270070314407349,
-0.03397300839424133,
-0.0783281996846199,
-0.3674950897693634,
-0.5332819819450378,
-0.8734472990036011,
0.5028644800186157,
-0.26519471406936646,
-0.7531302571296692,
-0.0031461413018405437,
0.18969981372356415,
-0.2884255647659302,
-0.03483983129262924,
-0.855052649974823,
1.1157047748565674,
-0.38176578283309937,
-0.47588440775871277,
-0.26311004161834717,
-0.3884274661540985,
0.04696567356586456,
-0.1686982661485672,
0.2830428183078766,
0.03326994925737381,
0.05978299304842949,
0.592675507068634,
-0.5627370476722717,
0.37266507744789124,
-0.09585393965244293,
-0.27110299468040466,
0.07778986543416977,
0.27822473645210266,
0.4513475000858307,
0.10745099931955338,
-0.23222549259662628,
0.19659103453159332,
0.10894422978162766,
-0.2515616714954376,
-0.9799957871437073,
0.9936008453369141,
-0.4063997268676758,
-0.848605215549469,
-0.3748350739479065,
-0.649135410785675,
-0.2693251073360443,
0.20541022717952728,
0.09899232536554337,
0.27192771434783936,
-0.17020677030086517,
0.19886696338653564,
-0.06556405127048492,
-0.41249698400497437,
0.46649542450904846,
0.5415369868278503,
-0.6233296990394592,
-0.2739713788032532,
0.7754014730453491,
-0.002715921960771084,
0.22905901074409485,
0.33247774839401245,
0.11288705468177795,
-0.34231963753700256,
-0.6861824989318848,
-0.5282939076423645,
-0.14707964658737183,
-0.9660027027130127,
0.02260936237871647,
-0.4358817934989929,
-0.02200368046760559,
-0.052627082914114,
-0.09147166460752487,
-0.1918599009513855,
-0.4069313704967499,
0.11669539660215378,
0.15783795714378357,
-0.004893218167126179,
0.9631655812263489,
0.12246491014957428,
0.24155689775943756,
-0.38991275429725647,
0.22426070272922516,
0.5518492460250854,
0.41351258754730225,
0.0426073893904686,
-0.1783696562051773,
-0.3661375939846039,
-0.24787472188472748,
-0.11849189549684525,
-0.47577375173568726,
0.44418516755104065,
-0.5262516140937805,
0.457977831363678,
0.2545798122882843,
-0.15869854390621185,
0.6545448303222656,
-0.3354232907295227,
0.592587947845459,
0.2185339778661728,
-0.9685205817222595,
0.24378471076488495,
-0.08160222321748734,
0.6155568957328796,
0.5854288339614868,
0.18804611265659332,
-0.2520381510257721,
-0.4474371373653412,
-0.27151286602020264,
-0.8283149600028992,
0.32736632227897644,
0.22653944790363312,
-0.34074991941452026,
0.2920900881290436,
-0.41665491461753845,
0.3527558743953705,
0.22581623494625092,
-0.6810270547866821,
-0.1533331274986267,
0.02747347019612789,
-0.20434574782848358,
-0.25820571184158325,
-0.08062149584293365,
-0.017118636518716812,
-0.10125976800918579,
0.33439916372299194,
-0.10494406521320343,
-0.08596359938383102,
-0.4095541834831238,
-0.3757762908935547,
-0.07526655495166779,
0.2546241581439972,
0.06149546429514885,
1.1432068347930908,
-0.12138774245977402,
0.1368696093559265,
0.4073481857776642,
0.09522198885679245,
-0.24205659329891205,
0.39115408062934875,
0.16380910575389862,
-0.05692419782280922,
0.48860108852386475,
0.7814841270446777,
0.01834256760776043,
-0.7274579405784607,
0.7979214787483215,
-0.3993946313858032,
0.12977834045886993,
-0.23539157211780548,
-0.115454763174057,
0.2094990611076355,
0.6433085203170776,
0.21793776750564575,
-0.29275211691856384,
0.6379442811012268,
-0.3674663305282593,
0.02052764594554901,
0.592186689376831,
-0.16116416454315186,
0.002139278221875429,
0.6544149518013,
0.39073053002357483,
-0.4404701888561249,
0.15565814077854156,
-0.0893000140786171,
-0.32084760069847107,
0.6710337400436401,
0.06291363388299942,
0.7790265083312988,
0.06675148755311966,
0.03879547491669655,
-0.12067274749279022,
0.08636347204446793,
0.21113209426403046,
0.2622464895248413,
-0.11645112931728363,
-0.08429963141679764,
-0.45721808075904846,
-0.5483548641204834,
-0.7630533576011658,
0.2932581305503845,
-0.8995571136474609,
0.5042394995689392,
-0.14587600529193878,
-0.20037618279457092,
0.4862304627895355,
0.08350437134504318,
-0.9508933424949646,
0.2777094542980194,
0.12928661704063416,
0.713281512260437,
-0.8164133429527283,
0.627527117729187,
0.7308976650238037,
-0.44911161065101624,
-0.39808928966522217,
-0.0382760614156723,
0.24295829236507416,
-0.9250654578208923,
0.7651011943817139,
0.14773088693618774,
-0.3910473585128784,
-0.1841067522764206,
-0.3326531648635864,
-0.6166597008705139,
0.8962718844413757,
0.47068968415260315,
-0.7780725955963135,
0.41436222195625305,
0.2696070075035095,
0.8306927680969238,
-0.24384576082229614,
0.6661049127578735,
0.47407999634742737,
0.4376969039440155,
-0.19993111491203308,
-1.1212234497070312,
0.22047166526317596,
-0.5367503762245178,
-0.014728432521224022,
0.2955482006072998,
-0.7365471720695496,
0.5923770666122437,
0.07586964964866638,
-0.13352197408676147,
0.09571775794029236,
0.6442523002624512,
0.0615355484187603,
0.6901655197143555,
0.6821507215499878,
0.5754512548446655,
0.33515653014183044,
0.13379992544651031,
0.9910825490951538,
-0.1824364811182022,
0.4753267765045166,
1.3415457010269165,
-0.2783384621143341,
0.9436488747596741,
0.6041626930236816,
-0.18187189102172852,
0.3426855504512787,
0.4706265926361084,
-0.29036572575569153,
0.18590368330478668,
0.5452700853347778,
-0.10346367210149765,
-0.31188535690307617,
0.012033860199153423,
-0.2607179582118988,
0.27382326126098633,
0.0022981532383710146,
-0.1126595064997673,
-0.3598187267780304,
-0.06088684871792793,
-0.12034770101308823,
0.13647516071796417,
-0.276288241147995,
0.570235013961792,
0.07209883630275726,
-0.5727007985115051,
0.4286741614341736,
-0.21759365499019623,
0.515513002872467,
-0.23842023313045502,
-0.11959024518728256,
-0.3395337164402008,
0.16538269817829132,
-0.31425195932388306,
-1.1220566034317017,
0.17164038121700287,
0.17051805555820465,
0.06036559119820595,
-0.2804465889930725,
0.43673309683799744,
-0.13643425703048706,
-0.5423793196678162,
0.6111561059951782,
0.7189171314239502,
0.2749153971672058,
-0.014135204255580902,
-0.9176496267318726,
0.7104259133338928,
-0.14918777346611023,
-0.4423871636390686,
0.23365263640880585,
0.3306080102920532,
-0.2006472498178482,
1.1955188512802124,
0.34529295563697815,
-0.06223660334944725,
-0.034875672310590744,
0.5786998867988586,
0.9175324440002441,
-0.45867279171943665,
-0.45311132073402405,
-0.9235101938247681,
0.5758064985275269,
-0.39638280868530273,
-0.06813462823629379,
1.1209967136383057,
0.9257046580314636,
0.8030186295509338,
0.059634819626808167,
0.7612560391426086,
0.18141987919807434,
0.3767189681529999,
-0.47279348969459534,
0.7432660460472107,
-0.8243016600608826,
0.6166220903396606,
-0.15016312897205353,
-0.9944695234298706,
-0.2911224663257599,
0.15483371913433075,
-0.49200886487960815,
0.02485000528395176,
0.7766898274421692,
0.5548315048217773,
-0.166331484913826,
-0.09213665872812271,
0.4327627122402191,
0.3552483320236206,
0.3320797383785248,
0.28815484046936035,
0.9996786713600159,
0.0636257529258728,
0.7185503244400024,
-0.21641802787780762,
-0.30024510622024536,
-0.1916382759809494,
-0.9557588696479797,
-1.2654495239257812,
-0.33269810676574707,
-0.470973938703537,
-0.2031506896018982,
0.02131163887679577,
0.8224398493766785,
0.2881650924682617,
-0.8270640969276428,
-0.6750617027282715,
0.24404507875442505,
0.04861779510974884,
0.09278524667024612,
-0.19049674272537231,
0.19203847646713257,
0.02360576204955578,
-0.8328324556350708,
0.42222893238067627,
0.4389781653881073,
-0.17066657543182373,
-0.42655956745147705,
0.08658348768949509,
0.38653674721717834,
-0.04194474592804909,
0.5536834001541138,
-0.007797693368047476,
-0.5442243218421936,
-0.0976538360118866,
-0.4609218239784241,
0.01961885206401348,
0.1395946443080902,
0.6916232705116272,
-0.6283184885978699,
0.706933856010437,
0.8748656511306763,
0.6144096851348877,
0.5984435677528381,
-0.07384373247623444,
0.5931451320648193,
-0.3331955373287201,
-0.12484407424926758,
-0.1383461058139801,
0.5250204205513,
0.4264633059501648,
-0.16185787320137024,
0.45992985367774963,
-0.19634993374347687,
-0.6184014081954956,
-0.8953286409378052,
0.09412649273872375,
-1.0639026165008545,
-0.09345567971467972,
0.9586388468742371,
-0.04575477913022041,
-0.06793934106826782,
0.14561673998832703,
-0.2471652776002884,
0.16921605169773102,
-0.43057072162628174,
0.8194659352302551,
0.7186687588691711,
-0.3579191267490387,
0.02203790284693241,
-0.8179054260253906,
0.20941658318042755,
0.5002988576889038,
-1.0959954261779785,
-0.1823548674583435,
0.5795724391937256,
0.3901083767414093,
-0.12816409766674042,
0.23667484521865845,
0.14487221837043762,
0.16124314069747925,
0.11382411420345306,
0.13043344020843506,
-0.08559893816709518,
-0.04696517065167427,
-0.7614489197731018,
0.11279463022947311,
0.3224449157714844,
-0.022831769660115242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10500v2 | Active Preference Optimization for Sample Efficient RLHF | 2024-02-16T08:19:34 | 2024-06-05T15:10:08 | Nirjhar Das, Souradip Chakraborty, Aldo Pacchiano, Sayak Ray Chowdhury | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is pivotal in aligning
Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences. Although aligned
generative models have shown remarkable abilities in various tasks, their
reliance on high-quality human preference data creates a costly bottleneck in
the practical application of RLHF. One primary reason is that current methods
rely on uniformly picking prompt-generation pairs from a dataset of
prompt-generations, to collect human feedback, resulting in sub-optimal
alignment under a constrained budget, which highlights the criticality of
adaptive strategies in efficient alignment. Recent works [Mehta et al., 2023,
Muldrew et al., 2024] have tried to address this problem by designing various
heuristics based on generation uncertainty. However, either the assumptions in
[Mehta et al., 2023] are restrictive, or [Muldrew et al., 2024] do not provide
any rigorous theoretical guarantee. To address these, we reformulate RLHF
within contextual preference bandit framework, treating prompts as contexts,
and develop an active-learning algorithm, $\textit{Active Preference
Optimization}$ ($\texttt{APO}$), which enhances model alignment by querying
preference data from the most important samples, achieving superior performance
for small sample budget. We analyze the theoretical performance guarantees of
$\texttt{APO}$ under the BTL preference model showing that the suboptimality
gap of the policy learned via $\texttt{APO}$ scales as $O(1/\sqrt{T})$ for a
budget of $T$. We also show that collecting preference data by choosing prompts
randomly leads to a policy that suffers a constant sub-optimality. We perform
detailed experimental evaluations on practical preference datasets to validate
$\texttt{APO}$'s efficacy over the existing methods, establishing it as a
sample-efficient and practical solution of alignment in a cost-effective and
scalable manner. | [
-0.2564708888530731,
-0.8436295390129089,
0.3839833438396454,
-0.042161621153354645,
-0.1995498239994049,
-0.18219970166683197,
-0.47796109318733215,
-0.2998126447200775,
0.013658540323376656,
0.4555019736289978,
-0.7789469361305237,
-0.23299282789230347,
-0.08444629609584808,
-0.15601661801338196,
0.1415957361459732,
0.8709741234779358,
-0.1770472675561905,
-0.17010462284088135,
-0.06524251401424408,
-0.2309623509645462,
-0.3162180781364441,
-0.16164110600948334,
-0.6112907528877258,
-0.32804569602012634,
0.6144815683364868,
0.6863365173339844,
0.8774704337120056,
0.9436841607093811,
0.12322066724300385,
0.20848672091960907,
-0.04661491885781288,
0.40587058663368225,
-0.4672672152519226,
0.4763435125350952,
-0.021334245800971985,
-0.30159202218055725,
-0.22867204248905182,
-0.021561669185757637,
0.5485996603965759,
0.43911299109458923,
-0.6334042549133301,
-0.06284992396831512,
-0.13854122161865234,
0.7216684222221375,
-0.8091416358947754,
0.005002517253160477,
-0.6525440812110901,
0.2028837502002716,
-0.11272835731506348,
-0.1118934154510498,
-0.4904821515083313,
-0.5671859383583069,
0.3671760559082031,
-0.8603345155715942,
0.24167566001415253,
0.3159278929233551,
1.0781904458999634,
0.4195861220359802,
-0.2972610890865326,
-0.2684568166732788,
-0.6723079085350037,
0.9009354114532471,
-0.4540766179561615,
0.28459009528160095,
0.44349926710128784,
0.3729584217071533,
-0.14062438905239105,
-0.410256952047348,
-0.47078806161880493,
-0.23136185109615326,
0.098453588783741,
0.30976301431655884,
-0.0362568236887455,
0.2423056960105896,
0.20203439891338348,
0.21390295028686523,
-0.43111610412597656,
0.24559694528579712,
-0.14883947372436523,
-0.2923838198184967,
0.7157288193702698,
-0.021438831463456154,
-0.03404952958226204,
-0.20771507918834686,
-0.4498195946216583,
-0.41756147146224976,
-0.6436433792114258,
0.3931715190410614,
0.6856257915496826,
0.4562327265739441,
-0.0016591212479397655,
0.4544581174850464,
-0.16891905665397644,
0.9068350791931152,
0.3001755177974701,
-0.16375508904457092,
0.0920030027627945,
-0.22941215336322784,
-0.08290114253759384,
0.07211510837078094,
0.7361693978309631,
0.13361890614032745,
0.30002278089523315,
0.09755021333694458,
-0.4712350368499756,
-0.17051100730895996,
0.4334336221218109,
-0.46570050716400146,
-0.20611535012722015,
0.28296107053756714,
-0.26823440194129944,
-0.30728021264076233,
-0.03223275765776634,
-0.8028977513313293,
-0.2752242982387543,
-0.19798608124256134,
0.31956103444099426,
-0.135780930519104,
-0.06446335464715958,
-0.14581282436847687,
0.22591803967952728,
0.17640061676502228,
0.40185579657554626,
-1.0446561574935913,
-0.09638646990060806,
0.390394926071167,
0.5909184813499451,
-0.3682021498680115,
-0.28902336955070496,
-0.6886361241340637,
-0.06746911257505417,
-0.4077930152416229,
0.792130172252655,
-0.449241578578949,
-0.5400194525718689,
0.22542108595371246,
-0.21485136449337006,
-0.1284203678369522,
-0.6468282341957092,
0.7305226922035217,
-0.7394965887069702,
0.26526662707328796,
-0.37225207686424255,
-0.4062891900539398,
0.05160900577902794,
0.05858341604471207,
-0.7207236886024475,
0.9844626188278198,
0.23445996642112732,
-0.41117337346076965,
0.6912159323692322,
-0.49089452624320984,
-0.2286646068096161,
-0.08425073325634003,
-0.12449328601360321,
-0.9064764976501465,
-0.13891053199768066,
0.33758944272994995,
0.18955367803573608,
0.04002467542886734,
0.32905808091163635,
-0.49926966428756714,
-0.28732168674468994,
0.30554938316345215,
-0.4363613426685333,
0.6516166925430298,
0.4213978052139282,
-0.34816187620162964,
0.6175991892814636,
-0.45509615540504456,
-0.026014074683189392,
-0.007263454608619213,
-0.6322677135467529,
-0.10425398498773575,
0.14867368340492249,
-0.0723675787448883,
-0.15548771619796753,
0.17975158989429474,
-0.34166401624679565,
0.37025681138038635,
-0.3257266581058502,
0.28110596537590027,
1.12130868434906,
0.06750063598155975,
0.6174301505088806,
-0.3233950436115265,
0.7650810480117798,
-0.30495399236679077,
0.30895495414733887,
0.04698072001338005,
-0.12543708086013794,
-0.40432289242744446,
-0.29956382513046265,
0.5731869339942932,
0.42988455295562744,
-0.5396391749382019,
0.5212545990943909,
0.013531642965972424,
-0.04457512125372887,
-0.5775119066238403,
0.1190265417098999,
0.5220442414283752,
0.6832807064056396,
0.3492657244205475,
-0.07645215094089508,
-0.4633711576461792,
-1.0851318836212158,
-0.15089505910873413,
-0.30433377623558044,
0.19485624134540558,
0.7018478512763977,
-0.09855184704065323,
0.10027934610843658,
1.145465612411499,
-0.6003733277320862,
-0.01599111221730709,
-0.2992042601108551,
0.08344733715057373,
0.09029097110033035,
0.3565785884857178,
0.3685280978679657,
-0.7971664071083069,
-0.6063567399978638,
-0.15909168124198914,
-0.36206620931625366,
-0.21706943213939667,
-0.030584948137402534,
-0.28104645013809204,
0.37414827942848206,
0.12895770370960236,
-0.497561514377594,
0.10699775069952011,
0.5437632203102112,
-0.2333241105079651,
0.3399520516395569,
-0.2101331204175949,
-0.07158719748258591,
-0.7481199502944946,
0.008384781889617443,
-0.03630908951163292,
-0.2364128828048706,
-0.30833378434181213,
-0.016861094161868095,
0.18892544507980347,
0.06136620417237282,
-0.40210965275764465,
0.6940621137619019,
-0.4306115210056305,
-0.054541561752557755,
-0.3278820514678955,
-0.05047369375824928,
-0.3195209801197052,
0.7049862146377563,
0.22785869240760803,
1.0145142078399658,
0.22436490654945374,
-0.5037537217140198,
0.30372801423072815,
0.13484561443328857,
-0.2724662721157074,
0.3661263585090637,
-0.5415289402008057,
0.051155269145965576,
-0.06757865846157074,
0.3747681975364685,
-0.8332685828208923,
-0.40721020102500916,
0.2979865074157715,
-0.3982613980770111,
0.4016200006008148,
-0.13650448620319366,
-0.010967168025672436,
-0.10483556985855103,
-0.18420852720737457,
0.4572039246559143,
0.6850671768188477,
-0.6988978385925293,
0.46804797649383545,
0.512212872505188,
0.08201619237661362,
-1.0319206714630127,
-0.039330244064331055,
-0.4633108377456665,
-0.2698839604854584,
-0.2938820421695709,
0.21366210281848907,
0.17158836126327515,
-0.18734265863895416,
0.10769277811050415,
-0.3581881523132324,
0.26156923174858093,
0.0393529050052166,
0.00759548507630825,
0.42051777243614197,
0.07124236226081848,
0.04036005586385727,
-0.04811202734708786,
-0.21258051693439484,
-0.21394284069538116,
-0.2740810513496399,
0.321022093296051,
0.1036287471652031,
-0.387874960899353,
-0.0899047926068306,
0.036575086414813995,
0.3222580552101135,
-0.10580472648143768,
0.24071021378040314,
0.4072466790676117,
-0.12419888377189636,
-0.5165415406227112,
-0.45091405510902405,
-0.21957698464393616,
-0.42331865429878235,
0.3166281282901764,
-0.22062036395072937,
-0.7438274025917053,
0.31440943479537964,
0.19754186272621155,
0.46314501762390137,
0.29871267080307007,
0.4327365756034851,
-0.1254478096961975,
0.9526812434196472,
0.2867552936077118,
-0.006023591849952936,
0.8120656609535217,
-0.07480892539024353,
-0.06062978506088257,
-0.6383241415023804,
-0.06255874782800674,
-0.395702064037323,
-0.39334508776664734,
-0.4793625771999359,
-0.2936500608921051,
0.5076132416725159,
0.18632188439369202,
-0.24986658990383148,
0.07604993134737015,
-0.48054736852645874,
0.3362223207950592,
0.817861795425415,
0.22873498499393463,
0.012027215212583542,
-0.04171818867325783,
-0.2201279103755951,
-0.009488980285823345,
-0.912334144115448,
-0.3750820457935333,
1.1509149074554443,
0.27588433027267456,
0.9742131233215332,
0.12474901974201202,
0.6557921171188354,
0.3719443380832672,
0.27723073959350586,
-0.9777984023094177,
0.4181024730205536,
0.0697212666273117,
-0.5558757781982422,
-0.744688093662262,
-0.5212403535842896,
-1.196797251701355,
0.32934650778770447,
-0.3858995735645294,
-0.45360079407691956,
0.4713689088821411,
0.7890013456344604,
-0.6964124441146851,
0.09152371436357498,
-0.7348474860191345,
0.7646411061286926,
-0.2079048454761505,
-0.6999489665031433,
-0.051552798599004745,
-0.7687472105026245,
0.4021715819835663,
0.11758103221654892,
0.018783142790198326,
-0.1441584825515747,
-0.045798130333423615,
0.7720279097557068,
-0.38684210181236267,
0.701596736907959,
-0.5297291278839111,
-0.08438912779092789,
0.37912610173225403,
-0.1663362681865692,
0.8385589718818665,
0.1659751832485199,
-0.03288102149963379,
-0.44908779859542847,
-0.17713940143585205,
-0.5862913131713867,
-0.5101137161254883,
0.5288850665092468,
-1.0217965841293335,
-0.6059303879737854,
-0.4409872591495514,
-0.42457500100135803,
-0.48897844552993774,
0.05258384346961975,
0.2577773928642273,
0.29100698232650757,
-0.1336860954761505,
0.12689754366874695,
1.026389718055725,
-0.0551699660718441,
0.5261316299438477,
0.3993111848831177,
-0.08119760453701019,
-0.649210512638092,
0.7110892534255981,
-0.03834885358810425,
0.41029301285743713,
0.38259565830230713,
0.45703303813934326,
-0.5839532017707825,
-0.4510778486728668,
-0.7818977236747742,
0.1138361319899559,
-0.41476184129714966,
-0.2354588806629181,
-0.4306972622871399,
0.06483924388885498,
-0.279438853263855,
-0.22559799253940582,
-0.4469870924949646,
-0.3979184925556183,
-0.14777228236198425,
-0.12591832876205444,
0.2757015526294708,
0.2468353807926178,
-0.1469896286725998,
0.2225656807422638,
-0.5976809859275818,
0.23812827467918396,
0.6999416351318359,
0.10557472705841064,
0.08525943011045456,
-0.3592473566532135,
-0.21706216037273407,
-0.009810751304030418,
-0.3130050599575043,
-0.8158408403396606,
0.2407202422618866,
-0.04146459698677063,
0.7884083986282349,
0.5747683644294739,
0.5428475141525269,
0.6635443568229675,
-0.2496618628501892,
0.6209006309509277,
-0.0711745098233223,
-0.6955416798591614,
0.45936107635498047,
-0.43045279383659363,
0.24867106974124908,
0.8395833373069763,
0.16620542109012604,
-0.34854090213775635,
0.034231036901474,
-0.7626373767852783,
-1.083615779876709,
0.9340460896492004,
-0.027410617098212242,
-0.0957995355129242,
0.2682422995567322,
0.4770432114601135,
0.06434443593025208,
0.16687853634357452,
-0.5538637638092041,
-0.18766871094703674,
-0.18577903509140015,
-0.21397969126701355,
-0.028394170105457306,
-0.18155673146247864,
-0.4483976364135742,
0.11745152622461319,
0.9034346342086792,
-0.29462921619415283,
0.10782425850629807,
0.18738818168640137,
0.12276598811149597,
-0.5214852094650269,
0.3859859108924866,
0.6716645359992981,
0.5518017411231995,
-0.4302758574485779,
0.03146464377641678,
0.006694577168673277,
-0.38323065638542175,
0.24422502517700195,
0.1497921645641327,
-0.6135348081588745,
-0.23777581751346588,
0.29528772830963135,
1.034145474433899,
0.16866452991962433,
-0.8315301537513733,
0.46933019161224365,
0.011630629189312458,
-0.2252967655658722,
-0.2331179976463318,
0.32877668738365173,
-0.23133797943592072,
0.09953458607196808,
0.427978515625,
0.02567351423203945,
-0.14117152988910675,
-0.495084285736084,
0.2650913596153259,
0.6625543236732483,
-0.598539412021637,
-0.1503795087337494,
0.4448266923427582,
0.3300830125808716,
-0.39512091875076294,
0.5283389091491699,
-0.1968834549188614,
-0.5083590149879456,
0.522154688835144,
0.4105079472064972,
0.8159048557281494,
-0.2331760823726654,
0.16834880411624908,
0.5009461045265198,
-0.054991669952869415,
-0.3284189701080322,
0.15322548151016235,
-0.3955792188644409,
-0.9863635897636414,
-0.14592862129211426,
-0.6221737861633301,
-0.7159391641616821,
-0.09770334511995316,
-0.8600070476531982,
0.18596436083316803,
-0.3525402545928955,
-0.07439164817333221,
-0.41004544496536255,
0.2004038393497467,
-0.2712816596031189,
0.13968151807785034,
-0.3198941946029663,
0.5982581377029419,
-0.7368260025978088,
0.7861508131027222,
0.7601363658905029,
-0.16485275328159332,
-0.9874483346939087,
0.2505261301994324,
0.0011460169916972518,
-1.1215018033981323,
0.25750893354415894,
-0.34302639961242676,
0.0388336181640625,
0.0403202548623085,
-0.4653455913066864,
-0.8842071294784546,
0.9961602687835693,
0.15663887560367584,
-0.5606818199157715,
-0.13699641823768616,
-0.642156183719635,
0.18382880091667175,
-0.2868003845214844,
0.10314153134822845,
0.4850188195705414,
0.6080378890037537,
0.36834946274757385,
-0.7756102681159973,
0.08229437470436096,
0.11244268715381622,
-0.08356912434101105,
0.4873543977737427,
-0.8447270393371582,
0.5700139403343201,
-0.35111522674560547,
-0.2680920660495758,
-0.04712199047207832,
0.7806361317634583,
0.7446618676185608,
0.23073124885559082,
0.8727464079856873,
0.5763263702392578,
0.7160319089889526,
-0.007350371219217777,
0.8726339936256409,
-0.17797839641571045,
0.4431191086769104,
0.9727399945259094,
-0.23824313282966614,
0.8110926747322083,
0.5570951104164124,
-0.41819047927856445,
0.2084273248910904,
1.0254507064819336,
0.053225018084049225,
0.8428453207015991,
0.19679154455661774,
-0.3068901002407074,
-0.39516618847846985,
-0.08153349161148071,
-0.19415125250816345,
0.15577873587608337,
0.018592223525047302,
-0.1829727441072464,
-0.13356232643127441,
-0.29009875655174255,
-0.018022138625383377,
0.2721773684024811,
-0.10964160412549973,
0.9783949851989746,
-0.2802378535270691,
-1.2601501941680908,
0.5634391903877258,
-0.08997207880020142,
0.6886379718780518,
-0.7539680004119873,
0.09707280993461609,
-0.292029470205307,
0.12298821657896042,
-0.0910375565290451,
-0.4961335361003876,
0.02726846933364868,
-0.23032228648662567,
-0.22548525035381317,
-0.37218114733695984,
0.40000176429748535,
-0.43731653690338135,
-0.1056092381477356,
-0.10416539758443832,
0.3559190034866333,
-0.22007228434085846,
0.5335623621940613,
-0.7288365960121155,
-0.05360366404056549,
0.25391674041748047,
-0.5131306052207947,
0.3936535716056824,
0.18126076459884644,
-0.1383979171514511,
0.4020306169986725,
0.7655463218688965,
0.33937329053878784,
-0.1453370451927185,
-0.06665489822626114,
0.558035671710968,
-0.5209996104240417,
-0.5706028342247009,
-0.6066704988479614,
0.28391385078430176,
-0.019608354195952415,
-0.5745905637741089,
0.4977149963378906,
0.47881266474723816,
0.7652902007102966,
0.13671256601810455,
0.854672908782959,
0.061983127146959305,
0.5327557921409607,
-0.7438303828239441,
0.3042638897895813,
-0.5282400250434875,
0.3642936944961548,
0.06598176062107086,
-0.8763347268104553,
-0.019059689715504646,
0.7497773766517639,
-0.25020498037338257,
0.1525479257106781,
0.5044679641723633,
0.7975157499313354,
-0.040064629167318344,
-0.11928793042898178,
0.14311890304088593,
-0.1781185269355774,
0.1359919309616089,
0.49171802401542664,
0.7689747214317322,
0.018230939283967018,
0.5875662565231323,
-0.33125782012939453,
-0.3780936300754547,
-0.25769224762916565,
-0.8080854415893555,
-0.5003100633621216,
-0.4672625958919525,
-0.17118777334690094,
-0.5610875487327576,
0.3103249967098236,
1.3704191446304321,
0.8855019807815552,
-0.7642038464546204,
-0.26493021845817566,
-0.19943128526210785,
0.36691728234291077,
-0.5152007341384888,
-0.2668992280960083,
0.5448322892189026,
-0.43637746572494507,
-0.8499389290809631,
0.32227686047554016,
-0.01688818447291851,
0.14167696237564087,
-0.33206334710121155,
-0.3425026834011078,
-0.1290222853422165,
0.12319343537092209,
0.20992179214954376,
0.7340350151062012,
-0.9375100135803223,
-0.25703659653663635,
0.1448187381029129,
-0.12349963188171387,
0.011485759168863297,
1.0017110109329224,
-0.6300466656684875,
0.41182297468185425,
0.4660121202468872,
0.7897165417671204,
0.4990167021751404,
0.5097554326057434,
0.7266682386398315,
-0.6683329939842224,
-0.1293785125017166,
0.37070316076278687,
0.25614064931869507,
0.1268250048160553,
-0.54070645570755,
0.4356898367404938,
0.2698936462402344,
-0.8050857186317444,
-0.9662256836891174,
0.46232566237449646,
-1.0298956632614136,
-0.39143848419189453,
1.3657011985778809,
-0.1899128258228302,
-0.1679634004831314,
-0.03815394639968872,
-0.23174530267715454,
0.16967742145061493,
-1.0005559921264648,
0.9396111369132996,
0.5484371781349182,
-0.5887680649757385,
-0.31320175528526306,
-0.25399255752563477,
0.77139812707901,
0.6462158560752869,
-0.4632893204689026,
0.26462653279304504,
0.6803607940673828,
-0.000049168189434567466,
-0.17136240005493164,
0.7369887828826904,
0.2242196649312973,
0.37090787291526794,
-0.22920195758342743,
-0.02920197881758213,
-0.10782095044851303,
-0.21187855303287506,
-0.4418316185474396,
0.36730051040649414,
0.32303905487060547,
-0.2742406129837036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10496v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10496v2 | Comparing Hallucination Detection Metrics for Multilingual Generation | 2024-02-16T08:10:34 | 2024-06-16T00:44:28 | Haoqiang Kang, Terra Blevins, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While many hallucination detection techniques have been evaluated on English
text, their effectiveness in multilingual contexts remains unknown. This paper
assesses how well various factual hallucination detection metrics (lexical
metrics like ROUGE and Named Entity Overlap, and Natural Language Inference
(NLI)-based metrics) identify hallucinations in generated biographical
summaries across languages. We compare how well automatic metrics correlate to
each other and whether they agree with human judgments of factuality. Our
analysis reveals that while the lexical metrics are ineffective, NLI-based
metrics perform well, correlating with human annotations in many settings and
often outperforming supervised models. However, NLI metrics are still limited,
as they do not detect single-fact hallucinations well and fail for
lower-resource languages. Therefore, our findings highlight the gaps in
exisiting hallucination detection methods for non-English languages and
motivate future research to develop more robust multilingual detection methods
for LLM hallucinations. | [
-0.5709339380264282,
-0.5874372124671936,
0.6383605003356934,
0.3685446083545685,
-0.016703875735402107,
0.21462401747703552,
-0.2726660966873169,
-0.7775336503982544,
0.8466697335243225,
0.43457290530204773,
-0.5280205607414246,
-0.6186339855194092,
-0.4347187876701355,
0.60870361328125,
-0.31336796283721924,
0.9169235825538635,
0.169765904545784,
0.10345709323883057,
-0.3659067451953888,
-0.3799298107624054,
-0.4421831965446472,
-0.7393349409103394,
-0.5559182167053223,
-0.09763231873512268,
0.5250063538551331,
0.009575223550200462,
0.7036187648773193,
0.07096507400274277,
0.43845152854919434,
0.2664974629878998,
-0.00343273370526731,
0.7481887340545654,
-0.3203648328781128,
0.3543781042098999,
0.09194735437631607,
-0.2865211069583893,
-0.33029428124427795,
-0.16499242186546326,
0.49052998423576355,
0.7809993028640747,
-0.03011677972972393,
-0.017575593665242195,
-0.09973198175430298,
0.5848259925842285,
-0.8226117491722107,
-0.10405444353818893,
-0.5390749573707581,
0.43487516045570374,
-0.03130853548645973,
-0.5222240686416626,
-0.5352892279624939,
-0.5239849090576172,
-0.14129048585891724,
-0.20260460674762726,
0.5494359135627747,
0.0266330074518919,
0.6944497227668762,
0.3529510796070099,
-0.4083220958709717,
-0.7436513900756836,
-0.6625522375106812,
0.6371996402740479,
-0.629260241985321,
0.8262335658073425,
0.38657283782958984,
0.23499278724193573,
0.07197989523410797,
-0.303641676902771,
-0.6440721750259399,
-0.500315248966217,
-0.5580055713653564,
0.11215658485889435,
-0.08678319305181503,
-0.2531939148902893,
0.3889133632183075,
0.3017122149467468,
-0.9091804623603821,
0.14431488513946533,
-0.40304940938949585,
-0.7087892889976501,
0.5869754552841187,
0.09211453795433044,
0.39243176579475403,
-0.44140687584877014,
-0.03381888195872307,
0.17636069655418396,
-0.5276446342468262,
-0.3805617392063141,
0.8172252774238586,
0.26912325620651245,
-0.2139878273010254,
0.3503715991973877,
-0.12335754930973053,
0.42725980281829834,
-0.3647307753562927,
-0.5504992604255676,
0.5491717457771301,
-0.544728696346283,
0.2549182176589966,
0.26026684045791626,
0.8895164132118225,
0.5195184350013733,
0.4826572835445404,
-0.7105435729026794,
-0.05802350491285324,
0.1634690761566162,
0.10453636199235916,
-0.5509545207023621,
-0.21524079144001007,
0.3286581337451935,
-0.31288763880729675,
-0.025304503738880157,
0.33670249581336975,
-1.0752335786819458,
-0.7026600241661072,
-0.13892625272274017,
0.15427635610103607,
-0.4417057931423187,
-0.42163732647895813,
-0.08272280544042587,
-0.32441118359565735,
0.3069653809070587,
0.11746614426374435,
-0.8011868596076965,
0.11898158490657806,
0.5891244411468506,
1.1595395803451538,
-0.6810188889503479,
-0.5467241406440735,
-0.5802352428436279,
-0.1342201977968216,
-0.4558447599411011,
0.8887200951576233,
-0.16685788333415985,
-0.2658694088459015,
0.17511914670467377,
0.23899368941783905,
-0.09103307127952576,
-0.848229169845581,
0.5187214016914368,
-0.007553367875516415,
0.2933647632598877,
-0.27591004967689514,
-0.16586869955062866,
-0.28486016392707825,
0.1066010519862175,
-0.8024062514305115,
0.938392698764801,
-0.16413795948028564,
-0.7897670865058899,
0.6980792880058289,
-0.07953014969825745,
-0.6341190338134766,
-0.04922983795404434,
-0.22098183631896973,
-0.4252651631832123,
0.16765744984149933,
0.1339007169008255,
0.5932033658027649,
0.0717722550034523,
0.3893020749092102,
-0.14668898284435272,
-0.5565072298049927,
0.17336736619472504,
-0.5075501203536987,
0.7711034417152405,
-0.03888210654258728,
-0.5407653450965881,
-0.08387919515371323,
-0.8574860095977783,
-0.2627168595790863,
-0.07073262333869934,
0.08073600381612778,
-0.24757926166057587,
-0.030139395967125893,
0.050977300852537155,
0.016234327107667923,
-0.034365735948085785,
-0.3091762065887451,
-0.20021863281726837,
-0.25464046001434326,
-0.1283974051475525,
0.21399825811386108,
0.16483570635318756,
-0.08141100406646729,
-0.3253953158855438,
0.3510136604309082,
-0.019119512289762497,
-0.31027114391326904,
-0.0740886777639389,
-0.4634137451648712,
-0.8032848834991455,
-0.3700878918170929,
-0.07655340433120728,
0.6806058883666992,
-0.5122231245040894,
0.7901307940483093,
-0.28311091661453247,
-0.33526650071144104,
-0.3958183228969574,
0.01447688601911068,
0.13560207188129425,
0.2781788408756256,
0.3918541371822357,
-0.15834634006023407,
-0.7124976515769958,
-1.047359824180603,
-0.34565937519073486,
-0.43797731399536133,
0.016351979225873947,
0.16564588248729706,
0.6842052936553955,
-0.24597524106502533,
0.4833911061286926,
-0.2294386476278305,
-0.4239409863948822,
-0.28570446372032166,
0.2153199017047882,
-0.11379822343587875,
0.041090745478868484,
0.7196345329284668,
-0.6529497504234314,
-0.326566219329834,
0.16583792865276337,
-1.3047075271606445,
-0.15141841769218445,
-0.5051189064979553,
0.14372557401657104,
0.7388975620269775,
0.4747995138168335,
-0.4808390140533447,
0.5428327918052673,
0.4278840720653534,
-0.39998966455459595,
0.8790341019630432,
-0.12386367470026016,
0.6278545260429382,
-0.8795015811920166,
0.016613846644759178,
-0.11613892018795013,
-0.1956789642572403,
-0.6191588640213013,
-0.00298239104449749,
-0.036362022161483765,
0.4035241901874542,
-0.29950404167175293,
0.38907501101493835,
-0.5660160183906555,
-0.2944067120552063,
-0.03689861670136452,
0.46952196955680847,
-0.14352457225322723,
0.3405025005340576,
0.21183082461357117,
0.8260188698768616,
0.49873247742652893,
-0.5903304815292358,
0.2995260953903198,
0.10703122615814209,
-0.44203299283981323,
0.6330286264419556,
-0.10275663435459137,
0.0278775654733181,
-0.1521216481924057,
-0.030805988237261772,
-1.0574268102645874,
-0.3991979658603668,
0.20254820585250854,
-0.5547824501991272,
0.12631288170814514,
0.361080527305603,
-0.5410180687904358,
-0.15268759429454803,
-0.5902122259140015,
0.07729168981313705,
0.33076372742652893,
-0.6834477186203003,
0.6059795618057251,
0.3344448506832123,
0.10215160250663757,
-0.6759629249572754,
-0.8015573620796204,
0.4902227222919464,
-0.43261846899986267,
-0.42041632533073425,
0.09761311858892441,
0.011681869626045227,
-0.5495996475219727,
-0.35566428303718567,
-0.09556456655263901,
-0.1391914039850235,
0.02726617455482483,
0.22958332300186157,
0.20002038776874542,
-0.24792295694351196,
-0.1192416176199913,
0.07448191195726395,
0.04275108501315117,
0.2699534595012665,
0.17022790014743805,
0.5597082376480103,
0.015347074717283249,
-0.31337109208106995,
-0.658876359462738,
0.4044766426086426,
0.7650748491287231,
0.14345216751098633,
1.0709038972854614,
0.8627194762229919,
-0.6277499794960022,
0.042407575994729996,
-0.9450936913490295,
-0.35203951597213745,
-0.32059425115585327,
0.4796518087387085,
-0.4257972240447998,
-0.4909918010234833,
0.7587974071502686,
0.2871059477329254,
-0.0006978418678045273,
0.38817960023880005,
0.656700849533081,
0.2429877519607544,
0.8740737438201904,
0.41014450788497925,
0.040678489953279495,
-0.15877625346183777,
-0.16391442716121674,
0.5779061317443848,
-0.6230730414390564,
-0.3222949206829071,
-0.365309476852417,
-0.04909824579954147,
-0.8529452681541443,
-0.09411410987377167,
0.1901506632566452,
-0.13818275928497314,
0.3274184465408325,
0.2865406572818756,
-0.4173590838909149,
0.5181569457054138,
0.06756296753883362,
-0.16444239020347595,
0.6504314541816711,
0.154982328414917,
0.14596261084079742,
-0.35302478075027466,
-0.28102922439575195,
-0.7188630700111389,
0.6937862038612366,
-0.0011294391006231308,
0.20810624957084656,
0.42627251148223877,
0.7102481722831726,
0.42066770792007446,
0.10011293739080429,
-0.770164966583252,
0.5113173723220825,
-0.04743018373847008,
-0.5108581781387329,
-0.270778089761734,
-0.4719163179397583,
-0.7633954286575317,
0.5519835948944092,
-0.3601820766925812,
-1.0220845937728882,
0.16944964230060577,
-0.1115528792142868,
-0.42477673292160034,
0.504209041595459,
-0.634611189365387,
0.6667446494102478,
-0.2108398973941803,
-0.2031366527080536,
-0.15992103517055511,
-0.43290919065475464,
0.5993341207504272,
-0.2356971949338913,
0.37919852137565613,
-0.1410226970911026,
-0.043408580124378204,
0.7279633283615112,
-0.06286224722862244,
0.7112299799919128,
-0.0722823217511177,
-0.2272498905658722,
0.09937350451946259,
0.2164781391620636,
0.08547181636095047,
0.27553460001945496,
0.03032730519771576,
0.5727892518043518,
0.12240338325500488,
-0.0783679187297821,
-0.5312851071357727,
0.7638733386993408,
-0.3678445816040039,
-0.5702643990516663,
-0.5219214558601379,
-0.528274655342102,
-0.2426537424325943,
-0.1258331686258316,
0.6502461433410645,
0.314310759305954,
-0.42477041482925415,
0.01778186857700348,
0.32533323764801025,
-0.3481747806072235,
0.4047093391418457,
0.3987674415111542,
-0.31748276948928833,
-0.2951975166797638,
1.1230283975601196,
0.13724824786186218,
0.05100005865097046,
0.24689346551895142,
-0.017524491995573044,
-0.249777689576149,
-0.515092670917511,
-0.4587925374507904,
0.6463428139686584,
-0.8322159051895142,
0.07742909342050552,
-1.1569037437438965,
-0.28174057602882385,
-0.6127374172210693,
-0.14475856721401215,
-0.18901664018630981,
-0.27186083793640137,
-0.003226951928809285,
-0.18478575348854065,
0.14020542800426483,
0.674315869808197,
-0.23570184409618378,
-0.1344115287065506,
-0.4474453926086426,
0.5339004993438721,
-0.143443763256073,
-0.09756001085042953,
0.12015692889690399,
-0.5640342235565186,
-0.14453648030757904,
-0.28903281688690186,
-0.1191156804561615,
-1.0890213251113892,
0.4494173228740692,
0.18752364814281464,
0.482695072889328,
0.6548076272010803,
-0.04186993092298508,
0.7336323857307434,
-0.39658123254776,
0.8886637687683105,
0.04762868583202362,
-0.6654618382453918,
0.20122358202934265,
0.11265091598033905,
-0.04800974950194359,
0.7033988237380981,
0.7032793760299683,
-0.7787721753120422,
-0.9196284413337708,
-0.18045386672019958,
-0.5920316576957703,
0.36105695366859436,
0.19274325668811798,
0.08189291507005692,
-0.1829085499048233,
0.2985862195491791,
0.6893083453178406,
0.07760047912597656,
-0.9523755311965942,
-0.43135541677474976,
0.15297992527484894,
-0.011882215738296509,
-0.17310811579227448,
-0.14781488478183746,
0.19827228784561157,
-0.34380581974983215,
0.5457061529159546,
-0.0666436180472374,
0.1904800981283188,
0.2499520480632782,
-0.38023996353149414,
0.06962506473064423,
-0.08109403401613235,
0.8061875700950623,
0.9044318199157715,
-0.2722076177597046,
0.3146734833717346,
0.5320776104927063,
-0.696316123008728,
0.12581470608711243,
-0.2518335282802582,
-0.06421144306659698,
0.5813890099525452,
0.9137759208679199,
0.8387494683265686,
0.1017647534608841,
-0.7468731999397278,
0.4516904354095459,
-0.14035354554653168,
-0.2911842465400696,
-0.5810964703559875,
-0.021184753626585007,
-0.06250747293233871,
0.044880982488393784,
0.2861559987068176,
-0.057744987308979034,
0.385263592004776,
-0.7017121911048889,
0.3660915195941925,
0.6607779264450073,
-0.26856595277786255,
-0.4725113809108734,
0.6304401159286499,
-0.08859580010175705,
-0.568152666091919,
0.4698874354362488,
-0.5857778191566467,
-0.5944879651069641,
0.525505006313324,
0.49068960547447205,
1.0086238384246826,
-0.08292219787836075,
0.3846498131752014,
0.6498502492904663,
0.5473167300224304,
-0.0005903920391574502,
0.12334126234054565,
-0.020122697576880455,
-0.8311669826507568,
-0.3999161422252655,
-0.5914014577865601,
-0.2573002576828003,
0.3360079526901245,
-0.5588189959526062,
0.4051198661327362,
-0.06677843630313873,
0.0020930757746100426,
0.19077810645103455,
-0.25868719816207886,
-0.5606765151023865,
-0.15030315518379211,
0.36125925183296204,
0.35534363985061646,
-0.9737527370452881,
0.35903942584991455,
0.30421921610832214,
-0.305552214384079,
-0.12501490116119385,
0.5492538213729858,
0.32772091031074524,
-0.48500874638557434,
0.476654976606369,
0.6285569071769714,
-0.5123391151428223,
-0.2786133587360382,
0.04647182673215866,
-0.4760286808013916,
0.7103657126426697,
0.23827198147773743,
-0.21795067191123962,
-0.07626410573720932,
0.17031055688858032,
0.7203948497772217,
-0.26525989174842834,
0.32684725522994995,
0.905665934085846,
0.5486633777618408,
-0.0910981148481369,
-0.6605860590934753,
0.07947865128517151,
0.0573645681142807,
-0.5229753851890564,
0.25490903854370117,
-0.44762271642684937,
0.39794817566871643,
-0.4545081853866577,
-0.6329941749572754,
0.1989823281764984,
0.660863995552063,
0.16207750141620636,
0.5529215931892395,
0.591849148273468,
0.39101558923721313,
1.0014876127243042,
0.008541076444089413,
0.9378717541694641,
-0.5405964255332947,
0.15126065909862518,
0.8093307614326477,
-0.4025992751121521,
0.550787091255188,
0.4261976480484009,
-0.2000604122877121,
0.6331397891044617,
0.5267358422279358,
-0.1069650650024414,
0.2596752643585205,
-0.14859172701835632,
-0.2040657103061676,
-0.0410568006336689,
-0.12330913543701172,
-0.2202790230512619,
0.35805395245552063,
0.20103687047958374,
-0.029971348121762276,
-0.07948242127895355,
0.18886853754520416,
0.07235294580459595,
0.00651168916374445,
0.2319381833076477,
0.8116540908813477,
-0.07003556936979294,
-0.8656556010246277,
0.7118666172027588,
-0.3249768912792206,
0.9170692563056946,
-0.3177909255027771,
-0.038133226335048676,
-0.5342090129852295,
-0.169119194149971,
-0.4958639442920685,
-0.4114420711994171,
0.6898494362831116,
0.18171663582324982,
-0.039071667939424515,
0.25761425495147705,
0.34228047728538513,
-0.5042148232460022,
-0.3782168924808502,
0.7224202156066895,
0.8510277271270752,
0.7996975183486938,
0.012478655204176903,
-0.13638119399547577,
-0.1368926763534546,
0.02130482904613018,
0.1093645691871643,
0.034709393978118896,
0.5186049342155457,
-0.025874270126223564,
0.4568890631198883,
0.4260749816894531,
0.41692906618118286,
0.015440371818840504,
0.42095062136650085,
0.040437307208776474,
-0.7423855066299438,
-0.3409137427806854,
-1.2138725519180298,
0.16145853698253632,
-0.2783844470977783,
-0.32850056886672974,
0.9930564165115356,
0.8319381475448608,
0.8544423580169678,
-0.10193924605846405,
0.5700960755348206,
0.07904578000307083,
0.3519975543022156,
-0.5876772403717041,
0.8806504607200623,
-0.7730408310890198,
0.07812054455280304,
-0.29333558678627014,
-1.170071005821228,
-0.43344613909721375,
0.6791259050369263,
0.07939021289348602,
0.06800227612257004,
1.221331000328064,
0.9896590113639832,
0.07404740154743195,
0.04608461633324623,
0.6387292146682739,
0.12434260547161102,
-0.12961597740650177,
0.16834129393100739,
0.9308933019638062,
-0.17940443754196167,
0.2757628858089447,
-0.2804730534553528,
-0.06593931466341019,
-0.12150198966264725,
-0.6489388346672058,
-1.216991662979126,
-0.7693613171577454,
-0.4360083341598511,
-0.28361788392066956,
0.03727131336927414,
0.7258661389350891,
0.4987008571624756,
-1.170744776725769,
-0.2906506359577179,
0.26925933361053467,
0.3574425280094147,
-0.27394673228263855,
-0.31633642315864563,
0.3773062229156494,
-0.442863404750824,
-0.8436806797981262,
0.31434309482574463,
0.48719218373298645,
-0.013318605720996857,
-0.6511583924293518,
-0.09844972938299179,
-0.10439877212047577,
0.0669587105512619,
0.6667734384536743,
0.00998431071639061,
-1.1396450996398926,
-0.3569432199001312,
0.05400233715772629,
-0.07145416736602783,
0.20136703550815582,
0.954410970211029,
-0.6777568459510803,
0.2528594434261322,
0.38568487763404846,
0.44895240664482117,
0.055769190192222595,
-0.23668107390403748,
0.16484034061431885,
-0.7427169680595398,
0.4008164703845978,
0.05125316232442856,
0.4674060642719269,
0.6523489952087402,
-0.6214609146118164,
0.7142784595489502,
0.5103020071983337,
-0.3627317249774933,
-1.1966506242752075,
0.06354545056819916,
-0.7041167616844177,
-0.39073774218559265,
1.0210875272750854,
0.3659059703350067,
0.057463545352220535,
-0.4514533579349518,
-0.01979682594537735,
0.15939949452877045,
-0.025827212259173393,
1.1267619132995605,
0.9193319082260132,
-0.38345637917518616,
0.13913394510746002,
-0.9501422643661499,
0.6833107471466064,
0.34597596526145935,
-0.9052939414978027,
0.15146024525165558,
0.45847299695014954,
-0.20128470659255981,
0.6520931124687195,
0.43576323986053467,
0.16023632884025574,
0.2814542353153229,
0.0031804281752556562,
0.1643962860107422,
0.3223906457424164,
-0.6683858633041382,
-0.28345242142677307,
0.02662350796163082,
-0.3312942087650299,
0.14448709785938263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10481v2 | Emoji Driven Crypto Assets Market Reactions | 2024-02-16T07:05:49 | 2024-05-04T14:32:44 | Xiaorui Zuo, Yao-Tsung Chen, Wolfgang Karl Härdle | q-fin.CP | q-fin.CP, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST | In the burgeoning realm of cryptocurrency, social media platforms like
Twitter have become pivotal in influencing market trends and investor
sentiments. In our study, we leverage GPT-4 and a fine-tuned transformer-based
BERT model for a multimodal sentiment analysis, focusing on the impact of emoji
sentiment on cryptocurrency markets. By translating emojis into quantifiable
sentiment data, we correlate these insights with key market indicators like BTC
Price and the VCRIX index. Our architecture's analysis of emoji sentiment
demonstrated a distinct advantage over FinBERT's pure text sentiment analysis
in such predicting power. This approach may be fed into the development of
trading strategies aimed at utilizing social media elements to identify and
forecast market trends. Crucially, our findings suggest that strategies based
on emoji sentiment can facilitate the avoidance of significant market downturns
and contribute to the stabilization of returns. This research underscores the
practical benefits of integrating advanced AI-driven analyses into financial
strategies, offering a nuanced perspective on the interplay between digital
communication and market dynamics in an academic context. | [
-0.14827607572078705,
-1.053125262260437,
0.18371963500976562,
0.11446888744831085,
-0.5698487162590027,
0.6006803512573242,
-0.3584647476673126,
-0.4038759171962738,
0.7868354916572571,
0.23717111349105835,
-0.519711434841156,
-0.4847680330276489,
-0.6681160926818848,
0.10814066976308823,
-0.3365674912929535,
1.2599549293518066,
0.20688770711421967,
-0.10041224211454391,
0.33501362800598145,
-0.002886693924665451,
-0.07541526108980179,
-0.5816759467124939,
-0.8034465909004211,
0.10889480262994766,
0.5942598581314087,
0.3253318965435028,
0.9318397641181946,
0.07057428359985352,
0.7797110080718994,
0.30325883626937866,
0.20261670649051666,
-0.22212889790534973,
-0.2766757905483246,
0.1899990290403366,
0.5198628902435303,
-0.0607442781329155,
-0.41501274704933167,
-0.04426100477576256,
0.07413399964570999,
0.05363640934228897,
-0.3072664439678192,
-0.0575847327709198,
-0.1468983143568039,
0.5354609489440918,
-0.527377188205719,
0.4473276734352112,
-0.7263573408126831,
0.08488474786281586,
-0.21075427532196045,
-0.1520317941904068,
-0.16809839010238647,
-0.37122026085853577,
0.27802419662475586,
-0.4289376437664032,
-0.3211616575717926,
0.037896715104579926,
0.6966919302940369,
-0.19127510488033295,
-0.16149921715259552,
-0.767966091632843,
-0.4146781265735626,
0.8958461284637451,
-0.447760671377182,
0.3668879270553589,
0.0652351975440979,
0.3577269911766052,
0.41147369146347046,
-0.6212465763092041,
-0.5479050278663635,
-0.07987653464078903,
0.21275126934051514,
0.03546912968158722,
-0.26239126920700073,
-0.17407575249671936,
-0.0495653860270977,
0.16880159080028534,
0.017652882263064384,
-0.2201961725950241,
-0.44905224442481995,
-0.06729724258184433,
0.6064777970314026,
0.022679399698972702,
0.5659006237983704,
-0.2763027548789978,
-0.35307517647743225,
-0.1846185028553009,
-0.5515744686126709,
-0.09385900944471359,
0.7054482102394104,
0.3924783170223236,
-0.17946240305900574,
0.5183607935905457,
0.31374216079711914,
0.24095386266708374,
0.0927886962890625,
-0.11639406532049179,
0.29106268286705017,
-0.5555152893066406,
-0.09300680458545685,
0.3352696895599365,
0.939884603023529,
0.4717654287815094,
0.4547792077064514,
-0.12394099682569504,
-0.25064167380332947,
-0.020745420828461647,
0.47639188170433044,
-0.8319169878959656,
-0.27250441908836365,
0.2831890285015106,
-0.5648593306541443,
-0.7203190922737122,
0.12096035480499268,
-1.0593948364257812,
-0.3308294117450714,
-0.011877886019647121,
0.34382909536361694,
-0.5269777178764343,
-0.2668638527393341,
-0.3222113847732544,
-0.5816118717193604,
0.2783939838409424,
0.2521876394748688,
-1.2904274463653564,
0.29275229573249817,
0.9435788989067078,
0.7432494759559631,
0.5388859510421753,
0.22795218229293823,
-0.04050128161907196,
0.028252294287085533,
-0.4597797989845276,
0.44399285316467285,
-0.6789689660072327,
-0.424935907125473,
0.2411828190088272,
-0.3236035108566284,
-0.03612218797206879,
0.0667363777756691,
0.2135060429573059,
-0.4706019461154938,
-0.08014123141765594,
-0.3702639043331146,
-0.22046376764774323,
-0.019792476668953896,
0.38380149006843567,
-0.6507818698883057,
0.4466067850589752,
0.044619496911764145,
-1.1680465936660767,
0.4533383548259735,
-1.0794963836669922,
-0.4924713373184204,
0.053344521671533585,
-0.24486510455608368,
-0.48977771401405334,
-0.02154499664902687,
0.4265810251235962,
0.500417172908783,
-0.2644557058811188,
-0.16735732555389404,
-0.6960263848304749,
-0.12768743932247162,
1.065309762954712,
-0.31218937039375305,
0.4020920395851135,
0.2775985896587372,
-0.5028427839279175,
-0.016749994829297066,
-0.492419958114624,
-0.16179755330085754,
0.17096063494682312,
0.2724546194076538,
-0.5623572468757629,
0.15229682624340057,
0.6257690191268921,
0.061160869896411896,
0.3576461970806122,
-0.6958625912666321,
0.2717333436012268,
-0.25419801473617554,
1.1873087882995605,
0.9935612678527832,
0.0036596152931451797,
0.367543488740921,
-0.12147188186645508,
0.38286787271499634,
-0.09534595906734467,
0.5572906732559204,
-0.12555624544620514,
-0.5456944108009338,
-0.28219008445739746,
-0.5371142625808716,
0.23411783576011658,
0.3595629334449768,
-0.6796836256980896,
0.22384701669216156,
-0.3451648950576782,
-0.42099782824516296,
-0.891156792640686,
0.1265796422958374,
-0.30854907631874084,
-0.10520951449871063,
-0.031315214931964874,
-0.015242590568959713,
-0.4138203263282776,
-0.7861427068710327,
-0.2956850826740265,
-0.15880925953388214,
0.091507188975811,
0.3704128861427307,
0.4486825466156006,
-0.5340808033943176,
0.639203667640686,
-0.2704159915447235,
-0.21931996941566467,
-0.16649401187896729,
0.3614356219768524,
0.07361886650323868,
0.03866713494062424,
0.6415868401527405,
-1.0473483800888062,
-0.4233020544052124,
0.5372872352600098,
-0.5720409154891968,
0.3953463137149811,
-0.5035836696624756,
0.13809233903884888,
0.405190646648407,
0.14869514107704163,
-0.5235792994499207,
0.3627571165561676,
0.49650874733924866,
-0.41562139987945557,
-0.22990372776985168,
0.08979775011539459,
0.5549806356430054,
-1.1013177633285522,
0.054955851286649704,
0.256728857755661,
0.18759195506572723,
-0.4996567368507385,
-0.168038472533226,
-0.13560673594474792,
-0.12305750697851181,
-0.3904697597026825,
0.25946980714797974,
-0.03931679576635361,
0.03262747824192047,
-0.16621799767017365,
0.26493048667907715,
-0.3013898432254791,
0.012583666481077671,
-0.30267080664634705,
0.7494468688964844,
0.7481192946434021,
0.039533279836177826,
0.395310640335083,
0.14671705663204193,
-0.12005359679460526,
0.21332547068595886,
-0.7538301944732666,
0.3509933650493622,
0.373237669467926,
-0.13501793146133423,
-1.3656548261642456,
-0.15581348538398743,
0.7892816662788391,
-0.745739221572876,
0.36109858751296997,
0.2524435818195343,
-0.7399685978889465,
-0.3860970139503479,
-0.8669679760932922,
0.2244638204574585,
0.35145053267478943,
-0.3050054907798767,
0.9469572305679321,
0.30705729126930237,
-0.36525246500968933,
-0.7596348524093628,
-0.7865791320800781,
0.27025744318962097,
-0.39122846722602844,
-0.6712896227836609,
0.11659451574087143,
0.017535321414470673,
-0.5502864122390747,
-0.14186912775039673,
0.16902758181095123,
0.00850588083267212,
0.25067469477653503,
0.4250316619873047,
0.6209726929664612,
0.22017870843410492,
0.04429614916443825,
0.025136496871709824,
-0.06483208388090134,
0.33235105872154236,
-0.22184568643569946,
0.4571595788002014,
-0.3734106123447418,
0.006443511229008436,
-0.6823773980140686,
0.03764685243368149,
0.8790159821510315,
0.1569691151380539,
0.9624542593955994,
0.570517897605896,
-0.14026229083538055,
0.382639080286026,
-0.4315509796142578,
-0.1335803121328354,
-0.5617730021476746,
0.03557056561112404,
-0.2221047729253769,
-0.8393148183822632,
0.7958758473396301,
0.2082081139087677,
-0.06886787712574005,
0.5346397161483765,
0.8258904218673706,
-0.12628047168254852,
1.2240633964538574,
0.5576191544532776,
-0.4383532702922821,
0.7255547046661377,
-0.25936177372932434,
0.7819359302520752,
-0.4608957767486572,
-0.270036518573761,
-0.3266943395137787,
-0.41481974720954895,
-1.117820143699646,
-0.022405482828617096,
0.006490497384220362,
-0.37680506706237793,
-0.07623010128736496,
0.19214126467704773,
-0.45956140756607056,
-0.18216867744922638,
0.22168026864528656,
0.08603643625974655,
-0.18584948778152466,
0.23729877173900604,
0.14589767158031464,
-0.15031272172927856,
-0.3600682020187378,
-0.4534336030483246,
1.3392713069915771,
0.7050734162330627,
0.9505535364151001,
-0.018373697996139526,
0.644005298614502,
0.6239035725593567,
0.6621353626251221,
-0.8250993490219116,
0.06741401553153992,
-0.01787509210407734,
-0.3442460298538208,
-0.27971571683883667,
-0.4033925235271454,
-0.6388331055641174,
-0.23916174471378326,
-0.41166558861732483,
-0.4254705011844635,
0.04648801311850548,
-0.37865692377090454,
-0.23003973066806793,
0.16720084846019745,
-0.5695059299468994,
0.9105022549629211,
-0.455929696559906,
-0.08642642199993134,
-0.47771474719047546,
-0.4857141673564911,
0.025948410853743553,
-0.4288107454776764,
0.5109114050865173,
-0.17083315551280975,
-0.2684275805950165,
0.559316098690033,
-0.3130020499229431,
0.9145584106445312,
0.17582078278064728,
-0.14342571794986725,
0.3633176386356354,
-0.34916356205940247,
0.39942052960395813,
0.32180121541023254,
0.09040270745754242,
0.48754987120628357,
-0.1083836778998375,
-0.5582532286643982,
-0.4771558344364166,
1.0788203477859497,
-0.9454779624938965,
-0.1434883028268814,
-0.2576209306716919,
-0.18071386218070984,
0.27435722947120667,
-0.16964437067508698,
0.16061849892139435,
0.008978228084743023,
-0.45401206612586975,
0.07990776002407074,
-0.016176311299204826,
0.11856059730052948,
0.6911544799804688,
-0.10110005736351013,
0.03208489716053009,
-1.185681700706482,
0.9514405131340027,
0.18988029658794403,
-0.10028834640979767,
0.467262327671051,
0.34421446919441223,
-0.4721093475818634,
-0.0089691998437047,
-0.3011404573917389,
0.13306811451911926,
-0.6866173148155212,
-0.03481783717870712,
-0.5992851853370667,
0.24228917062282562,
-0.8751201033592224,
-0.4176326394081116,
-0.23930859565734863,
-0.4873196482658386,
-0.3766259253025055,
-0.36128079891204834,
0.6410764455795288,
0.6946771740913391,
-0.005742717068642378,
0.17264491319656372,
-0.8465136885643005,
0.10454194247722626,
0.41468915343284607,
0.2235703021287918,
0.06127198040485382,
0.012467514723539352,
-0.2800820469856262,
0.2515517473220825,
-0.4468708336353302,
-0.9336609840393066,
0.52997225522995,
0.14205732941627502,
0.08841805905103683,
0.9250789880752563,
-0.07936195284128189,
0.5167827606201172,
0.00042236241279169917,
0.5374886989593506,
0.5374727249145508,
-1.1558347940444946,
0.6890554428100586,
-0.44146403670310974,
-0.2968326210975647,
0.22434097528457642,
0.3734922707080841,
-0.7160593271255493,
-0.4685770273208618,
-0.8257400393486023,
-0.8750500082969666,
0.33619892597198486,
0.6095048785209656,
0.5921376943588257,
-0.4776664078235626,
0.4757583439350128,
0.10744298994541168,
0.6730508804321289,
-0.6865322589874268,
-0.2922327220439911,
-0.7384636402130127,
-0.4758773744106293,
0.26519569754600525,
-0.24433793127536774,
-0.08082494884729385,
-0.20632332563400269,
0.2817305326461792,
-0.17777138948440552,
0.4231095016002655,
-0.21063849329948425,
0.2707386612892151,
-0.11787497997283936,
0.23744633793830872,
0.28011786937713623,
0.5430125594139099,
-0.2745214104652405,
-0.28667089343070984,
-0.05276501923799515,
-0.2773401737213135,
-0.331798255443573,
0.1011301726102829,
0.05598301813006401,
-0.11140395700931549,
0.17742027342319489,
0.5682572722434998,
0.33462071418762207,
-0.7560682892799377,
0.698728084564209,
-0.32783597707748413,
-0.15676206350326538,
-0.41111958026885986,
-0.3580459952354431,
-0.20087064802646637,
0.19431905448436737,
0.7199119329452515,
0.1892697513103485,
0.29211294651031494,
-0.9293506741523743,
0.29286468029022217,
0.5089870691299438,
-0.5862231254577637,
-0.8262530565261841,
0.6443454623222351,
0.343973308801651,
-0.08543600887060165,
0.8685177564620972,
0.45087966322898865,
-0.5067856311798096,
0.734639585018158,
0.15166153013706207,
1.2677464485168457,
0.045518066734075546,
0.33938172459602356,
-0.06962057203054428,
0.5052924752235413,
0.27329757809638977,
0.47473859786987305,
-0.15825463831424713,
-0.7599712014198303,
-0.13838526606559753,
-0.34601253271102905,
-0.22257348895072937,
-0.3833077549934387,
-0.3382663130760193,
0.4342895448207855,
-0.8256968855857849,
-0.6735060214996338,
0.5021703243255615,
-0.16113434731960297,
-0.6804802417755127,
0.3337608277797699,
0.40138283371925354,
0.2865210473537445,
-0.8305497169494629,
0.6316352486610413,
0.8054842352867126,
-0.5189881324768066,
-0.2399330884218216,
0.06291097402572632,
-0.2567555606365204,
-0.920126736164093,
0.6513403058052063,
0.48874861001968384,
0.10266780853271484,
-0.23619765043258667,
-0.7405061721801758,
-0.460567831993103,
0.7908136248588562,
-0.0062757073901593685,
-0.4670935869216919,
0.48322251439094543,
0.14945057034492493,
0.7985167503356934,
-0.7151665091514587,
0.5505020022392273,
0.308724582195282,
0.5486948490142822,
0.19315676391124725,
-0.44281134009361267,
0.005152938887476921,
-0.45500802993774414,
0.07368671894073486,
0.6245877742767334,
-0.6795428395271301,
0.5724368691444397,
-0.34730446338653564,
-0.35715341567993164,
-0.06532901525497437,
0.4120335280895233,
-0.1539493054151535,
0.6095576286315918,
0.2936377227306366,
0.4651060700416565,
0.2512422800064087,
-0.15540505945682526,
1.110190749168396,
-0.9330136179924011,
0.6207891702651978,
-0.021786291152238846,
-0.04530753195285797,
1.0615566968917847,
0.6028074026107788,
-0.07112333923578262,
0.6256928443908691,
0.6714576482772827,
-0.1659456044435501,
0.663598358631134,
-0.06189877912402153,
-0.15926863253116608,
-0.20450268685817719,
-0.0813632383942604,
-0.2742564082145691,
0.3295549154281616,
0.5729297995567322,
-0.5842493772506714,
0.37776127457618713,
0.18671362102031708,
-0.09229843318462372,
-0.224744513630867,
-0.21383534371852875,
0.6996070742607117,
0.12107003480195999,
0.03958256170153618,
-0.08605021983385086,
-0.09504303336143494,
0.6963813900947571,
-0.34075772762298584,
0.12021578848361969,
0.13631966710090637,
0.21810220181941986,
0.05875815451145172,
-0.7014031410217285,
0.38687747716903687,
-0.2971220910549164,
0.17988447844982147,
-0.3285864591598511,
0.7131375074386597,
-0.1124492958188057,
-0.8067030310630798,
0.39006826281547546,
0.1768309473991394,
-0.21476715803146362,
-0.14908447861671448,
-0.9780017733573914,
0.1608199030160904,
-0.07415997982025146,
-0.16468213498592377,
0.38039904832839966,
0.8283389210700989,
0.2973465621471405,
0.719506561756134,
0.8644804954528809,
-0.4656417667865753,
-0.2923465669155121,
0.014714189805090427,
1.0800371170043945,
-1.0323494672775269,
-0.4653845429420471,
-1.0708895921707153,
0.2827688157558441,
-0.11228396743535995,
-0.10672711580991745,
0.6436280608177185,
0.2621244788169861,
0.4538234770298004,
-0.16789382696151733,
0.8923402428627014,
-0.15774142742156982,
0.0003046613128390163,
-0.2798755168914795,
0.910358190536499,
-0.4519782066345215,
0.3055306673049927,
-0.43784865736961365,
-0.46800753474235535,
-0.18299600481987,
0.4838358759880066,
-0.36488351225852966,
0.1374267339706421,
0.32252374291419983,
0.37967047095298767,
0.401976615190506,
0.3508569002151489,
0.15173041820526123,
0.03476778790354729,
0.2053498923778534,
-0.0659644827246666,
0.893314003944397,
-0.7249652743339539,
0.4739258885383606,
-0.44384297728538513,
0.09351418912410736,
-0.48557621240615845,
-0.7351095676422119,
-1.0597437620162964,
-0.2088935524225235,
-0.587925374507904,
-0.3653550446033478,
0.09159297496080399,
0.912425696849823,
0.076780304312706,
-0.8367208242416382,
-0.046947021037340164,
0.13415463268756866,
0.12413627654314041,
-0.2724704444408417,
-0.3308045268058777,
0.4522430896759033,
-0.3417838215827942,
-0.46881285309791565,
-0.31509730219841003,
0.6449792385101318,
0.19331912696361542,
-0.11415104568004608,
0.05600704252719879,
0.14084722101688385,
0.3763509690761566,
0.6521794199943542,
-0.1647261530160904,
-0.6893201470375061,
-0.1472654640674591,
0.27565452456474304,
-0.26047617197036743,
0.09393005818128586,
1.0089836120605469,
-0.1502835750579834,
0.6137373447418213,
0.4793722629547119,
0.40308091044425964,
0.07434718310832977,
0.08358897268772125,
0.5189049243927002,
-0.2806890904903412,
0.06367576867341995,
0.12540344893932343,
0.25621479749679565,
0.34390538930892944,
-0.5046318173408508,
0.16113390028476715,
0.40486449003219604,
-0.45021331310272217,
-0.2708682715892792,
-0.45102474093437195,
-0.8290941119194031,
-0.33750560879707336,
0.7914500832557678,
0.017853060737252235,
-0.6678730249404907,
0.20037592947483063,
-0.09371312707662582,
-0.0352519266307354,
-0.9933040142059326,
1.3073521852493286,
0.8167330026626587,
0.21508201956748962,
-0.3585652709007263,
-0.2377263903617859,
0.2619299590587616,
0.056280240416526794,
-0.45414623618125916,
-0.1214202344417572,
0.19712188839912415,
0.0718061551451683,
0.20266255736351013,
0.5829747915267944,
0.028089391067624092,
0.22321553528308868,
0.08051334321498871,
0.12500761449337006,
0.19353923201560974,
-0.18081878125667572,
0.01933332532644272,
0.2387586534023285,
-0.11682111024856567,
-0.44682592153549194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12170v2 | Where is the answer? Investigating Positional Bias in Language Model Knowledge Extraction | 2024-02-16T06:29:16 | 2024-05-23T06:52:31 | Kuniaki Saito, Kihyuk Sohn, Chen-Yu Lee, Yoshitaka Ushiku | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models require updates to remain up-to-date or adapt to new
domains by fine-tuning them with new documents. One key is memorizing the
latest information in a way that the memorized information is extractable with
a query prompt. However, LLMs suffer from a phenomenon called perplexity curse;
despite minimizing document perplexity during fine-tuning, LLMs struggle to
extract information through a prompt sentence. In this new knowledge
acquisition and extraction, we find a very intriguing fact that LLMs can
accurately answer questions about the first sentence, but they struggle to
extract information described in the middle or end of the documents used for
fine-tuning. Our study suggests that the auto-regressive training causes this
issue; each token is prompted by reliance on all previous tokens, which hinders
the model from recalling information from training documents by question
prompts. To conduct the in-depth study, we publish both synthetic and real
datasets, enabling the evaluation of the QA performance w.r.t. the position of
the corresponding answer in a document. Our investigation shows that even a
large model suffers from the perplexity curse, but regularization such as
denoising auto-regressive loss can enhance the information extraction from
diverse positions. These findings will be (i) a key to improving knowledge
extraction from LLMs and (ii) new elements to discuss the trade-off between RAG
and fine-tuning in adapting LLMs to a new domain. | [
-0.3807433247566223,
-0.8990404009819031,
0.6936230659484863,
-0.08150939643383026,
-0.2940499782562256,
0.10495240986347198,
-0.032465774565935135,
-0.3638674020767212,
0.0365847572684288,
0.5333251357078552,
-0.615519106388092,
-0.39069026708602905,
-0.9780203104019165,
0.11994395405054092,
-0.3157995343208313,
0.9210206866264343,
0.05509417504072189,
0.10948554426431656,
-0.35452568531036377,
0.11538775265216827,
-0.5363904237747192,
-0.7756891250610352,
-0.5199909806251526,
-0.17720651626586914,
0.45278438925743103,
0.523731529712677,
0.580635666847229,
0.6389324069023132,
0.46668022871017456,
0.24570365250110626,
-0.15589816868305206,
0.04812728241086006,
-0.44108638167381287,
0.2861924171447754,
-0.03901590034365654,
-0.8354660868644714,
-0.25660207867622375,
0.2621007561683655,
0.6103371381759644,
0.7092143297195435,
-0.011998146772384644,
0.24539215862751007,
-0.030671915039420128,
0.49589642882347107,
-0.5408097505569458,
-0.002864362671971321,
-0.9245833158493042,
0.018356874585151672,
-0.3082192540168762,
-0.3413291275501251,
-0.1009206771850586,
-0.358582466840744,
0.4112621247768402,
-0.5478237867355347,
0.45250940322875977,
0.02032427489757538,
1.059859037399292,
0.5782141089439392,
-0.44422441720962524,
-0.3276258409023285,
-0.561756432056427,
0.6816972494125366,
-0.6512069702148438,
0.3066505193710327,
0.4974062442779541,
0.09199900180101395,
-0.20341114699840546,
-0.2877272963523865,
-0.5885806679725647,
0.06201040744781494,
0.024798903614282608,
-0.022567057982087135,
-0.143722265958786,
-0.24355700612068176,
0.4381466805934906,
0.2701985538005829,
-0.30962878465652466,
0.29677778482437134,
-0.2527850568294525,
-0.12075716257095337,
0.5598252415657043,
-0.03414835408329964,
0.23509354889392853,
-0.3505617082118988,
-0.3848426938056946,
-0.1216713935136795,
-0.8806239366531372,
0.2136278599500656,
0.45767441391944885,
0.08944671601057053,
0.2472258061170578,
0.46107420325279236,
0.057062141597270966,
0.5098190903663635,
0.2158997505903244,
-0.008835291489958763,
0.11514651775360107,
-0.08383043110370636,
-0.16741418838500977,
0.0026162713766098022,
0.6100481748580933,
0.044897571206092834,
0.3229617476463318,
-0.2139863669872284,
-0.2998813986778259,
-0.35531648993492126,
0.26972121000289917,
-0.5400411486625671,
-0.11363772302865982,
-0.02646774612367153,
-0.3274047374725342,
-0.4008905291557312,
0.08982687443494797,
-0.695580005645752,
-0.5925331711769104,
-0.16312317550182343,
0.115297831594944,
-0.18924126029014587,
-0.3027940094470978,
0.009007871150970459,
-0.08524715900421143,
0.4184779226779938,
0.2660853862762451,
-0.8831859827041626,
0.11983160674571991,
0.6485129594802856,
0.42610615491867065,
-0.5571075677871704,
-0.16266152262687683,
-0.4172995090484619,
-0.061348773539066315,
-0.19358769059181213,
0.9567365646362305,
-0.6115531325340271,
-0.4212595522403717,
-0.0744248479604721,
0.10563186556100845,
-0.16970832645893097,
-0.8065101504325867,
0.3456363081932068,
-0.743267297744751,
0.49911031126976013,
-0.546800434589386,
-0.5687133073806763,
-0.014040295965969563,
0.26115432381629944,
-0.5158690810203552,
0.9530906677246094,
-0.03343086317181587,
-0.7091197967529297,
0.39056652784347534,
-0.31222665309906006,
-0.27866464853286743,
-0.28777194023132324,
-0.40429797768592834,
-0.36034542322158813,
0.30556756258010864,
0.37409478425979614,
0.243615061044693,
-0.4810240864753723,
0.2259032428264618,
-0.3013330399990082,
-0.19671252369880676,
0.6054736375808716,
-0.5957907438278198,
0.6526421308517456,
0.17415210604667664,
-0.2750611901283264,
-0.2035084068775177,
-0.7367969751358032,
-0.3633086085319519,
0.32606741786003113,
-0.414196252822876,
-0.6065460443496704,
-0.1412881463766098,
-0.5458109378814697,
0.39101094007492065,
0.4198857247829437,
-0.4157795310020447,
0.3917411267757416,
-0.4635627865791321,
0.08048766851425171,
0.9280437231063843,
0.2813658118247986,
0.5684014558792114,
-0.1950506567955017,
0.9512842297554016,
0.13256381452083588,
0.10244212299585342,
0.031748779118061066,
-0.33644071221351624,
-0.6943256855010986,
0.1476440578699112,
0.3694848120212555,
0.550072431564331,
-0.5220759510993958,
0.16347624361515045,
-0.04898727312684059,
-0.013296820223331451,
-0.6392396092414856,
0.31385618448257446,
0.4366069436073303,
0.6852728724479675,
0.18798115849494934,
-0.2933737337589264,
-0.4451867938041687,
-1.0814728736877441,
-0.31321048736572266,
-0.09405222535133362,
-0.0026131891645491123,
0.23273542523384094,
0.2390613555908203,
0.15113544464111328,
1.0591058731079102,
-0.6132752299308777,
-0.05472133308649063,
-0.10568444430828094,
0.1946021169424057,
0.27912870049476624,
0.36029472947120667,
0.18479526042938232,
-0.949658989906311,
-0.20545344054698944,
-0.3982846736907959,
-0.7812921404838562,
-0.34817200899124146,
-0.01038313191384077,
-0.15383057296276093,
0.21304579079151154,
0.633418619632721,
-0.7516556978225708,
0.10378830134868622,
0.23011049628257751,
-0.28424471616744995,
0.5943105220794678,
0.06814152002334595,
-0.25167685747146606,
-1.0284960269927979,
0.0906272679567337,
-0.17976351082324982,
-0.03681204468011856,
-0.4514135420322418,
-0.21769528090953827,
-0.136636883020401,
0.21794982254505157,
-0.008510947227478027,
0.5847256779670715,
-0.6056669354438782,
-0.1381983458995819,
-0.3011307716369629,
0.5395417213439941,
0.07360948622226715,
0.4114144444465637,
-0.0782124251127243,
0.8383426666259766,
0.29092663526535034,
-0.5611032247543335,
-0.060534439980983734,
0.4069864749908447,
-0.20259758830070496,
0.23630401492118835,
-0.3990779519081116,
0.3540341854095459,
-0.23837168514728546,
-0.07062806934118271,
-1.015801191329956,
0.013738708570599556,
0.11789663881063461,
-0.6497710943222046,
0.5437930822372437,
-0.22631379961967468,
-0.28848373889923096,
-0.1736585795879364,
-0.09642456471920013,
0.23942184448242188,
0.5032365918159485,
-0.20792508125305176,
0.2973479628562927,
0.8029139637947083,
-0.4482131898403168,
-0.9313968420028687,
-0.30093321204185486,
-0.1462281048297882,
-0.2709536552429199,
-0.3664935529232025,
0.021966582164168358,
0.10331139713525772,
-0.46855607628822327,
-0.2344394475221634,
-0.5576452016830444,
0.07298186421394348,
0.46440547704696655,
0.05489552766084671,
0.26638263463974,
-0.174582839012146,
0.3003627061843872,
0.05936083197593689,
-0.11823246628046036,
0.4643581509590149,
-0.23875641822814941,
0.4475747048854828,
0.12850479781627655,
-0.32742583751678467,
-0.09153516590595245,
0.119869664311409,
0.4968195855617523,
-0.19956539571285248,
0.48304304480552673,
0.33973413705825806,
-0.30947941541671753,
-0.1445751190185547,
-0.8892386555671692,
-0.36475294828414917,
-0.4119475483894348,
0.44817933440208435,
-0.451341450214386,
-0.7686028480529785,
0.6825897097587585,
-0.14045998454093933,
-0.06716777384281158,
0.44895753264427185,
0.30952784419059753,
-0.11153680086135864,
1.0823866128921509,
0.6928675770759583,
-0.21781153976917267,
0.5262239575386047,
-0.26954108476638794,
0.1502511352300644,
-0.8571147918701172,
-0.256369024515152,
-0.5481924414634705,
-0.19381463527679443,
-0.39194267988204956,
-0.1777833104133606,
0.3157443702220917,
0.4450438618659973,
0.15845635533332825,
-0.04716925695538521,
-0.324413537979126,
0.4013183116912842,
0.4980229437351227,
-0.044267844408750534,
0.3581330180168152,
-0.026467343792319298,
-0.3250890076160431,
-0.1072017103433609,
-0.7464119791984558,
-0.5538910627365112,
1.0783746242523193,
0.4570621848106384,
0.5452357530593872,
0.03212015703320503,
0.5911985635757446,
0.022715404629707336,
0.18436221778392792,
-0.5940033793449402,
0.3705151677131653,
-0.11941015720367432,
-0.6322000622749329,
-0.39282283186912537,
-0.22581946849822998,
-1.0172532796859741,
0.3465946316719055,
-0.17209717631340027,
-0.5783784985542297,
0.4095223844051361,
0.11569155752658844,
-0.3830910623073578,
0.05145691707730293,
-0.5618345141410828,
0.8156612515449524,
-0.23595008254051208,
-0.3805569112300873,
0.20518474280834198,
-0.801716685295105,
0.2508417069911957,
-0.030086230486631393,
0.27927085757255554,
-0.06839427351951599,
0.14641721546649933,
0.7939919233322144,
-0.2399882823228836,
0.785110592842102,
-0.4480148255825043,
-0.537022590637207,
0.0427975207567215,
0.23578767478466034,
0.7295673489570618,
0.03474905714392662,
-0.0783066377043724,
-0.1277904510498047,
0.009228859096765518,
-0.24341420829296112,
-0.6941391229629517,
0.4840431809425354,
-0.8134792447090149,
-1.096077561378479,
-0.3749788701534271,
-0.5934146046638489,
-0.5852208137512207,
0.14385150372982025,
0.2739863991737366,
0.23277831077575684,
-0.01791391149163246,
-0.04869309812784195,
1.1174259185791016,
-0.4165268838405609,
0.2052977979183197,
0.6935669779777527,
-0.18104232847690582,
0.05382445454597473,
0.7094725370407104,
0.14884547889232635,
0.20764455199241638,
0.46092185378074646,
0.21235080063343048,
-0.4120961129665375,
-0.8118312954902649,
-0.2661345601081848,
0.3309016823768616,
-0.7965492606163025,
-0.1598503142595291,
-0.7217927575111389,
-0.2762485146522522,
-0.6501345634460449,
0.20941805839538574,
-0.2706983983516693,
-0.5349029302597046,
-0.4657467007637024,
-0.3139604330062866,
0.09957714378833771,
0.7683995962142944,
0.2247898131608963,
0.18106964230537415,
-0.7132118940353394,
0.0894506424665451,
0.24266783893108368,
-0.08427287638187408,
-0.08461105078458786,
-0.7459839582443237,
-0.16999280452728271,
-0.2156437337398529,
-0.33124372363090515,
-0.9889878034591675,
0.3906349241733551,
-0.282501757144928,
0.7662445902824402,
0.32047250866889954,
-0.027284253388643265,
0.6237216591835022,
-0.25932902097702026,
0.685126006603241,
-0.2403900921344757,
-0.5588354468345642,
0.4579215943813324,
-0.28407981991767883,
0.41442710161209106,
0.5537925958633423,
0.39773765206336975,
-0.42844662070274353,
-0.5767834782600403,
-0.6735579967498779,
-0.8079710006713867,
0.60926353931427,
-0.15140259265899658,
-0.07328832149505615,
-0.10967963933944702,
0.7113200426101685,
0.33853116631507874,
0.3999893367290497,
-0.6935313940048218,
-0.23637954890727997,
0.13635531067848206,
-0.13075388967990875,
0.06108766794204712,
-0.598736584186554,
-0.07654951512813568,
-0.0492696575820446,
0.6231551170349121,
-0.05580035597085953,
0.27609142661094666,
0.3818468451499939,
-0.3529326319694519,
-0.18342271447181702,
0.25791189074516296,
0.47309693694114685,
0.7992776036262512,
-0.11288069188594818,
0.24011068046092987,
0.22776904702186584,
-0.36356762051582336,
-0.1284869909286499,
0.2686176896095276,
-0.3287988305091858,
-0.11641599982976913,
0.3248268961906433,
0.7583425641059875,
0.18927101790905,
-0.31732669472694397,
0.6128339171409607,
0.006714716553688049,
-0.04603462666273117,
-0.4366147518157959,
0.030405059456825256,
-0.16032275557518005,
0.3341309130191803,
0.656306266784668,
-0.07911768555641174,
0.11716832965612411,
-0.35236066579818726,
0.16233019530773163,
0.6684132218360901,
-0.3269535005092621,
-0.279252290725708,
0.6321882009506226,
-0.05861008167266846,
-0.2451922446489334,
0.5217300653457642,
-0.0955711379647255,
-0.6696516275405884,
0.6017929911613464,
0.545477569103241,
0.7369018793106079,
-0.14656952023506165,
0.10032065957784653,
0.2290695458650589,
0.20537976920604706,
0.10391877591609955,
0.2522575259208679,
0.06749594211578369,
-0.8293894529342651,
-0.32940834760665894,
-0.6730787754058838,
-0.22008776664733887,
0.2808653712272644,
-0.5836755037307739,
0.11199624836444855,
-0.32195815443992615,
-0.05254937335848808,
-0.28570640087127686,
0.044517889618873596,
-0.5501667261123657,
0.07329172641038895,
0.15772932767868042,
0.7684637308120728,
-0.5708416700363159,
0.9225999116897583,
0.5856094360351562,
-0.4320457875728607,
-0.7385963797569275,
0.1522502601146698,
0.03135281056165695,
-1.0202600955963135,
0.6481078863143921,
-0.08362315595149994,
-0.13246610760688782,
-0.04535551369190216,
-0.7837370038032532,
-1.049012541770935,
1.0525308847427368,
0.43203505873680115,
-0.5028921365737915,
-0.42556843161582947,
0.05550230294466019,
0.4949367940425873,
-0.2705865502357483,
0.04326925426721573,
0.6531137228012085,
0.3069520592689514,
0.004075292963534594,
-0.6989926099777222,
0.21462950110435486,
-0.2621321976184845,
-0.09230847656726837,
0.022832121700048447,
-0.5685074925422668,
0.8274080157279968,
-0.1359919160604477,
-0.16641011834144592,
-0.14375801384449005,
0.3824760317802429,
0.2777097523212433,
0.08243338763713837,
0.48235249519348145,
0.2877708077430725,
0.9816265106201172,
-0.006749185733497143,
1.1308104991912842,
-0.2824135422706604,
0.12229375541210175,
1.1853116750717163,
-0.1938249170780182,
0.6665820479393005,
0.8208915591239929,
0.01961258053779602,
0.5168522596359253,
0.7308079600334167,
0.1531475931406021,
0.5227975845336914,
0.31251949071884155,
-0.04293989762663841,
-0.2589243948459625,
0.027761857956647873,
-0.21063923835754395,
0.45575183629989624,
0.34896937012672424,
-0.4594593942165375,
0.010575282387435436,
-0.00046676694182679057,
0.14521107077598572,
-0.08031980693340302,
-0.014787202700972557,
0.9530826807022095,
0.23403307795524597,
-0.9711782336235046,
0.6078038811683655,
-0.05872105434536934,
0.47458046674728394,
-0.5828762054443359,
-0.10379145294427872,
-0.4904549717903137,
0.013771277852356434,
-0.030814331024885178,
-0.4799501299858093,
0.12634363770484924,
-0.08581741899251938,
-0.3295448422431946,
-0.28771862387657166,
0.8388780355453491,
-0.37752777338027954,
-0.18138399720191956,
0.14516529440879822,
0.7670654058456421,
0.21950122714042664,
-0.1202913299202919,
-0.6183937788009644,
-0.23637035489082336,
0.026233747601509094,
-0.3759552836418152,
0.5136889815330505,
0.7174369096755981,
-0.12635503709316254,
0.5986647605895996,
0.6078746914863586,
0.24140334129333496,
0.25193238258361816,
0.04613802954554558,
0.8322054743766785,
-0.6176251173019409,
-0.31002897024154663,
-0.8531075716018677,
0.24019697308540344,
-0.09825118631124496,
-0.47729024291038513,
0.8965904116630554,
0.39863741397857666,
0.7542605400085449,
0.08124899864196777,
0.8524612188339233,
0.13250777125358582,
0.6060184240341187,
-0.7086886167526245,
0.6132439374923706,
-0.6079853773117065,
0.6715049743652344,
-0.1442411243915558,
-0.7536519765853882,
-0.2272528111934662,
0.6651765704154968,
-0.7130939960479736,
-0.1188964694738388,
0.7936164140701294,
0.7076722383499146,
0.13404212892055511,
-0.03815816342830658,
0.1854548156261444,
0.5742827653884888,
0.21493086218833923,
0.36849188804626465,
0.8802531361579895,
-0.33860546350479126,
0.5576338171958923,
-0.12275619804859161,
-0.13123662769794464,
-0.09511961787939072,
-0.6618218421936035,
-0.6299786567687988,
-0.5223973393440247,
-0.15273809432983398,
-0.3331364095211029,
0.04319681599736214,
0.8827873468399048,
0.3533400893211365,
-0.7840754985809326,
-0.1700936257839203,
-0.08425404876470566,
0.5626823902130127,
0.07115878164768219,
-0.2659284174442291,
0.40527278184890747,
-0.5664309859275818,
-0.6969773769378662,
0.38652148842811584,
0.04118078202009201,
0.11200320720672607,
-0.27240094542503357,
0.10727594047784805,
-0.45617300271987915,
-0.1802443116903305,
0.31399214267730713,
0.28438639640808105,
-0.6408610343933105,
-0.2594992518424988,
0.2707861065864563,
-0.13767342269420624,
0.22375516593456268,
0.8711839914321899,
-0.626085102558136,
0.36432206630706787,
0.28699246048927307,
0.7661073207855225,
0.44988399744033813,
0.1813434511423111,
0.8804289102554321,
-0.8648579716682434,
-0.1185234785079956,
0.07404839247465134,
0.25531309843063354,
0.3245681822299957,
-0.5263911485671997,
0.345744788646698,
0.41451025009155273,
-0.617385983467102,
-0.840992271900177,
0.16684140264987946,
-0.6040000915527344,
-0.43729037046432495,
1.2979772090911865,
-0.07069564610719681,
-0.19536826014518738,
-0.27664557099342346,
-0.2036770135164261,
0.39897578954696655,
-0.189093679189682,
1.1667133569717407,
0.9939724206924438,
-0.1125357523560524,
-0.21028664708137512,
-0.6896608471870422,
0.6658929586410522,
0.6910279989242554,
-0.6141282320022583,
0.15565308928489685,
0.449514240026474,
0.5255899429321289,
0.09000907093286514,
0.6043877601623535,
-0.3546738922595978,
-0.013793380931019783,
-0.24309110641479492,
-0.05748552829027176,
0.031387828290462494,
-0.3166505992412567,
-0.6310164928436279,
0.21165792644023895,
0.39001551270484924,
-0.11581382900476456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10466v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10466v4 | Large Language Models as Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracker through Function Calling | 2024-02-16T06:13:18 | 2024-05-30T04:19:54 | Zekun Li, Zhiyu Zoey Chen, Mike Ross, Patrick Huber, Seungwhan Moon, Zhaojiang Lin, Xin Luna Dong, Adithya Sagar, Xifeng Yan, Paul A. Crook | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly prevalent in conversational
systems due to their advanced understanding and generative capabilities in
general contexts. However, their effectiveness in task-oriented dialogues
(TOD), which requires not only response generation but also effective dialogue
state tracking (DST) within specific tasks and domains, remains less
satisfying. In this work, we propose a novel approach FnCTOD for solving DST
with LLMs through function calling. This method improves zero-shot DST,
allowing adaptation to diverse domains without extensive data collection or
model tuning. Our experimental results demonstrate that our approach achieves
exceptional performance with both modestly sized open-source and also
proprietary LLMs: with in-context prompting it enables various 7B or 13B
parameter models to surpass the previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) achieved by
ChatGPT, and improves ChatGPT's performance beating the SOTA by 5.6% average
joint goal accuracy (JGA). Individual model results for GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 are
boosted by 4.8% and 14%, respectively. We also show that by fine-tuning on a
small collection of diverse task-oriented dialogues, we can equip modestly
sized models, specifically a 13B parameter LLaMA2-Chat model, with
function-calling capabilities and DST performance comparable to ChatGPT while
maintaining their chat capabilities. We have made the code publicly available
at https://github.com/facebookresearch/FnCTOD | [
-0.2317013293504715,
-1.0309650897979736,
0.6312867403030396,
0.14157864451408386,
-0.4247395098209381,
0.19549153745174408,
-0.5681169629096985,
-0.3103533983230591,
0.1523813158273697,
0.7182263135910034,
-0.7074708342552185,
-0.5007649660110474,
-0.30623456835746765,
-0.09111741930246353,
-0.15350012481212616,
0.8894127607345581,
-0.0029509153682738543,
0.0262245275080204,
0.08346261829137802,
0.04168664291501045,
-0.4494973123073578,
-0.3980591893196106,
-0.5524637699127197,
-0.04550664499402046,
0.3318491578102112,
0.3826061487197876,
0.29675278067588806,
0.27546706795692444,
0.22016245126724243,
0.22352080047130585,
-0.19953620433807373,
0.1580236554145813,
-0.7727513909339905,
0.2770344913005829,
-0.20285232365131378,
-0.5222187638282776,
-0.5353871583938599,
-0.4483296573162079,
0.6292790174484253,
0.4938313961029053,
-0.2365262657403946,
0.12067336589097977,
0.2181396484375,
0.11439733952283859,
-0.5029385685920715,
0.6282712817192078,
-0.8095672726631165,
-0.2780688405036926,
-0.12002739310264587,
-0.44683942198753357,
-0.5110565423965454,
-0.21787413954734802,
0.05008463189005852,
-0.3445887267589569,
-0.03184729069471359,
-0.253727525472641,
0.39018088579177856,
0.2929239869117737,
-0.29847532510757446,
-0.22797134518623352,
-0.8104158043861389,
0.8492021560668945,
-1.0950465202331543,
0.16380459070205688,
0.07530545443296432,
0.27316275238990784,
-0.43720772862434387,
-0.32595890760421753,
-0.4694351851940155,
-0.5002471804618835,
0.4071502685546875,
-0.12503233551979065,
-0.2599170506000519,
0.23785382509231567,
0.45582494139671326,
0.286624938249588,
-0.28550082445144653,
0.09561111778020859,
-0.033268775790929794,
-0.09994594007730484,
0.5994418263435364,
0.3815065324306488,
0.07247582823038101,
0.10664107650518417,
-0.2240867167711258,
0.22191201150417328,
-0.730383038520813,
0.09944608807563782,
0.004602693486958742,
0.8891844153404236,
-0.18489092588424683,
0.45368534326553345,
-0.5959744453430176,
0.8981962203979492,
0.17920419573783875,
-0.25398609042167664,
-0.08347537368535995,
-0.34280651807785034,
-0.3094121515750885,
-0.1097283661365509,
0.7130839228630066,
0.33503472805023193,
0.2640898823738098,
-0.005702805705368519,
-0.16521377861499786,
-0.19647349417209625,
0.12328020483255386,
-1.157899260520935,
0.07870372384786606,
0.0398307703435421,
-0.21749432384967804,
-0.21661266684532166,
-0.43939274549484253,
-0.5237839221954346,
-0.3042244017124176,
-0.3727664351463318,
0.49932774901390076,
-0.47969698905944824,
-0.36397844552993774,
0.009722939692437649,
0.5953617095947266,
0.25356265902519226,
0.7114077806472778,
-0.9687513709068298,
0.26602503657341003,
0.7480351328849792,
1.2114685773849487,
-0.09156931191682816,
0.25392958521842957,
-0.7824301719665527,
-0.04709799960255623,
-0.38777777552604675,
0.5921770334243774,
-0.4767252504825592,
-0.4654890298843384,
-0.0019855715800076723,
-0.11829143762588501,
-0.16836023330688477,
-0.27807047963142395,
0.15881110727787018,
-0.29586267471313477,
-0.22155070304870605,
-0.2113577127456665,
-0.5195930004119873,
-0.10066003352403641,
0.3899363875389099,
-0.2653043270111084,
0.7635669708251953,
0.04129904508590698,
-0.5023210644721985,
-0.008573991246521473,
-0.7483200430870056,
-0.3194843530654907,
0.16379760205745697,
-0.20726780593395233,
-0.12269701808691025,
0.2780548334121704,
0.16092589497566223,
0.6355547308921814,
-0.45322147011756897,
0.4204992651939392,
-0.5723849534988403,
-0.4801087975502014,
0.21887169778347015,
-0.4827669858932495,
0.7361189126968384,
0.15067017078399658,
-0.3414739966392517,
0.2711883783340454,
-0.46407485008239746,
0.07779094576835632,
0.0748683288693428,
-0.14066581428050995,
-0.17427164316177368,
-0.005270093213766813,
-0.057043369859457016,
0.2024938315153122,
0.13429702818393707,
-0.8065202832221985,
0.37454357743263245,
-0.4682086706161499,
0.5643267631530762,
0.5813339948654175,
0.07868556678295135,
0.09652703255414963,
-0.15756303071975708,
0.6526986360549927,
-0.08448778837919235,
0.015025787986814976,
-0.25643235445022583,
-0.49644994735717773,
-0.608713686466217,
-0.5889246463775635,
0.12272264808416367,
0.50446617603302,
-0.904114305973053,
0.2820003628730774,
-0.35981816053390503,
-0.4402058720588684,
-0.16121666133403778,
0.016873503103852272,
0.4233156144618988,
0.40274184942245483,
0.2258375734090805,
-0.3652682602405548,
-0.05898357927799225,
-0.570733368396759,
-0.10974816232919693,
-0.07877936214208603,
-0.13758185505867004,
0.5090595483779907,
0.3813457489013672,
0.09251266717910767,
0.9701758623123169,
-0.6384540796279907,
-0.43936097621917725,
-0.4317358434200287,
-0.13877542316913605,
0.30567991733551025,
0.17961439490318298,
0.48200079798698425,
-0.3838145136833191,
-0.6970643997192383,
0.09808029979467392,
-0.3231588304042816,
-0.24530978500843048,
0.10367955267429352,
0.05191456153988838,
0.3733662962913513,
0.3713594079017639,
-0.5014147758483887,
0.5871424674987793,
0.5294485688209534,
-0.2020149677991867,
0.4014873206615448,
0.10386835783720016,
0.05652501806616783,
-1.3402613401412964,
0.1577727049589157,
0.07880845665931702,
-0.44245192408561707,
-0.8570355176925659,
-0.17415398359298706,
-0.1035521849989891,
-0.1822892725467682,
-0.5948600172996521,
0.7401725649833679,
-0.2907350957393646,
-0.10005904734134674,
-0.4729383587837219,
0.10948498547077179,
-0.5387956500053406,
0.7349966168403625,
0.06262191385030746,
0.6600217223167419,
0.6025334000587463,
-0.41248077154159546,
0.3689006567001343,
0.24450506269931793,
-0.40403246879577637,
0.598070502281189,
-0.42311882972717285,
0.16788582503795624,
0.19135108590126038,
0.6993103623390198,
-1.21437406539917,
0.006865402217954397,
0.20928458869457245,
-0.2978734076023102,
0.3031066358089447,
-0.38846802711486816,
-0.3801767826080322,
-0.14263570308685303,
-0.20026011765003204,
0.3057435154914856,
0.2293453961610794,
-0.3521440327167511,
0.5772513747215271,
0.19190210103988647,
-0.4590068459510803,
-0.41939976811408997,
-0.4025421142578125,
0.11784413456916809,
-0.03126278519630432,
-0.5342143177986145,
0.2328827828168869,
-0.19754758477210999,
0.061191242188215256,
-0.38441187143325806,
-0.49034345149993896,
-0.03677913546562195,
-0.022416768595576286,
0.1775778979063034,
0.29138249158859253,
-0.3168773055076599,
-0.1481972336769104,
-0.03947816044092178,
-0.08903863281011581,
-0.23524196445941925,
-0.42154327034950256,
0.8984375,
-0.06422796845436096,
-0.3347502052783966,
-0.6997905373573303,
0.35077840089797974,
0.6168848276138306,
-0.24326159060001373,
0.560039222240448,
0.4459068179130554,
-0.23146706819534302,
-0.45239028334617615,
-0.5254292488098145,
-0.3850680887699127,
-0.45292672514915466,
0.3455014228820801,
-0.5171524286270142,
-1.441980242729187,
0.5567353963851929,
-0.02054111659526825,
0.290423184633255,
-0.026477139443159103,
0.9096794724464417,
0.17125734686851501,
0.9407631754875183,
0.617148220539093,
-0.10305812209844589,
0.8501653075218201,
-0.1637049913406372,
0.4237176477909088,
-0.7997467517852783,
0.08653717488050461,
-0.4630544185638428,
-0.11772795766592026,
-0.49784088134765625,
-0.7319768071174622,
0.3870120346546173,
0.08310402184724808,
-0.17963063716888428,
0.37078577280044556,
-0.2542749345302582,
0.36215779185295105,
0.2866639792919159,
0.10791915655136108,
0.5406492948532104,
-0.00935445073992014,
-0.07320212572813034,
-0.0021823153365403414,
-0.6705825924873352,
-0.3266972005367279,
1.0687215328216553,
0.2839055061340332,
0.8714827299118042,
0.1532825529575348,
0.6881707310676575,
0.11044224351644516,
0.5030930042266846,
-1.026105284690857,
0.8198457360267639,
-0.3340277075767517,
-0.4397549033164978,
-0.40019914507865906,
-0.5565341114997864,
-0.5111350417137146,
0.3672354519367218,
0.18158039450645447,
-1.4530926942825317,
-0.12729111313819885,
0.19563186168670654,
-0.6321126222610474,
0.30333200097084045,
-0.48669448494911194,
0.7282446026802063,
0.02325008623301983,
-0.37744858860969543,
-0.2936239242553711,
-0.42064234614372253,
0.47444865107536316,
-0.05721627548336983,
-0.1375718116760254,
-0.4772689640522003,
0.24853184819221497,
0.4801139235496521,
-0.5575167536735535,
1.2420064210891724,
-0.42796429991722107,
-0.5086703300476074,
0.40122368931770325,
0.2495715618133545,
0.551899790763855,
0.02417675219476223,
0.12600843608379364,
0.1488276720046997,
0.3907741904258728,
-0.27289244532585144,
-0.647679328918457,
0.988557755947113,
-0.37262430787086487,
-0.7269625067710876,
-0.15469834208488464,
-0.7704850435256958,
-0.39643803238868713,
0.1572326272726059,
-0.15709085762500763,
0.7453442215919495,
-0.2468864917755127,
0.42920538783073425,
0.5868287086486816,
-0.18108613789081573,
0.6052693724632263,
0.8224490284919739,
-0.3841789960861206,
-0.11454892158508301,
0.905766487121582,
0.055997584015131,
0.7154029011726379,
0.538184642791748,
0.053009215742349625,
-0.5785491466522217,
-0.4766119420528412,
-0.5176081657409668,
0.18408676981925964,
-0.3935273289680481,
-0.48713651299476624,
-0.6700270175933838,
-0.22935007512569427,
-0.37390702962875366,
-0.008753187954425812,
-0.4307916462421417,
-0.35250112414360046,
-0.16870465874671936,
0.12256090342998505,
0.5321157574653625,
0.30596184730529785,
0.1708032637834549,
0.405046671628952,
-0.5789933800697327,
0.3390626609325409,
0.16979150474071503,
0.5122136473655701,
0.06491637974977493,
-0.4500650465488434,
-0.08911395817995071,
0.36004164814949036,
-0.420855313539505,
-0.7434296011924744,
0.29006481170654297,
0.13640913367271423,
0.36915215849876404,
0.2685653567314148,
0.28978559374809265,
0.7071899175643921,
-0.4200044274330139,
0.7702723145484924,
0.24593394994735718,
-1.1759531497955322,
0.47567060589790344,
-0.7891289591789246,
0.5263022184371948,
0.3049142360687256,
-0.03222404792904854,
-0.5771393179893494,
-0.5569553971290588,
-0.2230289876461029,
-0.5792152881622314,
1.1102283000946045,
0.22458596527576447,
0.30841580033302307,
0.11725842952728271,
0.19530801475048065,
-0.17992621660232544,
0.13366711139678955,
-0.4327705204486847,
0.10479658097028732,
-0.11515357345342636,
-0.2398381531238556,
-0.03898583725094795,
-0.06404545903205872,
-0.1300133466720581,
-0.07559192925691605,
0.5525239109992981,
-0.6317957043647766,
0.41869693994522095,
0.03494502604007721,
-0.06222895532846451,
-0.1674117147922516,
0.4929347634315491,
0.8788673877716064,
0.6108726859092712,
-0.2706087529659271,
-0.39751169085502625,
0.33458882570266724,
-0.30131587386131287,
0.03567727282643318,
0.21136797964572906,
-0.16044197976589203,
-0.12628231942653656,
0.03883182629942894,
0.9943555593490601,
0.5058650374412537,
-0.6718267202377319,
0.5993584394454956,
0.05868891626596451,
-0.20569603145122528,
-0.04157627746462822,
0.3252188563346863,
0.10305152088403702,
0.5736457109451294,
0.3741816282272339,
-0.2974410355091095,
-0.12448855489492416,
-0.5697404146194458,
0.17320263385772705,
0.6612676382064819,
-0.5449957847595215,
-0.35890114307403564,
0.5371034145355225,
0.41399332880973816,
-0.34213072061538696,
0.3060459494590759,
0.029360506683588028,
-0.4412223994731903,
0.438700795173645,
0.727074921131134,
0.8944954872131348,
-0.43682584166526794,
0.39453133940696716,
0.17922329902648926,
-0.11415138840675354,
-0.11020486056804657,
0.3430503010749817,
-0.39506053924560547,
-0.7702065706253052,
-0.9312506318092346,
-0.7310452461242676,
-0.4964295029640198,
0.29899460077285767,
-0.6289827227592468,
0.24298036098480225,
-0.5107681751251221,
-0.21577627956867218,
-0.004493368789553642,
0.20831477642059326,
-0.35108089447021484,
-0.037699028849601746,
0.24770592153072357,
0.9144397377967834,
-0.3805113434791565,
1.1229568719863892,
0.332354873418808,
-0.15810617804527283,
-0.7344858646392822,
0.12698166072368622,
0.30489882826805115,
-0.645091712474823,
0.2793702781200409,
0.21888571977615356,
-0.40977784991264343,
0.2866459786891937,
-0.4946961998939514,
-0.7801592946052551,
1.1265301704406738,
0.4438515305519104,
-0.8820434808731079,
0.12096451222896576,
0.02460114285349846,
0.5656331181526184,
-0.6183472871780396,
0.3183871805667877,
0.6348407864570618,
0.14275594055652618,
0.4934343993663788,
-1.3700705766677856,
0.2172679603099823,
0.10174442082643509,
0.1782505065202713,
0.47473618388175964,
-0.8767058849334717,
0.4627811014652252,
-0.3010913133621216,
-0.15247586369514465,
0.39723172783851624,
0.3997493088245392,
0.362445592880249,
0.1128932312130928,
0.5399105548858643,
0.18091298639774323,
0.34434178471565247,
-0.1454765498638153,
0.7664870023727417,
-0.24587172269821167,
0.5747846364974976,
1.2067797183990479,
-0.5747888684272766,
0.9316135048866272,
0.3496749699115753,
0.0706145167350769,
0.045327067375183105,
0.2915298640727997,
0.1285335123538971,
0.5617746710777283,
0.4150857627391815,
-0.4304961562156677,
-0.33129358291625977,
-0.24125955998897552,
-0.16017763316631317,
0.5301464796066284,
0.6218323111534119,
-0.10178765654563904,
-0.4243362247943878,
-0.07930292189121246,
0.1666940152645111,
-0.15370823442935944,
-0.2808081805706024,
0.8030330538749695,
0.24145524203777313,
-0.6906536221504211,
0.7684036493301392,
-0.04715751111507416,
0.6716618537902832,
-0.739704430103302,
-0.0011135067325085402,
-0.34472838044166565,
0.3427177369594574,
0.06462575495243073,
-0.4548014998435974,
0.2528280019760132,
0.2391054779291153,
0.1383092701435089,
-0.2599653899669647,
0.4784325659275055,
-0.6373566389083862,
-0.3655540645122528,
0.32408228516578674,
0.333481103181839,
0.01068204827606678,
-0.19580142199993134,
-0.5256328582763672,
0.2884993851184845,
0.4147849977016449,
-0.1707572489976883,
0.3986150026321411,
0.21395878493785858,
-0.4318021237850189,
0.7759377360343933,
0.703708827495575,
-0.06600091606378555,
-0.11409401148557663,
0.1829293668270111,
0.9187129139900208,
-0.6261780858039856,
-0.5474267601966858,
-0.7524051070213318,
0.40977251529693604,
-0.012546464800834656,
-0.29117828607559204,
0.46975570917129517,
0.33242493867874146,
0.6751668453216553,
-0.042784519493579865,
0.6145781874656677,
-0.16452538967132568,
0.6363880038261414,
-0.5033893585205078,
0.5623573660850525,
-0.37679487466812134,
0.24588365852832794,
-0.43659642338752747,
-1.1019281148910522,
-0.38756731152534485,
0.4903595745563507,
-0.48306697607040405,
-0.03767574951052666,
0.3863297402858734,
1.0238014459609985,
-0.13981035351753235,
0.22253620624542236,
0.625720739364624,
0.4039662480354309,
0.7243636846542358,
0.6307543516159058,
0.9183929562568665,
-0.06832843273878098,
0.569280743598938,
0.06285429000854492,
-0.40208280086517334,
-0.5432643294334412,
-0.7728240489959717,
-1.0695257186889648,
-0.6211587190628052,
-0.4199501872062683,
-0.1284773051738739,
0.04201888665556908,
0.9139653444290161,
0.8518891930580139,
-0.8045120239257812,
-0.3278398811817169,
0.09301922470331192,
-0.23286564648151398,
-0.17957857251167297,
-0.26804035902023315,
0.0672929510474205,
-0.35332679748535156,
-0.8194958567619324,
0.5532845258712769,
0.46273159980773926,
-0.08450561761856079,
-0.26273229718208313,
0.05302070826292038,
-0.08170967549085617,
0.3008367121219635,
0.7890117764472961,
0.30081114172935486,
-1.0965983867645264,
-0.36285415291786194,
-0.09850601851940155,
0.12334413081407547,
-0.08157195895910263,
1.0835505723953247,
-0.41950878500938416,
0.4212004840373993,
0.30013027787208557,
0.5271030068397522,
0.8924760818481445,
0.06211268901824951,
0.7001950740814209,
-0.7940210700035095,
0.15322540700435638,
0.28307440876960754,
0.1274380385875702,
0.32060739398002625,
-0.16974733769893646,
0.31600338220596313,
-0.005874748807400465,
-0.4309736490249634,
-0.9214529991149902,
0.42947980761528015,
-1.2453216314315796,
-0.08753687143325806,
1.1850894689559937,
-0.3259739577770233,
0.02184356190264225,
-0.0770721361041069,
-0.353331983089447,
0.12164618819952011,
-0.7589150667190552,
0.663809061050415,
0.60328209400177,
-0.2823392152786255,
-0.2818760573863983,
-0.733397364616394,
0.46128779649734497,
0.22672609984874725,
-0.7274088263511658,
0.40681126713752747,
0.6070296764373779,
0.5657941102981567,
-0.022911783307790756,
0.985027551651001,
0.042125385254621506,
-0.10675908625125885,
-0.4277888834476471,
-0.26064562797546387,
0.00913152378052473,
-0.22928564250469208,
-0.26731693744659424,
-0.07615961879491806,
-0.08303583413362503,
-0.2812303304672241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10462v1 | QDyLoRA: Quantized Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation for Efficient Large Language Model Tuning | 2024-02-16T05:42:17 | 2024-02-16T05:42:17 | Hossein Rajabzadeh, Mojtaba Valipour, Tianshu Zhu, Marzieh Tahaei, Hyock Ju Kwon, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Finetuning large language models requires huge GPU memory, restricting the
choice to acquire Larger models. While the quantized version of the Low-Rank
Adaptation technique, named QLoRA, significantly alleviates this issue, finding
the efficient LoRA rank is still challenging. Moreover, QLoRA is trained on a
pre-defined rank and, therefore, cannot be reconfigured for its lower ranks
without requiring further fine-tuning steps. This paper proposes QDyLoRA
-Quantized Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation-, as an efficient quantization approach
for dynamic low-rank adaptation. Motivated by Dynamic LoRA, QDyLoRA is able to
efficiently finetune LLMs on a set of pre-defined LoRA ranks. QDyLoRA enables
fine-tuning Falcon-40b for ranks 1 to 64 on a single 32 GB V100-GPU through one
round of fine-tuning. Experimental results show that QDyLoRA is competitive to
QLoRA and outperforms when employing its optimal rank. | [
-0.27840158343315125,
-0.8629545569419861,
0.48756614327430725,
0.18913106620311737,
-0.4968322217464447,
0.4935716688632965,
-0.2893964946269989,
-0.20109838247299194,
-0.11344937235116959,
0.16508309543132782,
-0.3713592290878296,
-0.5921221375465393,
-0.33103325963020325,
-0.18389038741588593,
-0.11006475239992142,
1.0111033916473389,
0.24512359499931335,
-0.33800041675567627,
0.28563785552978516,
-0.3626723289489746,
-0.5217269659042358,
-0.33796292543411255,
-1.019561767578125,
0.1678079217672348,
0.9081726670265198,
0.4147945046424866,
0.9838201999664307,
0.5499705076217651,
0.4113772213459015,
0.38094866275787354,
-0.32415899634361267,
0.21329548954963684,
-0.934289813041687,
0.3540530502796173,
-0.2718895673751831,
-0.7557476758956909,
-0.9212459325790405,
-0.10858942568302155,
0.9620632529258728,
0.39463499188423157,
-0.2723642885684967,
0.41310009360313416,
-0.08075250685214996,
0.8021001815795898,
-0.9639632701873779,
0.18142955005168915,
-0.87038654088974,
0.09131281822919846,
-0.2588326334953308,
-0.3550319969654083,
-0.027908923104405403,
-0.5413541197776794,
-0.23767700791358948,
-1.0731662511825562,
-0.2976442873477936,
0.026341969147324562,
0.6199698448181152,
0.5810683369636536,
-0.5423777103424072,
0.029527107253670692,
-0.8921496272087097,
0.5333072543144226,
-0.7351481914520264,
0.2544825077056885,
0.10743720829486847,
0.598739504814148,
-0.10687673091888428,
-0.7452669143676758,
-0.407074511051178,
-0.0039527527987957,
0.5624711513519287,
0.09110201895236969,
-0.14564315974712372,
0.21219296753406525,
0.45076167583465576,
0.49096396565437317,
-0.4825315475463867,
0.3864664137363434,
-0.2159615457057953,
0.27395865321159363,
0.4351412355899811,
0.11790242046117783,
0.23634333908557892,
0.23981362581253052,
0.057024918496608734,
-0.3119019567966461,
-0.6608429551124573,
0.11822621524333954,
0.41357067227363586,
0.44052690267562866,
-0.1737869828939438,
0.19058352708816528,
-0.28895822167396545,
0.6822564005851746,
0.43210095167160034,
-0.3452959656715393,
-0.15703317523002625,
-0.06476716697216034,
-0.45326611399650574,
0.35403767228126526,
0.18964624404907227,
0.02840729057788849,
0.25480204820632935,
0.011840484105050564,
-0.22211354970932007,
0.09018225222826004,
0.15545257925987244,
-1.1247981786727905,
-0.5401225090026855,
0.22422152757644653,
-0.39944571256637573,
-0.370534747838974,
-0.14595042169094086,
-0.8381026387214661,
-0.38737034797668457,
-0.21061015129089355,
0.60576331615448,
-0.08059267699718475,
-0.25718846917152405,
0.03154477849602699,
0.1382869929075241,
0.10302864760160446,
0.601016640663147,
-0.972272515296936,
0.30641964077949524,
0.5906456112861633,
0.9254508018493652,
-0.23616574704647064,
-0.11369607597589493,
-1.1332058906555176,
0.12803909182548523,
-0.5052528381347656,
0.6968955397605896,
-0.4098743498325348,
-0.2003997415304184,
-0.17523649334907532,
0.13829079270362854,
-0.255301296710968,
-0.7581133842468262,
0.31904134154319763,
-0.8726401925086975,
-0.1383841186761856,
0.01243863720446825,
-0.34443214535713196,
-0.013980070129036903,
-0.1477413922548294,
-0.6846799254417419,
0.7215576767921448,
0.5780866742134094,
-0.5653561949729919,
0.20545727014541626,
-0.4490799903869629,
0.0032158212270587683,
0.1700494885444641,
0.2399117648601532,
-0.4546138644218445,
0.4589046835899353,
-0.04189581796526909,
0.01632123440504074,
-0.12332373857498169,
0.14204487204551697,
-0.6268068552017212,
-0.7597609758377075,
0.2572048306465149,
-0.5214074850082397,
0.779518187046051,
0.5247403383255005,
-0.18677115440368652,
0.35852599143981934,
-0.825372576713562,
0.28212636709213257,
0.04649141803383827,
-0.6377891302108765,
-0.4516805410385132,
-0.1000501960515976,
-0.0743408128619194,
0.13625404238700867,
0.15671440958976746,
-0.06143835932016373,
0.5569445490837097,
-0.4942251145839691,
0.5580669045448303,
0.7147517204284668,
-0.03218927979469299,
0.4650406539440155,
-0.1541842222213745,
0.8395848870277405,
-0.07284434884786606,
0.1771443784236908,
0.32396411895751953,
-0.16798733174800873,
-0.8556122183799744,
-0.2668047845363617,
0.49708256125450134,
0.4213728904724121,
-0.977952778339386,
0.19898302853107452,
-0.38483530282974243,
-0.4406226575374603,
-0.5897032022476196,
0.21481958031654358,
0.19561803340911865,
-0.09604689478874207,
0.20892885327339172,
0.031979870051145554,
-0.3138900399208069,
-0.465860515832901,
-0.17571091651916504,
-0.06810120493173599,
0.15147973597049713,
-0.02129259519279003,
0.1882176697254181,
0.054863397032022476,
0.6277268528938293,
-0.4954964816570282,
-0.36523735523223877,
0.047061990946531296,
-0.14035864174365997,
0.41647207736968994,
0.5513831973075867,
0.8182289600372314,
-0.6350557208061218,
-0.6461354494094849,
0.15162868797779083,
-0.40177100896835327,
-0.07300534844398499,
-0.0576426200568676,
-0.2989068627357483,
0.18212635815143585,
0.5738226175308228,
-0.5020465850830078,
0.20743796229362488,
1.1245038509368896,
-0.47760218381881714,
0.29813703894615173,
-0.6360819339752197,
0.002105539431795478,
-0.9699646830558777,
0.06615269929170609,
-0.3193858563899994,
-0.5214729309082031,
-0.47259941697120667,
0.2384561151266098,
0.11168414354324341,
-0.39080873131752014,
-0.5475504994392395,
0.5008738040924072,
-0.3265293538570404,
-0.20488686859607697,
-0.47946593165397644,
0.4678674042224884,
-0.14250925183296204,
0.5142818689346313,
-0.4279139041900635,
1.0762150287628174,
0.419187068939209,
-0.5121080279350281,
0.4760607182979584,
0.08019494265317917,
-0.38211509585380554,
0.6862131953239441,
-0.4153154492378235,
0.08584947139024734,
0.07478092610836029,
0.17499972879886627,
-0.6988499164581299,
0.1554115116596222,
0.13656161725521088,
0.1673903465270996,
0.24685636162757874,
-0.5711476802825928,
-0.268227756023407,
-0.03537414222955704,
-0.3139098882675171,
0.8433631658554077,
0.5324522852897644,
-0.7471707463264465,
0.14757736027240753,
0.3282166123390198,
-0.3462907075881958,
0.03226413577795029,
-0.24251796305179596,
0.10975460708141327,
-0.601002037525177,
-0.1507038027048111,
0.5035038590431213,
-0.492197185754776,
-0.3361932933330536,
-0.27798646688461304,
-0.019970638677477837,
0.14950208365917206,
0.5534868240356445,
0.26081010699272156,
-0.06635932624340057,
-0.5509420037269592,
0.16277267038822174,
0.30928680300712585,
-0.14773546159267426,
-0.33164480328559875,
-0.27345797419548035,
0.42677539587020874,
-0.33128562569618225,
-0.03143589198589325,
-0.5836076140403748,
0.01700148917734623,
0.7896425724029541,
-0.19760453701019287,
0.6880079507827759,
0.7063900232315063,
-0.21238821744918823,
-0.5346328020095825,
0.00908456277102232,
-0.03396529704332352,
-0.5485072731971741,
0.5315732955932617,
-0.5241693258285522,
-0.775892972946167,
0.48121121525764465,
-0.396279901266098,
-0.3114382028579712,
0.43293461203575134,
0.4960777461528778,
-0.0514555498957634,
1.1289511919021606,
0.500198483467102,
-0.041770316660404205,
0.7763551473617554,
-0.316934734582901,
0.15865041315555573,
-0.7689663171768188,
0.36807680130004883,
-0.4641852080821991,
-0.5045981407165527,
-1.1221743822097778,
-0.40673455595970154,
0.5518298149108887,
0.47447943687438965,
-0.5014400482177734,
-0.08904185146093369,
-0.386072039604187,
0.41156333684921265,
0.4359566867351532,
0.028059637174010277,
0.4535864293575287,
-0.020839789882302284,
0.4098733365535736,
0.16637447476387024,
-0.7746067047119141,
-0.11415445804595947,
0.7568463683128357,
0.22106295824050903,
0.7300435304641724,
0.5547332167625427,
0.5740643739700317,
0.4946730434894562,
0.005808614660054445,
-0.7718240022659302,
0.415116548538208,
-0.579243004322052,
-0.13990148901939392,
-0.5562079548835754,
-0.3414188027381897,
-0.9444974660873413,
0.40612274408340454,
-0.38381925225257874,
-0.5455363988876343,
0.365380197763443,
0.15533235669136047,
-0.8769077658653259,
0.2347332388162613,
-0.5017233490943909,
0.8543548583984375,
-0.09165291488170624,
-0.37608134746551514,
-0.4892154037952423,
-0.07891152799129486,
0.3644336462020874,
-0.40453463792800903,
0.04513385519385338,
-0.4451505243778229,
0.10611173510551453,
0.804590106010437,
-0.5082728266716003,
0.6449348330497742,
-0.4502389430999756,
-0.5654394626617432,
-0.048797979950904846,
0.2624147832393646,
0.7591725587844849,
0.3215307295322418,
-0.13996805250644684,
-0.18883849680423737,
0.6943957805633545,
-0.5921905636787415,
-0.8777708411216736,
1.0771702527999878,
-0.9569255113601685,
-0.6134366989135742,
-0.44465208053588867,
-0.6756982803344727,
-0.32531729340553284,
0.12376686185598373,
-0.2296401560306549,
0.3113429546356201,
-0.006326646078377962,
0.19147957861423492,
0.5811470150947571,
-0.4148479402065277,
0.3872671127319336,
0.4391075670719147,
-0.28955554962158203,
-0.4940142035484314,
1.2170439958572388,
0.23328955471515656,
0.2249017059803009,
0.3177131414413452,
0.19259735941886902,
-0.008122753351926804,
-0.8690592646598816,
-0.4697045683860779,
0.2648332715034485,
-0.5727299451828003,
-0.33369237184524536,
-0.07925490289926529,
-0.361223965883255,
-0.1542109102010727,
-0.03408941999077797,
-0.5548856854438782,
-0.6782838106155396,
-0.5516526103019714,
0.3017294406890869,
0.42711734771728516,
0.42304515838623047,
0.2692486047744751,
0.57326740026474,
-0.5551088452339172,
0.5457417964935303,
0.6480010151863098,
0.257876455783844,
-0.005353019572794437,
-0.7727344036102295,
-0.464958131313324,
0.18606191873550415,
-0.21256619691848755,
-0.543328583240509,
0.531745433807373,
0.6933683156967163,
0.385898232460022,
0.4286799430847168,
0.40439799427986145,
1.086078405380249,
-0.2400783896446228,
0.33256086707115173,
-0.3666626513004303,
-0.9924256801605225,
0.4513189494609833,
-0.4778689444065094,
0.5132355690002441,
0.5444032549858093,
-0.009231703355908394,
-0.3308693766593933,
-0.33028095960617065,
-0.22521470487117767,
-0.5642500519752502,
0.7236736416816711,
-0.030428104102611542,
0.01285643596202135,
0.39024797081947327,
0.7165704965591431,
-0.10052406787872314,
0.13888411223888397,
-0.3227541446685791,
-0.021889377385377884,
-0.20118099451065063,
-0.25027063488960266,
-0.3577915132045746,
-0.3175974190235138,
-0.1789013296365738,
-0.40832605957984924,
0.6272575855255127,
-0.683500349521637,
0.09531232714653015,
-0.3454659879207611,
-0.34602290391921997,
-0.2266853302717209,
0.12321671098470688,
0.8979383111000061,
0.7545357346534729,
-0.557519793510437,
0.32894036173820496,
0.3759883642196655,
-0.3925302028656006,
0.32172372937202454,
-0.09344544261693954,
-0.01645546406507492,
-0.46383848786354065,
0.13717450201511383,
1.0919016599655151,
0.507875919342041,
-0.6040552854537964,
0.2659826874732971,
-0.1449873298406601,
-0.040648203343153,
-0.07058380544185638,
0.5440530180931091,
0.13218830525875092,
0.6812744140625,
0.27152565121650696,
-0.3621063828468323,
-0.28862980008125305,
-0.6935302019119263,
-0.1778419315814972,
0.37765443325042725,
-0.20734497904777527,
-0.43488359451293945,
0.7121922373771667,
-0.0007662207935936749,
-0.2065819948911667,
0.6093037128448486,
-0.2807886600494385,
-0.0447622574865818,
0.5611388683319092,
0.6844428181648254,
0.7679939270019531,
-0.3386680781841278,
0.31147488951683044,
0.18351471424102783,
-0.290554940700531,
0.004947775974869728,
0.3870401382446289,
-0.013604671694338322,
-0.46799108386039734,
-0.20008042454719543,
-0.9374293088912964,
-0.3545118272304535,
-0.10384650528430939,
-0.6948034167289734,
0.13329008221626282,
-0.6607295274734497,
-0.3384937345981598,
-0.07058807462453842,
0.4310173988342285,
-0.33925607800483704,
-0.021846754476428032,
0.1660107523202896,
0.7967954277992249,
-0.5953522324562073,
1.5748164653778076,
0.4052753746509552,
-0.1491294652223587,
-0.47474977374076843,
0.042376693338155746,
-0.31213685870170593,
-0.6823391318321228,
0.7729863524436951,
-0.4273216426372528,
-0.1381876915693283,
0.6519259214401245,
-0.16093645989894867,
-1.1298799514770508,
1.5183324813842773,
0.7834106087684631,
-0.7629150748252869,
-0.13459821045398712,
-0.09714475274085999,
0.7310625314712524,
-0.22798466682434082,
-0.049551695585250854,
0.6144712567329407,
0.523330807685852,
-0.18597659468650818,
-0.8752720952033997,
0.06587514281272888,
0.005614199209958315,
0.37205004692077637,
-0.07711184769868851,
-1.016942024230957,
1.072629451751709,
-0.19326923787593842,
-0.27841854095458984,
0.36225640773773193,
0.6351603269577026,
0.4487578272819519,
0.1517433077096939,
0.5646641254425049,
0.22856375575065613,
0.9710279703140259,
0.048452120274305344,
0.6401069760322571,
-0.5394607186317444,
0.5489732623100281,
0.9303269386291504,
-0.29823827743530273,
1.0472078323364258,
0.40861669182777405,
-0.4247077405452728,
0.5370566248893738,
0.6721334457397461,
0.0762486532330513,
0.6797139644622803,
0.42175447940826416,
-0.17339365184307098,
-0.36083295941352844,
0.10991998761892319,
-0.3460848033428192,
0.6304595470428467,
0.32235845923423767,
0.10494829714298248,
-0.14333517849445343,
0.25887951254844666,
-0.09111826121807098,
-0.18752475082874298,
-0.625236451625824,
0.7689935564994812,
0.10302727669477463,
-0.49287691712379456,
1.4617946147918701,
0.08022823929786682,
0.4315178096294403,
-0.39841753244400024,
0.003075224347412586,
-0.5735095143318176,
0.36689600348472595,
-0.09734740853309631,
-0.16923773288726807,
-0.073789082467556,
-0.30282583832740784,
-0.1401441991329193,
0.05002310499548912,
0.45343175530433655,
-0.5484766960144043,
-0.4661366045475006,
0.09013214707374573,
0.44645777344703674,
-0.057197850197553635,
-0.4190461337566376,
-0.6638195514678955,
0.525299608707428,
-0.3008778989315033,
-0.2704707980155945,
0.9264039397239685,
0.4914938509464264,
-0.40160754323005676,
0.8424510955810547,
0.6487466096878052,
0.38191986083984375,
0.055678755044937134,
0.026493502780795097,
0.9300677180290222,
-0.7565502524375916,
-0.6582231521606445,
-0.4658266007900238,
-0.17820775508880615,
0.31248635053634644,
-0.055651623755693436,
0.5468345284461975,
0.36251217126846313,
0.49455899000167847,
-0.06184352561831474,
0.5193530917167664,
0.4129733145236969,
0.10921219736337662,
-0.9125257730484009,
1.0077098608016968,
-0.7756187915802002,
0.3142786920070648,
-0.008019848726689816,
-1.1708897352218628,
-0.22259695827960968,
0.5695121884346008,
0.008487293496727943,
0.06801995635032654,
0.709229588508606,
0.7222052812576294,
-0.23448888957500458,
-0.2842670679092407,
0.8201097249984741,
0.581479012966156,
0.44565898180007935,
0.8110921382904053,
0.6710221171379089,
-0.49472081661224365,
0.35056599974632263,
-0.10706095397472382,
-0.11743024736642838,
-0.5316981673240662,
-0.938696026802063,
-0.6346717476844788,
-0.3985793888568878,
-0.6183803677558899,
-0.2404162585735321,
0.588762104511261,
0.736388087272644,
0.8715665936470032,
-0.9708109498023987,
-0.1497691571712494,
0.10723671317100525,
0.1570860892534256,
-0.48842400312423706,
-0.2268899530172348,
0.7251965403556824,
-0.36458200216293335,
-1.1311979293823242,
0.6169469356536865,
0.3218196630477905,
0.12676596641540527,
-0.5132797956466675,
-0.28990408778190613,
0.04751109331846237,
0.0029640498105436563,
0.6909675598144531,
0.3882019519805908,
-0.45784345269203186,
-0.3285442590713501,
-0.5834239721298218,
-0.19937759637832642,
0.07420947402715683,
0.7381585836410522,
-0.9300586581230164,
0.22769127786159515,
0.4782315194606781,
0.37493792176246643,
0.6284595131874084,
0.15991990268230438,
0.3031735122203827,
-0.2920687198638916,
0.3481557369232178,
-0.004787474405020475,
0.020908158272504807,
-0.03306467831134796,
-0.14693759381771088,
0.13103650510311127,
0.2836262881755829,
-0.6194851994514465,
-1.0388795137405396,
-0.05978117883205414,
-1.4169635772705078,
-0.47127190232276917,
1.3163679838180542,
-0.23886851966381073,
-0.3290052115917206,
0.00376336183398962,
-0.4054114520549774,
0.22626088559627533,
-0.25630176067352295,
0.9334085583686829,
0.024981381371617317,
0.21611417829990387,
-0.4048006534576416,
-0.6435188055038452,
0.9180731177330017,
0.14917315542697906,
-0.9336848855018616,
0.263567715883255,
0.10174641758203506,
0.31198814511299133,
-0.35305505990982056,
0.4368758797645569,
0.20774944126605988,
0.23813289403915405,
-0.12066778540611267,
-0.2670934796333313,
-0.12494370341300964,
-0.3129763603210449,
-0.603585958480835,
0.43538036942481995,
0.7452636957168579,
-0.0605589784681797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10987v2 | WilKE: Wise-Layer Knowledge Editor for Lifelong Knowledge Editing | 2024-02-16T05:29:59 | 2024-06-05T07:44:30 | Chenhui Hu, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge editing aims to rectify inaccuracies in large language models
(LLMs) without costly retraining for outdated or erroneous knowledge. However,
current knowledge editing methods primarily focus on single editing, failing to
meet the requirements for lifelong editing. This study reveals a performance
degradation encountered by knowledge editing in lifelong editing, characterized
by toxicity buildup and toxicity flash, with the primary cause identified as
pattern unmatch. We introduce a knowledge editing approach named Wise-Layer
Knowledge Editor (WilKE), which selects editing layer based on the pattern
matching degree of editing knowledge across different layers in language
models. Experimental results demonstrate that, in lifelong editing, WilKE
exhibits an average improvement of 46.2% and 67.8% on editing GPT2-XL and GPT-J
relative to state-of-the-art knowledge editing methods. | [
0.21930426359176636,
-0.7571354508399963,
0.7583862543106079,
0.1675174981355667,
0.004198775161057711,
0.22463871538639069,
-0.11109007149934769,
-0.5343841314315796,
0.014952530153095722,
0.8023093342781067,
-0.3219567537307739,
-0.6987817883491516,
-0.38526806235313416,
-0.2138124406337738,
-0.28602948784828186,
0.7858206033706665,
-0.016101740300655365,
0.1218644380569458,
-0.449253112077713,
-0.3491455316543579,
-0.9538214802742004,
-0.09027247875928879,
-1.1299110651016235,
-0.38373199105262756,
0.49539846181869507,
0.6551799774169922,
1.043784499168396,
0.5517676472663879,
0.18381215631961823,
0.3762424886226654,
-0.3371204733848572,
0.3002007007598877,
-0.3198331594467163,
0.3996250331401825,
-0.3782574534416199,
-0.35003548860549927,
-0.8826879262924194,
-0.021190691739320755,
0.5639007091522217,
0.5247223973274231,
0.02679259143769741,
0.010553157888352871,
0.1393798589706421,
1.0395857095718384,
-0.68558269739151,
-0.22409650683403015,
-0.5639826059341431,
0.08844246715307236,
-0.36807405948638916,
-0.19628390669822693,
-0.31833773851394653,
-0.3918777108192444,
-0.0035207963082939386,
-0.8399474024772644,
-0.2188396006822586,
-0.05033254250884056,
0.13058704137802124,
0.2305767834186554,
-0.3122331500053406,
0.1454220861196518,
-0.7126083970069885,
0.593392014503479,
-1.2195887565612793,
0.3975673317909241,
0.39551591873168945,
0.021862799301743507,
-0.41939300298690796,
-0.7443019151687622,
-0.6265267133712769,
-0.07803461700677872,
0.09403237700462341,
0.18095093965530396,
0.19565115869045258,
0.2941533923149109,
0.2913138270378113,
0.07083244621753693,
-0.4223003089427948,
0.019143197685480118,
-0.05363184213638306,
-0.39317816495895386,
0.7535790205001831,
0.1832822859287262,
0.5818421244621277,
-0.23253761231899261,
-0.16030067205429077,
0.2509838342666626,
-0.6928850412368774,
-0.21590860188007355,
0.5062779784202576,
-0.276630163192749,
0.45268428325653076,
0.5023165941238403,
-0.21063882112503052,
0.9117556810379028,
-0.17931735515594482,
-0.5436768531799316,
0.04736001789569855,
0.014024421572685242,
-0.3874921500682831,
0.07743553072214127,
0.7892581224441528,
0.6968157291412354,
0.2717982828617096,
-0.4158167839050293,
-0.2579911947250366,
-0.4122353792190552,
0.13904647529125214,
-0.4348640739917755,
-0.35854339599609375,
0.3397965133190155,
-0.22850900888442993,
-0.6687914133071899,
-0.08757888525724411,
-0.7759671211242676,
-0.651085615158081,
-0.11442027986049652,
0.7776017785072327,
-0.6119274497032166,
-0.08742815256118774,
0.34011250734329224,
-0.3369450271129608,
-0.3254663050174713,
0.49103060364723206,
-0.32942521572113037,
-0.1766970455646515,
0.43969982862472534,
0.8610904216766357,
-0.1348767727613449,
-0.6133741736412048,
-0.4728183448314667,
0.4593113362789154,
-0.4725828468799591,
0.9353687167167664,
-0.6854708194732666,
-0.38632944226264954,
-0.24189476668834686,
-0.2478044629096985,
0.01778050698339939,
-0.5357794761657715,
0.5081702470779419,
-0.9223164319992065,
0.3928837776184082,
-0.42828455567359924,
-0.852495551109314,
-0.13091795146465302,
0.047692589461803436,
-0.7251843214035034,
1.230912208557129,
0.2431402951478958,
-1.0392078161239624,
0.44521161913871765,
-0.8819526433944702,
-0.42527836561203003,
0.1545342206954956,
0.4475206136703491,
-0.41068607568740845,
-0.07996083796024323,
0.06744639575481415,
0.26865437626838684,
0.19288888573646545,
0.35023051500320435,
-0.36215341091156006,
-0.29737359285354614,
0.11186091601848602,
-0.20470954477787018,
0.8214537501335144,
0.034060463309288025,
-0.2683146595954895,
0.3705814480781555,
-0.989935040473938,
0.15751118957996368,
0.022256381809711456,
-0.4275563359260559,
-0.7609773278236389,
0.18532000482082367,
-0.06560390442609787,
0.4645012319087982,
0.2371547371149063,
-0.6267027258872986,
0.5074636340141296,
-0.11861393600702286,
0.40470707416534424,
1.1272149085998535,
0.40405914187431335,
0.3582425117492676,
-0.6458255052566528,
0.5200508236885071,
0.15887528657913208,
0.4034397006034851,
0.5560789108276367,
-0.7580225467681885,
-0.7225970029830933,
0.20533685386180878,
0.34178677201271057,
0.8567193746566772,
-0.8748728036880493,
0.18584689497947693,
-0.18130339682102203,
-0.39223068952560425,
-0.21955791115760803,
0.7266650795936584,
0.3080841898918152,
0.7961881756782532,
0.5116918683052063,
-0.3178420066833496,
-0.3396085202693939,
-0.7170887589454651,
-0.7706432938575745,
-0.02715115435421467,
0.14306935667991638,
-0.0512479729950428,
0.20927581191062927,
-0.5145370960235596,
1.0587908029556274,
-0.3290110230445862,
-0.3641454875469208,
-0.21200981736183167,
-0.005044084973633289,
-0.27081024646759033,
0.34230098128318787,
0.4025598466396332,
-0.34505340456962585,
-0.7600659132003784,
0.0068003954365849495,
-0.6164841055870056,
-0.32765963673591614,
-0.15528425574302673,
-0.47615328431129456,
0.2981155812740326,
0.7447599172592163,
-0.28006723523139954,
0.24046091735363007,
0.6773305535316467,
-0.43367165327072144,
0.6841413378715515,
-0.3309497535228729,
0.41352003812789917,
-1.1028372049331665,
-0.030593249946832657,
-0.24306701123714447,
-0.34654828906059265,
-0.7876297831535339,
-0.13299784064292908,
0.35589417815208435,
0.17780406773090363,
-0.536018967628479,
0.5230987071990967,
-0.386995404958725,
0.1959409862756729,
-0.13848693668842316,
0.16590744256973267,
0.06447522342205048,
0.3287394642829895,
-0.28963613510131836,
0.8882692456245422,
0.3861199617385864,
-0.4410754144191742,
0.37148091197013855,
0.136148601770401,
-0.5250858664512634,
0.5523319840431213,
-0.42173025012016296,
0.5489999651908875,
-0.01818234845995903,
-0.043735191226005554,
-0.6141272783279419,
-0.22075298428535461,
0.09261845797300339,
0.06468113511800766,
0.31170690059661865,
-0.06115845590829849,
-0.660078227519989,
-0.16497868299484253,
-0.5908063650131226,
0.37386611104011536,
0.2536492943763733,
-0.3682941198348999,
0.6354917287826538,
0.20040568709373474,
-0.06439847499132156,
-0.7616637349128723,
-0.7718477249145508,
0.32104042172431946,
-0.22727830708026886,
-0.9307568073272705,
0.38651132583618164,
-0.41956913471221924,
-0.3198496699333191,
0.15149849653244019,
-0.2200080007314682,
0.00894438847899437,
0.027399200946092606,
-0.041787706315517426,
0.10942515730857849,
-0.04578976333141327,
0.08534248173236847,
0.3158982992172241,
-0.13069210946559906,
-0.07409236580133438,
-0.3682648539543152,
0.04282720014452934,
0.27607181668281555,
-0.21005567908287048,
-0.24399864673614502,
0.4086233973503113,
0.9115541577339172,
-0.39818885922431946,
0.8412929177284241,
0.28287336230278015,
-0.2081250548362732,
-0.3459436893463135,
-0.9807189106941223,
0.3831119239330292,
-0.536817193031311,
0.46379154920578003,
-0.1882016658782959,
-0.8341587781906128,
0.7821881771087646,
-0.1390560269355774,
0.18474075198173523,
0.6466079354286194,
0.034040190279483795,
-0.2501380443572998,
0.7989127039909363,
0.6166557669639587,
-0.3393629789352417,
0.4728313088417053,
0.10704370588064194,
0.012233931571245193,
-1.0228331089019775,
-0.11569236218929291,
-0.048331644386053085,
-0.43698614835739136,
-0.22919178009033203,
-0.1766119748353958,
0.5734468102455139,
0.44321325421333313,
-0.2987561821937561,
0.20634223520755768,
-0.43636658787727356,
0.9766466617584229,
0.3629322946071625,
0.39447087049484253,
0.8047099709510803,
-0.3061397969722748,
-0.19432762265205383,
0.035032715648412704,
-0.7507879137992859,
-0.3646753132343292,
1.2229164838790894,
0.09237689524888992,
0.6621813774108887,
0.4300455152988434,
0.5923112630844116,
0.40033605694770813,
0.30876410007476807,
-0.3382796347141266,
0.6982877254486084,
-0.1350531280040741,
-0.5242052674293518,
-0.4371034801006317,
-0.35686826705932617,
-0.37011632323265076,
-0.12107621133327484,
-0.12888865172863007,
-0.5761170387268066,
0.019230134785175323,
0.4681392014026642,
-0.22966524958610535,
0.8932474255561829,
-0.8168837428092957,
1.0596532821655273,
-0.29695019125938416,
-0.4576953053474426,
-0.24684326350688934,
-0.6001635789871216,
0.4405306279659271,
-0.32614532113075256,
0.4321911036968231,
0.31681928038597107,
-0.04610076919198036,
0.9594270586967468,
-0.44947296380996704,
0.4574114680290222,
-0.3518522083759308,
-0.26916414499282837,
0.14344309270381927,
0.5803587436676025,
0.7982908487319946,
0.24112044274806976,
-0.22920677065849304,
0.11536136269569397,
-0.0002802077797241509,
-0.14079123735427856,
-0.6671911478042603,
0.7329400777816772,
-0.6726497411727905,
-0.5914435386657715,
-0.21189609169960022,
-0.7898009419441223,
-0.6159119009971619,
0.38308393955230713,
0.3622264862060547,
0.353606253862381,
0.0008922989945858717,
-0.17735078930854797,
0.8021193742752075,
-0.4964843988418579,
0.23148313164710999,
0.45933982729911804,
-0.31585797667503357,
-0.2428988665342331,
0.8588303327560425,
0.28774183988571167,
0.7218700051307678,
0.18264813721179962,
0.43933382630348206,
0.1079036295413971,
-0.6523633003234863,
-0.29834863543510437,
-0.022672226652503014,
-1.041874885559082,
-0.32274529337882996,
-0.7789580225944519,
-0.2997341454029083,
-0.3859030604362488,
-0.26149505376815796,
-0.3502940237522125,
-0.3875611424446106,
-0.0684606060385704,
0.18555614352226257,
0.6676139831542969,
1.1326638460159302,
-0.3181557357311249,
0.0529242567718029,
-0.6601685285568237,
0.382561594247818,
0.6462666988372803,
0.7809903621673584,
-0.10665425658226013,
-0.6516085863113403,
-0.25072479248046875,
-0.041240956634283066,
-0.29740992188453674,
-1.2954593896865845,
0.08907292783260345,
0.3798103332519531,
0.49095970392227173,
0.022282050922513008,
-0.23269608616828918,
0.852509617805481,
-0.4171715974807739,
0.6290929317474365,
-0.22137202322483063,
-1.1252785921096802,
0.7022934556007385,
-0.3865485191345215,
0.5262420177459717,
0.6751068830490112,
0.04226608946919441,
-1.074527382850647,
-0.7948470711708069,
-0.5006352066993713,
-0.7078129649162292,
0.5604988932609558,
-0.24366216361522675,
-0.12503086030483246,
0.17265912890434265,
0.5221792459487915,
0.0022152261808514595,
-0.04084113985300064,
-0.5780839920043945,
-0.26763275265693665,
-0.2915422022342682,
0.032976776361465454,
0.16681768000125885,
-0.5851773619651794,
0.08827181905508041,
-0.5712223052978516,
1.0985161066055298,
0.037785619497299194,
0.0966770276427269,
0.183878555893898,
-0.48984295129776,
-0.5782824754714966,
0.6227957606315613,
0.6804498434066772,
0.8332297205924988,
-0.30792731046676636,
-0.028935661539435387,
0.5374924540519714,
-0.5954992175102234,
-0.04787860065698624,
-0.3445456027984619,
-0.2790192663669586,
-0.2850569784641266,
0.5627972483634949,
0.41198402643203735,
0.4212511479854584,
-0.3970039486885071,
0.3750379979610443,
0.1688322275876999,
-0.31224918365478516,
-0.017179859802126884,
0.40835249423980713,
0.3897603154182434,
0.145233616232872,
0.07134735584259033,
0.5725844502449036,
0.0529320128262043,
-0.34773823618888855,
0.11469391733407974,
0.38974300026893616,
0.03006714954972267,
0.25249046087265015,
0.7646687030792236,
0.030488271266222,
-0.21846646070480347,
0.6865622401237488,
-0.2757599949836731,
-0.6215531229972839,
0.26987001299858093,
0.30740487575531006,
0.9012873768806458,
-0.24740661680698395,
0.15338200330734253,
0.33647462725639343,
0.26097041368484497,
-0.19080547988414764,
0.034115828573703766,
0.2796497344970703,
-0.8338785171508789,
-0.7561545968055725,
-0.43394842743873596,
-0.3884178400039673,
0.43790513277053833,
-0.47237229347229004,
0.07019472867250443,
-0.4703647792339325,
-0.012153944000601768,
-0.18749269843101501,
-0.12915915250778198,
-0.5240491628646851,
0.006490712519735098,
-0.33577919006347656,
0.9283740520477295,
-0.6804159879684448,
1.120829463005066,
0.7377660870552063,
-0.18403801321983337,
-0.9067478775978088,
0.1081601083278656,
0.24851931631565094,
-0.5857649445533752,
0.40104565024375916,
-0.22659508883953094,
-0.09967432916164398,
0.3161098062992096,
-0.4521176218986511,
-0.6962863206863403,
1.2542848587036133,
0.4398108124732971,
-0.7418996691703796,
-0.03743169084191322,
0.09104443341493607,
0.4026049077510834,
0.261738657951355,
0.06514539569616318,
0.6857529282569885,
0.6850412487983704,
-0.23129227757453918,
-0.8704954385757446,
-0.048198699951171875,
-0.18942297995090485,
0.16080839931964874,
0.14604920148849487,
-0.5867879986763,
0.519439697265625,
-0.24485021829605103,
-0.1485675722360611,
-0.0066787791438400745,
0.4079708456993103,
-0.22106999158859253,
-0.1144217699766159,
0.6095042824745178,
0.8631448745727539,
0.6125369071960449,
0.21300198137760162,
0.6336742043495178,
-0.43129393458366394,
0.3415919244289398,
1.009398102760315,
-0.07458604872226715,
0.5818712115287781,
0.19339773058891296,
-0.08492892235517502,
0.8830849528312683,
0.3521868884563446,
0.23287339508533478,
0.4454458951950073,
-0.23730526864528656,
-0.46981364488601685,
-0.3452579379081726,
0.4602036476135254,
-0.2966775894165039,
0.0812436193227768,
-0.010175449773669243,
-0.03334940969944,
-0.0872175544500351,
0.13427609205245972,
0.23941583931446075,
-0.03302757441997528,
-0.3264356851577759,
0.8295606970787048,
-0.16161268949508667,
-0.5800667405128479,
0.0478997677564621,
0.27610722184181213,
0.8389365673065186,
-0.6521180272102356,
-0.0038275064434856176,
-0.4084652066230774,
0.04027993232011795,
-0.4747284948825836,
-1.1516506671905518,
0.4189690947532654,
-0.09379322826862335,
-0.14673151075839996,
-0.22018858790397644,
1.043312430381775,
-0.550621747970581,
-0.4275846779346466,
0.48092424869537354,
0.4235532283782959,
-0.35808104276657104,
-0.2850697636604309,
-0.9762133955955505,
-0.033705875277519226,
-0.0020828507840633392,
-0.5202412009239197,
0.309611052274704,
0.4742913842201233,
-0.12489428371191025,
0.6961936950683594,
0.6626253128051758,
0.30822765827178955,
0.0605548657476902,
0.23041589558124542,
0.6924036741256714,
-0.698329746723175,
-0.36341768503189087,
-0.791292130947113,
0.8078982830047607,
-0.07023432105779648,
-0.31580591201782227,
0.6547003984451294,
0.39837217330932617,
0.8787497878074646,
-0.009071136824786663,
0.8464096784591675,
-0.13488838076591492,
0.2914273142814636,
-0.7421185970306396,
1.0943256616592407,
-0.6866809129714966,
0.3185725808143616,
-0.6844789385795593,
-1.0856469869613647,
-0.5332586765289307,
0.44674035906791687,
-0.2655496299266815,
0.2363079935312271,
0.93095862865448,
0.9890515208244324,
-0.05682388320565224,
0.028446227312088013,
0.49386829137802124,
0.5775147676467896,
0.240524023771286,
0.6491582989692688,
0.5479855537414551,
-0.34138771891593933,
0.15022413432598114,
-0.712815523147583,
-0.1703987717628479,
0.2065049260854721,
-1.0254497528076172,
-0.9485089778900146,
-0.44323936104774475,
-0.37222692370414734,
-0.39991244673728943,
0.2833932936191559,
0.5923775434494019,
0.33979398012161255,
-0.6135374307632446,
0.18887966871261597,
-0.22708040475845337,
0.14090485870838165,
-0.4183940887451172,
-0.2681770622730255,
0.3966442346572876,
-0.2929654121398926,
-0.18426665663719177,
0.5890328288078308,
0.4881604015827179,
-0.28788208961486816,
-0.29154375195503235,
-0.1619434356689453,
-0.21415872871875763,
-0.045094676315784454,
0.6834721565246582,
0.19478175044059753,
-0.40751612186431885,
-0.5996254682540894,
-0.14576709270477295,
-0.15671001374721527,
0.0389813669025898,
0.7870882153511047,
-0.5751704573631287,
0.7797750234603882,
0.4762016832828522,
0.590987503528595,
0.11516891419887543,
-0.323110967874527,
0.30628475546836853,
-0.6384040713310242,
-0.16145354509353638,
0.07566335052251816,
0.2547077238559723,
0.3595993220806122,
-0.6296733021736145,
0.2550821006298065,
0.437900185585022,
-0.8647034168243408,
-0.3915860652923584,
0.004157193936407566,
-1.1176762580871582,
-0.2883349061012268,
1.375733733177185,
0.1913628727197647,
-0.0413053035736084,
-0.3039917051792145,
-0.30276840925216675,
0.24324333667755127,
-0.01755126193165779,
0.6840149164199829,
0.8571214079856873,
-0.0971207544207573,
-0.14082284271717072,
-0.9748245477676392,
0.6514699459075928,
0.5967424511909485,
-0.9101899862289429,
0.16681012511253357,
0.6101208925247192,
0.8198102712631226,
-0.3228698968887329,
0.6650323867797852,
-0.2858327031135559,
0.4459843635559082,
-0.321747750043869,
-0.005514472723007202,
-0.4377226233482361,
-0.3414454758167267,
-0.0685667023062706,
-0.08059973269701004,
0.3488859534263611,
0.40499913692474365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10986v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10986v3 | FinTral: A Family of GPT-4 Level Multimodal Financial Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T05:05:12 | 2024-06-14T13:26:47 | Gagan Bhatia, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Hasan Cavusoglu, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce FinTral, a suite of state-of-the-art multimodal large language
models (LLMs) built upon the Mistral-7b model and tailored for financial
analysis. FinTral integrates textual, numerical, tabular, and image data. We
enhance FinTral with domain-specific pretraining, instruction fine-tuning, and
RLAIF training by exploiting a large collection of textual and visual datasets
we curate for this work. We also introduce an extensive benchmark featuring
nine tasks and 25 datasets for evaluation, including hallucinations in the
financial domain. Our FinTral model trained with direct preference optimization
employing advanced Tools and Retrieval methods, dubbed FinTral-DPO-T&R,
demonstrates an exceptional zero-shot performance. It outperforms ChatGPT-3.5
in all tasks and surpasses GPT-4 in five out of nine tasks, marking a
significant advancement in AI-driven financial technology. We also demonstrate
that FinTral has the potential to excel in real-time analysis and
decision-making in diverse financial contexts. The GitHub repository for
FinTral is available at \url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/fintral}. | [
-0.20002737641334534,
-0.8379854559898376,
0.23464274406433105,
0.37231406569480896,
-0.2014136016368866,
0.25003179907798767,
-0.41072702407836914,
-0.7195988893508911,
-0.057868607342243195,
0.83940589427948,
-0.43629980087280273,
-0.7187104821205139,
-0.5168750882148743,
-0.07146860659122467,
-0.3698185682296753,
1.0542904138565063,
0.17744700610637665,
0.07772311568260193,
0.2955945134162903,
0.022303806617856026,
-0.23526345193386078,
-0.8282736539840698,
-1.0442512035369873,
-0.34713855385780334,
0.4864695966243744,
0.17001259326934814,
0.5938603281974792,
0.31970828771591187,
0.7664925456047058,
0.2767496407032013,
0.2727878987789154,
-0.02454930730164051,
-0.5130473971366882,
0.14448809623718262,
-0.01712845452129841,
-0.14301104843616486,
-0.7283609509468079,
-0.09166514128446579,
0.47117137908935547,
0.5486737489700317,
-0.49221375584602356,
0.2961041331291199,
-0.25099989771842957,
0.6347096562385559,
-0.42530983686447144,
0.8814759850502014,
-0.3723032474517822,
-0.014441512525081635,
-0.3419128656387329,
-0.07563173025846481,
-0.42661812901496887,
-0.035174544900655746,
0.3448542356491089,
-0.6052141189575195,
0.14363135397434235,
0.268582820892334,
0.4911344647407532,
0.3016139268875122,
-0.6464477777481079,
-0.28174442052841187,
-0.7478116154670715,
0.4448559880256653,
-0.6078061461448669,
0.9414092302322388,
0.2278618961572647,
0.4299878478050232,
-0.03839550539851189,
-1.1767200231552124,
-0.3551104664802551,
-0.36842474341392517,
0.13026830554008484,
0.14728698134422302,
-0.37887826561927795,
0.5278852581977844,
0.03927520290017128,
0.3186548054218292,
-0.5314510464668274,
-0.1400468498468399,
-0.6501163840293884,
-0.3197922706604004,
0.5343194603919983,
0.17240747809410095,
0.018455836921930313,
0.027204351499676704,
-0.5565037131309509,
-0.4469436705112457,
-0.4705038368701935,
-0.008227525278925896,
0.4432029724121094,
0.6685726642608643,
-0.19686099886894226,
0.3598836362361908,
-0.08175966888666153,
0.9362550973892212,
0.1067274957895279,
-0.601049542427063,
0.19242049753665924,
-0.3945404589176178,
-0.37468844652175903,
0.3473294973373413,
0.7206830382347107,
0.211346834897995,
0.1099998727440834,
0.016249526292085648,
-0.5196948051452637,
-0.1754816770553589,
0.1630946397781372,
-0.5270595550537109,
-0.4768613278865814,
0.21048413217067719,
-0.374673992395401,
-0.29974108934402466,
-0.16017457842826843,
-0.823708176612854,
-0.30422160029411316,
-0.3769451379776001,
0.4803176820278168,
-0.3668593466281891,
-0.31958869099617004,
0.7011637687683105,
-0.19994254410266876,
0.16579778492450714,
0.16419991850852966,
-1.2558003664016724,
0.6481621861457825,
0.8781183362007141,
0.6518604159355164,
0.2387140989303589,
-0.2832302451133728,
-0.6011462807655334,
0.19836489856243134,
-0.4041667580604553,
0.9472088813781738,
-0.5753495097160339,
-0.21022309362888336,
-0.06474520266056061,
-0.3588277995586395,
-0.3164388835430145,
-0.30503231287002563,
0.34003889560699463,
-0.5628771185874939,
0.19617941975593567,
-0.10102084279060364,
-0.27415937185287476,
-0.516170859336853,
0.1479436606168747,
-0.8860920667648315,
0.895621657371521,
0.4080047905445099,
-0.7995470762252808,
0.5359379053115845,
-0.9351611733436584,
-0.18813326954841614,
0.18827396631240845,
-0.21541757881641388,
-0.22472955286502838,
-0.23806019127368927,
0.13776101171970367,
0.4726466238498688,
-0.5857972502708435,
0.41232502460479736,
-0.4572676122188568,
-0.19766439497470856,
0.1530977189540863,
-0.6610748767852783,
0.2695988416671753,
0.1418895125389099,
-0.5412018299102783,
0.41563132405281067,
-0.7107518911361694,
-0.3218803405761719,
-0.006094418000429869,
0.04648716002702713,
-0.3469591438770294,
-0.4068632423877716,
0.5743211507797241,
0.24613091349601746,
0.382269024848938,
-0.3118702173233032,
0.18304665386676788,
-0.2897034287452698,
0.6438179016113281,
0.9251672029495239,
-0.10357680171728134,
0.1785566359758377,
-0.23592354357242584,
0.5795470476150513,
-0.2674409747123718,
0.6058869361877441,
0.08833913505077362,
-0.1910252422094345,
-0.39979085326194763,
-0.661828339099884,
0.2831076383590698,
0.35756003856658936,
-0.5754708647727966,
-0.16221660375595093,
-0.2251415252685547,
-0.5068238377571106,
-0.17399820685386658,
0.21285417675971985,
0.17017042636871338,
0.30629369616508484,
0.07865127176046371,
-0.15336176753044128,
-0.273061066865921,
-1.1563433408737183,
0.09138791263103485,
-0.43102747201919556,
0.44916319847106934,
0.23679132759571075,
0.21409837901592255,
-0.2205413430929184,
0.6490625143051147,
-0.5223166346549988,
-0.32831647992134094,
-0.61026531457901,
0.14470332860946655,
0.40122273564338684,
0.060606714338064194,
0.8894609212875366,
-1.0837305784225464,
-0.1687719225883484,
0.1960369348526001,
-0.5494166612625122,
0.01985004171729088,
-0.383094847202301,
-0.09248096495866776,
0.05193309858441353,
0.4950524866580963,
-0.562443196773529,
0.03231785446405411,
0.6483795642852783,
-0.7427152395248413,
0.6346938610076904,
-0.3225370943546295,
0.04795237258076668,
-0.8745754361152649,
0.24827605485916138,
0.11039135605096817,
-0.24900686740875244,
-0.6659136414527893,
-0.002430528635159135,
0.0435643196105957,
-0.056165147572755814,
-0.1775379180908203,
0.8918792605400085,
-0.22040361166000366,
-0.44940975308418274,
-0.06268706917762756,
0.1864110827445984,
-0.015013621188700199,
0.6026150584220886,
-0.08875381946563721,
0.8031498789787292,
0.5108233690261841,
-0.3030133843421936,
0.8163687586784363,
0.255877286195755,
-0.29841136932373047,
0.3019140362739563,
-0.5084565877914429,
-0.2842762768268585,
0.022813305258750916,
0.28969407081604004,
-0.9378540515899658,
-0.37663957476615906,
0.5664952993392944,
0.046231985092163086,
0.35042330622673035,
0.05986317619681358,
-0.3993102014064789,
-0.360422819852829,
-0.11292875558137894,
0.538870632648468,
0.00043708790326491,
-0.49717625975608826,
0.8947069048881531,
0.1470174342393875,
-0.7171616554260254,
-0.9743459820747375,
-0.2725328505039215,
0.36465132236480713,
-0.3525269627571106,
-0.480000376701355,
0.20491698384284973,
0.04320186376571655,
-0.5371569395065308,
-0.058676935732364655,
-0.1640206128358841,
0.06408703327178955,
0.10055183619260788,
0.276547372341156,
0.7582401633262634,
-0.32588449120521545,
0.27885574102401733,
-0.1906432956457138,
-0.3194689154624939,
-0.0956479087471962,
-0.7232275009155273,
0.7248492240905762,
-0.4942798614501953,
-0.2850167453289032,
-0.30113834142684937,
-0.12272278964519501,
0.7666131854057312,
-0.43345242738723755,
0.5388996005058289,
0.6775913834571838,
-0.18417207896709442,
-0.05431807413697243,
-0.7713683247566223,
0.13131804764270782,
-0.5093165636062622,
0.33713066577911377,
-0.369132399559021,
-1.1344066858291626,
0.5803657174110413,
0.1360219120979309,
0.2690386474132538,
0.5602747201919556,
0.6217740774154663,
0.4513656795024872,
0.4095526337623596,
1.0994397401809692,
-0.14143149554729462,
0.7124363780021667,
-0.2022365778684616,
0.3194695711135864,
-0.23091614246368408,
-0.28440606594085693,
-0.18134886026382446,
0.0018757637590169907,
-0.24306949973106384,
-0.2120988965034485,
0.35698437690734863,
0.030434919521212578,
-0.5455325841903687,
0.17707191407680511,
-0.1460457146167755,
0.19855746626853943,
0.3588762581348419,
-0.20485366880893707,
0.36683225631713867,
-0.001308352337218821,
-0.2536662518978119,
0.3392954170703888,
-0.7489215135574341,
-0.31044885516166687,
1.3612430095672607,
0.5363516807556152,
0.9224815368652344,
-0.06651628017425537,
0.436779648065567,
0.6143990755081177,
0.5130152702331543,
-0.644672691822052,
0.18667174875736237,
-0.27225741744041443,
-0.6817931532859802,
-0.398295134305954,
-0.5915380716323853,
-0.5122886300086975,
0.2680460810661316,
-0.2762821614742279,
-0.5007101893424988,
0.19499115645885468,
-0.058072447776794434,
-0.9867820739746094,
0.4244709014892578,
-0.5246452689170837,
1.0798312425613403,
-0.6361173391342163,
-0.2323545515537262,
-0.17387184500694275,
-0.29774534702301025,
0.6679710745811462,
-0.5373969674110413,
0.4526163935661316,
-0.053943317383527756,
-0.026416612789034843,
0.6366868019104004,
-0.09988607466220856,
0.9010030627250671,
-0.04917043074965477,
-0.5742168426513672,
0.09491098672151566,
-0.11272156983613968,
0.13389098644256592,
0.20326490700244904,
-0.058967508375644684,
0.25478607416152954,
0.2237103432416916,
-0.36111965775489807,
-0.5949366688728333,
0.5874829888343811,
-0.6683086156845093,
-0.39979180693626404,
-0.40210285782814026,
-0.5164980888366699,
-0.15197104215621948,
0.23592357337474823,
-0.20627160370349884,
0.9124706387519836,
-0.22964833676815033,
0.07098443061113358,
0.2681754231452942,
-0.21666225790977478,
0.33090940117836,
0.18772880733013153,
-0.5734131932258606,
-0.8847275376319885,
0.8320806622505188,
-0.2056594043970108,
0.2847624719142914,
0.34489011764526367,
-0.047388654202222824,
-0.7223373651504517,
-0.39169156551361084,
-0.42679882049560547,
0.44859856367111206,
-0.8193961381912231,
-0.1724376380443573,
-0.6013239622116089,
-0.16124911606311798,
-0.5754516124725342,
-0.1190437525510788,
-0.4973783791065216,
-0.4300728142261505,
0.2297936975955963,
-0.4398280382156372,
0.5742488503456116,
1.0476391315460205,
-0.4165424108505249,
0.40955761075019836,
-0.8272725939750671,
0.34988272190093994,
0.39992383122444153,
0.6175954937934875,
0.06957674026489258,
-0.11609110981225967,
-0.2731485664844513,
-0.14709611237049103,
0.17642952501773834,
-0.25632426142692566,
0.4698551893234253,
0.16211232542991638,
0.5589824914932251,
0.769088089466095,
-0.09214245527982712,
0.6393151879310608,
-0.06526951491832733,
0.5902095437049866,
0.37503910064697266,
-0.7302879691123962,
-0.06319493055343628,
-0.5699743628501892,
-0.15219740569591522,
0.44875550270080566,
0.023187749087810516,
-0.9094311594963074,
-0.26386407017707825,
-0.5371807217597961,
-0.9303698539733887,
0.549859881401062,
0.052235305309295654,
-0.06661170721054077,
0.11616574972867966,
0.6450933218002319,
0.4796379506587982,
0.5029262900352478,
-0.7287166714668274,
-0.1245657429099083,
-0.48291322588920593,
-0.3402336537837982,
-0.43585675954818726,
-0.28777632117271423,
-0.11115165054798126,
0.08003108203411102,
0.49095892906188965,
-0.2584550678730011,
0.0771343931555748,
0.10376487672328949,
0.20068663358688354,
-0.012812251225113869,
0.03064829669892788,
0.7056508660316467,
0.8578209280967712,
-0.4040139615535736,
0.069167859852314,
-0.09372255951166153,
-0.7029879689216614,
0.021191272884607315,
0.4353203773498535,
0.35897311568260193,
-0.12005218863487244,
0.6524710059165955,
0.8898977041244507,
0.7309961318969727,
-0.9104823470115662,
0.434025377035141,
-0.4104476869106293,
-0.4862059950828552,
-0.7018219828605652,
0.0018168961396440864,
-0.11628144979476929,
0.8429179787635803,
0.61897212266922,
0.04757180064916611,
0.09233901649713516,
-0.5006894469261169,
0.361465185880661,
0.23711851239204407,
-0.44259852170944214,
-0.28986114263534546,
0.863106369972229,
0.1166066825389862,
0.286448210477829,
0.6540634632110596,
0.1795540750026703,
-0.5455318689346313,
0.34623613953590393,
0.42308616638183594,
0.9223805665969849,
0.07267414778470993,
0.5026347041130066,
0.05009999871253967,
0.2661620080471039,
-0.4639231860637665,
0.2876092791557312,
-0.14489802718162537,
-0.6976829171180725,
-0.4495655298233032,
-0.9442340135574341,
-0.44693616032600403,
0.11414831876754761,
-0.5892326235771179,
0.10854627192020416,
-0.7682415843009949,
-0.47396406531333923,
0.15494002401828766,
-0.038110893219709396,
-0.6109759211540222,
0.020834721624851227,
0.4694631099700928,
0.9495744705200195,
-0.5580626726150513,
0.5316078066825867,
0.4414769113063812,
-0.397365003824234,
-0.5046414732933044,
-0.24127741158008575,
-0.010506042279303074,
-0.670053243637085,
0.8688395619392395,
-0.07629746198654175,
-0.30178186297416687,
0.14359374344348907,
-0.4539462625980377,
-0.872241199016571,
1.1949058771133423,
0.4874786138534546,
-0.5807173252105713,
-0.3545663356781006,
0.15730059146881104,
0.3447522819042206,
-0.4301844835281372,
0.06420361995697021,
0.5811634063720703,
0.7268745303153992,
0.13918720185756683,
-1.0436129570007324,
-0.40062159299850464,
-0.2261693924665451,
-0.3164219856262207,
0.4161103367805481,
-0.9071611762046814,
1.0077552795410156,
-0.09143500030040741,
-0.07698486745357513,
-0.20762939751148224,
0.4987967312335968,
0.24653953313827515,
0.30874842405319214,
0.6145591139793396,
0.34587255120277405,
0.7774713039398193,
-0.08311060070991516,
1.1259758472442627,
-0.7012617588043213,
0.3548260033130646,
0.844631016254425,
-0.3914644122123718,
0.7793179154396057,
0.12360049784183502,
0.06327672302722931,
0.32251808047294617,
0.8705902099609375,
-0.050222378224134445,
0.3993352949619293,
-0.07256302982568741,
-0.43385595083236694,
-0.658177375793457,
0.09137319773435593,
-0.22687186300754547,
0.6806311011314392,
0.42915549874305725,
-0.0069672418758273125,
-0.24963980913162231,
0.18378819525241852,
-0.2516222298145294,
-0.22895903885364532,
-0.3756186068058014,
0.5784976482391357,
0.37906306982040405,
-0.09309239685535431,
0.3678858280181885,
0.13829529285430908,
0.6808086633682251,
-0.985177218914032,
0.04138398543000221,
-0.2484985738992691,
0.3550262749195099,
0.13994058966636658,
-0.38769301772117615,
-0.0857541561126709,
-0.13686370849609375,
0.18561473488807678,
-0.34931236505508423,
0.7697374224662781,
-0.3258669674396515,
-0.6757745742797852,
0.665000319480896,
0.5538672208786011,
-0.09395281225442886,
-0.0744304433465004,
-0.6613680124282837,
-0.12420409917831421,
-0.053642552345991135,
-0.26335805654525757,
0.09708742052316666,
0.5297813415527344,
-0.15490569174289703,
1.0297335386276245,
0.9921261072158813,
0.02396228350698948,
-0.19565008580684662,
0.23677021265029907,
0.8495720028877258,
-1.0368839502334595,
-0.5446687936782837,
-0.7760974764823914,
-0.06653536856174469,
0.16555927693843842,
-0.36843255162239075,
0.34473535418510437,
0.7336125373840332,
0.7895190715789795,
0.01930081658065319,
0.8343538641929626,
0.35449284315109253,
-0.040202077478170395,
-0.6079230308532715,
0.7440269589424133,
-0.3918696939945221,
0.11314182728528976,
-0.47553014755249023,
-0.982207179069519,
-0.46687644720077515,
0.4618202745914459,
-0.40204939246177673,
-0.05020944029092789,
0.4414389431476593,
0.4866633713245392,
-0.1340111643075943,
0.26840996742248535,
0.4634585976600647,
0.14778019487857819,
0.28271111845970154,
0.3454594910144806,
0.655929446220398,
-0.15052638947963715,
0.567093014717102,
-0.16914984583854675,
-0.17744769155979156,
-0.29194551706314087,
-0.5142530202865601,
-0.9642630219459534,
-0.6125100255012512,
-0.03268441557884216,
0.1296282410621643,
0.16980652511119843,
1.2284761667251587,
0.3428960144519806,
-0.37735041975975037,
-0.6372246146202087,
0.4403406083583832,
-0.1894262731075287,
-0.32563233375549316,
-0.10554378479719162,
0.3839610815048218,
-0.35737505555152893,
-0.3676510751247406,
0.31427884101867676,
0.8099969029426575,
0.280949205160141,
-0.447378009557724,
0.037348464131355286,
0.1591571718454361,
0.02382505126297474,
0.7615292072296143,
-0.024529775604605675,
-0.5450626611709595,
-0.25485047698020935,
0.09715026617050171,
-0.08251199126243591,
-0.15022633969783783,
0.8320979475975037,
-0.26542460918426514,
0.18802934885025024,
0.08841247856616974,
0.4216462969779968,
0.5717106461524963,
0.04379735514521599,
0.8412797451019287,
0.012908117845654488,
0.36274880170822144,
-0.02992810122668743,
0.468622624874115,
0.029369886964559555,
-0.309683233499527,
0.524674117565155,
0.16981349885463715,
-0.23436734080314636,
-0.5605655312538147,
-0.17964044213294983,
-0.9821208715438843,
-0.3067657947540283,
0.9542701244354248,
0.08209774643182755,
-0.46085405349731445,
-0.13703671097755432,
-0.32008111476898193,
-0.032467976212501526,
-0.5659799575805664,
0.7028880715370178,
0.7903637886047363,
-0.027430444955825806,
-0.256980299949646,
-0.9770594239234924,
0.6496812105178833,
-0.14479239284992218,
-0.48575714230537415,
0.5056318044662476,
0.6808061003684998,
0.2704222500324249,
0.0022174003534018993,
0.85126131772995,
-0.15340355038642883,
0.3075141906738281,
0.3422284424304962,
0.31121259927749634,
-0.3534819185733795,
-0.5034837126731873,
-0.21513484418392181,
0.32448455691337585,
0.09877078235149384,
0.3294470012187958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10453v1 | Steering Conversational Large Language Models for Long Emotional Support Conversations | 2024-02-16T05:03:01 | 2024-02-16T05:03:01 | Navid Madani, Sougata Saha, Rohini Srihari | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we address the challenge of consistently following emotional
support strategies in long conversations by large language models (LLMs). We
introduce the Strategy-Relevant Attention (SRA) metric, a model-agnostic
measure designed to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in adhering to strategic
prompts in emotional support contexts. By analyzing conversations within the
Emotional Support Conversations dataset (ESConv) using LLaMA models, we
demonstrate that SRA is significantly correlated with a model's ability to
sustain the outlined strategy throughout the interactions. Our findings reveal
that the application of SRA-informed prompts leads to enhanced strategic
adherence, resulting in conversations that more reliably exhibit the desired
emotional support strategies over longer conversations. Furthermore, we
contribute a comprehensive, multi-branch synthetic conversation dataset for
ESConv, featuring a variety of strategy continuations informed by our optimized
prompting method. The code and data are publicly available on our Github. | [
-0.2539914548397064,
-0.7223466038703918,
0.8393504619598389,
0.6658358573913574,
-0.27555420994758606,
0.17629648745059967,
-0.4662199914455414,
-0.20955504477024078,
0.5136749744415283,
0.5167274475097656,
-0.9900647401809692,
-0.3735068142414093,
-0.4227449595928192,
0.036797355860471725,
-0.049079298973083496,
1.0567858219146729,
-0.200792133808136,
-0.01106170192360878,
-0.2013942003250122,
-0.42908164858818054,
-1.0621439218521118,
-0.28125685453414917,
-1.0044220685958862,
-0.24991601705551147,
0.9676946401596069,
0.8133748173713684,
0.43791142106056213,
0.5209941267967224,
0.5006691813468933,
0.2245386838912964,
-0.29737287759780884,
0.13990913331508636,
-0.6980593800544739,
0.6487005352973938,
-0.24675920605659485,
-0.6766871809959412,
-0.38541552424430847,
-0.40419068932533264,
0.6771482825279236,
0.34013089537620544,
-0.6990330815315247,
0.30421093106269836,
0.04584576562047005,
0.6976331472396851,
-0.45728710293769836,
-0.0014555960660800338,
-0.7398501634597778,
0.08340679854154587,
-0.14481498301029205,
-0.2550967037677765,
-0.6004544496536255,
-0.00886086467653513,
0.3337949812412262,
-0.44584938883781433,
-0.4957156479358673,
-0.0026902162935584784,
0.6486309766769409,
0.41517141461372375,
-0.5256144404411316,
-0.4206434190273285,
-0.6696413159370422,
0.8479833006858826,
-0.5664049983024597,
0.3675641715526581,
0.2432212233543396,
0.19082827866077423,
-0.20910172164440155,
-0.3725109100341797,
-0.19464872777462006,
-0.3624565303325653,
0.14433130621910095,
0.30466604232788086,
-0.5046065449714661,
0.1688143014907837,
0.33217373490333557,
-0.41035979986190796,
-0.0893797054886818,
0.3047351837158203,
-0.2436237633228302,
0.23469199240207672,
0.4904806613922119,
0.25302091240882874,
0.06095029413700104,
0.1412673145532608,
-0.37800291180610657,
0.10404128581285477,
-0.7166467308998108,
0.2741197943687439,
0.22447890043258667,
0.05980418249964714,
-0.3589734733104706,
0.6514217853546143,
-0.13636280596256256,
0.34654703736305237,
0.44792428612709045,
0.1343984156847,
-0.1272391378879547,
-0.24112273752689362,
0.06585340201854706,
0.27237018942832947,
0.4214773178100586,
0.582095742225647,
0.5229422450065613,
-0.007840863429009914,
-0.007963987998664379,
0.044193971902132034,
0.43746304512023926,
-0.5911756753921509,
0.1688578724861145,
0.3706180453300476,
-0.49277350306510925,
0.08925711363554001,
-0.37381166219711304,
-0.8951141238212585,
-0.39100489020347595,
-0.5590173602104187,
-0.16392454504966736,
-0.0855189636349678,
-0.11714285612106323,
-0.011564560234546661,
0.222514808177948,
0.4702155292034149,
0.11426960676908493,
-0.903130292892456,
0.08612491935491562,
0.9268292188644409,
1.0046875476837158,
-0.158270463347435,
0.06590248644351959,
-0.5774690508842468,
0.36733028292655945,
-0.5423640012741089,
0.8142227530479431,
-0.6811705231666565,
-0.37324023246765137,
0.17841829359531403,
0.05726982280611992,
-0.06639914214611053,
-0.38532301783561707,
1.062820315361023,
-0.2519605755805969,
0.06706628203392029,
-0.4213884472846985,
-0.26604393124580383,
-0.0421312041580677,
0.596505343914032,
-0.3740916848182678,
0.706243634223938,
-0.3765496015548706,
-0.3446643054485321,
0.13858944177627563,
-0.5665187239646912,
-0.4265616238117218,
-0.2068033516407013,
-0.06497971713542938,
-0.34209439158439636,
0.1531745046377182,
0.31156593561172485,
0.647369921207428,
-0.3595528304576874,
0.2656971514225006,
-0.4307948052883148,
0.0537574328482151,
0.3242146968841553,
-0.27008572220802307,
-0.01256330031901598,
0.2437870353460312,
-0.39937543869018555,
0.3416549265384674,
-0.4598011374473572,
0.01991596817970276,
0.182329460978508,
-0.11521056294441223,
-0.36858949065208435,
0.2450432926416397,
-0.22767922282218933,
0.32967808842658997,
0.14971065521240234,
-0.2828667163848877,
0.14751724898815155,
-0.23810788989067078,
0.5932320952415466,
1.0299447774887085,
0.19213156402111053,
0.23450228571891785,
-0.13214553892612457,
0.9197841882705688,
-0.105388343334198,
-0.02739664353430271,
-0.2326197624206543,
-0.40856078267097473,
-0.8568814992904663,
-0.2595980167388916,
-0.16116221249103546,
0.48245999217033386,
-0.4502103626728058,
0.19764676690101624,
-0.4014308750629425,
-0.5682807564735413,
-0.4161830544471741,
-0.07968048751354218,
0.3422803282737732,
0.46406853199005127,
0.13067325949668884,
-0.1953776478767395,
-0.6287819743156433,
-1.1511600017547607,
-0.2088346928358078,
-0.22250178456306458,
0.2737533152103424,
0.6189051270484924,
0.19632014632225037,
-0.19328385591506958,
0.7001474499702454,
-0.3448592722415924,
-0.1398255079984665,
-0.4983953535556793,
-0.024974718689918518,
0.14114482700824738,
-0.008058388717472553,
0.4740199148654938,
-0.48336899280548096,
-0.7591873407363892,
-0.1110711395740509,
-0.5423228144645691,
-0.32423338294029236,
-0.39359045028686523,
-0.34656599164009094,
0.22979290783405304,
0.6610081791877747,
-0.7087857127189636,
0.1237163096666336,
0.8424428105354309,
-0.48726990818977356,
0.2725220322608948,
0.13062497973442078,
0.35127371549606323,
-1.180884838104248,
-0.03486575186252594,
0.3390759527683258,
-0.190309539437294,
-0.8185892701148987,
-0.39761853218078613,
-0.13839386403560638,
0.08352059125900269,
-0.34348371624946594,
0.4275166690349579,
-0.3624962270259857,
-0.03199424967169762,
-0.06157408282160759,
0.358014315366745,
-0.2731706500053406,
0.42307978868484497,
0.4624738395214081,
0.6239657402038574,
0.5032150745391846,
-0.4640918970108032,
0.26180434226989746,
0.39801788330078125,
-0.11254309862852097,
1.1143701076507568,
-1.0675132274627686,
0.19791708886623383,
-0.13754811882972717,
0.5094981789588928,
-1.1155883073806763,
0.0783889889717102,
0.25744542479515076,
-0.1444956213235855,
0.17256446182727814,
-0.10724123567342758,
-0.06568080186843872,
-0.3388199508190155,
-0.07663262635469437,
0.10977664589881897,
0.2787800431251526,
-0.28814932703971863,
0.8933938145637512,
0.33138397336006165,
-0.8147144317626953,
-0.5090919733047485,
-0.411888062953949,
0.279025137424469,
-0.5554059743881226,
-0.6747089624404907,
0.18136516213417053,
-0.20754197239875793,
-0.329372376203537,
-0.2243826687335968,
0.015479443594813347,
0.40141934156417847,
0.002951327245682478,
0.41814544796943665,
0.255776971578598,
-0.18382467329502106,
0.33154842257499695,
-0.32787084579467773,
0.03090054541826248,
0.3181908428668976,
0.03528769686818123,
0.7246773838996887,
-0.13276167213916779,
-0.4069432020187378,
-0.6775004863739014,
0.5217665433883667,
0.7353870868682861,
-0.17928089201450348,
0.8239594101905823,
0.30260688066482544,
-0.12329529225826263,
-0.18393658101558685,
-0.6943430304527283,
-0.44230806827545166,
-0.4010772109031677,
0.6190276145935059,
-0.24486173689365387,
-0.6829180121421814,
0.6617225408554077,
0.12926168739795685,
0.22991213202476501,
-0.008060755208134651,
0.558053731918335,
-0.24841220676898956,
1.3927674293518066,
0.5268174409866333,
-0.2711544930934906,
0.7459883093833923,
0.13473986089229584,
0.42102938890457153,
-0.8408879041671753,
-0.26247715950012207,
-0.37152180075645447,
-0.7074882984161377,
-0.13740801811218262,
-0.13278110325336456,
-0.0022034684661775827,
-0.34349143505096436,
-0.17647869884967804,
0.08221003413200378,
-0.3181236982345581,
0.18048588931560516,
0.07732681930065155,
-0.09031885117292404,
-0.13902565836906433,
-0.011585270054638386,
0.38107362389564514,
-0.32946744561195374,
-0.8621814846992493,
-0.3742641508579254,
0.7337530255317688,
0.9357046484947205,
0.8418537378311157,
0.24154624342918396,
0.29302313923835754,
0.12428977340459824,
0.32813510298728943,
-1.026285171508789,
0.6826510429382324,
0.4088932275772095,
-0.23121346533298492,
-0.09530270844697952,
-0.4469757080078125,
-0.9932753443717957,
0.04063195362687111,
-0.1689789742231369,
-0.7733948826789856,
-0.08000946789979935,
-0.03539697825908661,
-0.4176395833492279,
-0.13989727199077606,
-0.6847092509269714,
0.7873678207397461,
-0.4769827723503113,
-0.19288891553878784,
-0.4937974810600281,
-0.4719443619251251,
0.050803009420633316,
0.02143159881234169,
-0.020744487643241882,
-0.19753357768058777,
-0.1462070643901825,
1.0287256240844727,
0.02746535651385784,
0.924287736415863,
0.1490260660648346,
-0.347637414932251,
0.365909606218338,
-0.2436879277229309,
1.136328935623169,
-0.14353425800800323,
0.3074931800365448,
-0.16572700440883636,
-0.22115987539291382,
-0.22101835906505585,
-0.5721177458763123,
0.7638658285140991,
-0.5397551655769348,
-0.887628436088562,
-0.33409005403518677,
-0.47227317094802856,
-0.5918378233909607,
-0.10009977221488953,
-0.16014105081558228,
0.036668501794338226,
-0.10264600068330765,
0.6610721945762634,
0.9392527937889099,
0.08194368332624435,
0.32239973545074463,
0.6221030354499817,
0.19451649487018585,
-0.288848340511322,
0.4188523590564728,
0.146587073802948,
0.4616686701774597,
0.127829447388649,
0.08012967556715012,
-0.396842896938324,
-0.287602037191391,
-0.2567707300186157,
0.4468938708305359,
-0.6640534400939941,
-0.09802205860614777,
-0.6967489719390869,
0.16275154054164886,
-0.24960952997207642,
-0.2835235893726349,
-0.4294082820415497,
-0.032308533787727356,
-0.4793241322040558,
-0.5040562152862549,
0.5611156225204468,
0.5474914312362671,
0.29826676845550537,
0.17677649855613708,
-0.7923134565353394,
-0.1088714748620987,
0.11829087883234024,
-0.05484863743185997,
0.22680044174194336,
-0.6752699613571167,
-0.20895273983478546,
0.022719107568264008,
-0.14980770647525787,
-1.1560479402542114,
0.2931581437587738,
0.1490318924188614,
0.775775134563446,
0.38859859108924866,
-0.039576999843120575,
0.8529332280158997,
-0.428725004196167,
0.8675484657287598,
0.41705384850502014,
-0.8037218451499939,
0.7411107420921326,
-0.6110750436782837,
0.42706236243247986,
0.3940642476081848,
0.4572516977787018,
-0.9170131683349609,
-0.321480393409729,
-0.4891033470630646,
-0.9687196016311646,
0.6842123866081238,
-0.1654740869998932,
0.18337053060531616,
-0.03416671231389046,
0.2593052089214325,
-0.6637192368507385,
0.21664679050445557,
-0.5894444584846497,
-0.2750561833381653,
0.4114474356174469,
-0.5695338845252991,
0.2286515235900879,
-0.5203415751457214,
-0.4799971580505371,
0.459249347448349,
0.8093916177749634,
-0.3084797263145447,
0.03483873978257179,
-0.03386678919196129,
0.45085060596466064,
-0.3268648684024811,
0.45955362915992737,
0.6393805742263794,
0.6777467727661133,
0.21358640491962433,
-0.33256375789642334,
0.5007312893867493,
-0.3004707396030426,
0.11708912998437881,
-0.13388124108314514,
0.01012557465583086,
-0.28004029393196106,
0.152234748005867,
0.7981807589530945,
0.45591646432876587,
-0.8869668841362,
0.20371931791305542,
-0.06926143169403076,
0.010155949741601944,
-0.29480767250061035,
-0.243097722530365,
0.3319970369338989,
0.39650866389274597,
0.1044292151927948,
-0.4206852614879608,
-0.2416219413280487,
-0.7231078743934631,
0.14852799475193024,
0.5983761548995972,
-0.9742062091827393,
-0.07106310874223709,
0.3007947504520416,
0.41815856099128723,
-0.295215904712677,
0.44218170642852783,
0.2738395035266876,
-0.5899399518966675,
0.6874348521232605,
0.4569706320762634,
0.6529231667518616,
-0.278043270111084,
0.31738170981407166,
0.12703660130500793,
0.1145276427268982,
-0.1533598005771637,
0.2170487493276596,
0.05973592400550842,
-0.3630615770816803,
-0.3704553544521332,
-0.14627714455127716,
-0.4648642838001251,
-0.12153667956590652,
-0.7723440527915955,
0.330641508102417,
-0.439970463514328,
-0.45173874497413635,
-0.20217230916023254,
-0.1262005716562271,
-0.40176454186439514,
-0.13058774173259735,
0.3045884370803833,
0.8765125274658203,
-0.7032800912857056,
0.37385156750679016,
0.6888871788978577,
-0.19906170666217804,
-1.049689531326294,
-0.20209607481956482,
0.1562960296869278,
-0.7150300741195679,
0.5942867398262024,
0.10818490386009216,
-0.2693866789340973,
-0.23899640142917633,
-0.46970829367637634,
-0.9849867224693298,
1.278888463973999,
0.2981831133365631,
-1.0707770586013794,
0.19212007522583008,
-0.112331323325634,
0.652387261390686,
-0.6116628646850586,
0.211678147315979,
0.4904778301715851,
0.46473994851112366,
0.2686785161495209,
-0.7546502351760864,
-0.001180456019937992,
0.02574739046394825,
-0.16513942182064056,
0.258888304233551,
-1.1723049879074097,
0.09077877551317215,
-0.3537326455116272,
-0.37695032358169556,
0.1929582804441452,
0.9162555932998657,
0.6266640424728394,
0.3389381468296051,
0.6276209950447083,
0.7655727863311768,
0.6571365594863892,
-0.15822245180606842,
0.65525221824646,
-0.34618592262268066,
0.09636902809143066,
1.1080350875854492,
-0.630944013595581,
1.0966832637786865,
0.7764662504196167,
0.2205631285905838,
0.6900585889816284,
0.6902928948402405,
0.11640407890081406,
0.4248582720756531,
0.1552446484565735,
-0.11079076677560806,
-0.3239862620830536,
-0.6424426436424255,
-0.31629908084869385,
0.17100101709365845,
0.5123536586761475,
-0.5503995418548584,
0.18270626664161682,
-0.03650200366973877,
0.3241385221481323,
0.07456326484680176,
-0.4564962685108185,
0.8873189091682434,
0.3640384376049042,
-1.1367915868759155,
0.251907616853714,
-0.27527758479118347,
0.45940136909484863,
-0.9892656207084656,
0.07110682129859924,
-0.16915278136730194,
0.20418095588684082,
-0.0914006382226944,
-0.8817201852798462,
0.07660484313964844,
0.2084353119134903,
-0.18071286380290985,
-0.297220915555954,
0.4528992176055908,
-0.7348102331161499,
-0.19304391741752625,
0.36627498269081116,
0.3059403598308563,
-0.22961674630641937,
0.17707794904708862,
-0.8729546070098877,
0.23249782621860504,
0.05018341541290283,
-0.6555129289627075,
0.3339731693267822,
0.5870531797409058,
0.0022001841571182013,
1.045206904411316,
0.6492617726325989,
0.06462839245796204,
-0.25850018858909607,
0.2206384390592575,
0.6541261672973633,
-0.5720961689949036,
-0.7701111435890198,
-0.729227602481842,
0.5100645422935486,
-0.0815926268696785,
-0.4152719974517822,
1.0307461023330688,
-0.11651629954576492,
0.28471839427948,
0.14743418991565704,
0.47431015968322754,
0.2397836148738861,
0.15835604071617126,
-0.6973289251327515,
0.3984907865524292,
-0.3187895715236664,
0.25817960500717163,
0.04467514529824257,
-0.9667141437530518,
0.2209954857826233,
0.4895562529563904,
-0.542191207408905,
-0.002195527544245124,
0.4222888648509979,
0.8305293321609497,
0.23720626533031464,
0.061896249651908875,
0.08726813644170761,
0.250570684671402,
0.5851514339447021,
0.8154088854789734,
1.065736174583435,
0.2533346116542816,
0.587064266204834,
0.29428914189338684,
-0.11678017675876617,
-0.19385121762752533,
-1.0514683723449707,
-0.8360422253608704,
-0.39942777156829834,
-0.39512038230895996,
-0.31633123755455017,
0.31477096676826477,
1.2650002241134644,
0.8114563822746277,
-0.6731745004653931,
-0.09311268478631973,
-0.05317382141947746,
0.008815771900117397,
-0.12569132447242737,
-0.20188532769680023,
0.07450922578573227,
-0.3381665349006653,
-0.5996574759483337,
0.30103182792663574,
0.3858991861343384,
-0.0098314443603158,
-0.3781164288520813,
-0.11337464302778244,
-0.38041171431541443,
0.5290952324867249,
0.5433533787727356,
0.4140419661998749,
-0.6327251195907593,
-0.3034842014312744,
0.2890489399433136,
-0.17069734632968903,
-0.08413078635931015,
0.8053528666496277,
-0.4230886399745941,
0.26828545331954956,
0.3815807104110718,
0.872793972492218,
0.028247173875570297,
0.22453661262989044,
0.8085326552391052,
-0.653476893901825,
-0.04320138692855835,
0.431077241897583,
0.5145972967147827,
0.4365977644920349,
-0.5401281118392944,
0.6058146953582764,
-0.21429039537906647,
-0.8289517164230347,
-0.7447360157966614,
0.30486640334129333,
-1.0303090810775757,
0.18397146463394165,
1.6597900390625,
-0.2919808626174927,
-0.22888603806495667,
0.08171948045492172,
-0.47597676515579224,
-0.17762739956378937,
-0.8671700954437256,
0.5531347990036011,
1.0489780902862549,
-0.13634581863880157,
-0.5925581455230713,
-0.4831348657608032,
0.43845948576927185,
0.9179506897926331,
-0.8178633451461792,
0.37894579768180847,
0.47520923614501953,
-0.06326991319656372,
0.27965372800827026,
0.579178512096405,
0.2938194274902344,
-0.017216850072145462,
-0.4905751049518585,
-0.473177045583725,
0.34630507230758667,
-0.6008469462394714,
-0.354158490896225,
-0.08561914414167404,
-0.04316738247871399,
0.07860490679740906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10447v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10447v2 | Incremental Sequence Labeling: A Tale of Two Shifts | 2024-02-16T04:41:33 | 2024-05-27T15:23:17 | Shengjie Qiu, Junhao Zheng, Zhen Liu, Yicheng Luo, Qianli Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The incremental sequence labeling task involves continuously learning new
classes over time while retaining knowledge of the previous ones. Our
investigation identifies two significant semantic shifts: E2O (where the model
mislabels an old entity as a non-entity) and O2E (where the model labels a
non-entity or old entity as a new entity). Previous research has predominantly
focused on addressing the E2O problem, neglecting the O2E issue. This
negligence results in a model bias towards classifying new data samples as
belonging to the new class during the learning process. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel framework, Incremental Sequential Labeling
without Semantic Shifts (IS3). Motivated by the identified semantic shifts (E2O
and O2E), IS3 aims to mitigate catastrophic forgetting in models. As for the
E2O problem, we use knowledge distillation to maintain the model's
discriminative ability for old entities. Simultaneously, to tackle the O2E
problem, we alleviate the model's bias towards new entities through debiased
loss and optimization levels. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on three
datasets with various incremental settings, demonstrates the superior
performance of IS3 compared to the previous state-of-the-art method by a
significant margin.The data, code, and scripts are publicly available at
https://github.com/zzz47zzz/codebase-for-incremental-learning-with-llm. | [
-0.05338066443800926,
-0.5467703938484192,
0.3707762360572815,
0.2022431343793869,
-0.19738398492336273,
0.03154579922556877,
0.2653159201145172,
-0.6443066000938416,
-0.23944996297359467,
0.5038665533065796,
-0.7426779270172119,
-0.42762959003448486,
-0.7780818343162537,
0.14650119841098785,
-0.546658992767334,
1.0563209056854248,
0.0430171936750412,
0.16335555911064148,
-0.10119257122278214,
-0.20909865200519562,
-0.5223420262336731,
-0.11461777240037918,
-0.8552122116088867,
-0.5959557890892029,
0.49346494674682617,
0.5402940511703491,
0.40817373991012573,
0.9886059165000916,
0.3109331727027893,
0.11500908434391022,
-0.18247869610786438,
0.07276884466409683,
-0.4540367126464844,
0.19488419592380524,
-0.31789109110832214,
-0.610643208026886,
-0.25423663854599,
-0.2819579839706421,
0.7042357325553894,
0.6730477809906006,
-0.10808368027210236,
0.3386191725730896,
-0.044438641518354416,
1.0155177116394043,
-0.6765532493591309,
0.27930763363838196,
-0.9195138216018677,
0.2536143362522125,
-0.3921794295310974,
-0.0894969254732132,
-0.5161158442497253,
-0.18284864723682404,
0.2691151797771454,
-0.7427253127098083,
0.26268690824508667,
-0.1797599345445633,
0.8284306526184082,
0.6609282493591309,
-0.342054545879364,
-0.2652692198753357,
-0.5885143280029297,
0.47629228234291077,
-0.5681886672973633,
0.3086719214916229,
0.002106138039380312,
0.05070674046874046,
0.038722921162843704,
-0.5562595725059509,
-0.6514941453933716,
0.13049882650375366,
0.3551749289035797,
0.11933614313602448,
0.11936282366514206,
-0.33998414874076843,
0.3563038408756256,
0.3193492591381073,
-0.24082180857658386,
0.5658162832260132,
-0.2766260802745819,
-0.033446989953517914,
0.545677661895752,
-0.04838905110955238,
0.08789388090372086,
0.2826516330242157,
-1.0072436332702637,
-0.09273774176836014,
-1.0707660913467407,
-0.2629926800727844,
0.31909653544425964,
0.2863284945487976,
0.05652659758925438,
0.4819672703742981,
0.059521980583667755,
0.5298964977264404,
0.12240951508283615,
-0.2962934374809265,
0.5033231377601624,
-0.04245666414499283,
-0.0334794856607914,
0.415263831615448,
0.247998908162117,
0.26704299449920654,
0.00278653297573328,
-0.09464512765407562,
0.028236037120223045,
-0.002315834164619446,
0.14927847683429718,
-0.543555736541748,
-0.10617423057556152,
0.04737376421689987,
-0.05060514062643051,
-0.1787640005350113,
-0.11800225079059601,
-0.5214787125587463,
-0.6065686345100403,
-0.46543067693710327,
0.49117010831832886,
-0.5077546834945679,
-0.21358978748321533,
0.004477537702769041,
-0.22532743215560913,
0.3184192478656769,
0.5888049602508545,
-0.9021288156509399,
0.13089589774608612,
0.5962058901786804,
0.8589233756065369,
-0.3284391164779663,
-0.24552150070667267,
-0.16452960669994354,
0.4161604642868042,
-0.21202632784843445,
0.7010399103164673,
-0.4227573275566101,
-0.4442642629146576,
-0.20136664807796478,
0.1158728376030922,
0.1265041083097458,
-0.7959151864051819,
0.03441254049539566,
-0.6570631265640259,
-0.10276196897029877,
-0.12501859664916992,
-0.72529137134552,
-0.3349827527999878,
-0.01429152861237526,
-0.6900534629821777,
1.1212588548660278,
0.01209638174623251,
-0.6420466899871826,
0.5257871150970459,
-0.4503788352012634,
-0.3672935664653778,
-0.10666079074144363,
-0.16909702122211456,
-0.7317198514938354,
-0.09234781563282013,
-0.19086800515651703,
0.08330243825912476,
-0.3655265271663666,
0.1922881305217743,
-0.3833828568458557,
-0.2739393711090088,
-0.004461142234504223,
-0.07824474573135376,
0.6990680694580078,
0.22724097967147827,
-0.46195611357688904,
-0.08304496854543686,
-0.9324332475662231,
-0.09290700405836105,
0.03649380803108215,
-0.36118650436401367,
-0.25501611828804016,
0.16635647416114807,
-0.3696552813053131,
0.1682116687297821,
-0.020634416490793228,
-0.33897754549980164,
0.46368521451950073,
-0.1525602787733078,
0.45138347148895264,
0.7570327520370483,
0.14444777369499207,
0.6831963658332825,
-0.12397287786006927,
0.04761810600757599,
0.513133704662323,
-0.024396449327468872,
-0.33947259187698364,
-0.6113290786743164,
-1.0420458316802979,
-0.10706701129674911,
0.23604147136211395,
0.8736029267311096,
-0.786005437374115,
0.24604760110378265,
-0.3659724295139313,
-0.19625714421272278,
-0.2657754719257355,
0.10011161863803864,
0.2834087312221527,
0.7400224804878235,
0.7291833162307739,
-0.1760263890028,
-0.45055311918258667,
-0.9421254396438599,
-0.14758293330669403,
-0.17345453798770905,
-0.08741579204797745,
-0.28054630756378174,
0.34673669934272766,
-0.33911195397377014,
0.589043378829956,
-0.3839288353919983,
-0.3659050762653351,
0.07992155849933624,
0.2826940715312958,
-0.08077656477689743,
0.6633691191673279,
0.058973707258701324,
-0.7108209133148193,
-0.2474234402179718,
-0.24816249310970306,
-0.7604096531867981,
-0.05228225514292717,
-0.3590838313102722,
-0.28503674268722534,
0.49791908264160156,
0.5904218554496765,
-0.25155189633369446,
0.4473148584365845,
0.018056893721222878,
-0.04828009381890297,
-0.015779370442032814,
0.08718141913414001,
-0.2137639969587326,
-0.7742194533348083,
-0.1436263769865036,
0.039012253284454346,
0.032556284219026566,
-0.4935038983821869,
-0.31564775109291077,
0.3590535819530487,
0.07153210788965225,
-0.5355376601219177,
0.5508261322975159,
-0.46027377247810364,
-0.009258364327251911,
-0.16930818557739258,
-0.04707671329379082,
0.17947079241275787,
0.36253511905670166,
0.3024737536907196,
0.2602479159832001,
0.3785897493362427,
-0.8475039601325989,
-0.14745992422103882,
0.2993209958076477,
-0.3833028972148895,
0.5019400119781494,
-0.18830722570419312,
0.45742562413215637,
-0.32474425435066223,
0.2413281947374344,
-0.8823159337043762,
0.03064991533756256,
0.5034310221672058,
-0.3060218393802643,
0.7081531286239624,
-0.25975847244262695,
-0.5924364924430847,
-0.2182023823261261,
-0.1670600324869156,
0.3376378118991852,
0.26822707056999207,
-0.5210270881652832,
0.11274745315313339,
0.3660796284675598,
-0.1331847757101059,
-0.5270308256149292,
-0.8415115475654602,
-0.12587866187095642,
-0.24645793437957764,
-0.5560204982757568,
0.6905331611633301,
0.2028091549873352,
-0.06846290081739426,
0.17300568521022797,
-0.48303472995758057,
-0.03956612944602966,
0.05292787402868271,
0.10685092210769653,
0.4101997911930084,
0.024283278733491898,
0.6847830414772034,
0.14896459877490997,
-0.3894854187965393,
-0.13166305422782898,
-0.7124791741371155,
0.0559893399477005,
0.17420130968093872,
0.004309503827244043,
-0.39405590295791626,
0.4201156198978424,
0.24186788499355316,
0.04941576346755028,
0.6286846399307251,
0.4298381507396698,
-0.42270997166633606,
-0.32958880066871643,
-0.37297874689102173,
-0.021908756345510483,
-0.3703140914440155,
0.5209987163543701,
-0.3060917258262634,
-0.7876136898994446,
0.15145377814769745,
-0.25430500507354736,
0.08636404573917389,
0.4794309735298157,
0.4509994089603424,
-0.1025749146938324,
0.6564609408378601,
0.6576046347618103,
0.24061156809329987,
0.41735225915908813,
-0.20568332076072693,
0.17448186874389648,
-0.9663859009742737,
-0.5018953680992126,
-0.14685523509979248,
-0.3757980167865753,
-0.36373257637023926,
-0.5293661952018738,
0.5126703381538391,
0.28707820177078247,
-0.4824175238609314,
0.195543572306633,
-0.5876468420028687,
0.41535770893096924,
0.45151767134666443,
0.1219712495803833,
0.4702887237071991,
-0.0040390631183981895,
0.39794713258743286,
0.15824630856513977,
-0.5278854370117188,
-0.5182570815086365,
0.968153715133667,
0.2754609286785126,
0.6125505566596985,
0.22726865112781525,
0.6770811080932617,
0.5122105479240417,
0.5413874387741089,
-0.7597541213035583,
0.44014492630958557,
0.07179746776819229,
-0.6893605589866638,
-0.48239168524742126,
-0.309531569480896,
-0.9474883079528809,
0.45970582962036133,
-0.14591625332832336,
-0.7304662466049194,
0.2475636750459671,
0.3611040413379669,
-0.31705042719841003,
0.42933204770088196,
-0.6071312427520752,
0.6136093735694885,
-0.19131991267204285,
-0.6455026865005493,
-0.026568757370114326,
-1.0391002893447876,
0.4124687910079956,
-0.09303092211484909,
0.21290314197540283,
-0.5671250224113464,
-0.2880706191062927,
0.5035099387168884,
-0.6529977321624756,
0.6552466154098511,
-0.2981691360473633,
-0.29237860441207886,
0.5442954897880554,
-0.08576858043670654,
0.8772855997085571,
0.09164927154779434,
-0.05705535411834717,
0.22779704630374908,
-0.013814945705235004,
-0.3526488244533539,
-0.4519078731536865,
0.5665568709373474,
-0.5834243893623352,
-0.4724198579788208,
-0.541584312915802,
-0.26314061880111694,
-0.2847304344177246,
0.21282336115837097,
0.4348716735839844,
0.11120466142892838,
0.22488190233707428,
-0.3123524785041809,
1.0194681882858276,
-0.34316736459732056,
0.2366437166929245,
0.6496100425720215,
-0.13096781075000763,
-0.3932248055934906,
0.7345201969146729,
0.3737393915653229,
0.49597224593162537,
0.6006319522857666,
0.05764278769493103,
-0.5019752979278564,
-0.6243158578872681,
-0.589343249797821,
0.22709433734416962,
-0.9838629961013794,
-0.36240512132644653,
-0.6608235836029053,
0.028174202889204025,
-0.4405108094215393,
0.13777777552604675,
-0.40440577268600464,
-0.5983659029006958,
-0.3926182687282562,
-0.2193576544523239,
0.3066271245479584,
0.7053514719009399,
-0.14366565644741058,
0.09823661297559738,
-0.6526941657066345,
0.2557560205459595,
0.22419467568397522,
0.14738678932189941,
-0.014361618086695671,
-0.560692310333252,
-0.22445867955684662,
0.027087878435850143,
-0.48720020055770874,
-0.9675173163414001,
0.05971413850784302,
0.29664918780326843,
0.24694497883319855,
0.09352005273103714,
0.010996636003255844,
0.636031985282898,
-0.6649048924446106,
0.46454179286956787,
0.29022282361984253,
-1.020705223083496,
0.6177829504013062,
-0.17214791476726532,
0.5244893431663513,
0.6395925879478455,
0.4461211562156677,
-0.4804278314113617,
-0.04047458991408348,
-0.4769187867641449,
-1.5003693103790283,
0.9151543378829956,
-0.09148940443992615,
-0.16750048100948334,
-0.15032726526260376,
0.5992193222045898,
0.4623015224933624,
0.35387173295021057,
-0.7960888147354126,
-0.57026207447052,
-0.1524202674627304,
0.024023495614528656,
0.2525850534439087,
-0.2943095266819,
0.0707797110080719,
-0.05166748911142349,
1.0686465501785278,
0.059177085757255554,
0.33463186025619507,
0.23379960656166077,
-0.42464369535446167,
0.035215698182582855,
0.15360695123672485,
0.4695310890674591,
0.31422144174575806,
-0.13362349569797516,
0.3315448462963104,
0.19068630039691925,
-0.27214792370796204,
0.44046369194984436,
0.032473769038915634,
-0.46804752945899963,
-0.15684249997138977,
0.2031610757112503,
0.8763650059700012,
0.3049878478050232,
-0.34587669372558594,
0.2368893027305603,
0.5260688066482544,
-0.09221107512712479,
-0.4467538595199585,
0.049572546035051346,
0.003942827694118023,
0.26026979088783264,
0.24693705141544342,
0.43806925415992737,
0.3383123278617859,
-0.5845878720283508,
0.22295542061328888,
-0.16243304312229156,
-0.5111610889434814,
-0.24988502264022827,
0.7935476303100586,
0.16078710556030273,
-0.008657919242978096,
0.802531898021698,
-0.19433380663394928,
-0.08505271375179291,
0.6755322217941284,
0.6231034398078918,
0.7511817812919617,
-0.1831301748752594,
0.18931862711906433,
0.6037027835845947,
0.06622173637151718,
-0.3605865240097046,
0.029880529269576073,
-0.23631824553012848,
-0.762676477432251,
-0.14433477818965912,
-0.3341304063796997,
-0.2878400683403015,
0.11381292343139648,
-0.9490212798118591,
0.4298423230648041,
-0.500167965888977,
-0.1524314284324646,
0.18302927911281586,
-0.6403372287750244,
-0.5015358924865723,
0.15375162661075592,
0.6229206323623657,
0.8722651600837708,
-0.490743488073349,
0.9806907773017883,
0.559661328792572,
-0.2896835505962372,
-0.33135274052619934,
-0.11037305742502213,
0.49560052156448364,
-0.8545805215835571,
0.8208401799201965,
0.4489649832248688,
-0.2969420254230499,
0.32360512018203735,
-0.4372013509273529,
-1.2180612087249756,
1.3027455806732178,
0.26419299840927124,
-0.7310616374015808,
-0.02507813274860382,
0.1190459206700325,
0.20202849805355072,
-0.15273107588291168,
-0.14382407069206238,
0.46576184034347534,
0.40255850553512573,
0.42275470495224,
-0.45972317457199097,
0.03402308374643326,
-0.22958292067050934,
0.2469627410173416,
0.5213021636009216,
-0.7947338819503784,
0.7133963108062744,
-0.6317739486694336,
-0.6653392314910889,
0.17222318053245544,
0.5206233859062195,
0.19413115084171295,
0.47165346145629883,
0.36408570408821106,
0.8898943066596985,
1.00911545753479,
-0.37424084544181824,
0.8373479247093201,
0.19822381436824799,
0.3139481842517853,
1.6739838123321533,
-0.652908205986023,
0.640121340751648,
0.4580831527709961,
-0.3808385729789734,
0.3987584114074707,
0.8475192785263062,
-0.029804816469550133,
0.7560904622077942,
0.517007052898407,
-0.3917355239391327,
-0.16638053953647614,
0.2086726278066635,
-0.6262199282646179,
0.06796672940254211,
0.45233985781669617,
-0.34589752554893494,
-0.27627453207969666,
-0.0076395440846681595,
0.32871297001838684,
-0.3011728823184967,
-0.25134792923927307,
0.9376141428947449,
0.009599392302334309,
-0.7366930246353149,
0.47499123215675354,
-0.16691482067108154,
0.3360597491264343,
-0.561937689781189,
-0.15318265557289124,
-0.14447849988937378,
0.44877392053604126,
-0.20638033747673035,
-0.489138662815094,
0.3233319818973541,
-0.29821762442588806,
-0.46661877632141113,
-0.25049254298210144,
0.16455493867397308,
-0.5113089084625244,
-0.40417811274528503,
0.22806711494922638,
0.1297129988670349,
-0.09017246216535568,
0.13204480707645416,
-0.6322405338287354,
0.1880219280719757,
0.09118814021348953,
-0.044986333698034286,
0.2528178095817566,
0.5552400350570679,
-0.16494040191173553,
0.6139134764671326,
0.21149174869060516,
-0.3237755298614502,
0.2840248644351959,
0.024070318788290024,
0.49457740783691406,
-0.8313925266265869,
-0.18375909328460693,
-0.8335695862770081,
0.5580092072486877,
0.11694398522377014,
-0.31587132811546326,
0.6443805694580078,
0.6677687764167786,
1.1307380199432373,
-0.18203289806842804,
0.9775937795639038,
0.009481922723352909,
0.4847021996974945,
-0.8684130311012268,
-0.0002271413104608655,
-0.49317824840545654,
0.7625274062156677,
-0.0687096044421196,
-0.8105230927467346,
-0.5582204461097717,
0.41795599460601807,
-0.1809619814157486,
-0.3579576313495636,
0.6533552408218384,
0.6302088499069214,
0.4743199646472931,
0.11848201602697372,
-0.002969265216961503,
0.15824970602989197,
0.1347913146018982,
0.5962775945663452,
1.092600703239441,
-0.5176748037338257,
0.09770405292510986,
-0.1026226058602333,
-0.14737452566623688,
0.020372264087200165,
-0.8444749712944031,
-0.3803221881389618,
-0.5862352848052979,
-0.9160659909248352,
-0.42552056908607483,
0.243932843208313,
0.9239537119865417,
0.4950467050075531,
-0.7448784112930298,
0.03747754916548729,
-0.3374214470386505,
0.2656252980232239,
-0.22901803255081177,
-0.22948533296585083,
0.13227616250514984,
-0.604488730430603,
-0.7401654720306396,
0.20047223567962646,
0.6368279457092285,
0.3177649974822998,
0.15581941604614258,
0.18295714259147644,
-0.34542644023895264,
-0.08724001795053482,
0.5723770260810852,
0.39544370770454407,
-0.6789251565933228,
-0.1818605363368988,
-0.33290594816207886,
0.1583368182182312,
0.38825514912605286,
0.8015220761299133,
-0.7108059525489807,
0.604534387588501,
0.32868674397468567,
0.5257291197776794,
0.8582931756973267,
-0.16659170389175415,
0.275748610496521,
-0.4991509020328522,
0.14460162818431854,
0.1463814377784729,
0.15656951069831848,
0.42691993713378906,
-0.40313172340393066,
0.7828658223152161,
0.4054863154888153,
-0.32720792293548584,
-0.6545339822769165,
0.4532480537891388,
-0.756177544593811,
-0.33642035722732544,
1.088249683380127,
-0.06830163300037384,
0.04027634859085083,
-0.15220831334590912,
0.1274423748254776,
0.4128696322441101,
-0.23426775634288788,
0.8276370763778687,
0.4972091615200043,
-0.5377883911132812,
0.071756511926651,
-0.2756696045398712,
0.3733817934989929,
0.26463574171066284,
-0.65692538022995,
-0.18717607855796814,
0.527237594127655,
0.45469164848327637,
0.041569095104932785,
0.6266758441925049,
-0.45349904894828796,
-0.0412166565656662,
0.026565587148070335,
0.16824395954608917,
0.06218348816037178,
-0.4980824887752533,
-0.1781199723482132,
-0.05922475829720497,
0.028431333601474762,
-0.23928119242191315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10436v1 | I Am Not Them: Fluid Identities and Persistent Out-group Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T03:54:48 | 2024-02-16T03:54:48 | Wenchao Dong, Assem Zhunis, Hyojin Chin, Jiyoung Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explored cultural biases-individualism vs. collectivism-in ChatGPT across
three Western languages (i.e., English, German, and French) and three Eastern
languages (i.e., Chinese, Japanese, and Korean). When ChatGPT adopted an
individualistic persona in Western languages, its collectivism scores (i.e.,
out-group values) exhibited a more negative trend, surpassing their positive
orientation towards individualism (i.e., in-group values). Conversely, when a
collectivistic persona was assigned to ChatGPT in Eastern languages, a similar
pattern emerged with more negative responses toward individualism (i.e.,
out-group values) as compared to collectivism (i.e., in-group values). The
results indicate that when imbued with a particular social identity, ChatGPT
discerns in-group and out-group, embracing in-group values while eschewing
out-group values. Notably, the negativity towards the out-group, from which
prejudices and discrimination arise, exceeded the positivity towards the
in-group. The experiment was replicated in the political domain, and the
results remained consistent. Furthermore, this replication unveiled an
intrinsic Democratic bias in Large Language Models (LLMs), aligning with
earlier findings and providing integral insights into mitigating such bias
through prompt engineering. Extensive robustness checks were performed using
varying hyperparameter and persona setup methods, with or without social
identity labels, across other popular language models. | [
-0.49085772037506104,
-0.7566310167312622,
0.275617778301239,
0.09486578404903412,
-0.007510456722229719,
0.7346876263618469,
-0.4126662015914917,
-0.2777356803417206,
0.449138343334198,
0.48264071345329285,
-0.5724002718925476,
-0.08032755553722382,
-0.5902811288833618,
0.22799882292747498,
-0.35435548424720764,
0.9928090572357178,
0.011356503702700138,
0.16027168929576874,
0.1563819944858551,
-0.3599472939968109,
-0.11106537282466888,
-0.7136631011962891,
-0.06355533748865128,
-0.5130189657211304,
0.15978865325450897,
0.45159196853637695,
0.7946672439575195,
0.05600018426775932,
0.27389436960220337,
0.2707540690898895,
0.019405726343393326,
-0.17629483342170715,
-0.6222947835922241,
0.12830697000026703,
-0.3333068788051605,
-0.2652803063392639,
0.2543211281299591,
0.32858291268348694,
0.6582836508750916,
0.7258970141410828,
0.1564290076494217,
0.42221567034721375,
0.13124434649944305,
0.8602665066719055,
-0.5632725358009338,
0.27785149216651917,
-0.7954603433609009,
0.04065636917948723,
-0.461532860994339,
0.04588225111365318,
-0.5667061805725098,
-0.48590776324272156,
0.2096562385559082,
-0.30640503764152527,
0.31153926253318787,
0.026510128751397133,
1.0491036176681519,
-0.09517373889684677,
-0.6436830759048462,
-0.37137696146965027,
-0.7344570159912109,
0.781760573387146,
-0.5065116882324219,
0.215103417634964,
0.4092612862586975,
0.32429495453834534,
-0.2403217852115631,
-0.35348647832870483,
-0.6365366578102112,
0.012010019272565842,
0.04519052058458328,
0.3860403597354889,
-0.3895275890827179,
-0.1449016034603119,
0.12471830099821091,
0.20675891637802124,
-0.4952565133571625,
0.28932633996009827,
-0.593974232673645,
-0.1929650455713272,
0.6252733469009399,
-0.07467902451753616,
0.4160515367984772,
0.1310219019651413,
-0.44766712188720703,
0.11700192838907242,
-0.9606633186340332,
0.2965455651283264,
0.8035057187080383,
0.3050367832183838,
-0.38197803497314453,
0.7992302775382996,
-0.125899538397789,
0.17539115250110626,
0.2546623647212982,
-0.04801342263817787,
0.10698860883712769,
-0.22887305915355682,
-0.010921338573098183,
0.09763304144144058,
0.9802682399749756,
0.037669166922569275,
0.7821494340896606,
-0.3153284192085266,
0.030408503487706184,
0.18889783322811127,
-0.04988560453057289,
-0.6516922116279602,
-0.15214592218399048,
0.02964135818183422,
-0.7073966860771179,
-0.22661027312278748,
-0.15459053218364716,
-0.8286758661270142,
-0.6075723767280579,
-0.11787939816713333,
0.36721813678741455,
-0.2318078577518463,
-0.4418790340423584,
-0.3147684931755066,
-0.2230333536863327,
0.4559416174888611,
0.29940274357795715,
-1.213554859161377,
0.3401109278202057,
0.45777416229248047,
0.8441446423530579,
-0.15301577746868134,
-0.2500576376914978,
-0.30909085273742676,
-0.09601820260286331,
-0.5423317551612854,
0.7957133650779724,
-1.0045853853225708,
-0.8071151375770569,
0.08156965672969818,
0.0741674080491066,
-0.13603156805038452,
-0.6584347486495972,
0.19042280316352844,
-0.3465251624584198,
0.5100288391113281,
-0.7431727051734924,
-0.3567117750644684,
-0.19184112548828125,
-0.025372439995408058,
-0.286906361579895,
0.7269920110702515,
0.1395646184682846,
-0.6386998295783997,
0.30694156885147095,
-0.5612781643867493,
-0.160745769739151,
0.34929516911506653,
-0.6322993040084839,
-0.09957173466682434,
0.20046530663967133,
-0.0961732268333435,
0.2956532835960388,
-0.37873542308807373,
0.08790910243988037,
-0.6634547114372253,
-0.399801641702652,
0.5405295491218567,
-0.4292566180229187,
1.0015690326690674,
0.1673291027545929,
-0.6518815755844116,
0.0540735200047493,
-0.1981140524148941,
0.10174298286437988,
0.20033186674118042,
-0.20619824528694153,
-0.34820741415023804,
0.04161525145173073,
-0.00031867012148723006,
0.6711046695709229,
-0.004920410457998514,
-0.551571249961853,
0.16033709049224854,
-0.18177397549152374,
0.5181772708892822,
1.334437370300293,
0.021115589886903763,
0.5753522515296936,
-0.22383497655391693,
0.6937680840492249,
0.3195192813873291,
-0.20456118881702423,
0.0828130692243576,
-0.7448060512542725,
-0.6418161988258362,
-0.20082014799118042,
-0.030790122225880623,
0.6868345737457275,
-0.7581432461738586,
0.33299341797828674,
-0.2983997166156769,
-0.5126954317092896,
-0.35752034187316895,
0.14575448632240295,
0.27099794149398804,
0.3977647125720978,
0.12090674787759781,
-0.26044872403144836,
-0.21783556044101715,
-1.338923692703247,
-0.6105606555938721,
-0.7974462509155273,
0.0626632571220398,
0.014015402644872665,
0.792441189289093,
-0.23949658870697021,
1.0811303853988647,
-0.27088651061058044,
-0.010319831781089306,
-0.25973179936408997,
0.0022702310234308243,
0.06447342038154602,
0.2569318413734436,
0.2401900440454483,
-0.5485051870346069,
-0.9200088381767273,
0.2706882953643799,
-0.5534046292304993,
-0.38389673829078674,
-0.1252651810646057,
-0.012552645057439804,
0.3071745038032532,
0.4220230281352997,
-0.3357614576816559,
0.39127659797668457,
0.8880361914634705,
-0.654061496257782,
0.6203719973564148,
0.06914470344781876,
0.025024425238370895,
-1.1820485591888428,
-0.08303424715995789,
0.13531890511512756,
0.1266261637210846,
-0.516781210899353,
-0.2499769926071167,
0.05732714757323265,
-0.01979532279074192,
-0.23418956995010376,
0.8250610828399658,
-0.6507670879364014,
0.25194230675697327,
0.00009466561459703371,
0.14031577110290527,
-0.09976696968078613,
0.36343690752983093,
-0.012156214565038681,
0.8360589146614075,
0.5226325392723083,
-0.4899425506591797,
-0.02816087007522583,
0.1818120777606964,
-0.35141435265541077,
0.8315436840057373,
-0.49482232332229614,
0.18429622054100037,
-0.5041514039039612,
0.2398962825536728,
-1.090191125869751,
-0.16140803694725037,
0.4152093529701233,
-0.2852969467639923,
0.17201578617095947,
-0.4466419219970703,
-0.3503580093383789,
-0.1772768646478653,
-0.07931304723024368,
0.17168253660202026,
0.7777264714241028,
-0.5585647225379944,
0.35471564531326294,
0.5597514510154724,
-0.23686523735523224,
-0.6383102536201477,
-0.8867440223693848,
0.11176413297653198,
-0.6618902087211609,
-0.6697527170181274,
0.004725436680018902,
-0.33020254969596863,
-1.066112756729126,
-0.12225132435560226,
-0.01584445871412754,
-0.34938958287239075,
-0.1266496181488037,
0.21291819214820862,
-0.11525307595729828,
-0.1665598452091217,
0.15889938175678253,
0.0699378028512001,
-0.05983220040798187,
-0.24579213559627533,
-0.02433747798204422,
0.5063615441322327,
-0.4225843846797943,
-0.3120424747467041,
-0.27105817198753357,
0.6087206602096558,
0.5979541540145874,
-0.5085239410400391,
0.9224063754081726,
0.5171557664871216,
-0.1220303401350975,
-0.0346355214715004,
-0.7336364388465881,
-0.34276261925697327,
-0.4847085773944855,
0.26383328437805176,
-0.3725413978099823,
-1.0668072700500488,
0.9888365268707275,
0.1463758945465088,
0.19222114980220795,
0.222664475440979,
0.7405929565429688,
0.06063195317983627,
0.7839395403862,
0.41584745049476624,
-0.19256797432899475,
0.4961569011211395,
0.08717072010040283,
0.5723617076873779,
-0.6555886268615723,
0.061442840844392776,
-0.6562296152114868,
-0.3470880091190338,
-1.1701228618621826,
-0.33431220054626465,
0.46143022179603577,
-0.3064654767513275,
-0.35427170991897583,
-0.2388925701379776,
-0.23271134495735168,
0.4013358950614929,
0.3551021218299866,
-0.28839683532714844,
0.20308750867843628,
-0.10535813868045807,
0.4356336295604706,
-0.36519429087638855,
-0.477613627910614,
-0.7832951545715332,
0.8715385794639587,
0.34410834312438965,
1.0550256967544556,
0.5383328795433044,
0.7398703098297119,
0.2831081449985504,
0.38104403018951416,
-0.5311560034751892,
0.43546855449676514,
-0.01908029243350029,
-0.9585088491439819,
-0.06570801883935928,
-0.3003619313240051,
-1.0025283098220825,
0.8336594700813293,
0.02688606269657612,
-0.9470877647399902,
0.43274617195129395,
-0.006845482625067234,
-0.0634661540389061,
0.43575751781463623,
-0.9269391298294067,
0.750362753868103,
0.09380172193050385,
-0.41806843876838684,
0.06413901597261429,
-0.647393524646759,
0.6876128315925598,
-0.1147274598479271,
0.35466277599334717,
-0.4050740897655487,
-0.11829694360494614,
0.5229942798614502,
-0.3990418612957001,
1.2409499883651733,
0.013852386735379696,
-0.12394420057535172,
0.5049166083335876,
0.2033049315214157,
0.5756900310516357,
0.10445864498615265,
-0.04471836984157562,
0.4005982577800751,
0.10970879346132278,
-0.7761781811714172,
-0.13711939752101898,
0.842019259929657,
-1.0616109371185303,
-0.4804758131504059,
-0.38666486740112305,
-0.13505816459655762,
0.02258273772895336,
0.3280414342880249,
0.5871375203132629,
0.25740480422973633,
-0.46316152811050415,
0.19445809721946716,
0.6765947341918945,
-0.18950530886650085,
0.736806333065033,
0.5292118191719055,
-0.07582049071788788,
-0.21151798963546753,
0.7073190808296204,
0.5515881776809692,
0.6727671027183533,
0.04781264066696167,
0.31089937686920166,
-0.2740805745124817,
0.10707644373178482,
-0.5482418537139893,
0.16928526759147644,
-0.7511985898017883,
0.34635990858078003,
-0.7685686349868774,
0.11295837163925171,
-0.424683153629303,
-0.24841517210006714,
-0.5339204668998718,
-0.30378004908561707,
0.12614348530769348,
0.21958257257938385,
-0.12609678506851196,
0.7270017266273499,
0.11917873471975327,
0.5100172162055969,
-0.5377007722854614,
0.006921782158315182,
0.18557310104370117,
0.12584072351455688,
-0.3678208589553833,
-0.435359925031662,
-0.14223267138004303,
0.06716655194759369,
-0.35440948605537415,
-1.1896727085113525,
0.3130964934825897,
0.035407111048698425,
0.6149755716323853,
0.4529622197151184,
0.21789826452732086,
0.48289549350738525,
-0.49725812673568726,
0.9697973728179932,
-0.1868942379951477,
-1.081731915473938,
0.030466441065073013,
-0.4288778007030487,
0.4139006733894348,
0.48646441102027893,
0.09173231571912766,
-0.9120321273803711,
-0.636966347694397,
-0.7376660108566284,
-0.7585118412971497,
0.5293123126029968,
0.1331433653831482,
0.6059527397155762,
-0.0845491960644722,
-0.0025628115981817245,
0.37369775772094727,
0.2410900890827179,
-1.142339825630188,
-0.4593967795372009,
-0.1634230613708496,
0.09022053331136703,
-0.13468798995018005,
-0.11883259564638138,
-0.038202252238988876,
0.10251131653785706,
0.8609643578529358,
-0.4931783378124237,
0.13146352767944336,
0.09113477915525436,
0.18516434729099274,
-0.3429645895957947,
0.43711113929748535,
0.5997107625007629,
0.8085173964500427,
0.331242173910141,
0.08946694433689117,
0.0004071934672538191,
-0.45678839087486267,
0.31266728043556213,
-0.37562859058380127,
-0.2436046004295349,
0.14670994877815247,
0.31729423999786377,
0.6483891010284424,
-0.32332319021224976,
-0.4912601113319397,
0.5198445916175842,
-0.20541705191135406,
0.0899105966091156,
-0.6849982738494873,
-0.26834917068481445,
-0.04470454901456833,
0.14440995454788208,
0.16596336662769318,
0.12377561628818512,
-0.1887122541666031,
-0.6147445440292358,
-0.3437749147415161,
0.7181911468505859,
-0.6735290288925171,
-0.7873860001564026,
0.520976722240448,
0.06422906368970871,
0.0551903210580349,
0.674477219581604,
-0.22788700461387634,
-0.31952616572380066,
0.31783315539360046,
0.5545621514320374,
1.162152886390686,
-0.4710991680622101,
0.48589861392974854,
0.24241411685943604,
0.7409469485282898,
0.13071279227733612,
0.0530443973839283,
0.09845883399248123,
-0.9887986779212952,
-0.24508897960186005,
-0.21301069855690002,
-0.3851843476295471,
0.046462323516607285,
-0.4715985357761383,
0.2439182847738266,
-0.4000813663005829,
-0.08692619949579239,
-0.3258269131183624,
-0.0627846047282219,
-0.4558953046798706,
-0.15101872384548187,
-0.03254023194313049,
0.4803401529788971,
-1.2398661375045776,
0.7704391479492188,
0.49072641134262085,
-0.3593621850013733,
-0.44197797775268555,
0.45321184396743774,
0.48149535059928894,
-0.635865330696106,
0.4844091534614563,
0.06468616425991058,
0.1879250556230545,
-0.13732312619686127,
-0.5341105461120605,
-0.942659854888916,
0.6008054614067078,
0.41430193185806274,
-0.21420148015022278,
0.2586338222026825,
0.08329460769891739,
0.48489582538604736,
-0.1715492457151413,
0.18743450939655304,
0.18211111426353455,
0.5285594463348389,
-0.16725017130374908,
-0.9931073784828186,
-0.14962483942508698,
-0.24167096614837646,
-0.19396212697029114,
0.26892781257629395,
-1.3661248683929443,
0.9863654971122742,
-0.056936115026474,
-0.251973420381546,
-0.21409258246421814,
0.49477240443229675,
0.05751243233680725,
-0.035492949187755585,
0.27137884497642517,
0.06747729331254959,
0.7651557326316833,
-0.15162135660648346,
0.8973395228385925,
-0.22556999325752258,
0.005178044084459543,
0.9498365521430969,
-0.43804559111595154,
0.35749897360801697,
0.7275869846343994,
-0.04091036692261696,
0.47739720344543457,
0.6674380898475647,
0.36008763313293457,
0.38309919834136963,
0.1118319034576416,
-0.6361582279205322,
-0.26616400480270386,
-0.03490768373012543,
-0.5026556849479675,
0.7910813689231873,
0.3079533576965332,
-0.38610708713531494,
-0.20607370138168335,
-0.3425692617893219,
0.46311503648757935,
0.26745760440826416,
0.01300134602934122,
0.5682429075241089,
0.09439706802368164,
-0.604474663734436,
0.37145331501960754,
0.027532480657100677,
0.5015363097190857,
-0.775692880153656,
0.3215254545211792,
-0.2332455813884735,
0.18134500086307526,
-0.2026647925376892,
-0.589016318321228,
0.09804717451334,
-0.10722239315509796,
-0.15078182518482208,
-0.40048158168792725,
0.242181658744812,
-0.36761474609375,
-0.4346253573894501,
0.003886249614879489,
0.8255060315132141,
0.15260770916938782,
-0.034254834055900574,
-0.5709505081176758,
0.032047878950834274,
0.2599605917930603,
-0.29777824878692627,
0.4067293107509613,
0.47839879989624023,
-0.6467005610466003,
0.802372395992279,
0.45450541377067566,
-0.16874749958515167,
0.18332044780254364,
-0.12710286676883698,
0.693333089351654,
-0.5028702020645142,
-0.4252552092075348,
-1.2864798307418823,
0.5332343578338623,
0.0909663587808609,
-0.5304338335990906,
0.9552639722824097,
0.6945427060127258,
0.9673441052436829,
-0.10903891921043396,
1.1238861083984375,
-0.14899496734142303,
0.40523838996887207,
-0.2392304241657257,
0.81919264793396,
-0.1769392192363739,
0.10043716430664062,
-0.5750772953033447,
-0.8607512712478638,
0.07491849362850189,
0.3883781433105469,
-0.47740864753723145,
0.32187962532043457,
0.5007365345954895,
0.7625684142112732,
0.06730107963085175,
0.11925524473190308,
0.41581156849861145,
0.3617081642150879,
0.8031098246574402,
0.11541301757097244,
1.050244927406311,
-0.0502069890499115,
0.10078132152557373,
-0.2937376797199249,
-0.2736464738845825,
0.13296467065811157,
-0.547452449798584,
-1.0030691623687744,
-0.7814390659332275,
-0.5237493515014648,
-0.5624895095825195,
-0.33999910950660706,
1.0614218711853027,
0.554483950138092,
-0.6777843832969666,
-0.4470314383506775,
0.3781609833240509,
0.29579347372055054,
0.06847379356622696,
-0.25801607966423035,
-0.002149424748495221,
-0.3228505849838257,
-0.9447493553161621,
0.19548361003398895,
0.3480503559112549,
0.12646278738975525,
-0.5872901678085327,
-0.020997105166316032,
-0.0727272480726242,
0.26917725801467896,
0.6043466925621033,
0.42425408959388733,
-0.8112021684646606,
-0.46507060527801514,
-0.05320975184440613,
-0.045696426182985306,
0.09361021965742111,
0.628147542476654,
-0.5855146646499634,
0.6340193152427673,
0.514346718788147,
0.13837933540344238,
0.04206600785255432,
0.11652398854494095,
0.5772995948791504,
-0.47200527787208557,
0.3926668167114258,
0.1364857405424118,
0.3635047376155853,
0.40760281682014465,
-0.24401602149009705,
0.48970678448677063,
0.4278527796268463,
-0.7494680881500244,
-0.8625702857971191,
0.493428498506546,
-0.397756963968277,
-0.02129955217242241,
1.2340656518936157,
-0.09092205762863159,
0.01422828622162342,
-0.3877003490924835,
-0.26486605405807495,
-0.05465133860707283,
-0.33741530776023865,
0.8986579179763794,
0.8626232743263245,
-0.2690141797065735,
0.10142101347446442,
-0.7125095725059509,
0.35501962900161743,
0.3809630572795868,
-0.6552233695983887,
0.1035674586892128,
0.4401887059211731,
0.37269359827041626,
0.09374295920133591,
0.7498053312301636,
-0.26773524284362793,
-0.1335163563489914,
-0.09799551963806152,
0.0006844537565484643,
0.6851221919059753,
0.2435547411441803,
-0.2859604060649872,
0.009919627569615841,
0.20917189121246338,
-0.09596363455057144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10430v1 | Smaller Language Models are capable of selecting Instruction-Tuning Training Data for Larger Language Models | 2024-02-16T03:39:37 | 2024-02-16T03:39:37 | Dheeraj Mekala, Alex Nguyen, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuning language models has become a crucial step in aligning them
for general use. Typically, this process involves extensive training on large
datasets, incurring high training costs. In this paper, we introduce a novel
training data selection based on the learning percentage of the samples. We
assert that current language models possess the capability to autonomously
select high-quality training data, leading to comparable or improved
performance compared to training on the entire dataset. Our experiments span
different-sized models, revealing that this characteristic holds for models
ranging from 1B (small) to 13B (large) in size. Moreover, we demonstrate an
interesting finding that the data hardness transfers across model sizes, and a
smaller 350M model can effectively curate high-quality training data with hard
samples for a larger 13B model, resulting in an equally or superior
instruction-tuned model compared to training on the complete dataset. Utilizing
open-sourced OPT and Llama-2 models up to 13B in size, two publicly available
instruction-tuning training datasets and evaluated by both automatic metrics &
humans, our paper introduces a novel approach to training data selection,
showcasing a more efficient alternative. | [
-0.284323126077652,
-0.5312497615814209,
0.40351203083992004,
-0.11888028681278229,
-0.08548645675182343,
-0.050977710634469986,
-0.6357466578483582,
-0.2231162190437317,
-0.04951781779527664,
0.39731380343437195,
-0.5367912650108337,
-0.39126887917518616,
-0.43843168020248413,
-0.09765689820051193,
-0.34586799144744873,
0.8210672736167908,
0.20933260023593903,
0.31884655356407166,
-0.23659084737300873,
-0.044071976095438004,
-0.45481714606285095,
-0.19358085095882416,
-0.7730031609535217,
-0.3016078472137451,
0.41927921772003174,
0.7840090394020081,
0.519681453704834,
1.3034610748291016,
0.5771691799163818,
0.2273997664451599,
0.21187852323055267,
0.27331772446632385,
-0.5356769561767578,
-0.12941214442253113,
0.0007285880274139345,
-0.8312816023826599,
-0.4847380518913269,
0.09485094994306564,
0.5990591049194336,
0.840001106262207,
-0.18930579721927643,
0.476307213306427,
-0.12086454033851624,
1.0048426389694214,
-0.6452535390853882,
0.09698890149593353,
-0.8781575560569763,
0.025420982390642166,
-0.12525716423988342,
0.13952794671058655,
-0.643642246723175,
-0.39336463809013367,
-0.20512419939041138,
-0.5225654244422913,
0.43186795711517334,
0.1957331895828247,
0.5858734250068665,
0.4561825096607208,
-0.19901882112026215,
-0.1779690533876419,
-0.5077943205833435,
0.9196782112121582,
-0.532765805721283,
0.4733662009239197,
0.6537187099456787,
0.34707188606262207,
0.3170677125453949,
-0.32047218084335327,
-0.20514392852783203,
-0.3006402254104614,
0.116112619638443,
-0.23401208221912384,
0.06552957743406296,
-0.05828944221138954,
0.22144532203674316,
0.45418280363082886,
-0.606285572052002,
0.6065256595611572,
-0.39463114738464355,
-0.0829710066318512,
0.6673238277435303,
0.11485480517148972,
0.11610624939203262,
0.21119892597198486,
0.026366792619228363,
-0.39311766624450684,
-1.0088393688201904,
-0.06977706402540207,
0.5572671294212341,
0.6633858680725098,
-0.16637606918811798,
0.5096082091331482,
-0.4175344705581665,
1.0111433267593384,
0.12405479699373245,
-0.26584678888320923,
0.11829657107591629,
-0.18931661546230316,
-0.19927749037742615,
0.04086738079786301,
0.6915706992149353,
0.05770678073167801,
0.36526936292648315,
-0.11650997400283813,
-0.28464895486831665,
-0.17201459407806396,
0.1830463707447052,
-0.8947590589523315,
-0.66275954246521,
-0.17948707938194275,
-0.2956203520298004,
-0.2298842817544937,
-0.04806513711810112,
-0.6419651508331299,
-0.2200930416584015,
-0.6039307117462158,
0.21614158153533936,
-0.31294989585876465,
-0.007226959802210331,
0.10385920107364655,
0.19273249804973602,
0.06101608648896217,
0.1446027308702469,
-1.3642051219940186,
0.13991838693618774,
0.7239950299263,
0.7396130561828613,
-0.26906245946884155,
-0.09850773215293884,
-0.6037268042564392,
-0.13122297823429108,
-0.771202802658081,
0.6210818886756897,
-0.8575130105018616,
-0.2026345431804657,
-0.24973171949386597,
-0.01976528950035572,
-0.227552592754364,
-0.6372035145759583,
0.1871699094772339,
-0.49352070689201355,
-0.001415333477780223,
-0.0783340260386467,
-0.4826703369617462,
0.07625394314527512,
-0.12231594324111938,
-0.8842664361000061,
1.0422778129577637,
0.3671889901161194,
-0.45514538884162903,
0.5860912799835205,
-0.1626790314912796,
-0.4683257043361664,
-0.15979963541030884,
-0.15726572275161743,
-0.6791754961013794,
0.2741297781467438,
0.34987038373947144,
0.35605037212371826,
-0.45430848002433777,
-0.17142193019390106,
-0.38045522570610046,
-0.47313234210014343,
0.08196523040533066,
-0.49089381098747253,
0.5569329857826233,
0.20592457056045532,
-0.15779536962509155,
-0.12134679406881332,
-0.8154280185699463,
0.2673535645008087,
0.00857832282781601,
-0.6575600504875183,
-0.3253895044326782,
-0.1361711174249649,
-0.505351722240448,
0.013988533057272434,
0.43186014890670776,
-0.4773949980735779,
0.4021112322807312,
-0.44177377223968506,
0.26457449793815613,
0.757320761680603,
-0.27632033824920654,
0.7919252514839172,
-0.3312738239765167,
0.6128180027008057,
-0.317285418510437,
0.21122658252716064,
0.1346776783466339,
-0.1849367916584015,
-1.0910115242004395,
-0.3397083580493927,
0.7369340062141418,
0.4250251352787018,
-0.6254624128341675,
0.5051613450050354,
-0.5823811888694763,
-0.5454812049865723,
-1.0864169597625732,
0.6379327178001404,
0.4244653284549713,
0.3241231441497803,
0.27761632204055786,
-0.1163797453045845,
-0.3340982496738434,
-0.9166257977485657,
0.15164868533611298,
-0.0890423059463501,
-0.138525128364563,
0.4673846662044525,
0.17633582651615143,
0.29613834619522095,
0.8708670735359192,
-0.5480058193206787,
-0.17920346558094025,
-0.3538302481174469,
-0.088229238986969,
0.1810520440340042,
0.46821191906929016,
0.5544043779373169,
-0.4586767256259918,
-0.7417601346969604,
0.268490195274353,
-0.3031669557094574,
0.029667053371667862,
0.07818356156349182,
-0.2883591949939728,
0.1597031056880951,
0.5623788833618164,
-0.267379492521286,
0.10155550390481949,
0.6141191124916077,
0.03356277942657471,
0.16935434937477112,
-0.33289244771003723,
-0.019927872344851494,
-0.8272367715835571,
-0.10059241205453873,
-0.007007477339357138,
-0.24925421178340912,
-0.17891332507133484,
-0.13626056909561157,
0.4969181418418884,
0.1104973554611206,
-0.30054330825805664,
0.38319575786590576,
-0.5298258662223816,
0.03858119994401932,
-0.27992841601371765,
-0.2714208662509918,
-0.17558856308460236,
0.5638099908828735,
0.07409211993217468,
1.033071517944336,
0.5527490973472595,
-0.5209081768989563,
0.3602708578109741,
0.25697290897369385,
-0.8292022943496704,
0.3056495487689972,
-0.44621503353118896,
0.4805745780467987,
0.09115442633628845,
-0.04642143473029137,
-0.5811517834663391,
-0.35490357875823975,
-0.23587411642074585,
-0.290487140417099,
0.42626041173934937,
-0.6184831857681274,
-0.4394201636314392,
-0.22139482200145721,
-0.2240224927663803,
0.2068912833929062,
0.69090735912323,
-0.6545698642730713,
0.13015390932559967,
0.38423359394073486,
-0.3348447382450104,
-0.5084349513053894,
-0.543476939201355,
-0.2751070261001587,
-0.2786352336406708,
-0.2545405626296997,
0.05153965950012207,
-0.08036662638187408,
-0.013187327422201633,
-0.19395962357521057,
-0.10826887935400009,
-0.1217227429151535,
0.11891643702983856,
0.07661280781030655,
0.44055411219596863,
-0.5539150238037109,
0.2486019730567932,
0.3024517893791199,
-0.07492852210998535,
-0.22261419892311096,
-0.31088337302207947,
0.4423633813858032,
0.10152911394834518,
-0.42010176181793213,
-0.2584204375743866,
0.011280613020062447,
0.1740790754556656,
-0.35960453748703003,
0.8698075413703918,
0.33396077156066895,
-0.025615844875574112,
-0.7637457251548767,
-0.4332948625087738,
-0.402109831571579,
-0.5101453065872192,
0.6018660664558411,
-0.20518937706947327,
-0.7348603010177612,
-0.16408023238182068,
0.1637955754995346,
0.04761333018541336,
0.09699606895446777,
0.5100295543670654,
0.06620635837316513,
1.3576303720474243,
0.8491796851158142,
-0.5035325288772583,
0.7329739332199097,
-0.20743036270141602,
0.07196592539548874,
-0.6250369548797607,
-0.016407102346420288,
-0.795893669128418,
-0.33224543929100037,
-0.5114052891731262,
-0.3650055527687073,
0.3137841820716858,
-0.10646519064903259,
-0.39724770188331604,
0.2681857943534851,
-0.5410505533218384,
0.8833766579627991,
0.6388596296310425,
0.21584725379943848,
0.18070296943187714,
0.3411540985107422,
0.24404285848140717,
0.01875671185553074,
-0.6850433349609375,
-0.43214699625968933,
1.4349082708358765,
0.1790270060300827,
0.9677296876907349,
0.04100921377539635,
0.40707141160964966,
0.15098603069782257,
0.2902580499649048,
-0.8190118670463562,
0.44743821024894714,
-0.732697606086731,
-0.5870557427406311,
-0.46202728152275085,
-0.7268535494804382,
-0.9809983968734741,
0.030037954449653625,
-0.10534743964672089,
-0.5832170844078064,
0.05021268501877785,
0.2666935920715332,
-0.3648889362812042,
0.2727993428707123,
-0.9396814703941345,
0.652362585067749,
-0.2948839068412781,
-0.049873340874910355,
-0.2527152895927429,
-0.39226797223091125,
0.14186923205852509,
-0.28189343214035034,
0.12133970856666565,
-0.37029439210891724,
-0.023198788985610008,
0.7102642059326172,
-0.2243717610836029,
0.7072131633758545,
-0.1903998851776123,
-0.14672020077705383,
0.08840131014585495,
0.23002532124519348,
0.37234941124916077,
-0.09814176708459854,
-0.2665691375732422,
-0.04005039483308792,
-0.2603791654109955,
-0.42304855585098267,
-0.6270496845245361,
0.6556766629219055,
-0.8659014701843262,
-0.4325906038284302,
0.1801714301109314,
-0.512595534324646,
-0.5502361059188843,
-0.03129032254219055,
0.26949450373649597,
0.3974517583847046,
0.1684429943561554,
0.691728413105011,
0.7373812198638916,
-0.05331903323531151,
0.24183480441570282,
0.6226438879966736,
0.1254500448703766,
-0.19694028794765472,
1.4314801692962646,
0.12325821816921234,
0.5175883769989014,
0.4972952902317047,
0.11508021503686905,
-0.170403853058815,
-0.7112622261047363,
-0.584232747554779,
0.21407905220985413,
-0.4892951250076294,
-0.4345008134841919,
-0.20867714285850525,
-0.24671988189220428,
-0.1975640058517456,
-0.029647905379533768,
-0.6661330461502075,
-0.4561484456062317,
-0.24550822377204895,
-0.2387632429599762,
0.4191015660762787,
0.4712088704109192,
0.0050320373848080635,
0.512676477432251,
-0.44164592027664185,
0.16856494545936584,
0.539858877658844,
0.4063745141029358,
-0.04298640787601471,
-0.8240845799446106,
-0.5098702907562256,
0.2830122709274292,
-0.012217477895319462,
-0.33477237820625305,
0.37044379115104675,
0.6142511963844299,
0.36044150590896606,
0.2731359601020813,
-0.05590049549937248,
0.40474727749824524,
-0.5264193415641785,
0.4301767349243164,
-0.011385457590222359,
-0.5828185677528381,
0.6684805750846863,
-0.1523488461971283,
0.07250148057937622,
0.9222614169120789,
0.366732120513916,
-0.11273834109306335,
-0.12063483893871307,
-0.3047613501548767,
-0.7259069085121155,
1.0242737531661987,
-0.17748256027698517,
0.2668030560016632,
0.2564976215362549,
0.2915787994861603,
0.3743540048599243,
0.15400071442127228,
-0.4862026572227478,
-0.11304149031639099,
0.146603524684906,
-0.6553308367729187,
-0.1333649754524231,
0.11716047674417496,
-0.12119534611701965,
-0.3675853908061981,
0.8416391611099243,
-0.41238465905189514,
0.08413749933242798,
-0.5633260011672974,
-0.24701359868049622,
-0.11909739673137665,
0.17179512977600098,
-0.04939626157283783,
0.6199211478233337,
-0.12542535364627838,
-0.04881209880113602,
0.1853538304567337,
-0.5994663238525391,
0.2780228853225708,
-0.05911916866898537,
-0.3018518090248108,
-0.32163065671920776,
0.24971167743206024,
1.0970185995101929,
0.21764205396175385,
-0.6471445560455322,
0.5601793527603149,
-0.07357173413038254,
-0.08530101180076599,
0.046910177916288376,
0.8187075853347778,
-0.10127896815538406,
0.06526090204715729,
0.12066123634576797,
-0.24623174965381622,
-0.2610418200492859,
-0.31388965249061584,
0.02748011238873005,
0.3696427345275879,
-0.4574897885322571,
-0.23748959600925446,
0.43747439980506897,
0.05753994360566139,
-0.3130634129047394,
1.0181233882904053,
-0.14509610831737518,
0.054120536893606186,
0.7711952328681946,
0.3680831789970398,
0.35835492610931396,
-0.14084960520267487,
0.4453781843185425,
0.44063612818717957,
0.2487514764070511,
-0.3258459270000458,
0.016465002670884132,
-0.04572094604372978,
-0.7098773717880249,
-0.6293989419937134,
-0.8574481010437012,
-0.37341219186782837,
0.3075163662433624,
-0.9975115656852722,
0.31567618250846863,
-0.41923218965530396,
-0.009520010091364384,
-0.04582195356488228,
0.1750543862581253,
-0.7323610186576843,
0.34898531436920166,
0.30653026700019836,
0.904335618019104,
-0.8968027830123901,
1.2139924764633179,
0.5017849802970886,
-0.12155929952859879,
-0.9966185092926025,
-0.12310831248760223,
-0.18358616530895233,
-1.041536808013916,
0.41686326265335083,
0.013684834353625774,
0.12836162745952606,
0.19053591787815094,
-0.7502983212471008,
-0.9067320227622986,
0.8768006563186646,
0.8826949596405029,
-0.7599939703941345,
-0.07741135358810425,
0.12187285721302032,
0.4638836681842804,
-0.40509065985679626,
0.03420315682888031,
1.0600390434265137,
0.09929617494344711,
0.0317934975028038,
-0.7931836843490601,
-0.22515657544136047,
-0.12051453441381454,
-0.10046028345823288,
0.23840099573135376,
-0.7966521978378296,
0.833215057849884,
-0.1618407964706421,
0.06739269942045212,
0.1563933789730072,
0.6729549169540405,
0.2671908438205719,
-0.06738527119159698,
0.5546218752861023,
0.4156806766986847,
0.7938399910926819,
-0.10918505489826202,
0.9426184892654419,
-0.26923468708992004,
0.28228169679641724,
1.1567974090576172,
-0.06477054208517075,
1.0142111778259277,
0.10853280872106552,
-0.4281717538833618,
0.3974975049495697,
0.6907601356506348,
-0.1163293644785881,
0.6847115159034729,
0.02114826999604702,
-0.049473490566015244,
-0.5775325298309326,
0.056201785802841187,
-0.21787403523921967,
0.6263210773468018,
0.30237939953804016,
-0.1584886759519577,
0.11777909845113754,
-0.16170835494995117,
-0.0804658830165863,
-0.028376085683703423,
-0.3410867750644684,
0.8873922228813171,
-0.007806222885847092,
-0.724421501159668,
0.6632764339447021,
0.04871226102113724,
0.5277053713798523,
-0.6808635592460632,
0.11879059672355652,
-0.4191475212574005,
0.06804117560386658,
0.01813354901969433,
-0.48304030299186707,
-0.13791199028491974,
0.1949586719274521,
-0.10838504135608673,
-0.15909723937511444,
0.31507986783981323,
-0.5422731637954712,
-0.6282185912132263,
-0.1303754597902298,
0.3655146360397339,
0.08793183416128159,
-0.020439043641090393,
-0.4856441020965576,
-0.09266839176416397,
0.1919434368610382,
-0.24043220281600952,
0.6670833230018616,
0.36263078451156616,
0.00625140406191349,
0.6967235803604126,
0.593762993812561,
0.5651050209999084,
0.10991766303777695,
0.024050109088420868,
0.6282027363777161,
-0.3887604773044586,
-0.578346312046051,
-0.5848554372787476,
0.2306644767522812,
-0.20933669805526733,
-0.34458839893341064,
0.43565553426742554,
0.6218479871749878,
1.0025166273117065,
-0.06553398817777634,
0.8254150152206421,
0.013109836727380753,
0.702846884727478,
-0.7490997910499573,
0.5880976319313049,
-0.4729648530483246,
0.20641255378723145,
0.3146979510784149,
-0.8670268654823303,
0.19746950268745422,
0.7702034115791321,
-0.5881860852241516,
0.11328011751174927,
0.37249013781547546,
0.9584065675735474,
-0.3163275420665741,
0.000015136774891288951,
0.24087518453598022,
-0.02055284194648266,
0.08579369634389877,
0.6906986236572266,
0.5626637935638428,
-0.027469636872410774,
0.5404663681983948,
-0.4889243245124817,
-0.23817019164562225,
-0.2698958218097687,
-0.560973584651947,
-0.976003110408783,
-0.5195475816726685,
-0.24774447083473206,
0.11299052089452744,
-0.10051090270280838,
0.9156299829483032,
1.1108540296554565,
-0.8549573421478271,
-0.13318094611167908,
0.14205604791641235,
0.03090120479464531,
-0.17436018586158752,
-0.13085681200027466,
0.49764955043792725,
-0.377858430147171,
-0.8605190515518188,
0.6415764093399048,
-0.04511282593011856,
0.07249924540519714,
-0.15790913999080658,
0.006697316188365221,
0.20332378149032593,
0.08586399257183075,
0.2341308742761612,
0.3004474937915802,
-0.20096389949321747,
-0.24948115646839142,
-0.11573167890310287,
-0.30077075958251953,
0.16366326808929443,
0.7952013611793518,
-0.6223059892654419,
0.23445481061935425,
0.13128942251205444,
0.943007230758667,
0.5783630609512329,
-0.07141997665166855,
0.4920703172683716,
-1.188330888748169,
0.3127560317516327,
0.0968586653470993,
0.12586410343647003,
0.5387866497039795,
-0.3518414795398712,
0.6216825842857361,
-0.16045881807804108,
-0.4496621787548065,
-0.934502363204956,
0.10149452090263367,
-0.5776904225349426,
-0.25988924503326416,
1.1687636375427246,
0.020707789808511734,
-0.23184311389923096,
0.34926167130470276,
-0.08457585424184799,
0.07909727096557617,
-0.3067017197608948,
0.9127064347267151,
0.5786125659942627,
-0.004439269192516804,
-0.037710659205913544,
-0.7777905464172363,
0.5616329312324524,
0.44611600041389465,
-0.8271328806877136,
0.17539331316947937,
0.4483394920825958,
0.33074983954429626,
-0.336555153131485,
0.23887288570404053,
0.1917172372341156,
0.1934889853000641,
-0.011307137086987495,
-0.2149507701396942,
-0.16535180807113647,
-0.5955765843391418,
-0.23504537343978882,
0.08608239889144897,
0.2728908360004425,
-0.23557475209236145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10427v1 | Evaluating and Improving Continual Learning in Spoken Language Understanding | 2024-02-16T03:30:27 | 2024-02-16T03:30:27 | Muqiao Yang, Xiang Li, Umberto Cappellazzo, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Continual learning has emerged as an increasingly important challenge across
various tasks, including Spoken Language Understanding (SLU). In SLU, its
objective is to effectively handle the emergence of new concepts and evolving
environments. The evaluation of continual learning algorithms typically
involves assessing the model's stability, plasticity, and generalizability as
fundamental aspects of standards. However, existing continual learning metrics
primarily focus on only one or two of the properties. They neglect the overall
performance across all tasks, and do not adequately disentangle the plasticity
versus stability/generalizability trade-offs within the model. In this work, we
propose an evaluation methodology that provides a unified evaluation on
stability, plasticity, and generalizability in continual learning. By employing
the proposed metric, we demonstrate how introducing various knowledge
distillations can improve different aspects of these three properties of the
SLU model. We further show that our proposed metric is more sensitive in
capturing the impact of task ordering in continual learning, making it better
suited for practical use-case scenarios. | [
-0.054557833820581436,
-0.78321373462677,
0.599725067615509,
0.28392913937568665,
-0.3305138647556305,
0.24018457531929016,
-0.5894715189933777,
-0.32836654782295227,
-0.14653050899505615,
0.16140660643577576,
-0.32583189010620117,
-0.3417155146598816,
-0.6496301293373108,
-0.13627181947231293,
-0.1681181937456131,
1.0785990953445435,
0.18608525395393372,
0.09259933978319168,
-0.4460786283016205,
-0.44398069381713867,
-0.9283671379089355,
-0.3212183713912964,
-0.8270737528800964,
-0.7730340957641602,
0.5018558502197266,
0.3219338059425354,
0.5192768573760986,
0.2497960329055786,
0.21640266478061676,
0.3880656957626343,
-0.31078311800956726,
-0.08080633729696274,
-0.5883300304412842,
0.19054259359836578,
-0.2062777727842331,
-0.3524497151374817,
-0.26037681102752686,
0.049708958715200424,
0.8776105046272278,
1.12108314037323,
-0.4924868643283844,
0.20957186818122864,
0.6622189879417419,
0.6759816408157349,
-0.40978509187698364,
0.2675846219062805,
-0.8128495216369629,
-0.1896003931760788,
0.12288213521242142,
0.04583508148789406,
-0.32152074575424194,
-0.3223292827606201,
0.5936406254768372,
-0.49194005131721497,
0.017444897443056107,
-0.37923935055732727,
0.8975687623023987,
0.4072857201099396,
0.10086987912654877,
-0.39934825897216797,
-0.9678164124488831,
0.8311964273452759,
-0.6303985118865967,
0.5652269124984741,
0.17053788900375366,
0.3273930847644806,
0.1317453682422638,
-0.7092568278312683,
-0.4915376603603363,
-0.599326491355896,
0.11407455056905746,
0.3645833432674408,
-0.19921322166919708,
0.12733983993530273,
-0.26301953196525574,
0.35515087842941284,
-0.59294593334198,
0.1576823890209198,
-0.34276729822158813,
-0.18642131984233856,
0.37206459045410156,
-0.02661498822271824,
0.37849584221839905,
0.29445284605026245,
-0.2620985507965088,
0.1598273515701294,
-0.2880406379699707,
0.0046181450597941875,
0.0025936602614820004,
0.14140166342258453,
-0.09910345822572708,
-0.011128369718790054,
0.06242552027106285,
0.6152039766311646,
0.07760782539844513,
-0.41729557514190674,
0.39175188541412354,
-0.3029392659664154,
-0.1353079229593277,
-0.2628256380558014,
0.3389729857444763,
0.20024892687797546,
0.21014204621315002,
-0.7717458009719849,
-0.2121283859014511,
0.03957204148173332,
0.5584512948989868,
-0.1793176233768463,
-0.08455057442188263,
0.2386857122182846,
-0.33680668473243713,
-0.08467400074005127,
0.16876940429210663,
-0.38987499475479126,
0.014881986193358898,
-0.7543782591819763,
0.35047000646591187,
-0.5202491283416748,
-0.5249137282371521,
0.1136506125330925,
-0.22957128286361694,
0.04648864269256592,
0.28023281693458557,
-0.9420158863067627,
0.5021598935127258,
0.9112638831138611,
1.0225986242294312,
-0.49892470240592957,
-0.5119069218635559,
-0.4757293462753296,
0.14813829958438873,
-0.15556173026561737,
0.544194757938385,
-0.521037220954895,
-0.3425137996673584,
-0.14870646595954895,
-0.18629467487335205,
-0.37716323137283325,
-0.7754555940628052,
0.2704825699329376,
-0.20558297634124756,
0.12453696876764297,
0.06091564521193504,
-0.4606125056743622,
-0.3506310284137726,
0.19879762828350067,
-0.35375794768333435,
0.9594411849975586,
0.1670377254486084,
-0.30335018038749695,
0.710675835609436,
-0.6038289070129395,
-0.13506647944450378,
0.4110526144504547,
-0.03592637926340103,
-0.4429273307323456,
0.37351131439208984,
-0.3125719726085663,
0.34722843766212463,
0.19615809619426727,
0.6382032632827759,
-0.18628302216529846,
-0.3803173005580902,
0.17365773022174835,
-0.5196807384490967,
0.41544321179389954,
0.07102777808904648,
-0.4727696180343628,
0.07189309597015381,
-0.6877906918525696,
-0.029176518321037292,
-0.06225943937897682,
-0.5156684517860413,
-0.4205261170864105,
0.23275959491729736,
-0.1893150955438614,
-0.15430064499378204,
0.2741180956363678,
-0.4212619960308075,
0.08443716913461685,
-0.5695338249206543,
0.49060216546058655,
0.7805507183074951,
0.16685684025287628,
0.4560239017009735,
-0.29061952233314514,
0.31938546895980835,
0.04590168222784996,
0.3523859977722168,
0.390529602766037,
-0.28545376658439636,
-0.9811692237854004,
0.12541066110134125,
0.11711771041154861,
0.5570699572563171,
-0.6142151951789856,
0.22083322703838348,
-0.45910006761550903,
-0.49975669384002686,
-0.23967760801315308,
0.6586789488792419,
0.724245011806488,
0.30937647819519043,
0.3685557246208191,
-0.6701589226722717,
-0.20592474937438965,
-0.30698052048683167,
-0.006971749942749739,
-0.3931851387023926,
-0.07550958544015884,
0.2638048231601715,
0.3914159834384918,
-0.45064449310302734,
0.8172911405563354,
-0.19099855422973633,
-0.013647249899804592,
-0.4438226521015167,
0.4346249997615814,
0.30483007431030273,
0.47921517491340637,
0.5729794502258301,
-0.5444607138633728,
-0.3126974105834961,
0.36225757002830505,
-0.7316571474075317,
0.06930139660835266,
-0.3594580888748169,
0.11601880192756653,
0.1684405356645584,
0.1610984057188034,
-0.3461363911628723,
0.1719135046005249,
0.5059038400650024,
-0.10879054665565491,
0.8971147537231445,
-0.3823545575141907,
-0.06497447192668915,
-0.488253653049469,
0.03139941766858101,
0.06407603621482849,
-0.1678721010684967,
-0.9682871699333191,
0.03232321888208389,
-0.15578636527061462,
0.0010921373032033443,
-0.4033900201320648,
0.3844633400440216,
-0.3765796422958374,
0.050782687962055206,
-0.08373649418354034,
0.5493611097335815,
-0.1318245530128479,
0.3835242688655853,
-0.00044004840310662985,
0.6535893678665161,
0.4850172698497772,
-1.0100535154342651,
0.2795813977718353,
-0.18504036962985992,
-0.309043824672699,
0.6157036423683167,
-0.8450762629508972,
0.4964279532432556,
-0.18929363787174225,
-0.10463099926710129,
-0.7791833877563477,
0.18907848000526428,
0.15367195010185242,
-0.5925865769386292,
0.6228142380714417,
-0.20195744931697845,
-0.07424886524677277,
-0.3361360728740692,
0.22485452890396118,
0.04599183425307274,
0.3415762782096863,
-0.3473949134349823,
0.5966008305549622,
0.4169178009033203,
-0.26724696159362793,
-0.5962153673171997,
-0.3776628077030182,
0.03725401684641838,
-0.3815070390701294,
-0.4075300693511963,
0.26683753728866577,
-0.3427830636501312,
-0.58014315366745,
-0.14642304182052612,
-0.5336706638336182,
-0.22805364429950714,
0.2821681499481201,
0.20851241052150726,
0.2365371286869049,
-0.08301295340061188,
0.4161890745162964,
-0.05285508185625076,
-0.34569084644317627,
0.027010781690478325,
-0.6289196610450745,
0.5700421333312988,
-0.43337905406951904,
-0.025246862322092056,
-0.5714356899261475,
-0.056253354996442795,
0.5896239876747131,
-0.005944945849478245,
0.6664001941680908,
0.5363497734069824,
-0.10889259725809097,
-0.17580875754356384,
-0.8157597184181213,
0.12111380696296692,
-0.5068628191947937,
0.31308218836784363,
-0.31329435110092163,
-0.8864721655845642,
0.37457147240638733,
-0.1004757285118103,
0.36078280210494995,
0.33432796597480774,
0.4472740590572357,
-0.4995362162590027,
0.5315977931022644,
0.7786595821380615,
-0.4231518805027008,
0.34727370738983154,
-0.23962584137916565,
-0.09738131612539291,
-0.5469509363174438,
-0.4153200685977936,
-0.49644628167152405,
-0.05433516576886177,
-0.05520857125520706,
-0.14579962193965912,
0.2675483226776123,
0.2446831613779068,
0.049056634306907654,
0.33527109026908875,
-0.5114477276802063,
0.33172351121902466,
0.09978587180376053,
0.17616498470306396,
0.22644570469856262,
-0.09558507055044174,
-0.191715806722641,
0.059956323355436325,
-0.569538950920105,
-0.5268783569335938,
0.735363781452179,
0.5311559438705444,
0.47151339054107666,
0.21622250974178314,
0.7758758068084717,
0.41488903760910034,
0.2064075767993927,
-0.7260358333587646,
0.4251359701156616,
-0.21153411269187927,
0.001629586680792272,
-0.5586075782775879,
-0.67043536901474,
-1.1538668870925903,
0.25570425391197205,
0.17115238308906555,
-0.9308772683143616,
-0.033997271209955215,
0.357441246509552,
-0.15142203867435455,
0.04089658334851265,
-0.8524236083030701,
0.7374037504196167,
-0.4987381398677826,
-0.09678163379430771,
-0.654766321182251,
-0.3368898034095764,
0.0363592766225338,
0.02035624347627163,
0.203606978058815,
-0.09885165840387344,
-0.0024697796907275915,
0.7708661556243896,
-0.21771186590194702,
0.9518393278121948,
-0.4596671760082245,
-0.02034137025475502,
0.22054888308048248,
-0.21558445692062378,
-0.010635397396981716,
0.11137425154447556,
0.02743278257548809,
0.29234039783477783,
0.12789975106716156,
-0.46011099219322205,
-0.8343880772590637,
0.5106377005577087,
-0.7238990068435669,
-0.535834550857544,
-0.26460781693458557,
-0.39114823937416077,
-0.3258119225502014,
0.010730758309364319,
-0.0445251539349556,
0.46431493759155273,
-0.4501347243785858,
0.03922659531235695,
0.833152711391449,
-0.15778769552707672,
0.3845057785511017,
0.6506384015083313,
-0.017791008576750755,
-0.17757490277290344,
1.2225029468536377,
0.23720978200435638,
0.6308990716934204,
0.17406506836414337,
0.4231325685977936,
-0.33133170008659363,
-0.9097856283187866,
-0.16754333674907684,
0.30801331996917725,
-0.637639582157135,
0.1435319483280182,
-0.24496403336524963,
-0.19696162641048431,
-0.33550649881362915,
-0.031708844006061554,
-0.12376541644334793,
-0.15521247684955597,
-0.4873993694782257,
-0.15172883868217468,
0.14033423364162445,
0.9741946458816528,
-0.21773244440555573,
0.23458245396614075,
-0.7023311257362366,
0.1322295218706131,
0.5621709823608398,
0.44770821928977966,
0.14955927431583405,
-0.7952357530593872,
-0.3033275008201599,
0.08011317253112793,
-0.36282235383987427,
-0.7003152370452881,
0.13592560589313507,
0.8051766157150269,
1.0854237079620361,
0.5946675539016724,
-0.34252986311912537,
0.8396186232566833,
-0.4566105008125305,
0.8199509978294373,
0.4415060877799988,
-1.203137755393982,
0.8071898818016052,
-0.11733449250459671,
0.49992749094963074,
0.853523850440979,
0.3880898952484131,
-0.7525842189788818,
-0.6294150352478027,
-0.5795982480049133,
-0.7151867747306824,
0.18644224107265472,
0.10211024433374405,
0.36601266264915466,
0.034404899924993515,
0.5977044701576233,
0.25505146384239197,
0.0009360389085486531,
-0.7643945813179016,
-0.296237051486969,
-0.21677479147911072,
0.06445387750864029,
-0.11709083616733551,
-0.3300996422767639,
0.06932418793439865,
-0.49970197677612305,
0.7646231651306152,
0.09309753775596619,
0.011452369391918182,
-0.22475029528141022,
-0.5870287418365479,
0.4317607879638672,
0.4533695578575134,
0.44550272822380066,
1.1246962547302246,
-0.23094230890274048,
-0.15366613864898682,
0.4518280327320099,
-0.890035092830658,
0.07306438684463501,
-0.24918776750564575,
-0.1373937577009201,
0.1863926649093628,
0.19629447162151337,
0.7243695259094238,
0.49887773394584656,
-0.5642008185386658,
0.0821719616651535,
-0.03349903225898743,
-0.1743110865354538,
-0.38350698351860046,
0.3386823832988739,
-0.06592351198196411,
-0.031749993562698364,
0.3209589123725891,
-0.09200447052717209,
-0.060585927218198776,
-0.730215311050415,
0.48838376998901367,
0.15282200276851654,
-0.7412051558494568,
-0.2520977854728699,
0.10273950546979904,
0.28903594613075256,
-0.2348943054676056,
0.824824333190918,
-0.33356449007987976,
-0.4893011152744293,
0.3767121732234955,
0.49546125531196594,
0.7915012240409851,
-0.4096749722957611,
0.4030313193798065,
0.46670961380004883,
0.3633425235748291,
0.04266982153058052,
0.0509968101978302,
-0.4629087448120117,
-0.7760158181190491,
-0.3364885151386261,
-0.7421073913574219,
-0.5476942658424377,
0.14499275386333466,
-0.9600843191146851,
-0.2147177755832672,
-0.4223255217075348,
-0.30815425515174866,
-0.0021049771457910538,
0.051295891404151917,
-0.6032488346099854,
0.2777656614780426,
-0.003287473926320672,
0.4768330156803131,
-0.8010355830192566,
0.9066887497901917,
0.5089923739433289,
-0.5242259502410889,
-0.5350757837295532,
-0.06627558916807175,
0.15090179443359375,
-0.6953172087669373,
0.4914277493953705,
0.2237817943096161,
-0.33025768399238586,
-0.18928390741348267,
-0.39100173115730286,
-0.7476210594177246,
1.1125060319900513,
0.22261592745780945,
-0.8313377499580383,
0.17123937606811523,
-0.044126518070697784,
0.5613057017326355,
-0.16456618905067444,
0.17479251325130463,
1.1528304815292358,
0.41242387890815735,
0.01631668210029602,
-1.0618488788604736,
-0.4957469403743744,
-0.35838186740875244,
0.07410448044538498,
-0.048779044300317764,
-0.30043020844459534,
0.09412315487861633,
-0.09010841697454453,
-0.709763765335083,
0.016676783561706543,
0.8124597668647766,
0.08710677921772003,
0.5384497046470642,
0.7865128517150879,
0.7177259922027588,
1.0472289323806763,
-0.5139864683151245,
0.5367274284362793,
0.03757617995142937,
0.5254116058349609,
1.3263208866119385,
-0.0006935137789696455,
0.8276602029800415,
0.3383267819881439,
-0.418279230594635,
0.5960849523544312,
0.3742474913597107,
-0.09645655006170273,
0.3668421506881714,
0.38414597511291504,
-0.3367516100406647,
-0.07934002578258514,
0.009290727786719799,
-0.24453411996364594,
0.5003489255905151,
0.7490392923355103,
0.09447675198316574,
-0.11096355319023132,
0.2969837486743927,
0.07102281600236893,
0.19227367639541626,
-0.37432238459587097,
1.0888835191726685,
0.11652106046676636,
-0.6367830038070679,
0.8939118981361389,
-0.459848016500473,
0.7312164306640625,
-0.7211045026779175,
0.08984650671482086,
-0.2300628274679184,
-0.04845501482486725,
-0.126511350274086,
-0.7529244422912598,
0.6115795969963074,
0.1257781684398651,
-0.21382851898670197,
-0.21012943983078003,
0.43332505226135254,
-0.45904475450515747,
-0.30738985538482666,
0.49905142188072205,
0.16467556357383728,
0.45770683884620667,
0.18047526478767395,
-0.9379242062568665,
0.20484580099582672,
-0.0838790312409401,
0.2993823289871216,
0.304883748292923,
0.10093040019273758,
0.5200784802436829,
0.9134302139282227,
0.4297563135623932,
0.1894056349992752,
-0.042517583817243576,
0.6288132071495056,
0.6572209000587463,
-0.22715508937835693,
-0.15132875740528107,
-0.6808059215545654,
0.606740415096283,
-0.1841111034154892,
-0.46676579117774963,
0.698763906955719,
0.17163987457752228,
0.8832374811172485,
0.13036097586154938,
0.7544722557067871,
0.02180534042418003,
0.21381168067455292,
-0.6668148040771484,
0.8403064012527466,
-0.5219774842262268,
0.3050635755062103,
-0.3629710376262665,
-0.9118062853813171,
-0.11546481400728226,
0.6306135654449463,
-0.23272740840911865,
-0.12865883111953735,
0.706467866897583,
0.3455723226070404,
0.2194758951663971,
-0.09801366925239563,
0.500243604183197,
0.27971914410591125,
0.06944750249385834,
0.4498084485530853,
0.6490254998207092,
0.02306864596903324,
0.45841869711875916,
-0.2577810287475586,
-0.3753482699394226,
0.3771398067474365,
-0.642271101474762,
-0.7310373783111572,
-0.7895726561546326,
-0.5547314286231995,
-0.2953731119632721,
0.4760648310184479,
0.38143467903137207,
0.7200382351875305,
-0.761034369468689,
-0.4336579740047455,
-0.22396601736545563,
0.18559394776821136,
-0.6290924549102783,
-0.20930024981498718,
0.12994100153446198,
-0.9149790406227112,
-0.6099230051040649,
0.5725961923599243,
0.5461965799331665,
-0.12452483177185059,
-0.30680903792381287,
-0.33590051531791687,
0.020241033285856247,
-0.12211348116397858,
0.6683206558227539,
0.5942038893699646,
-0.8920366168022156,
-0.5388947129249573,
-0.3691367506980896,
0.39782580733299255,
0.0214095301926136,
0.5936535596847534,
-0.5769456028938293,
0.72284334897995,
0.13689517974853516,
0.6890584826469421,
0.5111971497535706,
-0.11706909537315369,
0.6119368672370911,
-0.6762329936027527,
0.03784406930208206,
0.2902817130088806,
0.3322009742259979,
0.17648573219776154,
-0.206454798579216,
0.472959041595459,
0.24237771332263947,
-0.7727532982826233,
-0.548025369644165,
0.1909872591495514,
-1.0948560237884521,
-0.15961164236068726,
1.0273709297180176,
-0.4670183062553406,
0.18006619811058044,
-0.6596099138259888,
0.24833838641643524,
0.19137060642242432,
-0.19396068155765533,
0.7985883951187134,
0.6741459965705872,
0.05925251916050911,
-0.2606355547904968,
-0.5477905869483948,
0.16494128108024597,
0.5142095685005188,
-0.7337567806243896,
-0.09277047216892242,
0.32929256558418274,
0.5787016153335571,
0.2420019656419754,
0.5356761813163757,
-0.02808193303644657,
0.3746848702430725,
-0.16267350316047668,
-0.28362828493118286,
0.2807357609272003,
-0.5721089243888855,
-0.49520349502563477,
-0.21534284949302673,
0.15150630474090576,
-0.13921646773815155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10426v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10426v1 | DELL: Generating Reactions and Explanations for LLM-Based Misinformation Detection | 2024-02-16T03:24:56 | 2024-02-16T03:24:56 | Herun Wan, Shangbin Feng, Zhaoxuan Tan, Heng Wang, Yulia Tsvetkov, Minnan Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models are limited by challenges in factuality and
hallucinations to be directly employed off-the-shelf for judging the veracity
of news articles, where factual accuracy is paramount. In this work, we propose
DELL that identifies three key stages in misinformation detection where LLMs
could be incorporated as part of the pipeline: 1) LLMs could \emph{generate
news reactions} to represent diverse perspectives and simulate user-news
interaction networks; 2) LLMs could \emph{generate explanations} for proxy
tasks (e.g., sentiment, stance) to enrich the contexts of news articles and
produce experts specializing in various aspects of news understanding; 3) LLMs
could \emph{merge task-specific experts} and provide an overall prediction by
incorporating the predictions and confidence scores of varying experts.
Extensive experiments on seven datasets with three LLMs demonstrate that DELL
outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by up to 16.8\% in macro f1-score.
Further analysis reveals that the generated reactions and explanations are
greatly helpful in misinformation detection, while our proposed LLM-guided
expert merging helps produce better-calibrated predictions. | [
-0.5309798121452332,
-0.7666817307472229,
0.9552256464958191,
0.14361345767974854,
-0.2416805475950241,
-0.12930582463741302,
-0.043605733662843704,
-0.5132337808609009,
0.023333176970481873,
0.28605014085769653,
-0.7864127159118652,
-0.7212469577789307,
-0.5534830093383789,
0.37993478775024414,
-0.8065248131752014,
0.9845876693725586,
0.19252678751945496,
0.0915536880493164,
-0.030090931802988052,
0.38028353452682495,
-0.2819759249687195,
-0.2260698676109314,
-0.6341039538383484,
-0.06490544974803925,
0.6578266620635986,
0.5859172940254211,
0.6147628426551819,
0.32666581869125366,
0.021424047648906708,
0.26378825306892395,
-0.0710686594247818,
0.4570644795894623,
-0.35299789905548096,
0.1280006617307663,
-0.15859878063201904,
-0.7591478824615479,
-0.21299104392528534,
0.14656567573547363,
0.44253551959991455,
0.26597580313682556,
0.04153939709067345,
-0.07933507859706879,
0.15959276258945465,
0.663647472858429,
-0.5076959133148193,
-0.21306884288787842,
-1.0264724493026733,
0.18970368802547455,
0.03376445174217224,
-0.17777809500694275,
-0.45062732696533203,
-0.34258583188056946,
-0.16715309023857117,
-0.26045095920562744,
0.4128516614437103,
0.1950230747461319,
0.43630626797676086,
0.19692794978618622,
-0.49607133865356445,
-0.1456967443227768,
-0.6836845874786377,
0.5735493302345276,
-0.7509704232215881,
0.377440869808197,
-0.11552548408508301,
0.2995576560497284,
-0.3365803062915802,
-0.2676241099834442,
-0.9163349866867065,
-0.06921067833900452,
-0.004488764796406031,
0.23971986770629883,
-0.3009202778339386,
-0.2120414674282074,
0.2845112085342407,
0.10741431266069412,
-0.5442960262298584,
0.30383166670799255,
-0.4734362065792084,
-0.4047858715057373,
0.6361574530601501,
0.11199835687875748,
-0.05281243100762367,
-0.22694101929664612,
-0.43712151050567627,
0.2991291284561157,
-0.871127724647522,
-0.46464577317237854,
0.5132415294647217,
0.24719035625457764,
0.04655689001083374,
0.623652994632721,
-0.20851127803325653,
0.7930192947387695,
0.3031323254108429,
-0.32563719153404236,
-0.0028782894369214773,
-0.282890647649765,
-0.32022222876548767,
0.41651058197021484,
0.7177339196205139,
0.47908979654312134,
0.1439431607723236,
-0.15454459190368652,
-0.28373634815216064,
0.1563885360956192,
0.369977205991745,
-0.5489881038665771,
0.022184036672115326,
0.33771297335624695,
-0.3227302134037018,
-0.5802919864654541,
0.1858910620212555,
-0.9252960681915283,
-0.701380729675293,
-0.4881933331489563,
0.4890614151954651,
-0.20331330597400665,
-0.38214707374572754,
-0.08649717271327972,
-0.17519663274288177,
-0.14379969239234924,
0.7766168713569641,
-0.32839298248291016,
0.03417748957872391,
0.6597386002540588,
0.7054282426834106,
-0.5873857736587524,
-0.18777340650558472,
-0.7506399154663086,
0.13483034074306488,
-0.5209980607032776,
1.04819917678833,
-0.2891416549682617,
-0.2157605141401291,
0.26984718441963196,
-0.14434926211833954,
-0.12422052770853043,
-0.6288113594055176,
0.60898357629776,
-0.3767542541027069,
0.46663475036621094,
-0.18855558335781097,
-0.7247685790061951,
-0.19293151795864105,
0.4350179135799408,
-0.5751099586486816,
1.0092369318008423,
-0.14595036208629608,
-1.0203962326049805,
0.4846046566963196,
-0.325761079788208,
-0.30686143040657043,
-0.13030976057052612,
-0.22608181834220886,
-0.20000943541526794,
0.43553832173347473,
0.29136237502098083,
0.5820009708404541,
-0.05883380398154259,
0.11387762427330017,
-0.19773901998996735,
-0.4728316068649292,
0.4609437882900238,
-0.5272729992866516,
0.29597097635269165,
0.38541021943092346,
-0.41058558225631714,
0.054212383925914764,
-0.7310425043106079,
-0.39491650462150574,
-0.36201515793800354,
-0.5610495209693909,
0.014942485839128494,
0.12965334951877594,
-0.30214622616767883,
0.16955192387104034,
0.11287939548492432,
-0.466756135225296,
-0.24453243613243103,
-0.06727208942174911,
-0.18948079645633698,
0.6428486108779907,
0.05726567283272743,
0.1482802778482437,
-0.2940080463886261,
0.293165385723114,
0.7357077598571777,
0.16078419983386993,
-0.23196035623550415,
-0.6504378318786621,
-0.840203583240509,
0.03829902783036232,
-0.16626566648483276,
0.6197201013565063,
-0.7233624458312988,
0.484544038772583,
-0.003026774385944009,
-0.43908998370170593,
-0.25329598784446716,
0.13122884929180145,
0.1303742378950119,
0.8255887627601624,
0.39882728457450867,
0.3334687054157257,
-0.563786506652832,
-1.0090291500091553,
-0.9567798972129822,
-0.3132863938808441,
-0.08294379711151123,
-0.037817515432834625,
0.18917977809906006,
-0.05163136497139931,
1.0694130659103394,
-0.27537864446640015,
-0.18159174919128418,
-0.335080623626709,
0.2702224552631378,
0.4992941617965698,
0.06502091139554977,
0.19387651979923248,
-0.8501352667808533,
-0.36958613991737366,
0.05295613780617714,
-0.6185622811317444,
-0.1601901650428772,
-0.11981216073036194,
0.3715057075023651,
0.694932758808136,
0.6882272362709045,
-0.7117123007774353,
0.6683913469314575,
0.35743021965026855,
-0.1311061978340149,
0.9222259521484375,
0.15790380537509918,
0.4618396461009979,
-1.2450677156448364,
-0.41277337074279785,
0.3645435869693756,
-0.3952607810497284,
-0.7743836641311646,
-0.48731139302253723,
-0.08044295012950897,
0.0879998505115509,
-0.6713160872459412,
0.13401807844638824,
-0.22302889823913574,
-0.19155217707157135,
-0.43429696559906006,
0.4822012484073639,
-0.3047616183757782,
0.11239399760961533,
0.02614131197333336,
0.7424830794334412,
0.34242725372314453,
-0.9697986841201782,
0.3729194402694702,
-0.27612292766571045,
-0.477592408657074,
0.612910807132721,
-0.3998686969280243,
-0.26007989048957825,
-0.18767882883548737,
0.14343667030334473,
-1.2786355018615723,
-0.27324530482292175,
0.43874114751815796,
-0.6936430931091309,
-0.07036847621202469,
-0.1856791228055954,
-0.9232147932052612,
-0.4618210792541504,
-0.23455992341041565,
-0.22608253359794617,
0.3632890582084656,
-0.5529491305351257,
0.6183887124061584,
0.04018115624785423,
0.07596247643232346,
-0.45990222692489624,
-0.7727436423301697,
0.1204795390367508,
-0.4472827613353729,
-0.6545600295066833,
0.1995583325624466,
0.030040821060538292,
-0.4410242438316345,
0.13529562950134277,
-0.43989336490631104,
0.0230687465518713,
0.07249459624290466,
0.1593758910894394,
0.30590271949768066,
-0.2193300724029541,
0.41923731565475464,
0.15046076476573944,
-0.06738102436065674,
0.2173817902803421,
-0.32712993025779724,
0.07325209677219391,
0.15311965346336365,
-0.5137194395065308,
-0.720245361328125,
0.15741702914237976,
0.7226701974868774,
0.42151233553886414,
0.8124403357505798,
0.9041063785552979,
-0.5774268507957458,
-0.17946968972682953,
-1.0278027057647705,
-0.39613157510757446,
-0.3938373923301697,
0.318830668926239,
-0.04430915415287018,
-0.8471984267234802,
0.24377863109111786,
-0.29106977581977844,
-0.00757488003000617,
0.719279408454895,
0.6125078797340393,
-0.0651707723736763,
1.1772116422653198,
0.4405604302883148,
-0.3407117426395416,
0.23433570563793182,
0.2686096131801605,
0.44628286361694336,
-0.28167009353637695,
-0.442146360874176,
-0.6369491219520569,
-0.3652999699115753,
-0.5709363222122192,
-0.43484851717948914,
0.6799979209899902,
0.05906904861330986,
0.04799111559987068,
0.061189573258161545,
-0.3571080267429352,
0.5419073700904846,
0.35210829973220825,
-0.03892118111252785,
0.5358319878578186,
0.42729291319847107,
-0.10743221640586853,
0.0009274230105802417,
-0.7703564763069153,
-0.45567843317985535,
0.858275830745697,
0.38225242495536804,
0.9550965428352356,
-0.021887222304940224,
0.7030017375946045,
0.5490499138832092,
0.35151398181915283,
-0.6329973340034485,
0.5011899471282959,
-0.06827175617218018,
-0.5816488265991211,
-0.04329439625144005,
-0.3560589551925659,
-0.3552832305431366,
0.3209719657897949,
-0.5619706511497498,
-0.862690269947052,
-0.06552089005708694,
0.16063052415847778,
-0.2546384036540985,
0.42460259795188904,
-0.6609809398651123,
0.5030243992805481,
0.033071864396333694,
-0.35045909881591797,
-0.6570692658424377,
-0.2471732497215271,
0.7436189651489258,
-0.18746064603328705,
0.5407253503799438,
-0.11947683990001678,
-0.1548837274312973,
0.5429048538208008,
-0.20579299330711365,
0.9926155805587769,
-0.2942933738231659,
-0.25120145082473755,
0.3075946569442749,
0.12123852223157883,
0.6213618516921997,
0.24845585227012634,
-0.18840952217578888,
-0.07169649004936218,
-0.3580567240715027,
0.23445658385753632,
-0.3471755087375641,
0.8310493230819702,
-0.514069676399231,
-0.8550279140472412,
-0.39337998628616333,
-0.5642871260643005,
-0.23237024247646332,
-0.09383382648229599,
0.40348973870277405,
-0.018923576921224594,
-0.010109743103384972,
-0.07887914776802063,
0.9635652303695679,
-0.06550426781177521,
0.34691402316093445,
0.6940426826477051,
-0.4038817584514618,
-0.21166592836380005,
0.556513249874115,
-0.09491384029388428,
-0.1972540318965912,
0.21526367962360382,
0.053711775690317154,
-0.3437528610229492,
-0.591093122959137,
-0.303067684173584,
0.07720529288053513,
-0.7358090877532959,
-0.4007859230041504,
-0.5075236558914185,
-0.3267524540424347,
-0.18511250615119934,
0.1515437364578247,
-0.15403421223163605,
-0.3838183879852295,
-0.6539456248283386,
-0.257190078496933,
0.3604445457458496,
0.9882094860076904,
-0.18441222608089447,
0.41655030846595764,
-0.9465572834014893,
0.3038710057735443,
0.2707769274711609,
-0.07437913864850998,
-0.15221595764160156,
-0.5187591910362244,
-0.49096789956092834,
0.1355533003807068,
-0.3826124668121338,
-1.2987358570098877,
0.25958770513534546,
-0.1728716343641281,
0.6507853269577026,
0.7147375345230103,
-0.2538403868675232,
0.6541183590888977,
-0.2686452269554138,
1.0180697441101074,
0.3927311897277832,
-0.8325140476226807,
0.7392070293426514,
-0.20138853788375854,
0.0036150359082967043,
0.2307719886302948,
0.7256102561950684,
-0.4716596305370331,
-0.6758893132209778,
-0.40572360157966614,
-0.3370908796787262,
0.8369252681732178,
0.04917459189891815,
0.06990233063697815,
-0.2105933576822281,
0.4742618501186371,
0.2988536059856415,
0.23561520874500275,
-0.7901343107223511,
-0.14995472133159637,
0.12112545222043991,
-0.08496285229921341,
0.05879206955432892,
-0.47494930028915405,
-0.23648041486740112,
-0.07460598647594452,
0.811313271522522,
-0.13968442380428314,
0.20082120597362518,
0.36992117762565613,
-0.35167229175567627,
-0.14805644750595093,
0.16837403178215027,
0.6123485565185547,
0.8435368537902832,
0.2492009401321411,
0.30107560753822327,
0.26144763827323914,
-0.060606472194194794,
-0.171926349401474,
-0.09010008722543716,
0.0692022517323494,
0.439531534910202,
0.35980892181396484,
0.44778743386268616,
0.012707117013633251,
-0.40924981236457825,
0.4795725345611572,
0.011217478662729263,
-0.32652175426483154,
-0.3855563700199127,
0.34145212173461914,
0.287906676530838,
0.5006494522094727,
0.7993372678756714,
0.13556839525699615,
0.237748384475708,
-0.46401527523994446,
0.2724161148071289,
0.40273919701576233,
-0.3717278242111206,
-0.35349979996681213,
0.5019826889038086,
0.06720064580440521,
-0.01564117707312107,
0.4294004440307617,
-0.12224023789167404,
-0.6641181111335754,
0.522671103477478,
0.4873833954334259,
0.7374433279037476,
-0.24218867719173431,
0.31742602586746216,
0.3423815965652466,
0.4784274697303772,
-0.05964991822838783,
0.25311198830604553,
0.02755715511739254,
-0.8600848913192749,
-0.37743937969207764,
-0.4949114918708801,
-0.1919344961643219,
0.3489951491355896,
-0.2330009937286377,
0.5931337475776672,
-0.22489523887634277,
-0.11191918700933456,
0.06812790781259537,
-0.27393749356269836,
-0.564090371131897,
0.30395787954330444,
0.5143780708312988,
1.3313087224960327,
-0.9488913416862488,
0.4861409068107605,
0.5348919630050659,
-0.16275344789028168,
-0.5118580460548401,
0.5386847257614136,
0.4753735065460205,
-0.6812543869018555,
0.7448932528495789,
0.3907090723514557,
-0.023652393370866776,
-0.26670292019844055,
-0.6191465258598328,
-0.4499584436416626,
0.9963286519050598,
0.3436580002307892,
-0.839034378528595,
0.2203287035226822,
0.128031924366951,
0.2846704125404358,
-0.7138630747795105,
0.20109021663665771,
0.623599112033844,
0.7003204822540283,
0.14619457721710205,
-0.6323274374008179,
-0.10607787221670151,
0.28253817558288574,
-0.19352522492408752,
-0.1713242530822754,
-0.201841801404953,
0.8100300431251526,
-0.22492794692516327,
-0.08401089906692505,
-0.1213340014219284,
0.7437257766723633,
0.3168570399284363,
0.5715757012367249,
0.7459675669670105,
0.7069811820983887,
0.6988031268119812,
-0.20659524202346802,
0.7955717444419861,
-0.405001699924469,
0.061709657311439514,
0.8271976709365845,
-0.006538846995681524,
0.7379626035690308,
0.4848306179046631,
-0.17770738899707794,
0.8460210561752319,
0.983296275138855,
0.03753603994846344,
0.24159836769104004,
0.20065569877624512,
-0.7072725296020508,
-0.46198770403862,
-0.11632699519395828,
-0.3286805748939514,
0.13851717114448547,
0.6660631895065308,
-0.44735342264175415,
-0.3765740394592285,
-0.13445597887039185,
0.22942373156547546,
-0.09367875009775162,
-0.6497200727462769,
0.7515373826026917,
-0.05083978921175003,
-0.842033326625824,
0.3242509365081787,
-0.00303179444745183,
0.6483592987060547,
-0.37044787406921387,
0.07522112876176834,
-0.34359461069107056,
0.18331795930862427,
-0.6605325937271118,
-0.9599683284759521,
0.44558095932006836,
0.24387076497077942,
-0.2470315545797348,
0.14394736289978027,
1.0776889324188232,
-0.617988646030426,
-0.48752039670944214,
0.15324801206588745,
0.8127853870391846,
0.3933701813220978,
-0.5311490893363953,
-0.5119606852531433,
0.32735586166381836,
0.09610166400671005,
-0.19102530181407928,
0.09245530515909195,
0.6488983631134033,
0.0728892832994461,
0.4377431273460388,
0.5291860103607178,
-0.10868985950946808,
0.1758943349123001,
0.12873433530330658,
0.982230007648468,
-0.3666934370994568,
-0.2824145555496216,
-0.9393894672393799,
0.5504932999610901,
-0.3293795883655548,
0.1932162493467331,
0.7969956994056702,
0.7088028192520142,
0.5369755625724792,
-0.2887115478515625,
1.0850998163223267,
0.2235201895236969,
0.5388556718826294,
-0.6771354675292969,
0.5182726383209229,
-0.7474336624145508,
0.3137207627296448,
-0.10170791298151016,
-1.2050710916519165,
-0.2805187702178955,
0.3213883638381958,
-0.039900895208120346,
0.07953222841024399,
0.9094333052635193,
0.8775257468223572,
-0.06787054240703583,
0.21625147759914398,
0.3778148889541626,
0.4927487373352051,
0.08937502652406693,
0.29123038053512573,
0.9377790093421936,
-0.08237878233194351,
0.6104656457901001,
0.08589522540569305,
-0.19857382774353027,
-0.5821511149406433,
-1.1054539680480957,
-0.8850581645965576,
-0.30188098549842834,
-0.4342634081840515,
-0.34820055961608887,
0.13158075511455536,
0.5551943182945251,
0.6406909227371216,
-0.8043935298919678,
0.023723376914858818,
-0.3757473826408386,
0.6478753089904785,
0.021273592486977577,
-0.28746911883354187,
-0.15930239856243134,
-0.7041530609130859,
-0.7537890672683716,
0.7134737968444824,
0.39136311411857605,
0.06751596927642822,
-0.35295161604881287,
-0.06998694688081741,
-0.012547298334538937,
0.15113568305969238,
0.6122854948043823,
-0.04144533351063728,
-0.8852773308753967,
-0.3413722813129425,
-0.19466178119182587,
0.12168130278587341,
-0.28966856002807617,
0.7625487446784973,
-1.0513921976089478,
0.12049347162246704,
0.4661182463169098,
0.4582970440387726,
0.47124361991882324,
0.006345352157950401,
0.3754562735557556,
-0.7322138547897339,
-0.1401403248310089,
-0.02875780314207077,
0.27250948548316956,
0.2759968340396881,
-0.6107900738716125,
0.42355892062187195,
0.5377340316772461,
-0.3117882013320923,
-0.6098344922065735,
0.23736247420310974,
-0.7674055099487305,
-0.32815131545066833,
1.1955482959747314,
0.038961056619882584,
-0.18423669040203094,
-0.060783371329307556,
-0.07938971370458603,
0.19827218353748322,
-0.39801037311553955,
0.917024552822113,
0.7969377636909485,
-0.3162161111831665,
-0.07559321075677872,
-0.4711456894874573,
0.6250564455986023,
0.24655847251415253,
-1.0022813081741333,
-0.013227537274360657,
0.7482509613037109,
0.4565925896167755,
0.22391849756240845,
0.302087664604187,
-0.12469983845949173,
0.5328832864761353,
-0.2456388771533966,
-0.20773935317993164,
-0.10654555261135101,
-0.5902901887893677,
-0.12481749057769775,
-0.031026098877191544,
-0.18156039714813232,
-0.13991770148277283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10424v1 | Understanding In-Context Learning with a Pelican Soup Framework | 2024-02-16T03:20:14 | 2024-02-16T03:20:14 | Ting-Rui Chiang, Dani Yogatama | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many existing theoretical analyses of in-context learning for natural
language processing are based on latent variable models that leaves gaps
between theory and practice. We aim to close these gaps by proposing a
theoretical framework, the Pelican Soup Framework. In this framework, we
introduce (1) the notion of a common sense knowledge base, (2) a general
formalism for natural language classification tasks, and the notion of (3)
meaning association. Under this framework, we can establish a
$\mathcal{O}(1/T)$ loss bound for in-context learning, where $T$ is the number
of example-label pairs in the demonstration. Compared with previous works, our
bound reflects the effect of the choice of verbalizers and the effect of
instruction tuning. An additional notion of \textit{atom concepts} makes our
framework possible to explain the generalization to tasks unseen in the
language model training data. Finally, we propose a toy setup, Calcutec, and a
digit addition task that mimics types of distribution shifts a model needs to
overcome to perform in-context learning. We also experiment with GPT2-Large on
real-world NLP tasks. Our empirical results demonstrate the efficacy of our
framework to explain in-context learning. | [
-0.10433011502027512,
-0.9093980193138123,
0.5729525089263916,
0.20903564989566803,
-0.07825244963169098,
-0.18803927302360535,
-0.2806199789047241,
-0.24553075432777405,
-0.33236056566238403,
0.2564457952976227,
-0.19205032289028168,
-0.2921159565448761,
-0.4838240444660187,
0.04980747774243355,
-0.3476604223251343,
0.9650260806083679,
-0.1319923996925354,
0.00399826280772686,
-0.09999267011880875,
0.02269391529262066,
-0.5592865943908691,
-0.4341669976711273,
-0.6238582134246826,
-0.48405784368515015,
0.3813767433166504,
0.37836429476737976,
0.47372931241989136,
0.7919983863830566,
0.29447001218795776,
0.20447038114070892,
-0.08616144955158234,
-0.18885529041290283,
-0.45485150814056396,
0.049662429839372635,
-0.3471739888191223,
-0.5070256590843201,
-0.38013723492622375,
0.251863032579422,
0.6904297471046448,
1.2284791469573975,
-0.042067889124155045,
-0.11353325843811035,
0.3931904137134552,
0.44687116146087646,
-0.7806350588798523,
0.2839244306087494,
-0.6003887057304382,
0.19987107813358307,
-0.26578786969184875,
-0.1580384224653244,
-0.47463420033454895,
0.12223263829946518,
0.5699793696403503,
-0.6660769581794739,
0.28411543369293213,
-0.14206565916538239,
0.648698091506958,
0.15466991066932678,
-0.7432793974876404,
-0.40338948369026184,
-0.5332026481628418,
0.8365246057510376,
-0.4442383944988251,
0.5009517669677734,
0.5857396125793457,
0.33293968439102173,
-0.1348768174648285,
-0.756593644618988,
-0.6601584553718567,
0.10632766783237457,
0.012325223535299301,
-0.08892271667718887,
0.051952555775642395,
0.05247537046670914,
0.02699836529791355,
0.5292220115661621,
-0.5345720052719116,
-0.2856196165084839,
-0.13399793207645416,
0.04616672173142433,
0.3428928256034851,
0.0042048487812280655,
0.348675936460495,
0.14242185652256012,
-0.4291585683822632,
0.010132977738976479,
-0.8056232929229736,
0.12322146445512772,
-0.07193901389837265,
0.2846066653728485,
-0.38299891352653503,
0.2252558022737503,
0.10100109875202179,
0.9939805865287781,
0.06352033466100693,
-0.022688983008265495,
0.26402485370635986,
-0.3251575529575348,
-0.5067651867866516,
0.06604472547769547,
0.4453117549419403,
0.2999635636806488,
0.3248717486858368,
-0.4266999363899231,
0.022800881415605545,
0.0014911190373823047,
0.09143463522195816,
-0.6056544184684753,
-0.32885006070137024,
-0.23941127955913544,
-0.25156524777412415,
-0.2641342282295227,
0.20017856359481812,
-0.2673403322696686,
-0.19138044118881226,
-0.37073078751564026,
0.3779556453227997,
-0.46865567564964294,
-0.28689005970954895,
0.19217181205749512,
-0.34134072065353394,
0.3070763349533081,
0.23246778547763824,
-1.096614956855774,
0.7893015146255493,
0.7798025012016296,
0.9632009863853455,
0.07665562629699707,
-0.46800264716148376,
-0.5808348059654236,
0.4491616487503052,
-0.292532354593277,
0.6730770468711853,
-0.7152331471443176,
-0.1313430368900299,
-0.19644902646541595,
0.03924350067973137,
-0.4407806098461151,
-0.4627026319503784,
-0.16957439482212067,
-0.3006516695022583,
0.45302271842956543,
-0.14829140901565552,
-0.8151407241821289,
-0.4300794303417206,
0.3930967450141907,
-0.40616169571876526,
0.7198173403739929,
0.29843494296073914,
-0.7639997005462646,
0.38930585980415344,
-0.7935199737548828,
-0.4932660758495331,
-0.0002976581745315343,
-0.2601637542247772,
0.174525186419487,
0.15897542238235474,
-0.24716126918792725,
0.608928382396698,
-0.33305591344833374,
0.30854281783103943,
-0.3013068735599518,
-0.5482933521270752,
0.43640071153640747,
-0.48538118600845337,
0.720257043838501,
0.05233914032578468,
-0.4317772388458252,
-0.15379182994365692,
-0.41086456179618835,
-0.2445525825023651,
0.017960259690880775,
-0.6539525389671326,
-0.5463998317718506,
-0.027193132787942886,
0.045593515038490295,
0.010820434428751469,
-0.13244937360286713,
-0.3194938004016876,
0.18570590019226074,
-0.9324211478233337,
0.7342718839645386,
0.5179007649421692,
0.09631490707397461,
1.1653873920440674,
-0.13584282994270325,
0.2677990198135376,
-0.11868613958358765,
-0.022863540798425674,
-0.24947743117809296,
-0.3449108600616455,
-0.44541075825691223,
0.09855537861585617,
0.2867560088634491,
0.49671757221221924,
-0.4934825897216797,
0.1485370695590973,
-0.09916123747825623,
0.03358589857816696,
0.02306259796023369,
0.1859334409236908,
0.42352259159088135,
0.9043843150138855,
0.2970505952835083,
-0.20183482766151428,
-0.32850149273872375,
-0.8899149894714355,
-0.342049241065979,
0.0110195716843009,
-0.34666377305984497,
0.30495232343673706,
0.4371911585330963,
-0.08697046339511871,
1.1160176992416382,
-0.23302926123142242,
-0.2286147177219391,
-0.28803303837776184,
-0.0720098465681076,
0.27827921509742737,
0.47394824028015137,
0.44038787484169006,
-1.2349568605422974,
-0.6415588855743408,
-0.018039733171463013,
-0.739637553691864,
0.019604535773396492,
0.03655320033431053,
0.12895536422729492,
0.04593205824494362,
0.3622558116912842,
-0.15129636228084564,
0.2956312596797943,
0.36260753870010376,
-0.48159924149513245,
0.057582274079322815,
-0.06808195263147354,
-0.17345386743545532,
-1.1911541223526,
-0.17264202237129211,
0.25954052805900574,
-0.174733504652977,
-0.9161199927330017,
0.00807141326367855,
0.19288276135921478,
-0.04530029743909836,
-0.6080713868141174,
0.6625182628631592,
-0.16853144764900208,
0.04299719259142876,
-0.1734495609998703,
0.09496712684631348,
0.22067752480506897,
0.3251684308052063,
0.16639211773872375,
0.8516271710395813,
0.5660568475723267,
-0.917975902557373,
0.11914253979921341,
-0.1262635439634323,
-0.014325047843158245,
0.4484177827835083,
-0.6641773581504822,
0.15609653294086456,
-0.06904580444097519,
0.34205684065818787,
-0.5969868898391724,
-0.3397590219974518,
0.7271631956100464,
-0.28049734234809875,
0.30589914321899414,
-0.23399090766906738,
-0.2996201813220978,
0.11923147737979889,
-0.14071166515350342,
0.5285776257514954,
0.17876487970352173,
-0.45998328924179077,
0.5332258939743042,
0.5316064357757568,
0.09857676178216934,
-0.34863805770874023,
-0.7680047154426575,
-0.024851735681295395,
-0.496214359998703,
-0.4723230004310608,
0.7108239531517029,
-0.12618355453014374,
-0.5973777174949646,
-0.000480121118016541,
-0.2105889916419983,
-0.3975370228290558,
0.40808001160621643,
0.3164145052433014,
-0.21783983707427979,
-0.1872709095478058,
0.4477706253528595,
0.048325370997190475,
-0.16416676342487335,
0.04205400124192238,
-0.40351253747940063,
0.5174379348754883,
-0.5834013819694519,
-0.10211795568466187,
-0.08279120922088623,
0.2778399884700775,
0.19859696924686432,
-0.020176198333501816,
0.634238600730896,
0.24446646869182587,
-0.5503540635108948,
-0.2808566391468048,
0.02683470956981182,
-0.13938026130199432,
-0.41596290469169617,
0.3163272440433502,
-0.4717012643814087,
-0.5111979246139526,
0.3014666438102722,
-0.1319064348936081,
-0.15273892879486084,
0.19596335291862488,
0.29862141609191895,
-0.1512136161327362,
0.8682235479354858,
0.7565650939941406,
0.07556642591953278,
0.5273482203483582,
-0.5424879193305969,
0.13522681593894958,
-0.8811979293823242,
-0.14388643205165863,
-0.179978147149086,
-0.23537786304950714,
-0.08537257462739944,
-0.4325965940952301,
0.20716169476509094,
0.4589185118675232,
-0.4101722836494446,
0.2998226284980774,
-0.2384987324476242,
0.8694774508476257,
0.5545480847358704,
0.05421650782227516,
0.13029150664806366,
-0.1635991483926773,
-0.10444562882184982,
0.1959468573331833,
-0.8860305547714233,
-0.6077719330787659,
1.0108376741409302,
0.352272093296051,
0.46960458159446716,
0.13952864706516266,
0.6238235235214233,
0.23875027894973755,
0.2671954333782196,
-0.8518590927124023,
0.23328183591365814,
-0.000773623411078006,
-0.48300278186798096,
-0.32090991735458374,
-0.32796645164489746,
-0.8529279828071594,
0.3116835057735443,
0.005549932364374399,
-0.7249688506126404,
0.11385174840688705,
0.36083248257637024,
-0.1385958045721054,
0.11185886710882187,
-0.9100581407546997,
1.1231276988983154,
-0.2301737517118454,
-0.41870737075805664,
-0.03192095831036568,
-0.6871456503868103,
0.1982477605342865,
0.07105937600135803,
0.364993155002594,
0.07237111032009125,
-0.1472233384847641,
0.6274824142456055,
-0.33446013927459717,
0.9707051515579224,
-0.18430955708026886,
-0.01278388500213623,
0.1411595642566681,
0.12275577336549759,
0.33078083395957947,
0.24235323071479797,
-0.11601187288761139,
0.02888360433280468,
0.09271395951509476,
-0.4730207622051239,
-0.7420833706855774,
0.42607295513153076,
-0.5587664842605591,
-0.12801167368888855,
-0.5535478591918945,
-0.6510022282600403,
-0.18061208724975586,
0.09143170714378357,
0.3750075399875641,
0.589975893497467,
-0.19345290958881378,
0.3432285785675049,
0.7670606374740601,
0.05770028010010719,
0.35417017340660095,
0.5431199073791504,
0.01807531900703907,
-0.02835577167570591,
0.9010646939277649,
0.16440226137638092,
0.18645241856575012,
0.7334093451499939,
0.4945172667503357,
-0.23002992570400238,
-0.45821407437324524,
-0.29168277978897095,
0.029093636199831963,
-0.7883402705192566,
0.03723819553852081,
-0.3033531904220581,
0.15865503251552582,
-0.3722441792488098,
-0.3267700672149658,
0.05550079047679901,
-0.029091851785779,
-0.3555128574371338,
0.1351373791694641,
0.016813552007079124,
0.8304294347763062,
0.18450100719928741,
0.4962890148162842,
-0.5229589939117432,
0.13921569287776947,
0.4237572252750397,
0.41996702551841736,
0.10873153805732727,
-0.42059263586997986,
-0.4421091079711914,
0.29778388142585754,
-0.4160307049751282,
-1.1745728254318237,
0.3216021656990051,
0.6556237936019897,
0.5425280332565308,
0.5525622963905334,
0.034341972321271896,
0.5256333947181702,
-0.4217877686023712,
0.7465185523033142,
0.008901216089725494,
-1.1734007596969604,
0.6110755205154419,
-0.46675577759742737,
0.20944282412528992,
0.4756411612033844,
0.30937016010284424,
-0.8634728789329529,
-0.20258887112140656,
-0.6918714046478271,
-0.9100719094276428,
0.5677813291549683,
0.0399632528424263,
0.19679459929466248,
-0.33519601821899414,
0.35179609060287476,
0.22871418297290802,
0.2366618514060974,
-0.8187118768692017,
-0.0805635154247284,
-0.3240894377231598,
-0.3710941970348358,
-0.1728987842798233,
-0.045915547758340836,
-0.059954047203063965,
-0.23936785757541656,
0.5756215453147888,
-0.44094422459602356,
0.048567917197942734,
0.02103426307439804,
-0.7233773469924927,
0.055204521864652634,
0.23610323667526245,
0.38824567198753357,
0.8706564903259277,
-0.20630675554275513,
0.5577778816223145,
0.2315916121006012,
-0.2101907730102539,
-0.030427785590291023,
-0.0596211776137352,
-0.048847269266843796,
-0.3317851722240448,
0.6118026971817017,
0.6262637376785278,
0.894745945930481,
-0.5803788304328918,
0.6472204327583313,
-0.19675752520561218,
-0.061288975179195404,
-0.2744376063346863,
0.2678694725036621,
0.15953701734542847,
0.29855474829673767,
0.4816780090332031,
-0.0007647143793292344,
0.40167415142059326,
-0.7518042325973511,
0.24101555347442627,
0.19841045141220093,
-0.3699972331523895,
-0.5004146695137024,
0.19944129884243011,
0.1837533414363861,
-0.5902590155601501,
0.4864020049571991,
-0.2791041135787964,
-0.5319516658782959,
0.610819399356842,
1.0115607976913452,
0.587274968624115,
0.03656986355781555,
0.12908945977687836,
-0.1505429446697235,
-0.13762322068214417,
-0.16786962747573853,
-0.016184676438570023,
-0.5945144891738892,
-0.9199635982513428,
-0.2700155973434448,
-0.49136725068092346,
-0.4623962640762329,
0.13790284097194672,
-0.5866293907165527,
-0.012228264473378658,
-0.4386601448059082,
0.221992626786232,
-0.03377415984869003,
-0.054261207580566406,
-0.7016356587409973,
-0.056528158485889435,
0.13962723314762115,
0.7829346656799316,
-1.1134960651397705,
0.8977270722389221,
0.9234545230865479,
-0.38999414443969727,
-0.9582776427268982,
0.25042998790740967,
0.05896710604429245,
-0.49458712339401245,
0.7770206332206726,
0.3356128931045532,
0.07585229724645615,
0.038638293743133545,
-0.4497019350528717,
-0.8576244115829468,
1.0328420400619507,
0.45085588097572327,
-0.3720315396785736,
-0.17441301047801971,
-0.11381956189870834,
0.29806363582611084,
-0.7307879328727722,
-0.004581884481012821,
0.5709640383720398,
0.2872113883495331,
-0.08277544379234314,
-0.9854699373245239,
-0.19720971584320068,
-0.36404868960380554,
0.010422500781714916,
0.15438400208950043,
-0.09294690191745758,
1.1228163242340088,
0.08741921186447144,
-0.38059738278388977,
-0.34494680166244507,
0.34598857164382935,
0.13916049897670746,
0.7132593989372253,
0.43358469009399414,
0.3098682463169098,
0.7248746156692505,
0.06892680376768112,
1.1970958709716797,
-0.03703539818525314,
0.45219582319259644,
1.263738989830017,
-0.159891277551651,
0.6907027959823608,
0.7163523435592651,
-0.27340778708457947,
0.438851535320282,
0.8276609778404236,
0.33575230836868286,
0.5378902554512024,
0.11333522200584412,
-0.29436925053596497,
-0.14635708928108215,
-0.13014112412929535,
-0.36088550090789795,
0.47785601019859314,
0.5525094866752625,
-0.5395373702049255,
-0.4802948832511902,
0.2737313508987427,
-0.07170189917087555,
0.315206915140152,
-0.3255736529827118,
0.8990707397460938,
0.19683833420276642,
-0.24396061897277832,
0.5694912075996399,
-0.11691100150346756,
0.5962280035018921,
-0.3571271598339081,
-0.33396944403648376,
0.015693726018071175,
0.29623329639434814,
0.041323959827423096,
-0.7584955096244812,
0.3370738625526428,
-0.2695457935333252,
-0.5772226452827454,
-0.34224241971969604,
0.6515849232673645,
-0.4694702625274658,
-0.24630750715732574,
0.21782611310482025,
0.39175453782081604,
0.2903715968132019,
-0.2801390290260315,
-0.7292061448097229,
-0.09346763044595718,
-0.37757381796836853,
-0.20995229482650757,
0.5858364701271057,
0.46715453267097473,
-0.00942067988216877,
0.5649189949035645,
0.3006095886230469,
0.08863544464111328,
-0.11760947108268738,
0.0416867621243,
0.6604146361351013,
-0.3984195590019226,
-0.6154162287712097,
-0.8560381531715393,
0.16728730499744415,
0.016645733267068863,
-0.2970653772354126,
0.7238110899925232,
0.436631977558136,
1.241191029548645,
-0.011343243531882763,
0.7150207161903381,
-0.078069306910038,
0.2970806360244751,
-0.4681677222251892,
0.5515949726104736,
-0.357374370098114,
0.30178704857826233,
-0.218349888920784,
-0.9463151693344116,
-0.4958118200302124,
1.116631031036377,
-0.6825171709060669,
-0.2333202213048935,
0.7126218676567078,
0.5194671154022217,
-0.3446735739707947,
0.044776879251003265,
0.13428489863872528,
0.03729972243309021,
0.20678840577602386,
0.7620357275009155,
0.6469802856445312,
-0.4762287735939026,
0.21613745391368866,
-0.4728488624095917,
-0.20822076499462128,
-0.07422343641519547,
-0.8223122358322144,
-0.7136399745941162,
-0.8462738394737244,
0.020938539877533913,
-0.20902925729751587,
0.11137843132019043,
1.180809736251831,
0.8938684463500977,
-0.5723406076431274,
-0.40598997473716736,
-0.5652382969856262,
0.35571709275245667,
-0.3516956865787506,
-0.28541192412376404,
0.2188635617494583,
-0.5243286490440369,
-0.6913797855377197,
0.651229977607727,
0.28014323115348816,
0.07982860505580902,
0.20703193545341492,
-0.5159267783164978,
-0.2582593858242035,
-0.2549678385257721,
0.6610346436500549,
0.3533502519130707,
-0.7082246541976929,
-0.28207090497016907,
-0.15607166290283203,
0.2651856243610382,
-0.028791554272174835,
0.8704513907432556,
-1.116595983505249,
0.29454857110977173,
0.42295339703559875,
0.5210984349250793,
0.25833165645599365,
-0.11451530456542969,
0.9310356378555298,
-0.8780381083488464,
0.17712925374507904,
0.28820207715034485,
0.32766368985176086,
0.3330060839653015,
-0.24673296511173248,
0.4675822854042053,
0.40956422686576843,
-0.3467042148113251,
-0.9758344888687134,
0.4421218931674957,
-0.5634552240371704,
-0.5256264805793762,
0.9688106775283813,
-0.11581740528345108,
-0.40814071893692017,
-0.3118125796318054,
0.0030316782649606466,
0.3560006618499756,
-0.38606879115104675,
0.548829972743988,
0.44359293580055237,
-0.2423594892024994,
-0.08336517959833145,
-0.27411508560180664,
0.4385836124420166,
0.11627162992954254,
-0.5193342566490173,
0.1410626620054245,
0.33551025390625,
0.5823790431022644,
0.07640577107667923,
0.6040678024291992,
0.26660147309303284,
0.3151945471763611,
-0.14690439403057098,
-0.3243938088417053,
-0.21411462128162384,
-0.6372460126876831,
-0.5737650990486145,
0.2985858619213104,
-0.013518230058252811,
-0.1351885050535202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10422v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10422v2 | Pushing the Limits of Zero-shot End-to-End Speech Translation | 2024-02-16T03:06:37 | 2024-06-05T20:56:20 | Ioannis Tsiamas, Gerard I. Gállego, José A. R. Fonollosa, Marta R. Costa-jussà | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data scarcity and the modality gap between the speech and text modalities are
two major obstacles of end-to-end Speech Translation (ST) systems, thus
hindering their performance. Prior work has attempted to mitigate these
challenges by leveraging external MT data and optimizing distance metrics that
bring closer the speech-text representations. However, achieving competitive
results typically requires some ST data. For this reason, we introduce
ZeroSwot, a method for zero-shot ST that bridges the modality gap without any
paired ST data. Leveraging a novel CTC compression and Optimal Transport, we
train a speech encoder using only ASR data, to align with the representation
space of a massively multilingual MT model. The speech encoder seamlessly
integrates with the MT model at inference, enabling direct translation from
speech to text, across all languages supported by the MT model. Our experiments
show that we can effectively close the modality gap without ST data, while our
results on MuST-C and CoVoST demonstrate our method's superiority over not only
previous zero-shot models, but also supervised ones, achieving state-of-the-art
results. | [
-0.1549098789691925,
-0.6503654718399048,
0.4455703794956207,
-0.3659985065460205,
-0.73897784948349,
0.11248884350061417,
-0.4322502315044403,
-0.46431398391723633,
0.2656221389770508,
0.435455322265625,
-0.6396768689155579,
-0.5594759583473206,
-0.5793226361274719,
0.025991855189204216,
-0.4612290859222412,
0.970535397529602,
-0.07405835390090942,
-0.08869818598031998,
-0.22832880914211273,
-0.3366866111755371,
-0.6224639415740967,
-0.5619485974311829,
-0.3718896508216858,
-0.11775899678468704,
0.33834898471832275,
0.4069342315196991,
0.6042719483375549,
0.7622453570365906,
0.14693833887577057,
0.06603709608316422,
-0.03978680819272995,
0.04509681090712547,
-0.5204681158065796,
0.430790513753891,
-0.12652179598808289,
-0.3680460453033447,
-0.12856736779212952,
-0.16396096348762512,
0.37390393018722534,
0.8206977844238281,
-0.025185396894812584,
0.11603371053934097,
-0.3088235557079315,
0.14574524760246277,
-0.44338348507881165,
-0.24773021042346954,
-0.5362330675125122,
0.1286722719669342,
-0.5821336507797241,
-0.32534196972846985,
-0.4921644628047943,
-0.17427438497543335,
-0.12817367911338806,
-0.3011394739151001,
0.06182388588786125,
0.025832146406173706,
0.9111315608024597,
0.4907214641571045,
-0.8297057747840881,
0.03640478104352951,
-0.7362368702888489,
0.6622119545936584,
-0.564491331577301,
0.6241767406463623,
0.15284228324890137,
0.2872324287891388,
-0.06667674332857132,
-0.14283329248428345,
-0.5971379280090332,
-0.1966402530670166,
0.40594157576560974,
0.216172993183136,
-0.3362043499946594,
0.06785845011472702,
-0.05420295149087906,
0.16821573674678802,
-0.8651283979415894,
0.17521218955516815,
-0.5041927695274353,
0.08477666974067688,
0.45151078701019287,
-0.11696653813123703,
0.20257973670959473,
-0.15711542963981628,
-0.39038968086242676,
-0.14412853121757507,
-0.6037608981132507,
0.013896120712161064,
0.09491978585720062,
0.4106282591819763,
-0.22193242609500885,
0.7387445569038391,
-0.1282465010881424,
0.6352035403251648,
-0.15576115250587463,
0.3647956848144531,
0.34718185663223267,
-0.21799948811531067,
-0.3529714047908783,
0.2775552272796631,
0.9013705849647522,
0.24562251567840576,
0.02424044720828533,
-0.5658875703811646,
-0.0860232561826706,
0.17987535893917084,
-0.10732297599315643,
-0.6230306625366211,
0.38921278715133667,
0.21286790072917938,
0.09543197602033615,
-0.17424951493740082,
-0.2661883533000946,
-0.3758049011230469,
0.11479320377111435,
-0.2803017497062683,
0.484712153673172,
-0.38595107197761536,
-0.23687265813350677,
0.13142158091068268,
-0.165178582072258,
0.34514835476875305,
0.11838706582784653,
-0.5617450475692749,
0.20978154242038727,
0.27114278078079224,
1.1570545434951782,
-0.1497325897216797,
-0.028176045045256615,
-0.5165852904319763,
0.43116721510887146,
-0.7346934676170349,
0.7301464676856995,
-0.6057466864585876,
-0.39576536417007446,
-0.20594681799411774,
-0.19012892246246338,
-0.14331908524036407,
-0.1750190109014511,
0.8719837665557861,
-0.13780686259269714,
0.32689058780670166,
-0.09137868881225586,
-0.5069764256477356,
-0.11038777232170105,
0.020388919860124588,
-0.2184579223394394,
0.7931348085403442,
0.18827804923057556,
-0.16340167820453644,
0.19120514392852783,
-0.7514511346817017,
-0.7432594895362854,
0.09751731902360916,
-0.25557440519332886,
-0.18368084728717804,
0.6418984532356262,
0.15834279358386993,
0.32735663652420044,
-0.4967974126338959,
0.31122177839279175,
-0.26359209418296814,
-0.3295579254627228,
0.17360305786132812,
-0.6410578489303589,
0.6514596343040466,
0.18609124422073364,
-0.2440032809972763,
0.17376919090747833,
-0.37143877148628235,
-0.03959454223513603,
0.36348116397857666,
0.07475509494543076,
-0.4524760842323303,
-0.25919288396835327,
0.23916849493980408,
0.46868735551834106,
0.03255612775683403,
-0.9752025008201599,
0.15715891122817993,
-0.4177146255970001,
0.791425347328186,
0.7637863159179688,
-0.28384286165237427,
0.4850124418735504,
-0.3268239498138428,
0.4606674015522003,
-0.10530782490968704,
0.030170343816280365,
-0.26395225524902344,
-0.3174391984939575,
-0.5221677422523499,
-0.22269602119922638,
0.3532409071922302,
0.4807456135749817,
-0.7900477051734924,
0.5135663151741028,
-0.6839765310287476,
-0.3723280429840088,
-0.816108226776123,
-0.48654666543006897,
0.08813720941543579,
0.551270067691803,
0.5006600618362427,
-0.4204959571361542,
-0.2238978147506714,
-0.7283881902694702,
0.005734041333198547,
0.17414401471614838,
-0.32989591360092163,
0.13828662037849426,
0.1905355453491211,
0.031460441648960114,
0.7650110125541687,
-0.24918030202388763,
-0.3624095320701599,
-0.287007600069046,
0.059786826372146606,
0.17080049216747284,
0.5655361413955688,
0.36107775568962097,
-0.5111222863197327,
-0.4495537579059601,
0.23060697317123413,
-0.566245436668396,
-0.2645289897918701,
-0.40820157527923584,
-0.022197267040610313,
0.14819593727588654,
0.28212621808052063,
-0.6397804021835327,
0.5369219779968262,
0.6586868762969971,
-0.2994900643825531,
0.20262514054775238,
-0.14524896442890167,
0.27879953384399414,
-0.9105752110481262,
0.20678409934043884,
-0.30155250430107117,
-0.5340548157691956,
-1.0822473764419556,
0.0793718695640564,
-0.06556754559278488,
-0.5122658610343933,
-0.4766485095024109,
0.4180411398410797,
-0.22385184466838837,
0.10079247504472733,
-0.19260413944721222,
0.3360356092453003,
-0.10013911873102188,
0.6490234732627869,
0.1204327866435051,
0.6277037858963013,
0.46262460947036743,
-0.24699756503105164,
0.12788505852222443,
0.48106688261032104,
0.2137191891670227,
0.8441941738128662,
-0.6478397846221924,
0.4058760404586792,
-0.12163710594177246,
0.2994527220726013,
-0.9251484274864197,
-0.11330967396497726,
0.2863132953643799,
-0.8847199082374573,
0.47329041361808777,
-0.09946835786104202,
-0.3434779942035675,
-0.02375786006450653,
-0.1459285020828247,
0.49164456129074097,
0.6205334663391113,
-0.16239997744560242,
0.18103326857089996,
0.1275075078010559,
-0.1982189118862152,
-0.19799575209617615,
-1.0443915128707886,
0.6364741921424866,
0.06281013786792755,
-0.6491614580154419,
0.35982540249824524,
-0.16128091514110565,
0.36207807064056396,
-0.08193541318178177,
-0.46213191747665405,
-0.19947998225688934,
-0.2671540379524231,
0.134700745344162,
0.17752495408058167,
0.011744053103029728,
0.01584073156118393,
0.4299250543117523,
-0.33111584186553955,
-0.42131543159484863,
-0.4605411887168884,
0.5998244285583496,
0.2712172865867615,
-0.6418688297271729,
-0.4275098145008087,
0.7386821508407593,
0.8468839526176453,
-0.2708090841770172,
0.5576069951057434,
0.41149306297302246,
-0.31166234612464905,
-0.032124172896146774,
-0.3730635643005371,
0.0386318601667881,
-0.36357128620147705,
0.19391557574272156,
-0.35942816734313965,
-1.0725630521774292,
0.07367753237485886,
-0.001242724247276783,
0.09770634770393372,
0.23990660905838013,
0.21091920137405396,
0.05428139492869377,
0.8512405157089233,
0.6372842192649841,
0.07546769082546234,
0.33262646198272705,
-0.03835759684443474,
0.4080830514431,
-0.7477623820304871,
-0.2403547614812851,
-0.5061889886856079,
-0.35883277654647827,
-0.22796061635017395,
-0.8925459980964661,
0.459854394197464,
0.021633539348840714,
-0.258759081363678,
0.7585252523422241,
-0.7670798897743225,
0.38880378007888794,
0.5527113676071167,
-0.03154316172003746,
0.26046109199523926,
0.10114617645740509,
0.001508894725702703,
-0.261380136013031,
-0.7337031364440918,
0.02213672734797001,
0.9306260347366333,
0.11634885519742966,
0.30052751302719116,
0.2866540551185608,
0.589067280292511,
0.2709504961967468,
-0.0997808650135994,
-0.8127942681312561,
0.46389877796173096,
-0.3610176742076874,
-0.4897957146167755,
-0.4669151306152344,
-0.5138394832611084,
-0.6825567483901978,
0.3844773769378662,
0.04660766199231148,
-0.4293246269226074,
0.2871394455432892,
-0.3281521797180176,
-0.04169000685214996,
0.3239291310310364,
-0.34296709299087524,
0.6710350513458252,
-0.3239646852016449,
-0.41833239793777466,
-0.07179983705282211,
-0.9366195201873779,
0.05905376374721527,
-0.10187314450740814,
0.2369779646396637,
-0.2796650826931,
-0.19615404307842255,
0.45196256041526794,
-0.4748065769672394,
0.5794530510902405,
-0.09663320332765579,
0.09285280108451843,
0.11141777038574219,
0.3651946485042572,
0.4843389391899109,
-0.6567093729972839,
0.0006664160755462945,
0.608052134513855,
-0.04225949943065643,
-0.5554015040397644,
-0.3312382698059082,
0.33087435364723206,
-0.6033009886741638,
-0.2186262160539627,
-0.3987567722797394,
-0.6523663997650146,
-0.15697360038757324,
0.2069728523492813,
0.3821820616722107,
0.3869688808917999,
-0.04763416945934296,
0.3686298727989197,
0.49802640080451965,
-0.11320308595895767,
0.536949872970581,
0.5255469679832458,
0.36466288566589355,
-0.5831126570701599,
0.8920584321022034,
0.3635561764240265,
0.5428608059883118,
0.46398964524269104,
0.09638790786266327,
-0.5706080198287964,
-0.630698561668396,
-1.0087388753890991,
0.2594359517097473,
-0.3418130874633789,
-0.41553032398223877,
-0.5521009564399719,
-0.2299482375383377,
-0.5770697593688965,
-0.8716696500778198,
-0.5937226414680481,
-0.5659449100494385,
-0.2087089866399765,
-0.11055081337690353,
0.23021697998046875,
0.3111361265182495,
-0.43579715490341187,
0.3917144536972046,
-0.6615582704544067,
0.13291557133197784,
-0.18394674360752106,
0.20443513989448547,
-0.18497592210769653,
-0.9056624174118042,
-0.10941562801599503,
0.10263360291719437,
-0.06438805907964706,
-0.9508431553840637,
0.6302463412284851,
0.3265400230884552,
0.21290206909179688,
0.3311847746372223,
0.4062359035015106,
1.2160202264785767,
-0.633091151714325,
0.8579258322715759,
0.724665641784668,
-1.2409319877624512,
0.5211014151573181,
-0.42242270708084106,
0.481838196516037,
0.4605310559272766,
0.19493331015110016,
-1.0892211198806763,
-0.43068164587020874,
-0.4056321680545807,
-1.0660121440887451,
0.5126748085021973,
0.46026483178138733,
0.2147514671087265,
-0.04938575625419617,
0.06240125000476837,
0.14465241134166718,
0.38619133830070496,
-0.6254001259803772,
0.02429690584540367,
-0.3462839722633362,
-0.2381991297006607,
0.03533283248543739,
0.12212581932544708,
-0.0422087162733078,
-0.09665775299072266,
0.33305975794792175,
-0.07822927087545395,
0.329738050699234,
0.3746379017829895,
-0.2365996539592743,
-0.4688459634780884,
0.5668256878852844,
0.7699546217918396,
0.1556282490491867,
-0.06734827160835266,
0.06671145558357239,
0.3146056532859802,
-0.10272485017776489,
0.387207955121994,
0.07789165526628494,
-0.32758209109306335,
0.25349825620651245,
0.2872135639190674,
0.7651222348213196,
0.2115754336118698,
-0.7563899159431458,
0.8410578966140747,
0.27654939889907837,
-0.3093970715999603,
-0.10938774049282074,
-0.445642352104187,
-0.21120300889015198,
0.021864503622055054,
0.3654061555862427,
0.24068816006183624,
-0.0041061588563025,
-0.27289333939552307,
0.4145221710205078,
0.340497761964798,
-0.8088927268981934,
-0.44702503085136414,
1.0085002183914185,
0.21483595669269562,
-0.23552969098091125,
0.41050925850868225,
-0.1663033366203308,
-0.1202746331691742,
0.15148094296455383,
0.6978145837783813,
1.0285905599594116,
-0.3775055706501007,
0.24953718483448029,
0.08627762645483017,
0.40940409898757935,
0.11692806333303452,
0.018595481291413307,
-0.4074207544326782,
-0.15673893690109253,
-0.7543949484825134,
-0.4784029424190521,
-0.43478766083717346,
-0.1616392880678177,
-0.6095967292785645,
0.3437618613243103,
-0.20041806995868683,
0.07953713834285736,
-0.525646448135376,
-0.4003406763076782,
-0.47457417845726013,
-0.09745098650455475,
0.3631107807159424,
0.7519768476486206,
-0.8283193111419678,
0.8719066977500916,
0.21977373957633972,
-0.44588208198547363,
-0.3736535310745239,
-0.4217945635318756,
0.08211314678192139,
-0.6831523180007935,
0.20725186169147491,
0.07493322342634201,
-0.2717282176017761,
0.032101165503263474,
-0.650306224822998,
-0.8445228934288025,
0.997391402721405,
0.622246265411377,
-0.7752425074577332,
-0.034236714243888855,
0.5050095319747925,
0.4451976418495178,
-0.16351306438446045,
0.2439163327217102,
0.2379082888364792,
0.2797229290008545,
0.7055202722549438,
-1.100743055343628,
0.0822223350405693,
-0.025790952146053314,
-0.05992588773369789,
0.39038586616516113,
-0.5412644147872925,
0.636268138885498,
0.017471475526690483,
-0.4923914074897766,
-0.04726431518793106,
0.4495351314544678,
-0.04713873937726021,
0.37712588906288147,
0.2607198655605316,
0.6208585500717163,
0.4067554771900177,
-0.0361768901348114,
0.6002129316329956,
-0.08743155002593994,
0.19612884521484375,
1.2129937410354614,
-0.45373430848121643,
0.9946399331092834,
0.4328024983406067,
0.193379744887352,
-0.019073795527219772,
0.4601925313472748,
0.07234930992126465,
0.5503393411636353,
0.11436793208122253,
-0.39056918025016785,
-0.3616642355918884,
-0.7141954302787781,
-0.3590548038482666,
0.5189588069915771,
0.22993649542331696,
0.058177921921014786,
-0.4518686532974243,
0.2788172662258148,
0.4106473922729492,
0.12196923792362213,
-0.06411153823137283,
0.48230671882629395,
0.047829557210206985,
-0.18650966882705688,
0.8694598078727722,
-0.01583160273730755,
0.7772937417030334,
-0.7821940183639526,
0.16756558418273926,
-0.2803192734718323,
-0.32550060749053955,
0.0061438786797225475,
-0.44465503096580505,
0.5509194135665894,
0.1369548887014389,
0.2422008365392685,
-0.5195024013519287,
0.4459494948387146,
-0.703330934047699,
-0.2363557517528534,
0.2745800018310547,
0.5648961663246155,
0.3737832307815552,
-0.18464690446853638,
-0.37257641553878784,
0.08972352743148804,
0.10026713460683823,
0.08463311940431595,
0.2656481862068176,
0.5417699813842773,
0.030161095783114433,
0.48727771639823914,
0.963197648525238,
0.2610674202442169,
0.03100043162703514,
-0.14115937054157257,
0.8449889421463013,
-0.8235055804252625,
-0.4048413336277008,
-0.7640746235847473,
0.5314319729804993,
0.0047100926749408245,
-0.2786361873149872,
0.555226743221283,
0.5766335129737854,
0.7999558448791504,
0.30921027064323425,
0.9009479880332947,
-0.2189999371767044,
0.3420628607273102,
-0.0305804256349802,
0.5602774024009705,
-0.6312443614006042,
-0.18653318285942078,
0.017856959253549576,
-0.4759089946746826,
-0.6157299280166626,
0.3521934449672699,
-0.21105322241783142,
-0.5481095910072327,
0.6007554531097412,
0.588914155960083,
0.016815021634101868,
-0.07387960702180862,
0.9718355536460876,
0.1365526169538498,
0.5098719596862793,
0.7982296347618103,
0.487393319606781,
-0.5623458027839661,
1.0044386386871338,
0.08808267116546631,
-0.28784650564193726,
-0.07067631185054779,
-0.6729635000228882,
-0.7089338898658752,
-0.49849531054496765,
-0.22163064777851105,
-0.031375207006931305,
0.22038310766220093,
0.9637342095375061,
0.8265000581741333,
-0.48753616213798523,
-0.26269322633743286,
-0.13918964564800262,
-0.1618197113275528,
-0.2730492651462555,
-0.12326342612504959,
0.227484330534935,
-0.11870891600847244,
-0.6478420495986938,
0.7250099778175354,
0.6506735682487488,
0.1982649862766266,
-0.05704464763402939,
0.056142713874578476,
-0.02808406762778759,
0.3406321704387665,
0.7159646153450012,
0.3267189860343933,
-0.626223087310791,
-0.4699539244174957,
0.2881998121738434,
0.26157650351524353,
0.2068883180618286,
0.7351694703102112,
-0.6571110486984253,
0.5651906132698059,
0.2809882164001465,
0.7286445498466492,
0.6054419279098511,
-0.2475907802581787,
0.6177833080291748,
-0.8124757409095764,
0.16809585690498352,
0.47689956426620483,
-0.11366131156682968,
0.266396701335907,
-0.1342088282108307,
0.48659127950668335,
0.33135125041007996,
-0.4703371226787567,
-0.9927534461021423,
0.35789811611175537,
-1.194133996963501,
-0.33511263132095337,
0.9469225406646729,
0.13836197555065155,
-0.2200012505054474,
-0.23799410462379456,
-0.006327114999294281,
0.4895273447036743,
-0.6360962390899658,
0.371236652135849,
0.3116244375705719,
-0.2106710970401764,
-0.3317584693431854,
-0.8048946261405945,
-0.11376441270112991,
0.4667496681213379,
-0.4462581276893616,
0.20441429316997528,
0.45234617590904236,
0.09378241002559662,
-0.07189686596393585,
0.6126102805137634,
-0.03571559116244316,
-0.018744494765996933,
0.1895739883184433,
0.15649008750915527,
-0.3897389769554138,
-0.2135244905948639,
-0.5294094085693359,
0.2631860375404358,
-0.3593898415565491,
-0.4949985146522522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10416v1 | Grounding Language about Belief in a Bayesian Theory-of-Mind | 2024-02-16T02:47:09 | 2024-02-16T02:47:09 | Lance Ying, Tan Zhi-Xuan, Lionel Wong, Vikash Mansinghka, Joshua Tenenbaum | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the fact that beliefs are mental states that cannot be directly
observed, humans talk about each others' beliefs on a regular basis, often
using rich compositional language to describe what others think and know. What
explains this capacity to interpret the hidden epistemic content of other
minds? In this paper, we take a step towards an answer by grounding the
semantics of belief statements in a Bayesian theory-of-mind: By modeling how
humans jointly infer coherent sets of goals, beliefs, and plans that explain an
agent's actions, then evaluating statements about the agent's beliefs against
these inferences via epistemic logic, our framework provides a conceptual role
semantics for belief, explaining the gradedness and compositionality of human
belief attributions, as well as their intimate connection with goals and plans.
We evaluate this framework by studying how humans attribute goals and beliefs
while watching an agent solve a doors-and-keys gridworld puzzle that requires
instrumental reasoning about hidden objects. In contrast to pure logical
deduction, non-mentalizing baselines, and mentalizing that ignores the role of
instrumental plans, our model provides a much better fit to human goal and
belief attributions, demonstrating the importance of theory-of-mind for a
semantics of belief. | [
-0.56651771068573,
-0.6675834059715271,
1.1105624437332153,
-0.07356587052345276,
-0.17237131297588348,
0.0998108834028244,
-0.20991569757461548,
-0.1740330010652542,
0.17113712430000305,
0.44226232171058655,
-0.5054702758789062,
-0.5427824854850769,
-0.5368687510490417,
-0.3126472532749176,
0.2249414026737213,
0.7421112060546875,
-0.013472199440002441,
-0.28531959652900696,
-0.34540122747421265,
0.14177201688289642,
-0.4508163332939148,
-0.3043234646320343,
-0.37721362709999084,
-0.6120405197143555,
0.48514413833618164,
0.1706196516752243,
0.9488002061843872,
0.5127590298652649,
0.17843550443649292,
0.12103515863418579,
0.10458256304264069,
-0.2035389244556427,
-0.30499884486198425,
0.2358291894197464,
-0.6756032705307007,
-1.01841402053833,
-0.13048583269119263,
0.2030019909143448,
0.4537808895111084,
0.737912118434906,
-0.3168957531452179,
-0.17213137447834015,
-0.11147656291723251,
0.27706608176231384,
-0.7329238653182983,
0.5932149291038513,
-0.6335983276367188,
0.22417721152305603,
0.4500029981136322,
-0.11509633809328079,
-0.21140818297863007,
-0.2988817095756531,
0.17231860756874084,
-0.44155317544937134,
0.3574572503566742,
-0.11036445945501328,
0.8776010274887085,
0.4142237901687622,
-0.44962260127067566,
0.04583021253347397,
-0.5085064172744751,
0.705784261226654,
-0.4570055305957794,
0.37100809812545776,
0.7871116399765015,
0.2515752911567688,
-0.3125506341457367,
0.04412167891860008,
-0.8591384887695312,
-0.2615201473236084,
-0.17326048016548157,
0.27249664068222046,
0.04671165347099304,
0.3440791666507721,
0.5591008067131042,
0.21064810454845428,
-0.34301871061325073,
-0.46324169635772705,
0.28742319345474243,
0.0026646822225302458,
0.4385083019733429,
-0.10194122791290283,
0.299517422914505,
0.11936010420322418,
-0.14313118159770966,
-0.23477178812026978,
-0.5963013172149658,
-0.03245797008275986,
0.027375904843211174,
0.07888723164796829,
0.06386496126651764,
0.4693223536014557,
-0.6088086366653442,
0.4229980707168579,
0.10313806682825089,
-0.14652173221111298,
-0.17069613933563232,
0.2377355992794037,
-0.2818056643009186,
0.16456818580627441,
0.04365479573607445,
0.5515018105506897,
0.24173040688037872,
-0.4456225037574768,
-0.18262889981269836,
1.1911442279815674,
0.4400802552700043,
-0.5467624664306641,
-0.23971574008464813,
0.10420208424329758,
-0.42686131596565247,
-0.16831757128238678,
0.22172217071056366,
-0.32300904393196106,
-0.5917995572090149,
-0.3271770477294922,
0.6900477409362793,
-0.33794596791267395,
-0.5380181074142456,
0.4927464425563812,
-0.4463368058204651,
0.25659021735191345,
0.4667414128780365,
-0.8419756293296814,
0.7059221267700195,
0.9106329679489136,
0.3583758473396301,
0.25353652238845825,
-0.4261395037174225,
-0.2073580026626587,
0.6913300156593323,
-0.5881943106651306,
0.7132490873336792,
-0.7511445879936218,
-0.37682196497917175,
-0.17718252539634705,
-0.0198659747838974,
-0.014808012172579765,
-0.0810546949505806,
0.5165705680847168,
-0.20201466977596283,
-0.023833969607949257,
-0.8553124070167542,
-0.9478596448898315,
-0.4051623046398163,
0.23453876376152039,
-0.16847288608551025,
0.3219795227050781,
-0.07477843761444092,
-0.5779211521148682,
0.7522199749946594,
-0.6761277914047241,
-0.32746654748916626,
0.04202334210276604,
-0.7094535231590271,
0.12836256623268127,
0.6341657638549805,
-0.17133714258670807,
0.4485735297203064,
-0.37742727994918823,
0.4526570439338684,
-0.3688545227050781,
-0.2584727108478546,
0.5653097033500671,
-0.38794639706611633,
0.5803901553153992,
0.09709958732128143,
-0.7131466269493103,
-0.29219239950180054,
-0.554960310459137,
0.13649773597717285,
0.09786707907915115,
-0.04437007009983063,
-0.5657893419265747,
0.7626969814300537,
-0.6724799275398254,
0.15401983261108398,
0.1700476109981537,
-0.6704943180084229,
0.2820446193218231,
-0.444940984249115,
0.14477793872356415,
0.5983874201774597,
0.06795579195022583,
0.5637306571006775,
-0.5428916215896606,
0.06090168282389641,
0.10941567271947861,
0.08039576560258865,
0.02900470420718193,
-0.7861859798431396,
-0.528905987739563,
-0.02315618097782135,
-0.06466560065746307,
0.37515929341316223,
-0.12702201306819916,
0.6234530210494995,
-0.09133400022983551,
-0.20897497236728668,
-0.33133500814437866,
-0.30092406272888184,
0.3233073651790619,
0.4120202958583832,
0.14256638288497925,
-0.19074338674545288,
-0.1598217785358429,
-1.0456273555755615,
-0.2899653911590576,
-0.593499481678009,
-0.1460479348897934,
-0.07836506515741348,
0.6533066630363464,
-0.2729482352733612,
1.1929874420166016,
-0.9620175957679749,
0.08048027753829956,
0.07574683427810669,
0.26641008257865906,
0.17202159762382507,
0.598872721195221,
0.37003254890441895,
-0.9244133234024048,
-0.2230660617351532,
0.2162308394908905,
-0.9117980599403381,
0.08175060153007507,
-0.1353314369916916,
-0.3396032154560089,
-0.1615612506866455,
-0.17035870254039764,
-1.062625765800476,
0.9170738458633423,
0.008104941807687283,
-0.7489478588104248,
0.2899876534938812,
-0.08203058689832687,
0.2831452488899231,
-0.8723136186599731,
-0.4963589012622833,
-0.030107107013463974,
-0.09174324572086334,
-0.43455687165260315,
0.363583505153656,
-0.11297020316123962,
0.08231066167354584,
0.17740850150585175,
0.18267269432544708,
-0.2716153860092163,
-0.16438636183738708,
-0.43056344985961914,
0.0004167015431448817,
0.14990830421447754,
0.6246255040168762,
0.6100083589553833,
0.29444998502731323,
0.7952989935874939,
-0.558184027671814,
0.08484835177659988,
0.30707094073295593,
-0.1743493527173996,
0.7671680450439453,
-0.35840192437171936,
-0.1414041817188263,
-0.39187777042388916,
0.34069129824638367,
-0.7932482361793518,
-0.10046309977769852,
0.4131578207015991,
-0.6373246908187866,
0.1218225508928299,
-0.2980525493621826,
-0.4429507553577423,
0.04422827437520027,
0.0783175453543663,
-0.05651196464896202,
0.5466812252998352,
-0.2602905035018921,
0.5050981044769287,
0.57966148853302,
0.06772875040769577,
-0.2248823195695877,
-0.5574544072151184,
0.13091646134853363,
-0.33253011107444763,
-0.42923489212989807,
0.6683452129364014,
0.052762240171432495,
-0.9709016680717468,
0.18679192662239075,
-0.5917528867721558,
-0.1894366294145584,
0.29244163632392883,
0.5237962603569031,
0.10453157126903534,
-0.16153503954410553,
0.37414807081222534,
0.4172289967536926,
-0.32701370120048523,
0.43738576769828796,
-0.8444992899894714,
0.09736490249633789,
-0.2438577562570572,
-0.5378628969192505,
-0.1386813223361969,
0.7448096871376038,
0.3718017637729645,
0.1168142557144165,
0.9228394627571106,
0.11656516045331955,
-0.8051429986953735,
-0.28843024373054504,
-0.41727414727211,
-0.34740781784057617,
-0.34670692682266235,
-0.022030536085367203,
-0.7226485013961792,
-0.6067899465560913,
0.38924384117126465,
-0.02563326060771942,
-0.1503983438014984,
0.32642316818237305,
0.4697237014770508,
-0.3535669147968292,
1.1025500297546387,
0.6574956178665161,
0.2033776193857193,
0.013326533138751984,
-0.07391571253538132,
0.07254347205162048,
-0.4345781207084656,
-0.018002862110733986,
-0.2983342409133911,
-0.03033214621245861,
-0.5327626466751099,
-0.5343829989433289,
0.2195741832256317,
0.3279074430465698,
-0.32283446192741394,
0.12155820429325104,
-0.28864428400993347,
0.6490482091903687,
0.289791464805603,
0.3209892809391022,
0.14199908077716827,
-0.04313793033361435,
-0.3709506392478943,
-0.01352622825652361,
-0.48138758540153503,
-0.8157945275306702,
0.7951653599739075,
0.4095161259174347,
0.7093362212181091,
0.37087661027908325,
0.6499447822570801,
0.4291993975639343,
0.11838928610086441,
-0.8594133257865906,
0.43823692202568054,
0.3612823784351349,
-0.9236411452293396,
-0.20833919942378998,
-0.126915842294693,
-0.4746463894844055,
0.6529543995857239,
-0.20579271018505096,
-1.0899441242218018,
0.3391627371311188,
0.08475849777460098,
-0.2125893384218216,
0.37400031089782715,
-0.5503092408180237,
0.986582338809967,
-0.016953416168689728,
-0.3629555404186249,
-0.7481100559234619,
-0.7606496810913086,
0.03963841125369072,
0.2769036591053009,
0.06123074144124985,
-0.05285317450761795,
-0.008639557287096977,
0.6637218594551086,
-0.5020334124565125,
1.0597678422927856,
-0.3753022253513336,
-0.4335903823375702,
0.43251749873161316,
0.1264926791191101,
0.5348659157752991,
0.27605119347572327,
0.2277580201625824,
0.06048472225666046,
0.24799109995365143,
-0.4927827715873718,
-1.0132579803466797,
0.42092862725257874,
-0.884770393371582,
-0.9185789227485657,
-0.43062761425971985,
-0.31245312094688416,
-0.3921252191066742,
0.006466659717261791,
0.05306249111890793,
0.36122626066207886,
-0.31892839074134827,
-0.11553000658750534,
1.0931141376495361,
-0.015283427201211452,
-0.08964769542217255,
0.6475233435630798,
-0.3165316879749298,
0.03369942680001259,
0.8851713538169861,
-0.16436071693897247,
0.3780520260334015,
0.8337616920471191,
0.35756534337997437,
-0.3714997470378876,
-0.2513328790664673,
0.16998140513896942,
0.2261877804994583,
-1.050328016281128,
0.31727802753448486,
-0.6245905756950378,
0.2785714864730835,
-0.2314557284116745,
-0.20019258558750153,
-0.2898789048194885,
-0.33065056800842285,
0.007588058244436979,
-0.4085666239261627,
0.0735418051481247,
0.6597985029220581,
-0.18962796032428741,
0.3527962267398834,
-0.5323505401611328,
0.47097140550613403,
0.5801816582679749,
0.20637351274490356,
-0.14016874134540558,
-0.13002637028694153,
-0.31903600692749023,
0.5214986205101013,
-0.17876562476158142,
-1.2641688585281372,
0.054677318781614304,
-0.08226475119590759,
0.8439631462097168,
0.5439417958259583,
0.054608117789030075,
0.6752216219902039,
-0.3393803536891937,
0.3402971029281616,
0.09759838879108429,
-1.0772895812988281,
0.7511736154556274,
-0.5677324533462524,
-0.06438679248094559,
0.48882073163986206,
0.3070491552352905,
-0.5410781502723694,
-0.4197508990764618,
-0.8678839206695557,
-0.022911114618182182,
0.28687724471092224,
0.2607819437980652,
-0.20602849125862122,
-0.32459142804145813,
0.43921512365341187,
0.2757298946380615,
0.4633783996105194,
-0.4970315098762512,
-0.2218802273273468,
-0.4485405683517456,
0.004958282690495253,
-0.17081880569458008,
-0.0005415629711933434,
-0.45001888275146484,
-0.3443017899990082,
0.32229819893836975,
-0.4375707805156708,
0.7209380865097046,
0.2176012545824051,
-0.16686752438545227,
-0.4709140658378601,
0.4369088411331177,
0.41679880023002625,
0.8028302788734436,
-0.21837252378463745,
0.4034104645252228,
-0.050290852785110474,
-0.15089912712574005,
0.16051089763641357,
-0.1896277666091919,
-0.2718259394168854,
-0.2821398377418518,
0.21917670965194702,
0.8251360058784485,
0.2938942611217499,
-0.3604480028152466,
0.3557000458240509,
-0.01300311740487814,
-0.14970149099826813,
-0.3204120397567749,
0.15503808856010437,
0.14298109710216522,
0.4679591953754425,
0.3839898705482483,
0.31272751092910767,
0.0026047020219266415,
-1.1287330389022827,
0.2829609215259552,
0.36539992690086365,
-0.26371270418167114,
-0.6137199997901917,
0.5080282688140869,
-0.283214807510376,
-0.001019444433040917,
0.03340170159935951,
-0.37383073568344116,
-0.8787904977798462,
0.5230218768119812,
0.643792986869812,
0.9931422472000122,
0.12826032936573029,
0.5936892628669739,
-0.11226791143417358,
0.3782655894756317,
-0.20047229528427124,
0.4375256299972534,
-0.394076943397522,
-1.3507753610610962,
-0.37978431582450867,
-0.7132275700569153,
-0.48815593123435974,
-0.21160608530044556,
-0.6841973662376404,
-0.1847410500049591,
-0.3165372312068939,
-0.2604874074459076,
-0.21887442469596863,
0.12592753767967224,
-0.4705415368080139,
0.45138928294181824,
0.37800389528274536,
0.4855300784111023,
-1.054970145225525,
0.7580134868621826,
0.7987703084945679,
-0.49585267901420593,
-0.6498779058456421,
0.4759460687637329,
-0.10941513627767563,
-0.5288717746734619,
0.6331453323364258,
0.027332505211234093,
-0.13646599650382996,
0.11440849304199219,
-0.7004839181900024,
-0.8920149207115173,
0.8571194410324097,
0.2539388835430145,
-0.29957303404808044,
-0.10130498558282852,
-0.21039727330207825,
0.4787219166755676,
-0.6665393114089966,
0.03360544890165329,
0.4840092360973358,
0.6456167101860046,
-0.08919043093919754,
-0.5230660438537598,
0.17440202832221985,
0.009480944834649563,
-0.19888931512832642,
0.1633932739496231,
-0.4586234986782074,
0.9122591018676758,
-0.11884097009897232,
-0.2714892029762268,
-0.2953900098800659,
0.6778537034988403,
0.3171667158603668,
0.23474982380867004,
0.41002601385116577,
0.697802722454071,
0.7733750939369202,
-0.032131653279066086,
1.0123742818832397,
-0.010000880807638168,
0.2989366054534912,
0.8754605054855347,
-0.42243993282318115,
0.6160241961479187,
0.3740532696247101,
-0.5014865398406982,
0.7199453711509705,
0.5052030086517334,
0.32107096910476685,
0.7547110915184021,
0.20146186649799347,
-0.2610549330711365,
-0.697911262512207,
0.03331202268600464,
-0.21276944875717163,
0.4246666729450226,
0.7834281921386719,
0.001429285272024572,
-0.11764277517795563,
-0.18771126866340637,
-0.3374882936477661,
0.15747876465320587,
-0.32610365748405457,
0.6323567032814026,
0.07938995212316513,
-0.830187201499939,
0.3143547475337982,
-0.02369922213256359,
0.25471577048301697,
-0.3637024462223053,
-0.2722143828868866,
0.2568058669567108,
0.1577359437942505,
-0.055429521948099136,
-0.7598972320556641,
0.2477121651172638,
-0.24810276925563812,
-0.3225836753845215,
-0.18978142738342285,
0.9719597101211548,
-0.21375146508216858,
-0.07076667994260788,
0.14013688266277313,
0.591143012046814,
0.23016653954982758,
-0.3915511667728424,
-0.5653029084205627,
-0.1437494456768036,
-0.15905296802520752,
-0.019487710669636726,
0.43607527017593384,
0.5673956274986267,
-0.19632913172245026,
0.5856141448020935,
0.4624198377132416,
0.2851050794124603,
-0.15968602895736694,
-0.04595624655485153,
0.7865790128707886,
-0.8535205125808716,
-0.8799828886985779,
-0.8245536684989929,
0.35774269700050354,
-0.012835786677896976,
0.08188977092504501,
0.6013705134391785,
0.11089543998241425,
0.7574355006217957,
-0.1250862330198288,
1.1691009998321533,
-0.15449360013008118,
0.2509111762046814,
-0.41121286153793335,
0.7775875926017761,
-0.3528957664966583,
0.06741385161876678,
-0.5028942823410034,
-1.0894666910171509,
-0.02286015823483467,
1.3886380195617676,
-0.34214070439338684,
-0.26172584295272827,
0.7907755374908447,
0.3658903241157532,
0.30402180552482605,
0.3720848560333252,
0.6294598579406738,
0.27542296051979065,
0.1381748765707016,
0.5156777501106262,
1.3064894676208496,
-0.17193253338336945,
-0.283046156167984,
-0.1871775984764099,
-0.4500464200973511,
0.03331029415130615,
-0.5847463607788086,
-0.9273176789283752,
-0.5350962281227112,
-0.5404458045959473,
-0.11113359034061432,
-0.10776069760322571,
0.9845906496047974,
0.404904305934906,
-0.6591419577598572,
-0.36066752672195435,
-0.45813626050949097,
0.43312615156173706,
-0.5103850364685059,
-0.22718890011310577,
-0.16332994401454926,
-0.1690244823694229,
-0.3133060932159424,
0.5276760458946228,
0.5033606886863708,
-0.005496353376656771,
-0.32572734355926514,
-0.1958097219467163,
-0.11575827747583389,
0.20220091938972473,
0.5433315634727478,
0.10191614925861359,
-1.0087907314300537,
-0.7441408038139343,
-0.32862532138824463,
0.10046067088842392,
-0.03103092685341835,
0.7622693181037903,
-0.934371829032898,
0.32906341552734375,
0.33429306745529175,
0.24041377007961273,
0.26550352573394775,
0.017044246196746826,
0.7575811147689819,
-0.25333690643310547,
-0.07639402151107788,
0.236564502120018,
0.4266461730003357,
-0.11640625447034836,
-0.27245858311653137,
0.4029686152935028,
0.5722246766090393,
-0.2423444241285324,
-0.7173587679862976,
0.6554325222969055,
-0.7285398840904236,
-0.4209561049938202,
0.7378612160682678,
-0.350276917219162,
-0.3110705316066742,
-0.258310467004776,
-0.15437805652618408,
0.3374013602733612,
-0.45139846205711365,
0.7000592947006226,
0.8389384150505066,
0.016887633129954338,
0.003518685232847929,
-0.3763308525085449,
0.47841736674308777,
0.3179512619972229,
-0.6121221780776978,
0.11091344058513641,
0.6315182447433472,
0.14083468914031982,
0.3920997381210327,
0.5769174695014954,
0.3801495432853699,
0.13952237367630005,
0.5921299457550049,
-0.19581952691078186,
0.41321316361427307,
-0.44361940026283264,
0.01046268455684185,
0.25242099165916443,
0.036324482411146164,
-0.09261221438646317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10412v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10412v2 | Measuring and Reducing LLM Hallucination without Gold-Standard Answers | 2024-02-16T02:32:06 | 2024-06-06T18:33:02 | Jiaheng Wei, Yuanshun Yao, Jean-Francois Ton, Hongyi Guo, Andrew Estornell, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | LLM hallucination, i.e. generating factually incorrect yet seemingly
convincing answers, is currently a major threat to the trustworthiness and
reliability of LLMs. The first step towards solving this complicated problem is
to measure it. However, existing hallucination metrics require having a
benchmark dataset with gold-standard answers, i.e. "best" or "correct" answers
written by humans. Such requirements make hallucination measurement costly and
prone to human errors. In this work, we propose Factualness Evaluations via
Weighting LLMs (FEWL), an innovative hallucination metric that is specifically
designed for the scenario when gold-standard answers are absent. FEWL leverages
the answers from off-the-shelf LLMs that serve as a proxy of gold-standard
answers. The key challenge is how to quantify the expertise of reference LLMs
resourcefully. We show FEWL has certain theoretical guarantees and demonstrate
empirically it gives more accurate hallucination measures than naively using
reference LLMs. We also show how to leverage FEWL to reduce hallucination
through both in-context learning and supervised fine-tuning. Extensive
experiment results on Truthful-QA, CHALE, and HaluEval datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of FEWL. | [
-0.47260767221450806,
-0.7014087438583374,
0.8107839226722717,
0.037212248891592026,
-0.08962064981460571,
-0.13842502236366272,
-0.16336779296398163,
-0.45313560962677,
0.3785082995891571,
0.4241383969783783,
-0.7854118347167969,
-0.6151177287101746,
-0.4707805812358856,
0.47501400113105774,
-0.25497567653656006,
1.0704090595245361,
0.2194259762763977,
0.09838800132274628,
-0.5144805312156677,
-0.40453478693962097,
-0.2328331470489502,
-0.3751430809497833,
-0.1688394397497177,
-0.5688042640686035,
0.6073366403579712,
0.39554673433303833,
0.6853370666503906,
0.23698587715625763,
0.624522864818573,
0.1587354987859726,
-0.07626711577177048,
0.5924106240272522,
-0.803013801574707,
-0.3603627383708954,
0.03189236670732498,
-0.6193429231643677,
-0.6018837094306946,
0.09136208146810532,
0.20494018495082855,
0.9120655655860901,
-0.12226756662130356,
0.4628232717514038,
0.15785294771194458,
0.9270682334899902,
-0.6324863433837891,
-0.14117516577243805,
-0.7836561799049377,
0.36206910014152527,
-0.04136183112859726,
-0.5804315209388733,
-0.32609814405441284,
-0.5228713154792786,
-0.15074411034584045,
-0.5270475745201111,
0.4397127032279968,
0.10619395971298218,
0.7149495482444763,
0.816731870174408,
-0.11719558387994766,
-0.3814530372619629,
-0.7682235836982727,
0.8325129151344299,
-0.6947888731956482,
0.47416946291923523,
0.7046425938606262,
0.23698122799396515,
-0.05464714393019676,
-0.48987793922424316,
-0.4479147493839264,
-0.47753819823265076,
-0.31706899404525757,
0.08749350905418396,
0.05726856738328934,
-0.09335236251354218,
0.4851109981536865,
0.17839141190052032,
-0.7609124779701233,
-0.17666207253932953,
-0.3005654513835907,
-0.42011526226997375,
0.5215076804161072,
0.25791922211647034,
-0.10048756748437881,
-0.20526759326457977,
-0.2827204465866089,
0.2635555863380432,
-0.8091081380844116,
-0.37404170632362366,
0.24524812400341034,
0.17003774642944336,
0.18445700407028198,
0.6428194046020508,
-0.19390076398849487,
0.293522447347641,
0.17019563913345337,
-0.45784875750541687,
0.2399926483631134,
-0.33846917748451233,
-0.24716134369373322,
0.35419419407844543,
0.351083904504776,
0.3630317747592926,
0.23518113791942596,
-0.6983298063278198,
-0.26650917530059814,
0.3015942871570587,
0.308215856552124,
-0.7791029810905457,
-0.32919082045555115,
0.35442599654197693,
-0.4447420537471771,
-0.21031856536865234,
0.017341814935207367,
-0.630681574344635,
-0.6999735832214355,
-0.2228759229183197,
0.5614698529243469,
-0.3573872745037079,
0.06869464367628098,
0.08326087892055511,
0.03897302225232124,
0.23867174983024597,
0.41656991839408875,
-0.7362747192382812,
0.6107724905014038,
0.6850906610488892,
0.9684458374977112,
-0.5151116251945496,
-0.14287644624710083,
-0.8323317170143127,
-0.04994462430477142,
-0.5375369787216187,
0.8251470923423767,
0.049446746706962585,
-0.36183983087539673,
-0.21475492417812347,
-0.10590900480747223,
0.19765529036521912,
-1.0072559118270874,
0.7692250609397888,
-0.4697888195514679,
-0.0805170089006424,
-0.6065122485160828,
-0.6905953288078308,
-0.20468558371067047,
0.5328797698020935,
-0.6173944473266602,
0.8008577227592468,
-0.022754700854420662,
-0.6636649966239929,
0.4617755115032196,
-0.27021390199661255,
-0.28779396414756775,
0.09792057424783707,
-0.23791278898715973,
-0.45017677545547485,
0.33954575657844543,
0.1838606745004654,
0.28581950068473816,
0.03651449456810951,
0.08294127881526947,
-0.37831205129623413,
-0.8290998339653015,
0.5389083027839661,
-0.488148957490921,
0.5572085976600647,
0.0814318135380745,
-0.41466692090034485,
-0.05415188521146774,
-0.8394424915313721,
-0.11913348734378815,
-0.17217513918876648,
-0.033762626349925995,
-0.18912014365196228,
-0.09724736213684082,
-0.161800816655159,
0.061846643686294556,
0.22708219289779663,
-0.4283527433872223,
-0.16460058093070984,
-0.5243880748748779,
-0.23490430414676666,
0.8144491910934448,
-0.07546205073595047,
0.26894959807395935,
-0.7643678784370422,
0.21982699632644653,
-0.1426653265953064,
0.09213985502719879,
0.5212163329124451,
-0.2877540588378906,
-0.9507379531860352,
-0.23175372183322906,
0.015231060795485973,
0.5889233350753784,
-0.38995909690856934,
0.6128202676773071,
-0.3044990301132202,
-0.29552212357521057,
-0.8136586546897888,
0.6584831476211548,
0.2495451420545578,
0.6469202637672424,
0.607221245765686,
-0.20218485593795776,
-0.46248286962509155,
-0.702573835849762,
-0.23909109830856323,
-0.28112074732780457,
-0.2531569004058838,
0.36507704854011536,
0.59257572889328,
-0.3031480610370636,
0.8894683122634888,
-0.48701080679893494,
-0.8640588521957397,
0.07105863839387894,
0.16081508994102478,
0.17695550620555878,
0.20514513552188873,
0.3231572210788727,
-0.5057426691055298,
-0.05346193164587021,
-0.21403521299362183,
-1.1289563179016113,
-0.10542769730091095,
-0.2481870800256729,
0.11126630008220673,
0.4417087733745575,
0.22560568153858185,
-0.6671645641326904,
0.36198344826698303,
0.3493260443210602,
-0.18348267674446106,
0.6724280118942261,
-0.08435836434364319,
0.17331737279891968,
-0.44927898049354553,
0.05895764008164406,
-0.14488106966018677,
-0.2772969603538513,
-0.40397632122039795,
-0.16048486530780792,
-0.137800931930542,
0.3643282353878021,
-0.4232039153575897,
0.456418514251709,
-0.13246053457260132,
-0.346475213766098,
-0.19451645016670227,
0.40995967388153076,
0.0075778961181640625,
0.3820188045501709,
0.006329899653792381,
0.6582466959953308,
0.12364299595355988,
-0.5720077753067017,
0.33710262179374695,
0.3629036843776703,
-0.30329713225364685,
0.6665480136871338,
-0.5420922636985779,
0.3214457929134369,
-0.008590682409703732,
0.05481164902448654,
-0.9624842405319214,
-0.06667771935462952,
0.33270516991615295,
-0.47748714685440063,
-0.18709245324134827,
0.06688828766345978,
-0.6149265170097351,
-0.038228850811719894,
-0.4444189965724945,
0.11464408040046692,
0.6317574977874756,
-0.6487222909927368,
0.3590935468673706,
-0.14553749561309814,
0.12005525827407837,
-0.4458625614643097,
-0.9058706164360046,
0.15496161580085754,
-0.3297542333602905,
-0.5535674095153809,
0.37411242723464966,
-0.5302047729492188,
-0.4482266902923584,
-0.009604631923139095,
-0.6637561917304993,
0.16781583428382874,
0.10353432595729828,
0.13047854602336884,
0.23366543650627136,
-0.19473133981227875,
0.19716326892375946,
-0.11697643250226974,
-0.36688870191574097,
0.4051867127418518,
-0.09388367831707001,
0.3335427939891815,
-0.37838059663772583,
-0.6479458808898926,
-0.6737698912620544,
-0.10214996337890625,
0.4565621316432953,
0.27265194058418274,
0.6514618396759033,
0.6975764036178589,
-0.5452488660812378,
-0.1247078999876976,
-0.8493981957435608,
-0.7002676129341125,
-0.45548924803733826,
0.14866696298122406,
-0.3841235935688019,
-0.7397721409797668,
0.5833334922790527,
-0.16663572192192078,
0.10899661481380463,
0.030304256826639175,
0.5835382342338562,
-0.17306114733219147,
0.9447171688079834,
0.2838667929172516,
0.22381703555583954,
-0.20483358204364777,
-0.08613094687461853,
0.27660468220710754,
-0.5671656727790833,
-0.32455870509147644,
-0.29288551211357117,
-0.3736829161643982,
-0.5420581698417664,
-0.411893367767334,
0.525687575340271,
-0.11021887511014938,
-0.010157149285078049,
-0.28281494975090027,
-0.4390091300010681,
0.5625088810920715,
0.2005021870136261,
0.5167794823646545,
0.7109492421150208,
0.0211750790476799,
0.2712075412273407,
-0.2813299298286438,
-0.48277387022972107,
-0.9146947860717773,
1.0727694034576416,
0.1573866456747055,
0.9265866875648499,
0.06407080590724945,
1.0496900081634521,
0.4462043046951294,
0.30010685324668884,
-0.9518703818321228,
0.645898163318634,
-0.023037031292915344,
-0.6080352663993835,
-0.4716661274433136,
-0.6809850931167603,
-0.5744717121124268,
0.24018481373786926,
-0.3155216872692108,
-0.6049494743347168,
-0.06917888671159744,
0.14310947060585022,
-0.6832072138786316,
0.2635468542575836,
-0.17309430241584778,
0.5380106568336487,
-0.32782623171806335,
-0.5632355213165283,
-0.19808067381381989,
-0.556389570236206,
0.6286686062812805,
-0.25602924823760986,
0.08076414465904236,
-0.21794778108596802,
-0.13649670779705048,
0.9325523376464844,
-0.34959495067596436,
0.939355194568634,
-0.04024222865700722,
-0.1282530575990677,
0.1559727042913437,
0.24810579419136047,
0.6378876566886902,
0.3141835331916809,
-0.13255633413791656,
0.17466071248054504,
0.0930672436952591,
-0.41572150588035583,
-0.7855605483055115,
0.9068859219551086,
-0.8495113253593445,
-0.5415483713150024,
-0.41950052976608276,
-0.57926344871521,
-0.35258233547210693,
-0.09589477628469467,
0.36036932468414307,
0.019935283809900284,
-0.32866498827934265,
0.017657887190580368,
1.1603153944015503,
0.01134532317519188,
0.1034146323800087,
0.30705755949020386,
-0.02393011376261711,
-0.37261566519737244,
0.8919647932052612,
0.33350127935409546,
0.018254276365041733,
0.09371402114629745,
0.33179837465286255,
-0.3740819990634918,
-0.5138902068138123,
-0.1830061972141266,
0.40379756689071655,
-0.8784575462341309,
-0.18004748225212097,
-0.7346166968345642,
-0.10198163986206055,
-0.42971041798591614,
-0.2866378128528595,
-0.4167293608188629,
-0.4079466760158539,
-0.49437275528907776,
-0.3579278886318207,
0.42993950843811035,
0.44805124402046204,
-0.14271186292171478,
0.02754574455320835,
-0.6614319682121277,
0.7903993129730225,
0.6073549389839172,
0.23868221044540405,
-0.0755184143781662,
-0.7121913433074951,
-0.05420343577861786,
-0.02040058560669422,
-0.1436653435230255,
-0.7273101806640625,
0.3659682273864746,
0.09491077065467834,
0.4512132704257965,
0.6738664507865906,
0.4710208773612976,
1.0547823905944824,
-0.22062106430530548,
0.8126972913742065,
0.04933253675699234,
-0.9745132327079773,
0.3233897387981415,
0.35726332664489746,
-0.0904429703950882,
0.8701506853103638,
0.2700832784175873,
-0.33330973982810974,
-0.3670161962509155,
-0.5456953048706055,
-0.4718785881996155,
0.4103027284145355,
0.3810390830039978,
-0.04623810946941376,
0.1258324384689331,
0.4133191704750061,
0.46567705273628235,
0.15075571835041046,
-0.8356971144676208,
-0.2631276249885559,
-0.11433868855237961,
-0.11718682944774628,
-0.046852853149175644,
-0.25589799880981445,
-0.5706222057342529,
-0.3463704288005829,
0.7839810848236084,
-0.2588810324668884,
0.033896639943122864,
0.32842743396759033,
-0.4660983681678772,
-0.310698002576828,
0.10286779701709747,
0.6546241641044617,
0.810353696346283,
-0.5331217050552368,
0.5049335360527039,
0.7790036797523499,
-0.2650373578071594,
0.14168056845664978,
-0.3497055172920227,
-0.3203437924385071,
0.21759943664073944,
0.5369395017623901,
0.4461631178855896,
-0.017312103882431984,
-0.6718178391456604,
0.4807463586330414,
0.06540181487798691,
-0.36606377363204956,
-0.5755054354667664,
0.06612927466630936,
-0.009486991912126541,
0.15815919637680054,
0.4051732122898102,
0.07375092804431915,
0.2581290900707245,
-0.22980576753616333,
0.542797327041626,
0.4352082312107086,
-0.553482711315155,
-0.2907521426677704,
0.6084792613983154,
0.07073259353637695,
-0.26784461736679077,
0.741392970085144,
-0.36558201909065247,
-0.17020706832408905,
0.5086144208908081,
0.5372008681297302,
0.9330877661705017,
0.14179953932762146,
0.26704955101013184,
0.2712828814983368,
0.6703824400901794,
-0.1108594685792923,
0.25454574823379517,
0.006905344780534506,
-0.7185266017913818,
-0.21499735116958618,
-0.6442675590515137,
-0.469061940908432,
0.21645452082157135,
-0.6369017362594604,
0.2575729191303253,
-0.5169401168823242,
-0.15691088140010834,
-0.5047447681427002,
0.3109980523586273,
-0.6605344414710999,
0.07814116030931473,
0.25415974855422974,
0.6765466332435608,
-1.0812536478042603,
0.5201163291931152,
0.41117173433303833,
-0.37379246950149536,
-0.22759251296520233,
0.2523035407066345,
0.2264583855867386,
-0.7344021201133728,
0.51303631067276,
0.3358982801437378,
-0.49798107147216797,
-0.05703381448984146,
-0.7845808267593384,
-0.511846661567688,
1.1354572772979736,
0.40203896164894104,
-0.46047478914260864,
0.14150470495224,
0.20505106449127197,
0.47392430901527405,
-0.10670915246009827,
0.01602553203701973,
0.8765235543251038,
0.7081634402275085,
0.27535784244537354,
-0.5566087365150452,
0.23509366810321808,
0.1217200979590416,
-0.2823643088340759,
-0.24488213658332825,
-0.5850074887275696,
0.3282608091831207,
-0.520831286907196,
-0.19990703463554382,
0.13214319944381714,
0.7379167675971985,
0.7422704100608826,
0.7488455176353455,
0.5501661896705627,
0.6414753198623657,
1.2237458229064941,
0.04705046862363815,
0.6238164305686951,
-0.13743305206298828,
0.2796849310398102,
1.0649311542510986,
-0.5752565860748291,
0.5202174186706543,
0.9371734261512756,
-0.16439446806907654,
0.1331392377614975,
0.6642612218856812,
-0.1196451410651207,
0.523806095123291,
0.30591124296188354,
-0.38199323415756226,
-0.6305274367332458,
-0.0653543472290039,
-0.16252976655960083,
0.11501947790384293,
0.2437557727098465,
0.17644670605659485,
-0.15303152799606323,
0.01437035296112299,
-0.03677928447723389,
0.11655101180076599,
-0.04431147500872612,
0.8366237282752991,
0.416481614112854,
-0.31320682168006897,
0.9187778234481812,
-0.32091811299324036,
0.784102737903595,
-0.37787821888923645,
-0.0502287894487381,
-0.699903130531311,
0.03569300100207329,
-0.7035002708435059,
-0.26115044951438904,
0.4120156168937683,
0.18176953494548798,
-0.10933879762887955,
0.016388827934861183,
0.5119630694389343,
-0.25623512268066406,
-0.6827669739723206,
0.28202879428863525,
0.7077842950820923,
0.6141098141670227,
-0.03468244522809982,
-0.4140872657299042,
-0.12563523650169373,
-0.29795125126838684,
-0.14899013936519623,
0.31735894083976746,
0.5458280444145203,
0.19259490072727203,
0.8564507961273193,
0.602437436580658,
0.349069744348526,
0.07137268036603928,
0.10440297424793243,
0.6292924284934998,
-0.6206019520759583,
-0.14738941192626953,
-0.9917973875999451,
0.01660911925137043,
0.0658845528960228,
-0.13923496007919312,
0.80216383934021,
0.5987170934677124,
0.7156286239624023,
-0.03371930867433548,
0.6180887818336487,
0.22429458796977997,
0.23069961369037628,
-0.6769697070121765,
0.8933132290840149,
-0.8111894130706787,
0.6034770607948303,
-0.30260470509529114,
-0.9671921730041504,
-0.5823385119438171,
0.8378034830093384,
-0.010338908061385155,
-0.14700055122375488,
0.9343985319137573,
1.1881229877471924,
-0.003831601934507489,
-0.11971551924943924,
0.7511236071586609,
0.17306891083717346,
0.025119759142398834,
0.5527835488319397,
0.853317141532898,
-0.33947619795799255,
0.7111412882804871,
-0.41148439049720764,
-0.25185272097587585,
-0.4438570737838745,
-0.8190186023712158,
-1.0798797607421875,
-0.11419761925935745,
-0.5739923715591431,
-0.5422505736351013,
0.17712125182151794,
0.9942224025726318,
0.4365476071834564,
-0.9652574062347412,
-0.22155393660068512,
0.07181181758642197,
0.4011188745498657,
-0.6002966165542603,
-0.18087489902973175,
0.5335952639579773,
-0.5293099284172058,
-0.3785213232040405,
0.37613725662231445,
0.22427186369895935,
0.007948274724185467,
-0.41867753863334656,
-0.3951188921928406,
0.30066314339637756,
0.20285077393054962,
0.6092326045036316,
-0.04474684223532677,
-0.9981102347373962,
-0.45967671275138855,
0.3090764880180359,
-0.26393789052963257,
0.29629945755004883,
0.522341251373291,
-0.9306308031082153,
0.20381174981594086,
0.4231856167316437,
0.6346230506896973,
0.2827592194080353,
0.09405824542045593,
-0.10651298612356186,
-0.6811779141426086,
-0.0640978291630745,
0.43835872411727905,
0.07200409471988678,
0.3800466060638428,
-0.5046678781509399,
0.6749894022941589,
0.48384883999824524,
-0.4944825768470764,
-0.9279077053070068,
-0.0030010647606104612,
-1.018454670906067,
-0.18108518421649933,
1.0415807962417603,
0.04835263267159462,
-0.21649658679962158,
-0.2258068323135376,
-0.0602339543402195,
0.19867490231990814,
-0.1807217299938202,
1.4363205432891846,
0.7152178287506104,
-0.4800497889518738,
-0.0520344153046608,
-0.4913204312324524,
0.635063111782074,
0.6240032315254211,
-0.8741908073425293,
0.11718340963125229,
0.5572775602340698,
0.22199729084968567,
0.331574022769928,
0.6613963842391968,
-0.06993968039751053,
0.27696436643600464,
-0.027553383260965347,
0.07733441144227982,
0.05163070559501648,
-0.5025234818458557,
-0.28956690430641174,
0.26107728481292725,
0.19742275774478912,
-0.05977707356214523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10409v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10409v1 | Understanding Survey Paper Taxonomy about Large Language Models via Graph Representation Learning | 2024-02-16T02:21:59 | 2024-02-16T02:21:59 | Jun Zhuang, Casey Kennington | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | As new research on Large Language Models (LLMs) continues, it is difficult to
keep up with new research and models. To help researchers synthesize the new
research many have written survey papers, but even those have become numerous.
In this paper, we develop a method to automatically assign survey papers to a
taxonomy. We collect the metadata of 144 LLM survey papers and explore three
paradigms to classify papers within the taxonomy. Our work indicates that
leveraging graph structure information on co-category graphs can significantly
outperform the language models in two paradigms; pre-trained language models'
fine-tuning and zero-shot/few-shot classifications using LLMs. We find that our
model surpasses an average human recognition level and that fine-tuning LLMs
using weak labels generated by a smaller model, such as the GCN in this study,
can be more effective than using ground-truth labels, revealing the potential
of weak-to-strong generalization in the taxonomy classification task. | [
-0.43136465549468994,
-0.38936951756477356,
0.5286960005760193,
-0.3119601905345917,
-0.31986913084983826,
0.5155957937240601,
-0.17891298234462738,
-0.6421195864677429,
0.43195924162864685,
0.6029558777809143,
-0.05628509074449539,
-0.7186558246612549,
-0.7391263246536255,
0.20626334846019745,
-0.3183537721633911,
1.1394703388214111,
-0.02812574990093708,
-0.03566378355026245,
-0.4487258195877075,
-0.0002719084150157869,
0.04100358858704567,
-0.49503931403160095,
-0.6250735521316528,
-0.4682735204696655,
0.9914270043373108,
0.1507127285003662,
0.5024779438972473,
0.6987982988357544,
0.528300404548645,
0.3098381757736206,
-0.15794935822486877,
0.19591251015663147,
-0.6613550186157227,
-0.18425039947032928,
0.12326391041278839,
-0.6997485756874084,
-0.5323160290718079,
0.15353205800056458,
0.6033087372779846,
1.0544312000274658,
0.059647031128406525,
0.40530145168304443,
0.23968049883842468,
0.11958640813827515,
-0.5041126012802124,
0.4962410032749176,
-0.7644881010055542,
-0.24319733679294586,
-0.32004010677337646,
-0.2547062337398529,
-0.5529596209526062,
-0.32068294286727905,
-0.05838717892765999,
-0.49551260471343994,
0.38512924313545227,
0.12375587224960327,
0.92107754945755,
-0.15606920421123505,
-0.7104977965354919,
-0.3515929579734802,
-0.5752176642417908,
0.43913987278938293,
-0.44121259450912476,
0.20819558203220367,
0.4273785352706909,
0.21361371874809265,
-0.06814223527908325,
-0.7954407930374146,
-0.11989959329366684,
-0.21770958602428436,
-0.11540765315294266,
0.12430962920188904,
-0.17994830012321472,
0.20110656321048737,
0.22254760563373566,
0.31662529706954956,
-0.6288474798202515,
0.45326581597328186,
-0.34556812047958374,
-0.2780972719192505,
0.5844573974609375,
0.27951961755752563,
0.031151333823800087,
-0.2870771288871765,
-0.07724801450967789,
-0.02707267925143242,
-0.6172967553138733,
-0.07952558994293213,
0.23829591274261475,
0.6162714958190918,
0.05907031148672104,
0.5036596655845642,
-0.00736360065639019,
1.0174616575241089,
-0.024418428540229797,
-0.2283993512392044,
0.2812707722187042,
-0.13191011548042297,
-0.18409961462020874,
-0.3248308002948761,
0.7366001009941101,
0.088141068816185,
0.1266648769378662,
-0.3267326056957245,
-0.28969401121139526,
0.03625553846359253,
0.18296563625335693,
-0.47487831115722656,
-0.332674503326416,
-0.27705514430999756,
-0.3852783143520355,
-0.3052150309085846,
-0.046104948967695236,
-0.2863348722457886,
-0.3723440170288086,
-0.5128427743911743,
0.25216391682624817,
0.04713723063468933,
-0.2456461787223816,
0.0917297825217247,
-0.14041177928447723,
0.16258619725704193,
0.5552088022232056,
-0.9050896167755127,
0.5353267788887024,
0.8284758925437927,
0.8645472526550293,
-0.2301102876663208,
-0.14525821805000305,
-0.2735719382762909,
0.24975810945034027,
-0.5074928998947144,
0.966707706451416,
-0.5332680940628052,
-0.2812159061431885,
-0.045278459787368774,
0.0010217142989858985,
-0.14907293021678925,
-0.67616868019104,
0.1581338346004486,
-0.8008543252944946,
0.30799630284309387,
-0.01730736903846264,
-0.5088651776313782,
-0.1469719409942627,
0.5825318098068237,
-0.598307192325592,
0.7938915491104126,
0.337903767824173,
-0.7662765979766846,
0.4955618679523468,
-0.22452552616596222,
-0.05987270176410675,
0.19215604662895203,
-0.13577747344970703,
-0.5719538927078247,
0.1880009025335312,
-0.1021818071603775,
0.6300256848335266,
-0.3019651770591736,
0.2770947515964508,
-0.5726959109306335,
-0.16155976057052612,
0.007527280133217573,
0.10267381370067596,
0.9534950256347656,
0.26713985204696655,
0.34892600774765015,
0.18905587494373322,
-0.5411298274993896,
-0.08018577843904495,
0.14515291154384613,
-0.4833577573299408,
-0.6275568604469299,
-0.1609276384115219,
-0.08784298598766327,
0.05808516964316368,
0.17177392542362213,
-0.4067336618900299,
0.5959045886993408,
-0.33371642231941223,
0.2623288929462433,
0.507279098033905,
-0.02883627451956272,
0.46196413040161133,
-0.3150780200958252,
0.6493310332298279,
-0.2110346406698227,
-0.1766330599784851,
0.1690213829278946,
-0.4003806710243225,
-0.623927652835846,
-0.18945105373859406,
0.7325233221054077,
0.3735203146934509,
-0.45157766342163086,
0.37419620156288147,
-0.6967562437057495,
-0.6384789347648621,
-0.0738925114274025,
0.2876688838005066,
0.07124540954828262,
0.4584411382675171,
0.02452332153916359,
-0.6467524766921997,
-0.5494096279144287,
-0.7355631589889526,
0.017425235360860825,
-0.5876357555389404,
-0.15512019395828247,
0.37945103645324707,
0.6026982069015503,
-0.24502795934677124,
0.933521032333374,
-0.7760676145553589,
-0.3345722258090973,
-0.23621635138988495,
0.5573428273200989,
0.1260722428560257,
-0.04712359607219696,
0.5300039052963257,
-0.5023860335350037,
-0.3733105957508087,
-0.2161872386932373,
-0.5426319241523743,
-0.1874905824661255,
-0.004755998961627483,
0.14427578449249268,
0.07592520862817764,
0.5499280691146851,
-0.40055450797080994,
-0.022842874750494957,
0.4635486900806427,
-0.07719767838716507,
0.43392232060432434,
-0.048843707889318466,
-0.49273842573165894,
-1.1191571950912476,
-0.150181382894516,
0.1695459932088852,
-0.3543550670146942,
-0.3365071415901184,
0.051047880202531815,
-0.14813467860221863,
-0.19988173246383667,
-0.1294480860233307,
0.4997692108154297,
-0.7204453349113464,
-0.17023147642612457,
-0.23292867839336395,
0.029613705351948738,
-0.04596773907542229,
0.3887021839618683,
0.19232839345932007,
0.3557918071746826,
0.40648311376571655,
-0.5336600542068481,
0.19667884707450867,
0.2108045518398285,
-0.23780570924282074,
0.16073459386825562,
-0.317404180765152,
0.2548464238643646,
-0.42392054200172424,
0.5833776593208313,
-1.2137516736984253,
-0.24891327321529388,
0.2468988597393036,
-0.4844874441623688,
0.3680124878883362,
-0.3366168439388275,
-0.5758796334266663,
-0.5322008728981018,
-0.1236094981431961,
0.2698986828327179,
0.32501882314682007,
-0.3830711543560028,
0.6075423955917358,
0.7766034007072449,
-0.1348293572664261,
-0.2029569000005722,
-0.486603707075119,
0.25837600231170654,
-0.3427417278289795,
-0.30675020813941956,
0.2249855250120163,
0.3207532465457916,
-0.13365538418293,
-0.054059967398643494,
0.021563155576586723,
-0.05511924996972084,
0.30620065331459045,
0.14026418328285217,
0.1185717061161995,
-0.19930832087993622,
0.470708429813385,
-0.39715540409088135,
-0.16548798978328705,
0.2491731196641922,
-0.32860076427459717,
0.584563672542572,
-0.06890854984521866,
-0.2853439748287201,
0.2049807608127594,
0.03988717496395111,
0.21253624558448792,
-0.2932480275630951,
0.291147917509079,
0.41270482540130615,
-0.30119144916534424,
-0.11903978884220123,
-0.198499396443367,
-0.09165603667497635,
-0.4166952073574066,
0.5407344698905945,
-0.38470903038978577,
-1.1453169584274292,
0.47249773144721985,
-0.4050266742706299,
0.011874684132635593,
0.5639044046401978,
0.5599851608276367,
-0.2405754178762436,
0.9771468639373779,
0.7288928031921387,
-0.3214331567287445,
0.3568893074989319,
-0.4265819489955902,
0.1099318414926529,
-0.7229286432266235,
-0.22635839879512787,
-0.9351068139076233,
-0.27481338381767273,
-0.775445818901062,
-0.449993371963501,
0.414588063955307,
0.0529642291367054,
-0.3371965289115906,
0.20070812106132507,
-0.4464871883392334,
0.3844810724258423,
0.42631086707115173,
-0.0035117436200380325,
0.4371854066848755,
0.23592908680438995,
0.11290346086025238,
0.13665378093719482,
-0.8532758951187134,
-0.585106611251831,
1.0913819074630737,
0.441337525844574,
1.0799578428268433,
0.030307581648230553,
1.092307686805725,
0.14007560908794403,
0.6857287883758545,
-1.092568278312683,
0.5501874089241028,
-0.4089549779891968,
-0.4795133173465729,
-0.19233262538909912,
-0.3994893729686737,
-1.3022667169570923,
0.21442824602127075,
-0.16162484884262085,
-0.7861672639846802,
0.1792180985212326,
0.17472855746746063,
-0.14645643532276154,
0.3137381672859192,
-0.5126325488090515,
0.5465251803398132,
-0.3726298213005066,
-0.05351196229457855,
0.006383306346833706,
-0.45491787791252136,
0.354245126247406,
-0.02334064245223999,
0.231074720621109,
-0.04129263386130333,
-0.1424521505832672,
0.963857114315033,
-0.007832423783838749,
1.1687744855880737,
-0.1415776163339615,
-0.3368988633155823,
0.3046180307865143,
0.10111120343208313,
0.4531238079071045,
-0.025928936898708344,
0.16752222180366516,
0.15822623670101166,
-0.09535416960716248,
-0.26705193519592285,
-0.5233778357505798,
0.22764211893081665,
-0.8797571063041687,
-0.638839602470398,
-0.5534281730651855,
-0.44297224283218384,
-0.5267468690872192,
0.3128981292247772,
0.2430098056793213,
0.32380473613739014,
-0.3115575313568115,
0.13495726883411407,
0.5419563055038452,
0.08162000775337219,
0.04358142986893654,
0.3900958299636841,
-0.7069539427757263,
-0.2360328584909439,
0.9649384021759033,
0.4513055682182312,
0.1312086433172226,
0.5472710728645325,
0.17109964787960052,
-0.399306982755661,
-0.8337056636810303,
-0.04644745960831642,
0.310824453830719,
-0.7313039302825928,
-0.3584838807582855,
-0.6359590291976929,
-0.28715774416923523,
-0.45113807916641235,
0.1001126617193222,
0.06064996495842934,
-0.3669250011444092,
-0.37700092792510986,
-0.07985199987888336,
0.21153944730758667,
0.9032249450683594,
0.012949846684932709,
0.4630110561847687,
-0.5493534207344055,
0.36158373951911926,
0.5835410356521606,
0.47176089882850647,
0.043892815709114075,
-0.5503102540969849,
-0.35533371567726135,
-0.03396346792578697,
-0.23061059415340424,
-0.7683668732643127,
0.06134026497602463,
0.15918861329555511,
0.49386608600616455,
0.36084261536598206,
-0.1980856955051422,
0.5506552457809448,
-0.2396261990070343,
0.5745240449905396,
0.24996691942214966,
-0.5998421907424927,
0.11340086162090302,
-0.7683015465736389,
0.4285775125026703,
0.43809837102890015,
0.5508686304092407,
-0.5926072597503662,
-0.4794158935546875,
-0.6369449496269226,
-0.7548901438713074,
0.48587852716445923,
-0.41619420051574707,
0.34985238313674927,
-0.001592269167304039,
0.3152902126312256,
-0.005618428811430931,
0.10077089071273804,
-0.8434878587722778,
0.11898205429315567,
0.002685528015717864,
-0.2086164802312851,
-0.3911033570766449,
-0.25162190198898315,
-0.3127480447292328,
-0.45078369975090027,
0.4237959086894989,
-0.5379802584648132,
0.2736974358558655,
-0.34334275126457214,
-0.21153952181339264,
-0.034455787390470505,
0.26618456840515137,
0.3306845724582672,
0.8393491506576538,
-0.2621031701564789,
0.616172730922699,
0.10816024988889694,
-0.3512832224369049,
0.1902853101491928,
-0.0010239643743261695,
-0.26128941774368286,
-0.011915506795048714,
0.6453524231910706,
0.8462936282157898,
-0.16215303540229797,
-0.20777596533298492,
0.2822181284427643,
0.0641295537352562,
-0.4160175025463104,
-0.13606925308704376,
0.08390948176383972,
0.3583735525608063,
-0.17147907614707947,
0.39692381024360657,
-0.05168387293815613,
0.02932298369705677,
-0.5946593880653381,
0.047862209379673004,
0.7033891677856445,
-0.2783327102661133,
-0.23191145062446594,
0.42932286858558655,
0.028230488300323486,
-0.2171243131160736,
0.39908280968666077,
-0.28913044929504395,
-0.5527147054672241,
0.611640453338623,
0.7263296246528625,
0.7523759603500366,
0.1020074188709259,
0.6187384724617004,
0.35049039125442505,
0.251899778842926,
-0.039199020713567734,
0.0685657262802124,
0.09270378202199936,
-0.857952892780304,
-0.5196807384490967,
-0.7154062986373901,
-0.5438328385353088,
0.3883291482925415,
-0.6328129172325134,
0.27262723445892334,
-0.4632481634616852,
-0.23111070692539215,
0.16014233231544495,
0.14513570070266724,
-0.556114137172699,
0.2728118300437927,
0.49224135279655457,
0.7724494934082031,
-1.1428320407867432,
0.6883585453033447,
0.8920432925224304,
-0.2679987847805023,
-0.9826394319534302,
0.010788282379508018,
0.04491102322936058,
-0.8123817443847656,
0.6789907813072205,
-0.15186800062656403,
-0.27081459760665894,
0.12886038422584534,
-0.8175792694091797,
-0.9668599367141724,
0.7582294344902039,
0.40525272488594055,
-0.6104075312614441,
-0.10844933986663818,
0.14844711124897003,
0.8585492968559265,
-0.5498384237289429,
0.2450585961341858,
0.1137135773897171,
0.272666335105896,
0.1408175826072693,
-0.8408694863319397,
-0.09948448091745377,
-0.10857068002223969,
0.1611744612455368,
0.23742049932479858,
-0.5994353890419006,
0.8330066800117493,
-0.012937954626977444,
-0.17836536467075348,
-0.30565446615219116,
0.6050888299942017,
0.22847460210323334,
0.26035502552986145,
0.6678420901298523,
0.593757152557373,
1.0021992921829224,
-0.12477956712245941,
0.8591853380203247,
0.05696392431855202,
0.5230016112327576,
1.152376413345337,
-0.2733982503414154,
0.7258253693580627,
0.26310697197914124,
-0.3380878269672394,
0.5579917430877686,
1.0301283597946167,
-0.2425573319196701,
0.3295409381389618,
0.5839139223098755,
-0.12560875713825226,
-0.4282984435558319,
-0.15277992188930511,
-0.3232567012310028,
0.8104010224342346,
0.41465315222740173,
-0.3035551607608795,
-0.6296249032020569,
-0.042240481823682785,
0.11090385168790817,
-0.05148595944046974,
-0.6145422458648682,
1.1186485290527344,
0.14223681390285492,
-0.6445066332817078,
0.8637563586235046,
-0.01233731023967266,
0.5284010171890259,
-0.5413869619369507,
0.18758761882781982,
-0.001576123177073896,
-0.02466505393385887,
-0.320218563079834,
-0.756676971912384,
0.3125685453414917,
-0.1668364554643631,
-0.06444352120161057,
-0.3716820776462555,
0.843953013420105,
-0.4407121241092682,
-0.6309797167778015,
0.24249668419361115,
0.7012431621551514,
0.1553259938955307,
0.2373182773590088,
-0.5099543333053589,
-0.06266825646162033,
-0.24329784512519836,
-0.05585798621177673,
0.5037933588027954,
0.2762391269207001,
-0.43511494994163513,
0.5418261885643005,
0.31206852197647095,
0.3952607214450836,
-0.14215920865535736,
0.19614243507385254,
0.9477391839027405,
-0.5624479651451111,
-0.4705842435359955,
-0.6759870052337646,
0.03373107686638832,
0.03057641163468361,
-0.229082852602005,
0.780640721321106,
0.8551369309425354,
0.9672892093658447,
-0.08487024903297424,
0.8803592920303345,
-0.05948274955153465,
0.5165881514549255,
-0.4906059503555298,
0.5625844597816467,
-0.5348912477493286,
0.12758775055408478,
-0.18632012605667114,
-0.8476971983909607,
-0.7153774499893188,
0.34805941581726074,
-0.630247950553894,
0.01082208938896656,
0.44181329011917114,
0.7219005823135376,
-0.1826111078262329,
-0.29881322383880615,
-0.031159184873104095,
0.11878090351819992,
0.21559669077396393,
0.5141665935516357,
0.8521552681922913,
0.02022426389157772,
0.5291234850883484,
0.060538023710250854,
-0.06408694386482239,
-0.14652800559997559,
-0.7717992067337036,
-0.8523966670036316,
-0.7456915378570557,
-0.4154011905193329,
-0.48495012521743774,
-0.0729043036699295,
0.6689250469207764,
0.6395247578620911,
-0.5828286409378052,
-0.5315130352973938,
0.11176617443561554,
0.12445351481437683,
0.08861251175403595,
-0.1800786405801773,
0.41819149255752563,
-0.33808159828186035,
-0.5491098761558533,
-0.0568169541656971,
0.20744331181049347,
0.0752398744225502,
-0.3258821368217468,
-0.03146791085600853,
-0.24241238832473755,
-0.27528274059295654,
0.5451422929763794,
0.3031480014324188,
-0.5516219735145569,
-0.4147592782974243,
-0.020080020651221275,
-0.30778661370277405,
0.3414124548435211,
0.9648318886756897,
-0.835597813129425,
0.34843069314956665,
0.6129044890403748,
0.5825667381286621,
0.7562393546104431,
0.012779556214809418,
0.21033848822116852,
-0.8203111886978149,
-0.12029120326042175,
0.48131731152534485,
0.24199478328227997,
0.2791803181171417,
-0.08782318979501724,
0.4686034917831421,
0.23707261681556702,
-0.34479820728302,
-0.8903763294219971,
0.37594226002693176,
-1.016669511795044,
-0.3414323031902313,
1.1126574277877808,
0.08035801351070404,
-0.3001765012741089,
-0.3267211616039276,
-0.16805510222911835,
0.32975688576698303,
-0.0052385032176971436,
0.9513110518455505,
0.7410885691642761,
-0.3118869662284851,
-0.4760224223136902,
-0.13721151649951935,
0.4036845862865448,
0.01029847003519535,
-0.7920001149177551,
-0.06969207525253296,
0.5715182423591614,
0.4289777874946594,
0.4337323307991028,
1.0235695838928223,
0.053511958569288254,
-0.09440065920352936,
-0.29994356632232666,
-0.012716943398118019,
0.004670317284762859,
-0.18693260848522186,
-0.3947485089302063,
0.4882642924785614,
0.5405634045600891,
0.1563698798418045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10400v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10400v2 | Chain of Logic: Rule-Based Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-16T01:54:43 | 2024-02-23T18:55:23 | Sergio Servantez, Joe Barrow, Kristian Hammond, Rajiv Jain | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rule-based reasoning, a fundamental type of legal reasoning, enables us to
draw conclusions by accurately applying a rule to a set of facts. We explore
causal language models as rule-based reasoners, specifically with respect to
compositional rules - rules consisting of multiple elements which form a
complex logical expression. Reasoning about compositional rules is challenging
because it requires multiple reasoning steps, and attending to the logical
relationships between elements. We introduce a new prompting method, Chain of
Logic, which elicits rule-based reasoning through decomposition (solving
elements as independent threads of logic), and recomposition (recombining these
sub-answers to resolve the underlying logical expression). This method was
inspired by the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion) framework, a
sequential reasoning approach used by lawyers. We evaluate chain of logic
across eight rule-based reasoning tasks involving three distinct compositional
rules from the LegalBench benchmark and demonstrate it consistently outperforms
other prompting methods, including chain of thought and self-ask, using
open-source and commercial language models. | [
-0.1971290111541748,
-0.9918546080589294,
1.0412927865982056,
0.29526710510253906,
-0.2033279836177826,
-0.09381841868162155,
0.019820449873805046,
-0.2553054392337799,
-0.027720468118786812,
0.7764036655426025,
-0.7627512812614441,
-0.3531489968299866,
-0.26448649168014526,
0.12028081715106964,
-0.6310994625091553,
0.8615052103996277,
-0.1832370162010193,
0.06588447093963623,
-0.19777177274227142,
-0.23625174164772034,
-0.8306060433387756,
-0.27032238245010376,
-0.5822407603263855,
-0.42229747772216797,
0.8345558047294617,
0.3577445447444916,
0.4551296830177307,
0.7746289968490601,
0.41977331042289734,
0.31557539105415344,
0.04294079542160034,
0.053734421730041504,
-0.1834331601858139,
0.4146670997142792,
-0.5738049149513245,
-0.6157006621360779,
-0.18158335983753204,
-0.08588291704654694,
0.23012147843837738,
0.7252326607704163,
-0.5302746295928955,
-0.01551005244255066,
-0.7651904225349426,
0.9165158867835999,
-0.8358375430107117,
0.06383246928453445,
-0.5501896739006042,
0.04679565131664276,
0.05034514144062996,
-0.2796960175037384,
-0.8231115937232971,
-0.46746256947517395,
0.028421489521861076,
-0.5283260345458984,
-0.2191656231880188,
0.32197752594947815,
0.3494769036769867,
0.17587682604789734,
-0.5575804710388184,
-0.6349060535430908,
-0.7410467267036438,
0.5571973919868469,
-0.6156052350997925,
0.49803122878074646,
0.29251718521118164,
0.31862619519233704,
-0.18163783848285675,
-0.7798534035682678,
-0.6818652153015137,
-0.3530080020427704,
-0.03995564579963684,
0.1722559928894043,
-0.18997690081596375,
-0.00009441065776627511,
0.5072236657142639,
0.08193372935056686,
-0.508882462978363,
-0.11575797945261002,
-0.3712947368621826,
0.19138173758983612,
0.663080096244812,
0.1451272815465927,
0.45007234811782837,
0.13585026562213898,
-0.26438164710998535,
0.04086874797940254,
-0.9489691257476807,
-0.17790378630161285,
0.3536510169506073,
0.10948445647954941,
0.15460918843746185,
0.46882906556129456,
-0.3585551977157593,
0.8657737970352173,
0.2537471354007721,
-0.19814935326576233,
-0.28922367095947266,
-0.2085523009300232,
-0.1959405541419983,
0.3852182924747467,
0.6325334906578064,
0.30905812978744507,
0.5049614906311035,
-0.03634385019540787,
-0.07301413267850876,
0.011061369441449642,
0.014759829267859459,
-0.5210204720497131,
-0.1821780949831009,
0.21032489836215973,
-0.5361373424530029,
-0.15263673663139343,
0.3342925012111664,
-0.4213154911994934,
-0.26784786581993103,
-0.6818166375160217,
0.4053688943386078,
-0.21747583150863647,
-0.1428307741880417,
0.57850182056427,
-0.1600135862827301,
0.2723439335823059,
0.5098342299461365,
-0.7272320985794067,
0.5423873066902161,
0.7704222798347473,
0.45380115509033203,
0.3008803129196167,
-0.1726466715335846,
-0.7627582550048828,
0.3523487448692322,
-0.4460180997848511,
0.9182377457618713,
-0.5330809950828552,
-0.07799767702817917,
0.018003040924668312,
-0.17236827313899994,
-0.09661749750375748,
-0.5033362507820129,
0.6310003995895386,
-0.6782307624816895,
0.18832150101661682,
-0.5687904357910156,
-0.6025447845458984,
-0.37406808137893677,
0.20607727766036987,
-0.7698701024055481,
0.5021992325782776,
-0.2133055031299591,
-0.5064774751663208,
0.4903075098991394,
-0.571983277797699,
-0.9003975987434387,
0.028530551120638847,
-0.24667759239673615,
0.12969695031642914,
-0.033931925892829895,
0.08049178868532181,
0.24904261529445648,
-0.6217728853225708,
0.4941628873348236,
-0.2391585111618042,
0.04502251744270325,
0.24363835155963898,
-0.10218477994203568,
0.9865272641181946,
0.4082137942314148,
-0.5182033181190491,
0.2916037142276764,
-0.6614848375320435,
-0.07726263254880905,
-0.052935320883989334,
-0.0930975154042244,
-0.337891161441803,
0.5408293604850769,
-0.6377840638160706,
0.5844746828079224,
-0.13712497055530548,
-0.25660231709480286,
0.271619588136673,
-0.02385915070772171,
0.47560635209083557,
0.8257637023925781,
0.2228068858385086,
0.1874820441007614,
-0.5180509686470032,
0.4132002592086792,
0.05857845023274422,
0.10751767456531525,
-0.38466379046440125,
-0.5076500773429871,
-0.74440598487854,
-0.02695021778345108,
0.002600297098979354,
0.6804692149162292,
-0.5070737600326538,
0.6079362034797668,
0.024770323187112808,
-0.26131001114845276,
-0.1642235815525055,
-0.07766173779964447,
0.27724143862724304,
0.5508763194084167,
0.3257392644882202,
0.0503031462430954,
-0.5892075300216675,
-0.6349256038665771,
-0.39288565516471863,
-0.48404619097709656,
0.310062974691391,
-0.0937872901558876,
0.7137153744697571,
0.03596270829439163,
0.7539162039756775,
-0.5634929537773132,
0.12716199457645416,
-0.35030877590179443,
0.2953638732433319,
0.24532929062843323,
0.08012440800666809,
0.15566036105155945,
-0.5317937135696411,
-0.4088762402534485,
0.07382079213857651,
-0.8292259573936462,
-0.43890389800071716,
-0.2857029438018799,
-0.25735753774642944,
-0.10585575550794601,
0.8760458827018738,
-0.44258517026901245,
0.43631410598754883,
-0.04900987073779106,
-0.5801417827606201,
0.9509405493736267,
-0.10032112896442413,
0.21654455363750458,
-0.49469295144081116,
0.01922149956226349,
-0.12919087707996368,
-0.2038494348526001,
-0.42320284247398376,
0.24705500900745392,
-0.3750734329223633,
0.11168958991765976,
-0.3220073878765106,
0.3620995283126831,
-0.30584296584129333,
0.22089658677577972,
-0.40596210956573486,
-0.0038020259235054255,
0.11681289225816727,
0.2531064450740814,
0.08198845386505127,
0.39877134561538696,
0.5447425842285156,
-0.6812499165534973,
0.8211543560028076,
0.01534207258373499,
-0.31299349665641785,
0.8334637880325317,
-0.6716191172599792,
-0.06637746095657349,
-0.26875898241996765,
0.5302117466926575,
-0.6692427396774292,
-0.1006326749920845,
0.3520827293395996,
0.3238597810268402,
-0.25672146677970886,
-0.10218682140111923,
-0.8016641736030579,
-0.4918167293071747,
0.03934027999639511,
0.47600769996643066,
0.4250200390815735,
-0.4524460732936859,
0.7998597621917725,
-0.07434771955013275,
0.11054697632789612,
-0.3599090576171875,
-0.5259141325950623,
-0.1279613971710205,
-0.10679185390472412,
-0.6411725282669067,
0.03167270869016647,
-0.24902039766311646,
-0.9080930352210999,
0.16044652462005615,
-0.20467449724674225,
-0.05059732869267464,
-0.0106899319216609,
0.21968944370746613,
-0.12199431657791138,
-0.1664351373910904,
0.04541602358222008,
0.11145826429128647,
0.022607585415244102,
0.6741191148757935,
-0.4368363320827484,
0.4253886044025421,
-0.11865866929292679,
-0.6171391606330872,
-0.4660564661026001,
0.6991831660270691,
0.6747761964797974,
-0.374180406332016,
0.5702702403068542,
-0.24762387573719025,
-0.18735788762569427,
-0.4349954426288605,
-0.6740586161613464,
-0.22185230255126953,
-0.3869946599006653,
-0.35883063077926636,
-0.4986835718154907,
-0.6779900789260864,
0.6390503644943237,
-0.21845656633377075,
-0.1476191282272339,
0.5560382604598999,
0.5695639848709106,
0.12459435313940048,
0.99609375,
0.06509274989366531,
0.06659021228551865,
0.3288162052631378,
0.093368761241436,
0.4129336476325989,
-0.2665695250034332,
-0.34557268023490906,
-0.4965618848800659,
0.005419398657977581,
-0.30199113488197327,
-0.15990878641605377,
0.15018229186534882,
0.13147404789924622,
-0.4213358759880066,
0.2793848514556885,
-0.15863513946533203,
0.8820984363555908,
0.5812357664108276,
0.16888722777366638,
0.3862632215023041,
-0.2911459505558014,
-0.4362999200820923,
0.6212193369865417,
-0.6481833457946777,
-0.20497727394104004,
0.6585493087768555,
-0.012803373858332634,
0.9203736186027527,
0.2458190619945526,
0.5361558794975281,
0.27300769090652466,
-0.027703043073415756,
-0.8201148509979248,
0.8582464456558228,
0.03665389120578766,
-0.8133525252342224,
0.03639674931764603,
-0.584661602973938,
-0.6190381646156311,
0.08474011719226837,
-0.08444485813379288,
-0.8380981087684631,
0.06740009784698486,
-0.08538564294576645,
-0.44174817204475403,
0.39479392766952515,
-0.5256956815719604,
0.6589568257331848,
-0.263349324464798,
-0.41132113337516785,
-0.46189436316490173,
-0.8942380547523499,
0.6215916275978088,
0.1116187795996666,
0.3025391697883606,
-0.13833630084991455,
0.513473391532898,
0.5810156464576721,
-0.979552686214447,
0.6746617555618286,
0.13048219680786133,
-0.2617994546890259,
0.8088255524635315,
0.4166363775730133,
0.5698075294494629,
-0.2885584831237793,
0.06169012561440468,
-0.49647417664527893,
0.2006688266992569,
-0.01811806485056877,
-1.0473451614379883,
0.5336554646492004,
-0.23124906420707703,
-0.6036052703857422,
-0.4502415657043457,
-0.32112550735473633,
0.1627020388841629,
0.3102317154407501,
0.01250513270497322,
0.5123645067214966,
0.1719834804534912,
0.01281940471380949,
0.5586809515953064,
0.17059019207954407,
0.22039799392223358,
0.49396947026252747,
-0.2938031554222107,
-0.37021109461784363,
0.6604496836662292,
-0.07060413807630539,
0.2829214632511139,
0.5888477563858032,
0.6482883095741272,
-0.44942012429237366,
-0.08284962922334671,
-0.1211618185043335,
0.3102504312992096,
-1.0460611581802368,
-0.08426548540592194,
-0.42278486490249634,
-0.15460313856601715,
-0.21437641978263855,
-0.30884599685668945,
-0.0873461365699768,
-0.3126658797264099,
0.168356254696846,
-0.11387940496206284,
0.3470538258552551,
0.8809047341346741,
-0.08762956410646439,
0.07032971829175949,
-0.5850319266319275,
0.35124334692955017,
0.7024081945419312,
0.32745450735092163,
0.1384451538324356,
-0.0205776859074831,
0.14739109575748444,
-0.26780226826667786,
-0.06444960832595825,
-0.9746578335762024,
-0.1890503615140915,
-0.2548348307609558,
0.45782268047332764,
0.7591966390609741,
0.19632215797901154,
0.7868021726608276,
-0.8295203447341919,
0.4992561936378479,
0.350243479013443,
-1.117681622505188,
0.9239542484283447,
-0.5500948429107666,
0.07604143023490906,
0.5971142053604126,
0.24533671140670776,
-0.6958751082420349,
-0.39545172452926636,
-0.632475733757019,
-0.6327509880065918,
0.34278786182403564,
0.002821610076352954,
-0.3139783442020416,
-0.3672049641609192,
0.5223236680030823,
-0.02144084870815277,
0.13110269606113434,
-0.6620202660560608,
-0.12660539150238037,
0.08413545787334442,
-0.1718205362558365,
0.6701375842094421,
-0.1671140044927597,
-0.21605411171913147,
-0.3845197260379791,
0.6317171454429626,
-0.01074631791561842,
-0.06813172250986099,
0.2482205033302307,
-0.0680919885635376,
-0.1971098631620407,
0.3744075298309326,
0.880189061164856,
0.991138219833374,
-0.046599578112363815,
0.3703085780143738,
-0.13163205981254578,
0.10277197510004044,
0.4371378719806671,
-0.27060335874557495,
-0.19496886432170868,
-0.30959394574165344,
0.5975331664085388,
0.5879880785942078,
0.023220961913466454,
-0.8005515336990356,
0.43879345059394836,
0.000016629261153866537,
-0.507654070854187,
-0.1566425859928131,
0.13963986933231354,
-0.1121256873011589,
0.25448963046073914,
0.21048229932785034,
-0.13564755022525787,
0.3403474986553192,
-0.7772722840309143,
0.38230112195014954,
0.0586172454059124,
-0.2888326942920685,
-0.14261336624622345,
0.7484006285667419,
0.06703013181686401,
-0.05100424587726593,
0.6141271591186523,
-0.08104484528303146,
-0.4749481976032257,
0.49808135628700256,
0.6191353797912598,
0.7079557180404663,
0.0009389253682456911,
0.23001933097839355,
0.25875237584114075,
0.20886953175067902,
-0.6894543766975403,
0.4000397026538849,
-0.14455734193325043,
-0.7277196645736694,
-0.905730128288269,
-0.056056562811136246,
-0.38814225792884827,
-0.25031283497810364,
-0.6010908484458923,
0.09498471021652222,
-0.7997410297393799,
0.21054521203041077,
0.014281491748988628,
-0.32676517963409424,
-0.26651453971862793,
0.18429957330226898,
-0.09337758272886276,
1.008251667022705,
-0.9659503698348999,
0.3599366247653961,
0.44657573103904724,
-0.7372888922691345,
-1.1124225854873657,
-0.09344583749771118,
0.2281985729932785,
-0.47737622261047363,
0.9671748280525208,
0.16551530361175537,
-0.5341172814369202,
-0.1603461056947708,
-0.7763118743896484,
-0.37479913234710693,
0.8072716593742371,
0.276227205991745,
-0.5237067341804504,
0.20918913185596466,
-0.1744844615459442,
0.3511962592601776,
-0.3632015883922577,
0.27719274163246155,
0.553922176361084,
0.6407865881919861,
0.5306683778762817,
-0.5085815787315369,
0.45285898447036743,
-0.23491336405277252,
-0.3096093535423279,
0.33786579966545105,
-0.41885557770729065,
0.8216731548309326,
-0.23959071934223175,
-0.14604955911636353,
0.02201704867184162,
0.5350953936576843,
0.5523328185081482,
0.23553159832954407,
0.6495643258094788,
0.7751244902610779,
0.8184777498245239,
-0.06300947815179825,
1.104801893234253,
-0.2991076707839966,
0.0286705382168293,
1.2230641841888428,
-0.7071501612663269,
0.5632838010787964,
0.4527471661567688,
0.017836829647421837,
1.3835780620574951,
0.20055672526359558,
0.06618421524763107,
0.4377838373184204,
0.5246081352233887,
-0.6340137124061584,
-0.49448370933532715,
-0.29306453466415405,
-0.13938169181346893,
0.38783711194992065,
0.10260134190320969,
-0.3745538294315338,
-0.22171850502490997,
-0.30038872361183167,
0.05253708362579346,
0.16336111724376678,
-0.3788466453552246,
0.7649187445640564,
0.002548648277297616,
-1.002381682395935,
-0.06864514201879501,
0.1391977071762085,
-0.2000902146100998,
-0.5951555967330933,
-0.27532970905303955,
-0.0036578148137778044,
0.2186061441898346,
-0.2128722220659256,
-0.8446523547172546,
0.1836245059967041,
-0.1115395650267601,
-0.3195512890815735,
-0.337677925825119,
0.6817005276679993,
-0.2909354567527771,
-0.42256635427474976,
0.3120260238647461,
0.46145913004875183,
0.050782281905412674,
0.020436398684978485,
-0.5714300274848938,
-0.08844166249036789,
-0.37659505009651184,
0.17175140976905823,
-0.32148072123527527,
0.8653771877288818,
-0.46501991152763367,
0.8339096903800964,
0.7973743677139282,
0.08640321344137192,
0.09591484069824219,
0.48671579360961914,
0.7789475917816162,
-0.7803162336349487,
-0.5945453643798828,
-1.0760549306869507,
0.6374080181121826,
0.013609007000923157,
0.05051755532622337,
0.5469588041305542,
0.42189928889274597,
0.607375979423523,
-0.05178604647517204,
0.6004236936569214,
-0.14218461513519287,
0.20560729503631592,
-0.864118754863739,
0.2647741734981537,
-0.2106046974658966,
0.106783926486969,
-0.2556896209716797,
-0.5721684694290161,
-0.5832073092460632,
0.6980226635932922,
-0.46292203664779663,
0.10845424234867096,
1.1201224327087402,
0.4962923526763916,
0.034819550812244415,
0.2643596827983856,
0.1255909502506256,
0.017943117767572403,
0.3899535834789276,
0.49195995926856995,
1.0800238847732544,
-0.2070600390434265,
0.23841716349124908,
0.1305636763572693,
-0.0769684687256813,
-0.13978998363018036,
-1.0230565071105957,
-0.7965410351753235,
-0.34497833251953125,
-0.48372942209243774,
-0.3776751756668091,
-0.007118485402315855,
0.987572193145752,
0.6404216289520264,
-0.7840773463249207,
-0.5418795347213745,
-0.8013484477996826,
0.513929009437561,
-0.525067925453186,
-0.21052707731723785,
0.09666246175765991,
-0.3277493119239807,
0.07433760911226273,
0.430648535490036,
0.40811651945114136,
-0.33423617482185364,
-0.054731614887714386,
-0.07249502837657928,
-0.7081615924835205,
0.2990790605545044,
0.7548003196716309,
0.4263879060745239,
-0.8850331902503967,
-0.3713490068912506,
-0.23462817072868347,
0.18385851383209229,
-0.12702879309654236,
1.3878989219665527,
-0.5729748010635376,
0.5202174186706543,
0.8354631066322327,
0.3383016288280487,
0.28760629892349243,
0.013568642549216747,
0.7823594808578491,
-0.40121376514434814,
0.018756123259663582,
0.017807209864258766,
0.5694337487220764,
-0.2597092390060425,
0.010975970886647701,
0.5319948196411133,
0.384621798992157,
-0.44568920135498047,
-0.38023877143859863,
0.6722395420074463,
-0.9370891451835632,
-0.53514564037323,
1.0018752813339233,
-0.029678208753466606,
-0.38829538226127625,
0.05388835445046425,
-0.17930041253566742,
0.027913955971598625,
-0.2840622067451477,
0.41265052556991577,
0.8339775204658508,
-0.21565312147140503,
-0.4043768346309662,
-0.28489530086517334,
0.11623222380876541,
0.1187618300318718,
-1.0097001791000366,
0.040374625474214554,
0.7717128992080688,
0.3128850758075714,
0.14966221153736115,
0.6462113261222839,
-0.09090893715620041,
0.23717860877513885,
0.015413069166243076,
-0.07947319746017456,
0.14737829566001892,
-0.6559918522834778,
-0.002356545766815543,
0.06141751632094383,
-0.12530359625816345,
0.22852900624275208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10380v1 | Subgraph-level Universal Prompt Tuning | 2024-02-16T00:25:24 | 2024-02-16T00:25:24 | Junhyun Lee, Wooseong Yang, Jaewoo Kang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the evolving landscape of machine learning, the adaptation of pre-trained
models through prompt tuning has become increasingly prominent. This trend is
particularly observable in the graph domain, where diverse pre-training
strategies present unique challenges in developing effective prompt-based
tuning methods for graph neural networks. Previous approaches have been
limited, focusing on specialized prompting functions tailored to models with
edge prediction pre-training tasks. These methods, however, suffer from a lack
of generalizability across different pre-training strategies. Recently, a
simple prompt tuning method has been designed for any pre-training strategy,
functioning within the input graph's feature space. This allows it to
theoretically emulate any type of prompting function, thereby significantly
increasing its versatility for a range of downstream applications.
Nevertheless, the capacity of such simple prompts to fully grasp the complex
contexts found in graphs remains an open question, necessitating further
investigation. Addressing this challenge, our work introduces the
Subgraph-level Universal Prompt Tuning (SUPT) approach, focusing on the
detailed context within subgraphs. In SUPT, prompt features are assigned at the
subgraph-level, preserving the method's universal capability. This requires
extremely fewer tuning parameters than fine-tuning-based methods, outperforming
them in 42 out of 45 full-shot scenario experiments with an average improvement
of over 2.5%. In few-shot scenarios, it excels in 41 out of 45 experiments,
achieving an average performance increase of more than 6.6%. | [
-0.5331398248672485,
-0.8026750087738037,
0.27290019392967224,
-0.011246029287576675,
-0.5617486834526062,
-0.04111841320991516,
-0.13621416687965393,
0.026103833690285683,
0.0855933353304863,
0.024334125220775604,
-1.1697356700897217,
-0.5160071849822998,
-0.35501739382743835,
0.3262180685997009,
0.19896066188812256,
1.054748296737671,
0.3167369067668915,
-0.08253808319568634,
-0.12128213047981262,
-0.14751863479614258,
-0.7499872446060181,
-0.3393794000148773,
-0.9420883655548096,
-0.3528491258621216,
0.9271056056022644,
0.4037753939628601,
0.5075280666351318,
0.5647342801094055,
-0.02871590107679367,
0.2526420056819916,
-0.17629694938659668,
0.3860163986682892,
-0.6693286299705505,
-0.10365267097949982,
-0.2699624001979828,
-0.15263794362545013,
-0.23687486350536346,
0.09266888350248337,
0.3296546936035156,
0.8308466076850891,
0.26124733686447144,
0.13847172260284424,
0.35815542936325073,
0.5839594006538391,
-0.616284966468811,
0.191140279173851,
-0.680587112903595,
0.13757085800170898,
-0.10550405830144882,
-0.5544841885566711,
-0.5658605694770813,
-0.10075626522302628,
0.07393711060285568,
-1.024172306060791,
0.5306861996650696,
0.21569019556045532,
0.8319834470748901,
0.310718297958374,
-0.388954222202301,
0.14662174880504608,
-0.09133608639240265,
0.18590328097343445,
-0.3273424506187439,
0.08005601912736893,
0.08973191678524017,
0.22885215282440186,
-0.39792928099632263,
-0.8500095009803772,
-0.07699475437402725,
-0.03419534116983414,
-0.19122233986854553,
0.2814461588859558,
-0.5371805429458618,
0.47056856751441956,
0.6791156530380249,
-0.16661931574344635,
-0.4967445731163025,
0.4912230670452118,
0.013210567645728588,
-0.44887322187423706,
0.31612008810043335,
0.19380824267864227,
0.27630043029785156,
-0.16545358300209045,
-0.0928194671869278,
-0.03549511358141899,
-0.7000856399536133,
0.5638043880462646,
0.40465739369392395,
0.9433466792106628,
0.0850083976984024,
0.15283381938934326,
-0.3157055974006653,
0.9401835203170776,
0.18730448186397552,
0.3719934821128845,
0.08279989659786224,
-0.5061467885971069,
-0.21408399939537048,
-0.07935486733913422,
0.7221236824989319,
0.3559987545013428,
0.7398802638053894,
0.17390350997447968,
0.08107972890138626,
-0.0669979676604271,
0.11879605054855347,
-0.7307054996490479,
-0.5097594857215881,
-0.2411184310913086,
-0.16718517243862152,
-0.15768827497959137,
-0.2447393238544464,
-0.4875190854072571,
-0.5717254877090454,
-0.40226268768310547,
0.3368058502674103,
-0.6165274381637573,
0.05002620443701744,
-0.2103109359741211,
-0.3619379997253418,
-0.00862161535769701,
0.3923643231391907,
-0.9408606290817261,
-0.051054149866104126,
0.24964648485183716,
0.8049978613853455,
0.06518242508172989,
-0.4216758906841278,
-0.9377140402793884,
-0.2387668937444687,
-0.5321887135505676,
0.9465889930725098,
-0.6370571851730347,
-0.5131877660751343,
-0.1366068422794342,
0.1984618455171585,
-0.467196524143219,
-0.22250576317310333,
0.40441298484802246,
-0.3251354992389679,
0.025024663656949997,
-0.5913318991661072,
-0.28954267501831055,
0.00603487016633153,
-0.13362212479114532,
-0.23702022433280945,
0.881414532661438,
0.4796159267425537,
-0.8328409790992737,
0.6253288984298706,
-0.7516785264015198,
-0.8202937841415405,
0.20537911355495453,
-0.04898133873939514,
-0.4897640347480774,
0.20203199982643127,
0.8490753769874573,
0.37520304322242737,
-0.07030057162046432,
-0.1469208300113678,
-0.3749126195907593,
-0.596045732498169,
-0.08061253279447556,
-0.18342071771621704,
0.7158710360527039,
0.049696944653987885,
-0.06711416691541672,
0.750433087348938,
-0.5447661876678467,
0.22092555463314056,
-0.015524967573583126,
0.2716054320335388,
-0.2627399265766144,
-0.5510082244873047,
-0.4758688807487488,
-0.056481633335351944,
0.009547334164381027,
-0.39033645391464233,
0.37790268659591675,
-0.33290448784828186,
0.7655104398727417,
0.955077052116394,
0.2977907955646515,
0.3926583230495453,
0.03452017158269882,
0.6394844055175781,
-0.003427624236792326,
0.2933889925479889,
-0.5990755558013916,
-0.4234160780906677,
-0.4013687074184418,
-0.45028385519981384,
0.7838515639305115,
0.600268542766571,
-0.5024591088294983,
0.6505686640739441,
0.057812195271253586,
-0.31877946853637695,
-0.34442538022994995,
-0.02135586366057396,
0.38653764128685,
1.189937710762024,
0.5155808925628662,
-0.09183885157108307,
-0.5989020466804504,
-0.6990429162979126,
-0.3972128927707672,
0.1456211358308792,
-0.11287878453731537,
0.7211918234825134,
0.09848726540803909,
-0.016271410509943962,
1.0980603694915771,
-0.37513086199760437,
-0.39506977796554565,
-0.583619236946106,
0.11240407824516296,
0.5668927431106567,
0.352078914642334,
0.6222310662269592,
-0.3738965094089508,
-0.5665402412414551,
-0.2305503636598587,
-0.5943077206611633,
-0.4250602424144745,
-0.09113951772451401,
-0.06893099844455719,
-0.05041477084159851,
0.6710676550865173,
-0.5294861197471619,
0.6344828009605408,
0.06610886752605438,
-0.3375585973262787,
0.30883318185806274,
-0.44204896688461304,
0.05769740417599678,
-0.7876853346824646,
-0.1484968215227127,
0.07117222994565964,
-0.21628621220588684,
-0.24008958041667938,
-0.26478663086891174,
0.19460657238960266,
-0.4205968677997589,
-0.3276672959327698,
0.40925323963165283,
-0.45186442136764526,
-0.08790629357099533,
-0.12334953993558884,
0.15007179975509644,
-0.0707758441567421,
0.6088692545890808,
-0.48197123408317566,
0.8134791254997253,
1.0590977668762207,
-0.8569355607032776,
0.3015977442264557,
0.1393606960773468,
0.0023635157849639654,
0.6653730869293213,
-0.976081132888794,
0.29368290305137634,
-0.359677255153656,
0.4737640619277954,
-1.4408811330795288,
-0.2240523099899292,
0.2027728110551834,
-0.6093990206718445,
0.43257731199264526,
-0.5352069139480591,
-0.26880890130996704,
-0.5641475319862366,
0.01054381113499403,
0.2930832505226135,
0.7011594772338867,
-0.6318304538726807,
0.690316915512085,
-0.10282759368419647,
0.029828451573848724,
-0.43747490644454956,
-0.04400704801082611,
-0.22722820937633514,
-0.09116241335868835,
-0.5161402821540833,
0.08463981747627258,
0.030100639909505844,
0.563716471195221,
-0.2025914043188095,
-0.2615719437599182,
0.5618497133255005,
0.24145673215389252,
0.3908923864364624,
0.051546767354011536,
-0.009642058983445168,
-0.027438217774033546,
0.580033540725708,
-0.6889930367469788,
-0.4217721223831177,
-0.6405245065689087,
0.7409307360649109,
0.0026033464819192886,
-0.20703354477882385,
-0.6971624493598938,
0.022089943289756775,
0.008720440790057182,
-0.2488686591386795,
0.22590839862823486,
0.5337254405021667,
-0.06733749806880951,
-0.4726852476596832,
0.30539923906326294,
-0.2344113439321518,
-0.5731300115585327,
0.5153740644454956,
-0.6935990452766418,
-0.8148168921470642,
0.6084043979644775,
-0.6625956296920776,
-0.12901003658771515,
0.3416000306606293,
0.26553016901016235,
-0.4498544931411743,
1.2667748928070068,
0.6455885767936707,
0.029372118413448334,
0.691933274269104,
-0.29706624150276184,
-0.006153536960482597,
-0.8142056465148926,
-0.07468122988939285,
-0.5443971157073975,
-0.7851442694664001,
-0.2852422595024109,
0.2084885835647583,
0.7193536758422852,
0.3467979431152344,
-0.42285871505737305,
0.40076979994773865,
-0.6598552465438843,
0.7888582348823547,
0.741127073764801,
0.13934101164340973,
-0.14787155389785767,
0.08138417452573776,
-0.6042713522911072,
-0.08761591464281082,
-1.051558017730713,
0.09576201438903809,
0.7406516671180725,
0.040159132331609726,
0.7459051012992859,
-0.5468659996986389,
0.3946685194969177,
0.39111456274986267,
0.07431524246931076,
-0.5557193756103516,
0.6640991568565369,
-0.2639841139316559,
-0.06317957490682602,
-0.7866185903549194,
-0.4162616729736328,
-1.3419781923294067,
0.15138356387615204,
-0.15015909075737,
-0.9088369607925415,
0.06030113622546196,
0.662767231464386,
-0.5055248141288757,
0.035176005214452744,
-0.733237624168396,
1.1244338750839233,
0.041876599192619324,
0.1127668023109436,
0.22898772358894348,
-0.8353887796401978,
-0.28294485807418823,
0.3325273394584656,
-0.15218617022037506,
-0.2838793992996216,
0.1657150834798813,
0.34242939949035645,
-0.3090434670448303,
1.045539140701294,
-0.5318935513496399,
0.1573386937379837,
0.12274789065122604,
0.1587996780872345,
0.6132100224494934,
0.324442058801651,
0.06984636187553406,
0.14911900460720062,
-0.22678609192371368,
-0.45697835087776184,
-0.8239659070968628,
0.39609238505363464,
-0.9828669428825378,
-0.4501340389251709,
-0.04858551174402237,
-0.5133504867553711,
-0.5889573693275452,
0.6256169080734253,
1.1004880666732788,
0.8066165447235107,
-0.0050803725607693195,
-0.0933510959148407,
0.6428436040878296,
-0.03900276497006416,
0.5763064026832581,
0.2019812911748886,
-0.025951698422431946,
-0.4728962481021881,
0.7960322499275208,
0.0963626354932785,
-0.006586376577615738,
0.33451876044273376,
0.4266851842403412,
-0.5310494303703308,
-0.47762924432754517,
-0.8050166368484497,
-0.0046613276936113834,
-0.6526153683662415,
-0.38748589158058167,
-0.5273813605308533,
-0.1661108434200287,
-0.7164096832275391,
-0.29267239570617676,
-0.0695377066731453,
-0.25578343868255615,
-0.6712304353713989,
-0.3247130811214447,
0.4401198923587799,
0.13497306406497955,
-0.0313110426068306,
0.5440321564674377,
-0.46712327003479004,
0.26977136731147766,
0.3370010256767273,
0.24111934006214142,
-0.34826427698135376,
-0.7155605554580688,
0.0933317095041275,
-0.07357517629861832,
-0.020266374573111534,
-0.674614429473877,
-0.0017042768886312842,
0.5386922955513,
0.6258490085601807,
0.23982663452625275,
0.3097991347312927,
0.7327641844749451,
-0.4912285804748535,
0.5392239689826965,
0.22534571588039398,
-0.9436806440353394,
0.9272699952125549,
-0.5116440653800964,
0.4953279197216034,
0.7468351125717163,
0.44803115725517273,
-0.35716867446899414,
-0.057459358125925064,
-0.46550020575523376,
-0.8166254758834839,
0.7784895300865173,
-0.240446537733078,
0.36273837089538574,
0.24598422646522522,
0.5754770636558533,
0.13536831736564636,
0.16521400213241577,
-0.2772625684738159,
-0.2048986703157425,
-0.6200067400932312,
-0.23429007828235626,
-0.2487524151802063,
0.2819790542125702,
-0.2953958809375763,
-0.575267493724823,
0.24895727634429932,
-0.8149300217628479,
-0.010499265976250172,
0.23081524670124054,
-0.04731375351548195,
-0.2214389145374298,
0.10479580610990524,
0.4007496237754822,
0.8952917456626892,
0.07800059765577316,
0.16140291094779968,
0.4578673541545868,
-0.15960851311683655,
0.20037062466144562,
0.13349349796772003,
-0.5689591765403748,
-0.17523488402366638,
0.4223332405090332,
1.2835242748260498,
0.06532368063926697,
-0.20603878796100616,
0.47479963302612305,
-0.12487208843231201,
-0.2793704569339752,
0.13015900552272797,
0.5773881077766418,
-0.18134805560112,
0.07822127640247345,
0.39394259452819824,
0.2517319619655609,
-0.19550085067749023,
-0.323163241147995,
0.20751066505908966,
0.47006431221961975,
-0.8503255248069763,
-0.35460153222084045,
0.6365721821784973,
0.18851548433303833,
-0.5334836840629578,
0.9191768765449524,
-0.20169135928153992,
-0.346733957529068,
0.7135798335075378,
0.8247725367546082,
0.8772435784339905,
0.06435621529817581,
0.3535107374191284,
0.41149893403053284,
0.20856480300426483,
0.5410234332084656,
0.24981750547885895,
-0.12358825653791428,
-0.7028276920318604,
-0.2064310908317566,
-0.36563584208488464,
-0.11462068557739258,
-0.10274176299571991,
-0.5628295540809631,
0.22451645135879517,
-0.764853298664093,
-0.3724375367164612,
-0.06352250277996063,
-0.11430748552083969,
-0.6519266366958618,
0.24810311198234558,
-0.17149142920970917,
1.208583116531372,
-0.8108731508255005,
0.5632005929946899,
0.8597449064254761,
-0.16407747566699982,
-0.936785101890564,
-0.1088002622127533,
-0.1827893704175949,
-0.9120519757270813,
0.2475791722536087,
0.2387441098690033,
-0.08974514156579971,
0.5722375512123108,
-0.7919715642929077,
-0.6658742427825928,
0.9400768280029297,
0.6305498480796814,
-0.48181387782096863,
-0.05342744290828705,
-0.14395785331726074,
0.6019486784934998,
-0.5310834646224976,
0.30743226408958435,
0.5866151452064514,
0.35815301537513733,
0.2989445924758911,
-0.6845905184745789,
0.3164615333080292,
-0.3195289373397827,
0.2864970564842224,
0.11202997714281082,
-0.9103215932846069,
0.8904714584350586,
-0.5646891593933105,
-0.2948448956012726,
-0.09638189524412155,
0.7902752161026001,
0.44351673126220703,
0.31433233618736267,
0.7742811441421509,
0.3437570333480835,
0.9528523683547974,
-0.24622145295143127,
0.957594633102417,
-0.41264382004737854,
0.08887742459774017,
0.8033711910247803,
-0.05750148370862007,
-0.07932769507169724,
0.04623312130570412,
0.04116430506110191,
0.3863236904144287,
1.2745212316513062,
0.05931694060564041,
0.7451079487800598,
0.34763115644454956,
0.28059178590774536,
-0.6687753796577454,
-0.31133970618247986,
-0.5466746091842651,
0.05159550532698631,
0.1930355429649353,
-0.04842435568571091,
-0.2998802959918976,
0.04345684126019478,
-0.21632535755634308,
-0.13049578666687012,
-0.6726511716842651,
0.7724881172180176,
0.0710710659623146,
-0.7547269463539124,
0.49688515067100525,
-0.27481985092163086,
0.3019200563430786,
-0.8246701955795288,
0.09603645652532578,
-0.47466206550598145,
-0.1377394050359726,
-0.16966357827186584,
-0.4743218421936035,
-0.3614937961101532,
-0.4257412254810333,
-0.07334517687559128,
-0.16198845207691193,
0.7602142095565796,
0.14743192493915558,
-0.17046065628528595,
0.23523440957069397,
0.3200697898864746,
-0.20278026163578033,
0.0948396697640419,
-0.7207468748092651,
-0.09644538164138794,
-0.03433813527226448,
-0.23441298305988312,
0.5175313949584961,
0.8200344443321228,
0.0370437353849411,
0.5574771761894226,
0.7789864540100098,
-0.0854705274105072,
-0.16278134286403656,
0.5875765681266785,
1.0582759380340576,
-0.6258034110069275,
-0.9777368903160095,
-0.7871200442314148,
0.4567473828792572,
-0.07248746603727341,
-0.9682891964912415,
0.7896774411201477,
0.2832057476043701,
0.672101616859436,
0.1299108862876892,
0.8354536890983582,
0.16448363661766052,
0.3311523497104645,
-0.6726714968681335,
0.34333336353302,
-0.4617611765861511,
-0.04541022330522537,
-0.4646247625350952,
-0.7660172581672668,
-0.2543953061103821,
0.4332408905029297,
-0.13769514858722687,
0.31736019253730774,
0.5230184197425842,
0.6558735370635986,
-0.14507810771465302,
0.21925397217273712,
0.2683279514312744,
-0.025775497779250145,
0.1611981838941574,
0.4698694348335266,
0.8523042798042297,
0.020265329629182816,
0.4782593846321106,
0.0763600543141365,
-0.5146684050559998,
-0.18044017255306244,
-1.001041293144226,
-1.109047293663025,
-0.3019894063472748,
-0.08844969421625137,
-0.38742977380752563,
0.025860220193862915,
0.7530540227890015,
0.8866998553276062,
-0.7351993322372437,
0.37208878993988037,
-0.29696154594421387,
0.14854146540164948,
-0.45245298743247986,
-0.1347837895154953,
0.42906588315963745,
-0.775428831577301,
-0.4087914526462555,
0.6343508362770081,
0.4062321186065674,
0.0963115468621254,
0.11856291443109512,
0.08961712568998337,
0.30654582381248474,
0.07922066748142242,
0.3142678737640381,
0.5237855315208435,
-0.1720256358385086,
-0.5188990831375122,
0.20113356411457062,
0.05372461676597595,
0.07401526719331741,
1.187005877494812,
-0.9497863054275513,
0.36299076676368713,
0.5628618001937866,
0.45575278997421265,
0.6124069094657898,
0.39052432775497437,
0.5549530982971191,
-1.3053209781646729,
0.21984826028347015,
0.0568351149559021,
0.4214109480381012,
0.07487792521715164,
-0.5380605459213257,
0.47986048460006714,
0.5474427938461304,
-0.3843739628791809,
-0.7286189198493958,
0.5643266439437866,
-0.8289636969566345,
-0.41105979681015015,
0.7454062700271606,
-0.11360419541597366,
-0.2691583037376404,
-0.11695334315299988,
-0.4114059507846832,
0.4750221073627472,
-0.49026474356651306,
0.4290020763874054,
0.1113419309258461,
-0.8471308946609497,
-0.1696576178073883,
0.1957842856645584,
0.6589323282241821,
0.2736220955848694,
-0.53329998254776,
0.04032715782523155,
0.3924858272075653,
0.23922914266586304,
-0.09061872214078903,
0.9585208296775818,
0.35740116238594055,
0.3830753564834595,
-0.05400620400905609,
-0.4407777190208435,
-0.6491743326187134,
-0.8120744824409485,
-0.39023342728614807,
0.34032389521598816,
-0.2698039710521698,
-0.15297001600265503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10379v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10379v2 | DataDreamer: A Tool for Synthetic Data Generation and Reproducible LLM Workflows | 2024-02-16T00:10:26 | 2024-05-27T19:54:44 | Ajay Patel, Colin Raffel, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have become a dominant and important tool for
NLP researchers in a wide range of tasks. Today, many researchers use LLMs in
synthetic data generation, task evaluation, fine-tuning, distillation, and
other model-in-the-loop research workflows. However, challenges arise when
using these models that stem from their scale, their closed source nature, and
the lack of standardized tooling for these new and emerging workflows. The
rapid rise to prominence of these models and these unique challenges has had
immediate adverse impacts on open science and on the reproducibility of work
that uses them. In this paper, we introduce DataDreamer, an open source Python
library that allows researchers to write simple code to implement powerful LLM
workflows. DataDreamer also helps researchers adhere to best practices that we
propose to encourage open science and reproducibility. The library and
documentation are available at https://github.com/datadreamer-dev/DataDreamer . | [
0.06695234030485153,
-0.5065022706985474,
0.3842201232910156,
0.3928071856498718,
-0.08475302159786224,
-0.0425935722887516,
-0.2844444513320923,
-0.2723581790924072,
0.21695832908153534,
0.7268753051757812,
-0.340689480304718,
-0.4620150327682495,
-0.3720763623714447,
0.2589477300643921,
-0.7456563711166382,
0.9542347192764282,
-0.37454304099082947,
-0.04580952972173691,
-0.30750012397766113,
0.11805874854326248,
0.08632586151361465,
-0.81209397315979,
-0.5418974757194519,
-0.4440508484840393,
0.7940322756767273,
0.1552329808473587,
0.9441021680831909,
0.7522068619728088,
0.7538478374481201,
0.24430663883686066,
0.03098982758820057,
0.13868868350982666,
-0.6882666945457458,
0.6049672365188599,
-0.3322882056236267,
-0.4291534423828125,
-0.3175155818462372,
-0.09213829785585403,
0.6556493639945984,
0.7151198387145996,
-0.4537610113620758,
0.3726634681224823,
-0.236054927110672,
0.6897759437561035,
-0.4144366979598999,
0.14804531633853912,
-0.7139521837234497,
0.02734440006315708,
-0.6989725828170776,
-0.21196871995925903,
-0.14422635734081268,
-0.7650651931762695,
0.15075571835041046,
-0.3971346914768219,
0.5042148232460022,
0.08743216842412949,
0.4540104568004608,
0.3694186806678772,
0.21558935940265656,
-0.1987738162279129,
-1.168174147605896,
0.7306699752807617,
-0.8465721607208252,
0.3292384147644043,
0.12097335606813431,
0.4830198585987091,
-0.6754151582717896,
-0.9189671277999878,
-0.7796654105186462,
0.06862160563468933,
0.17452159523963928,
-0.3585646152496338,
-0.5056200623512268,
-0.25299814343452454,
0.3808114230632782,
0.44507864117622375,
-0.6168760657310486,
0.11051763594150543,
-0.7409753799438477,
0.10197648406028748,
0.5467797517776489,
0.5532808899879456,
0.035452235490083694,
0.21338355541229248,
0.15742690861225128,
0.06939389556646347,
-0.7658107280731201,
-0.38629150390625,
0.36235520243644714,
0.31693172454833984,
0.06221213564276695,
0.9601008892059326,
-0.16898265480995178,
0.7029305696487427,
-0.34119755029678345,
-0.01709228754043579,
0.28588512539863586,
-0.09235013276338577,
-0.27465909719467163,
0.0795091986656189,
0.8698780536651611,
0.17508874833583832,
0.13949346542358398,
-0.3779059946537018,
-0.221530020236969,
0.08542037755250931,
0.3412024974822998,
-0.9228631854057312,
-0.28553810715675354,
0.681395947933197,
-0.18675053119659424,
-0.5020384788513184,
-0.16059014201164246,
-0.7975204586982727,
-0.44378742575645447,
-0.3218223750591278,
-0.03549516573548317,
-0.11454299837350845,
-0.42338746786117554,
0.2550555467605591,
-0.17832139134407043,
0.09342312812805176,
0.44709762930870056,
-0.6101704239845276,
0.1329706907272339,
0.9026339054107666,
1.2386200428009033,
-0.4517472982406616,
-0.4374005198478699,
-0.09292111545801163,
0.016102515161037445,
-0.6396313309669495,
0.3482877314090729,
-0.47371935844421387,
-0.11035234481096268,
-0.030587034299969673,
-0.00823622103780508,
-0.10622149705886841,
-0.6257658004760742,
0.4366483986377716,
-0.6619518399238586,
0.12110693752765656,
0.37624260783195496,
-0.5145515203475952,
-0.05545497685670853,
0.05291718617081642,
-0.9332301020622253,
1.1448698043823242,
0.2844865322113037,
-0.801649808883667,
-0.027496375143527985,
-0.8439821004867554,
-0.08479543030261993,
0.12909112870693207,
-0.016923407092690468,
-0.4159553349018097,
0.28215256333351135,
-0.15207305550575256,
0.5059565305709839,
-0.3765576183795929,
0.483737587928772,
-0.3146037459373474,
-0.2944527268409729,
0.5000712275505066,
-0.38603702187538147,
0.6638898849487305,
0.2468024492263794,
-0.01927861012518406,
0.20345352590084076,
-0.811427891254425,
0.06721101701259613,
0.3254123330116272,
-0.2502778470516205,
-0.192142054438591,
-0.053989190608263016,
0.19777855277061462,
0.044996414333581924,
0.004454032052308321,
-0.7476677894592285,
0.33574333786964417,
-0.4045792520046234,
0.6780438423156738,
0.5525267720222473,
-0.191314697265625,
0.17475804686546326,
-0.6612586379051208,
0.6373018622398376,
-0.05825445428490639,
-0.0333486944437027,
0.06753144413232803,
-0.4459499716758728,
-0.4901554584503174,
-0.4021187126636505,
0.10164496302604675,
0.3555114269256592,
-0.6421256065368652,
0.26984846591949463,
-0.42995578050613403,
-1.0414372682571411,
-0.8277539610862732,
0.16391390562057495,
-0.03908668830990791,
0.36959192156791687,
0.10410666465759277,
0.12662607431411743,
-0.9296819567680359,
-0.4635060429573059,
0.07809906452894211,
0.03847851604223251,
-0.21753272414207458,
0.030133862048387527,
0.6765452027320862,
-0.5061221122741699,
1.0522849559783936,
-0.43772321939468384,
-0.08606339246034622,
-0.2722991406917572,
-0.04491502419114113,
0.6787484884262085,
0.4792070984840393,
0.37601926922798157,
-0.5147141814231873,
0.004319014959037304,
-0.3788509666919708,
-0.8038610219955444,
-0.17260614037513733,
0.19025076925754547,
-0.16536693274974823,
0.33562198281288147,
0.19308586418628693,
-0.930004358291626,
0.25602462887763977,
0.7953014373779297,
0.059580519795417786,
0.8088065981864929,
-0.13755416870117188,
-0.13469938933849335,
-1.1465826034545898,
0.25570908188819885,
-0.09765590727329254,
-0.10301592200994492,
-0.7627689838409424,
0.022997872903943062,
-0.2599405348300934,
-0.4309070110321045,
-0.5738924145698547,
0.5222739577293396,
-0.07085765898227692,
-0.009430927224457264,
-0.34755635261535645,
-0.07680544257164001,
0.03326071426272392,
-0.21840056777000427,
0.41838449239730835,
0.7963297367095947,
0.7228161692619324,
-0.5666151642799377,
0.7926449179649353,
0.27564772963523865,
-0.4972339868545532,
0.12400196492671967,
-0.9949585795402527,
0.42494502663612366,
-0.10946048051118851,
0.30100029706954956,
-0.46374455094337463,
-0.40615972876548767,
0.4101982116699219,
-0.2816137671470642,
-0.17459575831890106,
-0.31545430421829224,
-0.8361377716064453,
-0.566953718662262,
-0.2761988043785095,
0.3113464415073395,
0.5156522989273071,
-0.8089788556098938,
0.22252333164215088,
0.3295603394508362,
-0.24037694931030273,
-0.3057347536087036,
-0.5482772588729858,
0.18743720650672913,
-0.3293314278125763,
-0.7515403628349304,
0.36088183522224426,
-0.11113633215427399,
-0.4525110721588135,
-0.10642804950475693,
0.0846475288271904,
-0.22382107377052307,
-0.17580167949199677,
0.3646346628665924,
0.3968505561351776,
-0.1676512509584427,
-0.027823148295283318,
-0.383504718542099,
-0.04595422372221947,
0.27177345752716064,
-0.42312195897102356,
0.5047917366027832,
0.05875231698155403,
-0.36764776706695557,
-0.25441133975982666,
0.16888940334320068,
0.8107970952987671,
-0.08831358700990677,
0.7568117380142212,
0.3248380422592163,
-0.5396489500999451,
-0.48673170804977417,
-0.27887430787086487,
-0.11368699371814728,
-0.49425068497657776,
0.09866458922624588,
-0.07465124875307083,
-0.8061084747314453,
0.31256428360939026,
-0.23416666686534882,
0.3958622217178345,
-0.13440749049186707,
0.842132031917572,
-0.05670502781867981,
0.460363507270813,
0.5092936754226685,
-0.0878664031624794,
0.20013189315795898,
-0.21286575496196747,
0.3941330015659332,
-0.8275202512741089,
-0.20759844779968262,
-0.6547600030899048,
-0.23914258182048798,
-0.420391321182251,
-0.9554961323738098,
0.20333582162857056,
-0.011865154840052128,
-0.0806610956788063,
0.30550816655158997,
-0.7631386518478394,
0.39020615816116333,
0.5783708095550537,
-0.14451062679290771,
0.24931193888187408,
0.006021297071129084,
0.31578779220581055,
-0.17680978775024414,
-0.6811666488647461,
-0.9236652255058289,
1.245395302772522,
0.2198937088251114,
1.3306586742401123,
-0.03857036679983139,
0.82358318567276,
0.20539021492004395,
0.1551448106765747,
-0.7061255574226379,
0.39130303263664246,
0.1562066525220871,
-0.4432503581047058,
-0.31898897886276245,
-0.3519652187824249,
-1.2047362327575684,
0.19470977783203125,
0.12446214258670807,
-0.7531642913818359,
0.022086838260293007,
0.23549646139144897,
-0.07579568028450012,
0.46536415815353394,
-0.03253750503063202,
0.5935443043708801,
-0.07482653856277466,
-0.3845568597316742,
0.27272921800613403,
-0.2349325716495514,
0.3524864614009857,
-0.32795366644859314,
0.07099640369415283,
-0.23326323926448822,
0.1821606159210205,
0.7986372709274292,
-0.49215513467788696,
0.7591245770454407,
-0.08736006915569305,
-0.2540591061115265,
0.25134116411209106,
0.3104846179485321,
0.67653888463974,
0.014381778426468372,
-0.46221956610679626,
0.5611722469329834,
0.008984955959022045,
-0.16169121861457825,
-0.433395117521286,
0.8970133066177368,
-0.5174631476402283,
-0.5021223425865173,
-0.57537841796875,
-0.8993058204650879,
0.19586925208568573,
0.06682241708040237,
-0.0842072069644928,
0.24098241329193115,
-0.14505061507225037,
0.16982723772525787,
0.549589991569519,
-0.189189612865448,
0.19173948466777802,
0.5916096568107605,
-0.5045774579048157,
-0.3754720985889435,
0.8052126169204712,
-0.06267563253641129,
0.15317025780677795,
0.11110489070415497,
0.21983592212200165,
-0.0852608010172844,
-0.7977379560470581,
-0.32112419605255127,
0.14690697193145752,
-0.3619861304759979,
-0.13948899507522583,
-0.5508826375007629,
-0.36039021611213684,
-0.41810280084609985,
-0.26172566413879395,
-0.5651994943618774,
-0.6416673064231873,
-0.28353509306907654,
-0.09507507085800171,
0.7988715171813965,
0.6801251769065857,
-0.1752982884645462,
0.07357041537761688,
-0.6069181561470032,
0.38957884907722473,
-0.3562200665473938,
0.15882959961891174,
-0.31395551562309265,
-0.3513544201850891,
-0.1308785080909729,
0.12612992525100708,
-0.06555856764316559,
-0.37787100672721863,
0.6706933379173279,
-0.06784121692180634,
0.4569989740848541,
0.022520465776324272,
0.2507891356945038,
0.39901003241539,
-0.5397315621376038,
0.7137743234634399,
-0.14863383769989014,
-0.5304693579673767,
0.596183180809021,
-0.2422025501728058,
0.12697912752628326,
0.1862301528453827,
0.5732693076133728,
-0.5700812339782715,
-0.6717400550842285,
-0.3794938027858734,
-0.9381746649742126,
0.5525082945823669,
0.4722331166267395,
0.049204424023628235,
0.22486166656017303,
0.23423108458518982,
0.30388718843460083,
0.3374145030975342,
-0.396426796913147,
-0.18577982485294342,
-0.2544909417629242,
-0.26763713359832764,
-0.0177035853266716,
0.05838233605027199,
-0.31930381059646606,
-0.2029382735490799,
0.7152342796325684,
-0.012821878306567669,
0.16492696106433868,
0.23332643508911133,
0.031460102647542953,
-0.16268861293792725,
0.2950853705406189,
0.3855922520160675,
0.8252046704292297,
-0.4783620536327362,
0.15292279422283173,
-0.32193827629089355,
-0.5071381330490112,
0.16034187376499176,
0.3132280111312866,
-0.6491241455078125,
0.3603256642818451,
0.24198414385318756,
0.4475567936897278,
-0.16641931235790253,
-0.6948624849319458,
0.14407214522361755,
-0.04025273770093918,
-0.18991415202617645,
-0.5984926819801331,
0.18800736963748932,
0.18684518337249756,
0.30561894178390503,
0.16067089140415192,
-0.023875748738646507,
-0.16871176660060883,
-0.20505139231681824,
0.12845148146152496,
0.1439005434513092,
-0.091343954205513,
-0.31443387269973755,
0.6447805762290955,
0.0057817306369543076,
-0.48290398716926575,
0.8547531962394714,
0.011397709138691425,
-0.28263887763023376,
0.5790697336196899,
0.7624695897102356,
0.8224000930786133,
-0.04230998829007149,
0.11183502525091171,
0.23522672057151794,
0.37031105160713196,
-0.2114914506673813,
0.5798965692520142,
0.42285269498825073,
-0.7700738906860352,
-0.20612511038780212,
-0.8007730841636658,
-0.821281909942627,
0.41895022988319397,
-0.5304393768310547,
0.1410938799381256,
-0.3777611255645752,
-0.046888407319784164,
0.3558558523654938,
-0.3611615300178528,
-0.703899085521698,
-0.3064316213130951,
0.008190721273422241,
1.1195731163024902,
-0.4776531457901001,
1.0178378820419312,
0.7399603724479675,
-0.036803971976041794,
-0.5384364128112793,
-0.26343590021133423,
0.2538281977176666,
-0.5485051274299622,
0.734924852848053,
0.15280307829380035,
-0.08462066948413849,
0.048386797308921814,
-0.5643342137336731,
-0.901479184627533,
1.1397855281829834,
0.5199175477027893,
-0.6197373867034912,
0.05006776377558708,
0.47257480025291443,
0.7332500219345093,
-0.4615665376186371,
0.16722814738750458,
0.4411988854408264,
0.3808668553829193,
0.2524144649505615,
-0.8884484171867371,
0.07199575752019882,
-0.20311608910560608,
0.19573071599006653,
0.13684232532978058,
-0.24599532783031464,
0.7530242800712585,
-0.4493686556816101,
-0.12252163141965866,
0.18542979657649994,
0.4479461908340454,
0.6459847688674927,
0.3223353922367096,
-0.014519496820867062,
0.5282436013221741,
0.8955341577529907,
-0.15697737038135529,
0.8513113856315613,
-0.2847403585910797,
0.21351154148578644,
1.2953234910964966,
-0.7324179410934448,
0.769218385219574,
0.6761319637298584,
-0.22848129272460938,
0.35232144594192505,
0.36965465545654297,
-0.3625640571117401,
0.3472588062286377,
0.8044484853744507,
-0.3765992224216461,
0.24558576941490173,
-0.23143267631530762,
-0.22483083605766296,
0.26858821511268616,
0.4067153036594391,
-0.41812336444854736,
-0.4216631352901459,
0.0512218177318573,
0.12737725675106049,
-0.039549291133880615,
-0.12884077429771423,
0.4752483069896698,
0.09486658126115799,
-0.3728986382484436,
0.6556239128112793,
-0.08928374946117401,
0.6001337766647339,
-0.7253560423851013,
-0.23655664920806885,
-0.15431416034698486,
0.44373270869255066,
-0.30257049202919006,
-0.9146649241447449,
0.6104739904403687,
0.4321814477443695,
-0.26337435841560364,
-0.2414495199918747,
0.6879169344902039,
-0.3808422386646271,
-0.5829930901527405,
0.17671331763267517,
0.35445693135261536,
0.5729361772537231,
-0.0676802471280098,
-0.539842963218689,
0.3723146915435791,
-0.3306645452976227,
-0.4777584671974182,
0.1374233216047287,
0.504625678062439,
0.09074855595827103,
1.149681806564331,
1.0712703466415405,
0.5151382684707642,
0.23572327196598053,
0.07466502487659454,
0.913330078125,
-0.7160550951957703,
0.06909289211034775,
-0.9935952425003052,
0.07779030501842499,
0.08472457528114319,
-0.11236615478992462,
0.7410972714424133,
0.9156183004379272,
0.9286746382713318,
-0.24480505287647247,
0.9763368964195251,
-0.24921157956123352,
0.6962083578109741,
-0.24329900741577148,
0.5998214483261108,
0.030325327068567276,
0.23554164171218872,
-0.017611730843782425,
-0.8159600496292114,
-0.2859857678413391,
0.48221027851104736,
0.06869402527809143,
-0.4791761636734009,
0.4452514946460724,
1.1653629541397095,
-0.07818365842103958,
0.051681142300367355,
0.07208952307701111,
0.1042536199092865,
0.5570141673088074,
0.44414666295051575,
0.9165270328521729,
-0.1152094155550003,
0.5019096732139587,
-0.6379475593566895,
-0.1465073525905609,
-0.03058605268597603,
-1.0841517448425293,
-1.0104448795318604,
-0.3116476833820343,
-0.41279879212379456,
-0.439710795879364,
0.17742237448692322,
1.1005617380142212,
0.6516537666320801,
-0.7426160573959351,
-0.4004936218261719,
-0.24755726754665375,
0.13934271037578583,
-0.25758370757102966,
-0.28480908274650574,
0.1673961579799652,
-0.053013741970062256,
-0.7745987176895142,
0.5340355038642883,
0.13048401474952698,
0.1673468053340912,
-0.49225369095802307,
-0.02605290710926056,
0.1866631954908371,
0.1121605709195137,
0.3717919886112213,
0.3899018168449402,
-0.5420274138450623,
0.18242917954921722,
-0.15634998679161072,
-0.21624962985515594,
-0.12743330001831055,
0.9287464022636414,
-0.5542076230049133,
0.3625301718711853,
0.42480799555778503,
0.624557375907898,
0.3367387354373932,
-0.18106824159622192,
0.8900174498558044,
-0.5210246443748474,
0.03148502856492996,
0.4116697907447815,
0.3600817024707794,
0.3630800247192383,
-0.39992913603782654,
0.8613419532775879,
0.14980705082416534,
-0.6962540149688721,
-1.1286088228225708,
0.003161003580316901,
-0.8865894079208374,
0.15254397690296173,
1.1040445566177368,
-0.280737966299057,
-0.30556148290634155,
-0.08559807389974594,
-0.12790583074092865,
0.022797605022788048,
-0.4460805058479309,
0.8442224860191345,
0.43637794256210327,
-0.20596963167190552,
-0.038075465708971024,
-0.7430617809295654,
0.4592057168483734,
-0.2809698283672333,
-0.9217616319656372,
0.5838534832000732,
0.37122878432273865,
0.39040160179138184,
0.16092771291732788,
0.6184389591217041,
-0.2676284611225128,
-0.08671495318412781,
0.011035040952265263,
0.23645621538162231,
-0.4969545602798462,
-0.2561253607273102,
-0.1540997326374054,
-0.10811052471399307,
-0.01698298007249832,
-0.10530378669500351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10373v2 | BioMistral: A Collection of Open-Source Pretrained Large Language Models for Medical Domains | 2024-02-15T23:39:04 | 2024-06-09T15:19:09 | Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Emmanuel Morin, Pierre-Antoine Gourraud, Mickael Rouvier, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable versatility in
recent years, offering potential applications across specialized domains such
as healthcare and medicine. Despite the availability of various open-source
LLMs tailored for health contexts, adapting general-purpose LLMs to the medical
domain presents significant challenges. In this paper, we introduce BioMistral,
an open-source LLM tailored for the biomedical domain, utilizing Mistral as its
foundation model and further pre-trained on PubMed Central. We conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of BioMistral on a benchmark comprising 10 established
medical question-answering (QA) tasks in English. We also explore lightweight
models obtained through quantization and model merging approaches. Our results
demonstrate BioMistral's superior performance compared to existing open-source
medical models and its competitive edge against proprietary counterparts.
Finally, to address the limited availability of data beyond English and to
assess the multilingual generalization of medical LLMs, we automatically
translated and evaluated this benchmark into 7 other languages. This marks the
first large-scale multilingual evaluation of LLMs in the medical domain.
Datasets, multilingual evaluation benchmarks, scripts, and all the models
obtained during our experiments are freely released. | [
0.1627403348684311,
-0.531116247177124,
0.8449062705039978,
0.042667191475629807,
-0.3829849660396576,
0.1745097041130066,
-0.29774096608161926,
-0.5163658857345581,
0.20310769975185394,
0.5065852403640747,
-0.5225526690483093,
-0.7911732196807861,
-0.5572604537010193,
0.4146842956542969,
0.07259640097618103,
0.9580975770950317,
-0.1816861480474472,
0.8066924810409546,
-0.5604143142700195,
-0.5167543888092041,
-0.016336826607584953,
-0.8401533961296082,
-0.5292748212814331,
-0.4153578579425812,
0.3989652693271637,
-0.41483208537101746,
0.5127915143966675,
0.2871163487434387,
0.6053261756896973,
0.33436670899391174,
-0.1041443794965744,
-0.02927352860569954,
-0.3442007005214691,
0.33637651801109314,
-0.6656040549278259,
-0.36035215854644775,
-0.47469350695610046,
-0.28825274109840393,
0.552132785320282,
0.7713690400123596,
-0.32084113359451294,
0.45729297399520874,
-0.13082164525985718,
0.6365549564361572,
-0.4469621777534485,
0.10549791902303696,
-0.3619345724582672,
-0.12548574805259705,
0.024879224598407745,
-0.006734104361385107,
-0.07886633276939392,
-0.5598936080932617,
0.1915636509656906,
-0.5108258128166199,
-0.035570863634347916,
-0.28197500109672546,
0.37073156237602234,
0.38478031754493713,
-0.3065643906593323,
-0.045331019908189774,
-0.6838021278381348,
0.6621150374412537,
-0.674555242061615,
0.7733240127563477,
0.14382308721542358,
0.6111963987350464,
-0.05200076848268509,
-0.969933032989502,
-0.0719788670539856,
-0.06184401363134384,
0.3649787902832031,
0.16157230734825134,
-0.5811193585395813,
0.15787696838378906,
-0.3118988275527954,
0.2096693366765976,
-0.7436510920524597,
-0.18055428564548492,
-0.5211446285247803,
-0.22729505598545074,
0.3511528968811035,
0.25450554490089417,
0.3265703618526459,
0.13123106956481934,
-0.10525710880756378,
0.059864867478609085,
-0.6207886338233948,
-0.06415535509586334,
-0.43049025535583496,
0.2312629520893097,
-0.21601855754852295,
0.6009424924850464,
-0.1166887879371643,
0.4452162981033325,
-0.14289437234401703,
-0.2490442544221878,
0.23520059883594513,
-0.5094242691993713,
-0.26767364144325256,
0.11791704595088959,
0.8205140829086304,
0.1410314440727234,
0.08029548823833466,
-0.2506393790245056,
0.00249613169580698,
0.004381414037197828,
0.21688812971115112,
-1.0697908401489258,
-0.20312459766864777,
0.7237750291824341,
-0.524233877658844,
-0.08189141005277634,
-0.5315321683883667,
-0.3852957487106323,
-0.40071478486061096,
-0.23015782237052917,
0.44274795055389404,
-0.5316736102104187,
-0.14377106726169586,
0.3844756484031677,
0.13144008815288544,
-0.051566168665885925,
0.3867045044898987,
-0.3383917808532715,
0.3467698097229004,
0.6195080876350403,
0.9172175526618958,
-0.1558401882648468,
-0.1111176609992981,
-0.2197638601064682,
0.16595621407032013,
-0.2884633541107178,
0.8303708434104919,
-0.4427996873855591,
-0.42646586894989014,
-0.1350383758544922,
0.29265913367271423,
0.022268880158662796,
-0.7400770783424377,
0.17449410259723663,
-0.46067601442337036,
0.1329704076051712,
-0.13416440784931183,
-0.326826274394989,
-0.03480548784136772,
0.08131967484951019,
-0.5502298474311829,
0.6177548766136169,
0.3669891059398651,
-0.642163872718811,
0.03490958362817764,
-0.4796980917453766,
-0.3331998586654663,
0.3156887888908386,
-0.2731579542160034,
-0.25049522519111633,
0.18008099496364594,
0.10348580032587051,
0.15883611142635345,
-0.7834143042564392,
0.371913880109787,
-0.3503126800060272,
-0.10401476174592972,
0.49913716316223145,
-0.19230115413665771,
0.9510233998298645,
0.1966630518436432,
-0.07005232572555542,
0.40920597314834595,
-0.6202253699302673,
0.16837625205516815,
-0.001625401433557272,
-0.2955642640590668,
-0.5571956038475037,
0.0966416597366333,
0.07360313087701797,
0.17048944532871246,
0.38245251774787903,
-0.6734896302223206,
0.03356580063700676,
-0.7468409538269043,
0.7037648558616638,
0.5150981545448303,
0.13623368740081787,
0.16649183630943298,
-0.2860076427459717,
0.8066547513008118,
-0.12137886136770248,
0.268259197473526,
0.1715102195739746,
-0.33239951729774475,
0.011242648586630821,
-0.7689365148544312,
0.27101126313209534,
0.7024781107902527,
-0.7967382669448853,
0.20859558880329132,
-0.32296323776245117,
-0.6906383037567139,
-0.9863322973251343,
0.17860136926174164,
0.45674455165863037,
0.26106399297714233,
0.41978690028190613,
-0.021598149091005325,
-0.19404610991477966,
-0.7860507965087891,
-0.30760225653648376,
-0.20343512296676636,
-0.0747399628162384,
0.2543299198150635,
0.4781588315963745,
-0.7235410213470459,
0.6182891726493835,
-0.40660133957862854,
-0.0755276083946228,
-0.06295251846313477,
-0.260624498128891,
0.4503602981567383,
0.1953892558813095,
0.5443092584609985,
-0.40468770265579224,
-0.26928529143333435,
0.27907484769821167,
-0.7593560814857483,
-0.19286726415157318,
0.49478664994239807,
-0.3302202820777893,
-0.15512973070144653,
0.4249365031719208,
-0.6666749715805054,
-0.00543590821325779,
0.9579717516899109,
-0.15341873466968536,
0.5249471664428711,
-0.40066295862197876,
0.18965880572795868,
-1.5184400081634521,
0.3986832797527313,
-0.07653146982192993,
-0.4598853588104248,
-0.48310109972953796,
0.44733187556266785,
0.09296927601099014,
-0.5520540475845337,
-0.740664541721344,
0.8494501113891602,
-0.22524970769882202,
0.16453802585601807,
-0.15661662817001343,
-0.2722461521625519,
-0.054757893085479736,
-0.0013754358515143394,
0.1276242733001709,
0.887921929359436,
0.6176189184188843,
-0.4797625243663788,
0.4754966199398041,
0.34455588459968567,
-0.2685230076313019,
0.6746149659156799,
-1.07048499584198,
-0.108864925801754,
-0.3004573881626129,
0.34677428007125854,
-0.7988876104354858,
-0.377724826335907,
0.1987132430076599,
-0.2721996307373047,
-0.11208415776491165,
-0.07856794446706772,
-0.2881241738796234,
-0.3738630414009094,
-0.2626000642776489,
0.6060664057731628,
0.5674882531166077,
-0.3350931406021118,
0.6414581537246704,
0.29002782702445984,
-0.63461834192276,
-0.2733226418495178,
-0.6511263251304626,
-0.21931621432304382,
0.2439277619123459,
-0.28927984833717346,
0.2506087124347687,
-0.30532053112983704,
-0.3406865894794464,
0.03928031772375107,
-0.21702399849891663,
-0.39215192198753357,
-0.0012938834261149168,
0.2843261659145355,
0.2526174783706665,
-0.45768001675605774,
0.32124921679496765,
0.4091201424598694,
0.05144977569580078,
0.17809125781059265,
-0.44007378816604614,
0.3501424789428711,
0.03582693636417389,
-0.532609760761261,
-0.32427680492401123,
0.25124531984329224,
0.8837244510650635,
-0.4495497941970825,
0.7898045182228088,
0.17817595601081848,
-0.5291385650634766,
-0.045702818781137466,
-0.2991843819618225,
-0.06734628975391388,
-0.4273183345794678,
0.6560889482498169,
-0.08241353183984756,
-0.942929208278656,
0.3404911160469055,
-0.39017751812934875,
-0.003543541766703129,
0.38672327995300293,
0.7802307605743408,
-0.0029550271574407816,
0.9523919224739075,
0.4805840849876404,
-0.048221405595541,
-0.1773102879524231,
0.25450360774993896,
-0.08153659105300903,
-0.45531466603279114,
-0.2506382465362549,
-0.6218817234039307,
0.0724579244852066,
-0.4220823049545288,
-0.605449378490448,
0.9529136419296265,
0.04709563031792641,
-0.328957736492157,
0.010350520722568035,
-0.49816781282424927,
0.2754041850566864,
0.07337576150894165,
0.4617544412612915,
0.27908486127853394,
0.17648226022720337,
-0.33559754490852356,
0.010856325738132,
-0.5826268792152405,
-0.34285107254981995,
1.0776197910308838,
0.353674978017807,
0.89610356092453,
0.36378154158592224,
0.5478068590164185,
0.0019659646786749363,
0.5480962991714478,
-0.6593481302261353,
0.23848210275173187,
-0.428053617477417,
-0.7208749055862427,
-0.1783648133277893,
-0.47398674488067627,
-1.1212010383605957,
0.2718098759651184,
-0.281665563583374,
-0.4949492812156677,
0.004764442332088947,
-0.0447930209338665,
-0.5489562749862671,
0.15697383880615234,
-0.2628428041934967,
0.7695100903511047,
-0.46233290433883667,
-0.38113924860954285,
-0.2187495082616806,
-0.5046023726463318,
0.2391924113035202,
-0.6687140464782715,
0.4378472566604614,
-0.17365917563438416,
-0.19497747719287872,
0.40396565198898315,
-0.5211259722709656,
0.7974503040313721,
-0.031452033668756485,
-0.33862265944480896,
0.032755304127931595,
-0.002498073736205697,
-0.07527431845664978,
0.1276846081018448,
-0.23059450089931488,
0.5116880536079407,
0.7698754072189331,
-0.41229668259620667,
-0.2624261975288391,
0.5775178670883179,
-0.9985140562057495,
-0.406209796667099,
-0.47882771492004395,
-0.1709207445383072,
-0.4573409855365753,
0.34900423884391785,
0.264140248298645,
0.4693533778190613,
-0.661165714263916,
0.12306933850049973,
0.7070596814155579,
-0.8104649186134338,
-0.1467212587594986,
0.8573253154754639,
-0.5033010840415955,
-0.8525745868682861,
0.7385058999061584,
-0.3267466425895691,
0.16686533391475677,
0.4373761713504791,
0.26348093152046204,
-0.416332870721817,
-0.36026957631111145,
-0.5767679214477539,
0.5443905591964722,
-0.6017219424247742,
-0.25521883368492126,
-0.7707766890525818,
-0.3511560261249542,
-0.6306827664375305,
-0.026550298556685448,
-0.33160534501075745,
-0.07047982513904572,
-0.08800182491540909,
0.30727237462997437,
0.48502376675605774,
0.7551591992378235,
0.18716904520988464,
0.04251665249466896,
-1.2774410247802734,
0.4680888056755066,
0.24702076613903046,
0.5437952876091003,
-0.2134554535150528,
-0.2618545889854431,
-0.2180890589952469,
0.08736617118120193,
0.028341537341475487,
-0.9948835968971252,
0.37876731157302856,
0.39078205823898315,
0.6516707539558411,
0.13994021713733673,
-0.17147310078144073,
0.2287626564502716,
-0.7920838594436646,
0.6804895401000977,
0.313813179731369,
-0.6803279519081116,
0.5370701551437378,
-0.33462879061698914,
0.5924584269523621,
0.8073268532752991,
0.7827339768409729,
-0.38492774963378906,
-0.398478627204895,
-0.10067756474018097,
-0.6307596564292908,
0.26801037788391113,
-0.1721244752407074,
0.16877779364585876,
-0.19261837005615234,
0.47362199425697327,
0.27299219369888306,
0.4390660226345062,
-0.47220176458358765,
-0.06493403017520905,
-0.09772004187107086,
-0.5409862399101257,
-0.32751932740211487,
0.03235600143671036,
-0.19266308844089508,
-0.47555968165397644,
0.45731860399246216,
-0.1378704458475113,
0.2883624732494354,
0.28109681606292725,
-0.2899248003959656,
-0.10877236723899841,
0.44859442114830017,
0.447979599237442,
0.7077051401138306,
-0.14972496032714844,
0.014069996774196625,
0.12737184762954712,
-0.7247649431228638,
0.3519800305366516,
0.4185269773006439,
0.1590202897787094,
0.14509479701519012,
0.4138326346874237,
0.31231918931007385,
0.4436316192150116,
-1.1475321054458618,
0.6245521903038025,
0.05407368019223213,
-0.2463798075914383,
-0.10332340747117996,
-0.211856409907341,
0.31406649947166443,
0.47246304154396057,
0.18145619332790375,
-0.1813209503889084,
0.1327711045742035,
-0.4375545382499695,
0.1087590903043747,
0.4404652416706085,
-0.4458165466785431,
-0.5628526210784912,
0.979086697101593,
0.22041857242584229,
0.014658376574516296,
0.2451632171869278,
0.3015885055065155,
-0.46644484996795654,
0.22090940177440643,
0.6118643879890442,
0.7734419107437134,
-0.6406638026237488,
0.20696967840194702,
0.31251391768455505,
0.15973211824893951,
-0.09104565531015396,
0.6345970630645752,
0.16852208971977234,
-0.3887662887573242,
-0.7138904333114624,
-0.944202721118927,
-0.51652592420578,
0.03335244953632355,
-0.49648791551589966,
-0.0391850546002388,
-0.5861318707466125,
-0.5473873019218445,
0.15035147964954376,
-0.35560357570648193,
-0.6097677946090698,
0.11702881753444672,
-0.02663533017039299,
0.9305725693702698,
-0.7383314371109009,
0.756374716758728,
1.2584561109542847,
-0.4045037627220154,
-0.39330652356147766,
-0.2431650310754776,
-0.16558009386062622,
-0.9489192366600037,
0.6555652022361755,
-0.3234190344810486,
-0.1520523726940155,
0.06043413653969765,
-0.5740604400634766,
-0.8246553540229797,
0.9814160466194153,
0.7043066024780273,
-0.5376773476600647,
-0.16517359018325806,
0.3362467288970947,
0.8423671126365662,
0.017427392303943634,
0.09294018149375916,
0.2187790423631668,
0.1552400141954422,
-0.17431321740150452,
-0.9866563081741333,
0.11289156228303909,
-0.34708282351493835,
-0.12328977882862091,
0.15833868086338043,
-0.5691509246826172,
0.8682117462158203,
0.010634555481374264,
-0.020349597558379173,
0.42030248045921326,
0.24332286417484283,
0.515773594379425,
0.17767298221588135,
-0.010796766728162766,
0.2878446877002716,
0.7629467248916626,
0.15789951384067535,
1.2258950471878052,
-0.7461494207382202,
0.10284596681594849,
0.7169533371925354,
-0.6476622819900513,
0.8860368132591248,
0.15208683907985687,
-0.4841279685497284,
0.5061240196228027,
0.44684654474258423,
0.2561585605144501,
0.5151563286781311,
0.2271714210510254,
-0.638025164604187,
-0.25520381331443787,
-0.2817203402519226,
-0.6601653099060059,
0.20057247579097748,
0.29750362038612366,
-0.375134140253067,
-0.24665355682373047,
0.1878991574048996,
-0.07875501364469528,
0.05799395591020584,
-0.45519304275512695,
0.7976616024971008,
0.34160667657852173,
-0.2221631109714508,
0.7387926578521729,
0.05984114110469818,
0.3969348073005676,
-0.8117213845252991,
-0.03133251518011093,
-0.1055927649140358,
0.23936569690704346,
-0.014085390605032444,
-0.43455472588539124,
-0.05385446548461914,
-0.03001001849770546,
-0.19742144644260406,
0.07146123051643372,
0.8180655837059021,
-0.5470998287200928,
-0.6559337377548218,
0.35350772738456726,
0.8864215016365051,
0.31766173243522644,
-0.14388658106327057,
-0.7249484062194824,
-0.00257021258585155,
-0.2928317189216614,
0.1634209305047989,
0.2981778085231781,
0.521040141582489,
-0.12973922491073608,
0.6132273077964783,
0.6135036945343018,
0.4881550967693329,
-0.2648680806159973,
-0.02664097398519516,
0.7534325122833252,
-0.5695316791534424,
-0.3180520236492157,
-0.728798508644104,
0.1227564588189125,
0.3722213804721832,
-0.13666212558746338,
0.47122567892074585,
0.5574888586997986,
0.4250872731208801,
-0.33816879987716675,
0.9603121876716614,
0.6509537696838379,
0.6453949809074402,
-0.42009854316711426,
0.9955096244812012,
-0.706638753414154,
-0.16531290113925934,
-0.17235729098320007,
-0.8390508890151978,
-0.20904064178466797,
0.31215593218803406,
-0.029739290475845337,
0.10985562205314636,
0.8195582628250122,
0.40932852029800415,
-0.0024449836928397417,
-0.25267183780670166,
0.32957425713539124,
0.3277445435523987,
-0.051810987293720245,
0.7113160490989685,
0.7215708494186401,
-0.10970944166183472,
0.12216506898403168,
0.06504996865987778,
-0.3174591660499573,
-0.12237534672021866,
-0.623666524887085,
-0.9194455146789551,
-0.29476770758628845,
-0.21779422461986542,
-0.4499121606349945,
0.4150404632091522,
1.3183636665344238,
0.5830127596855164,
-0.9462551474571228,
-0.10600286722183228,
0.30918270349502563,
-0.4190903306007385,
-0.14499971270561218,
-0.055743563920259476,
0.30477383732795715,
0.006753492634743452,
-0.35537588596343994,
0.5819302201271057,
0.37560996413230896,
0.22376054525375366,
-0.278882771730423,
-0.06167342886328697,
0.13144391775131226,
0.39039385318756104,
0.8079808354377747,
0.3615448474884033,
-0.6337642073631287,
0.0902804583311081,
0.3015857934951782,
-0.45951536297798157,
-0.17706888914108276,
0.6244298219680786,
-0.7819092869758606,
0.39910006523132324,
0.2282659411430359,
0.9993881583213806,
0.1665268987417221,
-0.11726625263690948,
0.696481466293335,
-0.3173661231994629,
0.049417316913604736,
0.14367453753948212,
0.2524779140949249,
0.21425825357437134,
-0.1290304809808731,
0.4249252378940582,
0.21818971633911133,
-0.2807912826538086,
-0.7024412155151367,
-0.14378048479557037,
-0.7980937957763672,
-0.7503711581230164,
1.1647099256515503,
0.05492442101240158,
-0.41537708044052124,
-0.03314071521162987,
-0.2208247035741806,
0.26153048872947693,
-0.027774067595601082,
0.39738601446151733,
0.4957107603549957,
0.13951173424720764,
0.14760147035121918,
-0.5368626117706299,
0.34343013167381287,
0.33095765113830566,
-0.992835521697998,
-0.05378324165940285,
0.623164713382721,
0.5989617705345154,
-0.14155466854572296,
1.0208892822265625,
-0.40552380681037903,
0.39604783058166504,
-0.4295676052570343,
0.45186465978622437,
0.20854412019252777,
0.006080977618694305,
-0.710348904132843,
0.032957617193460464,
0.33421704173088074,
0.30277055501937866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10359v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10359v2 | Can we Soft Prompt LLMs for Graph Learning Tasks? | 2024-02-15T23:09:42 | 2024-03-16T19:56:04 | Zheyuan Liu, Xiaoxin He, Yijun Tian, Nitesh V. Chawla | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Graph plays an important role in representing complex relationships in
real-world applications such as social networks, biological data and citation
networks. In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
tremendous success in various domains, which makes applying LLMs to graphs
particularly appealing. However, directly applying LLMs to graph modalities
presents unique challenges due to the discrepancy and mismatch between the
graph and text modalities. Hence, to further investigate LLMs' potential for
comprehending graph information, we introduce GraphPrompter, a novel framework
designed to align graph information with LLMs via soft prompts. Specifically,
GraphPrompter consists of two main components: a graph neural network to encode
complex graph information and an LLM that effectively processes textual
information. Comprehensive experiments on various benchmark datasets under node
classification and link prediction tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our
proposed method. The GraphPrompter framework unveils the substantial
capabilities of LLMs as predictors in graph-related tasks, enabling researchers
to utilize LLMs across a spectrum of real-world graph scenarios more
effectively. | [
-0.08205562084913254,
-0.9104209542274475,
0.7833141088485718,
-0.21622410416603088,
-0.3831351399421692,
0.2236829549074173,
-0.2538505494594574,
-0.18468178808689117,
0.09862590581178665,
0.18765117228031158,
-0.8467194437980652,
-0.6027668714523315,
-0.5640421509742737,
0.3222779631614685,
-0.06865425407886505,
1.0002676248550415,
-0.21611051261425018,
0.1797095239162445,
-0.34893202781677246,
0.061125703155994415,
-0.5946851372718811,
-0.22535733878612518,
-0.7440229058265686,
-0.5520777106285095,
1.0168641805648804,
0.31593745946884155,
0.44837406277656555,
0.2970728874206543,
0.22212840616703033,
0.40648046135902405,
-0.08976228535175323,
0.5140528082847595,
-0.565317690372467,
0.40137848258018494,
-0.13294565677642822,
-0.4510931968688965,
-0.2746492624282837,
-0.013045839965343475,
0.5175520777702332,
1.197554111480713,
0.3362574279308319,
0.02948463335633278,
0.5516021847724915,
0.49254167079925537,
-0.1727391928434372,
0.6371962428092957,
-0.4522861838340759,
-0.08163408190011978,
-0.024484902620315552,
-0.06576138734817505,
-0.40456488728523254,
-0.4791298508644104,
-0.04182695969939232,
-0.6559966802597046,
0.35423827171325684,
0.221985325217247,
0.7906502485275269,
0.08357485383749008,
-0.5764179229736328,
-0.15302471816539764,
-0.4364279508590698,
0.2252550572156906,
-0.3046630024909973,
0.37978532910346985,
-0.035654373466968536,
0.3071165382862091,
-0.475187748670578,
-1.0886006355285645,
-0.5373674631118774,
-0.11938713490962982,
-0.04231195151805878,
0.10593195259571075,
0.0035458842758089304,
0.20784235000610352,
0.1584019660949707,
-0.0062668342143297195,
-0.47636932134628296,
0.2905782163143158,
-0.13631948828697205,
-0.3724064528942108,
0.20290198922157288,
0.4008292853832245,
0.3250364065170288,
-0.24051204323768616,
-0.20490002632141113,
0.008668356575071812,
-0.6375107765197754,
0.10589229315519333,
0.28266048431396484,
0.7588137984275818,
0.07201284170150757,
0.5638957023620605,
0.09297787398099899,
0.8161405920982361,
0.07001671940088272,
-0.07434418052434921,
0.31721383333206177,
-0.1696702390909195,
0.06722594797611237,
0.04180008918046951,
0.9251294732093811,
0.2972744405269623,
0.5780258774757385,
-0.3757055699825287,
-0.2673385441303253,
0.15654948353767395,
-0.11325234174728394,
-0.8570894002914429,
-0.2609487473964691,
0.1563359498977661,
-0.27324172854423523,
-0.00512650003656745,
0.044625528156757355,
-0.5465536713600159,
-0.6637664437294006,
-0.34722524881362915,
-0.036055926233530045,
-0.3705609142780304,
-0.3071383237838745,
-0.07150746881961823,
-0.2476004958152771,
-0.34626415371894836,
0.4565739333629608,
-0.5219643115997314,
0.3182390630245209,
0.8069932460784912,
0.9743673205375671,
-0.14304526150226593,
-0.34975317120552063,
-0.7274989485740662,
0.08737515658140182,
-0.23040875792503357,
0.7798977494239807,
-0.4621627628803253,
-0.17186638712882996,
0.17908541858196259,
0.394945353269577,
-0.4569978713989258,
-0.4153052568435669,
0.31947487592697144,
-0.4694785475730896,
0.06089072301983833,
-0.16399464011192322,
-0.616580605506897,
-0.12428503483533859,
0.42891404032707214,
-0.8240060210227966,
0.7287550568580627,
0.37962546944618225,
-0.8050441145896912,
0.23303310573101044,
-0.1660347580909729,
-0.597557544708252,
0.3854222595691681,
-0.3507414162158966,
-0.3950727581977844,
-0.12801037728786469,
-0.10279109328985214,
0.7023327350616455,
-0.11789916455745697,
0.5203757286071777,
-0.42092445492744446,
-0.42690885066986084,
0.437452107667923,
-0.3131028115749359,
0.3842007517814636,
-0.03957734629511833,
-0.25920769572257996,
0.3722080886363983,
-0.3412148058414459,
-0.09422186017036438,
0.2685279846191406,
-0.2236514389514923,
-0.10013604909181595,
0.05843290314078331,
0.08467824012041092,
0.19591191411018372,
0.2773902714252472,
-0.5217030644416809,
0.19923356175422668,
-0.45279866456985474,
0.6381918787956238,
1.0640171766281128,
-0.08985061943531036,
0.33466044068336487,
-0.15573064982891083,
0.6237077713012695,
-0.1417163759469986,
-0.21641507744789124,
-0.18558759987354279,
-0.4426375925540924,
-0.2740735411643982,
-0.27325135469436646,
0.4231414198875427,
0.6658178567886353,
-0.720816969871521,
0.20627844333648682,
-0.33318012952804565,
-0.25225400924682617,
-0.028957700356841087,
0.4488430321216583,
0.35690268874168396,
0.76303631067276,
0.21371106803417206,
-0.030958862975239754,
-0.3916161358356476,
-0.3250640630722046,
-0.16225819289684296,
-0.10896845906972885,
-0.14987099170684814,
0.6789560914039612,
0.24274298548698425,
-0.11443814635276794,
0.9185407757759094,
-0.7350503206253052,
-0.551622211933136,
-0.844136655330658,
0.0384814478456974,
0.5107016563415527,
0.13985006511211395,
0.39393219351768494,
-0.9198723435401917,
-0.3705340027809143,
-0.33909228444099426,
-0.7821817398071289,
-0.2059916853904724,
0.12262220680713654,
0.07418249547481537,
-0.18412400782108307,
0.7627778053283691,
-0.736611008644104,
-0.08282792568206787,
0.3879232406616211,
-0.5259276628494263,
0.4872475564479828,
-0.007067307364195585,
-0.28819921612739563,
-1.011022686958313,
-0.11354004591703415,
0.2526048719882965,
-0.4770106375217438,
-0.32087329030036926,
-0.3164401948451996,
-0.06126857176423073,
-0.28165337443351746,
-0.4281936585903168,
0.675966739654541,
-0.4775049686431885,
0.18345028162002563,
-0.2005939781665802,
0.42955413460731506,
0.13393725454807281,
0.3856858015060425,
-0.2643680274486542,
0.6809364557266235,
0.6548886895179749,
-0.582883358001709,
0.4487112760543823,
0.21213847398757935,
-0.12393886595964432,
0.46286365389823914,
-0.8249147534370422,
0.1031416654586792,
-0.4477293789386749,
0.633000910282135,
-1.34052574634552,
-0.3207038938999176,
0.43566426634788513,
-0.31877240538597107,
0.5597687363624573,
-0.29673710465431213,
-0.6416018605232239,
-0.5798331499099731,
-0.23518751561641693,
0.19059090316295624,
0.348570317029953,
-0.330431193113327,
0.8315733075141907,
0.170427605509758,
-0.23800607025623322,
-0.23793962597846985,
-0.30052444338798523,
0.07174760848283768,
-0.06562016904354095,
-0.5251463651657104,
0.3091442286968231,
-0.09168336540460587,
0.10293014347553253,
0.16165520250797272,
-0.05620729923248291,
0.1524830311536789,
0.18918350338935852,
0.6848511695861816,
0.40981507301330566,
-0.20836970210075378,
0.19183200597763062,
-0.16283826529979706,
-0.5290079712867737,
0.13067051768302917,
-0.6307730078697205,
0.6213729381561279,
0.02397974021732807,
-0.40091410279273987,
-0.24750378727912903,
-0.09395410865545273,
0.236422598361969,
0.006279587745666504,
0.43859395384788513,
0.7428724765777588,
-0.3383885324001312,
-0.1423390954732895,
-0.20409314334392548,
-0.32925084233283997,
-0.5780784487724304,
0.4445304274559021,
-0.3112621009349823,
-1.105736494064331,
0.43707987666130066,
-0.8274626731872559,
-0.3468187153339386,
0.10930456221103668,
0.12643134593963623,
-0.28702405095100403,
1.403853416442871,
0.4769347012042999,
-0.1334434598684311,
0.5961014032363892,
-0.366708368062973,
0.3543107509613037,
-0.7746310234069824,
-0.5295642018318176,
-0.33567601442337036,
-0.5701143145561218,
-0.42137691378593445,
-0.01231439970433712,
0.40061262249946594,
0.16657887399196625,
-0.27873557806015015,
0.06481089442968369,
-0.4752424955368042,
0.4117237627506256,
0.2804080843925476,
0.5247784852981567,
-0.2305714637041092,
0.03442201763391495,
-0.33425790071487427,
-0.01506507396697998,
-0.8191441893577576,
-0.4346887171268463,
0.5862998366355896,
0.15370051562786102,
0.7776443362236023,
-0.1585129052400589,
0.4693835377693176,
0.1682787388563156,
0.315426230430603,
-0.9996012449264526,
0.8319646120071411,
-0.36137956380844116,
-0.04203910008072853,
-0.0796101838350296,
-0.45003536343574524,
-1.2984082698822021,
-0.15205518901348114,
-0.06865492463111877,
-0.7221552729606628,
-0.011856826953589916,
0.2422754466533661,
-0.12778255343437195,
0.20324406027793884,
-0.5022148489952087,
1.047239065170288,
-0.19667887687683105,
-0.49610525369644165,
0.3236749470233917,
-0.41427499055862427,
-0.13204379379749298,
0.22446800768375397,
0.3969956636428833,
-0.5028899908065796,
-0.20919694006443024,
0.8139906525611877,
-0.3371891677379608,
1.3437288999557495,
-0.37400129437446594,
0.069700688123703,
0.3598652184009552,
0.31924405694007874,
0.720672070980072,
0.025370405986905098,
-0.22759583592414856,
-0.17576202750205994,
-0.609243631362915,
-0.2162022739648819,
-0.6993961334228516,
0.683634340763092,
-0.5381770133972168,
-0.6575804352760315,
-0.16830630600452423,
-0.6103925704956055,
-0.31106019020080566,
0.499408483505249,
0.24235877394676208,
0.7684798836708069,
-0.023118313401937485,
-0.16448543965816498,
0.6218317747116089,
0.3110652267932892,
0.290673166513443,
0.17614062130451202,
-0.05307161435484886,
-0.34792086482048035,
1.1357595920562744,
0.1564721316099167,
0.0026260504964739084,
0.18372797966003418,
0.38484588265419006,
-0.507202684879303,
-0.7193054556846619,
-0.39323389530181885,
0.38561126589775085,
-0.9131195545196533,
-0.533053457736969,
-0.7014302015304565,
-0.022233450785279274,
-0.3552335202693939,
-0.3203478455543518,
0.2822911739349365,
-0.17051458358764648,
-0.6097792983055115,
-0.3784593343734741,
0.579439103603363,
0.8503829836845398,
0.307071715593338,
0.2743198275566101,
-0.7694942355155945,
0.20746497809886932,
0.24627910554409027,
0.3090022802352905,
-0.24369646608829498,
-0.2843198776245117,
0.06849843263626099,
-0.05570918694138527,
-0.09044216573238373,
-0.9750782251358032,
0.2027042657136917,
0.38534459471702576,
0.6686297059059143,
0.4029217064380646,
0.17976132035255432,
0.21298480033874512,
-0.5848687291145325,
0.7988749146461487,
0.3383229672908783,
-0.7237206101417542,
0.5834149122238159,
-0.3584705591201782,
0.07754629850387573,
0.5680820345878601,
0.6450548768043518,
-0.3134815990924835,
-0.4277695119380951,
-0.4138883054256439,
-1.0265071392059326,
0.4116772711277008,
-0.36834362149238586,
0.5732539296150208,
-0.17186836898326874,
0.6380751132965088,
0.03241962194442749,
0.06309820711612701,
-0.6678938269615173,
-0.13917800784111023,
-0.3191213011741638,
-0.8108657002449036,
-0.08174949884414673,
-0.2119024693965912,
-0.07941444218158722,
-0.07294899970293045,
0.23955591022968292,
-0.7145674228668213,
-0.03151461109519005,
0.10592707246541977,
-0.1983790397644043,
-0.16655725240707397,
0.062390271574258804,
-0.08220195770263672,
0.7732959389686584,
0.02460610680282116,
0.5659776329994202,
0.3429921865463257,
-0.3282569646835327,
0.2815134525299072,
0.23388922214508057,
-0.11239476501941681,
0.01053621619939804,
0.668053150177002,
0.7569246292114258,
0.5148966312408447,
-0.7382029294967651,
0.7777016758918762,
0.08508795499801636,
-0.10624247789382935,
0.05989394709467888,
0.29828381538391113,
0.319298654794693,
0.2195870578289032,
0.3433206379413605,
-0.18640398979187012,
0.050731394439935684,
-0.4235275685787201,
0.09599833190441132,
0.4014071822166443,
-0.8191461563110352,
-0.43139544129371643,
0.746258556842804,
0.12015905231237411,
-0.5313490033149719,
0.760392963886261,
-0.33680352568626404,
-0.9548051953315735,
0.7120497226715088,
0.9718799591064453,
0.4985108971595764,
-0.0894700288772583,
0.2544499337673187,
0.28435176610946655,
-0.24100962281227112,
0.17914587259292603,
0.3351338505744934,
0.14679521322250366,
-0.6440437436103821,
-0.3916967511177063,
-0.39849045872688293,
-0.2669858932495117,
-0.12261249870061874,
-0.18869547545909882,
0.3637271523475647,
-0.57275390625,
-0.33848655223846436,
0.06567328423261642,
-0.006376351695507765,
-0.6479634642601013,
0.11426500231027603,
0.1971784383058548,
0.8756903409957886,
-0.9727939367294312,
0.37671515345573425,
0.8543911576271057,
-0.3756794035434723,
-1.0040324926376343,
-0.21997806429862976,
0.04803094267845154,
-0.7375490665435791,
0.8278112411499023,
0.5260248184204102,
-0.3172162175178528,
0.26370322704315186,
-0.6705377697944641,
-0.3086886405944824,
1.100405216217041,
0.6510780453681946,
-0.4846700131893158,
-0.08630166202783585,
0.17724040150642395,
0.21810543537139893,
-0.3187229335308075,
0.20338313281536102,
0.04872961342334747,
0.5411487221717834,
0.24144357442855835,
-0.48437851667404175,
0.6338931918144226,
-0.3666500151157379,
-0.2493753284215927,
0.1855859011411667,
-0.5461066961288452,
0.9043519496917725,
-0.3420095145702362,
-0.2582506537437439,
-0.3578391969203949,
0.7434206008911133,
0.33796367049217224,
0.47041410207748413,
0.7749356031417847,
-0.09965292364358902,
0.9419530034065247,
-0.043260861188173294,
0.943812370300293,
-0.4450286626815796,
0.03854865953326225,
0.8889017701148987,
-0.4844357371330261,
0.3890487551689148,
0.20429888367652893,
-0.16216792166233063,
0.8405773043632507,
1.0085113048553467,
0.07367967814207077,
0.3187687397003174,
0.3883426785469055,
-0.23169292509555817,
-0.45290473103523254,
-0.5682873129844666,
-0.319987952709198,
0.040252573788166046,
0.5084345936775208,
-0.13030166923999786,
-0.24359287321567535,
0.033148717135190964,
0.16800570487976074,
0.20266003906726837,
-0.3679683208465576,
0.7387195825576782,
0.3085522949695587,
-0.4854739010334015,
0.3112754225730896,
-0.2477131187915802,
0.5713685154914856,
-0.7292458415031433,
-0.16981914639472961,
-0.017784666270017624,
0.21291835606098175,
-0.26522010564804077,
-1.0117650032043457,
-0.027096711099147797,
-0.29868969321250916,
-0.06804929673671722,
-0.3469063937664032,
1.18386709690094,
-0.21939396858215332,
-0.53243488073349,
0.5446385145187378,
0.5627105832099915,
-0.02496703527867794,
-0.1798398196697235,
-0.7870023846626282,
0.016435394063591957,
-0.39374643564224243,
-0.23645690083503723,
0.33710646629333496,
0.7720183730125427,
0.02526536025106907,
0.6802495718002319,
0.5947418212890625,
-0.02066643349826336,
-0.37585246562957764,
0.4788382947444916,
1.2427997589111328,
-0.4122741222381592,
-0.5364644527435303,
-0.9389375448226929,
0.17697420716285706,
0.057258911430835724,
-0.028448421508073807,
0.7651014924049377,
0.565274178981781,
0.4023251533508301,
0.26779505610466003,
0.7696519494056702,
0.17559657990932465,
0.22804009914398193,
-0.5261651277542114,
0.40488430857658386,
-0.34775471687316895,
-0.0007328195497393608,
-0.19403094053268433,
-0.729356586933136,
-0.16326774656772614,
0.15757350623607635,
-0.396982878446579,
0.11882781982421875,
0.6296858787536621,
0.7110292911529541,
-0.1908714771270752,
-0.1713721752166748,
-0.1710675209760666,
0.04255322739481926,
0.2140491008758545,
0.5664660930633545,
0.8287393450737,
0.08115451037883759,
0.7397769093513489,
0.1302599012851715,
-0.20244520902633667,
-0.21569621562957764,
-0.9732622504234314,
-1.0076478719711304,
-0.5494264960289001,
-0.3360997438430786,
-0.7495351433753967,
0.17462243139743805,
0.9713612794876099,
0.5658145546913147,
-0.6074602603912354,
-0.08661362528800964,
-0.2779289186000824,
0.5778625011444092,
-0.16849546134471893,
-0.25349536538124084,
0.45810630917549133,
-0.49994605779647827,
-0.639401376247406,
0.40000447630882263,
0.03209495171904564,
0.2592233717441559,
-0.12098076194524765,
-0.14681659638881683,
0.06747137010097504,
-0.17764130234718323,
0.4059756100177765,
0.06905076652765274,
-0.29655128717422485,
-0.2783535122871399,
0.2070145606994629,
-0.1973876953125,
0.0439627431333065,
1.0746779441833496,
-0.947415828704834,
0.008965964429080486,
0.6756504774093628,
0.42521950602531433,
0.44169166684150696,
-0.07625327259302139,
0.45001864433288574,
-0.7712308168411255,
0.07509564608335495,
0.20723843574523926,
0.5542630553245544,
0.49907180666923523,
-0.7367798686027527,
0.3800027668476105,
0.5030755996704102,
-0.13431958854198456,
-0.8004153966903687,
0.2586559057235718,
-0.9462082982063293,
-0.5199074745178223,
1.1154943704605103,
-0.3424514830112457,
-0.6221092939376831,
-0.49285200238227844,
-0.24653442203998566,
0.5415338277816772,
-0.20182295143604279,
0.2428242713212967,
0.2814544141292572,
-0.16891847550868988,
-0.11733363568782806,
-0.29018205404281616,
0.17774565517902374,
0.06580772250890732,
-0.6650938391685486,
0.05887873098254204,
0.5261202454566956,
0.4162704646587372,
0.02132273092865944,
0.765438437461853,
0.4169265031814575,
0.08776259422302246,
-0.09490730613470078,
-0.2750048041343689,
-0.6753063201904297,
-0.4280773997306824,
0.04790564626455307,
0.42490845918655396,
0.171778604388237,
0.06786388903856277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10353v1 | Prompt-Based Bias Calibration for Better Zero/Few-Shot Learning of Language Models | 2024-02-15T22:54:24 | 2024-02-15T22:54:24 | Kang He, Yinghan Long, Kaushik Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Prompt learning is susceptible to intrinsic bias present in pre-trained
language models (LMs), resulting in sub-optimal performance of prompt-based
zero/few-shot learning. In this work, we propose a null-input prompting method
to calibrate intrinsic bias encoded in pre-trained LMs. Different from prior
efforts that address intrinsic bias primarily for social fairness and often
involve excessive computational cost, our objective is to explore enhancing
LMs' performance in downstream zero/few-shot learning while emphasizing the
efficiency of intrinsic bias calibration. Specifically, we leverage a diverse
set of auto-selected null-meaning inputs generated from GPT-4 to prompt
pre-trained LMs for intrinsic bias probing. Utilizing the bias-reflected
probability distribution, we formulate a distribution disparity loss for bias
calibration, where we exclusively update bias parameters ($0.1\%$ of total
parameters) of LMs towards equal probability distribution. Experimental results
show that the calibration promotes an equitable starting point for LMs while
preserving language modeling abilities. Across a wide range of datasets,
including sentiment analysis and topic classification, our method significantly
improves zero/few-shot learning performance of LMs for both in-context learning
and prompt-based fine-tuning (on average $9\%$ and $2\%$, respectively). | [
-0.31681177020072937,
-0.8008080720901489,
0.6996159553527832,
-0.09741104394197464,
-0.29061299562454224,
-0.15011364221572876,
-0.3638613820075989,
0.10956952720880508,
-0.07427099347114563,
0.07375191897153854,
-0.7684504985809326,
-0.45269134640693665,
-0.3894166052341461,
0.09985067695379257,
0.2670878767967224,
1.0871648788452148,
0.1371903270483017,
0.444806843996048,
0.005084577016532421,
-0.04157533124089241,
-0.8272010684013367,
-0.24832972884178162,
-0.47596755623817444,
-0.2503504753112793,
0.7588558197021484,
0.507490336894989,
0.2484149932861328,
0.27652767300605774,
-0.09241101890802383,
0.14246350526809692,
-0.07013648748397827,
-0.0888870432972908,
-0.6272939443588257,
0.19857646524906158,
-0.33544930815696716,
-0.48829734325408936,
-0.1026802733540535,
0.21055549383163452,
0.637103259563446,
0.7477620244026184,
0.19200976192951202,
0.3292868733406067,
0.28840020298957825,
0.5334595441818237,
-0.9337658882141113,
0.05355357006192207,
-0.8178765773773193,
0.04005206376314163,
-0.2211153209209442,
-0.44655683636665344,
-0.46753355860710144,
-0.6301527619361877,
0.13616614043712616,
-0.4267122149467468,
0.19262318313121796,
-0.15930120646953583,
0.6119512319564819,
0.5306054949760437,
-0.25806504487991333,
0.04545765370130539,
-0.5299919247627258,
0.9122142791748047,
-0.7708299160003662,
0.2532021999359131,
0.4885885715484619,
0.260097861289978,
0.0006539379828609526,
-0.004725905600935221,
-0.5628940463066101,
-0.2849094271659851,
0.18816104531288147,
0.12831991910934448,
0.11183691769838333,
0.09081923216581345,
0.5043318271636963,
0.11161144077777863,
-0.5054457783699036,
0.18273070454597473,
-0.07229991257190704,
-0.39068910479545593,
0.18156835436820984,
-0.07006148248910904,
0.018981412053108215,
-0.10771191865205765,
-0.0240248404443264,
-0.07510154694318771,
-0.9347365498542786,
0.07151492685079575,
0.6121325492858887,
0.6502743363380432,
-0.05926015228033066,
0.26705488562583923,
-0.19162388145923615,
0.8025492429733276,
0.31685662269592285,
-0.021102793514728546,
0.37548133730888367,
-0.32459697127342224,
0.08253445476293564,
0.15004554390907288,
0.5171636939048767,
0.20845595002174377,
0.2622639238834381,
0.11223458498716354,
-0.19908024370670319,
0.10014976561069489,
-0.06164412200450897,
-0.9063171744346619,
0.01335194893181324,
0.0276484414935112,
-0.02782166562974453,
-0.2592763304710388,
-0.2516392171382904,
-0.5987728834152222,
-0.3656909763813019,
-0.39288246631622314,
0.6807590126991272,
-0.28957656025886536,
0.012555851601064205,
-0.11645188182592392,
0.11278709769248962,
0.4132724404335022,
0.5816747546195984,
-0.8300865292549133,
-0.07063011825084686,
0.20572321116924286,
0.8059658408164978,
0.052677616477012634,
-0.14501439034938812,
-1.0521360635757446,
-0.27724316716194153,
-0.26314759254455566,
0.6678844690322876,
-0.312110036611557,
-0.20777656137943268,
0.09808503836393356,
-0.2709434926509857,
0.07679300755262375,
-0.13763779401779175,
0.6917546987533569,
-0.5510693788528442,
0.46098336577415466,
-0.6109490394592285,
-0.5243076086044312,
0.011705967597663403,
0.457468718290329,
-0.3901670277118683,
0.9036393761634827,
0.049021363258361816,
-0.8523159623146057,
0.6037619113922119,
-0.4499201476573944,
-0.28344228863716125,
0.17408952116966248,
-0.45277276635169983,
-0.31113529205322266,
0.045630015432834625,
0.38309410214424133,
0.46875062584877014,
-0.07629316300153732,
0.2710263431072235,
-0.5696425437927246,
-0.5213565826416016,
0.06011874973773956,
-0.722172200679779,
0.6751413345336914,
-0.025681860744953156,
-0.6495257616043091,
0.04146274924278259,
-0.6254101395606995,
-0.0028250121977180243,
-0.050055619329214096,
0.06245614215731621,
-0.35882818698883057,
-0.07265851646661758,
-0.29436442255973816,
0.38740697503089905,
0.17428551614284515,
-0.5921902060508728,
0.16152669489383698,
-0.5980490446090698,
-0.11595398187637329,
1.112315058708191,
0.010976048186421394,
0.7261376976966858,
-0.13578657805919647,
0.5551633238792419,
0.1824684590101242,
0.07761583477258682,
-0.6126827001571655,
-0.3443828821182251,
-0.7236343622207642,
-0.22338420152664185,
0.3509840667247772,
0.5676445364952087,
-0.8019959926605225,
0.5710998177528381,
-0.044450320303440094,
-0.1486184448003769,
-0.4746660888195038,
0.08774937689304352,
0.2493533194065094,
1.1318984031677246,
0.32981398701667786,
-0.2871621251106262,
-0.09897904098033905,
-0.6086413860321045,
-0.25472888350486755,
-0.12885244190692902,
-0.07237866520881653,
0.4697134494781494,
0.21930669248104095,
-0.02477879635989666,
1.317797064781189,
-0.4163498878479004,
-0.3883965015411377,
-0.11600780487060547,
0.21598653495311737,
0.5460426807403564,
0.295120507478714,
0.5760848522186279,
-0.20866243541240692,
-0.6380988359451294,
-0.3128040134906769,
-0.4766026735305786,
-0.7193162441253662,
-0.0011016576318070292,
-0.20410528779029846,
0.14537255465984344,
0.014255856163799763,
-0.2866438627243042,
0.43636205792427063,
0.24261517822742462,
-0.26820093393325806,
0.6351001858711243,
0.002465183148160577,
0.09202039986848831,
-0.7683031558990479,
0.05464445799589157,
0.1948915421962738,
-0.3510618805885315,
-0.6264668107032776,
-0.3030908405780792,
0.25524038076400757,
0.13330595195293427,
-0.6836061477661133,
0.8330729603767395,
-0.3960099518299103,
0.10294365137815475,
-0.4373134970664978,
0.20407643914222717,
0.007061608135700226,
0.6412030458450317,
0.020963463932275772,
0.8173792958259583,
0.8150407671928406,
-0.6746670007705688,
-0.09297829121351242,
-0.07085306942462921,
0.07371103763580322,
0.6970536708831787,
-0.5845664143562317,
0.34907659888267517,
-0.38796618580818176,
0.3817962110042572,
-0.7537612915039062,
0.1885780692100525,
0.4694540500640869,
-0.4214556813240051,
0.35359975695610046,
-0.44458356499671936,
-0.24798054993152618,
0.020863911136984825,
-0.6528013348579407,
0.4849526286125183,
0.5569973587989807,
-0.48024001717567444,
0.27639240026474,
0.14004427194595337,
-0.36584386229515076,
-0.7822589874267578,
-0.30288463830947876,
-0.37797144055366516,
-0.0016436215955764055,
-0.21176202595233917,
0.08766427636146545,
-0.26703429222106934,
0.19246555864810944,
-0.25945809483528137,
-0.12760937213897705,
0.2468491643667221,
-0.07941750437021255,
0.10344900190830231,
0.5033679008483887,
-0.1690487116575241,
0.11508810520172119,
0.2821353077888489,
-0.22794169187545776,
-0.09700660407543182,
-0.5809913277626038,
0.6961321830749512,
0.034237392246723175,
-0.47382158041000366,
-0.351668119430542,
0.043165821582078934,
0.14977417886257172,
0.020584173500537872,
0.6141489744186401,
0.6050511002540588,
-0.31086665391921997,
-0.3462296426296234,
-0.6563392281532288,
-0.5789104700088501,
-0.4516899585723877,
0.2349921315908432,
-0.20464667677879333,
-0.945662796497345,
0.4255523681640625,
0.10309267789125443,
0.13478195667266846,
0.28665563464164734,
0.6907781362533569,
0.15655696392059326,
1.0092240571975708,
0.49700024724006653,
-0.415921151638031,
0.6590630412101746,
0.029599616304039955,
0.11927353590726852,
-0.626716673374176,
0.04856392368674278,
-0.6202425360679626,
-0.17508156597614288,
-0.21284706890583038,
-0.5279911756515503,
0.4270364046096802,
0.0783071517944336,
-0.38786086440086365,
-0.13032777607440948,
-0.3209800720214844,
0.6808275580406189,
0.7722188830375671,
0.1808498054742813,
0.07002987712621689,
0.030462708324193954,
-0.41264408826828003,
-0.32135888934135437,
-0.5637305378913879,
-0.5675146579742432,
1.1021220684051514,
0.37047097086906433,
0.899440586566925,
-0.14150995016098022,
0.7380649447441101,
0.3375384211540222,
0.33248788118362427,
-0.7554063200950623,
0.3081451952457428,
0.22322040796279907,
-0.44109204411506653,
-0.3399201035499573,
-0.7949468493461609,
-0.4807629883289337,
0.14332203567028046,
0.00727709848433733,
-0.6211033463478088,
0.3649961054325104,
0.5849444270133972,
-0.5817359089851379,
-0.02610793523490429,
-0.7500850558280945,
0.7774497866630554,
-0.2606716752052307,
-0.7970521450042725,
0.031121084466576576,
-0.5670445561408997,
0.2609279751777649,
-0.14729522168636322,
0.08725562691688538,
-0.32986608147621155,
0.14234623312950134,
0.5483184456825256,
-0.2710564434528351,
0.9979177117347717,
-0.750633955001831,
-0.17814669013023376,
0.02193935215473175,
0.09516799449920654,
0.5512141585350037,
0.2785137891769409,
-0.19602644443511963,
0.17963023483753204,
-0.28713542222976685,
-0.47129255533218384,
-0.5597350597381592,
0.5746904611587524,
-0.8381929397583008,
-0.3461560606956482,
-0.6071232557296753,
-0.16653871536254883,
-0.4347643554210663,
0.23758022487163544,
0.31777480244636536,
0.3906414806842804,
-0.18565037846565247,
-0.3357887268066406,
0.7499449253082275,
-0.4183329939842224,
0.38623684644699097,
0.8298383951187134,
-0.04762251302599907,
-0.20888632535934448,
0.9485080242156982,
-0.012408914975821972,
0.2475307434797287,
0.26427072286605835,
0.2605006992816925,
-0.5601825714111328,
-0.2778600752353668,
-0.6111820936203003,
0.2956593632698059,
-0.7650790810585022,
-0.44024658203125,
-0.5531882643699646,
-0.030678700655698776,
-0.43259093165397644,
-0.15832030773162842,
-0.3325471878051758,
-0.2488182932138443,
-0.518502950668335,
-0.1076761856675148,
0.29182934761047363,
0.31353533267974854,
-0.0808565765619278,
0.5245363712310791,
-0.6031790971755981,
0.09781528264284134,
0.2854655683040619,
0.39070212841033936,
-0.07802516967058182,
-0.9841384887695312,
-0.10252568125724792,
0.3358842730522156,
-0.38656628131866455,
-1.058403730392456,
0.3082403540611267,
0.27424314618110657,
0.45612218976020813,
0.5524897575378418,
0.14501993358135223,
0.6282416582107544,
-0.8100196719169617,
0.810930073261261,
0.22109198570251465,
-1.1864278316497803,
0.7061002254486084,
-0.23873472213745117,
0.6015694737434387,
0.9453749656677246,
0.34282398223876953,
-0.519670307636261,
-0.21746926009655,
-0.269563764333725,
-0.7111150622367859,
1.0490199327468872,
-0.02401484176516533,
0.4158935844898224,
0.07632081210613251,
0.21884523332118988,
0.3174057900905609,
0.18040306866168976,
-0.8926824927330017,
-0.4365066885948181,
-0.34882283210754395,
-0.2508477568626404,
-0.06758040934801102,
-0.15901155769824982,
0.11499819904565811,
-0.2599582374095917,
0.9243716597557068,
-0.5302832126617432,
0.08520606905221939,
0.02579096332192421,
-0.5085814595222473,
-0.21504758298397064,
0.42638808488845825,
0.5179217457771301,
0.3857743442058563,
-0.30910348892211914,
0.1600942611694336,
0.2997579872608185,
-0.4449935555458069,
0.3359068036079407,
0.189602792263031,
-0.5986798405647278,
0.058055583387613297,
-0.06626700609922409,
1.1137826442718506,
0.13463741540908813,
-0.47040829062461853,
0.8780270218849182,
-0.17663510143756866,
0.0026955234352499247,
0.07958026975393295,
-0.02317100018262863,
-0.41843539476394653,
-0.05153576657176018,
0.7084598541259766,
-0.007578756660223007,
0.09220482409000397,
-0.20435519516468048,
0.22513307631015778,
0.45830658078193665,
-0.5016235709190369,
-0.5521895885467529,
0.4675906300544739,
0.3930290937423706,
-0.003222402883693576,
0.42503342032432556,
-0.44461700320243835,
-0.7656221985816956,
0.054876603186130524,
0.4240743815898895,
1.0126912593841553,
-0.32796984910964966,
0.4621046781539917,
0.4626479148864746,
0.29307493567466736,
0.06400250643491745,
0.10162140429019928,
-0.39623120427131653,
-0.9079300165176392,
-0.6328626275062561,
-0.6329512000083923,
-0.5040185451507568,
0.07633135467767715,
-0.2841027081012726,
0.5636371970176697,
-0.4769485294818878,
-0.1110927164554596,
-0.35678666830062866,
0.1439974308013916,
-0.8124564290046692,
0.07042161375284195,
0.42587825655937195,
0.6898335814476013,
-1.007102608680725,
0.6079962849617004,
0.46534737944602966,
-0.5032344460487366,
-0.8098894953727722,
0.08394449204206467,
0.17253462970256805,
-0.7630487680435181,
0.6520370244979858,
0.2680368423461914,
-0.1731557548046112,
0.26063182950019836,
-0.602195680141449,
-0.6945322155952454,
0.7316338419914246,
0.7699584364891052,
-0.6354023814201355,
0.09373243898153305,
0.08442938327789307,
0.23776966333389282,
-0.1721736341714859,
0.9951151609420776,
0.2615814507007599,
0.2726835310459137,
0.14834339916706085,
-0.726525068283081,
-0.006628320552408695,
-0.16961728036403656,
-0.1600067913532257,
0.0004709663917310536,
-0.26310211420059204,
0.6308814883232117,
0.0027475550305098295,
-0.22266696393489838,
-0.4539267420768738,
0.5399643778800964,
0.510012686252594,
0.1896428018808365,
0.564139723777771,
0.2711386978626251,
0.6910939812660217,
-0.04529127851128578,
0.6073062419891357,
-0.2948491871356964,
0.3811914026737213,
1.0740069150924683,
-0.755419135093689,
0.5348635911941528,
0.48336175084114075,
0.0004758642171509564,
0.2970513701438904,
0.7139353156089783,
0.43163585662841797,
0.6244427561759949,
0.10659629851579666,
-0.600032389163971,
-0.0718093067407608,
-0.15250076353549957,
-0.3706466853618622,
-0.07159734517335892,
0.18913115561008453,
-0.11068858951330185,
-0.5093830823898315,
0.06399697810411453,
0.03465894237160683,
-0.2166629135608673,
-0.297936350107193,
0.7006794214248657,
0.07448733597993851,
-0.6179558634757996,
0.5031458735466003,
-0.13040874898433685,
1.00333571434021,
-0.6635602116584778,
-0.052443649619817734,
-0.4637106955051422,
0.020510224625468254,
-0.037516046315431595,
-0.4560397267341614,
-0.20739896595478058,
0.2219819575548172,
-0.21189604699611664,
-0.3776889443397522,
0.7382614016532898,
-0.5094770193099976,
-0.22087202966213226,
0.10522779077291489,
0.6046296954154968,
-0.016734933480620384,
-0.24285270273685455,
-0.6675297021865845,
0.024912407621741295,
0.022579118609428406,
-0.27994468808174133,
0.33434566855430603,
0.33300793170928955,
0.12424881011247635,
0.26001760363578796,
0.7028300166130066,
0.26374301314353943,
0.1786150485277176,
0.5639325380325317,
0.9225377440452576,
-0.5754616260528564,
-0.6730761528015137,
-0.9431636333465576,
0.6171152591705322,
-0.07178103923797607,
-0.2951079308986664,
0.7028418183326721,
0.2680532932281494,
0.8462297916412354,
-0.08453155308961868,
0.8968491554260254,
0.1057453528046608,
0.5621008276939392,
-0.5332322120666504,
0.5887033939361572,
-0.2786482274532318,
0.29217493534088135,
-0.5623158812522888,
-1.1212459802627563,
-0.26867470145225525,
0.8283319473266602,
-0.5299356579780579,
0.27060601115226746,
0.5693170428276062,
0.9480555653572083,
-0.0629764050245285,
-0.14107298851013184,
0.5030474066734314,
0.0881517231464386,
0.24641919136047363,
0.41211313009262085,
0.8961561918258667,
-0.21482016146183014,
0.04278852418065071,
-0.14779974520206451,
-0.635741114616394,
-0.17211298644542694,
-0.9898229241371155,
-0.8707992434501648,
-0.2870599627494812,
-0.2617533206939697,
-0.1500127911567688,
0.17084228992462158,
1.2247310876846313,
0.7433755993843079,
-0.8665066361427307,
0.02541777491569519,
-0.04259364306926727,
0.12953652441501617,
0.208819180727005,
-0.2431008219718933,
0.1728217601776123,
-0.7529193162918091,
-0.7907764911651611,
0.28095734119415283,
0.3265227675437927,
-0.09360121190547943,
-0.37601393461227417,
-0.3160178065299988,
-0.06349584460258484,
0.01567217707633972,
0.587731122970581,
0.32554465532302856,
-0.44138574600219727,
-0.2221146672964096,
0.21443597972393036,
-0.08201411366462708,
-0.037414826452732086,
0.7252623438835144,
-1.1103124618530273,
0.4573644697666168,
0.4121326804161072,
0.8027046918869019,
0.3443021774291992,
-0.12864698469638824,
0.6397671103477478,
-1.1282694339752197,
0.29338857531547546,
0.5160382986068726,
0.2370487004518509,
0.36894580721855164,
-0.3780722916126251,
0.11053944379091263,
0.3200138509273529,
-0.6086406111717224,
-0.8931632041931152,
0.10899952799081802,
-0.7418799996376038,
0.07609239965677261,
1.0709738731384277,
0.005652209278196096,
-0.17950063943862915,
-0.01604175940155983,
-0.3981196880340576,
0.3149057626724243,
-0.7454738020896912,
0.5609874725341797,
0.5214918851852417,
0.2627837061882019,
-0.2900303304195404,
-0.335360586643219,
0.43242451548576355,
0.7645109295845032,
-0.6539841890335083,
-0.038968704640865326,
0.8270736336708069,
0.24757274985313416,
-0.24689997732639313,
0.919413685798645,
0.12721629440784454,
0.3885708451271057,
-0.5091040134429932,
0.20112717151641846,
0.1635133922100067,
-0.19864465296268463,
-0.889336884021759,
-0.21304303407669067,
0.08250436186790466,
-0.09251554310321808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19669v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19669v2 | Analyzing the Roles of Language and Vision in Learning from Limited Data | 2024-02-15T22:19:41 | 2024-05-10T17:33:24 | Allison Chen, Ilia Sucholutsky, Olga Russakovsky, Thomas L. Griffiths | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Does language help make sense of the visual world? How important is it to
actually see the world rather than having it described with words? These basic
questions about the nature of intelligence have been difficult to answer
because we only had one example of an intelligent system -- humans -- and
limited access to cases that isolated language or vision. However, the
development of sophisticated Vision-Language Models (VLMs) by artificial
intelligence researchers offers us new opportunities to explore the
contributions that language and vision make to learning about the world. We
ablate components from the cognitive architecture of these models to identify
their contributions to learning new tasks from limited data. We find that a
language model leveraging all components recovers a majority of a VLM's
performance, despite its lack of visual input, and that language seems to allow
this by providing access to prior knowledge and reasoning. | [
-0.32685500383377075,
-0.6918859481811523,
0.7789925932884216,
-0.31047695875167847,
-0.062108829617500305,
-0.06432683765888214,
-0.16747738420963287,
-0.8409290909767151,
-0.14901365339756012,
0.7445833683013916,
-0.4251127541065216,
-0.076431043446064,
-0.47477245330810547,
-0.19641968607902527,
-0.3377337157726288,
0.7066044807434082,
0.3079667091369629,
0.13641737401485443,
-0.6573853492736816,
-0.18661686778068542,
-0.29196926951408386,
-0.4249851405620575,
-0.45493799448013306,
-0.45015883445739746,
0.5840347409248352,
0.4650813937187195,
0.7225550413131714,
0.819209635257721,
0.7221324443817139,
0.2906927764415741,
0.28137579560279846,
-0.05441488325595856,
-0.41632696986198425,
-0.04862567037343979,
-0.2886793315410614,
-0.7872312664985657,
-0.17778490483760834,
-0.07158330082893372,
0.5411875247955322,
1.1267424821853638,
0.22253815829753876,
0.3384917974472046,
0.034296710044145584,
0.7443704605102539,
-0.5419549942016602,
0.6685326099395752,
-0.6811932325363159,
0.08708276599645615,
-0.1817866414785385,
0.020639950409531593,
-0.34294095635414124,
0.09240175783634186,
0.4670107364654541,
-0.7737847566604614,
0.19090723991394043,
0.14417286217212677,
0.7956941723823547,
0.6109176278114319,
-0.2868642210960388,
-0.042423080652952194,
-0.9888011813163757,
1.0258015394210815,
-0.11572525650262833,
0.5804423689842224,
0.45597416162490845,
0.43558433651924133,
-0.08262065052986145,
-0.652067244052887,
-0.6357057094573975,
-0.2571371793746948,
0.00862102210521698,
0.19654838740825653,
-0.11482896655797958,
-0.048050619661808014,
0.30348196625709534,
0.001361468224786222,
-0.3556840419769287,
-0.09527794271707535,
-0.8636452555656433,
-0.18376988172531128,
0.7325354814529419,
0.31516405940055847,
0.6069480776786804,
0.030632946640253067,
-0.21856102347373962,
-0.38206225633621216,
-0.6517658233642578,
0.27583444118499756,
0.007856171578168869,
0.24366147816181183,
0.015303676947951317,
0.8355675339698792,
-0.21171784400939941,
0.9742637872695923,
-0.6577107310295105,
-0.11071779578924179,
0.057251110672950745,
-0.19047851860523224,
-0.2805692255496979,
-0.2409183830022812,
0.19405697286128998,
0.2421417087316513,
0.5104448199272156,
0.003375567961484194,
-0.2675687074661255,
0.40572062134742737,
0.28322792053222656,
-0.460424542427063,
-0.5292757153511047,
-0.3170506954193115,
-0.4367671310901642,
0.08238474279642105,
0.06525014340877533,
-0.6423510313034058,
-0.6283891797065735,
-0.5812384486198425,
0.3114497661590576,
-0.40943974256515503,
-0.2287917286157608,
0.0038305483758449554,
-0.44321373105049133,
0.4091983735561371,
0.618975818157196,
-0.7903090119361877,
0.524025559425354,
0.5834309458732605,
0.30619218945503235,
-0.1597718447446823,
-0.49617093801498413,
-0.32659053802490234,
-0.025947192683815956,
-0.47382500767707825,
0.8506964445114136,
-0.7489997148513794,
-0.07691212743520737,
-0.08357085287570953,
-0.18757390975952148,
-0.008723349310457706,
-0.5286376476287842,
0.1316716969013214,
-0.4872457683086395,
-0.05923396721482277,
-0.48136791586875916,
-0.46088674664497375,
-0.41215500235557556,
-0.048121921718120575,
-0.8004290461540222,
0.5309443473815918,
0.20584438741207123,
-0.4719463586807251,
0.5811815857887268,
-0.6441877484321594,
-0.43167102336883545,
0.5021739602088928,
-0.6191114783287048,
-0.08551108837127686,
0.5520398020744324,
0.05677998811006546,
0.23326541483402252,
-0.19297491014003754,
-0.1786772757768631,
-0.17105191946029663,
-0.15216709673404694,
0.4757477939128876,
-0.3887239694595337,
0.8137158155441284,
0.19847503304481506,
-0.07953213155269623,
-0.11580285429954529,
-0.8124243021011353,
0.03960961475968361,
0.4188748896121979,
-0.43586137890815735,
-0.5437639951705933,
0.507325291633606,
0.09266654402017593,
-0.06490585952997208,
0.3017498254776001,
-0.39173731207847595,
0.011866847053170204,
-0.4071241617202759,
0.31679219007492065,
0.6508306860923767,
-0.305419921875,
0.616727888584137,
-0.226922869682312,
0.3783808946609497,
0.02669183909893036,
0.3528967499732971,
-0.031509604305028915,
-0.6369822025299072,
-1.1695524454116821,
-0.20581719279289246,
0.11551254242658615,
0.6284003853797913,
-1.0225539207458496,
-0.22802548110485077,
-0.1269114911556244,
-0.20949670672416687,
-0.6440993547439575,
0.4369897246360779,
0.11917506903409958,
0.41708770394325256,
0.1901039332151413,
-0.2820337116718292,
-0.624801516532898,
-0.9154766798019409,
-0.04893534630537033,
-0.4140589237213135,
-0.10621200501918793,
0.5597242712974548,
0.572934091091156,
-0.0823744684457779,
0.8824872374534607,
-0.41812312602996826,
-0.14045460522174835,
-0.587394118309021,
-0.40395909547805786,
-0.07102055847644806,
0.2773228585720062,
0.7113990783691406,
-0.9516171813011169,
-0.25581175088882446,
0.13812261819839478,
-1.098095417022705,
0.10980923473834991,
-0.11793608963489532,
-0.14562322199344635,
-0.0692146047949791,
0.4472309947013855,
-0.4680458605289459,
0.7386602759361267,
0.3370838463306427,
-0.40460991859436035,
0.0980052649974823,
-0.31458142399787903,
-0.3496829867362976,
-0.22548829019069672,
-0.05350217968225479,
-0.12177243828773499,
-0.17256146669387817,
-0.8239385485649109,
0.18269288539886475,
-0.09708374738693237,
-0.1767856776714325,
-0.4655696749687195,
0.6834262609481812,
-0.5886517763137817,
-0.351858913898468,
-0.2913833260536194,
0.252562016248703,
-0.0990566834807396,
0.5078225135803223,
0.06937957555055618,
0.31436964869499207,
0.8364969491958618,
-0.6401294469833374,
0.3363277316093445,
0.11321922391653061,
-0.5559087991714478,
0.5013680458068848,
-0.38912108540534973,
-0.10378078371286392,
-0.5444521307945251,
-0.34931647777557373,
-0.7762033939361572,
-0.37394869327545166,
0.21825248003005981,
-0.4837908446788788,
0.15756142139434814,
0.22785651683807373,
-0.08283672481775284,
-0.3285909593105316,
0.1338089108467102,
0.41707828640937805,
0.6633011698722839,
-0.33468058705329895,
0.7239850759506226,
0.7930464148521423,
0.013915271498262882,
-0.28442147374153137,
-0.754755437374115,
-0.004439434967935085,
0.12065815925598145,
-0.28760871291160583,
-0.05225258693099022,
-0.06501661241054535,
-0.775092363357544,
0.2993168830871582,
-0.1136055737733841,
-0.2907545268535614,
0.44795727729797363,
0.43735748529434204,
0.4765140414237976,
-0.2665618062019348,
0.25866392254829407,
-0.5488455295562744,
-0.014133949764072895,
0.02499018795788288,
-0.3911207616329193,
0.3526557981967926,
-0.1912432163953781,
-0.4724162220954895,
-0.16908250749111176,
0.43500617146492004,
0.7231147289276123,
-0.5049490928649902,
0.5967695116996765,
0.14533597230911255,
-0.4352993965148926,
-0.426704078912735,
-0.31439632177352905,
-0.12535303831100464,
-0.3878989815711975,
0.6590932607650757,
-0.20469902455806732,
-0.5413200259208679,
0.24356895685195923,
0.22881990671157837,
-0.0969383493065834,
0.3809385299682617,
0.36722511053085327,
-0.21452558040618896,
0.9762347340583801,
1.2319878339767456,
-0.07417645305395126,
0.8076653480529785,
-0.2787702977657318,
0.2277447134256363,
-0.49224573373794556,
-0.48340317606925964,
-0.2899300754070282,
-0.24544624984264374,
-0.36155951023101807,
-0.4556439220905304,
0.3688541054725647,
-0.03959329426288605,
-0.03577689453959465,
-0.12569352984428406,
-0.3688780963420868,
0.6374921798706055,
1.0229617357254028,
0.18232852220535278,
0.1018446683883667,
0.11462455242872238,
0.08144497126340866,
0.14826159179210663,
-0.8961228132247925,
-0.40310123562812805,
1.0414153337478638,
0.14190243184566498,
0.7001143097877502,
-0.18574796617031097,
0.5325012803077698,
0.10260280966758728,
0.14402304589748383,
-0.8160935044288635,
0.7278409600257874,
-0.06234435364603996,
-0.3788468539714813,
-0.31121987104415894,
-0.22834518551826477,
-1.00702702999115,
0.3029537796974182,
-0.38411200046539307,
-0.6013761162757874,
0.1561424285173416,
0.06657104939222336,
-0.19279395043849945,
0.16284063458442688,
-0.7064662575721741,
0.7413407564163208,
-0.5581867694854736,
-0.16672199964523315,
-0.22953090071678162,
-0.579350471496582,
0.2529323101043701,
0.07485569268465042,
0.3719988763332367,
-0.06262743473052979,
-0.08612729609012604,
0.6935021877288818,
-0.17226991057395935,
0.9112176895141602,
-0.23638728260993958,
0.3486771881580353,
0.3990266025066376,
-0.11579897999763489,
0.08098605275154114,
-0.1634819358587265,
0.28112226724624634,
0.1697106957435608,
-0.12725743651390076,
-0.6235183477401733,
-0.609158992767334,
0.29447290301322937,
-0.7550544142723083,
-0.7285824418067932,
-0.2430417239665985,
-0.7539919018745422,
-0.07266585528850555,
0.32593801617622375,
-0.001885288511402905,
0.2840249240398407,
-0.2009839564561844,
0.33500269055366516,
0.6493141651153564,
-0.2651039958000183,
0.4309063255786896,
0.4253379702568054,
-0.47608307003974915,
0.0291798897087574,
1.0604676008224487,
0.13070568442344666,
0.14375008642673492,
0.37668219208717346,
0.09873901307582855,
0.036936771124601364,
-0.7060660123825073,
-0.2832532525062561,
0.14868566393852234,
-0.9060236215591431,
0.11376772820949554,
-0.4034550189971924,
-0.3496842384338379,
-0.0031932119745761156,
-0.0415072925388813,
-0.06759048253297806,
-0.42953380942344666,
-0.20515216886997223,
-0.14278772473335266,
0.12126687169075012,
1.0347752571105957,
-0.0663624033331871,
0.012883135117590427,
-0.5664657354354858,
0.3104802370071411,
0.6331388354301453,
0.001590827596373856,
-0.021277446299791336,
0.06862137466669083,
-0.4525744915008545,
0.08440378308296204,
0.1248704195022583,
-0.7222603559494019,
0.35464829206466675,
0.43483155965805054,
0.9798761606216431,
0.22705209255218506,
-0.08625105768442154,
0.5643158555030823,
-0.6503754258155823,
0.8439226746559143,
0.003392215818166733,
-0.577303409576416,
0.5581771731376648,
0.10683996230363846,
0.45743486285209656,
0.3266395628452301,
0.06771854311227798,
-0.19520138204097748,
-0.5089797973632812,
-0.42218834161758423,
-0.7408587336540222,
0.5447725653648376,
0.046673133969306946,
0.11949826776981354,
0.09698901325464249,
0.18341615796089172,
-0.0846511721611023,
0.24161191284656525,
-0.7645474076271057,
0.009513640776276588,
-0.21915684640407562,
-0.4008381962776184,
-0.018630346283316612,
-0.02275198884308338,
-0.1764899343252182,
-0.39662161469459534,
0.12276897579431534,
-0.2156280279159546,
0.2043907791376114,
0.19553780555725098,
-0.41439089179039,
-0.03738158941268921,
-0.138749897480011,
0.37747544050216675,
0.7003223896026611,
0.4479677379131317,
0.34458860754966736,
0.04488939791917801,
-0.6194810271263123,
-0.3675183057785034,
-0.22460493445396423,
-0.3859322965145111,
-0.2900240421295166,
0.7258107662200928,
1.0085031986236572,
-0.13299506902694702,
-1.1348353624343872,
0.4197814464569092,
-0.08994157612323761,
-0.018723219633102417,
-0.354153037071228,
0.4381113350391388,
-0.1719304621219635,
0.7240390181541443,
0.5346259474754333,
0.43017497658729553,
-0.03725961595773697,
-0.8035611510276794,
0.20385950803756714,
0.6125642657279968,
-0.3468143343925476,
-0.40376704931259155,
0.5946738123893738,
-0.11276578903198242,
-0.36809104681015015,
0.8045987486839294,
0.2015570104122162,
-0.5908529758453369,
0.7858493328094482,
0.28981921076774597,
0.5227953791618347,
-0.07914219796657562,
0.216794952750206,
-0.05395839363336563,
0.48493385314941406,
0.09677991271018982,
0.482522189617157,
-0.2800968289375305,
-0.964577317237854,
-0.14250536262989044,
-0.7430011034011841,
-0.20291553437709808,
-0.07482517510652542,
-0.5359845757484436,
-0.19496697187423706,
-0.6435191631317139,
0.16412360966205597,
0.08100811392068863,
-0.22038523852825165,
-1.205505132675171,
0.3648136556148529,
0.5119003653526306,
0.7470331788063049,
-0.8975414037704468,
0.9333555102348328,
0.6484230160713196,
-0.5122857689857483,
-0.6813211441040039,
-0.2355339378118515,
-0.2171143740415573,
-1.073089599609375,
1.0726656913757324,
0.011241782456636429,
-0.15573765337467194,
-0.13211561739444733,
-0.7892730832099915,
-0.8640934824943542,
0.7890753746032715,
0.46730154752731323,
-0.3272418975830078,
0.03357847407460213,
0.19880525767803192,
0.7089899182319641,
-0.44405505061149597,
-0.17873144149780273,
0.3771497905254364,
0.43596041202545166,
-0.08444434404373169,
-0.5798764824867249,
-0.2302078753709793,
-0.339582234621048,
-0.0781354010105133,
0.11981000006198883,
-0.36905670166015625,
1.0130139589309692,
-0.429317444562912,
-0.4137227237224579,
-0.09325192868709564,
0.6392587423324585,
-0.21046917140483856,
0.3410884141921997,
0.44689396023750305,
0.2686007022857666,
0.8406945466995239,
-0.05252653360366821,
1.1144511699676514,
-0.009342658333480358,
0.06971484422683716,
0.8605133891105652,
-0.23438914120197296,
1.0426326990127563,
0.609285295009613,
-0.0888773575425148,
0.3412165641784668,
0.27676770091056824,
-0.07081609964370728,
0.7708085179328918,
0.06050533801317215,
-0.14551910758018494,
-0.4877454936504364,
-0.2556288242340088,
0.042227860540151596,
0.7488335371017456,
0.5545905232429504,
-0.2587130665779114,
-0.07843570411205292,
0.3686884045600891,
-0.5282717347145081,
0.06841521710157394,
-0.5001554489135742,
0.8158239722251892,
0.08541805297136307,
-0.6357970833778381,
0.26244932413101196,
-0.6035925149917603,
0.11449633538722992,
-0.4338291883468628,
-0.3145155608654022,
-0.150377556681633,
0.27703866362571716,
-0.03235896676778793,
-0.6441978216171265,
0.36058419942855835,
-0.14454129338264465,
-0.19008609652519226,
-0.08961541950702667,
0.7829428315162659,
-0.3573189079761505,
-0.7458334565162659,
0.3747745454311371,
0.8107552528381348,
0.20422063767910004,
0.2517683207988739,
-0.5326974391937256,
0.1398017257452011,
0.09137830138206482,
-0.09372548013925552,
0.35066840052604675,
0.4003823697566986,
-0.1515703797340393,
0.8654013276100159,
0.49053865671157837,
0.3389561176300049,
0.3047752380371094,
-0.14804783463478088,
0.7475260496139526,
-0.7723516225814819,
-0.17722344398498535,
-0.8508975505828857,
0.4163382947444916,
-0.1120992973446846,
0.01204020157456398,
0.6448759436607361,
0.3697679936885834,
1.155585765838623,
-0.2523745000362396,
0.9961660504341125,
-0.10328308492898941,
0.1906852275133133,
-0.5993064641952515,
0.6391690373420715,
-0.9177900552749634,
0.09706529974937439,
-0.001861024065874517,
-0.6734281182289124,
-0.5636038184165955,
0.8234828114509583,
-0.2323000282049179,
-0.4143427014350891,
0.6595177054405212,
0.554502546787262,
0.15910279750823975,
-0.15401528775691986,
0.7386837601661682,
0.2861287593841553,
0.12095282971858978,
0.7850245237350464,
1.0271116495132446,
-0.042298734188079834,
0.6206246614456177,
-0.10500187426805496,
-0.22708460688591003,
-0.09328579157590866,
-0.35852038860321045,
-0.9009959101676941,
-0.7494513988494873,
-0.0592602901160717,
0.22290149331092834,
-0.11654546111822128,
0.5608213543891907,
0.6117103099822998,
-0.5304750800132751,
-0.29674890637397766,
-0.1879434883594513,
0.23682574927806854,
-0.2764632999897003,
-0.1653047800064087,
0.07089763879776001,
-0.3151058256626129,
-0.7034214735031128,
0.5470793843269348,
0.572685956954956,
0.21534663438796997,
-0.3785533905029297,
-0.011733154766261578,
0.22767290472984314,
0.21657663583755493,
0.6658400297164917,
0.46764084696769714,
-0.8285662531852722,
-0.47861185669898987,
0.13939151167869568,
0.01939764805138111,
0.10477588325738907,
0.7688541412353516,
-0.9868418574333191,
0.5106574296951294,
0.6452498435974121,
0.7937784194946289,
0.32398897409439087,
-0.45247918367385864,
0.546665608882904,
-0.32917991280555725,
0.38357043266296387,
0.269563764333725,
0.618698000907898,
0.3761887848377228,
-0.24293144047260284,
0.35935452580451965,
0.29692333936691284,
-0.3671362102031708,
-0.708113968372345,
0.5603874921798706,
-0.8651751279830933,
-0.5266237258911133,
0.7284043431282043,
-0.032790761440992355,
-0.8147229552268982,
-0.25063401460647583,
-0.35691460967063904,
0.032094236463308334,
0.039557356387376785,
0.6716189980506897,
0.5801461935043335,
-0.3520453870296478,
-0.4719283878803253,
-0.9103897213935852,
0.4897175431251526,
0.302731454372406,
-0.8083266019821167,
-0.1179693192243576,
0.7362186908721924,
0.060376089066267014,
0.27141448855400085,
0.5179445147514343,
0.19669678807258606,
0.2513514459133148,
0.28301215171813965,
-0.3516664206981659,
0.10340375453233719,
-0.8438349962234497,
-0.20896293222904205,
0.27265727519989014,
0.2986293435096741,
-0.3384303152561188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10342v1 | Exploration-Driven Policy Optimization in RLHF: Theoretical Insights on Efficient Data Utilization | 2024-02-15T22:11:18 | 2024-02-15T22:11:18 | Yihan Du, Anna Winnicki, Gal Dalal, Shie Mannor, R. Srikant | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has achieved impressive
empirical successes while relying on a small amount of human feedback. However,
there is limited theoretical justification for this phenomenon. Additionally,
most recent studies focus on value-based algorithms despite the recent
empirical successes of policy-based algorithms. In this work, we consider an
RLHF algorithm based on policy optimization (PO-RLHF). The algorithm is based
on the popular Policy Cover-Policy Gradient (PC-PG) algorithm, which assumes
knowledge of the reward function. In PO-RLHF, knowledge of the reward function
is not assumed and the algorithm relies on trajectory-based comparison feedback
to infer the reward function. We provide performance bounds for PO-RLHF with
low query complexity, which provides insight into why a small amount of human
feedback may be sufficient to get good performance with RLHF. A key novelty is
our trajectory-level elliptical potential analysis technique used to infer
reward function parameters when comparison queries rather than reward
observations are used. We provide and analyze algorithms in two settings:
linear and neural function approximation, PG-RLHF and NN-PG-RLHF, respectively. | [
-0.3792526125907898,
-0.6596643328666687,
0.6714937686920166,
0.23042821884155273,
0.08418750017881393,
0.05071045830845833,
-0.22949837148189545,
-0.36894261837005615,
0.3362064063549042,
0.5584933757781982,
-1.0923473834991455,
-0.31204450130462646,
-0.12564779818058014,
-0.3281523287296295,
0.21561037003993988,
0.7572043538093567,
-0.046962589025497437,
-0.247493177652359,
-0.2532859444618225,
-0.06745301187038422,
-0.31867992877960205,
-0.3995169401168823,
-0.5991694331169128,
-0.5461146831512451,
0.7377591133117676,
0.44105568528175354,
0.4426056146621704,
0.6669458150863647,
0.40165677666664124,
0.05926463007926941,
-0.14438028633594513,
0.46852654218673706,
-0.8330715894699097,
-0.08023757487535477,
0.0036888059694319963,
-0.34015461802482605,
-0.012082916684448719,
-0.15789692103862762,
0.7179401516914368,
0.5520264506340027,
-0.589651346206665,
-0.3680688142776489,
-0.09357540309429169,
0.9046468734741211,
-0.9755107760429382,
0.24957770109176636,
-0.19341552257537842,
0.48450708389282227,
0.07659157365560532,
-0.5288069248199463,
-0.2631603181362152,
-0.5372333526611328,
0.42877423763275146,
-1.0938186645507812,
-0.11605226993560791,
0.16812849044799805,
0.8190737962722778,
0.18171288073062897,
-0.24157589673995972,
-0.18473875522613525,
-0.8429834842681885,
0.9756205677986145,
-0.34222084283828735,
0.13220252096652985,
0.4398753046989441,
0.44221925735473633,
-0.36703020334243774,
-0.28184956312179565,
-0.31705430150032043,
-0.563143789768219,
-0.059679608792066574,
0.1254229098558426,
0.09142462909221649,
0.5086149573326111,
0.17800858616828918,
0.3329765200614929,
-0.3584410548210144,
0.31844562292099,
-0.12273671478033066,
-0.313696950674057,
0.8264255523681641,
0.2924422025680542,
-0.2840934991836548,
-0.09533899277448654,
-0.5271353125572205,
-0.6956911683082581,
-0.9102246761322021,
0.8400248885154724,
0.6227555871009827,
0.23538486659526825,
0.02105795592069626,
0.35139894485473633,
-0.39490124583244324,
0.6047133803367615,
-0.16174077987670898,
0.03153134882450104,
0.17580553889274597,
-0.15992507338523865,
0.051854219287633896,
-0.2631283104419708,
0.5620284080505371,
0.3888140022754669,
0.17188145220279694,
-0.1963401436805725,
-0.4798907935619354,
-0.3073250353336334,
0.3878561556339264,
-0.6892008185386658,
0.0795687809586525,
0.040125876665115356,
-0.4523617625236511,
-0.4036465883255005,
0.34737884998321533,
-1.0369956493377686,
-0.47415873408317566,
0.006737140007317066,
0.37769314646720886,
0.04038481414318085,
-0.24164339900016785,
0.06334191560745239,
-0.12533555924892426,
0.3337404131889343,
0.27965158224105835,
-0.8013206720352173,
0.4155288636684418,
0.6935322284698486,
0.6225175261497498,
-0.5876358151435852,
-0.44225460290908813,
-0.832694947719574,
-0.30551677942276,
-0.3068521022796631,
0.5481663942337036,
-0.32668986916542053,
-0.7735697031021118,
0.4160982370376587,
-0.12558861076831818,
-0.08797988295555115,
-0.6809205412864685,
0.685515820980072,
-0.7430557608604431,
0.01654898002743721,
-0.5116924047470093,
-0.38848745822906494,
-0.38337281346321106,
0.2923048436641693,
-0.6868518590927124,
1.1331276893615723,
0.261801540851593,
-0.45060107111930847,
0.619695782661438,
-1.1670690774917603,
-0.3451506197452545,
-0.20544393360614777,
-0.14591072499752045,
-0.6180038452148438,
-0.0445481538772583,
0.11567050963640213,
-0.012855499051511288,
-0.18461431562900543,
0.17900535464286804,
-0.27702686190605164,
-0.5208141803741455,
0.11543489247560501,
-0.4149599075317383,
0.42051437497138977,
0.160067617893219,
-0.33904629945755005,
0.48987236618995667,
-0.48065605759620667,
0.1656690388917923,
0.1150633916258812,
-0.4521166682243347,
-0.06342446804046631,
0.40132656693458557,
0.0770658329129219,
-0.12182807922363281,
0.0823327824473381,
-0.3992392420768738,
0.3432140648365021,
-0.24671053886413574,
0.32383373379707336,
0.7096907496452332,
0.4069255292415619,
0.5191447138786316,
-0.36414819955825806,
1.0233168601989746,
-0.5097426772117615,
0.3113095164299011,
-0.04083440452814102,
-0.15508891642093658,
-0.09071114659309387,
-0.080651193857193,
0.421414852142334,
0.49854689836502075,
-0.3955000340938568,
0.2920495271682739,
0.11966311186552048,
-0.16834953427314758,
-0.2860577404499054,
-0.27168717980384827,
0.38535746932029724,
0.6152459979057312,
0.3593984842300415,
-0.19975975155830383,
-0.18304280936717987,
-0.9106338024139404,
-0.30229687690734863,
-0.2138323038816452,
0.24556845426559448,
1.0255804061889648,
0.1625998616218567,
-0.1425933688879013,
0.8824892044067383,
-0.6445228457450867,
-0.16773763298988342,
-0.20384618639945984,
0.08135359734296799,
0.35710790753364563,
0.35339829325675964,
0.4244321584701538,
-0.5735737681388855,
-0.34477561712265015,
0.011598440818488598,
-0.4753699004650116,
0.01389346458017826,
-0.27930036187171936,
-0.17229795455932617,
-0.007804164197295904,
0.23668326437473297,
-0.5205241441726685,
0.6005897521972656,
0.1994851529598236,
-0.2935996353626251,
0.442391037940979,
-0.5843836665153503,
0.09374451637268066,
0.29232755303382874,
0.12986692786216736,
-0.06609147042036057,
-0.35436153411865234,
-0.28202715516090393,
0.1371135115623474,
-0.10331818461418152,
-0.057328756898641586,
-0.3542442321777344,
0.4703565835952759,
-0.09077229350805283,
-0.32659319043159485,
-0.39082229137420654,
0.04548799619078636,
-0.2811242341995239,
0.9892362952232361,
0.24122194945812225,
0.771023690700531,
0.46635565161705017,
-0.8651366233825684,
0.053770679980516434,
-0.2428971827030182,
-0.014497468248009682,
0.20242102444171906,
-0.5551069378852844,
0.04031038656830788,
-0.15711380541324615,
0.2255387008190155,
-0.6004834175109863,
-0.032971806824207306,
0.4406062662601471,
-0.09764352440834045,
0.20475561916828156,
-0.09676138311624527,
-0.021182404831051826,
-0.1863408237695694,
-0.6348296403884888,
0.5142943263053894,
0.38895100355148315,
-0.6276288628578186,
0.43451765179634094,
0.6061822772026062,
0.23605501651763916,
-0.8131007552146912,
-0.13685260713100433,
-0.49962684512138367,
-0.4427776038646698,
-0.32823875546455383,
0.6239176988601685,
0.29002654552459717,
0.04247720539569855,
0.017170732840895653,
-0.21042431890964508,
0.1508977711200714,
0.11736172437667847,
0.13918116688728333,
0.23254366219043732,
0.20508751273155212,
-0.03108380362391472,
0.1133001521229744,
-0.13617825508117676,
0.33831560611724854,
-0.346551775932312,
0.5390704274177551,
-0.1945505291223526,
-0.39640551805496216,
-0.28906387090682983,
0.09987080842256546,
0.2226743847131729,
-0.05077532306313515,
0.25401315093040466,
0.39822977781295776,
-0.07606831938028336,
-0.3415060043334961,
-0.042330287396907806,
-0.5909525156021118,
-0.37076908349990845,
0.5717552304267883,
-0.11874715983867645,
-0.6506808400154114,
0.3602388799190521,
-0.05074387788772583,
0.2647866904735565,
0.4685468375682831,
0.1445530652999878,
-0.08611761778593063,
0.6990364789962769,
0.5109679102897644,
-0.023349478840827942,
0.6871805191040039,
-0.5247555375099182,
-0.19197484850883484,
-0.5005181431770325,
-0.3731311857700348,
-0.18913553655147552,
-0.5257176756858826,
-1.0291814804077148,
-0.2562711834907532,
0.5386135578155518,
0.010906020179390907,
-0.23752298951148987,
0.06170166656374931,
-0.4276357591152191,
0.3802119791507721,
0.6980978846549988,
0.23476819694042206,
0.09225884824991226,
0.13058559596538544,
0.05036954954266548,
-0.0914463996887207,
-1.0665397644042969,
0.1395515352487564,
1.26544988155365,
0.5459336638450623,
0.7891018986701965,
-0.31792354583740234,
0.8056171536445618,
0.614398181438446,
0.05866072699427605,
-0.8290570378303528,
0.2534046173095703,
0.25214454531669617,
-0.10749122500419617,
-0.7341068983078003,
-0.6511709690093994,
-1.1991848945617676,
0.4409767687320709,
-0.27780547738075256,
-0.5836620330810547,
0.3491077423095703,
0.5632138252258301,
-0.6504250168800354,
0.026287296786904335,
-0.3554733097553253,
0.6999539732933044,
-0.5428732633590698,
-0.5861374139785767,
-0.5737162828445435,
-0.5887629985809326,
0.17625461518764496,
0.5091034770011902,
-0.02607620507478714,
0.16420941054821014,
0.08849199116230011,
0.8656529188156128,
-0.38232389092445374,
0.31380870938301086,
-0.976357638835907,
0.07019742578268051,
0.41483721137046814,
-0.0710076093673706,
0.7888362407684326,
0.27667614817619324,
0.2568507790565491,
-0.07730673253536224,
0.002334523480385542,
-0.33276522159576416,
-0.6315999627113342,
0.4929158091545105,
-0.8621783256530762,
-0.3244810998439789,
-0.5925349593162537,
-0.3767719864845276,
-0.3875420093536377,
0.142767995595932,
0.14075858891010284,
0.009605752304196358,
-0.16503286361694336,
0.1571628898382187,
0.8423538208007812,
-0.30869385600090027,
0.4197789430618286,
0.08967450261116028,
-0.6975225210189819,
-0.29026344418525696,
0.9179960489273071,
-0.19649676978588104,
0.08503008633852005,
0.594379186630249,
0.47412019968032837,
-0.7100549936294556,
-0.2588517367839813,
-0.42544105648994446,
0.2491256594657898,
-0.23858322203159332,
0.09036506712436676,
-0.1319388598203659,
0.009712222963571548,
0.2706916332244873,
0.17323528230190277,
-0.4929153025150299,
-0.29308512806892395,
-0.07135295122861862,
0.04800466075539589,
0.1802026331424713,
0.635209321975708,
-0.3118687868118286,
0.312203586101532,
-0.17532415688037872,
0.14603592455387115,
0.34413254261016846,
0.2776922583580017,
0.06522953510284424,
-0.15663188695907593,
-0.2813796103000641,
0.13919083774089813,
-0.4495132267475128,
-0.7577418684959412,
0.2851569652557373,
0.003199747297912836,
0.7612438201904297,
0.47901859879493713,
0.08539693057537079,
0.35833701491355896,
0.017124895006418228,
0.38247251510620117,
-0.053752601146698,
-0.3162652552127838,
0.27236711978912354,
-0.23246914148330688,
-0.1597454994916916,
0.5978958010673523,
0.14173753559589386,
-0.4433903396129608,
0.4678177833557129,
-0.6634076833724976,
-0.8046224117279053,
0.902360737323761,
0.06889685243368149,
-0.27337735891342163,
0.6637636423110962,
0.5754323601722717,
-0.09475145488977432,
0.42032018303871155,
-0.6283044219017029,
-0.2666221857070923,
-0.07138477265834808,
0.41990867257118225,
0.05914362519979477,
0.11764232814311981,
-0.2706717848777771,
0.0553007498383522,
0.5707472562789917,
-0.25578737258911133,
0.5268111824989319,
0.265461266040802,
0.1546594351530075,
-0.20457233488559723,
0.022377587854862213,
0.7847414016723633,
0.5701570510864258,
-0.4408877491950989,
-0.27325060963630676,
-0.07934453338384628,
-0.31510305404663086,
0.08225040882825851,
0.09177695959806442,
-0.4069128632545471,
-0.344667911529541,
-0.037906210869550705,
1.0373344421386719,
0.054870061576366425,
-1.0340168476104736,
0.48653697967529297,
-0.00009606444655219093,
-0.3364458680152893,
-0.4228924810886383,
0.39236798882484436,
-0.4213677644729614,
0.2333257645368576,
0.35896313190460205,
-0.011503541842103004,
0.07769230008125305,
-0.2894279360771179,
0.14351454377174377,
0.6665908694267273,
-0.5446605682373047,
0.04074689745903015,
0.2589763104915619,
0.041948359459638596,
-0.5363858342170715,
0.6618689298629761,
-0.32534176111221313,
-0.5071595311164856,
0.8204289078712463,
0.10271406173706055,
0.7313507199287415,
0.25204896926879883,
0.39537882804870605,
0.3357307016849518,
0.12824365496635437,
-0.10904511064291,
0.40981918573379517,
-0.5311103463172913,
-0.6817988157272339,
-0.5513268113136292,
-0.22596707940101624,
-0.6467427015304565,
0.20734211802482605,
-0.9245513081550598,
-0.05126066878437996,
-0.61772221326828,
-0.04747023805975914,
-0.6022917628288269,
0.2691246569156647,
-0.586397111415863,
-0.1413862705230713,
-0.37438246607780457,
0.6715102791786194,
-0.48141127824783325,
0.4571032226085663,
0.3747027516365051,
-0.03042742796242237,
-0.660206139087677,
0.11803421378135681,
-0.22148992121219635,
-0.9408824443817139,
0.42963534593582153,
-0.01238436158746481,
-0.1843189001083374,
-0.22068877518177032,
-0.23435726761817932,
-0.6805303692817688,
1.197420358657837,
0.09675650298595428,
-0.5931419134140015,
-0.10730067640542984,
-0.1442866325378418,
0.3514326214790344,
-0.3895815312862396,
0.1943616271018982,
0.7508814930915833,
0.7497401833534241,
-0.015745585784316063,
-0.5564786791801453,
-0.3215574622154236,
0.1400476098060608,
0.121843621134758,
0.3550119400024414,
-0.46596112847328186,
0.5543032288551331,
-0.35771337151527405,
0.057844121009111404,
-0.22963665425777435,
0.6613560914993286,
0.8322680592536926,
0.47736892104148865,
0.8335415720939636,
0.4763500392436981,
0.7183526754379272,
0.11258505284786224,
1.3036264181137085,
-0.17778868973255157,
0.7926260828971863,
0.6571635007858276,
-0.1513967663049698,
0.6511046290397644,
0.6498280167579651,
-0.6807811260223389,
0.3565504848957062,
0.9864440560340881,
0.06885775923728943,
1.0880632400512695,
0.6523493528366089,
-0.15251366794109344,
0.0012585049262270331,
-0.03355062007904053,
-0.2090252786874771,
0.09560511261224747,
0.06443848460912704,
-0.05441133677959442,
-0.3275519013404846,
-0.13687939941883087,
-0.23730558156967163,
0.0018172664567828178,
-0.5201889276504517,
0.6860605478286743,
-0.3370910584926605,
-1.1491326093673706,
0.43362075090408325,
0.266944944858551,
0.5219528675079346,
-0.5732044577598572,
-0.35812392830848694,
-0.11488780379295349,
0.03136767819523811,
-0.10254281759262085,
-0.6561492681503296,
0.038657642900943756,
-0.49227267503738403,
-0.026476280763745308,
-0.28736594319343567,
0.5773809552192688,
-0.2975709140300751,
0.14859279990196228,
0.36187803745269775,
0.397904634475708,
-0.1609441488981247,
-0.07159435749053955,
-0.4636540412902832,
-0.21903550624847412,
0.21237137913703918,
-0.38401854038238525,
0.4244641363620758,
0.029565632343292236,
0.014156943187117577,
0.6551803946495056,
0.664408266544342,
0.43624064326286316,
0.04932436719536781,
-0.2681238055229187,
0.5416103005409241,
-0.5955350399017334,
-1.1172646284103394,
-0.5643353462219238,
0.16900058090686798,
0.020396843552589417,
-0.47962087392807007,
0.0366312637925148,
0.3393123745918274,
0.7789389491081238,
0.0042045386508107185,
0.7142692804336548,
-0.025339806452393532,
0.45686548948287964,
-0.7815127372741699,
0.3785768151283264,
-0.5729771852493286,
0.39337894320487976,
0.024038704112172127,
-0.8317320346832275,
-0.032184842973947525,
0.9126637578010559,
-0.41231971979141235,
0.191331684589386,
0.41025274991989136,
0.9908329844474792,
0.029108550399541855,
0.04148668795824051,
0.1668918877840042,
-0.3781355619430542,
0.39078977704048157,
0.6668582558631897,
0.8038558959960938,
-0.04195753112435341,
0.3215537965297699,
-0.42892658710479736,
-0.47090423107147217,
-0.4989399015903473,
-0.982609748840332,
-0.44956061244010925,
-0.19935059547424316,
0.06821806728839874,
-0.4052210748195648,
0.09128297120332718,
0.9972823262214661,
0.9025633335113525,
-0.6015053987503052,
-0.5214845538139343,
-0.7173050045967102,
0.49745291471481323,
-0.6971777677536011,
-0.3265683948993683,
0.6462320685386658,
-0.1819259226322174,
-0.43975746631622314,
0.6366583704948425,
0.2305440455675125,
-0.3332693874835968,
-0.6649594902992249,
-0.8081461787223816,
-0.057124074548482895,
-0.18162120878696442,
0.22828303277492523,
0.9396849870681763,
-0.37831607460975647,
0.015595471486449242,
0.13127119839191437,
0.30746951699256897,
0.12347295135259628,
1.3362047672271729,
-0.9498801231384277,
0.31167635321617126,
0.346525102853775,
1.2259458303451538,
0.9905231595039368,
0.1902664601802826,
0.36104267835617065,
-0.456149160861969,
0.04729020595550537,
0.4508291184902191,
0.13651041686534882,
-0.11556705087423325,
-0.5656601786613464,
0.4098568856716156,
0.39679625630378723,
-0.7477648854255676,
-0.8628268837928772,
0.3742663562297821,
-0.8278133869171143,
0.02356378547847271,
0.9792475700378418,
-0.2165384292602539,
-0.13479523360729218,
0.3141174018383026,
-0.17607851326465607,
-0.3670702576637268,
-0.8784251809120178,
0.9172308444976807,
0.4062657654285431,
-0.7971585988998413,
-0.3664557635784149,
-0.3457249104976654,
0.7858850359916687,
0.5918941497802734,
-0.8451476693153381,
-0.06368587166070938,
0.2459375411272049,
-0.13483278453350067,
-0.09416168928146362,
0.6503874659538269,
0.0479336641728878,
0.5758810043334961,
-0.34203997254371643,
-0.3380368649959564,
-0.2679642140865326,
-0.5482521057128906,
-0.4309033751487732,
0.37038204073905945,
0.18382064998149872,
-0.4613325297832489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10979v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10979v2 | SportsMetrics: Blending Text and Numerical Data to Understand Information Fusion in LLMs | 2024-02-15T20:26:07 | 2024-06-16T06:43:50 | Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models hold significant potential for integrating various data
types, such as text documents and database records, for advanced analytics.
However, blending text and numerical data presents substantial challenges. LLMs
need to process and cross-reference entities and numbers, handle data
inconsistencies and redundancies, and develop planning capabilities such as
building a working memory for managing complex data queries. In this paper, we
introduce four novel tasks centered around sports data analytics to evaluate
the numerical reasoning and information fusion capabilities of LLMs. These
tasks involve providing LLMs with detailed, play-by-play sports game
descriptions, then challenging them with adversarial scenarios such as new game
rules, longer durations, scrambled narratives, and analyzing key statistics in
game summaries. We conduct extensive experiments on NBA and NFL games to assess
the performance of LLMs on these tasks. Our benchmark, SportsMetrics,
introduces a new mechanism for assessing LLMs' numerical reasoning and fusion
skills. | [
-0.3292474150657654,
-0.6868796348571777,
0.4479019045829773,
0.36564603447914124,
-0.06403710693120956,
0.6559900045394897,
-0.05905719846487045,
-0.5410729646682739,
0.19329404830932617,
0.40200334787368774,
-0.8382426500320435,
-0.5637332201004028,
-0.45699343085289,
0.17980508506298065,
-0.3332318961620331,
0.993036150932312,
-0.4345129430294037,
0.3665948510169983,
-0.6997602581977844,
-0.20054738223552704,
-0.5803590416908264,
-0.7019242644309998,
-0.6090793609619141,
-0.6170358061790466,
-0.04955706000328064,
0.21817950904369354,
0.6817763447761536,
0.5858010649681091,
0.9768743515014648,
0.35161274671554565,
0.16672126948833466,
0.5136639475822449,
-0.8480493426322937,
0.6301848888397217,
-0.22932058572769165,
-0.43694981932640076,
-0.42687249183654785,
-0.051163431257009506,
0.5620018243789673,
0.7605185508728027,
0.13459694385528564,
0.24894869327545166,
0.017316406592726707,
0.6511031985282898,
-0.5500401258468628,
0.35036325454711914,
-0.33352530002593994,
0.2814129590988159,
-0.26173871755599976,
-0.45037841796875,
0.06274530291557312,
-0.3562192916870117,
-0.05917276069521904,
-0.6080232858657837,
0.10521000623703003,
0.02858942560851574,
0.5538591742515564,
0.40851935744285583,
-0.2827652394771576,
-0.09659772366285324,
-1.0978690385818481,
0.6826245188713074,
-0.5084187984466553,
0.4795987010002136,
0.3211173117160797,
0.42252224683761597,
-0.24406352639198303,
-0.13207536935806274,
-0.44802266359329224,
0.01072901114821434,
0.057842597365379333,
0.40860071778297424,
-0.1306324005126953,
-0.0687127411365509,
0.2517896592617035,
0.10560304671525955,
-0.5870548486709595,
0.08192164450883865,
-0.22415083646774292,
0.2006741166114807,
1.2289245128631592,
0.7374483346939087,
0.12406937032938004,
0.27441146969795227,
-0.3552802503108978,
-0.12065912038087845,
-0.48799964785575867,
0.07159925997257233,
0.28468143939971924,
0.18825778365135193,
-0.09320879727602005,
0.8171374201774597,
-0.48228228092193604,
0.5475873351097107,
-0.21345098316669464,
-0.3125480115413666,
0.09137547761201859,
-0.5547746419906616,
-0.2850205600261688,
0.10675998032093048,
0.7417746186256409,
0.4582476019859314,
0.04952657222747803,
-0.6312351822853088,
-0.1385050117969513,
-0.08988292515277863,
-0.06828569620847702,
-0.41269364953041077,
-0.04928160458803177,
0.4836254417896271,
-0.4650263488292694,
-0.3103131055831909,
-0.005693539977073669,
-0.8018766641616821,
-0.841511070728302,
-0.45761439204216003,
0.3015443980693817,
-0.5239065289497375,
-0.06326874345541,
0.1788584291934967,
-0.4443674385547638,
0.3587843179702759,
0.18936625123023987,
-0.7820855975151062,
0.4113924503326416,
0.9870249629020691,
0.556582510471344,
-0.5030206441879272,
-0.30482393503189087,
-0.40491852164268494,
0.35144513845443726,
-0.18303152918815613,
1.0370073318481445,
-0.589693009853363,
-0.36282917857170105,
0.23493418097496033,
-0.5760399103164673,
0.0743221566081047,
-0.6623620390892029,
0.30542999505996704,
-0.3606398105621338,
-0.23637773096561432,
-0.18016138672828674,
-0.8314231038093567,
-0.09544059634208679,
0.4799851179122925,
-0.609454870223999,
1.262467384338379,
-0.014762027189135551,
-0.5796436667442322,
0.4381701350212097,
-0.6249200701713562,
-0.6758348345756531,
0.15225569903850555,
-0.32790815830230713,
-0.2964969575405121,
0.17257961630821228,
0.03116920031607151,
0.3976036310195923,
-0.612342894077301,
0.18743185698986053,
-0.6052695512771606,
-0.3023584485054016,
0.49761635065078735,
-0.20710739493370056,
0.35564231872558594,
-0.0364677757024765,
-0.06604713946580887,
-0.14279289543628693,
-0.6190046668052673,
-0.03605358302593231,
0.053774457424879074,
-0.24167940020561218,
-0.25498732924461365,
0.4772454500198364,
-0.27099546790122986,
-0.01837083511054516,
0.12371627241373062,
-0.18463461101055145,
0.2752056419849396,
-0.27256399393081665,
-0.0835583284497261,
0.30214691162109375,
-0.07273121923208237,
0.47531941533088684,
-0.4149571657180786,
0.6014356017112732,
-0.0179121233522892,
0.1566760092973709,
0.03336813300848007,
-0.5090214014053345,
-0.22876028716564178,
0.015163537114858627,
0.2193690836429596,
0.953883707523346,
-1.1706949472427368,
0.2579801082611084,
-0.5227423310279846,
-0.8048736453056335,
-0.25571128726005554,
0.29860666394233704,
0.03718924894928932,
0.32747936248779297,
0.1489729881286621,
0.014818227849900723,
-0.5631027817726135,
-0.6284930109977722,
-0.5169914960861206,
-0.0392831414937973,
0.0891331136226654,
0.31436583399772644,
0.44211211800575256,
0.12107346206903458,
0.7676680684089661,
-0.7075169682502747,
-0.26067042350769043,
-0.2336667776107788,
0.2777727544307709,
0.23339930176734924,
0.27193206548690796,
0.4198203980922699,
-0.8712171912193298,
-0.40971970558166504,
-0.13699880242347717,
-1.1887305974960327,
-0.1752670258283615,
-0.12246151268482208,
0.073816679418087,
-0.3092437982559204,
0.39851436018943787,
-0.6452446579933167,
0.5678051114082336,
0.5325121283531189,
-0.5189787745475769,
0.4344620704650879,
-0.05380386486649513,
0.5702658295631409,
-0.5201407670974731,
0.02699114754796028,
0.2993527352809906,
-0.04140579700469971,
-0.9167942404747009,
0.022232023999094963,
-0.4862889349460602,
0.02324334904551506,
-0.3148471713066101,
0.506671130657196,
-0.5442833304405212,
-0.41693413257598877,
-0.3567171096801758,
0.0671735480427742,
-0.16390684247016907,
0.04130828380584717,
0.16929912567138672,
0.6060740351676941,
0.5056309700012207,
-0.7001146674156189,
0.963148832321167,
0.2359483689069748,
-0.5506978631019592,
0.5221195816993713,
-0.2540115416049957,
-0.25089335441589355,
-0.37987643480300903,
0.22978919744491577,
-1.1646262407302856,
-0.18054935336112976,
0.13137519359588623,
-0.345774382352829,
0.04167897254228592,
0.19666680693626404,
-0.6800994873046875,
-0.39923784136772156,
-0.4127238690853119,
0.6836287975311279,
0.2685653567314148,
-0.07642246782779694,
0.9808449745178223,
0.7577279210090637,
-0.28754767775535583,
-0.4079126715660095,
-0.5140787959098816,
0.12331288307905197,
-0.3930720090866089,
-0.5574126243591309,
0.5376736521720886,
-0.14870373904705048,
-0.5382146835327148,
0.19198721647262573,
-0.056360840797424316,
-0.5295165777206421,
0.14679110050201416,
-0.010861193761229515,
0.5318699479103088,
-0.31202200055122375,
-0.09745275229215622,
-0.06633003056049347,
0.007194308564066887,
0.08690961450338364,
0.19155341386795044,
0.38698846101760864,
0.3580703139305115,
-0.19099223613739014,
-0.25190645456314087,
0.5052286982536316,
0.2811359763145447,
0.08807853609323502,
0.6446488499641418,
0.36330822110176086,
-0.3605199456214905,
0.06344049423933029,
-0.6168377995491028,
-0.07529264688491821,
-0.403068482875824,
0.3557818830013275,
-0.3686113655567169,
-0.6953367590904236,
0.7579239010810852,
-0.1650526225566864,
0.3403274118900299,
0.42110127210617065,
0.508137047290802,
-0.42941921949386597,
1.409796953201294,
0.12272675335407257,
-0.13373076915740967,
0.08913837373256683,
-0.09867965430021286,
-0.10989604890346527,
-0.4079466760158539,
-0.5445948839187622,
-0.4791414439678192,
-0.6575521230697632,
-0.19298817217350006,
-0.517663836479187,
0.3089662194252014,
-0.12707501649856567,
-0.18325656652450562,
0.11061400175094604,
-0.2506338059902191,
1.114863634109497,
0.25771966576576233,
0.0812826007604599,
0.23222514986991882,
-0.13266167044639587,
0.32959604263305664,
-0.3261997401714325,
-0.5913832783699036,
0.0003534699499141425,
0.7870064377784729,
0.38720056414604187,
0.9216628074645996,
0.41463226079940796,
0.7094947099685669,
0.4033574163913727,
0.2619292736053467,
-0.8733673691749573,
0.5211072564125061,
-0.5167832374572754,
-0.6291411519050598,
-0.22635342180728912,
-0.5830795168876648,
-0.5138916969299316,
0.13670313358306885,
-0.8214696049690247,
-0.5384389758110046,
-0.12673993408679962,
0.0028013240080326796,
-0.4834199547767639,
0.3386989235877991,
-0.30176112055778503,
0.24727916717529297,
-0.5441828370094299,
-0.43639224767684937,
0.143124058842659,
-0.09412796795368195,
0.7199009656906128,
-0.22356189787387848,
0.489865779876709,
-0.22243575751781464,
-0.3391956090927124,
0.7911539673805237,
-0.12184662371873856,
0.7558920979499817,
0.09851586073637009,
-0.004150041379034519,
0.13861486315727234,
0.3558761179447174,
0.31072360277175903,
-0.1857200562953949,
-0.14630953967571259,
0.09968660771846771,
0.30386486649513245,
-0.23804877698421478,
-0.8591464161872864,
0.5789564847946167,
-0.5068466067314148,
-0.6987765431404114,
-0.5399527549743652,
-0.7582595348358154,
-0.7998209595680237,
-0.091710664331913,
0.007339455187320709,
0.07800786197185516,
-0.21304534375667572,
0.2903650104999542,
0.5537761449813843,
-0.011018305085599422,
0.290859580039978,
0.4518641233444214,
0.037681035697460175,
-0.43359094858169556,
0.892578125,
-0.04674219712615013,
-0.33035755157470703,
0.46894413232803345,
0.16725429892539978,
-0.678627073764801,
-0.7962179780006409,
-0.038373928517103195,
0.3442182242870331,
-0.6151730418205261,
-0.5134001970291138,
0.06587556004524231,
-0.26223137974739075,
-0.3757075071334839,
0.1451261341571808,
-0.08795136958360672,
-0.2800358831882477,
-0.16330814361572266,
0.02559249848127365,
0.22837035357952118,
1.0211074352264404,
0.06181025877594948,
0.2428840845823288,
-1.121022343635559,
0.21283194422721863,
-0.10487161576747894,
0.46804481744766235,
-0.12212222069501877,
-0.33128055930137634,
-0.14534379541873932,
0.007318902760744095,
-0.1433078646659851,
-1.050103783607483,
0.3063773810863495,
-0.042315732687711716,
0.8237942457199097,
0.2593851387500763,
-0.2383379340171814,
0.7018221020698547,
-0.5737351179122925,
0.9519784450531006,
0.30783364176750183,
-0.7053419947624207,
0.19161877036094666,
-0.383020281791687,
0.05022115632891655,
0.7515803575515747,
0.5181966423988342,
-0.2317563146352768,
-0.23226754367351532,
-0.4729171693325043,
-0.4113336503505707,
0.743880033493042,
0.30490779876708984,
-0.13401725888252258,
0.24966061115264893,
0.5978286862373352,
-0.07906545698642731,
0.1583978235721588,
-0.21429230272769928,
-0.4165872633457184,
0.14224426448345184,
-0.6329873204231262,
-0.34160202741622925,
0.02552912011742592,
-0.3677135407924652,
-0.3653944730758667,
0.4853333532810211,
-0.016432734206318855,
-0.09521208703517914,
-0.2061636596918106,
0.18235647678375244,
0.21355211734771729,
-0.29393839836120605,
0.7876449823379517,
0.5147740840911865,
0.046666089445352554,
0.00998688954859972,
0.5400480628013611,
-0.21893075108528137,
0.16080598533153534,
0.1661568582057953,
-0.04861855134367943,
0.004802082199603319,
0.6092288494110107,
0.5572388768196106,
0.4657379984855652,
-0.872698962688446,
0.3481149673461914,
-0.05615568906068802,
-0.6102540493011475,
0.23120805621147156,
0.13246534764766693,
0.07898106426000595,
0.36726999282836914,
0.3774133324623108,
-0.2915441393852234,
0.32743072509765625,
-0.6662127375602722,
0.26904159784317017,
0.5118436813354492,
-0.2665426433086395,
-0.1814163625240326,
0.654455840587616,
0.22631888091564178,
-0.1764453798532486,
0.12460724264383316,
0.11953012645244598,
-0.5974869132041931,
0.5375847220420837,
0.43125009536743164,
0.5049463510513306,
-0.2335418313741684,
0.2432730495929718,
0.07818444818258286,
-0.08772832900285721,
-0.13110709190368652,
0.43742597103118896,
0.1116933524608612,
-0.6560578942298889,
-0.5827022194862366,
-0.36116868257522583,
-0.6040088534355164,
0.057349324226379395,
-0.36666566133499146,
0.15658019483089447,
-0.28871697187423706,
-0.4046071469783783,
0.340555876493454,
0.03559097647666931,
-0.7513575553894043,
0.2576407790184021,
0.4635930359363556,
1.0711275339126587,
-0.956982433795929,
0.2894233763217926,
0.7796487212181091,
-0.47182148694992065,
-0.4642847776412964,
-0.4166761636734009,
0.29002833366394043,
-0.955186665058136,
1.0493218898773193,
-0.5182828903198242,
0.13276343047618866,
-0.18879334628582,
-0.40055832266807556,
-0.5523425936698914,
0.9553635120391846,
0.29039692878723145,
-0.12227871268987656,
-0.22296403348445892,
0.6330264210700989,
0.31168490648269653,
-0.4017235040664673,
0.29950273036956787,
0.9516604542732239,
0.43280401825904846,
0.5761100649833679,
-0.6692357063293457,
-0.18642939627170563,
0.08320821076631546,
-0.36925897002220154,
0.2386520504951477,
-0.6314192414283752,
0.6116592288017273,
0.029067562893033028,
-0.011553118005394936,
-0.20963983237743378,
0.7829692959785461,
0.39149993658065796,
0.48806384205818176,
0.40225455164909363,
0.42917779088020325,
0.8756946921348572,
-0.24523383378982544,
0.8608183264732361,
-0.15604709088802338,
0.33230534195899963,
0.979985773563385,
-0.718009352684021,
0.7860026955604553,
0.2080536186695099,
-0.2461889386177063,
0.15031418204307556,
0.528669536113739,
-0.20891831815242767,
0.28531360626220703,
0.2858772575855255,
-0.5141438841819763,
-0.3581116795539856,
-0.18142785131931305,
-0.1711118519306183,
0.8316561579704285,
0.34513750672340393,
-0.016706733033061028,
-0.5939375162124634,
-0.0007889808621257544,
-0.07427316159009933,
0.19633148610591888,
-0.30234530568122864,
1.1007493734359741,
-0.1217818483710289,
-0.7326486706733704,
0.007824099622666836,
-0.13288795948028564,
0.46238404512405396,
-0.6105952858924866,
-0.1905774176120758,
-0.23101378977298737,
0.1464412659406662,
-0.17747610807418823,
-1.3854784965515137,
0.4197618365287781,
0.19617794454097748,
-0.11263617873191833,
-0.1135043203830719,
0.717409074306488,
-0.499133825302124,
-0.4076639711856842,
-0.04801876097917557,
0.45394009351730347,
0.31587910652160645,
-0.013384014368057251,
-1.1383047103881836,
0.4211539328098297,
-0.06794323772192001,
0.19059203565120697,
0.30910778045654297,
0.43630290031433105,
0.23329217731952667,
0.6549994349479675,
0.5700096487998962,
0.5846090316772461,
-0.0579921118915081,
0.019068289548158646,
0.6621162295341492,
-0.8560359477996826,
-0.4331728219985962,
-1.1512848138809204,
0.08989270776510239,
-0.39010441303253174,
-0.19581805169582367,
0.7287224531173706,
1.035531997680664,
0.22909821569919586,
0.028241142630577087,
0.8719587922096252,
0.3559303879737854,
0.4862680733203888,
-0.7189172506332397,
0.6875494122505188,
-0.3505147099494934,
0.1292523443698883,
0.18166714906692505,
-0.8785481452941895,
-0.3922504782676697,
0.16215476393699646,
-0.21197953820228577,
-0.33179619908332825,
0.37175875902175903,
0.14989043772220612,
-0.051569875329732895,
0.17222605645656586,
0.31619831919670105,
-0.08831267803907394,
0.4291814863681793,
0.6815895438194275,
0.8089460730552673,
-0.42756468057632446,
0.6136873364448547,
0.038712915033102036,
-0.4470007121562958,
-0.18797951936721802,
-0.7970993518829346,
-1.0152485370635986,
-0.43689224123954773,
-0.34501123428344727,
-0.5065796375274658,
-0.21809296309947968,
0.7026587128639221,
0.3936043083667755,
-0.7950617671012878,
-0.5214173793792725,
0.40089887380599976,
0.13033682107925415,
-0.19336381554603577,
-0.2528384327888489,
0.2210095077753067,
-0.2571331858634949,
-0.7985181212425232,
0.45003509521484375,
0.24815133213996887,
0.2962492108345032,
-0.2725672125816345,
0.0745072290301323,
-0.10381206125020981,
0.36876097321510315,
0.6929558515548706,
0.6020529866218567,
-0.46642038226127625,
-0.0469348281621933,
0.18351702392101288,
-0.005488005466759205,
-0.19790342450141907,
0.9518807530403137,
-0.7307054400444031,
0.3607654273509979,
0.8423517346382141,
1.0461955070495605,
0.3351738750934601,
0.32458749413490295,
0.782045841217041,
-0.4100377857685089,
-0.11676577478647232,
0.33238255977630615,
0.17060215771198273,
0.1118440106511116,
-0.19873663783073425,
0.6263284087181091,
0.3717678189277649,
-0.20597510039806366,
-0.9498645663261414,
-0.17533649504184723,
-0.797343909740448,
-0.17942798137664795,
1.219771146774292,
0.3593154549598694,
-0.26709097623825073,
-0.17951925098896027,
0.057490985840559006,
-0.07072217762470245,
0.016884827986359596,
0.5722191333770752,
1.1278659105300903,
-0.668749988079071,
0.20741385221481323,
-0.510031521320343,
0.8552341461181641,
0.0765744000673294,
-1.013429045677185,
0.15102483332157135,
0.32160723209381104,
-0.012894543819129467,
0.06609796732664108,
0.6177549362182617,
0.22015558183193207,
0.1918424516916275,
0.13405773043632507,
-0.33377963304519653,
-0.1824093461036682,
-0.16590502858161926,
0.027972519397735596,
0.18003186583518982,
-0.5275840759277344,
-0.07107760012149811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10311v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10311v5 | The optimal placement of the head in the noun phrase. The case of demonstrative, numeral, adjective and noun | 2024-02-15T20:24:39 | 2024-03-22T16:10:14 | Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | The word order of a sentence is shaped by multiple principles. The principle
of syntactic dependency distance minimization is in conflict with the principle
of surprisal minimization (or predictability maximization) in single head
syntactic dependency structures: while the former predicts that the head should
be placed at the center of the linear arrangement, the latter predicts that the
head should be placed at one of the ends (either first or last). A critical
question is when surprisal minimization (or predictability maximization) should
surpass syntactic dependency distance minimization. In the context of single
head structures, it has been predicted that this is more likely to happen when
two conditions are met, i.e. (a) fewer words are involved and (b) words are
shorter. Here we test the prediction on the noun phrase when it is composed of
a demonstrative, a numeral, an adjective and a noun. We find that, across
preferred orders in languages, the noun tends to be placed at one of the ends,
confirming the theoretical prediction. We also show evidence of anti locality
effects: syntactic dependency distances in preferred orders are longer than
expected by chance. | [
-0.6076028943061829,
-0.8471010327339172,
0.6879533529281616,
0.38262608647346497,
-0.27219781279563904,
-0.2919033467769623,
-0.18300755321979523,
-0.4933070242404938,
0.6070691347122192,
0.3676973581314087,
-0.45238590240478516,
-0.1065182164311409,
-0.7133870124816895,
0.19252577424049377,
-0.09719016402959824,
0.7221538424491882,
0.17192788422107697,
-0.09646600484848022,
-0.6075024604797363,
-0.16504310071468353,
-0.37352776527404785,
-0.7655986547470093,
-0.22986117005348206,
-0.23831848800182343,
0.43505391478538513,
0.313100665807724,
1.249630331993103,
1.253132700920105,
0.740055501461029,
0.3579716086387634,
-0.2751292884349823,
-0.15249866247177124,
-0.039110030978918076,
-0.00938880629837513,
-0.09200333803892136,
-0.8063293695449829,
0.003997412510216236,
-0.03754217550158501,
0.41170328855514526,
1.0549975633621216,
-0.08405250310897827,
-0.11829651147127151,
-0.19195137917995453,
0.7998693585395813,
-0.6506720185279846,
0.042564913630485535,
-0.272966206073761,
-0.0889897271990776,
-0.49502241611480713,
-0.41888627409935,
-0.09687595814466476,
-0.4934684634208679,
0.5102302432060242,
-0.15881577134132385,
0.04122542589902878,
0.15256468951702118,
1.13167142868042,
0.423809289932251,
-0.3561781644821167,
0.057335224002599716,
-0.49685463309288025,
0.8168239593505859,
-0.470843106508255,
0.4229329526424408,
0.3111422657966614,
0.1261601597070694,
-0.3082701563835144,
-0.4136127829551697,
-0.5283385515213013,
-0.23840445280075073,
-0.3412333130836487,
-0.05928470194339752,
-0.3273339867591858,
0.5014057159423828,
0.36850300431251526,
0.34195050597190857,
-0.6121863126754761,
0.20253366231918335,
-0.37960395216941833,
0.1390082836151123,
0.12943944334983826,
0.05990906059741974,
0.34451016783714294,
-0.41428449749946594,
-0.6613684892654419,
0.18054290115833282,
-0.6882034540176392,
0.2444377839565277,
0.2646257281303406,
0.6958950161933899,
0.12248952686786652,
0.4816904366016388,
-0.5296406745910645,
0.5670880079269409,
0.2726691663265228,
-0.31077173352241516,
0.28062063455581665,
-0.5628807544708252,
-0.1015511304140091,
0.20352432131767273,
0.6563328504562378,
0.7566567659378052,
0.22701101005077362,
-0.1721017062664032,
-0.15570957958698273,
0.7113690972328186,
0.2951423227787018,
-0.6114215850830078,
0.06583287566900253,
0.048338882625103,
-0.30227622389793396,
-0.2836216390132904,
0.10452594608068466,
-0.5203313231468201,
-0.03803723677992821,
-0.5076313018798828,
0.10313218832015991,
-0.26985248923301697,
0.079121433198452,
0.10749048739671707,
0.175619438290596,
-0.017383340746164322,
-0.17592757940292358,
-0.9482138752937317,
0.7183343768119812,
0.555387556552887,
0.811227023601532,
-0.28462865948677063,
-0.3377092480659485,
-0.14849181473255157,
0.09939415007829666,
-0.49603354930877686,
1.0490195751190186,
-0.2273329794406891,
-0.21462327241897583,
-0.10124421119689941,
-0.08250947296619415,
-0.15388555824756622,
-0.46903857588768005,
0.5029837489128113,
-0.14896906912326813,
0.32569482922554016,
-0.3690781593322754,
-0.692699134349823,
-0.35306471586227417,
-0.19043104350566864,
-0.49453669786453247,
0.43822917342185974,
0.108163021504879,
-0.9125025272369385,
0.47018951177597046,
-0.36159178614616394,
-0.7700691819190979,
-0.08974190056324005,
-0.34727346897125244,
-0.238682821393013,
0.3984402120113373,
-0.2364107221364975,
0.14425420761108398,
-0.21929389238357544,
-0.09745955467224121,
-0.19550879299640656,
-0.07008305191993713,
-0.03597637265920639,
0.038922157138586044,
0.8383658528327942,
0.17180941998958588,
-0.36000365018844604,
-0.08699126541614532,
-0.6384344696998596,
0.18559233844280243,
0.040229544043540955,
-0.23520483076572418,
-0.7800782918930054,
0.07936647534370422,
-0.11013845354318619,
0.21631571650505066,
0.2507307231426239,
-0.41916948556900024,
0.02790019102394581,
-0.7568705081939697,
0.14295122027397156,
0.7574277520179749,
0.3439241349697113,
0.6545611023902893,
-0.2667998671531677,
0.636203408241272,
-0.07030262798070908,
0.33336660265922546,
0.2612617015838623,
-0.16147029399871826,
-0.712708592414856,
0.05760064348578453,
0.26385802030563354,
0.7539551854133606,
-0.47648853063583374,
0.28355738520622253,
-0.11004338413476944,
-0.05168436840176582,
-0.03948559984564781,
-0.05143452063202858,
0.8188424706459045,
0.17951852083206177,
0.21269294619560242,
-0.3708054721355438,
-0.9416864514350891,
-1.1773508787155151,
-0.10569866746664047,
-0.47015270590782166,
0.6729103922843933,
-0.19742225110530853,
0.2997458577156067,
-0.07817154377698898,
1.0872060060501099,
-0.8577799201011658,
-0.29670754075050354,
-0.3874973952770233,
0.03517228364944458,
0.3502213954925537,
0.3396591544151306,
0.9718988537788391,
-1.0300843715667725,
-0.3016897737979889,
-0.26306766271591187,
-0.4774381220340729,
-0.167119100689888,
-0.028016310185194016,
-0.15217457711696625,
0.26672878861427307,
0.4078509509563446,
-0.9149641394615173,
0.628641664981842,
0.13307370245456696,
-0.23984508216381073,
0.6788169145584106,
-0.2164735645055771,
-0.3623736500740051,
-0.9542590379714966,
-0.42821696400642395,
0.02436227723956108,
-0.1400289386510849,
-1.1013433933258057,
0.2260366976261139,
-0.24509736895561218,
0.6483691930770874,
-0.4121938645839691,
0.10639006644487381,
-0.3575063645839691,
-0.0058028819039464,
-0.5225160717964172,
0.015163813717663288,
0.05275697261095047,
0.41944649815559387,
0.14747419953346252,
0.6012343168258667,
0.5409263968467712,
-1.0241376161575317,
0.1988818198442459,
0.2571578025817871,
-0.6791715621948242,
0.6159617900848389,
-0.7488937973976135,
-0.2900730073451996,
-0.3414047956466675,
-0.23434671759605408,
-0.9739527106285095,
0.03708989918231964,
-0.07005380839109421,
-0.3712944984436035,
0.15974107384681702,
0.39802268147468567,
-0.45291954278945923,
-0.30412906408309937,
-0.07824727147817612,
0.2781979739665985,
0.24224866926670074,
-0.15793639421463013,
-0.1517622023820877,
0.6275925040245056,
-0.12714871764183044,
-0.61765456199646,
-0.7900792360305786,
-0.18910564482212067,
-0.26654160022735596,
-0.39120087027549744,
0.5265796184539795,
-0.192378431558609,
-0.8750187754631042,
-0.09819073230028152,
-0.3524330258369446,
0.0818035751581192,
0.019821669906377792,
0.37552863359451294,
0.06900369375944138,
-0.1666577160358429,
0.08861693739891052,
-0.12389035522937775,
-0.25515612959861755,
0.046908434480428696,
-0.080808624625206,
0.4202321767807007,
-0.2496524155139923,
0.24613620340824127,
-0.13087403774261475,
0.21853438019752502,
0.6610309481620789,
0.007283430080860853,
0.634147047996521,
-0.10606960952281952,
-0.3935598134994507,
0.07809490710496902,
-0.4748077988624573,
0.008025726303458214,
-0.46032801270484924,
0.2809755504131317,
-0.5719560980796814,
-0.2477857619524002,
0.24396982789039612,
0.2086486965417862,
0.05460192635655403,
0.39390769600868225,
0.3177354037761688,
-0.07539305090904236,
0.8226441740989685,
0.9329694509506226,
-0.07464338093996048,
0.46884021162986755,
-0.22137731313705444,
0.18689705431461334,
-0.6516104340553284,
0.07590584456920624,
-0.5425422787666321,
-0.16050532460212708,
-0.8190582394599915,
-0.07928626239299774,
0.31980690360069275,
0.20348449051380157,
0.1638127863407135,
0.8256445527076721,
-0.30061450600624084,
0.7102981805801392,
0.634882390499115,
0.018384868279099464,
0.07261042296886444,
-0.18115007877349854,
-0.679685652256012,
-0.1983664631843567,
-0.5273007154464722,
-0.3339376747608185,
0.3278561532497406,
0.07679957896471024,
0.426698237657547,
0.23316968977451324,
0.7416477799415588,
-0.028305355459451675,
-0.3136550784111023,
-0.9224109649658203,
0.7329998016357422,
-0.31277865171432495,
-0.46987810730934143,
-0.3858143985271454,
-0.1434679627418518,
-1.0027271509170532,
0.40240395069122314,
0.10902206599712372,
-0.6817142367362976,
0.47799545526504517,
-0.2784280478954315,
-0.7487443685531616,
-0.07301189750432968,
-0.3980986177921295,
0.7751691341400146,
-0.23779739439487457,
0.013775025494396687,
0.11066151410341263,
-0.910517156124115,
-0.039090901613235474,
0.24484410881996155,
0.43375712633132935,
-0.05293041467666626,
-0.1576293706893921,
0.6144270896911621,
-0.7284010052680969,
0.39933979511260986,
-0.017097407951951027,
0.27613765001296997,
0.18073667585849762,
0.18503695726394653,
0.27820923924446106,
-0.5398462414741516,
0.12483397871255875,
-0.23219269514083862,
-0.08101442456245422,
-0.217370867729187,
-0.4838828444480896,
0.4660259783267975,
-0.6535671353340149,
-0.7636401057243347,
-0.45434117317199707,
-0.4690752327442169,
-0.12326513975858688,
0.3535286486148834,
0.7625139951705933,
0.5745692849159241,
0.014574592933058739,
0.18753205239772797,
0.4569617211818695,
-0.13806948065757751,
0.5928966403007507,
0.26585423946380615,
-0.3635815978050232,
-0.2913515865802765,
0.5811976194381714,
0.5760135650634766,
0.5677313208580017,
0.6917815804481506,
0.586595356464386,
-0.26532992720603943,
-0.6060893535614014,
0.011662560515105724,
0.3291738033294678,
-0.7214017510414124,
-0.04532938078045845,
-0.5510253310203552,
-0.03407325968146324,
-0.560312807559967,
-0.3262932002544403,
-0.37636232376098633,
-0.7042897939682007,
0.00741584412753582,
-0.4814036190509796,
0.21209478378295898,
0.4197406768798828,
-0.253184050321579,
0.4237014055252075,
-0.2839422821998596,
0.46416375041007996,
0.0701698437333107,
0.07728521525859833,
-0.4366338849067688,
-0.4925478398799896,
-0.20647525787353516,
-0.2868395447731018,
-0.07236412912607193,
-0.7177642583847046,
0.3181779980659485,
0.06027687340974808,
0.57368004322052,
0.92109614610672,
0.26194602251052856,
1.0345065593719482,
-0.7371546626091003,
0.4473794996738434,
0.5906063914299011,
-0.6855162382125854,
0.6472518444061279,
-0.33237749338150024,
0.4675488770008087,
0.8643128275871277,
0.3922753632068634,
-0.41732731461524963,
-0.652653694152832,
-0.6208698749542236,
-0.8234255313873291,
0.38052278757095337,
0.24752403795719147,
-0.09412677586078644,
-0.4219878911972046,
0.29597824811935425,
0.16195763647556305,
0.3339558243751526,
-0.6959123015403748,
-0.823014497756958,
0.35376453399658203,
0.23296427726745605,
-0.0175621397793293,
-0.15715292096138,
0.21254710853099823,
-0.21437519788742065,
0.45787695050239563,
0.28842297196388245,
0.40819284319877625,
-0.03619460016489029,
-0.003099591936916113,
-0.3455353081226349,
0.01723594218492508,
0.9150829315185547,
1.0803382396697998,
-0.3638429641723633,
0.3220588266849518,
-0.026595463976264,
-0.38065144419670105,
0.12799902260303497,
-0.23695974051952362,
-0.5449714660644531,
0.48769018054008484,
0.2700135409832001,
0.7694784998893738,
0.18317566812038422,
-0.08486704528331757,
0.5506368279457092,
0.38016432523727417,
-0.03100871667265892,
-0.5224066376686096,
-0.17587465047836304,
-0.20102530717849731,
0.2137243002653122,
0.16261188685894012,
0.26858747005462646,
0.2986343502998352,
-0.7378943562507629,
0.5077742338180542,
0.4503854811191559,
-0.06208689138293266,
-0.1981183886528015,
0.531562864780426,
-0.3833480179309845,
-0.28621578216552734,
0.14894014596939087,
-0.09504286199808121,
-0.8853105306625366,
0.7808043360710144,
0.4123818576335907,
0.699327290058136,
-0.4906634986400604,
0.349651575088501,
0.4001275300979614,
0.43063855171203613,
-0.36292290687561035,
0.40910547971725464,
0.2708365023136139,
-0.6983400583267212,
-0.08694272488355637,
-0.6901264190673828,
-0.2907586991786957,
-0.15790855884552002,
-0.7769371271133423,
0.2722397744655609,
-0.5507122278213501,
-0.5132587552070618,
0.2822168171405792,
0.014547879807651043,
-0.2967681586742401,
0.43296995759010315,
0.07166779041290283,
0.3229084312915802,
-0.740771472454071,
0.6521993279457092,
0.44748368859291077,
-0.5017852187156677,
-0.6032386422157288,
-0.12279900163412094,
0.08037044107913971,
-0.6120288968086243,
0.7655535936355591,
0.3676607012748718,
-0.3065989315509796,
-0.40329715609550476,
-0.28975459933280945,
-1.213104009628296,
0.734796941280365,
0.2431826889514923,
-0.3090518116950989,
-0.3345769941806793,
0.3137457072734833,
0.6571811437606812,
-0.3274744749069214,
0.04793846979737282,
0.3932260274887085,
0.39173707365989685,
-0.0210229754447937,
-1.0560837984085083,
0.09798765927553177,
0.07093749195337296,
0.49411413073539734,
0.5218361020088196,
-0.7811500430107117,
0.9979725480079651,
-0.5018903613090515,
-0.37588927149772644,
0.2717280983924866,
0.7219377160072327,
-0.07258911430835724,
0.09681810438632965,
0.7477152347564697,
0.7745791673660278,
0.4647749662399292,
-0.11881297826766968,
1.2794804573059082,
-0.3518697917461395,
0.182266503572464,
1.0830752849578857,
0.10972986370325089,
0.6940262317657471,
0.6676987409591675,
-0.49469155073165894,
0.6641536951065063,
0.7727999687194824,
0.27138254046440125,
1.1650947332382202,
0.4279361069202423,
0.09934001415967941,
0.12677791714668274,
-0.4686419665813446,
-0.3005628287792206,
0.7534788250923157,
0.16132870316505432,
-0.3157240152359009,
0.02357270009815693,
0.12610377371311188,
0.06805598735809326,
0.16514459252357483,
-0.32653602957725525,
0.6174291372299194,
0.30437958240509033,
-0.5717788338661194,
0.7174746990203857,
0.05317690595984459,
0.3566759526729584,
-0.3353336751461029,
0.4304739236831665,
-0.3645406663417816,
0.3101560175418854,
-0.25981298089027405,
-0.31380388140678406,
0.3250393867492676,
-0.5781402587890625,
-0.38841018080711365,
-0.21079613268375397,
0.5096816420555115,
-0.2368525117635727,
-0.41763898730278015,
0.29094198346138,
0.4996107816696167,
0.2209595888853073,
0.16025212407112122,
-0.39239031076431274,
-0.24394071102142334,
-0.37866124510765076,
-0.5638762712478638,
0.39645716547966003,
0.46202829480171204,
0.16965380311012268,
0.5071884393692017,
0.3074477016925812,
0.43267062306404114,
0.09546682983636856,
0.07632452249526978,
0.516122043132782,
-0.4911186695098877,
-1.0081846714019775,
-1.0196640491485596,
0.05074157938361168,
0.23088222742080688,
-0.2392806112766266,
0.843139111995697,
0.42468592524528503,
0.8620480298995972,
0.020418984815478325,
0.4398708939552307,
-0.08280099928379059,
0.5309230089187622,
-0.2841247320175171,
0.11320186406373978,
-0.5194270014762878,
-0.06291770935058594,
-0.6043658256530762,
-1.2258021831512451,
-0.5429195165634155,
0.791744589805603,
-0.46774500608444214,
-0.20732437074184418,
1.2113511562347412,
0.7120946645736694,
0.2726138234138489,
-0.055622220039367676,
0.41845154762268066,
0.17615428566932678,
-0.4579630196094513,
0.5674855709075928,
0.5845061540603638,
-0.1491205394268036,
0.33556362986564636,
-0.9067474603652954,
-0.04458222910761833,
-0.04765785485506058,
-0.5264967083930969,
-0.6493155360221863,
-0.6581024527549744,
-0.5069682002067566,
-0.29678967595100403,
0.02989441715180874,
1.1798983812332153,
0.46423500776290894,
-0.6773344278335571,
-0.49713560938835144,
-0.40582093596458435,
0.21465888619422913,
-0.5797950625419617,
-0.2689465284347534,
0.4075724482536316,
-0.24731381237506866,
-0.7371968030929565,
0.21311643719673157,
0.42647451162338257,
0.049015238881111145,
-0.05863853171467781,
0.0974356159567833,
-0.6178485155105591,
0.15125079452991486,
0.6092498898506165,
0.2381511628627777,
-0.8809964060783386,
-0.42350924015045166,
0.03581353649497032,
-0.48809847235679626,
0.2683637738227844,
0.47103604674339294,
-0.7208141684532166,
0.3317267596721649,
0.5592157244682312,
0.27116209268569946,
-0.20215950906276703,
0.18044134974479675,
0.43360933661460876,
-0.7374759316444397,
0.073172427713871,
-0.095831960439682,
0.3684067726135254,
-0.14288313686847687,
-0.6014324426651001,
0.7454439401626587,
0.4301941394805908,
-0.2946699261665344,
-0.8344736695289612,
0.5460960865020752,
-0.835713803768158,
-0.4512457251548767,
1.2301040887832642,
0.03770080581307411,
-0.20898748934268951,
-0.08919421583414078,
0.05844501033425331,
0.2650128901004791,
-0.038925349712371826,
0.6365044713020325,
0.7341086864471436,
-0.5161380767822266,
-0.2378951609134674,
-0.5961788892745972,
0.48804759979248047,
0.5412795543670654,
-0.6094849109649658,
-0.22053301334381104,
0.34068500995635986,
-0.01867472566664219,
0.7727153301239014,
0.5440893173217773,
0.08553952723741531,
0.35065218806266785,
0.014635785482823849,
-0.12726746499538422,
0.1536576747894287,
-0.6351375579833984,
-0.17553775012493134,
0.23162522912025452,
-0.1016310527920723,
-0.5719782710075378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10302v1 | How to Discern Important Urgent News? | 2024-02-15T20:08:07 | 2024-02-15T20:08:07 | Oleg Vasilyev, John Bohannon | cs.CL | cs.CL | We found that a simple property of clusters in a clustered dataset of news
correlate strongly with importance and urgency of news (IUN) as assessed by
LLM. We verified our finding across different news datasets, dataset sizes,
clustering algorithms and embeddings. The found correlation should allow using
clustering (as an alternative to LLM) for identifying the most important urgent
news, or for filtering out unimportant articles. | [
-0.2395090013742447,
-0.7948465347290039,
0.8695704936981201,
0.556605875492096,
-0.35883617401123047,
0.1464499682188034,
-0.040793877094984055,
-0.5177533626556396,
0.5060277581214905,
0.2217404991388321,
-0.2651253044605255,
-0.57535719871521,
-0.8915033340454102,
-0.2225833684206009,
-1.0608820915222168,
0.8262672424316406,
0.22310836613178253,
0.052331164479255676,
-0.10385199636220932,
-0.40031906962394714,
-0.08307619392871857,
-0.2727090120315552,
-0.8031690120697021,
-0.09992050379514694,
0.7836512923240662,
0.6483168005943298,
0.6476042866706848,
0.658119261264801,
1.1882884502410889,
0.14330807328224182,
-0.6104127168655396,
-0.29475343227386475,
-0.6996732950210571,
-0.22204361855983734,
-0.3290376365184784,
-0.6719369888305664,
-0.2047497183084488,
0.035170987248420715,
0.5858705639839172,
0.8102198839187622,
-0.010050186887383461,
0.49242812395095825,
-0.0017948001623153687,
1.3057249784469604,
-0.2898271679878235,
0.02697228454053402,
-0.6471806764602661,
0.16053782403469086,
-0.444254606962204,
-0.18133091926574707,
-0.061775658279657364,
-0.4763461649417877,
0.20585839450359344,
-0.36731189489364624,
0.33835867047309875,
0.30684831738471985,
0.9355393052101135,
0.32927146553993225,
-0.7130482792854309,
-0.32584840059280396,
-0.6433239579200745,
0.6805154085159302,
-0.3860210180282593,
0.13366369903087616,
0.21228258311748505,
0.1106371358036995,
-0.38682109117507935,
-0.5433107018470764,
-0.1960509866476059,
0.22106827795505524,
-0.2712354362010956,
0.15888182818889618,
-0.10795188695192337,
-0.015140388160943985,
0.25048044323921204,
0.7906063795089722,
-0.21748009324073792,
0.13801389932632446,
-0.5450221300125122,
0.013257256709039211,
0.38113510608673096,
0.07546533644199371,
0.3282662034034729,
-0.3018438220024109,
-0.3766743242740631,
0.23747572302818298,
-0.883041501045227,
0.3820236325263977,
0.3491162955760956,
0.1969902664422989,
-0.13144011795520782,
0.6456008553504944,
-0.5038235187530518,
0.6661151051521301,
0.41108232736587524,
-0.33079448342323303,
0.1757836937904358,
-0.3264716863632202,
0.3245556950569153,
0.629990816116333,
0.3457430303096771,
0.6983789801597595,
-0.35768312215805054,
0.024063926190137863,
0.007182124070823193,
-0.04345007240772247,
0.23642240464687347,
-0.4746033549308777,
0.3488329350948334,
0.47007882595062256,
-0.8772578835487366,
-0.5298054218292236,
0.3203541040420532,
-0.7118130922317505,
-0.3930168151855469,
-0.23880703747272491,
0.4302522838115692,
0.5348021388053894,
-0.47627612948417664,
-0.04654446616768837,
-0.2501078248023987,
0.16734950244426727,
0.34943369030952454,
-0.5947692394256592,
0.026747215539216995,
0.8208888173103333,
0.7021534442901611,
-0.5100352764129639,
0.06459815800189972,
-0.29697978496551514,
0.041305720806121826,
-0.5271749496459961,
1.0911650657653809,
-0.3625626564025879,
0.14896155893802643,
-0.07308252155780792,
0.28903767466545105,
0.3500780761241913,
-0.5543788075447083,
0.973163902759552,
-0.5793917179107666,
-0.20778773725032806,
-0.4119868874549866,
-0.4848165512084961,
-0.5775083303451538,
0.1128544956445694,
-0.9477392435073853,
1.0197795629501343,
0.3349449336528778,
-0.7998912334442139,
0.6873519420623779,
-0.43424874544143677,
-1.0298991203308105,
-0.3037087321281433,
-0.08541378378868103,
-0.7138878703117371,
0.4912080764770508,
0.12956103682518005,
0.6679049134254456,
-0.42716184258461,
0.44574281573295593,
-0.3325689733028412,
-0.34688326716423035,
0.2961205244064331,
-0.2045179009437561,
0.3167392611503601,
0.2603296637535095,
-0.4629198908805847,
0.09466003626585007,
-0.8698769211769104,
-0.27032995223999023,
-0.04969150200486183,
-0.5425137877464294,
-0.32854321599006653,
0.27382156252861023,
-0.1708332598209381,
0.03186221793293953,
0.2783152759075165,
-0.24579738080501556,
0.08606923371553421,
0.09248393028974533,
0.42307472229003906,
0.32451099157333374,
0.5194541811943054,
0.5408403873443604,
-0.4838959276676178,
0.35921981930732727,
0.3890301287174225,
0.35276925563812256,
0.14740046858787537,
-0.6573472619056702,
-0.8105338215827942,
-0.03010924533009529,
0.14364467561244965,
0.6999388337135315,
0.13031518459320068,
0.4440307021141052,
0.12018365412950516,
-0.4253882169723511,
-0.5075652003288269,
0.005691122729331255,
-0.07060584425926208,
0.4539278447628021,
0.04584905132651329,
-0.02564835175871849,
-0.6630106568336487,
-0.9681938886642456,
-0.5375860929489136,
0.17920435965061188,
0.5041822791099548,
0.14543019235134125,
-0.16614103317260742,
-0.00934329442679882,
0.9677423238754272,
-0.44363948702812195,
-0.3006802797317505,
-0.4748590886592865,
0.33513736724853516,
1.1286766529083252,
0.20384560525417328,
0.6277983784675598,
-1.3541736602783203,
-0.5107255578041077,
0.09002634137868881,
-0.696823239326477,
-0.40591859817504883,
-0.4108934700489044,
-0.021409014239907265,
-0.4268503785133362,
0.9502021074295044,
-0.3092990517616272,
0.930270254611969,
0.36830446124076843,
-0.15835943818092346,
0.10063265264034271,
-0.09023967385292053,
0.40672963857650757,
-0.8272445201873779,
-0.14473778009414673,
-0.09601861983537674,
-0.4334454834461212,
-0.6559428572654724,
-0.11721508949995041,
0.08496749401092529,
-0.219788059592247,
-0.5477852821350098,
0.3696528673171997,
-0.529930830001831,
-0.38795584440231323,
-0.30927249789237976,
0.16985701024532318,
0.07172912359237671,
-0.012386570684611797,
-0.07220307737588882,
0.49664369225502014,
0.6141704320907593,
-0.7789086103439331,
0.1981433779001236,
-0.170159712433815,
-0.8910703063011169,
0.25692445039749146,
-0.5157722234725952,
-0.47849032282829285,
-0.22746159136295319,
-0.13517716526985168,
-1.2372071743011475,
-0.4317590892314911,
-0.20739157497882843,
-0.15398500859737396,
0.17478083074092865,
-0.004504370968788862,
-0.34755846858024597,
-0.7674077749252319,
-0.00014957270468585193,
0.37001997232437134,
0.30339547991752625,
-0.5411052107810974,
0.40764662623405457,
0.6344155073165894,
-0.16513483226299286,
-0.5111986398696899,
-0.49892836809158325,
-0.07688449323177338,
-0.5641462206840515,
-0.10600928217172623,
0.10072171688079834,
0.05026508867740631,
-0.5614744424819946,
0.22809723019599915,
-0.20676490664482117,
-0.35826995968818665,
0.5082135796546936,
0.6257832050323486,
-0.2034868597984314,
-0.23784604668617249,
0.12391539663076401,
0.29165560007095337,
-0.44718995690345764,
-0.01034699846059084,
0.4117555022239685,
0.23991164565086365,
-0.2887728810310364,
-0.2682017683982849,
-0.5797232389450073,
0.7107331156730652,
0.9193732142448425,
0.15103110671043396,
0.7163117527961731,
0.7710249423980713,
-0.3081911504268646,
0.3368377089500427,
-0.7710893154144287,
-0.3521459996700287,
-0.41312137246131897,
0.46190983057022095,
0.12887562811374664,
-0.7715081572532654,
0.6038491129875183,
-0.6297826766967773,
-0.1357855200767517,
0.688984751701355,
0.46905654668807983,
-0.03706057742238045,
1.2288256883621216,
0.44783419370651245,
-0.5698193907737732,
0.693213701248169,
-0.0401485301554203,
0.43100982904434204,
-0.3963908851146698,
0.12636837363243103,
-0.2895354628562927,
-0.6974624991416931,
-0.3859025537967682,
0.12807561457157135,
0.729920506477356,
0.47525840997695923,
0.23352450132369995,
-0.1967237889766693,
-0.6966103911399841,
0.8236714601516724,
0.8114405870437622,
0.3507026433944702,
0.5084230899810791,
0.3066478371620178,
0.4700419306755066,
0.07906881719827652,
-0.5569068193435669,
-0.21459096670150757,
0.867044985294342,
0.1640664041042328,
0.8337090015411377,
0.07758940756320953,
0.5165849924087524,
0.43479984998703003,
0.320625364780426,
-0.9276608228683472,
0.4750424027442932,
-0.27825528383255005,
-0.6784743070602417,
-0.3170028328895569,
-0.19070576131343842,
-1.285278081893921,
-0.2244347184896469,
-0.5489925146102905,
-0.30196478962898254,
0.437741756439209,
-0.3120250403881073,
-0.5960057377815247,
0.2030693143606186,
-0.691796600818634,
0.30396130681037903,
0.06216113269329071,
-0.03648623824119568,
-0.8076568841934204,
-0.6906888484954834,
0.14728352427482605,
-0.0757802426815033,
0.6677043437957764,
-0.5860540270805359,
0.1057242825627327,
0.975713849067688,
-0.2288062870502472,
0.7884379625320435,
0.20577843487262726,
0.35073888301849365,
0.6220346093177795,
-0.4659244120121002,
0.515424907207489,
0.1785285323858261,
-0.11468065530061722,
0.05045894533395767,
-0.4423181712627411,
-0.40382295846939087,
-0.251679390668869,
0.869858980178833,
-0.8480908274650574,
-0.9346364736557007,
-0.5041379332542419,
-0.7172021865844727,
0.41275882720947266,
0.16784271597862244,
0.3086925745010376,
0.6609132289886475,
-0.059310853481292725,
0.4242802858352661,
0.5955111384391785,
0.5304205417633057,
0.6675975322723389,
0.7716996669769287,
-0.24680188298225403,
-0.22718586027622223,
0.8493532538414001,
0.4895799458026886,
-0.09279314428567886,
0.7085050940513611,
0.5506331324577332,
0.14944180846214294,
-0.6117830872535706,
-0.12051860243082047,
0.08191593736410141,
-0.6679564714431763,
-0.30510348081588745,
-0.7149261236190796,
-0.3477061986923218,
-0.1919461041688919,
-0.467343270778656,
-0.33899739384651184,
-0.7340975403785706,
-0.7397213578224182,
-0.26593297719955444,
0.7575544714927673,
1.1444151401519775,
-0.3855445086956024,
0.5571877360343933,
-1.1399222612380981,
0.5271538496017456,
0.4721764326095581,
-0.03266409784555435,
-0.28330570459365845,
-0.1546061784029007,
-0.46608787775039673,
-0.4145040512084961,
-0.11987504363059998,
-0.8856341242790222,
0.15302559733390808,
0.16487476229667664,
0.6137290596961975,
1.0551289319992065,
0.24860318005084991,
0.5499769449234009,
-0.2429417222738266,
0.6425036787986755,
0.08336138725280762,
-0.640030562877655,
0.7043992280960083,
-0.615042507648468,
0.09429328888654709,
0.864741861820221,
0.6789384484291077,
-0.24144777655601501,
-0.3688008189201355,
-0.836503267288208,
-1.0687968730926514,
0.4354596436023712,
-0.17853155732154846,
-0.3573969304561615,
-0.18831767141819,
0.8466618657112122,
0.12389695644378662,
0.4498118758201599,
-0.7227652668952942,
-0.3386250138282776,
0.468246191740036,
-0.21358337998390198,
0.2257986217737198,
-0.7692369818687439,
-0.2876702845096588,
-0.42238903045654297,
0.24250014126300812,
0.22413022816181183,
0.19057577848434448,
0.3926087021827698,
0.00604292843490839,
-0.3480938673019409,
0.39064353704452515,
0.25332385301589966,
1.0257147550582886,
-0.26426780223846436,
0.14642345905303955,
0.0502939410507679,
-0.7519016265869141,
0.3185572922229767,
-0.3365858197212219,
-0.107955202460289,
0.15039098262786865,
0.37772709131240845,
0.4958897829055786,
0.5447746515274048,
-0.4368303418159485,
1.016278624534607,
0.03637184947729111,
0.07190025597810745,
-0.2675587832927704,
0.08024405688047409,
-0.022968122735619545,
0.4075225591659546,
0.6742611527442932,
0.11881224811077118,
0.4889037311077118,
-0.84839928150177,
0.08345745503902435,
-0.22134430706501007,
-0.6387413740158081,
-0.29847171902656555,
0.4505247473716736,
0.17459091544151306,
0.08062556385993958,
0.5163177847862244,
-0.08536966890096664,
-0.6192969679832458,
0.9987986087799072,
0.5327247977256775,
0.36318084597587585,
-0.3622342646121979,
0.174178808927536,
0.468323290348053,
0.2642088830471039,
-0.6050668954849243,
0.7085650563240051,
0.33425289392471313,
-0.2646251618862152,
-0.29056140780448914,
-0.17518550157546997,
-0.43546009063720703,
-0.2179284393787384,
-1.1207283735275269,
0.38162854313850403,
-0.3362305760383606,
-0.25854629278182983,
-0.3208077847957611,
-0.01204109750688076,
-0.4344988167285919,
0.4140694737434387,
-0.35513919591903687,
0.7437276840209961,
-1.0748026371002197,
0.3749546706676483,
0.6341336369514465,
0.23758865892887115,
-0.6853471398353577,
0.027265481650829315,
0.02736474759876728,
-0.9445865154266357,
0.5265881419181824,
0.32485276460647583,
0.6287140250205994,
0.0015539401210844517,
-0.5508671402931213,
-1.3822931051254272,
1.0257757902145386,
0.18855342268943787,
-0.9758274555206299,
0.14113911986351013,
0.029913948848843575,
0.10998887568712234,
-0.47764822840690613,
0.19580665230751038,
0.4335941672325134,
0.7578637003898621,
0.03232908621430397,
-0.5747504830360413,
-0.061549242585897446,
0.030593812465667725,
-0.6162013411521912,
0.5173973441123962,
-1.0850577354431152,
0.8819752931594849,
-0.6004524827003479,
-0.21121296286582947,
-0.38452965021133423,
0.8725741505622864,
-0.2960566282272339,
0.7196945548057556,
0.7487731575965881,
0.6899591088294983,
1.0636050701141357,
-0.18832938373088837,
0.7636107206344604,
-0.5730597972869873,
0.22148071229457855,
0.8353813886642456,
0.030849002301692963,
0.9755700826644897,
0.41913744807243347,
-0.18222445249557495,
0.3335965573787689,
0.8735448122024536,
0.24886327981948853,
0.9163246154785156,
-0.10462897270917892,
-0.4555230736732483,
-0.3200323283672333,
-0.47189778089523315,
-0.5837898254394531,
0.23502597212791443,
1.0503910779953003,
-0.2995464503765106,
-0.36680272221565247,
0.15948373079299927,
0.06759055703878403,
-0.22674454748630524,
-0.7656964659690857,
0.9165686368942261,
0.21777866780757904,
-0.34913602471351624,
-0.04390319064259529,
-0.4299186170101166,
0.19770291447639465,
-0.4485339820384979,
0.05322966352105141,
0.09474240243434906,
0.1976911723613739,
-0.48034143447875977,
-1.0684607028961182,
0.5651864409446716,
-0.4492660164833069,
-0.8248388767242432,
0.10083917528390884,
1.018263578414917,
-0.42151910066604614,
-0.5233670473098755,
0.31701740622520447,
0.5328375101089478,
0.37107419967651367,
-0.3617715537548065,
-0.41004759073257446,
0.1013854444026947,
-0.030835481360554695,
-0.443586140871048,
0.4498559236526489,
0.6428288221359253,
-0.13316260278224945,
0.3537687063217163,
0.6720812320709229,
0.19383487105369568,
-0.15259388089179993,
0.09536051005125046,
0.9502828121185303,
-0.8630616068840027,
-0.4307737946510315,
-0.595586895942688,
0.13585257530212402,
-0.2962741255760193,
-0.27307388186454773,
0.8675976991653442,
0.5635631084442139,
-0.08618691563606262,
0.24505575001239777,
0.40206193923950195,
0.0186179056763649,
0.943243682384491,
-0.5822501182556152,
0.7610856294631958,
-0.4554150700569153,
0.042146388441324234,
0.06269248574972153,
-0.7551677227020264,
-0.4341152012348175,
0.43546050786972046,
-0.3243677318096161,
-0.5377326011657715,
0.9073905348777771,
0.5622918605804443,
0.073837049305439,
0.23762120306491852,
0.16253453493118286,
0.609635591506958,
-0.0570976659655571,
0.2718046009540558,
0.8530765771865845,
-0.3056352138519287,
0.504513144493103,
-0.3289211094379425,
-0.5878438353538513,
-0.8714714050292969,
-1.1295939683914185,
-1.0700637102127075,
-0.515758752822876,
-0.6019396781921387,
-0.26588961482048035,
-0.09305621683597565,
0.7143736481666565,
0.7286630272865295,
-0.7381179332733154,
0.08000160753726959,
-0.1748572140932083,
0.7128576636314392,
-0.47088533639907837,
-0.2926187813282013,
0.7086568474769592,
-0.16515594720840454,
-0.4239371418952942,
0.34580197930336,
0.5482361316680908,
0.1419084221124649,
0.04680508002638817,
0.8247207403182983,
-0.0651063621044159,
-0.08704912662506104,
0.72774338722229,
0.18070875108242035,
-0.4492556154727936,
-0.34898504614830017,
-0.2822260558605194,
-0.22748194634914398,
0.30468443036079407,
0.9599804282188416,
-0.5234869122505188,
0.06160970777273178,
0.862220823764801,
0.3990470767021179,
0.1967764049768448,
-0.07905790209770203,
0.2500200867652893,
-0.6271111369132996,
0.5756558179855347,
-0.062295928597450256,
0.44961434602737427,
-0.028911961242556572,
-1.0940061807632446,
0.6225619912147522,
0.13642075657844543,
-0.9953041672706604,
-0.6897737979888916,
-0.11012179404497147,
-1.3912593126296997,
0.10907255858182907,
1.1429686546325684,
-0.17363432049751282,
-0.8449406027793884,
-0.4971180260181427,
-0.38625356554985046,
-0.18648897111415863,
-0.6200328469276428,
0.9121710658073425,
0.8328031301498413,
0.006097850855439901,
-0.1020231619477272,
-0.43554025888442993,
0.25241002440452576,
0.30475491285324097,
-0.9040908813476562,
-0.2839681804180145,
-0.2224736213684082,
-0.06001720577478409,
0.21648931503295898,
0.40282493829727173,
-0.04781239852309227,
0.3522857129573822,
-0.07712527364492416,
-0.4951736629009247,
0.4614832103252411,
-0.4979686737060547,
0.004446116276085377,
0.3980242908000946,
-0.052340343594551086,
0.14018723368644714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10294v1 | LAVE: LLM-Powered Agent Assistance and Language Augmentation for Video Editing | 2024-02-15T19:53:11 | 2024-02-15T19:53:11 | Bryan Wang, Yuliang Li, Zhaoyang Lv, Haijun Xia, Yan Xu, Raj Sodhi | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Video creation has become increasingly popular, yet the expertise and effort
required for editing often pose barriers to beginners. In this paper, we
explore the integration of large language models (LLMs) into the video editing
workflow to reduce these barriers. Our design vision is embodied in LAVE, a
novel system that provides LLM-powered agent assistance and language-augmented
editing features. LAVE automatically generates language descriptions for the
user's footage, serving as the foundation for enabling the LLM to process
videos and assist in editing tasks. When the user provides editing objectives,
the agent plans and executes relevant actions to fulfill them. Moreover, LAVE
allows users to edit videos through either the agent or direct UI manipulation,
providing flexibility and enabling manual refinement of agent actions. Our user
study, which included eight participants ranging from novices to proficient
editors, demonstrated LAVE's effectiveness. The results also shed light on user
perceptions of the proposed LLM-assisted editing paradigm and its impact on
users' creativity and sense of co-creation. Based on these findings, we propose
design implications to inform the future development of agent-assisted content
editing. | [
-0.39670488238334656,
-0.9290105700492859,
0.7155834436416626,
-0.06989387422800064,
-0.0797315239906311,
0.4151212275028229,
-0.40315601229667664,
-0.3987126648426056,
0.3135925233364105,
0.7577753067016602,
-0.661321759223938,
-0.5096836686134338,
-0.5433043837547302,
0.0609644316136837,
-0.4314434826374054,
0.6324194073677063,
-0.4301266074180603,
-0.04312967136502266,
-0.19660331308841705,
0.0787787064909935,
-0.6810235977172852,
-0.24987605214118958,
-0.5395104289054871,
-0.11064745485782623,
0.4387454092502594,
0.3820541203022003,
1.1716777086257935,
0.5514034628868103,
0.39606064558029175,
0.4296696186065674,
-0.052923619747161865,
0.6244183778762817,
-0.3672783076763153,
0.35206547379493713,
-0.3978107273578644,
-0.3529229462146759,
-1.0851441621780396,
-0.2763744294643402,
0.5949758291244507,
0.33484938740730286,
0.15934330224990845,
0.002410332439467311,
-0.0030465933959931135,
0.46294069290161133,
-0.46214085817337036,
-0.16550207138061523,
-0.407146155834198,
0.17130209505558014,
-0.013607694767415524,
-0.18220609426498413,
-0.1708804965019226,
0.015487920492887497,
-0.2989613115787506,
-0.7349839806556702,
0.1260976344347,
-0.43458205461502075,
0.3578488528728485,
0.8601595759391785,
0.012586954049766064,
-0.09244951605796814,
-0.9008229970932007,
0.24180720746517181,
-0.4117940068244934,
0.6018298864364624,
0.30905234813690186,
0.3985297679901123,
-0.17624518275260925,
-0.556259036064148,
-0.8492628335952759,
-0.01795976608991623,
0.3039029538631439,
-0.13808004558086395,
-0.24529847502708435,
0.3819064199924469,
0.24641664326190948,
0.23601675033569336,
-0.47054022550582886,
0.4444866478443146,
-0.1420382559299469,
-0.19886980950832367,
0.721673846244812,
0.23048123717308044,
0.6400607824325562,
0.03831128403544426,
0.12282843887805939,
0.047339312732219696,
-0.6304782629013062,
0.0576503612101078,
0.389096200466156,
0.12932950258255005,
0.03129442408680916,
0.9341795444488525,
-0.16733357310295105,
0.7305355072021484,
-0.002208011457696557,
-0.3386235237121582,
-0.014850950799882412,
-0.018965929746627808,
-0.656727135181427,
0.08504997938871384,
0.6914963722229004,
0.4771679937839508,
0.21686232089996338,
-0.08871310949325562,
-0.3255294859409332,
-0.036740873008966446,
0.1997222602367401,
-0.6594370007514954,
0.13008847832679749,
0.12237727642059326,
-0.0897522121667862,
-0.15646760165691376,
0.1500919759273529,
-0.39781254529953003,
-0.8671936392784119,
-0.2988963723182678,
0.5609768629074097,
0.035023365169763565,
-0.0958809033036232,
0.2907053828239441,
-0.018076304346323013,
0.01641499437391758,
0.8009290099143982,
-0.5651183724403381,
0.17880019545555115,
0.5572169423103333,
0.7372276186943054,
-0.0818382054567337,
-0.34276869893074036,
-1.0399284362792969,
0.3348364233970642,
-0.2571852505207062,
0.675434947013855,
-0.6027340888977051,
-0.5258981585502625,
0.254850834608078,
0.26327836513519287,
0.6699640154838562,
-0.4124476909637451,
0.3489025831222534,
-0.666543185710907,
-0.11944897472858429,
0.07983029633760452,
-0.39166179299354553,
0.04415889456868172,
-0.046552758663892746,
-0.8147875070571899,
0.7466933131217957,
0.039947692304849625,
-0.0815117135643959,
0.3104143440723419,
-0.6521704196929932,
-0.1841396987438202,
0.31197676062583923,
-0.2129424512386322,
-0.15430383384227753,
0.04612254723906517,
0.2597636878490448,
0.43467143177986145,
-0.13930024206638336,
0.20646433532238007,
-0.04869254305958748,
-0.21594148874282837,
0.41325613856315613,
-0.3426040709018707,
0.14571787416934967,
0.09865574538707733,
0.057243507355451584,
0.15253658592700958,
-0.5923998951911926,
-0.2717956602573395,
-0.20169195532798767,
-0.20594364404678345,
0.04439957067370415,
-0.21840177476406097,
0.08678902685642242,
0.23290960490703583,
0.27175667881965637,
-0.3453182280063629,
0.5306191444396973,
-0.1871280074119568,
0.19205564260482788,
0.8993088603019714,
0.06953126937150955,
0.8231431245803833,
-0.03183311969041824,
0.9251882433891296,
-0.6151763796806335,
0.13250157237052917,
-0.17912521958351135,
-0.16126352548599243,
-0.4529854357242584,
-0.3016390800476074,
-0.15699434280395508,
0.4908887445926666,
-1.0007741451263428,
0.13233226537704468,
-0.06495978683233261,
-0.31574779748916626,
-0.6244975924491882,
0.9565010666847229,
0.07665353268384933,
0.22298617660999298,
0.10670311003923416,
-0.22812579572200775,
-0.5973647236824036,
-0.7767578363418579,
0.053317565470933914,
0.016772497445344925,
-0.3408917784690857,
0.17545601725578308,
0.16500963270664215,
-0.20675228536128998,
1.0568580627441406,
-0.556935727596283,
-0.40349775552749634,
-0.4389236271381378,
-0.24580420553684235,
0.08177179843187332,
0.17025572061538696,
0.3335958421230316,
-0.6952014565467834,
-0.6005836129188538,
0.2564449906349182,
-0.9571577310562134,
-0.5157965421676636,
-0.13244563341140747,
-0.11708848178386688,
0.1313081979751587,
0.6068167686462402,
-0.6738729476928711,
0.5905589461326599,
0.4207984209060669,
-0.1930648386478424,
0.40198004245758057,
-0.5009129643440247,
0.2021438330411911,
-0.9689626693725586,
-0.5079308748245239,
-0.2501746714115143,
-0.3812059462070465,
-0.6325562000274658,
-0.04145145043730736,
-0.3098662793636322,
-0.19179396331310272,
-0.8151763677597046,
0.6260589361190796,
-0.4005763530731201,
-0.27772682905197144,
-0.6377387046813965,
0.3943803012371063,
0.2764102518558502,
0.34597110748291016,
0.297370046377182,
0.8189453482627869,
0.58592689037323,
-0.2899909019470215,
0.7571253180503845,
0.32299384474754333,
-0.32036805152893066,
0.7386772036552429,
-0.6605199575424194,
0.2840740382671356,
-0.20743346214294434,
0.08768898248672485,
-0.5742876529693604,
-0.4983835816383362,
0.21866632997989655,
-0.3735799491405487,
-0.033840879797935486,
-0.10979025065898895,
-0.5550361275672913,
-0.13180039823055267,
-0.18149815499782562,
0.36515992879867554,
0.40989258885383606,
-0.4832017123699188,
0.6888017654418945,
0.5080219507217407,
-0.38136953115463257,
-0.517052948474884,
-0.7591276168823242,
0.4861883819103241,
-0.14142192900180817,
-1.075710654258728,
0.5033129453659058,
-0.3019442558288574,
-0.5106366872787476,
0.08897428214550018,
0.13431744277477264,
-0.1053156703710556,
-0.20818136632442474,
0.42953354120254517,
0.2302907407283783,
0.09865183383226395,
0.2139323651790619,
0.021191274747252464,
0.2129092663526535,
-0.3400779068470001,
0.08002443611621857,
0.31640613079071045,
0.05469685420393944,
-0.24406698346138,
-0.513976514339447,
0.4816153645515442,
0.5536353588104248,
-0.5041266679763794,
0.42387112975120544,
0.5734596252441406,
-0.3132985830307007,
-0.30498629808425903,
-0.6402542591094971,
0.16511258482933044,
-0.5181365609169006,
0.6499196887016296,
-0.17141199111938477,
-1.0656715631484985,
0.5236919522285461,
0.10049699991941452,
-0.03261542692780495,
-0.027089936658740044,
0.7113053202629089,
-0.18414796888828278,
0.8240787386894226,
0.8392582535743713,
0.40492525696754456,
0.9482751488685608,
-0.467949241399765,
-0.030878793448209763,
-0.706331729888916,
-0.13795162737369537,
-0.1791323870420456,
-0.23856623470783234,
-0.32782915234565735,
-0.8200007081031799,
0.5046597123146057,
-0.08914770185947418,
-0.08625378459692001,
0.16977527737617493,
-0.24797114729881287,
0.812842071056366,
0.03659545257687569,
0.04289404675364494,
0.44876018166542053,
-0.08602947741746902,
0.2593664824962616,
-0.10232646018266678,
-0.5547816157341003,
-0.5952864289283752,
0.7635440826416016,
0.510159969329834,
1.0224791765213013,
0.34499213099479675,
0.576194703578949,
0.9468767046928406,
0.049824073910713196,
-0.9732622504234314,
0.8532930016517639,
-0.07076980173587799,
-0.11852803826332092,
-0.6220802664756775,
0.2997152507305145,
-0.638674259185791,
-0.0008624003967270255,
-0.4591013193130493,
-0.6413913369178772,
0.08666437864303589,
0.09735693782567978,
-0.44016751646995544,
0.4257689118385315,
-0.5117589235305786,
0.6065391898155212,
-0.39666447043418884,
-1.126277208328247,
-0.25600624084472656,
-0.1941007822751999,
0.16274091601371765,
-0.08313354849815369,
0.5379997491836548,
0.17094029486179352,
-0.2122706025838852,
0.40817052125930786,
-0.9369738698005676,
0.8113955855369568,
-0.18032757937908173,
-0.34490177035331726,
0.5413658022880554,
0.3334108293056488,
0.7520303726196289,
0.20884130895137787,
0.11608992516994476,
-0.3194316327571869,
-0.619895875453949,
0.034304577857255936,
-0.9518882036209106,
0.5593677759170532,
-0.7274305820465088,
-0.8595764636993408,
0.04364114627242088,
-0.6583088040351868,
0.01621326059103012,
0.10019584000110626,
-0.34685415029525757,
0.27608799934387207,
-0.28975746035575867,
0.10506375133991241,
0.5290673971176147,
-0.4197060763835907,
0.6140068173408508,
0.5557829737663269,
-0.5371476411819458,
-0.678795337677002,
0.6783633232116699,
0.03489800542593002,
0.3024342954158783,
0.18752062320709229,
-0.18276947736740112,
-0.04935578629374504,
-0.36873769760131836,
-0.6200798749923706,
0.15156491100788116,
-0.7824644446372986,
-0.03380632773041725,
-0.3688584566116333,
-0.16807757318019867,
-0.219608873128891,
-0.7299713492393494,
-0.44994479417800903,
-0.3157168924808502,
-0.17721837759017944,
-0.32674041390419006,
0.40354031324386597,
0.901190996170044,
-0.1733495146036148,
0.5784617066383362,
-0.8101014494895935,
0.5399136543273926,
0.7143529653549194,
0.33998236060142517,
-0.33859920501708984,
-0.4932846128940582,
-0.6708935499191284,
-0.23522518575191498,
-0.2688426673412323,
-0.9507960677146912,
0.408462792634964,
0.16025681793689728,
0.5259827971458435,
0.2196069061756134,
-0.4143263101577759,
0.4726228713989258,
-0.5453633666038513,
0.972407877445221,
0.02312476374208927,
-0.8762860298156738,
0.5007821321487427,
-0.3380046486854553,
0.30082982778549194,
0.1335480660200119,
-0.1606525182723999,
-0.6165064573287964,
-0.34786665439605713,
-0.21032585203647614,
-0.5493786334991455,
0.5015876889228821,
0.09859919548034668,
0.1409405767917633,
0.2481287121772766,
0.24686872959136963,
0.20632246136665344,
0.20954833924770355,
-0.581208348274231,
0.1227540448307991,
-0.2122669816017151,
0.1635638028383255,
-0.11844612658023834,
-0.07848561555147171,
0.07776234298944473,
-0.06518487632274628,
0.5489182472229004,
-0.06042013689875603,
-0.11817719042301178,
0.2745873034000397,
-0.4385095238685608,
-0.49157509207725525,
0.5114748477935791,
0.5510920882225037,
0.461513489484787,
-0.16834643483161926,
-0.07011806964874268,
0.19152402877807617,
-0.36454644799232483,
0.3710794746875763,
-0.0663638487458229,
-0.20092123746871948,
-0.03411373496055603,
0.3452274203300476,
0.9506494402885437,
-0.10485156625509262,
-1.000238060951233,
0.2813898026943207,
0.03334526717662811,
-0.33561816811561584,
-0.3778303265571594,
0.21500596404075623,
-0.1152803897857666,
0.597767174243927,
0.19666051864624023,
-0.07729673385620117,
0.08728396147489548,
-0.4266153872013092,
-0.006419114302843809,
0.6318616271018982,
-0.1211678758263588,
-0.3416118025779724,
0.7111788392066956,
0.34051987528800964,
-1.0320711135864258,
0.0307993832975626,
-0.03156371787190437,
-0.2639332711696625,
0.30584102869033813,
0.13340701162815094,
1.0820164680480957,
-0.15396006405353546,
0.5139902234077454,
-0.030119257047772408,
0.2718881070613861,
0.05911107361316681,
0.083815798163414,
-0.14342138171195984,
-0.686517059803009,
-0.9005406498908997,
-0.584743082523346,
-0.5191832780838013,
0.14322376251220703,
-0.25593578815460205,
0.6031308174133301,
-0.24883438646793365,
-0.23522451519966125,
-0.059388332068920135,
-0.3171687424182892,
-0.8155031800270081,
0.10460614413022995,
0.30293339490890503,
0.8263342380523682,
-0.7670886516571045,
0.9020757675170898,
1.0018513202667236,
-0.604291558265686,
-0.6041762828826904,
-0.39980265498161316,
-0.019087864086031914,
-0.6132662296295166,
0.5871421694755554,
-0.21441513299942017,
-0.3583226501941681,
-0.3625575304031372,
-0.3732476234436035,
-0.45436134934425354,
1.0910534858703613,
0.5456153154373169,
-0.44949859380722046,
-0.2923182249069214,
0.6438566446304321,
0.7708566188812256,
-0.47992244362831116,
-0.01284706499427557,
0.5368677973747253,
0.3322110176086426,
0.32491540908813477,
-0.9867576360702515,
-0.38356494903564453,
-0.18799328804016113,
-0.1641998440027237,
0.06527627259492874,
-0.5808831453323364,
0.6341034770011902,
-0.22085483372211456,
0.2434040606021881,
-0.08478645980358124,
0.5127902626991272,
-0.08839862048625946,
0.28174349665641785,
0.4482792615890503,
0.2639465928077698,
0.5114158391952515,
0.42355918884277344,
0.6363595724105835,
-0.09908547252416611,
-0.20330430567264557,
1.2474905252456665,
-0.09314337372779846,
0.667827308177948,
0.6451055407524109,
-0.1206444725394249,
0.5448929667472839,
0.18236437439918518,
0.21733629703521729,
0.22670875489711761,
-0.030580926686525345,
-0.6474882364273071,
-0.49124017357826233,
-0.532291054725647,
-0.0563335157930851,
0.7247068881988525,
0.2804092466831207,
-0.41186094284057617,
0.02948041446506977,
0.3147986829280853,
0.039812881499528885,
0.4543081820011139,
-0.7412335276603699,
0.8205680251121521,
-0.03800322487950325,
-0.4996728301048279,
0.2771468758583069,
-0.10679831355810165,
0.28654810786247253,
-0.5289900898933411,
-0.23916849493980408,
-0.2122023105621338,
-0.030653806403279305,
-0.41238293051719666,
-1.1417468786239624,
0.19583387672901154,
0.5993074178695679,
-0.06519678980112076,
-0.4613812267780304,
0.8272426724433899,
-0.6312849521636963,
-0.3276577591896057,
0.12105482071638107,
0.7350496053695679,
0.15782169997692108,
-0.08684548735618591,
-0.2739807665348053,
0.5252988338470459,
-0.13329817354679108,
-0.08609432727098465,
0.21383608877658844,
0.3086986541748047,
-0.20490805804729462,
0.5399328470230103,
0.3855310082435608,
0.21794092655181885,
-0.3347305655479431,
0.27368614077568054,
0.825741171836853,
-0.40740808844566345,
-0.49807900190353394,
-0.9170342087745667,
0.9048664569854736,
0.07559208571910858,
0.43990278244018555,
0.47828343510627747,
0.370710164308548,
0.7594950199127197,
-0.24635440111160278,
1.1354084014892578,
-0.045388538390398026,
-0.11152930557727814,
-0.6112801432609558,
0.3614431321620941,
-0.7153237462043762,
0.40789034962654114,
-0.5503197908401489,
-1.0433927774429321,
-0.2742144763469696,
0.18929408490657806,
-0.29292604327201843,
-0.30220577120780945,
0.24326810240745544,
1.0777617692947388,
0.12614648044109344,
-0.42056262493133545,
0.6193562746047974,
0.2676662504673004,
0.603571891784668,
0.41846132278442383,
0.91144859790802,
-0.04467717930674553,
0.5809236764907837,
-0.22604718804359436,
-0.15306343138217926,
-0.09935514628887177,
-0.9386146068572998,
-1.0067893266677856,
-0.36070069670677185,
-0.05479661002755165,
-0.10820125043392181,
0.05571693554520607,
1.2316821813583374,
0.36729079484939575,
-0.11694331467151642,
-0.4227263331413269,
0.09184975177049637,
0.2698766589164734,
0.07204387336969376,
-0.11055508255958557,
0.18074136972427368,
0.2345598042011261,
-0.994965136051178,
0.7002436518669128,
0.5422689318656921,
0.10768406838178635,
-0.6555887460708618,
-0.617803692817688,
0.14627449214458466,
0.1978282779455185,
0.7083090543746948,
0.44672608375549316,
-0.7792856693267822,
-0.3529664874076843,
0.1205085963010788,
0.2054051011800766,
0.03598276898264885,
0.707461953163147,
-0.7020471096038818,
0.9509420990943909,
0.46472951769828796,
0.7152723670005798,
0.373183935880661,
-0.0037698992528021336,
0.7115615010261536,
-0.6728474497795105,
0.4135740101337433,
-0.2583257853984833,
0.2747035324573517,
0.5106162428855896,
-0.4818340539932251,
0.4375617802143097,
0.04463401809334755,
-0.5484892725944519,
-0.905106782913208,
0.253347784280777,
-1.0435534715652466,
0.10781395435333252,
1.0408483743667603,
0.14188142120838165,
-0.13948646187782288,
0.20580071210861206,
-0.8417050838470459,
0.3640548288822174,
-0.38911738991737366,
0.4093192517757416,
0.7428073883056641,
-0.28510209918022156,
-0.4625439941883087,
-0.740977942943573,
0.4863123595714569,
0.04717398062348366,
-0.7815050482749939,
0.05752705782651901,
0.8244715332984924,
-0.036216653883457184,
-0.14493396878242493,
0.6422330141067505,
0.289634108543396,
0.7283580303192139,
-0.28094497323036194,
0.46760615706443787,
-0.6405863165855408,
-0.4568045437335968,
-0.4483909010887146,
0.2023613154888153,
0.4628971517086029,
0.19270417094230652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10210v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10210v1 | Self-Play Fine-Tuning of Diffusion Models for Text-to-Image Generation | 2024-02-15T18:59:18 | 2024-02-15T18:59:18 | Huizhuo Yuan, Zixiang Chen, Kaixuan Ji, Quanquan Gu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Fine-tuning Diffusion Models remains an underexplored frontier in generative
artificial intelligence (GenAI), especially when compared with the remarkable
progress made in fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs). While cutting-edge
diffusion models such as Stable Diffusion (SD) and SDXL rely on supervised
fine-tuning, their performance inevitably plateaus after seeing a certain
volume of data. Recently, reinforcement learning (RL) has been employed to
fine-tune diffusion models with human preference data, but it requires at least
two images ("winner" and "loser" images) for each text prompt. In this paper,
we introduce an innovative technique called self-play fine-tuning for diffusion
models (SPIN-Diffusion), where the diffusion model engages in competition with
its earlier versions, facilitating an iterative self-improvement process. Our
approach offers an alternative to conventional supervised fine-tuning and RL
strategies, significantly improving both model performance and alignment. Our
experiments on the Pick-a-Pic dataset reveal that SPIN-Diffusion outperforms
the existing supervised fine-tuning method in aspects of human preference
alignment and visual appeal right from its first iteration. By the second
iteration, it exceeds the performance of RLHF-based methods across all metrics,
achieving these results with less data. | [
-0.6092151403427124,
-0.8270281553268433,
0.7350356578826904,
0.07996165752410889,
-0.38031336665153503,
0.01770535483956337,
-0.2382524162530899,
-0.037552982568740845,
0.059768520295619965,
0.4862156808376312,
-0.8096886873245239,
-0.5129345655441284,
-0.5524190068244934,
0.011615628376603127,
-0.17651233077049255,
1.021889328956604,
0.053710367530584335,
-0.09539493918418884,
-0.18908478319644928,
-0.11354366689920425,
-0.4923067092895508,
0.26717039942741394,
-1.1267892122268677,
-0.4748958349227905,
0.6933585405349731,
0.6315982341766357,
0.7629421353340149,
0.7091448903083801,
0.1652631014585495,
0.28682607412338257,
-0.0929216742515564,
0.5399429798126221,
-0.46885010600090027,
0.2817232310771942,
-0.44834256172180176,
-0.24662084877490997,
-0.08709380030632019,
0.1935824155807495,
0.41272425651550293,
0.1689167618751526,
-0.2663618326187134,
-0.0035328578669577837,
0.08829650282859802,
1.2368276119232178,
-0.4948919713497162,
-0.20558501780033112,
-0.47193291783332825,
0.2925969958305359,
-0.03778856620192528,
-0.43085867166519165,
-0.38168594241142273,
-0.3179329037666321,
0.08024386316537857,
-0.8125198483467102,
0.47334614396095276,
0.2558151185512543,
0.7887014746665955,
0.43530017137527466,
-0.27439814805984497,
-0.28102147579193115,
-0.7605730295181274,
0.5801733136177063,
-0.6766025424003601,
-0.005796033423393965,
0.24790789186954498,
0.18175427615642548,
-0.24472132325172424,
-0.2738547921180725,
-0.47405076026916504,
-0.07015056908130646,
0.0808829814195633,
0.21408160030841827,
-0.07630143314599991,
-0.058114368468523026,
0.01799551397562027,
0.13764433562755585,
-0.3632473349571228,
0.33854344487190247,
-0.23502738773822784,
0.14237971603870392,
0.7337104678153992,
0.09835498780012131,
0.35244596004486084,
-0.11884939670562744,
-0.15973946452140808,
-0.2964960038661957,
-0.6506256461143494,
-0.034083642065525055,
0.433511883020401,
0.40280547738075256,
-0.048674702644348145,
0.4498600661754608,
-0.33548516035079956,
0.6627979278564453,
0.7912700176239014,
0.08592956513166428,
0.15275931358337402,
-0.0608648881316185,
-0.08821520209312439,
-0.04046718031167984,
1.0560907125473022,
0.3981308937072754,
0.31876593828201294,
-0.052771277725696564,
-0.19451379776000977,
-0.19131961464881897,
0.22166575491428375,
-0.8342880606651306,
-0.539607048034668,
-0.028922520577907562,
-0.716956615447998,
-0.6603140830993652,
-0.44022291898727417,
-0.9334477782249451,
-0.5504863858222961,
-0.24045151472091675,
0.6791845560073853,
-0.41346609592437744,
-0.3366389274597168,
0.009264178574085236,
-0.13772930204868317,
-0.03389503061771393,
0.4158828556537628,
-1.0748473405838013,
-0.006138104945421219,
0.3149753510951996,
0.957573413848877,
-0.7132830619812012,
-0.22964295744895935,
-0.4846141040325165,
-0.004644285887479782,
-0.7790267467498779,
1.1755194664001465,
-0.40011903643608093,
-0.4881812632083893,
-0.1571435034275055,
-0.34204089641571045,
0.07161690294742584,
-0.6229125261306763,
0.2727660834789276,
-0.6422894597053528,
0.465136855840683,
-0.04200787469744682,
-0.621877133846283,
0.09441913664340973,
0.13123859465122223,
-0.47037094831466675,
0.8355163335800171,
-0.09460500627756119,
-0.5755826234817505,
0.5553280115127563,
-0.7608314156532288,
-0.6282290816307068,
-0.0790109783411026,
-0.28893133997917175,
-0.8186810612678528,
0.2842453718185425,
0.45912420749664307,
0.5699116587638855,
-0.1551559716463089,
0.15026327967643738,
-0.4218546450138092,
-0.1993083506822586,
0.06519988924264908,
-0.5513079762458801,
0.28241464495658875,
0.38204851746559143,
-0.3433902859687805,
0.35234618186950684,
-0.7408746480941772,
-0.026807470247149467,
0.3293783962726593,
-0.10177662968635559,
-0.26267939805984497,
0.25517910718917847,
0.012947970069944859,
0.37422072887420654,
0.04160236194729805,
-0.3505193591117859,
0.3065791428089142,
-0.31026268005371094,
0.3821101188659668,
0.9174798130989075,
0.019328361377120018,
0.9418167471885681,
-0.30048561096191406,
0.4884975850582123,
0.22890299558639526,
0.11363136023283005,
-0.21913065016269684,
-0.45921629667282104,
-0.647486686706543,
-0.25701892375946045,
0.49333667755126953,
0.22056595981121063,
-0.7418313026428223,
0.24408981204032898,
0.06219141557812691,
-0.3526453375816345,
-0.6777411103248596,
0.24487891793251038,
0.21211354434490204,
0.706318199634552,
0.45186448097229004,
-0.26619747281074524,
0.068998321890831,
-0.8122655153274536,
-0.12287720292806625,
0.28408291935920715,
0.1512380838394165,
0.5843526124954224,
0.11502554267644882,
-0.1627281755208969,
0.9454279541969299,
-0.5376819968223572,
-0.5771376490592957,
-0.10734793543815613,
0.7256468534469604,
0.06199421361088753,
0.623645544052124,
0.4912935495376587,
-0.7065154910087585,
-0.620940625667572,
-0.04543351009488106,
-0.47041288018226624,
0.04015830531716347,
-0.3756924569606781,
-0.1625247448682785,
0.40027332305908203,
0.5416028499603271,
-0.322760671377182,
0.42390841245651245,
0.5903559923171997,
-0.6353845000267029,
0.4390332102775574,
-0.805574357509613,
0.4197513163089752,
-0.8268837928771973,
-0.22666294872760773,
0.2658628523349762,
-0.3306255042552948,
-0.3532346785068512,
-0.11846233904361725,
0.07398921996355057,
-0.02430601231753826,
-0.2641923725605011,
0.6860030889511108,
-0.3743118643760681,
-0.003797776298597455,
-0.6421108245849609,
0.09681648761034012,
-0.1449567973613739,
0.32792019844055176,
0.2454981654882431,
1.0417537689208984,
0.7359760403633118,
-0.8494969606399536,
-0.18597717583179474,
0.13864922523498535,
-0.3932356536388397,
0.711422860622406,
-0.6003983020782471,
0.04806520417332649,
-0.41649937629699707,
0.1195911392569542,
-1.199480652809143,
-0.11978524178266525,
0.23816481232643127,
-0.3155575394630432,
0.4232911467552185,
-0.18094591796398163,
-0.3735859990119934,
-0.08150390535593033,
-0.10488617420196533,
0.4557623267173767,
0.7011054158210754,
-0.8265650272369385,
0.7172142267227173,
0.05689380690455437,
0.021462196484208107,
-0.3100375235080719,
-0.3184455931186676,
-0.04134761542081833,
-0.44956719875335693,
-0.5343512296676636,
0.5243338346481323,
-0.23959924280643463,
0.41832274198532104,
-0.04190696403384209,
0.10901517421007156,
0.18019214272499084,
0.1448979675769806,
0.07503477483987808,
0.06754998862743378,
0.06333590298891068,
0.08585795760154724,
0.4814209043979645,
-0.3561915457248688,
-0.2606395483016968,
-0.22186926007270813,
0.5256963968276978,
0.2540379464626312,
-0.13808345794677734,
-0.6833552718162537,
0.17522652447223663,
0.24871818721294403,
-0.2012292742729187,
0.47321248054504395,
0.7349281907081604,
0.16696226596832275,
-0.466181218624115,
-0.4024108052253723,
-0.11084349453449249,
-0.5721344351768494,
-0.022159729152917862,
-0.3871540129184723,
-1.0140798091888428,
0.2867847979068756,
-0.4261561632156372,
-0.09530571848154068,
0.5415993332862854,
0.47521117329597473,
-0.7653254270553589,
1.5243849754333496,
0.614469587802887,
0.09346417337656021,
0.8362818956375122,
-0.29367363452911377,
-0.07412008196115494,
-0.7075476050376892,
0.023241456598043442,
-0.2033667266368866,
-0.5810686349868774,
-0.7381258010864258,
-0.3352624475955963,
0.4223583936691284,
0.023743966594338417,
-0.36637064814567566,
0.005463447421789169,
-0.6358475089073181,
0.654456377029419,
0.7105855941772461,
0.3801022469997406,
0.2919028401374817,
0.16146442294120789,
-0.1984267383813858,
-0.010494474321603775,
-0.7499128580093384,
-0.21533632278442383,
0.9595049023628235,
0.24210768938064575,
1.0451453924179077,
-0.06385855376720428,
1.0924310684204102,
0.6348022818565369,
0.07337154448032379,
-0.4931897521018982,
0.4348307251930237,
-0.481400728225708,
-0.3481598198413849,
-0.5567200779914856,
-0.47681480646133423,
-0.9549655914306641,
0.09733643382787704,
-0.5975154042243958,
-0.2274782508611679,
0.2468763291835785,
0.7079131007194519,
-0.617240309715271,
0.09340879321098328,
-0.5615091919898987,
0.8501812219619751,
-0.20527079701423645,
-0.5256769061088562,
-0.5619479417800903,
-0.23267410695552826,
0.17283907532691956,
0.16647158563137054,
0.11573801189661026,
-0.2000168114900589,
0.19691945612430573,
0.46911296248435974,
0.1301296055316925,
0.7136815190315247,
-0.1993158906698227,
-0.197524294257164,
-0.023076578974723816,
0.39289167523384094,
0.45058533549308777,
0.03447351232171059,
0.15165719389915466,
-0.22615230083465576,
-0.2599920630455017,
-0.27382034063339233,
-0.6821720004081726,
0.6817668676376343,
-0.739568293094635,
-0.5329369306564331,
-0.31683871150016785,
-0.30856913328170776,
-0.1344883143901825,
0.2634654939174652,
0.5842112302780151,
0.2217959761619568,
-0.24413837492465973,
-0.13863395154476166,
1.126369595527649,
-0.23256948590278625,
0.46366021037101746,
0.28791624307632446,
-0.3126034438610077,
-0.4727284908294678,
1.100313425064087,
-0.09653402119874954,
0.3019125461578369,
0.08950042724609375,
0.5222648978233337,
-0.32586467266082764,
-0.6712082028388977,
-0.7299945950508118,
0.1317276805639267,
-0.2936030924320221,
-0.3024958670139313,
-0.4365367889404297,
-0.11199309676885605,
-0.23917223513126373,
-0.2681463658809662,
-0.5701779127120972,
-0.3053508698940277,
-0.834565281867981,
0.22617501020431519,
0.34609565138816833,
0.8859121799468994,
-0.28019800782203674,
0.4602794349193573,
-0.425570547580719,
0.5940408706665039,
0.534773588180542,
0.6717451810836792,
0.03486352041363716,
-0.6953931450843811,
-0.11798334121704102,
-0.0860321894288063,
-0.33659666776657104,
-0.6628194451332092,
0.4045211672782898,
0.30455151200294495,
0.2144342064857483,
0.5867617726325989,
-0.18378044664859772,
0.7086478471755981,
-0.8513827919960022,
0.5931496620178223,
0.4347139596939087,
-0.5648860931396484,
0.7725618481636047,
-0.5523169636726379,
0.3246302008628845,
0.5908981561660767,
0.08285130560398102,
-0.38024091720581055,
-0.21115094423294067,
-0.6336917877197266,
-0.6852221488952637,
0.6179017424583435,
0.017212357372045517,
0.17788317799568176,
-0.024673765525221825,
0.47019240260124207,
0.0385163314640522,
-0.016037654131650925,
-0.5282256603240967,
-0.2899089753627777,
-0.14599156379699707,
-0.3499181568622589,
-0.2510286271572113,
-0.1117190420627594,
-0.16208718717098236,
-0.19144968688488007,
0.6985135078430176,
-0.33683550357818604,
0.13567790389060974,
0.20971542596817017,
0.044173985719680786,
-0.24379278719425201,
0.12901611626148224,
0.5457851886749268,
0.18377332389354706,
0.06335166841745377,
-0.1266334056854248,
-0.1830117106437683,
0.07925036549568176,
0.30136963725090027,
-0.001623883261345327,
-0.7255457043647766,
-0.41360363364219666,
-0.2919290363788605,
0.9065570831298828,
0.05412212386727333,
-0.42417624592781067,
0.39654749631881714,
-0.20992402732372284,
-0.3963964879512787,
-0.10030514746904373,
0.48089852929115295,
-0.016150156036019325,
0.477395623922348,
0.2173871248960495,
0.300916463136673,
0.43990805745124817,
-0.32967549562454224,
0.23182080686092377,
0.7499476671218872,
-0.34019193053245544,
0.11730651557445526,
0.8430637121200562,
0.20815181732177734,
-0.3892936110496521,
0.4501284956932068,
-0.4765462279319763,
-0.1292717009782791,
0.5022256374359131,
0.648754358291626,
0.901641309261322,
0.03975716978311539,
0.8758468627929688,
0.4701962172985077,
-0.07904340326786041,
-0.5416638851165771,
0.05499826744198799,
-0.20397602021694183,
-0.8092732429504395,
-0.2217995673418045,
-0.3130195438861847,
-0.20199355483055115,
-0.2959509789943695,
-0.4311528205871582,
0.0611446313560009,
-0.5549641847610474,
-0.25768205523490906,
-0.007678886875510216,
-0.16308675706386566,
-0.6922481656074524,
0.31637313961982727,
0.32414260506629944,
0.7047463655471802,
-0.9284175634384155,
0.6544202566146851,
0.408133864402771,
-0.28845757246017456,
-0.4132309854030609,
0.09225475043058395,
-0.28701677918434143,
-0.4879358112812042,
0.5022331476211548,
0.007669944316148758,
-0.357782781124115,
0.316916286945343,
-0.7867285013198853,
-0.93370121717453,
1.1351932287216187,
-0.01229012943804264,
-0.5027205944061279,
-0.03452473133802414,
-0.16249695420265198,
0.5904453992843628,
-0.6018486022949219,
0.21665583550930023,
0.6077354550361633,
0.2714066803455353,
0.23504292964935303,
-0.3748548924922943,
-0.27801278233528137,
0.10889046639204025,
0.42831215262413025,
0.0873962938785553,
-0.8928275108337402,
0.43816912174224854,
-0.37989136576652527,
-0.3030995726585388,
0.1476735919713974,
1.0522263050079346,
0.4092370271682739,
0.28702715039253235,
0.7169668078422546,
0.7278674244880676,
0.5227290391921997,
0.046770207583904266,
0.5816437602043152,
-0.062147147953510284,
0.3801664113998413,
1.2680518627166748,
-0.05086999014019966,
0.7636080384254456,
0.3370993435382843,
0.17216695845127106,
0.6161331534385681,
0.6221218705177307,
-0.13989172875881195,
0.9414957761764526,
0.028803709894418716,
0.06123112514615059,
-0.609987199306488,
0.14243194460868835,
0.06142974644899368,
0.3187144100666046,
0.2614617943763733,
-0.4010889530181885,
-0.27876558899879456,
0.18780027329921722,
-0.2399626076221466,
0.4071740508079529,
-0.30983948707580566,
0.984024703502655,
-0.36557433009147644,
-0.843886137008667,
0.08603455126285553,
0.01925671100616455,
1.0704429149627686,
-0.2900019884109497,
-0.15953819453716278,
-0.41971251368522644,
0.027934158220887184,
-0.03086077980697155,
-1.0017327070236206,
-0.07664214819669724,
-0.11742033064365387,
-0.34674733877182007,
-0.3728587329387665,
0.7005396485328674,
-0.544426441192627,
-0.5053660869598389,
0.2251417487859726,
0.3311486840248108,
-0.3338782489299774,
0.13873471319675446,
-0.9998549818992615,
-0.2217712253332138,
-0.004912628326565027,
-0.29865574836730957,
0.47209829092025757,
0.37596407532691956,
0.2895292639732361,
0.8869699835777283,
0.5034762024879456,
0.031732819974422455,
-0.009818902239203453,
0.10711240768432617,
0.6265643835067749,
-0.5672181248664856,
-0.5441449880599976,
-0.7114018201828003,
0.3784082531929016,
-0.16214387118816376,
-0.5327892303466797,
0.4045780599117279,
0.3984438180923462,
0.6655178666114807,
-0.1111500933766365,
0.6329473257064819,
-0.010273748077452183,
0.5371691584587097,
-0.6252891421318054,
0.8947353959083557,
-0.8303217887878418,
-0.17039261758327484,
-0.296089231967926,
-0.4885927140712738,
-0.12220439314842224,
0.8429081439971924,
-0.12100563198328018,
0.22136874496936798,
0.2547243535518646,
0.781351625919342,
-0.24625025689601898,
-0.26760250329971313,
0.3723529875278473,
-0.017305942252278328,
0.27300071716308594,
0.21156436204910278,
0.710800290107727,
-0.30805620551109314,
0.2914857566356659,
-0.35902470350265503,
-0.3110707700252533,
-0.09035854786634445,
-1.0786499977111816,
-0.9421905875205994,
-0.6123208999633789,
-0.49406567215919495,
-0.43274566531181335,
0.12513947486877441,
0.8542289733886719,
0.8115425705909729,
-0.6486257314682007,
-0.07972551882266998,
-0.28124311566352844,
0.05657445639371872,
-0.3816397786140442,
-0.21310563385486603,
0.3730839788913727,
-0.7423081994056702,
-0.6436510682106018,
0.3690117597579956,
0.26886293292045593,
0.1585521399974823,
-0.37138471007347107,
-0.1583688110113144,
-0.10773101449012756,
0.1899077147245407,
0.45694294571876526,
0.37129905819892883,
-0.4774312674999237,
-0.06609763950109482,
-0.059135064482688904,
-0.0721815899014473,
0.32134875655174255,
0.642747700214386,
-0.9089363217353821,
0.5662875175476074,
0.3401481807231903,
0.5678039193153381,
0.7486005425453186,
0.21100416779518127,
0.5003870725631714,
-0.5080845952033997,
-0.2085789144039154,
-0.010312873870134354,
-0.0172544214874506,
0.20059093832969666,
-0.4064585864543915,
0.2742563486099243,
-0.040131356567144394,
-0.8255221247673035,
-0.2544422745704651,
0.3971237242221832,
-0.7035432457923889,
-0.3935118019580841,
1.0587201118469238,
0.2716253697872162,
-0.17852306365966797,
0.3149900436401367,
-0.3591305911540985,
0.18013273179531097,
-0.5995304584503174,
1.2639282941818237,
0.4612654447555542,
-0.36833178997039795,
-0.47506222128868103,
-0.15290942788124084,
0.9349392056465149,
0.5902976989746094,
-0.7658919095993042,
-0.03819475695490837,
0.693295419216156,
0.5084466338157654,
-0.066199392080307,
0.777694821357727,
0.073895663022995,
0.43003660440444946,
-0.4643600583076477,
-0.08413825184106827,
0.044559743255376816,
-0.6717721223831177,
-0.5830926895141602,
-0.04418780654668808,
0.11331314593553543,
-0.12204760313034058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10208v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10208v2 | Recovering the Pre-Fine-Tuning Weights of Generative Models | 2024-02-15T18:59:02 | 2024-07-01T12:48:51 | Eliahu Horwitz, Jonathan Kahana, Yedid Hoshen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | The dominant paradigm in generative modeling consists of two steps: i)
pre-training on a large-scale but unsafe dataset, ii) aligning the pre-trained
model with human values via fine-tuning. This practice is considered safe, as
no current method can recover the unsafe, pre-fine-tuning model weights. In
this paper, we demonstrate that this assumption is often false. Concretely, we
present Spectral DeTuning, a method that can recover the weights of the
pre-fine-tuning model using a few low-rank (LoRA) fine-tuned models. In
contrast to previous attacks that attempt to recover pre-fine-tuning
capabilities, our method aims to recover the exact pre-fine-tuning weights. Our
approach exploits this new vulnerability against large-scale models such as a
personalized Stable Diffusion and an aligned Mistral. | [
-0.5750956535339355,
-0.5477378368377686,
-0.011515436694025993,
-0.3769088089466095,
-0.31801196932792664,
0.06882621347904205,
-0.07797123491764069,
-0.5218663811683655,
-0.08119236677885056,
0.7285279035568237,
-0.7212642431259155,
-0.3564426600933075,
-0.5748914480209351,
-0.2258402556180954,
-0.6059220433235168,
1.1153039932250977,
0.3450753688812256,
-0.025179948657751083,
0.21320204436779022,
0.23114661872386932,
-0.36426496505737305,
-0.40753740072250366,
-0.7915281057357788,
-0.014752949588000774,
0.8514403700828552,
0.2381083369255066,
0.5778168439865112,
0.3467027246952057,
0.5691627264022827,
0.33975890278816223,
0.053822074085474014,
0.21991050243377686,
-1.0044347047805786,
0.07590760290622711,
-0.05567069724202156,
-0.8008100986480713,
-0.5225841403007507,
0.39105021953582764,
0.42598840594291687,
0.6563427448272705,
-0.19024790823459625,
0.1745937466621399,
0.3930855393409729,
0.9651573300361633,
-0.9820818305015564,
-0.43304216861724854,
-0.9832865595817566,
0.15055011212825775,
-0.3861440122127533,
-0.23589985072612762,
-0.5636779069900513,
-0.6433311104774475,
-0.2091057449579239,
-0.6417410969734192,
0.4452458918094635,
-0.09479758143424988,
1.0703747272491455,
0.7451006174087524,
-0.32113391160964966,
0.4466175436973572,
-1.0577092170715332,
0.6964656114578247,
-0.40751245617866516,
0.04047449678182602,
0.7205523252487183,
0.5908970832824707,
0.0702546238899231,
-0.8030574917793274,
-0.09631916135549545,
0.07017819583415985,
0.19164663553237915,
0.1466420441865921,
-0.3631136119365692,
0.14012421667575836,
0.40345460176467896,
0.4754244387149811,
-0.1284395456314087,
0.5164073705673218,
-0.37905412912368774,
-0.06957463920116425,
0.5609516501426697,
0.13331377506256104,
0.061911098659038544,
-0.07007094472646713,
-0.4992001950740814,
-0.28024211525917053,
-1.0965142250061035,
-0.24003998935222626,
0.7545816898345947,
0.7002176642417908,
-0.1911342740058899,
0.43090304732322693,
0.11497321724891663,
0.772985577583313,
0.4996086061000824,
0.16785715520381927,
0.07992174476385117,
-0.37186646461486816,
-0.4202026426792145,
0.09959511458873749,
0.5151302218437195,
0.12253300100564957,
0.510096549987793,
-0.14477317035198212,
-0.08729061484336853,
0.1790369153022766,
0.6846162676811218,
-0.6378870010375977,
-0.44008785486221313,
0.08093272894620895,
-0.5988705158233643,
-0.7343465685844421,
-0.07109977304935455,
-0.7911165356636047,
-0.48425933718681335,
-0.42677196860313416,
0.6940027475357056,
-0.432894766330719,
-0.3606082499027252,
-0.018375296145677567,
0.10016857087612152,
0.24831622838974,
0.3868471682071686,
-1.0603458881378174,
0.10766914486885071,
0.6701099276542664,
0.5037765502929688,
0.06815090775489807,
-0.00972041767090559,
-0.4112258851528168,
0.072684146463871,
-0.43285006284713745,
0.4932418763637543,
-0.24559985101222992,
-0.5011429190635681,
-0.23717793822288513,
-0.027623968198895454,
-0.005691093858331442,
-0.6219177842140198,
0.5244078636169434,
-0.7226603031158447,
-0.31001293659210205,
-0.6405684947967529,
-0.26784026622772217,
0.11613094806671143,
0.1697828471660614,
-0.7181786298751831,
0.6181296110153198,
0.06631746888160706,
-0.983363151550293,
0.5101664662361145,
-0.3881469666957855,
-0.06831136345863342,
-0.1608356237411499,
0.020968381315469742,
-0.7967982888221741,
0.33024850487709045,
-0.01704368181526661,
0.292618989944458,
-0.17930454015731812,
-0.2110578715801239,
-0.6141360402107239,
-0.24030980467796326,
-0.059132348746061325,
-0.5350850224494934,
0.9932565689086914,
0.3705219030380249,
-0.04686865210533142,
0.1834179162979126,
-1.0722373723983765,
0.0848238542675972,
0.07967255264520645,
-0.06157670542597771,
-0.5140225887298584,
-0.017263775691390038,
-0.18519939482212067,
0.19171078503131866,
0.15917345881462097,
-0.5319902300834656,
0.2570774257183075,
-0.36457082629203796,
0.43843236565589905,
1.0834394693374634,
0.057009171694517136,
0.3888612389564514,
-0.33174535632133484,
0.4633202850818634,
0.08401355147361755,
0.12167014926671982,
0.3009639382362366,
0.15433643758296967,
-0.6070676445960999,
-0.5543180704116821,
0.5795712471008301,
0.11920598149299622,
-0.5061338543891907,
0.6685909628868103,
-0.23856137692928314,
-0.7618271112442017,
-0.6195734143257141,
0.052990227937698364,
0.46126696467399597,
0.5536591410636902,
0.23330196738243103,
-0.2092140167951584,
-0.6904711127281189,
-0.955491304397583,
-0.3504089415073395,
0.22944094240665436,
-0.3259047865867615,
0.013938292860984802,
0.5512678623199463,
-0.3231678009033203,
0.8825704455375671,
-0.7301093339920044,
-0.48660513758659363,
0.26570066809654236,
0.30916163325309753,
-0.20459023118019104,
1.1629747152328491,
0.5385934710502625,
-0.7875024080276489,
-0.20538556575775146,
-0.1310712993144989,
-0.6840984225273132,
0.21810504794120789,
0.20087186992168427,
-0.3609447479248047,
-0.15867863595485687,
0.5515487194061279,
-0.5461460947990417,
0.39201682806015015,
0.3347843289375305,
-0.0821179673075676,
0.6742241382598877,
-0.3459891974925995,
0.004113626666367054,
-1.1000012159347534,
0.30959802865982056,
-0.0870196595788002,
-0.2688206136226654,
-0.6492719054222107,
0.3348657488822937,
0.026204250752925873,
-0.19538649916648865,
-0.17931672930717468,
-0.16116097569465637,
-0.31721407175064087,
-0.0014782885555177927,
-0.17909830808639526,
-0.315250039100647,
-0.1844395399093628,
0.23264478147029877,
-0.2712576389312744,
0.6306599378585815,
0.5248591303825378,
-0.68001389503479,
-0.11422993987798691,
0.1489974409341812,
-0.732729971408844,
0.7200708389282227,
-0.7694584131240845,
0.4097725749015808,
-0.5729448199272156,
-0.03804701194167137,
-0.8609179258346558,
-0.2927582263946533,
-0.07015059888362885,
-0.09520447254180908,
0.3972836136817932,
-0.5018343329429626,
-0.472968727350235,
-0.18666960299015045,
-0.20052780210971832,
0.525173544883728,
0.629715621471405,
-0.6250151991844177,
0.5081169009208679,
0.4060910642147064,
0.13449953496456146,
-0.4507521092891693,
-0.4507421553134918,
-0.33011943101882935,
-0.5653207898139954,
-0.37991443276405334,
0.34441128373146057,
0.0697365254163742,
-0.14686833322048187,
-0.3675553798675537,
-0.038271691650152206,
0.14627264440059662,
0.7525133490562439,
0.5842146277427673,
0.21622677147388458,
0.051888905465602875,
-0.05596379190683365,
0.06649395078420639,
-0.5232100486755371,
-0.18287762999534607,
-0.2336377203464508,
0.7391143441200256,
0.018630683422088623,
-0.5842414498329163,
-0.2840036451816559,
0.06995534896850586,
0.5799200534820557,
-0.5954693555831909,
0.6197894215583801,
0.6873148679733276,
-0.7022520303726196,
-0.1597248762845993,
-0.3119368255138397,
-0.22050248086452484,
-0.5217515826225281,
0.3291604518890381,
-0.27968141436576843,
-0.565866231918335,
0.5875498056411743,
-0.3270634412765503,
0.19722311198711395,
0.5126407146453857,
0.4051467180252075,
-0.3533569276332855,
1.2797062397003174,
0.8959125280380249,
-0.09351995587348938,
0.51197350025177,
-0.4585250914096832,
0.09720289707183838,
-0.6693443655967712,
-0.21498852968215942,
-0.8953834772109985,
-0.7268199324607849,
-0.49292129278182983,
0.11472178995609283,
0.6990482211112976,
0.5606070756912231,
-0.5977031588554382,
0.2223014384508133,
-0.49241766333580017,
0.5367289185523987,
0.6458662748336792,
0.32149288058280945,
0.19012552499771118,
0.3173193633556366,
0.15991616249084473,
0.02296876721084118,
-0.2458958774805069,
-0.15078437328338623,
0.9840734601020813,
0.15074901282787323,
1.2593728303909302,
0.22733984887599945,
0.8305099606513977,
0.07941854745149612,
0.22957219183444977,
-0.4458143413066864,
0.2702069580554962,
-0.4803396165370941,
-0.6688284873962402,
-0.4353167414665222,
-0.5858012437820435,
-1.2557471990585327,
0.3324942886829376,
-0.3761942684650421,
-0.9580016732215881,
0.5037198066711426,
0.4516203999519348,
-0.7516032457351685,
0.34336432814598083,
-0.6792515516281128,
0.6695824861526489,
0.020061863586306572,
-0.1316620260477066,
-0.25247201323509216,
-0.7288342118263245,
0.5888215899467468,
-0.3292548358440399,
0.04208837077021599,
-0.07161390036344528,
0.36517471075057983,
0.6672739386558533,
-0.5098429322242737,
1.0525516271591187,
-0.45050233602523804,
-0.5017260313034058,
-0.13808377087116241,
0.17367896437644958,
0.5011013150215149,
-0.36937224864959717,
0.11831434816122055,
0.017092855647206306,
0.09272149205207825,
-0.3925357758998871,
-0.46245265007019043,
0.6560953855514526,
-1.0275282859802246,
-0.5444859862327576,
-0.014666738919913769,
-0.23011192679405212,
-0.23336610198020935,
0.30467689037323,
0.8139783143997192,
0.24764756858348846,
-0.30042320489883423,
0.2318628877401352,
0.8496768474578857,
0.14522479474544525,
0.38505977392196655,
0.46456366777420044,
0.014029140584170818,
-0.26203832030296326,
0.9735684394836426,
0.2778039872646332,
0.5626809597015381,
0.12786084413528442,
-0.04071997478604317,
0.1381637156009674,
-0.5250027179718018,
-0.0414583757519722,
-0.20664402842521667,
-0.3393280506134033,
-0.48815664649009705,
-0.3773270845413208,
-0.30480533838272095,
-0.14208242297172546,
-0.18679386377334595,
-0.7513571977615356,
-0.2351977676153183,
-0.36000561714172363,
-0.21517054736614227,
0.24960479140281677,
0.3198142349720001,
-0.21962088346481323,
0.40333980321884155,
-0.9165002703666687,
0.4925699830055237,
0.3812868893146515,
0.3369632363319397,
0.204239621758461,
-0.2646705210208893,
-0.1826096922159195,
0.33868730068206787,
-0.23130856454372406,
-0.5407676696777344,
0.2987942695617676,
0.24478454887866974,
0.12062465399503708,
0.9444512128829956,
0.2007753700017929,
0.861771285533905,
-0.6867372393608093,
0.50783771276474,
0.34198877215385437,
-0.7407568097114563,
0.6936813592910767,
-0.41711074113845825,
0.2656782269477844,
0.9236333966255188,
0.37605252861976624,
-0.1906179040670395,
-0.03267268091440201,
-0.46153149008750916,
-0.8001806139945984,
0.4801194667816162,
0.05800362303853035,
0.050063300877809525,
0.19022032618522644,
0.4806586503982544,
0.22330822050571442,
0.20390506088733673,
-0.4695630669593811,
-0.32754993438720703,
-0.25695985555648804,
-0.3022350072860718,
-0.28837424516677856,
-0.1397067904472351,
-0.6668312549591064,
-0.4547789990901947,
0.38675573468208313,
-0.13907259702682495,
0.04966374486684799,
-0.09178737550973892,
-0.1963195651769638,
-0.3325332999229431,
-0.016455361619591713,
0.281281977891922,
0.3101119101047516,
-0.21006621420383453,
0.4426960349082947,
-0.13516807556152344,
-0.5692633390426636,
0.27270573377609253,
0.22804920375347137,
-0.36965256929397583,
-0.7366756796836853,
0.1944647878408432,
0.6223911046981812,
0.44286343455314636,
-0.3041357100009918,
0.36549636721611023,
0.003927558660507202,
-0.17690511047840118,
-0.3657005727291107,
0.2054777592420578,
-0.24946202337741852,
0.047233354300260544,
0.33067774772644043,
0.6840993762016296,
-0.1656506210565567,
-0.2064538449048996,
0.07588577270507812,
0.8165690302848816,
-0.45719262957572937,
-0.5790128111839294,
0.984123170375824,
0.0718795657157898,
0.05898147076368332,
0.5283419489860535,
0.23915345966815948,
-0.044211246073246,
0.5394057631492615,
0.47292453050613403,
0.9601474404335022,
-0.38697779178619385,
0.06848212331533432,
0.28766676783561707,
0.2783965766429901,
-0.15111178159713745,
0.1682421714067459,
-0.042713653296232224,
-0.8251270651817322,
-0.1398947685956955,
-0.6899999380111694,
0.38166818022727966,
-0.1165216714143753,
-1.042788028717041,
0.14278116822242737,
-0.680767297744751,
-0.3968280553817749,
0.22187906503677368,
-0.06390682607889175,
-0.58877032995224,
0.06123088672757149,
0.025236740708351135,
0.7370397448539734,
-0.8124131560325623,
0.8695333003997803,
0.22417052090168,
-0.45649513602256775,
-0.7199873328208923,
-0.0081006595864892,
0.10643398761749268,
-0.722012460231781,
0.7388699650764465,
-0.07958916574716568,
-0.34667539596557617,
0.47596704959869385,
-0.9373483061790466,
-1.3089457750320435,
1.1281780004501343,
0.8519112467765808,
-0.5714247822761536,
-0.3256000876426697,
-0.13107508420944214,
0.43391555547714233,
0.2613479495048523,
-0.3324436843395233,
0.5380028486251831,
0.3190311789512634,
-0.11060015112161636,
-0.7102894186973572,
-0.029174860566854477,
-0.11894766241312027,
0.018412884324789047,
0.4876965284347534,
-0.5762558579444885,
1.0488909482955933,
-0.15419065952301025,
-0.4690483510494232,
0.3972569704055786,
0.5128958821296692,
-0.009811455383896828,
-0.27005505561828613,
0.7738111615180969,
1.0064923763275146,
1.0624488592147827,
-0.15420953929424286,
1.0274722576141357,
-0.4272727370262146,
0.3234338164329529,
0.9032515287399292,
-0.2025534212589264,
0.7380262613296509,
0.19408637285232544,
-0.2519468367099762,
0.2990114390850067,
0.6006470322608948,
-0.04766058549284935,
0.9046231508255005,
0.24319319427013397,
-0.19331610202789307,
-0.46907851099967957,
0.038133855909109116,
-0.693264901638031,
0.724438488483429,
0.2000695914030075,
-0.31888917088508606,
-0.31389668583869934,
0.1322580724954605,
-0.08323120325803757,
-0.23101095855236053,
-0.83662348985672,
0.8919206857681274,
0.15910331904888153,
-0.3980850875377655,
0.9871522784233093,
-0.057227279990911484,
0.6069086194038391,
-0.7418237924575806,
0.14397922158241272,
0.06550014764070511,
0.3317163586616516,
-0.366299569606781,
0.06620785593986511,
0.17537853121757507,
-0.15259018540382385,
-0.3175165057182312,
-0.08170908689498901,
0.8692184686660767,
-0.3307592570781708,
-0.4578719437122345,
-0.009818246588110924,
0.2556065618991852,
-0.28411343693733215,
0.02417510561645031,
-0.1969965547323227,
-0.019715894013643265,
-0.1346723735332489,
0.003493069438263774,
0.6971710920333862,
-0.0184063408523798,
0.12614518404006958,
0.6983447074890137,
0.5652109980583191,
-0.0677114725112915,
-0.004731035325676203,
0.2182105928659439,
0.8612795472145081,
-0.45716798305511475,
-0.5956629514694214,
-0.821595311164856,
0.46395495533943176,
0.06031721085309982,
-0.19575367867946625,
0.7993929386138916,
0.34425196051597595,
0.6892336010932922,
-0.10554524511098862,
0.48459839820861816,
0.24505506455898285,
0.3408796787261963,
-0.6776368618011475,
1.1519683599472046,
-0.45468494296073914,
0.13433530926704407,
-0.5340726971626282,
-0.7162500619888306,
-0.20001919567584991,
0.44096213579177856,
-0.16338594257831573,
0.20642778277397156,
0.1291215568780899,
0.702582061290741,
-0.10804880410432816,
0.11278689652681351,
0.23868966102600098,
0.5131815671920776,
0.12322473526000977,
0.34393027424812317,
0.6734440326690674,
-0.20884358882904053,
0.17720690369606018,
-0.10369369387626648,
-0.21003802120685577,
0.043251633644104004,
-0.6634659171104431,
-0.6315187215805054,
-0.6398327350616455,
-0.12338627874851227,
-0.4819643199443817,
-0.0774780735373497,
0.7531424164772034,
0.9110763669013977,
-0.6711373925209045,
0.32416030764579773,
-0.22917066514492035,
-0.09810420125722885,
-0.3809534013271332,
-0.15270471572875977,
0.44902539253234863,
-0.19941718876361847,
-0.7321791648864746,
0.19433683156967163,
0.011592847295105457,
0.30632317066192627,
-0.42749151587486267,
0.2406465858221054,
0.15214358270168304,
-0.15010866522789001,
0.4311782717704773,
0.42522919178009033,
-0.4451349675655365,
-0.49477052688598633,
-0.6278240084648132,
-0.049325305968523026,
-0.0576309934258461,
0.8202772736549377,
-0.9343360066413879,
0.16979582607746124,
0.2000904381275177,
0.5692446231842041,
0.5409049391746521,
0.31518176198005676,
0.6342189311981201,
-1.0234565734863281,
0.18113884329795837,
0.1461591124534607,
0.26971808075904846,
0.07911226153373718,
-0.2761274576187134,
0.36366599798202515,
-0.005308749154210091,
-0.30250024795532227,
-1.0334233045578003,
0.6208715438842773,
-0.9011480808258057,
-0.387204647064209,
0.5398677587509155,
-0.13421641290187836,
0.01724698767066002,
0.06711480766534805,
-0.15052035450935364,
0.3172879219055176,
0.21761752665042877,
1.0340646505355835,
0.16667959094047546,
0.2533356249332428,
-0.06364452093839645,
-0.11253734678030014,
0.8650719523429871,
0.3340655565261841,
-0.8722187876701355,
0.22777123749256134,
0.450069785118103,
0.3301929235458374,
0.27313822507858276,
0.3823811411857605,
-0.44088509678840637,
0.02093183994293213,
0.0688139870762825,
-0.16216358542442322,
-0.06502046436071396,
-0.32763737440109253,
-0.3936423659324646,
0.589846134185791,
0.16303366422653198,
-0.19227026402950287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10207v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10207v5 | Rewards-in-Context: Multi-objective Alignment of Foundation Models with Dynamic Preference Adjustment | 2024-02-15T18:58:31 | 2024-06-05T09:25:41 | Rui Yang, Xiaoman Pan, Feng Luo, Shuang Qiu, Han Zhong, Dong Yu, Jianshu Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We consider the problem of multi-objective alignment of foundation models
with human preferences, which is a critical step towards helpful and harmless
AI systems. However, it is generally costly and unstable to fine-tune large
foundation models using reinforcement learning (RL), and the
multi-dimensionality, heterogeneity, and conflicting nature of human
preferences further complicate the alignment process. In this paper, we
introduce Rewards-in-Context (RiC), which conditions the response of a
foundation model on multiple rewards in its prompt context and applies
supervised fine-tuning for alignment. The salient features of RiC are
simplicity and adaptivity, as it only requires supervised fine-tuning of a
single foundation model and supports dynamic adjustment for user preferences
during inference time. Inspired by the analytical solution of an abstracted
convex optimization problem, our dynamic inference-time adjustment method
approaches the Pareto-optimal solution for multiple objectives. Empirical
evidence demonstrates the efficacy of our method in aligning both Large
Language Models (LLMs) and diffusion models to accommodate diverse rewards with
only around 10% GPU hours compared with multi-objective RL baseline. | [
-0.43259990215301514,
-0.569340705871582,
0.4329865574836731,
0.38184434175491333,
-0.047684814780950546,
0.056379783898591995,
-0.5039105415344238,
-0.2500005066394806,
-0.019084306433796883,
0.18378347158432007,
-0.8158707618713379,
-0.22325368225574493,
-0.6447699069976807,
-0.021665140986442566,
0.13676977157592773,
1.2246400117874146,
-0.13601267337799072,
-0.18955481052398682,
-0.3009754717350006,
-0.3485782742500305,
-0.670052170753479,
-0.023518895730376244,
-0.6816409230232239,
-0.3030090928077698,
0.7485101222991943,
0.790812075138092,
0.45853349566459656,
0.6480889320373535,
0.4702150523662567,
0.2875630557537079,
-0.024982869625091553,
0.2405603677034378,
-0.5893059968948364,
0.25799715518951416,
-0.32752102613449097,
-0.20372098684310913,
-0.24685770273208618,
0.08553893864154816,
0.557029128074646,
0.4299791157245636,
-0.3106619417667389,
0.0625893846154213,
0.39338618516921997,
0.7254543304443359,
-1.0386096239089966,
-0.014327071607112885,
-0.47005483508110046,
0.0879681333899498,
0.08343266695737839,
-0.3791539967060089,
-0.30961084365844727,
-0.25323131680488586,
0.15299177169799805,
-0.8197764754295349,
-0.182747483253479,
-0.26584336161613464,
0.8899039626121521,
0.8964095711708069,
-0.5616827011108398,
-0.3541712462902069,
-0.5160019397735596,
1.115997076034546,
-0.2736790180206299,
0.1069430485367775,
0.06913314759731293,
0.5652751922607422,
-0.022274456918239594,
-0.3176816701889038,
-0.11342480778694153,
-0.14432044327259064,
-0.2151602953672409,
0.10506867617368698,
0.29749760031700134,
-0.03305792808532715,
0.1668502241373062,
0.08845724910497665,
-0.19453312456607819,
0.2023366242647171,
0.12483121454715729,
0.14771221578121185,
0.5103706121444702,
0.2920211851596832,
0.06158548593521118,
0.16370058059692383,
-0.7116369605064392,
-0.29076701402664185,
-0.6263037323951721,
0.6532387733459473,
0.21251024305820465,
0.5840057730674744,
-0.2668069303035736,
0.5070109963417053,
-0.5185689926147461,
1.021799087524414,
0.44104573130607605,
-0.3897646963596344,
0.09397818893194199,
-0.3619718849658966,
-0.07819043844938278,
0.37720218300819397,
0.5113807916641235,
0.4094010293483734,
0.05698679760098457,
-0.058749567717313766,
-0.30547887086868286,
0.3052060902118683,
0.35329949855804443,
-0.865557074546814,
0.08080578595399857,
0.24962204694747925,
-0.3347051739692688,
-0.5186827778816223,
-0.10074333101511002,
-0.6927877068519592,
-0.512946367263794,
-0.5829590559005737,
0.366048663854599,
-0.10673714429140091,
-0.0077407630160450935,
0.32126253843307495,
-0.12177209556102753,
0.1255442351102829,
0.5032845735549927,
-1.0247679948806763,
-0.018957581371068954,
0.6460093259811401,
0.6790683269500732,
-0.2909556031227112,
-0.4842943251132965,
-0.9617051482200623,
0.4535498023033142,
0.05465451255440712,
0.7879173755645752,
-0.8323889374732971,
-0.2706512212753296,
-0.13251721858978271,
-0.1873091608285904,
-0.051618993282318115,
-0.26927655935287476,
0.5124848484992981,
-0.2245214879512787,
0.20588067173957825,
-0.5604977011680603,
-0.42684781551361084,
0.2116907387971878,
0.6232563853263855,
-0.3872871994972229,
0.8343757390975952,
-0.008922066539525986,
-0.5847158432006836,
0.6996768116950989,
-1.0627871751785278,
-0.4946553409099579,
-0.23809537291526794,
-0.1754816621541977,
-0.2777993083000183,
0.1105499118566513,
0.27577441930770874,
0.44669029116630554,
-0.13143572211265564,
0.8035306334495544,
-0.39651790261268616,
-0.5050963163375854,
0.23726315796375275,
-0.2998698353767395,
0.692262589931488,
0.18269599974155426,
-0.7113168239593506,
0.5262827277183533,
-0.668851912021637,
-0.2465927004814148,
-0.14706334471702576,
-0.5800111889839172,
-0.3589220941066742,
0.41244226694107056,
-0.16540823876857758,
0.20977286994457245,
0.47858983278274536,
-0.4379705488681793,
0.5422661900520325,
-0.03547133877873421,
0.36019253730773926,
1.0377458333969116,
-0.31750425696372986,
0.6297203898429871,
-0.24191656708717346,
0.509202778339386,
-0.12529653310775757,
0.2411399632692337,
0.15542805194854736,
-0.11265742778778076,
-0.4313585162162781,
-0.5577376484870911,
0.32609331607818604,
0.3886376917362213,
-0.28706830739974976,
0.30148884654045105,
-0.32148483395576477,
-0.12352631986141205,
-0.3713745176792145,
-0.17310453951358795,
0.32660844922065735,
0.6364444494247437,
0.4486757516860962,
-0.10314647853374481,
-0.11833033710718155,
-0.9029173254966736,
-0.3244268298149109,
0.13196280598640442,
0.14558033645153046,
0.8298287391662598,
0.2660224139690399,
-0.2470536082983017,
1.024349570274353,
-0.536697268486023,
-0.3599785268306732,
0.1793619692325592,
0.28599536418914795,
0.10956865549087524,
0.6330322027206421,
0.8032937049865723,
-1.082947850227356,
-0.5809162855148315,
0.0024033263325691223,
-0.6152238845825195,
-0.21223978698253632,
-0.20152416825294495,
-0.31874537467956543,
-0.20370641350746155,
0.24120554327964783,
-0.2680245041847229,
0.15141403675079346,
0.5209738612174988,
-0.4053380787372589,
0.42341336607933044,
-0.021655241027474403,
0.33299580216407776,
-0.8487712144851685,
0.1217866763472557,
0.011161268688738346,
-0.09134358167648315,
-0.1950579583644867,
0.0025098647456616163,
0.09844470769166946,
-0.014005661010742188,
-0.30497923493385315,
0.8836690783500671,
-0.27070993185043335,
-0.11324191838502884,
-0.3818683624267578,
0.02621658332645893,
0.04106317460536957,
0.5602545738220215,
0.2637799084186554,
0.7344837188720703,
0.5868746638298035,
-0.8459144234657288,
0.3358229994773865,
0.3049983084201813,
-0.3997081518173218,
1.1037834882736206,
-0.4859897494316101,
-0.2554885149002075,
-0.03448287397623062,
0.4267047941684723,
-0.7507950663566589,
-0.4323924779891968,
0.3197496235370636,
-0.2733880579471588,
0.21701186895370483,
-0.06351464241743088,
0.1562700867652893,
0.20745788514614105,
-0.3131372928619385,
0.6279420256614685,
-0.03162100538611412,
-0.8984984755516052,
0.6596090197563171,
0.24325205385684967,
-0.02843737043440342,
-1.3039600849151611,
-0.4023668169975281,
-0.07561703771352768,
-0.5116128921508789,
-0.32958248257637024,
0.8635448217391968,
-0.35286349058151245,
-0.11952240020036697,
0.2997492849826813,
-0.10997278243303299,
0.2393997311592102,
0.5475730299949646,
0.27256470918655396,
-0.07413002848625183,
-0.1268964409828186,
-0.07855301350355148,
0.4111592471599579,
-0.3125620484352112,
-0.25323766469955444,
-0.21594712138175964,
0.23311957716941833,
-0.16034775972366333,
-0.30869609117507935,
-0.37753939628601074,
0.27414193749427795,
0.5583364963531494,
-0.34867432713508606,
0.7739502787590027,
0.5369520783424377,
-0.4114934504032135,
0.034144699573516846,
-0.41354021430015564,
-0.22181470692157745,
-0.454446941614151,
0.2541264295578003,
-0.6506059765815735,
-1.003137469291687,
0.3807528614997864,
-0.048540085554122925,
0.19714422523975372,
0.21899749338626862,
0.6783705949783325,
0.011612941510975361,
1.1940292119979858,
0.6346947550773621,
-0.19683171808719635,
0.8512366414070129,
0.010570479556918144,
0.04295451566576958,
-0.9201257824897766,
-0.372016966342926,
-0.6722709536552429,
-0.8173183798789978,
-0.38268211483955383,
0.271062970161438,
0.4090316593647003,
0.18541319668293,
-0.5833517909049988,
0.06605082005262375,
-0.5813812017440796,
0.49635154008865356,
0.5348625183105469,
0.1621050089597702,
0.015508905053138733,
-0.19727705419063568,
0.027931900694966316,
0.22042088210582733,
-0.6329865455627441,
-0.2843989133834839,
0.7613573670387268,
-0.019842738285660744,
0.75482177734375,
0.34576156735420227,
0.5792914032936096,
0.23549607396125793,
0.4991573691368103,
-0.6003896594047546,
0.1178756058216095,
-0.10740122199058533,
-0.6586512327194214,
-0.5124873518943787,
-0.3761196434497833,
-0.804166316986084,
0.23610283434391022,
-0.5076335072517395,
-0.7821494936943054,
0.4998345375061035,
0.4460219442844391,
-0.7254458665847778,
-0.023292602971196175,
-0.44723671674728394,
1.2593586444854736,
-0.5848727822303772,
-0.7104516625404358,
-0.3641842007637024,
-0.6890687942504883,
0.3910217881202698,
0.1673348844051361,
0.0975179374217987,
-0.38573402166366577,
0.0678008496761322,
0.28937846422195435,
-0.08131559193134308,
0.6796883940696716,
-0.4544622004032135,
0.10753193497657776,
-0.31914106011390686,
-0.07872142642736435,
0.5883158445358276,
0.39072492718696594,
-0.1172802746295929,
-0.33885622024536133,
-0.10758763551712036,
-0.6035780906677246,
-0.5959069728851318,
0.9431318044662476,
-0.6970769762992859,
-0.42057064175605774,
-0.47615325450897217,
-0.7652615308761597,
-0.23684044182300568,
0.10210030525922775,
0.014608790166676044,
0.47736290097236633,
-0.3682926893234253,
0.4643056392669678,
0.4556484818458557,
-0.3874572515487671,
0.31050631403923035,
0.4708022475242615,
0.12971144914627075,
-0.21662886440753937,
0.8704285025596619,
-0.4908158779144287,
0.16083167493343353,
0.6591853499412537,
0.42920294404029846,
-0.3597647547721863,
-0.35157036781311035,
-0.7637419700622559,
-0.1301816701889038,
-0.34588658809661865,
-0.29278668761253357,
-0.47882530093193054,
0.4228983521461487,
-0.2069040834903717,
-0.7586646676063538,
-0.45920708775520325,
-0.06495043635368347,
-0.5067912340164185,
0.17861095070838928,
0.1694311499595642,
0.4411654472351074,
-0.07933053374290466,
0.4879743158817291,
-0.587997555732727,
0.261842280626297,
0.34221914410591125,
0.45482751727104187,
-0.19411639869213104,
-0.34529876708984375,
-0.396640419960022,
0.26288455724716187,
-0.2396426498889923,
-0.5008240938186646,
0.09443462640047073,
0.19884030520915985,
0.5343775749206543,
0.5798124670982361,
0.09524595737457275,
0.8702983260154724,
-0.345521479845047,
0.6060338616371155,
0.14165188372135162,
-0.9218905568122864,
0.3801126480102539,
-0.3353649079799652,
0.05442731827497482,
0.8335607647895813,
0.23988401889801025,
-0.5415273904800415,
0.08869323879480362,
-0.24555207788944244,
-0.709257185459137,
0.8461884260177612,
-0.24753275513648987,
-0.056873392313718796,
0.1312575787305832,
0.5238345861434937,
0.07802430540323257,
0.2889748513698578,
-0.763437807559967,
-0.09483380615711212,
-0.21285152435302734,
-0.4714820384979248,
-0.299398273229599,
-0.23802904784679413,
-0.4989650249481201,
-0.10034217685461044,
0.7871629595756531,
-0.4836711585521698,
0.12380357086658478,
-0.2930537760257721,
-0.20761339366436005,
-0.12102783471345901,
0.20466351509094238,
1.034303069114685,
0.7739812135696411,
-0.3585543632507324,
-0.06273304671049118,
-0.04658627510070801,
0.29634609818458557,
0.40388792753219604,
0.22381792962551117,
0.015658874064683914,
-0.6655504107475281,
0.01596546731889248,
1.1755160093307495,
0.5810765624046326,
-0.6567299365997314,
0.5788376927375793,
-0.2572054862976074,
-0.03160539269447327,
-0.06982338428497314,
0.3549044132232666,
-0.012412620708346367,
0.5048145055770874,
0.10123641788959503,
0.23367314040660858,
0.08214316517114639,
-0.46287447214126587,
0.017423570156097412,
0.8800305128097534,
-0.4043000042438507,
-0.006751949433237314,
0.8437821269035339,
0.18963046371936798,
-0.09452278167009354,
0.5458874702453613,
-0.07049992680549622,
-0.42679715156555176,
0.6751219630241394,
0.4053153097629547,
0.6086388826370239,
-0.2196664810180664,
0.25472503900527954,
0.25832340121269226,
-0.12757708132266998,
-0.32521766424179077,
-0.09733694791793823,
-0.2288210690021515,
-1.0519022941589355,
-0.4504193067550659,
-0.7187811732292175,
-0.473481148481369,
-0.159555584192276,
-0.879018247127533,
0.3370828330516815,
-0.15998771786689758,
0.0902387797832489,
0.11469287425279617,
-0.06760867685079575,
-0.47341299057006836,
0.31116634607315063,
-0.09862194210290909,
0.6753600835800171,
-0.9391896724700928,
0.7241958379745483,
0.7407446503639221,
-0.14916767179965973,
-0.5156550407409668,
-0.1864265650510788,
0.04496491700410843,
-0.494435578584671,
0.5544947981834412,
0.25197505950927734,
-0.37809672951698303,
0.10286986082792282,
-0.49247726798057556,
-0.9300094246864319,
1.0735342502593994,
0.5393030643463135,
-0.3914930820465088,
0.1513848900794983,
-0.2810233533382416,
0.23965823650360107,
-0.6526155471801758,
0.13054028153419495,
0.4579196274280548,
0.83916175365448,
-0.17269854247570038,
-0.44628292322158813,
-0.1833667904138565,
-0.10620363801717758,
-0.3160169720649719,
0.39459019899368286,
-0.7320424318313599,
0.657611072063446,
-0.05685243755578995,
0.1078854501247406,
-0.03232140839099884,
0.500390350818634,
0.4858032763004303,
0.24311549961566925,
0.7948837876319885,
0.5418728590011597,
0.741861879825592,
-0.18797431886196136,
1.0966218709945679,
-0.4698391854763031,
0.4703301787376404,
0.9954894185066223,
-0.3580072820186615,
0.37363919615745544,
0.49647361040115356,
0.10550610721111298,
0.6032031774520874,
1.0494400262832642,
0.26638180017471313,
0.9197105169296265,
-0.029901407659053802,
-0.13538025319576263,
-0.3857719302177429,
-0.2505933344364166,
-0.35526877641677856,
0.37842613458633423,
0.29388439655303955,
0.10655108094215393,
-0.061706360429525375,
0.01992853730916977,
-0.36786729097366333,
0.025084182620048523,
-0.16285203397274017,
0.5699465870857239,
-0.28960540890693665,
-1.0263617038726807,
0.2964371144771576,
0.24611365795135498,
0.694861114025116,
-0.5571726560592651,
0.0039510964415967464,
-0.24539996683597565,
0.34974631667137146,
-0.15016594529151917,
-0.4128393828868866,
0.0322691835463047,
-0.043748121708631516,
-0.4681941270828247,
-0.44413378834724426,
0.3282356858253479,
-0.6414621472358704,
-0.28410404920578003,
0.2960233986377716,
0.1642930656671524,
-0.28683823347091675,
-0.06339877098798752,
-0.9080384969711304,
0.09997940808534622,
-0.023861074820160866,
-0.412507027387619,
0.5772919058799744,
0.2186935693025589,
-0.1136765331029892,
0.5288679003715515,
0.49609026312828064,
-0.2433403730392456,
-0.28685256838798523,
-0.135702446103096,
0.7105518579483032,
-0.5303599834442139,
-0.7123456597328186,
-1.000383973121643,
0.751753568649292,
-0.011909013614058495,
-0.49151116609573364,
0.2750547528266907,
0.5729491710662842,
0.889092743396759,
0.1796666532754898,
0.6117212772369385,
-0.14949896931648254,
0.19201648235321045,
-0.671000599861145,
0.20334747433662415,
-1.1524455547332764,
0.10825502872467041,
-0.31336820125579834,
-1.0104669332504272,
-0.29294344782829285,
0.9001891613006592,
-0.11976813524961472,
-0.020182467997074127,
0.5554826855659485,
0.5846111178398132,
-0.45102161169052124,
-0.13110367953777313,
-0.13179995119571686,
-0.1196083277463913,
0.26566559076309204,
0.7225909233093262,
0.8075500130653381,
0.30519285798072815,
0.02500028721988201,
-0.31076568365097046,
-0.47690436244010925,
-0.4838004410266876,
-1.292260766029358,
-0.4063534736633301,
-0.40491026639938354,
-0.29263362288475037,
-0.26623260974884033,
0.24715271592140198,
1.0564028024673462,
0.658051073551178,
-0.9783427715301514,
-0.3793599605560303,
0.18466629087924957,
0.35127025842666626,
-0.7412782311439514,
-0.1877664476633072,
0.4302836060523987,
-0.42338284850120544,
-0.9925857186317444,
0.7040711045265198,
0.39597204327583313,
-0.36895132064819336,
-0.05537853017449379,
-0.45648589730262756,
-0.212161585688591,
-0.16378691792488098,
0.341715008020401,
0.2640264630317688,
-0.6827981472015381,
-0.5247026681900024,
-0.018387358635663986,
-0.19751320779323578,
0.23097319900989532,
0.9539082050323486,
-0.6631841063499451,
0.36534297466278076,
0.2652464210987091,
1.00679349899292,
0.5985936522483826,
0.5219147801399231,
0.5260388255119324,
-0.6779872179031372,
0.20851808786392212,
-0.1524951457977295,
0.37825432419776917,
0.2169477343559265,
-0.5536695122718811,
0.44102275371551514,
0.0790993943810463,
-0.5933272838592529,
-0.9577711820602417,
0.40659868717193604,
-0.9299212694168091,
-0.48222294449806213,
1.0173275470733643,
-0.08634904772043228,
0.040743645280599594,
0.23846419155597687,
-0.04143903777003288,
0.32232242822647095,
-0.5333161950111389,
0.9237352609634399,
0.7649442553520203,
-0.2991175353527069,
0.031870532780885696,
-0.16440434753894806,
0.6472594738006592,
0.6447973251342773,
-0.7107080221176147,
-0.05415456369519234,
0.7516351938247681,
0.18313409388065338,
-0.06118518486618996,
0.4625597298145294,
0.2750542163848877,
0.22986766695976257,
-0.5113680958747864,
0.16715680062770844,
-0.13720041513442993,
-0.7886126041412354,
-0.5307503938674927,
0.23319153487682343,
0.0936688706278801,
-0.25627419352531433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10260v1 | A StrongREJECT for Empty Jailbreaks | 2024-02-15T18:58:09 | 2024-02-15T18:58:09 | Alexandra Souly, Qingyuan Lu, Dillon Bowen, Tu Trinh, Elvis Hsieh, Sana Pandey, Pieter Abbeel, Justin Svegliato, Scott Emmons, Olivia Watkins, Sam Toyer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | The rise of large language models (LLMs) has drawn attention to the existence
of "jailbreaks" that allow the models to be used maliciously. However, there is
no standard benchmark for measuring the severity of a jailbreak, leaving
authors of jailbreak papers to create their own. We show that these benchmarks
often include vague or unanswerable questions and use grading criteria that are
biased towards overestimating the misuse potential of low-quality model
responses. Some jailbreak techniques make the problem worse by decreasing the
quality of model responses even on benign questions: we show that several
jailbreaking techniques substantially reduce the zero-shot performance of GPT-4
on MMLU. Jailbreaks can also make it harder to elicit harmful responses from an
"uncensored" open-source model. We present a new benchmark, StrongREJECT, which
better discriminates between effective and ineffective jailbreaks by using a
higher-quality question set and a more accurate response grading algorithm. We
show that our new grading scheme better accords with human judgment of response
quality and overall jailbreak effectiveness, especially on the sort of
low-quality responses that contribute the most to over-estimation of jailbreak
performance on existing benchmarks. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/alexandrasouly/strongreject. | [
-0.30641546845436096,
-0.6785427927970886,
0.582643985748291,
-0.09578204154968262,
-0.258381187915802,
0.03026912547647953,
-0.208261638879776,
-0.6100319027900696,
0.07078726589679718,
0.7039668560028076,
-0.013724750839173794,
-0.46322453022003174,
-0.5560200214385986,
-0.05960735306143761,
-0.6197798252105713,
1.1793975830078125,
-0.06430146098136902,
-0.0335267037153244,
-0.15602411329746246,
-0.42400452494621277,
-0.4538574814796448,
-0.5801447629928589,
0.0912892147898674,
-0.33121317625045776,
0.4372846484184265,
0.4641943871974945,
0.661601185798645,
0.47138673067092896,
0.7642623782157898,
0.2483900934457779,
-0.20702692866325378,
-0.060437362641096115,
-0.431319922208786,
-0.07719209790229797,
-0.24824343621730804,
-0.27145013213157654,
-0.3019767105579376,
0.19906897842884064,
0.13308309018611908,
0.4282912015914917,
-0.24172794818878174,
0.3375045955181122,
-0.11250803619623184,
0.6532503366470337,
-0.980709969997406,
-0.3958248794078827,
-0.6202853322029114,
-0.07529979944229126,
-0.3054702877998352,
0.2857549488544464,
-0.4100322127342224,
-0.33988457918167114,
-0.3880521059036255,
-0.2679624557495117,
0.14089541137218475,
-0.10755409300327301,
0.9026761054992676,
0.07676875591278076,
-0.3155413866043091,
-0.17247004806995392,
-0.5799340009689331,
0.7757529020309448,
-0.9911389946937561,
0.1040075272321701,
0.5261284708976746,
0.35650527477264404,
-0.18994230031967163,
-0.5184481739997864,
-0.13451014459133148,
-0.45575377345085144,
0.16123120486736298,
-0.029952596873044968,
-0.2371443659067154,
0.09893534332513809,
0.36619970202445984,
0.543293833732605,
-0.3579414486885071,
0.2618277668952942,
-0.7529873847961426,
-0.25414416193962097,
0.6816591620445251,
0.18093959987163544,
0.13098855316638947,
-0.3547913730144501,
-0.26067981123924255,
0.2362024039030075,
-1.0452871322631836,
-0.03486161306500435,
0.9407457709312439,
0.4185176491737366,
-0.11588099598884583,
0.881449818611145,
-0.08072805404663086,
0.7266926169395447,
-0.12783603370189667,
-0.06466890126466751,
0.42822861671447754,
-0.31663790345191956,
-0.09527447074651718,
-0.15595272183418274,
0.8001308441162109,
0.4827173948287964,
0.3066283166408539,
-0.2870486080646515,
-0.20682945847511292,
0.0022928104735910892,
0.418447881937027,
-1.0669078826904297,
-0.25077930092811584,
0.3598555028438568,
-0.36405259370803833,
-0.47936707735061646,
0.17181384563446045,
-0.5781986117362976,
-0.7738938927650452,
0.32437989115715027,
0.41495436429977417,
-0.2568528652191162,
-0.1498776227235794,
0.12221262603998184,
-0.1659146100282669,
0.09861844033002853,
0.34087836742401123,
-0.6446242928504944,
0.36456766724586487,
0.5380483865737915,
0.9185171127319336,
-0.05520956218242645,
-0.09658157080411911,
-0.6699352264404297,
-0.06498570740222931,
-0.3020366132259369,
0.7497290372848511,
-0.3480108678340912,
-0.2948981523513794,
-0.20386570692062378,
-0.1519201546907425,
0.36577147245407104,
-0.9437946677207947,
0.592667281627655,
-0.2501566708087921,
-0.035333052277565,
-0.030135927721858025,
-0.6016750335693359,
-0.029575545340776443,
0.23719549179077148,
-0.503996729850769,
0.7351294755935669,
0.31872230768203735,
-0.7517649531364441,
0.39557725191116333,
-0.34030577540397644,
-0.4685707688331604,
-0.05135522410273552,
0.0835694670677185,
-0.5399311780929565,
0.31429821252822876,
0.13808760046958923,
0.3748185932636261,
-0.24466204643249512,
0.5323141813278198,
-0.759243905544281,
-0.6183804273605347,
0.24885837733745575,
-0.1990652084350586,
0.5729992985725403,
0.44105419516563416,
-0.29832926392555237,
-0.04702092707157135,
-0.8047084808349609,
0.12296546995639801,
0.0669565424323082,
-0.4266977608203888,
-0.49180519580841064,
0.13926216959953308,
-0.1614178717136383,
0.13264833390712738,
0.14038200676441193,
-0.9670059680938721,
0.2583639919757843,
-0.5244207978248596,
0.6119837164878845,
0.8888124227523804,
-0.08115816861391068,
0.29301607608795166,
-0.20556552708148956,
0.26431646943092346,
0.13117901980876923,
0.23823243379592896,
0.008623599074780941,
-0.4374224841594696,
-0.419503390789032,
-0.1637044996023178,
0.11327964812517166,
0.41872307658195496,
-0.24535852670669556,
0.11019564419984818,
0.016175804659724236,
-0.6840784549713135,
-0.7410545945167542,
0.6763290166854858,
0.650405764579773,
0.504535973072052,
0.6221153140068054,
-0.4151676297187805,
-0.46629276871681213,
-0.9925277233123779,
-0.6046438217163086,
-0.47740939259529114,
-0.06484568119049072,
0.3951985538005829,
0.5215457081794739,
0.0413026437163353,
0.5151597261428833,
-0.39072084426879883,
-0.22001773118972778,
-0.38768473267555237,
0.2549416720867157,
0.42057833075523376,
0.35298752784729004,
0.562223494052887,
-0.39632150530815125,
-0.025734039023518562,
-0.37924179434776306,
-0.8401777148246765,
-0.29785048961639404,
0.3538537919521332,
0.3588099777698517,
-0.11216511577367783,
0.3839010000228882,
-0.5679111480712891,
0.19540025293827057,
0.5144052505493164,
-0.606839656829834,
0.726402223110199,
-0.05865904688835144,
0.12861640751361847,
-0.7458095550537109,
0.13412657380104065,
0.10698960721492767,
-0.1428007185459137,
-0.6087160110473633,
0.553712010383606,
0.27734270691871643,
-0.10118965059518814,
-0.8628237247467041,
0.6461913585662842,
-0.2738729417324066,
-0.1392006129026413,
-0.22908447682857513,
0.1224401518702507,
0.02258969098329544,
0.08880643546581268,
-0.4368162155151367,
0.8497491478919983,
0.09032166004180908,
-0.12433426082134247,
0.3378300368785858,
0.1658947914838791,
-0.6214452981948853,
0.26206132769584656,
-0.8330588340759277,
0.08108799904584885,
-0.03408869728446007,
-0.21036498248577118,
-0.8759626746177673,
-0.2367832213640213,
-0.0215951818972826,
-0.3540574312210083,
0.09394756704568863,
-0.5304922461509705,
-0.4444005489349365,
-0.69410240650177,
-0.49196234345436096,
0.3020426034927368,
0.49056383967399597,
-0.4204234480857849,
-0.058294061571359634,
0.23782511055469513,
0.1775643527507782,
-0.6355800628662109,
-0.830752432346344,
0.10112055391073227,
-0.37435242533683777,
-0.5191054940223694,
0.11376875638961792,
-0.11489742249250412,
-0.4360199570655823,
-0.006129855755716562,
-0.1772509068250656,
-0.12857702374458313,
0.29052403569221497,
0.4942421019077301,
0.29294121265411377,
-0.2579375207424164,
-0.2445387989282608,
-0.27414482831954956,
0.08696582168340683,
0.07607156038284302,
0.23585748672485352,
0.26835519075393677,
-0.18509653210639954,
-0.36529770493507385,
-0.092368945479393,
0.08637923002243042,
0.8679357767105103,
-0.2726970911026001,
0.5132854580879211,
0.10563844442367554,
-0.06717469543218613,
-0.04090869426727295,
-0.7262573838233948,
-0.04981504753232002,
-0.5144228339195251,
0.2540140450000763,
-0.3369719088077545,
-1.158735752105713,
0.5729508399963379,
0.14596912264823914,
-0.03636515513062477,
0.04040687903761864,
0.4458807408809662,
0.08285067230463028,
0.9700329899787903,
0.48636293411254883,
-0.3985423147678375,
0.3411046862602234,
0.01890680380165577,
0.19733327627182007,
-0.8419358730316162,
-0.05794971436262131,
-0.6553377509117126,
-0.23243191838264465,
-0.4753279685974121,
-0.1908695250749588,
-0.12798619270324707,
0.5072637796401978,
-0.6333051919937134,
0.6449503898620605,
-0.47060492634773254,
0.5994072556495667,
0.2984798550605774,
0.15579430758953094,
0.41057202219963074,
-0.23700648546218872,
-0.04733585566282272,
-0.07289408147335052,
-0.17778606712818146,
-0.5236336588859558,
1.3596361875534058,
0.3774554133415222,
1.0787626504898071,
0.22521813213825226,
0.8698543906211853,
0.37048327922821045,
0.6970142126083374,
-0.7392012476921082,
0.5141685605049133,
-0.23610562086105347,
-0.9229979515075684,
0.03597048297524452,
-0.7597391605377197,
-0.6396259665489197,
0.12496063113212585,
0.12943565845489502,
-1.0647412538528442,
-0.040446024388074875,
0.10063757002353668,
-0.38663795590400696,
0.4252251982688904,
-0.9067480564117432,
1.0719431638717651,
-0.27239349484443665,
-0.6467238664627075,
0.0046983943320810795,
-0.3614191710948944,
0.8220331072807312,
-0.16459456086158752,
0.3514745533466339,
-0.69755619764328,
0.19391730427742004,
0.5974587798118591,
-0.7963482141494751,
0.6033912301063538,
-0.6344807147979736,
-0.1207893118262291,
0.5129417777061462,
0.3092445731163025,
0.5383241176605225,
0.2021821141242981,
-0.3234153687953949,
0.11387882381677628,
-0.20310400426387787,
-0.3580950200557709,
-0.5629713535308838,
0.7594693899154663,
-0.8756750822067261,
-0.6385248303413391,
-0.1439637690782547,
-0.3359452784061432,
-0.25397947430610657,
0.22419078648090363,
0.2367151528596878,
0.27885809540748596,
-0.04699508845806122,
-0.002199874259531498,
0.15500526130199432,
-0.48479437828063965,
0.251609206199646,
0.8807783126831055,
-0.24939654767513275,
-0.4000357985496521,
0.6643757224082947,
0.17264620959758759,
0.3488975167274475,
-0.12017828971147537,
0.19207832217216492,
-0.057893190532922745,
-0.9575315713882446,
-0.41595780849456787,
0.24339522421360016,
-0.4830494821071625,
-0.603195071220398,
-0.2660287320613861,
-0.21670539677143097,
-0.3018456995487213,
-0.14417828619480133,
-0.6367753744125366,
-0.35449719429016113,
0.01429393608123064,
-0.2893241047859192,
0.359792560338974,
0.6184772849082947,
-0.12555813789367676,
0.17987850308418274,
-0.6640307903289795,
0.5769803524017334,
0.09821422398090363,
0.5251336097717285,
-0.28203144669532776,
-1.0149863958358765,
-0.24106545746326447,
-0.12651656568050385,
-0.5127902030944824,
-0.7581185698509216,
0.24895384907722473,
0.017718272283673286,
0.38972926139831543,
0.4157896637916565,
0.26099565625190735,
0.9228792190551758,
-0.48909273743629456,
0.7355571389198303,
0.3671150505542755,
-0.8699022531509399,
0.8117799758911133,
-0.38601285219192505,
0.2528221011161804,
0.870236337184906,
0.12831270694732666,
-0.2644169330596924,
-1.0395408868789673,
-0.37680572271347046,
-1.0545400381088257,
0.42512738704681396,
0.11937572062015533,
0.4347243309020996,
-0.22818687558174133,
0.4442325830459595,
0.012769756838679314,
0.3079580068588257,
-0.8557594418525696,
-0.1286039501428604,
-0.34354323148727417,
0.06751232594251633,
-0.22128364443778992,
-0.2691403925418854,
-0.0018223545048385859,
-0.34286391735076904,
0.4397411048412323,
0.11265365779399872,
0.17585088312625885,
-0.04227367043495178,
-0.17575907707214355,
-0.2625909447669983,
0.5522469282150269,
0.4774602949619293,
0.46886324882507324,
-0.7025728225708008,
0.2206445038318634,
-0.07831002026796341,
-0.5536468029022217,
0.6385180354118347,
0.042808886617422104,
-0.17599020898342133,
-0.2154371589422226,
0.27887725830078125,
0.4540213346481323,
0.05552445352077484,
-0.9789457321166992,
0.9320493340492249,
0.01199394091963768,
-0.20134246349334717,
-0.00504866149276495,
0.38535165786743164,
-0.16361689567565918,
0.1724281907081604,
0.2629975378513336,
0.039069484919309616,
0.1590760499238968,
-0.7024095058441162,
0.3410724103450775,
0.3169272243976593,
-0.5078365802764893,
-0.3383295238018036,
0.9003485441207886,
0.16402079164981842,
-0.04418976232409477,
0.8457754850387573,
-0.2035086452960968,
-0.13570179045200348,
0.5280875563621521,
0.6029223799705505,
0.7924694418907166,
-0.21530988812446594,
0.2884442210197449,
0.446431428194046,
0.49588897824287415,
-0.2574484348297119,
0.22186720371246338,
0.14089816808700562,
-0.8116511702537537,
-0.6064973473548889,
-0.6695133447647095,
-0.3737504184246063,
0.549901008605957,
-0.6834656596183777,
0.19910573959350586,
-0.7970518469810486,
-0.24830710887908936,
-0.0188905019313097,
-0.12002985924482346,
-0.29292285442352295,
0.09237778186798096,
0.04904735088348389,
1.008506178855896,
-0.8267942070960999,
0.755815327167511,
0.523296058177948,
-0.5714423060417175,
-0.6673790812492371,
-0.40785685181617737,
0.13577701151371002,
-0.630876898765564,
0.5508452653884888,
0.4851686656475067,
0.20453546941280365,
-0.30348876118659973,
-0.678260087966919,
-0.7371748089790344,
0.5476109981536865,
0.7181366086006165,
-0.5972265601158142,
0.025660967454314232,
0.05728347226977348,
0.41393473744392395,
0.19132335484027863,
0.26670175790786743,
0.47991514205932617,
0.4724074900150299,
-0.295647531747818,
-0.85560542345047,
0.17393368482589722,
-0.44287019968032837,
-0.41799694299697876,
0.6668627858161926,
-0.5872902274131775,
0.7294976711273193,
-0.5985890030860901,
-0.00991656444966793,
0.5987960696220398,
0.28829604387283325,
0.1698017716407776,
0.2251424342393875,
0.04130135476589203,
1.0021735429763794,
0.42011067271232605,
-0.28645336627960205,
0.9684171676635742,
-0.11341358721256256,
0.378030002117157,
1.3208978176116943,
-0.4414292275905609,
0.986878514289856,
0.5792508721351624,
-0.18537530303001404,
0.36325204372406006,
0.21812117099761963,
-0.5129219889640808,
0.7313368916511536,
0.6936339139938354,
-0.2351837456226349,
-0.14515459537506104,
0.14970791339874268,
-0.2253631055355072,
0.43656304478645325,
0.14205437898635864,
-0.27917301654815674,
-0.46002963185310364,
0.28124678134918213,
0.12793979048728943,
0.06953499466180801,
-0.35506531596183777,
0.6735436320304871,
0.21389785408973694,
-0.5283743143081665,
0.67955082654953,
0.4694388508796692,
0.6934192180633545,
-0.49592217803001404,
0.23818078637123108,
-0.6555237174034119,
0.3058581054210663,
-0.38485923409461975,
-0.9471274018287659,
0.30466145277023315,
0.543154776096344,
0.0011802924564108253,
0.04831143468618393,
0.6967295408248901,
0.1400984823703766,
-0.2517843544483185,
0.600486159324646,
0.5558974146842957,
0.39685314893722534,
-0.15721116960048676,
-0.7192730903625488,
0.05368565768003464,
-0.2949020564556122,
-0.4421878457069397,
0.5338906645774841,
0.18252117931842804,
0.24508428573608398,
0.7271127700805664,
0.4573504328727722,
0.25890710949897766,
-0.05432187020778656,
0.09900081902742386,
0.9608057737350464,
-0.7805597186088562,
0.02654223144054413,
-1.0341330766677856,
0.4964570105075836,
-0.020587652921676636,
-0.4364204406738281,
1.0703039169311523,
0.7865297794342041,
0.765034019947052,
0.2920112609863281,
0.6825506687164307,
-0.1704813838005066,
0.5013782382011414,
-0.38150861859321594,
0.6163976192474365,
-0.6381369233131409,
0.4671066105365753,
-0.7772332429885864,
-0.7433440685272217,
-0.3504028022289276,
0.5387786030769348,
-0.413102388381958,
-0.017273198813199997,
0.38863879442214966,
0.818096399307251,
-0.16051673889160156,
-0.3116702437400818,
0.6015108227729797,
0.2758253514766693,
0.34703126549720764,
0.581169068813324,
1.0339299440383911,
-0.5572751760482788,
0.6960604190826416,
-0.2798186242580414,
0.08196953684091568,
-0.07858581095933914,
-0.6395873427391052,
-0.9902507066726685,
-0.0512080118060112,
-0.190131276845932,
-0.5493353605270386,
0.47032275795936584,
0.4621693789958954,
0.6278174519538879,
-0.8489713072776794,
-0.3686009645462036,
-0.20758138597011566,
0.05180925875902176,
0.13200463354587555,
-0.24189001321792603,
-0.0561027005314827,
-0.2715129256248474,
-0.1831197291612625,
0.6096569299697876,
0.24255460500717163,
0.18282854557037354,
-0.16039249300956726,
-0.05617383494973183,
0.16058781743049622,
-0.08158251643180847,
0.5691267251968384,
0.47569751739501953,
-0.4911711812019348,
-0.49179381132125854,
-0.10432057827711105,
-0.09612342715263367,
0.2980727255344391,
0.8665206432342529,
-0.6024128794670105,
0.27762219309806824,
0.13938498497009277,
0.5087187886238098,
0.4999217689037323,
0.29968753457069397,
0.31476491689682007,
-0.7814321517944336,
0.27638137340545654,
0.26259416341781616,
0.36288681626319885,
0.3238885998725891,
-0.13054461777210236,
0.45484012365341187,
0.1623680144548416,
-0.5334814786911011,
-1.1209337711334229,
0.31471166014671326,
-0.4887202978134155,
-0.5297574996948242,
1.096145749092102,
-0.3457334637641907,
-0.21825388073921204,
-0.16177567839622498,
0.13066662847995758,
-0.19526149332523346,
-0.573710560798645,
0.7915805578231812,
0.7273058891296387,
-0.002537952736020088,
-0.27134472131729126,
-0.8064829111099243,
0.12235327810049057,
0.2995164394378662,
-0.8805246353149414,
0.39199456572532654,
0.7508143782615662,
0.45761239528656006,
0.04457440227270126,
0.4768202304840088,
-0.5510665774345398,
0.25962257385253906,
-0.1170729398727417,
0.03981428220868111,
-0.27364209294319153,
-0.4041122496128082,
-0.29556313157081604,
0.44169700145721436,
0.4495771527290344,
0.16220234334468842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10200v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10200v2 | Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Without Prompting | 2024-02-15T18:55:41 | 2024-05-23T20:53:59 | Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In enhancing the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs),
prior research primarily focuses on specific prompting techniques such as
few-shot or zero-shot chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. These methods, while
effective, often involve manually intensive prompt engineering. Our study takes
a novel approach by asking: Can LLMs reason effectively without prompting? Our
findings reveal that, intriguingly, CoT reasoning paths can be elicited from
pre-trained LLMs by simply altering the \textit{decoding} process. Rather than
conventional greedy decoding, we investigate the top-$k$ alternative tokens,
uncovering that CoT paths are frequently inherent in these sequences. This
approach not only bypasses the confounders of prompting but also allows us to
assess the LLMs' \textit{intrinsic} reasoning abilities. Moreover, we observe
that the presence of a CoT in the decoding path correlates with a higher
confidence in the model's decoded answer. This confidence metric effectively
differentiates between CoT and non-CoT paths. Extensive empirical studies on
various reasoning benchmarks show that the proposed CoT-decoding effectively
elicits reasoning capabilities from language models, which were previously
obscured by standard greedy decoding. | [
-0.46011021733283997,
-0.8927274942398071,
1.0668612718582153,
-0.01599871553480625,
-0.6675823330879211,
0.2609036862850189,
-0.3157978951931,
-0.37276145815849304,
0.14558778703212738,
0.5903838276863098,
-0.7758107781410217,
-0.3026893734931946,
-0.5682653188705444,
0.27964431047439575,
-0.39879462122917175,
0.7599005103111267,
-0.1873297393321991,
0.0031252794433385134,
-0.15667836368083954,
0.23309512436389923,
-0.4183278977870941,
-0.5235011577606201,
-0.5227561593055725,
-0.29468896985054016,
0.9054403901100159,
0.3477569818496704,
0.4812464118003845,
0.46395570039749146,
0.13012279570102692,
0.15499603748321533,
-0.3041039705276489,
0.5964187979698181,
-0.47268202900886536,
0.197186678647995,
-0.32190918922424316,
-0.736453652381897,
-0.39567455649375916,
-0.0522962287068367,
0.43737301230430603,
0.6375874280929565,
0.13976885378360748,
-0.007000702433288097,
0.07318266481161118,
0.8459929823875427,
-0.9882248044013977,
-0.340763658285141,
-1.1286990642547607,
-0.04024605453014374,
-0.007760284468531609,
-0.6727017760276794,
-0.9010477066040039,
-0.11838550865650177,
-0.11919350922107697,
-0.29108062386512756,
-0.09874160587787628,
0.20118460059165955,
0.6080315709114075,
0.2257387489080429,
-0.383992463350296,
-0.49225685000419617,
-0.7367224097251892,
0.6554517149925232,
-0.3122715651988983,
0.367037296295166,
0.5435488224029541,
0.09611400961875916,
-0.38974708318710327,
-0.44623449444770813,
-0.6332241296768188,
-0.37750864028930664,
0.05248391255736351,
0.051385704427957535,
-0.0841757208108902,
0.32035696506500244,
0.45731449127197266,
0.2144966870546341,
-0.30326274037361145,
-0.15027117729187012,
-0.1811627745628357,
-0.04019869863986969,
0.3333904445171356,
-0.0026210907381027937,
0.1040738895535469,
-0.023402605205774307,
-0.5249404907226562,
-0.11574497818946838,
-0.9266219735145569,
0.0883355364203453,
0.2066120207309723,
0.1476127952337265,
0.07497192919254303,
0.6688913702964783,
-0.14247651398181915,
0.7386889457702637,
0.11720847338438034,
0.2298874408006668,
-0.2572667598724365,
-0.3686157166957855,
-0.2722712755203247,
0.16321305930614471,
0.6218161582946777,
-0.025879789143800735,
0.43421077728271484,
-0.28817349672317505,
-0.3736706078052521,
0.18496589362621307,
0.17467395961284637,
-0.3135964870452881,
-0.11442920565605164,
0.3319292664527893,
-0.20789718627929688,
-0.2244652360677719,
-0.0894593745470047,
-0.47748252749443054,
-0.2965700328350067,
-0.1400594860315323,
0.3165493607521057,
-0.42339739203453064,
-0.2613474428653717,
0.24425315856933594,
-0.340931236743927,
0.5459413528442383,
0.23282398283481598,
-0.7190314531326294,
0.10713094472885132,
0.6321828365325928,
0.8644202947616577,
0.08222075551748276,
-0.12300298362970352,
-0.6441361308097839,
0.17182864248752594,
-0.7908071875572205,
1.0099681615829468,
-0.5789762735366821,
-0.4163699746131897,
-0.27941250801086426,
-0.2903432846069336,
0.005353920161724091,
-0.22093060612678528,
0.4360907971858978,
-0.6995311379432678,
-0.26616302132606506,
-0.6501227021217346,
-0.5019055604934692,
0.029032334685325623,
0.5575225949287415,
-0.49976789951324463,
0.7386757731437683,
-0.16938823461532593,
-0.610874593257904,
0.3626548945903778,
-0.45964640378952026,
-0.3907127380371094,
-0.09053383022546768,
-0.3354601562023163,
0.1795111447572708,
0.2502984404563904,
0.7488760948181152,
0.1998700350522995,
-0.27293670177459717,
0.3094092011451721,
-0.41269779205322266,
-0.4010586440563202,
0.5344426035881042,
-0.895968496799469,
0.9095620512962341,
0.17794828116893768,
-0.45798882842063904,
-0.014363489113748074,
-0.601909875869751,
0.270499050617218,
0.12972714006900787,
-0.0256295595318079,
-0.3704533576965332,
-0.12309227138757706,
-0.6552976369857788,
0.33479130268096924,
0.13822349905967712,
-0.30350232124328613,
0.5154882669448853,
-0.4412264823913574,
0.19839447736740112,
1.1293872594833374,
0.20226383209228516,
0.4741829037666321,
-0.3674556016921997,
0.7736234664916992,
-0.013605935499072075,
0.12272132188081741,
-0.19052354991436005,
-0.6037643551826477,
-0.8998352289199829,
-0.23816685378551483,
0.049685679376125336,
0.34980976581573486,
-1.0480659008026123,
0.3279467523097992,
0.033842019736766815,
-0.3426445722579956,
-0.46675923466682434,
0.1079539805650711,
0.44829797744750977,
0.4734799265861511,
0.36738017201423645,
0.07917161285877228,
-0.668244481086731,
-0.23416586220264435,
-0.4077705442905426,
-0.2456335574388504,
0.1620466411113739,
0.23562881350517273,
0.3733147382736206,
0.080108143389225,
0.7910146117210388,
-0.49405550956726074,
0.4210992753505707,
-0.5243289470672607,
0.013868763111531734,
0.37477797269821167,
0.2852496802806854,
0.12176287174224854,
-0.4076944589614868,
-0.2463844269514084,
-0.1555052250623703,
-0.6814815998077393,
-0.05729341879487038,
-0.40512821078300476,
-0.6718714833259583,
0.02320757322013378,
0.5865822434425354,
-0.8894087672233582,
0.5728475451469421,
0.16856306791305542,
-0.41599270701408386,
0.8112502694129944,
-0.2921815812587738,
0.18038710951805115,
-0.5963190197944641,
0.060038208961486816,
-0.4592241644859314,
-0.17239616811275482,
-0.3680424094200134,
0.1303575485944748,
-0.04655539616942406,
0.1898653358221054,
-0.41550782322883606,
0.5533411502838135,
-0.6220236420631409,
-0.08387977629899979,
-0.46022212505340576,
0.22033609449863434,
0.2444513440132141,
0.5804228782653809,
0.1567428708076477,
0.7878099083900452,
0.7644173502922058,
-1.002550482749939,
0.189772829413414,
0.18025824427604675,
-0.28678658604621887,
0.3907776474952698,
-0.5919035077095032,
0.5727826952934265,
-0.26117733120918274,
0.5945948362350464,
-0.9500827789306641,
0.07058590650558472,
0.3261278569698334,
-0.3874346613883972,
-0.07980603724718094,
-0.20363637804985046,
-0.5311166048049927,
-0.5161495208740234,
-0.24247176945209503,
0.5720319151878357,
0.6445825695991516,
-0.7938650846481323,
0.39473584294319153,
-0.14201246201992035,
0.36344268918037415,
-0.6643556952476501,
-0.6635124683380127,
0.1637907773256302,
-0.09629266709089279,
-0.3731328547000885,
0.07862205803394318,
-0.2314700186252594,
-0.18619707226753235,
-0.17175506055355072,
-0.2322450876235962,
-0.08597957342863083,
0.07045060396194458,
0.015228156931698322,
0.6019067168235779,
-0.11952418088912964,
0.15367165207862854,
0.17918480932712555,
-0.12247825413942337,
0.20157550275325775,
-0.5959078669548035,
0.696089506149292,
-0.033755701035261154,
-0.3508980870246887,
-0.3862071931362152,
0.1350732296705246,
0.5992560982704163,
-0.2240997850894928,
0.7788772583007812,
0.23206330835819244,
-0.3216055631637573,
-0.44707030057907104,
-0.38378414511680603,
-0.29702675342559814,
-0.5390104651451111,
-0.42434507608413696,
-0.533980667591095,
-0.8399396538734436,
0.3752031922340393,
-0.21075758337974548,
-0.23163650929927826,
0.02569788321852684,
0.4724201261997223,
-0.1336064636707306,
1.221832036972046,
0.20707519352436066,
0.13125236332416534,
0.29349029064178467,
-0.48831096291542053,
0.4716881215572357,
-1.005584716796875,
-0.26872000098228455,
-0.29254886507987976,
-0.20113788545131683,
-0.3342954218387604,
-0.40815991163253784,
0.47797542810440063,
0.40044260025024414,
-0.1869076043367386,
0.2824435830116272,
-0.5889999866485596,
0.8325312733650208,
0.33976316452026367,
0.3934052288532257,
0.27275654673576355,
-0.17093431949615479,
-0.577653706073761,
0.6235513687133789,
-0.8323579430580139,
-0.5431978106498718,
1.0116912126541138,
0.043447040021419525,
0.7501886487007141,
-0.14279747009277344,
0.7989727258682251,
0.16859985888004303,
-0.017910271883010864,
-0.9066981673240662,
0.8391808271408081,
0.22439810633659363,
-0.5954631567001343,
-0.18481457233428955,
-0.47010815143585205,
-1.0810365676879883,
0.1928223967552185,
-0.25246673822402954,
-0.9760175347328186,
0.17314602434635162,
0.4000343382358551,
-0.597333550453186,
0.5811453461647034,
-0.5657376050949097,
0.41601312160491943,
-0.3676145076751709,
-0.3794808089733124,
-0.17791244387626648,
-0.37185510993003845,
0.516747236251831,
0.2349526286125183,
0.11044668406248093,
0.02155873365700245,
-0.03495267406105995,
0.49163562059402466,
-0.6113972067832947,
0.5561833381652832,
-0.10309349000453949,
-0.24861586093902588,
0.762485146522522,
0.3535873591899872,
0.8073697090148926,
-0.08361479640007019,
-0.05829070881009102,
-0.22206096351146698,
-0.22292044758796692,
-0.43052053451538086,
-0.927236020565033,
0.6206439733505249,
-0.36163392663002014,
-0.887128472328186,
-0.2749099135398865,
-0.5332536101341248,
-0.49228134751319885,
0.172001913189888,
0.40796396136283875,
0.39737528562545776,
0.21194441616535187,
-0.16943968832492828,
0.6051702499389648,
-0.07165942341089249,
0.43963998556137085,
0.008866150863468647,
-0.1766461282968521,
-0.3725339472293854,
0.6104552149772644,
-0.06267945468425751,
0.6098624467849731,
0.3878592252731323,
0.4231606423854828,
-0.6247416138648987,
-0.43199634552001953,
-0.49518874287605286,
0.1306716352701187,
-0.8703215718269348,
-0.07755831629037857,
-0.6247520446777344,
-0.1356183886528015,
-0.18373702466487885,
-0.4588049352169037,
-0.3031771183013916,
-0.3389729857444763,
-0.23499298095703125,
-0.386542946100235,
0.46415579319000244,
0.796351969242096,
0.08367898315191269,
0.12104331701993942,
-0.769333004951477,
0.3481816053390503,
0.31087058782577515,
0.28358301520347595,
0.5155221819877625,
-0.23108305037021637,
0.049471739679574966,
0.2484765499830246,
-0.21737229824066162,
-0.8331391215324402,
0.14188122749328613,
-0.4107038080692291,
0.4312419891357422,
0.5174329280853271,
0.37631598114967346,
1.0326000452041626,
-0.4984334409236908,
0.8903034329414368,
0.33249273896217346,
-1.225476861000061,
0.8320959806442261,
-0.20669394731521606,
0.4008946716785431,
0.48656535148620605,
0.33339399099349976,
-0.09052804112434387,
-0.544911801815033,
-0.6473293900489807,
-0.6638156771659851,
0.47897106409072876,
0.2609387934207916,
-0.07227201759815216,
-0.5142430663108826,
0.3523247241973877,
0.05637812986969948,
0.016414418816566467,
-0.7426121234893799,
0.05354950949549675,
0.03790302947163582,
0.137374147772789,
0.3150525987148285,
-0.14294007420539856,
0.0366053506731987,
-0.3900088369846344,
0.4948555529117584,
-0.03840986639261246,
0.38772818446159363,
0.556952178478241,
-0.13739769160747528,
-0.17765067517757416,
0.38159114122390747,
0.47343143820762634,
0.7417513132095337,
-0.04108266532421112,
0.6668305397033691,
0.3857576847076416,
-0.04262329265475273,
0.4427723288536072,
-0.7963321208953857,
0.014448368921875954,
-0.11104677617549896,
0.5028823614120483,
0.8357158303260803,
-0.022436270490288734,
-0.6771093606948853,
0.4722190797328949,
0.09239405393600464,
-0.22161009907722473,
-0.07717191427946091,
0.33491072058677673,
-0.09107039868831635,
0.17872054874897003,
0.21956469118595123,
0.14831757545471191,
-0.06880226731300354,
-0.6319024562835693,
0.11030665785074234,
0.49641746282577515,
-0.43250781297683716,
-0.1454072892665863,
0.4648013412952423,
0.005347666330635548,
-0.25672903656959534,
0.5878456830978394,
-0.32516956329345703,
-0.49684178829193115,
0.536028265953064,
0.6066617369651794,
0.8890631794929504,
0.14751945436000824,
0.1813189834356308,
0.2942200005054474,
0.42715370655059814,
-0.2672550082206726,
0.40591707825660706,
-0.38722527027130127,
-0.7718421220779419,
-0.6583660244941711,
-0.29304760694503784,
-0.34296759963035583,
0.0406063012778759,
-0.6223116517066956,
0.3247728943824768,
-0.7702929973602295,
-0.15476073324680328,
-0.37152788043022156,
-0.47713813185691833,
-0.6446853876113892,
0.1414986550807953,
0.24638786911964417,
1.1531479358673096,
-0.4511169493198395,
0.7925183176994324,
0.21913573145866394,
-0.30155158042907715,
-1.0635035037994385,
0.24609535932540894,
-0.35260966420173645,
-0.9268842935562134,
0.33121949434280396,
0.22980348765850067,
-0.7674930095672607,
0.04126328229904175,
-0.9245468378067017,
-0.6777240037918091,
0.9375738501548767,
0.44876018166542053,
-0.5657303333282471,
-0.10927508771419525,
-0.10333183407783508,
0.2622351050376892,
-0.3584900498390198,
0.5076754093170166,
0.589744508266449,
0.4153677821159363,
0.49791228771209717,
-0.6265912055969238,
0.3298792243003845,
0.007255427539348602,
-0.11586681008338928,
0.19223102927207947,
-0.3013177514076233,
0.6962273120880127,
-0.49749183654785156,
-0.3780561685562134,
0.14330074191093445,
0.32929757237434387,
0.634529709815979,
0.2950596511363983,
0.6129405498504639,
0.3490432798862457,
1.0407203435897827,
0.272926926612854,
1.233603835105896,
-0.3021230399608612,
0.03933064639568329,
0.99908447265625,
-0.31336671113967896,
0.8302338719367981,
0.7377133369445801,
-0.03290889039635658,
0.9650934338569641,
0.4274362623691559,
0.4748712182044983,
0.6556222438812256,
0.19894570112228394,
-0.3790428340435028,
-0.7715163230895996,
-0.07863615453243256,
-0.14471064507961273,
0.39673563838005066,
0.4168546199798584,
-0.24488984048366547,
-0.025894859805703163,
-0.09457729756832123,
-0.06370505690574646,
0.006383661646395922,
-0.6204255819320679,
0.6522104740142822,
0.4052691161632538,
-0.9837026596069336,
1.1256157159805298,
-0.3882710039615631,
0.5235762000083923,
-0.6275442242622375,
-0.06068370118737221,
0.08336778730154037,
-0.15394240617752075,
-0.12593045830726624,
-0.817640483379364,
0.14391112327575684,
0.3236849009990692,
0.07239492237567902,
-0.30007171630859375,
0.7671974897384644,
-0.2260124832391739,
-0.4265860319137573,
0.34375596046447754,
0.7143135070800781,
0.20124076306819916,
0.013775010593235493,
-0.4554770886898041,
0.05171997845172882,
-0.1813511997461319,
-0.08766456693410873,
-0.019919155165553093,
0.6206088662147522,
0.020415928214788437,
0.8320004940032959,
0.9882772564888,
0.24860914051532745,
-0.09656167030334473,
0.15326064825057983,
1.0659677982330322,
-0.8641760349273682,
-0.6603648066520691,
-1.3044929504394531,
0.5062582492828369,
0.006324696820229292,
-0.127876877784729,
0.5293633341789246,
0.0893905833363533,
0.7209175229072571,
-0.010368387214839458,
0.7960808873176575,
0.2159545123577118,
-0.0755099281668663,
-0.9836469292640686,
0.4473065435886383,
-0.32676756381988525,
0.46118953824043274,
-0.2763362228870392,
-0.625649631023407,
-0.1407860964536667,
0.6367077827453613,
-0.5404980182647705,
0.017199300229549408,
1.128450632095337,
0.7679184079170227,
0.16593976318836212,
0.24195094406604767,
0.39699897170066833,
0.09422332793474197,
0.24257944524288177,
0.9079394340515137,
1.317350149154663,
0.02547711692750454,
0.6084972023963928,
0.18211334943771362,
-0.33327504992485046,
0.12802842259407043,
-1.0123692750930786,
-1.1843887567520142,
-0.20431235432624817,
-0.0064799366518855095,
-0.5012701749801636,
0.10834792256355286,
1.119067668914795,
0.42969393730163574,
-0.5745803713798523,
-0.10341066867113113,
-0.8911295533180237,
0.6279259920120239,
-0.4390973150730133,
-0.15024666488170624,
0.1533677726984024,
-0.4412042796611786,
-0.23377276957035065,
0.6649553179740906,
0.32941240072250366,
0.04494118690490723,
-0.36313095688819885,
-0.23741020262241364,
-0.321776419878006,
0.5388119220733643,
0.6315360069274902,
-0.030389446765184402,
-0.9277399182319641,
-0.4471539855003357,
0.25653982162475586,
0.10116253048181534,
0.07653044164180756,
1.1322963237762451,
-0.9909264445304871,
0.5071406960487366,
0.5143322348594666,
0.4659719169139862,
0.3640955090522766,
-0.13950198888778687,
0.6945124864578247,
-0.6043421626091003,
0.11856822669506073,
0.3283701241016388,
0.4119753837585449,
0.027684485539793968,
-0.6325332522392273,
0.2442954182624817,
0.25394508242607117,
-0.35050180554389954,
-0.7612685561180115,
0.4912364184856415,
-1.0135118961334229,
-0.36260637640953064,
1.3670721054077148,
-0.17272719740867615,
-0.5250297784805298,
-0.08316899836063385,
-0.41968581080436707,
0.2817728519439697,
-0.20745398104190826,
0.642011284828186,
0.8660340309143066,
-0.28123703598976135,
-0.3927072286605835,
-0.04303963482379913,
0.3160785734653473,
0.36820682883262634,
-0.6668621301651001,
0.1480865478515625,
0.14509540796279907,
-0.09170675277709961,
-0.0784560963511467,
0.9039199352264404,
-0.05421168729662895,
0.3728671967983246,
0.17164437472820282,
-0.4028438329696655,
-0.07240456342697144,
-0.5464079976081848,
-0.15652510523796082,
-0.04662078619003296,
0.34324878454208374,
-0.13576607406139374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10196v1 | A Trembling House of Cards? Mapping Adversarial Attacks against Language Agents | 2024-02-15T18:51:32 | 2024-02-15T18:51:32 | Lingbo Mo, Zeyi Liao, Boyuan Zheng, Yu Su, Chaowei Xiao, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have seen exploding
development. Their capability of using language as a vehicle for thought and
communication lends an incredible level of flexibility and versatility. People
have quickly capitalized on this capability to connect LLMs to a wide range of
external components and environments: databases, tools, the Internet, robotic
embodiment, etc. Many believe an unprecedentedly powerful automation technology
is emerging. However, new automation technologies come with new safety risks,
especially for intricate systems like language agents. There is a surprisingly
large gap between the speed and scale of their development and deployment and
our understanding of their safety risks. Are we building a house of cards? In
this position paper, we present the first systematic effort in mapping
adversarial attacks against language agents. We first present a unified
conceptual framework for agents with three major components: Perception, Brain,
and Action. Under this framework, we present a comprehensive discussion and
propose 12 potential attack scenarios against different components of an agent,
covering different attack strategies (e.g., input manipulation, adversarial
demonstrations, jailbreaking, backdoors). We also draw connections to
successful attack strategies previously applied to LLMs. We emphasize the
urgency to gain a thorough understanding of language agent risks before their
widespread deployment. | [
-0.5888012647628784,
-0.962692141532898,
0.3987826704978943,
-0.08578070253133774,
0.17513155937194824,
0.3640884757041931,
-0.11924382299184799,
-0.26955652236938477,
0.08660320192575455,
0.8532452583312988,
-0.1973239630460739,
-0.44741663336753845,
-1.0245862007141113,
-0.3926701843738556,
-0.5430945158004761,
0.932020366191864,
0.1371852606534958,
-0.21433258056640625,
0.11955152451992035,
0.11377181112766266,
-0.16036595404148102,
-0.5535376071929932,
-0.7123573422431946,
-0.4473784565925598,
0.504410982131958,
0.02535008080303669,
1.5696232318878174,
0.7986629605293274,
0.5011422634124756,
0.39939382672309875,
0.09257270395755768,
-0.42744389176368713,
-0.38341715931892395,
0.2264651209115982,
-0.02476022206246853,
-0.584940493106842,
-0.7533054947853088,
0.1274375468492508,
0.4125509262084961,
0.7065515518188477,
-0.16613373160362244,
-0.04724866896867752,
-0.04438064992427826,
0.6555836200714111,
-0.3873119652271271,
0.11929832398891449,
-0.8172774910926819,
0.07805967330932617,
-0.28206372261047363,
-0.3556612432003021,
-0.5070700645446777,
-0.12261240929365158,
-0.11431825906038284,
-0.3676418662071228,
-0.033023666590452194,
0.11778861284255981,
0.7461766600608826,
0.5256147384643555,
-0.45192527770996094,
-0.2808271050453186,
-0.6393718123435974,
0.28140100836753845,
-0.35622549057006836,
0.005931560415774584,
0.45455819368362427,
0.42345425486564636,
-0.8304644227027893,
-0.46600374579429626,
-0.5579570531845093,
-0.44558605551719666,
0.05509829893708229,
0.037824686616659164,
-0.4970177710056305,
0.1847268044948578,
0.3429429531097412,
0.0965704396367073,
-0.5493436455726624,
0.06114187091588974,
-0.06952868402004242,
-0.15669620037078857,
0.8057278990745544,
0.276846319437027,
0.763859212398529,
0.38941383361816406,
-0.45568713545799255,
-0.5388234853744507,
-0.7222261428833008,
-0.22700174152851105,
0.9281637072563171,
0.4056720435619354,
-0.1204918622970581,
0.37975654006004333,
0.3555421531200409,
0.559065580368042,
-0.002049459842965007,
-0.28821948170661926,
-0.3212183117866516,
0.08960315585136414,
-0.09857044368982315,
0.17068815231323242,
0.8049330115318298,
0.2257176786661148,
0.39205285906791687,
-0.3863067030906677,
-0.21958386898040771,
0.3608201742172241,
0.794312059879303,
-0.21836958825588226,
-0.2295462191104889,
0.352504163980484,
-0.2260076403617859,
-0.6528911590576172,
-0.03659209609031677,
-1.0952272415161133,
-1.0556128025054932,
0.16876807808876038,
0.31457510590553284,
-0.1747891902923584,
-0.3959595263004303,
-0.1520017683506012,
-0.13902857899665833,
0.610672116279602,
-0.09638591855764389,
-0.8943822979927063,
0.8167866468429565,
0.7955251336097717,
0.2525283396244049,
-0.02273077704012394,
-0.6399412155151367,
-0.3395698070526123,
0.07186373323202133,
-0.5407876372337341,
0.48655128479003906,
-0.23777686059474945,
-0.6825170516967773,
0.17273716628551483,
-0.32401901483535767,
0.08869252353906631,
-0.33039963245391846,
0.21903139352798462,
-0.6106348633766174,
-0.23382529616355896,
0.16123463213443756,
-0.1043858528137207,
0.0875779390335083,
0.6643162369728088,
-0.8822298049926758,
0.6701259613037109,
0.003072829684242606,
-0.5557779669761658,
-0.08025161176919937,
-0.4733832776546478,
-0.7302831411361694,
-0.12369851022958755,
-0.2895398736000061,
-0.180815652012825,
-0.17412744462490082,
-0.03873363137245178,
0.4309929311275482,
-0.31217944622039795,
0.1648288071155548,
-0.29701095819473267,
-0.1973152458667755,
0.5209056735038757,
-0.6278800964355469,
0.9935417175292969,
0.36627140641212463,
-0.5259177684783936,
0.1380234807729721,
-0.4877074658870697,
-0.08580374717712402,
0.22602733969688416,
-0.19234713912010193,
-0.04430950805544853,
0.18920616805553436,
-0.3159010410308838,
0.1367485672235489,
0.23087681829929352,
-0.07307994365692139,
0.08857518434524536,
-0.3663380742073059,
0.06544514745473862,
0.7036048769950867,
-0.19757667183876038,
0.6830954551696777,
-0.37261325120925903,
0.8510615229606628,
-0.13079425692558289,
0.36947616934776306,
-0.10962999612092972,
-0.3850685954093933,
-0.5991348028182983,
-0.13387906551361084,
0.06870241463184357,
0.7277463674545288,
-0.704921305179596,
0.6781213879585266,
-0.24730870127677917,
-0.7811381220817566,
-0.433811753988266,
-0.034544214606285095,
0.2995494604110718,
-0.11706215888261795,
0.06300365179777145,
-0.018601590767502785,
-0.19820740818977356,
-0.3799133002758026,
-0.34499219059944153,
-0.4935072660446167,
0.18399758636951447,
-0.1631830930709839,
0.3345744013786316,
-0.284647136926651,
0.6844475269317627,
-0.3999149799346924,
-0.28864169120788574,
-0.4359322488307953,
-0.03719203546643257,
-0.2471676617860794,
0.3239172697067261,
0.529058575630188,
-0.6667324304580688,
-0.5337345600128174,
0.19295617938041687,
-0.7139618396759033,
0.3060743510723114,
-0.2825312614440918,
-0.11942470818758011,
0.15507210791110992,
0.7053284645080566,
-0.5495263934135437,
0.5165225267410278,
0.5571999549865723,
-0.3187355101108551,
0.04520736262202263,
-0.2013493925333023,
-0.3478813171386719,
-1.0930120944976807,
-0.13563521206378937,
-0.2163095772266388,
0.13936565816402435,
-1.0492839813232422,
0.4012889564037323,
-0.356375515460968,
-0.34602347016334534,
-0.38333797454833984,
0.8091500401496887,
-0.5306140184402466,
0.10641513019800186,
-0.39953121542930603,
0.34030377864837646,
-0.31925809383392334,
0.48604393005371094,
-0.2929562032222748,
0.25114279985427856,
0.8646713495254517,
-0.4423416554927826,
0.5392592549324036,
-0.18792039155960083,
0.1187128871679306,
0.4850064516067505,
-0.3051415979862213,
0.23161351680755615,
-0.06888586282730103,
0.16625523567199707,
-1.056465744972229,
-0.06028607860207558,
0.6321848630905151,
-0.6055048108100891,
0.6934595108032227,
0.200267031788826,
-0.4123360812664032,
-0.23961982131004333,
-0.4254312813282013,
-0.06913705915212631,
0.6270974278450012,
-0.4182186722755432,
1.057486653327942,
0.8108633756637573,
-0.00015895366959739476,
-0.8713172078132629,
-0.555809736251831,
0.34912097454071045,
-0.26332536339759827,
-0.32639145851135254,
0.05608415976166725,
0.17884045839309692,
-0.8137896060943604,
-0.0596148706972599,
0.07968506217002869,
-0.02776084467768669,
0.722641110420227,
0.6728155016899109,
-0.07663757354021072,
0.12404440343379974,
-0.14063216745853424,
-0.38399967551231384,
-0.30756041407585144,
0.4603477418422699,
-0.10423479229211807,
0.42423924803733826,
-0.31931886076927185,
-0.4766177535057068,
-0.08604634553194046,
0.2856817841529846,
0.8705056309700012,
-0.016736453399062157,
0.696332573890686,
0.47337761521339417,
-0.4696655869483948,
-0.29165664315223694,
-0.43109703063964844,
-0.10986839234828949,
-0.4741181433200836,
0.4225272536277771,
-0.3150430917739868,
-0.2995307147502899,
0.6526027321815491,
-0.10973870754241943,
0.13831181824207306,
0.2749997675418854,
0.5116754770278931,
0.0489017553627491,
0.9205672144889832,
0.7505233287811279,
-0.4647863209247589,
0.33678945899009705,
-0.19266510009765625,
0.45940524339675903,
-0.3438313603401184,
-0.19572094082832336,
-0.6301502585411072,
-0.3463675081729889,
-0.7293544411659241,
-0.2575549781322479,
0.14672325551509857,
-0.3457508683204651,
-0.03409045934677124,
0.2140163630247116,
-0.1834685206413269,
0.39973580837249756,
0.4953945577144623,
-0.2775818705558777,
0.11030399799346924,
-0.01765827089548111,
0.0430939607322216,
0.33102089166641235,
-0.7654306292533875,
-0.7840600609779358,
1.311410903930664,
0.705323338508606,
1.0557366609573364,
0.17531542479991913,
0.7085228562355042,
0.3792596459388733,
0.6199742555618286,
-0.7488458752632141,
0.7540012001991272,
0.09302884340286255,
-0.7271108031272888,
-0.5962305068969727,
0.03532921150326729,
-1.2728354930877686,
0.34214553236961365,
-0.24238480627536774,
-0.34660178422927856,
-0.07838467508554459,
0.0018567792139947414,
-0.2789453864097595,
0.5374110341072083,
-0.5330172777175903,
0.900860071182251,
-0.6335368752479553,
-0.1270705759525299,
-0.018510350957512856,
-0.9462211728096008,
0.21526004374027252,
-0.0394892543554306,
0.3954518437385559,
-0.02957898937165737,
-0.027477001771330833,
0.4324394166469574,
-0.27804070711135864,
1.1229326725006104,
-0.1136794462800026,
-0.4022497236728668,
0.4845414161682129,
0.10669475048780441,
0.5216819643974304,
-0.37034451961517334,
-0.10105837136507034,
0.09742017835378647,
-0.07039646059274673,
-0.5334307551383972,
-0.6203745007514954,
0.6439781785011292,
-0.954867422580719,
-0.6516798138618469,
-0.8259567022323608,
-0.40266090631484985,
-0.07914301007986069,
-0.031987208873033524,
-0.03789721801877022,
0.11447189748287201,
-0.7205126285552979,
-0.28238222002983093,
0.5402043461799622,
0.06304986029863358,
0.5124551057815552,
0.5111716389656067,
-0.02911766618490219,
-0.3919023871421814,
1.0742640495300293,
0.012069998309016228,
0.2857604920864105,
0.2622297406196594,
0.041181016713380814,
-0.1603640466928482,
-0.575544536113739,
-0.15565840899944305,
0.07520882040262222,
-0.7627534866333008,
-0.017873868346214294,
-0.3050452470779419,
-0.16338396072387695,
-0.483261376619339,
-0.2404545098543167,
-0.23435750603675842,
0.1461731642484665,
-0.017801037058234215,
-0.06223756819963455,
0.24534620344638824,
0.8127231597900391,
0.04859395697712898,
0.6409324407577515,
-0.44679340720176697,
0.3414629399776459,
0.4548550546169281,
0.1743163913488388,
0.012092433869838715,
-0.18927833437919617,
-0.18691964447498322,
0.053315434604883194,
-0.47495025396347046,
-1.1018505096435547,
0.3859096169471741,
-0.21574316918849945,
0.8911309838294983,
0.4884640872478485,
0.2899002134799957,
0.3057052791118622,
-0.4523841440677643,
0.7307208180427551,
0.06491914391517639,
-0.6569865942001343,
0.3246881365776062,
-0.23776446282863617,
0.001035305904224515,
0.40070486068725586,
0.34914830327033997,
-0.3770699203014374,
-0.6572202444076538,
-1.0920603275299072,
-0.7901042699813843,
0.41074293851852417,
-0.047153543680906296,
0.2681541442871094,
-0.1972694844007492,
0.12694083154201508,
-0.07034176588058472,
0.25976642966270447,
-0.7588002681732178,
-0.3996165096759796,
-0.1887025088071823,
-0.09411891549825668,
-0.18681609630584717,
0.054025471210479736,
-0.5068312287330627,
0.2464679777622223,
0.6235144734382629,
-0.1268477737903595,
0.03778405115008354,
-0.16527718305587769,
-0.16004303097724915,
-0.18336299061775208,
0.3482208549976349,
0.519201397895813,
0.32136446237564087,
0.21662528812885284,
0.4824928343296051,
0.07518263161182404,
-0.49919945001602173,
0.2530437707901001,
0.12209991365671158,
0.08168001472949982,
-0.34824034571647644,
0.49764594435691833,
0.642704427242279,
-0.0037251741159707308,
-0.7487632632255554,
0.5317532420158386,
-0.03011193312704563,
-0.20870530605316162,
-0.6017441749572754,
0.11229649186134338,
-0.12874729931354523,
0.3017343282699585,
0.012754087336361408,
0.06654199957847595,
-0.19238190352916718,
-0.9387158155441284,
0.0772964209318161,
0.7609837055206299,
-0.5742157697677612,
-0.28964024782180786,
0.45512697100639343,
0.31369471549987793,
-0.6757518649101257,
0.2780299186706543,
-0.2780939042568207,
-0.6584274768829346,
0.7332118153572083,
0.2580386996269226,
1.1997374296188354,
-0.42210742831230164,
0.10973592847585678,
-0.3349159359931946,
0.9055371284484863,
-0.11739473044872284,
0.08640281111001968,
0.05166180431842804,
-0.7622721791267395,
0.19304420053958893,
-0.25127458572387695,
-0.45772433280944824,
0.12738211452960968,
-0.5292806029319763,
0.05607818067073822,
-0.7500640749931335,
-0.3769308626651764,
-0.4284140467643738,
0.12084385007619858,
-0.3753925561904907,
0.009555860422551632,
0.4970826804637909,
0.765306293964386,
-0.9655218720436096,
0.7957955598831177,
0.7911322712898254,
-0.17246752977371216,
-0.501915454864502,
0.4290355443954468,
0.060646239668130875,
-0.5926128029823303,
0.4225361943244934,
-0.25873804092407227,
-0.42645207047462463,
0.0002721394703257829,
-0.4509078860282898,
-0.5933927297592163,
0.9244602918624878,
0.43685847520828247,
-0.04261837527155876,
0.14466089010238647,
0.26225677132606506,
0.8033978343009949,
-0.3093302845954895,
0.05657532438635826,
0.8811454772949219,
0.6244145631790161,
-0.1531987190246582,
-0.5870978832244873,
0.133857861161232,
-0.2940917909145355,
-0.13109026849269867,
0.3402065932750702,
-0.5084568858146667,
0.5318666696548462,
-0.23889215290546417,
-0.24317291378974915,
0.09848789125680923,
0.5397000908851624,
0.033150799572467804,
0.3899795711040497,
0.3711508512496948,
0.5499099493026733,
0.6122250556945801,
-0.30576789379119873,
1.151473045349121,
-0.5612884759902954,
-0.22640661895275116,
0.9359267950057983,
-0.6150908470153809,
0.9201086759567261,
0.5299349427223206,
-0.21754190325737,
0.10895412415266037,
0.33657389879226685,
0.10680164396762848,
0.18858475983142853,
0.789445698261261,
-0.11393631249666214,
-0.051216743886470795,
0.11933577060699463,
-0.345608651638031,
0.3759477734565735,
0.6625450253486633,
-0.1477406620979309,
-0.27553731203079224,
0.08799099177122116,
0.40596213936805725,
0.5133647322654724,
-0.014451001770794392,
0.8621528148651123,
0.02035173773765564,
-0.6954312920570374,
0.4345002770423889,
-0.09421749413013458,
0.334406316280365,
-0.8448014855384827,
0.06317436695098877,
-0.05268405005335808,
0.19167497754096985,
0.1267102062702179,
-0.6753281354904175,
0.1564909964799881,
-0.1633233278989792,
0.17387636005878448,
-0.3470834195613861,
0.5090208053588867,
-0.42651113867759705,
-0.20079171657562256,
0.6398637294769287,
0.30837512016296387,
0.2687476873397827,
-0.06517461687326431,
-0.6754118800163269,
0.2994614839553833,
-0.4275597035884857,
-0.30394497513771057,
0.6117157936096191,
0.3647972643375397,
0.008380617015063763,
0.813576877117157,
0.34690818190574646,
0.31362926959991455,
0.24560941755771637,
-0.14282101392745972,
0.7299295663833618,
-0.5665121674537659,
-0.44535592198371887,
-0.9676618576049805,
0.35702332854270935,
-0.06200973689556122,
-0.050375111401081085,
0.7048006057739258,
0.06068002060055733,
0.6019031405448914,
0.036422956734895706,
0.8128551840782166,
0.14210300147533417,
-0.05986965820193291,
-0.32236623764038086,
1.1212859153747559,
-0.31608814001083374,
0.4023779332637787,
-0.19994665682315826,
-0.6468775272369385,
-0.4510878920555115,
0.36482399702072144,
-0.1128709465265274,
-0.19479995965957642,
0.7485909461975098,
0.917925238609314,
0.5334529876708984,
-0.181851327419281,
0.6092007756233215,
0.2887161672115326,
0.5092705488204956,
0.3093876242637634,
0.9432905912399292,
-0.6401464343070984,
0.9102736711502075,
-0.1546749323606491,
-0.19557933509349823,
-0.23531268537044525,
-0.7156142592430115,
-1.171649694442749,
-0.44368258118629456,
-0.46688923239707947,
-0.4291672706604004,
0.2754448652267456,
0.604779064655304,
0.3597937226295471,
-0.4717743396759033,
-0.5912694931030273,
0.17683590948581696,
0.4371482729911804,
-0.36900028586387634,
-0.12251383811235428,
0.22355453670024872,
-0.0781007707118988,
-0.6196096539497375,
0.382252961397171,
0.3018200099468231,
0.30150240659713745,
-0.7022440433502197,
-0.3195256292819977,
-0.13081128895282745,
0.2280511111021042,
0.23904727399349213,
0.6304135322570801,
-1.0703778266906738,
-0.07153169810771942,
-0.2400965839624405,
-0.3830460011959076,
-0.30342966318130493,
0.5588347911834717,
-0.6120067238807678,
0.44464072585105896,
0.3462640643119812,
0.7583880424499512,
-0.3923208713531494,
-0.15446363389492035,
0.6016781330108643,
-0.6450156569480896,
0.3096849024295807,
0.16988879442214966,
0.17281797528266907,
0.11899498850107193,
-0.49856099486351013,
0.370786190032959,
-0.06270663440227509,
-0.2736110985279083,
-0.8526824712753296,
0.3408850431442261,
-0.886417031288147,
-0.3094499707221985,
1.016998052597046,
0.12060502171516418,
-0.49133190512657166,
-0.32894858717918396,
-0.2834763526916504,
0.11601459980010986,
-0.25076502561569214,
0.8983799815177917,
0.7950537800788879,
0.36645177006721497,
0.3079374134540558,
-0.45044854283332825,
0.6428243517875671,
0.09930423647165298,
-0.7615041732788086,
0.17639680206775665,
0.060564443469047546,
-0.22409723699092865,
0.543405294418335,
0.6606805324554443,
-0.17243655025959015,
0.20638087391853333,
0.4930456578731537,
0.1892872303724289,
0.04674635827541351,
-0.6828145384788513,
-0.5951417088508606,
0.46499818563461304,
0.33223485946655273,
-0.21944811940193176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10193v2 | BitDelta: Your Fine-Tune May Only Be Worth One Bit | 2024-02-15T18:50:06 | 2024-02-28T03:42:10 | James Liu, Guangxuan Xiao, Kai Li, Jason D. Lee, Song Han, Tri Dao, Tianle Cai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are typically trained in two phases:
pre-training on large internet-scale datasets, and fine-tuning for downstream
tasks. Given the higher computational demand of pre-training, it's intuitive to
assume that fine-tuning adds less new information to the model, and is thus
more compressible. We explore this assumption by decomposing the weights of
fine-tuned models into their pre-trained components and an additional delta. We
introduce a simple method, BitDelta, which successfully quantizes this delta
down to 1 bit without compromising performance. This interesting finding not
only highlights the potential redundancy of information added during
fine-tuning, but also has significant implications for the multi-tenant serving
and multi-tenant storage of fine-tuned models. By enabling the use of a single
high-precision base model accompanied by multiple 1-bit deltas, BitDelta
dramatically reduces GPU memory requirements by more than 10x, which can also
be translated to enhanced generation latency in multi-tenant settings. We
validate BitDelta through experiments across Llama-2 and Mistral model
families, and on models up to 70B parameters, showcasing minimal performance
degradation over all tested settings. | [
-0.6140942573547363,
-0.8284577131271362,
0.32721570134162903,
0.17518949508666992,
-0.5431000590324402,
-0.16320912539958954,
-0.40150004625320435,
-0.41034573316574097,
0.18030469119548798,
0.6671370267868042,
-0.4812620282173157,
-0.1709429919719696,
-0.4316839575767517,
-0.23607365787029266,
-0.33321550488471985,
0.7143980264663696,
0.3500126302242279,
0.015509727410972118,
-0.01973332092165947,
-0.022626040503382683,
-0.5210275053977966,
-0.304149866104126,
-0.734119176864624,
-0.3226758539676666,
0.4751606583595276,
0.4727246165275574,
0.8271947503089905,
0.8651673197746277,
0.5546078681945801,
0.234078049659729,
-0.124034084379673,
0.33385682106018066,
-0.7448974847793579,
0.07195524871349335,
0.07431171834468842,
-0.6016512513160706,
-0.5585390329360962,
-0.23538213968276978,
0.6347095370292664,
0.6998440623283386,
-0.12178356945514679,
0.4099540114402771,
0.026647742837667465,
0.9766824245452881,
-0.875400722026825,
0.14320866763591766,
-0.7050023674964905,
-0.17520549893379211,
-0.042349543422460556,
-0.42916563153266907,
-0.25124454498291016,
-0.31597861647605896,
-0.19842490553855896,
-0.45715010166168213,
0.44741153717041016,
-0.09228182584047318,
0.9890876412391663,
0.6878460645675659,
-0.23357070982456207,
0.2576524615287781,
-0.8285156488418579,
0.46637722849845886,
-0.6892879605293274,
0.5327089428901672,
0.5887020826339722,
0.20211659371852875,
-0.007746631745249033,
-0.4509209990501404,
-0.5213667750358582,
0.04352463036775589,
0.18096321821212769,
-0.38478386402130127,
-0.2558014392852783,
0.23002195358276367,
0.11260423809289932,
0.5529926419258118,
-0.26271072030067444,
0.18872956931591034,
-0.39506492018699646,
-0.14447809755802155,
0.44684699177742004,
0.33583778142929077,
-0.20379428565502167,
0.16193710267543793,
-0.10157465189695358,
-0.1089944913983345,
-1.1709407567977905,
0.03318338096141815,
0.44839879870414734,
0.6921738982200623,
-0.04051494598388672,
0.4227418899536133,
-0.18914839625358582,
0.5447568893432617,
0.3395330011844635,
0.12566503882408142,
-0.22235792875289917,
-0.5313354134559631,
-0.2570103406906128,
0.15477696061134338,
0.5614624619483948,
0.267544686794281,
0.36446821689605713,
-0.2684904634952545,
-0.22484607994556427,
0.13185010850429535,
0.4438384175300598,
-1.4063035249710083,
-0.5220062136650085,
0.23563918471336365,
-0.39204663038253784,
-0.3040030300617218,
-0.21668657660484314,
-0.20338484644889832,
-0.4530307948589325,
-0.4085257351398468,
0.5189608335494995,
-0.2834722399711609,
-0.32120221853256226,
0.37834295630455017,
0.14983497560024261,
-0.0021670928690582514,
0.37380656599998474,
-1.085099697113037,
0.4279944896697998,
1.081214427947998,
0.9252305626869202,
0.11372224986553192,
-0.2692195773124695,
-0.5033010244369507,
-0.29120954871177673,
-0.7837393283843994,
0.6297302842140198,
-0.46032583713531494,
-0.2304420918226242,
-0.19388867914676666,
-0.13313984870910645,
0.3737732768058777,
-0.7534163594245911,
-0.03436075150966644,
-0.6904863715171814,
-0.5072218179702759,
-0.5279864072799683,
-0.5382465720176697,
-0.1973351687192917,
0.03581327199935913,
-1.0490821599960327,
0.8391146063804626,
0.38743433356285095,
-0.6550365686416626,
0.5148302316665649,
-0.3650437593460083,
-0.44409146904945374,
0.11956163495779037,
-0.047928594052791595,
-0.4995218813419342,
0.7293611764907837,
0.008162633515894413,
0.6595203280448914,
-0.45541849732398987,
0.22705844044685364,
-0.41783326864242554,
-0.6867080926895142,
0.060227278620004654,
-0.4150550067424774,
0.5522267818450928,
0.3233049213886261,
-0.12946170568466187,
-0.11503185331821442,
-0.9335581064224243,
-0.016322022303938866,
-0.19311311841011047,
-0.7899242043495178,
-0.2606467306613922,
0.006598514039069414,
-0.003444187343120575,
0.09519795328378677,
0.44342875480651855,
-0.556166410446167,
0.3608315587043762,
-0.289400190114975,
0.4963925778865814,
0.7364588975906372,
-0.07915416359901428,
0.2885136008262634,
-0.2922331392765045,
0.48326900601387024,
0.214799702167511,
-0.06540194898843765,
-0.03682669624686241,
-0.013527299277484417,
-1.0290712118148804,
-0.4691583216190338,
0.5417874455451965,
0.05026106908917427,
-0.6583476066589355,
0.32297608256340027,
-0.5372703075408936,
-0.48549097776412964,
-1.1685881614685059,
0.26956412196159363,
0.20575587451457977,
0.014041776768863201,
0.22227340936660767,
-0.22926738858222961,
-0.5710503458976746,
-0.910432755947113,
0.107715904712677,
0.09237975627183914,
0.17838184535503387,
0.17392505705356598,
0.34510862827301025,
-0.11521614342927933,
0.8906837701797485,
-0.3759569823741913,
0.08665985614061356,
-0.16078758239746094,
-0.007084287237375975,
0.04781828075647354,
0.5175228118896484,
0.2566501796245575,
-0.6083460450172424,
-0.37398096919059753,
0.14350014925003052,
-0.26116493344306946,
0.09217830747365952,
-0.1290062814950943,
0.03707209974527359,
0.1678658276796341,
0.3517398536205292,
-0.5980504751205444,
0.21210527420043945,
0.7583053112030029,
-0.43001115322113037,
0.591500997543335,
-0.4711059331893921,
0.13336843252182007,
-0.9859623908996582,
-0.07472400367259979,
-0.23597268760204315,
-0.48973485827445984,
-0.4501116871833801,
0.22986531257629395,
0.17542852461338043,
-0.006927447859197855,
-0.1894441395998001,
0.4076312184333801,
-0.2468620240688324,
0.021039577201008797,
-0.5689180493354797,
-0.47880151867866516,
-0.15617500245571136,
0.5463796257972717,
-0.17508357763290405,
1.304689884185791,
0.45077598094940186,
-0.9995675086975098,
0.15075403451919556,
0.0556233674287796,
-0.6543090343475342,
0.2606363296508789,
-0.6406192779541016,
0.16708935797214508,
-0.07842015475034714,
-0.1833522617816925,
-0.868350088596344,
-0.00644910242408514,
-0.3728457987308502,
-0.2167419046163559,
0.4017241895198822,
-0.3163318634033203,
-0.9144640564918518,
0.06439467519521713,
-0.3648567199707031,
0.49052396416664124,
0.2880435883998871,
-0.6559267044067383,
0.35883745551109314,
0.33548423647880554,
-0.2259785532951355,
-0.33317258954048157,
-0.6135457754135132,
-0.06353269517421722,
-0.0828949585556984,
-0.40104079246520996,
0.14657138288021088,
-0.050563644617795944,
0.03527418524026871,
0.07137365639209747,
-0.17127187550067902,
-0.31717607378959656,
0.5108650922775269,
0.4060899019241333,
0.14439046382904053,
-0.3536075949668884,
0.3403702676296234,
0.12551532685756683,
-0.25856447219848633,
-0.11364965885877609,
-0.4236888289451599,
0.8419690728187561,
-0.38955140113830566,
-0.1475212126970291,
-0.25899460911750793,
0.2700408101081848,
0.5432422161102295,
-0.2276109904050827,
0.885125994682312,
0.6130853891372681,
-0.3738597333431244,
-0.03560223802924156,
-0.535418689250946,
-0.21124520897865295,
-0.5167676210403442,
0.500714123249054,
-0.5255346894264221,
-1.0456264019012451,
0.4887434244155884,
-0.11620175093412399,
0.1678582727909088,
0.2845056354999542,
0.6422898173332214,
-0.14311449229717255,
0.8029754757881165,
1.0979112386703491,
-0.19290798902511597,
0.6873814463615417,
-0.3276858627796173,
0.2382933646440506,
-0.6583119034767151,
0.0979682058095932,
-0.5687201619148254,
-0.312411367893219,
-0.9417047500610352,
-0.329497754573822,
0.24916990101337433,
0.29832780361175537,
-0.624967634677887,
0.46438291668891907,
-0.35100334882736206,
0.7835555672645569,
0.5495809316635132,
0.3455691933631897,
0.3639415204524994,
0.08380824327468872,
0.31063488125801086,
0.1460503786802292,
-0.7664805054664612,
-0.38281187415122986,
1.1292804479599,
0.3606427311897278,
0.8949177265167236,
0.20721784234046936,
0.5562083721160889,
0.1282484084367752,
-0.06215152144432068,
-0.8103998899459839,
0.44236865639686584,
-0.356486976146698,
-0.7646508812904358,
-0.4154055714607239,
-0.6340446472167969,
-0.9274585843086243,
0.3197912275791168,
-0.3373976945877075,
-0.6093098521232605,
0.192887544631958,
0.4358658492565155,
-0.6982195973396301,
0.44077757000923157,
-0.5813376903533936,
0.70660001039505,
0.09455922991037369,
-0.44815778732299805,
-0.6456065773963928,
-0.37837329506874084,
0.17975781857967377,
-0.357848584651947,
-0.1428888440132141,
-0.2131146788597107,
0.05773673206567764,
0.5416410565376282,
-0.6334811449050903,
0.8178765177726746,
-0.12412148714065552,
-0.20981837809085846,
0.07867243140935898,
0.5290208458900452,
0.543412446975708,
-0.18127626180648804,
0.0865258276462555,
0.28765222430229187,
0.37293386459350586,
-0.5752232074737549,
-0.42642971873283386,
0.6840489506721497,
-0.8383834958076477,
-0.21940864622592926,
0.25456690788269043,
-0.48639073967933655,
-0.11459071934223175,
0.18930497765541077,
0.33705973625183105,
0.5012801289558411,
0.10841438174247742,
0.37878888845443726,
0.8580900430679321,
0.08380942046642303,
0.21230703592300415,
0.39163634181022644,
0.004110459703952074,
-0.24825070798397064,
1.0201592445373535,
0.17061996459960938,
0.3048267960548401,
0.4922906160354614,
0.2983951270580292,
-0.09791935235261917,
-0.6156850457191467,
-0.10683177411556244,
0.14375759661197662,
-0.5843208432197571,
-0.24880516529083252,
-0.42850130796432495,
0.048783354461193085,
-0.23595693707466125,
-0.09043847769498825,
-1.0386005640029907,
-0.5832886695861816,
-0.22467750310897827,
-0.09255287796258926,
0.38339608907699585,
0.6273610591888428,
-0.18937157094478607,
0.7490387558937073,
-0.7428735494613647,
0.1653384417295456,
0.2984158396720886,
0.7179911136627197,
0.1457858383655548,
-0.5013370513916016,
-0.7390015125274658,
-0.003381409216672182,
-0.10520913451910019,
-0.29749974608421326,
0.2187384068965912,
0.13459512591362,
-0.017062894999980927,
0.5752834677696228,
-0.18620797991752625,
0.9805060625076294,
-0.5687845945358276,
0.5906940698623657,
0.0492275170981884,
-0.8751387596130371,
0.1813768893480301,
-0.09550167620182037,
0.3407362103462219,
0.9630858898162842,
0.14238876104354858,
-0.27090609073638916,
-0.060698024928569794,
-0.5898305773735046,
-0.8265286684036255,
0.4650105834007263,
-0.16884605586528778,
0.35754382610321045,
0.17802350223064423,
0.34942999482154846,
0.32439929246902466,
0.5150740742683411,
-0.4599733054637909,
-0.42104852199554443,
-0.0028417345602065325,
-0.036545202136039734,
-0.2616366446018219,
-0.5235557556152344,
0.07016398012638092,
-0.414370059967041,
0.7652342319488525,
-0.05807914957404137,
0.33950650691986084,
-0.35814204812049866,
-0.14073212444782257,
-0.2448141723871231,
0.20925326645374298,
0.5830103754997253,
0.5812556147575378,
-0.40089327096939087,
0.34410908818244934,
0.006228943355381489,
-0.5057893991470337,
0.1574736386537552,
-0.08669323474168777,
-0.04257330298423767,
-0.005665401462465525,
0.41612523794174194,
1.069872260093689,
0.2808215320110321,
-0.3186938166618347,
0.36896559596061707,
0.013774095103144646,
-0.05631948634982109,
0.16888783872127533,
0.11612722277641296,
0.14202985167503357,
0.35469892621040344,
-0.040591269731521606,
-0.07741393893957138,
0.033229947090148926,
-0.37013691663742065,
0.09853000938892365,
0.4450715184211731,
-0.1981121301651001,
-0.4530262053012848,
0.38673943281173706,
0.1146320104598999,
-0.09391096234321594,
0.649963915348053,
-0.17983995378017426,
-0.33680489659309387,
0.33614206314086914,
0.3388929069042206,
0.9606457352638245,
0.06366707384586334,
-0.1663162112236023,
0.25170087814331055,
0.4188019037246704,
-0.12724439799785614,
0.3467439115047455,
-0.3195280134677887,
-0.7049798369407654,
-0.6085287928581238,
-0.7577846646308899,
-0.20279857516288757,
0.18406975269317627,
-0.6128297448158264,
0.05124647170305252,
-0.5384793877601624,
-0.31751489639282227,
0.12636880576610565,
0.41262319684028625,
-0.9123875498771667,
-0.05842102691531181,
0.1458330899477005,
1.0520339012145996,
-0.8344504833221436,
0.84088134765625,
0.49274957180023193,
-0.2392451912164688,
-0.9274881482124329,
-0.26950109004974365,
-0.4753519296646118,
-0.735218346118927,
0.5186705589294434,
-0.02296556532382965,
-0.283255010843277,
0.10168708115816116,
-0.6896917819976807,
-0.6849249601364136,
0.6759174466133118,
0.6574456095695496,
-0.8901000022888184,
-0.04306867718696594,
0.13796290755271912,
0.2913103699684143,
-0.03026696667075157,
0.0034855555277317762,
0.8337622284889221,
0.3684067130088806,
-0.06416509300470352,
-0.9296202659606934,
0.023808861151337624,
0.04115493223071098,
0.05347181484103203,
0.5755037665367126,
-0.5763756632804871,
1.208256721496582,
-0.3615016043186188,
-0.3362000584602356,
-0.13567672669887543,
0.40648993849754333,
-0.1277025043964386,
-0.19979356229305267,
0.41842490434646606,
0.6037267446517944,
0.8821212649345398,
-0.04013547673821449,
1.02089262008667,
-0.5625510811805725,
0.5543718338012695,
1.2022290229797363,
0.15875989198684692,
0.9475374221801758,
0.6091735363006592,
-0.23224686086177826,
0.014472797513008118,
0.737218976020813,
0.21906031668186188,
0.8114750981330872,
0.14272713661193848,
-0.27978113293647766,
-0.7273517847061157,
0.01600007154047489,
-0.17333705723285675,
0.415749728679657,
0.15925054252147675,
0.025784285739064217,
-0.30567264556884766,
-0.18034924566745758,
0.04790782928466797,
-0.2549246549606323,
-0.496266633272171,
0.8954227566719055,
0.057017382234334946,
-0.37433135509490967,
0.9324018359184265,
-0.06168784573674202,
0.5903587937355042,
-0.5088289380073547,
0.014900271780788898,
-0.3429252803325653,
0.31581562757492065,
-0.18404728174209595,
-0.4468466639518738,
-0.02103729173541069,
-0.05087834596633911,
-0.31168830394744873,
0.0912344753742218,
0.38624873757362366,
-0.5628268718719482,
-0.4801512658596039,
-0.2084912657737732,
0.35669466853141785,
0.1970588117837906,
-0.496187686920166,
-0.223796546459198,
0.15662747621536255,
-0.09867951273918152,
-0.21904033422470093,
0.2527168393135071,
0.6281375885009766,
0.12231754511594772,
0.8848865032196045,
0.6602604389190674,
0.5435354709625244,
0.10094306617975235,
-0.08986426889896393,
1.0062015056610107,
-0.7506186366081238,
-0.6260935068130493,
-1.0326952934265137,
0.1804543286561966,
0.3890545964241028,
-0.25726428627967834,
0.32054027915000916,
0.7429166436195374,
0.8557453751564026,
0.023948395624756813,
0.7012296915054321,
0.31135550141334534,
0.08873232454061508,
-0.7410632371902466,
0.7126362323760986,
-0.5882591009140015,
0.2426326721906662,
0.12670515477657318,
-0.7183740735054016,
0.006087492685765028,
0.6127293109893799,
0.051801647990942,
-0.08664588630199432,
0.4756503105163574,
0.8722442984580994,
-0.13207867741584778,
-0.03799871355295181,
0.5753284692764282,
0.12468783557415009,
0.3273760974407196,
0.5918975472450256,
0.7017263770103455,
-0.4034573435783386,
0.21911181509494781,
-0.43075689673423767,
0.07353141903877258,
-0.40730392932891846,
-0.8574097752571106,
-0.7834857106208801,
-0.5372356176376343,
-0.3505800664424896,
-0.25944480299949646,
0.039537038654088974,
1.1102789640426636,
1.0592992305755615,
-0.7747989296913147,
-0.07690827548503876,
-0.01630202680826187,
-0.09901789575815201,
-0.22344867885112762,
-0.08744604885578156,
0.3384346067905426,
-0.35447612404823303,
-0.4186379015445709,
0.19262883067131042,
0.15025362372398376,
0.2614932358264923,
-0.42625871300697327,
-0.015084929764270782,
0.21994532644748688,
0.22882723808288574,
0.5994661450386047,
0.0062713040970265865,
-0.450324147939682,
-0.239225372672081,
-0.36765357851982117,
-0.28404590487480164,
0.18357546627521515,
0.8972281217575073,
-0.7421296238899231,
0.47549402713775635,
0.3078921139240265,
1.0372560024261475,
0.8443741202354431,
-0.0026176143437623978,
0.374288409948349,
-0.8148029446601868,
0.1419488489627838,
0.05232815816998482,
0.29480186104774475,
0.18971548974514008,
-0.4811916947364807,
0.30718106031417847,
-0.27542644739151,
-0.36455395817756653,
-0.7800690531730652,
0.12755157053470612,
-0.9039439558982849,
-0.44158005714416504,
0.9655827283859253,
0.06717707961797714,
-0.10921328514814377,
0.2225741446018219,
-0.03817998245358467,
0.19620771706104279,
-0.39860251545906067,
0.8119937777519226,
0.839884877204895,
0.1727495640516281,
-0.1414192020893097,
-0.7543066143989563,
0.5274850130081177,
0.35982516407966614,
-0.6710068583488464,
0.5796740651130676,
0.4801061749458313,
0.4465266764163971,
-0.04520920291543007,
0.728428065776825,
0.17389315366744995,
0.27739712595939636,
0.3034002184867859,
0.15111973881721497,
-0.5193819999694824,
-0.6726245284080505,
-0.6945239901542664,
0.07362958788871765,
0.4426528215408325,
-0.48401549458503723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10189v2 | Uncertainty Quantification for In-Context Learning of Large Language Models | 2024-02-15T18:46:24 | 2024-03-28T19:41:34 | Chen Ling, Xujiang Zhao, Xuchao Zhang, Wei Cheng, Yanchi Liu, Yiyou Sun, Mika Oishi, Takao Osaki, Katsushi Matsuda, Jie Ji, Guangji Bai, Liang Zhao, Haifeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In-context learning has emerged as a groundbreaking ability of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and revolutionized various fields by providing a few
task-relevant demonstrations in the prompt. However, trustworthy issues with
LLM's response, such as hallucination, have also been actively discussed.
Existing works have been devoted to quantifying the uncertainty in LLM's
response, but they often overlook the complex nature of LLMs and the uniqueness
of in-context learning. In this work, we delve into the predictive uncertainty
of LLMs associated with in-context learning, highlighting that such
uncertainties may stem from both the provided demonstrations (aleatoric
uncertainty) and ambiguities tied to the model's configurations (epistemic
uncertainty). We propose a novel formulation and corresponding estimation
method to quantify both types of uncertainties. The proposed method offers an
unsupervised way to understand the prediction of in-context learning in a
plug-and-play fashion. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate the
effectiveness of the decomposition. The code and data are available at:
https://github.com/lingchen0331/UQ_ICL. | [
-0.3063257932662964,
-1.2042394876480103,
0.8342509269714355,
0.11422770470380783,
-0.114475779235363,
0.17575430870056152,
-0.4936829209327698,
-0.2089853435754776,
-0.04230697825551033,
0.15751288831233978,
-0.47727662324905396,
-0.3621982932090759,
-0.5131635665893555,
-0.21527987718582153,
-0.34208977222442627,
0.46791037917137146,
-0.20774616301059723,
0.06953165680170059,
-0.48269394040107727,
0.00868907105177641,
-0.2710481882095337,
-0.5157912969589233,
-0.20416413247585297,
-0.42266935110092163,
0.11462271213531494,
0.38721799850463867,
0.3818073570728302,
0.1893211156129837,
0.059306271374225616,
0.22875399887561798,
-0.3076872229576111,
0.05591496080160141,
-0.19664114713668823,
0.3155328035354614,
0.022336183115839958,
-0.4577323794364929,
-0.06740099936723709,
-0.307293176651001,
0.7620607614517212,
1.0496100187301636,
-0.20521201193332672,
0.09164763242006302,
0.2541181445121765,
0.2855355143547058,
-0.7828332185745239,
0.12886863946914673,
-0.7826941013336182,
0.21569395065307617,
0.14609543979167938,
-0.05565907433629036,
-0.5107188820838928,
-0.02659461833536625,
0.35629382729530334,
-0.6321905851364136,
-0.12980429828166962,
0.15337668359279633,
0.5591144561767578,
0.5689029097557068,
-0.48258739709854126,
-0.24286691844463348,
-0.9102035760879517,
0.8836289048194885,
-0.5675287246704102,
0.5473716259002686,
0.49695315957069397,
0.38304468989372253,
-0.36496180295944214,
-0.6901405453681946,
-0.5606297254562378,
0.021113278344273567,
-0.019765174016356468,
0.07971467077732086,
-0.0633167251944542,
-0.17023496329784393,
0.078334741294384,
0.2990732789039612,
-0.37675800919532776,
0.26332801580429077,
0.005005401559174061,
-0.3211342990398407,
0.19165660440921783,
-0.0061769066378474236,
0.03779220208525658,
0.006756131071597338,
-0.6838422417640686,
0.10691617429256439,
-0.7266484498977661,
0.0873759537935257,
0.23129665851593018,
0.14050936698913574,
-0.2939358949661255,
0.442270964384079,
-0.0999421551823616,
0.5334994792938232,
-0.00622556684538722,
-0.08095262199640274,
0.2553892731666565,
0.12244231253862381,
-0.45753398537635803,
0.0173483993858099,
0.7018629908561707,
-0.12315250188112259,
-0.02749602124094963,
-0.2871295213699341,
-0.4295944571495056,
-0.1149921789765358,
0.06344978511333466,
-0.6183816194534302,
0.002199264708906412,
0.4972727596759796,
-0.04142418131232262,
-0.19387458264827728,
0.15464115142822266,
-0.6273826956748962,
-0.37455084919929504,
-0.2700704038143158,
0.7205504179000854,
-0.37431642413139343,
-0.14935821294784546,
0.116944320499897,
0.30335789918899536,
-0.005170509684830904,
0.45929694175720215,
-0.5267004370689392,
0.17032282054424286,
0.5807687640190125,
0.5929649472236633,
-0.17755979299545288,
-0.44205349683761597,
-0.5517353415489197,
0.2116711437702179,
-0.29412633180618286,
0.5469534397125244,
-0.4236460030078888,
-0.2197587788105011,
0.2539825141429901,
-0.10326707363128662,
-0.054420825093984604,
-0.44388601183891296,
0.20954866707324982,
-0.5783922672271729,
0.08895771950483322,
-0.09102936089038849,
-0.9811103343963623,
-0.21200773119926453,
0.22761456668376923,
-0.5950911045074463,
0.8629046082496643,
0.20978944003582,
-0.8218082189559937,
0.3252037465572357,
-0.2625385522842407,
-0.18048597872257233,
0.13156570494174957,
-0.45197200775146484,
-0.5214111804962158,
0.46232420206069946,
0.14422205090522766,
0.6061322689056396,
-0.12505099177360535,
0.5039277672767639,
-0.3354319930076599,
-0.5640192627906799,
0.9255977272987366,
-0.5896294713020325,
0.7158131003379822,
0.12854163348674774,
-0.3661492168903351,
-0.019596949219703674,
-0.6077796816825867,
0.011942845769226551,
-0.11239396035671234,
-0.24007335305213928,
-0.26253652572631836,
0.004503148607909679,
-0.09289991110563278,
0.14922814071178436,
0.227974534034729,
-0.3487339913845062,
-0.08979785442352295,
-0.4908294081687927,
0.3156124949455261,
0.7367458939552307,
0.27875763177871704,
0.525776743888855,
-0.00028545805253088474,
0.5289738178253174,
0.1357792466878891,
0.1107804924249649,
-0.17228585481643677,
-0.3635670840740204,
-0.43952327966690063,
-0.16490328311920166,
0.2687644362449646,
0.24957497417926788,
-0.6369003057479858,
0.41814708709716797,
-0.09491371363401413,
-0.24495309591293335,
-0.12064678966999054,
-0.08841089904308319,
0.5174821615219116,
0.35881826281547546,
0.24444136023521423,
-0.012893596664071083,
-0.2726386487483978,
-0.5131304264068604,
-0.21726951003074646,
-0.37852880358695984,
-0.3549148738384247,
0.16397589445114136,
0.6185979247093201,
-0.33039742708206177,
0.8313470482826233,
-0.2669549882411957,
-0.08509178459644318,
0.016533996909856796,
0.22587361931800842,
-0.1914772093296051,
0.3912612497806549,
0.10830888152122498,
-0.7864176630973816,
-0.4488692581653595,
0.09234299510717392,
-0.6006991267204285,
0.1605885922908783,
-0.24425247311592102,
0.12032242864370346,
0.3281377851963043,
0.6489158272743225,
-0.5091215372085571,
0.5685378909111023,
0.5413287281990051,
-0.13034069538116455,
0.5581554174423218,
-0.26734068989753723,
-0.07318858802318573,
-1.067065715789795,
-0.18917380273342133,
-0.02925718016922474,
-0.05679568275809288,
-0.49114879965782166,
0.2294445037841797,
0.32529306411743164,
0.32837972044944763,
-0.4908420443534851,
0.5380604863166809,
-0.3824639916419983,
-0.3480852246284485,
0.009708989411592484,
0.06696059554815292,
-0.12892162799835205,
0.5006296038627625,
0.1513158231973648,
0.682025134563446,
0.7222163081169128,
-0.5413697957992554,
-0.0393136665225029,
0.11918161064386368,
-0.6780832409858704,
0.3676607608795166,
-0.5280913710594177,
-0.008597468957304955,
0.10946952551603317,
0.2920111417770386,
-0.9153067469596863,
-0.656349241733551,
0.1781555712223053,
-0.5825744867324829,
0.29528242349624634,
-0.024882687255740166,
-0.5634811520576477,
0.1327955573797226,
-0.04452985152602196,
0.5388419032096863,
0.2743254005908966,
-0.6659067869186401,
0.5992634892463684,
0.41225868463516235,
0.15621425211429596,
-0.7331346273422241,
-0.5414650440216064,
-0.2357608824968338,
-0.43493515253067017,
-0.12114531546831131,
0.3857041299343109,
-0.2288637012243271,
-0.5773206353187561,
-0.29929158091545105,
-0.3222757875919342,
-0.1796274334192276,
0.4438362717628479,
0.4728242754936218,
0.04972923547029495,
0.06548420339822769,
0.3070732057094574,
0.3025023341178894,
0.07988323271274567,
0.3356640338897705,
-0.2707139253616333,
0.4918104112148285,
-0.3720833957195282,
-0.862438440322876,
-0.16179783642292023,
0.13438931107521057,
0.5301225185394287,
-0.04661181941628456,
0.687704861164093,
0.6485732197761536,
-0.693452775478363,
-0.5885718464851379,
-0.3353351354598999,
-0.2295302301645279,
-0.4568864703178406,
0.36236992478370667,
-0.17856097221374512,
-0.9180402159690857,
0.8417659401893616,
-0.17697566747665405,
-0.22514474391937256,
0.0787414014339447,
0.7125712633132935,
-0.1588876098394394,
0.7405633926391602,
0.5234926342964172,
0.22556574642658234,
0.2914324104785919,
-0.15722018480300903,
0.21747268736362457,
-0.8071866631507874,
-0.6118392944335938,
-0.38351792097091675,
0.010561445727944374,
-0.3588961064815521,
-0.5103657841682434,
0.5486052632331848,
0.04782281816005707,
-0.37365058064460754,
-0.09370499104261398,
0.02919899858534336,
0.4417523145675659,
0.3433448374271393,
0.07373472303152084,
0.3337365686893463,
0.13189658522605896,
-0.27215397357940674,
0.1160522997379303,
-0.38457202911376953,
-0.4376325011253357,
1.0606759786605835,
0.44498342275619507,
0.7631871700286865,
0.35600921511650085,
0.5824223160743713,
0.01610749028623104,
-0.0030575839336961508,
-0.9756669998168945,
0.24909505248069763,
0.447234570980072,
-0.5001905560493469,
-0.5563904643058777,
-0.4686257541179657,
-0.7064754366874695,
0.2981991767883301,
-0.1327274888753891,
-1.1228183507919312,
0.16820205748081207,
0.011517512612044811,
-0.5732357501983643,
0.27417227625846863,
-0.4484542906284332,
0.666930079460144,
-0.06719285249710083,
-0.3307201862335205,
0.006737060379236937,
-0.8931444883346558,
0.1598823219537735,
-0.5285040140151978,
0.36560022830963135,
0.25803086161613464,
-0.08080177009105682,
0.3755481243133545,
-0.2517556846141815,
1.0102617740631104,
0.04959975928068161,
-0.3129202425479889,
0.21914173662662506,
0.3745321035385132,
0.6420615315437317,
0.3604394197463989,
0.08736220002174377,
0.03709415718913078,
-0.03681504353880882,
-0.20381905138492584,
-0.6403366327285767,
0.6267220377922058,
-0.7269412279129028,
-0.3295232355594635,
-0.30595749616622925,
-0.6198729872703552,
-0.5008001923561096,
-0.21277524530887604,
0.6170204281806946,
0.47058966755867004,
-0.2582349181175232,
0.13869939744472504,
1.1189528703689575,
-0.3825819194316864,
0.5468684434890747,
0.33388733863830566,
-0.3952135741710663,
-0.11188220232725143,
0.7374901175498962,
0.13085637986660004,
0.4689599573612213,
0.5500264167785645,
0.20576587319374084,
-0.34898123145103455,
-0.5998935699462891,
-0.288970410823822,
0.05115791782736778,
-0.8968099355697632,
-0.01428751740604639,
-0.45927321910858154,
-0.058201439678668976,
-0.12332739681005478,
-0.25560688972473145,
-0.37876689434051514,
-0.40404388308525085,
-0.5280724167823792,
-0.2540811598300934,
0.08215852826833725,
0.8600220680236816,
0.18239381909370422,
0.46089357137680054,
-0.3373422920703888,
-0.2729451060295105,
0.3607717454433441,
0.3669450283050537,
-0.06733899563550949,
-0.8907149434089661,
-0.5436052083969116,
0.12053435295820236,
-0.09516417980194092,
-0.8147680163383484,
0.5199164152145386,
0.2307216376066208,
0.6646709442138672,
0.6008706092834473,
0.32407432794570923,
0.590354859828949,
-0.24936158955097198,
0.9073681235313416,
-0.0464228093624115,
-1.1395660638809204,
0.32014548778533936,
-0.19983962178230286,
0.07195722311735153,
0.39365914463996887,
0.4199530780315399,
-0.1888170838356018,
-0.5704436898231506,
-0.7457882165908813,
-0.9049510955810547,
0.39288240671157837,
0.026211099699139595,
0.030994649976491928,
0.14928753674030304,
0.30000218749046326,
0.22700083255767822,
0.319955050945282,
-0.6207883954048157,
-0.2103867381811142,
0.05430634319782257,
0.03473373129963875,
-0.13267406821250916,
-0.27246326208114624,
-0.1319257766008377,
-0.34522008895874023,
0.4971790611743927,
-0.24605417251586914,
0.3092699646949768,
-0.21012942492961884,
-0.5210376381874084,
-0.325273334980011,
0.18404564261436462,
0.5961102247238159,
0.8658398985862732,
-0.36445581912994385,
0.3642546236515045,
0.2975045144557953,
-0.27661556005477905,
0.0863032415509224,
-0.24844980239868164,
-0.06261880695819855,
0.050094783306121826,
0.5096731781959534,
0.7855726480484009,
0.4579622745513916,
-0.8194736838340759,
0.6881176829338074,
-0.0797911211848259,
0.005166761111468077,
-0.9455646872520447,
-0.3694307506084442,
-0.0995655208826065,
0.373785138130188,
0.4054632782936096,
0.1417628675699234,
0.21631966531276703,
-0.4035229980945587,
0.3524698317050934,
0.34452617168426514,
-0.583880603313446,
-0.5279532670974731,
0.6101380586624146,
-0.22204981744289398,
-0.21923498809337616,
0.24870267510414124,
-0.3366626501083374,
-0.5165570974349976,
0.6010196208953857,
0.6884613633155823,
0.8809094429016113,
-0.2909311354160309,
0.28852584958076477,
0.17099899053573608,
0.14000865817070007,
-0.1179150640964508,
0.02315591089427471,
0.0006463203462772071,
-0.8040001392364502,
-0.43606963753700256,
-0.6719144582748413,
-0.6636330485343933,
0.17129534482955933,
-0.9410085678100586,
0.036286164075136185,
-0.1920728236436844,
0.028562473133206367,
-0.3934158384799957,
-0.10524459183216095,
-0.5331272482872009,
0.06838459521532059,
0.2581583261489868,
0.6271793246269226,
-1.1228328943252563,
0.920590877532959,
0.802543044090271,
-0.20029012858867645,
-0.9463567733764648,
0.6213034987449646,
0.11618876457214355,
-0.4538859724998474,
0.4321090877056122,
0.13109926879405975,
-0.193711519241333,
-0.16058853268623352,
-0.5418119430541992,
-0.7948992848396301,
1.0872409343719482,
0.5511688590049744,
-0.22972288727760315,
0.15506333112716675,
0.08828853070735931,
0.32927611470222473,
-0.45825842022895813,
0.2838883697986603,
0.44371992349624634,
0.24408620595932007,
0.21032880246639252,
-0.6703765988349915,
-0.012643096037209034,
0.17599861323833466,
0.11195475608110428,
-0.06510422378778458,
-0.37338942289352417,
1.0653975009918213,
-0.15727460384368896,
-0.3182753324508667,
-0.06468706578016281,
0.7232394814491272,
0.2880699038505554,
0.292080283164978,
0.3363368511199951,
0.34857627749443054,
1.0303324460983276,
-0.008982406929135323,
0.9225915670394897,
-0.24929098784923553,
0.5675867795944214,
1.1690990924835205,
-0.11647114157676697,
0.9640012979507446,
0.8542738556861877,
-0.2898947298526764,
0.44443416595458984,
0.9571446776390076,
0.5582144260406494,
0.4318957030773163,
0.18643704056739807,
-0.5017174482345581,
-0.3879558742046356,
0.03838527202606201,
-0.22086215019226074,
0.44609642028808594,
0.8163687586784363,
-0.22469303011894226,
0.08671221137046814,
0.07819858938455582,
-0.02396235056221485,
0.08488592505455017,
-0.014981617219746113,
0.6290783286094666,
0.06157568842172623,
-0.6266000270843506,
0.517512857913971,
-0.14634191989898682,
0.47540736198425293,
-0.2774365544319153,
0.0323835164308548,
-0.20604434609413147,
0.10908999294042587,
-0.021520139649510384,
-0.6983541250228882,
0.13122053444385529,
-0.38170063495635986,
0.12985378503799438,
0.05097080022096634,
0.18435382843017578,
-0.5663087368011475,
-0.4710763990879059,
0.41396889090538025,
0.6722416281700134,
0.2374984472990036,
-0.30069661140441895,
-0.2972869873046875,
0.2104203701019287,
-0.04601424187421799,
-0.4422312378883362,
0.6226545572280884,
0.8155990839004517,
-0.0044484250247478485,
0.8490421772003174,
0.016901256516575813,
-0.15437127649784088,
0.07805819809436798,
-0.028336884453892708,
0.7331569790840149,
0.05958839878439903,
-0.21472902595996857,
-0.8768758773803711,
0.5478805899620056,
0.28193986415863037,
-0.3749133348464966,
0.7886677384376526,
0.36342570185661316,
1.1912753582000732,
-0.24659620225429535,
0.7557631134986877,
0.1828475445508957,
0.2746356427669525,
-0.6117885708808899,
0.6732946038246155,
-0.6554116606712341,
0.6880775690078735,
-0.35707753896713257,
-0.8424020409584045,
-0.4230031669139862,
0.7661871910095215,
-0.07688555866479874,
-0.20974022150039673,
0.8270826935768127,
0.8152165412902832,
-0.06512506306171417,
0.03439144790172577,
0.5694755911827087,
0.09806916117668152,
-0.05310631915926933,
0.42051833868026733,
1.045913815498352,
-0.23962582647800446,
0.12119708210229874,
-0.47024789452552795,
-0.20728643238544464,
-0.3047315776348114,
-0.80986487865448,
-0.7035142779350281,
-1.0304327011108398,
-0.3590146005153656,
-0.3121592402458191,
-0.3107554018497467,
1.1996055841445923,
0.36874231696128845,
-0.870214581489563,
-0.4082140624523163,
-0.04409592226147652,
0.22453178465366364,
-0.3667082190513611,
-0.09731819480657578,
0.4829839766025543,
-0.35357600450515747,
-0.7455804347991943,
0.37985318899154663,
-0.04477911815047264,
0.14208334684371948,
-0.5179166793823242,
-0.33906012773513794,
-0.00013210764154791832,
0.21497869491577148,
0.5364770293235779,
0.10533156245946884,
-1.037872076034546,
-0.4294678568840027,
-0.005818861536681652,
0.16375257074832916,
-0.12175875157117844,
0.47801217436790466,
-0.7644591331481934,
0.5187184810638428,
0.16903477907180786,
0.6737815141677856,
0.49143174290657043,
-0.1495792120695114,
0.5320249199867249,
-1.12001633644104,
0.08381135016679764,
0.15178517997264862,
0.6043645739555359,
0.21882177889347076,
-0.4088028371334076,
0.3447449803352356,
0.09214962273836136,
-0.5930631756782532,
-1.1331881284713745,
0.44368836283683777,
-0.7831889390945435,
-0.4788089990615845,
1.2954280376434326,
-0.43851596117019653,
-0.22361619770526886,
-0.22655922174453735,
0.3414817154407501,
0.2739036977291107,
-0.1985199749469757,
0.8924782276153564,
0.589168131351471,
0.19477902352809906,
0.04956590011715889,
-0.6855950951576233,
0.30589529871940613,
0.27527573704719543,
-0.59939044713974,
0.1513456553220749,
0.6095165014266968,
0.09775573015213013,
0.07639888674020767,
0.020662259310483932,
0.07952264696359634,
0.033101338893175125,
-0.046516723930835724,
0.059075843542814255,
0.08508865535259247,
-0.7028640508651733,
-0.5841554999351501,
0.24412985146045685,
0.17205475270748138,
-0.0037501652259379625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10184v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10184v5 | Reward Generalization in RLHF: A Topological Perspective | 2024-02-15T18:39:24 | 2024-06-16T21:25:50 | Tianyi Qiu, Fanzhi Zeng, Jiaming Ji, Dong Yan, Kaile Wang, Jiayi Zhou, Yang Han, Josef Dai, Xuehai Pan, Yaodong Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DM | Existing alignment methods share a common topology of information flow, where
reward information is collected from humans, modeled with preference learning,
and used to tune language models. However, this shared topology has not been
systematically characterized, nor have its alternatives been thoroughly
explored, leaving the problems of low data efficiency and unreliable
generalization unaddressed. As a solution, we introduce a theoretical framework
for investigating reward generalization in reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF), focusing on the topology of information flow at both macro and
micro levels. At the macro level, we portray the RLHF information flow as an
autoencoding process over behavior distributions, formalizing the RLHF
objective of distributional consistency between human preference and model
behavior. At the micro level, we present induced Bayesian networks as a theory
of reward generalization in RLHF, introducing fine-grained dataset topologies
into generalization bounds. Combining analysis on both levels, we propose
reward modeling from tree-structured preference information. It is shown to
reduce reward uncertainty by up to $\Theta(\log n/\log\log n)$ times compared
to baselines, where $n$ is the dataset size. Validation on three NLP tasks
shows that our tree-based reward model achieves an average win rate of 65%
against baseline methods, thus improving reward generalization for free via
topology design. | [
-0.12319625914096832,
-0.6981976628303528,
0.28469735383987427,
-0.14635540544986725,
-0.08277641236782074,
-0.22971104085445404,
-0.20265379548072815,
-0.2462945133447647,
0.5337334275245667,
0.39857569336891174,
-0.7170466184616089,
-0.43298226594924927,
-0.7059566974639893,
-0.24761977791786194,
-0.0027022354770451784,
1.1807829141616821,
0.16672687232494354,
-0.2854950428009033,
-0.1027187630534172,
-0.15483178198337555,
-0.20366771519184113,
-0.6990563273429871,
-0.8228963017463684,
-0.5772830247879028,
1.2110130786895752,
0.4736461937427521,
0.7483558058738708,
1.006941556930542,
0.7360678315162659,
0.25395697355270386,
0.11994102597236633,
-0.10475696623325348,
-0.6100525856018066,
0.1601288914680481,
-0.3862961232662201,
-0.4176296591758728,
-0.44385093450546265,
0.08656484633684158,
0.6584140062332153,
0.7343295216560364,
-0.8742833733558655,
-0.0018714917823672295,
0.2349538654088974,
1.1050523519515991,
-0.6690614223480225,
0.4500187337398529,
-0.26470762491226196,
0.23732496798038483,
-0.06657124310731888,
-0.3998596966266632,
-0.19730237126350403,
-0.6178200244903564,
0.2054305374622345,
-0.7714872360229492,
0.12482564896345139,
0.14559505879878998,
0.7394616603851318,
0.42439112067222595,
-0.328690767288208,
-0.23021697998046875,
-0.7205142974853516,
0.5281306505203247,
-0.5448272228240967,
0.15399546921253204,
0.4409545063972473,
0.4415721595287323,
-0.16117991507053375,
-0.3542291224002838,
-0.1389959454536438,
-0.10268783569335938,
-0.3131870925426483,
0.02932995930314064,
-0.029775790870189667,
0.4496816098690033,
0.12828610837459564,
0.44923925399780273,
-0.5482357144355774,
0.13281874358654022,
-0.09643665701150894,
0.222190722823143,
0.75306236743927,
0.2662056088447571,
0.1749306172132492,
-0.11728652566671371,
-0.24993421137332916,
-0.7381415367126465,
-0.6329851746559143,
0.590811550617218,
0.5057033896446228,
0.4963688552379608,
-0.17516526579856873,
0.5550385117530823,
-0.375438928604126,
0.8647922277450562,
0.11758935451507568,
0.01607031561434269,
-0.1105131208896637,
-0.1442638486623764,
-0.185881108045578,
-0.17631277441978455,
0.7175638675689697,
0.3508821725845337,
0.4668271243572235,
-0.27872058749198914,
-0.24109315872192383,
-0.025972427800297737,
0.5081381797790527,
-0.6732785105705261,
-0.3351242244243622,
0.10778980702161789,
-0.6787067651748657,
-0.6321518421173096,
0.27892929315567017,
-0.6346553564071655,
-0.5424245595932007,
-0.24411875009536743,
0.26130667328834534,
-0.13309571146965027,
-0.5283459424972534,
0.12711504101753235,
-0.23870019614696503,
0.44202834367752075,
0.22393669188022614,
-1.3420829772949219,
0.4360123872756958,
0.769468367099762,
0.5467491149902344,
-0.3640267848968506,
-0.3626612424850464,
-0.6852883696556091,
0.28349730372428894,
-0.3697216808795929,
0.6664475202560425,
-0.5060564875602722,
-0.29612866044044495,
0.06312226504087448,
0.0725393295288086,
-0.24789217114448547,
-0.6809664964675903,
0.33192962408065796,
-0.5993196368217468,
0.042468324303627014,
-0.11531167477369308,
-0.6837447285652161,
-0.12523484230041504,
0.21298232674598694,
-0.732304036617279,
0.6453099846839905,
0.18565376102924347,
-0.9427772760391235,
0.5355263948440552,
-0.7888321280479431,
-0.27692562341690063,
-0.08871037513017654,
-0.23416009545326233,
-0.36144307255744934,
0.1250130832195282,
-0.07378864288330078,
0.34241044521331787,
-0.06893519312143326,
0.6991903781890869,
-0.44967758655548096,
-0.367620050907135,
0.07485458999872208,
-0.0230482779443264,
0.4281710088253021,
0.04976772144436836,
-0.5136352181434631,
0.4644392132759094,
-0.2963552474975586,
-0.15644729137420654,
0.0891624167561531,
-0.47268998622894287,
-0.3823575973510742,
0.22262097895145416,
-0.29411378502845764,
0.019458916038274765,
-0.12024351954460144,
-0.4573787748813629,
0.6569207310676575,
-0.35799646377563477,
0.1223679631948471,
0.991021990776062,
-0.0017606327310204506,
0.6044701933860779,
-0.5102662444114685,
0.6127285361289978,
0.051099177449941635,
0.15632010996341705,
0.44413119554519653,
-0.3884802460670471,
-0.5015602707862854,
0.032889802008867264,
0.49323898553848267,
0.5495535731315613,
-0.42722415924072266,
0.41111037135124207,
-0.23533745110034943,
-0.15788717567920685,
-0.2875734269618988,
-0.27527672052383423,
0.3736874759197235,
0.3608408272266388,
0.2770841121673584,
-0.36370575428009033,
-0.15185320377349854,
-1.0353537797927856,
-0.25983935594558716,
-0.3571675419807434,
-0.04186687618494034,
0.6826584935188293,
0.21599191427230835,
-0.06522002071142197,
0.8672990798950195,
-0.46107369661331177,
-0.24392889440059662,
-0.19372500479221344,
0.3454570770263672,
0.5475682020187378,
0.848456859588623,
0.20489594340324402,
-0.6560347080230713,
-0.1296202391386032,
0.029466522857546806,
-0.6132169365882874,
0.2386612892150879,
0.0837927758693695,
-0.07763007283210754,
0.15111283957958221,
0.24541136622428894,
-0.2615821957588196,
0.6417185068130493,
0.4723937511444092,
-0.5960057377815247,
0.37449780106544495,
-0.2152140885591507,
0.1808047592639923,
-0.5930894017219543,
0.15983609855175018,
-0.19757631421089172,
-0.2683801054954529,
-0.34836748242378235,
0.046615153551101685,
-0.15705864131450653,
0.09199187159538269,
0.11300399154424667,
0.5366070866584778,
-0.09766972064971924,
-0.31909993290901184,
-0.2798922657966614,
-0.2401709109544754,
-0.41148582100868225,
0.9390883445739746,
0.4377877116203308,
0.2680109441280365,
0.34671515226364136,
-0.7809637188911438,
0.5286639332771301,
-0.11741705983877182,
-0.17411918938159943,
0.5990200638771057,
-0.9582513570785522,
-0.19288446009159088,
-0.2187156081199646,
0.4963279366493225,
-0.8115436434745789,
-0.4070313572883606,
0.5036126375198364,
-0.5876686573028564,
0.37638822197914124,
-0.261501282453537,
-0.28948912024497986,
0.004423127043992281,
-0.21463291347026825,
0.6262776851654053,
0.3240989148616791,
-0.5396800637245178,
0.2493767887353897,
0.4064914882183075,
-0.04821394756436348,
-0.697204053401947,
-0.4388808310031891,
-0.32437649369239807,
-0.375767320394516,
-0.402981698513031,
0.3371618688106537,
-0.046784065663814545,
-0.07323060929775238,
0.055591288954019547,
0.07195289433002472,
0.031517721712589264,
0.2522156238555908,
0.37244799733161926,
0.0693536028265953,
0.027296876534819603,
0.37698987126350403,
-0.13828955590724945,
-0.25239965319633484,
0.1471126228570938,
-0.6497091054916382,
0.24121470749378204,
-0.13441544771194458,
-0.3555012047290802,
-0.37060174345970154,
0.42316505312919617,
-0.02867284044623375,
0.08415544033050537,
0.730230987071991,
0.5564826130867004,
-0.2039400339126587,
-0.062250908464193344,
-0.2361430823802948,
-0.641033947467804,
-0.3631440997123718,
0.11173860728740692,
-0.259712815284729,
-1.151301622390747,
0.18486011028289795,
0.041766706854104996,
0.13215993344783783,
0.4388950765132904,
0.3604218661785126,
-0.18297800421714783,
0.9945907592773438,
0.8762989044189453,
-0.16560353338718414,
0.5633285045623779,
-0.378911554813385,
-0.06978730857372284,
-0.5537579655647278,
-0.22855032980442047,
-0.35066625475883484,
-0.7157905101776123,
-0.8717277646064758,
-0.17813149094581604,
0.3391090929508209,
0.3448854684829712,
-0.39534351229667664,
0.09549467265605927,
-0.5695931911468506,
0.2736712694168091,
0.9053307771682739,
0.03744269534945488,
0.15609778463840485,
0.07773172110319138,
-0.35937929153442383,
0.1871563196182251,
-1.2251982688903809,
0.02750326879322529,
0.9886778593063354,
0.4009344279766083,
0.88922518491745,
0.23833271861076355,
0.8785614967346191,
0.49801814556121826,
0.17517340183258057,
-0.7966707348823547,
-0.00016651344776619226,
0.05632154271006584,
-0.30679407715797424,
-0.8161653876304626,
-0.5181364417076111,
-1.3199793100357056,
0.055860430002212524,
-0.23252074420452118,
-0.8472417593002319,
0.5486680865287781,
0.441288560628891,
-0.3508349657058716,
0.4107357859611511,
-0.3419441878795624,
1.0221428871154785,
0.05619385093450546,
-0.4843732714653015,
-0.45700782537460327,
-0.8985945582389832,
0.4101240932941437,
0.6228464245796204,
0.18997342884540558,
0.07897605001926422,
0.28339964151382446,
0.916896641254425,
-0.5326859354972839,
0.7375389933586121,
-0.3209240138530731,
-0.010473375208675861,
0.058626629412174225,
0.12420885264873505,
0.793182373046875,
0.14983215928077698,
0.1498805731534958,
-0.20164702832698822,
0.0737699568271637,
-0.5498396754264832,
-0.8032835125923157,
0.363235741853714,
-0.8312975168228149,
-0.4034537672996521,
-0.4998869001865387,
-0.5864270329475403,
-0.24698302149772644,
-0.18798384070396423,
0.18930765986442566,
0.3841695785522461,
-0.06594646722078323,
0.18660664558410645,
0.8191913962364197,
-0.16899210214614868,
0.21701358258724213,
0.19708147644996643,
-0.41916581988334656,
-0.35109081864356995,
0.9079158902168274,
-0.37998950481414795,
0.20025946199893951,
0.636337399482727,
0.4393310546875,
-0.4351978003978729,
-0.15747323632240295,
-0.44901230931282043,
0.3695780634880066,
-0.38664278388023376,
-0.15211836993694305,
-0.39776676893234253,
-0.14749717712402344,
-0.4195607900619507,
-0.12846215069293976,
-0.2778705060482025,
-0.6461158394813538,
0.1389470249414444,
-0.16793055832386017,
0.32459741830825806,
1.2331756353378296,
-0.5086677670478821,
0.3246855139732361,
-0.5104970335960388,
0.15724767744541168,
0.749138355255127,
0.6855894923210144,
0.1050412580370903,
-0.33848699927330017,
-0.401300847530365,
0.09516526013612747,
0.03995466232299805,
-0.8660550713539124,
0.30128222703933716,
-0.06884840875864029,
0.521536648273468,
0.38519561290740967,
-0.02221718430519104,
0.24072960019111633,
-0.056602299213409424,
0.4099186956882477,
0.22566154599189758,
-0.4872850775718689,
0.42622140049934387,
-0.6380506753921509,
0.1062433123588562,
0.33665329217910767,
0.26518556475639343,
-0.8499575257301331,
-0.10603714734315872,
-0.977296769618988,
-0.5922874808311462,
0.8168622851371765,
-0.12027926743030548,
-0.401793509721756,
0.14094962179660797,
0.5043507218360901,
-0.1086842343211174,
0.29111355543136597,
-0.9061945676803589,
-0.21285930275917053,
-0.2528454661369324,
-0.060989074409008026,
-0.19839449226856232,
-0.23473301529884338,
-0.3196472227573395,
-0.2329002022743225,
0.5395783185958862,
-0.30608975887298584,
0.43065375089645386,
0.2093471735715866,
0.08735521137714386,
-0.2531232237815857,
0.3241700530052185,
0.427446186542511,
0.46808040142059326,
-0.5700227618217468,
0.2085442990064621,
-0.4135971665382385,
0.10207532346248627,
0.3550666272640228,
-0.1513272225856781,
0.041439082473516464,
-0.29196715354919434,
0.2731418311595917,
0.8469607830047607,
0.1091558039188385,
-0.13409124314785004,
0.5560535192489624,
-0.1440621316432953,
-0.3422960340976715,
0.027594249695539474,
0.28116482496261597,
0.31655585765838623,
0.2638872265815735,
0.021246427670121193,
-0.3910481035709381,
0.31628450751304626,
-0.5079084634780884,
0.31864476203918457,
0.6842469573020935,
-0.7370254993438721,
-0.1536611020565033,
0.30091583728790283,
0.08281214535236359,
-0.34230414032936096,
0.7811896204948425,
-0.2832801640033722,
-0.28082412481307983,
0.6884653568267822,
0.37522247433662415,
0.8987346887588501,
-0.2197403609752655,
0.4531606137752533,
0.7286356687545776,
0.09979307651519775,
0.05712277069687843,
-0.014674569480121136,
-0.5033477544784546,
-0.7062361836433411,
-0.1659291386604309,
-0.7361274361610413,
-0.48871052265167236,
-0.21517987549304962,
-0.7511537075042725,
-0.16321757435798645,
-0.38062575459480286,
-0.03180897608399391,
-0.22033992409706116,
-0.24427787959575653,
-0.49131515622138977,
0.08626104891300201,
-0.03790522366762161,
0.5641707181930542,
-0.6989349722862244,
0.9364973902702332,
0.8179268836975098,
-0.21938194334506989,
-0.9964655637741089,
-0.1780572533607483,
-0.09873709082603455,
-0.7407972812652588,
0.8575161695480347,
-0.04779199883341789,
-0.22290436923503876,
-0.020453350618481636,
-0.44714948534965515,
-1.0112656354904175,
1.1427464485168457,
-0.13507091999053955,
-0.2914060950279236,
-0.29482656717300415,
0.08895893394947052,
0.3379705846309662,
-0.6345049738883972,
0.3526228368282318,
0.4862273335456848,
0.528764009475708,
0.15268045663833618,
-0.7087207436561584,
-0.17112021148204803,
-0.24033068120479584,
0.21124744415283203,
0.3055470883846283,
-0.34571272134780884,
0.6758518218994141,
-0.1965986043214798,
-0.23235714435577393,
-0.2872079312801361,
0.4239034652709961,
0.45992934703826904,
-0.0383547842502594,
0.7489994168281555,
0.6049389839172363,
0.5898172855377197,
0.0766787901520729,
1.1912028789520264,
-0.1480054259300232,
0.5321653485298157,
0.9690347909927368,
0.2742617428302765,
0.6459825038909912,
0.4579136073589325,
-0.3231809437274933,
0.8793436288833618,
0.9305538535118103,
0.5002941489219666,
0.5688673257827759,
0.8096644878387451,
0.2496388703584671,
-0.1783117949962616,
-0.3499806523323059,
-0.36369165778160095,
0.1343574821949005,
0.2551786005496979,
-0.24149835109710693,
-0.2632150948047638,
-0.4257316291332245,
-0.31838008761405945,
-0.12495014071464539,
-0.28067877888679504,
1.0705946683883667,
-0.09507402777671814,
-0.9965664148330688,
0.5843431949615479,
-0.05750398337841034,
0.637118935585022,
-0.6779280304908752,
-0.2808031141757965,
-0.36877575516700745,
0.12688980996608734,
-0.24979186058044434,
-0.6932772994041443,
0.38953959941864014,
-0.5159905552864075,
-0.27810725569725037,
-0.31422510743141174,
0.6398603916168213,
-0.5593592524528503,
-0.0979018285870552,
0.47693678736686707,
0.42112022638320923,
0.1229531392455101,
-0.022616885602474213,
-0.7467271685600281,
-0.4894265830516815,
-0.10783073306083679,
-0.2751666307449341,
0.5158970952033997,
0.20908989012241364,
-0.019218582659959793,
0.5570974946022034,
0.5111607313156128,
0.13339099287986755,
-0.05333346128463745,
-0.014924779534339905,
0.5645483136177063,
-0.8049489855766296,
-0.7800154685974121,
-0.6971197724342346,
0.39275380969047546,
0.05158007889986038,
-0.15078359842300415,
0.14964018762111664,
0.25065985321998596,
0.712463915348053,
0.019082529470324516,
0.4650946855545044,
0.0692703127861023,
0.5507016777992249,
-0.5117096304893494,
0.4158947467803955,
-0.6041736602783203,
-0.031695980578660965,
-0.30404821038246155,
-0.7821868658065796,
-0.1394452452659607,
0.598170280456543,
-0.024736154824495316,
0.07266774028539658,
0.6151971220970154,
0.7075306177139282,
-0.187641441822052,
-0.0042753866873681545,
0.15074275434017181,
-0.18220679461956024,
0.06784258037805557,
0.8482497334480286,
0.8738301396369934,
0.07276071608066559,
0.08866618573665619,
-0.455671489238739,
-0.5587345361709595,
-0.3558473587036133,
-0.8678575754165649,
-0.38990384340286255,
-0.6673255562782288,
-0.1081901341676712,
-0.31961697340011597,
0.2595718204975128,
0.8499417901039124,
0.9028747081756592,
-0.8010931611061096,
-1.0351202487945557,
-0.4816115200519562,
0.6501424312591553,
-0.5206424593925476,
-0.3158508539199829,
0.4236605763435364,
-0.6037331223487854,
-0.2825596034526825,
0.07560110837221146,
0.4254952073097229,
-0.16350440680980682,
-0.1654711812734604,
-0.4184459447860718,
-0.38105443120002747,
-0.07263608276844025,
0.2345060557126999,
0.48955634236335754,
-0.5965014100074768,
-0.30921581387519836,
-0.14543627202510834,
-0.11232049763202667,
0.11745268106460571,
1.1640782356262207,
-0.82100510597229,
0.30173295736312866,
0.5189710855484009,
0.7925512790679932,
0.5386462211608887,
0.3435373306274414,
0.8272325396537781,
-0.5700376629829407,
-0.07335663586854935,
0.08614709228277206,
0.2156151682138443,
0.10380250215530396,
-0.3547709584236145,
0.8405645489692688,
0.41449230909347534,
-0.8602713346481323,
-0.4233109652996063,
0.5939089059829712,
-0.6775153279304504,
-0.2484520971775055,
1.0571528673171997,
-0.14149035513401031,
-0.26427915692329407,
0.1678241789340973,
0.1761307418346405,
0.3294881284236908,
-0.46053290367126465,
0.865849494934082,
0.7005528211593628,
-0.47358253598213196,
-0.13858211040496826,
-0.13346779346466064,
1.0982743501663208,
0.6851961016654968,
-0.8225857019424438,
0.2647075653076172,
0.4935827851295471,
0.02702164463698864,
-0.04777439311146736,
0.9330803751945496,
0.1066894382238388,
0.43241095542907715,
-0.41121071577072144,
0.1531887650489807,
0.13866928219795227,
-0.5284693837165833,
-0.6635172963142395,
0.14375744760036469,
0.42397546768188477,
-0.15439192950725555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10978v1 | Language Models with Conformal Factuality Guarantees | 2024-02-15T18:31:53 | 2024-02-15T18:31:53 | Christopher Mohri, Tatsunori Hashimoto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Guaranteeing the correctness and factuality of language model (LM) outputs is
a major open problem. In this work, we propose conformal factuality, a
framework that can ensure high probability correctness guarantees for LMs by
connecting language modeling and conformal prediction. We observe that the
correctness of an LM output is equivalent to an uncertainty quantification
problem, where the uncertainty sets are defined as the entailment set of an
LM's output. Using this connection, we show that conformal prediction in
language models corresponds to a back-off algorithm that provides high
probability correctness guarantees by progressively making LM outputs less
specific (and expanding the associated uncertainty sets). This approach applies
to any black-box LM and requires very few human-annotated samples. Evaluations
of our approach on closed book QA (FActScore, NaturalQuestions) and reasoning
tasks (MATH) show that our approach can provide 80-90% correctness guarantees
while retaining the majority of the LM's original output. | [
0.014770688489079475,
-0.4952625334262848,
0.8074039220809937,
0.054010819643735886,
0.21717427670955658,
-0.27822962403297424,
-0.5243472456932068,
-0.3750755786895752,
-0.14573010802268982,
0.7995831370353699,
-0.4569193124771118,
-0.49902740120887756,
-0.5472003817558289,
-0.2341650128364563,
-0.2654518783092499,
0.9675422310829163,
-0.016933612525463104,
-0.17973309755325317,
-0.3769429624080658,
-0.05736490711569786,
-0.4455801844596863,
-0.5631657242774963,
-0.23193582892417908,
-0.2517314851284027,
0.31974807381629944,
0.21277576684951782,
1.1939976215362549,
0.779399037361145,
0.48318472504615784,
0.19991084933280945,
-0.05607670545578003,
-0.22635503113269806,
-0.3844183385372162,
0.18971242010593414,
-0.322531133890152,
-0.8122203946113586,
-0.35239169001579285,
0.045888010412454605,
0.880206286907196,
0.6037454605102539,
-0.4490607976913452,
0.2337702512741089,
-0.3066393733024597,
0.8079307079315186,
-0.8225429058074951,
0.40023738145828247,
-0.6898640990257263,
0.00899101234972477,
0.10746627300977707,
0.3913760483264923,
-0.7489364147186279,
-0.8066403269767761,
0.0702073723077774,
-0.6415020227432251,
0.21369227766990662,
0.08174872398376465,
1.0257757902145386,
0.44619524478912354,
-0.2814590632915497,
-0.3018772602081299,
-1.1541481018066406,
0.6692026257514954,
-1.1280651092529297,
0.8305286169052124,
0.5806657075881958,
0.49642857909202576,
-0.10919926315546036,
-0.4778830409049988,
-0.7622334957122803,
-0.27837783098220825,
-0.07082118839025497,
0.17602886259555817,
0.05468197166919708,
0.07126712054014206,
0.37507644295692444,
0.22902563214302063,
-0.4030696749687195,
-0.2757052481174469,
-0.6010617613792419,
-0.24088634550571442,
0.6826516389846802,
-0.22773832082748413,
0.012300780043005943,
0.24101011455059052,
0.06623250246047974,
-0.06524006277322769,
-0.8570280075073242,
0.15681274235248566,
0.2393142580986023,
0.3050804138183594,
-0.032162558287382126,
0.6489142179489136,
-0.4064544141292572,
0.6348311305046082,
0.21902501583099365,
-0.23983801901340485,
-0.22972477972507477,
-0.35333123803138733,
-0.222449392080307,
0.036603137850761414,
0.6318214535713196,
0.0061402879655361176,
0.5732353925704956,
-0.28077948093414307,
-0.2999045252799988,
0.14035101234912872,
0.15870314836502075,
-0.5555347800254822,
-0.17503604292869568,
0.5341140031814575,
-0.0512680783867836,
-0.2519236207008362,
0.2741762697696686,
-0.34901878237724304,
-0.16939373314380646,
-0.26395100355148315,
0.2913421094417572,
-0.5874172449111938,
-0.2615688443183899,
0.3871147334575653,
0.31077927350997925,
-0.33554568886756897,
0.29051169753074646,
-0.7075805068016052,
0.24202221632003784,
0.7895256280899048,
0.6192582249641418,
0.08753596991300583,
-0.04208427295088768,
-0.6176209449768066,
0.7054259181022644,
-0.4902288019657135,
0.5097551345825195,
-0.5983671545982361,
-0.014175508171319962,
0.34898242354393005,
-0.09715909510850906,
0.01929033175110817,
-0.32131099700927734,
0.5561390519142151,
-0.6913376450538635,
0.0824378952383995,
-0.2573164403438568,
-0.8013743758201599,
-0.3596256375312805,
0.30377843976020813,
-0.8616824746131897,
0.49273523688316345,
-0.11141200363636017,
-0.5307515263557434,
0.31318870186805725,
-0.16221480071544647,
-0.16810519993305206,
-0.12655752897262573,
-0.023562194779515266,
-0.4201361835002899,
-0.0077485875226557255,
-0.19431519508361816,
0.26086732745170593,
-0.060057323426008224,
0.46663400530815125,
-0.4686180353164673,
-0.261989563703537,
0.4429274797439575,
-0.18182672560214996,
0.32774800062179565,
0.07326453179121017,
-0.20783135294914246,
-0.018770990893244743,
-0.8346850872039795,
0.21249981224536896,
-0.27634096145629883,
-0.5867534875869751,
-0.11080106347799301,
0.09206085652112961,
-0.3139992356300354,
0.4343990385532379,
0.3331962823867798,
-0.7220882177352905,
-0.13191719353199005,
-0.7146143317222595,
0.06823454797267914,
0.7388440370559692,
-0.15019884705543518,
0.4464639127254486,
-0.5487600564956665,
0.3579505681991577,
0.15246281027793884,
0.013112403452396393,
-0.015625936910510063,
-0.7714478373527527,
-0.6182981729507446,
-0.17019833624362946,
0.4464816749095917,
0.6790225505828857,
-0.22389549016952515,
0.40935182571411133,
-0.13425177335739136,
-0.45233267545700073,
-0.3531420826911926,
-0.03467336297035217,
0.6627302169799805,
0.2513366639614105,
-0.11033623665571213,
0.04846305772662163,
-0.4683898091316223,
-0.8026366233825684,
-0.431972861289978,
-0.6605880856513977,
0.0541352853178978,
-0.1689530462026596,
0.19119928777217865,
-0.03753313422203064,
1.1828677654266357,
-0.6029676795005798,
-0.27502673864364624,
0.22667470574378967,
-0.09765668958425522,
0.5098188519477844,
0.5651657581329346,
0.3224920332431793,
-0.8680770397186279,
-0.4353853464126587,
0.02596447244286537,
-0.6715549826622009,
0.171697199344635,
-0.026884568855166435,
0.049582768231630325,
0.5745145678520203,
0.3890625238418579,
-0.5857336521148682,
0.6377342343330383,
0.6176292896270752,
-0.36297163367271423,
0.7120101451873779,
-0.26972588896751404,
0.021999523043632507,
-0.9394983053207397,
-0.23124158382415771,
0.21794812381267548,
-0.4395013451576233,
-0.4918730556964874,
0.05307300388813019,
0.06080913543701172,
-0.08012006431818008,
-0.049700137227773666,
0.39409300684928894,
-0.15449674427509308,
0.02745736762881279,
-0.03199521824717522,
-0.022601883858442307,
0.01469764206558466,
0.45896756649017334,
0.33155837655067444,
0.5257400274276733,
0.38991066813468933,
-0.5051484107971191,
0.2759331166744232,
0.29012632369995117,
-0.04869024455547333,
0.425327330827713,
-0.7318065166473389,
-0.18956907093524933,
-0.25439557433128357,
0.14445190131664276,
-0.8723942041397095,
-0.1351962685585022,
0.054388388991355896,
-0.3937610387802124,
0.17020931839942932,
-0.10957404226064682,
-0.2650729715824127,
-0.040882088243961334,
-0.08119621872901917,
0.1819007247686386,
0.7957730889320374,
-0.09226994216442108,
0.4435180127620697,
0.1453978270292282,
-0.2664490342140198,
-0.6745501160621643,
-0.626128077507019,
-0.22297774255275726,
0.360895037651062,
-0.667812168598175,
-0.02360924705862999,
-0.3991684317588806,
-0.3897985517978668,
0.03323157876729965,
-0.11879715323448181,
-0.3024972379207611,
-0.08981900662183762,
0.4115864634513855,
0.3132990002632141,
-0.49285027384757996,
0.14189957082271576,
-0.06914643198251724,
0.12498223036527634,
0.17896820604801178,
-0.5123472213745117,
0.001703718793578446,
-0.5054351687431335,
-0.6203638911247253,
-0.3462378680706024,
0.023376300930976868,
0.4469946026802063,
-0.1092095822095871,
0.9616929292678833,
0.3647104799747467,
-0.7775053977966309,
0.057712018489837646,
-0.7087902426719666,
-0.25962477922439575,
-0.4018581509590149,
0.12489382177591324,
-0.44451698660850525,
-0.666046679019928,
0.45778927206993103,
0.3218228220939636,
0.353667289018631,
0.42481908202171326,
0.619964599609375,
-0.08026198297739029,
0.840644359588623,
0.6631519794464111,
0.2767602205276489,
0.1478339284658432,
0.11203257739543915,
0.39516979455947876,
-0.37770259380340576,
-0.1969052106142044,
-0.48614171147346497,
0.3034483790397644,
-0.5380423069000244,
-0.37543338537216187,
0.19438551366329193,
0.23322607576847076,
-0.1703602522611618,
0.2425461709499359,
-0.23482279479503632,
0.4114406704902649,
0.6621376276016235,
0.09541191905736923,
0.6446646451950073,
-0.22493049502372742,
-0.05254277586936951,
-0.1145988330245018,
-0.5091500282287598,
-0.8139479756355286,
1.1101471185684204,
0.36674851179122925,
0.7086397409439087,
0.35718342661857605,
0.6250149607658386,
0.37213802337646484,
0.5915855169296265,
-0.6079967617988586,
0.37870630621910095,
0.08592285215854645,
-1.0514854192733765,
-0.6469758152961731,
-0.266664981842041,
-0.2998548150062561,
-0.1011195257306099,
-0.43240341544151306,
-0.8924541473388672,
0.29996538162231445,
0.5179874897003174,
-0.26180315017700195,
0.31786686182022095,
-0.5196646451950073,
0.6185505986213684,
0.4632302224636078,
-0.26263755559921265,
-0.18363764882087708,
-0.6578418612480164,
0.7883345484733582,
-0.39080190658569336,
0.536679208278656,
-0.28627240657806396,
0.23196804523468018,
0.5192772150039673,
-0.40522435307502747,
1.000084638595581,
0.046841274946928024,
-0.4527691602706909,
0.274825781583786,
0.5663880705833435,
0.7189199924468994,
0.3450652062892914,
-0.3478943407535553,
0.17307345569133759,
0.6816011071205139,
-0.3748117685317993,
-0.6908952593803406,
0.4478733241558075,
-0.5549866557121277,
-0.8397328853607178,
-0.4988155663013458,
-0.6552267074584961,
-0.4273381531238556,
0.16100797057151794,
0.2315184623003006,
0.17565466463565826,
-0.29635554552078247,
-0.25960710644721985,
0.9067487716674805,
0.0938398614525795,
0.13957327604293823,
0.5490692257881165,
-0.2203027307987213,
-0.2943258583545685,
0.9874513745307922,
0.11331555992364883,
0.5712343454360962,
0.29293569922447205,
0.25051164627075195,
-0.2965606153011322,
-0.49213066697120667,
-0.23712584376335144,
0.4787554144859314,
-0.9160918593406677,
-0.11701492220163345,
-0.36536893248558044,
-0.3782028555870056,
-0.8936815857887268,
-0.10681107640266418,
-0.4361339211463928,
-0.765344500541687,
0.2949393093585968,
0.06819819658994675,
0.09873569756746292,
0.9796642065048218,
-0.24822896718978882,
0.08280956000089645,
-1.0126800537109375,
0.2561314105987549,
0.3262689709663391,
0.46832334995269775,
-0.2801603078842163,
-0.6439489126205444,
-0.42849302291870117,
0.47247833013534546,
-0.3217516839504242,
-0.7341326475143433,
0.08271834999322891,
0.4447649419307709,
0.24201329052448273,
0.5089686512947083,
0.30345016717910767,
0.10272520035505295,
-0.6427534222602844,
0.6132248044013977,
0.33504801988601685,
-1.0296262502670288,
0.5975722074508667,
-0.2535494863986969,
0.00407251575961709,
0.2025603950023651,
0.2550122141838074,
-0.780602753162384,
-0.9997411370277405,
-0.7192074060440063,
-0.1406172513961792,
0.646798849105835,
0.46311214566230774,
-0.28251710534095764,
0.11782777309417725,
0.4804253876209259,
0.21855634450912476,
0.25464311242103577,
-0.75146484375,
0.06684912741184235,
-0.31339773535728455,
-0.5434737801551819,
0.04722859710454941,
-0.39577358961105347,
-0.3208378255367279,
0.22216378152370453,
1.1236214637756348,
-0.1949055939912796,
0.0015628699911758304,
0.20111317932605743,
0.03383522853255272,
-0.44464048743247986,
0.41838201880455017,
0.6822707056999207,
1.1358221769332886,
-0.555357813835144,
0.08616860210895538,
-0.05256695672869682,
-0.5054291486740112,
0.27137771248817444,
-0.12959404289722443,
-0.5514764785766602,
0.1744844913482666,
0.33768606185913086,
0.41771894693374634,
-0.10393805801868439,
-0.7491692304611206,
0.528830349445343,
0.14531131088733673,
0.10222744941711426,
-0.5086615085601807,
-0.054706934839487076,
0.19088128209114075,
0.19108764827251434,
0.15741951763629913,
0.20439203083515167,
0.025072520598769188,
-0.44274047017097473,
0.4212152659893036,
0.24465090036392212,
-0.5274112224578857,
-0.73555588722229,
0.808427631855011,
-0.16844584047794342,
-0.2959008514881134,
0.09594772756099701,
0.1047360897064209,
-0.2843538820743561,
0.6753992438316345,
0.8007622361183167,
0.7520976066589355,
-0.3577982485294342,
0.27540460228919983,
0.4867395758628845,
0.48054039478302,
-0.415494829416275,
0.26344284415245056,
0.44654619693756104,
-1.0516135692596436,
-0.47325432300567627,
-0.7572272419929504,
-0.785033106803894,
-0.2678734064102173,
-0.6921589970588684,
0.21050050854682922,
-0.6099548935890198,
-0.10385163873434067,
0.033989571034908295,
-0.43969830870628357,
-0.3400088846683502,
0.5900152325630188,
0.27196136116981506,
0.8623483180999756,
-0.8164035677909851,
0.7284491658210754,
0.7086935639381409,
-0.5740017294883728,
-0.754945695400238,
0.15371207892894745,
-0.17116636037826538,
-0.5642149448394775,
0.7706363201141357,
-0.25252673029899597,
-0.06904309242963791,
-0.32206854224205017,
-0.6084185242652893,
-1.0727242231369019,
0.7144976258277893,
0.8305978775024414,
-0.7238882184028625,
-0.1639925241470337,
0.3399416506290436,
0.256744384765625,
-0.2228652834892273,
-0.273355633020401,
0.4666706919670105,
0.615567684173584,
0.2778918147087097,
-0.8614833354949951,
0.44073233008384705,
0.3121144771575928,
0.07365591824054718,
-0.026796890422701836,
-0.50091552734375,
0.6622552275657654,
-0.5758612155914307,
-0.20330430567264557,
-0.05226242542266846,
1.0764325857162476,
0.5914912819862366,
0.34710896015167236,
0.3128514587879181,
0.4376032054424286,
0.8518802523612976,
-0.14248675107955933,
1.0433365106582642,
-0.39140963554382324,
0.5158577561378479,
1.084600567817688,
-0.39874401688575745,
0.8242204189300537,
0.38049063086509705,
-0.4013548791408539,
0.4669657051563263,
0.5095590353012085,
0.3602134883403778,
0.38970476388931274,
0.0694333165884018,
-0.15204812586307526,
-0.29785677790641785,
-0.04380425065755844,
-0.16071194410324097,
0.03999275341629982,
0.23947682976722717,
0.04765269160270691,
0.06171838566660881,
-0.29236242175102234,
0.09074599295854568,
0.5200555920600891,
-0.06067497655749321,
0.5591174960136414,
0.07463095337152481,
-0.7706559300422668,
0.7206639051437378,
0.10698023438453674,
0.3802907466888428,
-0.48542702198028564,
-0.0809561163187027,
-0.06918653845787048,
0.231294646859169,
-0.29741108417510986,
-0.7256783843040466,
0.5768952965736389,
-0.5293933153152466,
-0.6495342254638672,
0.21151404082775116,
0.6353861093521118,
-0.8238649368286133,
-0.8133124113082886,
-0.29953503608703613,
0.30943724513053894,
-0.0114425765350461,
-0.1188567653298378,
-0.18400606513023376,
-0.2557596266269684,
-0.1884593665599823,
-0.08024322986602783,
-0.08607693761587143,
0.6794533729553223,
-0.14744040369987488,
0.749934196472168,
0.497211754322052,
0.47771114110946655,
0.2882496118545532,
-0.2788412868976593,
0.5474879145622253,
-0.6502290964126587,
-0.5936965346336365,
-0.6818309426307678,
0.2348388284444809,
0.02483271062374115,
-0.006916737649589777,
0.38483673334121704,
0.4430474638938904,
0.7704514265060425,
-0.29641351103782654,
1.0803930759429932,
0.1644173562526703,
0.43956637382507324,
-0.7583234906196594,
0.6970374584197998,
-0.06768273562192917,
0.18788115680217743,
0.018553510308265686,
-0.8763611912727356,
-0.22822412848472595,
0.4112911522388458,
-0.1907520443201065,
-0.15575537085533142,
0.8665279150009155,
0.6868234872817993,
-0.16285179555416107,
0.023575881496071815,
0.7074490785598755,
0.28236207365989685,
0.30776095390319824,
0.5470795035362244,
0.43565836548805237,
-0.5503029823303223,
0.44177424907684326,
-0.23083452880382538,
-0.16760578751564026,
-0.05893079191446304,
-0.8175399303436279,
-0.7541961669921875,
-0.8550446629524231,
-0.7011600732803345,
-0.8448792695999146,
0.2573409378528595,
0.6567433476448059,
0.6930781602859497,
-1.3201535940170288,
-0.3238459527492523,
0.05354798212647438,
0.4789934456348419,
-0.28129279613494873,
-0.1926906406879425,
0.17494414746761322,
-0.4201493263244629,
-0.7499277591705322,
0.015759821981191635,
0.2903374433517456,
0.20331868529319763,
-0.19140924513339996,
-0.23331420123577118,
-0.24598294496536255,
0.5839034914970398,
0.2652515470981598,
0.36457833647727966,
-0.8430790901184082,
-0.6186753511428833,
-0.18074734508991241,
-0.1699291318655014,
0.04004393517971039,
0.6547054648399353,
-0.6212560534477234,
0.1779591292142868,
0.28661906719207764,
0.5689945220947266,
0.3961559236049652,
-0.1770484745502472,
1.151689887046814,
-0.8022828698158264,
0.22342199087142944,
0.17494405806064606,
0.4253706634044647,
0.26222726702690125,
-0.5726593732833862,
0.5789108872413635,
0.30269479751586914,
-0.35357576608657837,
-0.8617005944252014,
0.7028701901435852,
-0.8431248664855957,
0.012749580666422844,
1.2665976285934448,
-0.6116457581520081,
-0.41652899980545044,
-0.1417609006166458,
0.15345498919487,
0.3819318413734436,
-0.31112173199653625,
0.8874466419219971,
0.9672872424125671,
0.3254484534263611,
0.07856755703687668,
-0.3598405718803406,
0.7013648748397827,
0.30808624625205994,
-0.5349881052970886,
0.26350030303001404,
0.597116231918335,
0.4336947500705719,
0.47589433193206787,
0.33418744802474976,
-0.024176273494958878,
0.3864278793334961,
-0.38491714000701904,
0.3621951937675476,
-0.020824672654271126,
-0.1493964046239853,
-0.13706108927726746,
0.25040867924690247,
0.2775367796421051,
-0.02811882458627224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10178v1 | TDAG: A Multi-Agent Framework based on Dynamic Task Decomposition and Agent Generation | 2024-02-15T18:27:37 | 2024-02-15T18:27:37 | Yaoxiang Wang, Zhiyong Wu, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT has inspired the
development of LLM-based agents capable of addressing complex, real-world
tasks. However, these agents often struggle during task execution due to
methodological constraints, such as error propagation and limited adaptability.
To address this issue, we propose a multi-agent framework based on dynamic Task
Decomposition and Agent Generation (TDAG). This framework dynamically
decomposes complex tasks into smaller subtasks and assigns each to a
specifically generated subagent, thereby enhancing adaptability in diverse and
unpredictable real-world tasks. Simultaneously, existing benchmarks often lack
the granularity needed to evaluate incremental progress in complex, multi-step
tasks. In response, we introduce ItineraryBench in the context of travel
planning, featuring interconnected, progressively complex tasks with a
fine-grained evaluation system. ItineraryBench is designed to assess agents'
abilities in memory, planning, and tool usage across tasks of varying
complexity. Our experimental results reveal that TDAG significantly outperforms
established baselines, showcasing its superior adaptability and context
awareness in complex task scenarios. | [
-0.35147684812545776,
-0.7116613388061523,
0.6784935593605042,
0.45930376648902893,
-0.0369856096804142,
0.8355402946472168,
-0.25541093945503235,
-0.17259690165519714,
0.1080564633011818,
0.017253883183002472,
-0.7690379619598389,
-0.43768030405044556,
-0.18204668164253235,
-0.24382050335407257,
-0.18024638295173645,
0.6609516739845276,
-0.19949384033679962,
-0.4031221866607666,
-0.1354912668466568,
0.004563876893371344,
-0.6317818760871887,
-0.43732455372810364,
-0.8019016981124878,
-0.6084731221199036,
0.5087644457817078,
0.5191071629524231,
0.4396926164627075,
0.3050386905670166,
0.36641445755958557,
0.3359316289424896,
0.11795778572559357,
0.2332805097103119,
-0.43326854705810547,
0.29050666093826294,
-0.5504041314125061,
-0.013212021440267563,
-0.7795801162719727,
-0.5222736597061157,
0.6457775235176086,
0.3436742126941681,
-0.5040990114212036,
0.21282941102981567,
-0.23057356476783752,
0.1332322508096695,
-0.603067934513092,
0.4463781416416168,
-0.547451376914978,
-0.0714605450630188,
-0.1308642327785492,
-0.18732024729251862,
-0.1834123432636261,
0.1528065949678421,
0.08311684429645538,
-0.5145452618598938,
0.11192108690738678,
-0.03916074335575104,
0.582119345664978,
0.2792155146598816,
-0.5475178360939026,
-0.15289223194122314,
-0.9334061145782471,
0.6417490839958191,
-0.3189845383167267,
0.08067800104618073,
-0.0886651873588562,
0.786968469619751,
-0.4553365409374237,
-0.8132534027099609,
-0.670840859413147,
-0.33747151494026184,
0.21367748081684113,
0.05102202668786049,
-0.15022672712802887,
0.12528569996356964,
-0.13063503801822662,
-0.0464925691485405,
-0.6694974899291992,
-0.021381936967372894,
0.08574138581752777,
-0.06618279963731766,
0.42417797446250916,
0.5565667152404785,
0.5085543990135193,
0.18781952559947968,
-0.30483049154281616,
0.010923647321760654,
-0.358828067779541,
-0.08707725256681442,
-0.016375059261918068,
0.45994657278060913,
-0.0455879308283329,
0.3409349322319031,
-0.4084908962249756,
0.3825366795063019,
-0.02162851393222809,
-0.32592710852622986,
0.03985517472028732,
-0.45370402932167053,
-0.23452365398406982,
-0.014905554242432117,
0.2202838957309723,
0.3432174324989319,
0.18166305124759674,
-0.48460522294044495,
-0.2049112319946289,
0.04679444059729576,
0.5015403032302856,
-0.832618236541748,
-0.1089916005730629,
0.42905867099761963,
-0.11687494069337845,
-0.24628958106040955,
-0.3448067307472229,
-0.6394692659378052,
-0.3700980842113495,
0.000009160738954960834,
0.3453488349914551,
-0.18701259791851044,
-0.6305366158485413,
0.0506773442029953,
-0.1772114634513855,
0.15522044897079468,
0.6360642313957214,
-0.39008989930152893,
0.16170866787433624,
0.4121384918689728,
0.7555899620056152,
-0.2743811011314392,
-0.7309280633926392,
-0.5075924396514893,
0.563080906867981,
-0.16958482563495636,
1.2181673049926758,
-0.6486344933509827,
-0.4706003963947296,
0.008277040906250477,
-0.007964929565787315,
-0.2917291224002838,
-0.40165722370147705,
0.4244355261325836,
-0.479208767414093,
-0.25668278336524963,
-0.42983561754226685,
-0.07549992948770523,
-0.3467910885810852,
0.8190635442733765,
-0.5013428330421448,
0.7829077839851379,
0.5137650966644287,
-0.18702155351638794,
0.4592113196849823,
-0.8747996091842651,
-0.36489689350128174,
0.13746869564056396,
-0.08046197146177292,
-0.34525081515312195,
0.015227681957185268,
-0.13835754990577698,
0.18188776075839996,
-0.4788374602794647,
0.4728414714336395,
-0.4772327244281769,
-0.30358487367630005,
-0.06642456352710724,
-0.1359562873840332,
0.4751744270324707,
0.21087516844272614,
-0.35404762625694275,
0.5037939548492432,
-0.9254682064056396,
0.29352763295173645,
0.1309620589017868,
-0.7908985614776611,
0.19899043440818787,
0.26796141266822815,
0.3692016005516052,
0.33935290575027466,
0.14307737350463867,
-0.3220028281211853,
0.5413323640823364,
0.053401146084070206,
0.3111805319786072,
0.8503351211547852,
0.05557401850819588,
0.3060450255870819,
-0.5247463583946228,
0.7564157247543335,
0.04122849181294441,
-0.14811402559280396,
0.10375617444515228,
0.14059779047966003,
-0.7899523973464966,
-0.29934513568878174,
-0.08246325701475143,
0.4640315771102905,
-0.7995806336402893,
0.19762058556079865,
-0.5430465340614319,
-0.6951900720596313,
0.2877776026725769,
-0.2342763990163803,
0.24280737340450287,
0.18482020497322083,
0.11783082038164139,
-0.1088104397058487,
-0.3077186942100525,
-0.4607762396335602,
-0.1643133908510208,
-0.3352583646774292,
0.11412937194108963,
-0.06310258060693741,
0.4773288667201996,
-0.5178698301315308,
0.4604555368423462,
-0.22080069780349731,
-0.3798747956752777,
-0.49983859062194824,
-0.03751494735479355,
-0.3359839618206024,
0.47140565514564514,
0.8293097615242004,
-0.43008026480674744,
-0.45223620533943176,
0.04970148950815201,
-0.4195244610309601,
-0.08821083605289459,
-0.3506277799606323,
-0.2746509611606598,
0.0749623104929924,
0.19981493055820465,
-0.7333969473838806,
0.22447241842746735,
0.12550629675388336,
-0.7787489295005798,
0.4715711772441864,
-0.266845703125,
0.017562787979841232,
-0.9104070067405701,
0.11181370913982391,
-0.41358280181884766,
-0.4699326753616333,
-0.7075260281562805,
0.2834475040435791,
-0.2242479920387268,
-0.09986478090286255,
-0.2421707659959793,
0.7978222370147705,
-0.4060085713863373,
-0.18651142716407776,
-0.49674999713897705,
-0.07640102505683899,
0.029003743082284927,
0.7170279026031494,
-0.17186255753040314,
0.8288233876228333,
0.4913710951805115,
-0.5377116203308105,
0.3345499038696289,
0.11064136028289795,
-0.14376652240753174,
0.6919461488723755,
-0.3315035104751587,
0.21905098855495453,
-0.11338426172733307,
0.40395447611808777,
-0.9452440738677979,
-0.4137154817581177,
0.13650517165660858,
0.09430850297212601,
0.18645983934402466,
0.15461720526218414,
-0.5654439330101013,
-0.03675691783428192,
-0.2393885999917984,
0.3559459447860718,
0.19627895951271057,
-0.3101171851158142,
1.3746933937072754,
0.3874206840991974,
-0.020448829978704453,
-0.4872278571128845,
-0.4025149941444397,
0.3032758831977844,
-0.177436962723732,
-0.5160241723060608,
0.4613229036331177,
-0.19031797349452972,
-0.4321175813674927,
0.02371208369731903,
-0.532615065574646,
-0.2177431583404541,
0.16763794422149658,
0.4222894012928009,
-0.18426932394504547,
0.1227886825799942,
0.19783322513103485,
0.01757674105465412,
0.027267031371593475,
-0.13211998343467712,
-0.15237826108932495,
0.7778072357177734,
-0.29203885793685913,
-0.3799270689487457,
0.1660609394311905,
0.5603541731834412,
0.8331959843635559,
-0.3301866054534912,
0.4529067575931549,
0.8394747972488403,
-0.30469104647636414,
-0.6329599022865295,
-0.3834969401359558,
0.3386472463607788,
-0.49727895855903625,
0.43331366777420044,
-0.9706342220306396,
-0.5447428822517395,
0.7398221492767334,
-0.4128197133541107,
0.2986387610435486,
0.207727313041687,
1.0054510831832886,
0.12937846779823303,
0.6121668219566345,
0.8015157580375671,
0.36159569025039673,
0.5815038084983826,
-0.02481132000684738,
0.057222675532102585,
-0.3948279321193695,
-0.3365846872329712,
-0.4561493992805481,
-0.31629639863967896,
-0.4589391350746155,
-0.5853912234306335,
0.3306887149810791,
-0.4003017246723175,
-0.2831241190433502,
0.09936654567718506,
-0.2666831314563751,
0.3536781370639801,
0.49895256757736206,
-0.02223752997815609,
0.31139716506004333,
-0.19105035066604614,
0.0813637524843216,
0.697180986404419,
-0.7469888925552368,
-0.5334863066673279,
0.8073734641075134,
0.032400187104940414,
0.7115175127983093,
0.2658953368663788,
0.4075435400009155,
0.6584101319313049,
0.1107608750462532,
-0.8333877921104431,
0.8442909717559814,
0.17279034852981567,
-0.6935830116271973,
-0.11385460197925568,
-0.06569824367761612,
-0.8482821583747864,
0.48236411809921265,
0.028192095458507538,
-0.8041139245033264,
0.2120680809020996,
0.011758305132389069,
-0.4495343863964081,
0.27242404222488403,
-0.868334174156189,
0.6639729738235474,
-0.11174262315034866,
-0.4271048307418823,
-0.4770517945289612,
-0.33930882811546326,
-0.08437325060367584,
-0.28304556012153625,
-0.015531416051089764,
-0.5598752498626709,
-0.11368055641651154,
0.4558296501636505,
-0.32010385394096375,
0.5903077721595764,
-0.3494584858417511,
-0.11306259781122208,
0.43461185693740845,
0.4674132466316223,
0.6019988059997559,
0.05899902805685997,
-0.22631922364234924,
0.0692528709769249,
0.27447232604026794,
-0.5233083367347717,
-0.310495525598526,
0.8574689626693726,
-0.5794055461883545,
-0.623583197593689,
-0.4817875027656555,
-1.0335767269134521,
-0.2741999328136444,
0.5271968841552734,
-0.27323052287101746,
0.22535672783851624,
-0.3405485153198242,
-0.32476377487182617,
-0.09224111586809158,
-0.14010252058506012,
0.8227697014808655,
0.6611483693122864,
0.01655757427215576,
-0.1055307686328888,
0.8643196225166321,
0.33946460485458374,
0.08396314829587936,
0.23979559540748596,
-0.12886932492256165,
-0.05433930456638336,
-0.8374513387680054,
-0.29357364773750305,
-0.04688304290175438,
-0.8371354937553406,
0.04210447520017624,
-0.5888667702674866,
0.1854925900697708,
-0.18574677407741547,
-0.32564327120780945,
-0.4692900478839874,
-0.4078565835952759,
0.1233692467212677,
0.03478430584073067,
-0.2094125598669052,
0.6308577656745911,
0.08147221803665161,
0.5612999200820923,
-0.5461284518241882,
0.40975430607795715,
0.23238369822502136,
0.4087393283843994,
-0.18095728754997253,
0.020104769617319107,
-0.3772951364517212,
-0.31729114055633545,
-0.3552004098892212,
-0.565980076789856,
0.14889663457870483,
0.19906485080718994,
0.6985670328140259,
0.04377686604857445,
0.20524147152900696,
0.8880681991577148,
-0.4700334966182709,
0.6635469198226929,
-0.42687082290649414,
-0.8385900259017944,
0.15064719319343567,
-0.5943419933319092,
0.6469852924346924,
0.46985357999801636,
-0.2743946611881256,
-0.07979263365268707,
-0.34044158458709717,
-0.5407013893127441,
-0.7571213245391846,
0.8269267082214355,
0.29183125495910645,
-0.19446052610874176,
0.447919100522995,
0.06878481060266495,
0.020591232925653458,
0.5000060200691223,
-0.6134013533592224,
0.1332607865333557,
0.040455084294080734,
0.048630595207214355,
-0.13473467528820038,
-0.33472055196762085,
-0.3896045386791229,
0.08028321713209152,
0.4873749017715454,
-0.24665340781211853,
0.5841357707977295,
-0.0493001826107502,
-0.10899139940738678,
-0.3257904648780823,
0.4131888151168823,
0.7611914873123169,
1.2773637771606445,
-0.414349764585495,
0.2029998004436493,
0.12104112654924393,
-0.31417134404182434,
0.5050548911094666,
0.19994749128818512,
0.08534631878137589,
-0.09215248376131058,
0.5467512011528015,
0.43281686305999756,
-0.44492608308792114,
-0.9395110607147217,
0.14539189636707306,
-0.2399454265832901,
0.06864263117313385,
-0.5305176377296448,
0.2800741195678711,
-0.015479939058423042,
0.7326563596725464,
0.24301777780056,
0.1736176609992981,
0.04210658371448517,
-0.6682556867599487,
0.10053826868534088,
0.3449120819568634,
-0.052114177495241165,
-0.49007856845855713,
0.5124223828315735,
0.35258349776268005,
-0.4885413944721222,
0.057429779320955276,
-0.6052069664001465,
-0.37508758902549744,
0.7153607606887817,
0.283191978931427,
1.174426794052124,
-0.29209601879119873,
0.13957524299621582,
0.05969178304076195,
0.48777565360069275,
0.0017014421755447984,
0.67160964012146,
-0.20912852883338928,
-0.5354371666908264,
-0.40497028827667236,
-0.4651901423931122,
-0.33254215121269226,
-0.1371755301952362,
-0.03204008564352989,
0.18383388221263885,
-0.4309006631374359,
-0.22788195312023163,
-0.1460380256175995,
-0.010654740035533905,
-0.8094527125358582,
0.16928155720233917,
-0.052354734390974045,
0.5675984621047974,
-0.42806607484817505,
0.9266983270645142,
1.1109980344772339,
-0.17844943702220917,
-0.820906937122345,
0.5344609618186951,
0.062298115342855453,
-0.7238681316375732,
0.4860968589782715,
0.16398529708385468,
-0.41294586658477783,
-0.007986743003129959,
0.06740999966859818,
-0.7325353026390076,
1.1919207572937012,
0.5650975704193115,
-0.27218711376190186,
-0.5194323658943176,
0.18549026548862457,
0.5225571393966675,
-0.2526837885379791,
0.2931404411792755,
0.5549858212471008,
0.5643489956855774,
0.16777780652046204,
-1.2146824598312378,
0.36302363872528076,
-0.16347451508045197,
-0.025613872334361076,
0.05658113583922386,
-1.0248531103134155,
0.9044181704521179,
-0.1762964278459549,
-0.42718496918678284,
-0.2744613289833069,
0.08650463819503784,
0.18635468184947968,
0.4339445233345032,
0.734131932258606,
0.24437406659126282,
0.46397098898887634,
-0.22224092483520508,
0.7036488652229309,
-0.12255845218896866,
0.2664354741573334,
1.235913872718811,
-0.48697972297668457,
0.32873252034187317,
0.44966810941696167,
0.03508700802922249,
0.6562076807022095,
0.5704584121704102,
0.27544352412223816,
0.6751235723495483,
0.31763118505477905,
-0.3951338827610016,
-0.41568800806999207,
-0.34421852231025696,
-0.01150279026478529,
0.7699189782142639,
0.2614433169364929,
0.2172955572605133,
-1.0064928531646729,
0.24755290150642395,
0.05261513218283653,
-0.2982518672943115,
-0.1680397093296051,
0.6706503629684448,
-0.23726628720760345,
-0.8433284759521484,
0.6204741597175598,
0.06009009853005409,
0.053805846720933914,
-0.7563458681106567,
-0.11520188301801682,
-0.1238800436258316,
0.43344196677207947,
-0.06469549238681793,
-0.6183150410652161,
0.3613046109676361,
-0.16506387293338776,
0.10119116306304932,
-0.3769969940185547,
0.9255892038345337,
-0.24847465753555298,
-0.1917058229446411,
0.3051854372024536,
0.807887852191925,
-0.2149006575345993,
-0.2755674123764038,
-0.5383710265159607,
0.29229310154914856,
-0.06094648689031601,
-0.6847200393676758,
0.2513694167137146,
0.5946060419082642,
-0.22193805873394012,
1.1197823286056519,
0.2655192017555237,
-0.04032598435878754,
-0.06450584530830383,
-0.1082565188407898,
1.083237648010254,
-0.6667105555534363,
-0.6122143864631653,
-0.8447248935699463,
0.6782201528549194,
0.08188563585281372,
0.18982522189617157,
0.5282764434814453,
0.32124242186546326,
0.6179619431495667,
-0.11043033003807068,
0.909553050994873,
-0.38408976793289185,
0.1794331818819046,
-0.12526361644268036,
0.42579957842826843,
-0.6599925756454468,
0.47626930475234985,
-0.11054769158363342,
-0.8106505274772644,
-0.041107095777988434,
0.2435077279806137,
0.12630967795848846,
0.061210185289382935,
0.6906086802482605,
0.6509093046188354,
-0.08718128502368927,
-0.6149525046348572,
0.20371466875076294,
-0.1463375985622406,
1.156031608581543,
0.8169879913330078,
0.7634959816932678,
0.06220778450369835,
0.8424535989761353,
-0.05385366082191467,
-0.07299376279115677,
-0.21183669567108154,
-0.8211513161659241,
-1.1736034154891968,
-0.5590421557426453,
-0.3655642867088318,
-0.24688895046710968,
0.10035287588834763,
1.07870352268219,
0.7293726205825806,
-0.3933446705341339,
-0.41434234380722046,
-0.22537553310394287,
0.07682515680789948,
-0.43912896513938904,
-0.19385653734207153,
0.18190114200115204,
-0.2894784212112427,
-0.805126965045929,
0.5934250354766846,
0.41411763429641724,
0.1320299655199051,
-0.3198985159397125,
0.19068408012390137,
-0.10013935714960098,
0.21157383918762207,
0.6196545362472534,
0.08154377341270447,
-0.4839683771133423,
-0.37828776240348816,
-0.21571534872055054,
-0.009495989419519901,
-0.11152338236570358,
0.7394722104072571,
-0.5799745321273804,
0.6593199968338013,
0.4797922372817993,
0.6290519833564758,
0.5339159369468689,
-0.061271581798791885,
0.5744203329086304,
-0.6933067440986633,
0.329135000705719,
0.1733519583940506,
0.19973450899124146,
-0.2055833339691162,
-0.2750624716281891,
0.6614024043083191,
0.04913339018821716,
-0.6304205656051636,
-1.0301425457000732,
0.3074759244918823,
-1.4740136861801147,
-0.4681069254875183,
1.201720118522644,
-0.14564841985702515,
-0.04482290521264076,
-0.25440436601638794,
-0.3478105664253235,
0.30352360010147095,
-0.6709040999412537,
0.9113143086433411,
0.761085569858551,
-0.30290302634239197,
0.04748060181736946,
-0.3828042149543762,
0.43997007608413696,
0.2744237780570984,
-1.211434006690979,
0.15041594207286835,
0.6056301593780518,
0.3064272403717041,
0.30224260687828064,
0.9649033546447754,
0.494514524936676,
0.11960794776678085,
0.29417434334754944,
0.13753435015678406,
-0.3678251802921295,
-0.4377388060092926,
0.19086988270282745,
0.6520096659660339,
0.32890942692756653,
-0.3182995021343231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10176v1 | OpenMathInstruct-1: A 1.8 Million Math Instruction Tuning Dataset | 2024-02-15T18:26:11 | 2024-02-15T18:26:11 | Shubham Toshniwal, Ivan Moshkov, Sean Narenthiran, Daria Gitman, Fei Jia, Igor Gitman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work has shown the immense potential of synthetically generated
datasets for training large language models (LLMs), especially for acquiring
targeted skills. Current large-scale math instruction tuning datasets such as
MetaMathQA (Yu et al., 2024) and MAmmoTH (Yue et al., 2024) are constructed
using outputs from closed-source LLMs with commercially restrictive licenses. A
key reason limiting the use of open-source LLMs in these data generation
pipelines has been the wide gap between the mathematical skills of the best
closed-source LLMs, such as GPT-4, and the best open-source LLMs. Building on
the recent progress in open-source LLMs, our proposed prompting novelty, and
some brute-force scaling, we construct OpenMathInstruct-1, a math instruction
tuning dataset with 1.8M problem-solution pairs. The dataset is constructed by
synthesizing code-interpreter solutions for GSM8K and MATH, two popular math
reasoning benchmarks, using the recently released and permissively licensed
Mixtral model. Our best model, OpenMath-CodeLlama-70B, trained on a subset of
OpenMathInstruct-1, achieves a score of 84.6% on GSM8K and 50.7% on MATH, which
is competitive with the best gpt-distilled models. We release our code, models,
and the OpenMathInstruct-1 dataset under a commercially permissive license. | [
-0.337750107049942,
-0.6663009524345398,
0.24055850505828857,
0.03744414821267128,
-0.15733517706394196,
-0.28164568543434143,
-0.369297057390213,
0.08243651688098907,
-0.2838927209377289,
0.48324358463287354,
-0.8553787469863892,
-0.7425795793533325,
-0.35566091537475586,
-0.06503818184137344,
0.026386683806777,
1.1375641822814941,
-0.13345928490161896,
0.3550261855125427,
-0.37189626693725586,
-0.22390349209308624,
-0.27898934483528137,
-0.4606795907020569,
-0.2998444437980652,
-0.22541411221027374,
0.4877386689186096,
0.6324720978736877,
0.7404123544692993,
0.8558439612388611,
0.550139844417572,
0.21614456176757812,
0.11248070746660233,
0.15681329369544983,
-0.8482084274291992,
-0.17195336520671844,
-0.24677754938602448,
-0.5322757959365845,
-0.7096045017242432,
0.4242510497570038,
0.6631145477294922,
0.7341326475143433,
-0.3910161256790161,
0.5085664391517639,
-0.19518481194972992,
0.8039445281028748,
-0.4665972590446472,
0.4950302541255951,
-0.6864398121833801,
0.006665998604148626,
-0.5260485410690308,
-0.09523942321538925,
-0.4657312035560608,
-0.7710996270179749,
-0.18659426271915436,
-0.7822068929672241,
0.022335588932037354,
-0.0964634120464325,
0.4635632336139679,
0.5202520489692688,
-0.007139990106225014,
-0.3975454568862915,
-0.34213587641716003,
0.9218218326568604,
-0.6545490622520447,
0.27204057574272156,
0.6200271248817444,
0.520111620426178,
-0.09735903888940811,
-0.37183091044425964,
-0.12335578352212906,
-0.005611842963844538,
0.25016969442367554,
0.1113993376493454,
0.021932901814579964,
-0.02533324994146824,
0.5028309226036072,
0.7105268836021423,
-0.6965489983558655,
0.16448524594306946,
-0.6694067120552063,
-0.05994721129536629,
0.390988826751709,
0.4263625741004944,
0.06404648721218109,
0.20991723239421844,
-0.07216617465019226,
-0.07126358896493912,
-1.1895653009414673,
-0.25438982248306274,
0.7380765676498413,
0.2712000012397766,
-0.25359591841697693,
0.8128434419631958,
0.019894368946552277,
0.7465645670890808,
-0.3199416399002075,
-0.16698680818080902,
0.1456054300069809,
-0.25009575486183167,
-0.2948710322380066,
0.10008349269628525,
0.4413830041885376,
-0.009465848095715046,
0.7056233286857605,
0.054534267634153366,
-0.18056844174861908,
0.190082848072052,
0.18350332975387573,
-0.9735614657402039,
-0.32363536953926086,
-0.11353079974651337,
-0.28172677755355835,
-0.3268999457359314,
0.24621595442295074,
-0.5762254595756531,
0.02017577923834324,
-0.5912051200866699,
0.39716604351997375,
-0.36711201071739197,
-0.27952611446380615,
0.24654023349285126,
0.23136143386363983,
0.10399169474840164,
0.32210034132003784,
-1.0058215856552124,
0.3275303542613983,
0.7813223004341125,
0.9819478392601013,
-0.10396037250757217,
-0.1222194954752922,
-0.5210058689117432,
-0.25719332695007324,
-0.5398789048194885,
0.3771577775478363,
-0.6320489048957825,
-0.28203681111335754,
-0.00019127095583826303,
-0.07951676845550537,
-0.1520644873380661,
-0.7556734085083008,
0.500880241394043,
-0.5156680941581726,
0.47170737385749817,
0.021752096712589264,
-0.6287790536880493,
-0.023943206295371056,
0.046172134578228,
-0.6949993968009949,
0.8071568012237549,
0.7134833335876465,
-0.5493836998939514,
0.06726563721895218,
-0.8978145122528076,
-0.11685888469219208,
0.005130022764205933,
-0.277698278427124,
-0.567643940448761,
0.25304701924324036,
0.13755957782268524,
-0.024684537202119827,
-0.46672698855400085,
0.06313075125217438,
-0.29340827465057373,
-0.3643437325954437,
0.16267643868923187,
-0.567363440990448,
0.9990326762199402,
0.3505645990371704,
-0.02607126720249653,
0.08902999758720398,
-0.7475569844245911,
0.19655853509902954,
0.19551587104797363,
-0.49453219771385193,
-0.12871398031711578,
-0.20501427352428436,
-0.3597579300403595,
0.2157885730266571,
0.1595001220703125,
-0.6313509941101074,
0.2418789118528366,
-0.43762698769569397,
0.3088432252407074,
1.0984793901443481,
-0.35053887963294983,
0.2853226661682129,
-0.38359642028808594,
0.8927766680717468,
0.04191647842526436,
0.02896757610142231,
-0.46430835127830505,
-0.5296441316604614,
-0.5402727127075195,
-0.3711414635181427,
0.3985131084918976,
0.46550142765045166,
-0.4492066204547882,
0.2254372388124466,
-0.26253852248191833,
-0.3471611440181732,
-0.8057425022125244,
0.11170757561922073,
0.6231915950775146,
0.612052857875824,
0.2865254878997803,
0.23017725348472595,
-0.3956144452095032,
-0.8412891030311584,
-0.22975440323352814,
0.24723556637763977,
-0.22127686440944672,
0.4516439139842987,
0.38155749440193176,
0.21833467483520508,
0.7130295038223267,
-0.7133858799934387,
-0.2531077265739441,
0.029914213344454765,
-0.2129557877779007,
0.5324674248695374,
0.40712159872055054,
0.3855038285255432,
-0.4411769211292267,
-0.5563757419586182,
0.061382491141557693,
-0.7533678412437439,
-0.1767754703760147,
0.5146345496177673,
-0.19355279207229614,
0.23810528218746185,
0.35633668303489685,
-0.48275992274284363,
0.32323840260505676,
0.7142971158027649,
-0.2481835037469864,
0.6721370220184326,
-0.10183075815439224,
-0.022386085242033005,
-1.079397201538086,
-0.00958765484392643,
-0.05365327000617981,
-0.07661251723766327,
-0.34838545322418213,
0.16337308287620544,
0.0975012555718422,
-0.36746305227279663,
-0.44280770421028137,
0.4912600517272949,
-0.2509586811065674,
-0.07252561300992966,
0.10369199514389038,
-0.1418846994638443,
-0.5255281329154968,
0.5279210209846497,
-0.3999674320220947,
1.2527551651000977,
0.4392639398574829,
-0.3497641682624817,
0.33482152223587036,
0.36374443769454956,
-0.6347182393074036,
0.4100574851036072,
-0.6508917212486267,
0.23170939087867737,
0.14163914322853088,
-0.054345473647117615,
-0.632450520992279,
-0.4502337872982025,
0.22397024929523468,
-0.3760797083377838,
0.1408044695854187,
-0.3831772208213806,
-0.5320422053337097,
-0.19125159084796906,
-0.13403140008449554,
0.446727454662323,
0.7609298229217529,
-0.7034267783164978,
0.3401714563369751,
0.25832024216651917,
-0.33023419976234436,
-0.30099087953567505,
-0.4909752905368805,
-0.43827152252197266,
-0.08466129004955292,
-0.7512478232383728,
-0.05429113283753395,
-0.26019880175590515,
-0.281547874212265,
0.06049228459596634,
-0.31265872716903687,
-0.025975577533245087,
-0.01480436883866787,
0.25392264127731323,
0.5010291337966919,
-0.5987334847450256,
0.1973750740289688,
0.106875479221344,
-0.410423219203949,
0.24667486548423767,
-0.4818156361579895,
0.43288734555244446,
-0.1841127872467041,
-0.5704393982887268,
0.02598590962588787,
0.03389989584684372,
0.6173027753829956,
-0.30729079246520996,
0.6151918172836304,
0.25457027554512024,
-0.3071250319480896,
-0.40947774052619934,
-0.13250944018363953,
-0.11666902899742126,
-0.5275218486785889,
0.41508448123931885,
-0.47446519136428833,
-0.9930739402770996,
0.24525965750217438,
-0.1745413839817047,
0.3446049988269806,
0.38507819175720215,
0.7088977694511414,
0.32933324575424194,
1.1069475412368774,
0.2512195110321045,
-0.16133853793144226,
0.3655407130718231,
-0.11814696341753006,
0.0772726833820343,
-0.6735992431640625,
-0.13033346831798553,
-0.5231923460960388,
-0.18167845904827118,
-0.5806858539581299,
-0.4459523856639862,
0.5039768815040588,
-0.07383854687213898,
-0.37416017055511475,
0.09678921103477478,
-0.3535791039466858,
0.9394704699516296,
0.5386524200439453,
0.21049706637859344,
0.2847629189491272,
0.4709278643131256,
-0.31846392154693604,
-0.1555381417274475,
-0.7340127825737,
-0.36615684628486633,
1.4555836915969849,
0.39964401721954346,
1.0220930576324463,
0.2651364505290985,
0.40069881081581116,
-0.10454890131950378,
0.380142480134964,
-0.6518276333808899,
0.48180660605430603,
-0.365578293800354,
-0.6269335150718689,
-0.2585722804069519,
-0.9107653498649597,
-0.7366746068000793,
-0.10051586478948593,
0.2169409692287445,
-0.31504225730895996,
-0.5833317637443542,
0.12250042706727982,
0.09673100709915161,
0.3442283570766449,
-0.7121222615242004,
0.941718578338623,
0.020195748656988144,
-0.4505355656147003,
-0.3966568410396576,
-0.2574693262577057,
0.6172313094139099,
-0.18763893842697144,
0.23067481815814972,
-0.20034338533878326,
0.12815049290657043,
0.41806283593177795,
-0.6434115767478943,
0.5139682292938232,
-0.24432994425296783,
-0.40930455923080444,
0.22590965032577515,
0.3165702223777771,
0.31040504574775696,
0.17717261612415314,
-0.2580599784851074,
0.2912319004535675,
-0.32172030210494995,
-0.4515385329723358,
-0.5899945497512817,
0.8835057616233826,
-0.880768895149231,
-0.5131316781044006,
-0.12556467950344086,
-0.7602083086967468,
-0.08443442732095718,
0.03687949851155281,
0.266577810049057,
0.8269482851028442,
-0.05077510327100754,
0.3001486361026764,
0.9745951294898987,
-0.13013342022895813,
0.1427251696586609,
0.47277384996414185,
-0.24652199447155,
-0.6333779692649841,
1.2175939083099365,
0.11427752673625946,
0.5211480259895325,
0.056704454123973846,
0.3740798234939575,
-0.24378462135791779,
-0.3202877938747406,
-0.6114591956138611,
0.24004600942134857,
-0.680037796497345,
-0.32636573910713196,
-0.07337809354066849,
-0.5352099537849426,
-0.10898876935243607,
-0.003474086057394743,
-0.3709217309951782,
-0.5796928405761719,
-0.3373733162879944,
0.05492447316646576,
0.39578670263290405,
0.9233062267303467,
0.03736558556556702,
0.0578003004193306,
-0.6193928718566895,
0.1653289496898651,
0.2179887741804123,
0.8346590995788574,
-0.2508903741836548,
-0.7551257610321045,
-0.516015887260437,
0.31565484404563904,
-0.24437133967876434,
-0.37940293550491333,
0.04457623139023781,
0.2133459746837616,
0.4952787160873413,
0.41003766655921936,
-0.27291056513786316,
0.48261865973472595,
-0.6583728194236755,
0.42415452003479004,
0.061198532581329346,
-0.7377801537513733,
0.5868737101554871,
-0.6696018576622009,
0.5972270369529724,
0.29121002554893494,
0.5087617635726929,
-0.14786604046821594,
-0.1062321737408638,
-0.37642702460289,
-0.1037420704960823,
1.1192286014556885,
0.3255678415298462,
0.04914040118455887,
0.10532645136117935,
0.3224090337753296,
0.36808502674102783,
0.2760576009750366,
-0.48893871903419495,
-0.32342851161956787,
-0.3432265818119049,
-0.6657630205154419,
-0.01686464063823223,
0.12873141467571259,
-0.249394953250885,
-0.44425755739212036,
0.6434229016304016,
-0.2381240725517273,
0.10933007299900055,
-0.33105695247650146,
-0.12266872078180313,
-0.34931936860084534,
0.1573944389820099,
0.9264766573905945,
1.0094691514968872,
-0.26168203353881836,
-0.08955428749322891,
-0.07886023819446564,
-0.7310753464698792,
0.11748506873846054,
0.10451505333185196,
-0.04372011870145798,
-0.17825204133987427,
0.13287071883678436,
0.8525056838989258,
0.23223429918289185,
-0.6574777960777283,
0.3642578721046448,
0.10095500200986862,
-0.5920548439025879,
-0.19272074103355408,
0.4122869372367859,
0.07592448592185974,
-0.0526445135474205,
0.15802037715911865,
-0.12423066049814224,
-0.363909512758255,
-0.3820735216140747,
0.12397164851427078,
0.3828556537628174,
-0.21036744117736816,
-0.49596986174583435,
0.5765640735626221,
-0.040521446615457535,
-0.48688095808029175,
0.8789941668510437,
-0.17378176748752594,
-0.3859674632549286,
0.6299571990966797,
0.7646913528442383,
0.6307561993598938,
-0.4541987180709839,
0.049552492797374725,
0.6685436964035034,
0.31018686294555664,
-0.017055490985512733,
0.34250330924987793,
0.11016137152910233,
-0.37168818712234497,
-0.42468157410621643,
-0.6849554181098938,
-0.5394750237464905,
0.21298740804195404,
-0.5812214612960815,
0.4875947833061218,
-0.6141983866691589,
0.28469526767730713,
-0.18961751461029053,
-0.10410261154174805,
-0.621010422706604,
-0.030736342072486877,
-0.043353646993637085,
1.0547614097595215,
-0.5724128484725952,
0.8452216982841492,
0.6664007902145386,
-0.311587393283844,
-0.7738242745399475,
-0.4568921625614166,
0.12901335954666138,
-0.9644227623939514,
0.4694504141807556,
0.1903758943080902,
0.17319507896900177,
0.3916947543621063,
-0.6861158609390259,
-0.8054826855659485,
1.0788848400115967,
0.6718437671661377,
-0.7157617211341858,
-0.1237609013915062,
0.39127856492996216,
0.2324838638305664,
-0.5255042314529419,
0.2365867793560028,
0.48430293798446655,
0.29366159439086914,
0.09922174364328384,
-0.8517859578132629,
-0.13906723260879517,
-0.24799856543540955,
-0.345665842294693,
0.6057165265083313,
-0.5759106874465942,
1.1677823066711426,
-0.21189101040363312,
-0.16618536412715912,
0.09222368896007538,
0.1989230066537857,
0.4109707772731781,
0.18490272760391235,
0.22889883816242218,
0.9297781586647034,
0.5186930894851685,
-0.1825845092535019,
0.8328888416290283,
-0.26135367155075073,
0.2988002300262451,
1.2436487674713135,
0.011749586090445518,
0.5903887152671814,
0.07397419959306717,
-0.37432989478111267,
0.5156267881393433,
0.5198184251785278,
-0.17651960253715515,
0.4566095173358917,
0.4345987141132355,
-0.24980303645133972,
-0.2203202098608017,
0.26004254817962646,
-0.5282557010650635,
0.30835291743278503,
0.5776802897453308,
-0.2277970165014267,
-0.5754187703132629,
-0.212162047624588,
-0.11109057813882828,
-0.01436039712280035,
-0.3999688923358917,
0.6153258085250854,
0.1644531786441803,
-0.5336695313453674,
0.6325507760047913,
-0.14181897044181824,
0.27956071496009827,
-0.8724446296691895,
-0.327440470457077,
-0.3247631788253784,
0.2559707462787628,
-0.1687750518321991,
-0.6843065619468689,
0.11241041868925095,
0.03815435618162155,
-0.14845474064350128,
-0.04075697064399719,
0.39722660183906555,
-0.6266952753067017,
-0.5802517533302307,
-0.15922246873378754,
0.411573201417923,
0.2001936435699463,
-0.019128164276480675,
-0.5215128064155579,
0.09641022980213165,
-0.07948841154575348,
-0.15687088668346405,
0.5449904799461365,
0.5120503902435303,
0.005664092022925615,
0.518323540687561,
0.8947260975837708,
0.16124527156352997,
0.2507200539112091,
0.10405967384576797,
1.1019996404647827,
-0.4893743395805359,
-0.38886550068855286,
-0.7896974086761475,
0.4067273437976837,
0.09340865164995193,
-0.6728384494781494,
0.8064163327217102,
0.7934621572494507,
1.049661636352539,
-0.1486920416355133,
0.7093327641487122,
0.3330720067024231,
0.5107235908508301,
-0.7249148488044739,
0.5360996723175049,
-0.3415229916572571,
0.2632294297218323,
0.07052898406982422,
-1.1099720001220703,
0.011981897987425327,
0.6520483493804932,
-0.19356603920459747,
0.09328603744506836,
0.7178918719291687,
0.9398638606071472,
-0.43973803520202637,
0.20355956256389618,
0.36706194281578064,
0.04047830402851105,
0.17249871790409088,
0.6996239423751831,
0.6480385065078735,
-0.29739028215408325,
0.5048589706420898,
-0.03998430073261261,
-0.4273408055305481,
-0.08868467807769775,
-0.5902808308601379,
-1.1869183778762817,
-0.2823966443538666,
-0.10699530690908432,
-0.3117893636226654,
-0.11299914121627808,
0.9941746592521667,
0.5439623594284058,
-0.7074325084686279,
-0.316188782453537,
-0.48895588517189026,
0.09819306433200836,
0.11429332941770554,
-0.23196519911289215,
0.1737457513809204,
-0.5604081153869629,
-0.6252633929252625,
0.5235744714736938,
0.25303328037261963,
0.054016079753637314,
-0.6095051169395447,
-0.29926201701164246,
0.16919605433940887,
0.17511829733848572,
0.47766637802124023,
0.11069723218679428,
-0.550430953502655,
0.13243308663368225,
0.2128271907567978,
-0.1458822786808014,
0.27779048681259155,
1.0423128604888916,
-0.5053336024284363,
0.4334205389022827,
0.2159315049648285,
0.6778591275215149,
0.34868043661117554,
-0.05583598464727402,
0.5392404794692993,
-0.614300012588501,
0.16797178983688354,
0.18411773443222046,
0.10413117706775665,
0.07071606814861298,
-0.0799054354429245,
0.8226495385169983,
0.14447157084941864,
-0.6626163721084595,
-0.79161137342453,
0.23349857330322266,
-0.49441275000572205,
-0.13236074149608612,
0.9808486700057983,
-0.1995260864496231,
-0.22300724685192108,
0.18276621401309967,
-0.0721016675233841,
-0.050565630197525024,
-0.3107771873474121,
0.5825070738792419,
0.7627296447753906,
0.25383713841438293,
-0.03841320425271988,
-0.7494767904281616,
0.4456944763660431,
0.3856217861175537,
-1.0161443948745728,
0.18346253037452698,
0.5973341464996338,
0.308932363986969,
-0.1539963036775589,
0.32508906722068787,
-0.46660131216049194,
0.4469830095767975,
0.23265422880649567,
-0.1721036732196808,
-0.698890745639801,
-0.4548906981945038,
-0.455856591463089,
0.08184772729873657,
-0.014872937463223934,
-0.16913513839244843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10175v2 | Unlocking Structure Measuring: Introducing PDD, an Automatic Metric for Positional Discourse Coherence | 2024-02-15T18:23:39 | 2024-04-02T21:51:36 | Yinhong Liu, Yixuan Su, Ehsan Shareghi, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in
aligning generated text with user intentions across various tasks. When it
comes to long-form text generation, there has been a growing interest in
generation from a discourse coherence perspective. However, existing lexical or
semantic metrics such as BLEU, ROUGE, BertScore cannot effectively capture the
discourse coherence. The development of discourse-specific automatic evaluation
methods for assessing the output of LLMs warrants greater focus and
exploration. In this paper, we present a novel automatic metric designed to
quantify the discourse divergence between two long-form articles. Extensive
experiments on three datasets from representative domains demonstrate that our
metric aligns more closely with human preferences and GPT-4 coherence
evaluation, outperforming existing evaluation methods. | [
-0.32961127161979675,
-0.7414366602897644,
0.709830105304718,
0.33083197474479675,
-0.37698209285736084,
0.3822042942047119,
0.02589033544063568,
-0.2573660910129547,
0.20556864142417908,
0.058884914964437485,
-0.2822253406047821,
-0.7454416155815125,
-0.4560239315032959,
0.14810307323932648,
-0.3270929157733917,
1.017055630683899,
-0.2877013087272644,
-0.20731061697006226,
-0.49422338604927063,
-0.06761592626571655,
-0.1943780779838562,
-0.33736878633499146,
-0.5947747826576233,
-0.30124080181121826,
0.5944351553916931,
-0.06951300799846649,
0.7040167450904846,
0.4937385320663452,
0.6261561512947083,
0.3060220181941986,
-0.11678362637758255,
0.23358924686908722,
-0.37505972385406494,
0.08727244287729263,
-0.3160933256149292,
-0.2722024619579315,
-0.7171144485473633,
0.059085406363010406,
0.9541997909545898,
0.9859002828598022,
-0.0628252625465393,
-0.062345340847969055,
0.47712090611457825,
0.6746488213539124,
-0.5209711790084839,
0.06110910326242447,
-0.4128035306930542,
0.18488796055316925,
-0.41900497674942017,
-0.1449616402387619,
-0.3121771812438965,
-0.5793368816375732,
0.4331720769405365,
-0.2605355381965637,
0.14497920870780945,
-0.0624900721013546,
1.0926092863082886,
0.17753641307353973,
-0.5766364336013794,
-0.48489323258399963,
-0.37086260318756104,
0.8252043128013611,
-0.6064258217811584,
0.5306126475334167,
0.10142093896865845,
0.17979025840759277,
-0.2225581854581833,
-0.4121049642562866,
-0.4617810845375061,
-0.02385619655251503,
-0.0002041002589976415,
0.28883668780326843,
-0.15646147727966309,
0.16048240661621094,
-0.16124992072582245,
0.521109938621521,
-0.6611743569374084,
0.22055265307426453,
-0.19505202770233154,
-0.21217890083789825,
0.7949626445770264,
0.1979036182165146,
0.4275719225406647,
-0.38656896352767944,
-0.48146381974220276,
-0.009727432392537594,
-0.7871057391166687,
0.06969758868217468,
0.6759997010231018,
-0.0562230609357357,
-0.46451902389526367,
0.6701233983039856,
0.2677531838417053,
0.3789044916629791,
0.3388207256793976,
-0.23810730874538422,
0.11229509860277176,
-0.48542001843452454,
-0.3125787377357483,
0.030701467767357826,
1.0140682458877563,
0.2809492349624634,
-0.23607760667800903,
-0.03621678799390793,
0.012238061055541039,
-0.013352243229746819,
0.07482630014419556,
-0.8035830855369568,
-0.3647387623786926,
0.03811914846301079,
-0.3538670539855957,
-0.2352185994386673,
0.058569785207509995,
-0.5109356045722961,
-0.25459685921669006,
-0.11608564108610153,
-0.04928668960928917,
-0.4038683772087097,
-0.30542489886283875,
-0.028866570442914963,
-0.21559932827949524,
0.5843440294265747,
0.27393263578414917,
-0.8473243117332458,
0.36760589480400085,
1.0195610523223877,
1.152101755142212,
-1.1569979190826416,
-0.14141720533370972,
-0.15093165636062622,
0.22809739410877228,
-0.6937220096588135,
0.8673292398452759,
-0.3112678527832031,
-0.36320802569389343,
-0.16262444853782654,
-0.01772097870707512,
0.02545095793902874,
-0.5142073631286621,
0.8310975432395935,
-0.4564571678638458,
0.41464391350746155,
-0.12877163290977478,
-0.7222718000411987,
-0.05958723649382591,
0.3815646767616272,
-0.5016136765480042,
0.9430528879165649,
0.3287450969219208,
-0.8423293232917786,
0.8244050145149231,
-0.4123610258102417,
-0.30090874433517456,
0.19154760241508484,
-0.43735483288764954,
-0.9562590718269348,
0.20886114239692688,
0.09967838227748871,
0.3451245427131653,
-0.3357742428779602,
0.5711842179298401,
-0.5112901329994202,
-0.030981317162513733,
0.19064100086688995,
-0.6246374249458313,
0.8974822759628296,
-0.14550088346004486,
-0.13435187935829163,
0.21643640100955963,
-0.6196420192718506,
0.011434214189648628,
-0.2578379511833191,
-0.46624115109443665,
-0.5525391697883606,
0.06240028142929077,
-0.4989601671695709,
-0.12368647754192352,
0.2751353979110718,
-0.47878435254096985,
-0.15673579275608063,
-0.9854211807250977,
0.2953092157840729,
0.7384917140007019,
0.19898705184459686,
0.6122649312019348,
-0.2186686396598816,
0.5060164928436279,
0.22897998988628387,
-0.41631296277046204,
-0.05579095706343651,
-0.2999979853630066,
-0.5618525743484497,
-0.5670846104621887,
0.2992532551288605,
0.10907299071550369,
-0.2712077796459198,
1.066850185394287,
-0.4933273494243622,
-0.40522316098213196,
-0.4088170528411865,
0.0006033458048477769,
0.4060881733894348,
0.35539528727531433,
0.059161849319934845,
-0.7964265942573547,
-0.29548120498657227,
-0.9713749885559082,
-0.24644044041633606,
-0.18377479910850525,
-0.20972076058387756,
0.3707509934902191,
0.4657723903656006,
0.04733520373702049,
1.0247019529342651,
-0.5242862105369568,
0.08976411819458008,
-0.025056298822164536,
0.29689937829971313,
0.07738161832094193,
0.3411988615989685,
0.5591210126876831,
-0.3260310888290405,
-0.6743848919868469,
0.04226066544651985,
-0.8762565851211548,
-0.13970127701759338,
-0.10752953588962555,
-0.3990866541862488,
0.42837974429130554,
0.18706518411636353,
-0.6918536424636841,
0.28105124831199646,
0.5980709195137024,
-0.31514209508895874,
0.676688551902771,
-0.14347366988658905,
-0.01779431663453579,
-1.1518223285675049,
0.0007310807704925537,
-0.15215232968330383,
-0.21956978738307953,
-0.17707812786102295,
0.00020120244880672544,
0.08177351951599121,
-0.08214161545038223,
-0.2701164484024048,
0.4569478929042816,
-0.9078406691551208,
-0.5396384000778198,
0.0911412462592125,
0.4774182438850403,
0.41851872205734253,
0.24895057082176208,
-0.04185238853096962,
0.7170178890228271,
0.32887184619903564,
-0.41876116394996643,
0.17988957464694977,
0.1635298728942871,
-0.5557066202163696,
0.8446677327156067,
-0.669151246547699,
0.2395620495080948,
0.0972028523683548,
0.48291611671447754,
-1.1399494409561157,
-0.3598497807979584,
0.06662169098854065,
-0.1382342129945755,
0.10392281413078308,
-0.05811058729887009,
-0.18088828027248383,
-0.4800342321395874,
-0.584784209728241,
0.5817186236381531,
0.20402707159519196,
-0.44563472270965576,
0.019615061581134796,
0.5010491013526917,
-0.547950804233551,
-0.3200635015964508,
-0.5212441086769104,
0.2619139850139618,
-0.3286730647087097,
-0.9126856923103333,
0.43401849269866943,
-0.2019914835691452,
-0.2431774139404297,
-0.323391318321228,
-0.13032202422618866,
-0.18513604998588562,
0.04785238951444626,
0.2255769520998001,
0.15862978994846344,
-0.3252156376838684,
0.06697042286396027,
0.9951790571212769,
0.22014035284519196,
0.43883439898490906,
-0.3322201371192932,
0.5740523934364319,
0.05583656206727028,
-0.5979782938957214,
-0.6847327947616577,
0.2760211229324341,
0.4099496603012085,
-0.20004624128341675,
0.5141557455062866,
0.18063466250896454,
-0.112540103495121,
-0.3496206998825073,
-0.16331323981285095,
0.1787284016609192,
-0.45802339911460876,
0.32325980067253113,
-0.4397716820240021,
-0.6655107736587524,
0.3756093382835388,
-0.07806726545095444,
-0.05703263729810715,
0.38820716738700867,
0.7735142707824707,
0.01644204743206501,
1.0010085105895996,
0.6167373657226562,
0.15420229732990265,
0.16350261867046356,
-0.21213391423225403,
0.3965539336204529,
-0.7033252120018005,
-0.14664104580879211,
-0.2610646188259125,
-0.29120174050331116,
-0.42854002118110657,
-0.414725124835968,
0.3639070987701416,
0.24737490713596344,
0.008610025979578495,
0.1429452747106552,
-0.6278488636016846,
0.4952816367149353,
-0.08029582351446152,
-0.2477705329656601,
0.3802809715270996,
0.07906268537044525,
-0.37979060411453247,
-0.3944946527481079,
-0.2593909800052643,
-0.6653754115104675,
0.8719509243965149,
0.4608573615550995,
0.46510830521583557,
0.22158612310886383,
0.9340500235557556,
0.28251802921295166,
0.3518485128879547,
-0.8632924556732178,
0.4762633442878723,
0.04788540303707123,
-0.09657851606607437,
-0.37927189469337463,
-0.3997338116168976,
-1.1065490245819092,
0.2189772129058838,
0.41328078508377075,
-0.3859070837497711,
0.29115355014801025,
-0.03654196858406067,
-0.4137504994869232,
-0.07760578393936157,
-0.4392176568508148,
0.6816442608833313,
-0.2208363562822342,
-0.26361557841300964,
0.04467826336622238,
-0.33330515027046204,
0.3980497419834137,
0.023290200158953667,
-0.22759197652339935,
-0.3408835530281067,
-0.30087900161743164,
0.738419234752655,
-0.27448126673698425,
0.63532555103302,
-0.04071491211652756,
-0.8426944017410278,
0.2543541193008423,
0.2285199910402298,
0.17629975080490112,
0.16589142382144928,
-0.20938125252723694,
0.14570412039756775,
-0.2590762674808502,
-0.1822592318058014,
-0.39940348267555237,
0.871326744556427,
-0.6869845986366272,
-0.4956052303314209,
-0.3645683526992798,
-0.6661293506622314,
0.01261301338672638,
0.2762039303779602,
0.27618810534477234,
0.2116631269454956,
-0.8690925240516663,
0.07389649748802185,
0.5272803902626038,
-0.2200210690498352,
0.47913721203804016,
0.3678189516067505,
-0.071564681828022,
-0.522263765335083,
0.7232232689857483,
0.0782754123210907,
0.23366640508174896,
0.45224276185035706,
0.26456907391548157,
-0.5141578316688538,
-0.5814485549926758,
-0.5654588341712952,
0.19225245714187622,
-0.2635611295700073,
-0.3753940463066101,
-0.6099485754966736,
-0.38786622881889343,
-0.29864782094955444,
-0.43847814202308655,
-0.14870350062847137,
-0.555671751499176,
-0.2940067946910858,
-0.3811885714530945,
-0.19197162985801697,
0.48582887649536133,
0.1720910370349884,
0.10661985725164413,
-0.4498468041419983,
0.04916325956583023,
0.17445071041584015,
0.10362064093351364,
-0.1506834328174591,
-0.32993054389953613,
-0.09428806602954865,
0.1136932447552681,
-0.7658374309539795,
-0.8919956684112549,
0.6569615006446838,
0.32860249280929565,
0.17524465918540955,
0.643242359161377,
-0.007133385166525841,
0.5531427264213562,
-0.4536108076572418,
0.9365141987800598,
0.5025136470794678,
-1.0601379871368408,
0.6350924372673035,
-0.4400656819343567,
0.3603411316871643,
0.18461211025714874,
0.45399171113967896,
-0.14606541395187378,
-0.7336986660957336,
-0.4020983576774597,
-0.6838802695274353,
0.26839902997016907,
0.15327875316143036,
0.015519744716584682,
-0.18533161282539368,
0.30367332696914673,
0.43602654337882996,
0.1778993159532547,
-0.653767466545105,
0.11273712664842606,
0.03262028098106384,
-0.42198437452316284,
0.1872684359550476,
-0.14070259034633636,
-0.4987577795982361,
-0.2058308720588684,
0.11164657026529312,
-0.2196636199951172,
0.13229794800281525,
0.226337730884552,
-0.2329733669757843,
-0.12929381430149078,
0.43684816360473633,
0.5151339769363403,
0.9054020643234253,
0.10869614779949188,
0.40254315733909607,
0.1364428699016571,
-0.39760664105415344,
0.31641149520874023,
0.08369097113609314,
-0.425823450088501,
0.12067441642284393,
0.28175508975982666,
0.6489706039428711,
0.11864425987005234,
-0.32358136773109436,
0.6873956918716431,
0.0904180109500885,
-0.3410443961620331,
-0.27259188890457153,
0.03093082830309868,
0.166885644197464,
0.025407103821635246,
0.08562934398651123,
-0.09503033012151718,
0.16892658174037933,
-0.655220627784729,
0.3518570363521576,
0.5822601914405823,
-0.47316038608551025,
-0.6999233365058899,
0.5209668874740601,
0.42974966764450073,
-0.42229026556015015,
0.30300214886665344,
-0.5751966834068298,
-0.21337391436100006,
0.48197609186172485,
0.6690255403518677,
1.1777186393737793,
-0.21477161347866058,
0.4252692759037018,
0.2236613631248474,
-0.07694488763809204,
0.2227080762386322,
0.16328483819961548,
-0.3016005754470825,
-0.6933783888816833,
-0.43538400530815125,
-0.8976818919181824,
-0.2225264012813568,
-0.10064826905727386,
-0.7321810722351074,
0.12963081896305084,
-0.31525835394859314,
-0.22191546857357025,
0.1338198482990265,
0.32991188764572144,
-0.22453123331069946,
-0.20381230115890503,
-0.20158828794956207,
0.5125665068626404,
-0.6590582132339478,
0.7066717147827148,
0.3537898063659668,
-0.1784530133008957,
-0.3939947187900543,
0.2627943158149719,
-0.04973498731851578,
-0.39324072003364563,
0.5200901627540588,
0.16004733741283417,
-0.35296258330345154,
-0.21186162531375885,
-0.2889149487018585,
-0.6782556176185608,
1.320461392402649,
0.6581329107284546,
-0.6694911122322083,
-0.3326530456542969,
0.3268269896507263,
0.6995527148246765,
-0.519707441329956,
0.02374548278748989,
0.7746159434318542,
0.22780607640743256,
-0.32449081540107727,
-0.8402463793754578,
0.12458204478025436,
0.04485663026571274,
0.08856280148029327,
0.5966058969497681,
-0.6098918914794922,
0.656757652759552,
-0.0642462819814682,
-0.8635023236274719,
0.30714502930641174,
0.8400418758392334,
0.30645060539245605,
0.4549621045589447,
0.43348097801208496,
0.6052287817001343,
0.8909972310066223,
-0.08443204313516617,
0.6961445808410645,
-0.3627682030200958,
0.3599318563938141,
1.187497854232788,
-0.4839605689048767,
0.7742709517478943,
0.25617215037345886,
-0.2627178430557251,
0.796296238899231,
0.5417369604110718,
0.09323226660490036,
0.36338919401168823,
0.41919150948524475,
-0.36094576120376587,
0.09766124933958054,
0.020874056965112686,
-0.281197726726532,
0.3652212619781494,
0.48685821890830994,
-0.5062342882156372,
-0.19568610191345215,
-0.29401683807373047,
0.2587350010871887,
0.2581545114517212,
-0.03174973279237747,
0.9491510391235352,
0.34828463196754456,
-1.0222419500350952,
0.6760494709014893,
0.030792567878961563,
0.3657429814338684,
-0.3154921531677246,
0.12879064679145813,
-0.2255856692790985,
0.2549978494644165,
-0.1752447932958603,
-0.9719504714012146,
0.6340742111206055,
-0.0037857654970139265,
-0.06516440212726593,
-0.2768746316432953,
0.5608225464820862,
-0.7221609950065613,
-0.36853405833244324,
0.43923234939575195,
0.7194421887397766,
0.13628990948200226,
0.33830931782722473,
-0.7323964834213257,
0.102932870388031,
-0.23330479860305786,
-0.03700433298945427,
0.2737151086330414,
0.6594098210334778,
-0.07468575984239578,
0.336212158203125,
0.3990781307220459,
0.04970824345946312,
-0.04178434610366821,
0.10450407862663269,
0.7426546812057495,
-0.4403632879257202,
-0.6165311932563782,
-0.951964259147644,
0.08425745368003845,
-0.4418926239013672,
-0.5707986354827881,
0.951117992401123,
0.9554882645606995,
0.5961953997612,
0.3256280720233917,
0.6263216137886047,
0.08321785181760788,
0.42749449610710144,
-0.3028920888900757,
0.9317516684532166,
-0.20349659025669098,
0.23267453908920288,
-0.3308883309364319,
-1.1628721952438354,
-0.13560251891613007,
0.4155797064304352,
-0.42297014594078064,
-0.31308552622795105,
0.7738763689994812,
0.6541673541069031,
-0.22078318893909454,
-0.29179060459136963,
0.2338496744632721,
0.2539598047733307,
0.44234010577201843,
0.2444140911102295,
0.7224673628807068,
-0.21212886273860931,
0.4973263740539551,
0.1255672574043274,
-0.29927268624305725,
0.22019532322883606,
-0.7940323352813721,
-0.8940892219543457,
-0.543870210647583,
-0.34604647755622864,
-0.1632121354341507,
0.22754305601119995,
0.32745879888534546,
0.6302179098129272,
-0.59467613697052,
-0.534024715423584,
-0.4132690727710724,
0.2952643036842346,
-0.13456349074840546,
-0.3360295593738556,
0.7337338924407959,
-0.26886454224586487,
-0.7915483117103577,
0.4721544682979584,
0.7888868451118469,
0.10928691923618317,
-0.7654803395271301,
-0.17173387110233307,
-0.015765247866511345,
0.4551389217376709,
0.7556665539741516,
0.02189195342361927,
-0.6054831743240356,
-0.43141698837280273,
-0.2632761299610138,
-0.2840070426464081,
0.39404141902923584,
0.7503861784934998,
-0.41223955154418945,
0.22680550813674927,
0.7701045870780945,
0.40754902362823486,
0.4250561594963074,
0.19561848044395447,
1.0195554494857788,
-1.078869342803955,
-0.08647048473358154,
0.3882761299610138,
0.153097003698349,
0.4691318869590759,
-0.15589939057826996,
0.26695138216018677,
0.05340196192264557,
-0.6913204789161682,
-1.0667667388916016,
0.4875692129135132,
-0.8832071423530579,
0.06554579734802246,
0.679234504699707,
-0.5005483627319336,
-0.25604936480522156,
-0.23896104097366333,
-0.04710959270596504,
0.1872694343328476,
-0.4774671792984009,
0.8610480427742004,
0.6010168790817261,
-0.1606931835412979,
-0.03446279838681221,
0.10303957760334015,
0.8162805438041687,
0.2823435962200165,
-1.181563377380371,
0.038278646767139435,
0.494947224855423,
0.11040499806404114,
0.2884111702442169,
0.714779794216156,
-0.22299692034721375,
0.08443828672170639,
-0.09923160076141357,
-0.2889072895050049,
0.564390242099762,
-0.33917292952537537,
-0.17723341286182404,
0.36131390929222107,
-0.09563513100147247,
0.10851040482521057
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.