id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11908v1 | Semantic Textual Similarity Assessment in Chest X-ray Reports Using a Domain-Specific Cosine-Based Metric | 2024-02-19T07:48:25 | 2024-02-19T07:48:25 | Sayeh Gholipour Picha, Dawood Al Chanti, Alice Caplier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Medical language processing and deep learning techniques have emerged as
critical tools for improving healthcare, particularly in the analysis of
medical imaging and medical text data. These multimodal data fusion techniques
help to improve the interpretation of medical imaging and lead to increased
diagnostic accuracy, informed clinical decisions, and improved patient
outcomes. The success of these models relies on the ability to extract and
consolidate semantic information from clinical text. This paper addresses the
need for more robust methods to evaluate the semantic content of medical
reports. Conventional natural language processing approaches and metrics are
initially designed for considering the semantic context in the natural language
domain and machine translation, often failing to capture the complex semantic
meanings inherent in medical content. In this study, we introduce a novel
approach designed specifically for assessing the semantic similarity between
generated medical reports and the ground truth. Our approach is validated,
demonstrating its efficiency in assessing domain-specific semantic similarity
within medical contexts. By applying our metric to state-of-the-art Chest X-ray
report generation models, we obtain results that not only align with
conventional metrics but also provide more contextually meaningful scores in
the considered medical domain. | [
-0.33013492822647095,
-0.6804946064949036,
0.6585525870323181,
-0.2747359871864319,
-0.5396084189414978,
-0.10895925015211105,
-0.07088235765695572,
-0.6368619203567505,
0.1380740851163864,
0.6697043180465698,
-0.6639596223831177,
-0.9858036041259766,
-0.6861725449562073,
0.05993783473968506,
-0.368384450674057,
0.8668569922447205,
-0.15152591466903687,
-0.02574789524078369,
-0.5930647850036621,
-0.3115167021751404,
-0.75299471616745,
-0.37244585156440735,
-0.2623239755630493,
-0.17027798295021057,
0.17342083156108856,
-0.02713680826127529,
0.905874490737915,
0.6319221258163452,
0.9973125457763672,
0.2916981279850006,
0.41070616245269775,
0.29608675837516785,
-0.22161544859409332,
0.10554105788469315,
-0.22990761697292328,
-0.12927691638469696,
-0.473611980676651,
0.019821492955088615,
0.5023238062858582,
0.7092857956886292,
0.23014932870864868,
0.1631329208612442,
-0.15155605971813202,
0.710418164730072,
-0.4598633944988251,
0.17815837264060974,
-0.5492432713508606,
0.3062576353549957,
-0.033807169646024704,
-0.7433284521102905,
-0.29882702231407166,
-0.3291110396385193,
0.6263343691825867,
-0.640609622001648,
0.33749476075172424,
-0.007246507331728935,
1.1064693927764893,
0.24839597940444946,
-0.4129330813884735,
-0.6495059132575989,
-0.32699084281921387,
0.9145144820213318,
-0.7538716793060303,
0.5823259949684143,
0.3070186972618103,
0.5223641395568848,
0.12576690316200256,
-1.0220191478729248,
-0.3920290470123291,
-0.3329766094684601,
-0.3532477617263794,
0.25852447748184204,
-0.30459582805633545,
-0.18847911059856415,
-0.17976157367229462,
0.4811464846134186,
-1.05951988697052,
0.05098198726773262,
-0.15338006615638733,
-0.26668477058410645,
0.6301038861274719,
0.3997972905635834,
0.5426689982414246,
-0.45938292145729065,
-0.79547518491745,
-0.3593968451023102,
-0.5327897667884827,
-0.40388429164886475,
-0.39127153158187866,
0.20915716886520386,
-0.1003153920173645,
0.4110989272594452,
-0.41944023966789246,
0.8041464686393738,
-0.2041100561618805,
-0.4560021162033081,
0.6760268807411194,
-0.6297869682312012,
-0.5697339177131653,
0.3949221670627594,
0.6796801090240479,
0.7499642968177795,
-0.2256714105606079,
-0.20272541046142578,
0.1348302662372589,
0.5521863102912903,
0.4082617163658142,
-0.5927430987358093,
0.09075913578271866,
0.17822043597698212,
-0.7257207632064819,
-0.48662295937538147,
0.0565144382417202,
-0.5217254161834717,
-0.2989276349544525,
-0.4159698486328125,
0.4602469801902771,
-0.4841671884059906,
-0.058920968323946,
0.36409130692481995,
-0.1562601923942566,
0.32465165853500366,
0.09892380982637405,
-0.2910699248313904,
0.4475521147251129,
0.8450670838356018,
0.6658524870872498,
-0.281781405210495,
-0.0030187310185283422,
-0.6176909804344177,
0.08438081294298172,
-0.3439967632293701,
0.8980885148048401,
-0.4184901714324951,
-0.3088243305683136,
-0.07179351150989532,
-0.17780651152133942,
-0.05148479714989662,
-0.7989452481269836,
0.8321690559387207,
-0.4961457848548889,
0.2658429741859436,
0.12747514247894287,
-0.7820069193840027,
-0.34346306324005127,
0.6786866188049316,
-0.5773462057113647,
0.8631041049957275,
0.2902888357639313,
-0.642255961894989,
0.6612690091133118,
-0.21337909996509552,
-0.400716632604599,
0.24768111109733582,
-0.5686379671096802,
-0.7347255945205688,
0.10594569891691208,
0.16984239220619202,
0.742792010307312,
-0.6576648354530334,
0.40609338879585266,
-0.07022209465503693,
0.10860250145196915,
0.48732566833496094,
-0.3513474762439728,
0.39709165692329407,
0.02169204130768776,
-0.45259296894073486,
0.03950274735689163,
-0.958576500415802,
0.4854980409145355,
0.03569832071661949,
0.2236059606075287,
-0.705945611000061,
-0.14434055984020233,
-0.08854757994413376,
0.2977650463581085,
-0.058515701442956924,
-0.6848651170730591,
-0.27852514386177063,
-0.38590070605278015,
-0.2023521214723587,
0.0997774600982666,
0.22286809980869293,
0.16092006862163544,
-0.7482740879058838,
0.1717757135629654,
-0.054256994277238846,
0.08950312435626984,
-0.14936921000480652,
-0.46638303995132446,
-0.20133821666240692,
-0.6486295461654663,
0.08648622781038284,
0.40853753685951233,
-0.4867554306983948,
0.7510539889335632,
-0.7163706421852112,
-0.8413746356964111,
-0.6501947641372681,
-0.13611307740211487,
0.4975879490375519,
1.0483752489089966,
0.48143479228019714,
-0.7761637568473816,
-0.5532948970794678,
-0.8616188764572144,
-0.2810935378074646,
0.11389586329460144,
-0.08571882545948029,
0.47779759764671326,
0.18660981953144073,
-0.3421517312526703,
0.800719678401947,
-0.8798750638961792,
-0.8224722146987915,
-0.019795743748545647,
0.21580277383327484,
0.09397098422050476,
0.2983549237251282,
0.5395292639732361,
-0.9678789973258972,
-0.5914199948310852,
0.31775060296058655,
-1.2211796045303345,
-0.0327761173248291,
-0.24158059060573578,
-0.13930639624595642,
0.2009568214416504,
0.46123653650283813,
-0.3594883680343628,
0.6971431970596313,
0.5240416526794434,
-0.4756337106227875,
0.3732404410839081,
-0.1666545271873474,
0.5587495565414429,
-0.8627701997756958,
0.05055093392729759,
-0.10417065024375916,
-0.3672994375228882,
-0.6042672991752625,
0.2742776572704315,
-0.06202694773674011,
-0.11411946266889572,
-0.5191658735275269,
0.5664947628974915,
-0.3582516312599182,
0.06546912342309952,
-0.19918633997440338,
0.4524837136268616,
0.41937488317489624,
0.1290351301431656,
0.3426136076450348,
0.005658202804625034,
0.5832743048667908,
-0.536555826663971,
0.4375743567943573,
0.4469890296459198,
-0.5856426954269409,
0.990152895450592,
-0.5244650840759277,
0.07273205369710922,
0.07869445532560349,
0.21022242307662964,
-0.8052839040756226,
0.02626977115869522,
-0.04238063842058182,
-0.612251877784729,
0.21983198821544647,
0.306009441614151,
-0.39321404695510864,
-0.11408732086420059,
-0.45298680663108826,
0.4237760603427887,
0.4714587330818176,
-0.3204692602157593,
0.47321435809135437,
0.3159627616405487,
-0.27524104714393616,
-0.17809432744979858,
-0.7871708869934082,
0.12910625338554382,
-0.01587551459670067,
-0.8962039947509766,
0.6742390394210815,
0.02600681409239769,
-0.2385355830192566,
0.4088870584964752,
-0.16191904246807098,
-0.3778933882713318,
-0.01031425315886736,
0.20409323275089264,
0.4375697672367096,
-0.5645247101783752,
0.01002217922359705,
0.18390636146068573,
-0.3594842255115509,
0.011646355502307415,
-0.39058488607406616,
0.333953857421875,
-0.13874371349811554,
-0.4562724232673645,
-0.579889714717865,
0.4936217665672302,
0.43477949500083923,
-0.17839759588241577,
0.5309140086174011,
0.6109603047370911,
-0.5292242765426636,
0.2017754465341568,
-0.4991331398487091,
0.09135015308856964,
-0.3335840702056885,
0.5150113105773926,
-0.24990805983543396,
-0.6985881328582764,
0.18284809589385986,
0.04977843537926674,
-0.1807442158460617,
0.6422027349472046,
0.8180339932441711,
0.08484458178281784,
0.7378471493721008,
0.4146938920021057,
0.3361290693283081,
-0.28397178649902344,
-0.19903825223445892,
0.2149025946855545,
-0.6537917256355286,
-0.4407448470592499,
-0.5789654850959778,
0.00889747403562069,
-0.455826073884964,
-0.4339335858821869,
0.5102920532226562,
-0.6628270745277405,
0.1587279736995697,
0.1475864052772522,
-0.5538317561149597,
0.23769386112689972,
0.08585531264543533,
0.1772606074810028,
0.5983274579048157,
0.1630955934524536,
0.09532785415649414,
-0.33521100878715515,
-0.5139419436454773,
-0.4626888632774353,
0.8907970190048218,
0.1345597356557846,
0.42325013875961304,
0.017618753015995026,
0.7326047420501709,
0.4070717990398407,
0.18722036480903625,
-0.734501302242279,
0.3269866704940796,
-0.5284226536750793,
-0.3148500323295593,
-0.1668204814195633,
-0.37224605679512024,
-1.039476990699768,
0.2649199664592743,
-0.391597181558609,
-0.2842346131801605,
-0.11325819790363312,
-0.4757551848888397,
-0.3759290277957916,
0.02444748394191265,
-0.4023177921772003,
0.8409170508384705,
-0.17782345414161682,
-0.0032481153029948473,
-0.3680185377597809,
-0.6509829163551331,
0.038679566234350204,
-0.339523047208786,
0.2528854012489319,
-0.27740126848220825,
-0.2908134460449219,
0.6973254680633545,
-0.49026280641555786,
0.8489477634429932,
0.04368114471435547,
-0.13977128267288208,
0.3414086401462555,
0.17192356288433075,
-0.09791097044944763,
0.09151435643434525,
-0.0592852383852005,
0.46747684478759766,
0.2864645719528198,
-0.35512682795524597,
-0.7446595430374146,
0.8143130540847778,
-0.6556010246276855,
-0.24279527366161346,
-0.44728851318359375,
-0.6160883903503418,
-0.16528187692165375,
0.4259239137172699,
0.3679228723049164,
0.9574061632156372,
-0.43165716528892517,
0.08791612088680267,
0.42199817299842834,
-0.36823657155036926,
-0.09796292334794998,
0.5975263118743896,
0.051390547305345535,
-0.3783731758594513,
0.916043221950531,
0.12821470201015472,
0.20473356544971466,
0.7487633228302002,
0.3372786343097687,
-0.36788660287857056,
-0.544792652130127,
-0.36316943168640137,
0.20658975839614868,
-0.7841141223907471,
-0.46280762553215027,
-0.5330935716629028,
-0.25757235288619995,
-0.29331693053245544,
-0.5485249757766724,
-0.20648729801177979,
-0.1902327984571457,
0.1005401462316513,
0.08521625399589539,
0.16677555441856384,
0.42995068430900574,
0.35477834939956665,
-0.11473921686410904,
-1.3695265054702759,
0.24238421022891998,
-0.028103172779083252,
0.3013807535171509,
-0.17277131974697113,
-0.3474743962287903,
-0.13535425066947937,
-0.2740330994129181,
-0.14044661819934845,
-0.534141480922699,
0.5115503072738647,
0.25818318128585815,
0.6017279624938965,
-0.08610375970602036,
0.3574320077896118,
0.5468227863311768,
-0.4428446292877197,
0.8533199429512024,
0.3686017394065857,
-0.8406311273574829,
0.5794252157211304,
-0.01477112341672182,
0.307822585105896,
0.6427129507064819,
0.42016491293907166,
-0.4546593725681305,
-0.4979110360145569,
-0.84264075756073,
-0.7473485469818115,
0.09643833339214325,
0.17334820330142975,
0.07295242697000504,
-0.1316131055355072,
0.1936003565788269,
0.4951789379119873,
-0.03477703034877777,
-0.16982029378414154,
-0.12407931685447693,
0.03968824818730354,
-0.6370287537574768,
0.043196901679039,
0.08068650960922241,
-0.18944019079208374,
0.025380214676260948,
0.5040793418884277,
-0.27354949712753296,
0.2564068138599396,
0.6385097503662109,
-0.4159103333950043,
0.07462146133184433,
0.17486625909805298,
0.4626995027065277,
0.5426726937294006,
-0.1538778394460678,
0.30407920479774475,
0.08127693831920624,
-0.6162554025650024,
0.05570860579609871,
-0.029480023309588432,
0.1292998194694519,
0.30092498660087585,
0.7053259015083313,
0.5667812824249268,
0.39625370502471924,
-0.8494530916213989,
0.8044013381004333,
-0.40909019112586975,
-0.34814563393592834,
-0.156465545296669,
-0.21228672564029694,
-0.2754831314086914,
0.03055339679121971,
0.03628025949001312,
0.34454888105392456,
0.3488049805164337,
-0.43019381165504456,
0.7564929723739624,
0.240374356508255,
-0.8579381704330444,
-0.1458040177822113,
0.06147097796201706,
0.16608470678329468,
0.1895400881767273,
0.6289125680923462,
0.05871012806892395,
-0.12985102832317352,
0.5707850456237793,
0.4662863612174988,
0.906086266040802,
0.26883694529533386,
0.18063372373580933,
0.2924891412258148,
-0.06283506751060486,
0.46122437715530396,
0.012691535986959934,
0.041377950459718704,
-0.543954610824585,
-0.4751630425453186,
-0.33262351155281067,
-0.09062948077917099,
-0.18994766473770142,
-0.9288300275802612,
0.3657597601413727,
-0.32224273681640625,
-0.033080145716667175,
0.14333711564540863,
0.28686872124671936,
-0.6846991181373596,
0.7228783965110779,
0.34994444251060486,
1.0008935928344727,
-0.7733630537986755,
0.6987335681915283,
0.5288980603218079,
-0.2141980677843094,
-0.6338253617286682,
-0.05916755273938179,
0.3250926434993744,
-0.9085927605628967,
0.5838581323623657,
0.30540773272514343,
-0.08188021928071976,
-0.40303418040275574,
0.1894940435886383,
-0.5922616124153137,
1.2364332675933838,
0.0752149447798729,
-0.2797795236110687,
0.31084251403808594,
0.318790465593338,
0.7642006278038025,
-0.610078752040863,
0.10228723287582397,
0.6052075624465942,
0.14550556242465973,
0.06967683136463165,
-1.0161304473876953,
0.5270605683326721,
-0.1896151304244995,
-0.13202179968357086,
0.23609459400177002,
-0.20098386704921722,
0.3209878206253052,
-0.060907620936632156,
-0.3033541440963745,
0.2827044427394867,
0.64899742603302,
0.09965471178293228,
0.7203355431556702,
0.3951471447944641,
0.6784393191337585,
0.9852655529975891,
0.10899461060762405,
1.3372867107391357,
-0.06766889244318008,
0.47792333364486694,
0.9311240315437317,
-0.5001735687255859,
0.8317974209785461,
0.1266394406557083,
0.18047381937503815,
0.7068984508514404,
0.26207447052001953,
-0.10368731617927551,
0.6784636378288269,
-0.022006884217262268,
-0.24877631664276123,
-0.011413631960749626,
-0.4244921803474426,
-0.4786691963672638,
0.4699552059173584,
0.28809744119644165,
-0.3781644105911255,
-0.4357418119907379,
0.08382994681596756,
0.03758189082145691,
0.3172524869441986,
-0.28996601700782776,
1.0127122402191162,
0.14387992024421692,
-0.5554468631744385,
0.8670962452888489,
-0.2324324995279312,
0.35742422938346863,
-0.6927129626274109,
0.007460450287908316,
0.24383392930030823,
0.3353806436061859,
-0.45349615812301636,
-0.9214909076690674,
0.9637876152992249,
0.054340604692697525,
-0.26389604806900024,
0.12901361286640167,
0.8396543860435486,
-0.24059922993183136,
-0.3799905776977539,
0.3291955888271332,
0.4728514552116394,
-0.028407033532857895,
0.05193793401122093,
-0.7470880150794983,
0.21496590971946716,
-0.1387183964252472,
0.20853064954280853,
0.5031840801239014,
0.3441854417324066,
-0.12342143803834915,
0.39509087800979614,
0.5020549297332764,
-0.018525611609220505,
-0.13728447258472443,
0.0738448053598404,
0.687776505947113,
-0.5503242015838623,
-0.5643290281295776,
-0.7373836040496826,
0.3420531749725342,
-0.12312682718038559,
-0.32643765211105347,
0.5832394361495972,
0.589136004447937,
0.9057576656341553,
-0.10980965197086334,
0.8680267333984375,
-0.023173462599515915,
0.5437176823616028,
-0.7172313928604126,
0.6392897367477417,
-0.6047341823577881,
0.014548980630934238,
-0.36100491881370544,
-0.48062440752983093,
-0.833529531955719,
0.36385536193847656,
-0.24610690772533417,
-0.3772118091583252,
1.0929032564163208,
0.7663345336914062,
-0.10254605114459991,
0.14698107540607452,
0.5294671058654785,
0.18175692856311798,
0.26366856694221497,
0.5566349625587463,
0.5241991281509399,
-0.660402774810791,
0.4688783884048462,
-0.193691223859787,
-0.4478372037410736,
-0.08981337398290634,
-0.8464610576629639,
-0.5526801347732544,
-0.6498551964759827,
-0.7122147679328918,
-0.41233646869659424,
-0.11486311256885529,
0.8192742466926575,
0.7365477681159973,
-0.5442102551460266,
0.07994575053453445,
0.28318196535110474,
-0.17551709711551666,
-0.4610413610935211,
-0.20990991592407227,
0.850296139717102,
-0.36659836769104004,
-0.3269113004207611,
0.15690384805202484,
0.6859885454177856,
-0.2669459283351898,
0.011768343858420849,
-0.1546214371919632,
0.11361861974000931,
0.11928126215934753,
0.8090305924415588,
-0.06643925607204437,
-0.5613088011741638,
-0.29978665709495544,
0.18659783899784088,
-0.39605945348739624,
0.2286568135023117,
0.8220562934875488,
-1.0853664875030518,
0.6162158846855164,
0.5236140489578247,
0.9481638073921204,
0.2527748644351959,
-0.44088563323020935,
0.37220901250839233,
-0.6965254545211792,
-0.0434059277176857,
0.265510618686676,
0.12574249505996704,
0.5130501389503479,
-0.38792884349823,
0.39686790108680725,
0.3596805930137634,
-0.2641763687133789,
-0.7076767086982727,
0.18416805565357208,
-1.369278907775879,
-0.2681277096271515,
0.7494593858718872,
-0.34312567114830017,
-0.3992134928703308,
-0.16875721514225006,
-0.2477094829082489,
0.20824410021305084,
0.1519910991191864,
0.5732548236846924,
0.11877499520778656,
-0.26275327801704407,
0.2618860900402069,
-0.26477348804473877,
0.18637517094612122,
0.35201728343963623,
-0.9325928688049316,
-0.34460803866386414,
0.20620563626289368,
0.37203916907310486,
0.3817596733570099,
0.6019337177276611,
-0.6720614433288574,
0.6381927132606506,
-0.06292244791984558,
-0.30447742342948914,
0.11365911364555359,
0.04696596413850784,
-0.16732677817344666,
0.2537335157394409,
-0.2053380310535431,
-0.10046400874853134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11907v1 | Direct Large Language Model Alignment Through Self-Rewarding Contrastive Prompt Distillation | 2024-02-19T07:46:40 | 2024-02-19T07:46:40 | Aiwei Liu, Haoping Bai, Zhiyun Lu, Xiang Kong, Simon Wang, Jiulong Shan, Meng Cao, Lijie Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human expectations without
human-annotated preference data is an important problem. In this paper, we
propose a method to evaluate the response preference by using the output
probabilities of response pairs under contrastive prompt pairs, which could
achieve better performance on LLaMA2-7B and LLaMA2-13B compared to RLAIF. Based
on this, we propose an automatic alignment method, Direct Large Model Alignment
(DLMA). First, we use contrastive prompt pairs to automatically generate
preference data. Then, we continue to evaluate the generated preference data
using contrastive prompt pairs and calculate a self-rewarding score. Finally,
we use the DPO algorithm to effectively align LLMs by combining this
self-rewarding score. In the experimental stage, our DLMA method could surpass
the \texttt{RLHF} method without relying on human-annotated preference data. | [
-0.3455156981945038,
-0.49736958742141724,
0.6556092500686646,
0.29852235317230225,
-0.5278950929641724,
0.08053906261920929,
-0.2827329933643341,
-0.20076991617679596,
0.3402586877346039,
0.5021706223487854,
-0.6522055864334106,
-0.379993736743927,
-0.6424176096916199,
0.33477336168289185,
-0.052662234753370285,
0.7456836104393005,
-0.15020863711833954,
0.014609559439122677,
-0.2735143303871155,
-0.028712725266814232,
-0.7465198636054993,
-0.3563803434371948,
-0.47937560081481934,
-0.4642122685909271,
0.6777998208999634,
0.49933362007141113,
0.46766921877861023,
0.9130019545555115,
0.6594759225845337,
0.3880981504917145,
0.01569828763604164,
0.3085687458515167,
-0.47741398215293884,
0.3123115003108978,
-0.15523986518383026,
-0.0989532396197319,
-0.59847491979599,
0.06891652196645737,
0.49178066849708557,
0.41968104243278503,
-0.0668056383728981,
0.20343561470508575,
0.3588288128376007,
0.8724331259727478,
-0.3469998836517334,
0.11212167888879776,
-0.47276797890663147,
-0.02806873805820942,
0.018132109194993973,
-0.33375051617622375,
-0.47051382064819336,
-0.4974878430366516,
0.15526607632637024,
-0.35006245970726013,
-0.24013042449951172,
0.15739569067955017,
0.6288858652114868,
0.5344427227973938,
-0.5000469088554382,
-0.412868469953537,
-0.4863409996032715,
0.880230188369751,
-0.8318953514099121,
-0.13286219537258148,
0.07833512127399445,
0.3433077037334442,
-0.4033777117729187,
-0.2661755681037903,
-0.7018548250198364,
-0.38333916664123535,
-0.21698498725891113,
0.06737513840198517,
-0.045500610023736954,
-0.025568662211298943,
0.026506781578063965,
0.4738316535949707,
-0.6844749450683594,
0.5364057421684265,
-0.119744673371315,
0.0374530665576458,
0.8298538327217102,
0.4609341621398926,
0.1318926215171814,
-0.0937308520078659,
-0.603568971157074,
-0.262581467628479,
-0.5738660097122192,
-0.07053299993276596,
0.458832710981369,
0.6038895845413208,
-0.1586228609085083,
0.6691954135894775,
-0.24184539914131165,
0.7588664889335632,
0.6316885352134705,
-0.2936461865901947,
0.5122714638710022,
-0.3297154903411865,
-0.26573097705841064,
0.3274427354335785,
1.1188218593597412,
0.49548107385635376,
0.24296197295188904,
0.1351567506790161,
-0.2846965491771698,
-0.03779933229088783,
-0.10940089076757431,
-0.7626311182975769,
-0.02667962573468685,
0.31488293409347534,
-0.43170177936553955,
-0.43208613991737366,
-0.24913831055164337,
-0.8598933219909668,
-0.6359403133392334,
-0.5996728539466858,
0.4247218370437622,
0.030695103108882904,
-0.31594815850257874,
0.07876626402139664,
0.2134876549243927,
0.19186314940452576,
0.37914368510246277,
-1.1605007648468018,
0.13070806860923767,
0.5904296040534973,
0.6525086164474487,
-0.48285067081451416,
-0.27323073148727417,
-0.6991997361183167,
0.0007144062547013164,
-0.20658208429813385,
0.5927125811576843,
-0.421667218208313,
-0.41498908400535583,
-0.06001702696084976,
-0.13045793771743774,
0.23977594077587128,
-0.6484847664833069,
0.6929346323013306,
-0.3904089629650116,
0.3502121567726135,
-0.41502895951271057,
-0.6513211131095886,
0.041559699922800064,
0.31134653091430664,
-0.6475857496261597,
0.9636267423629761,
-0.18294519186019897,
-0.9489213228225708,
0.05203552916646004,
-0.3460005521774292,
-0.141152024269104,
-0.018964389339089394,
-0.20143836736679077,
-0.224932000041008,
0.04842700436711311,
0.44427719712257385,
0.4534413814544678,
-0.33588916063308716,
0.714126467704773,
-0.4876043200492859,
-0.2895258367061615,
0.3290070593357086,
-0.4683987498283386,
0.7242313027381897,
0.31159675121307373,
-0.542976975440979,
0.2908359169960022,
-0.7340033054351807,
-0.18446868658065796,
0.3271329700946808,
-0.32595163583755493,
-0.33867937326431274,
-0.11926032602787018,
-0.22819222509860992,
0.35282644629478455,
0.7431684732437134,
-0.30527612566947937,
0.5534743666648865,
-0.4134739637374878,
0.030750565230846405,
1.306273102760315,
-0.4165952205657959,
0.4436100721359253,
-0.10587940365076065,
0.44735920429229736,
0.06893903762102127,
0.04960809275507927,
0.038346849381923676,
-0.19546958804130554,
-0.6686370968818665,
-0.5122537612915039,
0.3688308894634247,
0.36799415946006775,
-0.2243872731924057,
0.9609546065330505,
-0.2504120171070099,
-0.42954546213150024,
-0.6890032887458801,
0.28543031215667725,
0.3554699420928955,
1.0077924728393555,
0.37961694598197937,
0.08113421499729156,
-0.6134688258171082,
-1.1664409637451172,
0.30770641565322876,
-0.2008887380361557,
0.04928654432296753,
0.2917759120464325,
0.060354214161634445,
-0.11794782429933548,
0.8420759439468384,
-0.7776724100112915,
-0.2454606145620346,
-0.19879105687141418,
0.07443197816610336,
0.5953699946403503,
0.499934583902359,
0.43731969594955444,
-0.4843434989452362,
-0.6055689454078674,
-0.14751558005809784,
-0.5958332419395447,
-0.5912072658538818,
0.22788049280643463,
-0.19214780628681183,
0.2475341260433197,
0.20803196728229523,
-0.2854945957660675,
-0.10517197847366333,
0.8956468105316162,
-0.2101486474275589,
0.4052726924419403,
-0.23356711864471436,
0.4606875777244568,
-1.269323706626892,
0.19233310222625732,
0.07375171780586243,
-0.21917860209941864,
-0.3863062262535095,
-0.2768896818161011,
0.036590468138456345,
0.21855370700359344,
-0.22235876321792603,
0.9014130234718323,
-0.5748624801635742,
-0.029171273112297058,
-0.6537988781929016,
0.4143010675907135,
0.0913180485367775,
0.3091047704219818,
0.18780632317066193,
0.6439806818962097,
0.420054167509079,
-0.46345254778862,
0.6835722327232361,
0.2588842213153839,
-0.36783260107040405,
0.43930351734161377,
-0.6418572068214417,
0.3353134095668793,
-0.13555951416492462,
0.41239428520202637,
-1.5075417757034302,
0.03165317326784134,
0.4302327036857605,
-0.09593022614717484,
0.2914468050003052,
0.034700699150562286,
-0.24827460944652557,
-0.37527066469192505,
-0.3006534278392792,
0.47573110461235046,
0.5120490193367004,
-0.9122648239135742,
0.3655999004840851,
0.2156924158334732,
-0.45775964856147766,
-0.869695246219635,
-0.5566717982292175,
-0.0433555543422699,
-0.6344922184944153,
-0.43584737181663513,
0.3958602547645569,
-0.3349865972995758,
-0.2735406458377838,
-0.32061848044395447,
-0.0006426709005609155,
0.30472034215927124,
0.09325762838125229,
0.36066436767578125,
0.8259173631668091,
-0.07000122219324112,
-0.01611533761024475,
-0.07009628415107727,
-0.2030104696750641,
-0.08781248331069946,
0.09461040049791336,
0.739723801612854,
0.16549819707870483,
-0.26883357763290405,
-0.5876474380493164,
0.22036346793174744,
0.2784803807735443,
-0.230065256357193,
0.36344820261001587,
0.25683191418647766,
-0.09736447781324387,
0.1036112904548645,
-0.7967330813407898,
-0.13148120045661926,
-0.505639910697937,
0.1125609278678894,
-0.37153151631355286,
-0.7479968070983887,
0.3888768255710602,
0.1063656359910965,
-0.016932332888245583,
0.47087785601615906,
0.8180792331695557,
0.017953485250473022,
1.185681700706482,
0.42219388484954834,
-0.37481895089149475,
0.45573413372039795,
0.32715916633605957,
0.10972275584936142,
-0.6791989207267761,
-0.2133750021457672,
-0.658927321434021,
-0.6520913243293762,
-0.36738383769989014,
-0.09002251923084259,
0.06470455229282379,
-0.027364246547222137,
-0.2781240940093994,
0.28692734241485596,
-0.6365996599197388,
0.33140480518341064,
0.5173126459121704,
-0.013757201842963696,
0.47219815850257874,
-0.05654380843043327,
-0.20977218449115753,
-0.10570622235536575,
-0.2208167016506195,
-0.6366804838180542,
1.0487748384475708,
0.4178406000137329,
1.011440396308899,
0.07703956216573715,
1.0415107011795044,
0.200748011469841,
0.18743665516376495,
-0.7789647579193115,
0.5234439969062805,
-0.09552482515573502,
-0.18298856914043427,
-0.2923194468021393,
-0.44925394654273987,
-0.8159428238868713,
0.06453261524438858,
-0.10983844101428986,
-0.6272347569465637,
0.1230720654129982,
0.25469061732292175,
-0.5163387656211853,
-0.23657304048538208,
-0.6679719090461731,
0.6987590193748474,
-0.5309950709342957,
-0.2754113972187042,
-0.06584086269140244,
-0.6318709254264832,
0.5566392540931702,
-0.060364801436662674,
0.07613948732614517,
-0.3980344235897064,
0.0020861169323325157,
0.6759916543960571,
-0.1589910387992859,
0.7783144116401672,
-0.24667951464653015,
-0.5627399682998657,
-0.028509993106126785,
0.0738890990614891,
0.6377094984054565,
-0.09708375483751297,
-0.24978157877922058,
-0.10945744812488556,
-0.1933213323354721,
-0.13609004020690918,
-0.5966513752937317,
1.1290767192840576,
-0.7049341797828674,
-1.0264387130737305,
-0.5339934825897217,
-0.5470011234283447,
-0.1340043544769287,
0.06583893299102783,
-0.09483154863119125,
0.11798027902841568,
-0.1592164784669876,
-0.32194697856903076,
0.49109750986099243,
-0.13070635497570038,
0.5898377299308777,
0.5512593388557434,
-0.44768857955932617,
-0.5775146484375,
0.5988810658454895,
-0.20208078622817993,
0.27123644948005676,
0.5282837152481079,
0.5632230639457703,
-0.8528308272361755,
-0.44465911388397217,
-0.4837598502635956,
0.2703079283237457,
-0.6155436635017395,
-0.3177185654640198,
-0.4318523406982422,
0.07497936487197876,
-0.5854410529136658,
-0.09270288050174713,
-0.22158648073673248,
-0.19683589041233063,
-0.38449031114578247,
-0.08815371245145798,
0.27118468284606934,
0.6203908920288086,
-0.0961708277463913,
0.08192399144172668,
-0.7607810497283936,
0.266742080450058,
0.4303874671459198,
0.05955616757273674,
-0.0744248479604721,
-0.8776947855949402,
0.1340845823287964,
0.033284593373537064,
-0.111751027405262,
-0.69155353307724,
0.44309690594673157,
-0.19109174609184265,
0.5458045601844788,
0.46709030866622925,
0.2071492224931717,
0.8207803964614868,
-0.501093327999115,
0.5472890734672546,
0.4643626809120178,
-0.9029126167297363,
0.5703285336494446,
-0.11928793787956238,
0.189657524228096,
0.6886218786239624,
0.4489123225212097,
-0.3203090727329254,
0.07704814523458481,
-0.21244506537914276,
-0.6865798830986023,
0.6205350160598755,
-0.24915406107902527,
0.13863664865493774,
-0.07013899087905884,
0.34725114703178406,
0.2837650775909424,
0.004518676083534956,
-0.7486087083816528,
-0.34686988592147827,
0.08433614671230316,
-0.6068097949028015,
-0.3743797242641449,
-0.33370813727378845,
-0.3898468315601349,
-0.020820554345846176,
0.6392644643783569,
-0.2414153814315796,
-0.23631028831005096,
0.08227135986089706,
0.11096181720495224,
-0.11627025157213211,
0.24919292330741882,
0.5871167182922363,
0.5944152474403381,
-0.37696218490600586,
0.250632643699646,
-0.09265957772731781,
-0.020492322742938995,
0.664705753326416,
0.17028261721134186,
0.08372380584478378,
-0.31115126609802246,
0.12931667268276215,
0.6454949975013733,
-0.06452930718660355,
-0.6705923080444336,
0.5648254156112671,
-0.16793565452098846,
0.02675129473209381,
0.013557682745158672,
-0.005130539648234844,
0.3613269329071045,
0.3401488661766052,
0.2910372316837311,
-0.5346011519432068,
0.12574465572834015,
-0.45972076058387756,
-0.10909406840801239,
0.5353278517723083,
-0.07911968976259232,
0.010582159273326397,
0.4276103973388672,
0.3497019112110138,
-0.1280258446931839,
0.5482045412063599,
-0.02081175521016121,
-0.16040167212486267,
0.5329216718673706,
0.7613096237182617,
0.820789098739624,
-0.5368684530258179,
0.09820141643285751,
0.5278688669204712,
-0.12295843660831451,
-0.23271441459655762,
-0.06010499596595764,
0.10404662042856216,
-0.6769732236862183,
-0.585242748260498,
-0.7779369950294495,
-0.28818610310554504,
0.194292351603508,
-0.7031137943267822,
0.5201319456100464,
-0.22929202020168304,
0.009829276241362095,
0.1642567366361618,
0.08295299112796783,
-0.4528217911720276,
0.2913180887699127,
0.2908823490142822,
0.6682573556900024,
-0.9194086194038391,
0.9650380611419678,
0.392651230096817,
-0.3524671196937561,
-0.816376805305481,
-0.07061741501092911,
0.02122826874256134,
-1.0896581411361694,
1.0446293354034424,
0.24387498199939728,
-0.2002096176147461,
-0.05208743363618851,
-0.2673966884613037,
-0.9211779236793518,
1.1341681480407715,
0.6019757390022278,
-1.2248215675354004,
0.0777822881937027,
-0.0314207561314106,
0.3953334391117096,
-0.5848290920257568,
0.3385757505893707,
0.5342318415641785,
0.5271369218826294,
0.37724247574806213,
-0.9195625185966492,
0.3683428466320038,
-0.0970802754163742,
-0.07998809963464737,
0.1573178619146347,
-0.692276656627655,
0.5751660466194153,
-0.21015962958335876,
-0.1596044898033142,
0.09691338241100311,
0.6314600706100464,
0.5087869167327881,
0.021955715492367744,
0.7449623942375183,
0.5790225267410278,
0.66107177734375,
0.053891636431217194,
0.5549912452697754,
-0.15870527923107147,
0.35867956280708313,
1.414291501045227,
-0.7535532116889954,
0.9292064905166626,
0.8705112338066101,
-0.2676176130771637,
0.282419890165329,
0.7806530594825745,
0.04710203781723976,
0.6735175251960754,
0.5131694674491882,
-0.1883457452058792,
-0.28319206833839417,
-0.0262204110622406,
-0.47265109419822693,
0.4823451638221741,
-0.14831991493701935,
-0.4077630341053009,
-0.09533045440912247,
-0.24056272208690643,
-0.006839493755251169,
0.2889045476913452,
-0.20860688388347626,
0.9642003774642944,
-0.0267492663115263,
-1.0753154754638672,
0.7547593712806702,
-0.09497252851724625,
0.8706047534942627,
-0.4614516794681549,
-0.015562072396278381,
-0.4711011052131653,
0.12676721811294556,
-0.21763740479946136,
-0.824470043182373,
0.05211063474416733,
0.12787771224975586,
-0.25378891825675964,
-0.014137054793536663,
0.3641394078731537,
-0.5901291966438293,
-0.3548499047756195,
0.5177168846130371,
0.2374216467142105,
-0.008064628578722477,
0.15972669422626495,
-0.7009720206260681,
0.18495111167430878,
0.1422063112258911,
-0.3131476044654846,
0.582464337348938,
0.14611567556858063,
0.2805689573287964,
0.5047610998153687,
0.4877012073993683,
-0.11048635095357895,
-0.2790718674659729,
0.19856742024421692,
0.9145582914352417,
-0.6395165324211121,
-0.27789488434791565,
-1.360134482383728,
0.45739230513572693,
-0.07041817903518677,
-0.08893302083015442,
0.5746389031410217,
0.5001055598258972,
0.41215774416923523,
-0.01910788007080555,
0.6709391474723816,
0.1336919069290161,
0.5005486011505127,
-0.6128905415534973,
0.28551870584487915,
-0.5141563415527344,
0.31901389360427856,
-0.31690946221351624,
-1.1417838335037231,
-0.08249638974666595,
0.46110010147094727,
-0.30046799778938293,
-0.17241373658180237,
0.5025050044059753,
0.8190973997116089,
0.021282576024532318,
-0.4228980243206024,
0.22656308114528656,
0.10805390030145645,
0.2794663906097412,
0.700393557548523,
0.7781465649604797,
-0.043561022728681564,
0.4240284562110901,
-0.21325962245464325,
-0.4844965636730194,
-0.328572154045105,
-1.3742088079452515,
-0.8202005624771118,
-0.5627259016036987,
-0.34650155901908875,
-0.4163306653499603,
-0.13348595798015594,
1.335971474647522,
0.3035185933113098,
-0.7504382133483887,
-0.3482057750225067,
0.1555243581533432,
-0.006200024392455816,
-0.08310867846012115,
-0.17074406147003174,
0.5852005481719971,
-0.3040021061897278,
-1.2128169536590576,
0.5378637313842773,
0.38053691387176514,
0.3340241014957428,
-0.5053857564926147,
-0.2894023358821869,
-0.1928490847349167,
-0.0038079845253378153,
0.14233125746250153,
-0.01087679248303175,
-0.9133702516555786,
-0.2618938386440277,
-0.09591984003782272,
-0.4285085201263428,
0.2485886663198471,
0.3911452293395996,
-0.5775406360626221,
0.3713407814502716,
0.5615883469581604,
0.694050669670105,
0.2428445816040039,
0.252733051776886,
0.7823584079742432,
-0.4511488378047943,
0.1032104641199112,
-0.01560603454709053,
0.5105522871017456,
0.4271467328071594,
-0.5009956955909729,
0.2779381275177002,
-0.16343271732330322,
-0.8013003468513489,
-0.8099833130836487,
0.2645709216594696,
-1.2748535871505737,
-0.02629963494837284,
1.205565094947815,
-0.35758110880851746,
-0.162435382604599,
0.3931080102920532,
-0.5954709053039551,
0.26539382338523865,
-0.46751150488853455,
1.0849450826644897,
0.7424950003623962,
-0.051975052803754807,
0.03771491348743439,
0.040855757892131805,
0.3635616600513458,
0.5427201390266418,
-0.8663066625595093,
0.28772106766700745,
0.5247706770896912,
0.32142919301986694,
0.012124234810471535,
0.7148160934448242,
-0.049027569591999054,
-0.09558511525392532,
-0.3728927969932556,
0.16330721974372864,
-0.1828954815864563,
-0.039183031767606735,
-0.7770272493362427,
0.009616229683160782,
0.3349284827709198,
-0.3666050434112549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11905v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11905v2 | Learning to Edit: Aligning LLMs with Knowledge Editing | 2024-02-19T07:45:17 | 2024-06-05T15:46:03 | Yuxin Jiang, Yufei Wang, Chuhan Wu, Wanjun Zhong, Xingshan Zeng, Jiahui Gao, Liangyou Li, Xin Jiang, Lifeng Shang, Ruiming Tang, Qun Liu, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge editing techniques, aiming to efficiently modify a minor proportion
of knowledge in large language models (LLMs) without negatively impacting
performance across other inputs, have garnered widespread attention. However,
existing methods predominantly rely on memorizing the updated knowledge,
impeding LLMs from effectively combining the new knowledge with their inherent
knowledge when answering questions. To this end, we propose a Learning to Edit
(LTE) framework, focusing on teaching LLMs to apply updated knowledge into
input questions, inspired by the philosophy of "Teach a man to fish." LTE
features a two-phase process: (i) the Alignment Phase, which fine-tunes LLMs on
a meticulously curated parallel dataset to make reliable, in-scope edits while
preserving out-of-scope information and linguistic proficiency; and (ii) the
Inference Phase, which employs a retrieval-based mechanism for real-time and
mass knowledge editing. By comparing our approach with seven advanced baselines
across four popular knowledge editing benchmarks and two LLM architectures, we
demonstrate LTE's superiority in knowledge editing performance, robustness in
both batch and sequential editing, minimal interference on general tasks, and
rapid editing speeds. The data and code are available at
https://github.com/YJiangcm/LTE. | [
-0.09932943433523178,
-0.8923189043998718,
0.6873724460601807,
-0.20180989801883698,
-0.033337317407131195,
0.3273255228996277,
-0.31800568103790283,
-0.3678845167160034,
0.02319737710058689,
0.5863592624664307,
-0.427155077457428,
-0.5817116498947144,
-0.44287461042404175,
0.09218338131904602,
-0.26671651005744934,
0.6663680076599121,
-0.26042163372039795,
0.13103541731834412,
-0.2974734604358673,
-0.19090436398983002,
-0.7110732793807983,
-0.12027864158153534,
-1.1956850290298462,
-0.2958310842514038,
0.7283641695976257,
0.6373319625854492,
0.6025559902191162,
1.106789469718933,
0.1006709560751915,
0.27873125672340393,
-0.1597093939781189,
0.5263729691505432,
-0.5913647413253784,
0.07869581133127213,
-0.6240946650505066,
-0.7867428064346313,
-0.4768849015235901,
-0.19854766130447388,
0.5872541666030884,
0.5945419669151306,
0.17248687148094177,
0.11976861953735352,
0.10991202294826508,
0.9868118166923523,
-0.4573756754398346,
-0.07061710953712463,
-0.7711579203605652,
-0.16323255002498627,
-0.13783054053783417,
-0.22726662456989288,
-0.4271952211856842,
-0.38189879059791565,
0.18393367528915405,
-0.9305455088615417,
-0.07963480800390244,
0.02686500921845436,
0.5681261420249939,
0.45688268542289734,
-0.39980876445770264,
-0.3710330128669739,
-0.39781978726387024,
0.4766311049461365,
-0.5322049856185913,
0.5763477683067322,
0.2396458089351654,
0.042131222784519196,
-0.06553523987531662,
-0.6649995446205139,
-0.6264887452125549,
0.328633576631546,
0.24306999146938324,
0.23288922011852264,
0.35287386178970337,
0.2212231308221817,
0.20959967374801636,
0.1941385716199875,
-0.30001434683799744,
0.355193555355072,
-0.1850588470697403,
0.020682498812675476,
0.6731031537055969,
-0.15056636929512024,
0.305761456489563,
0.07945307344198227,
-0.4279269278049469,
0.1444518268108368,
-0.75540691614151,
0.03556211665272713,
0.36136677861213684,
0.07566153258085251,
0.17240014672279358,
0.8645252585411072,
-0.013738764449954033,
0.7462940812110901,
0.4369336664676666,
-0.31766626238822937,
-0.16888976097106934,
-0.1493980586528778,
-0.21005350351333618,
0.12029606848955154,
0.6186913847923279,
0.7958723902702332,
0.1900748610496521,
-0.21400584280490875,
-0.3511672914028168,
-0.3358176052570343,
0.2878657579421997,
-0.35462915897369385,
0.06560181826353073,
0.3005537986755371,
-0.05802726745605469,
-0.2889465093612671,
-0.2163783460855484,
-0.7152003645896912,
-0.5006231069564819,
-0.40642619132995605,
0.8374592065811157,
-0.4038475751876831,
0.30168381333351135,
0.29892683029174805,
-0.12997274100780487,
0.09603111445903778,
0.5852369666099548,
-0.8480053544044495,
0.1905696839094162,
0.7238685488700867,
0.6057696342468262,
-0.08983913064002991,
-0.45568305253982544,
-0.41375717520713806,
0.2857101559638977,
-0.377206027507782,
0.8465209603309631,
-0.4294896423816681,
-0.2857193350791931,
-0.061925821006298065,
-0.13998839259147644,
-0.1505942940711975,
-0.4014788866043091,
0.3734892010688782,
-1.128671646118164,
0.47719937562942505,
-0.4797705113887787,
-1.2951494455337524,
-0.27686262130737305,
0.08107519149780273,
-0.4683956503868103,
1.1039756536483765,
0.1201956495642662,
-0.5812315940856934,
0.4391407370567322,
-0.851719856262207,
-0.2542421221733093,
-0.1674194037914276,
0.19721178710460663,
-0.2537795603275299,
-0.2565830945968628,
0.2939279079437256,
0.2568790912628174,
-0.08740947395563126,
0.327081561088562,
-0.018244944512844086,
-0.2587378919124603,
0.1313820630311966,
-0.02734527364373207,
0.4118473529815674,
0.04674694314599037,
-0.005517056677490473,
0.27090561389923096,
-0.48428526520729065,
-0.059519074857234955,
-0.05866476893424988,
-0.6015870571136475,
-0.2883710563182831,
0.22344879806041718,
-0.3318236470222473,
0.015997111797332764,
0.3417532444000244,
-0.5791073441505432,
0.644476056098938,
-0.3716396391391754,
0.5366542339324951,
0.8228158354759216,
0.20838874578475952,
0.8050159215927124,
-0.7192462682723999,
0.3598693609237671,
-0.12841297686100006,
-0.018820278346538544,
-0.18924300372600555,
-0.27043744921684265,
-0.7850357294082642,
0.101791612803936,
0.5524793863296509,
1.0240986347198486,
-1.085301399230957,
0.2919313311576843,
-0.22347648441791534,
-0.21332800388336182,
-0.7191116809844971,
0.6908323168754578,
0.20472067594528198,
0.7414126396179199,
0.6083186864852905,
-0.1401890069246292,
-0.4899706542491913,
-0.4368247091770172,
-0.6644651889801025,
-0.028674554079771042,
0.031165558844804764,
0.08740367740392685,
0.1771322637796402,
-0.10554700344800949,
1.085825800895691,
-0.30461564660072327,
-0.25264135003089905,
-0.19569312036037445,
-0.0647289976477623,
-0.16527056694030762,
0.5698729753494263,
0.23231017589569092,
-0.46128877997398376,
-0.441297322511673,
-0.00413784384727478,
-0.8219879865646362,
-0.3365560472011566,
-0.29887479543685913,
-0.27212002873420715,
0.12254589796066284,
0.8012984395027161,
-0.3314129710197449,
-0.06057203561067581,
0.3714591860771179,
-0.25097620487213135,
0.2641017436981201,
-0.12552528083324432,
0.17246967554092407,
-1.4590929746627808,
-0.4294922947883606,
-0.11280623078346252,
-0.30411696434020996,
-0.6161863207817078,
-0.0805133804678917,
0.3162558972835541,
0.07937045395374298,
-0.4586438238620758,
0.7507649660110474,
-0.350200891494751,
0.0005777594051323831,
-0.13587497174739838,
0.43545666337013245,
0.09675250202417374,
0.3235812783241272,
-0.11546891182661057,
1.0617308616638184,
0.1689017415046692,
-0.3138728737831116,
0.19924511015415192,
0.3123829960823059,
-0.5091474652290344,
0.5545533895492554,
-0.43839552998542786,
0.42052921652793884,
-0.3195553123950958,
0.10100401192903519,
-0.6077354550361633,
-0.16759423911571503,
-0.040719203650951385,
-0.18107742071151733,
0.48241788148880005,
-0.3099495470523834,
-0.3472236096858978,
0.07868573069572449,
-0.47822296619415283,
0.41162681579589844,
0.25757071375846863,
-0.628114640712738,
0.6335986256599426,
0.2590177357196808,
-0.3313884735107422,
-0.8665351867675781,
-0.48999127745628357,
0.12792141735553741,
-0.15126748383045197,
-0.6124761700630188,
0.44562700390815735,
-0.027481257915496826,
-0.22197622060775757,
0.04936207830905914,
-0.12191713601350784,
-0.21851719915866852,
0.09619266539812088,
-0.18879461288452148,
0.38037368655204773,
-0.1752694696187973,
0.3157913088798523,
0.4605891704559326,
-0.004295662976801395,
-0.1947590559720993,
-0.6168903112411499,
0.19117173552513123,
0.3655567765235901,
-0.3935677409172058,
-0.5793440937995911,
0.03883109614253044,
0.5758054256439209,
-0.2005302906036377,
0.3215125799179077,
0.20388847589492798,
-0.30224665999412537,
-0.2659018635749817,
-0.8350056409835815,
-0.06562838703393936,
-0.4502585530281067,
0.36010047793388367,
-0.1239316537976265,
-1.104601263999939,
0.2909928858280182,
-0.2722328305244446,
0.5241161584854126,
0.3063920736312866,
0.09666787832975388,
-0.4925030469894409,
0.45730409026145935,
0.5863893032073975,
-0.09469164162874222,
0.6409580707550049,
-0.08807221055030823,
-0.040300607681274414,
-1.0539602041244507,
-0.04739299789071083,
-0.12765608727931976,
-0.5416547656059265,
-0.3627702593803406,
-0.8577151298522949,
0.26161378622055054,
0.5564217567443848,
-0.1936449259519577,
0.15153437852859497,
-0.11686127632856369,
0.8575176000595093,
0.3147767186164856,
0.2945324182510376,
0.4429938793182373,
-0.2601177990436554,
-0.20969811081886292,
-0.07383986562490463,
-0.896226704120636,
-0.6779271960258484,
1.4589797258377075,
0.3853655457496643,
0.7351483106613159,
-0.06388022005558014,
0.8391849994659424,
0.3520280122756958,
0.2667374908924103,
-0.8681515455245972,
0.45631253719329834,
-0.2856918275356293,
-0.3313349485397339,
-0.4957767724990845,
-0.22188282012939453,
-0.5431756973266602,
0.02684989757835865,
-0.3329732120037079,
-0.43538013100624084,
0.06712067872285843,
0.36002129316329956,
-0.3220490515232086,
0.7340208292007446,
-0.8828245997428894,
0.7616033554077148,
-0.3856664299964905,
-0.7574841380119324,
-0.12979057431221008,
-0.4897351562976837,
0.34606435894966125,
-0.17688773572444916,
0.4809666872024536,
0.0521441213786602,
-0.41516417264938354,
0.7739197015762329,
-0.3898410201072693,
0.8279056549072266,
-0.2412731796503067,
-0.14907772839069366,
0.2576262056827545,
0.025706976652145386,
0.5000003576278687,
0.3415197730064392,
-0.21655602753162384,
-0.24691668152809143,
-0.12266597896814346,
-0.38322746753692627,
-0.7170028686523438,
0.6058289408683777,
-0.6052743196487427,
-0.5181798338890076,
0.016308600082993507,
-0.8959000110626221,
-0.5078828930854797,
0.210645392537117,
0.09523890912532806,
0.3636431396007538,
-0.019523927941918373,
-0.1459902971982956,
0.944358766078949,
-0.23820257186889648,
0.2751588225364685,
0.352387934923172,
-0.5008636713027954,
-0.6623176336288452,
0.8278073072433472,
0.35901767015457153,
0.5564888119697571,
0.695239782333374,
-0.003969937562942505,
-0.43425315618515015,
-0.6256197690963745,
-0.7108889818191528,
0.24466897547245026,
-0.8195797204971313,
-0.0952361598610878,
-0.6558952331542969,
-0.05447884276509285,
-0.11377673596143723,
-0.7088019251823425,
-0.4844658374786377,
-0.5355983972549438,
-0.19802795350551605,
-0.03259977698326111,
0.41621729731559753,
0.7948728203773499,
-0.0045000286772847176,
0.4008639454841614,
-0.7559179663658142,
0.40236520767211914,
0.6675187349319458,
0.3115159273147583,
-0.37643444538116455,
-0.5707725286483765,
-0.12120001018047333,
0.20725825428962708,
-0.388235867023468,
-0.7900559902191162,
-0.12995295226573944,
0.40457412600517273,
0.2993214428424835,
0.029323654249310493,
-0.21960236132144928,
0.8203081488609314,
-0.35420024394989014,
0.6709885597229004,
-0.03676643222570419,
-1.207853078842163,
0.5034140348434448,
-0.22196193039417267,
0.3716854751110077,
0.7563301920890808,
0.20107415318489075,
-0.7278792858123779,
-0.36206185817718506,
-0.2897791564464569,
-0.5903122425079346,
0.4096323251724243,
-0.3019711673259735,
-0.07119903713464737,
0.16065478324890137,
0.7988991737365723,
0.17106081545352936,
0.29198524355888367,
-0.6125712394714355,
-0.1984570473432541,
-0.07340241223573685,
-0.420428991317749,
0.028404606506228447,
-0.4590713381767273,
-0.0229625441133976,
-0.3513534367084503,
0.8531079888343811,
-0.3334428369998932,
0.059411220252513885,
0.40589436888694763,
-0.4778077304363251,
-0.23070386052131653,
0.47848615050315857,
0.7733968496322632,
0.6911166906356812,
-0.03209215775132179,
-0.0198298841714859,
0.6520880460739136,
-0.32589322328567505,
0.07838358730077744,
-0.21103966236114502,
-0.5090861916542053,
-0.3257659375667572,
0.45672935247421265,
0.7305419445037842,
0.6375051140785217,
-0.46886828541755676,
0.2223045527935028,
0.041690003126859665,
-0.668413519859314,
0.2524421811103821,
0.13730916380882263,
0.42238685488700867,
0.4113399088382721,
0.1015777736902237,
0.1600341945886612,
-0.30837175250053406,
-0.3010234534740448,
0.14270710945129395,
0.20983722805976868,
-0.19145047664642334,
-0.14920221269130707,
0.8322702646255493,
0.25463438034057617,
-0.29748857021331787,
0.3903055787086487,
-0.06374996900558472,
-0.5711519122123718,
0.2769012451171875,
0.32240861654281616,
0.7544451355934143,
-0.16877181828022003,
0.025167956948280334,
0.3539400100708008,
0.3982750177383423,
-0.18850599229335785,
0.5783951878547668,
0.021407663822174072,
-0.9565544128417969,
-0.8664034605026245,
-0.570752739906311,
-0.5181311964988708,
-0.02666892670094967,
-0.5754557251930237,
0.36979371309280396,
-0.5381181836128235,
0.06720434874296188,
-0.04762939736247063,
-0.17937631905078888,
-0.3658074140548706,
0.23731975257396698,
-0.15763205289840698,
1.205809235572815,
-0.573383629322052,
1.094926118850708,
0.9173930883407593,
-0.01307164877653122,
-0.8668355941772461,
-0.08276590704917908,
0.12145517021417618,
-0.8692197203636169,
0.23676639795303345,
-0.10892486572265625,
0.12089581042528152,
0.46684956550598145,
-0.41686785221099854,
-0.7044768333435059,
1.3087643384933472,
0.43851444125175476,
-0.7916447520256042,
-0.22556741535663605,
0.1452641785144806,
0.26698625087738037,
-0.20402021706104279,
-0.01637824811041355,
0.4659368395805359,
0.4820511043071747,
-0.007399280089884996,
-0.9484942555427551,
-0.39000368118286133,
0.21228376030921936,
-0.11249901354312897,
0.32076698541641235,
-0.5120951533317566,
0.5366316437721252,
-0.35204729437828064,
-0.09436311572790146,
-0.22407831251621246,
0.5345287919044495,
-0.22910727560520172,
0.2652343213558197,
0.4827852249145508,
0.9277696013450623,
0.8880037069320679,
-0.2265145182609558,
0.5795704126358032,
-0.5055698156356812,
0.31452369689941406,
1.3863431215286255,
-0.2752763628959656,
0.8853663802146912,
0.569041907787323,
-0.019068172201514244,
0.3497847318649292,
0.5382527112960815,
0.20895542204380035,
0.3132486045360565,
-0.16991066932678223,
-0.39364033937454224,
-0.07155101746320724,
0.11394345015287399,
-0.11580445617437363,
0.2926154136657715,
0.29563209414482117,
-0.2221175581216812,
-0.23696021735668182,
0.016514725983142853,
0.10628318041563034,
0.36037448048591614,
-0.46033522486686707,
1.163490653038025,
-0.03237337991595268,
-0.6364480257034302,
0.42907559871673584,
-0.0889909490942955,
0.5811089873313904,
-0.5288817882537842,
0.0377541147172451,
-0.029755081981420517,
-0.14888159930706024,
-0.39517971873283386,
-1.135649561882019,
0.3387925624847412,
0.06758014112710953,
-0.325884610414505,
-0.5161454081535339,
0.6532222628593445,
-0.7624184489250183,
-0.24934208393096924,
0.25479060411453247,
0.4785575568675995,
-0.3186122477054596,
0.22281600534915924,
-0.6812790036201477,
0.035385612398386,
0.10101362317800522,
-0.1445913463830948,
0.3443182110786438,
0.2894307076931,
0.09111510217189789,
0.7009084224700928,
0.6580556631088257,
0.11172585189342499,
0.27210935950279236,
-0.07084514945745468,
0.6216933131217957,
-0.5969838500022888,
-0.1992642730474472,
-0.587410569190979,
0.7924540638923645,
-0.01035994291305542,
-0.2576419413089752,
0.43805715441703796,
0.643913209438324,
1.1860682964324951,
0.017035534605383873,
0.9796130657196045,
0.048846907913684845,
0.5450913906097412,
-0.9924218654632568,
0.5637573003768921,
-0.4994455873966217,
0.443002849817276,
0.060846809297800064,
-0.9180040955543518,
-0.13263151049613953,
0.33584123849868774,
-0.48202624917030334,
-0.26945018768310547,
0.8169305324554443,
0.862313985824585,
0.20379029214382172,
0.12328451126813889,
0.3194001615047455,
0.25339749455451965,
0.12433762848377228,
0.5035858750343323,
0.7060732245445251,
-0.6057597994804382,
0.045254722237586975,
-0.6655458211898804,
0.003044985933229327,
0.14910192787647247,
-0.8486901521682739,
-0.7603051066398621,
-0.4122066795825958,
-0.3344047963619232,
0.01440784614533186,
0.35107290744781494,
1.184247374534607,
0.4074961841106415,
-0.5271905064582825,
-0.42056044936180115,
-0.10564269125461578,
0.41281670331954956,
-0.2545429468154907,
-0.17664584517478943,
0.1736953854560852,
-0.5649608969688416,
-0.7146432399749756,
0.8078399300575256,
0.40125608444213867,
0.040396831929683685,
0.2843647003173828,
-0.0815022811293602,
-0.38500261306762695,
0.06596878170967102,
0.6739604473114014,
0.30151525139808655,
-0.6840887665748596,
-0.4442327320575714,
-0.03700251877307892,
-0.10802793502807617,
0.053426723927259445,
0.6838694214820862,
-0.5097898840904236,
0.8118315935134888,
0.24443943798542023,
1.0750962495803833,
0.18042069673538208,
0.21274176239967346,
0.5507226586341858,
-0.5339575409889221,
-0.2822708189487457,
-0.02835012972354889,
0.2914995551109314,
0.23648305237293243,
-0.38966163992881775,
0.26391667127609253,
0.2238108366727829,
-0.8687188029289246,
-0.5320355892181396,
0.00350241013802588,
-1.1343791484832764,
-0.024401096627116203,
0.9180005788803101,
-0.05666130408644676,
-0.13240301609039307,
-0.19282642006874084,
-0.4818800091743469,
0.41716256737709045,
-0.14797723293304443,
0.6707282066345215,
0.7111706733703613,
0.01907404698431492,
-0.13026905059814453,
-0.7874879837036133,
0.445241242647171,
0.5308841466903687,
-0.9057059288024902,
0.08528914302587509,
0.37689757347106934,
0.6604608297348022,
-0.31799787282943726,
0.33696579933166504,
0.001083945157006383,
0.48177701234817505,
-0.4561547338962555,
0.19449104368686676,
-0.1585572063922882,
-0.12489671260118484,
-0.32716214656829834,
0.23655003309249878,
0.41681191325187683,
0.031923435628414154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11903v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11903v3 | DiLA: Enhancing LLM Tool Learning with Differential Logic Layer | 2024-02-19T07:38:57 | 2024-06-19T02:52:00 | Yu Zhang, Hui-Ling Zhen, Zehua Pei, Yingzhao Lian, Lihao Yin, Mingxuan Yuan, Bei Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Considering the challenges faced by large language models (LLMs) in logical
reasoning and planning, prior efforts have sought to augment LLMs with access
to external solvers. While progress has been made on simple reasoning problems,
solving classical constraint satisfaction problems, such as the Boolean
Satisfiability Problem (SAT) and Graph Coloring Problem (GCP), remains
difficult for off-the-shelf solvers due to their intricate expressions and
exponential search spaces. In this paper, we propose a novel differential logic
layer-aided language modeling (DiLA) approach, where logical constraints are
integrated into the forward and backward passes of a network layer, to provide
another option for LLM tool learning. In DiLA, LLM aims to transform the
language description to logic constraints and identify initial solutions of the
highest quality, while the differential logic layer focuses on iteratively
refining the LLM-prompted solution. Leveraging the logic layer as a bridge,
DiLA enhances the logical reasoning ability of LLMs on a range of reasoning
problems encoded by Boolean variables, guaranteeing the efficiency and
correctness of the solution process. We evaluate the performance of DiLA on two
classic reasoning problems and empirically demonstrate its consistent
outperformance against existing prompt-based and solver-aided approaches. | [
-0.2415183186531067,
-0.8567468523979187,
0.8979032039642334,
0.17464467883110046,
-0.26133155822753906,
0.2549407482147217,
-0.030350932851433754,
-0.31877240538597107,
0.21924230456352234,
0.54640793800354,
-0.9219940304756165,
-0.4696332812309265,
-0.443721741437912,
0.17016899585723877,
-0.0925232321023941,
0.5321041345596313,
-0.18884074687957764,
0.06797865778207779,
-0.191417396068573,
0.008290154859423637,
-0.742606520652771,
-0.31033027172088623,
-0.5493112802505493,
-0.38108378648757935,
0.28356149792671204,
0.26705217361450195,
0.5431138873100281,
0.5076028108596802,
0.30250993371009827,
0.39775368571281433,
-0.3338319659233093,
0.5847095847129822,
-0.18134747445583344,
-0.009275934658944607,
-0.25035110116004944,
-0.5740954875946045,
-0.4009462296962738,
0.0004135318158660084,
0.54387366771698,
0.906562864780426,
-0.13766828179359436,
-0.0820043683052063,
-0.3143708109855652,
0.7754750847816467,
-0.5072367787361145,
0.3717247545719147,
-0.8959846496582031,
0.042676977813243866,
0.07408037036657333,
-0.05200755223631859,
-0.2621564269065857,
-0.46368706226348877,
-0.03611666336655617,
-0.8595556020736694,
-0.30092233419418335,
-0.27809494733810425,
0.573893129825592,
0.5859739184379578,
-0.4926186501979828,
-0.3190247714519501,
-0.7785929441452026,
0.7166253328323364,
-0.5999594926834106,
0.3547007739543915,
0.02098180539906025,
0.46225836873054504,
-0.251270592212677,
-0.44717851281166077,
-0.7493054866790771,
0.07148326188325882,
0.09919276833534241,
0.11816718429327011,
0.03460793197154999,
-0.1952643245458603,
0.4262816607952118,
0.1180553287267685,
-0.17707961797714233,
0.11686179041862488,
-0.41909492015838623,
-0.1162169948220253,
0.6340492367744446,
0.3041590750217438,
0.29979217052459717,
0.16620643436908722,
-0.3420160710811615,
0.1271432787179947,
-0.7662695050239563,
0.08033906668424606,
0.3355698585510254,
0.39114928245544434,
-0.006957501173019409,
0.4289231300354004,
-0.20843806862831116,
0.7693609595298767,
-0.2147504836320877,
-0.3531268537044525,
0.3738398849964142,
-0.09670652449131012,
-0.30414655804634094,
-0.06278624385595322,
0.307486355304718,
0.03920610621571541,
0.30843761563301086,
-0.1001049131155014,
-0.5250102281570435,
0.2323046326637268,
0.10669353604316711,
-0.6326379776000977,
-0.2635684311389923,
0.07666920870542526,
0.03721223399043083,
-0.21777823567390442,
-0.10672087967395782,
-0.41551151871681213,
-0.5809561014175415,
-0.762612521648407,
0.41042518615722656,
-0.29341232776641846,
-0.33084049820899963,
0.39998263120651245,
0.11149410158395767,
0.3616003394126892,
0.6648368835449219,
-0.2088136374950409,
0.5012667179107666,
0.7272670865058899,
0.6813477277755737,
-0.029962552711367607,
0.08257699012756348,
-0.9947644472122192,
0.11127211898565292,
-0.3865084648132324,
0.6491875648498535,
-0.6284451484680176,
-0.3558633327484131,
-0.10013140738010406,
-0.022094255313277245,
0.015766071155667305,
-0.6441572308540344,
0.6534808874130249,
-0.9603997468948364,
0.13051125407218933,
-0.39062070846557617,
-0.4312323033809662,
-0.4798664152622223,
0.2758852541446686,
-0.6728653311729431,
0.599128782749176,
0.05203929916024208,
-0.739797055721283,
0.15002167224884033,
-0.3990788757801056,
-0.5642085671424866,
-0.012895815074443817,
-0.4314461648464203,
-0.4804838001728058,
-0.07029587030410767,
0.4793942868709564,
0.2751585841178894,
-0.4124176502227783,
0.23754428327083588,
-0.2622497081756592,
-0.47650831937789917,
0.1283910870552063,
0.0066526527516543865,
1.2297194004058838,
-0.0030944522004574537,
-0.26477330923080444,
0.2246810793876648,
-0.7362266778945923,
-0.054395757615566254,
0.4349011480808258,
-0.1819051057100296,
-0.22216403484344482,
-0.08130015432834625,
-0.5237144827842712,
0.4704596996307373,
0.1547446995973587,
-0.6097382307052612,
0.2734108567237854,
-0.7409855723381042,
0.3166654407978058,
0.9170367121696472,
-0.0803520604968071,
0.251361608505249,
-0.11668667197227478,
0.47022509574890137,
0.3670475482940674,
0.044233258813619614,
0.3252023756504059,
-0.5232354998588562,
-0.7175716161727905,
-0.27560123801231384,
0.17458994686603546,
0.8895250558853149,
-0.8020724654197693,
0.39642009139060974,
-0.036033134907484055,
-0.2054675817489624,
-0.15341578423976898,
0.5029162764549255,
0.22143502533435822,
0.8216370940208435,
0.44061630964279175,
-0.24424105882644653,
-0.3617364764213562,
-0.7681649923324585,
0.2129179686307907,
-0.24939875304698944,
0.04428159072995186,
0.5480376482009888,
0.32954075932502747,
-0.28480443358421326,
0.9323397874832153,
-0.7486220002174377,
-0.69355708360672,
-0.45293357968330383,
-0.20256850123405457,
0.48851698637008667,
0.21052777767181396,
0.3158631920814514,
-0.8070646524429321,
-0.43649864196777344,
-0.002133796224370599,
-0.6714017391204834,
-0.506064236164093,
-0.17108233273029327,
0.008448703214526176,
0.2183959186077118,
0.4214891195297241,
-0.41264256834983826,
0.3750516474246979,
0.29485130310058594,
-0.3506675958633423,
0.7895820140838623,
-0.1861426830291748,
-0.34505149722099304,
-0.6996927857398987,
-0.030302952975034714,
-0.014378528110682964,
-0.21708308160305023,
-0.3970087766647339,
-0.18875020742416382,
0.06435028463602066,
-0.06852608174085617,
-0.5313287377357483,
0.540466845035553,
-0.56959468126297,
-0.036654699593782425,
-0.31857597827911377,
0.5362539291381836,
0.20384499430656433,
0.48609936237335205,
0.08495672792196274,
0.8993449211120605,
0.744705080986023,
-0.4999043345451355,
0.5705588459968567,
0.30399832129478455,
-0.022641383111476898,
0.32709622383117676,
-0.7560144662857056,
0.32626256346702576,
-0.11636562645435333,
0.19078491628170013,
-0.7106048464775085,
0.2809714376926422,
0.1895056813955307,
0.10418692231178284,
0.34680989384651184,
-0.21706485748291016,
-0.5629404783248901,
-0.2229367345571518,
-0.3323916494846344,
0.3166345953941345,
0.6282051801681519,
-0.6847688555717468,
0.9548003673553467,
0.3702327013015747,
-0.046883806586265564,
-0.5922636389732361,
-0.5477876663208008,
0.005250141490250826,
-0.20771940052509308,
-0.7739320993423462,
0.3807727098464966,
-0.090596042573452,
-0.3249814212322235,
-0.1087329089641571,
-0.33470845222473145,
-0.10213761031627655,
0.3022368848323822,
0.04221435636281967,
0.39159294962882996,
-0.03912544250488281,
0.07388278096914291,
0.16363123059272766,
-0.18944065272808075,
0.441638320684433,
-0.4672192335128784,
0.3685586452484131,
-0.2128511518239975,
-0.5345358848571777,
-0.369489461183548,
0.1702626496553421,
0.16012337803840637,
-0.5177344083786011,
0.7039992809295654,
0.32638344168663025,
-0.1804673969745636,
-0.7042074203491211,
-0.590010404586792,
-0.2709673047065735,
-0.5663954019546509,
0.19248425960540771,
-0.67799973487854,
-0.6108165383338928,
0.6273173093795776,
-0.4823519289493561,
-0.1263682097196579,
0.09781880676746368,
0.27657806873321533,
0.17116111516952515,
0.9148115515708923,
0.7000139355659485,
-0.12335536628961563,
0.25894442200660706,
-0.3823036253452301,
0.060327570885419846,
-0.9305054545402527,
-0.29551494121551514,
-0.31934547424316406,
-0.18069931864738464,
-0.2457471638917923,
-0.6583265662193298,
0.47191479802131653,
0.3156369626522064,
-0.2567674517631531,
0.06479037553071976,
-0.3967142105102539,
0.7291927337646484,
0.37554648518562317,
0.21587184071540833,
0.5037009119987488,
-0.00798121839761734,
-0.5973929762840271,
0.11337762326002121,
-0.5971626043319702,
-0.45952239632606506,
0.8854526877403259,
0.3671130836009979,
0.6320431232452393,
0.3001767098903656,
0.7134436368942261,
-0.18295426666736603,
0.04223691299557686,
-0.5766911506652832,
0.8644928336143494,
-0.2512209117412567,
-0.32463398575782776,
-0.14173488318920135,
-0.6718313694000244,
-0.4395906627178192,
0.002761659910902381,
0.13790325820446014,
-0.9107998013496399,
0.13237355649471283,
-0.07174207270145416,
-0.05813201516866684,
0.4304729402065277,
-0.6072219014167786,
0.6031622886657715,
-0.4179457128047943,
-0.5498799681663513,
-0.1148696094751358,
-0.6441646814346313,
0.34524571895599365,
-0.037114523351192474,
0.11989734321832657,
-0.07370162010192871,
-0.23744980990886688,
0.4577384293079376,
-0.33263713121414185,
1.0152487754821777,
-0.40994149446487427,
-0.4500081241130829,
0.37555763125419617,
0.4133625030517578,
0.8534073829650879,
0.3530122935771942,
-0.05377696081995964,
-0.09420217573642731,
-0.2728815972805023,
-0.1937778741121292,
-0.9080675840377808,
0.6304434537887573,
-0.8059414029121399,
-1.0280940532684326,
-0.16682523488998413,
-0.6051243543624878,
-0.4959312975406647,
0.27097851037979126,
-0.5988909602165222,
0.524144172668457,
0.20503124594688416,
-0.379585862159729,
0.8430908918380737,
-0.4386727511882782,
0.15444175899028778,
0.4865928590297699,
-0.4161593019962311,
-0.12781956791877747,
0.9388412237167358,
-0.023771436884999275,
0.25733593106269836,
0.3899305760860443,
0.2826407253742218,
-0.41387927532196045,
-0.6566229462623596,
-0.4111317992210388,
0.5683658719062805,
-1.0618932247161865,
-0.2313675731420517,
-0.6506391167640686,
-0.4894625246524811,
-0.057646919041872025,
-0.11577750742435455,
-0.3445640206336975,
-0.6872130632400513,
-0.35932812094688416,
0.059645041823387146,
0.26087161898612976,
0.5905791521072388,
0.014290920458734035,
-0.2401716113090515,
-0.4384421110153198,
0.3755493760108948,
0.5196904540061951,
0.4872843027114868,
-0.20058871805667877,
-0.4272927939891815,
0.1675191968679428,
-0.21333368122577667,
-0.2930169999599457,
-0.878969669342041,
0.2255006581544876,
-0.003640312235802412,
0.5466694235801697,
0.20281121134757996,
0.17398123443126678,
0.29801174998283386,
-0.3816470205783844,
0.28322315216064453,
-0.026883963495492935,
-0.8967466354370117,
0.7201035022735596,
-0.11070556193590164,
0.30222854018211365,
0.32243743538856506,
0.3135495185852051,
0.014375310391187668,
-0.09204868227243423,
-0.34147730469703674,
-0.6459094882011414,
0.574068009853363,
0.19967150688171387,
-0.1087576374411583,
0.2603357136249542,
0.330674946308136,
0.04873589426279068,
0.06257299333810806,
-0.7966266870498657,
-0.20714071393013,
-0.11131366342306137,
-0.02422133833169937,
0.24782684445381165,
-0.15078288316726685,
-0.21746307611465454,
-0.2578256130218506,
0.9220014214515686,
-0.372811496257782,
0.008396519348025322,
0.23109467327594757,
-0.04158725589513779,
0.012244148179888725,
0.37047284841537476,
0.2674950361251831,
0.6923976540565491,
-0.2152068018913269,
0.10853154212236404,
0.3828781545162201,
-0.1795252412557602,
0.19866961240768433,
0.3621808588504791,
-0.36193084716796875,
-0.31387147307395935,
0.1967719942331314,
0.5315876603126526,
-0.5143749117851257,
-0.820469856262207,
0.4797031283378601,
-0.052364807575941086,
-0.1767590343952179,
-0.19445212185382843,
0.23439612984657288,
0.30740615725517273,
0.5114622712135315,
0.0970669835805893,
-0.2712911069393158,
0.155115008354187,
-0.1800195574760437,
0.037075676023960114,
0.6567219495773315,
-0.422066867351532,
-0.18677875399589539,
0.4541507661342621,
0.32912224531173706,
-0.11163310706615448,
0.7358427047729492,
-0.5338767766952515,
-0.930497944355011,
0.668857753276825,
0.6853199005126953,
0.830916702747345,
0.24854467809200287,
0.2646871507167816,
0.08328177779912949,
0.41658198833465576,
0.4231608211994171,
0.6260143518447876,
-0.10437625646591187,
-0.8887180685997009,
-0.7109524011611938,
-0.67457115650177,
-0.3153408169746399,
0.07567621022462845,
0.03245526924729347,
0.40074729919433594,
-0.6852865219116211,
0.16258102655410767,
-0.2930554747581482,
0.35569509863853455,
-0.6094421148300171,
0.2340329885482788,
0.07456231862306595,
1.0940196514129639,
-0.7128416299819946,
0.8984981775283813,
0.9763020873069763,
-0.44910290837287903,
-1.0955969095230103,
-0.10737273097038269,
0.1619703322649002,
-0.538701057434082,
1.2074651718139648,
0.1725885272026062,
-0.6667094230651855,
-0.08926203846931458,
-0.11940459161996841,
-0.5640432834625244,
1.131798267364502,
0.5918867588043213,
-0.5740115642547607,
0.034879665821790695,
0.37476596236228943,
0.3532639145851135,
-0.3675156235694885,
0.08630991727113724,
0.3802509605884552,
0.3160548508167267,
0.24286921322345734,
-0.7892360687255859,
0.43363308906555176,
-0.2425336390733719,
-0.09062059223651886,
0.0033515612594783306,
-0.6619513034820557,
0.6970313787460327,
-0.40781447291374207,
-0.35071253776550293,
-0.2647607624530792,
0.5934603810310364,
0.4832203984260559,
0.1672932207584381,
0.8341562151908875,
0.5347828269004822,
0.6803198456764221,
0.015108811669051647,
0.7439471483230591,
-0.059465646743774414,
-0.013926849700510502,
1.1205493211746216,
-0.6285216808319092,
0.4546608328819275,
0.48890793323516846,
-0.19470985233783722,
0.5727388262748718,
0.1455315500497818,
0.321453720331192,
0.5440807342529297,
0.4672936797142029,
-0.20570051670074463,
-0.45781126618385315,
-0.20396454632282257,
-0.2796587646007538,
0.32362139225006104,
0.34888267517089844,
-0.040007274597883224,
-0.17007924616336823,
-0.19445793330669403,
-0.20832940936088562,
0.3825128674507141,
-0.1667926162481308,
0.7989658713340759,
0.1903035193681717,
-0.2043171375989914,
0.504440188407898,
0.008708929643034935,
0.39289718866348267,
-0.44342249631881714,
-0.17152270674705505,
-0.3131953477859497,
0.3032182455062866,
-0.14534401893615723,
-0.7011705636978149,
0.42159146070480347,
-0.25902223587036133,
0.10779956728219986,
-0.024463048204779625,
0.9026067852973938,
-0.039664700627326965,
-0.7530590295791626,
0.634239673614502,
0.7527875304222107,
-0.30526795983314514,
-0.0047047920525074005,
-0.6693386435508728,
0.1932629644870758,
-0.16957809031009674,
-0.140412837266922,
0.051270872354507446,
0.8364254236221313,
0.08709488809108734,
0.998744010925293,
0.47189363837242126,
0.39539971947669983,
-0.07015630602836609,
0.3301185369491577,
1.4412493705749512,
-0.4827752709388733,
-0.615942656993866,
-0.5920117497444153,
0.42307665944099426,
-0.21906985342502594,
0.10128713399171829,
0.4401698708534241,
0.3684719502925873,
0.9714130759239197,
0.030797304585576057,
0.4488357901573181,
0.22686417400836945,
0.47783994674682617,
-0.8890289068222046,
0.3399866819381714,
-0.6413358449935913,
1.008028268814087,
-0.296146422624588,
-0.9619052410125732,
-0.3958139419555664,
0.5922698378562927,
-0.599459171295166,
0.14625775814056396,
0.6150846481323242,
0.8679441809654236,
-0.4318685531616211,
0.03300367295742035,
0.13224564492702484,
0.1685488224029541,
0.5100985765457153,
0.8742908835411072,
0.9632654190063477,
-0.06179141253232956,
0.42713141441345215,
-0.6169940829277039,
-0.3248303234577179,
0.23528888821601868,
-1.028152346611023,
-1.0607733726501465,
-0.4297821521759033,
-0.4759972095489502,
-0.0782753974199295,
0.1182185560464859,
0.8641172647476196,
0.6551322937011719,
-0.6940011382102966,
-0.2318461686372757,
-0.34670019149780273,
0.40557950735092163,
-0.17874273657798767,
-0.22775529325008392,
0.29377639293670654,
-0.5056793689727783,
-0.43235325813293457,
0.5806334614753723,
0.32034075260162354,
-0.13371337950229645,
-0.4205690622329712,
-0.09366995841264725,
-0.37255585193634033,
0.16202522814273834,
0.37783828377723694,
-0.001255336799658835,
-0.6067271828651428,
-0.12009946256875992,
-0.17622563242912292,
0.18342143297195435,
0.019685370847582817,
0.8522939085960388,
-1.1940290927886963,
0.27867892384529114,
0.3400070369243622,
0.9404763579368591,
0.4184989035129547,
-0.11449161171913147,
0.5600812435150146,
-0.913000226020813,
0.19347335398197174,
0.2833214998245239,
0.3790284991264343,
0.38411250710487366,
-0.2976762652397156,
0.5439336895942688,
0.24819529056549072,
-0.20156511664390564,
-0.7390157580375671,
0.5480310916900635,
-0.9631392359733582,
-0.4458008110523224,
0.9927845001220703,
-0.12042976915836334,
-0.07883373647928238,
-0.22343462705612183,
-0.33706730604171753,
0.2167462408542633,
-0.22560584545135498,
0.8194082379341125,
0.19681261479854584,
-0.07658586651086807,
-0.1790628433227539,
-0.2973616421222687,
0.2726922929286957,
0.46090924739837646,
-0.9879876375198364,
0.10787593573331833,
0.5258703231811523,
0.20088732242584229,
0.17598603665828705,
0.415754497051239,
-0.109588623046875,
0.17305341362953186,
-0.31846943497657776,
-0.46829116344451904,
-0.6961023807525635,
-0.6050918102264404,
-0.24385064840316772,
0.16848315298557281,
0.13615739345550537,
0.20899051427841187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11900v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11900v2 | Investigating Multi-Hop Factual Shortcuts in Knowledge Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T07:34:10 | 2024-06-02T09:17:37 | Tianjie Ju, Yijin Chen, Xinwei Yuan, Zhuosheng Zhang, Wei Du, Yubin Zheng, Gongshen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has showcased the powerful capability of large language models
(LLMs) in recalling knowledge and reasoning. However, the reliability of LLMs
in combining these two capabilities into reasoning through multi-hop facts has
not been widely explored. This paper systematically investigates the
possibilities for LLMs to utilize shortcuts based on direct connections between
the initial and terminal entities of multi-hop knowledge. We first explore the
existence of factual shortcuts through Knowledge Neurons, revealing that: (i)
the strength of factual shortcuts is highly correlated with the frequency of
co-occurrence of initial and terminal entities in the pre-training corpora;
(ii) few-shot prompting leverage more shortcuts in answering multi-hop
questions compared to chain-of-thought prompting. Then, we analyze the risks
posed by factual shortcuts from the perspective of multi-hop knowledge editing.
Analysis shows that approximately 20% of the failures are attributed to
shortcuts, and the initial and terminal entities in these failure instances
usually have higher co-occurrences in the pre-training corpus. Finally, we
propose erasing shortcut neurons to mitigate the associated risks and find that
this approach significantly reduces failures in multiple-hop knowledge editing
caused by shortcuts. | [
-0.22272557020187378,
-1.123257040977478,
1.191678762435913,
-0.2043309211730957,
-0.04624843969941139,
0.29816314578056335,
-0.32535043358802795,
-0.2482834756374359,
0.17136578261852264,
0.3704906702041626,
-0.5277866721153259,
-0.5033515095710754,
-0.5882059931755066,
0.1613306850194931,
-0.09896285086870193,
1.0589944124221802,
0.042848631739616394,
-0.33580029010772705,
-0.17859597504138947,
-0.22489626705646515,
-0.7262770533561707,
-0.6003566384315491,
-0.6375181078910828,
0.21282480657100677,
1.1261860132217407,
0.47441747784614563,
1.0105937719345093,
0.47259029746055603,
0.32374605536460876,
0.3390265107154846,
-0.4971735179424286,
0.20842032134532928,
-0.3543996810913086,
-0.060667138546705246,
-0.263641357421875,
-0.6978183388710022,
-0.48515886068344116,
-0.11917393654584885,
0.8275876045227051,
0.769677996635437,
0.17320826649665833,
0.13635273277759552,
-0.0056968326680362225,
0.5982407927513123,
-0.5369879603385925,
-0.34437087178230286,
-0.9087094664573669,
-0.23094728589057922,
-0.3985883593559265,
-0.3749057352542877,
-0.39963340759277344,
-0.5641673803329468,
0.000422412995249033,
-0.46477198600769043,
0.03086165525019169,
0.12506037950515747,
0.6273950338363647,
0.2519242465496063,
-0.5765613913536072,
-0.3922543525695801,
-0.5429747700691223,
0.5545365214347839,
-0.5663989782333374,
0.3240685760974884,
0.15239867568016052,
0.22408680617809296,
-0.22271332144737244,
-0.44194114208221436,
-0.5003522038459778,
-0.15496811270713806,
-0.2585528790950775,
-0.4063985049724579,
-0.0877145379781723,
0.2814299166202545,
0.7350132465362549,
-0.28720036149024963,
-0.2334137260913849,
0.03981531783938408,
-0.5410628914833069,
-0.4261969029903412,
0.19807489216327667,
0.15076355636119843,
0.4278045892715454,
-0.21073982119560242,
-0.21475377678871155,
0.19557519257068634,
-1.1435317993164062,
0.1768542230129242,
0.41800519824028015,
0.2955552339553833,
0.18567445874214172,
0.7849942445755005,
0.013961938209831715,
0.859788715839386,
-0.2682088017463684,
-0.6033580899238586,
0.1715869903564453,
-0.6145594120025635,
-0.12336639314889908,
0.14226789772510529,
0.7588121891021729,
0.004908145405352116,
0.3891119062900543,
-0.23134751617908478,
0.1879296600818634,
-0.3951338827610016,
-0.039725691080093384,
-0.490400105714798,
-0.009499921463429928,
0.13484764099121094,
-0.3005162477493286,
-0.1289130449295044,
-0.4678914248943329,
-0.5098322629928589,
-0.16178220510482788,
-0.2668343782424927,
0.6463280320167542,
-0.7114766240119934,
0.09069143235683441,
0.1414782851934433,
-0.33387312293052673,
-0.15234960615634918,
0.5216148495674133,
-0.5640493035316467,
-0.05334799364209175,
0.7533085942268372,
1.0136382579803467,
0.13364380598068237,
-0.6873852014541626,
-0.5826035141944885,
0.4303306043148041,
-0.33630478382110596,
0.4467755854129791,
-0.4164898693561554,
-0.37419503927230835,
-0.16906476020812988,
-0.23065920174121857,
-0.18344321846961975,
-0.23997366428375244,
0.5607292652130127,
-0.870836079120636,
-0.2242979258298874,
-0.6838082671165466,
-0.6830834746360779,
-0.28372395038604736,
0.3886585831642151,
-0.5947840809822083,
0.4495397210121155,
-0.479091614484787,
-1.1048530340194702,
0.2769813537597656,
-0.5215722918510437,
-0.583172619342804,
-0.461564838886261,
-0.10563082993030548,
-0.23705075681209564,
-0.029381994158029556,
0.08882341533899307,
0.2109752744436264,
-0.07959144562482834,
0.3867865800857544,
-0.45249682664871216,
-0.21245400607585907,
0.22698822617530823,
-0.5021418929100037,
0.8779869675636292,
-0.17286443710327148,
-0.0758005753159523,
0.07245472073554993,
-0.7944431900978088,
-0.16267725825309753,
0.061086054891347885,
-0.3484324812889099,
-0.7354496121406555,
-0.16452321410179138,
-0.5929036736488342,
0.5629493594169617,
-0.04475339502096176,
-0.3908005952835083,
0.5715504884719849,
-0.053682081401348114,
0.1643754094839096,
0.800241231918335,
0.5518548488616943,
0.21871145069599152,
-0.1319514811038971,
0.3482872247695923,
0.11135466396808624,
0.1554383933544159,
-0.2611280381679535,
-0.464450865983963,
-0.8064567446708679,
-0.4612610638141632,
0.31343719363212585,
0.3746451735496521,
-0.7873385548591614,
0.26465487480163574,
-0.2823998034000397,
-0.4020526707172394,
-0.38586339354515076,
0.2665797173976898,
0.28362271189689636,
0.7426923513412476,
0.46440696716308594,
0.23564933240413666,
-0.2301338165998459,
-0.8365427255630493,
-0.603459358215332,
-0.12659290432929993,
0.18690621852874756,
0.19533690810203552,
0.5765489339828491,
-0.18619263172149658,
1.0363911390304565,
-0.64422208070755,
-0.06828552484512329,
-0.11053396016359329,
0.2202375829219818,
0.2640460729598999,
0.30901455879211426,
0.6746699810028076,
-0.40862616896629333,
-0.24656197428703308,
-0.6131334900856018,
-0.5660548806190491,
0.3507029712200165,
-0.4430477023124695,
-0.26267367601394653,
-0.14906460046768188,
0.5661662817001343,
-1.1550086736679077,
0.45153436064720154,
0.15000343322753906,
-0.19852077960968018,
0.8465896844863892,
-0.19176436960697174,
0.22153645753860474,
-0.7344529628753662,
0.04588387906551361,
-0.4546496272087097,
-0.016387900337576866,
-0.6619468927383423,
-0.2761867344379425,
0.08417753875255585,
0.09143505245447159,
-0.6063299775123596,
0.3762472867965698,
-0.460307240486145,
-0.08246610313653946,
-0.15601585805416107,
0.09352502226829529,
0.20463509857654572,
0.5778235197067261,
0.030468983575701714,
0.694977343082428,
0.4774876534938812,
-0.8081436157226562,
0.0506664514541626,
0.495187371969223,
-0.4181358814239502,
-0.07010506838560104,
-0.5594927668571472,
0.30324745178222656,
-0.24582447111606598,
0.2536466717720032,
-0.7271592617034912,
0.12118501961231232,
0.07874126732349396,
-0.20810319483280182,
0.17490601539611816,
-0.3536973297595978,
-0.7194151282310486,
-0.1295785903930664,
-0.3709428906440735,
0.5088045001029968,
0.1263568252325058,
-0.6451057195663452,
0.40490081906318665,
-0.04209255054593086,
-0.3289472460746765,
-0.7321721315383911,
-0.5456053614616394,
0.19810569286346436,
-0.28221043944358826,
-0.8144206404685974,
0.06230626627802849,
-0.12347566336393356,
-0.08366622030735016,
0.14198805391788483,
0.20401406288146973,
0.2663605809211731,
0.2095780223608017,
0.04933645948767662,
0.5502172708511353,
-0.03036683239042759,
0.3587479591369629,
0.18544265627861023,
0.017277231439948082,
0.1219019815325737,
0.09471249580383301,
0.16274841129779816,
-0.038662999868392944,
-0.6823098659515381,
-0.24820241332054138,
0.2283860594034195,
0.7618069052696228,
-0.3208603262901306,
0.8799545168876648,
0.23078444600105286,
-0.2714819312095642,
0.1466345191001892,
-0.6305232048034668,
-0.20710471272468567,
-0.45350804924964905,
0.44342315196990967,
-0.4850793480873108,
-0.9806269407272339,
0.27900004386901855,
-0.39046934247016907,
0.02775232493877411,
0.3037809431552887,
0.32894256711006165,
-0.16882996261119843,
0.5849060416221619,
0.47126516699790955,
-0.19661778211593628,
0.18886828422546387,
-0.16304397583007812,
0.5388857126235962,
-0.9164982438087463,
-0.13422757387161255,
-0.6471524834632874,
-0.21426063776016235,
-0.4881390631198883,
-0.5367984771728516,
0.8095370531082153,
0.40818196535110474,
-0.167547807097435,
0.1643800139427185,
0.264313668012619,
0.6213168501853943,
0.7079151272773743,
-0.09614025056362152,
0.35068896412849426,
-0.25674867630004883,
-0.590982973575592,
0.06171058490872383,
-0.9306432604789734,
-0.33072975277900696,
1.106299638748169,
0.3978395164012909,
0.7647125720977783,
0.1256682127714157,
0.6982256770133972,
-0.11538992077112198,
-0.20151250064373016,
-0.8587081432342529,
0.4255967140197754,
0.31675276160240173,
-0.8161459565162659,
-0.4609937369823456,
-0.3900928497314453,
-0.47199365496635437,
0.156599223613739,
-0.4187585115432739,
-0.707332968711853,
0.24406489729881287,
0.5623367428779602,
-0.9487846493721008,
0.7314974069595337,
-0.7179902195930481,
0.8836215138435364,
-0.5484938621520996,
-0.4570969045162201,
-0.3508857190608978,
-0.9659238457679749,
0.7348905801773071,
-0.13804146647453308,
0.4934699833393097,
0.0447545051574707,
0.24625079333782196,
0.6984454989433289,
-0.3680518567562103,
0.8016068339347839,
-0.1496935784816742,
0.18656884133815765,
0.5085622072219849,
0.30309316515922546,
0.7271076440811157,
0.13306519389152527,
0.12030214816331863,
0.1436179131269455,
-0.22203226387500763,
-0.029119810089468956,
-0.6451758146286011,
0.41150155663490295,
-0.6814600229263306,
-0.6092700958251953,
-0.38057419657707214,
-0.3938383162021637,
-0.6219891309738159,
0.18746936321258545,
0.018042322248220444,
0.5466589331626892,
-0.12275633215904236,
0.020220475271344185,
0.5749040842056274,
-0.4917496144771576,
0.6077485084533691,
0.28967708349227905,
-0.10449354350566864,
-0.40191128849983215,
0.7303328514099121,
0.09717841446399689,
0.527066707611084,
0.3245551884174347,
0.20853134989738464,
-0.2874777913093567,
-0.5728319883346558,
-0.17538334429264069,
0.4217255413532257,
-1.0133408308029175,
-0.3273991346359253,
-0.9870219230651855,
-0.14298467338085175,
-0.3496103882789612,
-0.14054083824157715,
-0.40152430534362793,
-0.5695641040802002,
-0.13549894094467163,
-0.30069848895072937,
0.3885437548160553,
0.40516912937164307,
-0.37264829874038696,
0.30633509159088135,
-1.2756068706512451,
0.6407858729362488,
0.6021333932876587,
0.12120627611875534,
0.24513652920722961,
-0.30806678533554077,
-0.36566683650016785,
-0.10946662724018097,
-0.09005451202392578,
-0.8747481107711792,
-0.0018634065054357052,
0.10644027590751648,
0.400743693113327,
0.5109902620315552,
-0.27913451194763184,
0.7927638292312622,
-1.0267795324325562,
0.6288110613822937,
0.4272577166557312,
-0.8849853873252869,
0.4673963487148285,
-0.10085460543632507,
0.15405534207820892,
0.7510113716125488,
0.7169798016548157,
-0.846316933631897,
-0.22576095163822174,
-0.4954310953617096,
-0.5649347305297852,
0.658677875995636,
-0.016933461651206017,
-0.19067740440368652,
-0.13920027017593384,
0.3175906240940094,
0.13503055274486542,
0.36392587423324585,
-0.33938345313072205,
-0.431957483291626,
0.08742392808198929,
0.19947226345539093,
-0.08538324385881424,
-0.6923913955688477,
-0.3009173572063446,
-0.422428697347641,
0.7707836627960205,
0.014265364967286587,
0.010800197720527649,
-0.05257860943675041,
-0.3113856315612793,
0.1800527423620224,
0.6303187012672424,
0.7242273092269897,
0.7141175866127014,
-0.32421931624412537,
0.3188537657260895,
0.07758905738592148,
-0.2605839967727661,
0.16971471905708313,
-0.48595550656318665,
-0.429586261510849,
0.18233267962932587,
0.5858937501907349,
0.9794387817382812,
0.23411156237125397,
-0.3615437150001526,
0.4869334399700165,
0.0619635134935379,
0.059959348291158676,
0.11252066493034363,
-0.009930921718478203,
0.3482562303543091,
0.022719116881489754,
0.07552983611822128,
0.6803767681121826,
0.04999838396906853,
-0.71971195936203,
0.12829123437404633,
0.4296897053718567,
0.09286870062351227,
-0.4721522927284241,
0.35180166363716125,
0.11166069656610489,
-0.10642809420824051,
0.7370172739028931,
0.0016687983879819512,
-0.8121179938316345,
0.2828398048877716,
0.29056745767593384,
0.7561461329460144,
0.11204774677753448,
0.13281503319740295,
0.5293241143226624,
0.5801108479499817,
0.0946473702788353,
-0.22043414413928986,
0.15165190398693085,
-0.7932714223861694,
-0.5916087031364441,
-0.37683922052383423,
-0.32652345299720764,
0.11698079109191895,
-0.19852802157402039,
0.5653859972953796,
-0.3459715247154236,
-0.2307068258523941,
0.11373671889305115,
-0.360164999961853,
-0.8250578045845032,
0.18198177218437195,
0.12128417193889618,
1.0332847833633423,
-0.829321563243866,
1.01466965675354,
0.2710917592048645,
-0.42312949895858765,
-0.9705334901809692,
0.08566656708717346,
0.27051952481269836,
-0.5778513550758362,
0.7330612540245056,
-0.18295221030712128,
-0.24488049745559692,
-0.22719183564186096,
-0.4059605896472931,
-0.9993698596954346,
0.7993327379226685,
0.4650595188140869,
-0.7327775955200195,
-0.4596047103404999,
0.2861156761646271,
0.11109529435634613,
0.13795465230941772,
0.3739623427391052,
0.8814237117767334,
0.6027830839157104,
0.17613163590431213,
-0.8411928415298462,
0.06664558500051498,
0.3613370954990387,
-0.3719700574874878,
0.05490020290017128,
-0.5319584608078003,
0.761875569820404,
-0.6836471557617188,
0.03094138763844967,
-0.3603564202785492,
0.440468430519104,
0.41056668758392334,
-0.0202749315649271,
0.6850384473800659,
0.4741603434085846,
0.8002052903175354,
0.20971660315990448,
0.7831578254699707,
-0.22073477506637573,
0.1736614853143692,
1.4320173263549805,
-0.11268453299999237,
0.6389861106872559,
0.8148115277290344,
0.014044757932424545,
0.3832826018333435,
0.2948338985443115,
0.39835476875305176,
0.6880121231079102,
-0.023899320513010025,
-0.24930697679519653,
-0.285338819026947,
0.19502398371696472,
-0.3245326280593872,
0.4514646828174591,
0.36024823784828186,
-0.0544409453868866,
-0.32168346643447876,
0.11854405701160431,
0.4128715395927429,
-0.36750954389572144,
-0.2475772500038147,
0.7112271189689636,
0.14172038435935974,
-0.7606672644615173,
0.3837575912475586,
0.09434220939874649,
0.6229444742202759,
-0.7926338911056519,
-0.07905544340610504,
-0.04209784045815468,
-0.3196164071559906,
-0.03962697088718414,
-0.743035614490509,
0.35378748178482056,
0.12038619071245193,
-0.05278538167476654,
-0.09236764907836914,
0.8787680864334106,
-0.5168978571891785,
-0.31027519702911377,
0.2995217740535736,
0.5015949606895447,
-0.05132511258125305,
-0.18573924899101257,
-0.5285375714302063,
0.07772813737392426,
-0.07711636275053024,
-0.18841366469860077,
0.2227105349302292,
0.7000938057899475,
0.10556753724813461,
0.5339999794960022,
0.630579948425293,
0.34274375438690186,
0.4691149890422821,
0.0341535359621048,
0.9072903990745544,
-0.9038403630256653,
-0.3539303243160248,
-1.004341721534729,
0.4573098123073578,
0.0981745794415474,
-0.06833458691835403,
0.5978788137435913,
0.5393878221511841,
0.589293360710144,
-0.29719021916389465,
0.9547107815742493,
0.027649978175759315,
0.5927967429161072,
-0.8607452511787415,
0.7589976191520691,
-0.3235327899456024,
0.08796975016593933,
-0.3794245421886444,
-0.6864104866981506,
-0.17061012983322144,
-0.014710967428982258,
-0.4151892364025116,
-0.13061684370040894,
1.0911149978637695,
0.6526980996131897,
-0.07663389295339584,
-0.279344379901886,
0.44835180044174194,
0.3770180344581604,
0.42588910460472107,
0.5283979177474976,
0.9031010866165161,
-0.12457655370235443,
0.6480715870857239,
-0.4008455276489258,
-0.017623212188482285,
-0.21156999468803406,
-0.9985154867172241,
-0.9178609251976013,
-0.11681205779314041,
-0.3299979865550995,
-0.13130024075508118,
-0.016088949516415596,
0.918177604675293,
0.21821878850460052,
-0.5509598851203918,
0.17866629362106323,
0.23864522576332092,
0.7013769745826721,
0.054595593363046646,
-0.07864818722009659,
0.7181520462036133,
-0.5184773206710815,
-0.29560887813568115,
0.6176674365997314,
0.4340752363204956,
-0.0240327175706625,
0.12188194692134857,
0.03094489872455597,
-0.5768477320671082,
0.06337844580411911,
0.6283506155014038,
0.33871975541114807,
-0.592522144317627,
-0.7615016102790833,
-0.04045954346656799,
0.033072154968976974,
0.08851556479930878,
1.0467712879180908,
-0.5474382638931274,
0.3266684412956238,
0.540719747543335,
0.7682562470436096,
0.13249924778938293,
-0.06064930930733681,
0.24380484223365784,
-0.919031023979187,
0.24479301273822784,
0.13174182176589966,
0.5911591649055481,
0.23801858723163605,
-0.2771145701408386,
0.04745541512966156,
0.3843965530395508,
-0.4094887971878052,
-0.49821364879608154,
0.06308505684137344,
-0.8525192141532898,
-0.20825421810150146,
1.2002489566802979,
-0.16415159404277802,
-0.3071264326572418,
-0.019900387153029442,
-0.2890266180038452,
0.34742334485054016,
0.0750972107052803,
0.4960109293460846,
0.7798888087272644,
-0.11750327795743942,
0.20370706915855408,
-0.5613860487937927,
0.7821873426437378,
0.292786568403244,
-0.7952437996864319,
0.022604912519454956,
0.6710416078567505,
0.5406508445739746,
0.3228861391544342,
0.8138927221298218,
0.016562141478061676,
0.23292501270771027,
-0.13207751512527466,
0.08411522954702377,
-0.12411441653966904,
-0.9628068208694458,
-0.10582020878791809,
0.24815019965171814,
0.38519343733787537,
-0.32701975107192993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11896v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11896v2 | SIBO: A Simple Booster for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2024-02-19T07:22:29 | 2024-06-01T07:13:15 | Zhihao Wen, Jie Zhang, Yuan Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning all parameters of large language models (LLMs) necessitates
substantial computational power and extended time. Latest advancements in
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques, such as Adapter tuning and
LoRA, allow for adjustments to only a minor fraction of the parameters of these
LLMs. Concurrently, it has been noted that the issue of over-smoothing
diminishes the effectiveness of these Transformer-based LLMs, resulting in
suboptimal performances in downstream tasks. In this paper, we present SIBO,
which is a SImple BOoster to enhance PEFT, by injecting an initial residual.
SIBO is straightforward and readily extensible to a range of state-of-the-art
PEFT techniques to alleviate over-smoothing and enhance performance. Extensive
experiments on 22 benchmark datasets demonstrate that SIBO significantly
enhances the performance of various strong baselines, achieving up to 15.7% and
23.5% improvement over existing PEFT methods on the arithmetic and commonsense
reasoning tasks, respectively. | [
-0.6015099287033081,
-1.0651686191558838,
0.46129488945007324,
0.21194806694984436,
-0.3575024902820587,
0.08700103312730789,
-0.34843727946281433,
-0.2384507805109024,
0.14315684139728546,
0.6894016861915588,
-0.28442856669425964,
-0.17428545653820038,
-0.7078655362129211,
-0.21870706975460052,
-0.20043575763702393,
1.0297163724899292,
0.4326118230819702,
-0.28614407777786255,
0.11545347422361374,
0.1905614286661148,
-0.3440927565097809,
0.012017782777547836,
-0.8751601576805115,
-0.486979216337204,
0.3955923318862915,
0.5630797147750854,
0.730735182762146,
0.45398446917533875,
0.2566652297973633,
0.25340214371681213,
-0.34259849786758423,
0.5670265555381775,
-0.8271225094795227,
-0.05507920682430267,
-0.26905718445777893,
-0.31052976846694946,
-0.7724783420562744,
-0.3578369617462158,
0.8789107203483582,
0.8202758431434631,
-0.03796426206827164,
0.33928266167640686,
0.23984713852405548,
0.8008078932762146,
-0.8481058478355408,
0.08783160150051117,
-0.9832276105880737,
-0.6965385675430298,
-0.24055859446525574,
-0.44006940722465515,
-0.5324060916900635,
-0.39546847343444824,
-0.41042813658714294,
-0.33787739276885986,
-0.05503605678677559,
0.06048394367098808,
1.00851309299469,
0.5705510377883911,
-0.4549008309841156,
0.17891249060630798,
-0.6041775941848755,
0.729867696762085,
-0.9073643088340759,
0.3081124722957611,
0.26694047451019287,
0.14642438292503357,
-0.5837616920471191,
-0.6339473724365234,
-0.2554905116558075,
-0.1876288652420044,
-0.22223632037639618,
-0.07124673575162888,
-0.0514366552233696,
0.17210566997528076,
0.4933030903339386,
0.3007829189300537,
-0.06240883097052574,
0.3398963212966919,
-0.5952032804489136,
-0.23860450088977814,
0.45946747064590454,
0.03825584426522255,
-0.060927700251340866,
0.07061465829610825,
-0.29550546407699585,
0.4039585292339325,
-1.100256085395813,
0.3481695353984833,
0.5638676285743713,
0.5846864581108093,
0.29992255568504333,
0.22913292050361633,
-0.48077717423439026,
0.9213740825653076,
0.2505244016647339,
-0.2797437012195587,
0.1267024725675583,
-0.19048823416233063,
-0.20073804259300232,
-0.15842291712760925,
0.45311522483825684,
0.1826651692390442,
0.07498662173748016,
-0.07795078307390213,
-0.1850622594356537,
-0.12024042755365372,
0.10592090338468552,
-1.1217917203903198,
-0.17241857945919037,
0.0332689993083477,
-0.14879293739795685,
-0.1986032873392105,
-0.12238758057355881,
-0.6134202480316162,
-0.23167435824871063,
-0.3877294063568115,
0.5787185430526733,
-0.47606414556503296,
-0.04889824986457825,
0.07759001851081848,
-0.03550093621015549,
0.37161731719970703,
0.3068801164627075,
-0.882752001285553,
0.33816415071487427,
0.8641744256019592,
0.6269003748893738,
-0.029732324182987213,
-0.20998001098632812,
-1.160293459892273,
0.2268494963645935,
-0.4364519417285919,
0.9865177869796753,
-0.7121568918228149,
-0.20436991751194,
-0.37069499492645264,
0.15720029175281525,
0.16799482703208923,
-0.5521613359451294,
0.7498201727867126,
-0.21776936948299408,
-0.18558178842067719,
-0.2873663604259491,
-0.35482457280158997,
-0.014478407800197601,
-0.11540058255195618,
-0.4468478560447693,
1.3102481365203857,
0.1851796805858612,
0.013285266235470772,
0.5684689283370972,
-0.4405317008495331,
-0.8282786011695862,
0.19768252968788147,
-0.01357831247150898,
-0.25960105657577515,
0.33889326453208923,
0.47607067227363586,
0.4949198067188263,
-0.48004570603370667,
0.354559987783432,
-0.41749903559684753,
-1.0377873182296753,
-0.11248292773962021,
-0.5619262456893921,
0.5153833031654358,
0.10379212349653244,
-0.20425252616405487,
-0.22019891440868378,
-0.9351751208305359,
0.18997745215892792,
-0.2705394923686981,
-0.32726341485977173,
-0.34978771209716797,
-0.04514148086309433,
-0.5144959092140198,
-0.11391877382993698,
0.23059533536434174,
-0.6121526956558228,
0.4786219894886017,
-0.6904284954071045,
0.42626866698265076,
0.8448160886764526,
-0.1106736809015274,
0.5804193615913391,
-0.09858526289463043,
0.2887169420719147,
-0.1818455159664154,
0.04089226946234703,
-0.467023104429245,
-0.4888020157814026,
-0.7045038938522339,
-0.7638285160064697,
0.3613625466823578,
0.12546607851982117,
-0.3997189998626709,
0.5787330269813538,
-0.2777446508407593,
-0.6198570132255554,
-0.7735201716423035,
0.6004125475883484,
0.18942870199680328,
0.7312839031219482,
0.39890992641448975,
0.12255609780550003,
0.003169562201946974,
-1.045647144317627,
-0.3920968770980835,
0.006412663497030735,
-0.09044759720563889,
0.2950480878353119,
0.006872702389955521,
-0.17080363631248474,
0.8296064734458923,
-0.7025014162063599,
-0.4012172222137451,
-0.2157663106918335,
0.26211512088775635,
0.44521012902259827,
0.42829960584640503,
0.6292612552642822,
-0.5141290426254272,
-0.5601797699928284,
0.09522715210914612,
0.0991632416844368,
-0.6852662563323975,
-0.212527796626091,
-0.24317793548107147,
0.23961926996707916,
0.7007949948310852,
-0.22309888899326324,
0.2153693437576294,
0.4359000027179718,
-0.20378848910331726,
0.22667354345321655,
-0.3249056935310364,
0.1449093520641327,
-0.7831212878227234,
0.2418356090784073,
-0.30203473567962646,
-0.3497694134712219,
-0.38710248470306396,
-0.14859426021575928,
0.3602724075317383,
-0.026768404990434647,
-0.3764340877532959,
0.6843136548995972,
-0.4028247594833374,
0.24706025421619415,
-0.7989131808280945,
0.23881247639656067,
0.04335641860961914,
0.4687853455543518,
-0.29500612616539,
0.9275045990943909,
0.5562692880630493,
-0.7982418537139893,
0.211107537150383,
-0.24884971976280212,
-0.16387197375297546,
0.3462517261505127,
-0.6819966435432434,
-0.08659135550260544,
-0.373212605714798,
0.23022624850273132,
-1.2146728038787842,
-0.08648811280727386,
-0.032414596527814865,
-0.15504656732082367,
0.5012664198875427,
-0.17783929407596588,
-0.32140836119651794,
-0.3632770776748657,
-0.4036450982093811,
0.011439665220677853,
0.8324679136276245,
-0.6757836937904358,
0.8808397054672241,
0.2588016986846924,
-0.2613196074962616,
-0.5023465156555176,
-0.4415413439273834,
-0.14635708928108215,
-0.18786747753620148,
-0.29778456687927246,
0.4346424341201782,
0.1182158812880516,
0.18857043981552124,
-0.2488536238670349,
-0.2924722135066986,
0.17079836130142212,
0.34104663133621216,
0.15036438405513763,
0.10490666329860687,
-0.1538236439228058,
0.1161590963602066,
0.7400182485580444,
-0.43646979331970215,
-0.3154316842556,
0.08552168309688568,
0.45928704738616943,
-0.4048472046852112,
-0.21813653409481049,
-0.14911994338035583,
0.1349002718925476,
0.480218768119812,
-0.054964032024145126,
0.7347975969314575,
0.6392179727554321,
-0.22532403469085693,
-0.4379252791404724,
-0.7740181088447571,
-0.32189297676086426,
-0.5786808729171753,
0.4033132493495941,
-0.6669074296951294,
-0.6203995943069458,
0.3641398847103119,
-0.6958052515983582,
0.1254340559244156,
0.24964076280593872,
0.4937269389629364,
-0.09167268127202988,
0.9606503248214722,
0.7152069807052612,
-0.048050470650196075,
0.5877707004547119,
-0.016583973541855812,
0.44991129636764526,
-0.8558240532875061,
0.02443626895546913,
-0.5336869955062866,
-0.49954354763031006,
-0.48877257108688354,
-0.07734062522649765,
0.18255029618740082,
0.4959341883659363,
-0.30506637692451477,
0.6523630023002625,
-0.2604213356971741,
0.7013868093490601,
0.46451568603515625,
0.2114000767469406,
0.4249430000782013,
-0.20038340985774994,
0.2196512073278427,
0.077391617000103,
-0.5884736180305481,
-0.5369001030921936,
0.7761203050613403,
0.1930878609418869,
1.12073814868927,
-0.170155331492424,
0.46918824315071106,
0.07589675486087799,
0.24587330222129822,
-0.7049874663352966,
0.6811245679855347,
-0.4496632516384125,
-0.5339984893798828,
-0.3139990568161011,
-0.18348243832588196,
-0.6048282980918884,
0.24747738242149353,
-0.16538478434085846,
-1.0255688428878784,
0.3284326195716858,
0.5678369998931885,
-0.6607019901275635,
0.11788369715213776,
-0.9629167318344116,
0.6118149161338806,
-0.25704264640808105,
-0.550251841545105,
-0.3116229772567749,
-0.5140454769134521,
0.11657477915287018,
-0.462568074464798,
-0.009896991774439812,
-0.43811261653900146,
-0.24313004314899445,
0.3006914258003235,
-0.2516424357891083,
0.6478396654129028,
-0.09084009379148483,
-0.16769391298294067,
0.09004300832748413,
-0.005513294134289026,
0.7405611872673035,
0.1782800704240799,
-0.3956601321697235,
0.04155435413122177,
0.07258515805006027,
-0.5881158113479614,
-0.8889814615249634,
1.025312900543213,
-0.37016817927360535,
-0.6768113374710083,
-0.027095787227153778,
-0.47045931220054626,
-0.555469274520874,
0.2884475886821747,
0.07440418004989624,
0.421050488948822,
0.16877292096614838,
0.8514583706855774,
0.3335314393043518,
-0.2949657142162323,
0.30141332745552063,
0.7106783390045166,
-0.1891801655292511,
-0.19291310012340546,
0.9682771563529968,
0.1589280366897583,
0.6219806671142578,
0.31717395782470703,
0.28594034910202026,
-0.2236601859331131,
-0.2015829235315323,
-0.33652248978614807,
0.4024275541305542,
-0.45763278007507324,
-0.4259544312953949,
-0.4209578335285187,
-0.11889155209064484,
-0.4610982835292816,
-0.37771695852279663,
-0.6196696758270264,
-0.44536593556404114,
-0.0953812301158905,
0.016376471146941185,
0.3069082200527191,
0.18031302094459534,
0.06902498006820679,
0.7860507369041443,
-0.547642171382904,
0.5686157941818237,
0.05152647942304611,
0.5437127351760864,
-0.3318907618522644,
-0.8517717719078064,
-0.2503281533718109,
0.15811195969581604,
-0.4428163468837738,
-0.5090062618255615,
0.1916799545288086,
0.57615065574646,
0.6737619638442993,
0.6070467233657837,
0.13357335329055786,
1.287917137145996,
-0.340443879365921,
0.7107024192810059,
-0.12713433802127838,
-0.9345116019248962,
0.6078482270240784,
-0.1309977024793625,
0.2016783356666565,
0.6292617917060852,
0.20217415690422058,
0.17855791747570038,
-0.48874300718307495,
-0.3954514265060425,
-1.1471909284591675,
0.6888089776039124,
-0.07620041817426682,
0.2699339687824249,
0.1556369811296463,
0.49089062213897705,
0.33192747831344604,
0.23876409232616425,
-0.5241198539733887,
-0.14011260867118835,
0.24689850211143494,
0.07479602843523026,
-0.15297088027000427,
-0.26516690850257874,
0.11547234654426575,
-0.4599186182022095,
1.076686978340149,
-0.5772332549095154,
-0.031472574919462204,
-0.3310704827308655,
-0.08610452711582184,
-0.14537012577056885,
0.36164626479148865,
0.30554863810539246,
0.5839991569519043,
-0.31226813793182373,
0.03173809498548508,
0.5448117256164551,
-0.17544957995414734,
-0.08730775117874146,
0.0959683433175087,
-0.3922000229358673,
-0.21384382247924805,
-0.09688202291727066,
0.9184793829917908,
0.41632556915283203,
-0.5842508673667908,
0.165366068482399,
0.4186384081840515,
0.1696912795305252,
0.2591663599014282,
0.44853147864341736,
0.06161206215620041,
0.230849489569664,
0.5233539342880249,
-0.011734222993254662,
0.22024379670619965,
-0.6253796219825745,
0.032375726848840714,
0.5620947480201721,
0.015906529501080513,
0.03416617587208748,
0.45141246914863586,
0.18865817785263062,
-0.26102226972579956,
0.2195362001657486,
0.0955812856554985,
-0.20560874044895172,
0.4778684079647064,
0.7890000939369202,
0.5576553344726562,
0.0416729561984539,
-0.10582099109888077,
0.3240128755569458,
0.4430445432662964,
-0.004577531013637781,
0.14289337396621704,
-0.18423862755298615,
-0.3690013587474823,
-0.6271538138389587,
-0.833250880241394,
-0.21412868797779083,
0.2008507400751114,
-0.648617684841156,
0.7191696763038635,
-0.2477727085351944,
-0.320782870054245,
-0.04559265449643135,
-0.09758301079273224,
-0.3689160943031311,
0.1562880128622055,
0.04426576942205429,
0.9223830103874207,
-0.6448978781700134,
0.9489811062812805,
0.5352358818054199,
-0.21887217462062836,
-0.7974993586540222,
0.06392597407102585,
-0.5014936923980713,
-0.75844806432724,
0.5166191458702087,
0.06296766549348831,
-0.46788638830184937,
0.11649607867002487,
-0.5176631212234497,
-0.8954212069511414,
0.9109238982200623,
0.9008749723434448,
-0.7387231588363647,
-0.0231636893004179,
0.07527211308479309,
0.6251289248466492,
0.0061937603168189526,
0.4718751013278961,
0.935046911239624,
0.4438139498233795,
0.02611793391406536,
-0.8247491121292114,
0.13471774756908417,
-0.015266776084899902,
0.04404595121741295,
0.5297821760177612,
-0.9417445063591003,
0.4174448847770691,
-0.14113128185272217,
0.16205374896526337,
0.16315527260303497,
0.7075694799423218,
0.1282694786787033,
0.03611217439174652,
0.522205114364624,
0.1608455628156662,
0.8202144503593445,
-0.3912455439567566,
0.8117124438285828,
-0.5969784259796143,
0.3806052803993225,
1.139053225517273,
-0.17142513394355774,
0.8610776662826538,
0.6451414823532104,
-0.09697537869215012,
0.3134547173976898,
0.18033823370933533,
0.09360899776220322,
0.48467400670051575,
-0.1000918373465538,
-0.036144956946372986,
-0.6604090332984924,
0.008209120482206345,
-0.4757534861564636,
0.28054389357566833,
0.5153114795684814,
-0.2053881585597992,
-0.3349422216415405,
0.0921984538435936,
-0.12369345873594284,
-0.002285013208165765,
-0.4194798767566681,
0.6020998954772949,
0.25217488408088684,
-0.8643662929534912,
0.6181354522705078,
-0.08139938861131668,
0.6974016427993774,
-0.8253509402275085,
0.01987624168395996,
-0.38584521412849426,
0.5437875986099243,
-0.19879022240638733,
-0.7415195107460022,
0.3090105652809143,
-0.2021787017583847,
-0.019036058336496353,
-0.29770609736442566,
0.9317977428436279,
-0.37576812505722046,
-0.40253573656082153,
0.3914799094200134,
0.12042660266160965,
0.035167962312698364,
-0.08041646331548691,
-0.44223734736442566,
-0.003536681644618511,
-0.11299711465835571,
-0.3878956437110901,
0.25087136030197144,
0.309230238199234,
0.06293494254350662,
0.8968281745910645,
0.704801082611084,
0.4444608688354492,
0.043490950018167496,
0.11241559684276581,
0.9624638557434082,
-0.5507950782775879,
-0.4337921142578125,
-0.9114957451820374,
0.5254620313644409,
-0.11593514680862427,
-0.23567800223827362,
0.7436853647232056,
0.5638116598129272,
0.567741334438324,
0.09539178013801575,
0.4359149932861328,
-0.03292049467563629,
0.6451576352119446,
-0.4240654706954956,
0.5073879957199097,
-0.9358375668525696,
0.35020121932029724,
-0.4383138120174408,
-0.9580837488174438,
-0.1720716655254364,
0.4558761715888977,
-0.3958059847354889,
-0.0959329754114151,
0.45994871854782104,
1.0469586849212646,
-0.20625171065330505,
-0.16152460873126984,
0.497230589389801,
0.3558283746242523,
0.4897277057170868,
0.3997316062450409,
0.4482090175151825,
-0.5702195763587952,
0.6319762468338013,
-0.13463445007801056,
-0.3592697083950043,
-0.34000343084335327,
-1.0793706178665161,
-0.6651401519775391,
-0.1761421114206314,
-0.2194073647260666,
-0.23186136782169342,
0.20375007390975952,
0.8204095363616943,
0.7235369682312012,
-0.9054615497589111,
0.09306231141090393,
0.021715963259339333,
-0.02000759355723858,
-0.25190556049346924,
-0.19150909781455994,
0.062368251383304596,
-0.6333077549934387,
-1.0359567403793335,
0.49247780442237854,
0.4724910259246826,
-0.32776081562042236,
0.04756774753332138,
-0.0028224156703799963,
0.023718377575278282,
0.3848293125629425,
0.7010346055030823,
0.3580195903778076,
-0.7705226540565491,
-0.1446898877620697,
-0.019170131534337997,
0.03802435100078583,
-0.006761756259948015,
0.524196445941925,
-1.1060954332351685,
0.33176103234291077,
0.6183013916015625,
0.7698671817779541,
0.6037877798080444,
0.4942121207714081,
0.5886549949645996,
-0.6234296560287476,
0.22163674235343933,
-0.027859952300786972,
0.5624750256538391,
-0.10406892746686935,
-0.40633222460746765,
0.38825157284736633,
0.022953752428293228,
-0.5582267045974731,
-1.0777322053909302,
-0.01663648523390293,
-1.0577577352523804,
-0.29275405406951904,
1.314363718032837,
0.15196223556995392,
-0.036689210683107376,
0.21121487021446228,
-0.7441535592079163,
0.05658653378486633,
-0.6346576809883118,
0.6166446805000305,
0.5214120745658875,
-0.01833280175924301,
0.12655745446681976,
-0.21229298412799835,
0.277810275554657,
0.6547901034355164,
-0.7657788991928101,
0.011206071823835373,
0.35212981700897217,
0.3481025695800781,
0.05061180889606476,
0.5809550285339355,
-0.06889785826206207,
0.17371515929698944,
-0.22681491076946259,
-0.49274468421936035,
-0.3263005316257477,
-0.5131193399429321,
-0.12442239373922348,
0.2898651361465454,
0.04887709394097328,
0.02750176191329956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11895v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11895v3 | Bridging or Breaking: Impact of Intergroup Interactions on Religious Polarization | 2024-02-19T07:21:09 | 2024-03-10T05:38:20 | Rochana Chaturvedi, Sugat Chaturvedi, Elena Zheleva | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | While exposure to diverse viewpoints may reduce polarization, it can also
have a backfire effect and exacerbate polarization when the discussion is
adversarial. Here, we examine the question whether intergroup interactions
around important events affect polarization between majority and minority
groups in social networks. We compile data on the religious identity of nearly
700,000 Indian Twitter users engaging in COVID-19-related discourse during
2020. We introduce a new measure for an individual's group conformity based on
contextualized embeddings of tweet text, which helps us assess polarization
between religious groups. We then use a meta-learning framework to examine
heterogeneous treatment effects of intergroup interactions on an individual's
group conformity in the light of communal, political, and socio-economic
events. We find that for political and social events, intergroup interactions
reduce polarization. This decline is weaker for individuals at the extreme who
already exhibit high conformity to their group. In contrast, during communal
events, intergroup interactions can increase group conformity. Finally, we
decompose the differential effects across religious groups in terms of emotions
and topics of discussion. The results show that the dynamics of religious
polarization are sensitive to the context and have important implications for
understanding the role of intergroup interactions. | [
-0.5923499464988708,
-0.7870791554450989,
-0.167583629488945,
0.5209881663322449,
-0.36845195293426514,
0.30853036046028137,
-0.3025391399860382,
-0.35238680243492126,
0.5214970111846924,
-0.14643627405166626,
-0.4379618465900421,
-0.006792123429477215,
-0.8537455201148987,
-0.005797258578240871,
-0.33192938566207886,
1.1481646299362183,
0.29196128249168396,
-0.04960843548178673,
0.019450321793556213,
-0.42695385217666626,
0.030161870643496513,
-0.4307597875595093,
-0.616293728351593,
-0.46912479400634766,
0.65447998046875,
0.11372987926006317,
0.8117438554763794,
0.2132817953824997,
0.5987290143966675,
0.2826157808303833,
-0.33978521823883057,
-0.46336573362350464,
-0.8098437190055847,
0.13263948261737823,
-0.5343134999275208,
-0.3163772523403168,
-0.0015723280375823379,
0.4488079249858856,
0.6449535489082336,
0.8130100965499878,
-0.3104105591773987,
0.4783148169517517,
0.2755192816257477,
0.48889288306236267,
-0.19449545443058014,
0.05131268501281738,
-0.7734408974647522,
0.12262241542339325,
-0.37723681330680847,
-0.3792315721511841,
0.04783901199698448,
-0.5643826127052307,
0.3327711820602417,
-0.33101513981819153,
0.5143349170684814,
0.03929070010781288,
0.8543968200683594,
0.17214365303516388,
-0.6688491106033325,
-0.11529684066772461,
-0.4365459680557251,
0.8532357811927795,
-0.32938969135284424,
0.23328402638435364,
0.39541879296302795,
-0.009917103685438633,
0.07569536566734314,
-0.29494357109069824,
-0.4234558343887329,
0.6925128698348999,
0.14773494005203247,
0.2094133496284485,
-0.1754051297903061,
0.10980062186717987,
0.3436562120914459,
0.6622598171234131,
-0.15275007486343384,
-0.2818205952644348,
-0.9517317414283752,
0.2803303897380829,
0.4464655816555023,
0.12629356980323792,
0.9481973648071289,
-0.1124936118721962,
-0.341449111700058,
0.07552670687437057,
-0.5661333799362183,
0.42528876662254333,
0.3745364248752594,
0.15340539813041687,
-0.3393200635910034,
0.3637310862541199,
0.42904749512672424,
0.24522419273853302,
0.5710728168487549,
0.01801949180662632,
-0.22132232785224915,
-0.5630624890327454,
-0.28647544980049133,
0.07698870450258255,
0.4559834599494934,
0.8191908597946167,
0.0975654199719429,
-0.15316030383110046,
0.5090693235397339,
-0.08933036774396896,
-0.01251270342618227,
-1.0363798141479492,
0.0025852618273347616,
-0.20566633343696594,
-0.9835498332977295,
-0.10713797062635422,
0.36594706773757935,
-0.8657962679862976,
-0.6494376063346863,
-0.14429709315299988,
-0.11125974357128143,
-0.06983564049005508,
-0.5579748153686523,
-0.1520250290632248,
-0.5445020198822021,
0.6185449957847595,
0.48394107818603516,
-1.020559549331665,
0.17218178510665894,
0.7627188563346863,
0.9395771026611328,
-0.10557140409946442,
-0.13066360354423523,
-0.5566374063491821,
0.2816942632198334,
-0.01594715192914009,
0.30975449085235596,
-0.9124688506126404,
-0.5994081497192383,
-0.025051049888134003,
0.01441609114408493,
-0.13035628199577332,
-0.5526765584945679,
0.12319294363260269,
-0.6763392686843872,
0.08510968089103699,
-1.0591486692428589,
-0.2811982333660126,
-0.2722114622592926,
0.18022872507572174,
-0.4586545526981354,
0.03202151507139206,
-0.04929651319980621,
-0.8291063904762268,
0.6715377569198608,
-0.3969925045967102,
-0.5598348379135132,
0.3097551465034485,
-0.5516095161437988,
-0.5080380439758301,
0.34226080775260925,
-0.3189960718154907,
0.15723060071468353,
-0.47289547324180603,
0.17134329676628113,
-0.9460763931274414,
-0.34338662028312683,
-0.039407189935445786,
0.003927780780941248,
1.0985913276672363,
-0.0037135365419089794,
-0.4383079707622528,
-0.10385255515575409,
-0.029422463849186897,
-0.28118544816970825,
0.0005946357268840075,
-0.294198215007782,
-0.6306602358818054,
0.11912395060062408,
-0.0997186079621315,
0.3517485558986664,
-0.34619516134262085,
-0.574612557888031,
0.3235551714897156,
-0.3225991427898407,
0.2073127180337906,
0.9553254842758179,
0.45672667026519775,
0.5924244523048401,
-0.09136038273572922,
0.541073203086853,
0.10080940276384354,
0.6058406829833984,
0.3820788264274597,
-0.7252287864685059,
-0.45161107182502747,
0.16438767313957214,
-0.3306112587451935,
0.4247114956378937,
-0.5312334895133972,
-0.004688756074756384,
0.01958565041422844,
-0.1873903125524521,
-0.17642828822135925,
0.2524643540382385,
0.35538503527641296,
0.23740147054195404,
0.36199843883514404,
-0.40451958775520325,
-0.4488621950149536,
-0.8187288641929626,
-0.9147250056266785,
-0.4734096825122833,
0.31404605507850647,
0.08123127371072769,
0.3350924551486969,
-0.1462341845035553,
0.5954527854919434,
-0.3133324384689331,
-0.29287979006767273,
-0.05935535579919815,
0.6554258465766907,
0.14753401279449463,
0.20637103915214539,
0.4210222065448761,
-1.1018295288085938,
-1.0649195909500122,
0.30815041065216064,
-0.625826358795166,
-0.27299848198890686,
-0.16028690338134766,
0.11139361560344696,
-0.007244080305099487,
0.41298872232437134,
0.21486292779445648,
1.0865819454193115,
0.7750078439712524,
-0.6937898993492126,
-0.014582762494683266,
0.5485999584197998,
0.45918262004852295,
-1.1642488241195679,
-0.34039783477783203,
0.08099398016929626,
0.42037874460220337,
-0.7352207899093628,
-0.43687817454338074,
-0.31467655301094055,
0.1566781997680664,
-0.25347429513931274,
0.24160924553871155,
-0.2942412197589874,
-0.018384242430329323,
-0.134975403547287,
-0.42225417494773865,
-0.08695995062589645,
0.05846298858523369,
-0.12774012982845306,
0.8206896185874939,
0.46299654245376587,
-0.24427387118339539,
-0.03114631585776806,
0.6425442099571228,
-0.13054506480693817,
0.5378822684288025,
-0.49512967467308044,
-0.1323709785938263,
-0.24840423464775085,
0.25597837567329407,
-0.7714028358459473,
-0.2773834466934204,
0.2787523567676544,
-0.3132370710372925,
-0.05863025039434433,
-0.3119393587112427,
-0.03741079196333885,
-0.05032998323440552,
-0.3087303936481476,
0.8976935744285583,
0.30250105261802673,
-0.4651481807231903,
0.8136882781982422,
0.5253723859786987,
-0.1884741485118866,
-0.33601707220077515,
-0.9222043752670288,
0.16709479689598083,
-0.49209776520729065,
-0.833775520324707,
0.2824130058288574,
-0.09817218780517578,
-0.7463117241859436,
0.05989566817879677,
-0.202604278922081,
0.04691199213266373,
-0.08961547166109085,
0.7084857225418091,
-0.2374812811613083,
0.19717435538768768,
0.36064326763153076,
0.32273802161216736,
0.1960301399230957,
0.10119280964136124,
0.2823566496372223,
0.5298189520835876,
-0.9165750741958618,
-0.5508005619049072,
-0.5108202695846558,
0.9871450662612915,
0.40777790546417236,
-0.43067845702171326,
1.3449381589889526,
0.47944656014442444,
-0.09776818007230759,
0.33312517404556274,
-0.6019676327705383,
-0.19850587844848633,
-0.5008760094642639,
-0.07054601609706879,
-0.10392386466264725,
-0.9196596741676331,
0.8222188353538513,
-0.07405584305524826,
0.06516221910715103,
0.3209655284881592,
0.7741819620132446,
-0.21425692737102509,
0.6899785399436951,
0.5641539096832275,
0.2479933351278305,
0.711351752281189,
-0.007909639738500118,
0.5987575650215149,
-0.6387572288513184,
-0.3174053132534027,
-0.3251694440841675,
-0.40882956981658936,
-0.5633164048194885,
-0.3861347734928131,
0.7217288613319397,
0.1663036197423935,
0.08577680587768555,
-0.24859091639518738,
-0.2871515154838562,
0.5322268009185791,
0.16697745025157928,
-0.06725548952817917,
0.18121053278446198,
0.20318230986595154,
0.30527836084365845,
-0.3100818991661072,
-0.5125542283058167,
0.05533015727996826,
0.4967983365058899,
0.050388410687446594,
0.7414553165435791,
0.6458286046981812,
0.7680123448371887,
0.5125784873962402,
0.9105937480926514,
-0.2436894029378891,
0.31334900856018066,
-0.013391431421041489,
-0.6746078133583069,
-0.23458190262317657,
-0.34255388379096985,
-0.8754020929336548,
0.2555478811264038,
-0.13619568943977356,
-0.29743242263793945,
0.8061232566833496,
-0.0936676636338234,
-0.15742839872837067,
0.5469655394554138,
-0.5511402487754822,
0.3924122154712677,
0.08993129432201385,
-0.47107988595962524,
-0.3479335606098175,
-0.7438720464706421,
0.46747642755508423,
0.06603194028139114,
0.2634919583797455,
0.003735686419531703,
0.2808835804462433,
0.6795161962509155,
-0.31779739260673523,
1.154468297958374,
-0.16569100320339203,
0.021595994010567665,
0.29028400778770447,
-0.23556819558143616,
0.12714986503124237,
0.20762845873832703,
-0.06057523936033249,
0.30695557594299316,
-0.01909816265106201,
-0.7018378973007202,
-0.5505117177963257,
0.6482489705085754,
-0.961571455001831,
-0.9410565495491028,
-0.5499120950698853,
-0.3971312344074249,
0.14429686963558197,
-0.14867791533470154,
0.4349554181098938,
0.1349276453256607,
-0.12061380594968796,
0.42763853073120117,
0.9677773714065552,
-0.2043602168560028,
0.565807044506073,
0.17999713122844696,
-0.35899487137794495,
-0.882283091545105,
0.6331647038459778,
0.4679100811481476,
0.6289140582084656,
-0.29587122797966003,
0.3290035128593445,
0.377453088760376,
-0.10438361018896103,
0.02230747602880001,
0.39176011085510254,
-0.588133692741394,
0.09472207725048065,
-0.5768014788627625,
0.0614265501499176,
-0.5040146708488464,
-0.396889865398407,
-0.101155124604702,
-0.08730611950159073,
-0.11834591627120972,
-0.044992681592702866,
0.1117091253399849,
0.5829768776893616,
-0.2569654583930969,
0.28326961398124695,
-0.6590793132781982,
-0.07032608985900879,
0.6157742738723755,
0.33357715606689453,
0.0894555151462555,
-0.24327225983142853,
-0.2608646750450134,
-0.2600966691970825,
-0.2327311635017395,
-1.0584609508514404,
-0.265146404504776,
0.39299118518829346,
0.21080802381038666,
1.0540653467178345,
0.10120853781700134,
0.957244336605072,
-0.16075390577316284,
0.6033278703689575,
0.6833020448684692,
-0.9636864066123962,
0.3064728379249573,
-0.48788973689079285,
0.336629182100296,
0.653441846370697,
0.443651407957077,
-1.0200510025024414,
-0.5928891897201538,
-0.6822939515113831,
-0.6737393140792847,
0.3640415370464325,
0.292359858751297,
0.0750318169593811,
-0.2260875254869461,
0.40976619720458984,
0.2213207483291626,
0.07710917294025421,
-0.8001703023910522,
-0.403929740190506,
-0.3674376904964447,
0.3841134011745453,
0.3151618242263794,
-0.29273363947868347,
-0.8112999200820923,
-0.7159188985824585,
0.3619578778743744,
0.10007917135953903,
-0.1704539656639099,
0.18734148144721985,
0.3565573990345001,
-0.5902664065361023,
-0.017953095957636833,
0.5576701164245605,
0.5618564486503601,
-0.15101492404937744,
0.2640936076641083,
-0.010907268151640892,
-0.5562924146652222,
0.038832519203424454,
-0.15151488780975342,
-0.11771327257156372,
-0.21825216710567474,
0.5103732347488403,
0.44854629039764404,
-0.4156350791454315,
0.08569999039173126,
0.6204712390899658,
-0.41590067744255066,
-0.2590119540691376,
-0.10000163316726685,
-0.17303317785263062,
0.029692910611629486,
0.5804430842399597,
0.37782159447669983,
0.20078188180923462,
-0.0075881946831941605,
-1.0679363012313843,
0.09242440015077591,
0.6401715278625488,
-0.39818787574768066,
-0.6924400925636292,
0.42375242710113525,
0.2356434464454651,
-0.3231913447380066,
0.33726945519447327,
-0.09415623545646667,
-0.7775843143463135,
0.5181663036346436,
0.48471006751060486,
0.9064531922340393,
-0.619871973991394,
0.17143790423870087,
0.17755788564682007,
0.5782701373100281,
0.6600238680839539,
0.20697210729122162,
-0.3424606919288635,
-0.5143246054649353,
-0.44028064608573914,
-0.5848956108093262,
-0.4041229784488678,
-0.3322063386440277,
-0.8692950010299683,
-0.19782860577106476,
-0.4510001242160797,
-0.5021459460258484,
-0.4332210123538971,
-0.1255302131175995,
-0.41024890542030334,
0.006739434786140919,
0.22988736629486084,
0.381274938583374,
-1.462116003036499,
0.4272283911705017,
0.6321775913238525,
-0.6577828526496887,
-0.3558337390422821,
0.6482329964637756,
-0.10371866077184677,
-0.2506495714187622,
0.5976183414459229,
0.19159454107284546,
-0.20583973824977875,
-0.4457591772079468,
-0.5453211665153503,
-0.8698129057884216,
0.8945304751396179,
-0.04771364852786064,
-0.1662062704563141,
0.2155289202928543,
0.618664562702179,
0.5309489965438843,
-0.07626185566186905,
-0.16893771290779114,
0.08393725007772446,
0.6126579642295837,
0.13718974590301514,
-0.6880266666412354,
0.10788998007774353,
-0.4263753890991211,
0.007285554893314838,
0.343747079372406,
-1.398604154586792,
0.8542894721031189,
0.1250416338443756,
-0.3733910620212555,
-0.6860674023628235,
0.8341121673583984,
-0.04020463675260544,
0.807487428188324,
0.7237849831581116,
0.39944663643836975,
0.5235567688941956,
0.05417083576321602,
0.7706432342529297,
-0.237798810005188,
0.2194857895374298,
0.8392195701599121,
-0.24932891130447388,
0.15061354637145996,
1.1196949481964111,
-0.17071034014225006,
0.37549883127212524,
0.38748741149902344,
0.2643926739692688,
0.4606989026069641,
0.0872870460152626,
-0.6636594533920288,
-0.434011310338974,
-0.35265669226646423,
-0.7880303263664246,
0.13231241703033447,
0.37588974833488464,
-0.37964677810668945,
-0.5326231122016907,
0.2961791753768921,
0.03083537518978119,
0.23263493180274963,
-0.29410862922668457,
0.49774953722953796,
0.2852681875228882,
-0.44433048367500305,
0.315628319978714,
-0.1361134946346283,
0.2817404568195343,
-0.3379549980163574,
0.04919238016009331,
-0.1844954639673233,
-0.11044220626354218,
-0.6229687929153442,
-0.6414291262626648,
0.8566960692405701,
-0.2076306939125061,
-0.3818146884441376,
-0.4315105378627777,
0.818283200263977,
-0.4463353157043457,
-0.09928674250841141,
0.7505427002906799,
0.3884815275669098,
-0.1567169725894928,
-0.002411163877695799,
-0.4207822382450104,
0.38634443283081055,
0.15568983554840088,
-0.303882360458374,
0.7361792922019958,
0.3927519619464874,
-0.22245068848133087,
0.3659050762653351,
0.7326202392578125,
-0.3224664330482483,
0.4427253007888794,
0.17378383874893188,
1.1904410123825073,
-0.5775189995765686,
-0.017990313470363617,
-1.0090042352676392,
0.29711678624153137,
-0.3603114187717438,
-0.19290228188037872,
1.0476877689361572,
0.5904004573822021,
0.49030816555023193,
0.20262432098388672,
0.7511265277862549,
-0.2512568533420563,
-0.1257622390985489,
0.00400689709931612,
0.7440804243087769,
-0.6401640772819519,
0.20295928418636322,
-0.08951988816261292,
-0.6317955255508423,
-0.26536208391189575,
0.05157119780778885,
-0.7892444729804993,
-0.34242329001426697,
0.2807072699069977,
0.5746591687202454,
-0.1879444718360901,
0.44122105836868286,
-0.027793627232313156,
0.24934811890125275,
0.6051768064498901,
0.09157105535268784,
1.0053504705429077,
-0.06368697434663773,
0.37395337224006653,
-0.2924765646457672,
-0.519329309463501,
-0.20210407674312592,
-0.7347749471664429,
-1.188399076461792,
-0.6532341241836548,
-0.49141138792037964,
-0.547390341758728,
-0.04089944437146187,
0.9938095211982727,
0.0942828357219696,
-0.49773547053337097,
-0.28780052065849304,
-0.042477019131183624,
0.38223522901535034,
-0.23743022978305817,
-0.2649427056312561,
0.2412630021572113,
-0.15179216861724854,
-0.5313944220542908,
0.04760238155722618,
0.8255119919776917,
-0.29465389251708984,
-0.20547270774841309,
0.22730393707752228,
-0.4724031388759613,
0.39015406370162964,
0.8309832811355591,
0.45704859495162964,
-0.6650269031524658,
-0.2859085500240326,
-0.30714234709739685,
0.13063733279705048,
0.17612555623054504,
0.7297818064689636,
-0.12532493472099304,
0.4491766095161438,
0.5507385730743408,
0.5734120011329651,
0.23170515894889832,
0.5406034588813782,
0.2839820981025696,
-0.33800917863845825,
-0.08718881011009216,
0.15452250838279724,
0.03838767483830452,
0.021144039928913116,
-0.4523804783821106,
0.3862551152706146,
0.644015908241272,
-0.7438657283782959,
-0.8676232695579529,
0.6743646860122681,
-0.7615870833396912,
0.08900735527276993,
1.1229724884033203,
-0.10978969186544418,
-0.2556089162826538,
-0.20958180725574493,
0.10119853913784027,
0.32389792799949646,
-0.21853797137737274,
1.130206823348999,
1.0089596509933472,
-0.36263495683670044,
0.0021544378250837326,
-0.024951914325356483,
0.3739643096923828,
0.6177993416786194,
-0.5975807905197144,
-0.09004729241132736,
-0.04196528345346451,
0.2695377469062805,
0.012761097401380539,
0.4454769790172577,
-0.029971810057759285,
0.254055917263031,
-0.3299798369407654,
-0.10753697901964188,
0.22954735159873962,
-0.0512564554810524,
-0.26961785554885864,
0.49008071422576904,
-0.5062962174415588,
0.2616289556026459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11894v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11894v3 | Automating Dataset Updates Towards Reliable and Timely Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T07:15:59 | 2024-06-06T12:49:44 | Jiahao Ying, Yixin Cao, Yushi Bai, Qianru Sun, Bo Wang, Wei Tang, Zhaojun Ding, Yizhe Yang, Xuanjing Huang, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance across
various natural language benchmarks, prompting a continual need to curate more
difficult datasets for larger LLMs, which is costly and time-consuming. In this
paper, we propose to automate dataset updating and provide systematic analysis
regarding its effectiveness in dealing with benchmark leakage issue, difficulty
control, and stability. Thus, once the current benchmark has been mastered or
leaked, we can update it for timely and reliable evaluation. There are two
updating strategies: 1) mimicking strategy to generate similar samples based on
original data, preserving stylistic and contextual essence, and 2) extending
strategy that further expands existing samples at varying cognitive levels by
adapting Bloom's taxonomy of educational objectives. Extensive experiments on
updated MMLU and BIG-Bench demonstrate the stability of the proposed strategies
and find that the mimicking strategy can effectively alleviate issues of
overestimation from benchmark leakage. In cases where the efficient mimicking
strategy fails, our extending strategy still shows promising results.
Additionally, by controlling the difficulty, we can better discern the models'
performance and enable fine-grained analysis neither too difficult nor too easy
an exam can fairly judge students' learning status. To the best of our
knowledge, we are the first to automate updating benchmarks for reliable and
timely evaluation. Our demo leaderboard can be found at
https://yingjiahao14.github.io/Automating-DatasetUpdates/. | [
0.02423691377043724,
-0.7647643089294434,
0.4393136203289032,
0.37942472100257874,
0.06726877391338348,
0.30560681223869324,
-0.6731976270675659,
-0.2397659420967102,
-0.3720942735671997,
0.33983659744262695,
-0.5840234756469727,
-0.5690829753875732,
-0.528030276298523,
-0.08533519506454468,
-0.6076539754867554,
0.5403041839599609,
-0.40334856510162354,
0.061587367206811905,
-0.23157520592212677,
-0.12736806273460388,
-0.7354058027267456,
-0.35917702317237854,
-0.717509925365448,
-0.3287557363510132,
-0.012041204608976841,
0.45236602425575256,
0.49552974104881287,
0.9986346364021301,
0.5054283142089844,
0.3392862379550934,
0.09969794750213623,
0.06123438477516174,
-0.4688642621040344,
0.5079919695854187,
-0.288860559463501,
-0.3556215465068817,
-0.3175409436225891,
-0.18533165752887726,
0.9701402187347412,
0.9492365717887878,
-0.4844958484172821,
0.34095829725265503,
0.4811307191848755,
0.7782557606697083,
-0.6558776497840881,
0.6042470335960388,
-0.7989580035209656,
-0.1489686518907547,
-0.27998992800712585,
0.0018818625248968601,
-0.37939226627349854,
-0.43018633127212524,
0.09519006311893463,
-0.44990095496177673,
-0.020890071988105774,
-0.06260716170072556,
0.5467066168785095,
0.45355209708213806,
0.14034493267536163,
-0.16882102191448212,
-0.5510313510894775,
0.9916699528694153,
-0.6627689003944397,
0.24796973168849945,
0.2713988125324249,
0.7427288293838501,
-0.3587154448032379,
-0.5979803204536438,
-0.19973023235797882,
-0.5110766887664795,
0.020900912582874298,
-0.004385694861412048,
0.060818862169981,
-0.3205640912055969,
0.30573010444641113,
0.4350273311138153,
-0.31393638253211975,
0.3005867898464203,
-0.1244923397898674,
-0.13515715301036835,
0.7867627143859863,
0.35903823375701904,
0.35374319553375244,
-0.04736282676458359,
-0.16225150227546692,
-0.49496808648109436,
-0.5304046273231506,
-0.2322845458984375,
0.2806987166404724,
0.41524219512939453,
-0.02103547751903534,
0.39400482177734375,
-0.40848061442375183,
0.5931116938591003,
-0.13810493052005768,
0.19288353621959686,
0.5415889024734497,
-0.41069746017456055,
-0.10814069956541061,
-0.14080263674259186,
0.7996684908866882,
0.15928730368614197,
0.46981698274612427,
-0.1347539871931076,
-0.3419732451438904,
-0.06357559561729431,
0.09535642713308334,
-0.6276170015335083,
-0.1381271928548813,
0.3330006003379822,
-0.15096509456634521,
-0.30051663517951965,
-0.05988031625747681,
-1.060102105140686,
-0.21386760473251343,
-0.5130676627159119,
0.5644954442977905,
-0.468034029006958,
-0.11044416576623917,
0.3716205656528473,
0.3225160241127014,
0.034733206033706665,
0.47900909185409546,
-0.8923413157463074,
0.4999575614929199,
0.8051648736000061,
0.7143872380256653,
-0.44352689385414124,
-0.46974557638168335,
-0.3417993485927582,
0.178445965051651,
-0.35277238488197327,
0.5284425616264343,
-0.5202823877334595,
-0.30649349093437195,
0.08712814748287201,
0.02049243450164795,
-0.1763327419757843,
-0.6443864107131958,
0.3972589373588562,
-0.37289103865623474,
0.28761667013168335,
-0.3549467623233795,
-0.7593268156051636,
0.30582189559936523,
0.4131239950656891,
-0.8338075876235962,
1.2534281015396118,
0.19179779291152954,
-0.4192520081996918,
0.0990700051188469,
-0.7936252355575562,
-0.18655847012996674,
-0.09072747081518173,
-0.06407070904970169,
-0.44922125339508057,
-0.3082441985607147,
0.5218831896781921,
0.4293963611125946,
-0.1499331146478653,
0.45681431889533997,
-0.2605164051055908,
-0.4098832905292511,
0.0774846151471138,
-0.45757293701171875,
0.9205612540245056,
0.026732666417956352,
-0.5922157168388367,
-0.02987438067793846,
-0.7079479098320007,
0.09064509719610214,
0.10397828370332718,
-0.1655297577381134,
-0.1330542117357254,
0.013519898988306522,
-0.017845334485173225,
0.03121558204293251,
0.2538641393184662,
-0.432730108499527,
0.4907962679862976,
-0.16107533872127533,
0.3118659555912018,
1.124220609664917,
0.08255894482135773,
0.17755253612995148,
-0.4942542314529419,
0.4678204357624054,
-0.1938706338405609,
0.4166703522205353,
-0.40309059619903564,
-0.25689399242401123,
-0.7864397764205933,
-0.18788760900497437,
0.5999425649642944,
0.5840340852737427,
-0.3865968585014343,
0.48863568902015686,
-0.490285187959671,
-0.5163753032684326,
-0.7243673205375671,
0.4643341302871704,
0.2990089952945709,
0.3124430775642395,
0.5309327244758606,
-0.33939266204833984,
-0.3566666543483734,
-0.6451718807220459,
-0.3573705852031708,
-0.10522661358118057,
-0.0298997201025486,
0.23635239899158478,
0.435874879360199,
-0.3188984990119934,
0.8500403761863708,
-0.4010688066482544,
-0.5454686284065247,
-0.04509676247835159,
0.29981350898742676,
0.21656650304794312,
0.5713757872581482,
0.4940662682056427,
-0.26848796010017395,
-0.6073234677314758,
-0.15204398334026337,
-0.739777684211731,
-0.43723151087760925,
-0.38787510991096497,
-0.13338737189769745,
0.16812613606452942,
0.6300626993179321,
-0.3805069029331207,
0.12439685314893723,
0.2712852954864502,
0.08973395079374313,
0.7506867051124573,
0.006675125565379858,
0.15222987532615662,
-0.8432274460792542,
0.05096926540136337,
-0.10983651131391525,
-0.08865991979837418,
-0.11993012577295303,
0.3246663510799408,
0.07708119601011276,
0.04250124841928482,
-0.29506874084472656,
0.7850149869918823,
-0.5880072116851807,
0.018753422424197197,
-0.07185575366020203,
0.1528455764055252,
-0.058976054191589355,
0.29507869482040405,
-0.255997896194458,
0.704181969165802,
0.9345376491546631,
-0.4569975733757019,
0.5588351488113403,
0.0876024067401886,
-0.529650092124939,
0.2976679503917694,
-0.5470073223114014,
0.04472128301858902,
0.01669681817293167,
0.30588221549987793,
-0.6674325466156006,
-0.18910372257232666,
0.28227800130844116,
-0.10675714164972305,
0.37227803468704224,
-0.1373795121908188,
-0.8500972986221313,
-0.2897123694419861,
-0.46000224351882935,
0.057657334953546524,
0.39759907126426697,
-0.6301944851875305,
0.5081183314323425,
0.14794886112213135,
-0.15318799018859863,
-0.5062608122825623,
-0.46939581632614136,
0.252210795879364,
-0.03244919702410698,
-0.35979485511779785,
0.35913288593292236,
-0.21658341586589813,
-0.4437890350818634,
-0.04804300516843796,
-0.12541189789772034,
0.07518390566110611,
0.14581042528152466,
-0.062321074306964874,
0.3606300354003906,
0.013812382705509663,
0.2267087996006012,
-0.09176957607269287,
-0.07377690076828003,
0.236328125,
-0.24610170722007751,
0.4111103415489197,
-0.08620503544807434,
-0.605254590511322,
-0.4330581724643707,
0.006067393813282251,
0.7474560737609863,
-0.12173614650964737,
0.40410369634628296,
0.55536949634552,
-0.43684929609298706,
-0.48813262581825256,
-0.6989624500274658,
-0.4182582497596741,
-0.5269912481307983,
0.3590233325958252,
-0.3728782534599304,
-0.33106327056884766,
0.44448578357696533,
-0.09691958874464035,
0.3274195194244385,
0.2906529903411865,
0.5306335091590881,
-0.05308592692017555,
0.7625865936279297,
0.5799117088317871,
-0.5063779950141907,
0.36566975712776184,
-0.3853970468044281,
-0.20333914458751678,
-0.8000955581665039,
-0.18485844135284424,
-0.4843301773071289,
-0.18181057274341583,
-0.3100753128528595,
-0.6034365892410278,
0.08883798122406006,
-0.26441124081611633,
0.08430347591638565,
0.2654012441635132,
-0.30818331241607666,
0.42563769221305847,
0.24648751318454742,
-0.04241131618618965,
0.3285799026489258,
0.09278731048107147,
-0.11745516210794449,
-0.12487407773733139,
-0.49788162112236023,
-0.4619649648666382,
1.4579083919525146,
0.3895573616027832,
0.9285033345222473,
0.0731155276298523,
0.5996415019035339,
0.4671742916107178,
0.41189366579055786,
-0.5817234516143799,
0.6719391345977783,
-0.12076495587825775,
-0.46276232600212097,
-0.36760252714157104,
-0.450541228055954,
-0.8141987323760986,
0.043395355343818665,
-0.19311700761318207,
-0.610740602016449,
0.09739787131547928,
0.10479706525802612,
-0.08538512885570526,
0.21530812978744507,
-0.5157768130302429,
0.7890101075172424,
-0.28387436270713806,
-0.6088109612464905,
-0.24970249831676483,
-0.48587149381637573,
0.23125328123569489,
-0.5450377464294434,
0.17634384334087372,
-0.005832625087350607,
0.009999222122132778,
0.8078939914703369,
-0.40326154232025146,
0.7010019421577454,
-0.08352557569742203,
-0.20211726427078247,
0.24387161433696747,
-0.05153802037239075,
0.5526496767997742,
-0.03227857127785683,
-0.504382848739624,
0.06648282706737518,
-0.07612785696983337,
-0.4320482909679413,
-0.8899900913238525,
0.6809425950050354,
-0.5468254685401917,
-0.525775134563446,
-0.4566054046154022,
-0.534168004989624,
-0.4725479185581207,
0.11756151914596558,
-0.17374886572360992,
0.4918387234210968,
-0.16105860471725464,
0.1490243822336197,
0.5590564012527466,
-0.057495664805173874,
0.4831579327583313,
0.6319054961204529,
-0.3545530438423157,
0.0052988869138062,
0.9192488193511963,
0.19004851579666138,
0.32765716314315796,
0.1523575484752655,
0.3446512222290039,
-0.33438730239868164,
-0.6964658498764038,
-0.6265647411346436,
0.15669982135295868,
-0.6363730430603027,
-0.05776160582900047,
-0.46027401089668274,
-0.2555038630962372,
-0.4429272413253784,
0.08294542133808136,
-0.5207081437110901,
-0.1831377148628235,
0.027984706684947014,
-0.0019859650637954473,
0.3527160882949829,
0.5470840930938721,
-0.1609218567609787,
0.23812294006347656,
-0.5683795809745789,
0.19286906719207764,
0.3249276578426361,
0.54790860414505,
0.14025536179542542,
-0.652381181716919,
-0.22609856724739075,
0.10303004086017609,
-0.07244657725095749,
-0.568722665309906,
0.05550755560398102,
0.4410119652748108,
0.5943232178688049,
0.09878450632095337,
-0.03335770592093468,
0.7662342190742493,
-0.5675221085548401,
0.4811203181743622,
-0.34949585795402527,
-1.0759847164154053,
0.6368441581726074,
-0.3342020511627197,
0.4128772020339966,
0.9542269110679626,
0.2201819270849228,
-0.4260038733482361,
-0.6501070857048035,
-0.5230688452720642,
-0.8627588748931885,
0.5349440574645996,
0.17252175509929657,
0.23341670632362366,
0.2810175120830536,
0.36640241742134094,
0.1344543695449829,
0.1781495213508606,
-0.403393417596817,
-0.2757548689842224,
-0.20263895392417908,
-0.38692161440849304,
0.0124521404504776,
-0.0038880351930856705,
-0.029715120792388916,
-0.367704838514328,
0.8891279697418213,
-0.14768368005752563,
-0.17478767037391663,
-0.0982087105512619,
-0.32856395840644836,
-0.058647867292165756,
0.42633163928985596,
0.16797955334186554,
0.9376779198646545,
-0.5014722943305969,
-0.3053922653198242,
0.30284029245376587,
-0.7118452191352844,
0.1687757968902588,
0.29334792494773865,
-0.160161554813385,
0.09401577711105347,
0.5210805535316467,
0.41813579201698303,
0.44322213530540466,
-0.9379227161407471,
0.530245840549469,
-0.023634962737560272,
-0.017236411571502686,
-0.23106615245342255,
0.22877424955368042,
-0.24392423033714294,
-0.0904754176735878,
0.4990776777267456,
-0.21126829087734222,
0.010722712613642216,
-0.7006880640983582,
0.4921650290489197,
0.20088200271129608,
-0.16413968801498413,
-0.13282231986522675,
0.37099894881248474,
-0.12019579857587814,
-0.04942294582724571,
0.6537370681762695,
-0.08069878071546555,
-0.5594586133956909,
0.4910198152065277,
0.32609742879867554,
0.7366929054260254,
-0.4061915874481201,
0.18345534801483154,
0.4981742203235626,
0.3366490602493286,
-0.33634698390960693,
0.02422736957669258,
0.0834793895483017,
-0.4903927445411682,
-0.5676721334457397,
-0.6696820855140686,
-0.6559191346168518,
0.24452465772628784,
-0.7889068126678467,
0.3520715832710266,
-0.47268587350845337,
0.1276613473892212,
-0.1527286022901535,
0.17800283432006836,
-0.4754195511341095,
0.3529133200645447,
0.10587605088949203,
1.187878966331482,
-0.9577804207801819,
0.9420909285545349,
0.48099491000175476,
-0.057322174310684204,
-0.7946059703826904,
0.03719382360577583,
0.08673588931560516,
-0.714038074016571,
0.4770336449146271,
0.06062154844403267,
0.01007454190403223,
0.03118213266134262,
-0.317819207906723,
-0.9387146830558777,
1.0364105701446533,
0.22877620160579681,
-1.064874529838562,
0.12148230522871017,
0.18206077814102173,
0.6950955986976624,
-0.24393993616104126,
0.184665247797966,
0.7095234394073486,
0.7382930517196655,
-0.012313414365053177,
-0.8005877733230591,
0.1170060932636261,
-0.31089475750923157,
-0.21351082623004913,
-0.016297508031129837,
-0.43754205107688904,
0.5970313549041748,
-0.07141558080911636,
-0.19611848890781403,
-0.022535433992743492,
0.6391968131065369,
0.15947841107845306,
-0.11201809346675873,
0.6426819562911987,
0.7060489654541016,
0.7608827948570251,
-0.11303867399692535,
0.8276383876800537,
-0.3493102788925171,
0.4515451490879059,
1.450276494026184,
-0.5334922671318054,
0.9151058197021484,
0.24248187243938446,
-0.28408437967300415,
0.5124818086624146,
0.5885429978370667,
-0.5866226553916931,
0.48676347732543945,
0.4216635823249817,
0.00013601485989056528,
-0.02134287729859352,
0.14081066846847534,
-0.4518081247806549,
0.5488319993019104,
0.30364367365837097,
-0.11661598086357117,
-0.4900950789451599,
0.01683281734585762,
0.13011741638183594,
0.20859414339065552,
-0.20052285492420197,
0.5826632380485535,
-0.1565801054239273,
-0.7814240455627441,
0.5030339360237122,
-0.10407104343175888,
0.4041942059993744,
-0.5944675803184509,
0.035062141716480255,
-0.15107469260692596,
0.11561375856399536,
0.021716533228754997,
-0.7175773978233337,
0.2752109467983246,
-0.032298799604177475,
0.09182555973529816,
-0.30844151973724365,
0.5245208144187927,
-0.5984302163124084,
-0.6341522336006165,
0.46941521763801575,
0.5081828832626343,
-0.05368947237730026,
0.12569521367549896,
-1.0905245542526245,
0.5524400472640991,
-0.2461971640586853,
-0.11012698709964752,
0.15267358720302582,
0.00824603158980608,
-0.14919568598270416,
0.9447630047798157,
0.6904692649841309,
0.3934515118598938,
0.16331692039966583,
0.5865582227706909,
0.7276735305786133,
-0.32523879408836365,
-0.2069145292043686,
-0.9974529147148132,
0.33529531955718994,
-0.26302725076675415,
0.036997146904468536,
0.8783684372901917,
0.4614012837409973,
0.771232008934021,
0.10344206541776657,
0.7278003096580505,
0.16813534498214722,
0.49506351351737976,
-0.5663697719573975,
0.8857660889625549,
-0.4296218454837799,
0.6002159118652344,
-0.3561026155948639,
-1.110253930091858,
-0.15761463344097137,
0.2866264283657074,
-0.34461116790771484,
0.08349714428186417,
0.745725154876709,
0.7728902697563171,
-0.08893950283527374,
-0.03719212859869003,
-0.06053881719708443,
0.4916192889213562,
0.4072231352329254,
0.5027264952659607,
0.6320182681083679,
-0.5654938817024231,
0.34507134556770325,
-0.46584847569465637,
-0.3870926797389984,
-0.1946822702884674,
-0.9641502499580383,
-0.7034640908241272,
-0.4321715831756592,
-0.8729533553123474,
-0.17010647058486938,
0.43601885437965393,
0.7321560978889465,
0.6854430437088013,
-0.777822732925415,
-0.36036017537117004,
0.07165729999542236,
-0.05872592329978943,
-0.4646909832954407,
-0.3032384216785431,
0.685747504234314,
-0.7091532945632935,
-0.823413074016571,
0.47186213731765747,
0.11235397309064865,
-0.12287590652704239,
-0.5816232562065125,
0.3579462170600891,
-0.14923444390296936,
0.13166700303554535,
0.3215827941894531,
0.25234657526016235,
-0.5241442918777466,
-0.290829598903656,
-0.09868593513965607,
-0.26531708240509033,
-0.03881455212831497,
0.4527044892311096,
-0.8333914279937744,
0.6041860580444336,
0.15330104529857635,
1.0093753337860107,
0.33226320147514343,
-0.036390263587236404,
0.6371828317642212,
-0.6298484802246094,
-0.36049842834472656,
0.031316306442022324,
0.3988877236843109,
0.5850741863250732,
-0.07794938236474991,
0.5831045508384705,
0.11722345650196075,
-0.42997658252716064,
-1.097719430923462,
-0.006176465656608343,
-0.89289790391922,
-0.1851077675819397,
1.0575417280197144,
-0.23220787942409515,
-0.46544507145881653,
-0.1193530261516571,
0.05040392279624939,
0.14496250450611115,
-0.14040426909923553,
1.1911425590515137,
0.872913122177124,
0.35919296741485596,
0.10200328379869461,
-0.7508924007415771,
0.556735634803772,
0.6113131642341614,
-1.04020094871521,
0.4491385519504547,
0.23436741530895233,
0.458099365234375,
0.0720444992184639,
0.35702767968177795,
-0.32829955220222473,
0.25198057293891907,
-0.36657238006591797,
-0.2752009630203247,
-0.10993069410324097,
-0.2935313880443573,
-0.4670689105987549,
0.001762977335602045,
-0.058417048305273056,
-0.1880594938993454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11891v1 | FeB4RAG: Evaluating Federated Search in the Context of Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-02-19T07:06:52 | 2024-02-19T07:06:52 | Shuai Wang, Ekaterina Khramtsova, Shengyao Zhuang, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Federated search systems aggregate results from multiple search engines,
selecting appropriate sources to enhance result quality and align with user
intent. With the increasing uptake of Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
pipelines, federated search can play a pivotal role in sourcing relevant
information across heterogeneous data sources to generate informed responses.
However, existing datasets, such as those developed in the past TREC FedWeb
tracks, predate the RAG paradigm shift and lack representation of modern
information retrieval challenges. To bridge this gap, we present FeB4RAG, a
novel dataset specifically designed for federated search within RAG frameworks.
This dataset, derived from 16 sub-collections of the widely used \beir
benchmarking collection, includes 790 information requests (akin to
conversational queries) tailored for chatbot applications, along with top
results returned by each resource and associated LLM-derived relevance
judgements. Additionally, to support the need for this collection, we
demonstrate the impact on response generation of a high quality federated
search system for RAG compared to a naive approach to federated search. We do
so by comparing answers generated through the RAG pipeline through a
qualitative side-by-side comparison. Our collection fosters and supports the
development and evaluation of new federated search methods, especially in the
context of RAG pipelines. | [
-0.5355428457260132,
-0.2938007414340973,
0.20793437957763672,
0.2550334334373474,
0.11055228114128113,
0.315551221370697,
0.18102404475212097,
-0.23877902328968048,
0.3421822786331177,
0.45392704010009766,
-0.7280847430229187,
-0.1728578805923462,
-0.07121424376964569,
0.43966707587242126,
-0.5324044823646545,
1.1537715196609497,
0.30585217475891113,
-0.1878843754529953,
-0.45144185423851013,
-0.3432542681694031,
-0.5585442185401917,
-0.41617998480796814,
-0.45314842462539673,
-0.275404691696167,
0.6254813075065613,
0.3024863302707672,
0.565385639667511,
0.20527756214141846,
0.9285387992858887,
0.27896422147750854,
0.19331365823745728,
0.1691843420267105,
-1.0883595943450928,
0.609558641910553,
-0.07059098780155182,
-0.5182021856307983,
-0.37053629755973816,
0.4979749917984009,
0.6760342717170715,
0.20989564061164856,
-0.4965459406375885,
0.430063933134079,
-0.16450834274291992,
0.5705597996711731,
-0.977168619632721,
0.08867281675338745,
-0.6659048795700073,
0.36168384552001953,
-0.6877757906913757,
-0.49540606141090393,
-0.4371598958969116,
-0.2051350623369217,
-0.10542292892932892,
-0.7544459104537964,
0.5529828667640686,
0.3573111891746521,
0.8406152725219727,
0.34742432832717896,
-0.05847456678748131,
-0.3041522204875946,
-0.5353362560272217,
0.4818585515022278,
-0.29419514536857605,
0.7410848736763,
0.26550912857055664,
0.6480995416641235,
-0.2938166856765747,
-1.2541611194610596,
-0.45944124460220337,
0.36562156677246094,
-0.399415522813797,
0.32103338837623596,
-0.46336618065834045,
-0.2759685516357422,
0.20458009839057922,
0.5987164378166199,
-0.661867082118988,
0.09092477709054947,
-0.32963746786117554,
-0.1665121614933014,
0.7422755360603333,
0.4478170871734619,
0.019683996215462685,
-0.23313267529010773,
-0.6297324895858765,
-0.3204866349697113,
-0.6463638544082642,
0.020404662936925888,
0.49038931727409363,
0.35464751720428467,
0.08583288639783859,
0.6123453974723816,
-0.48821672797203064,
0.6381788849830627,
0.38360968232154846,
-0.08675846457481384,
0.33255189657211304,
-0.5777211785316467,
-0.07513801753520966,
-0.17178961634635925,
0.8384685516357422,
0.3497624099254608,
-0.4810634255409241,
-0.3120136559009552,
-0.6509861946105957,
-0.126065194606781,
0.5912317633628845,
-0.9650557041168213,
-0.13881011307239532,
0.18113359808921814,
-0.37824469804763794,
-0.5283604860305786,
0.03171510249376297,
-0.8302496671676636,
-0.5422625541687012,
-0.08717633783817291,
0.3500887155532837,
0.12944002449512482,
-0.06295794248580933,
-0.19757163524627686,
-0.4029255211353302,
0.17343424260616302,
0.12274044752120972,
-0.43071290850639343,
0.25174909830093384,
0.958644688129425,
0.7339598536491394,
-0.08426067978143692,
-0.03461693227291107,
-1.095475673675537,
-0.37756726145744324,
-0.27739182114601135,
1.0835745334625244,
-0.745425820350647,
-0.3169698119163513,
-0.049836453050374985,
-0.3014850616455078,
0.05426599830389023,
-0.5388650298118591,
0.6945701241493225,
-1.1657354831695557,
0.8104058504104614,
-0.27066361904144287,
-0.43709200620651245,
0.10870543867349625,
0.2503450810909271,
-0.7591765522956848,
1.0955206155776978,
0.3457315266132355,
-1.0198407173156738,
0.35773569345474243,
-0.6271970868110657,
0.08707883208990097,
0.6144536137580872,
-0.46525898575782776,
-0.4414079189300537,
0.006669471971690655,
0.1533687859773636,
0.32531219720840454,
-0.7187406420707703,
0.17262724041938782,
-0.328486829996109,
-0.4572555124759674,
0.018480276688933372,
-0.14276659488677979,
0.8338673114776611,
0.3406442701816559,
-0.014124163426458836,
-0.11622190475463867,
-0.31857043504714966,
0.2417575716972351,
0.17136868834495544,
-0.237101748585701,
-0.337317556142807,
-0.3153441250324249,
-0.12114432454109192,
0.14360538125038147,
0.43105533719062805,
-0.5581396818161011,
-0.035786956548690796,
-0.2719861567020416,
-0.06729398667812347,
0.6676240563392639,
-0.10730771720409393,
0.5031805038452148,
-0.44756126403808594,
0.774085283279419,
-0.3204376995563507,
0.13826167583465576,
-0.13416306674480438,
-0.24109205603599548,
-0.3705364465713501,
-0.15927062928676605,
0.41780975461006165,
0.21955598890781403,
-0.8323856592178345,
-0.08156679570674896,
-0.3861739933490753,
-0.517672061920166,
-0.7533115148544312,
-0.07601054757833481,
0.4076915979385376,
0.7122812867164612,
0.32011184096336365,
-0.41066303849220276,
-0.7196558117866516,
-0.7284685373306274,
-0.0423707440495491,
-0.2584682106971741,
-0.1458704024553299,
0.6631472110748291,
0.08712523430585861,
-0.3605513572692871,
1.0285451412200928,
-0.4130188822746277,
-0.40591204166412354,
-0.005240725353360176,
0.3023185729980469,
0.33317428827285767,
-0.03922033682465553,
0.5310516357421875,
-1.164884328842163,
-0.3544606566429138,
-0.10705674439668655,
-0.7543359398841858,
-0.4364524185657501,
0.24320337176322937,
-0.3244069814682007,
0.08704634010791779,
0.18074150383472443,
-0.4179539382457733,
0.2688145637512207,
0.69559645652771,
-0.3490671217441559,
0.6305842995643616,
0.14441481232643127,
0.3512313663959503,
-0.944766640663147,
0.3339420557022095,
-0.4130174517631531,
-0.09756755083799362,
-0.4244571626186371,
0.3687043786048889,
-0.07984483987092972,
-0.21448475122451782,
0.012476545758545399,
0.6110130548477173,
-0.3012504279613495,
-0.610442042350769,
-0.3858620524406433,
0.19028523564338684,
0.1536722183227539,
0.02991606667637825,
-0.44597747921943665,
1.160865306854248,
-0.15267957746982574,
-0.20819716155529022,
0.5487728118896484,
0.6643375158309937,
-0.034281082451343536,
0.880816638469696,
-0.4803251028060913,
0.14085568487644196,
-0.1536235362291336,
0.6863096952438354,
-0.6693179607391357,
-0.5207532048225403,
-0.015728279948234558,
-0.5410540103912354,
0.24653367698192596,
0.007545892149209976,
-0.4754965305328369,
-0.5011324882507324,
-0.3551318943500519,
0.3224738538265228,
0.23298192024230957,
-0.7615090012550354,
0.3580397367477417,
0.5220493674278259,
-0.1001887321472168,
-1.1054431200027466,
-0.15918494760990143,
0.03733115643262863,
-0.2982935309410095,
-0.6231306195259094,
0.41857942938804626,
-0.07997047156095505,
-0.2762957215309143,
0.000605656357947737,
-0.30361899733543396,
-0.0997554287314415,
0.16857770085334778,
0.19866304099559784,
0.22398334741592407,
-0.2634906470775604,
0.09096422791481018,
-0.27961188554763794,
-0.15585146844387054,
-0.02981693297624588,
0.1517607569694519,
0.8049653172492981,
-0.2030772566795349,
-0.3127218782901764,
-0.02103334106504917,
0.01074428204447031,
0.12874753773212433,
-0.5832588076591492,
0.4830649495124817,
0.9150477051734924,
-0.05880999565124512,
0.060734085738658905,
-0.6583861112594604,
-0.5571761727333069,
-0.50703364610672,
-0.17275412380695343,
-0.3324222266674042,
-1.154029130935669,
0.43245604634284973,
0.15690405666828156,
0.3291478157043457,
0.4359029531478882,
0.42338013648986816,
-0.38541197776794434,
0.6161195039749146,
0.45733538269996643,
-0.04440011456608772,
0.30059364438056946,
-0.18178260326385498,
0.1824956238269806,
-0.9088635444641113,
-0.1753770411014557,
-0.666216254234314,
-0.6112707257270813,
-1.056153416633606,
-0.49846428632736206,
0.5763654112815857,
-0.12180537730455399,
-0.2089226096868515,
0.3225901424884796,
-0.38208064436912537,
0.15795309841632843,
0.5279332399368286,
-0.07594604790210724,
0.38564619421958923,
-0.03787348419427872,
-0.1536148339509964,
-0.1201416403055191,
-0.8995893597602844,
0.05754301697015762,
1.123783826828003,
-0.049662839621305466,
0.5149104595184326,
0.07829289138317108,
0.9864161014556885,
0.5953234434127808,
0.49064669013023376,
-0.38855084776878357,
0.37156641483306885,
-0.005377032794058323,
-0.8547903895378113,
-0.22095444798469543,
-0.6914309859275818,
-1.1180137395858765,
0.4004043638706207,
-0.3075914978981018,
-0.28678569197654724,
0.23766309022903442,
-0.21880179643630981,
-0.19170475006103516,
-0.051159247756004333,
-0.21768486499786377,
0.4554361402988434,
-0.019359571859240532,
-0.5740129947662354,
-0.05996750295162201,
-0.7725450992584229,
0.4224073588848114,
-0.19207154214382172,
0.029956554993987083,
-0.14002129435539246,
0.07304906845092773,
0.6551051735877991,
-0.3363744020462036,
0.1992139369249344,
-0.1698056161403656,
0.2770412564277649,
0.08801945298910141,
-0.13530544936656952,
0.5140502452850342,
0.14670148491859436,
-0.28377726674079895,
0.027594059705734253,
-0.241758331656456,
-0.2028084546327591,
-0.5718971490859985,
0.8211442828178406,
-0.3858357071876526,
-0.7447579503059387,
-0.46865224838256836,
-0.6505963802337646,
-0.09066573530435562,
0.408149778842926,
0.2066328376531601,
0.43575239181518555,
-0.19462336599826813,
0.45595598220825195,
0.323649525642395,
0.00048704969231039286,
0.2010197788476944,
0.7390823364257812,
-0.456188440322876,
-0.35629725456237793,
0.6329494714736938,
-0.0505550280213356,
-0.19646015763282776,
0.4610757827758789,
0.125681534409523,
-0.4413154423236847,
-0.17579977214336395,
-0.3209068477153778,
0.24027925729751587,
-0.24502713978290558,
-0.8405610918998718,
-0.6555542945861816,
-0.309163361787796,
-0.37969228625297546,
-0.01796281337738037,
-0.3097894489765167,
-0.20734748244285583,
-0.10848366469144821,
0.09608851373195648,
0.33846741914749146,
0.5449337959289551,
-0.29680392146110535,
0.06357473134994507,
-0.5937924981117249,
0.17724746465682983,
0.1645556539297104,
0.37703201174736023,
-0.3424716591835022,
-0.3342823088169098,
-0.23863467574119568,
0.11446092277765274,
-0.46552786231040955,
-0.5140339136123657,
0.3036994934082031,
0.09905608743429184,
0.6379355192184448,
0.1255248785018921,
0.5357183218002319,
0.813869833946228,
-0.4863550662994385,
0.4594598710536957,
-0.12439059466123581,
-0.2888924777507782,
0.2683543562889099,
-0.5353440642356873,
0.14847154915332794,
0.5431121587753296,
0.4590858817100525,
-0.43951696157455444,
-0.2996405363082886,
-0.8996468186378479,
-0.5708799958229065,
0.7720907330513,
0.5877974033355713,
-0.07055261731147766,
0.24888387322425842,
0.15476743876934052,
0.053307823836803436,
0.41164320707321167,
-0.07281945645809174,
-0.17748484015464783,
-0.059019219130277634,
0.13419753313064575,
0.02058844454586506,
-0.17218933999538422,
-0.3345109522342682,
0.26920583844184875,
0.515311062335968,
-0.08863537013530731,
0.50950688123703,
-0.03447699919342995,
0.2877490222454071,
-0.13108724355697632,
0.1732184737920761,
0.1463584303855896,
0.3202879726886749,
-0.34962937235832214,
-0.14692969620227814,
-0.1281261295080185,
-0.4725973606109619,
-0.03919651359319687,
0.6921745538711548,
-0.08824841678142548,
0.05826025456190109,
0.13249626755714417,
0.5684700608253479,
0.29120635986328125,
-0.5987467765808105,
0.5429863929748535,
-0.3348407447338104,
0.12654905021190643,
-0.27170810103416443,
0.06911986321210861,
-0.05636559799313545,
0.5714874863624573,
0.6464110612869263,
-0.06115782633423805,
0.5398059487342834,
-0.1745256781578064,
0.5178735256195068,
0.5647697448730469,
-0.14243917167186737,
-0.3325048089027405,
0.6779232025146484,
0.08498375862836838,
-0.17879007756710052,
0.7750493288040161,
-0.11043000221252441,
-0.41724610328674316,
0.12839321792125702,
0.4446423649787903,
0.6325427293777466,
-0.3829703629016876,
0.23541580140590668,
0.3495935797691345,
0.02557351067662239,
-0.00006195543392095715,
0.008920006453990936,
-0.3373885154724121,
-0.6897943615913391,
-0.12503336369991302,
-0.9166728258132935,
-0.4166968762874603,
0.06525631248950958,
-0.9419031739234924,
0.2486172318458557,
-0.08621702343225479,
-0.3445690870285034,
-0.01959695667028427,
0.2809312343597412,
-0.9064764380455017,
-0.01812194660305977,
-0.23220567405223846,
0.5880030393600464,
-0.42621174454689026,
0.1444164514541626,
0.7236433029174805,
-0.366267591714859,
-0.47331470251083374,
-0.019168158993124962,
0.1299404501914978,
-0.782088041305542,
0.6156212687492371,
0.06909869611263275,
-0.032175611704587936,
-0.0326656810939312,
-0.36681339144706726,
-0.9514089822769165,
1.4320508241653442,
0.18324488401412964,
-0.18551768362522125,
-0.20617614686489105,
0.0013919040793552995,
0.6588004231452942,
-0.3403247594833374,
0.5153450965881348,
0.47939223051071167,
0.2443459928035736,
0.17429284751415253,
-1.10370934009552,
-0.21447192132472992,
-0.3945417106151581,
-0.0940740555524826,
0.3446582555770874,
-0.8343027234077454,
0.8645951747894287,
0.10270103067159653,
-0.5844447612762451,
0.02131662517786026,
0.556187093257904,
0.5746064782142639,
0.8665091395378113,
0.294147253036499,
0.855137050151825,
0.6934506893157959,
-0.16493111848831177,
1.0249158143997192,
-0.03447189927101135,
0.39391225576400757,
1.3054803609848022,
-0.38823992013931274,
1.015937089920044,
0.3050636053085327,
-0.09328621625900269,
0.37557509541511536,
0.3114411234855652,
0.19516636431217194,
0.5850844979286194,
-0.10019686818122864,
-0.34584400057792664,
0.009681610390543938,
-0.4563838541507721,
-0.46107494831085205,
0.8702133893966675,
0.4273732304573059,
-0.31865644454956055,
-0.6593769192695618,
-0.11671734601259232,
-0.040972158312797546,
0.13585913181304932,
0.09857258945703506,
0.8965445756912231,
-0.21562746167182922,
-0.49677640199661255,
0.6205488443374634,
-0.23774176836013794,
0.5203747153282166,
-0.1326972395181656,
0.018999731168150902,
-0.6900062561035156,
0.036223024129867554,
-0.3441656231880188,
-0.7711530923843384,
0.2570877969264984,
0.14044158160686493,
-0.18936070799827576,
-0.4523482620716095,
0.8109133839607239,
-0.06858473271131516,
-0.2500443458557129,
0.10886087268590927,
0.6624292135238647,
0.18657433986663818,
0.13674868643283844,
-0.6260859370231628,
0.25899744033813477,
-0.0408511720597744,
-0.11764980107545853,
0.4534492790699005,
0.41696879267692566,
0.0024161585606634617,
0.5637646317481995,
0.6998654007911682,
-0.30824822187423706,
-0.14569149911403656,
-0.28427737951278687,
1.1762205362319946,
-0.3016946613788605,
-0.4002114534378052,
-0.08590441942214966,
0.24486291408538818,
-0.20295093953609467,
-0.058875374495983124,
0.8879639506340027,
0.7820988297462463,
0.9488555788993835,
0.3634950816631317,
0.5110092759132385,
-0.3298536241054535,
0.8344646096229553,
-0.12403798848390579,
0.8449174761772156,
-0.7670992612838745,
0.30276739597320557,
-0.0827084481716156,
-0.7685006856918335,
0.07915976643562317,
0.36400261521339417,
-0.18331636488437653,
-0.07100141793489456,
0.22981680929660797,
0.8794656991958618,
-0.2677916884422302,
0.2982279062271118,
0.22677725553512573,
0.1133447214961052,
0.3689703941345215,
0.011253979988396168,
0.6959550380706787,
-0.6801348328590393,
0.4537637531757355,
-0.28529486060142517,
0.01012970507144928,
-0.543064296245575,
-0.5314965844154358,
-0.39384573698043823,
-0.8065598011016846,
0.17217114567756653,
-0.23214416205883026,
0.3514806628227234,
0.5492815971374512,
0.2982652187347412,
-0.4451487064361572,
-0.13316023349761963,
0.08519380539655685,
-0.0040143439546227455,
0.11957477778196335,
-0.3222914934158325,
-0.07327967137098312,
-0.6668797731399536,
-0.5646191835403442,
0.5862874984741211,
0.1294841170310974,
-0.34241783618927,
-0.3921603560447693,
0.0556364506483078,
-0.16131563484668732,
-0.2668660283088684,
0.441454142332077,
0.2341344952583313,
-0.37515583634376526,
-0.08334751427173615,
0.36028411984443665,
-0.20538464188575745,
0.11094076186418533,
0.6946757435798645,
-1.167235016822815,
0.6873525977134705,
0.7068279385566711,
0.773780345916748,
0.5486335158348083,
0.4396550953388214,
0.6616427898406982,
-0.9116623401641846,
0.019617820158600807,
0.581343948841095,
-0.07197505235671997,
0.5115635395050049,
-0.35272589325904846,
0.9168490767478943,
0.10673065483570099,
-0.8184387683868408,
-1.0864779949188232,
-0.07448835670948029,
-0.4884062707424164,
0.34768980741500854,
0.8740774989128113,
-0.015566151589155197,
0.17857058346271515,
0.14803828299045563,
0.16383840143680573,
0.05218108743429184,
-0.5937879681587219,
0.7992062568664551,
0.42992112040519714,
-0.36112117767333984,
-0.06245053932070732,
-0.535591721534729,
0.42644280195236206,
0.14951658248901367,
-0.649371325969696,
-0.064908966422081,
0.9056359529495239,
-0.021229306235909462,
0.3743838369846344,
0.6448767781257629,
-0.10345926135778427,
0.4246838390827179,
0.032150570303201675,
-0.21401043236255646,
0.09314536303281784,
-0.2963158190250397,
0.06858430802822113,
0.3697604835033417,
-0.33669939637184143,
-0.0004858403408434242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11890v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11890v2 | Revisiting Knowledge Distillation for Autoregressive Language Models | 2024-02-19T07:01:10 | 2024-06-17T02:44:28 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge distillation (KD) is a common approach to compress a teacher model
to reduce its inference cost and memory footprint, by training a smaller
student model. However, in the context of autoregressive language models (LMs),
we empirically find that larger teacher LMs might dramatically result in a
poorer student. In response to this problem, we conduct a series of analyses
and reveal that different tokens have different teaching modes, neglecting
which will lead to performance degradation. Motivated by this, we propose a
simple yet effective adaptive teaching approach (ATKD) to improve the KD. The
core of ATKD is to reduce rote learning and make teaching more diverse and
flexible. Extensive experiments on 8 LM tasks show that, with the help of ATKD,
various baseline KD methods can achieve consistent and significant performance
gains (up to +3.04% average score) across all model types and sizes. More
encouragingly, ATKD can improve the student model generalization effectively. | [
-0.30296167731285095,
-0.7202062606811523,
0.44131988286972046,
-0.2552894353866577,
-0.37647512555122375,
0.3898839056491852,
-0.43299612402915955,
-0.016427772119641304,
-0.07767973095178604,
0.2993200421333313,
-0.08885267376899719,
-0.31012874841690063,
-0.8325889706611633,
-0.32111772894859314,
-0.38131287693977356,
0.8336346745491028,
-0.1098921000957489,
0.18595144152641296,
-0.31279537081718445,
-0.3030968904495239,
-0.7256142497062683,
-0.4142424762248993,
-0.8682063221931458,
-0.7096858024597168,
0.25756123661994934,
0.6856340765953064,
0.5739242434501648,
0.7061095237731934,
0.22154644131660461,
0.3193758428096771,
-0.061247386038303375,
-0.12013516575098038,
-0.34879669547080994,
0.4350711405277252,
-0.1469336897134781,
-0.693778395652771,
-0.11271560192108154,
0.06610418856143951,
0.4883928894996643,
0.9404405355453491,
-0.6838763952255249,
-0.08133455365896225,
0.3170072138309479,
0.9670795202255249,
-0.870276927947998,
0.17808149755001068,
-0.8008196353912354,
-0.11377741396427155,
0.2241685390472412,
0.2807462513446808,
-0.4479401409626007,
-0.4366358816623688,
0.2406345009803772,
-0.46745428442955017,
0.2498692274093628,
-0.4109151363372803,
0.2958890199661255,
0.6714230179786682,
-0.6164078712463379,
-0.495465487241745,
-1.0153394937515259,
0.6822711229324341,
-0.8124720454216003,
0.5386902093887329,
0.4248195290565491,
0.7096622586250305,
-0.057507842779159546,
-0.7948954105377197,
-0.5252688527107239,
-0.04068598523736,
0.03586446866393089,
0.05017552152276039,
-0.014521623030304909,
0.0067356545478105545,
0.11516337096691132,
0.484246164560318,
-0.11959939450025558,
0.08253894746303558,
-0.32297682762145996,
0.10797254741191864,
0.3959360718727112,
0.14812323451042175,
-0.038051046431064606,
0.1293579488992691,
-0.24754242599010468,
-0.49025312066078186,
-0.3716064691543579,
0.060939982533454895,
0.2657001316547394,
0.13627536594867706,
0.16063490509986877,
0.08356131613254547,
-0.24177761375904083,
0.7791188359260559,
0.2478766143321991,
-0.3481140732765198,
-0.12744852900505066,
-0.0670178085565567,
-0.14442841708660126,
0.001978902379050851,
0.5045943856239319,
0.3682568669319153,
0.3823843002319336,
-0.15030820667743683,
-0.12216313928365707,
0.0351177453994751,
0.24980509281158447,
-0.749301552772522,
-0.9681360721588135,
-0.27161142230033875,
-0.32586559653282166,
-0.45165911316871643,
-0.3980005979537964,
-0.7742530107498169,
-0.3314801752567291,
-0.4746869206428528,
0.518359899520874,
-0.6631718277931213,
-0.39601606130599976,
0.1461709588766098,
-0.1951128989458084,
-0.10414458066225052,
0.4762263000011444,
-1.0291627645492554,
0.5872023105621338,
0.24000878632068634,
0.7034400105476379,
-0.18344002962112427,
-0.31482458114624023,
-0.17770324647426605,
0.13428997993469238,
-0.250386118888855,
0.6010682582855225,
-0.4684756100177765,
-0.6096406579017639,
-0.4219522476196289,
-0.3305761218070984,
-0.14351622760295868,
-0.797475278377533,
0.13737431168556213,
-0.5203288793563843,
0.236791729927063,
-0.33314117789268494,
-0.736990749835968,
-0.24573424458503723,
0.11665120720863342,
-0.7114094495773315,
1.0639630556106567,
0.17218972742557526,
-0.4635457694530487,
0.7126622796058655,
-0.5617334246635437,
-0.32134419679641724,
-0.31518474221229553,
0.0538204051554203,
-0.3259750008583069,
0.23685100674629211,
0.21944457292556763,
0.29121237993240356,
-0.13503685593605042,
0.3429068624973297,
-0.27043667435646057,
0.0704473927617073,
0.0748906061053276,
-0.673543393611908,
0.6499881148338318,
0.4848387539386749,
-0.13643699884414673,
-0.20841458439826965,
-0.8157805800437927,
-0.013087996281683445,
-0.04361126199364662,
-0.5314732193946838,
-0.8818155527114868,
0.09549764543771744,
-0.2587015628814697,
0.015004594810307026,
-0.2030026912689209,
-0.18040570616722107,
0.5077995657920837,
-0.16769063472747803,
0.36798906326293945,
0.8659546375274658,
0.06975704431533813,
0.751476526260376,
-0.27743080258369446,
0.5095210075378418,
0.14215931296348572,
0.035617128014564514,
-0.20809361338615417,
-0.23968148231506348,
-0.8793626427650452,
-0.32637959718704224,
0.4492596983909607,
0.14294588565826416,
-1.1040852069854736,
-0.060787178575992584,
-0.09293469041585922,
-0.7048424482345581,
-0.6711069345474243,
0.40991711616516113,
0.20422090590000153,
0.7981934547424316,
0.47296178340911865,
-0.27393266558647156,
-0.34765195846557617,
-0.5793545246124268,
-0.41953426599502563,
-0.4781036674976349,
0.09838270395994186,
-0.05791334807872772,
0.30396348237991333,
0.0902043953537941,
1.1219420433044434,
-0.7396040558815002,
-0.10457628965377808,
0.0019040107727050781,
0.16339246928691864,
0.01228401344269514,
0.5892512798309326,
0.7044841051101685,
-0.48172515630722046,
-1.0435458421707153,
-0.16305609047412872,
-0.43709588050842285,
-0.1172075867652893,
0.005650236736983061,
0.02691740170121193,
0.42025282979011536,
0.5702399611473083,
-0.41854405403137207,
0.3118883967399597,
0.28110793232917786,
-0.3405664265155792,
0.4705200791358948,
-0.39676639437675476,
0.2876620590686798,
-1.1265926361083984,
-0.2208663374185562,
-0.25166717171669006,
-0.36886289715766907,
-0.4979844391345978,
-0.05862952023744583,
0.11899006366729736,
0.08973367512226105,
-0.22999489307403564,
0.46687424182891846,
-0.4571596682071686,
0.20637616515159607,
-0.6966767907142639,
-0.060449134558439255,
0.05765683576464653,
0.2234821617603302,
-0.0068245455622673035,
0.43671295046806335,
0.5596453547477722,
-0.7508577108383179,
0.6341700553894043,
-0.25894156098365784,
-0.5810442566871643,
0.5582519173622131,
-0.42892077565193176,
0.037631191313266754,
-0.2522602379322052,
0.4153388738632202,
-1.1335184574127197,
0.043192531913518906,
0.06018297001719475,
-0.2768455445766449,
0.5359976887702942,
-0.3252263069152832,
-0.255376398563385,
-0.3431794047355652,
-0.151945561170578,
0.4831365644931793,
0.8283053636550903,
-0.7047001123428345,
0.7260602116584778,
0.08728266507387161,
0.002967247273772955,
-0.4204421043395996,
-0.5234197378158569,
-0.03050154261291027,
-0.5426264405250549,
-0.36167317628860474,
0.16199062764644623,
-0.17897148430347443,
-0.5042747855186462,
0.22779954969882965,
-0.2202165722846985,
-0.35942456126213074,
0.46698638796806335,
-0.25700801610946655,
-0.004571012686938047,
-0.15918591618537903,
0.2531369626522064,
0.1641022264957428,
-0.10346589237451553,
0.08694756031036377,
-0.35451892018318176,
0.45895907282829285,
0.2871982455253601,
-0.4503293037414551,
-0.38519495725631714,
0.08568243682384491,
0.7879642248153687,
0.24857734143733978,
0.8323046565055847,
0.48845329880714417,
-0.35965389013290405,
-0.35093775391578674,
-0.5755687355995178,
-0.5638980865478516,
-0.49357113242149353,
0.4375631809234619,
-0.33638978004455566,
-0.4182372987270355,
0.6987283229827881,
-0.12051386386156082,
0.06054660305380821,
0.3458036780357361,
0.5681150555610657,
-0.02244315855205059,
0.6904597282409668,
0.724876344203949,
-0.3098103106021881,
0.48670312762260437,
-0.2684360146522522,
-0.02550262026488781,
-0.4449400007724762,
-0.20092663168907166,
-0.408474862575531,
-0.3747413158416748,
-0.17364348471164703,
-0.47311416268348694,
0.2660398483276367,
0.5966946482658386,
-0.056331172585487366,
0.08309300243854523,
-0.3686266541481018,
0.6974816918373108,
0.5269138216972351,
-0.018492791801691055,
0.5339478254318237,
-0.07009878009557724,
-0.009248562157154083,
-0.10487891733646393,
-0.9983636140823364,
-0.32648947834968567,
1.4056133031845093,
0.2966521382331848,
1.127128005027771,
0.25328171253204346,
0.756113588809967,
0.3118723928928375,
0.4668579697608948,
-0.7375120520591736,
0.2159726470708847,
-0.18873490393161774,
-0.4226343333721161,
-0.44231587648391724,
-0.3636919856071472,
-0.5735050439834595,
0.36571818590164185,
0.22219033539295197,
-0.36411818861961365,
0.14252519607543945,
0.5435572266578674,
-0.4325321316719055,
0.4772215187549591,
-1.2345634698867798,
0.7671476006507874,
0.0027898813132196665,
-0.00549346162006259,
-0.3683026134967804,
-0.3471623659133911,
0.424422949552536,
-0.34200209379196167,
0.2908034324645996,
0.19641384482383728,
0.08055761456489563,
0.8319095373153687,
-0.7547076344490051,
0.9630236029624939,
-0.7655600905418396,
-0.23512735962867737,
0.4414243698120117,
0.16459745168685913,
0.5566281080245972,
-0.010605373419821262,
-0.05482134968042374,
-0.4003243148326874,
0.06333178281784058,
-0.41141563653945923,
-1.0941349267959595,
0.790170431137085,
-0.9183914661407471,
-0.8162163496017456,
-0.11709573864936829,
-0.6425807476043701,
-0.18660157918930054,
-0.16916587948799133,
0.09586947411298752,
0.24866941571235657,
0.06870925426483154,
0.22223684191703796,
0.745170533657074,
0.07334592938423157,
0.6376174092292786,
0.8450687527656555,
-0.28385764360427856,
-0.4106222689151764,
0.7417150139808655,
0.43424293398857117,
0.8509984612464905,
-0.05230315402150154,
0.4304439425468445,
-0.3837311267852783,
-0.520675003528595,
-0.4144078493118286,
-0.20755362510681152,
-1.078676700592041,
-0.3012867271900177,
-0.5905786752700806,
0.03432885557413101,
-0.7629132270812988,
-0.2254805713891983,
-0.8237963318824768,
-0.6153128743171692,
-0.3052075505256653,
-0.04903055354952812,
0.7064287066459656,
0.6451252698898315,
-0.14295977354049683,
0.4846847951412201,
-0.4152487814426422,
0.18765731155872345,
0.6115412712097168,
0.2630651593208313,
0.441310852766037,
-0.922342836856842,
-0.32473087310791016,
0.17758646607398987,
-0.4598391652107239,
-0.6352269649505615,
0.28564271330833435,
0.6494073867797852,
0.6657878160476685,
0.38537660241127014,
0.4892446994781494,
0.7641040086746216,
-0.5165215134620667,
0.6919551491737366,
0.3549119532108307,
-0.7592220902442932,
0.5271037220954895,
0.07472322136163712,
0.5389085412025452,
0.5480521321296692,
0.5987797379493713,
-0.7546179294586182,
-0.5586853623390198,
-0.6076353788375854,
-0.9358965754508972,
0.7182797193527222,
-0.2020866870880127,
0.16789966821670532,
0.13587066531181335,
0.6247016787528992,
0.3604322671890259,
-0.003424982074648142,
-0.6937806010246277,
-0.6152899265289307,
-0.4577707052230835,
-0.44081437587738037,
-0.14027930796146393,
-0.3363412320613861,
0.09917885810136795,
-0.5405017137527466,
0.8249478936195374,
-0.10442083328962326,
-0.1253594607114792,
-0.05278854817152023,
-0.18080143630504608,
-0.06702588498592377,
0.14023621380329132,
0.37570425868034363,
0.5047823786735535,
0.020865125581622124,
0.391588032245636,
0.410907119512558,
-0.6604787707328796,
0.5008495450019836,
-0.1643485128879547,
0.0842917189002037,
-0.09568925946950912,
0.3747900128364563,
0.743812084197998,
0.14550264179706573,
-0.25682333111763,
0.164333313703537,
0.03690055012702942,
-0.24119330942630768,
-0.08478721231222153,
0.45579537749290466,
0.23064085841178894,
0.31855860352516174,
0.6277353167533875,
0.0211739931255579,
-0.009191187098622322,
-0.507722020149231,
0.2846640348434448,
0.13051334023475647,
-0.30370020866394043,
-0.26442837715148926,
0.6065640449523926,
0.190216064453125,
-0.2114197015762329,
0.4730561077594757,
0.05079163983464241,
-0.5509987473487854,
0.5153327584266663,
0.5798231363296509,
0.7366137504577637,
-0.7107060551643372,
0.13828271627426147,
0.19997721910476685,
0.15451307594776154,
-0.28024160861968994,
-0.13517048954963684,
-0.23925834894180298,
-0.7751418948173523,
-0.4129154682159424,
-0.5382359623908997,
-0.22405336797237396,
0.1810881346464157,
-0.8518133163452148,
0.2763057053089142,
-0.3260493278503418,
0.00341531983576715,
0.036241933703422546,
-0.07378038018941879,
-0.17523406445980072,
0.11323176324367523,
-0.18748174607753754,
0.6893944144248962,
-1.1124989986419678,
1.3208482265472412,
0.8466913104057312,
-0.06330195814371109,
-0.7483618259429932,
-0.05094694718718529,
-0.027854636311531067,
-0.6479011178016663,
0.821359395980835,
-0.45976150035858154,
0.17576001584529877,
0.2029799371957779,
-0.18933241069316864,
-0.7704285383224487,
1.214942216873169,
0.47690722346305847,
-0.6400263905525208,
0.05131709203124046,
0.0968613401055336,
0.594160795211792,
-0.235142782330513,
0.17801642417907715,
0.5594552755355835,
0.24637340009212494,
0.34388136863708496,
-0.9896472096443176,
-0.22604766488075256,
0.14012405276298523,
0.07176242023706436,
0.24668124318122864,
-0.5644357204437256,
0.846916913986206,
-0.08313733339309692,
-0.08170462399721146,
-0.318768709897995,
0.6053844690322876,
-0.09587430208921432,
0.35660797357559204,
0.7928177714347839,
0.7878251671791077,
0.7912923097610474,
0.03337380290031433,
0.6056151986122131,
-0.30977174639701843,
0.46716997027397156,
1.3023887872695923,
-0.06972628086805344,
0.5269752740859985,
0.698157012462616,
-0.4382663369178772,
0.4138152003288269,
0.4390251040458679,
0.3218615651130676,
0.8905229568481445,
0.1961691826581955,
-0.42160341143608093,
-0.31700870394706726,
0.34510189294815063,
-0.3842286765575409,
0.40053489804267883,
0.11146286129951477,
-0.2924768924713135,
-0.6271733641624451,
0.6323601603507996,
-0.020726613700389862,
0.5059501528739929,
-0.28894171118736267,
0.8392930030822754,
0.011743948794901371,
-0.7066896557807922,
0.9360266923904419,
-0.07930094003677368,
0.5646178722381592,
-0.3487609624862671,
0.07047069817781448,
-0.42994892597198486,
0.4347020089626312,
0.13536381721496582,
-0.4415826201438904,
0.5540079474449158,
-0.15977410972118378,
-0.594375729560852,
-0.3593662679195404,
0.7998505234718323,
-0.8702750205993652,
-0.4235707223415375,
0.0734085738658905,
0.37908098101615906,
-0.021983638405799866,
0.09832664579153061,
-0.5667667388916016,
-0.004988798405975103,
0.2235129326581955,
-0.23653371632099152,
0.4079888164997101,
0.6604092121124268,
0.06306174397468567,
0.9385844469070435,
0.28865376114845276,
-0.10223131626844406,
0.21708695590496063,
-0.08453161269426346,
1.088399052619934,
-0.366088330745697,
-0.3389456272125244,
-1.0380109548568726,
0.4419161379337311,
0.14572787284851074,
-0.03271709382534027,
0.8027979731559753,
0.3563400208950043,
0.9701863527297974,
-0.09614747762680054,
0.6904751062393188,
-0.040106698870658875,
0.6075071692466736,
-0.6001257300376892,
0.9904751777648926,
-0.45307838916778564,
0.5457294583320618,
-0.2942236065864563,
-0.8697929978370667,
0.10887452214956284,
0.6406193971633911,
-0.2583327293395996,
0.08356306701898575,
0.6557850241661072,
0.3364088833332062,
-0.019537396728992462,
-0.05383327603340149,
0.41155561804771423,
0.26499730348587036,
0.5146265625953674,
0.4109730124473572,
0.8337777853012085,
-0.5688355565071106,
0.47380080819129944,
-0.5502447485923767,
-0.10537780821323395,
-0.07644923031330109,
-0.763026237487793,
-0.7029798030853271,
-0.7440575957298279,
-0.7492645978927612,
-0.2027135193347931,
0.17885297536849976,
0.7061609029769897,
0.5131482481956482,
-0.5775856971740723,
-0.221720889210701,
-0.15320825576782227,
0.2403663545846939,
-0.1654488891363144,
-0.2721675932407379,
0.3327775299549103,
-0.655689537525177,
-0.8195059299468994,
0.18300534784793854,
-0.3359687924385071,
0.24816195666790009,
-0.27997109293937683,
-0.255352646112442,
-0.17876702547073364,
-0.194339781999588,
0.4524969756603241,
0.10095202922821045,
-0.46746107935905457,
-0.35379403829574585,
-0.29195764660835266,
0.038442011922597885,
-0.2943553924560547,
0.8766154646873474,
-1.1611546277999878,
0.6446204781532288,
0.16251464188098907,
0.5238572955131531,
0.45654991269111633,
-0.24957354366779327,
0.6751995086669922,
-0.6950745582580566,
0.1886320859193802,
0.0895407572388649,
-0.009546414017677307,
0.12935620546340942,
-0.0952325090765953,
0.2988540232181549,
0.586164653301239,
-0.5427625179290771,
-1.0884990692138672,
0.037936676293611526,
-0.43248286843299866,
-0.5693057775497437,
1.0941828489303589,
-0.3667208254337311,
-0.007245025131851435,
-0.3380083739757538,
0.03943613916635513,
0.30310696363449097,
-0.31179845333099365,
1.170753002166748,
0.981552004814148,
0.11454566568136215,
-0.09428086131811142,
-0.42381781339645386,
0.7563351392745972,
0.468475878238678,
-0.30932384729385376,
0.43292951583862305,
0.47322747111320496,
0.6706647872924805,
-0.09477215260267258,
0.7059942483901978,
0.127950519323349,
0.21911902725696564,
0.0016366227064281702,
0.04400085285305977,
-0.14071966707706451,
-0.3387698531150818,
-0.21959000825881958,
-0.0763193741440773,
0.45628947019577026,
-0.16820119321346283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11889v2 | ROSE Doesn't Do That: Boosting the Safety of Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models with Reverse Prompt Contrastive Decoding | 2024-02-19T06:58:42 | 2024-06-17T02:48:21 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the development of instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs),
improving the safety of LLMs has become more critical. However, the current
approaches for aligning the LLMs output with expected safety usually require
substantial training efforts, e.g., high-quality safety data and expensive
computational resources, which are costly and inefficient. To this end, we
present reverse prompt contrastive decoding (ROSE), a simple-yet-effective
method to directly boost the safety of existing instruction-tuned LLMs without
any additional training. The principle of ROSE is to improve the probability of
desired safe output via suppressing the undesired output induced by the
carefully-designed reverse prompts. Experiments on 6 safety and 2
general-purpose tasks show that, our ROSE not only brings consistent and
significant safety improvements (up to +13.8% safety score) upon 5 types of
instruction-tuned LLMs, but also benefits the general-purpose ability of LLMs.
In-depth analyses explore the underlying mechanism of ROSE, and reveal when and
where to use it. | [
0.06515701860189438,
-0.5758388638496399,
0.25767210125923157,
0.17440564930438995,
-0.388656347990036,
-0.01914658583700657,
0.012789699248969555,
-0.25755757093429565,
0.12016567587852478,
0.37618160247802734,
-0.703214704990387,
-0.5518714189529419,
-0.39925771951675415,
0.11726418137550354,
-0.4516920745372772,
1.190190076828003,
0.29093626141548157,
0.002394238719716668,
0.001212610863149166,
0.32810646295547485,
-0.2884656488895416,
-0.5558094382286072,
-0.7835330367088318,
-0.08234445005655289,
0.6058366298675537,
0.4963666796684265,
0.6166014075279236,
0.8393868803977966,
0.45638877153396606,
0.20591755211353302,
-0.3518436849117279,
0.08180739730596542,
-0.801767885684967,
0.04333467036485672,
0.07697132229804993,
-0.7578831911087036,
-0.5405982136726379,
-0.07571503520011902,
0.5921788811683655,
0.4927207827568054,
0.10315118730068207,
-0.2621922194957733,
0.39705246686935425,
1.0283684730529785,
-0.860382080078125,
-0.14896520972251892,
-0.5919308662414551,
-0.03966779261827469,
-0.020470917224884033,
-0.7438433766365051,
-0.6228657364845276,
-0.7607688307762146,
-0.18333135545253754,
-0.2274855077266693,
0.33450981974601746,
0.11561927944421768,
0.7296900749206543,
0.25523194670677185,
-0.1496341973543167,
-0.027680428698658943,
-0.5375449061393738,
0.9584259986877441,
-0.6362177133560181,
0.28476232290267944,
0.3150809109210968,
0.1854395866394043,
-0.2997162342071533,
-0.2486676573753357,
-0.2797064781188965,
-0.17173320055007935,
0.07407432794570923,
0.21195366978645325,
0.12493053078651428,
0.01864258386194706,
0.41949692368507385,
0.32406026124954224,
-0.3682525157928467,
0.23769624531269073,
-0.11804433166980743,
-0.2513011693954468,
0.37646445631980896,
0.2828575372695923,
0.4283447265625,
0.23875364661216736,
-0.49435654282569885,
-0.2566867470741272,
-1.5234540700912476,
0.24211205542087555,
0.24818043410778046,
0.6205363869667053,
-0.22514291107654572,
0.29177525639533997,
-0.15609529614448547,
0.6194743514060974,
-0.22329553961753845,
-0.14133818447589874,
0.2061588168144226,
-0.09625045955181122,
-0.3179561197757721,
0.12445905059576035,
0.7316950559616089,
0.5520301461219788,
0.29573243856430054,
-0.29044267535209656,
-0.22855046391487122,
0.4215983748435974,
-0.005349266808480024,
-1.0814777612686157,
-0.4080379009246826,
0.07468201965093613,
-0.19876685738563538,
-0.6103763580322266,
-0.22013799846172333,
-0.7481701970100403,
-0.5097029805183411,
-0.06657778471708298,
0.23958127200603485,
-0.40206974744796753,
-0.11815629154443741,
-0.04456662759184837,
-0.09680961072444916,
0.2719927728176117,
0.2660578489303589,
-0.9737492203712463,
-0.1653459072113037,
0.7991570234298706,
0.679024338722229,
-0.06094415485858917,
-0.27756011486053467,
-1.227400302886963,
-0.02335282973945141,
-0.8190790414810181,
0.5584282875061035,
-0.8450441956520081,
-0.6450244784355164,
0.2904985547065735,
0.22929862141609192,
0.13379593193531036,
-0.40013664960861206,
0.8305192589759827,
-0.7386932969093323,
0.002576985862106085,
-0.9200649261474609,
-0.2856331169605255,
0.16729781031608582,
0.11984176933765411,
-0.2899141311645508,
0.3038555085659027,
-0.4045630395412445,
-0.7975003719329834,
0.4027780592441559,
-0.12275654822587967,
-0.8438553810119629,
-0.1989242285490036,
-0.3860057294368744,
-0.4551069140434265,
0.11001373827457428,
0.40849363803863525,
0.25171512365341187,
-0.21227137744426727,
-0.18712319433689117,
-0.21446312963962555,
-0.6220842599868774,
0.21930135786533356,
-0.7300279140472412,
0.9634524583816528,
-0.030383622273802757,
-0.09069976955652237,
0.31134214997291565,
-0.8487329483032227,
-0.15535110235214233,
0.08858340233564377,
-0.7220834493637085,
-0.23600253462791443,
-0.023716634139418602,
-0.27069994807243347,
0.025802168995141983,
-0.008322272449731827,
-0.6386291980743408,
-0.05769612267613411,
-0.7156141996383667,
0.16615131497383118,
0.7075009346008301,
-0.1928306370973587,
0.5406733155250549,
-0.4827137887477875,
0.5930563807487488,
0.1276264637708664,
-0.13054442405700684,
-0.5770760774612427,
-0.5718811750411987,
-0.8341478705406189,
-0.186244934797287,
0.12881527841091156,
0.8157382011413574,
-0.8640835881233215,
0.5235426425933838,
-0.10352188348770142,
-0.09496167302131653,
-0.6414582133293152,
0.21555683016777039,
0.7694476246833801,
1.155552864074707,
0.5279743075370789,
0.23941130936145782,
-0.2608918845653534,
-0.7699760794639587,
-0.4083392918109894,
-0.014891255646944046,
0.01713225431740284,
-0.13661250472068787,
0.0023254507686942816,
-0.09860669076442719,
0.626679003238678,
-0.4254278838634491,
-0.1495789736509323,
-0.19643504917621613,
0.09578456729650497,
0.3086518943309784,
0.7433596253395081,
0.47659793496131897,
-0.5976637005805969,
-0.36615899205207825,
-0.26670533418655396,
-0.6154212951660156,
-0.0905974954366684,
-0.1579703986644745,
-0.25548452138900757,
0.258277028799057,
0.8648003935813904,
-0.32395458221435547,
0.36269110441207886,
0.31791090965270996,
-0.15848557651042938,
0.4292812943458557,
-0.3067505359649658,
0.224388986825943,
-1.0090363025665283,
-0.14487037062644958,
0.025855777785182,
-0.09318343549966812,
-0.7112199068069458,
0.027028126642107964,
0.5677222013473511,
-0.2079506665468216,
-0.4007006585597992,
0.1655651479959488,
-0.41467422246932983,
0.11336103081703186,
-0.5863320231437683,
0.03400815650820732,
0.13371671736240387,
0.3363646864891052,
0.016518646851181984,
1.0977684259414673,
0.7566129565238953,
-0.8741559982299805,
0.19604918360710144,
0.13091568648815155,
-0.2885355055332184,
0.6374013423919678,
-0.6769710779190063,
0.08805102109909058,
-0.3465157449245453,
0.07554503530263901,
-1.1782273054122925,
-0.10761978477239609,
0.379781037569046,
-0.3762313425540924,
0.8291237950325012,
-0.3179628551006317,
-0.02798776887357235,
-0.16409052908420563,
-0.4979800581932068,
0.2068714201450348,
1.0574054718017578,
-1.033602237701416,
0.26831677556037903,
0.05861005187034607,
-0.17146402597427368,
-0.9284011721611023,
-1.1090127229690552,
0.06051033362746239,
-0.21882620453834534,
-0.3947787582874298,
0.2112143337726593,
-0.1534944474697113,
-0.025647766888141632,
-0.09117516130208969,
-0.29976311326026917,
0.3494340479373932,
0.3973553478717804,
0.1816105842590332,
0.4041789472103119,
-0.3611067831516266,
0.2582991421222687,
0.28696393966674805,
-0.39263010025024414,
0.2324802577495575,
0.11223339289426804,
0.22517238557338715,
-0.11114775389432907,
-0.5695732235908508,
-0.7924749255180359,
0.1581839621067047,
0.42773371934890747,
-0.07141640037298203,
0.8119512796401978,
0.24213504791259766,
-0.06273329257965088,
-0.31767505407333374,
-0.18264079093933105,
-0.4345192611217499,
-0.5404987931251526,
0.3182753026485443,
-0.39545610547065735,
-0.5496155619621277,
0.10945429652929306,
-0.15058811008930206,
0.5368512868881226,
0.2095777690410614,
0.21959182620048523,
-0.3419421911239624,
1.0479423999786377,
0.5851759314537048,
-0.2005809247493744,
0.5149789452552795,
0.09482378512620926,
0.16366328299045563,
-0.887547492980957,
-0.11995401978492737,
-0.7217758893966675,
-0.28875115513801575,
-0.32865190505981445,
0.07225684076547623,
0.31989744305610657,
0.3806226849555969,
-0.23517805337905884,
0.08103368431329727,
-0.4970908463001251,
0.8083988428115845,
0.6090747714042664,
0.15817934274673462,
0.35252583026885986,
0.19468526542186737,
0.04579029232263565,
-0.0975940003991127,
-0.7417508959770203,
-0.4460579752922058,
0.8844420909881592,
0.31678810715675354,
1.2661540508270264,
0.21100252866744995,
0.9387657642364502,
-0.03276072442531586,
0.37252604961395264,
-0.7648571133613586,
0.7287205457687378,
-0.26031073927879333,
-0.17218732833862305,
-0.20448821783065796,
-0.6707253456115723,
-1.0503002405166626,
0.190410777926445,
-0.45349210500717163,
-0.38187167048454285,
0.20329833030700684,
0.6194710731506348,
-0.4666057527065277,
0.34719008207321167,
-0.8746875524520874,
0.4579838514328003,
-0.3129139244556427,
-0.43427371978759766,
-0.11865919828414917,
-0.5172473192214966,
0.4745308756828308,
0.12018130719661713,
0.18856097757816315,
0.04183734580874443,
-0.03684453293681145,
0.6778294444084167,
-0.38155633211135864,
1.0226672887802124,
-0.05309540033340454,
-0.4022444784641266,
-0.09339573234319687,
0.28652462363243103,
0.7695604562759399,
-0.19077199697494507,
0.04160488024353981,
-0.30403807759284973,
-0.30714863538742065,
-0.47476503252983093,
-0.6520254015922546,
1.1380950212478638,
-0.6621912717819214,
-0.9749501347541809,
-0.22433573007583618,
-0.4409750998020172,
-0.5025277137756348,
0.11606918275356293,
0.49607419967651367,
0.8369722962379456,
-0.03625292703509331,
0.158421128988266,
0.9355798363685608,
-0.44263842701911926,
0.5881320834159851,
0.47823649644851685,
-0.18136118352413177,
-0.39078807830810547,
1.2117911577224731,
-0.24104629456996918,
0.4069659113883972,
0.6807504892349243,
0.37474435567855835,
-0.42798417806625366,
-0.5654175877571106,
-0.5624057650566101,
0.16580618917942047,
-0.9321171641349792,
-0.13418662548065186,
-0.38439226150512695,
-0.11677641421556473,
-0.35369664430618286,
-0.31725403666496277,
-0.20262031257152557,
-0.2309509515762329,
-0.6659627556800842,
-0.15391550958156586,
0.4826657474040985,
0.5055084824562073,
-0.08393584936857224,
0.2217331826686859,
-1.0514856576919556,
0.4740889072418213,
0.6003615856170654,
0.3143395483493805,
0.011883651837706566,
-0.7797770500183105,
0.02280956506729126,
0.13155581057071686,
-0.06028878688812256,
-0.7843334078788757,
0.23105160892009735,
0.023015858605504036,
0.47400641441345215,
0.5770272612571716,
0.4767683744430542,
0.5098837018013,
-0.6410725116729736,
0.6029754281044006,
0.49829939007759094,
-0.6722899675369263,
0.7210289835929871,
-0.09843441098928452,
0.08675511926412582,
0.3965506851673126,
0.27121129631996155,
-0.019355248659849167,
0.032732877880334854,
-0.13798753917217255,
-0.751325786113739,
0.7668907046318054,
0.0008687548106536269,
0.3806721568107605,
-0.1552208662033081,
-0.02393038012087345,
0.027357494458556175,
-0.022417565807700157,
-0.4783708453178406,
-0.22113682329654694,
-0.19395974278450012,
-0.16348795592784882,
-0.209972083568573,
-0.6546465158462524,
-0.5097965598106384,
0.1154991090297699,
0.93597012758255,
0.17670901119709015,
-0.058877088129520416,
0.044984474778175354,
-0.11417251825332642,
-0.3383884131908417,
0.5599049925804138,
0.7185238599777222,
0.3184491991996765,
-0.3363085389137268,
0.29005753993988037,
0.012639608234167099,
-0.3223794996738434,
0.20581969618797302,
-0.08026205748319626,
-0.3480277955532074,
-0.27061688899993896,
0.45144394040107727,
0.8112689852714539,
0.2007599025964737,
-0.37858912348747253,
0.40687382221221924,
0.011125700548291206,
0.026738587766885757,
0.32537201046943665,
0.5359635353088379,
0.11245079338550568,
0.1513565331697464,
0.23453569412231445,
0.09367494285106659,
-0.2680819034576416,
-0.5364335775375366,
0.05728182569146156,
0.6515716314315796,
-0.21081194281578064,
-0.19483549892902374,
0.6483328342437744,
0.8110743761062622,
-0.6527093648910522,
0.6011127233505249,
-0.04264754056930542,
-0.25362157821655273,
0.5846274495124817,
0.8052322268486023,
0.9790162444114685,
-0.21052537858486176,
-0.062403466552495956,
0.28264886140823364,
0.49283868074417114,
-0.15422318875789642,
0.493408739566803,
0.06933961808681488,
-0.6935442686080933,
-0.4105314314365387,
-0.4813966751098633,
-0.46089401841163635,
0.2920334041118622,
-0.5758417844772339,
0.0773593932390213,
-0.5362516045570374,
-0.011224795132875443,
-0.39756497740745544,
-0.4604036808013916,
-0.3111542761325836,
0.2709386944770813,
-0.01599297486245632,
1.094024896621704,
-1.0253502130508423,
0.7924250364303589,
0.5184600353240967,
-0.26994723081588745,
-0.4721086621284485,
0.40994253754615784,
-0.09311415255069733,
-0.8941245079040527,
0.7037745118141174,
0.30893567204475403,
-0.7225466966629028,
0.04000532627105713,
-0.535258948802948,
-0.4749949872493744,
0.7550166845321655,
0.5093536972999573,
-1.0598169565200806,
0.1310739815235138,
-0.08902130275964737,
0.2541465759277344,
-0.18490369617938995,
0.0024495692923665047,
0.48952072858810425,
-0.01918756030499935,
0.39060190320014954,
-0.3234473168849945,
0.11989449709653854,
-0.2743266522884369,
0.05001324042677879,
0.08911550790071487,
-0.26106446981430054,
0.7355316281318665,
-0.5706772208213806,
-0.6693551540374756,
0.21437597274780273,
0.6626310348510742,
0.3902911841869354,
0.13845518231391907,
0.2588960826396942,
0.6565003991127014,
0.7544355392456055,
-0.12312581390142441,
1.3182917833328247,
-0.43639442324638367,
-0.09479332715272903,
1.1363208293914795,
-0.1408277302980423,
0.9053534865379333,
0.37128299474716187,
-0.19954676926136017,
0.33991310000419617,
0.33610543608665466,
0.3645399510860443,
0.7199245691299438,
-0.07421237230300903,
-0.10341338813304901,
-0.6459918022155762,
0.053447309881448746,
-0.8793172836303711,
-0.30158817768096924,
0.3166675269603729,
-0.515518069267273,
-0.2909620702266693,
-0.23912380635738373,
-0.024321727454662323,
0.3165879249572754,
-0.4754889905452728,
0.387961208820343,
0.20718678832054138,
-0.48351433873176575,
1.0776147842407227,
-0.35259106755256653,
0.8819645047187805,
-0.33438369631767273,
-0.12868931889533997,
-0.4465327262878418,
0.2918337285518646,
-0.31787294149398804,
-0.8272914290428162,
0.07889344543218613,
0.19001568853855133,
-0.0644994005560875,
-0.0677105262875557,
0.623498797416687,
-0.3253616988658905,
-0.4566625952720642,
0.05624248459935188,
0.15881666541099548,
0.02078857459127903,
0.2614821493625641,
-0.5070657730102539,
0.1414564698934555,
-0.0187140591442585,
-0.06578722596168518,
0.460631787776947,
0.34371212124824524,
0.3922589421272278,
0.779297411441803,
0.8340702652931213,
0.12423630058765411,
-0.19819028675556183,
0.30412837862968445,
0.8927443623542786,
-0.7992627024650574,
-0.7537809610366821,
-1.0445717573165894,
0.548126757144928,
0.030593590810894966,
-0.05446939170360565,
0.7099069356918335,
0.23952321708202362,
0.5410339832305908,
-0.14911377429962158,
0.8612786531448364,
0.7480003237724304,
0.6971786618232727,
-0.8750105500221252,
0.5733446478843689,
-0.5921183824539185,
0.8167659044265747,
-0.19700241088867188,
-0.8002732992172241,
-0.33054041862487793,
0.5400762557983398,
-0.44365188479423523,
0.020156629383563995,
0.3274589478969574,
1.156008243560791,
0.014455422759056091,
0.09787670522928238,
0.48950162529945374,
0.2641753554344177,
0.4059939980506897,
0.5883191227912903,
1.1759662628173828,
-0.1908917874097824,
0.7052140831947327,
-0.05929354578256607,
-0.5261347889900208,
-0.35010120272636414,
-1.0521451234817505,
-1.361601710319519,
-0.02826063148677349,
-0.3699376881122589,
-0.6117368340492249,
0.11299439519643784,
0.8719046711921692,
0.4765752851963043,
-1.0855693817138672,
0.11791669577360153,
-0.5487527847290039,
0.18877747654914856,
-0.03786047548055649,
-0.14505989849567413,
0.4112566411495209,
-0.6572725772857666,
-0.5372067093849182,
0.9101489186286926,
0.37549155950546265,
0.3164713382720947,
0.02882462926208973,
-0.13951295614242554,
0.24640555679798126,
-0.02935054711997509,
0.37904295325279236,
0.6411718130111694,
-0.7072409987449646,
-0.02733798697590828,
-0.12668998539447784,
-0.2817658483982086,
0.05886529013514519,
0.5404635667800903,
-0.7992091774940491,
0.29303011298179626,
0.8014957904815674,
1.0264261960983276,
-0.13516554236412048,
0.13478319346904755,
0.49212121963500977,
-0.6446437239646912,
-0.03394626826047897,
0.05823377147316933,
0.44343075156211853,
0.500862181186676,
-0.4492720067501068,
0.1648130565881729,
0.21560706198215485,
-0.38166341185569763,
-0.8001936674118042,
0.7165618538856506,
-0.6208878755569458,
-0.39384207129478455,
1.3167139291763306,
-0.1552201360464096,
-0.17498508095741272,
-0.03186919540166855,
-0.2846878468990326,
0.06561730057001114,
-0.4627172350883484,
0.860272228717804,
0.043709125369787216,
0.0043748957104980946,
-0.20004716515541077,
0.0995330885052681,
0.8763973712921143,
0.6140059232711792,
-0.7450611591339111,
0.33146801590919495,
0.42182403802871704,
0.3074813783168793,
0.1670476794242859,
0.2837827205657959,
0.085297130048275,
0.3805522322654724,
-0.06083879619836807,
-0.421440988779068,
-0.36773523688316345,
-0.5568999648094177,
-0.8329131603240967,
0.20695939660072327,
0.15334151685237885,
-0.7040838599205017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14840v1 | RJUA-MedDQA: A Multimodal Benchmark for Medical Document Question Answering and Clinical Reasoning | 2024-02-19T06:57:02 | 2024-02-19T06:57:02 | Congyun Jin, Ming Zhang, Xiaowei Ma, Li Yujiao, Yingbo Wang, Yabo Jia, Yuliang Du, Tao Sun, Haowen Wang, Cong Fan, Jinjie Gu, Chenfei Chi, Xiangguo Lv, Fangzhou Li, Wei Xue, Yiran Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, stat.AP | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large Multi-modal
Models (LMMs) have shown potential in various medical applications, such as
Intelligent Medical Diagnosis. Although impressive results have been achieved,
we find that existing benchmarks do not reflect the complexity of real medical
reports and specialized in-depth reasoning capabilities. In this work, we
introduced RJUA-MedDQA, a comprehensive benchmark in the field of medical
specialization, which poses several challenges: comprehensively interpreting
imgage content across diverse challenging layouts, possessing numerical
reasoning ability to identify abnormal indicators and demonstrating clinical
reasoning ability to provide statements of disease diagnosis, status and advice
based on medical contexts. We carefully design the data generation pipeline and
proposed the Efficient Structural Restoration Annotation (ESRA) Method, aimed
at restoring textual and tabular content in medical report images. This method
substantially enhances annotation efficiency, doubling the productivity of each
annotator, and yields a 26.8% improvement in accuracy. We conduct extensive
evaluations, including few-shot assessments of 5 LMMs which are capable of
solving Chinese medical QA tasks. To further investigate the limitations and
potential of current LMMs, we conduct comparative experiments on a set of
strong LLMs by using image-text generated by ESRA method. We report the
performance of baselines and offer several observations: (1) The overall
performance of existing LMMs is still limited; however LMMs more robust to
low-quality and diverse-structured images compared to LLMs. (3) Reasoning
across context and image content present significant challenges. We hope this
benchmark helps the community make progress on these challenging tasks in
multi-modal medical document understanding and facilitate its application in
healthcare. | [
-0.22353538870811462,
-1.0234969854354858,
0.8420403599739075,
-0.05234363675117493,
-0.44153693318367004,
0.10464334487915039,
-0.06859375536441803,
-0.5075855255126953,
0.24361172318458557,
0.38610973954200745,
-0.4953271746635437,
-0.6155292987823486,
-0.3978537917137146,
0.3092586100101471,
0.017349429428577423,
0.7191822528839111,
-0.22855344414710999,
0.32488253712654114,
-0.497563898563385,
-0.5454090237617493,
-0.5649471282958984,
-0.3768843710422516,
-0.4616166055202484,
-0.2280881702899933,
0.6556512713432312,
0.000022065985831432045,
0.807982325553894,
0.7429301738739014,
0.8393932580947876,
0.2818955183029175,
0.0443078950047493,
0.5962997674942017,
0.0966641753911972,
0.3557119369506836,
-0.05765354260802269,
-0.3955208659172058,
-0.44726887345314026,
-0.28283771872520447,
0.68537837266922,
0.6245057582855225,
-0.11899595707654953,
0.1559361070394516,
-0.36176708340644836,
0.710284948348999,
-0.5390729904174805,
0.22263377904891968,
-0.31193625926971436,
0.11812857538461685,
-0.22542715072631836,
-0.4095281958580017,
-0.3604053854942322,
-0.46405038237571716,
-0.2611788213253021,
-0.8193841576576233,
0.008041873574256897,
0.010574039071798325,
1.022452473640442,
0.5357229113578796,
-0.6224966049194336,
-0.11554301530122757,
-0.24134641885757446,
0.47422918677330017,
-0.8236981630325317,
0.4799129068851471,
0.23566855490207672,
0.4342396855354309,
-0.24752074480056763,
-0.9646604657173157,
-0.4734053909778595,
-0.16523535549640656,
-0.03241592273116112,
0.4529617726802826,
0.08234309405088425,
0.06221066042780876,
0.37495964765548706,
0.37728333473205566,
-0.7013572454452515,
-0.005641927011311054,
-0.3132341504096985,
-0.27792850136756897,
0.42170992493629456,
0.29972147941589355,
0.5479040741920471,
-0.2228560596704483,
-0.451262503862381,
-0.14473828673362732,
-0.5745368599891663,
0.01678135059773922,
-0.3352569341659546,
-0.05230167508125305,
0.01173445675522089,
0.5358560085296631,
-0.36125248670578003,
0.47604531049728394,
-0.4276907742023468,
-0.7248398065567017,
0.7048218846321106,
-0.39184194803237915,
-0.3187527358531952,
-0.37195807695388794,
0.610908567905426,
0.6738668084144592,
-0.16140511631965637,
0.08123161643743515,
-0.10800380259752274,
0.22993911802768707,
0.20844505727291107,
-0.6946351528167725,
-0.01879645697772503,
0.314596951007843,
-0.8539876341819763,
0.11611098796129227,
-0.38161948323249817,
-0.6715887188911438,
-0.6643788814544678,
-0.1576116383075714,
0.4241825044155121,
-0.4033550024032593,
-0.1425315886735916,
0.10469699651002884,
0.007971271872520447,
0.13637234270572662,
0.6916189789772034,
-0.45993557572364807,
0.1144586130976677,
0.5810315012931824,
0.6987324953079224,
-0.09530708193778992,
-0.027866337448358536,
-0.586991548538208,
-0.1734277307987213,
-0.3937319219112396,
1.0499331951141357,
-0.3634243309497833,
-0.20498299598693848,
-0.009848291054368019,
0.19557876884937286,
-0.26078519225120544,
-0.7407438158988953,
1.0244196653366089,
-0.2813429534435272,
0.08104053884744644,
-0.240929514169693,
-0.2911311388015747,
-0.584254264831543,
0.6095719337463379,
-0.6979018449783325,
0.9786860942840576,
0.13378411531448364,
-0.5879794955253601,
0.47750234603881836,
-0.1807769536972046,
-0.3004550039768219,
0.2531088590621948,
-0.5617022514343262,
-0.663753092288971,
-0.011084319092333317,
0.5360773205757141,
0.3909246623516083,
-0.803000807762146,
0.482708215713501,
-0.3482465445995331,
-0.17955149710178375,
0.3069188892841339,
-0.49248212575912476,
0.3409355878829956,
0.2632199823856354,
-0.004474685061722994,
0.1116628497838974,
-0.8150733113288879,
0.22625593841075897,
0.17917518317699432,
-0.4234428405761719,
-0.2999442219734192,
-0.09316477924585342,
0.03626963123679161,
0.4802252948284149,
-0.04136517271399498,
-0.5654370784759521,
0.2053084820508957,
-0.2381342202425003,
0.31701141595840454,
0.30608588457107544,
0.31262874603271484,
-0.19446660578250885,
-0.719095766544342,
0.8071853518486023,
0.09420085698366165,
0.16459175944328308,
-0.5650125741958618,
-0.7198576331138611,
-0.407472163438797,
-0.8866367936134338,
0.37333613634109497,
0.5029007792472839,
-0.817508339881897,
-0.0902329683303833,
-0.3485737442970276,
-0.6002103090286255,
-0.8221127986907959,
-0.24577777087688446,
0.5974237322807312,
0.8425914645195007,
0.5421107411384583,
-0.5164589881896973,
-0.21027661859989166,
-1.206888198852539,
-0.21650058031082153,
-0.18281899392604828,
-0.010927346535027027,
0.401263564825058,
0.4706418514251709,
-0.2958635985851288,
0.3034716546535492,
-0.27911949157714844,
-0.4004128873348236,
0.03734203055500984,
0.09300003200769424,
0.2951332926750183,
0.32982781529426575,
0.37471938133239746,
-0.7518386244773865,
-0.23478537797927856,
0.00613158755004406,
-0.9010166525840759,
-0.31368687748908997,
-0.5214478373527527,
0.11208973824977875,
0.20580120384693146,
0.49139878153800964,
-0.40935972332954407,
0.5388860702514648,
0.4893895983695984,
-0.25745072960853577,
0.4726037085056305,
-0.4088888168334961,
0.6533377766609192,
-1.0066587924957275,
0.27554404735565186,
-0.04132985696196556,
-0.2628069221973419,
-0.40990397334098816,
0.28461235761642456,
0.46643581986427307,
-0.1337389349937439,
-0.22926554083824158,
0.5019334554672241,
-0.49411284923553467,
-0.0018689701100811362,
0.06765971332788467,
0.27508971095085144,
0.3584476411342621,
0.47263842821121216,
-0.09210721403360367,
0.7335594892501831,
0.28249579668045044,
-0.18145042657852173,
0.21393626928329468,
0.380624383687973,
-0.37331220507621765,
0.8215200901031494,
-0.6345024108886719,
-0.06627955287694931,
-0.28901687264442444,
0.36026090383529663,
-1.1613483428955078,
-0.08665033429861069,
0.08227337896823883,
-0.368714839220047,
0.2596401572227478,
0.0749528706073761,
-0.5718274116516113,
-0.23328232765197754,
-0.2800537049770355,
0.5321778059005737,
0.11957880109548569,
-0.37719762325286865,
0.9929277300834656,
0.24221470952033997,
-0.29932737350463867,
-0.6207417845726013,
-0.6316055059432983,
0.23875847458839417,
-0.06933068484067917,
-0.6968865394592285,
0.3463495969772339,
-0.08558464795351028,
-0.10346987098455429,
-0.10306555032730103,
-0.041278667747974396,
-0.14752447605133057,
0.12393569946289062,
0.3888952434062958,
0.44513291120529175,
-0.3750138580799103,
0.451973557472229,
0.20696139335632324,
-0.10932821035385132,
0.048037733882665634,
0.4870413839817047,
0.08730997890233994,
-0.10489755123853683,
-0.7686565518379211,
-0.4637003540992737,
0.42200666666030884,
0.8476473093032837,
-0.5162356495857239,
0.501223623752594,
0.34893789887428284,
-0.5280162692070007,
0.019362427294254303,
-0.693787157535553,
0.20114991068840027,
-0.31945228576660156,
0.5340802669525146,
-0.5877029895782471,
-0.4292208254337311,
0.7268098592758179,
-0.28045955300331116,
0.13131950795650482,
0.654282808303833,
0.682203471660614,
0.013334478251636028,
1.0723049640655518,
0.007636238820850849,
0.3448850214481354,
-0.08635345101356506,
0.11588292568922043,
-0.10911146551370621,
-0.9091677665710449,
-0.532164454460144,
-0.4859820306301117,
0.004525056108832359,
-0.2859658896923065,
-0.6251922249794006,
0.8443798422813416,
-0.12554265558719635,
-0.02490229345858097,
-0.22473381459712982,
-0.46878811717033386,
0.13294075429439545,
0.27309930324554443,
0.4137571156024933,
0.6296705603599548,
-0.44303277134895325,
-0.36675935983657837,
-0.13532420992851257,
-0.611144483089447,
-0.4540993869304657,
0.9317041039466858,
0.5982110500335693,
0.7558534145355225,
0.08212333917617798,
0.3087737560272217,
0.25127097964286804,
0.5137405395507812,
-0.9039317965507507,
0.3409063220024109,
0.06449989229440689,
-0.6175667643547058,
0.09529858827590942,
-0.17646485567092896,
-0.6974400877952576,
0.6577551960945129,
-0.6115976572036743,
-0.18231062591075897,
0.11601734161376953,
-0.12992103397846222,
-0.4143713712692261,
0.23277540504932404,
-0.5551273226737976,
0.8820412158966064,
-0.09260593354701996,
-0.20841582119464874,
-0.1324988454580307,
-0.7840501070022583,
0.37649649381637573,
-0.14379370212554932,
0.46371904015541077,
-0.20306913554668427,
-0.2815181016921997,
0.4849654734134674,
-0.3987725079059601,
0.5606774687767029,
-0.023563455790281296,
-0.10639265179634094,
-0.1112537607550621,
-0.025193840265274048,
0.276825487613678,
0.23344506323337555,
-0.029938260093331337,
-0.09456806629896164,
0.4873389005661011,
-0.25306636095046997,
-0.6796972155570984,
0.3497695326805115,
-0.39174705743789673,
-0.5458028316497803,
-0.5052052736282349,
-0.6287052035331726,
-0.4144509732723236,
0.29208624362945557,
-0.09201814979314804,
0.9111023545265198,
-0.08129200339317322,
0.42837733030319214,
0.6033738851547241,
-0.5254611372947693,
0.04110346734523773,
0.492146760225296,
-0.07089833915233612,
-0.5873836278915405,
0.5444925427436829,
0.04457530751824379,
0.14099432528018951,
0.39059358835220337,
0.024622416123747826,
-0.381442666053772,
-0.7561156153678894,
-0.8264523148536682,
0.4004243314266205,
-0.9977099895477295,
-0.46689459681510925,
-0.7318735122680664,
-0.15599049627780914,
-0.005117891822010279,
-0.01810288056731224,
-0.30694910883903503,
-0.40154021978378296,
0.02972470037639141,
0.18495391309261322,
0.005296668969094753,
0.3892455995082855,
0.2252882868051529,
-0.44573619961738586,
-0.9543323516845703,
0.6926829218864441,
0.046514421701431274,
0.37533247470855713,
-0.08411386609077454,
-0.4584556221961975,
-0.1397736817598343,
-0.2492372840642929,
-0.16301582753658295,
-0.7446261644363403,
0.21510376036167145,
0.15594767034053802,
0.7835750579833984,
0.2468290776014328,
0.1072673350572586,
0.5164462924003601,
-0.4289904534816742,
0.6579434275627136,
0.0622204914689064,
-0.5241747498512268,
0.3608972430229187,
-0.2671670913696289,
0.36847496032714844,
0.6439554691314697,
0.12242487818002701,
-0.6185036897659302,
-0.33938461542129517,
-0.3406604826450348,
-0.6588135361671448,
0.17291127145290375,
-0.15531758964061737,
-0.2708177864551544,
-0.12791050970554352,
0.43458133935928345,
0.09397482872009277,
-0.09401671588420868,
-0.40076977014541626,
-0.2471863031387329,
-0.1596253216266632,
-0.3989567160606384,
0.20418888330459595,
-0.1652660369873047,
-0.2836756110191345,
-0.09645064175128937,
0.5227469205856323,
-0.37050190567970276,
0.06572460383176804,
0.5787274241447449,
-0.1305752545595169,
0.02110513485968113,
0.38193875551223755,
0.7291602492332458,
0.7509515881538391,
-0.001318944152444601,
0.06835992634296417,
0.24452736973762512,
-0.6041634678840637,
-0.033106479793787,
0.278880774974823,
-0.11142096668481827,
-0.04423192888498306,
0.5065715909004211,
0.510934054851532,
0.018330998718738556,
-1.0548607110977173,
0.6340541839599609,
-0.27233821153640747,
-0.33005791902542114,
-0.12400346994400024,
-0.2885687053203583,
0.08676192909479141,
0.5131960511207581,
0.40114688873291016,
0.00122695358004421,
0.2528921663761139,
-0.5782080888748169,
0.1542283296585083,
0.4036041498184204,
-0.2674477696418762,
0.05506012216210365,
0.8202135562896729,
0.13841326534748077,
0.06946203112602234,
0.42670947313308716,
0.1988251954317093,
-0.25133565068244934,
0.6965417265892029,
0.4695630371570587,
0.42843034863471985,
0.17136439681053162,
0.07733900099992752,
0.5067870020866394,
0.3456209897994995,
-0.04587552323937416,
0.5661930441856384,
0.11385250836610794,
-0.48045119643211365,
-0.47453537583351135,
-0.28691157698631287,
-0.5519163012504578,
0.02991625666618347,
-0.659231960773468,
-0.06078501045703888,
-0.433583527803421,
-0.3119420111179352,
0.22232963144779205,
0.047589391469955444,
-0.3735175132751465,
0.5981633067131042,
0.11151952296495438,
1.012791633605957,
-0.5420389175415039,
0.6169663667678833,
0.6541988253593445,
-0.6377068161964417,
-0.7248737812042236,
-0.33563047647476196,
0.13523711264133453,
-0.8119854927062988,
0.3989558815956116,
0.1447012722492218,
-0.04551630839705467,
-0.3610546886920929,
-0.19015273451805115,
-0.4612247049808502,
1.2805119752883911,
0.160268634557724,
-0.27052146196365356,
0.04229466989636421,
-0.049905162304639816,
0.6381627321243286,
-0.3494439721107483,
0.3402077853679657,
0.3199651539325714,
0.38558852672576904,
-0.04620957002043724,
-1.028656244277954,
0.6212601065635681,
-0.4700133800506592,
-0.0049753692001104355,
0.10915406793355942,
-0.6816824674606323,
0.6482349038124084,
-0.22451120615005493,
-0.3348034918308258,
0.4048037827014923,
0.38720279932022095,
0.40845564007759094,
0.46183091402053833,
0.37184518575668335,
0.6330747604370117,
0.7223244905471802,
-0.2267971783876419,
1.1133947372436523,
-0.21983744204044342,
0.06073584780097008,
0.8243716359138489,
-0.22456835210323334,
0.7196637392044067,
0.37340784072875977,
-0.15789130330085754,
0.5760657787322998,
0.4582238495349884,
-0.002842852845788002,
0.2276948243379593,
0.041427623480558395,
-0.2960159480571747,
-0.2977248728275299,
-0.44276970624923706,
-0.7007145285606384,
0.3288849890232086,
0.4523083567619324,
-0.4753122329711914,
-0.11967617273330688,
-0.006172381341457367,
-0.03425908833742142,
0.33067503571510315,
-0.1855204850435257,
0.7408819198608398,
-0.029996544122695923,
-0.6379220485687256,
0.6555735468864441,
0.03954954445362091,
0.3741967976093292,
-0.5329034924507141,
-0.26509323716163635,
-0.32244089245796204,
0.10318171977996826,
-0.19030991196632385,
-0.6757540106773376,
0.22979049384593964,
-0.3531434237957001,
-0.07214736193418503,
0.07918881624937057,
0.6589224338531494,
-0.32462090253829956,
-0.21682393550872803,
-0.06762536615133286,
0.6743879318237305,
0.07265816628932953,
0.12173686176538467,
-0.7459414601325989,
0.1152166798710823,
-0.3522915840148926,
-0.16422763466835022,
0.2435389906167984,
0.580588698387146,
-0.16976596415042877,
0.8060408234596252,
0.5084990859031677,
0.02323603816330433,
-0.21568992733955383,
0.3855474591255188,
1.016130805015564,
-0.5659142732620239,
-0.2286001294851303,
-0.3651523292064667,
0.33868205547332764,
0.07873398065567017,
-0.467155396938324,
0.44228848814964294,
0.5318885445594788,
0.4245663583278656,
-0.04510948807001114,
0.4882909953594208,
0.21914105117321014,
0.7690175175666809,
-0.6485574841499329,
0.7548823952674866,
-0.9217377305030823,
-0.06655597686767578,
-0.27090469002723694,
-0.4304582178592682,
-0.6126316785812378,
0.3276144862174988,
0.08698518574237823,
-0.04554882273077965,
1.024985909461975,
0.8464655876159668,
0.10796438902616501,
-0.12172594666481018,
0.3955208957195282,
0.09141872823238373,
0.2895239591598511,
0.5975353717803955,
0.7365245223045349,
-0.6063776016235352,
0.4449033737182617,
0.004022625740617514,
-0.2790537476539612,
0.01854182407259941,
-0.701446533203125,
-0.7425227761268616,
-0.6061379909515381,
-0.2894158363342285,
-0.3480619192123413,
0.012135417200624943,
0.8416498303413391,
0.49106502532958984,
-0.5407983064651489,
0.5312079787254333,
0.4639132022857666,
-0.028062958270311356,
-0.43726295232772827,
-0.11433075368404388,
0.6018192172050476,
-0.1501169055700302,
-0.46532896161079407,
0.36629533767700195,
0.5094214677810669,
-0.2074163407087326,
-0.2128046303987503,
0.19331198930740356,
-0.37328627705574036,
0.08092150092124939,
0.5289852619171143,
0.439906507730484,
-0.7617301940917969,
-0.14999224245548248,
-0.006964472122490406,
-0.3925149142742157,
0.342497855424881,
0.640087366104126,
-0.7914546132087708,
0.7567045092582703,
0.5016807913780212,
1.0053601264953613,
0.33805930614471436,
0.16532336175441742,
0.25551241636276245,
-0.24754780530929565,
-0.0178228747099638,
0.2497154027223587,
0.5536741614341736,
0.2907699644565582,
-0.11610972881317139,
0.6228561997413635,
0.25715312361717224,
-0.5115082859992981,
-0.7555103898048401,
0.10057780146598816,
-1.1061549186706543,
-0.36144140362739563,
0.8859034180641174,
-0.3396569490432739,
-0.14057449996471405,
-0.4148333966732025,
-0.5127862095832825,
0.26272356510162354,
-0.0981588363647461,
0.7502957582473755,
0.3971882462501526,
-0.14375007152557373,
-0.3482339382171631,
-0.7620644569396973,
0.36384475231170654,
0.6379558444023132,
-1.1986699104309082,
-0.19482819736003876,
0.6962075233459473,
0.14221514761447906,
0.05560635030269623,
0.9216870069503784,
-0.5832726955413818,
0.7041079998016357,
-0.03175925090909004,
-0.16895729303359985,
-0.30043932795524597,
-0.26582443714141846,
-0.2824048697948456,
0.2828129231929779,
0.029692616313695908,
-0.11195824295282364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11886v1 | The Colorful Future of LLMs: Evaluating and Improving LLMs as Emotional Supporters for Queer Youth | 2024-02-19T06:54:55 | 2024-02-19T06:54:55 | Shir Lissak, Nitay Calderon, Geva Shenkman, Yaakov Ophir, Eyal Fruchter, Anat Brunstein Klomek, Roi Reichart | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Queer youth face increased mental health risks, such as depression, anxiety,
and suicidal ideation. Hindered by negative stigma, they often avoid seeking
help and rely on online resources, which may provide incompatible information.
Although access to a supportive environment and reliable information is
invaluable, many queer youth worldwide have no access to such support. However,
this could soon change due to the rapid adoption of Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as ChatGPT. This paper aims to comprehensively explore the
potential of LLMs to revolutionize emotional support for queers. To this end,
we conduct a qualitative and quantitative analysis of LLM's interactions with
queer-related content. To evaluate response quality, we develop a novel
ten-question scale that is inspired by psychological standards and expert
input. We apply this scale to score several LLMs and human comments to posts
where queer youth seek advice and share experiences. We find that LLM responses
are supportive and inclusive, outscoring humans. However, they tend to be
generic, not empathetic enough, and lack personalization, resulting in
nonreliable and potentially harmful advice. We discuss these challenges,
demonstrate that a dedicated prompt can improve the performance, and propose a
blueprint of an LLM-supporter that actively (but sensitively) seeks user
context to provide personalized, empathetic, and reliable responses. Our
annotated dataset is available for further research. | [
-0.4624781906604767,
-0.4966447353363037,
0.7147353291511536,
0.5416146516799927,
-0.24346934258937836,
0.34019267559051514,
-0.23670147359371185,
-0.5230918526649475,
0.4736921787261963,
0.09761341661214828,
-1.0893819332122803,
-0.15378697216510773,
-0.40192317962646484,
0.23254744708538055,
-0.4015410244464874,
1.0907293558120728,
0.03558632731437683,
0.13256655633449554,
-0.07644782960414886,
0.008877662941813469,
-0.6499204635620117,
-0.0595286563038826,
-0.680047333240509,
-0.006620446685701609,
0.9760648012161255,
0.39071592688560486,
0.5532310605049133,
0.07343744486570358,
0.20352289080619812,
0.35673731565475464,
-0.3360852599143982,
-0.13610321283340454,
-1.0565847158432007,
0.60101717710495,
-0.1521625816822052,
-0.43220603466033936,
-0.5553045272827148,
-0.019381191581487656,
0.4644988477230072,
0.43380311131477356,
-0.16084203124046326,
-0.013670756481587887,
0.04253317788243294,
0.7547619938850403,
-0.2582876682281494,
-0.08855988085269928,
-0.6816911101341248,
0.25107985734939575,
-0.22796893119812012,
0.12978406250476837,
0.10053317993879318,
-0.42099565267562866,
-0.18544112145900726,
-0.5642275810241699,
-0.24483974277973175,
0.16772715747356415,
0.32930129766464233,
-0.18590646982192993,
-0.7129387259483337,
-0.2122887372970581,
-0.7704289555549622,
0.6093947291374207,
-0.5280839204788208,
0.4760430157184601,
0.2489875704050064,
0.446734756231308,
-0.37666240334510803,
-0.5794954299926758,
-0.5960334539413452,
0.12776575982570648,
0.2834119200706482,
0.5128278136253357,
-0.14878378808498383,
-0.03923267126083374,
-0.08307544142007828,
0.2512768507003784,
-0.5503852963447571,
-0.14017394185066223,
-0.349830687046051,
0.12202642112970352,
0.8360978364944458,
0.4469154179096222,
0.4197506010532379,
0.1189701035618782,
-0.6357167363166809,
0.3014342486858368,
-0.4012928009033203,
0.20953263342380524,
0.49262428283691406,
0.22933758795261383,
-0.156223863363266,
0.5979031920433044,
0.07670202851295471,
-0.12335889786481857,
0.07933177798986435,
0.11333521455526352,
-0.01463086437433958,
-0.18328776955604553,
-0.09573668986558914,
-0.16364414989948273,
0.6720452904701233,
0.5392954349517822,
0.4050687551498413,
0.0014557043323293328,
-0.4982576072216034,
-0.28328049182891846,
0.38567253947257996,
-0.784960925579071,
0.051443759351968765,
0.46259185671806335,
-0.5716339945793152,
0.3038981854915619,
-0.08868767321109772,
-0.8831049799919128,
-1.0903211832046509,
-0.27082359790802,
0.3305591642856598,
-0.4997427463531494,
-0.3402194380760193,
0.14981476962566376,
-0.12771083414554596,
-0.0541067011654377,
0.7321707010269165,
-0.828316330909729,
0.08200861513614655,
0.7377843856811523,
0.760664701461792,
-0.15045619010925293,
0.028550148010253906,
0.0016006750520318747,
-0.14366860687732697,
-0.18852847814559937,
0.6127923130989075,
-0.5075161457061768,
-0.2956429421901703,
0.07628537714481354,
0.06721223145723343,
0.04759112372994423,
-0.25129085779190063,
0.5451576113700867,
-0.42713019251823425,
0.09979423135519028,
-0.5724193453788757,
-0.597614586353302,
0.23145565390586853,
0.24961867928504944,
-0.48016297817230225,
0.6744388937950134,
0.11460422724485397,
-0.6749489307403564,
0.2588743269443512,
-0.3966810703277588,
0.19994381070137024,
0.35218629240989685,
0.049478597939014435,
0.019168894737958908,
0.20122960209846497,
0.05627639964222908,
0.5666936039924622,
-0.09167128056287766,
0.14856699109077454,
-0.74464350938797,
-0.5746989846229553,
0.49732062220573425,
-0.2343052178621292,
0.5420140624046326,
0.07042569667100906,
-0.25569507479667664,
0.34789976477622986,
-0.396730899810791,
-0.25725364685058594,
0.14591102302074432,
-0.2766840159893036,
-0.03135719522833824,
-0.20636998116970062,
0.3616578280925751,
0.19873179495334625,
0.21488513052463531,
-0.6959404945373535,
-0.06718365848064423,
-0.24835105240345,
0.2089492529630661,
1.0730587244033813,
-0.06718563288450241,
0.13155797123908997,
-0.311297744512558,
0.9043896198272705,
-0.18667693436145782,
0.5136237740516663,
-0.11947192996740341,
-0.7644758224487305,
-0.3971908688545227,
-0.29557961225509644,
-0.46755892038345337,
0.1585671305656433,
-0.5666679739952087,
0.144460991024971,
0.1719600111246109,
-0.5287479758262634,
-0.3056755065917969,
0.3128044009208679,
-0.0812910795211792,
0.21449431777000427,
0.2645760178565979,
-0.0716695562005043,
-0.6853563785552979,
-0.7040247917175293,
-0.36127880215644836,
-0.6743683218955994,
0.10582899302244186,
0.3540585935115814,
0.3466356098651886,
-0.4117323160171509,
0.6594419479370117,
-0.06942234933376312,
-0.1480703204870224,
-0.2431505173444748,
-0.3125436305999756,
0.3598428964614868,
0.13092711567878723,
0.22852124273777008,
-0.936384916305542,
-0.6980266571044922,
-0.17436106503009796,
-0.3976198136806488,
-0.304109662771225,
-0.09005081653594971,
-0.31315919756889343,
-0.3395756483078003,
0.28104421496391296,
-0.4347226917743683,
0.034086354076862335,
0.5960525870323181,
-0.966211199760437,
0.6254329681396484,
0.33572784066200256,
0.21013419330120087,
-0.6762679219245911,
-0.11520013958215714,
0.13876374065876007,
-0.1692323386669159,
-0.816037118434906,
-0.3277149796485901,
-0.21357765793800354,
-0.03182061389088631,
-0.6014328598976135,
0.8199240565299988,
-0.17205972969532013,
0.19476798176765442,
-0.26113161444664,
0.3082253932952881,
-0.239350825548172,
0.20013312995433807,
-0.3593948781490326,
0.6852064728736877,
0.4321160912513733,
-0.04397884011268616,
0.7539716958999634,
0.22263306379318237,
0.015198471024632454,
0.8402690291404724,
-0.6978512406349182,
0.03154382109642029,
-0.3508843779563904,
0.40074408054351807,
-1.4218541383743286,
-0.13881604373455048,
0.44357413053512573,
-0.4212420582771301,
0.19357843697071075,
-0.008392520248889923,
-0.3203441798686981,
-0.53413987159729,
-0.5816108584403992,
0.24629805982112885,
0.31282559037208557,
-0.2616810202598572,
0.5209323763847351,
0.4863288998603821,
-0.5531342625617981,
-0.45135238766670227,
-0.22252003848552704,
0.2728111743927002,
-0.5342473983764648,
-0.6230279207229614,
0.11128677427768707,
-0.5111121535301208,
-0.42165032029151917,
-0.05852000042796135,
-0.022465869784355164,
-0.008781809359788895,
0.3601064085960388,
0.3325563073158264,
0.06992123275995255,
-0.138121098279953,
0.6390039324760437,
0.0012094053672626615,
0.2505651116371155,
0.22594863176345825,
0.020392388105392456,
0.6095210909843445,
-0.5892149806022644,
-0.34018421173095703,
-0.11183267086744308,
0.47027891874313354,
0.52071613073349,
0.1787044256925583,
0.740720272064209,
0.9928895831108093,
-0.4227772355079651,
-0.19362938404083252,
-0.5702431201934814,
-0.1437472552061081,
-0.5259903073310852,
0.3237963020801544,
0.17047928273677826,
-1.0602443218231201,
0.49015089869499207,
0.2849646508693695,
0.09343656897544861,
-0.023684188723564148,
0.7392773032188416,
-0.6254076957702637,
0.7349909543991089,
0.6967325210571289,
0.36893990635871887,
0.6234166622161865,
0.20625530183315277,
0.036915525794029236,
-0.8024075627326965,
-0.6000905632972717,
-0.0006563531933352351,
-0.8109349608421326,
-0.4222260117530823,
-0.31595906615257263,
0.23514717817306519,
0.09040722250938416,
-0.5451716184616089,
-0.05799540504813194,
-0.15971574187278748,
0.1469990611076355,
0.15122860670089722,
0.23821841180324554,
-0.07145380228757858,
-0.309303343296051,
0.14761675894260406,
-0.46070951223373413,
-0.37968575954437256,
-0.7606489658355713,
0.6509921550750732,
0.8138818740844727,
0.9250257611274719,
0.41525688767433167,
0.5144208669662476,
0.27005964517593384,
0.6784816384315491,
-0.8009628653526306,
0.7286103963851929,
0.04396333917975426,
-0.6867884993553162,
-0.3461715877056122,
-0.23883506655693054,
-0.9280729293823242,
0.23484009504318237,
-0.5739158987998962,
-1.0714958906173706,
0.31853368878364563,
-0.0023330848198384047,
-0.22769427299499512,
0.3197775185108185,
-0.3821333646774292,
0.46293899416923523,
-0.2490827590227127,
-0.7121964693069458,
0.12442859262228012,
-0.5507391691207886,
0.43602362275123596,
-0.3313322067260742,
0.20421700179576874,
-0.5985528826713562,
-0.40777894854545593,
0.7253400087356567,
-0.2519865930080414,
1.1964621543884277,
-0.12175609171390533,
-0.5266637206077576,
0.08509450405836105,
0.05545767769217491,
0.1813502311706543,
0.28813108801841736,
-0.36352136731147766,
-0.39773479104042053,
-0.021834682673215866,
-0.2849290668964386,
-0.6064176559448242,
0.7870895266532898,
-0.7344573140144348,
-0.708065390586853,
0.08281348645687103,
-0.5976693630218506,
-0.5583308339118958,
-0.003902261145412922,
-0.29432737827301025,
-0.18604594469070435,
-0.1686982810497284,
0.22374694049358368,
0.6478548049926758,
-0.3301968276500702,
0.5986571907997131,
0.12979359924793243,
-0.49901649355888367,
-0.5838950872421265,
0.34712377190589905,
-0.3088500201702118,
0.02237349934875965,
-0.06131995469331741,
0.40606600046157837,
-0.6164298057556152,
-0.08342038840055466,
-0.21187427639961243,
0.550569474697113,
-0.7705509066581726,
-0.19392088055610657,
-0.7482091188430786,
0.23506508767604828,
-0.4531172811985016,
-0.24762558937072754,
-0.3232341408729553,
-0.2527009844779968,
-0.3994958698749542,
-0.15251067280769348,
0.5384420156478882,
0.8340867161750793,
0.06632202118635178,
0.30544567108154297,
-0.9024828672409058,
-0.09327452629804611,
0.4926470220088959,
0.43484732508659363,
0.23037517070770264,
-0.2951836884021759,
-0.34691861271858215,
-0.10047090798616409,
-0.4185899496078491,
-1.3845528364181519,
0.35044407844543457,
0.25457656383514404,
0.49627652764320374,
0.5878488421440125,
0.16786199808120728,
0.5218812823295593,
-0.20114098489284515,
0.9216328859329224,
0.37815427780151367,
-0.9308463931083679,
0.4428851306438446,
-0.541496753692627,
-0.15204215049743652,
0.4244017004966736,
0.4970250725746155,
-0.9169987440109253,
-0.5404821038246155,
-0.37732744216918945,
-0.9165446758270264,
0.4324324131011963,
0.22091305255889893,
0.6613547205924988,
-0.052300188690423965,
0.5278299450874329,
0.0217126477509737,
0.4283427298069,
-0.9930033683776855,
-0.44653579592704773,
-0.25945204496383667,
-0.3070465624332428,
0.12968294322490692,
-0.40983954071998596,
-0.08654043078422546,
0.119710274040699,
0.4940340518951416,
-0.2788221538066864,
0.31441983580589294,
0.06670104712247849,
0.6621077656745911,
-0.4728740155696869,
0.41835442185401917,
0.33866092562675476,
0.27624794840812683,
-0.06361491978168488,
0.12862618267536163,
0.1916310042142868,
-0.4685194492340088,
0.3460974097251892,
-0.37248843908309937,
0.23674488067626953,
-0.1879144012928009,
0.28933006525039673,
0.7090550661087036,
0.02630172111093998,
-0.7697411179542542,
0.6359986662864685,
-0.24685153365135193,
0.21117672324180603,
-0.31125959753990173,
0.2871319353580475,
0.5335204005241394,
0.8665828108787537,
0.4005648195743561,
-0.4189963638782501,
0.15518243610858917,
-0.8126373291015625,
0.15460869669914246,
0.4663258492946625,
-0.8793053030967712,
-0.6409318447113037,
0.6880310773849487,
0.23203575611114502,
-0.3520388901233673,
0.21655628085136414,
0.1526440978050232,
-0.6212261319160461,
0.6305491924285889,
0.7104731798171997,
0.8326146006584167,
-0.03933129087090492,
0.41023969650268555,
0.21566851437091827,
-0.0002934046206064522,
0.1640385538339615,
0.6088581681251526,
0.2818918526172638,
-0.7159392237663269,
0.01282218936830759,
-0.5250299572944641,
-0.44687050580978394,
-0.025244614109396935,
-0.4632604122161865,
0.28436484932899475,
-0.6683092713356018,
-0.47482389211654663,
-0.6349115371704102,
0.132917121052742,
-0.579671323299408,
0.3462895452976227,
0.5399350523948669,
0.7886877059936523,
-0.81308513879776,
0.3766293525695801,
1.2368991374969482,
-0.1881587952375412,
-0.5129824876785278,
0.14713521301746368,
0.46221426129341125,
-0.7589221596717834,
0.7544598579406738,
0.13851943612098694,
0.053019046783447266,
-0.321607381105423,
-0.37823304533958435,
-0.6030623316764832,
1.1133050918579102,
0.4300970435142517,
-0.569219172000885,
0.12441571801900864,
0.07367081195116043,
0.8274757266044617,
-0.38231438398361206,
0.662631094455719,
0.03368167206645012,
0.5276961922645569,
0.17707112431526184,
-0.5827136635780334,
0.05638791248202324,
-0.35839489102363586,
0.0854196697473526,
-0.12443843483924866,
-0.9256173372268677,
0.9339832663536072,
-0.23343628644943237,
-0.49304792284965515,
0.10135642439126968,
0.8659583926200867,
0.5536280274391174,
0.32888418436050415,
0.5930231809616089,
-0.11432986706495285,
0.8990936279296875,
0.08162694424390793,
0.763372004032135,
-0.12035977840423584,
0.27008646726608276,
0.6151400208473206,
-0.1418704241514206,
0.8437117338180542,
0.6991037130355835,
-0.11823832988739014,
0.33086884021759033,
0.7652394771575928,
-0.004658830352127552,
0.08345205336809158,
0.364827960729599,
-0.5972723364830017,
-0.24633418023586273,
-0.46414124965667725,
-0.14167454838752747,
-0.04417238384485245,
0.42008447647094727,
-0.10046479105949402,
0.02511579543352127,
-0.01707802340388298,
-0.08567366003990173,
0.28100326657295227,
-0.3795124590396881,
0.4086914360523224,
0.474327027797699,
0.0339936800301075,
0.15415024757385254,
-0.37138116359710693,
0.8895835876464844,
-0.37482789158821106,
0.060662295669317245,
-0.6250321865081787,
-0.0053473105654120445,
-0.29491010308265686,
-1.1516729593276978,
0.08587730675935745,
-0.022729646414518356,
-0.02622561901807785,
-0.3444795310497284,
0.8724879026412964,
-0.5137451887130737,
-0.39927300810813904,
0.6232003569602966,
0.7556986808776855,
-0.04565554857254028,
0.10368898510932922,
-0.8659878969192505,
0.23856021463871002,
-0.163784459233284,
-0.32326316833496094,
0.3508087396621704,
0.8217812776565552,
0.2227391004562378,
1.1050796508789062,
0.5349347591400146,
0.4809024930000305,
-0.05316162109375,
-0.09316176176071167,
0.9588016867637634,
-0.7386850118637085,
-0.2718906104564667,
-0.8293740749359131,
0.7681645154953003,
0.13843074440956116,
-0.4863142967224121,
0.8610349893569946,
-0.05606643483042717,
0.44728362560272217,
0.16078433394432068,
0.2387939840555191,
0.23440678417682648,
0.26174336671829224,
-0.28694120049476624,
0.8768193125724792,
-0.8882217407226562,
0.5647494196891785,
-0.3821924030780792,
-1.027194857597351,
-0.23564507067203522,
0.30646318197250366,
0.051307227462530136,
0.22805292904376984,
0.2665838897228241,
0.7131756544113159,
0.29585000872612,
0.16843359172344208,
0.5163758397102356,
0.3309115767478943,
0.6844294667243958,
0.5179036259651184,
1.5092228651046753,
-0.09569518268108368,
0.35353270173072815,
-0.08790478110313416,
0.004777770023792982,
-0.07917021214962006,
-0.7553112506866455,
-0.9415582418441772,
-0.4952360689640045,
-0.2361019104719162,
-0.2504647970199585,
0.1757556051015854,
1.2643495798110962,
0.39899423718452454,
-0.4626099169254303,
-0.19859927892684937,
0.19463776051998138,
0.12824559211730957,
0.3103928565979004,
-0.22634455561637878,
-0.12949170172214508,
-0.3142852187156677,
-0.7217875123023987,
0.29233476519584656,
0.3214760422706604,
0.17882047593593597,
-0.42195791006088257,
-0.13679315149784088,
0.17720232903957367,
0.26779741048812866,
0.6165802478790283,
-0.027446841821074486,
-0.6002113223075867,
-0.09953762590885162,
0.2487364113330841,
-0.21779567003250122,
-0.09806381911039352,
0.5718396306037903,
-0.4613661766052246,
0.26234006881713867,
0.36464807391166687,
0.5683517456054688,
-0.010772350244224072,
-0.024928098544478416,
0.6481180787086487,
-0.31249570846557617,
-0.4675595164299011,
0.4748367369174957,
0.5815755128860474,
0.39743679761886597,
-0.579161524772644,
0.37536901235580444,
0.316322386264801,
-0.5178096890449524,
-0.6555517911911011,
0.02796182967722416,
-0.6888172030448914,
-0.023594971746206284,
1.4048835039138794,
-0.40224358439445496,
-0.14430198073387146,
-0.17358851432800293,
-0.4794347286224365,
-0.01909499801695347,
-0.8132674098014832,
0.7112828493118286,
0.43893152475357056,
-0.2752940058708191,
-0.579498291015625,
-0.36710190773010254,
0.2872530221939087,
0.3046127259731293,
-0.7221441864967346,
0.20270466804504395,
0.4076363146305084,
0.12652555108070374,
-0.294807106256485,
0.5528226494789124,
-0.0010059919441118836,
0.008193974383175373,
-0.35849863290786743,
0.06014374643564224,
0.10325237363576889,
-0.10069271177053452,
-0.3755181133747101,
-0.006714439485222101,
0.06355344504117966,
0.44256219267845154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11875v1 | M2K-VDG: Model-Adaptive Multimodal Knowledge Anchor Enhanced Video-grounded Dialogue Generation | 2024-02-19T06:32:39 | 2024-02-19T06:32:39 | Hongcheng Liu, Pingjie Wang, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Video-grounded dialogue generation (VDG) requires the system to generate a
fluent and accurate answer based on multimodal knowledge. However, the
difficulty in multimodal knowledge utilization brings serious hallucinations to
VDG models in practice. Although previous works mitigate the hallucination in a
variety of ways, they hardly take notice of the importance of the multimodal
knowledge anchor answer tokens. In this paper, we reveal via perplexity that
different VDG models experience varying hallucinations and exhibit diverse
anchor tokens. Based on this observation, we propose M2K-VDG, a model-adaptive
multimodal knowledge anchor enhancement framework for hallucination reduction.
Furthermore, we introduce the counterfactual effect for more accurate anchor
token detection. The experimental results on three popular benchmarks exhibit
the superiority of our approach over state-of-the-art methods, demonstrating
its effectiveness in reducing hallucinations. | [
-0.6463331580162048,
-1.022351861000061,
0.7526574730873108,
0.10671471059322357,
-0.4430060088634491,
-0.15037958323955536,
0.08666452020406723,
-0.13491611182689667,
0.270210862159729,
0.2795146703720093,
-0.806796133518219,
-0.5931118726730347,
-0.6913166046142578,
0.024599861353635788,
-0.013276767916977406,
0.729041576385498,
0.268589586019516,
0.3504863679409027,
-0.38663753867149353,
-0.35767146944999695,
-0.8425495028495789,
-0.45929962396621704,
-0.3773413300514221,
-0.11017527431249619,
0.2905172109603882,
0.3323308527469635,
0.858968198299408,
0.3772134482860565,
0.23262041807174683,
0.274792343378067,
0.12788265943527222,
0.4950447380542755,
-0.47907567024230957,
0.06689827144145966,
-0.13547945022583008,
-0.37188720703125,
-0.7060580849647522,
-0.14688724279403687,
0.2574846148490906,
0.3898208737373352,
-0.13265912234783173,
-0.025965629145503044,
-0.17559343576431274,
0.5696043372154236,
-0.7920043468475342,
0.05661162734031677,
-0.751565158367157,
0.1405339539051056,
0.6040984988212585,
-0.40529268980026245,
-0.43475398421287537,
-0.04139147698879242,
0.12098927050828934,
-0.8057934045791626,
0.2405758649110794,
-0.018459787592291832,
0.5916985273361206,
0.7346392273902893,
-0.5514963865280151,
-0.26729246973991394,
-0.4919576644897461,
0.5657745003700256,
-0.6659910678863525,
0.6674850583076477,
0.45630908012390137,
0.31172624230384827,
-0.10587707161903381,
-0.5113799571990967,
-0.7501459717750549,
-0.184060737490654,
0.02475721389055252,
0.24783611297607422,
-0.04860348999500275,
0.37392881512641907,
0.43420645594596863,
0.018221290782094002,
-0.5479760766029358,
-0.207508385181427,
-0.2420874685049057,
-0.37636932730674744,
0.17719672620296478,
0.3089457154273987,
0.19021454453468323,
-0.5890784859657288,
-0.5636138319969177,
-0.05539874732494354,
-0.6019349098205566,
-0.011053928174078465,
0.3199367821216583,
-0.1690729260444641,
0.07105163484811783,
0.5425416231155396,
-0.245644211769104,
0.5121365189552307,
0.3002353310585022,
-0.37723278999328613,
0.20529301464557648,
-0.24460476636886597,
-0.23643110692501068,
0.24782489240169525,
0.2936664819717407,
1.103122353553772,
0.1793890744447708,
0.08066152781248093,
0.2083563208580017,
0.19999529421329498,
0.6503896117210388,
-0.9092892408370972,
-0.3495098352432251,
0.27832767367362976,
-0.688873291015625,
-0.3256334364414215,
-0.0013584152329713106,
-0.9371997714042664,
-0.48948121070861816,
-0.3857581913471222,
0.5486440062522888,
-0.4720093011856079,
-0.51796555519104,
0.00719727948307991,
-0.29898446798324585,
0.28619998693466187,
0.5558446645736694,
-0.5183524489402771,
-0.04044598713517189,
0.45521408319473267,
0.8135231137275696,
-0.14607654511928558,
-0.14224225282669067,
-0.6790950894355774,
0.3760310411453247,
-0.35509437322616577,
0.5868302583694458,
-0.6524839997291565,
-0.3849811553955078,
-0.02775118313729763,
0.25187867879867554,
-0.03361110761761665,
-0.4357828199863434,
0.36411556601524353,
-0.23091036081314087,
0.11281432956457138,
-0.5827999711036682,
-0.36428704857826233,
-0.6301119923591614,
0.462917685508728,
-0.5213164687156677,
0.7985959053039551,
-0.12065467983484268,
-0.6151069402694702,
0.6425400972366333,
-0.37139931321144104,
-0.13649004697799683,
-0.26653972268104553,
-0.3118996322154999,
-0.3147909641265869,
0.4744492769241333,
0.5988760590553284,
0.3189581334590912,
-0.05167219787836075,
0.4007512927055359,
-0.46052563190460205,
-0.37282583117485046,
0.13895367085933685,
-0.6052477955818176,
0.26848867535591125,
0.22547295689582825,
-0.47304844856262207,
0.42514416575431824,
-1.167554259300232,
-0.20063188672065735,
-0.15226952731609344,
0.03929038718342781,
-0.37434470653533936,
0.02575194463133812,
-0.26071688532829285,
0.40668225288391113,
-0.2543019950389862,
-0.07199341058731079,
0.13113008439540863,
-0.04541589692234993,
0.16004806756973267,
0.9564553499221802,
0.135511577129364,
0.28893768787384033,
-0.4048500657081604,
0.5430868864059448,
0.537840723991394,
0.10689335316419601,
-0.37867286801338196,
-0.7428357005119324,
-0.8927279114723206,
-0.46115952730178833,
-0.29757657647132874,
0.38992559909820557,
-1.175449252128601,
0.20204219222068787,
-0.10794549435377121,
-0.17688776552677155,
-0.6507479548454285,
0.004800346214324236,
0.3278137445449829,
0.6757712364196777,
0.597159206867218,
-0.19163765013217926,
-0.6300731301307678,
-0.7017641663551331,
0.02091456949710846,
-0.31559130549430847,
-0.04132367670536041,
0.6705120205879211,
0.40227818489074707,
-0.3827076554298401,
0.6878929734230042,
-0.48162078857421875,
-0.34847065806388855,
0.22789156436920166,
0.36059272289276123,
-0.15538142621517181,
0.40313631296157837,
0.5097654461860657,
-0.9432837963104248,
-0.268915057182312,
-0.1533021777868271,
-0.9954829216003418,
0.008333967998623848,
-0.3825850784778595,
0.07454921305179596,
0.23708923161029816,
0.7371498346328735,
-0.9501595497131348,
0.6230077147483826,
0.5322288870811462,
-0.36282408237457275,
0.6824975609779358,
-0.25162628293037415,
0.5195769667625427,
-1.140320897102356,
-0.22187140583992004,
-0.47630658745765686,
-0.10202454775571823,
-0.5480666160583496,
-0.11572974175214767,
-0.11254637688398361,
-0.13429123163223267,
-0.2851274013519287,
0.39999985694885254,
-0.1830039620399475,
-0.017809094861149788,
-0.36509233713150024,
0.2801295816898346,
-0.04378492757678032,
0.73228919506073,
0.24208791553974152,
0.6020914912223816,
0.5605259537696838,
-0.6675599217414856,
0.44470444321632385,
0.34443071484565735,
-0.045687127858400345,
0.9324119091033936,
-0.3908689618110657,
0.29741936922073364,
-0.3423101305961609,
0.0014102900167927146,
-1.5133813619613647,
-0.2963104844093323,
0.31301942467689514,
-0.6032257676124573,
0.16515667736530304,
-0.3612426221370697,
-0.06399576365947723,
-0.0741519033908844,
-0.42900747060775757,
0.4795520305633545,
0.43589550256729126,
-0.7577618956565857,
0.8815855979919434,
-0.01116173155605793,
-0.03204839304089546,
-0.6063489317893982,
-0.22113317251205444,
0.18914051353931427,
-0.4366193115711212,
-0.7690913081169128,
0.2128484547138214,
-0.25749897956848145,
-0.10978846251964569,
0.012634098529815674,
-0.43261104822158813,
0.17612884938716888,
-0.05638078227639198,
0.5213866233825684,
0.01747897081077099,
-0.4568576514720917,
0.39068901538848877,
0.1794433444738388,
-0.2777509391307831,
0.15671959519386292,
-0.33181801438331604,
0.40369492769241333,
0.06987643241882324,
-0.5697405338287354,
-0.2644044756889343,
0.3772388994693756,
0.8446139693260193,
0.13267450034618378,
0.8594008684158325,
1.1105153560638428,
-0.422189861536026,
0.009352803230285645,
-0.8229489922523499,
-0.5608551502227783,
-0.4803258180618286,
0.5252697467803955,
-0.6950191259384155,
-0.7540648579597473,
0.5787316560745239,
-0.26806962490081787,
-0.3217548131942749,
0.14748014509677887,
0.7247451543807983,
-0.07276857644319534,
1.2485086917877197,
0.3751268982887268,
0.2357708066701889,
0.20849663019180298,
0.1858282834291458,
0.3838556408882141,
-0.6556715369224548,
-0.24162617325782776,
-0.10272540897130966,
-0.03656356781721115,
-0.36134159564971924,
-0.5077012181282043,
0.38351699709892273,
0.41982656717300415,
0.1789558231830597,
-0.009655612520873547,
-0.3917609453201294,
0.11470697820186615,
0.3273056745529175,
0.22374868392944336,
0.3659224808216095,
-0.06120119243860245,
-0.34591877460479736,
-0.4709152281284332,
-0.7428125739097595,
-0.35086989402770996,
1.1298376321792603,
0.2595219016075134,
0.6965800523757935,
0.19429586827754974,
0.08703828603029251,
0.47218620777130127,
0.013459138572216034,
-0.6188032627105713,
0.532335102558136,
0.28831782937049866,
-0.5192586779594421,
-0.30476081371307373,
-0.14762113988399506,
-0.2960537075996399,
0.4838820695877075,
-0.4437767565250397,
-0.5766876935958862,
0.1273791342973709,
0.3408164381980896,
-0.3960733115673065,
0.18457241356372833,
-0.7675305604934692,
0.7584530115127563,
0.015709340572357178,
-0.44690096378326416,
-0.5066298842430115,
-0.5220397710800171,
0.4086586534976959,
0.08184553682804108,
0.22511939704418182,
0.126311793923378,
0.271865576505661,
0.49487149715423584,
-0.3621874153614044,
0.8193759322166443,
-0.5559413433074951,
-0.07752300053834915,
0.395212322473526,
0.1686418652534485,
0.7975767850875854,
0.3989868462085724,
0.45183083415031433,
-0.056175217032432556,
-0.24012218415737152,
-0.22138004004955292,
-0.7945199012756348,
0.579378604888916,
-0.6205500364303589,
-0.8904805779457092,
-0.038088228553533554,
-0.7383503317832947,
-0.24686948955059052,
-0.08473938703536987,
0.11227018386125565,
0.34576618671417236,
-0.09051775932312012,
0.5595507621765137,
0.925164520740509,
-0.5842105150222778,
0.2571604549884796,
0.2595101594924927,
-0.31712061166763306,
-0.7340747714042664,
0.8775239586830139,
-0.013924943283200264,
0.27227258682250977,
0.018745072185993195,
0.14698456227779388,
-0.3300289213657379,
-0.5246987342834473,
-0.3935989439487457,
0.027222001925110817,
-1.015501856803894,
-0.14679744839668274,
-1.0916556119918823,
-0.06299083679914474,
-0.6522482633590698,
-0.2401941567659378,
-0.3325433135032654,
-0.36913949251174927,
-0.2655923068523407,
-0.6676873564720154,
0.48961660265922546,
0.27038338780403137,
-0.21387264132499695,
0.3768954575061798,
-0.6473711729049683,
0.9706812500953674,
0.7680573463439941,
0.20142848789691925,
-0.07511845976114273,
-0.4701518714427948,
-0.005292627960443497,
0.0692325159907341,
-0.13309939205646515,
-0.9156067371368408,
0.1482495218515396,
0.004069565795361996,
0.5660051703453064,
0.8896941542625427,
0.12708976864814758,
1.1134425401687622,
-0.4808292090892792,
0.8509902954101562,
0.39015406370162964,
-0.7893620729446411,
0.27928096055984497,
-0.3822232484817505,
0.11879013478755951,
0.28335386514663696,
0.42693570256233215,
-0.3230842649936676,
-0.09474951773881912,
-0.40021228790283203,
-0.6222084164619446,
0.5174093842506409,
0.20304222404956818,
0.03566822037100792,
-0.039512667804956436,
0.15260879695415497,
0.23533889651298523,
0.47217410802841187,
-0.9280958771705627,
-0.003401579335331917,
-0.8275988101959229,
-0.13952510058879852,
0.150889053940773,
-0.7141585350036621,
-0.3269493877887726,
-0.3190925121307373,
0.5848010182380676,
-0.48082366585731506,
0.3436506986618042,
0.3688848614692688,
-0.5147222280502319,
-0.16616478562355042,
0.0002616566780488938,
1.1007308959960938,
0.6447755098342896,
-0.47321823239326477,
0.24345465004444122,
0.34977439045906067,
-0.4583497941493988,
0.11260039359331131,
-0.3618737757205963,
0.01153088454157114,
0.16820964217185974,
0.34947001934051514,
1.0389715433120728,
0.14641700685024261,
-0.4770973324775696,
0.5284063220024109,
0.024019327014684677,
-0.402842253446579,
-0.22570829093456268,
0.11037244647741318,
0.06498485058546066,
0.4273839592933655,
0.33598536252975464,
0.13118956983089447,
0.09472259134054184,
-0.28637728095054626,
0.4472667872905731,
0.3940604627132416,
-0.827466607093811,
-0.2879822254180908,
0.8086573481559753,
0.21561042964458466,
-0.3883754014968872,
0.5024024844169617,
-0.1425984650850296,
-0.536044180393219,
0.3534460663795471,
0.45714762806892395,
1.0754441022872925,
-0.36589935421943665,
0.25542548298835754,
0.4643177390098572,
0.4811351001262665,
0.2011338621377945,
0.2565375566482544,
-0.34240391850471497,
-0.6798595786094666,
-0.27628466486930847,
-0.3382458984851837,
-0.15172293782234192,
0.35891982913017273,
-0.5268647074699402,
0.29189419746398926,
-0.43425214290618896,
-0.2177218198776245,
-0.4391704797744751,
-0.5859366655349731,
-0.48229435086250305,
0.19790183007717133,
0.017929738387465477,
0.39157959818840027,
-0.8680460453033447,
0.7836243510246277,
0.47428226470947266,
-0.2837861180305481,
-0.2093164473772049,
0.01172653492540121,
0.23606626689434052,
-0.6364787220954895,
0.6297258734703064,
0.31840407848358154,
-0.2740778625011444,
-0.0920042172074318,
-0.4464070796966553,
-0.5190823674201965,
1.077238917350769,
0.03628803789615631,
-0.21278074383735657,
-0.1277925819158554,
0.30958428978919983,
0.3879358768463135,
-0.5510914921760559,
0.28620460629463196,
0.30337175726890564,
0.6607888340950012,
0.24829083681106567,
-0.7260387539863586,
0.1863000988960266,
-0.14281725883483887,
-0.06723541021347046,
-0.3050869405269623,
-0.4872375428676605,
0.7047367691993713,
-0.27441099286079407,
0.05889279395341873,
-0.13118650019168854,
0.5584965944290161,
0.4431418776512146,
0.48780500888824463,
0.7106079459190369,
0.6117911338806152,
0.41261062026023865,
-0.01994871348142624,
0.4345315396785736,
-0.21775878965854645,
0.020735371857881546,
1.1234177350997925,
-0.156499981880188,
0.22740261256694794,
0.9814911484718323,
0.09309438616037369,
0.33904534578323364,
0.21631887555122375,
0.020341599360108376,
0.672119677066803,
-0.11912903934717178,
-0.08065161854028702,
-0.5518161058425903,
-0.11810403317213058,
-0.4302110970020294,
0.49165987968444824,
0.44416168332099915,
-0.14796237647533417,
-0.06243970990180969,
0.3407098352909088,
-0.19236743450164795,
-0.0062484778463840485,
-0.20879724621772766,
0.971347451210022,
0.07509936392307281,
-0.7145083546638489,
0.5697623491287231,
-0.19009169936180115,
0.35255107283592224,
-0.44139933586120605,
-0.5773804187774658,
-0.22602607309818268,
0.19851671159267426,
-0.17657288908958435,
-0.1261885017156601,
0.1643027514219284,
-0.22006748616695404,
-0.18980728089809418,
0.051767390221357346,
0.8573483824729919,
-0.36731451749801636,
-0.22660444676876068,
0.5110915303230286,
0.4794580340385437,
-0.06662578135728836,
-0.35334810614585876,
-0.45513224601745605,
-0.1482287496328354,
0.051046185195446014,
-0.22718779742717743,
0.13040459156036377,
0.7177859544754028,
-0.070508673787117,
0.7008795142173767,
0.8188033103942871,
-0.31539350748062134,
0.4262981712818146,
0.08303245157003403,
0.8542801737785339,
-0.7095609307289124,
-0.6218127608299255,
-0.7456303238868713,
0.8037543296813965,
-0.18538567423820496,
-0.09776150435209274,
0.8660827875137329,
0.17996063828468323,
0.6973385214805603,
-0.3798234164714813,
0.608148455619812,
0.09377792477607727,
0.11058992147445679,
-0.8525764346122742,
0.6449088454246521,
-0.6757628321647644,
0.12737424671649933,
-0.7297682762145996,
-1.0715909004211426,
-0.04892771318554878,
0.7293755412101746,
0.08238831907510757,
-0.054377857595682144,
0.7720451354980469,
1.165883183479309,
-0.08004303276538849,
-0.045383889228105545,
0.8326976895332336,
0.30380305647850037,
0.42519813776016235,
0.37235990166664124,
1.0346118211746216,
-0.524357259273529,
0.6218686103820801,
-0.057657863944768906,
-0.08873104304075241,
-0.5850605964660645,
-0.9893419742584229,
-1.3714126348495483,
-0.6942795515060425,
-0.331546425819397,
-0.42962777614593506,
0.09529485553503036,
0.8584549427032471,
0.7262114882469177,
-0.8661326169967651,
0.19948527216911316,
-0.02936038002371788,
0.27184656262397766,
-0.31258711218833923,
-0.23023487627506256,
0.4009157717227936,
-0.1890837699174881,
-0.30520132184028625,
0.43324241042137146,
0.5820545554161072,
0.03467123582959175,
-0.22280386090278625,
-0.44074395298957825,
-0.296371728181839,
0.14786526560783386,
0.6858980655670166,
-0.18762528896331787,
-0.9413148164749146,
-0.7007128596305847,
0.17704573273658752,
0.21528314054012299,
0.2861856520175934,
0.9437829256057739,
-0.802514910697937,
0.9015353918075562,
0.42956945300102234,
0.6241471171379089,
0.47150176763534546,
0.17974478006362915,
0.4963515102863312,
-0.6378815770149231,
0.5428003668785095,
-0.1390119343996048,
0.22277729213237762,
0.05249493941664696,
-0.39251768589019775,
0.3383277952671051,
0.6449482440948486,
-0.16469305753707886,
-0.8846877813339233,
0.2860981822013855,
-0.917068362236023,
-0.43011850118637085,
1.1478062868118286,
-0.04012726992368698,
0.1632416844367981,
-0.39382404088974,
-0.6661505103111267,
0.2536584138870239,
-0.19176878035068512,
1.1245489120483398,
1.0040167570114136,
0.13640549778938293,
-0.4845924377441406,
-0.45744895935058594,
0.7899929285049438,
0.5681718587875366,
-0.6635246276855469,
-0.05395016074180603,
0.6261644959449768,
0.026379959657788277,
0.29999038577079773,
0.48985350131988525,
0.06501999497413635,
0.6483591794967651,
0.353415846824646,
0.05832502990961075,
-0.39045026898384094,
-0.7863507866859436,
-0.2872420847415924,
0.3568362593650818,
-0.10030490159988403,
-0.08840399235486984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11863v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11863v3 | How Interpretable are Reasoning Explanations from Prompting Large Language Models? | 2024-02-19T06:11:28 | 2024-04-01T08:33:11 | Wei Jie Yeo, Ranjan Satapathy, Rick Siow Mong Goh, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt Engineering has garnered significant attention for enhancing the
performance of large language models across a multitude of tasks. Techniques
such as the Chain-of-Thought not only bolster task performance but also
delineate a clear trajectory of reasoning steps, offering a tangible form of
explanation for the audience. Prior works on interpretability assess the
reasoning chains yielded by Chain-of-Thought solely along a singular axis,
namely faithfulness. We present a comprehensive and multifaceted evaluation of
interpretability, examining not only faithfulness but also robustness and
utility across multiple commonsense reasoning benchmarks. Likewise, our
investigation is not confined to a single prompting technique; it expansively
covers a multitude of prevalent prompting techniques employed in large language
models, thereby ensuring a wide-ranging and exhaustive evaluation. In addition,
we introduce a simple interpretability alignment technique, termed
Self-Entailment-Alignment Chain-of-thought, that yields more than 70\%
improvements across multiple dimensions of interpretability. Code is available
at https://github.com/SenticNet/CoT_interpretability | [
-0.17411403357982635,
-0.8311029076576233,
1.0443847179412842,
0.46803686022758484,
-0.15312045812606812,
-0.12647107243537903,
-0.2524024546146393,
-0.3964078426361084,
-0.04788509011268616,
0.3688637316226959,
-0.8120262622833252,
-0.16423748433589935,
-0.3365100622177124,
0.28579625487327576,
-0.27480706572532654,
0.9669192433357239,
-0.22788988053798676,
-0.19555358588695526,
-0.3160121440887451,
-0.22554832696914673,
-0.9355069994926453,
-0.15298008918762207,
-0.3693442940711975,
-0.25346481800079346,
0.5820825695991516,
0.39632314443588257,
1.0355569124221802,
0.7734088897705078,
0.23867420852184296,
0.28003114461898804,
-0.16423694789409637,
0.11142174899578094,
-0.41342729330062866,
0.47173649072647095,
-0.6043621301651001,
-0.20638784766197205,
-0.514042317867279,
0.09764374047517776,
0.6658196449279785,
0.7382598519325256,
0.059832897037267685,
0.1254875361919403,
0.4827251136302948,
0.5815470814704895,
-0.6339719891548157,
0.09927640855312347,
-0.7462829351425171,
-0.44519734382629395,
-0.004436244256794453,
-0.20764148235321045,
-0.7249674797058105,
-0.324360191822052,
0.20381195843219757,
-0.8349396586418152,
-0.18773193657398224,
0.30016979575157166,
0.5218947529792786,
0.3318139910697937,
-0.24871011078357697,
-0.49280086159706116,
-0.42598792910575867,
0.8964685797691345,
-0.5167377591133118,
0.5513221025466919,
0.3082500994205475,
0.3928180932998657,
-0.31520113348960876,
-0.744047999382019,
-0.533613920211792,
-0.22213532030582428,
-0.07513140887022018,
0.25376078486442566,
-0.16531115770339966,
0.16582363843917847,
0.5775310397148132,
0.43018507957458496,
-0.7079861164093018,
0.07652436941862106,
-0.04009413719177246,
-0.21176302433013916,
0.39309751987457275,
0.06577623635530472,
0.4515928030014038,
-0.055263832211494446,
-0.4794238209724426,
0.20583929121494293,
-0.6522942781448364,
-0.04286910220980644,
0.3788115680217743,
0.4131568670272827,
-0.09783235192298889,
0.36865419149398804,
-0.2575286328792572,
0.8059932589530945,
0.11683206260204315,
0.47576048970222473,
-0.16520889103412628,
-0.555685818195343,
-0.2667468786239624,
-0.07007833570241928,
0.6485592722892761,
0.1615595668554306,
0.42982783913612366,
-0.1031838208436966,
-0.19237379729747772,
-0.2532039284706116,
0.6034253239631653,
-0.5007003545761108,
-0.317693293094635,
0.5274432897567749,
-0.6462563276290894,
-0.14776767790317535,
-0.07131020724773407,
-0.7725557088851929,
-0.4450012743473053,
-0.5266494154930115,
0.40738603472709656,
-0.34017375111579895,
-0.370866060256958,
0.31218650937080383,
-0.1859171837568283,
0.29163095355033875,
0.43661800026893616,
-0.8913683295249939,
0.09640932083129883,
0.8959004282951355,
0.8788956999778748,
-0.14885224401950836,
-0.586372971534729,
-0.705773651599884,
-0.07735128700733185,
-0.17629379034042358,
0.7511361837387085,
-0.6211237907409668,
-0.09610096365213394,
-0.19510473310947418,
0.08454971760511398,
-0.2426426261663437,
-0.2656089663505554,
0.7836155295372009,
-0.5789129137992859,
-0.10512224584817886,
-0.5727500319480896,
-0.5565635561943054,
-0.17705674469470978,
0.3556065261363983,
-0.770564079284668,
0.6783796548843384,
-0.08280398696660995,
-0.7182595133781433,
0.26611730456352234,
-0.5620125532150269,
-0.24265576899051666,
-0.061715736985206604,
0.04263848438858986,
0.16109909117221832,
0.18316888809204102,
0.4013330340385437,
0.2711315453052521,
-0.20471687614917755,
0.3610275983810425,
-0.5867786407470703,
-0.21322587132453918,
0.6344889402389526,
-0.942215621471405,
0.8376699686050415,
0.47036442160606384,
-0.24377064406871796,
0.14302754402160645,
-0.6841575503349304,
0.11091101169586182,
-0.25322601199150085,
0.1688985675573349,
-0.22507601976394653,
-0.03628580644726753,
-0.20303742587566376,
0.2543208599090576,
0.2958987057209015,
-0.2798701822757721,
0.32406851649284363,
-0.530135989189148,
0.4213200807571411,
0.956388533115387,
0.013437717221677303,
0.47671324014663696,
-0.09731269627809525,
0.610079288482666,
-0.11048414558172226,
0.43130120635032654,
-0.3265801966190338,
-0.504733145236969,
-0.2923532724380493,
-0.21813829243183136,
0.05019819363951683,
0.2560071647167206,
-0.7950775027275085,
0.09854726493358612,
-0.07595174759626389,
-0.3343295454978943,
-0.31519412994384766,
0.13087496161460876,
0.4583480656147003,
0.5182198286056519,
0.3739069104194641,
0.1257104128599167,
-0.3721455931663513,
-0.8211456537246704,
-0.8519036769866943,
-0.3130394518375397,
0.15283703804016113,
-0.12794950604438782,
0.46193599700927734,
-0.08422230929136276,
0.7912001609802246,
-0.4833025336265564,
0.6738290190696716,
-0.10625117272138596,
0.24547864496707916,
0.5670560002326965,
0.657651424407959,
0.15954793989658356,
-0.5401146411895752,
-0.30133578181266785,
0.08262346684932709,
-0.7734056711196899,
-0.2221423238515854,
-0.6360568404197693,
-0.6226295828819275,
-0.1883973330259323,
0.41304925084114075,
-0.6472903490066528,
0.3775228261947632,
0.5273030996322632,
-0.4423191249370575,
0.9634807109832764,
-0.2556675374507904,
0.1318780481815338,
-0.7556867599487305,
0.17287638783454895,
-0.1352308988571167,
-0.3357445299625397,
-0.5637122988700867,
0.27497220039367676,
0.13769085705280304,
0.008936965838074684,
-0.3371921479701996,
0.5455665588378906,
-0.6564896702766418,
0.02376309037208557,
-0.39282265305519104,
0.302107572555542,
0.32774221897125244,
0.19163881242275238,
-0.1994180530309677,
0.9186925292015076,
0.8029683828353882,
-0.805544912815094,
0.29100391268730164,
0.46388378739356995,
-0.18624776601791382,
0.7931466102600098,
-0.7775261998176575,
0.18538717925548553,
-0.1013353019952774,
0.272879421710968,
-1.015901803970337,
-0.2222808599472046,
0.29836195707321167,
-0.36037909984588623,
0.05204393342137337,
-0.10842937231063843,
-0.3635818064212799,
-0.33619728684425354,
-0.14129751920700073,
0.619594931602478,
0.36519500613212585,
-1.068555235862732,
0.7121250033378601,
-0.3201332688331604,
-0.03716009855270386,
-0.6438987255096436,
-0.4850686490535736,
-0.061760153621435165,
-0.160442516207695,
-0.48942768573760986,
-0.156593918800354,
-0.2883036434650421,
-0.44636261463165283,
-0.25375643372535706,
-0.4785633981227875,
-0.14603178203105927,
0.3736495077610016,
0.3617517650127411,
0.43544384837150574,
-0.18656504154205322,
0.4558607339859009,
0.17704889178276062,
-0.21814946830272675,
0.3835360109806061,
-0.6186137795448303,
0.23493856191635132,
-0.2923770546913147,
-0.4735327661037445,
-0.5818877816200256,
0.1819300353527069,
0.7683800458908081,
-0.05710677057504654,
0.8071643114089966,
0.14425820112228394,
-0.20859596133232117,
-0.2961914837360382,
-0.45177459716796875,
-0.18704161047935486,
-0.5326658487319946,
-0.2194654941558838,
-0.6685585975646973,
-0.5631579756736755,
0.654830276966095,
-0.17697620391845703,
0.14305169880390167,
0.6477283239364624,
0.1769063025712967,
-0.14088842272758484,
1.1887409687042236,
0.2059987336397171,
0.22077757120132446,
0.13597659766674042,
0.2238065004348755,
0.25603222846984863,
-0.8253347277641296,
-0.11080516874790192,
-0.6416149139404297,
0.03425809368491173,
-0.574230432510376,
-0.18215741217136383,
0.09119603782892227,
0.20973043143749237,
-0.2938319444656372,
0.33499467372894287,
-0.5021695494651794,
0.6400265097618103,
0.08916633576154709,
-0.013761267066001892,
0.3015356957912445,
-0.267329603433609,
-0.06624750792980194,
0.14097775518894196,
-0.5664364695549011,
-0.8052566051483154,
0.6260839104652405,
0.5011755228042603,
0.9926674365997314,
-0.04551826789975166,
0.3077142834663391,
0.05475828796625137,
0.19837571680545807,
-0.8345381021499634,
0.2966311573982239,
-0.012517769820988178,
-0.5912392139434814,
-0.33869484066963196,
-0.4279428720474243,
-1.0181918144226074,
0.15597817301750183,
-0.10780131816864014,
-0.9276140332221985,
0.1976858675479889,
0.4825535714626312,
-0.4378252625465393,
0.06149526685476303,
-0.7074009776115417,
1.0231025218963623,
-0.34508681297302246,
-0.2596788704395294,
-0.29500406980514526,
-0.5862869620323181,
0.34738585352897644,
-0.04905715584754944,
0.215168297290802,
0.18186801671981812,
0.04301029443740845,
0.43547502160072327,
-0.3374999761581421,
0.7056220173835754,
0.048586923629045486,
-0.37716588377952576,
0.33329546451568604,
0.18265241384506226,
0.6616935729980469,
0.059603746980428696,
-0.3877124786376953,
0.1110081821680069,
0.18084752559661865,
-0.40312036871910095,
-1.1514860391616821,
0.7525400519371033,
-0.3354540467262268,
-0.8111767172813416,
-0.24801307916641235,
-0.7249476909637451,
-0.2746220827102661,
0.22498668730258942,
0.1805771142244339,
0.9345293045043945,
0.032329726964235306,
-0.06764692068099976,
0.7540938854217529,
-0.3374512493610382,
0.25295329093933105,
0.04790343716740608,
-0.24229827523231506,
-0.31914615631103516,
1.0133494138717651,
-0.11952447891235352,
0.6171848177909851,
0.28038960695266724,
0.3313552737236023,
-0.6657658815383911,
-0.3147379755973816,
-0.7439963817596436,
0.2486463189125061,
-0.9960759878158569,
0.1716582328081131,
-0.5751370191574097,
0.03913091495633125,
-0.3366285264492035,
-0.2897888720035553,
-0.24815230071544647,
-0.591770350933075,
-0.27300140261650085,
0.010316924192011356,
0.17681671679019928,
0.9727926850318909,
0.19140875339508057,
0.2574886679649353,
-0.7903106808662415,
0.17971719801425934,
0.3681401312351227,
0.6863279938697815,
0.3145289421081543,
-0.5386788845062256,
-0.07857723534107208,
0.14833499491214752,
-0.30873510241508484,
-1.0389738082885742,
-0.1729121059179306,
-0.1797381341457367,
0.7769943475723267,
0.5662351250648499,
0.2058405578136444,
0.7961193919181824,
-0.28901445865631104,
0.8603999614715576,
0.22720681130886078,
-1.4077109098434448,
0.7631193995475769,
-0.3214081823825836,
0.6163820028305054,
0.6618136167526245,
0.403510183095932,
-0.3141193985939026,
-0.5726457834243774,
-0.5927944183349609,
-0.564984142780304,
0.4662337303161621,
0.2948811948299408,
-0.019933782517910004,
-0.016771577298641205,
0.5275917053222656,
0.6412084102630615,
-0.07972006499767303,
-0.48667705059051514,
-0.10238056629896164,
-0.33806392550468445,
-0.3350883722305298,
0.1321435570716858,
-0.15625807642936707,
0.09588860720396042,
0.012622573412954807,
0.6584298610687256,
-0.3580658733844757,
0.16155721247196198,
0.23373731970787048,
-0.1839003562927246,
0.1438561975955963,
0.5561053156852722,
0.5574660897254944,
1.227994680404663,
0.06811489164829254,
0.35187220573425293,
0.23487727344036102,
-0.31332582235336304,
0.014625581912696362,
-0.15550251305103302,
-0.0030594803392887115,
-0.1512959748506546,
0.525392472743988,
0.7671859860420227,
0.10449373722076416,
-0.40971991419792175,
0.3763106167316437,
-0.05452727526426315,
0.0006915857666172087,
0.09684845060110092,
0.007519030477851629,
-0.3134227395057678,
0.1889127641916275,
0.09334822744131088,
0.028942521661520004,
0.40426549315452576,
-0.6989977955818176,
-0.02657521329820156,
0.34906551241874695,
-0.5861712098121643,
-0.48478269577026367,
0.6945639252662659,
0.16831976175308228,
0.03327949345111847,
0.7928093671798706,
0.017864162102341652,
-0.5316990613937378,
0.5370908975601196,
0.5477725267410278,
1.0568398237228394,
-0.035924170166254044,
0.345754474401474,
0.5005430579185486,
0.40338149666786194,
-0.30346181988716125,
0.3620341420173645,
-0.280569851398468,
-0.5297902822494507,
-0.877772331237793,
-0.29924482107162476,
-0.5006981492042542,
-0.12391949445009232,
-0.9753425121307373,
-0.016690600663423538,
-0.1983860284090042,
0.004745775368064642,
0.17673365771770477,
-0.579041600227356,
-0.5503200888633728,
0.2574344277381897,
-0.1177305057644844,
1.155555009841919,
-0.9027583003044128,
0.4604170620441437,
0.7156734466552734,
-0.3588191866874695,
-1.1507172584533691,
0.3908756375312805,
-0.06687821447849274,
-0.6983011960983276,
0.4355355501174927,
0.40451255440711975,
-0.33397412300109863,
-0.22259481251239777,
-0.7973061203956604,
-0.6547636985778809,
0.7196606993675232,
0.3334386348724365,
-0.6054764986038208,
0.24161496758460999,
-0.17203819751739502,
0.41970425844192505,
-0.003006958169862628,
0.5119199156761169,
0.7169855237007141,
0.6886571049690247,
0.10699238628149033,
-0.9905360341072083,
0.5041163563728333,
-0.15080924332141876,
-0.10756412893533707,
0.1663687825202942,
-0.3284042477607727,
0.46789082884788513,
-0.11038999259471893,
-0.2890777587890625,
0.14333510398864746,
0.7150152921676636,
0.4732830822467804,
0.49946385622024536,
0.7144752740859985,
0.13707555830478668,
1.1216967105865479,
-0.07772144675254822,
1.123923897743225,
-0.3116336762905121,
0.16987156867980957,
1.0010122060775757,
-0.07145635783672333,
0.6496237516403198,
0.6207742094993591,
-0.0018887765472754836,
0.6571550369262695,
0.5406826734542847,
0.3350583612918854,
0.24035091698169708,
-0.024247873574495316,
-0.01645570434629917,
-0.6491402387619019,
-0.07377853989601135,
-0.22077809274196625,
0.3461069166660309,
0.26001107692718506,
-0.23233343660831451,
-0.06600544601678848,
0.03885077312588692,
-0.2904360294342041,
0.09447899460792542,
-0.4985927939414978,
0.5401397943496704,
0.2911219596862793,
-1.1722934246063232,
0.5684223771095276,
-0.6974508166313171,
0.20214621722698212,
-0.30397704243659973,
-0.245229572057724,
0.1386137157678604,
0.0659204050898552,
-0.31053557991981506,
-1.3615328073501587,
0.3674358129501343,
-0.033730246126651764,
-0.21823960542678833,
-0.6848232746124268,
0.7981156706809998,
-0.10654296725988388,
-0.12635424733161926,
0.017705019563436508,
0.5824242830276489,
0.34760594367980957,
-0.13270066678524017,
-0.6078131198883057,
0.10435368120670319,
-0.18104583024978638,
-0.023421859368681908,
-0.0661434754729271,
0.6606674790382385,
-0.044770002365112305,
0.7967716455459595,
0.5242466330528259,
-0.010621861554682255,
-0.2594969570636749,
0.2086614966392517,
0.8808433413505554,
-0.6655410528182983,
-0.5536711812019348,
-1.0726289749145508,
0.5771207213401794,
-0.004071335773915052,
-0.44818639755249023,
0.9513183236122131,
0.270316481590271,
0.3261568546295166,
-0.09333191066980362,
0.6403123736381531,
0.11048717051744461,
0.11805831640958786,
-0.8652030825614929,
0.455099880695343,
-0.3327922224998474,
0.30846282839775085,
-0.33781230449676514,
-0.8100259304046631,
-0.06253092736005783,
0.3327691853046417,
-0.4401533305644989,
-0.029837200418114662,
1.0336722135543823,
0.564877450466156,
-0.08910384029150009,
0.7389022707939148,
0.1801966279745102,
0.3935790956020355,
0.09934906661510468,
0.2958664894104004,
1.467603087425232,
0.01685933582484722,
0.4406115710735321,
0.16482464969158173,
-0.2138763815164566,
0.17568334937095642,
-1.0877560377120972,
-0.7232075929641724,
-0.4370841383934021,
-0.3621433675289154,
-0.5180916786193848,
0.031292594969272614,
0.7869076132774353,
0.525567889213562,
-0.8397266864776611,
0.08317680656909943,
-0.45025017857551575,
0.4084101915359497,
-0.6190296411514282,
-0.1898125857114792,
0.2709479331970215,
-0.5760638117790222,
-0.41535019874572754,
0.4209684729576111,
0.23040197789669037,
-0.16425330936908722,
-0.23582597076892853,
-0.05353450030088425,
0.025661595165729523,
0.141188845038414,
0.5082901120185852,
0.21851152181625366,
-0.8616222143173218,
-0.5098080039024353,
0.1836051642894745,
0.15729153156280518,
-0.04146444424986839,
0.9436749815940857,
-0.6287137866020203,
0.869856059551239,
0.6889945864677429,
0.6280260682106018,
-0.00016305477765854448,
0.37990590929985046,
0.8955559730529785,
-0.4907481372356415,
-0.3366791009902954,
-0.0483466312289238,
0.4048442244529724,
0.13326598703861237,
-0.6378008127212524,
0.3542379140853882,
-0.14651189744472504,
-0.8763964772224426,
-0.6816635727882385,
0.43711057305336,
-1.221958875656128,
-0.27671587467193604,
1.2309893369674683,
-0.3031124472618103,
-0.18158937990665436,
-0.4322342574596405,
-0.2801274359226227,
0.23619242012500763,
-0.25750818848609924,
0.38988518714904785,
0.8659582138061523,
-0.19641439616680145,
-0.16405896842479706,
-0.5832807421684265,
0.13410471379756927,
0.5438008308410645,
-0.8455861806869507,
0.37136808037757874,
0.5641273260116577,
0.2311084121465683,
0.0500364825129509,
0.3125529885292053,
0.08201736956834793,
0.43514978885650635,
0.00957446452230215,
-0.3688119351863861,
0.1520453244447708,
-0.4115600287914276,
-0.6974702477455139,
-0.15839222073554993,
0.297627329826355,
-0.13103638589382172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11845v1 | Modularized Networks for Few-shot Hateful Meme Detection | 2024-02-19T05:15:13 | 2024-02-19T05:15:13 | Rui Cao, Roy Ka-Wei Lee, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we address the challenge of detecting hateful memes in the
low-resource setting where only a few labeled examples are available. Our
approach leverages the compositionality of Low-rank adaptation (LoRA), a widely
used parameter-efficient tuning technique. We commence by fine-tuning large
language models (LLMs) with LoRA on selected tasks pertinent to hateful meme
detection, thereby generating a suite of LoRA modules. These modules are
capable of essential reasoning skills for hateful meme detection. We then use
the few available annotated samples to train a module composer, which assigns
weights to the LoRA modules based on their relevance. The model's learnable
parameters are directly proportional to the number of LoRA modules. This
modularized network, underpinned by LLMs and augmented with LoRA modules,
exhibits enhanced generalization in the context of hateful meme detection. Our
evaluation spans three datasets designed for hateful meme detection in a
few-shot learning context. The proposed method demonstrates superior
performance to traditional in-context learning, which is also more
computationally intensive during inference.We then use the few available
annotated samples to train a module composer, which assigns weights to the LoRA
modules based on their relevance. The model's learnable parameters are directly
proportional to the number of LoRA modules. This modularized network,
underpinned by LLMs and augmented with LoRA modules, exhibits enhanced
generalization in the context of hateful meme detection. Our evaluation spans
three datasets designed for hateful meme detection in a few-shot learning
context. The proposed method demonstrates superior performance to traditional
in-context learning, which is also more computationally intensive during
inference. | [
-0.5601208806037903,
-0.8168693780899048,
0.17235219478607178,
-0.16697071492671967,
-0.5577281713485718,
-0.20733068883419037,
-0.19769544899463654,
-0.17493319511413574,
0.5163910388946533,
0.5060858130455017,
-0.7300838828086853,
-0.4324822723865509,
-0.7316221594810486,
0.19000859558582306,
-0.33210644125938416,
1.060233235359192,
0.5068073272705078,
-0.31118446588516235,
0.30947303771972656,
-0.45682790875434875,
0.012260979041457176,
-0.18721799552440643,
-0.8144838809967041,
-0.27238962054252625,
1.2033313512802124,
0.7258565425872803,
0.3578583896160126,
0.4640789330005646,
0.4250027537345886,
0.2959129512310028,
-0.014282557182013988,
0.23403510451316833,
-0.7820770740509033,
0.06303144246339798,
-0.3534946143627167,
-0.46473485231399536,
-0.4370286762714386,
0.04856811463832855,
0.42617595195770264,
0.000837505969684571,
0.10522828996181488,
0.391246497631073,
-0.11076010763645172,
0.5467689037322998,
-0.8130213618278503,
-0.2855873107910156,
-1.2356312274932861,
0.16350392997264862,
-0.35940295457839966,
-0.09959670901298523,
-0.5150948762893677,
-0.2106907069683075,
-0.3939211070537567,
-0.4927491247653961,
-0.2322392612695694,
-0.02916274406015873,
0.2894020080566406,
0.21203090250492096,
-0.3079487979412079,
0.018232474103569984,
-0.3606977164745331,
1.0545930862426758,
-1.0601831674575806,
-0.327612966299057,
0.3332322835922241,
0.42826205492019653,
-0.15577782690525055,
-0.2738439738750458,
-0.7792041897773743,
0.3725925385951996,
0.20232167840003967,
0.04921136796474457,
-0.6927374005317688,
-0.17768444120883942,
0.37087222933769226,
0.2169986516237259,
-0.544039249420166,
0.6547259092330933,
-0.520870566368103,
-0.19767995178699493,
0.447914719581604,
0.2259981334209442,
0.29630333185195923,
-0.7839586734771729,
-0.4180556833744049,
0.010270452126860619,
-0.6656874418258667,
-0.16677719354629517,
0.7796348929405212,
0.5233085751533508,
-0.14748242497444153,
0.5143075585365295,
-0.4068426787853241,
0.7978290319442749,
0.20553983747959137,
-0.4454745352268219,
0.14792737364768982,
-0.034561529755592346,
-0.30863213539123535,
-0.1786404401063919,
0.7580768465995789,
0.21023224294185638,
0.2728622257709503,
0.2175924926996231,
-0.1989324539899826,
0.26140516996383667,
0.4914775490760803,
-0.9838330149650574,
-0.10555332154035568,
-0.1897660195827484,
-0.6080265641212463,
-0.6679782271385193,
-0.4794435203075409,
-0.7654440402984619,
-0.4984467327594757,
-0.0729316994547844,
0.6872432827949524,
-0.41841089725494385,
-0.08589116483926773,
-0.2811404764652252,
-0.1660708636045456,
0.019630329683423042,
0.36796459555625916,
-0.9614751935005188,
0.16459248960018158,
0.6625954508781433,
0.8424392938613892,
-0.2047709822654724,
-0.12371999025344849,
-0.7675110697746277,
0.12248295545578003,
-0.002366897650063038,
0.9302619695663452,
-0.49146604537963867,
0.27098894119262695,
-0.19346299767494202,
0.018209950998425484,
-0.01758517697453499,
-0.7761374711990356,
0.4005459249019623,
-0.6532421112060547,
-0.15538454055786133,
0.04461769759654999,
-0.34350118041038513,
-0.3602115213871002,
0.6971731781959534,
-0.6241397261619568,
0.4326149523258209,
0.40092378854751587,
-0.8399732112884521,
0.16066287457942963,
-0.6615427732467651,
-0.33207616209983826,
-0.12649239599704742,
-0.1078961193561554,
-0.7234737277030945,
0.21792013943195343,
-0.15839147567749023,
0.669981837272644,
0.029725365340709686,
-0.2751710116863251,
-0.6310121417045593,
-0.3696681559085846,
0.020506441593170166,
-0.17433048784732819,
0.7248501181602478,
0.37125152349472046,
-0.3612549602985382,
0.19503039121627808,
-0.7815892100334167,
-0.19785742461681366,
0.13801424205303192,
-0.5688298344612122,
-0.5892912745475769,
0.048371825367212296,
-0.029218381270766258,
0.19167593121528625,
-0.12754687666893005,
-0.7299233675003052,
0.07271566987037659,
-0.4272642731666565,
0.2893671691417694,
1.1704007387161255,
-0.04739183932542801,
0.41122370958328247,
-0.4333452880382538,
0.4213871359825134,
0.41233059763908386,
0.31721433997154236,
0.10162048041820526,
-0.48052775859832764,
-0.6829206943511963,
-0.45046594738960266,
-0.4546548128128052,
0.39051148295402527,
-0.8213177919387817,
0.3966403007507324,
-0.055112555623054504,
-0.28679919242858887,
0.030250655487179756,
0.5246095657348633,
0.3368181586265564,
0.4646812081336975,
0.5147520899772644,
-0.32387852668762207,
-0.7767543196678162,
-1.177932620048523,
-0.32102563977241516,
-0.2532161474227905,
0.08304890245199203,
0.2670261263847351,
0.5798665285110474,
-0.18096159398555756,
0.6458125710487366,
-0.36329907178878784,
-0.4470709264278412,
-0.3264431059360504,
0.2049056738615036,
0.4660208225250244,
0.4549511969089508,
0.7801181077957153,
-0.5259841084480286,
-0.5308587551116943,
0.03008059225976467,
-0.47888174653053284,
-0.16056987643241882,
0.2747337222099304,
-0.08308378607034683,
-0.0033522064331918955,
0.24418731033802032,
0.2106824368238449,
0.2548762857913971,
0.7315406203269958,
-0.3438374698162079,
0.4277721345424652,
0.4844963252544403,
0.3198483884334564,
-1.3792579174041748,
-0.3604998290538788,
0.07634038478136063,
-0.453056275844574,
-0.5892927646636963,
-0.056515853852033615,
-0.2711833119392395,
0.068717822432518,
-0.7028185725212097,
0.3870204985141754,
0.1106606274843216,
0.05297759920358658,
-0.4174145758152008,
-0.015520494431257248,
-0.20799903571605682,
0.6398293375968933,
-0.44948461651802063,
0.5071014761924744,
0.12230092287063599,
-0.4175105392932892,
0.3308226466178894,
0.08210944384336472,
-0.47260138392448425,
0.8931694626808167,
-0.08199429512023926,
0.20348213613033295,
-0.05070652812719345,
0.12066496163606644,
-0.8816338181495667,
-0.20953822135925293,
0.6063949465751648,
-0.14614345133304596,
-0.1266506463289261,
-0.6565753221511841,
-0.4705372452735901,
-0.21135927736759186,
-0.39910486340522766,
0.7846653461456299,
0.4338112473487854,
-0.663719117641449,
0.39325326681137085,
0.21010272204875946,
0.18114356696605682,
-0.5576061010360718,
-0.7331774830818176,
-0.10277022421360016,
-0.5993248224258423,
-0.522926390171051,
-0.1349974125623703,
-0.18854208290576935,
-0.1505255401134491,
-0.2748379707336426,
0.0030605632346123457,
-0.4065578877925873,
0.22983989119529724,
0.3398377597332001,
-0.27294301986694336,
-0.6491708159446716,
-0.00044306140625849366,
0.1472177654504776,
-0.039012640714645386,
-0.3763243854045868,
-0.4079586863517761,
0.32055872678756714,
-0.07583615183830261,
-0.5032587051391602,
-0.4290582239627838,
0.37374359369277954,
0.6580823659896851,
0.2618563175201416,
0.6369247436523438,
0.8514814972877502,
-0.422094464302063,
-0.6057072281837463,
-0.723375678062439,
-0.25541791319847107,
-0.49114352464675903,
0.4138815402984619,
-0.18554536998271942,
-1.3014345169067383,
0.5670334100723267,
0.08502714335918427,
-0.19134515523910522,
0.31060367822647095,
0.6477712988853455,
-0.03485063835978508,
0.6173486709594727,
0.3236582577228546,
-0.5396043062210083,
0.7983530163764954,
-0.2685985565185547,
0.17841657996177673,
-0.7105977535247803,
0.16624827682971954,
-0.3830925524234772,
-1.0086613893508911,
-0.358906626701355,
-0.7198836803436279,
0.6431372165679932,
-0.07115010917186737,
-0.3286842703819275,
0.44311007857322693,
-0.3215636909008026,
0.8723999857902527,
0.20513705909252167,
0.4224466383457184,
0.3358789384365082,
0.41601261496543884,
0.08152080327272415,
-0.14803546667099,
-0.613250732421875,
-0.2860197424888611,
1.0020794868469238,
0.08888848125934601,
0.8035233616828918,
0.6348482370376587,
0.6656561493873596,
0.635652482509613,
0.38879987597465515,
-1.0011194944381714,
0.49190232157707214,
-0.6666839122772217,
-0.6615182161331177,
-0.3042972981929779,
-0.3407679498195648,
-0.8706330060958862,
0.272330105304718,
-0.3171702027320862,
-0.8315979838371277,
0.10735924541950226,
0.20758844912052155,
-0.35796689987182617,
0.9711534976959229,
-0.47490137815475464,
0.8367307186126709,
0.34795451164245605,
-0.3773973882198334,
-0.8908380270004272,
-0.16319972276687622,
0.5872675180435181,
-0.1497957855463028,
0.13844254612922668,
-0.36886724829673767,
0.007558930665254593,
0.7829945087432861,
-0.16614992916584015,
1.2892457246780396,
-0.15427392721176147,
0.14587895572185516,
0.376481831073761,
0.27864208817481995,
0.4764074385166168,
-0.22809627652168274,
-0.5095698237419128,
-0.09366212785243988,
-0.35072702169418335,
-0.7964151501655579,
-0.5544123649597168,
0.8881624341011047,
-0.6593299508094788,
-0.4296239912509918,
0.1518985778093338,
-0.4257432520389557,
0.15137474238872528,
0.1859234720468521,
0.2096984088420868,
0.5366725921630859,
-0.3052109181880951,
0.1850755661725998,
0.6738153100013733,
-0.18143457174301147,
0.4551618695259094,
0.4694928824901581,
-0.0006723786354996264,
-0.3546179234981537,
0.9688488841056824,
0.09923437982797623,
0.3279341757297516,
0.3328110873699188,
0.24239039421081543,
0.41225484013557434,
-0.779434084892273,
-0.5221438407897949,
-0.062064435333013535,
-0.8708922863006592,
-0.607782244682312,
-0.5771661996841431,
0.02839386649429798,
0.03129270300269127,
-0.20296786725521088,
-0.4471660256385803,
-0.5422224998474121,
-0.40001702308654785,
0.24669532477855682,
0.481456995010376,
0.9652075171470642,
-0.16422584652900696,
0.7832930088043213,
-0.32849323749542236,
0.4491879940032959,
0.5651838779449463,
0.3203287422657013,
0.23468148708343506,
-1.0592082738876343,
-0.3540658950805664,
-0.3416176438331604,
-0.46240776777267456,
-0.893770694732666,
0.15172621607780457,
0.20455582439899445,
0.11202038824558258,
0.9094032645225525,
0.02511833980679512,
0.5987668037414551,
-0.4351077079772949,
0.44930174946784973,
0.31704893708229065,
-0.6795045733451843,
0.5301909446716309,
-0.619867205619812,
0.07887116819620132,
0.5978124737739563,
0.31117314100265503,
-0.3537045419216156,
-0.376742959022522,
-0.3280865550041199,
-0.34844666719436646,
0.8866048455238342,
-0.010363917797803879,
0.5559131503105164,
-0.3809363543987274,
0.4275147616863251,
0.17365676164627075,
-0.12089784443378448,
-1.1685904264450073,
-0.3472081124782562,
-0.14574562013149261,
-0.03842988237738609,
0.13820534944534302,
-0.5179733633995056,
-0.18502816557884216,
-0.3987046182155609,
0.8245789408683777,
-0.4932003319263458,
-0.03315292298793793,
-0.19707806408405304,
-0.3638307452201843,
-0.20895344018936157,
0.5000084638595581,
0.6620765924453735,
0.5240851044654846,
-0.09747947007417679,
0.4056128263473511,
0.22621062397956848,
-0.10770045220851898,
0.27805399894714355,
-0.5610079169273376,
-0.11835850030183792,
-0.15563130378723145,
0.20679278671741486,
0.735674262046814,
0.3532024323940277,
-0.27714118361473083,
0.8535682559013367,
0.25305089354515076,
-0.10700567066669464,
-0.18556858599185944,
0.2254054993391037,
-0.03809328004717827,
0.6474815607070923,
0.2426908165216446,
0.26722845435142517,
0.1185341402888298,
-0.3967822790145874,
0.3426551818847656,
0.5556138157844543,
-0.4033035635948181,
-0.6908069252967834,
0.19166970252990723,
0.11415727436542511,
-0.12180615961551666,
0.1665746420621872,
-0.43959447741508484,
-0.5876936316490173,
0.6106577515602112,
0.7397474050521851,
0.7256439328193665,
-0.22040137648582458,
0.5721405148506165,
0.7736400365829468,
0.5672449469566345,
0.2686264216899872,
-0.11330533772706985,
-0.09494676440954208,
-0.935206413269043,
-0.23632726073265076,
-0.7890653014183044,
-0.2115909904241562,
0.5398175716400146,
-0.3350290358066559,
0.28875675797462463,
-0.9520566463470459,
0.014381169341504574,
0.1309722512960434,
-0.2096412181854248,
-0.33511316776275635,
0.028197545558214188,
0.4338763356208801,
0.7321423888206482,
-1.1407254934310913,
0.6444274187088013,
0.6492628455162048,
-0.3719771206378937,
-0.44007042050361633,
-0.1904178410768509,
0.4971577525138855,
-0.9875665903091431,
0.599777102470398,
0.0032825213856995106,
-0.1633472740650177,
0.06889652460813522,
-0.8251082897186279,
-0.4524475336074829,
0.8226202130317688,
0.2517356276512146,
-0.32957449555397034,
0.47936490178108215,
-0.1146148294210434,
0.4143211245536804,
-0.6899547576904297,
0.12653815746307373,
0.39231038093566895,
0.36317160725593567,
-0.020747238770127296,
-0.4174875020980835,
0.0700402557849884,
-0.06125309690833092,
-0.396942138671875,
0.19278423488140106,
-0.7569602131843567,
1.015894889831543,
0.06089363619685173,
0.1567627489566803,
0.10642540454864502,
0.42198696732521057,
0.010157685726881027,
0.37994813919067383,
0.8555939197540283,
0.7101430296897888,
0.36696097254753113,
0.3537680208683014,
0.7232546210289001,
0.46299952268600464,
0.19942842423915863,
0.9976598620414734,
0.2472039759159088,
1.0071150064468384,
0.553306519985199,
-0.11817694455385208,
0.9024474024772644,
0.3931211829185486,
-0.032402489334344864,
0.3583933413028717,
0.5480802655220032,
-0.704519510269165,
-0.5994530916213989,
-0.22444243729114532,
-0.034794535487890244,
0.5586206912994385,
0.2899811267852783,
-0.3906858265399933,
-0.5976423621177673,
0.07817953079938889,
0.08530905097723007,
0.18419164419174194,
-0.6275089383125305,
0.9512721300125122,
0.11197315156459808,
-0.14395764470100403,
0.8465578556060791,
0.06293104588985443,
0.9933338165283203,
-0.5594147443771362,
0.3225836455821991,
-0.15924304723739624,
0.14099949598312378,
-0.578288733959198,
-0.1763773262500763,
0.40952467918395996,
0.21205052733421326,
-0.7034550309181213,
0.26136672496795654,
0.8452821969985962,
-0.15962976217269897,
-0.31819766759872437,
0.4854770004749298,
0.5282719731330872,
0.3044726252555847,
-0.17872950434684753,
-0.6310511827468872,
0.06121715158224106,
0.0924573540687561,
-0.34631696343421936,
0.7523465752601624,
0.3280596435070038,
-0.13326208293437958,
0.3724132776260376,
0.5982469320297241,
-0.02208682894706726,
0.2854152321815491,
0.2907513976097107,
1.1732664108276367,
-0.5676203370094299,
-0.2827916443347931,
-1.0127848386764526,
0.27248334884643555,
-0.0013903003418818116,
0.027191244065761566,
0.4918065369129181,
0.5543296933174133,
0.7728877067565918,
-0.2468796819448471,
0.7333958745002747,
-0.1010834351181984,
0.4508257210254669,
-0.3873082101345062,
0.6013824939727783,
-0.9233117699623108,
0.17966417968273163,
-0.3931301534175873,
-0.8806350827217102,
-0.39663293957710266,
0.5377694964408875,
-0.3510058522224426,
-0.32900530099868774,
0.5190051198005676,
0.9973272681236267,
-0.7853164672851562,
-0.17988359928131104,
0.7197107672691345,
0.5213201642036438,
0.07189928740262985,
0.6243214011192322,
0.8482825756072998,
-0.4988756477832794,
0.5754361152648926,
-0.23557308316230774,
-0.24168992042541504,
-0.3450108468532562,
-0.9152966737747192,
-1.137501835823059,
-0.28314346075057983,
-0.29256948828697205,
-0.3250501751899719,
-0.06571382284164429,
0.9221916794776917,
0.7913972735404968,
-1.0808100700378418,
-0.17542055249214172,
0.36427047848701477,
0.6768048405647278,
0.11717245727777481,
-0.19488520920276642,
-0.15581317245960236,
-0.3065760135650635,
-0.6283829808235168,
0.636717677116394,
0.6476262211799622,
-0.2585955858230591,
-0.07510920614004135,
-0.07036992907524109,
-0.5322456955909729,
0.24427330493927002,
0.8644368052482605,
0.3630623519420624,
-0.7454428672790527,
-0.5944949984550476,
-0.6224365234375,
-0.0401296392083168,
0.3107963800430298,
0.7695976495742798,
-0.6292849779129028,
0.2386850118637085,
0.48966795206069946,
0.6677780151367188,
0.3539142310619354,
0.1777171492576599,
-0.0889844074845314,
-0.9074878692626953,
0.5153003931045532,
0.14948831498622894,
0.2444067895412445,
0.26289597153663635,
-0.12363798171281815,
0.37444567680358887,
0.47534582018852234,
-0.37556612491607666,
-0.6383399367332458,
0.6133137345314026,
-1.0848065614700317,
-0.23491300642490387,
1.029967188835144,
-0.12893694639205933,
-0.39114466309547424,
-0.2425023764371872,
0.0429275706410408,
-0.008429119363427162,
-0.4307163655757904,
0.7587828040122986,
0.43367502093315125,
-0.010510413907468319,
-0.0028183648828417063,
-0.3388228416442871,
0.32714736461639404,
0.6082023978233337,
-0.7443029284477234,
-0.33296439051628113,
0.5774974822998047,
0.49007949233055115,
0.17609523236751556,
0.6835997104644775,
0.13234277069568634,
0.3836468756198883,
-0.30751922726631165,
-0.11986690014600754,
0.08288581669330597,
-0.1276501566171646,
-0.40291059017181396,
0.15439441800117493,
-0.04701051861047745,
-0.06547759473323822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11839v1 | An enhanced Teaching-Learning-Based Optimization (TLBO) with Grey Wolf Optimizer (GWO) for text feature selection and clustering | 2024-02-19T05:06:10 | 2024-02-19T05:06:10 | Mahsa Azarshab, Mohammad Fathian, Babak Amiri | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text document clustering can play a vital role in organizing and handling the
everincreasing number of text documents. Uninformative and redundant features
included in large text documents reduce the effectiveness of the clustering
algorithm. Feature selection (FS) is a well-known technique for removing these
features. Since FS can be formulated as an optimization problem, various
meta-heuristic algorithms have been employed to solve it.
Teaching-Learning-Based Optimization (TLBO) is a novel meta-heuristic algorithm
that benefits from the low number of parameters and fast convergence. A hybrid
method can simultaneously benefit from the advantages of TLBO and tackle the
possible entrapment in the local optimum. By proposing a hybrid of TLBO, Grey
Wolf Optimizer (GWO), and Genetic Algorithm (GA) operators, this paper suggests
a filter-based FS algorithm (TLBO-GWO). Six benchmark datasets are selected,
and TLBO-GWO is compared with three recently proposed FS algorithms with
similar approaches, the main TLBO and GWO. The comparison is conducted based on
clustering evaluation measures, convergence behavior, and dimension reduction,
and is validated using statistical tests. The results reveal that TLBO-GWO can
significantly enhance the effectiveness of the text clustering technique
(K-means). | [
-0.36419913172721863,
-0.48189324140548706,
0.4816953241825104,
-0.12444411963224411,
-0.5139403343200684,
0.5492902398109436,
-0.36465755105018616,
-0.5038003921508789,
0.14637139439582825,
0.17497994005680084,
-0.44674837589263916,
-0.6069104671478271,
-0.5756436586380005,
-0.12804222106933594,
-0.45377546548843384,
1.0189801454544067,
0.2864645719528198,
0.11307168751955032,
-0.1950397789478302,
-0.29050296545028687,
-0.4214038550853729,
-0.04355049878358841,
-0.7459471225738525,
-0.42456597089767456,
0.308796763420105,
0.3114456534385681,
0.41382184624671936,
0.572331428527832,
0.18830877542495728,
0.2721230089664459,
-0.3278522193431854,
0.10286484658718109,
-0.6254178285598755,
-0.1761000156402588,
-0.2682705819606781,
-0.5652146339416504,
0.07417682558298111,
-0.3347151577472687,
0.7585934400558472,
0.40174996852874756,
-0.05801011994481087,
-0.164282888174057,
0.18166841566562653,
0.40441593527793884,
-0.8048141002655029,
-0.39326614141464233,
-0.5753323435783386,
0.339862585067749,
-0.009430037811398506,
-0.21861618757247925,
-0.25328925251960754,
-0.6776700615882874,
0.2127501666545868,
-0.7027387022972107,
0.7047260403633118,
0.23773258924484253,
0.8420515060424805,
0.1340155303478241,
-0.38652294874191284,
-0.37654146552085876,
-0.44643718004226685,
1.3104838132858276,
-0.6523542404174805,
0.35646843910217285,
0.32829439640045166,
0.21902412176132202,
-0.012921122834086418,
-0.15232224762439728,
-0.357768177986145,
-0.12778818607330322,
-0.3095245361328125,
0.17903019487857819,
0.37006357312202454,
0.14445942640304565,
0.027586836367845535,
0.7490920424461365,
-0.6040886640548706,
0.5451707243919373,
-0.5604402422904968,
-0.3659878969192505,
0.5053626298904419,
-0.10409393161535263,
0.20790325105190277,
0.011265018954873085,
-0.09512775391340256,
-0.4012555181980133,
-0.05302990972995758,
0.01590992510318756,
0.13166646659374237,
-0.15503975749015808,
-0.03673303872346878,
0.13562577962875366,
0.15150509774684906,
0.417421817779541,
0.0536208301782608,
-0.647137463092804,
0.4364332854747772,
0.0540275014936924,
-0.04714643210172653,
-0.10978396981954575,
0.6240445971488953,
0.4917535185813904,
-0.08523492515087128,
-0.48491790890693665,
-0.18234513700008392,
0.20132946968078613,
0.3149324953556061,
-0.7694995403289795,
0.3162882626056671,
0.22088173031806946,
-0.8816474080085754,
-1.0474926233291626,
0.014702362939715385,
-1.1600421667099,
-0.16285645961761475,
0.14594252407550812,
0.39445334672927856,
-0.372592031955719,
-0.2699398100376129,
-0.30462846159935,
-0.49482396245002747,
-0.05128982290625572,
0.09033751487731934,
-1.2095708847045898,
0.2878158390522003,
0.5916804671287537,
0.7503089904785156,
-0.7456907033920288,
-0.28371894359588623,
-0.26646164059638977,
0.3987674415111542,
-0.3278453052043915,
0.5780258178710938,
-0.9012731313705444,
-1.0646822452545166,
-0.03297257050871849,
-0.27209001779556274,
0.018511969596147537,
-0.621688187122345,
0.6169233918190002,
-0.38454291224479675,
0.5467620491981506,
0.06302741169929504,
-0.495414137840271,
-0.5834314227104187,
0.2871042788028717,
-0.5461986660957336,
1.4735950231552124,
0.3253912627696991,
-0.4163212776184082,
0.5001263618469238,
-0.6082047820091248,
-0.4837074875831604,
0.04567055404186249,
-0.10542016476392746,
-0.5939493775367737,
0.29532936215400696,
0.2268422394990921,
0.18901124596595764,
-0.42046934366226196,
0.36852261424064636,
-0.3064332902431488,
-0.5874722003936768,
-0.3249076008796692,
0.20669160783290863,
0.4287295341491699,
0.20899131894111633,
-0.39430221915245056,
0.1674553006887436,
-0.7718998789787292,
0.3210083842277527,
0.12865276634693146,
-0.4360489547252655,
-0.4678816497325897,
0.2596704661846161,
0.037245772778987885,
-0.11591004580259323,
0.15178342163562775,
-0.6044866442680359,
0.10650859773159027,
-0.37712734937667847,
0.44603967666625977,
0.455039381980896,
0.13255228102207184,
0.6630010008811951,
-0.4653549790382385,
0.4325230121612549,
-0.46487319469451904,
0.36584755778312683,
0.19662511348724365,
-0.40128564834594727,
-0.4934995472431183,
-0.024848174303770065,
0.24221418797969818,
0.7342694997787476,
-0.8135227560997009,
0.5500065684318542,
0.19679509103298187,
-0.6557401418685913,
-0.2659461796283722,
0.05303755775094032,
0.5849750638008118,
0.4963321387767792,
0.5053720474243164,
0.0069062067195773125,
-0.13766664266586304,
-0.6161484718322754,
-0.08359555155038834,
0.07596655935049057,
0.06469401717185974,
0.29344040155410767,
0.31400954723358154,
-0.3734142780303955,
0.7789137363433838,
-0.906565248966217,
-0.3307282328605652,
-0.07529328018426895,
0.11437024176120758,
-0.10445936024188995,
0.40475764870643616,
1.040887713432312,
-0.9374463558197021,
-0.4948560893535614,
0.387805312871933,
-0.7289429903030396,
-0.218470960855484,
0.12376276403665543,
-0.14829498529434204,
0.4285489618778229,
0.33692899346351624,
0.1437232792377472,
0.34458187222480774,
0.5321603417396545,
-0.06222439184784889,
0.4945818781852722,
-0.47157707810401917,
0.33611688017845154,
-0.9885079264640808,
-0.140077143907547,
0.06469310820102692,
0.07257802784442902,
-0.4203672409057617,
0.1714908629655838,
0.11647406965494156,
-0.34700852632522583,
0.05567748844623566,
0.7174479961395264,
-0.22722017765045166,
0.09045649319887161,
-0.5630897879600525,
0.17708507180213928,
-0.07892065495252609,
0.638685941696167,
-0.1405336707830429,
0.645492672920227,
0.5326666235923767,
-0.4355485141277313,
-0.013180240988731384,
0.2391456514596939,
0.10814385861158371,
0.45118293166160583,
-0.17992578446865082,
0.20638996362686157,
0.07334490865468979,
-0.1451648473739624,
-0.5080170631408691,
0.2559678852558136,
-0.2049582153558731,
-0.324370801448822,
0.5475396513938904,
0.2915136516094208,
-0.4461532235145569,
-0.6720492839813232,
-0.8892326354980469,
0.20126119256019592,
0.4933162033557892,
-0.541519284248352,
0.7391648292541504,
0.27237799763679504,
0.004410586319863796,
-0.6070795059204102,
-0.3383757174015045,
-0.05950864776968956,
-0.21260903775691986,
-0.3298773467540741,
0.5000370144844055,
-0.0021642125211656094,
0.25347334146499634,
0.18684113025665283,
-0.32755693793296814,
-0.12234572321176529,
0.1779651641845703,
-0.21865782141685486,
0.2709743082523346,
0.17674431204795837,
0.2707148492336273,
0.553974449634552,
-0.2655254006385803,
-0.3519112765789032,
-0.3882237374782562,
0.2865680456161499,
0.15155504643917084,
0.004192882217466831,
0.05783551558852196,
0.47928792238235474,
0.24534189701080322,
-0.2975180149078369,
0.5334793329238892,
0.8855686783790588,
-0.2058587670326233,
-0.7202030420303345,
-0.7255675792694092,
-0.3278517425060272,
-0.5358506441116333,
0.49663493037223816,
0.06775883585214615,
-1.216499924659729,
0.2575364410877228,
-0.1565961241722107,
0.18390437960624695,
0.3744358718395233,
0.18128085136413574,
-0.23739580810070038,
0.6413425803184509,
0.9202855825424194,
-0.2784368097782135,
0.7937460541725159,
-0.29314664006233215,
0.3110310435295105,
-0.4708499014377594,
-0.4001489579677582,
-0.8494967222213745,
-0.40316975116729736,
-0.8115071058273315,
-0.27688995003700256,
0.4605512320995331,
-0.05793836712837219,
0.020084472373127937,
0.022396238520741463,
-0.9347513914108276,
0.3252979815006256,
0.8162556886672974,
0.2990846037864685,
0.0168194267898798,
0.22073012590408325,
-0.2721271216869354,
-0.18014122545719147,
-0.5209261178970337,
-0.1216174066066742,
1.0441612005233765,
-0.08072512596845627,
0.31951379776000977,
-0.29620161652565,
0.797249972820282,
0.4698852598667145,
0.17793965339660645,
-0.7678456902503967,
0.7125638723373413,
-0.5830720663070679,
-0.42934468388557434,
-0.3898753225803375,
-0.36014461517333984,
-0.6604742407798767,
0.4813913106918335,
-0.8193666338920593,
-0.8092839121818542,
0.017221445217728615,
-0.1376582533121109,
0.1832127422094345,
0.5013650059700012,
-0.8343794345855713,
0.5945739150047302,
-0.3260945975780487,
-0.13738232851028442,
-0.6505001783370972,
-0.18044038116931915,
-0.1295873522758484,
-0.5166926980018616,
0.2672700881958008,
0.2885040044784546,
-0.1953754425048828,
0.9205988049507141,
-0.5405825972557068,
0.3776046633720398,
-0.2544158101081848,
0.193730890750885,
0.14200051128864288,
-0.18124918639659882,
0.3252864480018616,
-0.5627244710922241,
-0.4016248881816864,
0.01718001253902912,
-0.04752800241112709,
-0.23070555925369263,
-0.6789107322692871,
0.5567775368690491,
-0.7131775617599487,
-0.6733210682868958,
-0.10651761293411255,
-0.4439083933830261,
-0.2927028238773346,
0.4592666029930115,
0.4230250418186188,
0.43295854330062866,
0.02291194535791874,
0.47399234771728516,
0.519627571105957,
-0.2766537070274353,
0.7662580013275146,
0.3619886040687561,
-0.1994158774614334,
-0.7941439747810364,
1.3697434663772583,
0.08191390335559845,
0.200607031583786,
0.6551957726478577,
0.7208613157272339,
-0.004234062507748604,
-1.098447561264038,
-0.16687433421611786,
0.48373451828956604,
-0.4573010206222534,
-0.0654255673289299,
-0.5281774401664734,
-0.18537026643753052,
-0.04649156332015991,
-0.887069046497345,
0.3409614562988281,
-0.13221219182014465,
-0.34092411398887634,
-0.1255004107952118,
0.1294025182723999,
0.4941251277923584,
0.13665097951889038,
0.40211719274520874,
-1.0326223373413086,
0.3602280020713806,
0.21556533873081207,
0.22978931665420532,
0.4379587471485138,
-0.18985788524150848,
-0.4784563481807709,
-0.511020839214325,
-0.7200883626937866,
-0.8237919211387634,
0.23522181808948517,
0.2797926068305969,
0.8291113376617432,
0.7136061191558838,
-0.07481896132230759,
0.280470073223114,
-0.1785571128129959,
0.5527878403663635,
0.3001396656036377,
-0.8813696503639221,
0.7531359791755676,
-0.5509247183799744,
0.11404705047607422,
0.6654496192932129,
0.20407608151435852,
-0.22453296184539795,
-0.660980224609375,
-0.5938718914985657,
-0.5203539133071899,
0.7834054231643677,
0.23232266306877136,
-0.22820724546909332,
0.3652714192867279,
0.29546433687210083,
0.21392013132572174,
0.5052279233932495,
-0.638301432132721,
-0.26668062806129456,
-0.07382980734109879,
-0.23559698462486267,
0.05725175887346268,
-0.4300144612789154,
0.048778679221868515,
-0.12225648015737534,
0.8246344923973083,
-0.2517736256122589,
-0.082418292760849,
-0.21800532937049866,
0.04138682037591934,
-0.19514775276184082,
0.2829751670360565,
0.39381545782089233,
0.4052570164203644,
-0.3337087035179138,
-0.6703696250915527,
0.5359407663345337,
-1.0341256856918335,
0.04374365881085396,
-0.012709910981357098,
-0.6688756346702576,
-0.0790136381983757,
0.31842291355133057,
0.6429007053375244,
0.5356917381286621,
-0.28676679730415344,
0.3241974115371704,
0.44580742716789246,
-0.41395583748817444,
0.27492260932922363,
0.5863174796104431,
-0.11804414540529251,
0.1838308721780777,
0.7969825267791748,
-0.15767936408519745,
0.28863105177879333,
-0.37908923625946045,
-0.1662677377462387,
0.4066316783428192,
-0.04216434061527252,
0.21290355920791626,
0.4663589596748352,
0.41311097145080566,
-0.42021068930625916,
0.15199562907218933,
-0.11398942768573761,
-0.7737230062484741,
0.9331237077713013,
0.5941452980041504,
0.896895170211792,
-0.24354855716228485,
0.34779566526412964,
0.5896931886672974,
0.28969576954841614,
-0.13984520733356476,
0.1522260457277298,
-0.31739869713783264,
-0.6664000749588013,
-0.08247131109237671,
-0.723864734172821,
-0.5443350672721863,
-0.055388957262039185,
-0.723717451095581,
0.5069490075111389,
-0.6134358048439026,
0.045835740864276886,
-0.21080484986305237,
0.5134981870651245,
-0.05622025579214096,
0.6143113374710083,
0.11543533205986023,
0.8759068846702576,
-0.6134024262428284,
0.8222416043281555,
0.7466858625411987,
0.2178189754486084,
-0.6111394762992859,
0.01916283741593361,
0.019616663455963135,
-0.5648370981216431,
0.07023707032203674,
0.19915106892585754,
-0.08157297223806381,
0.03753914311528206,
-0.17989875376224518,
-0.5484299659729004,
1.3229641914367676,
-0.041345082223415375,
-0.6004277467727661,
-0.19388583302497864,
-0.14988648891448975,
0.5577926635742188,
-0.22135812044143677,
0.12553317844867706,
0.44960159063339233,
0.3709779679775238,
0.4163024425506592,
-0.9370529651641846,
-0.06241016089916229,
0.0689404085278511,
0.36350709199905396,
0.6341993808746338,
-0.8855200409889221,
0.32461726665496826,
-0.061317794024944305,
-0.01490884181112051,
-0.10674446821212769,
0.27686190605163574,
0.29116371273994446,
0.6019250154495239,
0.6552004814147949,
0.8970121741294861,
0.9126065969467163,
-0.06809563934803009,
0.8078984022140503,
0.07061043381690979,
0.646353542804718,
0.5597909092903137,
0.0015046225162222981,
0.6054911017417908,
0.22762514650821686,
-0.29080089926719666,
0.5064478516578674,
0.5655450224876404,
-0.5528585910797119,
0.9056265950202942,
-0.13223865628242493,
-0.38632944226264954,
0.024769781157374382,
0.076774463057518,
-0.4754890203475952,
0.1403021365404129,
0.3719460666179657,
-0.16101539134979248,
-0.6427798271179199,
0.3674432039260864,
-0.08844652026891708,
0.2734771966934204,
-0.6290463209152222,
0.8218938708305359,
0.13253465294837952,
-0.41365692019462585,
0.3579424023628235,
-0.08437853306531906,
1.0825389623641968,
-0.8943607211112976,
0.12222747504711151,
-0.028007544577121735,
-0.00494419876486063,
-0.5240085124969482,
-0.6647363901138306,
0.1856357902288437,
-0.15702667832374573,
-0.5317761898040771,
-0.14584951102733612,
0.9638062715530396,
-0.19190531969070435,
-0.4406229555606842,
0.749517023563385,
0.056166235357522964,
-0.14282472431659698,
0.20835983753204346,
-0.5012233257293701,
-0.07354701310396194,
0.4009273946285248,
0.05459494888782501,
0.49774935841560364,
0.18165317177772522,
-0.3894374966621399,
0.5401999950408936,
0.6529034376144409,
0.16462375223636627,
-0.24524909257888794,
-0.025795146822929382,
0.8382540941238403,
-0.6841393113136292,
-0.918066680431366,
-0.5460540056228638,
0.18659155070781708,
-0.36558231711387634,
-0.18049506843090057,
0.47357431054115295,
0.5608134269714355,
0.8350908756256104,
-0.001410622033290565,
0.8348588347434998,
-0.0697886273264885,
0.6934300065040588,
-0.4776000380516052,
0.9110178351402283,
-0.9344823360443115,
-0.23141968250274658,
-0.1812615990638733,
-1.2311457395553589,
-0.041018493473529816,
0.18983127176761627,
-0.4894918203353882,
0.06092461571097374,
1.126312017440796,
0.7419137358665466,
0.12442456185817719,
0.23251017928123474,
0.45508307218551636,
-0.15691499412059784,
0.18396303057670593,
0.398456871509552,
0.230226069688797,
-0.2461300492286682,
0.7748993635177612,
-0.27290478348731995,
-0.4099191725254059,
-0.4185715317726135,
-0.9277036786079407,
-1.1066166162490845,
-0.46441975235939026,
-0.13025277853012085,
-0.06048182025551796,
-0.11952531337738037,
0.45118746161460876,
0.6292199492454529,
-0.924530029296875,
-0.025029711425304413,
0.31474819779396057,
0.38635504245758057,
-0.19460253417491913,
-0.23371201753616333,
0.4229556620121002,
-0.3532074987888336,
-0.6315006017684937,
0.2992113530635834,
0.16324664652347565,
0.02549912966787815,
0.16162283718585968,
-0.05207231268286705,
0.05534452572464943,
-0.23493067920207977,
0.49066200852394104,
0.296257883310318,
-0.3627100884914398,
-0.21277013421058655,
-0.28090518712997437,
-0.07613862305879593,
-0.11082148551940918,
0.7130704522132874,
-0.6426567435264587,
0.41624030470848083,
0.3668459355831146,
0.8510526418685913,
0.7721198201179504,
-0.1942748725414276,
0.35329779982566833,
-0.4760562479496002,
0.4419909417629242,
0.13831831514835358,
0.08127863705158234,
0.10370481014251709,
-0.6032413244247437,
0.5929531455039978,
0.5537519454956055,
-0.345669686794281,
-0.8230230212211609,
-0.3698429763317108,
-0.956889808177948,
-0.4956352114677429,
0.8630207180976868,
0.2943929135799408,
-0.2282392531633377,
0.12541377544403076,
-0.2507518231868744,
0.08743154257535934,
-0.395984947681427,
0.9303869009017944,
0.8024145364761353,
0.28861963748931885,
-0.2684260606765747,
-0.691277027130127,
0.2999320328235626,
0.4733898341655731,
-0.8171663880348206,
-0.8572139739990234,
0.3112665116786957,
0.36765581369400024,
0.1192934587597847,
0.31728479266166687,
0.11502230167388916,
0.33989012241363525,
-0.07999694347381592,
0.07411515712738037,
-0.3310106098651886,
-0.032960932701826096,
-0.15636037290096283,
0.42512038350105286,
-0.2861216366291046,
-0.36318573355674744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11827v1 | Ask Optimal Questions: Aligning Large Language Models with Retriever's Preference in Conversational Search | 2024-02-19T04:41:31 | 2024-02-19T04:41:31 | Chanwoong Yoon, Gangwoo Kim, Byeongguk Jeon, Sungdong Kim, Yohan Jo, Jaewoo Kang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Conversational search, unlike single-turn retrieval tasks, requires
understanding the current question within a dialogue context. The common
approach of rewrite-then-retrieve aims to decontextualize questions to be
self-sufficient for off-the-shelf retrievers, but most existing methods produce
sub-optimal query rewrites due to the limited ability to incorporate signals
from the retrieval results. To overcome this limitation, we present a novel
framework RetPO (Retriever's Preference Optimization), which is designed to
optimize a language model (LM) for reformulating search queries in line with
the preferences of the target retrieval systems. The process begins by
prompting a large LM to produce various potential rewrites and then collects
retrieval performance for these rewrites as the retrievers' preferences.
Through the process, we construct a large-scale dataset called RF collection,
containing Retrievers' Feedback on over 410K query rewrites across 12K
conversations. Furthermore, we fine-tune a smaller LM using this dataset to
align it with the retrievers' preferences as feedback. The resulting model
achieves state-of-the-art performance on two recent conversational search
benchmarks, significantly outperforming existing baselines, including GPT-3.5. | [
-0.35050585865974426,
-0.776204526424408,
0.4098614454269409,
-0.1444050669670105,
-0.319271445274353,
-0.16191211342811584,
-0.2735694944858551,
-0.28907766938209534,
0.4748951196670532,
0.8137755393981934,
-0.8352416753768921,
-0.14646267890930176,
-0.18533258140087128,
0.1707903891801834,
-0.34319019317626953,
0.87941575050354,
0.19613578915596008,
-0.24339932203292847,
0.007529200054705143,
-0.048317957669496536,
-0.33631184697151184,
-0.2697913944721222,
-0.6874328851699829,
-0.17208541929721832,
0.5707632899284363,
0.6172531247138977,
0.9513314366340637,
0.6111684441566467,
0.42994701862335205,
0.32795581221580505,
-0.026384854689240456,
0.26421624422073364,
-0.7608790397644043,
0.7138020992279053,
-0.21835048496723175,
-0.6773158311843872,
-0.022807257249951363,
-0.3186441659927368,
0.41915369033813477,
0.74306720495224,
-0.660873532295227,
-0.11627604067325592,
-0.3118838369846344,
0.7215535640716553,
-0.612917959690094,
-0.08040428906679153,
-1.050127387046814,
0.08584442734718323,
0.12743991613388062,
-0.5492672324180603,
-0.5025779008865356,
-0.73882657289505,
0.5980362892150879,
-0.7947766780853271,
0.3987116515636444,
0.4605124890804291,
0.8598608374595642,
0.09282802790403366,
-0.4113921523094177,
-0.1582929641008377,
-0.42962244153022766,
0.8919191956520081,
-0.44846001267433167,
0.6577329039573669,
0.3741868734359741,
0.4063485264778137,
-0.3516162931919098,
-0.474217027425766,
-0.1970655471086502,
-0.13758794963359833,
-0.06126035004854202,
-0.023243853822350502,
-0.30373266339302063,
0.008587797172367573,
-0.17654666304588318,
0.2907692492008209,
-0.6439710855484009,
-0.1014045849442482,
-0.1908184438943863,
0.09624150395393372,
0.6558569669723511,
0.22368592023849487,
0.10876491665840149,
-0.17180924117565155,
-0.14748862385749817,
-0.11702733486890793,
-0.6475557684898376,
-0.034890491515398026,
0.24399836361408234,
0.4416491985321045,
0.564972996711731,
0.6197581887245178,
-0.6198012232780457,
0.7951333522796631,
0.34169137477874756,
0.12741073966026306,
0.0012531414395198226,
-0.5143914222717285,
-0.12996143102645874,
-0.1613278090953827,
0.6429768800735474,
0.5141025185585022,
0.25377920269966125,
-0.2928275465965271,
-0.370140016078949,
-0.5821604132652283,
0.45073172450065613,
-0.8419825434684753,
-0.0737529918551445,
0.30335497856140137,
-0.44045278429985046,
-0.30518776178359985,
-0.288848340511322,
-0.6494452357292175,
-0.04504995420575142,
-0.41291946172714233,
0.3759715259075165,
-0.30672287940979004,
-0.31796813011169434,
0.39840948581695557,
-0.08412350714206696,
0.3786454200744629,
0.3453253507614136,
-1.2933341264724731,
0.17076376080513,
0.6044143438339233,
0.5251637697219849,
0.13445234298706055,
0.101763054728508,
-0.48157256841659546,
-0.03621479496359825,
-0.3622302711009979,
0.948638916015625,
-0.787082314491272,
-0.6308838725090027,
0.20144465565681458,
0.0887613296508789,
-0.026103684678673744,
-0.6826721429824829,
0.5505363941192627,
-0.9341355562210083,
0.39051005244255066,
-0.5791364908218384,
-0.3494087755680084,
0.20725932717323303,
0.3966442942619324,
-0.47703808546066284,
0.9188480973243713,
0.02375904843211174,
-0.44369181990623474,
0.26013803482055664,
-0.46877622604370117,
-0.24653127789497375,
0.011668710969388485,
-0.07025991380214691,
-0.18313488364219666,
0.2539456784725189,
0.2902599275112152,
0.045916762202978134,
-0.5366516709327698,
0.47679126262664795,
-0.1279159039258957,
-0.27237457036972046,
0.34288591146469116,
-0.16562128067016602,
0.36346375942230225,
0.31727758049964905,
-0.10978101938962936,
0.046408604830503464,
-0.3096395432949066,
0.4163341522216797,
0.25316932797431946,
-0.4978744685649872,
-0.2541086971759796,
0.202417254447937,
-0.17840363085269928,
-0.24450458586215973,
0.46079081296920776,
-0.6242277026176453,
0.20227904617786407,
-0.6843493580818176,
0.46094077825546265,
0.7378875017166138,
-0.14764952659606934,
0.4792060852050781,
-0.40704646706581116,
0.6500799655914307,
-0.42588260769844055,
0.3374233841896057,
-0.22683554887771606,
-0.08178935945034027,
-0.7319642305374146,
0.2318229228258133,
0.10288586467504501,
0.25331127643585205,
-0.5817878842353821,
0.3273143768310547,
-0.4259341061115265,
-0.40486499667167664,
-0.6161309480667114,
-0.022095799446105957,
0.4640277028083801,
0.557410717010498,
0.23891997337341309,
-0.12310584634542465,
-0.5521544814109802,
-1.2556968927383423,
-0.3745167553424835,
-0.17847880721092224,
-0.0029064880218356848,
0.7987600564956665,
0.16898827254772186,
0.037453729659318924,
1.0472891330718994,
-0.90096116065979,
-0.003888737643137574,
-0.3143825829029083,
-0.08458272367715836,
0.215959832072258,
0.39828136563301086,
0.1651189923286438,
-1.0406314134597778,
-0.4613659381866455,
0.07385247945785522,
-0.3857329487800598,
-0.3166236877441406,
0.32578447461128235,
-0.4802730679512024,
0.027300942689180374,
0.44761112332344055,
-0.5069653987884521,
-0.01024092361330986,
0.11452388763427734,
0.0531938336789608,
0.44554880261421204,
-0.3115982413291931,
0.23702391982078552,
-0.9309528470039368,
0.27815234661102295,
-0.1803629994392395,
-0.0924474447965622,
-0.4500192701816559,
0.24701473116874695,
-0.13011525571346283,
-0.20439428091049194,
-0.28674498200416565,
0.49004918336868286,
-0.4297986924648285,
0.07415670156478882,
-0.3152366578578949,
0.44499099254608154,
0.09475447982549667,
0.424313485622406,
0.2217743992805481,
0.7421020269393921,
0.1339767724275589,
-0.4415751099586487,
0.233724445104599,
0.5163887143135071,
-0.17059093713760376,
0.5924514532089233,
-0.9489927887916565,
0.4200858771800995,
-0.27872905135154724,
0.3438139855861664,
-1.2077374458312988,
-0.28530624508857727,
-0.17290548980236053,
-0.46408015489578247,
0.14198480546474457,
-0.3666563928127289,
-0.35891589522361755,
-0.08474099636077881,
-0.47033071517944336,
0.5776071548461914,
0.20430853962898254,
-0.6494589447975159,
0.5307333469390869,
0.5738798975944519,
-0.1751302033662796,
-0.7800214290618896,
-0.23787908256053925,
-0.009514829143881798,
-0.08799473941326141,
-0.8504374027252197,
0.4596201181411743,
-0.1694214940071106,
0.1379426270723343,
-0.37247946858406067,
-0.14942041039466858,
0.0024428521282970905,
-0.1001623272895813,
-0.1862456500530243,
0.19693824648857117,
-0.15222884714603424,
0.13690169155597687,
0.15807756781578064,
-0.11075984686613083,
-0.01061653159558773,
-0.21421846747398376,
0.8871203064918518,
-0.1259864866733551,
-0.20777325332164764,
-0.21864372491836548,
0.5858650803565979,
0.4060879349708557,
-0.4163252115249634,
0.43914303183555603,
0.03895813971757889,
-0.04199017956852913,
-0.016397787258028984,
-0.7935926914215088,
-0.5289632678031921,
-0.5093746185302734,
0.3992006480693817,
-0.5644128918647766,
-1.0506162643432617,
0.42447730898857117,
0.01825946755707264,
0.20703013241291046,
0.048331163823604584,
0.2946326434612274,
-0.018945110961794853,
1.337489128112793,
0.43054965138435364,
-0.013414636254310608,
0.6508851051330566,
-0.06373365968465805,
0.46663835644721985,
-0.8945866227149963,
-0.423846572637558,
-0.7946127653121948,
-0.2028188854455948,
-0.5740875005722046,
-0.15976117551326752,
0.21100971102714539,
-0.1922542154788971,
-0.25439655780792236,
0.4521818459033966,
-0.6227949261665344,
0.5811676979064941,
0.7010964751243591,
0.20340731739997864,
0.2733076214790344,
0.004452602472156286,
-0.050443392246961594,
-0.28528550267219543,
-0.6790921688079834,
-0.37292054295539856,
1.2306095361709595,
-0.011752229183912277,
0.8031236529350281,
0.27181515097618103,
0.7859876155853271,
-0.09061548113822937,
0.05895860120654106,
-0.7488880753517151,
0.5685956478118896,
-0.01935104839503765,
-0.8999007344245911,
-0.5090276598930359,
-0.4254930019378662,
-1.3971232175827026,
0.6836813688278198,
0.08221009373664856,
-0.741070032119751,
0.2391185313463211,
0.24603688716888428,
-0.28483521938323975,
-0.1495886743068695,
-0.6785715222358704,
0.8230053782463074,
-0.25782129168510437,
-0.4410132169723511,
-0.21851471066474915,
-0.7185474038124084,
0.13470607995986938,
0.03810084983706474,
-0.05189986526966095,
-0.0955352783203125,
-0.047905050218105316,
0.48952311277389526,
-0.21813462674617767,
0.4115855097770691,
-0.09084782004356384,
0.08074715733528137,
0.056095633655786514,
0.38701003789901733,
0.7072686553001404,
0.02663365751504898,
-0.12190742045640945,
-0.595578670501709,
0.3351106345653534,
-0.1974797546863556,
-0.7744603157043457,
0.5841013193130493,
-0.4890049397945404,
-0.9832980036735535,
-0.15935344994068146,
-0.3541354537010193,
-0.18611156940460205,
0.3370218575000763,
0.07556070387363434,
0.33271563053131104,
-0.45723190903663635,
0.49752283096313477,
0.7657149434089661,
-0.18300890922546387,
-0.08178175240755081,
0.8186355829238892,
-0.36244726181030273,
-0.1760401576757431,
0.6979904770851135,
-0.2508845627307892,
0.3005900979042053,
0.7451617121696472,
0.35196471214294434,
-0.772763192653656,
-0.4558371603488922,
-0.26221567392349243,
0.3835703134536743,
-0.5048251748085022,
-0.23288239538669586,
-0.7097529172897339,
0.15954425930976868,
-0.38269293308258057,
-0.1814657747745514,
-0.471851110458374,
-0.08448828011751175,
-0.11480163037776947,
0.04862887039780617,
0.012413584627211094,
0.02155711129307747,
0.16466876864433289,
0.2592999041080475,
-0.46367204189300537,
0.23651482164859772,
0.2675092816352844,
0.22581543028354645,
-0.12335170060396194,
-0.6352400779724121,
-0.05423355475068092,
0.24372023344039917,
-0.3735336363315582,
-0.6173826456069946,
0.6108959317207336,
0.03867384418845177,
0.5167496800422668,
0.22193153202533722,
0.3159853219985962,
0.7232670187950134,
-0.5023406744003296,
0.3641808331012726,
0.015532256104052067,
-0.720730721950531,
0.9707080721855164,
-0.5706753134727478,
0.10027182847261429,
0.9149869084358215,
0.2700192630290985,
-0.7758565545082092,
-0.08358049392700195,
-0.5165557861328125,
-1.019370436668396,
0.7430235743522644,
0.2589132785797119,
0.29429692029953003,
-0.21948803961277008,
0.4686899781227112,
-0.019814107567071915,
0.41791054606437683,
-0.4331017732620239,
0.07900992035865784,
-0.06714174896478653,
-0.019773749634623528,
0.2847018837928772,
-0.28985917568206787,
-0.27571818232536316,
0.08575563877820969,
0.5898168087005615,
-0.33516472578048706,
0.25327977538108826,
0.16695095598697662,
0.03738719969987869,
-0.19481326639652252,
0.35932379961013794,
0.3263450264930725,
0.5309546589851379,
-0.5913791656494141,
-0.21523217856884003,
-0.09775374829769135,
-0.0812268853187561,
0.03411807119846344,
-0.045162368565797806,
-0.2037297636270523,
-0.2534470558166504,
-0.23908771574497223,
0.4680243134498596,
0.43669530749320984,
-1.0529305934906006,
0.3338924050331116,
-0.3204241693019867,
-0.24524758756160736,
-0.1934863179922104,
0.11930674314498901,
0.16624587774276733,
0.04318517446517944,
0.2745693027973175,
-0.326266884803772,
0.3235667645931244,
-0.5675246715545654,
0.05754932761192322,
0.7579723596572876,
-0.1411636620759964,
-0.15307781100273132,
0.5249307155609131,
0.32606321573257446,
-0.44361332058906555,
0.8222815990447998,
0.21717320382595062,
-0.41078200936317444,
0.3036538064479828,
0.5666917562484741,
0.7117838859558105,
-0.32684943079948425,
0.26064735651016235,
0.39299944043159485,
0.115148164331913,
-0.29210370779037476,
0.2950451076030731,
-0.22639572620391846,
-0.9833117127418518,
-0.06911330670118332,
-0.5374768972396851,
-0.47396615147590637,
0.07897194474935532,
-0.757585346698761,
0.04239507392048836,
-0.23747949302196503,
0.0013796655694022775,
0.059816740453243256,
0.03423898294568062,
-0.3922790586948395,
0.24236461520195007,
-0.5966972708702087,
0.612464964389801,
-0.33832380175590515,
0.5406209826469421,
0.41003310680389404,
-0.41782695055007935,
-0.6918570399284363,
-0.3503393828868866,
-0.09827394038438797,
-1.0772615671157837,
0.5363982915878296,
-0.01075866911560297,
-0.37650805711746216,
0.03689830005168915,
-0.44889917969703674,
-1.1719762086868286,
1.0012911558151245,
0.6514900922775269,
-0.6005699038505554,
-0.15586981177330017,
0.019487647339701653,
0.575951874256134,
-0.46829497814178467,
0.43946173787117004,
0.7211692333221436,
0.3029768764972687,
0.290122389793396,
-0.9535638093948364,
0.0396004281938076,
-0.21207624673843384,
0.11320333927869797,
0.49721091985702515,
-0.8752415180206299,
0.38071179389953613,
-0.13924925029277802,
-0.2208661586046219,
0.31007176637649536,
0.2544794976711273,
0.4361411929130554,
0.0767282173037529,
0.49485382437705994,
0.42327380180358887,
0.5866162180900574,
-0.15139254927635193,
1.0321531295776367,
-0.3907414972782135,
0.3354845941066742,
0.9956213235855103,
-0.2660757303237915,
1.0520933866500854,
0.5490769743919373,
-0.08589397370815277,
-0.0010982647072523832,
0.7581241130828857,
0.4038553833961487,
0.6011855006217957,
0.41701772809028625,
-0.19556546211242676,
-0.4615379571914673,
-0.2390812188386917,
-0.2880672812461853,
0.6133734583854675,
0.049412667751312256,
-0.4688098132610321,
-0.11020387709140778,
-0.3646419644355774,
0.0626465231180191,
0.14821426570415497,
0.26655086874961853,
0.8112918138504028,
-0.2059229165315628,
-1.172351360321045,
0.6846415996551514,
0.08255621790885925,
0.4840032756328583,
-0.5816700458526611,
0.2646746337413788,
-0.7505336999893188,
0.2523360550403595,
-0.04185355827212334,
-0.5926223993301392,
0.2068328559398651,
-0.31903719902038574,
-0.21054553985595703,
-0.20800864696502686,
0.4271458387374878,
-0.5273922681808472,
-0.25932639837265015,
0.19417348504066467,
0.47098055481910706,
0.2241559773683548,
-0.2749798893928528,
-0.8205481767654419,
0.06647755950689316,
0.44667795300483704,
-0.3203835189342499,
0.43843236565589905,
0.35270342230796814,
0.04152470454573631,
0.9366508722305298,
0.8138240575790405,
-0.18859724700450897,
-0.0577375590801239,
0.2514473497867584,
0.8986991047859192,
-0.6611921191215515,
-0.3385067582130432,
-0.32017067074775696,
0.1052272617816925,
-0.01954413205385208,
-0.39243078231811523,
0.4687696397304535,
0.804867684841156,
0.8164393305778503,
0.1602676808834076,
0.4952753484249115,
0.19341342151165009,
0.6208924651145935,
-0.38315391540527344,
0.3093494474887848,
-0.7147538661956787,
0.33510324358940125,
-0.20474116504192352,
-1.0516270399093628,
-0.025863640010356903,
0.71131831407547,
-0.3051955997943878,
0.19166666269302368,
0.42867258191108704,
1.279728651046753,
-0.06288143247365952,
0.32848477363586426,
0.25129589438438416,
-0.19054105877876282,
0.662696897983551,
0.6256516575813293,
0.798643946647644,
-0.42839300632476807,
0.7093309164047241,
0.027312636375427246,
-0.08453002572059631,
-0.44193074107170105,
-0.5429030656814575,
-0.3251979649066925,
-0.621002733707428,
-0.17289504408836365,
-0.09179151058197021,
0.21654103696346283,
0.8773790597915649,
0.7239877581596375,
-0.41140902042388916,
-0.44121626019477844,
-0.11260868608951569,
-0.03573504835367203,
0.2317616492509842,
-0.2347380518913269,
0.23349973559379578,
-0.522186815738678,
-0.8955305814743042,
0.5270203948020935,
0.20956340432167053,
-0.27849531173706055,
-0.06174676492810249,
-0.061225999146699905,
-0.24251607060432434,
0.0434672050178051,
0.5357121229171753,
0.38169926404953003,
-0.8091917634010315,
-0.30397942662239075,
0.49517157673835754,
0.12004699558019638,
0.18417996168136597,
1.0102020502090454,
-0.6465720534324646,
0.8250387907028198,
0.5002046823501587,
0.6833129525184631,
0.7298972010612488,
0.29146608710289,
0.8586906790733337,
-0.4980736970901489,
-0.30452606081962585,
0.4121297001838684,
0.1673930436372757,
0.2921988368034363,
-0.354705274105072,
0.4074608087539673,
-0.09206979721784592,
-0.8324654698371887,
-0.9031842947006226,
0.31898564100265503,
-0.9118891954421997,
-0.24302226305007935,
0.9836745858192444,
0.09185654670000076,
-0.022659005597233772,
-0.05174548923969269,
-0.44453907012939453,
-0.15256644785404205,
-0.6990368366241455,
0.8914044499397278,
0.44431790709495544,
-0.34096559882164,
-0.28504154086112976,
-0.29536205530166626,
0.32467639446258545,
0.9106550216674805,
-0.42085492610931396,
0.36593344807624817,
0.5283677577972412,
0.41950488090515137,
-0.017014313489198685,
0.860013484954834,
-0.20361283421516418,
0.19650812447071075,
-0.2677513659000397,
-0.35294559597969055,
0.21675899624824524,
-0.08212748914957047,
0.06928420811891556,
0.20829345285892487,
0.13607703149318695,
-0.17921103537082672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11821v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11821v2 | Microstructures and Accuracy of Graph Recall by Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T04:29:45 | 2024-02-20T03:23:49 | Yanbang Wang, Hejie Cui, Jon Kleinberg | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SI | Graphs data is crucial for many applications, and much of it exists in the
relations described in textual format. As a result, being able to accurately
recall and encode a graph described in earlier text is a basic yet pivotal
ability that LLMs need to demonstrate if they are to perform reasoning tasks
that involve graph-structured information. Human performance at graph recall
has been studied by cognitive scientists for decades, and has been found to
often exhibit certain structural patterns of bias that align with human
handling of social relationships. To date, however, we know little about how
LLMs behave in analogous graph recall tasks: do their recalled graphs also
exhibit certain biased patterns, and if so, how do they compare with humans and
affect other graph reasoning tasks? In this work, we perform the first
systematical study of graph recall by LLMs, investigating the accuracy and
biased microstructures (local structural patterns) in their recall. We find
that LLMs not only underperform often in graph recall, but also tend to favor
more triangles and alternating 2-paths. Moreover, we find that more advanced
LLMs have a striking dependence on the domain that a real-world graph comes
from -- by yielding the best recall accuracy when the graph is narrated in a
language style consistent with its original domain. | [
-0.08680146187543869,
-0.9949461817741394,
0.7068051099777222,
-0.06094491481781006,
0.06739551573991776,
0.20244422554969788,
0.015976740047335625,
-0.43476784229278564,
0.3700396716594696,
0.3718910813331604,
-0.11755292117595673,
-0.7650215029716492,
-0.4782707095146179,
0.11890126764774323,
-0.376308798789978,
0.5715128183364868,
-0.3000051975250244,
-0.006951065268367529,
-0.3657805919647217,
-0.04415323957800865,
-0.12453275173902512,
-0.8549501895904541,
-0.798332154750824,
-0.7698971033096313,
0.8085070848464966,
0.21796299517154694,
0.673832356929779,
0.9562613368034363,
0.07050830870866776,
0.2622072100639343,
-0.3828926682472229,
0.1479583978652954,
-0.6272104978561401,
-0.1777559518814087,
-0.07720264047384262,
-0.6417837142944336,
-0.7091720104217529,
-0.06050172820687294,
0.8815089464187622,
1.0352317094802856,
0.11654740571975708,
0.04889164865016937,
0.4524073302745819,
0.9611093997955322,
-0.055374521762132645,
0.607799768447876,
-0.5976913571357727,
-0.09015489369630814,
-0.40255242586135864,
-0.28286322951316833,
-0.7406090497970581,
-0.5267212390899658,
-0.08110634237527847,
-0.5465694069862366,
0.43448585271835327,
0.3470818102359772,
0.7069234848022461,
-0.21051838994026184,
-0.5825852751731873,
-0.38278648257255554,
-0.49240007996559143,
0.1751306802034378,
-0.22570683062076569,
0.3479768931865692,
0.6649910807609558,
0.017019588500261307,
-0.5603305101394653,
-0.7319366931915283,
-0.011671549640595913,
0.039800554513931274,
-0.368491530418396,
-0.12245447188615799,
-0.26952874660491943,
0.1551879644393921,
0.31832072138786316,
0.21450267732143402,
-0.50108402967453,
0.34200799465179443,
-0.4672253429889679,
-0.6130754351615906,
0.4301627576351166,
0.3783191740512848,
0.19439385831356049,
-0.34858542680740356,
-0.21186858415603638,
-0.20477555692195892,
-1.1139627695083618,
0.031767912209033966,
0.35212820768356323,
0.4493246376514435,
0.012796120718121529,
0.6083385348320007,
-0.315116286277771,
0.42779284715652466,
-0.0755361020565033,
0.04451288282871246,
0.23176003992557526,
-0.1559235006570816,
-0.12118229269981384,
0.14432740211486816,
0.4664326608181,
0.20124977827072144,
0.7563199400901794,
-0.17806801199913025,
-0.05964924022555351,
-0.024681756272912025,
0.06268034875392914,
-0.5186233520507812,
-0.6231646537780762,
-0.31309041380882263,
-0.6951364278793335,
-0.013142903335392475,
-0.0722849890589714,
-0.40423089265823364,
-0.5002732872962952,
-0.14302395284175873,
0.12296506017446518,
-0.5052933096885681,
0.020121034234762192,
-0.066532664000988,
-0.22536109387874603,
-0.05353317782282829,
0.2243444323539734,
-0.7485109567642212,
0.44801750779151917,
0.641921877861023,
1.0628300905227661,
-0.11486627906560898,
-0.6346851587295532,
-0.35921844840049744,
0.16234807670116425,
-0.42707177996635437,
0.8853453993797302,
-0.49117380380630493,
-0.2628413736820221,
-0.07946926355361938,
0.06033964827656746,
-0.16510680317878723,
-0.5980483293533325,
0.35624387860298157,
-0.5942010283470154,
-0.23519504070281982,
-0.7548432350158691,
-0.7217257022857666,
-0.3910781145095825,
0.08974890410900116,
-0.7823348641395569,
0.8766764402389526,
0.08600541204214096,
-0.834067702293396,
0.19226782023906708,
0.194906085729599,
-0.6059827208518982,
-0.25869718194007874,
-0.405773401260376,
-0.303911030292511,
0.07728642225265503,
-0.009366781450808048,
0.5388000011444092,
0.018811985850334167,
-0.09141183644533157,
-0.44896799325942993,
-0.5768804550170898,
0.26589539647102356,
-0.3468240797519684,
0.8018410205841064,
-0.2113959640264511,
0.00528502743691206,
-0.016360854730010033,
-0.6014645099639893,
-0.22698204219341278,
0.3833323121070862,
-0.5319667458534241,
-0.6169964671134949,
0.23934289813041687,
-0.6880803108215332,
0.13400281965732574,
0.03423572704195976,
-0.550338625907898,
0.15394814312458038,
-0.11956770718097687,
0.5479004383087158,
1.1822636127471924,
0.12832196056842804,
0.457035630941391,
-0.48493608832359314,
0.1368454247713089,
-0.0642547607421875,
-0.11457499116659164,
-0.10504978895187378,
-0.4830201268196106,
-0.5592593550682068,
-0.25482112169265747,
0.12692338228225708,
0.4654044806957245,
-0.5050871968269348,
-0.037955205887556076,
-0.3291754722595215,
-0.3137282729148865,
0.14243899285793304,
0.1671476513147354,
0.4734358787536621,
0.5020264387130737,
0.07179372012615204,
-0.4403126835823059,
-0.5646547675132751,
-0.9128423929214478,
-0.22218239307403564,
-0.14695383608341217,
0.1478348672389984,
0.6817317605018616,
0.30263552069664,
-0.13612507283687592,
0.8433488011360168,
-0.6351321339607239,
-0.3984268605709076,
-0.2493113875389099,
0.005377733148634434,
0.12373866885900497,
0.03324145823717117,
0.6485022902488708,
-0.2985318601131439,
-0.36443206667900085,
-0.3272949159145355,
-0.7457494735717773,
-0.08074367791414261,
0.20864993333816528,
-0.24316950142383575,
0.42895302176475525,
0.6534917950630188,
-0.5914262533187866,
0.4385862946510315,
0.3986680805683136,
-0.6346468329429626,
0.4059422016143799,
-0.22941836714744568,
-0.21174374222755432,
-0.5854419469833374,
-0.2199741154909134,
-0.12026647478342056,
-0.2673039734363556,
-0.5231725573539734,
-0.5063967704772949,
0.06657228618860245,
0.2517678141593933,
-0.08630528301000595,
0.5798642039299011,
-0.7265146970748901,
-0.4624515473842621,
0.06514550745487213,
0.33964183926582336,
-0.01990688033401966,
0.5998275876045227,
-0.15636178851127625,
0.6826183795928955,
0.24930225312709808,
-0.7085908055305481,
-0.13777950406074524,
0.10464467853307724,
-0.4080103933811188,
0.29091301560401917,
-0.4643528461456299,
0.45601391792297363,
-0.23012125492095947,
0.3101264536380768,
-1.2288960218429565,
-0.20553411543369293,
-0.07327115535736084,
-0.27912452816963196,
0.4403442442417145,
-0.10464490205049515,
-0.6510187387466431,
-0.4032088816165924,
-0.16070803999900818,
0.32732513546943665,
0.4725784659385681,
-0.4214760661125183,
0.5428562164306641,
0.574891209602356,
-0.2488599717617035,
-0.3049663007259369,
-0.47601261734962463,
-0.33106371760368347,
0.025884222239255905,
-0.40847957134246826,
0.050809506326913834,
0.1974688172340393,
-0.19238066673278809,
-0.0869622677564621,
-0.40060049295425415,
0.03870607540011406,
0.1697840541601181,
0.44277966022491455,
0.3278612494468689,
-0.04442465305328369,
0.09705043584108353,
-0.1302574872970581,
-0.14977072179317474,
0.15165600180625916,
-0.08227165788412094,
0.981837809085846,
-0.17068065702915192,
-0.2981225848197937,
-0.09517306834459305,
-0.035697437822818756,
0.36353322863578796,
0.15371598303318024,
0.279543399810791,
0.1304885894060135,
-0.4646022319793701,
0.06407876312732697,
-0.3876113295555115,
-0.11859779804944992,
-0.4271135628223419,
0.6166781783103943,
-0.511451244354248,
-1.0167922973632812,
0.8490238785743713,
-0.027829302474856377,
-0.36942434310913086,
0.3509988486766815,
0.36919987201690674,
-0.35272061824798584,
1.01566743850708,
0.3273657560348511,
-0.3776381313800812,
0.5224661827087402,
-0.13821916282176971,
-0.13717612624168396,
-0.8597200512886047,
-0.25409263372421265,
-0.5397040247917175,
-0.42998212575912476,
-0.44363468885421753,
-0.41694045066833496,
0.28295785188674927,
0.11263737082481384,
-0.5132340788841248,
0.07972478121519089,
-0.23159250617027283,
0.6940250992774963,
0.5274339318275452,
0.4357788562774658,
0.3999366760253906,
0.43627551198005676,
-0.3347197473049164,
-0.09483715146780014,
-0.8484593033790588,
-0.6745095252990723,
0.9340223073959351,
0.3366380035877228,
0.9037359356880188,
-0.17217287421226501,
0.7285816669464111,
0.18910470604896545,
0.21245001256465912,
-0.5122304558753967,
0.6668127179145813,
-0.391381174325943,
-0.4085678458213806,
-0.22509898245334625,
-0.517308235168457,
-1.1985915899276733,
0.09894447028636932,
0.029517613351345062,
-0.8277776837348938,
0.09912020713090897,
0.5390706658363342,
-0.0854496881365776,
0.475607305765152,
-0.5952573418617249,
0.6379730105400085,
-0.18705178797245026,
-0.16153375804424286,
-0.11886754631996155,
-0.40580758452415466,
0.19563032686710358,
0.31836503744125366,
0.3141558766365051,
-0.23769614100456238,
0.30019962787628174,
0.6570199131965637,
0.22629737854003906,
1.2668285369873047,
-0.025991003960371017,
0.14841187000274658,
0.36356934905052185,
0.700195848941803,
0.7266980409622192,
-0.42083659768104553,
-0.09630320966243744,
0.365387886762619,
-0.23488004505634308,
-0.3347695469856262,
-0.44364285469055176,
0.5493316054344177,
-0.7853250503540039,
-0.4488503336906433,
-0.33209022879600525,
-0.5565646290779114,
0.09120259433984756,
0.3375528156757355,
0.20717650651931763,
0.6223373413085938,
-0.5333309769630432,
0.03361502289772034,
0.7321704626083374,
-0.05275692418217659,
0.24990101158618927,
0.15733268857002258,
-0.45323073863983154,
-0.17484498023986816,
0.9681035876274109,
0.6186204552650452,
0.5711790323257446,
0.37536051869392395,
0.131283700466156,
0.056152284145355225,
-0.6363615393638611,
-0.2408268004655838,
0.4113330841064453,
-0.9053428173065186,
-0.15075115859508514,
-0.5862002372741699,
-0.2885211408138275,
-0.059547681361436844,
-0.20125581324100494,
-0.25495150685310364,
-0.7114474773406982,
-0.34091734886169434,
-0.36366716027259827,
0.2666504979133606,
1.1365007162094116,
0.14602160453796387,
-0.19615043699741364,
-0.4614134728908539,
0.20454277098178864,
0.2286413013935089,
0.4264359772205353,
0.25611254572868347,
-0.1874217987060547,
-0.12449440360069275,
0.00014797557378187776,
-0.14705052971839905,
-0.7946346402168274,
0.09627238661050797,
0.07132051885128021,
0.7489456534385681,
0.089399054646492,
-0.26236096024513245,
0.5933037400245667,
-0.6495662331581116,
0.43270087242126465,
-0.26507067680358887,
-0.6747202277183533,
0.3083447515964508,
-0.20709797739982605,
0.16288402676582336,
0.24331018328666687,
0.3110225796699524,
-0.4304935038089752,
-0.34015995264053345,
-0.6089485287666321,
-0.6815972328186035,
0.591912031173706,
0.10416051745414734,
0.007165595889091492,
-0.3877480924129486,
0.7570465803146362,
-0.04074771702289581,
-0.12838025391101837,
-0.56271892786026,
-0.22748497128486633,
-0.11426940560340881,
-0.2600879371166229,
-0.11823699623346329,
-0.46411892771720886,
-0.1967729926109314,
-0.22351127862930298,
0.22998569905757904,
-0.22424206137657166,
0.4885560870170593,
0.333855539560318,
-0.23802803456783295,
0.030991675332188606,
-0.008605497889220715,
0.4419575035572052,
0.657234251499176,
-0.24981947243213654,
0.6711035370826721,
0.3452475070953369,
-0.5814917683601379,
0.06788584589958191,
-0.2330341339111328,
-0.36524394154548645,
-0.12513260543346405,
0.5855242609977722,
0.6435775756835938,
0.37801414728164673,
-0.20928017795085907,
0.14404183626174927,
0.18730774521827698,
0.006322489585727453,
-0.18018531799316406,
0.12566059827804565,
0.2557750940322876,
0.3797318935394287,
0.25768446922302246,
0.013717499561607838,
-0.03044275753200054,
-0.8626643419265747,
0.04309998080134392,
0.5127635598182678,
-0.36498937010765076,
-0.41398948431015015,
0.4309764802455902,
-0.14049018919467926,
-0.5843547582626343,
0.8957409262657166,
-0.31224602460861206,
-0.603148341178894,
0.6608614325523376,
0.8567252159118652,
0.6723641753196716,
0.0558253638446331,
0.025282295420765877,
0.46312814950942993,
0.3520466089248657,
-0.13063402473926544,
0.20553259551525116,
0.24718311429023743,
-0.9942318201065063,
0.007058421149849892,
-0.3876822292804718,
-0.23076283931732178,
-0.5100146532058716,
-0.6157539486885071,
-0.05624322220683098,
-0.6830435991287231,
-0.21082575619220734,
-0.16866204142570496,
-0.11782925575971603,
-0.5659782290458679,
-0.004374206531792879,
0.23871944844722748,
1.0542256832122803,
-0.909152090549469,
0.9037575125694275,
0.4260314106941223,
-0.2890390157699585,
-0.8570582270622253,
-0.3594718873500824,
0.2701317071914673,
-1.0581471920013428,
0.6128233075141907,
0.07556433975696564,
-0.40524640679359436,
0.06010618060827255,
-0.45770254731178284,
-1.0317689180374146,
1.4470415115356445,
0.38259199261665344,
-0.4578745365142822,
-0.21358071267604828,
-0.0827331617474556,
0.5050822496414185,
-0.5955952405929565,
-0.04405272752046585,
0.7677570581436157,
0.06155840680003166,
0.04135369136929512,
-0.7197705507278442,
0.308986634016037,
0.06250061839818954,
0.12009526789188385,
0.31012052297592163,
-0.8972923159599304,
1.1125786304473877,
-0.3052769601345062,
-0.33937811851501465,
-0.21984948217868805,
0.45160558819770813,
0.5396649241447449,
0.3089689016342163,
0.2660767436027527,
0.1876085102558136,
1.1999402046203613,
-0.0966176763176918,
1.2968082427978516,
0.06609974056482315,
0.2162632793188095,
1.2359193563461304,
-0.30449411273002625,
0.7935245037078857,
0.1318521350622177,
-0.14650613069534302,
0.748229444026947,
0.7440347671508789,
0.26972758769989014,
0.29914000630378723,
-0.030298788100481033,
0.42300620675086975,
-0.221403107047081,
0.12879787385463715,
-0.053209077566862106,
0.29728394746780396,
0.37015700340270996,
-0.6289026141166687,
0.13844165205955505,
-0.4994221031665802,
0.46192535758018494,
0.014350966550409794,
-0.5005710124969482,
0.6837136745452881,
0.27197495102882385,
-0.31688761711120605,
0.45439931750297546,
-0.29420292377471924,
0.1656070500612259,
-0.4363365173339844,
-0.016921743750572205,
-0.4622427225112915,
0.27042341232299805,
-0.19717051088809967,
-0.965297520160675,
0.2958243489265442,
-0.36761319637298584,
-0.5346965789794922,
-0.2713109254837036,
0.8915274143218994,
-0.12583030760288239,
-0.37383773922920227,
0.6344553232192993,
0.35286009311676025,
0.24765217304229736,
0.06673374027013779,
-0.26470884680747986,
0.11359003186225891,
0.1418997198343277,
-0.3825919032096863,
0.4677470326423645,
0.3596011698246002,
-0.524320125579834,
0.7020078301429749,
0.36862242221832275,
0.19596286118030548,
0.46985846757888794,
0.3003116846084595,
0.7958236336708069,
-0.8668174147605896,
-0.13218209147453308,
-1.0533591508865356,
0.034550897777080536,
-0.14606964588165283,
-0.10308607667684555,
0.9608407020568848,
0.8580707311630249,
1.0008692741394043,
0.24813304841518402,
0.4794330894947052,
0.2839302718639374,
0.3707067668437958,
-0.824338972568512,
0.5075352191925049,
-0.06322728097438812,
0.08484699577093124,
-0.39303311705589294,
-0.7952184081077576,
-0.2301580011844635,
0.7147487998008728,
-0.28089872002601624,
0.06284796446561813,
0.8340938091278076,
0.7598052024841309,
0.03266763687133789,
0.0491839163005352,
-0.008099226281046867,
0.7356828451156616,
0.2609769403934479,
0.7437840104103088,
0.763658344745636,
-0.20009180903434753,
0.5395576357841492,
-0.12980517745018005,
-0.23255608975887299,
-0.11321551352739334,
-0.6835861802101135,
-1.0733057260513306,
-0.4219231903553009,
-0.025929637253284454,
-0.6141899228096008,
-0.20518460869789124,
0.7067123055458069,
0.31505516171455383,
-0.5176986455917358,
-0.47173383831977844,
0.04761919751763344,
0.6343831419944763,
-0.17896397411823273,
-0.1696212887763977,
0.5725041031837463,
-0.09336143732070923,
-0.3755583167076111,
0.204204261302948,
0.6051375865936279,
0.38579797744750977,
0.025533700361847878,
-0.18505382537841797,
-0.10928893089294434,
0.05086391791701317,
0.7725974321365356,
0.24884793162345886,
-0.6375393867492676,
-0.7745881676673889,
0.21620528399944305,
-0.4270835220813751,
0.4616415500640869,
1.06401789188385,
-0.6292389035224915,
0.23313648998737335,
0.6131783127784729,
0.12851642072200775,
0.775766134262085,
0.047045331448316574,
0.40351951122283936,
-0.6461113691329956,
0.11492463946342468,
-0.07526084780693054,
0.6542366147041321,
0.4312644302845001,
-0.23890306055545807,
0.6688780784606934,
0.46439430117607117,
-0.6161412596702576,
-0.6559940576553345,
0.40363577008247375,
-0.7086268663406372,
-0.3280208110809326,
1.13688063621521,
-0.045086003839969635,
-0.29813307523727417,
-0.30122098326683044,
-0.4080907702445984,
0.41700831055641174,
-0.11460250616073608,
0.7153717279434204,
0.8838024139404297,
-0.4937026798725128,
-0.00038909396971575916,
-0.33782824873924255,
0.3915305435657501,
-0.00818413496017456,
-0.3724542558193207,
0.2531459629535675,
0.6559577584266663,
0.5048544406890869,
0.06900360435247421,
1.1504319906234741,
-0.1336897611618042,
0.035132523626089096,
0.1870398372411728,
-0.2339329719543457,
-0.08091767132282257,
-0.5192376971244812,
-0.17132647335529327,
0.2801901400089264,
0.3059040307998657,
0.21502743661403656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11819v1 | Head-wise Shareable Attention for Large Language Models | 2024-02-19T04:19:36 | 2024-02-19T04:19:36 | Zouying Cao, Yifei Yang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) suffer from huge number of parameters, which
restricts their deployment on edge devices. Weight sharing is one promising
solution that encourages weight reuse, effectively reducing memory usage with
less performance drop. However, current weight sharing techniques primarily
focus on small-scale models like BERT and employ coarse-grained sharing rules,
e.g., layer-wise. This becomes limiting given the prevalence of LLMs and
sharing an entire layer or block obviously diminishes the flexibility of weight
sharing. In this paper, we present a perspective on $\textit{$\textbf{head-wise
shareable attention for large language models}$}$. We further propose two
memory-efficient methods that share parameters across attention heads, with a
specific focus on LLMs. Both of them use the same dynamic strategy to select
the shared weight matrices. The first method directly reuses the pre-trained
weights without retraining, denoted as $\textbf{DirectShare}$. The second
method first post-trains with constraint on weight matrix similarity and then
shares, denoted as $\textbf{PostShare}$. Experimental results reveal our
head-wise shared models still maintain satisfactory capabilities, demonstrating
the feasibility of fine-grained weight sharing applied to LLMs. | [
-0.4637344181537628,
-0.4491470754146576,
0.6938092112541199,
0.5939840078353882,
-0.4450448453426361,
-0.2443210929632187,
-0.5743666291236877,
-0.5350474715232849,
0.4329304099082947,
0.506587564945221,
-0.49014535546302795,
-0.2937822937965393,
-0.8204284906387329,
-0.40402230620384216,
-0.3643324673175812,
0.8759307861328125,
-0.32751262187957764,
-0.13768233358860016,
-0.42251795530319214,
-0.49672138690948486,
-0.4559786915779114,
-0.3262370228767395,
-0.851618230342865,
-0.4069085121154785,
1.1216126680374146,
0.32043635845184326,
0.6564752459526062,
0.7768902778625488,
0.5704773664474487,
0.2326236218214035,
-0.15772157907485962,
0.11169935017824173,
-0.615517795085907,
0.19052863121032715,
-0.2977035343647003,
-0.15915469825267792,
-0.6400054097175598,
-0.06285066902637482,
0.7257798314094543,
0.8443583846092224,
-0.23491734266281128,
0.0952472910284996,
0.4546930193901062,
0.6146211624145508,
-0.6560630202293396,
0.050072647631168365,
-0.7641834616661072,
0.17690709233283997,
-0.1559724509716034,
-0.07436176389455795,
-0.19257038831710815,
-0.2945370376110077,
0.4448545277118683,
-0.4180434048175812,
-0.19185902178287506,
-0.08988460153341293,
0.5867735743522644,
0.24891351163387299,
-0.09945987910032272,
0.052727095782756805,
-0.5683144927024841,
1.178486704826355,
-0.707207441329956,
0.5518438220024109,
0.48682576417922974,
0.18147993087768555,
0.20708440244197845,
-0.6206210851669312,
-0.3554442226886749,
-0.18176813423633575,
0.12716726958751678,
-0.20894768834114075,
-0.3311646282672882,
0.10607213526964188,
0.13195106387138367,
0.2923186421394348,
-0.27906328439712524,
0.07119226455688477,
-0.035178616642951965,
-0.08148834109306335,
0.6123010516166687,
-0.27080488204956055,
0.18361181020736694,
0.36239543557167053,
-0.5639289617538452,
-0.09561989456415176,
-0.8023863434791565,
-0.17257829010486603,
0.07628181576728821,
0.2880886495113373,
-0.1911810338497162,
0.4143654704093933,
-0.18945758044719696,
0.7019138336181641,
0.2733977735042572,
0.13851860165596008,
0.31378990411758423,
-0.25172537565231323,
-0.2487632930278778,
-0.0757753849029541,
0.7620606422424316,
0.33364027738571167,
0.709443211555481,
-0.4242197871208191,
-0.27291572093963623,
-0.5176777839660645,
0.2584986090660095,
-0.8057115077972412,
-0.06289002299308777,
0.17435678839683533,
-0.4894501864910126,
0.0006815035594627261,
-0.4690288305282593,
-0.4919399321079254,
-0.45486539602279663,
-0.41125136613845825,
0.6384278535842896,
-0.40611186623573303,
-0.31457871198654175,
0.14982247352600098,
0.19756583869457245,
0.35551878809928894,
0.3049304783344269,
-0.9720155000686646,
0.18697455525398254,
0.6360019445419312,
1.0165550708770752,
-0.4951317310333252,
-0.44852593541145325,
-0.6702905893325806,
0.2648439109325409,
0.10675043612718582,
0.6042394638061523,
-0.4984217882156372,
-0.1552325338125229,
-0.16849616169929504,
-0.23261329531669617,
-0.13651585578918457,
-0.699769914150238,
0.29413601756095886,
-0.6493276357650757,
-0.32225388288497925,
-0.5996257662773132,
-0.5065229535102844,
-0.1836138218641281,
0.23329393565654755,
-0.5869775414466858,
0.7673687934875488,
-0.19522887468338013,
-0.9982425570487976,
0.004250500816851854,
-0.14372022449970245,
-0.4026426672935486,
0.05055617541074753,
-0.23537252843379974,
-0.45200976729393005,
0.23538221418857574,
0.08410070836544037,
0.7762454152107239,
-0.007080026436597109,
0.32363569736480713,
-0.5872046947479248,
-0.27220383286476135,
0.030910706147551537,
-0.31992629170417786,
0.5412380695343018,
0.21147207915782928,
-0.1355859935283661,
0.20280182361602783,
-0.3391507863998413,
0.022514579817652702,
0.2326454371213913,
-0.2549959719181061,
-0.4646560847759247,
0.1806272715330124,
0.026488324627280235,
0.017034703865647316,
0.5899537205696106,
-0.3352968096733093,
0.21268218755722046,
-0.04667496308684349,
0.34359312057495117,
0.6619175672531128,
-0.09095162898302078,
0.47002291679382324,
-0.5138784050941467,
0.29193681478500366,
-0.03475422039628029,
-0.014444731175899506,
0.1463184952735901,
-0.16400453448295593,
-0.6326002478599548,
-0.4622213840484619,
0.25527334213256836,
0.4046776592731476,
-0.4053230285644531,
0.1341022551059723,
-0.19498595595359802,
-0.4482239782810211,
-0.5256140828132629,
0.4019638001918793,
0.4547818601131439,
0.09435047209262848,
0.2356228083372116,
-0.3183252811431885,
-0.391586571931839,
-1.1046738624572754,
-0.48756954073905945,
0.25453639030456543,
-0.03645236790180206,
0.6662441492080688,
-0.039761003106832504,
-0.12466539442539215,
0.7750493288040161,
-0.5795058608055115,
-0.20257693529129028,
-0.6056879758834839,
0.027103543281555176,
-0.038933392614126205,
0.6134132146835327,
0.496576189994812,
-0.6309179067611694,
-0.7503148317337036,
0.02378297597169876,
-0.5024186968803406,
-0.2638435363769531,
0.016089532524347305,
-0.1940232515335083,
-0.015223275870084763,
0.6199871301651001,
-0.6820964813232422,
0.07294432073831558,
0.8217588067054749,
0.15826106071472168,
0.30440500378608704,
-0.26396626234054565,
-0.2259375900030136,
-0.8134081363677979,
0.10063233971595764,
0.21149468421936035,
-0.6556523442268372,
-0.5287437438964844,
0.23544466495513916,
0.02341158129274845,
0.05948290601372719,
-0.6282299757003784,
0.6036324501037598,
-0.7102446556091309,
-0.28272655606269836,
-0.561583936214447,
0.2892083525657654,
-0.1924278885126114,
0.8026577234268188,
0.12300559878349304,
0.6000543832778931,
1.035652995109558,
-0.7405497431755066,
0.29951491951942444,
-0.2667348384857178,
-0.24680669605731964,
0.772466778755188,
-0.9060980677604675,
0.26327967643737793,
-0.1901932805776596,
0.08658158034086227,
-0.8049007654190063,
0.017534587532281876,
0.26806846261024475,
-0.16042475402355194,
0.40733814239501953,
0.014986029826104641,
-0.502484142780304,
0.05735471099615097,
-0.587492823600769,
0.7333388328552246,
0.1917998045682907,
-0.5451357364654541,
0.5967004895210266,
0.6337867975234985,
-0.50156569480896,
-0.5688430666923523,
-0.701633632183075,
-0.0516144335269928,
-0.33343738317489624,
-0.501007616519928,
0.5920921564102173,
-0.22963911294937134,
-0.11216089129447937,
0.15738071501255035,
-0.20863980054855347,
-0.12436208128929138,
-0.06991516053676605,
-0.0388791449368,
-0.02568664960563183,
0.017470547929406166,
0.06627588719129562,
-0.03255743160843849,
0.04892423748970032,
-0.15656854212284088,
-0.37983325123786926,
0.8410124182701111,
-0.0044307708740234375,
-0.21407873928546906,
-0.634205162525177,
0.6449424624443054,
0.5043208003044128,
-0.5493060946464539,
0.8603690266609192,
0.6014131307601929,
-0.507243275642395,
-0.14189235866069794,
-0.7604645490646362,
-0.13057354092597961,
-0.48685717582702637,
0.5006865859031677,
-0.17892690002918243,
-0.9413237571716309,
0.7481300830841064,
0.07887210696935654,
0.21889378130435944,
-0.030966157093644142,
0.5239094495773315,
-0.2629191279411316,
0.841921865940094,
0.8873969912528992,
-0.3683881461620331,
0.9066193103790283,
-0.008201229386031628,
0.06513377279043198,
-1.0726666450500488,
-0.09283603727817535,
-0.18563798069953918,
-0.7290829420089722,
-0.27405375242233276,
-0.6056578159332275,
0.13782727718353271,
0.18657222390174866,
-0.10504336655139923,
0.4166899621486664,
-0.2876177430152893,
0.6120113730430603,
0.6196630001068115,
0.1547328680753708,
0.24559789896011353,
0.2074688971042633,
-0.02694857306778431,
-0.04963504895567894,
-0.45182564854621887,
-0.06076739728450775,
0.8664533495903015,
0.3120391070842743,
0.9104121327400208,
-0.17132842540740967,
0.679404079914093,
0.09747405350208282,
0.04587991163134575,
-0.9644342660903931,
0.8416761755943298,
-0.17528434097766876,
-0.22100362181663513,
-0.258666455745697,
-0.6341149210929871,
-0.9329791069030762,
0.46543779969215393,
0.2748562693595886,
-1.0930500030517578,
0.0025212359614670277,
0.26199376583099365,
-0.38777992129325867,
0.44619274139404297,
-0.5628440380096436,
0.7581910490989685,
-0.009268403053283691,
-0.4654921591281891,
-0.6758474707603455,
-0.48019668459892273,
0.14759305119514465,
-0.07431832700967789,
-0.13592125475406647,
0.14777161180973053,
0.002567247487604618,
0.9452126026153564,
-0.10785287618637085,
0.8307356238365173,
-0.32348117232322693,
-0.3793303370475769,
0.3484288156032562,
-0.06856627017259598,
0.8022291660308838,
-0.05223199725151062,
0.17165055871009827,
0.19726043939590454,
-0.2548365592956543,
-0.32541102170944214,
-0.3700043857097626,
1.0858269929885864,
-0.8499974012374878,
-0.7056969404220581,
-0.18628039956092834,
-0.8382159471511841,
-0.4576442539691925,
0.4816399812698364,
-0.08790428191423416,
0.3427770137786865,
0.1923362761735916,
0.45816880464553833,
1.0701823234558105,
-0.34130609035491943,
0.5951352715492249,
0.3689948618412018,
-0.27207133173942566,
-0.23262271285057068,
0.8839502334594727,
0.39536330103874207,
0.4302775263786316,
0.3582812547683716,
0.249050572514534,
-0.058418720960617065,
-0.6492086052894592,
-0.03411472588777542,
0.574287474155426,
-0.41340193152427673,
-0.11399820446968079,
-1.1129487752914429,
-0.3940429389476776,
-0.13386063277721405,
-0.1416085809469223,
-0.6670777201652527,
-0.16623729467391968,
-0.11569242924451828,
-0.11195406317710876,
0.4546002447605133,
0.3058601915836334,
-0.13604813814163208,
0.7807154655456543,
-0.6258598566055298,
0.4043898582458496,
0.5333755612373352,
0.6485314965248108,
0.49597692489624023,
-0.3631076514720917,
-0.44271713495254517,
0.00017824328097049147,
-0.4055352210998535,
-0.6907451152801514,
0.2659335136413574,
0.03151440620422363,
0.7334989309310913,
0.3455052077770233,
0.033875737339258194,
0.6522583961486816,
-0.6265920996665955,
0.357400119304657,
0.06949654966592789,
-1.0118111371994019,
0.17035862803459167,
-0.4024321138858795,
0.44000720977783203,
0.6700835227966309,
0.3746147155761719,
-0.7715675234794617,
-0.483401358127594,
-0.31640440225601196,
-1.0618669986724854,
0.9001163244247437,
-0.08403687179088593,
0.2546330988407135,
0.4142199754714966,
0.2932223379611969,
0.026499178260564804,
0.3786381483078003,
-0.9015586376190186,
-0.16886486113071442,
0.22340410947799683,
-0.309172660112381,
0.29068607091903687,
-0.23018917441368103,
0.089894138276577,
-0.1329500377178192,
0.44575244188308716,
0.1269536018371582,
0.2532954216003418,
0.020724432542920113,
-0.20840799808502197,
-0.09204849600791931,
0.10508182644844055,
0.3558696210384369,
0.5707919597625732,
-0.4030231833457947,
0.33715978264808655,
0.23453959822654724,
-0.4980093538761139,
-0.22762995958328247,
0.011371765285730362,
-0.06539108604192734,
-0.2850748300552368,
0.2454853057861328,
0.9303944706916809,
0.2580130398273468,
-0.6062979102134705,
0.5812565088272095,
-0.026327237486839294,
-0.1128653734922409,
-0.012915301136672497,
-0.15140829980373383,
0.5806452035903931,
0.48494774103164673,
0.13940273225307465,
-0.011277290061116219,
-0.08515776693820953,
-0.3987722098827362,
0.3877783417701721,
0.7407825589179993,
-0.5011639595031738,
-0.3961665630340576,
0.368878573179245,
0.20505301654338837,
-0.14452163875102997,
0.18892927467823029,
-0.0957200676202774,
-0.41731393337249756,
0.37529492378234863,
0.3549771010875702,
0.9076383709907532,
-0.35745948553085327,
0.02674180455505848,
0.00967544224113226,
0.09683570265769958,
-0.19671925902366638,
0.3360271751880646,
-0.3176506459712982,
-0.7341477870941162,
-0.5772733688354492,
-0.4624844193458557,
-0.3780944049358368,
0.3459286093711853,
-0.7365033030509949,
0.21015918254852295,
-0.5644773840904236,
-0.06757592409849167,
-0.2396029233932495,
0.09843277931213379,
-0.6266475915908813,
-0.021116357296705246,
0.38848450779914856,
0.6843894720077515,
-0.42514270544052124,
1.1221176385879517,
0.672329306602478,
-0.018467916175723076,
-0.7479019165039062,
0.34896767139434814,
-0.23639163374900818,
-1.0900611877441406,
0.45107701420783997,
0.35901328921318054,
-0.3321886360645294,
0.07208569347858429,
-0.4161202311515808,
-1.061201810836792,
1.017398715019226,
0.36345618963241577,
-0.8121102452278137,
-0.14825353026390076,
-0.1275789886713028,
0.21735264360904694,
-0.1768461912870407,
0.06331770122051239,
0.19234342873096466,
0.46543046832084656,
0.2993837594985962,
-1.0000004768371582,
0.10680675506591797,
0.20271116495132446,
0.049961552023887634,
0.016189169138669968,
-0.9881939888000488,
0.9207517504692078,
-0.18968816101551056,
-0.377978652715683,
-0.28927695751190186,
0.819703996181488,
0.40716415643692017,
0.19028069078922272,
0.8328794836997986,
0.6350463032722473,
0.6039247512817383,
0.5004092454910278,
0.8259357213973999,
-0.33451443910598755,
0.48218098282814026,
1.0249723196029663,
-0.6099032163619995,
1.0701096057891846,
0.6359361410140991,
-0.05577833577990532,
0.02641603909432888,
0.25143706798553467,
0.368895947933197,
0.8049872517585754,
0.38250482082366943,
-0.07579752057790756,
-0.3061490058898926,
-0.33173245191574097,
-0.39934566617012024,
0.2789606750011444,
-0.07213293015956879,
-0.17723718285560608,
-0.3157726526260376,
0.13243623077869415,
0.38328316807746887,
-0.17217154800891876,
-0.6557512879371643,
0.7375582456588745,
0.46709418296813965,
-0.6520159840583801,
0.5145238637924194,
-0.034925803542137146,
1.1147080659866333,
-0.6463382840156555,
0.39922380447387695,
-0.3882480263710022,
0.5239169597625732,
-0.008002171292901039,
-0.80085688829422,
0.5344538688659668,
0.22288089990615845,
-0.32679131627082825,
-0.5951587557792664,
0.6377793550491333,
-0.8872237205505371,
-0.3683333694934845,
0.6499677300453186,
0.38209792971611023,
-0.0446380153298378,
-0.4861557185649872,
-0.5314066410064697,
0.43576696515083313,
-0.014530627988278866,
-0.38644757866859436,
0.6753593683242798,
0.3736485242843628,
0.008904441259801388,
0.8956992626190186,
0.22174929082393646,
0.471566766500473,
0.002082702936604619,
0.027347568422555923,
0.8929426074028015,
-0.6234174370765686,
-0.5564782023429871,
-1.0596187114715576,
0.034977223724126816,
0.08619143068790436,
0.10659494996070862,
0.7351884841918945,
0.2133299559354782,
0.838413417339325,
0.13165345788002014,
0.5709666609764099,
0.23171915113925934,
0.49586498737335205,
-0.342790812253952,
0.9422053098678589,
-0.9188588261604309,
0.09783172607421875,
-0.31680312752723694,
-1.1090800762176514,
-0.2932385206222534,
0.6846415400505066,
-0.22095510363578796,
0.18685176968574524,
0.5146512985229492,
0.5684845447540283,
-0.3633565902709961,
-0.3272796869277954,
0.16814632713794708,
0.15417148172855377,
0.10653728246688843,
0.950873851776123,
0.5626052021980286,
0.03267037868499756,
0.5856469869613647,
-0.04519791901111603,
-0.21743066608905792,
-0.36466753482818604,
-0.8632208704948425,
-0.7807710766792297,
-0.3524482250213623,
-0.531230628490448,
0.12699155509471893,
0.03307691588997841,
1.051806092262268,
0.8720265030860901,
-0.5885718464851379,
-0.33336758613586426,
0.03089274652302265,
0.060830071568489075,
-0.41244393587112427,
-0.16408027708530426,
0.4642394483089447,
-0.08280359208583832,
-0.8569044470787048,
0.09614718705415726,
0.2615906894207001,
-0.08690402656793594,
-0.3276126980781555,
0.06788377463817596,
-0.2552488148212433,
0.4082581102848053,
0.6494613885879517,
0.18831950426101685,
-0.4760330021381378,
-0.3396889269351959,
-0.18780721724033356,
-0.3247832953929901,
-0.062061335891485214,
0.7662390470504761,
-0.6849475502967834,
0.009131289087235928,
0.7228636145591736,
1.076981544494629,
0.4539753198623657,
-0.038259074091911316,
0.568210780620575,
-0.9701200127601624,
0.17628537118434906,
0.20222169160842896,
0.5422593951225281,
0.46656474471092224,
-0.19534607231616974,
0.014226095750927925,
0.02947007119655609,
-0.5259647965431213,
-0.8258412480354309,
0.2676407992839813,
-1.5038864612579346,
-0.20216654241085052,
1.2834112644195557,
-0.32155150175094604,
-0.13897499442100525,
0.4194811284542084,
-0.11672069132328033,
0.3105534315109253,
-0.5048722624778748,
0.4788958728313446,
0.7207277417182922,
0.1357034146785736,
-0.5383182168006897,
-0.6007885336875916,
0.3213794231414795,
0.7395640015602112,
-0.5759186744689941,
0.5480701327323914,
0.02291487716138363,
0.2692261040210724,
-0.059716206043958664,
0.7046904563903809,
0.05678172409534454,
-0.34069448709487915,
-0.5020609498023987,
0.12273692339658737,
-0.12142787128686905,
-0.4818175733089447,
-0.24545753002166748,
-0.04376384988427162,
0.04390576109290123,
-0.5096395015716553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11818v1 | Where It Really Matters: Few-Shot Environmental Conservation Media Monitoring for Low-Resource Languages | 2024-02-19T04:17:21 | 2024-02-19T04:17:21 | Sameer Jain, Sedrick Scott Keh, Shova Chettri, Karun Dewan, Pablo Izquierdo, Johanna Prussman, Pooja Shreshtha, Cesar Suarez, Zheyuan Ryan Shi, Lei Li, Fei Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Environmental conservation organizations routinely monitor news content on
conservation in protected areas to maintain situational awareness of
developments that can have an environmental impact. Existing automated media
monitoring systems require large amounts of data labeled by domain experts,
which is only feasible at scale for high-resource languages like English.
However, such tools are most needed in the global south where news of interest
is mainly in local low-resource languages, and far fewer experts are available
to annotate datasets sustainably. In this paper, we propose NewsSerow, a method
to automatically recognize environmental conservation content in low-resource
languages. NewsSerow is a pipeline of summarization, in-context few-shot
classification, and self-reflection using large language models (LLMs). Using
at most 10 demonstration example news articles in Nepali, NewsSerow
significantly outperforms other few-shot methods and achieves comparable
performance with models fully fine-tuned using thousands of examples. The World
Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) has deployed NewsSerow for media monitoring in
Nepal, significantly reducing their operational burden, and ensuring that AI
tools for conservation actually reach the communities that need them the most.
NewsSerow has also been deployed for countries with other languages like
Colombia. | [
-0.453098863363266,
-0.31301894783973694,
0.23432812094688416,
0.41516971588134766,
-0.5377954244613647,
-0.06623005121946335,
-0.2673834264278412,
-0.5208345055580139,
0.28930631279945374,
0.6516709923744202,
-0.3830302953720093,
-0.6497615575790405,
-0.7048967480659485,
0.48550477623939514,
-0.2570649981498718,
0.8777593374252319,
0.036194272339344025,
-0.4985930025577545,
0.23346269130706787,
-0.46201542019844055,
-0.02519645355641842,
0.32477936148643494,
-0.6195203065872192,
-0.0017758803442120552,
0.3131023943424225,
0.36498042941093445,
0.4648674428462982,
0.5198368430137634,
0.46603724360466003,
0.3217463791370392,
-0.2867389917373657,
0.300652414560318,
-0.43605899810791016,
-0.1528692990541458,
-0.24521583318710327,
-0.5188825130462646,
-0.02338392101228237,
0.15066802501678467,
0.7817233204841614,
0.34591761231422424,
-0.09436304867267609,
0.6447513103485107,
0.015322615392506123,
0.643738329410553,
-0.9484757781028748,
0.21727287769317627,
-0.6023440361022949,
0.17894341051578522,
-0.023870626464486122,
-0.5336953401565552,
-0.1538819968700409,
-0.1559828221797943,
-0.10822340846061707,
-0.6478387713432312,
0.11803512275218964,
0.12739624083042145,
0.6337971687316895,
0.5183809995651245,
-0.5875288844108582,
0.17374029755592346,
-0.43907949328422546,
1.2596515417099,
-0.6140164732933044,
0.2468133568763733,
0.9755186438560486,
0.28313347697257996,
-0.18573319911956787,
-0.294304758310318,
-0.5021984577178955,
0.34415894746780396,
-0.348030149936676,
0.3975847661495209,
-0.6591349244117737,
-0.2332381010055542,
-0.0720161572098732,
0.0420507974922657,
-0.37383612990379333,
0.07558418065309525,
-0.4196178913116455,
-0.49349963665008545,
0.6417000889778137,
0.06578326225280762,
0.17787891626358032,
-0.7357245087623596,
-0.14203229546546936,
0.12496940791606903,
-0.8081845045089722,
-0.0018222808139398694,
0.41075441241264343,
0.4585130512714386,
-0.3658849895000458,
0.38159072399139404,
-0.4416031539440155,
0.8366560935974121,
-0.24827632308006287,
-0.5398748517036438,
-0.23258310556411743,
-0.4893455505371094,
-0.15894004702568054,
0.24521633982658386,
0.48258551955223083,
0.661368191242218,
-0.14958307147026062,
0.1476067155599594,
-0.15429574251174927,
0.0028673771303147078,
-0.19362327456474304,
-0.9522202610969543,
-0.13531510531902313,
-0.022586654871702194,
-0.6598653197288513,
-0.3238650858402252,
-0.2608599066734314,
-0.8672391772270203,
-0.5734927654266357,
-0.3296215832233429,
0.06494751572608948,
0.22876116633415222,
-0.5258205533027649,
0.15582506358623505,
-0.17817175388336182,
0.054826561361551285,
0.7693259716033936,
-0.5542988777160645,
-0.07310108840465546,
0.41758742928504944,
1.0828275680541992,
-0.016769401729106903,
-0.26677823066711426,
-0.8250510096549988,
0.4030255973339081,
-0.431400328874588,
1.068503737449646,
-0.42931368947029114,
-0.274724543094635,
0.05661126598715782,
0.3685424327850342,
0.3044022023677826,
-0.42759621143341064,
0.2588348686695099,
-0.4752049446105957,
0.2952011227607727,
-0.07483183592557907,
-0.3312341570854187,
-0.3571217954158783,
0.47937649488449097,
-0.6933480501174927,
0.7047367691993713,
0.24984407424926758,
-0.9548882842063904,
0.6027213931083679,
-0.2389012575149536,
-0.5610485672950745,
0.07951053231954575,
0.21321065723896027,
-0.44089025259017944,
0.1522853821516037,
0.18136052787303925,
0.18333204090595245,
0.12304218858480453,
-0.29853567481040955,
-0.09551247954368591,
-0.3155266046524048,
-0.3000682294368744,
-0.48132091760635376,
0.7855669260025024,
0.14768201112747192,
-0.13289664685726166,
-0.2716708481311798,
-0.7346616983413696,
0.04437816143035889,
-0.34104371070861816,
-0.7839677929878235,
-0.5491992831230164,
0.03268243372440338,
0.30939239263534546,
0.0148700512945652,
0.029784638434648514,
-0.7513188123703003,
0.05187486112117767,
-0.08767560869455338,
0.5749355554580688,
0.4492652714252472,
0.3488645553588867,
0.5087136626243591,
-0.19021368026733398,
0.6295604109764099,
-0.3010340631008148,
0.16336563229560852,
-0.35986605286598206,
-0.20545697212219238,
-0.37118133902549744,
-0.6222898960113525,
0.07309456169605255,
0.43714162707328796,
-0.44646206498146057,
0.18471217155456543,
-0.16681423783302307,
-0.2784637212753296,
-0.60963374376297,
0.45268699526786804,
0.07203409075737,
0.25378304719924927,
0.21746765077114105,
0.21898576617240906,
-0.7525888681411743,
-0.8800233602523804,
-0.2387576550245285,
-0.27765530347824097,
0.19804799556732178,
0.3449692726135254,
0.30211734771728516,
-0.21786916255950928,
1.113847017288208,
-0.33380401134490967,
-0.8505849838256836,
-0.13008609414100647,
0.42027002573013306,
0.1247977763414383,
0.15227873623371124,
0.5738727450370789,
-0.9333395957946777,
-0.4786131680011749,
0.23043838143348694,
-0.6943711042404175,
-0.20495764911174774,
0.01499940175563097,
-0.10051338374614716,
0.4418809711933136,
0.3135182559490204,
-0.42189842462539673,
0.35206684470176697,
0.9373524188995361,
0.07009298354387283,
0.2894543409347534,
-0.06421079486608505,
0.372917503118515,
-0.7339882850646973,
0.05632069706916809,
0.005087764002382755,
-0.3770589828491211,
-0.10749273747205734,
-0.3315061926841736,
-0.19824635982513428,
-0.3762289583683014,
-0.8597938418388367,
0.9385141134262085,
-0.5338837504386902,
-0.2195422500371933,
-0.8004169464111328,
0.19943788647651672,
0.11948316544294357,
0.2237437218427658,
0.41908958554267883,
0.8167018890380859,
0.2666580379009247,
-0.5790048837661743,
0.15730804204940796,
0.370307058095932,
-0.4509236812591553,
0.6106230616569519,
-0.27720925211906433,
-0.131371408700943,
-0.27312830090522766,
0.4723021686077118,
-0.6336215734481812,
-0.23400229215621948,
-0.2534206509590149,
-0.1290300041437149,
0.002521399175748229,
-0.7102792263031006,
-0.49156683683395386,
-0.2894349694252014,
-0.42351844906806946,
0.1091589704155922,
0.3876394033432007,
-0.46304669976234436,
0.4984506666660309,
0.5677362084388733,
-0.18851341307163239,
-0.5263331532478333,
-0.8956462740898132,
0.3773155212402344,
-0.22213095426559448,
-0.49220433831214905,
-0.29982730746269226,
0.3414832353591919,
-0.1515948325395584,
0.25698062777519226,
-0.25131672620773315,
-0.13042455911636353,
0.11843634396791458,
0.019365590065717697,
-0.14127810299396515,
-0.197143092751503,
0.189128577709198,
0.06381659209728241,
-0.13858211040496826,
-0.368103951215744,
-0.28157269954681396,
0.022254452109336853,
-0.31257835030555725,
0.01749083399772644,
-0.6112094521522522,
0.49349087476730347,
0.5211787819862366,
-0.4436095952987671,
0.49280279874801636,
0.6095110177993774,
-0.4279007017612457,
-0.3543713688850403,
-0.4101499319076538,
-0.1817435771226883,
-0.4308379590511322,
0.27504852414131165,
0.048260416835546494,
-0.7248286008834839,
0.2694922387599945,
-0.2947443127632141,
-0.04656483605504036,
0.23274831473827362,
0.09304257482290268,
-0.2983070909976959,
1.1357324123382568,
0.9825237989425659,
-0.3254011571407318,
0.5004003643989563,
-0.6293483972549438,
0.2558790147304535,
-0.6500325202941895,
0.20815324783325195,
-0.40970730781555176,
-0.3220343589782715,
-0.7228028774261475,
-0.018827103078365326,
0.3432869613170624,
0.07676070928573608,
-0.12174251675605774,
0.4878491163253784,
-0.5451323390007019,
0.7857320308685303,
0.523402214050293,
-0.14001813530921936,
0.6561843156814575,
0.15031851828098297,
0.8197989463806152,
-0.1906273365020752,
-0.5624881982803345,
-0.8259274363517761,
0.39882779121398926,
-0.18339067697525024,
1.0415048599243164,
0.09672778099775314,
1.0160669088363647,
0.6482130885124207,
0.3878537118434906,
-0.9654991030693054,
0.4363672137260437,
-0.354534775018692,
-0.436720609664917,
-0.5059619545936584,
-0.15065139532089233,
-0.8967724442481995,
0.37274283170700073,
0.05027176812291145,
-0.4351551830768585,
0.3741471767425537,
0.2508927583694458,
-0.3075498044490814,
0.3252910375595093,
-0.5945665836334229,
0.5845090746879578,
-0.07544663548469543,
-0.39167216420173645,
-0.4697516858577728,
-0.24665997922420502,
0.26203566789627075,
-0.1481170356273651,
0.5361828207969666,
-0.45338326692581177,
-0.439698725938797,
0.5604133605957031,
-0.06194866821169853,
1.148820161819458,
-0.25661829113960266,
-0.09558304399251938,
0.5598446726799011,
0.3592206537723541,
0.7256186604499817,
0.017143333330750465,
-0.02090831659734249,
0.0780634880065918,
0.05515487864613533,
-0.3741833567619324,
-0.22202090919017792,
0.6553755402565002,
-0.6962847113609314,
-0.6691061854362488,
-0.4109650254249573,
-0.19283924996852875,
-0.008086437359452248,
0.5460608005523682,
0.3697129487991333,
0.15942977368831635,
-0.015356311574578285,
0.35999658703804016,
0.22103913128376007,
-0.2263595312833786,
0.5755425691604614,
1.0869570970535278,
0.03207968920469284,
-0.23759819567203522,
1.0151981115341187,
0.2584255337715149,
-0.08219678699970245,
0.36717489361763,
0.4563332498073578,
-0.21966451406478882,
-0.48325246572494507,
-0.3393833637237549,
0.060465533286333084,
-0.7051795125007629,
-0.6966304779052734,
-0.7174901366233826,
0.14231644570827484,
0.10337170213460922,
-0.3036049008369446,
-0.17736205458641052,
-0.20674988627433777,
-0.04757627099752426,
-0.18985213339328766,
0.40062618255615234,
0.5380697846412659,
-0.37330180406570435,
0.3181547522544861,
-1.0094172954559326,
0.22942791879177094,
0.4479854106903076,
0.17521533370018005,
-0.3531024754047394,
-0.32621026039123535,
-0.390684574842453,
0.1074272096157074,
-0.1635584831237793,
-0.5632928609848022,
0.47068074345588684,
0.6007296442985535,
0.43868762254714966,
0.3783295452594757,
0.40644171833992004,
0.4867688715457916,
-0.23406381905078888,
0.6458412408828735,
0.10271064192056656,
-0.8693514466285706,
1.081007719039917,
-0.4531437158584595,
0.36046743392944336,
0.5613272190093994,
0.09864646941423416,
-0.8296718001365662,
-0.7512812614440918,
-0.2339550256729126,
-0.47957974672317505,
0.7652701735496521,
-0.13187074661254883,
0.2665409445762634,
-0.2647468149662018,
-0.45084863901138306,
0.15904958546161652,
0.2995465099811554,
-0.5040020942687988,
0.5199347734451294,
-0.4252351224422455,
0.01935493014752865,
0.23508211970329285,
0.05954185128211975,
-0.39025944471359253,
0.09166278690099716,
0.7641793489456177,
-0.39179563522338867,
-0.1414341926574707,
0.2434246838092804,
-0.4928048551082611,
-0.5923687815666199,
0.410520076751709,
0.5657366514205933,
0.5159648656845093,
-0.04152647778391838,
0.5574345588684082,
0.12726883590221405,
-0.389055997133255,
0.28161904215812683,
-0.15681029856204987,
-0.36560437083244324,
0.06161409988999367,
0.614758312702179,
0.6958966255187988,
0.35483318567276,
-0.5721471309661865,
0.707907497882843,
0.2151441127061844,
0.11516744643449783,
-0.10089071840047836,
-0.246600940823555,
-0.02836231328547001,
0.280048668384552,
0.4508223235607147,
0.17386949062347412,
0.24650366604328156,
-0.4741455912590027,
-0.045591238886117935,
0.24042755365371704,
0.09508264809846878,
-0.3000930845737457,
0.37538158893585205,
0.4594079852104187,
-0.11052308231592178,
0.5505098104476929,
-0.3545173406600952,
-0.6366901993751526,
0.8148121237754822,
0.4633580446243286,
0.7340067625045776,
0.0027657316531986,
0.4962727129459381,
0.6085114479064941,
0.4656880795955658,
-0.2199198603630066,
0.13105465471744537,
-0.23429332673549652,
-0.45393192768096924,
-0.5413382053375244,
-0.7261173725128174,
-0.4115285873413086,
0.03428489342331886,
-0.3618309199810028,
0.2834959626197815,
-0.3575989902019501,
-0.14248263835906982,
0.0652225986123085,
0.34863460063934326,
-0.632532000541687,
-0.042419787496328354,
0.1160692647099495,
1.038422703742981,
-1.314858317375183,
0.39516618847846985,
0.8637372851371765,
-0.35640376806259155,
-0.3782147765159607,
-0.14519518613815308,
0.13473711907863617,
-0.9684475660324097,
0.780085027217865,
0.17848551273345947,
-0.5516045689582825,
0.1840972751379013,
-0.6691814064979553,
-0.9054780602455139,
0.9800674915313721,
0.4479825496673584,
-0.4874287545681,
0.5789574980735779,
-0.342755526304245,
0.587781548500061,
0.032687000930309296,
-0.3393666744232178,
0.17626774311065674,
1.0463905334472656,
-0.2032196819782257,
-0.8388158679008484,
-0.27795591950416565,
-0.08649536967277527,
-0.012824182398617268,
0.4934650957584381,
-0.9197025299072266,
0.2861452102661133,
-0.42997148633003235,
-0.564111590385437,
-0.11443813145160675,
0.37821441888809204,
0.023935744538903236,
0.24973881244659424,
0.5397528409957886,
0.33014771342277527,
0.615801215171814,
0.13647788763046265,
1.0408689975738525,
-0.3397008180618286,
0.49406495690345764,
0.9017183184623718,
-0.28458309173583984,
0.850262463092804,
0.3843505084514618,
-0.4234183132648468,
0.12822484970092773,
0.6278906464576721,
-0.34506353735923767,
0.8959802389144897,
0.06584551185369492,
-0.48819082975387573,
-0.40664657950401306,
-0.8172969818115234,
-0.05478290468454361,
0.7657324075698853,
0.05317174643278122,
0.17852823436260223,
-0.6605207324028015,
0.3893064260482788,
-0.04235696420073509,
0.18549799919128418,
-0.5093379020690918,
0.6290485858917236,
0.10787983983755112,
-0.6474710702896118,
0.4019355773925781,
-0.10561991482973099,
0.710825502872467,
-0.6686481833457947,
-0.17919306457042694,
-0.5241589546203613,
0.2668890953063965,
-0.6627683639526367,
-1.008240818977356,
0.49878397583961487,
0.1068865954875946,
-0.32029855251312256,
-0.05702752619981766,
0.7724757194519043,
-0.7181857824325562,
-0.4099523425102234,
0.2388218492269516,
0.3648630678653717,
0.310005784034729,
-0.004870587959885597,
-0.24313285946846008,
0.1291232854127884,
-0.23693284392356873,
-0.22117914259433746,
0.11305267363786697,
0.28388503193855286,
-0.4012307822704315,
0.5388155579566956,
0.47913703322410583,
0.46624672412872314,
0.17580971121788025,
0.17082273960113525,
0.23099252581596375,
-0.27485156059265137,
-0.7655275464057922,
-0.4040987193584442,
0.049991633743047714,
-0.1510830819606781,
-0.16524472832679749,
0.9813603758811951,
0.6874442100524902,
0.5698971152305603,
-0.002709189197048545,
0.953452467918396,
0.1935124397277832,
0.2243531197309494,
-0.25222545862197876,
0.7745053172111511,
-0.710630476474762,
-0.26058492064476013,
0.2860477566719055,
-0.8594295978546143,
-0.2779253423213959,
0.6585656404495239,
-0.11477690935134888,
-0.2392238825559616,
0.37525680661201477,
0.7155345678329468,
-0.14261215925216675,
-0.0007374311098828912,
0.3948422074317932,
0.086886927485466,
0.13914445042610168,
0.0976630225777626,
0.8631231188774109,
-0.08034227043390274,
0.7736818194389343,
-0.23381902277469635,
-0.2063332051038742,
-0.1782742589712143,
-1.4424949884414673,
-0.5383129715919495,
-0.2030702382326126,
-0.5670440793037415,
0.1773228496313095,
0.040415890514850616,
0.563173770904541,
0.9765347242355347,
-0.9117235541343689,
-0.033278416842222214,
-0.021406659856438637,
0.1750098317861557,
-0.24922148883342743,
-0.1950148046016693,
0.5469626784324646,
-0.2560848891735077,
-0.8060048222541809,
0.34492209553718567,
0.6114374995231628,
0.17465658485889435,
-0.4773227274417877,
-0.050019521266222,
-0.13136248290538788,
-0.13859477639198303,
0.6727792024612427,
0.726881206035614,
-0.6574519872665405,
-0.34708258509635925,
-0.08757038414478302,
-0.2069748342037201,
-0.1928531676530838,
0.725048303604126,
-0.6464864611625671,
0.43982237577438354,
0.75901859998703,
0.6069056987762451,
0.590313732624054,
-0.13500043749809265,
0.11640460789203644,
-1.0387238264083862,
0.5079777240753174,
0.28950390219688416,
0.44725003838539124,
0.7658461928367615,
-0.37729910016059875,
0.666902482509613,
0.2534146010875702,
-0.39621782302856445,
-0.8471891283988953,
0.086546890437603,
-0.7347800731658936,
-0.10562285035848618,
1.1927547454833984,
-0.1342436820268631,
-0.3004899024963379,
-0.07700610905885696,
-0.3891475200653076,
-0.05874921381473541,
-0.3385724425315857,
0.6122350692749023,
0.7903203368186951,
0.10054167360067368,
-0.40186750888824463,
-0.5184787511825562,
0.4350743889808655,
-0.008024129085242748,
-0.7267130017280579,
0.23886233568191528,
0.546929121017456,
0.3726428747177124,
0.3303844630718231,
0.7870640158653259,
0.1501847356557846,
0.4882957637310028,
-0.07091625779867172,
-0.0697772353887558,
-0.10163508355617523,
-0.2129061371088028,
-0.16443106532096863,
-0.34079447388648987,
-0.2603222727775574,
-0.3504737317562103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11815v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11815v2 | HU at SemEval-2024 Task 8A: Can Contrastive Learning Learn Embeddings to Detect Machine-Generated Text? | 2024-02-19T04:11:34 | 2024-03-27T20:30:08 | Shubhashis Roy Dipta, Sadat Shahriar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our system developed for SemEval-2024 Task 8,
``Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated
Text Detection'' Machine-generated texts have been one of the main concerns due
to the use of large language models (LLM) in fake text generation, phishing,
cheating in exams, or even plagiarizing copyright materials. A lot of systems
have been developed to detect machine-generated text. Nonetheless, the majority
of these systems rely on the text-generating model. This limitation is
impractical in real-world scenarios, as it's often impossible to know which
specific model the user has used for text generation. In this work, we propose
a $\textbf{single}$ model based on contrastive learning, which uses
$\textbf{$\approx$40% of the baseline's parameters}$ (149M vs. 355M) but shows
a comparable performance on the test dataset $(\textbf{21st out of 137
participants})$. Our key finding is that even without an ensemble of multiple
models, a single base model can have comparable performance with the help of
data augmentation and contrastive learning. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/dipta007/SemEval24-Task8. | [
-0.35755351185798645,
-0.7214496731758118,
0.3357560932636261,
-0.09866761416196823,
-0.4571906626224518,
-0.14258502423763275,
0.03211430087685585,
-0.5548200607299805,
-0.01615416631102562,
0.667293131351471,
-0.3712512254714966,
-0.4436858594417572,
-0.53927081823349,
0.4075513482093811,
-0.2948004901409149,
0.8898236155509949,
-0.06620968878269196,
-0.017275631427764893,
-0.28982236981391907,
-0.34948021173477173,
-0.2257653921842575,
-0.5929269194602966,
-0.4840888977050781,
-0.267789363861084,
0.45734184980392456,
0.3865664601325989,
0.083144910633564,
0.3904111981391907,
0.35025590658187866,
0.3794979155063629,
0.06919354200363159,
0.4699881970882416,
-0.41809794306755066,
0.3358674943447113,
-0.12824374437332153,
-0.1725132167339325,
-0.06182413920760155,
-0.04560350999236107,
0.5067614316940308,
0.27599355578422546,
0.15222793817520142,
-0.10693038254976273,
0.4689493775367737,
0.20680677890777588,
-0.7263869643211365,
-0.1474098563194275,
-0.7145246863365173,
0.1471516191959381,
-0.03915520757436752,
-0.23084275424480438,
-0.6406535506248474,
0.04961329326033592,
-0.08134778589010239,
-0.3232327997684479,
0.22349028289318085,
0.10615985095500946,
0.8011175990104675,
0.26097896695137024,
-0.7352021932601929,
-0.3793672025203705,
-0.4146575331687927,
0.841644287109375,
-0.6255388259887695,
0.2389249950647354,
0.1471368372440338,
0.13661716878414154,
0.19438861310482025,
-0.5748307704925537,
-0.4515101909637451,
-0.03342367708683014,
0.03987881913781166,
0.2914532423019409,
0.025808613747358322,
-0.2848200798034668,
0.2636961042881012,
0.40386709570884705,
-0.4546755850315094,
0.25207510590553284,
-0.43319904804229736,
-0.3116919994354248,
0.3742305636405945,
0.13199825584888458,
0.16501550376415253,
-0.15615686774253845,
-0.5888051986694336,
-0.0027073360979557037,
-0.559374213218689,
-0.32978689670562744,
0.43484336137771606,
0.2748780846595764,
-0.30333611369132996,
0.23805294930934906,
0.13724061846733093,
0.23211391270160675,
0.02531908079981804,
0.1567573845386505,
0.5841448903083801,
-0.40661317110061646,
-0.23947201669216156,
-0.06904105842113495,
0.8346526622772217,
-0.08037137240171432,
-0.01877347007393837,
0.0988057479262352,
-0.5065961480140686,
0.3114200234413147,
0.34421682357788086,
-1.1104847192764282,
-0.4778108596801758,
-0.016325898468494415,
-0.3635995388031006,
-0.6787647008895874,
-0.06536149978637695,
-0.7579391002655029,
-0.5996642708778381,
-0.08994465321302414,
0.7439814209938049,
-0.4302808344364166,
-0.18502989411354065,
-0.09243281185626984,
-0.0685892179608345,
0.07524572312831879,
0.38437578082084656,
-0.3915672302246094,
0.03581932187080383,
0.22030480206012726,
0.45695146918296814,
-0.32157203555107117,
-0.4844367206096649,
-0.6961442232131958,
-0.11862362921237946,
-0.16157828271389008,
0.8360378742218018,
-0.6311630010604858,
-0.32009533047676086,
0.15122102200984955,
0.18711894750595093,
0.07399027794599533,
-0.5817410945892334,
0.6413201093673706,
-0.48823192715644836,
0.39774706959724426,
-0.08392418175935745,
-0.6494184136390686,
-0.1321883648633957,
0.2998156249523163,
-0.8503442406654358,
0.8672562837600708,
-0.20235025882720947,
-1.036456823348999,
0.26213374733924866,
-0.3948058485984802,
-0.36817118525505066,
0.1520925909280777,
-0.3163175582885742,
-1.060098648071289,
-0.03254261240363121,
0.23987920582294464,
0.4893338680267334,
-0.02772250398993492,
0.04850491136312485,
-0.40552088618278503,
-0.47602126002311707,
0.25182658433914185,
-0.6299096345901489,
0.5806170701980591,
0.25866520404815674,
-0.5955796837806702,
-0.1760142743587494,
-0.7553490996360779,
-0.3219863176345825,
0.2834400236606598,
-0.598217248916626,
-0.4604819118976593,
-0.301089882850647,
0.14865456521511078,
0.3675064444541931,
0.37183427810668945,
-0.5409163236618042,
-0.3450119197368622,
-0.31242021918296814,
-0.10862911492586136,
0.9175765514373779,
0.14906737208366394,
0.32399582862854004,
-0.39224016666412354,
0.5037082433700562,
0.5624942779541016,
-0.3704459071159363,
-0.9034064412117004,
-0.3419840335845947,
-0.9913310408592224,
-0.31645071506500244,
0.4836212694644928,
0.4089713990688324,
-0.8561363816261292,
0.3455255329608917,
0.26295918226242065,
-0.3152179718017578,
-0.428752601146698,
0.1710946410894394,
0.5424396395683289,
0.42103129625320435,
0.5011568665504456,
0.019930480048060417,
-0.7168747186660767,
-0.8306185007095337,
-0.24645310640335083,
0.4018034338951111,
0.18552349507808685,
0.30121713876724243,
0.9141283631324768,
-0.366720050573349,
0.05556578189134598,
-0.2337007373571396,
-0.029231613501906395,
0.05576610937714577,
0.31981033086776733,
-0.2145746350288391,
0.7178024053573608,
0.3796038031578064,
-0.8829869031906128,
-0.479470819234848,
0.06058591231703758,
-1.0524344444274902,
-0.23949187994003296,
0.166444793343544,
-0.0869208574295044,
0.23392176628112793,
0.6432917714118958,
0.010524934157729149,
0.40269649028778076,
0.7679204344749451,
-0.3383554220199585,
0.47325605154037476,
-0.3457064628601074,
0.31710201501846313,
-1.5347980260849,
0.0035573099739849567,
0.12442445009946823,
-0.26935940980911255,
-0.620668351650238,
0.21659427881240845,
0.3165547251701355,
-0.33080753684043884,
-0.3279339075088501,
0.4569639563560486,
-0.5213434100151062,
0.09981474280357361,
-0.6158360838890076,
-0.002639378421008587,
0.12355851382017136,
0.5430482625961304,
-0.13379478454589844,
0.7797493934631348,
0.24600432813167572,
-0.8103067278862,
-0.1571929156780243,
0.09384047985076904,
-0.15707896649837494,
0.8096878528594971,
-0.5631691813468933,
0.3128413259983063,
-0.09356853365898132,
0.13197724521160126,
-1.0065892934799194,
-0.17584599554538727,
0.23404867947101593,
-0.5590932965278625,
0.1653086543083191,
0.008710420690476894,
-0.26749593019485474,
-0.07132275402545929,
-0.33698195219039917,
0.3320128321647644,
0.4866691827774048,
-0.7735247611999512,
0.5409187078475952,
0.4850867986679077,
-0.14103224873542786,
-0.6335645914077759,
-0.6284902691841125,
-0.17961718142032623,
-0.3337893486022949,
-0.4614354074001312,
0.4618349075317383,
-0.12446647882461548,
0.09375030547380447,
0.07778516411781311,
0.046921826899051666,
-0.05541669949889183,
0.34390535950660706,
0.1544492393732071,
0.2896524965763092,
-0.20449267327785492,
0.31040629744529724,
0.19326932728290558,
-0.07385598123073578,
-0.01866990327835083,
-0.2106725126504898,
0.3824610114097595,
0.0668330192565918,
-0.513420045375824,
-0.1507968306541443,
0.4784126281738281,
0.3693070709705353,
-0.399140864610672,
0.7722511291503906,
0.7765482664108276,
-0.643761157989502,
-0.4958485960960388,
-0.46855130791664124,
-0.230153426527977,
-0.4726024270057678,
0.2358468919992447,
-0.5435283780097961,
-1.0025311708450317,
0.5457673072814941,
-0.15411782264709473,
-0.026561038568615913,
0.658719003200531,
0.5813654661178589,
0.02221173793077469,
1.2732479572296143,
0.5696520805358887,
0.19936077296733856,
0.5693365335464478,
-0.1287996768951416,
-0.04180615395307541,
-0.6859344244003296,
-0.20962543785572052,
-0.6813597083091736,
-0.17954440414905548,
-0.9545966982841492,
-0.45236948132514954,
0.3159168064594269,
-0.19674767553806305,
-0.39156538248062134,
0.2050560563802719,
-0.4913793206214905,
0.25938311219215393,
0.5026471614837646,
0.3325849175453186,
0.16344264149665833,
0.1732780635356903,
-0.6457083225250244,
-0.02850525826215744,
-0.3603316843509674,
-0.5363517999649048,
1.1000494956970215,
0.1664123833179474,
0.6510860323905945,
-0.06967833638191223,
1.1096805334091187,
0.386667937040329,
0.19097797572612762,
-0.26012083888053894,
0.28017351031303406,
-0.32958224415779114,
-0.2950253486633301,
-0.047774605453014374,
-0.44196245074272156,
-1.1161645650863647,
0.6293614506721497,
-0.3639650046825409,
-0.21463830769062042,
0.26547208428382874,
0.20995540916919708,
0.034758009016513824,
0.27690136432647705,
-0.5932093858718872,
0.9062713980674744,
-0.10137798637151718,
-0.5250856876373291,
-0.12630245089530945,
-0.19492432475090027,
0.2463146448135376,
-0.31433454155921936,
0.26243817806243896,
0.0411129891872406,
-0.04581879824399948,
0.6636875867843628,
-0.1527974009513855,
0.9170162081718445,
-0.28563347458839417,
-0.16328562796115875,
0.13580448925495148,
0.039278458803892136,
0.7377668619155884,
-0.26395243406295776,
-0.20075054466724396,
-0.2574978172779083,
-0.46445176005363464,
-0.5610987544059753,
-0.1965780258178711,
0.8018618226051331,
-0.6699380874633789,
-0.26120778918266296,
-0.30016493797302246,
-0.10512296855449677,
0.017925959080457687,
0.21365591883659363,
0.4484734833240509,
0.5752283930778503,
-0.3495834767818451,
0.43817105889320374,
0.8718741536140442,
-0.3295194208621979,
0.2085392028093338,
0.38043010234832764,
0.010242357850074768,
-0.4195862412452698,
1.1325911283493042,
-0.11736946552991867,
-0.0498863160610199,
0.38412392139434814,
0.3332073986530304,
-0.1221916452050209,
-0.5363897681236267,
-0.3435988426208496,
0.12801790237426758,
-0.8943301439285278,
-0.33467066287994385,
-0.9135898947715759,
-0.3084213435649872,
-0.32393336296081543,
-0.26190000772476196,
-0.06463935226202011,
-0.07782220840454102,
-0.48517921566963196,
-0.1028917208313942,
-0.12106369435787201,
0.7809228301048279,
-0.000478771748021245,
0.03395744413137436,
-0.79148268699646,
0.2296328842639923,
0.38161352276802063,
-0.16705350577831268,
-0.0556042455136776,
-0.8781875967979431,
-0.4496441185474396,
-0.005016053561121225,
-0.5965667366981506,
-0.8983123302459717,
0.5182478427886963,
0.06938239932060242,
0.7834855318069458,
0.3713024854660034,
0.04215768352150917,
0.27268359065055847,
-0.3837614059448242,
0.589593768119812,
0.1285904049873352,
-0.7673271298408508,
0.5250674486160278,
-0.1759970337152481,
0.43145596981048584,
0.48638561367988586,
0.40734562277793884,
-0.2669253349304199,
-0.5693989396095276,
-0.7513203024864197,
-0.6294771432876587,
0.45991677045822144,
0.06463883072137833,
0.34380897879600525,
0.02291634865105152,
-0.04266726225614548,
0.3710937201976776,
0.353979229927063,
-1.007343053817749,
-0.062355682253837585,
-0.23293490707874298,
-0.44467055797576904,
-0.022393828257918358,
-0.3069044053554535,
0.21137318015098572,
0.30585744976997375,
0.8023833632469177,
-0.23004092276096344,
0.256955087184906,
-0.11769098043441772,
-0.2763808071613312,
0.10726897418498993,
0.4090859889984131,
0.49626243114471436,
0.2628237307071686,
0.1569143831729889,
0.46518462896347046,
0.3980952799320221,
-0.21789143979549408,
0.06752496212720871,
0.31446942687034607,
-0.38114094734191895,
-0.13985349237918854,
0.1679966300725937,
0.7526282072067261,
0.4257323145866394,
-0.5383987426757812,
0.6633172035217285,
0.2162051945924759,
-0.3162643611431122,
-0.19835811853408813,
-0.12854039669036865,
0.0017940865363925695,
0.2637637257575989,
0.2136552631855011,
0.10926799476146698,
0.34162554144859314,
-0.3038467764854431,
0.4759255647659302,
0.26278847455978394,
-0.5075674653053284,
-0.48358651995658875,
0.6196352243423462,
0.5883175730705261,
-0.16696961224079132,
0.2680535912513733,
-0.444710910320282,
-0.8912545442581177,
0.6797323822975159,
0.7085786461830139,
0.826019287109375,
-0.516085147857666,
0.08665632456541061,
0.5045219659805298,
0.09264873713254929,
0.1477987915277481,
0.2722429633140564,
0.03557148203253746,
-1.0379064083099365,
-0.14712756872177124,
-0.46834591031074524,
-0.4318040609359741,
0.5053688883781433,
-0.24125497043132782,
0.4576853811740875,
-0.1429557502269745,
0.18600352108478546,
0.08516158908605576,
-0.01998564973473549,
-0.843499481678009,
0.33580994606018066,
0.314729779958725,
0.46897390484809875,
-1.107059359550476,
0.5116433501243591,
0.8956131935119629,
-0.4562034606933594,
-0.502599835395813,
-0.03058774210512638,
0.05591721460223198,
-0.6492906808853149,
0.4362574517726898,
0.5568836331367493,
-0.2837373912334442,
-0.20664408802986145,
-0.6275129914283752,
-0.17921535670757294,
0.8901813626289368,
0.19315683841705322,
-0.22650374472141266,
0.0440240204334259,
-0.1686095893383026,
0.4259915351867676,
-0.6817790865898132,
0.1982986479997635,
0.06658676266670227,
0.20741650462150574,
-0.10721669346094131,
-0.48267772793769836,
-0.0011187780182808638,
-0.5320799946784973,
-0.21687084436416626,
0.12635457515716553,
-0.601595938205719,
1.0483689308166504,
0.01778331957757473,
-0.22788797318935394,
-0.05299675837159157,
0.49622687697410583,
0.5025627017021179,
0.5132111310958862,
0.41906511783599854,
0.6841884851455688,
0.7740188241004944,
0.26008644700050354,
0.8039552569389343,
-0.28694409132003784,
0.2708325684070587,
1.1124547719955444,
-0.35068953037261963,
0.8564863204956055,
0.1844056099653244,
0.17142154276371002,
0.7054315805435181,
0.4525813162326813,
-0.07216164469718933,
0.5262125730514526,
0.07862457633018494,
-0.48869773745536804,
-0.5210418701171875,
-0.08839337527751923,
-0.2122933566570282,
0.5229772329330444,
0.34794411063194275,
-0.6828483939170837,
-0.12790904939174652,
0.20933452248573303,
-0.06785503029823303,
0.4029218256473541,
-0.07891105860471725,
0.7838611602783203,
0.1037728413939476,
-0.5694625377655029,
0.27235373854637146,
0.12344387173652649,
0.9984375834465027,
-0.3201158940792084,
-0.24401529133319855,
-0.20556572079658508,
0.4450511038303375,
0.03640657290816307,
-0.40005266666412354,
-0.026837853714823723,
-0.011547909118235111,
0.04519873857498169,
-0.043963439762592316,
1.181544303894043,
-0.675384521484375,
-0.43142011761665344,
0.27351632714271545,
0.7772454619407654,
-0.008642258122563362,
-0.06945642083883286,
-0.6701675653457642,
0.062472037971019745,
0.1315232366323471,
-0.02639545314013958,
0.4050063490867615,
0.70096355676651,
0.18436914682388306,
0.4054725766181946,
0.48367682099342346,
-0.25749078392982483,
-0.0679030567407608,
0.020568594336509705,
0.7369971871376038,
-0.514024019241333,
-0.7291156649589539,
-0.7159777283668518,
0.4730796813964844,
-0.30638158321380615,
-0.09486447274684906,
0.794913649559021,
0.7460154891014099,
0.9326097369194031,
-0.11474069207906723,
1.1196163892745972,
0.4243084490299225,
0.7112312912940979,
-0.538459300994873,
0.2859198749065399,
-0.798471987247467,
0.24096275866031647,
-0.27335336804389954,
-0.6686130166053772,
0.17803768813610077,
0.538946807384491,
0.011508487164974213,
0.14695706963539124,
0.8337675333023071,
0.8022503852844238,
-0.23138655722141266,
0.03448179364204407,
0.61328125,
-0.12957680225372314,
0.1520901620388031,
0.5305525660514832,
1.0348132848739624,
-0.7722649574279785,
0.8919304609298706,
-0.11873384565114975,
0.05743582546710968,
-0.4365639388561249,
-0.7445218563079834,
-1.0912871360778809,
-0.6660431623458862,
-0.3989908695220947,
-0.3945332467556,
0.05876633897423744,
0.6725974082946777,
0.5540508031845093,
-1.0006253719329834,
0.04908444732427597,
-0.04070938378572464,
0.03086928091943264,
0.028865229338407516,
-0.16954240202903748,
0.23763476312160492,
-0.3674863278865814,
-0.8951274752616882,
0.34059691429138184,
0.22541797161102295,
0.30474913120269775,
-0.29801085591316223,
-0.14261223375797272,
-0.25362563133239746,
0.3159997761249542,
0.4526613652706146,
-0.0948498472571373,
-0.32885828614234924,
-0.33213210105895996,
-0.07036957144737244,
-0.31992626190185547,
0.16152949631214142,
0.7758281230926514,
-0.6438865065574646,
0.4628441333770752,
0.6306354999542236,
0.969465970993042,
0.5866442918777466,
-0.018159309402108192,
0.38642585277557373,
-0.7688590288162231,
-0.0002805452386382967,
0.12075472623109818,
0.5805611610412598,
0.5865562558174133,
-0.33805134892463684,
0.39344120025634766,
0.3969683051109314,
-0.6799255609512329,
-0.6666973233222961,
0.24262826144695282,
-0.42551589012145996,
-0.31994736194610596,
0.9207432270050049,
-0.3550404906272888,
-0.034129828214645386,
-0.2183438539505005,
-0.15425650775432587,
0.2705823481082916,
-0.39841949939727783,
0.5366902947425842,
0.4900285005569458,
0.262265145778656,
-0.4235018789768219,
-0.23184943199157715,
0.305315762758255,
0.35578298568725586,
-1.1411490440368652,
-0.3089262843132019,
0.6368638873100281,
0.22965291142463684,
0.3012770116329193,
0.5541992783546448,
-0.08297723531723022,
0.44174253940582275,
0.3166838586330414,
0.0198066309094429,
-0.08480451256036758,
-0.2791399359703064,
-0.5191775560379028,
0.4245569705963135,
-0.13854551315307617,
-0.31405097246170044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11811v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11811v2 | FIPO: Free-form Instruction-oriented Prompt Optimization with Preference Dataset and Modular Fine-tuning Schema | 2024-02-19T03:56:44 | 2024-06-16T10:29:03 | Junru Lu, Siyu An, Min Zhang, Yulan He, Di Yin, Xing Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | When the quality of naive prompts is carefully optimized by human experts,
the task performance of large language models (LLMs) can be significantly
improved. However, expert-based prompt optimizations are expensive. Herein,
some works have proposed Automatic Prompt Optimization (APO), to optimize naive
prompts according to task outputs of given in-box testing models, with the help
of advanced LLMs (e.g., GPT-4) in an ad-hoc way. Although effective, existing
schemes suffer from poor generalization ability and privacy risk. To this end,
we collect the first large-scale Prompt Optimization Preference dataset (POP),
fine-tune offline local LLM-based optimizers, then fairly test with various
downstream models. Our method allows accurate optimization of the core task
instruction part within the naive prompt in a model-agnostic manner, and thus
is named Free-from Instruction-oriented Prompt Optimization (FIPO). In
specific, FIPO uses a modular APO template that dynamically integrate the naive
task instruction, optional instruction responses, and optional ground truth to
produce finely optimized prompts. The POP dataset is meticulously constructed
using advanced LLMs, undergoing rigorous cross-validation by human experts and
analytical models. Leveraging insights from the data with Tulu2 models and
diverse fine-tuning strategies, we validate the efficacy of FIPO framework
across five public benchmarks and three testing models. Check codes and data
here: https://github.com/LuJunru/FIPO_Project. | [
-0.398193359375,
-0.9452323913574219,
0.2903037965297699,
-0.028009437024593353,
-0.16009920835494995,
-0.39254191517829895,
-0.252035528421402,
-0.03617578372359276,
-0.2971489727497101,
0.4106661379337311,
-0.8476755023002625,
-0.19978174567222595,
-0.2045527696609497,
0.2950502038002014,
0.15843325853347778,
0.750802218914032,
0.02892647683620453,
0.016369184479117393,
-0.3908161520957947,
0.39374539256095886,
-0.6245968341827393,
0.007401514332741499,
-0.758424699306488,
0.07412765175104141,
0.14805980026721954,
0.9662503600120544,
0.32279497385025024,
0.5762484669685364,
0.0422610267996788,
0.21656283736228943,
-0.045932602137327194,
0.6982488632202148,
-0.4479687213897705,
0.21276472508907318,
0.029172120615839958,
-0.4997023940086365,
-0.3719826936721802,
-0.0853247195482254,
0.4566102921962738,
0.22374111413955688,
0.08214941620826721,
0.04543706029653549,
0.050769150257110596,
0.770828366279602,
-0.5987781286239624,
0.3000989854335785,
-0.6542357802391052,
0.04829111695289612,
0.10831567645072937,
-0.2670094966888428,
-0.602994441986084,
-0.598119854927063,
0.18492847681045532,
-0.8401657342910767,
0.17266081273555756,
0.33258572220802307,
0.5366721749305725,
0.359601229429245,
-0.39166828989982605,
-0.3541703522205353,
-0.37248143553733826,
0.7354642152786255,
-0.36694568395614624,
0.060421574860811234,
0.41313838958740234,
0.3243408203125,
-0.5376976728439331,
-0.14688892662525177,
-0.3275424540042877,
-0.26777946949005127,
0.05804690346121788,
0.001814396819099784,
-0.25853630900382996,
0.3496610224246979,
0.09250565618276596,
0.42042064666748047,
-0.4964800775051117,
0.118734210729599,
-0.1501942127943039,
-0.28242745995521545,
0.4348701238632202,
0.09614013135433197,
0.18921712040901184,
-0.1684417724609375,
-0.599589467048645,
0.22289352118968964,
-0.5898738503456116,
0.679809033870697,
0.3586071729660034,
0.36839190125465393,
-0.04156743735074997,
0.4646908938884735,
-0.5030727982521057,
0.8817906379699707,
0.3543001115322113,
-0.12653443217277527,
0.07174386084079742,
-0.2742328345775604,
0.09274416416883469,
-0.1520044058561325,
0.812216579914093,
0.5280430912971497,
0.500605046749115,
-0.05565411597490311,
-0.33980685472488403,
-0.2187471091747284,
0.05869116634130478,
-0.73109370470047,
0.18142451345920563,
0.2968986928462982,
-0.3898179531097412,
-0.5184063911437988,
-0.15714408457279205,
-0.7987873554229736,
-0.18721625208854675,
-0.4017571806907654,
0.44373559951782227,
-0.4719521105289459,
0.11206701397895813,
0.030201006680727005,
0.23588763177394867,
0.008182208985090256,
0.3760274052619934,
-1.0599902868270874,
0.06262864917516708,
0.8599541187286377,
0.8428826332092285,
-0.2063450664281845,
-0.044336091727018356,
-1.0789527893066406,
-0.06107553467154503,
-0.2835651934146881,
0.9528647661209106,
-0.6487211585044861,
-0.5826532244682312,
-0.11633157730102539,
-0.00006033834506524727,
-0.31685757637023926,
-0.20171013474464417,
0.5448302626609802,
-0.3077910542488098,
0.5709332823753357,
-0.033385176211595535,
-0.7564877271652222,
-0.07231887429952621,
0.2572682201862335,
-0.3587438464164734,
0.9221581220626831,
0.2020493596792221,
-0.5282865762710571,
-0.008272761479020119,
-0.9612359404563904,
-0.09386195242404938,
-0.10936862975358963,
-0.1403847187757492,
-0.17602303624153137,
0.35948801040649414,
0.262315034866333,
0.3517678380012512,
-0.6744231581687927,
0.35163718461990356,
0.00003908151848008856,
-0.4934620261192322,
-0.0802507996559143,
-0.3063618242740631,
0.744070827960968,
0.3560909628868103,
-0.4051060378551483,
0.492904394865036,
-0.7169332504272461,
-0.0626334622502327,
-0.12941974401474,
-0.1308862417936325,
-0.21554237604141235,
-0.0685780718922615,
-0.6836857199668884,
-0.03561734780669212,
0.30872464179992676,
-0.5590180158615112,
0.5271557569503784,
-0.46889322996139526,
0.22103647887706757,
0.9558011889457703,
0.1115637868642807,
0.5282280445098877,
-0.394441694021225,
0.7598040103912354,
-0.2890753746032715,
0.7111685276031494,
-0.3525751829147339,
-0.7246834635734558,
-0.3851819932460785,
-0.3206080496311188,
-0.05651606246829033,
0.7915832996368408,
-0.617607593536377,
0.5887486338615417,
0.0060561951249837875,
-0.3805959224700928,
-0.14581292867660522,
-0.026866832748055458,
0.30710622668266296,
1.182785153388977,
0.18462403118610382,
0.18638932704925537,
-0.039683859795331955,
-0.9996569752693176,
0.09172381460666656,
-0.05000566318631172,
-0.0807165876030922,
0.4649313688278198,
0.030297210440039635,
-0.16712936758995056,
1.03828763961792,
-0.6142767071723938,
-0.16147562861442566,
-0.047564804553985596,
-0.04852109029889107,
0.3283050060272217,
0.4860641658306122,
0.4859965443611145,
-0.39206662774086,
-0.5287942886352539,
-0.18091115355491638,
-0.015515023842453957,
-0.43303918838500977,
-0.011233310215175152,
-0.350502073764801,
0.3415723443031311,
0.13581867516040802,
-0.5241219997406006,
0.029882075265049934,
0.27388739585876465,
-0.5201621055603027,
0.7633776068687439,
-0.32704484462738037,
0.20734886825084686,
-0.9092435240745544,
0.0717853531241417,
-0.23205892741680145,
0.061018411070108414,
-0.5746160745620728,
-0.10177531093358994,
0.1906275451183319,
-0.4875108301639557,
-0.32244524359703064,
0.7826153039932251,
-0.30034157633781433,
0.2582304775714874,
-0.3151836693286896,
-0.2556973397731781,
0.144544780254364,
0.617548406124115,
-0.04422103241086006,
1.1097161769866943,
0.5710919499397278,
-0.4331764280796051,
0.2280731350183487,
0.19397404789924622,
-0.15505720674991608,
0.42595160007476807,
-0.6957952380180359,
0.21114757657051086,
-0.15665645897388458,
0.09607911854982376,
-1.099483847618103,
-0.19470298290252686,
0.3896874487400055,
-0.32808730006217957,
0.13707390427589417,
-0.19509035348892212,
-0.4085938334465027,
-0.12927193939685822,
-0.5463629364967346,
0.10330391675233841,
0.5480026006698608,
-0.3479958772659302,
0.47793787717819214,
0.03962237015366554,
-0.16030846536159515,
-0.5152288675308228,
-0.10572808235883713,
-0.5399059057235718,
-0.12927751243114471,
-0.691983699798584,
0.09745421260595322,
-0.2878723442554474,
0.08953365683555603,
-0.5227499604225159,
-0.1760990023612976,
-0.06670486927032471,
0.25845664739608765,
0.10194221884012222,
0.33661308884620667,
-0.1251615434885025,
0.14561042189598083,
0.34824126958847046,
-0.40642890334129333,
-0.07793872058391571,
-0.2968074083328247,
0.5524214506149292,
-0.23465892672538757,
0.10601871460676193,
-0.6565040946006775,
0.42783764004707336,
0.37467414140701294,
-0.14141404628753662,
0.1979619562625885,
0.28785642981529236,
-0.3052195608615875,
-0.2137172669172287,
-0.3603459298610687,
-0.16646713018417358,
-0.5124042630195618,
-0.13820189237594604,
-0.38640713691711426,
-0.6876919865608215,
0.24049359560012817,
-0.05975767597556114,
0.23324790596961975,
0.2211960405111313,
0.24068965017795563,
0.1633499562740326,
0.8839543461799622,
0.42212194204330444,
0.1780845671892166,
0.6154441237449646,
-0.24381114542484283,
-0.09137395024299622,
-0.514556884765625,
-0.2649291753768921,
-0.6246827840805054,
-0.11438222974538803,
-0.2106177806854248,
-0.44627827405929565,
0.4231278896331787,
0.19165541231632233,
-0.32538866996765137,
0.01567797176539898,
-0.7335055470466614,
0.5948503017425537,
0.8578296303749084,
0.08163239806890488,
0.1962079405784607,
0.14953547716140747,
-0.20547199249267578,
0.04878870025277138,
-0.5409412980079651,
-0.5873611569404602,
1.0604374408721924,
0.24866999685764313,
0.4937132000923157,
-0.3465542197227478,
0.37805309891700745,
0.33667758107185364,
-0.034077756106853485,
-1.0053086280822754,
0.5297052264213562,
-0.2714998126029968,
-0.48012080788612366,
-0.15011943876743317,
-0.49607276916503906,
-0.7908552289009094,
-0.17907999455928802,
-0.04213700443506241,
-0.6939399242401123,
0.3507087528705597,
0.44457802176475525,
-0.8131983280181885,
0.0747629925608635,
-1.0021920204162598,
0.9501532316207886,
-0.3034483790397644,
-0.21637080609798431,
-0.0657593384385109,
-0.5953838229179382,
0.20995771884918213,
0.04314505308866501,
0.10322137176990509,
-0.3985446095466614,
-0.4442204236984253,
0.4471888840198517,
-0.5425296425819397,
0.5850178599357605,
-0.5358997583389282,
-0.11856697499752045,
0.3519723415374756,
0.11707804352045059,
0.6028701066970825,
0.11101780831813812,
-0.4139658808708191,
-0.12255413085222244,
-0.0945030227303505,
-0.37224075198173523,
-0.4870041608810425,
0.679826021194458,
-0.8363370299339294,
-0.5454502701759338,
-0.02019207738339901,
-0.5751188397407532,
-0.5280806422233582,
0.287482887506485,
0.4838886559009552,
0.8398070335388184,
0.218903049826622,
0.06152717024087906,
0.7741003036499023,
-0.19133397936820984,
0.4183604121208191,
0.46944206953048706,
0.06598462164402008,
-0.5958577394485474,
0.7947770953178406,
-0.11169850826263428,
0.2428654432296753,
0.5894405245780945,
0.712920606136322,
-0.24687916040420532,
-0.5421968698501587,
-0.55070960521698,
-0.0797208845615387,
-0.387080579996109,
-0.41124066710472107,
-0.4337626099586487,
0.37942954897880554,
-0.3920951783657074,
-0.3520258069038391,
-0.2593540847301483,
-0.6089386343955994,
-0.5680387616157532,
0.23603805899620056,
0.5513915419578552,
0.1841765195131302,
0.07440822571516037,
0.5726025700569153,
-0.6470751762390137,
0.2539904713630676,
0.2745642066001892,
0.32941412925720215,
-0.14502166211605072,
-0.3403708338737488,
0.10493090748786926,
0.046510592103004456,
-0.361919641494751,
-0.7519232034683228,
0.0019706881139427423,
0.3699214458465576,
0.5051053762435913,
0.7181951999664307,
0.33422091603279114,
0.3205791115760803,
-0.42975932359695435,
0.7265869379043579,
-0.03440670669078827,
-0.8179576396942139,
1.0420117378234863,
-0.5574987530708313,
0.21270734071731567,
0.7907763719558716,
0.42987820506095886,
-0.2546103298664093,
0.15556547045707703,
-0.37520766258239746,
-0.7545961737632751,
0.9469959735870361,
-0.13517890870571136,
0.08159475028514862,
-0.18373523652553558,
0.6030016541481018,
0.6603614091873169,
0.19195757806301117,
-0.1444644331932068,
-0.2559352517127991,
-0.0945776030421257,
-0.33131009340286255,
0.3231605291366577,
-0.3552120327949524,
-0.13713130354881287,
0.03924575075507164,
0.777829647064209,
-0.4212944805622101,
0.4679032862186432,
0.1435956060886383,
0.06247827410697937,
-0.1659698635339737,
0.15093451738357544,
0.8505915403366089,
0.44090235233306885,
-0.22645874321460724,
-0.3814298212528229,
-0.1026945561170578,
-0.4124337136745453,
0.281320184469223,
0.2367468923330307,
-0.5945219397544861,
-0.1095055490732193,
0.006710385903716087,
0.8379474878311157,
0.07761023193597794,
-0.6809644103050232,
0.5826492309570312,
-0.2388487607240677,
0.13449686765670776,
-0.15321579575538635,
0.6473430395126343,
-0.4145766496658325,
0.021116238087415695,
0.5554160475730896,
0.16348305344581604,
0.2320258915424347,
-0.13054627180099487,
0.18007045984268188,
0.2864244878292084,
-0.24217066168785095,
-0.2925611436367035,
0.6023892164230347,
0.6787254810333252,
-0.5477525591850281,
0.3603467345237732,
-0.30330392718315125,
-0.1616864800453186,
0.6195990443229675,
0.33851224184036255,
0.8632646203041077,
-0.27664294838905334,
0.3573271632194519,
0.48208263516426086,
0.06056399643421173,
-0.009374410845339298,
0.42931315302848816,
-0.31088873744010925,
-0.4234701693058014,
-0.30488958954811096,
-0.21974064409732819,
-0.5398479700088501,
0.03358888626098633,
-0.40278080105781555,
0.6512617468833923,
-0.6594240069389343,
0.07359430193901062,
-0.5560490489006042,
0.4518851339817047,
-0.37532326579093933,
0.09695244580507278,
0.030266428366303444,
1.1783262491226196,
-0.52753084897995,
0.614180326461792,
0.6023014783859253,
-0.06415828317403793,
-0.5909111499786377,
-0.08778303861618042,
0.07852675765752792,
-0.9410722851753235,
0.25431862473487854,
0.536055326461792,
0.07308520376682281,
0.1714198738336563,
-0.2558533549308777,
-0.683584451675415,
0.9867817163467407,
0.5193092226982117,
-0.7977128028869629,
-0.29063841700553894,
-0.028749529272317886,
0.11187915503978729,
-0.6304839849472046,
0.5462719202041626,
0.3354889154434204,
0.27135980129241943,
-0.01044648326933384,
-0.7479676604270935,
0.09713955223560333,
-0.24773569405078888,
-0.0961339995265007,
0.06836148351430893,
-0.908976137638092,
0.6062055230140686,
-0.1461256891489029,
-0.02772705629467964,
0.12410130351781845,
0.49361369013786316,
0.42138558626174927,
0.3235291838645935,
0.8926479816436768,
0.10460440814495087,
0.8032351732254028,
-0.06961247324943542,
1.007642149925232,
-0.6995720267295837,
0.09324907511472702,
0.9855470657348633,
0.08558251708745956,
0.38688790798187256,
0.45022398233413696,
0.126559779047966,
0.20900823175907135,
0.8492823243141174,
0.18153470754623413,
0.7188034057617188,
0.0951719880104065,
-0.3246650993824005,
-0.10277491807937622,
-0.2478088140487671,
-0.3933109939098358,
0.3076513409614563,
0.245474174618721,
-0.20520374178886414,
-0.17054851353168488,
-0.07165201008319855,
0.09005631506443024,
-0.11993777751922607,
-0.39938101172447205,
0.6564573645591736,
-0.38863393664360046,
-0.8034766912460327,
0.5976266860961914,
-0.227223739027977,
0.8487751483917236,
-0.7635807394981384,
0.2607429623603821,
-0.6756913661956787,
-0.04339264705777168,
0.05999321863055229,
-0.34254589676856995,
0.11343659460544586,
0.1345362663269043,
-0.24147993326187134,
-0.29960882663726807,
0.7256012558937073,
-0.2233877331018448,
-0.31658053398132324,
-0.17604318261146545,
0.2323864996433258,
0.05979175493121147,
-0.10074138641357422,
-0.6683700084686279,
-0.16380426287651062,
0.22372430562973022,
-0.5460069179534912,
-0.09691978245973587,
0.5098830461502075,
-0.1067529246211052,
0.607718288898468,
0.6003172397613525,
0.11558191478252411,
-0.2613109052181244,
-0.14527657628059387,
0.5681152939796448,
-0.42142921686172485,
-0.6079567670822144,
-0.6222111582756042,
0.6162676215171814,
-0.0025324015878140926,
-0.7866771221160889,
0.24602477252483368,
0.6985955238342285,
0.538049578666687,
-0.1694158911705017,
0.5366138219833374,
0.08205942809581757,
0.42662733793258667,
-0.49892184138298035,
0.37773704528808594,
-0.4610692858695984,
0.12260961532592773,
-0.09398077428340912,
-0.8525117635726929,
-0.041887376457452774,
0.4590614438056946,
-0.33781561255455017,
-0.2609921097755432,
0.3925960958003998,
0.9001332521438599,
0.003833996132016182,
0.28948721289634705,
0.16585713624954224,
-0.221233069896698,
0.26076650619506836,
0.6407173275947571,
0.65067058801651,
-0.21108095347881317,
0.6290925741195679,
-0.5093801617622375,
-0.6281248331069946,
-0.31608906388282776,
-1.0299075841903687,
-0.7472197413444519,
-0.43274345993995667,
-0.23718388378620148,
0.1500571072101593,
0.026384208351373672,
1.3672572374343872,
0.5659540891647339,
-0.7666655778884888,
-0.042729537934064865,
-0.21804337203502655,
0.15834881365299225,
-0.09543485194444656,
-0.28337815403938293,
0.3328844904899597,
-0.664979100227356,
-0.8186295628547668,
0.6187359094619751,
0.09799031168222427,
0.2163171023130417,
0.00809995736926794,
-0.0037838411517441273,
0.173721581697464,
0.1211475133895874,
0.4746468961238861,
0.06397580355405807,
-0.48012781143188477,
-0.2720305025577545,
0.48841190338134766,
0.06384674459695816,
0.01596144028007984,
0.9144508242607117,
-0.5083704590797424,
0.6015474796295166,
0.8409043550491333,
0.6733173727989197,
-0.23354727029800415,
0.14791782200336456,
0.84148770570755,
-0.600517749786377,
0.07623636722564697,
0.14373628795146942,
0.3569197654724121,
0.17056509852409363,
-0.6878042221069336,
0.483707457780838,
0.2889634668827057,
-0.6626368761062622,
-0.7596184611320496,
0.14568905532360077,
-0.782156765460968,
-0.24363131821155548,
1.1769177913665771,
-0.18668055534362793,
-0.2539951801300049,
0.004906617570668459,
-0.4698164463043213,
0.14096111059188843,
-0.9003024101257324,
0.9209564924240112,
0.5771740674972534,
-0.606343686580658,
-0.013965150341391563,
-0.4450782537460327,
0.6239851117134094,
0.47392693161964417,
-0.8711264729499817,
0.11912960559129715,
0.7082764506340027,
0.1995851993560791,
-0.1481195092201233,
0.6219944357872009,
0.12701845169067383,
0.46157512068748474,
-0.36246228218078613,
-0.14306433498859406,
-0.6503129005432129,
-0.27278855443000793,
-0.36785832047462463,
0.19821366667747498,
-0.214090034365654,
-0.6006953120231628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11809v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11809v3 | Generation Meets Verification: Accelerating Large Language Model Inference with Smart Parallel Auto-Correct Decoding | 2024-02-19T03:39:10 | 2024-05-20T01:48:18 | Hanling Yi, Feng Lin, Hongbin Li, Peiyang Ning, Xiaotian Yu, Rong Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This research aims to accelerate the inference speed of large language models
(LLMs) with billions of parameters. We propose \textbf{S}mart \textbf{P}arallel
\textbf{A}uto-\textbf{C}orrect d\textbf{E}coding (SPACE), an innovative
approach designed for achieving lossless acceleration of LLMs. By integrating
semi-autoregressive inference and speculative decoding capabilities, SPACE
uniquely enables autoregressive LLMs to parallelize token generation and
verification. This is realized through a specialized semi-autoregressive
supervised fine-tuning process that equips existing LLMs with the ability to
simultaneously predict multiple tokens. Additionally, an auto-correct decoding
algorithm facilitates the simultaneous generation and verification of token
sequences within a single model invocation. Through extensive experiments on a
range of LLMs, SPACE has demonstrated inference speedup ranging from 2.7x-4.0x
on HumanEval-X while maintaining output quality. | [
-0.0828903391957283,
-0.8434430360794067,
0.6290984749794006,
0.45046213269233704,
0.024925991892814636,
0.32874444127082825,
-0.27534225583076477,
-0.28424394130706787,
-0.0878593772649765,
0.4547570049762726,
-0.34032341837882996,
-0.48897773027420044,
-0.673488199710846,
0.32212138175964355,
-0.6841998100280762,
0.501834511756897,
-0.10211431235074997,
-0.14229391515254974,
-0.18590733408927917,
0.0319727286696434,
-0.15499602258205414,
-0.747530996799469,
-0.5846092104911804,
0.01481827162206173,
0.0741565078496933,
0.42349740862846375,
0.5807023644447327,
1.1878870725631714,
0.25640565156936646,
0.43339329957962036,
-0.051145266741514206,
0.5878608822822571,
-0.34693366289138794,
0.037864893674850464,
0.020459292456507683,
-0.3819582760334015,
-0.6557738184928894,
-0.27716776728630066,
0.8994448184967041,
0.6481176018714905,
-0.25158730149269104,
0.2915957570075989,
-0.24908973276615143,
0.5471510291099548,
-0.7876404523849487,
0.14114855229854584,
-0.6240296959877014,
-0.1357533037662506,
-0.05009742081165314,
-0.2961389720439911,
-0.7042629718780518,
-0.3353533148765564,
-0.5101709961891174,
-0.5627183318138123,
0.24744461476802826,
0.6613427400588989,
0.8563656210899353,
0.44343146681785583,
-0.4878321588039398,
-0.14387303590774536,
-0.8686079978942871,
0.906376302242279,
-0.6018980145454407,
0.5910915732383728,
0.22019225358963013,
0.2093169391155243,
-0.34318292140960693,
-0.9911537766456604,
-0.7491180300712585,
-0.11117689311504364,
0.0554497130215168,
-0.2353801131248474,
-0.19819000363349915,
0.17311391234397888,
0.602425754070282,
0.6001318693161011,
-0.6019664406776428,
0.35799190402030945,
-0.1718570441007614,
-0.36413338780403137,
0.7366014719009399,
0.2868289053440094,
0.21557798981666565,
0.01893160305917263,
-0.13469034433364868,
-0.13202591240406036,
-0.9193355441093445,
-0.18349626660346985,
0.4575255811214447,
-0.043647442013025284,
-0.09974450618028641,
0.6024429202079773,
-0.3459430932998657,
0.6528354287147522,
0.12845435738563538,
0.16403041779994965,
0.22276993095874786,
-0.45411747694015503,
-0.39447343349456787,
-0.10008880496025085,
0.9430992007255554,
0.32119929790496826,
0.07838752120733261,
-0.13345520198345184,
-0.23925940692424774,
0.22849050164222717,
-0.10976184904575348,
-0.8768709301948547,
-0.22440490126609802,
0.3571981191635132,
-0.37983039021492004,
0.04330798238515854,
-0.17038454115390778,
-0.6946277022361755,
-0.1127181276679039,
-0.3156913220882416,
0.0704406276345253,
-0.17291288077831268,
-0.2286706417798996,
0.6810783743858337,
0.06787853688001633,
0.0781935304403305,
0.25848495960235596,
-0.9285091161727905,
0.06750278174877167,
0.695406436920166,
0.3978081941604614,
0.04093368351459503,
-0.4548085033893585,
-0.722657322883606,
0.22764888405799866,
-0.44431883096694946,
0.8006112575531006,
-0.35428616404533386,
-0.12498953193426132,
-0.0407257042825222,
0.014981991611421108,
-0.10747562348842621,
-0.4498227536678314,
0.6463862657546997,
-0.6445363163948059,
-0.1384907066822052,
-0.21565714478492737,
-0.8393810987472534,
0.2257186472415924,
0.014045855961740017,
-0.4346049726009369,
1.1796684265136719,
-0.05157598480582237,
-0.6077178716659546,
0.523157000541687,
-0.49000388383865356,
-0.4075678884983063,
0.06997378170490265,
-0.25672951340675354,
-0.3620850443840027,
0.13165265321731567,
0.503812849521637,
0.4552018344402313,
-0.5069260001182556,
0.506465494632721,
-0.39303725957870483,
-0.3982177972793579,
0.023822041228413582,
-0.40660399198532104,
0.7079163789749146,
0.4323650896549225,
-0.3696501553058624,
0.14190568029880524,
-1.0182219743728638,
-0.04434887692332268,
0.3116355836391449,
-0.41892433166503906,
-0.07750663161277771,
0.23744690418243408,
-0.19010135531425476,
0.075605109333992,
0.3485889732837677,
-0.7684573531150818,
0.3444722592830658,
-0.3185736835002899,
0.5972278714179993,
0.6622406244277954,
-0.18913187086582184,
0.37476059794425964,
0.06274711340665817,
0.38135141134262085,
-0.04890020936727524,
0.10702967643737793,
-0.418049693107605,
-0.2544345557689667,
-1.0096094608306885,
-0.44244837760925293,
0.5078727006912231,
0.5829274654388428,
-0.6973810791969299,
0.9601966738700867,
-0.2842423617839813,
-0.1868954300880432,
-0.4118450880050659,
0.0948224663734436,
0.42639702558517456,
0.33563435077667236,
0.19773069024085999,
0.06325702369213104,
-0.8072210550308228,
-0.7891370058059692,
-0.2889649271965027,
-0.4256388545036316,
-0.0339931957423687,
0.2661453187465668,
0.4835277199745178,
-0.22975340485572815,
0.6954042911529541,
-0.2747381031513214,
0.4312644302845001,
-0.28932473063468933,
0.24988998472690582,
0.07915202528238297,
0.7252777218818665,
0.41478821635246277,
-0.45404982566833496,
-0.2741382122039795,
-0.14529424905776978,
-0.8595426082611084,
-0.41019076108932495,
-0.03687519207596779,
-0.16803580522537231,
0.34613093733787537,
1.0335545539855957,
-0.5137442946434021,
0.3094250559806824,
0.6800228357315063,
-0.5505630970001221,
0.41661715507507324,
-0.49919191002845764,
0.3911951780319214,
-0.954304575920105,
0.023729348555207253,
-0.296162486076355,
-0.34415513277053833,
-0.34659653902053833,
0.2446240335702896,
0.26696231961250305,
-0.03879355639219284,
-0.3099028468132019,
0.5267508625984192,
-0.6457692384719849,
-0.2634022533893585,
-0.32123878598213196,
-0.12721557915210724,
0.15297529101371765,
0.2699909508228302,
-0.07694926112890244,
1.0791733264923096,
0.8211818933486938,
-0.6879026889801025,
0.2628980875015259,
-0.008042196743190289,
-0.3245973289012909,
0.12193454802036285,
-0.7415121793746948,
0.2985559105873108,
-0.1477230191230774,
0.391501247882843,
-0.8763427734375,
-0.1883646696805954,
-0.23902302980422974,
-0.26085779070854187,
0.13740374147891998,
-0.001254864502698183,
-1.2411701679229736,
-0.696063220500946,
0.17026548087596893,
0.8467817902565002,
0.626991331577301,
-0.8183197975158691,
0.6642683744430542,
0.3854226768016815,
0.16035343706607819,
-0.5024927854537964,
-0.5008180737495422,
0.25888192653656006,
0.01016098540276289,
-0.6322352290153503,
0.0438176728785038,
-0.13741815090179443,
-0.19908472895622253,
-0.23572136461734772,
0.17284508049488068,
0.22957465052604675,
0.17766141891479492,
0.10011354088783264,
0.1550656408071518,
-0.14992107450962067,
-0.09188180416822433,
0.24553725123405457,
-0.2530977427959442,
0.03398137539625168,
-0.5978772640228271,
0.5677683353424072,
-0.3680213391780853,
-0.5955803394317627,
-0.4416336119174957,
0.4159730076789856,
0.8182650804519653,
-0.24245525896549225,
0.6507507562637329,
0.37326839566230774,
-0.40442922711372375,
-0.4713622033596039,
-0.7382427453994751,
-0.03797724470496178,
-0.5198220014572144,
0.32368892431259155,
-0.35051730275154114,
-1.2014659643173218,
0.8282763957977295,
-0.23963849246501923,
0.04682442918419838,
0.553352952003479,
0.8074640035629272,
0.24095679819583893,
1.408957600593567,
0.7126010656356812,
0.0009510529926046729,
0.12863127887248993,
-0.18936921656131744,
0.3386414051055908,
-0.5413855910301208,
-0.28710687160491943,
-0.712695837020874,
0.020534925162792206,
-0.47888556122779846,
-0.7143470644950867,
0.08143038302659988,
0.31921231746673584,
-0.3795681595802307,
0.47100183367729187,
-0.3992501497268677,
0.631504237651825,
0.5520293116569519,
-0.258223295211792,
0.4817744195461273,
-0.14821135997772217,
-0.3062002658843994,
0.20505069196224213,
-0.9917038083076477,
-0.4044772982597351,
1.0664324760437012,
0.5891891121864319,
0.7990568280220032,
-0.0997367799282074,
0.5607126951217651,
0.35256272554397583,
0.19877149164676666,
-0.4808812439441681,
0.7970555424690247,
-0.3187369406223297,
-0.4760085344314575,
0.048865292221307755,
-0.49621084332466125,
-0.7845230102539062,
-0.049595437943935394,
-0.009541520848870277,
-0.6831487417221069,
0.23559428751468658,
0.5804666876792908,
-0.4302673041820526,
0.3365398347377777,
-0.6802003979682922,
0.8503701686859131,
-0.17618893086910248,
-0.3387661278247833,
-0.2930878698825836,
-0.40701135993003845,
0.4720397889614105,
0.03873629495501518,
0.16175101697444916,
-0.07650520652532578,
0.12289858609437943,
0.49563610553741455,
-0.5483790636062622,
0.6339616179466248,
-0.19150762259960175,
-0.27346810698509216,
0.3936959505081177,
0.19893258810043335,
0.7684249877929688,
0.13735680282115936,
-0.07383864372968674,
0.19152085483074188,
-0.29363173246383667,
-0.425636351108551,
-0.40863320231437683,
0.6704312562942505,
-0.5152456760406494,
-0.41335102915763855,
-0.18736444413661957,
-0.7486191391944885,
-0.20969676971435547,
0.10901045054197311,
0.17558959126472473,
0.23174095153808594,
0.04668735712766647,
0.12657509744167328,
0.7004460096359253,
-0.4126153886318207,
0.4412239193916321,
0.5973466634750366,
-0.23042938113212585,
-0.3105819523334503,
0.7766571044921875,
-0.36526426672935486,
0.18974223732948303,
0.3718835115432739,
-0.021293124184012413,
-0.5141834616661072,
-0.8509916067123413,
-0.7246271967887878,
0.24475686252117157,
-0.6289108991622925,
-0.2484855353832245,
-0.812369704246521,
-0.24995538592338562,
-0.4925880432128906,
-0.19112657010555267,
-0.6454070806503296,
-0.35893142223358154,
-0.06124602258205414,
-0.03766239434480667,
0.25915005803108215,
0.7024661898612976,
-0.0910617858171463,
0.3268268406391144,
-1.0069791078567505,
0.293496310710907,
0.22167335450649261,
0.2721753716468811,
-0.2435108870267868,
-0.6278862953186035,
-0.3405359983444214,
-0.21642421185970306,
0.125930055975914,
-0.3539814352989197,
0.22104930877685547,
0.08742149919271469,
0.5050486326217651,
0.31635352969169617,
-0.05859604477882385,
0.7233542799949646,
-0.6705399751663208,
0.843744158744812,
0.021821103990077972,
-1.2503300905227661,
0.5580767393112183,
-0.3619858920574188,
0.30091947317123413,
0.3515361249446869,
-0.13199065625667572,
-0.18955038487911224,
-0.734024167060852,
-0.7381758689880371,
-0.9149261116981506,
0.5035918951034546,
0.06622938066720963,
-0.07810642570257187,
-0.3294490873813629,
0.4312979280948639,
-0.07605639100074768,
0.19067132472991943,
-0.34615781903266907,
-0.17122803628444672,
-0.0435945987701416,
-0.16692987084388733,
-0.01042331662029028,
-0.3593580424785614,
0.05077337846159935,
-0.24159234762191772,
0.5444579720497131,
-0.32303163409233093,
0.4029749631881714,
0.17306672036647797,
-0.1856294721364975,
-0.295112669467926,
0.17071199417114258,
0.6272567510604858,
0.5676586627960205,
-0.0881546139717102,
0.13826440274715424,
0.10374479740858078,
-0.12883220613002777,
0.15143908560276031,
0.20856444537639618,
-0.11896897852420807,
-0.1547660529613495,
0.344948947429657,
0.9987272620201111,
-0.0019495589658617973,
-0.7951499223709106,
0.5345197916030884,
-0.22598949074745178,
-0.5290843844413757,
-0.20191416144371033,
0.022547833621501923,
-0.10587846487760544,
0.3246229887008667,
0.39464619755744934,
0.07201726734638214,
0.08720945566892624,
-0.16564814746379852,
0.3663598895072937,
0.31847718358039856,
0.39252302050590515,
-0.32777178287506104,
1.0288528203964233,
0.2213621735572815,
-0.05114132910966873,
0.6714091300964355,
-0.463628888130188,
-0.35851556062698364,
0.7558907866477966,
0.6356103420257568,
0.9872649908065796,
0.015956774353981018,
-0.21676331758499146,
0.6748244166374207,
0.3060612976551056,
-0.33073127269744873,
0.4304102063179016,
-0.17905214428901672,
-0.7018947601318359,
-0.9704352021217346,
-1.0879753828048706,
-0.2621295154094696,
0.14448438584804535,
-0.4921959638595581,
-0.08498888462781906,
-0.5728565454483032,
0.07266609370708466,
-0.22466608881950378,
-0.32768991589546204,
-0.5644983053207397,
0.13276797533035278,
0.4607952833175659,
1.1703801155090332,
-0.9958045482635498,
0.8310346007347107,
0.5609488487243652,
0.13660261034965515,
-1.0901906490325928,
-0.08172857016324997,
-0.15218880772590637,
-1.0187290906906128,
0.9784379601478577,
0.010711830109357834,
-0.31079718470573425,
0.26680541038513184,
-0.5628715753555298,
-0.9052320718765259,
0.969793438911438,
0.5716664791107178,
-0.8670787811279297,
-0.052883002907037735,
0.11720670014619827,
0.5237025022506714,
-0.4208618104457855,
0.12433324754238129,
0.6534416079521179,
0.3798081576824188,
0.17546603083610535,
-1.043949007987976,
0.12553386390209198,
-0.21096983551979065,
0.18729083240032196,
0.302206814289093,
-0.5893509984016418,
0.7363008856773376,
-0.30690833926200867,
-0.32280832529067993,
0.3656856417655945,
1.1008963584899902,
0.570634663105011,
0.030811715871095657,
0.5879722833633423,
0.891914963722229,
0.66400146484375,
-0.19641152024269104,
0.9797553420066833,
-0.886834442615509,
0.4334483742713928,
0.8377054333686829,
-0.3514998257160187,
0.6762918829917908,
0.5058098435401917,
-0.22025080025196075,
0.49228131771087646,
0.4892190098762512,
-0.03566954284906387,
0.14581730961799622,
0.27539628744125366,
-0.25268417596817017,
-0.5236589908599854,
-0.1079300045967102,
-0.13428713381290436,
0.5196677446365356,
0.4936731159687042,
-0.5399901866912842,
-0.2111569046974182,
-0.10580296069383621,
-0.16666573286056519,
0.184504896402359,
-0.3744557797908783,
0.5037817358970642,
-0.17179803550243378,
-0.9262260794639587,
0.7218645215034485,
0.284213125705719,
0.5730821490287781,
-0.3883131146430969,
-0.007187359966337681,
-0.1138787716627121,
0.40394020080566406,
-0.0017502333503216505,
-0.5767608284950256,
0.2032291144132614,
-0.04056081920862198,
-0.15309321880340576,
-0.5994278192520142,
0.6136468648910522,
-0.4758405089378357,
-0.4853023588657379,
0.29812854528427124,
0.4441109597682953,
0.10371629148721695,
0.18844161927700043,
-0.6223912835121155,
0.29698556661605835,
-0.09851951897144318,
-0.2078663557767868,
0.07641962170600891,
0.5858058929443359,
-0.053992804139852524,
0.6322877407073975,
0.846388578414917,
0.13091033697128296,
0.33278360962867737,
0.3566252589225769,
0.7622660994529724,
-0.5012064576148987,
-0.6668201684951782,
-0.8509826064109802,
0.48841217160224915,
0.03636760637164116,
-0.22516246140003204,
0.928707480430603,
0.6824434399604797,
0.7929796576499939,
-0.1633870154619217,
0.6011690497398376,
-0.2126539945602417,
0.3681972622871399,
-0.7260268926620483,
0.41793766617774963,
-0.48576590418815613,
0.416490763425827,
0.15872742235660553,
-0.7127413153648376,
-0.33014941215515137,
0.36329957842826843,
-0.10129952430725098,
0.0557255744934082,
0.7772185206413269,
0.9961310625076294,
-0.04257292300462723,
-0.15787677466869354,
0.26717254519462585,
0.2867323160171509,
0.31947943568229675,
0.7610814571380615,
0.8795085549354553,
-0.6338204741477966,
0.43451279401779175,
-0.15902993083000183,
-0.32223477959632874,
-0.0920465737581253,
-1.1650233268737793,
-0.8511985540390015,
-0.37276265025138855,
-0.4766843914985657,
-0.6093071699142456,
0.0475546233355999,
0.801927387714386,
0.7988677024841309,
-0.8205720782279968,
-0.21722713112831116,
-0.6709365844726562,
-0.22165580093860626,
-0.11541342735290527,
-0.2395196110010147,
0.3929542005062103,
-0.39440134167671204,
-0.9713888764381409,
0.5915131568908691,
0.5157821178436279,
0.011631856672465801,
-0.3682194948196411,
-0.3046437203884125,
-0.057076841592788696,
0.14747354388237,
0.46089231967926025,
0.5515080094337463,
-0.6911542415618896,
-0.11901507526636124,
-0.031089643016457558,
-0.17339837551116943,
-0.14870961010456085,
1.1658146381378174,
-0.7164480686187744,
0.23139789700508118,
0.6508252620697021,
0.8102431893348694,
0.33182209730148315,
0.01312586385756731,
0.8295402526855469,
-0.6896172165870667,
0.22675925493240356,
0.2048642933368683,
0.6529796719551086,
0.2486743927001953,
-0.47409123182296753,
0.09431596100330353,
0.48021000623703003,
-0.9113245606422424,
-1.0214102268218994,
0.373782217502594,
-0.7854250073432922,
-0.012738077901303768,
1.234724521636963,
-0.286096453666687,
-0.45154228806495667,
-0.06709838658571243,
0.163927361369133,
0.255554735660553,
-0.345248818397522,
0.6205421686172485,
0.41792550683021545,
-0.06804471462965012,
-0.1698395311832428,
-0.30208727717399597,
0.4592705965042114,
0.7790477275848389,
-0.8226690888404846,
0.6220201253890991,
0.5889925956726074,
0.1273396909236908,
0.12459366023540497,
0.610431432723999,
-0.18697716295719147,
0.4037872552871704,
0.26298362016677856,
0.20360375940799713,
-0.30725646018981934,
-0.551317036151886,
-0.32769066095352173,
0.15754559636116028,
0.17872342467308044,
-0.11763989180326462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11804v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11804v3 | LLM as Prompter: Low-resource Inductive Reasoning on Arbitrary Knowledge Graphs | 2024-02-19T03:21:19 | 2024-06-19T09:00:53 | Kai Wang, Yuwei Xu, Zhiyong Wu, Siqiang Luo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Knowledge Graph (KG) inductive reasoning, which aims to infer missing facts
from new KGs that are not seen during training, has been widely adopted in
various applications. One critical challenge of KG inductive reasoning is
handling low-resource scenarios with scarcity in both textual and structural
aspects. In this paper, we attempt to address this challenge with Large
Language Models (LLMs). Particularly, we utilize the state-of-the-art LLMs to
generate a graph-structural prompt to enhance the pre-trained Graph Neural
Networks (GNNs), which brings us new methodological insights into the KG
inductive reasoning methods, as well as high generalizability in practice. On
the methodological side, we introduce a novel pretraining and prompting
framework ProLINK, designed for low-resource inductive reasoning across
arbitrary KGs without requiring additional training. On the practical side, we
experimentally evaluate our approach on 36 low-resource KG datasets and find
that ProLINK outperforms previous methods in three-shot, one-shot, and
zero-shot reasoning tasks, exhibiting average performance improvements by 20%,
45%, and 147%, respectively. Furthermore, ProLINK demonstrates strong
robustness for various LLM promptings as well as full-shot scenarios. | [
-0.3473988175392151,
-0.7115285992622375,
0.7376532554626465,
0.01531597226858139,
-0.33258742094039917,
-0.0338747464120388,
-0.2915734350681305,
-0.10175327211618423,
0.07062886655330658,
0.12737098336219788,
-0.7925353050231934,
-0.5220573544502258,
-0.3979158401489258,
0.4965066611766815,
-0.006961219012737274,
0.6591242551803589,
-0.21596725285053253,
-0.014859498478472233,
-0.4392182230949402,
-0.21570290625095367,
-0.3869000971317291,
-0.1454169750213623,
-0.6580499410629272,
-0.6503931283950806,
0.9735669493675232,
0.46551385521888733,
0.7461960911750793,
0.380478173494339,
0.15314723551273346,
0.2373889833688736,
-0.17653638124465942,
0.5178402066230774,
-0.4252917468547821,
0.09265164285898209,
-0.20116984844207764,
-0.2328655868768692,
-0.1796112060546875,
-0.07421468943357468,
0.5762219429016113,
0.9284305572509766,
0.3125878572463989,
0.10981955379247665,
0.2534172534942627,
0.5607125759124756,
-0.5458738803863525,
0.49358320236206055,
-0.5539066791534424,
-0.02703840658068657,
-0.045443110167980194,
-0.14434124529361725,
-0.6485009789466858,
-0.5782808065414429,
0.016730889678001404,
-0.8835726976394653,
-0.004142866004258394,
0.2256300449371338,
0.7346745133399963,
0.4045279622077942,
-0.29300373792648315,
-0.31323665380477905,
-0.4014587104320526,
0.28566524386405945,
-0.539006233215332,
0.3538687229156494,
0.4022844433784485,
0.30217981338500977,
-0.4110974967479706,
-1.045050859451294,
-0.7071351408958435,
-0.47027894854545593,
-0.4387706518173218,
0.03371388465166092,
-0.1554381251335144,
0.2531070113182068,
0.29690417647361755,
0.09023553878068924,
-0.5639486312866211,
0.3263370394706726,
-0.04630083590745926,
-0.1708829700946808,
0.3036677837371826,
0.20305176079273224,
0.13149422407150269,
-0.3927415609359741,
0.07940268516540527,
0.07098902761936188,
-1.0563963651657104,
-0.014781191013753414,
0.48002150654792786,
0.6669161915779114,
0.01850021444261074,
0.5646013617515564,
-0.42650505900382996,
0.9117354154586792,
-0.2006296068429947,
-0.059830665588378906,
0.09660881012678146,
-0.40407463908195496,
-0.137856125831604,
0.14612826704978943,
1.104285478591919,
0.1678091585636139,
0.48270395398139954,
-0.3475774824619293,
0.19245094060897827,
-0.052120476961135864,
-0.16994476318359375,
-0.9436934590339661,
-0.5965952277183533,
0.137319877743721,
-0.3789800703525543,
-0.0920337364077568,
-0.5568835139274597,
-0.3127945363521576,
-0.48996809124946594,
-0.1764540672302246,
0.331243634223938,
-0.593358039855957,
-0.14896667003631592,
0.00014353501319419593,
0.06542181968688965,
-0.09811572730541229,
0.40576088428497314,
-0.7694113254547119,
-0.2624751627445221,
0.21665622293949127,
0.8003401160240173,
0.26414039731025696,
-0.17831560969352722,
-0.6560612916946411,
0.11369022727012634,
-0.2556273639202118,
0.850490391254425,
-0.5681748986244202,
-0.3974595367908478,
-0.044932473450899124,
0.06746664643287659,
-0.053771261125802994,
-0.5813042521476746,
0.48311829566955566,
-0.5616803169250488,
0.09742777794599533,
-0.6887108683586121,
-0.3757990002632141,
-0.080705925822258,
0.47591057419776917,
-0.5768462419509888,
0.9668596386909485,
0.36093196272850037,
-0.8494341373443604,
0.21023677289485931,
-0.6790600419044495,
-0.7062762975692749,
0.4605244994163513,
-0.2998768389225006,
-0.12544065713882446,
-0.32281675934791565,
0.3042246997356415,
0.39997589588165283,
-0.6086493730545044,
0.34022873640060425,
-0.4301512837409973,
-0.2377537190914154,
0.06382693350315094,
-0.18959610164165497,
0.7726417779922485,
0.21259427070617676,
-0.08568922430276871,
0.28221893310546875,
-0.7693014740943909,
0.12907816469669342,
0.2697218358516693,
-0.508997917175293,
-0.15250079333782196,
-0.08504500985145569,
-0.5838723182678223,
0.12131712585687637,
0.031126854941248894,
-0.4220048487186432,
0.43125760555267334,
-0.35555294156074524,
0.6394254565238953,
0.6985166072845459,
-0.11335403472185135,
0.5025479197502136,
0.08576861768960953,
0.4681406021118164,
-0.12600009143352509,
0.0822463259100914,
-0.1670999526977539,
-0.3441386818885803,
-0.5638287663459778,
-0.28252750635147095,
0.33719897270202637,
0.5453741550445557,
-1.2884316444396973,
0.258889377117157,
-0.24922755360603333,
-0.3436596095561981,
-0.38376402854919434,
0.18841759860515594,
0.40988799929618835,
0.9189547896385193,
0.5226531028747559,
0.24910876154899597,
-0.3808603882789612,
-0.6041087508201599,
-0.15119412541389465,
-0.3809677064418793,
-0.12345492839813232,
0.5279565453529358,
0.3440668284893036,
-0.08847847580909729,
1.0988600254058838,
-0.47665145993232727,
-0.17624014616012573,
-0.6811912655830383,
0.12281350791454315,
0.37317126989364624,
0.20897790789604187,
0.3552299439907074,
-0.4035991430282593,
-0.40714171528816223,
-0.15824392437934875,
-1.1267114877700806,
-0.24467863142490387,
0.0002511529892217368,
-0.1971990317106247,
-0.1987556666135788,
0.6365588903427124,
-0.9314699769020081,
0.05764741450548172,
0.2543134391307831,
-0.16733711957931519,
0.7294753193855286,
0.0007952972082421184,
-0.2872684895992279,
-0.8807762265205383,
-0.10497089475393295,
-0.00337402056902647,
-0.019368072971701622,
-0.3153606951236725,
-0.1538124978542328,
-0.1430446207523346,
-0.23677729070186615,
-0.35562869906425476,
0.7927334308624268,
-0.4931568503379822,
0.038156893104314804,
-0.04099363088607788,
0.3350221514701843,
0.05138123035430908,
0.4360700249671936,
-0.1638377606868744,
0.8093156218528748,
0.38774847984313965,
-0.7240308523178101,
0.6614521741867065,
0.44630199670791626,
-0.4731650650501251,
0.4258802831172943,
-0.7153434157371521,
-0.03798676282167435,
-0.3155041038990021,
0.5610222816467285,
-0.9576526880264282,
-0.31095150113105774,
0.49643734097480774,
-0.3201836347579956,
0.28059133887290955,
-0.418914258480072,
-0.9078280925750732,
-0.8039582371711731,
0.007548308931291103,
0.38867974281311035,
0.41184163093566895,
-0.7018663287162781,
0.7585546970367432,
-0.2613442540168762,
-0.14375711977481842,
-0.5616499185562134,
-0.21819612383842468,
-0.07050967961549759,
-0.01661578007042408,
-0.759630024433136,
0.1640065610408783,
-0.08363723754882812,
-0.10335249453783035,
0.28692367672920227,
0.058407723903656006,
0.3053865432739258,
0.21552330255508423,
0.16830800473690033,
0.2272465080022812,
-0.2485181838274002,
0.39140263199806213,
-0.03523608669638634,
-0.28857511281967163,
0.1078050509095192,
-0.733863353729248,
0.7126567363739014,
-0.11502949893474579,
-0.4936698079109192,
-0.4792400300502777,
0.05745773762464523,
0.20540307462215424,
-0.12128730863332748,
0.8650667071342468,
0.6312084197998047,
-0.09391539543867111,
-0.1982303261756897,
-0.3010175824165344,
-0.33511781692504883,
-0.5190914273262024,
0.30906063318252563,
-0.34484174847602844,
-1.0640394687652588,
0.5132663249969482,
-0.5590920448303223,
-0.3306404650211334,
0.33841994404792786,
0.4852047264575958,
-0.2563009262084961,
0.8382410407066345,
0.20921853184700012,
0.003282758640125394,
0.35811060667037964,
-0.4204272925853729,
0.5669753551483154,
-0.6965901851654053,
-0.4160429835319519,
-0.4488268196582794,
-0.429526150226593,
-0.2672211229801178,
-0.1785196214914322,
0.5364649295806885,
0.5049679279327393,
-0.6412215232849121,
0.12388226389884949,
-0.4103962779045105,
0.6768750548362732,
0.6458823084831238,
0.03527801111340523,
0.11355746537446976,
-0.08857346326112747,
-0.6139271259307861,
0.2662925720214844,
-1.1065036058425903,
-0.3264898657798767,
0.6827500462532043,
-0.015360315330326557,
0.8009220957756042,
-0.13070707023143768,
0.5097354054450989,
0.06464753299951553,
0.4663723111152649,
-0.8523188233375549,
0.7948333024978638,
-0.0326647013425827,
-0.2556382715702057,
-0.3864048719406128,
-0.7305070757865906,
-0.8373575806617737,
0.018581552430987358,
-0.14919626712799072,
-0.6408399939537048,
-0.05777968838810921,
0.2735673785209656,
-0.565962016582489,
0.4512946903705597,
-0.6352478861808777,
1.0513986349105835,
-0.12983004748821259,
-0.2436758279800415,
0.23079955577850342,
-0.653590977191925,
0.19742777943611145,
0.2859269082546234,
0.0920150950551033,
-0.2756187617778778,
0.5352606177330017,
0.45284464955329895,
-0.6523110270500183,
0.951782763004303,
-0.46189525723457336,
0.0631810873746872,
0.6368414163589478,
0.1556180715560913,
0.9787315130233765,
-0.07137324661016464,
-0.08257223665714264,
-0.17156215012073517,
-0.6609440445899963,
-0.2565601170063019,
-0.6954439878463745,
0.42353272438049316,
-0.721362829208374,
-0.5723187923431396,
0.15180158615112305,
-0.780680239200592,
-0.3601119816303253,
0.3169892132282257,
0.6113321185112,
0.7054991722106934,
0.19584597647190094,
0.18602703511714935,
0.6746549606323242,
-0.3779515326023102,
0.4029349684715271,
0.29624924063682556,
0.0798526182770729,
-0.3146049380302429,
0.7698925137519836,
0.22655460238456726,
0.2082074135541916,
0.3332635462284088,
0.32235610485076904,
-0.5327818393707275,
-0.7093098759651184,
-0.6760488748550415,
0.40768715739250183,
-1.0800775289535522,
-0.5535637140274048,
-0.8790821433067322,
-0.2571223974227905,
-0.277341365814209,
-0.3785490095615387,
-0.09163367748260498,
-0.295662522315979,
-0.3846985101699829,
-0.32831722497940063,
0.5006284117698669,
0.49989554286003113,
0.10407836735248566,
0.5270867943763733,
-0.7802081108093262,
0.18739335238933563,
0.4353164732456207,
0.29791006445884705,
0.1774451583623886,
-0.3619270920753479,
-0.21412938833236694,
-0.3182023763656616,
-0.0331881083548069,
-0.6924082040786743,
0.07575219124555588,
-0.06092741712927818,
0.7764295935630798,
0.32404759526252747,
0.55475914478302,
0.4317387342453003,
-0.4654198884963989,
0.8184792995452881,
0.4858211874961853,
-0.5963120460510254,
0.6696276068687439,
-0.4184436500072479,
0.28364086151123047,
0.531147837638855,
0.7267690300941467,
-0.23043575882911682,
-0.2979903817176819,
-0.3645009994506836,
-0.9462893605232239,
0.5507946610450745,
-0.01416228897869587,
-0.009877204895019531,
-0.42758452892303467,
0.4346955120563507,
-0.17563264071941376,
-0.011325052008032799,
-0.7871811389923096,
-0.1334066092967987,
-0.3228093385696411,
-0.4593935012817383,
0.2862839102745056,
-0.42810696363449097,
-0.26311764121055603,
-0.2978050708770752,
0.6519331336021423,
-0.6420466899871826,
0.16445066034793854,
0.1421339213848114,
-0.2431199848651886,
0.10396527498960495,
0.34936851263046265,
0.23499776422977448,
0.6271220445632935,
-0.0308797899633646,
0.37210145592689514,
0.4136239290237427,
-0.1009925901889801,
0.3308042585849762,
0.24106203019618988,
-0.1903623342514038,
-0.0874517634510994,
0.5830502510070801,
0.8608783483505249,
0.13359899818897247,
-0.41818469762802124,
0.4473177194595337,
0.09045904129743576,
-0.28956738114356995,
-0.01781998574733734,
-0.019634222611784935,
0.3969419002532959,
0.53536057472229,
0.27436453104019165,
-0.2770542502403259,
-0.34088635444641113,
-0.2603631913661957,
-0.22005051374435425,
0.4202326834201813,
-0.2528039515018463,
-0.24860475957393646,
0.8184168338775635,
0.3368782699108124,
-0.08689229190349579,
1.0187584161758423,
-0.8827624320983887,
-0.5245854258537292,
0.3917849063873291,
0.6826596260070801,
0.6696398854255676,
0.10771872848272324,
0.4001295268535614,
0.4912126660346985,
0.3054558336734772,
-0.059239789843559265,
0.1375693678855896,
-0.12343940138816833,
-0.9565169811248779,
-0.7272111773490906,
-0.6702846884727478,
-0.2485072761774063,
0.15799903869628906,
-0.23015142977237701,
0.09373042732477188,
-0.6144985556602478,
-0.1700039654970169,
-0.12394915521144867,
-0.029548397287726402,
-0.610957145690918,
-0.0053784484043717384,
0.0927053913474083,
1.0708813667297363,
-0.7512766122817993,
0.8290612697601318,
0.5664708018302917,
-0.5605557560920715,
-1.171703577041626,
-0.21617531776428223,
-0.020575832575559616,
-0.9124346375465393,
1.1534124612808228,
0.17659969627857208,
-0.3172719478607178,
0.18479102849960327,
-0.5911054015159607,
-0.5714794993400574,
1.335422396659851,
0.661687970161438,
-0.4273433983325958,
-0.22710612416267395,
0.056942060589790344,
0.23527368903160095,
-0.34250709414482117,
0.22709789872169495,
0.41040733456611633,
0.5526077747344971,
0.5553422570228577,
-0.6937450766563416,
0.3686509430408478,
-0.18901169300079346,
-0.11964660882949829,
0.036636169999837875,
-0.4824094772338867,
0.9235790371894836,
-0.48306092619895935,
-0.2510153353214264,
-0.08639616519212723,
0.7441889047622681,
0.4425663948059082,
0.22913822531700134,
0.546257734298706,
0.6746276021003723,
1.1413133144378662,
-0.18109750747680664,
1.2464730739593506,
-0.27710577845573425,
0.05218493938446045,
1.0881503820419312,
-0.44971218705177307,
0.25632530450820923,
0.000645296648144722,
-0.2586667239665985,
0.7959553599357605,
0.7163140773773193,
0.2049931436777115,
0.5019969344139099,
0.2267453372478485,
-0.536965012550354,
-0.5851312875747681,
-0.5628319382667542,
-0.45131343603134155,
0.13012675940990448,
0.225459024310112,
-0.23274913430213928,
-0.4397444725036621,
0.008005660958588123,
0.412016898393631,
-0.14477497339248657,
-0.4796571731567383,
0.5847960114479065,
0.14215818047523499,
-0.5408148169517517,
0.6795145273208618,
-0.28643733263015747,
0.39617517590522766,
-0.7506840825080872,
0.17629148066043854,
-0.3602263927459717,
0.08506683260202408,
-0.24087771773338318,
-0.7486951351165771,
0.03323078155517578,
-0.11571934074163437,
-0.25854265689849854,
-0.33464598655700684,
0.8905467391014099,
-0.16030991077423096,
-0.20375846326351166,
0.5012124180793762,
0.5594430565834045,
-0.02110852301120758,
-0.11699441820383072,
-0.4436979591846466,
-0.16413280367851257,
-0.19242988526821136,
-0.20218582451343536,
0.3995733857154846,
0.7825812697410583,
-0.10002102702856064,
0.8128839135169983,
0.7339425683021545,
-0.040442463010549545,
-0.23876310884952545,
0.5555518269538879,
1.3177130222320557,
-0.5067185759544373,
-0.5394881367683411,
-0.9484943747520447,
0.1776212453842163,
-0.05522637441754341,
0.052307769656181335,
0.6596994400024414,
0.2983328700065613,
0.7573520541191101,
0.1137462705373764,
0.7992187142372131,
-0.00532688619568944,
0.1650059074163437,
-0.7563925981521606,
0.6093920469284058,
-0.30825063586235046,
0.08727023005485535,
-0.026216479018330574,
-0.7524356842041016,
-0.26662343740463257,
0.5878257751464844,
-0.5299456715583801,
-0.0061490414664149284,
0.7515196800231934,
0.8058921694755554,
0.1523716151714325,
0.09577177464962006,
0.04748893901705742,
0.2361125349998474,
0.32748350501060486,
0.5971003174781799,
1.1817923784255981,
0.19362185895442963,
0.9429289102554321,
0.21902568638324738,
-0.0009315384086221457,
-0.19539402425289154,
-1.1044741868972778,
-0.9867739677429199,
-0.29830339550971985,
-0.17965830862522125,
-0.6122822165489197,
-0.09145808964967728,
1.0736422538757324,
0.5469425916671753,
-0.4963260591030121,
0.25138580799102783,
-0.15243889391422272,
0.43330270051956177,
0.023576751351356506,
-0.2096492350101471,
0.4210914671421051,
-0.6473655104637146,
-0.14528407156467438,
0.659034252166748,
0.31251955032348633,
0.02591012232005596,
-0.11020610481500626,
-0.3540424108505249,
-0.12870799005031586,
-0.18703633546829224,
0.7780733108520508,
0.3308098316192627,
-0.5658378005027771,
-0.490058958530426,
-0.04028257727622986,
0.09270525723695755,
-0.07133770734071732,
0.9848906993865967,
-1.088197946548462,
0.2631441354751587,
0.5456485152244568,
0.7249303460121155,
0.40702110528945923,
-0.18667922914028168,
0.28161418437957764,
-1.0971508026123047,
0.22758233547210693,
0.1846989393234253,
0.472046822309494,
0.47253432869911194,
-0.3942064940929413,
0.5665065050125122,
0.6287208795547485,
-0.39351075887680054,
-0.7789749503135681,
0.586222231388092,
-0.6716664433479309,
-0.4241319000720978,
1.2253669500350952,
-0.34030699729919434,
-0.0825737863779068,
-0.10701658576726913,
0.11873312294483185,
0.4072987139225006,
-0.07355828583240509,
0.4019457697868347,
0.6370921730995178,
-0.26353389024734497,
-0.29903432726860046,
-0.35608166456222534,
0.5481821894645691,
0.0782960057258606,
-0.87446528673172,
0.15731507539749146,
0.5310423970222473,
0.19370323419570923,
0.16367290914058685,
1.0681935548782349,
0.09418244659900665,
-0.010671783238649368,
0.1189185157418251,
-0.2080516219139099,
-0.6909290552139282,
-0.617508053779602,
0.2467120736837387,
0.26988062262535095,
0.12214744091033936,
0.02841888926923275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11794v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11794v1 | Unveiling the Magic: Investigating Attention Distillation in Retrieval-augmented Generation | 2024-02-19T02:48:44 | 2024-02-19T02:48:44 | Zizhong Li, Haopeng Zhang, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-augmented generation framework can address the limitations of large
language models by enabling real-time knowledge updates for more accurate
answers. An efficient way in the training phase of retrieval-augmented models
is attention distillation, which uses attention scores as a supervision signal
instead of manually annotated query-document pairs. Despite its growing
popularity, the detailed mechanisms behind the success of attention
distillation remain unexplored, particularly the specific patterns it leverages
to benefit training. In this paper, we address this gap by conducting a
comprehensive review of attention distillation workflow and identifying key
factors influencing the learning quality of retrieval-augmented language
models. We further propose indicators for optimizing models' training methods
and avoiding ineffective training. | [
-0.46994495391845703,
-0.6974008679389954,
0.5059815645217896,
-0.02242361195385456,
-0.23023205995559692,
0.5646145939826965,
-0.11569324135780334,
-0.3152340054512024,
-0.05639823153614998,
0.4650808572769165,
-0.5396586656570435,
0.09357466548681259,
-0.9701142907142639,
0.24020865559577942,
-0.40088748931884766,
1.0002772808074951,
0.00042489709449000657,
-0.12897856533527374,
-0.18571801483631134,
0.12611646950244904,
-0.47947582602500916,
-0.5606003999710083,
-0.4082530736923218,
-0.5748112797737122,
0.33501771092414856,
0.2613161504268646,
0.36048299074172974,
0.4715498983860016,
0.7042376399040222,
0.2437652051448822,
-0.2166280597448349,
0.6589766144752502,
-0.9991368651390076,
0.34522774815559387,
-0.15189790725708008,
-0.5499334931373596,
-0.086545929312706,
0.23998938500881195,
0.38020414113998413,
0.8389180302619934,
-0.23664306104183197,
0.5811002850532532,
0.46277356147766113,
1.1262388229370117,
-1.0314196348190308,
0.024088209494948387,
-0.939817488193512,
0.10566039383411407,
-0.18277260661125183,
-0.31848761439323425,
-0.30532702803611755,
-0.2687760889530182,
0.2999952733516693,
-0.4566290080547333,
0.48132196068763733,
0.2325168251991272,
0.7387377619743347,
0.5678108334541321,
-0.3759884536266327,
-0.10954081267118454,
-0.9659898281097412,
0.8993912935256958,
-0.3059926927089691,
0.184709370136261,
0.6247993111610413,
0.4404449462890625,
-0.14517946541309357,
-0.8287635445594788,
-0.44351229071617126,
-0.07183827459812164,
-0.008804586715996265,
0.08939342945814133,
-0.02632707543671131,
0.11330975592136383,
0.5301772952079773,
0.8717085123062134,
-0.18551813066005707,
-0.6559059619903564,
-0.34493765234947205,
0.17462587356567383,
0.4376179873943329,
0.02407594956457615,
-0.008590565994381905,
0.15174341201782227,
-0.11032269150018692,
0.02139385975897312,
-0.46191853284835815,
-0.26479899883270264,
0.33168888092041016,
0.1391574740409851,
0.525484025478363,
0.5794293284416199,
-0.3391254246234894,
0.8513827323913574,
0.6630890369415283,
-0.0892019122838974,
0.154119074344635,
-0.47787705063819885,
-0.200150266289711,
0.20569749176502228,
0.5128360986709595,
0.2304077446460724,
0.40406128764152527,
-0.2485884726047516,
-0.20818959176540375,
-0.2531845271587372,
0.6021354794502258,
-0.9126359820365906,
-0.2695589065551758,
0.02261333540081978,
-0.2424921691417694,
-0.26852595806121826,
-0.07274432480335236,
-0.6118043065071106,
-0.1981222778558731,
-0.5900408029556274,
0.3376106023788452,
-0.2791588604450226,
-0.49588078260421753,
-0.012873701751232147,
-0.366298109292984,
-0.26818618178367615,
0.1080276221036911,
-1.3151901960372925,
-0.000026307910957257263,
0.6211090087890625,
0.6889284253120422,
-0.015510238707065582,
-0.13481183350086212,
-0.6825116276741028,
0.10049260407686234,
-0.30018147826194763,
0.5951065421104431,
-0.5262568593025208,
-0.30115705728530884,
0.009513221681118011,
-0.1692735105752945,
-0.13954521715641022,
-0.7336789965629578,
0.15202628076076508,
-0.805844783782959,
0.16602009534835815,
-0.4578188359737396,
-0.3863646686077118,
-0.16146180033683777,
0.4213722348213196,
-0.5800247192382812,
1.240334391593933,
0.3322324752807617,
-0.7215131521224976,
0.5352592468261719,
-0.6219987273216248,
-0.2740914523601532,
0.006334546022117138,
0.38976675271987915,
-0.11526789516210556,
0.6358619928359985,
0.04677215963602066,
0.19682671129703522,
-0.3131944239139557,
0.2545740008354187,
-0.01816651038825512,
-0.3492480218410492,
0.24394263327121735,
-0.65115886926651,
0.5178276896476746,
0.518988847732544,
-0.2511719763278961,
-0.5358317494392395,
-1.0680596828460693,
-0.11576182395219803,
0.06898879259824753,
-0.3242329955101013,
-0.6588435769081116,
-0.29616764187812805,
-0.16084024310112,
0.18490637838840485,
0.3427455723285675,
-0.3893900513648987,
0.25637829303741455,
-0.5149424076080322,
0.34350651502609253,
0.33414632081985474,
0.4449983239173889,
0.3195134699344635,
0.07967700064182281,
0.35787272453308105,
0.09531956166028976,
0.30996236205101013,
-0.32635265588760376,
-0.14027473330497742,
-0.6219351291656494,
0.017875205725431442,
0.48970699310302734,
0.15046100318431854,
-0.8492671847343445,
0.12542837858200073,
-0.09661704301834106,
-0.37838712334632874,
-1.0478373765945435,
0.5617825984954834,
0.7145171761512756,
0.7667583227157593,
0.4045570492744446,
-0.1268492043018341,
-0.28445613384246826,
-0.6322087645530701,
-0.42039862275123596,
-0.050043776631355286,
0.2713555097579956,
-0.0605698898434639,
0.38965514302253723,
-0.03535187244415283,
0.7998824715614319,
-0.5889460444450378,
-0.2992088198661804,
-0.17936909198760986,
0.27656519412994385,
0.07999911159276962,
0.09540925174951553,
0.5019851922988892,
-1.0480141639709473,
-0.9423918128013611,
-0.053696323186159134,
-0.7201599478721619,
-0.044372376054525375,
0.20252224802970886,
-0.31086423993110657,
-0.04646258056163788,
0.28369447588920593,
-0.29221633076667786,
0.33417561650276184,
0.25864800810813904,
-0.05509006604552269,
0.3040981590747833,
-0.16729910671710968,
0.6631677746772766,
-0.9542943239212036,
0.27076900005340576,
0.006760262418538332,
0.01822511851787567,
-0.7687675952911377,
-0.0015595282893627882,
0.023379724472761154,
0.14393633604049683,
-0.4946340024471283,
0.2738330662250519,
-0.8732128739356995,
0.16537010669708252,
-0.5670995116233826,
0.1480473279953003,
0.47013625502586365,
0.5686048269271851,
-0.08265433460474014,
0.668319582939148,
0.3656831979751587,
-0.5725250840187073,
0.5545037388801575,
0.14712700247764587,
-0.24651746451854706,
0.5622552037239075,
-0.4942399859428406,
0.08688889443874359,
-0.12374930828809738,
-0.6272867321968079,
-1.1584595441818237,
-0.2621389329433441,
-0.08399131149053574,
-0.5373516082763672,
0.8406865000724792,
-0.34951478242874146,
-0.7018634080886841,
-0.44590815901756287,
-0.18441537022590637,
0.18585187196731567,
0.6662532687187195,
-0.6119323968887329,
0.5374165177345276,
0.3412356376647949,
0.30402490496635437,
-0.8846264481544495,
-0.6728377938270569,
-0.11778827011585236,
-0.2844446897506714,
-0.27918678522109985,
0.17232513427734375,
0.16526290774345398,
-0.526671826839447,
-0.03273093327879906,
-0.26384028792381287,
0.002806713804602623,
0.33032694458961487,
0.029755281284451485,
0.08697352558374405,
0.3210660517215729,
0.027263782918453217,
0.09556791931390762,
-0.09494027495384216,
0.04828685149550438,
-0.1517569124698639,
0.3015556335449219,
0.5168017148971558,
-0.36231788992881775,
-0.319231778383255,
0.19179368019104004,
0.6740438938140869,
-0.5135688781738281,
0.8686143159866333,
0.45353859663009644,
-0.24302995204925537,
-0.21202878654003143,
-0.7845580577850342,
-0.3506529927253723,
-0.4494120180606842,
0.23528271913528442,
-0.32130318880081177,
-0.4817040264606476,
0.4574902057647705,
-0.21661415696144104,
0.19217489659786224,
0.25081872940063477,
0.6056812405586243,
-0.020945539698004723,
1.2890080213546753,
0.6451553702354431,
0.203762024641037,
0.8429269194602966,
-0.2789199650287628,
0.27639544010162354,
-1.1365865468978882,
-0.3939146101474762,
-0.393806517124176,
-0.26305821537971497,
-0.17354977130889893,
-0.157459557056427,
0.3983668088912964,
0.3497510850429535,
0.06794473528862,
0.08318784087896347,
-1.0649131536483765,
0.5945694446563721,
0.6477289795875549,
-0.101153165102005,
0.5242704153060913,
0.28111690282821655,
-0.0032200640998780727,
-0.0762087032198906,
-0.4979158043861389,
-0.4858843684196472,
1.3523733615875244,
0.08918529748916626,
0.7815675735473633,
-0.174506276845932,
0.832188069820404,
0.2050141543149948,
0.08451525866985321,
-0.5393202304840088,
0.15042150020599365,
0.06806353479623795,
-0.8505599498748779,
-0.14337292313575745,
-0.33833035826683044,
-0.843399703502655,
0.3726736605167389,
0.09811776131391525,
-0.501396894454956,
0.17066827416419983,
0.36744019389152527,
-0.4689940810203552,
0.02227221429347992,
-0.9937805533409119,
0.8745427131652832,
-0.21698789298534393,
-0.7159505486488342,
-0.046496473252773285,
-0.5394872426986694,
0.5240049958229065,
-0.2957206666469574,
0.06376950442790985,
-0.026439020410180092,
0.4356454014778137,
0.5649482607841492,
-0.41182854771614075,
0.4776161015033722,
-0.3237467408180237,
-0.13362909853458405,
0.7019517421722412,
0.06839630752801895,
0.3811076879501343,
-0.15281078219413757,
0.16426639258861542,
-0.12343436479568481,
0.1042795181274414,
-0.24462497234344482,
-0.6879442930221558,
0.6356971263885498,
-0.5134387612342834,
-0.7595033645629883,
-0.4869975745677948,
-0.2625252902507782,
-0.5541003346443176,
0.035995714366436005,
0.20956560969352722,
0.23709437251091003,
-0.03908872604370117,
0.1275980919599533,
1.132819652557373,
0.3662918210029602,
0.4764115810394287,
0.42949405312538147,
-0.2787111699581146,
-0.11982350051403046,
0.9941953420639038,
0.47395390272140503,
0.5287293195724487,
0.32371848821640015,
-0.1648263782262802,
-0.4467378258705139,
-0.6106346845626831,
-0.33448973298072815,
0.10953327268362045,
-0.5617814064025879,
-0.006490929517894983,
-0.66051185131073,
-0.1209525465965271,
-0.39727866649627686,
0.5006005167961121,
-0.4981767237186432,
-0.25821176171302795,
-0.5662460327148438,
-0.1986774057149887,
0.47395122051239014,
0.48927247524261475,
-0.10109288990497589,
0.1438942849636078,
-0.9198647737503052,
0.5030708909034729,
0.5609433054924011,
0.14074252545833588,
0.3465264141559601,
-0.7877498865127563,
-0.545310914516449,
0.2554394602775574,
-0.6252346038818359,
-0.8308722972869873,
0.3702375888824463,
0.28468057513237,
0.6194277405738831,
0.3722797930240631,
0.14251109957695007,
0.7825648188591003,
-0.5351893901824951,
0.7952278852462769,
0.14459265768527985,
-0.6006067991256714,
0.9171609282493591,
-0.006645573303103447,
0.2527218163013458,
0.9014765620231628,
0.34718507528305054,
-0.21766364574432373,
-0.23896890878677368,
-0.5385873913764954,
-0.7461239099502563,
0.8248751759529114,
0.16491059958934784,
0.1604141891002655,
-0.12503641843795776,
0.5591105222702026,
0.09663160145282745,
0.6373888254165649,
-0.2687593102455139,
-0.41102853417396545,
-0.14875724911689758,
-0.14839453995227814,
0.12741577625274658,
-0.4309336543083191,
-0.25968649983406067,
-0.1367783397436142,
0.7040745615959167,
0.06965731084346771,
-0.22105814516544342,
0.007505707908421755,
-0.2816525101661682,
-0.20173196494579315,
-0.06807153671979904,
0.1915433704853058,
0.7149326205253601,
-0.2483118772506714,
0.08372265845537186,
-0.1263696551322937,
-0.848050057888031,
0.1768660992383957,
0.05467459186911583,
-0.006710677407681942,
0.023411167785525322,
0.19777555763721466,
0.944202721118927,
-0.01737525314092636,
-0.6177073121070862,
0.33121857047080994,
-0.06556547433137894,
-0.21781854331493378,
-0.035455022007226944,
0.4553958475589752,
-0.16076935827732086,
0.24158553779125214,
0.8502237796783447,
-0.13861390948295593,
0.5292072296142578,
-0.77139812707901,
-0.18616528809070587,
0.3591892719268799,
-0.4765518009662628,
-0.260884553194046,
0.7242145538330078,
0.16309364140033722,
-0.14144694805145264,
0.5917487144470215,
-0.24248874187469482,
-0.2965569496154785,
0.334911972284317,
0.08104340732097626,
0.8104248046875,
-0.2974519729614258,
-0.05863983556628227,
0.33210015296936035,
0.1765497773885727,
-0.4030217230319977,
0.1989419311285019,
-0.4224570393562317,
-0.23148582875728607,
-0.46817412972450256,
-0.8949722647666931,
-0.27847471833229065,
-0.07444463670253754,
-1.0068943500518799,
-0.0316384918987751,
0.08775164186954498,
-0.44611161947250366,
0.08371394872665405,
0.10611723363399506,
-0.5958493947982788,
0.16583837568759918,
0.06118251755833626,
0.5734319090843201,
-0.6654727458953857,
0.6658994555473328,
0.5553106069564819,
-0.7136325240135193,
-0.5995299816131592,
-0.10926090180873871,
-0.260577917098999,
-0.6414229869842529,
0.8733376264572144,
-0.06960169225931168,
0.0002823928080033511,
0.3520677387714386,
-0.4073163568973541,
-0.8303450345993042,
1.014099359512329,
0.5134665966033936,
-0.8320546746253967,
-0.31116512417793274,
0.08382844924926758,
0.7720903158187866,
-0.00766556803137064,
0.23609234392642975,
0.9451388716697693,
0.28507789969444275,
0.29301413893699646,
-0.9537155628204346,
-0.4972939193248749,
-0.21090519428253174,
0.1612396091222763,
0.33933281898498535,
-0.6222487688064575,
0.47502076625823975,
-0.18182432651519775,
-0.3260211646556854,
-0.36049720644950867,
0.3353152871131897,
0.27845025062561035,
0.423860102891922,
-0.047189097851514816,
0.6617543697357178,
0.5848184823989868,
-0.4440365433692932,
0.9392024874687195,
-0.46419984102249146,
0.436175137758255,
0.9061307907104492,
-0.3864958882331848,
0.5372793674468994,
0.918474018573761,
-0.35880833864212036,
0.19467954337596893,
0.7079252004623413,
-0.019253430888056755,
1.1221845149993896,
0.1142910048365593,
-0.2911929786205292,
-0.1584293693304062,
-0.19258232414722443,
-0.44378677010536194,
0.0920557826757431,
0.30341386795043945,
-0.6436777114868164,
-0.13004319369792938,
0.5334112048149109,
-0.29346150159835815,
0.24790140986442566,
-0.4134658873081207,
1.19020676612854,
0.02043582871556282,
-1.137664794921875,
0.9681565761566162,
-0.5846776366233826,
0.40821701288223267,
-0.3886304795742035,
-0.293251097202301,
-0.2417442798614502,
0.3292696475982666,
-0.11839563399553299,
-0.6087682247161865,
0.09581784158945084,
0.20500709116458893,
-0.7608681917190552,
-0.2375694215297699,
0.4852524399757385,
-0.5814408659934998,
-0.26684242486953735,
0.23132658004760742,
0.5317085981369019,
0.12140355259180069,
-0.43998488783836365,
-0.7200265526771545,
0.040916796773672104,
-0.037140633910894394,
-0.6438491344451904,
0.661176860332489,
0.9988274574279785,
0.33926355838775635,
0.5008716583251953,
0.6537409424781799,
-0.05563812330365181,
0.34712105989456177,
0.08155975490808487,
0.8505282998085022,
-0.2816654443740845,
-0.10429257154464722,
-1.0495562553405762,
0.6937363147735596,
-0.19683773815631866,
-0.07762184739112854,
0.988696813583374,
0.45844531059265137,
0.6937230825424194,
-0.1860533505678177,
0.7622106671333313,
0.13341353833675385,
0.6389739513397217,
-0.32815828919410706,
0.779327392578125,
-0.7341295480728149,
0.1885523796081543,
-0.0789431631565094,
-1.1645121574401855,
0.0711192712187767,
0.2860317826271057,
-0.27540236711502075,
0.21396227180957794,
0.6851393580436707,
0.5565059781074524,
0.006788232829421759,
-0.30982276797294617,
0.4638306498527527,
-0.05768478289246559,
0.20692910254001617,
0.49915337562561035,
0.9054524302482605,
-0.6195893883705139,
0.553032398223877,
-0.3088572025299072,
-0.1975608766078949,
-0.43965497612953186,
-0.710960865020752,
-1.1039327383041382,
-0.6538766622543335,
-0.510591447353363,
-0.3767662048339844,
0.12567487359046936,
0.5808297991752625,
0.5558428764343262,
-0.5917172431945801,
0.2685057818889618,
-0.13039220869541168,
-0.07573011517524719,
-0.37569454312324524,
-0.2232973724603653,
0.31664708256721497,
-0.7481626272201538,
-1.1338844299316406,
0.10411497205495834,
0.4011624753475189,
0.10279068350791931,
-0.5824115872383118,
0.3369221091270447,
-0.3650141656398773,
0.025162938982248306,
0.49676504731178284,
0.34763652086257935,
-0.5541260242462158,
0.2940104007720947,
0.07717365026473999,
-0.2248198688030243,
-0.09599153697490692,
0.5675597786903381,
-0.6416809558868408,
0.9145272374153137,
0.39635899662971497,
0.5089890360832214,
0.6621385216712952,
0.2261987179517746,
0.35467788577079773,
-0.9265079498291016,
0.0153481001034379,
0.12518347799777985,
0.2663859724998474,
0.43238797783851624,
-0.4973212480545044,
0.6548669934272766,
0.34387850761413574,
-0.706483006477356,
-1.3283973932266235,
-0.11468809098005295,
-0.5912405848503113,
-0.07280933111906052,
1.0841773748397827,
-0.08972260355949402,
-0.4931681454181671,
-0.28766557574272156,
-0.38534507155418396,
0.35713809728622437,
-0.24835900962352753,
1.0977885723114014,
0.9426121711730957,
-0.08001590520143509,
-0.050203438848257065,
-0.6744339466094971,
0.7102069854736328,
0.12876960635185242,
-0.3944763243198395,
0.5239199995994568,
0.5139229893684387,
0.24662140011787415,
0.5057969093322754,
0.28206053376197815,
-0.19806833565235138,
0.2843150496482849,
0.04484298825263977,
-0.024590080603957176,
-0.5079671740531921,
-0.42745164036750793,
-0.1703849583864212,
0.41101083159446716,
0.24462005496025085,
-0.3534073531627655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11782v1 | What Evidence Do Language Models Find Convincing? | 2024-02-19T02:15:34 | 2024-02-19T02:15:34 | Alexander Wan, Eric Wallace, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented language models are being increasingly tasked with
subjective, contentious, and conflicting queries such as "is aspartame linked
to cancer". To resolve these ambiguous queries, one must search through a large
range of websites and consider "which, if any, of this evidence do I find
convincing?". In this work, we study how LLMs answer this question. In
particular, we construct ConflictingQA, a dataset that pairs controversial
queries with a series of real-world evidence documents that contain different
facts (e.g., quantitative results), argument styles (e.g., appeals to
authority), and answers (Yes or No). We use this dataset to perform sensitivity
and counterfactual analyses to explore which text features most affect LLM
predictions. Overall, we find that current models rely heavily on the relevance
of a website to the query, while largely ignoring stylistic features that
humans find important such as whether a text contains scientific references or
is written with a neutral tone. Taken together, these results highlight the
importance of RAG corpus quality (e.g., the need to filter misinformation), and
possibly even a shift in how LLMs are trained to better align with human
judgements. | [
-0.3257020115852356,
-0.6899440884590149,
0.8816120028495789,
-0.05900425836443901,
-0.19515617191791534,
0.05870514363050461,
-0.008132672868669033,
-0.532541036605835,
0.07558218389749527,
0.5777047276496887,
-0.4628296196460724,
-0.4198756814002991,
-0.6915007829666138,
0.29410284757614136,
-0.7264970541000366,
0.918941855430603,
0.11330665647983551,
0.25291135907173157,
-0.5434859991073608,
-0.19301965832710266,
-0.07737360894680023,
-0.6443221569061279,
-0.5094706416130066,
-0.566158652305603,
0.8151752352714539,
0.25840502977371216,
0.8618611693382263,
0.6096775531768799,
0.31625616550445557,
0.23424169421195984,
-0.26226353645324707,
0.06908098608255386,
-0.4717567563056946,
0.35650452971458435,
-0.5864893198013306,
-0.7336809635162354,
0.06079090014100075,
0.15592558681964874,
0.3346451222896576,
0.7505088448524475,
0.009209616109728813,
0.06618541479110718,
0.1155601367354393,
0.618559718132019,
-0.6300883293151855,
-0.3746780455112457,
-0.8663293123245239,
-0.24623171985149384,
-0.4400516450405121,
-0.27474647760391235,
-0.3892689049243927,
-0.3564881980419159,
0.07752528786659241,
-0.3989323079586029,
0.3260473608970642,
0.1875227391719818,
1.1813026666641235,
0.27672576904296875,
-1.0076212882995605,
-0.6919982433319092,
-0.5148661732673645,
0.8136526942253113,
-0.7247101664543152,
0.5069056749343872,
0.6644666790962219,
0.09795042872428894,
-0.3253839313983917,
-0.6196879744529724,
-0.5696941614151001,
-0.48858699202537537,
-0.18707944452762604,
0.04938146471977234,
-0.19746312499046326,
-0.022141311317682266,
0.33052119612693787,
0.45698362588882446,
-0.612163245677948,
0.16849669814109802,
-0.12033681571483612,
-0.4332820773124695,
0.548520028591156,
-0.0006376414676196873,
0.5154594779014587,
-0.32785478234291077,
-0.2814180552959442,
0.06439850479364395,
-0.9569646120071411,
0.09816420823335648,
0.4382379651069641,
0.15575966238975525,
0.2400663197040558,
0.8419860601425171,
-0.142372727394104,
0.6232631802558899,
-0.048275724053382874,
0.0305876974016428,
-0.3540602922439575,
-0.24548578262329102,
-0.09937033802270889,
0.15594828128814697,
0.8374006748199463,
0.3967636227607727,
0.0759248360991478,
-0.006162485107779503,
-0.22413486242294312,
0.276117742061615,
0.29233384132385254,
-0.8086925148963928,
-0.1248127892613411,
0.3748936355113983,
-0.3537296950817108,
-0.22164970636367798,
-0.20126618444919586,
-0.5814781188964844,
-0.6568784117698669,
-0.2485561966896057,
0.43370118737220764,
-0.32647931575775146,
-0.07956366240978241,
0.09971723705530167,
-0.2281987965106964,
0.05870473012328148,
0.3292173743247986,
-0.7977278232574463,
0.4121517837047577,
0.7794156670570374,
0.5098589658737183,
-0.2639249563217163,
0.11625491082668304,
-0.46027159690856934,
-0.16485363245010376,
-0.43817010521888733,
1.2285165786743164,
-0.7333791255950928,
-0.32334813475608826,
0.08383537083864212,
0.11466743797063828,
0.15322521328926086,
-0.7094452977180481,
1.0351588726043701,
-0.6072373390197754,
0.6127530336380005,
-0.7767430543899536,
-0.8023251295089722,
-0.3354518711566925,
0.3070330023765564,
-0.6108324527740479,
1.0000213384628296,
-0.37182602286338806,
-0.8017420172691345,
0.3758884370326996,
-0.2998822033405304,
-0.2588706910610199,
-0.25547999143600464,
-0.3451065123081207,
-0.22766467928886414,
0.24730002880096436,
-0.0002108762855641544,
0.21103884279727936,
-0.700824499130249,
0.3662078380584717,
-0.2912910282611847,
-0.17019490897655487,
0.7466467618942261,
-0.5087173581123352,
0.7350011467933655,
0.41024258732795715,
-0.21915702521800995,
-0.055872369557619095,
-0.6102554798126221,
-0.24443978071212769,
0.11681357026100159,
-0.43803513050079346,
-0.5981415510177612,
0.2253498136997223,
-0.15396499633789062,
0.1371384561061859,
0.17860764265060425,
-0.5686348676681519,
0.042570825666189194,
-0.3186741769313812,
0.12973403930664062,
0.37603309750556946,
0.1068825051188469,
0.1692560464143753,
-0.7101939916610718,
0.6431742906570435,
0.008725454099476337,
-0.17851074039936066,
0.039445195347070694,
-0.8127776980400085,
-0.7407439947128296,
0.1276663988828659,
0.42330241203308105,
0.3438767194747925,
-0.679972231388092,
-0.07820037007331848,
-0.03155691921710968,
-0.38397452235221863,
-0.6344139575958252,
0.05960429087281227,
0.3978963792324066,
0.775954008102417,
0.2986725866794586,
-0.07263149321079254,
-0.6256843209266663,
-1.0027927160263062,
-0.6793051958084106,
-0.3885022699832916,
-0.13346855342388153,
0.38518354296684265,
0.44869500398635864,
-0.112271748483181,
1.0202906131744385,
-0.3150457739830017,
0.3239251375198364,
0.08580365777015686,
0.23033703863620758,
0.27436575293540955,
0.09227555990219116,
0.3696410357952118,
-1.0275399684906006,
-0.5153765678405762,
-0.09644675999879837,
-0.763035774230957,
-0.666555643081665,
-0.01962241344153881,
0.0016769368667155504,
0.06536653637886047,
0.344973623752594,
-0.6182140111923218,
0.21836453676223755,
0.6224097609519958,
-0.5159355401992798,
0.658593475818634,
0.16859255731105804,
0.46437424421310425,
-0.8954588174819946,
0.053806040436029434,
0.1720050871372223,
-0.35862430930137634,
-0.7466328144073486,
0.07024653255939484,
-0.026124875992536545,
0.23108738660812378,
-0.28182873129844666,
0.7841942310333252,
-0.38377219438552856,
0.08152849972248077,
-0.5405032634735107,
0.31980106234550476,
0.3079502582550049,
-0.11331424117088318,
-0.011142134666442871,
0.8932467699050903,
0.3361749053001404,
-0.5448581576347351,
0.08206593245267868,
0.13993239402770996,
-0.28630542755126953,
0.44305869936943054,
-0.5259523391723633,
-0.007281008176505566,
-0.0023686012718826532,
0.08411260694265366,
-1.1755839586257935,
-0.310152530670166,
0.041085898876190186,
-0.6671291589736938,
0.10181238502264023,
-0.3343319594860077,
-0.30054542422294617,
-0.14938855171203613,
-0.23730790615081787,
0.14431867003440857,
0.4044753313064575,
-0.4422355890274048,
0.701429545879364,
0.5233662724494934,
-0.16300880908966064,
-0.7223972678184509,
-0.6658249497413635,
0.2596151828765869,
-0.26456141471862793,
-0.4431237578392029,
0.322966605424881,
-0.0731944590806961,
-0.8033596277236938,
0.08158281445503235,
-0.31417953968048096,
-0.10883182287216187,
0.3407568633556366,
0.34193307161331177,
0.16884863376617432,
-0.29495590925216675,
0.1558462679386139,
0.034669406712055206,
0.23217041790485382,
0.3297520875930786,
0.11129605025053024,
0.41401851177215576,
0.06764420866966248,
-0.628038763999939,
-0.12666594982147217,
0.279071182012558,
0.46292826533317566,
0.2587150037288666,
0.6488759517669678,
0.28198909759521484,
-0.40110981464385986,
-0.055461958050727844,
-0.8005754947662354,
-0.31208536028862,
-0.4641260504722595,
0.1340634524822235,
-0.25753381848335266,
-0.9655123949050903,
0.6568273305892944,
-0.13659444451332092,
-0.1250147819519043,
0.6293162107467651,
0.7104895114898682,
-0.31371742486953735,
0.8655444383621216,
0.13213138282299042,
0.22163036465644836,
0.28245094418525696,
0.24118372797966003,
-0.16118191182613373,
-0.6770199537277222,
-0.27338099479675293,
-0.7337130308151245,
-0.06420546025037766,
-0.784862220287323,
-0.42699310183525085,
0.12991909682750702,
0.07409651577472687,
-0.0791846290230751,
0.11992897093296051,
-0.4601110816001892,
0.46865999698638916,
0.56522136926651,
0.03545777499675751,
0.4127892553806305,
-0.05496463552117348,
-0.24817796051502228,
-0.15567997097969055,
-0.6571604013442993,
-0.8650552034378052,
1.1778137683868408,
0.3363451063632965,
0.5727310180664062,
0.3702855408191681,
0.35830390453338623,
0.39003801345825195,
0.4877471327781677,
-0.7232632637023926,
0.635265052318573,
-0.26317694783210754,
-1.0342410802841187,
0.07821208983659744,
-0.48255467414855957,
-1.1474015712738037,
0.27671390771865845,
-0.5813175439834595,
-0.4579612612724304,
0.1913321614265442,
0.02028353326022625,
-0.15905019640922546,
0.24816252291202545,
-0.5247102975845337,
0.55146723985672,
-0.40791085362434387,
-0.6990394592285156,
-0.09851457178592682,
-0.5329709649085999,
0.3691125512123108,
-0.11677516996860504,
0.16366490721702576,
-0.2748122811317444,
-0.09948372095823288,
0.7865967750549316,
-0.1414496898651123,
0.7414165735244751,
0.23193040490150452,
-0.3959057331085205,
0.4860035479068756,
0.32717639207839966,
0.3306969106197357,
0.055218882858753204,
-0.4386163055896759,
0.11054632812738419,
0.1053004041314125,
-0.4192560315132141,
-0.4784547984600067,
0.7240914106369019,
-0.5782918334007263,
-0.9377660155296326,
-0.5959171056747437,
-0.3547552824020386,
-0.36336562037467957,
0.13233108818531036,
0.2750789523124695,
0.2966141700744629,
-0.35144755244255066,
0.3267160654067993,
0.8125717043876648,
-0.2928432822227478,
0.13274985551834106,
0.7771714329719543,
-0.4132406413555145,
-0.20644785463809967,
0.6479871869087219,
0.030920233577489853,
0.3359978199005127,
0.5141687989234924,
0.4425569176673889,
-0.6008020639419556,
-0.5917350649833679,
-0.3299427330493927,
0.2476092129945755,
-0.8284473419189453,
-0.17286142706871033,
-0.6166982054710388,
-0.19440771639347076,
-0.41957536339759827,
0.15453410148620605,
-0.18827499449253082,
-0.3919309079647064,
-0.43362414836883545,
-0.0024799772072583437,
0.35690927505493164,
0.9438363909721375,
0.13346846401691437,
0.12925972044467926,
-0.7387279272079468,
0.33791106939315796,
0.41926515102386475,
0.10076268762350082,
-0.3473639190196991,
-0.7841601371765137,
-0.010313373059034348,
0.18491123616695404,
-0.3172477185726166,
-1.2032190561294556,
0.26724404096603394,
0.12692248821258545,
0.6486485600471497,
0.34595856070518494,
0.1674090176820755,
0.3914520740509033,
-0.2739754319190979,
0.8871579766273499,
-0.12866538763046265,
-0.6918179988861084,
0.3870742917060852,
-0.5538557767868042,
0.09038682281970978,
0.5773303508758545,
0.8959827423095703,
-0.6370359659194946,
-0.4843488037586212,
-0.5056731700897217,
-0.5103355050086975,
0.2815619707107544,
0.21377170085906982,
0.0066953194327652454,
-0.08565414696931839,
0.5581514835357666,
0.29289063811302185,
0.25907468795776367,
-0.8715710639953613,
-0.20913861691951752,
-0.051908764988183975,
-0.30460023880004883,
0.3299466073513031,
-0.5963049530982971,
-0.3687460124492645,
0.0759960263967514,
0.5136693120002747,
-0.15280020236968994,
-0.030744750052690506,
0.1206686720252037,
0.06055458262562752,
-0.10345623642206192,
0.3911066949367523,
0.6461015343666077,
0.5655017495155334,
-0.18387247622013092,
0.4593450427055359,
0.16517511010169983,
-0.44228842854499817,
0.1746779829263687,
0.055889811366796494,
-0.21348822116851807,
0.09882841259241104,
0.5739662051200867,
0.6613115668296814,
0.00742492126300931,
-0.8901513814926147,
0.4911048114299774,
-0.09340764582157135,
-0.04539337381720543,
-0.03270016983151436,
0.14962448179721832,
0.18600015342235565,
0.18056359887123108,
0.5857505798339844,
-0.015525022521615028,
0.37970027327537537,
-0.8682708740234375,
0.23899266123771667,
0.529159426689148,
-0.29057395458221436,
-0.4089549779891968,
0.7001160979270935,
0.052793510258197784,
-0.2720847725868225,
0.35566002130508423,
-0.01490053441375494,
-0.6298219561576843,
0.5301491618156433,
0.4882204532623291,
0.6376595497131348,
-0.10573377460241318,
0.041346412152051926,
0.18066303431987762,
0.18300269544124603,
-0.12367081642150879,
0.32962334156036377,
0.24363167583942413,
-0.802661120891571,
-0.5100301504135132,
-0.6927801370620728,
-0.6861969828605652,
0.06622418761253357,
-0.4728749394416809,
0.2904517650604248,
-0.2862645089626312,
-0.3122013807296753,
-0.03741827607154846,
0.09211947023868561,
-0.2906166911125183,
0.4620961844921112,
0.3258228302001953,
0.8053939938545227,
-0.9630126357078552,
0.7859808802604675,
0.7552151083946228,
-0.3656575679779053,
-0.4870245158672333,
0.26865243911743164,
0.35012856125831604,
-0.8156578540802002,
0.5944200158119202,
-0.014949972741305828,
-0.18390856683254242,
-0.319213330745697,
-0.7031084299087524,
-0.9748490452766418,
0.8060611486434937,
0.6643797159194946,
-0.5573351383209229,
0.048846300691366196,
0.05716520920395851,
0.68857342004776,
-0.25882628560066223,
0.43770089745521545,
0.2811145782470703,
0.33381885290145874,
0.35249221324920654,
-0.8325586318969727,
0.2448548823595047,
-0.22697897255420685,
-0.2819438576698303,
-0.04757789149880409,
-0.47459015250205994,
0.8244408369064331,
-0.05096276104450226,
-0.3492186665534973,
-0.051813118159770966,
0.677676796913147,
0.39732983708381653,
0.5684080123901367,
0.394029438495636,
0.5509018301963806,
0.9332674741744995,
-0.0849987119436264,
1.1723662614822388,
-0.33626964688301086,
0.21653319895267487,
1.1297175884246826,
-0.3147343099117279,
0.9606605768203735,
0.4938853681087494,
-0.2397862672805786,
0.7774578332901001,
0.9544040560722351,
0.09290973842144012,
0.36455175280570984,
0.0980401560664177,
-0.28757038712501526,
-0.5093541741371155,
-0.5229097604751587,
-0.21950343251228333,
0.37177568674087524,
0.5161840915679932,
-0.3585747182369232,
-0.12524470686912537,
-0.13619238138198853,
0.16224801540374756,
0.4287453889846802,
-0.04692646861076355,
0.7222012877464294,
0.22744092345237732,
-0.8865635395050049,
0.567510724067688,
-0.16182737052440643,
0.5728344917297363,
-0.5239115357398987,
0.01875855214893818,
-0.308758020401001,
-0.20767490565776825,
-0.351181298494339,
-1.1296418905258179,
0.3351649045944214,
0.05653466284275055,
-0.1704135537147522,
-0.07613423466682434,
0.8452928066253662,
-0.35296621918678284,
-0.21193252503871918,
0.22081534564495087,
0.6583141684532166,
0.2518489956855774,
-0.15201683342456818,
-0.7621970772743225,
0.17198021709918976,
0.13453440368175507,
-0.24487702548503876,
0.46475499868392944,
0.6768543720245361,
-0.03627818450331688,
0.9381186962127686,
0.852241039276123,
0.26341354846954346,
-0.10165214538574219,
-0.06835918873548508,
0.9730270504951477,
-0.763432502746582,
0.12577706575393677,
-0.9421228766441345,
0.32863175868988037,
-0.12791474163532257,
-0.22764801979064941,
1.0392191410064697,
0.6074040532112122,
0.42944657802581787,
0.35117143392562866,
0.5108547806739807,
0.15044602751731873,
0.6730408072471619,
-0.7256674766540527,
0.7500956654548645,
-0.8490750789642334,
0.5714865326881409,
0.07889306545257568,
-0.5893111228942871,
-0.22978153824806213,
0.3083593249320984,
-0.45773884654045105,
0.14021649956703186,
0.6543126106262207,
0.723911464214325,
0.018386853858828545,
0.15311066806316376,
0.34898650646209717,
0.4861336648464203,
0.34025096893310547,
0.2803516983985901,
1.1555341482162476,
-0.3985147178173065,
0.4331803321838379,
0.056746408343315125,
0.11241611838340759,
-0.32380661368370056,
-1.0276806354522705,
-0.8058550357818604,
-0.5422520637512207,
-0.3998343348503113,
-0.673592209815979,
0.1361350417137146,
0.8840341567993164,
0.32007887959480286,
-0.9648610949516296,
-0.21728435158729553,
0.013701575808227062,
0.2826325297355652,
0.33054912090301514,
-0.16357150673866272,
0.16472381353378296,
-0.15140216052532196,
-0.7062588334083557,
0.5286852717399597,
0.12473224848508835,
-0.008090361021459103,
-0.15712256729602814,
0.12567636370658875,
-0.5300427675247192,
0.4733659625053406,
0.3522353768348694,
0.32517001032829285,
-0.947939932346344,
-0.2680381238460541,
0.09725388139486313,
-0.4888412654399872,
0.010939452797174454,
0.6488056182861328,
-0.8030815124511719,
0.38131529092788696,
0.5128279328346252,
0.6364048719406128,
0.31184816360473633,
0.23619163036346436,
0.5841904878616333,
-0.5654048323631287,
-0.14707733690738678,
0.36555618047714233,
0.4512379467487335,
0.5589790940284729,
-0.36760666966438293,
0.5105313062667847,
0.3324504494667053,
-0.8291400074958801,
-0.932060956954956,
0.18647989630699158,
-0.9334827661514282,
-0.4695587158203125,
1.4545915126800537,
-0.02104516513645649,
-0.38602137565612793,
-0.3990705609321594,
-0.2635025084018707,
0.005161420442163944,
-0.29323887825012207,
0.8897297978401184,
0.9284202456474304,
-0.2575119137763977,
-0.10808658599853516,
-0.6203205585479736,
0.7130220532417297,
0.60915207862854,
-0.5556226372718811,
0.03178035095334053,
0.4692275822162628,
0.4116232395172119,
0.17946776747703552,
0.48588234186172485,
0.09058414399623871,
0.13379351794719696,
-0.03528936207294464,
-0.28477025032043457,
0.3429640233516693,
0.017196808010339737,
-0.3303012251853943,
0.18766941130161285,
0.4345242977142334,
0.31436070799827576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11777v1 | Uncovering Latent Human Wellbeing in Language Model Embeddings | 2024-02-19T02:08:03 | 2024-02-19T02:08:03 | Pedro Freire, ChengCheng Tan, Adam Gleave, Dan Hendrycks, Scott Emmons | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Do language models implicitly learn a concept of human wellbeing? We explore
this through the ETHICS Utilitarianism task, assessing if scaling enhances
pretrained models' representations. Our initial finding reveals that, without
any prompt engineering or finetuning, the leading principal component from
OpenAI's text-embedding-ada-002 achieves 73.9% accuracy. This closely matches
the 74.6% of BERT-large finetuned on the entire ETHICS dataset, suggesting
pretraining conveys some understanding about human wellbeing. Next, we consider
four language model families, observing how Utilitarianism accuracy varies with
increased parameters. We find performance is nondecreasing with increased model
size when using sufficient numbers of principal components. | [
0.1872549057006836,
-0.4652872085571289,
0.6070919632911682,
0.022703880444169044,
-0.007267840672284365,
-0.14587996900081635,
-0.155922994017601,
-0.438698947429657,
-0.11986825615167618,
0.30139943957328796,
-0.36000341176986694,
-0.23575471341609955,
-0.6373537182807922,
-0.1640244871377945,
0.12201190739870071,
0.841861367225647,
0.345904141664505,
0.418747216463089,
-0.03901298716664314,
-0.29274746775627136,
-0.2589755356311798,
-0.6384597420692444,
-0.5233253836631775,
-0.4736618101596832,
0.6061750054359436,
0.3145707845687866,
0.870984673500061,
0.5350976586341858,
0.039478693157434464,
0.10800842940807343,
-0.1421521157026291,
-0.35810521245002747,
-0.7744481563568115,
0.03115701489150524,
-0.20284484326839447,
-0.7068774700164795,
-0.5487868189811707,
0.4512188732624054,
0.4611102044582367,
0.8776635527610779,
-0.16615082323551178,
0.35497361421585083,
0.4543410539627075,
0.33865514397621155,
-0.8093950152397156,
0.10824593901634216,
-0.09390772134065628,
0.17354410886764526,
-0.03606236353516579,
-0.04141545668244362,
-0.5474620461463928,
-0.46243077516555786,
0.08862338960170746,
-0.5405640006065369,
-0.23850350081920624,
0.06328486651182175,
0.6956978440284729,
0.559966504573822,
-0.6438472270965576,
-0.05987544357776642,
-0.4549407958984375,
1.2814379930496216,
-0.7709438800811768,
0.49213331937789917,
0.7526271939277649,
-0.34767794609069824,
0.12379555404186249,
-0.6233636736869812,
-0.432573139667511,
-0.12381935864686966,
-0.17031115293502808,
-0.007528653834015131,
-0.23714032769203186,
0.3543848395347595,
0.38962677121162415,
0.43069860339164734,
-0.24557185173034668,
0.5073155760765076,
-0.012482383288443089,
-0.010426673106849194,
0.4113152325153351,
-0.025821425020694733,
0.47631943225860596,
-0.41175878047943115,
0.07904177159070969,
-0.12894712388515472,
-0.9494432806968689,
0.40050727128982544,
0.4608292579650879,
0.3376253843307495,
-0.17467725276947021,
0.528412938117981,
0.34631988406181335,
0.07206952571868896,
-0.21987392008304596,
0.051770053803920746,
0.30225709080696106,
-0.12175364792346954,
-0.16693387925624847,
-0.026675991714000702,
0.4011191129684448,
0.2868606448173523,
0.4335770606994629,
-0.08331464976072311,
-0.27631717920303345,
-0.08220116049051285,
0.4494357407093048,
-0.9799107909202576,
-0.24319018423557281,
0.16433967649936676,
-0.7032665610313416,
-0.3848258852958679,
-0.002910611219704151,
-0.39902302622795105,
-0.4179934561252594,
-0.4421404004096985,
0.26429155468940735,
-0.3487403392791748,
-0.42556172609329224,
0.013103547506034374,
0.28972452878952026,
0.35941269993782043,
0.09853558987379074,
-1.1633048057556152,
0.03829702362418175,
0.8666258454322815,
0.5911860466003418,
0.35103490948677063,
0.020091161131858826,
-0.8645994663238525,
-0.046383198350667953,
-0.36548927426338196,
0.3495083153247833,
-0.9612302184104919,
-0.5073310732841492,
-0.05642448365688324,
0.11124257743358612,
0.03997829183936119,
-0.1785343587398529,
0.8022676706314087,
-0.209595188498497,
0.14586758613586426,
-0.7162894606590271,
-0.46900177001953125,
-0.1605062633752823,
-0.026962781324982643,
-0.5703859925270081,
1.0489498376846313,
-0.01778552494943142,
-0.7622153759002686,
0.6007838845252991,
-0.897122323513031,
-0.43867042660713196,
-0.00732676824554801,
-0.28953230381011963,
-0.35598647594451904,
0.48129215836524963,
0.089870385825634,
0.6444385051727295,
-0.05168186500668526,
0.24335287511348724,
-0.5775946974754333,
-0.13691821694374084,
0.07723972201347351,
-0.47883522510528564,
1.094232439994812,
0.19684052467346191,
-0.3522862493991852,
-0.002479281509295106,
-0.5038718581199646,
0.07558724284172058,
0.13132402300834656,
-0.18243557214736938,
-0.7714179754257202,
0.06276866793632507,
0.2245611548423767,
0.24134987592697144,
0.2508509159088135,
-0.7827038168907166,
-0.04974287375807762,
-0.36826756596565247,
0.4250059127807617,
1.1466319561004639,
-0.0848330706357956,
0.4155416488647461,
-0.13413213193416595,
0.4869231879711151,
-0.2885097861289978,
0.13265587389469147,
0.056614700704813004,
-0.514817476272583,
-0.4084637463092804,
-0.24638722836971283,
0.3739892840385437,
0.4217723608016968,
-0.13433465361595154,
0.6246232390403748,
-0.08422363549470901,
-0.02600919082760811,
-0.679751455783844,
0.11414482444524765,
0.5550591945648193,
0.3361934721469879,
0.1683027595281601,
-0.31539204716682434,
-0.21915461122989655,
-0.8934657573699951,
-0.40130776166915894,
-0.16889390349388123,
-0.14713598787784576,
0.2857433557510376,
0.6504902243614197,
-0.19293683767318726,
0.686037003993988,
-0.34504860639572144,
0.03570467233657837,
-0.061436060816049576,
0.5246422290802002,
-0.29302358627319336,
0.7606601715087891,
0.7542269229888916,
-0.823697030544281,
-0.05160069465637207,
-0.2547990083694458,
-0.8548830151557922,
0.08569973707199097,
0.21698357164859772,
-0.04100000113248825,
0.016974089667201042,
0.1044725626707077,
-0.2073957771062851,
0.3601919412612915,
0.5097883343696594,
-0.6070650219917297,
0.35811498761177063,
-0.46736299991607666,
-0.024782933294773102,
-1.2097214460372925,
0.3247273564338684,
0.006744749378412962,
-0.3537553548812866,
-0.5793249011039734,
0.05408738553524017,
0.10569598525762558,
-0.07677602767944336,
-0.40899771451950073,
0.32786110043525696,
-0.39201581478118896,
-0.15604589879512787,
-0.14863182604312897,
-0.15923981368541718,
-0.09495005756616592,
0.2893839180469513,
-0.1834966540336609,
0.8434181213378906,
0.5122347474098206,
-0.33751675486564636,
-0.2299659103155136,
0.18502742052078247,
-0.2321643829345703,
0.6815179586410522,
-0.8367302417755127,
0.2819957137107849,
-0.2284160554409027,
0.017627906054258347,
-0.6943584084510803,
-0.21629957854747772,
-0.18830062448978424,
-0.47175848484039307,
0.08588960766792297,
-0.00468957144767046,
-0.6602275371551514,
-0.20753589272499084,
-0.3410891592502594,
0.36029741168022156,
0.7509063482284546,
-0.4527025520801544,
0.4183124303817749,
0.7524152994155884,
-0.45760735869407654,
-0.6878833770751953,
-0.7223032116889954,
-0.16289548575878143,
-0.19699405133724213,
-0.4311928451061249,
0.09470655769109726,
0.10177440196275711,
-0.2919286787509918,
0.04332280904054642,
-0.05660344287753105,
0.03289542347192764,
0.5696815848350525,
0.3136303722858429,
0.14922986924648285,
-0.20918303728103638,
0.44441890716552734,
0.07243319600820541,
-0.1660444438457489,
0.26462796330451965,
-0.14038270711898804,
0.30246472358703613,
-0.3574783205986023,
-0.30954110622406006,
-0.6067934036254883,
0.3656361401081085,
0.35044556856155396,
-0.5099439024925232,
0.9317994713783264,
0.43888214230537415,
-0.807770311832428,
0.26512929797172546,
-0.3612521290779114,
-0.40776100754737854,
-0.46983233094215393,
0.28191518783569336,
-0.1532427966594696,
-1.1339558362960815,
0.5724367499351501,
-0.02419366128742695,
0.1665070652961731,
0.5400516986846924,
0.347542405128479,
-0.27732113003730774,
1.2922508716583252,
1.2261993885040283,
-0.012201772071421146,
0.5560885071754456,
-0.32002246379852295,
0.2017846703529358,
-0.8044613003730774,
0.08076133579015732,
-0.611013650894165,
-0.2732914090156555,
-0.8439860939979553,
-0.21479153633117676,
0.0772731751203537,
0.18437951803207397,
-0.5353813171386719,
-0.06925536692142487,
-0.2304055243730545,
0.41142022609710693,
0.47780612111091614,
0.0982084721326828,
0.1959417313337326,
-0.2719305455684662,
-0.12610767781734467,
-0.2620678246021271,
-0.28983062505722046,
-1.016736388206482,
1.1818065643310547,
0.5519123673439026,
0.9596109390258789,
0.16498014330863953,
0.6936102509498596,
0.3640381693840027,
0.578980028629303,
-0.41921326518058777,
0.09447367489337921,
-0.16076917946338654,
-0.50543212890625,
-0.42319726943969727,
-0.4054255783557892,
-1.0746885538101196,
-0.07479174435138702,
-0.17584167420864105,
-1.077149510383606,
0.45491254329681396,
0.13184042274951935,
-0.7542267441749573,
0.34393996000289917,
-0.6710839867591858,
1.0703773498535156,
-0.4578688442707062,
-0.3577691614627838,
-0.6203036904335022,
-0.7421226501464844,
-0.011221274733543396,
0.0018703409004956484,
0.11569090187549591,
-0.23810239136219025,
0.1242453083395958,
1.120597004890442,
-0.23114384710788727,
1.018560767173767,
-0.4659751057624817,
-0.3281945288181305,
-0.04923824965953827,
-0.26324865221977234,
0.4133315980434418,
0.08940361440181732,
-0.20367106795310974,
-0.0789700448513031,
0.07107274234294891,
-0.7396354675292969,
-0.5333730578422546,
0.7333547472953796,
-0.847744882106781,
-0.4722415804862976,
-0.21759098768234253,
-0.312218576669693,
-0.3324902057647705,
0.4823693335056305,
-0.04105038568377495,
0.5059962868690491,
-0.4780414402484894,
0.563258707523346,
0.8515344262123108,
-0.37465208768844604,
0.1846330314874649,
0.31609904766082764,
0.006734497379511595,
-0.023804403841495514,
0.6093588471412659,
0.0862431675195694,
0.28918007016181946,
0.23614740371704102,
0.2850150465965271,
-0.5381636023521423,
-0.0394931323826313,
-0.17089803516864777,
0.24099549651145935,
-0.6376520395278931,
0.08033224940299988,
-0.7535896897315979,
0.16421614587306976,
-0.39200228452682495,
-0.27268168330192566,
-0.6598483324050903,
-0.2453909069299698,
-0.5617637038230896,
-0.4512179493904114,
0.1326691061258316,
1.2130353450775146,
-0.30518829822540283,
0.1975058913230896,
-0.5705346465110779,
0.09721370041370392,
0.505948543548584,
0.5881361365318298,
0.1296088546514511,
-0.4339604675769806,
-0.1294323056936264,
0.5145454406738281,
-0.4730697572231293,
-0.5159655809402466,
0.15483175218105316,
0.128714919090271,
0.7976865172386169,
0.6940893530845642,
0.33184877038002014,
0.38638851046562195,
-0.3071274161338806,
0.8068491220474243,
0.27088630199432373,
-1.0200728178024292,
0.6390025615692139,
-0.26179787516593933,
-0.09633661061525345,
0.667372465133667,
0.573878288269043,
-0.3897574245929718,
-0.2137400209903717,
-0.7099222540855408,
-0.6086370348930359,
0.6357776522636414,
0.21641497313976288,
0.47036534547805786,
0.11974258720874786,
0.3374864459037781,
0.21390852332115173,
-0.06765058636665344,
-0.8486366868019104,
-0.22916243970394135,
-0.2993543744087219,
-0.2889820635318756,
-0.27437037229537964,
-0.4942791163921356,
0.008252025581896305,
-0.3041435480117798,
0.461831271648407,
-0.05944127216935158,
0.42490360140800476,
-0.0823000892996788,
-0.29687872529029846,
-0.1421816498041153,
0.43293535709381104,
0.38967373967170715,
0.7183281779289246,
-0.3668178617954254,
0.19546478986740112,
-0.026345539838075638,
-0.4619932174682617,
0.32041481137275696,
0.12091154605150223,
0.2904714047908783,
-0.5219013094902039,
0.36043915152549744,
0.815152108669281,
0.5159397125244141,
-0.49927493929862976,
0.7579259276390076,
-0.04139420762658119,
0.21747519075870514,
-0.17574794590473175,
0.11923546344041824,
0.1500633805990219,
0.22434110939502716,
0.5314698219299316,
-0.17138858139514923,
0.1659935712814331,
-0.7823259234428406,
0.20510059595108032,
0.27660661935806274,
-0.6167854070663452,
-0.6931906342506409,
0.8366946578025818,
0.33182674646377563,
-0.3474833071231842,
0.7558658123016357,
-0.18710047006607056,
-0.3759564161300659,
0.3319253623485565,
0.34261393547058105,
0.9001659154891968,
-0.4247663617134094,
0.06706221401691437,
0.2231239676475525,
0.36088287830352783,
-0.14732839167118073,
0.466640442609787,
-0.05534490570425987,
-0.7306446433067322,
-0.6334649324417114,
-0.6020635962486267,
-0.3525502383708954,
-0.015345516614615917,
-1.0529674291610718,
-0.17915190756320953,
-0.16009049117565155,
-0.2522136867046356,
-0.1311572939157486,
0.02914511412382126,
-0.7977257370948792,
0.2512633204460144,
0.14759057760238647,
0.4796202778816223,
-0.9956064224243164,
0.8856361508369446,
0.7383485436439514,
-0.7157372832298279,
-0.9198135137557983,
0.3939349949359894,
-0.20770543813705444,
-0.6487317085266113,
0.7108590602874756,
0.4837159812450409,
-0.21340876817703247,
0.24029336869716644,
-0.5684574246406555,
-0.6527631282806396,
1.1466765403747559,
0.7781047224998474,
-0.07360530644655228,
-0.1731608510017395,
0.11739187687635422,
0.47169163823127747,
-0.2686396837234497,
0.1890426129102707,
0.38671740889549255,
0.41113588213920593,
-0.4062204360961914,
-0.8839797973632812,
0.07427076250314713,
-0.36913931369781494,
0.047236859798431396,
-0.19599390029907227,
-0.36717554926872253,
0.8630101680755615,
-0.49431097507476807,
-0.4592341184616089,
-0.131211519241333,
0.5703980326652527,
0.0010739266872406006,
-0.048364780843257904,
0.518815815448761,
0.7483313083648682,
1.193453311920166,
0.0562877282500267,
1.3415364027023315,
-0.30469954013824463,
0.5985180735588074,
0.7912898659706116,
-0.12562336027622223,
0.840924859046936,
0.303512841463089,
-0.18436993658542633,
0.4629894495010376,
0.7288587093353271,
0.5636131763458252,
0.6245278120040894,
-0.0319921113550663,
-0.06497493386268616,
-0.5301697254180908,
-0.334026575088501,
-0.36358270049095154,
0.3801220655441284,
0.24933384358882904,
-0.49700602889060974,
-0.1344471573829651,
0.3610919117927551,
0.15776532888412476,
-0.008727461099624634,
-0.2535087764263153,
0.5300339460372925,
0.4728570282459259,
-0.33994707465171814,
0.41264608502388,
-0.026587028056383133,
0.7354806661605835,
-0.2693946659564972,
-0.03524184226989746,
-0.05757074058055878,
0.20281153917312622,
0.049502111971378326,
-0.8654947280883789,
0.23782439529895782,
0.02478364296257496,
-0.04483317583799362,
-0.5375067591667175,
0.6045712232589722,
-0.10637283325195312,
-0.36669474840164185,
0.39108380675315857,
0.5143991112709045,
0.16021454334259033,
0.06608660519123077,
-0.5593894720077515,
-0.2677227854728699,
-0.13535092771053314,
-0.47200432419776917,
0.28891900181770325,
0.37654465436935425,
0.016608020290732384,
0.6397414803504944,
0.5965638160705566,
-0.15154771506786346,
-0.08225826174020767,
0.10839081555604935,
0.6397597789764404,
-0.7616869211196899,
-0.767259418964386,
-0.8381853699684143,
0.6391259431838989,
-0.13128381967544556,
-0.4737603962421417,
0.4809891879558563,
0.38306620717048645,
0.6513582468032837,
0.06467488408088684,
0.7070485353469849,
0.016523374244570732,
0.15675438940525055,
-0.44163942337036133,
1.037980318069458,
-0.7431036233901978,
-0.04310734570026398,
-0.30012455582618713,
-0.6162148118019104,
-0.2503114938735962,
1.018394112586975,
-0.7854753136634827,
0.12247247993946075,
0.4047265350818634,
0.6977359652519226,
-0.28448960185050964,
0.31521156430244446,
0.4943714439868927,
0.1271485686302185,
0.2783723473548889,
0.328056663274765,
0.6872889995574951,
-0.0317399837076664,
-0.17858047783374786,
-0.12285444885492325,
-0.34270942211151123,
-0.1951821744441986,
-0.9029595851898193,
-0.8042436838150024,
-0.6560378074645996,
-0.20252470672130585,
-0.018678702414035797,
0.0870879590511322,
1.0367051362991333,
0.8185034394264221,
-0.7341302633285522,
0.06294004619121552,
-0.0713900625705719,
0.05388680845499039,
-0.09434909373521805,
-0.18386372923851013,
0.44301125407218933,
-0.3413078486919403,
-0.4220409691333771,
0.03274250030517578,
0.12682485580444336,
-0.0336865670979023,
-0.4551015794277191,
-0.24300001561641693,
-0.31310269236564636,
0.14769956469535828,
0.6435527205467224,
0.14726103842258453,
-0.7042553424835205,
-0.7059021592140198,
-0.3360908329486847,
-0.3055614233016968,
0.027819007635116577,
0.7613973021507263,
-0.2425183653831482,
0.24470758438110352,
0.06793931126594543,
0.7218294739723206,
0.08134761452674866,
0.009041647426784039,
0.6559332013130188,
-0.7645089626312256,
0.2092193067073822,
0.3619251847267151,
0.6044042110443115,
0.396065354347229,
-0.588318407535553,
0.42202338576316833,
0.021488817408680916,
-0.5845514535903931,
-0.9407467246055603,
0.14421047270298004,
-0.5935544371604919,
0.0028004483319818974,
0.9628285765647888,
-0.5369992256164551,
-0.30713653564453125,
-0.016762958839535713,
-0.07508886605501175,
0.33690348267555237,
-0.4181218147277832,
0.4562223553657532,
0.5463769435882568,
-0.05390005186200142,
-0.28580987453460693,
-0.6567885875701904,
0.4823469817638397,
0.737079381942749,
-0.7371363043785095,
0.23572592437267303,
0.4417940378189087,
0.45553895831108093,
0.13513165712356567,
0.4841531813144684,
-0.046684976667165756,
0.2075439989566803,
-0.13628515601158142,
0.2788448631763458,
0.21292223036289215,
0.04778469726443291,
-0.2650619447231293,
0.0561402402818203,
0.3534737229347229,
-0.0861368402838707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11770v2 | Structured Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Few-Shot Generation of Content-Grounded QA Conversations | 2024-02-19T01:49:53 | 2024-02-20T02:55:57 | Md Arafat Sultan, Jatin Ganhotra, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a structured chain-of-thought (SCoT) prompting approach to
generating content-grounded multi-turn question-answer conversations using a
pre-trained large language model (LLM). At the core of our proposal is a
structured breakdown of the complex task into a number of states in a state
machine, so that actions corresponding to various subtasks, e.g., content
reading and utterance generation, can be executed in their own dedicated
states. Each state leverages a unique set of resources including prompts and
(optionally) additional tools to augment the generation process. Our
experimental results show that SCoT prompting with designated states for
hallucination mitigation increases agent faithfulness to grounding documents by
up to 16.8%. When used as training data, our open-domain conversations
synthesized from only 6 Wikipedia-based seed demonstrations train strong
conversational QA agents; in out-of-domain evaluation, for example, we observe
improvements of up to 13.9% over target domain gold data when the latter is
augmented with our generated examples. | [
-0.4735625088214874,
-1.2204878330230713,
0.846959114074707,
-0.11444225907325745,
-0.49944427609443665,
0.021014157682657242,
-0.10767271369695663,
-0.05164240673184395,
0.5875283479690552,
0.6892642378807068,
-0.8679096698760986,
-0.4493287205696106,
0.024236449971795082,
0.08940322697162628,
-0.2631092071533203,
1.2020909786224365,
0.14826896786689758,
-0.021467292681336403,
-0.19520451128482819,
0.06511950492858887,
-0.609951913356781,
-0.5717386603355408,
-0.5199346542358398,
-0.36177971959114075,
0.6753544211387634,
0.6451712846755981,
0.502631425857544,
0.2073562741279602,
0.21649472415447235,
0.18677011132240295,
-0.17285719513893127,
0.5030002593994141,
-0.7958695888519287,
0.6087043881416321,
-0.3203933537006378,
-0.33785122632980347,
-0.538616955280304,
-0.10208941996097565,
0.4578813910484314,
0.5605289936065674,
-0.3171519339084625,
0.28241604566574097,
0.0036722312215715647,
0.8092247247695923,
-0.8258216977119446,
-0.05331925302743912,
-0.9176004528999329,
-0.07784254848957062,
0.3068343997001648,
-0.6481080055236816,
-0.7112912535667419,
-0.36837613582611084,
0.1701725870370865,
-0.5728621482849121,
-0.061330005526542664,
-0.016473302617669106,
0.6966930627822876,
0.19898085296154022,
-0.45808249711990356,
-0.3745500147342682,
-0.7470629811286926,
0.341438353061676,
-0.4371434450149536,
0.2640349566936493,
0.34813007712364197,
-0.027237046509981155,
-0.4321472942829132,
-0.6892718076705933,
-0.8983483910560608,
-0.038993436843156815,
0.23738254606723785,
0.36621251702308655,
-0.08595135807991028,
0.23660610616207123,
0.3505097031593323,
0.3013691306114197,
-0.41839632391929626,
-0.32525599002838135,
-0.3965039849281311,
0.17617672681808472,
0.5219213962554932,
0.20857790112495422,
-0.000013207499250711408,
-0.09657495468854904,
-0.17087456583976746,
-0.208783820271492,
-0.828041136264801,
0.06099053844809532,
0.3368947207927704,
0.33002781867980957,
0.25190991163253784,
0.7433878779411316,
-0.5691989064216614,
0.48947155475616455,
0.47014638781547546,
-0.056287430226802826,
-0.04178275913000107,
-0.5020230412483215,
-0.33876582980155945,
0.0860092043876648,
0.6906611919403076,
0.292371928691864,
0.2349187135696411,
0.15560826659202576,
-0.0721547082066536,
0.16277939081192017,
0.6554859280586243,
-0.8581712245941162,
-0.3856469392776489,
0.545218288898468,
-0.18786115944385529,
-0.31169965863227844,
0.08826415240764618,
-0.33010318875312805,
-0.27735263109207153,
-0.2599101960659027,
0.3305697441101074,
-0.35654106736183167,
-0.20734301209449768,
0.23050227761268616,
-0.11745065450668335,
0.36135244369506836,
0.12955085933208466,
-0.7502625584602356,
0.24736790359020233,
0.4734576344490051,
0.44522708654403687,
-0.15937983989715576,
-0.1618649959564209,
-0.8209331631660461,
0.24212977290153503,
-0.6264240145683289,
1.0227786302566528,
-0.37562721967697144,
-0.2554406523704529,
0.24126160144805908,
-0.10047605633735657,
0.12038032710552216,
-0.4369044005870819,
0.1887364387512207,
-0.6799265742301941,
0.18076463043689728,
-0.3427942395210266,
-0.3232002854347229,
0.0759730413556099,
0.8321303129196167,
-0.47908487915992737,
1.240799903869629,
0.0013937895419076085,
-0.7319426536560059,
0.37842801213264465,
-0.4892842471599579,
-0.4754422903060913,
0.15731199085712433,
-0.3385494649410248,
-0.22660315036773682,
0.033098556101322174,
0.3157535195350647,
0.40055614709854126,
0.05038557946681976,
0.2685466408729553,
-0.14082492887973785,
-0.27215567231178284,
0.5457989573478699,
-0.25456684827804565,
0.24808740615844727,
0.1090468242764473,
-0.3079298138618469,
0.5058767795562744,
-0.7531331181526184,
0.520893394947052,
0.021370779722929,
-0.3020266592502594,
-0.2687259018421173,
-0.03848724067211151,
-0.27832114696502686,
0.5497772097587585,
-0.1333107352256775,
-0.2803492844104767,
0.3149357736110687,
-0.5701078772544861,
0.38826003670692444,
0.7221090793609619,
0.6997331976890564,
0.42790234088897705,
-0.4311582148075104,
0.7172391414642334,
0.3247024714946747,
0.1589251309633255,
-0.6157715320587158,
-0.45428842306137085,
-0.8834855556488037,
-0.1297111213207245,
-0.1689961850643158,
0.4363325536251068,
-1.1076093912124634,
0.5278395414352417,
-0.2678028643131256,
-0.4027717113494873,
-0.4360942542552948,
-0.007736328989267349,
0.42628368735313416,
0.5164952874183655,
0.35326912999153137,
-0.38293489813804626,
-0.2270200401544571,
-0.6373156309127808,
0.06657730787992477,
-0.3944573998451233,
0.07025748491287231,
0.09534364938735962,
0.5630176067352295,
0.07191640883684158,
0.9983641505241394,
-0.6240913271903992,
0.015516277402639389,
-0.4527682960033417,
0.0024077887646853924,
0.0110423369333148,
0.36518821120262146,
-0.15961499512195587,
-0.4612814486026764,
-0.35842883586883545,
-0.26503652334213257,
-0.6941433548927307,
0.3210229277610779,
-0.25399893522262573,
-0.5766236782073975,
0.03589994087815285,
0.3683771789073944,
-0.8539422750473022,
0.37720349431037903,
0.3559878468513489,
-0.17323479056358337,
0.5415679812431335,
0.006643199827522039,
0.24970698356628418,
-1.3340157270431519,
-0.17327530682086945,
-0.4553866684436798,
-0.0902058556675911,
-0.682580292224884,
0.15186640620231628,
-0.19816157221794128,
-0.34008118510246277,
-0.8385013341903687,
0.3612613379955292,
-0.29384738206863403,
-0.03067994862794876,
-0.3029516339302063,
0.4536719024181366,
0.16468533873558044,
0.791871190071106,
0.11020594835281372,
0.9207760691642761,
0.33856433629989624,
-0.7929534316062927,
0.004769343417137861,
0.7841397523880005,
-0.08356454223394394,
0.8107078075408936,
-0.7510285377502441,
0.7214697003364563,
-0.1478825807571411,
0.6548241376876831,
-0.8870890140533447,
-0.15333805978298187,
0.41106000542640686,
-0.18846996128559113,
-0.17565900087356567,
-0.02119901217520237,
-0.5069165825843811,
-0.2636042535305023,
-0.41907230019569397,
0.44796818494796753,
0.43140026926994324,
-0.3491404056549072,
0.2823869287967682,
0.16170048713684082,
-0.21410401165485382,
-0.28132253885269165,
-0.4843567907810211,
0.05242817476391792,
0.10243263095617294,
-0.7978488802909851,
0.15453563630580902,
-0.3573667109012604,
-0.12855350971221924,
-0.16760942339897156,
-0.27832114696502686,
-0.11279883980751038,
-0.03541789576411247,
0.43674206733703613,
0.1540718674659729,
-0.19149069488048553,
0.2976929843425751,
0.38299909234046936,
0.05112870782613754,
0.17962764203548431,
-0.6664925813674927,
0.8350081443786621,
-0.23647668957710266,
-0.4190213680267334,
-0.5787043571472168,
0.5439426898956299,
0.2863899767398834,
-0.3339965045452118,
0.6102423667907715,
0.07233113795518875,
-0.29216277599334717,
-0.3852948844432831,
-0.29806259274482727,
-0.6694343686103821,
-0.4760878384113312,
-0.07945504784584045,
-0.6042585968971252,
-1.0504443645477295,
0.3508223295211792,
-0.10180731117725372,
0.01358166616410017,
0.2143068015575409,
0.7004761099815369,
-0.33432289958000183,
1.0115301609039307,
0.39673906564712524,
0.4095740020275116,
0.42056772112846375,
-0.35702815651893616,
0.443694531917572,
-0.5364915132522583,
-0.1074996143579483,
-0.23393899202346802,
-0.06236559897661209,
-0.3669780194759369,
-0.40562739968299866,
0.49762341380119324,
0.201760932803154,
-0.0792921707034111,
0.021941393613815308,
-0.5403356552124023,
0.5833278298377991,
0.5110272169113159,
0.37377578020095825,
0.38523241877555847,
-0.0012588092358782887,
-0.11926817148923874,
0.1317780315876007,
-0.9881424903869629,
-0.7536073923110962,
0.8859530091285706,
0.15618391335010529,
0.6295831203460693,
-0.3472338020801544,
0.942586362361908,
0.18461966514587402,
0.021467505022883415,
-1.142101526260376,
0.6047942042350769,
0.5585156679153442,
-0.6086118221282959,
-0.49951982498168945,
0.017015857622027397,
-0.9135692119598389,
0.17172499001026154,
-0.3876506984233856,
-0.3062555491924286,
0.0496295765042305,
0.20172442495822906,
-0.6247683763504028,
-0.0023182141594588757,
-0.27728039026260376,
0.5598229169845581,
0.19023267924785614,
-0.24670125544071198,
-0.4101659059524536,
-0.5612263083457947,
0.4891664385795593,
0.09158669412136078,
-0.16678206622600555,
0.18254713714122772,
0.4579319655895233,
0.6489489674568176,
-0.44230708479881287,
0.7748510241508484,
0.13277491927146912,
-0.37240004539489746,
0.8856056332588196,
0.2160528600215912,
0.838798999786377,
0.07009822875261307,
0.10854919999837875,
-0.2686654329299927,
0.04129587858915329,
-0.4348510801792145,
-0.7471400499343872,
0.14214876294136047,
-0.36328932642936707,
-0.5649740695953369,
-0.2951296269893646,
-0.47662171721458435,
-0.3786191940307617,
0.1654929518699646,
0.23160120844841003,
0.3684668242931366,
-0.2630620300769806,
0.1296936571598053,
0.9180542826652527,
-0.06608078628778458,
0.09316352754831314,
0.32193300127983093,
-0.01158730499446392,
-0.5193615555763245,
0.7121956944465637,
-0.1733020395040512,
0.5798549056053162,
0.07392729073762894,
0.08965115249156952,
-0.14352944493293762,
-0.38690757751464844,
-0.30531495809555054,
0.1141062006354332,
-0.9516343474388123,
-0.25403183698654175,
-0.7585130333900452,
-0.22390151023864746,
-0.3911419212818146,
-0.21967674791812897,
-0.3155076503753662,
-0.30903109908103943,
-0.16505645215511322,
-0.45870476961135864,
0.2784678339958191,
0.821225643157959,
0.5204904675483704,
0.5834009051322937,
-0.9036446809768677,
0.3838964104652405,
0.49481216073036194,
0.03102225251495838,
-0.19062356650829315,
-0.31421011686325073,
-0.2051631659269333,
0.13847462832927704,
-0.5708677768707275,
-0.9796608090400696,
0.12517240643501282,
0.09188998490571976,
0.2516503632068634,
0.4501316547393799,
0.33875367045402527,
0.8680535554885864,
-0.5988346934318542,
1.1154866218566895,
0.2455342561006546,
-0.9416900277137756,
0.974389910697937,
-0.3547115623950958,
0.2362833172082901,
0.8028035163879395,
0.20837503671646118,
-0.42539694905281067,
-0.8855200409889221,
-0.782008945941925,
-0.677066445350647,
0.5067130327224731,
0.1474500596523285,
0.36197376251220703,
-0.6151439547538757,
0.36108601093292236,
0.10828053206205368,
0.43044114112854004,
-0.4471868872642517,
-0.07729151099920273,
-0.14753000438213348,
-0.018559716641902924,
0.5113125443458557,
-0.4324234127998352,
-0.48611846566200256,
0.05169704183936119,
0.707338809967041,
-0.6000769138336182,
0.1576518565416336,
0.4858994781970978,
-0.23142793774604797,
-0.3240228593349457,
0.6430258750915527,
0.6960063576698303,
0.92740398645401,
0.12711328268051147,
0.2166854590177536,
0.18509677052497864,
-0.3488834798336029,
0.2788510322570801,
-0.6179250478744507,
-0.37322014570236206,
-0.13748858869075775,
0.0960344448685646,
0.7550563812255859,
0.0719725638628006,
-0.5791530609130859,
0.4436299204826355,
0.10741548240184784,
-0.5063353776931763,
-0.11329097300767899,
0.16818849742412567,
-0.18932154774665833,
0.3973987400531769,
0.3408993184566498,
-0.4096871316432953,
0.03792484849691391,
-0.683426022529602,
0.40391066670417786,
0.2609972059726715,
-0.43088337779045105,
-0.26147061586380005,
0.4516758322715759,
0.35154983401298523,
-0.26743337512016296,
0.7299336791038513,
-0.5066422820091248,
-0.613494873046875,
0.24492470920085907,
0.6285184025764465,
0.9138715267181396,
0.12598778307437897,
0.5826775431632996,
0.3558851480484009,
0.29660722613334656,
-0.22339685261249542,
0.8816090226173401,
-0.2437887191772461,
-0.7693939208984375,
-0.6192190647125244,
-0.2737320363521576,
-0.6434547901153564,
0.08220414817333221,
-0.7438382506370544,
0.1619725078344345,
-0.5605084896087646,
-0.16917060315608978,
-0.4531014561653137,
0.02288106642663479,
-0.4742145836353302,
0.19469651579856873,
0.026192452758550644,
0.7929314374923706,
-0.8261960744857788,
0.8130199909210205,
0.5217052698135376,
-0.6515890955924988,
-1.06266450881958,
0.183597132563591,
-0.3716440200805664,
-0.48609957098960876,
0.5222321152687073,
0.022360192611813545,
-0.3848158121109009,
0.2365308254957199,
-0.8080816864967346,
-0.4829837381839752,
1.0501599311828613,
0.20364217460155487,
-0.4349585473537445,
-0.059873949736356735,
-0.09774859249591827,
0.5392966270446777,
-0.39883843064308167,
0.12818129360675812,
0.40738460421562195,
0.16976536810398102,
0.23378419876098633,
-0.6320281624794006,
0.2714827060699463,
-0.23982299864292145,
-0.21250765025615692,
0.033587660640478134,
-0.5231963396072388,
0.6293219327926636,
-0.27929291129112244,
-0.3653833866119385,
-0.08195022493600845,
0.9510429501533508,
0.8534456491470337,
0.3619047999382019,
0.6581315398216248,
0.32451218366622925,
0.962084949016571,
0.23159605264663696,
0.7711490392684937,
-0.4852921664714813,
-0.07644428312778473,
1.1583385467529297,
-0.5179953575134277,
1.0240262746810913,
0.8087826371192932,
0.09497898072004318,
0.8090078234672546,
0.6265019178390503,
0.2903198301792145,
0.3787914216518402,
0.27850714325904846,
-0.2394508719444275,
-0.43703362345695496,
-0.3790200650691986,
-0.3093658685684204,
0.312406450510025,
0.20351542532444,
0.005064607597887516,
0.1691361367702484,
0.005571409594267607,
-0.1381329745054245,
0.09220578521490097,
-0.1156192347407341,
0.9829246997833252,
0.13812974095344543,
-1.0093079805374146,
0.5877084136009216,
-0.37224701046943665,
0.25252479314804077,
-0.5337083339691162,
-0.2509814202785492,
-0.3558976352214813,
-0.3264519274234772,
-0.23956236243247986,
-0.7786465287208557,
0.0628419816493988,
0.011856332421302795,
-0.27828073501586914,
-0.5516210794448853,
0.6423590183258057,
-0.6342424154281616,
-0.05999121814966202,
-0.11928786337375641,
0.6780053377151489,
0.31355932354927063,
-0.4049186408519745,
-0.3736478388309479,
-0.1932428926229477,
-0.42578402161598206,
-0.3899523913860321,
0.14263930916786194,
0.5506849884986877,
-0.3668651282787323,
0.5332140922546387,
0.9633080959320068,
-0.017095288261771202,
0.10569081455469131,
0.3110986053943634,
1.1956913471221924,
-0.7561981678009033,
-0.8871846795082092,
-0.4359341561794281,
0.7782996892929077,
0.08382584154605865,
-0.2806934118270874,
0.5491232872009277,
0.3925146758556366,
0.790504515171051,
-0.04411396384239197,
0.651371419429779,
0.1367894858121872,
0.05299118906259537,
-0.7383151054382324,
0.49656349420547485,
-0.21284493803977966,
0.09082473814487457,
-0.27349555492401123,
-1.022870421409607,
0.16610565781593323,
0.44378313422203064,
0.05942635238170624,
-0.2668701112270355,
1.1927666664123535,
0.7433032989501953,
0.2784053385257721,
0.08723988384008408,
0.3442820608615875,
-0.07634313404560089,
0.3674829304218292,
0.4261297881603241,
1.259533405303955,
-0.4027898609638214,
0.6276658773422241,
0.00008981541759567335,
0.08260291069746017,
-0.03269317373633385,
-0.6693254709243774,
-1.0472630262374878,
-0.5362619161605835,
-0.39369669556617737,
-0.7374486923217773,
0.05674660578370094,
1.1214938163757324,
0.5787515044212341,
-0.7252532243728638,
-0.003717075800523162,
-0.2058762013912201,
0.08605226874351501,
-0.25810715556144714,
-0.18984349071979523,
0.10789524018764496,
-0.5420665740966797,
-0.42335936427116394,
0.664627194404602,
0.39906737208366394,
-0.11060137301683426,
-0.41741928458213806,
-0.10704410821199417,
-0.0992349162697792,
0.3379002511501312,
0.9182891845703125,
0.07512602210044861,
-0.7739050984382629,
-0.3712780773639679,
0.43407607078552246,
-0.2663072645664215,
0.13066135346889496,
1.1206053495407104,
-0.8150113224983215,
0.3885559141635895,
0.5680960416793823,
0.6470444798469543,
0.5669333934783936,
0.24628841876983643,
0.6079748868942261,
-0.8845486640930176,
0.14214551448822021,
0.3366183638572693,
-0.17655225098133087,
-0.019959090277552605,
-0.37766125798225403,
0.3973713517189026,
0.07551629096269608,
-0.3868202567100525,
-0.8105111122131348,
0.37983444333076477,
-1.0933822393417358,
-0.05948326364159584,
1.2747012376785278,
-0.0078017679043114185,
-0.2566901445388794,
-0.10457132756710052,
-0.3833226263523102,
0.33257731795310974,
-0.4698793590068817,
0.7093488574028015,
0.7294628024101257,
-0.14648354053497314,
-0.12562249600887299,
-0.2558029890060425,
0.519496738910675,
0.46910688281059265,
-1.1679713726043701,
0.011438828893005848,
0.6466764807701111,
-0.09481113404035568,
0.024794353172183037,
1.15510892868042,
0.20619159936904907,
0.2851831316947937,
-0.026989392936229706,
0.11828623712062836,
0.08698863536119461,
-0.6939083337783813,
-0.33101555705070496,
0.2018037885427475,
0.028980905190110207,
-0.15434056520462036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11764v1 | ChatGPT Based Data Augmentation for Improved Parameter-Efficient Debiasing of LLMs | 2024-02-19T01:28:48 | 2024-02-19T01:28:48 | Pengrui Han, Rafal Kocielnik, Adhithya Saravanan, Roy Jiang, Or Sharir, Anima Anandkumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, 68T50, I.2.7; K.4.1 | Large Language models (LLMs), while powerful, exhibit harmful social biases.
Debiasing is often challenging due to computational costs, data constraints,
and potential degradation of multi-task language capabilities. This work
introduces a novel approach utilizing ChatGPT to generate synthetic training
data, aiming to enhance the debiasing of LLMs. We propose two strategies:
Targeted Prompting, which provides effective debiasing for known biases but
necessitates prior specification of bias in question; and General Prompting,
which, while slightly less effective, offers debiasing across various
categories. We leverage resource-efficient LLM debiasing using adapter tuning
and compare the effectiveness of our synthetic data to existing debiasing
datasets. Our results reveal that: (1) ChatGPT can efficiently produce
high-quality training data for debiasing other LLMs; (2) data produced via our
approach surpasses existing datasets in debiasing performance while also
preserving internal knowledge of a pre-trained LLM; and (3) synthetic data
exhibits generalizability across categories, effectively mitigating various
biases, including intersectional ones. These findings underscore the potential
of synthetic data in advancing the fairness of LLMs with minimal retraining
cost. | [
-0.3258884847164154,
-1.0358487367630005,
0.5300322771072388,
0.19934536516666412,
-0.31110885739326477,
0.24706192314624786,
-0.5026376247406006,
-0.22573494911193848,
0.10277282446622849,
0.3086642026901245,
-0.682316780090332,
-0.46990007162094116,
-0.6157174706459045,
-0.06244713068008423,
-0.1607184261083603,
0.9893789291381836,
0.28826138377189636,
0.415728896856308,
-0.01655123569071293,
0.021845608949661255,
-0.5270220041275024,
-0.6827738881111145,
-0.8541913628578186,
-0.41411924362182617,
0.4414049983024597,
0.4751482903957367,
0.8048900365829468,
0.23884542286396027,
0.35554271936416626,
0.26590192317962646,
-0.05729798600077629,
0.4542875587940216,
-0.8090479969978333,
0.14115166664123535,
0.024590229615569115,
-0.3889158368110657,
-0.4621420204639435,
0.12666954100131989,
0.46904420852661133,
0.6880486607551575,
-0.01620388962328434,
0.03253139927983284,
0.43964624404907227,
0.7322351336479187,
-0.4970094859600067,
0.3073761463165283,
-1.1121689081192017,
-0.013520090840756893,
-0.00747923506423831,
-0.15997596085071564,
-0.27461931109428406,
-0.6637107729911804,
-0.06297370046377182,
-0.5852579474449158,
0.3866150975227356,
0.005210799630731344,
0.3721540570259094,
0.5685916543006897,
-0.14953021705150604,
-0.12109682708978653,
-0.6231739521026611,
0.8654031157493591,
-0.6382761001586914,
0.5162136554718018,
0.3533051908016205,
0.3144069015979767,
-0.33646348118782043,
-0.3543906509876251,
-0.6532078385353088,
-0.37577390670776367,
-0.01695508323609829,
0.19737251102924347,
-0.09141256660223007,
0.16630569100379944,
0.32616862654685974,
0.19879311323165894,
-0.4361177682876587,
0.076332688331604,
-0.33959564566612244,
-0.10766952484846115,
0.5862480998039246,
-0.04644177481532097,
0.1880713552236557,
-0.07198505103588104,
-0.2501882016658783,
-0.09788791835308075,
-0.9036162495613098,
-0.2909190058708191,
0.7631611227989197,
0.39625194668769836,
-0.11891365051269531,
0.5871302485466003,
-0.4017598628997803,
0.4464188814163208,
0.24130432307720184,
0.1784525364637375,
0.44430112838745117,
-0.05400975048542023,
-0.03276041895151138,
0.18160483241081238,
0.780701220035553,
0.7009966969490051,
0.5136765241622925,
-0.13805916905403137,
-0.05981641635298729,
0.25539958477020264,
0.04490545764565468,
-0.7929264307022095,
-0.2095932811498642,
0.14804111421108246,
-0.14587350189685822,
-0.48911431431770325,
-0.35914528369903564,
-0.968411922454834,
-0.7267692685127258,
-0.6260290741920471,
0.29819995164871216,
-0.5109535455703735,
-0.10439897328615189,
0.11671783030033112,
-0.05858911946415901,
0.19401861727237701,
0.31992629170417786,
-0.9642581343650818,
0.03619273751974106,
0.6054958701133728,
0.7894245982170105,
-0.1417788416147232,
-0.010802585631608963,
-0.4942011833190918,
-0.011271478608250618,
-0.22177641093730927,
0.7363394498825073,
-0.8657366037368774,
-0.42430758476257324,
-0.21537303924560547,
-0.24086689949035645,
0.03858204558491707,
-0.5639949440956116,
0.7098498344421387,
-0.39864665269851685,
0.0708981305360794,
-0.27611494064331055,
-0.2522833049297333,
0.026603609323501587,
0.4696989357471466,
-0.5732011795043945,
1.2377266883850098,
0.12319311499595642,
-0.7250854969024658,
0.5672280192375183,
-0.5179864168167114,
-0.14779861271381378,
-0.1996118426322937,
-0.3206779360771179,
-0.3004206120967865,
0.007340649142861366,
0.7914994955062866,
0.2212493121623993,
-0.3249826729297638,
0.49620121717453003,
-0.6695196628570557,
-0.3898710310459137,
0.31012478470802307,
-0.8791180849075317,
0.47368937730789185,
0.19344671070575714,
-0.13646234571933746,
-0.029512817040085793,
-0.7336628437042236,
-0.04191264137625694,
-0.11988598853349686,
-0.261403352022171,
-0.2684142589569092,
0.0839918702840805,
-0.16601066291332245,
0.047411300241947174,
0.13107919692993164,
-0.7030598521232605,
0.2349480837583542,
-0.6251808404922485,
0.32487696409225464,
0.923372745513916,
0.10007234662771225,
0.4033544659614563,
-0.33812764286994934,
0.4663558006286621,
-0.13806763291358948,
0.19009405374526978,
0.29080861806869507,
-0.2891695499420166,
-0.8400389552116394,
-0.4610966742038727,
0.29261672496795654,
0.5285686254501343,
-0.7685716152191162,
0.436931848526001,
-0.4169968068599701,
-0.4464026093482971,
-0.7298625111579895,
0.10934839397668839,
0.08047053962945938,
0.38969650864601135,
0.3384723961353302,
-0.026615289971232414,
-0.8033333420753479,
-0.8759804964065552,
-0.3866867125034332,
0.019225269556045532,
-0.18425606191158295,
0.223464697599411,
0.06017063558101654,
-0.2427348792552948,
0.9491515159606934,
-0.49576202034950256,
-0.17333172261714935,
-0.24711690843105316,
-0.15654121339321136,
0.2916466295719147,
0.42966631054878235,
0.43929392099380493,
-0.502905011177063,
-0.535683810710907,
-0.18041883409023285,
-0.4131447672843933,
-0.4380059242248535,
-0.07116007059812546,
-0.3053395450115204,
0.0329522080719471,
0.46096381545066833,
-0.45328983664512634,
0.22861027717590332,
0.49358683824539185,
0.00993741862475872,
0.33225542306900024,
-0.04019381105899811,
0.2156144231557846,
-0.9921653866767883,
-0.1997641772031784,
-0.16448429226875305,
-0.1787673383951187,
-0.47698190808296204,
-0.3665432631969452,
-0.30301034450531006,
-0.12498998641967773,
-0.29685917496681213,
0.5806601643562317,
-0.3341248333454132,
0.3317805528640747,
-0.35361114144325256,
0.3484857976436615,
-0.22609765827655792,
0.5259225964546204,
-0.012014900334179401,
0.6890642046928406,
0.6394795179367065,
-0.45616111159324646,
0.37002643942832947,
0.3389277756214142,
-0.26896896958351135,
0.4729526937007904,
-0.7229146957397461,
0.30800661444664,
-0.41021010279655457,
0.3590877950191498,
-0.9770718216896057,
-0.1648927927017212,
0.428000271320343,
-0.4688563644886017,
0.024176429957151413,
-0.5426250696182251,
-0.35251250863075256,
-0.09323452413082123,
-0.5195174813270569,
0.35563430190086365,
0.7636555433273315,
-0.6809253692626953,
0.2938838303089142,
0.42832162976264954,
-0.12470812350511551,
-0.5878629088401794,
-0.6503217816352844,
-0.010600682348012924,
-0.42740172147750854,
-0.4495011568069458,
0.3314853608608246,
-0.0634506344795227,
-0.21160678565502167,
-0.24739475548267365,
-0.11291711032390594,
0.10147960484027863,
-0.19035066664218903,
0.31301313638687134,
0.32681703567504883,
0.17801788449287415,
0.13825514912605286,
0.15941281616687775,
-0.17266060411930084,
-0.015221953392028809,
-0.19180293381214142,
0.7338188290596008,
0.18921007215976715,
-0.6042330265045166,
-0.12549662590026855,
0.10218637436628342,
0.34001415967941284,
-0.10422750562429428,
0.5887260437011719,
0.7464346885681152,
-0.20400117337703705,
-0.47352421283721924,
-0.6750298738479614,
-0.4886012077331543,
-0.5459498167037964,
0.3644159734249115,
-0.12583725154399872,
-0.8546397089958191,
0.3144184947013855,
0.0561051219701767,
0.020724305883049965,
-0.0429261177778244,
0.8511815071105957,
0.33617979288101196,
1.0880532264709473,
0.006353931967169046,
-0.36718544363975525,
0.6960365772247314,
-0.026940040290355682,
0.47008028626441956,
-0.7970902323722839,
0.040755271911621094,
-0.2839497923851013,
-0.3928063213825226,
-0.7530220150947571,
-0.7556409239768982,
0.5854766964912415,
-0.07065646350383759,
-0.19708319008350372,
-0.16666921973228455,
-0.6661550402641296,
0.6511863470077515,
0.581330418586731,
0.5805895328521729,
0.2746129631996155,
0.26692697405815125,
0.21476808190345764,
-0.09752705693244934,
-0.612312376499176,
-0.5247268676757812,
1.3325679302215576,
0.2351810187101364,
1.0916305780410767,
-0.09585630893707275,
0.6461862325668335,
0.3348625600337982,
0.2554452121257782,
-0.7364264130592346,
0.5360667705535889,
-0.14365608990192413,
-0.4778189957141876,
-0.24202507734298706,
-0.4098142087459564,
-0.8284919261932373,
0.36434921622276306,
-0.37628641724586487,
-0.6244649887084961,
0.1559046357870102,
0.4244469106197357,
-0.2427346408367157,
0.1730419546365738,
-0.7362083196640015,
0.4431220591068268,
-0.11350683122873306,
-0.5087864398956299,
-0.3487890660762787,
-0.2924427390098572,
0.3036104440689087,
-0.11978836357593536,
0.26306068897247314,
-0.45437589287757874,
0.11484573781490326,
0.5454104542732239,
-0.27013692259788513,
1.199288249015808,
-0.41935062408447266,
-0.12198303639888763,
0.4440857470035553,
-0.04847129434347153,
0.7831939458847046,
0.3792175352573395,
-0.4316507875919342,
0.023594027385115623,
-0.26079845428466797,
-0.2492603361606598,
-0.7887938618659973,
0.8077540993690491,
-0.6790019273757935,
-0.7330405712127686,
-0.09424666315317154,
-0.6862354874610901,
-0.6752788424491882,
-0.17538435757160187,
-0.03661302104592323,
0.2781934440135956,
-0.1738729476928711,
0.22642362117767334,
0.447232723236084,
-0.306936651468277,
0.11858512461185455,
0.45430517196655273,
0.058173902332782745,
-0.4820590913295746,
0.8460664749145508,
-0.05081842094659805,
0.3324016332626343,
0.11847930401563644,
0.3324131369590759,
-0.46920302510261536,
-0.5784786939620972,
-0.32805413007736206,
-0.11927980929613113,
-0.5074484348297119,
-0.15300773084163666,
-0.5826523900032043,
-0.1609726846218109,
-0.48302188515663147,
0.004393311683088541,
-0.3104843199253082,
-0.504619836807251,
0.12938229739665985,
-0.24407528340816498,
0.6044212579727173,
0.21898549795150757,
-0.20711871981620789,
0.5214371681213379,
-0.6211822032928467,
0.3802953362464905,
0.3131696283817291,
0.42009782791137695,
-0.19972370564937592,
-0.6204438209533691,
0.041917234659194946,
0.49136069416999817,
-0.30377504229545593,
-0.7656644582748413,
0.4396306574344635,
0.16435478627681732,
0.6449283957481384,
0.13787920773029327,
0.32930687069892883,
0.7130724787712097,
-0.5035409927368164,
0.5704060196876526,
-0.0560147687792778,
-0.709992527961731,
0.45892584323883057,
-0.4709325432777405,
-0.021769100800156593,
0.5769560933113098,
0.13521134853363037,
-0.4435066282749176,
-0.5306697487831116,
-0.4401642382144928,
-0.869897186756134,
0.684889018535614,
0.2346070110797882,
0.5134772062301636,
-0.08525598049163818,
0.31859177350997925,
0.16803152859210968,
0.179698646068573,
-0.7588008046150208,
-0.06573247164487839,
-0.08147262036800385,
-0.3677639961242676,
0.14387600123882294,
-0.241008460521698,
-0.02745443396270275,
-0.3347536325454712,
0.8917899131774902,
-0.2788982689380646,
0.022314339876174927,
0.1560523957014084,
-0.11393141746520996,
0.19403165578842163,
0.41743263602256775,
0.15133525431156158,
0.31057581305503845,
-0.19423910975456238,
0.03580796346068382,
0.5997635126113892,
-0.44311127066612244,
0.14311851561069489,
0.160710409283638,
-0.21231438219547272,
-0.0897008404135704,
0.013899262063205242,
0.982835590839386,
0.02171582542359829,
-0.6412442326545715,
0.2493104338645935,
0.18109433352947235,
-0.03706895932555199,
-0.18903480470180511,
0.3221873342990875,
-0.12506335973739624,
0.33917152881622314,
0.06800650805234909,
-0.21034730970859528,
0.0570298470556736,
-0.3087790012359619,
0.1119249239563942,
0.7469975352287292,
-0.3324708342552185,
-0.1618662029504776,
0.5750401020050049,
0.3211813271045685,
0.08408107608556747,
0.37792277336120605,
-0.11383064836263657,
-0.4591122269630432,
0.25841814279556274,
0.4679027497768402,
0.7660681009292603,
-0.25897514820098877,
0.21861925721168518,
0.5655998587608337,
0.296432763338089,
0.07515743374824524,
0.18707381188869476,
0.0309595987200737,
-1.0028854608535767,
-0.5718681812286377,
-0.7128069996833801,
-0.4906507730484009,
0.3348257839679718,
-0.24284586310386658,
0.4647839069366455,
-0.30424410104751587,
-0.18517521023750305,
-0.26256030797958374,
-0.1839563399553299,
-0.5729230642318726,
0.16554827988147736,
0.24985553324222565,
0.5141438841819763,
-0.6731452345848083,
0.7531173229217529,
0.4232194721698761,
-0.17459040880203247,
-0.538436233997345,
-0.047273170202970505,
0.03624389320611954,
-1.1969722509384155,
0.48008036613464355,
0.028538169339299202,
-0.14119867980480194,
0.0546104833483696,
-0.47267836332321167,
-0.7804780602455139,
0.7062114477157593,
0.7087586522102356,
-0.7460570931434631,
-0.001792180584743619,
0.5463793873786926,
0.4589395821094513,
-0.16611556708812714,
0.4735344350337982,
0.7516653537750244,
0.6047306656837463,
0.10255200415849686,
-0.7116448283195496,
0.1841084361076355,
-0.01961749792098999,
-0.1619570255279541,
0.07234761863946915,
-0.5923871994018555,
0.5025734901428223,
-0.10246368497610092,
-0.06675378233194351,
-0.3727012276649475,
0.13381241261959076,
0.3685881495475769,
0.030252983793616295,
0.6745269298553467,
0.3970772922039032,
0.7296909093856812,
-0.07463012635707855,
0.6843859553337097,
-0.4461328089237213,
0.22996892035007477,
1.2381019592285156,
-0.36088019609451294,
0.43328437209129333,
0.5401453971862793,
-0.29622605443000793,
0.15498651564121246,
0.5915365815162659,
-0.045672737061977386,
0.36663690209388733,
0.4637730121612549,
-0.4677254855632782,
-0.39426133036613464,
-0.17284253239631653,
-0.3420163094997406,
0.46593764424324036,
0.39441534876823425,
-0.26977941393852234,
-0.4539417624473572,
0.06719228625297546,
0.022332577034831047,
-0.043223198503255844,
-0.1342807561159134,
0.856736958026886,
0.02226409502327442,
-0.6194112300872803,
0.781157374382019,
-0.213238924741745,
0.7118447422981262,
-0.5834777355194092,
-0.017427662387490273,
-0.3107311427593231,
0.22309240698814392,
-0.22035321593284607,
-0.6538538336753845,
0.3618644177913666,
0.0710548684000969,
-0.092744380235672,
-0.23498976230621338,
0.8306684494018555,
-0.6720855236053467,
-0.6132944226264954,
0.0891994833946228,
0.61849045753479,
0.06910111755132675,
-0.4122067987918854,
-0.5623173713684082,
0.04715986177325249,
0.31430545449256897,
-0.3801210820674896,
0.21247662603855133,
0.3693901598453522,
-0.18341971933841705,
0.6738245487213135,
0.9875131845474243,
0.2832411229610443,
0.057717371731996536,
0.37988603115081787,
1.107542872428894,
-0.5299270153045654,
-0.287651389837265,
-1.1360197067260742,
0.26547878980636597,
-0.2126927673816681,
0.0064127785153687,
0.6996091604232788,
0.5207135081291199,
0.6640142202377319,
-0.07733452320098877,
1.1243922710418701,
-0.04005126282572746,
0.5975815653800964,
-0.6539750099182129,
0.6598710417747498,
-0.1278955489397049,
0.5288041234016418,
-0.1051952913403511,
-0.9936354756355286,
-0.1337703913450241,
0.4828348457813263,
-0.6415660977363586,
0.03291821852326393,
0.2058984488248825,
1.412947177886963,
-0.20955662429332733,
0.03460843488574028,
0.26418179273605347,
0.0630248486995697,
0.47615399956703186,
0.548981785774231,
0.9298993945121765,
-0.15441657602787018,
0.625930666923523,
-0.18872982263565063,
-0.3044998049736023,
-0.0213974229991436,
-0.8076701164245605,
-1.1040815114974976,
-0.23880955576896667,
-0.20448271930217743,
-0.2612153887748718,
0.254273921251297,
1.2082737684249878,
0.7569690346717834,
-0.7507701516151428,
0.14235645532608032,
-0.13457006216049194,
0.07653453201055527,
0.22516728937625885,
-0.25733625888824463,
0.3395615816116333,
-0.6589047312736511,
-1.0883703231811523,
0.48951417207717896,
-0.23356789350509644,
0.01851777918636799,
-0.12726686894893646,
-0.06741563975811005,
0.28612834215164185,
0.1387244164943695,
0.6907805800437927,
-0.19577553868293762,
-0.4125088155269623,
-0.3788304328918457,
-0.24776425957679749,
0.27525776624679565,
0.16239133477210999,
0.7343213558197021,
-1.0186378955841064,
0.3784691393375397,
0.4739414155483246,
0.6122795939445496,
0.44651174545288086,
0.19828850030899048,
0.739654541015625,
-0.9460787177085876,
0.4727151691913605,
0.230667844414711,
0.29200586676597595,
0.42717108130455017,
-0.37336087226867676,
0.6497005820274353,
0.11911982297897339,
-0.4991162419319153,
-0.8055243492126465,
0.29184311628341675,
-0.8326870799064636,
0.03793024271726608,
1.4157586097717285,
0.34595394134521484,
-0.05633765831589699,
-0.052275825291872025,
-0.8154273629188538,
0.34078946709632874,
-0.6265552043914795,
1.0306782722473145,
0.4703734219074249,
-0.09340119361877441,
-0.0000359637379006017,
-0.5453914403915405,
0.6611651182174683,
0.47701629996299744,
-0.8427011370658875,
0.4602859616279602,
0.7009832262992859,
0.2877417504787445,
-0.3495550751686096,
0.4992733597755432,
-0.17558206617832184,
-0.07167460769414902,
-0.09799271076917648,
-0.027983656153082848,
-0.13833071291446686,
0.15712271630764008,
-0.08759933710098267,
-0.1540992707014084,
0.054344918578863144,
-0.34419503808021545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11757v1 | Large Language Models for Stemming: Promises, Pitfalls and Failures | 2024-02-19T01:11:44 | 2024-02-19T01:11:44 | Shuai Wang, Shengyao Zhuang, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Text stemming is a natural language processing technique that is used to
reduce words to their base form, also known as the root form. The use of
stemming in IR has been shown to often improve the effectiveness of
keyword-matching models such as BM25. However, traditional stemming methods,
focusing solely on individual terms, overlook the richness of contextual
information. Recognizing this gap, in this paper, we investigate the promising
idea of using large language models (LLMs) to stem words by leveraging its
capability of context understanding. With this respect, we identify three
avenues, each characterised by different trade-offs in terms of computational
cost, effectiveness and robustness : (1) use LLMs to stem the vocabulary for a
collection, i.e., the set of unique words that appear in the collection
(vocabulary stemming), (2) use LLMs to stem each document separately
(contextual stemming), and (3) use LLMs to extract from each document entities
that should not be stemmed, then use vocabulary stemming to stem the rest of
the terms (entity-based contextual stemming). Through a series of empirical
experiments, we compare the use of LLMs for stemming with that of traditional
lexical stemmers such as Porter and Krovetz for English text. We find that
while vocabulary stemming and contextual stemming fail to achieve higher
effectiveness than traditional stemmers, entity-based contextual stemming can
achieve a higher effectiveness than using Porter stemmer alone, under specific
conditions. | [
-0.37791118025779724,
-0.7492853999137878,
0.5561729669570923,
0.15229202806949615,
-0.4226478934288025,
0.4162091612815857,
-0.4025801122188568,
-0.5349557399749756,
0.2467440366744995,
0.42012181878089905,
-0.6318573355674744,
-0.49668121337890625,
-0.6854792237281799,
0.20645202696323395,
-0.6905820369720459,
0.8955032825469971,
0.026996023952960968,
-0.04958105832338333,
-0.0879383534193039,
0.21193647384643555,
-0.9617846608161926,
-0.42378273606300354,
-0.677346408367157,
-0.41713449358940125,
0.711893618106842,
0.4597402513027191,
0.6278791427612305,
0.7119042873382568,
0.6939340233802795,
0.20624296367168427,
-0.3418582081794739,
0.02726978063583374,
-0.5474568605422974,
0.39179858565330505,
-0.4548914432525635,
-0.5471693873405457,
-0.0060165319591760635,
-0.1382005363702774,
0.49394434690475464,
0.854305624961853,
0.27487704157829285,
-0.37957829236984253,
-0.15896379947662354,
0.5567194223403931,
-0.4872089922428131,
-0.22090363502502441,
-1.2258808612823486,
-0.22934746742248535,
-0.4387793242931366,
-0.21680445969104767,
-0.42489778995513916,
-0.15627312660217285,
0.48551565408706665,
-0.147284597158432,
0.16670601069927216,
0.22882744669914246,
0.9893929958343506,
0.027625637128949165,
-0.4094136953353882,
-0.6755332350730896,
-0.7696025967597961,
0.945369303226471,
-0.6106611490249634,
0.14453624188899994,
0.20244066417217255,
0.296617329120636,
-0.21046049892902374,
-0.6260830163955688,
-0.32777082920074463,
-0.15096352994441986,
0.05438962206244469,
0.17674832046031952,
-0.3655437231063843,
0.008906226605176926,
0.00285959686152637,
0.3876371383666992,
-0.26938578486442566,
0.6898388266563416,
-0.4454474151134491,
-0.003957042936235666,
0.2897522747516632,
-0.07776317000389099,
0.40555089712142944,
-0.45223695039749146,
-0.6087560653686523,
0.019697820767760277,
-1.211592674255371,
-0.1589863896369934,
0.17042793333530426,
0.6487655639648438,
0.21962371468544006,
0.7750543355941772,
0.1661836802959442,
0.4677633047103882,
-0.13688530027866364,
-0.1874951422214508,
-0.0008983295410871506,
-0.2810001075267792,
-0.04486091434955597,
0.037355247884988785,
0.4550853669643402,
0.2897973656654358,
0.47602254152297974,
-0.39244937896728516,
-0.27841028571128845,
0.02482013590633869,
0.3424338400363922,
-0.770664393901825,
0.18988634645938873,
0.2601636052131653,
-0.4190867841243744,
-0.11079266667366028,
-0.0985245555639267,
-0.609373152256012,
-0.25919678807258606,
-0.3895435035228729,
0.0638023391366005,
-0.9275173544883728,
-0.12572497129440308,
-0.17009331285953522,
-0.19486957788467407,
0.19040021300315857,
0.4130357801914215,
-0.7393624186515808,
0.1827407032251358,
0.9214703440666199,
1.1894689798355103,
-0.7416301965713501,
-0.08716785162687302,
-0.4452211260795593,
-0.015941346064209938,
-0.4928358197212219,
0.8207331895828247,
-0.539452850818634,
-0.6915528774261475,
0.3535778224468231,
-0.1971481293439865,
-0.04838227108120918,
-0.5665057897567749,
0.9637466669082642,
-0.5693445801734924,
-0.26492875814437866,
-0.02802659012377262,
-0.860531210899353,
-0.019813811406493187,
0.05310244485735893,
-0.528883159160614,
0.8360434174537659,
-0.20683187246322632,
-0.7001809477806091,
0.3628476560115814,
-0.398149311542511,
-0.6905202865600586,
0.27479663491249084,
0.016572047024965286,
-0.1283276379108429,
0.5354119539260864,
0.06650218367576599,
0.6299355626106262,
-0.4347706437110901,
0.32973742485046387,
-0.19535017013549805,
-0.22986459732055664,
0.20428401231765747,
-0.3303321301937103,
0.6062520742416382,
0.30817535519599915,
-0.10149957984685898,
0.17495208978652954,
-0.4644496738910675,
-0.4660094082355499,
0.005210911855101585,
-0.06080334633588791,
-1.031988263130188,
0.282875120639801,
0.3055837154388428,
0.14443840086460114,
0.020577218383550644,
-0.5558792352676392,
0.24700994789600372,
-0.6896514892578125,
0.4496847689151764,
0.6907168030738831,
0.02472277171909809,
0.467518150806427,
-0.3488258719444275,
0.4418891370296478,
-0.11786192655563354,
-0.5179769396781921,
-0.5182483792304993,
-0.49836310744285583,
-0.49024268984794617,
-0.6060291528701782,
0.4016152322292328,
0.23907041549682617,
-0.8708384037017822,
0.4451778829097748,
-0.5079633593559265,
-0.6645247936248779,
-0.018695024773478508,
-0.031000837683677673,
0.18643611669540405,
0.5521641969680786,
0.29485639929771423,
-0.040900107473134995,
-0.5064147114753723,
-0.9861250519752502,
-0.49088162183761597,
0.011234582401812077,
-0.13363318145275116,
0.09818564355373383,
0.7680320143699646,
-0.10857062041759491,
1.3455209732055664,
-0.5262312293052673,
-0.44723376631736755,
-0.31811416149139404,
0.3419507145881653,
0.2575758099555969,
0.42520225048065186,
0.5727691650390625,
-0.9654662013053894,
-0.29526445269584656,
0.015983007848262787,
-0.32251793146133423,
-0.09586918354034424,
-0.14305095374584198,
-0.002743641845881939,
0.2756977081298828,
0.4881208539009094,
-0.795318603515625,
0.45389485359191895,
0.3961121737957001,
-0.10725101083517075,
0.7085619568824768,
-0.05621359497308731,
-0.20476624369621277,
-1.3181382417678833,
0.026796359568834305,
0.2512430250644684,
-0.14496608078479767,
-0.7571611404418945,
0.14744608104228973,
0.11269834637641907,
0.10804960876703262,
-0.5178396701812744,
0.6788331270217896,
-0.5898085832595825,
-0.049418531358242035,
-0.5459843873977661,
0.12491122633218765,
-0.2642730176448822,
-0.032264191657304764,
0.17178165912628174,
0.8491042852401733,
0.41194528341293335,
-0.6516802906990051,
0.14020036160945892,
0.19261541962623596,
-0.3063134551048279,
0.7672633528709412,
-0.5935878753662109,
-0.16840051114559174,
-0.2640535235404968,
0.13382595777511597,
-1.0133084058761597,
-0.06073709577322006,
-0.22284317016601562,
-0.4304918348789215,
0.427092045545578,
-0.20511335134506226,
-0.5618038773536682,
-0.4269300103187561,
-0.21607357263565063,
0.1062711626291275,
0.5040308833122253,
-0.6219730973243713,
0.5711603164672852,
0.3059040307998657,
-0.5104736685752869,
-0.36239945888519287,
-0.7766776084899902,
0.4469503164291382,
-0.4698517322540283,
-0.4675438404083252,
0.836715579032898,
0.0448618121445179,
-0.34439393877983093,
0.06774585694074631,
-0.09051856398582458,
-0.019494593143463135,
0.20363445580005646,
0.28946200013160706,
0.4670068323612213,
0.013700566254556179,
0.5185173153877258,
0.18173015117645264,
0.055285755544900894,
-0.03398991376161575,
-0.531832754611969,
0.7448604702949524,
0.09288937598466873,
-0.39336833357810974,
0.11436016857624054,
0.4299740493297577,
0.6110990643501282,
-0.20335663855075836,
0.7764958739280701,
0.23297153413295746,
-0.7534483075141907,
-0.16786514222621918,
-0.6443668603897095,
-0.15435095131397247,
-0.39492514729499817,
0.30445003509521484,
-0.47399309277534485,
-1.1010479927062988,
0.4013247787952423,
-0.2007729411125183,
0.4029380679130554,
0.620491087436676,
0.738145649433136,
-0.11641403287649155,
0.6969955563545227,
0.47747185826301575,
-0.14841391146183014,
0.4035949110984802,
0.0810241550207138,
0.40392038226127625,
-0.6548198461532593,
-0.0006369850016199052,
-0.8513914942741394,
-0.0489262193441391,
-0.5662981867790222,
-0.38807937502861023,
0.17632165551185608,
0.12641198933124542,
0.16659031808376312,
0.4454129934310913,
-0.18300867080688477,
0.18262234330177307,
0.5201238393783569,
-0.4462124705314636,
0.5810025334358215,
0.494890421628952,
-0.2241101861000061,
-0.3373071253299713,
-0.5686110258102417,
-0.536310076713562,
0.8689973950386047,
0.49138519167900085,
0.7540012001991272,
0.030599739402532578,
0.5934818387031555,
0.1904178261756897,
0.3927772045135498,
-1.364324688911438,
0.3647458553314209,
-0.19099543988704681,
-0.6541719436645508,
-0.19777140021324158,
-0.4994277060031891,
-1.3361899852752686,
0.3781062364578247,
-0.25729718804359436,
-0.8857454657554626,
-0.05796044319868088,
-0.25025010108947754,
-0.051425639539957047,
0.3768933117389679,
-0.3461301326751709,
0.3291351795196533,
-0.2307101935148239,
-0.1932750940322876,
-0.25892379879951477,
-0.43554967641830444,
0.350094735622406,
-0.3499687910079956,
0.5144575238227844,
0.045968905091285706,
-0.10272841155529022,
0.806654155254364,
-0.3767111599445343,
0.6240091323852539,
0.24035629630088806,
-0.3211386203765869,
0.28379830718040466,
0.05612356588244438,
0.43767595291137695,
-0.1710498183965683,
0.13570107519626617,
0.09090601652860641,
-0.06510154157876968,
-0.20502735674381256,
-0.3752133250236511,
0.9118117094039917,
-0.35667720437049866,
-0.634120762348175,
-0.5472591519355774,
-0.7172168493270874,
-0.268775075674057,
0.5357846617698669,
0.2923847734928131,
0.48298779129981995,
-0.14707833528518677,
0.5818331837654114,
0.577160120010376,
-0.21277517080307007,
0.5749854445457458,
0.23923932015895844,
-0.5013983845710754,
-0.20786172151565552,
0.7319821715354919,
0.2812768816947937,
0.3208308219909668,
0.4027438461780548,
0.215877503156662,
-0.3655644357204437,
-0.8278311491012573,
-0.20382016897201538,
0.2971157133579254,
-0.6610299348831177,
-0.1775510609149933,
-0.5823773741722107,
-0.2225959599018097,
-0.38363853096961975,
-0.19316349923610687,
-0.2927106022834778,
-0.19501782953739166,
-0.300915002822876,
-0.1879110038280487,
0.5076567530632019,
0.6669861674308777,
0.1912994086742401,
0.3320492208003998,
-0.7425028085708618,
0.020739218220114708,
-0.1924559623003006,
0.13908807933330536,
-0.01983809284865856,
-0.4072483479976654,
0.023629724979400635,
-0.013283787295222282,
-0.02623731829226017,
-0.9948875308036804,
0.7617356181144714,
-0.08385393768548965,
0.3459579050540924,
0.2790912091732025,
-0.016847552731633186,
0.511547863483429,
-0.81583172082901,
0.5925500988960266,
0.4381257891654968,
-0.8616189956665039,
0.42597508430480957,
-0.5422283411026001,
0.313458114862442,
0.49258914589881897,
0.6860733032226562,
-0.6574438214302063,
-0.3664065897464752,
-0.3773261308670044,
-1.255301833152771,
0.32145562767982483,
0.3667919337749481,
0.29077380895614624,
-0.19113072752952576,
0.38409265875816345,
0.12141716480255127,
0.17194554209709167,
-0.3376830816268921,
-0.2108825445175171,
0.3324489891529083,
-0.24385985732078552,
-0.01208021491765976,
-0.19577839970588684,
-0.025907456874847412,
0.08686451613903046,
0.6073382496833801,
-0.15890175104141235,
0.03504268452525139,
0.1644369512796402,
-0.20800742506980896,
0.1494579315185547,
0.3969655930995941,
0.3443813621997833,
0.7764105200767517,
-0.08346107602119446,
0.279042512178421,
0.02740667760372162,
-0.40429314970970154,
-0.06854047626256943,
0.020650168880820274,
-0.44421371817588806,
0.3268621563911438,
0.36230120062828064,
0.5468635559082031,
0.30800390243530273,
-0.7680255174636841,
0.2993262708187103,
0.14166438579559326,
-0.19739891588687897,
-0.38902440667152405,
-0.5159931778907776,
0.40164700150489807,
-0.2307249903678894,
0.8117033839225769,
0.028957901522517204,
0.0653490424156189,
-0.624448835849762,
0.12813062965869904,
0.7072811722755432,
-0.4520551562309265,
0.02071208320558071,
0.2188480645418167,
-0.009744462557137012,
-0.3798172175884247,
0.35053321719169617,
0.1465698629617691,
-0.6193060278892517,
0.514107882976532,
0.6655701398849487,
0.5780132412910461,
0.18785464763641357,
-0.00210203998722136,
0.044109027832746506,
0.2863873541355133,
-0.07150524109601974,
-0.2788153886795044,
0.3260089159011841,
-0.6810214519500732,
-0.7171977162361145,
-0.6215299963951111,
-0.4658188223838806,
0.09333539009094238,
-0.5248859524726868,
0.31238487362861633,
-0.318215548992157,
-0.14711648225784302,
-0.0007741481531411409,
-0.14845891296863556,
-0.6180191040039062,
0.14124365150928497,
0.03777679055929184,
1.2430824041366577,
-0.6595549583435059,
0.5879079699516296,
0.6681308746337891,
-0.45881807804107666,
-0.6185659170150757,
0.14814653992652893,
0.05305938422679901,
-0.5125917792320251,
0.927573561668396,
0.3453480005264282,
-0.28261834383010864,
0.045046813786029816,
-0.43567103147506714,
-1.0973429679870605,
0.9051873087882996,
-0.036495890468358994,
-0.6568514108657837,
-0.2839280068874359,
-0.1339690089225769,
0.4868960380554199,
-0.4055672287940979,
0.11551833152770996,
0.5215191841125488,
0.3311971426010132,
0.5446937680244446,
-0.7620929479598999,
0.08177516609430313,
0.0860893726348877,
0.33734530210494995,
0.09492333233356476,
-0.17479518055915833,
0.8095117211341858,
0.18298161029815674,
-0.4722338318824768,
0.3104372024536133,
0.9274738430976868,
0.3010651767253876,
-0.05582471564412117,
0.4532894790172577,
0.26344531774520874,
0.6870893239974976,
-0.18065039813518524,
1.1418439149856567,
-0.30278488993644714,
0.3415825664997101,
0.7059798240661621,
-0.3948873281478882,
0.8837693333625793,
0.7223947644233704,
0.00914359837770462,
0.370328426361084,
0.5765575170516968,
0.060461677610874176,
0.24073274433612823,
0.3833003342151642,
-0.05461905151605606,
0.023846913129091263,
-0.31801649928092957,
-0.19361333549022675,
0.3300246000289917,
0.5509244799613953,
-0.27115458250045776,
-0.3610081672668457,
0.1482505351305008,
0.3045468032360077,
0.30068013072013855,
-0.5114612579345703,
0.41276153922080994,
0.37697166204452515,
-0.9770140647888184,
0.38359391689300537,
0.31459107995033264,
1.0632201433181763,
-0.5429008603096008,
0.07601109147071838,
-0.05104823037981987,
0.050999611616134644,
-0.12170197814702988,
-0.7429952025413513,
0.5525237321853638,
0.19521723687648773,
0.0061820256523787975,
-0.35589849948883057,
1.2316309213638306,
-0.19123424589633942,
-0.5110405087471008,
0.4521426856517792,
0.7307422757148743,
0.030311379581689835,
-0.08353429287672043,
-0.34004899859428406,
-0.1019745022058487,
-0.4861149489879608,
-0.1886293739080429,
0.3297171890735626,
0.21247661113739014,
-0.14767079055309296,
0.7817487716674805,
0.8593233227729797,
0.42281731963157654,
-0.10400528460741043,
0.08676659315824509,
0.807074248790741,
-0.4579983353614807,
-0.45380744338035583,
-1.0295361280441284,
0.2076835334300995,
-0.23499931395053864,
-0.2914283275604248,
0.9318185448646545,
0.4253925383090973,
0.7180086970329285,
-0.008588214404881,
0.9413930177688599,
0.001296177739277482,
0.7957820892333984,
-0.7295711040496826,
0.583899199962616,
-0.5021864771842957,
0.22471322119235992,
-0.43130260705947876,
-0.9491405487060547,
-0.49584075808525085,
0.503495991230011,
-0.6153501868247986,
-0.027546755969524384,
0.8342716097831726,
0.3129672408103943,
0.12267682701349258,
-0.01955704763531685,
0.33313602209091187,
0.17134414613246918,
0.40022245049476624,
0.2845476269721985,
0.8359119296073914,
0.08309808373451233,
0.4565284848213196,
0.036755405366420746,
-0.20376749336719513,
-0.2814890742301941,
-0.8704863786697388,
-1.0293062925338745,
-0.4760478436946869,
0.051839422434568405,
-0.25414153933525085,
0.0700978934764862,
1.0242232084274292,
0.4836449921131134,
-0.6601420044898987,
-0.19211088120937347,
-0.26719632744789124,
0.2403954416513443,
0.03655162826180458,
-0.2140602469444275,
0.2280806601047516,
-0.5259571075439453,
-0.9684462547302246,
0.49700260162353516,
0.33521825075149536,
-0.0573425367474556,
-0.43348708748817444,
0.24554868042469025,
-0.45875853300094604,
0.06626493483781815,
0.5987391471862793,
0.1475890725851059,
-0.817655622959137,
-0.3048466444015503,
0.26578277349472046,
-0.23060274124145508,
0.03663220629096031,
0.850676417350769,
-0.5847281217575073,
0.13565662503242493,
0.5427541732788086,
1.1232664585113525,
0.5416296124458313,
0.07554400712251663,
0.7682585120201111,
-0.5168789625167847,
-0.26681146025657654,
0.34685251116752625,
0.5613011717796326,
0.4806579053401947,
-0.13493436574935913,
0.43164870142936707,
0.3454965353012085,
-0.16480806469917297,
-0.7373113632202148,
0.5822111964225769,
-0.752827525138855,
-0.69283527135849,
1.2943782806396484,
-0.15525853633880615,
-0.1720886379480362,
-0.10794766247272491,
-0.27965912222862244,
0.042252834886312485,
-0.3509707748889923,
0.3727385699748993,
0.9174785614013672,
0.30767345428466797,
-0.05442482978105545,
-0.4967595934867859,
0.2694164514541626,
0.6328567266464233,
-0.6801160573959351,
-0.13897618651390076,
0.49729064106941223,
0.19001582264900208,
0.4370672404766083,
0.27353620529174805,
-0.03197166323661804,
-0.21922063827514648,
-0.3163672983646393,
-0.03853718191385269,
0.14323000609874725,
-0.4639032185077667,
-0.4872414171695709,
0.3593602180480957,
0.11284452676773071,
0.2413620501756668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11756v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11756v3 | MARS: Meaning-Aware Response Scoring for Uncertainty Estimation in Generative LLMs | 2024-02-19T01:04:22 | 2024-06-08T20:40:55 | Yavuz Faruk Bakman, Duygu Nur Yaldiz, Baturalp Buyukates, Chenyang Tao, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Salman Avestimehr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely utilized for their
excellence in various tasks. However, their tendency to produce inaccurate or
misleading outputs poses a potential risk, particularly in high-stakes
environments. Therefore, estimating the correctness of generative LLM outputs
is an important task for enhanced reliability. Uncertainty Estimation (UE) in
generative LLMs is an evolving domain, where SOTA probability-based methods
commonly employ length-normalized scoring. In this work, we propose
Meaning-Aware Response Scoring (MARS) as an alternative to length-normalized
scoring for UE methods. MARS is a novel scoring function that considers the
semantic contribution of each token in the generated sequence in the context of
the question. We demonstrate that integrating MARS into UE methods results in a
universal and significant improvement in UE performance. We conduct experiments
using three distinct closed-book question-answering datasets across five
popular pre-trained LLMs. Lastly, we validate the efficacy of MARS on a Medical
QA dataset. Code can be found https://github.com/Ybakman/LLM_Uncertainity. | [
-0.29887712001800537,
-0.8011165857315063,
0.7852612733840942,
0.33281397819519043,
-0.32199639081954956,
0.07056418061256409,
-0.2785663306713104,
-0.17799656093120575,
0.3347418010234833,
0.4382612705230713,
-0.5378544330596924,
-0.7901061773300171,
-0.646848201751709,
0.16007022559642792,
0.021916663274168968,
0.8459296226501465,
0.06579232960939407,
0.1371537446975708,
-0.5416402816772461,
-0.2579468786716461,
-0.33617642521858215,
-0.40868520736694336,
-0.43121784925460815,
-0.005538366734981537,
0.6111795902252197,
0.3613820970058441,
0.7488400340080261,
0.3421732187271118,
0.804655909538269,
0.20341645181179047,
-0.11211641132831573,
0.3790172338485718,
-0.25108054280281067,
0.3922496736049652,
-0.08384883403778076,
-0.6918469071388245,
-0.589122474193573,
-0.18359540402889252,
0.6225990653038025,
0.7895042896270752,
-0.3166113793849945,
0.503657877445221,
0.09051168709993362,
0.8769601583480835,
-0.8421740531921387,
-0.14115646481513977,
-0.6563436388969421,
0.16608594357967377,
-0.011612934991717339,
-0.38456177711486816,
-0.5063310265541077,
-0.5004658699035645,
-0.17904521524906158,
-0.7551767826080322,
0.029274439439177513,
0.16058668494224548,
0.5409241318702698,
0.6579968929290771,
-0.0501239113509655,
-0.41711243987083435,
-0.8030056357383728,
0.7223429679870605,
-0.7109025716781616,
0.3870374262332916,
0.3961404860019684,
0.3464507758617401,
-0.399883896112442,
-0.5301806926727295,
-0.655209481716156,
-0.06696900725364685,
0.160020649433136,
0.5209068655967712,
0.07265719771385193,
0.1347871869802475,
0.08377016335725784,
0.32749617099761963,
-0.6828104853630066,
0.12938767671585083,
-0.00541381910443306,
-0.3317512273788452,
0.6196694374084473,
0.2772119343280792,
-0.05863916873931885,
-0.32971295714378357,
-0.5343425869941711,
-0.0308001060038805,
-0.7933423519134521,
0.21230073273181915,
0.2774104177951813,
0.331186980009079,
-0.01876906491816044,
0.6349998116493225,
-0.05637814849615097,
0.7183533906936646,
-0.13990285992622375,
0.005090978462249041,
0.1728205382823944,
-0.01396965328603983,
-0.45757001638412476,
-0.4397757947444916,
0.9315627217292786,
0.4760853052139282,
0.18087753653526306,
-0.09641879796981812,
-0.1554761826992035,
-0.11910095810890198,
0.20117232203483582,
-0.5638014078140259,
-0.09488167613744736,
0.42920175194740295,
-0.0004162085533607751,
0.005853757262229919,
0.12300877273082733,
-0.9375056624412537,
-0.833294153213501,
-0.0006242691306397319,
0.3949214220046997,
-0.4524136781692505,
0.010250518098473549,
0.27534782886505127,
0.24412718415260315,
0.06890347599983215,
0.39550650119781494,
-0.6142338514328003,
0.2580963969230652,
0.29585978388786316,
0.402392715215683,
-0.08354128152132034,
0.0343257337808609,
-0.8977238535881042,
-0.04020434617996216,
-0.5011708736419678,
0.851452648639679,
-0.5236319303512573,
-0.7500306367874146,
-0.18169239163398743,
-0.3725945055484772,
-0.20481617748737335,
-0.7370685935020447,
0.6857432723045349,
-0.804448127746582,
0.15662619471549988,
-0.2957684397697449,
-0.7369679808616638,
-0.04369403049349785,
0.44228196144104004,
-0.385042667388916,
1.3899035453796387,
0.23602381348609924,
-0.6126638054847717,
0.338070273399353,
-0.7163113951683044,
-0.2547558844089508,
0.2535187304019928,
-0.35266202688217163,
-0.6204813718795776,
0.20010100305080414,
0.4103289246559143,
0.5178361535072327,
-0.3565939664840698,
0.11894364655017853,
-0.4251791536808014,
-0.32279011607170105,
0.7526424527168274,
-0.6222460865974426,
0.3431190252304077,
0.17813439667224884,
0.05856999382376671,
0.26158130168914795,
-0.7290560007095337,
0.5213034152984619,
-0.07624159008264542,
-0.4542982280254364,
-0.15292952954769135,
0.03177922964096069,
-0.09114223718643188,
-0.022746922448277473,
0.31057435274124146,
-0.5751519203186035,
-0.03813426196575165,
-0.3841871917247772,
-0.11354755610227585,
0.7901888489723206,
0.14267119765281677,
0.27925920486450195,
-0.13159997761249542,
0.8069303035736084,
-0.29447025060653687,
0.29702258110046387,
0.24384407699108124,
-0.5880904197692871,
-0.3783781826496124,
-0.5824658274650574,
0.48462504148483276,
0.6460995674133301,
-0.6885547041893005,
0.5502481460571289,
-0.4445078372955322,
-0.4131055772304535,
-0.4952421188354492,
0.2024083137512207,
0.4062272608280182,
0.38333943486213684,
0.4829094707965851,
-0.13879597187042236,
-0.510126531124115,
-0.34057527780532837,
-0.17969846725463867,
-0.5208102464675903,
-0.5054935812950134,
0.562031626701355,
0.2083936482667923,
-0.0772857815027237,
1.0775550603866577,
-0.8647608757019043,
-0.20445221662521362,
-0.21905696392059326,
0.1781553328037262,
-0.013105095364153385,
0.17112809419631958,
0.36129438877105713,
-0.8930643200874329,
-0.3218044638633728,
-0.20711390674114227,
-0.7206277251243591,
-0.023858992382884026,
-0.03645055741071701,
-0.067540742456913,
0.02232801541686058,
0.2683452069759369,
-0.6490668654441833,
0.37929248809814453,
0.6642706394195557,
-0.23743747174739838,
0.5387986898422241,
-0.39866524934768677,
0.41854724287986755,
-1.4202896356582642,
-0.08073992282152176,
-0.12458015978336334,
-0.08426639437675476,
-0.31727364659309387,
0.14771880209445953,
0.16321861743927002,
0.3461703956127167,
-0.4147053062915802,
0.46813711524009705,
-0.22024483978748322,
-0.21494920551776886,
-0.12762968242168427,
0.33553335070610046,
0.16144049167633057,
0.1497979462146759,
-0.20125408470630646,
0.9148548245429993,
0.4323996305465698,
-0.7756735682487488,
0.363383412361145,
0.18723872303962708,
-0.3671613037586212,
0.5860438346862793,
-0.37969866394996643,
0.20415258407592773,
-0.09223167598247528,
0.17151163518428802,
-1.1232826709747314,
-0.39178362488746643,
0.25526565313339233,
-0.8575055599212646,
0.15040883421897888,
0.2277151495218277,
-0.6024757623672485,
-0.5507873296737671,
-0.3459691107273102,
0.41536352038383484,
0.4764518439769745,
-0.33585554361343384,
0.746300458908081,
0.1034284457564354,
-0.2708185017108917,
-0.5167112946510315,
-0.5534552931785583,
-0.024506516754627228,
-0.28943249583244324,
-0.42029520869255066,
0.019684571772813797,
-0.5008891820907593,
-0.012314833700656891,
-0.09159029275178909,
-0.2571493685245514,
-0.02381710521876812,
0.4057822525501251,
0.43692269921302795,
0.2557193636894226,
-0.29284071922302246,
0.5163247585296631,
0.10644929111003876,
-0.04318414628505707,
0.08127457648515701,
0.0503058098256588,
0.5215272307395935,
-0.07122062146663666,
-0.7423059344291687,
-0.16043740510940552,
0.20492936670780182,
0.6423148512840271,
-0.3582877218723297,
0.7834126353263855,
0.4976956844329834,
-0.5404249429702759,
-0.17988553643226624,
-0.47154900431632996,
-0.11272801458835602,
-0.4499638080596924,
0.479082852602005,
-0.4028139114379883,
-0.9940093755722046,
0.8094338178634644,
-0.10103251039981842,
-0.29660648107528687,
0.46609216928482056,
0.5165913105010986,
-0.5556535720825195,
0.8047107458114624,
0.5431527495384216,
0.12699899077415466,
0.031377825886011124,
0.020391380414366722,
0.27685338258743286,
-0.9343924522399902,
-0.26676610112190247,
-0.430899441242218,
-0.008153106085956097,
-0.41992583870887756,
-0.7682576179504395,
0.664311945438385,
0.18275828659534454,
-0.14268265664577484,
-0.10123001039028168,
-0.2556576728820801,
0.39682483673095703,
0.3275161683559418,
0.03693269193172455,
0.2949778139591217,
-0.13731256127357483,
-0.10163600742816925,
0.011851193383336067,
-0.452105313539505,
-0.4949796199798584,
1.2847697734832764,
0.31551384925842285,
0.8377888798713684,
0.27644744515419006,
0.693860650062561,
0.2871078550815582,
0.7085169553756714,
-0.8119023442268372,
0.56232750415802,
-0.0559677928686142,
-0.4959051012992859,
-0.5409417748451233,
-0.6713293194770813,
-0.8467991352081299,
0.07919111847877502,
-0.34438854455947876,
-0.8322009444236755,
-0.190442755818367,
0.07369497418403625,
-1.0667414665222168,
0.25078409910202026,
-0.42894497513771057,
0.47478845715522766,
-0.11140817403793335,
0.01995735988020897,
0.11255497485399246,
-0.8215897679328918,
-0.03921889513731003,
-0.21035557985305786,
0.3198821246623993,
-0.3241683542728424,
-0.009670132771134377,
0.7577748894691467,
-0.08853627741336823,
0.7826799154281616,
-0.11463620513677597,
-0.17862193286418915,
0.4595930874347687,
0.0839802622795105,
0.43401122093200684,
0.31438887119293213,
-0.3140736520290375,
-0.05561043694615364,
-0.059146229177713394,
-0.3975100517272949,
-0.8701597452163696,
0.4178972840309143,
-0.5428179502487183,
-0.6513231992721558,
-0.30979251861572266,
-0.8407033681869507,
-0.7117789387702942,
0.031243689358234406,
0.47653964161872864,
0.10996589809656143,
-0.1896602064371109,
0.12815949320793152,
0.8550694584846497,
-0.2143593430519104,
0.2083190381526947,
0.7780583500862122,
-0.241586834192276,
-0.4730795919895172,
0.7186786532402039,
-0.06919528543949127,
0.4614045023918152,
0.5771327614784241,
0.13014927506446838,
-0.5489585399627686,
-0.5770998001098633,
-0.7556143999099731,
0.019693966954946518,
-0.6706910133361816,
-0.4838797152042389,
-0.41435882449150085,
-0.2804661989212036,
-0.27422595024108887,
-0.09294764697551727,
-0.36889389157295227,
-0.1691778153181076,
-0.25591158866882324,
-0.48634904623031616,
0.5402651429176331,
0.5671496391296387,
0.08551274985074997,
0.3294444978237152,
-1.1136983633041382,
0.28602007031440735,
0.15099433064460754,
0.6728373765945435,
-0.6367306113243103,
-0.7372333407402039,
-0.1692308485507965,
0.18919701874256134,
-0.16982510685920715,
-0.8218613266944885,
0.11709310114383698,
0.20388178527355194,
0.5148218274116516,
0.24575068056583405,
0.29330384731292725,
0.40266484022140503,
-0.27655917406082153,
0.8141254782676697,
0.14607204496860504,
-0.7186083197593689,
0.5513707995414734,
-0.1774541288614273,
0.07420427352190018,
0.5902542471885681,
0.08445458859205246,
-0.34311729669570923,
-0.44547611474990845,
-0.4130977988243103,
-0.7456938028335571,
0.2313719093799591,
0.2536531090736389,
0.2812313437461853,
-0.16137324273586273,
0.494075745344162,
0.05332905799150467,
0.19883708655834198,
-0.5441272258758545,
-0.3660376965999603,
0.28312286734580994,
-0.6609688401222229,
-0.1100059524178505,
-0.35654839873313904,
-0.20504333078861237,
0.11242848634719849,
0.5360128879547119,
-0.32191169261932373,
0.2393660992383957,
0.24396179616451263,
-0.05575884133577347,
-0.3315473198890686,
0.5619661211967468,
0.49325817823410034,
0.38956570625305176,
-0.43722596764564514,
0.101821169257164,
0.3287411332130432,
-0.5801762938499451,
0.19793787598609924,
0.25926274061203003,
-0.0698183998465538,
-0.25542938709259033,
0.233629047870636,
0.47150108218193054,
-0.06188138946890831,
-1.041640281677246,
0.5651575922966003,
-0.11447372287511826,
-0.13376595079898834,
-0.14237381517887115,
-0.12246682494878769,
0.15531906485557556,
0.13377468287944794,
0.24346306920051575,
0.2093244343996048,
0.2101382613182068,
0.011294027790427208,
0.17842084169387817,
0.3843936324119568,
-0.6150364279747009,
-0.09491809457540512,
0.590890109539032,
0.04404698684811592,
-0.08730949461460114,
0.352407306432724,
-0.4608055651187897,
-0.3721045255661011,
0.6258381009101868,
0.4744957983493805,
0.8456522822380066,
-0.5495333075523376,
0.47100043296813965,
0.2426627278327942,
0.33457207679748535,
0.16361497342586517,
0.6115926504135132,
0.077035091817379,
-0.9974375367164612,
-0.5353273749351501,
-0.9184058308601379,
-0.5590178370475769,
-0.07691007107496262,
-0.8733495473861694,
-0.2863752841949463,
-0.39173269271850586,
-0.3087174594402313,
-0.4737013876438141,
-0.2885248064994812,
-0.4221118688583374,
0.7615400552749634,
0.19689945876598358,
0.8178190588951111,
-0.9281838536262512,
0.37650781869888306,
0.9942080974578857,
-0.3282776474952698,
-1.0371943712234497,
0.350462943315506,
-0.22310872375965118,
-0.6994577646255493,
0.35526174306869507,
0.01900152675807476,
-0.5090904235839844,
-0.12381765991449356,
-0.2556964159011841,
-0.9973685145378113,
1.0018898248672485,
0.5039726495742798,
-0.14306017756462097,
0.43611428141593933,
0.529325008392334,
0.6321122050285339,
-0.1628817468881607,
0.06993649154901505,
0.3484848737716675,
0.24397972226142883,
0.19867785274982452,
-0.49820682406425476,
0.03991632163524628,
-0.1648230254650116,
0.0651647225022316,
0.3298299312591553,
-0.30837738513946533,
0.3374188244342804,
-0.58470618724823,
-0.25723257660865784,
0.4964756965637207,
0.9392469525337219,
0.49935534596443176,
0.6163961291313171,
0.5098719596862793,
0.6136240363121033,
1.1597646474838257,
-0.16753335297107697,
1.0293080806732178,
-0.12015248835086823,
0.4838345944881439,
1.158432126045227,
-0.2843126952648163,
1.1315193176269531,
0.5036324858665466,
-0.5400054454803467,
0.4215746819972992,
0.8918725848197937,
0.3254552483558655,
0.2781674563884735,
0.4537043571472168,
-0.5443251729011536,
-0.45303860306739807,
-0.02001660317182541,
-0.2916848659515381,
0.3266404867172241,
0.6948609948158264,
-0.2768169939517975,
0.11587322503328323,
-0.027509598061442375,
-0.11350391060113907,
0.49952858686447144,
-0.1859043836593628,
0.6218344569206238,
0.08883833885192871,
-0.6388256549835205,
0.4236985445022583,
-0.13757655024528503,
0.3008977770805359,
-0.5121007561683655,
0.15544115006923676,
-0.28538233041763306,
0.12753379344940186,
-0.1941796839237213,
-0.9885886907577515,
0.1361730694770813,
0.08461376279592514,
-0.3236183822154999,
0.3085090219974518,
0.21664702892303467,
-0.2759420871734619,
-0.7396210432052612,
0.3072623610496521,
0.6305997371673584,
0.09489401429891586,
-0.19569960236549377,
-0.5010755658149719,
-0.11278292536735535,
-0.15201549232006073,
-0.380982369184494,
0.21195943653583527,
0.4421969950199127,
0.08247505128383636,
0.8821740746498108,
0.4320552349090576,
-0.09603568911552429,
0.09406673908233643,
0.2802221179008484,
0.6751385927200317,
-0.4199676513671875,
-0.17647242546081543,
-0.7125387787818909,
0.5868945121765137,
0.12471967190504074,
-0.40586021542549133,
0.6223292946815491,
0.5710818767547607,
0.4974137246608734,
-0.14289964735507965,
0.7830842137336731,
0.02294994331896305,
0.6363961696624756,
-0.6611390709877014,
0.4984527826309204,
-0.5693641901016235,
0.552423894405365,
-0.13692183792591095,
-0.9118155837059021,
-0.7965629696846008,
0.29546114802360535,
-0.45007678866386414,
0.16939736902713776,
0.6299017667770386,
0.9313414096832275,
0.30194762349128723,
0.0072220428846776485,
0.5095328688621521,
0.12901070713996887,
0.14783412218093872,
0.4919692277908325,
0.8243793249130249,
-0.37434813380241394,
0.46970561146736145,
-0.05217273160815239,
-0.33216217160224915,
-0.12897615134716034,
-0.7707619667053223,
-0.43136245012283325,
-0.36555343866348267,
-0.3117177188396454,
-0.4223695695400238,
-0.027902929112315178,
0.9206974506378174,
0.30698901414871216,
-0.9260518550872803,
0.0815785825252533,
-0.03973976522684097,
0.07489649951457977,
-0.2926052212715149,
-0.22406844794750214,
0.6513407826423645,
-0.2694873511791229,
-0.4316280782222748,
0.35652026534080505,
0.439778596162796,
-0.05788218602538109,
0.20230203866958618,
-0.25070545077323914,
0.0972275659441948,
0.4420711398124695,
0.3931701183319092,
0.18383502960205078,
-0.7927665710449219,
-0.5532066226005554,
0.2917621433734894,
-0.33641135692596436,
0.07412120699882507,
0.2589188516139984,
-0.513826847076416,
0.5408039689064026,
0.12734541296958923,
0.8079449534416199,
0.01963583193719387,
0.15812812745571136,
0.4065471887588501,
-0.9050844311714172,
-0.3933025002479553,
0.4334832727909088,
0.40018028020858765,
0.6913892030715942,
-0.5294787287712097,
0.443099707365036,
0.16422155499458313,
-0.42162421345710754,
-0.6535983681678772,
0.4978274405002594,
-1.1135411262512207,
0.025979962199926376,
1.2339473962783813,
-0.5141302943229675,
0.05853143706917763,
0.1489538699388504,
-0.16565394401550293,
0.2183358371257782,
-0.006407351698726416,
0.8835750222206116,
0.4699755609035492,
-0.10024930536746979,
0.11499031633138657,
-0.29007571935653687,
0.2741800844669342,
0.7472312450408936,
-0.988894522190094,
0.017323056235909462,
0.35105979442596436,
0.3324648141860962,
0.32619571685791016,
0.6489103436470032,
-0.1332138478755951,
0.4231805205345154,
-0.27790164947509766,
0.28731653094291687,
0.2912863492965698,
-0.20035575330257416,
-0.06484213471412659,
0.333322137594223,
0.40377965569496155,
-0.5146085619926453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11755v1 | SPML: A DSL for Defending Language Models Against Prompt Attacks | 2024-02-19T00:53:48 | 2024-02-19T00:53:48 | Reshabh K Sharma, Vinayak Gupta, Dan Grossman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.PL | Large language models (LLMs) have profoundly transformed natural language
applications, with a growing reliance on instruction-based definitions for
designing chatbots. However, post-deployment the chatbot definitions are fixed
and are vulnerable to attacks by malicious users, emphasizing the need to
prevent unethical applications and financial losses. Existing studies explore
user prompts' impact on LLM-based chatbots, yet practical methods to contain
attacks on application-specific chatbots remain unexplored. This paper presents
System Prompt Meta Language (SPML), a domain-specific language for refining
prompts and monitoring the inputs to the LLM-based chatbots. SPML actively
checks attack prompts, ensuring user inputs align with chatbot definitions to
prevent malicious execution on the LLM backbone, optimizing costs. It also
streamlines chatbot definition crafting with programming language capabilities,
overcoming natural language design challenges. Additionally, we introduce a
groundbreaking benchmark with 1.8k system prompts and 20k user inputs, offering
the inaugural language and benchmark for chatbot definition evaluation.
Experiments across datasets demonstrate SPML's proficiency in understanding
attacker prompts, surpassing models like GPT-4, GPT-3.5, and LLAMA. Our data
and codes are publicly available at: https://prompt-compiler.github.io/SPML/. | [
-0.2964532673358917,
-1.0799617767333984,
0.35017645359039307,
0.33723798394203186,
0.025952022522687912,
0.19332851469516754,
-0.09880515187978745,
-0.056546423584222794,
-0.38663792610168457,
0.8176890015602112,
-0.7172578573226929,
-0.5509859323501587,
-0.6092221140861511,
0.44601231813430786,
-0.3421410620212555,
1.110768437385559,
0.254588782787323,
-0.12577767670154572,
-0.43907034397125244,
0.020999638363718987,
-0.7640100121498108,
-0.8245514035224915,
-0.7929092645645142,
0.3290809988975525,
0.5496278405189514,
0.15533983707427979,
0.6139512658119202,
0.19714270532131195,
0.5092462301254272,
0.2714892625808716,
-0.1965862214565277,
0.04477148503065109,
-0.30751898884773254,
0.6856489777565002,
-0.040708377957344055,
-0.2672880291938782,
-0.4972260594367981,
-0.20485536754131317,
0.3977115750312805,
0.2113356590270996,
-0.10605503618717194,
0.1254338026046753,
0.023982463404536247,
0.27649447321891785,
-0.5750991106033325,
0.10946255922317505,
-0.6645877361297607,
0.08089432865381241,
-0.291409432888031,
-0.4141985774040222,
-0.9415557980537415,
-0.2795855700969696,
0.06313630938529968,
-0.25676947832107544,
0.025915678590536118,
0.012405911460518837,
0.7095472812652588,
0.4088289141654968,
-0.2833264172077179,
-0.45264238119125366,
-0.1627008318901062,
0.6044331789016724,
-0.5837368965148926,
0.14517711102962494,
0.21816754341125488,
0.7786057591438293,
-0.598598837852478,
-0.6025856733322144,
-0.58048015832901,
-0.5047910809516907,
-0.18584369122982025,
-0.20909300446510315,
-0.5095616579055786,
0.2327023148536682,
0.46645691990852356,
-0.1702321320772171,
-0.6951168179512024,
-0.09664618223905563,
-0.19942669570446014,
-0.3009965717792511,
0.5871119499206543,
0.48934054374694824,
0.7071470618247986,
-0.1081194058060646,
-0.8696486949920654,
0.05550204962491989,
-1.0750999450683594,
0.05732700601220131,
0.36552104353904724,
0.6961730122566223,
-0.15877778828144073,
0.24097026884555817,
-0.008151721209287643,
0.700527548789978,
-0.03820229321718216,
-0.12186599522829056,
-0.15077416598796844,
-0.05073105916380882,
-0.18855048716068268,
-0.053603049367666245,
0.8651013374328613,
0.4771227538585663,
0.13131357729434967,
0.12029419094324112,
-0.47846075892448425,
0.09013528376817703,
0.2588677704334259,
-0.6543075442314148,
0.03442760184407234,
0.2904694974422455,
-0.10541457682847977,
-0.48916372656822205,
-0.21958591043949127,
-0.6392406821250916,
-0.9511141777038574,
0.10651358217000961,
0.34992411732673645,
-0.44115033745765686,
-0.034526173025369644,
0.06111440062522888,
-0.07173513621091843,
0.289995402097702,
0.501315712928772,
-0.5198113322257996,
0.3764731287956238,
0.9574742913246155,
0.5624875426292419,
-0.2996150553226471,
-0.2587977945804596,
-0.75928795337677,
-0.05682166665792465,
-0.21485698223114014,
0.8078277707099915,
-0.4898982644081116,
-0.6743224263191223,
-0.05413982644677162,
0.0587988942861557,
-0.019783111289143562,
-0.45038536190986633,
0.6083608865737915,
-0.6753174066543579,
0.3426457941532135,
0.0749693214893341,
-0.6248474717140198,
0.17417892813682556,
0.3261866569519043,
-0.3922405540943146,
1.006646752357483,
-0.2581682801246643,
-0.5680050253868103,
0.14065156877040863,
-0.6028395891189575,
-0.5232136249542236,
0.3475959002971649,
-0.34594494104385376,
-0.19343449175357819,
-0.09341441839933395,
-0.04183966666460037,
0.5356147885322571,
-0.34127604961395264,
0.43783918023109436,
-0.0731889009475708,
-0.10720890015363693,
0.4480808675289154,
-0.6616979241371155,
0.970593273639679,
0.3764418661594391,
-0.1071569174528122,
0.42992982268333435,
-0.6742285490036011,
-0.15829890966415405,
0.3404383361339569,
-0.15758070349693298,
0.08586344867944717,
0.02979380078613758,
-0.19119910895824432,
0.06107936426997185,
0.45805084705352783,
-0.3940247595310211,
0.13171492516994476,
-0.20542052388191223,
0.26183971762657166,
0.8733174800872803,
-0.0062614865601062775,
0.1501891016960144,
-0.026831185445189476,
0.7267537713050842,
-0.09016510844230652,
0.4473758637905121,
-0.8516761064529419,
-0.5405043363571167,
-0.4160991311073303,
-0.41865044832229614,
-0.17535504698753357,
0.6590734124183655,
-0.6544857621192932,
0.46188831329345703,
0.11748530715703964,
-0.5928587913513184,
-0.2226942628622055,
-0.2968710660934448,
0.3377797603607178,
0.634762167930603,
0.26161524653434753,
0.10780081152915955,
-0.40381789207458496,
-0.7608508467674255,
-0.43601715564727783,
-0.18542438745498657,
-0.15809576213359833,
0.4672366678714752,
0.02101784758269787,
-0.2598525583744049,
1.120866298675537,
-0.5659958720207214,
0.1800052672624588,
-0.46161511540412903,
-0.22717954218387604,
0.3068792521953583,
0.29456281661987305,
0.5091727375984192,
-0.4783989489078522,
-0.8508495092391968,
-0.3531807065010071,
-0.5974363684654236,
-0.6874573826789856,
-0.25985708832740784,
0.12548422813415527,
0.24782782793045044,
0.4790269434452057,
-0.8805423378944397,
0.6195467710494995,
0.3247712552547455,
-0.9079010486602783,
0.6663556098937988,
-0.10411781817674637,
-0.030890483409166336,
-0.7543931007385254,
0.14725300669670105,
-0.11307995021343231,
-0.3820611834526062,
-1.199436068534851,
0.4160413146018982,
0.24847327172756195,
-0.7012700438499451,
-0.6499559283256531,
0.9123878479003906,
-0.06617478281259537,
0.19570216536521912,
-0.35686421394348145,
0.11117756366729736,
-0.00243947422131896,
0.23138876259326935,
-0.10805913060903549,
1.0146957635879517,
0.7301211953163147,
-0.6089379787445068,
0.4292795956134796,
0.160264253616333,
0.16781803965568542,
0.814411997795105,
-1.0040208101272583,
0.3271850049495697,
0.06945193558931351,
0.46474000811576843,
-1.0450332164764404,
0.09580068290233612,
0.42943522334098816,
-0.6543976068496704,
0.29520466923713684,
-0.05937851965427399,
-0.36851608753204346,
-0.0786384642124176,
-0.10620106756687164,
-0.1931784600019455,
0.22457268834114075,
-0.4459536373615265,
0.6567637324333191,
0.3693940043449402,
-0.2954808473587036,
-0.7137717604637146,
-0.2299366146326065,
0.6042091250419617,
-0.34990832209587097,
-0.7477723956108093,
-0.19722740352153778,
-0.31554728746414185,
-0.24842263758182526,
-0.6688811779022217,
-0.03453346714377403,
0.04614008963108063,
0.6993820667266846,
0.3098341226577759,
0.5991037487983704,
-0.08509086072444916,
-0.01833295449614525,
-0.3971635103225708,
-0.48666009306907654,
0.1650744080543518,
0.04990266263484955,
0.8206552267074585,
-0.04043516889214516,
-0.44384121894836426,
-0.7718960642814636,
0.4078137278556824,
0.5701176524162292,
-0.14133509993553162,
0.605109453201294,
0.15557017922401428,
-0.1647840440273285,
-0.294893741607666,
-0.2906216084957123,
-0.3333494961261749,
-0.5630437135696411,
0.3975009322166443,
-0.5341975092887878,
-0.7286604642868042,
0.308580607175827,
0.2420005053281784,
0.27275601029396057,
0.26642468571662903,
0.3913205862045288,
0.07580263912677765,
0.9532681703567505,
0.4834596812725067,
-0.09028088301420212,
0.3614966869354248,
0.5753798484802246,
0.17705655097961426,
-0.13524362444877625,
0.07180557399988174,
-0.6200482845306396,
0.1685527265071869,
-0.211441770195961,
-0.2962322533130646,
0.22988855838775635,
-0.2138921171426773,
-0.2890240550041199,
0.554821252822876,
-0.3945600986480713,
0.5675815343856812,
0.412575900554657,
-0.25564607977867126,
0.0963546484708786,
-0.3128391206264496,
0.019614670425653458,
0.12780453264713287,
-0.36869892477989197,
-0.9745973348617554,
0.9179448485374451,
0.6828582882881165,
0.7659453749656677,
0.1488010287284851,
0.5184224247932434,
0.7034907937049866,
-0.01852766051888466,
-0.4796582758426666,
0.8821688294410706,
0.16364926099777222,
-0.6843673586845398,
-0.2660786509513855,
-0.3729429244995117,
-0.8145152926445007,
0.04135165736079216,
0.15198387205600739,
-0.6034239530563354,
-0.26649871468544006,
0.16046229004859924,
-0.533588707447052,
0.10364105552434921,
-0.7537542581558228,
0.9156550168991089,
-0.32409051060676575,
-0.03502574935555458,
-0.030163394287228584,
-0.7376582622528076,
-0.060625795274972916,
-0.050753749907016754,
-0.03469601646065712,
-0.2736108899116516,
-0.1140710636973381,
0.2874479293823242,
-0.491117924451828,
1.1355253458023071,
-0.5016759634017944,
-0.5213725566864014,
0.3414878845214844,
0.28637465834617615,
0.7300896644592285,
0.14752449095249176,
0.1818574070930481,
0.11291822791099548,
0.07482868432998657,
-0.40550553798675537,
-0.5455583333969116,
0.2862062156200409,
-0.4230061173439026,
-0.9808511734008789,
-0.32164570689201355,
-0.2102562040090561,
-0.08659982681274414,
0.16175581514835358,
-0.07371314615011215,
0.4122850000858307,
-0.28358691930770874,
-0.10870465636253357,
0.7373312711715698,
-0.88718181848526,
0.30223146080970764,
0.7548099160194397,
-0.2969799041748047,
-0.20847201347351074,
0.8135930299758911,
-0.3964131474494934,
0.5217080116271973,
0.20487681031227112,
0.19742709398269653,
-0.0019170365994796157,
-0.38446053862571716,
-0.6726948022842407,
-0.2085612565279007,
-0.7367165684700012,
-0.5210802555084229,
-0.6586121916770935,
-0.28797176480293274,
-0.4883229732513428,
-0.11922587454319,
-0.22080345451831818,
-0.32120978832244873,
-0.10433278977870941,
0.14746811985969543,
0.4051285684108734,
0.6351039409637451,
0.46738603711128235,
0.40471503138542175,
-0.7924299240112305,
0.0024995675776153803,
0.2693445682525635,
0.12136413902044296,
-0.14322014153003693,
-0.47779005765914917,
0.08156319707632065,
-0.3017139434814453,
-0.21190793812274933,
-0.9480767250061035,
0.3843644857406616,
0.055125925689935684,
0.6587385535240173,
0.4226139783859253,
0.2907433807849884,
0.23275868594646454,
-0.6938580274581909,
1.0196772813796997,
0.17291682958602905,
-0.8867796063423157,
0.6997390985488892,
-0.37141528725624084,
0.2897808849811554,
0.31478771567344666,
0.002427800092846155,
-1.0722788572311401,
-0.48229819536209106,
-0.5936883091926575,
-0.5496939420700073,
0.7594921588897705,
-0.09807990491390228,
0.43394118547439575,
-0.36539143323898315,
0.07378600537776947,
0.2401748150587082,
0.2355550080537796,
-0.43283191323280334,
-0.5025222897529602,
0.03958604484796524,
-0.2469533085823059,
0.16194763779640198,
-0.3786467909812927,
-0.21303124725818634,
0.3334263861179352,
0.45541271567344666,
-0.1419713944196701,
0.10738631337881088,
-0.12873134016990662,
-0.2358592301607132,
0.26190000772476196,
0.31893911957740784,
0.7668743133544922,
0.23728865385055542,
0.2221883088350296,
0.2903611660003662,
0.4053610563278198,
-0.4752345085144043,
0.16432999074459076,
0.01384026650339365,
-0.2381894886493683,
-0.03194383159279823,
0.34208422899246216,
0.665290892124176,
0.05549338832497597,
-1.0364757776260376,
0.8506494760513306,
-0.38884231448173523,
0.380126953125,
-0.15669207274913788,
0.23886261880397797,
-0.06361894309520721,
0.14366737008094788,
0.3867555558681488,
0.07510820776224136,
-0.09497161209583282,
-0.20024219155311584,
0.3521184027194977,
0.3835591971874237,
-0.5411521792411804,
-0.44833052158355713,
0.26506298780441284,
0.5019388794898987,
-0.5700200796127319,
0.20098522305488586,
-0.22989311814308167,
-0.6743531823158264,
0.549170970916748,
0.7697885632514954,
0.9068263173103333,
-0.5066401362419128,
0.02475530095398426,
0.13239207863807678,
0.21726197004318237,
0.40078678727149963,
0.23147369921207428,
-0.14247260987758636,
-0.6014285683631897,
0.10951065272092819,
-0.3504997789859772,
-0.4891515076160431,
-0.17467011511325836,
-0.1413165032863617,
0.6963418126106262,
-0.9388176798820496,
-0.1515875905752182,
-0.32176634669303894,
-0.29407036304473877,
-0.4015113115310669,
-0.0945681631565094,
0.42221519351005554,
1.1873011589050293,
-0.52206951379776,
0.4576537609100342,
0.5129566788673401,
-0.12742994725704193,
-0.29977673292160034,
-0.16543249785900116,
0.4686618149280548,
-0.8262258768081665,
0.7772035002708435,
0.1561133712530136,
-0.1257602572441101,
-0.38040778040885925,
-0.6901814937591553,
-0.594679594039917,
0.6368597149848938,
0.28743207454681396,
-0.4725748300552368,
0.15556374192237854,
0.377230703830719,
0.29739683866500854,
-0.24470746517181396,
0.3759511113166809,
0.5577919483184814,
0.3352300524711609,
-0.08823990076780319,
-0.8733737468719482,
0.22497226297855377,
-0.1346697360277176,
-0.2686609625816345,
0.13497890532016754,
-0.44949838519096375,
0.7715728282928467,
0.05536177381873131,
-0.7220897674560547,
0.16035780310630798,
0.5049329400062561,
0.6013056039810181,
0.3690818250179291,
0.4855114817619324,
0.24024462699890137,
0.8427801728248596,
-0.09696429967880249,
0.7218229174613953,
-0.5815863609313965,
0.08896076679229736,
1.0637598037719727,
-0.5023670196533203,
0.6993391513824463,
0.3782278597354889,
-0.342698335647583,
0.11149345338344574,
0.5167121291160583,
0.060807015746831894,
0.16243858635425568,
0.37694352865219116,
-0.5468394756317139,
-0.015293416567146778,
-0.11795064806938171,
-0.3126729726791382,
0.21998131275177002,
0.544426679611206,
-0.16080959141254425,
-0.2479376494884491,
0.024593109264969826,
0.3647301197052002,
0.09596408158540726,
-0.04320172592997551,
0.9725788235664368,
-0.010861851274967194,
-0.38455793261528015,
0.5456311702728271,
-0.15662948787212372,
0.7883415222167969,
-0.7384876012802124,
0.32291772961616516,
-0.4008573591709137,
-0.038114115595817566,
0.034946855157613754,
-0.7506486773490906,
0.21487592160701752,
0.4192487597465515,
0.08049331605434418,
-0.22525493800640106,
0.9113124012947083,
-0.11321406811475754,
-0.0975484699010849,
0.060260213911533356,
0.30871912837028503,
0.079419806599617,
-0.07405164837837219,
-0.8246179819107056,
0.23199273645877838,
-0.002755713416263461,
-0.20588067173957825,
0.09187659621238708,
0.5246337652206421,
-0.07634060084819794,
0.9499748349189758,
0.37739381194114685,
0.03372633829712868,
-0.01693357340991497,
0.035807833075523376,
0.8997708559036255,
-0.718658983707428,
-0.5761355757713318,
-1.1605910062789917,
0.5140482783317566,
-0.2349604368209839,
-0.17270201444625854,
0.9144834280014038,
0.3651871979236603,
0.3894210457801819,
0.0032881174702197313,
0.8452089428901672,
0.03315693885087967,
0.6771222352981567,
-0.25507888197898865,
0.8678731918334961,
-0.04861355945467949,
0.5727938413619995,
-0.24902011454105377,
-0.39711618423461914,
-0.4606363773345947,
0.1597348153591156,
-0.2781909108161926,
-0.1645989865064621,
0.28669679164886475,
1.0208649635314941,
0.31601768732070923,
0.10758433490991592,
0.4665329158306122,
-0.04154711216688156,
0.7910818457603455,
0.2665626108646393,
1.287898063659668,
-0.09618566185235977,
0.5076279044151306,
0.33642831444740295,
-0.32623961567878723,
-0.2398473024368286,
-0.8708925843238831,
-1.0612478256225586,
-0.31239527463912964,
-0.12564660608768463,
-0.3602387309074402,
0.21929298341274261,
1.0653152465820312,
0.40390002727508545,
-0.9151556491851807,
-0.20026835799217224,
0.16976860165596008,
0.11677160859107971,
0.18294690549373627,
-0.24590836465358734,
0.18389958143234253,
-0.7749698162078857,
-0.3683053255081177,
0.6417616009712219,
0.5048852562904358,
0.03695635870099068,
-0.4388669729232788,
-0.1469513475894928,
0.055392369627952576,
0.43537652492523193,
0.5188570618629456,
0.28530973196029663,
-0.7470133304595947,
-0.3886887729167938,
0.0851069837808609,
-0.44988271594047546,
-0.017840508371591568,
0.6731715798377991,
-0.6534149050712585,
0.4318758547306061,
0.563143789768219,
0.8676499128341675,
-0.6088548302650452,
-0.1199934184551239,
0.9242958426475525,
-0.9503753185272217,
0.025773046538233757,
0.14542153477668762,
0.3639391362667084,
0.42994415760040283,
-0.5342316031455994,
0.23584012687206268,
0.1504257172346115,
-0.45021259784698486,
-0.9886949062347412,
0.44516706466674805,
-0.496783971786499,
-0.43544599413871765,
1.0636729001998901,
-0.3360728919506073,
-0.3564937114715576,
-0.19906465709209442,
-0.5705696940422058,
-0.013695983216166496,
-0.7093062400817871,
0.6483190655708313,
0.5421253442764282,
0.2901461720466614,
-0.041105031967163086,
-0.49819251894950867,
0.8163915276527405,
0.2939237356185913,
-0.7725879549980164,
0.6392940878868103,
0.4184251129627228,
0.06781226396560669,
0.09831984341144562,
0.4027959108352661,
-0.06461619585752487,
0.39005348086357117,
-0.15164586901664734,
0.14481522142887115,
-0.05579914525151253,
-0.4209160804748535,
-0.6733850240707397,
0.15283203125,
-0.013102664612233639,
-0.019319113343954086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11753v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11753v4 | ArtPrompt: ASCII Art-based Jailbreak Attacks against Aligned LLMs | 2024-02-19T00:43:31 | 2024-06-07T17:35:17 | Fengqing Jiang, Zhangchen Xu, Luyao Niu, Zhen Xiang, Bhaskar Ramasubramanian, Bo Li, Radha Poovendran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Safety is critical to the usage of large language models (LLMs). Multiple
techniques such as data filtering and supervised fine-tuning have been
developed to strengthen LLM safety. However, currently known techniques presume
that corpora used for safety alignment of LLMs are solely interpreted by
semantics. This assumption, however, does not hold in real-world applications,
which leads to severe vulnerabilities in LLMs. For example, users of forums
often use ASCII art, a form of text-based art, to convey image information. In
this paper, we propose a novel ASCII art-based jailbreak attack and introduce a
comprehensive benchmark Vision-in-Text Challenge (ViTC) to evaluate the
capabilities of LLMs in recognizing prompts that cannot be solely interpreted
by semantics. We show that five SOTA LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Gemini, Claude, and
Llama2) struggle to recognize prompts provided in the form of ASCII art. Based
on this observation, we develop the jailbreak attack ArtPrompt, which leverages
the poor performance of LLMs in recognizing ASCII art to bypass safety measures
and elicit undesired behaviors from LLMs. ArtPrompt only requires black-box
access to the victim LLMs, making it a practical attack. We evaluate ArtPrompt
on five SOTA LLMs, and show that ArtPrompt can effectively and efficiently
induce undesired behaviors from all five LLMs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/uw-nsl/ArtPrompt. | [
-0.2219552993774414,
-0.9156193137168884,
0.685823380947113,
0.0352136455476284,
-0.5736231207847595,
0.2766075134277344,
-0.09976829588413239,
-0.7538097500801086,
0.2499045580625534,
0.8802638053894043,
-0.7316374778747559,
-0.7754464149475098,
-0.7646734118461609,
0.1451767534017563,
-0.3864412307739258,
0.6216787099838257,
-0.3186362385749817,
-0.26074928045272827,
0.11715946346521378,
-0.23355622589588165,
-0.8109651803970337,
-0.3360413908958435,
-0.5151157379150391,
0.3019743263721466,
0.3027482032775879,
0.4760679006576538,
0.6968973875045776,
0.37342676520347595,
0.8106912970542908,
0.2524155080318451,
0.21693871915340424,
0.0047776345163583755,
-0.14043620228767395,
0.3084406852722168,
0.15296468138694763,
-0.2067786157131195,
-0.28504031896591187,
-0.06987568736076355,
0.17820870876312256,
0.013506574556231499,
0.08950973302125931,
-0.03656857833266258,
-0.144105926156044,
0.7153190970420837,
-0.8158345818519592,
-0.2190786898136139,
-0.6831502914428711,
-0.0033073967788368464,
-0.6498444080352783,
-0.014943424612283707,
-0.45445987582206726,
-0.3857327997684479,
-0.4657557010650635,
-0.3845099210739136,
-0.24313141405582428,
0.21079590916633606,
0.9059618711471558,
0.3488316833972931,
-0.08813442289829254,
-0.5215919017791748,
-0.030583610758185387,
0.26100146770477295,
-0.5129793882369995,
0.0771980807185173,
0.10971219092607498,
0.3296474516391754,
-0.3038015365600586,
-0.5469216704368591,
-0.63828045129776,
-0.2542983293533325,
0.2072264403104782,
0.033798784017562866,
-0.3729567229747772,
0.03747715428471565,
0.5178325772285461,
-0.024540651589632034,
-0.5939173102378845,
0.35309141874313354,
-0.3192739486694336,
-0.2958730161190033,
0.4001029133796692,
0.21861498057842255,
0.680488646030426,
-0.12845195829868317,
-0.7524317502975464,
0.07490650564432144,
-1.1618216037750244,
0.2452714741230011,
0.6661555171012878,
-0.026903918012976646,
-0.07406584918498993,
0.5851578712463379,
0.18604998290538788,
0.722343921661377,
-0.052197664976119995,
0.11199373006820679,
0.0035878492053598166,
-0.08110392093658447,
-0.023328058421611786,
0.15119880437850952,
1.3820496797561646,
0.6200425624847412,
0.3508465886116028,
-0.1321863979101181,
-0.23914262652397156,
0.1972687989473343,
0.3336929380893707,
-0.8138765692710876,
-0.2172824889421463,
0.05818770080804825,
-0.0912945494055748,
-0.4223339259624481,
0.16347143054008484,
-0.7011600732803345,
-0.6961590051651001,
0.4052030146121979,
0.47201380133628845,
-0.7546746730804443,
0.10970558226108551,
0.11781121045351028,
0.016303775832057,
0.20683330297470093,
0.2267104834318161,
-0.7548611760139465,
0.13833263516426086,
0.5120872855186462,
0.8728302717208862,
-0.20505230128765106,
-0.09648803621530533,
-0.6057738065719604,
0.2204119861125946,
-0.3195001184940338,
0.9369086623191833,
-0.5127868056297302,
-0.4588964283466339,
-0.17233172059059143,
-0.05010870099067688,
-0.0033406857401132584,
-0.568540632724762,
0.5624793767929077,
-0.6473379135131836,
-0.4994667172431946,
-0.17018800973892212,
-0.38567033410072327,
0.08797384798526764,
0.1398317813873291,
-0.8712294101715088,
0.4012540280818939,
-0.3161355257034302,
-0.8608165383338928,
0.18183331191539764,
-0.6561742424964905,
-0.5028292536735535,
0.07519293576478958,
-0.38021165132522583,
-0.5699234008789062,
0.05198221653699875,
0.18877753615379333,
0.19900333881378174,
-0.07390490174293518,
0.056153442710638046,
-0.3378099501132965,
-0.5323262214660645,
0.4298659861087799,
-0.1832478791475296,
0.8927525281906128,
0.38491499423980713,
-0.44526880979537964,
0.11720006167888641,
-0.5236679911613464,
-0.18846946954727173,
0.24539391696453094,
0.00446031428873539,
-0.5201823711395264,
-0.05816749110817909,
-0.06731852889060974,
-0.1429140865802765,
0.4298032522201538,
-0.8550075888633728,
0.48981085419654846,
-0.3353094160556793,
0.6409206390380859,
0.81135094165802,
-0.06440483778715134,
0.04960467293858528,
0.23007458448410034,
0.4473601281642914,
-0.14852416515350342,
0.3627679646015167,
0.04747221618890762,
-0.544782817363739,
-0.4185744822025299,
-0.5133888721466064,
0.04211054742336273,
0.6942284107208252,
-1.0944141149520874,
0.1359379142522812,
0.06928360462188721,
-0.3014799952507019,
-0.5491402745246887,
0.19068197906017303,
0.6472627520561218,
0.35011419653892517,
0.25659170746803284,
-0.5164636373519897,
-0.32768514752388,
-0.7022948861122131,
-0.7148197293281555,
-0.09545305371284485,
0.18617235124111176,
0.004874346312135458,
0.38353431224823,
-0.3964191675186157,
0.549987256526947,
-0.42089253664016724,
-0.41811615228652954,
-0.1610509157180786,
0.074808269739151,
0.32921114563941956,
0.4588063955307007,
0.626213550567627,
-0.3887340724468231,
-0.3850727081298828,
-0.3285263776779175,
-0.7803037762641907,
-0.5015110969543457,
0.048594921827316284,
0.05790279060602188,
0.3082207441329956,
0.879883348941803,
-0.6599499583244324,
0.6751285791397095,
0.4573601186275482,
-0.8787713050842285,
0.6909706592559814,
-0.013266006484627724,
0.27945777773857117,
-0.6504297852516174,
-0.06862745434045792,
-0.07760366052389145,
-0.16797538101673126,
-0.4780063033103943,
0.5216808915138245,
0.3001924753189087,
-0.19926558434963226,
-0.4821307957172394,
0.29953280091285706,
-0.4455409348011017,
0.08976583927869797,
-0.3640176057815552,
0.01207346748560667,
-0.06318724155426025,
0.1813993901014328,
0.0769345760345459,
0.7553243041038513,
0.5973175764083862,
0.00865787360817194,
0.4087624251842499,
0.1940748393535614,
-0.4655265212059021,
0.7264918088912964,
-0.4432603418827057,
0.4207817018032074,
0.015893656760454178,
-0.13407683372497559,
-0.954997181892395,
0.14491619169712067,
0.5039449334144592,
-0.4248311519622803,
0.432863712310791,
-0.022549208253622055,
-0.5510919690132141,
-0.1740822046995163,
-0.4619724750518799,
0.25810492038726807,
0.28425145149230957,
-0.5358603000640869,
0.43537473678588867,
0.07024729996919632,
-0.08652060478925705,
-0.7253057956695557,
-0.6013151407241821,
0.5447434782981873,
-0.4503169357776642,
-0.6071136593818665,
0.08101163059473038,
-0.0471721775829792,
-0.2884005010128021,
-0.008938570506870747,
-0.07637353241443634,
0.12170282006263733,
0.32087233662605286,
0.6022654175758362,
0.4881870150566101,
0.01952587068080902,
-0.5226114988327026,
-0.11570339649915695,
-0.3171476125717163,
0.23131562769412994,
-0.1546478420495987,
0.3430614471435547,
-0.21737158298492432,
-0.7215859889984131,
-0.5909364819526672,
0.40106484293937683,
0.7157140374183655,
-0.09389730542898178,
0.4295293390750885,
0.362585186958313,
-0.0850532054901123,
0.1261143535375595,
-0.5223620533943176,
-0.09333440661430359,
-0.5229331254959106,
0.13201718032360077,
-0.43478187918663025,
-0.9617984890937805,
0.47499632835388184,
-0.0014644599286839366,
0.11281698942184448,
0.08853936195373535,
0.27852436900138855,
-0.3907376229763031,
0.7317516207695007,
0.48171883821487427,
-0.24403102695941925,
0.46492838859558105,
-0.13183172047138214,
0.2927040755748749,
-0.6886529922485352,
-0.14442779123783112,
-0.40619096159935,
-0.5448881983757019,
-0.36206480860710144,
-0.22749172151088715,
0.3968093693256378,
-0.016549643129110336,
-0.30958375334739685,
0.684088945388794,
-0.34609323740005493,
0.5300911664962769,
0.44950053095817566,
0.1602640599012375,
0.4322146475315094,
-0.041826922446489334,
-0.41407227516174316,
-0.14874647557735443,
-0.24661771953105927,
-0.4687645137310028,
0.8891806602478027,
0.22694900631904602,
1.09194016456604,
0.18434886634349823,
0.7550674080848694,
0.28177887201309204,
0.1469973772764206,
-0.652336597442627,
0.6341277360916138,
-0.3991031348705292,
-0.3023460805416107,
-0.0973718985915184,
-0.07745479792356491,
-0.8341798186302185,
-0.11641459167003632,
-0.14915111660957336,
-1.1732542514801025,
0.1447933465242386,
0.02755044959485531,
-0.5145447850227356,
0.4855382442474365,
-0.6774395704269409,
1.0590088367462158,
-0.4582407772541046,
-0.40576598048210144,
-0.1173131912946701,
-0.8060342073440552,
0.4501292407512665,
-0.09790252149105072,
0.4525476396083832,
-0.27053165435791016,
0.015125850215554237,
0.5445215106010437,
-0.6352270245552063,
0.8638335466384888,
-0.31564033031463623,
0.09354457259178162,
0.3022438883781433,
0.4285244345664978,
0.6400038003921509,
0.07077272236347198,
0.3229014575481415,
0.296371728181839,
-0.046933166682720184,
-0.23660306632518768,
-0.572439968585968,
0.6785607933998108,
-0.5781576037406921,
-0.7605573534965515,
-0.2113966941833496,
-0.4511530101299286,
-0.015443217940628529,
0.012451536022126675,
0.6052918434143066,
0.4129975140094757,
0.1344611942768097,
-0.19349250197410583,
0.6674520969390869,
-0.42409977316856384,
0.5806542038917542,
0.6078444123268127,
0.032441042363643646,
-0.45492249727249146,
0.9085848331451416,
-0.009022802114486694,
0.21529099345207214,
0.1719469428062439,
-0.14619463682174683,
-0.21894286572933197,
-0.8949698209762573,
-0.7687616944313049,
0.008342455141246319,
-0.7046178579330444,
-0.5174182653427124,
-0.4001484811306,
-0.21623645722866058,
-0.1454312950372696,
-0.5038914084434509,
-0.2252349853515625,
-0.15890738368034363,
-0.2107371985912323,
0.005002858582884073,
0.657741129398346,
0.5394405126571655,
0.052511170506477356,
0.3421974778175354,
-0.6802701354026794,
0.5154798626899719,
0.21455401182174683,
0.4020090699195862,
-0.3474644720554352,
-0.36589646339416504,
0.11521556973457336,
-0.471000999212265,
-0.44561102986335754,
-1.2568490505218506,
0.2631019651889801,
0.09436208754777908,
0.32458069920539856,
0.6590332984924316,
0.31588006019592285,
0.5839441418647766,
-0.6395816802978516,
0.45892030000686646,
0.5237470865249634,
-0.9463182091712952,
0.7542275190353394,
-0.24926529824733734,
-0.04182757809758186,
0.8301029801368713,
0.08621829748153687,
-0.3217340409755707,
-0.9140245914459229,
-0.5599863529205322,
-0.9850143194198608,
0.38557493686676025,
0.06682895123958588,
-0.062481556087732315,
-0.01678125560283661,
0.4105210304260254,
0.015960954129695892,
0.07402800023555756,
-0.7921517491340637,
-0.05178374424576759,
-0.27674388885498047,
-0.36937329173088074,
0.33370229601860046,
-0.2409115433692932,
-0.05898827686905861,
-0.13587522506713867,
0.2936719059944153,
0.0022742252331227064,
0.19318440556526184,
0.15682773292064667,
-0.4247630834579468,
0.038198746740818024,
0.25677213072776794,
0.38739249110221863,
0.12875376641750336,
-0.0005665378994308412,
0.33528342843055725,
0.08962911367416382,
-0.8847891092300415,
0.2332756519317627,
-0.10330712050199509,
-0.2635972797870636,
-0.24978385865688324,
0.38912710547447205,
0.9136834144592285,
0.04321793466806412,
-1.0795016288757324,
0.8110135197639465,
-0.249505877494812,
0.05194498226046562,
-0.41456174850463867,
0.2717236578464508,
-0.21213658154010773,
0.49896982312202454,
0.1571563482284546,
0.21578045189380646,
0.13234388828277588,
-0.5642272233963013,
0.20642441511154175,
0.7828028202056885,
-0.7180069088935852,
-0.23757869005203247,
0.91700279712677,
-0.004220711067318916,
-0.3011954128742218,
0.5530715584754944,
-0.1042284220457077,
-0.4102552831172943,
0.5978056788444519,
0.5503866672515869,
0.8773322105407715,
-0.10636700689792633,
-0.14052383601665497,
-0.010829250328242779,
0.6502549648284912,
0.18353618681430817,
0.5011295080184937,
0.08556056022644043,
-0.7865036129951477,
-0.3606105148792267,
-0.46748146414756775,
-0.2957429587841034,
0.09639568626880646,
-0.44853582978248596,
0.4402732253074646,
-0.798359215259552,
-0.19226951897144318,
-0.2764747142791748,
-0.284038245677948,
-0.23590068519115448,
-0.16809603571891785,
0.3354843556880951,
1.006700873374939,
-0.8408740162849426,
0.8423317670822144,
0.7430421710014343,
-0.11583907157182693,
-0.6902967095375061,
-0.012462317012250423,
0.27998635172843933,
-1.0107554197311401,
0.5330802798271179,
0.39558088779449463,
-0.20340213179588318,
0.04749207943677902,
-0.9263455271720886,
-0.504886269569397,
0.7758828997612,
0.7233474850654602,
-0.652566134929657,
0.35775160789489746,
-0.0754825696349144,
0.13853095471858978,
-0.2052670270204544,
0.015404586680233479,
0.9263961315155029,
0.625148355960846,
0.12744762003421783,
-0.650911271572113,
0.3831583261489868,
-0.441853404045105,
-0.36230984330177307,
0.28389033675193787,
-0.41740870475769043,
0.4908982813358307,
-0.6639509797096252,
-0.3106444776058197,
0.36756980419158936,
0.4831012189388275,
0.6944505572319031,
0.33522164821624756,
0.4256751835346222,
0.9852520227432251,
0.26449185609817505,
-0.22991551458835602,
0.8195647597312927,
-0.19870033860206604,
-0.14564095437526703,
0.6695626378059387,
-0.20624969899654388,
0.8002605438232422,
0.7041810154914856,
0.05096518620848656,
0.6551364064216614,
0.46547600626945496,
-0.24455752968788147,
0.7512495517730713,
0.2676195502281189,
-0.1664234846830368,
-0.06916980445384979,
0.10714041441679001,
-0.08220160752534866,
0.4521677792072296,
0.5366736054420471,
-0.05041961371898651,
-0.08278360217809677,
0.39964815974235535,
0.34821221232414246,
0.3036944270133972,
-0.2932921051979065,
0.7814181447029114,
0.12428657710552216,
-0.32149723172187805,
0.5912337303161621,
-0.08811139315366745,
0.8080614805221558,
-0.4101700782775879,
0.14064806699752808,
0.06047860532999039,
-0.032247088849544525,
-0.20035956799983978,
-1.007537841796875,
0.34298914670944214,
0.40598025918006897,
0.2926362454891205,
-0.1276932656764984,
0.8653333783149719,
0.0012110971147194505,
-0.32235199213027954,
0.2921035885810852,
-0.01549350842833519,
0.18755805492401123,
-0.1999930590391159,
-0.5605705380439758,
0.47420746088027954,
-0.07139777392148972,
-0.07797165215015411,
0.46754834055900574,
0.32923436164855957,
-0.24896454811096191,
0.6488219499588013,
0.36299362778663635,
0.18635942041873932,
-0.14158278703689575,
-0.03340480849146843,
0.9076970219612122,
-0.6735763549804688,
-0.3860114514827728,
-1.2862075567245483,
0.32375064492225647,
-0.026091475039720535,
0.13314847648143768,
0.503531813621521,
0.39125677943229675,
0.46011531352996826,
-0.06315995007753372,
0.7572235465049744,
-0.24067966639995575,
0.001493973657488823,
-0.8940708041191101,
0.9819584488868713,
-0.4353609085083008,
0.4739539921283722,
-0.6267858743667603,
-0.3318940997123718,
-0.296211302280426,
0.49281612038612366,
-0.5220996141433716,
-0.5143156051635742,
0.7746353149414062,
0.7510989904403687,
0.2570205628871918,
-0.02751285955309868,
0.20962131023406982,
0.2090429812669754,
0.15934981405735016,
0.9443008899688721,
1.1815658807754517,
-0.3852100968360901,
0.5436617732048035,
0.09109936654567719,
-0.23531180620193481,
-0.1252547949552536,
-0.8915581107139587,
-0.9546491503715515,
-0.3621920645236969,
-0.3708133399486542,
-0.29336854815483093,
0.30517464876174927,
0.6877642869949341,
0.20504337549209595,
-0.833194375038147,
-0.043052300810813904,
-0.08533137291669846,
0.17762859165668488,
-0.1765386164188385,
-0.13748452067375183,
0.3832979202270508,
-0.1582762897014618,
-0.3339909017086029,
0.43624716997146606,
0.6406281590461731,
0.07649106532335281,
0.034887831658124924,
0.0906718447804451,
0.2545633614063263,
-0.21664248406887054,
0.25483831763267517,
0.3923976719379425,
-0.6800578832626343,
-0.36549416184425354,
-0.08948532491922379,
-0.08312436938285828,
0.13257688283920288,
0.8597692251205444,
-0.6471033692359924,
0.3777390718460083,
0.19255614280700684,
0.45035871863365173,
0.1575954556465149,
-0.056914303451776505,
0.3418108820915222,
-0.6581627130508423,
0.34037938714027405,
0.09261192381381989,
0.5715267658233643,
0.22134123742580414,
-0.512517511844635,
0.19776944816112518,
0.4580024182796478,
-0.21848642826080322,
-0.6070080399513245,
0.44526463747024536,
-0.8242636322975159,
-0.5321763753890991,
0.8900943994522095,
-0.19912822544574738,
-0.5003357529640198,
-0.2594187557697296,
-0.38125649094581604,
-0.12312710285186768,
-0.37445884943008423,
0.8126044869422913,
0.34909677505493164,
-0.10777650028467178,
-0.3322485387325287,
-0.8479792475700378,
0.5000620484352112,
-0.022099768742918968,
-0.5557270646095276,
0.020913487300276756,
0.40688496828079224,
0.27591946721076965,
0.060333769768476486,
0.6428012251853943,
-0.3440263867378235,
0.39589646458625793,
-0.20321613550186157,
0.24714775383472443,
-0.30043819546699524,
-0.3275798559188843,
-0.06981706619262695,
0.3100951313972473,
0.2678694427013397,
-0.19790612161159515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14838v1 | RFBES at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Investigating Syntactic and Semantic Features for Distinguishing AI-Generated and Human-Written Texts | 2024-02-19T00:40:17 | 2024-02-19T00:40:17 | Mohammad Heydari Rad, Farhan Farsi, Shayan Bali, Romina Etezadi, Mehrnoush Shamsfard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Nowadays, the usage of Large Language Models (LLMs) has increased, and LLMs
have been used to generate texts in different languages and for different
tasks. Additionally, due to the participation of remarkable companies such as
Google and OpenAI, LLMs are now more accessible, and people can easily use
them. However, an important issue is how we can detect AI-generated texts from
human-written ones. In this article, we have investigated the problem of
AI-generated text detection from two different aspects: semantics and syntax.
Finally, we presented an AI model that can distinguish AI-generated texts from
human-written ones with high accuracy on both multilingual and monolingual
tasks using the M4 dataset. According to our results, using a semantic approach
would be more helpful for detection. However, there is a lot of room for
improvement in the syntactic approach, and it would be a good approach for
future work. | [
-0.44066953659057617,
-0.7192824482917786,
0.7367400527000427,
-0.11889682710170746,
-0.13435280323028564,
0.04139469563961029,
-0.09865299612283707,
-0.9403852224349976,
0.11843903362751007,
0.8674615621566772,
-0.670190691947937,
-0.5181955695152283,
-0.6309712529182434,
0.9362897872924805,
-0.487674355506897,
0.9452264308929443,
-0.1623581200838089,
-0.286668598651886,
-0.5092294216156006,
-0.29577046632766724,
-0.07758814841508865,
-0.4970570504665375,
-0.4647499620914459,
-0.24035169184207916,
0.37650519609451294,
0.3546702563762665,
0.3380495607852936,
0.5382757186889648,
0.5855239033699036,
0.45516231656074524,
0.0644003227353096,
0.3834902346134186,
0.14627809822559357,
0.3300549387931824,
-0.1272093504667282,
-0.3152047097682953,
-0.3810267448425293,
-0.15451614558696747,
0.6216869950294495,
0.11921315640211105,
0.1890953779220581,
0.203009694814682,
-0.06897693127393723,
0.24573716521263123,
-0.24206621944904327,
0.030025092884898186,
-0.5812810659408569,
-0.029208028689026833,
-0.5686531066894531,
-0.2925114631652832,
-0.4052520990371704,
0.06506630033254623,
-0.0752793550491333,
-0.39384207129478455,
0.23088829219341278,
0.1827365607023239,
1.0392807722091675,
0.19497056305408478,
-0.5143715739250183,
-0.7010533809661865,
-0.4765468239784241,
1.0627532005310059,
-0.9163267612457275,
0.35757678747177124,
0.2699550986289978,
-0.00410864781588316,
-0.20312760770320892,
-0.7008668780326843,
-0.9011763334274292,
-0.16053839027881622,
-0.10754719376564026,
-0.02138526178896427,
-0.11873068660497665,
-0.15697358548641205,
0.33504462242126465,
-0.027518996968865395,
-0.5551126003265381,
0.21661476790905,
-0.29913610219955444,
-0.5635387301445007,
0.6823694109916687,
0.1540049910545349,
0.5656864643096924,
-0.5233662724494934,
-0.5288653373718262,
0.07594960182905197,
-0.6671821475028992,
-0.21347002685070038,
0.5892781615257263,
0.1449243575334549,
0.026289544999599457,
0.4217280149459839,
-0.24136219918727875,
0.5340611934661865,
-0.6168950796127319,
-0.34668272733688354,
0.45190590620040894,
-0.7902819514274597,
-0.022390995174646378,
-0.2752576768398285,
0.9430094361305237,
-0.1440788358449936,
0.3225227892398834,
-0.10653350502252579,
-0.5385276675224304,
0.15100832283496857,
0.23047888278961182,
-0.6197922825813293,
0.12175952643156052,
0.026987140998244286,
-0.4716672897338867,
-0.5972018241882324,
-0.1469678282737732,
-0.7344765663146973,
-0.3501667380332947,
-0.27611681818962097,
0.49230119585990906,
-0.2569301724433899,
-0.07875635474920273,
-0.03182775154709816,
-0.2043379694223404,
0.41043704748153687,
0.42544201016426086,
-0.763084888458252,
0.16434575617313385,
0.5850991606712341,
0.2928120195865631,
-0.12781602144241333,
-0.49504852294921875,
-0.31840500235557556,
0.20603583753108978,
-0.028065502643585205,
1.1465647220611572,
-0.4874982535839081,
0.10544939339160919,
-0.2745557129383087,
-0.1179942712187767,
0.1578146070241928,
-0.49418580532073975,
0.9200661182403564,
-0.41061636805534363,
0.6260733604431152,
-0.13833913207054138,
-0.4874630868434906,
-0.27474895119667053,
0.3281688392162323,
-0.6622213125228882,
1.0196982622146606,
0.00743752159178257,
-0.8108242154121399,
0.4815913736820221,
-0.6463684439659119,
-0.558259904384613,
0.17238940298557281,
-0.6970012784004211,
-0.6889480948448181,
-0.27499449253082275,
0.20006006956100464,
0.4941630959510803,
-0.48938941955566406,
0.30029839277267456,
-0.04728659614920616,
-0.2189212590456009,
0.4244936406612396,
-0.4661542475223541,
0.5531994700431824,
0.19558490812778473,
-0.5311555862426758,
0.08424322307109833,
-0.8729986548423767,
0.015616766177117825,
0.27406322956085205,
-0.48825663328170776,
-0.3184136152267456,
0.14743366837501526,
0.14312463998794556,
0.24821186065673828,
0.379955530166626,
-0.5990080237388611,
-0.16517016291618347,
-0.485393226146698,
0.565829336643219,
0.7745060920715332,
0.08595272153615952,
0.3185630440711975,
-0.25602996349334717,
0.7594241499900818,
0.10083029419183731,
-0.22246648371219635,
-0.4510713219642639,
-0.5030028820037842,
-0.7766936421394348,
-0.3023807406425476,
0.38437238335609436,
0.4908653795719147,
-0.8386915922164917,
0.5639410614967346,
0.12582874298095703,
-0.2620658576488495,
-0.3508640229701996,
0.2270377278327942,
0.45065948367118835,
0.31680828332901,
0.2530953586101532,
-0.02223956398665905,
-0.5843402743339539,
-0.976498007774353,
-0.3633883595466614,
-0.1551043838262558,
0.1560324877500534,
0.25636225938796997,
0.80927574634552,
-0.4889792799949646,
0.6135040521621704,
-0.2414364367723465,
-0.200270876288414,
-0.37998759746551514,
0.2775074541568756,
-0.10031000524759293,
0.29523715376853943,
0.7687999606132507,
-0.8540889620780945,
-0.13195928931236267,
-0.07012032717466354,
-0.908722460269928,
-0.5332795977592468,
-0.14590123295783997,
-0.17900343239307404,
0.4749574065208435,
0.7979230880737305,
-0.6044628620147705,
0.41490766406059265,
0.3058629035949707,
-0.5347027778625488,
0.4574914574623108,
-0.0058375452645123005,
0.4029043912887573,
-1.337621808052063,
-0.018763048574328423,
0.021238168701529503,
-0.4290239214897156,
-0.5382201671600342,
0.1784246414899826,
-0.002221528207883239,
-0.21634802222251892,
-0.15495045483112335,
0.7839440107345581,
-0.5299888253211975,
-0.2739061415195465,
-0.3077211380004883,
0.29334986209869385,
0.3176215589046478,
0.3482845425605774,
-0.13005799055099487,
0.8876782059669495,
0.053138233721256256,
-0.5017200708389282,
0.1577020287513733,
0.3520045876502991,
-0.338336318731308,
0.30371415615081787,
-0.503378689289093,
0.09651003032922745,
-0.02655061148107052,
-0.012045218609273434,
-1.0309339761734009,
-0.3370925784111023,
0.32958802580833435,
-0.8613384962081909,
0.041673444211483,
0.3719087243080139,
-0.6988459229469299,
-0.12486161291599274,
-0.34703272581100464,
0.32507288455963135,
0.27490177750587463,
-0.29402387142181396,
0.7352796792984009,
0.5445833802223206,
-0.32911232113838196,
-0.5525050759315491,
-0.598181962966919,
0.250332772731781,
-0.3802666664123535,
-0.8344532251358032,
0.33374956250190735,
0.19844385981559753,
-0.23582494258880615,
-0.015124204568564892,
0.046283427625894547,
0.01771269179880619,
0.3789714574813843,
-0.004455603193491697,
0.23380160331726074,
-0.3980403542518616,
0.01892344281077385,
0.24587486684322357,
-0.3361274003982544,
0.1714475303888321,
-0.06006718799471855,
0.29570120573043823,
0.017846832051873207,
-0.36517342925071716,
-0.411749929189682,
0.4087721109390259,
0.7840225696563721,
-0.5755998492240906,
0.4933476448059082,
0.8724735379219055,
-0.5581360459327698,
-0.4549887180328369,
-0.3438332974910736,
-0.2310120314359665,
-0.5078128576278687,
0.34865182638168335,
-0.28575238585472107,
-0.9616861939430237,
0.4437667727470398,
0.04485536739230156,
-0.019052868708968163,
0.5310516953468323,
0.6725350022315979,
-0.19009365141391754,
1.1175057888031006,
0.5944716930389404,
0.1495657116174698,
0.4273078739643097,
0.08962861448526382,
0.37306341528892517,
-0.6147546768188477,
-0.178950697183609,
-1.011902093887329,
-0.1152167022228241,
-0.753746509552002,
-0.24423781037330627,
0.320103257894516,
-0.30608972907066345,
0.08412062376737595,
0.49870213866233826,
-0.39232337474823,
0.3908531367778778,
0.6914973258972168,
-0.21079134941101074,
0.1557440459728241,
-0.08931006491184235,
-0.15680643916130066,
-0.03466183319687843,
-0.28686729073524475,
-0.9928936958312988,
0.8507524132728577,
0.23442694544792175,
0.4271743595600128,
0.2670561373233795,
1.020167350769043,
0.6089158058166504,
-0.12753915786743164,
-0.5118747353553772,
0.863298773765564,
-0.10747766494750977,
-0.5259581208229065,
-0.2620321214199066,
-0.3147314190864563,
-1.0164544582366943,
0.30472373962402344,
-0.5434457063674927,
-0.5661898851394653,
-0.18144741654396057,
-0.1384856253862381,
0.04199008271098137,
-0.08142506331205368,
-0.7321633100509644,
1.123811960220337,
-0.31656187772750854,
-0.14845682680606842,
-0.11229727417230606,
-0.46955516934394836,
-0.09007785469293594,
-0.1258488893508911,
0.31901493668556213,
-0.3991534411907196,
-0.10458351671695709,
0.9289383292198181,
-0.2767260670661926,
0.697726309299469,
0.025176024064421654,
-0.12778232991695404,
0.46546459197998047,
-0.09369517117738724,
0.5051327347755432,
-0.06791290640830994,
-0.08329681307077408,
-0.05100193992257118,
-0.038029853254556656,
-0.31026116013526917,
-0.31671980023384094,
0.39275801181793213,
-0.7237346768379211,
-0.4452712833881378,
-0.6155202388763428,
-0.2973940372467041,
-0.015839265659451485,
0.5419107675552368,
0.3381103277206421,
0.7121742367744446,
-0.24591708183288574,
-0.037340130656957626,
0.325651615858078,
-0.5353813767433167,
0.3563770353794098,
0.44155025482177734,
-0.037511277943849564,
-0.1337742656469345,
0.7900025844573975,
-0.2348804920911789,
-0.03546706959605217,
0.4029954671859741,
0.035055194050073624,
-0.3033902049064636,
-0.7854664921760559,
-0.6529396772384644,
0.3181913197040558,
-0.8398581147193909,
-0.41200676560401917,
-0.7116084694862366,
-0.29802557826042175,
-0.5031716823577881,
-0.21271468698978424,
0.06823292374610901,
-0.4084785282611847,
-0.5811354517936707,
-0.03209371119737625,
0.2569763660430908,
0.788292646408081,
0.3045359253883362,
0.010254432447254658,
-1.002376675605774,
0.36111974716186523,
-0.15722967684268951,
-0.24859125912189484,
-0.30997034907341003,
-0.5076711773872375,
-0.11348889023065567,
-0.2707282602787018,
-0.3563736081123352,
-0.773678183555603,
0.4512898027896881,
0.16101424396038055,
0.6472422480583191,
0.23446029424667358,
-0.12037643790245056,
0.15920063853263855,
-0.44140759110450745,
0.6066701412200928,
-0.21794132888317108,
-1.0322349071502686,
0.6674302220344543,
-0.4815230071544647,
0.2568613886833191,
0.49043795466423035,
0.1620350331068039,
-0.43077945709228516,
-0.8177326321601868,
-0.7140557765960693,
-0.7137195467948914,
0.7339509129524231,
0.41453707218170166,
0.24592743813991547,
-0.13325393199920654,
0.33385488390922546,
0.10526232421398163,
0.21535764634609222,
-0.8818711638450623,
0.16422583162784576,
0.4598236083984375,
-0.581153154373169,
0.19347617030143738,
-0.29014983773231506,
0.24363727867603302,
0.27110251784324646,
0.6029410362243652,
-0.04757711663842201,
0.41878023743629456,
-0.008911559358239174,
-0.1123637780547142,
0.1946585476398468,
0.5099384188652039,
0.7790083289146423,
0.44560888409614563,
0.25729063153266907,
0.17574770748615265,
0.025822969153523445,
-0.321384459733963,
0.118462935090065,
0.07522276788949966,
-0.36701303720474243,
-0.007534634321928024,
0.7427160143852234,
0.6467267870903015,
0.04046262055635452,
-0.9773467779159546,
0.6405792236328125,
0.03496047854423523,
-0.15941214561462402,
-0.5374277234077454,
0.25280386209487915,
0.018651803955435753,
0.4521833658218384,
0.02842387929558754,
0.38343527913093567,
0.48764947056770325,
-0.4958566129207611,
0.39725255966186523,
0.3258645534515381,
0.14036321640014648,
-0.5562575459480286,
0.5929785966873169,
0.5429529547691345,
-0.3189130425453186,
0.4981730580329895,
-0.5948395729064941,
-0.9100211262702942,
0.9641065001487732,
0.6711193919181824,
0.7573204040527344,
-0.03220377489924431,
0.09977683424949646,
0.2636711299419403,
0.3732454776763916,
0.27574118971824646,
0.3621712028980255,
-0.1161082535982132,
-1.181836485862732,
-0.24739041924476624,
-0.6388624310493469,
-0.40018317103385925,
0.17069201171398163,
-0.4329397678375244,
0.7229810357093811,
-0.18945026397705078,
-0.12355640530586243,
0.5796043276786804,
-0.1321522742509842,
-0.5712636709213257,
0.22459077835083008,
0.30713850259780884,
0.5247172117233276,
-0.931755006313324,
0.6466225981712341,
0.9261988997459412,
-0.3303072452545166,
-0.6268554329872131,
0.0007290554349310696,
0.22652341425418854,
-0.7051430344581604,
0.527278482913971,
0.32286375761032104,
-0.3739970028400421,
-0.04147806763648987,
-0.5034111738204956,
-0.7484740018844604,
1.142907977104187,
0.15833218395709991,
-0.0780285969376564,
-0.04304197058081627,
0.11326485872268677,
0.5698071718215942,
-0.2980358302593231,
0.1772439181804657,
0.4323461949825287,
0.44971635937690735,
-0.1619924008846283,
-0.7843545079231262,
-0.06813085824251175,
-0.30750030279159546,
-0.19333848357200623,
0.63826584815979,
-0.4010351300239563,
0.6988527178764343,
-0.093100905418396,
-0.35291993618011475,
0.19368581473827362,
0.7403798699378967,
0.22459040582180023,
0.4904358386993408,
0.26724594831466675,
0.52840256690979,
0.8070235848426819,
-0.02578461728990078,
0.7812583446502686,
-0.045605309307575226,
0.15369005501270294,
0.7395647764205933,
-0.5852383375167847,
0.7593393921852112,
0.2549515664577484,
-0.144304096698761,
0.5289633274078369,
0.42636749148368835,
-0.07661662995815277,
0.30615273118019104,
-0.02187562733888626,
-0.4376600384712219,
-0.13734863698482513,
-0.04420437663793564,
-0.11858906596899033,
0.9746147394180298,
0.5122823715209961,
-0.5003859996795654,
-0.197252094745636,
0.18389299511909485,
0.1424766480922699,
0.2597958445549011,
0.05856211483478546,
0.9935325980186462,
0.003174803452566266,
-0.7701064348220825,
0.09263993054628372,
0.62744140625,
0.7885109782218933,
-0.4564947187900543,
-0.12537701427936554,
0.03825006261467934,
0.27907371520996094,
-0.17127567529678345,
-0.7710276246070862,
0.5235974192619324,
0.27659934759140015,
-0.1038476899266243,
-0.3044795095920563,
1.3471921682357788,
-0.37802642583847046,
-0.4243820905685425,
0.2519138753414154,
0.7133421301841736,
0.3136049211025238,
0.24957722425460815,
-0.7337613105773926,
0.1769092082977295,
0.26783862709999084,
-0.13975678384304047,
0.20930363237857819,
0.7684096693992615,
-0.17719495296478271,
0.4713898301124573,
0.471378892660141,
-0.13235892355442047,
-0.15327739715576172,
0.0317101776599884,
0.6149084568023682,
-0.8424907922744751,
-0.503391683101654,
-0.8517902493476868,
0.16454926133155823,
-0.0059186299331486225,
-0.4167260229587555,
0.6988332867622375,
0.356021523475647,
0.8400613069534302,
-0.03558966889977455,
0.9501777291297913,
-0.13803833723068237,
0.7058699131011963,
-0.7891039252281189,
0.5638197064399719,
-0.567541778087616,
0.30695411562919617,
-0.307881236076355,
-0.7233766317367554,
-0.09324035048484802,
0.8186740279197693,
-0.12421635538339615,
0.23502279818058014,
0.6594783663749695,
0.8080877661705017,
0.06799838691949844,
0.0990438312292099,
0.22233816981315613,
-0.11996305733919144,
0.29742786288261414,
0.4417394697666168,
1.056814432144165,
-0.480303019285202,
0.44158852100372314,
0.20146988332271576,
0.03356214985251427,
-0.07992912083864212,
-0.919694721698761,
-0.9523791670799255,
-0.8498338460922241,
-0.386020690202713,
-0.24666529893875122,
-0.2321748584508896,
0.7824457287788391,
0.37047767639160156,
-0.826909065246582,
-0.04683375358581543,
-0.044237762689590454,
0.19959108531475067,
0.3105979561805725,
-0.21971732378005981,
0.003213736694306135,
-0.3104279339313507,
-0.7372209429740906,
0.4004896581172943,
0.49563685059547424,
0.07214117050170898,
-0.2084510773420334,
0.057369332760572433,
-0.37800928950309753,
0.368541419506073,
0.5348191261291504,
0.0002543065929785371,
-0.7350822687149048,
-0.5111324191093445,
0.08562415838241577,
-0.39566296339035034,
0.028528911992907524,
0.735230028629303,
-0.6549733281135559,
0.1628372222185135,
0.8207803964614868,
0.7474173903465271,
0.19247741997241974,
-0.0015278870705515146,
0.5342735052108765,
-0.7129887342453003,
0.14243043959140778,
0.3930911123752594,
0.4528926610946655,
0.350093275308609,
-0.3616653382778168,
0.5935958027839661,
0.35655319690704346,
-0.8375833034515381,
-0.7821471691131592,
0.36200955510139465,
-0.796869158744812,
-0.2640967071056366,
1.1305813789367676,
0.004203013144433498,
-0.2194206416606903,
-0.23114268481731415,
-0.25858646631240845,
0.14322461187839508,
-0.2025458961725235,
0.4545767605304718,
0.8924192786216736,
-0.2587426006793976,
-0.06098010763525963,
-0.6286104917526245,
0.5597572922706604,
0.42314237356185913,
-1.3916488885879517,
-0.3203943073749542,
0.6956910490989685,
0.19225510954856873,
0.24165575206279755,
0.9573220610618591,
-0.1965283304452896,
0.3957074284553528,
-0.044001542031764984,
0.15719486773014069,
0.08217815309762955,
-0.4770823121070862,
-0.11535564810037613,
-0.06586799025535583,
0.2627834677696228,
-0.09475301206111908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11750v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11750v2 | In-Context Learning Demonstration Selection via Influence Analysis | 2024-02-19T00:39:31 | 2024-06-17T18:34:54 | Vinay M. S., Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their In-Context Learning (ICL)
capabilities, enabling few-shot learning without the need for gradient updates.
Despite its advantages, the effectiveness of ICL heavily depends on the choice
of demonstrations. Selecting the most effective demonstrations for ICL remains
a significant research challenge. To tackle this issue, we propose a
demonstration selection method named InfICL, which utilizes influence functions
to analyze impacts of training samples. By identifying the most influential
training samples as demonstrations, InfICL aims to enhance the ICL
generalization performance. To keep InfICL cost-effective, we only use the LLM
to generate sample input embeddings, avoiding expensive fine-tuning. Through
empirical studies on various real-world datasets, we demonstrate advantages of
InfICL compared to state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.49350273609161377,
-0.7495971918106079,
0.41986969113349915,
0.3999078869819641,
-0.3307030498981476,
-0.12989197671413422,
-0.4338339865207672,
-0.3633618950843811,
-0.26225391030311584,
0.29620036482810974,
-0.41036367416381836,
-0.5426121354103088,
-0.5208345055580139,
0.0201168991625309,
-0.40762659907341003,
1.115604043006897,
-0.11943157017230988,
0.25078967213630676,
-0.6286486387252808,
-0.0948125571012497,
-0.15463650226593018,
-0.1505109965801239,
-0.5457380414009094,
-0.7647613883018494,
-0.001239668927155435,
0.7772570252418518,
0.08753874152898788,
0.11856883764266968,
0.14164024591445923,
0.145241379737854,
-0.3128737509250641,
0.22142954170703888,
-0.6946908235549927,
-0.016301924362778664,
-0.09606597572565079,
-0.2658078074455261,
0.20731963217258453,
-0.049909766763448715,
0.9174543023109436,
0.6147745847702026,
0.26052019000053406,
0.18051645159721375,
0.28619295358657837,
0.33588624000549316,
-0.7260168194770813,
0.11474163085222244,
-0.6648269295692444,
-0.11678798496723175,
-0.21045978367328644,
0.09939275681972504,
-0.6890278458595276,
-0.37299802899360657,
0.38472607731819153,
-0.23344449698925018,
-0.13466346263885498,
0.005169390235096216,
0.416513592004776,
0.20375967025756836,
-0.5137555599212646,
-0.31781336665153503,
-0.7502703666687012,
0.9324120879173279,
-0.7432296872138977,
0.4603036344051361,
0.3415605425834656,
0.3321269154548645,
-0.5456715822219849,
-0.8882450461387634,
-0.37923726439476013,
-0.46368464827537537,
-0.29673734307289124,
-0.06640443950891495,
-0.0740126296877861,
0.03600722551345825,
0.3945481479167938,
0.06758273392915726,
-0.19622530043125153,
0.13205009698867798,
-0.2631855309009552,
-0.10574620962142944,
0.3994816243648529,
-0.15740764141082764,
0.16191847622394562,
0.1500319242477417,
-0.596747875213623,
-0.3897152543067932,
-1.2320563793182373,
0.3335876166820526,
0.09503110498189926,
0.04289410263299942,
-0.16326504945755005,
0.17592385411262512,
-0.33070382475852966,
0.6283209323883057,
0.30175352096557617,
-0.41158100962638855,
0.19383853673934937,
-0.11877424269914627,
-0.5087887644767761,
0.1422266960144043,
0.6744973063468933,
-0.07189278304576874,
-0.07433757185935974,
0.04009411111474037,
-0.0709492415189743,
-0.5755305290222168,
-0.27326318621635437,
-1.1719105243682861,
-0.0504915788769722,
-0.054870594292879105,
-0.35334351658821106,
-0.30258840322494507,
0.27337273955345154,
-0.9586032629013062,
-0.3065834939479828,
-0.06610677391290665,
0.5815103054046631,
-0.32215583324432373,
-0.10879097133874893,
-0.14927034080028534,
-0.19863860309123993,
0.2536962032318115,
0.24342618882656097,
-0.7411988973617554,
0.34595587849617004,
0.44368976354599,
0.5793973207473755,
-0.3377053141593933,
-0.12058263272047043,
-0.8615185022354126,
0.16420337557792664,
-0.35778898000717163,
0.8306564092636108,
-0.6803266406059265,
-0.6568751931190491,
0.2233177125453949,
-0.27340295910835266,
-0.026949862018227577,
-0.6913412809371948,
0.43945229053497314,
-0.45535552501678467,
0.14915704727172852,
-0.20816273987293243,
-0.924248218536377,
-0.25022417306900024,
0.03468770906329155,
-0.4306849539279938,
1.0884836912155151,
0.22170019149780273,
-0.6629416942596436,
0.7445039749145508,
-0.8276304602622986,
-0.5070375204086304,
0.21697033941745758,
-0.5738123059272766,
-0.6082534193992615,
0.0004077050543855876,
0.2888619601726532,
0.6491537094116211,
-0.025753196328878403,
0.2701122760772705,
-0.34978705644607544,
-0.5521240234375,
0.32759931683540344,
-0.3092750310897827,
0.721611738204956,
0.04564890265464783,
-0.9543238282203674,
0.1597452014684677,
-0.6423874497413635,
-0.20967254042625427,
-0.1564323604106903,
-0.372325599193573,
-0.4418359696865082,
0.17587444186210632,
-0.148541659116745,
0.21831049025058746,
-0.21764841675758362,
-0.5441587567329407,
0.07232168316841125,
-0.5850847959518433,
0.13674767315387726,
0.5751931667327881,
0.4476064145565033,
0.47708436846733093,
-0.2042243331670761,
0.6208416223526001,
-0.32158413529396057,
0.237013578414917,
-0.06242961809039116,
-0.3978055417537689,
-0.5340614914894104,
-0.5184642672538757,
0.34870561957359314,
-0.07652164995670319,
-0.769759476184845,
-0.08567493408918381,
-0.13539429008960724,
-0.390080064535141,
-0.18730148673057556,
0.44974520802497864,
0.590440571308136,
0.5726261138916016,
0.2246892750263214,
0.1767641305923462,
-0.2436923384666443,
-0.9020292162895203,
-0.07506602257490158,
-0.23443558812141418,
0.13815101981163025,
0.2851889431476593,
0.5468057990074158,
0.0462859570980072,
0.9415270686149597,
-0.2767072021961212,
-0.24128378927707672,
-0.6639906764030457,
-0.08892209082841873,
0.10958164930343628,
0.3441712260246277,
1.0014457702636719,
-0.7941861152648926,
-0.8715195059776306,
0.0601734034717083,
-0.3259434700012207,
-0.19475919008255005,
-0.21908409893512726,
-0.17742520570755005,
-0.09200058877468109,
0.9087128043174744,
-0.014296372421085835,
0.5671596527099609,
0.5133407115936279,
-0.2162914127111435,
0.19056452810764313,
-0.055985428392887115,
-0.019947411492466927,
-0.5083174109458923,
-0.15298084914684296,
0.05955946817994118,
-0.3210456669330597,
-0.7913979887962341,
-0.07320182770490646,
0.37504515051841736,
0.22131073474884033,
-0.827151894569397,
0.8272519111633301,
-0.13623498380184174,
0.1506817787885666,
-0.1254432499408722,
-0.07971522957086563,
-0.055864520370960236,
0.41995570063591003,
0.009541559033095837,
0.745362401008606,
0.49335023760795593,
-0.6824707388877869,
-0.2720493674278259,
0.2541303038597107,
-0.7069220542907715,
0.23681434988975525,
-0.4424390196800232,
0.15696123242378235,
0.006396657787263393,
0.43031826615333557,
-1.1900912523269653,
-0.3514465391635895,
0.3168478012084961,
-0.07820294797420502,
0.42350661754608154,
-0.3064134120941162,
-0.5528606176376343,
0.13149695098400116,
-0.4111692011356354,
0.24725070595741272,
0.3996400833129883,
-1.1042160987854004,
0.40079715847969055,
0.15960612893104553,
0.2723522484302521,
-0.401439368724823,
-0.5892645120620728,
-0.49384042620658875,
-0.5582172870635986,
-0.17684251070022583,
0.3706400394439697,
-0.3538845479488373,
-0.47433343529701233,
-0.44161903858184814,
0.06924181431531906,
0.1380685716867447,
0.1612715721130371,
0.4474133253097534,
0.004635361023247242,
0.03408738225698471,
0.36253225803375244,
0.5080050826072693,
0.25988662242889404,
0.11104033142328262,
-0.015222100540995598,
0.3132557272911072,
-0.009860038757324219,
-0.6097056269645691,
-0.5069298148155212,
0.18293079733848572,
0.5275911092758179,
-0.07748030126094818,
0.4168147146701813,
0.30764997005462646,
-0.15075936913490295,
-0.78751140832901,
-0.3770933151245117,
-0.10243140906095505,
-0.48292893171310425,
0.4113248586654663,
-0.06309710443019867,
-0.7773322463035583,
-0.028880663216114044,
-0.488718181848526,
0.2499307543039322,
0.1930529922246933,
0.5313923954963684,
0.03306956589221954,
1.0626999139785767,
0.6301708221435547,
-0.24133440852165222,
1.020237684249878,
-0.4130847156047821,
-0.2717876136302948,
-0.7504671216011047,
-0.29087504744529724,
-0.33639517426490784,
-0.23819279670715332,
-0.1533912569284439,
-0.21624647080898285,
0.6915701031684875,
0.06182682886719704,
-0.26677945256233215,
0.046574290841817856,
-0.2170800268650055,
0.656406581401825,
0.46884655952453613,
0.2229253053665161,
0.21586337685585022,
0.15760113298892975,
-0.2496357411146164,
0.08459657430648804,
-0.5723368525505066,
-0.3595963418483734,
1.188098669052124,
0.3210279941558838,
0.6547677516937256,
0.18947306275367737,
0.7015806436538696,
0.21741841733455658,
0.7335546612739563,
-0.6403184533119202,
0.40560680627822876,
-0.09401752054691315,
-0.43868082761764526,
-0.2503271996974945,
-0.0528966523706913,
-0.6124791502952576,
0.3632073402404785,
-0.3422626852989197,
-0.7387738227844238,
0.2757817208766937,
0.27932116389274597,
-0.21662630140781403,
0.22941844165325165,
-0.6319698691368103,
0.5736183524131775,
-0.269401878118515,
-0.26742812991142273,
-0.38692137598991394,
-0.4043276906013489,
0.3869856894016266,
-0.13919813930988312,
0.2313401997089386,
0.2554877996444702,
0.17141830921173096,
0.7150629758834839,
-0.2310885339975357,
1.1336525678634644,
-0.38194483518600464,
0.0138749610632658,
0.33905884623527527,
0.07298559695482254,
0.6918882727622986,
0.22029544413089752,
-0.2569449543952942,
-0.12966950237751007,
-0.3158456087112427,
-0.04578982666134834,
-0.7275667190551758,
0.7589911222457886,
-0.49516233801841736,
-0.36339685320854187,
0.16063310205936432,
-0.18781204521656036,
-0.5173928737640381,
-0.019146747887134552,
0.502299427986145,
0.792012631893158,
-0.38905420899391174,
0.5697930455207825,
0.7358797788619995,
-0.10216575860977173,
0.7326728105545044,
0.2903261184692383,
-0.38419538736343384,
-0.33011335134506226,
0.7083739638328552,
-0.017727253958582878,
0.7393659353256226,
0.3918498456478119,
0.6606883406639099,
-0.21496343612670898,
-0.7479886412620544,
-0.5329725742340088,
0.1459687203168869,
-0.9360004663467407,
-0.16483591496944427,
-0.4813406765460968,
0.057111967355012894,
-0.1538248211145401,
-0.2645532488822937,
-0.08208159357309341,
-0.12057183682918549,
-0.354498952627182,
-0.21863935887813568,
0.2468947321176529,
0.9489189982414246,
0.2440118044614792,
0.5875554084777832,
-0.1487135887145996,
-0.10891282558441162,
0.5876416563987732,
0.18629799783229828,
0.05769292637705803,
-0.6044851541519165,
-0.3631119132041931,
-0.16878488659858704,
-0.5325927138328552,
-0.7490240931510925,
0.186028853058815,
0.6559932231903076,
1.0804229974746704,
0.9785160422325134,
0.10240735113620758,
0.6586447954177856,
-0.23666439950466156,
0.766914963722229,
-0.010038955137133598,
-0.9840015769004822,
0.6373099088668823,
0.0073743038810789585,
0.13646116852760315,
0.7434245944023132,
0.4103052020072937,
-0.13325081765651703,
-0.5237075090408325,
-0.8385348320007324,
-0.5403153896331787,
0.6216638088226318,
0.06292666494846344,
0.05540316551923752,
0.025700638070702553,
0.35479536652565,
0.2282574325799942,
0.0606258362531662,
-0.6301917433738708,
-0.33080005645751953,
0.039556942880153656,
-0.05931650102138519,
0.15841256082057953,
-0.12684063613414764,
-0.10559341311454773,
-0.48850107192993164,
0.7478664517402649,
-0.37386199831962585,
-0.18250565230846405,
0.18669377267360687,
-0.3573910593986511,
-0.061751581728458405,
0.05281069129705429,
0.8043910264968872,
0.7962062954902649,
-0.1271437704563141,
0.0458085760474205,
0.7260310053825378,
-0.3110729455947876,
0.005598810501396656,
-0.34137070178985596,
-0.3490075469017029,
0.19100743532180786,
0.6576454043388367,
0.9312277436256409,
0.6749058961868286,
-0.9345266819000244,
1.017872929573059,
0.07220876216888428,
-0.25992223620414734,
-0.3901463449001312,
0.25895893573760986,
-0.32863715291023254,
0.5248838663101196,
0.2720710039138794,
-0.263852059841156,
0.21974165737628937,
-0.38804352283477783,
0.37765926122665405,
0.5703489780426025,
-0.8157964944839478,
-0.27821701765060425,
0.3833611309528351,
-0.02745935507118702,
-0.046629998832941055,
0.3035722076892853,
-0.15602782368659973,
-0.5471968054771423,
0.6789245009422302,
0.816108763217926,
0.7008605599403381,
-0.0863279402256012,
0.25064989924430847,
0.32229873538017273,
-0.10019628703594208,
-0.20268477499485016,
-0.12040255218744278,
-0.17280371487140656,
-0.5637902617454529,
-0.4774228036403656,
-0.28822553157806396,
-0.6470577120780945,
0.224679633975029,
-0.6079962253570557,
0.6591024994850159,
-0.4881027042865753,
0.19799862802028656,
-0.2101702094078064,
-0.015047142282128334,
-0.6055198311805725,
0.06772489100694656,
0.23285865783691406,
0.9544355273246765,
-1.0606685876846313,
1.1986039876937866,
0.6478924751281738,
-0.13476793467998505,
-0.6596719622612,
0.2904056906700134,
0.15024921298027039,
-0.5364060997962952,
1.0673514604568481,
0.056926146149635315,
-0.18902376294136047,
-0.009529396891593933,
-1.1286031007766724,
-0.6879199743270874,
1.136093020439148,
0.4948340058326721,
-0.10572804510593414,
0.5378754138946533,
-0.1418834775686264,
0.4218633472919464,
-0.9608792662620544,
0.5084874629974365,
0.4745946228504181,
0.43060651421546936,
0.24331092834472656,
-0.5584678053855896,
-0.21602793037891388,
0.24750223755836487,
-0.08437779545783997,
0.04177314043045044,
-0.7804570198059082,
0.4663541913032532,
-0.09174202382564545,
-0.1998298019170761,
-0.15185926854610443,
0.8023723363876343,
0.40689077973365784,
0.3114200234413147,
0.905407726764679,
-0.0880168005824089,
0.5839554071426392,
0.295294851064682,
1.0558651685714722,
0.0197641309350729,
0.3092367947101593,
1.2022854089736938,
-0.09750612080097198,
0.9577458500862122,
0.6714436411857605,
-0.09239830821752548,
0.6601859331130981,
0.46674540638923645,
0.05368567630648613,
0.8369701504707336,
0.3328326642513275,
-0.359027236700058,
-0.3531256318092346,
-0.0933079645037651,
-0.033134348690509796,
0.5451219081878662,
0.5405943989753723,
-0.3593556880950928,
-0.4298599064350128,
0.30591580271720886,
0.1985224485397339,
-0.0026368803810328245,
-0.1137167438864708,
0.8169898390769958,
-0.06439168751239777,
-0.41467195749282837,
0.40438878536224365,
-0.46539390087127686,
0.6023719310760498,
-0.8391505479812622,
-0.4756729304790497,
-0.2056664079427719,
0.08848263323307037,
-0.19907249510288239,
-0.39958563446998596,
-0.08178076893091202,
-0.09609450399875641,
0.08881163597106934,
-0.254550039768219,
0.5836539268493652,
-0.43226343393325806,
-0.2800324857234955,
0.6065713167190552,
0.20940282940864563,
0.14113491773605347,
0.06181768327951431,
-0.21450458467006683,
-0.04515843093395233,
0.25625479221343994,
-0.2689487338066101,
0.7584025859832764,
0.136827751994133,
-0.3754555881023407,
0.6445232629776001,
0.5031095743179321,
0.0876791849732399,
-0.08680704236030579,
0.03888744115829468,
1.0651793479919434,
-0.1875154674053192,
-0.16805347800254822,
-0.9395357966423035,
0.5078413486480713,
-0.26722314953804016,
-0.5026997923851013,
0.6602570414543152,
0.4800586402416229,
1.1327998638153076,
0.055740777403116226,
0.8822029829025269,
0.015300870873034,
0.43194296956062317,
-0.5712454319000244,
0.606174111366272,
-0.6213275790214539,
0.34053322672843933,
-0.4979148805141449,
-0.5908271074295044,
-0.43817824125289917,
0.4895045757293701,
-0.3058379888534546,
-0.39339014887809753,
0.6653116941452026,
0.761096179485321,
-0.1967158317565918,
0.06891992688179016,
0.523750364780426,
0.04996020346879959,
0.6271178722381592,
0.3673388659954071,
0.932121992111206,
-0.14014814794063568,
0.5990280508995056,
-0.6079127192497253,
-0.46277832984924316,
-0.2789675295352936,
-1.1541001796722412,
-1.2539466619491577,
-0.526357114315033,
-0.3056941330432892,
-0.07824781537055969,
-0.27327829599380493,
1.5057482719421387,
0.8784328103065491,
-0.9617424607276917,
-0.4147394597530365,
0.31899699568748474,
0.23586179316043854,
-0.5356853008270264,
-0.13205072283744812,
0.6640020608901978,
-0.496952086687088,
-0.970892608165741,
0.8661869764328003,
0.030856486409902573,
-0.0653819590806961,
-0.17190735042095184,
-0.18473570048809052,
-0.15904267132282257,
-0.2302945852279663,
0.6501548290252686,
0.2227264791727066,
-0.6581196188926697,
-0.45818033814430237,
-0.32059404253959656,
0.2830730974674225,
0.0176085252314806,
0.9607841968536377,
-0.8340694308280945,
0.5703343152999878,
0.5203657150268555,
0.7203611731529236,
0.6918814182281494,
-0.10285890102386475,
0.5018144845962524,
-0.8863966464996338,
0.2550305128097534,
-0.03582615405321121,
0.47861313819885254,
0.08543358743190765,
-0.42908093333244324,
0.41080614924430847,
-0.020258266478776932,
-0.5814990997314453,
-0.6621400117874146,
0.08831916004419327,
-0.620036244392395,
-0.28570905327796936,
1.5041629076004028,
-0.1967695653438568,
-0.06877722591161728,
-0.15205921232700348,
-0.23432470858097076,
-0.06148093193769455,
-0.5646567940711975,
0.4461797773838043,
0.45776695013046265,
-0.5060619115829468,
-0.03964094817638397,
-0.7051443457603455,
0.7582888007164001,
0.20577479898929596,
-0.5764094591140747,
-0.20925825834274292,
0.2654503285884857,
0.4035886228084564,
-0.17629723250865936,
0.27088192105293274,
-0.09359556436538696,
-0.045934222638607025,
-0.5763716101646423,
-0.11292506009340286,
-0.03845730051398277,
-0.3415519893169403,
-0.62201327085495,
0.3421971797943115,
0.28773194551467896,
-0.0662410780787468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11746v1 | Language Models are Homer Simpson! Safety Re-Alignment of Fine-tuned Language Models through Task Arithmetic | 2024-02-19T00:18:09 | 2024-02-19T00:18:09 | Rishabh Bhardwaj, Do Duc Anh, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aligned language models face a significant limitation as their fine-tuning
often results in compromised safety. To tackle this, we propose a simple method
RESTA that performs LLM safety realignment. RESTA stands for REstoring Safety
through Task Arithmetic. At its core, it involves a simple arithmetic addition
of a safety vector to the weights of the compromised model. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of RESTA in both parameter-efficient and full fine-tuning,
covering a wide range of downstream tasks, including instruction following in
Chinese, English, and Hindi, as well as problem-solving capabilities in Code
and Math. We also showcase the generalizability of RESTA on three existing
safety evaluation benchmarks and a multilingual benchmark dataset proposed as a
part of this work, consisting of 550 harmful questions covering 11 categories,
each with 5 sub-categories of harm. Overall, RESTA decreases the harmfulness of
the compromised model from 18.6% to 5.1% and from 9.2% to 1.5% in
parameter-efficient and full fine-tuning, respectively, while maintaining most
of the model's performance on the task. We release the source codes at:
https://github.com/declare-lab/resta. | [
0.17633163928985596,
-0.8834097385406494,
0.48948535323143005,
0.13593555986881256,
-0.2982434034347534,
0.09655012935400009,
-0.1685234159231186,
-0.5578752160072327,
0.09261263906955719,
0.5446341037750244,
-0.5311486721038818,
-0.5417299270629883,
-0.6676938533782959,
-0.04164305701851845,
-0.29844361543655396,
0.8335908651351929,
-0.19216907024383545,
0.11700326949357986,
0.09167051315307617,
-0.0008768226252868772,
-0.6898322701454163,
-0.5495028495788574,
-0.7371795773506165,
-0.06884398311376572,
0.8067896366119385,
0.3699672520160675,
0.9057452082633972,
1.0283995866775513,
0.7899069786071777,
0.41782134771347046,
-0.010045618750154972,
0.0290203969925642,
-0.6659881472587585,
0.03247363492846489,
-0.24276778101921082,
-0.4861888587474823,
-0.5124489665031433,
-0.17746716737747192,
0.43237927556037903,
0.7720686197280884,
-0.4104754328727722,
0.25144335627555847,
-0.3139338791370392,
0.9119915962219238,
-0.9263991117477417,
0.058882713317871094,
-0.5861213207244873,
-0.21663643419742584,
-0.10275298357009888,
-0.04605682194232941,
-0.529887318611145,
-0.609217643737793,
-0.24505367875099182,
-0.551325798034668,
-0.32187530398368835,
0.19364386796951294,
0.9759517312049866,
0.6832849383354187,
-0.3966107666492462,
0.11057019978761673,
-0.5944360494613647,
0.9955787658691406,
-0.8613411784172058,
0.7380241751670837,
0.2610708773136139,
0.3291146457195282,
-0.35799330472946167,
-0.3082141578197479,
-0.4920574724674225,
0.05993659421801567,
0.05332885682582855,
-0.1804078370332718,
-0.10388532280921936,
0.023403728380799294,
0.07322262972593307,
0.09274563193321228,
-0.5310676097869873,
0.1948845535516739,
-0.44458743929862976,
-0.16941401362419128,
0.784430742263794,
0.30463913083076477,
0.8537833094596863,
0.1614282876253128,
-0.2517143785953522,
-0.16275283694267273,
-1.090375304222107,
0.07020062208175659,
0.406337171792984,
0.6644973158836365,
-0.13894109427928925,
0.5735700130462646,
-0.2811407446861267,
0.8806782960891724,
-0.11398288607597351,
-0.39912867546081543,
0.2522454857826233,
-0.28050878643989563,
-0.43315112590789795,
0.1583210974931717,
0.7111829519271851,
0.5018975734710693,
0.39809027314186096,
-0.2953474521636963,
-0.15057440102100372,
-0.0018439776031300426,
0.7066174149513245,
-0.6844773292541504,
0.1258532702922821,
0.07670663297176361,
-0.21887651085853577,
-0.35649678111076355,
-0.35499051213264465,
-0.40114638209342957,
-0.07300067692995071,
-0.6089833378791809,
0.4351659417152405,
-0.48003003001213074,
-0.26944342255592346,
0.44395893812179565,
0.5149092078208923,
0.2954396605491638,
0.06520271301269531,
-1.1498788595199585,
0.07916919887065887,
1.2249678373336792,
0.5869471430778503,
0.047165073454380035,
-0.3100329041481018,
-0.44784659147262573,
0.19437438249588013,
-0.601184606552124,
0.5959606170654297,
-0.6584814190864563,
-0.1862650364637375,
0.0709780603647232,
0.3100876808166504,
-0.3044906556606293,
-0.35958075523376465,
0.7138493061065674,
-0.6559048891067505,
0.17611004412174225,
-0.19892406463623047,
-0.2885392904281616,
-0.4759775996208191,
0.22208021581172943,
-0.5688779354095459,
0.7214177846908569,
-0.09526485204696655,
-0.6640328168869019,
0.016647696495056152,
-0.02778223529458046,
-0.7292976379394531,
-0.5204660296440125,
0.05107424780726433,
-0.5644857883453369,
-0.07873943448066711,
0.10284634679555893,
0.08441228419542313,
-0.1193297728896141,
0.2988324761390686,
-0.2875592112541199,
-0.3585643768310547,
0.14552035927772522,
-0.34229740500450134,
0.8456577062606812,
0.25038355588912964,
-0.07995493710041046,
0.31664443016052246,
-0.6639015674591064,
0.1697666198015213,
-0.04798748716711998,
-0.4942067861557007,
-0.628392219543457,
-0.01972959376871586,
-0.2804630994796753,
0.25631552934646606,
0.4578644037246704,
-0.5671625137329102,
-0.03991687297821045,
-0.7312095165252686,
0.0107822734862566,
0.6878246068954468,
-0.05073348805308342,
0.2538444697856903,
-0.4515165388584137,
0.4924199879169464,
-0.16724038124084473,
0.14669586718082428,
0.16187255084514618,
-0.3498089611530304,
-0.7922589182853699,
-0.2974683940410614,
0.34532609581947327,
0.8742111325263977,
-0.48308274149894714,
0.509638249874115,
-0.3908016085624695,
-0.5021466016769409,
-0.8396645188331604,
0.07056494057178497,
0.9342793226242065,
0.7133175134658813,
0.37603485584259033,
-0.16396787762641907,
-0.5756162405014038,
-0.9016187191009521,
-0.48658424615859985,
-0.2662269175052643,
0.027915850281715393,
-0.24939772486686707,
-0.006787769962102175,
-0.2688470482826233,
0.46963512897491455,
-0.34028562903404236,
-0.06549406796693802,
-0.12839137017726898,
-0.007030893117189407,
0.01902146264910698,
0.7033373713493347,
0.30665332078933716,
-0.49199509620666504,
-0.31315675377845764,
-0.06489092111587524,
-0.7113456726074219,
-0.25490206480026245,
-0.11280135810375214,
-0.48019954562187195,
0.35753870010375977,
0.31423768401145935,
-0.5064792037010193,
0.2050725817680359,
0.6230243444442749,
-0.3137819468975067,
0.33924198150634766,
0.024338698014616966,
0.2548859119415283,
-1.3902692794799805,
-0.08239980041980743,
-0.05466867983341217,
-0.307995080947876,
-0.8599473834037781,
0.49898678064346313,
0.1952238827943802,
-0.09291929751634598,
-0.646324098110199,
0.28403112292289734,
-0.37049970030784607,
0.16571907699108124,
-0.45514506101608276,
0.182540163397789,
-0.2614120841026306,
0.4882362484931946,
-0.19081246852874756,
0.7244902849197388,
0.5769559144973755,
-0.5290234684944153,
0.018235381692647934,
0.1807318776845932,
-0.1788177341222763,
0.3188254237174988,
-0.5738614201545715,
0.057756174355745316,
-0.04050751030445099,
-0.17362995445728302,
-0.903107762336731,
-0.12313572317361832,
0.3822402060031891,
-0.28403738141059875,
0.5816838145256042,
-0.27716949582099915,
-0.12691614031791687,
0.2980327308177948,
-0.12577089667320251,
0.6637922525405884,
0.611399233341217,
-0.4122714400291443,
0.6268696188926697,
0.7893680930137634,
-0.42066290974617004,
-0.943943977355957,
-0.575206995010376,
0.02309776470065117,
-0.16494596004486084,
-0.8104065656661987,
0.11900132149457932,
0.22314630448818207,
-0.44616764783859253,
-0.039328064769506454,
-0.33435165882110596,
-0.041327767074108124,
0.27737152576446533,
0.3483198881149292,
0.4873502552509308,
-0.10824820399284363,
-0.0753425881266594,
0.12858787178993225,
-0.48699167370796204,
0.10008561611175537,
0.3391660749912262,
0.3105151653289795,
-0.10356089472770691,
-0.6002766489982605,
-0.5555847883224487,
0.24153465032577515,
0.46460914611816406,
-0.2963005304336548,
0.659460186958313,
0.07193988561630249,
-0.5987978577613831,
0.18974994122982025,
-0.43552476167678833,
-0.1371299773454666,
-0.5224730372428894,
0.3861094117164612,
-0.25510555505752563,
-0.8681842088699341,
0.3893079459667206,
0.07096762210130692,
0.5857645869255066,
0.3177153170108795,
0.5755119323730469,
0.12319986522197723,
1.1043524742126465,
0.7585289478302002,
-0.2313680201768875,
0.39176222681999207,
0.3065136969089508,
0.76183021068573,
-0.5528152585029602,
-0.16413359344005585,
-0.6471073031425476,
-0.31212741136550903,
-0.5172160863876343,
-0.4970887005329132,
0.18800237774848938,
0.093607097864151,
-0.31063008308410645,
0.5961840152740479,
-0.396317720413208,
0.5747571587562561,
0.3051387071609497,
0.15865406394004822,
0.34536436200141907,
-0.10763225704431534,
0.29266056418418884,
-0.14778748154640198,
-0.419599324464798,
-0.8059101104736328,
0.861931324005127,
0.4564070999622345,
1.0573697090148926,
0.43991315364837646,
0.9348807334899902,
-0.17138782143592834,
0.49899113178253174,
-0.7489204406738281,
0.7709479928016663,
-0.27988389134407043,
-0.5081063508987427,
-0.46761295199394226,
-0.533935546875,
-0.8948241472244263,
0.4308188259601593,
-0.14044906198978424,
-0.6127736568450928,
0.04226120188832283,
0.07291810214519501,
-0.5220770239830017,
0.2810610830783844,
-0.9084998369216919,
0.8800943493843079,
-0.4865861237049103,
-0.2156241536140442,
-0.5836330056190491,
-0.5149626731872559,
0.7049850821495056,
-0.06205615773797035,
0.48133689165115356,
-0.5259878635406494,
-0.0860549807548523,
0.6894992589950562,
-0.4719298481941223,
1.0417336225509644,
0.08860881626605988,
-0.5964059829711914,
0.052183255553245544,
0.29750528931617737,
0.6332254409790039,
-0.26377934217453003,
0.026081997901201248,
0.19925746321678162,
0.21896852552890778,
-0.40474092960357666,
-0.6001594066619873,
0.8603951930999756,
-0.5520625710487366,
-0.8662477731704712,
-0.4541153013706207,
-0.7288167476654053,
-0.4016875922679901,
0.5335333347320557,
-0.38770127296447754,
0.35655462741851807,
0.023655058816075325,
-0.054382845759391785,
0.5404049158096313,
-0.21332533657550812,
0.48893219232559204,
0.9835147261619568,
-0.06688280403614044,
-0.3515329658985138,
1.1366554498672485,
-0.04766815900802612,
0.32451528310775757,
0.493012934923172,
-0.12999972701072693,
-0.32043102383613586,
-0.5247461795806885,
-0.6372449398040771,
0.2848988175392151,
-0.6484128832817078,
-0.3015695810317993,
-0.4635055959224701,
-0.04429501295089722,
-0.3948538899421692,
-0.249030202627182,
-0.5561772584915161,
-0.661553144454956,
-0.07383106648921967,
-0.3588085174560547,
0.07986674457788467,
0.41971585154533386,
0.02291039377450943,
0.08044954389333725,
-0.9209117293357849,
0.3930360972881317,
0.21681638062000275,
0.5778833031654358,
-0.2214568853378296,
-0.5921551585197449,
-0.2766770124435425,
0.15239238739013672,
-0.09591406583786011,
-0.6520307660102844,
0.2914799153804779,
-0.08846231549978256,
0.38323506712913513,
0.26783421635627747,
0.20087884366512299,
0.8451964259147644,
-0.8679670095443726,
0.41458138823509216,
0.28040409088134766,
-0.6822726726531982,
0.10015690326690674,
-0.10427369177341461,
-0.07781833410263062,
0.6621748805046082,
0.3069373667240143,
-0.6137784719467163,
-0.56510990858078,
-0.21702063083648682,
-0.9334244728088379,
0.4413769543170929,
0.010887589305639267,
0.30881789326667786,
-0.05215604975819588,
0.18116119503974915,
-0.03837982192635536,
-0.22656647861003876,
-0.5221936106681824,
-0.07388695329427719,
0.06982447952032089,
-0.5942320823669434,
0.3827282786369324,
-0.4440995454788208,
-0.567959189414978,
0.11056238412857056,
1.0104260444641113,
0.02698010765016079,
-0.1596754789352417,
-0.2817036211490631,
-0.06988321244716644,
-0.4408664405345917,
0.5908285975456238,
0.8133410811424255,
0.8001781105995178,
-0.15026983618736267,
0.2815420627593994,
0.2253497838973999,
-0.3574810028076172,
0.3260064125061035,
0.19006489217281342,
-0.2989935874938965,
-0.2806273102760315,
0.43302303552627563,
0.47992923855781555,
0.6980749368667603,
-0.8873099684715271,
0.09855891019105911,
-0.13788150250911713,
0.16243460774421692,
0.03621231019496918,
0.408498078584671,
0.1378723531961441,
0.04048101231455803,
0.06310374289751053,
-0.16930188238620758,
-0.14204563200473785,
-0.44869571924209595,
0.3654094636440277,
0.4063800275325775,
-0.17500343918800354,
-0.37435382604599,
0.7694437503814697,
0.4672030806541443,
-0.5507757663726807,
0.2370476871728897,
0.02995937503874302,
-0.367577463388443,
0.46749043464660645,
0.6404918432235718,
1.0584224462509155,
-0.2707262337207794,
-0.13550782203674316,
0.5317865014076233,
0.6424111723899841,
-0.19692440330982208,
0.6495150327682495,
0.678059995174408,
-0.7006031274795532,
-0.6997056603431702,
-0.6876224279403687,
-0.4688986837863922,
-0.23221659660339355,
-0.5150421857833862,
-0.08072353899478912,
-0.47330373525619507,
0.002818390494212508,
-0.1982678771018982,
-0.28791213035583496,
0.00117215933278203,
0.3477821350097656,
0.0929945781826973,
0.8081022500991821,
-0.8906817436218262,
0.7075220942497253,
0.6338424682617188,
-0.45154696702957153,
-1.0108485221862793,
0.02359296940267086,
0.005500711500644684,
-0.9421139359474182,
0.343191921710968,
0.14138826727867126,
-0.4287422299385071,
-0.07184725999832153,
-0.37774425745010376,
-1.1912097930908203,
0.7827288508415222,
0.7577998042106628,
-1.0201245546340942,
0.10814981162548065,
0.3067677915096283,
0.6041198968887329,
-0.08972006291151047,
-0.14980269968509674,
0.6406941413879395,
0.3435978591442108,
-0.17472490668296814,
-1.0085678100585938,
0.4871445298194885,
-0.07072731852531433,
-0.08992871642112732,
0.37637263536453247,
-0.7270351052284241,
0.4881705939769745,
-0.47596508264541626,
-0.5352223515510559,
-0.023266034200787544,
0.6852354407310486,
0.5541090965270996,
0.15411731600761414,
0.5738310217857361,
1.0437475442886353,
0.6121073365211487,
-0.2824440598487854,
1.0046656131744385,
-0.672786295413971,
0.23185212910175323,
1.0695838928222656,
-0.1411464363336563,
1.012067437171936,
0.6213932633399963,
-0.23249433934688568,
0.4293636381626129,
0.6371414661407471,
0.6501685976982117,
0.557472288608551,
-0.021075904369354248,
-0.20093397796154022,
-0.5165697932243347,
-0.04149523004889488,
-0.30449432134628296,
0.06008080765604973,
0.10091941058635712,
-0.0531056709587574,
-0.22845673561096191,
-0.3909345865249634,
0.35192224383354187,
0.1310470998287201,
-0.15642592310905457,
0.7661111354827881,
0.22898639738559723,
-0.7919477224349976,
0.9401956796646118,
0.20857107639312744,
0.33313706517219543,
-0.4025336503982544,
-0.03949497640132904,
-0.38129183650016785,
0.31623250246047974,
-0.2516344487667084,
-0.7143099308013916,
0.5906754732131958,
0.0641247108578682,
-0.12563396990299225,
-0.1605244129896164,
0.5420774817466736,
-0.7502222657203674,
-0.7279683351516724,
0.10315360128879547,
0.08008536696434021,
0.04387904331088066,
0.30732160806655884,
-0.6602562069892883,
0.1611713320016861,
0.03824303299188614,
-0.11314339190721512,
0.5256262421607971,
0.3616528809070587,
-0.2520065903663635,
1.0474234819412231,
0.6542726755142212,
-0.11293213814496994,
0.25904393196105957,
0.11838823556900024,
0.7689084410667419,
-0.7404397130012512,
-0.41779306530952454,
-0.8452460765838623,
0.4913524389266968,
0.36936795711517334,
-0.004418977070599794,
0.6492312550544739,
0.5645464062690735,
0.934742271900177,
-0.03484189882874489,
0.6639026999473572,
-0.10331927984952927,
0.5248775482177734,
-0.704251229763031,
0.6320206522941589,
-0.591842770576477,
0.26518023014068604,
-0.08774113655090332,
-0.5073585510253906,
-0.44040194153785706,
0.39233142137527466,
-0.4159504175186157,
-0.262470006942749,
0.462283730506897,
1.0751420259475708,
-0.10813333839178085,
-0.23869143426418304,
0.32394081354141235,
-0.009121192619204521,
0.43585193157196045,
0.5542412996292114,
0.47161686420440674,
-0.48483166098594666,
0.5751543045043945,
-0.4947061538696289,
-0.12508103251457214,
-0.21942657232284546,
-0.783007025718689,
-0.7352386116981506,
-0.1937449723482132,
-0.40476542711257935,
-0.2706484794616699,
0.20304450392723083,
0.8487804532051086,
0.6645703911781311,
-1.197089433670044,
-0.01397642120718956,
0.1709573119878769,
0.5024413466453552,
-0.39107945561408997,
-0.1394074410200119,
0.4019428491592407,
-0.7002786993980408,
-0.8865665197372437,
0.6594553589820862,
0.34385862946510315,
-0.07669872790575027,
-0.06839846819639206,
-0.17148688435554504,
-0.222358837723732,
0.19914168119430542,
0.34769344329833984,
0.6029545664787292,
-0.8067622184753418,
-0.5519821047782898,
-0.1727433204650879,
-0.4130657911300659,
-0.2520211935043335,
0.6254538297653198,
-0.12792286276817322,
0.47897106409072876,
0.6992967128753662,
1.1437402963638306,
-0.36807140707969666,
0.5314623117446899,
0.8791868686676025,
-0.7460344433784485,
0.2470865696668625,
-0.0623646005988121,
0.6050137877464294,
0.4303959608078003,
-0.39658960700035095,
0.6603009700775146,
0.010494422167539597,
-0.5899828672409058,
-1.0183252096176147,
0.33897465467453003,
-0.9562695622444153,
-0.0766461193561554,
1.0842019319534302,
-0.09576619416475296,
-0.40942659974098206,
-0.12321297824382782,
-0.33910444378852844,
0.4595256745815277,
-0.26047155261039734,
1.3326115608215332,
0.4085370600223541,
-0.01666215993463993,
-0.17985869944095612,
-0.3039608597755432,
0.48717543482780457,
0.7752223610877991,
-0.9324955940246582,
0.3912540376186371,
0.4667743742465973,
0.5297449231147766,
0.10386724770069122,
0.405878484249115,
-0.16883376240730286,
0.35019221901893616,
-0.42847684025764465,
0.23743391036987305,
-0.14734293520450592,
-0.27641838788986206,
-0.2019498646259308,
-0.06369853764772415,
0.06169411167502403,
-0.4746449589729309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11744v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11744v2 | Machine-Generated Text Localization | 2024-02-19T00:07:28 | 2024-06-10T19:20:20 | Zhongping Zhang, Wenda Qin, Bryan A. Plummer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine-Generated Text (MGT) detection aims to identify a piece of text as
machine or human written. Prior work has primarily formulated MGT detection as
a binary classification task over an entire document, with limited work
exploring cases where only part of a document is machine generated. This paper
provides the first in-depth study of MGT that localizes the portions of a
document that were machine generated. Thus, if a bad actor were to change a key
portion of a news article to spread misinformation, whole document MGT
detection may fail since the vast majority is human written, but our approach
can succeed due to its granular approach. A key challenge in our MGT
localization task is that short spans of text, e.g., a single sentence,
provides little information indicating if it is machine generated due to its
short length. To address this, we leverage contextual information, where we
predict whether multiple sentences are machine or human written at once. This
enables our approach to identify changes in style or content to boost
performance. A gain of 4-13% mean Average Precision (mAP) over prior work
demonstrates the effectiveness of approach on five diverse datasets: GoodNews,
VisualNews, WikiText, Essay, and WP. We release our implementation at
https://github.com/Zhongping-Zhang/MGT_Localization. | [
-0.3324701488018036,
-1.1258352994918823,
0.6486347913742065,
-0.030507855117321014,
-0.34818097949028015,
-0.0782032459974289,
-0.3097211718559265,
-0.43867507576942444,
0.18310904502868652,
0.38080859184265137,
-0.5151826739311218,
-0.7261359691619873,
-0.7244637608528137,
0.19187161326408386,
-0.27545925974845886,
1.0892428159713745,
-0.20887070894241333,
-0.395744651556015,
0.10204589366912842,
0.17647258937358856,
-0.556262731552124,
-0.7779443860054016,
-0.6967664361000061,
-0.2310202568769455,
0.46684446930885315,
0.2944224774837494,
0.6403557658195496,
0.7335240244865417,
0.5848367810249329,
0.2061718851327896,
0.003435604739934206,
0.41283994913101196,
-0.37083911895751953,
-0.09642679989337921,
-0.04539197310805321,
-0.2823432385921478,
-0.019169427454471588,
-0.13639867305755615,
0.663130521774292,
0.2726270258426666,
0.2919803559780121,
-0.10087919235229492,
0.016930345445871353,
0.46638432145118713,
-0.40874233841896057,
-0.05331990867853165,
-0.6281042098999023,
0.17165665328502655,
-0.43078529834747314,
-0.3102818429470062,
-0.5263354778289795,
-0.20807261765003204,
-0.03048725239932537,
-0.44170182943344116,
0.6590410470962524,
-0.09293793886899948,
0.8949843049049377,
0.17055532336235046,
-0.690525233745575,
-0.5350282788276672,
-0.6852865815162659,
0.5591535568237305,
-0.6078202128410339,
0.07057146728038788,
0.37330758571624756,
0.14431755244731903,
-0.3392370045185089,
-0.6334182620048523,
-0.5063101649284363,
-0.03693457320332527,
-0.4166114926338196,
0.060027074068784714,
-0.2363014817237854,
-0.1943986713886261,
0.24496209621429443,
0.201436385512352,
-0.7795795798301697,
-0.19692565500736237,
-0.2447027713060379,
-0.48924800753593445,
0.4347490966320038,
-0.21183162927627563,
0.5439664721488953,
-0.3498521149158478,
-0.43765681982040405,
0.1645561158657074,
-0.31963086128234863,
-0.2720882296562195,
0.2866339087486267,
0.36079466342926025,
0.019984673708677292,
0.43169817328453064,
-0.22053273022174835,
0.7705907225608826,
0.017582999542355537,
-0.4274787902832031,
0.18770429491996765,
-0.38340744376182556,
-0.13255491852760315,
0.39503365755081177,
0.9662811160087585,
0.20310121774673462,
0.17158058285713196,
-0.18338850140571594,
-0.3942995071411133,
-0.13409605622291565,
0.3344617486000061,
-0.8195690512657166,
-0.041382964700460434,
-0.17988073825836182,
-0.36226534843444824,
-0.2820851802825928,
0.4107062816619873,
-0.1357385367155075,
-0.5402421355247498,
-0.47478967905044556,
0.63343745470047,
-0.48457279801368713,
-0.14017154276371002,
0.08809458464384079,
-0.07272791117429733,
-0.08487334102392197,
0.014950983226299286,
-0.7691326141357422,
-0.4097227156162262,
0.5678760409355164,
1.0830464363098145,
-0.2006276398897171,
-0.5213309526443481,
-0.23563657701015472,
0.27231091260910034,
-0.3020639419555664,
1.0525940656661987,
-0.0565669946372509,
-0.29545965790748596,
-0.0216895192861557,
0.16825152933597565,
-0.2929179072380066,
-0.46156227588653564,
0.7219672799110413,
-0.1573851853609085,
0.3654686212539673,
-0.3826289474964142,
-0.16437400877475739,
-0.05627291649580002,
0.5383030772209167,
-0.5802053809165955,
1.0839581489562988,
0.32440394163131714,
-1.1626009941101074,
0.6150681972503662,
-0.8699804544448853,
-0.8996832966804504,
-0.2602076232433319,
0.20780189335346222,
-0.7123533487319946,
0.05299227684736252,
0.5160906910896301,
0.5477441549301147,
0.3098997473716736,
0.33860498666763306,
0.1596350222826004,
-0.6434017419815063,
0.13298429548740387,
-0.6599504947662354,
0.3850448727607727,
0.23906077444553375,
-0.4659976363182068,
0.03019856847822666,
-0.4864002466201782,
-0.2963939607143402,
0.04619926959276199,
-0.4359120726585388,
-0.29081472754478455,
-0.062011633068323135,
0.234147310256958,
0.2092398703098297,
0.2905957102775574,
-0.3873583972454071,
0.4237075746059418,
-0.13133551180362701,
0.24607393145561218,
0.526901364326477,
0.18762706220149994,
0.35686370730400085,
-0.12936927378177643,
0.40992841124534607,
0.13729281723499298,
0.09063316881656647,
-0.42284923791885376,
-0.42746788263320923,
-0.550790548324585,
-0.2287895828485489,
0.2802369296550751,
0.7219257354736328,
-1.035284399986267,
0.23701205849647522,
-0.2699911892414093,
-0.2987156808376312,
-0.15711721777915955,
-0.008438902907073498,
0.29822054505348206,
0.4416166841983795,
0.25697264075279236,
-0.06705290824174881,
-0.6422865390777588,
-0.7863216996192932,
-0.4765739440917969,
-0.011931768618524075,
-0.13272084295749664,
-0.14122305810451508,
0.5965635776519775,
-0.5651612877845764,
1.204352855682373,
-0.6125006079673767,
-0.45028477907180786,
-0.15387728810310364,
0.782436728477478,
-0.041953589767217636,
0.2936597764492035,
0.565119743347168,
-0.7902776598930359,
-0.5380109548568726,
0.3921695053577423,
-0.9639392495155334,
-0.2944124937057495,
-0.2990066409111023,
-0.16322249174118042,
0.3389522135257721,
0.5894975662231445,
-0.46919795870780945,
0.5355579853057861,
0.374500036239624,
-0.33308035135269165,
0.46218299865722656,
-0.24748672544956207,
0.39024537801742554,
-1.4892489910125732,
-0.054245155304670334,
0.0031479618046432734,
-0.36962437629699707,
-0.6734052300453186,
-0.1370997577905655,
0.06154424324631691,
-0.2896558344364166,
-0.27277928590774536,
0.4224499464035034,
-0.632266104221344,
-0.10671548545360565,
-0.5418445467948914,
0.32199984788894653,
-0.07722996175289154,
0.33136996626853943,
-0.06905233860015869,
1.1036146879196167,
-0.09632766991853714,
-0.28656071424484253,
-0.009358708746731281,
-0.1156391128897667,
-0.24501797556877136,
0.7372090816497803,
-0.22443971037864685,
0.32927238941192627,
-0.27536800503730774,
0.38648274540901184,
-0.8680801391601562,
-0.3504464030265808,
0.2909049689769745,
-0.7310139536857605,
0.08003877103328705,
-0.32521477341651917,
-0.8280530571937561,
-0.24240341782569885,
0.05685466527938843,
0.11866941303014755,
0.09386065602302551,
-0.36498579382896423,
0.38453158736228943,
0.2721428871154785,
-0.12954308092594147,
-0.36447203159332275,
-0.6863294839859009,
0.32014381885528564,
-0.09082170575857162,
-0.7946034073829651,
0.2240825593471527,
0.17505234479904175,
0.048639994114637375,
-0.15767580270767212,
-0.062491003423929214,
-0.28757938742637634,
0.16395625472068787,
0.07513703405857086,
-0.10512643307447433,
-0.46195706725120544,
0.31247514486312866,
0.1380520462989807,
-0.2747345566749573,
-0.16313336789608002,
-0.5951047539710999,
0.3982669413089752,
0.0021306134294718504,
-0.282404363155365,
-0.35914942622184753,
0.4181723892688751,
0.5139070153236389,
-0.307285338640213,
0.6316595673561096,
1.428726315498352,
-0.5715072154998779,
0.11754975467920303,
-0.3084902763366699,
0.08005727827548981,
-0.38759878277778625,
0.16765987873077393,
-0.3727680444717407,
-0.8052932024002075,
0.3162897825241089,
0.016511008143424988,
-0.22557057440280914,
0.605636715888977,
0.32204800844192505,
0.10738545656204224,
1.0312600135803223,
0.7992427945137024,
-0.4157639145851135,
0.65128493309021,
-0.008147054351866245,
0.5918229222297668,
-0.38513126969337463,
0.1007421687245369,
-0.47331148386001587,
-0.25801602005958557,
-0.4644899368286133,
-0.4797793924808502,
0.3736923635005951,
0.26957690715789795,
0.15500366687774658,
0.5185991525650024,
-0.792019784450531,
0.8111099600791931,
0.5899967551231384,
0.17682236433029175,
0.29471349716186523,
-0.04365484043955803,
-0.12262675166130066,
0.06843763589859009,
-0.42238110303878784,
-0.7947402000427246,
0.7250922322273254,
0.022251740097999573,
0.3036405146121979,
0.05777836963534355,
0.7745020985603333,
0.6522796750068665,
0.5134291052818298,
-0.6599328517913818,
0.22785866260528564,
-0.0493866503238678,
-0.4162123203277588,
-0.32077348232269287,
-0.4592830538749695,
-1.0507363080978394,
0.2776282727718353,
-0.07937218248844147,
-0.6569687724113464,
-0.3618827760219574,
-0.025918368250131607,
-0.06414181739091873,
0.4934369623661041,
-1.08685302734375,
1.1367416381835938,
0.008158323355019093,
0.059004127979278564,
0.44796237349510193,
-0.6257379651069641,
0.12191648781299591,
-0.23131097853183746,
0.2205127477645874,
0.05294506996870041,
0.20559442043304443,
0.5226115584373474,
-0.12050279974937439,
0.715955913066864,
-0.17781049013137817,
-0.2813171148300171,
0.47436949610710144,
0.08505670726299286,
0.6865311861038208,
-0.061273034662008286,
0.050471577793359756,
0.08016528189182281,
-0.25776538252830505,
-0.48102957010269165,
-0.4445239305496216,
0.588264524936676,
-0.3759297728538513,
-0.0908568874001503,
-0.3371632993221283,
-0.5920379161834717,
0.1583448201417923,
0.6422385573387146,
0.7752183675765991,
0.3160974681377411,
-0.23348647356033325,
-0.007362447679042816,
0.7994688153266907,
0.03127623349428177,
0.6012745499610901,
0.3071172833442688,
-0.16376332938671112,
-0.37804949283599854,
0.9995202422142029,
0.10495451092720032,
-0.0807492807507515,
0.6653648614883423,
0.19761008024215698,
-0.09096043556928635,
-0.5907543897628784,
-0.6781180500984192,
-0.09209500998258591,
-0.7012963891029358,
-0.061085060238838196,
-0.5264434814453125,
-0.04739433899521828,
-0.4428085386753082,
-0.6352134346961975,
-0.10052409768104553,
0.10225797444581985,
-0.5231488347053528,
-0.10570813715457916,
-0.03435884043574333,
0.829755961894989,
0.04065190255641937,
0.8497651815414429,
-0.5833569169044495,
0.30775806307792664,
-0.0728287547826767,
0.038642074912786484,
-0.516168475151062,
-0.26344385743141174,
-0.5642027854919434,
0.02902846969664097,
-0.35349032282829285,
-0.7815879583358765,
0.3803147077560425,
-0.3443543314933777,
0.21596841514110565,
0.4294763207435608,
-0.1810189187526703,
0.47830721735954285,
-0.3349005877971649,
0.8832700848579407,
-0.03429993987083435,
-0.8916064500808716,
0.7233816385269165,
-0.7455037832260132,
0.7220776677131653,
0.4865662753582001,
0.15875166654586792,
-0.8282320499420166,
-0.3167516887187958,
-0.23103559017181396,
-0.5110942125320435,
0.46601590514183044,
0.3738441467285156,
0.10536538064479828,
-0.21304799616336823,
0.35558947920799255,
-0.02629692852497101,
0.02925232984125614,
-0.7608463168144226,
0.06972455233335495,
0.03952448070049286,
-0.28880301117897034,
-0.2745975852012634,
-0.13331057131290436,
0.253408819437027,
0.10546450316905975,
0.6414491534233093,
-0.3712918162345886,
0.49206453561782837,
0.41138339042663574,
-0.5635697245597839,
0.1344163864850998,
0.27644407749176025,
1.1419728994369507,
0.6660273671150208,
-0.13073097169399261,
0.20039135217666626,
0.03481803834438324,
-0.6778290271759033,
0.00853168498724699,
0.05246082693338394,
-0.4611837863922119,
0.5691317319869995,
0.4563342034816742,
0.6413185000419617,
0.07128787785768509,
-0.10525814443826675,
0.6451848745346069,
0.1313452273607254,
-0.10102424025535583,
-0.11004011332988739,
-0.35183724761009216,
-0.22653630375862122,
0.050436027348041534,
0.3782615065574646,
0.1681542694568634,
0.19396179914474487,
-0.4773351848125458,
0.3875235915184021,
0.2991173565387726,
-0.7355221509933472,
-0.2734968364238739,
0.5477871894836426,
0.11873844265937805,
-0.47583121061325073,
0.39743557572364807,
-0.49307823181152344,
-0.8688320517539978,
0.5601003170013428,
0.6966854333877563,
0.969315767288208,
0.04536709934473038,
0.3243160843849182,
0.30433374643325806,
0.7247667908668518,
-0.14775007963180542,
-0.14284534752368927,
0.005444178823381662,
-0.5389940142631531,
-0.2761557400226593,
-0.38863664865493774,
-0.08921511471271515,
0.01606038399040699,
-0.19657662510871887,
0.3642556369304657,
-0.14702080190181732,
-0.43089649081230164,
-0.07128270715475082,
0.022540226578712463,
-0.16113919019699097,
0.2625269591808319,
0.19963674247264862,
0.44812875986099243,
-0.8836902379989624,
0.606468141078949,
0.6068852543830872,
-0.3312038779258728,
-0.3568958640098572,
0.5146108269691467,
0.10569196939468384,
-0.47085005044937134,
0.14816288650035858,
0.5152356624603271,
-0.13021942973136902,
-0.1374409943819046,
-0.48050498962402344,
-0.5857327580451965,
1.1910265684127808,
0.3642847239971161,
-0.11145923286676407,
0.0567927248775959,
0.2780122756958008,
0.39354485273361206,
-0.14923714101314545,
-0.024955717846751213,
0.5454835891723633,
0.5543104410171509,
-0.28652507066726685,
-0.821690559387207,
-0.06917302310466766,
0.0018380949040874839,
0.1101120188832283,
0.7051514387130737,
-0.3767910301685333,
0.8859629034996033,
-0.1300930231809616,
-0.2238801270723343,
-0.15887022018432617,
0.5232940912246704,
-0.2082637995481491,
0.7003366351127625,
0.10056746006011963,
0.5521185398101807,
0.8929951786994934,
-0.24820935726165771,
1.066794753074646,
-0.010845703072845936,
0.5431528687477112,
0.9754700064659119,
0.16437000036239624,
0.44934582710266113,
0.3737756609916687,
0.25468000769615173,
0.35937726497650146,
0.7184216380119324,
0.11702874302864075,
0.24229560792446136,
0.17532603442668915,
-0.4659656584262848,
0.051240887492895126,
-0.05849974974989891,
-0.31197160482406616,
0.2159261703491211,
-0.16355673968791962,
-0.6606525778770447,
-0.1931447684764862,
0.269704669713974,
0.5048651099205017,
-0.009055267088115215,
-0.2997133135795593,
0.6633822321891785,
-0.2728531062602997,
-0.5434414744377136,
0.2858462929725647,
0.42417216300964355,
0.8395381569862366,
-0.503228485584259,
0.12757942080497742,
-0.2792881429195404,
0.20442986488342285,
-0.22599662840366364,
-0.733380138874054,
0.2814358174800873,
-0.01099823135882616,
-0.6266449689865112,
-0.22244144976139069,
1.1984941959381104,
-0.3331291973590851,
-0.5639731884002686,
-0.16264326870441437,
0.25371795892715454,
0.1967136561870575,
-0.6048687100410461,
-0.2713029682636261,
-0.06664962321519852,
0.10482868552207947,
-0.18567858636379242,
0.24163906276226044,
0.875901997089386,
-0.27418434619903564,
0.30602914094924927,
0.8289428949356079,
-0.34353187680244446,
0.07758230715990067,
-0.016963040456175804,
0.34945815801620483,
-0.5857618451118469,
-0.5421789288520813,
-0.9838941097259521,
0.3573615252971649,
-0.13681180775165558,
-0.445008784532547,
0.693001389503479,
0.8446211814880371,
0.9574517011642456,
-0.2621084749698639,
0.9699992537498474,
-0.061863746494054794,
0.1460193693637848,
-0.5766780376434326,
0.9463748931884766,
-0.36409860849380493,
-0.1384856253862381,
-0.3829527497291565,
-0.8243528008460999,
-0.5240797996520996,
0.4336109161376953,
-0.462850421667099,
-0.11464584618806839,
0.8930597305297852,
0.778743326663971,
-0.2775720953941345,
-0.2233683168888092,
0.48679307103157043,
-0.2847192883491516,
0.18805423378944397,
0.3551005721092224,
0.5562657713890076,
-0.5878822803497314,
0.7177569270133972,
-0.13045427203178406,
0.04369301348924637,
-0.3454008996486664,
-0.9654819965362549,
-0.87127286195755,
-0.5851017832756042,
-0.17426180839538574,
-0.1924801915884018,
-0.05469215288758278,
0.594151496887207,
0.7571709156036377,
-0.5080391764640808,
0.11652599275112152,
0.048027925193309784,
0.2571376860141754,
-0.18249419331550598,
-0.2720833420753479,
0.3536178469657898,
-0.23250657320022583,
-0.534929633140564,
0.2982903718948364,
0.37915563583374023,
0.26436731219291687,
0.060601554811000824,
0.19096879661083221,
-0.21202974021434784,
0.12880343198776245,
0.9287981390953064,
0.08047760277986526,
-0.5414759516716003,
-0.46256518363952637,
-0.16600161790847778,
-0.5024131536483765,
0.247168630361557,
0.9879217147827148,
-0.4480011761188507,
0.46559903025627136,
0.4777641296386719,
0.5724846720695496,
0.39367395639419556,
0.20112349092960358,
0.2748245894908905,
-1.1202197074890137,
0.01704682782292366,
-0.13889573514461517,
0.15226885676383972,
0.5188086628913879,
-0.7115844488143921,
0.6871737241744995,
0.47268253564834595,
-0.5587729811668396,
-0.6265758275985718,
0.12857569754123688,
-0.8870884776115417,
-0.24947932362556458,
1.1059167385101318,
-0.005424712784588337,
-0.1751808524131775,
-0.09038792550563812,
-0.8837158679962158,
0.45412135124206543,
-0.24140992760658264,
0.6492787599563599,
0.7718948721885681,
0.14954906702041626,
0.05038686841726303,
-0.7039296627044678,
0.2575637102127075,
-0.17237910628318787,
-1.0005005598068237,
-0.20140379667282104,
0.5152632594108582,
0.3413315713405609,
0.3056318461894989,
0.7513405084609985,
0.12012103945016861,
0.06620669364929199,
0.03183181211352348,
0.12359187006950378,
-0.10308757424354553,
-0.3422563076019287,
-0.18689751625061035,
0.19999782741069794,
-0.2831202447414398,
-0.2554623484611511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00784v1 | Utilizing BERT for Information Retrieval: Survey, Applications, Resources, and Challenges | 2024-02-18T23:22:40 | 2024-02-18T23:22:40 | Jiajia Wang, Jimmy X. Huang, Xinhui Tu, Junmei Wang, Angela J. Huang, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Amran Bhuiyan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent years have witnessed a substantial increase in the use of deep
learning to solve various natural language processing (NLP) problems. Early
deep learning models were constrained by their sequential or unidirectional
nature, such that they struggled to capture the contextual relationships across
text inputs. The introduction of bidirectional encoder representations from
transformers (BERT) leads to a robust encoder for the transformer model that
can understand the broader context and deliver state-of-the-art performance
across various NLP tasks. This has inspired researchers and practitioners to
apply BERT to practical problems, such as information retrieval (IR). A survey
that focuses on a comprehensive analysis of prevalent approaches that apply
pretrained transformer encoders like BERT to IR can thus be useful for academia
and the industry. In light of this, we revisit a variety of BERT-based methods
in this survey, cover a wide range of techniques of IR, and group them into six
high-level categories: (i) handling long documents, (ii) integrating semantic
information, (iii) balancing effectiveness and efficiency, (iv) predicting the
weights of terms, (v) query expansion, and (vi) document expansion. We also
provide links to resources, including datasets and toolkits, for BERT-based IR
systems. A key highlight of our survey is the comparison between BERT's
encoder-based models and the latest generative Large Language Models (LLMs),
such as ChatGPT, which rely on decoders. Despite the popularity of LLMs, we
find that for specific tasks, finely tuned BERT encoders still outperform, and
at a lower deployment cost. Finally, we summarize the comprehensive outcomes of
the survey and suggest directions for future research in the area. | [
-0.5684911608695984,
-0.6614170670509338,
0.42306894063949585,
0.25595924258232117,
-0.14732129871845245,
0.09443841874599457,
-0.46204107999801636,
-0.43579602241516113,
-0.012142213992774487,
0.3200651705265045,
-0.3261139392852783,
-0.2707309126853943,
-0.6407431364059448,
0.10007629543542862,
-0.7821206450462341,
0.8552350401878357,
0.16109968721866608,
0.1536751687526703,
-0.13156434893608093,
0.0862220749258995,
-0.3277331590652466,
-0.8693971037864685,
-0.3640010952949524,
-0.36682623624801636,
0.6671110987663269,
0.23545151948928833,
0.6197848320007324,
-0.08818186819553375,
1.039979338645935,
0.2093074768781662,
-0.19278842210769653,
-0.04616106301546097,
-0.48089656233787537,
0.38621342182159424,
0.0922471284866333,
-0.37043505907058716,
0.18059402704238892,
-0.15987354516983032,
0.7434194087982178,
0.760844349861145,
-0.15975865721702576,
0.005089018028229475,
0.17977279424667358,
0.8636887073516846,
-0.6312800049781799,
0.04405556991696358,
-0.5955584049224854,
0.14634186029434204,
-0.41357421875,
-0.15612652897834778,
-0.6559663414955139,
-0.5947995781898499,
0.6436802744865417,
-0.2703372538089752,
0.3604659140110016,
-0.06987310200929642,
0.8274638056755066,
0.168252632021904,
-0.38457542657852173,
-0.6756594777107239,
-0.9361182451248169,
0.8960133194923401,
-0.6206279993057251,
0.7272793054580688,
0.27322840690612793,
0.32883816957473755,
-0.21189294755458832,
-1.052445411682129,
-0.5264738202095032,
-0.24474191665649414,
-0.1792106330394745,
0.1799221932888031,
-0.2488504946231842,
0.17791327834129333,
0.1207650676369667,
0.3646397590637207,
-0.5185188055038452,
0.14644251763820648,
-0.2357473373413086,
0.04041730612516403,
0.20487555861473083,
-0.26301488280296326,
0.009843342937529087,
-0.2984431982040405,
-0.40382373332977295,
-0.4729311466217041,
-0.4930448532104492,
-0.012257787398993969,
0.35866212844848633,
0.24298328161239624,
0.5977729558944702,
0.6794001460075378,
0.12576359510421753,
0.6849303245544434,
-0.24905285239219666,
0.2695509195327759,
0.11559928208589554,
-0.2849096357822418,
0.018551480025053024,
-0.10356636345386505,
0.5729549527168274,
0.0884270966053009,
0.1633892059326172,
-0.2334679812192917,
-0.34832683205604553,
-0.5833816528320312,
0.4521394670009613,
-0.6762370467185974,
-0.07658293843269348,
-0.12397726625204086,
-0.7114357352256775,
0.14256179332733154,
0.1044737696647644,
-0.8533538579940796,
-0.2621738910675049,
-0.2891864776611328,
0.5280202627182007,
-0.6986415386199951,
-0.039679188281297684,
-0.010855970904231071,
-0.33427464962005615,
0.6294164657592773,
0.20297783613204956,
-0.7526713609695435,
0.06867678463459015,
0.47964414954185486,
0.5544383525848389,
-0.07054925709962845,
0.04666228964924812,
-0.010474844835698605,
-0.09949963539838791,
-0.10956112295389175,
0.6913224458694458,
-0.49281787872314453,
-0.30702897906303406,
0.48659592866897583,
-0.24328665435314178,
0.03095005825161934,
-0.570049524307251,
0.8158034086227417,
-1.0405373573303223,
0.16257081925868988,
-0.31584885716438293,
-0.5928767919540405,
-0.21364079415798187,
0.33931857347488403,
-0.8338998556137085,
1.182239055633545,
-0.11190378665924072,
-0.7095385789871216,
0.18237121403217316,
-0.6502988934516907,
-0.6087567806243896,
-0.0892590582370758,
-0.0046187941916286945,
-0.2746901214122772,
0.18233352899551392,
0.12238157540559769,
0.5058115124702454,
-0.4706830382347107,
0.2831972539424896,
0.23378227651119232,
-0.4490155279636383,
0.13543634116649628,
-0.6469955444335938,
0.533633828163147,
0.4784010946750641,
-0.057688262313604355,
-0.30710065364837646,
-0.39406830072402954,
-0.022146454080939293,
0.12432237714529037,
-0.5599036812782288,
-0.3598020076751709,
0.37736666202545166,
0.17577745020389557,
-0.23749102652072906,
0.498568058013916,
-0.5798219442367554,
0.12730801105499268,
-0.06236829236149788,
0.3215445280075073,
0.5041998028755188,
-0.25840187072753906,
0.3260166347026825,
-0.07038531452417374,
0.06237189844250679,
-0.1733233481645584,
0.20044638216495514,
-0.16318830847740173,
-0.3934975862503052,
-0.7935215830802917,
0.020016323775053024,
0.6854755878448486,
0.38850730657577515,
-0.8909306526184082,
0.6042557954788208,
-0.34635213017463684,
-0.5391142964363098,
-0.7915216088294983,
-0.04719344154000282,
-0.005886309314519167,
0.4017266631126404,
0.5629262924194336,
-0.2728373408317566,
-0.4976077675819397,
-0.9643412232398987,
-0.12601467967033386,
-0.28202134370803833,
-0.12156422436237335,
0.40829944610595703,
0.18962547183036804,
-0.39595839381217957,
1.0560067892074585,
-0.4312945604324341,
-0.331039696931839,
-0.33272412419319153,
0.6443108320236206,
0.4956822097301483,
0.3682740330696106,
0.5211185812950134,
-1.0394115447998047,
-0.3403564989566803,
-0.14177817106246948,
-0.5690495371818542,
0.19534675776958466,
-0.0063076866790652275,
-0.04474010318517685,
0.2149943858385086,
0.30344921350479126,
-0.5173446536064148,
0.3011322617530823,
0.214493989944458,
0.22330845892429352,
0.25374218821525574,
-0.3566489815711975,
0.19911828637123108,
-0.7171925902366638,
0.3643769323825836,
-0.0508682057261467,
-0.039522118866443634,
-0.623052716255188,
0.03211461752653122,
0.11405152082443237,
-0.030123000964522362,
-0.01043330691754818,
0.03129734843969345,
-0.34236106276512146,
-0.03546307981014252,
-0.09664793312549591,
0.08127913624048233,
-0.09671570360660553,
0.25860148668289185,
0.0474967360496521,
0.9118197560310364,
0.012092053890228271,
-0.5027028918266296,
0.3459031879901886,
0.40404269099235535,
-0.5410051345825195,
0.16286663711071014,
-0.5375199913978577,
0.23583196103572845,
-0.6549029350280762,
0.11822263896465302,
-0.9811065793037415,
0.06952320784330368,
-0.14435975253582,
-0.5028731822967529,
0.5739321112632751,
0.08343803882598877,
-0.9486501216888428,
-0.5626446604728699,
-0.2864137589931488,
0.20331385731697083,
0.8122440576553345,
-0.7253649830818176,
0.6345073580741882,
0.2359616905450821,
-0.28028595447540283,
-0.9473827481269836,
-0.5979484915733337,
0.20781393349170685,
0.16520477831363678,
-0.47609183192253113,
0.5248255133628845,
-0.12651318311691284,
-0.02243977226316929,
0.05990350991487503,
-0.14789709448814392,
-0.3846568465232849,
-0.04542728140950203,
-0.39686983823776245,
0.15692010521888733,
-0.154261514544487,
0.4381553828716278,
-0.19712837040424347,
0.12103036791086197,
-0.09785513579845428,
-0.025241969153285027,
0.6326178908348083,
-0.07407163828611374,
-0.4682231843471527,
0.016429105773568153,
0.5870869159698486,
0.344260036945343,
-0.20027472078800201,
0.7123725414276123,
0.8387973308563232,
-0.1595010757446289,
0.17744246125221252,
-1.081240177154541,
-0.33415687084198,
-0.3934291899204254,
0.4234561026096344,
0.029196104034781456,
-0.7130925059318542,
0.3171669542789459,
-0.2132330983877182,
0.1312461495399475,
0.38973090052604675,
0.27251026034355164,
-0.6728714108467102,
0.6714129447937012,
0.7629474401473999,
-0.35348570346832275,
0.8332737684249878,
-0.29065418243408203,
0.5317739844322205,
-0.749078094959259,
-0.426785945892334,
-0.7758152484893799,
-0.43726155161857605,
-0.5644329786300659,
-0.2854127585887909,
0.28584781289100647,
0.052438799291849136,
-0.005039478186517954,
0.2803701162338257,
-0.5471203923225403,
0.14806829392910004,
1.0306445360183716,
0.13481561839580536,
0.24578598141670227,
-0.004443278070539236,
0.09918081760406494,
-0.14304877817630768,
-0.6160271763801575,
-0.3460446894168854,
0.9177059531211853,
0.2435317486524582,
1.0801212787628174,
0.057954490184783936,
0.6099499464035034,
0.5152114629745483,
0.1317465901374817,
-0.8661531805992126,
0.4787255823612213,
-0.48179516196250916,
-0.6972221732139587,
-0.38221776485443115,
-0.2774256467819214,
-1.1523025035858154,
0.11489971727132797,
-0.05585441365838051,
-0.33655333518981934,
0.3892723321914673,
-0.1661107838153839,
0.011531722731888294,
0.1742197871208191,
-0.815228283405304,
0.4046550393104553,
-0.5455744862556458,
-0.04463839903473854,
-0.1485738456249237,
-1.004296898841858,
-0.2149399071931839,
-0.08097159117460251,
-0.1553497165441513,
0.04333031550049782,
0.24517565965652466,
0.834695041179657,
0.14152821898460388,
0.5679827332496643,
-0.2140611857175827,
0.028063004836440086,
0.2806410789489746,
-0.4112745225429535,
0.4657125174999237,
-0.2887224555015564,
-0.401346355676651,
0.136552631855011,
0.0060912808403372765,
-0.16232715547084808,
-0.5946876406669617,
0.4938593804836273,
-0.7341840863227844,
-0.5413444638252258,
-0.4870929419994354,
-0.4422943592071533,
-0.12247768044471741,
0.47424474358558655,
0.28429272770881653,
0.24112699925899506,
-0.1780397891998291,
0.7920202612876892,
0.9215554594993591,
-0.28974786400794983,
0.5731509923934937,
0.4993637800216675,
0.12232819944620132,
-0.10731876641511917,
0.7567631602287292,
0.246667742729187,
-0.07553187757730484,
0.7654560804367065,
-0.1965726912021637,
-0.3884159326553345,
-0.5201659798622131,
0.1632080376148224,
0.045391689985990524,
-0.702153205871582,
-0.45118921995162964,
-0.41803863644599915,
-0.5673376321792603,
-0.33562523126602173,
0.04493408650159836,
-0.2999970614910126,
-0.18913719058036804,
-0.39592307806015015,
0.08283582329750061,
0.14654965698719025,
0.6693615913391113,
0.0902617946267128,
0.275167852640152,
-0.700862467288971,
0.2682003378868103,
0.34294426441192627,
0.6184685230255127,
-0.038630418479442596,
-0.12152019888162613,
-0.2812552750110626,
-0.019295280799269676,
-0.25109344720840454,
-0.7425263524055481,
0.26530665159225464,
0.2146008014678955,
0.8151965141296387,
0.1273401379585266,
0.40999728441238403,
0.6014294624328613,
-0.5095734596252441,
0.6843079924583435,
-0.10041164606809616,
-0.5252051949501038,
0.6438990831375122,
-0.019668692722916603,
0.02378004603087902,
0.7354757189750671,
0.686961829662323,
-0.5108049511909485,
-0.029319703578948975,
-0.23417073488235474,
-1.1396567821502686,
0.5723804235458374,
0.5209987163543701,
0.43097612261772156,
-0.03300900384783745,
0.3671954274177551,
0.09720513969659805,
0.3003557026386261,
-0.5307912230491638,
-0.24798595905303955,
-0.07624685019254684,
-0.36626842617988586,
0.1391087770462036,
-0.5814155340194702,
0.09050185978412628,
-0.059550777077674866,
0.6631035208702087,
0.005083325784653425,
0.8800292611122131,
0.498582124710083,
-0.38835570216178894,
0.2964319884777069,
0.4983142018318176,
0.09477539360523224,
0.37251579761505127,
-0.6460239887237549,
-0.025078661739826202,
-0.10423077642917633,
-0.5295574069023132,
-0.13419164717197418,
0.552819013595581,
-0.011923653073608875,
0.3678470253944397,
0.24988862872123718,
0.3668871819972992,
0.20728108286857605,
-0.7994681000709534,
0.60392165184021,
-0.23039506375789642,
0.02817249856889248,
-0.5013459324836731,
-0.38922837376594543,
-0.21539856493473053,
0.3166549801826477,
0.9157336354255676,
-0.15915773808956146,
0.4281575679779053,
-0.3498113751411438,
-0.004164434503763914,
0.6715880036354065,
-0.4017515778541565,
-0.01921035163104534,
0.24485498666763306,
0.19989831745624542,
-0.1894877851009369,
1.2281445264816284,
0.4121764004230499,
-0.2893035411834717,
0.38278183341026306,
0.47304823994636536,
0.7825835347175598,
0.06510940939188004,
-0.05193455517292023,
-0.02281915582716465,
0.5168026089668274,
-0.02613842487335205,
0.2232852280139923,
-0.35778892040252686,
-0.7466875314712524,
-0.19443432986736298,
-0.559323787689209,
-0.4996776580810547,
0.02248845249414444,
-0.8563278913497925,
0.07096563279628754,
0.009921576827764511,
-0.6003578901290894,
-0.10722289234399796,
-0.09345787018537521,
-0.965664803981781,
-0.04059290140867233,
0.17898723483085632,
1.2277778387069702,
-0.2741212248802185,
0.7414196133613586,
0.6939865350723267,
-0.4676433205604553,
-0.1742294579744339,
0.2470141351222992,
-0.5732284188270569,
-0.7004673480987549,
0.8167006969451904,
0.0813218504190445,
0.013785474002361298,
0.09873410314321518,
-0.558934211730957,
-0.8394207954406738,
1.052575707435608,
0.2539677917957306,
-0.41365453600883484,
-0.42398059368133545,
0.12422271072864532,
0.6758252382278442,
0.17873291671276093,
0.45973309874534607,
0.6075879335403442,
0.5786867141723633,
0.1736668050289154,
-0.7895821928977966,
-0.4392821788787842,
-0.19714957475662231,
0.23225043714046478,
0.24891974031925201,
-0.4855460524559021,
0.5036364197731018,
0.04296720027923584,
-0.19064927101135254,
0.32933396100997925,
0.5923201441764832,
-0.15927241742610931,
0.02766002155840397,
0.23274090886116028,
0.30754122138023376,
0.6512971520423889,
-0.39955195784568787,
0.9247589707374573,
-0.38669079542160034,
0.46906620264053345,
0.580819845199585,
-0.11753350496292114,
0.9943786859512329,
0.617904782295227,
-0.17436790466308594,
0.5089725255966187,
0.45904892683029175,
-0.06608439981937408,
0.734933614730835,
0.0029004099778831005,
-0.306484580039978,
-0.06556201726198196,
-0.2894074022769928,
-0.4488072693347931,
0.24944616854190826,
0.5086946487426758,
-0.564702033996582,
-0.2714794874191284,
0.17348279058933258,
-0.335941880941391,
-0.20343248546123505,
0.018476830795407295,
1.0016908645629883,
-0.10734935849905014,
-0.5459654927253723,
0.12378360331058502,
-0.12297932803630829,
0.876224935054779,
-0.970552384853363,
-0.17798787355422974,
-0.23373810946941376,
0.1486736387014389,
0.11169303953647614,
-1.1086080074310303,
0.08569195866584778,
-0.12465179711580276,
-0.1972777545452118,
-0.5187357068061829,
1.0362749099731445,
-0.29228344559669495,
-0.18258216977119446,
0.3532702624797821,
0.42338287830352783,
0.03759538382291794,
0.07352618128061295,
-0.3932282626628876,
-0.0005454518832266331,
-0.057171523571014404,
-0.24047958850860596,
0.11062841862440109,
0.36398667097091675,
0.4583342969417572,
0.5979313850402832,
0.4367777109146118,
-0.18287131190299988,
0.1615118831396103,
0.23926544189453125,
0.9540700912475586,
-0.8740151524543762,
0.0117090018466115,
-0.5221869349479675,
0.3591844141483307,
-0.08823445439338684,
0.06271008402109146,
0.5982974767684937,
0.4859308898448944,
0.8673772811889648,
-0.12327418476343155,
0.8193153738975525,
-0.2683906853199005,
0.4584466814994812,
-0.4873688220977783,
0.6591658592224121,
-0.3799094259738922,
0.18577370047569275,
-0.12017791718244553,
-0.9236587285995483,
-0.3367505967617035,
0.6611151695251465,
-0.16009147465229034,
0.08732284605503082,
0.38198453187942505,
0.3790002763271332,
0.16405124962329865,
0.05642660707235336,
0.0985744446516037,
0.04900047928094864,
0.4183061420917511,
0.083490289747715,
0.955228865146637,
-0.46270111203193665,
0.722388505935669,
-0.1793140023946762,
-0.017484378069639206,
-0.5501139163970947,
-0.7138814330101013,
-0.6202917098999023,
-0.7753532528877258,
0.19043724238872528,
0.07239887863397598,
0.29017606377601624,
0.8655056357383728,
0.616714596748352,
-0.7409685254096985,
-0.1492040902376175,
0.19654692709445953,
0.21702693402767181,
0.0407552607357502,
-0.22671981155872345,
0.19350627064704895,
-0.8167487978935242,
-0.7603222727775574,
0.2983250319957733,
0.006565169896930456,
0.10960085690021515,
-0.12510433793067932,
0.2387399524450302,
-0.5084941983222961,
-0.14724144339561462,
0.8135157823562622,
0.25925129652023315,
-0.5999244451522827,
-0.3216616213321686,
0.3313535153865814,
-0.23627004027366638,
0.13739043474197388,
0.8810808658599854,
-0.9237509965896606,
0.6134141683578491,
0.7404711842536926,
1.0586587190628052,
0.6273608803749084,
-0.020675210282206535,
0.6612098813056946,
-1.008678913116455,
-0.21551325917243958,
0.5858119130134583,
0.27092626690864563,
0.3012639880180359,
-0.3073626756668091,
0.5817197561264038,
-0.25991395115852356,
-0.7096245288848877,
-0.6211156845092773,
-0.11413546651601791,
-0.812798261642456,
-0.18295514583587646,
0.7492673993110657,
0.0430760495364666,
0.1702079325914383,
-0.04496617242693901,
-0.25449249148368835,
0.22654388844966888,
-0.43766677379608154,
0.7810149192810059,
0.7316779494285583,
-0.3334890305995941,
-0.14822009205818176,
-0.5738073587417603,
0.14558835327625275,
0.4731009900569916,
-0.44414108991622925,
-0.1718563586473465,
0.2599857747554779,
-0.1999301314353943,
0.4695165753364563,
0.2998173236846924,
-0.10581044107675552,
-0.08269733935594559,
-0.4631933569908142,
0.2641766369342804,
0.2411131113767624,
-0.30344411730766296,
-0.2326677292585373,
0.16752897202968597,
0.23240283131599426,
-0.2040949910879135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14837v1 | An Empirical Categorization of Prompting Techniques for Large Language Models: A Practitioner's Guide | 2024-02-18T23:03:56 | 2024-02-18T23:03:56 | Oluwole Fagbohun, Rachel M. Harrison, Anton Dereventsov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Due to rapid advancements in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs),
programming these models with prompts has recently gained significant
attention. However, the sheer number of available prompt engineering techniques
creates an overwhelming landscape for practitioners looking to utilize these
tools. For the most efficient and effective use of LLMs, it is important to
compile a comprehensive list of prompting techniques and establish a
standardized, interdisciplinary categorization framework. In this survey, we
examine some of the most well-known prompting techniques from both academic and
practical viewpoints and classify them into seven distinct categories. We
present an overview of each category, aiming to clarify their unique
contributions and showcase their practical applications in real-world examples
in order to equip fellow practitioners with a structured framework for
understanding and categorizing prompting techniques tailored to their specific
domains. We believe that this approach will help simplify the complex landscape
of prompt engineering and enable more effective utilization of LLMs in various
applications. By providing practitioners with a systematic approach to prompt
categorization, we aim to assist in navigating the intricacies of effective
prompt design for conversational pre-trained LLMs and inspire new possibilities
in their respective fields. | [
-0.6443119049072266,
-1.0834521055221558,
0.8601712584495544,
0.7709962725639343,
-0.02393258735537529,
0.03007003664970398,
-0.31019529700279236,
0.10576336085796356,
-0.19310185313224792,
0.28410202264785767,
-0.7535210847854614,
-0.4389939606189728,
-0.11202969402074814,
0.40257662534713745,
-0.30562686920166016,
0.5940230488777161,
0.035796619951725006,
0.28892308473587036,
-0.29551541805267334,
0.33711475133895874,
-0.7553339600563049,
-0.5216044187545776,
-0.7811982035636902,
-0.22752662003040314,
0.9751546382904053,
0.4994080662727356,
0.2590140700340271,
0.2735387980937958,
0.1676967740058899,
0.3177206516265869,
-0.4399642050266266,
-0.04786765202879906,
-0.08615651726722717,
0.24650715291500092,
-0.18389934301376343,
-0.43150246143341064,
-0.1713532656431198,
-0.07880554348230362,
0.4820536971092224,
0.9514102935791016,
-0.32757800817489624,
0.35659459233283997,
0.16069036722183228,
0.2518516182899475,
-0.5640200972557068,
0.07152357697486877,
-0.4147583246231079,
0.09682805091142654,
-0.1711285561323166,
-0.6531865000724792,
-0.7998741269111633,
-0.5989404320716858,
0.056231699883937836,
-0.4478233754634857,
0.006538606248795986,
0.33997753262519836,
0.2333032786846161,
-0.0011144103482365608,
-0.35050541162490845,
-0.45329150557518005,
-0.42521703243255615,
0.85271155834198,
-0.49474892020225525,
0.22760823369026184,
0.2879290282726288,
0.44133424758911133,
-0.3440053164958954,
-0.4573891758918762,
-0.36275774240493774,
-0.5599436163902283,
0.17667488753795624,
-0.2380986213684082,
-0.0650118961930275,
0.4049774408340454,
0.6426840424537659,
0.2501726746559143,
-0.6768205165863037,
0.6785949468612671,
-0.1335824579000473,
-0.18124108016490936,
0.3231022357940674,
0.2958357632160187,
0.47181177139282227,
0.09443726390600204,
-0.2671821415424347,
-0.1201685443520546,
-1.0560518503189087,
0.20962730050086975,
0.35318562388420105,
0.484086811542511,
-0.05068285018205643,
0.323192298412323,
-0.22723175585269928,
1.0493229627609253,
0.21778392791748047,
-0.25682833790779114,
-0.08004945516586304,
-0.1647987961769104,
-0.054355308413505554,
-0.00264511676505208,
0.8065340518951416,
0.3812156915664673,
0.50934237241745,
0.16369685530662537,
-0.3113420605659485,
-0.3057973086833954,
0.10669875144958496,
-0.6212577223777771,
-0.023883400484919548,
0.11971742659807205,
-0.49752748012542725,
-0.3083796203136444,
-0.46434733271598816,
-0.9272605776786804,
-0.7747893333435059,
-0.44921526312828064,
0.135665163397789,
0.019145846366882324,
-0.17901408672332764,
0.11074353754520416,
-0.10894837230443954,
0.38194921612739563,
0.39746570587158203,
-0.9531358480453491,
0.05410878732800484,
0.5946992039680481,
0.6845676302909851,
0.1537623256444931,
-0.1791849583387375,
-0.500481903553009,
-0.2940097451210022,
-0.4458540976047516,
0.9159706830978394,
-0.7061887383460999,
-0.7546735405921936,
0.5628830790519714,
-0.11664580553770065,
0.09461244940757751,
-0.5078166127204895,
0.6382355093955994,
-0.6213964223861694,
0.20089054107666016,
-0.4749806225299835,
-0.49780744314193726,
-0.26508504152297974,
0.26837822794914246,
-0.4226819574832916,
0.8748995661735535,
-0.10743549466133118,
-0.4186592996120453,
0.2385316640138626,
-0.6624134182929993,
-0.1250416785478592,
0.1848713606595993,
-0.17815661430358887,
0.1829439401626587,
0.11004730314016342,
0.28119540214538574,
0.770570695400238,
-0.6962559223175049,
0.5929288864135742,
-0.20699156820774078,
0.016720741987228394,
0.3394204080104828,
-0.4689164459705353,
0.8766039609909058,
0.4253467321395874,
0.14261102676391602,
0.2370978742837906,
-0.5801209807395935,
0.010779289528727531,
-0.05013543739914894,
-0.23828287422657013,
-0.18764005601406097,
-0.14297634363174438,
-0.05435757339000702,
0.08578091859817505,
0.11835866421461105,
-0.1915522962808609,
0.4224538803100586,
-0.19825834035873413,
0.4039435386657715,
0.7470698952674866,
0.22466802597045898,
0.42463499307632446,
-0.24965068697929382,
0.9475138187408447,
-0.2916828691959381,
-0.0051726531237363815,
-0.7131987810134888,
-0.286674439907074,
-0.4981359541416168,
-0.23353311419487,
0.08880628645420074,
0.7417104244232178,
-0.7761202454566956,
0.42424747347831726,
0.04349496588110924,
-0.6897335052490234,
-0.20855571329593658,
0.04802187532186508,
0.43580856919288635,
0.552028238773346,
0.21441638469696045,
0.17446421086788177,
-0.47995123267173767,
-0.8090296387672424,
-0.26113855838775635,
-0.26850560307502747,
-0.021192865446209908,
0.13657332956790924,
0.024585286155343056,
0.13745182752609253,
0.9715932607650757,
-0.2211841344833374,
0.21098391711711884,
-0.389174222946167,
0.23939743638038635,
0.5709734559059143,
0.35482993721961975,
0.642427384853363,
-0.400545597076416,
-0.5239187479019165,
-0.20989619195461273,
-0.6184211373329163,
-0.6193761825561523,
-0.22219350934028625,
0.06348923593759537,
-0.23892533779144287,
0.9647098779678345,
-0.5477885603904724,
0.06378578394651413,
0.16784462332725525,
-0.027388565242290497,
0.855108380317688,
0.04667259380221367,
0.14138086140155792,
-0.738222599029541,
0.024689488112926483,
0.11634735018014908,
0.011766745708882809,
-0.8668558597564697,
0.13767914474010468,
0.040231846272945404,
-0.19228589534759521,
-0.787239670753479,
0.9265966415405273,
-0.789678156375885,
0.2995622158050537,
-0.17018522322177887,
-0.05109106004238129,
-0.27142810821533203,
0.21529275178909302,
0.053794316947460175,
0.9203879237174988,
0.8646267056465149,
-1.0590983629226685,
0.624004065990448,
0.3456563949584961,
-0.305833101272583,
0.6770613193511963,
-0.7980613708496094,
0.07258293777704239,
-0.2766392230987549,
0.38965684175491333,
-1.0205484628677368,
-0.25275126099586487,
0.35800647735595703,
-0.32771480083465576,
0.46293190121650696,
-0.28898298740386963,
-0.7287585735321045,
-0.44989699125289917,
-0.23105423152446747,
0.4368223547935486,
0.7693701982498169,
-0.7595610618591309,
0.21879291534423828,
-0.06706443428993225,
-0.6924172043800354,
-0.5465670228004456,
-0.3164072632789612,
0.081318199634552,
-0.5661904215812683,
-0.3855587840080261,
-0.08066879957914352,
-0.3397364318370819,
-0.37083855271339417,
-0.6232291460037231,
0.20081020891666412,
-0.02972584217786789,
0.29504916071891785,
0.04741545766592026,
0.32097765803337097,
-0.11184005439281464,
0.01999938115477562,
-0.026333896443247795,
-0.14384031295776367,
0.275703102350235,
0.03114287368953228,
0.8159080743789673,
0.14174431562423706,
-0.47805678844451904,
-0.5701701641082764,
0.3482110798358917,
0.2615090310573578,
-0.09587362408638,
0.41928830742836,
0.33098408579826355,
-0.14586523175239563,
-0.25656846165657043,
-0.6706503033638,
-0.36575061082839966,
-0.5742949843406677,
0.15726591646671295,
-0.4187040328979492,
-0.9498605132102966,
0.49817585945129395,
-0.3325059413909912,
0.3347018361091614,
-0.11584419012069702,
0.6695908308029175,
0.08452509343624115,
1.2245147228240967,
0.4621630609035492,
-0.04575011879205704,
0.7613990902900696,
0.2595694959163666,
0.24892912805080414,
-0.6507821679115295,
-0.15216746926307678,
-0.9127035140991211,
0.1462801694869995,
-0.33297935128211975,
-0.2637695074081421,
0.3093741238117218,
0.1721242219209671,
-0.20909643173217773,
0.03799982741475105,
-0.52113276720047,
0.5141938328742981,
0.35676977038383484,
-0.3746429681777954,
-0.05755843594670296,
0.08276956528425217,
-0.1691216230392456,
0.20356100797653198,
-0.7740250825881958,
-0.7792185544967651,
0.6607139110565186,
0.5371164679527283,
1.1071959733963013,
-0.03972642868757248,
0.6254384517669678,
0.13647376000881195,
0.41785338521003723,
-1.2485053539276123,
0.9442700743675232,
0.44076523184776306,
-0.6698318123817444,
-0.25167688727378845,
-0.28045859932899475,
-1.239919662475586,
0.09501975774765015,
0.15028661489486694,
-0.8805876970291138,
0.25155872106552124,
0.38088253140449524,
-0.5502330660820007,
-0.09744634479284286,
-0.656385600566864,
0.7417321801185608,
-0.15383559465408325,
0.05567389726638794,
0.0024154868442565203,
-0.40117594599723816,
0.3966265618801117,
-0.00857254583388567,
0.39891383051872253,
-0.14970813691616058,
-0.15479007363319397,
0.4848548471927643,
-0.2728859782218933,
1.0784640312194824,
-0.3327135145664215,
-0.496928334236145,
0.44262418150901794,
0.1543792486190796,
0.43052053451538086,
-0.2117760181427002,
0.06813059002161026,
-0.2911118268966675,
-0.04765493795275688,
-0.15901675820350647,
-0.6069884300231934,
0.4940355122089386,
-0.359384685754776,
-0.7752902507781982,
-0.35093003511428833,
-0.19710798561573029,
-0.5224880576133728,
0.1776321977376938,
0.3730494976043701,
0.7525310516357422,
-0.17101751267910004,
0.07541600614786148,
0.9947216510772705,
-0.49595358967781067,
0.6525329351425171,
0.516973078250885,
-0.37800103425979614,
-0.21820001304149628,
0.809497594833374,
0.0027863625437021255,
0.14754578471183777,
0.48150888085365295,
0.2271353006362915,
-0.6941684484481812,
-0.7186844348907471,
-0.3160901665687561,
0.38443759083747864,
-0.9446871876716614,
-0.21897907555103302,
-0.499074786901474,
-0.02067762240767479,
-0.5700569748878479,
-0.48931407928466797,
0.3022291362285614,
-0.0317276194691658,
-0.4656771123409271,
-0.1712104231119156,
0.3423062860965729,
0.5778592824935913,
0.2673828601837158,
0.7222416400909424,
-1.067037582397461,
0.01188837643712759,
0.34485116600990295,
0.17332763969898224,
0.30179789662361145,
-0.32083526253700256,
0.17602546513080597,
-0.2971658706665039,
-0.11679546535015106,
-1.102497935295105,
0.29696449637413025,
-0.028453659266233444,
0.9633369445800781,
0.6029983162879944,
0.34099826216697693,
0.555114209651947,
-0.6994850635528564,
1.1411895751953125,
0.545210063457489,
-0.7641022801399231,
0.5913882851600647,
-0.4750509262084961,
0.12018559128046036,
0.3424195349216461,
0.5727030634880066,
-0.8672704100608826,
-0.0852310061454773,
-0.3510102331638336,
-0.9430956840515137,
0.5836606025695801,
-0.46670645475387573,
0.30268481373786926,
-0.2993256449699402,
0.09967105835676193,
0.14311577379703522,
0.26961737871170044,
-0.4232484996318817,
-0.02241002768278122,
0.2789880931377411,
-0.39633867144584656,
0.06599943339824677,
-0.3073940873146057,
-0.17625463008880615,
0.07112374156713486,
0.6295733451843262,
-0.23738685250282288,
0.18591313064098358,
0.04955373704433441,
-0.2907923758029938,
0.20181557536125183,
0.6769654750823975,
0.6772556900978088,
0.7417914271354675,
0.12454818189144135,
0.014661252498626709,
0.23279814422130585,
-0.1363030970096588,
0.4629902243614197,
-0.13612686097621918,
-0.10957285016775131,
-0.00827673077583313,
0.2812731862068176,
0.8338877558708191,
0.09636633843183517,
-0.7882629036903381,
0.3299875259399414,
0.09080781787633896,
-0.025090094655752182,
-0.3817148208618164,
0.2629169821739197,
-0.1384902000427246,
-0.022337600588798523,
0.3165513575077057,
-0.4336932897567749,
0.3461333215236664,
-0.44038286805152893,
-0.33838537335395813,
0.37938031554222107,
-0.202945739030838,
-0.2804928421974182,
0.3526892364025116,
0.5150227546691895,
-0.5388273000717163,
0.35210445523262024,
-0.1641654223203659,
-0.25024086236953735,
0.423238068819046,
0.36004382371902466,
0.933295488357544,
-0.45172640681266785,
0.278033584356308,
0.4475836455821991,
0.011227855458855629,
-0.4121648073196411,
0.2564067244529724,
-0.23531211912631989,
-0.5491307377815247,
-0.5356110334396362,
-0.5240421295166016,
-0.46970152854919434,
0.09216786921024323,
-0.6453007459640503,
0.3790585398674011,
-0.6417324542999268,
-0.3302973210811615,
0.15297117829322815,
-0.31740856170654297,
-0.6127305030822754,
-0.10765339434146881,
0.36076274514198303,
1.434535264968872,
-0.8523236513137817,
0.21308110654354095,
1.1779544353485107,
-0.24209743738174438,
-1.0177127122879028,
-0.37497684359550476,
0.40908342599868774,
-0.7357475161552429,
0.5995506048202515,
0.17048503458499908,
0.08592981100082397,
0.14943717420101166,
-0.9530542492866516,
-0.45948752760887146,
0.5793294906616211,
-0.006368172820657492,
-0.6043976545333862,
-0.12015743553638458,
-0.10637228935956955,
0.31535568833351135,
-0.3243334889411926,
0.6977737545967102,
0.4370591938495636,
0.6367981433868408,
0.13094133138656616,
-1.1021921634674072,
0.07837720215320587,
-0.18588298559188843,
0.387263685464859,
-0.009258117526769638,
-0.4991283118724823,
0.4565833508968353,
0.09638628363609314,
-0.30097830295562744,
0.4323384165763855,
0.3146893084049225,
0.775306761264801,
0.45780375599861145,
0.6917440891265869,
-0.20613859593868256,
0.7236563563346863,
-0.1292266994714737,
0.8549100160598755,
-0.1754998415708542,
-0.033264774829149246,
0.6042405366897583,
-0.36587390303611755,
0.4278446137905121,
0.4798938035964966,
-0.37564966082572937,
0.17520388960838318,
1.2080117464065552,
0.17445482313632965,
0.13381327688694,
0.38592949509620667,
-0.3355959355831146,
-0.3444270193576813,
-0.4686700999736786,
-0.496955931186676,
-0.19290076196193695,
0.6749430894851685,
-0.12886682152748108,
-0.29505497217178345,
0.33626896142959595,
0.1570344716310501,
-0.13497309386730194,
-0.5802040100097656,
0.7245050668716431,
0.3889027237892151,
-0.8995938897132874,
0.6782487630844116,
-0.24847400188446045,
0.7904319167137146,
-0.6433561444282532,
0.030824998393654823,
-0.20283706486225128,
-0.36339548230171204,
-0.09261486679315567,
-1.007684588432312,
-0.35582128167152405,
0.10288543254137039,
-0.19954831898212433,
-0.8202261328697205,
0.5770666003227234,
-0.3122805953025818,
0.019537877291440964,
-0.1765178143978119,
0.5367304682731628,
0.4021577537059784,
0.1066071018576622,
-0.6339060068130493,
-0.0017578991828486323,
-0.01514851488173008,
-0.3888612389564514,
0.21029461920261383,
0.6507095098495483,
-0.26411259174346924,
0.9930222630500793,
0.8238562941551208,
0.059087276458740234,
0.06773654371500015,
0.4128091037273407,
0.7532399892807007,
-0.8314011693000793,
-0.5333526730537415,
-0.7900714874267578,
0.505547285079956,
0.08853619545698166,
-0.38842785358428955,
0.8638214468955994,
0.09923116862773895,
0.3189464509487152,
-0.30599987506866455,
0.7163907885551453,
0.06094847619533539,
0.6634556651115417,
-0.6831564903259277,
0.24151740968227386,
-0.2823856770992279,
0.3240455687046051,
-0.279961496591568,
-1.0590921640396118,
-0.2684456408023834,
0.47680678963661194,
-0.32069891691207886,
0.17353634536266327,
0.42100265622138977,
1.0681794881820679,
0.31629541516304016,
0.04975391551852226,
0.30900394916534424,
0.037559639662504196,
0.39181554317474365,
0.10401111841201782,
1.5965989828109741,
0.5321906805038452,
0.27714699506759644,
0.1790802776813507,
-0.45217254757881165,
-0.5655356645584106,
-0.8569422364234924,
-1.0958797931671143,
-0.420286625623703,
-0.35849830508232117,
-0.048716869205236435,
-0.2366247922182083,
1.3142093420028687,
0.7153393626213074,
-0.5891624093055725,
-0.22690823674201965,
-0.05339488014578819,
0.10933990776538849,
-0.006357467267662287,
-0.2325068563222885,
-0.07621641457080841,
-0.7688798308372498,
-0.7177030444145203,
0.609801173210144,
-0.08254129439592361,
0.26945558190345764,
-0.4162956476211548,
0.2024816870689392,
0.14991480112075806,
0.12336765974760056,
0.6454251408576965,
0.6417135000228882,
-0.7839035987854004,
-0.07790447026491165,
0.3309941291809082,
0.03276185318827629,
-0.31110402941703796,
1.193686842918396,
-0.5784881711006165,
0.30170199275016785,
0.8754634857177734,
0.49115297198295593,
-0.31110766530036926,
-0.015340038575232029,
0.5438475608825684,
-0.7689477801322937,
0.09532096236944199,
0.37753239274024963,
0.30219054222106934,
0.27976396679878235,
-0.34463950991630554,
0.2927207946777344,
-0.05010738968849182,
-0.6934617757797241,
-1.1119203567504883,
0.4693060517311096,
-0.9506440758705139,
-0.20294898748397827,
1.3921937942504883,
0.011934191919863224,
-0.22216597199440002,
-0.25098109245300293,
-0.6729418635368347,
-0.14477843046188354,
-0.6499470472335815,
0.3079119920730591,
0.9028451442718506,
-0.14243167638778687,
-0.6266164779663086,
-0.5654370784759521,
0.46457281708717346,
0.3750916123390198,
-0.7476020455360413,
0.11744579672813416,
0.7995458245277405,
0.18350397050380707,
0.19178219139575958,
0.6871535181999207,
0.10262571275234222,
0.14070910215377808,
-0.24382272362709045,
0.22581975162029266,
0.1847863793373108,
-0.2903502881526947,
-0.6222051382064819,
0.05143436789512634,
0.46044573187828064,
0.18696539103984833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11728v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11728v1 | Numerical Claim Detection in Finance: A New Financial Dataset, Weak-Supervision Model, and Market Analysis | 2024-02-18T22:55:26 | 2024-02-18T22:55:26 | Agam Shah, Arnav Hiray, Pratvi Shah, Arkaprabha Banerjee, Anushka Singh, Dheeraj Eidnani, Bhaskar Chaudhury, Sudheer Chava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP | In this paper, we investigate the influence of claims in analyst reports and
earnings calls on financial market returns, considering them as significant
quarterly events for publicly traded companies. To facilitate a comprehensive
analysis, we construct a new financial dataset for the claim detection task in
the financial domain. We benchmark various language models on this dataset and
propose a novel weak-supervision model that incorporates the knowledge of
subject matter experts (SMEs) in the aggregation function, outperforming
existing approaches. Furthermore, we demonstrate the practical utility of our
proposed model by constructing a novel measure ``optimism". Furthermore, we
observed the dependence of earnings surprise and return on our optimism
measure. Our dataset, models, and code will be made publicly (under CC BY 4.0
license) available on GitHub and Hugging Face. | [
0.02226879820227623,
-0.4898824393749237,
0.29708537459373474,
0.4687715470790863,
0.06548357009887695,
0.0829792469739914,
0.04807442054152489,
-0.6619251370429993,
0.4793957769870758,
0.33064723014831543,
-0.045228395611047745,
-0.4949336647987366,
-0.7088974118232727,
0.029552225023508072,
-0.4489270746707916,
1.0724272727966309,
0.1184617206454277,
-0.11212464421987534,
-0.1960732787847519,
0.2951374351978302,
-0.2683345079421997,
-0.3418860137462616,
-0.734336256980896,
0.15536145865917206,
0.2262374758720398,
0.08586791902780533,
0.5382648706436157,
0.18710513412952423,
0.7368621826171875,
0.2815054953098297,
0.08203937858343124,
-0.20602285861968994,
-0.0080569414421916,
-0.41215047240257263,
-0.002232244238257408,
-0.639223039150238,
-0.9156469702720642,
-0.18001516163349152,
0.6570409536361694,
0.5563105344772339,
-0.5386505722999573,
0.307623952627182,
0.05082610994577408,
0.5925383567810059,
-0.8205152750015259,
0.8516189455986023,
-0.615679919719696,
0.06368926912546158,
-0.614265501499176,
-0.04609367623925209,
-0.6491434574127197,
-0.47855716943740845,
0.23814541101455688,
-0.4386407732963562,
0.3447827100753784,
0.022568998858332634,
0.8586949110031128,
0.018390076234936714,
-0.6657879948616028,
-0.2797084152698517,
-0.4948461949825287,
0.9345678091049194,
-0.9449774622917175,
0.14945247769355774,
0.5451772212982178,
0.4764593541622162,
0.1100674569606781,
-0.7972752451896667,
-0.007387285120785236,
-0.14080792665481567,
0.041307225823402405,
0.13865911960601807,
-0.7473248243331909,
0.0054962546564638615,
0.17623452842235565,
0.5000923871994019,
-0.254284143447876,
0.18388693034648895,
-0.7515361309051514,
-0.42261549830436707,
0.9063048958778381,
-0.03402405604720116,
-0.06187361851334572,
-0.07698391377925873,
-0.339218407869339,
0.05958487093448639,
-0.7014719843864441,
0.09287074208259583,
0.5916288495063782,
0.536404013633728,
-0.5433322787284851,
0.31702619791030884,
-0.16952422261238098,
0.40204355120658875,
-0.16720254719257355,
-0.407989501953125,
0.47112375497817993,
-0.021127823740243912,
-0.279087096452713,
0.3924224376678467,
0.5164427161216736,
0.17304711043834686,
0.1775674819946289,
-0.09529335796833038,
-0.42685335874557495,
0.11074607819318771,
0.1989845633506775,
-0.627096951007843,
-0.30120885372161865,
-0.0032874110620468855,
-0.5554149150848389,
-0.5587902665138245,
0.3281520903110504,
-0.7318975329399109,
-0.3904597759246826,
-0.12354768067598343,
0.19983546435832977,
-0.13359679281711578,
-0.575758695602417,
0.28593137860298157,
-0.22181835770606995,
0.03877311199903488,
0.09599193185567856,
-0.5671567320823669,
0.6271613836288452,
0.6066163778305054,
0.5253518223762512,
0.2468743920326233,
0.20124584436416626,
-0.8303278088569641,
0.14388738572597504,
-0.5568298697471619,
0.9893624186515808,
-0.13105376064777374,
-0.26566267013549805,
0.039316076785326004,
-0.10440779477357864,
0.03914162144064903,
-0.7375518679618835,
0.5782663822174072,
-0.369457483291626,
-0.11917700618505478,
-0.27628904581069946,
-0.44485583901405334,
-0.20454925298690796,
-0.03952290490269661,
-0.6418678760528564,
0.744723379611969,
0.17017269134521484,
-0.8342351913452148,
0.5722838640213013,
-0.6269429922103882,
-0.31224316358566284,
0.34960681200027466,
-0.35120823979377747,
-0.5333511829376221,
0.37456077337265015,
-0.08002621680498123,
0.22038057446479797,
-0.49183887243270874,
0.4598536491394043,
-0.5376499891281128,
-0.08349374681711197,
0.6765375137329102,
-0.46175694465637207,
0.6719469428062439,
0.03011513687670231,
-0.30196577310562134,
-0.2296806424856186,
-0.76680588722229,
-0.03917330875992775,
0.09055796265602112,
0.0680788904428482,
-0.49744313955307007,
0.469504177570343,
-0.178201362490654,
-0.26862990856170654,
0.4025321304798126,
-0.616661012172699,
-0.036076147109270096,
-0.5117488503456116,
0.0638987123966217,
0.7341093420982361,
0.0787132978439331,
-0.13848625123500824,
-0.1061910092830658,
0.6992264986038208,
0.2371872216463089,
-0.06682541966438293,
-0.05530429258942604,
-0.3130662441253662,
-0.17297378182411194,
-0.4541657865047455,
0.845608651638031,
0.6871656775474548,
-0.6120234727859497,
0.022279489785432816,
-0.005058035720139742,
-0.06597067415714264,
-0.23312395811080933,
0.1383054554462433,
0.215421661734581,
0.4387691617012024,
0.08691640943288803,
-0.3117006719112396,
-0.7546336650848389,
-1.35090172290802,
-0.6145073175430298,
-0.38843655586242676,
-0.321368932723999,
0.02601921372115612,
0.2866795063018799,
0.12837737798690796,
1.0032038688659668,
-1.0029613971710205,
-0.34565281867980957,
-0.07873954623937607,
0.6075950264930725,
0.5726507902145386,
0.14632724225521088,
1.2970998287200928,
-1.0278693437576294,
-0.3394410312175751,
-0.05804443359375,
-0.9649462103843689,
-0.044079605489969254,
-0.07622183114290237,
0.43777531385421753,
0.004437051247805357,
0.3792542517185211,
-0.24134640395641327,
0.7014178037643433,
0.1830935776233673,
-0.383916974067688,
0.7221264243125916,
0.03627181053161621,
-0.07855615764856339,
-0.8782216310501099,
-0.21560846269130707,
0.7639493942260742,
-0.1088438406586647,
-0.4654058814048767,
-0.4073270857334137,
-0.026925791054964066,
0.16421280801296234,
-0.19193579256534576,
0.28572168946266174,
-0.2587069869041443,
-0.29438725113868713,
-0.4034252166748047,
-0.040063828229904175,
-0.3562213182449341,
0.26138195395469666,
-0.2104267179965973,
0.7192448377609253,
0.9534725546836853,
-0.364749938249588,
0.07035364210605621,
0.10947436839342117,
-0.4198465645313263,
0.39331385493278503,
-0.7118924260139465,
-0.2975768744945526,
-0.04504374787211418,
-0.07489684969186783,
-1.120535135269165,
-0.350395530462265,
0.08379287272691727,
-0.5878026485443115,
0.06431451439857483,
-0.27949386835098267,
-0.5261223912239075,
-0.662209153175354,
-0.21582655608654022,
0.12853308022022247,
0.3108731508255005,
-0.3170371949672699,
0.6811503767967224,
0.48773935437202454,
-0.8874264359474182,
-0.44855618476867676,
-0.8993215560913086,
0.23045477271080017,
-0.3596084415912628,
-0.39848795533180237,
0.2593453526496887,
0.27905502915382385,
-0.8873540163040161,
0.046806447207927704,
-0.26225244998931885,
-0.34828880429267883,
0.1688341498374939,
0.17755497992038727,
0.9053826332092285,
-0.4943860173225403,
-0.15240687131881714,
0.15631172060966492,
-0.24118362367153168,
0.7526603937149048,
-0.10921898484230042,
-0.24401302635669708,
-0.4667600691318512,
-0.18970762193202972,
-0.42611023783683777,
0.21245011687278748,
0.33402565121650696,
-0.11814761906862259,
0.6778493523597717,
0.14168497920036316,
-0.5872271656990051,
0.0739419013261795,
-0.5665926337242126,
0.07587406784296036,
-0.5695834755897522,
0.1731812208890915,
-0.1295384019613266,
-0.45763206481933594,
0.6807888150215149,
-0.12731923162937164,
0.13422514498233795,
0.8073126077651978,
0.3968967795372009,
0.05054490640759468,
1.1514803171157837,
0.7957423329353333,
-0.07381605356931686,
0.25597429275512695,
-0.19171306490898132,
0.40732836723327637,
-0.18214116990566254,
-0.047434449195861816,
-0.6197696924209595,
-0.08342095464468002,
-0.3912884294986725,
0.016856810078024864,
0.3925471305847168,
0.19534677267074585,
-0.012957992032170296,
0.3275223970413208,
-0.24250860512256622,
0.5064535140991211,
0.2773083746433258,
-0.014620780013501644,
0.35655322670936584,
0.03137355297803879,
0.018932566046714783,
-0.4885568916797638,
-0.40446048974990845,
-0.34039464592933655,
1.1051535606384277,
0.42460688948631287,
0.6051660180091858,
0.20265409350395203,
0.672655463218689,
0.780620813369751,
0.765367329120636,
-0.5348728895187378,
0.3352543115615845,
-0.2464604675769806,
-0.3946920335292816,
0.25098562240600586,
-0.7853266000747681,
-0.4115561544895172,
-0.010753835551440716,
-0.05744831636548042,
-0.9619352221488953,
0.6009355187416077,
0.06824678182601929,
-0.6383806467056274,
0.22983849048614502,
-0.7840218544006348,
0.5227242708206177,
-0.18354915082454681,
-0.20475997030735016,
-0.1173659935593605,
-0.27465641498565674,
0.7211558818817139,
-0.32162296772003174,
0.4624897837638855,
-0.14287875592708588,
0.25645965337753296,
0.9540159106254578,
-0.4770071804523468,
1.2854442596435547,
-0.5335308313369751,
-0.5080564618110657,
0.8571935892105103,
-0.13707751035690308,
0.689405083656311,
0.21932491660118103,
-0.2211073338985443,
-0.010060591623187065,
0.14074113965034485,
-0.5569683909416199,
-0.22528286278247833,
0.21093334257602692,
-0.18933230638504028,
-0.20566421747207642,
-0.6670176982879639,
-0.4773435592651367,
-0.20490606129169464,
0.0633649006485939,
-0.04611241817474365,
0.4375261068344116,
-0.14599524438381195,
0.24926967918872833,
0.2571232318878174,
-0.14971065521240234,
0.3378083407878876,
0.9312407374382019,
-0.31133654713630676,
-0.5619823932647705,
1.1756395101547241,
0.21646268665790558,
-0.11915292590856552,
-0.24871990084648132,
-0.04033123701810837,
-0.3722705841064453,
-0.46519193053245544,
0.01844121515750885,
0.1504918485879898,
-0.2368021458387375,
-0.6659132838249207,
-0.34024322032928467,
-0.22559364140033722,
-0.6290045976638794,
-0.04315362870693207,
-0.55640709400177,
-0.33899378776550293,
-0.00695756496861577,
-0.4491996169090271,
0.4739792048931122,
0.8114959597587585,
-0.3279135823249817,
0.23326531052589417,
-0.8631919026374817,
0.4214878976345062,
0.1801593154668808,
0.42552077770233154,
0.06841487437486649,
-0.16765017807483673,
-0.66265469789505,
0.22968003153800964,
-0.47218844294548035,
-0.7144788503646851,
0.6394298076629639,
-0.11006775498390198,
0.44340550899505615,
0.7814268469810486,
0.28115421533584595,
0.30964288115501404,
0.045822590589523315,
0.3385784327983856,
0.4722377061843872,
-0.8024685978889465,
0.46778252720832825,
-0.48733365535736084,
-0.1369190365076065,
0.43118196725845337,
0.4240834414958954,
-0.0672035664319992,
-0.5410282611846924,
-0.9692448377609253,
-0.7437120676040649,
0.5443757772445679,
0.17434710264205933,
-0.21425983309745789,
-0.23644888401031494,
0.23877085745334625,
-0.06492933630943298,
0.4878746569156647,
-0.5214360952377319,
-0.12388502806425095,
0.2477196455001831,
-0.08522623032331467,
0.3752846419811249,
-0.3085554838180542,
-0.1545916050672531,
0.005959080997854471,
0.4107857048511505,
-0.33958396315574646,
0.1352018564939499,
-0.07330415397882462,
0.3070254921913147,
-0.12753735482692719,
0.11395000666379929,
0.24038875102996826,
0.8782476186752319,
-0.39214417338371277,
-0.1916477382183075,
0.2771415114402771,
-0.43127360939979553,
-0.19461552798748016,
0.6079562902450562,
-0.012248554266989231,
0.3413621485233307,
0.3161703646183014,
0.5084198117256165,
0.7788293361663818,
-0.6902836561203003,
0.6909392476081848,
-0.0070016649551689625,
-0.5104214549064636,
-0.6553974151611328,
-0.23543250560760498,
-0.09335402399301529,
0.4396631121635437,
1.1146562099456787,
0.38894274830818176,
0.5038408637046814,
-0.49979501962661743,
0.4410754442214966,
-0.012006578966975212,
-0.24884380400180817,
-0.7103883624076843,
0.9777693152427673,
-0.15701140463352203,
0.03575839102268219,
0.3978894054889679,
-0.3625756800174713,
-0.5737477540969849,
1.1124366521835327,
0.6328065395355225,
0.7203523516654968,
-0.08814388513565063,
0.4509514272212982,
0.11531035602092743,
0.11369578540325165,
-0.33236783742904663,
0.3741864264011383,
0.1541876494884491,
-0.6194436550140381,
-0.8065403699874878,
-0.4481935203075409,
-0.45707061886787415,
-0.11600445210933685,
-1.2152286767959595,
0.3108822703361511,
-0.2783794403076172,
-0.5470346212387085,
0.40964317321777344,
-0.07454290241003036,
-0.3136727213859558,
0.07837656885385513,
0.3165738880634308,
1.0057594776153564,
-1.059057593345642,
0.5279880166053772,
0.43348270654678345,
-0.3721635043621063,
-0.6022071242332458,
-0.09658373147249222,
0.41252681612968445,
-0.3783750534057617,
0.9123507142066956,
-0.02815585397183895,
-0.164475217461586,
-0.22087925672531128,
-0.6264253854751587,
-0.5662426352500916,
0.7108421921730042,
0.6996063590049744,
-0.4168786108493805,
-0.2536735236644745,
-0.04036472365260124,
0.4113883376121521,
-0.2726811170578003,
-0.21034471690654755,
0.3657855987548828,
0.3437345027923584,
0.21306201815605164,
-0.8085190057754517,
-0.43201857805252075,
-0.12944306433200836,
-0.3358149826526642,
0.5207887291908264,
-0.7361412048339844,
0.8348419666290283,
-0.3289058208465576,
-0.05141478404402733,
-0.2004510760307312,
1.3051655292510986,
0.5081993937492371,
0.918733537197113,
0.40691056847572327,
0.37570664286613464,
0.8936455845832825,
-0.1047259271144867,
1.267055630683899,
-0.16713179647922516,
0.5358514189720154,
1.0899643898010254,
-0.4696023762226105,
0.9229011535644531,
0.003971201833337545,
-0.5568469762802124,
0.5489163398742676,
0.4415823817253113,
-0.21811379492282867,
0.265778124332428,
0.10426368564367294,
-0.39159536361694336,
-0.25851982831954956,
-0.1716010719537735,
-0.4180022180080414,
0.3356885612010956,
0.4934220314025879,
-0.2799927294254303,
-0.3035487234592438,
-0.14871065318584442,
-0.10797696560621262,
0.07491526007652283,
-0.3870399594306946,
0.4550686180591583,
0.5187527537345886,
-0.1339176744222641,
0.07501765340566635,
0.08572740852832794,
0.5634282827377319,
-0.8023658990859985,
-0.03175865113735199,
-0.10222697257995605,
0.42349356412887573,
-0.30747735500335693,
-0.3978479206562042,
0.6049872636795044,
0.262805700302124,
-0.1620166003704071,
-0.09154768288135529,
0.8747143149375916,
-0.15971554815769196,
-0.7875872254371643,
0.3267401158809662,
0.27936291694641113,
0.04997832700610161,
-0.14206212759017944,
-0.4766760468482971,
-0.3648107647895813,
0.0992332324385643,
-0.032794371247291565,
0.4957042932510376,
0.5718193054199219,
-0.18910709023475647,
0.5394659042358398,
0.49758803844451904,
0.13042758405208588,
-0.07915129512548447,
-0.0229212436825037,
0.6382550597190857,
-0.703393280506134,
-0.7369643449783325,
-0.6159043312072754,
0.20901378989219666,
-0.18085019290447235,
-0.04714583232998848,
0.9747878909111023,
1.0826473236083984,
0.3941563367843628,
-0.06694971770048141,
0.7260633111000061,
0.11714308708906174,
0.7043716311454773,
-0.4730428457260132,
0.5461150407791138,
-0.4269111752510071,
0.46929931640625,
-0.47384265065193176,
-0.47979894280433655,
-0.2067086547613144,
0.2224263697862625,
-0.7350232005119324,
-0.1366545408964157,
0.35613349080085754,
0.43877312541007996,
-0.1115148738026619,
0.524753212928772,
0.04625104367733002,
0.5014748573303223,
-0.03529717028141022,
0.12059216946363449,
0.5004765391349792,
-0.6099525690078735,
0.4897688627243042,
-0.09993068873882294,
-0.093132384121418,
-0.2567976117134094,
-0.8493087887763977,
-0.4037986099720001,
-0.211373433470726,
-0.9203170537948608,
-0.5602293014526367,
-0.28725698590278625,
0.3409215807914734,
0.2589609622955322,
-1.0563430786132812,
-0.3838832676410675,
0.16969692707061768,
-0.19921135902404785,
-0.37571513652801514,
-0.35466673970222473,
0.38570910692214966,
-0.2582336366176605,
-0.43388310074806213,
0.532989501953125,
0.40004777908325195,
0.40848031640052795,
0.1668437123298645,
0.21526235342025757,
0.01622876711189747,
0.11478078365325928,
0.3857177197933197,
0.48790907859802246,
-0.021039433777332306,
0.26954227685928345,
-0.2505270540714264,
0.004198708105832338,
0.005095305852591991,
0.8038402795791626,
-0.5275839567184448,
-0.22882112860679626,
0.16062523424625397,
0.6490203142166138,
0.6275343298912048,
0.15643887221813202,
0.8939694762229919,
-0.8664811253547668,
0.41900360584259033,
0.09997046738862991,
0.5173556208610535,
-0.16825875639915466,
-0.5792057514190674,
0.616071879863739,
0.2611657679080963,
-0.19013549387454987,
-1.1142957210540771,
-0.2891198992729187,
-0.7981773018836975,
-0.1808573305606842,
0.3262544870376587,
-0.22071218490600586,
-0.5100258588790894,
0.051302630454301834,
0.14979179203510284,
-0.3166794776916504,
-0.4982154965400696,
0.7991383075714111,
0.7403422594070435,
0.06386435776948929,
0.11148784309625626,
-0.9251893162727356,
0.16775260865688324,
0.3565049469470978,
-0.5254349112510681,
0.2470713108778,
0.53007572889328,
0.1740698516368866,
0.2665935456752777,
0.681486189365387,
-0.30245116353034973,
0.5913808345794678,
0.3908064067363739,
-0.0160051342099905,
0.20479224622249603,
-0.33114686608314514,
-0.14567892253398895,
0.4024239480495453,
0.015785817056894302,
-0.1282457411289215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11725v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11725v3 | How Susceptible are Large Language Models to Ideological Manipulation? | 2024-02-18T22:36:19 | 2024-06-18T05:14:02 | Kai Chen, Zihao He, Jun Yan, Taiwei Shi, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the potential to exert substantial
influence on public perceptions and interactions with information. This raises
concerns about the societal impact that could arise if the ideologies within
these models can be easily manipulated. In this work, we investigate how
effectively LLMs can learn and generalize ideological biases from their
instruction-tuning data. Our findings reveal a concerning vulnerability:
exposure to only a small amount of ideologically driven samples significantly
alters the ideology of LLMs. Notably, LLMs demonstrate a startling ability to
absorb ideology from one topic and generalize it to even unrelated ones. The
ease with which LLMs' ideologies can be skewed underscores the risks associated
with intentionally poisoned training data by malicious actors or inadvertently
introduced biases by data annotators. It also emphasizes the imperative for
robust safeguards to mitigate the influence of ideological manipulations on
LLMs. | [
-0.15559878945350647,
-0.6498209834098816,
0.5428647994995117,
-0.29214560985565186,
-0.1105429083108902,
-0.03213158994913101,
-0.48496386408805847,
-0.363599568605423,
-0.08304903656244278,
0.8921495676040649,
-0.447233110666275,
-0.47291260957717896,
-0.983644962310791,
-0.2917526960372925,
-0.4428141713142395,
1.327115774154663,
0.3014574348926544,
0.17768612504005432,
0.17749156057834625,
-0.22828832268714905,
0.05234835669398308,
-0.7411077618598938,
-0.3249257802963257,
-0.4469251334667206,
0.6787848472595215,
0.23287911713123322,
0.9381645917892456,
0.8779471516609192,
0.2953106462955475,
0.2429906725883484,
0.01488164346665144,
-0.5056141018867493,
-0.8373907208442688,
0.1926606297492981,
-0.44789934158325195,
-1.0213850736618042,
-0.08590171486139297,
0.3869907259941101,
0.6678981184959412,
0.7751006484031677,
-0.041541725397109985,
0.1092144325375557,
0.23418889939785004,
0.5910415649414062,
-0.6531781554222107,
-0.06628962606191635,
-1.4167110919952393,
-0.29121026396751404,
-0.3861331641674042,
0.08898870646953583,
-0.6771866083145142,
-0.22320879995822906,
0.173771470785141,
-0.46827390789985657,
-0.09122256934642792,
-0.09814345091581345,
0.5994105339050293,
0.3253646492958069,
-0.5680957436561584,
-0.3902413845062256,
-0.868477463722229,
1.0805529356002808,
-0.430469274520874,
0.08449982851743698,
0.2873106002807617,
0.0513148158788681,
-0.19342869520187378,
-0.40278488397598267,
-0.2955053746700287,
0.021827926859259605,
0.05014381185173988,
-0.2840658128261566,
-0.13396704196929932,
0.25857993960380554,
0.47685256600379944,
-0.15909920632839203,
-0.10761216282844543,
0.414763480424881,
-0.4160357117652893,
-0.0721392035484314,
0.668870747089386,
0.28524836897850037,
0.4958311915397644,
-0.2975350320339203,
-0.3764367699623108,
-0.2514828145503998,
-1.0870060920715332,
-0.16648966073989868,
0.8685144782066345,
0.12907759845256805,
0.07081178575754166,
0.6329748630523682,
0.18824703991413116,
0.37228915095329285,
-0.061188746243715286,
-0.02541940100491047,
-0.13874715566635132,
0.0343378521502018,
-0.24581395089626312,
0.18416334688663483,
0.5565909743309021,
0.3348623812198639,
0.5250476598739624,
0.17354260385036469,
-0.07671263068914413,
0.16791853308677673,
0.39508187770843506,
-0.5761637687683105,
-0.17448179423809052,
0.115152508020401,
-0.3174138367176056,
-0.432353675365448,
0.07426315546035767,
-0.9108458757400513,
-0.7531409859657288,
-0.2514582872390747,
0.3565075099468231,
-0.2928069829940796,
0.01923627406358719,
-0.011886915192008018,
-0.19115261733531952,
0.3985392153263092,
0.2137748748064041,
-0.8193058967590332,
-0.04711891710758209,
0.9420969486236572,
0.5297753810882568,
-0.04414159432053566,
-0.060173261910676956,
-0.27787622809410095,
0.522763729095459,
-0.3980414867401123,
0.429430216550827,
-0.9673123955726624,
-0.46591195464134216,
0.13768184185028076,
-0.12900660932064056,
0.05634927749633789,
-0.48906391859054565,
0.33925923705101013,
-0.47791343927383423,
0.03799828141927719,
-0.3100140690803528,
-0.3685167133808136,
0.032938018441200256,
0.06729146093130112,
-0.5629852414131165,
0.5198239088058472,
-0.17600823938846588,
-1.060018539428711,
0.2610076367855072,
-0.2178281545639038,
-0.3812835216522217,
-0.22639477252960205,
-0.2874965965747833,
-0.24732765555381775,
0.2887250483036041,
0.0217643603682518,
0.4847347140312195,
-0.08069419860839844,
0.12710613012313843,
-0.6039906740188599,
-0.381226509809494,
0.4888758659362793,
-0.7653443217277527,
0.7712246775627136,
0.07098417729139328,
-0.33869197964668274,
0.04821952059864998,
-0.656396210193634,
-0.16697095334529877,
0.0675634890794754,
-0.3282369375228882,
-0.926846981048584,
0.27648961544036865,
-0.23245486617088318,
0.20176288485527039,
0.08896856009960175,
-0.3118802309036255,
0.5196181535720825,
-0.652557373046875,
0.31201231479644775,
1.3927656412124634,
0.1209007203578949,
0.6488747000694275,
-0.32742127776145935,
0.39770427346229553,
-0.06019818037748337,
0.12795127928256989,
0.058982718735933304,
-0.15921200811862946,
-0.8211824297904968,
-0.15430596470832825,
-0.027651816606521606,
0.517005443572998,
-0.8052024245262146,
0.17837795615196228,
-0.3237560987472534,
-0.7390292286872864,
-0.45261919498443604,
0.31774622201919556,
0.29172956943511963,
0.030566105619072914,
-0.048387542366981506,
0.28514912724494934,
-0.3250342011451721,
-1.0423511266708374,
-0.8441500067710876,
-0.2025979906320572,
-0.23938336968421936,
0.2200995683670044,
0.6460988521575928,
-0.1743893176317215,
0.49768519401550293,
-0.5433534979820251,
-0.10544593632221222,
-0.24835509061813354,
0.21518391370773315,
0.15770132839679718,
0.32245540618896484,
0.4752771854400635,
-0.5701138377189636,
-0.483495831489563,
-0.056909795850515366,
-0.383010596036911,
-0.07335533201694489,
-0.34707897901535034,
-0.2235378921031952,
0.13685046136379242,
0.4332596957683563,
-0.5459773540496826,
0.37314584851264954,
0.4595234990119934,
-0.12071554362773895,
0.5531192421913147,
0.13198785483837128,
-0.08893214166164398,
-1.1200580596923828,
-0.07813698053359985,
-0.02189098484814167,
0.22266198694705963,
-0.7541210651397705,
-0.04417973756790161,
-0.04807224124670029,
0.20370890200138092,
-0.6551017165184021,
0.3101924657821655,
-0.24217502772808075,
0.22979946434497833,
-0.16008059680461884,
-0.10992726683616638,
-0.138647198677063,
0.08791758865118027,
-0.31433236598968506,
0.6792851090431213,
0.532166600227356,
-0.3867359459400177,
0.04029407352209091,
-0.10560602694749832,
-0.6047757863998413,
0.549126386642456,
-0.5581343770027161,
0.3766760528087616,
-0.4862683415412903,
0.24333032965660095,
-0.6662315726280212,
-0.5641968846321106,
0.27341940999031067,
0.11005912721157074,
0.45090150833129883,
-0.3473925292491913,
-0.36139577627182007,
0.22179627418518066,
-0.48581987619400024,
0.031450264155864716,
0.36897939443588257,
-0.5546725392341614,
0.5703915953636169,
0.5035454630851746,
-0.1431163251399994,
-0.8830564022064209,
-0.5721361637115479,
0.07014254480600357,
-0.6685541272163391,
-0.2763293981552124,
-0.08076998591423035,
0.11394614726305008,
-0.8117910027503967,
-0.13473506271839142,
0.036169420927762985,
0.20543497800827026,
0.18463832139968872,
0.5780548453330994,
0.27252718806266785,
0.14336621761322021,
0.4310161769390106,
0.23745791614055634,
0.17137783765792847,
0.5263103246688843,
-0.1257333904504776,
0.5967292189598083,
0.1951340138912201,
-0.48701590299606323,
-0.2896246314048767,
0.45920121669769287,
0.7931142449378967,
-0.03722500801086426,
1.0279862880706787,
0.0475224032998085,
-0.29071852564811707,
-0.5255547165870667,
-0.35127487778663635,
-0.27726152539253235,
-0.5164439082145691,
0.7273558974266052,
0.001315537141636014,
-0.6595547199249268,
0.29121193289756775,
-0.18380674719810486,
0.14962995052337646,
0.4322778880596161,
0.6895153522491455,
-0.07676000148057938,
1.1726092100143433,
0.42357710003852844,
-0.48236438632011414,
0.5518448948860168,
-0.25474628806114197,
-0.014682091772556305,
-0.7322173118591309,
-0.08769884705543518,
-0.7284296154975891,
-0.44027695059776306,
-0.6763730645179749,
-0.39401373267173767,
0.5518617033958435,
-0.40044212341308594,
-0.33417895436286926,
-0.27592217922210693,
-0.3857799768447876,
0.8341233134269714,
0.19398233294487,
0.03017888218164444,
-0.11236204206943512,
0.18209567666053772,
0.1600734144449234,
-0.14795196056365967,
-0.3601071238517761,
-0.7387384176254272,
1.447453498840332,
0.6178475022315979,
1.4732929468154907,
-0.0525209903717041,
0.4451840817928314,
0.15603351593017578,
0.4731602668762207,
-0.5470429062843323,
0.4544074535369873,
-0.3419978618621826,
-0.8130318522453308,
-0.15456412732601166,
-0.21328936517238617,
-0.7545404434204102,
0.16505396366119385,
-0.16232551634311676,
-0.9940018057823181,
0.2514200806617737,
0.06417559832334518,
0.05825995281338692,
0.48856934905052185,
-0.5991114974021912,
0.3545933961868286,
-0.4893571138381958,
-0.4146604835987091,
-0.443652868270874,
-0.6102882027626038,
0.34918084740638733,
-0.18298403918743134,
0.31727153062820435,
-0.23324331641197205,
-0.1547815203666687,
0.7630205154418945,
0.25393474102020264,
1.2596107721328735,
-0.17267054319381714,
-0.16597965359687805,
-0.17550823092460632,
0.13413657248020172,
0.5464953780174255,
0.01115527842193842,
-0.35312914848327637,
0.45002177357673645,
-0.025227410718798637,
-0.3345387578010559,
-0.4946620464324951,
0.8617294430732727,
-1.11326003074646,
-1.1571435928344727,
-0.5004943013191223,
-0.7155217528343201,
-0.12976044416427612,
0.12209608405828476,
0.37439948320388794,
0.20455709099769592,
-0.19095969200134277,
0.4236398935317993,
0.8096005320549011,
-0.32767295837402344,
0.07358922064304352,
0.21190355718135834,
-0.12143155187368393,
-0.20222924649715424,
0.6888076663017273,
0.4497131109237671,
0.8526023030281067,
-0.002494779182597995,
0.13179481029510498,
-0.022216128185391426,
-0.4062708616256714,
-0.210196852684021,
0.19141876697540283,
-1.0498348474502563,
-0.02578071877360344,
-0.5310084819793701,
-0.0875031128525734,
-0.17054744064807892,
-0.33170536160469055,
-0.25995129346847534,
-0.17102080583572388,
-0.5662102103233337,
-0.134756937623024,
0.24880248308181763,
1.1001285314559937,
0.2073860615491867,
0.5443143248558044,
-0.3236995041370392,
-0.11417478322982788,
0.20568080246448517,
0.16171813011169434,
-0.32923758029937744,
-0.6206487417221069,
-0.1328769028186798,
0.2549280822277069,
-0.1548915058374405,
-1.2631343603134155,
0.19376042485237122,
0.28129440546035767,
0.5380162596702576,
0.7664092779159546,
0.10471400618553162,
0.25186535716056824,
-0.39008665084838867,
0.7763017416000366,
-0.22318784892559052,
-0.8494499921798706,
0.4256625175476074,
-0.4527795612812042,
0.34511199593544006,
0.42200949788093567,
0.741087794303894,
-0.3305528163909912,
-0.7580834031105042,
-0.38536033034324646,
-0.7398398518562317,
0.7492332458496094,
-0.4172440767288208,
0.6618497371673584,
0.10027990490198135,
0.4770454466342926,
0.2420511692762375,
0.14004385471343994,
-0.5447779297828674,
-0.31982189416885376,
-0.1683928668498993,
-0.22099444270133972,
-0.08197107911109924,
-0.5040902495384216,
-0.47229936718940735,
-0.2099173665046692,
0.687525749206543,
-0.10652255266904831,
-0.18455849587917328,
-0.1843143254518509,
-0.016945093870162964,
0.000041076287743635476,
0.6077480316162109,
0.3248816132545471,
0.6324640512466431,
0.14623862504959106,
0.4832734763622284,
0.18130600452423096,
-0.3694506585597992,
0.2198377102613449,
-0.38433364033699036,
-0.26323050260543823,
-0.30454134941101074,
0.2814953327178955,
0.7269866466522217,
0.24909260869026184,
-0.45188140869140625,
0.26650863885879517,
0.16494502127170563,
0.06705094128847122,
-0.3137417435646057,
0.30549371242523193,
0.10249391198158264,
0.06012740358710289,
0.30171263217926025,
-0.04202934727072716,
-0.15498808026313782,
-0.8910189270973206,
0.056863926351070404,
0.8931784629821777,
-0.14171643555164337,
-0.31387028098106384,
0.4503380060195923,
-0.049338195472955704,
-0.10033423453569412,
0.459872305393219,
0.3189204931259155,
-0.7401806712150574,
0.3962268829345703,
0.6244623064994812,
0.5776467323303223,
-0.5311404466629028,
0.17710554599761963,
0.1398971825838089,
0.7176967263221741,
0.2955220639705658,
-0.1213308721780777,
0.44054269790649414,
-0.7356974482536316,
-0.2697475254535675,
-0.4674180746078491,
-0.2792934477329254,
0.3200910985469818,
-0.740337610244751,
0.21664829552173615,
-0.7427051067352295,
-0.13838544487953186,
0.059022653847932816,
-0.3295033872127533,
-0.5099620819091797,
-0.03979643061757088,
0.1410440355539322,
0.6339859962463379,
-1.1054527759552002,
1.070418119430542,
0.6565300822257996,
0.13428102433681488,
-0.7012385129928589,
0.4145703613758087,
0.2152291089296341,
-0.7931879162788391,
0.6936757564544678,
0.1677190065383911,
0.013888961635529995,
-0.18485763669013977,
-0.9091330766677856,
-0.7372967600822449,
0.5282713770866394,
0.7021253705024719,
-0.4594840109348297,
-0.09736943989992142,
0.5118473172187805,
0.41633686423301697,
-0.21883320808410645,
-0.0485367625951767,
0.8422502875328064,
0.5203976035118103,
-0.18408387899398804,
-0.44414904713630676,
-0.09087086468935013,
0.13694971799850464,
-0.1385306566953659,
0.4045630097389221,
-0.5524038076400757,
0.985600471496582,
-0.0411173477768898,
-0.17817535996437073,
-0.36815083026885986,
0.25624918937683105,
-0.1896742284297943,
0.0674765557050705,
0.4433141350746155,
0.262500524520874,
0.5619757771492004,
0.008158671669661999,
0.978482723236084,
-0.4163748323917389,
0.03192511573433876,
0.8399916887283325,
-0.4282803535461426,
0.7632955312728882,
0.717283308506012,
0.15261346101760864,
0.45049017667770386,
0.07719899713993073,
0.0893208384513855,
0.39106738567352295,
0.20960654318332672,
-0.4379274845123291,
-0.2276846468448639,
-0.2712671756744385,
-0.11296473443508148,
0.8187842965126038,
0.8708110451698303,
-0.5621930360794067,
-0.09415965527296066,
0.14469723403453827,
0.4383213520050049,
0.23333346843719482,
-0.39332565665245056,
0.7490295171737671,
0.050381094217300415,
-0.5422338843345642,
0.3234816789627075,
-0.06521319597959518,
0.5058860182762146,
-0.7996103763580322,
-0.08372011035680771,
0.300565242767334,
0.2673756778240204,
-0.23274613916873932,
-0.8129656314849854,
0.30135226249694824,
-0.004580237437039614,
-0.07336484640836716,
-0.25172698497772217,
0.9277763962745667,
-0.2850152254104614,
-0.5066072940826416,
0.27656254172325134,
0.14127123355865479,
-0.14308704435825348,
-0.003599936841055751,
-0.42829543352127075,
0.5306591987609863,
0.2174997329711914,
-0.5184919834136963,
0.7592028975486755,
0.09972257912158966,
-0.03764261677861214,
0.7348282337188721,
0.6445326805114746,
0.3091078996658325,
0.1032605692744255,
-0.4857878088951111,
1.0177221298217773,
-0.3819507956504822,
-0.040561478585004807,
-1.0913528203964233,
0.2110343724489212,
-0.11350435763597488,
-0.09023898094892502,
0.8192927837371826,
0.21379511058330536,
1.0380393266677856,
-0.0299533624202013,
1.0219727754592896,
0.23315821588039398,
0.3302652835845947,
-0.6235185265541077,
1.291934609413147,
-0.25877973437309265,
0.4814162850379944,
0.08409637212753296,
-0.6618545055389404,
-0.07509233802556992,
0.42812231183052063,
-0.8065244555473328,
-0.0583517849445343,
0.2835730016231537,
0.8406246900558472,
0.21189288794994354,
-0.10911325365304947,
0.287880539894104,
0.6837706565856934,
0.3488456904888153,
0.43344420194625854,
0.8770539164543152,
0.1864539384841919,
0.3546840250492096,
-0.5012087821960449,
-0.14050094783306122,
-0.07047391682863235,
-0.7750417590141296,
-1.0027625560760498,
-0.4034494161605835,
0.008219868876039982,
-0.30518999695777893,
0.29272526502609253,
0.9643897414207458,
0.35608071088790894,
-0.5399046540260315,
-0.168783038854599,
0.48657503724098206,
0.4783322513103485,
0.34666746854782104,
-0.23275943100452423,
0.332671195268631,
0.037584587931632996,
-0.9630975723266602,
0.14259925484657288,
0.2736922800540924,
-0.22313697636127472,
-0.7171291708946228,
0.25171664357185364,
-0.1032211184501648,
0.47271233797073364,
0.393746018409729,
0.009110073558986187,
-0.7946457266807556,
-0.8336542248725891,
-0.16114261746406555,
-0.2510536313056946,
-0.1345592588186264,
0.6813692450523376,
-0.5572003126144409,
0.48531416058540344,
0.24680373072624207,
0.5088258981704712,
-0.38888782262802124,
-0.053461361676454544,
0.48932936787605286,
-0.8476656675338745,
0.24209818243980408,
0.2511031925678253,
0.29644033312797546,
0.19657205045223236,
-0.5512346029281616,
-0.02398546412587166,
0.11284687370061874,
-0.6120176315307617,
-0.9751390218734741,
0.3851347863674164,
-0.48271310329437256,
-0.36469346284866333,
1.5255247354507446,
-0.03936884179711342,
-0.30492207407951355,
0.010571472346782684,
-0.28362008929252625,
0.14063960313796997,
-0.14993548393249512,
0.9064144492149353,
0.7682563066482544,
0.20149600505828857,
0.10842637717723846,
-0.7398932576179504,
0.29804015159606934,
0.3655444085597992,
-0.7682414650917053,
0.2970571219921112,
0.5063751935958862,
0.5721349716186523,
-0.16062256693840027,
0.06060304865241051,
0.04571997746825218,
-0.027952224016189575,
-0.11222460865974426,
-0.1215154379606247,
0.2581673264503479,
-0.39040425419807434,
-0.5847011208534241,
0.18169938027858734,
0.22918763756752014,
0.1289726197719574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11723v1 | Shaping Human-AI Collaboration: Varied Scaffolding Levels in Co-writing with Language Models | 2024-02-18T22:27:42 | 2024-02-18T22:27:42 | Paramveer S. Dhillon, Somayeh Molaei, Jiaqi Li, Maximilian Golub, Shaochun Zheng, Lionel P. Robert | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Advances in language modeling have paved the way for novel human-AI
co-writing experiences. This paper explores how varying levels of scaffolding
from large language models (LLMs) shape the co-writing process. Employing a
within-subjects field experiment with a Latin square design, we asked
participants (N=131) to respond to argumentative writing prompts under three
randomly sequenced conditions: no AI assistance (control), next-sentence
suggestions (low scaffolding), and next-paragraph suggestions (high
scaffolding). Our findings reveal a U-shaped impact of scaffolding on writing
quality and productivity (words/time). While low scaffolding did not
significantly improve writing quality or productivity, high scaffolding led to
significant improvements, especially benefiting non-regular writers and less
tech-savvy users. No significant cognitive burden was observed while using the
scaffolded writing tools, but a moderate decrease in text ownership and
satisfaction was noted. Our results have broad implications for the design of
AI-powered writing tools, including the need for personalized scaffolding
mechanisms. | [
-0.22261689603328705,
-0.704137921333313,
0.7005578279495239,
0.2878653109073639,
0.16019751131534576,
0.37388288974761963,
0.038965094834566116,
-0.6674408912658691,
0.12909485399723053,
0.33862122893333435,
-0.549373209476471,
-0.4089888334274292,
-0.38867536187171936,
0.3194945454597473,
-0.27911219000816345,
1.091372013092041,
-0.32174521684646606,
-0.13444215059280396,
-0.8016753792762756,
-0.15086297690868378,
-0.5702497363090515,
-0.7483304142951965,
-0.43965572118759155,
-0.45135799050331116,
0.828795850276947,
0.6188395619392395,
0.6519490480422974,
0.8362062573432922,
0.3999166786670685,
0.3588208258152008,
0.30433574318885803,
-0.1240798830986023,
-0.2539009749889374,
0.33031967282295227,
-0.05967843532562256,
-0.7163470387458801,
-0.6099068522453308,
0.09933239966630936,
0.24890358746051788,
0.85291987657547,
-0.12559866905212402,
0.1995038092136383,
0.32288995385169983,
0.516477644443512,
-0.374362587928772,
-0.09833761304616928,
-0.5631027221679688,
0.06714249402284622,
-0.2016986906528473,
-0.014680257998406887,
-0.40115365386009216,
-0.11802876740694046,
0.14093154668807983,
-0.505403995513916,
0.3945712447166443,
0.4651924669742584,
0.7986847162246704,
0.28414809703826904,
0.07192476093769073,
-0.49915334582328796,
-0.6865920424461365,
0.4255286157131195,
-0.5489246249198914,
-0.011665401980280876,
0.42944446206092834,
-0.0045174406841397285,
-0.22820009291172028,
-0.7335990071296692,
-0.465256929397583,
-0.40674689412117004,
0.02209119312465191,
0.07206369936466217,
0.042950890958309174,
0.2995813190937042,
0.31738728284835815,
0.35992756485939026,
-0.3819896876811981,
0.42807918787002563,
-0.4520348608493805,
-0.3397659361362457,
0.9036269187927246,
0.3282598853111267,
0.42873644828796387,
0.3085606098175049,
-0.3089783489704132,
0.0032654323149472475,
-0.7898512482643127,
0.258396178483963,
0.627021074295044,
0.1363171488046646,
-0.1414482593536377,
0.8108182549476624,
-0.12481740117073059,
0.41359904408454895,
-0.020517190918326378,
0.16966365277767181,
-0.19647762179374695,
-0.2052748054265976,
-0.22892092168331146,
-0.1487659066915512,
0.7886353731155396,
0.41297900676727295,
0.3269732594490051,
-0.1924210488796234,
-0.10329598188400269,
0.3574972152709961,
0.2722727656364441,
-0.45744821429252625,
-0.2970921993255615,
0.14133746922016144,
-0.28956666588783264,
-0.2706785798072815,
0.11584945768117905,
-0.1736288219690323,
-0.7527832388877869,
-0.3059510588645935,
0.17050673067569733,
-0.25771206617355347,
0.14998167753219604,
-0.003365047974511981,
-0.3245982527732849,
-0.009106217883527279,
0.2704600989818573,
-0.875175952911377,
0.5329605340957642,
0.5297313928604126,
0.7848148941993713,
-0.20638909935951233,
-0.7183487415313721,
-0.5042427778244019,
0.24169380962848663,
-0.214511439204216,
0.8972116112709045,
-0.34399595856666565,
-0.2683539092540741,
0.08568666130304337,
-0.4886877238750458,
-0.10235555469989777,
-0.2243688404560089,
0.4838326871395111,
-0.022588737308979034,
0.5840793251991272,
-0.12583859264850616,
-0.4711098372936249,
0.2680557072162628,
0.010849918238818645,
-0.6195828914642334,
1.0087130069732666,
0.05399671196937561,
-0.6423885822296143,
0.5157003998756409,
-0.730258584022522,
-0.6129275560379028,
0.21894586086273193,
-0.5887699127197266,
-0.3993774354457855,
0.3510650396347046,
0.053688909858465195,
0.5987889170646667,
-0.30394700169563293,
0.2746276259422302,
-0.22873617708683014,
-0.5236636996269226,
0.37427717447280884,
-0.19798706471920013,
0.49094468355178833,
-0.07028203457593918,
-0.3838968575000763,
0.44358304142951965,
-0.6396382451057434,
-0.18358933925628662,
-0.05981466546654701,
-0.47573232650756836,
-0.015250314958393574,
-0.06385750323534012,
-0.20915985107421875,
0.34907183051109314,
0.16448692977428436,
-0.4415432810783386,
0.08121230453252792,
-0.23747316002845764,
0.6158187389373779,
0.8243761658668518,
-0.024962514638900757,
0.5973766446113586,
-0.8565449118614197,
0.781792163848877,
-0.49518176913261414,
-0.22371648252010345,
-0.17879240214824677,
-0.5102940797805786,
-0.7720450162887573,
-0.30485862493515015,
-0.032565124332904816,
0.24811065196990967,
-0.5066933035850525,
0.2982691526412964,
-0.10835930705070496,
-0.5016341209411621,
-0.8520474433898926,
0.1700839251279831,
0.4592055678367615,
0.39789435267448425,
0.12958462536334991,
-0.1507660299539566,
-0.5351953506469727,
-0.9997614622116089,
-0.4927540719509125,
-0.33007580041885376,
-0.19088846445083618,
0.12819220125675201,
0.5063184499740601,
0.1638224869966507,
0.9304962754249573,
-0.48629385232925415,
-0.45329728722572327,
-0.6189022064208984,
0.46528470516204834,
-0.18252038955688477,
0.35239100456237793,
0.29117342829704285,
-0.2749408185482025,
-0.6918639540672302,
-0.43423542380332947,
-0.5359793305397034,
-0.3122515082359314,
-0.5363157987594604,
-0.09399710595607758,
0.5143245458602905,
0.8196584582328796,
-0.761633038520813,
0.5705462694168091,
0.4537436068058014,
-0.3354421555995941,
0.5803555846214294,
-0.44314631819725037,
-0.1788095235824585,
-1.1182204484939575,
0.09731413424015045,
-0.18050076067447662,
0.083997942507267,
-0.4512801468372345,
0.11782398819923401,
-0.46553143858909607,
-0.07957467436790466,
-0.18246977031230927,
0.14100901782512665,
-0.5958013534545898,
-0.06985370814800262,
-0.10248705744743347,
0.26511600613594055,
0.19364610314369202,
0.619495153427124,
-0.1208672896027565,
0.6366654634475708,
0.10200420022010803,
-0.029780328273773193,
-0.03130979463458061,
0.21886731684207916,
-0.28172361850738525,
0.531906008720398,
-0.9492295980453491,
0.692577064037323,
-0.039242956787347794,
0.5036366581916809,
-1.0120606422424316,
-0.48710623383522034,
0.01711544394493103,
-0.3134438097476959,
-0.27665677666664124,
0.3128754198551178,
-0.6169156432151794,
-0.328085333108902,
-0.5040585398674011,
0.09826382249593735,
-0.058396026492118835,
-0.06165233626961708,
0.6926564574241638,
0.3027474880218506,
-0.43715640902519226,
0.0820249691605568,
-0.8366378545761108,
0.46952149271965027,
-0.2241964489221573,
-0.8827137351036072,
0.7257099151611328,
-0.411782830953598,
-0.4059465825557709,
-0.20482106506824493,
0.19433438777923584,
0.0032000881619751453,
0.31849685311317444,
0.8902471661567688,
0.2247539907693863,
0.046081166714429855,
-0.04394556209445,
0.23510807752609253,
-0.03626086935400963,
0.05740554630756378,
0.22987449169158936,
0.7347065806388855,
-0.22879576683044434,
-0.2644449472427368,
-0.7173919081687927,
0.9048972129821777,
0.5851706266403198,
-0.2502370774745941,
0.6841257214546204,
0.3535698652267456,
-0.38563141226768494,
-0.18230214715003967,
-0.38298580050468445,
-0.0710134208202362,
-0.4575188457965851,
0.12925639748573303,
-0.40677309036254883,
-1.1682299375534058,
0.4071682393550873,
0.08084758371114731,
0.2188870906829834,
0.22271431982517242,
0.5790201425552368,
-0.6154296398162842,
0.9915912747383118,
0.8513163924217224,
0.019661854952573776,
0.43094128370285034,
-0.10329700261354446,
0.1607675999403,
-0.612302303314209,
-0.18913815915584564,
-0.6696428060531616,
-0.5136471390724182,
-0.2530440092086792,
-0.16248536109924316,
0.17971311509609222,
-0.00615308154374361,
-0.23296764492988586,
0.34414225816726685,
-0.4216277599334717,
0.44437506794929504,
0.7876713275909424,
-0.10614575445652008,
0.24618925154209137,
-0.058433450758457184,
-0.28845903277397156,
-0.08570998907089233,
-0.9957007765769958,
-0.6745235323905945,
0.638130784034729,
0.3160717785358429,
0.39353930950164795,
-0.40491849184036255,
0.7839384078979492,
0.5561037063598633,
0.34784772992134094,
-0.28978943824768066,
0.6184245347976685,
0.18163082003593445,
-0.5617877840995789,
-0.4502284526824951,
0.23988083004951477,
-0.7459279894828796,
0.08633410930633545,
-0.6593761444091797,
-0.836670458316803,
-0.10370644927024841,
0.13390637934207916,
-0.6561760902404785,
-0.054743364453315735,
-0.8495907187461853,
0.5545779466629028,
-0.1308922916650772,
-0.5007739663124084,
-0.45051032304763794,
-0.7782335877418518,
-0.24636997282505035,
0.39795997738838196,
0.24519535899162292,
0.10836240649223328,
0.14877133071422577,
0.6652154326438904,
-0.5052036643028259,
1.1243435144424438,
0.24251362681388855,
-0.09017116576433182,
0.4913286864757538,
0.09725790470838547,
0.5537550449371338,
-0.15119093656539917,
-0.3814997971057892,
-0.001201100181788206,
-0.2864040732383728,
-0.4290153682231903,
-0.5107787251472473,
0.5863812565803528,
-0.9073994755744934,
-0.8554071187973022,
-0.4197137653827667,
-0.9186867475509644,
-0.012773632071912289,
0.1184154748916626,
0.3966374695301056,
0.359912246465683,
-0.3302097022533417,
0.31689542531967163,
-0.08363501727581024,
0.12238877266645432,
0.6269852519035339,
-0.07563722133636475,
0.028552236035466194,
-0.5083245635032654,
0.6554256677627563,
0.1574336141347885,
0.32779461145401,
0.04635884612798691,
0.10787701606750488,
0.09394894540309906,
-0.6827762722969055,
-0.47196534276008606,
0.08087270706892014,
-0.42778635025024414,
0.03014925867319107,
-0.4726404547691345,
-0.22234109044075012,
-0.39162173867225647,
-0.7638558745384216,
0.04380171000957489,
-0.5944929122924805,
-0.3109090030193329,
-0.33641672134399414,
-0.06495525687932968,
0.9442138075828552,
0.16754750907421112,
0.3751441538333893,
-0.5780051350593567,
0.08646810054779053,
-0.06529566645622253,
0.16507333517074585,
-0.07127998024225235,
0.009298808872699738,
-0.5549864768981934,
0.023043256253004074,
-0.23383207619190216,
-0.4730195999145508,
-0.0848904475569725,
0.12338346987962723,
0.3621707260608673,
0.07356628775596619,
0.004715524148195982,
0.6260448694229126,
-0.266053706407547,
0.9941832423210144,
0.16131028532981873,
-0.8367177248001099,
0.18755677342414856,
-0.5029492378234863,
0.33846724033355713,
0.7778276205062866,
0.1693999469280243,
-0.49767813086509705,
-0.5512179136276245,
-0.3598040044307709,
-0.9574110507965088,
0.46105140447616577,
0.45230308175086975,
0.06640469282865524,
0.40587881207466125,
0.5779944658279419,
0.3807663917541504,
0.22548753023147583,
-0.8006642460823059,
0.3018587827682495,
0.11696421355009079,
-0.2566159665584564,
0.15090113878250122,
-0.1798618584871292,
-0.33451616764068604,
-0.256265789270401,
0.14669230580329895,
-0.17757676541805267,
0.21194255352020264,
0.25594839453697205,
-0.1460874080657959,
-0.3589758574962616,
0.17362326383590698,
0.6034243106842041,
0.5174205899238586,
0.1548401564359665,
0.13551048934459686,
0.25195804238319397,
-0.1929396688938141,
-0.003506473498418927,
0.05320223420858383,
-0.11476528644561768,
-0.523863673210144,
0.9480809569358826,
0.7188291549682617,
-0.12580783665180206,
-0.36677485704421997,
0.21446232497692108,
-0.18880613148212433,
-0.6120514273643494,
-0.30082881450653076,
0.6084092259407043,
0.21877408027648926,
0.36015409231185913,
0.3156665563583374,
0.1840682327747345,
-0.24454432725906372,
-0.7060112357139587,
-0.1763758808374405,
0.2875879406929016,
-0.29132917523384094,
-0.5160815119743347,
0.6280294060707092,
0.4347990155220032,
-0.981736421585083,
0.4800797402858734,
0.16729067265987396,
-0.3128683269023895,
0.4175318777561188,
0.5630520582199097,
0.9166982173919678,
0.021149031817913055,
0.38116711378097534,
-0.21119484305381775,
0.17031629383563995,
0.2708524763584137,
0.29050561785697937,
-0.22794875502586365,
-0.46323272585868835,
-0.1785191148519516,
-0.25007471442222595,
-0.5453382134437561,
0.02583109773695469,
-0.4725808799266815,
0.3369729518890381,
-0.5903038382530212,
-0.006397252436727285,
-0.05921947956085205,
0.21364668011665344,
-0.710067868232727,
0.2678992450237274,
-0.04450767859816551,
0.6899064183235168,
-0.8628201484680176,
0.5081172585487366,
1.0856192111968994,
-0.6505218148231506,
-0.5644001960754395,
0.28252550959587097,
-0.07596057653427124,
-0.44816887378692627,
-0.08678873628377914,
0.3443794548511505,
-0.5000303983688354,
0.0605609230697155,
-0.830481231212616,
-0.6566314101219177,
1.507116436958313,
0.3823516070842743,
-0.4644281268119812,
-0.454841285943985,
0.824960470199585,
1.0936551094055176,
-0.8394899368286133,
-0.05192142724990845,
0.2614613175392151,
0.09172862023115158,
-0.2387915700674057,
-0.6081188917160034,
0.31612780690193176,
-0.3217436671257019,
-0.19466882944107056,
-0.38898542523384094,
-0.8424261808395386,
0.572535514831543,
-0.324104905128479,
-0.2160699963569641,
0.43437978625297546,
0.7925552725791931,
0.3696674108505249,
0.45724454522132874,
0.5877310037612915,
0.39139533042907715,
0.7699522376060486,
0.28021976351737976,
0.8073918223381042,
-0.39120981097221375,
-0.4697435796260834,
1.2135623693466187,
-0.4094623327255249,
0.7902477383613586,
0.6524321436882019,
0.13170786201953888,
1.0829589366912842,
0.2700901925563812,
0.21264110505580902,
0.07198618352413177,
0.500359058380127,
-0.0728074312210083,
-0.20278476178646088,
-0.47428616881370544,
-0.1556161642074585,
0.4067580997943878,
0.14305861294269562,
-0.24346911907196045,
0.2003794014453888,
-0.1343597024679184,
0.3189363479614258,
0.503659188747406,
0.2718985080718994,
0.6941249966621399,
0.2439405620098114,
-1.1044138669967651,
0.09156662225723267,
-0.03484579175710678,
0.2268414944410324,
-0.09188178181648254,
0.004668307490646839,
-0.23644638061523438,
0.08068723231554031,
-0.28751224279403687,
-0.8746105432510376,
0.3713753819465637,
0.12561024725437164,
-0.1824306845664978,
-0.6921456456184387,
0.7024633288383484,
-0.46743980050086975,
-0.19107685983181,
0.15373584628105164,
0.6240772604942322,
-0.12188462167978287,
-0.11371860653162003,
-0.4100860357284546,
0.3654234707355499,
-0.4091409146785736,
-0.23892252147197723,
0.4012189507484436,
0.35942786931991577,
-0.3423565924167633,
0.4962334930896759,
0.8555176258087158,
-0.19997268915176392,
-0.33556392788887024,
0.1780049055814743,
1.0412296056747437,
-0.5445273518562317,
-0.6241809725761414,
-0.7355659008026123,
0.8986584544181824,
-0.3134995102882385,
-0.6623777747154236,
0.5703670382499695,
0.5222992897033691,
0.651906430721283,
0.24963420629501343,
0.9507549405097961,
-0.06807388365268707,
0.11547750979661942,
-0.15618470311164856,
0.9561126232147217,
-0.28042295575141907,
0.12914755940437317,
-0.46512168645858765,
-0.7571914196014404,
-0.5383041501045227,
0.289324015378952,
-0.16149426996707916,
-0.14811742305755615,
0.7136029601097107,
0.6352545022964478,
0.44616949558258057,
0.062325283885002136,
0.1486281305551529,
0.17377588152885437,
0.6141091585159302,
0.35845068097114563,
0.904558002948761,
-0.08699817210435867,
0.49540427327156067,
-0.14777541160583496,
-0.2817608416080475,
-0.21159440279006958,
-0.9924718737602234,
-1.3129442930221558,
-0.882387101650238,
-0.21097829937934875,
-0.3625079095363617,
0.10742679238319397,
1.1810811758041382,
0.4261927604675293,
-0.42016902565956116,
-0.44678980112075806,
-0.5198799967765808,
-0.016829393804073334,
0.04642052203416824,
-0.10708367079496384,
0.25930526852607727,
-0.0017387755215168,
-0.3729906678199768,
0.3997783064842224,
0.45415037870407104,
-0.03546803817152977,
-0.38569876551628113,
-0.20547792315483093,
-0.37652796506881714,
0.3509519100189209,
0.3916108012199402,
0.12744081020355225,
-0.42166006565093994,
-0.42888471484184265,
0.28780242800712585,
-0.22456003725528717,
0.15136121213436127,
0.9453497529029846,
-0.553597092628479,
0.1564319133758545,
0.6793357133865356,
0.37984031438827515,
0.4135560989379883,
0.059770748019218445,
1.158539891242981,
-0.6180826425552368,
-0.0019540884532034397,
0.1546914279460907,
0.3274552524089813,
0.4791506826877594,
-0.3880925476551056,
0.3424279987812042,
0.1806955188512802,
-0.755210816860199,
-0.7816929817199707,
0.14113974571228027,
-0.42812201380729675,
-0.07174797356128693,
0.8602420687675476,
-0.21014922857284546,
-0.16689421236515045,
-0.23326179385185242,
-0.7287667393684387,
0.283949077129364,
-0.3488776385784149,
1.313887596130371,
1.0844531059265137,
-0.7036601305007935,
0.038149770349264145,
0.06829197704792023,
0.5356040000915527,
0.5547562837600708,
-0.920565664768219,
0.001983906142413616,
0.6311527490615845,
-0.15875567495822906,
0.15981826186180115,
0.88320392370224,
0.3737022578716278,
0.20771408081054688,
0.06550398468971252,
-0.08676683902740479,
-0.23689702153205872,
-0.677672266960144,
-0.21582822501659393,
0.3899691700935364,
0.31422314047813416,
0.13797156512737274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11712v1 | Modelling Political Coalition Negotiations Using LLM-based Agents | 2024-02-18T21:28:06 | 2024-02-18T21:28:06 | Farhad Moghimifar, Yuan-Fang Li, Robert Thomson, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coalition negotiations are a cornerstone of parliamentary democracies,
characterised by complex interactions and strategic communications among
political parties. Despite its significance, the modelling of these
negotiations has remained unexplored with the domain of Natural Language
Processing (NLP), mostly due to lack of proper data. In this paper, we
introduce coalition negotiations as a novel NLP task, and model it as a
negotiation between large language model-based agents. We introduce a
multilingual dataset, POLCA, comprising manifestos of European political
parties and coalition agreements over a number of elections in these countries.
This dataset addresses the challenge of the current scope limitations in
political negotiation modelling by providing a diverse, real-world basis for
simulation. Additionally, we propose a hierarchical Markov decision process
designed to simulate the process of coalition negotiation between political
parties and predict the outcomes. We evaluate the performance of
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) as agents in handling coalition
negotiations, offering insights into their capabilities and paving the way for
future advancements in political modelling. | [
-0.7421125173568726,
-0.4508557915687561,
0.7732586860656738,
0.11744645982980728,
-0.39469051361083984,
0.0059967441484332085,
-0.5544252991676331,
-0.2438298463821411,
0.41271382570266724,
0.7746689319610596,
-0.7628946304321289,
-0.768584668636322,
-0.4641488194465637,
0.12906122207641602,
-0.2731185257434845,
0.4632229506969452,
0.3873511552810669,
0.21622398495674133,
-0.12014202028512955,
-0.21595652401447296,
-0.17864997684955597,
-0.910366415977478,
-0.656962513923645,
-0.5977153778076172,
0.37885868549346924,
0.2565528154373169,
0.7804523706436157,
0.3347727358341217,
0.4247620403766632,
0.3302258551120758,
-0.347214937210083,
0.12712527811527252,
-0.3419768214225769,
0.1878633201122284,
-0.5319187641143799,
-0.5978803634643555,
-0.3551883399486542,
0.08677274733781815,
0.810140073299408,
0.6021914482116699,
-0.6770015358924866,
-0.23716305196285248,
0.03005210869014263,
0.5211706161499023,
-0.5310018658638,
0.7841157913208008,
-1.1577893495559692,
0.08252651244401932,
-0.15645380318164825,
-0.1818707287311554,
-0.6102096438407898,
-0.013954165391623974,
-0.20259974896907806,
-0.2974433898925781,
-0.37807750701904297,
-0.18523748219013214,
0.5652697682380676,
0.15780441462993622,
-0.5641770958900452,
-0.4234120845794678,
-0.5293563604354858,
0.46663615107536316,
-0.8438507914543152,
0.13661698997020721,
0.24830305576324463,
0.34670063853263855,
-0.7059309482574463,
-0.6936777830123901,
-0.5425616502761841,
-0.20441769063472748,
0.1464386284351349,
0.25154733657836914,
-0.13233084976673126,
-0.05508456751704216,
-0.14575199782848358,
0.16983339190483093,
-0.2564927935600281,
0.43745487928390503,
-0.1943632960319519,
0.06297510862350464,
0.5759836435317993,
0.4814980626106262,
0.0341525636613369,
-0.47507086396217346,
-0.604881763458252,
0.3351997137069702,
-0.7110609412193298,
-0.049213141202926636,
0.5880823731422424,
0.9074655175209045,
-0.3134739398956299,
0.8403787612915039,
0.02508954331278801,
1.0014053583145142,
0.01056388858705759,
0.1518523246049881,
-0.2607343792915344,
-0.3323773443698883,
-0.1708568036556244,
-0.28156402707099915,
0.956114649772644,
0.19289229810237885,
0.26953640580177307,
-0.1261075735092163,
-0.1676517128944397,
0.433454304933548,
0.005672784056514502,
-0.40475818514823914,
-0.14242997765541077,
0.42472273111343384,
-0.4284626841545105,
-0.36589279770851135,
-0.19581907987594604,
-0.8306514024734497,
-0.21616657078266144,
-0.619003176689148,
-0.10657807439565659,
-0.19567817449569702,
-0.4283510148525238,
0.36067038774490356,
0.08186765015125275,
0.5069860219955444,
0.27229928970336914,
-0.6290196776390076,
0.68365877866745,
0.8381541967391968,
0.6708410978317261,
-0.23838229477405548,
-0.15328632295131683,
-0.34254390001296997,
0.20136402547359467,
-0.43265846371650696,
1.0150926113128662,
-0.7765032052993774,
-0.40254679322242737,
0.20020592212677002,
-0.16020262241363525,
-0.2991199791431427,
-0.49442267417907715,
0.24229824542999268,
-0.6124164462089539,
0.1303883045911789,
-0.07590097934007645,
-0.570212185382843,
-0.05597846582531929,
0.6298683881759644,
-1.0396205186843872,
0.33087727427482605,
-0.31657591462135315,
-0.28397926688194275,
0.3724502921104431,
-0.6404665112495422,
-0.021707143634557724,
-0.051193978637456894,
-0.3827524185180664,
-0.2554810643196106,
-0.16950315237045288,
0.19519339501857758,
0.5707302093505859,
-0.44993481040000916,
0.5443081855773926,
-0.33417144417762756,
0.07044661045074463,
0.40402987599372864,
-0.14675918221473694,
0.8709614276885986,
0.04877166077494621,
0.060211312025785446,
0.2792564332485199,
-0.4617796242237091,
-0.3409390151500702,
0.014287399128079414,
-0.4609326124191284,
0.19716553390026093,
0.2084319293498993,
0.12215615063905716,
0.5312442779541016,
0.35164913535118103,
-0.3800258934497833,
0.7402161359786987,
-0.4795943796634674,
0.5461300611495972,
0.7131069302558899,
0.12092232704162598,
0.5563251972198486,
-0.43836966156959534,
0.6619491577148438,
0.05724742263555527,
0.05195317789912224,
0.33200815320014954,
-0.7076680660247803,
-0.4505772292613983,
-0.04300428181886673,
0.4524550437927246,
0.45298972725868225,
-0.8943129181861877,
0.19383575022220612,
-0.17328476905822754,
-0.3630572557449341,
-0.11631153523921967,
-0.21294376254081726,
0.021466288715600967,
-0.28479573130607605,
-0.09866737574338913,
-0.1441548764705658,
-0.43712151050567627,
-0.708516538143158,
-0.09554313868284225,
-0.5380889177322388,
0.3703497350215912,
0.30944347381591797,
0.4776460528373718,
-0.06514084339141846,
1.114668846130371,
-0.03888474404811859,
-0.4335761070251465,
-0.507082462310791,
0.2963431477546692,
0.3735845386981964,
0.19783703982830048,
0.5545499920845032,
-0.9369193315505981,
-0.13907299935817719,
0.2260797768831253,
-0.16393232345581055,
0.1361764818429947,
-0.45449429750442505,
0.11146055161952972,
0.5278351902961731,
0.3560338020324707,
-0.8402304649353027,
0.21097791194915771,
0.9071706533432007,
-0.3045015335083008,
0.7888126969337463,
-0.16123484075069427,
0.20475971698760986,
-1.2321773767471313,
-0.15332619845867157,
-0.232246533036232,
-0.6179633140563965,
-0.5134338736534119,
0.25959745049476624,
-0.18878737092018127,
-0.35124021768569946,
-0.9967884421348572,
0.5235544443130493,
-0.5987595915794373,
-0.13650450110435486,
-0.13954603672027588,
0.21962574124336243,
-0.5386303663253784,
0.6372737288475037,
0.4867404103279114,
0.7243629097938538,
0.6133846044540405,
-0.6349534392356873,
0.3443790078163147,
0.39839401841163635,
-0.45093947649002075,
0.5641399025917053,
-0.29861998558044434,
0.09510569274425507,
-0.04476860165596008,
0.46099793910980225,
-0.7286813855171204,
-0.13794833421707153,
0.6071571707725525,
-0.1139441654086113,
0.18323160707950592,
-0.5422951579093933,
-0.6593532562255859,
-0.10033838450908661,
0.05623329058289528,
0.2344980537891388,
0.031968675553798676,
-0.3713737428188324,
0.9293569326400757,
0.7492250204086304,
-0.2949185371398926,
-0.5722118616104126,
-0.4648953676223755,
0.7369484901428223,
-0.09829384088516235,
-0.3934517502784729,
0.3963608145713806,
0.19671161472797394,
-0.3677489459514618,
-0.12073613703250885,
0.308524489402771,
-0.22780337929725647,
-0.31914767622947693,
0.221445694565773,
-0.022186078131198883,
0.08151011914014816,
-0.11895979940891266,
-0.22647373378276825,
-0.34103548526763916,
-0.001579410512931645,
-0.04812580719590187,
0.8876733183860779,
-0.1520678699016571,
-0.5761407017707825,
-0.4055035412311554,
0.38553544878959656,
0.9850778579711914,
-0.40929821133613586,
0.9768489003181458,
0.08559982478618622,
-0.5101824402809143,
-0.15478569269180298,
-0.17804338037967682,
-0.1039896234869957,
-0.40456730127334595,
0.12571276724338531,
-0.6586008071899414,
-0.5255612730979919,
0.8346867561340332,
-0.5641469955444336,
0.18918293714523315,
0.30850112438201904,
1.177678108215332,
0.29870620369911194,
0.8211444616317749,
0.45406678318977356,
-0.13490888476371765,
0.28583958745002747,
-0.31448832154273987,
0.0255216546356678,
-0.29584768414497375,
-0.42361849546432495,
-0.6294029951095581,
-0.13927419483661652,
-0.4268247187137604,
-0.9255202412605286,
0.2609037160873413,
-0.35907647013664246,
0.10434076935052872,
0.40268102288246155,
-0.20178066194057465,
0.3460986316204071,
0.324905663728714,
-0.00381896342150867,
0.26365870237350464,
-0.23966549336910248,
-0.05919662490487099,
-0.07994595915079117,
-0.8996368050575256,
-0.5863475203514099,
0.6338180899620056,
0.05538526549935341,
0.6529697775840759,
0.19814558327198029,
0.44464996457099915,
0.30026698112487793,
0.1005595326423645,
-0.6910048127174377,
0.8939976096153259,
0.0043339356780052185,
-0.39908653497695923,
-0.2344399392604828,
-0.7097358107566833,
-1.1841024160385132,
0.4473538398742676,
-0.5144329071044922,
-0.46872031688690186,
0.5406318306922913,
-0.4040168225765228,
0.03621154651045799,
0.8080381155014038,
0.01990337483584881,
0.7653130888938904,
-0.13512173295021057,
0.008160092867910862,
-0.7011144757270813,
-0.4964607059955597,
0.20697757601737976,
0.09937474876642227,
0.3181764483451843,
-0.23696269094944,
-0.2384517937898636,
0.7067490816116333,
-0.32281821966171265,
0.8829951286315918,
-0.07982427626848221,
-0.2961244583129883,
0.13711941242218018,
0.2563202679157257,
0.7349143624305725,
-0.1345769315958023,
-0.5140620470046997,
0.2907734811306,
0.03491099178791046,
-0.4115906059741974,
-0.3259824514389038,
0.5857231616973877,
-0.6110950112342834,
-0.3482353389263153,
-0.5363895297050476,
-0.7576583027839661,
0.06656104326248169,
-0.19087892770767212,
0.1291540265083313,
0.1865234524011612,
-0.6460193395614624,
0.0413053072988987,
-0.13741159439086914,
0.07716107368469238,
0.3892569839954376,
0.4884416460990906,
-0.26587405800819397,
-0.3421037495136261,
0.7847998738288879,
0.12306230515241623,
0.2300986796617508,
0.12538093328475952,
-0.0893886461853981,
-0.43722203373908997,
-0.7014296650886536,
-0.1767146736383438,
0.23238325119018555,
-0.6695238351821899,
-0.3606015145778656,
-0.291176438331604,
0.043638184666633606,
-0.046981073915958405,
-0.20917001366615295,
-0.34932297468185425,
-0.8003450036048889,
-0.2645457088947296,
0.014484502375125885,
0.0721561461687088,
0.9508383274078369,
-0.4549459218978882,
0.40158987045288086,
-0.27344417572021484,
0.3989652395248413,
0.1564207673072815,
0.15522508323192596,
-0.5325771570205688,
-0.012348086573183537,
-0.08598455041646957,
0.136122927069664,
-0.3115277886390686,
-1.288460373878479,
0.6020728349685669,
0.08593973517417908,
0.43185800313949585,
0.19135533273220062,
0.19914257526397705,
0.35701748728752136,
-0.5038191676139832,
1.0750454664230347,
0.12696753442287445,
-0.7797780632972717,
0.32983484864234924,
-0.5932633280754089,
-0.16462036967277527,
0.27408966422080994,
-0.06432190537452698,
-0.3613996207714081,
-0.7624967694282532,
-0.5305575728416443,
-0.9487246870994568,
0.55616295337677,
0.27751994132995605,
-0.03337250277400017,
0.018816594034433365,
0.21710801124572754,
0.09515348076820374,
0.28716298937797546,
-0.9499107003211975,
-0.06336676329374313,
0.4682212769985199,
0.12504789233207703,
-0.09972704946994781,
-0.12174683809280396,
-0.4506388306617737,
-0.037334710359573364,
0.7385579347610474,
-0.1461215764284134,
0.08848897367715836,
-0.21444906294345856,
-0.04288714751601219,
-0.10185455530881882,
0.5018952488899231,
0.36965706944465637,
0.8108586668968201,
-0.09219224750995636,
-0.20333051681518555,
0.0957227572798729,
0.2808524966239929,
0.2988593578338623,
0.16984833776950836,
0.3711094558238983,
0.09097909182310104,
0.1076984778046608,
0.3361123204231262,
0.21908479928970337,
-0.5445610284805298,
0.5052177309989929,
-0.3819662928581238,
-0.4417319595813751,
-0.43044835329055786,
-0.26335349678993225,
0.460610955953598,
0.44332438707351685,
0.19636693596839905,
0.0359187014400959,
-0.08563372492790222,
-0.6563196778297424,
0.408044695854187,
0.7859221696853638,
-0.09988219290971756,
0.017190441489219666,
0.6257477402687073,
0.35623499751091003,
-0.561164915561676,
0.4041821360588074,
-0.12520629167556763,
-0.6507781744003296,
0.7756974101066589,
0.18434737622737885,
0.29794442653656006,
-0.05842069908976555,
0.47008439898490906,
-0.11788827925920486,
0.40035203099250793,
0.2667224407196045,
0.3766987919807434,
-0.17092935740947723,
-0.5608222484588623,
-0.5640796422958374,
-0.3367161452770233,
-1.109480619430542,
-0.04724392667412758,
-0.7961090207099915,
0.40285903215408325,
-0.29048746824264526,
-0.45937567949295044,
-0.15718090534210205,
0.5330141186714172,
-0.8003031015396118,
-0.2510567605495453,
0.4534158408641815,
1.0540896654129028,
-0.8939661979675293,
0.6381526589393616,
0.42584964632987976,
0.053075987845659256,
-0.24502363801002502,
-0.13162650167942047,
-0.05167407914996147,
-0.5689113736152649,
0.14654718339443207,
-0.05872577801346779,
0.10430949926376343,
-0.1593281775712967,
-0.4362182021141052,
-0.43279123306274414,
0.6985986232757568,
1.179333209991455,
-0.7616419792175293,
-0.2881565988063812,
0.413560152053833,
0.2066950649023056,
-0.4175460636615753,
0.0014509839238598943,
0.5537198185920715,
0.8053383231163025,
-0.2365134209394455,
-0.7686275243759155,
-0.1590532511472702,
-0.0672902837395668,
-0.31226351857185364,
0.1738303154706955,
-0.7216095328330994,
1.122746229171753,
0.23055148124694824,
-0.18864262104034424,
0.36787793040275574,
0.6847879886627197,
0.2814544141292572,
0.11835987865924835,
0.5828394889831543,
0.4777332544326782,
0.6564886569976807,
-0.15086935460567474,
1.2112789154052734,
-0.5621106028556824,
0.6167781949043274,
0.7982247471809387,
-0.523032009601593,
0.8842540383338928,
0.5286210775375366,
-0.06557495892047882,
0.6722736358642578,
0.7203454971313477,
0.1995512992143631,
0.3915611207485199,
0.42062753438949585,
-0.34425458312034607,
-0.6423282623291016,
-0.033035557717084885,
-0.18617644906044006,
0.6131841540336609,
0.6398534178733826,
0.052997197955846786,
-0.5686066150665283,
-0.16627809405326843,
-0.24473580718040466,
0.4171043634414673,
-0.3672647178173065,
0.9371929168701172,
0.2840546667575836,
-0.4503450393676758,
0.4105026423931122,
0.15277935564517975,
0.4124593734741211,
-0.6057542562484741,
-0.1605001538991928,
0.2895372807979584,
-0.06341519951820374,
0.0679716169834137,
-1.0378954410552979,
0.2566923201084137,
-0.350990891456604,
-0.1474429816007614,
-0.4408361315727234,
0.2899666428565979,
-0.8209132552146912,
-0.6694809198379517,
0.6404798626899719,
0.6942610740661621,
0.33298957347869873,
-0.04424784332513809,
-1.1275595426559448,
0.19460511207580566,
-0.3839957118034363,
-0.3988844156265259,
0.252519428730011,
0.47047287225723267,
0.22936271131038666,
0.7896930575370789,
0.7512896656990051,
0.6510176658630371,
-0.3083234429359436,
0.05732452869415283,
0.9979618191719055,
-0.3721139430999756,
-0.7412500381469727,
-0.6429071426391602,
0.42241472005844116,
0.016900332644581795,
0.0949062779545784,
0.2295018434524536,
0.38736459612846375,
0.4637965261936188,
0.17217890918254852,
0.486257404088974,
0.29814907908439636,
0.1895003765821457,
-0.8754642009735107,
0.9362849593162537,
-0.3733939528465271,
0.15110287070274353,
0.08748291432857513,
-0.7190252542495728,
-0.18165408074855804,
0.575413167476654,
-0.2540439963340759,
-0.2789904773235321,
0.4145103991031647,
0.7938864827156067,
-0.3646266460418701,
-0.10765897482633591,
0.33257538080215454,
0.3654196262359619,
0.2828544080257416,
0.8805802464485168,
0.823238730430603,
0.06313879787921906,
0.6045078635215759,
-0.0622241385281086,
0.21418879926204681,
-0.04793722182512283,
-0.8674299120903015,
-0.9460300207138062,
-0.9505576491355896,
-0.07399658113718033,
-0.31718045473098755,
0.11009400337934494,
1.0584402084350586,
0.800788164138794,
-0.5632862448692322,
-0.6587749123573303,
-0.01705572009086609,
0.3526779115200043,
-0.12122076749801636,
-0.16839298605918884,
0.12362954765558243,
-0.22943125665187836,
-0.7936403155326843,
0.5833156108856201,
0.16273058950901031,
-0.09195435792207718,
-0.5405815839767456,
-0.1464339792728424,
-0.4601142406463623,
0.462955504655838,
0.30770355463027954,
0.24199527502059937,
-0.8556795120239258,
-0.004965659696608782,
-0.697201132774353,
0.05244371294975281,
0.24955765902996063,
1.2624088525772095,
-0.9928656816482544,
0.19836288690567017,
0.015430849976837635,
0.1984218955039978,
0.5601858496665955,
-0.0819573923945427,
0.9715720415115356,
-0.596529483795166,
0.5436976552009583,
0.4801158308982849,
0.47784024477005005,
0.45861634612083435,
-0.06184106320142746,
0.44935107231140137,
-0.19183361530303955,
-0.4328339695930481,
-0.8855519890785217,
0.407563179731369,
-1.0079692602157593,
-0.48218756914138794,
1.0487139225006104,
0.04355696588754654,
-0.11679324507713318,
-0.23966456949710846,
-0.29226136207580566,
0.054811879992485046,
-0.4916825294494629,
0.4810842275619507,
0.7602064609527588,
0.05907077342271805,
-0.07329656928777695,
-0.209193155169487,
0.2974817752838135,
0.2616523504257202,
-0.6741187572479248,
0.17372307181358337,
0.47268325090408325,
-0.21664907038211823,
-0.05159633234143257,
0.8408187031745911,
0.030673425644636154,
0.2793442904949188,
-0.16147156059741974,
-0.182106152176857,
0.2068091630935669,
-0.6133260726928711,
-0.5660616159439087,
0.5311524868011475,
-0.20261292159557343,
-0.022725043818354607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11711v1 | MORL-Prompt: An Empirical Analysis of Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning for Discrete Prompt Optimization | 2024-02-18T21:25:09 | 2024-02-18T21:25:09 | Yasaman Jafari, Dheeraj Mekala, Rose Yu, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CL | cs.CL | RL-based techniques can be used to search for prompts that when fed into a
target language model maximize a set of user-specified reward functions.
However, in many target applications, the natural reward functions are in
tension with one another -- for example, content preservation vs. style
matching in style transfer tasks. Current techniques focus on maximizing the
average of reward functions, which does not necessarily lead to prompts that
achieve balance across rewards -- an issue that has been well-studied in the
multi-objective and robust optimization literature. In this paper, we adapt
several techniques for multi-objective optimization to RL-based discrete prompt
optimization -- two that consider volume of the Pareto reward surface, and
another that chooses an update direction that benefits all rewards
simultaneously. We conduct an empirical analysis of these methods on two NLP
tasks: style transfer and machine translation, each using three competing
reward functions. Our experiments demonstrate that multi-objective methods that
directly optimize volume perform better and achieve a better balance of all
rewards than those that attempt to find monotonic update directions. | [
-0.5561875700950623,
-0.6550507545471191,
0.6475239992141724,
0.5266152024269104,
-0.07101043313741684,
-0.1534431129693985,
-0.26353374123573303,
0.06241700425744057,
-0.07983653247356415,
0.3228212893009186,
-1.1933902502059937,
-0.2889016568660736,
-0.48385998606681824,
0.424570769071579,
0.2087864875793457,
1.144997477531433,
-0.027328837662935257,
-0.27024444937705994,
-0.34190019965171814,
-0.1593245416879654,
-0.7880092859268188,
-0.45531806349754333,
-0.9410383105278015,
-0.2874200940132141,
0.9953001141548157,
0.5995009541511536,
0.1590808779001236,
0.5320874452590942,
0.44409531354904175,
0.20103365182876587,
0.17114540934562683,
0.46446511149406433,
-0.49390602111816406,
0.4223603308200836,
-0.2288934886455536,
-0.1558019071817398,
-0.025626424700021744,
-0.027109619230031967,
0.5385590195655823,
0.24328070878982544,
-0.3932105004787445,
-0.09334366023540497,
0.11478674411773682,
0.812766969203949,
-1.0975611209869385,
0.09648432582616806,
-0.3340926170349121,
0.25785523653030396,
0.16469240188598633,
-0.5167933702468872,
-0.541947066783905,
-0.6052296161651611,
0.08590850234031677,
-0.8058092594146729,
-0.4676087200641632,
0.08229829370975494,
0.5644755959510803,
0.6539557576179504,
-0.3685101270675659,
-0.6277376413345337,
-0.30816948413848877,
1.4689671993255615,
-0.447773814201355,
-0.025829993188381195,
0.2703735828399658,
0.13476938009262085,
0.09048892557621002,
-0.3485654592514038,
-0.042376719415187836,
-0.4172704517841339,
-0.1647537648677826,
0.3329673409461975,
-0.0571754053235054,
0.10657089203596115,
0.3057551085948944,
-0.1045885682106018,
-0.4569903612136841,
-0.07987400889396667,
-0.10654202103614807,
0.03609069809317589,
0.67926424741745,
0.12138526141643524,
0.4483758807182312,
-0.0270402692258358,
-0.6801530718803406,
-0.5595883131027222,
-0.46681809425354004,
0.6294244527816772,
0.17949572205543518,
0.43659356236457825,
-0.16372065246105194,
0.4328268766403198,
-0.08552289754152298,
0.8714942932128906,
0.06965067237615585,
-0.5793978571891785,
0.1181928813457489,
-0.6000458002090454,
0.30933210253715515,
0.1377400904893875,
0.6906193494796753,
0.5816959738731384,
0.33799079060554504,
0.10353288054466248,
-0.5022912621498108,
-0.14838239550590515,
0.45639750361442566,
-0.5626434087753296,
0.11224991828203201,
0.12810161709785461,
-0.5039217472076416,
-0.33074602484703064,
-0.08180149644613266,
-0.7741760611534119,
-0.19579894840717316,
-0.7022084593772888,
0.49472302198410034,
-0.4826395511627197,
0.1821235865354538,
0.22037124633789062,
-0.407699853181839,
0.09397953003644943,
0.2993547320365906,
-1.0523250102996826,
0.05870998650789261,
0.5350297689437866,
0.8185146450996399,
-0.32286179065704346,
-0.4303516745567322,
-0.9066906571388245,
-0.10430622845888138,
-0.3859544098377228,
0.7303406000137329,
-0.5132297873497009,
-0.3667237162590027,
0.09684233367443085,
-0.607535183429718,
-0.3218904435634613,
-0.3222779333591461,
0.81833416223526,
-0.09299357235431671,
0.2716144621372223,
-0.6464835405349731,
-0.07973545789718628,
-0.13560441136360168,
0.5146948099136353,
-0.416964054107666,
0.9414576292037964,
0.13780374825000763,
-0.288716197013855,
0.1809333860874176,
-0.8722001314163208,
-0.355918824672699,
-0.3039170205593109,
0.01610618270933628,
-0.23005147278308868,
0.28858041763305664,
0.4191964864730835,
0.2610020041465759,
-0.18081369996070862,
0.45501166582107544,
-0.03047133795917034,
-0.10160847008228302,
0.39543068408966064,
-0.5369427800178528,
0.5499324798583984,
0.2841138243675232,
-0.23859696090221405,
0.5377026200294495,
-0.3686336278915405,
0.005526072811335325,
-0.10779383778572083,
-0.3566322922706604,
-0.5022473335266113,
0.09394820779561996,
-0.19605650007724762,
0.2505945861339569,
0.3236459493637085,
-0.2773743271827698,
0.4845857322216034,
0.019577354192733765,
0.23157371580600739,
0.9428663849830627,
0.16351109743118286,
0.3153800070285797,
-0.6067374348640442,
0.6994646787643433,
-0.34632205963134766,
0.512253999710083,
-0.24476952850818634,
-0.29980728030204773,
-0.2649996876716614,
-0.36759093403816223,
0.13420411944389343,
0.6751663088798523,
-0.8741222023963928,
0.13998854160308838,
0.15625892579555511,
-0.09782308340072632,
-0.3930342197418213,
-0.19023872911930084,
0.5011715292930603,
0.592826247215271,
0.5478491187095642,
-0.146145299077034,
-0.1018243357539177,
-1.0203123092651367,
-0.3069727420806885,
0.0013740110443904996,
0.24260839819908142,
0.6970784068107605,
0.24726927280426025,
-0.009704296477138996,
0.8004010915756226,
-0.4549689292907715,
-0.0914049819111824,
-0.16514591872692108,
0.5770638585090637,
0.2850586175918579,
0.3907187283039093,
0.8324042558670044,
-0.7499297261238098,
-0.640011191368103,
0.031259700655937195,
-0.6852352023124695,
-0.6530584692955017,
-0.5827954411506653,
-0.06000475585460663,
-0.09164195507764816,
0.3663882911205292,
-0.31021520495414734,
-0.06666171550750732,
0.5513256788253784,
-0.08665534108877182,
0.8364970088005066,
-0.19730651378631592,
0.4599744379520416,
-0.49204057455062866,
-0.12650159001350403,
0.13438759744167328,
-0.0508878231048584,
-0.5339558124542236,
0.006995328236371279,
0.19111819565296173,
-0.10335291922092438,
-0.583532989025116,
0.8242048025131226,
-0.27716538310050964,
0.0440397635102272,
-0.2950575649738312,
0.10507812350988388,
0.07806539535522461,
0.8432313799858093,
-0.01281306054443121,
1.1326956748962402,
0.7278223037719727,
-0.8578229546546936,
0.35856837034225464,
0.045442912727594376,
0.11118561774492264,
1.1121431589126587,
-0.6893037557601929,
-0.07363668829202652,
-0.397798627614975,
-0.15826290845870972,
-0.7324899435043335,
0.15100419521331787,
0.627601683139801,
-0.2558057904243469,
0.183577299118042,
0.06791023164987564,
0.11155921220779419,
-0.0021048143971711397,
-0.8056361079216003,
0.4149199426174164,
0.2406303584575653,
-0.5602794885635376,
0.608693540096283,
-0.14588762819766998,
-0.42585301399230957,
-1.0096694231033325,
-0.2277001142501831,
-0.08008068799972534,
-0.545131266117096,
-0.287884384393692,
0.5758736729621887,
-0.46169784665107727,
-0.3396401107311249,
0.04231500253081322,
-0.1662851721048355,
0.2263878881931305,
0.1778268665075302,
-0.20524828135967255,
0.18600577116012573,
0.054130058735609055,
-0.0550275482237339,
0.22125902771949768,
-0.31882956624031067,
0.13650284707546234,
-0.4141930937767029,
0.4203183948993683,
-0.1399400681257248,
-0.3335821032524109,
-0.5366899371147156,
0.5017892718315125,
0.3632734417915344,
-0.21513980627059937,
0.5045895576477051,
0.5745420455932617,
0.021044349297881126,
-0.29490047693252563,
-0.36039480566978455,
-0.29435837268829346,
-0.484476238489151,
0.3190426826477051,
-0.5599923729896545,
-0.5258243680000305,
0.14326542615890503,
-0.04421988129615784,
0.33662480115890503,
0.21146683394908905,
0.37699371576309204,
0.16185013949871063,
1.191339373588562,
0.3361362814903259,
0.03947961702942848,
0.8247221112251282,
0.04640663042664528,
-0.026886656880378723,
-0.980994701385498,
-0.4493717551231384,
-0.7377540469169617,
-0.557365894317627,
-0.04144029691815376,
-0.09753280878067017,
0.6024589538574219,
0.1973867416381836,
-0.2173597514629364,
0.12883250415325165,
-0.6133764982223511,
0.3650798499584198,
1.1252580881118774,
-0.07476206868886948,
-0.0010985936969518661,
-0.05306253582239151,
-0.14573511481285095,
-0.04151385650038719,
-0.8402391672134399,
-0.08211884647607803,
0.7163404226303101,
-0.08958422392606735,
0.9312963485717773,
0.14424192905426025,
0.8021786212921143,
0.4938267767429352,
-0.04921872913837433,
-0.8953322172164917,
0.3153465986251831,
-0.14829573035240173,
0.09472328424453735,
-0.4681285619735718,
-0.5024787187576294,
-0.9766974449157715,
0.3939882814884186,
-0.25511839985847473,
-0.6439993381500244,
0.3656729757785797,
0.07880567759275436,
-0.43653833866119385,
-0.13086535036563873,
-0.5551168918609619,
1.0460448265075684,
-0.7703750729560852,
-0.3374679386615753,
-0.03977637365460396,
-0.5271188020706177,
0.28087571263313293,
0.02575322613120079,
0.29340073466300964,
-0.08069107681512833,
-0.19888602197170258,
0.5876022577285767,
-0.044506173580884933,
0.45086225867271423,
-0.10370928049087524,
-0.11685361713171005,
0.02802029252052307,
-0.13097240030765533,
0.515509843826294,
0.2612971067428589,
-0.001618355861864984,
-0.27809464931488037,
-0.04528830572962761,
-0.26481813192367554,
-0.9019813537597656,
0.533646821975708,
-0.8473303914070129,
-0.359977126121521,
-0.4802103638648987,
-0.8102417588233948,
-0.09366527199745178,
0.09459540992975235,
0.1715245246887207,
0.7146772146224976,
0.08624572306871414,
0.31703993678092957,
0.7322084307670593,
-0.4247141182422638,
0.7272750735282898,
0.08873961120843887,
0.06965648382902145,
-0.5181958079338074,
0.892764687538147,
-0.33169299364089966,
0.3161209225654602,
0.6255324482917786,
0.5865353941917419,
-0.5350792407989502,
-0.4833076000213623,
-0.48396560549736023,
0.08422040939331055,
-0.4587174355983734,
-0.17260611057281494,
-0.505664050579071,
0.21068941056728363,
-0.16800257563591003,
-0.5546605587005615,
-0.3170563578605652,
-0.13771231472492218,
-0.28655341267585754,
0.25179752707481384,
0.13483773171901703,
0.5055886507034302,
-0.39169055223464966,
0.3783062994480133,
-0.7849192023277283,
0.35446059703826904,
0.47518637776374817,
-0.16246746480464935,
-0.14239268004894257,
-0.1628233790397644,
0.020406750962138176,
0.09517107158899307,
-0.29489633440971375,
-0.9566085934638977,
0.5312925577163696,
0.07080961763858795,
0.7975496649742126,
0.3296153247356415,
0.30517277121543884,
0.477335125207901,
-0.3203165829181671,
0.6902610063552856,
0.43299993872642517,
-0.9132463335990906,
0.6195662021636963,
-0.3123939633369446,
0.18838177621364594,
0.603546142578125,
0.3325275182723999,
-0.9689450263977051,
0.15432798862457275,
-0.3048713207244873,
-0.7595471739768982,
0.9865272045135498,
-0.061614990234375,
0.01776065304875374,
-0.010584081523120403,
0.39487913250923157,
0.08799918740987778,
0.4494398236274719,
-0.8665903210639954,
-0.4443790316581726,
-0.14357012510299683,
-0.3754022717475891,
0.057702187448740005,
-0.24156823754310608,
-0.31865590810775757,
0.22640368342399597,
0.7089837193489075,
-0.22597689926624298,
0.23357005417346954,
0.21382831037044525,
0.003806022461503744,
0.13364733755588531,
0.40017029643058777,
1.2008700370788574,
0.5951123237609863,
-0.1473693996667862,
-0.0043500615283846855,
-0.040700387209653854,
-0.02987111546099186,
0.24256587028503418,
-0.12469349801540375,
-0.3668004870414734,
-0.1744028478860855,
0.3063337802886963,
1.2282270193099976,
0.1937987506389618,
-0.8696625232696533,
0.33244386315345764,
-0.0964781865477562,
-0.2985619008541107,
0.12473297119140625,
0.17518435418605804,
-0.4391835033893585,
0.2995936870574951,
0.3525468111038208,
0.1409188210964203,
0.22862137854099274,
-0.5531264543533325,
0.15427464246749878,
0.6868186593055725,
-0.41982099413871765,
0.10444772243499756,
0.3499104380607605,
0.001628402853384614,
-0.5885664820671082,
0.51291823387146,
-0.41822630167007446,
-0.46882128715515137,
0.5321869850158691,
0.5323963761329651,
0.7108755707740784,
-0.2240152359008789,
0.559149980545044,
0.40131357312202454,
0.28673255443573,
-0.3520470857620239,
0.03348449617624283,
-0.015809111297130585,
-0.6491763591766357,
-0.6102848052978516,
-0.31333640217781067,
-0.594819962978363,
-0.18228404223918915,
-0.7194994688034058,
0.21015898883342743,
-0.1736113578081131,
-0.06745518743991852,
-0.2765493094921112,
-0.14885219931602478,
-0.2950238883495331,
-0.12080816924571991,
-0.02112755924463272,
0.42473143339157104,
-0.7663041949272156,
0.15037821233272552,
0.6126840114593506,
-0.3713967800140381,
-0.675125777721405,
-0.26929184794425964,
0.2943214476108551,
-0.796276330947876,
0.5791604518890381,
-0.04597782343626022,
-0.2126716673374176,
0.09290575236082077,
-0.33257612586021423,
-0.95732581615448,
0.7864381074905396,
0.12379981577396393,
-0.31254222989082336,
0.05422453209757805,
-0.3740352690219879,
0.043227750808000565,
-0.4516400098800659,
0.28247278928756714,
0.2662524878978729,
0.8871822953224182,
0.07920709997415543,
-0.6243677139282227,
-0.17515929043293,
-0.0025498191826045513,
-0.022153927013278008,
0.31184449791908264,
-0.425933837890625,
1.1071363687515259,
-0.019419943913817406,
0.021450966596603394,
-0.02748233452439308,
0.2856966257095337,
0.7152072787284851,
0.2908926010131836,
0.46072056889533997,
0.40905946493148804,
0.7917631268501282,
-0.07522068917751312,
1.3182755708694458,
-0.20677676796913147,
0.4920232892036438,
0.6619822382926941,
-0.14763519167900085,
0.2917706370353699,
0.6354016065597534,
-0.06426006555557251,
0.43737176060676575,
0.7486465573310852,
0.07689400017261505,
1.105434536933899,
0.16655468940734863,
-0.19258160889148712,
0.03995441272854805,
-0.5423886775970459,
-0.2554100751876831,
-0.13876819610595703,
0.2231537252664566,
0.14256568253040314,
-0.38657721877098083,
0.4277680814266205,
-0.15151524543762207,
0.0724840760231018,
-0.39815282821655273,
0.8105694651603699,
0.004062567371875048,
-1.1236292123794556,
0.4228496551513672,
0.22922374308109283,
0.9791191816329956,
-0.7835977077484131,
-0.058325693011283875,
-0.25237035751342773,
-0.016336428001523018,
0.1431293785572052,
-0.5444014668464661,
0.09089772403240204,
-0.26442378759384155,
-0.03401459380984306,
-0.7638605237007141,
0.6680940389633179,
-0.4633939862251282,
-0.13887512683868408,
0.06433960795402527,
0.564388632774353,
-0.11699806153774261,
-0.20796221494674683,
-1.2290022373199463,
0.13184978067874908,
0.04530312120914459,
-0.2910585105419159,
0.30942749977111816,
0.48043596744537354,
0.0789671391248703,
0.79509437084198,
0.6767849326133728,
0.09666473418474197,
-0.05630718171596527,
-0.014777556993067265,
0.3880295157432556,
-0.5385382175445557,
-0.5721173286437988,
-1.082079529762268,
0.4976483881473541,
-0.07548612356185913,
-0.47802430391311646,
0.5695450305938721,
0.2743293046951294,
0.6154049038887024,
-0.2262495905160904,
0.7341763973236084,
0.007201159372925758,
-0.018770046532154083,
-1.0412229299545288,
-0.20330938696861267,
-0.8221337795257568,
0.08680466562509537,
-0.302767276763916,
-1.0884835720062256,
-0.1731835901737213,
1.001031517982483,
-0.12020736932754517,
0.13789913058280945,
1.1145386695861816,
0.6470088958740234,
0.1912231296300888,
-0.23636148869991302,
0.21350319683551788,
-0.562268078327179,
0.161336287856102,
0.8261785507202148,
1.0129992961883545,
0.13240832090377808,
0.290754109621048,
-0.39193081855773926,
-0.33238717913627625,
-0.33623433113098145,
-1.0304516553878784,
-0.6576844453811646,
-0.4784236550331116,
-0.37282395362854004,
-0.0032431751023977995,
0.3846442699432373,
1.2303318977355957,
0.758413553237915,
-0.5115475654602051,
-0.35847657918930054,
0.04877420514822006,
0.5405715107917786,
-0.9195855855941772,
-0.23965418338775635,
0.2806544601917267,
-0.9140886664390564,
-0.9696734547615051,
0.6122622489929199,
0.6110858917236328,
-0.2219422608613968,
0.002572373254224658,
-0.2953766882419586,
-0.17134766280651093,
0.10951359570026398,
0.7247598171234131,
0.28081461787223816,
-0.6928699016571045,
-0.3394811153411865,
0.2959275543689728,
-0.1426563709974289,
0.00789217371493578,
1.0379681587219238,
-0.4891085624694824,
0.12103539705276489,
0.5366824865341187,
0.8984992504119873,
0.24582473933696747,
0.5461813807487488,
0.5316991209983826,
-1.0056843757629395,
-0.08988336473703384,
0.18413950502872467,
0.2688698470592499,
0.028266144916415215,
-0.2523028254508972,
0.5050716400146484,
0.16112706065177917,
-0.5433401465415955,
-0.6549257040023804,
0.3821072578430176,
-1.088207721710205,
-0.7561491131782532,
1.1826547384262085,
0.09845102578401566,
-0.0809076577425003,
0.08062849193811417,
-0.5135986804962158,
-0.16131989657878876,
-0.6900516748428345,
0.5251549482345581,
0.8115407228469849,
-0.4777992069721222,
-0.4821576476097107,
-0.6160457134246826,
0.6517692804336548,
0.547084391117096,
-0.8719885349273682,
-0.1683444380760193,
0.6793413758277893,
-0.31026914715766907,
0.19140803813934326,
0.6849899888038635,
0.24252985417842865,
0.2490343600511551,
-0.3206730782985687,
-0.038534294813871384,
-0.20668068528175354,
-0.8135589361190796,
-0.3891304135322571,
0.29466456174850464,
0.07431835681200027,
-0.2417348176240921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11710v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11710v1 | A Note on Bias to Complete | 2024-02-18T21:20:33 | 2024-02-18T21:20:33 | Jia Xu, Mona Diab | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimizing social bias strengthens societal bonds, promoting shared
understanding and better decision-making. We revisit the definition of bias by
discovering new bias types (e.g., societal status) in dynamic environments and
describe them relative to context, such as culture, region, time, and personal
background. Our framework includes eight hypotheses about bias and a minimizing
bias strategy for each assumption as well as five methods as proposed solutions
in LLM. The realization of the framework is yet to be completed. | [
-0.5900106430053711,
-0.7721444964408875,
0.7690560817718506,
0.3389876186847687,
0.10860899835824966,
0.2559273838996887,
-0.1001359298825264,
-0.25706061720848083,
0.7590672373771667,
0.5137798190116882,
-0.7757259011268616,
-0.258181095123291,
-0.6341392993927002,
-0.013783537782728672,
0.13293617963790894,
1.0265438556671143,
-0.05721854045987129,
0.18298621475696564,
-0.2379472553730011,
-0.2919701337814331,
-0.16655613481998444,
-0.5150880813598633,
-0.4276699423789978,
-0.460848331451416,
0.47036826610565186,
0.6697012186050415,
0.4351031184196472,
0.6142012476921082,
0.3715992271900177,
0.17626550793647766,
-0.7008134722709656,
-0.11834247410297394,
-0.7598041296005249,
0.14604225754737854,
-0.09582237899303436,
-0.6186705827713013,
-0.27629512548446655,
0.3066222667694092,
0.6189283132553101,
1.2322582006454468,
0.22663772106170654,
0.5922794938087463,
0.2794094979763031,
0.8746994733810425,
-0.6329412460327148,
-0.004672475624829531,
-0.2990819215774536,
0.3152102530002594,
-0.10479651391506195,
-0.10710923373699188,
-0.07402226328849792,
-0.6481234431266785,
0.5027429461479187,
-0.28539228439331055,
0.6942930221557617,
0.010609021410346031,
0.4556834101676941,
0.24685987830162048,
-1.0920971632003784,
-0.14907585084438324,
-0.6141637563705444,
0.6141447424888611,
-0.10308990627527237,
-0.036794405430555344,
0.2609633207321167,
0.2569030523300171,
-0.017958305776119232,
-0.22056877613067627,
0.1381566971540451,
-0.05829484760761261,
0.031564146280288696,
0.06232776492834091,
0.818486213684082,
0.2922830581665039,
0.9351682066917419,
0.28030163049697876,
0.21541419625282288,
-0.42679858207702637,
-0.5206338763237,
-0.42161425948143005,
0.4617251455783844,
0.11197564005851746,
0.14901071786880493,
-0.14367839694023132,
-0.28937795758247375,
0.28274989128112793,
-1.04086172580719,
0.17725135385990143,
0.5317702889442444,
-0.07656136900186539,
-0.2035192996263504,
0.5147669315338135,
-0.32722195982933044,
0.12766671180725098,
0.3769518733024597,
-0.18398965895175934,
0.1066945269703865,
-0.5021137595176697,
0.07913238555192947,
0.318597674369812,
-0.13362102210521698,
0.7273687720298767,
0.07446175813674927,
0.08206529915332794,
0.007879397831857204,
0.480304092168808,
-0.04804540053009987,
-0.4622346758842468,
0.22818154096603394,
-0.07253805547952652,
-0.8287317156791687,
-0.7254558205604553,
-0.22659285366535187,
-0.8817866444587708,
-0.5175920128822327,
-0.26193371415138245,
-0.21020816266536713,
0.45056718587875366,
-0.13052469491958618,
-0.20806460082530975,
-0.4120563268661499,
0.07715018093585968,
0.5029990077018738,
-0.6588773131370544,
0.30151546001434326,
0.47434788942337036,
0.870366096496582,
-0.08539612591266632,
0.09851628541946411,
-0.09768042713403702,
0.49726492166519165,
-0.3763994872570038,
0.708091139793396,
-0.3890003561973572,
-0.6685402393341064,
0.15819448232650757,
0.034661274403333664,
0.39674341678619385,
-0.42797860503196716,
0.6327227354049683,
-0.10052313655614853,
-0.0016700304113328457,
-1.1474307775497437,
-0.48490801453590393,
-0.03145875781774521,
0.3101902902126312,
-0.8785582780838013,
0.7551161646842957,
0.0015547721413895488,
-0.9383357763290405,
0.9376811385154724,
-0.6545045375823975,
-0.5661153197288513,
-0.41740095615386963,
-0.01319333165884018,
-0.055684011429548264,
0.26685214042663574,
-0.07175908982753754,
-0.024880869314074516,
-0.15083761513233185,
0.27886080741882324,
-0.900708794593811,
-0.39281246066093445,
-0.02402392216026783,
-0.11528760939836502,
0.890129029750824,
0.35063445568084717,
-0.6052617430686951,
0.014612664468586445,
-0.43489012122154236,
-0.5103283524513245,
-0.19719603657722473,
-0.4639839828014374,
-0.33965012431144714,
0.07581701874732971,
0.023804428055882454,
0.1674630492925644,
0.40642020106315613,
-0.5157785415649414,
0.2928016185760498,
-0.035588253289461136,
0.5348678231239319,
1.1463698148727417,
0.10315951704978943,
1.0674355030059814,
-0.4088181257247925,
0.34431377053260803,
-0.001008286140859127,
0.20537297427654266,
0.020715001970529556,
-0.15201441943645477,
-1.1004921197891235,
0.05538381636142731,
0.1893288791179657,
0.4738529622554779,
-0.48433732986450195,
-0.022272424772381783,
0.002711969194933772,
0.11219489574432373,
-0.150473490357399,
0.05714026466012001,
0.30862390995025635,
0.346253901720047,
-0.07725288718938828,
-0.3401246964931488,
-0.8816542029380798,
-0.9028474688529968,
-0.5224117040634155,
0.03809676691889763,
0.3154299259185791,
0.21976928412914276,
0.5561771392822266,
-0.4246409833431244,
0.906712532043457,
-0.4593043327331543,
-0.38523709774017334,
-0.31598204374313354,
-0.18162120878696442,
0.04644358158111572,
0.3275286853313446,
0.5198895931243896,
-0.6025049090385437,
-0.40071016550064087,
-0.37422245740890503,
-0.8469921350479126,
-0.2207065224647522,
0.15082797408103943,
-0.37056106328964233,
0.08251281082630157,
0.5582945346832275,
-0.4277591109275818,
0.7671168446540833,
-0.1623525470495224,
-0.3497919738292694,
0.231999009847641,
0.18317811191082,
0.07555267959833145,
-0.7288926243782043,
-0.44118696451187134,
0.47855323553085327,
-0.270513117313385,
-0.5264726281166077,
-0.14046445488929749,
-0.3604491949081421,
0.10243374854326248,
-0.31659162044525146,
0.6125431060791016,
-0.6858817934989929,
-0.1382506638765335,
-0.15319325029850006,
0.18898391723632812,
-0.3286845088005066,
0.1998666226863861,
-0.0660179853439331,
0.3395738899707794,
0.3974289894104004,
-0.5995563268661499,
0.14450328052043915,
0.03444484993815422,
-0.2736886143684387,
0.8022482395172119,
-0.5018666386604309,
-0.09503576904535294,
-0.5618909597396851,
0.5876292586326599,
-0.8306457996368408,
-0.3363507390022278,
0.14993584156036377,
-0.2667800486087799,
-0.04035980626940727,
-0.43415120244026184,
-0.12504857778549194,
-0.34051623940467834,
-0.6471413373947144,
0.46949276328086853,
0.4063367545604706,
-0.24546803534030914,
0.28967753052711487,
0.84828782081604,
0.07834643125534058,
-0.6743558049201965,
-0.6475101113319397,
-0.1116987094283104,
-0.6022630929946899,
-0.6963489055633545,
0.344152569770813,
-0.08703409135341644,
-0.7499258518218994,
-0.23934520781040192,
-0.5699149370193481,
0.2614712417125702,
0.021519718691706657,
-0.050827693194150925,
0.026013784110546112,
0.2555074691772461,
-0.3452349603176117,
0.1497935652732849,
-0.25621724128723145,
0.23314371705055237,
0.14034302532672882,
0.24428953230381012,
0.14992058277130127,
-0.10445038974285126,
0.1394260674715042,
0.5626598596572876,
0.43816372752189636,
0.438030481338501,
0.15152746438980103,
0.3262409567832947,
-0.603646457195282,
0.03992515802383423,
-0.8167405724525452,
-0.4219980537891388,
-0.4583275616168976,
0.09640537202358246,
-0.15297022461891174,
-1.1700658798217773,
0.8990799784660339,
-0.13303762674331665,
-0.04684508219361305,
0.06624063104391098,
0.48894235491752625,
0.06463631242513657,
1.1018829345703125,
0.8755427002906799,
-0.35156697034835815,
0.5864406824111938,
-0.23049966990947723,
0.2621874511241913,
-0.9936713576316833,
-0.08662423491477966,
-0.2933124005794525,
-0.34571874141693115,
-0.8990033268928528,
-0.09153541177511215,
0.409216046333313,
-0.09829188138246536,
-0.2592577040195465,
-0.18535731732845306,
-0.37522128224372864,
0.4461071789264679,
0.6300442218780518,
0.4268206059932709,
0.02966189570724964,
0.09193646162748337,
-0.2688896059989929,
-0.073966383934021,
-0.6641848087310791,
-0.5958103537559509,
1.1131759881973267,
0.4270908236503601,
0.8586257696151733,
0.2210453748703003,
1.0386613607406616,
0.6411467790603638,
0.5940338373184204,
-0.3902784585952759,
0.5826756358146667,
0.4989515244960785,
-1.0350244045257568,
-0.20749996602535248,
-0.2576422393321991,
-0.6254564523696899,
0.2589026987552643,
-0.3038924038410187,
-0.7779541611671448,
0.30819693207740784,
0.3102693557739258,
-0.22493578493595123,
0.037156250327825546,
-0.5798683762550354,
0.5577698349952698,
0.1053043007850647,
-0.8983452320098877,
-0.2669747471809387,
-0.7212318778038025,
0.4883849620819092,
0.3899255394935608,
0.4548034071922302,
-0.2960188388824463,
-0.004030723124742508,
0.85293048620224,
-0.34185105562210083,
1.0189288854599,
-0.5759072303771973,
0.12625311315059662,
0.40752318501472473,
-0.16937360167503357,
0.37176260352134705,
0.3090333640575409,
0.20854651927947998,
-0.3478457033634186,
0.1836375743150711,
-0.627103328704834,
-0.2525876462459564,
0.6431035995483398,
-0.676723301410675,
-0.764875054359436,
-0.7155659794807434,
-0.3700512945652008,
-0.08724478632211685,
0.10172457247972488,
0.16316619515419006,
0.10615304857492447,
-0.5518964529037476,
0.12784571945667267,
1.1194615364074707,
-0.033447086811065674,
0.3934522867202759,
0.16058747470378876,
-0.14431484043598175,
-0.29439276456832886,
0.25158393383026123,
0.5156961679458618,
0.11887093633413315,
-0.028267642483115196,
0.07655499130487442,
-0.29775404930114746,
-0.041042760014534,
0.17646770179271698,
0.25376778841018677,
-0.9413835406303406,
0.23770509660243988,
-0.6396385431289673,
0.19966255128383636,
-0.7379504442214966,
-0.40047183632850647,
0.005449645221233368,
-0.1827833652496338,
-0.04166140407323837,
-0.5950688123703003,
-0.08245917409658432,
0.9456389546394348,
-0.4495903551578522,
0.3566013276576996,
-0.31247007846832275,
0.3767138421535492,
0.29456421732902527,
0.16190655529499054,
0.07367594540119171,
-0.05885718762874603,
-0.2947860658168793,
0.10861123353242874,
-0.40405941009521484,
-0.9922047257423401,
0.07776195555925369,
-0.19639600813388824,
0.800271213054657,
0.4207741916179657,
0.0915340781211853,
0.4263876676559448,
-0.2561211585998535,
0.8042514324188232,
0.15791139006614685,
-0.9351197481155396,
0.7713030576705933,
-0.49724826216697693,
0.02143363282084465,
0.6078348755836487,
0.31821906566619873,
-0.3928834795951843,
0.016934871673583984,
-0.8457554578781128,
-1.0337245464324951,
0.3564179241657257,
-0.1546957641839981,
-0.045192476361989975,
-0.2548659145832062,
0.5253390669822693,
-0.26432502269744873,
0.4670430123806,
-0.9364786148071289,
-0.6792522072792053,
0.32904767990112305,
0.06709668785333633,
-0.02239828184247017,
-0.8674139380455017,
-0.542224109172821,
-0.3932212293148041,
0.4360058903694153,
-0.009610271081328392,
0.2944364547729492,
0.4380209743976593,
-0.3419605791568756,
-0.19458909332752228,
0.16717731952667236,
0.767500102519989,
0.7995840907096863,
-0.2941862642765045,
0.14403745532035828,
0.48469775915145874,
-0.5194271802902222,
0.4936843812465668,
-0.44989272952079773,
-0.6421941518783569,
-0.06361764669418335,
0.19935491681098938,
0.4556441307067871,
0.029193144291639328,
0.032339323312044144,
0.23332376778125763,
0.1517840325832367,
-0.21259023249149323,
-0.7335840463638306,
-0.12421751767396927,
-0.12231805920600891,
0.23447775840759277,
0.3893464207649231,
0.20709840953350067,
0.3576674461364746,
-0.8433114290237427,
0.20484963059425354,
0.5058137774467468,
-0.6354528069496155,
-0.05807296186685562,
0.6699269413948059,
0.4857151210308075,
-0.07112935930490494,
-0.00034457704168744385,
-0.08203323185443878,
-0.6494415998458862,
0.8766864538192749,
0.27029410004615784,
0.5989293456077576,
0.06240576133131981,
0.14714452624320984,
0.23071062564849854,
0.4857046902179718,
-0.547370970249176,
0.3404124975204468,
-0.17225435376167297,
-0.8673593997955322,
-0.4405583143234253,
-0.22203564643859863,
-0.2785119414329529,
-0.389324814081192,
-0.8743686676025391,
0.3492469787597656,
-0.5890607237815857,
-0.6178406476974487,
-0.2767571806907654,
0.18150000274181366,
-0.651913046836853,
0.262090265750885,
-0.21125206351280212,
0.9943525195121765,
-1.1511955261230469,
0.605109453201294,
0.638069212436676,
-0.2735227942466736,
-0.41062653064727783,
-0.06695909053087234,
0.5621247887611389,
-0.5713937878608704,
0.6655088067054749,
0.31032052636146545,
-0.21838055551052094,
-0.5869558453559875,
-0.795832097530365,
-1.128231167793274,
0.9055992960929871,
0.19249385595321655,
-0.13388784229755402,
-0.04209493100643158,
-0.14066675305366516,
0.325314462184906,
-0.565751850605011,
0.2940216362476349,
0.7145493626594543,
0.7630961537361145,
-0.15442030131816864,
-0.524474024772644,
0.06810984760522842,
-0.26200512051582336,
0.19642364978790283,
-0.19994938373565674,
-0.7912241220474243,
0.5461404919624329,
-0.34797489643096924,
0.11242937296628952,
-0.2736557126045227,
0.652033805847168,
0.21439915895462036,
0.688395619392395,
0.4981212913990021,
0.4897138476371765,
0.5954714417457581,
-0.36176222562789917,
0.7074534296989441,
-0.4373948276042938,
0.5415825843811035,
0.6377293467521667,
-0.469546377658844,
-0.18435733020305634,
0.6757290959358215,
-0.2359074205160141,
0.1790340393781662,
1.2235859632492065,
0.3900989890098572,
0.7942215800285339,
0.4878315031528473,
-0.3635500371456146,
-0.0646880716085434,
-0.41486942768096924,
-0.5798010230064392,
0.036804065108299255,
0.4172630310058594,
-0.3882426619529724,
0.05329699441790581,
-0.13310866057872772,
0.2310914546251297,
-0.07207243889570236,
-0.5595256090164185,
0.6348300576210022,
0.209384486079216,
-0.7757636308670044,
0.0005737463943660259,
-0.14626668393611908,
1.1417510509490967,
-0.16523048281669617,
-0.015048026107251644,
-0.4867457151412964,
0.1191268190741539,
-0.41822630167007446,
-0.4314444363117218,
0.42115986347198486,
-0.3879159390926361,
-0.5776305198669434,
-0.3222542405128479,
0.868971586227417,
-0.360808789730072,
-0.2623738944530487,
0.23136389255523682,
0.4020318388938904,
-0.24278108775615692,
0.37855300307273865,
-0.3905380964279175,
0.09725703299045563,
0.30900877714157104,
-0.2585868835449219,
0.4128454327583313,
0.4683419466018677,
-0.027564363554120064,
0.8392431735992432,
0.3245373070240021,
0.15803654491901398,
0.16143463551998138,
-0.09509627521038055,
0.5943263173103333,
-0.8671552538871765,
-0.5461904406547546,
-0.8042612671852112,
0.30542871356010437,
-0.6152201890945435,
-0.01984689198434353,
0.9809418320655823,
0.44008687138557434,
0.8766990900039673,
-0.0330594927072525,
1.2603434324264526,
-0.047661032527685165,
0.5854967832565308,
-0.2892434597015381,
0.37637972831726074,
-0.3348114788532257,
0.31403619050979614,
-0.6785550117492676,
-1.0501736402511597,
0.019185008481144905,
1.0003352165222168,
-0.4293346107006073,
0.24859930574893951,
0.706087589263916,
0.6214315295219421,
0.27952101826667786,
-0.17201918363571167,
-0.204504132270813,
-0.11983609944581985,
0.10774871706962585,
0.27282285690307617,
0.6943103075027466,
0.019836584106087685,
0.10713005065917969,
-0.30474743247032166,
-0.5804824829101562,
-0.24275146424770355,
-0.908940315246582,
-0.9952151775360107,
-0.15299761295318604,
-0.2895950973033905,
-0.8370035290718079,
0.20184887945652008,
0.9990829229354858,
0.6674156785011292,
-0.32702362537384033,
-0.5385586023330688,
0.25641942024230957,
0.8347334265708923,
-0.08333044499158859,
-0.23321200907230377,
-0.12062966078519821,
-0.24495919048786163,
-0.42658764123916626,
-0.2643376588821411,
0.22396741807460785,
-0.13698191940784454,
-0.37693071365356445,
-0.04021138325333595,
-0.18571150302886963,
0.18794921040534973,
0.7165288925170898,
0.0998578891158104,
-0.47905176877975464,
-0.6997932195663452,
0.011049267835915089,
-0.023132527247071266,
0.06259171664714813,
1.067441701889038,
-0.3173750042915344,
0.1450299769639969,
0.6780117750167847,
0.15957185626029968,
0.7179007530212402,
-0.2692680060863495,
0.6007623672485352,
-0.46067702770233154,
0.36186090111732483,
-0.1860189139842987,
0.6587396264076233,
0.19592784345149994,
-0.4366567134857178,
0.764136791229248,
0.5924888253211975,
-0.6082013249397278,
-0.7589502930641174,
0.8272724151611328,
-0.828003466129303,
-0.041956350207328796,
1.2136321067810059,
0.1183081716299057,
-0.3378278613090515,
-0.37107959389686584,
-0.39201295375823975,
0.374054878950119,
-0.46225690841674805,
0.9922914505004883,
0.8586899042129517,
-0.20215560495853424,
-0.1904091238975525,
-0.44615495204925537,
0.7271608710289001,
0.28302502632141113,
-0.4525967538356781,
-0.32844457030296326,
0.692710816860199,
0.665939450263977,
0.14048048853874207,
0.9749524593353271,
0.125977024435997,
0.03864322975277901,
-0.07890817523002625,
-0.12427016347646713,
0.5137497186660767,
-0.19363971054553986,
0.10580525547266006,
0.19266530871391296,
0.08621330559253693,
0.31838881969451904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11709v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11709v2 | GNNavi: Navigating the Information Flow in Large Language Models by Graph Neural Network | 2024-02-18T21:13:05 | 2024-06-07T14:36:33 | Shuzhou Yuan, Ercong Nie, Michael Färber, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong In-Context Learning (ICL)
capabilities when prompts with demonstrations are used. However, fine-tuning
still remains crucial to further enhance their adaptability. Prompt-based
fine-tuning proves to be an effective fine-tuning method in low-data scenarios,
but high demands on computing resources limit its practicality. We address this
issue by introducing a prompt-based parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
approach. GNNavi leverages insights into ICL's information flow dynamics, which
indicates that label words act in prompts as anchors for information
propagation. GNNavi employs a Graph Neural Network (GNN) layer to precisely
guide the aggregation and distribution of information flow during the
processing of prompts by hardwiring the desired information flow into the GNN.
Our experiments on text classification tasks with GPT-2 and Llama2 show GNNavi
surpasses standard prompt-based fine-tuning methods in few-shot settings by
updating just 0.2% to 0.5% of parameters. We compare GNNavi with prevalent PEFT
approaches, such as prefix tuning, LoRA and Adapter in terms of performance and
efficiency. Our analysis reveals that GNNavi enhances information flow and
ensures a clear aggregation process. | [
-0.33405405282974243,
-1.0919418334960938,
0.5342963337898254,
0.034111544489860535,
-0.6148747205734253,
-0.016064707189798355,
-0.3965083956718445,
-0.18351449072360992,
-0.24212102591991425,
0.290872186422348,
-0.30590349435806274,
-0.5603199005126953,
-0.6084719300270081,
-0.11396056413650513,
-0.14975886046886444,
1.0311537981033325,
-0.014090712182223797,
-0.11358518153429031,
0.09480107575654984,
-0.08322218805551529,
-0.3790581226348877,
-0.20531457662582397,
-1.0602697134017944,
-0.23124448955059052,
0.8924848437309265,
0.5712471008300781,
0.5821342468261719,
0.6709105372428894,
0.13604262471199036,
0.2302146553993225,
-0.4308520555496216,
0.47855427861213684,
-0.5646184682846069,
0.4540083408355713,
-0.2691825330257416,
-0.34001293778419495,
-0.11735754460096359,
-0.2889547646045685,
0.8854830265045166,
0.7065611481666565,
0.04183793067932129,
0.1302231252193451,
0.4462135434150696,
0.6718268394470215,
-0.5402228236198425,
0.2586611211299896,
-0.5368956923484802,
-0.3766167163848877,
-0.2238013744354248,
-0.4696867763996124,
-0.506561815738678,
-0.2785662114620209,
-0.07375539839267731,
-0.5785268545150757,
-0.05058615654706955,
0.29469797015190125,
0.6979005336761475,
0.3512425124645233,
-0.535711944103241,
-0.407597154378891,
-0.4638673961162567,
0.5870825052261353,
-0.44663146138191223,
0.341246634721756,
0.26196327805519104,
0.19317038357257843,
-0.4747263193130493,
-0.6825343370437622,
-0.396820068359375,
-0.2431892454624176,
0.0740429237484932,
-0.19334609806537628,
-0.24734395742416382,
0.3458174467086792,
0.3153354227542877,
-0.08269377797842026,
-0.6053121089935303,
0.3789357841014862,
-0.39747604727745056,
-0.1314888596534729,
0.25120189785957336,
0.13498786091804504,
0.24015915393829346,
0.049939822405576706,
-0.15264806151390076,
-0.12489990890026093,
-0.7377813458442688,
0.3120044767856598,
0.3941616117954254,
0.6402752995491028,
-0.11683760583400726,
0.17112037539482117,
-0.37603092193603516,
1.1912543773651123,
0.2342683970928192,
-0.05868217721581459,
0.06249862164258957,
-0.21723075211048126,
-0.2918652892112732,
0.41940268874168396,
0.6869692206382751,
0.2451634258031845,
0.22211268544197083,
-0.1383599191904068,
0.22209441661834717,
-0.12517234683036804,
-0.07667700946331024,
-0.9012109637260437,
-0.27368971705436707,
-0.17168912291526794,
-0.26996657252311707,
-0.3292379081249237,
-0.29715707898139954,
-0.6893567442893982,
-0.6155901551246643,
-0.46932047605514526,
0.3217748999595642,
-0.2656693458557129,
-0.0177211482077837,
0.032296132296323776,
0.12918677926063538,
0.18289777636528015,
0.8112308979034424,
-0.9004474878311157,
0.127377450466156,
0.7283816933631897,
1.1183497905731201,
-0.11925822496414185,
-0.02476278878748417,
-1.1615056991577148,
0.10104234516620636,
-0.3260008692741394,
0.6729733943939209,
-0.6491924524307251,
-0.2271563857793808,
-0.2889605760574341,
-0.050184719264507294,
-0.22735697031021118,
-0.26273760199546814,
0.507692277431488,
-0.513425350189209,
-0.14623424410820007,
-0.36274048686027527,
-0.37287312746047974,
-0.3401065766811371,
0.3826066851615906,
-0.48113536834716797,
0.6729490756988525,
-0.05232750251889229,
-0.662039041519165,
0.240247443318367,
-0.573983371257782,
-0.40927067399024963,
0.0670347511768341,
-0.17665480077266693,
-0.07034622877836227,
0.14680540561676025,
0.23183462023735046,
0.5179784893989563,
-0.37081238627433777,
0.2880844175815582,
-0.08583736419677734,
-0.508695125579834,
-0.08431209623813629,
-0.6657018661499023,
0.6137139201164246,
0.267645925283432,
-0.1523733139038086,
0.24876850843429565,
-0.6429035663604736,
-0.004044080153107643,
-0.4690130949020386,
-0.6586605906486511,
-0.35753628611564636,
-0.18299239873886108,
-0.06446819752454758,
0.15272849798202515,
-0.1241878867149353,
-0.3392089605331421,
0.5996260046958923,
-0.5322603583335876,
0.5582613348960876,
0.767941951751709,
0.20013724267482758,
0.5914300680160522,
-0.1715267300605774,
0.5708487033843994,
0.15147516131401062,
0.11075187474489212,
-0.22388777136802673,
-0.7759068608283997,
-0.6630966663360596,
-0.04126724600791931,
0.5067420601844788,
0.5415783524513245,
-0.9127412438392639,
-0.0860643982887268,
-0.11649848520755768,
-0.48503342270851135,
-0.4319987893104553,
0.5367563366889954,
0.2604443430900574,
1.0833086967468262,
0.23910225927829742,
0.26445069909095764,
-0.1967685967683792,
-0.8044610023498535,
-0.2941868305206299,
-0.2949149012565613,
0.2949281930923462,
0.43312039971351624,
0.10852637141942978,
-0.16636186838150024,
0.5331451296806335,
-0.17662322521209717,
-0.10385902971029282,
-0.23383350670337677,
0.3761393129825592,
0.661441445350647,
0.45399603247642517,
0.4015679657459259,
-0.9449047446250916,
-0.5758816599845886,
0.21544405817985535,
-0.3849888741970062,
-0.2090080827474594,
-0.09742066264152527,
-0.1954171359539032,
0.25464537739753723,
0.8190467357635498,
-0.3722667098045349,
0.30053505301475525,
0.37778517603874207,
-0.4756307005882263,
0.313420832157135,
-0.42673489451408386,
0.07945109158754349,
-0.9065899848937988,
0.07117383182048798,
0.09588886052370071,
-0.367253839969635,
-0.6507197618484497,
0.0006954394048079848,
0.18362300097942352,
0.09228939563035965,
-0.42946141958236694,
0.7504506707191467,
-0.47942444682121277,
0.3393339514732361,
-0.3152950406074524,
0.02680431306362152,
0.029136965051293373,
0.4845171868801117,
-0.430573970079422,
0.8904546499252319,
0.6164496541023254,
-0.9547479152679443,
0.3044440448284149,
0.05066276714205742,
-0.5114070773124695,
0.473453551530838,
-0.4886617064476013,
0.2635799050331116,
-0.3654501140117645,
0.22771234810352325,
-1.17243492603302,
-0.1110977977514267,
0.522386908531189,
-0.2731623649597168,
0.537541925907135,
-0.4478188753128052,
-0.5504677295684814,
0.13351844251155853,
-0.04318036884069443,
0.41306233406066895,
0.4272972643375397,
-0.6203463077545166,
0.7526918053627014,
0.04438997432589531,
-0.3168720304965973,
-0.42359015345573425,
-0.5765684843063354,
0.25067687034606934,
-0.3404220640659332,
-0.4933987855911255,
0.094350665807724,
-0.12914785742759705,
-0.17383599281311035,
-0.3765788972377777,
0.07026538252830505,
0.09063304215669632,
0.3862302005290985,
0.31622570753097534,
0.037701208144426346,
-0.1754494309425354,
0.5388258695602417,
0.4346700608730316,
-0.19111475348472595,
-0.1731395721435547,
-0.5444884300231934,
0.5684446096420288,
-0.22167181968688965,
-0.04563121125102043,
-0.39968249201774597,
0.21706649661064148,
0.46006539463996887,
0.012520450167357922,
0.6256181597709656,
0.6457312703132629,
-0.12662918865680695,
-0.2529563903808594,
-0.2972082197666168,
0.038213565945625305,
-0.5026942491531372,
0.3382347524166107,
-0.3613327145576477,
-0.9951546788215637,
0.3612403869628906,
-0.3312302231788635,
-0.2011341154575348,
0.27440309524536133,
0.45765092968940735,
-0.12136121839284897,
1.0983211994171143,
0.6429397463798523,
-0.22519400715827942,
0.5002065300941467,
-0.23158885538578033,
0.16214562952518463,
-0.9789138436317444,
-0.13217094540596008,
-0.6694048047065735,
-0.6919413805007935,
-0.5197593569755554,
-0.2923418879508972,
0.5703849792480469,
0.5801969766616821,
-0.379742830991745,
-0.07412309944629669,
-0.5107380747795105,
0.4944644868373871,
0.5907902121543884,
0.19276966154575348,
0.3499014377593994,
0.042409349232912064,
-0.31615933775901794,
0.3570256233215332,
-0.9316974878311157,
-0.3283691108226776,
0.7801223397254944,
0.2449846714735031,
0.9350168108940125,
0.07454921305179596,
0.42184004187583923,
0.2163836658000946,
0.12088680267333984,
-0.7704032063484192,
0.5543511509895325,
-0.14901301264762878,
-0.13844184577465057,
-0.35432013869285583,
-0.47071099281311035,
-0.7691365480422974,
0.04733046889305115,
-0.028672294691205025,
-1.0413498878479004,
0.3802541494369507,
0.446694940328598,
-0.47709929943084717,
0.2888984680175781,
-0.7678661346435547,
0.6591230034828186,
-0.23086023330688477,
-0.536575973033905,
-0.13123393058776855,
-0.5870146155357361,
-0.0027938156854361296,
-0.021279897540807724,
0.07614967972040176,
-0.00163203792180866,
-0.1786995530128479,
0.6357201933860779,
-0.21849974989891052,
0.7966766953468323,
-0.42189887166023254,
-0.20194053649902344,
0.17842088639736176,
0.17054440081119537,
0.7335365414619446,
0.2291525900363922,
-0.2261778712272644,
-0.0008600251749157906,
-0.30634739995002747,
-0.08757547289133072,
-0.8160065412521362,
1.0341681241989136,
-0.5249335765838623,
-0.43490999937057495,
-0.1772724837064743,
-0.5047206878662109,
-0.2887900769710541,
0.17152029275894165,
0.5093709230422974,
0.7116198539733887,
0.2441691905260086,
0.3464130461215973,
0.848294734954834,
-0.19158218801021576,
0.4875485599040985,
0.26884010434150696,
-0.10726045817136765,
-0.27083298563957214,
0.8749125599861145,
0.3080231845378876,
0.167236328125,
0.4358246922492981,
0.31654074788093567,
-0.3861273229122162,
-0.6818103194236755,
-0.685982346534729,
0.05884823575615883,
-0.7182143330574036,
-0.3367140591144562,
-0.5328720211982727,
0.009693914093077183,
-0.16785883903503418,
-0.1827392280101776,
0.09285008162260056,
-0.2754582166671753,
-0.5840978622436523,
0.045958347618579865,
0.6242331266403198,
0.506257951259613,
0.171415314078331,
0.618832528591156,
-0.47404152154922485,
0.08472683280706406,
0.25384974479675293,
0.4301847815513611,
0.03265416994690895,
-0.569194495677948,
-0.23941417038440704,
0.054098982363939285,
-0.13189204037189484,
-0.716737687587738,
0.05855824798345566,
0.5248266458511353,
0.3473172187805176,
0.4295901954174042,
-0.03935505077242851,
0.6841146945953369,
-0.3009456396102905,
0.6385901570320129,
0.11031532287597656,
-0.9264772534370422,
0.6293311715126038,
-0.5941282510757446,
0.5410235524177551,
0.7330949306488037,
0.214546799659729,
-0.5792522430419922,
-0.007144262082874775,
-0.298863023519516,
-0.9293410778045654,
0.5682570338249207,
-0.1582641303539276,
0.01594197377562523,
0.13758201897144318,
0.5978649258613586,
-0.03388025984168053,
0.2998555898666382,
-0.057648248970508575,
-0.07024714350700378,
0.14510051906108856,
-0.29291242361068726,
-0.44988006353378296,
-0.14062228798866272,
0.22020500898361206,
-0.5441443920135498,
0.6533447504043579,
-0.5959966778755188,
0.07405773550271988,
0.18012407422065735,
-0.2638092637062073,
-0.003960662987083197,
0.33759596943855286,
0.7415123581886292,
0.5863818526268005,
0.03582623973488808,
0.17840273678302765,
0.22402475774288177,
-0.42361313104629517,
0.24628108739852905,
-0.007385937497019768,
-0.3694445490837097,
-0.029080260545015335,
0.1673664003610611,
1.2265273332595825,
0.29123786091804504,
-0.2634889483451843,
0.29583558440208435,
-0.04503566026687622,
-0.19819480180740356,
0.32954153418540955,
0.5100997686386108,
-0.07262814790010452,
0.4413701295852661,
0.22591076791286469,
0.03431946039199829,
0.2357565313577652,
-0.41574087738990784,
-0.08614511787891388,
0.273775577545166,
-0.44567951560020447,
-0.17018847167491913,
0.5649948120117188,
-0.03613794222474098,
-0.3113396167755127,
0.6987767815589905,
-0.19361215829849243,
-0.3132810890674591,
0.4786769449710846,
0.5363274216651917,
0.7664134502410889,
-0.029853034764528275,
0.2673983871936798,
0.21022816002368927,
0.07656688243150711,
-0.2204723209142685,
0.3743695616722107,
-0.42342519760131836,
-0.36898303031921387,
-0.5052250623703003,
-0.6515334248542786,
-0.3859960734844208,
0.18481412529945374,
-0.40974199771881104,
0.2698903977870941,
-0.5813919901847839,
-0.1750619113445282,
0.027796395123004913,
0.013464541174471378,
-0.7232704758644104,
0.06270455569028854,
0.1702396422624588,
1.2784740924835205,
-0.7158318758010864,
0.8546227812767029,
0.8465918898582458,
-0.051897335797548294,
-0.9331409931182861,
-0.1360962688922882,
-0.238077774643898,
-0.4767785966396332,
0.7273828387260437,
0.13228794932365417,
-0.34584394097328186,
0.3792399764060974,
-0.7989583611488342,
-0.7634431719779968,
0.9548025131225586,
0.6323809027671814,
-0.7960480451583862,
-0.19187703728675842,
-0.19519144296646118,
0.4632919430732727,
-0.21336449682712555,
0.2251415252685547,
0.3761551082134247,
0.6699475646018982,
0.23826874792575836,
-0.8214560747146606,
-0.026015471667051315,
-0.41401952505111694,
0.1034424901008606,
0.30487412214279175,
-0.5955747365951538,
0.7776870131492615,
-0.07386256754398346,
-0.08872141689062119,
0.08750780671834946,
0.4233858287334442,
0.0755547434091568,
0.17834992706775665,
0.479263037443161,
0.37736713886260986,
1.1712121963500977,
-0.19902268052101135,
0.8918266296386719,
-0.3044070899486542,
0.09335371851921082,
1.0633574724197388,
-0.03189081698656082,
0.6842093467712402,
0.5316874384880066,
0.39727020263671875,
0.5711499452590942,
0.5692725777626038,
0.2428157925605774,
0.5752286314964294,
0.31391558051109314,
-0.18886341154575348,
-0.39937612414360046,
-0.26318788528442383,
-0.23027697205543518,
0.4314711093902588,
0.5217832326889038,
-0.4945331811904907,
-0.5319705605506897,
0.3989088237285614,
0.0014634416438639164,
-0.27981534600257874,
-0.6990903615951538,
0.7776781916618347,
0.19674347341060638,
-0.6778658032417297,
0.7228072881698608,
-0.04012323170900345,
0.4307865798473358,
-0.636472225189209,
-0.14316952228546143,
-0.029462667182087898,
0.20961767435073853,
-0.035478685051202774,
-0.6983450651168823,
-0.14081263542175293,
-0.014559347182512283,
-0.16576524078845978,
-0.26063939929008484,
0.9598149657249451,
-0.3535473644733429,
-0.32147061824798584,
0.11702921986579895,
0.2847285866737366,
0.134792760014534,
-0.0982305258512497,
-0.5007095336914062,
0.16007685661315918,
-0.1434314250946045,
-0.2904829978942871,
0.3646146059036255,
0.46480563282966614,
-0.262494832277298,
0.7386528253555298,
0.581646740436554,
0.3505171835422516,
-0.06817720085382462,
0.12107717990875244,
0.9777780771255493,
-0.4079541265964508,
-0.9873107075691223,
-0.9727087020874023,
0.3549177646636963,
0.0395272858440876,
-0.6264854073524475,
0.6151814460754395,
0.4082895517349243,
0.47615090012550354,
0.2862641215324402,
0.7024754285812378,
0.3918924629688263,
0.23484200239181519,
-0.8158050775527954,
0.8399539589881897,
-0.34024524688720703,
0.10685206949710846,
-0.2437690645456314,
-0.7628730535507202,
-0.375215083360672,
0.5490723848342896,
-0.4512786269187927,
-0.044879913330078125,
0.24545539915561676,
0.8006824254989624,
-0.2593574821949005,
0.06708969920873642,
0.08046570420265198,
0.3740583658218384,
0.38962167501449585,
0.6402761340141296,
0.7058095932006836,
-0.32882577180862427,
0.18586891889572144,
0.13088105618953705,
-0.26402926445007324,
-0.3228156864643097,
-1.0796881914138794,
-0.7839986085891724,
-0.5933815836906433,
-0.28926658630371094,
-0.32110360264778137,
0.3800695538520813,
0.9912015199661255,
0.8171055912971497,
-0.6321191787719727,
0.004224005155265331,
-0.2307288944721222,
0.15365755558013916,
0.006976015400141478,
-0.12579920887947083,
0.4191490411758423,
-0.44472843408584595,
-0.34150850772857666,
0.5020312666893005,
0.3923344016075134,
-0.041973769664764404,
-0.12730644643306732,
-0.2530328631401062,
-0.14025086164474487,
-0.01207028329372406,
0.3935847282409668,
0.3308641016483307,
-0.41491979360580444,
-0.1748853325843811,
-0.20256681740283966,
0.031035596504807472,
0.03496144711971283,
0.6908155679702759,
-1.011335015296936,
0.565758228302002,
0.6992172002792358,
0.7018342614173889,
0.30984801054000854,
0.2679058313369751,
0.46221715211868286,
-0.7178305387496948,
0.05747333914041519,
0.07677939534187317,
0.14897404611110687,
0.14394716918468475,
-0.5350656509399414,
0.06351813673973083,
-0.1495768427848816,
-0.6552602052688599,
-0.7940593361854553,
0.12152175605297089,
-0.9303044676780701,
-0.2542518675327301,
1.3510258197784424,
0.2674712538719177,
-0.4704452157020569,
-0.15295647084712982,
-0.5372977256774902,
0.27534782886505127,
-0.5800509452819824,
0.4269467890262604,
0.5164561867713928,
-0.13710394501686096,
-0.2751106917858124,
-0.5526878237724304,
0.5789424180984497,
0.04991108179092407,
-0.5287113189697266,
-0.07998911291360855,
0.3596450984477997,
0.15849046409130096,
-0.03180990740656853,
0.5502249598503113,
0.452296644449234,
0.20389358699321747,
-0.46036383509635925,
-0.7517919540405273,
-0.5222173929214478,
-0.8046704530715942,
-0.8052691221237183,
0.18397803604602814,
0.15679140388965607,
-0.15047143399715424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11700v1 | Why Lift so Heavy? Slimming Large Language Models by Cutting Off the Layers | 2024-02-18T20:47:10 | 2024-02-18T20:47:10 | Shuzhou Yuan, Ercong Nie, Bolei Ma, Michael Färber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess outstanding capabilities in addressing
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, the sheer size of
these models poses challenges in terms of storage, training and inference due
to the inclusion of billions of parameters through layer stacking. While
traditional approaches such as model pruning or distillation offer ways for
reducing model size, they often come at the expense of performance retention.
In our investigation, we systematically explore the approach of reducing the
number of layers in LLMs. Surprisingly, we observe that even with fewer layers,
LLMs maintain similar or better performance levels, particularly in
prompt-based fine-tuning for text classification tasks. Remarkably, in certain
cases, models with a single layer outperform their fully layered counterparts.
These findings offer valuable insights for future work aimed at mitigating the
size constraints of LLMs while preserving their performance, thereby opening
avenues for significantly more efficient use of LLMs. | [
-0.5450758337974548,
-0.566537082195282,
0.2927597463130951,
0.05787542462348938,
-0.32009032368659973,
0.09234773367643356,
-0.2504402995109558,
-0.5726732015609741,
-0.14893457293510437,
0.9755106568336487,
-0.5574468970298767,
-0.10906718671321869,
-0.6270064115524292,
0.032020971179008484,
-0.5923691391944885,
1.1873494386672974,
0.2794395685195923,
-0.12099884450435638,
-0.41442984342575073,
-0.020477019250392914,
-0.342917799949646,
-0.3730054199695587,
-0.8526027798652649,
-0.7471544742584229,
0.7871760725975037,
0.35509008169174194,
0.8228908777236938,
0.9417669773101807,
0.4922301471233368,
0.2958618998527527,
-0.5971711874008179,
0.31722545623779297,
-0.6525260210037231,
0.17171351611614227,
0.07537561655044556,
-0.6691490411758423,
-0.10702548176050186,
0.09002771973609924,
0.7554149627685547,
1.1448837518692017,
-0.07765716314315796,
0.10969948023557663,
0.2239055037498474,
1.0118167400360107,
-0.6602668166160583,
-0.12779299914836884,
-0.6770505905151367,
0.009741389192640781,
-0.2391756772994995,
-0.19608309864997864,
-0.4883824288845062,
0.18182052671909332,
0.12952902913093567,
-0.2786097526550293,
0.11209230870008469,
0.23345737159252167,
0.8031317591667175,
0.4499782919883728,
-0.37700966000556946,
0.10789859294891357,
-0.9286235570907593,
1.029978632926941,
-0.7887954115867615,
0.10732170939445496,
0.3889215886592865,
0.06007729098200798,
0.04577761888504028,
-0.4311095178127289,
-0.23937644064426422,
-0.1891959309577942,
-0.06102411448955536,
-0.3013148009777069,
-0.12225367873907089,
0.12492907047271729,
0.5598529577255249,
0.47108301520347595,
-0.3128769099712372,
0.6026461124420166,
-0.5019941926002502,
-0.0963493287563324,
0.5909676551818848,
0.013299133628606796,
0.4749657213687897,
-0.12533049285411835,
-0.45743152499198914,
-0.045281026512384415,
-0.9083855152130127,
-0.09568347036838531,
0.37082815170288086,
0.5168346166610718,
0.19302892684936523,
0.6389187574386597,
0.14142170548439026,
0.5795910954475403,
-0.11311262845993042,
-0.16759319603443146,
0.03765059635043144,
0.13299041986465454,
-0.44359490275382996,
0.050253886729478836,
0.7125951051712036,
0.21208477020263672,
0.4212665259838104,
-0.23078756034374237,
-0.37314295768737793,
-0.27284756302833557,
0.27122560143470764,
-1.0581088066101074,
-0.17220672965049744,
0.2665708363056183,
-0.45034125447273254,
-0.3264036178588867,
-0.23654243350028992,
-0.37529200315475464,
-0.5301133394241333,
-0.4095320403575897,
0.2666543424129486,
-0.4788488447666168,
-0.21330684423446655,
0.3533206284046173,
-0.21862564980983734,
0.08471261709928513,
0.4223708510398865,
-0.9540977478027344,
0.6392688751220703,
0.9429402351379395,
0.8994386196136475,
-0.10262100398540497,
-0.043044187128543854,
-0.5234814882278442,
0.2203924059867859,
-0.39951372146606445,
0.45329880714416504,
-0.48503613471984863,
-0.12361211329698563,
-0.13685669004917145,
-0.13849039375782013,
-0.013592272996902466,
-0.9348671436309814,
0.8004400730133057,
-0.45756062865257263,
0.40410470962524414,
-0.3911089599132538,
-0.5740681886672974,
-0.1355762481689453,
0.16385042667388916,
-0.8381465673446655,
1.1383150815963745,
-0.11295951902866364,
-0.8143113255500793,
0.09271828085184097,
-0.08552886545658112,
-0.6218591928482056,
0.07075109332799911,
0.23845739662647247,
-0.3560701310634613,
0.6034775972366333,
0.3041099011898041,
0.6417142748832703,
-0.6432727575302124,
-0.0343809649348259,
-0.14565816521644592,
-0.3949219584465027,
-0.22605758905410767,
-0.22291144728660583,
0.8721092343330383,
0.5197974443435669,
0.025986652821302414,
-0.12766246497631073,
-0.7244972586631775,
-0.002402188489213586,
0.03775724768638611,
-0.5339325070381165,
-0.7843703627586365,
0.12252252548933029,
-0.017314264550805092,
0.3859148919582367,
0.11704778671264648,
-0.5553318858146667,
0.20681165158748627,
-0.718477725982666,
0.7475185394287109,
0.6249468326568604,
-0.3338716924190521,
0.6558171510696411,
-0.47047746181488037,
0.5274226069450378,
0.0964241549372673,
-0.14803802967071533,
0.16332903504371643,
-0.1992778331041336,
-0.7968242168426514,
-0.49128320813179016,
0.2626783847808838,
0.4700068533420563,
-0.7198778390884399,
0.37367159128189087,
-0.3333614468574524,
-0.5060043931007385,
-0.497282475233078,
0.6954999566078186,
0.3301421105861664,
0.4141940176486969,
0.2911915183067322,
-0.12722648680210114,
-0.4090571403503418,
-1.1128759384155273,
-0.38656336069107056,
-0.1287379413843155,
-0.29730695486068726,
0.1330239623785019,
0.4067312180995941,
0.09217847138643265,
0.7198792695999146,
-0.40301844477653503,
-0.29566681385040283,
-0.6771707534790039,
-0.08360189199447632,
0.2750069200992584,
0.6303143501281738,
0.5512025952339172,
-0.7680707573890686,
-0.2827717363834381,
-0.008088677190244198,
-0.5557354092597961,
-0.2436053454875946,
-0.2676183581352234,
-0.016203617677092552,
-0.11621037870645523,
0.6850111484527588,
-1.068162441253662,
-0.1502992808818817,
0.4924732744693756,
0.1698448807001114,
0.4434107840061188,
-0.19981329143047333,
-0.41181614995002747,
-0.8081513047218323,
-0.1425788849592209,
0.16095344722270966,
-0.4716874659061432,
-0.7248522639274597,
0.14129948616027832,
-0.03164561465382576,
-0.1630719155073166,
-0.32819822430610657,
0.5853674411773682,
-0.8713709115982056,
-0.01302160695195198,
-0.30291494727134705,
0.0633964091539383,
0.294776052236557,
0.28985464572906494,
-0.32144519686698914,
0.4637843668460846,
0.528994619846344,
-0.7020865678787231,
0.12240146100521088,
0.050430990755558014,
-0.49979496002197266,
0.19952455163002014,
-0.640852689743042,
0.07510357350111008,
-0.38754430413246155,
0.12475273758172989,
-0.8793536424636841,
0.0912260189652443,
-0.1760549545288086,
0.12055917084217072,
0.6633254885673523,
-0.08908731490373611,
-0.6623420715332031,
-0.5340179800987244,
-0.6240347623825073,
0.2167387157678604,
0.7152117490768433,
-0.5141656994819641,
0.6910607814788818,
0.3967442214488983,
-0.13317416608333588,
-0.551296055316925,
-1.0429539680480957,
0.2883744537830353,
-0.42414340376853943,
-0.5803712010383606,
0.3369327485561371,
0.07536260038614273,
-0.3041326701641083,
-0.1254376918077469,
-0.41880887746810913,
0.07505761831998825,
0.34024348855018616,
0.07922616600990295,
0.027232607826590538,
-0.07932993769645691,
0.40941011905670166,
0.006604562979191542,
0.1109909862279892,
0.13022480905056,
-0.33864545822143555,
0.6778568029403687,
0.10717211663722992,
-0.12535911798477173,
-0.5101853013038635,
0.1646682471036911,
0.6720020771026611,
-0.20533061027526855,
1.1679346561431885,
0.43651673197746277,
-0.3386557400226593,
-0.8244717121124268,
-0.7165510654449463,
-0.121709905564785,
-0.5125789046287537,
0.4646989405155182,
-0.2679927945137024,
-1.0455520153045654,
0.5400071740150452,
-0.23878946900367737,
0.1557602882385254,
0.401169091463089,
0.34956878423690796,
-0.1506471186876297,
1.1715002059936523,
0.5492761731147766,
-0.450278639793396,
0.5912727117538452,
-0.13219986855983734,
0.23613575100898743,
-0.9337336421012878,
-0.07528456300497055,
-0.7939077019691467,
-0.5312933921813965,
-0.48997125029563904,
-0.4004177749156952,
0.052299462258815765,
0.2687520384788513,
-0.1228627935051918,
0.17169708013534546,
-0.618581235408783,
0.6310076117515564,
0.34019264578819275,
0.19579245150089264,
0.26581329107284546,
0.21654033660888672,
0.20029102265834808,
0.17746762931346893,
-0.839390754699707,
-0.5720089077949524,
0.6916467547416687,
0.6367296576499939,
0.9218659996986389,
-0.019740905612707138,
0.6153196692466736,
0.008528611622750759,
-0.03226524963974953,
-0.8814505338668823,
0.9030600190162659,
-0.6220065355300903,
-0.5959652066230774,
-0.3500308096408844,
-0.9212470054626465,
-0.7943729162216187,
0.4862179458141327,
-0.042214926332235336,
-0.4840780794620514,
-0.22886580228805542,
0.11200360953807831,
-0.21948271989822388,
0.6140691637992859,
-0.8164217472076416,
0.5321975350379944,
-0.2550216019153595,
-0.4554343819618225,
-0.22088654339313507,
-0.6117734909057617,
0.4716363549232483,
0.10029563307762146,
0.23629100620746613,
-0.23237767815589905,
-0.20953701436519623,
0.7018797397613525,
-0.7272615432739258,
0.8656563758850098,
-0.0861802026629448,
-0.34841322898864746,
0.22233892977237701,
0.19405247271060944,
0.502785325050354,
-0.40435168147087097,
-0.16813434660434723,
-0.025691257789731026,
-0.06565867364406586,
-0.4158708453178406,
-0.5968960523605347,
0.8522344827651978,
-0.788417637348175,
-0.8096244931221008,
0.0011053476482629776,
-0.7996848225593567,
-0.2584623694419861,
0.1663498878479004,
-0.13888396322727203,
0.5220510959625244,
0.1993284970521927,
0.610335111618042,
0.7953522801399231,
-0.45537328720092773,
0.36339476704597473,
0.022376595064997673,
-0.29616931080818176,
0.23366102576255798,
0.7508591413497925,
0.34874269366264343,
0.5183459520339966,
0.7504165768623352,
0.4694457948207855,
-0.12025920301675797,
-0.9805360436439514,
0.024940431118011475,
0.3797595202922821,
-0.5055807828903198,
-0.004513860214501619,
-0.8038697242736816,
-0.34134235978126526,
-0.35702791810035706,
0.15819531679153442,
-0.33159205317497253,
-0.8311089873313904,
-0.4090379476547241,
-0.24340718984603882,
0.16001461446285248,
0.68743497133255,
0.2659350335597992,
0.5054224729537964,
-0.7462182641029358,
0.21852059662342072,
0.27904269099235535,
0.3428567051887512,
0.14639580249786377,
-0.6863271594047546,
-0.32601192593574524,
-0.2987605631351471,
-0.04081723466515541,
-0.3574385344982147,
0.6064742207527161,
0.49520549178123474,
0.3489864468574524,
0.2357468605041504,
0.003495224053040147,
0.5571078062057495,
-0.5666378736495972,
0.6756422519683838,
0.16085857152938843,
-0.7731752991676331,
0.3282073736190796,
-0.3206365406513214,
0.6305619478225708,
0.3844698965549469,
0.40764379501342773,
-0.3905651867389679,
-0.3885309398174286,
-0.30917054414749146,
-1.1264578104019165,
0.6995989680290222,
0.04783084988594055,
0.36776426434516907,
0.18191087245941162,
0.5336507558822632,
-0.033994678407907486,
0.404253751039505,
-0.677810549736023,
-0.13714081048965454,
0.15124566853046417,
-0.2678035795688629,
-0.0793842151761055,
-0.5356543064117432,
-0.10759523510932922,
-0.17373089492321014,
0.6513922214508057,
0.05206925794482231,
-0.2944676876068115,
-0.07159027457237244,
-0.2948431968688965,
-0.0956394299864769,
0.31970080733299255,
0.28712326288223267,
0.36955708265304565,
-0.12052112072706223,
0.5700180530548096,
0.22308842837810516,
-0.4202185273170471,
-0.13607871532440186,
-0.2555080056190491,
-0.24117334187030792,
-0.29783952236175537,
0.620011031627655,
0.8485504984855652,
0.2370516061782837,
-0.7612173557281494,
0.20224741101264954,
0.22345055639743805,
-0.1763007491827011,
0.1705036759376526,
0.18540538847446442,
0.31652864813804626,
-0.04222511872649193,
0.3855152726173401,
0.1954006552696228,
0.006780768278986216,
-0.5709502100944519,
0.01684885285794735,
0.5640969276428223,
-0.27419567108154297,
-0.2343519777059555,
0.5570579171180725,
0.19132347404956818,
-0.15313811600208282,
0.6477948427200317,
0.2690931260585785,
-0.45446041226387024,
0.5310910940170288,
0.3377545177936554,
0.7849569320678711,
-0.027186691761016846,
0.11042241752147675,
0.17512735724449158,
0.6824118494987488,
-0.588067889213562,
-0.26491478085517883,
0.14435938000679016,
-0.7875169515609741,
-0.6417474150657654,
-0.8386750817298889,
-0.13588213920593262,
0.2966187298297882,
-0.5874308943748474,
0.13378271460533142,
-0.9244058132171631,
-0.11638875305652618,
0.003493435215204954,
0.21856842935085297,
-0.5026960968971252,
0.2090747356414795,
0.36091354489326477,
1.010849118232727,
-0.8566295504570007,
0.734170138835907,
0.41380074620246887,
-0.225763738155365,
-0.9091492891311646,
-0.3804449439048767,
0.04436187446117401,
-0.7290012240409851,
0.7264045476913452,
0.38572928309440613,
-0.1347278356552124,
-0.040845952928066254,
-0.7280006408691406,
-0.626426637172699,
0.5977058410644531,
0.7221515774726868,
-0.8633840084075928,
-0.4247320294380188,
0.16977466642856598,
0.7059085369110107,
-0.22021040320396423,
0.12309110164642334,
0.4849103093147278,
0.27843695878982544,
0.15039849281311035,
-0.9076272249221802,
0.18896406888961792,
-0.2188814878463745,
0.25773119926452637,
0.25372448563575745,
-0.7145904898643494,
1.0824103355407715,
-0.06151215359568596,
-0.3336980938911438,
0.008194275200366974,
0.38144806027412415,
0.05058625712990761,
-0.20185403525829315,
0.7630290389060974,
0.827530026435852,
0.8361778259277344,
0.025180594995617867,
1.38334321975708,
-0.12076233327388763,
0.08383788913488388,
1.00200355052948,
-0.5714688897132874,
0.7673125267028809,
0.629048764705658,
-0.021076273173093796,
0.3765496611595154,
0.33211594820022583,
-0.0032019782811403275,
0.3167648911476135,
0.38971057534217834,
-0.12514634430408478,
-0.5713245272636414,
-0.24446922540664673,
-0.0776267945766449,
0.4724896550178528,
0.05159839242696762,
-0.26624026894569397,
-0.2127058357000351,
0.010772831737995148,
0.12422355264425278,
0.19486187398433685,
-0.5234088897705078,
0.6536983251571655,
0.35790178179740906,
-0.5187660455703735,
0.5538208484649658,
-0.12503017485141754,
0.7411271333694458,
-0.6248347163200378,
0.2738054692745209,
0.09008656442165375,
0.33612683415412903,
-0.3208266496658325,
-0.5203555822372437,
0.20209665596485138,
-0.1324785351753235,
-0.3481699526309967,
-0.8362900018692017,
0.8832802176475525,
-0.4550691545009613,
-0.6205722093582153,
0.506256103515625,
0.7638180255889893,
0.1765517294406891,
-0.187138631939888,
-0.6445356607437134,
0.09299647808074951,
-0.156451016664505,
-0.7033165097236633,
0.7264296412467957,
0.7295641303062439,
0.021451691165566444,
1.1709551811218262,
0.6812921166419983,
0.5181757807731628,
-0.07387035340070724,
0.43691956996917725,
1.0719621181488037,
-0.5446385145187378,
-0.2341879904270172,
-0.9808241128921509,
0.3139961063861847,
-0.08315818756818771,
-0.1464943289756775,
0.9211060404777527,
0.7097229361534119,
0.7447802424430847,
0.08722570538520813,
0.5445780158042908,
0.15639255940914154,
0.6851429343223572,
-0.683232307434082,
0.7205383777618408,
-0.8462000489234924,
0.7744793891906738,
-0.215129554271698,
-0.906343400478363,
-0.322343647480011,
0.36469942331314087,
-0.25041496753692627,
0.30804091691970825,
0.5309120416641235,
0.6922433972358704,
0.15587109327316284,
-0.10347849130630493,
0.5651512145996094,
0.5876426100730896,
0.45675787329673767,
0.45907092094421387,
0.8590206503868103,
-0.29767727851867676,
0.5172665119171143,
-0.3056166470050812,
0.045509565621614456,
0.07456737756729126,
-1.0032278299331665,
-1.1900193691253662,
-0.2253267616033554,
-0.2543521225452423,
0.015333643183112144,
-0.22553986310958862,
0.7962789535522461,
0.808185875415802,
-0.6333870887756348,
-0.3917665481567383,
0.10278435796499252,
0.15348459780216217,
-0.3057243525981903,
-0.20867569744586945,
0.12356322258710861,
-0.29543039202690125,
-0.735725462436676,
0.43527647852897644,
0.23916220664978027,
-0.12519274652004242,
-0.3003635108470917,
0.2931404411792755,
-0.39457085728645325,
-0.08468972891569138,
0.7631360292434692,
0.04956559091806412,
-0.619570255279541,
-0.26683804392814636,
-0.22023969888687134,
-0.21463416516780853,
-0.1817343682050705,
0.761982262134552,
-0.7859895825386047,
-0.02093207836151123,
0.6954955458641052,
0.8568903803825378,
0.5607653260231018,
0.07084588706493378,
0.6386865377426147,
-1.1559429168701172,
0.2331327348947525,
0.3632132112979889,
0.3146345019340515,
0.592787504196167,
-0.3218829035758972,
0.44467976689338684,
-0.06038704887032509,
-0.5598829388618469,
-1.2153643369674683,
0.030310779809951782,
-1.0668927431106567,
-0.5600581169128418,
1.0428704023361206,
0.19517675042152405,
-0.34932830929756165,
0.1766582429409027,
-0.13878817856311798,
-0.025970568880438805,
-0.15782403945922852,
0.5911704301834106,
0.8162271976470947,
0.0169608723372221,
-0.6809130907058716,
-0.7561051249504089,
0.4932601749897003,
0.7333377599716187,
-0.7382691502571106,
0.46328189969062805,
0.44252604246139526,
0.2541738450527191,
0.19069436192512512,
0.2984893023967743,
0.052141886204481125,
-0.40525877475738525,
-0.32491302490234375,
-0.12144053727388382,
-0.2669755816459656,
-0.437739759683609,
-0.3621233403682709,
0.6354986429214478,
0.025024013593792915,
0.34114259481430054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11690v1 | Vision-Flan: Scaling Human-Labeled Tasks in Visual Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-18T19:38:44 | 2024-02-18T19:38:44 | Zhiyang Xu, Chao Feng, Rulin Shao, Trevor Ashby, Ying Shen, Di Jin, Yu Cheng, Qifan Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Despite vision-language models' (VLMs) remarkable capabilities as versatile
visual assistants, two substantial challenges persist within the existing VLM
frameworks: (1) lacking task diversity in pretraining and visual instruction
tuning, and (2) annotation error and bias in GPT-4 synthesized instruction
tuning data. Both challenges lead to issues such as poor generalizability,
hallucination, and catastrophic forgetting. To address these challenges, we
construct Vision-Flan, the most diverse publicly available visual instruction
tuning dataset to date, comprising 187 diverse tasks and 1,664,261 instances
sourced from academic datasets, and each task is accompanied by an
expert-written instruction. In addition, we propose a two-stage instruction
tuning framework, in which VLMs are firstly finetuned on Vision-Flan and
further tuned on GPT-4 synthesized data. We find this two-stage tuning
framework significantly outperforms the traditional single-stage visual
instruction tuning framework and achieves the state-of-the-art performance
across a wide range of multi-modal evaluation benchmarks. Finally, we conduct
in-depth analyses to understand visual instruction tuning and our findings
reveal that: (1) GPT-4 synthesized data does not substantially enhance VLMs'
capabilities but rather modulates the model's responses to human-preferred
formats; (2) A minimal quantity (e.g., 1,000) of GPT-4 synthesized data can
effectively align VLM responses with human-preference; (3) Visual instruction
tuning mainly helps large-language models (LLMs) to understand visual features. | [
-0.43324437737464905,
-0.5338257551193237,
0.3366643786430359,
0.10746835917234421,
-0.017769960686564445,
-0.16702900826931,
-0.3241472840309143,
-0.4159712493419647,
-0.19892732799053192,
0.5710000395774841,
-0.5459775924682617,
-0.35121244192123413,
-0.5591318011283875,
0.07715464383363724,
-0.23129743337631226,
0.9070399403572083,
0.003226066241040826,
0.07136073708534241,
-0.09288007766008377,
-0.13928918540477753,
-0.5358076095581055,
-0.21222808957099915,
-0.512916624546051,
0.08309277147054672,
0.7864899635314941,
0.6398571133613586,
0.625837504863739,
0.9409542679786682,
0.756316602230072,
0.335390567779541,
0.25038087368011475,
0.3529570996761322,
-0.5865239500999451,
-0.2552124559879303,
-0.08869333565235138,
-0.5640634298324585,
-0.8064550757408142,
0.025396406650543213,
0.5183518528938293,
0.5650566816329956,
-0.007958595640957355,
0.41389378905296326,
0.10071487724781036,
0.9314855933189392,
-0.691276490688324,
0.26603323221206665,
-0.5831164717674255,
-0.02050682157278061,
-0.3200230002403259,
-0.09429117292165756,
-0.2552039325237274,
-0.018698502331972122,
0.22094622254371643,
-0.9717128276824951,
0.6392943263053894,
0.1642751842737198,
0.8798359036445618,
0.505315363407135,
-0.3123652935028076,
-0.032117120921611786,
-0.6658613085746765,
0.755222499370575,
-0.4712875783443451,
0.4007493853569031,
0.271871417760849,
0.49218398332595825,
0.23907192051410675,
-0.6442393064498901,
-0.35917747020721436,
-0.017766423523426056,
0.14792408049106598,
0.09052526950836182,
0.22893831133842468,
0.4136824607849121,
0.40424638986587524,
0.40805676579475403,
-0.6319336891174316,
-0.023408448323607445,
-0.5464593768119812,
-0.2383326292037964,
0.5350539684295654,
0.19420379400253296,
0.2371968775987625,
0.23685705661773682,
-0.4440375566482544,
-0.3920289874076843,
-0.3899497389793396,
-0.05164821073412895,
0.18339301645755768,
0.31920740008354187,
0.08128666132688522,
0.5304184556007385,
-0.26045575737953186,
1.1542603969573975,
0.012995711527764797,
-0.14570319652557373,
0.19776098430156708,
-0.47262564301490784,
-0.4170391857624054,
-0.24920639395713806,
0.4310899078845978,
0.6095213294029236,
0.5016308426856995,
0.12102284282445908,
-0.4011036157608032,
0.1584223061800003,
0.5123626589775085,
-0.6816704869270325,
-0.47995370626449585,
-0.2817038297653198,
-0.20528298616409302,
-0.1523294299840927,
0.23581139743328094,
-0.9201204180717468,
-0.4114327132701874,
-0.7346089482307434,
0.7961580157279968,
-0.10591991245746613,
-0.1559719741344452,
-0.03933184966444969,
-0.008484811522066593,
0.187210351228714,
0.5710260272026062,
-1.1933070421218872,
0.24026574194431305,
0.6507316827774048,
0.7506393194198608,
-0.2726651132106781,
-0.4485374987125397,
-0.6154921054840088,
-0.05262956768274307,
-0.5445508360862732,
0.5701540112495422,
-0.6433600783348083,
-0.17396292090415955,
-0.05477427318692207,
0.023857299238443375,
-0.33663734793663025,
-0.7078554630279541,
0.105829618871212,
-0.12858504056930542,
-0.0012939616572111845,
-0.7909225821495056,
-0.33779415488243103,
-0.06948761641979218,
0.08823850005865097,
-0.6497220396995544,
0.7836047410964966,
0.3333609104156494,
-0.5104550719261169,
0.7460542321205139,
-0.5923327803611755,
-0.49931615591049194,
-0.00315255019813776,
-0.23571659624576569,
-0.40539246797561646,
0.27772849798202515,
0.29705390334129333,
0.36096423864364624,
-0.2932298183441162,
-0.0891508236527443,
-0.1283867359161377,
-0.5548255443572998,
-0.15749339759349823,
-0.4154432415962219,
0.3038238286972046,
0.04419105127453804,
-0.5933353304862976,
0.5664693117141724,
-0.8424758315086365,
-0.011113706044852734,
-0.014788572676479816,
-0.21292972564697266,
-0.03491657227277756,
-0.09932338446378708,
-0.031052948907017708,
0.036154892295598984,
0.3046474754810333,
-0.34605228900909424,
0.09679502993822098,
-0.3079821765422821,
0.3728633224964142,
0.8132094144821167,
-0.2007043957710266,
0.47577086091041565,
-0.19529695808887482,
0.6097869873046875,
0.010681034065783024,
0.5167296528816223,
-0.11776866018772125,
-0.7071396112442017,
-1.106229543685913,
-0.1336224377155304,
-0.13117581605911255,
0.6537455320358276,
-0.7779296636581421,
0.0013101400109007955,
-0.3121112287044525,
-0.16884978115558624,
-0.43546774983406067,
0.40892988443374634,
0.5546427965164185,
0.679145097732544,
0.5317551493644714,
-0.18363617360591888,
-0.1668955385684967,
-0.93264240026474,
-0.2940426766872406,
0.07163238525390625,
-0.24777701497077942,
0.2104770988225937,
0.3486134111881256,
0.07461230456829071,
0.6258124113082886,
-0.3595859110355377,
-0.637275755405426,
0.03139050677418709,
0.19955089688301086,
-0.24676471948623657,
0.26676470041275024,
0.4362449049949646,
-0.9225208163261414,
-0.46276307106018066,
0.2604840099811554,
-0.5246415138244629,
0.07059744000434875,
-0.16971130669116974,
-0.17725317180156708,
0.21558541059494019,
0.22673477232456207,
-0.08840574324131012,
0.5842598676681519,
0.3711961507797241,
-0.3974888324737549,
0.3342795670032501,
-0.4183289408683777,
0.3602716028690338,
-0.63166344165802,
-0.16882197558879852,
0.05314787104725838,
-0.11442022770643234,
-0.6557936072349548,
0.0032128491438925266,
0.2612820565700531,
-0.11573122441768646,
-0.23573455214500427,
0.3331420123577118,
-0.4987466335296631,
-0.1825983077287674,
-0.25017574429512024,
0.026829490438103676,
-0.06009070202708244,
0.6988317370414734,
-0.03429079428315163,
0.8759785890579224,
0.5101278424263,
-0.5281603932380676,
0.2878895401954651,
0.015284317545592785,
-0.20188188552856445,
0.6961182355880737,
-0.6102880239486694,
0.01725240796804428,
0.036410413682460785,
-0.21671941876411438,
-0.8291501998901367,
-0.5429161190986633,
0.23613716661930084,
0.04121091961860657,
0.38579586148262024,
-0.08113634586334229,
-0.31470558047294617,
-0.36718398332595825,
-0.19562512636184692,
0.33366096019744873,
0.42131081223487854,
-0.5540929436683655,
0.5975308418273926,
0.041898854076862335,
0.15094484388828278,
-0.4576016962528229,
-0.648298442363739,
-0.016986241564154625,
-0.14385652542114258,
-0.6384662985801697,
0.2122165560722351,
-0.14851447939872742,
0.019160471856594086,
-0.2433074563741684,
-0.4713464379310608,
0.01110280491411686,
-0.11980600655078888,
0.2938455641269684,
0.2732142508029938,
-0.39896923303604126,
-0.11354530602693558,
0.005139319691807032,
-0.023227756842970848,
-0.14783594012260437,
-0.5238014459609985,
-0.08227906376123428,
-0.40171927213668823,
-0.42125755548477173,
-0.3012672960758209,
0.07716456055641174,
0.608934760093689,
-0.4385361075401306,
0.40405234694480896,
1.028510570526123,
-0.20000740885734558,
-0.18397203087806702,
-0.41431617736816406,
-0.17650824785232544,
-0.4929385781288147,
0.48861798644065857,
-0.28033652901649475,
-0.8962343335151672,
0.13317325711250305,
0.0011267253430560231,
0.37414515018463135,
0.11270400136709213,
0.4217160940170288,
-0.12831659615039825,
0.9872928261756897,
0.6579902172088623,
0.26112377643585205,
0.7584804892539978,
-0.16152416169643402,
0.01007628533989191,
-0.6365028023719788,
-0.09083554148674011,
-0.06354913115501404,
-0.628803551197052,
-0.4392227530479431,
-0.652583122253418,
0.6254676580429077,
-0.07755731046199799,
-0.22480881214141846,
0.16918259859085083,
-0.7356284856796265,
0.48230063915252686,
0.7194998264312744,
0.24909785389900208,
-0.03883678838610649,
0.1948162466287613,
0.3295367360115051,
-0.16100504994392395,
-0.570066511631012,
-0.2768387198448181,
1.1906527280807495,
0.05332339555025101,
0.6442723870277405,
-0.016462011262774467,
0.47349217534065247,
0.1562449038028717,
0.1231880709528923,
-0.43021777272224426,
0.561479389667511,
-0.5128852128982544,
-0.6802442669868469,
-0.5604113936424255,
-0.3731003701686859,
-0.7044409513473511,
0.413885235786438,
-0.16849137842655182,
-0.7647889852523804,
0.17014586925506592,
0.7629944086074829,
-0.21947841346263885,
0.1996675282716751,
-1.035709261894226,
1.2513052225112915,
-0.523642361164093,
-0.6762921214103699,
-0.13197657465934753,
-0.8173718452453613,
0.39858299493789673,
0.0530908927321434,
0.16508068144321442,
-0.11586938053369522,
-0.15846410393714905,
0.5695555806159973,
-0.47914037108421326,
0.9385948777198792,
-0.3536210358142853,
-0.20112186670303345,
0.14787329733371735,
-0.15250402688980103,
0.2669026255607605,
-0.0062934928573668,
0.3400561511516571,
-0.08322975039482117,
0.06899012625217438,
-0.6096872687339783,
-0.826513946056366,
0.7042465806007385,
-0.6914693117141724,
-0.665321946144104,
-0.1723598837852478,
-0.4434034824371338,
-0.364096999168396,
0.20711243152618408,
0.3407870829105377,
0.6845187544822693,
0.08124969899654388,
0.15991856157779694,
0.8275035619735718,
-0.03671286627650261,
0.12559406459331512,
0.16827958822250366,
-0.36562785506248474,
-0.29791077971458435,
1.5566504001617432,
0.1549699455499649,
0.5496350526809692,
0.6360107064247131,
0.047866836190223694,
0.06276114284992218,
-0.34248584508895874,
-0.6984245181083679,
-0.015572885982692242,
-0.6538333296775818,
0.03861091285943985,
-0.09430695325136185,
0.10648521780967712,
-0.14450688660144806,
-0.2819691598415375,
-0.47534075379371643,
-0.16586045920848846,
-0.5430652499198914,
0.05148471146821976,
0.23981499671936035,
0.7929314374923706,
0.06741730123758316,
0.15843653678894043,
-0.41794469952583313,
0.6842650771141052,
0.694501519203186,
0.5035625100135803,
-0.22759634256362915,
-0.44415009021759033,
-0.2929080128669739,
0.15153002738952637,
-0.022190852090716362,
-0.6201625466346741,
0.014162946492433548,
0.5131349563598633,
0.2585894763469696,
0.42499879002571106,
-0.2045823037624359,
0.8861031532287598,
-0.45265302062034607,
0.8459606170654297,
0.12292223423719406,
-0.6575354933738708,
0.6596169471740723,
-0.34708261489868164,
0.5168187022209167,
0.5190470814704895,
-0.10939465463161469,
-0.004296413157135248,
-0.09490733593702316,
-0.12902937829494476,
-0.806373119354248,
0.7803748250007629,
0.16475196182727814,
-0.08371337503194809,
0.26432958245277405,
0.21924813091754913,
0.1965811550617218,
0.19336670637130737,
-0.3195057809352875,
-0.16063398122787476,
-0.6463214159011841,
-0.2854623794555664,
-0.20548653602600098,
-0.14854176342487335,
-0.23397770524024963,
-0.498052179813385,
0.3305237293243408,
-0.36533108353614807,
0.02677522413432598,
0.07036849856376648,
-0.2481948882341385,
-0.12533287703990936,
0.0750310942530632,
1.0239816904067993,
0.8360380530357361,
-0.09467002004384995,
0.007881187833845615,
0.07878357917070389,
-0.6594339609146118,
-0.005533118732273579,
-0.04889484867453575,
-0.1987449824810028,
-0.38848406076431274,
0.47571441531181335,
1.4176429510116577,
0.5372518301010132,
-0.6042339205741882,
0.47998613119125366,
-0.17159228026866913,
-0.4706753194332123,
-0.06140413507819176,
0.6337302327156067,
-0.12129773944616318,
0.1708296686410904,
0.3206053674221039,
0.4681413471698761,
0.017175903543829918,
-0.16497458517551422,
0.10502280294895172,
0.16294826567173004,
-0.39871177077293396,
-0.42981618642807007,
1.033951759338379,
0.30775630474090576,
-0.3408527374267578,
0.48491770029067993,
-0.04354913532733917,
-0.13015519082546234,
0.5407155752182007,
0.22150090336799622,
0.700584352016449,
-0.0439775250852108,
0.35763147473335266,
0.3767527639865875,
0.545602023601532,
-0.13325494527816772,
0.40785229206085205,
-0.2713764011859894,
-0.4299675524234772,
-0.1314925253391266,
-0.7405184507369995,
-0.08600583672523499,
-0.02653263881802559,
-0.9023882150650024,
0.058868251740932465,
-0.5682987570762634,
-0.18993094563484192,
-0.10295809805393219,
-0.16007038950920105,
-0.9892647862434387,
0.3167196214199066,
0.18484222888946533,
0.6070197820663452,
-0.7402476072311401,
0.7294994592666626,
0.8743408918380737,
-0.4402494728565216,
-0.7418103218078613,
0.021980367600917816,
0.3093145191669464,
-0.5769598484039307,
0.3658505380153656,
0.1587614119052887,
-0.2336616963148117,
0.20727548003196716,
-0.2937951385974884,
-0.6825971603393555,
1.2437965869903564,
0.5082080364227295,
-0.910509467124939,
-0.20520013570785522,
0.1886756420135498,
0.5868852734565735,
-0.22945787012577057,
-0.10334071516990662,
0.6986389756202698,
0.6837098002433777,
0.06135309115052223,
-0.9929928183555603,
-0.21627606451511383,
-0.19331669807434082,
0.3020073473453522,
0.05336528271436691,
-0.745911180973053,
0.7898088693618774,
-0.2820269763469696,
-0.03647663816809654,
0.0296615157276392,
0.7298256754875183,
-0.08210061490535736,
0.2494271844625473,
0.6611022353172302,
0.253357857465744,
0.6581329107284546,
-0.21637354791164398,
0.8926860094070435,
-0.11090541630983353,
-0.07261768728494644,
0.9812009930610657,
-0.023803161457180977,
0.5928990244865417,
0.3961855173110962,
-0.20551399886608124,
0.11019350588321686,
0.5314591526985168,
-0.005981592461466789,
0.25167766213417053,
-0.037234120070934296,
-0.08427991718053818,
-0.4720441401004791,
0.20793014764785767,
-0.21864178776741028,
0.48777177929878235,
0.4489800035953522,
-0.24568812549114227,
0.08800141513347626,
0.26944613456726074,
-0.42991411685943604,
0.12013913691043854,
-0.4252665638923645,
0.700511634349823,
-0.1287916600704193,
-0.6431795358657837,
0.7281640768051147,
-0.42768117785453796,
0.5313816070556641,
-0.5546837449073792,
-0.13106463849544525,
-0.28121820092201233,
0.2504362165927887,
-0.093658447265625,
-0.4915757477283478,
-0.21301445364952087,
-0.012214475311338902,
-0.26104065775871277,
-0.24998317658901215,
0.4219280183315277,
-0.5618692636489868,
-0.6688273549079895,
-0.006289506796747446,
0.12810729444026947,
-0.07665849477052689,
-0.05229976028203964,
-0.5863968133926392,
0.3250638544559479,
0.2363729029893875,
-0.33835265040397644,
0.5720831155776978,
0.36511853337287903,
-0.2491133064031601,
0.628435492515564,
0.191947802901268,
0.015419951640069485,
0.4715651273727417,
0.3192283809185028,
0.5541991591453552,
-0.4353775978088379,
-0.21223191916942596,
-0.42212921380996704,
0.5578917860984802,
-0.10842158645391464,
-0.6134555339813232,
0.5522303581237793,
0.3783794641494751,
0.9502406716346741,
-0.34944257140159607,
0.634446382522583,
0.054650258272886276,
0.13669469952583313,
-0.617780327796936,
0.4695599377155304,
-0.8823518753051758,
0.10769014805555344,
-0.2685996890068054,
-0.9060113430023193,
-0.3196678161621094,
0.5297276377677917,
-0.18200670182704926,
0.3266000747680664,
0.4695102274417877,
0.888899564743042,
-0.27890872955322266,
-0.04287373647093773,
0.566721498966217,
-0.11657418310642242,
0.20171506702899933,
0.521838903427124,
0.30598101019859314,
-0.21807745099067688,
0.6938241124153137,
-0.3239096999168396,
-0.40823817253112793,
-0.4472934305667877,
-0.4429892301559448,
-1.0178282260894775,
-0.8585611581802368,
-0.31089624762535095,
0.31752002239227295,
0.1714332103729248,
0.4579314887523651,
0.9665680527687073,
-0.8312505483627319,
-0.11119388043880463,
-0.24391549825668335,
-0.12406088411808014,
-0.6242440342903137,
-0.17368312180042267,
0.18164454400539398,
-0.49605146050453186,
-0.7637660503387451,
0.49866560101509094,
0.5066196918487549,
-0.06353604793548584,
-0.3550008237361908,
-0.12160234898328781,
0.13551212847232819,
-0.17843185365200043,
0.6315037608146667,
0.35643723607063293,
-1.0558658838272095,
-0.5032785534858704,
0.07320034503936768,
-0.05130117014050484,
-0.006113485433161259,
0.8097547888755798,
-0.46803396940231323,
1.0137324333190918,
0.3498055040836334,
0.49635058641433716,
0.48524755239486694,
0.17018015682697296,
0.6661551594734192,
-0.8381682634353638,
0.14882837235927582,
-0.11034402996301651,
0.11082654446363449,
0.35843247175216675,
-0.24748466908931732,
0.4643704295158386,
0.23216982185840607,
-0.55083167552948,
-0.611441969871521,
0.26139530539512634,
-0.9344301223754883,
-0.11582094430923462,
0.8992159366607666,
-0.006740782409906387,
-0.2481907457113266,
0.2239697277545929,
-0.3906721770763397,
0.1780044585466385,
-0.09004904329776764,
0.6116041541099548,
0.4932610094547272,
-0.2814341187477112,
-0.23763078451156616,
-0.8007936477661133,
0.7025715708732605,
0.4631943702697754,
-0.6297452449798584,
0.21923457086086273,
0.6620357632637024,
0.24703015387058258,
-0.07383506745100021,
0.3327203392982483,
0.22483450174331665,
0.533980667591095,
0.20677147805690765,
-0.1608062982559204,
-0.428432434797287,
-0.7716062664985657,
-0.044352106750011444,
0.09396103024482727,
0.11471710354089737,
-0.4015708267688751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11684v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11684v2 | ALLaVA: Harnessing GPT4V-Synthesized Data for Lite Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-18T19:26:49 | 2024-06-17T07:55:59 | Guiming Hardy Chen, Shunian Chen, Ruifei Zhang, Junying Chen, Xiangbo Wu, Zhiyi Zhang, Zhihong Chen, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have shown premise in a broad range of
vision-language tasks with their strong reasoning and generalization
capabilities. However, they require considerable computational resources for
training and deployment. This study aims to bridge the performance gap between
traditional-scale LVLMs and resource-friendly lite versions by adopting
high-quality training data. To this end, we propose a comprehensive pipeline
for generating a synthetic dataset. The key idea is to leverage strong
proprietary models to generate (i) fine-grained image annotations for
vision-language alignment and (ii) complex reasoning visual question-answering
pairs for visual instruction fine-tuning, yielding 1.3M samples in total. We
train a series of lite VLMs on the synthetic dataset and experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed scheme, where they achieve
competitive performance on 17 benchmarks among 4B LVLMs, and even perform on
par with 7B/13B-scale models on various benchmarks. This work highlights the
feasibility of adopting high-quality data in crafting more efficient LVLMs. We
name our dataset \textit{ALLaVA}, and open-source it to research community for
developing better resource-efficient LVLMs for wider usage. | [
-0.3909282982349396,
-0.6059648394584656,
0.49410486221313477,
-0.23796427249908447,
-0.12376829236745834,
-0.013308839872479439,
-0.0672125443816185,
-0.45429179072380066,
-0.053713783621788025,
0.7552766799926758,
-0.3857209384441376,
-0.369202196598053,
-0.015008972957730293,
-0.05034363269805908,
-0.463038831949234,
0.572390615940094,
-0.10963578522205353,
0.12821230292320251,
0.14319925010204315,
-0.3703242838382721,
-0.37434616684913635,
-0.22203010320663452,
-0.21361705660820007,
0.025673450902104378,
0.6750820875167847,
0.19012391567230225,
0.6066482067108154,
0.7712699770927429,
0.39505481719970703,
0.2943708598613739,
0.34717440605163574,
0.6310873627662659,
-0.4485272467136383,
-0.09342213720083237,
-0.2283041924238205,
-0.1881498396396637,
-0.5448652505874634,
0.025034189224243164,
0.8224338293075562,
0.3832564651966095,
-0.1680988222360611,
0.39229345321655273,
-0.0245046503841877,
0.6542141437530518,
-0.7608479261398315,
0.19737853109836578,
-0.9504124522209167,
-0.0381912924349308,
-0.22612227499485016,
0.02104964666068554,
-0.3617396056652069,
-0.33399075269699097,
0.03754662722349167,
-0.8457576036453247,
0.3858264684677124,
0.268809050321579,
0.818423330783844,
0.27398887276649475,
-0.03760456666350365,
0.1722387820482254,
-0.6316563487052917,
0.7343860268592834,
-0.6498606204986572,
0.42113059759140015,
-0.0012575099244713783,
0.6606375575065613,
0.08311369270086288,
-0.9786703586578369,
-0.743409276008606,
0.0589231476187706,
0.17642302811145782,
0.09007731825113297,
0.26998552680015564,
0.14346377551555634,
0.21440985798835754,
0.45031610131263733,
-0.6186577081680298,
-0.16068728268146515,
-0.7182030081748962,
-0.14396241307258606,
0.6746112108230591,
0.2983505129814148,
0.1368640512228012,
0.008823394775390625,
-0.29824474453926086,
-0.18053871393203735,
-0.9059717059135437,
-0.016292963176965714,
0.1995822936296463,
0.31663480401039124,
0.1775204986333847,
0.9686923623085022,
-0.2604134976863861,
1.0659382343292236,
-0.29162779450416565,
-0.16510429978370667,
0.36064204573631287,
-0.730344831943512,
-0.4961496591567993,
-0.17661969363689423,
0.5936338305473328,
0.5448577404022217,
0.472513884305954,
-0.05054633319377899,
-0.5033528804779053,
0.25277581810951233,
0.3940944969654083,
-0.7885522842407227,
-0.310404509305954,
-0.08128853887319565,
-0.1791970282793045,
-0.30800750851631165,
-0.23386524617671967,
-0.8092572093009949,
-0.28610923886299133,
-0.7337074279785156,
0.6933056116104126,
-0.3972994387149811,
-0.0073417662642896175,
0.13531818985939026,
0.07446464896202087,
0.46217218041419983,
0.4687877893447876,
-0.7569106817245483,
0.07175643742084503,
0.3231613039970398,
0.788520872592926,
-0.21735534071922302,
-0.2946467697620392,
-0.8675298690795898,
0.09105461835861206,
-0.5933957695960999,
0.38899481296539307,
-0.46010613441467285,
-0.11015595495700836,
0.13671299815177917,
-0.007735797669738531,
-0.03337445855140686,
-0.5086298584938049,
0.39824676513671875,
-0.3250206410884857,
0.07350974529981613,
-0.14001744985580444,
-0.5363898873329163,
0.11290382593870163,
0.1539696604013443,
-0.6246473789215088,
0.9580521583557129,
0.3047106862068176,
-0.6997055411338806,
0.40650105476379395,
-0.36924251914024353,
0.014529211446642876,
0.5005558729171753,
-0.5693865418434143,
-0.38107237219810486,
0.06509659439325333,
0.4326329827308655,
0.4304473400115967,
-0.3632300794124603,
0.20151029527187347,
-0.033516775816679,
-0.6134534478187561,
0.003009398700669408,
-0.422411173582077,
0.45345619320869446,
0.3720813989639282,
-0.20729446411132812,
0.1151149794459343,
-0.96683669090271,
0.279348224401474,
0.04932253807783127,
-0.12427302449941635,
-0.21281974017620087,
-0.15081271529197693,
0.18685245513916016,
0.028316203504800797,
0.21392326056957245,
-0.5276026129722595,
0.36135268211364746,
-0.506918728351593,
0.22062134742736816,
0.8081883788108826,
-0.23231008648872375,
0.42651641368865967,
-0.03764282912015915,
0.5188966989517212,
-0.27438053488731384,
0.5665093660354614,
-0.22402545809745789,
-0.4226885139942169,
-0.9284284710884094,
-0.4430922269821167,
0.08332604914903641,
0.442697137594223,
-1.3577908277511597,
0.13552793860435486,
-0.2410593181848526,
-0.37313953042030334,
-0.8116978406906128,
0.11026030033826828,
0.40016913414001465,
0.5808941721916199,
0.49673447012901306,
-0.07022720575332642,
-0.46839386224746704,
-1.083126425743103,
-0.0680660530924797,
0.13852165639400482,
-0.056409649550914764,
0.2720937430858612,
0.3590776324272156,
-0.1433175504207611,
1.0831602811813354,
-0.4932563006877899,
-0.1941274255514145,
-0.11890757828950882,
-0.15724338591098785,
0.053702469915151596,
0.3213454782962799,
0.6753822565078735,
-0.8524659276008606,
-0.37104251980781555,
0.14575229585170746,
-0.7188839316368103,
-0.17846724390983582,
0.2007431834936142,
-0.09045866876840591,
0.22658400237560272,
0.4584570527076721,
-0.33518368005752563,
0.4616297781467438,
0.7200901508331299,
-0.30627694725990295,
0.7678989768028259,
-0.2865515351295471,
0.18523497879505157,
-1.069306492805481,
0.053632985800504684,
0.0801042914390564,
-0.25696346163749695,
-0.5763567686080933,
0.07967843115329742,
0.03015795908868313,
-0.09917129576206207,
-0.7760319709777832,
0.7228775024414062,
-0.4068371057510376,
-0.18700972199440002,
-0.07880812883377075,
-0.22431489825248718,
0.08855216950178146,
0.31636855006217957,
0.0583735890686512,
1.1437844038009644,
0.7282285690307617,
-0.3218589723110199,
0.6362205147743225,
0.0387151874601841,
-0.7179896235466003,
0.33599358797073364,
-0.7569220066070557,
-0.08419027179479599,
0.01711675152182579,
-0.13748838007450104,
-0.4989702105522156,
-0.4864378273487091,
0.16059263050556183,
-0.04913632571697235,
0.013902298174798489,
-0.34068968892097473,
-0.6022072434425354,
-0.0810895785689354,
-0.1951904594898224,
0.48437434434890747,
0.9082200527191162,
-0.6977609992027283,
0.6819274425506592,
0.29520827531814575,
-0.041613418608903885,
-0.50408935546875,
-0.607408881187439,
0.049100205302238464,
-0.16997750103473663,
-0.6526882648468018,
0.2643190622329712,
0.016355229541659355,
-0.1581050455570221,
-0.1073276475071907,
0.17981375753879547,
0.046424511820077896,
-0.47835853695869446,
0.10727928578853607,
0.5051437020301819,
-0.28908777236938477,
0.053039636462926865,
-0.4975643754005432,
0.11660090833902359,
-0.240422323346138,
-0.362018883228302,
0.29545632004737854,
-0.43731749057769775,
-0.38274431228637695,
-0.08729971945285797,
0.006482437252998352,
0.7134727239608765,
-0.48810136318206787,
0.7147550582885742,
0.7070136070251465,
-0.21809089183807373,
-0.5026926398277283,
-0.6998292207717896,
-0.0628398060798645,
-0.5287428498268127,
0.23078253865242004,
-0.38865116238594055,
-0.7676820158958435,
0.11368942260742188,
-0.01536994706839323,
0.13779999315738678,
0.19833390414714813,
0.4685748815536499,
-0.0962541326880455,
0.9292182922363281,
0.35135623812675476,
0.31833121180534363,
0.5202614068984985,
-0.4013150930404663,
0.18747666478157043,
-0.7710139155387878,
-0.23068761825561523,
0.0030690578278154135,
-0.05745040997862816,
-0.6293013095855713,
-0.9187421798706055,
0.5937337279319763,
-0.23833149671554565,
-0.20452958345413208,
0.07802655547857285,
-0.5916988253593445,
0.6440237760543823,
0.3929782509803772,
-0.11020585894584656,
0.21517914533615112,
0.3746504783630371,
-0.09058614075183868,
-0.08782847970724106,
-0.7065516114234924,
-0.4217330813407898,
1.097777247428894,
0.09404274821281433,
0.8794636130332947,
-0.25703197717666626,
0.3539089858531952,
0.09084975719451904,
-0.12368940562009811,
-0.33261778950691223,
0.739621102809906,
-0.27850982546806335,
-0.3578893542289734,
-0.24084429442882538,
-0.5159823894500732,
-0.7069467306137085,
0.4199107885360718,
-0.3367379307746887,
-0.49755558371543884,
0.07423029094934464,
0.3239368498325348,
0.00969047099351883,
0.36956021189689636,
-0.8736299872398376,
0.9376731514930725,
-0.25054875016212463,
-0.7272717356681824,
-0.03191953897476196,
-0.5223775506019592,
0.4980853199958801,
-0.21603365242481232,
0.21446995437145233,
-0.09943077713251114,
0.1643923968076706,
0.30381685495376587,
-0.5388602018356323,
0.6507166028022766,
-0.2596249282360077,
-0.10875339061021805,
0.4604056775569916,
-0.15064507722854614,
0.566336452960968,
0.024216560646891594,
0.10825742781162262,
0.02361563965678215,
-0.1923026144504547,
-0.5111657381057739,
-0.47715577483177185,
0.7520249485969543,
-0.5644019246101379,
-0.24529333412647247,
-0.4180963337421417,
-0.5057250261306763,
-0.31909823417663574,
0.06016536429524422,
0.350777268409729,
0.6745430827140808,
-0.013345623388886452,
0.2916337251663208,
0.6076449155807495,
-0.2150893360376358,
0.1856691986322403,
0.266786128282547,
-0.5356825590133667,
-0.3829248249530792,
1.1825356483459473,
0.24072517454624176,
0.4310344159603119,
-0.0612456388771534,
-0.08534454554319382,
-0.1523151397705078,
-0.749890148639679,
-0.6560093760490417,
0.10476984083652496,
-0.6127201318740845,
-0.09727557748556137,
-0.1312507688999176,
-0.45711636543273926,
0.0015893090749159455,
-0.28759336471557617,
-0.7946869134902954,
-0.255264014005661,
0.07433632761240005,
0.15043172240257263,
0.473405122756958,
0.6486524343490601,
0.2406139224767685,
-0.01829461194574833,
-0.5914499163627625,
0.6070252656936646,
0.48409825563430786,
0.4911978840827942,
-0.26495006680488586,
-0.3310083746910095,
-0.3740141689777374,
0.19139425456523895,
0.1498998999595642,
-0.31940123438835144,
0.4789881706237793,
0.25222188234329224,
0.3941270709037781,
-0.1760401427745819,
-0.21273283660411835,
0.6464684009552002,
-0.7407760620117188,
0.9312551617622375,
0.2662450969219208,
-0.5652234554290771,
0.6624215841293335,
-0.3609585165977478,
0.2613178789615631,
0.45401278138160706,
-0.14876730740070343,
0.023193027824163437,
-0.2929410934448242,
-0.4476374089717865,
-0.9479967355728149,
0.493180513381958,
0.6209782361984253,
-0.1575576364994049,
0.3337250053882599,
0.5901721715927124,
0.16825222969055176,
0.2540270984172821,
-0.5706854462623596,
-0.06266912817955017,
-0.4179476499557495,
-0.4328782856464386,
-0.04875412583351135,
0.11985714733600616,
0.0004003708891104907,
-0.45810413360595703,
0.6353124380111694,
-0.39819955825805664,
-0.2139914184808731,
0.08413764089345932,
-0.051539454609155655,
0.22935466468334198,
0.04601091518998146,
0.16774091124534607,
0.7846764326095581,
-0.17417918145656586,
0.12319879233837128,
0.09477875381708145,
-0.5993169546127319,
0.13235419988632202,
0.00038785242941230536,
-0.42725253105163574,
-0.08303334563970566,
0.21861237287521362,
0.9633635878562927,
-0.30109506845474243,
-0.947329580783844,
0.4993482232093811,
-0.16001878678798676,
-0.18415741622447968,
-0.3607143759727478,
0.45763978362083435,
-0.15235325694084167,
0.3248756229877472,
0.16937480866909027,
0.05773862823843956,
0.05322881415486336,
-0.4848968982696533,
0.06474685668945312,
0.41157519817352295,
0.07396194338798523,
-0.29635751247406006,
0.6094125509262085,
0.28557825088500977,
0.172851100564003,
0.5833197832107544,
-0.11828584969043732,
-0.1728557050228119,
0.33455026149749756,
0.06709878146648407,
0.48086783289909363,
-0.09130682051181793,
0.15991473197937012,
0.4528258144855499,
0.19883288443088531,
-0.15749678015708923,
0.3678225576877594,
0.16058671474456787,
-0.6315106749534607,
-0.7932571172714233,
-0.9743913412094116,
-0.26163342595100403,
0.31818675994873047,
-0.3381956219673157,
0.3963191509246826,
-0.30985578894615173,
0.07423911243677139,
-0.18920810520648956,
-0.2557799518108368,
-0.9549389481544495,
0.4621905982494354,
0.354936420917511,
0.6390865445137024,
-0.810066819190979,
1.1376030445098877,
0.5428324937820435,
-0.5554383993148804,
-0.7858400344848633,
-0.26171794533729553,
-0.2471752166748047,
-0.9300592541694641,
0.5364248156547546,
0.05419067293405533,
-0.3682546615600586,
0.016186028718948364,
-0.6186185479164124,
-0.689393162727356,
1.1212756633758545,
0.6187909841537476,
-0.8102751970291138,
-0.17889609932899475,
0.2964841425418854,
0.5420328974723816,
-0.5225953459739685,
-0.19540750980377197,
0.5864608883857727,
0.372661828994751,
0.2861194908618927,
-0.9008115530014038,
-0.2506157457828522,
-0.3499901592731476,
0.27218639850616455,
0.0885489210486412,
-0.5342878699302673,
0.7471390962600708,
-0.02982216142117977,
0.036894265562295914,
0.008099044673144817,
0.389024019241333,
0.37882623076438904,
0.14204780757427216,
0.3292931020259857,
0.47153085470199585,
0.4767243564128876,
-0.15255677700042725,
1.0571908950805664,
-0.08853764832019806,
0.12842513620853424,
0.9894366264343262,
-0.41012391448020935,
0.7675008177757263,
0.5953254699707031,
-0.011327266693115234,
0.12018207460641861,
0.2037537395954132,
-0.2846306264400482,
0.6640885472297668,
0.0931520089507103,
-0.3327288329601288,
-0.21440747380256653,
-0.1353304088115692,
-0.28954628109931946,
0.5107595920562744,
0.44145384430885315,
-0.33748263120651245,
0.07219845056533813,
0.15530924499034882,
-0.5951019525527954,
-0.07802005857229233,
-0.4236636757850647,
0.5774106979370117,
-0.005870009306818247,
-0.6297810673713684,
0.8994502425193787,
-0.3249591886997223,
0.5136817097663879,
-0.6222689151763916,
-0.23373927175998688,
-0.09707066416740417,
0.32467126846313477,
-0.1221834123134613,
-0.9675577878952026,
0.11968960613012314,
0.2512482702732086,
0.08614160865545273,
-0.20330722630023956,
0.6334600448608398,
-0.6243900656700134,
-0.6713568568229675,
-0.010432335548102856,
0.44965770840644836,
0.04017123952507973,
0.041879888623952866,
-0.39027366042137146,
0.28841832280158997,
0.06792143732309341,
-0.2732103168964386,
0.3805501163005829,
0.33890196681022644,
0.05659403279423714,
0.5789309740066528,
0.592043936252594,
0.4545089602470398,
0.3878588378429413,
0.225982666015625,
0.8628113865852356,
-0.5101078748703003,
-0.169358029961586,
-0.6041587591171265,
0.7476112842559814,
-0.2348693609237671,
-0.17159496247768402,
0.5270801782608032,
0.6375893950462341,
0.760979175567627,
-0.18954496085643768,
0.968647837638855,
0.129210963845253,
0.3055712580680847,
-1.0138498544692993,
0.46056807041168213,
-0.740164577960968,
0.2110983431339264,
0.09312451630830765,
-1.2192472219467163,
-0.09657077491283417,
0.6283089518547058,
0.0979221984744072,
-0.06588423997163773,
0.4058273732662201,
0.8621758222579956,
-0.36469122767448425,
-0.22857555747032166,
0.3937661051750183,
0.21764735877513885,
0.47977039217948914,
0.5233728885650635,
0.644200325012207,
-0.4179869592189789,
0.548574686050415,
-0.08537458628416061,
-0.01522576529532671,
-0.2708355784416199,
-0.8570064902305603,
-0.7558926343917847,
-0.7180771231651306,
-0.2850329875946045,
-0.054287150502204895,
0.229608416557312,
0.629382312297821,
0.6724039912223816,
-0.48424896597862244,
0.0916416347026825,
-0.44832122325897217,
-0.5326953530311584,
0.21212328970432281,
-0.1476619988679886,
0.41915011405944824,
-0.2850486934185028,
-0.7240573763847351,
0.5605785250663757,
0.2923782169818878,
0.2942246198654175,
-0.47361794114112854,
-0.2553986608982086,
0.14103567600250244,
0.06389803439378738,
0.7059552669525146,
0.20530997216701508,
-0.967245876789093,
-0.33924588561058044,
-0.0279206745326519,
-0.05436226353049278,
0.019674507901072502,
0.4796249270439148,
-0.9799131155014038,
0.8762093782424927,
0.3979930281639099,
0.6270344853401184,
0.7327775955200195,
-0.006674203090369701,
0.6738756895065308,
-0.9696614742279053,
0.3166549503803253,
0.25843238830566406,
0.5603190660476685,
0.6201801300048828,
0.16210760176181793,
0.6981129050254822,
0.13041076064109802,
-0.5098951458930969,
-0.8369269371032715,
0.2359233945608139,
-0.9172669649124146,
-0.149250328540802,
1.2338749170303345,
0.07557028532028198,
-0.28504258394241333,
0.17293545603752136,
-0.5109712481498718,
0.1112854927778244,
-0.11173542588949203,
0.44306695461273193,
0.490656316280365,
-0.05517139658331871,
-0.2428692728281021,
-0.8715707063674927,
0.6581367254257202,
0.0899864062666893,
-0.7997427582740784,
0.1497003138065338,
0.8329384922981262,
0.19779318571090698,
-0.024688251316547394,
0.34742647409439087,
-0.1287793070077896,
0.3877931535243988,
0.12194608896970749,
0.16492703557014465,
-0.29593193531036377,
-0.45540568232536316,
-0.011591819114983082,
0.11849921941757202,
0.08012452721595764,
-0.1757987141609192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11683v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11683v2 | One Prompt To Rule Them All: LLMs for Opinion Summary Evaluation | 2024-02-18T19:13:52 | 2024-06-09T06:10:22 | Tejpalsingh Siledar, Swaroop Nath, Sankara Sri Raghava Ravindra Muddu, Rupasai Rangaraju, Swaprava Nath, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Suman Banerjee, Amey Patil, Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh, Muthusamy Chelliah, Nikesh Garera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluation of opinion summaries using conventional reference-based metrics
rarely provides a holistic evaluation and has been shown to have a relatively
low correlation with human judgments. Recent studies suggest using Large
Language Models (LLMs) as reference-free metrics for NLG evaluation, however,
they remain unexplored for opinion summary evaluation. Moreover, limited
opinion summary evaluation datasets inhibit progress. To address this, we
release the SUMMEVAL-OP dataset covering 7 dimensions related to the evaluation
of opinion summaries: fluency, coherence, relevance, faithfulness, aspect
coverage, sentiment consistency, and specificity. We investigate Op-I-Prompt a
dimension-independent prompt, and Op-Prompts, a dimension-dependent set of
prompts for opinion summary evaluation. Experiments indicate that Op-I-Prompt
emerges as a good alternative for evaluating opinion summaries achieving an
average Spearman correlation of 0.70 with humans, outperforming all previous
approaches. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to investigate LLMs
as evaluators on both closed-source and open-source models in the opinion
summarization domain. | [
-0.671128511428833,
-0.5222601294517517,
0.8437607884407043,
0.22820445895195007,
-0.46259620785713196,
-0.23896129429340363,
-0.054578326642513275,
-0.04570280760526657,
0.47247156500816345,
0.628934919834137,
-0.5646328926086426,
-0.6348110437393188,
-0.42348548769950867,
0.468487948179245,
-0.09762280434370041,
1.3146692514419556,
0.20185784995555878,
0.11182627081871033,
-0.6264287233352661,
-0.28395044803619385,
-0.37855294346809387,
-0.5573915243148804,
-0.2641834020614624,
-0.356597363948822,
0.809853732585907,
0.5234518051147461,
0.6846063733100891,
0.4577694237232208,
0.5528666973114014,
0.1575746387243271,
-0.22409985959529877,
0.36963093280792236,
-0.3324306905269623,
0.06016470119357109,
-0.27128276228904724,
-0.2599014341831207,
-0.8763718605041504,
0.25658220052719116,
0.46734538674354553,
0.8598232269287109,
-0.09477334469556808,
0.29831910133361816,
0.0947747677564621,
0.8973902463912964,
-0.494957834482193,
0.1395321637392044,
-0.3932030200958252,
-0.08962295204401016,
0.270292192697525,
-0.2370007485151291,
-0.3194643259048462,
-0.7557570934295654,
0.4778347909450531,
-0.5543048977851868,
0.10014482587575912,
0.25103530287742615,
0.4478725492954254,
0.16823457181453705,
-0.37960517406463623,
-0.42848485708236694,
-0.384286105632782,
0.8120039105415344,
-0.8995986580848694,
0.011608337983489037,
0.24627575278282166,
0.02571854554116726,
0.02611038275063038,
-0.3381003737449646,
-0.44352373480796814,
-0.21862271428108215,
-0.18193916976451874,
0.46875810623168945,
-0.45021262764930725,
0.05064535513520241,
0.094893679022789,
0.495820015668869,
-0.4378429353237152,
0.19496232271194458,
-0.3647029995918274,
0.10108785331249237,
0.6508191823959351,
0.5721035003662109,
-0.08926626294851303,
-0.48584410548210144,
-0.35923629999160767,
0.11432429403066635,
-0.7782041430473328,
0.0329442024230957,
0.40875953435897827,
0.360453724861145,
-0.20572271943092346,
0.5318792462348938,
-0.18937095999717712,
0.6362293362617493,
0.0710577741265297,
-0.29038187861442566,
0.19376131892204285,
-0.3703826665878296,
-0.30917465686798096,
-0.08827877789735794,
1.237654685974121,
0.9669133424758911,
0.26921406388282776,
0.06148324906826019,
-0.013674666173756123,
-0.20168374478816986,
0.1720021814107895,
-0.7574942708015442,
0.07488633692264557,
0.21886970102787018,
-0.751704752445221,
-0.37994635105133057,
0.3148176372051239,
-0.8596052527427673,
-0.8283948302268982,
-0.44233548641204834,
0.3455859422683716,
-0.23141755163669586,
-0.19108332693576813,
0.1941021978855133,
-0.19353529810905457,
0.1746608316898346,
0.6302139759063721,
-0.5543314218521118,
0.11193536967039108,
0.7695097923278809,
0.9149831533432007,
-0.3920328915119171,
-0.24789562821388245,
-0.21811439096927643,
-0.5074829459190369,
-0.5848235487937927,
0.9561885595321655,
-0.5145794749259949,
-0.6090799570083618,
0.03926488384604454,
-0.09380213916301727,
0.05321546643972397,
-0.49784550070762634,
0.7637226581573486,
-0.2276419997215271,
0.6504366397857666,
-0.6848329305648804,
-0.629533052444458,
-0.4718259274959564,
0.17912644147872925,
-0.5480741262435913,
0.5913918018341064,
-0.07539649307727814,
-0.6189103126525879,
0.4049959182739258,
-0.5662708282470703,
-0.3159608840942383,
-0.1129969134926796,
-0.09023258090019226,
-0.3181479573249817,
0.3375053107738495,
0.3844013512134552,
0.613845705986023,
-0.6865374445915222,
0.043399978429079056,
-0.3968510627746582,
-0.23733776807785034,
0.18388469517230988,
-0.2858453392982483,
0.5830075144767761,
0.1716115027666092,
0.2761572599411011,
0.3767666816711426,
-0.7830629944801331,
-0.25114673376083374,
-0.10357493162155151,
-0.1305917650461197,
-0.5216323733329773,
-0.11913497745990753,
-0.5167574882507324,
0.08923857659101486,
0.23288632929325104,
-0.3413710594177246,
0.309160977602005,
-0.2582683861255646,
0.2476269155740738,
0.7632359266281128,
0.44598573446273804,
0.4655596911907196,
-0.5588377714157104,
0.7626737952232361,
0.04746048152446747,
0.12385723739862442,
-0.7263988256454468,
-0.47408372163772583,
-0.5768316388130188,
-0.2226763367652893,
0.19269037246704102,
0.5095599889755249,
-0.45981648564338684,
0.76268070936203,
-0.29369106888771057,
-0.6054506301879883,
-0.6011591553688049,
0.16220957040786743,
0.240889772772789,
0.5879903435707092,
0.23990942537784576,
-0.14248105883598328,
-0.31448227167129517,
-1.0505682229995728,
-0.2610988914966583,
-0.40624648332595825,
-0.16755078732967377,
0.19244186580181122,
0.41487640142440796,
0.27744925022125244,
1.0819439888000488,
-0.38900041580200195,
-0.27677425742149353,
-0.43717554211616516,
0.20628821849822998,
0.6706289052963257,
-0.09559077024459839,
0.6104012131690979,
-0.20416758954524994,
-0.1930810511112213,
-0.29237890243530273,
-0.9868788719177246,
-0.4474802017211914,
-0.11633914709091187,
0.14911504089832306,
0.01710347831249237,
0.5413694977760315,
-0.3704526722431183,
-0.059894900768995285,
0.34496980905532837,
-0.4105970859527588,
0.614262580871582,
-0.14743416011333466,
0.3633679747581482,
-1.0522217750549316,
-0.11895699799060822,
0.10076552629470825,
-0.1354282796382904,
-0.3820050060749054,
-0.19136802852153778,
-0.11138012260198593,
0.2410484403371811,
-0.23204633593559265,
0.5857875943183899,
-0.20560817420482635,
-0.07713240385055542,
-0.26972681283950806,
0.5431742072105408,
0.21976181864738464,
0.412366658449173,
-0.2397083342075348,
0.7115309834480286,
0.4335801601409912,
-0.6837210655212402,
0.3410307765007019,
0.30801787972450256,
-0.604317843914032,
0.8294598460197449,
-0.9930389523506165,
0.052857905626297,
-0.40477779507637024,
0.21739837527275085,
-1.0240802764892578,
-0.035426102578639984,
0.20603734254837036,
-0.36698228120803833,
-0.056970056146383286,
0.11069463193416595,
-0.4367620646953583,
-0.22888405621051788,
-0.7800461649894714,
-0.12449496984481812,
0.5808045864105225,
-0.5159783959388733,
0.7104164361953735,
0.24974791705608368,
-0.2870991826057434,
-0.6471250653266907,
-0.3903488516807556,
0.062172260135412216,
-0.38012808561325073,
-0.3090225160121918,
-0.21367675065994263,
-0.2073698341846466,
-0.6895130276679993,
-0.013491235673427582,
0.027632787823677063,
0.4583088755607605,
-0.06374456733465195,
0.3346722722053528,
0.2787880301475525,
-0.20580457150936127,
0.09567120671272278,
-0.12040107697248459,
-0.041022662073373795,
0.2661350667476654,
-0.015577433630824089,
0.28556957840919495,
-0.3566632568836212,
-0.27799078822135925,
-0.18548481166362762,
0.37748587131500244,
0.8958812952041626,
-0.19797152280807495,
0.48350346088409424,
0.19823184609413147,
0.056094009429216385,
-0.15634937584400177,
-0.4860091805458069,
-0.07041969895362854,
-0.347769558429718,
0.43633508682250977,
-0.20536521077156067,
-0.7413834929466248,
0.5879952311515808,
0.21651005744934082,
0.4027490019798279,
0.6147903800010681,
0.6933692693710327,
-0.15230874717235565,
0.9523762464523315,
0.3484179973602295,
-0.18988916277885437,
0.32166633009910583,
0.11542367190122604,
0.1490463763475418,
-0.8185086250305176,
-0.03520580381155014,
-0.40788534283638,
-0.12462972104549408,
-0.3743091821670532,
-0.08523955941200256,
0.7391380667686462,
0.28561392426490784,
0.042787935584783554,
-0.13489635288715363,
-0.19361072778701782,
0.6550031304359436,
0.42700254917144775,
0.10643613338470459,
0.39884814620018005,
-0.17484426498413086,
-0.24165822565555573,
0.07868120819330215,
-0.711370587348938,
-0.7482817769050598,
0.8990346193313599,
0.4366551339626312,
0.7718287110328674,
0.08642005920410156,
0.3069968819618225,
0.5784426927566528,
0.2875364422798157,
-1.097569227218628,
0.7202156782150269,
-0.24381037056446075,
-0.11056288331747055,
-0.23885008692741394,
-0.3607918322086334,
-0.695549488067627,
0.46872732043266296,
-0.3429703414440155,
-0.3906461000442505,
0.05870744585990906,
0.04679308831691742,
-0.6261803507804871,
0.34025800228118896,
-0.5492314696311951,
0.496236115694046,
0.05926750972867012,
-0.05738082900643349,
-0.12431073188781738,
-0.6339966058731079,
0.5977258682250977,
0.053962141275405884,
0.24230831861495972,
-0.28799715638160706,
-0.00900180172175169,
0.8134230375289917,
-0.5163194537162781,
0.8033078908920288,
0.03379944711923599,
-0.2763332426548004,
0.4345460832118988,
-0.032272160053253174,
0.14960472285747528,
-0.06435135751962662,
-0.2617822289466858,
0.37622326612472534,
-0.2867512106895447,
0.007030854932963848,
-0.7649213075637817,
0.6024253964424133,
-0.7510585784912109,
-0.6216503381729126,
-0.428261399269104,
-0.3584999740123749,
-0.2809493839740753,
-0.04785299673676491,
0.3388885259628296,
0.5069987773895264,
-0.3380514681339264,
0.34150710701942444,
0.5645939111709595,
-0.34470289945602417,
0.6353195905685425,
0.6034989953041077,
-0.46951618790626526,
-0.7813705801963806,
0.43230053782463074,
-0.04099859297275543,
0.27454903721809387,
0.4146456718444824,
0.6175855398178101,
-0.3780522048473358,
-0.2709258496761322,
-0.6865332126617432,
0.3099834620952606,
-1.003965973854065,
-0.36248064041137695,
-0.7654886841773987,
0.16659468412399292,
-0.2945028245449066,
-0.06288187205791473,
0.030479053035378456,
-0.524020254611969,
-0.18192517757415771,
-0.2599492073059082,
0.658557116985321,
1.1819037199020386,
0.043483901768922806,
0.3350922167301178,
-0.8296350836753845,
0.17610128223896027,
0.41754433512687683,
0.41340991854667664,
0.06791491061449051,
-0.639444887638092,
-0.10028518736362457,
-0.29024842381477356,
-0.05315642058849335,
-0.9546803832054138,
0.1584595888853073,
0.020351486280560493,
0.49191829562187195,
0.6489890217781067,
0.1661243438720703,
0.3018518090248108,
-0.34723785519599915,
1.2024730443954468,
0.34885478019714355,
-0.8636249303817749,
0.2890387773513794,
-0.5670718550682068,
0.5263912677764893,
0.5551287531852722,
0.2588666081428528,
-0.5950642824172974,
-0.42103564739227295,
-0.45703423023223877,
-0.674745500087738,
0.6257688999176025,
-0.14600694179534912,
-0.14529675245285034,
-0.14955833554267883,
0.3268437087535858,
0.44506895542144775,
0.38440242409706116,
-0.33374854922294617,
-0.419290691614151,
-0.2042161077260971,
-0.1414014995098114,
-0.14364662766456604,
-0.48872441053390503,
-0.023896345868706703,
0.1322726607322693,
0.5458030104637146,
-0.11685775965452194,
-0.048904914408922195,
0.20703186094760895,
0.06285963952541351,
-0.07505481690168381,
0.678147554397583,
0.8280565142631531,
0.8292691111564636,
-0.21835990250110626,
0.19606097042560577,
0.43448272347450256,
-0.20301368832588196,
-0.04685426503419876,
-0.4497736990451813,
-0.33215826749801636,
0.17956483364105225,
0.5860517621040344,
0.8098669648170471,
-0.05202966183423996,
-0.3085203170776367,
0.7021235227584839,
-0.20855261385440826,
-0.23797842860221863,
-0.17575910687446594,
-0.05534207820892334,
-0.11953027546405792,
-0.06060298904776573,
0.35442280769348145,
0.15666459500789642,
-0.02034197561442852,
-0.6168153285980225,
-0.05035976320505142,
0.3624691963195801,
-0.354596346616745,
-0.4232316017150879,
0.39131611585617065,
0.16916052997112274,
-0.0698011964559555,
0.06030777096748352,
-0.28562843799591064,
-0.3838670253753662,
0.42638084292411804,
0.125441774725914,
1.1022647619247437,
-0.17079207301139832,
0.19880005717277527,
0.44332003593444824,
0.3101198971271515,
-0.08053508400917053,
0.3662385642528534,
0.19734208285808563,
-0.6021543741226196,
-0.35909345746040344,
-0.591266930103302,
-0.7319709658622742,
0.22896434366703033,
-0.7789953947067261,
0.4622647762298584,
-0.5518271327018738,
0.039942242205142975,
-0.007816198281943798,
-0.3398590683937073,
-0.4398525357246399,
0.1319703608751297,
-0.03426487371325493,
0.7359963059425354,
-0.8385909795761108,
0.24745632708072662,
0.7705327868461609,
-0.45190975069999695,
-0.47739309072494507,
-0.23088102042675018,
0.2690722346305847,
-0.6472914218902588,
0.1381884664297104,
-0.12523745000362396,
-0.3968328535556793,
-0.43898794054985046,
-0.4912508428096771,
-0.4569970965385437,
0.7767965197563171,
0.06472685933113098,
-0.4257187247276306,
0.1360062211751938,
-0.1820550113916397,
0.5879148840904236,
-0.732110857963562,
0.6564766764640808,
0.570955216884613,
0.4428347647190094,
0.06034587323665619,
-0.9245241284370422,
-0.09347929805517197,
-0.15011067688465118,
-0.3129911422729492,
0.043088722974061966,
-0.6648945212364197,
0.8089863657951355,
-0.4768826365470886,
0.011034475639462471,
0.032873962074518204,
0.6776989102363586,
0.3329635262489319,
0.16493509709835052,
0.6604807376861572,
0.2456492930650711,
0.641431987285614,
-0.05269124358892441,
1.057375192642212,
-0.37139585614204407,
0.17275600135326385,
1.2197566032409668,
-0.2229657769203186,
0.775877833366394,
0.1337093561887741,
-0.20908257365226746,
0.5536753535270691,
0.5208253860473633,
-0.057837698608636856,
0.2557682991027832,
0.0938090980052948,
-0.033728841692209244,
-0.1754693239927292,
-0.30642881989479065,
-0.2659858763217926,
0.4671396017074585,
0.2688825726509094,
-0.5666293501853943,
-0.38359132409095764,
-0.08686332404613495,
0.280325323343277,
0.09277255088090897,
-0.7265361547470093,
1.1431214809417725,
0.23932355642318726,
-0.7651842832565308,
0.2340889275074005,
-0.20709030330181122,
0.6913211345672607,
-0.6951454281806946,
-0.0571042001247406,
-0.33914852142333984,
-0.01717700995504856,
-0.3208814561367035,
-0.9400892853736877,
-0.061772529035806656,
0.1577775776386261,
-0.4545668363571167,
-0.28361403942108154,
0.376138299703598,
-0.26894083619117737,
-0.40909403562545776,
0.018876496702432632,
0.7395719885826111,
0.27043387293815613,
-0.006199204362928867,
-0.2688736915588379,
-0.27775898575782776,
-0.08234027773141861,
-0.2865697741508484,
0.06605205684900284,
0.5493941307067871,
-0.05796171724796295,
0.3641427755355835,
0.42914098501205444,
0.18822801113128662,
-0.2328406721353531,
0.4497390389442444,
0.5721376538276672,
-0.7149587273597717,
-0.6242307424545288,
-1.1161305904388428,
0.2982063591480255,
-0.04457462206482887,
-0.6082308292388916,
1.0856940746307373,
0.4968721270561218,
0.32867059111595154,
-0.139262393116951,
1.0570868253707886,
0.31516894698143005,
0.8941696286201477,
-0.5682912468910217,
0.6659296751022339,
-0.45017194747924805,
0.3832987844944,
-0.39643532037734985,
-0.9002230763435364,
-0.1586412787437439,
0.46880942583084106,
-0.2890652120113373,
0.17043261229991913,
0.7812731266021729,
0.4779897928237915,
0.3350559175014496,
0.28641408681869507,
0.43819981813430786,
0.22883696854114532,
0.23927970230579376,
0.19958515465259552,
0.9575750231742859,
-0.12682941555976868,
0.3121669590473175,
0.19492144882678986,
-0.35508468747138977,
-0.2748602032661438,
-1.2097411155700684,
-1.1746329069137573,
-0.4742804765701294,
-0.28593844175338745,
-0.39901310205459595,
-0.3921358585357666,
1.4516575336456299,
0.3968312442302704,
-0.7904778122901917,
-0.20681717991828918,
0.22349195182323456,
0.21061581373214722,
-0.19986669719219208,
-0.2297780066728592,
0.4238088130950928,
-0.22352731227874756,
-0.5998091697692871,
0.39479562640190125,
0.46151202917099,
0.010708622634410858,
-0.4853435158729553,
0.12406884133815765,
0.3715406358242035,
0.2502986192703247,
0.8362710475921631,
-0.01072823815047741,
-1.0034258365631104,
-0.25549018383026123,
0.20503570139408112,
-0.031003853306174278,
0.06713840365409851,
1.061308741569519,
-0.6138947606086731,
0.41815274953842163,
0.7192787528038025,
0.12919865548610687,
-0.13161802291870117,
0.43419572710990906,
0.711448609828949,
-0.7625544667243958,
-0.2261381298303604,
0.10085661709308624,
0.6804971694946289,
0.33043572306632996,
-0.17028526961803436,
0.40976226329803467,
-0.06122281029820442,
-0.5665079355239868,
-0.4703601002693176,
0.2244483232498169,
-1.0934393405914307,
-0.21929503977298737,
1.4269260168075562,
-0.11699027568101883,
-0.0587945282459259,
-0.0410459004342556,
-0.19429510831832886,
-0.3244527280330658,
-0.680260181427002,
0.6785682439804077,
0.9244433045387268,
-0.4293070137500763,
-0.341415137052536,
-0.38085633516311646,
0.3698502480983734,
0.23922598361968994,
-0.9499961733818054,
0.36677730083465576,
0.7191707491874695,
0.09348376095294952,
0.3228369653224945,
0.5115088224411011,
-0.08704643696546555,
0.08152636885643005,
-0.15316085517406464,
-0.005952192936092615,
-0.2830493748188019,
-0.34074699878692627,
-0.8192848563194275,
0.32702961564064026,
-0.021964851766824722,
0.048851847648620605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11681v1 | Opening the black box of language acquisition | 2024-02-18T19:11:58 | 2024-02-18T19:11:58 | Jérôme Michaud, Anna Jon-and | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.NA, math.NA | Recent advances in large language models using deep learning techniques have
renewed interest on how languages can be learned from data. However, it is
unclear whether or how these models represent grammatical information from the
learned languages. In addition, the models must be pre-trained on large corpora
before they can be used. In this work, we propose an alternative, more
transparent and cognitively plausible architecture for learning language.
Instead of using deep learning, our approach uses a minimal cognitive
architecture based on sequence memory and chunking. The learning mechanism is
based on the principles of reinforcement learning. We test our architecture on
a number of natural-like toy languages. Results show that the model can learn
these artificial languages from scratch and extract grammatical information
that supports learning. Our study demonstrates the power of this simple
architecture and stresses the importance of sequence memory as a key component
of the language learning process. Since other animals do not seem to have a
faithful sequence memory, this may explain why only humans have developed
complex languages. | [
-0.22472518682479858,
-1.0631093978881836,
0.5970665216445923,
-0.017759451642632484,
-0.19970212876796722,
0.3709712028503418,
-0.5101459622383118,
-0.48206889629364014,
-0.01956246793270111,
0.3204502761363983,
-0.422992467880249,
-0.11759863793849945,
-0.385191947221756,
0.00421758322045207,
-0.06454041600227356,
0.9630683660507202,
0.34430551528930664,
-0.07579044997692108,
0.050033316016197205,
0.23002663254737854,
-0.5861526131629944,
-0.3834327757358551,
-0.7237274646759033,
-0.3517618179321289,
0.3594645857810974,
0.45826664566993713,
0.8275377750396729,
0.7888902425765991,
-0.014370023272931576,
0.4092794954776764,
0.15779542922973633,
0.19552433490753174,
-0.3105144798755646,
-0.19231277704238892,
-0.36656567454338074,
-0.7665443420410156,
-0.10003527253866196,
-0.176369309425354,
0.4768626391887665,
0.8213669061660767,
-0.26599785685539246,
-0.10152404010295868,
-0.21805597841739655,
0.7786940932273865,
-0.5211008191108704,
0.6047993302345276,
-0.6584217548370361,
0.25490301847457886,
-0.102613165974617,
-0.007490338757634163,
-0.6890153288841248,
-0.10715993493795395,
0.21142709255218506,
-0.731185257434845,
-0.08421914279460907,
0.01934659667313099,
0.7735118865966797,
-0.038464680314064026,
-0.1231956034898758,
-0.5615956783294678,
-0.918097734451294,
0.671596884727478,
-0.43941760063171387,
0.39936333894729614,
0.6177613139152527,
0.2861015200614929,
-0.15791009366512299,
-0.4652537703514099,
-0.5777640342712402,
-0.45236438512802124,
-0.11659105867147446,
-0.14784103631973267,
-0.18949967622756958,
-0.05015254765748978,
0.11370175331830978,
0.3424573540687561,
-0.6351917386054993,
0.05447088181972504,
-0.7187861204147339,
-0.01688217744231224,
0.5600315928459167,
-0.15524756908416748,
0.4982220232486725,
-0.2059032917022705,
-0.30965685844421387,
-0.2760769724845886,
-0.5093700885772705,
0.18520084023475647,
0.24977585673332214,
0.6636790633201599,
-0.16744737327098846,
0.4915548264980316,
0.03206142038106918,
0.5611449480056763,
0.22345004975795746,
0.03565739095211029,
0.36171725392341614,
0.0887829139828682,
-0.3249792456626892,
0.2843126952648163,
0.6912268996238708,
-0.41746971011161804,
0.4800930619239807,
-0.3822134733200073,
-0.30046209692955017,
0.3624654710292816,
0.8685166835784912,
-0.4846605658531189,
-0.18729758262634277,
0.29791000485420227,
-0.12462709844112396,
-0.23481835424900055,
0.004689494613558054,
-0.584273636341095,
0.024952130392193794,
-0.22267143428325653,
0.44421684741973877,
-0.8774973750114441,
-0.39744818210601807,
0.4550807476043701,
0.10051017999649048,
0.4141848385334015,
0.16844512522220612,
-1.0543806552886963,
0.5411869883537292,
0.9093797206878662,
0.37176263332366943,
0.018747424706816673,
-0.3339197337627411,
-0.6334864497184753,
-0.07231331616640091,
-0.7463460564613342,
0.5005844831466675,
-0.6743586659431458,
-0.17315030097961426,
0.12840835750102997,
0.1367827206850052,
0.09572454541921616,
-0.6911754608154297,
0.003812587121501565,
-0.754528820514679,
0.27824723720550537,
0.06405380368232727,
-0.4113982617855072,
-0.4426300525665283,
0.10640394687652588,
-0.622042179107666,
0.6662278771400452,
0.08597078919410706,
-0.19358249008655548,
0.24010133743286133,
-0.47379037737846375,
-0.7353867888450623,
0.2532637119293213,
-0.35537809133529663,
-0.34874972701072693,
0.4545518159866333,
-0.12014377862215042,
0.39605528116226196,
0.061553988605737686,
0.5657347440719604,
-0.20943506062030792,
-0.2845039963722229,
0.3365413248538971,
-0.24694764614105225,
0.5584198832511902,
0.43295371532440186,
-0.474980890750885,
-0.24067862331867218,
-0.7782968878746033,
-0.03344268351793289,
0.1800556480884552,
-0.5356221795082092,
-0.5332302451133728,
0.09307420253753662,
-0.3992707133293152,
0.34597206115722656,
0.19531036913394928,
-0.5880987048149109,
0.23984363675117493,
-0.5670246481895447,
0.48404660820961,
0.7254257798194885,
-0.3348093032836914,
0.7585485577583313,
-0.23617298901081085,
0.49238961935043335,
0.2792344093322754,
-0.2677125334739685,
-0.25678348541259766,
-0.2483672946691513,
-0.8110328912734985,
-0.18564169108867645,
0.24161125719547272,
0.5660628080368042,
-0.6672000885009766,
0.350648432970047,
-0.11360077559947968,
-0.05429894104599953,
-0.7001218199729919,
0.2869633436203003,
0.7594544291496277,
-0.037922900170087814,
0.15781159698963165,
-0.5575404167175293,
-0.5148470997810364,
-0.825546383857727,
0.08372735977172852,
-0.28529107570648193,
0.20587174594402313,
0.32737940549850464,
0.4160636067390442,
-0.08215183764696121,
0.5621410608291626,
-0.4450613856315613,
0.23286017775535583,
-0.38704538345336914,
0.04986294358968735,
0.16514012217521667,
0.6108309030532837,
0.09512195736169815,
-0.6323134303092957,
0.04820111766457558,
0.1999419778585434,
-0.7976500391960144,
0.6205348372459412,
-0.22560545802116394,
-0.2287425398826599,
0.3017975389957428,
0.5568021535873413,
-0.9714383482933044,
0.06540582329034805,
0.3572743833065033,
-0.281288743019104,
0.29320189356803894,
-0.37334439158439636,
-0.4009256064891815,
-0.7787516713142395,
-0.07290500402450562,
-0.2682258188724518,
-0.2799495756626129,
-0.7410274147987366,
0.14019714295864105,
0.126831516623497,
-0.0933079943060875,
-0.5057045817375183,
0.5249937772750854,
-0.5917301177978516,
-0.29259705543518066,
-0.27633851766586304,
-0.005521236453205347,
-0.11496300995349884,
0.8042982816696167,
0.4746098518371582,
0.4624820947647095,
0.4362576901912689,
-0.7627081274986267,
-0.2423257827758789,
0.22072440385818481,
-0.5161134600639343,
0.2240121215581894,
-0.31605690717697144,
0.2424505054950714,
-0.4786655306816101,
-0.1499866396188736,
-0.81841641664505,
-0.1301744431257248,
0.1716846376657486,
-0.47106391191482544,
0.6612560749053955,
0.16107085347175598,
-0.15441478788852692,
-0.07238730788230896,
0.06943492591381073,
0.25260403752326965,
0.7114369869232178,
-0.4809492826461792,
0.44430920481681824,
0.4075736701488495,
-0.13976022601127625,
-0.6489019989967346,
-0.6929988265037537,
-0.124439537525177,
-0.029755325987935066,
-0.2988400161266327,
0.09276410192251205,
-0.009636209346354008,
-0.3424389660358429,
0.09966615587472916,
-0.14634881913661957,
-0.26481908559799194,
0.27413538098335266,
0.12792900204658508,
0.19768041372299194,
-0.7261897325515747,
0.4500383734703064,
-0.27191442251205444,
0.05686798691749573,
-0.006655994802713394,
-0.6656884551048279,
0.6396541595458984,
-0.2867692708969116,
0.024113493040204048,
-0.0028298834804445505,
0.1405981034040451,
0.441837877035141,
-0.37604084610939026,
0.539174497127533,
0.19826069474220276,
-0.4325082302093506,
-0.6897042393684387,
-0.291708379983902,
-0.026753783226013184,
-0.497536301612854,
0.45357200503349304,
-0.4800069332122803,
-0.7760593295097351,
-0.012872117571532726,
-0.10237929970026016,
-0.07292768359184265,
0.03498530760407448,
0.4247128367424011,
-0.12483269721269608,
0.4155697226524353,
0.906314492225647,
-0.10325866937637329,
0.6383159160614014,
-0.3172839283943176,
0.15425699949264526,
-0.4268316626548767,
-0.27589359879493713,
-0.37604185938835144,
-0.08097508549690247,
-0.3650764524936676,
-0.5243673920631409,
-0.33074823021888733,
0.30133676528930664,
-0.43881550431251526,
0.5053386092185974,
-0.15968164801597595,
0.426028847694397,
0.6047009825706482,
0.29437950253486633,
0.4125147759914398,
0.2306952327489853,
-0.3566119074821472,
0.29764509201049805,
-0.6627582311630249,
-0.5561752915382385,
0.8835334181785583,
0.21133998036384583,
0.6232596635818481,
-0.01946895569562912,
0.7700217366218567,
0.17030368745326996,
-0.12185487151145935,
-0.7562664151191711,
0.40544891357421875,
-0.21855978667736053,
-0.5894566178321838,
-0.3614891767501831,
-0.1757098138332367,
-1.2327288389205933,
0.38222843408584595,
-0.09428375959396362,
-0.562206506729126,
0.3266098201274872,
-0.059112198650836945,
-0.46499398350715637,
0.17519082129001617,
-0.7911434173583984,
0.9719054698944092,
-0.6176271438598633,
-0.40417560935020447,
-0.29251235723495483,
-0.5037833452224731,
0.5387909412384033,
-0.18758997321128845,
0.46255946159362793,
0.13811305165290833,
-0.11713571846485138,
0.3102896809577942,
-0.3347323536872864,
1.0578032732009888,
-0.0055234902538359165,
0.011371253058314323,
0.20596306025981903,
0.5021135807037354,
0.3616432249546051,
-0.01264938898384571,
0.10986596345901489,
-0.12343372404575348,
-0.42526474595069885,
-0.5775287747383118,
-0.5478920936584473,
0.2944793999195099,
-0.9532957077026367,
-0.5219704508781433,
-0.5627819299697876,
-0.4760444760322571,
-0.22889435291290283,
0.13567234575748444,
-0.3245454728603363,
0.1784752607345581,
-0.44308799505233765,
0.09117238968610764,
0.6772378087043762,
-0.5046947598457336,
0.5897833704948425,
0.7549604773521423,
-0.13709335029125214,
-0.20710040628910065,
0.9572068452835083,
-0.30369916558265686,
0.4852812886238098,
0.7029892802238464,
0.2375056892633438,
-0.19012580811977386,
-0.6571088433265686,
-0.47117385268211365,
0.22934117913246155,
-0.3130144774913788,
0.08545983582735062,
-0.5880968570709229,
-0.11841876059770584,
-0.030579740181565285,
-0.21132723987102509,
-0.47455349564552307,
-0.32242026925086975,
-0.09640280157327652,
-0.4530898332595825,
0.1199570819735527,
1.011304497718811,
-0.02547617442905903,
0.2607458233833313,
-0.7538244128227234,
0.35194751620292664,
0.3752131760120392,
0.1574118286371231,
0.09561854600906372,
-0.1460113674402237,
-0.281709760427475,
0.16696901619434357,
-0.15288282930850983,
-0.5152961015701294,
0.563256025314331,
0.3359493911266327,
0.44563668966293335,
0.3695971965789795,
-0.18027785420417786,
0.7580681443214417,
-0.7511091232299805,
0.586128294467926,
0.1123480498790741,
-0.8862026929855347,
0.4179125130176544,
-0.15818561613559723,
0.3128846287727356,
0.46950116753578186,
0.365546852350235,
-0.386527955532074,
-0.37733039259910583,
-0.9717828631401062,
-0.4803638160228729,
0.8963270783424377,
-0.1892794519662857,
0.23865634202957153,
-0.35496774315834045,
0.20759457349777222,
0.3142684996128082,
0.5906643867492676,
-0.7731888890266418,
0.04926668107509613,
-0.1351000815629959,
-0.09870228916406631,
-0.6897317171096802,
-0.009421051479876041,
0.15472130477428436,
-0.02733897790312767,
0.3769439160823822,
-0.10134996473789215,
0.19051019847393036,
0.005386270582675934,
-0.47513332962989807,
-0.11442775279283524,
0.5296609401702881,
0.4165111780166626,
0.38654839992523193,
-0.03342236950993538,
0.1720147728919983,
-0.20544642210006714,
-0.4331352412700653,
0.23269090056419373,
-0.2085702270269394,
-0.3438233435153961,
-0.11202752590179443,
0.3004501760005951,
0.9754800796508789,
0.6411680579185486,
-0.9697034358978271,
0.4820495545864105,
0.2842855155467987,
-0.007211845368146896,
-0.3923567533493042,
0.033960890024900436,
0.3554634749889374,
0.36182403564453125,
-0.04563219100236893,
0.10333317518234253,
-0.11421514302492142,
-1.1704721450805664,
0.6002576947212219,
0.5314088463783264,
-0.4386803209781647,
-0.5347468256950378,
0.3837614953517914,
-0.14815694093704224,
-0.4513023793697357,
0.7675467133522034,
-0.33885812759399414,
-0.2142874300479889,
0.6190213561058044,
0.789250373840332,
0.8145760893821716,
-0.22046220302581787,
0.6493797302246094,
0.2374853491783142,
0.42745134234428406,
-0.18530631065368652,
0.38376349210739136,
-0.20238633453845978,
-0.7574743032455444,
-0.492022305727005,
-0.9582744240760803,
-0.11885762959718704,
0.19808228313922882,
-0.5096423625946045,
0.14441826939582825,
-0.7843260169029236,
0.324722021818161,
0.011524886824190617,
0.09929342567920685,
-0.6453531384468079,
0.21067509055137634,
0.5741355419158936,
0.9209311008453369,
-0.7520582675933838,
1.129340648651123,
0.5435587763786316,
-0.5683632493019104,
-0.8896179795265198,
-0.35907402634620667,
-0.2791244387626648,
-1.0391533374786377,
0.7781569361686707,
0.086851105093956,
0.09945422410964966,
-0.16671933233737946,
-0.5033125281333923,
-0.7625576853752136,
0.6346262097358704,
0.3359133303165436,
-0.5253228545188904,
-0.29152819514274597,
0.11159436404705048,
0.5308318138122559,
-0.6093190312385559,
0.12557727098464966,
0.5526039600372314,
0.2573586404323578,
0.050105754286050797,
-0.47757473587989807,
0.15930920839309692,
-0.2885241210460663,
-0.03455129638314247,
0.21361367404460907,
-0.4432089626789093,
1.1342827081680298,
-0.24481771886348724,
-0.4127592444419861,
0.05749422311782837,
0.6642005443572998,
0.1292193979024887,
0.06763143837451935,
0.32982271909713745,
0.48664477467536926,
0.911941409111023,
0.16862480342388153,
1.065623164176941,
0.08132488280534744,
-0.10587108135223389,
1.2165862321853638,
-0.24046899378299713,
1.1899574995040894,
0.2545175552368164,
-0.17153984308242798,
0.8635077476501465,
0.3930724263191223,
0.13772498071193695,
0.5944060683250427,
0.4786151349544525,
0.0194998849183321,
-0.32646694779396057,
0.21915793418884277,
-0.05443128943443298,
0.4988847076892853,
0.6821132302284241,
-0.35181158781051636,
-0.2089669108390808,
0.08697596937417984,
0.11816267669200897,
0.17250187695026398,
-0.29604750871658325,
1.0171687602996826,
0.231504425406456,
-0.9293753504753113,
0.613213837146759,
-0.20095370709896088,
0.6228607296943665,
-0.7317726016044617,
-0.1537380963563919,
-0.12101680785417557,
0.29919710755348206,
-0.10928764194250107,
-0.34820401668548584,
0.10384371876716614,
-0.1452791541814804,
0.023340212181210518,
-0.14438872039318085,
0.40635180473327637,
-0.6690468788146973,
-0.47370412945747375,
0.360967218875885,
0.7872588634490967,
0.2884334325790405,
0.16231955587863922,
-0.5630261301994324,
-0.1872420608997345,
-0.13293249905109406,
-0.07019288837909698,
0.39013808965682983,
0.5107245445251465,
-0.10743261128664017,
0.5662023425102234,
0.7493973970413208,
0.2381683737039566,
0.4540378749370575,
-0.43464723229408264,
0.5755406618118286,
-0.8966296911239624,
-0.5868144035339355,
-0.7951564788818359,
0.48889321088790894,
0.1868721842765808,
-0.08723597973585129,
0.48361262679100037,
0.5530593991279602,
1.298140525817871,
-0.34870633482933044,
0.8228244781494141,
-0.031944818794727325,
0.09138669073581696,
-0.5952627062797546,
0.32216188311576843,
-0.47055771946907043,
0.13737840950489044,
-0.24308769404888153,
-0.6031771302223206,
-0.0402480773627758,
0.6312357783317566,
-0.20138853788375854,
-0.26735636591911316,
0.8949248194694519,
0.6874904036521912,
-0.2211998701095581,
0.14583224058151245,
0.532709002494812,
0.5245782136917114,
-0.011516817845404148,
0.870901882648468,
0.99448162317276,
-0.2185661345720291,
0.6060808897018433,
-0.382254958152771,
-0.07895021140575409,
0.052271272987127304,
-0.5641106963157654,
-0.8299612402915955,
-0.36212870478630066,
-0.17633506655693054,
-0.344226598739624,
0.41108375787734985,
1.033974289894104,
0.7124370336532593,
-0.813171923160553,
-0.5937173962593079,
-0.25879988074302673,
0.1047591045498848,
-0.41461941599845886,
-0.1181648001074791,
0.21137045323848724,
-0.8437412977218628,
-0.7803232073783875,
0.6916357278823853,
0.30842524766921997,
-0.0322469063103199,
-0.2675161361694336,
-0.1551685929298401,
-0.344422310590744,
0.20896299183368683,
0.6472514271736145,
0.8581876158714294,
-0.63892662525177,
-0.23551180958747864,
-0.018193325027823448,
-0.26995816826820374,
0.3525904417037964,
0.8420088887214661,
-1.0308693647384644,
0.4295349717140198,
0.27972614765167236,
0.9667905569076538,
0.6154378056526184,
-0.2634526491165161,
0.8763390183448792,
-0.5456030368804932,
0.4475414752960205,
0.11224179714918137,
0.20744161307811737,
0.12540021538734436,
-0.36949622631073,
0.2583546042442322,
-0.029922926798462868,
-0.02604721114039421,
-0.5653338432312012,
0.31689688563346863,
-0.9133859276771545,
-0.646479606628418,
0.8181864619255066,
-0.08507887274026871,
-0.7567298412322998,
-0.26768699288368225,
-0.05484984442591667,
0.04710754379630089,
-0.44649553298950195,
0.6234416365623474,
0.5839115977287292,
0.2537931501865387,
-0.026662174612283707,
-0.7891064882278442,
0.5545615553855896,
0.3096400797367096,
-0.6870517730712891,
-0.13118530809879303,
0.43886974453926086,
0.2630453407764435,
0.37062591314315796,
0.7340223789215088,
-0.2748716473579407,
0.43771326541900635,
0.09294424206018448,
0.15159453451633453,
0.022439390420913696,
-0.6576590538024902,
-0.7503966689109802,
0.2877788543701172,
0.21389321982860565,
-0.3727450668811798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11676v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11676v2 | A Multi-Aspect Framework for Counter Narrative Evaluation using Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T18:56:07 | 2024-03-29T15:01:38 | Jaylen Jones, Lingbo Mo, Eric Fosler-Lussier, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Counter narratives - informed responses to hate speech contexts designed to
refute hateful claims and de-escalate encounters - have emerged as an effective
hate speech intervention strategy. While previous work has proposed automatic
counter narrative generation methods to aid manual interventions, the
evaluation of these approaches remains underdeveloped. Previous automatic
metrics for counter narrative evaluation lack alignment with human judgment as
they rely on superficial reference comparisons instead of incorporating key
aspects of counter narrative quality as evaluation criteria. To address prior
evaluation limitations, we propose a novel evaluation framework prompting LLMs
to provide scores and feedback for generated counter narrative candidates using
5 defined aspects derived from guidelines from counter narrative specialized
NGOs. We found that LLM evaluators achieve strong alignment to human-annotated
scores and feedback and outperform alternative metrics, indicating their
potential as multi-aspect, reference-free and interpretable evaluators for
counter narrative evaluation. | [
-0.5378950238227844,
-0.6537213921546936,
0.7022656202316284,
-0.03776656463742256,
-0.25936877727508545,
0.3403003513813019,
0.005057403817772865,
-0.4696817994117737,
0.281473308801651,
0.4850028455257416,
-0.6379806995391846,
-0.45218712091445923,
-0.7265575528144836,
0.08857188373804092,
-0.5488042235374451,
1.3687396049499512,
-0.026266884058713913,
0.2338271290063858,
-0.14299586415290833,
-0.5350080132484436,
-0.46141594648361206,
-0.5169783234596252,
-0.4708867371082306,
-0.5428134799003601,
0.7079986929893494,
0.28932613134384155,
0.5145094990730286,
0.34428536891937256,
0.24788212776184082,
0.23026323318481445,
0.35025790333747864,
0.035987723618745804,
-0.5236210823059082,
0.09983500093221664,
-0.54095858335495,
-0.19639672338962555,
-0.42500191926956177,
0.47139182686805725,
0.466115266084671,
0.13787932693958282,
-0.07779223471879959,
0.4324117600917816,
0.04898136109113693,
0.4009830951690674,
-0.6041982173919678,
-0.4913288354873657,
-0.621764063835144,
-0.000057214710977859795,
-0.06778020411729813,
0.03762765973806381,
-0.20724636316299438,
-0.3892129063606262,
0.22149664163589478,
-0.31941598653793335,
0.3291260302066803,
-0.14435622096061707,
0.36220782995224,
0.10501638054847717,
-0.4146212637424469,
-0.5388168096542358,
-0.8202100992202759,
0.9573835730552673,
-0.8328249454498291,
0.11041783541440964,
0.10369788855314255,
0.08786109834909439,
0.21025234460830688,
-0.3315344452857971,
-0.7296574711799622,
-0.21017327904701233,
-0.10142042487859726,
0.38871872425079346,
-0.5639646649360657,
-0.07704135030508041,
-0.11607275903224945,
0.28125429153442383,
-0.6536470055580139,
0.42880770564079285,
-0.12909163534641266,
-0.28980720043182373,
0.8546563982963562,
0.5122784376144409,
0.15303727984428406,
-0.233210951089859,
-0.6281565427780151,
0.2557860314846039,
-0.7841365337371826,
-0.0981539934873581,
0.6864849328994751,
0.29878807067871094,
-0.29304710030555725,
0.39712759852409363,
-0.11340835690498352,
0.5896768569946289,
0.25689733028411865,
-0.2809647023677826,
0.042886704206466675,
-0.42458173632621765,
-0.09949100017547607,
0.21777945756912231,
1.0747268199920654,
0.7785324454307556,
0.32639071345329285,
-0.15669509768486023,
-0.17016065120697021,
0.3800358772277832,
0.9251705408096313,
-0.8172104954719543,
0.2685375213623047,
0.1925577074289322,
-0.4730508029460907,
-0.5741451382637024,
-0.1332354098558426,
-1.2395750284194946,
-0.7294979095458984,
-0.2987021505832672,
0.49018242955207825,
-0.17695069313049316,
-0.23385697603225708,
-0.5048853158950806,
-0.21449944376945496,
-0.01294473372399807,
0.22222524881362915,
-0.4804603159427643,
0.2818746566772461,
0.5829381942749023,
0.8099730014801025,
-0.3914775252342224,
-0.21519768238067627,
-0.6848079562187195,
0.07195425033569336,
-0.3920319974422455,
0.691038191318512,
-0.8604174256324768,
-0.3552692234516144,
0.06674972921609879,
-0.1749390959739685,
0.12115930765867233,
-0.4896048903465271,
0.5524848699569702,
-0.24114693701267242,
0.23095569014549255,
0.0022853866685181856,
-0.28296980261802673,
-0.32098865509033203,
0.46168115735054016,
-0.3968450725078583,
0.7826907634735107,
0.19682148098945618,
-0.5577263832092285,
0.400588721036911,
-0.39321279525756836,
-0.5147987008094788,
-0.0762823149561882,
-0.23780590295791626,
-0.4981660544872284,
0.2991485893726349,
0.27270182967185974,
0.016202617436647415,
-0.5294716358184814,
0.5300699472427368,
-0.10813004523515701,
-0.3324669897556305,
0.000502322509419173,
-0.6250253915786743,
0.5594133138656616,
0.12167216837406158,
-0.6324732899665833,
0.7858005166053772,
-0.7529885768890381,
-0.21512195467948914,
0.0976589247584343,
-0.0334453321993351,
-0.24582454562187195,
-0.22444967925548553,
-0.14891555905342102,
0.0811917707324028,
-0.02141874097287655,
-0.7869616150856018,
-0.17084774374961853,
-0.45381155610084534,
0.052869152277708054,
0.7902901768684387,
0.028548238798975945,
0.014278952963650227,
-0.6429335474967957,
0.9282053709030151,
-0.08978498727083206,
0.05073023587465286,
-0.13083787262439728,
-0.41006237268447876,
-0.6008076667785645,
-0.03682279214262962,
-0.3278045356273651,
0.6678689122200012,
-0.7402786016464233,
0.31610846519470215,
0.008685775101184845,
-0.9619135856628418,
-0.4815640449523926,
0.09792447090148926,
0.9216004014015198,
0.782301127910614,
0.6714491248130798,
-0.5838296413421631,
-0.9242504239082336,
-0.9126310348510742,
-0.465800017118454,
-0.48523595929145813,
-0.04490566626191139,
0.059541214257478714,
0.533338725566864,
0.022593433037400246,
1.1229355335235596,
-0.05981392413377762,
-0.15679562091827393,
-0.42936471104621887,
0.6219356656074524,
0.025439292192459106,
0.3861768841743469,
0.5936812162399292,
-0.5280000567436218,
-0.2852276563644409,
-0.5032083988189697,
-0.5662441253662109,
-0.5148290395736694,
-0.24268414080142975,
0.19366265833377838,
0.13418669998645782,
0.1332894265651703,
-0.15263724327087402,
0.5704454779624939,
0.6718822717666626,
-0.28469353914260864,
0.9746285676956177,
0.3421500027179718,
0.6379337310791016,
-0.7586012482643127,
-0.05637867748737335,
0.1129169836640358,
-0.12279776483774185,
-0.838875412940979,
-0.11971434950828552,
-0.23980097472667694,
-0.026210147887468338,
-0.5864294767379761,
0.6289440393447876,
0.1011035293340683,
0.21256431937217712,
-0.21002978086471558,
0.4002766013145447,
0.15136079490184784,
0.4401647448539734,
0.13966324925422668,
0.41568708419799805,
-0.0012262423988431692,
-0.48035505414009094,
0.5435611009597778,
-0.04029254615306854,
-0.45056310296058655,
1.4539999961853027,
-0.5387222170829773,
0.41581106185913086,
-0.03169328346848488,
0.3020860552787781,
-0.9147319793701172,
0.37697485089302063,
0.4611780047416687,
-0.26301857829093933,
0.14803878962993622,
-0.25362759828567505,
-0.11618685722351074,
-0.45483672618865967,
-0.6608079075813293,
0.4134323298931122,
-0.0013357086572796106,
-0.17871738970279694,
0.48520341515541077,
0.30181294679641724,
-0.11042077839374542,
-0.5506377816200256,
-0.6174800395965576,
0.2727517783641815,
-0.5681976675987244,
-0.08203721046447754,
0.24174274504184723,
-0.29657113552093506,
-0.38771066069602966,
-0.08683385699987411,
-0.07851415872573853,
0.15505743026733398,
-0.1936958283185959,
0.2883527874946594,
0.08074916154146194,
-0.2054799199104309,
-0.17604629695415497,
0.04677174240350723,
-0.06045514717698097,
0.12671518325805664,
-0.16116127371788025,
0.4000466465950012,
0.12786300480365753,
-0.5042659640312195,
-0.2046707272529602,
0.44458943605422974,
0.4696979522705078,
-0.0869581550359726,
0.5612271428108215,
0.7617104053497314,
-0.25994136929512024,
0.2781127393245697,
-0.7478326559066772,
0.10266109555959702,
-0.313193678855896,
0.48895588517189026,
-0.22994327545166016,
-0.8629685044288635,
0.2888273596763611,
0.3172285258769989,
0.259033203125,
0.5833238959312439,
0.832374095916748,
0.24651308357715607,
0.6762443780899048,
0.23415975272655487,
-0.11556820571422577,
0.1833663433790207,
0.2876712381839752,
0.24908147752285004,
-0.8663502931594849,
-0.11716309934854507,
-0.5557171702384949,
-0.2958190143108368,
-0.06905990093946457,
-0.40933898091316223,
0.402874231338501,
0.1766936331987381,
-0.4573437571525574,
0.28966274857521057,
-0.5762457847595215,
0.21415336430072784,
0.12135810405015945,
-0.15009024739265442,
0.3494220972061157,
-0.26120030879974365,
-0.16431795060634613,
-0.34396079182624817,
-0.3461781144142151,
-0.6590375304222107,
0.9654437899589539,
0.3133529722690582,
0.5026936531066895,
0.33654898405075073,
0.4613865613937378,
0.49357953667640686,
1.0221984386444092,
-0.7429084777832031,
0.4125118851661682,
-0.11428454518318176,
-0.6585100293159485,
-0.4587780833244324,
-0.2751227915287018,
-0.5601193308830261,
0.5106158256530762,
-0.3139301836490631,
-1.0498003959655762,
-0.023741085082292557,
-0.03674007207155228,
-0.6127835512161255,
0.44166359305381775,
-0.5338401794433594,
0.791709840297699,
-0.40631014108657837,
-0.23079805076122284,
-0.466665118932724,
-0.27184465527534485,
0.3631763756275177,
-0.34235846996307373,
0.4748246967792511,
-0.18417766690254211,
-0.014599040150642395,
0.9865238666534424,
-0.37748125195503235,
1.1860932111740112,
-0.2765834927558899,
-0.28643307089805603,
0.4198070764541626,
0.22282585501670837,
0.10863262414932251,
-0.08754359185695648,
-0.37836211919784546,
0.44487085938453674,
-0.09188806265592575,
-0.0007037086179479957,
-0.5238478183746338,
0.6030264496803284,
-0.4167170524597168,
-0.8531056642532349,
-0.13214555382728577,
-0.6975307464599609,
-0.3953350782394409,
0.2554037868976593,
0.16495651006698608,
0.49787724018096924,
-0.8393732309341431,
-0.04903798550367355,
0.1101137325167656,
-0.5745904445648193,
0.31547364592552185,
0.9293955564498901,
-0.3589756488800049,
-0.728633463382721,
0.7754146456718445,
0.17081817984580994,
0.28336992859840393,
0.24220982193946838,
0.5490328669548035,
-0.2684054970741272,
-0.6373737454414368,
-0.9316075444221497,
-0.09715808182954788,
-0.38602834939956665,
-0.3996168076992035,
-0.5915693640708923,
-0.09569186717271805,
-0.6789305806159973,
-0.32263946533203125,
-0.25038567185401917,
-0.030311834067106247,
0.1862569898366928,
-0.17054808139801025,
0.30595681071281433,
1.1255934238433838,
-0.33816179633140564,
0.4709646999835968,
-0.5957310199737549,
0.5920761823654175,
0.21369296312332153,
0.17710208892822266,
0.28364527225494385,
-0.8418685793876648,
-0.2499687820672989,
0.06087416037917137,
-0.44230133295059204,
-1.1365426778793335,
0.2962583899497986,
-0.22359125316143036,
0.5734474062919617,
0.3244234323501587,
0.2788445055484772,
0.7783909440040588,
-0.6303761601448059,
0.8144354820251465,
0.47523462772369385,
-0.9532245397567749,
0.6768544912338257,
-0.15591326355934143,
0.5828526616096497,
0.44977906346321106,
0.5233514308929443,
-0.6180203557014465,
-0.828133225440979,
-0.5337737202644348,
-0.7501778602600098,
0.6409738659858704,
-0.017607009038329124,
0.20391476154327393,
-0.010881658643484116,
-0.14974598586559296,
0.26432085037231445,
0.4499540627002716,
-0.5960161089897156,
-0.18212543427944183,
-0.4843292534351349,
-0.3653346002101898,
-0.05735531076788902,
-0.5306841731071472,
-0.5255403518676758,
-0.09010355919599533,
0.5870456695556641,
0.04114997386932373,
-0.38120555877685547,
0.1775968372821808,
-0.1891338974237442,
-0.27177631855010986,
0.5609978437423706,
0.5851148366928101,
0.9306003451347351,
0.06134049966931343,
0.18406051397323608,
0.3863997161388397,
-0.3917597532272339,
0.2709846794605255,
0.02738295868039131,
-0.31120526790618896,
-0.06041261553764343,
0.7200870513916016,
0.6041805148124695,
0.24846111238002777,
-0.4408295154571533,
0.49526703357696533,
0.018208462744951248,
-0.08621057868003845,
-0.28905826807022095,
-0.09952322393655777,
-0.0435304120182991,
0.34770452976226807,
0.3320647180080414,
-0.2652598023414612,
-0.06449581682682037,
-0.5378292202949524,
0.3354143500328064,
0.3945465385913849,
-0.7974216938018799,
-0.12130539864301682,
0.37584182620048523,
0.26426994800567627,
-0.534824788570404,
0.2222423255443573,
-0.1419004499912262,
-0.6583619117736816,
0.5679665207862854,
0.6371123194694519,
0.8278526067733765,
-0.6681894063949585,
0.4199286997318268,
0.48943203687667847,
0.6420843005180359,
0.6749984622001648,
-0.039785757660865784,
0.12830223143100739,
-0.7498674988746643,
-0.32834944128990173,
-0.8784687519073486,
-0.39558154344558716,
0.5832420587539673,
-0.6759620904922485,
-0.010945308953523636,
-0.5254223942756653,
0.17389369010925293,
-0.1250615417957306,
-0.023750431835651398,
-0.4631275236606598,
0.34339645504951477,
0.2483522593975067,
0.5677802562713623,
-0.8068219423294067,
0.4197871685028076,
0.374240517616272,
-0.4596281349658966,
-0.44199278950691223,
0.034157294780015945,
0.7024430632591248,
-0.7482273578643799,
0.2641911506652832,
0.3676868677139282,
-0.6249892115592957,
-0.3951144218444824,
-0.19199040532112122,
-0.46480265259742737,
0.5580723285675049,
0.19359445571899414,
-0.8774628639221191,
0.3828509449958801,
0.3200761377811432,
0.814680278301239,
-0.7184695601463318,
0.542457640171051,
0.6717669367790222,
0.5223208069801331,
-0.0858660563826561,
-1.0191017389297485,
0.2923522889614105,
0.034721676260232925,
-0.2645637094974518,
-0.05305614694952965,
-0.5424185395240784,
0.2654561698436737,
-0.01319719199091196,
-0.15006251633167267,
0.16307085752487183,
0.47172093391418457,
0.24803422391414642,
0.4456178545951843,
0.7919825911521912,
0.6404719352722168,
0.4137903153896332,
0.17819638550281525,
0.8356124758720398,
-0.034264907240867615,
-0.059053290635347366,
1.4635494947433472,
-0.31274932622909546,
0.47140708565711975,
0.23194347321987152,
-0.15237663686275482,
0.6455398201942444,
0.09047412127256393,
-0.011749206110835075,
0.260031133890152,
0.506971538066864,
-0.3010435700416565,
-0.1382753551006317,
-0.6200240254402161,
0.05106580629944801,
0.6743893027305603,
0.3053026795387268,
-0.23191289603710175,
-0.39590024948120117,
-0.044174905866384506,
0.16824808716773987,
0.5522634387016296,
-0.42138180136680603,
0.7367584705352783,
0.06990969181060791,
-0.6779030561447144,
0.24737510085105896,
0.03282525762915611,
0.6733026504516602,
-0.4687611162662506,
-0.16545778512954712,
0.03589978069067001,
-0.08874361962080002,
-0.2987862527370453,
-0.8507493138313293,
0.7328742742538452,
0.5430511236190796,
-0.2609736919403076,
-0.2767540514469147,
0.40501081943511963,
-0.44920578598976135,
-0.37924036383628845,
0.3930065631866455,
0.3528069853782654,
0.1195298433303833,
-0.10471165180206299,
-0.8362460136413574,
0.16687104105949402,
-0.08763989061117172,
-0.23067137598991394,
0.30823564529418945,
0.20086003839969635,
-0.32417118549346924,
0.18397754430770874,
0.511305570602417,
0.06216498836874962,
-0.4446617066860199,
0.6083716750144958,
0.5413530468940735,
-0.6967403292655945,
-0.3451085090637207,
-1.0508992671966553,
0.4654538333415985,
-0.025434479117393494,
-0.49399152398109436,
0.571519672870636,
0.7109560966491699,
0.8411107063293457,
0.3913918435573578,
0.7981746792793274,
-0.06823144108057022,
0.9574217796325684,
-0.4010293781757355,
0.6551702618598938,
-0.3990115523338318,
0.05805988982319832,
-0.5368162989616394,
-0.7803394794464111,
0.05567091330885887,
0.3075062036514282,
-0.47712841629981995,
-0.08539778739213943,
0.586012065410614,
0.7843745946884155,
0.18672247231006622,
0.06959938257932663,
0.44954562187194824,
0.27542009949684143,
0.48058146238327026,
0.37522652745246887,
0.8770418763160706,
-0.2599875032901764,
0.6392152309417725,
-0.046334829181432724,
-0.26758790016174316,
0.21494150161743164,
-1.0375829935073853,
-0.7593816518783569,
-0.3554740846157074,
-0.1480533480644226,
-0.29666391015052795,
0.13630789518356323,
0.5153858065605164,
0.4853087365627289,
-0.8754932284355164,
-0.23728644847869873,
0.4683119058609009,
0.2818806767463684,
-0.07533435523509979,
-0.2822226583957672,
0.09105119109153748,
0.12192176282405853,
-0.7401110529899597,
0.675459086894989,
0.542203426361084,
-0.4152340590953827,
-0.5947670936584473,
-0.2062327265739441,
-0.3885026276111603,
0.33149757981300354,
0.6597802639007568,
0.028643837198615074,
-1.018854022026062,
-0.5553218126296997,
-0.6602182388305664,
-0.06287755072116852,
-0.08574514091014862,
1.2119373083114624,
-0.9009401798248291,
0.38205021619796753,
0.049324486404657364,
0.5204725861549377,
0.25992530584335327,
0.09250783175230026,
0.7995421290397644,
-0.8012276291847229,
0.25361505150794983,
0.3575061857700348,
0.08600981533527374,
0.27259591221809387,
-0.3251267671585083,
0.5598108768463135,
0.17793689668178558,
-0.0926266759634018,
-0.6455838084220886,
0.5829459428787231,
-0.4872118830680847,
-0.26530852913856506,
0.9556987881660461,
-0.33948656916618347,
0.225087508559227,
-0.39495086669921875,
-0.009230510331690311,
0.3637898564338684,
-0.26152583956718445,
0.721413254737854,
0.8174001574516296,
-0.22834961116313934,
-0.19464798271656036,
-0.28046467900276184,
0.2684069871902466,
0.4913158416748047,
-0.7457355856895447,
0.0016338108107447624,
0.6976458430290222,
-0.056260403245687485,
0.33804911375045776,
0.8082249760627747,
-0.2676595449447632,
0.08884494006633759,
-0.03819238767027855,
0.04703042656183243,
-0.0178819727152586,
-0.3608875870704651,
-0.31890493631362915,
0.06490856409072876,
-0.27679482102394104,
0.3528556525707245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11671v1 | Autocorrect for Estonian texts: final report from project EKTB25 | 2024-02-18T18:20:57 | 2024-02-18T18:20:57 | Agnes Luhtaru, Martin Vainikko, Krista Liin, Kais Allkivi-Metsoja, Jaagup Kippar, Pille Eslon, Mark Fishel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The project was funded in 2021-2023 by the National Programme of Estonian
Language Technology. Its main aim was to develop spelling and grammar
correction tools for the Estonian language. The main challenge was the very
small amount of available error correction data needed for such development. To
mitigate this, (1) we annotated more correction data for model training and
testing, (2) we tested transfer-learning, i.e. retraining machine learning
models created for other tasks, so as not to depend solely on correction data,
(3) we compared the developed method and model with alternatives, including
large language models. We also developed automatic evaluation, which can
calculate the accuracy and yield of corrections by error category, so that the
effectiveness of different methods can be compared in detail.
There has been a breakthrough in large language models during the project:
GPT4, a commercial language model with Estonian-language support, has been
created. We took into account the existence of the model when adjusting plans
and in the report we present a comparison with the ability of GPT4 to improve
the Estonian language text.
The final results show that the approach we have developed provides better
scores than GPT4 and the result is usable but not entirely reliable yet. The
report also contains ideas on how GPT4 and other major language models can be
implemented in the future, focusing on open-source solutions.
All results of this project are open-data/open-source, with licenses that
allow them to be used for purposes including commercial ones. | [
-0.05444848909974098,
-0.7588204741477966,
0.6086391806602478,
-0.0743522197008133,
-0.22353164851665497,
-0.02394721284508705,
-0.3536171615123749,
-0.6392655372619629,
0.027046745643019676,
0.4945126473903656,
0.16100811958312988,
-0.7031528353691101,
-0.598022997379303,
0.5312910079956055,
-0.6007888317108154,
0.5155357718467712,
-0.5310738682746887,
0.26299333572387695,
0.012596683576703072,
-0.1282445341348648,
-0.6519924998283386,
-0.8583193421363831,
-0.5439777970314026,
0.18872115015983582,
0.4066999852657318,
0.7742916941642761,
0.3556603193283081,
0.8287454843521118,
0.5616288185119629,
0.3676411807537079,
-0.08788125216960907,
-0.2835913300514221,
-0.02956809289753437,
-0.013761906884610653,
0.018414275720715523,
-0.6690554618835449,
-0.46315714716911316,
-0.10860168933868408,
0.7007685899734497,
0.10241740196943283,
-0.31808334589004517,
0.1135483980178833,
-0.09056501090526581,
0.6491931676864624,
-0.3929402232170105,
0.2948886752128601,
-0.5060521364212036,
-0.08195763826370239,
-0.37660759687423706,
0.4170559048652649,
-0.45743218064308167,
-0.4169781804084778,
-0.19724582135677338,
-0.2765345573425293,
0.10894425213336945,
0.09410683065652847,
0.9268035888671875,
0.12384641915559769,
-0.46297717094421387,
-0.5270708799362183,
-0.7651844620704651,
0.644861102104187,
-0.6852407455444336,
0.5160499811172485,
0.6785481572151184,
0.17957767844200134,
0.02912840247154236,
-0.7942839860916138,
-0.554396390914917,
-0.29526379704475403,
-0.08493023365736008,
0.22893565893173218,
-0.21441121399402618,
0.19741611182689667,
-0.07738807052373886,
0.5651553273200989,
-0.361641526222229,
0.13073286414146423,
-0.6544848680496216,
-0.16890306770801544,
0.43938806653022766,
0.06028272584080696,
0.12280082702636719,
-0.31752580404281616,
0.09133685380220413,
-0.04907316714525223,
-0.5063145756721497,
-0.22627267241477966,
0.6752231121063232,
0.16375304758548737,
0.05586211755871773,
0.8300828337669373,
-0.3110984265804291,
0.4999872148036957,
0.12820163369178772,
0.4917074143886566,
0.3697432279586792,
-0.5585618019104004,
-0.2826569080352783,
0.07435930520296097,
0.684371829032898,
0.13449358940124512,
0.10643354058265686,
-0.092527836561203,
-0.41127651929855347,
0.2391224056482315,
0.237868070602417,
-0.3205951452255249,
-0.4310639798641205,
0.2408834844827652,
-0.4816238284111023,
-0.326909601688385,
-0.2061270922422409,
-0.5891419649124146,
0.2500267028808594,
-0.4939362704753876,
0.7097769975662231,
-0.4893353581428528,
-0.17191077768802643,
0.10958842188119888,
0.05275711044669151,
-0.05514194071292877,
0.29050779342651367,
-0.8958845138549805,
0.2377834916114807,
0.4293946921825409,
0.79319828748703,
0.036834005266427994,
-0.30799272656440735,
-0.3407037556171417,
0.025059597566723824,
-0.48041844367980957,
0.9169377088546753,
-0.3622562885284424,
-0.5002925395965576,
-0.029326120391488075,
0.2126452624797821,
0.053314946591854095,
-0.4409466087818146,
0.8969570398330688,
-0.18944405019283295,
0.6058208346366882,
-0.32002297043800354,
-0.6581432223320007,
-0.10001647472381592,
-0.08868149667978287,
-0.5665799975395203,
1.2688764333724976,
0.14011773467063904,
-0.3611602783203125,
0.3001149892807007,
-0.7820307016372681,
-0.3338419795036316,
0.24145609140396118,
0.17118653655052185,
-0.49820199608802795,
0.12972812354564667,
-0.07679730653762817,
0.23552395403385162,
-0.12432092428207397,
0.1257576197385788,
0.18572962284088135,
0.0016112857265397906,
-0.3093407154083252,
-0.2140832394361496,
0.43407154083251953,
0.14477862417697906,
-0.5818440914154053,
0.10566917061805725,
-0.7577662467956543,
0.11893461644649506,
-0.0832812562584877,
-0.6390920281410217,
-0.23109173774719238,
-0.30965039134025574,
0.28001371026039124,
0.10128681361675262,
0.2590346038341522,
-0.7993659973144531,
0.08024321496486664,
-0.2395372986793518,
0.5148442387580872,
0.7659511566162109,
-0.39292478561401367,
0.4033064544200897,
0.016206542029976845,
0.5493980050086975,
0.015635160729289055,
0.44550055265426636,
-0.19786450266838074,
-0.6333116292953491,
-0.9850483536720276,
-0.05406947061419487,
0.865242063999176,
0.6126805543899536,
-0.5156704783439636,
0.5444767475128174,
0.20847219228744507,
-0.7695484757423401,
-0.6753147840499878,
-0.0777091383934021,
0.6440608501434326,
0.5639786124229431,
0.46862202882766724,
-0.6034445762634277,
-0.7875198721885681,
-1.0089588165283203,
-0.28941309452056885,
-0.4576471745967865,
0.26960527896881104,
0.14982497692108154,
0.48389682173728943,
-0.23761272430419922,
0.559506356716156,
-0.2383035570383072,
-0.5825144052505493,
0.15169423818588257,
0.3579552173614502,
0.131710022687912,
0.4346690773963928,
0.40772855281829834,
-0.6611039042472839,
-0.8762617707252502,
0.08851779997348785,
-0.3986046016216278,
-0.17296603322029114,
0.5765510201454163,
-0.14404700696468353,
0.8655861020088196,
0.5379992723464966,
-0.5861694812774658,
0.5281566381454468,
0.5826098918914795,
-0.6794643998146057,
0.7897727489471436,
-0.4495943784713745,
0.370662659406662,
-0.8925700783729553,
0.27009010314941406,
-0.33607083559036255,
-0.40943440794944763,
-0.4671226441860199,
-0.15492947399616241,
0.35550573468208313,
0.20072875916957855,
-0.4092259705066681,
0.43875211477279663,
-0.604633092880249,
0.1852787435054779,
-0.07109653949737549,
-0.21224389970302582,
-0.4287068247795105,
0.13668031990528107,
-0.13870124518871307,
0.8910354971885681,
0.3497459590435028,
-0.4132689833641052,
0.5708857774734497,
0.5692216157913208,
-0.29388073086738586,
0.6468265652656555,
-0.42050600051879883,
0.37850913405418396,
-0.1579291671514511,
-0.011156877502799034,
-0.9116241931915283,
-0.16033273935317993,
0.21013645827770233,
-0.6316656470298767,
0.36804327368736267,
-0.2726724445819855,
-0.5494367480278015,
-0.4550885558128357,
0.1088719367980957,
0.025276875123381615,
0.7285573482513428,
-0.2272050976753235,
0.7040821313858032,
0.6353666186332703,
-0.3037070631980896,
-0.23965278267860413,
-0.5956678986549377,
0.6226077675819397,
-0.16863103210926056,
-0.3898875117301941,
0.1599387228488922,
-0.19804422557353973,
-0.23845499753952026,
0.32024481892585754,
0.19097837805747986,
-0.22013911604881287,
-0.15727609395980835,
-0.01228755246847868,
0.23056186735630035,
-0.34656596183776855,
0.22890198230743408,
-0.16235338151454926,
-0.22936654090881348,
-0.13407596945762634,
-0.4908270239830017,
0.3553224205970764,
-0.37260159850120544,
-0.046065475791692734,
-0.20780062675476074,
0.26880431175231934,
0.42177802324295044,
-0.2653217315673828,
0.5872167348861694,
0.32668986916542053,
-0.34916529059410095,
0.15218061208724976,
-0.8518648743629456,
0.13484933972358704,
-0.48689448833465576,
0.2541179656982422,
-0.3403150737285614,
-0.6592140793800354,
0.3905736207962036,
0.34300675988197327,
0.10681205987930298,
0.758837103843689,
0.636371374130249,
-0.1521863043308258,
0.6613273024559021,
0.6238840222358704,
-0.018895816057920456,
0.4039444625377655,
0.04184442758560181,
0.023351559415459633,
-0.5338627099990845,
-0.21381045877933502,
-0.8200789093971252,
-0.1310964673757553,
-0.49979493021965027,
-0.2301352322101593,
0.19816163182258606,
-0.029052289202809334,
0.3483287990093231,
0.7404987215995789,
-0.4556499123573303,
0.479381263256073,
0.7857778072357178,
-0.06360610574483871,
0.45419517159461975,
-0.07005017250776291,
-0.5058249831199646,
-0.11518651247024536,
-0.6374872922897339,
-0.5911797285079956,
1.2786152362823486,
0.2758427858352661,
0.3113715648651123,
0.11105363070964813,
0.7138599753379822,
0.32218435406684875,
0.222421795129776,
-0.5658948421478271,
0.376834899187088,
-0.4695613384246826,
-0.6515458822250366,
-0.6813233494758606,
-0.10409291088581085,
-0.9676403999328613,
-0.09238746017217636,
-0.10292648524045944,
-0.33031490445137024,
0.21257741749286652,
0.4866202473640442,
-0.0692170038819313,
0.17572613060474396,
-1.0579190254211426,
0.7503144145011902,
-0.16921475529670715,
-0.22546489536762238,
-0.3934849500656128,
-0.5720176696777344,
-0.03460704907774925,
-0.3759848475456238,
0.31930795311927795,
0.08800473809242249,
0.09580391645431519,
0.628862202167511,
-0.5311865210533142,
0.5463499426841736,
-0.0930129662156105,
-0.20188894867897034,
0.3989127576351166,
-0.07089272141456604,
0.5890131592750549,
-0.40625157952308655,
-0.08312574774026871,
0.37353870272636414,
0.0706482082605362,
-0.2582225203514099,
-0.022361649200320244,
0.4955480992794037,
-0.5334831476211548,
-0.3229382634162903,
-0.41350802779197693,
-0.17310333251953125,
-0.021525857970118523,
0.4318130910396576,
0.3560677170753479,
0.45886313915252686,
-0.4265436828136444,
0.26605480909347534,
0.5127283334732056,
-0.14762668311595917,
0.4938138723373413,
0.5800365805625916,
-0.20239339768886566,
-0.7325484156608582,
0.48087796568870544,
0.3598153591156006,
0.24361149966716766,
0.2614472508430481,
0.10895515233278275,
-0.3706125020980835,
-0.5232393741607666,
-0.5976898074150085,
0.34962916374206543,
-0.8040138483047485,
-0.05336449667811394,
-0.7436791658401489,
0.01953037455677986,
-0.6381960511207581,
0.11320081353187561,
-0.5635519027709961,
-0.6992399096488953,
-0.16321507096290588,
-0.17132380604743958,
0.4809196889400482,
1.0925571918487549,
-0.3418775200843811,
0.3098990023136139,
-0.7771849632263184,
0.2239183783531189,
0.011447002179920673,
0.6537368297576904,
-0.2961079180240631,
-0.3873392939567566,
-0.5504953861236572,
-0.1428757905960083,
-0.32048299908638,
-0.7174016833305359,
0.38374510407447815,
0.17318864166736603,
0.261142373085022,
-0.43895453214645386,
-0.2959928512573242,
0.471000999212265,
-0.8772396445274353,
0.6892575621604919,
0.03614634647965431,
-1.14485502243042,
0.4127040505409241,
-0.41856202483177185,
0.4198656678199768,
0.5274127125740051,
0.00882475171238184,
-0.9522296786308289,
-0.4707854986190796,
-0.9058325886726379,
-0.9929448366165161,
0.6067296862602234,
0.39611703157424927,
-0.07236073166131973,
-0.04244508594274521,
0.5689816474914551,
0.12707795202732086,
0.2987731397151947,
-0.35861915349960327,
-0.17233535647392273,
0.05391373112797737,
-0.6124851703643799,
-0.22837652266025543,
-0.4911417067050934,
0.31042951345443726,
-0.22915789484977722,
1.0903185606002808,
0.1642507016658783,
0.4159221947193146,
0.342520534992218,
-0.17005538940429688,
-0.49867257475852966,
0.18666163086891174,
0.5225599408149719,
0.6983227133750916,
0.05944669246673584,
-0.08772505074739456,
0.33416372537612915,
-0.927843451499939,
0.1735461950302124,
0.153062641620636,
-0.13326767086982727,
0.5365674495697021,
0.07235158234834671,
0.6646050810813904,
0.16165122389793396,
-0.3567345142364502,
0.3361024558544159,
-0.24962668120861053,
-0.45717236399650574,
-0.6615272164344788,
-0.24913562834262848,
0.016734842211008072,
0.08861600607633591,
0.2787380814552307,
-0.06404128670692444,
0.09440938383340836,
-0.38461920619010925,
0.2612127959728241,
0.2227298766374588,
-0.2146524041891098,
-0.49492117762565613,
0.8498036861419678,
0.39572134613990784,
-0.5121278762817383,
0.45441576838493347,
0.20341798663139343,
-0.6323145031929016,
0.6521331071853638,
0.19830580055713654,
1.006554126739502,
-0.833060622215271,
0.2028593271970749,
0.4817030727863312,
0.5904960632324219,
-0.3617285192012787,
0.6900092363357544,
0.29813966155052185,
-0.2703079283237457,
-0.3808230459690094,
-0.4788457155227661,
-0.38008448481559753,
0.13740220665931702,
-0.3995157778263092,
0.9254361987113953,
-0.17905215919017792,
-0.24198253452777863,
-0.1984945684671402,
-0.22228123247623444,
-0.7411626577377319,
0.476744681596756,
-0.13606342673301697,
0.8608137369155884,
-0.7887417674064636,
0.7915116548538208,
0.6972557306289673,
-0.1855299174785614,
-0.8271742463111877,
-0.29087120294570923,
-0.2600260078907013,
-0.5869598388671875,
0.6098548769950867,
-0.1267019808292389,
0.13153059780597687,
0.33644384145736694,
-0.43030694127082825,
-1.1345478296279907,
0.8238905668258667,
0.18782205879688263,
-0.9609925150871277,
-0.15202859044075012,
0.233530193567276,
0.6259179711341858,
0.11361206322908401,
0.15977948904037476,
0.4733574390411377,
0.763024091720581,
-0.18319688737392426,
-1.5555912256240845,
-0.33224156498908997,
-0.12174655497074127,
-0.25402408838272095,
0.6822035908699036,
-0.5368226170539856,
0.7613792419433594,
0.19200527667999268,
-0.13634724915027618,
0.263343870639801,
0.6895045042037964,
-0.4323238134384155,
0.007352741435170174,
0.3533891439437866,
0.7577148675918579,
0.6691744923591614,
-0.14685848355293274,
0.7920612692832947,
-0.36789169907569885,
0.3716066777706146,
0.8844801187515259,
0.06296937167644501,
0.9178511500358582,
0.4400675594806671,
-0.26438698172569275,
0.23199622333049774,
0.4795871078968048,
-0.06603438407182693,
0.42958134412765503,
-0.06698885560035706,
-0.07537723332643509,
0.08775852620601654,
0.2100227028131485,
-0.29764237999916077,
0.483295738697052,
0.028851976618170738,
-0.5097437500953674,
0.06725313514471054,
0.012111927382647991,
0.12965701520442963,
0.06133538857102394,
-0.12883222103118896,
0.7582709789276123,
0.026362182572484016,
-0.6551774144172668,
0.382291704416275,
0.3245195746421814,
0.5543677806854248,
-0.5054025650024414,
-0.09353271126747131,
-0.16903378069400787,
0.4302334487438202,
-0.11095957458019257,
-0.6517249345779419,
0.5359752774238586,
0.1873275637626648,
-0.015826363116502762,
-0.1473502814769745,
0.5648899078369141,
-0.8111463785171509,
-0.6352592706680298,
0.0006312885088846087,
0.26869523525238037,
0.30317074060440063,
0.11636777222156525,
-0.35363587737083435,
-0.040519971400499344,
-0.04427160322666168,
-0.008376715704798698,
-0.0869733989238739,
0.5247995853424072,
-0.1297977864742279,
0.3690217435359955,
0.4380229115486145,
0.35711413621902466,
0.28810495138168335,
-0.30023807287216187,
0.3992614150047302,
-0.6333035230636597,
-0.7077333927154541,
-0.7453868985176086,
0.6198200583457947,
0.19594353437423706,
-0.48045113682746887,
0.9142791032791138,
0.7587059140205383,
0.9452911615371704,
-0.20472513139247894,
1.0064202547073364,
-0.1303277462720871,
0.7124081254005432,
-0.6820515990257263,
0.6501668095588684,
-0.17978353798389435,
-0.1527489721775055,
-0.3055325746536255,
-0.9371262788772583,
-0.3300408124923706,
0.35707956552505493,
-0.1257137954235077,
-0.14354370534420013,
1.0796315670013428,
0.4792403280735016,
0.050932876765728,
0.02391815185546875,
0.3793966472148895,
0.6563098430633545,
0.17727446556091309,
0.23334601521492004,
0.4796324074268341,
-0.6724638938903809,
0.46327444911003113,
-0.23001308739185333,
-0.21170848608016968,
-0.20249073207378387,
-0.8585339784622192,
-0.5123236775398254,
-1.0024538040161133,
-0.3384940028190613,
-0.43837711215019226,
0.5879068374633789,
0.8025415539741516,
0.3240912854671478,
-0.8875453472137451,
-0.4035261273384094,
-0.253791481256485,
-0.4255303740501404,
0.15349772572517395,
-0.0851643905043602,
0.37856531143188477,
-0.16296343505382538,
-0.8984127640724182,
0.16244395077228546,
0.1179574579000473,
0.11071716248989105,
-0.12907442450523376,
0.06488163769245148,
-0.3209836184978485,
-0.0894598662853241,
0.46153613924980164,
0.13683359324932098,
-0.531221330165863,
-0.3855796158313751,
0.07669351249933243,
-0.0010129630099982023,
0.30899322032928467,
0.5040556192398071,
-0.6634151935577393,
0.5826140642166138,
0.363794207572937,
0.29553157091140747,
0.3872152268886566,
-0.17581167817115784,
0.9535385966300964,
-0.33799007534980774,
-0.05003335326910019,
0.12437567859888077,
0.33756697177886963,
0.5273756384849548,
-0.6630755066871643,
0.6836996078491211,
0.224168598651886,
-0.9049641489982605,
-0.7183350920677185,
-0.07878296822309494,
-0.2050820291042328,
0.00816168263554573,
1.196475625038147,
0.15493710339069366,
-0.3261050283908844,
-0.32314786314964294,
-0.596608579158783,
0.34339144825935364,
-0.4065825045108795,
0.9793384671211243,
1.1825017929077148,
0.14868491888046265,
-0.11392123997211456,
-0.6425959467887878,
0.6294819116592407,
0.5679879784584045,
-0.7933276295661926,
0.03882186487317085,
0.7461720705032349,
0.2621925473213196,
-0.08648223429918289,
0.5435896515846252,
-0.33530229330062866,
0.333778977394104,
-0.28768450021743774,
0.5520648956298828,
-0.030819837003946304,
-0.3117270767688751,
-0.7171918749809265,
-0.3389180302619934,
0.2919650971889496,
-0.20281465351581573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11656v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11656v2 | Integrating Pre-Trained Language Model with Physical Layer Communications | 2024-02-18T17:27:51 | 2024-06-28T23:00:45 | Ju-Hyung Lee, Dong-Ho Lee, Joohan Lee, Jay Pujara | cs.IT | cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP, math.IT | The burgeoning field of on-device AI communication, where devices exchange
information directly through embedded foundation models, such as language
models (LMs), requires robust, efficient, and generalizable communication
frameworks. However, integrating these frameworks with existing wireless
systems and effectively managing noise and bit errors pose significant
challenges. In this work, we introduce a practical ondevice AI communication
framework, integrated with physical layer (PHY) communication functions,
demonstrated through its performance on a link-level simulator. Our framework
incorporates end-to-end training with channel noise to enhance resilience,
incorporates vector quantized variational autoencoders (VQ-VAE) for efficient
and robust communication, and utilizes pre-trained encoder-decoder transformers
for improved generalization capabilities. Simulations, across various
communication scenarios, reveal that our framework achieves a 50% reduction in
transmission size while demonstrating substantial generalization ability and
noise robustness under standardized 3GPP channel models. | [
-0.43065690994262695,
-0.8469275832176208,
0.25486546754837036,
0.3653744161128998,
-0.30556485056877136,
0.05852871015667915,
-0.0767759382724762,
-0.807152271270752,
0.044317957013845444,
0.2251180112361908,
-0.26487496495246887,
-0.24123644828796387,
-0.2348061352968216,
-0.3811708092689514,
-0.18284395337104797,
0.4353008270263672,
-0.18237687647342682,
-0.21714791655540466,
-0.15977774560451508,
0.15938864648342133,
-0.10397122800350189,
-0.5435715913772583,
-0.5996133089065552,
-0.3361704349517822,
-0.020213311538100243,
0.036719910800457,
0.5072663426399231,
0.36560073494911194,
0.3684365749359131,
0.2504809498786926,
0.003784129163250327,
0.11569767445325851,
-0.09370150417089462,
0.07005640119314194,
-0.0353727713227272,
-0.2559678256511688,
-0.7339494228363037,
0.009511073119938374,
0.5241664052009583,
0.6413219571113586,
-0.3540074825286865,
-0.14740794897079468,
-0.13578353822231293,
0.3721112906932831,
-0.6462661027908325,
0.19812169671058655,
-0.4657694697380066,
0.24597232043743134,
0.2910030484199524,
-0.16360707581043243,
-0.396684855222702,
0.20102177560329437,
0.32008588314056396,
-0.5851839780807495,
-0.3628520965576172,
-0.14950306713581085,
0.971735417842865,
0.3324970304965973,
-0.2320212572813034,
0.030385121703147888,
-1.2356839179992676,
0.5447009801864624,
-0.8258081078529358,
0.7189764380455017,
0.727043867111206,
0.19180850684642792,
0.10654003918170929,
-0.7384814620018005,
-0.6179907917976379,
-0.4867428243160248,
0.243688702583313,
0.22696614265441895,
-0.2111610770225525,
0.5020277500152588,
-0.06503523886203766,
0.42166370153427124,
-0.2827151119709015,
0.20941311120986938,
-0.143024742603302,
-0.1256200224161148,
0.40664103627204895,
-0.24054594337940216,
0.22339797019958496,
0.4254230558872223,
-0.11226320266723633,
0.15041132271289825,
-0.5681036710739136,
-0.12958000600337982,
0.31306424736976624,
-0.026337992399930954,
-0.632957398891449,
0.2866175174713135,
-0.29561299085617065,
0.7998539805412292,
0.38865500688552856,
-0.19464285671710968,
0.29276567697525024,
-0.5149653553962708,
-0.3429420292377472,
0.010754127986729145,
0.8453983068466187,
0.004358816891908646,
0.07182779908180237,
-0.4353463649749756,
-0.20541144907474518,
0.04044622927904129,
0.3913947641849518,
-0.7924426794052124,
-0.4298815429210663,
0.30195605754852295,
-0.6105786561965942,
-0.26775750517845154,
-0.08388116955757141,
-0.3202717900276184,
0.013743946328759193,
0.09592469036579132,
0.28700512647628784,
-0.33499303460121155,
-0.570768415927887,
0.5388895869255066,
0.21546302735805511,
0.45519158244132996,
0.2501186430454254,
-1.097442388534546,
0.4023342728614807,
0.2273779958486557,
0.7054058909416199,
0.4402497112751007,
-0.2856101095676422,
-0.45323964953422546,
0.5663497447967529,
-0.20783084630966187,
0.5317910313606262,
-0.23667261004447937,
-0.5389710068702698,
-0.3139934539794922,
-0.22005705535411835,
-0.07631703466176987,
-0.33700236678123474,
0.3123342990875244,
-0.3066590428352356,
0.1291991025209427,
0.445346862077713,
-0.2539035379886627,
0.2984786927700043,
0.18389274179935455,
-0.41625523567199707,
0.5140329599380493,
0.16153939068317413,
-0.5129334330558777,
-0.01615389809012413,
-0.6582369804382324,
-0.7221384644508362,
0.08515141904354095,
-0.15050005912780762,
-0.6203706860542297,
0.18351860344409943,
0.1845788210630417,
0.46710532903671265,
-0.36316460371017456,
-0.07397400587797165,
-0.18967726826667786,
-0.36217013001441956,
0.014263121411204338,
-0.4857698380947113,
0.4896603226661682,
0.41771820187568665,
-0.7133822441101074,
-0.018739812076091766,
-1.0367283821105957,
0.16880834102630615,
-0.10801705718040466,
-0.3379286229610443,
-0.2964683175086975,
-0.020643021911382675,
-0.16337350010871887,
0.17788970470428467,
0.17321614921092987,
-0.8474020957946777,
0.0642596036195755,
-0.425395131111145,
0.7264019846916199,
0.20116399228572845,
-0.14563214778900146,
0.7941641807556152,
-0.11560703814029694,
0.39621540904045105,
0.029194816946983337,
0.3553979694843292,
-0.1988336592912674,
-0.5483843684196472,
-0.46687042713165283,
-0.4019092619419098,
0.19356822967529297,
0.6802979111671448,
-0.8507205843925476,
0.7807564735412598,
-0.28828150033950806,
-0.512546956539154,
-0.6640746593475342,
0.07058446109294891,
0.3355635106563568,
0.550560474395752,
0.4123099744319916,
-0.33453717827796936,
-0.14625196158885956,
-0.5985590219497681,
0.14286693930625916,
-0.6176171898841858,
-0.20589733123779297,
0.5051258206367493,
-0.08304022997617722,
-0.5177424550056458,
0.6583200097084045,
0.2411099672317505,
0.032317884266376495,
-0.30182114243507385,
0.1921282410621643,
-0.3218529522418976,
0.8757220506668091,
0.49071478843688965,
-0.6361732482910156,
-0.08722449839115143,
0.33911508321762085,
-0.6875672340393066,
-0.1624240279197693,
-0.25334304571151733,
0.08923201262950897,
-0.05239283666014671,
0.44807517528533936,
-0.8236909508705139,
0.6644518375396729,
0.7070083618164062,
-0.23767511546611786,
0.29072004556655884,
-0.5647892355918884,
0.3135247528553009,
-0.9694989323616028,
-0.13629408180713654,
0.1589645892381668,
-0.23561307787895203,
-0.6403372883796692,
-0.08101384341716766,
-0.01944214291870594,
-0.2881491780281067,
-0.6284629106521606,
0.3282737731933594,
-0.4308941066265106,
-0.26434820890426636,
-0.21938511729240417,
-0.1674744188785553,
0.2033667266368866,
0.21754899621009827,
0.12044534832239151,
0.7327377200126648,
0.6248029470443726,
-0.76246577501297,
0.442954957485199,
-0.08874250203371048,
0.015290082432329655,
0.60300612449646,
-1.0739880800247192,
0.012656016275286674,
0.030502481386065483,
0.2813296318054199,
-0.5170843005180359,
0.05626634880900383,
0.31922924518585205,
-0.3519524037837982,
0.2337820827960968,
-0.15636329352855682,
-0.3646054267883301,
-0.18600082397460938,
-0.3001757264137268,
0.6663568019866943,
0.5571458339691162,
-0.46668094396591187,
0.896106481552124,
0.5799299478530884,
0.27479901909828186,
-0.18422545492649078,
-0.9505097270011902,
-0.09398651123046875,
-0.020599622279405594,
-0.7854558825492859,
0.6153873801231384,
-0.19314469397068024,
0.03537354618310928,
0.06489869207143784,
0.03408470377326012,
-0.24782240390777588,
0.4017389118671417,
0.3484642505645752,
-0.0389723964035511,
-0.2926434874534607,
-0.1122782975435257,
0.17362171411514282,
0.05546996742486954,
0.1940961331129074,
-0.554039478302002,
0.7582347989082336,
-0.3158979117870331,
-0.6677409410476685,
-0.9561725854873657,
0.28805679082870483,
0.46522256731987,
-0.3126574158668518,
0.816987931728363,
0.5894989967346191,
-0.4171619713306427,
-0.2368965446949005,
-0.21776260435581207,
-0.22520600259304047,
-0.5441576838493347,
0.5694156885147095,
-0.7061564326286316,
-0.6989517211914062,
0.36083054542541504,
-0.3286181390285492,
-0.193413645029068,
0.020169895142316818,
0.10898265242576599,
-0.38987937569618225,
1.0859434604644775,
0.7013663649559021,
-0.21406283974647522,
0.5709818601608276,
-0.2970591187477112,
0.46259015798568726,
-0.7365524172782898,
-0.3847567141056061,
-0.26567116379737854,
-0.007709144614636898,
-0.4300287365913391,
-0.6334106922149658,
0.03843327611684799,
0.5281277298927307,
-0.6983600854873657,
0.10618875920772552,
-0.4489322304725647,
0.28580936789512634,
0.3760879933834076,
0.24280507862567902,
0.10561374574899673,
0.3601340055465698,
0.2217792421579361,
0.17793938517570496,
-0.8443225026130676,
-0.3847533166408539,
0.8339530229568481,
0.9463514089584351,
0.9992676973342896,
0.05996686592698097,
0.46159806847572327,
0.02334395982325077,
0.2520827054977417,
-0.49747395515441895,
0.48107776045799255,
0.026360467076301575,
0.02408638969063759,
-0.1737913340330124,
-0.5596610307693481,
-0.5128737688064575,
-0.02400404028594494,
-0.14255088567733765,
-0.8832533955574036,
0.36783862113952637,
0.15917910635471344,
-0.37424421310424805,
0.5491617918014526,
-0.5250247120857239,
0.5299628376960754,
-0.24216590821743011,
-0.24197396636009216,
-0.16086073219776154,
-0.5657899379730225,
0.18658757209777832,
0.1914588212966919,
0.07354698330163956,
0.05311425402760506,
0.015456109307706356,
0.507776141166687,
-0.4433307349681854,
0.7903484106063843,
-0.09787987917661667,
-0.29610273241996765,
0.47412532567977905,
-0.08677522838115692,
0.3842597007751465,
0.13527512550354004,
0.1047227755188942,
0.3617329001426697,
-0.22145259380340576,
-0.4290115535259247,
-0.43622222542762756,
0.5617783665657043,
-1.2831287384033203,
-0.19126883149147034,
0.06400957703590393,
-0.4300377666950226,
-0.3355731666088104,
-0.11870822310447693,
0.23566393554210663,
0.5769190192222595,
-0.049965593963861465,
0.19114813208580017,
0.7856916189193726,
-0.4488386809825897,
0.3171025812625885,
0.36054500937461853,
-0.20040583610534668,
-0.35344934463500977,
1.176477074623108,
-0.37508493661880493,
0.5823273658752441,
0.24221159517765045,
-0.09466417878866196,
-0.042390454560518265,
-0.47494131326675415,
-0.6469094753265381,
0.10342885553836823,
-0.5000563859939575,
-0.102664053440094,
-0.8361676335334778,
-0.7841262221336365,
-0.332265704870224,
-0.25724858045578003,
-0.7769275903701782,
-0.13554242253303528,
-0.3119947016239166,
-0.17024189233779907,
-0.06649979203939438,
0.6886652708053589,
-0.19204357266426086,
0.8268199563026428,
-0.7584853172302246,
0.3170475363731384,
0.2626414895057678,
0.4483800232410431,
-0.022051533684134483,
-0.5617512464523315,
-0.5350562334060669,
0.2707926630973816,
-0.03796254098415375,
-0.7705559730529785,
0.19386327266693115,
0.39317652583122253,
0.7601033449172974,
0.27690407633781433,
-0.15275797247886658,
0.5270674824714661,
-0.057528864592313766,
0.7150428891181946,
0.2663673460483551,
-1.1321861743927002,
0.6655099987983704,
-0.28622156381607056,
0.25953200459480286,
0.34909841418266296,
0.14621111750602722,
-0.12283976376056671,
-0.31579849123954773,
-0.695483386516571,
-0.7183733582496643,
0.24334709346294403,
0.0006245439290069044,
0.2735793888568878,
-0.015486096031963825,
0.42444074153900146,
-0.4682874083518982,
0.19035251438617706,
-0.6601355075836182,
-0.26816070079803467,
-0.5151553153991699,
-0.4781818091869354,
0.45130717754364014,
-0.12103778123855591,
-0.02012844756245613,
-0.37960630655288696,
0.33274686336517334,
0.08758209645748138,
0.6010316610336304,
0.24273598194122314,
-0.09659625589847565,
-0.07045183330774307,
0.03536246344447136,
0.5152803063392639,
0.6087319850921631,
-0.07206439226865768,
0.02770368941128254,
0.025864236056804657,
-0.7269980907440186,
0.29826048016548157,
0.363938570022583,
-0.03010108508169651,
-0.23193755745887756,
0.35260656476020813,
1.041088342666626,
0.3009829521179199,
-0.4936017394065857,
0.5127248764038086,
-0.24277758598327637,
-0.08886236697435379,
-0.08376148343086243,
-0.2049247920513153,
0.04939158633351326,
0.13773344457149506,
0.21212510764598846,
-0.00696798088029027,
-0.07393129169940948,
-0.4683251976966858,
0.28086134791374207,
0.4419996738433838,
-0.2580524981021881,
-0.6486946940422058,
0.8736718893051147,
0.7761393189430237,
-0.24837040901184082,
0.5498440265655518,
-0.2247978001832962,
-0.4175056517124176,
0.6650209426879883,
0.7177401185035706,
0.605155348777771,
-0.3590124845504761,
0.4316841661930084,
-0.11755164712667465,
0.5180954337120056,
0.10317114740610123,
0.37810105085372925,
-0.2380586862564087,
-0.8940671682357788,
-0.5689616799354553,
-0.5389274954795837,
-0.20674391090869904,
0.19293507933616638,
-0.263282835483551,
-0.05004848167300224,
-0.7683702707290649,
-0.1034364178776741,
-0.5714349150657654,
-0.1791735291481018,
-0.6413704752922058,
0.4809209108352661,
0.46976545453071594,
0.7844071984291077,
-0.694288432598114,
1.118463397026062,
0.8551751375198364,
-0.2402033507823944,
-1.101401686668396,
0.12339586019515991,
-0.5494404435157776,
-0.5272234678268433,
0.7292961478233337,
-0.11806114763021469,
-0.3330616056919098,
0.3015032112598419,
-0.2620866298675537,
-0.6389808654785156,
1.1196494102478027,
0.34022533893585205,
-0.48882490396499634,
0.1473502516746521,
0.2387024611234665,
0.44061699509620667,
-0.5953627824783325,
0.6283126473426819,
0.13412773609161377,
0.1616498827934265,
0.06712311506271362,
-1.1993072032928467,
-0.25212913751602173,
-0.22777722775936127,
0.09110376983880997,
-0.09135406464338303,
-0.5888009071350098,
0.7719931602478027,
-0.13269861042499542,
-0.14282077550888062,
0.14587891101837158,
0.9068700671195984,
0.20897948741912842,
0.08877325803041458,
0.5095944404602051,
0.562430739402771,
0.5963439345359802,
0.10643374174833298,
1.0267969369888306,
-0.7777283787727356,
-0.002235976280644536,
0.775406002998352,
-0.34093913435935974,
0.6520360708236694,
0.33575910329818726,
-0.02353152073919773,
0.38661617040634155,
0.4369890093803406,
0.5076817870140076,
0.8525114059448242,
0.3457508683204651,
-0.7205439805984497,
-0.09377691894769669,
-0.15687792003154755,
-0.6195371150970459,
0.22065259516239166,
0.27217337489128113,
-0.06308076530694962,
0.08203843235969543,
0.277225136756897,
-0.16369561851024628,
-0.05717899650335312,
-0.46697402000427246,
0.5070008635520935,
0.002770397812128067,
0.07999156415462494,
0.4349367320537567,
0.19578732550144196,
0.9118431806564331,
-0.5842857956886292,
0.024847300723195076,
-0.3338935077190399,
0.2657868266105652,
-0.0760020911693573,
-0.49038761854171753,
0.1877032071352005,
-0.41919514536857605,
-0.025723986327648163,
-0.012782146222889423,
1.06065034866333,
-0.6202688217163086,
-0.20200201869010925,
0.3221125304698944,
0.5286945104598999,
0.021107330918312073,
-0.008068983443081379,
-0.550027072429657,
0.5847809314727783,
-0.3446362018585205,
-0.25463494658470154,
0.37629953026771545,
0.5873864889144897,
0.1590452343225479,
0.9210038781166077,
0.5989044308662415,
0.4136744737625122,
0.19555510580539703,
0.1627446860074997,
0.9995459318161011,
-0.3271496295928955,
-0.6627390384674072,
-0.47092390060424805,
0.6171671748161316,
-0.3237251341342926,
-0.30055224895477295,
0.5496958494186401,
0.3165567219257355,
0.9803327322006226,
0.09515992552042007,
0.8032111525535583,
0.04631924256682396,
-0.2261429727077484,
-0.30423927307128906,
0.9280783534049988,
-0.1345977485179901,
0.7223725914955139,
-0.03380768746137619,
-0.8030790090560913,
-0.011901537887752056,
0.9317640662193298,
-0.11144499480724335,
0.3316671550273895,
0.23782861232757568,
0.44938206672668457,
-0.36460182070732117,
0.07334442436695099,
0.5085394382476807,
0.13820360600948334,
0.5276604294776917,
0.5293874144554138,
0.6622258424758911,
-0.7033494114875793,
0.3273540437221527,
-0.6694550514221191,
-0.28859010338783264,
0.020217612385749817,
-0.7423171997070312,
-0.746683657169342,
-0.3142686188220978,
-0.4586436152458191,
-0.36993542313575745,
0.4848650395870209,
0.7166150212287903,
1.0343166589736938,
-0.40080055594444275,
-0.3166145384311676,
-0.30598846077919006,
-0.278878778219223,
0.050851453095674515,
-0.14711706340312958,
0.00893750973045826,
-0.09992001205682755,
-0.5196645259857178,
0.6172206997871399,
0.3559691309928894,
0.4419669508934021,
-0.4252886176109314,
-0.5065404176712036,
0.013046774081885815,
0.08334223181009293,
0.5511084794998169,
0.6136824488639832,
-0.4084330201148987,
-0.3378276228904724,
-0.21006862819194794,
-0.2209310382604599,
-0.1418185979127884,
0.9006965160369873,
-1.003700852394104,
0.19169902801513672,
0.2636553645133972,
0.8688563704490662,
0.34765398502349854,
0.21916624903678894,
0.8757327198982239,
-0.8286354541778564,
0.8119158744812012,
0.2609136998653412,
0.15484628081321716,
0.4119814336299896,
-0.33906039595603943,
0.10304335504770279,
0.301113486289978,
-0.4888882040977478,
-0.8544804453849792,
0.18379153311252594,
-0.8181900978088379,
-0.19833087921142578,
0.9509236812591553,
-0.5286990404129028,
-0.13349686563014984,
-0.1604791134595871,
0.0270644873380661,
0.08246743679046631,
-0.13667555153369904,
0.43011319637298584,
0.13151898980140686,
0.08091767132282257,
-0.690542459487915,
-0.39188265800476074,
0.3765478730201721,
0.3893781006336212,
-1.0743383169174194,
-0.29805004596710205,
0.20716077089309692,
-0.0022092126309871674,
-0.03820310905575752,
0.9305245876312256,
0.07574082165956497,
0.23412305116653442,
0.08784139156341553,
0.2023618072271347,
-0.2332092672586441,
-0.43983975052833557,
-0.19376322627067566,
-0.052579931914806366,
0.172220841050148,
-0.43680334091186523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11655v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11655v2 | Competition of Mechanisms: Tracing How Language Models Handle Facts and Counterfactuals | 2024-02-18T17:26:51 | 2024-06-06T21:45:21 | Francesco Ortu, Zhijing Jin, Diego Doimo, Mrinmaya Sachan, Alberto Cazzaniga, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interpretability research aims to bridge the gap between empirical success
and our scientific understanding of the inner workings of large language models
(LLMs). However, most existing research focuses on analyzing a single
mechanism, such as how models copy or recall factual knowledge. In this work,
we propose a formulation of competition of mechanisms, which focuses on the
interplay of multiple mechanisms instead of individual mechanisms and traces
how one of them becomes dominant in the final prediction. We uncover how and
where mechanisms compete within LLMs using two interpretability methods: logit
inspection and attention modification. Our findings show traces of the
mechanisms and their competition across various model components and reveal
attention positions that effectively control the strength of certain
mechanisms. Code: https://github.com/francescortu/comp-mech. Data:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/francescortu/comp-mech. | [
-0.11811685562133789,
-0.8099721670150757,
0.8562307357788086,
0.21689802408218384,
-0.2304646074771881,
0.08542264252901077,
0.027441494166851044,
-0.7284218668937683,
0.08119938522577286,
0.5842797756195068,
-0.655369222164154,
-0.1440715491771698,
-0.7239631414413452,
0.14533968269824982,
-0.5564903616905212,
0.8707305192947388,
-0.2229706346988678,
-0.01354803703725338,
-0.3184283971786499,
-0.2898980379104614,
-0.0733068436384201,
-0.7652192711830139,
-0.4390815496444702,
-0.5956979990005493,
0.6609243750572205,
0.1467255800962448,
0.49898844957351685,
0.8082446455955505,
0.48679864406585693,
0.36316660046577454,
-0.26995545625686646,
-0.2050188183784485,
-0.5799930095672607,
0.20287451148033142,
-0.3484751582145691,
-0.858185350894928,
-0.3243069648742676,
0.2054600715637207,
0.7293241024017334,
0.3423386216163635,
-0.17688561975955963,
0.12273570150136948,
0.4030982553958893,
0.41865164041519165,
-0.4032149016857147,
0.5109257698059082,
-0.6853811740875244,
-0.3999658226966858,
-0.5096518397331238,
-0.4520310163497925,
-0.6187332272529602,
-0.14817148447036743,
0.303645521402359,
-0.4306032955646515,
0.4012608528137207,
0.23427318036556244,
0.7550952434539795,
0.16666966676712036,
-0.34227293729782104,
-0.5852539539337158,
-0.404990553855896,
0.8201618194580078,
-0.7246376872062683,
0.3801230490207672,
0.2647455930709839,
-0.05099399760365486,
0.14550544321537018,
-0.8412859439849854,
-0.3816715180873871,
-0.2747802734375,
-0.4979088306427002,
0.00646967301145196,
-0.49925410747528076,
0.002257220447063446,
0.47877687215805054,
0.20181359350681305,
-0.5653710961341858,
0.1487777829170227,
-0.47254303097724915,
-0.210584819316864,
0.40252047777175903,
0.21023482084274292,
0.47241640090942383,
-0.07132493704557419,
-0.2681598663330078,
0.01322147436439991,
-0.8177582025527954,
-0.0003007357008755207,
0.34704968333244324,
0.20516541600227356,
-0.13207969069480896,
0.46539974212646484,
-0.3243379592895508,
0.6168647408485413,
-0.08446851372718811,
0.04327132925391197,
0.0792461484670639,
-0.4515155255794525,
-0.21486489474773407,
0.24575063586235046,
0.6746628284454346,
0.38041776418685913,
-0.04131179302930832,
-0.18310247361660004,
-0.17031820118427277,
0.11157998442649841,
0.3891938030719757,
-0.4727003276348114,
-0.09405776113271713,
0.0892244502902031,
-0.3577560484409332,
-0.46607506275177,
-0.30581873655319214,
-0.854111909866333,
-0.06415002048015594,
-0.377958208322525,
0.4521910846233368,
-0.03183426707983017,
-0.22681720554828644,
0.12415237724781036,
-0.05747247114777565,
0.2595681846141815,
0.018381165340542793,
-0.9327443242073059,
0.4546978175640106,
0.8732237815856934,
1.1257731914520264,
-0.15627306699752808,
-0.4107995331287384,
-0.54300457239151,
0.051908813416957855,
-0.17066040635108948,
0.6376693248748779,
-0.5478100776672363,
-0.14326579868793488,
-0.07313603162765503,
0.15759114921092987,
-0.4452866017818451,
-0.5105140209197998,
0.6888018250465393,
-0.8868898749351501,
0.09502904117107391,
-0.4032251834869385,
-0.6688209176063538,
-0.4790864586830139,
0.21492446959018707,
-1.1040687561035156,
0.6978811621665955,
-0.20779570937156677,
-0.8854981064796448,
0.22015507519245148,
-0.727155864238739,
-0.4068296253681183,
-0.19376157224178314,
-0.14108386635780334,
-0.4818487763404846,
0.339948445558548,
-0.18585115671157837,
0.3014949560165405,
-0.2616032063961029,
0.19442570209503174,
-0.4918619990348816,
-0.028361255303025246,
0.37090176343917847,
-0.4226740300655365,
0.7981818914413452,
0.09690899401903152,
-0.6393179297447205,
0.32411614060401917,
-0.7089101076126099,
-0.43674787878990173,
0.29741352796554565,
-0.24519094824790955,
-0.25521400570869446,
0.2391451597213745,
-0.19132962822914124,
0.3566143810749054,
-0.07044709473848343,
-0.4316956400871277,
0.0879303514957428,
-0.2866329848766327,
0.6613860130310059,
0.6159789562225342,
-0.09392882883548737,
0.37171342968940735,
-0.2595623731613159,
0.6120938062667847,
-0.14356070756912231,
0.17168471217155457,
-0.1324148178100586,
-0.3291322588920593,
-0.7782350778579712,
0.027661625295877457,
0.21193702518939972,
0.36978885531425476,
-0.527886152267456,
-0.09702625125646591,
-0.04755771905183792,
-0.2477710098028183,
-0.5027500987052917,
0.09694578498601913,
0.6789093017578125,
0.3036649525165558,
0.1241941899061203,
-0.3566569983959198,
-0.5431056618690491,
-0.8366014957427979,
-0.3755372166633606,
-0.22764858603477478,
0.40195369720458984,
0.16089697182178497,
0.3761104941368103,
0.136912003159523,
0.6713863015174866,
-0.39345046877861023,
-0.11362995952367783,
-0.37106671929359436,
0.3709738254547119,
0.06823039799928665,
0.3399048447608948,
0.7774258255958557,
-0.9410644769668579,
-0.44242310523986816,
0.053662341088056564,
-0.8268513679504395,
-0.3372909128665924,
-0.032749515026807785,
-0.0005545400781556964,
0.41177698969841003,
0.9973315000534058,
-0.6928285360336304,
0.5539343953132629,
0.772487461566925,
-0.41941899061203003,
0.8574181795120239,
0.14438673853874207,
0.233137845993042,
-0.40422773361206055,
0.2716754674911499,
-0.13463714718818665,
-0.20562976598739624,
-0.7365411520004272,
0.5661642551422119,
-0.11720267683267593,
0.38600513339042664,
-0.5964773297309875,
0.5907301902770996,
-0.40351402759552,
0.005712599493563175,
-0.27094271779060364,
0.3613310754299164,
-0.022689931094646454,
0.4964429438114166,
0.0008436563657596707,
0.535332977771759,
0.6138346791267395,
-0.5834665894508362,
0.4015021324157715,
0.12646998465061188,
-0.7153605222702026,
0.276100754737854,
-0.836505651473999,
-0.013892621733248234,
0.11309278756380081,
0.06990212202072144,
-1.199554681777954,
-0.15008430182933807,
0.3111427426338196,
-0.4174037277698517,
0.20673887431621552,
-0.19019700586795807,
-0.6335012316703796,
-0.003098769811913371,
-0.1531330645084381,
0.24773834645748138,
0.23225602507591248,
-0.4590567350387573,
0.6917688250541687,
0.03357253223657608,
-0.3990864157676697,
-0.579692542552948,
-0.6024312376976013,
0.09608949720859528,
-0.49803847074508667,
-0.278710275888443,
-0.07111388444900513,
-0.09615398198366165,
-0.6548475027084351,
0.17138251662254333,
-0.16757366061210632,
0.23278994858264923,
0.2691521942615509,
0.09986608475446701,
0.12679263949394226,
-0.38875246047973633,
0.0003931493265554309,
-0.03750799596309662,
-0.17390553653240204,
0.3758120536804199,
-0.15785694122314453,
0.4640437662601471,
0.22735092043876648,
-0.3908972442150116,
-0.36295780539512634,
0.10387896001338959,
0.7850480079650879,
-0.23369432985782623,
0.8385042548179626,
0.26196277141571045,
0.0531843937933445,
-0.145115926861763,
-0.6194505095481873,
-0.26302218437194824,
-0.46598008275032043,
0.35904571413993835,
-0.7390027046203613,
-0.849825382232666,
0.6108062863349915,
0.055329278111457825,
0.041448574513196945,
0.37279072403907776,
0.7252736687660217,
0.3191600441932678,
1.1302262544631958,
0.5858399271965027,
-0.24004685878753662,
0.42008548974990845,
0.13162697851657867,
0.02793888933956623,
-0.7573017477989197,
-0.21649476885795593,
-0.6372649669647217,
-0.1689114272594452,
-0.5285314917564392,
-0.34146690368652344,
0.10913247615098953,
0.057324159890413284,
0.2690849304199219,
0.3558737635612488,
-0.0660790503025055,
0.5710946917533875,
0.6622647643089294,
0.04928947240114212,
0.6059772372245789,
-0.0014496000949293375,
-0.535521924495697,
-0.050211627036333084,
-0.8199370503425598,
-0.5819793939590454,
0.9485803246498108,
0.39535558223724365,
0.6899121403694153,
0.2311577945947647,
0.3488287925720215,
0.21794699132442474,
0.4256170392036438,
-0.6654065251350403,
0.6242821216583252,
-0.04589282348752022,
-0.8688288927078247,
-0.2544628381729126,
-0.2915182113647461,
-0.8527306318283081,
0.47282055020332336,
0.1410384327173233,
-0.9744690656661987,
0.2473887801170349,
0.2637576162815094,
0.03144196793437004,
0.4014016389846802,
-0.6884034872055054,
0.9618827104568481,
-0.18498897552490234,
-0.7414649724960327,
-0.5609855651855469,
-0.6937004923820496,
0.28985247015953064,
-0.10473733395338058,
0.29900461435317993,
0.13026028871536255,
0.33046019077301025,
0.6250975131988525,
0.10846010595560074,
1.1893709897994995,
0.12244853377342224,
-0.4237249195575714,
0.1846744567155838,
0.3061826825141907,
0.5317831039428711,
-0.2668853998184204,
-0.04415861889719963,
0.049874261021614075,
0.07811026275157928,
-0.3367173969745636,
-0.5488787889480591,
0.5465196371078491,
-0.35546624660491943,
-0.8462120890617371,
-0.387423038482666,
-0.3199757933616638,
-0.035993512719869614,
0.23126791417598724,
0.4370431900024414,
0.6554296612739563,
-0.38904860615730286,
0.47366368770599365,
0.5783647298812866,
0.11083368211984634,
0.46587860584259033,
0.758167564868927,
-0.3152744174003601,
0.15835869312286377,
0.7876541614532471,
0.05909416079521179,
0.6366917490959167,
0.5886239409446716,
0.14456310868263245,
-0.4307531714439392,
-0.6003066897392273,
-0.23217728734016418,
0.2520681619644165,
-0.8705788850784302,
0.29036614298820496,
-0.6480948328971863,
-0.14307871460914612,
-0.24457457661628723,
0.1323712170124054,
-0.18354330956935883,
-0.27806881070137024,
-0.1301145702600479,
-0.3892258405685425,
-0.06781411916017532,
1.0563066005706787,
-0.3592970371246338,
0.36266571283340454,
-0.4914865493774414,
0.0999198630452156,
0.4636836051940918,
0.3853432238101959,
0.3755592405796051,
-0.46326231956481934,
-0.3676292598247528,
-0.2673427164554596,
-0.3044030964374542,
-0.7594684362411499,
0.221845805644989,
-0.22828957438468933,
0.7747363448143005,
0.4462221562862396,
-0.21038588881492615,
0.35363420844078064,
-0.4754093885421753,
0.43406662344932556,
0.017047926783561707,
-1.1068804264068604,
0.3396244943141937,
-0.1622045338153839,
0.0863688513636589,
0.13224518299102783,
0.47969934344291687,
-0.4537803828716278,
-0.7851251363754272,
-0.6853587031364441,
-0.5744956135749817,
1.0500794649124146,
0.30488717555999756,
-0.15726397931575775,
0.40369802713394165,
0.16313837468624115,
0.13154055178165436,
0.17188110947608948,
-0.8510170578956604,
-0.013545947149395943,
0.2020767629146576,
-0.15089231729507446,
-0.3095732629299164,
-0.5741146802902222,
-0.4195772111415863,
0.2614150941371918,
0.5457537174224854,
-0.08959907293319702,
-0.10411576926708221,
0.25490111112594604,
-0.4076458811759949,
-0.2024422585964203,
0.25851109623908997,
0.8194714784622192,
0.8992776274681091,
-0.09512107819318771,
0.3286166787147522,
-0.21154825389385223,
-0.3519829213619232,
-0.12048103660345078,
-0.03005221299827099,
-0.3243786096572876,
0.05185031518340111,
0.942148745059967,
1.2223984003067017,
0.3607204854488373,
-0.7065597176551819,
0.004482010379433632,
0.006704423576593399,
-0.3659709692001343,
0.39710360765457153,
0.18318484723567963,
-0.0060060578398406506,
0.6593900918960571,
0.18301112949848175,
-0.27684691548347473,
0.4477774500846863,
-0.789313018321991,
0.38989192247390747,
0.2831381559371948,
-0.4664021134376526,
-0.7315433621406555,
0.7120828032493591,
0.08553014695644379,
-0.11457505822181702,
0.2646418809890747,
-0.06842697411775589,
-0.7818354964256287,
0.6927599906921387,
0.3361585736274719,
0.7698559165000916,
-0.3845100998878479,
0.10324208438396454,
0.2767655849456787,
0.5195689797401428,
-0.08900000154972076,
-0.052865684032440186,
0.021047871559858322,
-0.7115762233734131,
-0.6128813624382019,
-0.35853758454322815,
-0.4516042172908783,
0.3474934995174408,
-0.8359972238540649,
0.022911177948117256,
-0.032347116619348526,
0.08335914462804794,
0.32013338804244995,
-0.15847907960414886,
-0.43864157795906067,
0.10956177860498428,
0.12661539018154144,
0.6696394681930542,
-0.9645732045173645,
0.6383966207504272,
0.5084722638130188,
-0.30525755882263184,
-0.4792095720767975,
0.08799122273921967,
0.4296323359012604,
-0.8968296051025391,
0.6366461515426636,
-0.003509216709062457,
-0.21583245694637299,
-0.1874607801437378,
-0.7653495073318481,
-0.7292761206626892,
0.605650782585144,
0.22179119288921356,
-0.814112663269043,
-0.16744939982891083,
-0.07006743550300598,
0.48882582783699036,
-0.24156014621257782,
0.023639284074306488,
0.949155330657959,
0.487155556678772,
-0.04606537148356438,
-1.153638243675232,
0.18610148131847382,
-0.05414241552352905,
-0.5721832513809204,
-0.10377312451601028,
-0.8234166502952576,
0.573035717010498,
-0.22990551590919495,
-0.34841278195381165,
0.11416769027709961,
0.20344261825084686,
0.2696736752986908,
0.5637120008468628,
0.42428308725357056,
0.5267596244812012,
0.2371527999639511,
-0.07249915599822998,
0.9067093729972839,
-0.36816152930259705,
0.5406757593154907,
1.2465797662734985,
-0.3101281225681305,
0.765739917755127,
0.4650013744831085,
-0.23641379177570343,
0.6822028160095215,
0.41578614711761475,
0.04633766785264015,
0.5427219867706299,
0.06783362478017807,
-0.012355574406683445,
-0.15116310119628906,
-0.06736329197883606,
0.11668477952480316,
0.5933275818824768,
0.28547966480255127,
-0.3377639651298523,
-0.08285268396139145,
-0.20221693813800812,
0.10195066779851913,
-0.0389256589114666,
-0.08663786202669144,
0.9510712623596191,
0.13135351240634918,
-0.8326773047447205,
0.30131450295448303,
-0.2208191454410553,
0.2782009243965149,
-0.8748235702514648,
-0.016635289415717125,
-0.14177905023097992,
0.3215847611427307,
0.022550402209162712,
-0.9056944251060486,
0.22636672854423523,
-0.22055751085281372,
-0.17990566790103912,
-0.12280777841806412,
0.6673700213432312,
-0.5250806212425232,
-0.16498416662216187,
0.7165165543556213,
0.5371495485305786,
-0.060819368809461594,
-0.003353497479110956,
-0.7894139885902405,
0.6216567158699036,
0.1310671865940094,
-0.5030770897865295,
0.2573162317276001,
0.5816694498062134,
-0.06978590786457062,
0.7240837812423706,
0.4454382658004761,
0.12635457515716553,
0.07871264219284058,
0.1985529661178589,
0.7285332083702087,
-0.733548641204834,
-0.5330455303192139,
-1.2869704961776733,
0.3448745310306549,
-0.010971511714160442,
-0.010636144317686558,
0.9143894910812378,
0.4787276089191437,
0.8173902034759521,
-0.06657503545284271,
0.6687597632408142,
0.0013159007066860795,
0.5532113909721375,
-0.8468083143234253,
0.5585680603981018,
-0.71329265832901,
0.05851667746901512,
-0.14085455238819122,
-0.6686803102493286,
-0.0713183805346489,
0.18028251826763153,
-0.11362689733505249,
-0.047653764486312866,
0.9469051361083984,
0.7222262620925903,
-0.18809843063354492,
-0.013432502746582031,
0.22952456772327423,
0.6997120380401611,
0.24320967495441437,
0.4030762314796448,
0.8821458220481873,
0.05830203369259834,
0.565880298614502,
0.0403364896774292,
-0.24289727210998535,
-0.47246336936950684,
-0.8169130682945251,
-0.8984468579292297,
-0.6465277075767517,
-0.3893772065639496,
-0.29944315552711487,
0.0054870895110070705,
0.30807995796203613,
0.7403085231781006,
-0.7785868048667908,
-0.44518813490867615,
-0.04869120940566063,
0.37052422761917114,
-0.32121577858924866,
-0.20829860866069794,
0.357570081949234,
-0.44884324073791504,
-0.7713900208473206,
0.22692465782165527,
0.2612576186656952,
-0.1314169466495514,
-0.2745409905910492,
0.06411449611186981,
-0.3030896484851837,
0.3479527235031128,
0.8143122792243958,
0.3213731646537781,
-0.969933032989502,
-0.04996580258011818,
0.006765029858797789,
0.09006746113300323,
-0.14875289797782898,
1.3239929676055908,
-0.39305579662323,
0.618308961391449,
0.5725542306900024,
0.3809241056442261,
0.45641300082206726,
-0.15758946537971497,
0.6813428401947021,
-0.6352666616439819,
0.06954561918973923,
-0.2870665192604065,
0.3980787694454193,
0.1615641564130783,
-0.08852275460958481,
0.7686561942100525,
0.5423678755760193,
-0.46203088760375977,
-0.9515895843505859,
0.23160794377326965,
-0.8383026719093323,
-0.38169065117836,
1.0144085884094238,
-0.2626233994960785,
-0.1713392734527588,
-0.19791197776794434,
-0.1472114771604538,
0.24478361010551453,
-0.08545093238353729,
0.8025546073913574,
1.3291394710540771,
-0.16342154145240784,
-0.34287744760513306,
-0.7947185039520264,
0.6849090456962585,
0.4258294105529785,
-0.5439306497573853,
0.3253767192363739,
0.2793161869049072,
0.34598883986473083,
0.39249926805496216,
0.39219018816947937,
-0.1420753449201584,
0.2055671066045761,
0.10282102227210999,
-0.31436726450920105,
0.3506854176521301,
-0.409638911485672,
-0.44322746992111206,
0.01018062885850668,
0.14314597845077515,
0.08710210025310516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11651v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11651v2 | Learning From Failure: Integrating Negative Examples when Fine-tuning Large Language Models as Agents | 2024-02-18T17:10:07 | 2024-04-16T11:41:13 | Renxi Wang, Haonan Li, Xudong Han, Yixuan Zhang, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved success in acting as agents, which
interact with environments through tools such as search engines. However, LLMs
are optimized for language generation instead of tool use during training or
alignment, limiting their effectiveness as agents. To resolve this problem,
previous work has first collected interaction trajectories between LLMs and
environments, using only trajectories that successfully finished the task to
fine-tune smaller models, making fine-tuning data scarce and acquiring it both
difficult and costly. Discarding failed trajectories also leads to significant
wastage of data and resources and limits the possible optimization paths during
fine-tuning. In this paper, we argue that unsuccessful trajectories offer
valuable insights, and LLMs can learn from these trajectories through
appropriate quality control and fine-tuning strategies. By simply adding a
prefix or suffix that tells the model whether to generate a successful
trajectory during training, we improve model performance by a large margin on
mathematical reasoning, multi-hop question answering, and strategic question
answering tasks. We further analyze the inference results and find that our
method provides a better trade-off between valuable information and errors in
unsuccessful trajectories. To our knowledge, we are the first to demonstrate
the value of negative trajectories and their application in agent-tunning
scenarios. Our findings offer guidance for developing better agent-tuning
methods and low-resource data usage techniques. | [
-0.34830939769744873,
-0.6549991965293884,
0.760915219783783,
-0.35450881719589233,
-0.18425995111465454,
0.1876131296157837,
-0.11576282978057861,
-0.08569812774658203,
0.03132712095975876,
0.5092554688453674,
-0.8703157901763916,
-0.4975908398628235,
-0.3895845413208008,
-0.22855135798454285,
-0.38604751229286194,
1.139948844909668,
-0.03685923293232918,
-0.20143799483776093,
-0.21790362894535065,
-0.09659375250339508,
-0.8659127950668335,
-0.3258252739906311,
-1.01901113986969,
-0.34263452887535095,
0.7378152012825012,
0.7971711754798889,
0.8300501704216003,
0.5654991865158081,
0.1327560842037201,
0.27387377619743347,
0.09269075840711594,
0.5356512665748596,
-0.9613890647888184,
0.16841639578342438,
-0.30520689487457275,
-0.45762911438941956,
-0.008902591653168201,
0.1976386308670044,
0.41744881868362427,
0.7725739479064941,
-0.16262148320674896,
-0.08390764892101288,
0.19226010143756866,
0.4819971024990082,
-0.4573803246021271,
0.051169320940971375,
-0.5715692043304443,
0.02972380258142948,
-0.04220619425177574,
-0.4079854190349579,
-0.34289881587028503,
-0.5549796223640442,
-0.1811753362417221,
-0.506447970867157,
0.08008560538291931,
-0.13838237524032593,
0.9280973076820374,
0.3647198975086212,
-0.38776785135269165,
-0.5846471786499023,
-1.003435730934143,
1.11225426197052,
-0.7046613097190857,
0.3018496632575989,
0.2694663107395172,
0.2255069464445114,
-0.586305558681488,
-0.2691272497177124,
-0.4244091510772705,
-0.1911213994026184,
0.08723995089530945,
-0.21446837484836578,
0.03937198966741562,
0.043975263833999634,
0.18879473209381104,
-0.2830534279346466,
-0.33748629689216614,
0.34977373480796814,
-0.44897544384002686,
-0.2785945236682892,
0.5473225712776184,
0.343329519033432,
0.2586686611175537,
0.1269608587026596,
0.21840627491474152,
-0.5420293211936951,
-0.8844279646873474,
0.0815620943903923,
0.5327773690223694,
0.6939065456390381,
0.13708163797855377,
0.5147855281829834,
0.01135504711419344,
0.5953782200813293,
-0.10856930911540985,
-0.19117127358913422,
0.09796572476625443,
-0.2856268882751465,
0.05347122997045517,
-0.14133334159851074,
0.3402215540409088,
0.2181164175271988,
0.29582634568214417,
-0.47820863127708435,
-0.29456040263175964,
0.06688572466373444,
0.45558062195777893,
-0.6051852107048035,
0.10866823047399521,
0.2295350730419159,
-0.026102446019649506,
-0.23595023155212402,
-0.17565636336803436,
-0.5382397770881653,
-0.35023507475852966,
-0.3937332034111023,
0.6068513989448547,
-0.5685449242591858,
0.009625609032809734,
0.04913570359349251,
-0.18781061470508575,
0.3437665104866028,
0.35083889961242676,
-0.419904500246048,
0.07087051123380661,
0.916505753993988,
0.8960998058319092,
0.028978746384382248,
-0.678900957107544,
-1.1074461936950684,
-0.02692515403032303,
-0.8027700185775757,
0.4861114025115967,
-0.3404342830181122,
-0.354937344789505,
0.04466357082128525,
-0.0011693744454532862,
-0.03407992050051689,
-0.5252675414085388,
0.5760719180107117,
-0.4849085509777069,
-0.08951124548912048,
-0.36224257946014404,
-0.5878634452819824,
-0.41178098320961,
0.30684801936149597,
-0.2862451374530792,
0.3922480642795563,
0.07532496005296707,
-0.16297045350074768,
0.375989705324173,
-0.34426572918891907,
-0.788969099521637,
-0.16872364282608032,
-0.07136142998933792,
-0.526267409324646,
0.33529800176620483,
-0.38548359274864197,
0.5052869319915771,
-0.08009222149848938,
0.2913636565208435,
-0.3880358934402466,
-0.49651288986206055,
-0.059277765452861786,
-0.26294589042663574,
0.5333364605903625,
-0.04736015200614929,
-0.3202129602432251,
-0.17688140273094177,
-0.7355183959007263,
0.10276330262422562,
0.18911710381507874,
-0.41268518567085266,
-0.5279424786567688,
0.3986116051673889,
-0.3416141867637634,
0.3984624743461609,
-0.12332369387149811,
-0.17834901809692383,
0.09027259796857834,
-0.5394912362098694,
0.27922987937927246,
0.7585232853889465,
0.19591914117336273,
0.33568277955055237,
-0.4612705409526825,
0.6790211200714111,
0.050282806158065796,
0.03788908198475838,
-0.04349464923143387,
-0.011247984133660793,
-0.9555132985115051,
0.5426750779151917,
-0.06512848287820816,
0.2928420305252075,
-1.018655776977539,
0.03870753198862076,
-0.13261756300926208,
-0.6507036089897156,
-0.37680649757385254,
0.4374813437461853,
0.3885146677494049,
0.5693241357803345,
0.2660902142524719,
-0.19924980401992798,
-0.40831461548805237,
-0.5925086736679077,
-0.19006451964378357,
-0.2633383572101593,
0.32262298464775085,
0.41618648171424866,
0.38422253727912903,
-0.2727636992931366,
0.5714547634124756,
-0.24322837591171265,
-0.17579928040504456,
-0.41378557682037354,
0.24497032165527344,
0.21366272866725922,
0.5692503452301025,
0.4633490741252899,
-0.5823935866355896,
-0.15817171335220337,
-0.10587067902088165,
-0.49189141392707825,
0.17104080319404602,
-0.3684656023979187,
-0.24118155241012573,
0.323326051235199,
0.4710056483745575,
-0.6022714376449585,
0.19895930588245392,
0.5017753839492798,
-0.5037828087806702,
0.5106411576271057,
-0.19946905970573425,
0.06675244122743607,
-0.7886291146278381,
-0.16187839210033417,
-0.015322345308959484,
-0.14965605735778809,
-0.6975131630897522,
-0.031555552035570145,
-0.15612947940826416,
0.03632943704724312,
-0.6194657683372498,
0.4332267940044403,
-0.37334558367729187,
0.06203579902648926,
-0.23509521782398224,
0.21575559675693512,
-0.11298896372318268,
0.5063103437423706,
-0.19469641149044037,
0.5693948864936829,
0.32424604892730713,
-0.7945571541786194,
0.13551601767539978,
0.1370365023612976,
-0.04696729779243469,
0.3340637981891632,
-0.43074139952659607,
0.11407166719436646,
-0.29284533858299255,
-0.3308973014354706,
-0.7379544973373413,
-0.19969254732131958,
0.18038557469844818,
-0.2793485224246979,
0.3516347408294678,
-0.34963780641555786,
-0.48039454221725464,
-0.2837177813053131,
-0.3148927688598633,
0.09828730672597885,
0.4891700744628906,
-0.42649418115615845,
0.31231099367141724,
0.21515393257141113,
0.12615595757961273,
-0.5309039354324341,
-0.6092553734779358,
0.07666158676147461,
-0.49455928802490234,
-0.30253666639328003,
-0.26052412390708923,
-0.023111607879400253,
-0.11351272463798523,
-0.09412772953510284,
-0.030796155333518982,
0.12821859121322632,
0.5695462226867676,
0.3471106290817261,
0.04270320013165474,
-0.1906787008047104,
0.4022655487060547,
0.07123897224664688,
-0.15297050774097443,
0.02242303639650345,
-0.2586245834827423,
0.5918448567390442,
-0.043368130922317505,
-0.5071510076522827,
-0.30430129170417786,
0.13839861750602722,
0.7814694046974182,
0.13709890842437744,
0.9997910261154175,
0.2807480990886688,
-0.3959388732910156,
-0.4309549033641815,
-0.36577609181404114,
-0.3271276652812958,
-0.44593456387519836,
0.4941510558128357,
-0.0570758692920208,
-0.5589405298233032,
0.29659783840179443,
-0.06925541162490845,
0.23643015325069427,
0.23685714602470398,
0.057606879621744156,
-0.26255106925964355,
0.904270589351654,
0.848995566368103,
-0.08534611016511917,
0.3576699197292328,
-0.4356297254562378,
0.25385111570358276,
-0.35654905438423157,
-0.04764130339026451,
-0.4611791670322418,
-0.37948787212371826,
-0.6585038304328918,
-0.25349873304367065,
0.34136226773262024,
0.09803114831447601,
-0.5058582425117493,
0.2662225067615509,
-0.03506152704358101,
0.44737115502357483,
0.6017975211143494,
0.010518506169319153,
0.2083798497915268,
-0.06500763446092606,
0.06603275239467621,
-0.11345112323760986,
-0.7648578882217407,
-0.5770604610443115,
0.8399398326873779,
0.2026354819536209,
0.9922239184379578,
0.1276974380016327,
0.8546580076217651,
0.058409593999385834,
0.12746785581111908,
-0.8849892020225525,
0.4168876111507416,
-0.14202135801315308,
-0.2534123659133911,
-0.5566007494926453,
-0.5831356644630432,
-0.9770811796188354,
-0.01760883815586567,
-0.11114919185638428,
-0.6187551617622375,
0.22536179423332214,
0.48517054319381714,
-0.4840880036354065,
0.08875983208417892,
-0.8793514966964722,
1.1256954669952393,
-0.36932334303855896,
-0.5099876523017883,
-0.24750635027885437,
-0.24509017169475555,
0.22755785286426544,
-0.21865957975387573,
0.2277689129114151,
0.16869890689849854,
0.03666536882519722,
0.6367417573928833,
-0.5376044511795044,
1.0292243957519531,
-0.285969078540802,
-0.20569822192192078,
0.44797077775001526,
0.45078328251838684,
0.8675535321235657,
-0.2132357954978943,
-0.14878351986408234,
-0.07723551988601685,
-0.166569322347641,
-0.26351603865623474,
-0.650571882724762,
0.787146270275116,
-0.7286725640296936,
-0.5039112567901611,
-0.09352138638496399,
-0.28386572003364563,
-0.4974544942378998,
0.326562762260437,
0.07515455037355423,
0.5071989893913269,
0.08241495490074158,
0.16416321694850922,
0.3216354548931122,
-0.298947274684906,
0.6257449388504028,
0.6422275900840759,
0.012819421477615833,
0.018335502594709396,
1.2957180738449097,
0.387620747089386,
0.41766905784606934,
0.02404562011361122,
0.1067168340086937,
-0.092531219124794,
-0.8484773635864258,
-0.21718049049377441,
0.32894647121429443,
-0.6524106860160828,
-0.4021335244178772,
-0.4827395975589752,
-0.18505385518074036,
0.015087547712028027,
-0.21203003823757172,
-0.6284533143043518,
-0.07218260318040848,
-0.5532432198524475,
-0.1554674655199051,
-0.009904426522552967,
0.7260953783988953,
-0.2229708582162857,
0.4271629750728607,
-0.8548630475997925,
-0.1375494748353958,
0.04859565570950508,
0.2715236246585846,
0.3155754506587982,
-0.3503076434135437,
-0.641417384147644,
0.19136209785938263,
-0.5869215726852417,
-0.7670210003852844,
0.5945857167243958,
0.30875030159950256,
0.4138983190059662,
0.37885159254074097,
0.07571770250797272,
0.7687069177627563,
-0.33210113644599915,
0.5697963833808899,
-0.1338343471288681,
-0.8112121224403381,
0.7527768015861511,
-0.3244599401950836,
0.2018444538116455,
0.6102561950683594,
0.36617374420166016,
-0.6155487298965454,
-0.672653317451477,
-0.5027288794517517,
-0.9372420310974121,
0.8865428566932678,
0.05018085613846779,
0.1701069474220276,
-0.026584841310977936,
0.7029343843460083,
0.18848025798797607,
0.20355500280857086,
-0.6497726440429688,
-0.2618291974067688,
0.21719221770763397,
-0.01717011258006096,
-0.7140238285064697,
-0.048212725669145584,
0.00869216863065958,
0.0394563227891922,
1.006011724472046,
-0.29348912835121155,
-0.2718881368637085,
-0.10381092131137848,
-0.3404318690299988,
-0.34673547744750977,
0.14894969761371613,
0.6120913624763489,
0.6533111929893494,
0.05539544299244881,
0.18161693215370178,
0.12405645102262497,
-0.021671898663043976,
0.3254188895225525,
-0.17291253805160522,
-0.18245941400527954,
-0.140094593167305,
0.4940769374370575,
0.6677057147026062,
-0.011438981629908085,
-0.9014585614204407,
0.28490906953811646,
-0.046552687883377075,
0.10549350082874298,
-0.07590821385383606,
0.38940203189849854,
0.02868390642106533,
0.42130306363105774,
0.24539023637771606,
0.12937629222869873,
0.04772309586405754,
-0.5476263761520386,
0.2326127588748932,
0.6335188150405884,
-0.5718757510185242,
-0.33805954456329346,
0.21307723224163055,
-0.0385420098900795,
-0.32817205786705017,
0.7265641093254089,
-0.5242996215820312,
-0.4316276013851166,
0.8518224358558655,
0.28657567501068115,
0.7768858671188354,
0.016113383695483208,
0.456233948469162,
0.2548069655895233,
0.5232994556427002,
-0.2869724929332733,
-0.027190029621124268,
0.14883384108543396,
-0.7224454879760742,
-0.6503608822822571,
-0.6032323837280273,
-0.3781517446041107,
0.435791552066803,
-0.30789509415626526,
0.4774901866912842,
-0.3115295171737671,
0.03936994448304176,
-0.3291429579257965,
0.026779277250170708,
-0.7686681151390076,
0.16948635876178741,
0.05043671652674675,
0.5872248411178589,
-1.0976026058197021,
0.31677109003067017,
0.6729945540428162,
-0.4519941806793213,
-1.003075361251831,
0.0968405231833458,
-0.01135181076824665,
-0.6144962906837463,
0.5575334429740906,
0.09261920303106308,
-0.21861185133457184,
-0.005347347352653742,
-0.4057807922363281,
-0.9638450741767883,
0.7619231939315796,
0.608244776725769,
-0.6668049693107605,
-0.10450814664363861,
0.15332144498825073,
0.6693931221961975,
-0.015352323651313782,
0.06282506138086319,
0.6200553774833679,
0.3524438142776489,
0.16299448907375336,
-0.5950330495834351,
0.1928407996892929,
0.15878556668758392,
-0.14537471532821655,
0.30448493361473083,
-0.7143573760986328,
0.6768728494644165,
-0.5634732246398926,
-0.5016267895698547,
0.055384546518325806,
0.3250901699066162,
-0.09669079631567001,
0.3524976372718811,
0.49480801820755005,
0.4906182587146759,
0.6213185787200928,
-0.0610487125813961,
1.015500783920288,
0.04780801758170128,
0.5228148698806763,
1.1282745599746704,
0.146809384226799,
0.6607800722122192,
0.5597269535064697,
0.10659899562597275,
0.3150100111961365,
0.7855105400085449,
0.23732547461986542,
0.7395525574684143,
0.16360382735729218,
0.21936212480068207,
-0.4798731207847595,
-0.0638657733798027,
0.00872708112001419,
0.42019030451774597,
0.32559728622436523,
-0.08388067781925201,
-0.49962159991264343,
0.21674376726150513,
-0.05355305224657059,
-0.07673264294862747,
-0.2114725410938263,
0.7755265235900879,
0.11100494861602783,
-0.7894605398178101,
0.7132790684700012,
-0.16318485140800476,
0.36925414204597473,
-0.309072881937027,
-0.25232094526290894,
-0.5134422779083252,
0.1755586713552475,
-0.07155085355043411,
-0.5394231081008911,
0.4350922107696533,
-0.2605865001678467,
0.030564725399017334,
-0.1281297504901886,
0.41100621223449707,
-0.3186110854148865,
-0.3376392722129822,
0.3845095932483673,
0.7506162524223328,
0.15367336571216583,
0.18778902292251587,
-0.34643808007240295,
0.11346523463726044,
0.06408031284809113,
-0.17628192901611328,
0.1910184770822525,
0.4562942385673523,
0.10390731692314148,
0.9630782008171082,
0.2969873547554016,
0.28719326853752136,
-0.286357581615448,
-0.08010244369506836,
0.6852860450744629,
-0.8651983141899109,
-0.3872518837451935,
-1.0566703081130981,
0.43309149146080017,
0.2181650996208191,
-0.04129187390208244,
0.5446090698242188,
0.3623844385147095,
1.031589150428772,
0.04722006246447563,
0.856050968170166,
0.14240078628063202,
0.5343047380447388,
-0.5511108040809631,
0.5561251044273376,
-0.9432141184806824,
0.42286375164985657,
-0.10758329927921295,
-0.7676145434379578,
-0.16127125918865204,
0.38344910740852356,
-0.3579126000404358,
0.10507645457983017,
0.43326565623283386,
0.8202669024467468,
-0.10721016675233841,
-0.5466422438621521,
0.5184445977210999,
0.45745909214019775,
0.608830988407135,
0.7738186717033386,
1.0225557088851929,
-0.41445571184158325,
0.7875411510467529,
-0.24158421158790588,
0.09492120146751404,
-0.31224268674850464,
-0.7174161076545715,
-0.732587993144989,
-0.4902527332305908,
-0.3567577600479126,
-0.5610572099685669,
0.3655747175216675,
0.859886884689331,
0.572355329990387,
-0.7607428431510925,
-0.13027243316173553,
-0.36103928089141846,
0.7233293056488037,
-0.06660779565572739,
-0.23264922201633453,
0.08401022851467133,
-0.7159056663513184,
-0.752914547920227,
0.3285316228866577,
0.10065814852714539,
0.3103225827217102,
-0.20136967301368713,
-0.41954708099365234,
0.14238420128822327,
0.056982070207595825,
0.364917129278183,
0.6528486013412476,
-0.49695831537246704,
-0.5687404274940491,
-0.30136919021606445,
-0.046337515115737915,
0.005156143568456173,
0.6340062022209167,
-0.6474928259849548,
0.2102188766002655,
0.07296035438776016,
0.7743914723396301,
0.1307131052017212,
-0.13310858607292175,
0.7646392583847046,
-0.7151828408241272,
-0.13611067831516266,
0.3169795274734497,
0.16572079062461853,
0.4294871985912323,
-0.3150322735309601,
0.3290182054042816,
0.05229765921831131,
-0.4708000123500824,
-0.9410319328308105,
0.012110820040106773,
-0.41849032044410706,
-0.2821042835712433,
1.2412313222885132,
0.016712700948119164,
-0.20704828202724457,
0.0013718096306547523,
-0.14258038997650146,
0.2642386555671692,
-0.44975948333740234,
0.9618269801139832,
0.6941884756088257,
-0.2541903853416443,
-0.012296589091420174,
-0.5087801218032837,
0.5436848402023315,
0.4126145839691162,
-0.8105787634849548,
-0.01757059060037136,
0.6099863648414612,
0.20700262486934662,
0.257637083530426,
0.2437557727098465,
0.3852434456348419,
0.2536988854408264,
-0.09458611905574799,
-0.17955757677555084,
0.054819513112306595,
-0.500676691532135,
-0.44517403841018677,
0.10802172124385834,
0.454741507768631,
-0.2229509800672531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14836v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14836v2 | Stealthy Attack on Large Language Model based Recommendation | 2024-02-18T16:51:02 | 2024-06-05T17:02:47 | Jinghao Zhang, Yuting Liu, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Guibing Guo, Liang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Recently, the powerful large language models (LLMs) have been instrumental in
propelling the progress of recommender systems (RS). However, while these
systems have flourished, their susceptibility to security threats has been
largely overlooked. In this work, we reveal that the introduction of LLMs into
recommendation models presents new security vulnerabilities due to their
emphasis on the textual content of items. We demonstrate that attackers can
significantly boost an item's exposure by merely altering its textual content
during the testing phase, without requiring direct interference with the
model's training process. Additionally, the attack is notably stealthy, as it
does not affect the overall recommendation performance and the modifications to
the text are subtle, making it difficult for users and platforms to detect. Our
comprehensive experiments across four mainstream LLM-based recommendation
models demonstrate the superior efficacy and stealthiness of our approach. Our
work unveils a significant security gap in LLM-based recommendation systems and
paves the way for future research on protecting these systems. | [
-0.06824232637882233,
-0.8595433831214905,
0.7080867886543274,
-0.0010746580082923174,
-0.20983338356018066,
0.06616310775279999,
-0.05553214251995087,
-0.7984834909439087,
0.20501375198364258,
0.9963234663009644,
-0.6480494737625122,
-0.5906475186347961,
-0.74519944190979,
-0.1834462583065033,
-0.5101335048675537,
1.1489096879959106,
0.19875085353851318,
-0.23956048488616943,
0.003906434401869774,
-0.16623568534851074,
-0.4960131347179413,
-0.7814861536026001,
-0.42196422815322876,
-0.11172249913215637,
0.6881924867630005,
0.013222907669842243,
0.707430362701416,
0.28325963020324707,
0.8284975290298462,
0.23732005059719086,
-0.18896624445915222,
-0.0966295599937439,
-0.5381176471710205,
0.6524837613105774,
-0.2769964635372162,
-0.40985381603240967,
-0.6084921956062317,
-0.49326521158218384,
0.4678436815738678,
0.5876391530036926,
0.0009943287586793303,
0.08009295165538788,
0.24723729491233826,
0.7530506253242493,
-0.7877628207206726,
-0.19361934065818787,
-0.9137787222862244,
-0.13017912209033966,
-0.4960748255252838,
0.09300851821899414,
-0.8213796019554138,
0.10857903957366943,
0.24853913486003876,
-0.4558688998222351,
-0.16386666893959045,
0.29053133726119995,
0.6041712164878845,
0.051620133221149445,
-0.33872777223587036,
-0.3674071133136749,
-0.9817063808441162,
0.7552341222763062,
-0.46583619713783264,
0.4079492390155792,
0.6047325134277344,
0.24540865421295166,
-0.5197824835777283,
-0.6048923134803772,
-0.03273280709981918,
-0.549213707447052,
-0.05033194273710251,
-0.36919838190078735,
-0.6724621653556824,
0.07129368931055069,
0.22233015298843384,
0.2623787224292755,
-0.5198724865913391,
0.21910251677036285,
-0.02865343540906906,
-0.26664143800735474,
0.5440802574157715,
0.014353588223457336,
0.4342450201511383,
-0.007316527888178825,
-0.5488488078117371,
0.1308642327785492,
-0.9269479513168335,
-0.08662217855453491,
0.5203591585159302,
0.2715766727924347,
-0.14907531440258026,
0.7761483788490295,
-0.017219020053744316,
0.34238219261169434,
0.04755854234099388,
-0.05547484755516052,
-0.2748926877975464,
-0.5651717782020569,
-0.2432749718427658,
-0.05058678239583969,
0.877142071723938,
0.2752997577190399,
0.20305801928043365,
-0.07996128499507904,
-0.4341883063316345,
-0.29978713393211365,
0.2908719480037689,
-0.8845336437225342,
-0.16823311150074005,
0.09629934281110764,
-0.3882332742214203,
-0.6207941770553589,
0.1106564998626709,
-0.4067012369632721,
-0.8603407144546509,
0.5947380661964417,
0.4319176971912384,
-0.41020044684410095,
0.12289589643478394,
0.11826357990503311,
0.054063618183135986,
0.011622088961303234,
0.1575373113155365,
-0.9391686916351318,
0.4372689425945282,
0.7123633623123169,
0.6354367733001709,
-0.0643506795167923,
-0.07120656222105026,
-0.43150290846824646,
0.5674965381622314,
-0.4053184986114502,
0.7462174892425537,
-0.612587571144104,
-0.7433699369430542,
0.017920274287462234,
0.054126087576150894,
0.2848411500453949,
-0.363810271024704,
0.5300745368003845,
-0.8534771203994751,
-0.03420254588127136,
-0.30830326676368713,
-0.4496854543685913,
-0.12217280268669128,
0.3546161949634552,
-0.6218400001525879,
0.8449281454086304,
-0.22555944323539734,
-0.815079391002655,
0.183522030711174,
-0.37157943844795227,
-0.38517603278160095,
0.11166214942932129,
0.14880232512950897,
-0.31958287954330444,
0.02423316240310669,
0.3539063036441803,
0.4874248206615448,
-0.024223273620009422,
0.08305324614048004,
-0.7144180536270142,
-0.5847676992416382,
0.7290297746658325,
-0.6656110286712646,
0.47221651673316956,
0.0752963051199913,
-0.25206083059310913,
0.27680709958076477,
-0.5821135640144348,
-0.31730276346206665,
0.1819491982460022,
-0.0878700241446495,
-0.6748406887054443,
-0.06434720754623413,
-0.0919964537024498,
-0.3061331808567047,
0.6041305065155029,
-0.34503257274627686,
0.2605627477169037,
-0.6667906641960144,
0.22166414558887482,
1.0394681692123413,
0.35810035467147827,
0.6381995677947998,
-0.2909361720085144,
0.5190746784210205,
-0.31942909955978394,
0.3694128096103668,
-0.4960443377494812,
-0.3677818775177002,
-0.5143569111824036,
-0.4641229212284088,
0.2897821366786957,
0.4881848394870758,
-0.5297226309776306,
0.3811860680580139,
0.15033304691314697,
-0.6007687449455261,
-0.08047927170991898,
0.2851938307285309,
0.393615186214447,
-0.24811047315597534,
0.0021680037025362253,
0.007516839075833559,
-0.4019978940486908,
-0.7586771845817566,
-0.5897628664970398,
-0.25184229016304016,
-0.13059623539447784,
0.4134470522403717,
0.35589972138404846,
-0.6709924936294556,
0.37549400329589844,
-0.709492564201355,
-0.3084994852542877,
-0.34577488899230957,
-0.6097245216369629,
0.25921452045440674,
0.39328885078430176,
0.6310988068580627,
-0.3985646367073059,
-0.3697381317615509,
-0.16403870284557343,
-0.5023583769798279,
-0.21130616962909698,
-0.14401282370090485,
-0.180752232670784,
-0.05716109275817871,
0.6147125363349915,
-0.46073684096336365,
0.3554311692714691,
0.46031057834625244,
-0.634884238243103,
0.45558106899261475,
-0.33359023928642273,
-0.2173309326171875,
-0.9798225164413452,
-0.24595938622951508,
-0.055470336228609085,
-0.28807592391967773,
-0.5572060346603394,
0.3414480984210968,
0.08205857127904892,
-0.09854782372713089,
-0.25527018308639526,
0.7423995137214661,
-0.1943947970867157,
0.34807562828063965,
-0.24652889370918274,
-0.1685027778148651,
0.11633191257715225,
0.16533906757831573,
-0.594315767288208,
0.520150899887085,
0.7877376079559326,
-0.5558447241783142,
0.07179051637649536,
0.02379840612411499,
-0.29977184534072876,
0.518134593963623,
-0.7115395069122314,
0.3965964913368225,
0.17801611125469208,
0.4693867266178131,
-0.882340133190155,
-0.2250339388847351,
0.5925341248512268,
-0.1289921998977661,
0.37381604313850403,
-0.23152753710746765,
-0.49197375774383545,
0.17877136170864105,
-0.6829480528831482,
0.485852986574173,
0.24161402881145477,
-0.4711988866329193,
0.5492474436759949,
0.34354355931282043,
-0.2813909351825714,
-0.8153569102287292,
-0.6039074063301086,
0.4720172584056854,
-0.24062365293502808,
-0.547036349773407,
0.39649149775505066,
-0.5043980479240417,
-0.5416213870048523,
-0.327927827835083,
-0.21499158442020416,
0.02010967768728733,
0.6549713611602783,
0.7065663933753967,
0.43303966522216797,
0.04647057503461838,
-0.05262485891580582,
-0.2001287341117859,
-0.14696022868156433,
0.23398059606552124,
-0.49853038787841797,
0.4151552617549896,
0.06322920322418213,
-0.6506562829017639,
-0.4986061453819275,
0.28355854749679565,
0.5922068953514099,
-0.15269732475280762,
0.751596212387085,
0.42407312989234924,
-0.3014998435974121,
-0.602484941482544,
-0.5891175270080566,
-0.3566704988479614,
-0.6243736147880554,
0.6680145859718323,
-0.17763134837150574,
-0.895958423614502,
0.21641916036605835,
0.18148820102214813,
-0.08557458221912384,
0.19637690484523773,
0.30108481645584106,
-0.11640271544456482,
0.8856537342071533,
0.8716536164283752,
-0.12143884599208832,
0.6484624147415161,
0.1301228404045105,
0.150320902466774,
-0.6716359853744507,
-0.3580189347267151,
-0.43373551964759827,
-0.01600351370871067,
-0.81500244140625,
-0.11456824094057083,
0.18379253149032593,
-0.10777976363897324,
0.05811609700322151,
0.14253756403923035,
-0.35513070225715637,
0.5745342373847961,
0.4792962968349457,
0.35519158840179443,
0.3322984278202057,
-0.1288510113954544,
-0.15874187648296356,
-0.01802903227508068,
-0.36836540699005127,
-0.427425742149353,
1.4841002225875854,
0.547197163105011,
1.0537506341934204,
0.38567954301834106,
0.6006181240081787,
0.692308783531189,
-0.04032694175839424,
-0.6596214175224304,
0.7979547381401062,
-0.08557064086198807,
-0.34983888268470764,
-0.12079337239265442,
-0.07789566367864609,
-0.8799402713775635,
0.055775098502635956,
-0.3474060893058777,
-0.7511669397354126,
0.023875640705227852,
-0.26388484239578247,
-0.24702729284763336,
0.5409871935844421,
-0.5644292235374451,
0.39306870102882385,
-0.3872734010219574,
-0.5268775224685669,
-0.09513264894485474,
-0.21935132145881653,
0.3408845067024231,
-0.5261667966842651,
0.4524420201778412,
-0.04838945344090462,
-0.05433569476008415,
0.8604325652122498,
-0.41152602434158325,
0.988565981388092,
0.13434617221355438,
-0.34237509965896606,
-0.14853326976299286,
0.6917381882667542,
0.9549896121025085,
0.3025638461112976,
-0.017970198765397072,
0.25358355045318604,
-0.2106330692768097,
-0.49505266547203064,
-0.4256969690322876,
0.9765532612800598,
-0.3019103407859802,
-1.2218049764633179,
-0.5891865491867065,
-0.6052958965301514,
-0.08009693771600723,
0.4772498905658722,
-0.09969951957464218,
0.24872362613677979,
-0.3686085045337677,
0.47799786925315857,
0.9941163659095764,
-0.3538076877593994,
0.4765968918800354,
0.6123511791229248,
-0.36213359236717224,
-0.585655689239502,
0.8391269445419312,
0.010740594007074833,
0.2920531928539276,
0.363333135843277,
0.3285313546657562,
-0.12064528465270996,
-0.9770248532295227,
-0.29446789622306824,
0.2900993525981903,
-0.6691548824310303,
0.09606802463531494,
-0.6495797038078308,
-0.0380258709192276,
-0.36693158745765686,
-0.2817618250846863,
-0.0239516943693161,
-0.36116719245910645,
-0.12088043242692947,
-0.2658833861351013,
0.44842296838760376,
1.2263166904449463,
0.46056073904037476,
0.26897993683815,
-0.5752060413360596,
0.10920252650976181,
0.3646310567855835,
0.458048552274704,
-0.24865011870861053,
-0.6459502577781677,
-0.4101966619491577,
-0.32738566398620605,
-0.22400158643722534,
-0.9244425296783447,
0.14301486313343048,
-0.14791162312030792,
0.40223127603530884,
0.7606680989265442,
0.2585688829421997,
0.11967668682336807,
-0.5597256422042847,
0.9100779891014099,
-0.10096481442451477,
-0.6748266816139221,
0.36175888776779175,
-0.5417855978012085,
0.28169959783554077,
0.35787180066108704,
-0.042739950120449066,
-0.12054192274808884,
-0.5686345100402832,
-0.5297950506210327,
-0.7937399744987488,
0.5046163201332092,
0.2127372771501541,
0.4101157784461975,
0.3867277204990387,
0.20262181758880615,
0.14079082012176514,
0.24496084451675415,
-0.905022382736206,
-0.4679807722568512,
0.10655596852302551,
0.166709765791893,
-0.15432855486869812,
-0.8857726454734802,
-0.08833558112382889,
0.12307509779930115,
0.6936684250831604,
0.37631934881210327,
-0.297290176153183,
-0.014329844154417515,
0.04275911673903465,
0.14734815061092377,
0.5546505451202393,
0.5964270234107971,
0.15817780792713165,
-0.33339497447013855,
0.24023225903511047,
0.2848663330078125,
-0.6187911033630371,
0.19158360362052917,
-0.007468186318874359,
-0.4098602831363678,
-0.0267274659126997,
0.4905160963535309,
0.6385723948478699,
0.5417695641517639,
-0.5568503737449646,
0.5367242693901062,
-0.08723825216293335,
0.027073029428720474,
-0.45554473996162415,
0.0735626369714737,
-0.032675351947546005,
0.2100711613893509,
0.3186410367488861,
0.3585331439971924,
0.023931564763188362,
-0.49605122208595276,
0.05799112468957901,
0.8653780817985535,
-0.679599940776825,
-0.23711353540420532,
0.46410122513771057,
0.03432106971740723,
-0.4988643229007721,
-0.12160888314247131,
0.2393142133951187,
-0.49950602650642395,
0.2679802477359772,
0.6959677934646606,
1.0397157669067383,
-0.30354058742523193,
-0.021910909563302994,
-0.25771939754486084,
0.8850182890892029,
-0.02604489028453827,
-0.15563683211803436,
-0.15917238593101501,
-0.4360615909099579,
0.2754768431186676,
-0.5320598483085632,
-0.5438095927238464,
0.12522634863853455,
-0.399837851524353,
0.32311466336250305,
-0.7967498898506165,
-0.11330823600292206,
-0.07081080228090286,
-0.25623637437820435,
-0.2452535778284073,
-0.16776630282402039,
0.11487835645675659,
0.6880382299423218,
-0.32284435629844666,
0.7127301692962646,
0.3089209496974945,
-0.001478283666074276,
-0.420332133769989,
0.2754272222518921,
-0.000632523384410888,
-0.4644261300563812,
0.4224810004234314,
0.0883714035153389,
-0.33115124702453613,
-0.45812445878982544,
-0.29007285833358765,
-0.7770777940750122,
0.8713535070419312,
0.4689328372478485,
-0.5376121997833252,
0.04964439943432808,
0.21842430531978607,
0.3588649332523346,
-0.18900898098945618,
0.29151642322540283,
0.12106354534626007,
0.6064765453338623,
-0.14534170925617218,
-0.6077954769134521,
0.4030846357345581,
-0.13763990998268127,
-0.1299031674861908,
0.061825573444366455,
-0.4931079149246216,
0.6188117265701294,
-0.23794670403003693,
-0.08575749397277832,
-0.02769388258457184,
0.40177804231643677,
0.39020612835884094,
0.4819740355014801,
0.3710147738456726,
0.22694723308086395,
0.8385172486305237,
0.23680290579795837,
1.2081598043441772,
-0.03457377105951309,
-0.1885286569595337,
1.111993432044983,
-0.7305529117584229,
0.8063972592353821,
0.47204816341400146,
0.014930001460015774,
0.670759916305542,
0.472239226102829,
-0.296310693025589,
0.43520036339759827,
0.2388051301240921,
-0.41730383038520813,
-0.16553986072540283,
-0.15926729142665863,
-0.4522957503795624,
0.16252285242080688,
0.3713253140449524,
-0.5822163820266724,
0.12168765813112259,
0.062368299812078476,
0.3508339822292328,
0.13840320706367493,
-0.25025060772895813,
0.9176305532455444,
0.24023935198783875,
-0.22947412729263306,
0.5429835319519043,
0.20658475160598755,
0.8078600764274597,
-1.0906124114990234,
0.13974802196025848,
0.006723195314407349,
0.18473513424396515,
-0.2916173040866852,
-0.37957727909088135,
-0.07689560204744339,
0.046400848776102066,
-0.4369048774242401,
-0.2420792281627655,
0.9341517090797424,
0.022796547040343285,
-0.7308522462844849,
0.5776666402816772,
0.24821123480796814,
-0.27020737528800964,
-0.269138365983963,
-0.4714953601360321,
0.0753079503774643,
0.044217247515916824,
-0.31542399525642395,
0.703178882598877,
0.1642759144306183,
-0.249262273311615,
0.9675582051277161,
1.0617066621780396,
0.20633137226104736,
-0.2655635476112366,
0.03634544089436531,
0.7194582223892212,
-0.5955572724342346,
-0.6456518173217773,
-1.4045627117156982,
-0.04053651541471481,
-0.0408378504216671,
0.25084492564201355,
1.353775978088379,
0.3206004202365875,
0.76640385389328,
0.17562048137187958,
0.703483521938324,
0.6728207468986511,
0.103640615940094,
-0.5521706938743591,
1.2593640089035034,
-0.17207901179790497,
1.4773026704788208,
-0.5077593326568604,
-0.6350886821746826,
-0.27602440118789673,
-0.40297719836235046,
-0.28482264280319214,
0.16706091165542603,
0.835113525390625,
1.0469410419464111,
0.18244805932044983,
-0.2534582316875458,
0.46551313996315,
0.5160890221595764,
0.48446106910705566,
0.32443904876708984,
0.805662214756012,
-0.3306158483028412,
0.7730708122253418,
-0.08352483063936234,
-0.07658638805150986,
-0.3607688546180725,
-0.8099289536476135,
-1.277756690979004,
-0.09336037933826447,
-0.14818742871284485,
-0.6727001667022705,
0.4703653156757355,
0.5839732885360718,
0.4530109167098999,
-0.8207094669342041,
-0.29116538166999817,
0.22400321066379547,
0.4404541254043579,
-0.18718858063220978,
-0.17176468670368195,
0.3831627070903778,
0.3837219476699829,
-0.2808820605278015,
0.9739708304405212,
0.3402903378009796,
0.25561243295669556,
-0.4707809388637543,
0.10315719991922379,
-0.05485822260379791,
0.508518397808075,
0.15199586749076843,
-0.08770883828401566,
-0.8924355506896973,
-0.1673477739095688,
0.03324773535132408,
-0.18618059158325195,
-0.344066858291626,
0.7358769774436951,
-0.6475729942321777,
0.4404175579547882,
0.2697087824344635,
0.5246065258979797,
0.2345140129327774,
-0.2508012652397156,
0.7485120892524719,
-0.6906733512878418,
0.21953874826431274,
-0.1109004020690918,
0.5147486329078674,
0.28308168053627014,
-0.857027530670166,
0.10424122959375381,
0.07660746574401855,
-0.3943174183368683,
-1.2765393257141113,
0.36160632967948914,
-0.9635326862335205,
-0.4972379505634308,
1.24509859085083,
-0.11851099133491516,
-0.21115392446517944,
-0.23649512231349945,
-0.41312816739082336,
-0.3550557792186737,
-0.6051708459854126,
0.7472242116928101,
0.6230565905570984,
0.5140405893325806,
0.2092779129743576,
-0.5031665563583374,
0.47330889105796814,
0.470680296421051,
-0.3672097325325012,
0.1850254088640213,
0.04763055220246315,
0.37354353070259094,
-0.1136271134018898,
0.33579251170158386,
-0.05501024052500725,
0.17133821547031403,
-0.16292844712734222,
-0.3027946949005127,
-0.3704472482204437,
-0.33598968386650085,
-0.6391454339027405,
0.48728084564208984,
0.36844775080680847,
-0.07228527963161469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11639v2 | In-Context Learning with Transformers: Softmax Attention Adapts to Function Lipschitzness | 2024-02-18T16:37:32 | 2024-05-28T05:15:53 | Liam Collins, Advait Parulekar, Aryan Mokhtari, Sujay Sanghavi, Sanjay Shakkottai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | A striking property of transformers is their ability to perform in-context
learning (ICL), a machine learning framework in which the learner is presented
with a novel context during inference implicitly through some data, and tasked
with making a prediction in that context. As such, that learner must adapt to
the context without additional training. We explore the role of softmax
attention in an ICL setting where each context encodes a regression task. We
show that an attention unit learns a window that it uses to implement a
nearest-neighbors predictor adapted to the landscape of the pretraining tasks.
Specifically, we show that this window widens with decreasing Lipschitzness and
increasing label noise in the pretraining tasks. We also show that on low-rank,
linear problems, the attention unit learns to project onto the appropriate
subspace before inference. Further, we show that this adaptivity relies
crucially on the softmax activation and thus cannot be replicated by the linear
activation often studied in prior theoretical analyses. | [
-0.633992075920105,
-0.369577556848526,
0.32806530594825745,
-0.03167085349559784,
0.1989995539188385,
-0.24836748838424683,
-0.3793841600418091,
-0.24254964292049408,
-0.2721157968044281,
0.3025696277618408,
-0.8338128924369812,
-0.1196352168917656,
-0.4754590392112732,
-0.024001345038414,
-0.2773793935775757,
1.3468343019485474,
0.08657519519329071,
-0.18630997836589813,
-0.42142418026924133,
-0.404661625623703,
-0.38071373105049133,
-0.32207074761390686,
-0.22738173604011536,
-0.3152424693107605,
0.23049350082874298,
0.6955791115760803,
0.6993343830108643,
0.13669538497924805,
0.37476909160614014,
0.3745938539505005,
0.2244827300310135,
-0.1930130273103714,
-0.7333429455757141,
0.13436013460159302,
-0.02069328911602497,
-0.6147907376289368,
-0.27410802245140076,
-0.0021632101852446795,
0.8226584196090698,
0.9844972491264343,
0.1765943318605423,
0.30893877148628235,
0.6170991659164429,
0.6189243793487549,
-0.6009789705276489,
0.18491539359092712,
-0.8528769016265869,
0.44675832986831665,
0.32896730303764343,
-0.06237577646970749,
-0.4479382336139679,
-0.027415495365858078,
0.451267808675766,
-0.5983923673629761,
0.5191850066184998,
-0.269025981426239,
0.634857714176178,
0.8846226930618286,
-0.36543402075767517,
0.018533796072006226,
-0.9796715974807739,
0.9746206998825073,
-0.2077312171459198,
0.594939649105072,
0.10594738274812698,
0.3208424746990204,
0.005387870129197836,
-0.8763096928596497,
-0.05366969853639603,
-0.32895463705062866,
-0.22338789701461792,
0.2551618814468384,
-0.015257968567311764,
0.14207829535007477,
0.6271122694015503,
-0.036218058317899704,
-0.24640755355358124,
-0.020723363384604454,
-0.3365037739276886,
-0.0055401260033249855,
0.18795129656791687,
0.031209155917167664,
-0.14596065878868103,
0.31562405824661255,
-0.67153000831604,
-0.10343952476978302,
-0.4218738377094269,
0.38434451818466187,
-0.10966244339942932,
0.34371840953826904,
-0.008700462989509106,
0.0000045557994781120215,
0.0830187201499939,
0.647737443447113,
0.2844204604625702,
-0.3293163776397705,
0.3443717658519745,
0.1388402283191681,
-0.36297866702079773,
0.1440989077091217,
0.16567525267601013,
0.05615091323852539,
0.3255968987941742,
-0.3472267687320709,
-0.3370375633239746,
-0.2411547303199768,
0.5395679473876953,
-0.720802366733551,
0.15350939333438873,
-0.04787507653236389,
-0.5256059765815735,
0.04130879044532776,
0.06174847483634949,
-0.5692060589790344,
0.00468624709174037,
-0.6581437587738037,
0.624971330165863,
-0.21696418523788452,
-0.183839812874794,
-0.28369683027267456,
0.04711592197418213,
0.43036338686943054,
0.11153239756822586,
-0.7916131019592285,
0.6154230833053589,
0.5310017466545105,
0.7484854459762573,
-0.12367778271436691,
-0.5630676746368408,
-0.5560051798820496,
0.15905678272247314,
-0.12424048781394958,
0.6165194511413574,
-0.31149449944496155,
-0.19802652299404144,
0.1720503717660904,
0.11940547823905945,
-0.37797755002975464,
-0.7416936755180359,
0.30371975898742676,
-0.31041982769966125,
-0.008469576016068459,
0.017684120684862137,
-0.2212403565645218,
0.13474036753177643,
-0.0410698838531971,
-0.537632942199707,
0.9754375219345093,
0.6087549924850464,
-0.5702528357505798,
0.6390469074249268,
-0.7071713209152222,
-0.6171113848686218,
-0.02185164950788021,
0.11065024137496948,
-0.6612287759780884,
0.4920773506164551,
-0.03227520361542702,
0.5018057227134705,
0.13341590762138367,
0.1019337922334671,
-0.4388347864151001,
-0.5124536156654358,
0.5118206143379211,
-0.32791996002197266,
0.39235514402389526,
0.030865246430039406,
-0.6435688138008118,
0.32346606254577637,
-0.5861284136772156,
-0.22345785796642303,
-0.1373414844274521,
0.07771042734384537,
-0.10957210510969162,
0.07383637875318527,
0.20916107296943665,
0.24801066517829895,
-0.020754791796207428,
-0.20808559656143188,
0.10358422249555588,
-0.48697933554649353,
0.4910857677459717,
0.9352599382400513,
-0.38066598773002625,
0.7752412557601929,
-0.1528196483850479,
0.5003881454467773,
-0.03962992876768112,
0.47087740898132324,
0.00789832416921854,
-0.11200784146785736,
-0.906126081943512,
-0.08556812256574631,
0.11643677204847336,
0.38839539885520935,
-0.5648723244667053,
0.10325228422880173,
-0.22897060215473175,
-0.24024872481822968,
-0.3013838231563568,
0.2706354558467865,
0.3326229453086853,
0.8202526569366455,
0.4759337306022644,
-0.22028093039989471,
-0.5532858967781067,
-0.942453920841217,
-0.10395322740077972,
0.34137895703315735,
-0.2267080694437027,
0.5583925843238831,
0.4370185434818268,
-0.2793842554092407,
1.1000484228134155,
-0.6089941263198853,
-0.8283784985542297,
-0.37488147616386414,
-0.14275972545146942,
0.2141236662864685,
0.4541557729244232,
0.5684494376182556,
-1.1114027500152588,
-0.6164276599884033,
-0.3030499517917633,
-0.5509113073348999,
0.029111729934811592,
-0.17869757115840912,
-0.00813446193933487,
-0.07152193039655685,
0.9731070399284363,
-0.3473209738731384,
0.4509482979774475,
0.2841135263442993,
-0.06921517103910446,
0.28499627113342285,
-0.16497890651226044,
-0.4535161852836609,
-0.977821946144104,
-0.03797013685107231,
0.2728279232978821,
-0.3449210822582245,
-0.8629551529884338,
-0.18946202099323273,
-0.031201058998703957,
-0.23092496395111084,
-0.4473619759082794,
0.42981576919555664,
-0.27286019921302795,
-0.4551713466644287,
-0.38524967432022095,
0.06386517733335495,
-0.3075256645679474,
0.7407568097114563,
0.0608377642929554,
0.8323537111282349,
0.6287679076194763,
-0.6024891138076782,
-0.19889318943023682,
0.20316608250141144,
-0.19225339591503143,
0.5370234251022339,
-0.45829662680625916,
0.13431721925735474,
-0.4057127833366394,
0.29275456070899963,
-0.9809362888336182,
-0.1338988095521927,
-0.11168278008699417,
-0.3737064599990845,
0.5342446565628052,
-0.1637374758720398,
-0.1323012113571167,
-0.3180285692214966,
-0.2670164108276367,
0.3938007652759552,
0.6305884718894958,
-0.6031790375709534,
0.7420972585678101,
0.34263333678245544,
0.30747517943382263,
-0.7585684657096863,
-0.6950612664222717,
-0.3710266351699829,
-0.4610731601715088,
-0.2250426858663559,
0.5468116402626038,
-0.1864776462316513,
-0.061815984547138214,
0.08364308625459671,
-0.1948540061712265,
-0.34164169430732727,
0.388492226600647,
0.5555323362350464,
0.13074631989002228,
-0.5011957287788391,
0.1260315179824829,
-0.19973349571228027,
-0.4268110692501068,
0.07234080135822296,
-0.4274786114692688,
0.19817933440208435,
-0.4848284125328064,
-0.012653863988816738,
-0.2541348934173584,
0.09417051076889038,
0.6785976886749268,
0.03296886757016182,
0.7126378417015076,
0.9005690813064575,
-0.4553478956222534,
-0.5213242769241333,
-0.34922048449516296,
-0.5276615023612976,
-0.5605584979057312,
0.48838987946510315,
-0.5090190768241882,
-0.7489973902702332,
0.38721388578414917,
-0.14925837516784668,
-0.19758422672748566,
0.23214730620384216,
0.5041907429695129,
-0.11161155253648758,
1.1943721771240234,
1.1320801973342896,
-0.18900255858898163,
0.79472416639328,
-0.415368914604187,
0.12367221713066101,
-1.1049915552139282,
-0.14427226781845093,
-0.4511343836784363,
-0.608793318271637,
-0.5818540453910828,
0.007268507964909077,
0.5652677416801453,
-0.2086811363697052,
-0.3427293300628662,
0.40340036153793335,
-0.5088029503822327,
0.4622591435909271,
0.5641950368881226,
0.21661530435085297,
-0.08445727080106735,
-0.060564685612916946,
0.13753890991210938,
-0.30360788106918335,
-0.8607237339019775,
0.013609681278467178,
0.8530803322792053,
0.28537583351135254,
0.6475591063499451,
-0.18634894490242004,
0.2512466609477997,
0.12850938737392426,
0.8939077854156494,
-0.7840951681137085,
0.3624425232410431,
-0.04498321935534477,
-0.45915547013282776,
-0.2639053761959076,
-0.2024402618408203,
-1.0387581586837769,
0.21403546631336212,
-0.056495435535907745,
-0.8874664306640625,
0.1809181421995163,
0.20204558968544006,
-0.3549952507019043,
0.1709955632686615,
-0.8805731534957886,
1.0094243288040161,
-0.06603911519050598,
-0.6540715098381042,
-0.1379650980234146,
-0.8048399090766907,
0.09977124631404877,
-0.09362263977527618,
0.160790354013443,
-0.12132513523101807,
-0.3187168538570404,
0.4842679500579834,
0.029129531234502792,
1.04373037815094,
-0.4991905093193054,
0.38377177715301514,
0.12985651195049286,
-0.020148754119873047,
0.11045530438423157,
0.1971098929643631,
0.17345377802848816,
-0.27969080209732056,
-0.38146817684173584,
-0.46727925539016724,
-0.631729781627655,
0.6467322111129761,
-0.8647672533988953,
-0.641273021697998,
-0.3475465476512909,
-0.8016647100448608,
-0.5974503755569458,
0.10965064913034439,
0.2628956437110901,
0.672764241695404,
-0.13853183388710022,
0.4541381001472473,
0.8742706775665283,
0.056184008717536926,
0.5522836446762085,
0.37041163444519043,
0.19696049392223358,
0.016599135473370552,
0.8899637460708618,
0.16709747910499573,
0.27049359679222107,
0.3899329602718353,
0.18692737817764282,
-0.15717899799346924,
-0.424810528755188,
-0.22696375846862793,
-0.13897016644477844,
-0.8169847726821899,
-0.3015673756599426,
-0.5229360461235046,
-0.3682079613208771,
-0.15555022656917572,
-0.5950356125831604,
-0.3195171058177948,
-0.009779739193618298,
-0.371976375579834,
0.016141118481755257,
-0.022484449669718742,
0.6169257760047913,
-0.016498371958732605,
0.2502753436565399,
-0.49969175457954407,
0.2277660369873047,
0.4948546588420868,
0.3780392110347748,
0.08914926648139954,
-0.7065399289131165,
-0.40453654527664185,
-0.42310917377471924,
-0.29623541235923767,
-0.6145787835121155,
0.3624576926231384,
0.6187165379524231,
0.650557279586792,
0.3994552195072174,
0.039970654994249344,
0.6096665263175964,
-0.574508786201477,
0.47124576568603516,
0.013700745068490505,
-1.0372713804244995,
0.3484615087509155,
0.025174995884299278,
0.5628851056098938,
0.763956606388092,
0.6590447425842285,
-0.18765246868133545,
-0.2880086302757263,
-0.6573964953422546,
-0.6636042594909668,
0.8045793175697327,
-0.04111034423112869,
0.45304012298583984,
0.483220636844635,
0.46366527676582336,
0.2786407470703125,
0.0951782613992691,
-0.9646022915840149,
-0.16521884500980377,
-0.3875278830528259,
-0.28763169050216675,
-0.2737897038459778,
-0.22391827404499054,
0.0052710664458572865,
-0.5476211905479431,
0.406269907951355,
-0.6250399947166443,
0.36939817667007446,
0.42267096042633057,
-0.5457362532615662,
-0.06319188326597214,
0.01443567406386137,
0.5507882237434387,
0.7181451320648193,
-0.27465367317199707,
0.10016918927431107,
0.6944072842597961,
-0.35670316219329834,
0.09464991092681885,
0.12272397428750992,
-0.20416462421417236,
-0.30832579731941223,
0.4885881543159485,
0.8613065481185913,
0.6412394642829895,
-0.6216445565223694,
0.6505777835845947,
-0.15615464746952057,
-0.21990060806274414,
-0.3881485164165497,
0.17107786238193512,
-0.3155968189239502,
0.3495156764984131,
0.6917634606361389,
0.40721556544303894,
0.32613393664360046,
-0.5025399923324585,
0.4197835326194763,
0.5022032260894775,
-1.1678413152694702,
-0.4294218122959137,
0.7525548934936523,
-0.0035899891518056393,
-0.33839085698127747,
0.4902064800262451,
0.023197490721940994,
-0.7800350785255432,
0.8711772561073303,
0.7848258018493652,
0.9159657955169678,
-0.26943454146385193,
-0.09162132441997528,
0.3166521191596985,
0.3138693869113922,
0.40728816390037537,
-0.30205291509628296,
-0.4350707232952118,
-0.6567366123199463,
-0.5554386973381042,
-0.4580850303173065,
-0.3029318153858185,
0.2331176996231079,
-0.6738625168800354,
0.23356109857559204,
-0.41562536358833313,
-0.08962620794773102,
-0.027919499203562737,
-0.2446487843990326,
-0.9549967646598816,
0.23059171438217163,
0.3264918327331543,
0.7318978309631348,
-0.8608508706092834,
0.8713222742080688,
0.5453692078590393,
-0.02281440794467926,
-0.4538102149963379,
0.45321303606033325,
-0.22757890820503235,
-0.6571218371391296,
0.6776042580604553,
0.737064778804779,
-0.181887686252594,
0.10558553785085678,
-0.5568709373474121,
-0.9640198945999146,
0.9273154735565186,
0.43281954526901245,
-0.29669880867004395,
0.24936677515506744,
0.11085619777441025,
0.5553916692733765,
-0.507404625415802,
0.3062102496623993,
0.5285747051239014,
0.2296248972415924,
-0.30627015233039856,
-0.7958694696426392,
-0.09823443740606308,
0.07135886698961258,
-0.032955024391412735,
0.1430416852235794,
-0.8265160918235779,
0.6105045080184937,
-0.2646963596343994,
0.09863438457250595,
-0.16162236034870148,
0.8845587372779846,
-0.4154303967952728,
0.41065844893455505,
0.8307844400405884,
0.13939988613128662,
0.3200935423374176,
-0.10099107027053833,
1.0045747756958008,
-0.2939499020576477,
0.41713008284568787,
0.9441590905189514,
-0.23945938050746918,
0.5486047267913818,
0.3741733729839325,
-0.10513400286436081,
0.536903977394104,
0.29275986552238464,
0.11397753655910492,
0.6983941793441772,
-0.06069130077958107,
-0.11383163183927536,
-0.05293237045407295,
-0.20904536545276642,
-0.2802482843399048,
0.49344250559806824,
0.5831261873245239,
-0.22789418697357178,
-0.0165832731872797,
0.71253502368927,
-0.3470458984375,
0.051762741059064865,
-0.4504133462905884,
0.8662779927253723,
0.16970083117485046,
-0.9233043193817139,
0.45250213146209717,
-0.4244515895843506,
0.6000142693519592,
-0.5670533776283264,
0.11026588082313538,
-0.1210145428776741,
0.7196738123893738,
-0.2569895088672638,
-0.569979727268219,
0.44672873616218567,
-0.4743083715438843,
-0.22668835520744324,
-0.4379076659679413,
1.0582294464111328,
-0.2283368706703186,
-0.273082971572876,
0.4711175560951233,
0.37520912289619446,
-0.26439011096954346,
0.060188524425029755,
-0.9124694466590881,
-0.07337067276239395,
-0.035969264805316925,
-0.40799978375434875,
0.6441060900688171,
0.04245776683092117,
0.23340004682540894,
0.7489806413650513,
0.3589021861553192,
-0.5467815399169922,
-0.042396802455186844,
0.019271982833743095,
0.8961037397384644,
-0.4272703230381012,
-0.20667269825935364,
-0.7141460180282593,
0.394727498292923,
0.0742669478058815,
-0.4169957637786865,
0.6294612884521484,
0.5328958034515381,
1.016750454902649,
-0.31689146161079407,
0.546794593334198,
0.14510416984558105,
0.19627389311790466,
-0.38708093762397766,
0.1954854279756546,
-0.6419084668159485,
-0.1778859943151474,
-0.0970168337225914,
-1.2289501428604126,
-0.3207901120185852,
0.5969277024269104,
-0.42855626344680786,
0.09327711164951324,
0.7627455592155457,
0.7177501916885376,
-0.43549844622612,
-0.2810242176055908,
0.34737908840179443,
0.22264759242534637,
-0.002702790079638362,
0.7747019529342651,
0.813202977180481,
-0.22971682250499725,
0.6598316431045532,
-0.4805399775505066,
-0.24945633113384247,
-0.41002440452575684,
-0.6628919839859009,
-0.9416604042053223,
-0.9380913376808167,
-0.20635761320590973,
-0.6370335817337036,
-0.11019304394721985,
0.8750929832458496,
1.1259394884109497,
-0.6854894757270813,
-0.21660082042217255,
-0.03670745715498924,
0.16059255599975586,
-0.4182250499725342,
-0.29418858885765076,
0.32538920640945435,
-0.751720130443573,
-0.8242573738098145,
0.39846134185791016,
0.3292754292488098,
-0.14129552245140076,
-0.32041287422180176,
-0.05925004184246063,
0.3000817894935608,
-0.15273626148700714,
0.6603012681007385,
0.3417443335056305,
-0.31678307056427,
-0.257273405790329,
-0.054562103003263474,
-0.06226286664605141,
0.5025988817214966,
1.1066868305206299,
-1.1175997257232666,
0.22954653203487396,
0.15346743166446686,
0.6060318350791931,
0.9647954106330872,
-0.23569296300411224,
0.34163007140159607,
-0.8096416592597961,
0.7424790263175964,
0.3747485876083374,
0.34676072001457214,
0.35001063346862793,
-0.339928537607193,
0.43191128969192505,
0.12888430058956146,
-0.7071977853775024,
-0.9191802144050598,
0.28218576312065125,
-0.8057668209075928,
-0.4385351538658142,
0.9366539716720581,
0.15353697538375854,
-0.5242468118667603,
-0.3099726140499115,
-0.10261169075965881,
0.038912754505872726,
-0.16689085960388184,
0.5809190273284912,
0.25958478450775146,
-0.1874544322490692,
-0.030506283044815063,
-0.8660663366317749,
0.9086278676986694,
0.8213194012641907,
-0.5648176074028015,
-0.1931213140487671,
-0.07605523616075516,
0.3130543529987335,
0.0855100005865097,
0.26253610849380493,
0.38627201318740845,
0.2860168218612671,
-0.14576275646686554,
-0.3839942514896393,
0.1970069855451584,
-0.5454939007759094,
-0.3514752686023712,
0.3953966498374939,
0.1852969080209732,
0.009229405783116817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11638v1 | Stumbling Blocks: Stress Testing the Robustness of Machine-Generated Text Detectors Under Attacks | 2024-02-18T16:36:00 | 2024-02-18T16:36:00 | Yichen Wang, Shangbin Feng, Abe Bohan Hou, Xiao Pu, Chao Shen, Xiaoming Liu, Yulia Tsvetkov, Tianxing He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread use of large language models (LLMs) is increasing the demand
for methods that detect machine-generated text to prevent misuse. The goal of
our study is to stress test the detectors' robustness to malicious attacks
under realistic scenarios. We comprehensively study the robustness of popular
machine-generated text detectors under attacks from diverse categories:
editing, paraphrasing, prompting, and co-generating. Our attacks assume limited
access to the generator LLMs, and we compare the performance of detectors on
different attacks under different budget levels. Our experiments reveal that
almost none of the existing detectors remain robust under all the attacks, and
all detectors exhibit different loopholes. Averaging all detectors, the
performance drops by 35% across all attacks. Further, we investigate the
reasons behind these defects and propose initial out-of-the-box patches to
improve robustness. | [
-0.40702927112579346,
-1.0885900259017944,
0.6053408980369568,
-0.07860342413187027,
-0.17702333629131317,
0.011304079554975033,
-0.0666566789150238,
-0.49544861912727356,
-0.27944061160087585,
0.6055096983909607,
-0.4276680648326874,
-0.4086434841156006,
-0.8858907222747803,
0.6072748303413391,
-0.6276825666427612,
0.8958263397216797,
-0.1226828321814537,
-0.2845672070980072,
-0.24942199885845184,
0.11400482058525085,
-0.44336989521980286,
-0.7193644642829895,
-0.5747295022010803,
0.03510740399360657,
0.4265657663345337,
0.20593297481536865,
0.6344178318977356,
0.35359081625938416,
0.8347005844116211,
0.2928822338581085,
-0.17385214567184448,
0.007614739239215851,
-0.3333211839199066,
0.5340989232063293,
-0.05054754018783569,
-0.3555012047290802,
-0.2401142120361328,
-0.41937315464019775,
0.47072651982307434,
0.19420365989208221,
0.32572004199028015,
-0.10393720865249634,
0.23442821204662323,
0.17053091526031494,
-0.7923683524131775,
-0.37388646602630615,
-1.1977494955062866,
-0.18831126391887665,
-0.5398260951042175,
-0.294187068939209,
-0.6931560039520264,
-0.10532781481742859,
-0.2161797732114792,
-0.19485785067081451,
0.2604447305202484,
0.0791216790676117,
0.7905318737030029,
0.46448519825935364,
-0.2694166600704193,
-0.741759717464447,
-0.6369361877441406,
0.7935071587562561,
-0.4917728006839752,
0.034741852432489395,
0.545673668384552,
0.049073439091444016,
-0.4187900722026825,
-0.6852903962135315,
-0.28099554777145386,
-0.5163463950157166,
0.17511947453022003,
-0.15576888620853424,
-0.49090859293937683,
0.1039491668343544,
0.5849928259849548,
0.3909560739994049,
-0.6724902987480164,
0.19800913333892822,
0.04586141183972359,
-0.37209352850914,
0.45756134390830994,
0.21569804847240448,
0.5238006711006165,
-0.2880859673023224,
-0.31944429874420166,
-0.24260568618774414,
-0.7772161364555359,
-0.17087727785110474,
0.6384540796279907,
0.17637383937835693,
0.1798861175775528,
0.5816587209701538,
0.17488037049770355,
0.697816789150238,
-0.19018828868865967,
-0.216069296002388,
-0.35905957221984863,
-0.3483545482158661,
-0.3296642005443573,
-0.22637836635112762,
0.9268462657928467,
0.24949325621128082,
0.2786500155925751,
0.04208695515990257,
-0.3480689823627472,
-0.00018899329006671906,
0.37007859349250793,
-0.7276768684387207,
-0.282028466463089,
0.23559679090976715,
-0.197071835398674,
-0.7564894556999207,
-0.10136372596025467,
-0.7190661430358887,
-0.7031261920928955,
0.5761721730232239,
0.30414560437202454,
-0.5640854239463806,
-0.019845522940158844,
0.05781181529164314,
-0.18191981315612793,
-0.069109708070755,
0.03671907261013985,
-0.6078596711158752,
0.17173348367214203,
0.4334923326969147,
0.6943758130073547,
-0.16846692562103271,
-0.2284131497144699,
-0.636968731880188,
-0.10656800866127014,
-0.18696188926696777,
0.9462795853614807,
-0.37257158756256104,
-0.6624296307563782,
0.17405526340007782,
-0.22311902046203613,
-0.024297865107655525,
-0.674613893032074,
0.9803557991981506,
-0.5088129639625549,
-0.13991177082061768,
-0.2395431250333786,
-0.5401243567466736,
0.41354772448539734,
0.44429317116737366,
-0.7923052310943604,
1.1370571851730347,
0.0047150044701993465,
-1.116387963294983,
0.25246402621269226,
-0.3428037464618683,
-0.5846940875053406,
-0.17898954451084137,
-0.03214035928249359,
-0.7070717811584473,
0.1493917554616928,
0.3298872709274292,
0.3743545114994049,
-0.18040193617343903,
0.24368120729923248,
-0.43911632895469666,
-0.39298808574676514,
0.7649915218353271,
-0.5289220809936523,
0.8113132119178772,
0.31748732924461365,
-0.41381707787513733,
-0.0026962680276483297,
-0.8872557282447815,
-0.3134382963180542,
0.3473827838897705,
-0.3296472132205963,
-0.37554869055747986,
0.2541496157646179,
0.24039585888385773,
-0.00456508994102478,
-0.017987383529543877,
-0.4689771831035614,
0.003212161362171173,
-0.27590522170066833,
0.23700851202011108,
0.8795920014381409,
0.2471877783536911,
-0.09074109047651291,
-0.31610366702079773,
0.7240888476371765,
0.029421396553516388,
0.04304508492350578,
-0.44223979115486145,
-0.48663726449012756,
-0.4836313724517822,
-0.21717508137226105,
0.1222112774848938,
0.5427412390708923,
-0.8823096752166748,
0.3724520206451416,
0.1395137757062912,
-0.41588136553764343,
-0.06552247703075409,
0.2666177749633789,
0.4456973969936371,
0.40975889563560486,
0.2548842132091522,
-0.1882830709218979,
-0.6207326650619507,
-0.5742184519767761,
-0.873833417892456,
-0.263807088136673,
-0.1787692755460739,
0.01232750341296196,
0.5789783596992493,
-0.263125479221344,
0.7235665321350098,
-0.4057874381542206,
0.18660451471805573,
-0.30681535601615906,
-0.03675025701522827,
-0.2182568907737732,
0.4086885452270508,
0.5928040146827698,
-0.3900892436504364,
-0.29351806640625,
-0.41841626167297363,
-0.623869001865387,
-0.3691959083080292,
-0.2650538384914398,
0.311361700296402,
0.347994327545166,
0.6791440844535828,
-0.5472398400306702,
0.4581666886806488,
0.5848076343536377,
-0.419864684343338,
0.831150472164154,
0.12173115462064743,
-0.1466268002986908,
-1.1694415807724,
-0.10509564727544785,
0.03099258802831173,
-0.285940021276474,
-0.6077466607093811,
0.31499677896499634,
-0.11450383812189102,
-0.34458020329475403,
-0.2804446816444397,
0.17620010673999786,
-0.4031578302383423,
0.06615069508552551,
-0.39483189582824707,
0.05113175883889198,
0.032671838998794556,
0.11603432893753052,
-0.4820241928100586,
0.6927564144134521,
0.535588264465332,
-0.5753490328788757,
0.07281956076622009,
-0.25470349192619324,
-0.4363648593425751,
0.7577643990516663,
-0.7102482318878174,
0.3862532377243042,
0.08778712898492813,
0.18493427336215973,
-1.1023088693618774,
-0.42667996883392334,
0.29830673336982727,
-0.44017744064331055,
0.42073318362236023,
-0.061558883637189865,
-0.69952392578125,
-0.2100573033094406,
-0.5086789727210999,
0.11657482385635376,
0.35895419120788574,
-0.5162025094032288,
0.36159756779670715,
0.3486388623714447,
-0.12204485386610031,
-0.5362112522125244,
-0.6671380400657654,
0.46601685881614685,
-0.3127306401729584,
-0.7088815569877625,
0.013249587267637253,
-0.16135622560977936,
-0.509798526763916,
-0.05398699268698692,
-0.10576537996530533,
-0.08363581448793411,
0.6371061205863953,
0.1991260051727295,
0.1479533463716507,
-0.06964392215013504,
-0.10827929526567459,
-0.18600235879421234,
0.0018098155269399285,
0.22667817771434784,
-0.13343465328216553,
0.6122496724128723,
0.08382310718297958,
-0.6835498213768005,
-0.43587160110473633,
0.3421361446380615,
0.7073230743408203,
-0.0855315700173378,
0.4979267120361328,
0.46980002522468567,
-0.5079175233840942,
-0.21118669211864471,
-0.45949921011924744,
-0.15510384738445282,
-0.5290683507919312,
0.5408177971839905,
-0.655161440372467,
-1.0387784242630005,
0.38840386271476746,
0.018054770305752754,
0.16767901182174683,
0.43529263138771057,
0.5017349123954773,
-0.07679221034049988,
0.9739148020744324,
0.4277763068675995,
0.00904459971934557,
0.2929602861404419,
0.2931196391582489,
0.2600456476211548,
-0.5799350142478943,
0.019692035391926765,
-0.9296750426292419,
0.031835995614528656,
-0.666877269744873,
-0.3520943820476532,
0.02068793773651123,
0.09331009536981583,
0.03931314870715141,
0.4568009674549103,
-0.5239096283912659,
0.5273900032043457,
0.3534860610961914,
-0.145558699965477,
0.29691076278686523,
0.07640387862920761,
-0.12326505035161972,
-0.07550165802240372,
-0.4261617958545685,
-0.6761459708213806,
1.233680009841919,
0.44069430232048035,
0.9895856976509094,
-0.14422732591629028,
0.8634125590324402,
0.15312950313091278,
0.10224217921495438,
-0.5549662709236145,
0.586968719959259,
0.02788200043141842,
-0.7250688672065735,
0.04880485311150551,
-0.4121851623058319,
-0.9598807692527771,
-0.09538861364126205,
-0.1381022036075592,
-0.8536264300346375,
0.04984443262219429,
0.26475298404693604,
-0.14339688420295715,
0.7396311163902283,
-0.5092041492462158,
0.6311944127082825,
-0.13418281078338623,
-0.14130450785160065,
0.07925540953874588,
-0.2656213939189911,
0.5411655902862549,
-0.3312533497810364,
0.19976061582565308,
0.014525379985570908,
0.1526954174041748,
0.5233104228973389,
-0.32279637455940247,
0.9549854397773743,
0.029231876134872437,
-0.27346768975257874,
0.5311021208763123,
0.3897857964038849,
0.753490149974823,
0.14943191409111023,
-0.0525730736553669,
-0.011695506982505322,
-0.21725398302078247,
-0.5269845724105835,
-0.15942583978176117,
0.5097188353538513,
-0.4714016914367676,
-0.7007248401641846,
-0.611576497554779,
-0.6779937148094177,
-0.12279379367828369,
0.09689003229141235,
0.7001168131828308,
0.4562528133392334,
-0.4130190312862396,
0.24498452246189117,
0.7746581435203552,
-0.44023409485816956,
0.5298319458961487,
0.0766100361943245,
-0.16443860530853271,
-0.4559239447116852,
0.7456057071685791,
-0.036656271666288376,
0.37690338492393494,
0.16391170024871826,
0.09155239909887314,
0.03325669839978218,
-0.9298207759857178,
-0.271658331155777,
-0.24462567269802094,
-0.6804365515708923,
-0.28692498803138733,
-0.5824983716011047,
-0.20346051454544067,
-0.45473623275756836,
-0.20515839755535126,
-0.2947773039340973,
-0.16819161176681519,
-0.163534477353096,
0.021092459559440613,
0.23981915414333344,
0.7027713656425476,
0.17852617800235748,
0.30870190262794495,
-0.6289661526679993,
0.19333715736865997,
0.24999772012233734,
0.12176836282014847,
-0.18770842254161835,
-0.4887367784976959,
-0.1479751318693161,
-0.45195266604423523,
-0.5760288238525391,
-1.0995954275131226,
0.11482169479131699,
-0.16206152737140656,
0.1479596048593521,
0.4566963016986847,
0.2789231240749359,
0.33829811215400696,
-0.2974338233470917,
0.9144284725189209,
0.08081591874361038,
-0.9859092235565186,
0.5417954325675964,
-0.4662329852581024,
0.2557232975959778,
0.4792916774749756,
0.1586335003376007,
-0.21655787527561188,
-0.8441481590270996,
-0.8213293552398682,
-0.7190954685211182,
0.5033665895462036,
0.4667636454105377,
0.11520204693078995,
-0.1474594622850418,
0.3466711938381195,
-0.08300863951444626,
-0.1502179056406021,
-0.8007042407989502,
-0.21612386405467987,
-0.1647888571023941,
-0.14982832968235016,
0.06721586734056473,
-0.5705872178077698,
-0.1502051204442978,
0.18417203426361084,
0.4625241756439209,
0.054994627833366394,
0.2584637701511383,
0.4097086191177368,
-0.3212087154388428,
-0.09678041934967041,
0.40766143798828125,
0.7822101712226868,
0.30563876032829285,
-0.17191632091999054,
0.5786405801773071,
0.3134538531303406,
-0.7095500826835632,
0.16378073394298553,
0.058257002383470535,
-0.4420572519302368,
0.2668655514717102,
0.604010283946991,
0.9110550284385681,
0.08069444447755814,
-0.7834760546684265,
0.21507364511489868,
-0.07575791329145432,
-0.18537364900112152,
-0.0839058980345726,
0.10444054007530212,
0.10117093473672867,
-0.05732494592666626,
0.13873179256916046,
0.22933244705200195,
-0.07252619415521622,
-0.5150020122528076,
0.3300766944885254,
0.6166104078292847,
-0.3569506108760834,
-0.3617914617061615,
0.521532416343689,
0.0004441911878529936,
-0.4882095754146576,
0.21523690223693848,
-0.24086405336856842,
-0.6630094051361084,
0.6502717137336731,
0.9084637761116028,
1.0264381170272827,
-0.25905826687812805,
-0.10069968551397324,
0.18043644726276398,
0.9195780158042908,
0.028647122904658318,
0.09488218277692795,
0.0978914424777031,
-0.557017982006073,
-0.16424395143985748,
-0.5158357620239258,
-0.6703949570655823,
0.39114534854888916,
-0.5471858382225037,
0.2155437469482422,
-0.6354620456695557,
-0.342267781496048,
-0.3413897454738617,
-0.00007882900536060333,
-0.2848289906978607,
0.12174549698829651,
0.17610859870910645,
0.9412431716918945,
-0.6230644583702087,
0.6456485390663147,
0.7004022002220154,
-0.1539246290922165,
-0.5435332655906677,
0.44022783637046814,
0.1569596827030182,
-0.8461297154426575,
0.17823220789432526,
0.18125474452972412,
-0.11822230368852615,
-0.17791521549224854,
-0.5775780081748962,
-0.7310006618499756,
0.6398249268531799,
0.41169580817222595,
-0.5180111527442932,
0.2223556488752365,
0.32248654961586,
0.32345083355903625,
-0.06595953553915024,
0.01479952409863472,
0.6460102200508118,
0.4494413137435913,
-0.1528267115354538,
-0.5027568936347961,
0.21768836677074432,
-0.08932871371507645,
-0.10541582107543945,
0.2822429835796356,
-0.315342515707016,
0.7645520567893982,
0.06526383012533188,
-0.2570788264274597,
0.22680635750293732,
0.372663289308548,
0.46351540088653564,
0.5943979024887085,
0.5717241168022156,
0.8479981422424316,
0.8111863136291504,
-0.16656692326068878,
1.1906551122665405,
-0.2802874445915222,
0.12911410629749298,
0.9265623092651367,
-0.3932740390300751,
0.8060024380683899,
0.42650720477104187,
-0.009120325557887554,
0.4747709333896637,
0.5219810605049133,
-0.273200124502182,
0.22320304811000824,
0.3800487816333771,
-0.36289432644844055,
-0.18728196620941162,
0.026848560199141502,
-0.2320266216993332,
0.12443524599075317,
0.1912776231765747,
-0.26742520928382874,
-0.2041112333536148,
0.1079622134566307,
0.5026752352714539,
0.08966503292322159,
-0.10660898685455322,
0.4846680164337158,
0.27371254563331604,
-0.6876655220985413,
0.5910288691520691,
0.19125743210315704,
0.8920661807060242,
-0.48947203159332275,
0.621330976486206,
-0.11811167001724243,
0.27819696068763733,
-0.18891184031963348,
-0.6805611252784729,
0.42102113366127014,
0.6646619439125061,
0.18338899314403534,
-0.010946162045001984,
1.4285677671432495,
-0.01811983995139599,
-0.3803523778915405,
0.26565685868263245,
0.2310882955789566,
0.12357059866189957,
-0.21280990540981293,
-0.5235305428504944,
0.6282303929328918,
-0.019746383652091026,
-0.4215731620788574,
0.5673323273658752,
0.25481393933296204,
0.06588586419820786,
0.5125158429145813,
0.6855790615081787,
0.01759212091565132,
0.32511594891548157,
-0.10470163822174072,
0.8242877125740051,
-0.6584523320198059,
0.004346530884504318,
-1.3083199262619019,
0.42025575041770935,
-0.17189407348632812,
-0.3417133092880249,
1.0244855880737305,
0.32071611285209656,
0.6623655557632446,
0.03066682256758213,
0.8734330534934998,
0.04302534461021423,
0.08397508412599564,
-0.5144626498222351,
0.6382455229759216,
-0.362030029296875,
0.39914679527282715,
-0.6673012375831604,
-0.792371928691864,
-0.4313189685344696,
0.28313148021698,
0.02378968894481659,
-0.12668916583061218,
0.8867929577827454,
0.845555305480957,
0.22861456871032715,
-0.18201933801174164,
0.38755837082862854,
0.2562576234340668,
0.5316552519798279,
0.6551887392997742,
1.0912036895751953,
-0.5783681273460388,
1.0424014329910278,
-0.24213050305843353,
-0.054820552468299866,
-0.13269343972206116,
-0.9921953082084656,
-1.3280450105667114,
-0.28592053055763245,
-0.3826908767223358,
-0.6755349040031433,
0.07743183523416519,
0.3741406202316284,
0.20596051216125488,
-0.7323012948036194,
-0.1421549767255783,
-0.3250938355922699,
0.32063597440719604,
0.11385449022054672,
-0.19678948819637299,
0.2758708894252777,
-0.5561631917953491,
-0.6392228007316589,
0.5430834293365479,
0.3679080903530121,
0.11121749132871628,
-0.2559758722782135,
0.09723212569952011,
0.05592240020632744,
0.41563257575035095,
0.3638702929019928,
0.27210381627082825,
-0.5453274846076965,
-0.3775646686553955,
0.2940382659435272,
-0.3549652397632599,
-0.12800730764865875,
0.8407930731773376,
-0.4103364944458008,
0.30981874465942383,
0.6174643635749817,
0.9106701016426086,
0.03941240534186363,
-0.2279558628797531,
0.41155362129211426,
-0.8297737240791321,
0.11550811678171158,
0.25336411595344543,
0.46384039521217346,
0.4110400974750519,
-0.2819438874721527,
0.14516474306583405,
0.4816436767578125,
-0.6529235243797302,
-1.4538666009902954,
0.5362488627433777,
-0.7781930565834045,
-0.48704835772514343,
1.065961241722107,
-0.21708877384662628,
-0.14147727191448212,
-0.3414181172847748,
-0.15865390002727509,
0.17147915065288544,
-0.033159289509058,
0.8559651374816895,
1.004415512084961,
0.20178484916687012,
0.043013036251068115,
-0.435847669839859,
0.6689300537109375,
0.5514717698097229,
-0.7774375081062317,
0.06026173755526543,
0.25493258237838745,
0.36105450987815857,
0.2862606644630432,
0.5937960743904114,
-0.2141069918870926,
0.24539582431316376,
0.26254355907440186,
-0.0997806116938591,
0.11769167333841324,
-0.18096841871738434,
-0.4332308769226074,
0.4653293192386627,
0.3896876573562622,
-0.014309934340417385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11633v1 | Self-seeding and Multi-intent Self-instructing LLMs for Generating Intent-aware Information-Seeking dialogs | 2024-02-18T16:20:43 | 2024-02-18T16:20:43 | Arian Askari, Roxana Petcu, Chuan Meng, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Amin Abolghasemi, Evangelos Kanoulas, Suzan Verberne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying user intents in information-seeking dialogs is crucial for a
system to meet user's information needs. Intent prediction (IP) is challenging
and demands sufficient dialogs with human-labeled intents for training.
However, manually annotating intents is resource-intensive. While large
language models (LLMs) have been shown to be effective in generating synthetic
data, there is no study on using LLMs to generate intent-aware
information-seeking dialogs. In this paper, we focus on leveraging LLMs for
zero-shot generation of large-scale, open-domain, and intent-aware
information-seeking dialogs. We propose SOLID, which has novel self-seeding and
multi-intent self-instructing schemes. The former improves the generation
quality by using the LLM's own knowledge scope to initiate dialog generation;
the latter prompts the LLM to generate utterances sequentially, and mitigates
the need for manual prompt design by asking the LLM to autonomously adapt its
prompt instruction when generating complex multi-intent utterances.
Furthermore, we propose SOLID-RL, which is further trained to generate a dialog
in one step on the data generated by SOLID. We propose a length-based quality
estimation mechanism to assign varying weights to SOLID-generated dialogs based
on their quality during the training process of SOLID-RL. We use SOLID and
SOLID-RL to generate more than 300k intent-aware dialogs, surpassing the size
of existing datasets. Experiments show that IP methods trained on dialogs
generated by SOLID and SOLID-RL achieve better IP quality than ones trained on
human-generated dialogs. | [
-0.110274538397789,
-0.6699159145355225,
0.8071364760398865,
0.03605415299534798,
-0.23178736865520477,
-0.26846209168434143,
-0.11026337742805481,
-0.07303665578365326,
0.1861737221479416,
0.6559895277023315,
-0.7995168566703796,
-0.5797821283340454,
0.010911140590906143,
0.15117448568344116,
0.0996769517660141,
0.8849770426750183,
-0.055051885545253754,
-0.05616511031985283,
-0.1290450394153595,
0.2680935263633728,
-0.8925279974937439,
-0.3866350054740906,
-0.20658276975154877,
-0.14501908421516418,
0.44617748260498047,
0.7586270570755005,
0.30981773138046265,
0.48998868465423584,
0.05227411910891533,
0.18378093838691711,
0.49765148758888245,
0.4205959141254425,
-0.7443901300430298,
0.4941498935222626,
0.08888698369264603,
-0.3589560091495514,
-0.18218837678432465,
0.15225063264369965,
0.5191435813903809,
0.40415772795677185,
-0.057881519198417664,
0.0020875753834843636,
-0.22137168049812317,
0.43286633491516113,
-0.6270798444747925,
0.09831979125738144,
-0.8421452045440674,
0.26953551173210144,
-0.039474960416555405,
-0.8499425649642944,
-0.7644265294075012,
-0.07725737243890762,
0.2133788913488388,
-0.5628114342689514,
0.08658837527036667,
0.1088719293475151,
0.3978230655193329,
0.034164246171712875,
-0.2273261994123459,
-0.5383687019348145,
-0.7699422240257263,
0.8717713356018066,
-0.6634858250617981,
0.37353426218032837,
0.34612390398979187,
0.1519089937210083,
-0.472046822309494,
-0.2917875349521637,
-0.325237512588501,
-0.16147252917289734,
0.21258415281772614,
0.2353232204914093,
0.3000335991382599,
0.18121154606342316,
-0.015270907431840897,
0.22605426609516144,
-0.4927150011062622,
-0.23321633040905,
-0.3029135465621948,
-0.11790231615304947,
0.6195186972618103,
0.2785874009132385,
0.12905515730381012,
-0.1743837147951126,
-0.5669774413108826,
0.010297155007719994,
-0.959492027759552,
0.10468525439500809,
0.16989703476428986,
0.44548019766807556,
0.15076875686645508,
0.7118124961853027,
-0.4413445293903351,
0.7004552483558655,
0.3831227123737335,
-0.2998366057872772,
0.08081535995006561,
-0.6014561653137207,
-0.1850079596042633,
0.4882974922657013,
0.8724038004875183,
0.4112732708454132,
0.23248250782489777,
-0.18088161945343018,
-0.07595828920602798,
-0.4531990587711334,
0.2547832131385803,
-1.1807329654693604,
0.16571617126464844,
0.3721691370010376,
-0.36770007014274597,
-0.157181054353714,
0.037277091294527054,
-0.3229714334011078,
-0.2357829213142395,
-0.2112056314945221,
0.278384804725647,
-0.5833629369735718,
-0.1069023609161377,
0.27514493465423584,
0.17053373157978058,
0.1807798594236374,
0.4936436712741852,
-0.8317321538925171,
-0.1381223350763321,
0.3125467896461487,
0.5619493126869202,
-0.005847509950399399,
-0.22387053072452545,
-0.661073625087738,
0.43054065108299255,
-0.56455397605896,
0.7475755214691162,
-0.4213763475418091,
-0.46283552050590515,
-0.0155794071033597,
-0.3041324019432068,
-0.003569269785657525,
-0.28954237699508667,
0.37702399492263794,
-0.5394318103790283,
0.4525086283683777,
-0.052711524069309235,
-0.7159478068351746,
-0.2857479155063629,
0.28345778584480286,
-0.23604600131511688,
0.5686091184616089,
-0.05216267332434654,
-0.4545380771160126,
0.4404245615005493,
-0.761401355266571,
-0.2864801287651062,
0.4855896532535553,
-0.5605229735374451,
-0.19883689284324646,
0.3480973243713379,
-0.006419836543500423,
0.7587316632270813,
-0.31288623809814453,
0.3646516799926758,
-0.32652509212493896,
-0.19915597140789032,
0.4357951581478119,
-0.8335166573524475,
0.1918536126613617,
0.18132540583610535,
-0.28768211603164673,
0.06751076132059097,
-0.420177161693573,
0.3925764560699463,
0.21510036289691925,
-0.32950517535209656,
-0.03448149189352989,
-0.024363858625292778,
-0.49875348806381226,
0.1333283931016922,
0.24201209843158722,
-0.7109754085540771,
0.3293476700782776,
-0.2369420975446701,
0.048494886606931686,
0.7159925103187561,
0.20154498517513275,
0.29976311326026917,
-0.1550518125295639,
0.332110732793808,
0.03458118811249733,
0.22680887579917908,
-0.7855224609375,
-0.19377285242080688,
-0.4870372712612152,
-0.028001820668578148,
0.10933571308851242,
0.396463543176651,
-0.6692377328872681,
0.2401759773492813,
-0.2577352821826935,
-0.14909599721431732,
-0.3132270574569702,
0.2436893731355667,
0.37524646520614624,
0.27716970443725586,
0.06262078136205673,
-0.3154211938381195,
-0.20695321261882782,
-0.5184546113014221,
-0.05359978601336479,
-0.15250734984874725,
0.06616891175508499,
0.9200319647789001,
-0.013484430499374866,
-0.028772156685590744,
1.2638273239135742,
-0.558083713054657,
-0.6265433430671692,
-0.2910960614681244,
0.2528097927570343,
0.2976604402065277,
0.11578033119440079,
0.4324345588684082,
-0.6834854483604431,
-0.7914754748344421,
-0.34874585270881653,
-0.9113008379936218,
0.011276669800281525,
-0.2468702644109726,
-0.0461917519569397,
0.12276045978069305,
0.21619126200675964,
-0.660103976726532,
0.38368695974349976,
0.39308488368988037,
-0.31301963329315186,
0.6641390323638916,
-0.2302999198436737,
0.21178434789180756,
-1.0863122940063477,
-0.24423739314079285,
-0.15677215158939362,
-0.1847672164440155,
-0.8874321579933167,
-0.5748343467712402,
-0.08861055225133896,
-0.1919257789850235,
-0.7451299428939819,
0.7426285743713379,
-0.8492380976676941,
0.004773534368723631,
-0.33806902170181274,
0.07239022850990295,
0.06407445669174194,
0.5065110921859741,
0.15519216656684875,
1.1797648668289185,
0.39418289065361023,
-0.635955274105072,
-0.04397958517074585,
0.09622588753700256,
-0.2636658549308777,
0.5692964196205139,
-0.2921707332134247,
0.19660575687885284,
-0.3537692129611969,
0.3063596487045288,
-0.825188398361206,
-0.399118572473526,
0.2842274010181427,
-0.4727688133716583,
0.2237914502620697,
-0.2730008661746979,
-0.14121250808238983,
-0.18851198256015778,
-0.3811802268028259,
0.522243082523346,
0.25023967027664185,
-0.4751773774623871,
0.6714158654212952,
0.1558799296617508,
-0.3719416558742523,
-0.5101804733276367,
-0.2514106035232544,
0.11848293244838715,
-0.056419551372528076,
-0.6988462805747986,
0.10846616327762604,
-0.476644366979599,
0.1588418334722519,
-0.16442064940929413,
0.036962319165468216,
-0.037407632917165756,
-0.197209894657135,
0.37564221024513245,
0.11898856610059738,
-0.18037910759449005,
0.2685282528400421,
-0.13599711656570435,
-0.16744056344032288,
-0.1149841696023941,
-0.49871689081192017,
0.7122279405593872,
-0.10136830806732178,
-0.5354680418968201,
-0.6330809593200684,
0.37391889095306396,
0.5608566403388977,
0.009910307824611664,
0.44702818989753723,
0.3898884654045105,
0.11058028042316437,
-0.2916092872619629,
-0.7292979955673218,
-0.4399193525314331,
-0.4684867858886719,
-0.09429829567670822,
-0.5470853447914124,
-0.8751277923583984,
0.04198259487748146,
-0.2552769184112549,
0.2701477110385895,
0.1214582547545433,
0.5032583475112915,
-0.1810297816991806,
1.0150566101074219,
0.4446543753147125,
0.2215375006198883,
0.6048417687416077,
-0.40141820907592773,
0.16339343786239624,
-0.8824877738952637,
0.0013117942726239562,
0.1153147965669632,
0.18670915067195892,
-0.054507192224264145,
-0.5279196500778198,
0.47010424733161926,
-0.05312196910381317,
0.1786022186279297,
0.015255650505423546,
-0.4722593128681183,
0.4642771780490875,
0.6639493703842163,
-0.1070956438779831,
0.29028812050819397,
0.3014722168445587,
-0.1713540405035019,
-0.0654274970293045,
-0.7621471881866455,
-0.4292897880077362,
1.308044672012329,
0.26692143082618713,
1.1774377822875977,
-0.1950054168701172,
0.8397430181503296,
0.2946532070636749,
0.15790943801403046,
-0.8030340075492859,
0.4600036144256592,
0.10009559988975525,
-0.5890162587165833,
-0.47663402557373047,
-0.6961043477058411,
-1.0300323963165283,
0.11335191130638123,
0.08278333395719528,
-0.616625189781189,
-0.0010338363936170936,
0.25320833921432495,
-0.6824784278869629,
0.22833748161792755,
-0.6259613633155823,
0.5487033724784851,
-0.8321735262870789,
-0.31311312317848206,
-0.043492354452610016,
-0.2911766767501831,
0.2855600118637085,
0.15112093091011047,
-0.028578786179423332,
-0.5163527727127075,
0.37128162384033203,
0.35431718826293945,
-0.12738275527954102,
0.9881384968757629,
-0.3764227628707886,
-0.1533438265323639,
0.7808467745780945,
0.34392398595809937,
0.5323672890663147,
0.1815148890018463,
-0.07651602476835251,
0.14572006464004517,
-0.43500447273254395,
0.028198853135108948,
-0.4168781042098999,
0.573944628238678,
-0.5782378911972046,
-0.6508134007453918,
-0.4237860441207886,
-0.6204367876052856,
-0.06796988844871521,
0.46883928775787354,
0.22062642872333527,
0.7372714281082153,
-0.2364538311958313,
0.5199605226516724,
0.8346670866012573,
-0.17559495568275452,
0.38898372650146484,
0.8497337102890015,
-0.0523562915623188,
-0.5043951272964478,
1.0217267274856567,
0.16432397067546844,
0.4473716616630554,
0.3220233917236328,
0.15445773303508759,
-0.4765949845314026,
-0.4951602518558502,
-0.7765427827835083,
0.1228477880358696,
-0.27122488617897034,
-0.47682854533195496,
-0.7331812977790833,
-0.4345450699329376,
-0.3992847204208374,
-0.21294154226779938,
-0.4263950288295746,
-0.05737774819135666,
-0.5236207842826843,
0.15395498275756836,
0.2872864902019501,
0.5794777274131775,
0.014143591746687889,
0.3781580328941345,
-0.6523874402046204,
0.4797404408454895,
0.4662257134914398,
0.5310178995132446,
-0.25283917784690857,
-0.4036545753479004,
-0.14792345464229584,
0.41690951585769653,
-0.30853167176246643,
-0.583731472492218,
0.3696698844432831,
0.27598100900650024,
0.4741559326648712,
0.6008756756782532,
0.2732926607131958,
0.3047342598438263,
-0.6383675932884216,
0.6739777326583862,
0.4279230833053589,
-0.3357192873954773,
0.6167360544204712,
-0.4024210572242737,
0.3261876702308655,
0.827989935874939,
0.16403867304325104,
-0.5331025719642639,
0.04554106667637825,
-0.4119914472103119,
-0.6964589953422546,
0.9985425472259521,
0.1752552092075348,
0.14337298274040222,
-0.08968541771173477,
0.330750435590744,
0.33939680457115173,
0.3684242367744446,
-0.6365535855293274,
-0.16647523641586304,
-0.2378946989774704,
-0.29749777913093567,
0.19411836564540863,
-0.528383731842041,
-0.05008796602487564,
0.4509832262992859,
0.7949783802032471,
-0.45594772696495056,
0.45916733145713806,
0.4194183647632599,
-0.04286732152104378,
-0.2550276219844818,
0.46139511466026306,
0.5025258660316467,
0.4701835811138153,
-0.42591041326522827,
-0.024652158841490746,
-0.1253805309534073,
-0.37243807315826416,
0.35807356238365173,
-0.1778743863105774,
-0.5952945947647095,
0.004668721463531256,
-0.39269495010375977,
1.1078723669052124,
0.04319796338677406,
-0.6483503580093384,
0.6530017852783203,
-0.3888038694858551,
-0.05694840848445892,
-0.5702295303344727,
0.2414272278547287,
-0.2083708941936493,
0.008196058683097363,
0.37610116600990295,
-0.5667455792427063,
0.24679455161094666,
-0.5496084094047546,
0.07864557206630707,
0.7447654008865356,
-0.5002100467681885,
-0.12592336535453796,
0.2089981883764267,
0.44527265429496765,
-0.3846079111099243,
0.5927941799163818,
-0.34658610820770264,
-0.1722937673330307,
0.14156091213226318,
0.7232137322425842,
1.118078589439392,
-0.29319894313812256,
0.494954913854599,
0.06851096451282501,
-0.009792188182473183,
0.15499213337898254,
0.41030582785606384,
-0.22807517647743225,
-0.7287205457687378,
-0.3523668348789215,
-0.504464864730835,
-0.610741376876831,
0.3448410630226135,
-0.017332058399915695,
0.20591218769550323,
-0.2169320434331894,
-0.2104274034500122,
-0.29141154885292053,
-0.0034169312566518784,
-0.5377007722854614,
0.13689465820789337,
0.04140034317970276,
0.5943546891212463,
-0.3440416753292084,
0.3757462203502655,
0.30835798382759094,
-0.16649508476257324,
-0.8130015730857849,
-0.0930897444486618,
-0.035112231969833374,
-0.6407647132873535,
0.3899362087249756,
0.5454574227333069,
-0.20525389909744263,
-0.07114948332309723,
-0.43778499960899353,
-1.0483132600784302,
1.3617699146270752,
0.182413712143898,
-0.4130406081676483,
0.010040760971605778,
0.5146089196205139,
0.04483482986688614,
-0.7769204378128052,
0.42128637433052063,
-0.14746874570846558,
0.24408890306949615,
0.4000761806964874,
-0.5729352831840515,
-0.09781630337238312,
-0.03599551320075989,
-0.12549009919166565,
0.1318269520998001,
-0.7177861332893372,
0.6282991766929626,
-0.1786516159772873,
-0.477937787771225,
-0.09844549745321274,
0.610474705696106,
0.5873602032661438,
0.3502209186553955,
0.48955225944519043,
0.27538952231407166,
0.3691836893558502,
0.19666634500026703,
0.7972343564033508,
-0.7858381867408752,
0.04848790541291237,
1.4074207544326782,
-0.5033141374588013,
0.48879289627075195,
0.21644696593284607,
0.3354538083076477,
0.3823477029800415,
0.41653919219970703,
0.16114462912082672,
0.43617337942123413,
-0.050252508372068405,
-0.5820600986480713,
-0.20315419137477875,
-0.39196717739105225,
-0.21154624223709106,
0.4564099907875061,
0.5913364887237549,
-0.406941682100296,
-0.2801710069179535,
-0.08832714706659317,
-0.21674218773841858,
-0.4908446967601776,
-0.16530676186084747,
1.0930241346359253,
-0.010501503013074398,
-0.8716098070144653,
0.4479500353336334,
-0.15375672280788422,
0.6436693668365479,
-0.7255164384841919,
-0.15959163010120392,
-0.014548909850418568,
-0.0742398276925087,
0.035243961960077286,
-0.9169396162033081,
-0.4084468185901642,
-0.060810014605522156,
-0.32908597588539124,
-0.45261508226394653,
1.1009101867675781,
-0.5103278160095215,
-0.2099444717168808,
0.06479604542255402,
0.42225223779678345,
0.5767297744750977,
-0.22664229571819305,
-0.49051976203918457,
-0.14500002562999725,
0.05479110777378082,
-0.3600502908229828,
0.20724692940711975,
0.6434688568115234,
0.09208618104457855,
0.7686475515365601,
0.8685937523841858,
-0.06262565404176712,
0.19953911006450653,
0.10535043478012085,
0.6901602149009705,
-0.6035751104354858,
-0.374580442905426,
-0.4499093294143677,
0.3425624668598175,
-0.03590327501296997,
-0.10248129069805145,
0.5806542038917542,
0.6327793002128601,
0.6132677793502808,
-0.07083764672279358,
0.9967606067657471,
-0.04034039378166199,
0.4213751256465912,
-0.4478408098220825,
0.33567386865615845,
-0.29818084836006165,
0.01576290652155876,
0.16083920001983643,
-0.9350727796554565,
0.28833895921707153,
0.40664657950401306,
-0.2388448268175125,
0.19851070642471313,
0.22129996120929718,
0.6521317362785339,
-0.21174107491970062,
-0.13768261671066284,
0.5742846131324768,
0.1260976493358612,
0.375724196434021,
0.493716835975647,
0.8103904724121094,
-0.23782792687416077,
0.6168709397315979,
-0.04199782386422157,
-0.27718767523765564,
-0.6797803640365601,
-0.8984432220458984,
-0.7899477481842041,
-0.3000093698501587,
0.14742091298103333,
-0.08135315030813217,
-0.015068708918988705,
0.8880751132965088,
1.0299863815307617,
-0.548242449760437,
-0.3268613815307617,
-0.23741744458675385,
-0.013517450541257858,
0.34299978613853455,
-0.29389771819114685,
-0.032471925020217896,
-0.6044162511825562,
-0.3747548758983612,
0.7240056991577148,
0.7183657884597778,
0.3431364893913269,
-0.5610872507095337,
-0.20991748571395874,
-0.09219847619533539,
0.3373035490512848,
0.6903719902038574,
0.5154176354408264,
-0.6602165699005127,
-0.3404470980167389,
0.16313646733760834,
-0.16101092100143433,
0.19301944971084595,
0.7560474276542664,
-0.6771930456161499,
0.7450441122055054,
0.31928110122680664,
0.48061302304267883,
0.5066051483154297,
0.24684517085552216,
0.68789142370224,
-0.8054431676864624,
-0.3001222014427185,
0.3481200635433197,
-0.01945326291024685,
0.2922963500022888,
-0.7714900970458984,
0.4397883415222168,
-0.26599422097206116,
-0.6900855898857117,
-0.5060081481933594,
0.3392661511898041,
-0.7636810541152954,
-0.1456836313009262,
1.2114394903182983,
-0.10311863571405411,
-0.31583020091056824,
-0.06379897892475128,
-0.3452273905277252,
-0.017351489514112473,
-0.8414334058761597,
0.8630101680755615,
0.229864701628685,
-0.5032773613929749,
-0.05189798027276993,
-0.4850137531757355,
0.4506649672985077,
0.4207351505756378,
-0.9095077514648438,
0.34184184670448303,
0.5984102487564087,
0.2571176588535309,
0.30070993304252625,
1.017840027809143,
0.06296422332525253,
0.30604287981987,
-0.3094205856323242,
0.25660640001296997,
-0.19235236942768097,
-0.7929622530937195,
0.12795062363147736,
0.2228086292743683,
-0.04671541973948479,
-0.10670098662376404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11628v1 | Discrete Neural Algorithmic Reasoning | 2024-02-18T16:03:04 | 2024-02-18T16:03:04 | Gleb Rodionov, Liudmila Prokhorenkova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Neural algorithmic reasoning aims to capture computations with neural
networks via learning the models to imitate the execution of classical
algorithms. While common architectures are expressive enough to contain the
correct model in the weights space, current neural reasoners are struggling to
generalize well on out-of-distribution data. On the other hand, classical
computations are not affected by distribution shifts as they can be described
as transitions between discrete computational states. In this work, we propose
to force neural reasoners to maintain the execution trajectory as a combination
of finite predefined states. Trained with supervision on the algorithm's state
transitions, such models are able to perfectly align with the original
algorithm. To show this, we evaluate our approach on the SALSA-CLRS benchmark,
where we get perfect test scores for all tasks. Moreover, the proposed
architectural choice allows us to prove the correctness of the learned
algorithms for any test data. | [
-0.2549232244491577,
-0.3164254128932953,
0.7739909887313843,
0.1718381643295288,
-0.18703678250312805,
-0.1994788646697998,
-0.2345479428768158,
-0.07490865886211395,
0.1487945169210434,
0.27861636877059937,
-0.4061782658100128,
-0.23071786761283875,
-0.31770798563957214,
-0.15418152511119843,
-0.6166508197784424,
0.9694124460220337,
-0.19933465123176575,
0.05769867077469826,
-0.30644163489341736,
0.02503223344683647,
-0.43348732590675354,
-0.057294540107250214,
-0.376753032207489,
-0.748113751411438,
0.5262375473976135,
0.03567736595869064,
0.6529622673988342,
0.8556326627731323,
0.2508286237716675,
0.3265266418457031,
0.1475526988506317,
0.23410087823867798,
-0.13610395789146423,
0.05441325530409813,
-0.4486840069293976,
-0.5069194436073303,
0.07945887744426727,
-0.22397728264331818,
0.3639664053916931,
0.5243139863014221,
-0.4410558044910431,
-0.003468794748187065,
-0.1987956166267395,
0.598298966884613,
-0.9020097255706787,
0.20384176075458527,
-0.5445384383201599,
0.08331158757209778,
-0.07747264951467514,
-0.19172658026218414,
-0.668987512588501,
-0.7725144028663635,
-0.06724096834659576,
-0.6147651672363281,
-0.18531297147274017,
-0.41644951701164246,
0.5812526345252991,
0.5674887299537659,
-0.43734100461006165,
-0.24464793503284454,
-1.0250322818756104,
0.45866310596466064,
-0.46011728048324585,
0.22067974507808685,
0.06775946170091629,
0.6501203775405884,
-0.23921434581279755,
-0.9094638824462891,
-0.5215306878089905,
0.029169395565986633,
0.14575281739234924,
0.046564362943172455,
-0.2125636488199234,
0.11456168442964554,
0.22698089480400085,
0.21966129541397095,
-0.3988422155380249,
0.04838725924491882,
-0.27093085646629333,
0.19719228148460388,
0.6260837316513062,
0.22956539690494537,
0.13627293705940247,
0.3383537530899048,
-0.21463266015052795,
-0.21206572651863098,
-0.6163301467895508,
0.18181872367858887,
0.17621444165706635,
0.16389094293117523,
-0.022173194214701653,
0.14905641973018646,
0.016320863738656044,
1.0666816234588623,
0.1821131855249405,
0.40390604734420776,
0.0052393353544175625,
0.006979552563279867,
-0.3591177463531494,
-0.01387542113661766,
0.7724640369415283,
0.04771726205945015,
0.5877393484115601,
-0.17498621344566345,
-0.17974825203418732,
0.33485686779022217,
0.7008031606674194,
-0.6237243413925171,
-0.4126955270767212,
0.17894138395786285,
-0.2554234564304352,
-0.04864218458533287,
-0.043266672641038895,
-0.6393598914146423,
-0.38535889983177185,
-0.676579475402832,
0.39205026626586914,
-0.6117667555809021,
-0.09816630184650421,
0.32199710607528687,
-0.09512045234441757,
0.3532654345035553,
0.41228556632995605,
-0.943784773349762,
0.6184241771697998,
0.8837593197822571,
0.5392947196960449,
0.04000411927700043,
-0.15134701132774353,
-0.17998917400836945,
-0.25691497325897217,
-0.7300629019737244,
0.5497063994407654,
-0.44099509716033936,
0.23870927095413208,
0.04742922633886337,
-0.5771746039390564,
-0.6430040001869202,
-0.40505170822143555,
0.3554365634918213,
-0.7777853012084961,
0.05489056184887886,
-0.4244246780872345,
-0.7216391563415527,
-0.27381032705307007,
0.38512152433395386,
-0.1894867867231369,
0.6391164064407349,
-0.15634073317050934,
-0.3440420627593994,
0.08124983310699463,
-0.8187078237533569,
-0.4549960494041443,
0.01714983955025673,
-0.46653929352760315,
-0.1668834239244461,
0.2145279198884964,
0.09235397726297379,
0.003832753049209714,
-0.18750689923763275,
0.2863244116306305,
-0.29902222752571106,
-0.6039831638336182,
0.3555338680744171,
-0.28145942091941833,
0.8337128758430481,
0.39036062359809875,
-0.5670570731163025,
0.25532329082489014,
-0.48124489188194275,
0.34626251459121704,
-0.1538955122232437,
-0.1790781021118164,
-0.26351797580718994,
0.5057594776153564,
-0.4648837447166443,
0.3787616789340973,
0.03869255259633064,
-0.35108304023742676,
0.16705405712127686,
-0.5315742492675781,
0.7144750356674194,
0.884882926940918,
-0.12826640903949738,
0.517936646938324,
-0.4838377833366394,
0.4603736698627472,
0.03487532213330269,
0.13998642563819885,
-0.02302018366754055,
-0.31742778420448303,
-0.5963570475578308,
-0.24004241824150085,
0.482388973236084,
0.6541693210601807,
-0.7025356292724609,
0.5006052255630493,
-0.3921304941177368,
-0.43408897519111633,
-0.31407809257507324,
-0.26594024896621704,
0.31893566250801086,
0.5451146960258484,
0.2637866139411926,
0.12097062915563583,
-0.45830750465393066,
-0.6940542459487915,
-0.11531087011098862,
0.08049090951681137,
0.13396349549293518,
0.12074179947376251,
0.6836094856262207,
0.07730314135551453,
0.7640961408615112,
-0.3012793958187103,
0.2788299322128296,
0.04721776396036148,
-0.004992207512259483,
0.6268616914749146,
0.6596903204917908,
0.3984133005142212,
-0.831986665725708,
-0.30999088287353516,
0.012129140086472034,
-0.8260278105735779,
0.20064476132392883,
-0.35599541664123535,
-0.19337794184684753,
-0.22590212523937225,
0.44227197766304016,
-0.78029865026474,
0.49953460693359375,
0.1923167109489441,
-0.13925568759441376,
0.4653204083442688,
-0.39195168018341064,
0.09988712519407272,
-0.7255403399467468,
0.031135454773902893,
-0.001363570336252451,
-0.08087626844644547,
-0.5540186166763306,
0.3631370961666107,
0.021427033469080925,
-0.04173319786787033,
-0.2810627818107605,
0.11061759293079376,
-0.15184688568115234,
-0.02850988134741783,
-0.19014215469360352,
-0.236689954996109,
-0.17118126153945923,
0.3789623975753784,
0.02314235270023346,
0.47563835978507996,
0.6321369409561157,
-0.8056584596633911,
0.33871790766716003,
0.06646176427602768,
-0.3014831244945526,
0.4692833721637726,
-0.9009429216384888,
0.2248283475637436,
-0.21810083091259003,
0.28378623723983765,
-0.9667763710021973,
0.1765257865190506,
0.20039889216423035,
-0.472648024559021,
-0.04807968810200691,
-0.10171028226613998,
-0.34239551424980164,
-0.3419574499130249,
-0.0869864895939827,
0.5354658961296082,
0.6616171598434448,
-0.6713845133781433,
0.9048939943313599,
-0.09321100264787674,
0.6849345564842224,
-0.6393224000930786,
-0.6384927034378052,
-0.12785708904266357,
-0.15031768381595612,
-0.601102352142334,
0.5164819955825806,
-0.1298052817583084,
-0.3925466239452362,
-0.0015860123094171286,
-0.12494625896215439,
-0.3061169385910034,
0.017930392175912857,
0.4042918086051941,
0.08609214425086975,
-0.39502519369125366,
-0.042547404766082764,
0.0699230507016182,
0.03216816112399101,
0.378309428691864,
-0.6974882483482361,
0.5218345522880554,
-0.20263326168060303,
-0.3879109025001526,
-0.4118509888648987,
0.004113351460546255,
0.755980908870697,
-0.4095943570137024,
0.6201071739196777,
-0.05058450251817703,
-0.43170246481895447,
-0.48109105229377747,
-0.1931198537349701,
-0.02503175660967827,
-0.48413124680519104,
-0.2617819607257843,
-0.5533269643783569,
-0.39853379130363464,
0.5244821310043335,
-0.14201273024082184,
-0.008266177959740162,
0.20948335528373718,
0.5034598112106323,
-0.3942650556564331,
0.8858679533004761,
0.0457262359559536,
0.06308330595493317,
0.2907322645187378,
-0.4026663601398468,
0.09332730621099472,
-0.4889134168624878,
-0.1687040776014328,
-0.37110260128974915,
-0.6986004710197449,
-0.458569198846817,
-0.19821996986865997,
0.26862072944641113,
-0.09437879920005798,
-0.46435853838920593,
0.18412867188453674,
-0.6742427945137024,
0.726622998714447,
0.5964627265930176,
0.2947086989879608,
-0.42047691345214844,
-0.19420067965984344,
-0.3901902437210083,
0.05518835037946701,
-0.5789564251899719,
-0.07332050055265427,
0.6582688093185425,
-0.023385806009173393,
0.40153852105140686,
0.07282411307096481,
0.8271169662475586,
0.20390985906124115,
-0.04634876549243927,
-0.5572171807289124,
0.48458853363990784,
-0.22514072060585022,
-0.46932780742645264,
0.017799511551856995,
-0.5102870464324951,
-0.9082818031311035,
0.30423492193222046,
0.059163179248571396,
-0.6435487270355225,
0.4545709192752838,
0.2518422603607178,
-0.4899113178253174,
0.17847910523414612,
-0.3402288556098938,
1.0354400873184204,
-0.21203316748142242,
-0.21425718069076538,
-0.3649204969406128,
-0.6794312000274658,
0.5688401460647583,
0.32981163263320923,
0.16071514785289764,
0.23994123935699463,
0.2935151159763336,
0.18842269480228424,
-0.9403466582298279,
0.6854386329650879,
-0.27309924364089966,
0.3388558030128479,
0.3646363317966461,
0.2751161754131317,
0.3277505040168762,
-0.28178390860557556,
-0.09244734048843384,
-0.16220617294311523,
-0.16781993210315704,
-0.27140411734580994,
-0.9864576458930969,
0.6502090096473694,
-0.6131241917610168,
-0.3434067964553833,
-0.5759783983230591,
-0.6182207465171814,
0.050745464861392975,
0.04132798686623573,
0.2283896803855896,
0.37296202778816223,
0.20366492867469788,
-0.0404999777674675,
0.8697174787521362,
0.37981101870536804,
0.5885962247848511,
0.26729822158813477,
0.020404038950800896,
-0.36734870076179504,
0.7156745195388794,
0.02687639743089676,
0.04027367755770683,
0.5607390999794006,
0.34290945529937744,
-0.6043318510055542,
-0.7742382287979126,
-0.4617913067340851,
-0.02542584389448166,
-0.6295609474182129,
-0.03897103667259216,
0.009590838104486465,
-0.2736884355545044,
-0.1860625296831131,
-0.26125550270080566,
-0.3366817831993103,
-0.35890161991119385,
-0.14578571915626526,
0.03316962718963623,
0.19839011132717133,
0.46940794587135315,
-0.3341463804244995,
0.258550763130188,
-0.40140241384506226,
0.30571913719177246,
0.3346555531024933,
0.1943657249212265,
-0.003516963217407465,
-0.5543599724769592,
0.06858811527490616,
0.1520448625087738,
-0.2570746839046478,
-0.835699200630188,
0.048022620379924774,
0.2630193829536438,
0.5693457126617432,
0.49550241231918335,
0.08593844622373581,
0.7427379488945007,
-0.5569131374359131,
0.38856756687164307,
0.11514127999544144,
-1.0237247943878174,
0.6981117129325867,
-0.4604352116584778,
0.3056640326976776,
0.7155242562294006,
0.5182028412818909,
-0.2619195282459259,
0.14006614685058594,
-0.442929208278656,
-0.41737595200538635,
0.33837300539016724,
0.23073384165763855,
-0.014060928486287594,
-0.14384420216083527,
0.6656613349914551,
-0.32270023226737976,
0.002719699405133724,
-0.5757619738578796,
-0.1293804794549942,
-0.37374621629714966,
-0.601464033126831,
0.1988578736782074,
0.3727419376373291,
-0.15057535469532013,
-0.46172359585762024,
0.41436004638671875,
-0.09472938627004623,
-0.003269817912951112,
0.0025465127546340227,
0.052428290247917175,
0.1991136372089386,
0.12784762680530548,
0.829606831073761,
1.0696327686309814,
0.0674319714307785,
0.37346336245536804,
-0.14972689747810364,
-0.11014329642057419,
0.3315640389919281,
0.1755169928073883,
-0.6891971230506897,
-0.2656976580619812,
-0.04063905403017998,
0.6567184329032898,
0.24712349474430084,
-0.5477808713912964,
0.48839062452316284,
-0.10429190844297409,
-0.14538097381591797,
-0.5356618165969849,
0.31256499886512756,
0.14236067235469818,
0.38613057136535645,
0.011236222460865974,
0.6138635873794556,
0.017374740913510323,
-0.2590900957584381,
0.37010976672172546,
0.35825836658477783,
-0.3425993323326111,
-0.314806193113327,
0.7344980835914612,
-0.18424327671527863,
-0.47378891706466675,
1.0953843593597412,
-0.3597712218761444,
-0.44493913650512695,
0.7665150165557861,
0.6238037347793579,
0.5559703707695007,
-0.24493147432804108,
0.28271663188934326,
0.3647187054157257,
0.35035139322280884,
-0.517547607421875,
0.42930859327316284,
-0.33945250511169434,
-0.9937207102775574,
-0.6120181083679199,
-0.5112149715423584,
-0.24473057687282562,
-0.29088228940963745,
-0.6446949243545532,
0.08966021239757538,
-1.0014227628707886,
0.0789775475859642,
0.08374220877885818,
-0.5355894565582275,
-0.2944277822971344,
0.46771085262298584,
0.2965700328350067,
1.0083558559417725,
-0.7768186330795288,
0.8962899446487427,
0.5144789218902588,
-0.40155690908432007,
-0.8216279149055481,
-0.4848797917366028,
0.04578160494565964,
-0.6455863118171692,
0.47996193170547485,
-0.0559534914791584,
-0.11036179214715958,
-0.07427536696195602,
-0.44332483410835266,
-0.7451725006103516,
0.8092217445373535,
0.7107265591621399,
-0.5387948155403137,
0.012879791669547558,
0.040260251611471176,
0.657941460609436,
-0.3976317346096039,
0.3351689577102661,
0.599781334400177,
0.316598117351532,
0.4514218270778656,
-0.6396263241767883,
-0.09555090963840485,
-0.4870823323726654,
-0.0656883716583252,
0.6018664240837097,
-0.1827254295349121,
1.0777593851089478,
-0.18904592096805573,
0.05487392470240593,
-0.017989017069339752,
0.6472148299217224,
0.6809646487236023,
0.33674341440200806,
0.6178174018859863,
0.9607276916503906,
0.8014995455741882,
-0.13924671709537506,
1.2706166505813599,
-0.1544758528470993,
0.06563805043697357,
1.2840681076049805,
-0.21796242892742157,
0.8645569682121277,
0.23804596066474915,
-0.15898539125919342,
1.0435421466827393,
0.6230239272117615,
0.08468321710824966,
0.6533817648887634,
0.8207927346229553,
-0.2577332854270935,
-0.43361765146255493,
0.19460737705230713,
-0.16873860359191895,
0.6485109925270081,
0.30732688307762146,
-0.46983689069747925,
-0.20023289322853088,
-0.4060310423374176,
-0.08563616871833801,
0.5297951102256775,
-0.5459268093109131,
0.35281237959861755,
0.02154529094696045,
-0.9050716757774353,
0.7176017761230469,
-0.14937542378902435,
0.42587918043136597,
-0.7403092384338379,
-0.21396853029727936,
0.06668491661548615,
0.5766924023628235,
-0.30257448554039,
-0.4533391296863556,
0.5812653303146362,
-0.43221765756607056,
-0.2892374098300934,
-0.26630571484565735,
0.48263368010520935,
-0.087203748524189,
-0.34252679347991943,
0.13607895374298096,
0.1215067133307457,
0.20807695388793945,
-0.10183445364236832,
-0.6867582201957703,
-0.048978425562381744,
-0.17788979411125183,
0.28827160596847534,
0.17503288388252258,
0.30139920115470886,
-0.08294030278921127,
0.5045198202133179,
0.5326328277587891,
0.13358592987060547,
0.49331915378570557,
0.002326380228623748,
0.6906363368034363,
-0.5581632256507874,
-0.6839768886566162,
-1.1395211219787598,
0.5931291580200195,
-0.02747098170220852,
-0.5267803072929382,
0.4475380778312683,
0.4377899169921875,
0.5042775869369507,
0.11485157161951065,
0.39706340432167053,
-0.1153746172785759,
0.06037106364965439,
-0.5294908285140991,
0.5488723516464233,
-0.16374076902866364,
0.0716874748468399,
0.1064496785402298,
-0.7254841923713684,
-0.23671449720859528,
0.7643868327140808,
-0.49832719564437866,
0.05285567045211792,
0.6700239181518555,
0.5258999466896057,
-0.28421053290367126,
0.23530717194080353,
0.040784500539302826,
0.05635324865579605,
0.28177857398986816,
1.2033758163452148,
0.9176851511001587,
-0.43441832065582275,
0.13345465064048767,
-0.18941932916641235,
-0.15826745331287384,
0.30676594376564026,
-0.9693508744239807,
-0.5593912601470947,
-0.3819146156311035,
-0.5095961689949036,
-0.37347468733787537,
0.2623317241668701,
0.777488112449646,
0.7847042083740234,
-0.8095991015434265,
-0.36464640498161316,
-0.7046273946762085,
0.2995882034301758,
-0.7028504014015198,
-0.18789410591125488,
0.11538039147853851,
-0.4633738398551941,
-0.2633214294910431,
0.6461514830589294,
0.010935220867395401,
-0.3501002788543701,
-0.11167096346616745,
-0.21132361888885498,
-0.2579665780067444,
0.23484480381011963,
0.24984239041805267,
0.5754759907722473,
-0.5090199708938599,
-0.23464524745941162,
-0.11004918068647385,
0.05492139607667923,
0.18770188093185425,
0.9211702346801758,
-0.7933785915374756,
0.3286301791667938,
0.6530194282531738,
0.905892550945282,
0.7933654189109802,
-0.10746607929468155,
0.6566286087036133,
-0.5820158123970032,
-0.24621310830116272,
0.47920456528663635,
0.46871793270111084,
0.0000339811340381857,
-0.09954061359167099,
0.40102821588516235,
0.06587827205657959,
-0.6917285919189453,
-0.6095960736274719,
0.19890104234218597,
-0.7772689461708069,
-0.29244986176490784,
0.6398444175720215,
-0.36699166893959045,
-0.49509644508361816,
0.0457351878285408,
0.5126540660858154,
0.15868407487869263,
-0.00914084818214178,
0.8019770383834839,
0.28583088517189026,
-0.5906848907470703,
-0.3842899799346924,
-0.13383004069328308,
0.33986639976501465,
0.35886430740356445,
-0.7982869744300842,
-0.1982710212469101,
0.4678446054458618,
0.39243173599243164,
0.41284626722335815,
0.6873697638511658,
-0.05034361407160759,
0.6321747303009033,
-0.04554295912384987,
0.015696963295340538,
-0.14051520824432373,
-0.5049005746841431,
-0.6239627003669739,
0.3976927399635315,
-0.2801022231578827,
-0.6331269145011902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11626v1 | Metacognitive Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T15:41:31 | 2024-02-18T15:41:31 | Yujia Zhou, Zheng Liu, Jiajie Jin, Jian-Yun Nie, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-augmented generation have become central in natural language
processing due to their efficacy in generating factual content. While
traditional methods employ single-time retrieval, more recent approaches have
shifted towards multi-time retrieval for multi-hop reasoning tasks. However,
these strategies are bound by predefined reasoning steps, potentially leading
to inaccuracies in response generation. This paper introduces MetaRAG, an
approach that combines the retrieval-augmented generation process with
metacognition. Drawing from cognitive psychology, metacognition allows an
entity to self-reflect and critically evaluate its cognitive processes. By
integrating this, MetaRAG enables the model to monitor, evaluate, and plan its
response strategies, enhancing its introspective reasoning abilities. Through a
three-step metacognitive regulation pipeline, the model can identify
inadequacies in initial cognitive responses and fixes them. Empirical
evaluations show that MetaRAG significantly outperforms existing methods. | [
-0.6251806616783142,
-1.0524481534957886,
0.500652551651001,
0.034769926220178604,
-0.040155649185180664,
0.12202578783035278,
-0.23255501687526703,
-0.33832240104675293,
0.2840765118598938,
0.6903026103973389,
-0.46719253063201904,
0.01504272036254406,
-0.40121597051620483,
0.23266734182834625,
-0.22754770517349243,
1.0852341651916504,
0.014426297508180141,
-0.3347008526325226,
0.09281112998723984,
-0.12833434343338013,
-0.8110297918319702,
-0.432735800743103,
-0.6805921196937561,
-0.2786598801612854,
0.502107560634613,
0.4826643466949463,
0.5705435276031494,
0.2196798175573349,
0.4551718831062317,
0.29130563139915466,
0.16049382090568542,
0.3751388192176819,
-0.20604048669338226,
0.35927411913871765,
-0.29658380150794983,
-0.1948312669992447,
-0.4588499069213867,
-0.07532438635826111,
0.5397933721542358,
0.47361448407173157,
-0.34620487689971924,
0.44734498858451843,
0.35993707180023193,
0.5568274855613708,
-1.3839550018310547,
-0.01974789798259735,
-0.6728729605674744,
0.07490868121385574,
-0.20171229541301727,
-0.37572067975997925,
-0.6067867875099182,
-0.26124534010887146,
-0.060918182134628296,
-0.4252399504184723,
0.32912176847457886,
0.10650590062141418,
0.06949685513973236,
0.43831050395965576,
-0.5021809935569763,
-0.6217089891433716,
-0.9982896447181702,
0.5189732909202576,
-0.41928309202194214,
0.32903391122817993,
0.506775975227356,
0.4509216248989105,
0.106470987200737,
-1.0296704769134521,
-0.7060983180999756,
-0.11093714088201523,
-0.3860415816307068,
-0.0000519147542945575,
-0.12971113622188568,
0.07743968069553375,
0.27569663524627686,
0.19172494113445282,
-0.5958985090255737,
-0.29776209592819214,
-0.512549877166748,
-0.22439424693584442,
0.5203618407249451,
0.25919878482818604,
0.13671763241291046,
-0.5320097804069519,
-0.19965822994709015,
-0.0487716980278492,
-0.33311477303504944,
-0.0697794184088707,
0.10947251319885254,
0.37637901306152344,
0.6340425610542297,
0.8546525239944458,
-0.2260410189628601,
0.8921552896499634,
0.3867233693599701,
-0.08273790031671524,
0.12865638732910156,
-0.5420289635658264,
-0.35008081793785095,
0.38247203826904297,
0.8107858300209045,
-0.016925476491451263,
0.023321039974689484,
0.07092717289924622,
-0.015551242977380753,
0.034242402762174606,
0.7200722098350525,
-0.6229661107063293,
-0.1798662394285202,
0.4108385443687439,
-0.33833372592926025,
-0.2508540451526642,
-0.1570747345685959,
-0.9319679141044617,
-0.03137006238102913,
-0.18377645313739777,
0.6223402619361877,
-0.5394842624664307,
-0.21117621660232544,
0.16501173377037048,
-0.019987676292657852,
0.09870384633541107,
0.16202688217163086,
-0.9896571040153503,
0.295136421918869,
0.6552526354789734,
0.7364047169685364,
0.2025669515132904,
-0.328143835067749,
-0.9002158045768738,
0.417824923992157,
-0.38635244965553284,
0.969001054763794,
-0.8490262031555176,
-0.2704748809337616,
-0.0393158458173275,
-0.28123998641967773,
-0.16646189987659454,
-0.37490078806877136,
1.0340638160705566,
-0.6049165725708008,
0.49917978048324585,
-0.2873464822769165,
-0.31551727652549744,
-0.4274722933769226,
0.41624635457992554,
-0.8070120215415955,
1.1566054821014404,
-0.20250140130519867,
-1.1758856773376465,
0.35977357625961304,
-0.7485618591308594,
-0.29928702116012573,
0.3288854956626892,
-0.04942934960126877,
-0.2084677368402481,
-0.03170040622353554,
0.33904457092285156,
0.4583881199359894,
-0.11984851956367493,
0.1827310174703598,
-0.3087138533592224,
-0.21576780080795288,
0.0007921282085590065,
-0.3093659579753876,
0.6427876353263855,
0.24756723642349243,
-0.30137595534324646,
-0.17502456903457642,
-0.6198906898498535,
0.4604528248310089,
-0.1881643831729889,
-0.5092129111289978,
-0.5083887577056885,
-0.020019209012389183,
-0.22859643399715424,
0.31955549120903015,
0.03402591869235039,
-0.333507776260376,
0.11616852134466171,
-0.1532135009765625,
0.5178683996200562,
0.27217692136764526,
0.2086450755596161,
0.4215526282787323,
-0.11158356070518494,
0.48014459013938904,
-0.21334819495677948,
0.007347474806010723,
-0.37210509181022644,
-0.17186860740184784,
-0.677544891834259,
-0.17857185006141663,
0.22712460160255432,
0.5255189538002014,
-0.9260633587837219,
0.42822393774986267,
-0.0968141108751297,
-0.4304870367050171,
-0.7498433589935303,
0.11770225316286087,
0.4287140965461731,
0.6917281150817871,
0.728598952293396,
-0.023172421380877495,
-0.6568898558616638,
-0.6138362288475037,
-0.4747937023639679,
-0.031141743063926697,
0.14554207026958466,
0.21448571979999542,
0.5798024535179138,
-0.5180805921554565,
0.7639306783676147,
-0.6094828844070435,
-0.12085860222578049,
-0.17685280740261078,
0.686998188495636,
0.06467102468013763,
0.41727277636528015,
0.27214059233665466,
-0.7512795925140381,
-0.42835259437561035,
-0.13311374187469482,
-0.6520885825157166,
-0.07323247194290161,
0.09718349575996399,
-0.11319121718406677,
0.1935022622346878,
0.5307369828224182,
-0.7874212861061096,
0.4022786617279053,
0.4156480133533478,
-0.2134268581867218,
0.8103426098823547,
-0.21226246654987335,
0.30545052886009216,
-0.8030601739883423,
0.3834611177444458,
-0.5141304731369019,
-0.2071758359670639,
-0.5178488492965698,
0.1495044231414795,
0.09109299629926682,
-0.13198496401309967,
-0.06600890308618546,
0.46873801946640015,
-0.5772926211357117,
-0.09582304209470749,
-0.44882315397262573,
0.187434121966362,
0.18358281254768372,
0.3144782483577728,
0.07968907058238983,
0.8255074620246887,
0.19786550104618073,
-0.8765625357627869,
0.46275386214256287,
0.3533235192298889,
-0.3143293857574463,
0.7655919194221497,
-0.782397449016571,
0.2002764642238617,
-0.50422602891922,
0.569025456905365,
-0.957541823387146,
-0.31856146454811096,
0.28749996423721313,
-0.4685271680355072,
0.25384092330932617,
-0.020836710929870605,
-0.2650909125804901,
-0.6037363409996033,
-0.20206564664840698,
0.5525298714637756,
0.040805891156196594,
-0.49197372794151306,
0.9052010774612427,
0.017875872552394867,
-0.27089107036590576,
-0.9947360157966614,
-0.593667209148407,
0.04246805980801582,
-0.17197388410568237,
-0.24467992782592773,
0.20978766679763794,
-0.088145412504673,
-0.17389464378356934,
0.09570935368537903,
0.28522831201553345,
-0.0010146964341402054,
-0.08156444132328033,
-0.037136562168598175,
0.07812309265136719,
0.07095419615507126,
0.4299232065677643,
-0.030245007947087288,
-0.17054712772369385,
0.04168539494276047,
-0.2782524526119232,
0.6378578543663025,
0.07605238258838654,
-0.3109225332736969,
-0.07073433697223663,
0.41456353664398193,
0.5910601019859314,
-0.8210523724555969,
0.6871051788330078,
0.8631556034088135,
-0.33961281180381775,
-0.1672915518283844,
-0.8149322867393494,
-0.19488219916820526,
-0.4215969145298004,
0.10993152856826782,
-0.44913777709007263,
-0.6673475503921509,
0.07874932140111923,
-0.017207546159625053,
-0.028637876734137535,
0.5372728109359741,
0.6360889077186584,
-0.3208760917186737,
0.8981530666351318,
0.26637113094329834,
0.27095720171928406,
0.2674432396888733,
-0.26225700974464417,
0.2921653985977173,
-1.3710577487945557,
-0.35332775115966797,
-0.5736513137817383,
-0.30738765001296997,
-0.4626048803329468,
-0.5700876712799072,
0.5576161742210388,
0.1922510415315628,
-0.3932598829269409,
0.3232283592224121,
-0.4772981107234955,
0.3267403244972229,
0.5292472839355469,
0.10429173707962036,
0.4535399377346039,
-0.299629807472229,
-0.3068663775920868,
-0.07266286015510559,
-0.664757251739502,
-0.5147558450698853,
1.1043729782104492,
-0.03486122190952301,
0.5038204193115234,
0.20203939080238342,
0.5037330985069275,
0.4256289005279541,
0.23172424733638763,
-0.6688166856765747,
0.293209433555603,
0.19835475087165833,
-0.9897502660751343,
-0.33122459053993225,
-0.5303434133529663,
-0.9824379086494446,
0.4304119944572449,
-0.539341926574707,
-0.38890722393989563,
-0.035831838846206665,
0.21314214169979095,
-0.6389809250831604,
0.12890392541885376,
-0.5184860825538635,
0.6798049211502075,
-0.2649720311164856,
-0.5024712681770325,
-0.375081866979599,
-0.6170362830162048,
0.7450913190841675,
-0.20466864109039307,
0.28740236163139343,
0.256674587726593,
0.06952694058418274,
0.5094821453094482,
-0.22885338962078094,
0.6286452412605286,
-0.08675804734230042,
0.04447497799992561,
0.6574781537055969,
0.4243350028991699,
0.5409654974937439,
-0.044818587601184845,
-0.038706228137016296,
-0.47902873158454895,
0.011130264028906822,
-0.35236096382141113,
-0.9016377329826355,
0.4910413324832916,
-0.3040929436683655,
-0.39340099692344666,
-0.29390591382980347,
-0.26326316595077515,
-0.1729879081249237,
0.306589812040329,
0.40194329619407654,
0.41830000281333923,
-0.4921022951602936,
0.1353815495967865,
0.5355231761932373,
-0.10914469510316849,
0.7138521075248718,
0.5754616856575012,
-0.26005348563194275,
-0.7268670201301575,
0.3945953845977783,
0.31559234857559204,
0.1612715870141983,
0.41756996512413025,
0.08769014477729797,
-0.44243112206459045,
-0.04476937651634216,
-0.30638471245765686,
0.18206872045993805,
-0.5011144876480103,
-0.4118318259716034,
-0.9459247589111328,
-0.004882201552391052,
-0.4506126046180725,
0.15257704257965088,
-0.2706792950630188,
-0.36724576354026794,
0.07915201783180237,
-0.22177371382713318,
-0.06904202699661255,
0.6489665508270264,
-0.2974768877029419,
0.18393507599830627,
-0.9003522396087646,
0.3882283866405487,
0.7855098843574524,
0.12080676853656769,
0.2634119391441345,
-0.3264576494693756,
-0.1751386523246765,
0.2054397016763687,
-0.5983495712280273,
-0.9289591312408447,
0.2120964527130127,
0.24675767123699188,
0.5066138505935669,
0.38913947343826294,
0.08441843092441559,
0.6460175514221191,
-0.776837170124054,
0.5738954544067383,
0.014553859829902649,
-1.0567376613616943,
0.836609959602356,
-0.2070857584476471,
0.1414424628019333,
0.5821962952613831,
0.49149876832962036,
-0.5378806591033936,
0.05874382331967354,
-0.7064722180366516,
-0.3614747226238251,
0.2553156614303589,
0.09325511753559113,
0.08583421260118484,
-0.3176914155483246,
0.4047410786151886,
-0.1212301179766655,
0.3180609941482544,
-0.5245053172111511,
0.18176482617855072,
-0.23794950544834137,
0.09607408940792084,
-0.24722707271575928,
-0.41440412402153015,
-0.07680543512105942,
-0.20713196694850922,
0.4522109925746918,
-0.28069716691970825,
0.2928668260574341,
0.337032675743103,
-0.12003908306360245,
-0.1408488154411316,
0.4172961413860321,
0.504664421081543,
0.47266885638237,
-0.17539061605930328,
0.39938217401504517,
0.3168988525867462,
-0.3245583474636078,
0.18929778039455414,
-0.1852249950170517,
0.0888441875576973,
0.03384356573224068,
0.7157398462295532,
0.5282231569290161,
0.2951410114765167,
-0.513053297996521,
0.4825023412704468,
0.05651549994945526,
-0.015516909770667553,
-0.2540077865123749,
0.12024502456188202,
-0.11409170180559158,
0.33997830748558044,
0.37180620431900024,
0.12074651569128036,
0.528725266456604,
-0.8451042175292969,
0.29718348383903503,
0.5241071581840515,
-0.1817118376493454,
-0.24635134637355804,
0.6217433214187622,
0.1711461991071701,
-0.2752951681613922,
0.8126847147941589,
-0.09451218694448471,
-0.7314264178276062,
0.060503002256155014,
0.6177656054496765,
1.0052428245544434,
-0.4845728278160095,
0.3919435143470764,
0.9323053956031799,
0.3419111371040344,
-0.23307770490646362,
0.13870583474636078,
-0.35591235756874084,
-0.7650657296180725,
-0.8231931328773499,
-0.5096338987350464,
-0.17844273149967194,
-0.21797820925712585,
-0.8736208081245422,
0.15322987735271454,
-0.32352879643440247,
-0.4410780966281891,
-0.20839668810367584,
0.13345900177955627,
-0.6761017441749573,
0.319408118724823,
0.03956650197505951,
0.8106938600540161,
-0.7317848801612854,
0.479057639837265,
0.5128412842750549,
-0.5129567980766296,
-0.6265233755111694,
0.1356988251209259,
-0.3394363224506378,
-0.7277072072029114,
0.7477025389671326,
-0.013694285415112972,
-0.4027157723903656,
-0.016234654933214188,
-0.5472210049629211,
-0.7879740595817566,
1.0426229238510132,
0.1090543270111084,
-0.3053971230983734,
-0.07646315544843674,
-0.2608872950077057,
0.6332693696022034,
-0.3024963140487671,
0.5164312720298767,
0.6863121390342712,
0.5253440737724304,
0.15134365856647491,
-0.9893015623092651,
0.07031837105751038,
0.003266273532062769,
-0.12529301643371582,
0.46475696563720703,
-0.6434341073036194,
0.9563651084899902,
-0.43922746181488037,
-0.34617722034454346,
-0.37473878264427185,
0.41950154304504395,
0.2909826338291168,
0.22918352484703064,
0.31777334213256836,
0.970011830329895,
0.9481759667396545,
0.30489596724510193,
0.9517914652824402,
-0.16103464365005493,
0.4102557301521301,
1.4116824865341187,
-0.17591756582260132,
1.232619285583496,
0.2642386257648468,
0.03571449965238571,
0.8555051684379578,
0.15205708146095276,
0.3543339967727661,
0.5561954379081726,
-0.2102697640657425,
-0.35108861327171326,
-0.26374557614326477,
-0.09429129213094711,
-0.3883506953716278,
0.8176363706588745,
0.4999069273471832,
-0.3693390190601349,
-0.12596282362937927,
0.12772156298160553,
0.03382711857557297,
0.05950499325990677,
-0.34453484416007996,
0.8397704362869263,
-0.22042860090732574,
-1.065670132637024,
0.6430342793464661,
-0.04950011521577835,
0.3365568220615387,
-0.2516975700855255,
-0.1829213798046112,
-0.11623673141002655,
0.08809502422809601,
-0.24600380659103394,
-0.8302465081214905,
0.6687386631965637,
0.011415957473218441,
-0.265020489692688,
-0.12127811461687088,
0.7747441530227661,
-0.4687485992908478,
-0.543763279914856,
0.29588595032691956,
0.5925963521003723,
-0.19540069997310638,
-0.26172196865081787,
-0.6244565844535828,
-0.01412786915898323,
-0.23405177891254425,
-0.02153048850595951,
-0.1843867003917694,
0.6629066467285156,
0.17713525891304016,
0.7868932485580444,
0.5168886184692383,
-0.09739924222230911,
-0.03333771228790283,
-0.3339352607727051,
0.6385890245437622,
-0.5856548547744751,
-0.3941469192504883,
-0.8827933669090271,
0.3891867697238922,
0.015157748945057392,
-0.04469289258122444,
0.6273100972175598,
0.4599153995513916,
0.5622382760047913,
0.07101108133792877,
0.8631488084793091,
-0.19808094203472137,
0.8930178880691528,
-0.6114821434020996,
0.2502906322479248,
-0.2796097695827484,
-0.017917007207870483,
-0.3627047538757324,
-1.119773507118225,
-0.09445266425609589,
0.6406782269477844,
-0.40376096963882446,
0.17996536195278168,
0.8883251547813416,
0.4344739317893982,
-0.23852187395095825,
-0.06666157394647598,
0.05901973322033882,
0.2106436938047409,
0.17611320316791534,
0.6948277354240417,
0.874286949634552,
-0.535456657409668,
0.6700742840766907,
0.09538654237985611,
-0.1039181798696518,
-0.26732105016708374,
-0.8437442183494568,
-0.7422641515731812,
-0.6238947510719299,
0.01845170184969902,
-0.3153291344642639,
-0.12020177394151688,
0.759346604347229,
0.5754510760307312,
-0.4683968424797058,
0.06591358035802841,
-0.04201293736696243,
0.07152895629405975,
-0.23956942558288574,
-0.2626464366912842,
0.11062490940093994,
-0.698481559753418,
-0.46694421768188477,
0.24279935657978058,
0.17536385357379913,
-0.12242188304662704,
-0.4742424786090851,
0.04465639591217041,
-0.3326154947280884,
0.19572491943836212,
0.6933397054672241,
0.23515231907367706,
-0.4646371901035309,
-0.2469073086977005,
-0.16608205437660217,
-0.13240157067775726,
-0.14241185784339905,
1.020429253578186,
-0.9800257682800293,
0.608022153377533,
0.6148679256439209,
0.5055575370788574,
0.7199417948722839,
0.2860596776008606,
0.5361475944519043,
-0.5632708072662354,
-0.061362624168395996,
0.29640501737594604,
0.15236149728298187,
0.3610885739326477,
-0.350186288356781,
0.6706287860870361,
-0.02028852142393589,
-0.7172462940216064,
-0.6391267776489258,
0.3194752037525177,
-0.3610899746417999,
-0.3542589545249939,
0.8242125511169434,
0.23378367722034454,
-0.019545534625649452,
-0.0213738065212965,
-0.4002605080604553,
0.189503476023674,
-0.01769881509244442,
0.816801130771637,
0.7905279397964478,
-0.2120000571012497,
-0.2518983781337738,
-0.6697887778282166,
0.5647411346435547,
0.2817467749118805,
-0.7709416747093201,
0.16041064262390137,
0.610924482345581,
0.18740101158618927,
0.53975510597229,
0.7680586576461792,
0.09849762916564941,
0.17851363122463226,
-0.0272823479026556,
-0.10363255441188812,
0.19370371103286743,
-0.6382100582122803,
-0.07585911452770233,
0.29249125719070435,
-0.16407927870750427,
-0.2134760618209839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11625v1 | SpeCrawler: Generating OpenAPI Specifications from API Documentation Using Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T15:33:24 | 2024-02-18T15:33:24 | Koren Lazar, Matan Vetzler, Guy Uziel, David Boaz, Esther Goldbraich, David Amid, Ateret Anaby-Tavor | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the digital era, the widespread use of APIs is evident. However, scalable
utilization of APIs poses a challenge due to structure divergence observed in
online API documentation. This underscores the need for automatic tools to
facilitate API consumption. A viable approach involves the conversion of
documentation into an API Specification format. While previous attempts have
been made using rule-based methods, these approaches encountered difficulties
in generalizing across diverse documentation. In this paper we introduce
SpeCrawler, a comprehensive system that utilizes large language models (LLMs)
to generate OpenAPI Specifications from diverse API documentation through a
carefully crafted pipeline. By creating a standardized format for numerous
APIs, SpeCrawler aids in streamlining integration processes within API
orchestrating systems and facilitating the incorporation of tools into LLMs.
The paper explores SpeCrawler's methodology, supported by empirical evidence
and case studies, demonstrating its efficacy through LLM capabilities. | [
-0.3879120945930481,
-0.14440074563026428,
0.4949970841407776,
0.2521909773349762,
-0.18671970069408417,
-0.010307244956493378,
-0.28467440605163574,
-0.6190001368522644,
0.36652451753616333,
0.8328438997268677,
-0.5030314922332764,
-0.6956768035888672,
-0.16301597654819489,
0.03835025429725647,
-0.3026506304740906,
0.9317488074302673,
-0.6119490265846252,
-0.3095550239086151,
0.0773395225405693,
0.04925171285867691,
-0.39988380670547485,
-0.29784026741981506,
-0.1808982938528061,
-0.2899703085422516,
0.6380680799484253,
0.37581586837768555,
0.28327757120132446,
0.6198488473892212,
0.39960727095603943,
0.17682906985282898,
0.08516637980937958,
0.5488218665122986,
-0.36174026131629944,
0.23569044470787048,
0.11710292845964432,
-0.559703528881073,
-0.5089603662490845,
0.16464194655418396,
0.5926326513290405,
0.6601817607879639,
-0.2612782418727875,
0.5970658659934998,
0.12437337636947632,
0.15161971747875214,
-0.7003541588783264,
0.13843031227588654,
-0.4957371652126312,
0.05369618162512779,
-0.45245108008384705,
-0.3898601531982422,
-0.6901243925094604,
-0.507326066493988,
0.20629361271858215,
-0.7606578469276428,
-0.22917509078979492,
0.10547898709774017,
0.6779405474662781,
0.37014636397361755,
-0.22450311481952667,
-0.4894493818283081,
-1.132422685623169,
0.7001027464866638,
-0.890042245388031,
0.23281943798065186,
0.24604463577270508,
0.6440130472183228,
-0.1271890252828598,
-0.9610044360160828,
-0.29589998722076416,
-0.18056848645210266,
-0.09747188538312912,
0.09129408001899719,
-0.31048738956451416,
0.16756246984004974,
0.02778337150812149,
0.4623051881790161,
-0.5343395471572876,
0.19252616167068481,
-0.4359736442565918,
-0.2651180624961853,
0.41576266288757324,
0.2963126301765442,
0.2907092571258545,
0.01579979807138443,
-0.02943754568696022,
0.14813180267810822,
-0.5269597172737122,
-0.16939401626586914,
0.6787460446357727,
0.5461722612380981,
-0.07663515955209732,
0.8489623069763184,
-0.04056815057992935,
0.5374071598052979,
-0.2805228531360626,
-0.29659122228622437,
0.2703600525856018,
-0.1382005512714386,
-0.11242856085300446,
-0.08535663038492203,
0.42265939712524414,
0.4798106253147125,
0.15065893530845642,
-0.39478829503059387,
-0.22784234583377838,
-0.01647280715405941,
0.2951325476169586,
-0.6665171980857849,
-0.026429614052176476,
0.5225719809532166,
-0.7655433416366577,
0.045273296535015106,
-0.0993989109992981,
-0.5325061082839966,
-0.22351399064064026,
-0.3681056499481201,
-0.14818458259105682,
-0.6017642021179199,
-0.3960248529911041,
-0.10847527533769608,
-0.5466030240058899,
0.3506377935409546,
0.12167097628116608,
-0.6457719206809998,
0.521736204624176,
0.8897352814674377,
1.038499116897583,
-0.06503617763519287,
-0.3476030230522156,
-0.31477901339530945,
0.528958797454834,
-0.2648572623729706,
0.9804836511611938,
-0.6051971912384033,
-0.4278023838996887,
0.25083762407302856,
-0.2707676589488983,
0.047132980078458786,
-0.5572077035903931,
0.6531462669372559,
-0.5385367274284363,
-0.1935972273349762,
0.2139579802751541,
-0.7882581949234009,
0.09868218004703522,
0.3028869032859802,
-0.7448915243148804,
0.8890878558158875,
0.11582983285188675,
-0.5574905872344971,
0.32664525508880615,
-1.088195562362671,
-0.2561092972755432,
0.4247804284095764,
0.12756961584091187,
0.05840449780225754,
0.11166005581617355,
-0.16548439860343933,
-0.02469450794160366,
-0.12818703055381775,
-0.11574064195156097,
-0.1560686081647873,
-0.33637169003486633,
0.104930579662323,
-0.14477266371250153,
0.5702784657478333,
0.4278698265552521,
0.2565765082836151,
0.30741316080093384,
-0.946883499622345,
0.051620032638311386,
-0.21053747832775116,
-0.7173568606376648,
-0.5229598879814148,
0.20470736920833588,
0.4171525835990906,
-0.15755029022693634,
0.39309486746788025,
-0.7482990622520447,
0.20717380940914154,
-0.5078237652778625,
0.617364764213562,
0.5435801148414612,
-0.08972705900669098,
0.3910379707813263,
-0.2685040533542633,
0.5343839526176453,
-0.5173545479774475,
0.4907887876033783,
-0.40540093183517456,
-0.350260853767395,
-0.4754694998264313,
-0.5492640137672424,
0.2617332637310028,
0.3858066499233246,
-0.05572851747274399,
0.5211153030395508,
-0.34440848231315613,
-0.7764541506767273,
-0.6515821814537048,
0.09685466438531876,
0.19672074913978577,
0.36055073142051697,
0.14465411007404327,
-0.01611371897161007,
-1.0301859378814697,
-0.7169531583786011,
-0.04117277264595032,
-0.14839142560958862,
-0.30413857102394104,
0.46173790097236633,
0.16967566311359406,
-0.4124087989330292,
1.1318280696868896,
-0.6212432980537415,
-0.21864402294158936,
-0.23139290511608124,
0.26886889338493347,
0.22577551007270813,
0.298196017742157,
0.7437697649002075,
-0.47901639342308044,
-0.2952316701412201,
-0.07342858612537384,
-0.4706861078739166,
-0.25772613286972046,
0.2860960364341736,
-0.46851134300231934,
0.25420081615448,
0.47797396779060364,
-0.68282151222229,
0.2671035826206207,
0.6310847401618958,
0.0008585081668570638,
0.8453139662742615,
-0.19924119114875793,
-0.341036856174469,
-1.0718985795974731,
0.36220264434814453,
0.05838306248188019,
-0.00930937472730875,
-0.564321756362915,
0.5669816136360168,
-0.07305369526147842,
-0.1309451460838318,
-0.34292086958885193,
0.4270459711551666,
-0.27189522981643677,
-0.10982191562652588,
-0.05596216022968292,
-0.30916088819503784,
-0.0655994713306427,
-0.04849626496434212,
-0.06326878815889359,
0.66036057472229,
0.1593177169561386,
-0.5254755020141602,
0.3380833566188812,
0.2508409023284912,
-0.1636820286512375,
0.35083261132240295,
-0.5840577483177185,
-0.008952518925070763,
0.2989635765552521,
0.6963738203048706,
-1.2657064199447632,
-0.34599506855010986,
0.24129775166511536,
-0.051239922642707825,
-0.2907889485359192,
-0.6245858073234558,
-0.9023948907852173,
-0.6978152394294739,
-0.27276286482810974,
0.19470587372779846,
0.5893986225128174,
-0.5613431930541992,
1.1342641115188599,
0.28124943375587463,
-0.05185551941394806,
-0.20803846418857574,
-0.8194648027420044,
0.16860128939151764,
-0.2286641150712967,
-0.73521488904953,
0.18187010288238525,
-0.4558909833431244,
-0.35914599895477295,
-0.13318507373332977,
-0.08516049385070801,
-0.18748223781585693,
-0.06661126017570496,
0.4852265417575836,
0.4424634873867035,
-0.5227933526039124,
0.04410204663872719,
-0.1198088601231575,
-0.011566387489438057,
0.0509612150490284,
-0.7423387765884399,
0.8882516026496887,
0.34308749437332153,
-0.6081931591033936,
-0.41668587923049927,
0.5188143253326416,
0.8307528495788574,
-0.6251416802406311,
0.4140610694885254,
0.23487494885921478,
0.0004206607991363853,
-0.5810064077377319,
-0.7012423276901245,
0.1633419245481491,
-0.48238277435302734,
-0.0524713397026062,
-0.4944836497306824,
-0.5178693532943726,
0.880511462688446,
-0.60801762342453,
0.6151630878448486,
0.017597027122974396,
0.24438071250915527,
0.047793641686439514,
0.9204064011573792,
0.9306434392929077,
0.10839420557022095,
0.5984328389167786,
-0.248824343085289,
0.27237439155578613,
-0.7706612348556519,
-0.1772422045469284,
-0.5161541104316711,
-0.41375869512557983,
-0.3849276602268219,
-0.34777072072029114,
0.25005245208740234,
-0.3995012044906616,
-0.04519282281398773,
-0.004878329578787088,
-0.4949878454208374,
0.6434884071350098,
0.5731322169303894,
-0.07407655566930771,
0.2666683793067932,
0.06835181266069412,
-0.2637341320514679,
0.3549695611000061,
-0.25265341997146606,
-0.8534085154533386,
1.364734411239624,
0.4925994277000427,
0.802205502986908,
0.1936676800251007,
1.0107967853546143,
0.04596330597996712,
0.3535051941871643,
-0.9662377834320068,
0.5487196445465088,
-0.4075239598751068,
-0.31426316499710083,
-0.23954419791698456,
-0.027147455140948296,
-0.7212904095649719,
-0.007050557993352413,
0.34492841362953186,
-0.6010947227478027,
0.20533283054828644,
0.07541505992412567,
-0.333638995885849,
0.36283642053604126,
-0.8843728303909302,
0.5361883044242859,
0.15714886784553528,
0.2523718476295471,
-0.04117712751030922,
-0.25932011008262634,
0.4975930154323578,
-0.006387948989868164,
0.21480759978294373,
-0.14770767092704773,
-0.2417561411857605,
0.4700734615325928,
-0.8500528335571289,
0.9338541030883789,
-0.25441262125968933,
-0.5472168922424316,
0.22810232639312744,
0.14861422777175903,
0.2947627007961273,
-0.269380122423172,
-0.472263365983963,
0.09841538965702057,
-0.03771015256643295,
-0.23207420110702515,
-0.2540636360645294,
0.4810575842857361,
-0.8415655493736267,
-0.17653000354766846,
0.32000669836997986,
-0.9524284601211548,
-0.0682535246014595,
0.2563335597515106,
0.033521801233291626,
0.39785006642341614,
-0.3701501786708832,
-0.4515796899795532,
0.6121010780334473,
0.046411145478487015,
0.41836273670196533,
0.8516104817390442,
-0.4029723107814789,
-0.17086674273014069,
0.7607767581939697,
0.429636150598526,
0.1151762530207634,
0.03536878898739815,
0.0028975517489016056,
-0.22177062928676605,
-0.7924005389213562,
-0.20543047785758972,
0.263060986995697,
-0.8114650845527649,
-0.0341683067381382,
-0.32973194122314453,
-0.3810505270957947,
-0.4852345883846283,
-0.16751262545585632,
-0.15430375933647156,
-0.25110530853271484,
-0.09649432450532913,
-0.03440413624048233,
0.4665044844150543,
0.8679414391517639,
0.019292732700705528,
0.2479335069656372,
-0.7196192145347595,
0.22335092723369598,
0.1796841025352478,
0.7848897576332092,
0.061947476118803024,
-0.2379123866558075,
-0.1526859551668167,
-0.2558886706829071,
0.11077052354812622,
-0.595566987991333,
0.2309158742427826,
0.15449367463588715,
0.8991508483886719,
0.4421626925468445,
0.23502196371555328,
0.6576512455940247,
-0.8413454294204712,
0.8357879519462585,
-0.158873051404953,
-0.765998899936676,
0.771695077419281,
-0.39657899737358093,
0.11077269911766052,
0.1895076036453247,
0.29026278853416443,
-0.484836608171463,
-0.7257389426231384,
-0.15256920456886292,
-1.249683141708374,
0.5711866617202759,
-0.26601293683052063,
0.322269469499588,
0.047704946249723434,
0.44749072194099426,
0.33302441239356995,
-0.051018599420785904,
-0.21894286572933197,
-0.15521240234375,
-0.1870776116847992,
-0.44205984473228455,
-0.010992765426635742,
-0.1987956464290619,
-0.5322393178939819,
0.0026142331771552563,
0.3017583191394806,
-0.25287941098213196,
-0.12370973080396652,
0.030114231631159782,
-0.21253922581672668,
-0.11662996560335159,
0.3571338653564453,
0.3737271726131439,
0.9527146816253662,
-0.43450987339019775,
0.14143523573875427,
-0.17259275913238525,
-0.49152815341949463,
-0.21514394879341125,
0.37247082591056824,
-0.24601353704929352,
0.22426559031009674,
0.2823777496814728,
0.4729272127151489,
0.1941809058189392,
-0.9843871593475342,
0.090450718998909,
-0.15161563456058502,
-0.3207349181175232,
-0.5712610483169556,
-0.07252823561429977,
0.1012839525938034,
0.3676932156085968,
0.6555795073509216,
-0.10479141771793365,
0.23505330085754395,
-0.3657776117324829,
0.02755097858607769,
0.25153419375419617,
0.22445255517959595,
-0.1329285204410553,
0.3338475525379181,
0.3547399640083313,
-0.36814504861831665,
0.30365288257598877,
-0.023516720160841942,
-0.0018375408835709095,
0.37298697233200073,
0.6368921399116516,
0.7727723717689514,
-0.2862553298473358,
0.18162722885608673,
0.04587511345744133,
0.3001507818698883,
-0.06506942957639694,
0.4186498522758484,
-0.14120037853717804,
-0.4322143793106079,
-0.5949153900146484,
-0.7758378386497498,
-0.6769284009933472,
0.04856035113334656,
-0.5737605094909668,
0.1336851567029953,
-0.6605891585350037,
0.013386063277721405,
0.38492968678474426,
-0.3285176455974579,
-0.5229375958442688,
-0.41996097564697266,
0.5598079562187195,
1.5323153734207153,
-0.9152644872665405,
0.5660759806632996,
0.9583795070648193,
-0.8208318948745728,
-1.1518992185592651,
0.3149945139884949,
0.03424159064888954,
-0.7095347046852112,
0.635559618473053,
-0.047535330057144165,
-0.15278470516204834,
0.04873966798186302,
-0.5994412302970886,
-0.8432249426841736,
1.0275802612304688,
0.3731030225753784,
-0.41982683539390564,
-0.21129590272903442,
0.38639453053474426,
0.6430927515029907,
-0.5954609513282776,
0.47571343183517456,
0.6425856947898865,
0.6593135595321655,
0.24651475250720978,
-1.2398526668548584,
0.08349987864494324,
-0.3721674978733063,
0.24044837057590485,
0.011507287621498108,
-0.5758495330810547,
0.9249505400657654,
0.31146037578582764,
-0.07594499737024307,
0.32461217045783997,
0.2790610194206238,
0.3321276903152466,
0.13628987967967987,
0.4545916020870209,
0.47727540135383606,
0.9961563348770142,
0.2944837808609009,
0.9012325406074524,
-0.45294317603111267,
-0.3277742266654968,
1.0077133178710938,
-0.655789315700531,
1.3626396656036377,
0.518143892288208,
-0.05101949721574783,
1.0035842657089233,
0.5672335624694824,
-0.16924887895584106,
0.22334539890289307,
0.19742241501808167,
-0.09099095314741135,
-0.02455054596066475,
-0.26780223846435547,
-0.2248038500547409,
0.5194305777549744,
0.21556983888149261,
-0.31092917919158936,
-0.48348578810691833,
0.016009269282221794,
-0.22930428385734558,
0.024610895663499832,
-0.47922980785369873,
0.9322882294654846,
-0.2788081169128418,
-0.634321928024292,
0.61733078956604,
-0.1175629049539566,
0.8651922941207886,
-0.6951023936271667,
-0.0346342958509922,
-0.1908283829689026,
0.15161527693271637,
-0.32186463475227356,
-0.7762949466705322,
0.47613292932510376,
0.28321996331214905,
-0.4894231855869293,
-0.25982680916786194,
0.5827890634536743,
-0.11076728999614716,
-0.3580206632614136,
0.46343913674354553,
0.5077301859855652,
0.42486754059791565,
0.12851393222808838,
-0.07451820373535156,
0.3214161694049835,
-0.3666350543498993,
0.023884166032075882,
0.208025261759758,
0.49127063155174255,
0.11477042734622955,
0.5256090760231018,
0.7605730891227722,
0.30641546845436096,
0.35962408781051636,
0.48252108693122864,
1.0664650201797485,
-0.13112837076187134,
-0.8705618977546692,
-0.6239588856697083,
0.6500570774078369,
-0.15041372179985046,
-0.09344998747110367,
0.7375069856643677,
0.9499188661575317,
0.5010315775871277,
-0.0770169347524643,
1.1880109310150146,
0.09968297183513641,
0.7349002361297607,
-0.22787527740001678,
0.7446671724319458,
-0.29679206013679504,
0.4678612947463989,
0.06398124992847443,
-0.7622290849685669,
-0.19654636085033417,
-0.006159348413348198,
-0.31950709223747253,
-0.6271014213562012,
0.29657137393951416,
0.6803338527679443,
-0.3957909941673279,
-0.0045671346597373486,
-0.14320030808448792,
0.18480980396270752,
0.4365474283695221,
0.20370684564113617,
0.8677797317504883,
-0.0037691383622586727,
1.2184457778930664,
0.17957362532615662,
-0.4370611011981964,
-0.3695862293243408,
-0.6542309522628784,
-0.7332205772399902,
-0.34119588136672974,
-0.08653240650892258,
-0.0602734200656414,
-0.05889685079455376,
0.8566551208496094,
1.0459963083267212,
-0.5811759233474731,
-0.6086806654930115,
-0.08092961460351944,
0.06224615499377251,
-0.16441017389297485,
-0.2319725900888443,
-0.11009193956851959,
-0.6422023177146912,
-0.618247926235199,
0.4833947420120239,
0.1850537359714508,
0.0381392203271389,
-0.5382598042488098,
-0.15215690433979034,
0.1736467033624649,
0.5297264456748962,
0.3922690749168396,
0.49110251665115356,
-0.9219244718551636,
-0.05263110622763634,
-0.30259957909584045,
0.07560288906097412,
0.1263609230518341,
0.8351518511772156,
-0.6652522683143616,
0.0726226419210434,
0.35065627098083496,
0.19970561563968658,
0.3200664818286896,
-0.2612028419971466,
0.5968875885009766,
-1.0009516477584839,
0.09925173968076706,
0.06541085243225098,
0.3314531147480011,
-0.08011622726917267,
-0.203147754073143,
0.48460933566093445,
-0.255769819021225,
-0.4364100992679596,
-1.2374789714813232,
0.30430662631988525,
-0.935026228427887,
-0.39770153164863586,
1.0154201984405518,
-0.3147582411766052,
-0.37845656275749207,
-0.321161687374115,
-0.4617329239845276,
0.29678234457969666,
-0.49458712339401245,
0.5109622478485107,
0.3968459665775299,
-0.21969573199748993,
-0.1411939263343811,
-0.4693969488143921,
0.07087034732103348,
-0.4807233214378357,
-0.8832888603210449,
0.5102150440216064,
0.5457618832588196,
0.6526312828063965,
0.6536688804626465,
0.5635003447532654,
-0.007588102016597986,
0.05843754857778549,
0.24795690178871155,
0.3267710208892822,
-0.13084204494953156,
0.13685423135757446,
0.017654037103056908,
0.39586371183395386,
0.26880571246147156,
-0.24280595779418945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11622v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11622v2 | Logical Closed Loop: Uncovering Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-18T15:28:39 | 2024-06-28T07:20:22 | Junfei Wu, Qiang Liu, Ding Wang, Jinghao Zhang, Shu Wu, Liang Wang, Tieniu Tan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Object hallucination has been an Achilles' heel which hinders the broader
applications of large vision-language models (LVLMs). Object hallucination
refers to the phenomenon that the LVLMs claim non-existent objects in the
image. To mitigate the object hallucinations, instruction tuning and external
model-based detection methods have been proposed, which either require
large-scare computational resources or depend on the detection result of
external models. However, there remains an under-explored field to utilize the
LVLM itself to alleviate object hallucinations. In this work, we adopt the
intuition that the LVLM tends to respond logically consistently for existent
objects but inconsistently for hallucinated objects. Therefore, we propose a
Logical Closed Loop-based framework for Object Hallucination Detection and
Mitigation, namely LogicCheckGPT. In specific, we devise logical consistency
probing to raise questions with logical correlations, inquiring about
attributes from objects and vice versa. Whether their responses can form a
logical closed loop serves as an indicator of object hallucination. As a
plug-and-play method, it can be seamlessly applied to all existing LVLMs.
Comprehensive experiments conducted on three benchmarks across four LVLMs have
demonstrated significant improvements brought by our method, indicating its
effectiveness and generality. | [
-0.444307804107666,
-0.9952355027198792,
0.7703098654747009,
-0.3805600106716156,
-0.35545581579208374,
-0.3835226893424988,
-0.15937408804893494,
-0.6713339686393738,
0.06284274905920029,
0.6847600936889648,
-0.54346764087677,
-0.4175223410129547,
-0.24192917346954346,
0.0983564555644989,
-0.6018815040588379,
0.6810113191604614,
0.10688783973455429,
-0.06070603057742119,
-0.31637006998062134,
-0.10713688284158707,
-0.7986315488815308,
-0.4403468370437622,
-0.15899662673473358,
-0.4057047963142395,
0.22831231355667114,
0.051727067679166794,
0.7327577471733093,
0.4388829171657562,
0.6617732644081116,
0.2397054135799408,
0.15308889746665955,
0.3215259611606598,
-0.4619612395763397,
-0.0008461304241791368,
-0.527395486831665,
-0.21760909259319305,
-0.32991233468055725,
-0.2887745797634125,
0.21926343441009521,
0.5615691542625427,
-0.39660292863845825,
0.06664630025625229,
-0.34368765354156494,
0.6932525634765625,
-0.9612560868263245,
0.20289860665798187,
-0.8748241662979126,
0.3705419898033142,
0.05419884994626045,
-0.1628052145242691,
-0.5568928718566895,
-0.21252433955669403,
-0.11617203801870346,
-0.49299612641334534,
0.3106418251991272,
0.2768591344356537,
0.7101050615310669,
0.463575541973114,
0.11739659309387207,
-0.2367180585861206,
-0.7030074000358582,
0.6953524947166443,
-0.5701645016670227,
0.6091278791427612,
0.2999497354030609,
0.3666405975818634,
-0.15279920399188995,
-0.46339842677116394,
-0.8147337436676025,
-0.4692268669605255,
-0.10854221135377884,
0.15002182126045227,
0.04320032149553299,
0.025294793769717216,
0.6504089832305908,
0.2384059727191925,
-0.5441492199897766,
-0.10167119652032852,
-0.5111500024795532,
-0.4126593768596649,
0.3802614212036133,
0.17400097846984863,
0.24859590828418732,
0.11081596463918686,
-0.3249289095401764,
0.14952173829078674,
-0.5066180229187012,
-0.2211606800556183,
0.2762477695941925,
0.12369551509618759,
0.36105820536613464,
0.842058539390564,
-0.31838953495025635,
0.9915647506713867,
-0.1123918667435646,
-0.25367891788482666,
0.25141090154647827,
-0.18728107213974,
-0.3468030095100403,
0.3413965106010437,
0.4249483048915863,
0.4337000548839569,
0.5908675193786621,
-0.2555365562438965,
-0.49409908056259155,
0.6191728115081787,
0.37905046343803406,
-0.753079354763031,
-0.5528225898742676,
0.35951992869377136,
-0.5057824850082397,
-0.23396535217761993,
0.2709527611732483,
-0.6825985312461853,
-0.7135195732116699,
-0.5568938255310059,
0.6169556975364685,
-0.45151153206825256,
-0.4667660593986511,
0.6918820738792419,
-0.05035734176635742,
0.49714571237564087,
0.46518611907958984,
-0.6155494451522827,
0.2224755436182022,
0.7847543358802795,
0.726830780506134,
-0.21562491357326508,
-0.2700577676296234,
-0.8707144260406494,
0.017337437719106674,
-0.6513680219650269,
0.8970378637313843,
-0.6181451678276062,
-0.1604013293981552,
-0.014536948874592781,
0.16569167375564575,
0.1422654539346695,
-0.8619964122772217,
0.5885769128799438,
-0.21755851805210114,
0.01127996202558279,
-0.337831974029541,
-0.5449835062026978,
-0.23745609819889069,
0.3865261673927307,
-0.4631659984588623,
0.7859221696853638,
-0.11589591950178146,
-0.7126511931419373,
0.33050793409347534,
-0.38908514380455017,
-0.27853912115097046,
0.027534237131476402,
-0.4688188433647156,
-0.6557647585868835,
0.26646167039871216,
0.28060153126716614,
0.37784504890441895,
-0.1825721710920334,
0.30526819825172424,
-0.5158953070640564,
-0.769498884677887,
0.12283375859260559,
-0.0014325107913464308,
0.5594853758811951,
-0.06322713941335678,
-0.5259222388267517,
0.376020222902298,
-0.6438009738922119,
0.013324210420250893,
0.20060408115386963,
0.41739264130592346,
-0.12495512515306473,
0.2824668288230896,
-0.19692248106002808,
0.15913274884223938,
-0.0774700939655304,
-0.560329794883728,
0.1368776559829712,
-0.2204972803592682,
0.08748931437730789,
0.7926520705223083,
-0.1021319255232811,
-0.0938836857676506,
-0.2542249858379364,
0.13584274053573608,
0.335368275642395,
0.1731969714164734,
-0.22320839762687683,
-0.4702816605567932,
-0.9080742597579956,
-0.2501358687877655,
-0.45516613125801086,
0.616967499256134,
-0.64644855260849,
0.6885132789611816,
0.022204359993338585,
-0.15335793793201447,
-0.2144959419965744,
-0.0077285668812692165,
0.28638240694999695,
0.8611667156219482,
0.4463038444519043,
-0.2617506682872772,
-0.40303337574005127,
-1.026434063911438,
-0.011460212990641594,
-0.09077157080173492,
-0.11116039752960205,
0.1195564791560173,
0.8156212568283081,
-0.30194342136383057,
0.7691062092781067,
-0.63661128282547,
-0.5150688886642456,
0.06382225453853607,
-0.41975104808807373,
0.12479012459516525,
0.3530626893043518,
0.2435215711593628,
-0.7832766175270081,
0.07036823034286499,
0.2242678701877594,
-1.0740139484405518,
-0.019157683476805687,
-0.04715993255376816,
-0.09649164229631424,
0.4993613064289093,
0.6852113604545593,
-0.6065002083778381,
0.7990544438362122,
0.16250303387641907,
-0.3447326421737671,
0.9331978559494019,
-0.1721828281879425,
-0.040134917944669724,
-0.46728625893592834,
0.21520568430423737,
-0.3327052891254425,
-0.08450186252593994,
-0.5038561224937439,
0.01463961973786354,
0.14080075919628143,
-0.1753762662410736,
-0.3830295205116272,
0.2334064245223999,
-0.39642879366874695,
-0.37708792090415955,
-0.3376007080078125,
0.353228896856308,
-0.07192562520503998,
0.43193280696868896,
0.3231242597103119,
0.4523332118988037,
0.8233543634414673,
-0.47913265228271484,
0.6701410412788391,
0.04857673868536949,
-0.42449259757995605,
0.6455481648445129,
-0.5965368151664734,
0.2134692668914795,
-0.38080650568008423,
0.14092151820659637,
-0.559877872467041,
-0.12859387695789337,
0.5906857848167419,
-0.03802802041172981,
-0.03564530983567238,
0.11746811121702194,
-0.4552978277206421,
-0.2697511613368988,
-0.2736205458641052,
0.31781795620918274,
0.6168546080589294,
-0.6523748636245728,
0.6088786721229553,
0.05833424627780914,
0.5485524535179138,
-0.43725720047950745,
-0.45685893297195435,
-0.0250849612057209,
-0.016681155189871788,
-0.6604946255683899,
-0.17274370789527893,
-0.21459850668907166,
-0.37496888637542725,
0.04306903854012489,
-0.47697994112968445,
0.2239905148744583,
-0.08501271903514862,
0.1650795042514801,
0.3924296200275421,
-0.34780195355415344,
0.18905670940876007,
-0.63588547706604,
-0.1420048028230667,
0.24684056639671326,
-0.6502957940101624,
0.6107446551322937,
-0.5421643257141113,
-0.9097628593444824,
-0.4233655035495758,
0.213096484541893,
0.596868634223938,
-0.47888845205307007,
0.6117859482765198,
0.5839048027992249,
-0.6310153603553772,
-0.42748579382896423,
-0.6848762035369873,
-0.5300068259239197,
-0.46097052097320557,
0.43530529737472534,
-0.5483891367912292,
-0.44785138964653015,
0.7214208841323853,
0.20212891697883606,
-0.3097912669181824,
0.10427971929311752,
0.6366006135940552,
0.2492535412311554,
0.8215259909629822,
0.4161836802959442,
0.10818719863891602,
0.11955472081899643,
-0.01640731282532215,
0.6745134592056274,
-0.6622995734214783,
-0.5967403054237366,
-0.11167801171541214,
-0.025994224473834038,
-0.3798428475856781,
-0.46001139283180237,
0.01695946976542473,
0.03345825895667076,
-0.25074684619903564,
-0.00919350329786539,
-0.7964162826538086,
0.8649805188179016,
0.2806963324546814,
0.49300500750541687,
0.41895902156829834,
-0.08099058270454407,
0.032227106392383575,
0.11575507372617722,
-0.4698321223258972,
-0.1873948574066162,
0.5907000303268433,
0.05254323035478592,
0.8850702047348022,
-0.13566555082798004,
0.4552391469478607,
0.14784513413906097,
0.011941032484173775,
-1.0474214553833008,
0.7846091985702515,
0.19592177867889404,
-0.3373807966709137,
-0.26497548818588257,
-0.1888015866279602,
-0.3920154273509979,
0.4270223379135132,
-0.1131560429930687,
-1.0606704950332642,
0.24808181822299957,
0.364582896232605,
0.062133971601724625,
0.6485470533370972,
-0.5326195955276489,
0.930012047290802,
-0.28000637888908386,
-0.596154510974884,
-0.07592590153217316,
-0.5786489844322205,
0.7834747433662415,
-0.270087331533432,
-0.1263057440519333,
-0.1513976901769638,
0.2101576328277588,
0.22701917588710785,
-0.37788984179496765,
0.7868390083312988,
-0.04494874179363251,
-0.2978649437427521,
0.31224873661994934,
0.3047175705432892,
0.7969303131103516,
-0.045802365988492966,
0.29649126529693604,
0.1829921007156372,
-0.20432148873806,
-0.3793017864227295,
-0.7234558463096619,
0.5312408208847046,
-0.23909446597099304,
-0.7937743663787842,
-0.4735659956932068,
-0.6398590207099915,
-0.13446633517742157,
0.29310721158981323,
0.09149295091629028,
0.3748380243778229,
0.22860568761825562,
0.2736183702945709,
1.0242481231689453,
-0.31253311038017273,
0.09861637651920319,
0.2611364722251892,
-0.6789470314979553,
0.15179044008255005,
0.9283124208450317,
-0.13678306341171265,
0.32673048973083496,
0.16123510897159576,
0.3137362599372864,
-0.12453708052635193,
-0.5232775807380676,
-0.262294203042984,
0.22926132380962372,
-0.9122485518455505,
-0.1057630330324173,
-0.48732706904411316,
-0.18991278111934662,
-0.2164047807455063,
-0.1856468915939331,
-0.4437037706375122,
0.02773721143603325,
0.006197180598974228,
-0.04802243411540985,
0.230441614985466,
0.43892186880111694,
0.1227026954293251,
-0.46337345242500305,
-0.35544389486312866,
0.7091543078422546,
0.26725390553474426,
0.5175094604492188,
-0.02191704697906971,
-0.30695393681526184,
0.08978038281202316,
-0.032199062407016754,
0.18284928798675537,
-0.660781741142273,
0.20372648537158966,
-0.09217627346515656,
0.5022733807563782,
0.63890141248703,
0.31552618741989136,
0.8111610412597656,
-0.4857330322265625,
0.5429919958114624,
0.2584003210067749,
-1.0158790349960327,
0.7070523500442505,
-0.3411993980407715,
0.19203686714172363,
0.08004340529441833,
-0.18937358260154724,
-0.45938563346862793,
-0.4176788330078125,
-0.38965919613838196,
-0.5908076763153076,
0.5985519886016846,
0.27460888028144836,
-0.3656884431838989,
0.26122739911079407,
0.10833679884672165,
0.0479438379406929,
0.2531881332397461,
-0.7001947164535522,
0.11233840882778168,
-0.5109315514564514,
0.0159786157310009,
0.14939995110034943,
-0.03828777000308037,
-0.2941504716873169,
-0.2968955934047699,
0.3919944167137146,
-0.2028273493051529,
0.2545912265777588,
0.3303951621055603,
-0.14661341905593872,
-0.04280281066894531,
-0.06490220874547958,
0.9343675374984741,
0.9826866388320923,
-0.4765181839466095,
0.272621750831604,
0.06935062259435654,
-0.48483791947364807,
-0.09537874907255173,
-0.3440965712070465,
-0.2909858822822571,
-0.049706410616636276,
0.448758602142334,
0.8339251279830933,
-0.18742677569389343,
-1.0885123014450073,
0.446041077375412,
0.22436168789863586,
-0.2296200841665268,
-0.5281893014907837,
0.2972184419631958,
-0.15697799623012543,
0.27885696291923523,
0.05035094916820526,
0.22275274991989136,
0.11052533239126205,
-0.6701749563217163,
0.4024515748023987,
0.5773345828056335,
-0.4121842384338379,
-0.12279778718948364,
0.5990228056907654,
-0.21916648745536804,
-0.24833811819553375,
0.8078063130378723,
-0.05745325982570648,
-0.7236382365226746,
0.8021150827407837,
0.6516472101211548,
1.0271095037460327,
0.16076704859733582,
-0.05555470660328865,
0.17459528148174286,
0.6695830821990967,
-0.3025447130203247,
0.28135183453559875,
-0.04531681910157204,
-0.9380252361297607,
-0.18303005397319794,
-0.55585116147995,
-0.39800095558166504,
0.2041143923997879,
-0.654651403427124,
0.35232388973236084,
-0.32060888409614563,
0.41115811467170715,
-0.3594462275505066,
-0.4367036521434784,
-0.4326898157596588,
0.14908206462860107,
0.2244279831647873,
0.6642298698425293,
-0.7664147019386292,
0.9135251641273499,
0.40838882327079773,
-0.2788219749927521,
-0.6795978546142578,
0.20446379482746124,
0.008663333021104336,
-0.7695005536079407,
0.6345619559288025,
0.4386400282382965,
-0.5047571063041687,
-0.13667090237140656,
-0.48423531651496887,
-0.44283345341682434,
0.8840468525886536,
0.3155593276023865,
-0.5990526676177979,
0.3013440668582916,
0.05403631925582886,
0.40603479743003845,
-0.33492177724838257,
-0.1124621331691742,
0.6948582530021667,
0.5939005613327026,
0.2932951748371124,
-0.6059259176254272,
0.3038365840911865,
-0.12036455422639847,
-0.11642993986606598,
0.43446093797683716,
-0.3837723433971405,
0.6207519173622131,
-0.5301583409309387,
-0.17735813558101654,
-0.02735292539000511,
0.396347314119339,
0.4784877598285675,
0.40342119336128235,
0.49350762367248535,
0.7022026777267456,
0.8617031574249268,
-0.131901815533638,
0.9480019807815552,
-0.1985466182231903,
0.45847630500793457,
1.061900019645691,
-0.5641998052597046,
0.701923131942749,
0.60465407371521,
0.15520364046096802,
0.06803829967975616,
0.33342376351356506,
-0.34118297696113586,
0.49321675300598145,
0.38713565468788147,
-0.23111501336097717,
-0.4555091857910156,
-0.06392932683229446,
-0.5591121912002563,
0.3946005702018738,
0.30127406120300293,
-0.05640268698334694,
-0.12537920475006104,
0.18437911570072174,
-0.26777103543281555,
-0.12832069396972656,
-0.39140042662620544,
0.518426775932312,
-0.045741964131593704,
-0.6527165174484253,
0.7655133008956909,
-0.4852496087551117,
0.32760486006736755,
-0.4360378086566925,
-0.3493843972682953,
-0.3899514973163605,
0.5580892562866211,
-0.37332960963249207,
-0.5184298157691956,
0.3419398069381714,
-0.23958183825016022,
-0.08661461621522903,
0.1518147587776184,
0.9654474258422852,
-0.4144352078437805,
-0.6486057043075562,
0.38231050968170166,
0.263321191072464,
0.2519403398036957,
-0.2338719516992569,
-0.304516464471817,
0.3544766902923584,
0.04268118739128113,
-0.05762174353003502,
-0.017826346680521965,
0.5569629073143005,
-0.20974302291870117,
0.7677729725837708,
0.7307042479515076,
0.043479073792696,
0.0371280200779438,
0.1199706420302391,
0.8394786715507507,
-0.6603057384490967,
-0.17304250597953796,
-0.9363625049591064,
0.47485366463661194,
-0.10998441278934479,
-0.01129753515124321,
0.578932523727417,
0.5521085262298584,
1.0788301229476929,
-0.444748193025589,
0.5317533612251282,
0.005535316653549671,
0.13860741257667542,
-0.8709836602210999,
0.4660953879356384,
-0.6401647329330444,
0.42434826493263245,
-0.3362615406513214,
-1.0492509603500366,
-0.4697459936141968,
0.9687026143074036,
-0.17923936247825623,
-0.10529714077711105,
1.0575615167617798,
1.1583364009857178,
-0.39053428173065186,
-0.08214964717626572,
0.719199538230896,
0.2605402171611786,
0.3075608015060425,
0.5202873945236206,
0.9318221807479858,
-0.2081061601638794,
0.4205693006515503,
-0.28157204389572144,
-0.041837967932224274,
-0.3384142220020294,
-0.9213492274284363,
-1.0846036672592163,
-0.38661232590675354,
-0.431941419839859,
-0.4172632396221161,
0.21154512465000153,
0.537135899066925,
0.49732065200805664,
-0.9891860485076904,
-0.08574426174163818,
-0.39565497636795044,
0.20925933122634888,
-0.25706303119659424,
-0.22903208434581757,
0.40659892559051514,
-0.28983086347579956,
-0.4168795347213745,
0.14186407625675201,
0.6490207314491272,
-0.10361844301223755,
-0.4603555202484131,
-0.05234397202730179,
0.09019270539283752,
-0.06191437318921089,
0.706567108631134,
0.25984904170036316,
-1.1324949264526367,
-0.6219061017036438,
0.070123091340065,
0.09628014266490936,
0.11670517176389694,
0.8857517838478088,
-0.9204824566841125,
0.8080236315727234,
0.42656901478767395,
0.5737026929855347,
0.4918329119682312,
-0.05314727500081062,
0.230959951877594,
-0.3677191734313965,
0.6585200428962708,
0.37409430742263794,
0.4111606776714325,
0.21699275076389313,
-0.2510473132133484,
0.6345219016075134,
0.5651858448982239,
-0.40135136246681213,
-1.0049161911010742,
0.5239936113357544,
-1.1085867881774902,
-0.4896734952926636,
0.903192937374115,
0.2341076284646988,
-0.21749165654182434,
-0.10097472369670868,
-0.4240579903125763,
-0.14834538102149963,
-0.08916822820901871,
1.0354214906692505,
0.5526722073554993,
-0.27960464358329773,
-0.340860515832901,
-0.727698564529419,
0.32808029651641846,
0.3199598789215088,
-0.9704005718231201,
0.16633431613445282,
0.7808833122253418,
-0.028765827417373657,
0.2632552981376648,
0.31724485754966736,
0.048176560550928116,
0.37578505277633667,
0.14434882998466492,
0.06319156289100647,
-0.2272300273180008,
-0.4724564254283905,
-0.02005327120423317,
0.15683308243751526,
-0.37570658326148987,
-0.3056924641132355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11621v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11621v3 | Decoding News Narratives: A Critical Analysis of Large Language Models in Framing Detection | 2024-02-18T15:27:48 | 2024-06-15T23:20:15 | Valeria Pastorino, Jasivan A. Sivakumar, Nafise Sadat Moosavi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous studies on framing have relied on manual analysis or fine-tuning
models with limited annotated datasets. However, pre-trained models, with their
diverse training backgrounds, offer a promising alternative. This paper
presents a comprehensive analysis of GPT-4, GPT-3.5 Turbo, and FLAN-T5 models
in detecting framing in news headlines. We evaluated these models in various
scenarios: zero-shot, few-shot with in-domain examples, cross-domain examples,
and settings where models explain their predictions. Our results show that
explainable predictions lead to more reliable outcomes. GPT-4 performed
exceptionally well in few-shot settings but often misinterpreted emotional
language as framing, highlighting a significant challenge. Additionally, the
results suggest that consistent predictions across multiple models could help
identify potential annotation inaccuracies in datasets. Finally, we propose a
new small dataset for real-world evaluation on headlines from a diverse set of
topics. | [
-0.510148823261261,
-0.8722836375236511,
0.8188827633857727,
0.1448337882757187,
-0.3242347836494446,
0.022000329568982124,
-0.058783262968063354,
-0.5215583443641663,
-0.040883030742406845,
0.303423136472702,
-0.43573516607284546,
-0.5889789462089539,
-0.9164734482765198,
0.18298210203647614,
-0.6113927364349365,
1.2408000230789185,
-0.145783931016922,
0.06186472997069359,
0.40999752283096313,
-0.09059285372495651,
-0.5337015986442566,
-0.4413776397705078,
-0.43365678191185,
0.00321499933488667,
0.06509856134653091,
-0.018262146040797234,
0.7998570203781128,
0.7251895070075989,
0.2519278824329376,
0.11866079270839691,
-0.20849111676216125,
-0.20191572606563568,
-0.4324268400669098,
-0.33980056643486023,
-0.013598572462797165,
-0.3249703645706177,
-0.41147342324256897,
0.2769086956977844,
0.7277106046676636,
0.3686167001724243,
0.2192317545413971,
0.20952658355236053,
-0.15134625136852264,
0.49822723865509033,
-0.4317527413368225,
0.2882210612297058,
-0.627801775932312,
0.1446780264377594,
-0.2882258892059326,
-0.1134452298283577,
-0.3660345673561096,
-0.32481256127357483,
0.066615991294384,
-0.5066908597946167,
0.4234498143196106,
0.1297541856765747,
1.0557130575180054,
0.05147925391793251,
-0.7060626149177551,
-0.39923232793807983,
-0.5071765184402466,
0.3708406090736389,
-0.7376928329467773,
0.3454400897026062,
0.4871745705604553,
0.25659671425819397,
-0.03861053287982941,
-0.38719460368156433,
-0.32766789197921753,
-0.07388970255851746,
-0.11573683470487595,
-0.01710255816578865,
-0.49298667907714844,
0.006167315877974033,
0.3386242389678955,
0.35495325922966003,
-0.8256993889808655,
-0.17874744534492493,
-0.3577686548233032,
-0.2556391954421997,
0.3222847878932953,
0.16855652630329132,
0.2901461720466614,
-0.29363882541656494,
-0.2616296410560608,
0.28740060329437256,
-0.4733741581439972,
-0.05488850176334381,
0.5317957401275635,
0.38465845584869385,
-0.3341480493545532,
0.3914973735809326,
-0.3795453906059265,
0.7703044414520264,
0.04006953537464142,
-0.13847234845161438,
0.28894200921058655,
-0.5822951793670654,
-0.16432376205921173,
0.23218099772930145,
0.556581974029541,
0.5566969513893127,
0.5942531824111938,
0.051492322236299515,
-0.23373587429523468,
0.07860254496335983,
0.04341019690036774,
-0.7113319039344788,
-0.11863074451684952,
-0.04799285903573036,
-0.5069891214370728,
-0.4930521547794342,
-0.0675237625837326,
-0.5296898484230042,
-0.13231590390205383,
-0.1774437129497528,
0.3625388741493225,
-0.33650296926498413,
-0.4815737009048462,
0.49925580620765686,
-0.3477741777896881,
0.42823195457458496,
0.134331613779068,
-0.8094536066055298,
-0.08238233625888824,
0.8382989168167114,
1.0139166116714478,
0.15567758679389954,
-0.09547920525074005,
-0.5565360188484192,
-0.031487394124269485,
-0.4488644599914551,
0.9286949634552002,
-0.7257727384567261,
0.09264915436506271,
0.02288827858865261,
0.06542196869850159,
-0.009076029062271118,
-0.1450924277305603,
0.727505624294281,
-0.5554131269454956,
0.3261466324329376,
-0.3450292944908142,
-0.6470583081245422,
-0.28564152121543884,
0.5670676231384277,
-0.8610090017318726,
0.5032013058662415,
0.2991122603416443,
-1.0320487022399902,
0.5795968174934387,
-0.5840812921524048,
-0.5625736117362976,
-0.17706751823425293,
0.03440197557210922,
-0.48316746950149536,
0.4482746422290802,
0.7065841555595398,
0.47989243268966675,
-0.014848252758383751,
0.510339081287384,
-0.1955675482749939,
-0.3833707273006439,
-0.10562405735254288,
-0.7293623685836792,
0.5289093852043152,
0.18428799510002136,
-0.41292455792427063,
0.01620512828230858,
-0.5424984097480774,
-0.3347122371196747,
0.1433069258928299,
-0.13839595019817352,
-0.11393840610980988,
-0.24905656278133392,
0.1786026507616043,
0.07165473699569702,
-0.26951566338539124,
-0.43769246339797974,
0.0237286239862442,
-0.1915275752544403,
0.5692229866981506,
0.4014184772968292,
0.1330125629901886,
0.21775871515274048,
-0.26619237661361694,
0.7787520885467529,
0.18803629279136658,
-0.13886336982250214,
-0.7585790157318115,
-0.4850800335407257,
-0.21279463171958923,
-0.21094238758087158,
0.36601758003234863,
0.4184821844100952,
-0.8682370185852051,
-0.09083633124828339,
-0.14898565411567688,
-0.07767224311828613,
-0.2579804062843323,
-0.35681959986686707,
0.33422720432281494,
0.42237797379493713,
0.2652578353881836,
-0.08473752439022064,
-0.5705329775810242,
-0.8854096531867981,
-0.7534481883049011,
0.1959676593542099,
-0.0069921668618917465,
-0.17401842772960663,
0.600238561630249,
0.18014363944530487,
1.1254019737243652,
-0.4182705581188202,
-0.15950602293014526,
-0.4700397551059723,
0.4988429546356201,
0.31667372584342957,
0.1730486899614334,
0.7890145182609558,
-0.9631550908088684,
-0.3494179844856262,
-0.3013850748538971,
-0.8158119320869446,
-0.05678153038024902,
-0.13947834074497223,
0.3517794609069824,
0.14645002782344818,
0.3372584581375122,
-0.5484410524368286,
0.7088301181793213,
0.5413937568664551,
-0.37866368889808655,
0.7839400172233582,
0.2477022409439087,
0.34562045335769653,
-0.9209855794906616,
-0.24182899296283722,
0.3484932482242584,
-0.6004235744476318,
-0.7125592231750488,
-0.33665478229522705,
0.017185235396027565,
-0.3312765955924988,
-0.3914271593093872,
0.479488730430603,
-0.5833607316017151,
-0.3505806028842926,
-0.4619738757610321,
0.12331879884004593,
0.11038053780794144,
0.21530303359031677,
0.2996855676174164,
0.7119192481040955,
0.33992108702659607,
-0.010996800847351551,
0.1505202054977417,
0.15796545147895813,
-0.7691181302070618,
0.4553614854812622,
-0.538644015789032,
-0.0422968715429306,
-0.44035813212394714,
0.6910164952278137,
-1.0563479661941528,
-0.641826868057251,
0.24213860929012299,
-0.4856165945529938,
0.08884453773498535,
-0.41657960414886475,
-0.5080280900001526,
-0.3304685354232788,
-0.41801291704177856,
0.502049446105957,
0.10006138682365417,
-0.46018996834754944,
0.29689836502075195,
0.37360814213752747,
-0.07749722898006439,
-0.3701740801334381,
-0.6913625001907349,
0.26086971163749695,
-0.30136340856552124,
-0.5158260464668274,
-0.009604976512491703,
0.2400636225938797,
-0.10595498979091644,
0.19061847031116486,
-0.2934134900569916,
-0.32629480957984924,
0.1827283501625061,
-0.06556718796491623,
0.11158928275108337,
-0.6384347081184387,
0.05572628974914551,
-0.1642131507396698,
-0.3535919785499573,
-0.10894321650266647,
-0.23459824919700623,
0.3260812759399414,
-0.5435395240783691,
-0.10277911275625229,
-0.49040791392326355,
0.4213602542877197,
0.6590189337730408,
-0.5090250372886658,
0.5829825401306152,
0.9365904927253723,
-0.5464045405387878,
0.04466965049505234,
-0.6300502419471741,
-0.06569783389568329,
-0.37753060460090637,
0.5101701021194458,
-0.46847644448280334,
-0.9574993252754211,
0.33649134635925293,
0.20402580499649048,
-0.25976747274398804,
0.3553963899612427,
0.6552023887634277,
0.27307477593421936,
1.1355122327804565,
0.7029025554656982,
-0.2290927767753601,
0.5041983723640442,
-0.01258458849042654,
0.44479212164878845,
-0.4750365912914276,
0.33651959896087646,
-0.10383883118629456,
-0.2020236998796463,
-0.22863584756851196,
-0.14568395912647247,
0.3718527555465698,
0.05862744152545929,
-0.17420001327991486,
0.4044284224510193,
-0.4254553020000458,
1.0233408212661743,
0.27754005789756775,
-0.14444111287593842,
0.6562589406967163,
-0.2029642015695572,
0.3965943455696106,
0.11834736913442612,
-0.5683077573776245,
-0.7072000503540039,
1.101523995399475,
0.5653570890426636,
0.5312655568122864,
-0.09997235238552094,
0.2383268177509308,
0.2922230064868927,
0.568035900592804,
-0.664692223072052,
0.10884063690900803,
-0.01816168799996376,
-1.1425821781158447,
0.003588220803067088,
-0.33984842896461487,
-0.6448150873184204,
0.278488427400589,
-0.14189746975898743,
-0.6855546236038208,
0.005460882093757391,
-0.05181308463215828,
-0.6726479530334473,
0.5398096442222595,
-0.7590620517730713,
1.0657234191894531,
-0.16039036214351654,
0.025468148291110992,
-0.047674715518951416,
-0.5530720353126526,
0.7991942763328552,
-0.24636901915073395,
0.43248844146728516,
-0.5883536338806152,
0.19139239192008972,
0.5490622520446777,
0.2575788199901581,
0.7049804329872131,
-0.14256830513477325,
0.04505842551589012,
0.22117838263511658,
0.0020200868602842093,
0.23494191467761993,
0.22080904245376587,
-0.06144054979085922,
0.2737290859222412,
0.16110855340957642,
-0.2713313698768616,
-0.2476603388786316,
0.2271861881017685,
-0.34158456325531006,
-0.5046887397766113,
-0.5233371257781982,
-0.7850444316864014,
-0.29918569326400757,
0.08419403433799744,
0.49821415543556213,
0.7991626262664795,
-0.16137929260730743,
0.32536131143569946,
0.19171808660030365,
0.039244674146175385,
0.6007822155952454,
0.5482958555221558,
-0.20362289249897003,
-0.3146234154701233,
0.4358781576156616,
0.10552729666233063,
-0.045552536845207214,
0.17939606308937073,
0.014585413970053196,
-0.10209979861974716,
-0.8157168030738831,
-0.43806374073028564,
0.1290637105703354,
-0.574285626411438,
-0.2830560803413391,
-0.5288748145103455,
-0.12748019397258759,
-0.23702660202980042,
-0.2239927351474762,
-0.5342280864715576,
-0.1398291438817978,
-0.12454026937484741,
-0.4845345616340637,
0.09187950193881989,
0.9139580726623535,
-0.027687253430485725,
0.5559505224227905,
-0.977378249168396,
0.41367071866989136,
-0.11261921375989914,
0.4770162105560303,
-0.18859222531318665,
-0.3606441020965576,
-0.47524532675743103,
0.06491135060787201,
-0.2208133339881897,
-1.0929349660873413,
0.39722004532814026,
-0.13776788115501404,
0.3928075432777405,
0.34675440192222595,
0.10883022844791412,
0.18284854292869568,
-0.6034740805625916,
0.8480644822120667,
0.03261967748403549,
-1.050560474395752,
0.5661087036132812,
-0.8452045321464539,
0.27248892188072205,
0.5538075566291809,
0.6763661503791809,
-0.24261517822742462,
-0.25307419896125793,
-0.5206829309463501,
-0.5309067964553833,
0.6704366207122803,
0.1535949558019638,
0.16170188784599304,
-0.274277925491333,
0.38000959157943726,
0.13720601797103882,
0.29566049575805664,
-0.9312337040901184,
0.30707573890686035,
-0.22379113733768463,
-0.30401575565338135,
0.02080528996884823,
-0.4278082251548767,
-0.08845528960227966,
-0.14108720421791077,
0.3961988091468811,
-0.22499608993530273,
0.1445600837469101,
0.12405086308717728,
-0.29508987069129944,
0.019696980714797974,
0.2769760191440582,
0.867483913898468,
0.7453039288520813,
-0.3122400641441345,
-0.048242390155792236,
0.050255414098501205,
-0.2979164719581604,
0.13152280449867249,
-0.02729903534054756,
0.11278989166021347,
0.26218998432159424,
0.8532983064651489,
1.1300498247146606,
0.4249683916568756,
-0.33281996846199036,
0.8981121778488159,
-0.1946374922990799,
-0.2132905125617981,
-0.2832541763782501,
-0.2955401837825775,
-0.10690660029649734,
0.5338313579559326,
0.44074833393096924,
0.042063843458890915,
0.1920720934867859,
-0.8047376871109009,
0.43653222918510437,
0.2494017481803894,
-0.3652326464653015,
-0.6541866064071655,
0.7880429029464722,
0.23904335498809814,
-0.14666877686977386,
0.44826287031173706,
-0.3846014440059662,
-0.9578226208686829,
0.5438799262046814,
0.5095142126083374,
1.0169527530670166,
0.0174090676009655,
0.2836062014102936,
0.2563819885253906,
0.5530082583427429,
-0.4740874767303467,
-0.23727022111415863,
0.05206558108329773,
-0.9722142219543457,
-0.4658340513706207,
-0.4511442184448242,
-0.38979780673980713,
0.2105652093887329,
-0.7336210012435913,
0.2153141349554062,
-0.3010324537754059,
-0.28066322207450867,
0.15277770161628723,
-0.07552328705787659,
-0.5139598846435547,
0.13683058321475983,
0.6596717238426208,
0.9558225274085999,
-1.220909833908081,
0.8424506187438965,
0.32069212198257446,
-0.42176899313926697,
-0.7026945948600769,
0.4577302038669586,
0.520164966583252,
-0.6442410349845886,
0.5117034316062927,
0.6306320428848267,
0.12006663531064987,
0.10425283759832382,
-0.40751686692237854,
-0.6506384015083313,
0.9042006731033325,
0.6303732991218567,
-0.36924317479133606,
-0.37722569704055786,
-0.0428909957408905,
0.28589385747909546,
-0.8130072951316833,
0.42156732082366943,
1.0079689025878906,
0.6820273995399475,
-0.0024360695388168097,
-1.1153554916381836,
-0.15947210788726807,
0.0689026415348053,
-0.2525843381881714,
0.12842097878456116,
-0.38956964015960693,
0.9038345217704773,
-0.10286235064268112,
-0.2526516020298004,
-0.1457139104604721,
0.35756728053092957,
0.049314554780721664,
0.6868523955345154,
0.4039243161678314,
0.4080849885940552,
0.43465864658355713,
-0.30780768394470215,
1.3038692474365234,
-0.399989515542984,
0.6070266962051392,
1.0960434675216675,
-0.10108380019664764,
0.6368923783302307,
-0.1375018060207367,
-0.008783207274973392,
0.26331570744514465,
0.637706995010376,
-0.05009482055902481,
0.5574451684951782,
-0.1157192587852478,
-0.08189649134874344,
-0.2816457748413086,
0.06740362197160721,
-0.3487851917743683,
0.6953772902488708,
0.2637809216976166,
-0.2711828649044037,
-0.7200015783309937,
0.40944308042526245,
0.3723783493041992,
-0.11630966514348984,
-0.44562628865242004,
0.5171234011650085,
0.1352112889289856,
-0.4326404631137848,
0.35199350118637085,
0.01982574723660946,
0.6986553072929382,
-0.4687429368495941,
0.1766088753938675,
-0.21513110399246216,
0.07697653770446777,
-0.16288740932941437,
-0.8460807204246521,
0.6077929139137268,
0.13028517365455627,
-0.3123558759689331,
-0.2645341753959656,
0.7909404635429382,
-0.4896461069583893,
-0.34940317273139954,
0.1601831167936325,
0.43366381525993347,
0.006148056127130985,
-0.570551335811615,
-0.49342063069343567,
0.5886174440383911,
0.1016121432185173,
-0.6616116166114807,
0.1537853181362152,
0.37846022844314575,
-0.06175117567181587,
0.18470509350299835,
0.47487086057662964,
-0.19865822792053223,
-0.13692297041416168,
-0.11881627887487411,
0.5883957147598267,
-0.8587767481803894,
-0.6036497950553894,
-0.8867955803871155,
0.48658478260040283,
0.02995716594159603,
-0.291763037443161,
0.5749130845069885,
0.5918492078781128,
0.6434378623962402,
-0.028527850285172462,
0.7572892904281616,
0.3922131657600403,
0.4029833972454071,
-0.6699949502944946,
0.6957967281341553,
-0.19062957167625427,
0.16918759047985077,
-0.0993306040763855,
-0.9526273608207703,
-0.49658554792404175,
0.6097880601882935,
-0.829380452632904,
0.13610991835594177,
0.7785502672195435,
0.4936678111553192,
-0.16321659088134766,
0.6968854069709778,
0.34262481331825256,
0.2824917733669281,
0.42010173201560974,
0.6626850962638855,
0.8407086133956909,
-0.37443453073501587,
0.5148609280586243,
0.18785865604877472,
-0.1653248518705368,
-0.23264360427856445,
-1.151781439781189,
-1.0342450141906738,
-0.5619499683380127,
-0.344307541847229,
-0.09425675123929977,
0.19754822552204132,
0.5663840770721436,
0.9151793122291565,
-0.694728672504425,
0.28337526321411133,
0.10225178301334381,
0.05595690757036209,
0.14825762808322906,
-0.22454006969928741,
0.2564717233181,
-0.3976607620716095,
-0.538905680179596,
0.48937591910362244,
0.36052820086479187,
-0.05307842046022415,
0.06802163273096085,
0.38096165657043457,
-0.12566924095153809,
0.2196246236562729,
0.5581285953521729,
0.17718122899532318,
-0.6119202971458435,
-0.6850771903991699,
-0.5050132870674133,
0.019863737747073174,
0.16703374683856964,
0.9410845041275024,
-0.896431565284729,
0.19386006891727448,
0.41017207503318787,
0.7376046776771545,
0.8490465879440308,
0.3329929709434509,
0.7038573622703552,
-0.7892974019050598,
0.3400328755378723,
0.07976177334785461,
0.4138738811016083,
0.4101812243461609,
-0.28885945677757263,
0.6783705353736877,
0.39813321828842163,
-0.3453909754753113,
-0.9176945090293884,
0.1408175826072693,
-0.686309278011322,
-0.3490476608276367,
0.9795182943344116,
-0.14837493002414703,
-0.18761314451694489,
-0.25698837637901306,
-0.044636320322752,
0.04280133545398712,
-0.19980476796627045,
0.3131686747074127,
1.1754711866378784,
0.030016472563147545,
-0.30861374735832214,
-1.1965733766555786,
0.5461022257804871,
0.08113400638103485,
-0.5933672785758972,
0.06587215512990952,
0.5124937891960144,
0.5199764966964722,
-0.058630432933568954,
0.7431635856628418,
-0.06721212714910507,
0.33519861102104187,
0.10211559385061264,
-0.35344916582107544,
-0.46101662516593933,
-0.3655189275741577,
-0.5761218070983887,
0.42429041862487793,
-0.4270836114883423,
-0.14709006249904633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11608v1 | Metric-Learning Encoding Models Identify Processing Profiles of Linguistic Features in BERT's Representations | 2024-02-18T14:57:53 | 2024-02-18T14:57:53 | Louis Jalouzot, Robin Sobczyk, Bastien Lhopitallier, Jeanne Salle, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Yair Lakretz | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Metric-Learning Encoding Models (MLEMs) as a new approach to
understand how neural systems represent the theoretical features of the objects
they process. As a proof-of-concept, we apply MLEMs to neural representations
extracted from BERT, and track a wide variety of linguistic features (e.g.,
tense, subject person, clause type, clause embedding). We find that: (1)
linguistic features are ordered: they separate representations of sentences to
different degrees in different layers; (2) neural representations are organized
hierarchically: in some layers, we find clusters of representations nested
within larger clusters, following successively important linguistic features;
(3) linguistic features are disentangled in middle layers: distinct, selective
units are activated by distinct linguistic features. Methodologically, MLEMs
are superior (4) to multivariate decoding methods, being more robust to type-I
errors, and (5) to univariate encoding methods, in being able to predict both
local and distributed representations. Together, this demonstrates the utility
of Metric-Learning Encoding Methods for studying how linguistic features are
neurally encoded in language models and the advantage of MLEMs over traditional
methods. MLEMs can be extended to other domains (e.g. vision) and to other
neural systems, such as the human brain. | [
-0.43688270449638367,
-0.48048919439315796,
0.5307039022445679,
0.1463315188884735,
-0.025992073118686676,
0.051774945110082626,
-0.4676559865474701,
-0.26925402879714966,
0.2828010320663452,
0.3991536796092987,
-0.4369208514690399,
-0.5757908225059509,
-0.8053518533706665,
-0.0501636303961277,
-0.35200053453445435,
0.9080191850662231,
0.21337135136127472,
0.5480066537857056,
-0.2687608301639557,
-0.1536085456609726,
-0.2650071382522583,
-1.1347368955612183,
-0.3719674348831177,
-0.3808320462703705,
0.6900339126586914,
-0.011613906361162663,
0.4525192677974701,
0.6664051413536072,
0.6460104584693909,
0.2549836337566376,
0.010827983729541302,
0.14687670767307281,
-0.3461303114891052,
0.009778350591659546,
0.07782424241304398,
-0.8414454460144043,
-0.24840880930423737,
-0.02403121069073677,
0.8776960968971252,
1.201017141342163,
-0.07524996250867844,
0.38858288526535034,
0.2477571666240692,
0.6580370664596558,
-0.5530422329902649,
0.27730584144592285,
-0.7630360722541809,
0.11785382777452469,
-0.09864579141139984,
-0.24540261924266815,
-0.6150408983230591,
-0.11495576798915863,
0.10686517506837845,
-0.2700026333332062,
0.23641853034496307,
-0.11734184622764587,
0.6982216238975525,
0.14082157611846924,
-0.37733832001686096,
-0.10646473616361618,
-0.8032154440879822,
0.9112695455551147,
-0.5295275449752808,
0.5654367208480835,
0.504891037940979,
0.36243072152137756,
-0.15323859453201294,
-0.34725111722946167,
-0.25962033867836,
-0.3337273895740509,
-0.3306621015071869,
0.05248308554291725,
0.01382539700716734,
0.05996903404593468,
0.12410946935415268,
0.06387577205896378,
-0.5645884871482849,
0.40471136569976807,
-0.48179012537002563,
-0.3021411597728729,
0.5843316316604614,
0.11039695888757706,
0.07599543780088425,
-0.13926547765731812,
-0.3681336045265198,
-0.041310474276542664,
-0.4932951033115387,
0.020674295723438263,
0.2762869894504547,
0.3405190706253052,
0.05334402993321419,
0.5261092782020569,
0.05518282204866409,
0.3902536630630493,
-0.28976312279701233,
-0.0106902364641428,
0.3415495455265045,
-0.012202246114611626,
0.011246996000409126,
-0.16488833725452423,
0.69632887840271,
0.13584142923355103,
0.19183310866355896,
-0.2707483470439911,
-0.3153243362903595,
0.12682458758354187,
0.0895993784070015,
-0.32299646735191345,
-0.14157375693321228,
0.1356617659330368,
-0.7019798159599304,
-0.03208938241004944,
0.12938636541366577,
-0.5801035761833191,
-0.10763376951217651,
-0.40888094902038574,
0.2875099182128906,
-0.6469157338142395,
-0.26506108045578003,
0.21139684319496155,
-0.2513711750507355,
0.12989267706871033,
-0.02400720864534378,
-1.1893655061721802,
0.6685923933982849,
0.7710631489753723,
0.789743959903717,
0.0806768536567688,
-0.4867476522922516,
-0.1605546623468399,
-0.08356136828660965,
-0.29957568645477295,
0.44731175899505615,
-0.7418142557144165,
-0.028454642742872238,
0.2034377157688141,
-0.16475322842597961,
-0.027805937454104424,
-0.5162438750267029,
0.07991564273834229,
-0.5241714715957642,
0.03814848139882088,
-0.3412577211856842,
-0.8078703880310059,
-0.3094511926174164,
0.07545927166938782,
-0.6870453953742981,
1.009839653968811,
-0.05457622557878494,
-0.540611207485199,
0.32980746030807495,
-0.7824651002883911,
-0.15291765332221985,
-0.261040061712265,
-0.19071733951568604,
-0.24406546354293823,
0.6216844916343689,
0.3876628279685974,
0.8222823739051819,
0.11300554126501083,
0.04329543933272362,
-0.2849549651145935,
-0.2335706353187561,
0.4747152030467987,
-0.41305476427078247,
0.8703188300132751,
0.18883870542049408,
0.04427645727992058,
-0.3156861662864685,
-0.8092957735061646,
-0.19350239634513855,
0.30980926752090454,
-0.3900233507156372,
-0.3820728361606598,
0.3620147705078125,
-0.1388205587863922,
-0.134291872382164,
0.5071430802345276,
-0.6817189455032349,
-0.08150603622198105,
-0.07907145470380783,
0.4410099387168884,
0.5648176670074463,
-0.07724280655384064,
0.5612300634384155,
-0.00342531967908144,
0.19605086743831635,
0.532979428768158,
0.1753925383090973,
-0.1509992480278015,
-0.4183506369590759,
-0.8034992814064026,
-0.346964031457901,
0.47628554701805115,
0.45165905356407166,
-0.4714893400669098,
0.46438246965408325,
-0.18472592532634735,
-0.34213101863861084,
-0.6737637519836426,
-0.07683885842561722,
0.426215797662735,
0.1589168757200241,
0.32699698209762573,
-0.4012044072151184,
-0.544722855091095,
-1.0090850591659546,
-0.08911625295877457,
-0.25060001015663147,
-0.2769371271133423,
0.19511397182941437,
0.5392087697982788,
-0.018895618617534637,
0.9317064881324768,
-0.3441384732723236,
0.0029132473282516003,
-0.0833001434803009,
0.3569566011428833,
0.10564056783914566,
0.4594595432281494,
0.8776394128799438,
-0.6307995319366455,
-0.22943426668643951,
0.17785605788230896,
-0.8193459510803223,
0.22429588437080383,
-0.040385302156209946,
0.04890350624918938,
-0.06420668959617615,
0.4141407012939453,
-0.3994148373603821,
0.23584270477294922,
0.5249017477035522,
-0.12771785259246826,
0.7649899125099182,
-0.5168643593788147,
-0.047804590314626694,
-0.8023924827575684,
-0.10639414191246033,
0.08848845958709717,
-0.26718956232070923,
-0.7113729119300842,
-0.0004468701663427055,
-0.0032695105765014887,
-0.04144489765167236,
-0.20562122762203217,
0.14215637743473053,
-0.6891336441040039,
-0.44815725088119507,
0.09449689090251923,
0.14350470900535583,
-0.03823334723711014,
0.8946914076805115,
0.12968945503234863,
0.45230069756507874,
0.7201197743415833,
-0.6458668112754822,
0.2142982929944992,
-0.008239254355430603,
-0.4003821015357971,
0.47791606187820435,
-0.3432689309120178,
0.08913185447454453,
-0.5798476934432983,
0.05923076346516609,
-0.8250325918197632,
0.14157676696777344,
-0.2252221405506134,
-0.9280656576156616,
0.30496373772621155,
-0.07727894186973572,
-0.6408986449241638,
-0.2406335175037384,
-0.09828771650791168,
0.18418939411640167,
0.6792131662368774,
-0.34388136863708496,
0.40845292806625366,
0.4892856180667877,
0.11527767032384872,
-0.7126484513282776,
-0.7446947693824768,
-0.02244425378739834,
-0.2125302404165268,
-0.0892895758152008,
0.14320369064807892,
0.2687547504901886,
-0.10055302083492279,
0.22197940945625305,
0.1970834583044052,
-0.3227512240409851,
0.34282034635543823,
-0.09147419780492783,
0.2337270975112915,
-0.6218132972717285,
0.2928660213947296,
-0.0792846754193306,
-0.12477203458547592,
0.1874355673789978,
-0.6056773662567139,
0.5303592681884766,
0.09313985705375671,
-0.2986169159412384,
-0.5078082084655762,
0.6595990657806396,
0.5526551008224487,
-0.41390490531921387,
0.8087767362594604,
0.8830249905586243,
-0.6276470422744751,
-0.14203743636608124,
-0.4505925178527832,
-0.42280322313308716,
-0.3753587007522583,
0.9198814034461975,
-0.46644067764282227,
-0.9205954670906067,
0.6914897561073303,
-0.09878990799188614,
0.11850001662969589,
0.37322038412094116,
0.5529942512512207,
-0.6770481467247009,
1.2388758659362793,
0.9193477034568787,
-0.3203306496143341,
0.5958924889564514,
-0.3548605144023895,
0.05392346531152725,
-0.9866819381713867,
-0.2660693824291229,
-0.6125872135162354,
-0.597106397151947,
-0.6146502494812012,
-0.37844401597976685,
0.22232453525066376,
0.08415719121694565,
-0.2625507712364197,
0.3150073289871216,
-0.4597376585006714,
0.5155655741691589,
0.533857524394989,
0.2311193197965622,
-0.08500957489013672,
0.1358421891927719,
-0.4770483672618866,
-0.2215747833251953,
-0.8746551871299744,
-0.6029139757156372,
1.1693485975265503,
0.7462409138679504,
0.617165744304657,
-0.10610529780387878,
0.6565835475921631,
0.36224302649497986,
0.04972878843545914,
-0.7729169130325317,
0.5540741682052612,
-0.626689076423645,
-0.6439005732536316,
-0.06654869019985199,
-0.3691408634185791,
-0.8617356419563293,
0.33908817172050476,
-0.31611716747283936,
-1.1865779161453247,
0.3862878382205963,
0.06226041540503502,
-0.3351607620716095,
0.5416610240936279,
-0.8642954230308533,
0.5321438908576965,
-0.3598298728466034,
0.25336647033691406,
-0.3051494359970093,
-0.6064668893814087,
0.09507178515195847,
0.21582211554050446,
0.0828118845820427,
-0.16351385414600372,
-0.12325192242860794,
0.8213879466056824,
-0.21646296977996826,
1.163392424583435,
-0.3925805985927582,
0.1804368644952774,
0.02435913309454918,
0.10062527656555176,
0.007534967735409737,
-0.074083611369133,
0.04211365059018135,
0.5848981738090515,
0.14973829686641693,
-0.5770463943481445,
-0.7737030982971191,
0.3448174297809601,
-1.000885248184204,
-0.41930297017097473,
-0.07146003842353821,
-0.552113950252533,
-0.30451086163520813,
-0.019744081422686577,
0.32988595962524414,
0.5190858840942383,
-0.3650015890598297,
0.1855488121509552,
0.5898950695991516,
-0.0017002783715724945,
0.41227951645851135,
0.043892085552215576,
-0.32926663756370544,
-0.3626461625099182,
0.9455822110176086,
0.228891983628273,
0.253523588180542,
0.7221457362174988,
-0.08508756011724472,
-0.18950186669826508,
-0.7817180156707764,
-0.0845421850681305,
0.443831205368042,
-0.7601932883262634,
0.12669126689434052,
-0.5030678510665894,
-0.44183555245399475,
-0.014543336816132069,
0.13325734436511993,
-0.47744107246398926,
-0.4808293879032135,
-0.44432303309440613,
-0.011347276158630848,
0.16781176626682281,
0.9292439222335815,
-0.18038809299468994,
0.5201255679130554,
-0.8990280032157898,
-0.021512437611818314,
0.12662355601787567,
0.21167339384555817,
0.1752457320690155,
-0.3963853716850281,
-0.6964182257652283,
0.19037607312202454,
-0.03770671412348747,
-0.7369695901870728,
0.35644590854644775,
0.3188597559928894,
0.7663838267326355,
0.42075732350349426,
-0.40326741337776184,
0.504267156124115,
-0.8881456255912781,
0.9686607718467712,
0.2495994120836258,
-0.7850959300994873,
0.41141146421432495,
-0.031412575393915176,
0.10683975368738174,
0.15856584906578064,
0.6425585150718689,
-0.6524905562400818,
-0.49677175283432007,
-0.46226051449775696,
-0.3910328149795532,
0.5344810485839844,
0.2106258124113083,
0.4227110743522644,
-0.12335684895515442,
0.48983240127563477,
0.467752605676651,
0.045174967497587204,
-0.5339860320091248,
-0.36066240072250366,
-0.11846797913312912,
-0.36036327481269836,
-0.23435169458389282,
-0.5196222066879272,
-0.13603118062019348,
-0.12268567085266113,
0.19659081101417542,
-0.10825271904468536,
0.8996725678443909,
0.16865196824073792,
-0.2545015513896942,
0.38531678915023804,
0.04464155435562134,
0.5722871422767639,
0.55833500623703,
-0.3110904097557068,
0.36719444394111633,
0.10517704486846924,
-0.4178459346294403,
0.02273310162127018,
-0.13452309370040894,
0.1585715115070343,
0.49898651242256165,
0.4982392191886902,
1.05299711227417,
0.010210697539150715,
-0.18872283399105072,
0.25454992055892944,
-0.14131125807762146,
-0.22425003349781036,
-0.2019687443971634,
-0.1316339522600174,
0.04961618781089783,
0.38594233989715576,
0.3678402900695801,
0.13752244412899017,
0.06516111642122269,
-0.4620610773563385,
0.21145707368850708,
0.43705418705940247,
-0.40986794233322144,
-0.7972604036331177,
0.36941853165626526,
0.05384640395641327,
-0.24012425541877747,
0.5485864877700806,
0.03453318774700165,
-0.624159038066864,
0.6611824035644531,
0.5662077069282532,
0.8634228110313416,
-0.10438834130764008,
0.2539966106414795,
0.5220862030982971,
0.3331751227378845,
0.12529055774211884,
0.21905477344989777,
-0.19306743144989014,
-1.027030348777771,
-0.28189781308174133,
-0.666267991065979,
-0.16326914727687836,
-0.017425334081053734,
-0.93958580493927,
-0.0004597267252393067,
-0.6075926423072815,
-0.45237621665000916,
0.2409873753786087,
-0.29860201478004456,
-0.8428109288215637,
0.06384438276290894,
0.7145228981971741,
0.8540802597999573,
-0.9074883460998535,
0.7832549214363098,
0.612474799156189,
-0.2501210868358612,
-0.41741839051246643,
-0.1965627670288086,
-0.018423939123749733,
-0.9308339357376099,
0.7759491801261902,
0.016567014157772064,
0.05382185056805611,
-0.07270586490631104,
-0.513923168182373,
-1.0154753923416138,
0.7743085622787476,
0.6796026825904846,
-0.5388619303703308,
-0.07700364291667938,
0.34462839365005493,
0.49781590700149536,
-0.8123929500579834,
0.22965440154075623,
0.7268217206001282,
0.07829047739505768,
-0.3538689613342285,
-0.7972030639648438,
-0.32632550597190857,
-0.049301207065582275,
0.39307889342308044,
0.1633038967847824,
-0.4137980043888092,
0.7039923071861267,
-0.1112835556268692,
-0.136141836643219,
0.11458621919155121,
0.5737190246582031,
-0.04956059902906418,
-0.266284704208374,
0.24738091230392456,
0.3939496874809265,
0.8520151376724243,
-0.2855150103569031,
0.9480263590812683,
-0.1784074604511261,
0.5866991877555847,
0.9465753436088562,
0.1323431432247162,
1.09860360622406,
0.44351598620414734,
-0.33859193325042725,
0.7254750728607178,
0.7880741357803345,
-0.0281040221452713,
0.640607476234436,
0.04355679824948311,
0.031612593680620193,
-0.20919765532016754,
0.022113125771284103,
-0.20484896004199982,
0.6849775314331055,
0.5993993282318115,
-0.5223369002342224,
-0.18597081303596497,
0.167816162109375,
-0.1277601569890976,
-0.008987657725811005,
-0.32259225845336914,
0.889058530330658,
0.10770604014396667,
-0.24654264748096466,
0.7572251558303833,
-0.21686764061450958,
0.5869700908660889,
-0.6993069648742676,
-0.0019184380071237683,
-0.15982049703598022,
0.14095166325569153,
-0.12236665189266205,
-0.7356818914413452,
0.19894076883792877,
0.02904524654150009,
-0.41314631700515747,
-0.06413695216178894,
0.3412063717842102,
-0.43482524156570435,
-0.5347499847412109,
0.49210020899772644,
0.4478447735309601,
0.47173604369163513,
0.26345932483673096,
-0.7543455958366394,
-0.1482999622821808,
-0.15382535755634308,
-0.13240671157836914,
0.2374262660741806,
0.6268208622932434,
0.04360028728842735,
0.40153536200523376,
0.5211268663406372,
0.3664360046386719,
0.46422263979911804,
0.31353431940078735,
0.5077178478240967,
-0.7843426465988159,
-0.46536028385162354,
-0.9518508911132812,
0.7341039180755615,
-0.10225731879472733,
-0.08587311208248138,
0.3361718952655792,
0.2591775357723236,
1.1323612928390503,
-0.22276261448860168,
0.6683574914932251,
0.16213874518871307,
0.2551923394203186,
-0.6790454983711243,
0.7081491351127625,
-0.548474907875061,
0.03475498408079147,
0.2718811631202698,
-1.0920095443725586,
-0.5753433108329773,
0.44338706135749817,
-0.2548530101776123,
0.09256908297538757,
0.9061504602432251,
0.5755751729011536,
-0.060909755527973175,
-0.2090013176202774,
0.6033379435539246,
0.2730374336242676,
0.07050969451665878,
0.5100858211517334,
0.8995757699012756,
-0.25180181860923767,
0.19031399488449097,
-0.33875223994255066,
-0.3483958840370178,
-0.16164752840995789,
-0.5448567271232605,
-0.8890143632888794,
-0.8584086298942566,
-0.08456072956323624,
0.2143062949180603,
-0.09461922198534012,
0.8501939177513123,
1.015974998474121,
-0.8596894145011902,
-0.5062327980995178,
0.2741924226284027,
-0.04561612755060196,
-0.623013973236084,
-0.10569263994693756,
0.3222203850746155,
-0.7946149110794067,
-0.6915951371192932,
0.10765399783849716,
0.4745650589466095,
-0.1418394297361374,
-0.6744122505187988,
0.022854061797261238,
-0.20585016906261444,
0.09626618772745132,
0.6662187576293945,
-0.026038752868771553,
-0.7978171706199646,
-0.4090627431869507,
0.08051618933677673,
-0.1118600070476532,
0.4836830198764801,
0.8859347105026245,
-0.5783014893531799,
0.4312824606895447,
0.3881022334098816,
0.7502787709236145,
0.29142311215400696,
-0.508169412612915,
0.5798117518424988,
-1.0380921363830566,
0.31814271211624146,
0.34718814492225647,
0.8084668517112732,
0.3551566004753113,
-0.42706188559532166,
0.16949054598808289,
0.13427981734275818,
-0.3607231080532074,
-0.6770671010017395,
0.3194972574710846,
-0.808107852935791,
-0.18977439403533936,
0.7548344731330872,
-0.3921082615852356,
-0.6550297141075134,
0.1279028356075287,
0.015343655832111835,
0.09745008498430252,
-0.14593593776226044,
0.7455520629882812,
0.8996775150299072,
-0.12528643012046814,
-0.2703094184398651,
-0.5107859969139099,
0.16830424964427948,
0.4440520107746124,
-0.39170974493026733,
0.1450210064649582,
0.3223189115524292,
0.26886701583862305,
0.4024523198604584,
0.21462398767471313,
-0.407027930021286,
0.26280027627944946,
0.13708265125751495,
0.14862778782844543,
0.20950083434581757,
-0.5090364813804626,
-0.521462619304657,
0.11940214782953262,
0.18734368681907654,
-0.7352984547615051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11597v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11597v2 | Multi-Task Inference: Can Large Language Models Follow Multiple Instructions at Once? | 2024-02-18T14:25:19 | 2024-06-06T12:55:17 | Guijin Son, Sangwon Baek, Sangdae Nam, Ilgyun Jeong, Seungone Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are typically prompted to follow a single
instruction per inference call. In this work, we analyze whether LLMs also hold
the capability to handle multiple instructions simultaneously, denoted as
Multi-Task Inference. For this purpose, we introduce the MTI Bench(Multi-Task
Inference Benchmark), a comprehensive evaluation benchmark encompassing 5,000
instances across 25 tasks. Each task in the MTI Bench involves 2 to 3
sub-tasks. As expected, we first demonstrate that Multi-Task Inference reduces
the total inference time by 1.46 times in average since it does not require
multiple inference calls. Interestingly, contrary to the expectation that LLMs
would perform better when tasks are divided, we find that state-of-the-art
LLMs, such as Llama-2-Chat-70B and GPT-4, show up to 7.3% and 12.4% improved
performance with Multi-Task Inference compared to Single-Task Inference on the
MTI Bench. We release the MTI Bench dataset and our code at this link
https://github.com/guijinSON/MTI-Bench. | [
-0.21936285495758057,
-0.8599183559417725,
0.813197672367096,
0.5257811546325684,
-0.08306775987148285,
-0.08746606111526489,
-0.31752121448516846,
-0.3355511426925659,
-0.262418657541275,
0.6366954445838928,
-0.8430293202400208,
-0.38283273577690125,
-0.7145218253135681,
0.04417373612523079,
-0.3523392081260681,
0.5294313430786133,
-0.00007162093970691785,
0.27600112557411194,
-0.2638632655143738,
-0.24532830715179443,
-0.6241841912269592,
-0.2979905605316162,
-0.6932083368301392,
-0.31643497943878174,
0.6307980418205261,
0.3759109079837799,
0.27807536721229553,
0.7601678371429443,
0.33953988552093506,
0.3581787049770355,
0.20683959126472473,
0.3122556507587433,
-0.212027445435524,
0.07959043234586716,
0.25006812810897827,
-0.7759515047073364,
-0.4010912775993347,
0.08842330425977707,
0.6814165711402893,
0.6730334758758545,
-0.10577327758073807,
0.32937243580818176,
0.05954812094569206,
0.6451298594474792,
-0.8154998421669006,
0.09546327590942383,
-0.3619877099990845,
-0.17309682071208954,
-0.41672247648239136,
0.0021007293835282326,
-0.7776941061019897,
-0.027709484100341797,
-0.028582526370882988,
-0.4047646224498749,
-0.08285696804523468,
0.1352638453245163,
0.31700649857521057,
0.35713696479797363,
-0.6937714219093323,
0.024240145459771156,
-0.5350279808044434,
1.2404916286468506,
-0.8617097735404968,
0.39644962549209595,
0.2351032942533493,
0.34083831310272217,
-0.1402295082807541,
-0.6523622870445251,
-0.5509519577026367,
-0.19005005061626434,
-0.004542605020105839,
0.052429139614105225,
-0.09893651306629181,
-0.0014300234615802765,
0.5551080107688904,
-0.11095546931028366,
-0.4474181830883026,
0.1977585256099701,
-0.05278313159942627,
0.24014081060886383,
0.3244453966617584,
0.2592296302318573,
0.04435642808675766,
-0.04598970711231232,
-0.31810012459754944,
-0.09542670100927353,
-0.7649401426315308,
-0.20192326605319977,
0.31341055035591125,
0.18329623341560364,
-0.13792769610881805,
0.5211936235427856,
-0.17703112959861755,
0.6654926538467407,
-0.30460479855537415,
-0.4521121382713318,
0.40281441807746887,
-0.4108913540840149,
-0.34073328971862793,
-0.25341278314590454,
1.054425597190857,
0.3894796371459961,
0.139193594455719,
-0.16571791470050812,
-0.03141128644347191,
0.008019202388823032,
0.30686914920806885,
-0.7533019781112671,
0.13054335117340088,
0.46416786313056946,
-0.6037452816963196,
0.1637340933084488,
-0.1476738601922989,
-0.6929465532302856,
-0.35052651166915894,
-0.4247085452079773,
0.21408596634864807,
-0.4661671221256256,
-0.15718123316764832,
-0.025354456156492233,
-0.17924748361110687,
0.14896996319293976,
0.3117982745170593,
-0.6045658588409424,
0.4728468954563141,
0.8490288257598877,
0.802241861820221,
-0.2759649455547333,
-0.6721654534339905,
-0.7621868252754211,
0.3045208156108856,
-0.222997784614563,
0.915329098701477,
-0.7339409589767456,
-0.2785743176937103,
-0.2584163248538971,
0.008100365288555622,
-0.5461152791976929,
-0.4559434950351715,
0.4455898404121399,
-0.2917559742927551,
-0.026657860726118088,
-0.43388786911964417,
-0.4583646059036255,
-0.22531239688396454,
0.17353853583335876,
-0.8105760216712952,
1.0853832960128784,
-0.3270818591117859,
-0.6833109259605408,
0.11171643435955048,
-0.7085238099098206,
-0.6177883148193359,
-0.4434153735637665,
0.009409424848854542,
-0.1724441647529602,
0.2176857739686966,
0.32057350873947144,
0.3662499785423279,
-0.6964417695999146,
0.012307374738156796,
-0.769650936126709,
-0.39066872000694275,
0.40791866183280945,
-0.6496865749359131,
0.6138643026351929,
0.1239132359623909,
-0.4229925274848938,
0.328143835067749,
-0.6331151723861694,
0.15545812249183655,
-0.07900508493185043,
-0.36329734325408936,
-0.1701456755399704,
0.4141433835029602,
-0.07184981554746628,
0.1678851842880249,
-0.04031664505600929,
-0.6216210722923279,
0.22644709050655365,
0.19681625068187714,
0.4659375250339508,
0.7948001623153687,
-0.23511140048503876,
0.09998471289873123,
-0.3907715380191803,
0.30061179399490356,
-0.05325927212834358,
0.08967720717191696,
-0.15861165523529053,
-0.46303921937942505,
-0.7382427453994751,
-0.5616881251335144,
0.17900997400283813,
0.8043910264968872,
-0.5891838669776917,
-0.08713240176439285,
-0.25889989733695984,
-0.28755342960357666,
-0.565177857875824,
0.10521729290485382,
0.6860378980636597,
-0.0005927053280174732,
0.3209827244281769,
-0.007458276581019163,
-0.4494266211986542,
-0.99493807554245,
-0.3745741844177246,
0.11460767686367035,
-0.16619855165481567,
0.29910656809806824,
0.550530731678009,
0.03914661705493927,
0.35351669788360596,
-0.24728769063949585,
0.03289250656962395,
-0.3014759421348572,
0.4450379014015198,
0.295224666595459,
0.4592300355434418,
0.5400529503822327,
-0.5063145160675049,
-0.4966658055782318,
-0.23809629678726196,
-0.6898083686828613,
-0.2803259789943695,
-0.20452983677387238,
-0.3008473217487335,
0.13805334270000458,
0.3496204614639282,
-0.7495397329330444,
0.27690887451171875,
0.7439987063407898,
0.1777758151292801,
0.5986684560775757,
-0.3555060923099518,
0.5917007923126221,
-1.136014461517334,
-0.07596248388290405,
0.11724762618541718,
-0.12823694944381714,
-0.7676518559455872,
0.10438131541013718,
0.1992294043302536,
0.45729243755340576,
-0.3770584166049957,
0.3811258375644684,
-0.7776643633842468,
-0.20355921983718872,
-0.48407506942749023,
0.03947139158844948,
-0.14164267480373383,
0.5652793645858765,
-0.1732122153043747,
0.8896626830101013,
0.8141894340515137,
-0.5378820896148682,
0.18910175561904907,
-0.057869911193847656,
-0.4457450211048126,
0.32837074995040894,
-0.6607216000556946,
0.40262970328330994,
-0.019899988546967506,
0.31844577193260193,
-1.2878886461257935,
-0.019351376220583916,
0.12880074977874756,
-0.012741143815219402,
0.3017489016056061,
-0.1248590499162674,
-0.9423037767410278,
-0.4726749658584595,
-0.3486764430999756,
0.2515975534915924,
0.16404414176940918,
-0.48198920488357544,
0.8596606850624084,
0.3388446271419525,
-0.07591109722852707,
-0.9084233045578003,
-0.9600666165351868,
-0.025059962645173073,
-0.1581750065088272,
-0.37476789951324463,
0.149709090590477,
-0.19044266641139984,
-0.3191004693508148,
-0.0404529795050621,
-0.2574642300605774,
-0.19013796746730804,
0.12984465062618256,
0.6489110589027405,
0.21744167804718018,
-0.24556681513786316,
0.05181685462594032,
0.04386176913976669,
0.04531421139836311,
0.06832806766033173,
-0.20483918488025665,
0.550880491733551,
0.05346289649605751,
-0.8094683289527893,
-0.8194873929023743,
0.5983306169509888,
0.7831812500953674,
-0.3536126911640167,
0.8845478892326355,
0.379054993391037,
-0.22973504662513733,
0.07677486538887024,
-1.0528432130813599,
0.04485466331243515,
-0.35538560152053833,
0.15887407958507538,
-0.9888043403625488,
-0.644068717956543,
0.4976988434791565,
-0.18137642741203308,
0.40919744968414307,
0.341475248336792,
0.6119861006736755,
0.037308793514966965,
1.1832619905471802,
0.31904879212379456,
-0.3264251947402954,
0.4389992952346802,
-0.10292848199605942,
-0.0482996329665184,
-0.9551761746406555,
0.09707894176244736,
-0.8161476254463196,
-0.36531925201416016,
-0.4631158113479614,
-0.6702587008476257,
0.16989246010780334,
0.0016817578580230474,
-0.044031981378793716,
0.3086186647415161,
-0.07861088216304779,
0.5425959825515747,
0.8514477014541626,
0.3141767382621765,
0.26337313652038574,
-0.12423402070999146,
-0.13334296643733978,
0.2562015950679779,
-0.6019749045372009,
-0.5461156368255615,
1.353941559791565,
0.12971043586730957,
0.6339626908302307,
0.20093850791454315,
0.5046654343605042,
0.03902610018849373,
0.724742591381073,
-0.3868173360824585,
0.6129141449928284,
-0.4193442761898041,
-0.7261695861816406,
-0.23006460070610046,
-0.6179242730140686,
-0.7945271730422974,
0.6643064618110657,
-0.13198763132095337,
-0.9838919043540955,
-0.25134894251823425,
-0.09005258977413177,
-0.18020814657211304,
0.38749369978904724,
-1.0990564823150635,
1.0432385206222534,
-0.29884999990463257,
-0.4276215136051178,
-0.7620981931686401,
-0.5401076674461365,
0.6574811339378357,
-0.2003055363893509,
0.42909520864486694,
-0.42601510882377625,
-0.004357613157480955,
0.6049210429191589,
-0.21771222352981567,
0.833091676235199,
-0.1904049515724182,
0.28535589575767517,
0.303641140460968,
-0.2976313531398773,
0.38478243350982666,
-0.21752306818962097,
-0.36456239223480225,
0.07244884967803955,
0.23526132106781006,
-0.46858125925064087,
-0.49167102575302124,
0.8121429681777954,
-0.5279243588447571,
-0.6119421720504761,
-0.12737511098384857,
-0.7877576947212219,
-0.2943335771560669,
0.2190309762954712,
-0.20822790265083313,
0.6336448788642883,
-0.08619586378335953,
0.05564684420824051,
0.3420620858669281,
-0.1292678415775299,
0.6309117078781128,
0.5196355581283569,
0.142739400267601,
-0.22707219421863556,
0.5190551280975342,
0.017198612913489342,
0.3930715322494507,
0.610321044921875,
0.11117222905158997,
-0.4066043496131897,
-0.7178858518600464,
-0.5898967385292053,
0.46881577372550964,
-0.5776316523551941,
0.1842503845691681,
-0.7692626118659973,
0.38689693808555603,
-0.42467260360717773,
0.5194411277770996,
-0.3262186348438263,
-0.170172318816185,
0.09183092415332794,
0.23418770730495453,
0.07991314679384232,
0.8309717178344727,
0.23748396337032318,
0.4849313497543335,
-1.1092661619186401,
0.4896518886089325,
0.24214765429496765,
0.3424261510372162,
0.055950894951820374,
-0.37731701135635376,
0.009357564151287079,
0.09293054789304733,
-0.0990157201886177,
-0.9030565023422241,
0.010980726219713688,
0.15871794521808624,
0.9677602648735046,
0.29726579785346985,
0.020809482783079147,
1.00699782371521,
-0.9651333093643188,
0.4680274724960327,
0.23871365189552307,
-0.8175550699234009,
0.08537917584180832,
-0.02990829013288021,
0.7463923096656799,
0.4235256314277649,
0.3325826823711395,
-0.47627413272857666,
-0.6245442032814026,
-0.13981184363365173,
-0.4358275234699249,
0.8762942552566528,
-0.0725613608956337,
0.018717098981142044,
-0.14119118452072144,
0.11831338703632355,
0.1900392472743988,
0.30057257413864136,
-0.4584790766239166,
-0.4926517903804779,
0.262990266084671,
-0.09125970304012299,
-0.07593302428722382,
-0.5295575857162476,
-0.3302536904811859,
0.10457038134336472,
0.5909860134124756,
-0.19128866493701935,
0.4755017161369324,
-0.27851033210754395,
-0.23183530569076538,
0.07290034741163254,
0.5307121872901917,
0.8044158220291138,
0.9073911905288696,
-0.015118739567697048,
0.2912522256374359,
0.4090239703655243,
-0.1065802350640297,
-0.10551510751247406,
0.3498026430606842,
0.4258067309856415,
-0.09005093574523926,
0.5826218128204346,
1.042143702507019,
0.3379038870334625,
-0.6984623074531555,
0.32756173610687256,
-0.24109451472759247,
-0.2907356321811676,
0.013762861490249634,
-0.019686751067638397,
0.38688868284225464,
0.5854531526565552,
0.37836986780166626,
0.0003499484446365386,
0.02230316586792469,
-0.5587432980537415,
0.11624709516763687,
0.5124374032020569,
0.16724829375743866,
-0.08177884668111801,
0.7287280559539795,
-0.006592406891286373,
-0.07856643199920654,
0.52092045545578,
-0.04157692939043045,
-0.3323318660259247,
0.5135027766227722,
0.3462800681591034,
0.6762457489967346,
-0.271246999502182,
-0.01712031662464142,
0.23810651898384094,
0.3308783769607544,
-0.44218194484710693,
0.2624216675758362,
-0.03636956214904785,
-0.5287729501724243,
-1.0126183032989502,
-0.3723098933696747,
-0.5151851773262024,
0.10178613662719727,
-0.5713536739349365,
-0.25143441557884216,
-0.09594201296567917,
-0.23267684876918793,
0.40411272644996643,
-0.2081710547208786,
-0.4991721212863922,
-0.07194700092077255,
0.2135883867740631,
0.8365907073020935,
-0.6479475498199463,
1.127462387084961,
0.6209166646003723,
0.10220634937286377,
-0.5683016777038574,
-0.14254900813102722,
0.3812248408794403,
-0.6242857575416565,
0.5451561212539673,
0.5259032845497131,
-0.2918723523616791,
-0.19019362330436707,
-0.32651394605636597,
-0.6748946905136108,
0.8684250116348267,
0.4189518094062805,
-0.6421091556549072,
0.16629010438919067,
0.16703945398330688,
0.2965938448905945,
-0.4055687189102173,
0.6419238448143005,
0.7542522549629211,
0.5883351564407349,
-0.0834006518125534,
-1.0916857719421387,
0.08812963962554932,
-0.18557386100292206,
-0.038195088505744934,
0.3363009989261627,
-0.5829963088035583,
0.900262176990509,
-0.2502356469631195,
-0.22937282919883728,
0.26871129870414734,
0.5271626710891724,
0.4117429256439209,
0.24067652225494385,
0.8443742394447327,
0.6550617218017578,
0.6261707544326782,
-0.1554139405488968,
1.3672672510147095,
-0.47909867763519287,
0.09114215523004532,
1.3526248931884766,
-0.48069000244140625,
1.0457005500793457,
0.5224170684814453,
-0.30723586678504944,
0.36196476221084595,
0.5421003103256226,
0.09620633721351624,
0.26574352383613586,
0.12287016957998276,
-0.36927682161331177,
-0.4164797067642212,
-0.013913145288825035,
-0.10043203830718994,
0.23553812503814697,
0.1945439577102661,
-0.07096081972122192,
-0.14923013746738434,
0.16105060279369354,
-0.06450247764587402,
-0.3460608124732971,
0.006401605438441038,
0.5714884996414185,
-0.033280644565820694,
-0.9820169806480408,
0.40755754709243774,
0.003066458972170949,
0.40845102071762085,
-0.6727914214134216,
-0.07357379049062729,
-0.0075391256250441074,
0.3365528881549835,
0.05885319411754608,
-0.7233439683914185,
-0.01034585852175951,
0.020206084474921227,
-0.23375608026981354,
-0.4066145718097687,
0.468042254447937,
-0.4679260551929474,
-0.3384939730167389,
0.4449109137058258,
0.7456528544425964,
0.33443164825439453,
-0.3564346432685852,
-0.723968505859375,
0.2599988579750061,
-0.037287335842847824,
-0.5969892740249634,
0.4040452241897583,
0.44691571593284607,
-0.07874640077352524,
0.9619436264038086,
0.6712688207626343,
-0.17743849754333496,
0.48601454496383667,
0.49909576773643494,
0.6822326183319092,
-0.4229016602039337,
0.04232149198651314,
-0.918712854385376,
0.3855661153793335,
-0.12677277624607086,
-0.13683156669139862,
0.7717048525810242,
0.5656830072402954,
0.5744117498397827,
-0.21056333184242249,
0.7296544909477234,
-0.0694279745221138,
0.6704024076461792,
-0.695741593837738,
0.24150115251541138,
-0.6761618256568909,
0.1990894079208374,
-0.022230377420783043,
-0.8119658827781677,
-0.20808076858520508,
0.18751345574855804,
-0.40028175711631775,
0.07162711769342422,
1.1954219341278076,
0.7736581563949585,
0.01256132684648037,
0.05779392644762993,
0.1236644834280014,
0.017415672540664673,
0.08077321946620941,
0.6798105239868164,
0.7270862460136414,
-0.29153308272361755,
0.6243104338645935,
-0.3120907247066498,
-0.1607029139995575,
0.07282704859972,
-0.7132664322853088,
-0.9941583275794983,
-0.1802840679883957,
-0.2677393853664398,
-0.0831257775425911,
0.07177309691905975,
0.7194348573684692,
0.9309588074684143,
-0.93181312084198,
-0.6320483684539795,
0.12915000319480896,
0.09200190752744675,
-0.8035018444061279,
-0.10604662448167801,
0.23082101345062256,
-0.3936555087566376,
-1.1643294095993042,
0.7670298218727112,
0.23586253821849823,
-0.38070008158683777,
0.14651493728160858,
0.04735122248530388,
-0.6246451735496521,
-0.0348331481218338,
0.618094801902771,
-0.10794216394424438,
-0.9522526264190674,
-0.32097360491752625,
0.0070400545373559,
-0.34734582901000977,
0.08403930813074112,
1.036674976348877,
-0.21482034027576447,
0.33522647619247437,
0.42051148414611816,
0.8115931153297424,
0.8518810272216797,
-0.03943665325641632,
0.5236421227455139,
-0.5987067222595215,
0.05177483707666397,
-0.44576722383499146,
0.5083237886428833,
0.010683447122573853,
0.19625695049762726,
0.515971839427948,
0.1692255139350891,
-0.4744786322116852,
-0.659487247467041,
0.10418561846017838,
-1.0543079376220703,
-0.5317133665084839,
1.0810084342956543,
-0.24723170697689056,
-0.3097034692764282,
0.10190833359956741,
-0.06965560466051102,
0.33817726373672485,
-0.3486912250518799,
0.2953886389732361,
0.9059312343597412,
-0.31908175349235535,
-0.7599862217903137,
-1.2863694429397583,
-0.1705777496099472,
0.5913004875183105,
-1.0991865396499634,
0.19841374456882477,
0.5320252180099487,
0.337823748588562,
0.0967189222574234,
0.5093638896942139,
0.2508825361728668,
0.10591393709182739,
0.1833832859992981,
0.09678307920694351,
-0.10293285548686981,
-0.3297140896320343,
0.04718298837542534,
0.3151363134384155,
-0.08097048103809357,
-0.6301522254943848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11592v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11592v3 | Revisiting Zeroth-Order Optimization for Memory-Efficient LLM Fine-Tuning: A Benchmark | 2024-02-18T14:08:48 | 2024-05-28T03:27:06 | Yihua Zhang, Pingzhi Li, Junyuan Hong, Jiaxiang Li, Yimeng Zhang, Wenqing Zheng, Pin-Yu Chen, Jason D. Lee, Wotao Yin, Mingyi Hong, Zhangyang Wang, Sijia Liu, Tianlong Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In the evolving landscape of natural language processing (NLP), fine-tuning
pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) with first-order (FO) optimizers like
SGD and Adam has become standard. Yet, as LLMs grow {in size}, the substantial
memory overhead from back-propagation (BP) for FO gradient computation presents
a significant challenge. Addressing this issue is crucial, especially for
applications like on-device training where memory efficiency is paramount. This
paper proposes a shift towards BP-free, zeroth-order (ZO) optimization as a
solution for reducing memory costs during LLM fine-tuning, building on the
initial concept introduced by MeZO. Unlike traditional ZO-SGD methods, our work
expands the exploration to a wider array of ZO optimization techniques, through
a comprehensive, first-of-its-kind benchmarking study across five LLM families
(Roberta, OPT, LLaMA, Vicuna, Mistral), three task complexities, and five
fine-tuning schemes. Our study unveils previously overlooked optimization
principles, highlighting the importance of task alignment, the role of the
forward gradient method, and the balance between algorithm complexity and
fine-tuning performance. We further introduce novel enhancements to ZO
optimization, including block-wise descent, hybrid training, and gradient
sparsity. Our study offers a promising direction for achieving further
memory-efficient LLM fine-tuning. Codes to reproduce all our experiments are at
https://github.com/ZO-Bench/ZO-LLM . | [
-0.44152089953422546,
-0.5404372215270996,
0.38927993178367615,
0.09520505368709564,
-0.4697168171405792,
-0.08275977522134781,
-0.3631385564804077,
-0.4941079914569855,
-0.1333804428577423,
0.48436644673347473,
-0.7451045513153076,
-0.6473867893218994,
-0.49953046441078186,
-0.17546875774860382,
-0.004596886690706015,
0.8697721362113953,
0.03133668377995491,
-0.03622346743941307,
0.003469194285571575,
-0.38895508646965027,
-0.2986963391304016,
-0.4419708549976349,
-0.7417530417442322,
-0.3529881238937378,
0.7748469710350037,
0.47126859426498413,
0.47930604219436646,
0.9270949959754944,
0.2631646394729614,
0.18665370345115662,
-0.19559112191200256,
0.3204445242881775,
-0.707662045955658,
0.10845687240362167,
-0.03414019197225571,
-0.34030455350875854,
-0.6156392097473145,
-0.18604764342308044,
0.46640685200691223,
0.7909529805183411,
-0.13592609763145447,
0.21461330354213715,
-0.10154709964990616,
0.9291170239448547,
-1.0501164197921753,
-0.1289580911397934,
-0.7609111666679382,
0.21725386381149292,
-0.16740763187408447,
-0.3020870089530945,
-0.2761306166648865,
-0.303711473941803,
0.0040092249400913715,
-0.5345730781555176,
0.45073145627975464,
0.027051473036408424,
0.6366931796073914,
0.4871106445789337,
0.27305659651756287,
0.09728860855102539,
-0.892028272151947,
1.0142098665237427,
-0.7468866109848022,
0.676967442035675,
-0.06477770954370499,
-0.01354721374809742,
-0.20259913802146912,
-0.45849111676216125,
-0.48405760526657104,
-0.004512053914368153,
0.5728116035461426,
0.1269959658384323,
-0.16475723683834076,
0.37213775515556335,
0.10040391236543655,
0.590567946434021,
-0.5105538964271545,
0.39224323630332947,
-0.07939746975898743,
0.09001966565847397,
0.4895309805870056,
0.09826995432376862,
-0.03601089492440224,
0.46032392978668213,
-0.3829338252544403,
-0.05670042708516121,
-0.715549886226654,
-0.033677056431770325,
0.12892787158489227,
0.42935898900032043,
0.2822047472000122,
0.3206189274787903,
-0.5751764178276062,
0.7802699208259583,
0.06450874358415604,
0.006633476819843054,
0.32501479983329773,
-0.4898819327354431,
-0.3500710725784302,
0.20567120611667633,
0.590419590473175,
0.5725274085998535,
0.28842973709106445,
-0.5367226004600525,
-0.32475465536117554,
0.04585905745625496,
0.40528762340545654,
-1.0197699069976807,
0.10950621962547302,
0.23791153728961945,
-0.21614712476730347,
-0.048008669167757034,
-0.3792557120323181,
-0.6818975806236267,
-0.13306017220020294,
-0.19360223412513733,
0.25979843735694885,
-0.2512495517730713,
0.035151004791259766,
0.40191391110420227,
0.26392486691474915,
0.20037852227687836,
0.38998091220855713,
-1.187619924545288,
0.4883091151714325,
1.0420674085617065,
0.948367178440094,
0.004306010436266661,
-0.3429788649082184,
-0.6825353503227234,
0.016149884089827538,
-0.5013250112533569,
0.4963344633579254,
-0.25728610157966614,
-0.3594631254673004,
-0.11375288665294647,
-0.457928866147995,
-0.17910772562026978,
-0.6552729606628418,
0.8285895586013794,
-0.43127715587615967,
-0.09703417122364044,
-0.081479512155056,
-0.4298427402973175,
-0.12442038953304291,
0.12296569347381592,
-0.1963905394077301,
0.9457289576530457,
0.10434989631175995,
-0.24894055724143982,
0.22798386216163635,
-0.3696693778038025,
-0.42118966579437256,
-0.24111303687095642,
-0.039035614579916,
-0.3987412750720978,
0.4402374029159546,
-0.02453436329960823,
0.6860413551330566,
-0.5646856427192688,
-0.13698036968708038,
-0.2792769968509674,
-0.5483779311180115,
-0.32438766956329346,
-0.22204485535621643,
0.3978216052055359,
0.2440538853406906,
-0.4148883819580078,
0.1939735859632492,
-1.039171814918518,
0.2585877776145935,
0.05150432139635086,
-0.1875040978193283,
-0.3474276661872864,
0.21826747059822083,
-0.3249891400337219,
0.16940799355506897,
0.24358460307121277,
-0.7192500233650208,
0.08132811635732651,
-0.7524062395095825,
0.3845334053039551,
0.5795847177505493,
-0.14195455610752106,
0.6279484629631042,
-0.21148400008678436,
0.16996613144874573,
-0.2706250250339508,
0.4704798460006714,
-0.04617169126868248,
-0.35432159900665283,
-0.7366731762886047,
-0.07021584361791611,
0.02703714370727539,
0.5891729593276978,
-0.36091148853302,
0.3751199543476105,
-0.2793470025062561,
-0.5401201844215393,
-0.5122671723365784,
0.4357978105545044,
0.6920617818832397,
0.7250679135322571,
0.6848192811012268,
-0.1642630398273468,
-0.09916834533214569,
-0.8109756112098694,
-0.1959836184978485,
0.01631259359419346,
-0.12232465296983719,
0.36636465787887573,
-0.08588311076164246,
-0.23942996561527252,
0.48430559039115906,
-0.49477288126945496,
-0.18113066256046295,
-0.08652062714099884,
0.11150771379470825,
0.2626928389072418,
0.6025031805038452,
0.5918318629264832,
-0.35363155603408813,
-0.23739244043827057,
0.17674656212329865,
-0.1937364786863327,
-0.23655635118484497,
-0.19892939925193787,
-0.24574647843837738,
0.4588663578033447,
0.4234207570552826,
-0.5528435707092285,
0.12183264642953873,
0.36142635345458984,
0.003102867631241679,
0.23077599704265594,
-0.5059189796447754,
-0.36648839712142944,
-0.7247934341430664,
-0.08024035394191742,
-0.06948091834783554,
0.11516585201025009,
-0.8671891689300537,
0.13708527386188507,
0.09618517756462097,
0.14845506846904755,
-0.21436834335327148,
0.48833611607551575,
-0.5573384761810303,
-0.024671360850334167,
-0.27502915263175964,
0.2189965397119522,
-0.01618461310863495,
0.8149440288543701,
-0.27904438972473145,
0.6180088520050049,
0.19113752245903015,
-0.6849257946014404,
-0.15436972677707672,
-0.03575531020760536,
-0.10675398260354996,
0.3395838141441345,
-0.6034805178642273,
0.2860308587551117,
-0.07811126857995987,
-0.36557573080062866,
-0.9882830381393433,
0.5525098443031311,
0.3812035024166107,
-0.2504025995731354,
0.4721856117248535,
-0.11085677891969681,
-0.6283206343650818,
-0.1116422638297081,
-0.5378913283348083,
0.43067851662635803,
0.482957661151886,
-0.4852387607097626,
0.330402672290802,
0.006239905022084713,
-0.03762578219175339,
-0.699941873550415,
-0.4313906133174896,
-0.1884630024433136,
-0.042356640100479126,
-0.4505864083766937,
0.729758620262146,
-0.268002450466156,
-0.11371418833732605,
-0.36578676104545593,
-0.6110705137252808,
-0.03821219876408577,
0.39013734459877014,
-0.06502610445022583,
0.1298467069864273,
-0.4755346179008484,
-0.0979667380452156,
0.26274770498275757,
-0.1638469249010086,
-0.07562121003866196,
-0.45073601603507996,
0.6891937851905823,
-0.13630500435829163,
-0.044138357043266296,
-0.36317455768585205,
0.004777106456458569,
0.4886147081851959,
-0.1977037638425827,
0.6231843829154968,
0.4889477491378784,
-0.24896878004074097,
-0.4680168330669403,
-0.6065043807029724,
0.06615833938121796,
-0.4720667600631714,
0.2552729547023773,
-0.16417032480239868,
-0.759980320930481,
0.44620800018310547,
-0.14994829893112183,
0.3487822115421295,
0.25213536620140076,
0.4871695339679718,
0.14392054080963135,
0.6313832998275757,
0.5207833051681519,
-0.2790631651878357,
0.7145284414291382,
-0.29242873191833496,
0.16535022854804993,
-0.8679966330528259,
0.06995540857315063,
-0.42438510060310364,
-0.46305397152900696,
-0.4868946969509125,
-0.5234605073928833,
-0.10772117227315903,
0.5380858778953552,
-0.2371656447649002,
0.179676815867424,
-0.48488810658454895,
0.6749531030654907,
0.49702975153923035,
-0.09892666339874268,
0.3144872188568115,
-0.06948566436767578,
-0.15141478180885315,
0.18933850526809692,
-0.6888766884803772,
-0.19227805733680725,
1.0125021934509277,
0.09513429552316666,
0.3636564016342163,
-0.2948128283023834,
0.9297289252281189,
-0.0669015571475029,
0.06871259212493896,
-0.7554414868354797,
0.6881109476089478,
-0.4326637089252472,
-0.06689281016588211,
-0.42673373222351074,
-0.27650782465934753,
-1.013533353805542,
0.48428604006767273,
-0.056035079061985016,
-0.8297401666641235,
0.25460317730903625,
0.17160151898860931,
-0.801692008972168,
0.3080693781375885,
-0.6487955451011658,
0.839354395866394,
-0.2761991322040558,
-0.6758669018745422,
-0.44622474908828735,
-0.7401106953620911,
0.07772760093212128,
0.11586567759513855,
-0.2637309730052948,
-0.3685796856880188,
-0.22703036665916443,
0.35647162795066833,
-0.5485694408416748,
0.4215678870677948,
-0.30668631196022034,
-0.15470032393932343,
0.0059016053564846516,
-0.02755500189960003,
0.3323744237422943,
-0.14455683529376984,
-0.19012418389320374,
0.3431926667690277,
-0.19651873409748077,
-0.3604118525981903,
-0.5664985179901123,
0.8805069923400879,
-0.6656720042228699,
-0.4673423171043396,
-0.08902650326490402,
-0.43410059809684753,
-0.29402342438697815,
0.4410817623138428,
0.003444510279223323,
0.5162511467933655,
-0.12235008925199509,
0.13986794650554657,
0.7955242991447449,
-0.20926150679588318,
0.6318592429161072,
0.35422617197036743,
0.09477805346250534,
-0.46115121245384216,
1.0209647417068481,
0.3531826436519623,
0.37679556012153625,
0.6627328395843506,
0.18266524374485016,
-0.11520332843065262,
-1.3049620389938354,
-0.6811752915382385,
0.25689366459846497,
-0.24713446199893951,
-0.19619102776050568,
-0.42401203513145447,
-0.007146912626922131,
-0.06053495779633522,
-0.19982615113258362,
-0.7764269709587097,
-0.512670636177063,
-0.47624775767326355,
0.12327250093221664,
0.207709401845932,
0.1356954127550125,
0.1258244812488556,
0.40963470935821533,
-0.7496033310890198,
0.45416924357414246,
-0.09933169931173325,
0.7732753753662109,
0.14878351986408234,
-0.14628632366657257,
-0.27325788140296936,
-0.02931303158402443,
-0.2506157457828522,
-0.2499745488166809,
0.22715482115745544,
0.2095939815044403,
0.5508797764778137,
0.5837734937667847,
0.19609805941581726,
0.8920238614082336,
-0.8186119794845581,
0.3509086072444916,
-0.013309398666024208,
-0.7055748701095581,
0.3721517324447632,
-0.39479902386665344,
0.10713682323694229,
0.8403274416923523,
0.11053528636693954,
-0.46714693307876587,
-0.003423514310270548,
-0.49898362159729004,
-1.19850754737854,
0.7210921049118042,
0.14213436841964722,
0.16526482999324799,
0.08100993186235428,
0.8107292652130127,
0.15363293886184692,
0.3605697751045227,
-0.14999523758888245,
-0.5685849189758301,
-0.03885694593191147,
-0.08361377567052841,
-0.31641101837158203,
-0.3159440755844116,
0.08211604505777359,
-0.2478175014257431,
0.4777100384235382,
-0.13617736101150513,
0.2476162314414978,
0.21638621389865875,
-0.03577733412384987,
-0.15958882868289948,
0.20606884360313416,
1.030163049697876,
0.5104315280914307,
-0.4683011472225189,
-0.26916396617889404,
0.049845140427351,
-0.33201277256011963,
-0.23374705016613007,
0.2527860701084137,
-0.3215517997741699,
-0.09665779024362564,
-0.18779267370700836,
0.8259873390197754,
0.472302109003067,
-0.5782076716423035,
0.25659608840942383,
0.08651810884475708,
-0.22264042496681213,
-0.07604905217885971,
0.4057619273662567,
-0.043415848165750504,
0.5168291330337524,
0.3092043101787567,
0.12509232759475708,
0.11218465864658356,
-0.25603118538856506,
-0.030880894511938095,
0.6057156920433044,
-0.07266681641340256,
-0.31393709778785706,
0.7894994616508484,
0.03692351281642914,
-0.5182890892028809,
0.39564239978790283,
-0.18506520986557007,
-0.12978875637054443,
0.3752893805503845,
0.3952600061893463,
1.052900791168213,
-0.06357841193675995,
-0.047737784683704376,
0.22813259065151215,
0.2471674680709839,
-0.30085697770118713,
0.42719462513923645,
-0.3757885992527008,
-0.8795342445373535,
-0.2986626923084259,
-0.5860952734947205,
-0.6097075343132019,
0.05719662085175514,
-0.6055344343185425,
-0.02561849169433117,
-1.1727343797683716,
0.030377093702554703,
-0.007025053258985281,
0.271944135427475,
-0.30664560198783875,
0.14935699105262756,
0.3475113809108734,
0.8325560688972473,
-0.06320090591907501,
0.9041751623153687,
0.15982699394226074,
-0.02614676207304001,
-0.24815040826797485,
0.11128521710634232,
-0.31866905093193054,
-0.8376944065093994,
0.28237903118133545,
0.19778291881084442,
-0.5297167301177979,
0.2612629532814026,
-0.22043393552303314,
-0.7639955878257751,
1.1534656286239624,
0.47306206822395325,
-0.7868828773498535,
0.053288526833057404,
-0.005982786417007446,
0.7222620844841003,
-0.2385610044002533,
0.01814611442387104,
0.41045141220092773,
0.07420419901609421,
-0.028019435703754425,
-0.6565492153167725,
-0.0035622657742351294,
-0.2049393355846405,
0.3478999435901642,
0.5058755874633789,
-0.9688034653663635,
0.8653966784477234,
-0.30052679777145386,
-0.25908809900283813,
0.28645598888397217,
0.6688714623451233,
0.21391217410564423,
0.49350664019584656,
0.3435324430465698,
0.5923672914505005,
0.8083198070526123,
-0.04350093752145767,
0.950867772102356,
-0.6490939855575562,
0.17025528848171234,
1.1043020486831665,
-0.41976600885391235,
0.9958746433258057,
0.7199570536613464,
-0.00790828000754118,
0.23524929583072662,
0.5811682939529419,
0.04808652028441429,
0.6240983009338379,
0.4601297676563263,
-0.18328842520713806,
0.10001915693283081,
-0.02960512600839138,
-0.30728450417518616,
0.008478897623717785,
0.12775486707687378,
-0.06948758661746979,
-0.29913008213043213,
-0.416609525680542,
-0.000859916559420526,
0.011905435472726822,
-0.6159721612930298,
0.6316598653793335,
-0.05884970352053642,
-0.3209475576877594,
0.9986939430236816,
0.05009011551737785,
0.823823094367981,
-0.49166324734687805,
0.20072850584983826,
-0.46801355481147766,
0.605620265007019,
0.007524462882429361,
-0.31376564502716064,
0.2686791718006134,
-0.2264862209558487,
-0.2520068287849426,
-0.5294932723045349,
0.4155024588108063,
-0.2441735714673996,
-0.19933761656284332,
0.6348296403884888,
0.468289852142334,
-0.08243954926729202,
-0.21318891644477844,
-0.5384014844894409,
-0.1675807386636734,
-0.15129688382148743,
-0.4409997761249542,
0.5556175112724304,
0.3747728765010834,
0.060022156685590744,
0.6506311297416687,
0.7095015645027161,
0.14148320257663727,
0.39772096276283264,
0.18786156177520752,
0.6849477291107178,
-0.6207311749458313,
-0.303129643201828,
-1.0437474250793457,
-0.04917571321129799,
0.2017451971769333,
-0.4689554274082184,
0.6409112811088562,
0.6517521142959595,
1.296042799949646,
0.05825164541602135,
0.2506345510482788,
0.35918480157852173,
0.3798964023590088,
-0.6046227216720581,
0.5668841600418091,
-0.7570005059242249,
0.17704355716705322,
-0.3669048547744751,
-0.8972037434577942,
-0.6291646957397461,
0.5404648184776306,
-0.15200096368789673,
-0.07890009135007858,
0.38651636242866516,
0.768962025642395,
0.046566225588321686,
0.1696983128786087,
0.4456106722354889,
0.15652482211589813,
-0.1157209724187851,
0.5833998918533325,
0.48472675681114197,
-0.45065557956695557,
0.42857638001441956,
-0.6588094830513,
0.08709641546010971,
-0.16955575346946716,
-0.7520950436592102,
-0.6597198843955994,
-0.16883699595928192,
-0.19997116923332214,
-0.06680367141962051,
0.3448035717010498,
1.1162294149398804,
0.393094539642334,
-0.787474513053894,
-0.3216145634651184,
-0.47492825984954834,
0.1516106277704239,
-0.37006744742393494,
-0.08247147500514984,
0.09422560036182404,
-0.4818451702594757,
-0.835662305355072,
0.4470800459384918,
0.5762957334518433,
-0.02078954130411148,
0.08477674424648285,
-0.12474136054515839,
-0.1949503868818283,
-0.04682010039687157,
0.8162916898727417,
0.5507526993751526,
-0.722637414932251,
-0.0643300861120224,
0.15267308056354523,
-0.025715496391057968,
0.48611167073249817,
0.7310537695884705,
-0.5669430494308472,
0.24729804694652557,
0.48815006017684937,
1.1004093885421753,
0.4846072196960449,
0.011206066235899925,
0.49751704931259155,
-0.6120918393135071,
-0.017928369343280792,
0.2004196047782898,
0.1150401309132576,
0.03463148698210716,
-0.35120412707328796,
0.7470160722732544,
0.2526788115501404,
-0.37234610319137573,
-0.9186278581619263,
-0.051957931369543076,
-1.162392497062683,
-0.18775419890880585,
0.8739558458328247,
0.024157507345080376,
-0.11364436149597168,
0.04657677933573723,
-0.03378209099173546,
0.29170045256614685,
-0.40594595670700073,
0.8296819925308228,
0.5128251314163208,
-0.4481818675994873,
-0.30375051498413086,
-0.7244285941123962,
0.4406374394893646,
0.8171794414520264,
-0.4788709282875061,
0.39159896969795227,
0.373675674200058,
0.08266306668519974,
0.051217466592788696,
0.6940842270851135,
0.09424231946468353,
0.12428175657987595,
-0.31501680612564087,
0.029166122898459435,
-0.20043058693408966,
-0.46986931562423706,
-0.5397557616233826,
0.1049175038933754,
0.04930810257792473,
-0.47358205914497375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11577v1 | Extensible Embedding: A Flexible Multipler For LLM's Context Length | 2024-02-18T12:50:19 | 2024-02-18T12:50:19 | Ninglu Shao, Shitao Xiao, Zheng Liu, Peitian Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) call for extension of context to handle many
critical applications. However, the existing approaches are prone to expensive
costs and inferior quality of context extension. In this work, we propose
Extensible Embedding, which realizes high-quality extension of LLM's context
with strong flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Extensible embedding stand as
an enhancement of typical token embedding, which represents the information for
an extensible scope of context instead of a single token. By leveraging such
compact input units of higher information density, the LLM can access to a vast
scope of context even with a small context window. Extensible embedding is
systematically optimized in architecture and training method, which leads to
multiple advantages. 1) High flexibility of context extension, which flexibly
supports ad-hoc extension of diverse context lengths. 2) Strong sample
efficiency of training, which enables the embedding model to be learned in a
cost-effective way. 3) Superior compatibility with the existing LLMs, where the
extensible embedding can be seamlessly introduced as a plug-in component.
Comprehensive evaluations on long-context language modeling and understanding
tasks verify extensible embedding as an effective, efficient, flexible, and
compatible method to extend the LLM's context. | [
-0.40520551800727844,
-0.9125010967254639,
0.40379321575164795,
0.15693698823451996,
-0.477336049079895,
0.08707280457019806,
-0.7209231853485107,
-0.530057430267334,
0.3011380732059479,
0.22570665180683136,
-0.08541246503591537,
-0.3422103524208069,
-0.5068982839584351,
-0.3608594834804535,
-0.2087557017803192,
0.5491185188293457,
-0.3566354811191559,
-0.18934735655784607,
-0.1323612630367279,
-0.5440444946289062,
-0.32104939222335815,
-0.6047386527061462,
-0.4164702594280243,
-0.048914842307567596,
0.28836408257484436,
0.43133416771888733,
0.6186455488204956,
0.8326520323753357,
0.17046301066875458,
0.2697423994541168,
-0.042350802570581436,
0.23668119311332703,
-0.33146560192108154,
0.26661455631256104,
-0.027456440031528473,
-0.35601338744163513,
-0.517605721950531,
-0.16937297582626343,
0.7996978163719177,
0.6517643332481384,
-0.15721404552459717,
0.002243595663458109,
0.2430601567029953,
0.4607197344303131,
-0.6367915868759155,
0.19233985245227814,
-0.43770626187324524,
-0.0036911710631102324,
0.001239092438481748,
-0.0519532673060894,
-0.3145081698894501,
-0.031117193400859833,
0.2732061743736267,
-0.3920378088951111,
-0.3475993275642395,
-0.12838450074195862,
0.39080899953842163,
0.17831213772296906,
-0.7347153425216675,
-0.36656421422958374,
-0.6497331261634827,
0.7028179168701172,
-0.5413920283317566,
0.7033978700637817,
0.01144365407526493,
0.62880539894104,
0.03764711320400238,
-0.6006950736045837,
-0.4639677405357361,
-0.08040142059326172,
0.19269083440303802,
-0.09156844019889832,
0.18327449262142181,
-0.10714750736951828,
0.1529843658208847,
0.4100278317928314,
-0.3495360016822815,
0.08918245136737823,
-0.10805962979793549,
0.016653966158628464,
0.13097620010375977,
-0.06961841881275177,
0.14629432559013367,
0.20810288190841675,
-0.5499780774116516,
0.017140120267868042,
-0.9517769813537598,
0.1261344701051712,
0.34969356656074524,
0.30815157294273376,
-0.2888118326663971,
0.5192530155181885,
-0.04433416202664375,
0.6697095632553101,
-0.3735765814781189,
-0.11328449100255966,
0.35573098063468933,
-0.42137962579727173,
-0.21583090722560883,
-0.2565724551677704,
0.2791455090045929,
-0.026940075680613518,
-0.16586652398109436,
-0.036178138107061386,
-0.15869858860969543,
-0.2551170587539673,
0.014495104551315308,
-0.829872727394104,
0.3785119652748108,
0.30975958704948425,
-0.35366153717041016,
0.21798324584960938,
0.08512448519468307,
-0.3972412645816803,
-0.017606016248464584,
-0.30750152468681335,
0.20075461268424988,
-0.6790850162506104,
-0.3674888610839844,
0.3161752223968506,
0.03644260764122009,
0.36817121505737305,
0.37976059317588806,
-0.7812103629112244,
0.1268715113401413,
0.7156614065170288,
0.9227519631385803,
-0.32451608777046204,
-0.24348612129688263,
-0.4580788314342499,
0.5717818737030029,
0.031119996681809425,
0.4921417236328125,
-0.7461525797843933,
-0.4219239056110382,
0.1916530430316925,
0.07265663146972656,
0.1732000857591629,
-0.28013938665390015,
0.5095370411872864,
-0.6108371019363403,
0.06455585360527039,
0.04833254590630531,
-0.7993645071983337,
-0.3193032443523407,
0.4394434094429016,
-0.8298324942588806,
0.8700926303863525,
0.4243537485599518,
-0.34906652569770813,
0.47644904255867004,
-0.8086276054382324,
-0.43801170587539673,
0.17374129593372345,
-0.15145674347877502,
-0.22037675976753235,
0.16968116164207458,
0.1816401183605194,
0.4677654504776001,
-0.015803001821041107,
0.40757831931114197,
-0.40235695242881775,
-0.32638123631477356,
0.1262115240097046,
-0.6489228010177612,
0.3591855764389038,
0.14283597469329834,
-0.3662436902523041,
0.2125099152326584,
-0.645570695400238,
-0.034764889627695084,
-0.09107395261526108,
-0.9364672899246216,
-0.4818982779979706,
-0.17185255885124207,
0.35509684681892395,
0.26460662484169006,
0.3413977026939392,
-0.5257798433303833,
0.2975347936153412,
-0.5406036972999573,
0.4562227427959442,
0.619929313659668,
-0.4546181261539459,
0.7633132934570312,
-0.24552643299102783,
0.5091114044189453,
-0.08752061426639557,
0.16200725734233856,
-0.3798454701900482,
-0.164948970079422,
-0.7539905905723572,
-0.7354307174682617,
0.17778022587299347,
0.1903553009033203,
-0.5545603632926941,
0.6752232313156128,
-0.6102313995361328,
-0.2475956231355667,
-0.2601902484893799,
0.11720863729715347,
0.22690269351005554,
0.07945803552865982,
0.39597398042678833,
-0.10182791203260422,
-0.6114853620529175,
-0.8045304417610168,
-0.2207951694726944,
0.14966623485088348,
0.2280362844467163,
0.46554914116859436,
0.4811643958091736,
-0.4381824731826782,
1.0231549739837646,
-0.3601084351539612,
-0.22069396078586578,
-0.4208377003669739,
-0.47305360436439514,
0.29544684290885925,
0.5423295497894287,
0.24327822029590607,
-0.8616992235183716,
-0.5745746493339539,
-0.043243058025836945,
-0.45698797702789307,
0.49519211053848267,
-0.032424744218587875,
-0.005768612492829561,
0.27674245834350586,
0.5275787115097046,
-0.4191281199455261,
0.17455177009105682,
0.7908024787902832,
-0.23908185958862305,
0.4522014856338501,
-0.4669763743877411,
-0.2134152054786682,
-1.2687749862670898,
0.012537327595055103,
-0.47990620136260986,
-0.7188074588775635,
-0.5381143689155579,
0.3916401267051697,
0.39975178241729736,
-0.045155271887779236,
-0.580355703830719,
0.8519551753997803,
-0.687045156955719,
0.06312067061662674,
-0.354129433631897,
0.1676633507013321,
0.043562598526477814,
0.2886328101158142,
-0.06886131316423416,
0.6000431776046753,
0.5386464595794678,
-0.4350121319293976,
0.4857735335826874,
0.027064595371484756,
-0.6432962417602539,
0.2702457010746002,
-0.5397375822067261,
0.02693747542798519,
-0.044874656945466995,
0.6016121506690979,
-0.8782591223716736,
-0.1396114081144333,
-0.010231124237179756,
-0.019421793520450592,
0.49156320095062256,
-0.11866982281208038,
-0.4616377353668213,
-0.05407469719648361,
-0.5806460976600647,
0.621343195438385,
0.333549439907074,
-1.0016690492630005,
0.84958815574646,
0.4895319938659668,
-0.16919676959514618,
-0.5995529294013977,
-0.7180318832397461,
0.1405004858970642,
-0.35544905066490173,
-0.513645589351654,
0.4818441867828369,
-0.19754734635353088,
0.30476850271224976,
0.17055219411849976,
0.07066291570663452,
0.0705089122056961,
-0.011628974229097366,
0.2418822944164276,
0.021688157692551613,
-0.29563719034194946,
0.49571552872657776,
0.2657252252101898,
-0.1977001279592514,
-0.4097836911678314,
-0.33155557513237,
0.7027356624603271,
-0.29342684149742126,
-0.763265073299408,
-0.011393477208912373,
0.7957995533943176,
0.6501021981239319,
-0.18474416434764862,
0.9470340013504028,
0.4074746072292328,
-0.5153286457061768,
-0.2811245918273926,
-0.5901720523834229,
0.02942870371043682,
-0.5176801681518555,
0.654446005821228,
-0.6545170545578003,
-1.5775784254074097,
0.4865957796573639,
-0.3456052839756012,
0.04116518795490265,
-0.037612587213516235,
0.5539510846138,
0.42416903376579285,
0.8173739314079285,
0.8048217296600342,
-0.06163739413022995,
0.6081985831260681,
-0.1531049907207489,
0.23145633935928345,
-1.2259610891342163,
-0.23664626479148865,
-0.009991145692765713,
-0.21919213235378265,
-0.2840022146701813,
-0.7731866836547852,
0.19221922755241394,
0.10910296440124512,
-0.11015935242176056,
0.44282224774360657,
-0.3257693648338318,
0.45243099331855774,
0.23861677944660187,
0.03868816792964935,
0.036373570561409,
-0.0020470593590289354,
-0.18562334775924683,
0.2910046875476837,
-0.49711525440216064,
-0.5567223429679871,
1.009213924407959,
0.780735194683075,
0.8128876090049744,
0.6670784950256348,
0.4482068717479706,
-0.273281991481781,
0.19123323261737823,
-1.0139957666397095,
0.25573256611824036,
0.00873034168034792,
-0.5562108755111694,
-0.6071135401725769,
-0.0880221500992775,
-0.6567058563232422,
0.4222477376461029,
-0.014700458385050297,
-0.7133716940879822,
0.1812012493610382,
0.026010708883404732,
-0.2979913353919983,
0.3571512699127197,
-0.5680648684501648,
0.4904566705226898,
-0.24380722641944885,
-0.3425418734550476,
-0.26641255617141724,
-0.2617637813091278,
0.02513359673321247,
-0.3105156421661377,
0.25887352228164673,
-0.004752439446747303,
-0.6195282936096191,
0.6009473204612732,
-0.3892501890659332,
0.7529499530792236,
-0.22759735584259033,
-0.24829430878162384,
0.13072243332862854,
-0.22461961209774017,
0.7655923366546631,
0.361028254032135,
-0.1986636370420456,
-0.21327580511569977,
-0.04273265227675438,
-0.3130052387714386,
-0.7301599979400635,
0.9236863851547241,
-0.4353191554546356,
-0.6601028442382812,
-0.04185882955789566,
-0.6830024123191833,
-0.294096976518631,
0.18338210880756378,
-0.1184256300330162,
0.6907943487167358,
-0.27669408917427063,
0.6233764886856079,
0.37703701853752136,
-0.3421720862388611,
0.5643230676651001,
0.4258521795272827,
-0.15845419466495514,
-0.3461604118347168,
0.7155672907829285,
-0.01580396108329296,
0.21752189099788666,
0.5131362080574036,
0.30535411834716797,
-0.6495017409324646,
-0.4754543602466583,
-0.2850033640861511,
0.03749547153711319,
-0.9243003129959106,
-0.08290889114141464,
-0.8095866441726685,
0.008762247860431671,
-0.4370926320552826,
-0.3648725748062134,
-0.5684565305709839,
-0.6301149129867554,
-0.16827625036239624,
-0.33048346638679504,
0.35502105951309204,
0.3109199106693268,
-0.026422683149576187,
0.44860202074050903,
-0.6250320076942444,
-0.14109310507774353,
0.3416062593460083,
0.6468158960342407,
0.24853408336639404,
-0.568062961101532,
-0.47757387161254883,
-0.14137868583202362,
-0.0030817973893135786,
-0.46759137511253357,
0.2738185524940491,
0.5107821822166443,
0.6370766758918762,
0.6665905714035034,
-0.10190699249505997,
0.6574624180793762,
-0.7174267768859863,
0.5605759620666504,
0.2389490306377411,
-1.0825903415679932,
0.11616373807191849,
-0.12234047800302505,
0.40835040807724,
0.4872514307498932,
0.29370447993278503,
-0.3296031653881073,
-0.07374120503664017,
-0.15564312040805817,
-1.2321051359176636,
0.3171640932559967,
-0.2667258381843567,
0.7004417181015015,
-0.12034173309803009,
0.27939164638519287,
0.44144973158836365,
-0.10534033179283142,
-0.559924840927124,
-0.1393759548664093,
-0.09746367484331131,
0.01413598470389843,
-0.18572334945201874,
-0.569138765335083,
-0.06550700217485428,
-0.2969816327095032,
0.506111741065979,
-0.4373117983341217,
0.4002474546432495,
-0.03441205620765686,
-0.3442319333553314,
0.38565659523010254,
0.5734080672264099,
0.6297561526298523,
0.8142812848091125,
-0.11354658007621765,
0.5457871556282043,
0.49424266815185547,
-0.14908520877361298,
0.25250443816185,
-0.08452516794204712,
0.4874257743358612,
-0.1245667040348053,
0.36124420166015625,
0.9179884195327759,
0.3185364305973053,
-0.6978550553321838,
0.8260784149169922,
0.01964598335325718,
0.17522452771663666,
-0.4946981966495514,
-0.04027784615755081,
0.5071315765380859,
0.25308656692504883,
0.1326284110546112,
-0.42303791642189026,
0.16964517533779144,
-0.5895596742630005,
0.4466013014316559,
0.6139176487922668,
-0.6322585940361023,
-0.1381283402442932,
0.14327514171600342,
0.13558357954025269,
-0.08668823540210724,
0.27009546756744385,
0.008218667469918728,
-0.5526245832443237,
0.3433494567871094,
0.9473689794540405,
0.4905022978782654,
-0.25493741035461426,
-0.12293926626443863,
0.14316299557685852,
-0.03130786865949631,
0.010387422516942024,
0.38922223448753357,
-0.17074283957481384,
-0.5924074053764343,
-0.5185535550117493,
-0.4491215646266937,
-0.30285486578941345,
0.03526091203093529,
-0.547917902469635,
0.37255582213401794,
-0.3895874321460724,
-0.07883495837450027,
-0.5357688069343567,
-0.30366232991218567,
-0.7085331678390503,
0.0722612589597702,
-0.08150364458560944,
1.3829867839813232,
-0.3990168869495392,
1.1207340955734253,
0.726618766784668,
-0.05957944318652153,
-0.7760312557220459,
-0.2327205389738083,
-0.21478667855262756,
-0.7567929029464722,
0.4430486559867859,
0.5604580640792847,
-0.12644369900226593,
-0.11623698472976685,
-0.18614692986011505,
-0.8647692799568176,
1.1739989519119263,
0.3066539168357849,
-0.5340390205383301,
0.011217056773602962,
0.1691933125257492,
0.30379095673561096,
-0.6628084778785706,
0.36153915524482727,
0.28727099299430847,
0.3493122160434723,
0.10639061033725739,
-0.5768930912017822,
0.68434077501297,
-0.2108379304409027,
0.161519393324852,
0.12035943567752838,
-0.6534793972969055,
0.5158774256706238,
-0.08253183960914612,
-0.2829476594924927,
0.10123053193092346,
0.536920964717865,
0.017247499898076057,
-0.21025365591049194,
0.5467227101325989,
0.42490509152412415,
0.6599287390708923,
0.07443629205226898,
1.0482771396636963,
-0.5615894198417664,
0.39988264441490173,
1.2098300457000732,
-0.22101932764053345,
1.1857722997665405,
0.6827711462974548,
0.031139420345425606,
0.44475817680358887,
0.34757721424102783,
0.2009943127632141,
0.5658882856369019,
0.3066607415676117,
-0.6974552869796753,
-0.18544340133666992,
-0.11227179318666458,
-0.5399218797683716,
0.5135548114776611,
0.5628721714019775,
-0.2879320979118347,
-0.1595565676689148,
0.2829008102416992,
-0.08433948457241058,
-0.40057024359703064,
0.174626424908638,
0.5752562880516052,
0.29637134075164795,
-0.3561641573905945,
0.38346558809280396,
0.20313045382499695,
1.0226068496704102,
-0.6472492218017578,
0.14093564450740814,
0.03898439183831215,
0.20846198499202728,
-0.10863886773586273,
-0.6973850131034851,
0.46367597579956055,
-0.37456828355789185,
-0.07401418685913086,
-0.2784518301486969,
0.6269429922103882,
-0.5744014382362366,
-0.1551702618598938,
0.5845416784286499,
0.6316894888877869,
-0.009676276706159115,
-0.062201205641031265,
-0.43318039178848267,
0.14826281368732452,
-0.3884805738925934,
-0.43746355175971985,
0.4282085597515106,
0.3377181887626648,
0.051830437034368515,
0.7174496054649353,
0.764616847038269,
0.08088023215532303,
-0.04564530774950981,
0.10651092976331711,
1.2052398920059204,
-0.5306872129440308,
-0.6202636957168579,
-0.9611998200416565,
0.4274276793003082,
-0.050108883529901505,
-0.037312109023332596,
0.4918697774410248,
0.7777676582336426,
0.5858408212661743,
-0.03608010709285736,
0.8860116004943848,
0.048617590218782425,
0.2175607979297638,
-0.44561296701431274,
0.703248143196106,
-0.6658133864402771,
0.362789511680603,
-0.010622436180710793,
-0.9816961288452148,
-0.47212836146354675,
0.4753321707248688,
-0.11087527126073837,
0.0400562509894371,
0.7324008345603943,
0.5308793783187866,
-0.47834089398384094,
-0.13017868995666504,
0.48591405153274536,
-0.18961526453495026,
0.6556106209754944,
0.7583562731742859,
0.8432015180587769,
-0.125901997089386,
0.4790942966938019,
0.11913669109344482,
-0.5788229703903198,
-0.2974143624305725,
-1.0853843688964844,
-0.8601546883583069,
-0.6210265159606934,
-0.16992413997650146,
-0.047290123999118805,
-0.04601869732141495,
0.9608722925186157,
1.0365829467773438,
-0.6307820081710815,
-0.029021335765719414,
0.1350094974040985,
0.026798788458108902,
0.04585769772529602,
-0.1978393942117691,
0.6786000728607178,
-0.19833184778690338,
-0.7952712178230286,
0.5448398590087891,
0.5786092281341553,
0.12835845351219177,
-0.13694746792316437,
-0.25405701994895935,
-0.19520942866802216,
0.031194746494293213,
0.8840190768241882,
0.128978431224823,
-0.6208118200302124,
-0.6313352584838867,
-0.011256211437284946,
0.0009939399315044284,
-0.022443503141403198,
0.7108395099639893,
-0.6252050995826721,
0.5020635724067688,
0.5770393013954163,
1.0579311847686768,
0.27239304780960083,
-0.2777692377567291,
0.7323090434074402,
-0.7560173273086548,
0.19373297691345215,
-0.13458189368247986,
0.6622298955917358,
0.41363316774368286,
-0.3488702178001404,
0.2941494584083557,
-0.2531548738479614,
-0.2012435793876648,
-0.6108115911483765,
0.425758421421051,
-0.9537345170974731,
-0.41359925270080566,
1.3253203630447388,
-0.6009934544563293,
-0.026324113830924034,
-0.2802443206310272,
-0.11497919261455536,
0.3343426287174225,
-0.4297249913215637,
0.3616049885749817,
0.8354175686836243,
-0.18020540475845337,
-0.16154150664806366,
-0.3008677363395691,
0.19518980383872986,
0.33957433700561523,
-0.8253282904624939,
0.0248554740101099,
0.08567547053098679,
0.24553894996643066,
0.1979287713766098,
0.42118000984191895,
-0.4305669069290161,
-0.031079726293683052,
-0.2800520062446594,
-0.3821312189102173,
-0.4668581187725067,
-0.3223086893558502,
-0.4996166527271271,
0.33006641268730164,
0.2254684716463089,
-0.15421733260154724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16880v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16880v2 | BESA: Pruning Large Language Models with Blockwise Parameter-Efficient Sparsity Allocation | 2024-02-18T12:44:15 | 2024-04-19T07:54:27 | Peng Xu, Wenqi Shao, Mengzhao Chen, Shitao Tang, Kaipeng Zhang, Peng Gao, Fengwei An, Yu Qiao, Ping Luo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding performance in
various tasks, such as text summarization, text question-answering, and etc.
While their performance is impressive, the computational footprint due to their
vast number of parameters can be prohibitive. Existing solutions such as
SparseGPT and Wanda attempt to alleviate this issue through weight pruning.
However, their layer-wise approach results in significant perturbation to the
model's output and requires meticulous hyperparameter tuning, such as the
pruning rate, which can adversely affect overall model performance. To address
this, this paper introduces a novel LLM pruning technique dubbed blockwise
parameter-efficient sparsity allocation (BESA) by applying a blockwise
reconstruction loss. In contrast to the typical layer-wise pruning techniques,
BESA is characterized by two distinctive attributes: i) it targets the overall
pruning error with respect to individual transformer blocks, and ii) it
allocates layer-specific sparsity in a differentiable manner, both of which
ensure reduced performance degradation after pruning. Our experiments show that
BESA achieves state-of-the-art performance, efficiently pruning LLMs like
LLaMA1, and LLaMA2 with 7B to 70B parameters on a single A100 GPU in just five
hours. Code is available at https://github.com/OpenGVLab/LLMPrune-BESA. | [
-0.5063873529434204,
-0.9307089447975159,
0.3430568277835846,
0.5226489305496216,
-0.8858257532119751,
-0.04002324491739273,
-0.40215936303138733,
-0.14782343804836273,
0.33182573318481445,
0.4957687258720398,
-0.7178846597671509,
-0.12467221915721893,
-0.6565494537353516,
-0.1433989256620407,
-0.40648001432418823,
0.8326576352119446,
0.02324693650007248,
-0.15889006853103638,
0.04310109466314316,
0.016404932364821434,
-0.4352998733520508,
-0.2555379867553711,
-0.8744508624076843,
-0.2388981580734253,
0.30856063961982727,
0.312555193901062,
0.5779860019683838,
0.7913641929626465,
0.28050267696380615,
0.33360037207603455,
-0.4613298177719116,
0.3689830005168915,
-0.6217679381370544,
0.1665107011795044,
0.10141376405954361,
0.036084990948438644,
-0.22622910141944885,
-0.2954072058200836,
0.920151948928833,
0.5716984272003174,
-0.35956135392189026,
0.27496862411499023,
0.3242405652999878,
0.6443542838096619,
-0.7203869819641113,
-0.18449686467647552,
-0.7426002621650696,
-0.20607778429985046,
-0.26003536581993103,
-0.3879218101501465,
-0.2624525725841522,
-0.16226783394813538,
-0.1125413253903389,
-0.6189018487930298,
0.20587186515331268,
0.08541147410869598,
1.049866795539856,
0.6210100054740906,
-0.11475655436515808,
0.3243728280067444,
-0.7320816516876221,
0.8140423893928528,
-0.776487410068512,
0.27125731110572815,
0.14453627169132233,
0.4363056719303131,
-0.0606045126914978,
-0.3569221496582031,
-0.45220980048179626,
0.007461834698915482,
0.09060411900281906,
-0.03606158867478371,
-0.3772405982017517,
-0.059326570481061935,
0.16269993782043457,
0.29414063692092896,
-0.6189741492271423,
0.18776433169841766,
-0.46319955587387085,
-0.29594385623931885,
0.551063597202301,
0.04570186138153076,
-0.05335887148976326,
-0.07559599727392197,
-0.4768279492855072,
0.048958636820316315,
-0.995071530342102,
-0.2503065764904022,
0.5382941961288452,
0.1899738907814026,
0.14001893997192383,
0.38874977827072144,
-0.012771179899573326,
0.9719407558441162,
-0.1355953812599182,
-0.14258639514446259,
-0.008229824714362621,
-0.3264555037021637,
-0.382005512714386,
-0.022837894037365913,
0.710806667804718,
0.1379925161600113,
0.3376464247703552,
-0.14246898889541626,
-0.2525845170021057,
-0.07908263802528381,
0.3688462972640991,
-0.980997622013092,
-0.08172502368688583,
-0.012769056484103203,
-0.43938010931015015,
-0.14988213777542114,
-0.11075494438409805,
-0.7519660592079163,
-0.19216234982013702,
-0.09993231296539307,
0.41857507824897766,
-0.2675936222076416,
-0.26283180713653564,
0.10918249189853668,
0.13505305349826813,
0.18702057003974915,
0.30472296476364136,
-0.9689089059829712,
0.7079432606697083,
0.7551971673965454,
0.9455669522285461,
-0.2228492647409439,
-0.26033642888069153,
-0.5762816071510315,
0.256797194480896,
-0.27501043677330017,
0.5667468905448914,
-0.5643675923347473,
-0.33411428332328796,
-0.314558744430542,
-0.0026332561392337084,
-0.04001055657863617,
-0.7341360449790955,
0.3495740592479706,
-0.32450881600379944,
-0.3992449939250946,
-0.08446896821260452,
-0.049055080860853195,
-0.24234183132648468,
0.21007806062698364,
-0.6259378790855408,
0.9442225098609924,
0.09128914773464203,
-0.4947839677333832,
0.037892717868089676,
-0.0697331503033638,
-0.6623711585998535,
-0.019660739228129387,
0.14833524823188782,
-0.7782871723175049,
0.330107182264328,
0.32139596343040466,
0.5540637373924255,
-0.7081508040428162,
0.5165539979934692,
-0.004061743151396513,
-0.4900569021701813,
0.18586233258247375,
-0.5296211838722229,
0.26565536856651306,
0.2983129918575287,
-0.12237967550754547,
0.2990821599960327,
-0.6507660150527954,
-0.12030002474784851,
0.11807698011398315,
-0.18799801170825958,
-0.42156559228897095,
0.08490204066038132,
0.20192860066890717,
0.024826131761074066,
0.1448504775762558,
-0.5519790649414062,
0.14399325847625732,
-0.2011357694864273,
0.5691516399383545,
0.8955592513084412,
-0.04061555862426758,
0.14147719740867615,
-0.3320883512496948,
0.370785653591156,
-0.12870073318481445,
0.11220169067382812,
0.08794033527374268,
-0.1657441109418869,
-0.7716395258903503,
-0.6343718767166138,
0.12769386172294617,
0.253219872713089,
-0.3710072934627533,
0.48284322023391724,
-0.2700112760066986,
-0.5057573318481445,
-0.4942430555820465,
0.16497276723384857,
0.6588932871818542,
0.44716519117355347,
0.4458898901939392,
-0.39590170979499817,
-0.5878774523735046,
-1.0201599597930908,
-0.13804835081100464,
-0.009445098228752613,
-0.049456000328063965,
0.35829952359199524,
0.3204876780509949,
0.19934223592281342,
0.46618473529815674,
-0.6988592743873596,
-0.3361783027648926,
-0.39687979221343994,
-0.20504112541675568,
0.1911245882511139,
0.6145408749580383,
0.07898861914873123,
-0.5009934902191162,
-0.26038601994514465,
-0.03187695890665054,
-0.17832694947719574,
-0.3403981029987335,
-0.097257100045681,
-0.15108050405979156,
0.08049368113279343,
0.3805197477340698,
-0.574629008769989,
0.3035518229007721,
0.5783141851425171,
-0.3140595555305481,
0.7003679275512695,
-0.2659657299518585,
-0.1389116644859314,
-1.0878148078918457,
0.12230027467012405,
0.34958168864250183,
-0.40164053440093994,
-0.4876353144645691,
-0.14934509992599487,
-0.1045466959476471,
-0.06435541063547134,
-0.255408376455307,
0.4129353165626526,
-0.5805773735046387,
-0.28017672896385193,
-0.44769346714019775,
-0.0012339312816038728,
-0.01234319806098938,
0.624790370464325,
0.15890507400035858,
0.7621998190879822,
0.436309814453125,
-0.6756280660629272,
0.02877623587846756,
0.10403991490602493,
-0.2363448143005371,
0.217689648270607,
-0.759243905544281,
0.034293025732040405,
-0.04295557364821434,
0.24020007252693176,
-0.784407377243042,
0.05513938143849373,
0.23984457552433014,
-0.14214040338993073,
0.4108821451663971,
-0.33613044023513794,
-0.30550751090049744,
0.01796131394803524,
-0.2699663043022156,
0.41382408142089844,
0.5536571741104126,
-0.5422577261924744,
0.3823254406452179,
0.6241308450698853,
-0.45026278495788574,
-0.686998188495636,
-0.5712997317314148,
-0.10648062825202942,
-0.26378390192985535,
-0.47454696893692017,
0.6169057488441467,
0.12436488270759583,
0.014387719333171844,
0.10943838208913803,
-0.43823152780532837,
-0.08369084447622299,
0.1614956259727478,
0.12337547540664673,
0.32820847630500793,
-0.12763021886348724,
-0.2671850323677063,
0.40677255392074585,
-0.34819868206977844,
-0.07736652344465256,
-0.351351261138916,
0.8957475423812866,
0.132444828748703,
-0.39001917839050293,
-0.24826350808143616,
0.20435889065265656,
0.38455361127853394,
-0.39890992641448975,
0.6833809614181519,
0.2836391031742096,
-0.40909260511398315,
-0.4734848141670227,
-0.7572486400604248,
-0.043881628662347794,
-0.4575224816799164,
0.5917478799819946,
-0.21232441067695618,
-0.9686188101768494,
0.3761546313762665,
-0.02116367220878601,
0.06759832799434662,
0.03654498606920242,
0.6709047555923462,
0.3625573217868805,
0.702954113483429,
0.5056449770927429,
-0.4652979373931885,
0.40084055066108704,
-0.2338453084230423,
0.21803753077983856,
-0.9959096908569336,
-0.10389650613069534,
-0.7002162337303162,
-0.4143926203250885,
-0.23264430463314056,
-0.653559684753418,
0.2938396632671356,
0.011799202300608158,
-0.24565131962299347,
0.21836057305335999,
-0.5813052654266357,
0.6547874212265015,
0.19325855374336243,
0.07730236649513245,
0.21541379392147064,
0.05141925439238548,
0.368115097284317,
0.3094629943370819,
-0.593441903591156,
-0.48454853892326355,
0.7639697194099426,
0.3994089365005493,
0.77060866355896,
-0.005014900583773851,
0.5585041046142578,
-0.15987595915794373,
0.25380071997642517,
-0.5673703551292419,
0.7713410258293152,
-0.24746239185333252,
-0.2890455722808838,
-0.6596539616584778,
-0.5853416323661804,
-0.8291844725608826,
0.5975261330604553,
0.05087307095527649,
-0.8297041058540344,
0.04274166002869606,
0.441972941160202,
-0.20464394986629486,
0.4843338131904602,
-0.419491708278656,
0.6554907560348511,
0.05382418632507324,
-0.495882511138916,
-0.45639994740486145,
-0.4164096713066101,
0.2879523038864136,
-0.06950800865888596,
0.007093878462910652,
-0.14361795783042908,
-0.18337644636631012,
0.749047577381134,
-0.7348331212997437,
0.49572739005088806,
-0.35946282744407654,
0.09428983926773071,
0.20212849974632263,
0.26093295216560364,
0.743694007396698,
0.10467849671840668,
0.045221175998449326,
-0.011933875270187855,
-0.027342025190591812,
-0.4157368242740631,
-0.514553427696228,
0.8677968382835388,
-0.6279129385948181,
-0.5284462571144104,
-0.12045269459486008,
-0.6801913976669312,
-0.1278400868177414,
0.04173557832837105,
0.1176827996969223,
0.39903873205184937,
-0.20035994052886963,
-0.03526395186781883,
0.598408579826355,
-0.30291426181793213,
0.4928753077983856,
0.4024135172367096,
-0.09109249711036682,
-0.3123406171798706,
1.3454982042312622,
0.27218249440193176,
0.13729441165924072,
0.12339847534894943,
0.16315948963165283,
-0.03065144456923008,
-1.0064973831176758,
-0.39673376083374023,
0.36432400345802307,
-0.25996220111846924,
-0.3930799067020416,
-0.3054889440536499,
-0.25021982192993164,
-0.06621824949979782,
-0.2519039213657379,
-0.44329044222831726,
-0.3797367513179779,
0.021198298782110214,
-0.1210038885474205,
0.2618417739868164,
0.37092429399490356,
0.11008728295564651,
0.7015982866287231,
-0.5065485239028931,
0.1621835082769394,
-0.013611232861876488,
0.4854600727558136,
0.1239239051938057,
-0.4946640133857727,
-0.03538401797413826,
-0.3781331777572632,
-0.16337671875953674,
-0.7406232357025146,
0.6975162625312805,
0.08247597515583038,
0.3672575056552887,
0.3490741550922394,
-0.17842498421669006,
0.9107725024223328,
-0.46855875849723816,
0.4203827381134033,
0.13256873190402985,
-0.8653914928436279,
0.07422102987766266,
-0.11343210935592651,
0.273062139749527,
0.5585582852363586,
0.08153706789016724,
-0.4780471622943878,
-0.3151211440563202,
-0.36081406474113464,
-1.0836269855499268,
0.7093668580055237,
0.11791890114545822,
0.05568217858672142,
0.1623544991016388,
0.20602327585220337,
0.29142841696739197,
0.1517421007156372,
-0.5475524067878723,
-0.1217510998249054,
-0.09393952786922455,
-0.09015908092260361,
-0.20735503733158112,
-0.5522608160972595,
-0.022023377940058708,
-0.07073689997196198,
1.0498610734939575,
-0.019879590719938278,
0.11306238919496536,
-0.012695238925516605,
-0.3311237394809723,
-0.14545029401779175,
0.3373585045337677,
0.4334970712661743,
0.6340660452842712,
-0.06619821488857269,
0.17048385739326477,
0.25660717487335205,
-0.5271347761154175,
0.1947469264268875,
0.2571916878223419,
-0.39610615372657776,
-0.1586899757385254,
-0.00928180105984211,
0.9462776780128479,
0.1250622719526291,
-0.5462594628334045,
0.36613601446151733,
0.006721936631947756,
-0.2450546771287918,
-0.1145387589931488,
-0.22756773233413696,
-0.031769897788763046,
0.1257225126028061,
0.41687753796577454,
-0.07445574551820755,
-0.06842713803052902,
0.0261724591255188,
0.033472366631031036,
0.5889593362808228,
-0.2333383411169052,
-0.18503208458423615,
0.4881320297718048,
0.1593611091375351,
-0.2077406644821167,
0.5314677357673645,
0.013922040350735188,
-0.343843936920166,
0.6042277216911316,
0.8386989235877991,
0.8313303589820862,
-0.2755683660507202,
0.2668536901473999,
0.2611182928085327,
0.5628842115402222,
-0.16850093007087708,
0.1377374231815338,
-0.07540824264287949,
-0.525712251663208,
-0.8629087209701538,
-0.8054606914520264,
-0.22037045657634735,
0.2774343192577362,
-0.36920079588890076,
0.10086310654878616,
-0.7398107647895813,
0.1875307559967041,
-0.15814709663391113,
-0.057106006890535355,
-0.18642373383045197,
0.15150219202041626,
0.036563970148563385,
1.0332263708114624,
-0.954386293888092,
0.8107301592826843,
0.41467154026031494,
-0.08954215049743652,
-0.9057974219322205,
0.0013941485667601228,
-0.1956050992012024,
-0.5458659529685974,
0.19183732569217682,
0.1124778762459755,
-0.14380517601966858,
0.1569214165210724,
-0.4928492605686188,
-0.9308478236198425,
0.9425324201583862,
0.6974233984947205,
-0.7856987118721008,
0.13888375461101532,
-0.07637806981801987,
0.13403435051441193,
-0.11967185139656067,
0.10590821504592896,
0.5773933529853821,
0.5836023688316345,
0.07548059523105621,
-0.809448778629303,
0.4697572588920593,
-0.3872028887271881,
0.18315398693084717,
0.5949226021766663,
-0.9415491819381714,
0.6382826566696167,
-0.059887178242206573,
-0.1389075368642807,
0.12910953164100647,
0.8011993765830994,
0.4693271517753601,
0.15580713748931885,
0.7437336444854736,
0.5947462320327759,
0.7084229588508606,
-0.16559720039367676,
0.884786069393158,
-0.30145493149757385,
0.13461469113826752,
0.5507656335830688,
-0.15375648438930511,
0.5475113391876221,
0.776674747467041,
-0.16710524260997772,
-0.09132348001003265,
0.616436779499054,
0.04950903728604317,
0.5500742793083191,
0.6447591185569763,
-0.16912822425365448,
-0.33209818601608276,
-0.06946706026792526,
-0.18171770870685577,
0.09909240901470184,
0.21917660534381866,
0.03968502953648567,
-0.2659743130207062,
-0.03254802152514458,
0.3321736752986908,
-0.02319631166756153,
-0.46080341935157776,
0.5194661617279053,
0.07558948546648026,
-0.8400318026542664,
0.7859808206558228,
0.18779759109020233,
0.727992057800293,
-0.8022997379302979,
0.0204139556735754,
-0.23885495960712433,
0.10205092281103134,
-0.2662111818790436,
-0.251758337020874,
0.3886958062648773,
0.10081598162651062,
-0.01586827263236046,
-0.1472410410642624,
0.8048986792564392,
-0.42393895983695984,
-0.381039559841156,
0.15790560841560364,
0.32980960607528687,
0.23122939467430115,
-0.02638896368443966,
-0.4507403075695038,
0.47933608293533325,
-0.04076952859759331,
-0.5877094268798828,
0.5998146533966064,
0.10415639728307724,
-0.28335151076316833,
0.9210779666900635,
0.6010196805000305,
0.43992966413497925,
0.08746237307786942,
-0.00558884534984827,
1.2426269054412842,
-0.3468095064163208,
-0.2991432547569275,
-0.8995116353034973,
0.28146955370903015,
0.03973689302802086,
-0.4355531334877014,
0.4778841435909271,
0.7423800230026245,
0.6695349812507629,
0.11008720844984055,
0.7091972827911377,
-0.043635789304971695,
0.3356158137321472,
-0.5976415276527405,
0.49521851539611816,
-0.4789542853832245,
0.5110424757003784,
-0.4045993685722351,
-1.1461678743362427,
-0.33841192722320557,
0.6586326956748962,
-0.2944222092628479,
-0.007371400482952595,
0.4553292691707611,
1.2032240629196167,
-0.09403393417596817,
-0.24817617237567902,
0.2494838982820511,
0.1300560086965561,
0.1958615630865097,
0.45824021100997925,
0.6597108840942383,
0.10740108788013458,
0.6242818236351013,
-0.3154884874820709,
-0.30832356214523315,
-0.05608602240681648,
-0.7438806295394897,
-0.5682138204574585,
-0.496744304895401,
-0.25452616810798645,
-0.1953943818807602,
0.42848750948905945,
0.787278950214386,
0.6506494283676147,
-0.5683456659317017,
-0.4356541931629181,
-0.04509110003709793,
0.18711718916893005,
-0.4274871349334717,
-0.08231975138187408,
0.48555898666381836,
-0.17761091887950897,
-0.6601975560188293,
0.5508398413658142,
0.3638429343700409,
-0.3047061860561371,
-0.29546022415161133,
-0.28075534105300903,
-0.2510262727737427,
0.14247584342956543,
0.34706857800483704,
0.3386510908603668,
-0.46008384227752686,
-0.15848247706890106,
-0.2689574658870697,
0.20250903069972992,
-0.16515380144119263,
0.882798433303833,
-0.7042353749275208,
-0.028407294303178787,
0.43678542971611023,
0.7981177568435669,
0.9080960750579834,
0.20640869438648224,
0.5817440748214722,
-0.9191385507583618,
0.31072336435317993,
0.17046430706977844,
0.4506126940250397,
0.19571715593338013,
-0.15496303141117096,
0.42707908153533936,
0.07132217288017273,
-0.4463657736778259,
-1.1080361604690552,
0.17529483139514923,
-1.1026052236557007,
-0.48455336689949036,
1.2189579010009766,
-0.008449937216937542,
-0.4847847819328308,
0.13566569983959198,
-0.35014042258262634,
0.27357831597328186,
-0.31027984619140625,
0.562893807888031,
0.3765948414802551,
0.24427570402622223,
-0.36812230944633484,
-0.32808902859687805,
0.2740143835544586,
0.7112874388694763,
-0.6864795088768005,
0.3602522611618042,
0.5352333188056946,
0.237125426530838,
-0.284648060798645,
0.6884246468544006,
-0.056155700236558914,
0.07167840003967285,
-0.2756832540035248,
0.0025776848196983337,
-0.5721471905708313,
-0.4194573163986206,
-0.28810742497444153,
0.17574621737003326,
0.16471442580223083,
-0.3001987040042877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11574v1 | Visual In-Context Learning for Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-18T12:43:38 | 2024-02-18T12:43:38 | Yucheng Zhou, Xiang Li, Qianning Wang, Jianbing Shen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In Large Visual Language Models (LVLMs), the efficacy of In-Context Learning
(ICL) remains limited by challenges in cross-modal interactions and
representation disparities. To overcome these challenges, we introduce a novel
Visual In-Context Learning (VICL) method comprising Visual Demonstration
Retrieval, Intent-Oriented Image Summarization, and Intent-Oriented
Demonstration Composition. Our approach retrieves images via ''Retrieval &
Rerank'' paradigm, summarises images with task intent and task-specific visual
parsing, and composes language-based demonstrations that reduce token count and
alleviate cross-modal interaction problem. Experimental evaluations on five
visual reasoning datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
Moreover, our extensive experiments leverage information flow analysis to
elucidate the effectiveness of our method, and investigate the impact of length
and position of demonstrations for LVLM. The use of in-context unlearning
further shows promise in resetting specific model knowledge without retraining. | [
-0.2124149054288864,
-0.8253294825553894,
0.47508129477500916,
0.014052852988243103,
-0.7482534050941467,
-0.10571658611297607,
-0.3286036252975464,
-0.16958646476268768,
-0.1399773359298706,
0.4369317293167114,
-0.26571670174598694,
-0.5748457312583923,
-0.29351234436035156,
-0.16809017956256866,
-0.4358452558517456,
0.5032920837402344,
-0.11541491001844406,
0.198007732629776,
-0.5897267460823059,
-0.26881587505340576,
-0.6229236721992493,
-0.22654345631599426,
-0.5595623850822449,
-0.18183578550815582,
0.46557697653770447,
0.6909803748130798,
0.23219554126262665,
0.3663700819015503,
0.46925702691078186,
0.28461953997612,
0.10025870054960251,
0.2634795606136322,
-0.5818772912025452,
0.13516280055046082,
-0.1528465747833252,
-0.4104739725589752,
0.1339539736509323,
-0.35912200808525085,
0.914840579032898,
0.8432063460350037,
0.06220201402902603,
0.07297035306692123,
0.163133904337883,
0.5608066916465759,
-0.8818178772926331,
0.2718948423862457,
-0.6032096147537231,
0.0704047754406929,
-0.05064690113067627,
-0.4223766326904297,
-0.7939527630805969,
0.05971531569957733,
0.30976882576942444,
-0.46306419372558594,
-0.11637435108423233,
0.018576784059405327,
0.45620474219322205,
0.390054315328598,
-0.6299870014190674,
0.02850215695798397,
-0.30310091376304626,
0.8409278988838196,
-0.5482665300369263,
0.5421901345252991,
0.1298953741788864,
0.6054995656013489,
0.014008909463882446,
-0.9950436949729919,
-0.4507657289505005,
-0.18166640400886536,
-0.05521175265312195,
0.18047508597373962,
-0.003552615875378251,
-0.17075088620185852,
0.3165988624095917,
0.06596416234970093,
-0.45097610354423523,
-0.08556848764419556,
-0.4397038221359253,
0.157490074634552,
0.41909006237983704,
0.10807350277900696,
0.3323036730289459,
0.08388050645589828,
-0.6196120381355286,
-0.21324831247329712,
-0.8356453776359558,
0.3631688058376312,
-0.5189586281776428,
0.3037295639514923,
-0.18283991515636444,
0.6187642216682434,
-0.2527361810207367,
0.8443167209625244,
-0.11838231235742569,
-0.17161260545253754,
0.2225659042596817,
-0.11395997554063797,
-0.6001916527748108,
-0.17383317649364471,
0.5274181365966797,
0.49705633521080017,
0.07677123695611954,
-0.11413642019033432,
-0.2760295569896698,
-0.2777678668498993,
-0.0005698900786228478,
-0.8484014272689819,
-0.06370610743761063,
-0.12925274670124054,
-0.5591718554496765,
-0.10459291189908981,
0.09525685012340546,
-0.5651313662528992,
-0.45232895016670227,
-0.4646303355693817,
0.8227689266204834,
-0.4351251423358917,
-0.011447192169725895,
-0.032353583723306656,
-0.33007484674453735,
0.45022958517074585,
0.6445873975753784,
-0.5379769802093506,
-0.01678025908768177,
0.3277013301849365,
0.7720464468002319,
-0.11893398314714432,
-0.48840638995170593,
-0.9625092148780823,
0.26982635259628296,
-0.5083193778991699,
0.4760187864303589,
-0.5762733221054077,
-0.2641438841819763,
0.16668535768985748,
-0.007873136550188065,
-0.01999255269765854,
-0.6657870411872864,
-0.1408502608537674,
-0.3358389735221863,
0.20263993740081787,
-0.40741026401519775,
-0.5668810606002808,
-0.33091962337493896,
0.18515801429748535,
-0.4392813444137573,
0.6200309991836548,
0.05626256391406059,
-0.6247481107711792,
0.7298617959022522,
-0.5595117807388306,
-0.5405319929122925,
0.36683234572410583,
-0.5912178158760071,
-0.21097572147846222,
0.2098674178123474,
0.18567006289958954,
0.7510477900505066,
-0.06624253839254379,
0.16806624829769135,
-0.277885764837265,
-0.6787338852882385,
0.08056049793958664,
-0.541397213935852,
0.6471642851829529,
-0.051103897392749786,
-0.5431498885154724,
0.4900040924549103,
-0.4955112934112549,
-0.211215540766716,
0.1559164971113205,
-0.21830593049526215,
-0.5219459533691406,
-0.0409427285194397,
-0.009410723112523556,
0.32230496406555176,
0.1879325956106186,
-0.4136199951171875,
0.267517626285553,
-0.12392663210630417,
0.23201246559619904,
0.49514156579971313,
-0.014559007249772549,
0.5227088928222656,
0.1013852059841156,
0.24274839460849762,
0.1453009396791458,
0.4224949777126312,
-0.5951510667800903,
-0.3123384118080139,
-0.8233148455619812,
-0.3859560489654541,
-0.2037506252527237,
0.1517464518547058,
-1.4129685163497925,
-0.08106835931539536,
-0.3855060040950775,
-0.1523348093032837,
-0.01069137454032898,
0.2313842922449112,
0.7999783754348755,
0.6915567517280579,
0.4371834993362427,
-0.3602047860622406,
-0.22122812271118164,
-0.8716439008712769,
-0.08458960801362991,
-0.03560774773359299,
0.053324878215789795,
0.2781889736652374,
0.607353925704956,
-0.1408558040857315,
0.905750572681427,
-0.19942177832126617,
-0.2126319408416748,
-0.48572486639022827,
0.07858460396528244,
-0.18495914340019226,
0.233486145734787,
0.5252298712730408,
-1.0861908197402954,
-0.5107362866401672,
0.1287229061126709,
-0.991615355014801,
0.24875344336032867,
0.007967902347445488,
0.0424538217484951,
0.3767102062702179,
1.0330321788787842,
-0.11438585817813873,
0.8153165578842163,
0.21490471065044403,
-0.5074149370193481,
0.3268609941005707,
-0.3429659605026245,
0.11921090632677078,
-0.8617600202560425,
-0.11243441700935364,
0.08917251229286194,
-0.4356440603733063,
-0.42375344038009644,
0.2461903840303421,
0.3275730013847351,
-0.07693424075841904,
-0.7350435853004456,
0.742237389087677,
-0.6177718043327332,
-0.23805390298366547,
-0.296176552772522,
0.0538959763944149,
0.029800018295645714,
0.5666702389717102,
0.2402198612689972,
0.7477279305458069,
0.7663137316703796,
-0.5662024021148682,
0.2770114243030548,
0.1465681791305542,
-0.6090586185455322,
0.4758448004722595,
-0.41994884610176086,
-0.32884567975997925,
-0.3291225731372833,
0.25514134764671326,
-0.9980146288871765,
-0.2809135615825653,
0.13767878711223602,
-0.10230611264705658,
0.2886057198047638,
-0.2608529329299927,
-0.21369031071662903,
0.024023039266467094,
-0.11673811823129654,
0.5482011437416077,
0.4637170433998108,
-1.1191277503967285,
0.7254331111907959,
0.1937686949968338,
0.15594901144504547,
-0.7576568722724915,
-0.7605397701263428,
0.08538158237934113,
-0.42612123489379883,
-0.3465351164340973,
0.0644044280052185,
0.0017236558487638831,
-0.37350451946258545,
-0.16073930263519287,
0.17400188744068146,
0.12327291071414948,
-0.05787539482116699,
0.28393417596817017,
0.14762775599956512,
-0.05458221212029457,
0.44793644547462463,
-0.2241489440202713,
0.22476351261138916,
-0.052102815359830856,
-0.16995637118816376,
0.36992475390434265,
-0.4199552834033966,
-0.6293503642082214,
-0.37673419713974,
0.4758385717868805,
0.6938254833221436,
-0.4239517152309418,
0.5777368545532227,
0.4976990818977356,
-0.2396300733089447,
-0.4359382092952728,
-0.2417519986629486,
-0.16318634152412415,
-0.4413575530052185,
0.5831902027130127,
-0.35742130875587463,
-0.7579021453857422,
0.22059570252895355,
-0.2121802419424057,
0.18661977350711823,
-0.1120547279715538,
0.41455158591270447,
-0.17597277462482452,
0.8326711654663086,
0.8189519047737122,
0.2435259222984314,
0.9491114616394043,
-0.5215861797332764,
0.13895200192928314,
-0.8145649433135986,
-0.532960057258606,
0.22100800275802612,
-0.2563779056072235,
0.17219854891300201,
-0.6606679558753967,
0.5194109678268433,
0.19050967693328857,
-0.35412096977233887,
-0.011005496606230736,
-0.07601933926343918,
0.6756724119186401,
0.593891441822052,
0.44371962547302246,
0.33063653111457825,
0.15861687064170837,
-0.17988231778144836,
0.16857324540615082,
-0.6751959323883057,
-0.14891621470451355,
0.9186622500419617,
0.026959506794810295,
0.8026258945465088,
0.20730216801166534,
0.4698825180530548,
0.026299763470888138,
0.37001195549964905,
-0.8093200922012329,
0.7406012415885925,
-0.19240960478782654,
0.05571404844522476,
-0.5616655945777893,
-0.3638821840286255,
-0.6875433921813965,
0.5241947174072266,
-0.2007051557302475,
-0.7728116512298584,
0.32524338364601135,
0.22015811502933502,
0.019290264695882797,
0.3120003938674927,
-0.7719717621803284,
1.0678915977478027,
-0.422721803188324,
-0.574714183807373,
-0.20918183028697968,
-0.7803273797035217,
0.4852559268474579,
0.23857466876506805,
0.14916861057281494,
0.455585777759552,
-0.004226050339639187,
0.22039523720741272,
-0.402812659740448,
1.1315068006515503,
-0.2059856504201889,
-0.23778973519802094,
0.12703607976436615,
0.023160530254244804,
0.37915927171707153,
-0.03611627221107483,
0.505594789981842,
-0.18818801641464233,
-0.41438382863998413,
-0.3035953938961029,
-0.9645945429801941,
0.5138950347900391,
-0.24542225897312164,
-0.3461422920227051,
0.028389520943164825,
-0.479661226272583,
-0.19679659605026245,
0.10502690821886063,
0.35428714752197266,
1.0630162954330444,
-0.06594674289226532,
0.6696815490722656,
0.7341626286506653,
-0.3003375232219696,
0.6899781227111816,
0.32003727555274963,
-0.5793478488922119,
-0.26214051246643066,
1.0975253582000732,
-0.1755143404006958,
0.4618137776851654,
0.6696000695228577,
0.19315770268440247,
-0.3482823073863983,
-0.42552077770233154,
-0.44493281841278076,
-0.0637921541929245,
-1.1607086658477783,
0.043978407979011536,
-0.3177468180656433,
0.16315864026546478,
-0.08631333708763123,
-0.3190212845802307,
-0.338180273771286,
-0.1542007029056549,
-0.10520926117897034,
0.23330970108509064,
-0.07126180082559586,
0.5936852693557739,
0.3420843780040741,
0.1553964614868164,
-0.2313036471605301,
0.3220912516117096,
0.6201590895652771,
0.39113694429397583,
0.2598203420639038,
-0.5914431214332581,
-0.33765631914138794,
-0.029005277901887894,
-0.08007657527923584,
-0.6592453122138977,
0.43899285793304443,
0.2221992015838623,
0.5594661235809326,
0.7296179533004761,
-0.04195167124271393,
0.9239101409912109,
-0.3004307150840759,
0.6817401051521301,
0.4426376223564148,
-0.9028753638267517,
0.5638957619667053,
-0.2230738401412964,
0.3198561370372772,
0.22942844033241272,
0.12253437936306,
-0.4549422264099121,
-0.20836485922336578,
-0.4190772473812103,
-1.0767717361450195,
0.15644292533397675,
-0.09057842195034027,
-0.151783287525177,
0.04538460448384285,
0.23378048837184906,
-0.06831411272287369,
0.1110464408993721,
-0.7149948477745056,
-0.12942339479923248,
-0.3102726936340332,
-0.23638750612735748,
-0.22565245628356934,
-0.05267078056931496,
-0.20561127364635468,
-0.5648055076599121,
0.49436065554618835,
-0.5890291929244995,
-0.16562752425670624,
0.27802643179893494,
-0.6025991439819336,
0.22589458525180817,
0.056257352232933044,
0.6881561279296875,
0.9913555979728699,
0.03740119934082031,
0.28334832191467285,
0.2684394419193268,
-0.11819662898778915,
-0.12027882784605026,
-0.3930751383304596,
-0.15689557790756226,
-0.09795324504375458,
0.5707695484161377,
0.9912868738174438,
0.5542506575584412,
-1.173417329788208,
0.9996852278709412,
-0.40723076462745667,
-0.0863310843706131,
-0.38723987340927124,
-0.1669376790523529,
-0.08980312198400497,
0.57539302110672,
0.458398699760437,
-0.164887934923172,
0.19310925900936127,
-0.7369109392166138,
0.3393365144729614,
0.7554675340652466,
-0.6301588416099548,
0.04867662489414215,
0.5223791599273682,
0.015449141152203083,
0.001369630335830152,
0.4632939398288727,
0.059220924973487854,
-0.26625803112983704,
0.6241229772567749,
0.6326215267181396,
0.5750988721847534,
0.3110876977443695,
0.24169835448265076,
0.14753486216068268,
0.04906770586967468,
-0.13487015664577484,
0.23562732338905334,
-0.27950969338417053,
-0.46823692321777344,
-0.44794705510139465,
-0.19459496438503265,
-0.3868074119091034,
0.021550145000219345,
-0.6455679535865784,
0.3074709475040436,
-0.23187729716300964,
0.2423824816942215,
-0.2763744592666626,
-0.39935222268104553,
-0.5048052668571472,
0.19248512387275696,
0.2666608691215515,
0.8457511067390442,
-0.9176082015037537,
0.7531753778457642,
0.8192796111106873,
-0.5351832509040833,
-0.692986011505127,
0.02202264778316021,
-0.14981959760189056,
-0.6409972906112671,
1.0325950384140015,
0.277448832988739,
-0.3224504292011261,
-0.13270016014575958,
-0.9408474564552307,
-0.5309714674949646,
1.2639206647872925,
0.47178366780281067,
-0.38876697421073914,
0.4419069290161133,
-0.29278722405433655,
0.3197520971298218,
-0.7118406295776367,
0.28049811720848083,
0.003077886998653412,
0.1898784190416336,
0.21722646057605743,
-0.7070983648300171,
0.037629060447216034,
-0.27226847410202026,
0.09195102006196976,
-0.026565443724393845,
-0.7474833726882935,
0.7573615908622742,
-0.4959447979927063,
-0.28641435503959656,
-0.07352614402770996,
0.7206976413726807,
0.32010507583618164,
0.45295262336730957,
0.6079838871955872,
0.2889742851257324,
0.5896422266960144,
0.15916940569877625,
1.0546085834503174,
0.2066340446472168,
0.12384622544050217,
1.3003654479980469,
-0.1507670134305954,
1.0671401023864746,
0.8110288381576538,
0.5097398161888123,
0.5244656801223755,
0.2628367841243744,
0.31163665652275085,
0.6469747424125671,
0.00341309467330575,
-0.39457592368125916,
-0.6429244875907898,
-0.27818232774734497,
-0.13766832649707794,
0.5651969313621521,
0.34935733675956726,
-0.33625224232673645,
-0.344909131526947,
0.46054792404174805,
-0.5089977979660034,
0.10559913516044617,
-0.44874340295791626,
0.8110305666923523,
0.07279983907938004,
-0.47266885638237,
0.6256060600280762,
-0.5147249102592468,
0.5130285024642944,
-0.34664395451545715,
-0.39183366298675537,
-0.21551433205604553,
0.348959356546402,
0.06111438199877739,
-0.6916138529777527,
-0.1476251482963562,
-0.2637690305709839,
-0.1189924106001854,
-0.1562034636735916,
0.4911746382713318,
-0.6971186995506287,
-0.27477410435676575,
0.32059091329574585,
0.4019632637500763,
0.16738373041152954,
-0.15099768340587616,
-0.22259174287319183,
-0.10037583112716675,
-0.09685812145471573,
-0.15404276549816132,
0.4864526391029358,
0.5375672578811646,
-0.5812005400657654,
1.1791362762451172,
0.3871763348579407,
-0.34330666065216064,
0.08534515649080276,
0.4495449960231781,
0.9592664837837219,
-0.6019335985183716,
-0.41251617670059204,
-0.8319602608680725,
0.5556913018226624,
-0.24662251770496368,
-0.13737761974334717,
0.657889187335968,
0.6793845295906067,
1.0169087648391724,
-0.2689141035079956,
0.8259327411651611,
0.1849861890077591,
0.05580053851008415,
-0.7096894979476929,
0.5276650786399841,
-1.1273009777069092,
0.11683202534914017,
-0.2921293377876282,
-0.5114744901657104,
-0.5022643208503723,
0.5949427485466003,
-0.07474487274885178,
-0.04887659102678299,
0.8066881895065308,
0.5510849952697754,
-0.23664243519306183,
-0.249458447098732,
0.6363933682441711,
0.05424131080508232,
0.3003785014152527,
0.7144419550895691,
1.0238561630249023,
-0.2587127983570099,
0.5617194175720215,
-0.32362130284309387,
-0.3665516674518585,
-0.3494813144207001,
-0.9613308906555176,
-1.1686115264892578,
-0.7724348306655884,
-0.16605748236179352,
0.09660904854536057,
0.10833203792572021,
0.7932061553001404,
0.7067832350730896,
-0.3260194957256317,
-0.25357288122177124,
-0.02417878434062004,
-0.0179391261190176,
-0.43961337208747864,
-0.16695167124271393,
0.37869369983673096,
-0.2789997458457947,
-0.5385629534721375,
0.6140261888504028,
0.47646471858024597,
0.019464686512947083,
-0.1806783825159073,
-0.22097909450531006,
0.026151500642299652,
-0.40618646144866943,
1.034803867340088,
0.46250683069229126,
-0.8630836606025696,
-0.2137136608362198,
-0.2585698068141937,
-0.025390416383743286,
-0.034037619829177856,
0.8791135549545288,
-0.9523537755012512,
0.5480052828788757,
0.6014630794525146,
0.4721377193927765,
0.4688158333301544,
0.08752812445163727,
0.5466665029525757,
-0.9136608242988586,
0.35845911502838135,
-0.033888280391693115,
0.7817122936248779,
0.3943628668785095,
-0.09702444076538086,
0.22909954190254211,
0.1550437957048416,
-0.20867298543453217,
-0.6540258526802063,
0.3693951368331909,
-1.1053496599197388,
-0.6409446597099304,
1.1794103384017944,
0.0026492266915738583,
-0.36729103326797485,
-0.16639691591262817,
-0.37771958112716675,
0.13602162897586823,
-0.18474909663200378,
0.5785288214683533,
0.08403222262859344,
0.026600345969200134,
-0.6107284426689148,
-0.4017152786254883,
0.22184091806411743,
0.24821794033050537,
-0.7002605199813843,
0.2906804084777832,
0.6093120574951172,
0.196332186460495,
-0.20330817997455597,
0.48867976665496826,
-0.014375579543411732,
0.39920541644096375,
-0.24428333342075348,
0.1851046085357666,
-0.3200032711029053,
-0.7719883918762207,
-0.3982824683189392,
0.16370956599712372,
-0.09815304726362228,
-0.17542557418346405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11573v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11573v1 | BGE Landmark Embedding: A Chunking-Free Embedding Method For Retrieval Augmented Long-Context Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T12:41:01 | 2024-02-18T12:41:01 | Kun Luo, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) call for extension of context to handle many
critical applications. However, the existing approaches are prone to expensive
costs and inferior quality of context extension. In this work, we
proposeExtensible Embedding, which realizes high-quality extension of LLM's
context with strong flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Extensible embedding
stand as an enhancement of typical token embedding, which represents the
information for an extensible scope of context instead of a single token. By
leveraging such compact input units of higher information density, the LLM can
access to a vast scope of context even with a small context window. Extensible
embedding is systematically optimized in architecture and training method,
which leads to multiple advantages. 1) High flexibility of context extension,
which flexibly supports ad-hoc extension of diverse context lengths. 2) Strong
sample efficiency of training, which enables the embedding model to be learned
in a cost-effective way. 3) Superior compatibility with the existing LLMs,
where the extensible embedding can be seamlessly introduced as a plug-in
component. Comprehensive evaluations on long-context language modeling and
understanding tasks verify extensible embedding as an effective, efficient,
flexible, and compatible method to extend the LLM's context. | [
-0.265227735042572,
-0.7740320563316345,
0.4612710475921631,
0.06600648164749146,
-0.5282287001609802,
-0.01300754677504301,
-0.7393847703933716,
-0.5937126278877258,
0.35900163650512695,
0.3589451014995575,
0.06470052152872086,
-0.5084684491157532,
-0.6890608072280884,
-0.3766143023967743,
-0.30483344197273254,
0.38646918535232544,
-0.11872188746929169,
-0.2113494724035263,
-0.07935091108083725,
-0.4439203143119812,
-0.3491092920303345,
-0.46595045924186707,
-0.4245907664299011,
-0.14240337908267975,
0.10749712586402893,
0.2926698625087738,
0.7095211148262024,
0.880643904209137,
0.0886555016040802,
0.1822822391986847,
-0.27196332812309265,
0.08176916092634201,
-0.44626501202583313,
0.1350095123052597,
-0.37765228748321533,
-0.3952833116054535,
-0.37942105531692505,
-0.23594944179058075,
0.8951206803321838,
0.8785576820373535,
-0.07583659142255783,
0.0258160587400198,
0.30449721217155457,
0.5378937125205994,
-0.7469322085380554,
0.472873330116272,
-0.6618250012397766,
-0.2241162210702896,
0.05528508871793747,
-0.0659986361861229,
-0.4674937129020691,
-0.2726638615131378,
0.4012225568294525,
-0.21908819675445557,
-0.23692645132541656,
0.08211780339479446,
0.6743627190589905,
0.013191541656851768,
-0.5873794555664062,
-0.3846280872821808,
-0.4861339032649994,
0.7564972043037415,
-0.5740095376968384,
0.7674610614776611,
0.13461905717849731,
0.5409368276596069,
-0.0003773221105802804,
-0.565884530544281,
-0.2354399710893631,
-0.2126617282629013,
0.052054405212402344,
-0.2284189909696579,
-0.09855465590953827,
0.03457570821046829,
0.23210939764976501,
0.5839571952819824,
-0.40624701976776123,
0.1290414035320282,
-0.08340348303318024,
-0.04249957576394081,
0.1922846883535385,
-0.3294879198074341,
0.1089591234922409,
-0.07420903444290161,
-0.48282045125961304,
0.020154030993580818,
-1.1823614835739136,
-0.03958658128976822,
0.0992528572678566,
0.5558328032493591,
-0.14591892063617706,
0.47205850481987,
-0.03505139797925949,
0.6856407523155212,
-0.01456600520759821,
0.026633914560079575,
0.4127492606639862,
-0.09970172494649887,
-0.3133430480957031,
-0.06541299819946289,
0.11097362637519836,
0.004962719976902008,
-0.11151502281427383,
-0.25124886631965637,
-0.20367968082427979,
-0.5180485844612122,
0.09729072451591492,
-0.8142792582511902,
0.2525700330734253,
0.255860298871994,
-0.36897099018096924,
0.27297717332839966,
0.07425523549318314,
-0.3198300004005432,
0.10478698462247849,
-0.2558510899543762,
0.45553144812583923,
-0.5672870874404907,
-0.19849893450737,
0.11115576326847076,
-0.03467097505927086,
0.3104020655155182,
0.41573280096054077,
-0.8214520215988159,
-0.09440694749355316,
0.7363585829734802,
0.8597923517227173,
-0.23042573034763336,
-0.1373203843832016,
-0.5062984228134155,
0.7409728169441223,
-0.09118913859128952,
0.2684590220451355,
-0.6723098158836365,
-0.5726052522659302,
0.4455350637435913,
0.24699248373508453,
0.2814658582210541,
-0.6119787693023682,
0.46894872188568115,
-0.7059803009033203,
-0.16358880698680878,
-0.2406122237443924,
-0.79478520154953,
-0.548478364944458,
0.5203032493591309,
-0.7505271434783936,
0.9580309987068176,
0.37859204411506653,
-0.3296341001987457,
0.4783669114112854,
-0.4305408298969269,
-0.35183921456336975,
0.29472482204437256,
-0.10869234800338745,
-0.11320027709007263,
0.2997639775276184,
0.3400989770889282,
0.500348687171936,
0.009489853866398335,
0.4597344398498535,
-0.29716166853904724,
-0.42768532037734985,
-0.2602660357952118,
-0.3401958644390106,
0.3377732038497925,
-0.06905701011419296,
-0.5955978035926819,
0.01498442143201828,
-0.4903110861778259,
-0.05281629413366318,
-0.1265588104724884,
-0.7232049107551575,
-0.7222392559051514,
-0.18965215981006622,
0.20160067081451416,
0.17241740226745605,
0.4461195170879364,
-0.5164259076118469,
0.33192169666290283,
-0.5582839846611023,
0.12305682897567749,
0.5489324331283569,
-0.26580554246902466,
0.6348251104354858,
-0.10684759169816971,
0.23924985527992249,
0.006069832481443882,
-0.01891731470823288,
-0.31371966004371643,
-0.22349956631660461,
-0.6776164770126343,
-0.7300711274147034,
0.11218176037073135,
0.2049710899591446,
-0.5956419110298157,
0.884645402431488,
-0.7797993421554565,
-0.30502909421920776,
-0.26330485939979553,
0.055489588528871536,
0.39991405606269836,
0.13231325149536133,
0.4770563840866089,
-0.295980840921402,
-0.4628791809082031,
-0.9524209499359131,
-0.24587711691856384,
0.012563788332045078,
0.14804138243198395,
0.5664004683494568,
0.42501044273376465,
-0.3196669816970825,
0.960796058177948,
-0.4888037145137787,
-0.18688251078128815,
-0.4196561872959137,
-0.3111295700073242,
0.22098074853420258,
0.5210340023040771,
0.2825615704059601,
-0.643054187297821,
-0.4307853579521179,
-0.025529656559228897,
-0.49088528752326965,
0.37542620301246643,
0.15283042192459106,
-0.06686823070049286,
0.2806151509284973,
0.5913107991218567,
-0.39818665385246277,
0.2911221981048584,
0.7112076878547668,
-0.1251368522644043,
0.40466028451919556,
-0.30169135332107544,
-0.017656808719038963,
-1.1940888166427612,
0.1847449243068695,
-0.3515535295009613,
-0.7358170747756958,
-0.4457360804080963,
0.5140798091888428,
0.3935225009918213,
-0.14609213173389435,
-0.4668312668800354,
0.9046006202697754,
-0.7072772979736328,
-0.04542551562190056,
-0.440317302942276,
0.3444434106349945,
-0.1109299436211586,
0.26361146569252014,
0.1125853955745697,
0.5271934270858765,
0.593730628490448,
-0.451407790184021,
0.08000876754522324,
0.23991447687149048,
-0.6490980386734009,
0.2263592928647995,
-0.5141814947128296,
-0.03247004747390747,
-0.11105530709028244,
0.550593376159668,
-0.8206748366355896,
0.022359758615493774,
-0.08499091863632202,
-0.07506057620048523,
0.7009561657905579,
-0.42839694023132324,
-0.41035398840904236,
-0.0422494038939476,
-0.4656883478164673,
0.5423446893692017,
0.546607255935669,
-1.1772369146347046,
0.6283314228057861,
0.45820459723472595,
-0.2699865400791168,
-0.6086137890815735,
-0.6485773921012878,
0.16587674617767334,
-0.12327462434768677,
-0.3781398832798004,
0.4578053057193756,
0.21241751313209534,
0.28718292713165283,
0.1627126783132553,
0.057266268879175186,
0.21884119510650635,
-0.13529011607170105,
0.17796774208545685,
0.03155163675546646,
-0.17121687531471252,
0.34686774015426636,
0.2779403626918793,
-0.10155177861452103,
-0.35683318972587585,
-0.4925471842288971,
0.5964650511741638,
-0.05115228518843651,
-0.6938723921775818,
0.005434240214526653,
0.7092732191085815,
0.5907807350158691,
-0.16892282664775848,
0.8868339657783508,
0.34841883182525635,
-0.635724663734436,
-0.23782233893871307,
-0.7094869613647461,
0.01961197331547737,
-0.4832717180252075,
0.7006108164787292,
-0.3486127257347107,
-1.6443592309951782,
0.4249706268310547,
-0.38807520270347595,
0.1285932958126068,
0.004616097547113895,
0.6272911429405212,
0.5089691281318665,
0.6959056854248047,
0.7321392297744751,
-0.24069252610206604,
0.5504627823829651,
-0.10971936583518982,
0.32697322964668274,
-1.1808274984359741,
-0.19958102703094482,
-0.1451968103647232,
-0.2044324427843094,
-0.4173440933227539,
-0.9086401462554932,
0.2493772655725479,
0.15907025337219238,
-0.17264674603939056,
0.378658652305603,
-0.3242434561252594,
0.2640194296836853,
0.2139795422554016,
-0.03142295032739639,
0.12973657250404358,
0.1158880814909935,
-0.07795656472444534,
0.19536025822162628,
-0.3139426112174988,
-0.4250805079936981,
0.9272469282150269,
0.6670205593109131,
0.8549776673316956,
0.5364530682563782,
0.6130311489105225,
-0.18335197865962982,
0.1953054517507553,
-1.0762652158737183,
0.3626447916030884,
-0.047222450375556946,
-0.6441171765327454,
-0.4616074562072754,
-0.08992619812488556,
-0.7753954529762268,
0.41952529549598694,
0.09763666987419128,
-1.0382097959518433,
0.21789325773715973,
0.15172907710075378,
-0.07315362244844437,
0.5214629173278809,
-0.4493052065372467,
0.37570661306381226,
0.029992131516337395,
-0.3590794503688812,
-0.348832905292511,
-0.2444627434015274,
0.043816059827804565,
-0.04574432969093323,
0.10797610133886337,
0.1505707949399948,
-0.3656052052974701,
0.6227589249610901,
-0.26889747381210327,
0.7225652933120728,
-0.40320008993148804,
-0.13494646549224854,
0.25351980328559875,
0.04586692526936531,
0.9663062691688538,
0.18003340065479279,
-0.17217205464839935,
-0.01542669627815485,
-0.18795758485794067,
-0.47996392846107483,
-0.7566806674003601,
1.0111632347106934,
-0.341916024684906,
-0.9453089237213135,
-0.05941836163401604,
-0.6423012614250183,
-0.42041492462158203,
0.16945470869541168,
-0.22694195806980133,
0.7112306952476501,
-0.2452973574399948,
0.5855163931846619,
0.4542255699634552,
-0.21524424850940704,
0.5058484673500061,
0.3116324543952942,
-0.29854345321655273,
-0.3041478395462036,
0.7094828486442566,
0.04102567210793495,
0.2508770227432251,
0.5057248473167419,
0.13405798375606537,
-0.5856949687004089,
-0.6874114871025085,
-0.30611422657966614,
0.3184666335582733,
-0.8829700946807861,
0.002279335865750909,
-0.7412406206130981,
0.033991724252700806,
-0.44286608695983887,
-0.4478852152824402,
-0.5668370723724365,
-0.501339852809906,
0.07921577244997025,
-0.3428375720977783,
0.2916194498538971,
0.39497774839401245,
0.029826823621988297,
0.29751160740852356,
-0.8216119408607483,
-0.3254891633987427,
0.29415658116340637,
0.44408532977104187,
0.47596076130867004,
-0.5651140213012695,
-0.6202237606048584,
-0.24625539779663086,
0.00877884030342102,
-0.5065187811851501,
0.33945420384407043,
0.25032666325569153,
0.5928888320922852,
0.6071362495422363,
-0.27090689539909363,
0.7255240678787231,
-0.7481726408004761,
0.7996625900268555,
0.036502376198768616,
-1.080816388130188,
0.21332883834838867,
-0.2330310046672821,
0.4056898057460785,
0.6136649250984192,
0.42323756217956543,
-0.3098825216293335,
-0.023667536675930023,
-0.19300802052021027,
-1.2628546953201294,
0.22819998860359192,
-0.2044043242931366,
0.5420875549316406,
-0.3102787733078003,
0.4053323566913605,
0.3781451880931854,
0.053142186254262924,
-0.4377453625202179,
-0.16562433540821075,
0.09770170599222183,
0.09553216397762299,
-0.2177078127861023,
-0.5346277356147766,
0.00367227615788579,
-0.35422489047050476,
0.674645721912384,
-0.3360019624233246,
0.4230152368545532,
0.0891106128692627,
-0.4774305522441864,
0.2539190649986267,
0.4290536344051361,
0.27851420640945435,
0.8409609794616699,
-0.3308030366897583,
0.31229832768440247,
0.35895898938179016,
-0.29023468494415283,
0.08899950236082077,
-0.012671218253672123,
0.23207877576351166,
0.06716746836900711,
0.32425007224082947,
0.8196167945861816,
0.5265053510665894,
-0.5022494792938232,
0.7631050944328308,
0.36511895060539246,
0.2925586402416229,
-0.3177805542945862,
-0.2227281779050827,
0.40176254510879517,
0.2612740993499756,
0.3737930357456207,
-0.6214320063591003,
0.2457725554704666,
-0.6689428687095642,
0.4786354899406433,
0.726700484752655,
-0.7060946226119995,
-0.17480146884918213,
0.1311189830303192,
0.09330154955387115,
0.05864160507917404,
0.40207400918006897,
-0.1273161768913269,
-0.5205316543579102,
0.10013522207736969,
0.9927650094032288,
0.6963052153587341,
-0.24249063432216644,
-0.1472541093826294,
0.4354610741138458,
0.05246562883257866,
-0.05337882041931152,
0.19479334354400635,
-0.1546775996685028,
-0.3579849600791931,
-0.4454743266105652,
-0.5265047550201416,
-0.387847900390625,
0.02638726308941841,
-0.7489013075828552,
0.3118654191493988,
-0.33361348509788513,
0.0504879429936409,
-0.6326352953910828,
-0.22164791822433472,
-0.6481387615203857,
0.18647560477256775,
0.02399270050227642,
1.4295377731323242,
-0.5315486192703247,
0.9018236994743347,
0.7748029232025146,
-0.01091782283037901,
-0.8382160067558289,
0.15898104012012482,
-0.2559424340724945,
-0.8864468336105347,
0.4980631172657013,
0.4116056561470032,
-0.05870271846652031,
0.05040200427174568,
-0.27910855412483215,
-1.0482282638549805,
1.2600878477096558,
0.2420884668827057,
-0.5299279689788818,
-0.2845562994480133,
-0.0609816275537014,
0.25267279148101807,
-0.45182356238365173,
0.31022340059280396,
0.2912933826446533,
0.35355088114738464,
0.2980789244174957,
-0.751324474811554,
0.7933904528617859,
0.04185614362359047,
0.22141873836517334,
0.2834409773349762,
-0.682519257068634,
0.3521951138973236,
0.028491435572504997,
-0.19659796357154846,
0.05302063748240471,
0.6994652152061462,
0.14807042479515076,
-0.24233488738536835,
0.5374534130096436,
0.6723219156265259,
0.6226353049278259,
-0.003919946029782295,
1.0973727703094482,
-0.4756852984428406,
0.5279512405395508,
0.9494063258171082,
-0.08831829577684402,
1.2214592695236206,
0.6610499024391174,
0.048663195222616196,
0.4290410280227661,
0.24610492587089539,
0.2267705798149109,
0.6275086402893066,
0.280977725982666,
-0.5487422943115234,
-0.25792044401168823,
-0.09508969634771347,
-0.5287736058235168,
0.4339819550514221,
0.527607262134552,
-0.4127671718597412,
-0.4441910982131958,
0.06411080807447433,
0.06344148516654968,
-0.44277408719062805,
-0.1571475714445114,
0.41079533100128174,
0.298907071352005,
-0.4717528820037842,
0.5013628602027893,
0.13987179100513458,
0.9227690696716309,
-0.6732410192489624,
0.08299622684717178,
0.07263465225696564,
0.05911862850189209,
-0.1099083423614502,
-0.6412175893783569,
0.38826605677604675,
-0.45408186316490173,
-0.09501736611127853,
-0.04301539435982704,
0.5413641929626465,
-0.6562785506248474,
-0.10737989097833633,
0.5418167114257812,
0.6803327798843384,
0.10770163685083389,
-0.041636839509010315,
-0.3790983259677887,
0.10801657289266586,
-0.21632452309131622,
-0.4279036521911621,
0.558906078338623,
0.12075860798358917,
-0.1986854076385498,
0.6205921769142151,
0.5841872096061707,
0.12189440429210663,
-0.1369507610797882,
0.0508759543299675,
1.090972661972046,
-0.6212965250015259,
-0.7203531265258789,
-0.7812869548797607,
0.3715752065181732,
0.026920242235064507,
0.15569983422756195,
0.6070091128349304,
0.7936315536499023,
0.5570498108863831,
-0.07063768059015274,
0.8302103877067566,
0.030218185856938362,
0.26875561475753784,
-0.4668867290019989,
0.75275057554245,
-0.7106053233146667,
0.10981214791536331,
-0.1983274221420288,
-1.0642380714416504,
-0.45242804288864136,
0.31042569875717163,
-0.3270881175994873,
0.15990376472473145,
0.7012558579444885,
0.6367396712303162,
-0.4452758729457855,
-0.20472481846809387,
0.5498328804969788,
-0.02086697705090046,
0.5956999659538269,
0.5848895907402039,
0.501609742641449,
-0.14856143295764923,
0.28371310234069824,
0.1567358374595642,
-0.5160455107688904,
-0.42953261733055115,
-1.002424716949463,
-0.9488797783851624,
-0.6331174373626709,
-0.2780592739582062,
-0.21501776576042175,
0.20785419642925262,
1.0729949474334717,
0.9278104901313782,
-0.653253436088562,
0.023500975221395493,
0.3896275758743286,
0.009916707873344421,
0.07427975535392761,
-0.1935253143310547,
0.9016848206520081,
-0.1761363297700882,
-1.0083950757980347,
0.5090699195861816,
0.6395450234413147,
-0.010476231575012207,
-0.10325641930103302,
0.002312326105311513,
-0.30644354224205017,
0.07467719167470932,
0.8838024139404297,
0.2024811953306198,
-0.6456634402275085,
-0.8941901326179504,
-0.2033970206975937,
0.040654368698596954,
-0.019786866381764412,
0.5772304534912109,
-0.7238698601722717,
0.5052242279052734,
0.5764773488044739,
1.092787504196167,
0.3745613098144531,
0.03953207656741142,
0.6060149669647217,
-0.8145194053649902,
0.2749006450176239,
-0.041431259363889694,
0.6261036992073059,
0.5066970586776733,
-0.41078484058380127,
0.16676008701324463,
-0.23027518391609192,
-0.3264322578907013,
-0.6010751724243164,
0.3968364894390106,
-1.0697025060653687,
-0.19265589118003845,
1.3393986225128174,
-0.6513561606407166,
-0.24491433799266815,
-0.14722619950771332,
-0.003155283397063613,
0.28025728464126587,
-0.4471319317817688,
0.5147045850753784,
0.7950700521469116,
-0.05662239342927933,
-0.012421110644936562,
-0.25894370675086975,
0.24201714992523193,
0.4346309304237366,
-0.5647889375686646,
0.07660795003175735,
0.2306595891714096,
0.32821837067604065,
0.1852354258298874,
0.23512385785579681,
-0.6060141921043396,
0.039216939359903336,
-0.33766305446624756,
-0.16753283143043518,
-0.401605486869812,
-0.18238486349582672,
-0.5296579003334045,
0.29246053099632263,
0.43938377499580383,
-0.16438300907611847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11572v1 | Cobra Effect in Reference-Free Image Captioning Metrics | 2024-02-18T12:36:23 | 2024-02-18T12:36:23 | Zheng Ma, Changxin Wang, Yawen Ouyang, Fei Zhao, Jianbing Zhang, Shujian Huang, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating the compatibility between textual descriptions and corresponding
images represents a core endeavor within multi-modal research. In recent years,
a proliferation of reference-free methods, leveraging visual-language
pre-trained models (VLMs), has emerged. Empirical evidence has substantiated
that these innovative approaches exhibit a higher correlation with human
judgment, marking a significant advancement in the field. However, does a
higher correlation with human evaluations alone sufficiently denote the
complete of a metric? In response to this question, in this paper, we study if
there are any deficiencies in reference-free metrics. Specifically, inspired by
the Cobra Effect, we utilize metric scores as rewards to direct the captioning
model toward generating descriptions that closely align with the metric's
criteria. If a certain metric has flaws, it will be exploited by the model and
reflected in the generated sentences. Our findings reveal that descriptions
guided by these metrics contain significant flaws, e.g. incoherent statements
and excessive repetition. Subsequently, we propose a novel method termed
Self-Improving to rectify the identified shortcomings within these metrics. We
employ GPT-4V as an evaluative tool to assess generated sentences and the
result reveals that our approach achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance.
In addition, we also introduce a challenging evaluation benchmark called Flaws
Caption to evaluate reference-free image captioning metrics comprehensively.
Our code is available at
https://github.com/aaronma2020/robust_captioning_metric | [
-0.3292962610721588,
-0.20973671972751617,
0.43944159150123596,
0.10596160590648651,
-0.6781911253929138,
-0.1297333538532257,
0.25947922468185425,
-0.497575044631958,
0.41193047165870667,
0.2539120018482208,
-0.3547070324420929,
-0.15274709463119507,
-0.3867805600166321,
0.319476455450058,
-0.28320881724357605,
1.1971091032028198,
-0.16338945925235748,
0.04253097251057625,
-0.634329617023468,
-0.3239438831806183,
-0.6745162010192871,
-0.3883248567581177,
0.010669266805052757,
0.17449112236499786,
0.6856651902198792,
0.26735126972198486,
0.8669549226760864,
0.9478768110275269,
1.0313546657562256,
0.17756269872188568,
0.31249693036079407,
0.2085351198911667,
-0.4116640090942383,
-0.0066115763038396835,
-0.09707695990800858,
-0.17522548139095306,
-0.09437038749456406,
0.06321726739406586,
0.7405528426170349,
0.1507551223039627,
0.03309250250458717,
0.19054678082466125,
-0.01575629599392414,
0.5881665349006653,
-0.7853779196739197,
0.3779686987400055,
-0.41440078616142273,
-0.07086750864982605,
-0.4149777591228485,
-0.649188220500946,
-0.12735822796821594,
-0.30268922448158264,
0.20762285590171814,
-0.5431816577911377,
0.2478809803724289,
0.3171231150627136,
1.4674253463745117,
0.7118541598320007,
-0.3014618158340454,
-0.23557507991790771,
-0.4701434075832367,
0.5300188064575195,
-0.6417458653450012,
0.11900907009840012,
0.04525545984506607,
0.33812594413757324,
-0.0463746003806591,
-0.86075758934021,
-0.6757252216339111,
-0.4754249155521393,
-0.1368601769208908,
0.47771167755126953,
-0.6856260895729065,
-0.19907386600971222,
0.1921466439962387,
0.5553414225578308,
-0.40833258628845215,
0.12371639162302017,
-0.5657728314399719,
-0.43193069100379944,
0.4262520968914032,
0.20261037349700928,
0.231134295463562,
-0.8289613127708435,
-0.6295863389968872,
-0.14745692908763885,
-0.6915122866630554,
0.1614387035369873,
0.34545260667800903,
0.1425400972366333,
-0.021976562216877937,
0.5837041735649109,
-0.2269131988286972,
0.5117546319961548,
-0.22492177784442902,
0.28840190172195435,
0.33277013897895813,
-0.7035266757011414,
-0.2426265925168991,
-0.38001933693885803,
0.9229688048362732,
0.6428805589675903,
0.31431591510772705,
-0.32485532760620117,
0.030397992581129074,
0.3973428010940552,
0.4407461881637573,
-0.8698148131370544,
-0.30880141258239746,
-0.09047865122556686,
-0.42597439885139465,
-0.42719873785972595,
0.42631345987319946,
-0.5385716557502747,
-0.5524197816848755,
-0.09609987586736679,
0.31047794222831726,
-0.3829326629638672,
0.011249740608036518,
-0.1455017328262329,
-0.18879282474517822,
0.34755560755729675,
0.06801581382751465,
-0.2174554467201233,
-0.02465399168431759,
0.06307783722877502,
0.9372013211250305,
-0.10202689468860626,
-0.3397751748561859,
-0.8378735780715942,
0.22037366032600403,
-0.37023255228996277,
1.1831845045089722,
-0.28995269536972046,
-0.2723765969276428,
-0.13570021092891693,
-0.16476354002952576,
0.22955244779586792,
-0.5071020126342773,
0.5793378949165344,
-0.24905341863632202,
0.11246411502361298,
-0.44515103101730347,
-0.2667641043663025,
-0.2372235208749771,
0.13952752947807312,
-0.8420069813728333,
0.7795594930648804,
0.10122719407081604,
-1.082053303718567,
0.39422860741615295,
-0.6291402578353882,
-0.3150031566619873,
0.21180978417396545,
-0.3296254277229309,
-0.8595696687698364,
0.1788780242204666,
0.46338263154029846,
0.3083387017250061,
-0.3349137604236603,
-0.04778553545475006,
-0.32490232586860657,
-0.4712497293949127,
0.6421424746513367,
-0.1259903907775879,
0.4294474422931671,
0.19043028354644775,
-0.3915331959724426,
0.4759470820426941,
-0.4498443007469177,
0.0886218473315239,
0.22897180914878845,
0.15133164823055267,
-0.36682263016700745,
-0.041965898126363754,
-0.2925516963005066,
0.1842549443244934,
0.011619489639997482,
-0.32821160554885864,
0.07092812657356262,
-0.1864130049943924,
0.4696296155452728,
0.8025697469711304,
0.2693973183631897,
0.19963623583316803,
-0.42830759286880493,
0.5466201901435852,
0.1977877914905548,
0.29142335057258606,
-0.5105555653572083,
-0.18470551073551178,
-0.9406158924102783,
-0.3519585430622101,
0.4017402231693268,
0.22509337961673737,
-1.0099208354949951,
0.13812604546546936,
-0.40701156854629517,
-0.5651564598083496,
-0.49597540497779846,
0.07742047309875488,
0.5393272638320923,
0.47920939326286316,
0.4269767701625824,
-1.0746097564697266,
-0.36688897013664246,
-1.080463171005249,
-0.08225459605455399,
-0.20075839757919312,
0.01996045932173729,
0.4221023917198181,
0.32884448766708374,
-0.12084385752677917,
0.8780097365379333,
-0.33747225999832153,
-0.6724950671195984,
0.14045646786689758,
0.07836288213729858,
-0.3402019143104553,
0.2331075221300125,
0.7199286818504333,
-0.37815630435943604,
-0.17659693956375122,
-0.3607669472694397,
-0.9255425333976746,
-0.11051986366510391,
-0.40927812457084656,
-0.11908305436372757,
0.19667868316173553,
0.47668248414993286,
-0.4607504606246948,
0.6189262866973877,
0.41502875089645386,
-0.07088149338960648,
0.7948176264762878,
-0.24905997514724731,
0.056022293865680695,
-0.5969696044921875,
0.15852490067481995,
0.245143860578537,
-0.1634175330400467,
-0.16134750843048096,
0.34695059061050415,
0.19746072590351105,
0.15587560832500458,
-0.5200554728507996,
0.19897356629371643,
-0.6757320761680603,
-0.2761152684688568,
-0.1374843865633011,
0.333601713180542,
-0.04046517238020897,
0.5143963098526001,
-0.23997078835964203,
0.7759849429130554,
0.5293465852737427,
-0.48934972286224365,
0.4162229895591736,
0.07943443953990936,
-0.4166605770587921,
0.6962275505065918,
-0.6959851980209351,
0.16085471212863922,
-0.23827871680259705,
0.2968054711818695,
-1.153917670249939,
-0.1393420398235321,
0.4614918529987335,
-0.39667072892189026,
0.04148454591631889,
0.2720826268196106,
-0.5828216075897217,
-0.7525514960289001,
-0.47335729002952576,
0.25027337670326233,
0.24559776484966278,
-0.20593367516994476,
0.28648096323013306,
-0.0815838873386383,
0.006730744615197182,
-0.6127708554267883,
-0.5147201418876648,
0.2188117653131485,
-0.291940301656723,
-0.360191285610199,
-0.025109559297561646,
-0.020897196605801582,
0.09074615687131882,
0.08623945713043213,
-0.3286561965942383,
0.051076553761959076,
-0.13266879320144653,
0.40786507725715637,
0.32064294815063477,
0.005602833814918995,
0.15430013835430145,
-0.19849304854869843,
-0.14521951973438263,
-0.02156350389122963,
-0.12469283491373062,
0.30952325463294983,
-0.6475472450256348,
-0.2347056269645691,
-0.8604483008384705,
-0.027286699041724205,
0.5004928112030029,
-0.643441379070282,
0.21377357840538025,
0.4765659272670746,
0.1955178827047348,
0.2731599807739258,
-0.35849469900131226,
-0.040599383413791656,
-0.4377588927745819,
0.29063329100608826,
-0.3159692585468292,
-0.5180760025978088,
0.4085667133331299,
0.029955575242638588,
-0.22184491157531738,
0.49716702103614807,
0.28481969237327576,
-0.3955434560775757,
0.5661730170249939,
0.564799964427948,
0.1548379510641098,
0.6394132971763611,
-0.39769843220710754,
0.06747326999902725,
-0.7735630869865417,
-0.16015762090682983,
-0.3378130793571472,
-0.32941940426826477,
-0.5029842853546143,
-0.37283405661582947,
0.2411995232105255,
-0.07897114008665085,
-0.18042276799678802,
0.2945560812950134,
-0.6350424885749817,
0.48875513672828674,
0.676853597164154,
-0.03523590415716171,
0.2692415714263916,
0.10917975753545761,
-0.18290963768959045,
-0.3154597878456116,
-0.5973709225654602,
-0.3748015761375427,
1.0244044065475464,
0.18083809316158295,
0.6637144088745117,
0.12820357084274292,
0.5610665082931519,
0.49537187814712524,
0.3821711838245392,
-0.7096796035766602,
0.43081578612327576,
-0.013744168914854527,
-0.22035449743270874,
-0.19172795116901398,
-0.5487561821937561,
-1.1593903303146362,
0.17491711676120758,
-0.21232156455516815,
-0.3383297324180603,
-0.04897547885775566,
0.1278746873140335,
-0.47722333669662476,
-0.12336412072181702,
-0.517715334892273,
0.9833757877349854,
-0.486192524433136,
-0.30712029337882996,
-0.023598164319992065,
-0.8370240926742554,
0.3421788513660431,
-0.047965843230485916,
0.06891272962093353,
-0.0630323514342308,
-0.00653073051944375,
0.5272893309593201,
-0.41611161828041077,
0.6106378436088562,
-0.11561957001686096,
0.21434161067008972,
0.4829522669315338,
0.2820165753364563,
0.2531545162200928,
-0.22437094151973724,
0.3059544265270233,
0.3637276887893677,
0.14009474217891693,
-0.5371712446212769,
-0.7465845942497253,
0.4133833646774292,
-0.8618713021278381,
-0.4911193251609802,
-0.6252720952033997,
-0.6050248146057129,
0.11326995491981506,
0.2669118642807007,
0.20303738117218018,
0.5103611946105957,
-0.04387541860342026,
0.1398962140083313,
-0.04516975209116936,
-0.43499496579170227,
0.5310482382774353,
0.4763643145561218,
-0.1577419489622116,
-0.6720645427703857,
0.9278154373168945,
0.22123213112354279,
0.3107806444168091,
-0.03877733275294304,
0.17901265621185303,
-0.4429883062839508,
-0.4625979959964752,
-0.7285850644111633,
0.544786810874939,
-0.563625693321228,
-0.6196032762527466,
-0.13034352660179138,
-0.006795120425522327,
-0.21755506098270416,
0.10025447607040405,
-0.17934948205947876,
-0.30503833293914795,
-0.12323165684938431,
0.040409911423921585,
0.12156245112419128,
0.6599650979042053,
0.010902168229222298,
0.4459141194820404,
-0.6174269914627075,
0.2738243043422699,
0.13389909267425537,
0.40007880330085754,
0.05306258797645569,
-0.41878122091293335,
-0.27984073758125305,
-0.01775873452425003,
-0.7273269295692444,
-0.7748809456825256,
0.2932112216949463,
0.12893815338611603,
0.4681580364704132,
0.42372751235961914,
0.3232179284095764,
1.033843994140625,
-0.4636586308479309,
0.9154333472251892,
0.509084939956665,
-1.004834771156311,
0.5913382768630981,
-0.39822229743003845,
0.3282684087753296,
0.26791179180145264,
0.09445949643850327,
-0.43322041630744934,
-0.7869267463684082,
-0.7392367124557495,
-0.7353517413139343,
0.3385963439941406,
0.4781337380409241,
0.3474944829940796,
0.008325807750225067,
0.37366682291030884,
-0.054596517235040665,
0.11263386160135269,
-1.0107862949371338,
-0.22498758137226105,
-0.7470636367797852,
0.06931411474943161,
0.022353706881403923,
-0.11088540405035019,
-0.06787044554948807,
-0.25327908992767334,
0.35703566670417786,
-0.2535202205181122,
0.3516930043697357,
0.36455070972442627,
-0.1656443476676941,
-0.026316339150071144,
0.15287216007709503,
0.6940101981163025,
0.587525486946106,
-0.011233516968786716,
0.09542056918144226,
-0.1510515660047531,
-0.09244818240404129,
-0.1161758154630661,
0.044632021337747574,
-0.16042593121528625,
0.17717339098453522,
0.2114800214767456,
0.7210046052932739,
-0.007701846770942211,
-0.5237497091293335,
0.8722951412200928,
-0.19658790528774261,
-0.00341307302005589,
-0.30618706345558167,
-0.14202278852462769,
-0.1956939399242401,
0.017619483172893524,
0.25833427906036377,
0.29750046133995056,
0.21747064590454102,
-0.48457273840904236,
0.29171720147132874,
0.42199620604515076,
-0.610447347164154,
-0.14345906674861908,
0.8061960935592651,
0.24088793992996216,
-0.0465087890625,
0.6551945209503174,
-0.20323778688907623,
-0.22808462381362915,
0.5971791744232178,
0.3321242034435272,
0.6294209957122803,
0.05633235722780228,
0.3370820879936218,
0.2855144739151001,
0.440552294254303,
0.2880830764770508,
0.05840715393424034,
-0.14724020659923553,
-0.5606833696365356,
-0.4111965298652649,
-0.28367316722869873,
-0.45612451434135437,
-0.1483907401561737,
-0.7251622676849365,
0.3645683228969574,
-0.4533237814903259,
-0.1465597152709961,
0.1612260788679123,
-0.24159111082553864,
-0.7214269638061523,
0.1457139253616333,
0.1387011706829071,
0.4180208146572113,
-0.6386630535125732,
0.7566612958908081,
0.5609268546104431,
-1.3175712823867798,
-1.1162151098251343,
0.15235264599323273,
-0.16898509860038757,
-0.6837265491485596,
0.49766793847084045,
0.4181034564971924,
-0.21124190092086792,
-0.06810799241065979,
-0.514642596244812,
-0.8471355438232422,
0.9557490348815918,
0.5426035523414612,
-0.32852694392204285,
0.05999811366200447,
0.16203618049621582,
0.7345226407051086,
-0.2681792676448822,
0.28825533390045166,
0.2667851746082306,
0.1792490929365158,
0.20588867366313934,
-1.0462497472763062,
0.22616595029830933,
-0.23358778655529022,
0.18292295932769775,
-0.07065767794847488,
-0.925385594367981,
0.6536656022071838,
-0.4588213264942169,
-0.4299897253513336,
0.5225885510444641,
0.8394891023635864,
0.08978290110826492,
0.22600816190242767,
0.4345927834510803,
0.4072487950325012,
0.8125654458999634,
-0.1448405534029007,
1.4427597522735596,
-0.10086148977279663,
0.40339502692222595,
1.1165326833724976,
-0.1729697436094284,
0.7671267986297607,
0.5284966230392456,
0.0005864941631443799,
1.074561357498169,
0.5182498693466187,
-0.37241750955581665,
0.6310825347900391,
0.5167125463485718,
0.2095075249671936,
-0.11954998970031738,
-0.2741880416870117,
-0.546497106552124,
0.7751415967941284,
-0.24329067766666412,
-0.39428502321243286,
-0.1886671632528305,
-0.10720768570899963,
-0.15220235288143158,
0.135190948843956,
-0.21146175265312195,
0.750396728515625,
0.010190702974796295,
-0.4533354640007019,
0.7116692662239075,
-0.3134424686431885,
0.5041294693946838,
-0.3562995493412018,
0.16592708230018616,
-0.30711162090301514,
0.1669139415025711,
-0.2585268020629883,
-0.699012279510498,
0.44689616560935974,
0.05192790552973747,
-0.08396239578723907,
-0.07916869968175888,
0.3917265832424164,
-0.040200915187597275,
-0.28550848364830017,
0.014288553968071938,
0.5420989990234375,
0.6095502972602844,
-0.0542323961853981,
-0.4769868552684784,
-0.0513923242688179,
-0.008427141234278679,
0.26423880457878113,
-0.06671831011772156,
0.29591307044029236,
-0.2591599225997925,
0.6617670059204102,
0.5180374979972839,
0.03665361925959587,
0.020096298307180405,
0.3235056698322296,
0.779216468334198,
-0.7300281524658203,
-0.672039270401001,
-0.8046159744262695,
0.538578450679779,
-0.20890872180461884,
-0.07308829575777054,
0.9265652894973755,
0.6601658463478088,
0.7804056406021118,
-0.19459852576255798,
0.8216907978057861,
-0.047526463866233826,
0.34042730927467346,
-0.24401794373989105,
0.6533126831054688,
-0.8147073984146118,
0.132195383310318,
-0.6415960192680359,
-1.0123201608657837,
-0.4741084575653076,
0.5532610416412354,
-0.22314342856407166,
-0.20323333144187927,
0.9125806093215942,
0.6502339839935303,
0.1513841450214386,
-0.1691214144229889,
0.1625792235136032,
0.05904266610741615,
0.3588032126426697,
0.4751697778701782,
1.145875334739685,
-0.5664655566215515,
1.1604293584823608,
-0.061935700476169586,
-0.0625724121928215,
0.05557319521903992,
-0.9424930810928345,
-0.5729147791862488,
-0.3962421715259552,
-0.5604482293128967,
-0.4383774399757385,
-0.14405246078968048,
0.21469786763191223,
0.4364820420742035,
-0.45890912413597107,
0.007556049153208733,
0.017832009121775627,
-0.12574522197246552,
-0.35312777757644653,
-0.20747044682502747,
0.49186813831329346,
-0.34615984559059143,
-0.47196584939956665,
-0.2670392096042633,
0.3437092900276184,
0.13984009623527527,
-0.4223317801952362,
-0.21741585433483124,
0.2570214867591858,
0.20150861144065857,
0.4351733326911926,
0.3024834394454956,
-1.0647696256637573,
-0.742246687412262,
0.0776335820555687,
-0.21459302306175232,
0.24848361313343048,
0.8028290867805481,
-0.9007521271705627,
0.7942843437194824,
0.020542580634355545,
0.4968094527721405,
0.47442835569381714,
0.24564392864704132,
0.3722113072872162,
-0.7989550232887268,
-0.003430726006627083,
-0.09591572731733322,
0.3730287551879883,
0.6492843627929688,
-0.025334620848298073,
0.6657487750053406,
0.4934699535369873,
-0.5038963556289673,
-0.8380922079086304,
0.24268989264965057,
-1.3126498460769653,
-0.03822153061628342,
1.183211088180542,
-0.18301726877689362,
-0.007515041157603264,
0.2846432328224182,
-0.4391498565673828,
0.36625173687934875,
-0.10216812044382095,
1.0943903923034668,
0.629199206829071,
-0.2967723608016968,
-0.18441332876682281,
-0.23129211366176605,
0.18160301446914673,
0.4554378092288971,
-0.8360824584960938,
-0.053802601993083954,
0.9054880738258362,
0.4928432106971741,
0.32722797989845276,
0.6310476660728455,
-0.27480998635292053,
0.6122836470603943,
0.03732636570930481,
0.28963422775268555,
-0.518337607383728,
-0.13048647344112396,
-0.22459420561790466,
0.03383837640285492,
-0.017147881910204887,
-0.5232053399085999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11571v1 | Ain't Misbehavin' -- Using LLMs to Generate Expressive Robot Behavior in Conversations with the Tabletop Robot Haru | 2024-02-18T12:35:52 | 2024-02-18T12:35:52 | Zining Wang, Paul Reisert, Eric Nichols, Randy Gomez | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Social robots aim to establish long-term bonds with humans through engaging
conversation. However, traditional conversational approaches, reliant on
scripted interactions, often fall short in maintaining engaging conversations.
This paper addresses this limitation by integrating large language models
(LLMs) into social robots to achieve more dynamic and expressive conversations.
We introduce a fully-automated conversation system that leverages LLMs to
generate robot responses with expressive behaviors, congruent with the robot's
personality. We incorporate robot behavior with two modalities: 1) a
text-to-speech (TTS) engine capable of various delivery styles, and 2) a
library of physical actions for the robot. We develop a custom,
state-of-the-art emotion recognition model to dynamically select the robot's
tone of voice and utilize emojis from LLM output as cues for generating robot
actions. A demo of our system is available here. To illuminate design and
implementation issues, we conduct a pilot study where volunteers chat with a
social robot using our proposed system, and we analyze their feedback,
conducting a rigorous error analysis of chat transcripts. Feedback was
overwhelmingly positive, with participants commenting on the robot's empathy,
helpfulness, naturalness, and entertainment. Most negative feedback was due to
automatic speech recognition (ASR) errors which had limited impact on
conversations. However, we observed a small class of errors, such as the LLM
repeating itself or hallucinating fictitious information and human responses,
that have the potential to derail conversations, raising important issues for
LLM application. | [
-0.07459047436714172,
-1.2594490051269531,
0.6251044273376465,
0.3469858467578888,
-0.18465043604373932,
0.4858420491218567,
-0.18542075157165527,
-0.6475096940994263,
0.712835431098938,
0.4464419186115265,
-0.5837612152099609,
-0.44658952951431274,
-0.5967206358909607,
0.12358783185482025,
-0.35939130187034607,
0.6988523602485657,
0.3131108283996582,
-0.3304749131202698,
0.05276089161634445,
-0.11616829037666321,
-0.3794337809085846,
-0.5364685654640198,
-0.6858853697776794,
-0.4205769896507263,
0.7799546718597412,
0.45765799283981323,
1.0178428888320923,
0.432873398065567,
0.3207642734050751,
0.48902812600135803,
-0.06208309531211853,
0.8085246086120605,
-0.6620069146156311,
0.25480538606643677,
0.08270680159330368,
-0.1879379004240036,
-0.5481972098350525,
-0.23969599604606628,
0.2978779673576355,
0.23929384350776672,
-0.2808997631072998,
-0.15908542275428772,
0.06105537712574005,
0.5301709175109863,
-0.36513838171958923,
0.2348846048116684,
-0.48146969079971313,
0.07904233783483505,
-0.025097284466028214,
-0.15475879609584808,
-0.3609755337238312,
-0.46180015802383423,
-0.10137125849723816,
-0.3106576204299927,
-0.5729861855506897,
-0.06501296907663345,
0.6936628222465515,
0.4870491623878479,
-0.4369311034679413,
-0.509482741355896,
-1.0936962366104126,
0.5477188229560852,
-0.6279460191726685,
-0.02235424518585205,
0.5092604756355286,
0.46655088663101196,
-0.4748515784740448,
-0.2016184777021408,
-0.908495306968689,
-0.47332268953323364,
0.006527932360768318,
0.0430150181055069,
-0.4573136568069458,
0.24070142209529877,
0.014792177826166153,
-0.05951373279094696,
-0.2814168632030487,
0.051946304738521576,
-0.26653018593788147,
-0.07311127334833145,
0.953497052192688,
0.453491747379303,
0.4357800781726837,
-0.3581429719924927,
-0.15113338828086853,
-0.2093643844127655,
-0.3366595208644867,
0.047416504472494125,
0.484784334897995,
0.43077757954597473,
-0.425950288772583,
0.8552465438842773,
-0.0568116120994091,
0.33002713322639465,
0.08815574645996094,
-0.05851629376411438,
0.17614130675792694,
-0.17460443079471588,
-0.2659572660923004,
-0.18175861239433289,
1.0901215076446533,
0.5981156826019287,
0.5941212773323059,
-0.08597732335329056,
-0.19958242774009705,
0.3239188492298126,
0.662695586681366,
-0.24072979390621185,
-0.17911450564861298,
0.29185736179351807,
-0.22331714630126953,
-0.6183182597160339,
-0.13054347038269043,
-0.6150304675102234,
-0.549385130405426,
-0.177186980843544,
0.5414186120033264,
-0.40445441007614136,
-0.025804199278354645,
-0.0327354371547699,
-0.027818825095891953,
0.03154835104942322,
0.5045293569564819,
-0.6226916909217834,
0.2076016068458557,
0.46107563376426697,
0.862430989742279,
0.012324641458690166,
-0.2028660625219345,
-0.547329306602478,
0.2578968107700348,
-0.583160400390625,
0.5548847317695618,
-0.6083242893218994,
-0.6588895320892334,
0.3312569856643677,
0.08137015998363495,
0.046887315809726715,
-0.42961975932121277,
0.32429736852645874,
-0.2686968147754669,
-0.020008550956845284,
0.12905380129814148,
-0.34182894229888916,
0.030317163094878197,
0.42442670464515686,
-0.1909937709569931,
0.8010937571525574,
-0.09345968812704086,
-0.24056151509284973,
-0.3437536656856537,
-1.0181052684783936,
-0.6659978032112122,
0.11820437014102936,
-0.2702791392803192,
-0.1582459956407547,
-0.0915897935628891,
-0.22374358773231506,
0.43352726101875305,
0.12921059131622314,
0.3139072060585022,
-0.4217686355113983,
-0.3049332797527313,
0.6609708070755005,
-0.290437787771225,
0.39613041281700134,
0.0016597240464761853,
-0.21302565932273865,
0.46406736969947815,
-0.49621790647506714,
0.03453189134597778,
0.27923139929771423,
-0.09713737666606903,
-0.055661652237176895,
0.11509222537279129,
-0.10854006558656693,
0.048517752438783646,
0.33480435609817505,
-0.638350248336792,
-0.06760045140981674,
-0.3429122567176819,
0.433481901884079,
0.8168802261352539,
-0.16397611796855927,
0.4176749587059021,
-0.7635555267333984,
0.5171709060668945,
-0.40620753169059753,
0.13554410636425018,
-0.01903463713824749,
-0.4475937783718109,
-0.7339404821395874,
-0.02212955243885517,
-0.3662099540233612,
0.852570116519928,
-0.8854309320449829,
0.7002223134040833,
-0.06934281438589096,
-0.7341682314872742,
-0.23915880918502808,
0.010336305014789104,
0.4150376617908478,
0.3336060047149658,
0.12888121604919434,
-0.09222009778022766,
-0.4150613844394684,
-0.6674537658691406,
-0.1834387183189392,
-0.7315834164619446,
-0.21129906177520752,
0.6915425658226013,
0.13395971059799194,
-0.5877072811126709,
0.7603509426116943,
-0.27595067024230957,
-0.2946610450744629,
-0.4194141924381256,
0.18481621146202087,
-0.18040618300437927,
0.2798367440700531,
0.2945156991481781,
-0.3824523687362671,
-0.45368197560310364,
0.01983175426721573,
-0.7070087790489197,
-0.2082781195640564,
-0.05730515345931053,
-0.29524487257003784,
0.5908930897712708,
0.38161349296569824,
-1.011033058166504,
0.5503819584846497,
0.4435802698135376,
-0.14010673761367798,
0.3062357008457184,
-0.17315952479839325,
0.22993601858615875,
-0.8687918782234192,
-0.25622496008872986,
-0.10513351857662201,
-0.27277666330337524,
-0.703736424446106,
-0.4608345627784729,
-0.41511279344558716,
-0.09738556295633316,
-0.5351682901382446,
0.5314265489578247,
0.058076705783605576,
-0.0076296646147966385,
-0.38763228058815,
0.3974120318889618,
-0.11747962981462479,
0.45336249470710754,
-0.02493259683251381,
0.4815523028373718,
0.1600590944290161,
-0.7177167534828186,
0.5455960631370544,
0.5095844268798828,
0.10671346634626389,
0.5745867490768433,
-0.8040859699249268,
0.4666300415992737,
0.04119984433054924,
0.32259368896484375,
-0.9365074038505554,
-0.5682095885276794,
0.6670156717300415,
-0.8083444833755493,
0.10184350609779358,
0.07523341476917267,
-0.6740179061889648,
-0.30698075890541077,
-0.3647424280643463,
-0.3281157612800598,
0.46553635597229004,
-0.2871279716491699,
0.9825140237808228,
0.7549583911895752,
-0.5057776570320129,
-0.3000245690345764,
-0.6583329439163208,
0.36566099524497986,
-0.28470370173454285,
-0.8849884271621704,
0.17031030356884003,
-0.1547371745109558,
-0.31703707575798035,
-0.2811228930950165,
0.1499098688364029,
0.05206778272986412,
-0.005486293695867062,
0.2839733958244324,
0.4521503746509552,
0.20591343939304352,
0.1306990534067154,
0.15769237279891968,
0.04787696897983551,
0.07038833945989609,
0.5811803936958313,
0.8467084169387817,
-0.21845006942749023,
-0.3597504198551178,
-0.7814132571220398,
0.21236616373062134,
0.7245516180992126,
0.44025862216949463,
0.2675938606262207,
0.5090419054031372,
-0.383504182100296,
0.06251300126314163,
-0.3449702262878418,
-0.32537075877189636,
-0.5840127468109131,
0.33303794264793396,
-0.036188993602991104,
-0.9300016760826111,
0.5133813619613647,
0.10022910684347153,
0.139568492770195,
-0.33331140875816345,
0.5287808775901794,
-0.6004783511161804,
0.8866244554519653,
0.677030086517334,
0.02928007021546364,
0.8352442383766174,
0.3456576466560364,
0.41772082448005676,
-0.5173671245574951,
-0.21713298559188843,
-0.480133980512619,
-0.43156546354293823,
-0.8114821314811707,
-0.5205128788948059,
0.27003830671310425,
-0.5765732526779175,
-0.5528393983840942,
0.271942138671875,
-0.18294787406921387,
0.4224541187286377,
0.3120235800743103,
0.18732963502407074,
0.1759498417377472,
-0.14425800740718842,
0.5224016904830933,
0.03557979315519333,
-0.43772798776626587,
-1.0795537233352661,
0.7492249011993408,
0.4855584502220154,
1.0124138593673706,
0.3020078241825104,
0.8244921565055847,
0.4855000078678131,
0.27201077342033386,
-0.9266237616539001,
0.7901425957679749,
-0.1904018372297287,
-0.2670135796070099,
-0.5822731256484985,
-0.46779850125312805,
-0.9677576422691345,
-0.05454466864466667,
-0.25620004534721375,
-1.2066950798034668,
-0.028529580682516098,
0.2855253219604492,
-0.3724362254142761,
0.16544221341609955,
-0.575836181640625,
0.6598128080368042,
-0.3017944097518921,
-0.24605846405029297,
-0.2709696888923645,
-0.8323512673377991,
0.2918504774570465,
0.22442908585071564,
0.2614850699901581,
-0.2907852232456207,
0.20346391201019287,
0.391385942697525,
-0.22283218801021576,
1.2543936967849731,
-0.06941840797662735,
-0.2414492964744568,
0.4357514977455139,
0.5968105792999268,
0.657783567905426,
-0.16460178792476654,
0.10553936660289764,
0.3189685046672821,
-0.06772448122501373,
0.022413870319724083,
-0.7876301407814026,
0.3533138036727905,
-0.8440544605255127,
-0.523976743221283,
-0.11919308453798294,
-0.5153584480285645,
-0.22331510484218597,
-0.07380104064941406,
-0.20002134144306183,
-0.019176797941327095,
-0.38294631242752075,
0.0892307311296463,
0.28291836380958557,
-0.5711848735809326,
0.30733317136764526,
0.48701921105384827,
-0.32534489035606384,
-0.32278844714164734,
0.9159700870513916,
-0.10442700982093811,
0.5801700949668884,
0.07761147618293762,
0.28039318323135376,
-0.22752325236797333,
0.25568482279777527,
-0.6007169485092163,
0.19736145436763763,
-0.5206305980682373,
-0.21429672837257385,
-0.9291340112686157,
-0.17116883397102356,
-0.25491711497306824,
-0.3542548716068268,
-0.5093187689781189,
-0.36024343967437744,
-0.20138931274414062,
0.00865517370402813,
0.5188925266265869,
0.8379926085472107,
-0.2873894274234772,
0.7343803644180298,
-1.0803914070129395,
0.40088552236557007,
0.24731968343257904,
0.07383633404970169,
-0.013926693238317966,
-0.5407204627990723,
0.16333860158920288,
0.2251574993133545,
-0.5662078857421875,
-0.9300444722175598,
0.6197776198387146,
0.21094200015068054,
0.2749616503715515,
0.2683590054512024,
0.2552255690097809,
0.5110585689544678,
-0.4621579051017761,
0.5678563117980957,
0.07118410617113113,
-0.9048096537590027,
0.6806042194366455,
-0.5700910091400146,
-0.08198978751897812,
0.2941336929798126,
0.011687787249684334,
-0.7361983060836792,
-0.7827315926551819,
-0.6025954484939575,
-0.8234780430793762,
0.7282130122184753,
0.29847627878189087,
0.7575390934944153,
-0.1273796260356903,
0.11723676323890686,
-0.26089778542518616,
0.34673991799354553,
-0.7056642174720764,
-0.25537583231925964,
-0.05642729997634888,
-0.37350255250930786,
0.029060350731015205,
-0.05108575150370598,
-0.2732382118701935,
0.19554565846920013,
0.42214706540107727,
-0.16934697329998016,
0.5163761377334595,
-0.15922124683856964,
0.06463827192783356,
-0.46892842650413513,
0.22644305229187012,
0.5039674043655396,
0.05284000188112259,
-0.1770358383655548,
-0.12075254321098328,
0.07525566965341568,
-0.24412937462329865,
-0.0893457680940628,
-0.21014152467250824,
0.20744019746780396,
-0.02083657495677471,
-0.10358428210020065,
0.6020128130912781,
0.1673712283372879,
-0.8401771783828735,
0.3545457422733307,
-0.177092045545578,
0.18289946019649506,
-0.4885769784450531,
0.36692461371421814,
0.19755437970161438,
0.4986354410648346,
0.03310804441571236,
-0.030042331665754318,
0.09301748871803284,
-0.7507990002632141,
0.10593412071466446,
0.49069297313690186,
-0.390430212020874,
-0.237442284822464,
0.22252382338047028,
0.4718453586101532,
-0.9805415272712708,
0.4766019582748413,
-0.2409728765487671,
-0.5548408627510071,
0.6770990490913391,
0.5552685260772705,
0.9139496684074402,
-0.19651944935321808,
0.574402928352356,
0.03089291602373123,
0.4238379895687103,
0.24889521300792694,
0.396514892578125,
-0.23009762167930603,
-0.9253830313682556,
-0.21989159286022186,
-0.2716621160507202,
-1.042125940322876,
-0.12303927540779114,
-0.3123399615287781,
0.3067932426929474,
-0.5326061248779297,
-0.3361460566520691,
-0.165217787027359,
-0.3604838252067566,
-0.33443042635917664,
-0.1818668693304062,
0.14871090650558472,
0.25480276346206665,
-0.7552928328514099,
0.5321201086044312,
0.6746447086334229,
-0.2116224765777588,
-0.5091284513473511,
0.03701223433017731,
0.1902509480714798,
-0.8757991790771484,
0.601123571395874,
0.1727171391248703,
-0.7396387457847595,
-0.2844766080379486,
-0.8689424395561218,
-0.5978338718414307,
0.7193644046783447,
0.26484766602516174,
-0.47317153215408325,
0.14990946650505066,
0.282438188791275,
0.6533218026161194,
-0.3598412275314331,
0.16919070482254028,
0.3378294110298157,
0.39089542627334595,
0.32371607422828674,
-1.1426414251327515,
-0.09871196001768112,
-0.29120129346847534,
-0.17355678975582123,
0.01188732124865055,
-0.923859179019928,
0.3478843569755554,
-0.2665887773036957,
-0.47618067264556885,
0.2348213791847229,
0.634056031703949,
0.6351645588874817,
0.6430272459983826,
0.48503804206848145,
0.10098826885223389,
0.843450665473938,
0.0326608344912529,
0.8218700289726257,
-0.25081154704093933,
-0.10739382356405258,
0.998141348361969,
-0.5512423515319824,
0.8850226402282715,
0.3246968686580658,
-0.09494615346193314,
0.4416040778160095,
0.33892160654067993,
0.3182528018951416,
0.08791887015104294,
0.23350070416927338,
-0.19136717915534973,
-0.3033009469509125,
-0.20637305080890656,
0.039232440292835236,
0.6019564270973206,
0.6935617923736572,
0.07359994202852249,
0.20493140816688538,
-0.09981968253850937,
0.08296426385641098,
0.2007201910018921,
0.14086738228797913,
0.9264430999755859,
0.27346208691596985,
-0.26919734477996826,
0.19849024713039398,
-0.163574680685997,
0.9707483649253845,
-0.47934505343437195,
-0.1125263124704361,
-0.11621668934822083,
-0.08185429126024246,
-0.13423363864421844,
-0.7522080540657043,
0.6066474318504333,
0.17321771383285522,
0.1407158523797989,
-0.1347694993019104,
0.8180884122848511,
-0.33745020627975464,
-0.2544146776199341,
0.49610549211502075,
0.5635373592376709,
0.3643074333667755,
0.1851198524236679,
-0.5504018068313599,
0.5503419041633606,
-0.12848946452140808,
0.025370171293616295,
0.2009623497724533,
0.5933375954627991,
0.0016600547824054956,
1.0964033603668213,
0.5858207941055298,
-0.23951871693134308,
-0.29778167605400085,
0.14716209471225739,
0.6723856925964355,
-0.745836615562439,
-0.4382593333721161,
-0.8555742502212524,
0.5783829689025879,
-0.07244716584682465,
-0.1391264945268631,
0.4589116871356964,
-0.08335589617490768,
0.43419942259788513,
0.1441144198179245,
0.6500438451766968,
-0.05811624974012375,
0.6393591165542603,
-0.16906246542930603,
0.7670639753341675,
-0.4676900804042816,
0.19102954864501953,
-0.6519206762313843,
-0.5850197076797485,
-0.18572762608528137,
1.0905086994171143,
-0.1600961983203888,
0.199928417801857,
0.15537665784358978,
0.8837926983833313,
0.29433006048202515,
0.172079399228096,
0.5830289125442505,
0.30633217096328735,
0.5303091406822205,
0.2783299684524536,
1.2444477081298828,
-0.14635059237480164,
0.6246422529220581,
-0.02134062349796295,
-0.21720795333385468,
-0.3884064257144928,
-0.6962249279022217,
-0.7091585397720337,
-0.23240919411182404,
-0.3382726311683655,
-0.5885441899299622,
0.20520952343940735,
1.1981829404830933,
0.3996312618255615,
-0.2511574327945709,
-0.4514709711074829,
0.08953946828842163,
0.3358745574951172,
0.39440497756004333,
-0.2568551301956177,
-0.03146545961499214,
-0.44888508319854736,
-0.8828797340393066,
0.654863715171814,
0.4958842694759369,
0.26605573296546936,
-0.1121058240532875,
-0.36953580379486084,
0.11282318085432053,
0.5111067891120911,
0.8295012712478638,
0.3748401403427124,
-0.5700762867927551,
-0.5231666564941406,
0.17136669158935547,
-0.1538548618555069,
0.11531315743923187,
0.2564599812030792,
-0.3932991623878479,
0.31033146381378174,
0.11913061141967773,
0.5938910245895386,
0.12938329577445984,
0.09821803867816925,
0.6558229327201843,
-0.48197275400161743,
-0.14027535915374756,
0.37248918414115906,
0.10978882759809494,
0.42793411016464233,
-0.4634064733982086,
0.30608293414115906,
-0.047530464828014374,
-0.7838444113731384,
-0.8592294454574585,
0.4362384080886841,
-1.0565967559814453,
0.053773440420627594,
1.1544160842895508,
0.037805646657943726,
-0.3797488212585449,
-0.1349455565214157,
-0.4458140432834625,
0.31818056106567383,
-0.8903381824493408,
1.1373811960220337,
0.583458662033081,
-0.636461615562439,
-0.04825939983129501,
-0.41469162702560425,
0.24778461456298828,
0.34377941489219666,
-0.8035579323768616,
0.30597418546676636,
0.7129834890365601,
-0.17123550176620483,
0.33697307109832764,
0.7432491779327393,
-0.09990822523832321,
0.17734912037849426,
-0.13400313258171082,
0.12287583202123642,
0.29546022415161133,
-0.3021651804447174,
-0.15789444744586945,
-0.26575082540512085,
-0.066233329474926,
-0.2553585171699524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11569v1 | Developing Autonomous Robot-Mediated Behavior Coaching Sessions with Haru | 2024-02-18T12:33:54 | 2024-02-18T12:33:54 | Matouš Jelínek, Eric Nichols, Randy Gomez | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | This study presents an empirical investigation into the design and impact of
autonomous dialogues in human-robot interaction for behavior change coaching.
We focus on the use of Haru, a tabletop social robot, and explore the
implementation of the Tiny Habits method for fostering positive behavior
change. The core of our study lies in developing a fully autonomous dialogue
system that maximizes Haru's emotional expressiveness and unique personality.
Our methodology involved iterative design and extensive testing of the dialogue
system, ensuring it effectively embodied the principles of the Tiny Habits
method while also incorporating strategies for trust-raising and
trust-dampening. The effectiveness of the final version of the dialogue was
evaluated in an experimental study with human participants (N=12). The results
indicated a significant improvement in perceptions of Haru's liveliness,
interactivity, and neutrality. Additionally, our study contributes to the
broader understanding of dialogue design in social robotics, offering practical
insights for future developments in the field. | [
-0.1681535840034485,
-0.8738070130348206,
0.47877708077430725,
0.15514801442623138,
-0.016369793564081192,
0.38221508264541626,
-0.13439996540546417,
-0.6003482937812805,
0.9398069381713867,
0.2146877944469452,
-0.7327924966812134,
-0.07250267267227173,
-0.3430721163749695,
0.2635315954685211,
0.08168995380401611,
0.41480767726898193,
0.2619473338127136,
0.1013621911406517,
0.43982869386672974,
-0.19928914308547974,
-0.7878418564796448,
-0.0007503015222027898,
-1.1645432710647583,
-0.6417372822761536,
0.627899169921875,
0.6554323434829712,
1.0617817640304565,
0.4991864264011383,
0.3743093013763428,
0.4470427632331848,
-0.08806503564119339,
0.31412652134895325,
-0.39108914136886597,
0.011577709577977657,
-0.10103552788496017,
-0.4366249740123749,
-0.6978539228439331,
0.10593456774950027,
0.5039635300636292,
0.5245631337165833,
-0.371182918548584,
0.23106199502944946,
0.234593465924263,
0.5771571397781372,
-0.23975172638893127,
0.3590841591358185,
-0.3098004460334778,
0.2868778705596924,
0.19686196744441986,
-0.01661376841366291,
-0.38453638553619385,
-0.3891373872756958,
-0.25809139013290405,
-1.0146199464797974,
-0.17512977123260498,
0.3501904308795929,
0.6407374143600464,
0.678500771522522,
-0.4394170343875885,
-0.3858829438686371,
-1.165928840637207,
0.5865485072135925,
-0.514138400554657,
-0.048332326114177704,
0.5999447107315063,
0.3156755864620209,
-0.5884610414505005,
-0.17371626198291779,
-0.7141256928443909,
-0.2042301446199417,
-0.15039853751659393,
0.09820825606584549,
-0.2561796009540558,
0.2890673577785492,
-0.16715463995933533,
0.0025456331204622984,
-0.09304261952638626,
0.07656272500753403,
-0.33696281909942627,
-0.0198797807097435,
1.0125398635864258,
0.4460119605064392,
0.28593894839286804,
-0.4564625322818756,
0.12933777272701263,
-0.3731288015842438,
-0.39345788955688477,
0.38871514797210693,
0.4598592221736908,
0.34693849086761475,
-0.3183695077896118,
0.4679684042930603,
-0.3852023780345917,
0.4359850585460663,
0.25829553604125977,
-0.41590651869773865,
0.06028183549642563,
-0.57422935962677,
0.01665065623819828,
0.12655508518218994,
0.8749049305915833,
0.5514392256736755,
0.5002972483634949,
0.17839477956295013,
-0.031212523579597473,
0.025150762870907784,
0.6962531805038452,
-0.509759783744812,
-0.33746105432510376,
0.013670036569237709,
-0.7869588732719421,
-0.6750167012214661,
0.12399153411388397,
-0.8352392911911011,
-0.716791033744812,
-0.3249798119068146,
0.6922595500946045,
-0.2263106256723404,
-0.33895590901374817,
0.07738596946001053,
-0.07769667357206345,
-0.0907600075006485,
0.6187613606452942,
-0.7373495697975159,
0.5346240401268005,
0.32052507996559143,
0.8904432654380798,
-0.02129307948052883,
-0.24348856508731842,
-0.6214072108268738,
0.22543185949325562,
-0.5697369575500488,
0.6795701384544373,
-0.4620126187801361,
-1.0051265954971313,
0.038704194128513336,
0.049760058522224426,
-0.16635555028915405,
-0.6563829779624939,
0.06571528315544128,
-0.005490921903401613,
-0.06824687868356705,
0.024584559723734856,
-0.17008790373802185,
0.030716130509972572,
0.3101258873939514,
-0.47308462858200073,
0.8597633838653564,
0.17802631855010986,
-0.06504137068986893,
0.2509769797325134,
-1.2975704669952393,
-0.7683048844337463,
0.1415119171142578,
-0.39894959330558777,
-0.3130812346935272,
-0.10512030124664307,
-0.22591632604599,
0.11196012794971466,
0.15978208184242249,
-0.14799128472805023,
-0.305041640996933,
-0.42164111137390137,
0.3375955820083618,
0.01707138493657112,
0.895343005657196,
0.003615360939875245,
-0.4800308644771576,
0.6816979646682739,
-0.38104018568992615,
0.033650267869234085,
0.1396421194076538,
-0.019299274310469627,
-0.1958238035440445,
0.09170695394277573,
-0.6022288203239441,
0.19854736328125,
0.04563358798623085,
-0.8791134357452393,
0.19639743864536285,
-0.12422976642847061,
0.4541133642196655,
1.0286012887954712,
0.30574145913124084,
0.6697775721549988,
-0.7442091703414917,
0.6896820068359375,
-0.6570136547088623,
0.6687703728675842,
0.17173728346824646,
-0.7889926433563232,
-0.7573447227478027,
-0.20077800750732422,
-0.298458456993103,
0.3768712282180786,
-0.7515798211097717,
0.5461035966873169,
-0.02643098309636116,
-0.4024485647678375,
-0.6685444116592407,
0.3129828870296478,
0.3542838394641876,
0.2282482087612152,
0.09670829772949219,
-0.4805249273777008,
-0.3932744860649109,
-0.5399237275123596,
0.06610395014286041,
-0.7187970876693726,
0.01196242868900299,
0.6048232913017273,
0.7247911095619202,
-0.316642165184021,
1.0090115070343018,
-0.4419098198413849,
-0.6959131956100464,
-0.34900131821632385,
0.2865735590457916,
-0.17033739387989044,
0.5706800818443298,
0.43346837162971497,
-0.5408409237861633,
-0.8417559862136841,
0.009408446028828621,
-0.5936164855957031,
0.5182890295982361,
-0.08156410604715347,
-0.3032192885875702,
0.15578672289848328,
0.4131370186805725,
-1.1261894702911377,
1.0225037336349487,
0.14156222343444824,
-0.601402759552002,
0.6641623973846436,
-0.3287335932254791,
0.5262645483016968,
-0.6164851188659668,
-0.3354147672653198,
-0.24797426164150238,
-0.2635756731033325,
-0.5015488862991333,
-0.4245862066745758,
-0.6265910267829895,
-0.23172280192375183,
-0.3566209375858307,
0.7594884634017944,
-0.08661329001188278,
-0.021849118173122406,
-0.39038026332855225,
-0.11744005978107452,
-0.10774612426757812,
0.5772972106933594,
-0.025078006088733673,
0.7368752360343933,
0.014347831718623638,
-0.7806041240692139,
0.3153945207595825,
0.7479817271232605,
-0.2703642249107361,
0.5811794996261597,
-0.9497098326683044,
0.15137934684753418,
0.25175419449806213,
0.4776206314563751,
-0.9327169060707092,
-0.4937485456466675,
0.7561025023460388,
-0.853118896484375,
-0.07291744649410248,
0.17920535802841187,
-0.7603646516799927,
-0.5364537835121155,
-0.3214462101459503,
-0.2423682063817978,
0.7327980995178223,
-0.2875531315803528,
0.5942192077636719,
0.6099969744682312,
-0.2981552183628082,
0.1511106789112091,
0.010088593699038029,
0.08451119065284729,
-0.2688295543193817,
-0.7089790105819702,
0.3292964994907379,
-0.3151303827762604,
-0.6302749514579773,
-0.021455589681863785,
-0.14525310695171356,
-0.05080287158489227,
0.2615726590156555,
0.2014394998550415,
0.1673862189054489,
0.2746674716472626,
-0.17094334959983826,
0.1891532987356186,
-0.17866744101047516,
0.24693575501441956,
0.3345720171928406,
0.6825557947158813,
-0.23680341243743896,
-0.1906009018421173,
-1.0476763248443604,
0.30499348044395447,
0.3008304238319397,
0.16948793828487396,
0.7297943234443665,
0.6323379874229431,
-0.17437462508678436,
-0.05864563211798668,
-0.016163265332579613,
-0.6270173788070679,
-0.6178215742111206,
-0.07681342959403992,
-0.02455081045627594,
-0.9226856827735901,
0.3700200021266937,
0.07847452163696289,
-0.06459180265665054,
-0.410749614238739,
0.5926432609558105,
-0.8317605257034302,
1.093614101409912,
0.8228117823600769,
0.15071816742420197,
0.9370478391647339,
-0.057949360460042953,
0.2016088217496872,
-0.7261516451835632,
-0.11456936597824097,
-0.39434555172920227,
-0.47999462485313416,
-0.4966816306114197,
-0.5098667144775391,
0.6050319075584412,
-0.5355072021484375,
-0.6214724183082581,
0.4003698229789734,
-0.4290412962436676,
0.37273108959198,
0.6209239363670349,
0.40593066811561584,
0.31947624683380127,
-0.5385801196098328,
0.32514622807502747,
0.04059873893857002,
-0.6693457961082458,
-0.5859182476997375,
0.6918544769287109,
0.1620764136314392,
0.6653499603271484,
0.37918031215667725,
0.8111643195152283,
0.8059130907058716,
0.2322317361831665,
-1.1749194860458374,
0.9769192934036255,
0.25933292508125305,
-0.869753897190094,
-0.8184534311294556,
-0.1766040325164795,
-1.2372990846633911,
0.25724107027053833,
-0.10345260053873062,
-1.1701788902282715,
0.050178609788417816,
0.40406334400177,
-0.7499591708183289,
0.05366133898496628,
-0.6883084774017334,
0.9470908641815186,
0.0017246007919311523,
-0.4231612980365753,
-0.7079651355743408,
-1.0167298316955566,
0.0878232792019844,
0.20444746315479279,
0.257407009601593,
-0.07282494008541107,
0.4324924349784851,
0.8562883138656616,
-0.43413206934928894,
1.3767199516296387,
-0.44784411787986755,
0.015397099778056145,
0.6944859623908997,
0.5045027732849121,
0.643967866897583,
0.09396563470363617,
0.18258365988731384,
-0.20713455975055695,
-0.02434336580336094,
-0.2791743278503418,
-0.8169646859169006,
-0.13580194115638733,
-0.9170656204223633,
-0.6754744052886963,
-0.2476174682378769,
-0.596170961856842,
-0.2375643402338028,
0.3831508457660675,
-0.2815474271774292,
0.04007804021239281,
-0.3472478687763214,
0.31070268154144287,
0.590877890586853,
-0.18469104170799255,
0.508315920829773,
0.635086715221405,
-0.24678310751914978,
-0.06459402292966843,
0.782233476638794,
-0.1776590347290039,
0.3546259105205536,
0.031543437391519547,
0.6662697196006775,
0.12857158482074738,
0.010220332071185112,
-0.2867952585220337,
0.18445228040218353,
-0.22670623660087585,
-0.05843668431043625,
-0.2407509833574295,
0.10404621809720993,
-0.6049095392227173,
-0.24115729331970215,
-0.7652977108955383,
-0.3370150923728943,
-0.08084780722856522,
0.03188103437423706,
0.27543798089027405,
1.0132211446762085,
-0.3080000579357147,
0.8903113603591919,
-0.627001941204071,
0.2935762405395508,
0.2935330867767334,
-0.12330733239650726,
0.15297873318195343,
-0.5099226236343384,
-0.29469162225723267,
0.11644025146961212,
-0.35620179772377014,
-0.7251431345939636,
0.3627893924713135,
0.003419953864067793,
0.5242257714271545,
0.40343257784843445,
0.3920523524284363,
0.5857890248298645,
-0.4862752854824066,
0.8582006096839905,
0.18705222010612488,
-0.5558475255966187,
0.7256590127944946,
-0.8502171635627747,
0.08189933001995087,
0.7152849435806274,
0.1767456978559494,
-0.4736292064189911,
-0.3253312408924103,
-0.6967480778694153,
-0.2521183490753174,
0.725604236125946,
0.3425920903682709,
0.3231309652328491,
0.07345446944236755,
0.1173391193151474,
-0.056423403322696686,
0.47808918356895447,
-0.5213618874549866,
-0.200156569480896,
-0.116264708340168,
-0.11181981861591339,
0.09128133207559586,
0.1456209272146225,
-0.46230459213256836,
-0.6050620675086975,
0.6049258708953857,
-0.25001630187034607,
0.8736621141433716,
0.051982372999191284,
0.20562897622585297,
-0.36195439100265503,
0.09327927976846695,
0.4612460732460022,
0.2876014709472656,
-0.1552107036113739,
-0.4190240502357483,
-0.08486045897006989,
-0.39512598514556885,
0.20150066912174225,
-0.5749743580818176,
-0.11659915000200272,
0.06367135792970657,
0.05640226602554321,
0.4267791509628296,
0.35885104537010193,
-0.3693404197692871,
0.3070443868637085,
-0.012540926225483418,
-0.27461758255958557,
-0.6426132321357727,
0.6796102523803711,
-0.09547979384660721,
0.2470792829990387,
-0.05088387429714203,
0.29299336671829224,
0.16019906103610992,
-0.7854495048522949,
0.12468356639146805,
0.3625449240207672,
-0.5335282683372498,
-0.5286547541618347,
0.5400056838989258,
0.7260352373123169,
-1.1190564632415771,
0.600757896900177,
-0.6074174642562866,
-0.25650089979171753,
0.48460251092910767,
0.355874240398407,
0.6883386373519897,
-0.26821255683898926,
0.981292188167572,
0.290801465511322,
0.29855671525001526,
0.07936112582683563,
0.14625076949596405,
-0.7445593476295471,
-1.1785376071929932,
-0.16513341665267944,
-0.1015358716249466,
-1.0052118301391602,
-0.2371111363172531,
-0.795630931854248,
0.0164340753108263,
-0.29970529675483704,
-0.3392227590084076,
0.04192451760172844,
0.1359434574842453,
-0.34455665946006775,
-0.12305700778961182,
-0.2440536916255951,
0.39415690302848816,
-0.5566387176513672,
1.0167065858840942,
0.9102879166603088,
-0.346995085477829,
-0.8796988129615784,
-0.04065508395433426,
0.43519508838653564,
-1.0907469987869263,
0.690513551235199,
-0.10759320110082626,
-0.8082644939422607,
0.04696349799633026,
-0.7242834568023682,
-0.6299690008163452,
1.0674118995666504,
-0.244175985455513,
-0.014713224023580551,
-0.1563996523618698,
0.03963620588183403,
0.5178743004798889,
-0.4642651379108429,
-0.24197551608085632,
0.5181611180305481,
0.6380334496498108,
0.023244664072990417,
-1.216470718383789,
-0.26019611954689026,
-0.38875892758369446,
-0.15371347963809967,
0.014560136944055557,
-1.380303978919983,
0.39922475814819336,
-0.37127915024757385,
-0.06098862737417221,
0.5299575924873352,
0.6637420058250427,
0.28107750415802,
0.3789754807949066,
0.745924711227417,
-0.1628519892692566,
0.848682701587677,
0.3917829394340515,
0.774869978427887,
-0.20750774443149567,
0.07530803233385086,
1.3370448350906372,
-0.580798327922821,
0.5842705965042114,
0.5639808773994446,
-0.03390182927250862,
0.8042997717857361,
0.2719079554080963,
0.34688064455986023,
0.33350735902786255,
-0.03814588114619255,
-0.4914906322956085,
-0.31529736518859863,
-0.4444983899593353,
0.23746062815189362,
0.7766789197921753,
0.4430493116378784,
0.1344536542892456,
0.18347851932048798,
0.13152755796909332,
0.2970540523529053,
0.3044675886631012,
-0.24489474296569824,
0.7505424618721008,
0.15617971122264862,
-0.6413348913192749,
-0.13765504956245422,
-0.18162165582180023,
0.6285879611968994,
-0.5516000986099243,
-0.09972666203975677,
-0.0427478551864624,
0.42948073148727417,
-0.08630308508872986,
-0.6942654848098755,
0.3258521258831024,
-0.11164578050374985,
0.35714390873908997,
-0.6797019243240356,
0.8963550329208374,
0.103400819003582,
-0.040798213332891464,
0.19340188801288605,
0.6672322750091553,
0.22015200555324554,
0.21040283143520355,
-0.7611732482910156,
0.11552616208791733,
-0.0011669829254969954,
-0.13479255139827728,
0.42079660296440125,
0.24519988894462585,
0.0919317975640297,
0.9649114012718201,
0.18842126429080963,
-0.25726208090782166,
-0.2533450126647949,
-0.03030920960009098,
0.6110088229179382,
-0.7750716805458069,
-0.7864980697631836,
-0.4958820044994354,
0.5040332674980164,
-0.25765007734298706,
-0.2982777953147888,
1.0558297634124756,
0.12211790680885315,
0.6936842799186707,
-0.1328670233488083,
0.5524742007255554,
-0.5106826424598694,
0.47531449794769287,
-0.24983559548854828,
0.8665610551834106,
-0.31480085849761963,
-0.29588842391967773,
-0.40179213881492615,
-0.5162222981452942,
-0.024940546602010727,
1.3661096096038818,
-0.11378363519906998,
0.08207298815250397,
0.670762300491333,
0.7968572974205017,
0.4279516041278839,
0.19089530408382416,
0.3699609935283661,
0.13418683409690857,
0.5198084712028503,
-0.008214025758206844,
1.0940366983413696,
-0.11116579920053482,
0.4902704954147339,
-0.39089640974998474,
-0.2499866634607315,
-0.26495304703712463,
-0.4570857584476471,
-1.0104656219482422,
-0.3730103373527527,
-0.4952585995197296,
-0.4897765517234802,
0.3526962995529175,
1.257407546043396,
0.9005681276321411,
-0.2537291944026947,
-0.6827974915504456,
-0.18120844662189484,
0.15153856575489044,
-0.19153662025928497,
-0.26645687222480774,
-0.2181726098060608,
-0.24651750922203064,
-0.7017725706100464,
0.6946369409561157,
0.15615041553974152,
-0.019734296947717667,
-0.11791391670703888,
-0.5417325496673584,
-0.12257169932126999,
0.04702450707554817,
0.8114845156669617,
0.5282444357872009,
-0.2538343071937561,
-0.8656728863716125,
0.42046642303466797,
0.18246054649353027,
0.2746777832508087,
0.8796911835670471,
-0.4806922972202301,
0.30479100346565247,
-0.03632427379488945,
0.1564142405986786,
0.4130825698375702,
0.16841508448123932,
0.6327934265136719,
-0.32593148946762085,
0.22355535626411438,
0.28942587971687317,
-0.017727574333548546,
-0.015624615363776684,
-0.386514276266098,
0.78266441822052,
0.30615946650505066,
-0.8057254552841187,
-0.7836023569107056,
0.48977571725845337,
-1.130515694618225,
-0.05172857642173767,
1.2843677997589111,
0.06291190534830093,
-0.4644985496997833,
-0.3955768942832947,
-0.5238812565803528,
0.16488298773765564,
-0.7976822257041931,
0.9222763180732727,
0.6839529871940613,
-1.04746413230896,
0.06632862985134125,
-0.634488582611084,
0.46445533633232117,
0.3528383672237396,
-0.6960577964782715,
-0.11721806973218918,
0.4142502248287201,
0.03860156983137131,
0.3151935935020447,
1.1299769878387451,
0.04806453734636307,
0.3411202132701874,
0.4000650942325592,
0.13001611828804016,
0.013733371160924435,
-0.5488557815551758,
0.13297002017498016,
-0.37228700518608093,
0.08022120594978333,
-0.3050559163093567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11550v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11550v2 | LongAgent: Scaling Language Models to 128k Context through Multi-Agent Collaboration | 2024-02-18T11:46:52 | 2024-03-13T07:16:42 | Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Hao Xu, Yi Lu, Wei He, Yiwen Ding, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance in
understanding language and executing complex reasoning tasks. However, LLMs
with long context windows have been notorious for their expensive training
costs and high inference latency. Even the most advanced models such as GPT-4
and Claude2 often make mistakes when processing inputs of over $100k$ tokens, a
phenomenon also known as \textit{lost in the middle}. In this paper, we propose
\textsc{LongAgent}, a method based on multi-agent collaboration, which scales
LLMs (e.g., LLaMA) to a context of 128K and demonstrates potential superiority
in long-text processing compared to GPT-4. In \textsc{LongAgent}, a leader is
responsible for understanding user intent and directing team members to acquire
information from documents. Due to members' hallucinations, it is non-trivial
for a leader to obtain accurate information from the responses of dozens to
hundreds of members. To address this, we develop an \textit{inter-member
communication} mechanism to resolve response conflicts caused by hallucinations
through information sharing. Our experimental results indicate that
\textsc{LongAgent} offers a promising alternative for long-text processing. The
agent team instantiated with LLaMA-7B achieves significant improvements in
tasks such as 128k-long text retrieval, multi-hop question answering, compared
to GPT-4. | [
-0.4819231927394867,
-0.7124359011650085,
0.8680734038352966,
0.47932782769203186,
-0.22761112451553345,
0.10999920219182968,
-0.5726786255836487,
-0.8483113050460815,
0.5278362035751343,
0.6477034091949463,
-0.3676745593547821,
-0.22896476089954376,
-0.7254894971847534,
0.27567023038864136,
-0.19211973249912262,
0.9001713395118713,
-0.08810250461101532,
-0.29381829500198364,
-0.11902537941932678,
-0.3546941578388214,
-0.561127781867981,
-0.6791006326675415,
-0.779167115688324,
-0.47215554118156433,
0.8243959546089172,
0.36971932649612427,
0.9465429186820984,
0.5392009019851685,
0.49503952264785767,
0.44032803177833557,
0.08749563992023468,
0.3377036154270172,
-0.8839365839958191,
0.42665040493011475,
-0.3406512141227722,
-0.3145730197429657,
-0.9336475133895874,
-0.1464422345161438,
0.6741721034049988,
0.4256213307380676,
-0.16932648420333862,
-0.19327685236930847,
0.12883776426315308,
0.5774409770965576,
-0.31054624915122986,
0.37306293845176697,
-0.4812313914299011,
-0.2003501057624817,
-0.0642482191324234,
-0.2890065610408783,
-0.5812075734138489,
0.1539561152458191,
0.05975087359547615,
-0.6292880177497864,
-0.1273048371076584,
-0.07548926770687103,
0.3780560791492462,
0.2932174503803253,
-0.38874414563179016,
-0.26179996132850647,
-0.7027994394302368,
0.6684816479682922,
-0.4141351580619812,
0.20886901021003723,
0.523009181022644,
0.33201560378074646,
-0.3991956412792206,
-0.689980685710907,
-0.502518355846405,
-0.20314475893974304,
0.1352527141571045,
0.0251363106071949,
-0.14121197164058685,
0.28906694054603577,
0.13923217356204987,
-0.08395940065383911,
-0.3835735023021698,
0.1134532168507576,
-0.26615673303604126,
-0.11737014353275299,
0.55014967918396,
0.1736227571964264,
-0.008938387967646122,
0.2903158664703369,
-0.37106040120124817,
-0.12528599798679352,
-0.2656194865703583,
-0.2160787433385849,
0.028070710599422455,
0.2968329191207886,
0.04610929265618324,
0.458379864692688,
-0.12502877414226532,
0.36851707100868225,
0.022469433024525642,
-0.03425615280866623,
0.23245663940906525,
-0.3752882778644562,
-0.14699450135231018,
0.18321116268634796,
0.5822157263755798,
0.5299507975578308,
0.15356315672397614,
-0.4445430636405945,
-0.27805373072624207,
0.08143746852874756,
0.3633314371109009,
-1.0167280435562134,
0.13616888225078583,
0.06964246183633804,
-0.29297593235969543,
0.01668757013976574,
-0.28365275263786316,
-0.828011691570282,
-0.525175929069519,
-0.31229323148727417,
0.6472077369689941,
-0.34906166791915894,
-0.33122411370277405,
0.1731981784105301,
0.11113341897726059,
0.225357785820961,
0.7168409824371338,
-0.5526148080825806,
0.494895875453949,
0.7106379270553589,
1.0348764657974243,
-0.3757231533527374,
-0.8616538047790527,
-0.7204915285110474,
0.23405086994171143,
-0.3322603404521942,
0.728879988193512,
-0.357626348733902,
-0.21565958857536316,
-0.29400116205215454,
0.0030494043603539467,
0.10235584527254105,
-0.4544025957584381,
0.22822153568267822,
-0.49802058935165405,
-0.11615799367427826,
-0.24804532527923584,
-0.5174469947814941,
0.09116130322217941,
0.38007646799087524,
-0.807287871837616,
0.7850207090377808,
0.08246023207902908,
-0.6026127338409424,
-0.0029859081842005253,
-0.7525578141212463,
-0.1091490089893341,
0.18957282602787018,
-0.20286795496940613,
-0.1950865089893341,
-0.0898272693157196,
0.19231116771697998,
0.49766454100608826,
-0.33295515179634094,
0.23455467820167542,
-0.16993939876556396,
-0.619409441947937,
0.2352968156337738,
-0.43156325817108154,
0.30269432067871094,
0.0160025916993618,
-0.4112004041671753,
0.39179643988609314,
-0.5362464189529419,
-0.13506725430488586,
0.12497764825820923,
-0.46488893032073975,
-0.36235693097114563,
-0.09938202053308487,
-0.0027144774794578552,
0.08079604804515839,
0.41806939244270325,
-0.26152631640434265,
0.2673794627189636,
-0.12077751755714417,
0.34121066331863403,
0.9182748198509216,
-0.30659520626068115,
0.5221050977706909,
-0.3475271463394165,
0.41681191325187683,
-0.13991975784301758,
0.14614376425743103,
-0.08061875402927399,
-0.2983284592628479,
-0.6688421368598938,
-0.281610369682312,
-0.3533307909965515,
0.1584489494562149,
-0.7525815367698669,
0.3682050406932831,
-0.44997820258140564,
-0.33615028858184814,
-0.3740541338920593,
0.011818653903901577,
0.0932268425822258,
0.32365843653678894,
0.5258204936981201,
-0.20599934458732605,
-0.19157059490680695,
-0.8034445643424988,
-0.07709293067455292,
-0.22776448726654053,
-0.09066217392683029,
0.2990991473197937,
0.37521710991859436,
-0.557350218296051,
0.8883150219917297,
-0.2912702262401581,
-0.37305203080177307,
-0.3229069709777832,
0.13471873104572296,
0.06961770355701447,
0.22023360431194305,
0.2412572205066681,
-0.752302885055542,
-0.40857234597206116,
0.0720466896891594,
-0.6138430237770081,
-0.018581699579954147,
-0.017075669020414352,
-0.29888731241226196,
0.29002729058265686,
0.5776718854904175,
-0.7042051553726196,
0.3777250051498413,
0.8097042441368103,
-0.3883187472820282,
0.4622671902179718,
-0.2968233525753021,
0.2557467818260193,
-1.4895250797271729,
-0.21402181684970856,
-0.3034968674182892,
-0.5767021179199219,
-0.5989850163459778,
0.08666227757930756,
0.025212200358510017,
-0.03960372507572174,
-0.22025734186172485,
0.4041271507740021,
-0.5443834662437439,
0.012359506450593472,
-0.5351484417915344,
0.28024429082870483,
-0.06356460601091385,
0.6143783330917358,
-0.02807859517633915,
0.9607491493225098,
0.4505225419998169,
-0.2980055510997772,
0.5909087657928467,
-0.05366548150777817,
0.03200135380029678,
0.7888681888580322,
-0.42301037907600403,
0.6206101179122925,
-0.2994067072868347,
0.6510079503059387,
-0.8310346603393555,
-0.36084622144699097,
0.11842234432697296,
-0.37460005283355713,
0.023757314309477806,
-0.06929312646389008,
-0.6018959283828735,
-0.09204268455505371,
-0.38308438658714294,
0.6592893600463867,
-0.0001854744623415172,
-0.6271836757659912,
0.8654142022132874,
0.20967473089694977,
-0.12061147391796112,
-0.6056472659111023,
-0.6613727807998657,
0.7319583296775818,
-0.30540478229522705,
-0.8138971924781799,
0.2626202702522278,
-0.3709951639175415,
-0.3014989495277405,
-0.14746783673763275,
0.030569173395633698,
-0.21096542477607727,
-0.1535356044769287,
0.2920638620853424,
-0.030643973499536514,
-0.1893659234046936,
0.5370911359786987,
-0.168643981218338,
-0.03775455802679062,
0.053963519632816315,
-0.08441239595413208,
0.7482580542564392,
-0.5949369072914124,
-0.19292499125003815,
-0.1311739832162857,
0.8089556694030762,
0.7926623225212097,
-0.1768934577703476,
1.0776301622390747,
0.30302369594573975,
-0.4606700837612152,
-0.3349802792072296,
-0.6921659111976624,
-0.3108502924442291,
-0.4899913966655731,
0.6628462672233582,
-0.4525052309036255,
-0.9335333108901978,
0.671145498752594,
-0.2857658863067627,
-0.08785703033208847,
0.290216863155365,
0.6030794382095337,
0.33238035440444946,
0.7873371839523315,
0.8948817849159241,
-0.4563528299331665,
0.38810497522354126,
-0.02443608269095421,
0.15307404100894928,
-0.522472620010376,
-0.07258841395378113,
-0.37034568190574646,
-0.2605474293231964,
-0.3369026482105255,
-0.8600725531578064,
0.5210302472114563,
-0.1559840589761734,
-0.04747510328888893,
0.2627633810043335,
-0.3701775074005127,
0.7847830653190613,
0.3591122329235077,
0.13438904285430908,
0.5293056964874268,
-0.05557361617684364,
0.23776240646839142,
0.21863815188407898,
-0.3170415461063385,
-0.5409224033355713,
0.6635730862617493,
0.4709574580192566,
1.108136534690857,
0.30413973331451416,
0.7990024089813232,
0.16877183318138123,
0.1695956140756607,
-1.0008457899093628,
0.6573429107666016,
0.3130304515361786,
-0.34492459893226624,
-0.7649355530738831,
-0.4811069965362549,
-1.072449803352356,
0.4383799135684967,
0.11279897391796112,
-0.8198248744010925,
0.021754655987024307,
-0.27110785245895386,
-0.10888472944498062,
0.2940099835395813,
-0.5629258155822754,
0.5976569056510925,
-0.03150702267885208,
-0.43427276611328125,
-0.5350619554519653,
-0.7518972754478455,
-0.027269836515188217,
-0.4068310558795929,
0.07226966321468353,
-0.013650327920913696,
-0.14399129152297974,
0.7736219167709351,
-0.362729012966156,
0.8286358118057251,
0.09423454105854034,
-0.32507258653640747,
0.17151671648025513,
0.19986233115196228,
0.7920511364936829,
0.17558574676513672,
-0.2165980190038681,
0.1097065731883049,
-0.27436673641204834,
-0.38187745213508606,
-0.535773754119873,
0.8093559145927429,
-0.9153323769569397,
-0.4444684088230133,
-0.4548581838607788,
-0.8755270838737488,
-0.10879940539598465,
0.13668784499168396,
0.1777626872062683,
0.248256117105484,
-0.10730202496051788,
0.38078945875167847,
0.45216256380081177,
0.09261766076087952,
0.5019714832305908,
0.43155980110168457,
-0.07299401611089706,
-0.31772127747535706,
0.5232271552085876,
0.18945960700511932,
0.26888373494148254,
0.1632891744375229,
0.07967857271432877,
-0.010411921888589859,
-0.29256391525268555,
-0.3372267186641693,
0.32606345415115356,
-0.7146763205528259,
-0.268187016248703,
-0.6917593479156494,
-0.20858031511306763,
-0.22334706783294678,
-0.28178831934928894,
-0.596836507320404,
0.09897429496049881,
-0.25594577193260193,
-0.09513501822948456,
0.3909752666950226,
0.7738425135612488,
-0.04860609024763107,
0.49896278977394104,
-0.5826966762542725,
0.20068375766277313,
0.37269124388694763,
0.43741393089294434,
0.16083240509033203,
-0.3244273364543915,
-0.5899655222892761,
-0.0699259340763092,
-0.17678497731685638,
-1.0561763048171997,
0.28944846987724304,
-0.03364396095275879,
0.23462213575839996,
0.11614946275949478,
0.11283662915229797,
0.76981520652771,
-0.4664846956729889,
0.611987292766571,
0.048879630863666534,
-0.9893553853034973,
0.20526666939258575,
-0.3278175890445709,
0.2696678042411804,
0.5734814405441284,
0.09995854645967484,
-0.8302046656608582,
-0.496273934841156,
-0.20266154408454895,
-0.9001960754394531,
0.708605170249939,
0.2984195053577423,
0.1491071730852127,
-0.019246529787778854,
0.372443825006485,
0.09026482701301575,
0.027574937790632248,
-0.7939667701721191,
0.09806068241596222,
-0.04374431073665619,
-0.047424767166376114,
-0.2956753373146057,
-0.17029723525047302,
-0.25906094908714294,
0.0886862725019455,
0.44373413920402527,
-0.41821688413619995,
0.2960766851902008,
0.42507827281951904,
-0.23382329940795898,
-0.2578682005405426,
0.41127699613571167,
0.5693889260292053,
1.0880893468856812,
-0.046682536602020264,
0.4153605103492737,
0.17898979783058167,
-0.3713468313217163,
0.22417770326137543,
0.1725284606218338,
0.5212764143943787,
-0.28474828600883484,
0.4417555630207062,
0.6601345539093018,
-0.36281657218933105,
-0.5116989612579346,
0.6625726222991943,
-0.41055095195770264,
-0.13372646272182465,
-0.24556362628936768,
-0.20147886872291565,
0.28331249952316284,
0.7788005471229553,
0.4707544445991516,
-0.21129484474658966,
0.052908241748809814,
-0.5753788352012634,
0.24101635813713074,
0.12850020825862885,
-0.3797651529312134,
-0.27670663595199585,
0.3397084176540375,
0.12247505784034729,
-0.430207222700119,
0.5931317806243896,
0.0013457939494401217,
-0.4450879395008087,
0.6173646450042725,
0.6939830183982849,
0.7599246501922607,
-0.32165205478668213,
0.13678564131259918,
-0.17469356954097748,
0.32338955998420715,
-0.43084144592285156,
-0.053474973887205124,
0.04332960769534111,
-0.6053895354270935,
-0.6467821598052979,
-0.30855315923690796,
-0.5673006176948547,
0.27374762296676636,
-0.3445211946964264,
0.03029034473001957,
-0.17462442815303802,
-0.28633132576942444,
-0.1648300141096115,
0.11643010377883911,
-0.4798644185066223,
-0.23286882042884827,
0.008794653229415417,
0.688147783279419,
-0.5599898099899292,
0.9892513155937195,
0.4711189866065979,
-0.2188214361667633,
-0.7969882488250732,
0.2200239896774292,
-0.20446427166461945,
-0.6129041910171509,
0.3446270525455475,
0.4101180136203766,
-0.4820290803909302,
-0.2407817244529724,
-0.6439489126205444,
-0.6554780006408691,
0.9941944479942322,
0.521632730960846,
-0.7656913995742798,
-0.13400740921497345,
0.22484880685806274,
0.6974886059761047,
-0.4191109240055084,
0.06613307446241379,
0.3444966673851013,
0.4341282546520233,
-0.061992719769477844,
-1.2025526762008667,
0.2317000776529312,
0.012952245771884918,
-0.3561730980873108,
0.32536962628364563,
-0.9581546783447266,
1.0973403453826904,
-0.11436034739017487,
0.07964977622032166,
0.12273861467838287,
0.7562052011489868,
0.216781347990036,
0.44213518500328064,
0.7325946688652039,
0.15844228863716125,
0.9804396033287048,
0.4338802695274353,
0.61817866563797,
-0.13469797372817993,
0.3922078013420105,
1.251316785812378,
-0.42618370056152344,
0.7753334045410156,
0.6519246697425842,
0.13452407717704773,
0.21652083098888397,
0.2940770089626312,
0.3142181932926178,
0.18746811151504517,
0.35786426067352295,
-0.6006097197532654,
-0.29774338006973267,
-0.16999147832393646,
-0.29278016090393066,
0.4233090877532959,
0.33424851298332214,
-0.20821310579776764,
-0.2154027372598648,
0.10685282945632935,
0.19522519409656525,
0.044752590358257294,
-0.22366240620613098,
0.7435749769210815,
0.2801830470561981,
-0.5992739200592041,
0.5241247415542603,
-0.019515417516231537,
0.7611876130104065,
-0.5645950436592102,
-0.10288190096616745,
-0.3692772686481476,
0.3887074589729309,
0.07679111510515213,
-0.7033885717391968,
0.07697682827711105,
-0.05656273290514946,
-0.14888398349285126,
-0.032843515276908875,
0.7837648391723633,
-0.658807635307312,
-0.24455448985099792,
0.9456637501716614,
0.5258878469467163,
0.40517377853393555,
-0.5271183848381042,
-0.3175077438354492,
0.2553342580795288,
-0.4492734670639038,
-0.3153288662433624,
0.30092090368270874,
0.6677042841911316,
-0.3098013699054718,
0.6132177114486694,
0.23767590522766113,
0.09077798575162888,
-0.10894228518009186,
0.13405615091323853,
1.1135894060134888,
-0.6831745505332947,
-0.492391973733902,
-0.9572763442993164,
-0.06704773753881454,
-0.20344139635562897,
0.008857659995555878,
0.44068554043769836,
0.46492883563041687,
0.6151659488677979,
0.2510865330696106,
0.5122616291046143,
0.2598673105239868,
0.21718481183052063,
-0.19302338361740112,
0.801945149898529,
-0.5320330858230591,
0.04318761080503464,
-0.17995502054691315,
-1.0509898662567139,
-0.14967316389083862,
0.5830580592155457,
0.12986822426319122,
0.03247808292508125,
0.7233359813690186,
0.7517080307006836,
-0.08450105786323547,
-0.24064086377620697,
0.46848830580711365,
0.428009033203125,
0.7368052005767822,
0.8851237893104553,
0.8050553798675537,
-0.22122688591480255,
0.8479939699172974,
-0.02891770750284195,
-0.37793105840682983,
-0.2501278221607208,
-0.7229691743850708,
-1.086409091949463,
-0.5507829785346985,
0.12853515148162842,
-0.37346455454826355,
0.33576318621635437,
1.202831506729126,
0.7572035193443298,
-0.1301059126853943,
-0.5187922120094299,
0.22184117138385773,
-0.025390969589352608,
-0.05268013849854469,
-0.14988753199577332,
0.3749859631061554,
-0.22394002974033356,
-0.6768437027931213,
0.6425248980522156,
0.2931635081768036,
0.04253823310136795,
-0.36914199590682983,
-0.4276063144207001,
0.10660307854413986,
0.3031560182571411,
0.764694094657898,
-0.159194678068161,
-0.6266134977340698,
-0.4791627526283264,
-0.04371264576911926,
-0.22708791494369507,
0.38585561513900757,
0.5879806280136108,
-0.6935184597969055,
0.4034929573535919,
0.34588730335235596,
0.6744846701622009,
0.593597412109375,
0.003502097213640809,
0.5614625811576843,
-0.6623310446739197,
0.11818297952413559,
0.25789979100227356,
0.1133357584476471,
0.31507524847984314,
-0.609716534614563,
0.5328841805458069,
-0.171463280916214,
-0.9959217309951782,
-0.6828887462615967,
-0.0324179045855999,
-1.1600422859191895,
-0.31904029846191406,
1.1139800548553467,
-0.01831093803048134,
-0.3188895583152771,
0.02837214432656765,
-0.5636979937553406,
0.3543154001235962,
-0.8382697701454163,
0.8384978771209717,
0.846418559551239,
-0.08272507786750793,
-0.04541226848959923,
-0.519080400466919,
0.33531010150909424,
0.3272274434566498,
-1.0737346410751343,
0.40462011098861694,
0.488821804523468,
0.0568145327270031,
0.32200461626052856,
0.8948277831077576,
0.1898801475763321,
-0.0623977929353714,
-0.10519424825906754,
0.04861236363649368,
0.058357007801532745,
-0.725936770439148,
-0.274428129196167,
0.14773070812225342,
0.11061117798089981,
-0.1501055210828781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11549v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11549v2 | Syntactic Language Change in English and German: Metrics, Parsers, and Convergences | 2024-02-18T11:46:16 | 2024-03-28T11:16:28 | Yanran Chen, Wei Zhao, Anne Breitbarth, Manuel Stoeckel, Alexander Mehler, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many studies have shown that human languages tend to optimize for lower
complexity and increased communication efficiency. Syntactic dependency
distance, which measures the linear distance between dependent words, is often
considered a key indicator of language processing difficulty and working memory
load. The current paper looks at diachronic trends in syntactic language change
in both English and German, using corpora of parliamentary debates from the
last c. 160 years. We base our observations on five dependency parsers,
including the widely used Stanford CoreNLP as well as 4 newer alternatives. Our
analysis of syntactic language change goes beyond linear dependency distance
and explores 15 metrics relevant to dependency distance minimization (DDM)
and/or based on tree graph properties, such as the tree height and degree
variance. Even though we have evidence that recent parsers trained on modern
treebanks are not heavily affected by data 'noise' such as spelling changes and
OCR errors in our historic data, we find that results of syntactic language
change are sensitive to the parsers involved, which is a caution against using
a single parser for evaluating syntactic language change as done in previous
work. We also show that syntactic language change over the time period
investigated is largely similar between English and German for the different
metrics explored: only 4% of cases we examine yield opposite conclusions
regarding upwards and downtrends of syntactic metrics across German and
English. We also show that changes in syntactic measures seem to be more
frequent at the tails of sentence length distributions. To our best knowledge,
ours is the most comprehensive analysis of syntactic language change using
modern NLP technology in recent corpora of English and German. | [
-0.42352768778800964,
-0.7944173216819763,
0.5962380170822144,
0.14014671742916107,
0.17188337445259094,
-0.05573637783527374,
-0.4538733661174774,
-0.9025411605834961,
0.18141694366931915,
0.07753215730190277,
-0.17128121852874756,
-0.2662822902202606,
-0.7988322973251343,
0.4650820195674896,
-0.25238028168678284,
0.5806378722190857,
-0.1299523562192917,
0.2930113971233368,
-0.23848362267017365,
-0.4647424817085266,
-0.4208810031414032,
-0.6648957133293152,
-0.6301394104957581,
-0.3125534951686859,
0.5637386441230774,
0.09313437342643738,
0.7867888808250427,
0.6174692511558533,
0.6148138642311096,
0.3364754915237427,
-0.5119007229804993,
-0.32499727606773376,
0.013731773942708969,
0.3684489130973816,
-0.21305018663406372,
-0.6833688616752625,
-0.09660421311855316,
-0.2540946304798126,
0.8573372960090637,
1.269275426864624,
-0.010173635557293892,
-0.07028292119503021,
-0.038892973214387894,
1.1477267742156982,
-0.5703577399253845,
0.38321417570114136,
-0.49199241399765015,
-0.03987335413694382,
-0.7417753338813782,
-0.043035391718149185,
-0.33137762546539307,
-0.11598609387874603,
0.20403453707695007,
-0.11953235417604446,
0.23293650150299072,
-0.11176245659589767,
1.0351614952087402,
0.19420580565929413,
-0.32861194014549255,
-0.44643256068229675,
-0.9401598572731018,
0.6668530106544495,
-0.7310020923614502,
0.8880231380462646,
0.033048953860998154,
0.16387106478214264,
-0.22643616795539856,
-0.653727650642395,
-0.2417774796485901,
-0.45877668261528015,
-0.1537030190229416,
-0.07678057253360748,
-0.6427294611930847,
-0.03624728322029114,
0.28857895731925964,
0.2237146943807602,
-0.42989441752433777,
0.4214327931404114,
-0.3034178912639618,
-0.014745975844562054,
0.2596806585788727,
0.13141095638275146,
0.28554877638816833,
-0.1593601554632187,
-0.07233887910842896,
0.019636932760477066,
-0.5248982310295105,
0.26554688811302185,
0.4382447600364685,
0.21974927186965942,
0.045715201646089554,
0.18139643967151642,
-0.11767091602087021,
0.7156218886375427,
0.0662018433213234,
-0.2807070314884186,
0.16653750836849213,
-0.49408185482025146,
0.16382566094398499,
0.003103177295997739,
0.5269911289215088,
0.40784868597984314,
0.27558770775794983,
-0.13903029263019562,
-0.13972119987010956,
0.2911333739757538,
-0.23707476258277893,
-0.4824572503566742,
-0.45704585313796997,
-0.15612509846687317,
-0.40911316871643066,
0.06859087198972702,
0.04120790585875511,
-0.5846224427223206,
-0.18600745499134064,
-0.335823655128479,
-0.5443956851959229,
-0.4997478127479553,
-0.2371816784143448,
0.3171865940093994,
-0.06658165901899338,
0.16057784855365753,
0.32823485136032104,
-0.9105561971664429,
0.6398429870605469,
0.6411669254302979,
0.7484609484672546,
-0.24121546745300293,
-0.5220754742622375,
-0.19171208143234253,
-0.014218945056200027,
-0.41006526350975037,
0.9829748868942261,
-0.3894427418708801,
0.0037121386267244816,
0.08388792723417282,
0.163780078291893,
-0.09355693310499191,
-0.8695676326751709,
0.17212004959583282,
-0.45084139704704285,
0.6021486520767212,
-0.22800368070602417,
-0.4968940019607544,
-0.18193574249744415,
0.026288215070962906,
-0.7791773676872253,
1.1816428899765015,
0.15001390874385834,
-0.964631199836731,
0.6555837988853455,
-0.48722144961357117,
-0.7994426488876343,
0.11067494004964828,
0.06867377460002899,
-0.2028837352991104,
0.13011422753334045,
-0.07064054161310196,
0.07367982715368271,
-0.18908391892910004,
0.19191935658454895,
-0.12639985978603363,
-0.19342641532421112,
-0.12978596985340118,
-0.23495520651340485,
0.8611679673194885,
-0.1216982752084732,
-0.3625212013721466,
-0.20523570477962494,
-0.9999052286148071,
-0.19826485216617584,
0.21843816339969635,
-0.4782288074493408,
-0.5683903694152832,
0.2530815005302429,
0.002479825634509325,
0.060476645827293396,
0.42184868454933167,
-0.36126473546028137,
-0.12648425996303558,
-0.6021370887756348,
0.5131784677505493,
0.5602878332138062,
0.04626914858818054,
0.45421358942985535,
-0.18031959235668182,
0.5735121965408325,
0.19866164028644562,
-0.033759087324142456,
-0.10230205953121185,
-0.5045329928398132,
-0.5374128818511963,
0.1944972425699234,
0.4884335994720459,
0.5775359272956848,
-0.08301059901714325,
0.4538321793079376,
-0.1012328639626503,
-0.1541420817375183,
-0.3749675452709198,
-0.04258877784013748,
0.019898969680070877,
0.32176369428634644,
0.22035649418830872,
-0.5933147668838501,
-0.7926428318023682,
-0.9909389019012451,
-0.3441467583179474,
-0.6348599195480347,
0.10480471700429916,
0.0035010483115911484,
0.20222759246826172,
0.03829244151711464,
0.9367730021476746,
-0.5387997627258301,
-0.08882972598075867,
-0.3075478672981262,
-0.06841970235109329,
0.06808603554964066,
0.05826075002551079,
0.7265100479125977,
-0.4766608774662018,
-0.6346036791801453,
-0.11390769481658936,
-0.23065917193889618,
-0.5442785620689392,
0.021725865080952644,
0.25959521532058716,
0.7180866599082947,
0.6447684168815613,
-0.7595424056053162,
0.07124751061201096,
0.5739786028862,
-0.31750252842903137,
0.7905707955360413,
-0.12769262492656708,
-0.11024367809295654,
-0.9279478192329407,
0.14032034575939178,
-0.0466865673661232,
-0.3829990327358246,
-0.5864478945732117,
-0.08595656603574753,
-0.22056721150875092,
0.29829922318458557,
-0.5711759328842163,
0.5135337710380554,
-0.5034244656562805,
-0.057684753090143204,
-0.004963764455169439,
0.2869146764278412,
-0.06901975721120834,
0.17415070533752441,
-0.21662838757038116,
0.5459316968917847,
0.38028469681739807,
-0.3775390386581421,
0.3946440517902374,
0.09388819336891174,
-0.2691899836063385,
0.484041690826416,
-0.238567054271698,
0.030144549906253815,
-0.26915672421455383,
0.2350899577140808,
-0.9495424628257751,
0.0930321142077446,
0.16331195831298828,
-0.22363297641277313,
0.27226680517196655,
-0.000323825137456879,
-0.7573192715644836,
-0.22018074989318848,
-0.14049892127513885,
-0.0081824641674757,
0.4584333300590515,
-0.15112923085689545,
0.12825889885425568,
0.2523328959941864,
-0.2983085513114929,
-0.14007483422756195,
-0.5997968316078186,
0.29609444737434387,
-0.2565270960330963,
-0.8284313082695007,
0.3571961522102356,
0.09780061990022659,
-0.8052677512168884,
0.15445971488952637,
-0.2701942026615143,
-0.09943562746047974,
0.14542199671268463,
-0.05926735699176788,
-0.050510916858911514,
-0.35085320472717285,
0.24769750237464905,
-0.19931699335575104,
-0.25513705611228943,
0.1813795417547226,
-0.31164565682411194,
0.6823447346687317,
-0.2772746682167053,
-0.02426108345389366,
-0.16602401435375214,
0.3665224611759186,
0.25757744908332825,
-0.0405668206512928,
0.5850886106491089,
0.41684412956237793,
-0.2460511475801468,
0.031000882387161255,
-0.5947615504264832,
-0.24711020290851593,
-0.38540953397750854,
0.484311044216156,
-0.4895767271518707,
-1.0203312635421753,
0.4743526577949524,
-0.09981899708509445,
-0.07086513936519623,
0.6727173328399658,
0.7490137219429016,
-0.20576849579811096,
0.6996430158615112,
0.674574613571167,
-0.06089283525943756,
0.8015926480293274,
0.3605612814426422,
0.15770912170410156,
-0.2517605125904083,
0.1518668234348297,
-0.7042673826217651,
-0.26911619305610657,
-0.8910470008850098,
0.012265313416719437,
0.1511058360338211,
0.19007401168346405,
0.09321951121091843,
0.6210944652557373,
-0.02807353250682354,
0.4088604748249054,
0.30870816111564636,
-0.5506010055541992,
0.3115403354167938,
-0.19489243626594543,
-0.050375960767269135,
-0.46539103984832764,
-0.7028682827949524,
-0.37047964334487915,
0.48958247900009155,
0.2841774821281433,
0.5231748223304749,
0.09152069687843323,
0.5843567848205566,
0.2920317053794861,
-0.33034566044807434,
-0.6014118194580078,
0.6803815960884094,
-0.3785666227340698,
-0.06366445124149323,
-0.14736856520175934,
-0.4355618953704834,
-1.3769384622573853,
0.10012895613908768,
0.23237848281860352,
-0.5713722109794617,
-0.05100235715508461,
-0.1071261391043663,
0.1746322065591812,
0.23766271770000458,
-0.8044745922088623,
0.7800822854042053,
-0.04552440345287323,
0.05930653214454651,
-0.2313171923160553,
-0.8026411533355713,
-0.2378893941640854,
0.15855880081653595,
0.10748586803674698,
-0.20369794964790344,
0.027399277314543724,
0.8033534288406372,
-0.25526660680770874,
0.7998867630958557,
-0.05552571639418602,
-0.26595842838287354,
0.15419872105121613,
0.31697794795036316,
0.43524080514907837,
-0.4184938371181488,
0.22503867745399475,
0.309198260307312,
0.3408021032810211,
-0.3827347755432129,
-0.43765002489089966,
0.5306543111801147,
-0.2970627248287201,
-0.7472628951072693,
-0.3807987570762634,
-0.7262246012687683,
-0.1323559731245041,
0.3461305797100067,
0.011286702007055283,
0.21266056597232819,
-0.23515188694000244,
-0.06610100716352463,
0.17302557826042175,
-0.07906273752450943,
0.7305936217308044,
0.7582793831825256,
-0.16465865075588226,
-0.049886174499988556,
0.4461922347545624,
0.3756673038005829,
0.4644773602485657,
0.47009697556495667,
0.31877145171165466,
-0.20416142046451569,
-0.43907415866851807,
-0.29420924186706543,
0.4052176773548126,
-0.7841137051582336,
0.14309322834014893,
-0.47442132234573364,
-0.011626966297626495,
-0.5310733318328857,
-0.1869829297065735,
-0.24210608005523682,
-0.7126376032829285,
-0.07483278214931488,
0.03381737694144249,
0.2632438838481903,
0.8367519378662109,
-0.17999601364135742,
-0.1309676468372345,
-0.6805195212364197,
-0.23469088971614838,
-0.2586158215999603,
0.2641255557537079,
-0.2141944020986557,
-0.3227209746837616,
-0.4962936341762543,
-0.3988293707370758,
-0.3313097655773163,
-1.0077015161514282,
0.04812870919704437,
0.2382567822933197,
0.09815169125795364,
0.24581146240234375,
-0.32224807143211365,
0.4882543981075287,
-0.7531542778015137,
0.8777889609336853,
0.1954938769340515,
-0.782945990562439,
0.29502713680267334,
-0.11633849889039993,
0.7607219815254211,
0.35418471693992615,
0.13502313196659088,
-1.0691252946853638,
-0.7571950554847717,
-0.7618648409843445,
-0.7462922930717468,
0.5430939793586731,
-0.2654106914997101,
-0.005785348359495401,
-0.09364581108093262,
0.16321580111980438,
0.16414177417755127,
0.021633490920066833,
-0.4017386734485626,
-0.2737884223461151,
0.5120716691017151,
0.03720974549651146,
0.05338124558329582,
0.07984349876642227,
0.0759902372956276,
-0.3836723268032074,
0.36769744753837585,
0.06079859286546707,
-0.05371474847197533,
-0.08655306696891785,
-0.19048795104026794,
-0.23804645240306854,
0.6496960520744324,
0.5080943703651428,
0.9564498662948608,
-0.026472143828868866,
0.514190673828125,
0.44144803285598755,
-0.3771267831325531,
0.21308211982250214,
0.3361997902393341,
-0.3350919783115387,
0.5792189240455627,
0.6546441316604614,
0.710830569267273,
0.46402212977409363,
-0.5383521914482117,
0.35587790608406067,
0.4591993987560272,
-0.08647729456424713,
-0.40567904710769653,
-0.19352661073207855,
0.321930468082428,
0.0179583840072155,
-0.13210920989513397,
0.29159674048423767,
-0.0639670118689537,
-0.527821958065033,
0.383026659488678,
0.08732371777296066,
-0.2489968240261078,
-0.7209700345993042,
0.5281332731246948,
-0.050556182861328125,
-0.3180151581764221,
0.14221279323101044,
-0.35662752389907837,
-0.5991347432136536,
0.3739307224750519,
0.5878978371620178,
0.6812056303024292,
-0.3594956398010254,
0.24977326393127441,
0.09875364601612091,
0.2695480287075043,
-0.02441384829580784,
0.16294418275356293,
0.11591550707817078,
-0.7167784571647644,
-0.4314231872558594,
-0.45225322246551514,
-0.33936455845832825,
-0.013032216578722,
-0.6128155589103699,
0.4449223577976227,
-0.38232994079589844,
-0.2251095473766327,
0.37741491198539734,
0.11780737340450287,
-0.5976467132568359,
-0.08837148547172546,
0.09914276003837585,
0.7055255770683289,
-0.7755544781684875,
0.7272984385490417,
0.9545130729675293,
-0.21347516775131226,
-0.3208375871181488,
0.21092911064624786,
0.13834378123283386,
-0.592911422252655,
0.704556941986084,
0.05091938003897667,
-0.08104513585567474,
-0.046169258654117584,
-0.0985664650797844,
-0.7538293600082397,
0.6700573563575745,
0.4386875629425049,
-0.6389800906181335,
-0.28961679339408875,
0.4720941483974457,
1.0318602323532104,
-0.06742145866155624,
0.13015979528427124,
1.053348183631897,
0.41408276557922363,
-0.45241954922676086,
-1.0154509544372559,
0.09199956804513931,
0.10904195159673691,
0.22604672610759735,
0.9867057800292969,
-0.6263463497161865,
0.7161312699317932,
0.028569886460900307,
-0.6765786409378052,
-0.33608904480934143,
0.3164677023887634,
-0.26744338870048523,
0.126132071018219,
0.6949988603591919,
0.7686436772346497,
0.5548948049545288,
-0.1465955525636673,
0.8258099555969238,
-0.6380397081375122,
0.1294473558664322,
0.9386880397796631,
-0.5785350203514099,
0.9228476285934448,
0.5666625499725342,
-0.6558879613876343,
0.7987516522407532,
0.5083020329475403,
-0.08199068158864975,
0.21593226492404938,
0.2708125114440918,
-0.2726896107196808,
0.23468264937400818,
-0.2735266387462616,
-0.1472092568874359,
0.36308205127716064,
-0.0059017762541770935,
-0.3425752818584442,
-0.7362805604934692,
0.08457166701555252,
0.6282617449760437,
0.1109171062707901,
0.3175567090511322,
0.8513389825820923,
0.11036795377731323,
-0.5143804550170898,
0.6141946911811829,
0.26360708475112915,
0.47265270352363586,
-0.6066789031028748,
0.1885853409767151,
-0.3517173230648041,
0.1546858698129654,
-0.11185934394598007,
-0.7658498883247375,
0.5704967379570007,
-0.08059889078140259,
-0.3204808533191681,
-0.40146541595458984,
0.6425905227661133,
-0.4857672452926636,
-0.1170412078499794,
0.8650727272033691,
0.7638696432113647,
0.2765592038631439,
0.2629365026950836,
-0.7280712723731995,
0.09151063114404678,
-0.13409332931041718,
-0.22474409639835358,
0.48336198925971985,
0.34305402636528015,
-0.050348106771707535,
0.3088954985141754,
0.394361674785614,
0.4479426145553589,
0.07862944155931473,
0.3010065257549286,
0.6392846703529358,
-0.7219821214675903,
-0.42644748091697693,
-0.7706086039543152,
0.05147600919008255,
0.3089939057826996,
-0.4018803834915161,
0.7554944157600403,
0.5671181082725525,
1.240625262260437,
0.1165408194065094,
0.5951970219612122,
-0.47350022196769714,
0.5460182428359985,
-0.5183201432228088,
0.3121892213821411,
-0.4702790081501007,
0.1312708854675293,
-0.05770416557788849,
-1.0682560205459595,
-0.2835352420806885,
0.033688634634017944,
-0.3802563548088074,
-0.13730372488498688,
1.2465825080871582,
0.7013369798660278,
0.19941651821136475,
-0.0676589161157608,
0.2820039987564087,
0.5241500735282898,
0.19761496782302856,
0.5143594741821289,
0.6231052279472351,
-0.18273811042308807,
0.5026939511299133,
-0.3153310716152191,
-0.13163724541664124,
0.09419778734445572,
-0.6086011528968811,
-0.3905905485153198,
-0.9385397434234619,
-0.46289053559303284,
-0.5016652345657349,
0.31156209111213684,
0.7608605623245239,
0.20755019783973694,
-0.8662412762641907,
-0.4093460440635681,
-0.2030327469110489,
-0.14848515391349792,
-0.5384210348129272,
-0.35954293608665466,
0.46908363699913025,
-0.6884609460830688,
-0.8114691376686096,
0.5215040445327759,
0.4186601936817169,
-0.014518984593451023,
-0.32957780361175537,
0.061173923313617706,
-0.31807565689086914,
-0.0405614897608757,
0.6268808245658875,
0.3370424211025238,
-0.8861730694770813,
-0.5504603385925293,
-0.09255237132310867,
-0.2985885441303253,
0.6224421858787537,
0.8820374608039856,
-0.5259997248649597,
0.37566813826560974,
0.6738435626029968,
0.3762773871421814,
0.2957304120063782,
-0.24334770441055298,
0.4560999572277069,
-0.7614384889602661,
0.33163297176361084,
0.1350831538438797,
0.31134533882141113,
0.533429741859436,
-0.01252762507647276,
0.5235228538513184,
0.757704496383667,
-0.5636630654335022,
-0.6949360966682434,
0.4139993190765381,
-0.5870830416679382,
-0.19133684039115906,
0.9781823754310608,
-0.09345118701457977,
-0.03858519345521927,
-0.27194148302078247,
-0.07566460967063904,
-0.04238889738917351,
-0.29798832535743713,
0.7129215002059937,
1.2362169027328491,
-0.26581621170043945,
-0.44913187623023987,
-0.5263679027557373,
0.668997049331665,
0.7869792580604553,
-0.8653453588485718,
0.0015579978935420513,
0.4829629361629486,
0.3738696873188019,
0.31360793113708496,
0.6066499948501587,
-0.15180805325508118,
0.03964504972100258,
0.24195607006549835,
-0.014510591514408588,
0.44754868745803833,
-0.27938851714134216,
-0.3632037341594696,
0.04056362062692642,
0.14253802597522736,
0.13532398641109467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11548v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11548v2 | KMMLU: Measuring Massive Multitask Language Understanding in Korean | 2024-02-18T11:41:07 | 2024-06-06T12:23:58 | Guijin Son, Hanwool Lee, Sungdong Kim, Seungone Kim, Niklas Muennighoff, Taekyoon Choi, Cheonbok Park, Kang Min Yoo, Stella Biderman | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose KMMLU, a new Korean benchmark with 35,030 expert-level
multiple-choice questions across 45 subjects ranging from humanities to STEM.
While prior Korean benchmarks are translated from existing English benchmarks,
KMMLU is collected from original Korean exams, capturing linguistic and
cultural aspects of the Korean language. We test 27 public and proprietary LLMs
and observe the best public model to score 50.5%, leaving significant room for
improvement. This model was primarily trained for English and Chinese, not
Korean. Current LLMs tailored to Korean, such as Polyglot-Ko, perform far
worse. Surprisingly, even the most capable proprietary LLMs, e.g., GPT-4 and
HyperCLOVA X do not exceed 60%. This suggests that further work is needed to
improve LLMs for Korean, and we believe KMMLU offers the appropriate tool to
track this progress. We make our dataset publicly available on the Hugging Face
Hub and integrate the benchmark into EleutherAI's Language Model Evaluation
Harness. | [
-0.49972569942474365,
-0.7618632316589355,
0.7055294513702393,
0.4413604736328125,
-0.2922777235507965,
0.14251862466335297,
-0.5083500146865845,
-0.5057479739189148,
-0.016402775421738625,
0.4518461525440216,
-0.46920523047447205,
-0.7055212259292603,
-0.6954807043075562,
0.22743959724903107,
0.1669977605342865,
0.7058586478233337,
-0.27844882011413574,
0.2699600160121918,
-0.6340671181678772,
-0.42767831683158875,
-0.4395476281642914,
-0.38108277320861816,
-0.5833480954170227,
-0.633201539516449,
0.5838924646377563,
0.460908442735672,
0.42605161666870117,
0.4046279191970825,
0.38251709938049316,
0.2597888112068176,
-0.1722080111503601,
-0.03674847632646561,
-0.5350919961929321,
-0.09056881815195084,
0.2523462474346161,
-0.5830225944519043,
-0.6110039949417114,
0.31601572036743164,
0.6247100830078125,
0.8662540316581726,
-0.06902527809143066,
0.42777329683303833,
-0.18797960877418518,
0.9370418190956116,
-0.5537802577018738,
0.35143420100212097,
-0.393057644367218,
0.14614728093147278,
-0.09938602149486542,
0.282798171043396,
-0.4652745723724365,
-0.280765175819397,
0.0658021941781044,
-0.6780271530151367,
-0.4607034921646118,
-0.20482145249843597,
0.7051417827606201,
0.32628485560417175,
-0.9424707293510437,
-0.1227116584777832,
-0.35351255536079407,
0.8577198386192322,
-0.5203896760940552,
0.8562354445457458,
0.5739850997924805,
0.41733625531196594,
-0.07648279517889023,
-0.4183845818042755,
-0.5017102956771851,
-0.687747597694397,
-0.09719429165124893,
0.3972828984260559,
0.13711191713809967,
0.1328565627336502,
0.06900851428508759,
0.3610425889492035,
-0.8855684399604797,
0.06020839884877205,
-0.21290436387062073,
-0.04282626882195473,
0.7943052053451538,
0.2901207506656647,
0.23891866207122803,
-0.3669368028640747,
-0.29760023951530457,
0.016348781064152718,
-0.5452837944030762,
0.10497714579105377,
0.4162684977054596,
-0.14277076721191406,
-0.06252791732549667,
0.5239875316619873,
-0.4708297550678253,
0.8032184839248657,
-0.2776171565055847,
-0.39204245805740356,
0.4019103944301605,
-0.5372751355171204,
-0.35366544127464294,
-0.05345981568098068,
0.6547132134437561,
0.5734453797340393,
0.27067655324935913,
-0.19597871601581573,
0.0608031265437603,
0.04949918016791344,
0.08116142451763153,
-0.6082574129104614,
-0.4519502818584442,
0.44555363059043884,
-0.5231543183326721,
-0.21104459464550018,
-0.10829731822013855,
-0.5581121444702148,
-0.4788822829723358,
-0.4932485818862915,
0.0794324278831482,
-0.17458662390708923,
-0.7338574528694153,
0.05402253940701485,
0.12093693017959595,
0.22526118159294128,
0.2888381779193878,
-0.38422417640686035,
0.027375299483537674,
0.6681478023529053,
0.6225890517234802,
-0.5082282423973083,
-0.8160674571990967,
-0.034101467579603195,
-0.005712749436497688,
-0.37144652009010315,
0.6532212495803833,
-0.4661785960197449,
-0.3860287666320801,
-0.3605636656284332,
0.12185744941234589,
-0.48353883624076843,
-0.9090797305107117,
0.6283726692199707,
-0.25217777490615845,
0.055008161813020706,
-0.2508373260498047,
-0.5915228128433228,
-0.3591897785663605,
0.5291616320610046,
-0.5645613670349121,
1.2950208187103271,
0.19400742650032043,
-0.35688135027885437,
0.30144202709198,
-0.7075839042663574,
-0.1863446682691574,
0.1781672239303589,
0.025338416919112206,
-0.2550491988658905,
0.03694251552224159,
0.10010144114494324,
0.6785473823547363,
-0.05514536052942276,
0.4536568522453308,
-0.3136771023273468,
-0.05294704809784889,
0.11135848611593246,
-0.013984781689941883,
0.6295176148414612,
0.2350795418024063,
0.02648644708096981,
0.26669737696647644,
-0.8686715960502625,
0.1790062040090561,
0.2484234720468521,
-0.6453036665916443,
-0.39210954308509827,
-0.34054940938949585,
0.21448707580566406,
0.5358364582061768,
0.32711902260780334,
-0.579825222492218,
0.09371930360794067,
0.03872031345963478,
0.1388419270515442,
0.6655797362327576,
-0.47231411933898926,
0.3903846740722656,
-0.08022748678922653,
0.7015823125839233,
0.0552496612071991,
0.14355851709842682,
-0.20239976048469543,
-0.6507176756858826,
-0.5783956050872803,
-0.1836148500442505,
0.1862296164035797,
0.48519259691238403,
-0.571779191493988,
0.1348821073770523,
-0.2482905089855194,
-0.8332486152648926,
-0.8235288262367249,
0.27429282665252686,
0.5065293312072754,
0.4778144359588623,
0.10896024852991104,
0.06512036919593811,
-0.3642999529838562,
-0.8303377628326416,
-0.5066125988960266,
-0.10959513485431671,
-0.13318556547164917,
0.7633079886436462,
0.4902231991291046,
-0.1537957638502121,
0.3641182482242584,
-0.4843073785305023,
-0.195814847946167,
-0.388882040977478,
0.10510676354169846,
0.17617161571979523,
0.15416184067726135,
0.2764887511730194,
-0.9348616600036621,
-0.9526485800743103,
0.41362956166267395,
-0.8824785947799683,
-0.011239273473620415,
0.1278437227010727,
-0.2001376450061798,
0.3154926598072052,
0.6018816232681274,
-0.9401537775993347,
-0.17602182924747467,
0.964205801486969,
-0.5515862107276917,
0.9215654134750366,
0.0352754145860672,
0.3107401728630066,
-1.117563009262085,
0.1441344916820526,
-0.14855548739433289,
-0.24707567691802979,
-0.8940799236297607,
0.5031243562698364,
0.3234885632991791,
-0.09315663576126099,
-0.5626471638679504,
0.5286856293678284,
-0.4259803891181946,
0.04021671414375305,
-0.3343706429004669,
0.4155561625957489,
-0.20828121900558472,
0.3913797438144684,
-0.2321072816848755,
0.5248529314994812,
0.3697889447212219,
-0.47718507051467896,
0.6484181880950928,
-0.02229294925928116,
-0.518006443977356,
0.6501181721687317,
-0.5568286776542664,
0.2820846438407898,
-0.11298630386590958,
0.31575512886047363,
-1.0904086828231812,
-0.3617136478424072,
0.03469172865152359,
-0.3772050142288208,
0.10890457034111023,
-0.258355975151062,
-0.36025679111480713,
-0.4596509039402008,
-0.13047869503498077,
0.2509789764881134,
0.3271227180957794,
-0.4640866219997406,
0.7623883485794067,
0.5113126039505005,
-0.1251726746559143,
-0.5979143381118774,
-0.36858877539634705,
0.02896079421043396,
-0.20721209049224854,
-0.7905876040458679,
-0.04583393409848213,
-0.20004956424236298,
-0.21649253368377686,
0.021623272448778152,
-0.15696987509727478,
-0.02826305851340294,
0.3066365420818329,
0.12353981286287308,
0.3090369999408722,
-0.4922805726528168,
-0.06352334469556808,
-0.1822330802679062,
-0.23841583728790283,
0.37330928444862366,
-0.09835726767778397,
0.7346653342247009,
-0.07329970598220825,
-0.3753557503223419,
-0.4029431641101837,
0.09882062673568726,
0.8822649121284485,
-0.04390906170010567,
0.5569334626197815,
0.8660386800765991,
-0.2881532907485962,
0.2690713405609131,
-0.526577353477478,
0.23231439292430878,
-0.4217405915260315,
0.7556301355361938,
-0.726426899433136,
-0.9969035983085632,
0.5434330701828003,
-0.29344919323921204,
0.0008653067634440958,
0.32729780673980713,
0.7929636240005493,
0.06690721213817596,
1.061388373374939,
0.39351198077201843,
-0.3988090753555298,
-0.08645883202552795,
0.19730746746063232,
0.025175489485263824,
-0.7854996919631958,
-0.3071628510951996,
-0.2112809717655182,
-0.3993651270866394,
-0.5575200915336609,
-0.38505885004997253,
0.19583526253700256,
0.23165087401866913,
0.1698407083749771,
0.29122233390808105,
-0.1293071061372757,
0.7578560709953308,
0.46096131205558777,
-0.12889662384986877,
0.41055741906166077,
-0.4979316294193268,
-0.17814567685127258,
-0.0443122461438179,
-0.41737911105155945,
-0.3716777265071869,
1.185755968093872,
0.2466202676296234,
0.517611563205719,
0.11318892985582352,
0.4645654857158661,
-0.24444334208965302,
0.34686195850372314,
-0.8449376821517944,
0.5750041007995605,
0.01651371642947197,
-0.5211830735206604,
-0.3670252561569214,
-0.5493110418319702,
-0.7810372710227966,
0.6079668402671814,
0.2036924660205841,
-0.5859057307243347,
-0.5294481515884399,
0.11909916251897812,
0.002865155693143606,
0.19090771675109863,
-0.9557905793190002,
1.1302436590194702,
0.015484331175684929,
0.20263372361660004,
-0.2021123766899109,
-0.4605991244316101,
0.7261825799942017,
-0.2116631269454956,
0.08119848370552063,
-0.6820574998855591,
-0.043130673468112946,
0.6255201101303101,
0.05654241144657135,
0.5162901282310486,
-0.3233182430267334,
-0.12611666321754456,
-0.031209196895360947,
-0.05559768155217171,
0.4833754301071167,
0.08296141028404236,
0.177445188164711,
0.2836582660675049,
-0.08819366991519928,
-0.5905781388282776,
-0.52875816822052,
0.8744646310806274,
-0.7209928631782532,
-0.510877251625061,
-0.07195252925157547,
-0.8467574119567871,
-0.1771935224533081,
0.12867289781570435,
-0.030614497140049934,
-0.17929323017597198,
-0.2713980972766876,
0.03524661436676979,
0.44975563883781433,
-0.27838799357414246,
0.23983971774578094,
0.6366434693336487,
-0.5333723425865173,
-0.3609139025211334,
1.0035055875778198,
0.08506830781698227,
0.4293469488620758,
0.11243849992752075,
0.4172850251197815,
-0.3255069851875305,
-0.3993011713027954,
-0.7049248218536377,
0.34309273958206177,
-0.6885888576507568,
0.11596012115478516,
-0.9507128000259399,
-0.09734783321619034,
-0.3963565528392792,
-0.017078381031751633,
-0.6040353775024414,
-0.24956002831459045,
0.17092280089855194,
-0.12155847996473312,
0.2029191255569458,
1.0516681671142578,
0.36750081181526184,
0.06416517496109009,
-0.6922594904899597,
0.3270285129547119,
0.1855040192604065,
0.5434993505477905,
0.12053986638784409,
-0.36687275767326355,
-0.19800786674022675,
-0.30587440729141235,
-0.22552931308746338,
-0.42940813302993774,
0.17944395542144775,
0.05908219888806343,
0.6890273094177246,
0.35801127552986145,
-0.09567512571811676,
0.697665810585022,
-0.6534048318862915,
0.8902391195297241,
-0.020549317821860313,
-0.7418124079704285,
0.3434544801712036,
-0.23923437297344208,
0.8168129920959473,
0.4835113286972046,
0.8424398899078369,
-1.1612415313720703,
-0.6751807928085327,
-0.2646959125995636,
-0.5646075010299683,
0.7548366785049438,
0.015445190481841564,
0.1374407261610031,
0.2633132040500641,
0.17615008354187012,
0.26764222979545593,
0.019220147281885147,
-0.6573664546012878,
-0.7386208772659302,
0.09916747361421585,
-0.20980443060398102,
-0.2724083662033081,
-0.31880730390548706,
0.03407157585024834,
-0.4629039466381073,
0.5228008031845093,
-0.08339603245258331,
0.07685975730419159,
-0.05481986701488495,
-0.3587947189807892,
-0.004259319510310888,
0.20345936715602875,
0.9399779438972473,
0.9888861179351807,
0.018774284049868584,
0.1729763001203537,
0.4443029761314392,
-0.9869931936264038,
0.11474885791540146,
0.18346647918224335,
0.14960822463035583,
0.08256357908248901,
0.07201652973890305,
0.6140406131744385,
0.13696642220020294,
-0.8070582151412964,
0.28146442770957947,
-0.059613052755594254,
-0.4347880780696869,
-0.14568042755126953,
-0.24331606924533844,
0.7369069457054138,
0.08366964757442474,
0.24045369029045105,
-0.4261372983455658,
-0.12786325812339783,
-0.15124908089637756,
0.24915680289268494,
0.18959160149097443,
-0.36288556456565857,
-0.4192182719707489,
0.6629549264907837,
0.19099605083465576,
-0.05229279771447182,
0.5852795243263245,
-0.3145712912082672,
-0.6500075459480286,
0.6308048367500305,
0.44209080934524536,
0.560600757598877,
-0.5813964605331421,
0.2667134702205658,
0.3724082112312317,
0.3167707920074463,
0.004953434690833092,
0.5723164677619934,
0.09137576073408127,
-0.6940852999687195,
-0.6868471503257751,
-0.6202786564826965,
-0.5283768773078918,
0.4117017686367035,
-0.5646030306816101,
0.166908860206604,
0.0006821795832365751,
0.12083327025175095,
0.030641475692391396,
0.1173166036605835,
-0.4665355980396271,
-0.042313553392887115,
0.2314145267009735,
0.8678916692733765,
-0.8149954676628113,
0.9528542160987854,
1.0581663846969604,
0.007666802033782005,
-0.6190353035926819,
-0.3312487304210663,
0.2399696707725525,
-0.9111859798431396,
0.5911893844604492,
0.3674417734146118,
0.2415740042924881,
0.0174457635730505,
-0.19653086364269257,
-0.851959228515625,
1.1554560661315918,
0.2439804971218109,
-0.37297362089157104,
0.2587798833847046,
0.40743422508239746,
0.2758265435695648,
-0.18746349215507507,
0.1957762986421585,
0.8780926465988159,
0.6015177369117737,
-0.33904701471328735,
-1.153833270072937,
0.0022722722496837378,
-0.3298933506011963,
-0.2771323025226593,
0.4427535831928253,
-0.762344479560852,
0.7733477354049683,
-0.06243867799639702,
0.006238674279302359,
-0.05401186645030975,
0.3746607005596161,
0.5103719234466553,
0.7874336838722229,
0.49361246824264526,
0.8673405051231384,
0.8553061485290527,
-0.1653139740228653,
1.0141929388046265,
-0.30733975768089294,
0.40683361887931824,
1.1201293468475342,
-0.18740324676036835,
0.71893709897995,
0.42557722330093384,
-0.43860042095184326,
0.08888578414916992,
0.7686295509338379,
0.04978318139910698,
0.18067316710948944,
0.19546163082122803,
-0.3347362279891968,
-0.20276208221912384,
-0.29533448815345764,
-0.2393304705619812,
0.531927764415741,
0.09061625599861145,
-0.19190309941768646,
-0.13081198930740356,
0.3121955692768097,
0.41308021545410156,
-0.13990840315818787,
-0.37978872656822205,
0.7006937861442566,
0.20515336096286774,
-0.6345915794372559,
0.5577659010887146,
-0.14566878974437714,
0.7251478433609009,
-0.4808305501937866,
0.21404774487018585,
-0.28446054458618164,
0.1180516928434372,
-0.12553586065769196,
-0.8214861154556274,
0.047444846481084824,
-0.15307843685150146,
-0.056797586381435394,
-0.06991363316774368,
0.7101479768753052,
-0.7193194627761841,
-0.516189694404602,
0.4274888038635254,
0.7531583309173584,
0.5974428057670593,
-0.3424679636955261,
-0.7035129070281982,
0.05062803626060486,
-0.13108189404010773,
-0.4758085012435913,
0.5344738364219666,
0.37602129578590393,
0.2332986742258072,
0.7526682019233704,
0.5659990310668945,
-0.07417551428079605,
0.35687318444252014,
0.32095420360565186,
0.6943907737731934,
-0.6308556199073792,
-0.22477151453495026,
-0.9272652864456177,
0.33906692266464233,
-0.08949942886829376,
-0.6777435541152954,
1.058039665222168,
0.5768516659736633,
1.4559303522109985,
-0.2622624933719635,
0.6135903596878052,
0.1382746547460556,
0.1776333898305893,
-0.4077628254890442,
1.057788610458374,
-0.6205469369888306,
-0.4364014267921448,
-0.23139213025569916,
-0.9241155385971069,
-0.26587456464767456,
0.13773123919963837,
-0.12768031656742096,
-0.07580086588859558,
0.7724300026893616,
0.5566777586936951,
0.020427485927939415,
0.12845519185066223,
0.9350246787071228,
0.13426202535629272,
0.031757205724716187,
0.6881123185157776,
1.0046188831329346,
-0.3182215988636017,
0.6187084317207336,
-0.5372217297554016,
-0.09188387542963028,
0.029719972983002663,
-0.6350758075714111,
-1.0060155391693115,
-0.5119023323059082,
-0.31985628604888916,
-0.05561663210391998,
-0.23712825775146484,
0.9196131229400635,
0.6196145415306091,
-0.7793740630149841,
-0.413655161857605,
0.2145792692899704,
0.20107512176036835,
-0.18169339001178741,
-0.2438504695892334,
0.3298571705818176,
-0.41935229301452637,
-0.8214806914329529,
0.49900323152542114,
0.18321168422698975,
-0.12277300655841827,
-0.2995951473712921,
-0.3514902591705322,
-0.20814615488052368,
-0.41920995712280273,
1.0277681350708008,
-0.10678920894861221,
-0.9150426387786865,
-0.008928433060646057,
0.3019734025001526,
-0.13727572560310364,
0.13045482337474823,
0.8960855603218079,
-0.4377378225326538,
0.4761715233325958,
0.422821044921875,
0.8392325043678284,
0.2612534463405609,
-0.17186971008777618,
0.39238089323043823,
-0.5627564787864685,
-0.04206316918134689,
-0.07531122863292694,
0.2067897915840149,
0.18428818881511688,
-0.4106542468070984,
0.5976764559745789,
0.336392879486084,
-0.8643767237663269,
-0.787566602230072,
0.13788296282291412,
-0.7356566786766052,
-0.2879136800765991,
1.1904888153076172,
-0.2693173289299011,
-0.26893749833106995,
-0.34894225001335144,
-0.024036074057221413,
-0.030453182756900787,
-0.22754189372062683,
0.5469720363616943,
1.2331382036209106,
-0.25005438923835754,
-0.3779713809490204,
-1.1151009798049927,
0.42253053188323975,
0.5619342923164368,
-0.8116390705108643,
0.31659266352653503,
0.1031293272972107,
0.30734631419181824,
0.01949271559715271,
0.7234959602355957,
-0.14401060342788696,
0.4145236015319824,
-0.13565075397491455,
0.14909833669662476,
-0.06325693428516388,
-0.3387511670589447,
-0.42268645763397217,
-0.10130511969327927,
0.10060317069292068,
-0.15788280963897705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12408v1 | ModelGPT: Unleashing LLM's Capabilities for Tailored Model Generation | 2024-02-18T11:24:34 | 2024-02-18T11:24:34 | Zihao Tang, Zheqi Lv, Shengyu Zhang, Fei Wu, Kun Kuang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized
various sectors by automating routine tasks, marking a step toward the
realization of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). However, they still
struggle to accommodate the diverse and specific needs of users and simplify
the utilization of AI models for the average user. In response, we propose
ModelGPT, a novel framework designed to determine and generate AI models
specifically tailored to the data or task descriptions provided by the user,
leveraging the capabilities of LLMs. Given user requirements, ModelGPT is able
to provide tailored models at most 270x faster than the previous paradigms
(e.g. all-parameter or LoRA finetuning). Comprehensive experiments on NLP, CV,
and Tabular datasets attest to the effectiveness of our framework in making AI
models more accessible and user-friendly. Our code is available at
https://github.com/IshiKura-a/ModelGPT. | [
-0.35546520352363586,
-0.8330134749412537,
0.6692909002304077,
0.06486658751964569,
-0.08477046340703964,
-0.04947836697101593,
-0.09850727021694183,
-0.21548016369342804,
-0.10222324728965759,
0.6112369894981384,
-0.7438138127326965,
-0.3002150058746338,
-0.3212515711784363,
-0.14512592554092407,
-0.6528040170669556,
1.084386944770813,
0.07267051935195923,
-0.04305790364742279,
-0.36503711342811584,
0.26164913177490234,
-0.34444770216941833,
-0.5189098715782166,
-0.6516894102096558,
-0.7037484645843506,
0.41207942366600037,
0.24703437089920044,
0.7588396072387695,
0.9094473719596863,
0.4865628480911255,
0.2185809314250946,
0.20828449726104736,
0.15649840235710144,
-0.32987678050994873,
0.18439160287380219,
0.08347482979297638,
-0.3757116198539734,
-0.7809775471687317,
0.04393942654132843,
0.5348415374755859,
0.4954666793346405,
-0.22659432888031006,
0.3284133970737457,
0.02490459382534027,
0.3662170469760895,
-0.2316257655620575,
0.267210453748703,
-0.854536771774292,
-0.0036299158819019794,
-0.2551361322402954,
-0.16711170971393585,
-0.2445356547832489,
0.0869578868150711,
-0.09276783466339111,
-0.5856496095657349,
0.3803357481956482,
0.15176188945770264,
0.6255080699920654,
0.5326582789421082,
-0.44673094153404236,
-0.1918986439704895,
-0.8687331080436707,
0.5020094513893127,
-0.9873999953269958,
0.21716633439064026,
0.05600709468126297,
0.5703555941581726,
-0.4211678206920624,
-1.0663700103759766,
-0.5064447522163391,
-0.6868515610694885,
-0.024548931047320366,
-0.08207626640796661,
-0.13862363994121552,
-0.027155093848705292,
0.4133356213569641,
0.29423823952674866,
-0.8013162612915039,
0.27962881326675415,
-0.19889557361602783,
0.03922107070684433,
0.6654670834541321,
0.3131755292415619,
0.5336310267448425,
-0.05400344356894493,
-0.08686701208353043,
0.20523209869861603,
-0.9469470381736755,
-0.20025691390037537,
0.5600059628486633,
0.49314460158348083,
0.1411110758781433,
0.7490061521530151,
-0.3417866826057434,
0.742702841758728,
-0.1668727993965149,
0.07048352062702179,
-0.12399978935718536,
-0.2582649886608124,
-0.32539230585098267,
-0.24711713194847107,
0.7894468903541565,
0.0352664440870285,
0.17919237911701202,
-0.3190007507801056,
-0.42023760080337524,
0.004455853253602982,
0.4374058246612549,
-0.8885853886604309,
-0.3715965747833252,
-0.032408084720373154,
-0.23340685665607452,
-0.4352290630340576,
-0.047271836549043655,
-0.5059282183647156,
-0.3434186279773712,
-0.34688276052474976,
0.20577222108840942,
-0.09668219834566116,
-0.09446848183870316,
-0.16185642778873444,
0.05196693167090416,
0.3468022346496582,
0.14319393038749695,
-1.044257402420044,
0.12595681846141815,
0.7961377501487732,
0.7433786392211914,
-0.3795619010925293,
-0.15654924511909485,
-0.49216845631599426,
0.3251272439956665,
-0.10579834133386612,
0.6853020191192627,
-0.7412315607070923,
-0.5321089029312134,
-0.15080249309539795,
-0.4067910313606262,
0.004468043800443411,
-0.3985844850540161,
0.5123797655105591,
-0.34530165791511536,
0.0587216280400753,
-0.052046455442905426,
-0.5648902058601379,
-0.14516553282737732,
0.4329358637332916,
-0.4998886287212372,
0.8623647689819336,
0.1685716211795807,
-0.4618959128856659,
0.22024261951446533,
-0.9953110218048096,
-0.4392584562301636,
0.3224770426750183,
-0.47159066796302795,
-0.5548600554466248,
0.09842905402183533,
0.49438798427581787,
0.6930209994316101,
-0.7191449403762817,
0.618583619594574,
-0.3965417146682739,
-0.17507795989513397,
0.03959173709154129,
-0.5661888122558594,
0.3703179657459259,
0.3714761734008789,
-0.18997137248516083,
0.4788903295993805,
-0.8144378662109375,
0.28516101837158203,
0.38995715975761414,
-0.511813759803772,
0.20750565826892853,
0.18178507685661316,
0.28486090898513794,
0.036299508064985275,
0.29171812534332275,
-0.14623692631721497,
0.48078322410583496,
-0.15033140778541565,
1.0600221157073975,
0.7939740419387817,
-0.3186241686344147,
0.39299097657203674,
-0.3616380989551544,
0.8009580969810486,
-0.3910595178604126,
-0.061202943325042725,
-0.2389681339263916,
-0.45530635118484497,
-0.6425236463546753,
-0.3758123815059662,
0.2106505185365677,
0.5727785229682922,
-0.4695797264575958,
0.3686261773109436,
-0.306831419467926,
-0.6638875603675842,
-0.3009227216243744,
0.14856798946857452,
0.23039862513542175,
0.6975978016853333,
0.09610860794782639,
-0.2081243395805359,
-0.4387710690498352,
-1.1314654350280762,
-0.2879319489002228,
-0.17857351899147034,
-0.44417738914489746,
0.5484097599983215,
0.41892901062965393,
-0.6036000847816467,
1.0396970510482788,
-0.5046659111976624,
-0.1107078492641449,
-0.5919930934906006,
-0.019604135304689407,
0.1787838637828827,
0.3780258297920227,
0.4401709735393524,
-0.915065348148346,
-0.2709047794342041,
0.12672878801822662,
-0.7440892457962036,
-0.37597280740737915,
-0.21009394526481628,
-0.04931560531258583,
-0.11611484736204147,
0.5347607135772705,
-0.7616366147994995,
0.30762815475463867,
0.254588782787323,
-0.16837726533412933,
0.5073297619819641,
-0.36167383193969727,
-0.11705274879932404,
-1.261232852935791,
0.3910098075866699,
-0.09352144598960876,
-0.3487798571586609,
-0.7893078923225403,
0.2162236124277115,
-0.1610415130853653,
-0.45952504873275757,
-0.30297112464904785,
0.7224987745285034,
-0.276790052652359,
-0.27499285340309143,
-0.2612435221672058,
0.02051715925335884,
-0.2853657901287079,
0.36201733350753784,
-0.19370168447494507,
1.0536690950393677,
0.46686333417892456,
-0.5768184661865234,
0.3380660116672516,
0.25753894448280334,
-0.09990247339010239,
0.21720214188098907,
-0.8948168754577637,
0.44006288051605225,
0.049237173050642014,
0.12674705684185028,
-0.7457534074783325,
-0.6935063004493713,
0.27521267533302307,
-0.22803689539432526,
0.05582588538527489,
-0.03535981476306915,
-0.4634425938129425,
-0.3405594229698181,
0.16425763070583344,
0.34266528487205505,
0.6267451047897339,
-0.5616083741188049,
0.968851625919342,
0.37598326802253723,
-0.22400963306427002,
-0.25465455651283264,
-0.5061243772506714,
0.24064858257770538,
-0.4090295732021332,
-0.6814011931419373,
0.32818278670310974,
-0.34575557708740234,
-0.09245268255472183,
-0.04484637454152107,
-0.028524497523903847,
-0.0901443138718605,
0.3077503740787506,
0.3302157521247864,
0.12247007340192795,
-0.19814877212047577,
-0.09173355996608734,
-0.11837077885866165,
-0.1430358588695526,
-0.002090930938720703,
-0.43341439962387085,
0.6529674530029297,
-0.17080895602703094,
-0.6776525378227234,
-0.24333696067333221,
0.3942643105983734,
0.42852583527565,
-0.4429517686367035,
0.19280332326889038,
0.7304064035415649,
-0.2940213680267334,
-0.47881487011909485,
-0.2380114197731018,
-0.0009539855527691543,
-0.4973303973674774,
0.729863703250885,
-0.4147637188434601,
-0.9165645241737366,
0.5767472982406616,
-0.10496874898672104,
0.15515199303627014,
0.252591997385025,
0.8291614055633545,
0.33145007491111755,
1.2209391593933105,
0.737709105014801,
-0.26662981510162354,
0.4444736838340759,
0.00603422662243247,
0.48663192987442017,
-0.6305633783340454,
-0.06304176151752472,
-0.39203909039497375,
-0.308987021446228,
-0.6808568835258484,
-0.14683769643306732,
0.3405088484287262,
-0.07542315125465393,
-0.3778020739555359,
0.0588860921561718,
-0.5990440845489502,
0.482393741607666,
0.8715656399726868,
-0.012742634862661362,
0.18652310967445374,
-0.08182956278324127,
0.2576015293598175,
0.34139859676361084,
-0.6916626691818237,
-0.8140407204627991,
1.333786129951477,
0.1985965520143509,
0.7851341962814331,
0.01676708087325096,
0.5144591927528381,
0.5255927443504333,
0.350248247385025,
-0.7281340956687927,
0.8229632377624512,
-0.19213049113750458,
-0.46000608801841736,
-0.18815164268016815,
-0.3760996460914612,
-0.7106716632843018,
0.11194147169589996,
-0.16743764281272888,
-0.643855094909668,
-0.5398979187011719,
0.5138732194900513,
-0.3032267391681671,
0.326459139585495,
-0.588793158531189,
0.8070254325866699,
-0.3051130771636963,
0.022929519414901733,
0.03318115696310997,
-0.3990812599658966,
0.4613059163093567,
-0.276908814907074,
-0.14309439063072205,
-0.3087494671344757,
-0.003855715040117502,
0.5022215843200684,
-0.36220085620880127,
0.760796844959259,
-0.03342197462916374,
0.07360366731882095,
0.13207919895648956,
0.030200932174921036,
0.5687129497528076,
0.18741150200366974,
-0.04691600427031517,
0.0009548275847919285,
-0.3427262008190155,
-0.28108757734298706,
-0.6277596354484558,
0.7133108973503113,
-0.5399973392486572,
-0.9470698833465576,
-0.03450999781489372,
-0.8988412022590637,
-0.18169619143009186,
0.34711945056915283,
0.24199967086315155,
0.18297231197357178,
-0.4635770916938782,
-0.038269639015197754,
0.4043537676334381,
0.06364507973194122,
0.36144396662712097,
0.1951718032360077,
-0.3218209743499756,
-0.0026975576765835285,
0.8353084921836853,
-0.0753416121006012,
0.06151747331023216,
0.14120231568813324,
0.04497664421796799,
-0.09591316431760788,
-0.8265842795372009,
-0.5671936869621277,
-0.022792384028434753,
-0.496577650308609,
-0.1595492660999298,
-0.34222450852394104,
-0.4082748591899872,
-0.4042464792728424,
-0.25617843866348267,
-0.19788745045661926,
-0.38489875197410583,
-0.4360765218734741,
-0.022838767617940903,
0.11830391734838486,
1.0468286275863647,
0.20280075073242188,
0.7043120861053467,
-0.5090230703353882,
0.2674029469490051,
0.47321179509162903,
0.0683676153421402,
-0.14201244711875916,
-0.38400962948799133,
0.09733214974403381,
-0.0013774336548522115,
-0.42929425835609436,
-0.5882071852684021,
0.6424220204353333,
0.3246026337146759,
0.6797131896018982,
0.2537546157836914,
-0.2506633400917053,
0.39581820368766785,
-0.7792629599571228,
0.7474195957183838,
-0.07218961417675018,
-0.8487867712974548,
0.6112238764762878,
-0.666141152381897,
0.19791382551193237,
0.03496894612908363,
0.12565729022026062,
-0.42810341715812683,
-0.20528171956539154,
-0.5013664364814758,
-1.0042012929916382,
0.5266728401184082,
0.1576060950756073,
0.23843935132026672,
0.3298742473125458,
0.8586792945861816,
0.1703571230173111,
0.29182785749435425,
-0.7570359110832214,
-0.00899114552885294,
-0.084084153175354,
-0.4379445016384125,
-0.25282010436058044,
-0.15280009806156158,
-0.05218857526779175,
0.1530144065618515,
0.7601719498634338,
-0.3956618905067444,
0.40142515301704407,
-0.14813001453876495,
-0.034068312495946884,
0.18600812554359436,
0.3312278985977173,
0.6592071056365967,
0.6938462257385254,
-0.0034787256736308336,
-0.0023273213300853968,
-0.018666882067918777,
-0.3020164668560028,
0.014878555200994015,
0.38134223222732544,
-0.570228099822998,
-0.39525100588798523,
0.30033206939697266,
0.9798694849014282,
-0.1970440149307251,
-0.7341915965080261,
0.15333081781864166,
-0.07919687032699585,
-0.18538746237754822,
-0.4143107831478119,
0.6491149663925171,
0.04417445510625839,
0.5075687170028687,
0.17250582575798035,
-0.10909152030944824,
0.18060317635536194,
-0.3405834138393402,
0.3613625466823578,
0.6704893708229065,
-0.11530789732933044,
-0.34096965193748474,
1.166764497756958,
0.08303329348564148,
-0.6913538575172424,
0.8963359594345093,
0.005349364131689072,
-0.3154431879520416,
0.5136205554008484,
0.7836698889732361,
0.9287784695625305,
-0.0895022377371788,
0.11599601805210114,
-0.003598931711167097,
0.22583884000778198,
-0.0654759407043457,
0.04088625684380531,
0.17959296703338623,
-0.6351270079612732,
-0.23146601021289825,
-0.6132713556289673,
-0.3126119077205658,
0.41931161284446716,
-0.4800242781639099,
0.15774774551391602,
-0.5502163171768188,
-0.12350983917713165,
0.002244272269308567,
-0.2713877856731415,
-0.7394139766693115,
-0.015086420811712742,
0.16971908509731293,
0.7060681581497192,
-0.72489333152771,
0.8286265134811401,
0.6845647692680359,
-0.38607099652290344,
-0.7571219801902771,
0.01649489253759384,
0.05416293069720268,
-1.1277209520339966,
0.5318341255187988,
0.21261978149414062,
0.10566797107458115,
0.2196812927722931,
-0.7249599695205688,
-0.6285185217857361,
1.2652289867401123,
0.6974735856056213,
-0.5126644968986511,
-0.46558889746665955,
0.5741763114929199,
0.4408068060874939,
-0.8455096483230591,
0.17301687598228455,
0.6367797255516052,
0.4399205446243286,
-0.038208961486816406,
-0.8590975403785706,
0.0018651258433237672,
-0.3222682774066925,
0.31429174542427063,
0.02260643057525158,
-0.36790698766708374,
0.8077428936958313,
-0.23514273762702942,
0.08510376513004303,
0.19879207015037537,
0.6789132356643677,
0.17110805213451385,
0.10952326655387878,
0.3073883056640625,
0.5442388653755188,
0.8362325429916382,
-0.05195675417780876,
1.1267856359481812,
-0.10361168533563614,
0.1027199849486351,
1.1096633672714233,
-0.20756521821022034,
0.684562623500824,
0.2771761417388916,
0.09056833386421204,
-0.10743517428636551,
0.7373510599136353,
-0.32401472330093384,
0.3855128884315491,
0.37518399953842163,
-0.20677541196346283,
-0.4045475721359253,
-0.050273142755031586,
-0.1346278339624405,
0.5918004512786865,
0.20889639854431152,
-0.43533045053482056,
-0.27649131417274475,
0.0067765130661427975,
0.03975266218185425,
0.027878109365701675,
-0.42681944370269775,
0.591759204864502,
0.013788008131086826,
-0.5371275544166565,
0.2676716446876526,
0.11832316964864731,
0.4302563965320587,
-0.707668662071228,
-0.1031871810555458,
-0.20882084965705872,
0.14014413952827454,
0.020126089453697205,
-0.5246612429618835,
0.2134280949831009,
0.11820647120475769,
-0.3206436336040497,
-0.2597617208957672,
0.7164751291275024,
-0.3525959849357605,
-0.6420038342475891,
0.019075613468885422,
0.7087790966033936,
0.12939132750034332,
-0.08601260185241699,
-0.8270246982574463,
-0.0688796266913414,
0.30096763372421265,
-0.467926025390625,
0.33784219622612,
0.10114452987909317,
-0.195783793926239,
1.0862370729446411,
0.7101901173591614,
-0.021431196480989456,
0.03264424949884415,
-0.032779429107904434,
0.9012632966041565,
-0.5483761429786682,
-0.31010130047798157,
-0.9791868329048157,
0.42891091108322144,
0.12590625882148743,
-0.3013118505477905,
0.4372038245201111,
0.4456764757633209,
0.7643820643424988,
-0.16809017956256866,
1.1178815364837646,
-0.18554139137268066,
0.28830230236053467,
-0.6321805119514465,
0.823381245136261,
-0.6169467568397522,
0.4465489089488983,
0.16572874784469604,
-1.0010586977005005,
-0.5114068984985352,
0.43682006001472473,
-0.2226424366235733,
0.4067065417766571,
0.10245239734649658,
0.9706136584281921,
-0.27207839488983154,
-0.1841612607240677,
0.3916015326976776,
0.01734182797372341,
0.8758568167686462,
0.4974779486656189,
0.6614182591438293,
-0.05775188282132149,
0.48441123962402344,
0.1753888726234436,
-0.12685845792293549,
-0.0984441488981247,
-1.0760056972503662,
-1.0349441766738892,
-0.500203013420105,
-0.17196588218212128,
0.11698969453573227,
0.12818600237369537,
0.8332445621490479,
0.7743853330612183,
-0.5320113301277161,
-0.12361668050289154,
-0.3534230589866638,
-0.1854371577501297,
0.13227280974388123,
-0.156333789229393,
0.3219809830188751,
-0.411680668592453,
-0.835961103439331,
0.6000100374221802,
0.1127583310008049,
0.22266191244125366,
-0.3762264549732208,
-0.184901624917984,
0.22956304252147675,
0.1825677752494812,
0.2779844403266907,
0.281442254781723,
-0.7678413987159729,
-0.12152068316936493,
0.013471384532749653,
0.07246389985084534,
0.06803224235773087,
1.0026007890701294,
-0.5572367310523987,
0.06855420023202896,
0.3202338218688965,
0.9211347699165344,
0.329844206571579,
-0.05686837062239647,
0.9008113145828247,
-0.6739113926887512,
0.04959608241915703,
0.16493454575538635,
0.4567112326622009,
0.37371495366096497,
-0.4638670086860657,
0.7146841287612915,
0.05641753599047661,
-0.756626546382904,
-0.9669661521911621,
0.600012481212616,
-0.9143555760383606,
-0.1425093710422516,
1.1114740371704102,
-0.057534825056791306,
-0.18624265491962433,
0.3387488126754761,
-0.18437910079956055,
0.21640734374523163,
-0.3240165412425995,
0.6674289107322693,
0.40493595600128174,
-0.4403108060359955,
-0.025562118738889694,
-0.8523968458175659,
0.501522958278656,
0.17079903185367584,
-0.9868946075439453,
0.23188161849975586,
0.4628855586051941,
0.24779647588729858,
-0.15286536514759064,
0.5560510158538818,
0.2578808665275574,
-0.07226313650608063,
-0.09590034186840057,
0.053814761340618134,
-0.5589559674263,
-0.24385814368724823,
-0.15190526843070984,
0.18548987805843353,
0.2363342046737671,
0.20994652807712555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11542v1 | Question Answering Over Spatio-Temporal Knowledge Graph | 2024-02-18T10:44:48 | 2024-02-18T10:44:48 | Xinbang Dai, Huiying Li, Guilin Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.4; I.2.7 | Spatio-temporal knowledge graphs (STKGs) extend the concept of knowledge
graphs (KGs) by incorporating time and location information. While the research
community's focus on Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA), the field of
answering questions incorporating both spatio-temporal information based on
STKGs remains largely unexplored. Furthermore, a lack of comprehensive datasets
also has hindered progress in this area. To address this issue, we present
STQAD, a dataset comprising 10,000 natural language questions for
spatio-temporal knowledge graph question answering (STKGQA). Unfortunately,
various state-of-the-art KGQA approaches fall far short of achieving
satisfactory performance on our dataset. In response, we propose STCQA, a new
spatio-temporal KGQA approach that utilizes a novel STKG embedding method named
STComplEx. By extracting temporal and spatial information from a question, our
QA model can better comprehend the question and retrieve accurate answers from
the STKG. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate the quality of our
dataset and the effectiveness of our STKGQA method. | [
-0.6117804646492004,
-1.2785277366638184,
0.770494818687439,
0.10603632032871246,
-0.3383633494377136,
0.4621058404445648,
0.22111551463603973,
-0.330594927072525,
0.4458705484867096,
0.4004095792770386,
-0.6957986354827881,
-0.7032666206359863,
-0.4820769429206848,
-0.20722927153110504,
0.1826140433549881,
0.35705241560935974,
-0.6006112694740295,
-0.049017440527677536,
-0.5330584049224854,
-0.3839907944202423,
-0.35089632868766785,
-0.31110650300979614,
-0.8581734895706177,
-0.0995444729924202,
0.6938790678977966,
0.458208292722702,
0.8858305215835571,
0.5151528716087341,
0.03986188769340515,
0.13395161926746368,
0.026566198095679283,
0.4569648206233978,
-0.2789525091648102,
-0.17660623788833618,
0.1302861124277115,
0.19859755039215088,
-0.030195150524377823,
-0.3540024161338806,
0.6275420784950256,
1.0901436805725098,
-0.06501201540231705,
0.14602616429328918,
-0.2471061497926712,
0.3521628975868225,
-0.3718789219856262,
0.10196751356124878,
0.020292367786169052,
0.2830984592437744,
0.22857099771499634,
-0.42235520482063293,
-0.04692509025335312,
-0.8736541271209717,
0.4115752577781677,
-0.8961109519004822,
-0.14833885431289673,
-0.019291460514068604,
0.9374026656150818,
0.48740988969802856,
-1.0028715133666992,
-0.2323848009109497,
-0.5592164397239685,
0.1499040275812149,
-0.413632333278656,
0.702096164226532,
0.5495649576187134,
0.8629799485206604,
-0.3215181529521942,
-0.8596406579017639,
-0.720172107219696,
0.17355544865131378,
0.06000150367617607,
0.39300715923309326,
0.06225842982530594,
-0.17393764853477478,
0.0555880069732666,
-0.1354021579027176,
-0.8573911786079407,
-0.21426907181739807,
-0.2531532645225525,
-0.10388694703578949,
0.5365526080131531,
0.27360260486602783,
0.2713574767112732,
-0.412921667098999,
-0.516542911529541,
-0.09100043028593063,
-0.36413079500198364,
0.5998112559318542,
0.3083575665950775,
-0.05780249461531639,
-0.009703090414404869,
0.5051401257514954,
-0.4412594735622406,
0.44556400179862976,
-0.1988133192062378,
0.1591760814189911,
-0.15068235993385315,
-0.39131349325180054,
-0.09829116612672806,
-0.23696480691432953,
0.6847695708274841,
0.4638633728027344,
-0.0006836671964265406,
-0.5937273502349854,
0.7591930031776428,
-0.6039673686027527,
0.168057382106781,
-0.4779699742794037,
-0.35677140951156616,
0.5315686464309692,
-0.04159938171505928,
0.08641456812620163,
-0.2350204885005951,
-0.7444543242454529,
-0.21190182864665985,
-0.23863427340984344,
0.4800621271133423,
-0.568290114402771,
-0.20973709225654602,
-0.10797064751386642,
-0.3487090766429901,
0.3664000928401947,
0.4444328844547272,
-0.2027996927499771,
-0.002988450927659869,
0.41813719272613525,
0.42107146978378296,
0.10863284021615982,
-0.29521217942237854,
-0.19717246294021606,
0.3824385702610016,
-0.4945351779460907,
1.0119986534118652,
-0.6561754941940308,
-0.25392279028892517,
-0.09357918053865433,
0.26986637711524963,
-0.11356939375400543,
-0.32242777943611145,
0.2737601697444916,
-1.1267880201339722,
0.03572225943207741,
-0.7284874320030212,
-0.5818213224411011,
-0.38510963320732117,
0.3837907314300537,
-0.5625773072242737,
1.4050593376159668,
0.37253570556640625,
-0.9429749250411987,
0.45515596866607666,
-0.45973700284957886,
-0.2616654336452484,
0.06270087510347366,
0.06423017382621765,
-0.2852308750152588,
-0.43011799454689026,
0.6414191126823425,
0.18944399058818817,
0.022774681448936462,
0.3086511194705963,
-0.42894986271858215,
-0.12277797609567642,
0.3249836266040802,
0.1378789097070694,
0.6982120871543884,
0.3463601768016815,
0.13376490771770477,
-0.2640097737312317,
-0.33411192893981934,
0.5135401487350464,
0.0952134057879448,
-0.32711538672447205,
-0.2616822123527527,
0.07329845428466797,
-0.5332646369934082,
0.1693388670682907,
0.35905060172080994,
-0.688447892665863,
0.26708605885505676,
-0.30703237652778625,
0.27037373185157776,
0.5030503869056702,
0.5161302089691162,
0.569212019443512,
-0.3632967174053192,
0.6977599859237671,
0.14084702730178833,
0.1601138710975647,
0.5014988780021667,
-0.5406602621078491,
-0.3851635456085205,
-0.03610540181398392,
0.23633168637752533,
0.33260852098464966,
-1.5712800025939941,
0.03959124535322189,
-0.6835991740226746,
-0.8860256671905518,
-0.479625940322876,
-0.18223761022090912,
0.004660164006054401,
0.5261099934577942,
0.5445537567138672,
-0.046796705573797226,
-0.39606568217277527,
-0.7148560881614685,
-0.05359988287091255,
-0.08698398619890213,
-0.16090165078639984,
0.9405975341796875,
0.4144188463687897,
-0.009094337932765484,
1.1641613245010376,
-0.8581585884094238,
0.5216748118400574,
-0.15975193679332733,
0.2153538018465042,
-0.07149864733219147,
-0.05909474566578865,
0.5532038807868958,
-0.6907070875167847,
-0.5903500914573669,
-0.16767629981040955,
-0.530523419380188,
-0.06973020732402802,
0.30551254749298096,
-0.6123425960540771,
-0.14620788395404816,
0.32034406065940857,
-0.6016521453857422,
0.5673316717147827,
0.3721705377101898,
-0.5392457246780396,
0.5411671996116638,
0.05864163860678673,
0.6228923201560974,
-1.2636728286743164,
0.03676293417811394,
-0.78556227684021,
-0.13571473956108093,
-0.843540608882904,
0.01820172369480133,
-0.003195842495188117,
-0.25891000032424927,
-0.5094714164733887,
0.5773850679397583,
0.1461934596300125,
-0.2473418116569519,
0.016575301066040993,
0.3682239353656769,
0.20906607806682587,
0.7425505518913269,
0.15535180270671844,
0.4275565445423126,
0.2270512878894806,
-0.7529168725013733,
0.35689061880111694,
0.4557868540287018,
-0.2776639759540558,
0.08301366120576859,
-0.674201488494873,
0.4756913483142853,
-0.46212196350097656,
0.38117682933807373,
-1.2076066732406616,
-0.16290530562400818,
0.2293504774570465,
-0.5368511080741882,
-0.030869225040078163,
-0.6280279755592346,
-0.7249871492385864,
-0.6016403436660767,
0.003216818440705538,
0.7011585235595703,
-0.061203572899103165,
-0.6350055932998657,
0.8217448592185974,
0.4823203980922699,
-0.26403820514678955,
-0.5530055165290833,
-0.28387388586997986,
-0.20332054793834686,
-0.06311407685279846,
-0.8839768767356873,
-0.10748360306024551,
-0.04124229773879051,
0.22359584271907806,
0.15110808610916138,
-0.12801264226436615,
-0.5165936946868896,
0.05812500789761543,
0.06454961001873016,
0.027082350105047226,
-0.028788577765226364,
0.2846912443637848,
0.04931262880563736,
-0.1533457636833191,
-0.022543929517269135,
-0.4107862114906311,
0.5827771425247192,
0.5817683339118958,
-0.32737407088279724,
-0.14778512716293335,
0.6932017803192139,
0.4135112762451172,
-0.14133530855178833,
0.5597271919250488,
0.6042956709861755,
-0.3828442692756653,
-0.09605435281991959,
-0.09767506271600723,
-0.011420190334320068,
-0.4533337354660034,
0.27411025762557983,
-0.30311188101768494,
-1.155178427696228,
0.602751612663269,
-0.06859186291694641,
-0.09494080394506454,
0.04465356096625328,
0.25772663950920105,
-0.6088749170303345,
0.8363783955574036,
0.17887993156909943,
0.19146347045898438,
0.08768745511770248,
-0.2408871203660965,
0.5510938763618469,
-0.6197944283485413,
-0.4111250042915344,
-0.4844858944416046,
-0.547421395778656,
-0.3138490915298462,
-0.8014654517173767,
0.5742139220237732,
0.21995092928409576,
-0.44524258375167847,
0.20053333044052124,
-0.3574965000152588,
0.2923063039779663,
0.5143122673034668,
0.2284998893737793,
0.03511815890669823,
-0.04629744961857796,
-0.4061141610145569,
-0.15623344480991364,
-1.0962477922439575,
-0.24781380593776703,
0.74711012840271,
0.24161821603775024,
0.4470203220844269,
0.46546822786331177,
0.20473475754261017,
-0.14975309371948242,
0.13957053422927856,
-0.45949074625968933,
0.5329917669296265,
-0.060955245047807693,
-0.4783436059951782,
-0.5580095052719116,
-0.7645375728607178,
-0.9644976258277893,
0.06252302974462509,
0.0391908623278141,
-0.7047256231307983,
0.18531517684459686,
-0.1259952038526535,
-0.5218126773834229,
0.5098986029624939,
-0.7315423488616943,
0.9925593733787537,
-0.23155610263347626,
-0.11304384469985962,
0.2605144679546356,
-0.5790891051292419,
-0.015884386375546455,
0.3366609215736389,
0.22570641338825226,
-0.34878775477409363,
0.10226840525865555,
1.0912712812423706,
-0.5523383021354675,
0.4682321846485138,
-0.5951086282730103,
0.07418308407068253,
0.6624769568443298,
0.12498650699853897,
0.533880889415741,
0.11803099513053894,
0.2480161041021347,
-0.05119256302714348,
0.5859652161598206,
-0.704944372177124,
-0.925817608833313,
0.455638587474823,
-0.981479823589325,
-0.2636559307575226,
-0.15119265019893646,
-0.8022480607032776,
-0.7240501642227173,
-0.09370274096727371,
0.0520554780960083,
0.6959879398345947,
-0.013403411954641342,
-0.052622418850660324,
0.5103799104690552,
-0.490776389837265,
0.2935543656349182,
0.502983570098877,
-0.1333460956811905,
-0.5302069783210754,
0.5057490468025208,
0.43271663784980774,
0.16787341237068176,
0.5123488306999207,
0.2749261260032654,
-0.8732705116271973,
-0.37250635027885437,
-0.5152212977409363,
0.18239116668701172,
-0.697893500328064,
-0.15520039200782776,
-0.9562337398529053,
-0.2352290153503418,
-0.6797193884849548,
-0.3162118196487427,
-0.1351996511220932,
-0.5900843739509583,
0.08482105284929276,
-0.1552676111459732,
0.6455491781234741,
0.5313230752944946,
0.3252220153808594,
0.17293505370616913,
-0.8307070732116699,
0.4260365068912506,
0.7118026614189148,
0.3727709949016571,
0.09788909554481506,
-0.40790465474128723,
-0.15673871338367462,
0.2649681270122528,
-0.09243661165237427,
-0.976463794708252,
0.20487184822559357,
0.04643721133470535,
0.5807268023490906,
0.12159640341997147,
0.4413144290447235,
1.1467974185943604,
-0.4238714873790741,
0.8639659881591797,
-0.2987087666988373,
-0.23976832628250122,
0.4922378957271576,
-0.4522363245487213,
0.6804555654525757,
0.5287415385246277,
0.869219183921814,
-0.7062645554542542,
-0.4289992153644562,
-0.7414790391921997,
-0.9011365175247192,
0.3819175660610199,
-0.06335090100765228,
-0.3152197003364563,
0.004375400487333536,
0.48706570267677307,
-0.047665711492300034,
0.2918391823768616,
-0.11022310703992844,
-0.3024005889892578,
-0.49439099431037903,
-0.3325269818305969,
0.021444957703351974,
-0.13134528696537018,
-0.22830428183078766,
-0.1339702159166336,
0.08492927998304367,
-0.29477062821388245,
0.6079163551330566,
0.4062648117542267,
0.00041073080501519144,
0.006277849432080984,
0.3420516550540924,
0.03975026309490204,
0.5521701574325562,
-0.13848228752613068,
0.41182518005371094,
0.6496554017066956,
-0.4335254430770874,
0.056051332503557205,
0.09982903301715851,
-0.2325337529182434,
-0.20681317150592804,
0.30587238073349,
0.23773236572742462,
0.33167070150375366,
-0.5088971853256226,
0.44872987270355225,
-0.09428664296865463,
-0.3972518742084503,
-0.3361556828022003,
-0.2763862907886505,
0.46832960844039917,
0.3360261917114258,
0.4982765018939972,
-0.4300228953361511,
-0.10736257582902908,
-0.34594762325286865,
0.3940843939781189,
0.21749959886074066,
-0.4674890637397766,
-0.04357456788420677,
0.5883505344390869,
-0.20251649618148804,
0.07379040867090225,
0.4253217875957489,
-0.21703316271305084,
-0.8510535359382629,
0.9091454148292542,
0.13217605650424957,
0.31023895740509033,
0.11614613234996796,
0.509958803653717,
0.515183687210083,
0.13213028013706207,
0.6255289912223816,
0.7205755710601807,
-0.1174904927611351,
-0.7264269590377808,
-0.4335942566394806,
-0.5800881385803223,
-0.43966543674468994,
-0.2555251121520996,
-0.43295934796333313,
-0.3232074975967407,
-0.5454689860343933,
-0.13354487717151642,
-0.24242915213108063,
0.4570130407810211,
-0.7617909908294678,
0.1654425859451294,
-0.32516351342201233,
1.107521414756775,
-0.5424548983573914,
0.5668330788612366,
0.8112798929214478,
-0.040374092757701874,
-1.157414436340332,
-0.3185211420059204,
-0.35243090987205505,
-0.5933369994163513,
0.5617649555206299,
-0.342180460691452,
-0.04986906424164772,
0.21062548458576202,
-0.7215774655342102,
-0.8839965462684631,
1.531622052192688,
-0.029400674626231194,
0.18786993622779846,
0.20492663979530334,
0.6784971952438354,
0.5497171878814697,
-0.20085567235946655,
0.19543954730033875,
0.4656849205493927,
0.6228949427604675,
0.5972635746002197,
-0.6439846158027649,
0.0468081571161747,
-0.1465250551700592,
-0.45879730582237244,
0.2090892493724823,
-0.7029336094856262,
0.30168262124061584,
-0.15119235217571259,
-0.5631590485572815,
-0.14697740972042084,
0.5640400648117065,
0.1798890084028244,
0.6816445589065552,
0.37998461723327637,
1.0088226795196533,
0.8717888593673706,
-0.4739528000354767,
1.0956779718399048,
-0.047782812267541885,
0.1347474455833435,
1.136956810951233,
-0.03225935623049736,
0.8662571310997009,
0.32594794034957886,
-0.3381127715110779,
0.3922731280326843,
0.9592042565345764,
0.4169664978981018,
0.6350743174552917,
-0.05631539970636368,
-0.16464653611183167,
-0.5721209049224854,
-0.24720576405525208,
-0.28843817114830017,
0.20691333711147308,
0.03402309864759445,
0.4063757359981537,
-0.3953661322593689,
-0.12263187766075134,
-0.011774501763284206,
-0.29121318459510803,
-0.2295394092798233,
0.7916500568389893,
-0.19636188447475433,
-0.6389870643615723,
0.2370697259902954,
-0.258633017539978,
-0.138364776968956,
-0.7179534435272217,
0.11873503774404526,
-0.3441435694694519,
-0.4717291593551636,
0.08223842084407806,
-1.0517849922180176,
0.34531116485595703,
-0.35843607783317566,
0.09388809651136398,
0.004494435619562864,
0.34602034091949463,
-0.6448490619659424,
-0.22191204130649567,
0.27249452471733093,
0.5904431939125061,
-0.08006330579519272,
0.2630447745323181,
-0.4680291712284088,
-0.5614038705825806,
-0.18826082348823547,
0.23436586558818817,
0.08839208632707596,
0.7820534706115723,
0.19788716733455658,
1.0496416091918945,
0.6708641648292542,
-0.22634626924991608,
0.34813496470451355,
-0.1513804793357849,
0.9164848327636719,
-0.6746363639831543,
-0.7427974939346313,
0.034626204520463943,
0.4802183508872986,
-0.03154366835951805,
-0.23683418333530426,
0.8613656163215637,
0.3876158893108368,
0.46350130438804626,
0.25449177622795105,
0.6466128826141357,
-0.15736405551433563,
0.6921765804290771,
-0.4772430658340454,
0.634766697883606,
-0.5717613697052002,
-0.032075878232717514,
-0.09620831161737442,
-0.3979761302471161,
-0.050399571657180786,
0.25792405009269714,
-0.5885974764823914,
-0.03955172374844551,
0.8387401700019836,
0.8672415018081665,
0.12533563375473022,
0.24882833659648895,
0.07715949416160583,
0.11872684210538864,
0.23649482429027557,
1.0612781047821045,
1.1915457248687744,
-0.636987030506134,
0.9089866280555725,
-0.38560086488723755,
0.02236984670162201,
-0.09509502351284027,
-0.5514112710952759,
-0.7165783047676086,
-0.6972826719284058,
-0.34791237115859985,
-0.29686591029167175,
0.043117668479681015,
0.5679959058761597,
0.5183566212654114,
-0.7178193926811218,
0.41841909289360046,
0.6000835299491882,
0.3503875732421875,
-0.14801062643527985,
-0.24575714766979218,
0.9199395179748535,
0.19422626495361328,
-0.3844996392726898,
0.34456801414489746,
0.11891595274209976,
0.2109462469816208,
0.221913680434227,
-0.12060444056987762,
-0.44965675473213196,
0.017716236412525177,
0.38143229484558105,
0.4289553165435791,
-0.04845888912677765,
-0.9217574596405029,
0.3588624596595764,
0.00004824226925848052,
-0.022079022601246834,
0.8243484497070312,
-0.5187826752662659,
0.48977434635162354,
0.7901904582977295,
0.8818261623382568,
0.5872460007667542,
0.3311338424682617,
0.36642587184906006,
-1.0261240005493164,
-0.2574233114719391,
0.24415455758571625,
0.028619032353162766,
0.12164059281349182,
-0.21130217611789703,
0.3002317249774933,
0.14627526700496674,
-0.6376898884773254,
-0.17159222066402435,
0.3601253926753998,
-1.168426275253296,
-0.37759000062942505,
1.1579238176345825,
0.018894674256443977,
-0.4245009124279022,
-1.1177771091461182,
-0.02963213436305523,
0.3607608675956726,
-0.09229237586259842,
0.6800409555435181,
0.7064470648765564,
-0.11461962759494781,
-0.24284377694129944,
-0.5936705470085144,
0.524901807308197,
0.12017714232206345,
-0.77519291639328,
0.04422703757882118,
0.4357065260410309,
0.30062630772590637,
-0.035239797085523605,
0.8648959398269653,
-0.13617339730262756,
0.4616304934024811,
0.1350603848695755,
-0.2910470962524414,
-0.32334721088409424,
-0.21048776805400848,
0.37685492634773254,
0.608288049697876,
-0.12076257914304733,
-0.07250311970710754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11541v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11541v3 | Large Language Models Can Better Understand Knowledge Graphs Than We Thought | 2024-02-18T10:44:03 | 2024-06-16T14:16:56 | Xinbang Dai, Yuncheng Hua, Tongtong Wu, Yang Sheng, Qiu Ji, Guilin Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.4; I.2.7 | As the parameter scale of large language models (LLMs) grows, jointly
training knowledge graph (KG) embeddings with model parameters to enhance LLM
capabilities becomes increasingly costly. Consequently, the community has shown
interest in developing prompt strategies that effectively integrate KG
information into LLMs. However, the format for incorporating KGs into LLMs
lacks standardization; for instance, KGs can be transformed into linearized
triples or natural language (NL) text. Current prompting methods often rely on
a trial-and-error approach, leaving researchers with an incomplete
understanding of which KG input format best facilitates LLM comprehension of KG
content. To elucidate this, we design a series of experiments to explore LLMs'
understanding of different KG input formats within the context of prompt
engineering. Our analysis examines both literal and attention distribution
levels. Through extensive experiments, we indicate a counter-intuitive
phenomenon: when addressing fact-related questions, unordered linearized
triples are more effective for LLMs' understanding of KGs compared to fluent NL
text. Furthermore, noisy, incomplete, or marginally relevant subgraphs can
still enhance LLM performance. Finally, different LLMs have distinct
preferences for different formats of organizing unordered triples. | [
-0.5648307204246521,
-0.8466908931732178,
1.0070600509643555,
0.2824476659297943,
-0.2938774526119232,
0.12256202846765518,
-0.31382089853286743,
-0.20142798125743866,
-0.0385286882519722,
0.187217578291893,
-0.4194939136505127,
-0.5104125142097473,
-0.5939950942993164,
0.2757187783718109,
-0.08042427897453308,
0.7684602737426758,
-0.3149939179420471,
0.1275302618741989,
-0.49501556158065796,
-0.2393053025007248,
-0.552087664604187,
-0.492127001285553,
-0.6163175702095032,
-0.5338912606239319,
1.0154236555099487,
0.14445523917675018,
0.7921619415283203,
0.699102520942688,
0.10360945016145706,
0.21389718353748322,
-0.2968646287918091,
0.3040556013584137,
-0.448828786611557,
0.1762862205505371,
0.04619212821125984,
-0.38476064801216125,
-0.27056142687797546,
0.152816504240036,
0.601859450340271,
1.2540465593338013,
0.23741400241851807,
-0.003068953985348344,
0.44250744581222534,
0.6774812340736389,
-0.36904990673065186,
0.7712095975875854,
-0.11481287330389023,
0.058775924146175385,
0.13129523396492004,
-0.23803073167800903,
-0.6372541189193726,
-0.4965801537036896,
0.1369428038597107,
-0.8298724889755249,
-0.014798849821090698,
0.3049563467502594,
0.61049485206604,
0.2726100981235504,
-0.7025337219238281,
-0.3584798574447632,
-0.4845066964626312,
0.43718528747558594,
-0.5673230886459351,
0.6635890007019043,
0.17709580063819885,
0.20707577466964722,
-0.2954663932323456,
-0.5540839433670044,
-0.4944152235984802,
-0.18132510781288147,
-0.404178649187088,
-0.13967783749103546,
-0.1185675784945488,
0.3963901698589325,
0.43228453397750854,
0.04164516180753708,
-0.4644620418548584,
0.3416077792644501,
-0.16235783696174622,
-0.2840704321861267,
0.3552773594856262,
0.08682047575712204,
0.2768497169017792,
-0.32581281661987305,
-0.08090957254171371,
-0.1551009714603424,
-0.6425896883010864,
0.21410244703292847,
0.28713861107826233,
0.47069689631462097,
-0.09289922565221786,
0.5119216442108154,
-0.34698352217674255,
1.030709981918335,
-0.013814812526106834,
-0.2647711932659149,
0.25984033942222595,
-0.3777520954608917,
-0.10969533026218414,
-0.09990335255861282,
0.9883397221565247,
0.3244996964931488,
0.5117853879928589,
-0.4163879454135895,
-0.13710254430770874,
-0.28580278158187866,
-0.07230737060308456,
-0.7251386046409607,
-0.23392412066459656,
0.04543263837695122,
-0.3055340647697449,
-0.18290933966636658,
-0.29329389333724976,
-0.43751898407936096,
-0.7900828123092651,
-0.6014952063560486,
0.4672882556915283,
-0.40336430072784424,
-0.037170860916376114,
0.17604269087314606,
-0.34552282094955444,
0.07447337359189987,
0.3409641683101654,
-0.9654425382614136,
-0.11277998238801956,
0.462819904088974,
0.6745253205299377,
-0.01866203360259533,
-0.1623169183731079,
-0.49082374572753906,
0.07731696963310242,
-0.4460575580596924,
0.8303167819976807,
-0.5040011405944824,
-0.22944721579551697,
-0.004989293869584799,
-0.12492495775222778,
-0.24058668315410614,
-0.33322057127952576,
0.3184344172477722,
-0.9975504279136658,
0.19800147414207458,
-0.7841475009918213,
-0.5735996961593628,
-0.2334510087966919,
0.35901525616645813,
-0.5879122018814087,
0.9171857833862305,
0.09714348614215851,
-0.9115288853645325,
0.5784818530082703,
-0.653360903263092,
-0.37199854850769043,
-0.18110878765583038,
-0.2903711497783661,
0.1235276609659195,
-0.077735036611557,
0.6655732989311218,
0.6761407852172852,
-0.3042348325252533,
0.41916424036026,
-0.4905231297016144,
-0.11581921577453613,
0.26375672221183777,
-0.4672399163246155,
0.6689802408218384,
0.05830853432416916,
0.11138216406106949,
0.051511216908693314,
-0.568019688129425,
-0.047747112810611725,
0.09670547395944595,
-0.44824448227882385,
-0.3228469491004944,
-0.14744119346141815,
-0.6068031787872314,
0.08632224798202515,
0.19695016741752625,
-0.3328605592250824,
0.3439755439758301,
-0.4401976764202118,
0.5118603110313416,
0.7314871549606323,
0.14279642701148987,
0.6103793978691101,
-0.17926421761512756,
0.5503314733505249,
-0.10666096210479736,
-0.06462592631578445,
-0.16614536941051483,
-0.4423676133155823,
-0.6661731600761414,
-0.1942981481552124,
0.2433413565158844,
0.24917984008789062,
-0.915959358215332,
0.12442903220653534,
-0.22060683369636536,
-0.30656805634498596,
-0.34943708777427673,
0.3203941881656647,
0.17316854000091553,
0.7571361660957336,
0.2650119364261627,
0.04903484135866165,
-0.3745045065879822,
-0.8207181692123413,
-0.25740888714790344,
-0.2172563076019287,
-0.04588926210999489,
0.3030104339122772,
0.10833204537630081,
0.11587197333574295,
1.269551396369934,
-0.5649542212486267,
0.16488294303417206,
-0.587442934513092,
0.262936532497406,
0.4437432289123535,
-0.08139870315790176,
0.6226466298103333,
-0.5167889595031738,
-0.5971404910087585,
-0.08124793320894241,
-0.9419438242912292,
-0.28338485956192017,
0.15218259394168854,
-0.05451919510960579,
-0.09783155471086502,
0.7106387615203857,
-0.5916388630867004,
0.18272210657596588,
0.37144139409065247,
-0.21544986963272095,
0.36623305082321167,
-0.10769946128129959,
0.09397696703672409,
-0.9346280097961426,
-0.1698019951581955,
-0.13167598843574524,
-0.19846223294734955,
-0.6684978604316711,
-0.14298005402088165,
0.20837195217609406,
0.011701197363436222,
-0.17933723330497742,
0.5947539806365967,
-0.6441320776939392,
-0.28496646881103516,
-0.09718232601881027,
0.4506281614303589,
0.33966562151908875,
0.5782632231712341,
-0.19723595678806305,
0.865066409111023,
0.5488991737365723,
-0.7839705348014832,
0.6329441666603088,
0.20753322541713715,
-0.3433353900909424,
0.45603373646736145,
-0.8290003538131714,
0.18739238381385803,
-0.48948127031326294,
0.33810752630233765,
-1.2009117603302002,
-0.4733966290950775,
0.15668807923793793,
-0.35959869623184204,
0.46181756258010864,
-0.2640892267227173,
-0.8497121930122375,
-0.43082985281944275,
-0.22202740609645844,
0.3375093638896942,
0.6007730960845947,
-0.7291810512542725,
0.5257799625396729,
0.20934949815273285,
-0.08604833483695984,
-0.5348840355873108,
-0.4522898495197296,
-0.06759146600961685,
-0.18331967294216156,
-0.7996964454650879,
-0.1752907782793045,
0.0011411423329263926,
-0.29671338200569153,
-0.012715181335806847,
-0.05286216735839844,
0.08915720880031586,
0.16368401050567627,
0.01476308237761259,
0.15399451553821564,
-0.39479637145996094,
0.49283739924430847,
-0.01644011214375496,
-0.06725452095270157,
0.27178025245666504,
-0.5700668096542358,
0.6847622990608215,
0.253173291683197,
-0.37784650921821594,
-0.43608659505844116,
0.030339833348989487,
0.5746609568595886,
-0.0626082792878151,
1.0341858863830566,
0.4585167467594147,
-0.01844891719520092,
-0.23159363865852356,
-0.38372358679771423,
-0.18996375799179077,
-0.5186489820480347,
0.24164755642414093,
-0.2901919186115265,
-0.9203112125396729,
0.44376805424690247,
-0.1049066111445427,
0.01750052347779274,
0.276440292596817,
0.2596447765827179,
-0.25634580850601196,
1.179165244102478,
0.6001569032669067,
-0.012225505895912647,
0.2802118957042694,
0.059858743101358414,
0.4241268038749695,
-0.788933277130127,
-0.3376067280769348,
-0.5287379026412964,
-0.2759856581687927,
-0.21756552159786224,
-0.26355987787246704,
0.6691585779190063,
0.3322405219078064,
-0.18579146265983582,
0.04778793081641197,
-0.22059954702854156,
0.6079530119895935,
0.3949667513370514,
0.0011139189591631293,
0.2303784191608429,
0.09175531566143036,
-0.44100967049598694,
0.0069759683683514595,
-0.9557681679725647,
-0.3915931284427643,
0.881917417049408,
0.3860538899898529,
0.9137645363807678,
-0.1075274869799614,
0.537785530090332,
-0.05126126855611801,
0.3228563666343689,
-0.9408388733863831,
0.43584492802619934,
0.07048825174570084,
-0.21970275044441223,
-0.37389999628067017,
-0.5004913210868835,
-0.9696415662765503,
-0.0063863955438137054,
0.08281074464321136,
-0.6962898969650269,
0.05046405643224716,
0.24883875250816345,
-0.45717817544937134,
0.25003135204315186,
-0.9168587923049927,
0.8957522511482239,
0.04565372318029404,
0.08858195692300797,
0.20399238169193268,
-0.5046178698539734,
0.17334342002868652,
-0.0923292338848114,
0.5302785634994507,
-0.011501272208988667,
0.09489600360393524,
0.8795818090438843,
-0.33252328634262085,
1.0170005559921265,
-0.23859767615795135,
-0.36700010299682617,
0.31488874554634094,
0.10235875099897385,
0.7092608213424683,
0.029064632952213287,
-0.09780599921941757,
-0.19725415110588074,
-0.47889062762260437,
-0.4028628468513489,
-1.1003696918487549,
0.5344261527061462,
-1.0380983352661133,
-0.8475232720375061,
0.10876183211803436,
-0.9679268598556519,
-0.6602145433425903,
0.18488191068172455,
0.09891615808010101,
0.731495201587677,
0.2092718780040741,
0.22081972658634186,
1.034969449043274,
-0.2658579647541046,
0.38537245988845825,
0.39094316959381104,
-0.247358039021492,
-0.20046623051166534,
0.48417115211486816,
0.3487583100795746,
0.6344769597053528,
0.46159031987190247,
0.37506040930747986,
-0.5234540104866028,
-0.544491708278656,
-0.41177108883857727,
0.3490801453590393,
-1.171428918838501,
0.015179906971752644,
-1.0726635456085205,
-0.19903552532196045,
-0.770752489566803,
-0.18802502751350403,
0.06962963938713074,
-0.3269197642803192,
-0.33423444628715515,
-0.407939076423645,
0.6819194555282593,
1.125913381576538,
-0.005393637344241142,
0.3370901644229889,
-0.8002256751060486,
0.21269218623638153,
0.5753504037857056,
0.277631014585495,
0.17788396775722504,
-0.6966937184333801,
-0.0756368488073349,
-0.03288562223315239,
0.06534600257873535,
-1.0242221355438232,
0.13705097138881683,
-0.2123059332370758,
0.7013906836509705,
0.359777569770813,
0.15735062956809998,
0.5368924736976624,
-0.39544185996055603,
0.7561575174331665,
0.03600872680544853,
-0.7324842214584351,
0.36393171548843384,
-0.4880470931529999,
0.3353264331817627,
0.2823634147644043,
0.5570075511932373,
-0.680826723575592,
-0.2834746241569519,
-0.24644729495048523,
-0.6610358357429504,
0.9511533975601196,
-0.17362578213214874,
0.2316267192363739,
0.011238493025302887,
0.3425753712654114,
0.09489644318819046,
0.2137029767036438,
-0.7029680013656616,
-0.26906296610832214,
0.024537352845072746,
-0.26323506236076355,
-0.15339505672454834,
-0.36864131689071655,
-0.14607451856136322,
-0.0894443541765213,
0.41507741808891296,
-0.20854398608207703,
0.11222846806049347,
0.05645862594246864,
0.032691776752471924,
0.08236350864171982,
0.24124526977539062,
0.18682630360126495,
0.6251426935195923,
-0.020290786400437355,
0.5354700088500977,
0.2432645857334137,
-0.21618270874023438,
0.09315620362758636,
0.021524297073483467,
-0.1410023421049118,
-0.15317966043949127,
0.6374972462654114,
0.8963313698768616,
0.19916895031929016,
-0.1907251626253128,
0.3885519504547119,
0.07508574426174164,
-0.12397923320531845,
0.24959847331047058,
0.15800225734710693,
0.39978814125061035,
0.16221536695957184,
0.21548448503017426,
-0.12429019063711166,
-0.15776145458221436,
-0.5406190156936646,
-0.07168365269899368,
0.29530951380729675,
-0.3977779746055603,
-0.1741660088300705,
0.47635403275489807,
0.2410833239555359,
-0.1391509473323822,
0.5166500806808472,
-0.4637252986431122,
-0.5910742282867432,
0.6098493933677673,
0.419511079788208,
0.4688895642757416,
0.11536452919244766,
0.3575724959373474,
0.32360658049583435,
0.3602742850780487,
-0.029149211943149567,
0.13407838344573975,
-0.13299791514873505,
-0.796676754951477,
-0.6781977415084839,
-0.522870659828186,
-0.12511105835437775,
0.01778484880924225,
-0.39277273416519165,
0.26845791935920715,
-0.4321114122867584,
0.08129067718982697,
0.07111874967813492,
-0.24197624623775482,
-0.8187987208366394,
-0.1439652144908905,
0.1664614975452423,
0.9321177005767822,
-0.9601128101348877,
0.5939419865608215,
0.6785131692886353,
-0.37517446279525757,
-1.4266622066497803,
-0.12770628929138184,
-0.06636998802423477,
-1.0729422569274902,
0.9652262330055237,
0.23104150593280792,
0.15304188430309296,
0.08024746179580688,
-0.6365361213684082,
-1.0803214311599731,
1.0755996704101562,
0.4553513824939728,
-0.32792940735816956,
-0.16088758409023285,
0.30133056640625,
0.39942094683647156,
-0.1357400119304657,
0.26294586062431335,
0.4270978271961212,
0.678389847278595,
0.336058646440506,
-0.9779582619667053,
0.14141659438610077,
0.15656262636184692,
-0.16817840933799744,
0.37600141763687134,
-0.5796079635620117,
0.7463883757591248,
-0.2314835488796234,
-0.2488209456205368,
-0.3155224323272705,
0.622979462146759,
0.15790937840938568,
0.35564887523651123,
0.5090674161911011,
0.3537793457508087,
0.8586385250091553,
-0.04364606365561485,
1.1398358345031738,
-0.11717512458562851,
0.13167376816272736,
0.8649901747703552,
-0.22779759764671326,
0.2205830067396164,
0.432306170463562,
-0.23804797232151031,
0.3795287609100342,
0.7281539440155029,
0.33474478125572205,
0.3697248697280884,
0.1143670529127121,
0.018466467037796974,
-0.4090377986431122,
-0.4310581386089325,
-0.3037964701652527,
-0.04616349935531616,
0.4059140086174011,
-0.37746208906173706,
-0.44351550936698914,
0.1456044614315033,
0.28637152910232544,
-0.08686260133981705,
-0.2766307592391968,
0.7533896565437317,
0.14341136813163757,
-0.7410180568695068,
0.5702893733978271,
-0.24810558557510376,
0.2721404731273651,
-0.565339982509613,
0.12767529487609863,
-0.3231951892375946,
-0.3008630573749542,
-0.15689337253570557,
-1.0427662134170532,
-0.11141398549079895,
-0.09554880112409592,
-0.2398969978094101,
-0.4559515416622162,
0.5241150856018066,
-0.2856139838695526,
-0.12638692557811737,
0.30528122186660767,
0.5834709405899048,
0.026520313695073128,
0.0854090079665184,
-0.28657475113868713,
0.07600893080234528,
-0.014173912815749645,
-0.39834827184677124,
0.2730726897716522,
0.9620082974433899,
0.0012044935720041394,
0.6302962899208069,
0.574554979801178,
-0.24927450716495514,
0.056874584406614304,
0.3557094931602478,
1.1223020553588867,
-0.30565547943115234,
-0.4843524992465973,
-0.9222427010536194,
0.3233458697795868,
-0.13972972333431244,
-0.09173214435577393,
0.9036166071891785,
0.15280276536941528,
0.5446741580963135,
0.0593697652220726,
0.740838348865509,
0.04592365399003029,
0.1771727055311203,
-0.8051422238349915,
0.4569946527481079,
-0.3647878170013428,
0.3053385317325592,
-0.09273100644350052,
-0.8393536806106567,
-0.26477617025375366,
0.18385110795497894,
-0.5597707033157349,
0.16099834442138672,
0.7956759929656982,
0.7005632519721985,
0.057089515030384064,
0.0976613312959671,
0.3182102143764496,
0.41884496808052063,
0.3642013669013977,
0.4860786497592926,
1.0847275257110596,
0.1288115233182907,
0.7265528440475464,
-0.0044175260700285435,
-0.22442446649074554,
0.048633038997650146,
-0.8035590052604675,
-1.353795051574707,
-0.3271726071834564,
-0.08378579467535019,
-0.2575109899044037,
-0.13416364789009094,
0.9919880628585815,
0.6200920343399048,
-0.4651638865470886,
0.14776666462421417,
-0.11112941801548004,
0.3391934931278229,
0.30228546261787415,
-0.20196273922920227,
0.4097125828266144,
-0.6881573796272278,
-0.4315112233161926,
0.5331912040710449,
0.3098059892654419,
0.1315230131149292,
-0.3336533308029175,
0.025462955236434937,
0.11552517861127853,
0.019566822797060013,
0.497437447309494,
0.03920011967420578,
-0.5395222306251526,
-0.5892372727394104,
0.2888706624507904,
-0.14331349730491638,
-0.03227466344833374,
0.8841784000396729,
-0.905584454536438,
0.475417822599411,
0.8274863958358765,
0.7606651186943054,
0.07452235370874405,
-0.18861840665340424,
0.6861622333526611,
-1.058314323425293,
0.06994760781526566,
-0.06392905116081238,
0.4220038950443268,
0.340404748916626,
-0.5089709162712097,
0.3317987620830536,
0.33108875155448914,
-0.5075218677520752,
-0.6774688363075256,
0.4106827676296234,
-0.6798412799835205,
-0.2840266525745392,
1.507076382637024,
-0.03736716881394386,
-0.26598891615867615,
-0.35658907890319824,
-0.309258371591568,
0.3257368803024292,
-0.4326818883419037,
0.4561668932437897,
0.966515302658081,
-0.2063458114862442,
-0.027691258117556572,
-0.5884907841682434,
0.443897008895874,
0.2806576192378998,
-0.5787627100944519,
0.22574153542518616,
0.43889614939689636,
0.18057934939861298,
0.16060546040534973,
0.613347589969635,
0.11114026606082916,
0.058259230107069016,
-0.1686106026172638,
-0.3152686059474945,
-0.24723105132579803,
-0.25525638461112976,
-0.2446698546409607,
0.30580592155456543,
0.3975376486778259,
0.18629808723926544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11537v2 | Deciphering the Impact of Pretraining Data on Large Language Models through Machine Unlearning | 2024-02-18T10:36:05 | 2024-03-26T10:45:40 | Yang Zhao, Li Du, Xiao Ding, Kai Xiong, Zhouhao Sun, Jun Shi, Ting Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Through pretraining on a corpus with various sources, Large Language Models
(LLMs) have gained impressive performance. However, the impact of each
component of the pretraining corpus remains opaque. As a result, the
organization of the pretraining corpus is still empirical and may deviate from
the optimal. To address this issue, we systematically analyze the impact of 48
datasets from 5 major categories of pretraining data of LLMs and measure their
impacts on LLMs using benchmarks about nine major categories of model
capabilities. Our analyses provide empirical results about the contribution of
multiple corpora on the performances of LLMs, along with their joint impact
patterns, including complementary, orthogonal, and correlational relationships.
We also identify a set of ``high-impact data'' such as Books that is
significantly related to a set of model capabilities. These findings provide
insights into the organization of data to support more efficient pretraining of
LLMs. | [
-0.3180541694164276,
-0.55494225025177,
0.5337969064712524,
0.060578830540180206,
-0.05583284795284271,
0.27525386214256287,
-0.445244163274765,
-0.44530123472213745,
-0.29548180103302,
0.8660098910331726,
-0.375424861907959,
-0.5233253240585327,
-0.7977733612060547,
0.097569040954113,
-0.498721718788147,
1.0383681058883667,
0.021723346784710884,
0.3108062148094177,
-0.39418327808380127,
-0.16532571613788605,
-0.49240750074386597,
-0.8509729504585266,
0.14698348939418793,
-0.30231955647468567,
0.587654173374176,
0.22286714613437653,
0.610943615436554,
0.8960715532302856,
0.5927553772926331,
0.3224789500236511,
-0.021180367097258568,
-0.13203133642673492,
-0.7781547904014587,
-0.09378538280725479,
-0.0823906660079956,
-0.7021788954734802,
-0.22222252190113068,
0.2849380671977997,
1.069347858428955,
1.088069200515747,
0.0029359536711126566,
0.2734832167625427,
0.36910662055015564,
0.4412602186203003,
-0.881147563457489,
0.09697697311639786,
-0.5597871541976929,
-0.25530198216438293,
-0.5476239919662476,
-0.13952073454856873,
-0.5193118453025818,
-0.09558068215847015,
0.17554934322834015,
-0.51505047082901,
0.15281374752521515,
-0.019832342863082886,
0.6269738674163818,
0.2354177087545395,
-0.32632774114608765,
-0.3696083128452301,
-0.9330027103424072,
0.8995291590690613,
-0.4088308811187744,
0.589020311832428,
0.28414690494537354,
-0.029196251183748245,
-0.16553790867328644,
-0.6275017857551575,
-0.1454223245382309,
0.04280782490968704,
-0.27702033519744873,
-0.2708829641342163,
-0.10519807785749435,
0.06062067300081253,
0.21744480729103088,
0.37606313824653625,
-0.42327064275741577,
0.5448408722877502,
-0.5396038889884949,
0.07124897837638855,
0.31536394357681274,
0.05472039431333542,
0.39082905650138855,
0.1923772096633911,
-0.11838250607252121,
-0.22000186145305634,
-0.9193572402000427,
-0.07138122618198395,
0.3997008800506592,
0.37534859776496887,
0.11392192542552948,
0.5846747756004333,
0.04583081603050232,
0.585273802280426,
-0.3921317458152771,
-0.15010417997837067,
0.5000184774398804,
-0.3901379406452179,
-0.2051151543855667,
0.026690226048231125,
0.8106903433799744,
-0.22078298032283783,
0.4746909439563751,
-0.4294893443584442,
-0.22142891585826874,
-0.1937331259250641,
0.19626882672309875,
-0.8456816673278809,
0.013633763417601585,
-0.09183429926633835,
-0.5101008415222168,
-0.18368254601955414,
0.09158100932836533,
-0.4729238450527191,
-0.3400397002696991,
-0.7351322770118713,
0.38462451100349426,
-0.3921469449996948,
-0.34548434615135193,
-0.001407027360983193,
0.005736715160310268,
0.024580171331763268,
0.09434724599123001,
-0.8068044185638428,
0.464268296957016,
0.8362615704536438,
0.7083236575126648,
-0.2723613679409027,
-0.4931269884109497,
-0.4854108393192291,
0.08035434037446976,
-0.22025513648986816,
0.6893677711486816,
-0.8087693452835083,
-0.3548838198184967,
0.10970620065927505,
0.10856502503156662,
-0.18614913523197174,
-0.7902013659477234,
0.3192881941795349,
-0.73237544298172,
-0.012757484801113605,
-0.34004926681518555,
-0.780928373336792,
-0.1390998214483261,
-0.161650612950325,
-0.81888347864151,
0.8805217742919922,
-0.04637783765792847,
-0.6506357789039612,
0.45256292819976807,
-0.3840755522251129,
-0.5006770491600037,
-0.08668212592601776,
-0.356441468000412,
-0.17560407519340515,
0.39546531438827515,
-0.07896532118320465,
0.6263006329536438,
-0.5155221223831177,
0.3891634941101074,
-0.3940051794052124,
-0.3225971758365631,
0.26745861768722534,
-0.33392080664634705,
0.8545494675636292,
0.18913812935352325,
-0.11747773736715317,
0.053601887077093124,
-1.2166647911071777,
0.00798462238162756,
-0.010750395245850086,
-0.3925710618495941,
-0.5902476906776428,
-0.06023300439119339,
-0.048787299543619156,
0.11990911513566971,
0.2258862853050232,
-0.22387446463108063,
0.07098511606454849,
-0.1006498634815216,
0.3080901503562927,
0.6865400075912476,
-0.34921133518218994,
0.49445798993110657,
0.009673482738435268,
0.5642879605293274,
-0.009158900938928127,
0.04586255922913551,
-0.11147721111774445,
-0.07880789041519165,
-0.5305929183959961,
-0.3789709508419037,
0.5136409997940063,
0.3606144189834595,
-0.24118196964263916,
0.4252670109272003,
-0.22598959505558014,
-0.6344127058982849,
-0.5836772918701172,
0.4315502345561981,
0.5932525396347046,
0.1636802852153778,
0.28315478563308716,
-0.42361927032470703,
-0.6742914319038391,
-0.8615069389343262,
-0.2426079958677292,
-0.0026377125177532434,
-0.0549689419567585,
-0.10973047465085983,
0.6030940413475037,
-0.22453579306602478,
0.9098020195960999,
-0.37984517216682434,
-0.10156659036874771,
-0.16834522783756256,
0.28157129883766174,
0.3127548396587372,
0.36948108673095703,
0.37036001682281494,
-0.3782092034816742,
-0.25563845038414,
-0.14183683693408966,
-0.7591889500617981,
-0.2338833510875702,
0.16987155377864838,
-0.27384427189826965,
0.01772136613726616,
0.6733053922653198,
-0.3103048801422119,
0.3039981722831726,
0.7434326410293579,
0.06382229924201965,
0.804093599319458,
-0.3148142397403717,
-0.18442310392856598,
-0.5950985550880432,
0.2166847288608551,
-0.3656792640686035,
0.21841959655284882,
-0.753616452217102,
-0.3663845956325531,
0.12309928238391876,
0.16750478744506836,
-0.29953888058662415,
0.25954726338386536,
-0.719383180141449,
-0.5929175019264221,
-0.10441717505455017,
-0.11501624435186386,
-0.02877887152135372,
0.1795668751001358,
0.11021573841571808,
0.7510411739349365,
0.4400666058063507,
-0.6608882546424866,
-0.13808582723140717,
0.24558766186237335,
-0.8345043063163757,
0.0023727284278720617,
-0.7327142357826233,
0.1456509679555893,
-0.21209309995174408,
0.14676924049854279,
-0.7310504913330078,
-0.012561284936964512,
-0.21453805267810822,
-0.04654805734753609,
0.35502004623413086,
-0.11350779980421066,
-0.8130154609680176,
0.11271228641271591,
-0.06463415920734406,
0.4721342921257019,
0.18052756786346436,
-0.5324548482894897,
0.39678847789764404,
0.5144078135490417,
-0.006292340811342001,
-0.7753350138664246,
-0.4582367241382599,
-0.13251256942749023,
-0.264530748128891,
-0.49337053298950195,
0.26341521739959717,
-0.021760115399956703,
-0.43044498562812805,
0.02502751350402832,
0.21508334577083588,
-0.021508289501070976,
0.28355082869529724,
0.3480317294597626,
0.31171730160713196,
-0.22841235995292664,
0.3921873867511749,
-0.46418723464012146,
0.02190619893372059,
0.1854080855846405,
-0.0838230699300766,
0.8351434469223022,
-0.21716241538524628,
-0.20541538298130035,
-0.057967595756053925,
0.06059598922729492,
0.5680916905403137,
-0.5148717761039734,
1.2888293266296387,
0.5032015442848206,
-0.1318386346101761,
-0.1693354994058609,
-0.46619653701782227,
0.07305211573839188,
-0.45197221636772156,
0.6120336055755615,
-0.46486276388168335,
-0.6980711221694946,
0.41903120279312134,
-0.11207816004753113,
0.10326802730560303,
0.2671438455581665,
0.55439692735672,
0.10087902843952179,
0.8815528750419617,
0.8013380765914917,
-0.27684974670410156,
0.7157599329948425,
-0.3073952794075012,
-0.011718487367033958,
-0.744454026222229,
-0.3045418858528137,
-0.6510301232337952,
-0.0819508507847786,
-0.662695050239563,
-0.330048531293869,
0.11523175239562988,
0.4539099633693695,
-0.3025805652141571,
0.23063498735427856,
-0.12047917395830154,
0.6093848943710327,
0.5580545663833618,
-0.14993330836296082,
0.5294502377510071,
0.07556521892547607,
0.0649934858083725,
0.14022240042686462,
-0.6769887804985046,
-0.7996988892555237,
1.5843522548675537,
0.49972131848335266,
0.7665213942527771,
0.03899260237812996,
0.5357539653778076,
-0.25314635038375854,
0.41429802775382996,
-0.539516270160675,
0.28641340136528015,
-0.41794928908348083,
-0.7421039938926697,
-0.2619248628616333,
-0.5891677737236023,
-1.2335352897644043,
0.27197450399398804,
-0.41913387179374695,
-0.5491432547569275,
0.1655023843050003,
-0.194888174533844,
-0.10010115057229996,
0.12614639103412628,
-0.7433915734291077,
0.8365952968597412,
-0.7011649012565613,
-0.3409407138824463,
-0.29366806149482727,
-0.48757901787757874,
0.33233457803726196,
-0.5053260326385498,
0.5306389331817627,
-0.17961281538009644,
0.022459903731942177,
1.0563228130340576,
-0.4344669580459595,
0.7973073124885559,
0.03802662715315819,
-0.11474176496267319,
0.06663405895233154,
-0.2021854966878891,
0.2601678669452667,
-0.3767448961734772,
-0.13181187212467194,
0.4899590015411377,
0.26786211133003235,
-0.3745284676551819,
-0.42763659358024597,
0.3620620369911194,
-1.1690834760665894,
-0.2951224744319916,
-0.16895420849323273,
-0.5704023838043213,
-0.5132686495780945,
0.36660388112068176,
0.37762850522994995,
0.5698965191841125,
-0.5049766302108765,
0.3068584203720093,
0.540720522403717,
-0.4019361734390259,
0.31416842341423035,
0.7010763883590698,
-0.33719563484191895,
-0.183272585272789,
0.7671133875846863,
0.42629820108413696,
0.4088080823421478,
0.3458326458930969,
-0.018257098272442818,
-0.2978541851043701,
-0.7819646000862122,
-0.08220116794109344,
0.5030420422554016,
-0.7009156942367554,
0.17992229759693146,
-0.5629361271858215,
-0.01535628642886877,
-0.5685637593269348,
0.21713826060295105,
-0.37280339002609253,
-0.030916009098291397,
-0.46569934487342834,
-0.013830989599227905,
-0.05024169757962227,
1.14087975025177,
0.04482564330101013,
0.7328969836235046,
-0.9528974294662476,
-0.1365143209695816,
0.0603405125439167,
0.5928478837013245,
0.04176018759608269,
-0.5220205783843994,
-0.5850000381469727,
-0.24002937972545624,
-0.0011352417059242725,
-0.4781975746154785,
0.38286447525024414,
0.18640543520450592,
0.6930990219116211,
0.7114468812942505,
-0.21714282035827637,
0.6128978729248047,
-0.675814688205719,
0.18723158538341522,
0.2646428048610687,
-0.7233753800392151,
0.17627432942390442,
-0.1944163292646408,
0.16239266097545624,
0.7333548665046692,
0.5960808396339417,
-0.26529282331466675,
-0.09020597487688065,
-0.5717182755470276,
-0.6531246304512024,
0.7941262722015381,
0.09463140368461609,
-0.04645787924528122,
0.21842676401138306,
0.17886555194854736,
0.24977244436740875,
0.30498433113098145,
-0.41306450963020325,
-0.1522815227508545,
0.19067290425300598,
-0.1829514503479004,
-0.7085004448890686,
-0.35740625858306885,
0.05073517933487892,
-0.25730133056640625,
0.43825334310531616,
0.29785314202308655,
-0.0521756112575531,
-0.49295321106910706,
-0.5822595357894897,
0.1400390863418579,
0.21905608475208282,
0.3892058730125427,
0.7545192837715149,
-0.29494982957839966,
0.32745248079299927,
-0.01332150585949421,
-0.5305026769638062,
0.027645034715533257,
-0.12709268927574158,
0.25258323550224304,
-0.06948329508304596,
0.870829164981842,
0.7345072627067566,
0.30623987317085266,
-0.7834106087684631,
0.16732144355773926,
0.03520369157195091,
-0.03863484784960747,
-0.3109133243560791,
0.040671445429325104,
0.047024790197610855,
0.0914972722530365,
0.1356813609600067,
-0.1303163468837738,
-0.13400065898895264,
-0.9240482449531555,
0.22322024405002594,
0.25408264994621277,
-0.07271020114421844,
-0.4864446818828583,
0.27708643674850464,
0.13475270569324493,
-0.0013816244900226593,
0.7085277438163757,
0.2538894712924957,
-0.49081727862358093,
0.49993425607681274,
0.4030883014202118,
0.49934470653533936,
-0.26090916991233826,
-0.08338519185781479,
0.260022908449173,
0.3381868898868561,
-0.3749306797981262,
-0.22507837414741516,
0.24941347539424896,
-0.8603828549385071,
-0.6107320189476013,
-0.7970276474952698,
-0.21042560040950775,
0.44845545291900635,
-0.7241102457046509,
0.36141061782836914,
-0.429370641708374,
-0.024797804653644562,
0.3340722918510437,
0.07668931782245636,
-1.114885687828064,
0.19931484758853912,
0.21689732372760773,
0.4975587725639343,
-0.82818204164505,
1.027954339981079,
0.5729271173477173,
-0.4413139224052429,
-0.6392834186553955,
-0.18664713203907013,
0.05963568016886711,
-1.0917733907699585,
0.9903818964958191,
0.23967233300209045,
-0.09175451099872589,
0.0016853522974997759,
-0.40939247608184814,
-1.1601492166519165,
0.6417744755744934,
0.4365924298763275,
-0.8313806653022766,
-0.03402101993560791,
0.6856412887573242,
0.5201717615127563,
-0.5149909257888794,
0.4840395450592041,
0.891840398311615,
0.42685478925704956,
-0.26458102464675903,
-0.9050644636154175,
-0.14934855699539185,
-0.10550576448440552,
-0.15280365943908691,
0.1893836110830307,
-0.34264814853668213,
0.8449369668960571,
0.06672399491071701,
-0.3595673739910126,
-0.3201170563697815,
0.3335561454296112,
0.043587327003479004,
-0.027046239003539085,
0.6538575887680054,
0.46831169724464417,
0.9564085006713867,
0.1665715128183365,
0.9450159072875977,
-0.4951232969760895,
-0.023510100319981575,
1.2473413944244385,
-0.19954657554626465,
0.8802244663238525,
0.21362265944480896,
-0.2840384542942047,
0.3775328993797302,
0.6351605653762817,
0.010593450628221035,
0.381743460893631,
0.5395049452781677,
-0.08103834092617035,
-0.2626245319843292,
-0.20118586719036102,
-0.33609479665756226,
0.6386216878890991,
0.37686508893966675,
-0.5408012270927429,
-0.06895856559276581,
0.1377958357334137,
0.09623254835605621,
-0.2015780806541443,
-0.24552211165428162,
0.5826702117919922,
0.03582608327269554,
-0.5163825750350952,
0.7083742618560791,
-0.18674559891223907,
0.6489447355270386,
-0.4297461211681366,
0.23044706881046295,
-0.019475312903523445,
0.35780036449432373,
-0.3402695953845978,
-0.5470499992370605,
0.09290749579668045,
0.23100577294826508,
-0.37328040599823,
-0.37218615412712097,
0.6074726581573486,
-0.43785712122917175,
-0.4350774586200714,
0.53448885679245,
0.9247120022773743,
0.5010877847671509,
-0.12480206042528152,
-0.2365773618221283,
0.42876675724983215,
-0.2185029536485672,
-0.4181641936302185,
0.7606357932090759,
0.6170759797096252,
-0.00972338393330574,
0.3948178291320801,
0.645579993724823,
0.009336857125163078,
0.09798688441514969,
0.21816770732402802,
0.8033145070075989,
-0.5749242901802063,
-0.030322575941681862,
-0.8194952011108398,
0.1383679360151291,
0.11948826909065247,
-0.372324138879776,
0.7850975394248962,
0.67148756980896,
0.9411048293113708,
0.20182636380195618,
0.793889582157135,
0.33434998989105225,
0.4934237599372864,
-0.4827527105808258,
0.7612006664276123,
-0.42198312282562256,
0.6136464476585388,
-0.25199687480926514,
-0.9155690670013428,
-0.10360421985387802,
0.29625070095062256,
-0.5678281188011169,
0.08029478788375854,
0.6600250005722046,
0.652052104473114,
0.15462654829025269,
0.13134141266345978,
0.3811003863811493,
0.2996181845664978,
0.18946237862110138,
0.11940719187259674,
1.0302627086639404,
0.03998790681362152,
0.7180840373039246,
-0.21805402636528015,
-0.32462069392204285,
-0.03891771659255028,
-0.6687570810317993,
-0.9530271887779236,
-0.5884360671043396,
-0.009525115601718426,
-0.025915462523698807,
-0.0522514246404171,
0.6627773642539978,
0.6742144227027893,
-0.6887600421905518,
-0.5781280994415283,
-0.06906966120004654,
-0.06446535140275955,
0.1651902049779892,
-0.17107926309108734,
0.5640336275100708,
-0.6114790439605713,
-0.6027860045433044,
0.45399636030197144,
-0.18389485776424408,
-0.00487415911629796,
-0.2966996729373932,
-0.06207706034183502,
-0.09216700494289398,
-0.13565893471240997,
0.8267994523048401,
0.040407467633485794,
-0.3883260190486908,
-0.08140050619840622,
0.09810464084148407,
-0.10761548578739166,
-0.09054435044527054,
1.0378495454788208,
-0.8100683093070984,
0.1471489816904068,
0.35738831758499146,
0.6409353017807007,
0.4648558497428894,
-0.22336536645889282,
0.7795339822769165,
-0.7031449675559998,
0.020121460780501366,
-0.10601197183132172,
0.24199402332305908,
0.09283773601055145,
-0.06556618958711624,
0.6970090866088867,
0.27046555280685425,
-0.5982089638710022,
-1.0742853879928589,
-0.05761924758553505,
-0.5195320844650269,
-0.7254682779312134,
1.1661131381988525,
-0.15637050569057465,
-0.24509526789188385,
-0.329402893781662,
0.24528269469738007,
0.396822065114975,
-0.1023448035120964,
0.5576156973838806,
0.96634840965271,
-0.14198897778987885,
-0.14366281032562256,
-0.8437938690185547,
0.3311600387096405,
0.5728346705436707,
-0.8094475269317627,
0.29174289107322693,
0.5525954961776733,
0.35404863953590393,
0.1347849816083908,
0.5471580028533936,
-0.09871822595596313,
-0.3606371283531189,
-0.03433529660105705,
0.23467335104942322,
-0.0860775038599968,
-0.44313880801200867,
-0.4114325940608978,
0.17774896323680878,
0.04444727674126625,
-0.006090693175792694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00782v1 | Ploutos: Towards interpretable stock movement prediction with financial large language model | 2024-02-18T10:28:18 | 2024-02-18T10:28:18 | Hanshuang Tong, Jun Li, Ning Wu, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have opened new pathways
for many domains. However, the full potential of LLMs in financial investments
remains largely untapped. There are two main challenges for typical deep
learning-based methods for quantitative finance. First, they struggle to fuse
textual and numerical information flexibly for stock movement prediction.
Second, traditional methods lack clarity and interpretability, which impedes
their application in scenarios where the justification for predictions is
essential. To solve the above challenges, we propose Ploutos, a novel financial
LLM framework that consists of PloutosGen and PloutosGPT. The PloutosGen
contains multiple primary experts that can analyze different modal data, such
as text and numbers, and provide quantitative strategies from different
perspectives. Then PloutosGPT combines their insights and predictions and
generates interpretable rationales. To generate accurate and faithful
rationales, the training strategy of PloutosGPT leverage rearview-mirror
prompting mechanism to guide GPT-4 to generate rationales, and a dynamic token
weighting mechanism to finetune LLM by increasing key tokens weight. Extensive
experiments show our framework outperforms the state-of-the-art methods on both
prediction accuracy and interpretability. | [
0.16847532987594604,
-0.32599735260009766,
0.48811256885528564,
0.1412048637866974,
-0.39975565671920776,
0.3989138901233673,
-0.2849131226539612,
-0.1868346780538559,
-0.006259726360440254,
0.6237507462501526,
-0.5276015400886536,
-0.460088849067688,
-0.7425333261489868,
-0.274017870426178,
-0.48377031087875366,
1.1097208261489868,
-0.19666868448257446,
0.37462833523750305,
0.2859661281108856,
0.07607725262641907,
-0.27116769552230835,
-0.3005097210407257,
-0.94841068983078,
-0.08406014740467072,
0.16014321148395538,
0.09927424043416977,
0.8326994776725769,
0.4544045925140381,
0.5451837778091431,
0.3988684117794037,
-0.13437838852405548,
0.07390028238296509,
-0.35402411222457886,
0.038098979741334915,
0.08461175113916397,
-0.43907761573791504,
-0.38285547494888306,
-0.1990496665239334,
0.6476368308067322,
0.6116059422492981,
-0.383362352848053,
-0.22791749238967896,
0.1762876659631729,
0.7076183557510376,
-0.319472998380661,
0.4743097424507141,
-0.42837923765182495,
0.12429752200841904,
-0.38902565836906433,
-0.15640467405319214,
-0.3170722424983978,
-0.21775256097316742,
0.5472061038017273,
-0.7792662382125854,
0.05095367878675461,
0.21522393822669983,
0.3368709087371826,
0.07480612397193909,
-0.4987739622592926,
-0.510040819644928,
-0.4302279055118561,
0.852527916431427,
-0.9046216011047363,
0.4607861042022705,
0.14829985797405243,
0.39303678274154663,
-0.35484713315963745,
-0.8670412302017212,
-0.35018885135650635,
-0.31842249631881714,
0.20154371857643127,
0.03825737163424492,
0.1437823623418808,
0.007103200536221266,
-0.08206847310066223,
0.4617977440357208,
-0.33794325590133667,
0.28471115231513977,
-0.32985568046569824,
-0.02288934774696827,
0.8208348155021667,
0.18336617946624756,
0.08989379554986954,
0.2962355315685272,
-0.836767852306366,
-0.15013228356838226,
-0.6452159881591797,
0.10734586417675018,
0.37551459670066833,
0.41409924626350403,
-0.5093486309051514,
0.28201770782470703,
0.21662765741348267,
0.35554027557373047,
0.03172694891691208,
-0.2290530800819397,
0.21819855272769928,
-0.014329468831419945,
-0.38467317819595337,
0.2196018099784851,
0.6434772610664368,
0.23153305053710938,
0.32368388772010803,
-0.20292672514915466,
-0.20052175223827362,
-0.4056541323661804,
-0.05618031322956085,
-0.7494760155677795,
-0.3455122709274292,
0.24189484119415283,
-0.3934008479118347,
-0.30135515332221985,
0.2819010317325592,
-1.0854727029800415,
-0.720191478729248,
-0.3937303125858307,
0.28015783429145813,
-0.6784825325012207,
-0.25761884450912476,
0.4757772386074066,
-0.07879412919282913,
0.22724099457263947,
0.4849817156791687,
-0.9640455842018127,
0.20354652404785156,
1.0442302227020264,
0.7291046977043152,
-0.28773602843284607,
-0.26173684000968933,
-0.6469213962554932,
0.4986671507358551,
-0.3335728049278259,
0.46562695503234863,
-0.36197543144226074,
-0.22552822530269623,
0.09958042204380035,
-0.20650061964988708,
-0.15027640759944916,
-0.23725570738315582,
0.22026030719280243,
-0.6208134293556213,
0.20964057743549347,
-0.17174190282821655,
-0.8371034264564514,
-0.583090603351593,
0.11251910775899887,
-0.5483771562576294,
0.4920656979084015,
-0.16443948447704315,
-0.6648952960968018,
0.43550577759742737,
-0.8696169853210449,
-0.47757506370544434,
0.2742205262184143,
-0.11760082840919495,
-0.3399215638637543,
-0.02979055605828762,
0.1008215919137001,
0.6440010070800781,
-0.4014383554458618,
0.3863423764705658,
-0.4798891842365265,
-0.3792913556098938,
0.7668749094009399,
-0.5226321816444397,
0.43583741784095764,
0.17239169776439667,
-0.4164104461669922,
0.2755330502986908,
-0.6700920462608337,
-0.39959949254989624,
0.1149907335639,
-0.024786442518234253,
-0.37278497219085693,
0.26038414239883423,
-0.290798157453537,
-0.3306610584259033,
0.4355684816837311,
-0.23123955726623535,
0.1704714447259903,
-0.7935657501220703,
0.7554376125335693,
1.0613452196121216,
-0.18733914196491241,
0.7801105380058289,
-0.03772711753845215,
0.6695538759231567,
0.11637852340936661,
0.17220160365104675,
-0.2734767496585846,
-0.35345733165740967,
-0.19000360369682312,
-0.5216590166091919,
0.36866283416748047,
0.5138840675354004,
-0.5605666041374207,
0.08333636820316315,
-0.17845040559768677,
-0.10089857131242752,
-0.1489943414926529,
0.3351612985134125,
-0.14235007762908936,
0.42505761981010437,
0.1854238063097,
-0.07197200506925583,
-0.49685972929000854,
-0.6346021294593811,
-0.12907111644744873,
-0.028409764170646667,
-0.0984056293964386,
-0.13686209917068481,
0.39494532346725464,
-0.09500464051961899,
0.6096182465553284,
-0.5695778131484985,
-0.2003507763147354,
-0.2607598304748535,
0.35728591680526733,
0.4213160574436188,
0.3406527638435364,
0.29167836904525757,
-0.9753218293190002,
-0.27652812004089355,
0.26735734939575195,
-0.6479454040527344,
0.31195056438446045,
-0.511736273765564,
0.028686122968792915,
-0.07241655886173248,
0.5706470012664795,
-0.6663430333137512,
0.26470738649368286,
0.5593792796134949,
-0.3784840404987335,
0.0925370454788208,
-0.0884244292974472,
-0.3296797275543213,
-1.241085171699524,
-0.07671505957841873,
0.27976566553115845,
-0.17918550968170166,
-0.33005622029304504,
0.08338040113449097,
-0.19263267517089844,
-0.05192156508564949,
-0.3364136517047882,
0.7864224910736084,
-0.2838251292705536,
-0.3637125492095947,
-0.19312703609466553,
0.20304642617702484,
-0.16597577929496765,
0.24735186994075775,
-0.041952747851610184,
0.8190081119537354,
0.6554951667785645,
-0.46459317207336426,
0.3500771224498749,
0.19224326312541962,
-0.47558853030204773,
0.07597411423921585,
-0.4864552319049835,
-0.3000936210155487,
0.054352082312107086,
0.27424952387809753,
-1.1253576278686523,
-0.058550212532281876,
0.4065418839454651,
-0.17160609364509583,
0.4736759066581726,
0.030034709721803665,
-0.3214172422885895,
-0.23247650265693665,
-0.4815903902053833,
0.2613757848739624,
0.25762009620666504,
-0.38277819752693176,
0.9152317643165588,
0.12754255533218384,
-0.5600895881652832,
-0.740547776222229,
-0.586403489112854,
0.13579893112182617,
-0.41045355796813965,
-0.7245940566062927,
0.2804138958454132,
-0.03795543313026428,
-0.40799620747566223,
-0.1625780314207077,
-0.07461470365524292,
0.11837353557348251,
0.26971161365509033,
0.28926971554756165,
0.44908416271209717,
-0.23869428038597107,
0.14181947708129883,
0.009686209261417389,
-0.2021932303905487,
-0.03650984540581703,
-0.4536634683609009,
0.36811044812202454,
-0.3618166148662567,
-0.10336030274629593,
-0.4860541522502899,
-0.003707912052050233,
0.7650884985923767,
-0.16609656810760498,
0.7717607021331787,
0.4748830795288086,
0.012928883545100689,
-0.257351815700531,
-0.3189193308353424,
-0.03732066974043846,
-0.5353420376777649,
0.36570286750793457,
-0.1855625957250595,
-0.8757007718086243,
0.7630786299705505,
-0.4878649413585663,
0.2782692611217499,
0.4754313826560974,
0.5732823014259338,
-0.3047083914279938,
0.9687209129333496,
0.6515077352523804,
0.1620168536901474,
0.4883882403373718,
-0.4296770393848419,
0.38003358244895935,
-0.512611985206604,
-0.4077432453632355,
0.09926358610391617,
-0.6396860480308533,
-0.3501671254634857,
-0.3908674716949463,
0.10872112214565277,
0.29085493087768555,
-0.3770098388195038,
0.17477285861968994,
-0.06700728833675385,
0.16401541233062744,
0.40415894985198975,
-0.3155014216899872,
0.26370489597320557,
-0.0015014208620414138,
-0.18291836977005005,
-0.07941586524248123,
-0.5772773623466492,
-0.279066801071167,
1.195285677909851,
0.8237482309341431,
0.9179463386535645,
0.03347040340304375,
0.41851934790611267,
0.23200319707393646,
0.6720701456069946,
-0.8125110268592834,
0.5533673167228699,
-0.5366326570510864,
-0.18504562973976135,
-0.36201250553131104,
-0.6075890064239502,
-0.6404621005058289,
-0.03286738693714142,
-0.1444770246744156,
-0.4473622739315033,
0.28593724966049194,
-0.033924102783203125,
-0.7519837617874146,
0.3531922698020935,
-0.6648532748222351,
0.747478723526001,
-0.7932029962539673,
-0.1875336617231369,
-0.23618084192276,
-0.5115288496017456,
0.2481900155544281,
-0.3744750916957855,
0.43697109818458557,
-0.08312051743268967,
-0.43549174070358276,
0.6976758241653442,
-0.5487232208251953,
1.1481142044067383,
-0.09347252547740936,
-0.36584317684173584,
0.23005585372447968,
0.1191171333193779,
0.8181615471839905,
0.23437702655792236,
-0.13199135661125183,
0.30527833104133606,
-0.10112964361906052,
-0.16731947660446167,
-0.4353567361831665,
0.6823164224624634,
-0.5557616949081421,
-0.2035253345966339,
-0.49670904874801636,
-0.752333402633667,
-0.21078595519065857,
-0.09582756459712982,
0.1418176293373108,
-0.036201078444719315,
0.12271777540445328,
0.20613610744476318,
0.32976529002189636,
-0.15441890060901642,
0.6695691347122192,
0.6165562272071838,
-0.19842001795768738,
-0.8914501667022705,
0.9018905758857727,
0.09971141070127487,
-0.24986985325813293,
0.4380702078342438,
0.4519614577293396,
-0.7207121849060059,
-0.8591682314872742,
-0.2553839385509491,
0.1796024590730667,
-0.2936529219150543,
-0.2669723331928253,
-0.03694958612322807,
0.06113511696457863,
-0.4707946181297302,
-0.4171030819416046,
-0.47234782576560974,
-0.1515483856201172,
-0.34207621216773987,
-0.3404099941253662,
0.47885462641716003,
0.6360445022583008,
-0.06741060316562653,
0.49794304370880127,
-0.8807100057601929,
0.06194261088967323,
0.4765288531780243,
0.537809431552887,
-0.0027912049554288387,
-0.5578933954238892,
-0.31268689036369324,
0.14481088519096375,
-0.224577397108078,
-0.7632473707199097,
0.6231897473335266,
0.01797431893646717,
0.2893247902393341,
0.8316788673400879,
0.048879388719797134,
0.665337860584259,
0.08014799654483795,
0.473440945148468,
0.553546130657196,
-0.9611223936080933,
0.27548307180404663,
-0.5537871718406677,
-0.06811711937189102,
0.41141149401664734,
0.28867509961128235,
-0.25164926052093506,
-0.19761385023593903,
-0.4336778521537781,
-1.0515824556350708,
0.4447139799594879,
0.08764173090457916,
0.01714654266834259,
0.14363634586334229,
0.512851893901825,
0.4733509123325348,
0.6711828112602234,
-0.6816867589950562,
0.255602091550827,
-0.16913701593875885,
-0.4313226044178009,
-0.06791377812623978,
-0.23490285873413086,
0.035152509808540344,
-0.027802571654319763,
0.6217444539070129,
-0.30545279383659363,
-0.20958305895328522,
-0.12724588811397552,
0.17463073134422302,
-0.1632116138935089,
-0.08971899002790451,
0.6205240488052368,
0.6801434755325317,
-0.24640560150146484,
-0.25072774291038513,
0.16930511593818665,
-0.23955869674682617,
-0.18095926940441132,
0.3966362476348877,
-0.1542639583349228,
-0.22927944362163544,
0.3257809281349182,
0.8549553155899048,
0.6939643621444702,
-1.0498219728469849,
0.6583094000816345,
-0.014314251951873302,
-0.46666017174720764,
-0.9078880548477173,
-0.3567003011703491,
-0.03427129238843918,
0.8607271313667297,
0.6995370984077454,
0.059748873114585876,
0.02784184366464615,
-0.5108776688575745,
0.18603187799453735,
0.38637930154800415,
-0.31496816873550415,
-0.4059661626815796,
0.8443621397018433,
0.35511916875839233,
0.16508543491363525,
0.5389897227287292,
0.028109624981880188,
-0.46801474690437317,
0.5367761254310608,
0.059133563190698624,
1.1005992889404297,
-0.11592704057693481,
0.2771434187889099,
-0.09652429819107056,
0.07752806693315506,
-0.591195821762085,
0.2901743948459625,
0.13044708967208862,
-0.8014143705368042,
-1.0178645849227905,
-0.7276050448417664,
-0.419954776763916,
0.3705681562423706,
-0.3249457776546478,
0.3532913029193878,
-0.8345377445220947,
-0.16037099063396454,
-0.10083283483982086,
-0.1560824066400528,
-0.22311308979988098,
0.09423097223043442,
0.5675851106643677,
0.8754645586013794,
-0.6195811629295349,
0.5593370795249939,
0.7114145159721375,
-0.16372627019882202,
-0.5097131729125977,
0.07755086570978165,
-0.10834168642759323,
-0.9409550428390503,
0.7569103837013245,
0.1364033967256546,
0.10024595260620117,
-0.22524552047252655,
-0.5367627143859863,
-0.8144705295562744,
1.1406309604644775,
0.6053928732872009,
-0.9222615361213684,
-0.12569637596607208,
-0.04362789914011955,
0.27245864272117615,
-0.4235793352127075,
-0.3488982319831848,
0.24019254744052887,
0.5578135848045349,
0.6156771779060364,
-0.44068968296051025,
-0.11041801422834396,
0.12489266693592072,
-0.10340121388435364,
0.4698289930820465,
-0.7469317317008972,
0.898342490196228,
-0.3488248586654663,
-0.11098235100507736,
0.3085685968399048,
0.9349136352539062,
0.19582314789295197,
0.7304193377494812,
0.34636005759239197,
0.6671919226646423,
0.8139679431915283,
0.06859685480594635,
1.0952256917953491,
-0.6370064616203308,
0.3716043531894684,
1.1421070098876953,
-0.5134357810020447,
1.049980878829956,
0.39997637271881104,
-0.13525836169719696,
0.44835948944091797,
0.6021145582199097,
-0.23285198211669922,
0.578744649887085,
0.14976860582828522,
-0.3675110340118408,
-0.47130176424980164,
0.26571735739707947,
-0.36458098888397217,
0.49122652411460876,
0.4354105293750763,
-0.5403827428817749,
0.07512199133634567,
0.04222947731614113,
-0.1094900369644165,
-0.09905052930116653,
-0.4550061523914337,
0.47421005368232727,
0.4942309856414795,
-0.2481883317232132,
-0.20082153379917145,
0.20778542757034302,
0.6556019186973572,
-0.8137776255607605,
0.07865463942289352,
-0.1653430461883545,
0.40761029720306396,
0.1597760170698166,
-0.7827695608139038,
0.1871032863855362,
-0.38042953610420227,
0.2819799482822418,
-0.5151466727256775,
0.6055617332458496,
-0.2546577453613281,
-0.6620917916297913,
0.2812521457672119,
0.2862423360347748,
-0.17534266412258148,
-0.13198499381542206,
-0.745833694934845,
-0.3506655991077423,
0.0686144307255745,
-0.26265618205070496,
0.48378226161003113,
0.7217674255371094,
0.03201624006032944,
0.9140319228172302,
1.0887547731399536,
0.10924521088600159,
-0.07053575664758682,
-0.046322304755449295,
0.5719549059867859,
-0.7494746446609497,
-0.779545783996582,
-0.953884482383728,
0.2973906099796295,
0.1133817806839943,
-0.32717227935791016,
0.5192852020263672,
0.5332643985748291,
0.30847007036209106,
0.0031037505250424147,
0.6563974618911743,
0.6886093616485596,
0.3745616376399994,
-0.7486915588378906,
0.5268194675445557,
-0.2971058487892151,
0.5654062628746033,
0.09678288549184799,
-0.7087769508361816,
-0.19238059222698212,
0.5902419090270996,
-0.5911450386047363,
-0.23324286937713623,
0.47233346104621887,
0.3267398476600647,
0.152450293302536,
0.45125460624694824,
0.11807340383529663,
0.5900134444236755,
-0.10913993418216705,
0.42897829413414,
0.7714855670928955,
-0.25539737939834595,
0.55719393491745,
-0.07683027535676956,
0.028902260586619377,
-0.38371309638023376,
-0.9750316739082336,
-0.6726347208023071,
-0.2451404184103012,
-0.6227706074714661,
-0.0012786388397216797,
-0.007617519237101078,
0.6811755299568176,
0.505240261554718,
-0.8276621699333191,
-0.4099523723125458,
-0.3683643341064453,
-0.027030901983380318,
-0.39286112785339355,
-0.22420841455459595,
0.36871740221977234,
-0.14067919552326202,
-0.4847693145275116,
0.5602299571037292,
0.5523831844329834,
0.5083539485931396,
-0.41339024901390076,
-0.3766385316848755,
0.24529428780078888,
0.05943043902516365,
0.6787226796150208,
0.34150031208992004,
-0.4433274567127228,
0.16280697286128998,
-0.19141416251659393,
0.2846374809741974,
-0.23496562242507935,
0.8368558883666992,
-0.5699899196624756,
0.007388849277049303,
0.5448654890060425,
0.6826479434967041,
0.5450252890586853,
0.03876442089676857,
0.916716992855072,
-0.5309872031211853,
0.2572893500328064,
0.3663167357444763,
0.40688014030456543,
0.11221028864383698,
-0.27369922399520874,
0.5013176798820496,
0.31362223625183105,
-0.2023146152496338,
-0.5684975981712341,
-0.2206895500421524,
-1.0744000673294067,
-0.5077219605445862,
1.077244520187378,
-0.11337857693433762,
-0.32539239525794983,
0.03286982700228691,
0.02191009558737278,
-0.003758526872843504,
-0.698119044303894,
0.6593697667121887,
0.42412590980529785,
0.16836637258529663,
-0.400272399187088,
-0.7606682777404785,
0.28390321135520935,
0.5514668226242065,
-0.30756255984306335,
0.20521768927574158,
0.1816737949848175,
0.1454005092382431,
-0.04108138009905815,
0.28357645869255066,
-0.10519582778215408,
0.10505938529968262,
-0.20907479524612427,
-0.18110840022563934,
-0.18571539223194122,
-0.15635834634304047,
-0.20688961446285248,
0.5667424201965332,
-0.1504262238740921,
-0.2624448239803314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11534v1 | PreAct: Predicting Future in ReAct Enhances Agent's Planning Ability | 2024-02-18T10:15:38 | 2024-02-18T10:15:38 | Dayuan Fu, Jianzhao Huang, Siyuan Lu, Guanting Dong, Yejie Wang, Keqing He, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Addressing the discrepancies between predictions and actual outcomes often
aids individuals in expanding their thought processes and engaging in
reflection, thereby facilitating reasoning in the correct direction. In this
paper, we introduce $\textbf{PreAct}$, an agent framework that integrates
$\textbf{pre}$diction with $\textbf{rea}$soning and $\textbf{act}$ion.
Leveraging the information provided by predictions, a large language model
(LLM) based agent can offer more diversified and strategically oriented
reasoning, which in turn leads to more effective actions that help the agent
complete complex tasks. Our experiments demonstrate that PreAct outperforms the
ReAct approach in accomplishing complex tasks and that PreAct can be
co-enhanced when combined with Reflexion methods. We prompt the model with
different numbers of historical predictions and find that historical
predictions have a sustained positive effect on LLM planning. The differences
in single-step reasoning between PreAct and ReAct show that PreAct indeed
offers advantages in terms of diversity and strategic directivity over ReAct. | [
-0.3053998649120331,
-0.5818865299224854,
0.8190197348594666,
0.19154399633407593,
-0.10226012766361237,
0.355919748544693,
0.09503671526908875,
-0.48628804087638855,
0.5166982412338257,
0.48685234785079956,
-0.9043287038803101,
-0.43687018752098083,
-0.26144397258758545,
-0.21923816204071045,
-0.016985755413770676,
0.5265011191368103,
-0.14091695845127106,
0.03608136251568794,
-0.21858899295330048,
0.23977281153202057,
-0.6689826250076294,
-0.6709407567977905,
-0.5078532099723816,
-0.575553834438324,
0.46944916248321533,
0.38205012679100037,
0.8723827600479126,
0.19490474462509155,
0.44209522008895874,
0.5055719017982483,
0.2848302125930786,
0.01142122596502304,
-0.5752351880073547,
0.42603686451911926,
-0.6138842105865479,
-0.47299832105636597,
-0.972444474697113,
0.0922730565071106,
0.4692476689815521,
0.30258774757385254,
-0.1629243791103363,
-0.1446887105703354,
-0.48817092180252075,
0.3372194766998291,
-0.628279447555542,
0.2601962685585022,
-0.322855681180954,
-0.01842055283486843,
0.10214581340551376,
-0.34062179923057556,
-0.38715511560440063,
-0.02391439862549305,
0.22463372349739075,
-0.8003982901573181,
-0.259466290473938,
0.08736632019281387,
0.4598659574985504,
0.39164140820503235,
-0.3325108587741852,
0.1478700041770935,
-0.9637083411216736,
0.7659461498260498,
-0.5890368819236755,
0.4905613660812378,
0.3144806921482086,
0.6230379939079285,
-0.5875750184059143,
-1.108252763748169,
-0.6947017312049866,
-0.011121520772576332,
-0.039453864097595215,
0.22993557155132294,
0.23207467794418335,
0.3096597492694855,
0.19560617208480835,
0.07308077812194824,
-0.36279404163360596,
-0.05811772122979164,
0.23448897898197174,
-0.3648020923137665,
0.7174996733665466,
0.32048413157463074,
0.3089388906955719,
0.1882624477148056,
-0.6745782494544983,
-0.2966102361679077,
-0.6459028720855713,
0.2262214571237564,
0.08621691167354584,
0.42829054594039917,
-0.004092656075954437,
0.2923288345336914,
-0.469292551279068,
0.49346110224723816,
-0.20319105684757233,
-0.04758443683385849,
0.01741572469472885,
-0.3895031213760376,
-0.37734124064445496,
-0.16869521141052246,
0.5163074731826782,
0.22463567554950714,
0.5537587404251099,
-0.04808826744556427,
-0.22895154356956482,
0.14671966433525085,
0.2735210061073303,
-0.8224023580551147,
0.0396118201315403,
0.23544597625732422,
-0.20495381951332092,
-0.05947892740368843,
-0.04751436412334442,
-0.9639266133308411,
-0.45537424087524414,
-0.4851638078689575,
0.49914684891700745,
-0.11756549030542374,
-0.4998965859413147,
0.21041372418403625,
-0.10663585364818573,
0.12446951866149902,
0.5651204586029053,
-0.47256407141685486,
0.5049260258674622,
0.7277858853340149,
0.13153235614299774,
-0.07581934332847595,
-0.6750553846359253,
-0.36747100949287415,
0.04169432073831558,
-0.5055724382400513,
1.0715384483337402,
-0.6723562479019165,
-0.4507236182689667,
-0.03546759858727455,
-0.06976724416017532,
0.18250133097171783,
-0.3485691547393799,
0.43520793318748474,
-0.7832845449447632,
-0.00047330805682577193,
-0.3202546238899231,
-0.1868242770433426,
-0.34981271624565125,
0.3414401710033417,
-0.9379698634147644,
0.4228116273880005,
0.04889725148677826,
-0.20532061159610748,
0.8013695478439331,
-0.6171162128448486,
-0.7009129524230957,
0.0767543613910675,
-0.309429794549942,
-0.09106327593326569,
-0.07142297923564911,
0.1314437985420227,
0.4232463836669922,
-0.32424280047416687,
0.5224737524986267,
-0.32031145691871643,
-0.17849192023277283,
0.3502362072467804,
-0.14741364121437073,
0.21066676080226898,
0.10077427327632904,
-0.31234440207481384,
0.6307726502418518,
-0.3522471785545349,
0.20865587890148163,
0.07018464058637619,
-0.022748537361621857,
0.0045562805607914925,
0.3123615086078644,
-0.416241854429245,
0.40897083282470703,
0.23330791294574738,
-0.11322441697120667,
0.07497980445623398,
-0.44995197653770447,
-0.04965492710471153,
0.9131016135215759,
0.1069653183221817,
0.8286505341529846,
-0.5228257179260254,
0.8500681519508362,
-0.21145668625831604,
0.3669767379760742,
-0.20312507450580597,
-0.3593564033508301,
-0.22372733056545258,
-0.03971146047115326,
-0.014485586434602737,
0.4338650405406952,
-0.6968083381652832,
-0.17028136551380157,
-0.41797226667404175,
-0.4013693928718567,
0.22595512866973877,
-0.2710197865962982,
0.36737316846847534,
0.39162638783454895,
0.3080359697341919,
-0.15868988633155823,
-1.0118321180343628,
-0.38938647508621216,
-0.4850209653377533,
-0.27694907784461975,
0.7328433990478516,
0.11336146295070648,
0.3906993269920349,
-0.31501466035842896,
1.1100022792816162,
-0.5245437026023865,
-0.0300391037017107,
-0.5512081980705261,
0.17898552119731903,
0.21892531216144562,
0.33161869645118713,
0.2598922550678253,
-1.272875428199768,
-0.50773024559021,
-0.35765737295150757,
-0.5116750597953796,
0.2954879403114319,
-0.11909652501344681,
-0.4341927766799927,
0.005044972524046898,
0.545936107635498,
-0.7295306921005249,
0.5760693550109863,
0.3584533929824829,
-0.6526588797569275,
0.674064040184021,
0.013207166455686092,
0.21916165947914124,
-1.0954301357269287,
-0.22641749680042267,
-0.40369629859924316,
-0.38648131489753723,
-0.8299169540405273,
-0.050870344042778015,
-0.3162388503551483,
-0.15493816137313843,
-0.6431472301483154,
0.892342209815979,
-0.40551379323005676,
-0.18468816578388214,
-0.37248075008392334,
-0.08400280028581619,
-0.12947028875350952,
0.32972362637519836,
0.39858999848365784,
0.8275033235549927,
0.30052757263183594,
-0.684169352054596,
0.1168200671672821,
0.08532349765300751,
-0.2279936969280243,
0.07074575871229172,
-0.36035794019699097,
-0.05529129505157471,
0.02180837281048298,
0.44242459535598755,
-0.8042325377464294,
-0.2745971083641052,
-0.17701546847820282,
-0.5895384550094604,
0.4412926137447357,
0.3803141713142395,
-0.3592640459537506,
-0.4155738055706024,
-0.09330584108829498,
0.46818041801452637,
0.4202582538127899,
-0.20430725812911987,
1.503800392150879,
0.3429306149482727,
-0.16976523399353027,
-1.0974470376968384,
-0.5382985472679138,
-0.18348905444145203,
0.06901030987501144,
-0.4732212722301483,
0.36392518877983093,
-0.2738444209098816,
-0.7159247398376465,
0.11417274922132492,
-0.13355772197246552,
-0.1200895607471466,
0.03319728001952171,
0.40711620450019836,
0.41730356216430664,
-0.05890795961022377,
0.22074946761131287,
-0.02690025046467781,
-0.31421545147895813,
0.04680977016687393,
-0.1946701556444168,
0.8065681457519531,
-0.01581818051636219,
-0.27002114057540894,
-0.1175205409526825,
0.13877372443675995,
0.9121664762496948,
-0.44426003098487854,
0.49565431475639343,
-0.007768579293042421,
-0.29224222898483276,
-0.5354251861572266,
-0.4654679596424103,
-0.45305493474006653,
-0.48049861192703247,
0.4241226017475128,
-0.5681903958320618,
-0.44585660099983215,
0.6180341243743896,
-0.7111237645149231,
-0.0392891988158226,
0.28527867794036865,
0.2659150958061218,
-0.10291298478841782,
0.8217665553092957,
0.6491686105728149,
0.2000635415315628,
0.6201164126396179,
-0.44986313581466675,
0.054276395589113235,
-0.5422557592391968,
-0.22624218463897705,
0.1290692687034607,
-0.3761712312698364,
-0.30156585574150085,
-0.7735313773155212,
-0.2325434535741806,
-0.10710359364748001,
-0.5150095224380493,
0.18312805891036987,
-0.19028371572494507,
0.4671570360660553,
0.29055023193359375,
-0.12887659668922424,
0.22989949584007263,
-0.32507482171058655,
0.04472462087869644,
0.10854092985391617,
-0.5315092206001282,
-0.47413188219070435,
1.2766140699386597,
0.10664843022823334,
0.8171597123146057,
0.03565818816423416,
0.8800494074821472,
0.25340455770492554,
0.6270462274551392,
-0.6842082142829895,
0.9644770622253418,
0.0940350666642189,
-0.9617915749549866,
-0.596350371837616,
-0.027486160397529602,
-0.9188783168792725,
0.3353927731513977,
-0.5392143130302429,
-0.3858753740787506,
0.48152703046798706,
0.057957135140895844,
-0.4479140341281891,
0.16150039434432983,
-0.7130025029182434,
0.6991560459136963,
-0.46026089787483215,
-0.5824412703514099,
-0.48568499088287354,
-0.5509532690048218,
-0.08662134408950806,
-0.08812412619590759,
0.3355892300605774,
-0.14876417815685272,
-0.21925823390483856,
0.4442262053489685,
-0.24267099797725677,
0.7903739809989929,
-0.24274206161499023,
0.1239793673157692,
0.6672624945640564,
0.17893026769161224,
0.8367778658866882,
-0.26105836033821106,
-0.2642156183719635,
-0.31006357073783875,
-0.3004230260848999,
-0.16547590494155884,
-0.7852926254272461,
0.5898009538650513,
-0.6812888383865356,
-0.8099562525749207,
-0.3387400507926941,
-0.7240279316902161,
-0.32605788111686707,
0.5116475820541382,
0.22812263667583466,
0.5038687586784363,
-0.8131375312805176,
-0.32588252425193787,
0.30598488450050354,
0.02641061507165432,
0.6630675792694092,
0.7882179021835327,
-0.5626769661903381,
-0.4797460436820984,
0.5107313990592957,
0.17035695910453796,
0.3568803071975708,
0.740919828414917,
0.2557830214500427,
-0.7233838438987732,
-0.35918277502059937,
0.16384874284267426,
0.14463026821613312,
-0.8406394124031067,
-0.12012000381946564,
-0.3919312357902527,
0.22046814858913422,
-0.5500616431236267,
-0.4263983964920044,
-0.2919681668281555,
-0.32379424571990967,
0.05557272210717201,
-0.3975062668323517,
-0.1215212270617485,
0.7380189895629883,
-0.09780365973711014,
0.30692753195762634,
-0.2954882085323334,
0.2825610041618347,
0.4019777774810791,
0.24974289536476135,
-0.0569038949906826,
0.08196893334388733,
-0.044556599110364914,
-0.18377502262592316,
-0.03582853078842163,
-1.0052984952926636,
0.4066048264503479,
-0.13782109320163727,
0.8845056295394897,
0.2927675247192383,
0.1938600242137909,
0.5204159617424011,
-0.5279020667076111,
0.5943118929862976,
0.1427256017923355,
-0.6804705262184143,
0.6649065017700195,
-0.37346112728118896,
0.3107750713825226,
0.5533274412155151,
0.2840249240398407,
0.09698638319969177,
-0.03421061858534813,
-0.8510555028915405,
-0.7289580702781677,
0.6061761379241943,
-0.19817495346069336,
-0.03744287043809891,
0.1008133590221405,
-0.030428091064095497,
-0.013138918206095695,
0.41208770871162415,
-0.6970930099487305,
-0.03944037854671478,
-0.17020052671432495,
0.03717300668358803,
-0.7154806852340698,
-0.3720976412296295,
-0.08771051466464996,
-0.38253727555274963,
0.37237289547920227,
-0.01811962015926838,
0.3657955527305603,
0.15946266055107117,
-0.062414221465587616,
-0.23503950238227844,
0.396842896938324,
0.8371675610542297,
0.8957194089889526,
-0.1364647001028061,
0.17406649887561798,
0.33807846903800964,
-0.4013424217700958,
0.3276345729827881,
0.23280595242977142,
0.34943774342536926,
-0.379166841506958,
0.7187256217002869,
0.5851038694381714,
0.2213219851255417,
-0.7624962329864502,
0.374066561460495,
0.045296672731637955,
-0.08330228924751282,
-0.6017530560493469,
-0.0009512378601357341,
0.09009458124637604,
0.7211262583732605,
0.3131319284439087,
0.17818167805671692,
0.08706046640872955,
-0.9151891469955444,
0.23734723031520844,
0.16114060580730438,
-0.28160253167152405,
-0.28862231969833374,
0.4742271900177002,
0.33141791820526123,
-0.520898163318634,
0.3233872056007385,
-0.3286401629447937,
-0.8139644265174866,
0.7719122171401978,
0.7289623618125916,
0.989271879196167,
-0.6051803827285767,
0.1892385482788086,
0.2484474927186966,
0.15060001611709595,
-0.23174983263015747,
0.8311466574668884,
-0.0005420005181804299,
-0.9539505243301392,
-0.9833773970603943,
-0.44321081042289734,
-0.19615961611270905,
-0.20314033329486847,
-0.07180467993021011,
0.09485877305269241,
-0.7054106593132019,
-0.6766923069953918,
-0.532738208770752,
0.17753413319587708,
-0.6921536326408386,
0.5456393361091614,
0.007300524041056633,
0.9421434998512268,
-0.7417391538619995,
0.7366392016410828,
1.0426428318023682,
-0.5834324359893799,
-1.0889770984649658,
0.21267421543598175,
-0.05625271424651146,
-0.5007299780845642,
1.0893973112106323,
0.0642775148153305,
-0.766485869884491,
-0.10198062658309937,
-0.35912758111953735,
-1.191819429397583,
1.2096939086914062,
0.3795022666454315,
-0.5642214417457581,
0.028606252744793892,
-0.035618096590042114,
0.5006183981895447,
-0.5267914533615112,
0.05924796313047409,
0.33916255831718445,
0.728103518486023,
0.3918638229370117,
-0.6893337368965149,
0.30696243047714233,
-0.16313739120960236,
-0.4946288764476776,
0.34073829650878906,
-0.43457114696502686,
1.2568596601486206,
-0.6423782110214233,
-0.5283932685852051,
-0.10209300369024277,
0.8717919588088989,
0.06847918778657913,
0.6195699572563171,
0.5968944430351257,
0.5905590653419495,
0.7113413214683533,
-0.0907502993941307,
1.2988510131835938,
-0.17616567015647888,
-0.08186201006174088,
1.4771955013275146,
-0.3409649431705475,
0.9424704313278198,
0.14592045545578003,
-0.0886942595243454,
1.1618744134902954,
0.3225685954093933,
0.6220853328704834,
0.7319328784942627,
-0.10431569814682007,
-0.1948062926530838,
-0.6548723578453064,
0.04545516148209572,
-0.18563735485076904,
0.5242199897766113,
0.2338695228099823,
-0.044473446905612946,
0.06579053401947021,
-0.11424940079450607,
-0.06400809437036514,
0.41004955768585205,
-0.5267553925514221,
0.7196003794670105,
0.11703162640333176,
-1.1556236743927002,
0.0381026528775692,
-0.5914904475212097,
0.3551085889339447,
-0.6368216276168823,
-0.14500641822814941,
0.06271101534366608,
0.554097056388855,
-0.0038123850245028734,
-0.8799274563789368,
0.18968960642814636,
-0.7686960697174072,
-0.20209063589572906,
-0.4147336184978485,
1.220488429069519,
-0.16586466133594513,
-0.007583505008369684,
0.6986362934112549,
0.7092697620391846,
-0.2630055546760559,
-0.21695789694786072,
-0.5514381527900696,
-0.20518751442432404,
-0.29335352778434753,
-0.2004384994506836,
0.10645172744989395,
0.43003228306770325,
-0.2915789783000946,
0.8467918634414673,
0.691983699798584,
0.17383840680122375,
-0.2831283211708069,
0.032148197293281555,
0.9935032725334167,
-0.6342713236808777,
-0.6868191361427307,
-0.8221698999404907,
0.7186306715011597,
-0.22027327120304108,
-0.01681044138967991,
0.3086446225643158,
0.3227194845676422,
0.5640736222267151,
-0.054015882313251495,
0.42833608388900757,
0.23719708621501923,
0.428949773311615,
-0.19970454275608063,
0.46741074323654175,
-0.5404940843582153,
-0.14805372059345245,
-0.300211101770401,
-0.8098071813583374,
0.005241138860583305,
0.3815035820007324,
-0.8748049736022949,
0.3165118992328644,
0.8983434438705444,
0.49721911549568176,
0.2766841948032379,
-0.0960952565073967,
0.4334835410118103,
0.09925317019224167,
0.3768942952156067,
0.3356463611125946,
1.2064791917800903,
0.17792728543281555,
0.19730205833911896,
0.04095614328980446,
-0.3423563838005066,
-0.13713517785072327,
-0.7981482744216919,
-0.8464723229408264,
-0.5517106652259827,
0.33953580260276794,
0.03995966538786888,
0.02861165441572666,
0.8928356170654297,
0.898335337638855,
-0.4700435698032379,
-0.3612445294857025,
-0.35881075263023376,
0.26425257325172424,
-0.2561814486980438,
-0.1252981573343277,
0.09516085684299469,
-0.39763614535331726,
-0.5611720085144043,
0.6386871337890625,
0.08014996349811554,
0.3533627688884735,
-0.19596339762210846,
-0.4451233446598053,
-0.37095558643341064,
0.5718159079551697,
0.8067449927330017,
0.397802472114563,
-0.5079635381698608,
0.13400518894195557,
0.08702301979064941,
0.16294336318969727,
-0.19987308979034424,
0.9422390460968018,
-1.0718274116516113,
0.7329274415969849,
0.7283489108085632,
0.22646261751651764,
0.5904567837715149,
0.2948218584060669,
1.1474114656448364,
-0.13394322991371155,
0.42108821868896484,
0.596622884273529,
0.31214427947998047,
-0.05077636241912842,
-0.46198770403862,
0.5833784937858582,
-0.05219800025224686,
-0.5790002346038818,
-0.4392751455307007,
0.5628775358200073,
-0.7009724974632263,
-0.7449776530265808,
0.999197244644165,
-0.023021239787340164,
-0.23203697800636292,
0.00688464380800724,
-0.15730012953281403,
0.4348331093788147,
-0.4100130498409271,
0.14011907577514648,
0.5548458695411682,
-0.35907649993896484,
0.044134628027677536,
-0.316686749458313,
0.7394170761108398,
0.4845731258392334,
-1.0372209548950195,
-0.11439000070095062,
0.5273219347000122,
-0.08509418368339539,
0.37082284688949585,
1.211585521697998,
0.057813700288534164,
0.3347335159778595,
0.22084757685661316,
0.12686972320079803,
-0.20225997269153595,
-0.9050780534744263,
0.22116369009017944,
0.07434771955013275,
0.25504037737846375,
-0.0202865581959486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11532v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11532v2 | Chain-of-Instructions: Compositional Instruction Tuning on Large Language Models | 2024-02-18T10:10:40 | 2024-06-24T22:43:57 | Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Taehee Jung, Tristan Bodding-Long, Sudipta Kar, Abhinav Sethy, Joo-Kyung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) with a collection of large and
diverse instructions has improved the model's generalization to different
tasks, even for unseen tasks. However, most existing instruction datasets
include only single instructions, and they struggle to follow complex
instructions composed of multiple subtasks. In this work, we propose a novel
concept of compositional instructions called chain-of-instructions (CoI), where
the output of one instruction becomes an input for the next like a chain.
Unlike the conventional practice of solving single instruction tasks, our
proposed method encourages a model to solve each subtask step by step until the
final answer is reached. CoI-tuning (i.e., fine-tuning with CoI instructions)
improves the model's ability to handle instructions composed of multiple
subtasks as well as unseen composite tasks such as multilingual summarization.
Overall, our study find that simple CoI tuning of existing instruction data can
provide consistent generalization to solve more complex, unseen, and longer
chains of instructions. | [
-0.25567227602005005,
-0.8260250091552734,
0.4911915957927704,
0.2578193247318268,
-0.21558994054794312,
0.3550454080104828,
-0.45526236295700073,
-0.2265963852405548,
0.15714432299137115,
0.6116828322410583,
-1.1378318071365356,
-0.6687428951263428,
-0.4330926835536957,
0.02244511805474758,
-0.1385902464389801,
1.0602548122406006,
-0.14165589213371277,
0.04711141809821129,
-0.21480219066143036,
0.04569728672504425,
-0.6850832104682922,
-0.42362821102142334,
-0.7035150527954102,
-0.46708789467811584,
0.7983996272087097,
0.8863393068313599,
0.47440865635871887,
0.9340599179267883,
0.5372985005378723,
0.23683962225914001,
0.18597246706485748,
0.6174957156181335,
-0.6981048583984375,
0.027083583176136017,
-0.23879504203796387,
-0.5137218236923218,
-0.6856468915939331,
-0.18461279571056366,
0.6173413395881653,
1.0480507612228394,
-0.13173751533031464,
0.1688259392976761,
0.09884493798017502,
0.854408323764801,
-0.7993810772895813,
0.1393500715494156,
-0.3894725739955902,
-0.10139427334070206,
-0.013107198290526867,
-0.44535183906555176,
-0.6066296100616455,
-0.16450093686580658,
0.10929594188928604,
-0.6468692421913147,
-0.08054673671722412,
0.2240104079246521,
0.46193212270736694,
0.08465585857629776,
-0.2925635576248169,
-0.5554841160774231,
-0.8575742840766907,
1.0516902208328247,
-0.7020229697227478,
0.10315381735563278,
0.22513017058372498,
0.08951874077320099,
-0.20856784284114838,
-0.3335317373275757,
-0.2629421055316925,
-0.1752896010875702,
-0.04365718364715576,
0.1661144644021988,
0.07701082527637482,
0.24803777039051056,
0.10297703742980957,
0.4979081451892853,
-0.5096246004104614,
0.4104280471801758,
-0.16463519632816315,
0.11116284877061844,
0.7401524186134338,
0.4139723777770996,
0.5882634520530701,
0.5086140036582947,
-0.20756258070468903,
0.04291919618844986,
-0.8500507473945618,
-0.10172785818576813,
0.4552338719367981,
0.4030616283416748,
-0.4742942452430725,
0.4084637761116028,
-0.42065706849098206,
0.9317308068275452,
0.3727268576622009,
-0.16211152076721191,
-0.10750334709882736,
-0.4301513135433197,
-0.0653001144528389,
0.2773570418357849,
0.6264837384223938,
0.1303592473268509,
0.42453762888908386,
-0.33533212542533875,
-0.1557367593050003,
-0.16810117661952972,
0.13041727244853973,
-0.7365034818649292,
-0.30490851402282715,
0.10259256511926651,
-0.26224765181541443,
-0.15196244418621063,
0.1440751701593399,
-0.4107573330402374,
-0.01983199268579483,
-0.4749129116535187,
0.35028311610221863,
-0.20525500178337097,
0.18401135504245758,
0.2783651351928711,
0.13445302844047546,
0.18730290234088898,
0.18133480846881866,
-1.3407918214797974,
0.6150858402252197,
0.9543269276618958,
0.7890757918357849,
-0.26593512296676636,
-0.5184773206710815,
-0.8609907031059265,
0.4404486119747162,
-0.4408089220523834,
0.4458352029323578,
-0.8001959919929504,
-0.27813148498535156,
-0.09756891429424286,
0.00889657624065876,
-0.2624835968017578,
-0.4840054512023926,
0.024480663239955902,
-0.4995976984500885,
0.05933421850204468,
-0.4090634882450104,
-0.7394991517066956,
-0.06021755933761597,
0.1675567477941513,
-0.8205898404121399,
0.6302852034568787,
-0.1452307403087616,
-0.506804883480072,
-0.2231959104537964,
-0.5938459038734436,
-0.8077996969223022,
-0.1817626804113388,
-0.03507380187511444,
-0.2522815763950348,
0.2735525965690613,
0.22330331802368164,
0.42239677906036377,
-0.3446243405342102,
0.06661233305931091,
-0.38210099935531616,
-0.5120862126350403,
0.06955579668283463,
-0.33569058775901794,
0.4758978486061096,
-0.03727671131491661,
-0.15387080609798431,
0.14776140451431274,
-0.7519660592079163,
0.06689459085464478,
-0.2162259966135025,
-0.521065354347229,
-0.3322767913341522,
0.021379847079515457,
-0.513347864151001,
-0.15787215530872345,
0.5708274841308594,
-0.3794216513633728,
0.4507959485054016,
-0.4263545572757721,
0.275561660528183,
0.7527848482131958,
0.1061096116900444,
0.5879598259925842,
-0.3961474895477295,
0.39350852370262146,
-0.003818565048277378,
0.1376183032989502,
-0.49173620343208313,
-0.3059360384941101,
-1.015547275543213,
-0.07335484027862549,
0.20051540434360504,
0.6657170057296753,
-0.7307924032211304,
0.5563036799430847,
-0.32362544536590576,
-0.3256353437900543,
-0.2397938072681427,
0.19651255011558533,
0.7008956074714661,
0.11956771463155746,
0.3200613558292389,
-0.2893296480178833,
-0.6403642296791077,
-0.8454853296279907,
-0.21742577850818634,
0.22513744235038757,
0.1292474865913391,
0.1347861886024475,
0.5390245914459229,
-0.016326259821653366,
0.463851660490036,
-0.5791912078857422,
0.09547670185565948,
-0.13438153266906738,
0.38975363969802856,
0.21225884556770325,
0.6904107332229614,
-0.12641766667366028,
-0.3288326859474182,
-0.5764636993408203,
0.38656920194625854,
-0.6567938923835754,
-0.00031981838401407003,
-0.1686173528432846,
-0.1980838179588318,
-0.08694269508123398,
0.521798849105835,
-0.13692831993103027,
-0.025190014392137527,
0.7807744145393372,
-0.03295055031776428,
0.4142615795135498,
-0.5366025567054749,
0.1371413618326187,
-1.146111249923706,
-0.10915502905845642,
-0.2856425642967224,
-0.2044912427663803,
-0.5579211115837097,
0.4648054242134094,
-0.13457639515399933,
-0.08721494674682617,
-0.23677463829517365,
0.18603506684303284,
-0.6982139348983765,
0.10850575566291809,
-0.3790183365345001,
-0.12033643573522568,
-0.034700002521276474,
0.71449875831604,
-0.0966544821858406,
0.7733742594718933,
0.6458677649497986,
-0.7975341081619263,
0.5235878825187683,
-0.0893649309873581,
-0.2309117168188095,
0.12282510846853256,
-0.5800080299377441,
0.5671207904815674,
-0.07348030805587769,
0.22763822972774506,
-0.7419764399528503,
-0.2513001263141632,
0.14128778874874115,
0.13714724779129028,
0.40391674637794495,
0.03960350155830383,
-0.3791031241416931,
-0.17590802907943726,
-0.15128161013126373,
0.5023523569107056,
0.2252538502216339,
-0.55942302942276,
0.604086697101593,
0.12161696702241898,
-0.05827692896127701,
-0.5959166884422302,
-0.7440070509910583,
-0.17286863923072815,
0.15304304659366608,
-0.44431254267692566,
0.5635946989059448,
-0.3559820353984833,
-0.09644169360399246,
-0.09677060693502426,
-0.4185921251773834,
-0.251417338848114,
0.08768994361162186,
0.07435578107833862,
0.1288386881351471,
-0.26167696714401245,
-0.008829277940094471,
0.5808919668197632,
-0.06862205266952515,
-0.12239260226488113,
-0.4903453290462494,
0.712303638458252,
-0.10413289070129395,
-0.39530161023139954,
-0.6841422915458679,
0.7320188879966736,
0.5918560028076172,
-0.43304744362831116,
0.7030194997787476,
0.3391827344894409,
-0.1844550520181656,
-0.33816811442375183,
-0.36240795254707336,
-0.15947718918323517,
-0.44025978446006775,
0.4164499044418335,
-0.5381976366043091,
-1.0550780296325684,
0.5213054418563843,
-0.3601543605327606,
-0.050870515406131744,
0.07112692296504974,
0.4922610819339752,
-0.1500619500875473,
1.1080422401428223,
0.7577431797981262,
-0.3133837878704071,
0.4785946309566498,
-0.5034380555152893,
0.22218069434165955,
-0.7366125583648682,
-0.15582503378391266,
-0.38386979699134827,
-0.5587401390075684,
-0.5782678127288818,
-0.31039947271347046,
0.3687296211719513,
0.2136869579553604,
-0.22449323534965515,
0.3631722331047058,
-0.2914940118789673,
1.0039390325546265,
0.573274552822113,
0.46761587262153625,
0.37929922342300415,
0.05625174939632416,
-0.07046635448932648,
0.4043726921081543,
-0.8901606202125549,
-0.4248175621032715,
0.7918999195098877,
0.14198416471481323,
0.9775670766830444,
-0.03011401556432247,
1.0759226083755493,
0.18453404307365417,
-0.08333247154951096,
-0.6165006756782532,
0.5935815572738647,
-0.84968101978302,
-0.2727263271808624,
-0.3093198835849762,
-0.3734608292579651,
-0.7101468443870544,
-0.05104514956474304,
0.020969310775399208,
-0.7796147465705872,
0.10386384278535843,
0.35162195563316345,
-0.4972369074821472,
0.2146024852991104,
-0.8458189368247986,
0.8314750790596008,
-0.27777373790740967,
-0.38439515233039856,
-0.5246355533599854,
-0.5412923097610474,
0.3114660382270813,
0.21075962483882904,
0.1739332228899002,
0.1276664435863495,
-0.10353515297174454,
0.5644585490226746,
-0.6044483780860901,
1.124413251876831,
0.206465482711792,
-0.40692374110221863,
0.39177173376083374,
0.09164483845233917,
0.8144907355308533,
-0.14492666721343994,
0.05950755253434181,
-0.09738549590110779,
0.0318865142762661,
-0.43553000688552856,
-0.9397386908531189,
0.9881279468536377,
-0.6635362505912781,
-0.558233380317688,
0.13069778680801392,
-0.7643975615501404,
-0.07676741480827332,
0.025305934250354767,
0.13809794187545776,
0.628262460231781,
-0.14817798137664795,
-0.012796396389603615,
0.8770505785942078,
-0.039136990904808044,
0.40218594670295715,
0.44869139790534973,
0.004185750149190426,
-0.30843958258628845,
1.1983023881912231,
-0.00480993464589119,
0.4868420660495758,
0.9024323225021362,
0.31027841567993164,
0.07396188378334045,
-0.4347395896911621,
-0.47351309657096863,
0.17694225907325745,
-0.5641959309577942,
0.014592085033655167,
-0.3367002606391907,
-0.041703592985868454,
0.02984093874692917,
-0.05274304747581482,
-0.3673834800720215,
-0.18483079969882965,
-0.39497455954551697,
0.18191593885421753,
0.07416491210460663,
0.7289092540740967,
0.3058857023715973,
0.39591115713119507,
-0.8477638363838196,
0.2919730544090271,
0.5505687594413757,
0.5705434679985046,
0.17590321600437164,
-0.3741663098335266,
-0.7258111238479614,
0.3509194552898407,
-0.12199078500270844,
-0.7282716035842896,
0.03698839619755745,
0.348167359828949,
0.24822492897510529,
0.20047925412654877,
-0.14731796085834503,
1.0714319944381714,
-0.7771135568618774,
0.48068109154701233,
0.13662771880626678,
-1.1069526672363281,
0.44830331206321716,
-0.4092309772968292,
0.7015401124954224,
0.5114682912826538,
0.4435078203678131,
-0.4655269682407379,
-0.3976798355579376,
-0.1323481798171997,
-0.6594374179840088,
0.6219751834869385,
-0.12455833703279495,
0.23692554235458374,
0.01989542692899704,
0.4603923261165619,
0.33281245827674866,
0.1452769637107849,
-0.4769839942455292,
-0.17337076365947723,
0.28067895770072937,
-0.5186129808425903,
0.044869184494018555,
-0.24414171278476715,
-0.12015385925769806,
-0.28235119581222534,
0.7540420889854431,
-0.1997402310371399,
0.11374282091856003,
-0.06055285781621933,
-0.12858442962169647,
-0.3677653670310974,
0.5079960227012634,
0.8291446566581726,
0.7970618009567261,
-0.0020609768107533455,
0.23628933727741241,
0.20762406289577484,
-0.3121144771575928,
0.022702878341078758,
-0.3416967988014221,
-0.13121086359024048,
-0.42526867985725403,
0.6346812844276428,
1.187127709388733,
0.367114394903183,
-0.6326972246170044,
0.16018866002559662,
0.16361293196678162,
-0.08955617994070053,
-0.1375236064195633,
0.36661824584007263,
0.15081442892551422,
0.20458298921585083,
0.08459407091140747,
0.04397791996598244,
0.05152969807386398,
-0.8094530701637268,
0.08564060926437378,
0.28580009937286377,
-0.3052332401275635,
-0.4777097702026367,
0.3133623003959656,
0.22607453167438507,
-0.47861096262931824,
0.5819429755210876,
-0.09888642281293869,
-0.2358776181936264,
0.4990675151348114,
0.6687055826187134,
0.8369670510292053,
-0.11389608681201935,
0.15944577753543854,
0.24610896408557892,
0.2782655954360962,
-0.25585827231407166,
0.38509759306907654,
0.03420776128768921,
-0.5865670442581177,
-0.8724351525306702,
-0.43219277262687683,
-0.4495275616645813,
0.18362823128700256,
-0.7608058452606201,
0.03251055255532265,
-0.5584843158721924,
0.4195632040500641,
-0.10312310606241226,
-0.15385273098945618,
-0.39716392755508423,
0.2924032509326935,
0.2462221086025238,
0.6591148972511292,
-0.8184749484062195,
0.926713228225708,
0.548911988735199,
-0.32717764377593994,
-1.0243477821350098,
0.09261411428451538,
-0.36207011342048645,
-0.5157524943351746,
0.4056189954280853,
0.11507142335176468,
-0.3383004367351532,
0.20044660568237305,
-0.6881415843963623,
-0.8294692039489746,
1.0250091552734375,
0.5590246319770813,
-1.1780959367752075,
-0.16854946315288544,
0.27670684456825256,
0.5777539610862732,
-0.778174877166748,
-0.00914160069078207,
0.6193220615386963,
0.28900548815727234,
0.02031136304140091,
-0.8062700033187866,
0.06859547644853592,
-0.1481369286775589,
0.030077248811721802,
0.12649153172969818,
-0.7730223536491394,
0.9806642532348633,
-0.2321939319372177,
-0.20272770524024963,
0.3616659939289093,
0.5905007123947144,
-0.011525286361575127,
0.1300845444202423,
0.4017386734485626,
0.6022440195083618,
0.8121187090873718,
0.11875691264867783,
1.2588603496551514,
-0.4622959494590759,
0.29432228207588196,
1.5726103782653809,
-0.15994064509868622,
0.7753684520721436,
0.43760257959365845,
0.09382936358451843,
0.9141559600830078,
0.40807923674583435,
0.04691527411341667,
0.4924185276031494,
0.3681158721446991,
-0.3952242434024811,
-0.4855847656726837,
-0.11767847090959549,
-0.0262075737118721,
0.4807036221027374,
0.08142106980085373,
-0.281305193901062,
-0.09740912169218063,
0.030451275408267975,
-0.20523302257061005,
0.1815693974494934,
-0.5033446550369263,
0.9279844760894775,
-0.07241333276033401,
-0.9094526171684265,
0.7507177591323853,
0.12586815655231476,
0.4164918065071106,
-0.5751592516899109,
-0.2995409071445465,
-0.09802467375993729,
0.1433587372303009,
-0.17935441434383392,
-0.42400309443473816,
0.21269826591014862,
-0.04340370371937752,
-0.6556514501571655,
-0.13316762447357178,
0.48070356249809265,
-0.8288542032241821,
-0.5658080577850342,
0.18907305598258972,
0.3848107159137726,
-0.04532530531287193,
-0.015248573385179043,
-0.4353613555431366,
0.1955224573612213,
-0.10283510386943817,
0.102581687271595,
0.18972505629062653,
0.30348458886146545,
-0.20257990062236786,
0.8344465494155884,
0.39126813411712646,
-0.15699604153633118,
0.22893722355365753,
0.2482418715953827,
0.8698688745498657,
-0.5774025321006775,
-0.502974808216095,
-1.0552918910980225,
0.4761573374271393,
0.12837719917297363,
-0.038379378616809845,
0.5788272619247437,
0.6971874237060547,
1.1078068017959595,
-0.4548244774341583,
0.6600165963172913,
0.17836016416549683,
0.2262236475944519,
-0.8244971036911011,
0.39804327487945557,
-0.4532284438610077,
0.34712180495262146,
-0.014142434112727642,
-0.7083454728126526,
-0.1650623232126236,
0.2083529680967331,
-0.30390384793281555,
0.04301288723945618,
1.0404247045516968,
0.9928330779075623,
-0.18991443514823914,
0.16425539553165436,
0.2539582848548889,
0.1148790493607521,
-0.04743380472064018,
0.6892974972724915,
0.6636032462120056,
-0.45379558205604553,
0.32733580470085144,
-0.34323403239250183,
-0.05692421644926071,
0.09162075817584991,
-0.721392810344696,
-1.0230205059051514,
-0.37802577018737793,
-0.5108617544174194,
0.04862732067704201,
0.3997951149940491,
0.8980768918991089,
0.7433786392211914,
-1.1026349067687988,
-0.7068603038787842,
-0.5228452682495117,
0.2387705147266388,
-0.6991013288497925,
-0.12608473002910614,
0.16580432653427124,
-0.5084790587425232,
-0.8109037280082703,
0.6542418599128723,
0.5323087573051453,
-0.2598411738872528,
-0.22250166535377502,
-0.27804937958717346,
-0.409527450799942,
0.2315542846918106,
0.6089529991149902,
0.10360652208328247,
-0.7390540838241577,
-0.28090110421180725,
0.03560145944356918,
0.06057484820485115,
0.03713051229715347,
1.2787100076675415,
-0.20722512900829315,
0.5927314162254333,
0.45264095067977905,
0.6047013998031616,
0.5761359930038452,
-0.17625854909420013,
0.7577637434005737,
-1.119292974472046,
-0.13757701218128204,
-0.10692068934440613,
0.07944705337285995,
0.08903113007545471,
-0.28916993737220764,
0.15963907539844513,
0.03893494978547096,
-0.3070625960826874,
-0.4172924757003784,
0.5871630311012268,
-1.1753895282745361,
-0.2774611711502075,
0.8174562454223633,
-0.29986265301704407,
-0.5565800666809082,
0.20859196782112122,
-0.20228326320648193,
0.4548671841621399,
-0.3195078670978546,
0.6576099991798401,
0.6259624361991882,
-0.004836966749280691,
-0.32455217838287354,
-0.0374741405248642,
0.057569194585084915,
0.434662401676178,
-0.8984310030937195,
0.15639659762382507,
0.26808592677116394,
0.19377954304218292,
0.07127662748098373,
0.2666723132133484,
0.22486111521720886,
0.22515997290611267,
-0.20083528757095337,
-0.016513025388121605,
-0.26602277159690857,
-0.6361836194992065,
-0.25921186804771423,
0.1502169668674469,
-0.02834273874759674,
-0.374485582113266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11525v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11525v3 | Advancing Translation Preference Modeling with RLHF: A Step Towards Cost-Effective Solution | 2024-02-18T09:51:49 | 2024-02-27T17:12:38 | Nuo Xu, Jun Zhao, Can Zu, Sixian Li, Lu Chen, Zhihao Zhang, Rui Zheng, Shihan Dou, Wenjuan Qin, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Faithfulness, expressiveness, and elegance is the constant pursuit in machine
translation. However, traditional metrics like \textit{BLEU} do not strictly
align with human preference of translation quality. In this paper, we explore
leveraging reinforcement learning with human feedback (\textit{RLHF}) to
improve translation quality. It is non-trivial to collect a large high-quality
dataset of human comparisons between translations, especially for low-resource
languages. To address this issue, we propose a cost-effective preference
learning strategy, optimizing reward models by distinguishing between human and
machine translations. In this manner, the reward model learns the deficiencies
of machine translation compared to human and guides subsequent improvements in
machine translation. Experimental results demonstrate that \textit{RLHF} can
effectively enhance translation quality and this improvement benefits other
translation directions not trained with \textit{RLHF}. Further analysis
indicates that the model's language capabilities play a crucial role in
preference learning. A reward model with strong language capabilities can more
sensitively learn the subtle differences in translation quality and align
better with real human translation preferences. | [
-0.13533630967140198,
-0.29700610041618347,
0.35220006108283997,
0.1005612164735794,
-0.3020796775817871,
0.10643399506807327,
-0.5157290101051331,
-0.4511837959289551,
0.05045521259307861,
0.5856307148933411,
-0.6188474893569946,
-0.27733466029167175,
-0.7806326150894165,
0.18525192141532898,
0.19977974891662598,
1.1263214349746704,
-0.19095478951931,
0.17268449068069458,
-0.0748276486992836,
-0.4071391224861145,
-0.3465234935283661,
-0.6167668104171753,
-0.656607449054718,
-0.7818189859390259,
0.9172361493110657,
0.65272057056427,
0.8992232084274292,
0.7993500232696533,
0.5350522994995117,
0.24079065024852753,
0.17696988582611084,
0.5554945468902588,
-0.6001986861228943,
0.25760433077812195,
-0.16835319995880127,
-0.5499789714813232,
-0.4818342328071594,
0.18441638350486755,
0.4379277229309082,
0.3627503514289856,
-0.3061010539531708,
-0.05728336423635483,
-0.07490979880094528,
1.1882169246673584,
-0.37882205843925476,
0.23980800807476044,
-0.29727303981781006,
0.2502504587173462,
0.07284475862979889,
-0.4365287125110626,
-0.5441705584526062,
-0.5080179572105408,
0.08327238261699677,
-0.5629645586013794,
0.01664850302040577,
0.27772146463394165,
1.1727005243301392,
0.495447039604187,
-0.3611541986465454,
0.022682949900627136,
-0.5712004899978638,
1.0401488542556763,
-0.6074253916740417,
0.678475558757782,
0.5595632791519165,
0.14390946924686432,
-0.1831231415271759,
-0.11428824812173843,
-0.17380473017692566,
-0.5836835503578186,
-0.18802671134471893,
0.25024986267089844,
0.18985800445079803,
-0.0431271567940712,
-0.031555626541376114,
0.3800204396247864,
-0.5452758073806763,
0.0679045245051384,
-0.1662740260362625,
-0.10780773311853409,
0.7259255647659302,
-0.00694811437278986,
0.3021167516708374,
-0.291839599609375,
-0.3884035348892212,
-0.741300106048584,
-0.6560771465301514,
0.47494006156921387,
0.3941511809825897,
0.43850791454315186,
-0.10326967388391495,
0.27381831407546997,
-0.20221823453903198,
0.5620925426483154,
0.16310207545757294,
-0.34426674246788025,
0.3110845386981964,
-0.021372167393565178,
-0.10927966982126236,
-0.06549807637929916,
0.7876301407814026,
0.3480200171470642,
0.1299474835395813,
-0.3340953588485718,
-0.6220293641090393,
-0.14724770188331604,
0.5436248183250427,
-0.7590354084968567,
-0.08051170408725739,
0.06462907791137695,
-0.6856886148452759,
-0.443988561630249,
0.019818400964140892,
-0.3722955584526062,
-0.23193717002868652,
-0.3815411627292633,
0.2141859382390976,
-0.2861000597476959,
-0.37527379393577576,
0.06498026102781296,
0.026265449821949005,
0.0843951553106308,
0.28984907269477844,
-1.1952741146087646,
0.023530561476945877,
0.5147548317909241,
0.6285199522972107,
-0.6574793457984924,
-0.3699307441711426,
-0.8331801891326904,
-0.19037935137748718,
-0.5027853846549988,
0.6261923313140869,
-0.20615099370479584,
-0.7154104709625244,
-0.15953166782855988,
-0.05106164887547493,
0.08567659556865692,
-0.8994218111038208,
0.8088113069534302,
-0.7434931993484497,
0.1487540602684021,
-0.35621440410614014,
-0.4389747381210327,
-0.1987040638923645,
0.19819101691246033,
-0.6402266025543213,
0.8961597084999084,
0.37757354974746704,
-0.337661474943161,
0.5305702686309814,
-0.5617971420288086,
-0.4188115894794464,
0.09793877601623535,
0.05916232988238335,
-0.6761377453804016,
0.18167901039123535,
0.2590935230255127,
0.20074276626110077,
-0.0932321697473526,
0.4811275899410248,
-0.1354014277458191,
-0.18039606511592865,
0.49929213523864746,
-0.3615265190601349,
0.26869305968284607,
0.3622821271419525,
-0.16437259316444397,
0.6045721769332886,
-0.23415346443653107,
-0.06116357445716858,
0.17142580449581146,
-0.9092437624931335,
-0.20889350771903992,
-0.04866166040301323,
0.23323717713356018,
0.2187282145023346,
0.19455325603485107,
-0.2962806522846222,
0.18950961530208588,
-0.6773948073387146,
0.21371696889400482,
0.7844658493995667,
-0.23179252445697784,
0.7430802583694458,
-0.40975797176361084,
0.7032913565635681,
-0.011782274581491947,
0.2537890374660492,
0.43379688262939453,
-0.21416381001472473,
-0.7693042755126953,
0.0372314490377903,
0.43450728058815,
0.33835697174072266,
-0.6435496211051941,
0.357602059841156,
-0.3769093155860901,
-0.13861504197120667,
-0.8352685570716858,
0.32701385021209717,
0.5973076820373535,
0.5179957747459412,
0.5948195457458496,
-0.47575607895851135,
-0.14494949579238892,
-0.8468858003616333,
-0.3288955092430115,
-0.35188981890678406,
0.15627014636993408,
0.466700941324234,
0.18119576573371887,
-0.0855456292629242,
0.6710397601127625,
-0.3962263762950897,
-0.207281693816185,
-0.4703083634376526,
0.21851171553134918,
0.204154372215271,
0.4620644748210907,
0.3660372197628021,
-1.0264322757720947,
-0.5126051902770996,
0.22386063635349274,
-0.374568909406662,
0.10728627443313599,
0.12007348984479904,
-0.35421887040138245,
0.44140565395355225,
0.14076781272888184,
-0.20188301801681519,
0.045484717935323715,
0.698828935623169,
-0.27234670519828796,
0.44882065057754517,
-0.48026159405708313,
0.5091773271560669,
-0.7297110557556152,
0.04477270320057869,
-0.0467248298227787,
-0.6000630259513855,
-0.31400254368782043,
0.18877561390399933,
0.3454880118370056,
0.1484585553407669,
-0.6424251198768616,
0.6363617777824402,
0.04956105723977089,
-0.09451998770236969,
-0.5030916333198547,
-0.02177472598850727,
-0.0000071374793151335325,
0.7943515777587891,
0.5387093424797058,
0.9772313833236694,
-0.24005816876888275,
-0.5720224976539612,
0.34030914306640625,
0.3014315664768219,
-0.21226999163627625,
0.410030335187912,
-0.5916433334350586,
0.0035979049280285835,
0.07294336706399918,
0.14266617596149445,
-0.6656920909881592,
-0.17656812071800232,
0.5350930690765381,
-0.8117092251777649,
0.37360918521881104,
-0.12769715487957,
-0.2879786193370819,
-0.0064472840167582035,
-0.031130466610193253,
0.2839615046977997,
0.5886581540107727,
-0.6510576009750366,
0.2411556988954544,
0.27534228563308716,
-0.117940254509449,
-0.6358026266098022,
-0.36756017804145813,
-0.0753578394651413,
-0.11171305924654007,
-0.2732558846473694,
0.42279234528541565,
-0.0051820483058691025,
0.1747356355190277,
0.014104373753070831,
-0.07042066007852554,
0.1604950726032257,
0.18258704245090485,
0.21708181500434875,
0.4910738170146942,
0.07595933973789215,
0.2394559681415558,
-0.038793690502643585,
-0.5509961247444153,
-0.11927738785743713,
-0.5493428111076355,
0.32270559668540955,
-0.2431870847940445,
-0.08866488188505173,
-0.17360809445381165,
0.2029561698436737,
0.4294334948062897,
-0.5752580761909485,
0.47983017563819885,
0.6622278690338135,
0.13004672527313232,
-0.267516553401947,
-0.35591644048690796,
-0.5263769030570984,
-0.4201090633869171,
0.4743480086326599,
-0.2797699570655823,
-0.8692046403884888,
-0.09877397865056992,
-0.013199621811509132,
0.1006554588675499,
0.2366994023323059,
0.4363056421279907,
-0.2032191902399063,
1.2242735624313354,
0.6322075128555298,
-0.33937782049179077,
0.6693273782730103,
-0.1308215707540512,
0.09183238446712494,
-0.6196059584617615,
-0.07847148180007935,
-0.4764486849308014,
-0.4095294177532196,
-0.7133707404136658,
-0.38200536370277405,
0.4488650858402252,
0.0983407199382782,
-0.2600724697113037,
0.4769306480884552,
-0.3785390257835388,
0.23494070768356323,
0.7571813464164734,
0.3771030902862549,
0.48342522978782654,
0.20575261116027832,
-0.24835357069969177,
-0.27721408009529114,
-0.7574771642684937,
-0.40928253531455994,
0.927776575088501,
0.4373534917831421,
0.6691600680351257,
0.1537170708179474,
0.8579343557357788,
0.4181838035583496,
0.4228673577308655,
-0.9204257726669312,
0.09737905114889145,
-0.16106049716472626,
-0.2383042424917221,
-0.5857846140861511,
-0.7607936859130859,
-0.7900368571281433,
0.34153300523757935,
-0.3845173418521881,
-0.10199031978845596,
0.1397455334663391,
0.5004920363426208,
-0.15661297738552094,
0.14584335684776306,
-0.3800220191478729,
1.0707300901412964,
-0.6799094676971436,
-0.5410611629486084,
-0.5682139992713928,
-0.615075409412384,
0.22437867522239685,
0.3665456175804138,
0.1517404317855835,
-0.06335312128067017,
0.16445110738277435,
0.7188708782196045,
-0.2025180459022522,
0.45258593559265137,
0.039047736674547195,
-0.14784575998783112,
-0.2462027221918106,
0.2833288311958313,
0.6201072335243225,
0.11789639294147491,
-0.02722671627998352,
-0.14136098325252533,
-0.2509743273258209,
-0.5693840980529785,
-0.6396449208259583,
0.550524890422821,
-1.1216251850128174,
-0.44504523277282715,
-0.39119014143943787,
-0.5811685919761658,
-0.3128971755504608,
0.1312192976474762,
0.20043392479419708,
0.031026490032672882,
-0.20464350283145905,
-0.08300821483135223,
0.8350176811218262,
-0.2787488102912903,
0.2371297925710678,
0.4644007086753845,
-0.42992302775382996,
-0.6310818195343018,
1.2524309158325195,
-0.3624361753463745,
0.5172764658927917,
0.7090820074081421,
0.3837112486362457,
-0.6495198607444763,
-0.25468775629997253,
-0.8518236875534058,
0.3900201916694641,
-0.5861136317253113,
-0.1558627337217331,
-0.4516238570213318,
0.03425149992108345,
-0.15322238206863403,
-0.12339825928211212,
-0.5368239879608154,
-0.22289231419563293,
-0.10689418017864227,
-0.21683599054813385,
0.30342116951942444,
0.5210081934928894,
-0.07760608196258545,
0.04561859369277954,
-0.9507623314857483,
0.21554094552993774,
0.4446483850479126,
0.2679673135280609,
0.10920947045087814,
-0.7289619445800781,
-0.5486533641815186,
0.05362881347537041,
-0.35093680024147034,
-0.6091049313545227,
0.8071504831314087,
-0.2988088130950928,
0.4766438901424408,
0.24018166959285736,
0.15071538090705872,
0.2880345284938812,
-0.23912812769412994,
0.547635018825531,
0.39523327350616455,
-0.8779062628746033,
0.3878515064716339,
-0.15299561619758606,
0.1805907040834427,
0.6653245687484741,
0.3322131931781769,
-0.937701940536499,
-0.037197135388851166,
-0.56276935338974,
-0.6728726625442505,
0.7771915197372437,
-0.06668524444103241,
-0.17789214849472046,
0.12211272865533829,
0.24746933579444885,
0.015501542016863823,
0.30146336555480957,
-0.9243454933166504,
-0.21768489480018616,
-0.40924617648124695,
0.12046116590499878,
-0.40358784794807434,
-0.04126868024468422,
-0.028258219361305237,
-0.1636618971824646,
0.9855011701583862,
-0.13856224715709686,
-0.001307270722463727,
0.04174596443772316,
-0.1971193552017212,
-0.45158490538597107,
0.46995213627815247,
0.5886610150337219,
0.320642352104187,
-0.37814176082611084,
-0.017902838066220284,
-0.030693568289279938,
-0.0670032948255539,
0.443332314491272,
-0.48232123255729675,
-0.25493335723876953,
-0.15009361505508423,
0.10818556696176529,
1.10667884349823,
0.16688460111618042,
-0.5915078520774841,
0.4688322842121124,
-0.0452825203537941,
-0.23612821102142334,
0.17517578601837158,
0.24358077347278595,
0.28713056445121765,
0.0062419213354587555,
-0.07107953727245331,
0.1638696789741516,
-0.024449804797768593,
-0.25951874256134033,
0.09541719406843185,
0.30726492404937744,
-1.0218833684921265,
0.04947541654109955,
0.4216906428337097,
0.5195605754852295,
-0.5192328691482544,
0.7026624083518982,
-0.2862689793109894,
-0.652574360370636,
0.3738277554512024,
0.42282119393348694,
0.7791486978530884,
-0.274069607257843,
0.5444030165672302,
0.49843859672546387,
0.08601284772157669,
-0.40788209438323975,
-0.07230649888515472,
-0.2177257239818573,
-0.6929756999015808,
-0.3830532729625702,
-0.7018209099769592,
-0.6671990156173706,
-0.288877010345459,
-0.7681395411491394,
0.09463834762573242,
-0.03519255295395851,
-0.15657727420330048,
-0.5173618197441101,
0.008029229938983917,
-0.43484020233154297,
0.19741789996623993,
-0.050353456288576126,
0.43317490816116333,
-0.7237818241119385,
0.95817631483078,
0.6289867758750916,
-0.7629834413528442,
-0.8966032862663269,
-0.1186412051320076,
-0.2383946031332016,
-0.7070248126983643,
0.9980548024177551,
-0.23021200299263,
-0.44389453530311584,
0.10212576389312744,
-0.353751003742218,
-0.5351534485816956,
0.7830587029457092,
0.22388224303722382,
-0.43594664335250854,
0.10278426855802536,
0.030627097934484482,
0.3579397201538086,
-0.24033379554748535,
0.1021059900522232,
0.516402542591095,
0.699566125869751,
-0.18228648602962494,
-0.6500430107116699,
-0.16926565766334534,
-0.04172363877296448,
0.15949781239032745,
0.3872091472148895,
-0.6342443227767944,
0.4703173339366913,
-0.25251898169517517,
-0.18977639079093933,
-0.13084247708320618,
0.7541226744651794,
0.2672146260738373,
-0.13836151361465454,
0.537163257598877,
0.3833698034286499,
0.545199990272522,
0.05626986175775528,
1.1202301979064941,
-0.16920559108257294,
0.5150296688079834,
0.9269863367080688,
-0.052377648651599884,
1.1413074731826782,
0.616643488407135,
-0.2906370460987091,
0.2969522774219513,
0.8222486972808838,
0.2782145142555237,
0.7489580512046814,
0.2098708599805832,
-0.0817524790763855,
-0.7749849557876587,
-0.32797425985336304,
-0.2370157390832901,
0.050677090883255005,
0.09711446613073349,
-0.3685145974159241,
-0.1066916212439537,
0.0006689314031973481,
-0.057110536843538284,
0.501054584980011,
0.012791708111763,
0.9069280028343201,
0.1618562936782837,
-1.1958729028701782,
0.7975935935974121,
0.4462684988975525,
0.7847055792808533,
-0.5534006357192993,
-0.13058412075042725,
-0.44681358337402344,
0.1732448786497116,
-0.1493067741394043,
-0.555029571056366,
0.006170053966343403,
-0.28180834650993347,
-0.43247389793395996,
-0.6195633411407471,
0.36079141497612,
-0.6585180759429932,
-0.26662179827690125,
0.5332995653152466,
0.5437458753585815,
-0.08795574307441711,
0.05114876106381416,
-0.8242608308792114,
-0.12656836211681366,
0.15212930738925934,
-0.05130903795361519,
0.48821592330932617,
-0.048251502215862274,
0.057504117488861084,
0.6401937007904053,
0.7851171493530273,
0.3765019476413727,
-0.3600064814090729,
0.07905968278646469,
0.3669254779815674,
-0.6376525163650513,
-0.7360773682594299,
-0.7010827660560608,
0.24429908394813538,
0.021470842882990837,
-0.3585748076438904,
0.34987276792526245,
0.28057020902633667,
1.0550179481506348,
-0.35097837448120117,
0.8325971364974976,
0.4391152262687683,
0.5383253693580627,
-0.49342653155326843,
0.793976902961731,
-0.7501874566078186,
0.030910080298781395,
-0.08563809841871262,
-0.7309063673019409,
-0.1798718273639679,
0.7101590037345886,
-0.3928792476654053,
-0.10270451754331589,
0.7590914368629456,
0.9320012331008911,
-0.11178029328584671,
-0.26556146144866943,
0.6228994131088257,
-0.31933289766311646,
0.3937707841396332,
0.7597705125808716,
0.7908269762992859,
-0.24087963998317719,
0.5526018142700195,
-0.16849501430988312,
-0.24117723107337952,
-0.5040342211723328,
-0.8557223677635193,
-0.5833861231803894,
-0.5145915746688843,
-0.20378164947032928,
-0.519498884677887,
0.19842883944511414,
1.5327200889587402,
0.8842679262161255,
-0.8935982584953308,
-0.6192476749420166,
-0.04264938458800316,
0.47617825865745544,
-0.6996352076530457,
-0.17180413007736206,
0.3571373224258423,
-0.6910067200660706,
-0.7622488737106323,
0.3317698836326599,
0.3680373728275299,
-0.008902372792363167,
-0.2541656196117401,
-0.8703298568725586,
-0.018669961020350456,
-0.10586341470479965,
0.4198635220527649,
0.4797840118408203,
-0.9537575840950012,
-0.1593264937400818,
0.16338734328746796,
-0.4586643576622009,
0.2941766083240509,
0.937921941280365,
-0.49615561962127686,
0.47629880905151367,
0.5008929371833801,
1.0672705173492432,
0.5848462581634521,
0.10798967629671097,
0.7523739337921143,
-0.3557736277580261,
-0.12515822052955627,
0.09128227084875107,
0.1696317046880722,
0.4257223308086395,
-0.44475600123405457,
0.39133331179618835,
0.26745057106018066,
-0.7027209997177124,
-0.3864269256591797,
0.46842822432518005,
-0.7662478089332581,
-0.3034890592098236,
0.9972595572471619,
-0.299679696559906,
-0.20554424822330475,
0.1112978458404541,
-0.35453057289123535,
0.34340807795524597,
-0.8503547310829163,
0.9687414169311523,
0.6205336451530457,
-0.17614974081516266,
-0.22235733270645142,
-0.44574815034866333,
0.9023000597953796,
0.83222895860672,
-0.6722509264945984,
0.13457489013671875,
0.3807016611099243,
0.11789599061012268,
-0.17357183992862701,
0.5758793354034424,
-0.21742013096809387,
0.6214645504951477,
-0.5958853363990784,
0.28582924604415894,
-0.14773136377334595,
-0.38973739743232727,
-0.3993231952190399,
-0.08848953247070312,
0.7642914056777954,
-0.17813190817832947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11522v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11522v2 | Unveiling the Secrets of Engaging Conversations: Factors that Keep Users Hooked on Role-Playing Dialog Agents | 2024-02-18T09:42:41 | 2024-03-13T02:40:21 | Shuai Zhang, Yu Lu, Junwen Liu, Jia Yu, Huachuan Qiu, Yuming Yan, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the growing humanlike nature of dialog agents, people are now engaging
in extended conversations that can stretch from brief moments to substantial
periods of time. Understanding the factors that contribute to sustaining these
interactions is crucial, yet existing studies primarily focusing on short-term
simulations that rarely explore such prolonged and real conversations.
In this paper, we investigate the factors influencing retention rates in real
interactions with roleplaying models. By analyzing a large dataset of
interactions between real users and thousands of characters, we systematically
examine multiple factors and assess their impact on user retention rate.
Surprisingly, we find that the degree to which the bot embodies the roles it
plays has limited influence on retention rates, while the length of each turn
it speaks significantly affects retention rates. This study sheds light on the
critical aspects of user engagement with role-playing models and provides
valuable insights for future improvements in the development of large language
models for role-playing purposes. | [
-0.570679247379303,
-0.849528431892395,
0.8488262295722961,
-0.05630304664373398,
-0.029126543551683426,
0.3219323456287384,
0.023507175967097282,
-0.5228894352912903,
-0.026673786342144012,
0.6916167140007019,
-0.7458009719848633,
0.08427554368972778,
-0.2572539150714874,
-0.18320222198963165,
-0.14122185111045837,
0.759591281414032,
0.34633126854896545,
-0.030261021107435226,
-0.4498826563358307,
-0.10035084187984467,
-0.6765380501747131,
-0.9462521076202393,
-0.5993685722351074,
-0.6978477835655212,
0.8029659390449524,
0.4787334203720093,
1.1101235151290894,
0.5379886031150818,
0.3264923691749573,
0.2493506371974945,
-0.1797313243150711,
0.1948586106300354,
-1.0773499011993408,
0.4846666753292084,
0.07895383983850479,
-0.9598538279533386,
-0.02256585843861103,
0.370697557926178,
0.33367037773132324,
0.3706999719142914,
-0.25184571743011475,
-0.04701843857765198,
-0.017051871865987778,
0.3769187033176422,
-0.1816207319498062,
0.32741087675094604,
-0.18290743231773376,
-0.09749957174062729,
-0.19431304931640625,
-0.5130971074104309,
-0.5588085651397705,
-0.30141639709472656,
0.5605729818344116,
-0.6783869862556458,
0.14836780726909637,
-0.11827477067708969,
0.881798267364502,
-0.36670613288879395,
-0.6048031449317932,
-0.3957549035549164,
-0.8165045380592346,
0.6977134346961975,
-0.5994696021080017,
0.36361876130104065,
0.8016282916069031,
0.02204023115336895,
-0.34030795097351074,
-0.07067836076021194,
-0.701807975769043,
-0.539327085018158,
-0.24814051389694214,
-0.2362409234046936,
0.15655013918876648,
0.1768985390663147,
0.6498273611068726,
-0.010227551683783531,
-0.024948300793766975,
0.037177883088588715,
-0.5923222303390503,
-0.044595979154109955,
0.7322171330451965,
0.46993038058280945,
0.6374296545982361,
-0.02779301442205906,
-0.2089095264673233,
-0.35609644651412964,
-0.7338077425956726,
0.6715494394302368,
0.7566174864768982,
0.049332939088344574,
0.027161041274666786,
0.6329113245010376,
0.4551110863685608,
0.22887925803661346,
0.03181813657283783,
-0.07689148187637329,
-0.0983218252658844,
-0.4395468533039093,
0.2851647734642029,
-0.24325396120548248,
0.5780388712882996,
0.4498429298400879,
0.7113859057426453,
0.03335191681981087,
0.08400975167751312,
-0.14034448564052582,
0.5346503853797913,
-0.8996568918228149,
-0.017939304932951927,
0.13735276460647583,
-0.44652149081230164,
-0.2580808103084564,
0.4475634694099426,
-0.49778032302856445,
-0.5005460381507874,
-0.15931716561317444,
0.22666800022125244,
-0.5038016438484192,
-0.4434623122215271,
-0.32607513666152954,
-0.3226795792579651,
0.10681768506765366,
0.29367783665657043,
-0.8148143887519836,
0.44874218106269836,
0.9002885818481445,
0.7830564975738525,
-0.1160624548792839,
-0.19019129872322083,
-0.7021581530570984,
-0.05981823429465294,
-0.6313897371292114,
0.27701568603515625,
-0.6719487905502319,
-0.6064501404762268,
0.41502001881599426,
0.1955697238445282,
-0.11230456829071045,
-0.3319809138774872,
0.36106762290000916,
-0.7147121429443359,
0.5710626840591431,
-0.6953098177909851,
-0.6604007482528687,
-0.10312352329492569,
0.22906966507434845,
-0.7156744599342346,
0.6183127760887146,
-0.1448376178741455,
0.0467475950717926,
0.43461790680885315,
-0.8954165577888489,
-0.21844501793384552,
0.26215752959251404,
-0.16812238097190857,
-0.12665824592113495,
0.41580528020858765,
-0.27116861939430237,
0.35802578926086426,
-0.42649441957473755,
0.23474866151809692,
-0.010607953183352947,
-0.5277122855186462,
0.8940437436103821,
-0.46070531010627747,
0.4383593201637268,
0.053804684430360794,
0.058773625642061234,
0.017279714345932007,
-0.054684773087501526,
-0.36479467153549194,
-0.03680333122611046,
-0.15619157254695892,
-0.2832471430301666,
0.29574427008628845,
0.0253192950040102,
0.42097923159599304,
-0.25739800930023193,
-0.7391928434371948,
0.2676749527454376,
-0.2526427209377289,
0.48846161365509033,
0.5255106687545776,
0.481780081987381,
0.42877641320228577,
-0.4456324875354767,
0.9624345898628235,
0.08400429040193558,
0.16708822548389435,
-0.7395209074020386,
-0.5986104607582092,
-0.6334725618362427,
-0.0926840752363205,
0.31859344244003296,
0.21006880700588226,
-0.3710096478462219,
0.05286935344338417,
-0.3165278732776642,
-0.4958426356315613,
-0.608212411403656,
0.18199698626995087,
0.4688612222671509,
0.09775815159082413,
0.06998273730278015,
-0.4392099976539612,
0.19258429110050201,
-0.729675829410553,
-0.0825335830450058,
-0.5194814801216125,
-0.042328137904405594,
0.9806261658668518,
0.1856697052717209,
-0.09987033158540726,
1.455868124961853,
-0.5050233602523804,
-0.3867446184158325,
-0.6181777715682983,
0.09199605137109756,
0.005886157508939505,
0.35467469692230225,
0.521207869052887,
-0.7746750116348267,
-0.8279285430908203,
-0.16907265782356262,
-0.5287681221961975,
0.004319778177887201,
-0.6036766171455383,
-0.00741503294557333,
0.12842121720314026,
0.42128393054008484,
-1.011798620223999,
0.7985944151878357,
0.4685116708278656,
-0.5385181307792664,
0.24341942369937897,
-0.09158404916524887,
0.40010637044906616,
-0.5616910457611084,
-0.08466741442680359,
0.07857536524534225,
-0.06482978165149689,
-0.9472243189811707,
-0.15876032412052155,
0.003415906336158514,
-0.47697076201438904,
-0.3818773031234741,
0.8111555576324463,
-0.783515453338623,
0.2153855264186859,
-0.16245800256729126,
0.1820889711380005,
0.0786554366350174,
0.25305598974227905,
0.0853482112288475,
0.966410756111145,
0.23553648591041565,
-0.5914753675460815,
-0.12033161520957947,
0.5547815561294556,
-0.14903052151203156,
0.05425063893198967,
-0.9290111660957336,
0.12906306982040405,
0.15655070543289185,
0.3565593957901001,
-1.0978285074234009,
-0.14843793213367462,
0.03214004635810852,
-0.2950136959552765,
0.19098491966724396,
-0.5497296452522278,
-0.583213746547699,
-0.312627911567688,
-0.24746739864349365,
-0.04157014191150665,
0.6337380409240723,
-0.19275835156440735,
0.6559032797813416,
0.45640870928764343,
-0.23549401760101318,
-0.5204232931137085,
-0.221473827958107,
0.1518351286649704,
-0.10123173147439957,
-0.5752626061439514,
0.07902727276086807,
-0.22054605185985565,
-0.16527380049228668,
-0.12789273262023926,
-0.2726210355758667,
0.11208754032850266,
0.09588972479104996,
0.34289637207984924,
0.11139866709709167,
0.13409796357154846,
0.4039558172225952,
-0.21403324604034424,
-0.1791953146457672,
0.14486055076122284,
0.23949149250984192,
0.9821040034294128,
0.12014210224151611,
-0.3131749927997589,
-1.0613186359405518,
0.3136979341506958,
0.9055749773979187,
-0.11002252995967865,
1.0995564460754395,
0.24966569244861603,
0.13685016334056854,
0.1607179045677185,
-0.8085360527038574,
-0.7773428559303284,
-0.4873620867729187,
0.41382893919944763,
-0.41736146807670593,
-0.8277723789215088,
0.926914632320404,
0.14836423099040985,
0.1328427940607071,
-0.07619646191596985,
0.07456708699464798,
-0.3893686830997467,
1.005951166152954,
0.7140210270881653,
0.037606921046972275,
0.6997262835502625,
-0.08005726337432861,
0.3010110557079315,
-0.7019888162612915,
-0.2057756781578064,
0.11533766239881516,
-0.3184633255004883,
-0.4669010639190674,
-0.4351659417152405,
0.049480799585580826,
0.11509396135807037,
0.29355642199516296,
0.2844010293483734,
-0.013482632115483284,
0.578937828540802,
0.24341905117034912,
-0.11554548889398575,
-0.05494147911667824,
-0.4273500144481659,
0.2428424060344696,
-0.1921507567167282,
-0.5875470638275146,
-0.5303258895874023,
0.7641075253486633,
0.7478813529014587,
0.7405765652656555,
0.4539642333984375,
0.4953358769416809,
0.474797785282135,
-0.060103416442871094,
-0.6883653998374939,
0.6706942319869995,
0.5839301943778992,
-0.8374673128128052,
-0.7325363755226135,
-0.3717625141143799,
-1.215383768081665,
0.05385155230760574,
-0.36739611625671387,
-0.7304866909980774,
0.2677153944969177,
0.27404117584228516,
-0.31384575366973877,
-0.048029981553554535,
-0.5952885746955872,
0.8054342865943909,
-0.21467892825603485,
-0.6172279715538025,
-0.46247145533561707,
-0.6418027281761169,
0.0792994350194931,
0.18899625539779663,
-0.15460073947906494,
-0.45199912786483765,
0.17163850367069244,
0.6091580986976624,
-0.4185507595539093,
0.9333288073539734,
-0.37113210558891296,
-0.16464214026927948,
0.6491379737854004,
0.37306246161460876,
0.6639173626899719,
0.31142163276672363,
0.1865868866443634,
0.14100292325019836,
-0.020920956507325172,
-0.27912548184394836,
-0.7884109616279602,
0.43860092759132385,
-0.6428456902503967,
-0.8957231640815735,
-0.4813169538974762,
-0.3658014237880707,
-0.1463274210691452,
-0.26127269864082336,
-0.17110806703567505,
0.5945177674293518,
-0.41187646985054016,
0.7082224488258362,
0.9111490845680237,
-0.13641072809696198,
0.38312801718711853,
0.30742764472961426,
-0.3633735775947571,
0.1194225549697876,
0.8732235431671143,
0.3044085204601288,
0.6753542423248291,
0.13047534227371216,
0.3353433310985565,
-0.2258399873971939,
-0.07165195792913437,
-0.19291818141937256,
0.48009204864501953,
-0.12948830425739288,
-0.07036010921001434,
-0.965973973274231,
-0.16978128254413605,
-0.16291560232639313,
-0.031129224225878716,
-0.25405386090278625,
-0.4832786023616791,
-0.5433330535888672,
-0.23370106518268585,
0.48694032430648804,
0.6571546196937561,
0.17383217811584473,
0.868327796459198,
-0.7698516845703125,
-0.1220712810754776,
0.5116435289382935,
0.027032243087887764,
0.35711535811424255,
-0.4078678786754608,
-0.1332051157951355,
-0.08045589923858643,
-0.10977444052696228,
-1.1558243036270142,
0.45782482624053955,
0.146392822265625,
0.8255274891853333,
0.7045584321022034,
-0.20152147114276886,
0.6359736919403076,
-0.15911053121089935,
1.1565122604370117,
0.05791102722287178,
-0.6334021687507629,
0.28714749217033386,
-0.6745480895042419,
0.176962211728096,
0.46009957790374756,
0.5304259657859802,
-0.941982626914978,
-0.03660164028406143,
-0.657261848449707,
-0.8599972724914551,
1.109190821647644,
0.34779879450798035,
0.47571542859077454,
0.019313281401991844,
0.3340360224246979,
-0.07355847209692001,
0.3523373007774353,
-0.39999762177467346,
-0.24350625276565552,
0.09735139459371567,
0.1086658462882042,
-0.2264697402715683,
-0.8103580474853516,
-0.2966664731502533,
0.02066638506948948,
0.38877663016319275,
0.06059461459517479,
0.1675710380077362,
-0.3066653311252594,
-0.10211634635925293,
-0.0014155018143355846,
0.16586928069591522,
0.8581843972206116,
0.6529147624969482,
-0.3294183611869812,
-0.3966035544872284,
-0.15000596642494202,
-0.6267414689064026,
-0.08181512355804443,
-0.25286951661109924,
-0.12454034388065338,
-0.31199610233306885,
0.2488272339105606,
0.7158768773078918,
0.2099395990371704,
-0.7750192284584045,
0.5298296213150024,
-0.34280022978782654,
-0.03854351118206978,
-0.38711315393447876,
0.3324172794818878,
0.18503102660179138,
-0.08425204455852509,
0.5914005637168884,
-0.17477037012577057,
-0.19340825080871582,
-1.1984096765518188,
0.2881165146827698,
0.3947083055973053,
-0.885402262210846,
-0.391769677400589,
0.3482828140258789,
0.706896185874939,
-0.8198262453079224,
0.8693409562110901,
0.0002674975257832557,
-0.7388888001441956,
0.44536635279655457,
0.3946659564971924,
0.6355929374694824,
-0.22091937065124512,
0.42325302958488464,
0.21008582413196564,
0.11028137058019638,
-0.047587521374225616,
-0.009487355127930641,
-0.2395932674407959,
-0.53965824842453,
-0.09546300768852234,
-0.01749078743159771,
-0.5152828693389893,
-0.02676994353532791,
-0.6745330691337585,
0.019076399505138397,
-0.12321172654628754,
-0.6726924777030945,
-0.23278266191482544,
0.3805582821369171,
-0.679405689239502,
-0.24570173025131226,
-0.05330783873796463,
0.6178397536277771,
-0.7634749412536621,
0.4422543942928314,
0.0019072068389505148,
-0.7512463927268982,
-0.40011173486709595,
-0.030258208513259888,
0.2508825659751892,
-0.4430430233478546,
0.48417040705680847,
0.2078951746225357,
0.23137208819389343,
-0.06248597800731659,
-0.45069825649261475,
-0.7937628030776978,
0.9950146675109863,
-0.10303419828414917,
-0.5630064010620117,
-0.1588944047689438,
0.07507802546024323,
0.7713668942451477,
-0.620090663433075,
0.5650714635848999,
0.5812670588493347,
0.19673308730125427,
-0.0390290841460228,
-0.977451503276825,
-0.24341747164726257,
-0.3466673195362091,
-0.11533105373382568,
0.24951596558094025,
-0.590112030506134,
0.35999801754951477,
-0.2718660235404968,
-0.4692274332046509,
0.056309763342142105,
0.6513620018959045,
0.3233739733695984,
0.272861510515213,
0.6144435405731201,
-0.013047490268945694,
0.6543806195259094,
-0.1236269548535347,
1.0418490171432495,
-0.2731212079524994,
-0.09949670732021332,
0.854368269443512,
-0.4134118854999542,
0.616997241973877,
0.48981764912605286,
0.4429479241371155,
0.7083734273910522,
0.3246765732765198,
-0.11698303371667862,
0.2216646522283554,
0.2379898875951767,
-0.18117472529411316,
-0.46342360973358154,
-0.3029538094997406,
-0.14474156498908997,
0.42596399784088135,
0.625333845615387,
-0.36657875776290894,
0.609262228012085,
0.12042535841464996,
0.24175624549388885,
0.09522681683301926,
0.19328869879245758,
0.8291038274765015,
-0.06183845177292824,
-0.9224793910980225,
-0.20223617553710938,
-0.5922713279724121,
0.2561390995979309,
-0.8434478044509888,
-0.29877007007598877,
-0.08743023127317429,
-0.10866042971611023,
0.12497184425592422,
-0.8837302327156067,
-0.5575442314147949,
-0.1980794370174408,
-0.29789862036705017,
-0.26809656620025635,
0.5902820825576782,
-0.5880004167556763,
0.17047721147537231,
0.24358391761779785,
0.7930530905723572,
0.19622065126895905,
0.12357568740844727,
-0.35962480306625366,
0.3548614978790283,
0.021468747407197952,
-0.44647017121315,
0.397601842880249,
0.39711228013038635,
-0.20806463062763214,
1.0146266222000122,
1.05344820022583,
-0.3416092097759247,
-0.20007725059986115,
0.0885913148522377,
0.7616375684738159,
-0.6929175853729248,
-0.344632625579834,
-0.5243726372718811,
0.7590007781982422,
-0.41979271173477173,
-0.5157651305198669,
1.0206339359283447,
0.5302914977073669,
0.24347589910030365,
-0.1687353253364563,
0.5013132691383362,
0.19216188788414001,
0.39008116722106934,
-0.04276346415281296,
0.9800282120704651,
-0.03440826013684273,
0.28745704889297485,
-0.058694228529930115,
-0.8352171778678894,
0.468227744102478,
0.506242573261261,
-0.027556704357266426,
0.13576534390449524,
0.359086275100708,
0.5287730097770691,
0.24370431900024414,
-0.12840025126934052,
0.6165005564689636,
-0.06434882432222366,
0.9040131568908691,
0.028926391154527664,
1.202182650566101,
-0.18532337248325348,
0.5733926892280579,
-0.06489607691764832,
-0.16460448503494263,
-0.519390344619751,
-0.6019036769866943,
-1.2574371099472046,
-0.6451964378356934,
-0.2608427107334137,
-0.27451977133750916,
0.0640428438782692,
0.8833761811256409,
0.762731671333313,
-0.37449222803115845,
-0.3663157820701599,
0.23853442072868347,
-0.10059976577758789,
-0.23072850704193115,
-0.2820640206336975,
0.14499163627624512,
-0.32160133123397827,
-0.7141323089599609,
0.450621098279953,
0.06183810159564018,
0.07428250461816788,
-0.3698844015598297,
-0.15183497965335846,
-0.3728577792644501,
0.6777039766311646,
0.5761439204216003,
0.8536688685417175,
-0.7259121537208557,
-0.1695224642753601,
0.5071958899497986,
-0.180753692984581,
-0.16505669057369232,
0.8570812940597534,
-0.9045424461364746,
0.6498535871505737,
0.5327917337417603,
0.22947922348976135,
0.726703941822052,
0.6698411107063293,
1.080906629562378,
-0.49432292580604553,
-0.15764936804771423,
0.2272234410047531,
-0.19408197700977325,
0.14949743449687958,
-0.5635819435119629,
0.7454550862312317,
0.14264729619026184,
-0.8973949551582336,
-1.1325989961624146,
0.06476761400699615,
-0.8082476854324341,
0.14462648332118988,
1.1297374963760376,
-0.07535704970359802,
0.19598731398582458,
-0.35445642471313477,
-0.30401718616485596,
-0.15453088283538818,
-0.8076652884483337,
0.5416281819343567,
0.8623538017272949,
-0.5250767469406128,
-0.3769960403442383,
-0.5857412219047546,
0.9155825972557068,
0.22639982402324677,
-0.38291722536087036,
0.5357515811920166,
0.5675923228263855,
-0.024499064311385155,
0.6475210189819336,
0.7200160622596741,
0.11198516190052032,
0.19316698610782623,
-0.04724486544728279,
-0.2762492299079895,
-0.09020829945802689,
-0.6858357787132263,
0.05421173572540283,
0.2014979124069214,
-0.19034399092197418,
0.17121301591396332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11518v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11518v2 | Large Language Model-driven Meta-structure Discovery in Heterogeneous Information Network | 2024-02-18T09:21:12 | 2024-06-22T04:03:30 | Lin Chen, Fengli Xu, Nian Li, Zhenyu Han, Meng Wang, Yong Li, Pan Hui | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Heterogeneous information networks (HIN) have gained increasing popularity in
recent years for capturing complex relations between diverse types of nodes.
Meta-structures are proposed as a useful tool to identify the important
patterns in HINs, but hand-crafted meta-structures pose significant challenges
for scaling up, drawing wide research attention towards developing automatic
search algorithms. Previous efforts primarily focused on searching for
meta-structures with good empirical performance, overlooking the importance of
human comprehensibility and generalizability. To address this challenge, we
draw inspiration from the emergent reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs). We propose ReStruct, a meta-structure search framework that integrates
LLM reasoning into the evolutionary procedure. ReStruct uses a grammar
translator to encode the meta-structures into natural language sentences, and
leverages the reasoning power of LLMs to evaluate their semantic feasibility.
Besides, ReStruct also employs performance-oriented evolutionary operations.
These two competing forces allow ReStruct to jointly optimize the semantic
explainability and empirical performance of meta-structures. Furthermore,
ReStruct contains a differential LLM explainer to generate and refine natural
language explanations for the discovered meta-structures by reasoning through
the search history. Experiments on eight representative HIN datasets
demonstrate that ReStruct achieves state-of-the-art performance in both
recommendation and node classification tasks. Moreover, a survey study
involving 73 graduate students shows that the discovered meta-structures and
generated explanations by ReStruct are substantially more comprehensible. Our
code and questionnaire are available at https://github.com/LinChen-65/ReStruct. | [
-0.3834191858768463,
-1.0204412937164307,
0.6981068253517151,
0.09736686944961548,
-0.14793843030929565,
-0.21854716539382935,
-0.3029492497444153,
-0.4743642508983612,
0.47224169969558716,
0.18754756450653076,
-0.6863155961036682,
-0.793191134929657,
-0.2550317347049713,
0.33819496631622314,
-0.07387521862983704,
0.6040370464324951,
-0.10960407555103302,
-0.3769424259662628,
-0.10189758241176605,
-0.05799037963151932,
-0.22136688232421875,
-0.17249317467212677,
-0.37041473388671875,
-0.47264277935028076,
0.8290866613388062,
0.34435123205184937,
0.9221013188362122,
1.1693010330200195,
0.22336755692958832,
0.3473328649997711,
-0.45832914113998413,
0.36105674505233765,
-0.5176857709884644,
0.2989407777786255,
-0.4248068928718567,
-0.17972633242607117,
-0.42524319887161255,
-0.2828941345214844,
0.8183298110961914,
0.9975302815437317,
-0.20600906014442444,
0.3231907784938812,
-0.07722339034080505,
0.45197543501853943,
-0.6893360614776611,
0.36831751465797424,
-0.6370147466659546,
0.20626889169216156,
-0.39467909932136536,
-0.5414592623710632,
-0.39046862721443176,
-0.26145005226135254,
0.2468574494123459,
-0.544100821018219,
0.1412694752216339,
0.11248915642499924,
0.6599981188774109,
0.2248067557811737,
-0.256207138299942,
-0.017739074304699898,
-0.6892648339271545,
0.37832871079444885,
-0.5776078104972839,
0.6442940831184387,
0.3125132918357849,
0.3541479706764221,
-0.4775119423866272,
-0.8266807794570923,
-0.3178269863128662,
-0.060672909021377563,
-0.1125267744064331,
-0.1870788037776947,
0.011976099573075771,
0.026642652228474617,
0.04861621931195259,
0.4411863684654236,
-0.7500647902488708,
0.14331474900245667,
-0.1527239978313446,
-0.19239331781864166,
0.41853463649749756,
0.19496440887451172,
0.3572029173374176,
-0.3419390916824341,
-0.2276378571987152,
0.09813526272773743,
-0.6838104128837585,
-0.12322082370519638,
0.35245683789253235,
0.37082624435424805,
0.07970123738050461,
0.6161336302757263,
-0.3194922208786011,
0.6384902596473694,
-0.1301543414592743,
-0.00504946568980813,
0.37118497490882874,
-0.3854443430900574,
-0.2499108761548996,
0.07911458611488342,
0.7159122228622437,
-0.026516754180192947,
0.1801092028617859,
-0.2703368663787842,
-0.047990504652261734,
-0.48130372166633606,
0.14903680980205536,
-0.9156548976898193,
-0.025099005550146103,
0.046159930527210236,
-1.004435420036316,
-0.33180898427963257,
0.1282963901758194,
-0.7126414179801941,
0.02307087928056717,
-0.13420793414115906,
0.15884271264076233,
-0.2387743890285492,
-0.40549883246421814,
0.24794891476631165,
-0.1557961106300354,
0.03795948624610901,
0.2896106541156769,
-0.744021475315094,
-0.007042642217129469,
0.725921630859375,
0.9013941884040833,
0.12823055684566498,
-0.6252442002296448,
-0.4566138982772827,
0.11109194159507751,
-0.26661932468414307,
0.711219847202301,
-0.8325807452201843,
-0.1082688421010971,
-0.01605619676411152,
0.2779771387577057,
-0.12459192425012589,
-0.303107351064682,
0.6660502552986145,
-0.7287226915359497,
0.2957456111907959,
-0.24347031116485596,
-0.2838430404663086,
-0.343771368265152,
0.47245290875434875,
-0.8027902245521545,
0.899419367313385,
0.09268204122781754,
-0.97495037317276,
0.21480722725391388,
-0.6873275637626648,
-0.6982956528663635,
0.1659581959247589,
-0.19006364047527313,
-0.506820559501648,
0.02382364682853222,
-0.03624845668673515,
0.45450732111930847,
-0.5381373167037964,
0.41718780994415283,
-0.7083091735839844,
-0.4058041572570801,
-0.051499802619218826,
-0.3017458915710449,
0.6531275510787964,
0.22124888002872467,
-0.48941177129745483,
0.04067649692296982,
-0.7422845959663391,
0.06666930764913559,
0.10466766357421875,
-0.7874260544776917,
-0.4417998194694519,
0.36700013279914856,
-0.2617250084877014,
0.07857260853052139,
0.14873701333999634,
-0.38817286491394043,
0.240764319896698,
-0.38449645042419434,
0.5108631253242493,
0.6429905891418457,
-0.12694613635540009,
0.3206157982349396,
-0.1273731291294098,
0.27007028460502625,
-0.39275431632995605,
0.082800954580307,
-0.32309189438819885,
-0.34777554869651794,
-0.20534659922122955,
-0.19644403457641602,
0.08361450582742691,
0.28470757603645325,
-0.4574233293533325,
0.5236535668373108,
-0.3339153528213501,
-0.286483496427536,
-0.3602200746536255,
-0.10844364762306213,
0.22442717850208282,
0.6780853271484375,
0.4616786241531372,
0.19653673470020294,
-0.7328054904937744,
-1.0151952505111694,
-0.2350379228591919,
-0.20181144773960114,
0.1680152863264084,
0.5384921431541443,
0.5094390511512756,
-0.9634622931480408,
0.6960325241088867,
-0.4683282971382141,
0.20572449266910553,
-0.18816040456295013,
0.18559536337852478,
0.3849034309387207,
0.16297796368598938,
0.2843843996524811,
-1.057068943977356,
-0.11886564642190933,
0.19822777807712555,
-0.6922131776809692,
-0.20830032229423523,
0.1583215296268463,
-0.08080492168664932,
-0.23678550124168396,
0.529890775680542,
-0.39618730545043945,
0.32260775566101074,
0.38583144545555115,
-0.36918210983276367,
0.5085810422897339,
-0.1395294964313507,
0.11249610781669617,
-1.1839498281478882,
0.26084500551223755,
-0.3210391402244568,
-0.3600381910800934,
-0.3511017858982086,
0.21886105835437775,
-0.13099238276481628,
-0.1285773068666458,
-0.0656244158744812,
0.43336886167526245,
-0.566551923751831,
-0.4200209379196167,
-0.18220633268356323,
0.06511662155389786,
-0.047950468957424164,
0.5164958238601685,
0.07484132051467896,
0.26354724168777466,
0.43728259205818176,
-0.6657354831695557,
0.46442529559135437,
0.22853752970695496,
-0.21135477721691132,
0.27945631742477417,
-0.7002316117286682,
-0.16153715550899506,
-0.17119120061397552,
0.5239901542663574,
-0.8558852672576904,
-0.4340344965457916,
0.0587923638522625,
-0.26543116569519043,
-0.13879311084747314,
-0.5819993615150452,
-0.3000028729438782,
-0.3951740860939026,
-0.2753918468952179,
0.6220268607139587,
-0.12081282585859299,
-0.8589888215065002,
0.8488584756851196,
0.08671673387289047,
-0.1549798548221588,
-0.5375344157218933,
-0.6138643026351929,
0.1511363834142685,
0.07578437775373459,
-1.192134976387024,
0.554902970790863,
-0.081495501101017,
-0.04182261601090431,
0.28165313601493835,
-0.1115647554397583,
0.002295243088155985,
0.3970547020435333,
0.37374430894851685,
0.15191605687141418,
-0.5553125739097595,
0.4410836398601532,
-0.08905114233493805,
-0.09444662183523178,
-0.04082929715514183,
-0.5588779449462891,
0.7395817637443542,
-0.416973352432251,
-0.3662595748901367,
-0.3162050247192383,
0.21288932859897614,
0.9641202688217163,
-0.5069199204444885,
0.7822732925415039,
0.5555423498153687,
-0.30098605155944824,
-0.3892543613910675,
-0.45665159821510315,
-0.12651214003562927,
-0.3817968964576721,
0.3990161418914795,
-0.551236093044281,
-0.9574890732765198,
0.5382456183433533,
-0.31753531098365784,
0.09430991858243942,
0.5807345509529114,
0.7788699865341187,
0.0679527074098587,
0.8867964148521423,
0.43646693229675293,
0.06526056677103043,
0.4827897846698761,
-0.12574172019958496,
0.18272598087787628,
-0.7198041081428528,
-0.5713340640068054,
-0.5780466794967651,
-0.545356810092926,
-0.8655909299850464,
-0.26302745938301086,
0.274739146232605,
-0.21961554884910583,
-0.13458915054798126,
0.3397543430328369,
-0.35126665234565735,
0.4994911253452301,
0.31904202699661255,
-0.10166539251804352,
0.4743214547634125,
-0.12880989909172058,
-0.3117980659008026,
0.480275422334671,
-0.6027701497077942,
-0.3606618046760559,
0.685731828212738,
0.5219950079917908,
0.9976420402526855,
0.2192305475473404,
0.879967987537384,
0.12221625447273254,
0.0370367169380188,
-0.6401037573814392,
0.36830106377601624,
-0.039356157183647156,
-0.612729012966156,
-0.5762460827827454,
-1.0057635307312012,
-1.0391231775283813,
0.4251331686973572,
-0.3280780017375946,
-0.4337374269962311,
0.5266082882881165,
0.1759517788887024,
-0.08577073365449905,
0.43404915928840637,
-0.4238613247871399,
1.019513487815857,
-0.19316953420639038,
-0.3981103301048279,
-0.15807540714740753,
-0.7135128378868103,
0.39027613401412964,
0.21308612823486328,
0.2358430176973343,
0.03862755000591278,
0.24933619797229767,
0.34686335921287537,
-0.32766804099082947,
0.5308898091316223,
0.13166946172714233,
-0.12639544904232025,
0.06446599215269089,
0.342663437128067,
0.816875696182251,
0.3646681010723114,
-0.3353513479232788,
-0.14226776361465454,
-0.013698092661798,
-0.14276550710201263,
-0.6082603335380554,
0.6189627051353455,
-0.4197651147842407,
-0.26773080229759216,
0.09559490531682968,
-0.3388327360153198,
0.20549198985099792,
0.4416813850402832,
0.3486233055591583,
0.5129378437995911,
-0.4349088966846466,
0.5570815205574036,
0.8445824384689331,
-0.08215896040201187,
0.372025728225708,
0.5024031400680542,
-0.2624369263648987,
-0.23204965889453888,
0.7452718019485474,
-0.09915007650852203,
0.031476061791181564,
0.6319238543510437,
0.5432870984077454,
-0.07792241871356964,
-0.45194554328918457,
-0.4697021543979645,
0.14119072258472443,
-0.3429153263568878,
-0.03530396521091461,
-0.6935243010520935,
-0.09938227385282516,
-0.2783944606781006,
0.09886375814676285,
-0.473720908164978,
-0.2564224898815155,
0.008573915809392929,
-0.15344083309173584,
-0.1492333710193634,
0.5337196588516235,
-0.09529948979616165,
-0.10810210555791855,
-0.5537742972373962,
0.4112471342086792,
0.3690674901008606,
0.639821469783783,
0.023944582790136337,
-0.1332070529460907,
-0.37105581164360046,
0.004029665607959032,
0.23927396535873413,
-0.7748681902885437,
-0.09962522238492966,
0.06511648744344711,
0.6165689826011658,
0.5565038323402405,
-0.1768876314163208,
0.42470547556877136,
-0.5880546569824219,
0.15166033804416656,
-0.14150135219097137,
-0.47253936529159546,
0.45688191056251526,
-0.4024578034877777,
0.04815017804503441,
0.45530232787132263,
0.31037262082099915,
-0.6625156402587891,
0.10262800753116608,
-0.6456773281097412,
-0.7237482070922852,
0.5735895037651062,
0.17215274274349213,
-0.20924416184425354,
0.03713371232151985,
0.4625001549720764,
-0.09773068875074387,
0.12134837359189987,
-0.7318238019943237,
-0.07118057459592819,
-0.2777528762817383,
-0.05138121917843819,
0.36112481355667114,
-0.23777727782726288,
-0.262543261051178,
0.07296336442232132,
0.3077006936073303,
-0.23686937987804413,
0.01576363295316696,
0.37875041365623474,
-0.18986624479293823,
-0.2760190963745117,
0.500493049621582,
0.5311623811721802,
0.6177577376365662,
-0.3913462460041046,
0.5875856876373291,
-0.0730949193239212,
-0.25592103600502014,
-0.09039128571748734,
0.3213808238506317,
-0.22077645361423492,
0.046670880168676376,
0.7773522138595581,
0.7144883871078491,
0.3416604697704315,
-0.5236573219299316,
0.47200268507003784,
-0.13800421357154846,
-0.2710006535053253,
-0.04380377009510994,
0.017027491703629494,
0.17322900891304016,
0.5590411424636841,
0.22191928327083588,
-0.25426411628723145,
0.2028190642595291,
-1.013715147972107,
0.08994484692811966,
0.49678799510002136,
0.1398843377828598,
-0.48677965998649597,
0.2701328694820404,
0.36571380496025085,
-0.44512060284614563,
0.4848795235157013,
-0.14105646312236786,
-0.6775678396224976,
0.30835211277008057,
0.5916223526000977,
0.996833086013794,
-0.05010941997170448,
0.3263879418373108,
0.2596069872379303,
0.32465314865112305,
-0.38597068190574646,
0.08613404631614685,
-0.34355080127716064,
-0.7734809517860413,
-0.41800275444984436,
-0.6112599968910217,
-0.23700638115406036,
0.051666002720594406,
-0.3097350597381592,
0.09829055517911911,
-0.36800581216812134,
0.11092731356620789,
-0.06992781162261963,
-0.2511271834373474,
-0.43838563561439514,
0.1656259149312973,
0.15308049321174622,
0.9135845303535461,
-0.7302800416946411,
0.2758692502975464,
0.6551311016082764,
-0.33144792914390564,
-0.819219172000885,
0.022625098004937172,
-0.02503954991698265,
-0.6421264410018921,
0.6498413681983948,
-0.02264287695288658,
-0.37411004304885864,
-0.22542721033096313,
-0.5058825016021729,
-0.9409843683242798,
1.2148704528808594,
0.3177712559700012,
-0.5562323927879333,
-0.4504272937774658,
-0.1640610247850418,
0.42903584241867065,
-0.5639341473579407,
0.3261209726333618,
0.24609068036079407,
0.7682838439941406,
0.2944374978542328,
-0.7124526500701904,
0.20604050159454346,
-0.26982536911964417,
-0.09384270012378693,
0.3804268538951874,
-0.41539835929870605,
0.9782471060752869,
-0.19486935436725616,
-0.27261534333229065,
-0.3031129837036133,
0.47339776158332825,
0.24024754762649536,
0.5169370174407959,
0.6046124696731567,
0.8168313503265381,
0.8573634028434753,
0.15668097138404846,
0.8883690237998962,
-0.04523943364620209,
0.3643473982810974,
1.110033631324768,
-0.09315857291221619,
0.616211473941803,
0.18389827013015747,
0.1333135962486267,
0.9260843992233276,
0.7655079364776611,
-0.08952133357524872,
0.2816197872161865,
0.2986903786659241,
0.07897970825433731,
-0.48418664932250977,
0.025264373049139977,
-0.33186957240104675,
0.3857305943965912,
-0.039229389280080795,
-0.4765961766242981,
-0.5240830183029175,
-0.23511050641536713,
-0.08330705016851425,
-0.07806646823883057,
-0.08564922213554382,
0.5654064416885376,
-0.24879297614097595,
-0.5770825743675232,
0.5258339047431946,
0.33950701355934143,
0.3722176253795624,
-0.5046321749687195,
-0.060879260301589966,
-0.2556222379207611,
-0.027234980836510658,
-0.5368347764015198,
-0.5207722187042236,
0.24818305671215057,
-0.21071183681488037,
-0.5215652585029602,
-0.10362353175878525,
0.7348941564559937,
-0.4783366620540619,
-0.15496867895126343,
0.440968781709671,
0.5313227772712708,
0.08726508170366287,
-0.01593140885233879,
-0.3681914210319519,
0.006931061390787363,
-0.03903783857822418,
-0.39103469252586365,
-0.018698779866099358,
0.8754853010177612,
-0.09983780980110168,
0.7118661999702454,
0.7556697130203247,
0.02896268106997013,
-0.05951661244034767,
0.172020822763443,
0.9497544169425964,
-0.6909170150756836,
-0.5528497695922852,
-1.0196287631988525,
0.19954918324947357,
0.026800377294421196,
-0.17536012828350067,
0.38119208812713623,
0.802152156829834,
0.7384237051010132,
0.2549212872982025,
0.5562681555747986,
-0.09983045607805252,
0.36665162444114685,
-0.6244381070137024,
0.3790227770805359,
-0.6775254607200623,
0.35862234234809875,
-0.3039335310459137,
-1.0250153541564941,
0.013575849123299122,
0.48292985558509827,
-0.2038586139678955,
-0.03582119196653366,
0.6149863600730896,
0.7877942323684692,
-0.5250622034072876,
0.07774604111909866,
-0.042127132415771484,
0.32378891110420227,
0.4842861294746399,
0.4222102761268616,
0.825484573841095,
0.09887303411960602,
0.7877565622329712,
0.23025035858154297,
-0.30425265431404114,
-0.6209696531295776,
-0.8926644921302795,
-0.8865057229995728,
-0.4940755069255829,
0.0850268229842186,
-0.2330247461795807,
0.056646037846803665,
0.8887796998023987,
0.7489080429077148,
-0.2608236074447632,
-0.025739844888448715,
-0.30745139718055725,
0.7614066004753113,
0.1661183387041092,
-0.22217951714992523,
0.46164700388908386,
-0.2679785192012787,
-0.29687556624412537,
0.7870533466339111,
0.46293121576309204,
-0.16411566734313965,
-0.2822592854499817,
-0.21551375091075897,
-0.4759509563446045,
-0.06993427872657776,
0.5163118243217468,
0.44969695806503296,
-0.48630690574645996,
-0.15595979988574982,
0.0904449075460434,
-0.03455595299601555,
-0.09909462183713913,
1.0121034383773804,
-0.5332359671592712,
0.33856749534606934,
0.9695343375205994,
0.8985998034477234,
0.545516312122345,
0.08290636539459229,
0.6166648864746094,
-0.5868697166442871,
-0.23559024930000305,
0.12525825202465057,
0.5114392042160034,
0.16456133127212524,
-0.3766944110393524,
0.6732901930809021,
0.4083201289176941,
-0.4377736449241638,
-0.8261072635650635,
0.4618714451789856,
-0.5630913376808167,
-0.5289005041122437,
1.043622612953186,
0.15890194475650787,
-0.3492700457572937,
-0.01596774160861969,
0.02441280707716942,
0.19482217729091644,
-0.275868684053421,
0.6772038340568542,
0.4317936301231384,
-0.06390722095966339,
-0.12681402266025543,
-0.16648992896080017,
0.3097348213195801,
0.16284005343914032,
-0.8647387623786926,
0.30677536129951477,
0.3756009042263031,
0.36654531955718994,
0.36746346950531006,
0.2985810339450836,
-0.12631534039974213,
0.337298721075058,
-0.4221666753292084,
-0.026667075231671333,
-0.541736900806427,
-0.5970317721366882,
0.07198773324489594,
0.25806519389152527,
-0.17694152891635895,
-0.016864493489265442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11517v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11517v3 | Knowledge-to-SQL: Enhancing SQL Generation with Data Expert LLM | 2024-02-18T09:10:04 | 2024-06-06T13:56:59 | Zijin Hong, Zheng Yuan, Hao Chen, Qinggang Zhang, Feiran Huang, Xiao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating accurate SQL queries for user questions (text-to-SQL) has been a
long-standing challenge since it requires a deep understanding of both the
user's question and the corresponding database schema in order to retrieve the
desired content accurately. Existing methods rely on the comprehensive
capability of large language models (LLMs) to generate the SQL. However, some
necessary knowledge is not explicitly included in the database schema and user
question or has been learned by LLMs. Thus, the generated SQL of the
knowledge-insufficient questions may be inaccurate, negatively influencing the
text-to-SQL models' performance and robustness. To address this challenge, we
propose the Knowledge-to-SQL framework, which employs tailored Data Expert LLM
(DELLM) to provide helpful knowledge for all text-to-SQL models. Specifically,
we introduce the detailed implementation of DELLM regarding table reading and
the basic fine-tuning process. We further propose a Preference Learning via
Database Feedback (PLDBF) strategy, refining the DELLM to generate more helpful
knowledge for LLMs. Extensive experiments verify that DELLM can enhance the
state-of-the-art approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. The corresponding code of
DELLM is released for further research. | [
-0.35368433594703674,
-1.0218539237976074,
0.692168116569519,
-0.2829938530921936,
-0.17377638816833496,
-0.09269378334283829,
-0.2574634850025177,
-0.18007706105709076,
0.1570543497800827,
0.9832786321640015,
-0.7252838015556335,
-0.8120850324630737,
-0.17774848639965057,
0.1543445736169815,
-0.46394863724708557,
0.9855449199676514,
0.373099684715271,
0.13740861415863037,
-0.6311291456222534,
0.09972303360700607,
-0.4273115396499634,
-0.7399240732192993,
-0.41065794229507446,
0.05639797821640968,
0.29403507709503174,
0.8160023093223572,
0.4403831362724304,
0.5451260209083557,
0.3269714117050171,
0.1033039465546608,
-0.009474835358560085,
0.5960502624511719,
-0.7178376317024231,
0.4067052900791168,
-0.6316659450531006,
-0.714001476764679,
-0.6469537019729614,
-0.554595947265625,
0.2271406203508377,
0.6648655533790588,
-0.2448284924030304,
0.07147450000047684,
-0.030204463750123978,
1.2650951147079468,
-0.3126734495162964,
0.08511719852685928,
-1.1881840229034424,
-0.14264146983623505,
-0.26002323627471924,
-0.37561821937561035,
-0.4653206765651703,
-0.41595616936683655,
0.1313590258359909,
-0.45480552315711975,
0.37623101472854614,
0.33216577768325806,
0.4246978759765625,
0.304817795753479,
-0.6478631496429443,
-0.30360060930252075,
-0.6593794226646423,
0.48564305901527405,
-0.633617639541626,
0.32374492287635803,
0.184495747089386,
0.3546255826950073,
-0.48590362071990967,
-0.3689616620540619,
-0.5543890595436096,
-0.2463499903678894,
-0.1358891725540161,
-0.04695149138569832,
0.48486316204071045,
-0.07734624296426773,
0.14642199873924255,
0.29638534784317017,
-0.474456787109375,
-0.016458014026284218,
-0.1607414036989212,
0.020592449232935905,
0.8689815402030945,
0.33299726247787476,
-0.1185159683227539,
-0.2569342851638794,
-0.2816201448440552,
0.3625272810459137,
-0.9040485620498657,
-0.2703225910663605,
0.25469836592674255,
0.39394432306289673,
0.3794821798801422,
0.780332088470459,
-0.4990023076534271,
1.2057369947433472,
0.12961535155773163,
0.009095446206629276,
-0.05911491438746452,
-0.45553967356681824,
-0.025717206299304962,
-0.03169962763786316,
0.4874330163002014,
0.4989893436431885,
0.23581235110759735,
-0.4290482997894287,
-0.20105059444904327,
-0.3390914499759674,
0.22318944334983826,
-0.6960105299949646,
-0.20785531401634216,
0.3386590778827667,
-0.1451098769903183,
-0.4034380316734314,
-0.005651867017149925,
-0.8759291172027588,
-0.6446731686592102,
-0.46889224648475647,
0.48874419927597046,
-0.41551947593688965,
-0.3913322389125824,
-0.1788717806339264,
0.09536275267601013,
0.14884373545646667,
0.369579017162323,
-0.9016628265380859,
0.35703152418136597,
0.4159107506275177,
0.19987839460372925,
-0.7129978537559509,
0.16178396344184875,
-0.38639840483665466,
0.6314195394515991,
-0.36206868290901184,
1.0803533792495728,
-0.3519568145275116,
-0.5015290975570679,
-0.06415707617998123,
-0.25863412022590637,
0.09299643337726593,
-0.6228574514389038,
0.2590327858924866,
-0.6073704361915588,
0.3514140546321869,
-0.5568636655807495,
-1.0290497541427612,
0.007245286367833614,
0.31556451320648193,
-0.35676002502441406,
1.0683708190917969,
0.11016242206096649,
-0.5718634128570557,
0.656829297542572,
-0.541685163974762,
-0.4311469495296478,
0.03280618414282799,
-0.4617842435836792,
-0.33902707695961,
0.1711117923259735,
0.5019881725311279,
0.6581909656524658,
-0.4366970956325531,
0.2871650159358978,
-0.22308333218097687,
-0.18614442646503448,
0.21660225093364716,
0.058794692158699036,
0.34494343400001526,
0.21125862002372742,
-0.06433390080928802,
0.0972198098897934,
-0.9131976962089539,
0.2253841608762741,
0.23348639905452728,
-0.4518555700778961,
-0.002252225996926427,
0.3086090087890625,
-0.08996565639972687,
-0.009751075878739357,
0.32546985149383545,
-0.21919293701648712,
0.015018253587186337,
-0.5395488739013672,
0.20539653301239014,
0.575476348400116,
0.23805609345436096,
0.4421979784965515,
-0.2738164961338043,
0.18384116888046265,
0.16059216856956482,
-0.11925408989191055,
0.03333810716867447,
-0.1696985512971878,
-0.8991565108299255,
0.1457073986530304,
0.13188762962818146,
0.6118313074111938,
-0.8075056076049805,
0.6545743942260742,
-0.0684635117650032,
-0.42067357897758484,
-0.12255967408418655,
0.34636104106903076,
-0.056560251861810684,
0.800166130065918,
0.5424672365188599,
-0.2614688277244568,
-0.3547051250934601,
-0.7319393157958984,
-0.5891348719596863,
-0.16427291929721832,
0.056817155331373215,
0.8018600344657898,
0.13763730227947235,
0.1479949802160263,
1.2944031953811646,
-0.8032503128051758,
-0.5901893377304077,
-0.3795691728591919,
-0.43764570355415344,
0.22948631644248962,
0.35750341415405273,
0.4822886884212494,
-0.4163110852241516,
-0.49868911504745483,
0.01635555364191532,
-0.53340744972229,
0.14747950434684753,
0.08024562895298004,
-0.29679960012435913,
0.5952841639518738,
0.4918753206729889,
-0.46513691544532776,
0.17969726026058197,
-0.05885909125208855,
-0.3859305679798126,
0.4807297885417938,
-0.2176099717617035,
0.16446737945079803,
-1.4928897619247437,
0.010151684284210205,
-0.027512652799487114,
-0.2654710114002228,
-0.5566056966781616,
-0.21468591690063477,
0.1355312317609787,
-0.16289351880550385,
-0.3345007002353668,
0.4161231219768524,
-0.37505701184272766,
-0.10769045352935791,
0.0420963391661644,
0.21563580632209778,
-0.10761698335409164,
0.34065309166908264,
0.3639167547225952,
0.8007640838623047,
0.4066320061683655,
-0.7772269248962402,
0.34554246068000793,
0.37147530913352966,
-0.366234689950943,
0.858321487903595,
-0.45372477173805237,
0.359409362077713,
-0.001020387513563037,
-0.18351466953754425,
-0.938323438167572,
-0.4965810179710388,
-0.07858387380838394,
-0.5101348161697388,
0.4803270399570465,
-0.29902639985084534,
-0.5972901582717896,
-0.16944457590579987,
0.06717847287654877,
-0.14803586900234222,
0.5221868753433228,
-0.5436549782752991,
0.5990159511566162,
0.37597668170928955,
-0.2932450771331787,
-0.46312808990478516,
-0.5762640237808228,
0.13633349537849426,
-0.1674649566411972,
-0.6726061105728149,
0.30921420454978943,
0.09109119325876236,
-0.12399079650640488,
-0.23603075742721558,
-0.09714223444461823,
-0.45117753744125366,
-0.11359097808599472,
-0.20578455924987793,
0.25931331515312195,
-0.10904984921216965,
0.459566205739975,
0.36276906728744507,
0.0368373803794384,
0.25213903188705444,
-0.3987722396850586,
0.23887374997138977,
0.23718933761119843,
-0.22399599850177765,
-0.07304802536964417,
0.38766103982925415,
0.13820849359035492,
-0.22559848427772522,
0.7298972010612488,
0.3809989392757416,
-0.12640473246574402,
-0.49199339747428894,
-0.8893424868583679,
-0.6471675038337708,
-0.4117978513240814,
0.612576961517334,
-0.2804204225540161,
-0.9144295454025269,
0.15469007194042206,
-0.31017202138900757,
0.005745052359998226,
0.47373589873313904,
0.46491751074790955,
-0.2079828530550003,
1.0024036169052124,
0.6664516925811768,
0.10597289353609085,
0.22403880953788757,
0.08492717146873474,
-0.01152847521007061,
-0.29484397172927856,
-0.605570375919342,
-0.7739848494529724,
0.12900415062904358,
-0.13596698641777039,
-0.3374290466308594,
0.38734346628189087,
-0.025984348729252815,
-0.2269269973039627,
0.10160347819328308,
-0.6846723556518555,
0.6611242294311523,
0.24432232975959778,
0.42752861976623535,
0.6286988258361816,
0.4478570818901062,
-0.08388292789459229,
-0.16583488881587982,
-0.8935260772705078,
-0.27565234899520874,
1.3705968856811523,
-0.11602351069450378,
0.8456299901008606,
0.08881931006908417,
0.7270500063896179,
0.2766992151737213,
0.05589616671204567,
-0.6391751766204834,
0.7113975882530212,
-0.1482975035905838,
-0.8078138828277588,
-0.20666861534118652,
-0.6584818959236145,
-0.3738672733306885,
-0.21219615638256073,
-0.5026901960372925,
-0.48884469270706177,
-0.029495786875486374,
0.43600115180015564,
-0.2365257292985916,
0.19164718687534332,
-0.8500494360923767,
0.6607378125190735,
-0.3802163302898407,
-0.6192289590835571,
-0.3326170742511749,
-0.525648295879364,
0.29216238856315613,
-0.1565181016921997,
0.003698656801134348,
0.028728004544973373,
-0.18047238886356354,
0.6915396451950073,
-0.6010836362838745,
0.701246976852417,
-0.3753926157951355,
-0.017544083297252655,
0.25913476943969727,
0.08856458216905594,
0.6103565692901611,
0.32191529870033264,
-0.45174917578697205,
-0.16856850683689117,
-0.07564625889062881,
-0.3712828457355499,
-0.5430764555931091,
0.6694290041923523,
-0.5454394817352295,
-0.8927558660507202,
-0.07666901499032974,
-0.535115122795105,
-0.6412650942802429,
0.21007871627807617,
0.19634725153446198,
0.20605306327342987,
-0.1803833693265915,
0.042926207184791565,
1.049045443534851,
-0.16863933205604553,
-0.007939684204757214,
0.6421201229095459,
-0.35046815872192383,
-0.4309956133365631,
0.7355802059173584,
0.06336697936058044,
0.16012005507946014,
0.6005178689956665,
-0.14974474906921387,
-0.6789690256118774,
-0.8322403430938721,
-0.6498881578445435,
0.1550290733575821,
-0.45972591638565063,
-0.32289814949035645,
-0.5407318472862244,
0.00945928506553173,
-0.25986960530281067,
0.0624924898147583,
-0.2595174312591553,
-0.671017050743103,
-0.6024996638298035,
-0.1417713165283203,
0.8607000708580017,
0.7546491622924805,
0.44357335567474365,
0.0850958377122879,
-0.726796567440033,
-0.04305163025856018,
0.36949560046195984,
0.37710726261138916,
-0.21884579956531525,
-0.46869346499443054,
-0.22116343677043915,
-0.1807258129119873,
-0.1984494924545288,
-1.0478277206420898,
0.10179102420806885,
0.3978206217288971,
0.4392086863517761,
0.22440043091773987,
0.2699033319950104,
0.46360859274864197,
-0.3483540117740631,
0.7892611026763916,
0.14750798046588898,
-0.7583487033843994,
0.9800132513046265,
-0.3748820722103119,
-0.08691205084323883,
0.7531207799911499,
0.2885526716709137,
0.11171779036521912,
-0.17271316051483154,
-0.2521800398826599,
-0.7521100044250488,
0.6760836243629456,
0.01687425561249256,
0.11925864219665527,
0.08095791935920715,
0.8307228684425354,
0.472503125667572,
0.3932759165763855,
-0.40619227290153503,
-0.19033309817314148,
-0.03234771639108658,
-0.2344730645418167,
0.021879637613892555,
-0.35993918776512146,
0.03741082549095154,
-0.3240610957145691,
0.5752763152122498,
-0.41982632875442505,
0.16811615228652954,
0.2208690196275711,
-0.23280127346515656,
0.006710364017635584,
0.4033505320549011,
0.22637902200222015,
0.9701934456825256,
-0.27857112884521484,
-0.273878812789917,
0.5550873875617981,
-0.2061225175857544,
-0.1966809183359146,
0.08079006522893906,
-0.26093775033950806,
-0.08946254849433899,
-0.2422052025794983,
0.5094844698905945,
-0.27576637268066406,
-0.6467848420143127,
0.3016647398471832,
-0.10285788029432297,
-0.4229104220867157,
-0.20440226793289185,
0.5482215881347656,
0.3704008460044861,
-0.107403963804245,
0.4516231119632721,
0.043202951550483704,
0.03156073018908501,
-0.23567821085453033,
0.2782980799674988,
0.5309327244758606,
-0.4751456677913666,
0.10661640763282776,
0.6838286519050598,
0.4440597593784332,
-0.13896849751472473,
0.6513766050338745,
0.10539761930704117,
-0.22987280786037445,
0.3868520259857178,
0.36941516399383545,
0.2391260415315628,
-0.3047229051589966,
0.03401795029640198,
0.3081221878528595,
0.08009150624275208,
0.07036591321229935,
0.8076884746551514,
-0.16171593964099884,
-0.5637003183364868,
-0.2908485233783722,
-0.42031675577163696,
-0.367233544588089,
-0.03247758373618126,
-0.6338716745376587,
0.44320520758628845,
-0.3236696124076843,
-0.16021692752838135,
-0.2396603524684906,
0.14603276550769806,
-0.5156516432762146,
0.2639361321926117,
-0.5678305625915527,
1.1397490501403809,
-0.42699119448661804,
0.9182696342468262,
0.7534229159355164,
-0.3571317791938782,
-0.7707324624061584,
-0.16918663680553436,
-0.31655725836753845,
-0.5390843749046326,
0.20910510420799255,
-0.15394669771194458,
0.3354473412036896,
0.35873305797576904,
-0.49083903431892395,
-0.4779808223247528,
1.1498675346374512,
0.5723032355308533,
-0.7304584980010986,
0.0628444105386734,
0.5551943778991699,
0.44903483986854553,
-0.5024979114532471,
0.14851409196853638,
0.7454842925071716,
0.343451589345932,
0.14564362168312073,
-0.5026504993438721,
0.023826943710446358,
0.07810773700475693,
-0.06364717334508896,
0.2201339304447174,
-0.36308181285858154,
0.3415459990501404,
-0.6415322422981262,
0.31828296184539795,
-0.06868061423301697,
0.8326552510261536,
0.251241534948349,
0.23535694181919098,
0.4791978895664215,
0.4265604615211487,
0.7788183689117432,
-0.14085640013217926,
0.8055633306503296,
-0.4235398471355438,
0.15208473801612854,
1.1865650415420532,
-0.37282314896583557,
0.9145979285240173,
0.5431748032569885,
-0.28608763217926025,
0.24323663115501404,
0.7097367644309998,
-0.047924209386110306,
0.504082202911377,
0.12320207059383392,
-0.2893699109554291,
-0.538534939289093,
-0.09256599843502045,
-0.5397529602050781,
0.041438452899456024,
0.5861873626708984,
-0.4927213788032532,
-0.10281284898519516,
-0.4852505624294281,
-0.12023269385099411,
0.3591112494468689,
-0.40363866090774536,
1.2471634149551392,
0.07446303218603134,
-0.5796205997467041,
0.40504512190818787,
-0.10765516757965088,
0.4282955229282379,
-0.5330625772476196,
0.0969453975558281,
-0.3769049048423767,
0.08116189390420914,
-0.5226065516471863,
-0.894899845123291,
0.40199506282806396,
0.055727798491716385,
-0.4502432346343994,
0.19391082227230072,
1.107971429824829,
-0.6690128445625305,
-0.4055846631526947,
-0.05673857778310776,
0.8358286619186401,
0.15568675100803375,
-0.17648449540138245,
-0.6008089780807495,
-0.40322014689445496,
0.25816377997398376,
-0.12388857454061508,
0.36140549182891846,
0.30340325832366943,
0.3328680098056793,
0.5308743119239807,
0.5027891993522644,
0.1340646743774414,
-0.13208161294460297,
0.017675790935754776,
0.7484048008918762,
-0.4675852656364441,
-0.377551406621933,
-0.7004749774932861,
0.4176922142505646,
-0.34857019782066345,
-0.03317025303840637,
0.6568034291267395,
0.7529628276824951,
0.6359299421310425,
-0.3068784773349762,
0.8457489609718323,
-0.005501117091625929,
0.8412981033325195,
-0.6640629172325134,
1.0822474956512451,
-0.6611616015434265,
0.502007782459259,
-0.21248720586299896,
-1.1355985403060913,
-0.1515125185251236,
0.21853694319725037,
-0.32045042514801025,
0.27838245034217834,
0.5801194310188293,
1.1484403610229492,
0.28698235750198364,
0.06952265650033951,
0.2597399055957794,
0.23689424991607666,
0.14652109146118164,
0.5328685641288757,
0.5725370049476624,
-0.08750738948583603,
0.8073497414588928,
-0.04872016981244087,
-0.10531280189752579,
-0.15029406547546387,
-0.8335305452346802,
-1.1735389232635498,
-0.5337992310523987,
-0.2517089247703552,
-0.3807985782623291,
0.3043232560157776,
0.914225161075592,
0.8122843503952026,
-0.920856773853302,
-0.23272104561328888,
-0.43641823530197144,
0.30939483642578125,
0.021408287808299065,
-0.22964178025722504,
0.5404181480407715,
-0.54354327917099,
-0.3656021058559418,
0.2881835103034973,
0.13251210749149323,
-0.0678773745894432,
-0.18466556072235107,
0.02693403884768486,
0.15665389597415924,
0.08813294768333435,
0.5576367378234863,
-0.15315745770931244,
-0.24339240789413452,
0.12623834609985352,
0.13493429124355316,
0.029300658032298088,
0.021228838711977005,
0.6799144744873047,
-0.863464891910553,
0.20489822328090668,
0.5041344165802002,
0.78282630443573,
0.5786163806915283,
0.03287398815155029,
0.791251003742218,
-0.9327011704444885,
-0.35880765318870544,
0.2694462537765503,
0.09340787678956985,
0.36505892872810364,
-0.9025652408599854,
0.4555707573890686,
0.29491958022117615,
-0.5531030297279358,
-0.5409156680107117,
0.25136494636535645,
-0.8575115203857422,
-0.2840132415294647,
1.1290390491485596,
0.23150770366191864,
-0.11635233461856842,
-0.2743821442127228,
-0.2737857699394226,
-0.0062288083136081696,
-0.5943378806114197,
0.9332432746887207,
0.4516587257385254,
-0.28159958124160767,
-0.1512964516878128,
-0.20962747931480408,
0.9069294333457947,
0.641973614692688,
-1.2118711471557617,
0.14845585823059082,
0.5208297967910767,
0.6317298412322998,
-0.42055803537368774,
0.4483741521835327,
-0.22718629240989685,
0.23859207332134247,
-0.34924477338790894,
-0.17055949568748474,
-0.24936598539352417,
-0.20079191029071808,
0.17736542224884033,
0.4015830457210541,
0.4270516037940979,
0.3939673900604248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11512v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11512v3 | From Prejudice to Parity: A New Approach to Debiasing Large Language Model Word Embeddings | 2024-02-18T08:53:41 | 2024-04-16T16:40:31 | Aishik Rakshit, Smriti Singh, Shuvam Keshari, Arijit Ghosh Chowdhury, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Embeddings play a pivotal role in the efficacy of Large Language Models. They
are the bedrock on which these models grasp contextual relationships and foster
a more nuanced understanding of language and consequently perform remarkably on
a plethora of complex tasks that require a fundamental understanding of human
language. Given that these embeddings themselves often reflect or exhibit bias,
it stands to reason that these models may also inadvertently learn this bias.
In this work, we build on the seminal previous work and propose DeepSoftDebias,
an algorithm that uses a neural network to perform 'soft debiasing'. We
exhaustively evaluate this algorithm across a variety of SOTA datasets,
accuracy metrics, and challenging NLP tasks. We find that DeepSoftDebias
outperforms the current state-of-the-art methods at reducing bias across
gender, race, and religion. | [
-0.5263126492500305,
-0.7815209031105042,
0.7568451166152954,
0.23170717060565948,
-0.28451821208000183,
-0.16786816716194153,
-0.2708706855773926,
-0.05955659970641136,
0.05434436723589897,
0.4496459662914276,
-0.3392288386821747,
-0.483129620552063,
-1.0436798334121704,
-0.1867317259311676,
-0.26686039566993713,
0.8180519938468933,
0.25155869126319885,
0.37202656269073486,
-0.04012470319867134,
-0.2721806764602661,
-0.3254307210445404,
-0.4733877182006836,
-0.17871412634849548,
-0.43208158016204834,
0.25770506262779236,
0.2342565655708313,
1.186206340789795,
0.4403584897518158,
0.4564216434955597,
0.20970672369003296,
-0.4039103090763092,
-0.23645401000976562,
-0.5026792287826538,
0.2351255565881729,
-0.49732235074043274,
-0.4023420512676239,
0.0014075515791773796,
0.209938183426857,
0.40588319301605225,
1.0927519798278809,
-0.1626819670200348,
0.05641820654273033,
0.29643312096595764,
0.6876947283744812,
-0.8422473073005676,
0.042076513171195984,
-0.6914220452308655,
0.2232477068901062,
-0.16361550986766815,
0.34712404012680054,
-0.2946930229663849,
-0.4484092593193054,
0.2448710799217224,
-0.2818532884120941,
0.2542213201522827,
-0.3743683397769928,
0.4664410352706909,
0.3201872408390045,
-0.6258626580238342,
-0.20412132143974304,
-0.5768512487411499,
1.0338069200515747,
-0.7782354950904846,
0.6777997612953186,
0.43837082386016846,
-0.010301351547241211,
-0.006796968635171652,
-0.3679800033569336,
-0.46319761872291565,
-0.048135530203580856,
0.2226867824792862,
-0.1558605283498764,
0.02279750071465969,
-0.0180129986256361,
0.2594454288482666,
0.32905009388923645,
-0.1319088190793991,
0.022452304139733315,
-0.17731788754463196,
0.20650243759155273,
0.5013099312782288,
-0.17416198551654816,
0.15647970139980316,
-0.11339154094457626,
-0.3816100060939789,
-0.15454915165901184,
-0.8258828520774841,
-0.2361837923526764,
0.2345450520515442,
0.2986297011375427,
-0.004720435943454504,
0.37722697854042053,
-0.12044060230255127,
0.18871642649173737,
0.053039442747831345,
0.2729925215244293,
0.4115307033061981,
0.26816198229789734,
-0.2955179810523987,
0.17105944454669952,
0.47186151146888733,
0.38033527135849,
0.36393749713897705,
-0.022545378655195236,
-0.17269594967365265,
0.25502344965934753,
0.1705365926027298,
-0.6343428492546082,
0.05365683138370514,
0.06887415796518326,
-0.5479856133460999,
-0.3608640134334564,
-0.17398111522197723,
-0.8279681205749512,
-1.1369401216506958,
-0.3898608386516571,
0.2263285368680954,
-0.44827407598495483,
-0.38013118505477905,
0.2140854150056839,
-0.20451363921165466,
0.27300333976745605,
0.19956167042255402,
-0.677666962146759,
0.0964188501238823,
1.1310175657272339,
0.745623767375946,
0.2615033984184265,
-0.3628595173358917,
-0.38254088163375854,
0.17221304774284363,
-0.5284405946731567,
0.4329853355884552,
-0.9457446932792664,
-0.13272833824157715,
0.13705040514469147,
-0.3618415296077728,
0.3824326992034912,
-0.4841763377189636,
0.6560013890266418,
-0.4837328791618347,
-0.18142937123775482,
-0.6094616651535034,
-0.5289681553840637,
-0.312858909368515,
0.23078767955303192,
-0.7115325331687927,
0.5098117589950562,
-0.07321431487798691,
-0.7041882872581482,
0.577442467212677,
-0.13717854022979736,
-0.3947012424468994,
-0.18502061069011688,
-0.251460999250412,
-0.19478739798069,
0.8130687475204468,
0.357547402381897,
0.5342879295349121,
-0.5635887980461121,
0.8074765801429749,
-0.8110097050666809,
-0.2602430284023285,
0.04570598900318146,
-0.3953734040260315,
1.0277462005615234,
0.25236058235168457,
-0.6805437207221985,
-0.2793002128601074,
-0.32729145884513855,
-0.39452871680259705,
0.08881381899118423,
0.08214184641838074,
-1.002442717552185,
0.25728610157966614,
-0.22816145420074463,
0.26577118039131165,
-0.16709600389003754,
-0.5952814221382141,
-0.06826405972242355,
-0.7264894843101501,
0.6201103925704956,
0.9451999664306641,
-0.3718327283859253,
0.7512991428375244,
0.1831824779510498,
0.2635936737060547,
0.03770697861909866,
0.2521854043006897,
0.22193121910095215,
-0.37439772486686707,
-0.6356627345085144,
0.008982492610812187,
0.4392155110836029,
0.22517149150371552,
-0.5556381940841675,
0.601446270942688,
-0.13769443333148956,
-0.36512207984924316,
-0.5909032225608826,
0.38661906123161316,
0.42077580094337463,
0.19364918768405914,
0.3694603145122528,
-0.3860345780849457,
-0.4037263095378876,
-1.1132148504257202,
-0.5809041261672974,
0.19123099744319916,
0.02723766677081585,
0.1478164792060852,
0.37028732895851135,
-0.32968899607658386,
0.668951153755188,
-0.4724956750869751,
-0.5422572493553162,
-0.17482870817184448,
0.09095851331949234,
0.3198613226413727,
0.5723268985748291,
0.6610254645347595,
-0.6831802129745483,
-0.2970377504825592,
-0.4323441684246063,
-0.6693805456161499,
-0.04902951046824455,
0.12294791638851166,
-0.14853109419345856,
-0.09460961818695068,
0.6794998645782471,
-0.48899051547050476,
0.34345918893814087,
0.6303979754447937,
-0.7218319177627563,
-0.018386708572506905,
0.18304915726184845,
-0.32197871804237366,
-0.920792818069458,
-0.23416461050510406,
0.04587781801819801,
-0.08825186640024185,
-0.389082133769989,
0.36390039324760437,
-0.14380982518196106,
-0.04145997390151024,
-0.4752548336982727,
0.28695112466812134,
-0.4125068485736847,
0.20315031707286835,
-0.05526581406593323,
0.044589851051568985,
0.26575279235839844,
0.16763220727443695,
-0.0736638754606247,
0.39047184586524963,
0.4735143780708313,
-0.28182682394981384,
-0.051012132316827774,
0.47355905175209045,
-0.581804096698761,
0.368817538022995,
-0.6769213676452637,
0.30195626616477966,
-0.5350683927536011,
0.19072020053863525,
-0.9481664896011353,
0.23844170570373535,
-0.10934225469827652,
-0.19900788366794586,
0.1507384330034256,
-0.38401851058006287,
-0.013203310780227184,
0.004520087037235498,
-0.4746045470237732,
0.6905590891838074,
0.555007815361023,
-0.5288337469100952,
0.45736104249954224,
0.9339943528175354,
-0.22312477231025696,
-0.8110857605934143,
-0.8815563917160034,
0.20120802521705627,
-0.034600112587213516,
-0.3119123876094818,
0.40426692366600037,
0.4101603329181671,
-0.664636492729187,
-0.1697121262550354,
-0.011897077783942223,
-0.06226639077067375,
0.3284617066383362,
0.15377995371818542,
-0.18228456377983093,
-0.03970086947083473,
0.17037568986415863,
0.20755091309547424,
-0.20600149035453796,
0.2362036257982254,
-0.32392627000808716,
0.8008922934532166,
-0.07396950572729111,
-0.33347105979919434,
-0.09325417876243591,
0.5484552979469299,
0.43192368745803833,
-0.18785133957862854,
0.6919712424278259,
0.46317845582962036,
-0.381658136844635,
-0.31698933243751526,
-0.8046399354934692,
-0.32079392671585083,
-0.45300814509391785,
0.39269593358039856,
-0.2450185865163803,
-0.972865104675293,
0.2854284942150116,
-0.011787356808781624,
-0.03681303188204765,
0.35527196526527405,
0.6799680590629578,
0.11464366316795349,
1.3088124990463257,
0.5829736590385437,
-0.2715437710285187,
0.3726421594619751,
-0.24702835083007812,
0.5587056875228882,
-0.5919535160064697,
-0.0032467194832861423,
-0.5496071577072144,
-0.5108708143234253,
-0.5760378241539001,
-0.8260293006896973,
0.05084693431854248,
0.17178557813167572,
-0.47213083505630493,
-0.08006729185581207,
-0.3473321497440338,
0.5680270791053772,
0.7315950989723206,
0.1708974987268448,
-0.0809871256351471,
-0.051990777254104614,
-0.16848920285701752,
-0.3351774513721466,
-0.34994566440582275,
-0.4913938641548157,
1.070091962814331,
0.6430730223655701,
0.7806386947631836,
0.08838152885437012,
0.763545572757721,
0.42271509766578674,
0.23774750530719757,
-0.713178813457489,
0.29179647564888,
-0.5786687731742859,
-0.743235170841217,
-0.2889178693294525,
-0.2166271060705185,
-0.678340494632721,
0.34909459948539734,
-0.1067270040512085,
-0.35071682929992676,
0.8409183621406555,
0.14055298268795013,
-0.39247679710388184,
0.36329105496406555,
-0.6142836809158325,
0.6970353126525879,
0.039837546646595,
-0.5996206998825073,
-0.4600977599620819,
-0.44520917534828186,
0.46131831407546997,
0.17017270624637604,
0.4854069948196411,
-0.5252524018287659,
0.030905921012163162,
0.8786427974700928,
-0.1685481071472168,
1.0176454782485962,
-0.5679571628570557,
-0.38539937138557434,
0.23252390325069427,
0.540450394153595,
0.38756251335144043,
0.2699497640132904,
-0.5213310718536377,
0.6078161001205444,
-0.15389250218868256,
-0.44943997263908386,
-0.4574034512042999,
0.719698429107666,
-0.6625751852989197,
-0.7086755037307739,
-0.3772314786911011,
-0.2784438133239746,
-0.35163265466690063,
0.08359557390213013,
-0.12551939487457275,
0.2965056002140045,
-0.400682270526886,
0.5454190969467163,
0.6530249118804932,
-0.41382187604904175,
0.378793329000473,
0.0991801843047142,
0.010821382515132427,
-0.535881757736206,
0.5330824255943298,
0.1617024838924408,
-0.08639578521251678,
0.11720619350671768,
0.5955334305763245,
-0.37062814831733704,
-0.5675156116485596,
-0.10274823755025864,
-0.05127537250518799,
-0.6888852715492249,
-0.3019351661205292,
-0.730975866317749,
0.18831247091293335,
-0.8012838959693909,
-0.22618304193019867,
-0.5664337873458862,
-0.40889883041381836,
0.0943128913640976,
-0.26751741766929626,
0.07163212448358536,
0.7856200933456421,
-0.14309629797935486,
0.3299322724342346,
-0.7258122563362122,
0.3405671715736389,
0.5922867655754089,
0.37459370493888855,
0.007903753779828548,
-0.5433191061019897,
0.0880403071641922,
0.17152361571788788,
-0.16393058001995087,
-0.9143849611282349,
0.44795316457748413,
0.27491337060928345,
0.3737685978412628,
0.7046249508857727,
0.23391953110694885,
0.3611533045768738,
-0.6074422001838684,
0.6671565771102905,
0.24074482917785645,
-1.4381955862045288,
0.43351125717163086,
-0.1821874976158142,
-0.15953248739242554,
0.9748424291610718,
0.42837756872177124,
-0.5551486611366272,
-0.17741964757442474,
-0.6041855812072754,
-0.9828652143478394,
0.446011483669281,
-0.12071267515420914,
0.7105148434638977,
-0.1478251963853836,
0.2514926493167877,
0.3231825828552246,
0.4673236310482025,
-0.717474102973938,
0.11571566015481949,
-0.29111310839653015,
-0.28264233469963074,
-0.4127110540866852,
-0.8967375755310059,
-0.1891648769378662,
-0.41320452094078064,
0.47528156638145447,
-0.2972528636455536,
0.036395251750946045,
0.25706207752227783,
-0.5163271427154541,
0.2527974247932434,
0.33319494128227234,
0.15561339259147644,
0.6784759163856506,
-0.17090848088264465,
0.5823599696159363,
0.1600232720375061,
-0.48471906781196594,
0.18981213867664337,
-0.04331332445144653,
-0.38106444478034973,
-0.05258016660809517,
0.33297163248062134,
0.6903305053710938,
-0.00413265498355031,
-0.46818679571151733,
0.9345858097076416,
0.11261805891990662,
-0.1678784042596817,
-0.12196947634220123,
-0.24687761068344116,
-0.055216193199157715,
0.36006683111190796,
0.02956775762140751,
-0.14574404060840607,
0.4416680335998535,
-0.6186349391937256,
0.21695028245449066,
0.5292643904685974,
-0.8719561696052551,
-0.2950943410396576,
0.4490537643432617,
0.4751935303211212,
-0.10940227657556534,
0.5592013597488403,
-0.08673404902219772,
-0.8540416359901428,
0.4230737090110779,
0.40743643045425415,
1.2191075086593628,
-0.3988151550292969,
0.2502855062484741,
0.03737805038690567,
0.421603798866272,
-0.20679987967014313,
0.32362857460975647,
0.09478344768285751,
-1.0711990594863892,
-0.6031838655471802,
-0.9036034941673279,
-0.21492929756641388,
0.1460382342338562,
-0.5631681084632874,
0.03568729758262634,
-0.7390546798706055,
-0.24120000004768372,
-0.08830902725458145,
-0.20805838704109192,
-0.7177627086639404,
0.2671353816986084,
0.4886918365955353,
0.8744180798530579,
-1.1969937086105347,
0.6805272698402405,
0.5804163813591003,
-0.2517537772655487,
-0.44825440645217896,
0.14811746776103973,
-0.0674375519156456,
-0.9442170262336731,
0.6399811506271362,
0.3467203676700592,
0.07256755977869034,
-0.061635926365852356,
-0.5192869901657104,
-0.8378909826278687,
0.39472395181655884,
0.6763238310813904,
-0.7380107641220093,
0.10511990636587143,
0.1818685233592987,
0.2573728561401367,
-0.17210374772548676,
0.3401797413825989,
0.9696066975593567,
0.4807415306568146,
-0.46537256240844727,
-0.39922016859054565,
0.3874416649341583,
-0.08126136660575867,
0.11816178262233734,
0.02234913595020771,
-0.606881856918335,
1.0682958364486694,
0.07156254351139069,
0.2264551818370819,
-0.674119770526886,
0.47907117009162903,
-0.10859832912683487,
0.16071580350399017,
0.8562836647033691,
0.7497637867927551,
0.5736293792724609,
-0.07638826221227646,
0.7878437042236328,
-0.22733177244663239,
0.3588869869709015,
1.1717400550842285,
-0.7206433415412903,
0.6816140413284302,
0.7124392986297607,
-0.15599322319030762,
0.5017469525337219,
0.160897895693779,
0.10527785122394562,
0.7241339683532715,
0.2995186150074005,
-0.03767585754394531,
-0.4763840138912201,
-0.4240760803222656,
-0.37699878215789795,
0.7790964245796204,
0.3250148594379425,
-0.5234739780426025,
-0.37927812337875366,
0.08517103642225266,
0.077151358127594,
0.40434530377388,
-0.16711504757404327,
0.8648932576179504,
0.3472967743873596,
-0.5971974730491638,
0.5047636032104492,
0.05215122550725937,
0.7874112725257874,
-0.2686791718006134,
-0.015572672709822655,
-0.33778873085975647,
0.5514709949493408,
-0.007432944606989622,
-0.6929499506950378,
0.4908784329891205,
-0.17978528141975403,
-0.09294010698795319,
-0.48291683197021484,
0.8092069029808044,
-0.2350398302078247,
-0.5686352252960205,
0.7163273096084595,
0.7501679062843323,
-0.3151925802230835,
-0.5381265878677368,
-0.7419703006744385,
0.1312500238418579,
0.12535299360752106,
-0.43532639741897583,
0.24584999680519104,
0.3583301901817322,
0.0034962098579853773,
0.37254077196121216,
0.49034520983695984,
0.08884463459253311,
-0.18705840408802032,
0.5078713297843933,
0.8185387849807739,
-0.9199399948120117,
-0.6143633723258972,
-1.293169617652893,
0.13000434637069702,
-0.2060939073562622,
-0.36354419589042664,
0.651721715927124,
0.4384760856628418,
0.798480749130249,
0.100209541618824,
0.8541760444641113,
0.023268569260835648,
0.47992751002311707,
-0.3616340458393097,
0.8592374324798584,
-0.43704405426979065,
0.17489199340343475,
-0.5964871644973755,
-1.0185645818710327,
-0.43559229373931885,
0.9863219857215881,
-0.6028111577033997,
-0.2420864850282669,
0.4530693590641022,
0.7276137471199036,
-0.16928601264953613,
0.19765768945217133,
0.2809039056301117,
0.3646400272846222,
0.3319949805736542,
0.48380935192108154,
1.0860670804977417,
-0.3657169044017792,
0.2006087303161621,
-0.5979468822479248,
-0.32616138458251953,
-0.19683057069778442,
-0.9999037981033325,
-0.9600299000740051,
-0.24837011098861694,
-0.16292472183704376,
-0.6054749488830566,
0.23202621936798096,
1.1815379858016968,
0.6528595685958862,
-1.0812195539474487,
-0.15305869281291962,
-0.20355482399463654,
0.37197810411453247,
-0.17227208614349365,
-0.13514070212841034,
0.39311888813972473,
-0.43421250581741333,
-0.8049221634864807,
0.33453214168548584,
0.05969939008355141,
-0.19470222294330597,
-0.3844519555568695,
0.0643487274646759,
-0.26970410346984863,
0.23453684151172638,
0.6918680667877197,
-0.32497018575668335,
-0.41554978489875793,
-0.33557620644569397,
-0.45460036396980286,
-0.08970313519239426,
-0.028434855863451958,
0.9876592755317688,
-0.7679219841957092,
0.14365257322788239,
0.7231749296188354,
0.8353304862976074,
0.16931428015232086,
-0.2060803323984146,
0.9149014353752136,
-0.6220703125,
0.5409654974937439,
0.5555455684661865,
0.4051955044269562,
0.32221049070358276,
-0.221376433968544,
0.6392545700073242,
0.2510179579257965,
-0.1595323085784912,
-1.12100088596344,
0.2848605513572693,
-0.39673998951911926,
-0.5896078944206238,
1.1048476696014404,
-0.03219754621386528,
-0.36808788776397705,
-0.34071817994117737,
-0.08367495983839035,
0.15286123752593994,
-0.33042004704475403,
1.0748032331466675,
0.3968972861766815,
0.564965546131134,
0.20830923318862915,
-0.2545440196990967,
0.6145577430725098,
0.8882601857185364,
-0.20502795279026031,
0.48390987515449524,
0.4115350842475891,
0.2369440197944641,
0.14886610209941864,
0.2942321002483368,
-0.0519581064581871,
-0.042615242302417755,
0.010813949629664421,
0.22475968301296234,
0.12108027189970016,
-0.20470792055130005,
-0.7150061130523682,
0.3660828769207001,
0.1386345773935318,
-0.0029644023161381483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11505v2 | Federated Fine-tuning of Large Language Models under Heterogeneous Tasks and Client Resources | 2024-02-18T08:32:59 | 2024-05-30T15:46:10 | Jiamu Bai, Daoyuan Chen, Bingchen Qian, Liuyi Yao, Yaliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Federated Learning (FL) has recently been applied to the parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). While promising, it raises
significant challenges due to the heterogeneous resources and data
distributions of clients. This study introduces FlexLoRA, a simple yet
effective aggregation scheme for LLM fine-tuning, which mitigates the ``bucket
effect'' in traditional FL that restricts the potential of clients with ample
resources by tying them to the capabilities of the least-resourced
participants. FlexLoRA allows for dynamic adjustment of local LoRA ranks,
fostering the development of a global model imbued with broader, less
task-specific knowledge. By synthesizing a full-size LoRA weight from
individual client contributions and employing Singular Value Decomposition
(SVD) for weight redistribution, FlexLoRA fully leverages heterogeneous client
resources. Involving thousands of clients performing heterogeneous NLP tasks
and client resources, our experiments validate the efficacy of FlexLoRA, with
the federated global model achieving consistently better improvement over SOTA
FL methods in downstream NLP task performance across various heterogeneous
distributions. FlexLoRA's practicality is further underscored by our
theoretical analysis and its seamless integration with existing LoRA-based FL
methods, offering a path toward cross-device, privacy-preserving federated
tuning for LLMs. | [
-0.5002314448356628,
-0.9052504301071167,
0.24415543675422668,
0.37594419717788696,
-0.12349768728017807,
-0.09008067101240158,
-0.5302567481994629,
-0.56253582239151,
0.1217256635427475,
0.4666244387626648,
-0.5390162467956543,
-0.40672802925109863,
-0.19819170236587524,
-0.06394965946674347,
-0.19525085389614105,
1.1390652656555176,
0.28635045886039734,
-0.1938154101371765,
0.13789664208889008,
-0.620917797088623,
-0.5534560680389404,
-0.0015133654233068228,
-0.4878987669944763,
-0.5084108710289001,
0.9398984909057617,
0.6256598830223083,
0.9880126118659973,
0.6212990880012512,
0.3652232885360718,
0.3462878465652466,
-0.17905566096305847,
0.27403372526168823,
-0.8669902682304382,
-0.017442995682358742,
-0.5657268762588501,
-0.5695362687110901,
-0.5834828615188599,
0.030183428898453712,
0.7633528113365173,
0.8116989731788635,
-0.3768763244152069,
0.43955492973327637,
-0.0099041648209095,
0.6769588589668274,
-0.8690000176429749,
0.2265012413263321,
-0.8165888786315918,
0.10936272889375687,
-0.3593420684337616,
-0.3105100393295288,
-0.304973840713501,
-0.1662428230047226,
0.15287570655345917,
-0.3783021867275238,
0.23745715618133545,
0.001220535603351891,
0.7960380911827087,
0.3120124340057373,
-0.055817700922489166,
0.047538500279188156,
-0.8498633503913879,
0.6843717098236084,
-0.5107666850090027,
0.1362382173538208,
0.08174734562635422,
0.46455118060112,
0.030147986486554146,
-0.6064868569374084,
-0.5149183869361877,
0.3953920900821686,
0.05804068595170975,
-0.3129827380180359,
-0.11263890564441681,
-0.09105251729488373,
-0.05919583514332771,
0.5159887671470642,
-0.2550339102745056,
0.7116926312446594,
-0.16255292296409607,
0.15117719769477844,
0.6113420128822327,
0.04588869586586952,
0.22146031260490417,
0.4428222179412842,
-0.3839082419872284,
-0.016951726749539375,
-0.8756622076034546,
-0.0567130371928215,
0.18350492417812347,
1.030502200126648,
-0.20886805653572083,
0.5259725451469421,
-0.25257474184036255,
0.5567586421966553,
0.13515591621398926,
-0.2140301614999771,
0.3291260004043579,
-0.15635092556476593,
-0.5453914999961853,
0.011678230948746204,
0.4619442820549011,
-0.03143574297428131,
0.013827194459736347,
-0.43842899799346924,
-0.4583566188812256,
-0.05572633445262909,
-0.05487822741270065,
-0.6889083981513977,
0.1417505145072937,
0.24086500704288483,
-0.3437705338001251,
-0.17900671064853668,
-0.14365258812904358,
-0.6822077035903931,
-0.4301013946533203,
-0.4590364992618561,
0.3728078305721283,
-0.09259331226348877,
-0.2694847285747528,
0.12696750462055206,
0.22132165729999542,
0.10180839896202087,
0.36251065135002136,
-1.1692399978637695,
0.4002346694469452,
1.1098166704177856,
0.7940651774406433,
-0.0435217060148716,
-0.597148597240448,
-1.0429631471633911,
0.08478625863790512,
0.17909039556980133,
0.8358318209648132,
-0.3682062029838562,
0.01823830045759678,
0.3737134635448456,
-0.031888943165540695,
-0.20300757884979248,
-0.5227915048599243,
0.1509736329317093,
-0.6377978920936584,
0.22367416322231293,
-0.2007838785648346,
-0.5797615647315979,
0.054904770106077194,
0.05387298762798309,
-0.6344871520996094,
0.3545604348182678,
0.30594101548194885,
-0.7368519902229309,
0.26273149251937866,
-0.616093635559082,
-0.28551119565963745,
0.2567160129547119,
-0.14694684743881226,
-0.4386066794395447,
0.13520440459251404,
0.08775981515645981,
0.5617318153381348,
-0.4786219894886017,
0.235842764377594,
-0.42444372177124023,
-0.5056344270706177,
0.041537776589393616,
-0.276201456785202,
0.8422738313674927,
0.3357792794704437,
-0.34113770723342896,
0.2122831493616104,
-0.48571038246154785,
0.11766918748617172,
0.029575029388070107,
-0.557507336139679,
-0.31479504704475403,
-0.1728503257036209,
0.31182971596717834,
-0.03816193714737892,
0.16576708853244781,
-0.34399935603141785,
0.25717979669570923,
-0.6111401915550232,
0.10473127663135529,
0.8011496663093567,
-0.2631101906299591,
0.5269649028778076,
-0.3530625104904175,
0.34145402908325195,
-0.37856578826904297,
0.25364285707473755,
0.29255685210227966,
-0.24515065550804138,
-0.5454505085945129,
-0.4567420780658722,
0.2531490921974182,
0.18016572296619415,
-0.6603055596351624,
0.40969645977020264,
-0.44831761717796326,
-0.5211848616600037,
-0.31718719005584717,
0.44041937589645386,
0.41241466999053955,
0.3504469096660614,
0.34400251507759094,
-0.09488232433795929,
-0.04685502126812935,
-0.6624141931533813,
-0.3194032907485962,
0.20255540311336517,
-0.08681096136569977,
0.30828624963760376,
0.13597844541072845,
-0.4746008813381195,
0.9894015192985535,
-0.4405929744243622,
-0.8094124794006348,
-0.2995986044406891,
0.1913042813539505,
0.2906036972999573,
0.4143655300140381,
0.8039310574531555,
-0.8272411823272705,
-0.6328663229942322,
0.3067934215068817,
-0.12100367248058319,
-0.3760030269622803,
0.08266151696443558,
0.05693488195538521,
0.5406953692436218,
0.08762548118829727,
-0.4025983214378357,
-0.027896665036678314,
0.88214111328125,
-0.7514736652374268,
0.4805477559566498,
-0.4110676050186157,
-0.3556448221206665,
-0.739026665687561,
0.20268869400024414,
-0.08073730766773224,
-0.3268257975578308,
-0.5534684062004089,
0.3489198386669159,
-0.06321386992931366,
0.014709056355059147,
-0.49512478709220886,
0.479233980178833,
-0.3274185061454773,
-0.3399285078048706,
-0.42127734422683716,
0.3126697838306427,
-0.272167444229126,
0.5265953540802002,
-0.30544859170913696,
0.633089542388916,
0.4170272946357727,
-0.5665987133979797,
0.1407223790884018,
0.058451760560274124,
-0.23924078047275543,
0.6178607940673828,
-0.4525527060031891,
-0.11903492361307144,
-0.03413097932934761,
0.13188104331493378,
-0.6664184331893921,
-0.0857447162270546,
-0.056362688541412354,
0.23393183946609497,
0.19003602862358093,
0.1202148050069809,
-0.6077895164489746,
0.06189919263124466,
-0.19063180685043335,
0.3930884897708893,
0.2881626784801483,
-0.8658545613288879,
0.7218563556671143,
0.5314823985099792,
-0.07001720368862152,
-0.6602781414985657,
-0.6452926397323608,
-0.19550268352031708,
-0.2453896403312683,
-0.5108110308647156,
0.39321160316467285,
-0.046417634934186935,
-0.30235952138900757,
-0.17657463252544403,
-0.027352143079042435,
-0.13396626710891724,
0.36570772528648376,
0.1107027679681778,
-0.043780338019132614,
-0.3016361594200134,
0.24482819437980652,
0.08006171882152557,
0.0024035172536969185,
-0.2818162143230438,
-0.056208714842796326,
0.6988106369972229,
-0.5791717171669006,
-0.4083513021469116,
-0.2830337882041931,
0.023345230147242546,
0.6028739213943481,
-0.30306515097618103,
1.0682499408721924,
0.9154751300811768,
-0.0027106250636279583,
-0.7022494673728943,
-0.6673903465270996,
-0.1380794197320938,
-0.5258570313453674,
0.06155984103679657,
-0.12507492303848267,
-1.1842905282974243,
0.8344175219535828,
-0.18219466507434845,
0.4118139147758484,
0.2243911772966385,
0.6737889647483826,
0.1883474439382553,
0.6928616166114807,
0.9349788427352905,
-0.4050862193107605,
0.7726297974586487,
-0.31536969542503357,
0.09892168641090393,
-0.42650195956230164,
0.06614698469638824,
-0.6658899784088135,
-0.4834336042404175,
-0.6889417171478271,
-0.5600311756134033,
0.23068252205848694,
-0.1801140308380127,
-0.3094783425331116,
0.02845362015068531,
-0.1417943686246872,
0.7087163925170898,
0.29051706194877625,
0.02168627828359604,
0.5439625978469849,
0.13322632014751434,
0.11163278669118881,
0.4341045022010803,
-0.9051467776298523,
-0.07357150316238403,
0.6738179922103882,
0.48769211769104004,
0.514260470867157,
0.4667135179042816,
0.6146988868713379,
0.3014116585254669,
0.5665693283081055,
-0.4551660716533661,
0.48520568013191223,
-0.35891643166542053,
-0.4015950858592987,
-0.6632808446884155,
-0.5508884787559509,
-0.9914838671684265,
0.659483790397644,
-0.35979893803596497,
-0.9444912075996399,
0.32749345898628235,
0.1801573634147644,
-0.31516915559768677,
0.34673288464546204,
-0.6920315027236938,
0.6965157389640808,
0.0732695609331131,
-0.6060590147972107,
-0.5178436040878296,
-0.502238392829895,
0.4062129855155945,
-0.16136014461517334,
0.2093917280435562,
-0.3533358871936798,
0.04930038005113602,
0.2675531506538391,
-0.6521674394607544,
0.9649752974510193,
-0.35109055042266846,
-0.5110472440719604,
0.00043405586620792747,
-0.08593104779720306,
0.6063238978385925,
0.20524710416793823,
-0.1651442050933838,
0.07412460446357727,
-0.0860678032040596,
-0.5569839477539062,
-0.5679689645767212,
0.9704732894897461,
-0.8006060123443604,
-0.47475865483283997,
0.008253500796854496,
-0.8443188071250916,
-0.3264140486717224,
0.30203256011009216,
-0.20255634188652039,
0.3207634687423706,
-0.19913749396800995,
0.40310969948768616,
0.560232937335968,
-0.1980411857366562,
0.42741158604621887,
0.9532012343406677,
-0.3126847445964813,
-0.11235527694225311,
0.8257885575294495,
0.021664144471287727,
0.36212289333343506,
0.35770702362060547,
0.44807034730911255,
-0.11861109733581543,
-0.49929550290107727,
-0.05696574226021767,
0.5449691414833069,
-0.6100746989250183,
-0.3361961841583252,
-0.2955012619495392,
0.14358927309513092,
-0.2882119417190552,
-0.3402039408683777,
-0.7153568267822266,
-0.19331976771354675,
-0.4043140113353729,
0.13517630100250244,
0.26125529408454895,
0.18710409104824066,
0.04385855793952942,
0.4206845760345459,
-0.6769090890884399,
0.19051478803157806,
0.2921232283115387,
0.8167043924331665,
0.028294600546360016,
-0.2291138768196106,
-0.4204137623310089,
0.06421608477830887,
0.16191357374191284,
-0.21660937368869781,
0.3623424768447876,
0.48714014887809753,
0.37803781032562256,
0.6311458945274353,
0.18172281980514526,
0.8022866249084473,
-0.34058326482772827,
0.42468956112861633,
0.07418972998857498,
-0.9477820992469788,
0.09050020575523376,
-0.5235524773597717,
0.5131385922431946,
0.6680333018302917,
-0.13908401131629944,
-0.3421895205974579,
-0.539334774017334,
-0.42331522703170776,
-0.7596732378005981,
0.8469604253768921,
0.07366008311510086,
0.24530147016048431,
0.38620349764823914,
0.16647100448608398,
0.2697834372520447,
0.13008564710617065,
-0.7234399318695068,
-0.28989177942276,
0.08521381765604019,
-0.012020023539662361,
-0.2428625077009201,
-0.10148913413286209,
-0.3570697605609894,
-0.1702791005373001,
0.645622193813324,
-0.5367828607559204,
-0.16857895255088806,
-0.1695169061422348,
0.08398526161909103,
-0.3040350675582886,
0.2704657316207886,
0.4793556034564972,
0.7635255455970764,
-0.2497551292181015,
0.07831352204084396,
0.11139941960573196,
-0.1635543406009674,
-0.16288645565509796,
0.3339919149875641,
-0.23926611244678497,
-0.2434045970439911,
0.24720939993858337,
0.8192787170410156,
0.40493229031562805,
-0.8835948705673218,
0.35776302218437195,
-0.21716979146003723,
-0.13338032364845276,
0.12773345410823822,
0.35260719060897827,
0.13339288532733917,
0.5724669098854065,
0.20339195430278778,
-0.09100168198347092,
-0.29551807045936584,
-0.5831509828567505,
0.01897278055548668,
0.5265322923660278,
-0.0509369783103466,
-0.2924312353134155,
0.26683729887008667,
0.2902243137359619,
-0.2640818655490875,
0.29706496000289917,
0.10623329132795334,
-0.10652462393045425,
0.33693552017211914,
0.6396713256835938,
0.7219573259353638,
-0.21802818775177002,
0.3771125078201294,
-0.18671193718910217,
-0.017908010631799698,
-0.2448662668466568,
0.24191103875637054,
-0.23365776240825653,
-0.8430249691009521,
-0.24705395102500916,
-0.6629381775856018,
-0.3189045488834381,
0.04994047060608864,
-0.46326810121536255,
0.05248540639877319,
-0.5251435041427612,
0.024023087695240974,
-0.015560419298708439,
0.2751619815826416,
-0.7452998757362366,
-0.18279366195201874,
0.1812746822834015,
0.9021827578544617,
-0.9660388231277466,
0.9420067667961121,
0.4309568703174591,
-0.27095627784729004,
-1.026705265045166,
0.01952456124126911,
-0.18724055588245392,
-0.5480424165725708,
0.4081389605998993,
0.000433937442721799,
-0.17463399469852448,
-0.02209731936454773,
-0.36291128396987915,
-0.8631540536880493,
1.2834606170654297,
0.6251198649406433,
-0.42527541518211365,
0.15490704774856567,
0.41035765409469604,
0.9012160301208496,
-0.4308268427848816,
-0.17104452848434448,
0.5879741311073303,
0.44486114382743835,
-0.0031320617999881506,
-1.2027965784072876,
0.05824767053127289,
0.07163386791944504,
0.08136896789073944,
-0.08889181911945343,
-0.8666961193084717,
1.0308539867401123,
-0.06637810915708542,
-0.4104727506637573,
-0.1812291443347931,
0.7074134945869446,
0.20469777286052704,
0.3452453017234802,
0.7943074703216553,
0.2593616247177124,
1.0296324491500854,
0.24402585625648499,
0.9432754516601562,
-0.15374237298965454,
0.5953333973884583,
1.2988535165786743,
-0.5999144911766052,
0.6547262072563171,
0.6246227622032166,
0.01214417815208435,
0.3083854913711548,
0.07594742625951767,
0.10151315480470657,
0.5098812580108643,
0.126066192984581,
-0.28440505266189575,
0.038218721747398376,
-0.3433939218521118,
-0.24646416306495667,
0.7049707770347595,
0.25818318128585815,
-0.27100634574890137,
-0.5135790705680847,
0.1761794239282608,
0.0135403573513031,
0.3111487627029419,
-0.5187568664550781,
0.6426835060119629,
-0.05758650228381157,
-0.66604083776474,
0.9118630290031433,
0.17611059546470642,
0.744126558303833,
-0.46797725558280945,
0.3526204526424408,
-0.38510841131210327,
0.5945872068405151,
-0.2536444365978241,
-0.2711043655872345,
0.26645612716674805,
0.07908447086811066,
-0.026224058121442795,
-0.3763839900493622,
0.5790572762489319,
-0.5774014592170715,
-0.2710495889186859,
0.35974404215812683,
0.5954962968826294,
-0.2542709708213806,
-0.0133394505828619,
-0.5211682319641113,
0.11687467247247696,
-0.16976752877235413,
-0.3763488531112671,
0.7099753618240356,
0.5148025751113892,
0.10681600123643875,
0.9103671908378601,
0.47272157669067383,
0.1650945246219635,
-0.17435026168823242,
0.39076006412506104,
1.0565067529678345,
-0.11771765351295471,
-0.7416970133781433,
-0.618207573890686,
0.05316729471087456,
0.10973091423511505,
-0.11381062865257263,
0.7969925403594971,
0.28044936060905457,
0.7753165364265442,
-0.08486831188201904,
0.2793666124343872,
-0.053077735006809235,
0.34791603684425354,
-0.4562646150588989,
0.8922262191772461,
-0.6682537794113159,
0.5720985531806946,
-0.27651262283325195,
-0.8949505090713501,
-0.45336759090423584,
0.2585095465183258,
-0.15034379065036774,
-0.3926348388195038,
0.37480464577674866,
0.7845936417579651,
-0.3370329737663269,
0.1647656112909317,
0.19513548910617828,
0.13286353647708893,
0.5170481204986572,
0.3197876513004303,
0.17205454409122467,
-0.0700952410697937,
0.255540668964386,
-0.26446136832237244,
-0.10107294470071793,
-0.5786629915237427,
-0.8346547484397888,
-0.7912933826446533,
-0.35440948605537415,
-0.313285768032074,
0.055791761726140976,
0.08478004485368729,
1.048736572265625,
0.60622239112854,
-0.7313733100891113,
-0.2340773493051529,
-0.13183286786079407,
0.47614094614982605,
-0.5637093782424927,
-0.25118640065193176,
0.33111897110939026,
-0.5467708110809326,
-0.7644884586334229,
0.3321436047554016,
0.03974801301956177,
-0.1861085295677185,
-0.5824155807495117,
-0.14840278029441833,
-0.2882828712463379,
-0.06966373324394226,
0.5248988270759583,
0.43845415115356445,
-0.5784270763397217,
-0.3152967691421509,
-0.5193911194801331,
-0.20179925858974457,
-0.1297626495361328,
0.7306443452835083,
-0.7822639346122742,
0.15635596215724945,
0.5753116011619568,
0.721174418926239,
0.1754026561975479,
0.18025951087474823,
0.5950034856796265,
-0.9875372052192688,
0.4094698429107666,
0.17333996295928955,
0.25373584032058716,
0.06331770867109299,
-0.3804945945739746,
0.4816684424877167,
-0.011411038227379322,
-0.604434072971344,
-1.0271940231323242,
-0.010792919434607029,
-0.9168232083320618,
-0.5131781697273254,
1.0692719221115112,
-0.26384681463241577,
-0.2809014618396759,
-0.006262011826038361,
0.034865036606788635,
0.20975390076637268,
-0.2900499403476715,
1.1095141172409058,
0.10457447171211243,
0.061809808015823364,
0.08431322872638702,
-0.10329050570726395,
0.507794976234436,
0.5431278944015503,
-0.8300813436508179,
0.5117022395133972,
0.6465360522270203,
0.15994204580783844,
0.13948363065719604,
0.7105048298835754,
0.29309993982315063,
0.1346869021654129,
-0.42825251817703247,
-0.22446872293949127,
-0.2594180703163147,
-0.3751622140407562,
-0.42930883169174194,
0.629572868347168,
0.04778788238763809,
0.16581997275352478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11493v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11493v2 | Benchmarking Knowledge Boundary for Large Language Models: A Different Perspective on Model Evaluation | 2024-02-18T07:48:15 | 2024-05-29T17:39:47 | Xunjian Yin, Xu Zhang, Jie Ruan, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, substantial advancements have been made in the development
of large language models, achieving remarkable performance across diverse
tasks. To evaluate the knowledge ability of language models, previous studies
have proposed lots of benchmarks based on question-answering pairs. We argue
that it is not reliable and comprehensive to evaluate language models with a
fixed question or limited paraphrases as the query, since language models are
sensitive to prompt. Therefore, we introduce a novel concept named knowledge
boundary to encompass both prompt-agnostic and prompt-sensitive knowledge
within language models. Knowledge boundary avoids prompt sensitivity in
language model evaluations, rendering them more dependable and robust. To
explore the knowledge boundary for a given model, we propose projected gradient
descent method with semantic constraints, a new algorithm designed to identify
the optimal prompt for each piece of knowledge. Experiments demonstrate a
superior performance of our algorithm in computing the knowledge boundary
compared to existing methods. Furthermore, we evaluate the ability of multiple
language models in several domains with knowledge boundary. | [
-0.4752253293991089,
-0.7447036504745483,
0.6969608664512634,
0.3082154393196106,
0.0917963758111,
-0.008584165014326572,
-0.31346237659454346,
-0.29482582211494446,
-0.2897639572620392,
0.5263659358024597,
-0.7184720635414124,
-0.5201025009155273,
-0.5887909531593323,
-0.028856122866272926,
-0.13009008765220642,
0.7443748712539673,
0.0065827094949781895,
0.11420981585979462,
-0.8663976192474365,
-0.3511645495891571,
-0.708114504814148,
-0.39414745569229126,
-0.4840804934501648,
-0.38385656476020813,
0.3496670722961426,
-0.09397044777870178,
0.39604443311691284,
0.8012245297431946,
0.36627456545829773,
0.23421046137809753,
-0.24430431425571442,
0.0035554207861423492,
-0.21017345786094666,
0.257813036441803,
-0.30488601326942444,
-0.28954553604125977,
-0.025978172197937965,
-0.06123797222971916,
0.8311952948570251,
1.081197738647461,
0.026966964825987816,
0.1306566745042801,
0.08537983149290085,
0.5835224390029907,
-0.7401551604270935,
0.16516916453838348,
-0.6431198716163635,
-0.12507928907871246,
-0.008735593408346176,
0.13036373257637024,
-0.385835200548172,
-0.5168359279632568,
0.46420931816101074,
-0.4652516841888428,
0.07951850444078445,
-0.029586374759674072,
0.7172709703445435,
0.29331129789352417,
-0.330574095249176,
-0.022458504885435104,
-0.3924170732498169,
0.8869239687919617,
-0.4907318353652954,
0.7570197582244873,
0.12273303419351578,
0.5350732207298279,
0.11860205233097076,
-0.6812251210212708,
-0.4099685549736023,
-0.43668901920318604,
0.2380652278661728,
-0.1050761416554451,
-0.23398201167583466,
-0.05179625377058983,
0.45821353793144226,
0.00655462546274066,
-0.47974836826324463,
0.0793410986661911,
-0.0012603505747392774,
-0.4480709135532379,
0.2713053822517395,
0.2503775954246521,
0.2985212206840515,
-0.14216241240501404,
-0.6772938966751099,
-0.0908343717455864,
-0.570106029510498,
0.23808005452156067,
0.3051041066646576,
0.3824259340763092,
0.08475862443447113,
0.23921319842338562,
-0.6213675141334534,
1.027669906616211,
-0.25957921147346497,
-0.10523220151662827,
0.2168676257133484,
-0.02997613325715065,
0.22707004845142365,
-0.5403081774711609,
0.6374571323394775,
0.7750130891799927,
0.19629521667957306,
-0.43583863973617554,
-0.1956043839454651,
0.21999375522136688,
-0.01774519681930542,
-0.6999568343162537,
-0.024073386564850807,
-0.18672622740268707,
-0.21241773664951324,
0.3009631633758545,
-0.21485789120197296,
-0.9478634595870972,
-0.5518836379051208,
-0.17243562638759613,
0.27883267402648926,
-0.3365994989871979,
-0.22118359804153442,
0.09738390892744064,
-0.20540349185466766,
0.1494181901216507,
0.33435818552970886,
-0.5737754702568054,
0.4845614433288574,
0.7840631008148193,
0.7493093609809875,
-0.26805058121681213,
-0.48342254757881165,
-0.5921481251716614,
-0.08315201103687286,
-0.10998676717281342,
0.7744492292404175,
-0.7964791655540466,
-0.3350975215435028,
0.07708824425935745,
-0.28101053833961487,
-0.30531612038612366,
-0.7003434896469116,
0.6510371565818787,
-0.6305596828460693,
0.13527216017246246,
-0.6796426177024841,
-0.7660684585571289,
-0.16550272703170776,
0.3402363955974579,
-0.5044705867767334,
0.9027019739151001,
0.1285262256860733,
-0.7785589694976807,
0.2563638687133789,
-0.3697893023490906,
-0.348080039024353,
0.14522193372249603,
-0.19412747025489807,
0.190972238779068,
-0.20118536055088043,
0.17765696346759796,
0.24546480178833008,
-0.785686194896698,
0.4813946485519409,
-0.2519930899143219,
0.0928458645939827,
0.1715017557144165,
-0.15057314932346344,
0.7358860373497009,
0.19100965559482574,
-0.18519534170627594,
-0.020029596984386444,
-0.6740396618843079,
0.2470283806324005,
-0.05604197084903717,
-0.10944684594869614,
-0.5654872059822083,
-0.07272191345691681,
-0.31648340821266174,
0.27068403363227844,
0.44874897599220276,
-0.5062565803527832,
-0.01910543255507946,
-0.2342774122953415,
0.21183401346206665,
0.6586306691169739,
0.23446869850158691,
0.44254621863365173,
-0.429841011762619,
0.6594120264053345,
-0.31498783826828003,
0.17743003368377686,
0.05404727905988693,
-0.5627745389938354,
-0.545728862285614,
0.06837278604507446,
0.3964877724647522,
0.44025617837905884,
-0.8008999824523926,
0.379254549741745,
-0.10226888954639435,
-0.6254531145095825,
-0.4142597019672394,
0.02149982377886772,
0.7036424279212952,
0.9974473118782043,
0.3641361594200134,
-0.3703407645225525,
-0.28812021017074585,
-1.081608772277832,
-0.7341985702514648,
-0.3361852765083313,
0.018895072862505913,
0.5239748358726501,
0.29793399572372437,
0.09085184335708618,
0.9864739775657654,
-0.6814740896224976,
0.11653909087181091,
-0.08713109791278839,
-0.020835818722844124,
0.09823203086853027,
0.5296416878700256,
0.5675061941146851,
-0.7923049926757812,
-0.355796217918396,
-0.13798198103904724,
-0.6222585439682007,
-0.45847246050834656,
0.2932460904121399,
-0.3584267795085907,
-0.17875301837921143,
0.43040651082992554,
-0.65693199634552,
-0.13110224902629852,
0.3106718063354492,
-0.27731218934059143,
0.6616042852401733,
0.13135235011577606,
0.017809700220823288,
-0.6848186254501343,
0.28184381127357483,
0.3451348543167114,
0.02188096195459366,
-0.7717031836509705,
0.1777561753988266,
0.2289515882730484,
0.04761291667819023,
-0.3044951856136322,
1.0523350238800049,
-0.28071317076683044,
0.14657062292099,
-0.1334685981273651,
0.14693082869052887,
0.15856017172336578,
0.4572126865386963,
0.3555116355419159,
0.3385588228702545,
0.6991706490516663,
-0.7152612209320068,
0.37044015526771545,
0.3112761080265045,
-0.6596670150756836,
0.5801908373832703,
-0.6383190751075745,
0.16988253593444824,
-0.007594795897603035,
0.0080553675070405,
-0.7986864447593689,
0.1078578382730484,
0.12530650198459625,
-0.3901987671852112,
0.03232609108090401,
-0.196991965174675,
-0.24094390869140625,
-0.5059269666671753,
-0.18485189974308014,
0.4119182527065277,
0.615278959274292,
-0.32239463925361633,
0.31974825263023376,
0.3772721588611603,
-0.21713770925998688,
-0.6986455917358398,
-0.2145041674375534,
-0.2375601977109909,
-0.28118187189102173,
-0.5614247918128967,
0.15923157334327698,
-0.25085532665252686,
-0.47078123688697815,
0.02991517446935177,
-0.2141747921705246,
-0.1791813224554062,
0.29292747378349304,
0.01601800136268139,
0.07737712562084198,
-0.049375928938388824,
0.245330810546875,
0.00015787793381605297,
-0.006919493433088064,
0.40008726716041565,
-0.4094361364841461,
0.6134923696517944,
0.0016144938999786973,
-0.3227027654647827,
0.0526990182697773,
0.2913663387298584,
0.336052805185318,
-0.6029255986213684,
0.6955175399780273,
0.18542180955410004,
-0.6093090772628784,
-0.41780972480773926,
-0.8588908910751343,
-0.1624678671360016,
-0.40372949838638306,
0.39861294627189636,
-0.6642310619354248,
-0.8082682490348816,
0.8167716860771179,
-0.24865026772022247,
-0.20573313534259796,
0.7289511561393738,
0.4680195152759552,
0.5055335760116577,
0.8492651581764221,
0.8133171796798706,
-0.0543496273458004,
0.24607671797275543,
0.021469302475452423,
-0.10500653833150864,
-0.8679179549217224,
-0.46863850951194763,
-0.9142345190048218,
0.14560548961162567,
-0.20853875577449799,
-0.2964158058166504,
0.29885438084602356,
0.21080496907234192,
-0.21171537041664124,
0.26238054037094116,
-0.2506673038005829,
0.4360097050666809,
0.6732567548751831,
0.09006847441196442,
0.28793108463287354,
-0.3033369183540344,
-0.53377366065979,
-0.059002045542001724,
-0.7995713949203491,
-0.449211448431015,
0.8379244804382324,
0.2498156726360321,
0.4735032916069031,
-0.20342597365379333,
0.2824963331222534,
0.13555391132831573,
0.09518177062273026,
-0.49150383472442627,
0.6279780268669128,
0.2509846091270447,
-0.7070488333702087,
-0.3503910005092621,
-0.7351272106170654,
-0.48690029978752136,
0.2823122441768646,
0.06283143162727356,
-1.0037076473236084,
0.18650925159454346,
-0.26370906829833984,
-0.3799141049385071,
0.2577345371246338,
-0.7598191499710083,
1.101181149482727,
-0.027949687093496323,
-0.49816086888313293,
0.21427233517169952,
-0.7439394593238831,
0.12735962867736816,
-0.09276202321052551,
0.1787426620721817,
-0.37276697158813477,
-0.061714623123407364,
1.1084480285644531,
-0.41337406635284424,
0.686769425868988,
-0.6156824827194214,
-0.17481344938278198,
0.4182984232902527,
0.07712412625551224,
0.3371266722679138,
-0.1038542091846466,
-0.32710564136505127,
-0.05932493507862091,
0.010549819096922874,
-0.3718867897987366,
-0.7486345767974854,
0.7246764898300171,
-0.6528127789497375,
-0.850462019443512,
-0.0669085681438446,
-0.6132233142852783,
-0.8162989616394043,
0.37904679775238037,
0.20796334743499756,
0.4943648874759674,
-0.24934449791908264,
-0.25272059440612793,
0.5161909461021423,
-0.23868738114833832,
0.2813189923763275,
0.6829681396484375,
-0.16709661483764648,
-0.19699214398860931,
0.8115676045417786,
0.17749808728694916,
0.28568586707115173,
0.5166919827461243,
0.16546419262886047,
-0.6226281523704529,
-0.6674060821533203,
-0.4490075707435608,
0.23711389303207397,
-0.8784846067428589,
-0.13593661785125732,
-0.8223682641983032,
-0.06847842782735825,
-0.43265968561172485,
0.14165130257606506,
-0.3257584869861603,
-0.1720869243144989,
0.1644231230020523,
0.13656222820281982,
0.20946693420410156,
0.6854630708694458,
0.10556390136480331,
-0.055437471717596054,
-0.7356808185577393,
0.01368186715990305,
0.4788985550403595,
0.5698209404945374,
0.31251049041748047,
-0.49402034282684326,
-0.23436567187309265,
-0.05141553655266762,
-0.14415724575519562,
-0.7680258750915527,
0.15116454660892487,
0.008618049323558807,
1.0243589878082275,
0.28613072633743286,
0.4098982512950897,
0.2777077257633209,
-0.64080810546875,
0.6313954591751099,
0.13694904744625092,
-1.1293662786483765,
0.45285362005233765,
-0.29418566823005676,
0.49417510628700256,
0.6138879656791687,
0.5994365811347961,
-0.7360348701477051,
-0.3877238631248474,
-0.46419432759284973,
-0.6629218459129333,
0.3635749816894531,
-0.14180517196655273,
0.15426142513751984,
-0.1144026592373848,
0.28838250041007996,
0.5302098393440247,
0.39239418506622314,
-0.48694515228271484,
-0.23081396520137787,
0.235609769821167,
0.04785663262009621,
-0.10800793766975403,
-0.2125379741191864,
-0.13418033719062805,
-0.18038317561149597,
0.5286890864372253,
-0.18379144370555878,
0.08791859447956085,
0.047295235097408295,
-0.27700743079185486,
-0.09884322434663773,
0.17379717528820038,
0.25323057174682617,
1.0448310375213623,
0.04060261696577072,
0.10221756994724274,
0.29854536056518555,
-0.18337690830230713,
0.10339948534965515,
0.4124739170074463,
-0.39423930644989014,
-0.13521012663841248,
0.44501620531082153,
0.9035122394561768,
-0.1428932100534439,
-0.7133868336677551,
0.5256199836730957,
0.05688035115599632,
-0.19850432872772217,
0.3288014233112335,
-0.13305972516536713,
0.0471031554043293,
0.43884819746017456,
0.45530566573143005,
0.06854042410850525,
0.23778311908245087,
-0.23104076087474823,
0.31402111053466797,
0.47405311465263367,
-0.4566076695919037,
-0.3259623050689697,
0.7949540615081787,
0.22087357938289642,
-0.09806326031684875,
0.3100043535232544,
-0.06985106319189072,
-0.851334273815155,
0.646744430065155,
0.3956683576107025,
0.7271628379821777,
-0.3241753578186035,
0.23998236656188965,
0.22158604860305786,
0.19075818359851837,
-0.06998763233423233,
0.22200195491313934,
-0.2075314074754715,
-0.9130766987800598,
-0.4581635892391205,
-0.6378602981567383,
-0.6126509308815002,
0.0816946029663086,
-0.7684236168861389,
0.07730495929718018,
-0.40480780601501465,
-0.16311447322368622,
0.11467991769313812,
0.1445295810699463,
-0.7132428884506226,
0.30735358595848083,
0.07059337198734283,
1.1236492395401,
-0.9131476283073425,
0.5933576226234436,
0.902306318283081,
-0.008887010626494884,
-0.557026743888855,
0.023886771872639656,
-0.4233890771865845,
-0.7648259997367859,
0.5099350214004517,
0.3201422095298767,
-0.08574722707271576,
0.09963180869817734,
-0.27155905961990356,
-0.5406836867332458,
0.612392783164978,
0.6178351044654846,
-0.45164522528648376,
0.0992957204580307,
-0.05638982728123665,
0.5666622519493103,
-0.282510906457901,
0.2563501000404358,
0.5478581190109253,
0.5270203351974487,
-0.0019257412059232593,
-1.0339843034744263,
0.1892346739768982,
-0.4435999393463135,
0.017991896718740463,
0.21818552911281586,
-0.7490628361701965,
0.8501312732696533,
-0.11838231235742569,
-0.2102390080690384,
0.1407162994146347,
0.5659533739089966,
0.05956738069653511,
0.45589977502822876,
0.5957260131835938,
0.5385043621063232,
0.9234791398048401,
-0.20071856677532196,
1.1036021709442139,
-0.406953901052475,
0.38654422760009766,
0.8773900270462036,
-0.5451563000679016,
0.5844037532806396,
0.3418385982513428,
-0.3114946782588959,
0.35828813910484314,
0.6253669261932373,
0.12975682318210602,
0.7094689607620239,
0.530099630355835,
-0.3150312900543213,
-0.4190065562725067,
-0.67039555311203,
-0.5223115682601929,
0.1755104660987854,
0.06137584522366524,
-0.07923083007335663,
-0.3749171197414398,
0.10157329589128494,
-0.014854795299470425,
0.3827384412288666,
-0.38873979449272156,
0.715583860874176,
-0.06973890960216522,
-0.8747726678848267,
0.6817548274993896,
0.05287832021713257,
0.442669153213501,
-0.49046772718429565,
0.08305856585502625,
-0.296146035194397,
-0.018285878002643585,
0.14511322975158691,
-0.5298073887825012,
-0.0883595198392868,
0.022050155326724052,
-0.26207098364830017,
-0.08036276698112488,
0.8786596655845642,
-0.4198628067970276,
-0.2701008915901184,
0.4170956313610077,
1.0374233722686768,
-0.02391258254647255,
-0.27573490142822266,
-0.5734352469444275,
0.03730107098817825,
-0.09723617881536484,
-0.24147388339042664,
0.17688117921352386,
0.5013803243637085,
-0.1312706470489502,
0.875565230846405,
0.234216570854187,
-0.03159411624073982,
0.09576176106929779,
0.19404149055480957,
1.0551084280014038,
-0.5648667812347412,
-0.6298723220825195,
-0.8799778819084167,
0.22406674921512604,
-0.09436853229999542,
-0.3383149802684784,
0.8931243419647217,
0.5440471768379211,
0.7741727232933044,
-0.01586499996483326,
0.998927116394043,
0.008572177961468697,
0.8204501271247864,
-0.5420597195625305,
0.6047430634498596,
-0.3891412615776062,
0.20716819167137146,
-0.40486907958984375,
-1.136944055557251,
-0.33075445890426636,
0.260850727558136,
-0.7959017157554626,
0.3313741683959961,
0.6902472972869873,
0.4967113435268402,
0.31888535618782043,
-0.0067343986593186855,
0.33738410472869873,
-0.03410772979259491,
-0.047667864710092545,
0.7583673000335693,
1.1951313018798828,
0.01076685730367899,
0.24407388269901276,
-0.3759396970272064,
-0.32202407717704773,
0.1477416455745697,
-0.8409304022789001,
-1.0455362796783447,
-0.7882920503616333,
-0.34976518154144287,
-0.2697502374649048,
0.27616599202156067,
0.60283362865448,
0.5639960765838623,
-0.6436649560928345,
-0.16997849941253662,
0.007353688590228558,
0.3623332381248474,
-0.15808580815792084,
-0.19180020689964294,
0.3945484757423401,
-0.31606245040893555,
-0.760983407497406,
0.3895280063152313,
0.013408641330897808,
-0.08758590370416641,
-0.21075160801410675,
-0.16917255520820618,
-0.173758864402771,
-0.1774604618549347,
0.2214454859495163,
0.332423597574234,
-0.41146454215049744,
-0.29104286432266235,
0.12636390328407288,
-0.030476925894618034,
-0.16805706918239594,
0.7256630063056946,
-0.9095378518104553,
0.4344313442707062,
0.3713948428630829,
0.9519067406654358,
0.24167409539222717,
0.036820657551288605,
0.740239679813385,
-0.672740638256073,
-0.020729342475533485,
0.36559873819351196,
0.28500574827194214,
0.48155057430267334,
-0.06234662979841232,
0.28202423453330994,
0.3752378821372986,
-0.35875362157821655,
-0.8689769506454468,
0.31410154700279236,
-0.6775661706924438,
-0.29219260811805725,
1.2201223373413086,
-0.4560595452785492,
-0.263531893491745,
0.04004756361246109,
0.0275268517434597,
0.17159046232700348,
-0.3910738527774811,
0.5201868414878845,
0.8756136894226074,
0.17705699801445007,
-0.08983631432056427,
-0.6147133111953735,
0.54416823387146,
0.6260255575180054,
-0.5310605764389038,
0.19901254773139954,
0.4027342200279236,
0.2430344521999359,
0.07197066396474838,
0.3402996361255646,
0.07103537768125534,
0.1630110889673233,
0.0438046008348465,
0.18391086161136627,
0.026974966749548912,
-0.32372739911079407,
-0.3552705943584442,
0.39868423342704773,
0.327068567276001,
-0.10361680388450623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11489v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11489v2 | What's the Plan? Evaluating and Developing Planning-Aware Techniques for Language Models | 2024-02-18T07:42:49 | 2024-05-22T22:50:25 | Eran Hirsch, Guy Uziel, Ateret Anaby-Tavor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Planning is a fundamental task in artificial intelligence that involves
finding a sequence of actions that achieve a specified goal in a given
environment. Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used for
applications that require planning capabilities, such as web or embodied
agents. In line with recent studies, we demonstrate through experimentation
that LLMs lack necessary skills required for planning. Based on these
observations, we advocate for the potential of a hybrid approach that combines
LLMs with classical planning methodology. Then, we introduce SimPlan, a novel
hybrid-method, and evaluate its performance in a new challenging setup. Our
extensive experiments across various planning domains demonstrate that SimPlan
significantly outperforms existing LLM-based planners. | [
-0.4916340410709381,
-0.71439528465271,
0.5898169279098511,
0.3367151618003845,
0.04038023576140404,
0.3225021958351135,
-0.2727038562297821,
-0.2750661075115204,
0.722165584564209,
0.37854263186454773,
-0.8878553509712219,
-0.3066750168800354,
-0.09507746994495392,
-0.0495721809566021,
-0.3739393353462219,
0.4780981242656708,
-0.32487964630126953,
0.14638149738311768,
-0.2315170168876648,
0.2007928192615509,
-0.4795485734939575,
-0.24171119928359985,
-0.5212571620941162,
-0.42076537013053894,
0.39643168449401855,
0.5653173923492432,
0.9083711504936218,
0.5028674602508545,
0.18349000811576843,
0.3529583513736725,
-0.21685834228992462,
0.3486558794975281,
-0.3460863530635834,
-0.25343117117881775,
-0.11979275941848755,
-0.4490661025047302,
-0.5805642008781433,
-0.15658046305179596,
0.40516430139541626,
1.1175038814544678,
-0.1289348304271698,
0.13407683372497559,
-0.390550822019577,
0.5027393698692322,
-0.8550775051116943,
0.25572723150253296,
-0.5146971344947815,
0.2733634412288666,
0.05807312950491905,
-0.11535391211509705,
-0.17389634251594543,
-0.16858357191085815,
0.17301374673843384,
-0.5951353907585144,
-0.03886520117521286,
-0.04331548511981964,
0.15967366099357605,
0.10556610673666,
-0.25709691643714905,
-0.2701719105243683,
-1.3533766269683838,
0.7310545444488525,
-0.6213341355323792,
0.13190500438213348,
0.3337286114692688,
0.548978865146637,
-0.43281370401382446,
-0.6500517725944519,
-0.9459800124168396,
-0.1876278817653656,
-0.08833645284175873,
0.16968725621700287,
-0.07200770080089569,
0.29077228903770447,
0.5791056752204895,
0.2857765853404999,
-0.7315772771835327,
0.2664472460746765,
-0.4340463876724243,
-0.10802370309829712,
0.887569785118103,
0.2506798207759857,
0.48330530524253845,
0.03045651875436306,
-0.3671559691429138,
-0.02919723093509674,
-0.5837332010269165,
-0.05934733897447586,
0.3100501298904419,
0.1651684045791626,
-0.03774423897266388,
0.9628168344497681,
-0.4744788408279419,
0.619776725769043,
-0.561926543712616,
-0.3878367245197296,
-0.28877514600753784,
-0.3552761673927307,
-0.5043870210647583,
-0.04221176356077194,
0.49238553643226624,
0.3001737892627716,
0.5593968629837036,
-0.037092965096235275,
-0.365005761384964,
0.3402385711669922,
-0.04125692695379257,
-0.35622578859329224,
-0.09862875193357468,
0.5101540684700012,
-0.2179848700761795,
0.07129381597042084,
-0.4665418565273285,
-0.585389256477356,
-0.23585814237594604,
-0.4098128378391266,
0.41324368119239807,
-0.5755333304405212,
-0.4532257318496704,
0.5275717973709106,
-0.20248378813266754,
0.39620065689086914,
0.4262472093105316,
-0.8780521154403687,
0.7046293020248413,
0.8029923439025879,
0.4458097219467163,
0.0063287727534770966,
-0.5982983708381653,
-0.06705150008201599,
0.29941466450691223,
-0.4726916551589966,
1.1659657955169678,
-0.38860177993774414,
-0.8284499049186707,
0.26560166478157043,
-0.603371262550354,
-0.03769322857260704,
-0.4649306535720825,
0.6597923636436462,
-0.248155876994133,
0.13950888812541962,
-0.43439415097236633,
-0.6798139214515686,
-0.25277024507522583,
0.2598281800746918,
-0.863556981086731,
0.7494246363639832,
-0.01772923953831196,
-0.47637832164764404,
0.49919283390045166,
-0.9157745838165283,
-0.6119359731674194,
0.4001224637031555,
-0.3619109094142914,
0.029674801975488663,
-0.13531236350536346,
0.1004575863480568,
0.2841484546661377,
-0.2859104871749878,
0.2903754711151123,
-0.01019294373691082,
-0.383564829826355,
0.22686515748500824,
0.03170670568943024,
0.6761150360107422,
0.15635761618614197,
-0.2058383822441101,
0.5361874103546143,
-0.6473139524459839,
0.22446635365486145,
0.22311288118362427,
-0.29570797085762024,
-0.11897801607847214,
0.4442616105079651,
0.19423732161521912,
0.20731300115585327,
0.3107597827911377,
-0.3532908260822296,
0.49684447050094604,
-0.3496723771095276,
0.23868677020072937,
0.448637992143631,
-0.35612574219703674,
0.7679070830345154,
-0.689479649066925,
0.7185230255126953,
-0.8493423461914062,
0.32187744975090027,
-0.10813919454813004,
-0.34867486357688904,
-0.9633823037147522,
-0.09068842232227325,
0.062164463102817535,
0.6680278182029724,
-0.7486698627471924,
0.23181378841400146,
-0.30244794487953186,
-0.5906596183776855,
0.09272238612174988,
0.014127884991466999,
0.20349009335041046,
-0.08194467425346375,
0.16820192337036133,
0.01667744480073452,
-0.6347123384475708,
-1.0192396640777588,
-0.296596497297287,
-0.15992523729801178,
0.4007364511489868,
-0.13273286819458008,
0.4630091190338135,
-0.08710762113332748,
0.9779870510101318,
-0.4460752010345459,
-0.1138530820608139,
-1.134839653968811,
0.11051727086305618,
-0.10889528691768646,
0.16148176789283752,
0.48018932342529297,
-1.090790867805481,
-0.3118113875389099,
-0.1065661609172821,
-0.6470336318016052,
-0.062133003026247025,
-0.2977299690246582,
0.002975730923935771,
-0.11657846719026566,
0.5211805105209351,
-0.9110515117645264,
0.511810302734375,
0.521365761756897,
-0.11439578235149384,
0.6848714351654053,
-0.2703322768211365,
-0.3629264235496521,
-0.8858547806739807,
0.01025429554283619,
-0.07651162147521973,
-0.04244149476289749,
-0.9032337069511414,
0.06564129143953323,
0.10237090289592743,
-0.3712889552116394,
-0.4859668016433716,
0.6856249570846558,
-0.7213931083679199,
-0.4368874132633209,
-0.5720637440681458,
-0.07216687500476837,
-0.2740359306335449,
0.33185699582099915,
0.23264667391777039,
0.7529429197311401,
0.3812960386276245,
-0.6125807762145996,
0.26144659519195557,
0.3231113851070404,
-0.2677193582057953,
0.20565226674079895,
-0.3183647096157074,
-0.00014110155461821705,
-0.06506487727165222,
0.41837334632873535,
-0.7859172821044922,
-0.4664950370788574,
-0.06854522228240967,
-0.19165226817131042,
0.21390798687934875,
0.11016175895929337,
-0.6459074020385742,
-0.6444268822669983,
-0.35973313450813293,
0.32452332973480225,
0.3551158308982849,
-0.2113221138715744,
1.223762035369873,
0.509883463382721,
-0.3212057054042816,
-0.2638464868068695,
-0.5335687398910522,
0.22415192425251007,
-0.08342984318733215,
-0.8632186651229858,
0.3960936367511749,
-0.07324688136577606,
-0.669042706489563,
0.0018926662160083652,
-0.05371454730629921,
-0.09410248696804047,
0.12623068690299988,
0.19207856059074402,
0.1109057292342186,
-0.0464651919901371,
-0.32363200187683105,
0.0234941765666008,
-0.2443644404411316,
0.1171729564666748,
0.09485320746898651,
0.8574479222297668,
0.322055459022522,
-0.4700399935245514,
-0.5081272125244141,
0.7105653882026672,
0.7625207304954529,
-0.4612104296684265,
0.4416259229183197,
-0.16134288907051086,
-0.4556526839733124,
-0.7445177435874939,
-0.5590130686759949,
0.2209223061800003,
-0.5059831142425537,
0.26540932059288025,
-0.4131741523742676,
-0.4164896607398987,
0.3772079348564148,
-0.6743295788764954,
0.2408255636692047,
0.08001065254211426,
0.40645286440849304,
-0.09510300308465958,
0.8261381983757019,
1.1363552808761597,
0.1776226907968521,
0.3167168200016022,
-0.47715869545936584,
0.4139884412288666,
-0.5051813721656799,
-0.453637033700943,
-0.3576057553291321,
-0.61046302318573,
-0.3960045874118805,
-0.6376118063926697,
0.3415571451187134,
0.06966502219438553,
0.09152109175920486,
0.40252360701560974,
0.18115289509296417,
0.5585231781005859,
0.5588526129722595,
-0.4008607864379883,
0.37607601284980774,
-0.30400344729423523,
-0.10210776329040527,
0.1882316917181015,
-0.7046843767166138,
-0.738832414150238,
0.8838559985160828,
0.053706541657447815,
0.7158034443855286,
-0.05508287623524666,
0.5845207571983337,
0.015581556595861912,
0.06441359221935272,
-0.8908409476280212,
1.1842628717422485,
0.1551128476858139,
-0.40116679668426514,
-0.415607750415802,
-0.028401125222444534,
-0.7058374285697937,
0.17827443778514862,
-0.3752695918083191,
-0.6997549533843994,
-0.00128364865668118,
-0.048327647149562836,
-0.31711140275001526,
0.5480518341064453,
-0.7652673721313477,
0.5136844515800476,
-0.7340167164802551,
0.1344723254442215,
-0.5239769220352173,
-0.19690504670143127,
0.3105851113796234,
-0.15282553434371948,
0.2857763171195984,
-0.29871320724487305,
-0.10956530272960663,
0.48034393787384033,
-0.254441499710083,
0.6009945273399353,
0.048485953360795975,
0.16338297724723816,
0.06329048424959183,
0.42535531520843506,
0.5222259759902954,
-0.522122859954834,
-0.12267325073480606,
-0.4004814028739929,
-0.23247317969799042,
-0.4263346791267395,
-0.6431295871734619,
0.6138169765472412,
-0.3864209055900574,
-0.4629637897014618,
-0.30157792568206787,
-0.9451622366905212,
-0.5590707659721375,
0.15188030898571014,
-0.02931978739798069,
0.0744125247001648,
-0.748642086982727,
-0.47940537333488464,
0.3506767451763153,
-0.5855374336242676,
0.882651686668396,
0.5395591855049133,
-0.717668890953064,
-0.08860218524932861,
0.4770105481147766,
0.27762722969055176,
0.5231340527534485,
0.3158416152000427,
0.19556641578674316,
-0.13177350163459778,
-0.7099283337593079,
-0.4107753038406372,
0.33697620034217834,
-0.5930142998695374,
0.26317116618156433,
-0.5942641496658325,
-0.4456009268760681,
-0.31478166580200195,
-0.4854986071586609,
-0.44085678458213806,
-0.546794593334198,
0.5388352274894714,
-0.26685085892677307,
-0.05304710939526558,
1.059942603111267,
-0.09654244035482407,
0.31199541687965393,
-0.2181447595357895,
0.22302751243114471,
0.2668024003505707,
-0.10918981581926346,
-0.25028806924819946,
0.39064252376556396,
0.1244058832526207,
-0.15162858366966248,
-0.094784215092659,
-0.7459291815757751,
0.5822117328643799,
-0.10771288722753525,
0.8509117960929871,
0.26946163177490234,
0.04025512933731079,
0.5989485383033752,
-0.415204793214798,
0.6299003958702087,
-0.05097494274377823,
-0.7247480154037476,
0.8364972472190857,
-0.32799032330513,
0.27712318301200867,
0.43444475531578064,
0.6774231195449829,
-0.3881101608276367,
-0.02347269468009472,
-0.628971517086029,
-0.9279336333274841,
0.3820071518421173,
0.23756404221057892,
0.09549570083618164,
0.375882625579834,
0.11854233592748642,
0.015685364603996277,
0.2751895785331726,
-0.8121054768562317,
-0.381642609834671,
0.5888522863388062,
0.31470662355422974,
-0.08063486218452454,
-0.49328503012657166,
-0.2338533103466034,
-0.24845722317695618,
0.20563004910945892,
0.014360811561346054,
0.19901050627231598,
-0.1319722980260849,
0.03860896825790405,
-0.2636988162994385,
0.2421022206544876,
0.7739060521125793,
1.0114744901657104,
-0.013554154895246029,
-0.03178711235523224,
0.41500163078308105,
-0.15835730731487274,
-0.16983595490455627,
0.1867987960577011,
-0.41234534978866577,
-0.012533241882920265,
0.6014633178710938,
0.4750717282295227,
0.30107298493385315,
-0.9558106660842896,
0.41404616832733154,
-0.05414027348160744,
-0.42771080136299133,
-0.5800362229347229,
0.13314993679523468,
0.26776713132858276,
0.20311512053012848,
0.22577430307865143,
-0.07945798337459564,
0.10441838949918747,
-0.8428050875663757,
-0.13102394342422485,
0.35110804438591003,
-0.09553246200084686,
-0.18356606364250183,
0.14782804250717163,
0.21860581636428833,
-0.7458848357200623,
0.17078343033790588,
-0.1952119767665863,
-0.6978337168693542,
0.5665383338928223,
0.6725459694862366,
0.798780620098114,
-0.2170078456401825,
0.3897559344768524,
0.08892623335123062,
0.5155764222145081,
-0.08293738216161728,
1.0653831958770752,
0.020520078018307686,
-0.7203752398490906,
-0.777070939540863,
-0.6573546528816223,
-0.48668965697288513,
0.1887427270412445,
-0.18656830489635468,
0.44309288263320923,
-0.7403905987739563,
0.22872772812843323,
-0.0007586368010379374,
0.0489656999707222,
-0.5784290432929993,
0.0816582515835762,
0.16831855475902557,
1.4795140027999878,
-0.9419415593147278,
0.6655150055885315,
1.0671730041503906,
-0.22674638032913208,
-1.135912299156189,
0.24785920977592468,
0.27964237332344055,
-0.8353895545005798,
0.650124728679657,
0.04212195798754692,
-0.32049646973609924,
-0.29353901743888855,
-0.4014992415904999,
-0.8461594581604004,
1.0609461069107056,
0.3120872378349304,
-0.5300894379615784,
-0.2736664414405823,
0.46244797110557556,
0.3625050187110901,
-0.24337585270404816,
-0.014738191850483418,
0.5823764801025391,
0.7386026978492737,
0.12641185522079468,
-1.3338412046432495,
-0.27929651737213135,
-0.12219113856554031,
-0.003943221643567085,
0.4092443585395813,
-0.5845546722412109,
0.8339796662330627,
-0.29314926266670227,
-0.5078334212303162,
0.28781858086586,
0.530392050743103,
-0.01760169304907322,
0.4439670741558075,
0.5959324836730957,
0.6547467112541199,
0.6843896508216858,
0.11734840273857117,
1.2913835048675537,
-0.0727076306939125,
-0.08805333077907562,
1.0353517532348633,
-0.6264384984970093,
1.0183805227279663,
0.2965659499168396,
-0.14680421352386475,
0.2824326157569885,
0.35869014263153076,
0.5544698238372803,
0.4658937454223633,
0.4632422924041748,
-0.5223910808563232,
-0.3223092257976532,
-0.1732388734817505,
-0.010629966855049133,
0.7501660585403442,
0.4193386733531952,
0.15929573774337769,
-0.5231517553329468,
0.10595368593931198,
0.0755813866853714,
0.4584363102912903,
-0.4517216682434082,
0.6237474083900452,
0.13624905049800873,
-0.6775117516517639,
0.012587815523147583,
-0.022452929988503456,
0.3388386070728302,
-0.7378591299057007,
0.04067973420023918,
-0.19904476404190063,
0.24160782992839813,
-0.08060377836227417,
-0.8236377835273743,
0.44471895694732666,
-0.21786774694919586,
0.09625115990638733,
-0.35993894934654236,
0.7177309989929199,
-0.1575162559747696,
-0.5271459221839905,
0.587197482585907,
0.8491987586021423,
-0.14832466840744019,
0.004280265420675278,
-0.6174867153167725,
0.09466703981161118,
-0.1990479826927185,
0.17377319931983948,
0.1784178614616394,
0.5502874851226807,
-0.3088061809539795,
1.0080461502075195,
0.6925152540206909,
0.38586825132369995,
0.09680201858282089,
-0.013775191269814968,
1.0666232109069824,
-0.9026864171028137,
-0.4636777937412262,
-0.6305385828018188,
0.4361651539802551,
-0.22802700102329254,
-0.3246356248855591,
0.6301741003990173,
0.8936977386474609,
0.9311196804046631,
0.18904051184654236,
0.7482723593711853,
0.009762490168213844,
0.48357778787612915,
-0.6174623966217041,
0.28262045979499817,
-0.3447563946247101,
0.4129657447338104,
-0.2025199830532074,
-1.0613019466400146,
-0.3789078891277313,
0.5951252579689026,
-0.6468058824539185,
-0.14782457053661346,
0.6464577913284302,
0.7656171917915344,
-0.09985362738370895,
0.15448787808418274,
0.5217136144638062,
-0.10795910656452179,
0.3224830627441406,
0.5842124819755554,
1.371259331703186,
0.19498485326766968,
0.2091684639453888,
-0.44204026460647583,
-0.4472435712814331,
-0.010195949114859104,
-0.8307042121887207,
-0.8555977940559387,
-0.5095914602279663,
0.029443172737956047,
0.13923917710781097,
-0.0066072274930775166,
1.0472252368927002,
0.7626468539237976,
-0.4289458990097046,
-0.7418009042739868,
-0.12556378543376923,
-0.10804425925016403,
0.016958629712462425,
-0.10462062060832977,
0.022653453052043915,
-0.13540181517601013,
-0.58209228515625,
0.7891531586647034,
0.5380850434303284,
0.0806042030453682,
-0.6538606286048889,
-0.08119182288646698,
-0.449558824300766,
0.17510324716567993,
0.49191468954086304,
0.6188063025474548,
-0.6665084362030029,
0.1871137022972107,
-0.043405335396528244,
0.014804022386670113,
-0.40722423791885376,
1.2063902616500854,
-0.6271206140518188,
0.33710595965385437,
0.37373319268226624,
0.5300809741020203,
0.5733869075775146,
-0.2717204689979553,
0.9896636009216309,
-0.2933574914932251,
0.363190233707428,
0.47832199931144714,
0.5316459536552429,
0.11815951019525528,
-0.1664230078458786,
0.5796794891357422,
-0.27878043055534363,
-0.46921148896217346,
-0.5114028453826904,
0.4972981810569763,
-1.2168103456497192,
-0.5435343980789185,
1.2615572214126587,
0.42969590425491333,
-0.20554819703102112,
-0.06986397504806519,
-0.5491799712181091,
-0.19427135586738586,
0.04060383141040802,
0.5021921396255493,
0.39989519119262695,
-0.5163876414299011,
0.11393755674362183,
-0.7829670310020447,
0.6095002293586731,
0.3164285719394684,
-0.8844039440155029,
-0.05051737651228905,
0.5622830986976624,
0.06809976696968079,
0.45049089193344116,
1.0088903903961182,
0.34913361072540283,
0.26481735706329346,
-0.006803906988352537,
0.12499327957630157,
0.16353614628314972,
-0.48014596104621887,
0.16026745736598969,
0.10058650374412537,
0.2856425642967224,
0.17719227075576782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15399v1 | ChatGPT in Linear Algebra: Strides Forward, Steps to Go | 2024-02-18T07:35:01 | 2024-02-18T07:35:01 | Eli Bagno, Thierry Dana-Picard, Shulamit Reches | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | As soon as a new technology emerges, the education community explores its
affordances and the possibilities to apply it in education. In this paper, we
analyze sessions with ChatGPT around topics in basic Linear Algebra. We reflect
the process undertaken by the ChatGPT along the recent year in our area of
interest, emphasising the vast improvement that has been done in grappling with
Linear Algebra problems. In particular, the question whether this software can
be a teaching assistant or even somehow replace the human teacher, is
addressed. As of the time this paper is written, the answer is generally
negative. For the small part where the answer can be positive, some reflections
about an original instrumental genesis are given.
Communication with the software gives the impression to talk to a human, and
sometimes the question is whether the software understands the question or not.
Therefore, the reader's attention is drawn to the fact that ChatGPT works on a
statistical basis and not according to reflection and understanding. | [
-0.4873693585395813,
-0.8192447423934937,
0.6489567160606384,
0.18307943642139435,
-0.05758900195360184,
0.46953168511390686,
-0.012647542171180248,
-0.33266597986221313,
0.16020824015140533,
0.031474966555833817,
-0.433804452419281,
0.07307758182287216,
-0.8487095832824707,
-0.5266438126564026,
-0.6653802394866943,
1.02493155002594,
-0.22410257160663605,
0.2944357395172119,
-0.23020310699939728,
-0.016466049477458,
-0.893670916557312,
-0.38461771607398987,
-1.2170121669769287,
-0.3604529798030853,
0.3607248365879059,
0.557553768157959,
0.9828109741210938,
0.20985865592956543,
0.6970027685165405,
0.296296089887619,
0.01736629195511341,
-0.48271819949150085,
-0.5518764853477478,
-0.006216701120138168,
0.35713350772857666,
-0.5781154036521912,
-0.5615169405937195,
0.12183617055416107,
0.41719523072242737,
1.0658525228500366,
-0.10216016322374344,
0.3141753375530243,
0.4474563002586365,
0.9348571300506592,
0.06940298527479172,
0.2461269646883011,
-0.19320741295814514,
0.31616124510765076,
-0.02755807340145111,
0.010599439963698387,
-0.16783063113689423,
-0.6011731028556824,
0.2775056064128876,
-0.4908653795719147,
0.3886791467666626,
-0.13765785098075867,
0.6095306277275085,
0.06310243159532547,
-0.3833559453487396,
-0.615748405456543,
-1.0718388557434082,
0.7070384621620178,
-0.1598353534936905,
0.5927941203117371,
0.1607046127319336,
0.7187689542770386,
-0.44139236211776733,
-0.8564628958702087,
-0.20345303416252136,
-0.30769678950309753,
0.24939152598381042,
0.08077431470155716,
-0.18153919279575348,
0.11785820126533508,
0.3850044310092926,
0.533282995223999,
-0.555464506149292,
-0.6816297769546509,
-1.0711394548416138,
-0.1441144198179245,
0.4156205952167511,
-0.21068456768989563,
0.4953923523426056,
0.19492121040821075,
-0.5243493318557739,
-0.08799995481967926,
-0.7201413512229919,
0.04827055707573891,
0.28792867064476013,
-0.013302666135132313,
0.17882971465587616,
0.4040515720844269,
0.3565870225429535,
0.6349758505821228,
-0.1934906393289566,
0.12195135653018951,
-0.24613060057163239,
-0.08184069395065308,
-0.08713389188051224,
0.006044188980013132,
0.1979520171880722,
0.01874985173344612,
0.27291274070739746,
-0.16572201251983643,
-0.13497012853622437,
0.3281708061695099,
0.31327444314956665,
-0.5153236389160156,
-0.7421579360961914,
-0.08130137622356415,
-0.3249376714229584,
-0.1434430480003357,
-0.017635473981499672,
-0.6157673001289368,
-0.3692389726638794,
-0.8315829634666443,
0.9731271266937256,
-0.5365469455718994,
0.10137556493282318,
0.002124325605109334,
0.19407816231250763,
0.292892187833786,
0.8273533582687378,
-0.7184067964553833,
0.6422857046127319,
0.9116441011428833,
0.790834903717041,
0.12263944745063782,
-0.011375426314771175,
-0.4494490623474121,
-0.5466485619544983,
-0.25782257318496704,
0.7848610877990723,
-0.4940030574798584,
-0.6633781790733337,
-0.24796263873577118,
-0.516308069229126,
0.17119260132312775,
-0.28370654582977295,
0.5422664284706116,
-0.4482269585132599,
0.579012930393219,
-0.4533447027206421,
-0.6855670213699341,
-0.20007765293121338,
0.20480071008205414,
-0.11205611377954483,
1.0777490139007568,
-0.066444031894207,
-0.3344809412956238,
0.15238450467586517,
-0.6472357511520386,
0.10345606505870819,
0.04763898253440857,
-0.20626701414585114,
-0.21489045023918152,
-0.010595458559691906,
-0.021785268560051918,
-0.12509267032146454,
0.017528530210256577,
-0.10265379399061203,
0.019060494378209114,
-0.6462457776069641,
0.3917255997657776,
-0.48882395029067993,
0.6331331729888916,
0.3348773121833801,
0.05282220244407654,
-0.3140961527824402,
-0.6572362780570984,
0.05152842774987221,
-0.3003203272819519,
-0.43091657757759094,
-0.09656377136707306,
0.18309131264686584,
-0.13098633289337158,
0.17772667109966278,
0.41245293617248535,
-0.5885607004165649,
0.6212712526321411,
-0.10550529509782791,
0.023769663646817207,
0.9780967831611633,
0.010551296174526215,
0.49384087324142456,
-0.24048642814159393,
0.8693838119506836,
-0.5685184597969055,
0.4857690632343292,
-0.12107446789741516,
-0.9203703999519348,
-1.0399247407913208,
0.3856201469898224,
0.5611741542816162,
0.5570253729820251,
-0.5197867155075073,
-0.31579574942588806,
0.06170879304409027,
-0.38138246536254883,
-0.3012068569660187,
0.18990282714366913,
0.3857739567756653,
0.3911222517490387,
0.2690412700176239,
-0.44645676016807556,
-0.7424280643463135,
-0.5091884136199951,
-0.11939697712659836,
-0.42935627698898315,
-0.18120147287845612,
0.21558649837970734,
0.04213933274149895,
0.1930173635482788,
0.9038560390472412,
-0.7806224226951599,
-0.14503586292266846,
0.10801324993371964,
0.2081070989370346,
0.4042912721633911,
0.475477933883667,
0.23644240200519562,
-0.5424191355705261,
-0.8060991764068604,
-0.13343526422977448,
-0.5339943766593933,
-0.020617453381419182,
-0.028013071045279503,
-0.37411412596702576,
-0.551383376121521,
0.736757755279541,
-0.196013942360878,
0.4573977589607239,
0.31841573119163513,
-0.47287818789482117,
0.2794685661792755,
-0.4321581721305847,
0.017660506069660187,
-0.8358890414237976,
-0.17521131038665771,
-0.35784581303596497,
-0.12696075439453125,
-0.9005987048149109,
-0.039691489189863205,
-0.4104247987270355,
-0.6789098978042603,
-0.05973120033740997,
0.34117668867111206,
-0.3450750708580017,
-0.5567509531974792,
-0.48123764991760254,
0.5236486792564392,
-0.5598429441452026,
0.36412036418914795,
-0.40008318424224854,
0.8402233719825745,
0.7467218041419983,
-0.5866226553916931,
0.3444836437702179,
0.3538917005062103,
0.1637822389602661,
0.6848300695419312,
-0.6148470044136047,
0.5343625545501709,
-0.22283820807933807,
-0.06962481886148453,
-1.0982451438903809,
0.15427091717720032,
0.4185205399990082,
-1.0500108003616333,
0.21169179677963257,
-0.41956576704978943,
-0.016417670994997025,
-0.2555990219116211,
-0.15245383977890015,
-0.12340640276670456,
0.7683228254318237,
-0.34131360054016113,
0.40296047925949097,
0.2060548961162567,
-0.19819557666778564,
-0.6021989583969116,
-0.22896873950958252,
0.3268875181674957,
0.1180763840675354,
-0.9379562735557556,
-0.3549119830131531,
-0.14006370306015015,
-0.5648546814918518,
-0.07361838221549988,
-0.21098031103610992,
-0.3069410026073456,
0.05698896944522858,
0.21763946115970612,
0.3837912678718567,
-0.4043930768966675,
0.5418083071708679,
-0.3594140410423279,
-0.3793528079986572,
0.21125778555870056,
-0.2707826793193817,
0.4821522831916809,
-0.3496064245700836,
-0.6582432389259338,
0.24718931317329407,
0.34647056460380554,
-0.13930732011795044,
0.10012342035770416,
0.13488508760929108,
0.5450410842895508,
-0.0962439775466919,
0.14999088644981384,
-0.07843922078609467,
-0.17311155796051025,
-0.49737170338630676,
0.1498197317123413,
0.02649824135005474,
-0.5696151852607727,
0.3131076395511627,
0.04725818336009979,
0.31668856739997864,
-0.012284989468753338,
0.21300099790096283,
-0.32590946555137634,
0.7864061594009399,
0.6713654398918152,
0.12290177494287491,
0.7511698007583618,
-0.2705833613872528,
0.32189059257507324,
-0.5307121872901917,
0.01067187450826168,
-0.4859248399734497,
-0.6928614377975464,
-0.5667003989219666,
-0.31752192974090576,
0.5708456635475159,
0.09095712006092072,
-0.13209769129753113,
0.45978695154190063,
-0.5290476083755493,
0.4975101947784424,
0.5517182350158691,
0.19986985623836517,
0.22988608479499817,
-0.2558203637599945,
0.4890698492527008,
-0.14471836388111115,
-0.48712748289108276,
-0.46958592534065247,
1.0335078239440918,
0.310147762298584,
0.8405880331993103,
0.5242101550102234,
0.9050999283790588,
0.37774524092674255,
0.4615776538848877,
-0.8186496496200562,
0.7382962703704834,
-0.00034366518957540393,
-0.7288010120391846,
-0.24795125424861908,
-0.06670188158750534,
-1.2045519351959229,
0.2723768651485443,
0.03567488491535187,
-0.9482382535934448,
0.15686319768428802,
0.42587172985076904,
-0.17765355110168457,
0.25092804431915283,
-1.2200652360916138,
0.8297548294067383,
-0.18985120952129364,
-0.27327147126197815,
-0.12485812604427338,
-0.5382111072540283,
0.3217969238758087,
0.04560467600822449,
0.08590523898601532,
0.031407564878463745,
0.12915562093257904,
0.700272262096405,
-0.4856773316860199,
0.5443958640098572,
-0.3217555284500122,
0.05516912415623665,
0.44540199637413025,
0.42729711532592773,
0.1902327984571457,
-0.18131530284881592,
0.4531281292438507,
-0.6527838110923767,
0.07359906286001205,
-0.7270181179046631,
-0.7603009939193726,
0.5582476854324341,
-0.7671557664871216,
-0.6082457304000854,
-0.6236319541931152,
-0.3612859845161438,
-0.5434796214103699,
0.09345215559005737,
-0.26897022128105164,
0.5770896673202515,
-0.28738290071487427,
-0.001853574882261455,
0.8621165156364441,
-0.25486260652542114,
0.3768244683742523,
0.17248095571994781,
-0.7771621346473694,
0.24035704135894775,
1.2955255508422852,
0.14623364806175232,
0.3785008192062378,
0.12059159576892853,
0.2082999050617218,
-0.027171442285180092,
-0.201356902718544,
-0.3713121712207794,
-0.004460396710783243,
-1.0573952198028564,
0.2243606448173523,
-0.17521631717681885,
-0.08360867947340012,
-0.023467043414711952,
-0.24640513956546783,
-0.38154545426368713,
-0.545099675655365,
-0.22391463816165924,
0.08370406925678253,
0.2753710150718689,
1.0556970834732056,
0.00395134137943387,
0.4522004723548889,
-0.7437418699264526,
-0.0697401911020279,
0.8469533920288086,
0.1782846450805664,
-0.07279805839061737,
-0.5008288621902466,
-0.1721184253692627,
0.05233251675963402,
-0.7062948942184448,
-0.6633566617965698,
0.05600455030798912,
0.21641860902309418,
0.2879941165447235,
0.275348424911499,
-0.4190394878387451,
0.7266097664833069,
-0.3683660924434662,
0.7851927280426025,
0.07001093775033951,
-0.9035794138908386,
0.27804967761039734,
-0.19003354012966156,
0.06343015283346176,
0.2835429906845093,
0.20206327736377716,
-1.107075810432434,
-0.35823237895965576,
-0.8358840346336365,
-0.4506659507751465,
0.5439593195915222,
0.5468800067901611,
0.30205464363098145,
0.6718810200691223,
0.2314290851354599,
-0.07594640552997589,
0.042496636509895325,
-0.48429417610168457,
-0.37351247668266296,
-0.21437212824821472,
-0.009282063692808151,
-0.05133065581321716,
-0.1402789056301117,
0.2145698368549347,
-0.11739252507686615,
0.5488600730895996,
0.2411242127418518,
0.8991279602050781,
-0.05795534700155258,
-0.09224123507738113,
0.009770368225872517,
0.5634332895278931,
0.6572574973106384,
1.0823394060134888,
-0.2700711190700531,
0.1281566321849823,
0.10949172079563141,
-1.05311119556427,
0.23279349505901337,
0.05961008369922638,
-0.126856729388237,
0.038080405443906784,
0.1250493824481964,
0.6013113856315613,
0.3353862762451172,
-0.15253786742687225,
0.4498956501483917,
-0.1660458892583847,
-0.20473617315292358,
-0.7613924145698547,
0.23549087345600128,
-0.02175978757441044,
0.20996485650539398,
0.4059264063835144,
0.3641199469566345,
0.26092636585235596,
-0.6311461925506592,
0.39279085397720337,
0.19483931362628937,
-0.7541321516036987,
-0.42238864302635193,
0.7136034965515137,
0.10893716663122177,
-0.6880249381065369,
0.350328654050827,
-0.09928492456674576,
-0.5532551407814026,
0.482492595911026,
0.23843875527381897,
0.7743254899978638,
-0.06557897478342056,
0.28589069843292236,
0.3875201642513275,
0.20049253106117249,
0.10635973513126373,
0.3073902130126953,
-0.15514183044433594,
-0.5352438688278198,
-0.34933415055274963,
-0.18923291563987732,
-0.8990481495857239,
-0.35638704895973206,
-0.31865206360816956,
0.39873260259628296,
-0.3557310700416565,
0.1456271857023239,
0.17114092409610748,
0.09650542587041855,
-0.19476480782032013,
-0.09007056057453156,
0.3489847779273987,
0.6075875759124756,
-0.6457493901252747,
0.9288132190704346,
0.7962813973426819,
-0.4903939366340637,
-0.7690787315368652,
-0.06497225910425186,
0.11387816071510315,
-0.8098188638687134,
0.864408016204834,
-0.3627012073993683,
-0.06977897137403488,
-0.023604324087500572,
-0.7150083780288696,
-0.8075907230377197,
0.8548736572265625,
0.2713247239589691,
-0.13374702632427216,
0.025318095460534096,
0.024182042106986046,
0.6930225491523743,
0.36246058344841003,
0.24490685760974884,
0.21121908724308014,
0.29487964510917664,
0.37660855054855347,
-0.8440812826156616,
-0.6355379819869995,
-0.09327882528305054,
-0.054247450083494186,
0.5550513863563538,
-0.2985236942768097,
1.4143189191818237,
0.11779289692640305,
-0.20647743344306946,
0.06576425582170486,
0.7226659655570984,
-0.32824206352233887,
0.41953298449516296,
0.3503437638282776,
0.10898494720458984,
0.5980873703956604,
-0.1746939867734909,
1.0200326442718506,
-0.1425534039735794,
0.6329332590103149,
0.8377546668052673,
0.15882417559623718,
0.5204495787620544,
0.6378771662712097,
-1.0557172298431396,
0.1831892430782318,
0.3674556016921997,
0.1902157962322235,
-0.09145763516426086,
0.19000177085399628,
-0.8206645846366882,
-0.13989801704883575,
0.40880998969078064,
-0.39857053756713867,
0.38748475909233093,
0.3984566926956177,
-0.12145514041185379,
-0.681376039981842,
0.15435874462127686,
0.2493906021118164,
0.06382939219474792,
-0.5352720022201538,
0.4142906367778778,
0.22742179036140442,
-0.5846539735794067,
0.204998180270195,
-0.17258021235466003,
0.10040055215358734,
-0.6178761720657349,
-0.4580935835838318,
-0.36360880732536316,
0.46492743492126465,
-0.12802712619304657,
-0.8747596144676208,
0.24627389013767242,
-0.12086739391088486,
0.3723987936973572,
-0.4329698383808136,
1.0300884246826172,
-0.14746633172035217,
-0.41450202465057373,
-0.33582738041877747,
0.5387925505638123,
0.5591914653778076,
0.20515143871307373,
-0.6667943000793457,
-0.16582205891609192,
0.27861395478248596,
0.19581203162670135,
0.4284058213233948,
0.2549373209476471,
-0.00914052128791809,
0.7244971394538879,
0.5247126817703247,
-0.17176619172096252,
0.3378855586051941,
-0.39841437339782715,
0.8944888114929199,
-0.47396087646484375,
-0.2715967297554016,
-0.44749781489372253,
0.013963235542178154,
0.025328503921628,
-0.39908650517463684,
1.1165953874588013,
0.46518898010253906,
0.587859034538269,
0.03538297116756439,
0.43172547221183777,
-0.3219391107559204,
0.7290686964988708,
-0.49639928340911865,
0.3937131464481354,
-0.06260751932859421,
0.39201322197914124,
-0.40214264392852783,
-1.021355152130127,
-0.15043756365776062,
0.7483018040657043,
-0.4336327016353607,
0.04387020692229271,
0.5373791456222534,
0.6102504134178162,
-0.33982768654823303,
0.1966702789068222,
0.49217161536216736,
-0.1213264912366867,
0.4155152440071106,
0.5378888249397278,
0.9352725744247437,
-0.6278423070907593,
0.8212215304374695,
-0.18442778289318085,
-0.18567770719528198,
-0.06805114448070526,
-0.34518784284591675,
-0.5143691301345825,
-0.4632178544998169,
-0.22795124351978302,
-0.39918166399002075,
0.05000157654285431,
1.0746833086013794,
0.225175142288208,
-0.6952282190322876,
-0.5320760011672974,
-0.1626407504081726,
0.0810290277004242,
-0.12397827953100204,
-0.15209625661373138,
0.478297621011734,
-0.49435511231422424,
-0.7319327592849731,
0.21749693155288696,
-0.04140095040202141,
0.048096999526023865,
-0.6011340618133545,
-0.1689055860042572,
-0.21700851619243622,
0.023195084184408188,
0.6060556173324585,
0.7668678164482117,
-0.07646159082651138,
-0.6458014249801636,
0.2518520951271057,
0.033428605645895004,
0.46473678946495056,
1.0144160985946655,
-0.6873975992202759,
0.7947799563407898,
0.4603882133960724,
0.5448569059371948,
0.6869068741798401,
-0.014245245605707169,
0.510906994342804,
-0.8049260973930359,
0.26721128821372986,
0.19755882024765015,
0.21288247406482697,
0.13522039353847504,
0.0371234305202961,
0.503045916557312,
0.3755330741405487,
-0.9892453551292419,
-0.5890288352966309,
0.19997695088386536,
-1.1217082738876343,
0.16648130118846893,
0.7998639345169067,
-0.09648943692445755,
-0.12487652897834778,
-0.43166211247444153,
-0.948952317237854,
-0.02543949894607067,
-0.34478676319122314,
0.7653451561927795,
0.8746874928474426,
-0.6059011816978455,
-0.2978026866912842,
-1.1428139209747314,
0.38115394115448,
0.2958102822303772,
-0.5371139049530029,
-0.3851684331893921,
0.40307745337486267,
0.06252424418926239,
0.2917155623435974,
0.743519127368927,
-0.1335679292678833,
0.3982051610946655,
0.3493523597717285,
0.05670229345560074,
0.16443391144275665,
0.20040903985500336,
-0.22369757294654846,
-0.08899590373039246,
0.5843220949172974,
-0.5515827536582947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11485v2 | LEIA: Facilitating Cross-lingual Knowledge Transfer in Language Models with Entity-based Data Augmentation | 2024-02-18T07:24:34 | 2024-06-06T05:30:59 | Ikuya Yamada, Ryokan Ri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Adapting English-based large language models (LLMs) to other languages has
become increasingly popular due to the efficiency and potential of
cross-lingual transfer. However, existing language adaptation methods often
overlook the benefits of cross-lingual supervision. In this study, we introduce
LEIA, a language adaptation tuning method that utilizes Wikipedia entity names
aligned across languages. This method involves augmenting the target language
corpus with English entity names and training the model using left-to-right
language modeling. We assess LEIA on diverse question answering datasets using
7B-parameter LLMs, demonstrating significant performance gains across various
non-English languages. The source code is available at
https://github.com/studio-ousia/leia. | [
-0.4605283737182617,
-0.8164975643157959,
0.43242931365966797,
-0.0038532435428351164,
-0.2730489671230316,
-0.013113370165228844,
-0.25685250759124756,
-0.6860901713371277,
0.5055107474327087,
0.7048994898796082,
-0.46337127685546875,
-0.46649110317230225,
-0.4399412274360657,
0.19016288220882416,
-0.11571580916643143,
0.9872917532920837,
-0.19534464180469513,
0.46259260177612305,
-0.08940315991640091,
-0.09927134215831757,
-0.6490306258201599,
0.08207563310861588,
-0.8944915533065796,
-0.042175259441137314,
0.6856372952461243,
0.7473247051239014,
0.6668530106544495,
0.5874910354614258,
0.30397599935531616,
0.1801030933856964,
0.2768429219722748,
0.4981256425380707,
-0.5694984793663025,
0.05682961642742157,
-0.8190362453460693,
-0.7889413833618164,
-0.35911524295806885,
-0.43364378809928894,
0.8217361569404602,
0.8857259154319763,
0.14434075355529785,
0.3146146833896637,
-0.42192697525024414,
0.539644718170166,
-0.7465025186538696,
0.1825246959924698,
-0.8616180419921875,
-0.18668116629123688,
-0.043197039514780045,
-0.23244662582874298,
-0.33924490213394165,
0.003622058080509305,
0.2504519522190094,
-1.1855978965759277,
-0.10937894135713577,
0.1771383285522461,
0.9931186437606812,
0.35210660099983215,
-0.41745004057884216,
-0.36715734004974365,
-0.8064450621604919,
0.710205614566803,
-0.5378348231315613,
0.8204467296600342,
0.19073106348514557,
0.16856476664543152,
0.03763763606548309,
-0.3160780072212219,
-0.6225919127464294,
0.04275234416127205,
0.11498913913965225,
0.0921042189002037,
-0.0033068435732275248,
-0.13716687262058258,
0.08518879115581512,
-0.07182484865188599,
-0.3555999994277954,
0.4397033751010895,
-0.4516441226005554,
0.15945711731910706,
0.6252321600914001,
-0.2887752652168274,
0.6486939191818237,
-0.002489148173481226,
-0.5300714373588562,
-0.05771820247173309,
-0.7418781518936157,
-0.0016329847276210785,
0.3636437654495239,
0.4067937731742859,
-0.22204242646694183,
0.5316789746284485,
-0.02615039423108101,
0.6902403831481934,
0.26937055587768555,
-0.20114651322364807,
0.09078016877174377,
0.012239762581884861,
-0.212458074092865,
0.22826863825321198,
0.12621894478797913,
0.6043878793716431,
0.5470489263534546,
-0.47447240352630615,
-0.013098216615617275,
-0.4050615131855011,
0.26005852222442627,
-0.5375185012817383,
0.049326442182064056,
-0.12076618522405624,
-0.0491209477186203,
0.15301349759101868,
0.14735999703407288,
-0.8671560287475586,
-0.23801890015602112,
-0.4197520315647125,
0.5184440016746521,
-0.17254310846328735,
-0.41626203060150146,
0.15836845338344574,
-0.11531493067741394,
0.4466850459575653,
0.31036576628685,
-1.0876120328903198,
0.12250271439552307,
0.6900262832641602,
0.4598969519138336,
-0.43382886052131653,
-0.5727113485336304,
-0.5895475149154663,
0.591833233833313,
-0.7383949160575867,
0.7803865671157837,
-0.4378170967102051,
-0.2121778130531311,
-0.05762825906276703,
0.46569907665252686,
-0.29703080654144287,
-0.37009772658348083,
0.391515851020813,
-1.026038646697998,
0.3761003315448761,
-0.2092706561088562,
-0.7409210205078125,
-0.433133989572525,
0.01881672628223896,
-0.8015638589859009,
0.8738012909889221,
0.2693115770816803,
-0.619747519493103,
0.323845773935318,
-0.5212351083755493,
-0.4271118938922882,
-0.02105429768562317,
0.08622526377439499,
-0.12155544012784958,
-0.04900004714727402,
0.4694388508796692,
0.2508452236652374,
-0.4372304677963257,
0.24411052465438843,
-0.3454917073249817,
-0.16224423050880432,
-0.08221177756786346,
-0.002488466678187251,
0.7228754758834839,
0.11433050781488419,
-0.13686370849609375,
-0.14323092997074127,
-0.604991614818573,
-0.1307799071073532,
0.05546163395047188,
-0.07486332207918167,
-0.6565653681755066,
-0.40648725628852844,
-0.08363061398267746,
0.06720318645238876,
0.26824358105659485,
-0.2280215322971344,
0.02380986325442791,
-0.5260182619094849,
-0.2361213117837906,
0.4824758470058441,
0.0737975537776947,
1.030408501625061,
-0.3814677894115448,
0.8447274565696716,
0.2146313339471817,
-0.21683640778064728,
-0.1778118908405304,
-0.5393022894859314,
-1.00153386592865,
0.034932754933834076,
0.5364526510238647,
0.9433985352516174,
-1.257845401763916,
0.42802420258522034,
-0.6501864194869995,
-0.5216824412345886,
-0.692879319190979,
0.5334596037864685,
0.10242053866386414,
0.9272832274436951,
0.519895613193512,
-0.36837083101272583,
-0.6030277609825134,
-1.0082027912139893,
-0.27326080203056335,
-0.36798304319381714,
-0.04246979579329491,
0.36679908633232117,
0.23439937829971313,
-0.21453219652175903,
0.6008166670799255,
-0.10447090119123459,
-0.21518073976039886,
-0.1086629331111908,
-0.26497882604599,
-0.0013054623268544674,
0.16288380324840546,
0.6229924559593201,
-0.6317098140716553,
-0.5746397376060486,
0.32061272859573364,
-0.6361663341522217,
-0.3146647810935974,
-0.3977932631969452,
-0.4611300528049469,
0.559386670589447,
0.5364574790000916,
-0.549339234828949,
-0.11966829746961594,
0.7462704181671143,
-0.29442837834358215,
0.11785408854484558,
-0.219815194606781,
0.17933060228824615,
-1.5958634614944458,
0.022217843681573868,
0.02117352932691574,
-0.2956709861755371,
-0.6822007298469543,
0.10914751887321472,
0.2766752541065216,
0.09726167470216751,
-0.5596752166748047,
0.9371370673179626,
-0.7759358882904053,
-0.2462518811225891,
-0.2086782455444336,
0.45227259397506714,
0.1845182329416275,
0.3023541271686554,
0.2756965756416321,
0.8228557705879211,
0.8070135712623596,
-0.49318110942840576,
0.39599668979644775,
0.2366274744272232,
-0.05112243816256523,
0.8015409111976624,
-0.24712695181369781,
0.106745146214962,
-0.2652187645435333,
0.06353931874036789,
-0.5064788460731506,
-0.13925832509994507,
0.19490331411361694,
-0.2513729929924011,
0.4928828179836273,
-0.3246026039123535,
0.10667181015014648,
0.11574038863182068,
-0.22285127639770508,
0.07996004819869995,
0.1415475755929947,
-0.7767720818519592,
0.9800958633422852,
0.7263373732566833,
-0.5593022704124451,
-0.7031951546669006,
-0.6732497811317444,
0.29529640078544617,
-0.43347471952438354,
-0.7471672296524048,
0.4801008403301239,
0.03289596736431122,
-0.390215665102005,
0.049270499497652054,
0.08626914769411087,
-0.12394209206104279,
0.03319525346159935,
-0.15483032166957855,
0.5328515768051147,
-0.540359377861023,
0.4346805810928345,
0.3819880485534668,
0.04900715500116348,
0.07263854891061783,
-0.3137957751750946,
0.0014075555372983217,
0.3114130198955536,
-0.06852523982524872,
0.029355628415942192,
0.3499108552932739,
0.35583528876304626,
-0.041394736617803574,
0.8023054003715515,
0.4898187518119812,
-0.3419750928878784,
-0.6304404139518738,
-0.45531371235847473,
-0.14323745667934418,
-0.357761025428772,
0.48915165662765503,
-0.6962078213691711,
-0.6872915625572205,
0.6132590770721436,
-0.11855876445770264,
-0.02432674914598465,
0.506581723690033,
0.5325590372085571,
0.04895729199051857,
0.5602969527244568,
0.8002281188964844,
-0.42078444361686707,
0.6466992497444153,
0.08872146159410477,
0.22906988859176636,
-0.5858478546142578,
0.11692671477794647,
-0.38318711519241333,
-0.16119498014450073,
-0.7632458209991455,
-0.8457058072090149,
0.12768110632896423,
0.3615189492702484,
0.011027705855667591,
0.3405706286430359,
-0.04913681745529175,
0.6561101078987122,
0.33914831280708313,
-0.26306191086769104,
0.48875853419303894,
-0.010763069614768028,
0.25655996799468994,
0.1036706417798996,
-0.787947416305542,
-0.42071059346199036,
1.1167067289352417,
0.4430810809135437,
0.9075961709022522,
0.2763650417327881,
0.49732840061187744,
0.017194505780935287,
0.19435171782970428,
-0.6677146553993225,
0.19259104132652283,
-0.13841105997562408,
-0.6096640825271606,
-0.49654343724250793,
-0.3196302652359009,
-0.9378153085708618,
0.06539348512887955,
-0.18108920753002167,
-0.524190366268158,
0.24029730260372162,
-0.28300440311431885,
-0.07155492156744003,
0.35364559292793274,
-0.964893102645874,
0.5371894836425781,
-0.3796769380569458,
-0.22533322870731354,
-0.11665718257427216,
-0.4943307042121887,
0.2606532871723175,
-0.476207435131073,
0.28821861743927,
-0.14586567878723145,
-0.48156440258026123,
0.7630800604820251,
0.1373417228460312,
0.491489440202713,
-0.2261805534362793,
-0.5406773090362549,
0.04857563599944115,
-0.14778223633766174,
0.6468701362609863,
0.4965640902519226,
0.02115808241069317,
0.32582685351371765,
0.14893192052841187,
-0.32878538966178894,
-0.7809824347496033,
0.9770168662071228,
-0.9073324799537659,
-0.6830414533615112,
0.01559967640787363,
-0.9033246636390686,
-0.6185871362686157,
0.27449455857276917,
-0.07118590176105499,
-0.19118565320968628,
-0.16687440872192383,
-0.12649516761302948,
0.8054091930389404,
-0.23890027403831482,
0.09767226874828339,
0.9503114223480225,
-0.5986286997795105,
-0.31882068514823914,
0.7303192019462585,
0.25243428349494934,
0.29150474071502686,
0.6301576495170593,
-0.3328549563884735,
-0.3559863865375519,
-0.2870393395423889,
-1.2363940477371216,
0.5058311820030212,
-0.8597570061683655,
-0.14383602142333984,
-0.5115275979042053,
-0.1305486559867859,
-0.598236083984375,
-0.2018136978149414,
-0.29986703395843506,
-0.6707231998443604,
-0.5230035781860352,
-0.21041998267173767,
0.4382113516330719,
0.5740509629249573,
0.1314236968755722,
-0.0705740749835968,
-0.6922668814659119,
0.6608691215515137,
0.2745339870452881,
0.31418195366859436,
-0.3734447658061981,
-0.7452367544174194,
-0.47079384326934814,
0.12294070422649384,
0.23555897176265717,
-1.0605801343917847,
0.29651105403900146,
0.49263209104537964,
0.6197540163993835,
-0.10414861887693405,
-0.10831809788942337,
0.6755366921424866,
-0.38009166717529297,
0.49630025029182434,
-0.14717139303684235,
-0.753509521484375,
0.3452402353286743,
-0.26735153794288635,
0.2092236876487732,
0.38250428438186646,
0.6287247538566589,
-0.6888910531997681,
-0.29564401507377625,
-0.41306355595588684,
-0.6665173172950745,
0.6829697489738464,
-0.37318041920661926,
0.25471019744873047,
0.22873292863368988,
0.3769751489162445,
0.24719643592834473,
-0.23893283307552338,
-0.4422599673271179,
-0.14059869945049286,
0.12993671000003815,
-0.3509606122970581,
-0.24380865693092346,
0.09513342380523682,
-0.06408944725990295,
-0.11051364243030548,
1.2332789897918701,
-0.6107418537139893,
-0.10851235687732697,
0.18968109786510468,
-0.7171486020088196,
-0.5029852390289307,
0.2497960925102234,
0.2843666672706604,
0.756620466709137,
0.21316732466220856,
-0.06271297484636307,
0.7800595760345459,
-0.2370101809501648,
-0.04105697572231293,
0.565525472164154,
-0.49230387806892395,
0.19382481276988983,
0.22684083878993988,
0.9720674753189087,
0.3240690231323242,
-0.5390541553497314,
0.05144180357456207,
-0.07201064378023148,
0.10322701185941696,
-0.11629568785429001,
0.1919441819190979,
0.45260384678840637,
0.3508533537387848,
0.31044360995292664,
-0.4820667505264282,
-0.116009421646595,
-0.37186434864997864,
0.07421693950891495,
0.37099409103393555,
-0.25807008147239685,
-0.18181848526000977,
0.48538339138031006,
0.16248391568660736,
-0.25038471817970276,
0.0751788392663002,
0.28499314188957214,
-0.11496463418006897,
0.5811099410057068,
0.5567307472229004,
0.7112183570861816,
-0.42982780933380127,
0.25412046909332275,
0.33797481656074524,
0.3154178857803345,
0.22580161690711975,
0.39016905426979065,
0.06626162678003311,
-0.9829552173614502,
-0.4768363833427429,
-0.6585185527801514,
-0.6264585256576538,
-0.12020497024059296,
-0.6768074631690979,
0.5533390045166016,
-0.11579280346632004,
0.0782889798283577,
0.32746073603630066,
0.03648974001407623,
-0.575799286365509,
0.25269749760627747,
0.3079340159893036,
1.1038471460342407,
-0.8543212413787842,
1.0772775411605835,
1.0149208307266235,
-0.3623778223991394,
-1.0475999116897583,
-0.149305522441864,
-0.40518149733543396,
-0.7891811728477478,
0.2748624086380005,
-0.2437860369682312,
-0.15483155846595764,
0.33250731229782104,
-0.07060179114341736,
-1.1208094358444214,
1.1697309017181396,
0.8216046690940857,
-0.6805253624916077,
-0.28316962718963623,
0.5205758213996887,
0.5825984477996826,
-0.6136026978492737,
0.11929687857627869,
0.6801095008850098,
0.4974807798862457,
-0.2579289376735687,
-1.0526996850967407,
-0.23494291305541992,
-0.19280046224594116,
0.11089783161878586,
0.11364556103944778,
-0.518324613571167,
0.373912513256073,
-0.21226690709590912,
-0.09139613807201385,
-0.05889245495200157,
0.6822994947433472,
0.11577244102954865,
0.18836680054664612,
0.6267698407173157,
0.6436256170272827,
0.9260357022285461,
0.1043805330991745,
0.6543682217597961,
-0.7067996859550476,
0.23217229545116425,
1.2552919387817383,
-0.46596935391426086,
0.6992365717887878,
0.7777065634727478,
0.0617002472281456,
0.7328447699546814,
0.513390302658081,
0.12096266448497772,
0.39065560698509216,
-0.1503247767686844,
-0.06291834264993668,
-0.05049412325024605,
-0.3967215418815613,
-0.2584775686264038,
0.5206188559532166,
0.3731391727924347,
-0.48849764466285706,
-0.19986893236637115,
0.10313730686903,
-0.018119169399142265,
-0.009178726933896542,
-0.46027234196662903,
0.9355654120445251,
0.09483110904693604,
-0.9972503781318665,
0.4590657949447632,
0.16088388860225677,
0.48507383465766907,
-0.4557609558105469,
-0.0011414993787184358,
-0.2746843993663788,
0.0171967763453722,
-0.09916231781244278,
-0.6955451369285583,
0.2623331844806671,
0.08482415229082108,
-0.3307335078716278,
-0.19238103926181793,
0.9475250244140625,
-0.8662752509117126,
-0.7050788998603821,
0.6845995783805847,
0.8541917204856873,
0.010915681719779968,
0.39474067091941833,
-0.7217504978179932,
-0.31547173857688904,
-0.04743076488375664,
-0.19324737787246704,
0.23327675461769104,
0.5058322548866272,
-0.4218796491622925,
0.5312661528587341,
0.6575048565864563,
0.2986700236797333,
0.2279585897922516,
0.26004233956336975,
0.6302372813224792,
-0.5253794193267822,
-0.5438717603683472,
-0.34351280331611633,
0.300547331571579,
0.1985723078250885,
-0.2624703645706177,
0.9430776238441467,
0.4861088693141937,
1.2130385637283325,
-0.09986121207475662,
0.5053138136863708,
0.23355817794799805,
0.840647280216217,
-0.7931440472602844,
0.669323205947876,
-0.5517623424530029,
0.2224092036485672,
-0.038537487387657166,
-1.0488132238388062,
-0.07387261092662811,
0.22273002564907074,
-0.3336189389228821,
0.07236400991678238,
0.43551328778266907,
1.063917636871338,
-0.11395028233528137,
0.0698525458574295,
0.4163057208061218,
0.003506643930450082,
0.06662731617689133,
0.5638459324836731,
0.49896907806396484,
-0.40008699893951416,
0.20172995328903198,
-0.33819934725761414,
0.05425625666975975,
0.05818231403827667,
-0.6481635570526123,
-0.7201498746871948,
-0.5830515027046204,
-0.19889478385448456,
-0.05527910217642784,
0.23278546333312988,
0.717991292476654,
0.7387867569923401,
-0.9477012157440186,
-0.16289685666561127,
0.16869543492794037,
0.3923013508319855,
0.13688135147094727,
-0.20193196833133698,
0.2319345623254776,
-0.3495531380176544,
-1.1157463788986206,
0.6283798217773438,
0.1941862553358078,
-0.0930146649479866,
-0.46167805790901184,
-0.30400341749191284,
-0.4920228123664856,
0.2783478796482086,
0.19824212789535522,
0.19420205056667328,
-0.5160728693008423,
-0.25811508297920227,
0.16166798770427704,
-0.1366479992866516,
0.017637111246585846,
0.4695731997489929,
-0.6806417107582092,
0.6289108395576477,
0.4459262192249298,
1.0850062370300293,
0.4427059292793274,
0.08261752128601074,
0.7026094794273376,
-0.6617454886436462,
0.1357899010181427,
0.03474893793463707,
0.3850241005420685,
0.6671111583709717,
-0.5511181950569153,
0.4976550042629242,
-0.039199069142341614,
-0.3826808035373688,
-0.5690247416496277,
-0.053713008761405945,
-0.7840099334716797,
-0.17948605120182037,
1.2043174505233765,
-0.1932460218667984,
-0.5112523436546326,
-0.23133498430252075,
-0.05658851936459541,
0.5196448564529419,
-0.12739881873130798,
0.6731334328651428,
0.7225196957588196,
0.30573517084121704,
-0.2938069999217987,
-0.5674952864646912,
0.2417704463005066,
0.648411214351654,
-1.1986664533615112,
-0.15748851001262665,
0.38439199328422546,
0.52561354637146,
0.18298755586147308,
0.3286891281604767,
0.2208414077758789,
0.5271022319793701,
-0.3903549909591675,
0.09132158756256104,
0.13172189891338348,
-0.41072073578834534,
-0.584683358669281,
-0.27169325947761536,
0.31986066699028015,
0.1395682990550995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14835v1 | MIKE: A New Benchmark for Fine-grained Multimodal Entity Knowledge Editing | 2024-02-18T07:15:03 | 2024-02-18T07:15:03 | Jiaqi Li, Miaozeng Du, Chuanyi Zhang, Yongrui Chen, Nan Hu, Guilin Qi, Haiyun Jiang, Siyuan Cheng, Bozhong Tian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multimodal knowledge editing represents a critical advancement in enhancing
the capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). Despite its
potential, current benchmarks predominantly focus on coarse-grained knowledge,
leaving the intricacies of fine-grained (FG) multimodal entity knowledge
largely unexplored. This gap presents a notable challenge, as FG entity
recognition is pivotal for the practical deployment and effectiveness of MLLMs
in diverse real-world scenarios. To bridge this gap, we introduce MIKE, a
comprehensive benchmark and dataset specifically designed for the FG multimodal
entity knowledge editing. MIKE encompasses a suite of tasks tailored to assess
different perspectives, including Vanilla Name Answering, Entity-Level Caption,
and Complex-Scenario Recognition. In addition, a new form of knowledge editing,
Multi-step Editing, is introduced to evaluate the editing efficiency. Through
our extensive evaluations, we demonstrate that the current state-of-the-art
methods face significant challenges in tackling our proposed benchmark,
underscoring the complexity of FG knowledge editing in MLLMs. Our findings
spotlight the urgent need for novel approaches in this domain, setting a clear
agenda for future research and development efforts within the community. | [
-0.6807828545570374,
-0.754730224609375,
0.556523859500885,
-0.11401982605457306,
0.10033973306417465,
0.12720905244350433,
-0.45411407947540283,
-0.4172443449497223,
-0.18349213898181915,
0.3160424530506134,
-0.593244194984436,
-0.8355127573013306,
-0.6322488188743591,
0.1481693834066391,
-0.17388784885406494,
0.7640000581741333,
-0.11868026852607727,
0.05284800007939339,
-0.24680043756961823,
-0.2715287208557129,
-0.3279084861278534,
-0.2292933464050293,
-0.7369175553321838,
0.11563269048929214,
0.9332408905029297,
0.4188637137413025,
0.7243291139602661,
0.6076505780220032,
0.5715710520744324,
0.3176119923591614,
-0.11363505572080612,
0.5384384989738464,
-0.18276983499526978,
0.17058566212654114,
-0.268562376499176,
-0.26085320115089417,
-0.7332963943481445,
-0.02118917927145958,
0.8009886741638184,
0.7532764673233032,
0.021936839446425438,
0.316690593957901,
-0.012435332871973515,
0.4937637746334076,
-1.0728744268417358,
0.3182034492492676,
-0.9466418623924255,
0.13871701061725616,
-0.35841500759124756,
-0.016529731452465057,
-0.2515338361263275,
0.04729299619793892,
0.049057308584451675,
-0.8033837080001831,
0.11777226626873016,
-0.0384521558880806,
0.5309663414955139,
0.26374614238739014,
-0.5147352814674377,
-0.058537233620882034,
-0.6292292475700378,
0.6643081903457642,
-0.6184834837913513,
0.907229483127594,
0.09657846391201019,
0.36317864060401917,
-0.2923263907432556,
-0.970289945602417,
-0.8275004029273987,
-0.2680812180042267,
0.2553287744522095,
-0.17728164792060852,
-0.21072812378406525,
0.2967749238014221,
0.4430382549762726,
0.056960780173540115,
-0.18675796687602997,
-0.031037284061312675,
-0.17064169049263,
-0.22491705417633057,
0.27636563777923584,
0.31788691878318787,
0.12286589294672012,
-0.20553745329380035,
-0.5426742434501648,
0.005453432444483042,
-0.4798573851585388,
0.23567216098308563,
0.05874192342162132,
0.2953517735004425,
0.2964448034763336,
0.850733757019043,
-0.4371834397315979,
0.7476904392242432,
-0.061054687947034836,
-0.4058307409286499,
0.3404332101345062,
-0.406215101480484,
-0.3886604309082031,
0.1214919313788414,
0.7763652801513672,
0.8847930431365967,
-0.025259513407945633,
-0.16890734434127808,
-0.2453497350215912,
-0.12948718667030334,
0.3134780824184418,
-0.7187589406967163,
-0.10571134835481644,
0.051954884082078934,
-0.44425418972969055,
-0.009473297744989395,
0.11576399207115173,
-0.8938211798667908,
-0.6093743443489075,
-0.36653241515159607,
0.5496821999549866,
-0.6606228351593018,
-0.1683206558227539,
0.11445542424917221,
-0.19717158377170563,
-0.2584599554538727,
0.6408137083053589,
-0.6597601175308228,
-0.0657048225402832,
0.8669683933258057,
0.7600137591362,
0.13206034898757935,
-0.8016229271888733,
-0.5544701218605042,
0.4873825013637543,
-0.3563885986804962,
0.704461395740509,
-0.7327185273170471,
0.07105827331542969,
-0.09498898684978485,
-0.029437625780701637,
-0.07667077332735062,
-0.6277691721916199,
0.6294130682945251,
-0.28833654522895813,
-0.2698037028312683,
-0.2545402944087982,
-0.7470355033874512,
-0.19191338121891022,
0.48417922854423523,
-0.6647932529449463,
1.124656081199646,
0.1859511435031891,
-0.7075358629226685,
0.7498589158058167,
-0.5996994972229004,
-0.12825393676757812,
-0.2512724995613098,
-0.035941846668720245,
-0.16774626076221466,
0.15210914611816406,
0.1927618682384491,
0.8195626139640808,
-0.05962616205215454,
0.358892560005188,
-0.7542645931243896,
-0.11089236289262772,
0.36330363154411316,
-0.5481815338134766,
0.1823660433292389,
0.13653771579265594,
-0.2726425230503082,
0.1070769876241684,
-1.2083799839019775,
0.0827627182006836,
-0.28105849027633667,
-0.6061677932739258,
-0.5177642703056335,
0.03612362593412399,
0.026052365079522133,
0.5301485657691956,
0.1620006561279297,
-0.4615381062030792,
0.3993667960166931,
0.20132094621658325,
0.4092015326023102,
0.5508069396018982,
-0.060112159699201584,
0.3232889175415039,
-0.1845368891954422,
0.1314786970615387,
0.4382515847682953,
0.3348442018032074,
-0.3700498044490814,
-0.37277916073799133,
-0.7533965706825256,
-0.41196268796920776,
0.5600844025611877,
0.30308541655540466,
-1.002307415008545,
0.05901867523789406,
-0.32957059144973755,
-0.6843081116676331,
-0.829039990901947,
0.41248613595962524,
0.2501319348812103,
0.5068255066871643,
0.6640959978103638,
-0.3001865744590759,
-0.5044692754745483,
-1.1310399770736694,
-0.3673384189605713,
0.06514260917901993,
-0.27167147397994995,
0.31160321831703186,
0.3703114986419678,
-0.40877407789230347,
0.8235247135162354,
-0.2138681411743164,
-0.36567771434783936,
0.046641986817121506,
0.425631046295166,
-0.3170780539512634,
0.5696004629135132,
0.5518966913223267,
-0.6530919671058655,
-0.24907003343105316,
0.04113591089844704,
-0.6719341278076172,
0.08434290438890457,
-0.25192198157310486,
-0.20591938495635986,
-0.06330171972513199,
0.6948626041412354,
-0.9461672306060791,
-0.05249941721558571,
0.5478654503822327,
-0.30143120884895325,
0.45324787497520447,
-0.19128425419330597,
0.4953247308731079,
-0.9249581694602966,
0.03122813254594803,
-0.01561391819268465,
-0.20067520439624786,
-0.6424329876899719,
0.11651255190372467,
0.45440974831581116,
0.12927860021591187,
-0.5737069845199585,
0.3993366062641144,
-0.47129353880882263,
-0.1318058967590332,
0.33031731843948364,
0.24561557173728943,
0.06932679563760757,
0.4990880787372589,
-0.283942848443985,
0.7011377811431885,
0.2556932270526886,
-0.544643223285675,
0.5131096243858337,
0.029321856796741486,
-0.6580771803855896,
0.928485631942749,
-0.1436351090669632,
0.031209997832775116,
-0.25810012221336365,
0.16776052117347717,
-0.6970686912536621,
0.030067957937717438,
0.1564362794160843,
-0.17344975471496582,
0.33915016055107117,
-0.27128905057907104,
-0.5380274653434753,
-0.008201069198548794,
-0.4612605571746826,
0.15176083147525787,
-0.4232436418533325,
-0.20734162628650665,
0.746934711933136,
0.37637537717819214,
-0.19828614592552185,
-0.7978926301002502,
-0.4930751621723175,
0.4698961079120636,
-0.13724175095558167,
-0.5642766356468201,
0.5245729088783264,
-0.1490042507648468,
-0.35187119245529175,
0.07595068216323853,
-0.14349058270454407,
-0.29191848635673523,
0.13557006418704987,
-0.03240114077925682,
0.08693479001522064,
-0.5414597988128662,
0.25443196296691895,
0.18976007401943207,
-0.06582538783550262,
-0.06598275154829025,
-0.10622891783714294,
0.20151954889297485,
0.14048978686332703,
-0.15524102747440338,
-0.3758683502674103,
0.3804641366004944,
0.9316686391830444,
-0.46073704957962036,
0.7247361540794373,
1.0041109323501587,
-0.5565312504768372,
0.08557827025651932,
-0.7830244302749634,
0.2686958312988281,
-0.3862067461013794,
0.5953710079193115,
-0.7156603336334229,
-0.7628226280212402,
0.16484782099723816,
-0.38805192708969116,
0.20701497793197632,
0.4253087341785431,
0.2961842119693756,
-0.23588578402996063,
0.771004319190979,
0.3251889646053314,
0.07281287759542465,
0.5367938876152039,
0.0079506766051054,
-0.17141366004943848,
-1.0197771787643433,
-0.261022686958313,
-0.5005655288696289,
-0.5042473077774048,
-0.4216998219490051,
-0.7844793796539307,
0.28405457735061646,
0.43168777227401733,
-0.028468549251556396,
0.1374344378709793,
0.03521858900785446,
0.3256874978542328,
0.5290889739990234,
0.22088277339935303,
0.5441159605979919,
-0.54135662317276,
-0.33480304479599,
-0.2561653256416321,
-0.5323292016983032,
-0.5068948268890381,
1.1471099853515625,
0.17989592254161835,
0.48324915766716003,
0.14284835755825043,
0.34109559655189514,
0.3696824014186859,
0.2920919954776764,
-0.6603185534477234,
0.5272030830383301,
-0.11673520505428314,
-0.7793776392936707,
-0.41561809182167053,
-0.3553108274936676,
-0.5902208089828491,
0.3650608956813812,
-0.7732611298561096,
-0.5144977569580078,
0.055849313735961914,
0.3208487629890442,
-0.3894445300102234,
0.5921244025230408,
-0.8990046381950378,
1.247406244277954,
0.12015677243471146,
-0.309658944606781,
-0.1911461055278778,
-0.5715571641921997,
0.28702619671821594,
-0.007828975096344948,
0.32920849323272705,
-0.5306372046470642,
-0.29753291606903076,
0.3963571786880493,
-0.15541791915893555,
0.38497596979141235,
-0.43319466710090637,
-0.101965993642807,
0.05542774125933647,
0.021466681733727455,
0.512129545211792,
0.25375914573669434,
0.1006615087389946,
0.09861141443252563,
0.09557296335697174,
-0.16221356391906738,
-0.7327229976654053,
0.6592239141464233,
-0.34305864572525024,
-0.17343510687351227,
0.13467983901500702,
-0.4001650810241699,
-0.5557950139045715,
0.18087580800056458,
-0.11218491941690445,
0.6571456789970398,
-0.3945922255516052,
0.37897759675979614,
0.7624411582946777,
-0.33612751960754395,
0.42350372672080994,
0.4197655916213989,
-0.045601747930049896,
-0.5225299596786499,
0.7106354236602783,
0.2844652831554413,
0.14918185770511627,
0.7030417919158936,
-0.24335119128227234,
-0.1357702910900116,
-0.6803936958312988,
-0.8974369168281555,
-0.22855550050735474,
-0.7096639275550842,
-0.3652839958667755,
-1.0964791774749756,
0.08101797848939896,
-0.20694999396800995,
-0.0769432783126831,
-0.6438723802566528,
-0.548766553401947,
0.017957264557480812,
0.10792162269353867,
0.01863633655011654,
0.5366309881210327,
0.06847326457500458,
-0.13235965371131897,
-0.9995043873786926,
0.5857362151145935,
0.6195797324180603,
0.6296387910842896,
-0.016035405918955803,
0.09605054557323456,
-0.3179008662700653,
0.02215045876801014,
-0.25091883540153503,
-0.7365915179252625,
-0.29558268189430237,
0.36934754252433777,
0.6206591129302979,
0.36529597640037537,
-0.01891210861504078,
1.074716329574585,
-0.8372498154640198,
0.6258559823036194,
0.06683198362588882,
-1.0748521089553833,
0.3897716999053955,
-0.26710212230682373,
0.2747695744037628,
0.7013134360313416,
0.3175278604030609,
-0.9483161568641663,
-0.5214962363243103,
-0.32311856746673584,
-0.7475219368934631,
0.5007109642028809,
0.014167613349854946,
0.003716357983648777,
0.1920652687549591,
0.2524411380290985,
0.26605039834976196,
0.563280463218689,
-0.3837697207927704,
-0.2867656350135803,
-0.1364009827375412,
-0.19101418554782867,
-0.32260194420814514,
-0.5399980545043945,
0.10553175956010818,
-0.42465853691101074,
0.6371960639953613,
-0.18356364965438843,
0.22132940590381622,
0.18000784516334534,
-0.532074511051178,
0.06650687754154205,
0.6968140006065369,
0.8970901966094971,
0.7301284670829773,
-0.25214123725891113,
0.39198291301727295,
0.4873278737068176,
-0.4768674969673157,
-0.05578836053609848,
0.2591865360736847,
-0.0006355201476253569,
0.23076511919498444,
0.36655232310295105,
0.7594451308250427,
0.8132543563842773,
-0.5564280152320862,
0.38762447237968445,
-0.25699472427368164,
-0.18223144114017487,
0.013338308781385422,
0.17214009165763855,
0.1461206078529358,
0.6159173250198364,
0.28977102041244507,
0.3995862305164337,
0.2721422016620636,
-0.44850194454193115,
0.17943055927753448,
0.377835214138031,
-0.256945937871933,
-0.18125440180301666,
0.6735591292381287,
0.170321524143219,
-0.11214489489793777,
0.28253161907196045,
-0.22624772787094116,
-0.15678143501281738,
0.04938506335020065,
0.03180450573563576,
0.5445825457572937,
-0.27799755334854126,
0.03174161538481712,
0.42156848311424255,
0.49577629566192627,
0.19153030216693878,
0.04614204913377762,
-0.1308615356683731,
-0.821523129940033,
-0.24234676361083984,
-0.60066157579422,
-0.4965387284755707,
0.28480228781700134,
-0.6151111125946045,
0.38054558634757996,
-0.5592955350875854,
-0.3991841971874237,
0.6411706209182739,
-0.08214832097291946,
-0.8484618067741394,
0.2513771057128906,
0.25341472029685974,
1.0697129964828491,
-0.18008765578269958,
0.9096626043319702,
0.849945604801178,
-0.04249301180243492,
-0.4998013973236084,
-0.25216981768608093,
0.24927149713039398,
-0.35548481345176697,
0.27474579215049744,
0.2050466686487198,
-0.029720207676291466,
0.0009347781306132674,
-0.12411896139383316,
-0.6692906022071838,
1.1496604681015015,
0.5466750264167786,
-0.7200421690940857,
-0.1571671962738037,
0.13181522488594055,
0.23482832312583923,
-0.2827964723110199,
0.29532095789909363,
0.7191146612167358,
0.7851172089576721,
-0.29905495047569275,
-1.0013843774795532,
-0.29109495878219604,
-0.16561123728752136,
0.16623620688915253,
0.2935977578163147,
-0.45295584201812744,
0.8838863968849182,
-0.11629927903413773,
0.09292015433311462,
-0.1335408091545105,
0.6112541556358337,
-0.14485880732536316,
0.4901466369628906,
0.6462602019309998,
0.6207516193389893,
0.7182124257087708,
-0.23235858976840973,
0.3930356800556183,
-0.35457557439804077,
0.41111719608306885,
1.2929058074951172,
-0.21014395356178284,
1.0227068662643433,
0.5098825097084045,
-0.15892836451530457,
0.29840824007987976,
0.3580663204193115,
-0.0659480020403862,
0.31025245785713196,
-0.09570722281932831,
-0.48939672112464905,
-0.30938640236854553,
-0.03238394856452942,
-0.30750685930252075,
0.8605910539627075,
0.31739649176597595,
-0.36161836981773376,
-0.20399779081344604,
0.13985934853553772,
0.423261821269989,
-0.20793244242668152,
-0.5744399428367615,
0.7999761700630188,
-0.29065847396850586,
-0.4541008770465851,
0.09872797876596451,
0.2984655201435089,
0.7864025831222534,
-0.5599852204322815,
-0.06190181151032448,
0.08916322886943817,
0.2820607125759125,
-0.07500149309635162,
-0.8420669436454773,
0.24872757494449615,
0.14368700981140137,
-0.23669832944869995,
-0.18432427942752838,
0.595819354057312,
-0.7047739028930664,
-0.32639673352241516,
0.2719171643257141,
0.4962088465690613,
-0.2904350161552429,
-0.3468850255012512,
-0.7513856887817383,
0.1467312127351761,
-0.2960800230503082,
-0.27705609798431396,
0.24401973187923431,
0.9692386388778687,
0.2917192578315735,
0.6335881948471069,
0.534306526184082,
-0.13401657342910767,
0.27221086621284485,
-0.019313419237732887,
0.7937759757041931,
-0.7747507691383362,
-0.20447763800621033,
-0.815931499004364,
0.6883535981178284,
-0.07731537520885468,
-0.508173406124115,
0.6051719188690186,
0.7552064657211304,
1.2231334447860718,
-0.14588011801242828,
0.6075286865234375,
-0.06809398531913757,
0.3222065269947052,
-0.8737826347351074,
0.8087559938430786,
-0.7447251081466675,
-0.21396371722221375,
-0.7402737140655518,
-0.9513155817985535,
-0.2345283031463623,
0.3355192244052887,
0.25924408435821533,
-0.09469752758741379,
0.6839366555213928,
0.7162448167800903,
-0.1818029135465622,
-0.03604276850819588,
0.6769856214523315,
0.32112225890159607,
0.1493247151374817,
0.4972962737083435,
0.9647935032844543,
-0.35722726583480835,
0.5748275518417358,
-0.48447054624557495,
0.1451641172170639,
-0.05655664578080177,
-0.8417460322380066,
-0.9047427773475647,
-0.7869580388069153,
-0.19376319646835327,
0.018321048468351364,
0.03118845820426941,
1.3701117038726807,
0.6122798323631287,
-0.6301307678222656,
0.2558525800704956,
0.5505453944206238,
0.01320969220250845,
-0.48764222860336304,
-0.16729755699634552,
-0.11115416139364243,
-0.23556791245937347,
-0.8562602400779724,
0.39453399181365967,
0.5925339460372925,
0.03652280196547508,
-0.23394392430782318,
0.1324816197156906,
-0.26002100110054016,
-0.20826371014118195,
0.9738056659698486,
-0.21176761388778687,
-0.7725761532783508,
-0.41662198305130005,
-0.27711206674575806,
-0.22733712196350098,
0.2844182252883911,
0.9683265686035156,
-0.6020506620407104,
0.5555664300918579,
-0.04482806846499443,
0.7598475217819214,
0.24151240289211273,
-0.37813547253608704,
0.2957119345664978,
-0.8297457098960876,
-0.07702312618494034,
-0.07451459765434265,
0.5546603202819824,
0.39390355348587036,
-0.12946367263793945,
0.23534871637821198,
0.22814486920833588,
-0.25087252259254456,
-0.6590524315834045,
-0.1055980697274208,
-0.9724902510643005,
-0.10063093155622482,
0.8609217405319214,
-0.40252751111984253,
0.06615067273378372,
-0.2412428855895996,
-0.4017728269100189,
0.35287776589393616,
-0.4326059818267822,
0.6629993915557861,
0.9784979224205017,
0.20471559464931488,
-0.35311952233314514,
-0.846556544303894,
0.5840886235237122,
0.010575096122920513,
-0.9976687431335449,
0.2799331843852997,
0.8154131174087524,
0.2951522469520569,
0.01682164892554283,
0.4376099109649658,
0.12416107952594757,
0.28840863704681396,
0.061808597296476364,
0.14250744879245758,
-0.4381823241710663,
-0.625823438167572,
-0.1674910932779312,
0.3556559085845947,
0.07408446818590164,
-0.0059701488353312016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11481v1 | DictLLM: Harnessing Key-Value Data Structures with Large Language Models for Enhanced Medical Diagnostics | 2024-02-18T07:10:02 | 2024-02-18T07:10:02 | YiQiu Guo, Yuchen Yang, Ya Zhang, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Structured data offers a sophisticated mechanism for the organization of
information. Existing methodologies for the text-serialization of structured
data in the context of large language models fail to adequately address the
heterogeneity inherent in key-value structured data. These methods are not
ideal and frequently result in larger input sizes and poor adaptability to
input changes. In this paper, we introduce DictLLM, an innovative framework
designed to improve the modeling of key-value structured data, like medical
laboratory reports, for generating medical diagnoses. DictLLM integrates three
key components: (1) group positional encoding to maintain permutation
invariance, (2) hierarchical attention bias to capture the inherent bias in
structured data, and (3) an optimal transport alignment layer that aligns the
embedding generated by the dictionary encoder with the LLM, thereby producing a
sequence of fixed-length virtual tokens. We carry out experiments using various
LLM models on a comprehensive real-world medical laboratory report dataset for
automatic diagnosis generation, our findings illustrate that DictLLM
significantly outperforms established baseline methods and few-shot GPT-4
implementations in terms of both Rouge-L and Knowledge F1 scores. Furthermore,
our evaluation of the framework's scalability and robustness, through a series
of experiments, underscores its exceptional capability in accurately modeling
the complex key-value data structure of medical dictionary data. | [
0.17462454736232758,
-0.793622612953186,
0.8683372139930725,
0.19363515079021454,
-0.346842885017395,
0.20827198028564453,
0.08154192566871643,
-0.2950395941734314,
-0.03394542261958122,
-0.004116942174732685,
-0.1151302382349968,
-0.8920534253120422,
-0.6264451742172241,
0.24194560945034027,
-0.7305638194084167,
0.973154604434967,
0.09392648935317993,
0.1722860485315323,
-0.34462472796440125,
-0.019544409587979317,
-0.166733980178833,
-0.8855111002922058,
-0.13663889467716217,
-0.20773550868034363,
0.3084045350551605,
0.055083490908145905,
0.850171685218811,
0.9683297276496887,
0.85770183801651,
0.22365562617778778,
-0.2523193955421448,
0.20885193347930908,
-0.3811039626598358,
0.05140627920627594,
0.09092316031455994,
-0.268363356590271,
-0.7531378865242004,
-0.022846654057502747,
0.8169173002243042,
1.056033968925476,
-0.42213860154151917,
-0.1439531296491623,
-0.15986038744449615,
0.6247696280479431,
-0.17549744248390198,
0.3214775025844574,
-0.4808708429336548,
-0.00013913805014453828,
-0.07121830433607101,
-0.04589533060789108,
-0.2921237051486969,
-0.25788697600364685,
-0.01885654218494892,
-0.7268999218940735,
0.11383552104234695,
-0.15033097565174103,
0.6926389932632446,
0.5860316157341003,
-0.3221381604671478,
-0.3745260536670685,
-0.6072345972061157,
0.3641427755355835,
-0.8257659673690796,
0.33732694387435913,
0.17802879214286804,
0.24537546932697296,
-0.24755480885505676,
-0.9037624001502991,
-0.40834495425224304,
-0.036192458122968674,
-0.20117126405239105,
0.19534200429916382,
0.15474911034107208,
0.033857543021440506,
0.05210455134510994,
0.45906177163124084,
-0.4855278730392456,
0.05466293543577194,
-0.1816873699426651,
0.041478704661130905,
0.49264803528785706,
0.6345057487487793,
0.2416253536939621,
0.04118119552731514,
-0.4405335485935211,
0.0982832983136177,
-0.7223817706108093,
-0.2863391935825348,
-0.1463385373353958,
0.3171129524707794,
-0.1393756866455078,
0.2357056885957718,
-0.060621559619903564,
0.9580187797546387,
0.2990342378616333,
-0.4469958543777466,
0.4457210600376129,
-0.6103990077972412,
-0.2909463346004486,
0.2914904057979584,
0.643557071685791,
0.41327065229415894,
-0.23317137360572815,
-0.1676589697599411,
-0.21594679355621338,
-0.09208757430315018,
0.15211476385593414,
-1.0436813831329346,
-0.3547106683254242,
0.4135527014732361,
-0.6745724678039551,
-0.7194210886955261,
-0.1611437201499939,
-0.5152344703674316,
-0.5137419104576111,
-0.1403418332338333,
0.3025318682193756,
-0.6160546541213989,
-0.2277613878250122,
0.35871538519859314,
-0.019778944551944733,
-0.1987047791481018,
0.2821069657802582,
-0.8873702883720398,
0.522274374961853,
0.44322335720062256,
0.8400222063064575,
-0.3039468824863434,
0.16252104938030243,
-0.6666909456253052,
0.14303439855575562,
-0.3990940451622009,
0.5560864806175232,
-0.5778319239616394,
-0.4028396010398865,
-0.21376144886016846,
-0.043801940977573395,
0.17091867327690125,
-0.7383493185043335,
0.07158291339874268,
-0.2428596168756485,
-0.2104981392621994,
-0.06431844085454941,
-0.6295226216316223,
0.27374106645584106,
0.35810044407844543,
-0.5358093976974487,
0.9344914555549622,
0.5551320910453796,
-0.6542752385139465,
0.6243470311164856,
-0.5323740839958191,
-0.5624616146087646,
0.31467363238334656,
-0.40322068333625793,
-0.5750400424003601,
0.09581489115953445,
0.17047464847564697,
0.6436355113983154,
-0.3763803243637085,
0.6744502186775208,
-0.1211543008685112,
-0.3769904673099518,
0.36189526319503784,
-0.22538436949253082,
0.46221280097961426,
0.13836726546287537,
0.0305138248950243,
-0.13253547251224518,
-1.0051230192184448,
-0.2665439546108246,
0.1772536188364029,
-0.5532812476158142,
-0.46696892380714417,
0.2871086299419403,
-0.07936356216669083,
0.15615145862102509,
0.13804493844509125,
-0.5597000122070312,
0.3804173171520233,
-0.7660958170890808,
0.7154057025909424,
0.4594038724899292,
-0.2219420224428177,
0.3994430899620056,
-0.42346593737602234,
0.3221971094608307,
0.7088018655776978,
0.2145049273967743,
-0.02840670943260193,
-0.29741567373275757,
-0.09039739519357681,
-0.5595980882644653,
0.28669068217277527,
0.44756993651390076,
-0.3359840214252472,
0.126842200756073,
-0.2706143260002136,
-0.11190058290958405,
-0.49110883474349976,
-0.04628470167517662,
0.012589840218424797,
0.9911652207374573,
0.5777775645256042,
-0.05821565166115761,
-0.32968494296073914,
-0.665852963924408,
0.22641339898109436,
-0.20209062099456787,
-0.14773423969745636,
0.05092969536781311,
0.09974122792482376,
-0.7336277365684509,
0.8161224126815796,
-0.6155053377151489,
-0.25575706362724304,
-0.12267686426639557,
-0.09565155953168869,
0.7594555616378784,
0.26521384716033936,
0.5359981656074524,
-0.6366733908653259,
-0.4279913902282715,
0.023286523297429085,
-0.525092363357544,
-0.2946667969226837,
0.048946842551231384,
0.11191178858280182,
-0.051131971180438995,
0.3233506381511688,
-0.27276214957237244,
0.37281274795532227,
0.3933664858341217,
-0.4292624890804291,
0.3774278163909912,
-0.4009111225605011,
0.14546014368534088,
-1.2122905254364014,
-0.007066602353006601,
-0.2378147393465042,
-0.5675809383392334,
-0.680030882358551,
-0.16728687286376953,
0.3408760726451874,
0.15950603783130646,
-0.2570173740386963,
0.35726457834243774,
-0.297207772731781,
0.3041660487651825,
-0.08493249118328094,
-0.07702549546957016,
0.20449431240558624,
-0.08271085470914841,
0.09483160823583603,
0.3837209939956665,
0.47135376930236816,
-0.6345042586326599,
0.36612287163734436,
0.4165785610675812,
-0.12518441677093506,
0.6425555348396301,
-0.724908173084259,
-0.022322162985801697,
-0.1426740139722824,
-0.06554540991783142,
-0.993494987487793,
-0.1802327185869217,
-0.0570017546415329,
-0.17957712709903717,
0.6992908716201782,
-0.11094912886619568,
-0.6837788820266724,
-0.2820091247558594,
-0.2818305790424347,
0.499990314245224,
0.7144280672073364,
-0.48666468262672424,
0.3209511339664459,
0.4925113320350647,
-0.002960083307698369,
-0.37696373462677,
-0.721001386642456,
-0.11177323013544083,
-0.2718997895717621,
-0.5873302221298218,
0.696773111820221,
-0.2679559588432312,
-0.3066919445991516,
0.037350691854953766,
-0.28380364179611206,
-0.3913049101829529,
0.2969530522823334,
0.3508288562297821,
0.48681414127349854,
-0.1715310662984848,
0.41666051745414734,
0.24827280640602112,
-0.014083138667047024,
0.07901626825332642,
-0.17708054184913635,
0.41159915924072266,
-0.04135555773973465,
-0.2180798202753067,
0.03247708082199097,
0.29035329818725586,
0.598353385925293,
0.12221960723400116,
0.7462201714515686,
0.14961877465248108,
-0.49367690086364746,
-0.39208266139030457,
-0.015629706904292107,
-0.0850255936384201,
-0.4218262732028961,
0.5093132853507996,
-0.24896275997161865,
-0.7808641195297241,
0.3430348336696625,
-0.29603877663612366,
-0.04283076152205467,
0.33783653378486633,
0.8184862732887268,
-0.36321955919265747,
1.1685967445373535,
0.36394327878952026,
-0.08843030780553818,
-0.10420281440019608,
0.025240855291485786,
0.28897303342819214,
-0.6103038787841797,
-0.1677248179912567,
-0.24991375207901,
-0.16066372394561768,
-0.08913061022758484,
-0.49356845021247864,
0.7608964443206787,
0.13653261959552765,
-0.03379407897591591,
-0.27367907762527466,
-0.9044266939163208,
0.23998473584651947,
-0.12977419793605804,
0.06659235805273056,
0.5768539905548096,
-0.17716319859027863,
-0.3630948066711426,
0.16845357418060303,
-0.7858210206031799,
-0.45817944407463074,
1.3673845529556274,
0.42272207140922546,
0.978106677532196,
0.011428934521973133,
0.6235777139663696,
0.1489877551794052,
0.4851119816303253,
-0.9229951500892639,
0.08225683867931366,
-0.54048752784729,
-0.22826378047466278,
-0.1503666192293167,
-0.3098662793636322,
-0.8507454991340637,
-0.05081702768802643,
0.050338827073574066,
-0.21141137182712555,
0.08394172787666321,
0.36311888694763184,
-0.6567012667655945,
-0.08488281816244125,
-0.4733773469924927,
0.5952759385108948,
-0.16518741846084595,
-0.038274362683296204,
0.1275734156370163,
-0.8197821974754333,
0.3718850612640381,
-0.42331576347351074,
0.4817148745059967,
-0.034975048154592514,
0.042932912707328796,
0.5571356415748596,
-0.8656015396118164,
0.7583019733428955,
-0.10137637704610825,
-0.24556627869606018,
-0.14362528920173645,
-0.03233342990279198,
0.3017404079437256,
0.5013842582702637,
-0.07501178979873657,
0.30306127667427063,
0.5069152116775513,
-0.014618313871324062,
-0.334170401096344,
0.6440127491950989,
-0.614508867263794,
-0.31070175766944885,
-0.429412841796875,
-0.833067774772644,
-0.28747302293777466,
0.06640547513961792,
0.11786456406116486,
0.7628677487373352,
-0.1605151742696762,
0.004443881567567587,
0.8383533358573914,
-0.25656431913375854,
0.21121089160442352,
0.7043887376785278,
-0.017616581171751022,
-0.08572006225585938,
0.5958617329597473,
0.19566892087459564,
0.4329105317592621,
0.5175012350082397,
0.3381310701370239,
-0.3442564010620117,
-0.7921510934829712,
-0.30877822637557983,
0.25857555866241455,
-0.6525943279266357,
-0.5155638456344604,
-0.6369658708572388,
-0.3732781410217285,
-0.4946272671222687,
-0.0828113704919815,
-0.3582105338573456,
-0.3764152526855469,
-0.4097556471824646,
-0.260159969329834,
0.6617929339408875,
0.7172819375991821,
-0.18611469864845276,
0.1309140920639038,
-0.7864214181900024,
0.6298251152038574,
0.06158647686243057,
0.2987857460975647,
-0.39371058344841003,
-0.31801289319992065,
-0.36329329013824463,
0.07495968788862228,
-0.06660747528076172,
-0.7694788575172424,
0.5301028490066528,
0.2595262825489044,
0.5638198852539062,
0.29318538308143616,
0.1804226040840149,
0.6373977661132812,
-0.7483708262443542,
0.5175279378890991,
0.0645662248134613,
-0.7990958094596863,
0.5522910356521606,
-0.027513813227415085,
0.1763632744550705,
0.3477797210216522,
0.15884196758270264,
-0.44982537627220154,
-0.6221253871917725,
-0.2805103063583374,
-0.828254222869873,
0.596781849861145,
-0.17540964484214783,
-0.24883197247982025,
-0.3323768377304077,
0.4733242392539978,
0.2439757138490677,
0.07889215648174286,
-0.3567192554473877,
-0.2824849784374237,
-0.434224396944046,
-0.9210180044174194,
0.06705059111118317,
-0.25193703174591064,
-0.3231472671031952,
-0.6529317498207092,
0.11919964849948883,
-0.20471087098121643,
0.21630452573299408,
0.7263779640197754,
-0.31869927048683167,
0.2263549119234085,
-0.013402946293354034,
0.4269949793815613,
0.6257542371749878,
-0.30080708861351013,
0.33700111508369446,
-0.11055377870798111,
-0.8562522530555725,
0.3155457377433777,
0.2160441279411316,
0.06998840719461441,
0.055124059319496155,
0.23622147738933563,
0.41569334268569946,
-0.08533081412315369,
-0.756916344165802,
0.5567236542701721,
-0.08195702731609344,
-0.4605177044868469,
-0.03464590013027191,
-0.061846740543842316,
0.3068130612373352,
0.1355232298374176,
0.3043562173843384,
-0.3924862742424011,
0.3098430931568146,
-0.34298065304756165,
0.2936265766620636,
0.2933756411075592,
-0.23013828694820404,
-0.40491265058517456,
0.8601990938186646,
0.15592730045318604,
0.0030849971808493137,
0.7416823506355286,
-0.054104432463645935,
-0.21285101771354675,
0.7029994130134583,
0.7659998536109924,
0.3437151610851288,
-0.3099444806575775,
0.140212744474411,
0.16298411786556244,
0.309765487909317,
-0.12867748737335205,
0.3467675447463989,
0.07119517028331757,
-0.8216531276702881,
-0.33828192949295044,
-0.8803955912590027,
0.011383549310266972,
0.3910914957523346,
-0.4509461522102356,
0.22737567126750946,
-0.45813265442848206,
0.006146745756268501,
-0.07899275422096252,
-0.333341121673584,
-0.5788449048995972,
0.24956892430782318,
-0.016384294256567955,
0.7965897917747498,
-0.7277543544769287,
1.02980637550354,
0.4921790659427643,
-0.17933236062526703,
-0.844100832939148,
-0.2975878417491913,
0.017597297206521034,
-0.817801833152771,
0.6771513223648071,
0.03888698294758797,
0.23439520597457886,
0.08564331382513046,
-0.27010032534599304,
-0.700510561466217,
1.1146243810653687,
0.18220534920692444,
-0.8667775988578796,
-0.0977313369512558,
0.5493068099021912,
0.5907936692237854,
-0.4545004367828369,
0.09410464763641357,
0.783555269241333,
0.30209124088287354,
0.07749234139919281,
-0.9987471103668213,
0.3070308566093445,
-0.3096049726009369,
-0.00529028894379735,
0.3939591646194458,
-0.134978786110878,
0.9492011070251465,
-0.0523458831012249,
-0.12685604393482208,
-0.1319676786661148,
-0.18903103470802307,
0.17174270749092102,
0.1777491420507431,
0.28635579347610474,
0.6733830571174622,
0.8529574871063232,
-0.08328932523727417,
1.0034019947052002,
-0.4363012909889221,
0.2311101257801056,
0.8666829466819763,
-0.5186408162117004,
0.29455703496932983,
0.45414307713508606,
-0.20110183954238892,
0.20622314512729645,
0.5542293190956116,
0.06564890593290329,
0.7465669512748718,
0.31867554783821106,
-0.1161455437541008,
-0.0644514262676239,
0.2793080508708954,
-0.5056149959564209,
0.20310236513614655,
0.6992103457450867,
-0.6060774326324463,
-0.2509787678718567,
-0.012465604580938816,
-0.253941148519516,
0.033734600991010666,
-0.26737529039382935,
0.919671356678009,
-0.0007928727427497506,
0.24381403625011444,
0.8580437302589417,
-0.10124022513628006,
0.464590460062027,
-0.46540576219558716,
-0.16871191561222076,
-0.29141271114349365,
0.16827887296676636,
-0.1728416383266449,
-0.4511216878890991,
0.5386562943458557,
-0.11312250047922134,
-0.40746480226516724,
-0.3189299404621124,
0.5881290435791016,
-0.5164461731910706,
-0.6757403612136841,
0.062100134789943695,
0.24107059836387634,
0.06588486582040787,
0.034909553825855255,
-0.35146209597587585,
0.040424346923828125,
-0.512304425239563,
0.00839957408607006,
0.3647412359714508,
0.6403858065605164,
-0.06450389325618744,
0.36717262864112854,
0.4673314690589905,
0.258247047662735,
-0.07561279088258743,
0.26872873306274414,
1.066114068031311,
-0.6142430305480957,
-0.30162790417671204,
-0.9888883233070374,
0.6185471415519714,
-0.07300597429275513,
0.019244352355599403,
0.27438199520111084,
0.6408883333206177,
0.3888663053512573,
-0.019509941339492798,
0.702672004699707,
0.15864530205726624,
0.594914972782135,
-0.3903096914291382,
1.0133010149002075,
-0.5315476059913635,
0.3037712574005127,
-0.2589185833930969,
-0.2621211111545563,
-0.4896598160266876,
0.5344251990318298,
0.22261543571949005,
-0.47237998247146606,
0.7617731690406799,
0.6572319269180298,
-0.062070224434137344,
-0.4917212128639221,
0.34228652715682983,
0.686482846736908,
0.4501725435256958,
0.7649512887001038,
0.8368276357650757,
-0.17273016273975372,
0.143140509724617,
-0.010744782164692879,
-0.4297260046005249,
-0.22728678584098816,
-0.8289167284965515,
-0.7738953828811646,
-0.5589470863342285,
-0.3671531677246094,
-0.15461958944797516,
-0.10297679901123047,
0.5332981944084167,
0.8357357978820801,
-0.5721155405044556,
0.10445301234722137,
-0.2131197303533554,
0.09414403140544891,
-0.27189433574676514,
-0.2005978226661682,
0.21163158118724823,
-0.4145794212818146,
-0.5091845989227295,
0.5770999789237976,
0.7184579372406006,
0.06440167129039764,
0.03779355064034462,
-0.012491877190768719,
0.11416664719581604,
-0.007689904421567917,
0.8199873566627502,
-0.3016121983528137,
-0.44923654198646545,
-0.13461673259735107,
0.013588976114988327,
-0.2571745812892914,
0.2989327609539032,
0.5086356401443481,
-0.9904574751853943,
0.49114686250686646,
0.2531775236129761,
0.6926063895225525,
0.3365234434604645,
0.042270611971616745,
0.5683178901672363,
-0.554798424243927,
0.20064200460910797,
0.5308629870414734,
0.24406592547893524,
0.0781223475933075,
-0.8197107911109924,
0.36119797825813293,
0.41477903723716736,
-0.3890078663825989,
-1.1025910377502441,
-0.04608103260397911,
-0.9348770380020142,
-0.45709583163261414,
1.0473583936691284,
0.10561765730381012,
-0.12056688219308853,
-0.3084437847137451,
0.01913057640194893,
0.17387813329696655,
-0.09156496077775955,
0.8863266706466675,
0.5727942585945129,
-0.1702938675880432,
0.2094884216785431,
-0.19619514048099518,
0.52524733543396,
0.010042551904916763,
-0.9333192110061646,
-0.09101643413305283,
0.6099821329116821,
0.6833925247192383,
-0.1387333869934082,
0.8804894089698792,
-0.42173218727111816,
0.17518511414527893,
-0.2492179572582245,
-0.30969223380088806,
-0.370577871799469,
-0.22617976367473602,
-0.3594558835029602,
0.15395674109458923,
-0.00031911456608213484,
-0.16050966084003448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11469v2 | A Curious Case of Searching for the Correlation between Training Data and Adversarial Robustness of Transformer Textual Models | 2024-02-18T05:58:25 | 2024-07-02T03:29:11 | Cuong Dang, Dung D. Le, Thai Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Existing works have shown that fine-tuned textual transformer models achieve
state-of-the-art prediction performances but are also vulnerable to adversarial
text perturbations. Traditional adversarial evaluation is often done
\textit{only after} fine-tuning the models and ignoring the training data. In
this paper, we want to prove that there is also a strong correlation between
training data and model robustness. To this end, we extract 13 different
features representing a wide range of input fine-tuning corpora properties and
use them to predict the adversarial robustness of the fine-tuned models.
Focusing mostly on encoder-only transformer models BERT and RoBERTa with
additional results for BART, ELECTRA, and GPT2, we provide diverse evidence to
support our argument. First, empirical analyses show that (a) extracted
features can be used with a lightweight classifier such as Random Forest to
predict the attack success rate effectively, and (b) features with the most
influence on the model robustness have a clear correlation with the robustness.
Second, our framework can be used as a fast and effective additional tool for
robustness evaluation since it (a) saves 30x-193x runtime compared to the
traditional technique, (b) is transferable across models, (c) can be used under
adversarial training, and (d) robust to statistical randomness. Our code is
publicly available at \url{https://github.com/CaptainCuong/RobustText_ACL2024}. | [
-0.5102325081825256,
-1.0674563646316528,
0.14678841829299927,
-0.2021600753068924,
0.062442999333143234,
-0.09078314900398254,
-0.3484928011894226,
-0.5230035185813904,
-0.28893178701400757,
0.3802819550037384,
-0.3096793293952942,
-0.3443213105201721,
-0.924286961555481,
-0.01684332638978958,
-0.8604718446731567,
1.2958273887634277,
0.38647276163101196,
0.13527075946331024,
0.027720417827367783,
-0.18128471076488495,
-0.40140360593795776,
-0.6222538352012634,
-0.5143676996231079,
-0.14773620665073395,
0.37874722480773926,
-0.20558731257915497,
1.3253626823425293,
0.6649691462516785,
0.7999132871627808,
0.3139341473579407,
-0.448943555355072,
0.07480067759752274,
-0.5884431004524231,
0.2978600859642029,
-0.1541990339756012,
-0.7027766108512878,
-0.29955753684043884,
-0.15569205582141876,
0.2732783854007721,
0.24698078632354736,
0.2534143328666687,
-0.017987240105867386,
0.305370956659317,
0.41030633449554443,
-0.6435791254043579,
-0.1514260470867157,
-1.2806166410446167,
-0.03536462411284447,
-0.2088947892189026,
-0.16285738348960876,
-0.5610722899436951,
-0.19992338120937347,
0.2564776837825775,
-0.5763942003250122,
0.8083682060241699,
-0.12680312991142273,
1.2332900762557983,
0.5776130557060242,
-0.26163163781166077,
-0.4522460401058197,
-0.8039700984954834,
0.663668155670166,
-0.41288313269615173,
0.17057788372039795,
0.3966580331325531,
0.41448286175727844,
-0.02215747721493244,
-0.6284520030021667,
-0.4576842784881592,
-0.24350449442863464,
-0.3387811779975891,
0.1043015643954277,
-0.4676573574542999,
-0.13692662119865417,
0.2716290354728699,
0.5295899510383606,
-0.540697455406189,
0.19036367535591125,
-0.16994206607341766,
-0.31086963415145874,
0.43112993240356445,
0.08230116218328476,
0.3078860640525818,
0.08627263456583023,
-0.5516659617424011,
-0.5649116635322571,
-0.5158193111419678,
0.20164911448955536,
0.5757352709770203,
0.42435264587402344,
-0.18180473148822784,
0.467316597700119,
0.35733604431152344,
0.419098824262619,
0.1579722911119461,
0.08475059270858765,
-0.1383070945739746,
-0.3063623011112213,
-0.21769484877586365,
-0.2569660246372223,
1.1213500499725342,
-0.037044722586870193,
0.35968461632728577,
-0.5066371560096741,
-0.20664440095424652,
0.4700922966003418,
0.6490364670753479,
-0.8073698878288269,
-0.6756740808486938,
0.041305288672447205,
-0.41065168380737305,
-0.8347427248954773,
0.1811670958995819,
-0.7269222736358643,
-0.3657684028148651,
0.008247599005699158,
0.3685621917247772,
-0.6640031337738037,
0.03517008200287819,
-0.19585341215133667,
-0.07253694534301758,
-0.056853797286748886,
-0.037940844893455505,
-1.0456575155258179,
0.15938545763492584,
0.8906369209289551,
0.6740381121635437,
-0.34323960542678833,
-0.384705126285553,
-0.45634302496910095,
-0.2509692907333374,
-0.31044888496398926,
0.5496460795402527,
-0.5124005079269409,
-0.15901070833206177,
0.19176819920539856,
0.20087005198001862,
-0.253609836101532,
-0.2986612021923065,
0.8603399395942688,
-0.7255105972290039,
0.05729978531599045,
0.07935721427202225,
-0.3265378177165985,
-0.057832442224025726,
0.44202935695648193,
-0.9545503258705139,
0.9038282036781311,
-0.0070463246665894985,
-1.1893303394317627,
0.47390443086624146,
-0.25802791118621826,
-0.6443405747413635,
-0.3822470009326935,
0.04822494089603424,
-1.0653260946273804,
-0.09136776626110077,
0.4038228690624237,
0.4519682824611664,
-0.17659109830856323,
0.41474664211273193,
-0.8244290947914124,
-0.4313426911830902,
0.6833785176277161,
-1.051479458808899,
1.023758053779602,
0.24208244681358337,
-0.3175289034843445,
0.051590874791145325,
-0.9765468835830688,
-0.23741808533668518,
0.16732709109783173,
-0.26155805587768555,
-0.31473469734191895,
-0.23710136115550995,
0.14131052792072296,
-0.08003131300210953,
0.18757891654968262,
-0.18063156306743622,
-0.027175933122634888,
-0.3991631865501404,
0.2829863131046295,
0.5850021243095398,
-0.13571514189243317,
0.44744765758514404,
-0.3142983019351959,
0.45196333527565,
-0.0944727212190628,
0.19648143649101257,
-0.17771579325199127,
-0.3480677902698517,
-0.5196348428726196,
-0.3858426809310913,
0.43790194392204285,
0.5722372531890869,
-0.5493588447570801,
0.5957205295562744,
-0.20834407210350037,
-0.7733634114265442,
-0.5526240468025208,
0.12214288115501404,
0.4724956452846527,
0.3390871584415436,
0.4916456937789917,
-0.07096008211374283,
-0.4754005968570709,
-0.7320454120635986,
-0.35433444380760193,
-0.18693125247955322,
-0.21431443095207214,
0.02484007738530636,
0.48458990454673767,
-0.269726425409317,
0.6902868747711182,
-0.2811488211154938,
-0.1542133092880249,
-0.0576733723282814,
0.14732807874679565,
0.035577353090047836,
0.35563045740127563,
0.7752047777175903,
-0.9236141443252563,
-0.4084256589412689,
-0.04175707697868347,
-0.7060624361038208,
0.26844120025634766,
-0.22351491451263428,
-0.14738331735134125,
-0.05078904330730438,
0.24975858628749847,
-0.503424882888794,
0.4022320806980133,
0.5751028060913086,
-0.17692212760448456,
0.4135279953479767,
-0.25591421127319336,
-0.04274395480751991,
-0.9757784605026245,
0.2014552652835846,
0.0039890231564641,
0.02966318465769291,
-0.6300736665725708,
0.3338239789009094,
0.14798344671726227,
-0.15639345347881317,
-0.06936725974082947,
0.00712493946775794,
-0.05328676849603653,
0.23127391934394836,
-0.11603716760873795,
0.04011509567499161,
0.11830538511276245,
0.331103652715683,
-0.23344756662845612,
0.8754904866218567,
0.774223268032074,
-0.49996206164360046,
0.1654893010854721,
0.5495137572288513,
-0.1711742877960205,
0.38628003001213074,
-0.8344309329986572,
0.028022971004247665,
0.05236309766769409,
0.030020250007510185,
-0.8140678405761719,
-0.07107589393854141,
-0.09371116757392883,
-0.751499354839325,
0.5964483618736267,
-0.1894412338733673,
-0.3701072335243225,
-0.18568167090415955,
-0.33024948835372925,
-0.012833802029490471,
0.2341109663248062,
-0.6771016120910645,
0.3710367679595947,
0.3440074622631073,
0.21565255522727966,
-0.6313297748565674,
-0.8602190613746643,
0.009801778942346573,
-0.4084013104438782,
-0.6868103742599487,
0.12666653096675873,
-0.01930321753025055,
0.003784543601796031,
-0.11210296303033829,
0.09047591686248779,
-0.14469698071479797,
0.6139832139015198,
0.3488055467605591,
0.49184250831604004,
-0.16808083653450012,
-0.19459353387355804,
-0.3543100953102112,
-0.1567308008670807,
0.20058979094028473,
0.051130373030900955,
0.2816751301288605,
-0.31976932287216187,
-0.2649219334125519,
-0.15700994431972504,
0.021007943898439407,
0.7612553238868713,
-0.22881339490413666,
0.9600417017936707,
1.151563048362732,
-0.2705817222595215,
-0.07610467076301575,
-0.19447138905525208,
-0.22670765221118927,
-0.45215746760368347,
0.47904279828071594,
-0.324135959148407,
-0.6503604054450989,
0.6798236966133118,
0.33170202374458313,
-0.10914722084999084,
0.583591639995575,
0.44935286045074463,
0.12277927249670029,
1.1705148220062256,
0.71158367395401,
-0.2644818425178528,
0.4103582799434662,
-0.40297678112983704,
0.2378198206424713,
-0.6113068461418152,
-0.14690187573432922,
-0.667410671710968,
-0.12872819602489471,
-1.0184767246246338,
0.15511716902256012,
0.23803535103797913,
0.030787255614995956,
-0.30285385251045227,
0.678730309009552,
-0.5902263522148132,
0.1137753427028656,
0.4784960150718689,
0.17655687034130096,
0.12024761736392975,
0.005288999993354082,
0.0520784892141819,
-0.10921354591846466,
-0.7018681168556213,
-0.48767417669296265,
1.1830213069915771,
0.540330708026886,
0.9301093816757202,
0.015024874359369278,
0.16543106734752655,
0.20562836527824402,
0.1275624781847,
-0.6294552087783813,
0.23941591382026672,
-0.5798016786575317,
-0.6998018622398376,
-0.21343830227851868,
-0.4462531507015228,
-1.0576651096343994,
0.04525376483798027,
-0.7321668267250061,
-0.5591474771499634,
0.25953468680381775,
0.0732174888253212,
-0.3352244794368744,
0.41173481941223145,
-0.5366212725639343,
0.8520768284797668,
-0.1651008427143097,
-0.3665379285812378,
0.12240192294120789,
-0.8160852193832397,
0.3055814504623413,
-0.16553880274295807,
0.03856151923537254,
0.2858763039112091,
0.27322468161582947,
0.5261995196342468,
-0.21116068959236145,
0.6860475540161133,
0.2475357949733734,
-0.13239043951034546,
0.11252853274345398,
0.18637824058532715,
0.6983429789543152,
0.18034927546977997,
-0.11366192251443863,
0.0753646120429039,
-0.1424633413553238,
-0.20476311445236206,
-0.6491609215736389,
0.7775480151176453,
-1.0286717414855957,
-0.21086902916431427,
-0.27787891030311584,
-0.5715709328651428,
-0.18721993267536163,
0.1770864725112915,
0.6306849718093872,
0.5220937728881836,
-0.3213313817977905,
0.6162374019622803,
0.9413543939590454,
0.02055935561656952,
0.35702162981033325,
0.21144002676010132,
0.35686013102531433,
-0.5644220113754272,
0.8741304874420166,
-0.07500674575567245,
0.32540008425712585,
0.603819727897644,
0.09502626955509186,
-0.027954675257205963,
-0.6546862721443176,
-0.43509432673454285,
-0.28982996940612793,
-0.5485788583755493,
-0.47053828835487366,
-0.7054139971733093,
-0.4801086187362671,
-0.32556265592575073,
-0.2706376910209656,
-0.5530661940574646,
-0.3504606783390045,
-0.32208457589149475,
-0.03740915656089783,
0.26670798659324646,
0.5791320204734802,
0.29383471608161926,
0.4071142375469208,
-0.5295348763465881,
0.3986264169216156,
0.297768771648407,
0.16502834856510162,
-0.06747645139694214,
-0.5704290866851807,
-0.3633754551410675,
0.16677097976207733,
-0.6227213144302368,
-0.6529741287231445,
0.28227949142456055,
0.15457333624362946,
0.2948361039161682,
0.6434991955757141,
0.1648605614900589,
0.4616955816745758,
-0.1747431606054306,
0.6845887303352356,
-0.0480254665017128,
-0.5763624906539917,
0.4519345462322235,
-0.3404156565666199,
0.11114922910928726,
0.6983241438865662,
0.29607728123664856,
0.28198474645614624,
-0.7414931654930115,
-0.9284875988960266,
-0.7914035320281982,
0.562369704246521,
0.4267747402191162,
-0.009423239156603813,
0.17885395884513855,
-0.014858374372124672,
0.172944113612175,
-0.09603392332792282,
-0.6221339702606201,
-0.39303305745124817,
-0.45033732056617737,
-0.21058641374111176,
-0.07159284502267838,
-0.2349744588136673,
-0.22353248298168182,
0.0892549529671669,
0.7357233166694641,
-0.07714594900608063,
0.08133479952812195,
-0.01632009819149971,
-0.028129853308200836,
0.07963503152132034,
0.23098208010196686,
0.2807480990886688,
0.26238739490509033,
-0.2719807028770447,
0.39514124393463135,
0.34755662083625793,
-0.7076178789138794,
-0.14115042984485626,
0.4242914021015167,
-0.45085522532463074,
-0.005686499644070864,
0.5452439188957214,
0.8006151914596558,
0.24650000035762787,
-0.20187708735466003,
0.6397907733917236,
-0.45463716983795166,
-0.02850211411714554,
-0.22634151577949524,
0.15379387140274048,
-0.3744858205318451,
0.16568182408809662,
0.2008695900440216,
0.8554717302322388,
0.15051710605621338,
-0.3917137086391449,
0.2954230308532715,
0.6871601343154907,
-0.636285126209259,
-0.4182499647140503,
0.9884563088417053,
-0.216622993350029,
-0.12290061265230179,
0.1861729770898819,
-0.01785900443792343,
-0.7212681174278259,
0.5772131085395813,
0.6320874691009521,
0.8641622066497803,
-0.038500744849443436,
0.012848942540585995,
0.3250044882297516,
0.5428459048271179,
-0.09322146326303482,
-0.36840957403182983,
0.1411849707365036,
-0.5475563406944275,
0.08940402418375015,
-0.5031706690788269,
-0.28375232219696045,
0.326903760433197,
-0.9238485097885132,
0.5648670792579651,
-0.2870815694332123,
-0.2287585735321045,
0.19341494143009186,
-0.06138782948255539,
-0.7219958305358887,
0.3674700856208801,
-0.004305771552026272,
0.7112687230110168,
-0.8771171569824219,
0.7485511898994446,
0.5684806704521179,
-0.19990919530391693,
-0.6623050570487976,
0.20400908589363098,
-0.09269817918539047,
-0.7174109220504761,
0.08987127244472504,
0.06912209838628769,
-0.13913366198539734,
-0.5201926827430725,
-0.317939430475235,
-0.648572564125061,
0.9754359126091003,
0.6048637628555298,
-0.3494313061237335,
-0.0002095850941259414,
-0.014481015503406525,
0.8136824369430542,
-0.14972816407680511,
0.3942050337791443,
0.5373965501785278,
0.18435975909233093,
0.0574001781642437,
-0.5555382966995239,
0.07887981832027435,
-0.3825679123401642,
0.15899701416492462,
0.037012044340372086,
-0.5152270197868347,
0.6240096092224121,
-0.08441745489835739,
-0.20374584197998047,
0.18091852962970734,
0.6957409977912903,
-0.19933384656906128,
0.28825387358665466,
0.40180784463882446,
0.5456084609031677,
0.7458525896072388,
-0.10222278535366058,
1.0798672437667847,
-0.6428804397583008,
0.569133996963501,
1.0438255071640015,
0.3990190923213959,
0.7438734769821167,
0.052897337824106216,
-0.1860540509223938,
0.17322178184986115,
0.33203554153442383,
-0.5096867084503174,
0.6762180328369141,
-0.32447549700737,
0.12135574966669083,
-0.09422589093446732,
0.13727624714374542,
-0.41523614525794983,
0.5256443023681641,
0.19879597425460815,
-0.6037771701812744,
0.06089393422007561,
-0.09305907785892487,
0.1672520637512207,
0.27764439582824707,
0.09100907295942307,
0.7148485779762268,
-0.1591186374425888,
-0.6875429749488831,
0.8131105303764343,
-0.1595565527677536,
0.8693737387657166,
-0.5785300731658936,
0.3953462839126587,
0.06124858558177948,
0.5585560202598572,
-0.26113462448120117,
-0.7091024518013,
0.5479755997657776,
0.12176097184419632,
-0.25309646129608154,
0.06630765646696091,
0.9435532689094543,
-0.3874143362045288,
-0.4698643386363983,
0.2878401279449463,
0.07222254574298859,
-0.29889214038848877,
0.07209943979978561,
-0.4737086594104767,
0.10447276383638382,
-0.05231186002492905,
-0.12786760926246643,
0.39832717180252075,
0.5853834748268127,
0.24117505550384521,
0.5900509357452393,
0.6539112329483032,
0.13705575466156006,
-0.07810268551111221,
0.02487172931432724,
0.8896386623382568,
-0.06673259288072586,
-0.2515077292919159,
-0.971644937992096,
0.38296958804130554,
-0.12024174630641937,
-0.5114185810089111,
0.9353803396224976,
0.679215669631958,
0.754548192024231,
0.05462251231074333,
0.9168556332588196,
0.08321748673915863,
0.23599474132061005,
-0.3362370729446411,
0.9304355978965759,
-0.13052186369895935,
0.4117142856121063,
-0.2732594311237335,
-0.649730920791626,
-0.314746618270874,
0.3877454996109009,
-0.1380331814289093,
-0.2309117615222931,
0.5438402891159058,
0.9072432518005371,
-0.3235246539115906,
0.31356045603752136,
0.25917962193489075,
0.10446082055568695,
0.3806106150150299,
0.33646827936172485,
0.5206855535507202,
-0.8530689477920532,
1.047666072845459,
-0.42121803760528564,
-0.12158908694982529,
-0.1980830729007721,
-0.5869953632354736,
-1.237431526184082,
-0.5457462668418884,
-0.2212403565645218,
-0.6667315363883972,
0.21137338876724243,
0.3155133128166199,
0.5398105978965759,
-1.0687681436538696,
0.4213695228099823,
-0.28154370188713074,
0.05795188248157501,
-0.26486852765083313,
-0.20228204131126404,
0.4136660695075989,
-0.35072430968284607,
-0.5420375466346741,
0.27583396434783936,
-0.2541380524635315,
0.2819496691226959,
-0.3500383496284485,
0.1479852944612503,
0.2242695391178131,
0.04800577089190483,
0.17407497763633728,
0.0754731222987175,
-0.38798514008522034,
-0.31351304054260254,
0.14367827773094177,
-0.3402279019355774,
-0.08886121958494186,
0.624232828617096,
-0.5514489412307739,
0.4732949137687683,
0.30487364530563354,
0.867533802986145,
0.42063143849372864,
-0.06959956139326096,
0.571039617061615,
-0.6541649103164673,
0.19224491715431213,
0.04073772579431534,
0.41689762473106384,
0.5334785580635071,
-0.5907039046287537,
0.5271133780479431,
-0.04179093986749649,
-0.6665397882461548,
-0.7621035575866699,
0.06839380413293839,
-0.7918442487716675,
0.042040057480335236,
1.0166336297988892,
-0.439074844121933,
-0.18706977367401123,
0.03646010532975197,
-0.13201607763767242,
0.49942800402641296,
-0.1518227607011795,
1.1099854707717896,
0.6003934144973755,
0.31347429752349854,
0.3105006217956543,
-0.4013785123825073,
0.5493386387825012,
0.25700119137763977,
-0.44744405150413513,
0.09913835674524307,
-0.0798603966832161,
0.09474796056747437,
0.4406077265739441,
-0.324217826128006,
-0.1199047639966011,
0.14983369410037994,
0.4134085476398468,
-0.543878436088562,
-0.2980158030986786,
-0.406737357378006,
-0.4078594148159027,
0.44597065448760986,
-0.05419166013598442,
-0.1559450924396515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14834v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14834v2 | MSynFD: Multi-hop Syntax aware Fake News Detection | 2024-02-18T05:40:33 | 2024-06-19T13:15:34 | Liang Xiao, Qi Zhang, Chongyang Shi, Shoujin Wang, Usman Naseem, Liang Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The proliferation of social media platforms has fueled the rapid
dissemination of fake news, posing threats to our real-life society. Existing
methods use multimodal data or contextual information to enhance the detection
of fake news by analyzing news content and/or its social context. However,
these methods often overlook essential textual news content (articles) and
heavily rely on sequential modeling and global attention to extract semantic
information. These existing methods fail to handle the complex, subtle twists
in news articles, such as syntax-semantics mismatches and prior biases, leading
to lower performance and potential failure when modalities or social context
are missing. To bridge these significant gaps, we propose a novel multi-hop
syntax aware fake news detection (MSynFD) method, which incorporates
complementary syntax information to deal with subtle twists in fake news.
Specifically, we introduce a syntactical dependency graph and design a
multi-hop subgraph aggregation mechanism to capture multi-hop syntax. It
extends the effect of word perception, leading to effective noise filtering and
adjacent relation enhancement. Subsequently, a sequential relative
position-aware Transformer is designed to capture the sequential information,
together with an elaborate keyword debiasing module to mitigate the prior bias.
Extensive experimental results on two public benchmark datasets verify the
effectiveness and superior performance of our proposed MSynFD over
state-of-the-art detection models. | [
-0.03342471271753311,
-1.1872135400772095,
0.6136720180511475,
0.48318132758140564,
-0.3585001230239868,
0.44489166140556335,
0.16735400259494781,
-0.28517642617225647,
0.7343272566795349,
0.22013354301452637,
-0.670075535774231,
-0.29411178827285767,
-0.5213357210159302,
0.07833284139633179,
-0.4772728681564331,
0.8041332960128784,
0.04892254248261452,
-0.04176487773656845,
0.010835452005267143,
-0.08812649548053741,
-0.06431460380554199,
-0.47004133462905884,
-0.1797441691160202,
0.3966837227344513,
0.5164530873298645,
0.1342918574810028,
0.762532114982605,
0.4073024094104767,
0.22321383655071259,
0.24091829359531403,
-0.048262182623147964,
0.3929366171360016,
-0.12126771360635757,
-0.08979739248752594,
-0.10867556184530258,
-0.0029355576261878014,
-0.25248220562934875,
0.007755342870950699,
0.7641558647155762,
0.4625421464443207,
0.013248153030872345,
0.12858952581882477,
-0.28022539615631104,
0.5930114984512329,
-0.5662223696708679,
-0.13346721231937408,
-0.7284484505653381,
0.05813358351588249,
-0.4112376868724823,
-0.303457647562027,
-0.3000912070274353,
-0.1168840304017067,
-0.3526669144630432,
-0.44102245569229126,
0.14599226415157318,
-0.025427212938666344,
0.9338046908378601,
0.13577494025230408,
-0.6567125916481018,
-0.009040012955665588,
-0.43218910694122314,
0.18462418019771576,
-0.49761366844177246,
0.7613991498947144,
-0.04419328272342682,
0.19642703235149384,
-0.17429238557815552,
-0.7346710562705994,
-0.9706004858016968,
0.01431250013411045,
-0.16268190741539001,
0.0670192763209343,
-0.12037090957164764,
-0.045854903757572174,
0.38206177949905396,
0.1285182386636734,
-0.8599698543548584,
-0.49270379543304443,
-0.2811252474784851,
-0.3728075623512268,
0.12501385807991028,
-0.40785640478134155,
0.32789355516433716,
-0.5353797078132629,
-0.7485032677650452,
0.2332627773284912,
-0.47529155015945435,
-0.1291954517364502,
0.6438670754432678,
0.5377969741821289,
-0.12079156935214996,
0.3775351643562317,
-0.46682143211364746,
0.5793511867523193,
-0.04293544217944145,
-0.32170116901397705,
0.7204391956329346,
-0.6686075925827026,
-0.2793301045894623,
-0.17936624586582184,
0.7986932992935181,
0.1631222367286682,
0.1680089831352234,
-0.05890071019530296,
-0.053804911673069,
0.5657175183296204,
0.38967475295066833,
-0.4324996769428253,
-0.19245371222496033,
0.21310549974441528,
-0.6081370711326599,
-0.6702317595481873,
0.07995165884494781,
-0.9878294467926025,
-0.28861841559410095,
-0.22059233486652374,
0.4165009558200836,
-0.44783440232276917,
-0.593966543674469,
-0.1466347724199295,
-0.5250152945518494,
-0.17767241597175598,
0.11046598106622696,
-0.15933851897716522,
-0.1029319167137146,
0.3264668881893158,
0.910797655582428,
0.17966219782829285,
-0.4593695402145386,
-0.8290367126464844,
0.06200006976723671,
-0.3074200451374054,
0.7400931715965271,
-0.5196955800056458,
0.12306036055088043,
-0.01106873806566,
0.09200795739889145,
-0.2296948879957199,
-0.15401877462863922,
0.5442659258842468,
-0.6964254975318909,
0.008955839090049267,
-0.11314841359853745,
-0.31811439990997314,
0.15507632493972778,
0.36068272590637207,
-0.7108365297317505,
1.0217266082763672,
0.2999067008495331,
-1.0764793157577515,
0.44000494480133057,
-0.4147630035877228,
-0.8190389275550842,
-0.1380273997783661,
-0.1374305635690689,
-0.37519413232803345,
-0.08949992805719376,
0.38305288553237915,
0.2085026204586029,
0.5542343258857727,
0.4530366361141205,
-0.4710450768470764,
-0.03981677442789078,
-0.046458858996629715,
-0.5552719831466675,
0.7377227544784546,
0.1711021512746811,
-0.21016591787338257,
0.35750719904899597,
-0.8091543316841125,
-0.1992386281490326,
0.20539870858192444,
-0.21703536808490753,
-0.4779594838619232,
-0.11315662413835526,
0.14451220631599426,
0.7225191593170166,
-0.1898496448993683,
-0.45080360770225525,
0.26101189851760864,
-0.1798992156982422,
0.2757025957107544,
0.8267372250556946,
0.09001979976892471,
0.5325168371200562,
-0.14648938179016113,
0.5190591216087341,
0.27808836102485657,
0.24749013781547546,
-0.7550636529922485,
-0.4226946532726288,
-0.4592588245868683,
-0.3759429156780243,
0.25434064865112305,
0.5700939893722534,
-1.232223391532898,
0.41800475120544434,
-0.2713167667388916,
0.014054790139198303,
-0.509345293045044,
0.25375476479530334,
0.2673305571079254,
0.5503379702568054,
0.5358603000640869,
0.31913286447525024,
-0.653969943523407,
-0.6699093580245972,
-0.985544741153717,
0.06983820348978043,
0.31226786971092224,
-0.20738641917705536,
0.4951022267341614,
-0.1536606252193451,
0.8256341218948364,
-0.22704531252384186,
-0.38982197642326355,
-0.21417739987373352,
-0.0017655754927545786,
0.08657082170248032,
0.31769558787345886,
0.679036021232605,
-1.0919885635375977,
-0.45319226384162903,
-0.5551274418830872,
-0.4792441427707672,
-0.04501822590827942,
-0.5107354521751404,
-0.32303503155708313,
0.34806182980537415,
0.7317907214164734,
-1.03752601146698,
0.489650696516037,
0.5938646793365479,
-0.6566133499145508,
0.8638659119606018,
0.3537851870059967,
0.14432696998119354,
-0.9620621204376221,
-0.1615253984928131,
-0.0020577963441610336,
-0.6309381127357483,
-0.6123918890953064,
0.16337375342845917,
0.3583530783653259,
0.061140164732933044,
-0.4243064820766449,
0.3447260856628418,
-0.45295020937919617,
0.10939400643110275,
-0.006498974282294512,
0.22968466579914093,
0.1100740134716034,
0.4277173578739166,
-0.06947007775306702,
0.3439663052558899,
0.4846712350845337,
-0.22342771291732788,
0.30405715107917786,
-0.1425994485616684,
-0.12639936804771423,
0.4196970462799072,
-0.3785397410392761,
0.029666557908058167,
-0.32599663734436035,
0.6784764528274536,
-1.2249141931533813,
-0.16763068735599518,
0.45728403329849243,
-0.6978926658630371,
0.20034164190292358,
-0.4720667600631714,
-0.8248165845870972,
-0.5564749240875244,
-0.46298131346702576,
0.22909049689769745,
0.0520821288228035,
-0.6490010619163513,
0.748320996761322,
0.11726363003253937,
0.23408883810043335,
-0.6497736573219299,
-0.577290415763855,
0.08518014848232269,
0.03652992472052574,
-0.8759090304374695,
0.4005766212940216,
-0.021395720541477203,
-0.09848788380622864,
0.21675869822502136,
-0.5606386661529541,
0.2061682939529419,
-0.2368302047252655,
-0.07408828288316727,
0.34001103043556213,
-0.27084124088287354,
0.21673895418643951,
0.12256365269422531,
-0.031875379383563995,
-0.09135934710502625,
-0.45514893531799316,
0.6282255053520203,
0.018275735899806023,
-0.37939146161079407,
-0.3724181354045868,
0.42894092202186584,
0.8684402704238892,
-0.30554357171058655,
0.7953582406044006,
0.970593273639679,
-0.5967949628829956,
-0.5078526139259338,
-0.4466715455055237,
-0.15598143637180328,
-0.42902442812919617,
0.1519053876399994,
-0.33662310242652893,
-0.5455958247184753,
0.12474257498979568,
-0.12910263240337372,
-0.48093077540397644,
0.30250754952430725,
0.06612307578325272,
0.047609731554985046,
0.9646399021148682,
0.41102808713912964,
-0.21121662855148315,
0.524150013923645,
-0.11405269056558609,
0.4311182200908661,
-0.40805721282958984,
0.04992391914129257,
-0.153755784034729,
-0.2706829309463501,
-0.2776309847831726,
-0.638425886631012,
0.2562978267669678,
0.38548702001571655,
0.07789051532745361,
0.33556416630744934,
-0.2123984545469284,
0.5306965112686157,
0.5751677751541138,
0.07799627631902695,
0.38091686367988586,
0.12319134175777435,
-0.3192245066165924,
0.08053725212812424,
-0.5124802589416504,
-0.14973019063472748,
0.8205788135528564,
0.23398949205875397,
0.47239813208580017,
0.14978505671024323,
0.2953738570213318,
0.4004468321800232,
0.025587573647499084,
-0.634346067905426,
0.1765809804201126,
0.11904507875442505,
-0.3744158148765564,
-0.08049286901950836,
-0.5905374884605408,
-0.2958983778953552,
0.6390379667282104,
-0.19901277124881744,
-0.4925194978713989,
-0.0393051877617836,
0.2781640589237213,
-0.2641338109970093,
0.47042855620384216,
-0.7653000950813293,
0.9784923195838928,
-0.08621465414762497,
-0.16076208651065826,
-0.07223416119813919,
-0.9246944189071655,
0.5753600001335144,
0.09063935279846191,
0.7467685341835022,
-0.14412756264209747,
0.1300906538963318,
0.3173429071903229,
-0.4582306444644928,
0.7847691774368286,
-0.4523482024669647,
0.24961811304092407,
0.0047679501585662365,
0.1714765876531601,
0.8457587361335754,
0.2930828630924225,
0.3549143671989441,
0.11734425276517868,
-0.17742229998111725,
-0.31057101488113403,
-0.3032875061035156,
0.7458030581474304,
-0.1809116005897522,
-0.15913516283035278,
-0.5663898587226868,
-0.45313435792922974,
-0.33691227436065674,
0.46235963702201843,
0.21317286789417267,
0.37125036120414734,
0.023327723145484924,
-0.1559443324804306,
0.23182128369808197,
-0.029418284073472023,
0.5370060205459595,
0.3619518280029297,
-0.4458722472190857,
-0.37581565976142883,
0.8124952912330627,
0.0789661854505539,
0.20182664692401886,
0.3452596068382263,
0.16883552074432373,
-0.4660817086696625,
-0.060367245227098465,
-0.6591989994049072,
0.2517223656177521,
-0.6435109376907349,
-0.32609614729881287,
-0.9340462684631348,
-0.07965777814388275,
-0.8834762573242188,
-0.13725408911705017,
-0.3546735942363739,
-0.47961342334747314,
-0.100457563996315,
-0.21872246265411377,
0.21367119252681732,
0.26564380526542664,
0.021765844896435738,
0.3627072870731354,
-0.628730058670044,
1.0463054180145264,
-0.003951004706323147,
0.3526221811771393,
-0.26407143473625183,
-0.2330019176006317,
0.1520732343196869,
0.0659656673669815,
-0.1761258840560913,
-1.1745938062667847,
0.4140109419822693,
0.12198208272457123,
0.5333042740821838,
0.5298601984977722,
0.2506723999977112,
0.6798868179321289,
-0.6413859724998474,
0.5836998820304871,
0.1888190060853958,
-0.9309426546096802,
0.7274236679077148,
-0.42595356702804565,
0.1141902282834053,
0.18673934042453766,
0.4675710201263428,
-0.6130666136741638,
-0.43375909328460693,
-0.7537448406219482,
-0.8580744862556458,
0.6131041049957275,
0.2195659577846527,
0.11520804464817047,
-0.15350815653800964,
-0.06562246382236481,
-0.18976204097270966,
0.4600120484828949,
-0.9471452832221985,
-0.3792141377925873,
-0.31075718998908997,
-0.12732692062854767,
0.2778019905090332,
-0.11474983394145966,
-0.024077298119664192,
-0.3650803864002228,
0.5219900608062744,
-0.22439706325531006,
0.12592263519763947,
0.2935692369937897,
-0.4480205476284027,
-0.060995616018772125,
0.12429330497980118,
0.680389940738678,
0.5644238591194153,
0.03920416906476021,
0.4427756369113922,
-0.33539292216300964,
-0.31396985054016113,
-0.2079431414604187,
0.04217452183365822,
-0.27491703629493713,
0.5726971626281738,
0.3373148739337921,
0.48749837279319763,
-0.002691772999241948,
-0.4627682566642761,
1.0446972846984863,
0.2387969195842743,
-0.04737059772014618,
-0.31318357586860657,
-0.3195962607860565,
0.19843246042728424,
0.19817304611206055,
0.5243250131607056,
0.9891163110733032,
0.1787600815296173,
-0.6020246148109436,
0.5773890614509583,
0.39317262172698975,
-0.2646290361881256,
-0.37760719656944275,
0.6151889562606812,
0.03954607993364334,
-0.22420090436935425,
0.24640247225761414,
-0.5154682397842407,
-0.9036538600921631,
0.5718861818313599,
0.8431991338729858,
0.45854413509368896,
-0.3051780164241791,
0.46750950813293457,
0.09679330885410309,
0.606018602848053,
-0.04791484400629997,
0.4131487309932709,
0.03878390043973923,
-0.933860182762146,
-0.386173814535141,
-0.7664755582809448,
0.36351922154426575,
0.2628970146179199,
-0.06607172638177872,
0.4718656837940216,
-0.45123299956321716,
0.013463909737765789,
0.06670060753822327,
-0.6160055994987488,
-0.37235525250434875,
-0.031084273010492325,
0.11738146096467972,
1.0858339071273804,
-0.9821100234985352,
0.7215272784233093,
0.5250028967857361,
-0.4218379557132721,
-0.5153232216835022,
0.40371307730674744,
0.5475819110870361,
-0.6186405420303345,
0.26938596367836,
0.28586795926094055,
-0.15215525031089783,
-0.04986008256673813,
-0.4721684753894806,
-0.6474313735961914,
0.5939021706581116,
0.5041900277137756,
-0.4249698519706726,
-0.06387997418642044,
-0.11286099255084991,
0.18864762783050537,
-0.2422351986169815,
0.07567936182022095,
0.3456014096736908,
0.49248701333999634,
0.0976121723651886,
-0.6969661116600037,
0.13923105597496033,
-0.3563673794269562,
-0.09342014789581299,
0.2792549431324005,
-0.6773238778114319,
0.939680814743042,
-0.2836763560771942,
-0.3118840456008911,
-0.4011557102203369,
0.4940662384033203,
0.20634444057941437,
0.504335880279541,
0.5994096398353577,
0.49417150020599365,
0.7444995641708374,
-0.006738736759871244,
0.9640301465988159,
-0.3659333884716034,
0.3410522937774658,
1.1082491874694824,
-0.10594078153371811,
0.7952706217765808,
0.5725416541099548,
-0.1120515838265419,
0.6531522274017334,
0.31054288148880005,
0.20457571744918823,
0.6251303553581238,
0.11639084666967392,
-0.17897439002990723,
-0.1986268311738968,
0.04879944398999214,
-0.3934001922607422,
0.30778560042381287,
0.34864342212677,
-0.5686787366867065,
-0.19410276412963867,
0.178297758102417,
0.2339896261692047,
0.14657901227474213,
-0.18682961165905,
0.2917758524417877,
-0.11508168280124664,
-0.182342529296875,
0.23605801165103912,
0.13297432661056519,
0.8754301071166992,
-0.587212324142456,
-0.16961638629436493,
-0.10218730568885803,
0.1474830061197281,
-0.3441691994667053,
-0.3898696005344391,
0.506381630897522,
-0.20150385797023773,
-0.25823163986206055,
-0.3977215588092804,
1.1106131076812744,
-0.6344665884971619,
-0.5221094489097595,
0.49471235275268555,
0.6238722205162048,
-0.2462446391582489,
-0.7434089183807373,
-0.5316153168678284,
0.1907639056444168,
-0.236399844288826,
-0.21419969201087952,
0.04336262866854668,
0.4357200562953949,
0.06437410414218903,
0.35625043511390686,
1.1225249767303467,
0.15913237631320953,
0.2319580763578415,
0.3983473479747772,
0.9597857594490051,
-0.5039379596710205,
-0.9623371958732605,
-0.8630017638206482,
0.5050768256187439,
-0.4046425223350525,
-0.32174184918403625,
0.7814288139343262,
0.5576463937759399,
0.9152037501335144,
-0.23994918167591095,
0.8374922275543213,
-0.18455921113491058,
0.6751291155815125,
-0.645173966884613,
0.756409227848053,
-0.4922347068786621,
0.19149233400821686,
-0.6235601305961609,
-0.6901236772537231,
-0.33856579661369324,
0.4199835956096649,
0.20199961960315704,
0.07037051767110825,
0.9501371383666992,
0.764510452747345,
-0.3859962821006775,
0.00879528559744358,
0.22114814817905426,
0.2816232144832611,
0.10909430682659149,
0.011053306981921196,
0.9651054739952087,
-0.5512639880180359,
0.6460651159286499,
-0.2382030338048935,
-0.19631925225257874,
-0.23211488127708435,
-0.9464909434318542,
-0.7907373905181885,
-0.4361611306667328,
-0.29962727427482605,
-0.5550760626792908,
0.02623257040977478,
0.8944100141525269,
0.8758777379989624,
-0.6749730110168457,
0.4749191701412201,
-0.18435846269130707,
0.5042380094528198,
-0.4387394189834595,
-0.4093303084373474,
0.4143825173377991,
-0.5137478113174438,
-0.3081526458263397,
0.693823516368866,
0.3298136293888092,
-0.16942161321640015,
-0.015146286226809025,
0.0903698205947876,
-0.6568820476531982,
0.036498524248600006,
0.7978119254112244,
-0.06371840089559555,
-0.7085320353507996,
-0.46419158577919006,
0.2125055342912674,
0.006335931830108166,
-0.05558997020125389,
0.8903549909591675,
-1.0142571926116943,
0.3164603114128113,
0.6196977496147156,
0.43213438987731934,
0.19333001971244812,
0.2544228136539459,
0.047637131065130234,
-1.3188962936401367,
0.2642335295677185,
-0.014553979970514774,
0.39148908853530884,
0.14976511895656586,
-0.5895743370056152,
0.26370203495025635,
1.1467676162719727,
-0.021334277465939522,
-0.8322938680648804,
0.23913761973381042,
-0.9786311388015747,
-0.513169527053833,
1.3160479068756104,
0.1525546759366989,
-0.10217724740505219,
-0.3532622158527374,
-0.1425018608570099,
0.14655445516109467,
-0.5956701040267944,
0.4123563766479492,
0.5004458427429199,
-0.023823585361242294,
-0.16306038200855255,
-0.6572718024253845,
0.6277191042900085,
-0.04514531046152115,
-0.6243716478347778,
-0.01881132461130619,
0.7080392241477966,
0.36607736349105835,
0.3124536871910095,
1.0619375705718994,
-0.017394404858350754,
0.1458301991224289,
0.3378785252571106,
-0.3217935562133789,
-0.13218672573566437,
-0.873134434223175,
-0.1467323750257492,
0.23287354409694672,
-0.7604585886001587,
-0.2732546329498291
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.